id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01015v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01015v1
|
PairEval: Open-domain Dialogue Evaluation with Pairwise Comparison
| 2024-04-01T09:35:06 | 2024-04-01T09:35:06 |
ChaeHun Park, Minseok Choi, Dohyun Lee, Jaegul Choo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Building a reliable and automated evaluation metric is a necessary but
challenging problem for open-domain dialogue systems. Recent studies proposed
evaluation metrics that assess generated responses by considering their
relevance to previous dialogue histories. Although effective, these metrics
evaluate individual responses directly rather than considering their relative
quality compared to other responses. To handle this, we propose PairEval, a
novel dialogue evaluation metric for assessing responses by comparing their
quality against responses in different conversations. PairEval is built on top
of open-sourced and moderate-size language models, and we make them specialized
in pairwise comparison between dialogue responses. Extensive experiments on
multiple benchmarks demonstrate that our metric exhibits a higher correlation
with human judgments than baseline metrics. We also find that the proposed
comparative metric is more robust in detecting common failures from open-domain
dialogue systems, including repetition and speaker insensitivity.
|
[
-0.38768884539604187,
-0.5926782488822937,
0.13469021022319794,
0.2419634908437729,
-0.09357471019029617,
0.5187991857528687,
-0.25978681445121765,
-0.17168700695037842,
0.18833978474140167,
0.3249492645263672,
-0.0804043859243393,
-0.4061453938484192,
-0.2639957070350647,
-0.16458402574062347,
-0.21804343163967133,
1.0082135200500488,
0.012870262376964092,
0.33525195717811584,
-0.6425411701202393,
-0.725105881690979,
-0.5155848264694214,
-0.4534582197666168,
-0.6544110178947449,
-0.19854113459587097,
-0.031454864889383316,
0.27227064967155457,
0.8700417280197144,
-0.3297117352485657,
0.785163402557373,
0.327364444732666,
0.20823867619037628,
0.23052950203418732,
-0.6629457473754883,
0.2571179270744324,
-0.004761916119605303,
0.044054578989744186,
-0.6215694546699524,
0.18788395822048187,
0.6506571173667908,
0.902435302734375,
-0.20386523008346558,
0.21585692465305328,
0.2651996910572052,
0.5012510418891907,
-0.37905818223953247,
-0.1682746708393097,
-0.5380486249923706,
-0.16313539445400238,
0.1658208668231964,
-0.3734956383705139,
-0.3516373038291931,
-0.6426752209663391,
0.3526709973812103,
-0.279487669467926,
0.18014168739318848,
0.3990491032600403,
0.5269178748130798,
0.03460021689534187,
-0.08985622227191925,
-0.05057011917233467,
-0.6159452795982361,
0.7291327118873596,
-0.9128173589706421,
0.4681592881679535,
0.4398290812969208,
0.44090595841407776,
-0.05988739803433418,
-0.5892821550369263,
-0.5204256176948547,
-0.6005753874778748,
-0.18211562931537628,
0.24221783876419067,
-0.21416792273521423,
-0.05636173114180565,
-0.13415668904781342,
0.5866398215293884,
-0.7620986104011536,
-0.0964895486831665,
-0.20141777396202087,
-0.24410371482372284,
0.5347753763198853,
0.37518706917762756,
0.3833453059196472,
-0.08592534810304642,
-0.4280237555503845,
-0.06737206131219864,
-0.5356444716453552,
0.1394871324300766,
0.4228774905204773,
0.2572459280490875,
-0.07375216484069824,
0.20862285792827606,
-0.10735756158828735,
0.66237473487854,
0.017057955265045166,
0.1229168102145195,
0.10550525039434433,
-0.6473681926727295,
-0.19398565590381622,
-0.10576051473617554,
0.9385780096054077,
0.8647710680961609,
-0.012478640303015709,
-0.4623889625072479,
-0.21455785632133484,
0.09822307527065277,
0.4176494777202606,
-0.7344439029693604,
-0.42520880699157715,
0.23464591801166534,
-0.7645488381385803,
-0.32195886969566345,
0.14905774593353271,
-0.6103236079216003,
-0.34918463230133057,
-0.051567383110523224,
0.5317155718803406,
-0.1812313348054886,
-0.38557323813438416,
-0.08726318925619125,
-0.010172678157687187,
-0.08412729948759079,
0.22082901000976562,
-0.6033580303192139,
0.6813686490058899,
0.9530127644538879,
0.991571843624115,
-0.5282151103019714,
-0.15360213816165924,
-1.0581656694412231,
-0.4125072658061981,
-0.41457152366638184,
0.826267659664154,
-0.6281927227973938,
-0.6907302141189575,
0.10879635065793991,
-0.27130934596061707,
0.08386383950710297,
-0.7256975173950195,
0.757622480392456,
-0.6725842356681824,
0.417583703994751,
0.03711167722940445,
-0.42249107360839844,
0.2127683460712433,
0.14948421716690063,
-0.3399236500263214,
0.9158937335014343,
0.3303583264350891,
-0.9680676460266113,
0.576075553894043,
-0.4894694983959198,
-0.3706625699996948,
0.5308994650840759,
-0.17764875292778015,
-0.2924267649650574,
-0.0584443174302578,
-0.08036139607429504,
0.06038829684257507,
-0.5507399439811707,
0.2669278383255005,
-0.6089404821395874,
-0.22576208412647247,
0.2228168547153473,
-0.3339090943336487,
0.6238852739334106,
0.017601169645786285,
-0.0518018938601017,
0.4640980064868927,
-0.5164060592651367,
0.31718307733535767,
-0.01266728900372982,
-0.058199457824230194,
-0.815737783908844,
-0.05527867004275322,
-0.17002461850643158,
-0.03254441171884537,
0.1636868268251419,
-0.7349184155464172,
-0.15974870324134827,
-0.6754387021064758,
0.2610219419002533,
0.648726224899292,
0.12702155113220215,
0.4227030277252197,
-0.4813169836997986,
0.36608055233955383,
-0.09238273650407791,
0.19404484331607819,
0.0675300657749176,
-0.5346361398696899,
-0.760048508644104,
0.05875653028488159,
0.33609819412231445,
0.5195005536079407,
-0.5424307584762573,
0.6230863332748413,
-0.3000548481941223,
-0.5454800128936768,
-0.8051844835281372,
0.237269788980484,
0.7733632326126099,
0.668328583240509,
0.23466305434703827,
-0.846591055393219,
-0.3915746212005615,
-0.7833946943283081,
-0.32899293303489685,
-0.6361163258552551,
-0.12465962767601013,
0.5262084603309631,
0.2269229292869568,
0.24281640350818634,
0.9229238629341125,
-0.3162412941455841,
-0.08470883965492249,
0.013431149534881115,
0.28386127948760986,
0.044381074607372284,
0.2516881227493286,
0.4415339529514313,
-0.6347430348396301,
-0.5752623677253723,
0.09102573990821838,
-0.6685670614242554,
-0.12585905194282532,
0.12799112498760223,
-0.2450307011604309,
0.07455265522003174,
0.1312551349401474,
-0.06006758287549019,
0.4495287537574768,
0.5843726396560669,
-0.5057932138442993,
0.4658087491989136,
-0.1674165576696396,
0.6316617131233215,
-1.1485507488250732,
0.00037981412606313825,
-0.14268918335437775,
-0.17367210984230042,
-0.519912838935852,
-0.11080516874790192,
-0.15825001895427704,
0.060961682349443436,
-0.3268239200115204,
0.6623004078865051,
-0.05020182207226753,
-0.4368012547492981,
0.1422523558139801,
0.48978930711746216,
-0.09981841593980789,
0.2608318030834198,
-0.05274390056729317,
1.1481575965881348,
0.1460696905851364,
-0.2574019432067871,
0.8017167448997498,
0.7555103898048401,
-0.6512383222579956,
1.0573580265045166,
-0.9102184176445007,
0.5897179245948792,
0.4748847186565399,
0.26434773206710815,
-1.2457858324050903,
-0.08441299200057983,
0.11160565167665482,
-0.6650217175483704,
-0.06841602176427841,
-0.0896332710981369,
-0.16914412379264832,
-0.4646027386188507,
-0.5540419816970825,
0.5871579647064209,
0.424990177154541,
-0.8060740232467651,
-0.043172530829906464,
0.3362933099269867,
-0.4704800546169281,
-0.2225998044013977,
-0.22838714718818665,
0.19086918234825134,
-0.14882662892341614,
-1.0363229513168335,
0.204102024435997,
-0.48472246527671814,
-0.6980983018875122,
-0.10239401459693909,
-0.23340338468551636,
-0.021862536668777466,
-0.004789236932992935,
0.2755226790904999,
0.4184696078300476,
-0.576471745967865,
-0.03400276601314545,
-0.10880334675312042,
-0.11866389214992523,
0.08256860077381134,
-0.31066349148750305,
0.4789482355117798,
-0.48294326663017273,
-0.44839975237846375,
-0.4267668128013611,
0.5050007104873657,
0.4528944492340088,
-0.252666711807251,
0.5511565804481506,
0.21155759692192078,
-0.08980923146009445,
0.10642664134502411,
-0.6791501641273499,
-0.24694941937923431,
-0.44521477818489075,
0.016132216900587082,
-0.27004989981651306,
-0.8254735469818115,
0.23298224806785583,
0.17516960203647614,
0.15323923528194427,
0.1457371860742569,
0.6579166650772095,
0.08484810590744019,
1.1305358409881592,
0.09214440733194351,
-0.10203361511230469,
0.2491917908191681,
0.062722347676754,
0.35261648893356323,
-0.8976978659629822,
-0.161423459649086,
-0.5978277921676636,
-0.13761703670024872,
-0.1483069658279419,
-0.2918883264064789,
0.5642301440238953,
0.08882669359445572,
-0.11721757799386978,
0.357622891664505,
-0.31847116351127625,
0.4316047430038452,
0.6011410355567932,
-0.11375310271978378,
0.5344258546829224,
-0.09585032612085342,
-0.103477843105793,
-0.08877145498991013,
-0.3442119359970093,
-0.798029899597168,
1.2628525495529175,
0.062170445919036865,
0.48625046014785767,
0.367688924074173,
0.6947596669197083,
0.5641043782234192,
0.3524155616760254,
-0.6539486050605774,
0.4949898421764374,
-0.004577166400849819,
-0.05888504534959793,
-0.27262264490127563,
-0.6313962936401367,
-0.8409021496772766,
0.25028660893440247,
-0.1824636310338974,
-0.929595947265625,
-0.32606804370880127,
0.004409341141581535,
-0.7999423146247864,
0.21298335492610931,
-0.6190471053123474,
0.8863041400909424,
-0.23065921664237976,
-0.3713647127151489,
-0.3664831221103668,
-0.7202960252761841,
0.18827764689922333,
0.05075651407241821,
-0.05256463587284088,
0.024479271844029427,
0.1440470814704895,
1.0163600444793701,
-0.7440720200538635,
0.4389365315437317,
-0.10766744613647461,
0.08059085160493851,
0.2903187870979309,
0.37637826800346375,
0.007511367090046406,
0.34369269013404846,
-0.022466836497187614,
0.09771975129842758,
0.29133036732673645,
-0.38155052065849304,
-0.7781746983528137,
1.070629358291626,
-0.8473052978515625,
-0.4799173176288605,
-0.04159047454595566,
-0.24360133707523346,
-0.6531416177749634,
-0.07754866778850555,
0.05538012087345123,
0.8944381475448608,
-0.856696367263794,
0.16413861513137817,
0.2808782160282135,
-0.15487425029277802,
0.3272037208080292,
0.5212849378585815,
-0.249752938747406,
-0.7044439315795898,
0.8148801922798157,
-0.441717267036438,
0.5461605191230774,
0.29729849100112915,
0.1904279589653015,
-0.33010515570640564,
-0.5516188740730286,
-0.49002763628959656,
-0.0894160270690918,
-0.38513922691345215,
-0.3983756899833679,
-0.5049484968185425,
-0.07446765154600143,
-0.5166141986846924,
-0.047217197716236115,
-0.0860259085893631,
-0.6376869082450867,
0.2335515171289444,
0.08859584480524063,
0.08365421742200851,
0.6372111439704895,
0.02502003125846386,
0.009364744648337364,
-0.8462094068527222,
0.24827677011489868,
0.5811333656311035,
0.38131481409072876,
-0.06182378903031349,
-0.6826469898223877,
0.0866866186261177,
0.020042601972818375,
-0.36880889534950256,
-0.5904159545898438,
0.28668278455734253,
0.2873160243034363,
0.6028639078140259,
0.3706859052181244,
0.3271094858646393,
0.35637781023979187,
-0.27349671721458435,
1.0811885595321655,
0.3329593241214752,
-0.8181091547012329,
0.6493752002716064,
-0.31305739283561707,
0.03521030768752098,
0.7913592457771301,
0.11256150156259537,
-0.6619762778282166,
-0.42605167627334595,
-0.7437054514884949,
-0.49846336245536804,
0.6181125640869141,
0.34632986783981323,
0.06169000640511513,
-0.006262288428843021,
-0.16274164617061615,
0.23389248549938202,
0.170924112200737,
-0.06568602472543716,
0.07238968461751938,
-0.11428177356719971,
-0.008475515060126781,
-0.3357924818992615,
-0.042883001267910004,
-0.45612838864326477,
-0.186689093708992,
0.5454716086387634,
-0.11856665462255478,
0.3027161657810211,
0.022954806685447693,
-0.2694792151451111,
-0.29603761434555054,
0.25615689158439636,
0.5089115500450134,
0.3963293433189392,
-0.4125387370586395,
-0.1308061182498932,
0.2702878415584564,
-0.10087573528289795,
-0.09532881528139114,
-0.1168237030506134,
0.2844752073287964,
-0.09327679127454758,
0.38114646077156067,
0.7612671256065369,
0.29833391308784485,
-0.5979924201965332,
1.06405770778656,
-0.34498706459999084,
0.03195476904511452,
-0.147329643368721,
-0.2623145282268524,
-0.21327556669712067,
0.18270492553710938,
0.04013744369149208,
0.30163711309432983,
0.33116960525512695,
-0.5092732906341553,
0.259576678276062,
0.5605950951576233,
-0.5886262655258179,
-0.3501560091972351,
0.4283677041530609,
0.8455850481987,
-0.8677206039428711,
0.665600061416626,
-0.34212154150009155,
-0.48043665289878845,
0.33787229657173157,
0.43431371450424194,
1.084243893623352,
-0.333005428314209,
0.23665370047092438,
0.35681846737861633,
-0.04910425469279289,
0.3344246447086334,
0.06447425484657288,
-0.38371893763542175,
-0.735361635684967,
0.01042352244257927,
-0.7050067186355591,
-0.6893995404243469,
-0.14910589158535004,
-0.9016706347465515,
-0.01766667701303959,
-0.5797858834266663,
-0.07240547239780426,
-0.07690414786338806,
-0.07766378670930862,
-0.48902592062950134,
-0.1973952054977417,
-0.16807779669761658,
0.7988430857658386,
-0.7335265874862671,
0.5069223642349243,
0.6170400381088257,
-0.540681004524231,
-0.32981550693511963,
0.1407567858695984,
0.19014392793178558,
-0.9217560291290283,
0.5748825073242188,
0.009600608609616756,
-0.5499200820922852,
-0.3387000262737274,
-0.08824964612722397,
-0.07786776125431061,
0.7776502966880798,
-0.04600772634148598,
-0.2705269157886505,
0.17270883917808533,
-0.10881039500236511,
0.6553253531455994,
-0.382533997297287,
0.6975218653678894,
0.8143978714942932,
0.1363576352596283,
-0.005964743439108133,
-1.460103988647461,
-0.09640920162200928,
-0.46990057826042175,
-0.04343400150537491,
0.6035808324813843,
-0.7802565693855286,
0.2825762927532196,
-0.2234547734260559,
-0.10783427953720093,
0.6558635830879211,
0.5818295478820801,
-0.12928007543087006,
0.6711502075195312,
0.6451179385185242,
0.4147947132587433,
0.682258129119873,
-0.1510879099369049,
0.8316921591758728,
-0.3738104999065399,
0.33719733357429504,
1.2947142124176025,
-0.427564412355423,
1.184253215789795,
0.2113979011774063,
-0.40728840231895447,
0.49445971846580505,
0.3989809453487396,
0.3287164866924286,
0.5202571749687195,
0.10607965290546417,
-0.6462271213531494,
-0.5193811655044556,
-0.1964174062013626,
-0.39408445358276367,
0.30208301544189453,
0.32906806468963623,
-0.019447462633252144,
-0.03407043218612671,
-0.18071989715099335,
-0.2705414295196533,
0.459446519613266,
-0.02768942341208458,
0.9585389494895935,
0.17198659479618073,
-0.9223201870918274,
0.6822895407676697,
-0.35904163122177124,
0.5991689562797546,
-0.28958818316459656,
0.06818042695522308,
-0.4540616273880005,
0.1907299906015396,
-0.2562674880027771,
-0.7031243443489075,
0.3019595742225647,
-0.04236855357885361,
0.14476166665554047,
-0.21001793444156647,
0.5399467945098877,
-0.498532235622406,
0.030061116442084312,
0.4752658009529114,
0.46960681676864624,
0.11716186255216599,
0.025080274790525436,
-0.5787631273269653,
-0.10809474438428879,
-0.1773506999015808,
0.24379877746105194,
0.21834278106689453,
-0.16943319141864777,
-0.14164449274539948,
0.4967969059944153,
0.5526913404464722,
-0.038308002054691315,
-0.202382430434227,
0.3305550515651703,
0.6392368674278259,
-0.32467561960220337,
-0.44215989112854004,
-0.4535004198551178,
0.2282547801733017,
-0.6274712681770325,
-0.5471340417861938,
0.6497477293014526,
0.6925683617591858,
0.755423903465271,
0.287935346364975,
0.6807152628898621,
0.19587406516075134,
0.8761745095252991,
-0.2789158225059509,
0.7307847142219543,
-0.3021276891231537,
0.23884965479373932,
-0.5431161522865295,
-0.9731453657150269,
-0.26265203952789307,
0.593605637550354,
-0.44310322403907776,
-0.05021824315190315,
0.8504018783569336,
1.011928677558899,
-0.20586344599723816,
0.5394237041473389,
0.43302953243255615,
0.1914372742176056,
0.2323056310415268,
0.5859667658805847,
1.3372858762741089,
-0.2772251069545746,
0.6709151268005371,
0.08488592505455017,
-0.6098126173019409,
-0.2916368246078491,
-0.5100055932998657,
-1.0737954378128052,
-0.7513610124588013,
-0.3904799222946167,
-0.6235447525978088,
0.3162829577922821,
1.0424234867095947,
0.6760086417198181,
-1.0657283067703247,
-0.45138663053512573,
0.2009548395872116,
-0.07658421993255615,
-0.11074358224868774,
-0.218698650598526,
0.2261177897453308,
-0.3238012194633484,
-0.4406093955039978,
0.7913253307342529,
0.6060252785682678,
-0.1474168598651886,
-0.29502278566360474,
-0.43993231654167175,
0.3804611563682556,
0.2211141586303711,
0.5138471126556396,
0.2747552692890167,
-0.8942879438400269,
-0.5956450700759888,
-0.34164565801620483,
-0.12308895587921143,
0.11680623143911362,
1.0504871606826782,
-0.827933132648468,
0.8232372403144836,
0.6814066171646118,
0.616310715675354,
0.14473921060562134,
-0.036212749779224396,
0.8804081678390503,
-0.6559942364692688,
-0.06713604182004929,
0.31682470440864563,
0.3357025980949402,
0.5575486421585083,
0.26539677381515503,
0.5187106132507324,
0.191441610455513,
-0.6996803879737854,
-0.8633313179016113,
0.2775561511516571,
-1.143181562423706,
0.2569607198238373,
1.0253844261169434,
-0.364413857460022,
0.35895949602127075,
-0.18175917863845825,
-0.45684435963630676,
-0.1514541208744049,
-0.6048485040664673,
0.6122869253158569,
0.6457587480545044,
-0.1307389885187149,
0.39355072379112244,
-0.12197645008563995,
0.3713015615940094,
0.5801350474357605,
-0.7708378434181213,
0.0009408859768882394,
0.4717419445514679,
0.14331164956092834,
0.24466626346111298,
0.6821860671043396,
-0.04828597605228424,
0.3584720194339752,
0.11485233902931213,
-0.5020322203636169,
0.2997914254665375,
-0.1251101940870285,
-0.21560242772102356,
0.11579462140798569,
0.294746071100235,
-0.247393399477005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01012v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01012v2
|
Query Performance Prediction using Relevance Judgments Generated by Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T09:33:05 | 2024-06-17T11:23:20 |
Chuan Meng, Negar Arabzadeh, Arian Askari, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.3
|
Query performance prediction (QPP) aims to estimate the retrieval quality of
a search system for a query without human relevance judgments. Previous QPP
methods typically return a single scalar value and do not require the predicted
values to approximate a specific information retrieval (IR) evaluation measure,
leading to certain drawbacks: (i) a single scalar is insufficient to accurately
represent different IR evaluation measures, especially when metrics do not
highly correlate, and (ii) a single scalar limits the interpretability of QPP
methods because solely using a scalar is insufficient to explain QPP results.
To address these issues, we propose a QPP framework using automatically
generated relevance judgments (QPP-GenRE), which decomposes QPP into
independent subtasks of predicting the relevance of each item in a ranked list
to a given query. This allows us to predict any IR evaluation measure using the
generated relevance judgments as pseudo-labels. This also allows us to
interpret predicted IR evaluation measures, and identify, track and rectify
errors in generated relevance judgments to improve QPP quality. We predict an
item's relevance by using open-source large language models (LLMs) to ensure
scientific reproducibility.
We face two main challenges: (i) excessive computational costs of judging an
entire corpus for predicting a metric considering recall, and (ii) limited
performance in prompting open-source LLMs in a zero-/few-shot manner. To solve
the challenges, we devise an approximation strategy to predict an IR measure
considering recall and propose to fine-tune open-source LLMs using
human-labeled relevance judgments. Experiments on the TREC 2019-2022 deep
learning tracks show that QPP-GenRE achieves state-of-the-art QPP quality for
both lexical and neural rankers.
|
[
-0.3223162293434143,
-0.2899702787399292,
0.5620443820953369,
-0.09196653217077255,
-0.12068521231412888,
0.020696675404906273,
-0.10399699956178665,
-0.46383795142173767,
0.3897126317024231,
0.543312668800354,
-0.44673195481300354,
-0.4774581491947174,
-0.33390098810195923,
-0.12184236198663712,
-0.31605347990989685,
0.8289600014686584,
0.5426635146141052,
-0.0837119072675705,
-0.3078019320964813,
0.04521029070019722,
-0.36852413415908813,
-0.5844123959541321,
-0.217133566737175,
-0.22280293703079224,
0.3702976405620575,
0.3765684962272644,
0.6512766480445862,
0.42747458815574646,
0.6084886193275452,
0.19621878862380981,
-0.051881447434425354,
0.06745902448892593,
-0.6969724297523499,
0.1951911896467209,
-0.20015792548656464,
-0.5540250539779663,
-0.3380935788154602,
0.050820089876651764,
0.8955419659614563,
0.5158702731132507,
-0.22240033745765686,
0.2236003279685974,
0.10294211655855179,
0.6245243549346924,
-0.6823638081550598,
0.10222575813531876,
-0.9906724095344543,
0.06708208471536636,
-0.08848410099744797,
-0.4584757685661316,
-0.5139511227607727,
-0.4364648461341858,
0.07929813861846924,
-0.48192909359931946,
0.3458099365234375,
0.37786099314689636,
0.6749168038368225,
0.1853330135345459,
-0.13481630384922028,
-0.07671333849430084,
-0.6614519357681274,
0.7704084515571594,
-0.7183419466018677,
0.3942390978336334,
0.6283097863197327,
0.6606655716896057,
-0.3962063491344452,
-0.7454884052276611,
-0.4168355166912079,
-0.3767050504684448,
-0.04635250195860863,
0.18762633204460144,
0.06569348275661469,
0.05395762622356415,
0.13649892807006836,
0.434239000082016,
-0.6385188698768616,
0.14547748863697052,
-0.2734087407588959,
-0.09441754966974258,
0.4473910629749298,
0.36797574162483215,
-0.07858020067214966,
-0.2069980651140213,
-0.2568108141422272,
-0.024256519973278046,
-0.6432816386222839,
0.29393598437309265,
0.04666552320122719,
0.3565824329853058,
0.36988288164138794,
0.6956416368484497,
-0.4353303611278534,
0.6073281764984131,
0.026247691363096237,
-0.21609479188919067,
0.07696640491485596,
-0.4527461528778076,
0.03811682015657425,
-0.12272042781114578,
0.9138857126235962,
0.4053090512752533,
-0.057651620358228683,
-0.31891363859176636,
-0.2129358947277069,
-0.2314470410346985,
0.4122951626777649,
-0.6882685422897339,
-0.19262266159057617,
0.2316911369562149,
-0.357834130525589,
-0.10743608325719833,
0.11774831265211105,
-0.850413978099823,
-0.390739768743515,
-0.03347889706492424,
0.5548921823501587,
-0.6145768165588379,
0.03417324274778366,
-0.019091319292783737,
-0.025006163865327835,
-0.07722706347703934,
0.2615100145339966,
-0.6317310333251953,
0.2050912082195282,
0.6706855297088623,
0.8132028579711914,
-0.04675160348415375,
-0.28023144602775574,
-0.7470547556877136,
0.060349274426698685,
-0.2806614637374878,
0.876342236995697,
-0.62834632396698,
-0.38946452736854553,
-0.1457839012145996,
-0.23835159838199615,
0.02096588723361492,
-0.4716576933860779,
0.626724123954773,
-0.8233450651168823,
0.16354086995124817,
-0.19162419438362122,
-0.7595341801643372,
0.07649938017129898,
0.11181394010782242,
-0.7264045476913452,
0.9743455052375793,
0.14759406447410583,
-0.777625560760498,
0.603325605392456,
-0.550468385219574,
-0.16146306693553925,
0.31785130500793457,
0.09384242445230484,
-0.3207196295261383,
0.14185211062431335,
0.05636097863316536,
0.18833154439926147,
-0.5473916530609131,
0.3049783706665039,
-0.4906240403652191,
-0.6408411860466003,
0.2607480585575104,
-0.021215194836258888,
0.15456067025661469,
0.2418118566274643,
-0.19161073863506317,
0.17006641626358032,
-0.5968744158744812,
0.42392799258232117,
-0.14234782755374908,
-0.1989055573940277,
-0.17252877354621887,
0.3554275631904602,
-0.2029774934053421,
0.2820519804954529,
0.1018841564655304,
-0.4670405387878418,
0.14681167900562286,
-0.6546481251716614,
0.19817717373371124,
0.5469812154769897,
-0.055976856499910355,
0.4973638355731964,
-0.26164063811302185,
0.7795112729072571,
-0.3504877984523773,
0.08591791242361069,
-0.14444027841091156,
-0.581063449382782,
-0.3843456208705902,
-0.15943142771720886,
0.5318759679794312,
0.41435137391090393,
-0.5955842733383179,
0.4886598289012909,
-0.514712393283844,
-0.773434579372406,
-0.5672006011009216,
-0.051286548376083374,
0.3762369155883789,
0.6066310405731201,
0.42258650064468384,
-0.2927926778793335,
-0.45103466510772705,
-0.71697598695755,
-0.5491328835487366,
-0.4835074245929718,
-0.2885192930698395,
0.4006914496421814,
0.30946311354637146,
0.2155631184577942,
1.005654215812683,
-0.5410654544830322,
-0.5377100706100464,
0.026152225211262703,
0.20817068219184875,
0.33766403794288635,
0.32428282499313354,
0.31119197607040405,
-0.7786762714385986,
-0.31787413358688354,
-0.35259681940078735,
-0.4225366711616516,
-0.002825625240802765,
0.24398183822631836,
0.06093943864107132,
0.005672439932823181,
0.27548959851264954,
-0.3331020474433899,
0.22346143424510956,
0.28341925144195557,
-0.3700157105922699,
0.7421430349349976,
-0.013925863429903984,
0.3520165681838989,
-0.7048931121826172,
0.11316966265439987,
0.13803550601005554,
0.014172163791954517,
-0.23322729766368866,
0.027882801368832588,
0.10376715660095215,
-0.24375104904174805,
-0.4567897915840149,
0.7716314792633057,
-0.04609440267086029,
-0.25022652745246887,
-0.1437891572713852,
-0.0825333520770073,
0.0930677205324173,
0.09133539348840714,
0.11461625248193741,
1.0040111541748047,
0.22659516334533691,
-0.6178796887397766,
-0.021771598607301712,
-0.09665831178426743,
-0.624822735786438,
0.24443523585796356,
-0.5797242522239685,
-0.06637866050004959,
-0.026901043951511383,
0.2683371603488922,
-1.029984712600708,
-0.1377488225698471,
-0.13418905436992645,
-0.7238529920578003,
0.154396191239357,
-0.31211596727371216,
-0.6838823556900024,
-0.505504310131073,
-0.2720574140548706,
0.27315592765808105,
0.5854166746139526,
-0.36167338490486145,
0.3510025143623352,
0.42216187715530396,
-0.018678275868296623,
-0.6661867499351501,
-0.3970146179199219,
0.0732048824429512,
-0.17779292166233063,
-0.3613341450691223,
0.44600263237953186,
-0.01433047279715538,
0.1062210202217102,
0.023757101967930794,
-0.022592034190893173,
-0.09301396459341049,
0.08809993416070938,
0.23512545228004456,
0.11872458457946777,
-0.27992987632751465,
0.3179628849029541,
-0.022442085668444633,
0.036435097455978394,
-0.04886265844106674,
-0.4118952751159668,
0.37035509943962097,
-0.2736699879169464,
-0.33238863945007324,
-0.3055804669857025,
0.05338572338223457,
0.5837993025779724,
-0.40710538625717163,
0.792646050453186,
0.49274271726608276,
-0.2016235738992691,
0.010975310578942299,
-0.6978256106376648,
-0.20065942406654358,
-0.43080881237983704,
0.36634713411331177,
-0.5646051168441772,
-0.8892070651054382,
0.378836065530777,
-0.012338743545114994,
-0.13538095355033875,
0.5312601923942566,
0.3731505572795868,
-0.31432726979255676,
1.096193790435791,
0.46803411841392517,
0.05872161686420441,
0.4630708396434784,
-0.26565849781036377,
0.052304547280073166,
-0.7273336052894592,
-0.3783293068408966,
-0.672677218914032,
-0.20030477643013,
-0.7581905126571655,
-0.5257810354232788,
0.5350708961486816,
0.2971078157424927,
-0.14108656346797943,
0.24138203263282776,
-0.3701063394546509,
0.4389289319515228,
0.8194688558578491,
-0.016122711822390556,
0.40435919165611267,
0.144972026348114,
-0.09216456860303879,
-0.3143179714679718,
-0.6443948149681091,
-0.4972416162490845,
1.295246958732605,
0.19462017714977264,
0.6762658357620239,
0.11233430355787277,
0.7101681232452393,
0.47819116711616516,
0.2154885083436966,
-0.8202142119407654,
0.45497652888298035,
-0.16613343358039856,
-0.5589638948440552,
-0.32773610949516296,
-0.6256900429725647,
-0.8422438502311707,
0.4631992280483246,
-0.3803776800632477,
-0.8289087414741516,
0.10827764868736267,
0.12392520159482956,
-0.348586767911911,
0.1817813515663147,
-0.515956699848175,
0.6753681302070618,
-0.14549620449543,
-0.4996715486049652,
-0.2689913511276245,
-0.5761175155639648,
0.3231949508190155,
-0.09082303941249847,
0.13731715083122253,
-0.19574344158172607,
-0.1428934931755066,
0.7695896625518799,
-0.13085494935512543,
0.4877212643623352,
-0.191875159740448,
0.28665077686309814,
0.4092656075954437,
0.32056522369384766,
0.2494867891073227,
0.07994260638952255,
-0.6725868582725525,
0.05081417039036751,
0.3012867867946625,
-0.39861243963241577,
-0.6039227843284607,
0.7382221221923828,
-0.4780580997467041,
-0.5894217491149902,
-0.4090694189071655,
-0.36502689123153687,
-0.37535348534584045,
0.43518105149269104,
0.38197198510169983,
0.27724194526672363,
-0.3345741927623749,
0.27063223719596863,
0.3719971776008606,
-0.23212338984012604,
0.141761913895607,
0.6949812173843384,
-0.16959786415100098,
-0.4332389831542969,
0.9294837713241577,
0.2042974978685379,
0.005766216199845076,
0.5572868585586548,
0.22549772262573242,
-0.655457079410553,
-0.6623069047927856,
-0.27136296033859253,
0.13617022335529327,
-0.5085136890411377,
-0.37271353602409363,
-0.6177349090576172,
0.09564900398254395,
-0.545232892036438,
0.1476861536502838,
-0.3732328712940216,
-0.41862449049949646,
-0.15611505508422852,
0.2801932394504547,
0.0930415540933609,
0.41101154685020447,
0.1454756259918213,
0.11577929556369781,
-0.8923853635787964,
0.2964072525501251,
0.0029952186159789562,
0.7129365801811218,
-0.08223779499530792,
-0.7888903021812439,
-0.41475552320480347,
0.03794439136981964,
-0.4027201533317566,
-0.546728253364563,
0.6117563843727112,
0.5049225687980652,
0.5314865112304688,
0.15195481479167938,
0.417611300945282,
0.527726948261261,
-0.5318883657455444,
0.8124940395355225,
0.11539794504642487,
-0.6044939160346985,
0.9430622458457947,
-0.3065987229347229,
0.22812530398368835,
0.8281932473182678,
0.5318480134010315,
-0.1199207678437233,
-0.4959143102169037,
-0.4968748390674591,
-0.7860547304153442,
0.7552171945571899,
-0.0023290885146707296,
-0.14507922530174255,
-0.18259480595588684,
0.4179351031780243,
0.13898727297782898,
0.3252471089363098,
-0.48159509897232056,
-0.05070122703909874,
-0.17673099040985107,
0.010397660546004772,
-0.3605533540248871,
-0.35008999705314636,
0.20845498144626617,
-0.20229680836200714,
0.5672923922538757,
-0.2347477227449417,
0.2763317823410034,
0.12693554162979126,
0.1120939776301384,
-0.297340452671051,
0.3254120349884033,
0.28530067205429077,
0.9123716950416565,
-0.6827108263969421,
-0.13990047574043274,
-0.23377737402915955,
-0.2732085585594177,
0.17305988073349,
0.04153994098305702,
-0.17867916822433472,
0.026583177968859673,
0.1285150796175003,
0.5445412993431091,
0.10135837644338608,
-0.87445068359375,
0.40001824498176575,
-0.13175633549690247,
0.17049558460712433,
-0.38689643144607544,
0.07279752939939499,
-0.01775101199746132,
0.23623661696910858,
0.6241220831871033,
-0.13159149885177612,
0.5235671997070312,
-0.5965046286582947,
0.3368326425552368,
0.48017486929893494,
-0.528234601020813,
-0.2471536099910736,
0.8163975477218628,
-0.010711558163166046,
-0.23183710873126984,
0.5714690089225769,
-0.22683455049991608,
-0.5071707963943481,
0.5454435348510742,
0.4700664281845093,
0.6470863223075867,
-0.2834995985031128,
0.07333043962717056,
0.6454391479492188,
0.15263324975967407,
-0.24998128414154053,
0.04421013221144676,
0.06768812239170074,
-0.4451446235179901,
-0.6357279419898987,
-0.956367552280426,
-0.5484184622764587,
0.2142305225133896,
-0.6348935961723328,
0.22858387231826782,
-0.3600757122039795,
-0.38282108306884766,
0.05774311348795891,
0.2603346109390259,
-0.538587212562561,
0.3458014726638794,
-0.06831830739974976,
0.8354594707489014,
-0.5527586936950684,
0.9759836196899414,
0.7342182993888855,
-0.5574769973754883,
-0.5294786691665649,
0.22897103428840637,
-0.13157536089420319,
-0.4969779849052429,
0.6894491314888,
0.03707848861813545,
-0.12961213290691376,
-0.007888306863605976,
-0.061586905270814896,
-0.9997336268424988,
0.9271510243415833,
0.470268577337265,
-0.5149034261703491,
-0.07076440751552582,
-0.03543218970298767,
0.6558045744895935,
-0.2674087882041931,
0.437507301568985,
0.32791197299957275,
0.21615970134735107,
0.22031663358211517,
-1.1146469116210938,
-0.017781496047973633,
-0.16592368483543396,
-0.014299573376774788,
0.2512531578540802,
-0.4423360824584961,
0.6202023029327393,
-0.3325989842414856,
-0.05407828465104103,
0.19588442146778107,
0.7725443243980408,
0.39097437262535095,
0.541667640209198,
0.21387435495853424,
0.4991452991962433,
0.6685241460800171,
-0.01785205490887165,
1.2835766077041626,
-0.3847787082195282,
0.5190848112106323,
1.194045901298523,
-0.27074164152145386,
1.1759529113769531,
0.25240641832351685,
-0.4719325006008148,
0.3014674484729767,
0.6399319171905518,
0.05790315568447113,
0.6373912692070007,
0.10089388489723206,
-0.08544263243675232,
-0.2705918252468109,
-0.22780026495456696,
-0.5063732862472534,
0.5933890342712402,
0.3612474203109741,
-0.41192278265953064,
0.032831910997629166,
-0.22782596945762634,
-0.5332314372062683,
0.12981818616390228,
-0.29139259457588196,
0.7980737686157227,
-0.08097013831138611,
-0.9339966773986816,
0.7603713274002075,
-0.05713646486401558,
0.6392314434051514,
-0.4263286292552948,
-0.1873154640197754,
-0.14924423396587372,
0.08377291262149811,
-0.04277896508574486,
-0.8875609040260315,
0.07676476985216141,
-0.3749496340751648,
-0.3400367796421051,
0.1080411747097969,
0.8174071311950684,
-0.28724032640457153,
-0.4518950581550598,
0.34657368063926697,
0.4134630262851715,
0.18198367953300476,
-0.2998381555080414,
-0.6635801792144775,
-0.23342850804328918,
-0.21692945063114166,
-0.21213246881961823,
0.7962974905967712,
0.2710154950618744,
0.09614482522010803,
0.9166818857192993,
0.40037745237350464,
0.3051242232322693,
-0.022402271628379822,
-0.1103491336107254,
0.7036495208740234,
-0.7538942694664001,
-0.6366803050041199,
-0.5221018195152283,
0.17302265763282776,
0.1860404908657074,
0.061461590230464935,
0.45654159784317017,
0.6573706269264221,
0.6558066010475159,
-0.00231342576444149,
0.6179534792900085,
0.12028462439775467,
0.7603193521499634,
-0.5030386447906494,
0.7104535698890686,
-0.8418359160423279,
0.4248265326023102,
-0.3217613101005554,
-0.9781304001808167,
-0.08807323127985,
0.24212445318698883,
-0.3704153001308441,
0.0929611474275589,
0.5106114149093628,
0.6977524757385254,
-0.03482111915946007,
-0.0832151249051094,
0.54139244556427,
0.08970437198877335,
0.10945406556129456,
0.4630558490753174,
0.6681262850761414,
-0.34075674414634705,
0.6160356402397156,
-0.444942831993103,
-0.130180224776268,
-0.542774498462677,
-0.7713984251022339,
-0.3634551167488098,
-0.6774907112121582,
-0.12012959271669388,
-0.42468294501304626,
0.16101358830928802,
0.6519190073013306,
0.6583829522132874,
-0.7843647003173828,
-0.2652985155582428,
0.08315670490264893,
0.12322884798049927,
-0.12911055982112885,
-0.30679526925086975,
0.4066182076931,
-0.47239670157432556,
-0.5287011861801147,
0.5506110191345215,
0.12914662063121796,
-0.4090321958065033,
-0.08634735643863678,
-0.011311177164316177,
-0.19703927636146545,
-0.24831317365169525,
0.630858838558197,
0.34777891635894775,
-0.9709084630012512,
-0.13968214392662048,
0.05896500125527382,
0.000564351852517575,
0.08604449033737183,
0.7036166787147522,
-1.1777770519256592,
0.6566827297210693,
0.5247055292129517,
0.5309357643127441,
0.5312662720680237,
0.25557538866996765,
0.5283018946647644,
-0.5840445160865784,
-0.15050704777240753,
0.7351548075675964,
0.15826177597045898,
0.08039592206478119,
-0.4485548436641693,
0.6074679493904114,
0.06989461928606033,
-0.5988919734954834,
-0.8539907336235046,
0.12464161962270737,
-0.6626016497612,
-0.2005322128534317,
0.8839985132217407,
-0.27718546986579895,
-0.17866569757461548,
0.0228826142847538,
0.07581397891044617,
0.10026617348194122,
-0.6352912187576294,
0.7885753512382507,
0.3126794397830963,
-0.3816159665584564,
-0.18800416588783264,
-0.6968533992767334,
0.39789408445358276,
0.5071417093276978,
-0.2982027232646942,
-0.00815507210791111,
0.6185166835784912,
0.27259743213653564,
0.20329983532428741,
0.6046404242515564,
-0.27863961458206177,
0.45125243067741394,
-0.15938645601272583,
0.13095776736736298,
0.008916792459785938,
-0.2467004805803299,
-0.13010697066783905,
0.5228971242904663,
0.5447949171066284,
0.04845866188406944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01009v1
|
Constructing and Expanding Low-Resource and Underrepresented Parallel Datasets for Indonesian Local Languages
| 2024-04-01T09:24:06 | 2024-04-01T09:24:06 |
Joanito Agili Lopo, Radius Tanone
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In Indonesia, local languages play an integral role in the culture. However,
the available Indonesian language resources still fall into the category of
limited data in the Natural Language Processing (NLP) field. This is become
problematic when build NLP model for these languages. To address this gap, we
introduce Bhinneka Korpus, a multilingual parallel corpus featuring five
Indonesian local languages. Our goal is to enhance access and utilization of
these resources, extending their reach within the country. We explained in a
detail the dataset collection process and associated challenges. Additionally,
we experimented with translation task using the IBM Model 1 due to data
constraints. The result showed that the performance of each language already
shows good indications for further development. Challenges such as lexical
variation, smoothing effects, and cross-linguistic variability are discussed.
We intend to evaluate the corpus using advanced NLP techniques for low-resource
languages, paving the way for multilingual translation models.
|
[
-0.4412404000759125,
-0.4262014627456665,
0.22301839292049408,
0.09305565059185028,
-0.20592962205410004,
0.11482017487287521,
-0.7211247682571411,
-0.6987668871879578,
0.16657818853855133,
0.9469925165176392,
-0.38143080472946167,
-0.3383808135986328,
-0.7559669613838196,
0.7141978144645691,
0.07069040089845657,
0.9286242723464966,
-0.1487257331609726,
-0.275788277387619,
-0.14790493249893188,
-0.8475017547607422,
-0.6532617211341858,
-0.4444120228290558,
-0.30731201171875,
-0.023547079414129257,
0.49751198291778564,
0.9759359359741211,
0.7086249589920044,
0.4688291847705841,
0.69366455078125,
0.32140493392944336,
-0.08964508771896362,
0.07013344019651413,
-0.1140032485127449,
0.3220711350440979,
-0.4288423955440521,
-0.7728008031845093,
-0.04424028843641281,
-0.33184194564819336,
0.890788733959198,
1.1948062181472778,
-0.06424970179796219,
0.4855339825153351,
-0.07934845238924026,
0.8068847060203552,
-0.7373083829879761,
0.33581945300102234,
-0.3570276200771332,
-0.013523497618734837,
-0.8871303200721741,
0.3447723388671875,
-0.03897152468562126,
-0.25111716985702515,
0.21479903161525726,
-0.46338802576065063,
0.14246703684329987,
-0.08286396414041519,
0.576272189617157,
0.19264096021652222,
-0.34586867690086365,
-0.3669084310531616,
-0.7982191443443298,
1.120824933052063,
-0.5704801082611084,
0.274615615606308,
0.4879244267940521,
0.4839901328086853,
-0.12570194900035858,
-0.4034769833087921,
-0.4126582145690918,
0.017546257004141808,
-0.302476167678833,
-0.1897333413362503,
-0.17570587992668152,
-0.14511963725090027,
0.37550562620162964,
0.5782279968261719,
-0.48488596081733704,
0.12101975083351135,
-0.8462150692939758,
0.12201035022735596,
0.32631492614746094,
0.1486540287733078,
0.3464117646217346,
-0.5602726340293884,
0.11520746350288391,
-0.2371358722448349,
-0.42293161153793335,
-0.025082621723413467,
0.6184147000312805,
0.9029970169067383,
-0.20605216920375824,
0.9696030020713806,
-0.5344120860099792,
0.7817541360855103,
-0.5691405534744263,
-0.14229771494865417,
0.327913373708725,
-0.4056479334831238,
-0.10743346065282822,
0.32554516196250916,
0.5464427471160889,
-0.16832304000854492,
0.0910947173833847,
0.07804856449365616,
0.19514626264572144,
0.34656742215156555,
0.016466591507196426,
-0.5939561724662781,
0.08804381638765335,
0.28501489758491516,
-0.5763316750526428,
-0.18730428814888,
-0.3942485749721527,
-0.9555301666259766,
-0.15820619463920593,
-0.3689030408859253,
-0.23081685602664948,
-0.3073722720146179,
-0.8231552243232727,
0.08562400192022324,
0.06350084394216537,
-0.2618236839771271,
-0.06259287148714066,
-0.8626872301101685,
0.438555508852005,
0.43912360072135925,
0.8992645740509033,
-0.11598844826221466,
-0.1899530291557312,
-0.18090581893920898,
0.1501389592885971,
-0.34259048104286194,
0.6153932809829712,
-0.8716090321540833,
-0.3146792948246002,
0.10561303794384003,
0.21664485335350037,
-0.0407872274518013,
-0.7602915167808533,
0.826460599899292,
0.03545890003442764,
0.08970087021589279,
-0.3271544873714447,
-0.4385985732078552,
-0.2906460165977478,
0.07817070186138153,
-0.8109440803527832,
0.9479143023490906,
0.20670008659362793,
-1.1274677515029907,
0.10594112426042557,
-0.7102089524269104,
-0.34623268246650696,
0.21203017234802246,
-0.3189983069896698,
-0.16837485134601593,
0.5063250660896301,
0.48852962255477905,
0.29886385798454285,
-0.24013029038906097,
0.04157988727092743,
-0.38965359330177307,
-0.20883163809776306,
-0.04953819513320923,
-0.1872880905866623,
0.879074215888977,
0.5440768003463745,
0.14683888852596283,
-0.17342835664749146,
-0.8626827001571655,
-0.296757310628891,
-0.014188376255333424,
-0.30856338143348694,
-0.862062394618988,
-0.20091114938259125,
0.11471084505319595,
0.08827116340398788,
0.338820219039917,
-0.8561765551567078,
0.42950668931007385,
-0.41436007618904114,
-0.039034534245729446,
0.1835828423500061,
-0.22357220947742462,
0.5448430180549622,
-0.1816249042749405,
0.6389176845550537,
0.049120496958494186,
-0.16213348507881165,
-0.4671415686607361,
-0.661482572555542,
-0.513811469078064,
-0.22484393417835236,
0.31490957736968994,
0.6027606129646301,
-0.8429694175720215,
-0.02033492736518383,
-0.4214901924133301,
-0.5401982069015503,
-0.9130785465240479,
0.3116004168987274,
0.14258603751659393,
0.3095960021018982,
0.2513960301876068,
-0.32167336344718933,
-0.8119063377380371,
-0.8935717344284058,
-0.18643935024738312,
0.19023941457271576,
-0.21677441895008087,
0.3133998513221741,
0.25631028413772583,
0.030305152758955956,
0.7078821659088135,
-0.22895033657550812,
-0.5415606498718262,
-0.667155385017395,
0.1850719004869461,
0.8177259564399719,
0.6392829418182373,
0.36028486490249634,
-0.4385334849357605,
-0.5860023498535156,
0.47313907742500305,
-0.9533993601799011,
0.09366235882043839,
0.1952655017375946,
-0.017997531220316887,
0.4900496006011963,
0.40664181113243103,
-0.8843991756439209,
0.29105836153030396,
0.7673435807228088,
0.0053849308751523495,
0.4039608836174011,
-0.4110359251499176,
0.14490270614624023,
-1.1309096813201904,
0.32790035009384155,
-0.14910799264907837,
-0.029229843989014626,
-0.4658103585243225,
0.2405383288860321,
-0.20752482116222382,
-0.5996734499931335,
-0.35789167881011963,
0.5923926830291748,
-0.35963279008865356,
-0.4854045808315277,
-0.3940395712852478,
-0.056560009717941284,
-0.39487046003341675,
0.3424036502838135,
0.3599236011505127,
0.43906617164611816,
0.5310832262039185,
-0.265437513589859,
0.2941950857639313,
0.2838068902492523,
-0.7193376421928406,
0.603024959564209,
-0.32589998841285706,
-0.018545320257544518,
-0.241251602768898,
0.03903178498148918,
-0.4538043737411499,
-0.3870314359664917,
0.32054319977760315,
-0.0758420005440712,
0.2375352829694748,
-0.6795410513877869,
-0.7567635178565979,
-0.3789460361003876,
0.30389639735221863,
0.6981154084205627,
0.45814454555511475,
-0.43755701184272766,
0.24966831505298615,
0.31999117136001587,
-0.6629618406295776,
-0.5029478669166565,
-0.6122689247131348,
0.038683608174324036,
-0.33603957295417786,
-0.6197416186332703,
0.10661916434764862,
0.3697754740715027,
-0.3245973289012909,
0.1823776513338089,
-0.010849780403077602,
-0.08229970186948776,
-0.45224109292030334,
-0.045827362686395645,
-0.08201680332422256,
-0.46136242151260376,
0.08399790525436401,
0.14383594691753387,
-0.027555275708436966,
-0.22170215845108032,
-0.3760946989059448,
0.4420943260192871,
-0.1290893852710724,
-0.09643439948558807,
-0.5170485377311707,
0.5461814999580383,
0.3501041531562805,
-0.34678560495376587,
0.4542517364025116,
0.5429081916809082,
-0.4488818645477295,
0.16758699715137482,
-0.45033779740333557,
0.03839430958032608,
-0.39793747663497925,
0.2717565596103668,
-0.532181978225708,
-0.6830118894577026,
0.5418887734413147,
-0.3040520250797272,
-0.029506772756576538,
0.338623583316803,
0.4756369888782501,
0.09523662179708481,
0.7058362364768982,
0.8707169890403748,
-0.2645166516304016,
0.3083638548851013,
-0.18497256934642792,
0.09645888209342957,
-0.5948415994644165,
0.2136244922876358,
-0.7742154002189636,
-0.298919141292572,
-1.144586443901062,
-0.57566237449646,
0.02718254365026951,
0.25970757007598877,
0.19237543642520905,
0.5653685331344604,
-0.5101115703582764,
0.45248597860336304,
0.5788400173187256,
-0.1927124410867691,
0.43928125500679016,
0.3462126553058624,
-0.06327781081199646,
-0.40658533573150635,
-0.9024621248245239,
-0.388480007648468,
1.3392679691314697,
0.2823311388492584,
0.4244534373283386,
0.07942818105220795,
0.8451677560806274,
-0.0816473737359047,
-0.03480682149529457,
-0.070307657122612,
0.21453362703323364,
-0.5350724458694458,
-0.7636623382568359,
-0.45575717091560364,
-0.3665030002593994,
-1.0750436782836914,
0.25147297978401184,
0.04062226414680481,
-0.7884155511856079,
0.35673093795776367,
-0.13182243704795837,
-0.2451862096786499,
0.45219388604164124,
-0.5606385469436646,
1.0807905197143555,
0.11530326306819916,
-0.29495474696159363,
-0.596743643283844,
-0.3771539628505707,
0.4017195403575897,
0.10265398770570755,
0.36585596203804016,
-0.43693235516548157,
0.11491920053958893,
0.5795459151268005,
-0.41359058022499084,
0.676191508769989,
-0.2309739887714386,
0.2073758840560913,
0.46790611743927,
0.06493084132671356,
0.4999355971813202,
0.14872924983501434,
-0.16777440905570984,
0.4643876552581787,
0.23257334530353546,
-0.9227822422981262,
-0.41235795617103577,
0.7708176970481873,
-0.5631699562072754,
-0.22524182498455048,
-0.5294128060340881,
-0.665012776851654,
-0.10061132162809372,
0.24076007306575775,
-0.13015002012252808,
0.0035533036570996046,
0.11905022710561752,
0.20439250767230988,
0.29956182837486267,
-0.5400297045707703,
0.39322179555892944,
0.38318777084350586,
-0.3654445707798004,
-0.31795206665992737,
1.1557486057281494,
0.2838805615901947,
-0.052337538450956345,
0.08294261991977692,
0.3241550326347351,
-0.14611005783081055,
-0.3812495470046997,
-0.62535560131073,
0.16691988706588745,
-0.5203510522842407,
0.04990259185433388,
-0.3786473572254181,
0.08833067864179611,
-0.3350012004375458,
0.11842332780361176,
-0.6761816143989563,
-0.6240174770355225,
0.15386556088924408,
0.08110051602125168,
0.3501715064048767,
0.6535340547561646,
-0.15812349319458008,
0.20224027335643768,
-0.7851888537406921,
0.20068220794200897,
-0.07739553600549698,
0.3914243280887604,
-0.23777832090854645,
-0.04863564297556877,
-0.34057244658470154,
-0.09354262799024582,
0.14304570853710175,
-0.6658567786216736,
0.5742025375366211,
-0.2152750939130783,
0.3297131061553955,
0.04564368724822998,
0.16038323938846588,
0.5923787951469421,
-0.21207304298877716,
0.42831262946128845,
-0.03204922005534172,
-0.3183758556842804,
0.7816421985626221,
-0.6433473229408264,
0.6703712344169617,
0.668351411819458,
0.4416634142398834,
-0.6279760599136353,
-0.5564164519309998,
-0.7171808481216431,
-0.8151436448097229,
0.8483114242553711,
0.6314574480056763,
0.07285024225711823,
0.043071139603853226,
0.3279517590999603,
0.38211143016815186,
0.34489890933036804,
-0.5048426389694214,
-0.06319622695446014,
-0.11107791215181351,
-0.11573876440525055,
-0.1579613983631134,
-0.16967344284057617,
0.18079936504364014,
-0.32361435890197754,
0.354534775018692,
-0.10650806874036789,
-0.04775603488087654,
0.15013369917869568,
-0.06622356176376343,
-0.22831642627716064,
0.2438812106847763,
0.4253942370414734,
0.4073360562324524,
-0.394422322511673,
-0.06583531945943832,
0.2561814785003662,
-0.3346436321735382,
-0.27058902382850647,
0.2782229781150818,
-0.1546982377767563,
0.4033423066139221,
0.3056681752204895,
0.7386693358421326,
0.15971729159355164,
-0.6258609294891357,
0.051087453961372375,
-0.008698349818587303,
0.3423636853694916,
-0.4354797601699829,
-0.3710872232913971,
-0.003316350746899843,
0.14824159443378448,
0.1552748680114746,
0.14722268283367157,
-0.08279096335172653,
-0.43979412317276,
0.07856988906860352,
-0.08773934096097946,
-0.09200235456228256,
-0.2292078286409378,
0.38363832235336304,
0.18274810910224915,
-0.06445511430501938,
0.8635754585266113,
-0.18385648727416992,
-0.0043577649630606174,
0.5972819924354553,
0.3634347915649414,
0.5750457048416138,
-0.2836671471595764,
0.14264953136444092,
0.7857739329338074,
0.31070542335510254,
-0.05882953852415085,
0.4378963112831116,
-0.19143792986869812,
-0.4258589744567871,
-0.6410602927207947,
-0.847122311592102,
-0.45096948742866516,
0.11505898833274841,
-0.613200306892395,
0.39632561802864075,
-0.22829021513462067,
0.04902873560786247,
-0.0709180161356926,
0.3382456302642822,
-0.7983134984970093,
-0.10520973801612854,
0.01943875104188919,
0.7308857440948486,
-0.8701429963111877,
1.2391409873962402,
0.576000988483429,
-0.5520698428153992,
-0.16321460902690887,
-0.2700801491737366,
-0.2868086099624634,
-0.5081157684326172,
0.7240592837333679,
0.3112887144088745,
0.5278255939483643,
-0.26511627435684204,
-0.06448691338300705,
-1.1103190183639526,
0.5037078261375427,
0.5879834890365601,
-0.695615291595459,
-0.017827056348323822,
0.6798939108848572,
0.6648371815681458,
-0.37059539556503296,
0.028778662905097008,
0.5973508954048157,
0.6365689039230347,
-0.29791393876075745,
-0.9546146392822266,
-0.0799499899148941,
-0.15607434511184692,
0.15863144397735596,
0.10794128477573395,
-0.3339015543460846,
0.7263102531433105,
0.05353230983018875,
-0.19375166296958923,
0.307828813791275,
0.7705940008163452,
0.237295001745224,
-0.023483002558350563,
0.3296123147010803,
0.6356275081634521,
0.567703902721405,
0.07886131852865219,
1.2913799285888672,
-0.2543465793132782,
0.03722941875457764,
1.2859265804290771,
-0.10708137601613998,
1.051385521888733,
0.7080896496772766,
-0.250270813703537,
0.41207244992256165,
0.5252594351768494,
-0.013904361054301262,
0.3179768919944763,
0.17207737267017365,
-0.37134411931037903,
-0.23908786475658417,
-0.5807369947433472,
-0.3555232286453247,
0.5281665921211243,
0.48601341247558594,
0.0794411227107048,
-0.5046708583831787,
0.2891865372657776,
-0.11846520006656647,
0.31694960594177246,
-0.1818787008523941,
0.30142322182655334,
0.08601385354995728,
-0.6987049579620361,
0.2969166040420532,
0.07502380013465881,
0.5642737746238708,
-0.4255785644054413,
-0.05066265910863876,
-0.4909907877445221,
0.33854779601097107,
-0.12085992842912674,
-0.5828444957733154,
0.8981916308403015,
-0.07563099265098572,
-0.13403412699699402,
-0.07019353657960892,
0.6831675171852112,
-0.5026335120201111,
-1.0346205234527588,
0.303687185049057,
0.3538583815097809,
0.3240060806274414,
-0.028335535898804665,
-0.41385531425476074,
0.24155734479427338,
-0.30302950739860535,
0.06970787048339844,
0.32753199338912964,
0.5108512043952942,
-0.3602222204208374,
0.5011862516403198,
0.693191647529602,
0.3232969045639038,
0.28804507851600647,
0.018369518220424652,
0.290800541639328,
-0.52908855676651,
-0.43448805809020996,
-0.3789871037006378,
0.26602354645729065,
-0.17516493797302246,
-0.36624032258987427,
0.660561740398407,
0.7278682589530945,
1.2649555206298828,
-0.08793094754219055,
0.9562214612960815,
-0.19307026267051697,
0.9103997349739075,
-0.14451763033866882,
0.5373267531394958,
-0.4140303432941437,
0.09169632196426392,
-0.34813109040260315,
-0.8620898723602295,
-0.3829396963119507,
0.47760581970214844,
-0.17338673770427704,
-0.43466371297836304,
0.4548569321632385,
0.39181265234947205,
-0.27094173431396484,
0.05048888549208641,
0.2981955409049988,
0.1903410702943802,
-0.03693127632141113,
0.5160794258117676,
0.4525495767593384,
-0.42418405413627625,
0.7718307375907898,
-0.8845416903495789,
-0.04058424010872841,
0.13140185177326202,
-0.6711095571517944,
-0.9414031505584717,
-0.4200512766838074,
-0.26691314578056335,
-0.017382701858878136,
0.10443273931741714,
0.8208665251731873,
0.40627309679985046,
-1.0176167488098145,
-0.7580356001853943,
-0.38356730341911316,
0.31875357031822205,
-0.36119210720062256,
-0.14775273203849792,
0.4073149859905243,
-0.7378382682800293,
-1.0510241985321045,
0.5502944588661194,
0.2492627650499344,
-0.10432222485542297,
-0.31983911991119385,
-0.025507746264338493,
-0.25234362483024597,
-0.3615152835845947,
0.36548182368278503,
0.7660948634147644,
-0.6443977355957031,
-0.011012406088411808,
-0.204448401927948,
0.15840448439121246,
0.09462503343820572,
0.839323878288269,
-0.7585157155990601,
0.7900575399398804,
0.48872965574264526,
0.703616738319397,
0.7211426496505737,
-0.5680440068244934,
0.8245409727096558,
-0.9292765855789185,
0.8286328911781311,
0.05499415844678879,
0.40420782566070557,
0.48402637243270874,
-0.05071255564689636,
0.608396053314209,
0.35405802726745605,
-0.23062044382095337,
-1.009214997291565,
0.25275811553001404,
-0.6395107507705688,
-0.34438538551330566,
0.7531006932258606,
-0.10930991917848587,
-0.21210218966007233,
-0.2232344001531601,
-0.21673887968063354,
0.2902136445045471,
-0.09662118554115295,
0.7842047810554504,
0.797713041305542,
-0.13228364288806915,
-0.18735963106155396,
-0.922322154045105,
0.6070390939712524,
0.5197846293449402,
-0.5187897682189941,
0.2484617531299591,
0.17353439331054688,
0.08796105533838272,
0.4170089364051819,
0.6776257157325745,
-0.1830596625804901,
0.14545701444149017,
0.2703762948513031,
0.0297906044870615,
0.22678735852241516,
-0.30547034740448,
-0.31883683800697327,
0.3543817698955536,
-0.023377565667033195,
-0.3066004812717438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00999v1
|
What Causes the Failure of Explicit to Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition?
| 2024-04-01T09:08:53 | 2024-04-01T09:08:53 |
Wei Liu, Stephen Wan, Michael Strube
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We consider an unanswered question in the discourse processing community: why
do relation classifiers trained on explicit examples (with connectives removed)
perform poorly in real implicit scenarios? Prior work claimed this is due to
linguistic dissimilarity between explicit and implicit examples but provided no
empirical evidence. In this study, we show that one cause for such failure is a
label shift after connectives are eliminated. Specifically, we find that the
discourse relations expressed by some explicit instances will change when
connectives disappear. Unlike previous work manually analyzing a few examples,
we present empirical evidence at the corpus level to prove the existence of
such shift. Then, we analyze why label shift occurs by considering factors such
as the syntactic role played by connectives, ambiguity of connectives, and
more. Finally, we investigate two strategies to mitigate the label shift:
filtering out noisy data and joint learning with connectives. Experiments on
PDTB 2.0, PDTB 3.0, and the GUM dataset demonstrate that classifiers trained
with our strategies outperform strong baselines.
|
[
-0.24079880118370056,
-0.6070839166641235,
0.8123018741607666,
0.0009518636506982148,
-0.06409940868616104,
0.0916215181350708,
0.10312885791063309,
-0.7286955714225769,
-0.4530490040779114,
0.23286698758602142,
-0.398906946182251,
-0.14383262395858765,
-0.6795041561126709,
0.13467085361480713,
-0.26961538195610046,
1.3181694746017456,
-0.157113179564476,
-0.23438599705696106,
-0.3090737462043762,
-0.37440356612205505,
-0.2815413177013397,
-0.3977985680103302,
-0.8542671203613281,
-0.5611634850502014,
0.593545138835907,
0.2780730426311493,
0.749338686466217,
0.764680027961731,
0.38230660557746887,
0.2895333170890808,
-0.41123923659324646,
0.0595792718231678,
-0.6404542922973633,
0.22406098246574402,
-0.02496933750808239,
-0.632255494594574,
-0.18995335698127747,
-0.03215192258358002,
0.9129570722579956,
1.170699954032898,
0.15545910596847534,
-0.05219333618879318,
-0.03362154960632324,
0.5994709134101868,
-0.8133804798126221,
0.48534512519836426,
-0.718061089515686,
-0.08094809949398041,
-0.27101320028305054,
0.37933260202407837,
-0.587726891040802,
-0.48831868171691895,
0.3325779139995575,
-0.6413144469261169,
0.26750412583351135,
0.10280115157365799,
1.1238763332366943,
0.09324678778648376,
-0.7301607728004456,
-0.21919257938861847,
-1.123663067817688,
0.3667846620082855,
-0.2984522879123688,
0.41170093417167664,
0.417507529258728,
-0.00492579210549593,
-0.2996785640716553,
-0.8628994822502136,
-0.45143431425094604,
0.1222810223698616,
-0.36626091599464417,
0.18896549940109253,
-0.18864229321479797,
0.11331357061862946,
0.6295526623725891,
0.15819048881530762,
-0.1358993947505951,
0.07159063965082169,
-0.5543333292007446,
-0.14732825756072998,
0.17843957245349884,
-0.12449515610933304,
0.06124905124306679,
0.15787948668003082,
-0.4802623689174652,
0.03561883419752121,
-1.0943810939788818,
0.3604266047477722,
0.3625487983226776,
0.10426020622253418,
0.19998960196971893,
0.1797640174627304,
0.4024930000305176,
0.4514818787574768,
0.23897568881511688,
-0.11598643660545349,
0.04453271999955177,
-0.07019095867872238,
-0.10024498403072357,
0.368840754032135,
0.6945236325263977,
0.0017542849527671933,
0.21085260808467865,
0.028489811345934868,
-0.14080987870693207,
0.1387293040752411,
-0.10796112567186356,
-0.4000396728515625,
-0.42070645093917847,
-0.14124856889247894,
-0.29139241576194763,
0.037297070026397705,
-0.07512784004211426,
-0.08436566591262817,
-0.3161335587501526,
-0.3319796323776245,
-0.09343384951353073,
-0.401572048664093,
-0.5108834505081177,
-0.16142240166664124,
-0.21955586969852448,
0.4555477201938629,
0.4489336609840393,
-0.8754625916481018,
0.821088969707489,
0.7005175948143005,
0.4472604990005493,
-0.059708282351493835,
-0.08228042721748352,
-0.2922336459159851,
0.44444242119789124,
-0.2964126169681549,
0.9400988817214966,
-0.333021342754364,
-0.35696738958358765,
0.008667158894240856,
0.12389809638261795,
-0.4701504707336426,
-0.6636981964111328,
0.5891349911689758,
-0.39891088008880615,
0.24252524971961975,
-0.5732855200767517,
-0.7133246660232544,
-0.20231543481349945,
-0.22489455342292786,
-0.6798561811447144,
0.8791634440422058,
0.003400874324142933,
-0.8163885474205017,
0.36704128980636597,
-0.18438059091567993,
-0.595425009727478,
-0.11770620197057724,
-0.02014436386525631,
-0.7757627367973328,
0.16045020520687103,
-0.19358588755130768,
0.11671064794063568,
-0.06556232273578644,
0.2740715444087982,
-0.16583900153636932,
-0.7630161643028259,
0.4779945909976959,
-0.266633003950119,
0.9733185768127441,
-0.14287815988063812,
-0.31426212191581726,
-0.12824104726314545,
-0.7057028412818909,
-0.48662590980529785,
-0.04829090088605881,
-0.02982414700090885,
-0.8593631982803345,
0.13959388434886932,
-0.21890336275100708,
0.30454471707344055,
-0.20524784922599792,
-0.518047034740448,
0.04269729554653168,
-0.5509481430053711,
0.260699987411499,
0.9169396758079529,
0.11837542802095413,
0.5575274229049683,
-0.11893919855356216,
0.2578035593032837,
0.439947247505188,
-0.1819344311952591,
0.08967086672782898,
-0.5712758302688599,
-1.0272220373153687,
0.04930298030376434,
0.492514431476593,
0.45731982588768005,
-0.6424843668937683,
-0.05090569704771042,
-0.3527141213417053,
-0.17172060906887054,
-0.5787790417671204,
-0.010216829366981983,
0.7151316404342651,
0.8100100755691528,
0.22987890243530273,
0.08644983917474747,
-0.43360838294029236,
-1.286471962928772,
-0.15465989708900452,
-0.5608270764350891,
0.11907753348350525,
0.025171132758259773,
0.32186245918273926,
0.11927864700555801,
0.9163452982902527,
-0.6729922890663147,
-0.1334441900253296,
0.035214170813560486,
0.4251803159713745,
-0.08739365637302399,
0.34613534808158875,
0.41850873827934265,
-0.9147243499755859,
-0.16904936730861664,
-0.1484207659959793,
-0.6409708261489868,
-0.1429220587015152,
-0.11814653873443604,
-0.052147090435028076,
0.44645416736602783,
0.7461581230163574,
-0.448411226272583,
0.45365002751350403,
0.16715548932552338,
-0.2765941023826599,
0.49737614393234253,
-0.06383155286312103,
-0.43263211846351624,
-0.7917425632476807,
-0.013519247993826866,
0.10438261181116104,
-0.3641180396080017,
-0.5335301756858826,
-0.4793627858161926,
0.08567459881305695,
0.14382433891296387,
-0.7314937114715576,
0.41738682985305786,
-0.6789470314979553,
-0.20759978890419006,
0.14864203333854675,
0.12363585829734802,
-0.008141008205711842,
0.634304940700531,
0.1610998511314392,
0.562823474407196,
0.2077832669019699,
-0.9095332622528076,
-0.11007954925298691,
0.41986191272735596,
0.20155544579029083,
0.7500226497650146,
-0.40472355484962463,
0.21653056144714355,
-0.36433401703834534,
0.2780667543411255,
-1.4535572528839111,
0.09117807447910309,
0.7330025434494019,
0.12878663837909698,
0.6628822088241577,
-0.42002004384994507,
-0.29338574409484863,
-0.0882088840007782,
-0.20676875114440918,
0.46860742568969727,
0.43985795974731445,
-0.5656054019927979,
0.17081892490386963,
0.4474640190601349,
-0.16364547610282898,
-0.35259222984313965,
-0.5798978805541992,
-0.24872057139873505,
-0.1264282464981079,
-0.11182961612939835,
0.27945682406425476,
0.11723742634057999,
-0.3570181727409363,
0.2090081423521042,
-0.5008125305175781,
-0.3731056749820709,
0.15545673668384552,
0.639978289604187,
0.21695132553577423,
-0.019124075770378113,
0.5659816265106201,
0.41119328141212463,
-0.1262570172548294,
0.6058265566825867,
0.2024819552898407,
-0.1883949190378189,
-0.2075398713350296,
-0.002800540765747428,
-0.16415779292583466,
0.07001668959856033,
0.20042966306209564,
0.16675172746181488,
0.7161176204681396,
0.4054945409297943,
-0.35399115085601807,
0.11068388819694519,
-0.3227368891239166,
0.016247736290097237,
-0.41958487033843994,
0.07750462740659714,
-0.5884060263633728,
-0.7086477875709534,
0.534404993057251,
-0.5409325957298279,
-0.029145387932658195,
0.45718568563461304,
-0.181492418050766,
-0.34453874826431274,
0.8113908767700195,
0.2604656517505646,
0.3548775613307953,
0.28793540596961975,
-0.05881037563085556,
0.21169644594192505,
-1.1072967052459717,
-0.24279920756816864,
-0.5213119983673096,
-0.1580091118812561,
-0.9708720445632935,
0.2422046810388565,
0.2795872688293457,
-0.06274191290140152,
-0.09554744511842728,
0.284359335899353,
-0.24112723767757416,
0.3944450616836548,
0.22665074467658997,
0.12189540266990662,
0.39681315422058105,
-0.06948986649513245,
-0.0326918289065361,
-0.4870608150959015,
-0.6209545135498047,
-0.3482358157634735,
0.5544037818908691,
0.2778503894805908,
0.44509226083755493,
0.1615767776966095,
0.6084524393081665,
-0.04353843256831169,
0.6034809947013855,
-0.6082196831703186,
0.8003512620925903,
-0.07440552115440369,
-0.368398517370224,
-0.17958761751651764,
-0.5069588422775269,
-1.2925773859024048,
0.25555333495140076,
-0.17108049988746643,
-0.5256452560424805,
0.4517713785171509,
0.01630929484963417,
0.18576626479625702,
0.17948953807353973,
-0.6579126119613647,
0.723670482635498,
0.22255465388298035,
-0.8097991347312927,
0.4082827866077423,
-0.9451414346694946,
0.6299264430999756,
0.1316014528274536,
0.2608737349510193,
-0.3008076846599579,
-0.008118431083858013,
0.8295806050300598,
-0.299134224653244,
0.8697713017463684,
-0.2146749645471573,
-0.3459970951080322,
0.21855665743350983,
0.1802980750799179,
0.26929450035095215,
-0.09075567871332169,
0.0851028636097908,
0.11788450926542282,
-0.28665581345558167,
-0.15049782395362854,
-0.6291536688804626,
0.6303495764732361,
-0.679879367351532,
-0.576422929763794,
-0.7162806987762451,
-0.34219494462013245,
-0.17922858893871307,
0.06520675122737885,
0.24822703003883362,
0.2120048850774765,
-0.37146449089050293,
-0.21588784456253052,
0.756592869758606,
0.1261473447084427,
0.589448094367981,
0.42533668875694275,
-0.16699372231960297,
-0.11091802269220352,
0.9139322638511658,
0.26640769839286804,
0.18093636631965637,
0.20323148369789124,
0.027707591652870178,
-0.4772714078426361,
-0.3309918940067291,
-0.1236877515912056,
0.5260231494903564,
-0.7969138622283936,
-0.138330340385437,
-0.5316735506057739,
-0.3498334288597107,
-0.4440978169441223,
0.09639406204223633,
-0.1395045816898346,
-0.6693834066390991,
-0.3519653379917145,
-0.2502657473087311,
0.056063905358314514,
0.8395744562149048,
0.12745317816734314,
0.18288876116275787,
-0.551949143409729,
0.2588519752025604,
0.39402228593826294,
0.18009507656097412,
-0.2958678603172302,
-0.5100859999656677,
0.14841328561306,
-0.12849190831184387,
-0.302695631980896,
-0.9472701549530029,
0.0596952922642231,
0.36798977851867676,
0.31643617153167725,
0.3767572045326233,
0.16647988557815552,
0.7143927216529846,
-0.4245525300502777,
0.3333759903907776,
-0.03892374411225319,
-1.0350961685180664,
0.5214864611625671,
-0.42512547969818115,
0.657524824142456,
0.5458282828330994,
0.741573691368103,
-0.24554544687271118,
-0.6244129538536072,
-0.7484757304191589,
-1.0096653699874878,
0.7324044704437256,
0.40322473645210266,
-0.26560646295547485,
-0.030752675607800484,
0.6751521825790405,
0.28522789478302,
0.2513900697231293,
-1.0170953273773193,
-0.6571599841117859,
0.2649501860141754,
0.14602871239185333,
0.23003298044204712,
-0.44406917691230774,
0.08838348090648651,
-0.4622945189476013,
0.6138116121292114,
0.07709812372922897,
0.16085119545459747,
0.16672708094120026,
-0.20384840667247772,
-0.16053509712219238,
0.30520936846733093,
0.6038888692855835,
0.6976901292800903,
-0.21636922657489777,
0.2505377531051636,
-0.05111577361822128,
-0.3580830991268158,
0.4218369424343109,
0.3403646647930145,
-0.630476713180542,
0.2844964861869812,
0.33650487661361694,
1.0682035684585571,
0.8964095115661621,
-0.17717570066452026,
0.395964115858078,
-0.20389971137046814,
-0.17164228856563568,
-0.37283721566200256,
-0.10692562162876129,
0.13375723361968994,
-0.41884100437164307,
0.17966175079345703,
0.37505337595939636,
0.3851951062679291,
-0.5776464939117432,
0.003222342813387513,
0.09533414244651794,
-0.4944920539855957,
-0.5352007150650024,
0.6107937693595886,
0.04987124726176262,
-0.03717916086316109,
0.7276909351348877,
-0.3586181104183197,
-0.573965311050415,
0.38734903931617737,
0.6354725956916809,
0.6905790567398071,
-0.5312096476554871,
0.44298169016838074,
0.37414294481277466,
0.16429901123046875,
-0.05873618274927139,
-0.19357439875602722,
-0.12749221920967102,
-0.7382429838180542,
-0.20184992253780365,
-0.15870317816734314,
-0.5939691066741943,
-0.03409440442919731,
-0.7038729190826416,
0.2704800069332123,
-0.5075944662094116,
-0.1924186646938324,
0.08947387337684631,
-0.37701302766799927,
-0.5661643147468567,
0.06533441692590714,
0.12798775732517242,
0.16096185147762299,
-1.107610821723938,
0.5733645558357239,
0.8410994410514832,
-0.1792120486497879,
-0.6728460788726807,
0.00247937417589128,
0.0046689207665622234,
-0.21151389181613922,
0.904472291469574,
0.1654822677373886,
-0.2084808498620987,
-0.06645119190216064,
-0.44429346919059753,
-0.6974155306816101,
0.5572848320007324,
0.7263345122337341,
-0.5809639096260071,
-0.07462279498577118,
0.1830015480518341,
0.7384806871414185,
0.05820618197321892,
0.2878769338130951,
0.5741745233535767,
0.5264151692390442,
0.2772214412689209,
-0.8288001418113708,
0.36112576723098755,
0.13929684460163116,
0.075482077896595,
0.56498783826828,
-0.5379948019981384,
0.9267153739929199,
-0.08471912145614624,
-0.5056557059288025,
-0.39112403988838196,
0.6424691081047058,
0.08086854964494705,
0.6590445637702942,
0.5495143532752991,
0.5097774863243103,
0.7384582161903381,
-0.5088145732879639,
0.987654983997345,
0.4421563446521759,
-0.026980310678482056,
1.4025996923446655,
-0.7138733267784119,
0.8085505366325378,
0.46915921568870544,
-0.22790706157684326,
0.8801332116127014,
0.5276673436164856,
0.242107093334198,
0.4393407702445984,
0.1765904426574707,
-0.43219760060310364,
-0.0002886670990847051,
-0.24895648658275604,
-0.27376842498779297,
0.5824472308158875,
0.652795672416687,
-0.28078439831733704,
-0.2703593969345093,
0.027849245816469193,
0.19432513415813446,
0.11164126545190811,
-0.2942849099636078,
1.093368411064148,
0.20494207739830017,
-0.8606142997741699,
0.6838598251342773,
-0.5328829288482666,
0.05957677960395813,
-0.39278027415275574,
-0.3086821138858795,
-0.17228008806705475,
0.17339277267456055,
-0.29470184445381165,
-0.7311367392539978,
0.3277518153190613,
-0.7510454058647156,
-0.15096580982208252,
-0.34390586614608765,
1.0389069318771362,
-0.5565090179443359,
-0.31956666707992554,
0.3723909556865692,
0.6012343764305115,
0.1741955280303955,
0.34513527154922485,
-0.49055027961730957,
0.17090345919132233,
-0.16508933901786804,
-0.07650099694728851,
0.40775638818740845,
0.7299425005912781,
-0.2635796070098877,
0.34177520871162415,
0.4300614595413208,
0.18578392267227173,
-0.13456951081752777,
-0.18291544914245605,
0.8605279326438904,
-0.45466774702072144,
-0.23866355419158936,
-0.6475281119346619,
0.15993382036685944,
-0.18030044436454773,
-0.23227229714393616,
0.7329291105270386,
0.5828453898429871,
0.7305353879928589,
-0.1230170875787735,
0.5702606439590454,
0.23575055599212646,
0.4315972328186035,
-0.5201275944709778,
0.40209197998046875,
-0.0001664796145632863,
0.4657142162322998,
-0.38574138283729553,
-1.0631691217422485,
-0.3479393422603607,
0.4132080674171448,
-0.38139981031417847,
-0.12950989603996277,
0.9990441799163818,
0.251844584941864,
-0.02316269278526306,
0.05506006255745888,
0.22540642321109772,
0.5481526255607605,
0.21216948330402374,
0.7382245659828186,
0.8185761570930481,
-0.7657907009124756,
0.7458761930465698,
-0.15582431852817535,
0.09158144146203995,
0.11473973840475082,
-0.8137530088424683,
-0.7628487348556519,
-0.8556167483329773,
-0.8878533840179443,
-0.4786592125892639,
0.5973252654075623,
0.3642725944519043,
0.45041990280151367,
-0.5355499386787415,
-0.20146533846855164,
-0.3291029930114746,
0.5923098921775818,
-0.24365781247615814,
-0.30197587609291077,
0.3754696846008301,
-0.15775619447231293,
-0.691159725189209,
0.11678783595561981,
0.1737397313117981,
0.2874469459056854,
0.16481588780879974,
0.26562607288360596,
-0.5234462022781372,
-0.41390490531921387,
0.41513270139694214,
0.7741944789886475,
-0.4893423020839691,
-0.36221975088119507,
-0.4782334566116333,
-0.15315914154052734,
0.3058130443096161,
0.8066005706787109,
-1.0724146366119385,
0.16235189139842987,
0.33240580558776855,
0.25499504804611206,
0.6172839403152466,
-0.07338020205497742,
0.7635867595672607,
-1.1167999505996704,
0.2403372973203659,
0.117019884288311,
0.3038857579231262,
0.4266005754470825,
-0.2899826467037201,
0.6674715876579285,
0.4428586959838867,
-0.5643707513809204,
-0.7981939911842346,
0.2690332531929016,
-0.8344409465789795,
-0.24611325562000275,
1.0895005464553833,
-0.32626816630363464,
-0.3875342309474945,
-0.6123890280723572,
-0.36029183864593506,
0.31409528851509094,
-0.4733709990978241,
0.6204964518547058,
0.7010810375213623,
-0.446544885635376,
-0.28979039192199707,
-0.16042500734329224,
0.8524608016014099,
0.28926095366477966,
-0.5879207253456116,
0.03467784821987152,
0.642540454864502,
0.18941573798656464,
0.3127232491970062,
0.7129940986633301,
0.21966873109340668,
0.33702895045280457,
-0.153716579079628,
-0.3323056995868683,
0.09493888914585114,
-0.17195633053779602,
-0.33388930559158325,
0.29868924617767334,
0.15380430221557617,
-0.11144809424877167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00998v1
|
LLM-RadJudge: Achieving Radiologist-Level Evaluation for X-Ray Report Generation
| 2024-04-01T09:02:12 | 2024-04-01T09:02:12 |
Zilong Wang, Xufang Luo, Xinyang Jiang, Dongsheng Li, Lili Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Evaluating generated radiology reports is crucial for the development of
radiology AI, but existing metrics fail to reflect the task's clinical
requirements. This study proposes a novel evaluation framework using large
language models (LLMs) to compare radiology reports for assessment. We compare
the performance of various LLMs and demonstrate that, when using GPT-4, our
proposed metric achieves evaluation consistency close to that of radiologists.
Furthermore, to reduce costs and improve accessibility, making this method
practical, we construct a dataset using LLM evaluation results and perform
knowledge distillation to train a smaller model. The distilled model achieves
evaluation capabilities comparable to GPT-4. Our framework and distilled model
offer an accessible and efficient evaluation method for radiology report
generation, facilitating the development of more clinically relevant models.
The model will be further open-sourced and accessible.
|
[
0.023066505789756775,
-0.19864247739315033,
0.853330671787262,
-0.06683797389268875,
-0.2507234513759613,
0.15833818912506104,
-0.11957910656929016,
-0.5852513313293457,
-0.11283837258815765,
0.21019548177719116,
-0.30398958921432495,
-0.6411438584327698,
-0.8799818754196167,
0.2116248905658722,
-0.36473432183265686,
0.8581239581108093,
-0.008090779185295105,
0.3725093603134155,
-0.4241100251674652,
0.058274123817682266,
-0.6004478931427002,
-0.03181879222393036,
-0.44505342841148376,
-0.721806526184082,
0.3314484655857086,
0.2574252486228943,
0.9810053706169128,
0.7062216997146606,
1.0416698455810547,
0.25234928727149963,
0.07417265325784683,
0.01175763737410307,
-0.4209975302219391,
0.16693739593029022,
-0.24527183175086975,
-0.17692197859287262,
-0.6918245553970337,
0.1631714403629303,
0.3803545832633972,
0.6038670539855957,
-0.27368786931037903,
0.15255048871040344,
-0.3591340482234955,
0.6324456930160522,
-0.5762335658073425,
0.3040197491645813,
-0.3605574369430542,
0.13897019624710083,
-0.038728468120098114,
-0.35274577140808105,
-0.41217362880706787,
-0.5196896195411682,
0.09471862018108368,
-0.3194670081138611,
0.061740443110466,
-0.06681615114212036,
0.8578156232833862,
0.09908746182918549,
-0.25463932752609253,
-0.7625075578689575,
-0.7396864891052246,
0.6106371283531189,
-0.5962451696395874,
0.14283040165901184,
0.2672789692878723,
0.6715323328971863,
0.2762005925178528,
-1.0980594158172607,
-0.21636554598808289,
-0.6718353033065796,
-0.052701711654663086,
0.28446489572525024,
-0.4389868974685669,
0.07292252033948898,
0.19314874708652496,
0.7419466972351074,
-0.6906703114509583,
0.12362319976091385,
-0.30189239978790283,
0.09618917852640152,
0.7276344299316406,
0.5639325976371765,
0.19547922909259796,
-0.4516433775424957,
-0.4426061511039734,
-0.06675741821527481,
-0.6783410310745239,
-0.62181556224823,
-0.1391821801662445,
0.12651003897190094,
0.04303731024265289,
0.5749204754829407,
-0.3547968566417694,
0.4239712953567505,
0.0056458208709955215,
-0.5477598309516907,
0.46238386631011963,
-0.3297382891178131,
-0.24296103417873383,
-0.04153312370181084,
0.6229081749916077,
0.4318312406539917,
-0.15047597885131836,
-0.012338126078248024,
-0.4568672776222229,
0.17008163034915924,
0.21111896634101868,
-0.936362624168396,
-0.3155483603477478,
0.17190171778202057,
-0.6707004308700562,
-0.7249247431755066,
-0.06585969775915146,
-0.4900691509246826,
-0.6092655062675476,
-0.06253214925527573,
0.6061697602272034,
-0.3267715573310852,
-0.5025702118873596,
0.4805700182914734,
0.09557754546403885,
0.11092554032802582,
0.4004085063934326,
-0.4983491599559784,
0.1837255358695984,
0.5042842030525208,
0.823772668838501,
-0.03707003593444824,
0.17152848839759827,
-0.5791604518890381,
0.04936196282505989,
-0.28484174609184265,
0.7850397825241089,
-0.6356967091560364,
-0.5491400957107544,
-0.17812268435955048,
-0.45914456248283386,
0.1420115828514099,
-0.7062912583351135,
0.45722001791000366,
-0.4983161687850952,
0.27797770500183105,
0.10018029808998108,
-0.47823280096054077,
-0.07230833917856216,
0.3790077567100525,
-0.5549716949462891,
0.7732597589492798,
0.5912243127822876,
-0.8105656504631042,
0.711999237537384,
-0.7306108474731445,
-0.31791362166404724,
0.6234241127967834,
-0.5923700928688049,
-0.5297471284866333,
0.19978877902030945,
0.2736130356788635,
0.49725428223609924,
-1.0121097564697266,
0.34161531925201416,
0.12171896547079086,
-0.18519903719425201,
0.07020512968301773,
-0.2317420095205307,
0.5125025510787964,
0.48145127296447754,
-0.22014018893241882,
0.18640755116939545,
-0.7280811071395874,
0.3044416904449463,
0.20985087752342224,
-0.35647648572921753,
-0.16489195823669434,
-0.27296480536460876,
-0.2933984398841858,
0.25473248958587646,
0.10986968874931335,
-0.5546646118164062,
0.08675078302621841,
-0.12100028991699219,
0.30210819840431213,
0.3725460171699524,
0.04149753600358963,
0.06874813139438629,
-0.5903858542442322,
1.1100375652313232,
-0.15759025514125824,
0.1527053713798523,
-0.11812785267829895,
-0.2874372899532318,
-0.3537088632583618,
-0.5694802403450012,
0.3433493971824646,
0.2046811878681183,
-0.639536440372467,
0.16545243561267853,
-0.7205376029014587,
-0.9036272168159485,
-0.5555320978164673,
-0.07998740673065186,
0.6644828915596008,
0.4902544915676117,
0.023132720962166786,
-0.34648895263671875,
-0.2693374752998352,
-0.6695171594619751,
0.16541631519794464,
-0.14426816999912262,
-0.06627363711595535,
0.22542046010494232,
0.3550752103328705,
-0.24429230391979218,
0.5903444886207581,
-0.6169905066490173,
-0.6050073504447937,
-0.6358435750007629,
0.20360438525676727,
0.27108970284461975,
0.07206761837005615,
0.4668525457382202,
-0.38782933354377747,
-0.4512975215911865,
0.30227547883987427,
-1.0750701427459717,
-0.09106166660785675,
0.100815050303936,
0.28656524419784546,
-0.032266709953546524,
0.5585451722145081,
-0.3656635284423828,
0.49943310022354126,
0.4884321689605713,
-0.10067784786224365,
0.32070687413215637,
-0.39192283153533936,
0.4395865499973297,
-0.8012703061103821,
0.08958817273378372,
-0.08296667039394379,
-0.5183220505714417,
-0.293783962726593,
0.14044655859470367,
0.07409001886844635,
-0.29154592752456665,
-0.4057944416999817,
0.3240914046764374,
-0.7792041897773743,
-0.34168726205825806,
-0.22010760009288788,
0.34644654393196106,
0.16103719174861908,
-0.21134234964847565,
0.0031375268008559942,
0.48814624547958374,
0.5395838618278503,
-0.17351041734218597,
0.43851223587989807,
0.20712615549564362,
-0.8114293813705444,
0.369100958108902,
-0.632060706615448,
0.2814808785915375,
0.15804779529571533,
0.07490605860948563,
-0.8791006803512573,
-0.22024402022361755,
-0.10007241368293762,
-0.4183034598827362,
0.5547020435333252,
-0.21117109060287476,
-0.35951387882232666,
-0.5781152248382568,
-0.3704327344894409,
0.40794774889945984,
0.7531604766845703,
-0.4085215926170349,
0.5683175325393677,
0.36821192502975464,
-0.257147878408432,
-0.45207253098487854,
-0.5742449760437012,
0.21515706181526184,
-0.25873684883117676,
-0.9411035180091858,
0.1687096506357193,
-0.021136440336704254,
-0.3938887119293213,
0.017721213400363922,
-0.007204074878245592,
-0.005199868697673082,
0.018714116886258125,
0.25775793194770813,
0.23610471189022064,
-0.47553393244743347,
-0.3073101043701172,
-0.14244961738586426,
-0.28278306126594543,
0.25810694694519043,
0.17134980857372284,
0.43373772501945496,
-0.1667206585407257,
-0.571390688419342,
-0.43835213780403137,
0.03813249617815018,
0.44624659419059753,
-0.0675877183675766,
0.18431203067302704,
0.2932054400444031,
-0.19628402590751648,
-0.07173117995262146,
-0.4446188807487488,
-0.030201349407434464,
-0.4359394609928131,
0.6360853314399719,
-0.5417187213897705,
-0.7558488845825195,
0.18339866399765015,
-0.1874345988035202,
-0.07069410383701324,
0.3885098397731781,
0.9621134996414185,
0.25664132833480835,
0.9819356203079224,
0.42375487089157104,
0.3377099633216858,
-0.05851951614022255,
-0.11341612040996552,
0.24835821986198425,
-0.5902603268623352,
-0.25302714109420776,
-0.4692952036857605,
0.10427585989236832,
-0.20701731741428375,
-0.31431645154953003,
0.6230410933494568,
-0.34836769104003906,
0.18610474467277527,
-0.13898815214633942,
-0.6415697336196899,
0.5932710766792297,
-0.000060240428865654394,
-0.012995677068829536,
0.7442524433135986,
0.04057224094867706,
0.10242348909378052,
-0.09531155228614807,
-0.7705155611038208,
-0.6030987501144409,
1.2843049764633179,
0.5582966208457947,
0.9349115490913391,
0.2411929816007614,
0.7883560657501221,
0.5100874900817871,
0.6887722015380859,
-0.7328254580497742,
0.40856069326400757,
-0.2538093030452728,
-0.616840660572052,
-0.22492702305316925,
-0.30480802059173584,
-0.8314597010612488,
0.36601728200912476,
-0.1785622388124466,
-0.19397962093353271,
-0.2725840210914612,
-0.16663533449172974,
-0.5447236895561218,
-0.026828715577721596,
-0.42728883028030396,
0.6328527927398682,
-0.1962386518716812,
-0.14359505474567413,
-0.4375915825366974,
-0.41207727789878845,
0.6227253675460815,
-0.3566605746746063,
0.3648723363876343,
-0.49730461835861206,
0.06843417137861252,
0.5279178619384766,
-0.5641441345214844,
0.5228664875030518,
-0.32641905546188354,
-0.14132951200008392,
0.20966887474060059,
0.2585037052631378,
0.07202094793319702,
0.3202785551548004,
-0.19612932205200195,
0.13751597702503204,
0.07569078356027603,
0.003877773182466626,
-0.5435239672660828,
0.6662730574607849,
-0.8392519354820251,
-0.6240401864051819,
-0.7023523449897766,
-0.7172841429710388,
-0.13123001158237457,
0.14969377219676971,
0.2594870626926422,
0.6613947749137878,
-0.33936408162117004,
0.0055651310831308365,
0.28248342871665955,
-0.37520697712898254,
-0.03717706352472305,
0.6561291217803955,
-0.5482823848724365,
-0.34975099563598633,
0.6369346976280212,
-0.006703714840114117,
0.3766137957572937,
0.24056456983089447,
0.4449174702167511,
-0.2015296369791031,
-0.9388863444328308,
-0.34355562925338745,
0.24227018654346466,
-0.9551730751991272,
-0.6872454881668091,
-0.32660993933677673,
-0.46031421422958374,
-0.2727448046207428,
-0.07100579887628555,
-0.37226808071136475,
-0.2623383402824402,
0.10868886113166809,
-0.0669485330581665,
0.37383463978767395,
1.3381719589233398,
-0.25461235642433167,
0.2090355008840561,
-0.6057046055793762,
0.08771660178899765,
-0.00728576211258769,
0.14613506197929382,
-0.07875470072031021,
-0.8588725328445435,
-0.437775194644928,
-0.26753902435302734,
-0.3912023901939392,
-0.3750230073928833,
0.5188282132148743,
-0.014897024258971214,
0.4308641254901886,
0.1946505457162857,
0.06514335423707962,
0.4904959499835968,
-0.2847077548503876,
0.5131145119667053,
0.5435618162155151,
-0.8856275677680969,
0.5250029563903809,
-0.47812619805336,
0.3059106171131134,
0.558708667755127,
0.2664896249771118,
-0.09005523473024368,
-0.3552813231945038,
-0.45538344979286194,
-0.8801325559616089,
0.5691044926643372,
0.07435428351163864,
-0.0005598198622465134,
-0.3484251797199249,
0.35299354791641235,
0.18974235653877258,
-0.09247542917728424,
-0.7704415321350098,
0.13524092733860016,
0.14308355748653412,
-0.16119740903377533,
0.23099373281002045,
-0.5263401865959167,
-0.3024877607822418,
-0.09332247078418732,
0.5247548818588257,
0.0288521908223629,
0.17410700023174286,
0.14633305370807648,
-0.3185959756374359,
-0.06048797443509102,
0.08419288694858551,
0.5570553541183472,
1.298178791999817,
-0.4199312627315521,
0.053541142493486404,
0.04922161251306534,
-0.6283478140830994,
0.2712700366973877,
-0.2079140543937683,
0.2101941704750061,
0.16628429293632507,
0.57106614112854,
0.41935020685195923,
0.17608138918876648,
-0.5070595741271973,
0.9606117010116577,
-0.3457506000995636,
-0.5822985768318176,
-0.46010810136795044,
0.05208594724535942,
0.2038850486278534,
0.23105669021606445,
0.3014170825481415,
-0.22928695380687714,
0.04215119406580925,
-0.1656787097454071,
0.3151237666606903,
0.18888461589813232,
-0.3436691164970398,
-0.03349052369594574,
0.6443859338760376,
0.20157794654369354,
0.2031484693288803,
0.7815632224082947,
-0.18553157150745392,
0.15978093445301056,
0.5901176929473877,
0.44484686851501465,
0.7852178812026978,
-0.26734331250190735,
0.155269593000412,
0.3815349340438843,
0.15934491157531738,
-0.11201968789100647,
0.2812248170375824,
0.49867451190948486,
-0.5057125091552734,
-0.5531641840934753,
-0.38049769401550293,
-0.3009721040725708,
0.11785084754228592,
-1.0424689054489136,
0.5756852030754089,
-0.7189037799835205,
-0.24683797359466553,
0.17407363653182983,
0.023823536932468414,
-0.6093106865882874,
0.3234553039073944,
0.11794827878475189,
0.9500331878662109,
-0.6881963014602661,
0.9061508774757385,
0.3779370188713074,
-0.7788480520248413,
-0.7911766171455383,
-0.2597413659095764,
-0.038658082485198975,
-1.1888667345046997,
0.9616661071777344,
0.12326875329017639,
-0.2176552712917328,
-0.3046870529651642,
-0.03838520497083664,
-0.905498206615448,
1.6347800493240356,
0.4492321014404297,
-0.6531208753585815,
0.02076864056289196,
0.12409869581460953,
0.4918411374092102,
-0.6719626188278198,
0.6040085554122925,
0.621904194355011,
0.3474636971950531,
0.28254008293151855,
-1.0560871362686157,
0.2384653091430664,
-0.04895555600523949,
0.046282678842544556,
-0.032610613852739334,
-0.3087802231311798,
0.6503280997276306,
-0.5006157159805298,
-0.3107795715332031,
0.23671117424964905,
0.690125048160553,
0.29299086332321167,
0.33510875701904297,
0.3714216351509094,
0.4675898253917694,
0.73183673620224,
0.04690941795706749,
1.3135781288146973,
-0.2903977334499359,
0.3809775710105896,
1.1396965980529785,
-0.711273729801178,
0.5697758197784424,
0.04214080050587654,
-0.1726834625005722,
0.33636781573295593,
0.2198335826396942,
-0.21802055835723877,
0.5902547836303711,
0.3996564447879791,
-0.2576574683189392,
-0.1350409835577011,
-0.10682161152362823,
-0.4762502610683441,
0.6440831422805786,
0.16360057890415192,
-0.525971531867981,
-0.4527011215686798,
0.07637451589107513,
0.1974778175354004,
0.09466204792261124,
-0.41525936126708984,
0.7009842991828918,
0.21531595289707184,
-0.3291603922843933,
0.8369316458702087,
0.08062901347875595,
0.38037165999412537,
-0.6548598408699036,
0.18713746964931488,
-0.279024600982666,
0.4104176163673401,
-0.54622882604599,
-0.686747133731842,
0.5245612263679504,
0.24875202775001526,
-0.18968570232391357,
-0.04879431799054146,
0.44601866602897644,
-0.009261111728847027,
-0.49497362971305847,
0.35935699939727783,
0.5817606449127197,
0.3915700614452362,
0.20882265269756317,
-0.6010251641273499,
0.31138625741004944,
0.14331987500190735,
-0.24072253704071045,
0.5190131068229675,
0.39634159207344055,
-0.11957317590713501,
0.7178472876548767,
0.18065699934959412,
0.2183905839920044,
-0.30684027075767517,
0.5118740797042847,
1.015228509902954,
-0.42315560579299927,
-0.11927852034568787,
-0.7519239187240601,
0.3603745698928833,
0.12417817860841751,
-0.2767024040222168,
0.5698371529579163,
0.6787465214729309,
0.5296315550804138,
0.08652017265558243,
0.9588421583175659,
-0.13483959436416626,
0.6504039168357849,
-0.6433308124542236,
0.7799256443977356,
-0.41362789273262024,
0.6502385139465332,
-0.39919513463974,
-0.7160922288894653,
-0.4890393614768982,
0.6734620928764343,
-0.4734351933002472,
0.30947208404541016,
0.8485226035118103,
0.7709825038909912,
-0.05192599073052406,
-0.0983612984418869,
0.8343874216079712,
0.22950336337089539,
0.4390137791633606,
0.5376182198524475,
1.1094858646392822,
-0.282601535320282,
0.6449254155158997,
0.00039295770693570375,
-0.43756163120269775,
0.030225269496440887,
-1.010923981666565,
-0.792320966720581,
-0.32106706500053406,
-0.6999897360801697,
-0.5167629718780518,
0.1579446792602539,
0.6401362419128418,
0.6112847924232483,
-0.28783538937568665,
-0.2957518994808197,
0.43888160586357117,
-0.416157990694046,
0.12135948240756989,
-0.17922723293304443,
0.5333635807037354,
-0.2505054473876953,
-0.33005422353744507,
0.426396906375885,
0.4422997534275055,
-0.2996455132961273,
-0.41274452209472656,
-0.147477388381958,
0.25225144624710083,
-0.13072092831134796,
0.4744691252708435,
-0.1657530814409256,
-0.5246855616569519,
-0.24014082551002502,
-0.2513524293899536,
-0.30376866459846497,
0.3332393765449524,
0.6015884876251221,
-0.6896644830703735,
0.39948686957359314,
0.23824171721935272,
0.46295565366744995,
0.6403815150260925,
-0.18122616410255432,
0.6210452914237976,
-0.35282382369041443,
0.021134182810783386,
0.3134498596191406,
0.29727602005004883,
0.5143339037895203,
-0.37995392084121704,
0.642155110836029,
-0.13816837966442108,
-0.6694275140762329,
-0.8138266205787659,
0.16479112207889557,
-0.8868452906608582,
-0.2382061779499054,
1.2323309183120728,
-0.4009658396244049,
0.02859942987561226,
-0.06295175850391388,
0.020572178065776825,
-0.17609447240829468,
-0.15889745950698853,
0.6655769944190979,
0.32504698634147644,
-0.33023297786712646,
-0.05468028038740158,
-0.5156537890434265,
0.49332937598228455,
0.14142000675201416,
-0.7438738346099854,
0.03975564241409302,
0.638213574886322,
0.6925299167633057,
-0.02887328714132309,
1.0040204524993896,
-0.7335416078567505,
0.41366538405418396,
0.054026100784540176,
0.22506164014339447,
-0.3321700096130371,
-0.14236833155155182,
-0.5235851407051086,
0.1819988638162613,
0.7228451371192932,
0.14931337535381317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00990v1
|
Exploring the Nexus of Large Language Models and Legal Systems: A Short Survey
| 2024-04-01T08:35:56 | 2024-04-01T08:35:56 |
Weicong Qin, Zhongxiang Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Large Language
Models (LLMs), there is a profound transformation occurring in the realm of
natural language processing tasks within the legal domain. The capabilities of
LLMs are increasingly demonstrating unique roles in the legal sector, bringing
both distinctive benefits and various challenges. This survey delves into the
synergy between LLMs and the legal system, such as their applications in tasks
like legal text comprehension, case retrieval, and analysis. Furthermore, this
survey highlights key challenges faced by LLMs in the legal domain, including
bias, interpretability, and ethical considerations, as well as how researchers
are addressing these issues. The survey showcases the latest advancements in
fine-tuned legal LLMs tailored for various legal systems, along with legal
datasets available for fine-tuning LLMs in various languages. Additionally, it
proposes directions for future research and development.
|
[
-0.2338036447763443,
-0.7927656173706055,
0.8582053184509277,
-0.190864697098732,
-0.17294621467590332,
0.20699135959148407,
-0.4411559998989105,
-0.7174296379089355,
0.21983326971530914,
0.8595388531684875,
-0.43938055634498596,
-0.27783188223838806,
-0.7960585951805115,
0.1468474268913269,
-0.6584651470184326,
0.7604416608810425,
0.17996574938297272,
0.4729616940021515,
-0.37703198194503784,
-0.47223272919654846,
-0.587508499622345,
-0.7726790308952332,
-0.6405567526817322,
-0.3969716429710388,
0.38773730397224426,
0.07547010481357574,
0.7187812924385071,
0.3324234187602997,
0.624788224697113,
0.37561482191085815,
-0.2827039957046509,
-0.10467688739299774,
-0.29444393515586853,
0.22032606601715088,
-0.30633237957954407,
-0.676216185092926,
-0.44052937626838684,
-0.0901370495557785,
0.6309113502502441,
0.6644163131713867,
-0.23908312618732452,
0.1613350659608841,
-0.3079516589641571,
0.6447405219078064,
-0.5774737000465393,
0.03314846009016037,
-0.6270744204521179,
0.055326834321022034,
-0.4934101998806,
-0.1015637069940567,
-0.19621410965919495,
-0.1881411224603653,
0.09785965085029602,
-0.28591620922088623,
-0.03673689067363739,
0.5436902642250061,
0.4251224100589752,
0.5163905024528503,
-0.6906935572624207,
-0.5169347524642944,
-0.758499801158905,
0.7348662614822388,
-0.8036246299743652,
0.4702812731266022,
0.1244744136929512,
0.3986876308917999,
-0.2836143672466278,
-0.8116499781608582,
-0.7305508852005005,
-0.4453204572200775,
-0.002067448804154992,
-0.11850569397211075,
-0.27519530057907104,
0.13781847059726715,
0.18777526915073395,
0.22739127278327942,
-0.4992680251598358,
0.8513677716255188,
-0.24351999163627625,
-0.31331729888916016,
0.9708340167999268,
0.5017465949058533,
0.6229982376098633,
0.0035530903842300177,
0.38745009899139404,
0.11087284982204437,
-0.9011878371238708,
-0.0276960376650095,
0.4227825403213501,
0.3119758069515228,
0.010227605700492859,
0.8626453876495361,
0.05463085323572159,
0.8412578105926514,
-0.4268210828304291,
-0.11881411075592041,
-0.0581740103662014,
-0.4354002773761749,
-0.3757202625274658,
0.18788406252861023,
1.0691081285476685,
0.13875119388103485,
0.13870424032211304,
0.09934385120868683,
-0.4051804542541504,
-0.32644373178482056,
-0.023841602727770805,
-0.5416240692138672,
0.28426530957221985,
0.20808711647987366,
-0.6457436680793762,
0.007360246963799,
-0.059533894062042236,
-0.6004137396812439,
-0.8482627272605896,
-0.6567660570144653,
-0.03419651463627815,
0.007542036939412355,
-0.10693912953138351,
0.37245941162109375,
-0.03359300270676613,
0.3766880929470062,
0.3014228940010071,
-0.7609754204750061,
0.40689361095428467,
0.9097984433174133,
0.5278132557868958,
0.19689054787158966,
0.0793655514717102,
-0.598154604434967,
0.07418427616357803,
-0.30439814925193787,
0.4313293993473053,
-0.587460458278656,
-0.32256269454956055,
0.34339889883995056,
-0.009353052824735641,
0.06426437199115753,
-0.7478331923484802,
0.6284332871437073,
-0.6975821256637573,
-0.11081422120332718,
-0.17035318911075592,
-0.5886869430541992,
0.04953991621732712,
0.4714859127998352,
-0.7870372533798218,
0.568891704082489,
-0.10303398966789246,
-0.4675990641117096,
0.3539268970489502,
-0.833795428276062,
-0.6112266182899475,
0.360310822725296,
-0.5495370626449585,
-0.4461787939071655,
0.1938709020614624,
-0.005075610242784023,
0.5107517838478088,
-0.8261551260948181,
0.47389766573905945,
-0.2781125605106354,
-0.20382794737815857,
0.2826177179813385,
-0.11762593686580658,
0.9303314089775085,
0.342644602060318,
-0.12759652733802795,
0.3548799157142639,
-0.6419671177864075,
-0.22698858380317688,
0.3427717387676239,
-0.29014715552330017,
-0.3398929834365845,
0.40543848276138306,
-0.08758942782878876,
0.22763589024543762,
0.47066596150398254,
-0.4771617352962494,
0.2818281650543213,
-0.24424993991851807,
0.8127776980400085,
0.5169378519058228,
-0.17240722477436066,
0.4676509201526642,
-0.20359200239181519,
0.6202226877212524,
-0.2292569875717163,
-0.08937608450651169,
0.2713855803012848,
-0.4710409939289093,
-0.6103163361549377,
0.025178546085953712,
0.43441295623779297,
0.6032354831695557,
-0.4669300317764282,
0.39117422699928284,
-0.5359372496604919,
-0.30865713953971863,
-0.753123939037323,
0.26761284470558167,
0.022431213408708572,
-0.12471811473369598,
0.12003006786108017,
0.19133228063583374,
-0.5250579714775085,
-1.0010935068130493,
-0.47989022731781006,
-0.3166452944278717,
0.0529036782681942,
0.6224513053894043,
0.5737761855125427,
-0.4424152970314026,
0.9484506249427795,
-0.04795829579234123,
-0.3698800504207611,
-0.5830354690551758,
-0.05812791362404823,
0.277719646692276,
0.11169642210006714,
0.624436616897583,
-1.0541353225708008,
-0.39683014154434204,
0.2827526330947876,
-0.627358615398407,
-0.22188985347747803,
-0.015077914111316204,
0.29968300461769104,
-0.001034880056977272,
0.8802198171615601,
-0.7883482575416565,
0.1721920520067215,
0.12774838507175446,
-0.5728451609611511,
0.6293182969093323,
-0.2238086462020874,
0.1132102757692337,
-0.8102882504463196,
-0.0305433738976717,
-0.10384317487478256,
-0.2208336740732193,
-0.7110393643379211,
0.34484705328941345,
-0.07856933027505875,
0.14094778895378113,
-0.4881628453731537,
0.6291921734809875,
-0.6694297194480896,
-0.32104119658470154,
-0.41429880261421204,
0.0719786211848259,
-0.3713538646697998,
-0.15743687748908997,
-0.35908445715904236,
0.7600390315055847,
0.5428687930107117,
-0.5065473318099976,
0.7094433307647705,
0.23344163596630096,
-0.3684169352054596,
0.6006859540939331,
-0.5417081117630005,
-0.023044632747769356,
-0.21449832618236542,
0.06626507639884949,
-0.2938288748264313,
-0.4914223253726959,
0.24876944720745087,
-0.026590287685394287,
0.22416625916957855,
-0.09949897229671478,
-1.0791263580322266,
-0.5820658802986145,
-0.056548453867435455,
0.5529838800430298,
0.5971163511276245,
-0.058046773076057434,
0.8389981389045715,
0.7527424097061157,
-0.38423478603363037,
-0.46313807368278503,
-0.7542737126350403,
0.5380780100822449,
-0.33844679594039917,
-0.49979737401008606,
0.1367298811674118,
0.06703875958919525,
-0.9071271419525146,
0.08721240609884262,
0.3692324161529541,
0.02298162318766117,
0.19186019897460938,
0.16762204468250275,
-0.03211311995983124,
-0.30085837841033936,
0.13043737411499023,
0.06465143710374832,
0.4308781623840332,
0.5335462093353271,
-0.1405748426914215,
0.5654711127281189,
-0.030491523444652557,
-0.4646971821784973,
-0.3257807195186615,
0.30043962597846985,
0.7943571209907532,
-0.336422860622406,
0.6519062519073486,
0.09785166382789612,
-0.3529552221298218,
-0.18325860798358917,
-0.6198604106903076,
0.11256718635559082,
-0.4244252145290375,
0.365291953086853,
-0.2615561783313751,
-1.421602725982666,
0.6145029067993164,
-0.013992124237120152,
0.051616329699754715,
0.6805729269981384,
0.8867078423500061,
0.18551500141620636,
0.8191745281219482,
0.7795798778533936,
-0.5329452753067017,
0.3903075158596039,
0.07132802903652191,
0.5624910593032837,
-0.5726975798606873,
-0.2828659117221832,
-0.7424159646034241,
-0.1963043212890625,
-0.6723204851150513,
-0.12892690300941467,
0.35464805364608765,
-0.20300649106502533,
-0.05932972952723503,
0.18102651834487915,
-0.1477961540222168,
0.42056509852409363,
0.5864840745925903,
-0.23935335874557495,
0.3986903429031372,
-0.44071197509765625,
-0.08415784686803818,
0.3244815170764923,
-0.6575995087623596,
-0.5864977836608887,
0.9428659081459045,
0.3250598609447479,
0.5726091861724854,
0.2585810720920563,
0.5974101424217224,
0.4052077531814575,
-0.11714658886194229,
-0.8921462297439575,
0.8605908155441284,
-0.25322049856185913,
-0.7124788165092468,
-0.4290824830532074,
-0.4272095263004303,
-1.0519094467163086,
0.17147482931613922,
-0.3663671314716339,
-0.7138711214065552,
-0.10183971375226974,
-0.25222963094711304,
-0.5425204038619995,
0.4228183627128601,
-0.3217199146747589,
0.5298175811767578,
-0.4023747742176056,
-0.3988872468471527,
-0.4009164571762085,
-0.7437949180603027,
0.332248330116272,
-0.27085214853286743,
0.35071277618408203,
-0.2821027934551239,
0.10014691948890686,
0.8040335178375244,
-0.5684522390365601,
0.5224530100822449,
0.09380484372377396,
-0.3159986734390259,
0.5623046159744263,
-0.09022001177072525,
0.512892484664917,
0.08252931386232376,
-0.12779968976974487,
-0.08652061969041824,
0.19832539558410645,
-0.19760453701019287,
-0.4080115258693695,
0.7318562865257263,
-0.5380035042762756,
-0.8149057030677795,
-0.47323188185691833,
-0.9212013483047485,
-0.22543089091777802,
0.38934075832366943,
-0.11357543617486954,
-0.07769136130809784,
-0.1976824551820755,
0.12490139156579971,
0.4041914939880371,
-0.2169347107410431,
0.5472936034202576,
0.6614668369293213,
-0.15339837968349457,
0.039729043841362,
0.7683907747268677,
0.11393534392118454,
-0.21616105735301971,
0.17288993299007416,
0.11798027902841568,
-0.46495842933654785,
-0.977741539478302,
-0.1863529533147812,
0.35719484090805054,
-0.5517426133155823,
-0.06574651598930359,
-0.5139216184616089,
-0.3745540380477905,
-0.5932530760765076,
-0.03057745471596718,
-0.13595455884933472,
-0.1372768133878708,
-0.4530474543571472,
0.14295253157615662,
0.21941626071929932,
1.1174386739730835,
0.3469603955745697,
0.11716268211603165,
-0.8262789249420166,
0.2570914924144745,
0.27776581048965454,
0.4276673495769501,
-0.27767032384872437,
-0.4008829593658447,
0.015995696187019348,
-0.020493024960160255,
0.11717630922794342,
-0.46805351972579956,
0.26635321974754333,
-0.08286408334970474,
0.6157291531562805,
0.22403359413146973,
-0.09433092176914215,
0.4966200590133667,
-0.8636819124221802,
0.8965920805931091,
0.06824696063995361,
-0.6859284043312073,
0.3064690828323364,
-0.4035075604915619,
0.016422787681221962,
0.5543149709701538,
0.162825807929039,
-0.5267395377159119,
-0.4375896155834198,
-0.29476913809776306,
-0.6512750387191772,
0.5518648028373718,
0.15661922097206116,
0.26391729712486267,
0.43177327513694763,
0.45002734661102295,
-0.08623506873846054,
0.2523234188556671,
-0.6022295355796814,
0.15125229954719543,
0.5602673888206482,
-0.29125458002090454,
-0.05313672870397568,
-0.1541159600019455,
-0.0821276530623436,
-0.35081785917282104,
0.5118725299835205,
0.011304528452455997,
-0.0030483726877719164,
-0.19450101256370544,
-0.28823280334472656,
0.00753176212310791,
0.5456429123878479,
0.6671713590621948,
0.6473119854927063,
0.14800700545310974,
-0.06636037677526474,
0.18276084959506989,
-0.212599977850914,
0.19148336350917816,
0.11335662752389908,
-0.11482103168964386,
-0.09261687099933624,
0.4600864350795746,
0.7154207229614258,
-0.10908102989196777,
-1.0385080575942993,
0.513328492641449,
-0.05875664949417114,
-0.4592697322368622,
-0.4215506315231323,
0.057680532336235046,
0.1755996197462082,
0.5645337104797363,
0.39652228355407715,
-0.32402902841567993,
0.301093727350235,
-0.6636507511138916,
-0.12511874735355377,
0.7371757626533508,
-0.18003542721271515,
-0.07288637012243271,
0.762695848941803,
0.10858461260795593,
-0.48716872930526733,
0.4437476396560669,
-0.06150694936513901,
-0.3587818741798401,
0.621155321598053,
0.2885076403617859,
0.7097213864326477,
0.3438965976238251,
-0.24879586696624756,
-0.1779140830039978,
0.24995797872543335,
-0.3615604341030121,
0.15379615128040314,
0.10668662935495377,
-0.5641731023788452,
-0.37121763825416565,
-0.6626145839691162,
-0.42686256766319275,
0.28367143869400024,
-0.3880337178707123,
0.2975943982601166,
-0.3697222173213959,
-0.16716255247592926,
0.0562131330370903,
0.0702781230211258,
-0.6336709856987,
-0.036281827837228775,
0.3716738224029541,
0.8435277938842773,
-0.46369442343711853,
0.8496411442756653,
0.7789698243141174,
-0.24276556074619293,
-0.327802449464798,
-0.19691680371761322,
0.1681385487318039,
-0.6500738263130188,
0.5034365057945251,
-0.057694897055625916,
-0.15049120783805847,
-0.07288134098052979,
-0.7333329319953918,
-0.3555698096752167,
0.9789087176322937,
0.4401315450668335,
-0.9091981053352356,
-0.22365324199199677,
0.7666290402412415,
0.8236297369003296,
-0.32389822602272034,
-0.07392120361328125,
1.1307448148727417,
0.4982212483882904,
-0.29237809777259827,
-1.0501943826675415,
-0.005127319600433111,
-0.24137258529663086,
0.031241102144122124,
0.38680213689804077,
-0.535243034362793,
0.713437020778656,
-0.027062809094786644,
-0.17228740453720093,
0.26660582423210144,
0.5381648540496826,
0.14806151390075684,
0.3500615656375885,
0.3645995259284973,
0.6341613531112671,
0.6635046601295471,
-0.15777797996997833,
1.059238314628601,
-0.4421808421611786,
0.1604420244693756,
0.9492958188056946,
-0.6855238080024719,
0.6173327565193176,
0.6881484985351562,
-0.26927438378334045,
0.29994553327560425,
0.4683450162410736,
-0.2395971268415451,
-0.07371395081281662,
0.5639877915382385,
-0.33434340357780457,
-0.2753998339176178,
-0.3556452989578247,
-0.09467139840126038,
0.410093754529953,
0.43758082389831543,
-0.31066712737083435,
-0.15909869968891144,
0.05582898110151291,
-0.24187421798706055,
0.2865946590900421,
-0.6209555268287659,
0.8842557668685913,
0.15918120741844177,
-0.5626517534255981,
-0.132546529173851,
0.2957225441932678,
0.7422999143600464,
-0.4279765188694,
0.05299528315663338,
-0.0212858933955431,
-0.021408798173069954,
-0.13500113785266876,
-1.052893042564392,
0.204335018992424,
0.1423036754131317,
-0.01405610702931881,
-0.24828505516052246,
0.7481772303581238,
-0.23691147565841675,
-0.38974297046661377,
0.44755804538726807,
0.6146953105926514,
0.1253156065940857,
0.07513744384050369,
-0.7567057609558105,
0.19078266620635986,
-0.48242950439453125,
-0.024596966803073883,
0.34430205821990967,
0.5790791511535645,
-0.3545680344104767,
0.9094277620315552,
0.4646078646183014,
0.3319758474826813,
0.3997451961040497,
0.2652877867221832,
0.7697394490242004,
-0.933813750743866,
-0.4226313829421997,
-0.9939050078392029,
0.24768614768981934,
-0.08598103374242783,
-0.13801927864551544,
0.4948592185974121,
0.5221954584121704,
0.6956506371498108,
0.031116439029574394,
0.7432655096054077,
-0.22422511875629425,
0.4237730801105499,
-0.6916372776031494,
0.9577196836471558,
-0.5488972067832947,
0.3119519054889679,
0.057662852108478546,
-0.7620999813079834,
-0.41694125533103943,
0.01963893696665764,
-0.38177305459976196,
-0.1668110340833664,
0.3884069323539734,
0.6644720435142517,
-0.09741219133138657,
-0.24036334455013275,
0.5217968821525574,
0.04617059975862503,
0.3770027160644531,
0.4429696500301361,
0.8964282870292664,
-0.2841029465198517,
0.2943315804004669,
0.32052817940711975,
0.3874652087688446,
-0.4588223397731781,
-0.5330604910850525,
-0.887217104434967,
-0.373104989528656,
-0.0074487728998064995,
0.010193070396780968,
-0.05383089557290077,
0.8587360382080078,
0.3863493502140045,
-0.9129235744476318,
-0.506472110748291,
-0.17289315164089203,
0.10855209827423096,
0.5072877407073975,
-0.13533423840999603,
-0.08520011603832245,
-0.39278894662857056,
-0.8710283637046814,
0.4622154235839844,
0.2710680365562439,
0.13126233220100403,
-0.24737916886806488,
-0.2679755687713623,
-0.38069120049476624,
0.2504851818084717,
0.7111481428146362,
0.4805058240890503,
-0.980114758014679,
-0.22595004737377167,
-0.2570514976978302,
-0.34881889820098877,
-0.03859686106443405,
1.159143328666687,
-0.3303154706954956,
0.21040357649326324,
0.5737928152084351,
1.035575270652771,
0.15585291385650635,
-0.3341037333011627,
0.6373891830444336,
-0.27148234844207764,
0.220064178109169,
0.49641576409339905,
0.8235584497451782,
0.1325606107711792,
-0.3013093173503876,
0.45149701833724976,
-0.016296204179525375,
-0.6880861520767212,
-0.903822660446167,
0.23635907471179962,
-0.8613682389259338,
-0.4986564517021179,
1.1035195589065552,
0.26162397861480713,
-0.16125212609767914,
-0.19041849672794342,
-0.10898518562316895,
0.12163418531417847,
0.014833396300673485,
0.4006791114807129,
0.9092700481414795,
-0.1363660842180252,
-0.06329980492591858,
-0.7460787296295166,
0.41686657071113586,
0.4228345453739166,
-0.8383113145828247,
-0.11835630983114243,
0.6779571771621704,
0.24311017990112305,
0.09907205402851105,
0.5244816541671753,
-0.14455771446228027,
0.09197400510311127,
-0.36581408977508545,
-0.1190769150853157,
0.03907787427306175,
-0.22827184200286865,
-0.7185978889465332,
0.136398583650589,
0.2762869596481323,
0.37952721118927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00978v1
|
Prior Constraints-based Reward Model Training for Aligning Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T07:49:11 | 2024-04-01T07:49:11 |
Hang Zhou, Chenglong Wang, Yimin Hu, Tong Xiao, Chunliang Zhang, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning with human feedback for aligning large language models
(LLMs) trains a reward model typically using ranking loss with comparison
pairs.However, the training procedure suffers from an inherent problem: the
uncontrolled scaling of reward scores during reinforcement learning due to the
lack of constraints while training the reward model.This paper proposes a Prior
Constraints-based Reward Model (namely PCRM) training method to mitigate this
problem. PCRM incorporates prior constraints, specifically, length ratio and
cosine similarity between outputs of each comparison pair, during reward model
training to regulate optimization magnitude and control score margins. We
comprehensively evaluate PCRM by examining its rank correlation with human
preferences and its effectiveness in aligning LLMs via RL. Experimental results
demonstrate that PCRM significantly improves alignment performance by
effectively constraining reward score scaling. As another bonus, our method is
easily integrated into arbitrary rank-based alignment methods, such as direct
preference optimization, and can yield consistent improvement.
|
[
-0.15076559782028198,
-0.2335076779127121,
0.6218129396438599,
0.00415722094476223,
-0.2403663843870163,
-0.011460314504802227,
-0.6461180448532104,
0.0913182869553566,
-0.06070098280906677,
0.6386426687240601,
-0.6874492168426514,
-0.258800208568573,
-0.45337748527526855,
-0.09465386718511581,
0.45956459641456604,
1.0322149991989136,
-0.2819378674030304,
0.1288207620382309,
-0.6330546736717224,
-0.012277661822736263,
-0.6643607020378113,
-1.043028712272644,
-0.536670982837677,
-0.6127451658248901,
0.71467125415802,
0.41105037927627563,
0.504952609539032,
0.8218321204185486,
0.882308840751648,
0.2128162980079651,
0.019766053184866905,
0.38536539673805237,
-0.8537356853485107,
0.03203641623258591,
-0.33633503317832947,
-0.37813881039619446,
-0.3390192687511444,
0.2372475415468216,
0.5843014121055603,
0.5452080965042114,
-0.4676628112792969,
-0.06326071172952652,
0.18785537779331207,
0.5493518114089966,
-0.832617998123169,
0.02083486132323742,
-0.46500498056411743,
0.1263715922832489,
-0.037226852029561996,
-0.5455718040466309,
-0.5827880501747131,
-0.6217512488365173,
0.013474836014211178,
-0.5886204242706299,
-0.12304748594760895,
0.1221507117152214,
0.8883518576622009,
0.7047014236450195,
-0.4700917601585388,
0.05869261547923088,
-0.6608836054801941,
1.0568172931671143,
-0.7140820622444153,
0.2939261198043823,
0.3436020612716675,
0.24698324501514435,
-0.29790741205215454,
-0.15387988090515137,
-0.4156450927257538,
-0.34832245111465454,
-0.17273396253585815,
-0.08525615930557251,
0.4241572916507721,
0.03139785677194595,
0.14447210729122162,
0.3383471965789795,
-0.6101284027099609,
0.38492074608802795,
-0.02545505203306675,
-0.1990671306848526,
0.5824690461158752,
0.344785213470459,
-0.153805211186409,
0.0631197914481163,
-0.7186593413352966,
-0.6474416255950928,
-0.7993711233139038,
0.3910404443740845,
0.30112892389297485,
0.6870551109313965,
-0.056393858045339584,
0.5212597846984863,
-0.029514802619814873,
0.7629562616348267,
0.36614611744880676,
-0.35615187883377075,
0.19099873304367065,
-0.05309725180268288,
-0.028315389528870583,
0.32464414834976196,
0.7083806991577148,
0.5081409811973572,
0.17848561704158783,
-0.05884547904133797,
-0.1525089591741562,
0.21506276726722717,
0.3605085015296936,
-0.7987040281295776,
-0.02646963857114315,
-0.1670534759759903,
-0.3076145350933075,
-0.21471311151981354,
0.3165653645992279,
-0.22195661067962646,
-0.47022998332977295,
-0.6605618000030518,
0.37177592515945435,
-0.09533108025789261,
-0.14839287102222443,
0.18150289356708527,
-0.040117960423231125,
0.4025610387325287,
0.2991328537464142,
-1.1161701679229736,
0.39540040493011475,
0.9597823619842529,
0.7169708013534546,
-0.41340339183807373,
-0.3003631830215454,
-0.9202565550804138,
0.2882266342639923,
-0.08996780216693878,
0.5452389121055603,
-0.6538344621658325,
-0.33062484860420227,
-0.17157776653766632,
-0.03407813981175423,
-0.1953548938035965,
-0.6252418160438538,
0.5157918930053711,
-0.5026360750198364,
0.1551356315612793,
-0.3593667149543762,
-0.779807984828949,
0.2123401165008545,
0.42995524406433105,
-0.3288637399673462,
0.9005600810050964,
0.1272624284029007,
-0.7864499092102051,
0.26192110776901245,
-0.22123350203037262,
-0.26756736636161804,
-0.08719352632761002,
-0.3517933785915375,
-0.5060412883758545,
0.056211259216070175,
0.20354074239730835,
0.21716812252998352,
-0.19658362865447998,
0.3324487507343292,
-0.4386760890483856,
-0.37181538343429565,
0.26935631036758423,
-0.07181616127490997,
0.4124666154384613,
0.15521398186683655,
-0.21091413497924805,
0.42935267090797424,
-0.31073182821273804,
0.32273250818252563,
-0.09406104683876038,
-0.4588630199432373,
-0.41998985409736633,
0.03618379682302475,
-0.21254421770572662,
0.2817046642303467,
0.5385951995849609,
-0.27591148018836975,
0.5714823007583618,
-0.2282947301864624,
0.31904616951942444,
1.060088872909546,
-0.10289984196424484,
0.5199939608573914,
-0.40225911140441895,
0.6268871426582336,
-0.30721205472946167,
0.2569717764854431,
0.3685145378112793,
0.18729811906814575,
-0.3958466351032257,
-0.22733242809772491,
0.47362664341926575,
0.6395442485809326,
-0.14136390388011932,
0.8594158887863159,
-0.39963313937187195,
-0.29918575286865234,
-0.30862000584602356,
0.1077282577753067,
0.4407859742641449,
0.5717645883560181,
0.3828077018260956,
-0.6083073616027832,
-0.5567463636398315,
-0.8052285313606262,
-0.08709699660539627,
-0.13174022734165192,
-0.1714901328086853,
0.4086426794528961,
0.21861183643341064,
0.02902691625058651,
1.0398472547531128,
-0.5964746475219727,
-0.3911634087562561,
-0.11617477238178253,
0.1649879664182663,
0.17991231381893158,
0.8806084990501404,
0.04117504134774208,
-0.6916691660881042,
-0.4084245264530182,
0.11419134587049484,
-0.23184004426002502,
-0.11189106851816177,
-0.12080370634794235,
-0.15165215730667114,
0.019898701459169388,
0.62181556224823,
-0.22375236451625824,
0.16905629634857178,
0.6664472222328186,
-0.13937486708164215,
0.4560092091560364,
-0.4683217704296112,
0.15618962049484253,
-0.653082013130188,
0.10963957011699677,
-0.016210801899433136,
-0.3588353097438812,
-0.16096404194831848,
-0.19028274714946747,
0.2804747223854065,
-0.0012763384729623795,
-0.2054785043001175,
0.4361668825149536,
-0.24155199527740479,
0.04521125927567482,
-0.299065500497818,
-0.074863962829113,
-0.15303517878055573,
0.767901599407196,
0.5366796851158142,
0.5126248598098755,
-0.002426362596452236,
-0.517052173614502,
0.149616077542305,
0.27215468883514404,
-0.26894062757492065,
0.6970084309577942,
-0.5362644195556641,
0.33765357732772827,
0.12072020024061203,
0.25531819462776184,
-0.7679572105407715,
0.11637524515390396,
0.07094642519950867,
-0.23372651636600494,
0.4423883855342865,
-0.153043732047081,
-0.25918927788734436,
-0.23682774603366852,
-0.33460503816604614,
0.4987277686595917,
0.3794877827167511,
-0.5414614081382751,
0.020334335044026375,
0.15459924936294556,
-0.18134014308452606,
-0.5632755160331726,
-0.34819716215133667,
-0.369074285030365,
-0.3207949995994568,
-0.19552628695964813,
0.8157546520233154,
-0.3085844814777374,
-0.040504977107048035,
-0.16751645505428314,
-0.29352349042892456,
0.09360137581825256,
-0.04338987171649933,
0.21577222645282745,
0.2972375154495239,
-0.04279274865984917,
-0.003873454872518778,
-0.14007510244846344,
-0.13835540413856506,
-0.14828382432460785,
-0.19137907028198242,
0.779009997844696,
-0.057170599699020386,
-0.3011985719203949,
-0.4376744329929352,
0.14280936121940613,
0.3234896659851074,
-0.4445880651473999,
0.7005602717399597,
0.17396803200244904,
0.11240126937627792,
0.06305424124002457,
-0.6020867228507996,
-0.3829444944858551,
-0.4621850550174713,
0.42083510756492615,
-0.22607646882534027,
-1.1984590291976929,
0.16962012648582458,
-0.24319729208946228,
-0.314940869808197,
0.1603788137435913,
0.4872330129146576,
0.1439288705587387,
1.2074376344680786,
0.8929269909858704,
-0.30569353699684143,
0.642382025718689,
0.24957813322544098,
-0.054154254496097565,
-1.0255036354064941,
-0.26519545912742615,
-0.5888793468475342,
-0.5168225169181824,
-0.5291751027107239,
-0.4850832521915436,
0.28723785281181335,
0.22403459250926971,
-0.7053973078727722,
0.16236263513565063,
-0.4560071527957916,
0.6143884062767029,
0.7021729946136475,
0.2665514647960663,
-0.06182708591222763,
-0.20474767684936523,
-0.3623359203338623,
-0.28326544165611267,
-0.6003337502479553,
-0.2906401455402374,
1.0407180786132812,
0.225607231259346,
0.9175372123718262,
-0.006055060308426619,
0.7040920257568359,
0.07947850972414017,
0.321247398853302,
-0.5409151911735535,
0.09035326540470123,
-0.05883944779634476,
-0.23446977138519287,
-0.604293704032898,
-0.7868961095809937,
-0.6885364055633545,
0.22401314973831177,
-0.06631454825401306,
-0.7621580362319946,
0.17459692060947418,
0.3271768093109131,
-0.4785650670528412,
0.09393543750047684,
-0.3920906186103821,
1.1520403623580933,
-0.8278865814208984,
-0.5540158748626709,
-0.22078917920589447,
-0.9005792737007141,
0.07144618034362793,
0.23074878752231598,
0.03400229662656784,
0.021782882511615753,
0.0028228748124092817,
0.5813549757003784,
-0.7964794635772705,
0.6831496357917786,
-0.1857198029756546,
0.01111769862473011,
-0.35355275869369507,
-0.1157500222325325,
0.7926278114318848,
-0.027470232918858528,
0.09928619116544724,
-0.3847000002861023,
-0.12426458299160004,
-0.49359360337257385,
-0.6584035158157349,
0.7460910677909851,
-0.9162617325782776,
-0.7194855213165283,
-0.5114333033561707,
-0.7376202344894409,
-0.4075912535190582,
0.09692166745662689,
0.07879427820444107,
0.02426820993423462,
-0.15259864926338196,
0.1932678073644638,
0.7781885266304016,
-0.2758789360523224,
0.058123715221881866,
0.5068398714065552,
-0.04235825687646866,
-0.6259815692901611,
0.7228850722312927,
-0.3916749954223633,
0.3248767554759979,
0.8962281942367554,
0.42305105924606323,
-0.5124363899230957,
-0.3213500380516052,
0.03558078408241272,
0.3037787079811096,
-0.2404649406671524,
-0.3312014043331146,
0.03470860421657562,
-0.07333309203386307,
-0.46837589144706726,
-0.33490657806396484,
-0.4175899624824524,
-0.21678145229816437,
-0.09664924442768097,
0.15835510194301605,
0.16665153205394745,
0.43413349986076355,
-0.05680282413959503,
0.44119009375572205,
-0.3383527398109436,
-0.08894144743680954,
0.43175721168518066,
0.654252827167511,
-0.12278802692890167,
-0.6246596574783325,
-0.27393296360969543,
-0.07603880763053894,
-0.3748246729373932,
-0.5803833603858948,
0.39624354243278503,
-0.1006336361169815,
0.6209543347358704,
0.525052547454834,
0.2141096442937851,
0.7166469097137451,
-0.5095688104629517,
0.4678170680999756,
0.3696247935295105,
-0.8540258407592773,
0.4699256122112274,
-0.21740415692329407,
0.4978579878807068,
0.7732213139533997,
0.4648883044719696,
-0.6381052732467651,
-0.1385394185781479,
-0.3312794268131256,
-0.6807665824890137,
0.6750919222831726,
-0.2237064689397812,
-0.15846335887908936,
0.17320051789283752,
0.4492422640323639,
0.012689332477748394,
0.3643331527709961,
-0.9568714499473572,
-0.10006146132946014,
-0.17212456464767456,
-0.19566872715950012,
-0.5492681860923767,
-0.2496900111436844,
-0.0719546526670456,
-0.4207935035228729,
0.8141939640045166,
-0.026107393205165863,
-0.1953955888748169,
0.16472342610359192,
-0.2677645981311798,
-0.2567860782146454,
0.25773271918296814,
0.9435890316963196,
0.5614827871322632,
-0.6975026726722717,
0.08875225484371185,
-0.0896773710846901,
-0.012935561127960682,
0.3542577028274536,
0.0129713648930192,
0.22377121448516846,
-0.5724468231201172,
0.041468266397714615,
0.907909095287323,
0.2509755492210388,
-0.6395822167396545,
0.5248294472694397,
-0.1287030428647995,
-0.2570347487926483,
-0.10062765330076218,
0.0073417797684669495,
0.05134144797921181,
0.17959891259670258,
0.058306530117988586,
-0.17808368802070618,
-0.4029161036014557,
-0.24176090955734253,
0.08382517844438553,
0.7007260918617249,
-0.7603920102119446,
0.08571641892194748,
0.6011302471160889,
-0.013408671133220196,
-0.17768925428390503,
0.8426055908203125,
-0.06402142345905304,
-0.7901728749275208,
0.4315580129623413,
0.6341100931167603,
0.37469229102134705,
-0.6264440417289734,
0.13352034986019135,
0.3884550929069519,
0.3193770945072174,
-0.33763647079467773,
0.0219250675290823,
-0.240956649184227,
-0.6447699666023254,
-0.6762174367904663,
-0.5773866772651672,
-0.594054102897644,
0.14978013932704926,
-0.8484514951705933,
0.40216711163520813,
-0.5223639607429504,
0.034970901906490326,
-0.24211516976356506,
0.1295761615037918,
-0.4659003019332886,
0.002243894850835204,
0.23495805263519287,
0.49819228053092957,
-0.7666492462158203,
0.9326426982879639,
0.621593177318573,
-0.3485832214355469,
-1.0636719465255737,
-0.2538774907588959,
0.047263141721487045,
-0.5395400524139404,
0.7984253168106079,
0.10984109342098236,
-0.06843326985836029,
-0.06525079905986786,
-0.32266321778297424,
-0.9369652271270752,
0.8776214122772217,
0.5782298445701599,
-0.7573003172874451,
0.011179394088685513,
0.20942622423171997,
0.5200411677360535,
-0.5528335571289062,
0.188664048910141,
0.36973685026168823,
0.5000715851783752,
0.14289242029190063,
-1.011716604232788,
0.11987065523862839,
-0.10271139442920685,
0.026649923995137215,
0.6467564702033997,
-0.6652474403381348,
0.9261019825935364,
0.008104189299046993,
0.16855138540267944,
0.14233723282814026,
0.43526431918144226,
0.4134499728679657,
-0.18555103242397308,
0.6270865797996521,
0.8421720266342163,
0.8995274305343628,
0.13162457942962646,
0.8942198157310486,
0.07497062534093857,
0.5506637096405029,
1.481101393699646,
-0.65088951587677,
1.000219464302063,
0.6881651878356934,
-0.1872463822364807,
0.637162983417511,
0.8744734525680542,
-0.04213540628552437,
0.8807397484779358,
0.8011879920959473,
0.08339603990316391,
-0.579333484172821,
-0.13931068778038025,
-0.6214872598648071,
0.30785679817199707,
0.06248113885521889,
-0.292348176240921,
-0.002576244529336691,
-0.23241879045963287,
-0.11822011321783066,
0.42230159044265747,
-0.5075511932373047,
0.7695144414901733,
-0.14493121206760406,
-0.8269301056861877,
0.7590675950050354,
-0.071012482047081,
0.7935882806777954,
-0.6422675848007202,
0.03093479387462139,
-0.28305917978286743,
0.47103962302207947,
-0.0571068674325943,
-0.038622934371232986,
-0.20654428005218506,
-0.24131788313388824,
-0.429798424243927,
-0.405205100774765,
0.18078191578388214,
-0.6214286684989929,
-0.2863079607486725,
-0.04216165468096733,
0.09674785286188126,
-0.1723805069923401,
-0.17094437777996063,
-0.4989560842514038,
0.05588415637612343,
-0.062253016978502274,
-0.03387676551938057,
0.6325815916061401,
0.1465621441602707,
-0.24297946691513062,
0.4506044387817383,
0.4090844690799713,
0.30678606033325195,
-0.2823959290981293,
-0.11109970510005951,
0.6481502056121826,
-0.6368485689163208,
-0.8110421895980835,
-0.8247902393341064,
0.11979816854000092,
-0.12389253824949265,
-0.15532532334327698,
0.4802141487598419,
0.7507423162460327,
1.0574544668197632,
-0.034641727805137634,
0.4406440258026123,
0.29884713888168335,
0.5953114628791809,
-0.569811999797821,
0.4155406355857849,
-0.4819757342338562,
0.25446832180023193,
-0.2770873010158539,
-0.907303512096405,
-0.36165496706962585,
0.6188557744026184,
-0.6621693968772888,
-0.04867574945092201,
0.802424430847168,
0.7996701002120972,
-0.023337261751294136,
-0.4462627172470093,
0.07097414880990982,
-0.19149020314216614,
0.07585322856903076,
0.9570262432098389,
0.9855242967605591,
0.23095348477363586,
0.4294760227203369,
-0.3523837625980377,
-0.2264196276664734,
-0.3213195502758026,
-1.165565013885498,
-0.8527671694755554,
-0.35493507981300354,
-0.34300702810287476,
-0.10614059120416641,
0.14038017392158508,
1.1671195030212402,
0.8091859817504883,
-0.8873632550239563,
-0.6113797426223755,
-0.04535047337412834,
0.23972003161907196,
-0.6060262322425842,
-0.1968231201171875,
0.513791561126709,
-0.43906837701797485,
-0.47090330719947815,
0.21920953691005707,
0.18014952540397644,
-0.02090967632830143,
-0.049359485507011414,
-0.629814088344574,
-0.24997343122959137,
-0.2294338196516037,
0.1410619169473648,
0.4589666724205017,
-0.7310680747032166,
-0.4657787084579468,
-0.06934001296758652,
-0.17699114978313446,
0.26369693875312805,
1.2961676120758057,
-0.7670265436172485,
0.21645675599575043,
0.197981059551239,
0.8054967522621155,
0.48229774832725525,
0.3391590416431427,
0.9541464447975159,
-1.0134556293487549,
0.3047711253166199,
0.15355220437049866,
0.2094414085149765,
0.38922056555747986,
-0.4350360929965973,
0.24830442667007446,
-0.1484609842300415,
-0.7583742141723633,
-0.9228043556213379,
0.26192063093185425,
-1.1803520917892456,
-0.2749323546886444,
0.9089130163192749,
-0.08619163185358047,
-0.10607051104307175,
0.4574548602104187,
-0.20306432247161865,
0.2193950116634369,
-0.3489059507846832,
0.8544152975082397,
0.6551307439804077,
-0.10546036064624786,
-0.24230097234249115,
0.018813444301486015,
0.7409399747848511,
0.785620927810669,
-0.6750535368919373,
0.22095979750156403,
0.5181187391281128,
0.01814449205994606,
-0.11259948462247849,
0.3887847661972046,
-0.02960979752242565,
0.2788008451461792,
-0.5866075158119202,
0.2866927981376648,
-0.09944498538970947,
-0.056341663002967834,
-0.5094550251960754,
0.1569734811782837,
0.558636486530304,
-0.056274671107530594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01353v1
|
Efficiently Distilling LLMs for Edge Applications
| 2024-04-01T07:35:15 | 2024-04-01T07:35:15 |
Achintya Kundu, Fabian Lim, Aaron Chew, Laura Wynter, Penny Chong, Rhui Dih Lee
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Supernet training of LLMs is of great interest in industrial applications as
it confers the ability to produce a palette of smaller models at constant cost,
regardless of the number of models (of different size / latency) produced. We
propose a new method called Multistage Low-rank Fine-tuning of
Super-transformers (MLFS) for parameter-efficient supernet training. We show
that it is possible to obtain high-quality encoder models that are suitable for
commercial edge applications, and that while decoder-only models are resistant
to a comparable degree of compression, decoders can be effectively sliced for a
significant reduction in training time.
|
[
-0.8010987043380737,
-0.4226010739803314,
0.17601342499256134,
-0.2607073485851288,
-0.28415241837501526,
0.0832747146487236,
0.08886110782623291,
-0.40855535864830017,
0.11936140060424805,
0.5674028992652893,
-0.9506177306175232,
-0.2681989371776581,
-0.5912853479385376,
0.2454952895641327,
-0.7089866995811462,
0.8865957260131836,
0.11580754071474075,
0.319592148065567,
-0.0033354591578245163,
-0.13132695853710175,
0.2330956608057022,
-0.6297279596328735,
-1.0199288129806519,
-0.6033861637115479,
0.5521561503410339,
0.4110605716705322,
0.7378044128417969,
0.8285762071609497,
0.8892869353294373,
0.2992728054523468,
-0.3934391736984253,
0.6726409196853638,
-0.7200223207473755,
0.17382851243019104,
-0.0970076471567154,
-0.6231452822685242,
-0.5717456340789795,
-0.0979464203119278,
0.5379915833473206,
0.624208390712738,
0.13990290462970734,
0.2849224805831909,
0.29674044251441956,
0.9616592526435852,
-0.5196148753166199,
-0.38478174805641174,
-0.7962616086006165,
0.4037383794784546,
-0.015153072774410248,
-0.4273054301738739,
-0.27796024084091187,
-0.2892347574234009,
-0.23880252242088318,
-0.37686803936958313,
0.34394755959510803,
-0.10001657158136368,
1.008413553237915,
0.5222949981689453,
-0.32724088430404663,
0.21043488383293152,
-0.8645404577255249,
0.6959958672523499,
-0.656938374042511,
0.6930841207504272,
-0.029458926990628242,
0.5949024558067322,
-0.18254008889198303,
-1.081113576889038,
-0.20099027454853058,
0.14410610496997833,
0.17784558236598969,
0.12286621332168579,
-0.006728620734065771,
0.4141310453414917,
0.3529743254184723,
0.5519439578056335,
-0.192531555891037,
0.44823381304740906,
-0.3208152651786804,
-0.13889959454536438,
0.5208899974822998,
0.4177992641925812,
-0.1137353852391243,
0.3295114040374756,
-0.3917178213596344,
0.0698937252163887,
-1.0973163843154907,
-0.023389745503664017,
0.680053174495697,
0.27655765414237976,
0.2807965576648712,
0.32346582412719727,
-0.3043125867843628,
0.6141791343688965,
0.21747010946273804,
-0.43216559290885925,
-0.06049859896302223,
-0.22131136059761047,
-0.2571023106575012,
-0.13896095752716064,
0.36346396803855896,
0.5747314095497131,
0.23383371531963348,
-0.04516053944826126,
-0.396853506565094,
-0.07880537956953049,
0.20387381315231323,
-1.2477502822875977,
-0.37087205052375793,
0.28108760714530945,
-0.6950588822364807,
-0.23254317045211792,
-0.5176140069961548,
-0.39021748304367065,
-0.3617691695690155,
-0.4121818244457245,
0.36649540066719055,
-0.16961923241615295,
-0.09749453514814377,
0.0057961707934737206,
-0.5665192604064941,
0.23155052959918976,
0.2292773425579071,
-1.074864149093628,
0.26029956340789795,
0.6084174513816833,
0.9791198968887329,
0.12042722851037979,
-0.20568932592868805,
-0.6493953466415405,
0.0409795343875885,
-0.4310314953327179,
0.7083578109741211,
-0.3769568204879761,
-0.46890589594841003,
-0.2025308907032013,
0.030044328421354294,
0.17131361365318298,
-0.8741502165794373,
0.3977277874946594,
-0.5748263597488403,
-0.7506300210952759,
-0.040602341294288635,
-0.3227806091308594,
0.02218606509268284,
0.3698510527610779,
-0.5761775374412537,
1.0745553970336914,
-0.01700238324701786,
-0.6607764363288879,
0.31209248304367065,
-0.4997828006744385,
-0.5067447423934937,
-0.134261816740036,
-0.14161866903305054,
-0.4485771954059601,
0.20534195005893707,
0.48685798048973083,
0.8724361658096313,
-0.3141615092754364,
-0.09510541707277298,
-0.29125648736953735,
-0.47142669558525085,
0.1484806090593338,
-0.7540690898895264,
0.46724769473075867,
0.3768012225627899,
-0.14768412709236145,
-0.030209440737962723,
-0.8872801661491394,
-0.24087174236774445,
-0.03495318815112114,
-0.48270726203918457,
-0.15218736231327057,
-0.07658100873231888,
-0.08699212968349457,
0.27190640568733215,
0.12346567958593369,
-0.606198251247406,
0.2492673099040985,
-0.46206018328666687,
0.8889688849449158,
0.9179933071136475,
-0.06453720480203629,
0.230842724442482,
-0.2896016240119934,
0.13477127254009247,
-0.045611146837472916,
0.5692319869995117,
0.05038498342037201,
-0.08819057792425156,
-1.2268410921096802,
-0.3423140347003937,
0.46604493260383606,
0.11911289393901825,
-0.9259259700775146,
0.25323474407196045,
-0.3077366352081299,
-0.6770371198654175,
-0.4936710298061371,
0.28811556100845337,
0.15283654630184174,
0.2866586446762085,
0.5089876651763916,
-0.009113667532801628,
-0.5005016326904297,
-1.2395726442337036,
-0.1586795449256897,
0.5610907077789307,
-0.11977536231279373,
0.14509503543376923,
0.4241032004356384,
-0.2213246375322342,
0.9288823008537292,
-0.4364944398403168,
-0.13435997068881989,
-0.5868067145347595,
0.058460548520088196,
0.46533337235450745,
0.4874047636985779,
0.4154722988605499,
-0.7108626961708069,
-0.6422662138938904,
0.004729495849460363,
-0.5905629396438599,
0.14577679336071014,
0.10893554985523224,
-0.11562484502792358,
-0.22143037617206573,
1.000425934791565,
-0.4292260408401489,
0.1855858415365219,
0.6355060935020447,
0.40293005108833313,
0.3596251606941223,
-0.2521260380744934,
-0.0639122948050499,
-1.0976942777633667,
-0.21702472865581512,
0.2818104326725006,
-0.46154314279556274,
-0.8769922852516174,
0.11683276295661926,
-0.026558998972177505,
-0.20519256591796875,
-0.9634341597557068,
0.02367904968559742,
-0.5996001362800598,
-0.06950506567955017,
-0.4020076394081116,
-0.1918218582868576,
0.06859825551509857,
0.5811639428138733,
-0.1553020179271698,
0.8038821816444397,
0.549269437789917,
-0.9112095236778259,
0.341904878616333,
-0.1781357079744339,
-0.07344668358564377,
0.8475815653800964,
-0.7104650139808655,
0.13622036576271057,
-0.28591540455818176,
0.27323171496391296,
-0.8119478225708008,
0.1631179004907608,
-0.01498010940849781,
0.10882934182882309,
0.33655333518981934,
-0.7916868329048157,
-0.3338196873664856,
-0.2826753854751587,
-0.33803892135620117,
0.032912351191043854,
0.4185979664325714,
-0.9454618692398071,
0.6167445182800293,
0.4811386466026306,
0.08270730823278427,
-0.4914981722831726,
-1.0856600999832153,
-0.04586782678961754,
-0.5458117127418518,
-0.5620623826980591,
0.5897755026817322,
-0.140435129404068,
0.25853076577186584,
-0.2946336567401886,
-0.40657028555870056,
-0.01744641177356243,
0.25901123881340027,
0.21275828778743744,
-0.00009787666203919798,
-0.018475288525223732,
-0.16516004502773285,
0.3632412552833557,
-0.5570001602172852,
-0.157240092754364,
-0.5019986629486084,
0.5201705694198608,
0.006517400499433279,
-0.41456711292266846,
-0.6189528107643127,
0.29220202565193176,
0.7097647786140442,
-0.03182629868388176,
0.6507964730262756,
0.8388697504997253,
-0.45335206389427185,
-0.54979407787323,
-0.41604629158973694,
-0.3872082531452179,
-0.6907890439033508,
0.4415780305862427,
-0.6931658983230591,
-0.9245527386665344,
0.4701831638813019,
-0.723639726638794,
0.39168235659599304,
0.5045787692070007,
0.2532297968864441,
-0.18422921001911163,
1.397219181060791,
0.5391126275062561,
-0.006686691660434008,
0.45447397232055664,
-1.012298345565796,
0.1597214639186859,
-0.949516773223877,
0.08049804717302322,
-0.5297664403915405,
-0.8583524227142334,
-0.5517110228538513,
-0.12070834636688232,
0.7985804080963135,
0.24631598591804504,
-0.1755005568265915,
0.3425631821155548,
-0.6865951418876648,
0.7705172300338745,
0.615703821182251,
0.2132025808095932,
0.2558899223804474,
0.21145862340927124,
-0.10462065786123276,
0.14901718497276306,
-0.992752730846405,
-0.4520080089569092,
0.9492197036743164,
0.6318460702896118,
0.8447443246841431,
-0.08488505333662033,
0.853681743144989,
0.2702445685863495,
-0.03920769691467285,
-0.6849194765090942,
0.6426305770874023,
-0.7481939196586609,
-0.5430752038955688,
-0.4606463611125946,
-0.3954165577888489,
-0.7552873492240906,
0.3183780312538147,
-0.18037128448486328,
-0.643963634967804,
0.3542521893978119,
0.28208962082862854,
-0.6180785894393921,
0.7335604429244995,
-0.3733121454715729,
0.45775267481803894,
-0.17233717441558838,
-0.11897224187850952,
-0.15867529809474945,
-0.4938577115535736,
-0.02118968963623047,
0.22333644330501556,
0.03851873055100441,
-0.47792673110961914,
0.19055584073066711,
0.6734362244606018,
-0.8355695009231567,
0.6870077848434448,
-0.28806036710739136,
-0.003003769088536501,
0.3750883638858795,
-0.014740291982889175,
0.7022666931152344,
0.09404625743627548,
-0.1555836945772171,
0.464926540851593,
-0.12472039461135864,
-0.1283934861421585,
-0.6282074451446533,
0.5765590071678162,
-0.9343481659889221,
-0.27565082907676697,
0.14178112149238586,
-0.441592276096344,
-0.18796655535697937,
0.05542248114943504,
0.627921462059021,
1.0043067932128906,
0.19466792047023773,
0.4132959544658661,
0.7969918251037598,
0.3513261079788208,
0.7667524814605713,
0.010985339060425758,
0.15212702751159668,
-0.336191326379776,
1.089329481124878,
0.6233333349227905,
0.3930167853832245,
0.4691372811794281,
0.1106739342212677,
-0.2796877920627594,
-1.13325834274292,
-0.6368481516838074,
-0.2971254885196686,
-0.9608822464942932,
-0.3945111036300659,
-0.5296568274497986,
-0.7003552913665771,
0.11880629509687424,
-0.355638325214386,
-1.0628422498703003,
-0.495365172624588,
-0.5146119594573975,
-0.06762611865997314,
0.5620125532150269,
0.6023197174072266,
-0.3334522545337677,
0.7746331095695496,
-0.9468648433685303,
0.34660980105400085,
0.50253826379776,
0.3376752734184265,
0.019342266023159027,
-0.56165611743927,
-0.6290273070335388,
0.22881516814231873,
-0.23692409694194794,
-0.39895567297935486,
0.27015233039855957,
0.4577826261520386,
0.757046639919281,
0.45009148120880127,
0.02710091508924961,
0.6922294497489929,
-0.4715626835823059,
0.735009491443634,
0.36364084482192993,
-0.7452831268310547,
0.2614710032939911,
-0.02917897328734398,
0.13692227005958557,
0.7514254450798035,
0.7139610052108765,
-0.29664546251296997,
-0.06758645921945572,
-0.24298709630966187,
-1.1510719060897827,
0.41382652521133423,
-0.04092196002602577,
0.2173408418893814,
0.26585638523101807,
0.5135284662246704,
0.22332505881786346,
-0.15423491597175598,
-0.4335465729236603,
-0.611698567867279,
-0.03197915479540825,
-0.1296202391386032,
0.027666455134749413,
-0.3248434364795685,
-0.337234765291214,
-0.31264692544937134,
0.7931304574012756,
-0.36657652258872986,
0.14120618999004364,
0.22255069017410278,
-0.27788442373275757,
0.26921162009239197,
-0.011033888906240463,
0.3087759017944336,
0.5404012203216553,
-0.2297300100326538,
0.5228139162063599,
0.7310858368873596,
-0.5075277090072632,
0.5872425436973572,
-0.15927688777446747,
-0.16079583764076233,
-0.09631490707397461,
-0.016543157398700714,
0.7446681261062622,
-0.029989268630743027,
-0.057522326707839966,
0.17397429049015045,
-0.058045193552970886,
-0.475742369890213,
0.020965799689292908,
0.34286725521087646,
0.22437120974063873,
0.5752109289169312,
0.5842877626419067,
0.051236480474472046,
0.40726348757743835,
0.04447467625141144,
0.17400693893432617,
0.28141313791275024,
-0.6126683354377747,
0.12327273935079575,
0.4351082146167755,
0.5299320816993713,
-0.3247646987438202,
0.5841649770736694,
-0.23905111849308014,
-0.25898033380508423,
0.5210824012756348,
0.2938673496246338,
0.9563987255096436,
0.17294172942638397,
-0.22263586521148682,
-0.0013416096335276961,
0.4884701669216156,
-0.025701288133859634,
0.12799422442913055,
0.3015078902244568,
-0.6680956482887268,
-0.3582805395126343,
-0.7287031412124634,
-0.5278287529945374,
0.2269851565361023,
-0.40787965059280396,
0.2968995273113251,
-0.6529038548469543,
-0.6878179907798767,
0.027686726301908493,
-0.3331185281276703,
-0.7386561632156372,
0.3153327703475952,
0.20517165958881378,
0.9915960431098938,
-0.7467789053916931,
0.7030102014541626,
0.3864509165287018,
-0.03661932423710823,
-0.4974842071533203,
-0.28787118196487427,
-0.18336163461208344,
-0.5220268368721008,
0.5666191577911377,
0.21881680190563202,
-0.5751765966415405,
0.3327684998512268,
-0.43391868472099304,
-0.9992761015892029,
1.2011210918426514,
0.641027569770813,
-0.7547328472137451,
0.2049223780632019,
0.4265078902244568,
0.22658927738666534,
-0.29185160994529724,
0.6604616641998291,
0.737676739692688,
0.22094973921775818,
-0.016610121354460716,
-0.6853355169296265,
-0.31233835220336914,
-0.21932607889175415,
0.3496038019657135,
0.10679280757904053,
-0.8952091336250305,
0.9301795959472656,
0.3107367157936096,
-0.2167801558971405,
-0.406266987323761,
0.8280943036079407,
0.026553915813565254,
-0.0858410969376564,
0.5990728735923767,
0.5231676697731018,
0.5316662192344666,
-0.04638179391622543,
0.48082220554351807,
-0.6667287945747375,
0.30035942792892456,
0.6635527610778809,
0.047144610434770584,
0.6011746525764465,
0.553130567073822,
-0.12566643953323364,
0.3235428035259247,
0.8697819113731384,
0.12212330847978592,
0.6378316283226013,
0.3845537304878235,
0.07202304154634476,
-0.383661687374115,
-0.1452137529850006,
-0.5612215399742126,
0.3395792841911316,
0.26594632863998413,
-0.2813182473182678,
-0.327730268239975,
-0.048384614288806915,
-0.08772296458482742,
-0.3930067718029022,
-0.7493674755096436,
0.48130932450294495,
0.2342454344034195,
-0.09470998495817184,
1.0086411237716675,
0.23329560458660126,
1.0626524686813354,
-0.5756814479827881,
0.06911963224411011,
-0.4495897591114044,
0.21039511263370514,
-0.42074716091156006,
-0.47454550862312317,
0.4213375747203827,
-0.1084727942943573,
-0.13306882977485657,
-0.3213871717453003,
0.9274175763130188,
-0.06895751506090164,
-0.5784200429916382,
0.1202254369854927,
0.2904265224933624,
0.38024625182151794,
-0.03342490643262863,
-0.6246852278709412,
0.18731558322906494,
-0.323511004447937,
-0.36764559149742126,
0.49762699007987976,
0.08096043020486832,
0.44297319650650024,
0.8987483382225037,
0.8101353049278259,
-0.12002548575401306,
0.2503648102283478,
0.17080557346343994,
1.0683488845825195,
-0.44125258922576904,
-0.47428375482559204,
-1.038217306137085,
0.667232096195221,
-0.12045882642269135,
-0.26346060633659363,
0.4944453835487366,
0.5731077790260315,
0.8292779326438904,
0.041784219443798065,
0.9102137684822083,
0.5065709352493286,
0.10302630811929703,
-0.7918419241905212,
0.5939728021621704,
-0.6876062750816345,
0.2616085708141327,
0.035053007304668427,
-1.0297927856445312,
-0.09689265489578247,
0.4636026620864868,
0.0948774442076683,
-0.01310054399073124,
0.35339027643203735,
0.9889109134674072,
-0.3273800313472748,
-0.00984908826649189,
0.41405540704727173,
-0.20803508162498474,
0.31561604142189026,
0.5059147477149963,
0.8964680433273315,
-0.4966111183166504,
0.7574246525764465,
-0.437637060880661,
-0.11502519249916077,
-0.49958598613739014,
-1.0510351657867432,
-0.9946047067642212,
-0.0891575962305069,
-0.2958947420120239,
-0.12361639738082886,
0.06910357624292374,
0.8744471669197083,
1.2496001720428467,
-0.547412097454071,
-0.33072930574417114,
-0.2530119717121124,
0.049913082271814346,
-0.5459108948707581,
-0.07447678595781326,
0.19088655710220337,
-0.2382735162973404,
-0.816783607006073,
0.7559058666229248,
0.43128466606140137,
0.06502564996480942,
-0.77517169713974,
-0.07790671288967133,
0.03384072706103325,
0.26789504289627075,
0.6174173355102539,
-0.14269396662712097,
-0.3289993703365326,
-0.4610632061958313,
-0.0459330715239048,
-0.07691539078950882,
0.18773873150348663,
0.6447461247444153,
-0.2980562150478363,
-0.0031543178483843803,
0.5606775879859924,
0.6892895102500916,
0.894849419593811,
-0.12921303510665894,
0.39884164929389954,
-0.9125324487686157,
-0.03112092986702919,
-0.01754850521683693,
0.47279471158981323,
0.2809903919696808,
-0.3806435167789459,
0.5916719436645508,
0.1942480355501175,
-0.4279904067516327,
-0.804844319820404,
0.37017104029655457,
-0.47887569665908813,
-0.3347848057746887,
1.0196399688720703,
-0.04327816143631935,
-0.09784365445375443,
-0.04986971244215965,
0.015303698368370533,
0.4468735456466675,
-0.015247918665409088,
0.27915170788764954,
0.15320265293121338,
-0.4050457775592804,
-0.09248016029596329,
-0.4612191617488861,
0.4303281605243683,
0.1712489128112793,
-0.5409367680549622,
-0.14479900896549225,
-0.05462898686528206,
0.2739025950431824,
0.0936620905995369,
0.3437310755252838,
0.23574241995811462,
-0.19142919778823853,
0.3697345554828644,
0.16666355729103088,
-0.576458752155304,
-0.9097946286201477,
-0.33225902915000916,
0.3624144494533539,
0.23268842697143555,
-0.41610243916511536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03683v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03683v1
|
Stream of Search (SoS): Learning to Search in Language
| 2024-04-01T06:50:52 | 2024-04-01T06:50:52 |
Kanishk Gandhi, Denise Lee, Gabriel Grand, Muxin Liu, Winson Cheng, Archit Sharma, Noah D. Goodman
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Language models are rarely shown fruitful mistakes while training. They then
struggle to look beyond the next token, suffering from a snowballing of errors
and struggling to predict the consequence of their actions several steps ahead.
In this paper, we show how language models can be taught to search by
representing the process of search in language, as a flattened string -- a
stream of search (SoS). We propose a unified language for search that captures
an array of different symbolic search strategies. We demonstrate our approach
using the simple yet difficult game of Countdown, where the goal is to combine
input numbers with arithmetic operations to reach a target number. We pretrain
a transformer-based language model from scratch on a dataset of streams of
search generated by heuristic solvers. We find that SoS pretraining increases
search accuracy by 25% over models trained to predict only the optimal search
trajectory. We further finetune this model with two policy improvement methods:
Advantage-Induced Policy Alignment (APA) and Self-Taught Reasoner (STaR). The
finetuned SoS models solve 36% of previously unsolved problems, including
problems that cannot be solved by any of the heuristic solvers. Our results
indicate that language models can learn to solve problems via search,
self-improve to flexibly use different search strategies, and potentially
discover new ones.
|
[
0.08554068207740784,
-0.3546990156173706,
0.7884989976882935,
0.06750459223985672,
-0.19763940572738647,
0.20103536546230316,
-0.20542845129966736,
0.046183761209249496,
0.14493751525878906,
0.5655379295349121,
-0.9466890096664429,
-0.06311860680580139,
-0.6095463037490845,
0.23632407188415527,
-0.38834312558174133,
0.8896424770355225,
-0.16195788979530334,
0.179957777261734,
0.2569032609462738,
0.3084726929664612,
-0.292127788066864,
-0.40996599197387695,
-0.8234735131263733,
-0.3385885953903198,
0.26645758748054504,
0.35780471563339233,
0.5765471458435059,
0.5922485589981079,
0.5768078565597534,
0.34444892406463623,
-0.07684652507305145,
-0.2098497599363327,
-0.7827382683753967,
0.2647826373577118,
-0.2917647659778595,
-0.6483118534088135,
0.2715197503566742,
0.07251234352588654,
0.4710640013217926,
0.4130876958370209,
-0.5102955102920532,
0.27890074253082275,
-0.15716338157653809,
0.6946979761123657,
-0.6419102549552917,
0.4128847122192383,
-0.7455153465270996,
-0.12366984784603119,
-0.45623597502708435,
-0.3624058961868286,
-0.3760618567466736,
-0.4753861129283905,
0.3240717649459839,
-0.7561989426612854,
0.06906790286302567,
-0.24199724197387695,
0.8370437622070312,
0.4524966776371002,
-0.13731922209262848,
-0.6756252646446228,
-0.931710422039032,
0.7228654026985168,
-0.7485342621803284,
0.44559937715530396,
0.19272534549236298,
0.5211349129676819,
-0.2472972571849823,
-0.7441626191139221,
-0.41658124327659607,
0.0019785671029239893,
0.11897742748260498,
0.012991287745535374,
0.016770480200648308,
-0.1749698519706726,
0.03764430060982704,
0.0749928429722786,
-0.498627245426178,
0.006597910542041063,
-0.6276084780693054,
0.014880574308335781,
0.8041613101959229,
0.023411614820361137,
0.27396681904792786,
-0.005302563309669495,
-0.28681790828704834,
-0.23565368354320526,
-0.7465021014213562,
0.43067315220832825,
0.29304811358451843,
0.6392844319343567,
0.3064180016517639,
0.2392546534538269,
-0.1443241536617279,
0.5552505850791931,
-0.23354752361774445,
-0.11322831362485886,
-0.2907087504863739,
0.054733358323574066,
0.13249102234840393,
0.07234971970319748,
0.5027321577072144,
-0.2516273558139801,
0.4166164696216583,
-0.09779086709022522,
-0.5270204544067383,
0.36847633123397827,
0.4763111472129822,
-0.6819297075271606,
-0.11018035560846329,
-0.15961389243602753,
-0.2761344313621521,
-0.17975272238254547,
0.050391074270009995,
-0.31800535321235657,
0.03816743567585945,
-0.35857975482940674,
0.4942350387573242,
-0.5043843984603882,
-0.014267903752624989,
0.5828596353530884,
-0.15034686028957367,
0.008828534744679928,
0.09088566899299622,
-0.9703158140182495,
0.5280497074127197,
0.40939462184906006,
0.32508790493011475,
0.2826599180698395,
-0.3210221827030182,
-0.431768000125885,
-0.12897871434688568,
-0.3953733444213867,
0.8796220421791077,
-0.9886650443077087,
-0.40307310223579407,
0.11842063069343567,
-0.2801663875579834,
-0.2794483006000519,
-0.2672630846500397,
0.4659215211868286,
-0.7210968732833862,
0.1699012815952301,
-0.20108440518379211,
-0.6830494403839111,
-0.1605408489704132,
-0.08387177437543869,
-0.5409052968025208,
1.2145246267318726,
0.04439743235707283,
-0.3255038261413574,
-0.041306376457214355,
-0.9022294282913208,
-0.34047600626945496,
0.30732256174087524,
-0.3306964933872223,
-0.336877703666687,
0.4444352686405182,
0.18963976204395294,
0.2903432548046112,
-0.36852818727493286,
0.3916318416595459,
0.0055915736593306065,
-0.6815171241760254,
-0.05497726798057556,
0.004383868537843227,
0.5456392765045166,
0.376746267080307,
-0.441880464553833,
-0.017165256664156914,
-0.3630063831806183,
0.027663197368383408,
0.7037910223007202,
-0.4850452244281769,
-0.44197332859039307,
0.3983076512813568,
-0.19067224860191345,
0.08940005302429199,
0.19445204734802246,
-0.4182506203651428,
0.37195149064064026,
-0.4260854721069336,
0.7121230959892273,
0.8082752227783203,
-0.5598201751708984,
0.3372066915035248,
0.18534742295742035,
0.5232845544815063,
-0.32565784454345703,
0.3517637848854065,
-0.5400742888450623,
-0.1307203322649002,
-0.6644369959831238,
0.20865611732006073,
0.34884485602378845,
0.23685622215270996,
-0.6767686009407043,
0.22124932706356049,
-0.3474021852016449,
-0.4619894027709961,
-0.6056939959526062,
0.06024559214711189,
0.40530872344970703,
0.12173905968666077,
0.3533720374107361,
-0.1942296028137207,
-0.725143551826477,
-0.18609096109867096,
-0.41848355531692505,
-0.08977752178907394,
0.0344277061522007,
0.2100996971130371,
0.27273932099342346,
-0.2722804844379425,
0.7677015066146851,
-0.6387213468551636,
-0.42387115955352783,
-0.3078151345252991,
0.1559913605451584,
0.0190171729773283,
0.13226595520973206,
0.19483263790607452,
-0.788453221321106,
-0.4329911470413208,
-0.38716766238212585,
-0.7488300204277039,
0.06016329675912857,
0.24897217750549316,
0.3130300045013428,
-0.00864507257938385,
0.8501792550086975,
-0.22096873819828033,
0.4828346371650696,
0.5004416108131409,
-0.4101337492465973,
0.45408573746681213,
-0.11515875905752182,
-0.3947748839855194,
-0.5438560247421265,
-0.13472627103328705,
-0.15481452643871307,
-0.07501987367868423,
-0.5827097296714783,
0.6102576851844788,
-0.13115240633487701,
-0.32148605585098267,
-0.5060172080993652,
0.5290448665618896,
-0.437889039516449,
0.10608872771263123,
-0.36843636631965637,
0.13875405490398407,
-0.140435591340065,
0.2560279667377472,
0.18902720510959625,
0.840507447719574,
0.7194210290908813,
-0.6696703433990479,
0.0778288021683693,
0.12171873450279236,
-0.17924515902996063,
-0.053969692438840866,
-0.6103373169898987,
0.18551139533519745,
-0.3898032605648041,
0.4183512330055237,
-0.7809577584266663,
0.29064303636550903,
-0.5371755361557007,
-0.05818348005414009,
0.31911054253578186,
-0.01488360483199358,
-0.2306259423494339,
-0.7153037786483765,
0.030505266040563583,
0.501836359500885,
0.5467498302459717,
-0.5051532983779907,
0.6271306872367859,
0.3894954323768616,
-0.21220210194587708,
-0.47065699100494385,
0.020301640033721924,
-0.20690996944904327,
0.13970376551151276,
-0.401001513004303,
0.23130761086940765,
0.09657277911901474,
0.2628680169582367,
-0.09686044603586197,
-0.5994629263877869,
0.05662037059664726,
0.32872235774993896,
-0.10634966939687729,
0.37639594078063965,
-0.2651437520980835,
0.08450987935066223,
-0.5116875767707825,
-0.37636247277259827,
-0.03531019762158394,
-0.7723497748374939,
1.0477900505065918,
-0.2903454303741455,
-0.43450039625167847,
-0.06652464717626572,
0.18966913223266602,
0.13244077563285828,
-0.4601125419139862,
0.18411028385162354,
0.12136144191026688,
-0.19074566662311554,
-0.011402497999370098,
-0.6067765951156616,
-0.6209070086479187,
-0.5249210596084595,
0.16238200664520264,
-0.597287118434906,
-1.074726939201355,
0.42696836590766907,
-0.3518454432487488,
-0.015470671467483044,
0.48713696002960205,
0.11050578206777573,
-0.4833126962184906,
1.1518027782440186,
1.0578423738479614,
0.10773369669914246,
0.5244587659835815,
-0.5657621026039124,
0.4798261523246765,
-0.3783435523509979,
-0.2007136195898056,
-0.7235870957374573,
-0.1658090204000473,
-0.6272754073143005,
-0.24735787510871887,
0.38836124539375305,
0.26207849383354187,
-0.32638561725616455,
0.6048493981361389,
-0.5720427632331848,
0.6835364103317261,
0.6775209903717041,
-0.017552873119711876,
0.0753246322274208,
-0.1475002020597458,
-0.3302253782749176,
-0.23758956789970398,
-0.891427755355835,
-0.5288630723953247,
0.9773144721984863,
0.19613327085971832,
1.1394435167312622,
-0.14299078285694122,
1.1190028190612793,
-0.09923490881919861,
0.1456315815448761,
-0.6388908624649048,
0.4234560430049896,
-0.49419450759887695,
-0.6573110818862915,
-0.8773237466812134,
-0.3468840718269348,
-1.1921920776367188,
-0.1735290139913559,
0.13213543593883514,
-0.7893269062042236,
-0.102359339594841,
-0.03695732355117798,
-0.5704811215400696,
0.1786329299211502,
-0.3953528106212616,
0.841425359249115,
-0.4802079498767853,
0.08180467039346695,
-0.2097829133272171,
-0.5495510697364807,
0.07563377916812897,
0.18010187149047852,
0.29612067341804504,
-0.17258162796497345,
0.5118128657341003,
0.8166217803955078,
-0.45098960399627686,
0.5365318059921265,
-0.04706832394003868,
0.030589906498789787,
0.3217405080795288,
0.2862585783004761,
0.7851898670196533,
-0.2921289801597595,
0.23463714122772217,
0.06540057808160782,
0.24706579744815826,
-0.5166389346122742,
-0.7011204361915588,
0.26213714480400085,
-0.5894896388053894,
-0.7809998989105225,
-0.5097975134849548,
-0.2889638841152191,
0.155727356672287,
0.4282483160495758,
0.25860780477523804,
0.16798242926597595,
-0.2949152886867523,
-0.07695388793945312,
0.7891378402709961,
0.16293177008628845,
0.6236851215362549,
0.8456676602363586,
-0.5934694409370422,
0.34905192255973816,
0.9906393885612488,
0.18175984919071198,
-0.0302512738853693,
0.36949342489242554,
0.6022299528121948,
-0.6591382622718811,
0.0038540298119187355,
-0.08297186344861984,
0.18576659262180328,
-0.48482680320739746,
-0.271035373210907,
-0.42029666900634766,
-0.6503769159317017,
-0.4898519515991211,
-0.22224661707878113,
-0.6998885273933411,
-0.03884131833910942,
-0.13980229198932648,
0.07318023592233658,
0.20021645724773407,
0.804122269153595,
0.14009413123130798,
0.5945687890052795,
-0.6924814581871033,
0.2784838080406189,
0.5752098560333252,
0.5217840671539307,
-0.2659156620502472,
-0.4691314697265625,
-0.08942429721355438,
0.07578779011964798,
-0.44176363945007324,
-0.792445957660675,
0.23624378442764282,
0.15616795420646667,
0.47310203313827515,
0.40574803948402405,
0.00659904582425952,
0.7077327966690063,
-0.8358476161956787,
0.5843669176101685,
0.26346614956855774,
-1.1277912855148315,
0.651991069316864,
-0.05356931686401367,
0.3718174397945404,
0.52388995885849,
0.4810694754123688,
-0.6540703773498535,
-0.148003950715065,
-0.819086492061615,
-0.5975315570831299,
0.8379019498825073,
0.1872478574514389,
0.21915395557880402,
0.12305150926113129,
0.1687169224023819,
0.029077209532260895,
0.07276634871959686,
-0.5989542603492737,
-0.17994557321071625,
-0.31987565755844116,
0.055561039596796036,
-0.26774734258651733,
-0.2842884659767151,
0.0754840075969696,
-0.14260976016521454,
0.6501547694206238,
-0.36262789368629456,
0.11493422836065292,
0.016073090955615044,
0.03850599005818367,
-0.27863872051239014,
0.3830994963645935,
0.383984237909317,
0.3959701657295227,
-0.04040409252047539,
0.3112425208091736,
-0.16435733437538147,
-0.35145506262779236,
0.3633001744747162,
0.25171634554862976,
-0.4425354599952698,
0.06351719796657562,
-0.020327093079686165,
0.9865737557411194,
0.610846221446991,
-0.7765800952911377,
0.38152173161506653,
-0.044469207525253296,
0.004480558913201094,
-0.14557598531246185,
0.13961052894592285,
0.3040272295475006,
0.13111639022827148,
0.619195818901062,
-0.012017984874546528,
0.3362460732460022,
-0.7181699275970459,
0.10964693129062653,
0.5095009803771973,
-0.6048802137374878,
-0.44555047154426575,
0.607164740562439,
0.15674537420272827,
-0.7288230657577515,
0.4978586435317993,
-0.35841047763824463,
-1.0124192237854004,
0.22621452808380127,
0.7365369200706482,
0.741833508014679,
-0.7764564156532288,
0.451144814491272,
0.0047863018698990345,
0.393730491399765,
-0.5873003602027893,
0.7472800612449646,
0.0452071949839592,
-0.7295336127281189,
-0.516789972782135,
-0.7004628777503967,
-0.11037015169858932,
0.3093521296977997,
-0.4906863868236542,
0.36965227127075195,
-0.22979392111301422,
-0.025640355423092842,
0.14141245186328888,
0.04344766587018967,
-0.9756607413291931,
0.23184671998023987,
0.06981360912322998,
1.014726996421814,
-0.8581586480140686,
0.5269041657447815,
0.7227242588996887,
-0.48001736402511597,
-1.0801433324813843,
-0.13547880947589874,
-0.21734490990638733,
-1.0068527460098267,
0.7150264978408813,
0.13681980967521667,
-0.1009691134095192,
0.3188716769218445,
-0.7005570530891418,
-1.3897557258605957,
0.5676977038383484,
0.6119868159294128,
-0.6083393096923828,
-0.5488585233688354,
0.07705076783895493,
0.5785720348358154,
-0.318486750125885,
0.41119956970214844,
0.7211557030677795,
0.2813662886619568,
0.24065077304840088,
-0.8907757997512817,
-0.1624414324760437,
-0.006127616390585899,
0.26699957251548767,
0.17598941922187805,
-0.656012237071991,
0.7379094958305359,
-0.2606607675552368,
-0.5638806819915771,
-0.23618029057979584,
0.4673633277416229,
0.394407719373703,
0.3628665804862976,
0.46803346276283264,
0.5174431800842285,
0.4707585275173187,
-0.26377996802330017,
0.9287259578704834,
-0.09605283290147781,
0.44260266423225403,
0.9844470024108887,
-0.41162294149398804,
0.9133808612823486,
0.4088810980319977,
-0.26763978600502014,
0.5990944504737854,
0.5940904021263123,
0.48424503207206726,
0.7321915626525879,
0.5028519034385681,
0.09753976762294769,
-0.5080286860466003,
-0.04382243752479553,
-0.11633992195129395,
0.6986374258995056,
0.2850494980812073,
-0.023511940613389015,
-0.65652996301651,
-0.09683971107006073,
-0.12694481015205383,
0.5695855021476746,
-0.11919675767421722,
0.8301059007644653,
0.16666661202907562,
-0.7613298892974854,
0.567216694355011,
-0.08111267536878586,
0.47506004571914673,
-0.6825694441795349,
-0.03584077209234238,
-0.12828779220581055,
0.20715561509132385,
0.15344694256782532,
-0.5155215263366699,
0.1840451955795288,
-0.2723499536514282,
-0.14678019285202026,
-0.259519100189209,
0.5266515016555786,
-0.3325018286705017,
-0.659876823425293,
0.3339886963367462,
0.3787105679512024,
0.34415143728256226,
-0.11912321299314499,
-0.8215935826301575,
0.17882072925567627,
-0.11358602344989777,
-0.11813881248235703,
0.09341058135032654,
0.2652493119239807,
-0.3369673490524292,
0.8477490544319153,
0.6967228651046753,
0.17768152058124542,
0.3084593415260315,
0.0650753527879715,
0.8137345910072327,
-0.5326361656188965,
-0.8191185593605042,
-0.6452741026878357,
0.25747057795524597,
0.24020881950855255,
0.05813147872686386,
0.3698028028011322,
0.46148163080215454,
1.096825361251831,
-0.04191998019814491,
0.7324702143669128,
0.2303687334060669,
0.6393378376960754,
-0.5167686939239502,
0.37848255038261414,
-0.43127909302711487,
0.20823656022548676,
0.08386775106191635,
-0.9509329795837402,
0.11304203420877457,
0.767998993396759,
-0.3440512418746948,
0.02468661405146122,
0.6788555979728699,
0.5787315964698792,
-0.2713662385940552,
0.2384830117225647,
0.27593106031417847,
-0.06040995195508003,
0.19065313041210175,
0.3239800035953522,
0.8575793504714966,
-0.673356294631958,
0.45764195919036865,
0.10111769288778305,
-0.11322803050279617,
-0.4882242977619171,
-0.5291808843612671,
-0.6778766512870789,
-0.7573179602622986,
-0.017927786335349083,
-0.03124396502971649,
0.32487568259239197,
0.6598647832870483,
0.8593209385871887,
-0.8153960704803467,
-0.4796748161315918,
-0.28634095191955566,
0.12484798580408096,
-0.5167952179908752,
-0.18649421632289886,
0.18568140268325806,
-0.8975444436073303,
-0.5303016304969788,
0.6131919622421265,
0.3819098472595215,
-0.14668968319892883,
-0.45979613065719604,
-0.2239810973405838,
-0.38157206773757935,
0.4367836117744446,
0.2454126924276352,
0.5510077476501465,
-0.8218819499015808,
-0.013534284196794033,
0.5191672444343567,
-0.21858830749988556,
-0.13983191549777985,
1.3306844234466553,
-0.7794826626777649,
0.7405032515525818,
0.19470283389091492,
0.6037020683288574,
0.86638343334198,
-0.3215545415878296,
0.5060040950775146,
-0.5993976593017578,
-0.08782098442316055,
0.20490577816963196,
0.2696734070777893,
0.12892314791679382,
-0.26597335934638977,
0.4959433972835541,
0.051350004971027374,
-0.402538925409317,
-0.8620068430900574,
0.3901384770870209,
-0.08929520100355148,
-0.38807055354118347,
0.8159568309783936,
-0.16856245696544647,
-0.22736206650733948,
0.043069224804639816,
-0.0594351701438427,
0.4208330512046814,
-0.31779158115386963,
1.1865229606628418,
0.34464359283447266,
0.2052222490310669,
-0.029012683779001236,
-0.1276114284992218,
0.7983489632606506,
0.5964507460594177,
-0.2972859740257263,
-0.07256786525249481,
-0.1301085203886032,
0.15723580121994019,
0.549344003200531,
0.7052786350250244,
0.07567828893661499,
0.1246594712138176,
-0.30073580145835876,
0.21468180418014526,
0.20039336383342743,
-0.6516476273536682,
-0.20596027374267578,
-0.18152815103530884,
-0.16139620542526245,
-0.019250545650720596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00950v1
|
AISPACE at SemEval-2024 task 8: A Class-balanced Soft-voting System for Detecting Multi-generator Machine-generated Text
| 2024-04-01T06:25:47 | 2024-04-01T06:25:47 |
Renhua Gu, Xiangfeng Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
SemEval-2024 Task 8 provides a challenge to detect human-written and
machine-generated text. There are 3 subtasks for different detection scenarios.
This paper proposes a system that mainly deals with Subtask B. It aims to
detect if given full text is written by human or is generated by a specific
Large Language Model (LLM), which is actually a multi-class text classification
task. Our team AISPACE conducted a systematic study of fine-tuning
transformer-based models, including encoderonly, decoder-only and
encoder-decoder models. We compared their performance on this task and
identified that encoder-only models performed exceptionally well. We also
applied a weighted Cross Entropy loss function to address the issue of data
imbalance of different class samples. Additionally, we employed softvoting
strategy over multi-models ensemble to enhance the reliability of our
predictions. Our system ranked top 1 in Subtask B, which sets a
state-of-the-art benchmark for this new challenge.
|
[
-0.2655225694179535,
-0.4869970977306366,
0.5102795958518982,
0.1024826392531395,
-0.37039172649383545,
0.23643606901168823,
-0.20339636504650116,
-0.34111297130584717,
-0.008371333591639996,
0.6066248416900635,
-0.6142467260360718,
-0.4429141879081726,
-0.7399724125862122,
0.5095961689949036,
-0.5331897139549255,
0.9558632373809814,
-0.08866984397172928,
-0.12880240380764008,
-0.3908015787601471,
-0.2665043771266937,
-0.6176655292510986,
-0.6095110774040222,
-0.5503844618797302,
-0.6195685863494873,
0.34452593326568604,
0.47245776653289795,
0.3936788737773895,
0.21778491139411926,
0.3523496687412262,
0.44333261251449585,
0.04436267912387848,
0.3645887076854706,
-0.2187652438879013,
0.321889191865921,
-0.2109861522912979,
-0.351472944021225,
-0.5625658631324768,
-0.0412936769425869,
0.4874904751777649,
0.15403559803962708,
-0.06200340390205383,
0.2672424018383026,
0.29524603486061096,
0.23193298280239105,
-0.6328547596931458,
-0.10583540052175522,
-0.6405681371688843,
-0.011799097061157227,
-0.4011938273906708,
-0.2206006944179535,
-0.6879293918609619,
0.12536968290805817,
-0.3758957087993622,
-0.13385000824928284,
0.45021477341651917,
0.16714315116405487,
0.7520087361335754,
0.4617513418197632,
-0.5461047291755676,
-0.19950835406780243,
-0.5189834833145142,
0.9155117273330688,
-0.6999757885932922,
0.3713427484035492,
0.012095899321138859,
-0.13301554322242737,
0.11942502856254578,
-0.42912712693214417,
-0.8006501793861389,
0.07537475228309631,
0.04263461008667946,
0.37386414408683777,
-0.11135337501764297,
-0.026831552386283875,
0.13370440900325775,
0.11591290682554245,
-0.6799617409706116,
0.22547860443592072,
-0.29175081849098206,
-0.4041535556316376,
0.6442854404449463,
0.35577133297920227,
0.24656838178634644,
-0.27671143412590027,
-0.31228339672088623,
0.07379098236560822,
-0.41349664330482483,
-0.16808682680130005,
0.6385173201560974,
0.14642570912837982,
-0.024424687027931213,
0.6381061673164368,
0.02894415706396103,
0.3576931059360504,
0.13000421226024628,
0.15919217467308044,
0.45595380663871765,
-0.40725165605545044,
-0.10955805331468582,
0.06508152931928635,
0.7608219385147095,
0.13119910657405853,
0.05743452534079552,
-0.016653304919600487,
-0.5010552406311035,
0.38161543011665344,
0.401838093996048,
-0.7920733094215393,
-0.15260976552963257,
0.09729509800672531,
-0.5664854049682617,
-0.4842066764831543,
-0.08465710282325745,
-0.5658136606216431,
-0.5904422402381897,
-0.37750422954559326,
0.6463242769241333,
-0.17439600825309753,
-0.3255821168422699,
0.08748944103717804,
-0.19249407947063446,
0.05690869316458702,
0.49436327815055847,
-0.6826664805412292,
0.0737345814704895,
0.6721441149711609,
0.6591412425041199,
-0.4097382724285126,
-0.5017129778862,
-0.3738427758216858,
-0.09077136963605881,
-0.05084291845560074,
0.9707128405570984,
-0.35377365350723267,
0.0074089402332901955,
-0.19094014167785645,
0.4220902621746063,
-0.03306642174720764,
-0.45375412702560425,
0.6639463901519775,
-0.30635902285575867,
0.11436816304922104,
0.0033672749996185303,
-0.6241911053657532,
-0.030649950727820396,
0.39366865158081055,
-0.5556898713111877,
0.8869367241859436,
-0.02237224578857422,
-0.730927586555481,
0.4737979471683502,
-0.179050013422966,
-0.487545907497406,
0.43109750747680664,
-0.061687126755714417,
-0.9407193660736084,
0.0017896443605422974,
0.1875881552696228,
0.6379576921463013,
-0.3110204041004181,
0.3561078608036041,
-0.2700483798980713,
-0.4954471290111542,
0.1266755610704422,
-0.6643688082695007,
0.5797321200370789,
0.11923776566982269,
-0.7093071937561035,
0.2603790760040283,
-0.5390451550483704,
-0.045400045812129974,
0.021823866292834282,
-0.6479843854904175,
-0.16336630284786224,
0.05737485736608505,
0.2604786455631256,
0.03180266544222832,
0.37525612115859985,
-0.8633295297622681,
0.20530283451080322,
-0.2269429862499237,
0.23730307817459106,
0.8506800532341003,
-0.16147230565547943,
0.36648327112197876,
-0.26370516419410706,
0.5796040892601013,
0.1431346833705902,
-0.092844158411026,
-0.36372020840644836,
-0.4862484335899353,
-0.9293487668037415,
-0.13052675127983093,
0.4364711046218872,
0.7607485055923462,
-0.6817590594291687,
0.4965282678604126,
-0.11671429127454758,
-0.5749698877334595,
-0.5413719415664673,
0.13577015697956085,
0.2739972174167633,
0.05778438225388527,
0.4113990068435669,
-0.17850951850414276,
-0.5203425288200378,
-0.7529313564300537,
-0.335524320602417,
-0.02197195589542389,
0.04233596846461296,
0.10816460847854614,
0.7066181898117065,
-0.6760642528533936,
0.25414082407951355,
-0.21533489227294922,
-0.35286664962768555,
-0.5064683556556702,
0.4118480682373047,
0.16918975114822388,
0.4463140070438385,
0.3507756292819977,
-0.6393745541572571,
-0.3579660952091217,
-0.030015159398317337,
-0.7590609788894653,
-0.3957623243331909,
0.057451482862234116,
0.10144969820976257,
0.5394411683082581,
0.581490695476532,
-0.4393502175807953,
0.4148499369621277,
0.45920267701148987,
-0.5202310085296631,
0.2617357671260834,
-0.07169406116008759,
0.4608018696308136,
-0.9926683306694031,
-0.01863686740398407,
-0.13563133776187897,
-0.3826550245285034,
-0.435357928276062,
0.0507698580622673,
0.27909478545188904,
-0.2585146427154541,
-0.1883162409067154,
0.48656654357910156,
-0.17382366955280304,
0.15214775502681732,
-0.547410786151886,
-0.4623034596443176,
-0.013561958447098732,
0.4649295210838318,
0.045616257935762405,
0.6016067266464233,
0.04559304192662239,
-0.3328118920326233,
0.3573943078517914,
0.06449410319328308,
-0.2839314639568329,
0.5344928503036499,
-0.5253413915634155,
0.47736459970474243,
-0.3587469458580017,
0.2724369466304779,
-1.0005980730056763,
-0.10676652938127518,
-0.08554497361183167,
-0.6444228291511536,
0.10538442432880402,
-0.1222287118434906,
-0.5373267531394958,
-0.3630734384059906,
-0.13461504876613617,
0.3102269172668457,
0.17715658247470856,
-0.3561684787273407,
0.7801542282104492,
0.5771780014038086,
-0.29453185200691223,
-0.5515981316566467,
-0.4255976378917694,
0.17663924396038055,
-0.13142262399196625,
-0.7051694393157959,
0.31911736726760864,
0.10841459035873413,
0.185169517993927,
0.15234097838401794,
0.11579448729753494,
0.08612745255231857,
0.08976569771766663,
0.31331464648246765,
0.15661267936229706,
-0.13870850205421448,
-0.027614599093794823,
0.10418619960546494,
-0.2411915808916092,
-0.1093151643872261,
-0.33356213569641113,
0.606361448764801,
-0.2241160273551941,
-0.29561418294906616,
-0.1306542307138443,
0.4859994649887085,
0.8070488572120667,
-0.247031569480896,
0.6255446672439575,
0.9093842506408691,
-0.5637652277946472,
-0.5414225459098816,
-0.5854897499084473,
-0.17983877658843994,
-0.4919432997703552,
0.40217483043670654,
-0.24852930009365082,
-0.9665290117263794,
0.3403853178024292,
-0.08076279610395432,
0.20210106670856476,
0.5667335987091064,
0.8917366862297058,
-0.10403282940387726,
1.4644283056259155,
0.5772416591644287,
-0.17374062538146973,
0.19573254883289337,
-0.22518710792064667,
0.24292972683906555,
-0.465911865234375,
-0.35657697916030884,
-0.6548944115638733,
-0.5863174200057983,
-0.5414464473724365,
-0.310327410697937,
0.569925844669342,
-0.4439680278301239,
-0.38614439964294434,
0.4443351924419403,
-0.7328991889953613,
0.3489689230918884,
0.7208887934684753,
0.002935664029791951,
0.13861408829689026,
-0.0854441300034523,
-0.07596826553344727,
0.03448297083377838,
-0.46244943141937256,
-0.4551254212856293,
0.8972857594490051,
0.21422187983989716,
0.7565128803253174,
0.01498977281153202,
0.813022255897522,
0.6319774985313416,
0.2195102572441101,
-0.6402763724327087,
0.6704851388931274,
-0.6888260245323181,
-0.562787652015686,
-0.37968456745147705,
-0.29586517810821533,
-0.9714357256889343,
0.3306839168071747,
-0.24213267862796783,
-0.1258554309606552,
0.030916282907128334,
0.16791117191314697,
-0.21499668061733246,
0.3210756480693817,
-0.5853629112243652,
1.069094181060791,
-0.16803939640522003,
-0.4739331305027008,
-0.24689272046089172,
-0.33517390489578247,
-0.008120790123939514,
-0.0384599044919014,
0.2322191298007965,
-0.10126587748527527,
0.10690246522426605,
0.6402736902236938,
-0.3290165960788727,
0.6664533615112305,
-0.3563385605812073,
-0.01322300173342228,
0.5259499549865723,
-0.03314819186925888,
0.5287932753562927,
-0.07464863359928131,
-0.25093427300453186,
0.14806628227233887,
-0.07647358626127243,
-0.22149178385734558,
-0.12364012002944946,
0.4984714388847351,
-0.8037360906600952,
-0.23033788800239563,
-0.602308452129364,
-0.10155407339334488,
0.06912662088871002,
0.30393722653388977,
0.7324541211128235,
0.4345315396785736,
0.08032798022031784,
0.6194864511489868,
0.509928286075592,
-0.28754574060440063,
0.33896663784980774,
0.5490497350692749,
0.20324978232383728,
-0.39838799834251404,
1.053107500076294,
0.013965538702905178,
-0.2558639645576477,
0.33932939171791077,
0.2359798401594162,
-0.2666778862476349,
-0.49956339597702026,
-0.8227890133857727,
-0.1927414834499359,
-0.5953637361526489,
-0.6443213224411011,
-0.8155484795570374,
-0.4283699691295624,
-0.4732152223587036,
-0.21607264876365662,
-0.3797576129436493,
-0.09738384187221527,
-0.2845887243747711,
0.051025547087192535,
-0.12912175059318542,
0.7459291815757751,
0.19264331459999084,
0.12343458086252213,
-0.802121102809906,
0.23965540528297424,
0.26026758551597595,
0.03515670448541641,
-0.17650002241134644,
-0.6345665454864502,
-0.20113526284694672,
-0.35517486929893494,
-0.49564120173454285,
-0.8256089687347412,
0.510056734085083,
0.02544037252664566,
0.3804803788661957,
-0.06184690073132515,
-0.12268664687871933,
0.31700316071510315,
-0.5756977796554565,
0.6941986680030823,
0.018740102648735046,
-1.0525591373443604,
0.5592533349990845,
-0.38089218735694885,
0.7070874571800232,
0.6395857334136963,
-0.0867653638124466,
-0.4786311388015747,
-0.7271712422370911,
-0.5101454257965088,
-0.9397175312042236,
0.7651922106742859,
0.22744840383529663,
0.2690325379371643,
0.20656733214855194,
0.1717233806848526,
0.19000795483589172,
0.4058525562286377,
-0.9924600124359131,
0.14351825416088104,
-0.32929691672325134,
-0.7694798111915588,
-0.014258576557040215,
-0.15625034272670746,
0.5023396611213684,
-0.07542707771062851,
0.8757026791572571,
-0.23185084760189056,
0.27563950419425964,
-0.1147700846195221,
-0.22711196541786194,
-0.3942742943763733,
0.5497058629989624,
0.42830583453178406,
0.1269867867231369,
0.09152970463037491,
0.3961995542049408,
0.42086103558540344,
-0.59334397315979,
0.36172839999198914,
0.06790918856859207,
-0.4724636971950531,
-0.09624374657869339,
0.6350023150444031,
0.7782971858978271,
0.10993080586194992,
-0.5550902485847473,
0.6820907592773438,
-0.015188327059149742,
-0.273414671421051,
-0.3180328607559204,
0.18081475794315338,
-0.12701067328453064,
0.31921738386154175,
0.31830549240112305,
0.4223765730857849,
0.367946058511734,
-0.3789694011211395,
0.21147951483726501,
0.3915461003780365,
-0.28760090470314026,
-0.5416988730430603,
0.7007042765617371,
0.4836774468421936,
-0.2959591746330261,
0.47290757298469543,
-0.49171173572540283,
-0.9618669748306274,
0.8343691229820251,
0.4794619083404541,
0.9326326251029968,
-0.36704733967781067,
0.07097449153661728,
0.46393391489982605,
0.6696639657020569,
-0.07580184936523438,
0.5836274027824402,
0.11187108606100082,
-0.8869573473930359,
-0.2922370135784149,
-0.8267305493354797,
-0.40748530626296997,
0.5652565360069275,
-0.1809411346912384,
0.6274463534355164,
-0.1856173574924469,
-0.18621060252189636,
0.12949487566947937,
0.14563409984111786,
-0.7959640026092529,
0.2193741649389267,
0.34602978825569153,
0.3749408721923828,
-1.063971996307373,
0.44747641682624817,
1.0009061098098755,
0.1081441268324852,
-0.7275933623313904,
-0.15756501257419586,
0.18967407941818237,
-0.40270867943763733,
0.35320356488227844,
0.5020278096199036,
-0.21506403386592865,
0.0412214919924736,
-0.6026361584663391,
-0.5679143667221069,
0.9088736176490784,
0.2413763850927353,
-0.6932916641235352,
0.10648401081562042,
-0.007347294595092535,
0.42739441990852356,
-0.032337311655282974,
0.11173784732818604,
0.21407359838485718,
0.5185965895652771,
-0.1745530366897583,
-0.9557064771652222,
-0.04408382251858711,
-0.39423567056655884,
-0.5847992300987244,
0.5081382989883423,
-0.7408102750778198,
1.0251030921936035,
0.20046930015087128,
-0.10354555398225784,
0.039657607674598694,
0.6593952775001526,
0.2580980062484741,
0.6869099736213684,
0.8836889266967773,
0.72232586145401,
0.5843585729598999,
0.003488146932795644,
0.5725570917129517,
-0.08472103625535965,
0.34619566798210144,
0.7670428156852722,
-0.4418671727180481,
0.630795955657959,
0.00340009736828506,
-0.05452036112546921,
0.49636775255203247,
0.33328086137771606,
-0.24589036405086517,
0.42334893345832825,
0.1439163237810135,
-0.3239847421646118,
-0.7195240259170532,
-0.03785856068134308,
-0.02941308729350567,
0.7346408367156982,
0.300577849149704,
-0.087620310485363,
-0.0028489213436841965,
0.23176679015159607,
-0.26948025822639465,
-0.015063442289829254,
-0.384411484003067,
0.8676759004592896,
0.057152364403009415,
-1.130450963973999,
-0.0008087411988526583,
0.5808032751083374,
1.0161821842193604,
-0.24961158633232117,
-0.04739777371287346,
-0.00978764146566391,
0.655927300453186,
-0.18349261581897736,
-0.7755464315414429,
0.22127404808998108,
0.18623070418834686,
-0.23366610705852509,
-0.3941011130809784,
1.3936396837234497,
-0.6153002381324768,
-0.6903336048126221,
0.1487659364938736,
0.3830558657646179,
-0.11910483986139297,
-0.017696060240268707,
-0.47758248448371887,
0.16016298532485962,
-0.0843634158372879,
-0.0721975564956665,
0.10121969878673553,
0.5630152821540833,
-0.21052046120166779,
0.2839457094669342,
0.43892112374305725,
-0.10432498902082443,
0.02261846885085106,
0.25086361169815063,
0.47045189142227173,
-0.4453679323196411,
-0.6599940657615662,
-0.8606932163238525,
0.3312816023826599,
0.033705152571201324,
-0.2611510753631592,
0.6224164366722107,
0.6583784222602844,
0.6139532327651978,
-0.15906678140163422,
0.9383952617645264,
0.0649116262793541,
0.6161107420921326,
-0.34877607226371765,
0.6232907772064209,
-0.7692906856536865,
0.08568181842565536,
-0.33628976345062256,
-0.7818589806556702,
0.05156038701534271,
0.46503588557243347,
0.1474291980266571,
-0.05228304862976074,
0.5207241773605347,
0.6444103121757507,
-0.2037525475025177,
0.15683624148368835,
0.18284669518470764,
-0.06128726154565811,
0.22702288627624512,
0.5071498155593872,
1.073609471321106,
-0.47490450739860535,
0.6506204605102539,
0.01886802539229393,
-0.13365450501441956,
-0.3121474087238312,
-0.7202094793319702,
-1.0203510522842407,
-0.6521495580673218,
-0.3586231470108032,
-0.3028680980205536,
-0.13072392344474792,
0.6987798810005188,
0.6135393977165222,
-1.0451745986938477,
-0.0818755254149437,
0.03725702688097954,
0.10785947740077972,
0.0007352516404353082,
-0.23156368732452393,
0.0720858946442604,
-0.18017436563968658,
-0.7893753051757812,
0.39934536814689636,
0.48739317059516907,
-0.1442277878522873,
-0.191949263215065,
0.024141576141119003,
-0.02114427275955677,
0.19318822026252747,
0.5691537261009216,
-0.25613653659820557,
-0.4237738847732544,
-0.4290110170841217,
0.17555628716945648,
-0.061057109385728836,
-0.32821768522262573,
0.8952675461769104,
-0.6368225812911987,
0.15469586849212646,
0.8753254413604736,
0.693653404712677,
0.5359829664230347,
0.03268783912062645,
0.3037918210029602,
-0.8527481555938721,
-0.048780739307403564,
0.490143746137619,
0.4270581305027008,
0.36566978693008423,
-0.44644656777381897,
0.4723113775253296,
0.43434253334999084,
-0.9195391535758972,
-0.8195096850395203,
-0.03223975747823715,
-0.5844443440437317,
-0.3132037818431854,
1.0192099809646606,
0.08036553859710693,
-0.13535703718662262,
-0.33470699191093445,
-0.1578085571527481,
0.2683865427970886,
-0.3025968372821808,
0.47448185086250305,
0.7349133491516113,
0.038672275841236115,
-0.20825064182281494,
-0.33245834708213806,
0.18238230049610138,
0.6312960982322693,
-0.8424457907676697,
-0.20599064230918884,
0.4626910984516144,
0.24963000416755676,
0.21577690541744232,
0.8246731162071228,
0.18822212517261505,
0.287901908159256,
-0.23948094248771667,
0.07102468609809875,
0.013936048373579979,
-0.6752393841743469,
-0.16620151698589325,
0.4509614109992981,
-0.33237192034721375,
0.02621343359351158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00943v1
|
Evalverse: Unified and Accessible Library for Large Language Model Evaluation
| 2024-04-01T06:03:39 | 2024-04-01T06:03:39 |
Jihoo Kim, Wonho Song, Dahyun Kim, Yunsu Kim, Yungi Kim, Chanjun Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces Evalverse, a novel library that streamlines the
evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) by unifying disparate evaluation
tools into a single, user-friendly framework. Evalverse enables individuals
with limited knowledge of artificial intelligence to easily request LLM
evaluations and receive detailed reports, facilitated by an integration with
communication platforms like Slack. Thus, Evalverse serves as a powerful tool
for the comprehensive assessment of LLMs, offering both researchers and
practitioners a centralized and easily accessible evaluation framework.
Finally, we also provide a demo video for Evalverse, showcasing its
capabilities and implementation in a two-minute format.
|
[
-0.4809112548828125,
-0.8125192523002625,
0.4754071533679962,
0.5265408158302307,
-0.07115916907787323,
0.46984320878982544,
-0.534436047077179,
-0.2999005615711212,
0.34099051356315613,
0.4766782522201538,
-0.6270260214805603,
-0.511430561542511,
-0.5065333247184753,
0.0431094616651535,
-1.0016334056854248,
0.6420996189117432,
-0.15228703618049622,
0.33419516682624817,
-0.3263319730758667,
-0.16975723206996918,
-0.21674488484859467,
-0.30531400442123413,
-0.5300981998443604,
-0.5028684139251709,
0.4637226462364197,
0.0987728014588356,
0.4971211850643158,
0.013402354903519154,
0.634206235408783,
0.47789379954338074,
-0.0700102299451828,
-0.1929195672273636,
-0.5830165147781372,
0.1932145357131958,
-0.42551472783088684,
-0.15904712677001953,
-0.2792419493198395,
-0.3986900746822357,
0.870284378528595,
0.7065860033035278,
-0.16773125529289246,
0.5426031947135925,
0.2853454053401947,
0.6512248516082764,
-0.7523612976074219,
-0.15160690248012543,
-0.4922994077205658,
-0.19912835955619812,
-0.28003403544425964,
-0.05024581402540207,
-0.5919967889785767,
-0.37843945622444153,
0.03644368425011635,
0.05796150863170624,
-0.26606783270835876,
-0.026330308988690376,
0.5095854997634888,
0.1862519234418869,
-0.3160998225212097,
-0.06449273228645325,
-0.897300660610199,
0.6726139187812805,
-0.4459609389305115,
0.643561840057373,
-0.13358858227729797,
0.508479654788971,
-0.25602662563323975,
-1.0442410707473755,
-0.3826069235801697,
-0.3683297634124756,
0.06829407066106796,
-0.17584241926670074,
-0.4496540427207947,
0.20799866318702698,
0.024759620428085327,
0.37606897950172424,
-0.7293112874031067,
0.3870719373226166,
-0.32071173191070557,
-0.17234522104263306,
0.7410647869110107,
0.30026188492774963,
0.44691982865333557,
-0.18524794280529022,
-0.24861419200897217,
0.024873390793800354,
-0.48741206526756287,
-0.057118047028779984,
0.3290499150753021,
0.05997743457555771,
-0.10357666015625,
0.5514925718307495,
0.04545561596751213,
0.48856744170188904,
-0.48683154582977295,
0.026946047320961952,
0.23926956951618195,
-0.05730056017637253,
-0.41601383686065674,
-0.14090222120285034,
1.0486193895339966,
-0.0332598052918911,
-0.24521592259407043,
-0.2820894122123718,
-0.36665526032447815,
-0.2608731985092163,
0.07827502489089966,
-0.9397085309028625,
-0.09621700644493103,
0.36332064867019653,
-0.45023366808891296,
-0.19401831924915314,
0.21485458314418793,
-1.0750244855880737,
-0.41136956214904785,
-0.4602578580379486,
0.424825519323349,
-0.1670023798942566,
-0.27326542139053345,
0.11754975467920303,
-0.10297329723834991,
0.16604912281036377,
0.5256391167640686,
-0.6551297903060913,
0.6487044095993042,
0.9894861578941345,
0.9500739574432373,
-0.222681924700737,
-0.5244292616844177,
-0.5540428757667542,
-0.36078548431396484,
-0.10751231014728546,
0.9871219992637634,
-0.49964916706085205,
-0.3068174719810486,
-0.0988457128405571,
0.06793089956045151,
-0.008191152475774288,
-0.3491276800632477,
0.5009711384773254,
-0.44279155135154724,
-0.006845785770565271,
0.35901400446891785,
-0.6684575080871582,
-0.2793315649032593,
-0.096404530107975,
-0.810778796672821,
1.0980175733566284,
0.3991655111312866,
-0.5362870693206787,
-0.1026654988527298,
-0.7768592238426208,
-0.11742552369832993,
0.6293944120407104,
-0.1695534735918045,
-0.22376704216003418,
0.2947918474674225,
-0.0027107233181595802,
0.3668062090873718,
-0.5999852418899536,
0.6983972191810608,
-0.486795574426651,
-0.33381855487823486,
0.19332319498062134,
-0.9212626218795776,
1.0761549472808838,
0.30750712752342224,
-0.2976416349411011,
0.5328567624092102,
-0.608206570148468,
0.2869861423969269,
0.07921821624040604,
-0.22045178711414337,
-0.20545783638954163,
-0.09142880141735077,
0.5011364221572876,
-0.17456935346126556,
0.5682687163352966,
-0.33990293741226196,
0.34980493783950806,
-0.16086846590042114,
0.26048213243484497,
0.9429147839546204,
-0.3646502196788788,
0.2646152675151825,
0.0828656479716301,
0.8639761805534363,
-0.6917803883552551,
0.20391076803207397,
-0.17061775922775269,
-0.11318425089120865,
-0.7438583970069885,
-0.45917895436286926,
0.5040988922119141,
0.4631800651550293,
-0.459392786026001,
0.804948627948761,
-0.3317292630672455,
-0.7978782653808594,
-0.986107349395752,
0.5289062261581421,
0.22642283141613007,
0.02895951084792614,
0.01892387494444847,
-0.12373912334442139,
-0.8064382076263428,
-1.022457480430603,
-0.09115723520517349,
-0.07300294190645218,
-0.2039031982421875,
0.13182026147842407,
0.6919573545455933,
-0.5910634398460388,
0.7866740226745605,
-0.15814027190208435,
0.05926079675555229,
-0.7569762468338013,
0.18071185052394867,
0.1815708726644516,
0.00653456524014473,
0.4994790852069855,
-0.5377077460289001,
-0.38524168729782104,
0.07063569873571396,
-0.6074433922767639,
-0.49097228050231934,
0.07139807194471359,
-0.06600441783666611,
0.04785506799817085,
0.41078490018844604,
-0.1734350472688675,
0.23784029483795166,
1.0051145553588867,
-0.3815232217311859,
0.7537708282470703,
-0.015643393620848656,
0.21629397571086884,
-0.9187411665916443,
0.23231637477874756,
-0.22697733342647552,
-0.4887174963951111,
-0.48253342509269714,
0.29699331521987915,
0.14801518619060516,
-0.010902967303991318,
-0.7173421382904053,
0.9028735756874084,
-0.28591957688331604,
-0.23192472755908966,
-0.14224831759929657,
0.3465266525745392,
0.22022943198680878,
0.024404462426900864,
-0.29151877760887146,
0.7591406106948853,
0.6566043496131897,
0.009918312542140484,
0.6629395484924316,
0.04500648006796837,
-0.7413234114646912,
0.17696882784366608,
-0.6366642117500305,
0.16707150638103485,
-0.07419532537460327,
0.12104233354330063,
-0.8179492354393005,
-0.3065059185028076,
-0.32176706194877625,
-0.13085803389549255,
0.259573370218277,
-0.11666088551282883,
-0.5508809685707092,
-0.6613737344741821,
-0.6180851459503174,
0.16651733219623566,
0.45979371666908264,
-0.915425717830658,
0.8358237147331238,
0.5867553949356079,
-0.344644695520401,
-0.3749644458293915,
-0.2907615602016449,
0.25173071026802063,
-0.2455972135066986,
-0.7923429608345032,
-0.21608230471611023,
-0.3868463337421417,
-0.4260360598564148,
-0.012626527808606625,
0.22943249344825745,
-0.2352655678987503,
0.46282637119293213,
0.24069935083389282,
0.4071080684661865,
-0.1558753401041031,
0.22558267414569855,
-0.11094176024198532,
0.19733908772468567,
-0.042961400002241135,
0.15030930936336517,
0.9697592854499817,
-0.6347809433937073,
-0.6772662997245789,
-0.4038911759853363,
0.28600332140922546,
0.6983975172042847,
-0.05292336270213127,
0.4870062470436096,
0.5816991329193115,
-0.1973312348127365,
-0.3805496096611023,
-0.734819233417511,
0.06045868247747421,
-0.5424878597259521,
0.7062146067619324,
-0.1359129697084427,
-1.2070921659469604,
0.4700857698917389,
-0.38477975130081177,
0.09798821806907654,
0.4796006381511688,
0.9415783286094666,
0.2265683114528656,
1.0370676517486572,
0.6218587160110474,
-0.3237721025943756,
0.4042494297027588,
-0.2083503156900406,
0.3118768334388733,
-1.0307371616363525,
-0.44677719473838806,
-0.8814331293106079,
-0.20481207966804504,
-0.03626912832260132,
-0.27870824933052063,
0.14054936170578003,
0.34086117148399353,
-0.1669909954071045,
0.3764175474643707,
-0.5344606041908264,
0.8282694816589355,
0.09021900594234467,
-0.36632993817329407,
0.2862805426120758,
-0.08698807656764984,
-0.05044230818748474,
0.086715929210186,
-0.5068939328193665,
-0.9748150110244751,
0.9579829573631287,
0.6922205090522766,
1.0534366369247437,
0.11736330389976501,
0.8479766249656677,
0.3216235041618347,
0.6425676941871643,
-1.0601296424865723,
0.6744024157524109,
-0.10966146737337112,
-0.40440258383750916,
-0.3052785396575928,
-0.4203687608242035,
-1.0028111934661865,
0.38664793968200684,
-0.027148474007844925,
-1.3169195652008057,
-0.3033839762210846,
-0.2628425359725952,
-0.11569086462259293,
0.4957791566848755,
-0.9521181583404541,
0.9863531589508057,
-0.7018129825592041,
-0.19728922843933105,
-0.19367153942584991,
-0.016396544873714447,
0.6210596561431885,
-0.3489367365837097,
0.473073273897171,
-0.304829865694046,
0.19719921052455902,
0.9547916650772095,
-0.25971388816833496,
0.4874532222747803,
0.18413692712783813,
0.06897983700037003,
0.3073967695236206,
0.46670711040496826,
0.12865449488162994,
0.14446155726909637,
-0.0791255459189415,
0.4384705722332001,
0.04407589137554169,
0.06478535383939743,
-0.8549982905387878,
0.9330267310142517,
-0.7621954679489136,
-0.6188156008720398,
-0.21187379956245422,
-0.4529169499874115,
0.08489695936441422,
0.34017691016197205,
-0.2645014822483063,
0.45095789432525635,
-0.6019188165664673,
0.39336124062538147,
0.30353105068206787,
-0.2258312851190567,
0.4383598566055298,
0.7119655013084412,
-1.0178779363632202,
-0.3093717098236084,
0.6787497997283936,
-0.24859221279621124,
0.010747337713837624,
0.1888488084077835,
0.29562366008758545,
-0.46918565034866333,
-0.3027949035167694,
-0.36176905035972595,
0.04865078255534172,
-0.8482664823532104,
-0.1751674860715866,
-0.5403857231140137,
-0.373565137386322,
-0.3236633241176605,
-0.336127370595932,
-0.744735062122345,
-0.4420757293701172,
-0.017789261415600777,
-0.08054349571466446,
0.3657119870185852,
1.1281148195266724,
0.13625425100326538,
0.2550784945487976,
-0.8315076231956482,
0.11958929896354675,
0.06054310500621796,
0.5538479685783386,
0.15440520644187927,
-0.47432488203048706,
-0.19290442764759064,
-0.13512535393238068,
-0.46678414940834045,
-0.560004472732544,
0.29420146346092224,
0.0839579701423645,
0.7040903568267822,
0.47449609637260437,
-0.23846600949764252,
0.760018527507782,
-0.6939479112625122,
0.8458516001701355,
0.46060600876808167,
-1.1687414646148682,
0.41571754217147827,
0.17929315567016602,
0.1972125619649887,
0.73716801404953,
0.32126861810684204,
-0.49223217368125916,
-0.5306135416030884,
-0.597244918346405,
-1.1145412921905518,
0.5062703490257263,
0.067494697868824,
0.24869823455810547,
0.028753915801644325,
-0.23622578382492065,
0.20480883121490479,
-0.004744706675410271,
-0.6702538728713989,
-0.14538805186748505,
0.25427573919296265,
-0.21901443600654602,
0.04392712190747261,
-0.193696066737175,
-0.13375967741012573,
-0.44387707114219666,
0.6112748980522156,
0.07797539234161377,
0.08455105125904083,
-0.15719357132911682,
-0.25125381350517273,
0.014268413186073303,
0.603902280330658,
0.2731075882911682,
0.7540678381919861,
-0.33106017112731934,
0.0774485394358635,
0.3691217005252838,
-0.3236956000328064,
0.2320869117975235,
0.0029541407711803913,
0.09219317883253098,
0.11718421429395676,
0.7327709794044495,
0.8939866423606873,
0.42138898372650146,
-1.1569324731826782,
0.6281118988990784,
-0.4055991470813751,
0.03318922594189644,
-0.500648558139801,
0.09671304374933243,
0.2733559310436249,
0.31243011355400085,
0.34045976400375366,
-0.199345663189888,
0.286281555891037,
-0.4978440999984741,
0.4055157005786896,
0.4221166670322418,
-0.29893258213996887,
-0.21802327036857605,
0.5086240768432617,
0.1459614485502243,
-0.6325018405914307,
0.5104556083679199,
-0.11111871153116226,
-0.4820391833782196,
0.48320475220680237,
0.36246928572654724,
1.406753659248352,
-0.4697699248790741,
0.13071879744529724,
0.13458672165870667,
0.2342974990606308,
-0.18824632465839386,
0.010542057454586029,
0.12998098134994507,
-0.39444485306739807,
-0.5656450390815735,
-1.1006801128387451,
-0.436900794506073,
0.3095807433128357,
-0.5994967222213745,
0.6917672157287598,
-0.32426461577415466,
0.02880878373980522,
0.07956496626138687,
-0.2518799901008606,
-0.7902196645736694,
-0.5392667651176453,
0.25820454955101013,
1.175480842590332,
-0.639689028263092,
0.752512514591217,
0.606296718120575,
-0.20263829827308655,
-0.7477624416351318,
-0.41006094217300415,
0.14854425191879272,
-0.7103806734085083,
0.7520773410797119,
0.2601727247238159,
-0.3174549341201782,
-0.2025352418422699,
-0.3699879050254822,
-0.7752338647842407,
1.030304193496704,
0.5731743574142456,
-0.8205029368400574,
0.09609837085008621,
0.019971268251538277,
0.5334368944168091,
-0.5131539702415466,
0.9714110493659973,
0.8475657105445862,
0.5955291986465454,
0.007783127017319202,
-1.307388424873352,
-0.35492628812789917,
-0.30598095059394836,
0.0944148600101471,
0.3246828019618988,
-0.5272765755653381,
0.53080815076828,
0.1562945395708084,
-0.23727300763130188,
0.14080367982387543,
0.34020477533340454,
0.02892642468214035,
0.025495456531643867,
0.27788877487182617,
0.5458221435546875,
0.7082729935646057,
0.021085307002067566,
1.2275840044021606,
-0.30364346504211426,
0.7565209269523621,
1.2270927429199219,
-0.45715057849884033,
1.0509446859359741,
0.31622597575187683,
-0.4136318862438202,
0.5604333877563477,
0.20196567475795746,
-0.031819358468055725,
0.10624198615550995,
0.42526862025260925,
-0.3723624050617218,
-0.037986449897289276,
-0.09300117194652557,
0.0818827897310257,
0.6011184453964233,
0.3199326694011688,
-0.05813385546207428,
-0.7608301043510437,
0.049710072576999664,
-0.051243774592876434,
-0.010668136179447174,
-0.46073734760284424,
0.7328609824180603,
0.17674212157726288,
-0.3661891520023346,
0.6076101660728455,
0.017324285581707954,
0.5042527914047241,
-0.8099086284637451,
0.06304354220628738,
0.0298091322183609,
0.20717579126358032,
-0.35793811082839966,
-1.0503149032592773,
0.31593531370162964,
0.23372726142406464,
0.1993146538734436,
-0.06096842512488365,
0.6680577397346497,
-0.22987248003482819,
-0.8226542472839355,
0.9127538204193115,
0.47263047099113464,
0.28703880310058594,
0.2276933342218399,
-0.9344832897186279,
0.6711130738258362,
0.07715705037117004,
-0.7332649230957031,
0.42780983448028564,
0.239761620759964,
-0.02279769256711006,
1.0267093181610107,
0.5099838972091675,
0.18494562804698944,
-0.10488361865282059,
0.5404545068740845,
0.920082688331604,
-0.43224188685417175,
0.003631285857409239,
-1.1399232149124146,
0.7185719609260559,
-0.11121847480535507,
-0.08456962555646896,
0.871595025062561,
0.838284969329834,
0.6702671051025391,
0.12307877093553543,
0.8436801433563232,
-0.14437949657440186,
0.4074552357196808,
-0.3043048083782196,
0.779687225818634,
-0.4544459283351898,
0.5584171414375305,
-0.439059853553772,
-1.0893611907958984,
-0.3102356791496277,
0.5243867635726929,
-0.13519403338432312,
-0.0498645082116127,
0.8172542452812195,
0.7527491450309753,
-0.18487268686294556,
-0.12809954583644867,
0.5030432939529419,
0.24689209461212158,
0.5423010587692261,
0.38606497645378113,
0.9646471738815308,
-0.16492050886154175,
0.30014461278915405,
-0.18522295355796814,
-0.39882561564445496,
-0.24488620460033417,
-0.8858223557472229,
-1.100176215171814,
-0.5303670167922974,
-0.17784607410430908,
-0.08985011279582977,
-0.17842286825180054,
1.3009886741638184,
0.378557026386261,
-0.745574414730072,
-0.6896674633026123,
0.3023603856563568,
0.2742190361022949,
0.2073706090450287,
-0.3479256331920624,
0.41055330634117126,
-0.3459400534629822,
-0.9068727493286133,
0.5241008400917053,
0.602971076965332,
-0.23541410267353058,
-0.7852866649627686,
-0.21092040836811066,
0.0795135572552681,
0.017843756824731827,
0.7058734893798828,
0.029822349548339844,
-0.6640806794166565,
-0.048417557030916214,
-0.3048844039440155,
0.0440065860748291,
-0.15187400579452515,
0.867159903049469,
-0.6194249391555786,
0.4448714256286621,
0.5182807445526123,
0.733086109161377,
0.24455894529819489,
-0.2372146099805832,
0.2882561981678009,
-0.39371973276138306,
0.4645923376083374,
0.3072747588157654,
0.7775565385818481,
0.2919023036956787,
-0.21596010029315948,
0.4672352373600006,
-0.28326481580734253,
-0.6795198917388916,
-1.0366512537002563,
0.05903676897287369,
-0.8712356090545654,
-0.3853667676448822,
1.097733497619629,
-0.19305433332920074,
-0.45854002237319946,
-0.11094904690980911,
-0.25623396039009094,
-0.2538353204727173,
-0.34511247277259827,
0.6568942666053772,
0.8135793209075928,
0.02794906310737133,
-0.3018615245819092,
-0.8721625804901123,
0.011654527857899666,
0.04539801552891731,
-0.8374372124671936,
0.1677103489637375,
0.4099303185939789,
0.39818325638771057,
0.01645503006875515,
0.4734295606613159,
-0.17662695050239563,
0.13105931878089905,
-0.3329482972621918,
0.3793167173862457,
-0.02892589196562767,
-0.5101518034934998,
-0.6308865547180176,
-0.008525725454092026,
0.4129999876022339,
0.69676673412323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00942v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00942v1
|
Evaluating the Factuality of Large Language Models using Large-Scale Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-04-01T06:01:17 | 2024-04-01T06:01:17 |
Xiaoze Liu, Feijie Wu, Tianyang Xu, Zhuo Chen, Yichi Zhang, Xiaoqian Wang, Jing Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has significantly transformed the
AI landscape, enhancing machine learning and AI capabilities. Factuality issue
is a critical concern for LLMs, as they may generate factually incorrect
responses. In this paper, we propose GraphEval to evaluate an LLM's performance
using a substantially large test dataset. Specifically, the test dataset is
retrieved from a large knowledge graph with more than 10 million facts without
expensive human efforts. Unlike conventional methods that evaluate LLMs based
on generated responses, GraphEval streamlines the evaluation process by
creating a judge model to estimate the correctness of the answers given by the
LLM. Our experiments demonstrate that the judge model's factuality assessment
aligns closely with the correctness of the LLM's generated outputs, while also
substantially reducing evaluation costs. Besides, our findings offer valuable
insights into LLM performance across different metrics and highlight the
potential for future improvements in ensuring the factual integrity of LLM
outputs. The code is publicly available at https://github.com/xz-liu/GraphEval.
|
[
0.030285654589533806,
-1.0165858268737793,
0.7316985726356506,
0.030561186373233795,
-0.02277560718357563,
0.2162376046180725,
-0.49727317690849304,
-0.33229413628578186,
-0.057889424264431,
0.5044361352920532,
-0.03560910001397133,
-0.7281782627105713,
-0.8768776655197144,
0.0007892423891462386,
-0.5135179758071899,
1.0474307537078857,
-0.03230215981602669,
-0.2171161025762558,
-0.501737654209137,
-0.27934128046035767,
-0.24369975924491882,
-0.4147462844848633,
-0.5217484831809998,
-0.21206147968769073,
0.46442803740501404,
0.3310169279575348,
0.7752780914306641,
0.6463901400566101,
0.40856459736824036,
0.4112941324710846,
-0.036649439483881,
0.4611281454563141,
-0.8815693855285645,
-0.02632548101246357,
-0.28265172243118286,
-0.3401753604412079,
-0.5699706077575684,
0.11375270038843155,
0.8849743604660034,
0.6523938775062561,
-0.056844111531972885,
0.47421401739120483,
-0.08565862476825714,
0.6667584180831909,
-0.4515344202518463,
0.7323561310768127,
-0.7106723189353943,
-0.19162845611572266,
-0.12432517111301422,
0.08515401184558868,
-0.8321564793586731,
-0.9194900989532471,
0.04225916787981987,
-0.41692185401916504,
0.05992859974503517,
0.4041162133216858,
0.8051573038101196,
0.202310711145401,
-0.6792646646499634,
-0.22175846993923187,
-0.7338712811470032,
0.3263138234615326,
-0.9332714676856995,
0.4170113205909729,
0.13470254838466644,
0.48230841755867004,
-0.2499137669801712,
-0.8839232921600342,
-0.7774650454521179,
-0.5485019087791443,
-0.13272516429424286,
0.09334609657526016,
-0.21974661946296692,
0.002322773216292262,
0.5807576775550842,
0.1093359887599945,
-0.59178626537323,
0.20388446748256683,
-0.12940478324890137,
-0.4452904760837555,
0.7129209041595459,
0.245172917842865,
0.3361763656139374,
-0.3096331059932709,
-0.06267978250980377,
-0.028745250776410103,
-0.7282564640045166,
-0.1107058897614479,
0.39256730675697327,
0.5677185654640198,
0.01043760310858488,
0.8354659080505371,
-0.1531730741262436,
0.572486937046051,
-0.04027724638581276,
-0.3868866562843323,
0.42081114649772644,
-0.3214859366416931,
-0.13847386837005615,
0.2776021659374237,
0.8434259295463562,
0.48716387152671814,
0.3897295892238617,
-0.3177683651447296,
-0.15557828545570374,
0.09443474560976028,
0.1340346783399582,
-1.1270475387573242,
-0.1657649576663971,
0.218593567609787,
-0.1336817741394043,
-0.36104896664619446,
-0.04528789594769478,
-0.6326127052307129,
-0.776208758354187,
-0.22331702709197998,
0.27043771743774414,
-0.4390210211277008,
-0.16610084474086761,
-0.06792102754116058,
0.023584773764014244,
-0.08869726210832596,
0.39444443583488464,
-0.4752681851387024,
0.11622639745473862,
0.8007772564888,
0.6116556525230408,
0.0428464412689209,
-0.30045050382614136,
-0.9711453914642334,
0.01886116899549961,
-0.5956699848175049,
0.6489101648330688,
-0.44239652156829834,
-0.22914376854896545,
0.11363160610198975,
0.020912593230605125,
-0.25786134600639343,
-0.47737812995910645,
0.7837488055229187,
-1.1020396947860718,
-0.19822046160697937,
-0.47521358728408813,
-0.8765059113502502,
-0.1309528648853302,
0.6840149760246277,
-0.7930193543434143,
0.9035658836364746,
0.08339523524045944,
-0.9652370810508728,
0.4478762745857239,
-0.573893666267395,
-0.5442207455635071,
0.19389906525611877,
-0.1992340087890625,
-0.4698910117149353,
-0.2646862268447876,
0.1899566501379013,
0.206678569316864,
-0.23140688240528107,
0.5774328112602234,
-0.4629799723625183,
-0.35703954100608826,
0.19273407757282257,
-0.645758867263794,
0.6902115345001221,
-0.07737506926059723,
-0.4187300205230713,
0.10546404868364334,
-0.9476848244667053,
0.028972847387194633,
0.19560804963111877,
-0.6856926083564758,
-0.010703925043344498,
0.23327389359474182,
-0.2470548450946808,
0.11354467272758484,
0.23132804036140442,
-0.7813693881034851,
0.004680115729570389,
-0.5527746677398682,
0.2229270190000534,
0.8806114792823792,
-0.2058211863040924,
-0.0267218966037035,
-0.14087128639221191,
0.3462483286857605,
-0.2739083766937256,
-0.10232125967741013,
0.18024002015590668,
-0.2947935461997986,
-0.6879902482032776,
-0.3118344843387604,
0.6014443039894104,
0.5606168508529663,
-0.5290392637252808,
0.5363278388977051,
-0.8399152159690857,
-0.6863548755645752,
-0.3922935128211975,
0.19392524659633636,
0.3396444022655487,
0.9902485609054565,
0.11213871091604233,
0.1142604798078537,
-0.36764582991600037,
-0.8581658005714417,
-0.3263247609138489,
-0.5858771204948425,
0.13450931012630463,
0.5262144804000854,
0.5689710974693298,
-0.31855472922325134,
0.9675387740135193,
-0.4947430193424225,
0.1777195930480957,
-0.06280434131622314,
0.17892739176750183,
0.25403541326522827,
-0.005294132977724075,
0.4803590476512909,
-0.470333069562912,
-0.3656248152256012,
0.1800963580608368,
-0.8604779243469238,
-0.07728137075901031,
0.27303504943847656,
0.02740386873483658,
0.2787553071975708,
0.40172380208969116,
-0.7233662009239197,
0.3387775421142578,
0.5802257061004639,
-0.44878196716308594,
0.9117296934127808,
-0.1943817436695099,
0.3417699337005615,
-0.8247135281562805,
0.350318968296051,
-0.13500647246837616,
-0.5746814012527466,
-0.17649054527282715,
0.08212316036224365,
0.11301697790622711,
-0.050522055476903915,
-0.12631277740001678,
0.4002174735069275,
-0.1674564778804779,
-0.3097843825817108,
-0.07639709115028381,
0.6636655330657959,
0.2209201157093048,
0.13545727729797363,
-0.43687915802001953,
0.8543462753295898,
0.2969514727592468,
-0.31229710578918457,
0.8201561570167542,
0.4480718970298767,
-0.7360614538192749,
0.3847983181476593,
-0.5350346565246582,
0.17623946070671082,
-0.09426947683095932,
0.4951472580432892,
-1.169753909111023,
-0.2606135606765747,
-0.016344889998435974,
-0.3301420211791992,
0.26101619005203247,
-0.37506455183029175,
-0.8813135027885437,
-0.4666062891483307,
-0.0856582373380661,
0.13262996077537537,
0.3463399112224579,
-0.7916186451911926,
0.7507662773132324,
0.3128955662250519,
-0.22831857204437256,
-0.5638816356658936,
-0.3118191659450531,
0.4020501971244812,
-0.012002235278487206,
-0.9873893857002258,
-0.23202252388000488,
-0.1386677473783493,
-0.3360835909843445,
0.016477636992931366,
0.07257212698459625,
0.3514532744884491,
0.20234106481075287,
0.1569458693265915,
0.494943231344223,
-0.46768656373023987,
0.32485103607177734,
-0.2204599529504776,
0.06610488146543503,
0.5006505846977234,
-0.2598215341567993,
0.4672820270061493,
-0.33179691433906555,
-0.5488035678863525,
-0.19307927787303925,
-0.33042773604393005,
0.7830106616020203,
-0.3377861976623535,
0.7861674427986145,
0.3124338388442993,
-0.12694065272808075,
-0.21208512783050537,
-0.6110216379165649,
0.26269352436065674,
-0.4421374201774597,
0.7501019239425659,
-0.13561943173408508,
-0.7921966314315796,
0.40737390518188477,
-0.3555974066257477,
0.10824237018823624,
0.5442685484886169,
0.6087220907211304,
0.1224232092499733,
1.0988954305648804,
0.18509835004806519,
-0.2673933207988739,
-0.09679525345563889,
-0.10636893659830093,
0.49425315856933594,
-0.5837128162384033,
-0.3458883762359619,
-0.5461037158966064,
-0.0019454153953120112,
-0.62696373462677,
-0.4512038826942444,
0.41984835267066956,
-0.39272621273994446,
-0.4245797097682953,
-0.046921681612730026,
0.05843043699860573,
0.449674129486084,
0.19498059153556824,
0.059079911559820175,
0.5371094346046448,
-0.08829382807016373,
-0.3267415165901184,
0.23504246771335602,
-0.5384652018547058,
-0.7766202092170715,
1.185756802558899,
0.2913089096546173,
0.5170551538467407,
0.2126457542181015,
0.19866487383842468,
0.46522271633148193,
0.596452534198761,
-0.8501491546630859,
0.5677247643470764,
-0.18554829061031342,
-0.6186001300811768,
-0.4888404309749603,
-0.6951546669006348,
-0.5958197712898254,
0.18213801085948944,
-0.2790609896183014,
-0.6056042909622192,
-0.253887414932251,
0.20810028910636902,
-0.11121352761983871,
0.5337744951248169,
-0.6814121007919312,
0.942731499671936,
-0.4183996021747589,
-0.25194987654685974,
-0.23380146920681,
-0.5583658218383789,
0.5289842486381531,
-0.3236307203769684,
0.46867725253105164,
-0.051868703216314316,
0.33577659726142883,
0.7692580819129944,
-0.6367402672767639,
0.7777944803237915,
-0.25079554319381714,
-0.19652585685253143,
0.22874338924884796,
0.2384277880191803,
0.9023730754852295,
0.15515398979187012,
-0.35628920793533325,
0.06200458109378815,
-0.10106667131185532,
-0.3808683454990387,
-0.8054699301719666,
0.7725939154624939,
-0.8312551379203796,
-0.7578096389770508,
-0.3091387152671814,
-0.6282856464385986,
-0.5930233001708984,
0.357976496219635,
-0.14015702903270721,
0.7226589918136597,
-0.43082195520401,
0.055322542786598206,
0.5573228597640991,
-0.21232543885707855,
0.019884496927261353,
0.6645653247833252,
-0.5593504309654236,
-0.32263967394828796,
1.0351773500442505,
0.2440279871225357,
0.28522297739982605,
0.06396728754043579,
0.4305887520313263,
-0.4832649528980255,
-0.6992948651313782,
-0.6493600010871887,
0.27149510383605957,
-0.8530080318450928,
-0.07419462502002716,
-0.5793851613998413,
-0.28531956672668457,
-0.5304301977157593,
0.2691270112991333,
-0.36622971296310425,
-0.333365261554718,
0.22446367144584656,
-0.547959566116333,
0.41792014241218567,
0.7110304236412048,
0.2074091136455536,
0.009904636070132256,
-0.7539151310920715,
0.14713004231452942,
0.4446547031402588,
0.39112892746925354,
0.07987234741449356,
-0.8539397716522217,
-0.20351368188858032,
0.053011178970336914,
0.0354052297770977,
-0.3501911163330078,
-0.021066080778837204,
0.04761863499879837,
0.38662660121917725,
0.5520788431167603,
0.18397997319698334,
0.6806312799453735,
-0.7057582139968872,
0.5145429968833923,
-0.0006916606798768044,
-0.9051513075828552,
0.3673829138278961,
-0.22578980028629303,
-0.14454936981201172,
0.6035624742507935,
0.15078166127204895,
-0.4632891118526459,
-0.38844865560531616,
-0.5471394658088684,
-0.6799744963645935,
0.4989664554595947,
0.04906582087278366,
0.153661847114563,
-0.011542441323399544,
0.4219056963920593,
-0.03871108219027519,
0.19888685643672943,
-0.43812596797943115,
-0.09348630905151367,
-0.16754378378391266,
-0.26660242676734924,
-0.24950635433197021,
-0.3374082148075104,
-0.42519402503967285,
-0.24543753266334534,
0.777298629283905,
-0.2873183488845825,
-0.3079586923122406,
0.044033896178007126,
-0.3306293487548828,
0.008549210615456104,
0.17171704769134521,
0.1934669464826584,
1.0175224542617798,
-0.2290571630001068,
0.2811768651008606,
0.3624038100242615,
-0.33333274722099304,
-0.03471604362130165,
0.28268587589263916,
-0.22569946944713593,
-0.21243058145046234,
0.780882716178894,
0.80924391746521,
0.11867012083530426,
-0.9331013560295105,
0.8507700562477112,
-0.006251945625990629,
-0.041050318628549576,
-0.12777255475521088,
-0.026382464915513992,
0.379923552274704,
0.286078542470932,
-0.004854499362409115,
0.005699902307242155,
-0.048781827092170715,
-0.5467432141304016,
0.21414804458618164,
0.3119490444660187,
-0.2140335738658905,
-0.2239178717136383,
0.559933066368103,
0.1975858062505722,
-0.03516519442200661,
1.0968838930130005,
-0.2300347536802292,
-0.7552785277366638,
0.678396999835968,
0.661641001701355,
0.42844927310943604,
0.08482012897729874,
0.3421693444252014,
0.4027271866798401,
0.4257394075393677,
0.22985416650772095,
-0.13253118097782135,
0.35385727882385254,
-0.9219622015953064,
-0.6478451490402222,
-0.580513060092926,
-0.4039406180381775,
-0.08359847217798233,
-0.25351962447166443,
0.12680235505104065,
-0.5313515663146973,
-0.1863473504781723,
0.003530393587425351,
0.14359921216964722,
-0.4947796165943146,
0.39897406101226807,
0.17731624841690063,
1.0467489957809448,
-0.922911524772644,
0.5443962216377258,
0.4450319707393646,
-0.3195202350616455,
-1.0794577598571777,
-0.08562968671321869,
-0.029735809192061424,
-1.1158287525177002,
0.8326891660690308,
0.053808946162462234,
-0.31770697236061096,
-0.17236390709877014,
-0.6910279989242554,
-0.7179877161979675,
0.9862946271896362,
0.7777824997901917,
-0.6167189478874207,
0.20764970779418945,
0.27015450596809387,
0.5245932936668396,
-0.15529970824718475,
0.3624535799026489,
0.7184406518936157,
0.7862780094146729,
0.25044137239456177,
-0.6633753776550293,
0.31030794978141785,
-0.1607544720172882,
-0.21760258078575134,
-0.05659230425953865,
-0.7983725666999817,
0.46874547004699707,
-0.4300956428050995,
-0.24417859315872192,
-0.2387741357088089,
0.6202090978622437,
0.45802488923072815,
0.22290243208408356,
0.6812337040901184,
0.5888364911079407,
1.379798173904419,
-0.0020119997207075357,
1.2324718236923218,
-0.4038938581943512,
0.4781886339187622,
1.1544276475906372,
-0.7249835133552551,
0.7129800915718079,
-0.006962457671761513,
-0.33346793055534363,
0.5945174694061279,
0.3859517574310303,
-0.20578865706920624,
-0.05240285024046898,
0.38239967823028564,
-0.08877751231193542,
-0.39049530029296875,
-0.11143365502357483,
-0.05011308193206787,
0.49406698346138,
-0.02303479053080082,
-0.18962296843528748,
-0.3081766366958618,
-0.41640424728393555,
0.4164649546146393,
0.2534160614013672,
-0.11226349323987961,
0.4158899784088135,
-0.20148421823978424,
-0.4505840241909027,
0.4434727430343628,
0.0354868546128273,
0.0406516008079052,
-0.47318708896636963,
-0.05629170686006546,
-0.1346287876367569,
0.03049927018582821,
-0.3272911608219147,
-0.7328914403915405,
0.0661240965127945,
0.28402653336524963,
-0.18633049726486206,
0.2759823799133301,
0.5537640452384949,
-0.09168562293052673,
-0.8559233546257019,
0.4222170114517212,
0.3501993715763092,
0.1338941752910614,
0.031105488538742065,
-0.4526340365409851,
0.1039789617061615,
-0.19844883680343628,
-0.1318834125995636,
0.1311861276626587,
0.5059347748756409,
-0.08323760330677032,
0.695579469203949,
0.6420652270317078,
0.22519271075725555,
-0.018081478774547577,
0.3345363140106201,
1.0007942914962769,
-0.3696800470352173,
-0.27085551619529724,
-0.9616333842277527,
0.28884416818618774,
-0.3468049168586731,
-0.09228614717721939,
0.9716199040412903,
0.9509899020195007,
0.429821640253067,
0.30298784375190735,
0.9328806400299072,
-0.09831716120243073,
0.45727241039276123,
-0.5443087220191956,
0.8456990718841553,
-0.16141898930072784,
0.2815299332141876,
-0.3336195945739746,
-0.6843715310096741,
-0.12379328906536102,
0.1329774558544159,
-0.6480556726455688,
0.006791554857045412,
0.6849040985107422,
0.8027856349945068,
0.10123945027589798,
0.11863677203655243,
0.34866559505462646,
0.9309859871864319,
0.5573133826255798,
0.24761301279067993,
0.9516051411628723,
-0.2548839747905731,
0.6873931884765625,
0.24037878215312958,
-0.31281593441963196,
-0.1466710865497589,
-1.0136932134628296,
-0.8376269936561584,
-0.0677734911441803,
-0.4013306498527527,
-0.7418701648712158,
0.056848134845495224,
0.7217109203338623,
0.4442179799079895,
-0.8443315625190735,
-0.08062434196472168,
0.3199794590473175,
0.3291091024875641,
0.15722574293613434,
-0.202291339635849,
0.8817839026451111,
-0.3075673580169678,
-0.5757906436920166,
0.4433533549308777,
0.1812719702720642,
-0.5172670483589172,
-0.14339126646518707,
-0.06398416310548782,
-0.1132521703839302,
0.1829472929239273,
0.8108811974525452,
-0.01603560335934162,
-0.5107862949371338,
-0.8194753527641296,
-0.2671973705291748,
-0.08902610838413239,
0.16620630025863647,
0.41937145590782166,
-0.600990355014801,
0.5855055451393127,
0.3955191373825073,
0.9391246438026428,
0.5919647812843323,
0.2571614384651184,
0.3599526286125183,
-0.5159536600112915,
-0.37102001905441284,
-0.014584911987185478,
0.4830816686153412,
0.4724286198616028,
-0.2995639741420746,
0.3091821074485779,
0.429808646440506,
-0.6154810190200806,
-0.822374165058136,
0.05291435495018959,
-0.8683005571365356,
0.01890105940401554,
1.1145139932632446,
-0.4066094160079956,
-0.36032992601394653,
-0.004096089396625757,
-0.10239244997501373,
0.2950509488582611,
-0.18311744928359985,
0.7688377499580383,
0.927078366279602,
0.0897887721657753,
0.43410027027130127,
-0.594882071018219,
0.0791880413889885,
-0.03453342616558075,
-0.8231424689292908,
0.47888752818107605,
0.7629567384719849,
0.6962448954582214,
0.16697287559509277,
0.4267534017562866,
-0.20263953506946564,
0.06556563824415207,
0.06589668244123459,
-0.11480792611837387,
-0.15665161609649658,
-0.14272306859493256,
0.04561609774827957,
0.3406136631965637,
0.47237569093704224,
0.22330231964588165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00938v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00938v2
|
How Can Large Language Models Enable Better Socially Assistive Human-Robot Interaction: A Brief Survey
| 2024-04-01T05:50:56 | 2024-04-05T21:55:47 |
Zhonghao Shi, Ellen Landrum, Amy O' Connell, Mina Kian, Leticia Pinto-Alva, Kaleen Shrestha, Xiaoyuan Zhu, Maja J Matarić
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.RO
|
Socially assistive robots (SARs) have shown great success in providing
personalized cognitive-affective support for user populations with special
needs such as older adults, children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD), and
individuals with mental health challenges. The large body of work on SAR
demonstrates its potential to provide at-home support that complements
clinic-based interventions delivered by mental health professionals, making
these interventions more effective and accessible. However, there are still
several major technical challenges that hinder SAR-mediated interactions and
interventions from reaching human-level social intelligence and efficacy. With
the recent advances in large language models (LLMs), there is an increased
potential for novel applications within the field of SAR that can significantly
expand the current capabilities of SARs. However, incorporating LLMs introduces
new risks and ethical concerns that have not yet been encountered, and must be
carefully be addressed to safely deploy these more advanced systems. In this
work, we aim to conduct a brief survey on the use of LLMs in SAR technologies,
and discuss the potentials and risks of applying LLMs to the following three
major technical challenges of SAR: 1) natural language dialog; 2) multimodal
understanding; 3) LLMs as robot policies.
|
[
-0.3243764638900757,
-0.7066247463226318,
0.8858927488327026,
0.11377105861902237,
0.023433560505509377,
0.45698460936546326,
-0.2793048024177551,
-0.8804070353507996,
0.12886586785316467,
0.5909925699234009,
-0.47198614478111267,
-0.2490999847650528,
-0.8986316323280334,
0.13225002586841583,
-0.029655789956450462,
0.7124533653259277,
0.02956772781908512,
0.2471402883529663,
0.14021404087543488,
0.05734506621956825,
-0.2882309556007385,
-0.8331257700920105,
-0.8585103154182434,
-0.4251958727836609,
0.5943899750709534,
0.2801753878593445,
0.9134641885757446,
-0.046383120119571686,
0.7085234522819519,
0.3705352246761322,
-0.2399797886610031,
0.1910645067691803,
-0.00953635387122631,
0.08475303649902344,
-0.026053601875901222,
-0.4903169274330139,
-0.730168879032135,
-0.09601845592260361,
0.5087934732437134,
0.7284188866615295,
-0.23188865184783936,
0.01701243221759796,
0.04651438444852829,
0.6500812768936157,
-0.28404536843299866,
0.07705917954444885,
-0.18563403189182281,
0.0828201025724411,
-0.16087569296360016,
0.04316610470414162,
-0.2084323912858963,
-0.3972764015197754,
0.20997771620750427,
-0.44069036841392517,
-0.29370543360710144,
-0.12006331235170364,
0.5065922737121582,
0.3497913181781769,
-0.695884644985199,
-0.45665687322616577,
-1.0708434581756592,
0.6821882128715515,
-0.8585063219070435,
0.250489205121994,
0.7362669706344604,
0.6185998916625977,
-0.4346579909324646,
-0.3166191279888153,
-0.6176666617393494,
-0.4806841313838959,
0.18557016551494598,
-0.18180912733078003,
-0.22364284098148346,
0.2638413906097412,
0.23179148137569427,
-0.06598816812038422,
-0.2922988831996918,
0.35450369119644165,
-0.5394755601882935,
-0.1351301521062851,
0.761984646320343,
0.3244033753871918,
0.39250874519348145,
-0.46310898661613464,
-0.2615836560726166,
-0.1191670149564743,
-0.501400351524353,
0.09873645007610321,
0.35473600029945374,
0.30398961901664734,
-0.4655809998512268,
0.9555480480194092,
0.020331457257270813,
0.5164794921875,
-0.27617549896240234,
-0.03191453963518143,
0.21572087705135345,
-0.3752587139606476,
0.06787928938865662,
-0.3025667667388916,
0.5216527581214905,
0.500225841999054,
0.7048024535179138,
0.03939307853579521,
-0.1941078007221222,
0.07347851246595383,
0.28794923424720764,
-0.28414449095726013,
0.29998886585235596,
0.29398295283317566,
-0.5462564826011658,
-0.001073450199328363,
-0.1610654890537262,
-0.6615791916847229,
-0.9323975443840027,
-0.43665963411331177,
0.2821626663208008,
-0.39154279232025146,
-0.397691935300827,
0.44109758734703064,
-0.1741124838590622,
0.1909351646900177,
0.4311877191066742,
-0.5668689012527466,
0.4197215139865875,
0.6575961709022522,
0.8667969107627869,
0.1730397641658783,
-0.025189481675624847,
-0.3658334016799927,
0.422904372215271,
-0.06004173308610916,
0.5981737375259399,
-0.608267605304718,
-0.5040977001190186,
0.03445983678102493,
0.06644078344106674,
-0.012879966758191586,
-0.35090023279190063,
0.25784945487976074,
-0.22708836197853088,
-0.02931303158402443,
-0.24981795251369476,
-0.13967344164848328,
-0.04968646913766861,
0.27685627341270447,
-0.4851205050945282,
0.479154497385025,
0.1233939528465271,
-0.39704862236976624,
-0.1918005794286728,
-1.000572919845581,
-0.6894648671150208,
0.0749921128153801,
-0.15883663296699524,
-0.0009314417839050293,
0.05759289860725403,
-0.05095977708697319,
0.7590004801750183,
-0.500706136226654,
0.12101782858371735,
-0.5162746906280518,
-0.22854426503181458,
0.5102625489234924,
-0.37123313546180725,
0.7580571174621582,
0.3533930778503418,
-0.3702826499938965,
0.3159688115119934,
-0.4420565068721771,
-0.25547948479652405,
0.18392512202262878,
-0.13742241263389587,
-0.2466118037700653,
0.2508569657802582,
0.21011947095394135,
0.2527742385864258,
0.4302152693271637,
-0.5681907534599304,
-0.23584406077861786,
-0.21660712361335754,
0.6337037086486816,
0.9474523067474365,
-0.15421995520591736,
0.4721260666847229,
-0.5336105823516846,
0.899725079536438,
-0.48201701045036316,
0.47581255435943604,
0.08187232911586761,
-0.5729750394821167,
-0.019679447636008263,
-0.5676860809326172,
-0.009096939116716385,
0.6216850280761719,
-0.7366845011711121,
0.318691611289978,
0.09286896884441376,
-0.4849205017089844,
-0.20701156556606293,
0.11191236972808838,
0.2674352526664734,
-0.0040585072711110115,
-0.11477957665920258,
-0.07142995297908783,
-0.3958168625831604,
-0.8718777894973755,
0.033912673592567444,
-0.2527388036251068,
-0.176531121134758,
0.6136524081230164,
0.14395186305046082,
-0.5744403600692749,
0.6025019288063049,
-0.4018074572086334,
-0.37282970547676086,
-0.3898826241493225,
-0.17380009591579437,
-0.2720711827278137,
0.2782195806503296,
0.3774988055229187,
-0.8260340094566345,
-0.2588443160057068,
0.17388512194156647,
-0.7803587913513184,
0.032888881862163544,
0.12307485938072205,
0.1413659304380417,
0.4623020887374878,
0.3943641483783722,
-0.9392129182815552,
0.3145844042301178,
0.6530717611312866,
-0.06458775699138641,
0.32732492685317993,
-0.43516671657562256,
0.15786655247211456,
-1.1688830852508545,
-0.08871752768754959,
0.2777000963687897,
-0.11807454377412796,
-0.6113879084587097,
-0.051022518426179886,
-0.2572011947631836,
-0.3290823698043823,
-0.3788073658943176,
0.5222545266151428,
-0.28332218527793884,
-0.3165052533149719,
-0.37528467178344727,
0.31304502487182617,
-0.22141654789447784,
-0.11236325651407242,
-0.021198350936174393,
0.5134530663490295,
0.4378621280193329,
-0.5900485515594482,
0.4299064874649048,
0.09818731993436813,
-0.14609357714653015,
0.5620977878570557,
-0.8817257881164551,
0.10225750505924225,
0.030300304293632507,
0.5561491847038269,
-0.8373498320579529,
-0.4782339036464691,
0.47395896911621094,
-0.5012879371643066,
0.017911693081259727,
0.2859398424625397,
-0.7335993051528931,
-0.389736533164978,
-0.4584941864013672,
0.34399282932281494,
0.42520591616630554,
-0.14470191299915314,
0.8267652988433838,
0.878084659576416,
-0.476647287607193,
-0.3784225881099701,
-0.5407962799072266,
0.3039148151874542,
-0.3252960741519928,
-0.7446998357772827,
0.07209216803312302,
-0.1724843680858612,
-0.4977017939090729,
-0.19804976880550385,
0.12343209981918335,
0.04753882810473442,
0.3180326223373413,
0.3389560580253601,
0.42347294092178345,
0.005538179539144039,
0.1271410435438156,
-0.12700393795967102,
-0.09572146087884903,
0.1256830245256424,
0.3377014100551605,
0.7910237908363342,
-0.23206645250320435,
-0.6170885562896729,
-0.5630887746810913,
0.6398686766624451,
0.8105713129043579,
-0.20279233157634735,
0.6582478284835815,
0.5593864321708679,
-0.6644253730773926,
0.24700725078582764,
-0.6737256050109863,
-0.24790413677692413,
-0.520969808101654,
0.3685693144798279,
0.02394125796854496,
-1.0955809354782104,
0.4810817837715149,
-0.2693485915660858,
0.032339539378881454,
-0.13396283984184265,
0.43649157881736755,
-0.35153618454933167,
1.2378032207489014,
0.6597230434417725,
-0.008142606355249882,
0.6450383067131042,
0.15841373801231384,
0.343024343252182,
-1.014756202697754,
-0.467588871717453,
-0.6018460392951965,
-0.1936195194721222,
-0.6046279072761536,
-0.5317592620849609,
0.4963095486164093,
-0.39851710200309753,
-0.41568613052368164,
0.17739936709403992,
-0.3409942090511322,
-0.030004465952515602,
0.1883799135684967,
0.30180326104164124,
0.10024645179510117,
0.08456858992576599,
0.4886015057563782,
0.2145465910434723,
-0.5284280776977539,
-0.9100388288497925,
0.916279137134552,
0.5918856859207153,
1.0243415832519531,
0.394665390253067,
0.5326624512672424,
0.5404329895973206,
-0.03600386157631874,
-0.6864954233169556,
0.7487177848815918,
-0.32336199283599854,
-0.5896506905555725,
-0.5056070685386658,
-0.34552738070487976,
-1.0661505460739136,
-0.16362877190113068,
-0.26673367619514465,
-1.0342483520507812,
0.08423177152872086,
0.08195558190345764,
-0.5562005043029785,
0.20965029299259186,
-0.7887807488441467,
0.3723308742046356,
-0.35509127378463745,
-0.049950093030929565,
-0.674350380897522,
-1.0071842670440674,
0.13593070209026337,
-0.12517432868480682,
0.4998719394207001,
-0.20696423947811127,
-0.0125401820987463,
0.5389639735221863,
0.10012850165367126,
1.2446032762527466,
-0.1710059940814972,
-0.2706093490123749,
0.14808888733386993,
-0.17416317760944366,
0.47403696179389954,
-0.0774187222123146,
-0.2024754136800766,
0.1735897809267044,
0.24849911034107208,
-0.38146305084228516,
-0.448354572057724,
0.6027172803878784,
-0.8890332579612732,
-0.9456541538238525,
-0.4988129436969757,
-0.7209044098854065,
-0.3131391704082489,
-0.07286038249731064,
-0.3811359107494354,
0.502261757850647,
-0.04327356815338135,
0.2322569042444229,
0.5728957653045654,
-0.5358104109764099,
0.28543850779533386,
0.49268096685409546,
-0.13406570255756378,
-0.12943410873413086,
0.7834986448287964,
-0.004134756047278643,
0.514890730381012,
-0.015356902033090591,
0.23287487030029297,
-0.31384730339050293,
-0.31302183866500854,
-0.2916046380996704,
0.39178597927093506,
-0.5762574076652527,
0.06013372167944908,
-0.6308401823043823,
-0.2471374124288559,
-0.5757921934127808,
-0.43858128786087036,
-0.19473670423030853,
-0.45712170004844666,
-0.2099543660879135,
0.08060300350189209,
0.5228835344314575,
1.1996312141418457,
-0.20329158008098602,
0.26132932305336,
-0.9283218383789062,
0.5911895036697388,
0.10324626415967941,
0.336652010679245,
0.09164498746395111,
-0.18191957473754883,
-0.07877147197723389,
0.16124624013900757,
0.03485146537423134,
-0.6946030259132385,
-0.008007721044123173,
-0.25369542837142944,
0.6509906053543091,
0.059608422219753265,
0.24143677949905396,
0.348760187625885,
-0.6463505029678345,
0.9172252416610718,
0.16586175560951233,
-0.7538395524024963,
0.37410470843315125,
-0.4530657231807709,
0.13722826540470123,
0.048225287348032,
0.4413977563381195,
-0.5908238887786865,
-0.23139646649360657,
-0.38087862730026245,
-0.8552095890045166,
0.6666882038116455,
-0.03803586959838867,
0.4038143455982208,
-0.10231172293424606,
0.32978686690330505,
-0.21623976528644562,
0.0936465635895729,
-0.5349355936050415,
0.08866312354803085,
0.2728419005870819,
-0.3166223466396332,
-0.1910371631383896,
-0.2902377247810364,
-0.3190006911754608,
0.1923229992389679,
0.45986202359199524,
0.11131410300731659,
0.2676604092121124,
0.005536514334380627,
0.17909829318523407,
-0.24315856397151947,
0.4197443127632141,
0.7347494959831238,
0.4875761568546295,
-0.08468770235776901,
0.08287631720304489,
0.18479736149311066,
-0.19440828263759613,
0.12357879430055618,
0.1363953948020935,
0.39998871088027954,
-0.5222878456115723,
0.010535784997045994,
0.3697764277458191,
0.16652528941631317,
-1.0363898277282715,
0.33938169479370117,
-0.05547667667269707,
0.2101149708032608,
-0.5392305254936218,
0.0065766251645982265,
0.2843256890773773,
0.8010721206665039,
0.3309629559516907,
0.12484408169984818,
-0.015521563589572906,
-0.6125792860984802,
0.0008730906411074102,
0.9125744700431824,
-0.25453925132751465,
-0.27813658118247986,
0.4329901337623596,
0.2870742678642273,
-0.9757936596870422,
0.016486138105392456,
0.02528824470937252,
-0.3407587707042694,
0.7112297415733337,
0.5780180096626282,
0.5926162600517273,
-0.33237043023109436,
0.41498202085494995,
-0.22512023150920868,
0.5912176966667175,
-0.09879597276449203,
0.3581424951553345,
0.1164354681968689,
-0.624793291091919,
-0.34404852986335754,
-0.12469465285539627,
-0.8043834567070007,
-0.17984184622764587,
-0.5476557016372681,
0.09687317162752151,
-0.6745445132255554,
-0.5566327571868896,
-0.030065419152379036,
-0.15348690748214722,
-0.5105167031288147,
-0.09261319786310196,
0.3818711042404175,
0.4601624608039856,
-0.6137226223945618,
0.6843585968017578,
0.9371911287307739,
-0.12831024825572968,
-0.6410947442054749,
0.11188312619924545,
0.11022169888019562,
-0.6465061902999878,
0.6323783993721008,
-0.07609620690345764,
-0.6788301467895508,
-0.3211796283721924,
-0.40369585156440735,
-0.6518636345863342,
0.9997513890266418,
0.5479357242584229,
-0.23932431638240814,
-0.15143612027168274,
0.31529632210731506,
0.5979570746421814,
-0.3892442286014557,
0.1264045685529709,
0.1884041279554367,
0.602451741695404,
-0.1136249527335167,
-1.0463844537734985,
0.2520761787891388,
-0.10117422789335251,
0.24817179143428802,
-0.02683980017900467,
-0.8297876715660095,
0.6112464666366577,
-0.1938396543264389,
0.006262124050408602,
0.2329079806804657,
0.3295169472694397,
0.47771555185317993,
0.4860827922821045,
0.6127195954322815,
-0.24151118099689484,
0.760925829410553,
0.39500150084495544,
1.3156582117080688,
-0.133543461561203,
-0.18659523129463196,
0.737506628036499,
-0.8564527630805969,
0.730357825756073,
0.33455556631088257,
-0.13881322741508484,
0.2134208083152771,
0.4690038859844208,
0.3587096035480499,
0.03133944794535637,
0.17222924530506134,
-0.5917409658432007,
-0.19183172285556793,
-0.45931023359298706,
-0.43116259574890137,
0.2818765938282013,
0.6952200531959534,
0.02022458426654339,
-0.014012682251632214,
0.3198601007461548,
-0.08838073909282684,
0.2897936701774597,
-0.1793992817401886,
0.5062633752822876,
0.34724369645118713,
-0.2962990403175354,
0.1258004754781723,
0.09650769829750061,
0.8262679576873779,
-0.7648125290870667,
-0.13459201157093048,
0.31116288900375366,
0.18929721415042877,
-0.14219433069229126,
-0.6989837288856506,
0.39974015951156616,
0.18204674124717712,
-0.18440215289592743,
-0.10881669074296951,
0.8588384985923767,
0.0017434429610148072,
-0.4606707990169525,
0.6222929954528809,
0.4534423053264618,
0.13536293804645538,
0.04117747023701668,
-0.6264170408248901,
0.26391667127609253,
-0.2708145081996918,
-0.12103621661663055,
0.6349193453788757,
0.30123287439346313,
-0.24445456266403198,
1.1816121339797974,
0.5236316323280334,
0.11542028933763504,
-0.0014632334932684898,
0.052149537950754166,
0.7622185349464417,
-0.5912681221961975,
-0.07694496959447861,
-0.7134958505630493,
0.28365573287010193,
-0.029525145888328552,
-0.0509699210524559,
0.6219392418861389,
-0.10544787347316742,
0.2673878073692322,
0.13767029345035553,
0.756243884563446,
-0.15011894702911377,
0.4208086431026459,
-0.3282012641429901,
0.7176926732063293,
-0.5565032958984375,
0.39783015847206116,
-0.4239301383495331,
-0.5573084354400635,
-0.2845402657985687,
0.7873964905738831,
-0.4736867845058441,
0.2050948143005371,
0.38224759697914124,
0.8162274360656738,
0.35591793060302734,
0.1696261167526245,
0.38803768157958984,
0.03414070978760719,
0.5238935947418213,
0.3924345374107361,
1.0568768978118896,
0.08936396986246109,
0.29338935017585754,
-0.06398841738700867,
-0.2561567425727844,
-0.04740013927221298,
-0.7324756383895874,
-0.9798611402511597,
-0.5836650729179382,
-0.12851771712303162,
-0.3674960434436798,
0.291786789894104,
1.4774857759475708,
0.5089912414550781,
-0.4152572453022003,
-0.49101462960243225,
0.341801255941391,
0.13716314733028412,
0.19402296841144562,
-0.16765499114990234,
0.09768259525299072,
-0.056288838386535645,
-0.7131093144416809,
0.5149419903755188,
0.3230724036693573,
0.10863440483808517,
-0.42899683117866516,
-0.1259090155363083,
-0.33993807435035706,
0.22097517549991608,
0.9026349782943726,
0.3841191232204437,
-0.8572800755500793,
-0.713184118270874,
0.1844547837972641,
-0.16663441061973572,
-0.275141179561615,
0.5585551261901855,
-0.5255194306373596,
0.08216318488121033,
0.05179090052843094,
0.8905576467514038,
0.11059322208166122,
-0.22275426983833313,
0.8593902587890625,
-0.1974405199289322,
0.1589842587709427,
0.25308260321617126,
0.35505911707878113,
0.4799107313156128,
-0.6305462718009949,
0.49181491136550903,
-0.20825478434562683,
-0.5783763527870178,
-0.9185683727264404,
0.49412956833839417,
-1.1170985698699951,
-0.22768595814704895,
1.399644136428833,
-0.017667410895228386,
0.00045171959209255874,
-0.3681873083114624,
-0.554730236530304,
0.3512536883354187,
-0.3433610498905182,
0.9064154028892517,
0.5986766815185547,
-0.22792118787765503,
-0.257129043340683,
-0.855670154094696,
0.16171494126319885,
0.3715576231479645,
-0.7648921608924866,
0.10955981910228729,
0.43285542726516724,
0.21290326118469238,
0.11226162314414978,
0.6698502898216248,
-0.23348845541477203,
0.20832043886184692,
-0.5216797590255737,
0.06350703537464142,
0.017059046775102615,
-0.1760101616382599,
-0.49900880455970764,
0.04798886179924011,
0.26933416724205017,
-0.018294576555490494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00934v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00934v2
|
ChatGLM-RLHF: Practices of Aligning Large Language Models with Human Feedback
| 2024-04-01T05:39:36 | 2024-04-03T17:04:06 |
Zhenyu Hou, Yilin Niu, Zhengxiao Du, Xiaohan Zhang, Xiao Liu, Aohan Zeng, Qinkai Zheng, Minlie Huang, Hongning Wang, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ChatGLM is a free-to-use AI service powered by the ChatGLM family of large
language models (LLMs). In this paper, we present the ChatGLM-RLHF pipeline --
a reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) system -- designed to
enhance ChatGLM's alignment with human preferences. ChatGLM-RLHF encompasses
three major components: the collection of human preference data, the training
of the reward model, and the optimization of policies. Throughout the process
of integrating ChatGLM-RLHF into production, we encountered and addressed
several unprecedented challenges. We introduce the strategies to mitigate
reward variance for stabilized large-scale training, implement model
parallelism with fused gradient-descent, and design regularization constraints
to avoid catastrophic forgetting in LLMs. Experiments show that ChatGLM-RLHF
brings significant improvements in alignment tasks compared to the supervised
fine-tuned (SFT) version of ChatGLM. For instance, it achieves on average 15\%
more wins against ChatGLM-SFT in Chinese alignment tasks. The work presents our
practices of aligning LLMs with human preferences, offering insights into the
challenges and solutions in RLHF implementations.
|
[
-0.3348897099494934,
-0.506799578666687,
0.2553579807281494,
0.2208753228187561,
0.08469276130199432,
0.37191954255104065,
-0.6088179349899292,
-0.4423538148403168,
-0.015037217177450657,
0.6816083192825317,
-0.9146533012390137,
-0.5383955240249634,
-0.4064030945301056,
-0.1810193508863449,
0.029312890022993088,
1.2131545543670654,
-0.18103709816932678,
0.08662562072277069,
-0.18273353576660156,
-0.23796693980693817,
-0.40960443019866943,
-0.7466105818748474,
-0.8598604798316956,
-0.722636878490448,
0.835099995136261,
0.5937561392784119,
1.025891900062561,
0.7634681463241577,
0.6179438233375549,
0.19736847281455994,
0.19727051258087158,
0.3967127501964569,
-0.7975119352340698,
0.23561659455299377,
-0.09059875458478928,
-0.39668044447898865,
-0.3319038152694702,
-0.10921408981084824,
0.5654419660568237,
0.3966411054134369,
-0.6297391653060913,
0.08418494462966919,
0.09554878622293472,
0.9194568991661072,
-0.5277920961380005,
0.35814934968948364,
-0.22446157038211823,
0.3552667796611786,
0.0026229205541312695,
-0.0734349861741066,
-0.4941936731338501,
-0.4129248857498169,
0.14197249710559845,
-0.6210777759552002,
-0.06415943801403046,
0.40820905566215515,
0.9238176345825195,
0.35770082473754883,
-0.11477719992399216,
-0.2335164099931717,
-0.8495429754257202,
0.9127391576766968,
-0.6661725044250488,
0.21176713705062866,
0.08832571655511856,
0.3871189057826996,
-0.43326839804649353,
-0.2450597882270813,
-0.32767876982688904,
-0.10839512944221497,
-0.11511174589395523,
0.22118447721004486,
0.41060423851013184,
0.23221725225448608,
0.0689103901386261,
0.3159247934818268,
-0.6366699934005737,
0.5276788473129272,
-0.1584220975637436,
-0.35382279753685,
0.8738115429878235,
0.36404725909233093,
0.22277039289474487,
0.15834900736808777,
-0.5047677159309387,
-0.4345199465751648,
-0.8136887550354004,
0.14412839710712433,
0.5547659993171692,
0.49555453658103943,
0.04503944516181946,
0.3596651554107666,
-0.24197404086589813,
0.60312420129776,
-0.011149298399686813,
-0.20756332576274872,
0.08646918088197708,
0.002371256472542882,
-0.14097990095615387,
0.08828459680080414,
0.8519024848937988,
0.2847211956977844,
0.2630229592323303,
-0.20527954399585724,
-0.5021063685417175,
0.027586745098233223,
0.3424799144268036,
-0.5796130299568176,
-0.04883595183491707,
0.22178035974502563,
-0.3946455717086792,
-0.40210649371147156,
-0.025090372189879417,
-0.4264373779296875,
-0.5793243646621704,
-0.27425846457481384,
0.36115050315856934,
-0.09854807704687119,
-0.24078916013240814,
0.13864342868328094,
0.08169501274824142,
0.6272449493408203,
0.4626375138759613,
-1.3360483646392822,
0.25628331303596497,
1.1283308267593384,
0.5767422318458557,
-0.622445285320282,
-0.42810335755348206,
-0.8574029207229614,
0.0014169822679832578,
-0.38169604539871216,
0.5460227131843567,
-0.2865956723690033,
-0.39139753580093384,
0.2674044668674469,
-0.013237006030976772,
0.05727421119809151,
-0.8672212958335876,
0.5704408884048462,
-0.5767777562141418,
0.44647127389907837,
-0.21703165769577026,
-0.6843069195747375,
-0.08569077402353287,
0.4292828142642975,
-0.38762354850769043,
0.9082754850387573,
-0.026793980970978737,
-0.5076634883880615,
0.23312588036060333,
-0.599412739276886,
-0.18040886521339417,
0.0321422703564167,
-0.2181769758462906,
-0.4723282754421234,
-0.2325761616230011,
0.2234092503786087,
0.2668703496456146,
-0.20880217850208282,
0.4322746694087982,
-0.35595467686653137,
-0.41600093245506287,
0.14348754286766052,
-0.29885056614875793,
0.4629036486148834,
0.324952095746994,
-0.23970654606819153,
0.7143649458885193,
-0.28064125776290894,
-0.02088160067796707,
0.05481672286987305,
-0.6063227653503418,
0.3524576723575592,
0.21727639436721802,
0.3219953775405884,
0.28125861287117004,
0.19193267822265625,
-0.28920504450798035,
0.2887638807296753,
-0.4764934778213501,
0.37801066040992737,
0.8433091640472412,
-0.24975843727588654,
0.4895939528942108,
-0.6216917037963867,
0.7246633768081665,
-0.07915633171796799,
0.2990471422672272,
-0.012232936918735504,
-0.22773189842700958,
-0.7179118990898132,
0.016655409708619118,
0.31194841861724854,
0.6238373517990112,
-0.42117127776145935,
0.3823593854904175,
-0.1412123739719391,
-0.28096458315849304,
-0.7304343581199646,
0.3049711287021637,
0.45713117718696594,
0.4560982286930084,
0.11994539946317673,
-0.39373230934143066,
-0.4169521927833557,
-0.9202041029930115,
-0.025749383494257927,
-0.31508129835128784,
-0.027859920635819435,
0.37566304206848145,
0.010304471477866173,
-0.20319941639900208,
0.8680919408798218,
-0.48403072357177734,
-0.33455657958984375,
-0.1580233871936798,
0.2066868394613266,
0.1567111760377884,
0.5737158060073853,
0.07498811930418015,
-0.4988214075565338,
-0.3903636932373047,
0.10935664176940918,
-0.605785608291626,
0.019427139312028885,
-0.018711654469370842,
-0.2946767508983612,
0.4700743854045868,
0.4268595576286316,
-0.5417165160179138,
-0.08742152154445648,
0.6218783259391785,
-0.005826059728860855,
0.6671900153160095,
-0.20978346467018127,
-0.08946747332811356,
-0.7491292357444763,
-0.14906293153762817,
-0.10024514049291611,
-0.5285663604736328,
-0.2544473111629486,
0.17059992253780365,
-0.0934770405292511,
-0.18556971848011017,
-0.6135241985321045,
0.5976307988166809,
-0.2235187441110611,
-0.20064117014408112,
-0.4226249158382416,
0.34063273668289185,
-0.24143077433109283,
1.0188097953796387,
0.40189477801322937,
0.7265114188194275,
0.2662470042705536,
-0.3577434718608856,
0.7058665156364441,
0.17848263680934906,
-0.19697201251983643,
0.4719487130641937,
-0.48183125257492065,
0.2385876625776291,
-0.12415878474712372,
0.3292163610458374,
-0.7518294453620911,
-0.24776628613471985,
0.5181962251663208,
-0.3473673164844513,
0.290214478969574,
0.047436561435461044,
-0.4503888487815857,
-0.20338554680347443,
-0.2796351909637451,
0.16242176294326782,
0.6988575458526611,
-0.7423848509788513,
0.48489728569984436,
0.4584323763847351,
-0.12058588862419128,
-0.714348554611206,
-0.26302412152290344,
0.03502188250422478,
-0.3557659983634949,
-0.6569164395332336,
0.3184874951839447,
-0.0007282824371941388,
-0.04956148937344551,
-0.0750371664762497,
0.026735147461295128,
0.2420799732208252,
0.15834906697273254,
0.3203209340572357,
0.5243062376976013,
-0.13355661928653717,
0.2016977220773697,
-0.44914355874061584,
-0.17728981375694275,
0.0031926718074828386,
-0.47928503155708313,
0.40901830792427063,
-0.21828687191009521,
-0.47371014952659607,
-0.26063987612724304,
0.18452060222625732,
0.2641153037548065,
0.003919509239494801,
0.46478283405303955,
0.7803032994270325,
-0.1284986138343811,
-0.260708749294281,
-0.5409309267997742,
-0.4028686583042145,
-0.4015246629714966,
0.4299415349960327,
0.25260552763938904,
-1.157409429550171,
0.31051552295684814,
-0.08139750361442566,
0.48201239109039307,
0.22161418199539185,
0.6251899003982544,
-0.3031972348690033,
1.3606785535812378,
0.5091984868049622,
-0.43258729577064514,
0.5237680077552795,
0.11616327613592148,
0.013996312394738197,
-0.6600844264030457,
-0.148545503616333,
-0.29474949836730957,
-0.5999702215194702,
-0.6399933695793152,
-0.3516891598701477,
0.19848871231079102,
0.07432102411985397,
-0.5724084973335266,
0.012150070630013943,
-0.3934701383113861,
0.37419992685317993,
0.6049542427062988,
0.06598027050495148,
0.28415632247924805,
-0.21425200998783112,
0.00997282937169075,
0.16915394365787506,
-0.9630603790283203,
-0.5149187445640564,
0.6820220351219177,
0.5846125483512878,
1.0631686449050903,
0.1341264694929123,
0.7705134749412537,
0.20486077666282654,
0.37186890840530396,
-1.0150377750396729,
0.30209875106811523,
0.07661247998476028,
-0.3095270097255707,
-0.6141782999038696,
-0.306213915348053,
-0.9036787152290344,
0.21672973036766052,
-0.425808310508728,
-0.6459043025970459,
-0.2922634184360504,
0.4459935128688812,
-0.4521555006504059,
0.11377272009849548,
-0.7465334534645081,
0.8852144479751587,
-0.44291457533836365,
-0.41017061471939087,
-0.345316082239151,
-0.7157308459281921,
0.43473005294799805,
0.34714406728744507,
0.21371489763259888,
-0.21887493133544922,
0.22787782549858093,
0.6909418106079102,
-0.47172027826309204,
0.9085133075714111,
-0.10580017417669296,
-0.3075938820838928,
0.08034256100654602,
-0.18992748856544495,
0.8666567802429199,
0.011516401544213295,
0.24821332097053528,
-0.22021470963954926,
-0.1625160574913025,
-0.5042887926101685,
-0.6525884866714478,
0.780331015586853,
-1.0395232439041138,
-0.9198864102363586,
-0.4833500385284424,
-0.6877312064170837,
-0.5037242770195007,
-0.013236582279205322,
-0.08724100142717361,
0.06519180536270142,
-0.32607513666152954,
0.0873466208577156,
0.7915268540382385,
-0.31232813000679016,
0.4027125835418701,
0.22816267609596252,
-0.785703182220459,
-0.3444584012031555,
0.976277232170105,
-0.3201048672199249,
0.36550894379615784,
0.3709288537502289,
0.16111662983894348,
-0.42977821826934814,
-0.18136389553546906,
-0.5650919079780579,
0.20712417364120483,
-0.4993115961551666,
-0.06924474239349365,
-0.24270053207874298,
-0.45600011944770813,
-0.17386773228645325,
-0.03525245934724808,
-0.47916075587272644,
-0.17729365825653076,
-0.2560332417488098,
0.030839044600725174,
0.27093252539634705,
0.6296932697296143,
0.10738682001829147,
0.17302873730659485,
-0.8693186044692993,
-0.09243163466453552,
0.4934048652648926,
0.45759034156799316,
0.09657947719097137,
-0.2750775218009949,
-0.5454165935516357,
0.05615466833114624,
-0.40234091877937317,
-0.3078075647354126,
0.3262529969215393,
-0.16764140129089355,
0.4623064696788788,
0.23867179453372955,
-0.028717610985040665,
0.3701379597187042,
-0.3570610284805298,
0.7194868326187134,
0.28838300704956055,
-0.6364852786064148,
0.10635054856538773,
-0.47246208786964417,
0.4249233603477478,
0.2653385400772095,
0.2008543461561203,
-1.0678850412368774,
-0.24634414911270142,
-0.4284549057483673,
-0.7229403257369995,
0.9104213118553162,
-0.057083610445261,
-0.09469050168991089,
0.2773023545742035,
0.16898243129253387,
-0.04201842471957207,
0.1751055121421814,
-0.5643632411956787,
-0.07963111996650696,
-0.0811084657907486,
-0.18838033080101013,
0.005521221552044153,
-0.0017578504048287868,
-0.3638054132461548,
0.15334494411945343,
0.9173815846443176,
-0.2738663852214813,
-0.09823302179574966,
-0.15050503611564636,
-0.14611457288265228,
-0.06138939782977104,
0.34547391533851624,
0.711978554725647,
0.4604964256286621,
-0.18535877764225006,
-0.05951894447207451,
0.03726622089743614,
-0.07582486420869827,
0.16653317213058472,
-0.2628527283668518,
-0.0803350955247879,
-0.4102214574813843,
0.16093061864376068,
1.1728864908218384,
0.2742083966732025,
-0.9684695601463318,
0.27295318245887756,
-0.024238234385848045,
-0.33008840680122375,
-0.16491007804870605,
0.39320656657218933,
0.4937570095062256,
0.30640220642089844,
0.1448574811220169,
-0.2603370249271393,
-0.3150169551372528,
-0.41180339455604553,
-0.015222854912281036,
0.5343644618988037,
-0.7036815881729126,
0.024747803807258606,
0.41230615973472595,
0.27464398741722107,
-0.5477514266967773,
0.81023770570755,
-0.049737364053726196,
-0.5352720618247986,
0.4726037383079529,
0.3508414030075073,
0.7765740752220154,
0.01090722344815731,
0.38891854882240295,
0.23601116240024567,
-0.017520979046821594,
-0.4621424078941345,
0.006209969986230135,
0.004289497621357441,
-0.9317525029182434,
-0.5745109915733337,
-0.47166985273361206,
-0.8131953477859497,
-0.16383175551891327,
-0.5801874995231628,
0.3987356424331665,
-0.48755839467048645,
0.02518227882683277,
-0.32922452688217163,
-0.0953969731926918,
-0.4465412199497223,
-0.06968922913074493,
0.3059854805469513,
0.5038405060768127,
-0.5192281603813171,
0.7680620551109314,
0.48193666338920593,
-0.39949026703834534,
-1.05082106590271,
-0.16978798806667328,
0.19677336513996124,
-1.0442525148391724,
0.6454893350601196,
-0.14309757947921753,
-0.12078264355659485,
0.03932778164744377,
-0.5480842590332031,
-0.6949291825294495,
1.0478802919387817,
0.3572789132595062,
-0.7767254114151001,
-0.12935812771320343,
0.024806862697005272,
0.4598841369152069,
-0.46719831228256226,
0.15016275644302368,
0.579835832118988,
0.35861441493034363,
0.26863065361976624,
-0.8429696559906006,
-0.1806323230266571,
0.09573423117399216,
0.18051935732364655,
0.4389163553714752,
-0.9123693704605103,
0.28760531544685364,
-0.1765059530735016,
-0.2040843665599823,
-0.09653206169605255,
0.7170268893241882,
0.536914050579071,
-0.1591922640800476,
0.5566502213478088,
0.5951998233795166,
0.7123969197273254,
-0.05890391021966934,
0.774118185043335,
-0.15581266582012177,
0.527116596698761,
1.2129985094070435,
-0.4269581735134125,
0.9114355444908142,
0.5759695768356323,
-0.2174385040998459,
0.4006943106651306,
0.9098091125488281,
0.0676078051328659,
0.34461677074432373,
0.5746669769287109,
-0.2537085711956024,
-0.3054511845111847,
-0.31538477540016174,
-0.2772996425628662,
0.219301238656044,
0.12749680876731873,
0.1826046109199524,
-0.2858692705631256,
-0.10050134360790253,
0.025567995384335518,
0.09450658410787582,
-0.2773526906967163,
1.0198649168014526,
0.05040643736720085,
-1.124921202659607,
0.5497989654541016,
-0.04662679135799408,
0.8460140824317932,
-0.5057089924812317,
0.03156580030918121,
-0.24921607971191406,
0.1173553466796875,
-0.2975793480873108,
-0.7516937255859375,
0.3289804756641388,
-0.21501097083091736,
-0.21266385912895203,
-0.39243990182876587,
0.49294212460517883,
-0.8009896278381348,
-0.16250655055046082,
0.261078417301178,
0.19301219284534454,
-0.1771816909313202,
0.19696184992790222,
-0.6958810687065125,
0.11843166500329971,
-0.059327367693185806,
-0.04546530917286873,
0.783524215221405,
0.03887929022312164,
-0.06929228454828262,
0.650714635848999,
0.5898310542106628,
0.1602856069803238,
-0.23253339529037476,
0.2519666850566864,
0.4353503882884979,
-0.7078211307525635,
-0.5063150525093079,
-0.686411440372467,
0.21166731417179108,
0.13703691959381104,
-0.1024567261338234,
0.38968726992607117,
0.31730887293815613,
0.9641430377960205,
-0.0505964457988739,
0.6519991159439087,
0.38343727588653564,
0.4161791205406189,
-0.5956342220306396,
0.5999289751052856,
-0.30735069513320923,
0.2578486204147339,
-0.005295844748616219,
-0.8208478689193726,
-0.20420221984386444,
0.4121464788913727,
-0.015455907210707664,
-0.1159902885556221,
0.5130233764648438,
0.9770205020904541,
0.23690438270568848,
0.005097381304949522,
0.23822860419750214,
-0.1585959643125534,
0.46839001774787903,
0.8079029321670532,
0.9533509612083435,
-0.07772880792617798,
0.6062959432601929,
-0.10681162029504776,
-0.04045898839831352,
-0.28017354011535645,
-1.0682238340377808,
-0.495457261800766,
-0.3825012147426605,
-0.38906991481781006,
-0.3656124472618103,
0.0791114866733551,
1.4891046285629272,
0.8552765846252441,
-0.9239822626113892,
-0.7665931582450867,
-0.0736611932516098,
0.45866596698760986,
-0.39327219128608704,
-0.24730701744556427,
0.16688206791877747,
-0.7803012132644653,
-0.7469645142555237,
0.15057018399238586,
0.5139428973197937,
-0.1515199840068817,
-0.5427005290985107,
-0.6427266597747803,
-0.21583034098148346,
-0.15889889001846313,
0.3840550482273102,
0.6232081651687622,
-0.9213018417358398,
-0.5144117474555969,
0.04880569502711296,
-0.25311678647994995,
0.27051210403442383,
0.8239830732345581,
-0.605012834072113,
0.35186588764190674,
0.48849159479141235,
1.0959906578063965,
0.5307387113571167,
0.16182714700698853,
0.9650498032569885,
-0.5492947697639465,
-0.03581728786230087,
0.21807105839252472,
0.23730310797691345,
0.41162943840026855,
-0.3727826774120331,
0.4380559027194977,
0.0076847621239721775,
-0.8946871161460876,
-0.5803579688072205,
0.29800179600715637,
-0.8317741751670837,
-0.011280842125415802,
0.9899517297744751,
-0.08232990652322769,
-0.1254459023475647,
0.05991187319159508,
-0.41641664505004883,
0.16705335676670074,
-0.5914533138275146,
0.9795057773590088,
1.0924583673477173,
-0.2559128999710083,
-0.2856491506099701,
-0.28812775015830994,
0.7755028009414673,
0.7180253267288208,
-0.7126936316490173,
0.2914610207080841,
0.4980901777744293,
0.007442598231136799,
-0.09852258116006851,
0.6104357838630676,
-0.10315784811973572,
0.27271655201911926,
-0.5878148674964905,
0.21049043536186218,
0.14018400013446808,
-0.09556127339601517,
-0.46308740973472595,
0.11157198250293732,
0.5822586417198181,
-0.22868090867996216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00930v1
|
PSYDIAL: Personality-based Synthetic Dialogue Generation using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T05:19:34 | 2024-04-01T05:19:34 |
Ji-Eun Han, Jun-Seok Koh, Hyeon-Tae Seo, Du-Seong Chang, Kyung-Ah Sohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a novel end-to-end personality-based synthetic dialogue data
generation pipeline, specifically designed to elicit responses from large
language models via prompting. We design the prompts to generate more
human-like dialogues considering real-world scenarios when users engage with
chatbots. We introduce PSYDIAL, the first Korean dialogue dataset focused on
personality-based dialogues, curated using our proposed pipeline. Notably, we
focus on the Extraversion dimension of the Big Five personality model in our
research. Experimental results indicate that while pre-trained models and those
fine-tuned with a chit-chat dataset struggle to generate responses reflecting
personality, models trained with PSYDIAL show significant improvements. The
versatility of our pipeline extends beyond dialogue tasks, offering potential
for other non-dialogue related applications. This research opens doors for more
nuanced, personality-driven conversational AI in Korean and potentially other
languages. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/jiSilverH/psydial.
|
[
-0.4107811748981476,
-0.49355241656303406,
0.9296742677688599,
0.14795002341270447,
-0.29975125193595886,
0.3315739035606384,
-0.2619189918041229,
0.03589871898293495,
0.5695610642433167,
0.5549482107162476,
-1.0221937894821167,
-0.5351664423942566,
-0.13315686583518982,
0.2687889635562897,
-0.02965712733566761,
1.1421736478805542,
0.381367027759552,
0.1988217532634735,
-0.13495393097400665,
0.09070515632629395,
-0.1306343376636505,
-0.7416761517524719,
-0.4568749964237213,
-0.21273194253444672,
0.6765614151954651,
0.4741232395172119,
0.5222653150558472,
0.15525604784488678,
-0.08754421770572662,
0.28291890025138855,
0.08487077802419662,
0.4035452902317047,
-0.5678403973579407,
0.5887714624404907,
-0.3793001174926758,
-0.2975780665874481,
-0.34789061546325684,
-0.07824655622243881,
0.4245932102203369,
0.6297634840011597,
-0.1220969632267952,
0.2614438831806183,
-0.47185444831848145,
0.6183430552482605,
-0.37149733304977417,
0.2682799994945526,
-0.4911347031593323,
0.05840306356549263,
-0.12203986942768097,
-0.29122331738471985,
-0.42419055104255676,
-0.3409845530986786,
0.4407467246055603,
-0.43465426564216614,
0.2035355418920517,
-0.07889693975448608,
0.29293376207351685,
0.1015465036034584,
-0.33335694670677185,
-0.26387444138526917,
-0.8006687760353088,
0.6396978497505188,
-0.7472535967826843,
0.216048002243042,
0.2045339196920395,
0.5148756504058838,
-0.23924149572849274,
-0.7097262144088745,
-0.7209620475769043,
-0.5110484957695007,
0.1938929557800293,
0.2166236937046051,
0.14557097852230072,
0.2182379812002182,
0.1552734375,
0.3382088243961334,
-0.5240129828453064,
-0.26024332642555237,
-0.3878794014453888,
-0.17754384875297546,
0.9537819027900696,
0.32255175709724426,
0.3291071355342865,
-0.14455388486385345,
0.21680425107479095,
-0.1592041403055191,
-0.6455171704292297,
0.0877615213394165,
1.027111291885376,
0.44402799010276794,
-0.09537725895643234,
0.63039630651474,
-0.5512820482254028,
0.39773908257484436,
0.4040144979953766,
-0.21644708514213562,
0.16540241241455078,
-0.45119598507881165,
0.11425245553255081,
0.25830551981925964,
0.9551923871040344,
0.5971993803977966,
0.47014760971069336,
-0.0016224434366449714,
0.04704825207591057,
0.13468597829341888,
0.40179163217544556,
-1.053336501121521,
-0.823600709438324,
0.6281281113624573,
-0.40530285239219666,
-0.7011911273002625,
0.0633104220032692,
-0.7675595879554749,
-0.7428046464920044,
-0.25255587697029114,
-0.20386157929897308,
-0.4240710735321045,
-0.5348597764968872,
-0.037632089108228683,
-0.14461219310760498,
0.0385839082300663,
0.3145180642604828,
-0.9794901609420776,
0.09119509160518646,
0.6139478087425232,
0.8155363202095032,
-0.010241532698273659,
-0.35747385025024414,
-0.6431284546852112,
-0.238878533244133,
-0.49223822355270386,
0.5303100943565369,
-0.6637666821479797,
-0.724373996257782,
-0.06775691360235214,
0.032785508781671524,
0.16295072436332703,
-0.5077531933784485,
0.3207072615623474,
0.04612614959478378,
0.4043991267681122,
-0.3084058463573456,
-0.41263625025749207,
0.1789156198501587,
-0.07184793055057526,
-0.16849729418754578,
0.5938949584960938,
0.37082335352897644,
-0.6901703476905823,
0.12760965526103973,
-0.684721827507019,
-0.23040178418159485,
0.3761255443096161,
-0.3578348457813263,
-0.25428205728530884,
0.13076196610927582,
-0.050452183932065964,
0.4447599947452545,
-0.24712130427360535,
0.5116168260574341,
-0.498159259557724,
-0.19627745449543,
0.5638383626937866,
-0.21635481715202332,
0.6944082975387573,
0.1059868335723877,
-0.17247697710990906,
0.5703750848770142,
-0.7322908043861389,
0.14114010334014893,
0.18255995213985443,
0.19918516278266907,
-0.024346845224499702,
-0.0024383908603340387,
0.07385234534740448,
0.657647430896759,
0.21885713934898376,
-1.038443922996521,
0.26787665486335754,
-0.4355645775794983,
0.5800102353096008,
0.7815183401107788,
0.07966909557580948,
0.46314361691474915,
-0.31758788228034973,
0.7528828382492065,
-0.04908684268593788,
-0.01931893639266491,
-0.6275200247764587,
-0.6793457865715027,
-0.36565858125686646,
-0.46630868315696716,
-0.18854665756225586,
0.5444439649581909,
-0.7472739815711975,
0.4703309237957001,
-0.0843132957816124,
-0.9859198927879333,
-0.5639743208885193,
0.015477652661502361,
0.3634677529335022,
0.4818143844604492,
-0.044068414717912674,
-0.2452743798494339,
-0.753925621509552,
-0.833859384059906,
-0.02251914143562317,
-0.5560612082481384,
-0.2804999053478241,
0.7300581932067871,
0.2552151083946228,
-0.20856106281280518,
0.9910048246383667,
-0.5715660452842712,
0.3073224425315857,
-0.6978159546852112,
-0.10891320556402206,
0.33151480555534363,
0.13003337383270264,
0.49916982650756836,
-0.5847163796424866,
-0.8039138913154602,
-0.011394023895263672,
-0.49991461634635925,
-0.370432049036026,
-0.21321018040180206,
-0.11375855654478073,
0.04227901250123978,
0.42018964886665344,
-1.1427761316299438,
0.04826652258634567,
0.5354946851730347,
-0.37656402587890625,
1.0976707935333252,
-0.14773662388324738,
-0.06763450056314468,
-1.3162387609481812,
0.17833594977855682,
-0.13828514516353607,
-0.155057892203331,
-0.9750811457633972,
-0.1416832059621811,
-0.26113855838775635,
-0.5639852285385132,
-0.4641627371311188,
0.6954197883605957,
0.2018212527036667,
-0.07047198712825775,
-0.22655494511127472,
0.08759981393814087,
-0.10931143909692764,
0.6952599883079529,
0.28835219144821167,
0.7463531494140625,
0.6354710459709167,
-0.49396222829818726,
0.9436899423599243,
0.42922478914260864,
-0.012965078465640545,
0.8373635411262512,
-0.8118745684623718,
0.45594149827957153,
-0.25812530517578125,
0.9345747828483582,
-1.0969350337982178,
-0.6244856119155884,
0.34972164034843445,
-0.5411597490310669,
-0.146271213889122,
-0.3889118731021881,
-0.3720906376838684,
-0.4224484860897064,
-0.5098764300346375,
0.004254601895809174,
0.49034667015075684,
-0.5490197539329529,
0.33919477462768555,
0.171020969748497,
-0.732088565826416,
-0.0030097353737801313,
0.050158411264419556,
0.11368919909000397,
-0.3034282326698303,
-0.5758306384086609,
0.2850811183452606,
-0.3914865553379059,
-0.26743748784065247,
-0.6057508587837219,
0.11160802841186523,
0.16178922355175018,
-0.29065340757369995,
0.3826235234737396,
0.39719122648239136,
-0.03882775455713272,
-0.13477958738803864,
0.21032199263572693,
-0.10148998349905014,
0.23423174023628235,
-0.5091941952705383,
0.9689132571220398,
-0.18211401998996735,
-0.23268918693065643,
-0.8560010194778442,
0.50880366563797,
0.9019709825515747,
-0.1868640035390854,
0.7557989954948425,
0.6022831201553345,
0.13443514704704285,
0.00488879531621933,
-0.07346091419458389,
-0.4519054591655731,
-0.52801513671875,
0.6456745266914368,
-0.41340184211730957,
-0.7197540998458862,
0.3702119290828705,
-0.11833368241786957,
0.2479647547006607,
-0.1733558475971222,
0.8705710172653198,
-0.13216112554073334,
1.5885413885116577,
0.23167063295841217,
0.07413292676210403,
0.3564905822277069,
0.09105715900659561,
0.6410667300224304,
-0.681812584400177,
-0.1488863080739975,
0.02224966324865818,
-0.19156336784362793,
-0.8641300797462463,
-0.11692433804273605,
0.09095313400030136,
-0.2642221748828888,
-0.3158552646636963,
0.24273915588855743,
-0.30604246258735657,
0.27500101923942566,
0.45156630873680115,
-0.15157589316368103,
-0.049219049513339996,
-0.327434778213501,
0.032613832503557205,
-0.19983819127082825,
-0.41507819294929504,
-0.47408682107925415,
1.2818738222122192,
0.3506733477115631,
0.3701079785823822,
0.10575465112924576,
0.6843401193618774,
-0.052641499787569046,
0.08348994702100754,
-0.8948071599006653,
0.6866337656974792,
0.08959107846021652,
-0.3254086673259735,
-0.2738746106624603,
-0.4741710126399994,
-0.6108208894729614,
0.02923613414168358,
0.037165310233831406,
-0.9258227944374084,
-0.13867023587226868,
0.1725519746541977,
-0.6710134148597717,
0.095942921936512,
-0.667484700679779,
0.628419041633606,
0.01676171086728573,
-0.08906446397304535,
0.06325312703847885,
-0.7348445653915405,
0.2856801450252533,
0.04633147269487381,
-0.3326072692871094,
-0.1889883428812027,
0.30194053053855896,
0.3436782658100128,
-0.6850017309188843,
0.7160719037055969,
-0.49776241183280945,
-0.23511813580989838,
0.12571454048156738,
0.17723557353019714,
0.6018308997154236,
0.5655573606491089,
0.12816017866134644,
-0.06382067501544952,
0.19166921079158783,
-0.36321333050727844,
-0.8155814409255981,
0.6163679957389832,
-0.7169976234436035,
-0.42627254128456116,
-0.1513756662607193,
-0.6596606373786926,
-0.5551051497459412,
-0.07568078488111496,
0.43894490599632263,
0.377864807844162,
-0.07225161045789719,
0.023073306307196617,
0.5616353154182434,
-0.7078772187232971,
0.020422210916876793,
0.5014275908470154,
-0.6379701495170593,
-0.4263167381286621,
1.2464245557785034,
-0.3854857385158539,
0.3643520772457123,
-0.1324884593486786,
0.30991607904434204,
-0.38531699776649475,
-0.2158471792936325,
-0.7451152801513672,
0.3539779782295227,
-0.2575182020664215,
0.15567825734615326,
-0.7575350403785706,
-0.38223010301589966,
-0.6305897831916809,
-0.06501483917236328,
-0.7372086644172668,
-0.3381470739841461,
0.07914090156555176,
-0.18386423587799072,
0.424501895904541,
0.7177203893661499,
0.3245489299297333,
0.25186339020729065,
-0.6244376301765442,
0.32252660393714905,
0.5518721342086792,
0.1921766996383667,
-0.3412291407585144,
-0.3563699424266815,
0.12537096440792084,
0.2644926607608795,
-0.20279152691364288,
-0.8901756405830383,
0.8111746907234192,
0.2667509913444519,
0.25481003522872925,
0.6079148054122925,
0.16140446066856384,
0.3196558654308319,
-0.6195078492164612,
0.8855379819869995,
0.03954596072435379,
-0.5954509377479553,
0.6579270958900452,
-0.7999230623245239,
0.3828555643558502,
0.4996611475944519,
0.28551098704338074,
-1.057773232460022,
-0.46383586525917053,
-0.7117671370506287,
-0.6891469955444336,
0.7758764624595642,
0.3412889540195465,
0.43878865242004395,
-0.016035404056310654,
0.33756157755851746,
0.22658702731132507,
0.6128944754600525,
-0.05860406160354614,
-0.29408982396125793,
-0.4069732129573822,
-0.3528187870979309,
-0.11872141808271408,
-0.006244198884814978,
-0.008295557461678982,
-0.3031952381134033,
0.5471492409706116,
-0.3977172374725342,
0.38359326124191284,
0.17388923466205597,
0.23229444026947021,
-0.018145710229873657,
0.09933760017156601,
0.6670560240745544,
0.5569776296615601,
-0.2517431080341339,
-0.2297775000333786,
-0.12893125414848328,
-0.5495253205299377,
0.08538435399532318,
-0.0041941809467971325,
-0.11299619823694229,
0.1276557296514511,
-0.17790468037128448,
0.9341667294502258,
-0.1660936027765274,
-1.0962773561477661,
0.4191494584083557,
-0.28075048327445984,
-0.1759956330060959,
-0.5859242677688599,
0.12406845390796661,
0.16908733546733856,
0.18304705619812012,
0.1869673728942871,
0.012195361778140068,
0.0503237247467041,
-0.6827859878540039,
0.04565402492880821,
0.19743207097053528,
-0.32758069038391113,
-0.687346875667572,
0.4088074266910553,
0.35925838351249695,
-0.6445850133895874,
0.7815982103347778,
-0.5061297416687012,
-0.6310369372367859,
0.3489358723163605,
0.5743943452835083,
0.7936056852340698,
-0.4153311848640442,
0.8811109662055969,
0.39443984627723694,
-0.42029374837875366,
0.13717876374721527,
0.33104196190834045,
-0.30201101303100586,
-0.766850471496582,
-0.3727585971355438,
-0.4494701027870178,
-0.7417077422142029,
0.5175295472145081,
-0.38616031408309937,
0.15689799189567566,
-0.8641210198402405,
0.03693115711212158,
-0.0847841426730156,
0.06410250812768936,
-0.12332498282194138,
-0.16526174545288086,
0.4048291742801666,
0.446978360414505,
-0.8552662134170532,
0.7821027040481567,
0.7332568764686584,
-0.060866061598062515,
-0.5054349899291992,
0.08523618429899216,
0.2674257159233093,
-0.2600788176059723,
0.38011422753334045,
0.39490851759910583,
-0.14544211328029633,
0.1069960817694664,
-0.6134605407714844,
-0.5860697627067566,
0.8660650849342346,
0.3900342583656311,
-0.45043569803237915,
-0.13734956085681915,
0.21298833191394806,
0.8156503438949585,
-0.5477704405784607,
0.3207796514034271,
0.576784074306488,
0.11709537357091904,
0.09928874671459198,
-0.868054211139679,
-0.20365047454833984,
-0.8491238951683044,
0.11958302557468414,
-0.028503570705652237,
-0.7667825818061829,
0.7093425393104553,
-0.15407316386699677,
0.027651706710457802,
0.5302654504776001,
0.5219113230705261,
0.9294227957725525,
0.19009028375148773,
0.3914209306240082,
0.11988212168216705,
0.9665749669075012,
0.21593442559242249,
1.031225323677063,
-0.6214632391929626,
-0.07120142132043839,
1.2067053318023682,
-0.6706996560096741,
0.4970126748085022,
0.39873006939888,
-0.2397710084915161,
0.6557716727256775,
0.7879536747932434,
0.11415805667638779,
0.4517596662044525,
0.22262370586395264,
-0.6362451314926147,
-0.15045204758644104,
-0.2825752794742584,
-0.07588335126638412,
0.4641495645046234,
0.39690619707107544,
-0.2970297932624817,
0.36977726221084595,
0.059738703072071075,
0.018878242000937462,
-0.02259465679526329,
0.04559309035539627,
0.6332312226295471,
-0.11767180263996124,
-0.903042733669281,
0.19628767669200897,
-0.0937177762389183,
0.6384954452514648,
-0.6200200915336609,
0.033527690917253494,
-0.3103666603565216,
0.013359942473471165,
-0.11785059422254562,
-0.7066253423690796,
0.021107478067278862,
-0.06904216855764389,
-0.04654065892100334,
-0.4055740237236023,
0.5506313443183899,
-0.591204822063446,
-0.26049408316612244,
-0.1688823401927948,
0.420014351606369,
0.4394172728061676,
-0.4066144824028015,
-0.5489583611488342,
-0.35349926352500916,
0.08543598651885986,
-0.0004221599956508726,
0.3137551248073578,
0.3531307876110077,
-0.03825068846344948,
0.7660240530967712,
0.9220595359802246,
0.24823403358459473,
-0.16929170489311218,
0.4474659264087677,
0.6664549112319946,
-0.35922971367836,
-0.7894603610038757,
-0.7707986831665039,
0.4236343502998352,
-0.33751678466796875,
-0.4584481716156006,
0.7521089315414429,
0.4145219624042511,
0.6661944389343262,
-0.2985799014568329,
1.0107758045196533,
-0.024348685517907143,
0.6357666254043579,
-0.048365868628025055,
0.8339968919754028,
0.13000842928886414,
-0.034650757908821106,
-0.48396429419517517,
-0.9053136110305786,
0.3692047595977783,
0.5704336166381836,
-0.20665523409843445,
0.1285383552312851,
0.4154323637485504,
0.9596742391586304,
0.10385777056217194,
0.31856033205986023,
0.42674392461776733,
0.24489983916282654,
0.4719063341617584,
0.504635751247406,
1.0401523113250732,
0.06550265848636627,
0.20263133943080902,
-0.48223763704299927,
-0.07035429775714874,
-0.13592509925365448,
-0.3248186707496643,
-1.084252953529358,
-0.9130834341049194,
-0.17353203892707825,
-0.4506896138191223,
0.004023303743451834,
1.3113280534744263,
0.6269403100013733,
-0.7729120254516602,
-0.09013266116380692,
-0.6091087460517883,
-0.3628104627132416,
0.19241251051425934,
-0.2664942443370819,
-0.0645853728055954,
-0.1715749204158783,
-0.8893613815307617,
0.4845946133136749,
0.49608567357063293,
-0.04715292900800705,
-0.8343951106071472,
-0.285302996635437,
0.23301705718040466,
0.2239474505186081,
0.6480969786643982,
0.38475751876831055,
-0.47669029235839844,
-0.10889489948749542,
0.2279818058013916,
0.13150222599506378,
-0.10808612406253815,
1.0628231763839722,
-0.7935556173324585,
0.4792523980140686,
0.4557833969593048,
0.3350079357624054,
0.31399059295654297,
-0.019806740805506706,
1.1750829219818115,
-0.8741241693496704,
0.27330145239830017,
0.255465567111969,
0.1687079817056656,
0.5774919390678406,
-0.55177241563797,
0.1521299183368683,
0.25324469804763794,
-0.4441927373409271,
-0.789007842540741,
0.6600151658058167,
-0.61446613073349,
-0.011682811193168163,
1.199722170829773,
-0.27171263098716736,
-0.10072707384824753,
-0.3695826232433319,
-0.8074070811271667,
0.1448364555835724,
-0.6455069184303284,
0.9007537961006165,
0.7389135360717773,
-0.37772223353385925,
-0.26910898089408875,
-0.48564237356185913,
0.7965168952941895,
0.4534599184989929,
-0.9039987325668335,
0.4255964756011963,
0.4506863057613373,
0.15067431330680847,
0.1945992261171341,
0.7065243721008301,
0.029090235009789467,
0.552889347076416,
-0.0576867051422596,
-0.29832857847213745,
0.12667754292488098,
-0.49379655718803406,
-0.18704596161842346,
-0.2054753601551056,
-0.17065384984016418,
0.23951222002506256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00929v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00929v2
|
A Survey on Multilingual Large Language Models: Corpora, Alignment, and Bias
| 2024-04-01T05:13:56 | 2024-06-06T16:04:15 |
Yuemei Xu, Ling Hu, Jiayi Zhao, Zihan Qiu, Yuqi Ye, Hanwen Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Based on the foundation of Large Language Models (LLMs), Multilingual Large
Language Models (MLLMs) have been developed to address the challenges of
multilingual natural language processing tasks, hoping to achieve knowledge
transfer from high-resource to low-resource languages. However, significant
limitations and challenges still exist, such as language imbalance,
multilingual alignment, and inherent bias. In this paper, we aim to provide a
comprehensive analysis of MLLMs, delving deeply into discussions surrounding
these critical issues. First of all, we start by presenting an overview of
MLLMs, covering their evolution, key techniques, and multilingual capacities.
Secondly, we explore widely utilized multilingual corpora for MLLMs' training
and multilingual datasets oriented for downstream tasks that are crucial for
enhancing the cross-lingual capability of MLLMs. Thirdly, we survey the
existing studies on multilingual representations and investigate whether the
current MLLMs can learn a universal language representation. Fourthly, we
discuss bias on MLLMs including its category and evaluation metrics, and
summarize the existing debiasing techniques. Finally, we discuss existing
challenges and point out promising research directions. By demonstrating these
aspects, this paper aims to facilitate a deeper understanding of MLLMs and
their potentiality in various domains.
|
[
-0.5212801694869995,
-0.5547245740890503,
0.36866721510887146,
0.13712121546268463,
0.17138449847698212,
0.36596882343292236,
-0.5228384733200073,
-0.5890841484069824,
-0.0874636173248291,
0.4726978540420532,
-0.5924767851829529,
-0.26693418622016907,
-0.7469024062156677,
0.2992091774940491,
-0.163871169090271,
1.006394624710083,
-0.1009499654173851,
0.6310420632362366,
-0.029960233718156815,
-0.42400920391082764,
-0.5480026602745056,
-0.9589371085166931,
-0.2082294076681137,
-0.20938560366630554,
0.6307936310768127,
0.15010830760002136,
0.5986399054527283,
0.17941145598888397,
0.514376163482666,
0.2442685216665268,
-0.20440556108951569,
0.11172302812337875,
-0.4639911353588104,
0.24402014911174774,
-0.12098844349384308,
-0.1346665769815445,
-0.3257997930049896,
-0.10219758003950119,
0.9438669085502625,
1.132999300956726,
0.060687098652124405,
0.3137136399745941,
0.21713046729564667,
0.5724445581436157,
-0.6576329469680786,
-0.08807438611984253,
-0.6666944026947021,
0.11018095910549164,
-0.32742586731910706,
0.28265658020973206,
-0.39625084400177,
-0.09923656284809113,
0.07201995700597763,
-0.2728419899940491,
-0.023828327655792236,
0.17789246141910553,
0.3900981843471527,
0.040745366364717484,
-0.8191124200820923,
-0.42923951148986816,
-0.6703863143920898,
1.136430025100708,
-0.6684946417808533,
0.7409451007843018,
0.07818286120891571,
0.3267268240451813,
0.16454574465751648,
-0.19317616522312164,
-0.1789812594652176,
-0.16987118124961853,
-0.007793068885803223,
-0.2687394618988037,
0.11832192540168762,
-0.2707985043525696,
0.18145422637462616,
0.33961132168769836,
-0.728049099445343,
0.5052410960197449,
-0.344251811504364,
-0.29569509625434875,
0.6050850749015808,
0.17912322282791138,
0.24825608730316162,
0.10345087200403214,
-0.43414291739463806,
0.17868302762508392,
-0.85616534948349,
-0.1550019383430481,
0.5693797469139099,
0.40552717447280884,
-0.20831076800823212,
0.7043242454528809,
0.10959263145923615,
0.8606786727905273,
-0.2763773500919342,
-0.22096702456474304,
0.4170582890510559,
-0.5657910108566284,
-0.16946280002593994,
0.030490202829241753,
0.7410566806793213,
0.1806521862745285,
0.3777464032173157,
-0.06277535110712051,
-0.012849490158259869,
-0.24461881816387177,
0.029188143089413643,
-0.5912060737609863,
0.383068710565567,
0.32098373770713806,
-0.48899203538894653,
-0.05824263393878937,
-0.16564783453941345,
-0.8721679449081421,
-0.5738311409950256,
-0.6543847918510437,
-0.21466079354286194,
-0.17316533625125885,
-0.525052547454834,
-0.04620015248656273,
0.18201975524425507,
0.16899614036083221,
0.30355972051620483,
-0.9226976037025452,
-0.02374451793730259,
0.6837091445922852,
0.5398228168487549,
-0.3476766049861908,
-0.48795318603515625,
-0.30003735423088074,
0.15562129020690918,
-0.26817306876182556,
0.43421000242233276,
-0.5887253880500793,
-0.08836100995540619,
0.5017412900924683,
0.1404380202293396,
-0.025010723620653152,
-0.3986540734767914,
0.3423292338848114,
-0.5409145951271057,
0.2635834515094757,
-0.56416916847229,
-0.45743101835250854,
-0.15218918025493622,
0.7088744044303894,
-0.8215581774711609,
0.7862834930419922,
-0.19730107486248016,
-0.8632032871246338,
0.2850680351257324,
-0.3775247633457184,
-0.2844271659851074,
-0.2653619647026062,
-0.1632407307624817,
-0.12582729756832123,
-0.028091920539736748,
0.23064398765563965,
0.4639506936073303,
-0.3954448997974396,
0.6511395573616028,
-0.591338574886322,
-0.0032437124755233526,
0.34638601541519165,
-0.6793715357780457,
1.2145651578903198,
0.3653923571109772,
-0.1696988344192505,
0.20564118027687073,
-0.7331545948982239,
-0.11829645186662674,
-0.09919112175703049,
-0.24100781977176666,
-0.30754920840263367,
-0.23681959509849548,
0.32392793893814087,
0.47771337628364563,
0.4692654609680176,
-0.4196934401988983,
0.29474306106567383,
-0.04663783684372902,
0.23996810615062714,
0.7472608089447021,
-0.3792177736759186,
0.5569960474967957,
0.12003175169229507,
0.4899267852306366,
0.0794118344783783,
0.3031765818595886,
-0.04631203040480614,
-0.30104318261146545,
-0.46463853120803833,
-0.18409720063209534,
0.38824179768562317,
0.5710499286651611,
-0.3751014769077301,
0.09773151576519012,
-0.15759603679180145,
-0.198327898979187,
-0.763361930847168,
0.5443975329399109,
0.37883293628692627,
0.04114821180701256,
0.300606906414032,
0.02146272547543049,
-0.6435883045196533,
-1.07998788356781,
-0.07326953113079071,
0.1948246955871582,
0.21164590120315552,
-0.05276251584291458,
0.36432626843452454,
-0.28695395588874817,
0.5199471116065979,
-0.10321847349405289,
-0.23997385799884796,
-0.3245912194252014,
-0.15533249080181122,
0.020996471866965294,
0.31483954191207886,
0.5332223773002625,
-0.897131085395813,
-0.50658118724823,
0.23947569727897644,
-0.8773521780967712,
-0.05044185370206833,
0.18553054332733154,
0.01767677441239357,
0.5024076104164124,
0.5499510169029236,
-0.6866959929466248,
-0.07255904376506805,
0.9725827574729919,
-0.16382786631584167,
0.726124107837677,
-0.012094409205019474,
-0.07299160957336426,
-0.8981829285621643,
0.2737866938114166,
0.012801471166312695,
-0.0767204761505127,
-0.6469029188156128,
0.24142314493656158,
0.11926931887865067,
0.07476732134819031,
-0.4667614996433258,
0.7274139523506165,
-0.8818110823631287,
-0.21047155559062958,
-0.07379540055990219,
0.2624586224555969,
-0.057930391281843185,
0.397360622882843,
0.06450353562831879,
0.3801698088645935,
0.5690186023712158,
-0.41545823216438293,
0.388116717338562,
0.12127238512039185,
-0.406970351934433,
0.5617982745170593,
-0.2425537407398224,
0.02948756329715252,
-0.330774188041687,
0.12813223898410797,
-0.8204192519187927,
0.11206328868865967,
0.1874869167804718,
-0.06433766335248947,
0.625078558921814,
-0.12182218581438065,
-0.4207923114299774,
-0.25440919399261475,
-0.26488229632377625,
0.5662739276885986,
0.1517358422279358,
-0.35215312242507935,
0.2730748653411865,
0.5412389039993286,
-0.22131407260894775,
-1.2167479991912842,
-0.5162674784660339,
0.22843927145004272,
-0.29807862639427185,
-0.3679792881011963,
0.020997263491153717,
-0.2670414447784424,
-0.7147750854492188,
-0.06666888296604156,
0.2742094099521637,
0.14867796003818512,
-0.013536804355680943,
-0.13233354687690735,
0.37736135721206665,
-0.3127848207950592,
0.14734531939029694,
-0.3463004529476166,
0.17086660861968994,
-0.052644044160842896,
-0.3470282256603241,
0.6090453267097473,
-0.057272493839263916,
-0.6172001361846924,
0.12277131527662277,
0.5937347412109375,
0.6570954322814941,
-0.3858751952648163,
0.7587988972663879,
0.9200514554977417,
-0.3441792130470276,
0.11017913371324539,
-0.8687198758125305,
0.1983681321144104,
-0.31689515709877014,
0.5063230395317078,
-0.33145079016685486,
-1.063930630683899,
0.5352024435997009,
0.19619281589984894,
0.3698907792568207,
0.4512863755226135,
1.121772289276123,
0.13954924046993256,
0.9803752303123474,
0.5811426639556885,
-0.4868515133857727,
0.1484616994857788,
0.02207675762474537,
0.2154075801372528,
-0.910219669342041,
-0.2737742066383362,
-0.6544166207313538,
-0.1954706758260727,
-0.6937753558158875,
-0.39828574657440186,
0.13471974432468414,
-0.0027709847781807184,
-0.3086355924606323,
-0.009097161702811718,
-0.18952050805091858,
0.09745730459690094,
0.343935489654541,
-0.5274730920791626,
0.4097403585910797,
0.0263303741812706,
-0.14649946987628937,
-0.1446456015110016,
-0.5880663394927979,
-0.6174238920211792,
1.1150617599487305,
0.4943268597126007,
0.7898858189582825,
0.27931278944015503,
0.2026841640472412,
0.07698024809360504,
0.4325261414051056,
-0.6222500205039978,
0.1805250346660614,
-0.11497955024242401,
-1.161917805671692,
-0.4521831274032593,
-0.3125092387199402,
-0.8229764103889465,
0.7109274864196777,
-0.1694907397031784,
-0.7005172967910767,
0.11073596030473709,
-0.09109862893819809,
0.0009965251665562391,
0.49867767095565796,
-0.41728225350379944,
0.8699348568916321,
-0.6173733472824097,
-0.5283085107803345,
0.042916249483823776,
-0.739281952381134,
0.5619621872901917,
-0.24422867596149445,
0.7823686003684998,
-0.2024899423122406,
0.02462140843272209,
0.4661492109298706,
-0.02775893732905388,
0.8735545873641968,
-0.13772639632225037,
-0.8060195446014404,
0.2903638184070587,
-0.08955013751983643,
0.24508747458457947,
-0.10833021998405457,
-0.19853998720645905,
0.37530675530433655,
0.12539757788181305,
-0.37067535519599915,
-0.25034382939338684,
0.7153670191764832,
-0.6686943769454956,
-0.5267051458358765,
-0.3559902310371399,
-0.7283913493156433,
-0.5474801063537598,
0.23365271091461182,
0.06322088092565536,
0.32195696234703064,
-0.4905874729156494,
0.11552203446626663,
0.4840278625488281,
-0.3313975930213928,
0.48995453119277954,
0.4160095155239105,
-0.6276593208312988,
-0.37897029519081116,
0.8011389970779419,
0.22116459906101227,
0.3482559025287628,
0.522701621055603,
-0.09012311697006226,
-0.4560176432132721,
-0.5271398425102234,
-0.7319984436035156,
0.20226366817951202,
-0.6624244451522827,
-0.0066413977183401585,
-0.6461081504821777,
-0.07096616923809052,
-0.7053847908973694,
0.09399325400590897,
-0.35358676314353943,
-0.1947968602180481,
-0.2096165418624878,
0.04015897959470749,
-0.1391942948102951,
0.8894596695899963,
-0.026996593922376633,
-0.08906514197587967,
-0.8207169771194458,
0.07117976993322372,
0.06151963770389557,
0.24467606842517853,
0.25366586446762085,
-0.35273608565330505,
-0.3680099546909332,
0.11958365142345428,
-0.17449988424777985,
-0.612737774848938,
0.3324507474899292,
-0.12867945432662964,
0.7149409651756287,
0.4362051784992218,
-0.2143940031528473,
0.5935177803039551,
-0.6738231182098389,
0.8151589035987854,
0.25682532787323,
-0.6296505331993103,
-0.12623146176338196,
-0.25051677227020264,
0.19831834733486176,
0.40581968426704407,
0.6257686018943787,
-0.7271326780319214,
-0.301536500453949,
-0.24531523883342743,
-0.6541303992271423,
0.3763882517814636,
-0.12805339694023132,
0.17611655592918396,
0.31122684478759766,
-0.12758633494377136,
0.3015328645706177,
0.41595959663391113,
-0.9205152988433838,
-0.2692614197731018,
0.10785634070634842,
-0.3182830214500427,
-0.40776771306991577,
-0.45510315895080566,
-0.1413697749376297,
-0.11212898790836334,
0.5946764349937439,
-0.11786188930273056,
-0.18939609825611115,
-0.16374167799949646,
-0.451219379901886,
-0.04080680012702942,
0.6668285727500916,
0.8520069122314453,
0.833565890789032,
-0.1615273505449295,
0.31079643964767456,
0.20366646349430084,
-0.3078376352787018,
0.31063368916511536,
0.07647965103387833,
-0.0337696336209774,
0.035825904458761215,
0.5014952421188354,
0.7993680238723755,
0.20866979658603668,
-0.7815885543823242,
0.33349958062171936,
0.13135376572608948,
-0.08773298561573029,
-0.28498733043670654,
-0.584886372089386,
0.2372683882713318,
0.1695520579814911,
0.3586128354072571,
-0.14193947613239288,
-0.04404091835021973,
-0.682343602180481,
-0.1416783183813095,
0.8940331339836121,
-0.41009607911109924,
-0.27645763754844666,
0.453401118516922,
0.018830332905054092,
0.06318322569131851,
0.408757746219635,
-0.10265079885721207,
-0.6167957782745361,
0.31156060099601746,
0.5573915243148804,
0.4711299538612366,
-0.3021751940250397,
-0.05055198818445206,
0.2539411783218384,
0.5612362027168274,
-0.027440816164016724,
-0.07304094731807709,
0.2326762080192566,
-0.7973006367683411,
-0.6331292390823364,
-0.7807096242904663,
-0.3770337998867035,
0.3639111816883087,
-0.4507121741771698,
0.3643338084220886,
-0.03757091611623764,
-0.0748017206788063,
-0.04251915216445923,
-0.02367945946753025,
-0.7041568756103516,
-0.02808367647230625,
0.5278589129447937,
0.785140335559845,
-0.6521235108375549,
0.7293133735656738,
0.6687145233154297,
-0.14724144339561462,
-0.35282209515571594,
-0.37743282318115234,
0.25114455819129944,
-0.7968082427978516,
0.8012471199035645,
0.04409194365143776,
0.14152280986309052,
-0.37569567561149597,
-0.37426748871803284,
-1.0061651468276978,
0.5375179052352905,
0.4725424349308014,
-0.8041684627532959,
-0.25846272706985474,
0.36538493633270264,
0.43417155742645264,
-0.4119630455970764,
0.1826138198375702,
0.4102664291858673,
0.7735956311225891,
-0.14757893979549408,
-1.0195146799087524,
-0.15306788682937622,
-0.14242786169052124,
-0.025400830432772636,
0.06403336673974991,
-0.5720049142837524,
0.9567697644233704,
-0.09021103382110596,
0.1399073749780655,
-0.08170484006404877,
0.4323287606239319,
0.25038301944732666,
0.20920579135417938,
0.2529897391796112,
0.3115023672580719,
0.7417702078819275,
0.15853191912174225,
0.8975696563720703,
-0.1771448254585266,
0.37950536608695984,
1.1063816547393799,
-0.8552777171134949,
0.6022400259971619,
0.6346976161003113,
-0.3698815405368805,
0.24259720742702484,
0.56924968957901,
-0.10688318312168121,
0.15332478284835815,
0.30409830808639526,
-0.12878412008285522,
-0.18836334347724915,
-0.23446673154830933,
-0.6110653877258301,
0.4274907410144806,
0.33469268679618835,
-0.3041137754917145,
-0.31230872869491577,
0.2735350728034973,
0.03241819143295288,
-0.18177613615989685,
-0.40966883301734924,
0.5854805707931519,
0.15175876021385193,
-0.7453994154930115,
0.5093256235122681,
-0.05290061980485916,
0.8893380165100098,
-0.5970524549484253,
0.12419811636209488,
-0.038017041981220245,
0.143029123544693,
-0.17791339755058289,
-0.6945645809173584,
0.2245117872953415,
0.06533598154783249,
-0.24185240268707275,
-0.4501998722553253,
0.6794090867042542,
-0.7756364345550537,
-0.7475734949111938,
0.5093327760696411,
0.8607175350189209,
0.12168797850608826,
0.007891600951552391,
-0.5928131937980652,
0.5151495933532715,
0.028418155387043953,
-0.226022407412529,
0.6126189231872559,
0.4303323030471802,
-0.1297806203365326,
0.6447327733039856,
0.4096720218658447,
0.12079830467700958,
0.3489229679107666,
0.33844494819641113,
0.3990482687950134,
-0.5870009660720825,
0.04661848396062851,
-0.9800482988357544,
0.46740418672561646,
-0.024742133915424347,
-0.16811423003673553,
1.0066437721252441,
0.7347099184989929,
0.9122766852378845,
-0.1515430361032486,
0.9314765334129333,
0.09471312910318375,
0.46515092253685,
-0.6223441362380981,
0.55653315782547,
-0.6284918785095215,
0.05780000612139702,
-0.3181700110435486,
-0.9680947065353394,
-0.3106536865234375,
0.2640133798122406,
-0.15097257494926453,
0.06967117637395859,
0.5615151524543762,
0.40725836157798767,
0.025702284649014473,
-0.05297005549073219,
0.3134079575538635,
0.10334865003824234,
0.2058551013469696,
0.40377795696258545,
1.0616015195846558,
-0.22369252145290375,
0.4478294253349304,
-0.06515544652938843,
0.0897376611828804,
-0.23232963681221008,
-0.8764945268630981,
-0.8561940789222717,
-0.6485341191291809,
-0.20116199553012848,
-0.20902447402477264,
-0.2117813378572464,
0.9380490779876709,
0.500992476940155,
-0.9721572995185852,
-0.5709354281425476,
0.4464435875415802,
0.3460855782032013,
0.023900382220745087,
-0.15420310199260712,
0.29589536786079407,
-0.5328841209411621,
-0.9513612389564514,
0.12420982122421265,
0.12849152088165283,
0.059533361345529556,
-0.7896559834480286,
-0.07394876331090927,
-0.5016418695449829,
-0.4014868140220642,
0.9221413731575012,
0.1902213841676712,
-0.8039863109588623,
-0.052787866443395615,
0.10084542632102966,
-0.35277634859085083,
-0.052829474210739136,
0.8899973034858704,
-0.254852831363678,
0.1687983125448227,
0.30082109570503235,
0.6712098121643066,
0.23338806629180908,
-0.3348255455493927,
0.512881875038147,
-0.6434555649757385,
0.21239502727985382,
0.07610990852117538,
0.6225839853286743,
0.7152628898620605,
-0.08759815990924835,
0.3741624355316162,
0.029360676184296608,
-0.4063873589038849,
-1.0301438570022583,
0.19352783262729645,
-0.8036611080169678,
-0.4964098036289215,
1.3239670991897583,
0.16368640959262848,
0.04660998284816742,
-0.2437492311000824,
-0.29279622435569763,
0.2282557487487793,
0.04330676794052124,
0.3449864983558655,
1.1155154705047607,
0.10651019960641861,
-0.18656499683856964,
-0.7794225811958313,
0.36676260828971863,
0.29351165890693665,
-0.653745174407959,
0.3878512978553772,
0.8182458877563477,
0.2907080352306366,
0.397314190864563,
0.5199858546257019,
-0.3058142364025116,
-0.33271631598472595,
-0.3715575635433197,
0.12867125868797302,
0.2962587773799896,
-0.3252842426300049,
-0.5478639602661133,
0.4055922031402588,
0.2397426962852478,
0.2470453381538391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00925v1
|
LLMs are Good Sign Language Translators
| 2024-04-01T05:07:13 | 2024-04-01T05:07:13 |
Jia Gong, Lin Geng Foo, Yixuan He, Hossein Rahmani, Jun Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Sign Language Translation (SLT) is a challenging task that aims to translate
sign videos into spoken language. Inspired by the strong translation
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) that are trained on extensive
multilingual text corpora, we aim to harness off-the-shelf LLMs to handle SLT.
In this paper, we regularize the sign videos to embody linguistic
characteristics of spoken language, and propose a novel SignLLM framework to
transform sign videos into a language-like representation for improved
readability by off-the-shelf LLMs. SignLLM comprises two key modules: (1) The
Vector-Quantized Visual Sign module converts sign videos into a sequence of
discrete character-level sign tokens, and (2) the Codebook Reconstruction and
Alignment module converts these character-level tokens into word-level sign
representations using an optimal transport formulation. A sign-text alignment
loss further bridges the gap between sign and text tokens, enhancing semantic
compatibility. We achieve state-of-the-art gloss-free results on two
widely-used SLT benchmarks.
|
[
0.10891954600811005,
-0.0917234793305397,
0.45927664637565613,
-0.023041823878884315,
-0.7392784953117371,
0.2176678627729416,
-0.1934077888727188,
-0.2968484163284302,
0.2384399026632309,
0.4962746798992157,
-0.3282894790172577,
-0.8059729337692261,
-0.9634894728660583,
0.08290679007768631,
-0.5977214574813843,
0.8916773796081543,
-0.3952905833721161,
0.31513863801956177,
0.23771438002586365,
-0.09826105087995529,
-0.08824818581342697,
-0.2763628363609314,
-0.525780975818634,
-0.1289098709821701,
0.0970776155591011,
0.023108728229999542,
0.9481330513954163,
0.6211040616035461,
0.5296441912651062,
0.17286497354507446,
-0.03572759032249451,
0.21509982645511627,
-0.40004923939704895,
-0.04031809791922569,
0.2775272727012634,
-0.29936715960502625,
-0.6120501756668091,
-0.14872349798679352,
0.8229033350944519,
0.5063186883926392,
0.26763567328453064,
0.008454691618680954,
-0.21526753902435303,
0.34115827083587646,
-0.10622691363096237,
0.34999942779541016,
-0.4239957332611084,
0.08159475773572922,
-0.08688990026712418,
-0.011320667341351509,
-0.42101675271987915,
-0.400129109621048,
-0.3912070095539093,
-0.7590745091438293,
0.05840636044740677,
0.24910418689250946,
0.7269390225410461,
0.6449100375175476,
-0.5765180587768555,
-0.12786592543125153,
-0.7463225722312927,
0.6076050996780396,
-1.0299656391143799,
0.6558249592781067,
0.24684804677963257,
0.2435852587223053,
-0.14532405138015747,
-0.39191240072250366,
-0.4474789500236511,
-0.07522686570882797,
-0.05760911479592323,
0.13068576157093048,
-0.006998203229159117,
0.2760113477706909,
0.03767998516559601,
0.4847922921180725,
-0.8014310002326965,
0.21510453522205353,
-0.1392761915922165,
-0.44461530447006226,
0.6148010492324829,
0.11235909163951874,
0.5755401849746704,
-0.02370416186749935,
-0.6803216338157654,
-0.09367644786834717,
-0.6334552764892578,
-0.19130834937095642,
0.03904392942786217,
0.47415998578071594,
-0.3477114140987396,
0.6450446248054504,
0.2311163991689682,
0.769102931022644,
-0.26138919591903687,
-0.45800676941871643,
0.045368436723947525,
-0.4002579152584076,
-0.28340521454811096,
0.048520367592573166,
0.7101274132728577,
0.30187562108039856,
0.40669822692871094,
-0.004271344281733036,
-0.4797489047050476,
-0.04150228947401047,
-0.41109979152679443,
-0.7313747406005859,
0.03210998326539993,
0.0011688239173963666,
-0.3710416555404663,
0.23783183097839355,
0.13918428122997284,
-0.16738511621952057,
-0.4852268695831299,
-0.2825498580932617,
0.38436710834503174,
-0.3592424988746643,
-0.45484134554862976,
0.5774938464164734,
0.08323090523481369,
0.5707837343215942,
0.6416458487510681,
-0.7622623443603516,
0.2753642201423645,
0.6920942068099976,
0.8594586253166199,
-0.5285161733627319,
0.17079602181911469,
-0.6701580286026001,
0.32974499464035034,
-0.3379459083080292,
0.36877429485321045,
-0.18056917190551758,
-0.1817813515663147,
0.24236266314983368,
-0.1355406492948532,
-0.01788303628563881,
-0.32529976963996887,
0.19419018924236298,
-0.5991843342781067,
-0.06677704304456711,
0.2893980145454407,
-0.6440207362174988,
0.052927643060684204,
0.1720060408115387,
-0.5938330888748169,
0.8072873950004578,
0.04348224774003029,
-0.02353002317249775,
0.4642598330974579,
-0.3021582067012787,
-0.6778495907783508,
0.24072706699371338,
-0.08540772646665573,
-0.37571510672569275,
0.0071380361914634705,
0.08624421805143356,
0.7065054774284363,
-0.031088484451174736,
0.03883969783782959,
0.24016442894935608,
-0.391979843378067,
0.4215161204338074,
-0.2103281021118164,
0.38132038712501526,
0.2556041181087494,
-0.22556379437446594,
0.11051677167415619,
-0.6612372994422913,
-0.1754252165555954,
-0.2853655517101288,
-0.25731897354125977,
-0.1549205183982849,
-0.28057289123535156,
0.2666516602039337,
0.32527628540992737,
0.24424877762794495,
-0.5519415140151978,
0.021983034908771515,
-0.46138763427734375,
0.4442385733127594,
0.6263608932495117,
-0.24870549142360687,
0.5306836366653442,
0.2146499902009964,
0.7850744128227234,
0.0263915304094553,
0.22289687395095825,
-0.24835729598999023,
-0.6771085262298584,
-0.7525800466537476,
-0.48822033405303955,
-0.1767364889383316,
0.34447216987609863,
-0.5758525729179382,
0.10735994577407837,
-0.33994296193122864,
-0.03601855784654617,
-0.6449490785598755,
0.37952688336372375,
0.5769644975662231,
0.06401481479406357,
0.4897136390209198,
-0.4093535840511322,
-0.25955188274383545,
-0.44141724705696106,
-0.12368456274271011,
-0.3361104130744934,
-0.035389285534620285,
-0.15685588121414185,
0.26065945625305176,
-0.0659417062997818,
0.5610209703445435,
-0.3299822211265564,
-0.722529947757721,
-0.24664348363876343,
-0.4120278060436249,
0.47417083382606506,
0.2936767339706421,
0.08721673488616943,
-0.9272821545600891,
-0.7505903840065002,
0.28485605120658875,
-0.5725052952766418,
-0.00483494158834219,
-0.3701898455619812,
0.13233797252178192,
-0.09149717539548874,
0.7299104332923889,
-0.550693154335022,
0.37628886103630066,
0.7055009007453918,
-0.6641139388084412,
0.29230546951293945,
-0.044623907655477524,
0.20659460127353668,
-1.0221279859542847,
-0.12583187222480774,
-0.12866251170635223,
-0.7752025723457336,
-0.617682933807373,
0.05821530520915985,
0.06274911761283875,
-0.4934784770011902,
-0.973977267742157,
0.6454799175262451,
-0.7258093357086182,
-0.442384272813797,
-0.09330477565526962,
0.6221131086349487,
0.019030919298529625,
0.2364485263824463,
-0.014198493212461472,
0.7479453086853027,
0.4647020995616913,
-0.5309534668922424,
0.4051571786403656,
0.5614948868751526,
-0.13475488126277924,
0.6872014403343201,
-0.329376757144928,
0.014392532408237457,
-0.07292473316192627,
-0.032784730195999146,
-1.1138087511062622,
-0.13863489031791687,
0.37911492586135864,
-0.31668081879615784,
0.6261564493179321,
-0.09097739309072495,
-0.4376819431781769,
0.012413939461112022,
-0.1801549792289734,
0.35358259081840515,
0.745698094367981,
-0.47889697551727295,
0.6714195013046265,
0.17723348736763,
-0.0024961356539279222,
-0.15577061474323273,
-0.8709221482276917,
0.3428635895252228,
-0.024884743615984917,
-0.6906577348709106,
0.32696568965911865,
-0.18231649696826935,
-0.07454568147659302,
-0.2551296055316925,
-0.1482316553592682,
-0.0058907316997647285,
-0.14167673885822296,
0.18337640166282654,
0.025865819305181503,
-0.36865824460983276,
0.09675804525613785,
-0.1485094577074051,
-0.34581321477890015,
-0.24061726033687592,
-0.45919281244277954,
0.16216251254081726,
-0.20746351778507233,
-0.5358989834785461,
-0.6450833678245544,
0.22704537212848663,
0.6048168540000916,
-0.08733465522527695,
0.38170087337493896,
0.757854163646698,
-0.22927656769752502,
-0.12416509538888931,
-0.23098699748516083,
-0.06283419579267502,
-0.4538971483707428,
0.3618856370449066,
-0.39608678221702576,
-1.1165157556533813,
0.33592724800109863,
-0.06792031228542328,
0.12457101047039032,
0.12151289731264114,
0.47125065326690674,
-0.13818538188934326,
0.8880274891853333,
0.5849788784980774,
0.22289562225341797,
0.5152831673622131,
-0.07029487192630768,
0.3112022578716278,
-0.5417441129684448,
-0.20998403429985046,
-0.10588713735342026,
-0.1716965287923813,
-0.08187548816204071,
-0.7692533731460571,
0.19975148141384125,
0.18902234733104706,
0.02003091759979725,
0.8676635026931763,
-0.4185985028743744,
0.23432062566280365,
-0.16793833673000336,
-0.10677458345890045,
0.7542279362678528,
0.11078707873821259,
0.021859413012862206,
-0.5227225422859192,
-0.40164878964424133,
-0.6766499876976013,
0.7059473991394043,
0.4853914678096771,
0.8856441378593445,
0.5409623980522156,
0.6774781942367554,
0.34318646788597107,
0.32081764936447144,
-0.9357887506484985,
0.8924596309661865,
-0.5536748766899109,
-0.28532674908638,
-0.28969743847846985,
-0.199079230427742,
-0.7384477257728577,
0.31097543239593506,
-0.19536550343036652,
-0.3451801538467407,
-0.2983209490776062,
0.2091892659664154,
0.11901430040597916,
0.3723176419734955,
-0.5661142468452454,
0.6631661057472229,
-0.5233629941940308,
-0.05176546797156334,
-0.056449610739946365,
-0.6057268381118774,
0.30099451541900635,
-0.2005562037229538,
0.5243146419525146,
-0.2213601917028427,
-0.42846986651420593,
0.48535341024398804,
-0.5230569839477539,
1.0712193250656128,
0.0171743743121624,
-0.6258458495140076,
0.10397874563932419,
0.28714317083358765,
0.5717042684555054,
-0.02682793140411377,
-0.03777496516704559,
-0.01787414401769638,
-0.06997740268707275,
-0.4199354350566864,
-0.6305516958236694,
0.4076477885246277,
-0.5560526251792908,
-0.5140122175216675,
-0.3067062795162201,
-0.43520069122314453,
-0.05018610879778862,
0.22727130353450775,
-0.13533705472946167,
0.260111927986145,
-0.34638652205467224,
-0.315658837556839,
0.73140949010849,
0.025344571098685265,
0.3809850215911865,
0.5047013163566589,
-0.4663458466529846,
-0.5248078107833862,
0.9735009074211121,
-0.38571542501449585,
0.6435559988021851,
0.6403760313987732,
0.03465308994054794,
-0.4524645507335663,
-0.7744541168212891,
-0.6205857396125793,
0.5111783742904663,
-0.9248846769332886,
-0.23111501336097717,
-0.09544192254543304,
0.08990918099880219,
-0.5665043592453003,
-0.2558937668800354,
-0.3115164339542389,
-0.48783570528030396,
-0.5190153121948242,
-0.2906418442726135,
0.5669843554496765,
0.5884243249893188,
-0.05428416654467583,
0.44733765721321106,
-0.698794424533844,
0.5558531284332275,
0.2778674066066742,
0.2542840838432312,
-0.4666626751422882,
-0.8528141379356384,
-0.39415308833122253,
-0.36706066131591797,
0.06867408007383347,
-0.6756722331047058,
0.23319970071315765,
0.6554484367370605,
0.2696199417114258,
0.497141033411026,
-0.07075925916433334,
0.6161268949508667,
-0.38441869616508484,
0.958358883857727,
0.7891076803207397,
-0.8596038818359375,
0.25648370385169983,
-0.2524920701980591,
0.3368251323699951,
0.16948245465755463,
0.26743030548095703,
-0.8292099833488464,
-0.5899292826652527,
-0.16182531416416168,
-0.8225203156471252,
0.3412579298019409,
0.442392498254776,
0.39395397901535034,
0.07699249684810638,
0.3916250169277191,
0.10822697728872299,
0.012621408328413963,
-0.9491530060768127,
-0.11580345779657364,
-0.4535962641239166,
-0.5351542830467224,
-0.12443078309297562,
0.052465856075286865,
0.1462274193763733,
-0.009273737668991089,
0.7086838483810425,
-0.1525707095861435,
0.029959777370095253,
0.08622188121080399,
-0.576547384262085,
-0.04041210189461708,
0.36878326535224915,
0.6589837074279785,
0.19586001336574554,
0.03808410465717316,
0.3947879374027252,
0.035680029541254044,
-0.6724465489387512,
0.5179173350334167,
-0.14627191424369812,
-0.45643532276153564,
0.2849864959716797,
0.46980682015419006,
0.742335319519043,
0.5447090268135071,
-0.6252545714378357,
0.6573051810264587,
0.3053470849990845,
-0.03930821642279625,
-0.2747441828250885,
-0.09989333897829056,
0.009574808180332184,
0.11622504889965057,
0.26518502831459045,
-0.1654636561870575,
-0.28500792384147644,
-0.2625022530555725,
0.3130132853984833,
0.365121066570282,
-0.6206345558166504,
-0.4730188846588135,
0.9787068963050842,
0.4852994978427887,
-0.6875873804092407,
0.04674059525132179,
-0.1385742723941803,
-0.5427807569503784,
0.18510183691978455,
0.7123374342918396,
0.7855702638626099,
-0.07343676686286926,
0.43490907549858093,
0.3914114832878113,
0.4083464443683624,
-0.21649576723575592,
0.2360440045595169,
-0.05483870953321457,
-0.5367503762245178,
-0.5612103939056396,
-0.7121938467025757,
-0.4081972539424896,
-0.19953127205371857,
-0.3692037761211395,
0.41907647252082825,
-0.5272693634033203,
-0.21546950936317444,
-0.6168954968452454,
-0.4499337077140808,
-0.5358889102935791,
0.388094425201416,
0.47012487053871155,
0.6332146525382996,
-0.9233484864234924,
0.6805371046066284,
0.5380465388298035,
-0.49514707922935486,
-0.6490176916122437,
-0.33573588728904724,
-0.19915369153022766,
-0.8975584506988525,
0.5787502527236938,
-0.03860156238079071,
-0.301278680562973,
0.39711448550224304,
-0.2017672210931778,
-0.8747527599334717,
0.7951599359512329,
0.5574328303337097,
-0.5699211955070496,
0.0016363157192245126,
0.7617093324661255,
0.4665679633617401,
-0.4480176568031311,
-0.14019720256328583,
0.43778330087661743,
0.5525084733963013,
0.06247339025139809,
-0.6922842860221863,
0.3842976689338684,
0.0784396156668663,
0.24187465012073517,
0.3012886643409729,
-0.4876076281070709,
0.34688258171081543,
-0.2609873414039612,
-0.4305400848388672,
0.16846220195293427,
0.8978684544563293,
0.19153515994548798,
0.2949244976043701,
0.22163785994052887,
0.33258238434791565,
0.5088936686515808,
0.05651887506246567,
0.6689978241920471,
-0.11994465440511703,
0.18671737611293793,
0.7153328657150269,
-0.17373959720134735,
0.8187994360923767,
0.883527398109436,
-0.3761823773384094,
0.3350759744644165,
0.48852866888046265,
0.012715646997094154,
0.2742916941642761,
0.4148922264575958,
-0.40087974071502686,
-0.5653440952301025,
0.037547945976257324,
-0.06745459139347076,
0.06238757073879242,
0.3031635284423828,
-0.45246708393096924,
-0.18287521600723267,
0.22356528043746948,
0.024957645684480667,
0.6482695937156677,
-0.5569562911987305,
0.4714699685573578,
0.6483657360076904,
-0.06943627446889877,
0.7378995418548584,
-0.17862975597381592,
0.8083446025848389,
-0.7025311589241028,
0.0423891618847847,
-0.2423606961965561,
0.089222252368927,
-0.36736172437667847,
-0.6877085566520691,
0.13323615491390228,
0.07219944894313812,
0.11908069998025894,
-0.8096540570259094,
0.6421703100204468,
-0.6773180961608887,
-0.3836648166179657,
0.3733755350112915,
0.3261283338069916,
0.8458493947982788,
0.3397700786590576,
-0.6343565583229065,
0.22716018557548523,
-0.009623382240533829,
-0.04130998253822327,
0.20121543109416962,
0.361564964056015,
-0.09651223570108414,
0.5204353332519531,
0.5929226279258728,
0.21455135941505432,
0.19335483014583588,
0.33566465973854065,
0.3953547477722168,
-0.7063717246055603,
-0.40719446539878845,
-0.5709438323974609,
0.7156943082809448,
0.2317967265844345,
-0.32905328273773193,
0.7949739694595337,
0.5876973271369934,
0.6140756607055664,
-0.3021065294742584,
0.5187685489654541,
0.17368803918361664,
-0.1300833523273468,
-0.910480260848999,
0.703449547290802,
-0.5756412744522095,
0.15255045890808105,
-0.33408060669898987,
-0.9245534539222717,
-0.7714794874191284,
0.4072416424751282,
0.07911984622478485,
-0.3329848647117615,
0.5551552772521973,
0.8461294174194336,
-0.02130020037293434,
-0.554523766040802,
0.9758962392807007,
0.11131070554256439,
0.47956201434135437,
0.6878609657287598,
0.4684402644634247,
-0.9473481178283691,
1.0630398988723755,
0.5879249572753906,
-0.07007695734500885,
-0.2298736274242401,
-1.0141206979751587,
-0.8611900806427002,
-0.5275574922561646,
-0.7932339906692505,
-0.3489101529121399,
-0.027343997731804848,
0.5749902725219727,
0.6241768002510071,
-0.7245647311210632,
-0.30533072352409363,
0.004940971732139587,
0.17398637533187866,
-0.2631772756576538,
-0.1384018361568451,
0.4149947762489319,
0.023604538291692734,
-0.6024447083473206,
0.6310657858848572,
0.4250727593898773,
0.47206196188926697,
-0.48490557074546814,
-0.6891773343086243,
0.08989299088716507,
-0.04580626264214516,
0.7359722852706909,
0.4513847827911377,
-0.8314261436462402,
-0.3202868700027466,
0.055677060037851334,
-0.35159704089164734,
0.1786147505044937,
0.8473249077796936,
-0.35881122946739197,
0.3849833905696869,
0.39733049273490906,
0.48936334252357483,
1.012922763824463,
-0.22790202498435974,
0.599868893623352,
-0.8784047961235046,
0.27671897411346436,
0.193365216255188,
0.3372199535369873,
0.7393706440925598,
-0.2747841775417328,
0.4211902916431427,
0.2608388662338257,
0.007171936333179474,
-0.6812437176704407,
0.591672956943512,
-1.3293355703353882,
0.05138644576072693,
1.4243338108062744,
-0.15588392317295074,
-0.24363861978054047,
-0.27605339884757996,
-0.08311097323894501,
0.31480172276496887,
-0.3518025577068329,
0.22323113679885864,
0.313795804977417,
-0.04009860008955002,
-0.47894030809402466,
-0.34173157811164856,
0.5734424591064453,
0.38052040338516235,
-0.433897465467453,
-0.0026546772569417953,
0.30269742012023926,
0.2820909917354584,
-0.04999992623925209,
0.828477144241333,
-0.3655538856983185,
0.22559919953346252,
-0.4493415653705597,
0.231248676776886,
-0.2962527573108673,
0.04374042525887489,
-0.4477619230747223,
-0.1672942042350769,
0.32944032549858093,
-0.13168217241764069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00914v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00914v1
|
Token-Efficient Leverage Learning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T04:39:44 | 2024-04-01T04:39:44 |
Yuanhao Zeng, Min Wang, Yihang Wang, Yingxia Shao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have excelled in various tasks but perform
better in high-resource scenarios, which presents challenges in low-resource
scenarios. Data scarcity and the inherent difficulty of adapting LLMs to
specific tasks compound the challenge. To address the twin hurdles, we
introduce \textbf{Leverage Learning}. We present a streamlined implement of
this methodology called Token-Efficient Leverage Learning (TELL). TELL
showcases the potential of Leverage Learning, demonstrating effectiveness
across various LLMs and low-resource tasks, ranging from $10^4$ to $10^6$
tokens. It reduces task data requirements by up to nearly an order of magnitude
compared to conventional Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) while delivering
competitive performance. With the same amount of task data, TELL leads in
improving task performance compared to SFT. We discuss the mechanism of
Leverage Learning, suggesting it aligns with quantization hypothesis and
explore its promising potential through empirical testing.
|
[
0.24764861166477203,
-0.7029679417610168,
0.3613656461238861,
0.20742061734199524,
-0.15011055767536163,
0.3150504529476166,
-0.5595897436141968,
-0.28735700249671936,
0.06730768084526062,
0.4449124038219452,
-0.3930709660053253,
-0.6714435815811157,
-0.6695507168769836,
-0.1734827309846878,
-0.35392439365386963,
0.9763245582580566,
0.05713878944516182,
0.1066313087940216,
0.011037582531571388,
-0.31880688667297363,
-0.44627639651298523,
-0.6035470962524414,
-1.1014609336853027,
-0.08612611144781113,
0.7522597312927246,
0.64591383934021,
0.39827489852905273,
0.8848950266838074,
0.544797956943512,
0.33049625158309937,
-0.048735909163951874,
0.03856246918439865,
-0.8132414221763611,
0.010011245496571064,
-0.06043243780732155,
-0.8174952864646912,
-0.4513722360134125,
0.005383251700550318,
0.5760042667388916,
0.9888946413993835,
-0.11631759256124496,
0.3049600124359131,
0.05458568036556244,
0.7344952821731567,
-0.7783687710762024,
0.2790297269821167,
-0.8725975751876831,
-0.1599808931350708,
-0.2349325567483902,
-0.05529506504535675,
-0.5702598094940186,
-0.2355455905199051,
-0.11128318309783936,
-0.7247877717018127,
0.007897404953837395,
0.3403719365596771,
0.5771417617797852,
0.22065015137195587,
-0.531009316444397,
-0.15647780895233154,
-0.5166114568710327,
1.003998875617981,
-0.43022021651268005,
0.39893415570259094,
0.4665064215660095,
0.1939975768327713,
0.14182154834270477,
-0.9927032589912415,
-0.22818733751773834,
-0.4094510078430176,
0.11431819945573807,
-0.2157762348651886,
-0.2604512572288513,
0.01738082431256771,
0.43299391865730286,
0.38817864656448364,
-0.16242101788520813,
0.5672659873962402,
-0.49151745438575745,
-0.20440328121185303,
0.4979102611541748,
0.1018889993429184,
-0.06453406810760498,
0.07312692701816559,
-0.48989006876945496,
-0.37881913781166077,
-0.8967502117156982,
0.22681450843811035,
0.3559868633747101,
0.6627299785614014,
-0.10347649455070496,
0.4711817502975464,
-0.044345904141664505,
0.48085618019104004,
-0.07869639992713928,
-0.1260196417570114,
0.12837910652160645,
-0.23746705055236816,
-0.23665547370910645,
-0.08088981360197067,
0.4828755259513855,
0.09680455178022385,
0.037481725215911865,
-0.2466462403535843,
-0.4225912392139435,
-0.40913400053977966,
0.2043328881263733,
-0.9565635323524475,
-0.15152522921562195,
-0.08189883083105087,
-0.6875417232513428,
-0.3940669000148773,
-0.07688271254301071,
-0.329052209854126,
-0.4206223487854004,
-0.380950003862381,
0.47350677847862244,
-0.6415792107582092,
-0.20408762991428375,
-0.04336720332503319,
-0.11358413845300674,
0.1728675663471222,
0.17217105627059937,
-1.1186851263046265,
0.4120188057422638,
1.0012211799621582,
1.0688278675079346,
-0.24061211943626404,
-0.22326405346393585,
-1.3136659860610962,
-0.06742183119058609,
-0.45068782567977905,
0.39867886900901794,
-0.37073734402656555,
-0.5163289904594421,
-0.07044612616300583,
-0.24366573989391327,
0.08530919998884201,
-0.7123827338218689,
0.5909422039985657,
-0.5325713157653809,
-0.3081473410129547,
-0.4612977206707001,
-0.6261389255523682,
-0.12366840243339539,
0.15946783125400543,
-0.795805037021637,
1.1383057832717896,
0.3466896116733551,
-0.6119391322135925,
0.7597144842147827,
-0.7732728719711304,
-0.49543145298957825,
0.12882685661315918,
0.22158409655094147,
-0.3014663755893707,
0.33579328656196594,
0.020867248997092247,
0.5382936596870422,
-0.2971586585044861,
0.15393944084644318,
-0.561734676361084,
-0.4578089118003845,
0.38278377056121826,
-0.452742338180542,
0.6429257988929749,
0.28418344259262085,
-0.26119908690452576,
0.40899479389190674,
-0.7260458469390869,
-0.15746910870075226,
0.04553522914648056,
-0.3100608289241791,
-0.6590883135795593,
-0.07471395283937454,
0.08359277248382568,
-0.1311984807252884,
0.2400473654270172,
-0.3384989798069,
0.4322071969509125,
-0.5358052849769592,
0.35139235854148865,
0.9309511184692383,
-0.4395458698272705,
0.6944736242294312,
-0.18530791997909546,
0.5106547474861145,
0.08423224836587906,
0.006391739007085562,
-0.11625760048627853,
0.24927085638046265,
-0.830558717250824,
-0.5449363589286804,
0.6391822695732117,
0.34764230251312256,
-0.7612401843070984,
0.09430237114429474,
-0.21920357644557953,
-0.35352209210395813,
-0.3586173951625824,
0.48109906911849976,
0.4029017388820648,
0.39843475818634033,
0.3271142542362213,
-0.1667649894952774,
-0.46282652020454407,
-0.8335925340652466,
-0.5551190376281738,
0.01654285006225109,
-0.18594913184642792,
0.248939648270607,
0.47971633076667786,
0.2210845798254013,
0.8090870976448059,
-0.5938553810119629,
-0.3409293591976166,
-0.43039670586586,
0.27833661437034607,
0.2036137878894806,
0.38327354192733765,
0.4568970501422882,
-0.9051388502120972,
-0.5101711750030518,
0.11772430688142776,
-0.3913317620754242,
0.07505661249160767,
-0.08683516830205917,
0.06917265057563782,
0.3362009823322296,
1.0140514373779297,
-0.3292531371116638,
0.12023191154003143,
0.49177634716033936,
-0.3808438181877136,
0.49903497099876404,
-0.3053654134273529,
-0.17741627991199493,
-1.1397349834442139,
0.29059305787086487,
-0.0026467812713235617,
-0.4286935031414032,
-0.4495045244693756,
-0.21695005893707275,
0.32469114661216736,
-0.1641758531332016,
-0.3934749662876129,
0.6621295213699341,
-0.5200011730194092,
-0.10018227249383926,
-0.33756136894226074,
-0.044905997812747955,
-0.4887197017669678,
0.4988802373409271,
-0.24713127315044403,
0.8818302750587463,
0.603394091129303,
-0.48288947343826294,
0.2298211306333542,
-0.08492688834667206,
-0.43471503257751465,
0.3597651422023773,
-0.5714852809906006,
0.055851489305496216,
0.10992743074893951,
0.08030923455953598,
-0.7374221682548523,
-0.11380813270807266,
-0.12019739300012589,
-0.08394264429807663,
0.3242736756801605,
-0.2300591766834259,
-0.6673226952552795,
-0.15360522270202637,
-0.37059199810028076,
0.412569135427475,
0.5369622707366943,
-0.8559993505477905,
0.5178502202033997,
0.27570992708206177,
-0.21890638768672943,
-0.8615068197250366,
-0.3768141567707062,
0.101557657122612,
-0.5587542057037354,
-0.1803613305091858,
0.3566785454750061,
0.21752817928791046,
-0.32024040818214417,
0.002908410970121622,
-0.17172710597515106,
0.053108569234609604,
0.4769619107246399,
0.31681278347969055,
0.26529955863952637,
-0.006292743608355522,
0.6331031918525696,
0.01991848088800907,
-0.19366148114204407,
-0.06391830742359161,
-0.6797341704368591,
0.5329061150550842,
-0.2474001944065094,
-0.3257676064968109,
-0.058538056910037994,
-0.02346854656934738,
0.5526524186134338,
-0.17823907732963562,
1.0111031532287598,
0.7142611742019653,
-0.19748488068580627,
-0.5069006085395813,
-0.49331238865852356,
-0.26165732741355896,
-0.5301951766014099,
0.5453689098358154,
-0.33466365933418274,
-1.2099370956420898,
0.4582829177379608,
-0.6355494856834412,
0.15376794338226318,
0.36617234349250793,
0.5455327033996582,
0.09334297478199005,
0.7966513633728027,
1.0248345136642456,
-0.374383807182312,
0.6942476630210876,
-0.37742722034454346,
0.3280636966228485,
-0.4101942181587219,
-0.1910543441772461,
-0.44475361704826355,
-0.5061521530151367,
-0.4281207025051117,
-0.5567069053649902,
0.42437103390693665,
0.37665146589279175,
-0.2662337124347687,
0.36736711859703064,
0.10744643956422806,
0.4996897876262665,
0.8576685786247253,
0.05458834767341614,
0.393661230802536,
-0.07903633266687393,
-0.08191002905368805,
0.05365917086601257,
-0.847104012966156,
-0.21861428022384644,
1.3658212423324585,
0.44025906920433044,
0.6880653500556946,
-0.05899360030889511,
0.6554626226425171,
0.23858973383903503,
0.3979407250881195,
-1.0200248956680298,
0.48345449566841125,
-0.3070676028728485,
-0.09733328223228455,
-0.5103417038917542,
-0.5824284553527832,
-0.9710044860839844,
-0.036163076758384705,
-0.3943450450897217,
-0.5394833087921143,
-0.11272634565830231,
0.19412761926651,
-0.20707498490810394,
0.48791077733039856,
-0.7482174038887024,
0.8527969717979431,
-0.33228614926338196,
-0.37853965163230896,
-0.6627957820892334,
-0.4163063168525696,
0.26675066351890564,
-0.33134180307388306,
0.2592068612575531,
0.037133801728487015,
-0.3649061322212219,
0.8359178900718689,
-0.5570337176322937,
1.135138988494873,
-0.30356013774871826,
-0.15241752564907074,
0.045364923775196075,
-0.013551163487136364,
0.7434662580490112,
0.01833207905292511,
-0.17112164199352264,
0.027095630764961243,
-0.2888794243335724,
-0.5116463303565979,
-0.5821704268455505,
0.5680676102638245,
-0.5029746294021606,
-0.25546780228614807,
0.051804207265377045,
-0.7721498608589172,
-0.3090180456638336,
0.2394704669713974,
0.0728364959359169,
0.36316779255867004,
-0.2321745604276657,
0.5984845161437988,
0.45826807618141174,
-0.13826382160186768,
0.6610162258148193,
0.24345263838768005,
-0.08879556506872177,
-0.3262149691581726,
0.9951661229133606,
0.10437190532684326,
0.2093317210674286,
0.5317974090576172,
0.2569620907306671,
-0.3863452076911926,
-0.6769585013389587,
-0.03541470691561699,
0.19875121116638184,
-0.5344792604446411,
-0.44251659512519836,
-0.44223129749298096,
0.05101332068443298,
-0.14378111064434052,
-0.3075565695762634,
-0.608618438243866,
-0.5206372737884521,
-0.17812590301036835,
-0.3476135730743408,
0.48943883180618286,
0.4270307123661041,
-0.20080044865608215,
0.35612812638282776,
-0.7809246778488159,
-0.012396210804581642,
0.4400908946990967,
0.5146777033805847,
0.12530472874641418,
-0.4519292116165161,
-0.6862369775772095,
-0.06813924759626389,
-0.34854453802108765,
-0.38930538296699524,
0.43209585547447205,
0.13947884738445282,
0.3823857009410858,
0.4528369605541229,
0.265919953584671,
0.6262449026107788,
-0.24033646285533905,
0.5382177829742432,
0.3974713087081909,
-1.332984209060669,
0.27395862340927124,
-0.27932319045066833,
-0.006704183295369148,
0.5691531896591187,
0.5096195936203003,
-0.45423102378845215,
-0.2196972817182541,
-0.6618289351463318,
-1.1280944347381592,
0.632887065410614,
-0.030802132561802864,
0.22616900503635406,
0.1368098109960556,
0.40631645917892456,
0.3905088007450104,
0.26775357127189636,
-0.7723896503448486,
-0.04566555470228195,
0.1884990930557251,
-0.1973668336868286,
-0.15947918593883514,
-0.3532881736755371,
-0.12229377031326294,
-0.17755238711833954,
0.5622082352638245,
-0.5134716629981995,
-0.11091935634613037,
-0.2718889117240906,
-0.3308738172054291,
0.11332433670759201,
0.16529572010040283,
0.23986771702766418,
0.6695677638053894,
0.12393225729465485,
0.1653512865304947,
0.7075037956237793,
-0.15949903428554535,
-0.07782572507858276,
-0.09304032474756241,
0.22318202257156372,
-0.3461940288543701,
0.5104940533638,
1.1547237634658813,
0.5763916969299316,
-0.9417921900749207,
0.6690796613693237,
0.09750174731016159,
-0.5258554816246033,
-0.14389149844646454,
0.06270642578601837,
0.23423977196216583,
0.5711007118225098,
0.607430636882782,
-0.22360751032829285,
0.010163399390876293,
-0.5009465217590332,
0.1983562856912613,
0.621222198009491,
-0.37417230010032654,
-0.17268328368663788,
0.47828394174575806,
0.26062190532684326,
-0.24162885546684265,
0.819790780544281,
-0.14586098492145538,
-0.43997922539711,
0.5553321242332458,
0.41509586572647095,
0.794588029384613,
0.12593623995780945,
0.051818836480379105,
0.30660346150398254,
0.031661685556173325,
-0.27955543994903564,
0.03391741216182709,
-0.34334948658943176,
-0.42926695942878723,
-0.8998174667358398,
-0.6099138855934143,
-0.48270562291145325,
0.07974075525999069,
-0.6918014287948608,
0.5469094514846802,
-0.4224485456943512,
-0.038671426475048065,
-0.15117605030536652,
0.09119722247123718,
-0.4952315092086792,
-0.13713230192661285,
0.058166712522506714,
1.1565662622451782,
-0.7558854818344116,
0.9440855383872986,
0.44112661480903625,
-0.09017811715602875,
-0.9712784886360168,
-0.002992703579366207,
-0.291048139333725,
-0.9573044180870056,
1.2422986030578613,
0.19724701344966888,
-0.014221708290278912,
0.08234155923128128,
-0.6829448938369751,
-0.6989622116088867,
1.190808892250061,
0.6079875826835632,
-0.5803590416908264,
0.006015004124492407,
-0.02834843099117279,
0.38677483797073364,
-0.14945043623447418,
-0.014577075839042664,
0.4689105153083801,
0.3742266893386841,
0.1139402687549591,
-0.9507851600646973,
0.06612590700387955,
0.0052441926673054695,
0.01416995283216238,
0.38317567110061646,
-0.7118280529975891,
0.7448896765708923,
-0.5027387738227844,
-0.19817757606506348,
-0.09012006223201752,
0.8651148676872253,
0.11029517650604248,
0.3919979929924011,
0.8438527584075928,
0.4845767915248871,
1.0387425422668457,
-0.0346854105591774,
0.831401526927948,
-0.34195035696029663,
0.5427116751670837,
0.8172692060470581,
-0.14809148013591766,
0.9276219010353088,
0.5290724039077759,
-0.21567031741142273,
0.3678208291530609,
0.356762170791626,
-0.029561098664999008,
0.3876694440841675,
0.45716604590415955,
-0.2717651426792145,
-0.4590620994567871,
-0.09477891027927399,
0.09219834953546524,
0.7276983857154846,
0.2197461575269699,
-0.16856124997138977,
-0.07756006717681885,
0.18052001297473907,
0.0706610456109047,
0.030686214566230774,
-0.4966144561767578,
0.9284718036651611,
0.2696453034877777,
-0.43161430954933167,
0.492177814245224,
0.10489851236343384,
0.7869071364402771,
-0.7380407452583313,
0.016616489738225937,
-0.14958684146404266,
0.33449113368988037,
0.12231177091598511,
-0.40677744150161743,
0.28954312205314636,
0.006077204365283251,
-0.06171019375324249,
-0.6146420240402222,
0.6691813468933105,
-0.4900895953178406,
-0.483882874250412,
0.2967768609523773,
0.4659842252731323,
-0.16104905307292938,
-0.17449349164962769,
-0.4990580081939697,
-0.10186731815338135,
-0.21117739379405975,
-0.23575858771800995,
0.6712262034416199,
0.545021116733551,
-0.14704306423664093,
0.9316717386245728,
0.9152746796607971,
0.28046590089797974,
-0.193805530667305,
-0.12568990886211395,
0.851020872592926,
-0.8113505244255066,
-0.6260374784469604,
-1.0039483308792114,
0.4047107994556427,
-0.3100956976413727,
-0.15633682906627655,
0.6999441385269165,
0.7648665308952332,
0.8929540514945984,
-0.052638426423072815,
0.6663720607757568,
0.06458842754364014,
0.446951687335968,
-0.818362832069397,
0.5450087785720825,
-0.6288375854492188,
0.34786316752433777,
0.05915430188179016,
-0.5920160412788391,
-0.33639368414878845,
0.3418118953704834,
-0.3797948360443115,
-0.04174254089593887,
0.8409512639045715,
0.6233232021331787,
-0.16052401065826416,
-0.17702080309391022,
0.3491925895214081,
0.18539340794086456,
0.1516721546649933,
0.5085153579711914,
0.641531229019165,
-0.16828575730323792,
0.6887835264205933,
-0.2393292635679245,
-0.24885693192481995,
-0.368580162525177,
-1.1141902208328247,
-0.9619742035865784,
-0.6066077351570129,
-0.1557016372680664,
-0.2439272105693817,
-0.09117113053798676,
1.1722463369369507,
0.8660961985588074,
-0.645521879196167,
-0.3550497591495514,
-0.16723690927028656,
0.2716121971607208,
-0.5142189860343933,
-0.15090100467205048,
0.6286478042602539,
-0.7842395305633545,
-0.8264732956886292,
0.37032976746559143,
0.24213477969169617,
-0.18410557508468628,
0.11236191540956497,
-0.0703195333480835,
0.2762759029865265,
-0.31618598103523254,
0.7221049070358276,
0.23778003454208374,
-0.2724441587924957,
-0.09298509359359741,
0.10044176131486893,
-0.03309652954339981,
-0.19090726971626282,
1.3897048234939575,
-0.7140435576438904,
0.0752977505326271,
0.14538827538490295,
0.9345793724060059,
0.6973375678062439,
-0.00322973751462996,
0.627791702747345,
-0.9343844652175903,
0.3244338929653168,
0.16784675419330597,
0.2429024577140808,
0.10400380939245224,
-0.31681013107299805,
0.5229493975639343,
0.255950391292572,
-0.3421662151813507,
-0.997677743434906,
0.03590407967567444,
-1.0597397089004517,
-0.4423358738422394,
1.2340242862701416,
-0.0877600908279419,
-0.04992958530783653,
0.12747055292129517,
-0.20813943445682526,
0.2362145632505417,
-0.25568246841430664,
0.7556236386299133,
0.42451798915863037,
0.2074330449104309,
0.023479359224438667,
-0.4626372158527374,
0.5736103653907776,
0.6464248895645142,
-0.7073847651481628,
0.5251989364624023,
0.21165454387664795,
0.3115319609642029,
-0.3103209137916565,
0.5158258080482483,
0.12980493903160095,
0.05653122067451477,
-0.01588861458003521,
-0.1561078131198883,
-0.37810298800468445,
-0.25449272990226746,
-0.32602569460868835,
0.355137437582016,
0.3826847970485687,
-0.24839042127132416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00913v1
|
LLaMA-Excitor: General Instruction Tuning via Indirect Feature Interaction
| 2024-04-01T04:39:21 | 2024-04-01T04:39:21 |
Bo Zou, Chao Yang, Yu Qiao, Chengbin Quan, Youjian Zhao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Existing methods to fine-tune LLMs, like Adapter, Prefix-tuning, and LoRA,
which introduce extra modules or additional input sequences to inject new
skills or knowledge, may compromise the innate abilities of LLMs. In this
paper, we propose LLaMA-Excitor, a lightweight method that stimulates the LLMs'
potential to better follow instructions by gradually paying more attention to
worthwhile information. Specifically, the LLaMA-Excitor does not directly
change the intermediate hidden state during the self-attention calculation of
the transformer structure. We designed the Excitor block as a bypass module for
the similarity score computation in LLMs' self-attention to reconstruct keys
and change the importance of values by learnable prompts. LLaMA-Excitor ensures
a self-adaptive allocation of additional attention to input instructions, thus
effectively preserving LLMs' pre-trained knowledge when fine-tuning LLMs on
low-quality instruction-following datasets. Furthermore, we unify the modeling
of multi-modal tuning and language-only tuning, extending LLaMA-Excitor to a
powerful visual instruction follower without the need for complex multi-modal
alignment. Our proposed approach is evaluated in language-only and multi-modal
tuning experimental scenarios. Notably, LLaMA-Excitor is the only method that
maintains basic capabilities while achieving a significant improvement (+6%) on
the MMLU benchmark. In the visual instruction tuning, we achieve a new
state-of-the-art image captioning performance of 157.5 CIDEr on MSCOCO, and a
comparable performance (88.39%) on ScienceQA to cutting-edge models with more
parameters and extensive vision-language pertaining.
|
[
-0.19854871928691864,
-0.687008798122406,
0.2765096426010132,
-0.15676918625831604,
-0.5676993727684021,
0.06648378074169159,
-0.31485670804977417,
-0.37119612097740173,
0.44963374733924866,
0.24195313453674316,
-0.5086992979049683,
-0.38578036427497864,
-0.4979703426361084,
-0.11751143634319305,
0.011641750112175941,
0.8701820373535156,
-0.08652394264936447,
-0.09259539097547531,
-0.051088981330394745,
-0.07970520108938217,
-0.3901352286338806,
-0.11222557723522186,
-0.5703334212303162,
-0.11911081522703171,
0.6614230871200562,
0.4271509647369385,
0.47527509927749634,
0.8795886635780334,
0.5044960379600525,
0.42779260873794556,
-0.025841129943728447,
0.24752067029476166,
-0.48484697937965393,
-0.02166411653161049,
-0.017033839598298073,
-0.851016640663147,
-0.5929232835769653,
-0.13554754853248596,
0.41928645968437195,
0.1860785037279129,
-0.006648463197052479,
0.2547861933708191,
0.2591637372970581,
0.49661052227020264,
-0.5621821880340576,
0.3900313973426819,
-0.7353474497795105,
0.07098466902971268,
0.08216341584920883,
-0.6495294570922852,
-0.21184846758842468,
-0.2819575071334839,
-0.21234095096588135,
-0.6753249764442444,
0.22394312918186188,
0.2283559888601303,
0.7009733319282532,
0.8005537986755371,
-0.24362918734550476,
-0.09929332882165909,
-0.33440133929252625,
0.6830993890762329,
-0.4323022663593292,
0.17119871079921722,
0.08977541327476501,
0.4033359885215759,
-0.0648217722773552,
-0.46685078740119934,
-0.45237720012664795,
-0.4153866469860077,
0.03180227428674698,
0.3751150667667389,
-0.1992081254720688,
0.14414912462234497,
0.1991107016801834,
0.3882041275501251,
-0.17454691231250763,
0.2056770920753479,
-0.287471204996109,
-0.17429223656654358,
0.1304330974817276,
0.11715348809957504,
0.17201238870620728,
-0.037167683243751526,
-0.5518510937690735,
-0.10107605159282684,
-1.1081840991973877,
0.3528747856616974,
0.38345766067504883,
0.020362257957458496,
-0.15740248560905457,
0.46440789103507996,
-0.15920859575271606,
0.7073087692260742,
0.23426023125648499,
-0.14656899869441986,
0.17375579476356506,
-0.3969869613647461,
-0.24232473969459534,
0.08262074738740921,
0.473414808511734,
0.358483225107193,
0.06261208653450012,
0.007936384528875351,
-0.17493624985218048,
-0.03129380941390991,
0.23639491200447083,
-0.6750144958496094,
-0.21497604250907898,
-0.3132071793079376,
-0.3827219009399414,
-0.2638010084629059,
-0.11845549196004868,
-0.640329897403717,
-0.11017138510942459,
-0.5524142980575562,
0.7724313139915466,
-0.39284029603004456,
0.16213905811309814,
-0.18507474660873413,
0.08799397200345993,
0.487125426530838,
0.5577749609947205,
-1.0524911880493164,
0.2126958966255188,
0.36196866631507874,
0.6771618723869324,
-0.19127869606018066,
-0.3434220254421234,
-0.7323341369628906,
0.4790516495704651,
-0.16261282563209534,
0.815513014793396,
-0.7855396866798401,
-0.10625318437814713,
-0.31576645374298096,
0.11246275156736374,
-0.1985895037651062,
-0.5774117112159729,
0.16796602308750153,
-0.53415846824646,
0.011231442913413048,
-0.24713134765625,
-0.3603454530239105,
-0.365207701921463,
0.04923909157514572,
-0.6120600700378418,
0.7720730304718018,
0.1309916079044342,
-0.30499932169914246,
0.22515127062797546,
-0.5953580141067505,
-0.4973202645778656,
-0.14960555732250214,
-0.40131428837776184,
-0.26280447840690613,
0.27602720260620117,
0.36183035373687744,
0.3067165017127991,
-0.40733304619789124,
-0.13359764218330383,
-0.10951046645641327,
-0.8522579669952393,
0.14573298394680023,
-0.5881208181381226,
0.11744499951601028,
-0.3027617633342743,
-0.5730533003807068,
0.46317484974861145,
-0.7790213227272034,
0.06211721524596214,
-0.11718180030584335,
-0.4596185088157654,
-0.0972319096326828,
-0.10654560476541519,
-0.28007251024246216,
0.18959969282150269,
0.5211558938026428,
-0.25860893726348877,
0.3206823468208313,
-0.21995830535888672,
0.473699688911438,
0.9667201638221741,
-0.16943223774433136,
0.47528207302093506,
-0.24604780972003937,
0.5888881087303162,
-0.014449294656515121,
0.2554599642753601,
-0.48460519313812256,
-0.3775584399700165,
-1.2664692401885986,
-0.4199295938014984,
0.07988432794809341,
0.38608992099761963,
-0.766728937625885,
0.45295649766921997,
-0.3253467381000519,
-0.07633223384618759,
-0.8477829098701477,
0.4618373215198517,
0.5626319050788879,
0.5881065726280212,
0.6477177143096924,
-0.0062048165127635,
-0.18854345381259918,
-0.8583572506904602,
-0.06557679921388626,
0.08829409629106522,
0.09815428406000137,
0.3772236704826355,
0.1979033201932907,
0.1325056403875351,
0.30186763405799866,
-0.3424530327320099,
-0.4679594337940216,
-0.12087327241897583,
-0.006052443757653236,
0.3653795123100281,
0.3624587655067444,
0.15381215512752533,
-0.4839238226413727,
-0.4255998730659485,
0.2967207729816437,
-0.484338641166687,
-0.08896083384752274,
-0.05900328978896141,
-0.031157052144408226,
0.22984446585178375,
0.6290476322174072,
-0.4190126657485962,
0.28657007217407227,
0.35304519534111023,
0.061299219727516174,
0.1107800081372261,
-0.343350887298584,
0.3363051116466522,
-0.7538058161735535,
-0.04670564830303192,
-0.3355617821216583,
-0.05196850374341011,
-0.4073513448238373,
0.14018666744232178,
0.3689839541912079,
0.1517065316438675,
-0.35815075039863586,
0.4036935269832611,
-0.6557444930076599,
0.07688550651073456,
-0.4702374339103699,
0.026057060807943344,
-0.20574532449245453,
0.9066953659057617,
-0.1739128977060318,
0.9136863350868225,
0.6211972832679749,
-0.5020934343338013,
0.36243322491645813,
-0.040489811450242996,
-0.3309724032878876,
0.5554159879684448,
-0.7350135445594788,
0.14307743310928345,
-0.16717487573623657,
-0.10602284222841263,
-1.0147291421890259,
-0.2002352476119995,
0.3869372308254242,
-0.11456550657749176,
0.6536486744880676,
-0.1469576507806778,
-0.2787584364414215,
-0.2537909150123596,
-0.6179684996604919,
0.1691659688949585,
0.44560348987579346,
-0.7720947265625,
0.8630287051200867,
-0.17329278588294983,
-0.13562092185020447,
-0.5863578915596008,
-0.561484694480896,
-0.03201839327812195,
-0.16937007009983063,
-0.4318907558917999,
0.4765528440475464,
-0.20191609859466553,
0.2807196080684662,
0.07906439155340195,
-0.3810194134712219,
0.2826111912727356,
-0.033626627177000046,
0.38546574115753174,
0.45371636748313904,
-0.19274917244911194,
0.10445301234722137,
0.619946300983429,
-0.31783732771873474,
-0.15287038683891296,
0.10764420032501221,
0.40499505400657654,
-0.11627433449029922,
-0.5595666766166687,
-0.5502002835273743,
0.1605861335992813,
0.4042503237724304,
-0.16762247681617737,
0.3309372365474701,
0.5504343509674072,
0.11383805423974991,
-0.2671699821949005,
-0.5543522834777832,
-0.2944202721118927,
-0.5766522288322449,
0.5543230175971985,
-0.48334527015686035,
-1.115046501159668,
0.18460670113563538,
-0.24274513125419617,
-0.2224932461977005,
-0.07214993983507156,
0.5968098044395447,
-0.15543468296527863,
0.6824741959571838,
0.7930483222007751,
-0.21395911276340485,
0.6518980860710144,
-0.11705763638019562,
0.01379495020955801,
-1.0904791355133057,
-0.3489912152290344,
0.03225252404808998,
-0.8419995903968811,
-0.2973273992538452,
-0.6978774070739746,
0.5682944655418396,
0.08033907413482666,
-0.026534657925367355,
0.34158116579055786,
-0.5527457594871521,
0.6132432818412781,
0.7483830451965332,
0.29627424478530884,
0.3064191937446594,
0.0392044298350811,
-0.01520110946148634,
-0.007215819321572781,
-0.5933476090431213,
-0.321863055229187,
0.869332492351532,
0.013251335360109806,
1.2493990659713745,
0.031145688146352768,
0.5899635553359985,
-0.00799005851149559,
0.18867963552474976,
-0.7065616250038147,
0.673117458820343,
0.08341997861862183,
-0.10357418656349182,
-0.20044702291488647,
-0.3755953311920166,
-0.6192113757133484,
0.29683756828308105,
0.06050265207886696,
-0.7017176151275635,
-0.004425130318850279,
0.43265461921691895,
-0.2651938199996948,
0.03126182779669762,
-0.8438050746917725,
0.5719025731086731,
-0.5263938903808594,
-0.5956857204437256,
-0.3873617351055145,
-0.6840644478797913,
0.29188746213912964,
-0.029572421684861183,
-0.22495108842849731,
-0.016008375212550163,
-0.6412546634674072,
0.2700211703777313,
-0.09658881276845932,
1.05404794216156,
-0.024167673662304878,
-0.30960407853126526,
0.14340777695178986,
-0.14320923388004303,
0.6293118596076965,
-0.0212214607745409,
0.07868731766939163,
-0.034301552921533585,
-0.38881391286849976,
-0.0732402577996254,
-0.8530698418617249,
0.9189172983169556,
-0.8680708408355713,
-0.9456275701522827,
0.10684403777122498,
-0.6194615960121155,
-0.00024315956397913396,
-0.005160834174603224,
0.16798825562000275,
0.14757245779037476,
0.06261707842350006,
0.12632524967193604,
0.7635671496391296,
-0.0502227358520031,
0.598138689994812,
0.6980147957801819,
0.2428465187549591,
-0.6122358441352844,
1.0221543312072754,
0.10357243567705154,
0.2292962372303009,
0.9730885028839111,
0.048597902059555054,
-0.10740029811859131,
-0.21429799497127533,
-0.5272226929664612,
0.13679249584674835,
-0.6076090335845947,
-0.6075612902641296,
-0.433491975069046,
-0.09466184675693512,
0.1074359193444252,
-0.17036172747612,
-0.08831427246332169,
-0.3839501440525055,
-0.4290023744106293,
-0.004681033082306385,
0.46322473883628845,
0.41135892271995544,
0.08885496109724045,
0.464315801858902,
-0.38950565457344055,
0.4763522446155548,
0.5939096212387085,
0.31613558530807495,
0.11027999967336655,
-0.7011185884475708,
-0.2928711473941803,
-0.22495222091674805,
-0.3234005868434906,
-0.721213161945343,
-0.016763297840952873,
0.4895535409450531,
0.695945143699646,
0.45085251331329346,
-0.34833815693855286,
0.764961838722229,
-0.5806768536567688,
0.3351198732852936,
0.29158473014831543,
-1.1273690462112427,
0.7932031750679016,
-0.008317233063280582,
0.3521767258644104,
0.3915257155895233,
0.19498415291309357,
-0.09194977581501007,
-0.3065508008003235,
-0.041379187256097794,
-0.6369717717170715,
0.6837133169174194,
-0.10420320183038712,
0.20719556510448456,
0.09785875678062439,
0.33504682779312134,
0.26561519503593445,
0.3682590425014496,
-0.6642089486122131,
-0.24179376661777496,
-0.2742818593978882,
-0.35114768147468567,
0.1424063742160797,
-0.06800771504640579,
-0.19777683913707733,
-0.34149599075317383,
0.5328851938247681,
-0.6591517925262451,
0.4572826623916626,
-0.04836244508624077,
-0.2176547348499298,
-0.31130871176719666,
0.2618052661418915,
0.6491427421569824,
0.35736826062202454,
0.08760444074869156,
0.4099928140640259,
0.4845961630344391,
-0.4549252986907959,
0.36784234642982483,
0.12187305837869644,
-0.18362799286842346,
-0.41420841217041016,
0.1566360592842102,
0.9515752196311951,
0.6212607622146606,
-0.38480034470558167,
0.5562593340873718,
0.07491669803857803,
0.15248897671699524,
0.2637903094291687,
0.7653656005859375,
0.2256176471710205,
0.43051791191101074,
0.29200419783592224,
0.17961910367012024,
-0.0628558099269867,
-0.3441679775714874,
-0.02018224075436592,
0.5615028738975525,
-0.4457976520061493,
-0.519626259803772,
0.6940300464630127,
0.2549818754196167,
-0.04065155237913132,
0.010628207586705685,
0.10668852180242538,
-0.27100619673728943,
0.6643111705780029,
0.7291944622993469,
0.5519230365753174,
-0.4487704038619995,
0.017854830250144005,
0.13193100690841675,
0.5524794459342957,
0.3171614110469818,
0.4429708421230316,
-0.5217868089675903,
-0.3812408149242401,
-0.6229508519172668,
-0.3682292699813843,
-0.3239860236644745,
0.006599738262593746,
-0.4869023561477661,
0.44132092595100403,
-0.5573434829711914,
0.16784930229187012,
-0.42140287160873413,
-0.08828678727149963,
-0.6438876390457153,
-0.02119087614119053,
0.021370956674218178,
0.76725172996521,
-0.4283975660800934,
0.9309731721878052,
0.7408236265182495,
-0.4208005666732788,
-0.6563827991485596,
-0.15328127145767212,
-0.029230738058686256,
-1.2089117765426636,
0.6334851980209351,
0.35975348949432373,
-0.47907087206840515,
0.17229825258255005,
-0.5469741225242615,
-0.9733484983444214,
1.499617338180542,
0.5724371671676636,
-0.909008264541626,
0.10687237232923508,
0.09725780785083771,
0.3384077250957489,
-0.29872608184814453,
0.4671730697154999,
0.3722890615463257,
0.398311585187912,
0.12450692802667618,
-0.46134528517723083,
0.34419459104537964,
-0.4215909242630005,
0.015598529018461704,
0.2484443485736847,
-1.2180795669555664,
0.5073078274726868,
-0.44735538959503174,
-0.0513768270611763,
0.3159329295158386,
0.8282970786094666,
-0.0024140719324350357,
-0.09301000088453293,
0.2777150273323059,
0.5802968740463257,
0.714857280254364,
0.05136629939079285,
0.696035623550415,
-0.5445030331611633,
-0.07551980763673782,
1.2016135454177856,
-0.1804710030555725,
0.7064885497093201,
0.6919904351234436,
0.042032867670059204,
0.33027058839797974,
0.1322564035654068,
-0.2988754212856293,
0.7311042547225952,
0.3375852704048157,
-0.33096906542778015,
-0.14455248415470123,
-0.03313992917537689,
-0.4122439920902252,
0.4069835841655731,
0.20240943133831024,
-0.36162248253822327,
-0.05718629062175751,
0.05259203538298607,
-0.14220376312732697,
-0.21468381583690643,
-0.4355807602405548,
0.6686848402023315,
0.0498218759894371,
-0.4261959195137024,
0.5477725267410278,
-0.25766998529434204,
0.8275926113128662,
-0.7764425873756409,
-0.39678955078125,
-0.34928053617477417,
0.04823452606797218,
-0.0331789031624794,
-0.5217387080192566,
-0.2532462775707245,
-0.12823036313056946,
-0.23670190572738647,
0.14512589573860168,
0.7296761870384216,
-0.484462171792984,
-0.24982967972755432,
0.33645176887512207,
0.536961555480957,
-0.13921114802360535,
0.16808494925498962,
-0.44365209341049194,
0.30920445919036865,
0.06219419464468956,
-0.2720686197280884,
0.4666650593280792,
0.3464355170726776,
0.20606644451618195,
0.7456471920013428,
0.3876650929450989,
-0.05021749064326286,
0.2050558179616928,
0.2044421285390854,
1.143079161643982,
-0.7789209485054016,
-0.19496901333332062,
-0.6652882099151611,
0.2482548952102661,
0.10669854283332825,
-0.3457937240600586,
0.7070335745811462,
0.2758636772632599,
0.6109539270401001,
-0.19533175230026245,
0.44479307532310486,
0.15702879428863525,
-0.00570914801210165,
-0.7862002849578857,
0.6080394983291626,
-0.5103530287742615,
0.34612175822257996,
0.0021345396526157856,
-1.1346110105514526,
-0.040836405009031296,
0.5522941946983337,
-0.06943430751562119,
0.1699809730052948,
0.6608456373214722,
1.0657740831375122,
-0.23613914847373962,
0.003199996892362833,
0.5978953838348389,
0.13347359001636505,
0.026608828455209732,
0.7923263907432556,
1.0530835390090942,
-0.41939854621887207,
0.7706106901168823,
-0.08633219450712204,
-0.34125635027885437,
-0.22128012776374817,
-0.6794511079788208,
-1.0843273401260376,
-0.11316724121570587,
-0.2596465051174164,
0.37232285737991333,
0.21783162653446198,
0.7674081325531006,
0.5647293329238892,
-0.5185584425926208,
-0.01739080436527729,
-0.09799107909202576,
0.19230443239212036,
-0.3539028763771057,
-0.17456956207752228,
0.3712230920791626,
-0.578844428062439,
-0.7670217752456665,
0.6237961649894714,
0.665582001209259,
0.018537303432822227,
-0.16438284516334534,
-0.038522690534591675,
0.21830347180366516,
-0.025512484833598137,
0.5603768229484558,
0.06293924152851105,
-0.7770776152610779,
-0.376679003238678,
0.19025135040283203,
-0.04570339247584343,
0.2989313304424286,
0.6605852842330933,
-0.8719544410705566,
0.30169597268104553,
0.12375964969396591,
0.5923601388931274,
0.5323919057846069,
-0.26121535897254944,
0.21298640966415405,
-0.6280771493911743,
-0.16097746789455414,
-0.19878579676151276,
0.4120105504989624,
0.32192468643188477,
-0.4758100211620331,
0.33044639229774475,
-0.059395577758550644,
-0.46709656715393066,
-0.14681904017925262,
0.0991121307015419,
-1.1130017042160034,
0.03454386070370674,
0.8214867115020752,
-0.05926938354969025,
-0.5676546096801758,
0.2595740556716919,
-0.45588502287864685,
0.2739845812320709,
-0.5572136640548706,
0.8682737350463867,
0.2380017191171646,
-0.27018406987190247,
-0.5435757040977478,
-0.24580812454223633,
0.2781004309654236,
0.5385825634002686,
-0.9804307818412781,
-0.18080610036849976,
0.3526061177253723,
0.17457129061222076,
0.1556779146194458,
0.24669964611530304,
0.005544291343539953,
0.5045011043548584,
-0.10779305547475815,
0.10816382616758347,
-0.4237598180770874,
-0.523508608341217,
-0.45848512649536133,
0.01688419282436371,
-0.1530337780714035,
-0.3413020372390747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15362v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15362v1
|
Diverse Perspectives, Divergent Models: Cross-Cultural Evaluation of Depression Detection on Twitter
| 2024-04-01T03:59:12 | 2024-04-01T03:59:12 |
Nuredin Ali, Charles Chuankai Zhang, Ned Mayo, Stevie Chancellor
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media data has been used for detecting users with mental disorders,
such as depression. Despite the global significance of cross-cultural
representation and its potential impact on model performance, publicly
available datasets often lack crucial metadata related to this aspect. In this
work, we evaluate the generalization of benchmark datasets to build AI models
on cross-cultural Twitter data. We gather a custom geo-located Twitter dataset
of depressed users from seven countries as a test dataset. Our results show
that depression detection models do not generalize globally. The models perform
worse on Global South users compared to Global North. Pre-trained language
models achieve the best generalization compared to Logistic Regression, though
still show significant gaps in performance on depressed and non-Western users.
We quantify our findings and provide several actionable suggestions to mitigate
this issue.
|
[
-0.3634919226169586,
-0.5868800282478333,
0.5369289517402649,
0.6015492677688599,
-0.175373375415802,
0.3202604055404663,
-0.4487527906894684,
-0.6527602076530457,
0.44677940011024475,
-0.03962226212024689,
-0.8065547943115234,
-1.0025629997253418,
-0.8046965599060059,
0.16479462385177612,
-0.3564741015434265,
0.862688422203064,
-0.1232752650976181,
0.20763829350471497,
0.06558234244585037,
-0.23469917476177216,
-0.07935678958892822,
-0.30326277017593384,
-0.7827670574188232,
-0.21795524656772614,
0.24268236756324768,
0.26634061336517334,
0.7651861906051636,
-0.29960760474205017,
0.662747859954834,
0.1876794695854187,
0.027768107131123543,
-0.0032217628322541714,
-0.701360821723938,
-0.14856228232383728,
-0.35551461577415466,
-0.4135277569293976,
-0.1769406795501709,
-0.11232111603021622,
0.1824813187122345,
0.7191840410232544,
0.12414368242025375,
0.32224977016448975,
-0.10822086036205292,
0.33491942286491394,
-0.6464903354644775,
-0.1360619217157364,
-0.06309615075588226,
0.36605334281921387,
0.12074880301952362,
0.4175982177257538,
0.1869874745607376,
-0.7149965763092041,
0.1807306855916977,
-0.16318900883197784,
0.5957320928573608,
-0.6039462089538574,
0.657297670841217,
0.37974047660827637,
-0.7784224152565002,
0.0019914358854293823,
-1.2050542831420898,
0.8089988827705383,
-0.4652351438999176,
0.1574152410030365,
0.5014053583145142,
0.6154842972755432,
0.3140255808830261,
-0.5041260123252869,
-0.009330101311206818,
0.23884090781211853,
-0.029589276760816574,
0.1774967610836029,
-0.4642690420150757,
-0.3944126069545746,
0.25060322880744934,
0.4135579764842987,
-0.5440340042114258,
0.18225274980068207,
-0.41377323865890503,
-0.08510119467973709,
0.9880345463752747,
0.44913315773010254,
0.6699633598327637,
-0.025386491790413857,
0.007213137112557888,
0.29839634895324707,
-0.2699560225009918,
0.21222367882728577,
0.18480774760246277,
0.44103455543518066,
-0.6484552025794983,
0.2982962131500244,
-0.4394973814487457,
0.23759528994560242,
-0.28691932559013367,
0.06906873732805252,
0.221632719039917,
-0.22519342601299286,
-0.15002773702144623,
-0.36005207896232605,
0.8082448244094849,
0.720139741897583,
0.37571078538894653,
-0.3202257454395294,
-0.26301681995391846,
0.22275838255882263,
0.08312738686800003,
-0.7386279106140137,
-0.35243502259254456,
0.3212133049964905,
-0.7947893142700195,
0.10836057364940643,
-0.11268211901187897,
-0.6847802996635437,
-0.6652820706367493,
-0.08630590885877609,
-0.034408994019031525,
-0.4174472391605377,
-0.6770649552345276,
-0.07150669395923615,
-0.35663557052612305,
-0.16490891575813293,
0.27497565746307373,
-0.7026872038841248,
0.37081849575042725,
0.3963611423969269,
1.074379324913025,
-0.21059264242649078,
0.019243700429797173,
0.05333951860666275,
-0.20605850219726562,
-0.37345635890960693,
0.7023324966430664,
-0.7005082368850708,
-0.4282870292663574,
0.14565178751945496,
0.039602793753147125,
0.0016933244187384844,
-0.5111854076385498,
0.6441039443016052,
0.00923942867666483,
0.19134557247161865,
-0.8404404520988464,
-0.07860963046550751,
-0.025205036625266075,
0.04288909584283829,
-0.8379696607589722,
0.6000712513923645,
0.5735284090042114,
-1.0073658227920532,
0.6981595754623413,
-0.5377718210220337,
-0.48607268929481506,
-0.05466744303703308,
-0.09036185592412949,
-0.10061204433441162,
0.42348238825798035,
0.6979411840438843,
0.6062662601470947,
-0.48089301586151123,
0.28146734833717346,
-0.7527130246162415,
-0.6346032023429871,
-0.07993465662002563,
-0.02965483069419861,
1.0572398900985718,
0.27320215106010437,
-0.16466233134269714,
-0.31899139285087585,
-0.5876247882843018,
-0.2978965640068054,
0.20688900351524353,
-0.157860666513443,
-0.7824274301528931,
-0.007766349706798792,
0.4395362138748169,
0.1882830411195755,
-0.10323861241340637,
-0.6292328834533691,
-0.041243601590394974,
-0.029772497713565826,
0.4283345639705658,
0.304109662771225,
-0.054012421518564224,
0.06834717094898224,
-0.19769132137298584,
0.785827100276947,
0.27338361740112305,
0.3458872437477112,
0.34083008766174316,
-0.5539442300796509,
-0.045829061418771744,
-0.5793213248252869,
0.15429776906967163,
0.6394450664520264,
-0.5321972370147705,
0.27126866579055786,
-0.2316386103630066,
-0.5865821242332458,
-0.703243613243103,
-0.09394630789756775,
-0.02611609175801277,
0.21966901421546936,
0.4136708676815033,
-0.1973288357257843,
-0.6353815197944641,
-0.9129223823547363,
-0.6452269554138184,
0.1890682876110077,
-0.35379403829574585,
0.37647899985313416,
0.4495275616645813,
-0.6330081820487976,
0.8785523176193237,
-0.35693344473838806,
-0.17986436188220978,
-0.4054337441921234,
0.2965933680534363,
0.09489118307828903,
0.25131621956825256,
0.7880128622055054,
-0.8474277853965759,
-0.750816285610199,
0.0030104697216302156,
-0.9656907916069031,
-0.09976686537265778,
-0.022002119570970535,
0.13628289103507996,
0.04164016619324684,
0.052107058465480804,
-0.42193105816841125,
0.5872757434844971,
0.5778651237487793,
-0.26449814438819885,
0.1385677009820938,
0.29424047470092773,
0.18964703381061554,
-1.1140682697296143,
0.14170368015766144,
0.5507171750068665,
-0.22340551018714905,
-0.593464732170105,
-0.46618562936782837,
-0.0014050647150725126,
-0.22780057787895203,
-0.11567144840955734,
0.2437925785779953,
-0.19215725362300873,
-0.04225665703415871,
0.01833614520728588,
-0.12203570455312729,
-0.21680998802185059,
-0.14214716851711273,
0.032549455761909485,
0.295235276222229,
0.8928499817848206,
-0.2830479145050049,
0.31167376041412354,
-0.03400878980755806,
-0.5623307824134827,
0.6304865479469299,
-0.5785905122756958,
-0.31530120968818665,
-0.2999404966831207,
0.3552112877368927,
-1.001342535018921,
-0.25866013765335083,
0.2628280520439148,
-0.38213464617729187,
-0.12832356989383698,
-0.10151083022356033,
-0.2812950313091278,
-0.6277479529380798,
-0.1727822721004486,
0.6435723900794983,
0.4578225612640381,
-0.39438357949256897,
0.4200427234172821,
0.33605486154556274,
-0.06733371317386627,
-0.4617473781108856,
-1.0801745653152466,
0.06144341826438904,
-0.638305127620697,
-0.6245454549789429,
0.4388713538646698,
0.2620108723640442,
-0.4487961530685425,
0.10467261075973511,
-0.011090891435742378,
-0.14854654669761658,
0.25211474299430847,
-0.09732206910848618,
-0.2548854649066925,
-0.14190882444381714,
0.31816399097442627,
0.047223832458257675,
0.19741997122764587,
0.24567703902721405,
0.13222281634807587,
0.4958081841468811,
0.019604170694947243,
-0.1597910076379776,
-0.6428057551383972,
0.6944999694824219,
0.2509053945541382,
0.004326118156313896,
0.7687193155288696,
0.8463672399520874,
-0.650856077671051,
-0.2603352963924408,
-0.3100909888744354,
-0.07335616648197174,
-0.35873207449913025,
0.16871954500675201,
-0.19930067658424377,
-0.6395430564880371,
1.032179832458496,
-0.3129185736179352,
-0.26580557227134705,
0.2137903869152069,
0.5176869630813599,
0.11651042103767395,
1.3474735021591187,
1.144766926765442,
-0.43705639243125916,
0.3494347333908081,
-0.45448780059814453,
0.5187426805496216,
-0.43609070777893066,
0.09562049061059952,
-0.42167025804519653,
-0.5779539942741394,
-0.9791955947875977,
-0.1766960471868515,
0.09145025908946991,
-0.012204878963530064,
-0.23741114139556885,
-0.04432603716850281,
-0.3179863691329956,
0.4378369152545929,
0.24675710499286652,
0.2671346366405487,
0.12327754497528076,
0.04755260422825813,
-0.1173887774348259,
-0.32962584495544434,
-0.4525195360183716,
-0.4259595572948456,
1.028482437133789,
0.24555353820323944,
1.1061670780181885,
-0.037098340690135956,
0.9423379302024841,
0.555570662021637,
0.4378678798675537,
-0.47322842478752136,
-0.01844809204339981,
-0.4428614377975464,
-0.5203346610069275,
-0.13471819460391998,
-0.609306812286377,
-0.8591576814651489,
0.02863221988081932,
0.11710642278194427,
-1.054663062095642,
0.5207536220550537,
-0.2350318729877472,
-0.4949662983417511,
0.3902394473552704,
-0.8467024564743042,
0.8269239068031311,
-0.2346293330192566,
0.1012331172823906,
-0.06935212761163712,
-0.5920260548591614,
0.8359861969947815,
-0.06843002885580063,
0.32578638195991516,
-0.41769668459892273,
0.11611638963222504,
0.5275954008102417,
-0.019231563434004784,
1.024474024772644,
-0.35648223757743835,
0.023211520165205002,
-0.07472384721040726,
-0.08607669919729233,
-0.07805509120225906,
0.2743833363056183,
-0.10703903436660767,
0.3448346257209778,
0.005360765848308802,
-0.7335052490234375,
-0.3547971546649933,
0.7155302166938782,
-1.136342167854309,
-0.43098214268684387,
0.012951675802469254,
-0.5070276856422424,
-0.3315344452857971,
-0.017865275964140892,
0.3753611743450165,
-0.045864105224609375,
-0.5514867901802063,
-0.040628187358379364,
0.10687657445669174,
-0.4224088191986084,
0.3447551429271698,
0.25585198402404785,
-0.24676916003227234,
-0.4008854031562805,
0.6385008692741394,
0.13558948040008545,
-0.0360313281416893,
0.07489626109600067,
0.21026068925857544,
0.025456128641963005,
-0.07267431914806366,
0.04543730244040489,
0.29400378465652466,
-0.8443892002105713,
0.007313330192118883,
-0.5487459897994995,
0.06608331948518753,
-0.6663546562194824,
-0.029384907335042953,
-0.3604061007499695,
-0.499597430229187,
-0.23155654966831207,
-0.19281616806983948,
0.2604800760746002,
0.8394525647163391,
-0.4849313795566559,
0.2635129690170288,
-0.6497693061828613,
0.4973006546497345,
-0.12662635743618011,
0.5419767498970032,
0.05651140585541725,
0.11013585329055786,
-0.438515841960907,
0.20630134642124176,
-0.21426278352737427,
-0.8058104515075684,
0.5481262803077698,
0.11280488967895508,
0.48961949348449707,
0.670036256313324,
0.40038275718688965,
0.7308269739151001,
0.1256559044122696,
0.6594420075416565,
0.16309696435928345,
-0.890077531337738,
0.754387617111206,
-0.19637992978096008,
0.35065820813179016,
0.5482848882675171,
1.2558647394180298,
-0.9826610088348389,
-0.6539750099182129,
-0.43186506628990173,
-0.8121802806854248,
0.6833065748214722,
0.006544333416968584,
0.36070045828819275,
0.06640557199716568,
0.1287708729505539,
0.4396026134490967,
-0.19242773950099945,
-0.655875027179718,
-0.17145003378391266,
-0.3939908444881439,
-0.25158998370170593,
-0.4304978847503662,
0.09226875752210617,
-0.36378708481788635,
-0.37798184156417847,
-0.0013129988219588995,
0.014920035377144814,
0.17559625208377838,
0.392202764749527,
0.047484029084444046,
-0.42924246191978455,
-0.2317042201757431,
0.06575209647417068,
0.9171545505523682,
-0.3174806535243988,
-0.08993454277515411,
-0.06924311816692352,
-0.09044615179300308,
-0.03298502787947655,
0.3424437642097473,
-0.2482813000679016,
0.18078605830669403,
0.4850754141807556,
0.6528071761131287,
-0.32593098282814026,
-0.5143454670906067,
0.2935805022716522,
-0.7409677505493164,
0.005414994433522224,
-0.21687346696853638,
-0.0753123089671135,
0.4162103831768036,
0.6146551966667175,
0.3221695125102997,
-0.06002234295010567,
0.3377569615840912,
-0.6509988903999329,
-0.10167071223258972,
0.4561094343662262,
-0.3109375834465027,
-0.7111552357673645,
0.5505319237709045,
0.19751185178756714,
-0.5491431355476379,
0.8298847675323486,
0.1741895079612732,
-0.510184645652771,
0.7305432558059692,
0.3479436933994293,
0.9800993204116821,
-0.36279425024986267,
0.6930049657821655,
0.19498766958713531,
0.3944861590862274,
-0.03718451410531998,
0.62699294090271,
-0.12028440833091736,
-0.7422521710395813,
-0.08230625838041306,
-0.30147647857666016,
-0.3756631016731262,
0.2115512639284134,
-0.7606141567230225,
0.3633391857147217,
-0.3828132152557373,
-0.6639714241027832,
-0.09641667455434799,
-0.020225076004862785,
-1.1081546545028687,
0.5070099234580994,
0.508534848690033,
0.7536107897758484,
-1.4948619604110718,
0.5365951657295227,
0.7451160550117493,
-0.4752078652381897,
-0.16371189057826996,
0.6776992678642273,
-0.09206479042768478,
-0.49777311086654663,
0.4058915674686432,
0.5227013826370239,
0.27066776156425476,
-0.39913278818130493,
-0.5594019889831543,
-0.9369009733200073,
0.8315103650093079,
0.389179527759552,
-0.1307249665260315,
0.2716188132762909,
0.5336377024650574,
0.9020599126815796,
-0.46526357531547546,
0.45443111658096313,
0.6994624137878418,
0.23106257617473602,
-0.22770410776138306,
-0.732816755771637,
0.08379858732223511,
-0.3043413758277893,
0.2508595883846283,
-0.06913675367832184,
-0.8458581566810608,
0.9370652437210083,
-0.1602160781621933,
-0.5439680814743042,
-0.4084725081920624,
0.16033193469047546,
0.01778739131987095,
0.47795140743255615,
0.34110018610954285,
0.66591477394104,
0.8955963850021362,
0.09998073428869247,
1.2158902883529663,
-0.2799708843231201,
0.46134212613105774,
0.6988937258720398,
-0.42456260323524475,
0.44578301906585693,
0.07887232303619385,
-0.19771622121334076,
0.5068576335906982,
1.1618666648864746,
0.006544182542711496,
0.6377032995223999,
0.01918916404247284,
-0.23931767046451569,
-0.41673222184181213,
-0.21483179926872253,
-0.4235050678253174,
0.26754552125930786,
0.40401923656463623,
-0.4911549389362335,
-0.6945977807044983,
0.10421403497457504,
-0.19235211610794067,
-0.014860274270176888,
-0.1559685468673706,
0.38959625363349915,
0.2865055501461029,
-0.3404313623905182,
0.8494793176651001,
0.06066117435693741,
0.5632913112640381,
-0.18567074835300446,
0.3859546482563019,
-0.8341346979141235,
0.35120126605033875,
-0.3529326915740967,
-0.4801592230796814,
0.6912714242935181,
0.27586930990219116,
-0.18877209722995758,
0.0090032322332263,
0.7871469259262085,
-0.19134294986724854,
-0.8893600702285767,
0.9363147616386414,
0.8716187477111816,
0.24075090885162354,
-0.1799355000257492,
-0.77554851770401,
-0.16412357985973358,
-0.11627982556819916,
-0.22949157655239105,
0.23053529858589172,
0.7224124073982239,
-0.46146252751350403,
0.838698148727417,
0.1970043033361435,
0.0491790771484375,
-0.1876586675643921,
0.5129815340042114,
0.7912852764129639,
-0.8036044239997864,
-0.46372631192207336,
-0.8716285228729248,
0.4315635561943054,
-0.1836869716644287,
-0.31545406579971313,
0.695972204208374,
0.37413445115089417,
1.0268911123275757,
0.026286637410521507,
1.305351972579956,
-0.19552505016326904,
0.5946779847145081,
0.0796804279088974,
0.597578227519989,
-0.8554951548576355,
0.0007135312771424651,
-0.15917105972766876,
-0.6324358582496643,
-0.5310342311859131,
0.3843017518520355,
-0.7011366486549377,
0.28807151317596436,
0.5737388134002686,
0.45985496044158936,
-0.4178275465965271,
0.16575337946414948,
0.17381681501865387,
0.049305643886327744,
0.4038323760032654,
0.5745828151702881,
1.0421054363250732,
-0.16956378519535065,
0.24387991428375244,
-0.6538580656051636,
-0.1411297470331192,
-0.11214084923267365,
-0.5405844449996948,
-1.1218332052230835,
-0.2653593420982361,
-0.3135678470134735,
0.03612656146287918,
0.06652463972568512,
0.654674768447876,
0.49557825922966003,
-0.905328094959259,
-0.2635747194290161,
0.16951224207878113,
0.3289971649646759,
-0.3516104221343994,
-0.22961950302124023,
0.3702341318130493,
-0.33071303367614746,
-0.7195882797241211,
-0.11465001851320267,
-0.06151364743709564,
-0.11060910671949387,
-0.34115421772003174,
0.2618180811405182,
-0.10793060064315796,
-0.1515698879957199,
0.43036767840385437,
-0.12198437750339508,
-0.5785660743713379,
0.016405431553721428,
-0.2426106333732605,
-0.07709282636642456,
0.1674671769142151,
0.7452718019485474,
-0.6104791760444641,
0.14187578856945038,
0.6055734753608704,
0.45285144448280334,
0.3012706935405731,
0.3753097653388977,
0.7495565414428711,
-0.47204142808914185,
0.02787047065794468,
0.4165799617767334,
0.37220263481140137,
0.7471791505813599,
-0.5399798154830933,
0.5774739384651184,
0.2869642972946167,
-0.39567238092422485,
-0.7431633472442627,
0.028778381645679474,
-0.30566659569740295,
-0.5347580909729004,
0.8048533797264099,
-0.47142407298088074,
-0.21256203949451447,
-0.22970496118068695,
0.15052539110183716,
0.3084603250026703,
-0.4363286793231964,
1.329880952835083,
0.7500138878822327,
-0.19859112799167633,
0.08113811165094376,
-0.48178350925445557,
0.3399394154548645,
0.32524603605270386,
-0.501174807548523,
0.07734426856040955,
0.2655714750289917,
0.41328302025794983,
-0.14968669414520264,
0.5974808931350708,
0.22295135259628296,
0.11996716260910034,
-0.14724983274936676,
0.12889842689037323,
0.679777979850769,
-0.00024070058134384453,
-0.5279953479766846,
-0.0306193009018898,
-0.45491889119148254,
0.04627053067088127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00899v1
|
TM-TREK at SemEval-2024 Task 8: Towards LLM-Based Automatic Boundary Detection for Human-Machine Mixed Text
| 2024-04-01T03:54:42 | 2024-04-01T03:54:42 |
Xiaoyan Qu, Xiangfeng Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the increasing prevalence of text generated by large language models
(LLMs), there is a growing concern about distinguishing between LLM-generated
and human-written texts in order to prevent the misuse of LLMs, such as the
dissemination of misleading information and academic dishonesty. Previous
research has primarily focused on classifying text as either entirely
human-written or LLM-generated, neglecting the detection of mixed texts that
contain both types of content. This paper explores LLMs' ability to identify
boundaries in human-written and machine-generated mixed texts. We approach this
task by transforming it into a token classification problem and regard the
label turning point as the boundary. Notably, our ensemble model of LLMs
achieved first place in the 'Human-Machine Mixed Text Detection' sub-task of
the SemEval'24 Competition Task 8. Additionally, we investigate factors that
influence the capability of LLMs in detecting boundaries within mixed texts,
including the incorporation of extra layers on top of LLMs, combination of
segmentation loss, and the impact of pretraining. Our findings aim to provide
valuable insights for future research in this area.
|
[
-0.5468679666519165,
-0.8059467673301697,
0.7200950980186462,
0.2307642251253128,
-0.4059097468852997,
0.3799379765987396,
-0.0585402213037014,
-0.8717712759971619,
0.017927497625350952,
0.9144262075424194,
-0.5619478821754456,
-0.7537282109260559,
-0.6721841096878052,
0.4814417362213135,
-0.2691710293292999,
0.7815021872520447,
-0.3672276437282562,
-0.24462270736694336,
-0.34944096207618713,
-0.07449960708618164,
-0.40058526396751404,
-0.9157280325889587,
-0.5379818081855774,
-0.7040591835975647,
0.5765508413314819,
0.24403706192970276,
0.055945102125406265,
0.6347788572311401,
0.2523520886898041,
0.24859337508678436,
-0.39452704787254333,
0.5324130654335022,
-0.07368215918540955,
0.3092770576477051,
-0.0830477923154831,
-0.5939072370529175,
-0.41173258423805237,
0.18959642946720123,
0.8503222465515137,
0.48539748787879944,
0.3354291617870331,
-0.14647753536701202,
0.293832391500473,
0.2671141028404236,
-0.3516286313533783,
-0.3385216295719147,
-0.6011197566986084,
0.289616197347641,
-0.6909666061401367,
-0.4741306006908417,
-0.6585814356803894,
0.10710036754608154,
-0.1883612722158432,
-0.31442931294441223,
0.09198573976755142,
0.40104785561561584,
0.8276860117912292,
0.18339276313781738,
-0.689745306968689,
-0.4028925895690918,
-0.4368228316307068,
0.7923654913902283,
-0.4043513238430023,
0.49698972702026367,
0.17564770579338074,
-0.1336764097213745,
-0.34887343645095825,
-0.5171659588813782,
-0.6736108064651489,
0.3547631800174713,
0.16256162524223328,
0.06295466423034668,
-0.10587739199399948,
-0.04185372591018677,
0.12784038484096527,
0.015608490444719791,
-0.40267235040664673,
0.6243135929107666,
-0.3704186677932739,
-0.6148631572723389,
0.5979969501495361,
0.35992372035980225,
0.46497058868408203,
-0.275516152381897,
-0.6663254499435425,
0.06428262591362,
-0.679502546787262,
-0.019655980169773102,
0.4341869652271271,
0.18446239829063416,
-0.10631851851940155,
0.5177927017211914,
0.22161036729812622,
0.5406222939491272,
-0.04703798517584801,
-0.14963151514530182,
0.32537877559661865,
-0.21063977479934692,
-0.01233016699552536,
0.03243266046047211,
1.0403205156326294,
0.5205243229866028,
0.14721524715423584,
-0.11678166687488556,
-0.4838043451309204,
0.0800582617521286,
0.09607401490211487,
-0.5228797793388367,
0.11819630861282349,
-0.040712740272283554,
-0.3333671987056732,
-0.48830646276474,
-0.13911941647529602,
-0.5292447805404663,
-0.6248923540115356,
-0.3215040862560272,
0.372922420501709,
-0.31191110610961914,
-0.20468853414058685,
-0.0771355852484703,
-0.16940122842788696,
0.3854654133319855,
0.32310009002685547,
-0.4629594683647156,
0.29232633113861084,
0.7130629420280457,
0.8750174045562744,
-0.7548839449882507,
-0.4708581566810608,
-0.4671919345855713,
-0.07411590218544006,
-0.1993904411792755,
1.1327927112579346,
-0.5937389731407166,
-0.5549517273902893,
-0.19803069531917572,
0.17951135337352753,
-0.15566711127758026,
-0.6519297361373901,
0.8927329182624817,
-0.48670220375061035,
0.26138684153556824,
-0.05580860748887062,
-0.6552550196647644,
0.01789909228682518,
0.4565525949001312,
-0.48635122179985046,
1.3023216724395752,
-0.24240659177303314,
-0.853554904460907,
0.49205195903778076,
-0.3495454490184784,
-0.5603030920028687,
0.07555096596479416,
-0.29392239451408386,
-0.7098052501678467,
-0.18339121341705322,
0.0679771900177002,
0.6119993925094604,
-0.13591177761554718,
0.1850292682647705,
-0.14817653596401215,
-0.24322298169136047,
0.5669940114021301,
-0.43287938833236694,
0.6754904985427856,
0.0621919259428978,
-0.3645998537540436,
0.12107743322849274,
-0.5834620594978333,
-0.048831306397914886,
-0.13521845638751984,
-0.5882183909416199,
-0.4019964039325714,
-0.05631333217024803,
0.2029217928647995,
0.37697234749794006,
0.2892521321773529,
-0.6391726732254028,
0.11574247479438782,
-0.0008080895058810711,
0.35032665729522705,
0.9348481297492981,
0.2030477374792099,
0.5353102087974548,
-0.3941187858581543,
0.5398544073104858,
0.2633014917373657,
-0.27106723189353943,
-0.019656620919704437,
-0.7127078175544739,
-0.7710674405097961,
-0.3274327218532562,
0.3158837556838989,
0.5893259644508362,
-0.6886914372444153,
0.7474254965782166,
0.15139073133468628,
-0.3725111484527588,
-0.36446598172187805,
0.03109605796635151,
0.22335639595985413,
0.4455398917198181,
0.36106300354003906,
-0.1393839716911316,
-0.7562463879585266,
-0.7106918692588806,
-0.37682801485061646,
-0.028744282200932503,
0.11206838488578796,
0.3442958891391754,
0.6418682336807251,
-0.6561855673789978,
0.838189423084259,
-0.3116934299468994,
-0.272879034280777,
-0.22082090377807617,
0.29515978693962097,
-0.1939133256673813,
0.36968618631362915,
0.15541794896125793,
-0.7363893389701843,
-0.5356388092041016,
-0.07569766044616699,
-0.6754012703895569,
-0.7976795434951782,
-0.210150346159935,
-0.384289026260376,
0.33416101336479187,
0.6718006730079651,
-0.34837469458580017,
0.4547850787639618,
0.3281387984752655,
-0.5902479290962219,
0.5772837400436401,
-0.01655595935881138,
0.05848454684019089,
-0.9120055437088013,
-0.14235451817512512,
0.15434502065181732,
-0.3407398760318756,
-0.7238771915435791,
-0.2662201523780823,
0.17217183113098145,
0.21806927025318146,
-0.21447928249835968,
0.7560566663742065,
-0.35328444838523865,
-0.05612804740667343,
-0.47359803318977356,
0.035074107348918915,
0.15819130837917328,
0.3910846412181854,
0.20297926664352417,
0.6322755217552185,
0.0939263105392456,
-0.6106396317481995,
-0.1398065686225891,
0.10279393941164017,
0.1854342669248581,
0.8572473526000977,
-0.23223797976970673,
0.3831368088722229,
0.08545679599046707,
0.31205540895462036,
-0.9823510646820068,
-0.04698722064495087,
0.4436942934989929,
-0.5182890892028809,
0.20421238243579865,
-0.04629623517394066,
-0.49402207136154175,
-0.18406246602535248,
-0.3344571590423584,
0.4945280849933624,
0.46416381001472473,
-0.4256400167942047,
0.7651461958885193,
0.5751980543136597,
-0.029967278242111206,
-0.16746114194393158,
-0.7081334590911865,
0.38203778862953186,
-0.48789167404174805,
-0.6814154982566833,
0.49066051840782166,
-0.035439856350421906,
-0.19600984454154968,
-0.22876323759555817,
-0.033544689416885376,
-0.08708400279283524,
0.2282119244337082,
0.48146358132362366,
0.28644222021102905,
0.020231051370501518,
-0.03382674604654312,
0.2350916713476181,
-0.13720367848873138,
0.10459692776203156,
-0.4431377053260803,
0.6195282340049744,
-0.02184922806918621,
-0.19729240238666534,
-0.3163737952709198,
0.305581659078598,
0.5259513258934021,
-0.2114892452955246,
0.5866397619247437,
0.7754919528961182,
-0.3546399176120758,
-0.5601024031639099,
-0.5683088898658752,
0.06751071661710739,
-0.4328005015850067,
0.1038188487291336,
-0.5135316848754883,
-1.0700527429580688,
0.7362921237945557,
-0.06586721539497375,
-0.11333223432302475,
0.7988891005516052,
0.5978203415870667,
-0.2898031771183014,
0.7111139893531799,
0.6337975263595581,
0.07406129688024521,
0.2026253640651703,
0.07941270619630814,
-0.05013898015022278,
-1.0868875980377197,
-0.6054912209510803,
-0.6233770251274109,
-0.29527246952056885,
-0.7457745671272278,
-0.6517868638038635,
0.43519169092178345,
-0.03927615284919739,
-0.1631069928407669,
0.2116658240556717,
-0.8543157577514648,
0.47431519627571106,
0.4760068356990814,
0.1221691220998764,
0.482577383518219,
-0.0536939837038517,
-0.4207295775413513,
-0.13362248241901398,
-0.49478936195373535,
-0.7748410105705261,
0.9597508311271667,
0.5440649390220642,
0.5461997985839844,
-0.3098372220993042,
1.0506672859191895,
0.5997858643531799,
0.26300472021102905,
-0.6720340251922607,
0.7356799840927124,
0.09548231959342957,
-0.46204110980033875,
-0.336019366979599,
-0.36999422311782837,
-0.9880151748657227,
0.489762544631958,
-0.19221289455890656,
-0.702951192855835,
0.014625685289502144,
-0.3594396710395813,
0.07804321497678757,
0.5069162249565125,
-0.39213085174560547,
0.670648455619812,
-0.3980724513530731,
-0.29413852095603943,
0.2521427869796753,
-0.5392574667930603,
0.054207708686590195,
-0.3829834461212158,
0.35126185417175293,
-0.22354160249233246,
-0.30583709478378296,
1.240394949913025,
-0.34428420662879944,
1.0325134992599487,
-0.059724316000938416,
-0.29211509227752686,
0.6224965453147888,
0.0508357509970665,
0.4004681706428528,
-0.3784688413143158,
0.0032534440979361534,
0.2774662375450134,
-0.21578100323677063,
-0.2262079268693924,
0.014574361965060234,
0.37641942501068115,
-0.9578359127044678,
-0.3490368723869324,
-0.5620059967041016,
-0.24676740169525146,
-0.05123453214764595,
0.4650910198688507,
0.5223685503005981,
0.14711979031562805,
-0.0808984711766243,
-0.16827194392681122,
0.5503674745559692,
-0.14531035721302032,
0.31297582387924194,
0.302678644657135,
-0.18983016908168793,
-0.29654091596603394,
0.8459116220474243,
0.09916405379772186,
-0.07488959282636642,
0.23985198140144348,
0.02632814086973667,
-0.43164029717445374,
-0.7816752791404724,
-0.49052396416664124,
0.2940398156642914,
-0.764723539352417,
-0.008992725051939487,
-0.6411110162734985,
-0.5283992290496826,
-0.07720989733934402,
-0.25345733761787415,
-0.09078051894903183,
-0.17238253355026245,
-0.7234838008880615,
-0.00783332996070385,
-0.05857296288013458,
0.9829082489013672,
0.031188275665044785,
0.3427612781524658,
-0.721436083316803,
-0.10809887945652008,
-0.16270634531974792,
0.032158058136701584,
-0.16520194709300995,
-0.7740733623504639,
-0.022450417280197144,
-0.2894239127635956,
-0.48945561051368713,
-0.7956721186637878,
0.3070732355117798,
-0.15373627841472626,
0.648634672164917,
0.16294267773628235,
0.027644312009215355,
0.17500443756580353,
-0.5602447986602783,
0.614733099937439,
0.2428644597530365,
-0.9551407098770142,
0.09691905975341797,
-0.36750683188438416,
0.2697243392467499,
0.2125599980354309,
0.28133732080459595,
-0.7816827893257141,
-0.5631033778190613,
-0.47883182764053345,
-0.7196887135505676,
0.4446217119693756,
0.4357038736343384,
-0.16183416545391083,
0.1588684320449829,
0.2276320904493332,
0.30931374430656433,
0.1156628355383873,
-0.9360820651054382,
0.0393141508102417,
0.1710764467716217,
-0.29480886459350586,
0.2036082148551941,
-0.23015516996383667,
0.1687753051519394,
0.1292048990726471,
0.4986332952976227,
0.011341098695993423,
0.16597001254558563,
0.23630906641483307,
-0.2522430717945099,
0.0036297535989433527,
0.38602855801582336,
0.5808455944061279,
0.2881455719470978,
0.10852574557065964,
0.5670070648193359,
0.3549079895019531,
-0.4084472358226776,
0.37324392795562744,
0.03906690701842308,
-0.25248876214027405,
-0.13547462224960327,
0.7108295559883118,
0.6781770586967468,
-0.24826979637145996,
-0.5587869882583618,
0.2598567306995392,
0.17104007303714752,
-0.4419057071208954,
-0.12859465181827545,
0.046251337975263596,
-0.036556851118803024,
0.349626749753952,
0.6187136173248291,
0.08184820413589478,
0.01918288692831993,
-0.3423468768596649,
0.33590197563171387,
0.2364494949579239,
-0.3999810516834259,
-0.5584626793861389,
0.4781299829483032,
0.5847705602645874,
-0.5736623406410217,
0.3007749319076538,
-0.42756909132003784,
-1.2164080142974854,
0.6382405161857605,
0.4519754648208618,
0.8392069935798645,
-0.026429418474435806,
0.006912867072969675,
-0.11182048916816711,
0.35482391715049744,
0.2475929856300354,
0.08931341767311096,
-0.07003727555274963,
-1.0219453573226929,
-0.3207571506500244,
-0.6416022181510925,
-0.34611111879348755,
0.1379636973142624,
-0.29287368059158325,
0.44900253415107727,
-0.29056689143180847,
-0.3988770544528961,
0.10130391269922256,
-0.04814249649643898,
-0.5793210864067078,
0.2744218111038208,
0.5914710760116577,
0.6194299459457397,
-0.9742708802223206,
0.27535420656204224,
0.831499457359314,
0.16747096180915833,
-0.4428021311759949,
0.006834911182522774,
0.11695954948663712,
-0.6936206817626953,
0.5346239805221558,
0.4043881893157959,
-0.4265728294849396,
-0.11073632538318634,
-0.5851112008094788,
-0.22045104205608368,
0.984930157661438,
-0.2788489758968353,
-0.34237879514694214,
-0.1301412433385849,
0.5388818979263306,
0.42169323563575745,
-0.434910386800766,
0.16985486447811127,
0.5709997415542603,
0.4486753046512604,
0.13041141629219055,
-0.989769697189331,
0.10996989160776138,
-0.07400393486022949,
-0.37117859721183777,
0.42008674144744873,
-0.7806907892227173,
0.9289644956588745,
0.2583475708961487,
-0.17087146639823914,
-0.20082922279834747,
0.4929928779602051,
0.4259895086288452,
0.7816985249519348,
0.6145902276039124,
0.49893879890441895,
1.0179383754730225,
-0.07827427983283997,
0.4726434648036957,
-0.014898738823831081,
0.16343559324741364,
0.602851927280426,
-0.43883806467056274,
0.5697579979896545,
0.5004931092262268,
-0.14142552018165588,
0.5744438767433167,
1.1400787830352783,
0.018788395449519157,
0.19300894439220428,
0.29758554697036743,
-0.39822709560394287,
-0.4875822961330414,
-0.3023935556411743,
-0.16768957674503326,
0.42847123742103577,
0.4556977450847626,
-0.2753917872905731,
0.0012633642181754112,
0.0033214306458830833,
0.03470883518457413,
-0.03912356495857239,
-0.3558465838432312,
0.6880435943603516,
0.43141716718673706,
-0.5196528434753418,
0.29042187333106995,
0.37304961681365967,
0.9452610611915588,
-0.05240373685956001,
0.19502657651901245,
-0.006323680281639099,
0.056824084371328354,
-0.32357257604599,
-1.120482087135315,
0.06241382285952568,
0.162995845079422,
-0.09241249412298203,
-0.2513761520385742,
1.2593915462493896,
-0.4766092300415039,
-0.4114481508731842,
0.33157461881637573,
0.7079076170921326,
0.2599768340587616,
-0.05651955306529999,
-0.42604053020477295,
0.3725198209285736,
0.14889384806156158,
-0.28982487320899963,
0.1614188551902771,
0.828086256980896,
-0.33742716908454895,
0.6587361693382263,
0.39673054218292236,
-0.08493944257497787,
0.043579474091529846,
-0.16216610372066498,
0.7968743443489075,
-0.8261454701423645,
-0.8140477538108826,
-1.0948563814163208,
0.5464007258415222,
-0.22603628039360046,
-0.32331568002700806,
0.6599137187004089,
0.6956788897514343,
0.6304495334625244,
0.27084478735923767,
1.0874453783035278,
0.3408207893371582,
0.40229055285453796,
-0.6684998869895935,
0.5818472504615784,
-0.5524183511734009,
0.3115052282810211,
-0.06964396685361862,
-0.808766782283783,
-0.2197520136833191,
0.34187284111976624,
-0.38742485642433167,
0.012167658656835556,
0.6989458799362183,
0.45565471053123474,
-0.013041605241596699,
-0.07375788688659668,
0.2233075648546219,
-0.1319224089384079,
0.3147140443325043,
0.5650450587272644,
1.3235210180282593,
-0.1625533103942871,
0.6106471419334412,
0.22411270439624786,
-0.08789113909006119,
-0.27255675196647644,
-0.7996842265129089,
-1.4543384313583374,
-0.6703797578811646,
-0.19145473837852478,
-0.44182294607162476,
-0.1990765631198883,
0.7109531760215759,
0.5031980276107788,
-0.5631294250488281,
-0.2702540159225464,
0.05192801356315613,
0.2773953974246979,
0.659995436668396,
-0.21437640488147736,
0.18817998468875885,
-0.09351176768541336,
-0.6651136875152588,
0.18759801983833313,
0.4008581340312958,
0.410276859998703,
-0.2686873972415924,
-0.2581278681755066,
-0.10896718502044678,
0.18352088332176208,
0.36705076694488525,
-0.042340237647295,
-0.5448607802391052,
-0.2915674149990082,
0.16367903351783752,
-0.36008304357528687,
0.2306164652109146,
0.7302857041358948,
-0.44983384013175964,
0.1133401021361351,
0.4525294005870819,
0.7772409915924072,
0.741024374961853,
0.11925797164440155,
0.46705836057662964,
-0.7840051651000977,
-0.010099774226546288,
0.42351609468460083,
0.2547212541103363,
0.4957493841648102,
-0.36380431056022644,
0.42739805579185486,
0.5477538704872131,
-0.620614767074585,
-0.8741123080253601,
0.00039178741280920804,
-0.8371386528015137,
-0.2817257344722748,
1.2696400880813599,
0.15283742547035217,
-0.35536420345306396,
-0.29498425126075745,
-0.3265521228313446,
0.29023149609565735,
-0.3326756954193115,
0.33408281207084656,
0.9840357303619385,
-0.24926067888736725,
-0.027518553659319878,
-0.21530143916606903,
0.3353850245475769,
0.32583028078079224,
-0.8736428022384644,
-0.27032509446144104,
0.30242106318473816,
0.24708245694637299,
0.17685134708881378,
0.7611660957336426,
0.23296846449375153,
-0.04919368028640747,
-0.05446549132466316,
0.15521545708179474,
-0.03182342275977135,
-0.33995890617370605,
-0.12030557543039322,
0.09564363211393356,
0.037398532032966614,
-0.08515540510416031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00884v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00884v1
|
Self-Demos: Eliciting Out-of-Demonstration Generalizability in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T03:25:06 | 2024-04-01T03:25:06 |
Wei He, Shichun Liu, Jun Zhao, Yiwen Ding, Yi Lu, Zhiheng Xi, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising abilities of in-context
learning (ICL), adapting swiftly to new tasks with only few-shot
demonstrations. However, current few-shot methods heavily depend on
high-quality, query-specific demos, which are often lacking. When faced with
out-of-demonstration (OOD) queries, methods that rely on hand-crafted demos or
external retrievers might fail. To bridge the gap between limited demos and OOD
queries, we propose Self-Demos, a novel prompting method that elicits the
inherent generalizability in LLMs by query-aware demo generation. The generated
demos strategically interpolate between existing demos and the given query,
transforming the query from OOD to ID. To evaluate the effectiveness of our
approach, we manually constructed OOD-Toolset, a dataset in the tool-using
scenario with over 300 real-world APIs and 1000 instances, each consisting of
three tool-use cases as demos and an OOD query. Thorough experiments on our
dataset and two public math benchmarks have shown that our method can
outperform state-of-the-art baselines in the OOD setting. Moreover, we conduct
a range of analyses to validate Self-Demos's generalization and provide more
insights.
|
[
-0.3835950791835785,
-0.8294338583946228,
0.7488635778427124,
0.31672143936157227,
-0.191819965839386,
-0.10150942206382751,
-0.33272576332092285,
0.07911930978298187,
-0.04172847047448158,
0.3262753486633301,
-0.5224747657775879,
-0.6257426738739014,
-0.11297963559627533,
-0.08715199679136276,
-0.7336881160736084,
0.6895847320556641,
0.1209077462553978,
-0.2925048768520355,
-0.434436559677124,
-0.25643619894981384,
-0.19172470271587372,
-0.5274267196655273,
-0.2242688536643982,
-0.026438914239406586,
0.10969742387533188,
0.5819952487945557,
0.29247725009918213,
0.37907907366752625,
-0.1206328347325325,
0.21477188169956207,
0.2238616943359375,
0.01991959661245346,
-0.4940967559814453,
0.29073700308799744,
-0.24458622932434082,
-0.6658634543418884,
-0.267431378364563,
-0.053799714893102646,
0.6731241941452026,
0.6788966655731201,
-0.23810675740242004,
0.36288195848464966,
0.2556919753551483,
0.3879266381263733,
-0.8284353017807007,
0.06418276578187943,
-0.9830525517463684,
-0.007660810369998217,
-0.08846146613359451,
-0.08405274897813797,
-0.6385676264762878,
-0.20647694170475006,
-0.01156336534768343,
-0.4708203673362732,
0.41224685311317444,
-0.05203228443861008,
0.46658024191856384,
0.005199076607823372,
-0.2996412217617035,
-0.29677361249923706,
-0.5109512209892273,
0.6325432658195496,
-0.8711430430412292,
0.30848681926727295,
0.2996525764465332,
0.7049626708030701,
-0.38009992241859436,
-0.8530777096748352,
-0.6982172727584839,
-0.5170052647590637,
0.18251681327819824,
0.20036524534225464,
-0.3501094877719879,
-0.036888666450977325,
0.33167076110839844,
0.3786506950855255,
-0.36632004380226135,
0.3372982442378998,
-0.15274293720722198,
0.012542779557406902,
0.47142690420150757,
-0.03614623844623566,
0.24241669476032257,
-0.07391238212585449,
-0.38292351365089417,
-0.10620644688606262,
-1.1934895515441895,
0.19164760410785675,
0.4663143754005432,
0.4219387471675873,
0.06351986527442932,
0.6172080636024475,
-0.49273526668548584,
0.7865833640098572,
0.39476490020751953,
0.12249122560024261,
-0.0007622573175467551,
-0.34228405356407166,
-0.2774353623390198,
-0.30157044529914856,
0.993536651134491,
0.1470901370048523,
-0.04430598020553589,
-0.16328196227550507,
-0.3520625829696655,
-0.32536041736602783,
-0.1533765196800232,
-0.889929473400116,
-0.1745556890964508,
0.3546646535396576,
-0.37812045216560364,
0.005524714011698961,
-0.06538690626621246,
-0.9780966639518738,
-0.28002092242240906,
-0.06313324719667435,
0.7342754602432251,
-0.26243045926094055,
-0.3447953164577484,
-0.03675364702939987,
-0.05067138001322746,
-0.1004410833120346,
0.1838066279888153,
-0.8154149651527405,
0.2582346200942993,
0.34217336773872375,
0.7613142728805542,
-0.20874983072280884,
-0.35035642981529236,
-0.8283970355987549,
0.21609467267990112,
-0.47511351108551025,
0.5835744738578796,
-0.39622384309768677,
-0.6283923983573914,
0.10741960257291794,
-0.33496782183647156,
0.10396705567836761,
-1.0099982023239136,
0.030890323221683502,
-0.42368143796920776,
0.4061475098133087,
-0.12557348608970642,
-0.8286913633346558,
0.277759850025177,
0.320596307516098,
-0.29475873708724976,
1.1409580707550049,
0.06256309896707535,
-0.28256696462631226,
0.4439481794834137,
-0.7464233040809631,
-0.039455778896808624,
0.061327140778303146,
-0.7439630031585693,
-0.10006818920373917,
0.42170411348342896,
0.5040715336799622,
0.5909222960472107,
-0.09803885966539383,
0.1433371901512146,
-0.4436522126197815,
-0.23065587878227234,
0.1155017614364624,
-0.4374963045120239,
0.47050416469573975,
0.12767761945724487,
-0.5139296054840088,
0.12401662766933441,
-0.7119296789169312,
0.20437823235988617,
0.2697032392024994,
-0.12324701249599457,
-0.332303524017334,
-0.1498369574546814,
-0.557488203048706,
0.2971450984477997,
0.09345611929893494,
-0.5854195356369019,
0.5836707949638367,
-0.6158626675605774,
0.4426584243774414,
0.6214771866798401,
0.11715471744537354,
0.4839392304420471,
-0.017122574150562286,
0.8467171788215637,
-0.18852894008159637,
0.2979924976825714,
-0.5811474323272705,
-0.3499714136123657,
-0.5898325443267822,
-0.4045034945011139,
0.15615978837013245,
0.010849237442016602,
-0.7073830366134644,
0.4086456894874573,
-0.12096497416496277,
-0.4876226782798767,
-0.4044654071331024,
0.2590748369693756,
0.4390699565410614,
0.6069040298461914,
0.35485008358955383,
0.04926862567663193,
-0.16423100233078003,
-0.8262214064598083,
-0.3268001675605774,
-0.34192726016044617,
-0.17198115587234497,
0.3953697979450226,
0.4071168601512909,
-0.006607921794056892,
1.4064077138900757,
-0.35511133074760437,
-0.37626248598098755,
-0.4649467468261719,
0.29838258028030396,
0.33361107110977173,
0.21105802059173584,
0.630186915397644,
-0.4455569088459015,
-0.570880115032196,
-0.22336077690124512,
-0.5559296011924744,
-0.19134654104709625,
-0.11440826952457428,
-0.0004627456364687532,
0.022830508649349213,
0.9329658150672913,
-0.3004779815673828,
0.6032693386077881,
0.6241422295570374,
0.03156772255897522,
0.7269699573516846,
-0.4865179657936096,
0.011572799645364285,
-0.8952476978302002,
-0.1374649703502655,
-0.3440452516078949,
-0.1101127564907074,
-0.3365131914615631,
0.20225763320922852,
0.3785194158554077,
-0.3172162175178528,
-0.5338023900985718,
0.8156915307044983,
-0.625537633895874,
-0.10532635450363159,
-0.23168595135211945,
0.07633635401725769,
0.055698737502098083,
0.22500163316726685,
-0.272320032119751,
1.143093466758728,
0.6471667885780334,
-0.8955523371696472,
0.20509105920791626,
0.026158250868320465,
-0.5101620554924011,
0.36509302258491516,
-0.7150641083717346,
0.2637198865413666,
-0.13894504308700562,
0.5027007460594177,
-1.3764500617980957,
-0.40500468015670776,
0.03970588743686676,
-0.3501368761062622,
0.0723802000284195,
-0.5173833966255188,
-0.7607483267784119,
-0.3045998811721802,
-0.21721050143241882,
0.5081984996795654,
0.5483463406562805,
-1.0937623977661133,
0.5822203159332275,
0.05995725840330124,
-0.012568633072078228,
-0.4715460538864136,
-0.5745067596435547,
0.09262665361166,
-0.34959566593170166,
-0.36508405208587646,
0.28610870242118835,
-0.26635968685150146,
-0.16249854862689972,
-0.2851060628890991,
0.12478804588317871,
-0.05988895148038864,
-0.0389825701713562,
0.273917555809021,
-0.08687939494848251,
-0.12224289029836655,
0.5255445241928101,
0.253731906414032,
0.21456819772720337,
0.11580456793308258,
-0.1954628825187683,
0.7804625034332275,
-0.05464162304997444,
-1.046525478363037,
-0.4622645378112793,
0.4027054011821747,
0.3097248375415802,
-0.19326792657375336,
0.20880261063575745,
0.05284466594457626,
-0.11180673539638519,
-0.7093265056610107,
-0.5909906625747681,
-0.3415224552154541,
-0.5359605550765991,
0.3465626835823059,
-0.45235368609428406,
-0.5738860368728638,
0.3738873302936554,
-0.4626173973083496,
0.16875654458999634,
0.12730981409549713,
0.5184428691864014,
-0.1313638985157013,
1.1974507570266724,
0.39888855814933777,
0.12818291783332825,
0.5727522969245911,
-0.5054731369018555,
-0.014133340679109097,
-0.6704338788986206,
0.02025727555155754,
-0.34495824575424194,
-0.06910256296396255,
0.06832731515169144,
-0.43574273586273193,
0.6885875463485718,
0.224589005112648,
0.07762118428945541,
0.09450510144233704,
-0.1861649602651596,
0.6478524804115295,
0.6548464894294739,
-0.018454939126968384,
0.30354437232017517,
0.01747879944741726,
-0.38292914628982544,
-0.11382770538330078,
-0.5525779724121094,
-0.30457937717437744,
1.264724850654602,
0.10496988892555237,
0.8574244976043701,
0.22223056852817535,
1.0395398139953613,
0.2173999845981598,
0.3374098539352417,
-0.6914499998092651,
0.7203714847564697,
0.16160529851913452,
-0.7818061113357544,
-0.4927871525287628,
-0.17189723253250122,
-1.073160171508789,
0.3870486617088318,
0.13968680799007416,
-0.8034908175468445,
0.2387215793132782,
0.5278221368789673,
-0.5726237893104553,
0.15283343195915222,
-0.8790155053138733,
0.7995744943618774,
-0.30922430753707886,
-0.17657168209552765,
-0.11162219941616058,
-0.3343285322189331,
0.22093044221401215,
0.08184143900871277,
0.3255567252635956,
-0.10311878472566605,
-0.104604072868824,
0.3071085512638092,
-0.3929010331630707,
1.0208617448806763,
-0.38651686906814575,
-0.27222633361816406,
0.4292077422142029,
0.3223457932472229,
0.5912432670593262,
0.04717244207859039,
-0.08356557786464691,
-0.35416051745414734,
-0.15053711831569672,
-0.13315558433532715,
-1.132239818572998,
0.6061909198760986,
-0.3616807162761688,
-0.8006420731544495,
0.10240408033132553,
-0.286822646856308,
-0.5487952828407288,
0.05612548068165779,
0.5834219455718994,
0.7529635429382324,
-0.2329082190990448,
0.23453137278556824,
0.41587918996810913,
-0.26933184266090393,
0.5498054027557373,
0.5309197902679443,
-0.7297385931015015,
-0.3332904279232025,
1.0047861337661743,
0.26512834429740906,
0.761462926864624,
0.0704021081328392,
0.5580114126205444,
-0.6999145746231079,
-0.6599065065383911,
-0.6175273060798645,
0.1972406655550003,
-0.8613096475601196,
-0.02789761684834957,
-0.5355901122093201,
0.22059069573879242,
-0.6952069401741028,
0.027284247800707817,
-0.3862096071243286,
-0.2607353925704956,
-0.20284241437911987,
-0.05765252560377121,
-0.08500529825687408,
0.7293061017990112,
-0.011214518919587135,
0.39597517251968384,
-0.5165114998817444,
0.28889498114585876,
0.7466350197792053,
0.13857027888298035,
0.11096981167793274,
-0.7461344003677368,
0.1253371685743332,
-0.10770095884799957,
-0.2752801477909088,
-0.9655956625938416,
0.42599213123321533,
0.49377477169036865,
0.780247688293457,
0.7133798599243164,
0.41648000478744507,
0.8375481367111206,
-0.3655591905117035,
0.9136471152305603,
0.17182688415050507,
-0.9644719362258911,
0.9354448318481445,
-0.40759557485580444,
0.14943891763687134,
0.6490605473518372,
0.32502317428588867,
-0.1976121962070465,
-0.5193006992340088,
-0.7147231698036194,
-0.9279128313064575,
0.32300764322280884,
-0.07700503617525101,
0.4541109502315521,
-0.15244323015213013,
0.32454511523246765,
0.5443728566169739,
0.3339582681655884,
-0.5654467344284058,
-0.2305549532175064,
-0.14254961907863617,
-0.0796392410993576,
0.08577364683151245,
-0.2127908170223236,
-0.12691539525985718,
-0.20715884864330292,
0.4387476146221161,
-0.6288250088691711,
-0.0585642047226429,
0.16956079006195068,
-0.283761203289032,
0.23886653780937195,
0.5441977977752686,
0.1431744247674942,
1.0093289613723755,
-0.15224073827266693,
0.042355749756097794,
0.2289918065071106,
0.08649992197751999,
0.2492365837097168,
-0.10798856616020203,
-0.1844891756772995,
0.05475873500108719,
0.04752698540687561,
0.47665321826934814,
0.20295259356498718,
-0.9015257954597473,
1.0212106704711914,
-0.13722212612628937,
-0.09085915237665176,
-0.2864706516265869,
0.10905315726995468,
-0.1602710336446762,
0.1503925621509552,
0.5510765910148621,
-0.6024218797683716,
0.43384867906570435,
-0.7283692955970764,
0.12492521852254868,
0.5432001948356628,
-0.2986222505569458,
-0.3126000463962555,
0.5833366513252258,
0.0935259535908699,
-0.12565931677818298,
0.43126213550567627,
-0.3548067808151245,
-0.08502711355686188,
0.44828641414642334,
0.8805172443389893,
0.6602308750152588,
0.03563467040657997,
0.2828366458415985,
0.23517121374607086,
-0.14668679237365723,
-0.10939647257328033,
0.18760567903518677,
-0.3877742886543274,
-0.4495152235031128,
-0.4068991243839264,
-0.08473236858844757,
-0.6340422630310059,
0.3058607578277588,
-0.8733139038085938,
0.26475903391838074,
-0.3625563085079193,
-0.08303651213645935,
-0.32998502254486084,
-0.40626129508018494,
-0.47301843762397766,
0.09774437546730042,
0.03143111988902092,
1.1552248001098633,
-0.769483745098114,
0.7703680992126465,
0.7009886503219604,
-0.35063594579696655,
-0.616016149520874,
0.2663988471031189,
-0.15052585303783417,
-0.939610481262207,
0.7179267406463623,
0.1739758551120758,
-0.0017070886678993702,
0.157039612531662,
-0.873723566532135,
-0.6491224765777588,
0.9175782799720764,
0.7763262987136841,
-0.5509837865829468,
-0.08897589892148972,
0.14232727885246277,
0.3895687758922577,
-0.31528565287590027,
0.3599931299686432,
0.2936585545539856,
0.1977483034133911,
-0.02356830984354019,
-0.7748136520385742,
-0.07085580378770828,
0.11776726692914963,
-0.18928179144859314,
-0.15268667042255402,
-0.6899461150169373,
0.8112666606903076,
-0.2749142646789551,
-0.3100491762161255,
0.27867063879966736,
0.9464746117591858,
0.5235454440116882,
0.28863200545310974,
0.7376444935798645,
0.34468916058540344,
0.7280288934707642,
0.09011330455541611,
1.1348538398742676,
-0.11781288683414459,
0.2245083898305893,
1.4722812175750732,
-0.11428305506706238,
1.0198893547058105,
0.5595188736915588,
-0.19184643030166626,
0.4230433404445648,
0.22127275168895721,
0.30235347151756287,
0.4452402889728546,
0.29667404294013977,
-0.4250219166278839,
-0.5046384334564209,
-0.03805932775139809,
-0.582595944404602,
0.43959861993789673,
0.3753852844238281,
-0.22280460596084595,
-0.5651030540466309,
0.2014608234167099,
-0.17173269391059875,
0.3712807893753052,
-0.11097019165754318,
0.7717397212982178,
-0.09842172265052795,
-0.7673236131668091,
0.4054222106933594,
-0.4772852659225464,
0.7349020838737488,
-0.7668456435203552,
-0.17078465223312378,
-0.4256812334060669,
0.13494226336479187,
0.15982681512832642,
-0.7801517844200134,
-0.18523885309696198,
-0.19233424961566925,
0.07428976148366928,
-0.2972636818885803,
0.3747733235359192,
-0.4788156747817993,
-0.16092121601104736,
0.30120766162872314,
0.7608940005302429,
0.243946373462677,
-0.4763336777687073,
-0.48805204033851624,
-0.21934133768081665,
-0.22683903574943542,
-0.07098165154457092,
0.6978476047515869,
0.6585708856582642,
-0.021165553480386734,
0.775954008102417,
0.53919917345047,
0.06987841427326202,
0.3186689615249634,
0.34619972109794617,
0.9898804426193237,
-0.4894806146621704,
-0.5953355431556702,
-0.8097163438796997,
0.31373658776283264,
-0.14653590321540833,
-0.48010900616645813,
1.0355945825576782,
0.6061201095581055,
0.8979706168174744,
-0.18899543583393097,
0.9524669647216797,
0.20666927099227905,
0.6858389377593994,
-0.4947596788406372,
0.5114519000053406,
-0.6876188516616821,
0.10497493296861649,
0.00991213321685791,
-0.5547688007354736,
-0.022176917642354965,
0.21403564512729645,
-0.24370601773262024,
-0.08956649899482727,
0.33992230892181396,
0.7846697568893433,
-0.16593851149082184,
-0.3279227614402771,
0.5949118137359619,
0.15528243780136108,
0.7531751394271851,
0.19329318404197693,
1.3491195440292358,
-0.08782758563756943,
0.7739415764808655,
-0.2728564441204071,
-0.307057648897171,
-0.28782132267951965,
-1.0387721061706543,
-0.984375,
-0.5834597945213318,
-0.21811243891716003,
-0.2597943842411041,
0.037852369248867035,
1.0493254661560059,
0.8851293921470642,
-0.7338433265686035,
-0.33517858386039734,
-0.1426948606967926,
-0.13791000843048096,
-0.10697589069604874,
-0.2050294131040573,
0.3012547492980957,
-0.7311423420906067,
-0.8519192934036255,
0.8642743229866028,
0.1236409991979599,
0.1386278122663498,
-0.525459885597229,
0.22303420305252075,
0.18821865320205688,
-0.04754825308918953,
0.38280269503593445,
0.6077601909637451,
-0.743488073348999,
-0.09083805233240128,
-0.169546976685524,
0.10943520814180374,
0.07172104716300964,
0.8833643794059753,
-1.0855474472045898,
0.7815001010894775,
0.42589709162712097,
0.4938408136367798,
0.31817978620529175,
0.16826817393302917,
0.6543233394622803,
-1.2059845924377441,
0.17402590811252594,
0.19093097746372223,
0.3360562026500702,
0.09868602454662323,
-0.16458134353160858,
0.35324105620384216,
-0.07542185485363007,
-0.43520545959472656,
-0.978516697883606,
0.3246802091598511,
-0.60252845287323,
-0.16690780222415924,
1.388136386871338,
-0.3544118106365204,
-0.19884927570819855,
-0.10903605818748474,
-0.33852919936180115,
-0.23200199007987976,
-0.530256986618042,
0.8900979161262512,
0.33979716897010803,
-0.27482566237449646,
0.11026428639888763,
-0.45893150568008423,
0.37542396783828735,
0.28758636116981506,
-0.8403247594833374,
0.2727765440940857,
0.42562007904052734,
0.38226816058158875,
-0.04988749697804451,
0.7554152011871338,
-0.12748950719833374,
0.17117244005203247,
-0.2265099436044693,
-0.007598129566758871,
-0.24911421537399292,
-0.3364886939525604,
-0.448611855506897,
0.4203382134437561,
0.27916476130485535,
-0.406802237033844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00862v1
|
Bailong: Bilingual Transfer Learning based on QLoRA and Zip-tie Embedding
| 2024-04-01T02:04:44 | 2024-04-01T02:04:44 |
Lung-Chuan Chen, Zong-Ru Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance in
various NLP applications. However, the majority of existing open-source LLMs
are pre-trained primarily on English data and little part of other languages.
This deficiency in multilingual training data results in suboptimal performance
when applied to languages with fewer available resources. Furthermore,
enhancing the performance of LLMs on low-resource languages by full-parameter
fine-tuning with additional data requires substantial computational resources,
posing computational barriers for research organizations and individual
researchers. Consequently, several techniques such as parameter-efficient
tuning and advanced embedding initialization have been proposed to address
these challenges. In this work, we combine them to facilitate cross-lingual
transfer on English-dominated open-source LLM. To effectively enhance the
model's proficiency in Traditional Chinese, we conduct secondary pre-training
on Llama 2 7B with Traditional Chinese data by leveraging QLoRA and our
proposed zip-tie embedding initialization. The resulting model called Bailong,
which stands for Bilingual trAnsfer learnIng based on qLOra and zip-tie
embeddiNG. We present Bailong-instruct 7B, a fine-tuned version of Bailong 7B
optimized for multi-turn dialogue scenarios. Recognizing the inadequacy of
benchmark datasets in Traditional Chinese, we further introduce Bailong-bench
to assess the alignment of models with human preferences and the capability to
follow instructions in both Traditional Chinese and English tasks. In our
evaluation, Bailong-instruct 7B exhibits competitive performance on
Bailong-bench and other benchmark datasets when compared to other open-source
models of similar or even larger parameter sizes. Bailong-instruct 7B and
Bailong-bench are publicly available with the aim of empowering the community
to build upon our efforts.
|
[
-0.23285694420337677,
-0.34374263882637024,
0.34471067786216736,
0.4912259578704834,
-0.4088667631149292,
0.21395888924598694,
-0.39921095967292786,
-0.44482019543647766,
0.2768171727657318,
0.42944663763046265,
-0.06329776346683502,
-0.4203535318374634,
-0.519036591053009,
0.06516747921705246,
-0.11851529777050018,
0.7375435829162598,
-0.054283808916807175,
0.1650329828262329,
0.13584484159946442,
-0.08495835959911346,
-0.492788165807724,
-0.3432299494743347,
-0.730115532875061,
-0.1809365153312683,
0.6314365863800049,
0.6019794940948486,
0.5478829145431519,
0.47872576117515564,
0.09105969965457916,
0.14046244323253632,
-0.01744147762656212,
0.48909053206443787,
-0.7417237758636475,
-0.3329983949661255,
-0.23020008206367493,
-0.7900781631469727,
-0.4540541172027588,
-0.17589491605758667,
0.752229630947113,
0.376667320728302,
-0.2374677062034607,
0.22053515911102295,
-0.11805129051208496,
0.6142151355743408,
-0.6330850720405579,
0.4091113805770874,
-0.711284339427948,
0.1391894370317459,
-0.15925267338752747,
-0.20335286855697632,
-0.45663243532180786,
-0.6029834747314453,
0.0887351930141449,
-0.6927950382232666,
-0.0700300931930542,
0.19247712194919586,
0.5641637444496155,
0.0917050689458847,
-0.6666319370269775,
-0.3016909956932068,
-0.4301806688308716,
0.5140562057495117,
-0.961914598941803,
0.4772501587867737,
0.42502474784851074,
0.31946229934692383,
-0.15541094541549683,
-0.4662613570690155,
-0.5611520409584045,
-0.3466094434261322,
-0.06205961853265762,
0.09374873340129852,
0.3292393088340759,
-0.0831257551908493,
0.11415358632802963,
0.22895468771457672,
-0.6469522714614868,
0.48464831709861755,
-0.6744843125343323,
0.07467783987522125,
0.831652045249939,
-0.1098611131310463,
0.5155766010284424,
0.009139695204794407,
-0.39262130856513977,
-0.22542813420295715,
-0.8509035110473633,
0.25801825523376465,
0.20775732398033142,
0.6486319899559021,
-0.37605100870132446,
0.34929394721984863,
0.06256355345249176,
0.5225374698638916,
0.2730325758457184,
-0.21215486526489258,
0.3175611197948456,
-0.17957817018032074,
-0.0869966372847557,
0.404643177986145,
0.6914678812026978,
0.12191236764192581,
0.40989696979522705,
-0.20899026095867157,
0.020610349252820015,
-0.56965172290802,
0.057805612683296204,
-0.6152551174163818,
-0.08858348429203033,
0.13546736538410187,
-0.2019723653793335,
-0.2462851107120514,
0.431477427482605,
-0.6400315165519714,
-0.2967883050441742,
-0.17837156355381012,
0.26362696290016174,
-0.21151643991470337,
-0.2577022910118103,
0.1652490794658661,
0.33047810196876526,
0.5261995196342468,
0.32605770230293274,
-1.1041876077651978,
0.11331111192703247,
0.5744699239730835,
1.049195408821106,
-0.1336180865764618,
-0.4580276310443878,
-0.7664028406143188,
0.45409145951271057,
-0.6155030727386475,
0.5617507100105286,
-0.23073101043701172,
-0.11435079574584961,
0.28620198369026184,
0.4406328499317169,
-0.3399646282196045,
-0.41502246260643005,
0.6225265860557556,
-0.41103067994117737,
0.01986204832792282,
-0.32009974122047424,
-0.2689630389213562,
-0.4294682741165161,
-0.05561061203479767,
-0.856753408908844,
0.8838092088699341,
0.1945565640926361,
-0.6547361016273499,
0.0285041444003582,
-0.2578262388706207,
-0.6132069826126099,
-0.1457098126411438,
0.09713660925626755,
-0.30418631434440613,
0.08069419115781784,
0.42044246196746826,
0.367299348115921,
-0.6066581010818481,
0.2448042333126068,
-0.26775169372558594,
-0.5851521492004395,
-0.13888463377952576,
0.028311071917414665,
0.8819693326950073,
0.016383636742830276,
-0.381329208612442,
-0.0917016789317131,
-0.7107023596763611,
-0.04808517545461655,
0.06531213223934174,
-0.21167781949043274,
-0.3683610260486603,
-0.25428488850593567,
-0.062407009303569794,
0.35749801993370056,
0.18058918416500092,
-0.2851526737213135,
0.32420116662979126,
-0.4980648458003998,
0.2863149642944336,
0.7314944267272949,
-0.4873870313167572,
0.4808267652988434,
-0.3761395215988159,
0.558840811252594,
0.05151507630944252,
-0.0418759323656559,
-0.2057255059480667,
-0.35371464490890503,
-0.6769686341285706,
-0.1769331395626068,
0.5378541946411133,
0.9059781432151794,
-0.7301336526870728,
0.29916277527809143,
-0.19870448112487793,
-0.5285526514053345,
-0.568728506565094,
0.36741894483566284,
0.2429874688386917,
0.15501490235328674,
0.4606053829193115,
-0.39039596915245056,
-0.4260390102863312,
-0.7129229307174683,
-0.0425553061068058,
-0.19949975609779358,
-0.03154752776026726,
0.21190515160560608,
0.07712181657552719,
-0.0030280177015811205,
0.473351389169693,
-0.20316435396671295,
-0.4054505527019501,
-0.2528418004512787,
0.002270918805152178,
0.2347717434167862,
0.5237035751342773,
0.7731143832206726,
-0.690972089767456,
-0.786784827709198,
0.45185860991477966,
-0.6138294339179993,
-0.26239925622940063,
-0.23656775057315826,
-0.30133262276649475,
0.1403767168521881,
0.3258524537086487,
-0.45980316400527954,
0.1419791579246521,
0.7944767475128174,
-0.0012467621127143502,
0.5855115056037903,
-0.361663818359375,
0.14058813452720642,
-1.1287646293640137,
-0.14522747695446014,
-0.23519274592399597,
-0.18469925224781036,
-0.6732824444770813,
-0.06089415401220322,
0.3603593707084656,
0.017643166705965996,
-0.5564045906066895,
0.4988165497779846,
-0.6497295498847961,
-0.11284353584051132,
-0.18593208491802216,
0.2873394787311554,
-0.10157100856304169,
0.5656480193138123,
-0.15692803263664246,
0.6848933100700378,
0.4378218650817871,
-0.28500130772590637,
0.3973722755908966,
0.37548819184303284,
-0.1723247617483139,
0.29692038893699646,
-0.692241370677948,
0.41176432371139526,
0.02866446226835251,
0.35214322805404663,
-0.7342902421951294,
-0.04266464710235596,
0.32968205213546753,
-0.01328198704868555,
0.5613998174667358,
-0.379094660282135,
-0.44409915804862976,
-0.20302408933639526,
-0.4595385789871216,
0.619744062423706,
0.41611236333847046,
-0.9032412171363831,
0.38195177912712097,
0.129488006234169,
-0.276340514421463,
-0.5577878355979919,
-0.67142653465271,
-0.0045380559749901295,
-0.36752772331237793,
-0.6618955135345459,
0.47238069772720337,
0.057059768587350845,
0.2127062976360321,
-0.2509402334690094,
0.1265677958726883,
-0.20367102324962616,
-0.19537362456321716,
-0.0472920686006546,
0.20146282017230988,
-0.2867914140224457,
0.15096250176429749,
0.40907958149909973,
0.07976370304822922,
-0.2156539410352707,
-0.5321456789970398,
0.32127994298934937,
-0.07782041281461716,
-0.20503084361553192,
-0.18122024834156036,
0.33899691700935364,
0.48639458417892456,
-0.517799437046051,
1.0443012714385986,
0.8511598110198975,
-0.19811689853668213,
-0.4897902011871338,
-0.5099037289619446,
0.24170729517936707,
-0.4152177572250366,
0.30247029662132263,
-0.3704493045806885,
-0.9548928737640381,
0.5396697521209717,
-0.19139721989631653,
0.05891573429107666,
0.05634591728448868,
0.6685043573379517,
0.2981499135494232,
0.7320815324783325,
0.78118896484375,
-0.2860145568847656,
0.4504186809062958,
-0.0031320552807301283,
0.367441862821579,
-0.7155277729034424,
-0.13940301537513733,
-0.2239597588777542,
0.005935703869909048,
-0.7298831343650818,
-0.6938250660896301,
0.2895320951938629,
0.6184601783752441,
-0.2658730745315552,
0.4906611442565918,
-0.10285492986440659,
0.1989906281232834,
0.47026798129081726,
0.148429274559021,
0.18671441078186035,
-0.11109865456819534,
-0.15374889969825745,
0.24715662002563477,
-0.9671887159347534,
-0.3678361177444458,
1.1203855276107788,
0.25291937589645386,
0.7262777090072632,
0.17805016040802002,
0.7010840177536011,
0.24337142705917358,
0.08205336332321167,
-0.5490568280220032,
0.15399937331676483,
-0.2384963035583496,
0.11098024994134903,
-0.2484271079301834,
-0.3434717059135437,
-0.9273949861526489,
0.39116525650024414,
-0.17553161084651947,
-0.7580052614212036,
0.2935456931591034,
0.09840013831853867,
-0.24543003737926483,
0.4182996153831482,
-0.6100242137908936,
0.6050887703895569,
-0.5087633728981018,
-0.43132901191711426,
-0.1610793173313141,
-0.5454025864601135,
0.7090702056884766,
-0.4336775243282318,
0.3312314450740814,
-0.19549500942230225,
0.14206671714782715,
0.5210796594619751,
-0.1678042709827423,
0.7498078942298889,
0.034668125212192535,
-0.5285739898681641,
0.1224583238363266,
-0.019945956766605377,
0.6910831332206726,
0.11162702739238739,
0.012605546042323112,
0.23178830742835999,
0.18008407950401306,
-0.43028464913368225,
-0.8657127618789673,
0.6391606330871582,
-0.7407860159873962,
-0.6537749767303467,
-0.09250431507825851,
-0.5215513706207275,
-0.17448540031909943,
0.018854130059480667,
-0.11945502460002899,
0.2201019525527954,
0.1301472932100296,
-0.03522462770342827,
0.3790976405143738,
-0.5632452368736267,
0.10448167473077774,
0.46157437562942505,
-0.29367658495903015,
-0.39846181869506836,
0.9675124883651733,
0.29325437545776367,
0.2710690498352051,
0.37695813179016113,
0.3378356397151947,
-0.11146897822618484,
-0.34144219756126404,
-0.5168105959892273,
0.5460888147354126,
-0.4688907265663147,
-0.11417526751756668,
-0.15631231665611267,
-0.2726873755455017,
-0.6060321927070618,
-0.21209117770195007,
-0.5441125631332397,
-0.5521905422210693,
-0.1319887638092041,
-0.1608172059059143,
0.10093896090984344,
0.6864832639694214,
-0.38926422595977783,
0.07891274988651276,
-0.8828210234642029,
0.36677810549736023,
0.27579063177108765,
0.24240843951702118,
0.2633941173553467,
-0.5523771643638611,
-0.7702594995498657,
0.1266460120677948,
-0.11740906536579132,
-0.9178308248519897,
0.465312123298645,
0.28695347905158997,
0.716271698474884,
0.5009766221046448,
0.2735044062137604,
0.4246450364589691,
-0.6245274543762207,
0.5965881943702698,
0.09928592294454575,
-0.9112615585327148,
0.4747403562068939,
-0.2734473645687103,
-0.08582626283168793,
0.23170581459999084,
0.6652511358261108,
-0.4025310277938843,
-0.19118833541870117,
-0.21540479362010956,
-0.7985435724258423,
0.7398409247398376,
0.011841759085655212,
-0.20871947705745697,
0.2859213650226593,
0.2862144410610199,
0.17959342896938324,
0.15211303532123566,
-0.4954761266708374,
-0.05006116256117821,
-0.2819003760814667,
0.05105367675423622,
-0.31712546944618225,
-0.27247941493988037,
-0.0973871499300003,
-0.3654513955116272,
0.5420048832893372,
-0.31851789355278015,
0.060327790677547455,
0.16538336873054504,
-0.3641597032546997,
0.02170737273991108,
0.10577630996704102,
0.6761932969093323,
0.7227311730384827,
-0.16002032160758972,
0.08943718671798706,
0.39031216502189636,
-0.1682254821062088,
0.3510054647922516,
0.1257464736700058,
-0.09196938574314117,
-0.18538394570350647,
0.3734971880912781,
0.9317825436592102,
0.40023672580718994,
-0.5608469247817993,
0.22595001757144928,
0.22851407527923584,
-0.08609689772129059,
-0.18893292546272278,
-0.05598916858434677,
0.09539342671632767,
0.545641303062439,
0.33154192566871643,
-0.63702392578125,
-0.10058141499757767,
-0.5678511261940002,
0.05808570235967636,
0.1309840977191925,
-0.0850352868437767,
-0.525597333908081,
0.4884435534477234,
0.07723750919103622,
-0.3846249580383301,
0.360299676656723,
-0.10490678995847702,
-0.7734211087226868,
0.45724961161613464,
0.7358569502830505,
0.8269986510276794,
-0.4361960291862488,
0.4441186785697937,
0.6456438302993774,
0.507807195186615,
-0.3245741128921509,
-0.009638482704758644,
-0.1813976913690567,
-0.7385486960411072,
-0.36002105474472046,
-0.45245856046676636,
-0.5003306865692139,
-0.22399328649044037,
-0.811302125453949,
0.26381975412368774,
-0.2546607553958893,
0.1950644552707672,
-0.7410489916801453,
0.16656798124313354,
-0.5508671998977661,
-0.18716740608215332,
0.27936556935310364,
0.8023614883422852,
-0.8307055830955505,
0.9735045433044434,
0.43440812826156616,
-0.2933928668498993,
-1.0539162158966064,
-0.13392768800258636,
-0.1984792947769165,
-0.6705410480499268,
0.5608440637588501,
0.10167501121759415,
-0.04071635380387306,
-0.03782465308904648,
-0.4273137152194977,
-0.9310325384140015,
1.2432838678359985,
0.6747881770133972,
-0.5489170551300049,
-0.22265231609344482,
0.2276805341243744,
0.3803078830242157,
-0.46301203966140747,
0.3449271023273468,
0.6666032075881958,
0.5584512948989868,
-0.0982857421040535,
-1.307763695716858,
0.2844579219818115,
-0.1530887335538864,
0.06858650594949722,
-0.242141455411911,
-1.1361671686172485,
0.9201176762580872,
-0.24746453762054443,
-0.2612915337085724,
0.016165826469659805,
0.6259139180183411,
0.426113098859787,
0.1515822410583496,
0.4550483524799347,
0.30666014552116394,
0.8920823931694031,
0.21765707433223724,
0.7752639651298523,
-0.41361719369888306,
0.27871963381767273,
1.039522409439087,
-0.37107911705970764,
0.9527350664138794,
0.34271693229675293,
-0.19308815896511078,
0.523362934589386,
0.5191865563392639,
0.053378526121377945,
0.477215051651001,
0.28391435742378235,
-0.04976169019937515,
0.016514642164111137,
-0.030016126111149788,
-0.5159277319908142,
0.4783569276332855,
0.24241657555103302,
-0.09870416671037674,
-0.12582160532474518,
0.018840795382857323,
-0.1678161472082138,
-0.13172799348831177,
-0.27702847123146057,
0.44650307297706604,
0.3192463219165802,
-0.4551141560077667,
0.8765780925750732,
0.053128354251384735,
0.7095435857772827,
-0.7374022603034973,
-0.12262167781591415,
-0.3930109143257141,
-0.13936878740787506,
-0.2445429265499115,
-0.22259540855884552,
-0.1401994824409485,
-0.30596107244491577,
0.057676441967487335,
0.10269947350025177,
0.47757816314697266,
-0.9166314005851746,
-0.4450743496417999,
0.5673035383224487,
0.46533694863319397,
0.1401302069425583,
0.22167427837848663,
-0.45599988102912903,
-0.10835782438516617,
-0.02246689982712269,
-0.16403767466545105,
0.47158047556877136,
0.42836254835128784,
-0.28995218873023987,
0.6475481390953064,
0.7911780476570129,
0.4691917300224304,
0.44509437680244446,
0.22568732500076294,
0.7528536319732666,
-0.5266779661178589,
-0.6320586800575256,
-0.39623376727104187,
0.21439333260059357,
0.23971332609653473,
-0.010233729146420956,
0.7381587028503418,
0.30715063214302063,
0.9672873020172119,
-0.06395169347524643,
0.6926543712615967,
0.2340647131204605,
0.2759949266910553,
-0.8480361104011536,
0.6913616061210632,
-0.569135308265686,
0.13587774336338043,
-0.3323245644569397,
-0.9025832414627075,
-0.13351638615131378,
0.6384965777397156,
-0.10124454647302628,
-0.156622514128685,
0.5267698764801025,
0.7896500825881958,
-0.10385669022798538,
-0.11319006234407425,
0.4956040382385254,
0.17203353345394135,
0.38763055205345154,
1.0237295627593994,
0.736690104007721,
-0.43833187222480774,
0.33530372381210327,
-0.27223995327949524,
-0.2712349593639374,
-0.2242552489042282,
-0.8758525848388672,
-1.0315598249435425,
-0.48026445508003235,
0.03587518632411957,
-0.028224080801010132,
0.3166879713535309,
1.0395004749298096,
0.6526398062705994,
-0.7624221444129944,
-0.5742682218551636,
0.26780420541763306,
0.2773120105266571,
-0.26202666759490967,
-0.17824141681194305,
0.6319889426231384,
-0.4512246549129486,
-0.7379279136657715,
0.6134694814682007,
0.10233309119939804,
0.0167989544570446,
-0.35968783497810364,
-0.22299453616142273,
-0.3644965589046478,
0.04250255227088928,
0.640186071395874,
0.6652328372001648,
-0.6117525696754456,
-0.24967356026172638,
-0.259381502866745,
0.09973355382680893,
0.09605144709348679,
0.8674143552780151,
-0.5527826547622681,
0.3781709671020508,
0.47860637307167053,
0.7911829352378845,
0.638713538646698,
0.11382219940423965,
1.0425304174423218,
-0.40492141246795654,
0.4426693916320801,
-0.2227422297000885,
0.29528069496154785,
0.3262590169906616,
-0.3412714898586273,
0.499737024307251,
-0.05651051551103592,
-0.45267924666404724,
-0.9112417101860046,
-0.0759958028793335,
-0.9349370002746582,
-0.028888847678899765,
0.9765373468399048,
-0.5240941047668457,
-0.061103783547878265,
0.05812181532382965,
-0.25116482377052307,
0.5029358267784119,
-0.12903907895088196,
0.7575944662094116,
0.5043699145317078,
0.13094566762447357,
-0.4615849256515503,
-0.5763383507728577,
0.3753628134727478,
0.3952060043811798,
-0.7020803689956665,
-0.07753309607505798,
-0.08751138299703598,
0.04777458682656288,
-0.06427858769893646,
0.48863521218299866,
0.14668028056621552,
0.3401194214820862,
-0.10847093909978867,
-0.08959020674228668,
-0.328345388174057,
-0.4538187086582184,
-0.31379520893096924,
0.09280622005462646,
-0.08379985392093658,
-0.023334311321377754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00859v1
|
Do language models plan ahead for future tokens?
| 2024-04-01T02:01:28 | 2024-04-01T02:01:28 |
Wilson Wu, John X. Morris, Lionel Levine
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Do transformers "think ahead" during inference at a given position? It is
known transformers prepare information in the hidden states of the forward pass
at $t$ that is then used in future forward passes $t+\tau$. We posit two
explanations for this phenomenon: pre-caching, in which off-diagonal gradient
terms present in training result in the model computing features at $t$
irrelevant to the present inference task but useful for the future, and
breadcrumbs, in which features most relevant to time step $t$ are already the
same as those that would most benefit inference at time $t+\tau$. We test these
hypotheses by training language models without propagating gradients to past
timesteps, a scheme we formalize as myopic training. In a synthetic data
setting, we find clear evidence for pre-caching. In the autoregressive language
modeling setting, our experiments are more suggestive of the breadcrumbs
hypothesis.
|
[
-0.41720032691955566,
-0.4929921329021454,
0.5295549631118774,
0.1459842175245285,
0.062113869935274124,
0.23858505487442017,
-0.09625851362943649,
-0.44601666927337646,
0.46545010805130005,
0.5635531544685364,
-0.8928016424179077,
-0.005639694631099701,
-0.38304445147514343,
-0.17875473201274872,
-1.0069726705551147,
0.7580559253692627,
0.03299174830317497,
-0.05327904596924782,
0.022529860958456993,
0.12615461647510529,
-0.3707791864871979,
-0.710774838924408,
-0.6305297017097473,
-0.4503445029258728,
0.6703010201454163,
0.2898249328136444,
1.0026191473007202,
0.6597236394882202,
0.07521571964025497,
0.3488650619983673,
0.15714646875858307,
-0.6078705787658691,
-0.12508943676948547,
0.22020727396011353,
-0.3104097247123718,
-0.9161501526832581,
-0.296257883310318,
0.4674493074417114,
0.5203288793563843,
0.7691908478736877,
-0.09057657420635223,
0.12014182657003403,
-0.2759857475757599,
0.4663967490196228,
-0.8907668590545654,
0.18949061632156372,
-0.7433777451515198,
0.42738035321235657,
-0.30259427428245544,
-0.277072936296463,
-0.6722908616065979,
-0.2905842065811157,
0.10177434235811234,
-0.24264241755008698,
0.5798928141593933,
-0.01937483437359333,
0.7416014671325684,
0.16011928021907806,
-0.07578872889280319,
-0.2407897561788559,
-0.7529710531234741,
0.6905696392059326,
-0.7025870680809021,
0.6871173977851868,
0.5388913750648499,
0.5520171523094177,
-0.1430739015340805,
-1.0761828422546387,
-0.8479579091072083,
-0.2690242528915405,
-0.17787064611911774,
0.3035767078399658,
-0.0036696174647659063,
-0.043948374688625336,
0.23952040076255798,
0.2780507504940033,
-0.22046270966529846,
0.36264196038246155,
0.008619217202067375,
-0.14453841745853424,
0.058930858969688416,
0.3197025954723358,
-0.037131041288375854,
0.0681791752576828,
-0.5490146279335022,
-0.49324485659599304,
-0.6375739574432373,
0.1642303168773651,
0.23946687579154968,
0.36460191011428833,
-0.206556037068367,
0.610891580581665,
0.14484603703022003,
0.48744723200798035,
0.1456393301486969,
0.2855100929737091,
0.14166514575481415,
-0.21877852082252502,
-0.18702884018421173,
0.01927967742085457,
0.41618812084198,
-0.04183428734540939,
0.5313136577606201,
-0.38449543714523315,
-0.30354395508766174,
0.37289151549339294,
0.313309907913208,
-0.6184561848640442,
-0.3685838282108307,
0.31478431820869446,
-0.24564163386821747,
-0.22674453258514404,
-0.037860918790102005,
-0.7997341156005859,
0.03759397193789482,
-0.20780068635940552,
0.13749010860919952,
-0.2546943426132202,
-0.2721189558506012,
0.04921849071979523,
-0.27536439895629883,
0.026912741363048553,
0.056505076587200165,
-1.1425977945327759,
0.4131205976009369,
0.6855903267860413,
0.5195906162261963,
0.001994226360693574,
-0.5311810970306396,
-0.4515584707260132,
0.24629084765911102,
-0.5637233257293701,
1.0891116857528687,
-0.9559481739997864,
-0.5097007155418396,
0.2537585496902466,
0.0661245584487915,
-0.2779248058795929,
-0.23604801297187805,
0.256963312625885,
-0.6092373728752136,
0.3300647437572479,
-0.2894758880138397,
-0.4867836833000183,
-0.03955163434147835,
0.01730535179376602,
-0.6613384485244751,
0.8751448392868042,
0.0130601916462183,
-0.8453004360198975,
0.5669939517974854,
-0.41494637727737427,
-0.5427972674369812,
-0.3020356297492981,
-0.34354671835899353,
-0.22331884503364563,
0.15950006246566772,
0.3315425515174866,
0.41956114768981934,
0.05029737949371338,
0.3413388729095459,
-0.19470946490764618,
-0.3396058678627014,
0.4654610753059387,
-0.5067643523216248,
0.5863965749740601,
0.06887859851121902,
-0.5699601173400879,
-0.16270609200000763,
-0.39977800846099854,
-0.003336655907332897,
0.1118675172328949,
-0.24517133831977844,
0.0790761187672615,
0.5764163136482239,
-0.27424100041389465,
0.5441343188285828,
0.05241120606660843,
-0.34089428186416626,
0.06452544033527374,
-0.3778822720050812,
0.5580160617828369,
1.203198790550232,
-0.3166564404964447,
0.5789269804954529,
-0.35213008522987366,
0.7364006638526917,
0.37930917739868164,
0.27624964714050293,
-0.7039404511451721,
-0.4735255539417267,
-1.327309489250183,
0.36994460225105286,
0.4348334074020386,
0.4014139175415039,
-0.5916009545326233,
0.222348153591156,
-0.2661774456501007,
-0.4871349036693573,
-0.11535055935382843,
-0.6324658393859863,
0.4163196384906769,
0.4200204312801361,
0.46336719393730164,
-0.4305655062198639,
-0.4846367835998535,
-0.9214791059494019,
-0.4535691440105438,
-0.2537297010421753,
0.23879800736904144,
-0.09718161821365356,
0.3834007978439331,
-0.10456998646259308,
0.9806571006774902,
-0.40791064500808716,
0.14279772341251373,
-0.29938286542892456,
0.4318282902240753,
-0.0006232047453522682,
0.5960608720779419,
0.458633154630661,
-0.8554995656013489,
-0.10232313722372055,
-0.5176262855529785,
-0.14205724000930786,
-0.0026801880449056625,
-0.292642205953598,
0.0794648677110672,
0.21235430240631104,
0.8349547386169434,
-0.6740850806236267,
0.5591544508934021,
0.7141559720039368,
-0.33319079875946045,
0.5779345631599426,
0.02184707671403885,
-0.06681817024946213,
-0.7201505303382874,
-0.02527371421456337,
-0.327161967754364,
-0.19122624397277832,
-0.4894006550312042,
-0.19126494228839874,
-0.001120388275012374,
-0.012391685508191586,
-0.39293017983436584,
0.8598926663398743,
-0.4030660390853882,
-0.40822169184684753,
-0.1747450828552246,
0.18192818760871887,
-0.011038345284759998,
0.4381656348705292,
0.02669680304825306,
1.0077686309814453,
0.3876307010650635,
-0.7627991437911987,
-0.5045852661132812,
0.10545725375413895,
-0.1861659437417984,
-0.07654177397489548,
-0.20209930837154388,
0.042984865605831146,
-0.058882445096969604,
0.5329193472862244,
-0.952470064163208,
0.1849517822265625,
0.1642150729894638,
-0.6876413226127625,
0.3649195432662964,
-0.045096199959516525,
-0.5370937585830688,
-0.881605327129364,
0.07198977470397949,
0.27254536747932434,
0.558653712272644,
-0.4769397974014282,
0.825082004070282,
0.38267451524734497,
-0.039790909737348557,
-0.8006435036659241,
-1.1041641235351562,
0.00772473681718111,
0.12276341021060944,
-0.14957380294799805,
0.4716620147228241,
0.09107756614685059,
-0.26315563917160034,
-0.0944061353802681,
-0.016100989654660225,
-0.029603764414787292,
0.13892807066440582,
0.36984893679618835,
-0.08371888101100922,
-0.27055248618125916,
0.2009909451007843,
-0.20522721111774445,
-0.5522062182426453,
0.0988728329539299,
-0.4716454744338989,
0.9807591438293457,
0.09165365993976593,
-0.5041787028312683,
-0.3221129775047302,
0.24954290688037872,
0.36786365509033203,
-0.45648694038391113,
0.5661207437515259,
0.5611831545829773,
-0.26658135652542114,
0.010990026406943798,
-0.9189170002937317,
-0.41096970438957214,
-0.5495104789733887,
0.11774462461471558,
-0.36470872163772583,
-0.6316789984703064,
0.8920091986656189,
0.09362944960594177,
0.19843070209026337,
0.5214502811431885,
0.6415265202522278,
-0.15727201104164124,
0.9637472033500671,
0.8711594939231873,
-0.021391749382019043,
0.9506490230560303,
-0.3294309973716736,
0.26857733726501465,
-0.5904093980789185,
-0.1332637369632721,
-0.6955861449241638,
-0.2829076647758484,
-0.5680238008499146,
-0.5969719290733337,
-0.12137878686189651,
-0.11394716054201126,
-0.27865803241729736,
0.3306131660938263,
0.07671469449996948,
0.5700315833091736,
0.7661800980567932,
-0.24159377813339233,
-0.013137701898813248,
-0.2449137270450592,
-0.4907386898994446,
-0.06335269659757614,
-0.7979733943939209,
-0.24881844222545624,
0.7718856930732727,
0.06953608989715576,
0.6421329975128174,
-0.6545175313949585,
0.3948967456817627,
0.14225620031356812,
0.31095215678215027,
-0.3629346489906311,
0.640838623046875,
-0.15683071315288544,
-0.8297014236450195,
-0.007585079409182072,
0.03159007802605629,
-1.0712347030639648,
0.10127657651901245,
-0.08668005466461182,
-0.7999082803726196,
0.23355676233768463,
0.3777600824832916,
-0.06649056822061539,
0.5855003595352173,
-0.6586595773696899,
0.666395902633667,
-0.21339762210845947,
-0.11534474790096283,
-0.5359933972358704,
-0.8195778727531433,
-0.004621247760951519,
-0.009700799360871315,
0.19838730990886688,
-0.1311187446117401,
0.0716514140367508,
0.8539198637008667,
-0.29865145683288574,
0.9689676761627197,
-0.24938315153121948,
0.20649971067905426,
0.3373596966266632,
0.35826683044433594,
0.5233865976333618,
-0.3273496627807617,
-0.04309339448809624,
0.029515640810132027,
-0.2630370259284973,
-0.3556020259857178,
-0.5333448648452759,
0.3878086507320404,
-0.2598433196544647,
-0.7486474514007568,
-0.3608570098876953,
-0.38973745703697205,
-0.2861001193523407,
0.35073983669281006,
0.3213498294353485,
0.5694594979286194,
0.04317779466509819,
-0.22325006127357483,
0.2347087413072586,
-0.21205845475196838,
1.0233906507492065,
0.4597187638282776,
-0.3740365207195282,
0.19419626891613007,
0.3996071517467499,
0.14933143556118011,
0.459330290555954,
0.5252180099487305,
0.2841236889362335,
-0.2527523338794708,
-0.5455344319343567,
-0.07821201533079147,
0.18525154888629913,
-0.8047273755073547,
-0.009503833018243313,
-0.7531769871711731,
-0.2331591248512268,
-0.2506154775619507,
-0.46781888604164124,
-0.7263957858085632,
-0.6580568552017212,
-0.07449258863925934,
-0.15503820776939392,
0.045488033443689346,
0.672168493270874,
-0.03157676011323929,
0.6648464202880859,
-0.7742398381233215,
0.06859714537858963,
-0.08676185458898544,
0.3159763813018799,
0.49466705322265625,
-0.1848926991224289,
-0.529456615447998,
0.09397143125534058,
-0.2584579288959503,
-0.4255790412425995,
0.3743273615837097,
-0.004527598153799772,
0.7110520005226135,
0.48978304862976074,
-0.29725006222724915,
0.848775327205658,
-1.0455857515335083,
0.9949063062667847,
0.12435450404882431,
-0.9273761510848999,
0.3997209966182709,
-0.14925675094127655,
0.42870229482650757,
0.6124415397644043,
0.3503968119621277,
-0.5753924250602722,
-0.9010037779808044,
-0.9488798379898071,
-0.6533818244934082,
0.34612223505973816,
0.03575998917222023,
0.3659781217575073,
-0.4789925515651703,
0.25890687108039856,
0.2988150715827942,
0.3537059426307678,
-0.6967880725860596,
-0.05134015902876854,
-0.1596136838197708,
0.13441327214241028,
-0.4286210834980011,
-0.1464940905570984,
0.36353063583374023,
-0.18015795946121216,
0.2578006386756897,
0.04933243244886398,
0.80604088306427,
-0.16046574711799622,
0.03172191604971886,
-0.31491056084632874,
-0.004784527234733105,
0.5013763308525085,
0.8869848251342773,
-0.009521341882646084,
0.13515762984752655,
-0.010679073631763458,
-0.48695608973503113,
-0.01657864637672901,
-0.23649023473262787,
0.04987861588597298,
0.12137526273727417,
0.47240445017814636,
0.45576971769332886,
0.5351901054382324,
-0.4926040470600128,
0.6347211599349976,
-0.10725590586662292,
0.21047857403755188,
-0.7241183519363403,
0.17430581152439117,
0.12234806269407272,
0.5546825528144836,
0.37338244915008545,
0.31355345249176025,
-0.15585725009441376,
-0.6437376737594604,
0.31306806206703186,
0.25148099660873413,
-0.4836771488189697,
-0.7141350507736206,
0.9063259363174438,
-0.21497540175914764,
-0.3481210470199585,
0.7409585118293762,
0.253385454416275,
-0.8161059021949768,
0.5683181881904602,
0.666671872138977,
0.955818772315979,
-0.42003166675567627,
-0.07203225046396255,
0.034747909754514694,
0.19191385805606842,
-0.139779731631279,
0.22461648285388947,
-0.05486694723367691,
-0.6761268377304077,
-0.5099623203277588,
-0.5649669766426086,
-0.2867158055305481,
-0.11090263724327087,
-0.6176949143409729,
0.2863233685493469,
-0.3943161964416504,
-0.512158989906311,
-0.06136733666062355,
-0.4169178605079651,
-0.8681054711341858,
0.5869817137718201,
0.12565231323242188,
1.1962807178497314,
-0.8266229629516602,
0.9337318539619446,
-0.1274285614490509,
-0.3678591549396515,
-0.6125887632369995,
0.43800589442253113,
-0.408696711063385,
-1.0982226133346558,
0.847525954246521,
0.32308024168014526,
-0.40001362562179565,
0.010797188617289066,
-0.3663225769996643,
-1.126999855041504,
0.864484429359436,
0.22753283381462097,
-0.4955432415008545,
-0.7911612391471863,
0.05879148095846176,
0.41767311096191406,
-0.25184711813926697,
0.13819624483585358,
0.529485821723938,
0.4530012011528015,
0.07383187115192413,
-0.6397242546081543,
-0.2287120521068573,
-0.07455074042081833,
-0.24153782427310944,
0.5049858689308167,
-0.5723113417625427,
1.4633309841156006,
-0.31146830320358276,
-0.4891164004802704,
0.03990166634321213,
0.7002090215682983,
-0.39293140172958374,
-0.08583386242389679,
0.47229015827178955,
0.6747714877128601,
0.3377533257007599,
-0.08377820253372192,
1.3734601736068726,
-0.42150580883026123,
0.03473107889294624,
1.2811808586120605,
0.09176892042160034,
1.1503621339797974,
0.5638550519943237,
-0.1518152952194214,
0.8416810035705566,
0.7021300792694092,
0.1062108725309372,
0.7714413404464722,
0.02471124194562435,
0.29609405994415283,
-0.30563342571258545,
0.17446397244930267,
-0.4453846216201782,
0.5894294381141663,
0.6014503240585327,
-0.5191195607185364,
-0.3670641779899597,
-0.02165927365422249,
0.07925377041101456,
-0.07858990877866745,
-0.23878951370716095,
0.36493557691574097,
0.18960876762866974,
-0.9494401216506958,
0.4069390296936035,
-0.0985756367444992,
0.31860247254371643,
-0.5462462306022644,
0.1947454810142517,
-0.20261158049106598,
0.34161803126335144,
0.2175411731004715,
-0.7738713622093201,
0.1994980275630951,
-0.48777255415916443,
-0.041039541363716125,
-0.25516027212142944,
0.2757343053817749,
-0.09619131684303284,
-0.4954018294811249,
0.4543079435825348,
0.5780325531959534,
-0.16168013215065002,
0.2034684419631958,
-0.7871794700622559,
-0.3007482588291168,
-0.3788263201713562,
-0.3713676631450653,
0.21659481525421143,
0.2025446593761444,
-0.18508858978748322,
0.9317905902862549,
0.5045093297958374,
0.2859136462211609,
0.47895872592926025,
0.28592437505722046,
0.9332102537155151,
-0.7594072222709656,
-1.0318782329559326,
-1.0146280527114868,
0.3883424997329712,
0.3400886356830597,
-0.288899302482605,
0.6311875581741333,
0.39660710096359253,
1.0177949666976929,
0.02378103882074356,
0.3359157145023346,
0.2645058035850525,
0.5623534321784973,
-0.908428430557251,
0.5238589644432068,
-0.32846376299858093,
-0.17983472347259521,
-0.28692173957824707,
-0.8003109693527222,
-0.15824930369853973,
0.5195103883743286,
-0.6845768690109253,
0.26876750588417053,
0.9481956362724304,
0.4874323010444641,
-0.11881095916032791,
0.2821527421474457,
-0.006679207552224398,
0.2530730366706848,
0.4225298762321472,
0.45298174023628235,
1.150471806526184,
-0.13558751344680786,
0.10959921777248383,
-0.21461538970470428,
0.3060888350009918,
-0.26456230878829956,
-0.8030652403831482,
-0.9704864025115967,
-0.8400236368179321,
0.13221244513988495,
-0.11034861207008362,
0.0918811708688736,
0.5123685598373413,
0.6543905138969421,
-0.7720790505409241,
-0.22720502316951752,
-0.30648231506347656,
-0.3342823088169098,
-0.06754384934902191,
-0.15045182406902313,
0.33183062076568604,
-0.6668908596038818,
-0.5023792386054993,
0.15400266647338867,
0.1933407038450241,
0.46276041865348816,
-0.4103650152683258,
0.3191711902618408,
-0.2704973816871643,
0.23177501559257507,
0.29693570733070374,
0.11745291948318481,
-0.7497143745422363,
-0.46859854459762573,
-0.06973600387573242,
0.034600548446178436,
0.527506947517395,
1.2614129781723022,
-1.277644157409668,
0.4837176203727722,
0.15372079610824585,
0.2839692234992981,
0.7501757144927979,
-0.08058327436447144,
0.7749167084693909,
-0.5003954768180847,
0.8900039196014404,
0.5330518484115601,
0.49588271975517273,
0.17317141592502594,
-0.045186158269643784,
0.17340140044689178,
-0.05310652032494545,
-0.3634181320667267,
-0.5845154523849487,
0.43045467138290405,
-0.32155293226242065,
-0.34581854939460754,
0.5705287456512451,
-0.1255611628293991,
-0.34433627128601074,
0.09456899762153625,
0.3753677308559418,
0.44668444991111755,
0.016876747831702232,
0.8233916163444519,
0.7449479103088379,
-0.10016826540231705,
0.10102438181638718,
-0.7618685960769653,
0.573687732219696,
0.4753149151802063,
-0.42517855763435364,
0.2180144488811493,
0.06595227867364883,
-0.12616999447345734,
0.3102901577949524,
0.7514955997467041,
-0.21509481966495514,
0.14572769403457642,
0.3903980553150177,
-0.41203033924102783,
0.2526768743991852,
-0.8024494647979736,
0.14051900804042816,
-0.22740983963012695,
0.00008688901289133355,
-0.11767161637544632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00829v1
|
Returning to the Start: Generating Narratives with Related Endpoints
| 2024-03-31T23:48:50 | 2024-03-31T23:48:50 |
Anneliese Brei, Chao Zhao, Snigdha Chaturvedi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human writers often bookend their writing with ending sentences that relate
back to the beginning sentences in order to compose a satisfying narrative that
"closes the loop." Motivated by this observation, we propose RENarGen, a
controllable story-generation paradigm that generates narratives by ensuring
the first and last sentences are related and then infilling the middle
sentences. Our contributions include an initial exploration of how various
methods of bookending from Narratology affect language modeling for stories.
Automatic and human evaluations indicate RENarGen produces better stories with
more narrative closure than current autoregressive models.
|
[
-0.3620673716068268,
-0.45318928360939026,
0.5857545137405396,
-0.12750914692878723,
-0.03904690593481064,
0.2373502105474472,
-0.3849846422672272,
-0.5241187810897827,
0.03369751200079918,
0.6841086745262146,
-0.8992251753807068,
-0.25899407267570496,
-0.3637238144874573,
0.18363887071609497,
-0.6362707614898682,
1.4040509462356567,
-0.32244569063186646,
-0.47265714406967163,
-0.33377349376678467,
-0.20995308458805084,
-0.44725751876831055,
-0.576806366443634,
-0.5843110680580139,
-0.745164155960083,
0.978818416595459,
0.6532201170921326,
0.7863535284996033,
0.9128506183624268,
0.34345030784606934,
0.22260402143001556,
0.4161668121814728,
0.01870604231953621,
-0.6853801012039185,
0.9197486639022827,
-0.1824515461921692,
-0.8083915710449219,
0.2587602734565735,
-0.0019514946034178138,
0.45630353689193726,
0.8028079867362976,
-0.27240005135536194,
0.2686868906021118,
0.003525777021422982,
1.0657488107681274,
-0.2414570301771164,
-0.4288814961910248,
0.06646551936864853,
0.03869962319731712,
-0.06155228987336159,
-0.6763461232185364,
-0.5557490587234497,
-0.7829380631446838,
0.09846346080303192,
-0.2632094919681549,
0.659851610660553,
0.2731252610683441,
1.020475149154663,
0.22236613929271698,
-0.1294037103652954,
-0.6771407127380371,
-1.1216580867767334,
0.7072477340698242,
-0.487480103969574,
0.18274959921836853,
0.09108134359121323,
0.31924018263816833,
-0.25944676995277405,
-0.8013716340065002,
-0.6558325886726379,
-0.34300854802131653,
-0.18937498331069946,
0.005663164425641298,
-0.42655280232429504,
-0.22791096568107605,
0.18773001432418823,
0.2606583535671234,
-0.7663317918777466,
-0.028661277145147324,
-0.5344611406326294,
0.08943651616573334,
0.4907457232475281,
0.39815112948417664,
0.4980764091014862,
-0.07074015587568283,
-0.5004356503486633,
-0.5045561194419861,
-0.7284532189369202,
0.3225460648536682,
0.8792586922645569,
0.20211128890514374,
0.0939059630036354,
0.5429324507713318,
-0.09512943774461746,
0.7496626377105713,
0.1491311937570572,
-0.09414514899253845,
0.0437539741396904,
-0.35853517055511475,
-0.08675294369459152,
0.50478595495224,
0.5500635504722595,
1.1019008159637451,
0.7604667544364929,
-0.296475350856781,
-0.03299959748983383,
0.03914507105946541,
0.3733544647693634,
-0.5324348211288452,
-0.10036326199769974,
0.17109650373458862,
-0.8859888315200806,
-0.6948883533477783,
-0.027666576206684113,
-0.49822360277175903,
-0.11195752769708633,
-0.37973102927207947,
0.004551307763904333,
-0.51332688331604,
-0.07438299804925919,
0.15527038276195526,
-0.3885989785194397,
0.3311331570148468,
-0.07522530108690262,
-0.865666389465332,
0.49395716190338135,
0.5345188975334167,
0.6886460185050964,
-0.16426964104175568,
-0.5710205435752869,
-0.5221532583236694,
0.37564507126808167,
-0.5399826169013977,
0.9570310711860657,
-0.3520186245441437,
-0.41960766911506653,
0.06560096889734268,
0.11172285676002502,
0.4142308831214905,
-0.3481408357620239,
0.4775286316871643,
-0.3417919874191284,
0.7731550931930542,
-0.12668734788894653,
-0.5162503123283386,
-0.35893815755844116,
0.06750436127185822,
-0.3789854943752289,
0.7188666462898254,
-0.007618957664817572,
-0.4278179705142975,
0.5589361786842346,
-0.02914682775735855,
-0.4704389274120331,
-0.48533257842063904,
-0.05144279822707176,
-0.2506694495677948,
0.2909202575683594,
-0.2754974961280823,
0.24195273220539093,
-0.5546466708183289,
0.5167572498321533,
0.30948325991630554,
-0.07782420516014099,
0.03407220542430878,
-0.2181955873966217,
0.4995347261428833,
0.2872955799102783,
-0.013187646865844727,
0.35944864153862,
-0.7845085263252258,
-0.17011111974716187,
0.20683854818344116,
-0.17109419405460358,
-0.5393657684326172,
-0.14159837365150452,
-0.059996191412210464,
0.10394808650016785,
-0.02706971950829029,
-0.6071085929870605,
0.5286564826965332,
-0.2856735587120056,
-0.09740753471851349,
0.5726568102836609,
0.4584523141384125,
0.3961973488330841,
-1.1003422737121582,
1.085342526435852,
-0.25066712498664856,
-0.1772630363702774,
-1.0239596366882324,
-0.4357166290283203,
-0.6923421621322632,
0.550051748752594,
0.16911163926124573,
0.4763404428958893,
-0.5747630000114441,
0.04182053357362747,
-0.05334555357694626,
-0.650656521320343,
-0.01452499721199274,
-0.09423916786909103,
0.7197967171669006,
0.6707004308700562,
-0.03138734772801399,
-0.26387858390808105,
-0.7311066389083862,
-0.8827863931655884,
-0.32807374000549316,
-0.39407843351364136,
0.04823938012123108,
0.04233023524284363,
0.07265446335077286,
0.20077018439769745,
1.0333929061889648,
-0.7111358642578125,
-0.14598873257637024,
-0.4194379448890686,
0.3574508726596832,
0.4076659679412842,
0.5173880457878113,
0.6459420919418335,
-0.5101523995399475,
-0.5199108719825745,
-0.05275996774435043,
-0.7074573636054993,
-0.36959466338157654,
-0.8317320942878723,
-0.15043345093727112,
0.107695572078228,
0.8908454775810242,
-0.40453222393989563,
0.48208439350128174,
0.36745738983154297,
-0.6414569020271301,
0.8082655668258667,
-0.39103835821151733,
0.29519739747047424,
-1.032240867614746,
-0.007857744581997395,
-0.27736803889274597,
-0.15608689188957214,
-0.6887202262878418,
-0.28821390867233276,
-0.5075480937957764,
-0.03313460946083069,
-0.004902310203760862,
0.5686676502227783,
-0.5037618279457092,
-0.03902127966284752,
-0.47190943360328674,
0.09535852819681168,
0.19033440947532654,
0.4790187180042267,
-0.09287324547767639,
0.5882076025009155,
0.07461408525705338,
-0.5529183149337769,
0.4999040365219116,
0.46646690368652344,
-0.0964876264333725,
0.16116899251937866,
-0.6216732263565063,
-0.1497710794210434,
-0.32692211866378784,
0.029319318011403084,
-1.2873876094818115,
-0.3323333263397217,
0.16025790572166443,
-0.8227390050888062,
0.4206516146659851,
0.12135899811983109,
-0.33908337354660034,
-0.2208324521780014,
-0.24554617702960968,
0.31079766154289246,
0.7530441284179688,
-0.38413116335868835,
0.32448601722717285,
-0.09781908988952637,
-0.7314547896385193,
-0.23930925130844116,
-0.6048914194107056,
0.36265042424201965,
-0.33412814140319824,
-0.6619442701339722,
0.28478455543518066,
0.0696801096200943,
-0.4067309498786926,
0.16440299153327942,
0.32189470529556274,
0.2510928511619568,
-0.3496365547180176,
0.3321683704853058,
0.10733021050691605,
-0.22153159976005554,
0.2852604389190674,
0.2707960307598114,
-0.3985553979873657,
-0.0956825390458107,
-0.06633662432432175,
0.64263516664505,
0.16422273218631744,
-0.19617192447185516,
0.06652287393808365,
0.693053662776947,
0.5065985918045044,
-0.16719035804271698,
0.5358906984329224,
0.3760315179824829,
-0.19036082923412323,
-0.1678646355867386,
-0.38934972882270813,
-0.1477522850036621,
-0.43882328271865845,
0.03244735300540924,
-0.17840811610221863,
-0.7435141801834106,
0.6777675747871399,
-0.1018165647983551,
0.1367211788892746,
0.30393078923225403,
0.7643709182739258,
0.07757601886987686,
0.49380171298980713,
1.1236063241958618,
0.364645779132843,
0.26612576842308044,
-0.04993071407079697,
0.47487321496009827,
-0.5955213904380798,
-0.20108650624752045,
-0.4067867398262024,
-0.3862237334251404,
-0.38770851492881775,
-0.07107184082269669,
-0.07152952253818512,
0.601335883140564,
-0.10176468640565872,
0.6039574146270752,
-0.8501348495483398,
0.6673316359519958,
0.8857589364051819,
-0.5151875615119934,
0.6637297868728638,
-0.1621348261833191,
-0.31297361850738525,
-0.11068547517061234,
-0.9009720087051392,
-0.8978596329689026,
0.9149460196495056,
0.14268477261066437,
0.7637152075767517,
0.1538853496313095,
1.0975521802902222,
0.23463931679725647,
0.43349897861480713,
-0.3078479468822479,
0.3302313983440399,
0.04449804127216339,
-0.4737212061882019,
-0.46346914768218994,
0.3014662563800812,
-1.026017189025879,
-0.15056706964969635,
0.11253126710653305,
-0.915859043598175,
0.6294875144958496,
-0.012788803316652775,
-0.7036574482917786,
0.21999011933803558,
-0.5996203422546387,
0.6062749028205872,
-0.15276828408241272,
-0.4422244727611542,
0.22429300844669342,
-0.9462608098983765,
0.49757206439971924,
0.06319944560527802,
0.046347614377737045,
-0.15739114582538605,
0.12182147055864334,
0.7099419832229614,
-0.5571319460868835,
0.8424268364906311,
0.19687043130397797,
-0.16637219488620758,
0.7053183913230896,
0.42066359519958496,
0.2715475261211395,
-0.3260120153427124,
0.24262826144695282,
-0.3621522784233093,
0.01223119255155325,
0.06204766407608986,
-0.5340411067008972,
0.6950675249099731,
-0.3365347683429718,
-0.5172334909439087,
-0.5859739780426025,
-0.47778937220573425,
0.10606071352958679,
0.2391018271446228,
0.47921425104141235,
0.5359174013137817,
-0.18786565959453583,
-0.17872461676597595,
0.22235171496868134,
-0.458130806684494,
0.8706439137458801,
0.18206928670406342,
-0.8034911155700684,
-0.24524548649787903,
0.7365608215332031,
-0.2192901372909546,
0.3420393168926239,
-0.05085265263915062,
0.1486634761095047,
-0.1323365569114685,
-0.326038122177124,
-0.3273700475692749,
0.15087562799453735,
-0.5052879452705383,
-0.36917170882225037,
-0.6306194067001343,
-0.18316641449928284,
-0.07924333959817886,
-0.9124056696891785,
-0.17116960883140564,
-0.38316696882247925,
-0.16374240815639496,
-0.34862634539604187,
0.4972887635231018,
0.6594215631484985,
-0.7699486613273621,
0.435545951128006,
-1.0455816984176636,
0.4460817873477936,
-0.05166766420006752,
0.27339404821395874,
0.3791179955005646,
-0.32845187187194824,
-0.35384124517440796,
-0.49096420407295227,
-0.2831185460090637,
-0.6001518964767456,
0.7413062453269958,
0.1182769238948822,
0.27238503098487854,
0.4594038128852844,
-0.030959151685237885,
0.4279916286468506,
-0.8756521344184875,
0.7831636667251587,
0.5993142127990723,
-0.37673220038414,
0.597198486328125,
-0.8409785032272339,
0.5447394847869873,
0.5776541233062744,
0.33492007851600647,
-1.1122125387191772,
-0.38704603910446167,
-0.6540793180465698,
-0.8502625823020935,
0.38566067814826965,
0.1801767349243164,
0.13763079047203064,
-0.3008323907852173,
0.5737453103065491,
0.6055250763893127,
0.34690868854522705,
-0.44952934980392456,
-0.2661384046077728,
0.0804670974612236,
-0.08076184242963791,
-0.18733015656471252,
-0.5099305510520935,
-0.005505337845534086,
0.10197977721691132,
0.4561961889266968,
0.17573776841163635,
0.12133100628852844,
0.4589642286300659,
0.23500294983386993,
-0.7137512564659119,
0.057527683675289154,
0.6856188178062439,
0.7861649990081787,
-0.1714237928390503,
-0.22061629593372345,
-0.5777636766433716,
-0.17123085260391235,
0.44588813185691833,
-0.1849396824836731,
-0.4863705635070801,
0.3676166236400604,
0.9840941429138184,
0.6432091593742371,
0.23377253115177155,
-0.831346869468689,
0.227403923869133,
0.02556072175502777,
-0.29902493953704834,
-0.5209457278251648,
0.2776035964488983,
-0.01465355884283781,
0.5578144192695618,
0.5822471380233765,
0.06902638077735901,
-0.07843606173992157,
-0.8521162867546082,
0.8227531313896179,
-0.2556188702583313,
-0.49899113178253174,
-0.09688641130924225,
1.0032727718353271,
-0.11562483012676239,
-0.680366039276123,
0.5628576874732971,
0.08915259689092636,
-0.4044029414653778,
0.7550588846206665,
0.5841984152793884,
1.204622745513916,
-0.23241166770458221,
0.2853415906429291,
0.5401696562767029,
0.26314428448677063,
0.06678622215986252,
0.28674909472465515,
0.07142530381679535,
-0.7696597576141357,
-0.773356556892395,
-0.7434386014938354,
-0.34582045674324036,
-0.41278785467147827,
-1.0263800621032715,
0.1472875326871872,
-0.1513006091117859,
-0.04467259719967842,
-0.192940816283226,
-0.5203302502632141,
-0.1436367779970169,
0.16670778393745422,
0.27722683548927307,
0.7575637698173523,
-0.6467368006706238,
0.4181051552295685,
0.3950944244861603,
-0.7209557294845581,
-0.2935961186885834,
0.10856405645608902,
-0.04838008061051369,
-0.39486396312713623,
0.806930422782898,
0.14258012175559998,
-0.18269895017147064,
0.13406172394752502,
-0.6666577458381653,
-0.828975260257721,
1.1271716356277466,
-0.20952941477298737,
-0.6677829027175903,
-0.44718021154403687,
-0.0745314210653305,
0.7261034250259399,
-0.7922895550727844,
-0.3771158456802368,
0.6471752524375916,
0.34509360790252686,
0.09156075865030289,
-0.6016753315925598,
0.017766475677490234,
-0.08767855167388916,
-0.09325187653303146,
0.45102041959762573,
-0.5835340023040771,
0.6872808337211609,
-0.755859911441803,
-0.1782618761062622,
0.447419136762619,
0.6508495211601257,
0.258527547121048,
0.3455543518066406,
0.18290217220783234,
0.5597705245018005,
0.3611747622489929,
0.01314448844641447,
1.4236340522766113,
-0.46434369683265686,
0.1397661417722702,
1.596362829208374,
-0.13728483021259308,
0.34637829661369324,
0.5206156373023987,
0.030194878578186035,
0.8041144013404846,
0.7280041575431824,
-0.06672658026218414,
0.7725902199745178,
0.502210795879364,
-0.13147693872451782,
-0.03509197756648064,
-0.3148435950279236,
-0.16407053172588348,
0.4094260036945343,
-0.05613839253783226,
-0.4464166462421417,
-0.6269528269767761,
0.5274795293807983,
-0.06799714267253876,
0.4340474009513855,
-0.052570536732673645,
0.634837806224823,
0.1957477629184723,
-0.8180202841758728,
0.30668485164642334,
-0.17979705333709717,
0.14134839177131653,
-0.42532819509506226,
-0.339322030544281,
-0.3030754029750824,
-0.07011719048023224,
0.023348353803157806,
-0.7422877550125122,
0.43484070897102356,
0.013510089367628098,
-0.6186381578445435,
-0.4982653260231018,
0.8392906188964844,
-0.770295262336731,
-0.36473676562309265,
0.12651197612285614,
0.6263850331306458,
0.10632607340812683,
0.3794478178024292,
-0.2340105175971985,
-0.04004387930035591,
0.19368359446525574,
-0.550835907459259,
-0.018592756241559982,
0.5557572245597839,
-0.11224336922168732,
0.726875364780426,
0.9517978429794312,
0.044245630502700806,
0.1060858741402626,
0.23296770453453064,
0.7324122190475464,
-1.066135048866272,
-0.499758780002594,
-0.8504678010940552,
0.6489428877830505,
0.14171196520328522,
-0.5793542861938477,
0.605013906955719,
0.6494463086128235,
0.7409288287162781,
-0.03576507046818733,
0.8081434965133667,
-0.1010546162724495,
0.8250795006752014,
-0.33833885192871094,
0.6086841225624084,
-0.21236634254455566,
-0.18494679033756256,
-0.1984313279390335,
-1.0596729516983032,
-0.28564125299453735,
0.26878467202186584,
-0.02749234065413475,
-0.0627354308962822,
0.8085589408874512,
0.2437818944454193,
0.2541097402572632,
-0.282504677772522,
0.5435508489608765,
0.17226268351078033,
0.18944482505321503,
0.35830026865005493,
0.8316295146942139,
-0.32605981826782227,
0.34729307889938354,
-0.20703011751174927,
-0.2939503490924835,
-0.1984330117702484,
-0.8900133967399597,
-0.7379213571548462,
-0.7835674285888672,
-0.08336440473794937,
-0.43771472573280334,
0.14736035466194153,
0.3679865002632141,
-0.023931805044412613,
-0.5759236216545105,
-0.3397892117500305,
-0.1562195122241974,
-0.12497697025537491,
0.03510309383273125,
-0.26559188961982727,
0.28919219970703125,
-0.5390191078186035,
-0.48552370071411133,
0.044005028903484344,
0.5733680725097656,
0.13741859793663025,
-0.4401856064796448,
0.057020097970962524,
-0.39558956027030945,
0.12177357077598572,
0.354900598526001,
0.5714011788368225,
-0.42733773589134216,
-0.34760451316833496,
-0.14200162887573242,
0.1631639450788498,
0.03147868067026138,
1.0926365852355957,
-1.0488673448562622,
0.41137415170669556,
0.3578031361103058,
0.3753369450569153,
0.4075106680393219,
0.3137708306312561,
1.2603838443756104,
-0.5968693494796753,
0.20435743033885956,
0.1515476107597351,
0.09374533593654633,
0.1717391014099121,
-0.39651647210121155,
0.858371376991272,
-0.05595302954316139,
-0.7422518134117126,
-0.8368422985076904,
0.276071161031723,
-0.5141357183456421,
-0.2886199355125427,
0.8743309378623962,
0.21346840262413025,
-0.4185653626918793,
0.07360587269067764,
-0.3852730393409729,
0.4911901652812958,
0.005287054926156998,
0.45518895983695984,
1.1528913974761963,
-0.6603268384933472,
-0.3614519238471985,
-0.583116352558136,
0.5886693596839905,
0.29351040720939636,
-0.4535138010978699,
0.3706294596195221,
0.5933377146720886,
-0.15776698291301727,
0.27479928731918335,
0.5536118745803833,
0.09696640074253082,
0.3157326579093933,
0.26037275791168213,
0.49565577507019043,
-0.2415301352739334,
-0.5831827521324158,
-0.05872366577386856,
0.10185223817825317,
-0.07213766127824783,
0.010661874897778034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00828v1
|
PID Control-Based Self-Healing to Improve the Robustness of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-31T23:46:51 | 2024-03-31T23:46:51 |
Zhuotong Chen, Zihu Wang, Yifan Yang, Qianxiao Li, Zheng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the effectiveness of deep neural networks in numerous natural
language processing applications, recent findings have exposed the
vulnerability of these language models when minor perturbations are introduced.
While appearing semantically indistinguishable to humans, these perturbations
can significantly reduce the performance of well-trained language models,
raising concerns about the reliability of deploying them in safe-critical
situations. In this work, we construct a computationally efficient self-healing
process to correct undesired model behavior during online inference when
perturbations are applied to input data. This is formulated as a trajectory
optimization problem in which the internal states of the neural network layers
are automatically corrected using a PID (Proportional-Integral-Derivative)
control mechanism. The P controller targets immediate state adjustments, while
the I and D controllers consider past states and future dynamical trends,
respectively. We leverage the geometrical properties of the training data to
design effective linear PID controllers. This approach reduces the
computational cost to that of using just the P controller, instead of the full
PID control. Further, we introduce an analytical method for approximating the
optimal control solutions, enhancing the real-time inference capabilities of
this controlled system. Moreover, we conduct a theoretical error analysis of
the analytic solution in a simplified setting. The proposed PID control-based
self-healing is a low cost framework that improves the robustness of
pre-trained large language models, whether standard or robustly trained,
against a wide range of perturbations. A detailed implementation can be found
in:https://github.com/zhuotongchen/PID-Control-Based-Self-Healing-to-Improve-the-Robustness-of-Large-Language-Models.
|
[
-0.20278948545455933,
-1.0160094499588013,
0.3727407157421112,
0.381169855594635,
0.11004671454429626,
0.02961963601410389,
-0.3690439760684967,
-0.15354160964488983,
0.31480398774147034,
0.4670064151287079,
-0.44417470693588257,
-0.1328342854976654,
-0.5309860110282898,
-0.09703435003757477,
-0.21717701852321625,
0.9798708558082581,
0.01643741875886917,
-0.0924074575304985,
0.20776908099651337,
0.1768832951784134,
-0.3834512531757355,
-0.5141628384590149,
-0.871716320514679,
-0.2416960746049881,
0.6148139238357544,
0.30973902344703674,
0.6293329000473022,
0.7321047782897949,
0.6799470782279968,
0.3259921967983246,
-0.05524611845612526,
-0.08311723172664642,
-0.4455704689025879,
0.34392139315605164,
-0.28037354350090027,
-0.16863250732421875,
-0.5981168150901794,
-0.15896640717983246,
0.5999326705932617,
0.74530029296875,
-0.3635779321193695,
-0.30898094177246094,
0.21000543236732483,
0.6952857375144958,
-0.6846899390220642,
-0.018638577312231064,
-0.38240185379981995,
0.2749016582965851,
-0.13253280520439148,
-0.12574553489685059,
-0.3078412413597107,
-0.22582754492759705,
-0.10189755260944366,
-0.4059944748878479,
0.020412174984812737,
-0.4230821430683136,
0.4221818745136261,
0.5635727047920227,
-0.09498173743486404,
0.04860963672399521,
-1.0500366687774658,
0.3219187557697296,
-0.8942021727561951,
0.2245330810546875,
0.47042208909988403,
0.23294265568256378,
-0.648387610912323,
-0.47272247076034546,
-0.3424822688102722,
-0.1727955937385559,
0.0816044956445694,
0.12164720892906189,
-0.055127665400505066,
0.13731230795383453,
0.19105082750320435,
0.14046701788902283,
-0.5636655688285828,
0.52480149269104,
0.0027758071664720774,
-0.3009963035583496,
0.41145679354667664,
0.1281103789806366,
0.4692509174346924,
0.04509957507252693,
-0.267349511384964,
-0.12672220170497894,
-0.8220075964927673,
0.13555201888084412,
0.34462472796440125,
0.42098039388656616,
0.09328959137201309,
0.44595015048980713,
-0.27057182788848877,
0.45289644598960876,
0.33016693592071533,
-0.25807252526283264,
-0.06162666901946068,
-0.17918084561824799,
-0.10251515358686447,
0.19314447045326233,
1.0175466537475586,
0.36807674169540405,
0.31430986523628235,
-0.2092333734035492,
-0.1254538595676422,
-0.08690372854471207,
0.381005197763443,
-0.7224196195602417,
-0.4080727994441986,
0.1961192637681961,
-0.27870678901672363,
-0.3325028121471405,
-0.14879880845546722,
-0.794309675693512,
-0.4722674489021301,
-0.1344393491744995,
0.38488346338272095,
-0.5931842923164368,
-0.53936368227005,
0.19211383163928986,
0.5257316827774048,
-0.10155139118432999,
0.3688514828681946,
-1.1201529502868652,
0.29532909393310547,
0.44495889544487,
0.9060531854629517,
-0.21423566341400146,
-0.3299233019351959,
-0.5967391133308411,
0.15314926207065582,
-0.4752829968929291,
0.6963050365447998,
-0.29602792859077454,
-0.1156592071056366,
-0.2471512407064438,
-0.10652793198823929,
-0.26471707224845886,
-0.4151051640510559,
0.3485817611217499,
-0.3466331660747528,
0.12493233382701874,
0.06784926354885101,
-0.680575430393219,
0.07499318569898605,
0.13946469128131866,
-0.4869158864021301,
0.7428125143051147,
-0.3251723051071167,
-0.8932912349700928,
-0.1223415732383728,
-0.8118132948875427,
-0.5638890266418457,
-0.17005234956741333,
0.019478697329759598,
-0.7157847881317139,
0.08815091103315353,
0.21405425667762756,
0.6297548413276672,
0.0599493645131588,
0.37018394470214844,
-0.5966339707374573,
-0.012898608110845089,
0.02792186476290226,
-0.5740795135498047,
0.6361427307128906,
0.2019900530576706,
-0.5376482605934143,
0.2644653022289276,
-0.635858952999115,
0.08142226934432983,
0.1867898553609848,
-0.18207372725009918,
-0.20485317707061768,
0.19434493780136108,
-0.13030581176280975,
0.12159084528684616,
0.004349405877292156,
-0.456844300031662,
0.5114979147911072,
-0.6722887754440308,
0.3342794179916382,
0.8418260812759399,
0.2093130499124527,
0.6348916292190552,
-0.1229948177933693,
0.6835984587669373,
-0.21152743697166443,
0.14255060255527496,
-0.25773292779922485,
-0.0921703651547432,
-0.5674241185188293,
-0.4233085811138153,
0.14743423461914062,
0.46457675099372864,
-0.6886981129646301,
0.6365876197814941,
0.0015710936859250069,
-0.5017736554145813,
-0.22195567190647125,
0.02248813956975937,
0.4477362036705017,
0.760661244392395,
0.3454235792160034,
-0.16285330057144165,
-0.09471669048070908,
-0.6808400750160217,
-0.25696882605552673,
-0.07440746575593948,
-0.001019085175357759,
-0.14370742440223694,
0.26737499237060547,
-0.13826248049736023,
0.9158210754394531,
-0.22353681921958923,
-0.4559766948223114,
-0.0012362883426249027,
0.07395064830780029,
0.15752479434013367,
0.8650641441345215,
0.5043584108352661,
-0.3084026575088501,
-0.44743868708610535,
-0.028106601908802986,
-0.553528368473053,
-0.28676244616508484,
-0.4788481295108795,
-0.2004375010728836,
0.24694742262363434,
0.5807915925979614,
-0.5114458799362183,
0.598284900188446,
0.6083124876022339,
-0.4835827946662903,
0.6187865734100342,
-0.6320018172264099,
0.0497254952788353,
-0.6234725713729858,
0.24315145611763,
-0.1026061475276947,
-0.25592857599258423,
-0.7225671410560608,
-0.1142793744802475,
0.13089336454868317,
0.044001512229442596,
-0.39516115188598633,
0.34833449125289917,
-0.3154740333557129,
0.0482059009373188,
-0.5620360970497131,
-0.13471756875514984,
-0.327942818403244,
0.5735194683074951,
0.06049714237451553,
0.5761304497718811,
0.8622587323188782,
-0.6969720125198364,
0.4107312560081482,
-0.02791511081159115,
0.0041511147283017635,
0.4245682656764984,
-0.644077718257904,
0.17617924511432648,
-0.11000802367925644,
0.21190643310546875,
-0.7109213471412659,
-0.12749822437763214,
0.7568180561065674,
-0.3108729124069214,
0.3794327974319458,
-0.34977957606315613,
-0.4683455228805542,
-0.007315132301300764,
0.03243803605437279,
0.3147372901439667,
0.0689806193113327,
-0.6240630745887756,
0.6769872903823853,
0.24898241460323334,
-0.32818347215652466,
-0.10777415335178375,
-0.42560839653015137,
0.11012975871562958,
-0.12591156363487244,
-0.49192875623703003,
0.166252002120018,
-0.39861178398132324,
-0.11148089915513992,
-0.21274499595165253,
-0.13526006042957306,
-0.07670438289642334,
0.4984486997127533,
0.2872856557369232,
0.10853978246450424,
-0.2249755710363388,
0.40362948179244995,
0.3271854519844055,
-0.4295073449611664,
0.047308437526226044,
-0.4200890362262726,
0.7780005931854248,
-0.3447662591934204,
-0.6988022923469543,
-0.8352572917938232,
0.14463378489017487,
0.7343265414237976,
-0.563321053981781,
0.7207163572311401,
0.30613479018211365,
-0.40301045775413513,
-0.027959130704402924,
-0.45405447483062744,
-0.3476564884185791,
-0.4976637363433838,
0.2509828805923462,
-0.2998097538948059,
-0.6165320873260498,
0.44822192192077637,
-0.11262423545122147,
-0.13116399943828583,
0.4999966621398926,
0.7446030378341675,
-0.42211636900901794,
0.7909860610961914,
0.36713430285453796,
-0.38019493222236633,
0.5445008873939514,
-0.27994030714035034,
0.2389824241399765,
-0.52056884765625,
-0.017189931124448776,
-0.30042898654937744,
-0.25262296199798584,
-0.4475691616535187,
-0.16178792715072632,
0.39841195940971375,
0.16844937205314636,
-0.4614185094833374,
0.09802281856536865,
-0.5405279994010925,
0.4404884874820709,
0.44314590096473694,
0.18785762786865234,
0.15515828132629395,
-0.09133018553256989,
-0.11378421634435654,
-0.07751401513814926,
-0.7666062712669373,
-0.4283658266067505,
0.6923182010650635,
0.5156223177909851,
1.0308252573013306,
0.07159124314785004,
0.6240693926811218,
0.07666525989770889,
0.12172679603099823,
-0.6131786704063416,
0.12992504239082336,
-0.030019402503967285,
-0.35073137283325195,
-0.653044581413269,
-0.5755519270896912,
-0.9039825797080994,
0.37812569737434387,
-0.3259580433368683,
-0.8157757520675659,
0.1584964245557785,
0.5473524332046509,
-0.7837960124015808,
0.6906281113624573,
-0.6695175766944885,
0.9028587937355042,
-0.8224079608917236,
-0.502225399017334,
-0.2900148630142212,
-0.5598905086517334,
0.050400108098983765,
-0.3000974953174591,
0.04959726706147194,
-0.14988626539707184,
0.24357269704341888,
0.45269104838371277,
-0.5568187236785889,
0.8837932348251343,
-0.377428263425827,
-0.23607487976551056,
-0.15267512202262878,
0.47233060002326965,
0.49174779653549194,
0.07761222124099731,
0.036769188940525055,
0.00963536836206913,
0.04854867234826088,
-0.45303699374198914,
-0.872540295124054,
0.6318894028663635,
-0.48628950119018555,
-0.4477919042110443,
-0.5811562538146973,
-0.2621375620365143,
-0.21854133903980255,
0.3762250542640686,
0.16342811286449432,
0.49266526103019714,
0.023327399045228958,
0.3357712924480438,
0.5687578320503235,
-0.3194722831249237,
0.9585962295532227,
0.6044825315475464,
-0.3385418951511383,
-0.34251511096954346,
0.7831746339797974,
0.038201190531253815,
0.3729186952114105,
0.24399489164352417,
0.32840245962142944,
-0.09353392571210861,
-0.44896170496940613,
-0.4350646734237671,
0.23743313550949097,
-0.06627890467643738,
-0.28150275349617004,
-0.3452596068382263,
-0.08846642822027206,
-0.357456237077713,
-0.017192790284752846,
-0.931511402130127,
-0.31800398230552673,
-0.40032926201820374,
-0.0355653241276741,
0.29420191049575806,
0.6805923581123352,
-0.10733848065137863,
0.5224733948707581,
-0.5512530207633972,
0.31702715158462524,
-0.09663302451372147,
0.961413562297821,
-0.04206090793013573,
-0.42282554507255554,
-0.08248298615217209,
0.2846156656742096,
-0.11105559021234512,
-0.6934734582901001,
0.6580808758735657,
0.4579828977584839,
0.4611637592315674,
0.4883772134780884,
0.19202570617198944,
0.5111599564552307,
-0.7088664770126343,
0.2759498357772827,
0.41511520743370056,
-0.7726015448570251,
0.7939456105232239,
-0.33002641797065735,
0.3472386598587036,
0.34771206974983215,
0.19039924442768097,
-0.7188599109649658,
-0.38616666197776794,
-0.4003962576389313,
-0.682410717010498,
0.6353722214698792,
0.15785843133926392,
0.018296755850315094,
0.04234100878238678,
0.6703729033470154,
-0.11871171742677689,
-0.23761288821697235,
-0.5543093681335449,
-0.2636580169200897,
-0.38815760612487793,
-0.25165367126464844,
0.07020826637744904,
-0.15762485563755035,
0.06364994496107101,
-0.13984793424606323,
0.7776854634284973,
-0.39774391055107117,
0.23802056908607483,
0.34911051392555237,
-0.09021548926830292,
-0.1564282774925232,
-0.07504717260599136,
0.5328503251075745,
0.4659070372581482,
0.05537217855453491,
0.08238480985164642,
-0.08722192794084549,
-0.28518691658973694,
0.16889813542366028,
-0.10450299084186554,
-0.08425451815128326,
-0.4912305176258087,
0.2741658091545105,
0.6175820231437683,
0.13866685330867767,
-0.6589120626449585,
0.46884897351264954,
-0.2732047140598297,
0.3110676407814026,
-0.3622478246688843,
0.13244716823101044,
-0.1298869550228119,
0.33201509714126587,
0.22025038301944733,
0.31379106640815735,
-0.10668870806694031,
-0.160537451505661,
0.2291812151670456,
0.4246161878108978,
-0.28116562962532043,
-0.33188799023628235,
0.578813910484314,
0.10268836468458176,
-0.5940747857093811,
0.6217057108879089,
0.1572524607181549,
-0.6351316571235657,
0.3871020972728729,
0.5450497269630432,
0.7990999221801758,
-0.4122611880302429,
0.2155880481004715,
0.22864213585853577,
0.2704385221004486,
-0.07325208932161331,
-0.18461914360523224,
0.19834157824516296,
-0.9442881345748901,
-0.5510331988334656,
-0.5428282618522644,
-0.13268332183361053,
-0.10004720091819763,
-0.3842213749885559,
-0.1751001477241516,
-1.086081624031067,
-0.2318757176399231,
-0.20974205434322357,
-0.20158985257148743,
-0.14769232273101807,
0.2696976363658905,
-0.08766300976276398,
0.6036391854286194,
-0.5974923372268677,
1.0704265832901,
0.27770134806632996,
-0.5017076730728149,
-0.7542439103126526,
0.15101569890975952,
-0.05052020400762558,
-0.27787622809410095,
0.48990336060523987,
-0.20012089610099792,
-0.34041261672973633,
-0.07458433508872986,
-0.40934309363365173,
-0.9888315200805664,
0.6803373694419861,
0.8370110988616943,
-0.8042412996292114,
0.18916836380958557,
-0.05554712936282158,
0.9005624651908875,
-0.02192831039428711,
0.20326592028141022,
0.41233912110328674,
0.30515599250793457,
-0.04424317181110382,
-1.16777503490448,
-0.16411779820919037,
-0.35564589500427246,
-0.13136263191699982,
0.1734272986650467,
-0.45837321877479553,
0.3903839588165283,
-0.06666570156812668,
-0.10715802013874054,
0.1175655648112297,
0.6731600761413574,
0.035217754542827606,
-0.1841108798980713,
0.6164265871047974,
0.5218440294265747,
0.8724484443664551,
-0.029049169272184372,
1.152475118637085,
-0.5696356296539307,
0.5662126541137695,
1.2059495449066162,
0.0569000206887722,
0.7162016034126282,
0.39988356828689575,
-0.06701720505952835,
0.10253792256116867,
0.46859097480773926,
0.11228130757808685,
0.41249802708625793,
0.07956806570291519,
-0.14520005881786346,
-0.271714985370636,
0.2088812291622162,
-0.2705482542514801,
0.5258924961090088,
0.0876050516963005,
-0.1570432037115097,
-0.12320000678300858,
0.2531973719596863,
0.1261185258626938,
0.2250046283006668,
-0.18661315739154816,
0.7891701459884644,
-0.31563177704811096,
-0.619152843952179,
0.5147650837898254,
0.006367603782564402,
0.52737957239151,
-0.43589064478874207,
0.017009206116199493,
-0.48142194747924805,
0.4832042455673218,
-0.1575472205877304,
-0.5413438081741333,
0.4843571186065674,
-0.18744680285453796,
-0.1557035744190216,
-0.5684508085250854,
0.6874446868896484,
-0.539889395236969,
-0.4779970645904541,
0.4689328670501709,
0.10928665846586227,
-0.13623981177806854,
-0.3646993935108185,
-0.5214570164680481,
0.13154162466526031,
-0.06514354050159454,
-0.12606275081634521,
0.334812730550766,
0.1981668472290039,
-0.019608082249760628,
1.0636330842971802,
0.5257831811904907,
0.3886062204837799,
0.2630055546760559,
-0.019888199865818024,
0.8116130232810974,
-0.3700225055217743,
-0.3794860541820526,
-0.8621047735214233,
0.3111130893230438,
0.20215077698230743,
-0.22422818839550018,
0.3445342481136322,
0.34401842951774597,
0.6691335439682007,
0.037566911429166794,
0.5192508697509766,
-0.06313027441501617,
0.7709304690361023,
-0.6118248701095581,
1.1371067762374878,
-0.3095748722553253,
0.3397589325904846,
-0.3528953194618225,
-0.6117702126502991,
-0.7249215841293335,
0.9844717979431152,
-0.29544538259506226,
-0.04157260060310364,
0.38041406869888306,
0.8779833912849426,
-0.04172294959425926,
-0.11136380583047867,
0.25196361541748047,
0.667722761631012,
0.6606467366218567,
0.18636193871498108,
0.6916420459747314,
-0.06333792954683304,
0.22062678635120392,
-0.5944709777832031,
-0.3692067861557007,
0.03447052091360092,
-0.9390250444412231,
-0.45846614241600037,
-0.4147794246673584,
-0.3477376699447632,
-0.20051243901252747,
0.24609273672103882,
1.1970356702804565,
0.6581439971923828,
-1.0571000576019287,
-0.15514937043190002,
-0.2674833834171295,
0.031114043667912483,
-0.13058732450008392,
-0.20403294265270233,
0.517717719078064,
-0.5450142621994019,
-0.5506218671798706,
0.6617776155471802,
0.4236677885055542,
-0.06101943179965019,
-0.33067694306373596,
-0.2203521728515625,
-0.23990654945373535,
-0.4635399878025055,
0.418274849653244,
0.64515620470047,
-0.7525217533111572,
-0.48072028160095215,
-0.029568390920758247,
-0.0938880667090416,
0.058258626610040665,
0.8567903637886047,
-0.627610981464386,
0.7927774786949158,
0.20076104998588562,
1.0131473541259766,
0.3760031759738922,
-0.1436203420162201,
0.879795491695404,
-0.39838922023773193,
-0.08129588514566422,
0.3072189390659332,
0.4391162395477295,
0.2989951968193054,
-0.5194724798202515,
0.33549588918685913,
0.3739217519760132,
-0.4981527030467987,
-0.45423394441604614,
0.16388054192066193,
-0.6236618757247925,
-0.25796395540237427,
0.9767234325408936,
-0.4395783245563507,
-0.0709230825304985,
0.1772259622812271,
-0.49022164940834045,
0.18724776804447174,
-0.255982369184494,
0.950965166091919,
0.3934505581855774,
-0.3770987093448639,
-0.3020581007003784,
0.004065347835421562,
0.37886282801628113,
0.4430944323539734,
-0.7798255681991577,
0.12549717724323273,
0.5277480483055115,
0.4433859884738922,
-0.031256645917892456,
0.5704436302185059,
-0.01703319326043129,
0.1410711109638214,
-0.6737000942230225,
0.25019824504852295,
0.08652877062559128,
-0.6180089116096497,
-0.6526849865913391,
0.1612483114004135,
-0.21472224593162537,
-0.05055926740169525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00826v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00826v2
|
Extracting Social Determinants of Health from Pediatric Patient Notes Using Large Language Models: Novel Corpus and Methods
| 2024-03-31T23:37:18 | 2024-04-04T04:21:34 |
Yujuan Fu, Giridhar Kaushik Ramachandran, Nicholas J Dobbins, Namu Park, Michael Leu, Abby R. Rosenberg, Kevin Lybarger, Fei Xia, Ozlem Uzuner, Meliha Yetisgen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social determinants of health (SDoH) play a critical role in shaping health
outcomes, particularly in pediatric populations where interventions can have
long-term implications. SDoH are frequently studied in the Electronic Health
Record (EHR), which provides a rich repository for diverse patient data. In
this work, we present a novel annotated corpus, the Pediatric Social History
Annotation Corpus (PedSHAC), and evaluate the automatic extraction of detailed
SDoH representations using fine-tuned and in-context learning methods with
Large Language Models (LLMs). PedSHAC comprises annotated social history
sections from 1,260 clinical notes obtained from pediatric patients within the
University of Washington (UW) hospital system. Employing an event-based
annotation scheme, PedSHAC captures ten distinct health determinants to
encompass living and economic stability, prior trauma, education access,
substance use history, and mental health with an overall annotator agreement of
81.9 F1. Our proposed fine-tuning LLM-based extractors achieve high performance
at 78.4 F1 for event arguments. In-context learning approaches with GPT-4
demonstrate promise for reliable SDoH extraction with limited annotated
examples, with extraction performance at 82.3 F1 for event triggers.
|
[
-0.03451168164610863,
-0.922027587890625,
0.785957396030426,
0.003132336540147662,
-0.2732546627521515,
0.1954968124628067,
-0.21236874163150787,
-0.5958175659179688,
0.608397364616394,
0.4518581032752991,
-0.3104790151119232,
-0.5503009557723999,
-0.7757141590118408,
0.17292717099189758,
0.007852678187191486,
1.4815025329589844,
-0.10936944931745529,
-0.1676332652568817,
-0.13448090851306915,
0.22148573398590088,
0.029082493856549263,
-0.7343531250953674,
-0.7855154871940613,
-0.08553459495306015,
0.6890891790390015,
0.46143513917922974,
0.241219162940979,
0.6639520525932312,
0.5111943483352661,
0.16298756003379822,
-0.24478788673877716,
0.09237845242023468,
-0.4485607147216797,
0.1841413378715515,
-0.2222677767276764,
0.11101649701595306,
-0.7556726336479187,
-0.24482141435146332,
0.6742300987243652,
0.9240869879722595,
0.05898650363087654,
0.3597905933856964,
0.1481492668390274,
0.6700597405433655,
-0.4668787121772766,
0.5880419015884399,
-0.3768160045146942,
0.05449770763516426,
-0.3933870494365692,
-0.19934265315532684,
-0.3291867971420288,
-0.49775877594947815,
0.3222382366657257,
-0.4670102298259735,
-0.03414174169301987,
-0.4826059937477112,
0.6186841130256653,
-0.005734297446906567,
-0.8669523596763611,
-0.23343895375728607,
-0.567765474319458,
0.7130020260810852,
-0.49113550782203674,
0.1177327036857605,
0.6344831585884094,
0.07041143625974655,
-0.19651846587657928,
-0.741627037525177,
-0.19512787461280823,
0.08363932371139526,
-0.15233641862869263,
-0.05529560521245003,
0.16632294654846191,
0.06500614434480667,
0.46608319878578186,
0.060758382081985474,
-0.09176187217235565,
-0.13103170692920685,
-0.6739594340324402,
-0.17210417985916138,
0.8819209933280945,
0.3916477560997009,
0.2686861455440521,
-0.4066790044307709,
-0.13376161456108093,
0.21554504334926605,
-0.590961754322052,
0.19281578063964844,
0.021402230486273766,
0.26928314566612244,
-0.4030839502811432,
0.486284077167511,
-0.19554783403873444,
0.00024277223565150052,
0.11481668055057526,
-0.5470383167266846,
0.4246290922164917,
-0.09517166763544083,
0.30158987641334534,
0.37870025634765625,
0.7547799944877625,
0.39568349719047546,
0.2677362859249115,
-0.0900503396987915,
-0.16522882878780365,
-0.1541394144296646,
0.07927268743515015,
-0.7818024158477783,
-0.4341449439525604,
0.032010383903980255,
-0.8944288492202759,
-0.4999968409538269,
0.09889932721853256,
-1.2577385902404785,
-0.5379756093025208,
-0.35134580731391907,
-0.12777046859264374,
-0.4014263153076172,
-0.12244393676519394,
-0.3803083896636963,
0.11434606462717056,
-0.0715147852897644,
0.23071323335170746,
-1.0937334299087524,
0.46278059482574463,
0.779144287109375,
0.7470242381095886,
-0.4109903573989868,
0.07256925851106644,
-0.5816402435302734,
0.2799835503101349,
-0.19051983952522278,
0.6579560041427612,
-0.49124813079833984,
-0.5235828757286072,
0.2253851592540741,
0.33683452010154724,
-0.19190645217895508,
-0.45149463415145874,
0.6187829971313477,
-0.15334154665470123,
-0.27621522545814514,
-0.22325681149959564,
-0.6889517903327942,
0.3616710305213928,
-0.12339043617248535,
-0.5266080498695374,
0.7133110761642456,
0.2243608832359314,
-0.7730844020843506,
0.40619659423828125,
-0.3744679391384125,
-1.0588730573654175,
0.35148218274116516,
-0.33650273084640503,
-0.6484615802764893,
0.23434238135814667,
0.3720454275608063,
0.7241300344467163,
0.043897707015275955,
0.6659145951271057,
-0.4294825792312622,
-0.167958065867424,
0.14944185316562653,
-0.39737188816070557,
0.8898395895957947,
0.02761511318385601,
-0.18748731911182404,
0.12297071516513824,
-0.8978444337844849,
-0.46848049759864807,
0.2628968060016632,
-0.4416350722312927,
-0.40574586391448975,
0.15025143325328827,
0.16171196103096008,
0.17788231372833252,
0.4313981533050537,
-0.5655201077461243,
-0.09446749091148376,
-0.047544997185468674,
0.3822908401489258,
0.6829487681388855,
0.6227907538414001,
0.15202300250530243,
-0.45067861676216125,
0.45556244254112244,
-0.2196532040834427,
0.4204697906970978,
-0.4077981412410736,
-0.5403947234153748,
0.06683747470378876,
-0.7370494604110718,
0.13853052258491516,
0.05791812017560005,
-0.45092132687568665,
0.5406941175460815,
-0.38202372193336487,
-0.24704189598560333,
-0.061862166970968246,
-0.21277040243148804,
0.28682634234428406,
0.6886658668518066,
0.3732704818248749,
-0.20579013228416443,
-0.6937076449394226,
-0.5295032858848572,
0.19246432185173035,
-0.3919532299041748,
0.1340135931968689,
0.5970699787139893,
0.5948119163513184,
-0.22201545536518097,
0.5526072382926941,
-0.39188364148139954,
-0.21250759065151215,
-0.19741973280906677,
-0.09700716286897659,
-0.05735934525728226,
0.33896690607070923,
0.3356541693210602,
-0.43844372034072876,
-0.5004804134368896,
0.12756919860839844,
-0.6394944787025452,
-0.3682289123535156,
0.044932108372449875,
0.07236654311418533,
0.06834559142589569,
0.5525859594345093,
-0.3941265344619751,
0.5640699863433838,
0.3497633635997772,
-0.3595615327358246,
0.6367449760437012,
-0.182997927069664,
-0.05286073684692383,
-0.8735566139221191,
0.192072793841362,
0.17831292748451233,
-0.10678411275148392,
-0.33873671293258667,
-0.4082326889038086,
0.3307843506336212,
-0.06537560373544693,
-0.40004220604896545,
0.5125008821487427,
-0.1950511932373047,
0.34068337082862854,
0.16372187435626984,
-0.05998014286160469,
-0.08480586111545563,
0.10854674130678177,
0.13560429215431213,
0.0336671806871891,
0.19764772057533264,
-0.26604434847831726,
0.16740216314792633,
-0.024884194135665894,
-0.021957116201519966,
0.6329021453857422,
-0.5289570689201355,
-0.07704591751098633,
-0.15513324737548828,
0.4656848609447479,
-0.6750490665435791,
-0.5162695050239563,
0.12267373502254486,
-0.3007647395133972,
0.316592276096344,
-0.2793803811073303,
-0.4806753993034363,
-0.22616934776306152,
-0.3633216917514801,
0.05218186601996422,
0.3211420774459839,
-0.37034082412719727,
0.31024566292762756,
1.2250274419784546,
-0.63885498046875,
-0.15801164507865906,
-0.038887131959199905,
-0.0871109738945961,
-0.3391231596469879,
-0.23440538346767426,
0.43827882409095764,
0.21006430685520172,
-0.30476948618888855,
-0.030552629381418228,
-0.19299004971981049,
-0.19216004014015198,
0.2264508754014969,
0.42008522152900696,
0.6453184485435486,
-0.27893346548080444,
0.2706424593925476,
0.4256451725959778,
-0.07005661725997925,
0.40924087166786194,
0.3088345527648926,
0.4040317237377167,
0.08459646999835968,
-0.008935111574828625,
-0.44835126399993896,
0.4980466663837433,
0.6884229779243469,
-0.08403972536325455,
0.669015645980835,
0.18553803861141205,
-0.803298830986023,
0.1034141331911087,
-0.4091826379299164,
-0.3002478778362274,
-0.3290155827999115,
0.3956969678401947,
-0.15985676646232605,
-0.7026183009147644,
0.6865950226783752,
-0.16721211373806,
-0.06682542711496353,
0.41918590664863586,
0.4020068645477295,
-0.1798529028892517,
0.8888434767723083,
0.20895697176456451,
-0.2141542285680771,
0.6228634715080261,
0.024942951276898384,
-0.09573616832494736,
-0.9865583777427673,
-0.32123488187789917,
-0.3898300528526306,
-0.01715248078107834,
-0.5372583270072937,
-0.07596321403980255,
0.37613192200660706,
-0.19811315834522247,
-0.34119096398353577,
-0.05817612260580063,
-0.2689409852027893,
0.21833471953868866,
-0.013048919849097729,
0.4135935306549072,
0.35259243845939636,
-0.14185993373394012,
-0.051811978220939636,
-0.24128060042858124,
-0.2073746770620346,
-0.6277368664741516,
1.346675992012024,
0.6141619682312012,
0.5392946600914001,
0.10684823989868164,
1.0219162702560425,
0.00021689290588255972,
0.628852903842926,
-0.4882102310657501,
0.42369532585144043,
-0.28869715332984924,
-0.623219907283783,
-0.3202739357948303,
-0.401772141456604,
-1.0166264772415161,
0.05332230031490326,
-0.31276315450668335,
-1.2401171922683716,
0.3434366285800934,
-0.1361933946609497,
-0.6352660059928894,
0.08748970925807953,
-0.5132799744606018,
0.8463041186332703,
-0.4040417969226837,
-0.4209205210208893,
0.08298536390066147,
-0.7958541512489319,
0.11037450283765793,
-0.3078826069831848,
0.2874393165111542,
-0.34593844413757324,
0.05002233386039734,
0.7339621782302856,
-0.410807341337204,
0.9815666079521179,
-0.02895473502576351,
-0.020898642018437386,
0.057528965175151825,
-0.19726726412773132,
0.6068667769432068,
0.3293454051017761,
0.04946340620517731,
0.2608441412448883,
0.3810204267501831,
-0.23261798918247223,
-0.21602576971054077,
0.8456991314888,
-0.576701819896698,
-0.2786064147949219,
-0.5225096344947815,
-0.23042802512645721,
-0.16964191198349,
0.1815130114555359,
-0.11385410279035568,
0.5683892965316772,
-0.2484181970357895,
0.4286060929298401,
0.41478055715560913,
-0.23887403309345245,
0.35864824056625366,
0.4199124276638031,
-0.12254709750413895,
-0.49148452281951904,
0.679404079914093,
0.23102131485939026,
-0.0445883646607399,
0.2080298662185669,
0.5414590835571289,
-0.23041480779647827,
-0.2580644190311432,
-0.3222234845161438,
0.5813820958137512,
-0.5234920978546143,
-0.039402227848768234,
-0.9103932976722717,
-0.3156324326992035,
-0.5632521510124207,
-0.2427241951227188,
-0.210657998919487,
-0.21494020521640778,
-0.49132370948791504,
-0.3388610780239105,
0.2747143805027008,
0.6292790174484253,
-0.07992502301931381,
-0.266606867313385,
-0.7621159553527832,
0.34880751371383667,
0.16266967356204987,
0.22468790411949158,
0.21603120863437653,
-0.2510804235935211,
-0.2604043185710907,
-0.3105161786079407,
-0.3393673300743103,
-1.0290387868881226,
0.4581008553504944,
0.09971235692501068,
0.5851513147354126,
0.609711766242981,
0.272623211145401,
0.7389636635780334,
-0.6578708291053772,
0.6340076923370361,
0.1460018903017044,
-0.6414228677749634,
0.7760182619094849,
-0.47018077969551086,
-0.12069828063249588,
0.621152937412262,
0.419805109500885,
-0.46520406007766724,
0.057207733392715454,
-0.745229184627533,
-1.1690775156021118,
0.6678028106689453,
-0.21627464890480042,
-0.13362225890159607,
-0.6236915588378906,
0.44429436326026917,
0.15345221757888794,
-0.17881189286708832,
-0.3170127868652344,
-0.3719961643218994,
0.008032224141061306,
-0.67690110206604,
0.006647867616266012,
-0.5444998145103455,
-0.0675501823425293,
-0.3979376554489136,
0.48625871539115906,
-0.061609234660863876,
-0.27715033292770386,
0.3229706883430481,
-0.05336825177073479,
-0.3799300193786621,
0.13216598331928253,
0.3276697099208832,
0.6073593497276306,
-0.40996110439300537,
0.34929510951042175,
0.05990445613861084,
-0.8631056547164917,
-0.13063210248947144,
0.5633051991462708,
-0.29613083600997925,
-0.13791117072105408,
0.5595998764038086,
0.49313756823539734,
0.5760097503662109,
-0.6377660036087036,
0.5963112115859985,
-0.19187666475772858,
0.19958381354808807,
-0.5513078570365906,
-0.20119649171829224,
0.019832201302051544,
0.1914619654417038,
0.32950741052627563,
-0.5791611671447754,
0.2142338752746582,
-0.5518345832824707,
0.4605277180671692,
0.16857562959194183,
-0.7027539610862732,
-0.5228132605552673,
0.6401538252830505,
0.30811432003974915,
-0.18657854199409485,
0.22116276621818542,
0.12966077029705048,
-0.156202033162117,
0.7240186929702759,
0.7012261152267456,
0.638546884059906,
-0.12430763244628906,
0.46316248178482056,
0.44205033779144287,
0.05119891092181206,
-0.015776028856635094,
0.053012024611234665,
-0.07751429080963135,
-0.29288455843925476,
-0.48387420177459717,
-0.5554970502853394,
-0.3902947008609772,
0.31470829248428345,
-0.8253231048583984,
0.19133225083351135,
-0.40835076570510864,
-0.2817199230194092,
0.18573112785816193,
0.28849276900291443,
-0.6317958235740662,
0.11635025590658188,
0.3999384343624115,
0.1891341656446457,
-0.8900308012962341,
0.9024971723556519,
0.7869764566421509,
-0.42800626158714294,
-0.641308605670929,
0.17772342264652252,
0.25291314721107483,
-0.3103034794330597,
0.6169445514678955,
0.010495283640921116,
0.29090726375579834,
-0.17490951716899872,
-0.10539447516202927,
-0.8207092881202698,
0.8368067145347595,
0.2213328629732132,
-0.6930809617042542,
0.05482923984527588,
0.15307427942752838,
0.6697640419006348,
-0.5424825549125671,
0.20123212039470673,
0.6971413493156433,
0.08219478279352188,
-0.2864667773246765,
-0.8652236461639404,
0.3069162964820862,
-0.22172464430332184,
-0.09615938365459442,
0.04327225312590599,
-0.2970117926597595,
0.6853033900260925,
-0.40643733739852905,
-0.18420635163784027,
-0.22832536697387695,
0.34644168615341187,
0.511658251285553,
0.6581472754478455,
0.19296056032180786,
0.22032339870929718,
0.9300841093063354,
0.0753067284822464,
1.1186463832855225,
-0.2754029333591461,
0.5171245336532593,
1.0975581407546997,
-0.41679811477661133,
0.6617064476013184,
0.5878723859786987,
-0.25905096530914307,
0.35179850459098816,
0.6094978451728821,
0.5512367486953735,
0.6845664978027344,
0.06655055284500122,
-0.4791658818721771,
0.1272929608821869,
-0.06251014024019241,
-0.1535923331975937,
0.1045631617307663,
0.6551680564880371,
-0.8940070867538452,
0.10985437035560608,
-0.26015862822532654,
0.40124380588531494,
-0.13324697315692902,
-0.2141115665435791,
0.9486773610115051,
0.37069007754325867,
-0.3342485725879669,
0.08861933648586273,
-0.3791995048522949,
0.2918426990509033,
-0.2811453938484192,
-0.3455881178379059,
-0.16879311203956604,
0.20310719311237335,
-0.15961481630802155,
-0.6075672507286072,
0.3244667053222656,
0.010521912015974522,
-0.14050054550170898,
0.01728501170873642,
0.877238392829895,
-0.31263765692710876,
-0.5689266324043274,
0.2788659334182739,
0.29236480593681335,
0.08148033171892166,
0.17259453237056732,
-0.4502594769001007,
0.21679061651229858,
-0.20617541670799255,
-0.316764235496521,
0.4840781092643738,
0.832804262638092,
-0.34292641282081604,
0.14741788804531097,
0.7984736561775208,
0.5844652652740479,
-0.12730778753757477,
0.22854797542095184,
0.5646687150001526,
-0.5908107757568359,
-0.267231822013855,
-0.9784768223762512,
0.5025450587272644,
-0.3527773320674896,
-0.5541775226593018,
0.5123310089111328,
0.4270341396331787,
0.4721733331680298,
0.06332218647003174,
0.7948355078697205,
0.0669344961643219,
0.778113842010498,
-0.00011131461360491812,
0.8299438953399658,
-0.23826147615909576,
0.10211466252803802,
-0.5143169164657593,
-0.46168968081474304,
-0.46302247047424316,
0.835626482963562,
-0.5175247192382812,
-0.42409464716911316,
0.683282732963562,
0.23055396974086761,
0.24616602063179016,
0.05060969665646553,
0.14732980728149414,
0.14703789353370667,
0.5754364728927612,
0.423240602016449,
0.5248823165893555,
-0.2081703543663025,
0.13165810704231262,
-0.5938364863395691,
-0.3887622654438019,
-0.4077637791633606,
-0.8520230054855347,
-0.7956610918045044,
-0.4753110110759735,
-0.6168464422225952,
-0.4039919376373291,
0.3414272665977478,
1.02742600440979,
0.39125731587409973,
-0.8488648533821106,
0.14517618715763092,
0.36256101727485657,
0.16223137080669403,
-0.1867402344942093,
-0.25586479902267456,
0.8619554042816162,
-0.10145770758390427,
-0.35866233706474304,
0.03335608169436455,
0.3777048587799072,
-0.2692207992076874,
0.06203555315732956,
0.1589152216911316,
0.046392522752285004,
-0.08778592199087143,
0.7707903385162354,
0.37140756845474243,
-0.5200360417366028,
-0.4338269531726837,
-0.3221611976623535,
-0.2772928476333618,
0.0014330068370327353,
0.5763017535209656,
-0.5054545998573303,
0.40745529532432556,
0.27808985114097595,
0.4653606116771698,
0.5396218299865723,
-0.10642323642969131,
0.09414245188236237,
-0.5565803647041321,
-0.2199549674987793,
0.3340360224246979,
0.7211759686470032,
0.30043426156044006,
-0.4503805637359619,
0.37253090739250183,
0.38546985387802124,
-0.516713559627533,
-0.7386105060577393,
-0.18973322212696075,
-0.7664950489997864,
-0.10919082164764404,
1.383294939994812,
-0.2964506149291992,
-0.4320296049118042,
-0.5414236783981323,
-0.3661779463291168,
0.46487957239151,
-0.6931289434432983,
1.093436598777771,
0.3474865257740021,
-0.2225748747587204,
-0.23912878334522247,
-0.6141906976699829,
0.39407724142074585,
-0.14973436295986176,
-0.8746942281723022,
0.15981365740299225,
0.5229141116142273,
0.30140236020088196,
-0.0820561945438385,
0.9464231729507446,
-0.8232870101928711,
0.156788170337677,
-0.21459847688674927,
-0.0007453930447809398,
0.40226057171821594,
-0.2754380404949188,
-0.20168671011924744,
0.2313973307609558,
-0.4433511793613434,
0.07059752941131592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01349v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01349v1
|
Fairness in Large Language Models: A Taxonomic Survey
| 2024-03-31T22:22:53 | 2024-03-31T22:22:53 |
Zhibo Chu, Zichong Wang, Wenbin Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable success across
various domains. However, despite their promising performance in numerous
real-world applications, most of these algorithms lack fairness considerations.
Consequently, they may lead to discriminatory outcomes against certain
communities, particularly marginalized populations, prompting extensive study
in fair LLMs. On the other hand, fairness in LLMs, in contrast to fairness in
traditional machine learning, entails exclusive backgrounds, taxonomies, and
fulfillment techniques. To this end, this survey presents a comprehensive
overview of recent advances in the existing literature concerning fair LLMs.
Specifically, a brief introduction to LLMs is provided, followed by an analysis
of factors contributing to bias in LLMs. Additionally, the concept of fairness
in LLMs is discussed categorically, summarizing metrics for evaluating bias in
LLMs and existing algorithms for promoting fairness. Furthermore, resources for
evaluating bias in LLMs, including toolkits and datasets, are summarized.
Finally, existing research challenges and open questions are discussed.
|
[
-0.1688699573278427,
-0.6246013641357422,
0.6382660865783691,
0.2835752069950104,
0.16948707401752472,
0.20101436972618103,
-0.5342613458633423,
-0.5131291747093201,
0.13772273063659668,
0.514090895652771,
-0.29919353127479553,
-0.5775495767593384,
-0.9755262732505798,
0.09488295018672943,
-0.38984790444374084,
0.7232990264892578,
0.3562427759170532,
0.59803706407547,
-0.33136215806007385,
-0.4097212255001068,
-0.37268975377082825,
-0.9745262265205383,
-0.6837137937545776,
-0.5769152641296387,
0.6394070386886597,
0.08812643587589264,
0.5697409510612488,
0.6218329071998596,
0.5857623815536499,
0.3988856077194214,
-0.576034665107727,
-0.3079334497451782,
-0.42983609437942505,
0.217960387468338,
-0.2806812822818756,
-0.7844784259796143,
-0.5754384994506836,
0.10746268928050995,
0.8946152925491333,
1.347137689590454,
-0.26116424798965454,
0.18118582665920258,
-0.032798781991004944,
0.7129049897193909,
-0.904524028301239,
0.015177950263023376,
-0.7890298366546631,
0.3573388457298279,
-0.7517783641815186,
0.03874192014336586,
-0.4416930377483368,
-0.7170165777206421,
0.04499807208776474,
-0.2933841645717621,
0.09305494278669357,
0.22071175277233124,
0.29005807638168335,
0.18290495872497559,
-0.57715904712677,
-0.49967777729034424,
-0.39684975147247314,
1.3445645570755005,
-0.8768634796142578,
0.5399929881095886,
0.21821902692317963,
0.3241238594055176,
-0.3420628607273102,
-0.6257266402244568,
-0.4640176594257355,
-0.0002370838774368167,
0.1371191293001175,
-0.21961230039596558,
-0.3172079920768738,
0.09191516786813736,
0.26482757925987244,
0.5947026610374451,
-0.38815993070602417,
0.7344315052032471,
-0.07309367507696152,
-0.29148510098457336,
0.5738559365272522,
0.24732942879199982,
0.16739466786384583,
-0.2229076772928238,
0.028583547100424767,
0.16798388957977295,
-0.8916154503822327,
0.009243723005056381,
0.6626653671264648,
0.32365643978118896,
-0.0639612004160881,
0.5717554092407227,
-0.20337262749671936,
0.6959386467933655,
-0.30474406480789185,
-0.29476723074913025,
0.5123071074485779,
0.02608133852481842,
-0.1920468807220459,
-0.05728888139128685,
0.6430022120475769,
0.40077832341194153,
0.3460544943809509,
-0.17269514501094818,
-0.47254490852355957,
0.07576049864292145,
-0.3021090030670166,
-0.5233989357948303,
0.3168937861919403,
0.06390292197465897,
-0.8725460767745972,
-0.21058596670627594,
-0.2412968873977661,
-0.8251663446426392,
-0.7463686466217041,
-0.32291924953460693,
-0.09866053611040115,
0.3038942515850067,
-0.3774591088294983,
0.15250088274478912,
0.003197580808773637,
0.2999281585216522,
0.34314993023872375,
-0.8452370166778564,
0.5121146440505981,
1.0325508117675781,
0.8193711042404175,
-0.2984392046928406,
-0.1214745044708252,
-0.5625073313713074,
-0.010295297019183636,
-0.2512247562408447,
0.616189181804657,
-0.6694518327713013,
-0.19240769743919373,
0.35383671522140503,
-0.09200049936771393,
0.2734158933162689,
-0.8570734858512878,
0.4847809970378876,
-0.6460797190666199,
0.23132188618183136,
-0.4654707610607147,
-0.5901912450790405,
-0.191336527466774,
0.23443888127803802,
-0.5730310678482056,
0.46802929043769836,
-0.02723952941596508,
-0.9301714897155762,
0.3826214075088501,
-0.4794310927391052,
-0.44102609157562256,
0.03337483108043671,
-0.4269551932811737,
-0.1790023148059845,
0.1494075506925583,
-0.24590499699115753,
0.4365639090538025,
-0.3778764009475708,
0.7393048405647278,
-0.6583357453346252,
-0.25846636295318604,
0.38539621233940125,
-0.46626412868499756,
1.0550804138183594,
0.5452460646629333,
-0.3333450257778168,
0.031000031158328056,
-0.2512829899787903,
-0.2494998276233673,
0.15596391260623932,
-0.2407950758934021,
-0.32079651951789856,
0.24471943080425262,
0.07152745127677917,
0.15116830170154572,
0.2125481367111206,
-0.5028389096260071,
0.022130487486720085,
-0.3705825209617615,
0.4621715843677521,
1.179715633392334,
-0.6176438927650452,
0.6232832074165344,
-0.3807271420955658,
0.43998533487319946,
-0.1521890014410019,
0.31683579087257385,
0.3654290735721588,
-0.532683253288269,
-0.7052470445632935,
-0.31779050827026367,
0.7087137699127197,
0.3552287817001343,
-0.4951983094215393,
0.22627535462379456,
-0.30841168761253357,
-0.09828978776931763,
-0.586324155330658,
0.056239839643239975,
0.3146722912788391,
0.07291851937770844,
-0.11632795631885529,
-0.6399127840995789,
-0.3635267913341522,
-1.1204023361206055,
-0.24024827778339386,
-0.008548435755074024,
0.07299914956092834,
0.5606737732887268,
0.2954149544239044,
-0.081657774746418,
0.832447350025177,
-0.2626236379146576,
-0.33375391364097595,
-0.12077680230140686,
-0.27376589179039,
0.15863202512264252,
0.19816696643829346,
0.7155709862709045,
-0.8192656636238098,
-0.17719867825508118,
-0.18097689747810364,
-0.6943475604057312,
-0.3009943962097168,
0.6866904497146606,
0.21494178473949432,
0.4366218149662018,
0.5089791417121887,
-0.38370612263679504,
0.08914452791213989,
0.7984339594841003,
-0.2712358832359314,
0.24039030075073242,
0.255804181098938,
0.18564869463443756,
-0.7559795379638672,
0.03955305367708206,
-0.021789025515317917,
-0.325887531042099,
-0.42364567518234253,
0.18179966509342194,
-0.3926360309123993,
0.4877896308898926,
-0.6081984043121338,
0.9969800710678101,
-0.17397302389144897,
-0.588470458984375,
-0.29066547751426697,
0.3041965961456299,
-0.636157214641571,
0.09829676151275635,
-0.09814734756946564,
0.38306325674057007,
0.6251143217086792,
-0.49020567536354065,
0.3048029839992523,
-0.0656343474984169,
-0.11895254999399185,
0.495768278837204,
-0.36867260932922363,
-0.10889070481061935,
-0.36093711853027344,
0.5164545774459839,
-0.6328712105751038,
-0.2833230793476105,
0.3722701966762543,
-0.4723283052444458,
0.15833789110183716,
-0.22121986746788025,
-0.6229849457740784,
-0.2911495268344879,
-0.3986843228340149,
0.8549380302429199,
0.7479404211044312,
-0.47849708795547485,
0.2642800807952881,
0.9069833755493164,
-0.5745583176612854,
-0.7905571460723877,
-0.7228137254714966,
0.014591697603464127,
-0.397940993309021,
-0.4093238413333893,
0.08776192367076874,
-0.13683858513832092,
-0.8873904347419739,
-0.08696190267801285,
0.05376952886581421,
-0.024384433403611183,
0.3300766050815582,
-0.04358469694852829,
-0.08502575755119324,
-0.05091371387243271,
0.1438031941652298,
-0.14645569026470184,
0.10756032168865204,
0.00871242955327034,
-0.16612006723880768,
0.6532002091407776,
-0.0984605923295021,
-0.3963051736354828,
0.049389977008104324,
0.28778237104415894,
0.29019734263420105,
-0.07693052291870117,
0.5106534361839294,
0.4008949100971222,
-0.5903890132904053,
-0.23833097517490387,
-0.7566061019897461,
0.03293773531913757,
-0.441592812538147,
0.2966213822364807,
0.032904282212257385,
-1.5477441549301147,
0.5426660180091858,
0.03494785726070404,
0.27139657735824585,
0.394694983959198,
0.9247300028800964,
0.13749828934669495,
0.8429133892059326,
0.7008181214332581,
-0.286278635263443,
0.3676687479019165,
0.2780890166759491,
0.3337218165397644,
-0.47378048300743103,
-0.32730430364608765,
-0.9772902727127075,
-0.32753801345825195,
-1.0131152868270874,
-0.4445900022983551,
0.01416332833468914,
-0.045652084052562714,
-0.2834089696407318,
-0.479533851146698,
-0.32093703746795654,
0.3661808669567108,
0.520524263381958,
-0.34941285848617554,
0.5675354599952698,
-0.07836971431970596,
0.06548818945884705,
-0.16745831072330475,
-0.7980989813804626,
-0.7570961713790894,
1.1878976821899414,
0.6500869989395142,
0.8027764558792114,
0.4556954503059387,
0.5860609412193298,
0.5075299143791199,
0.7190502882003784,
-0.7105593085289001,
0.5290729999542236,
-0.5801073312759399,
-0.6936463713645935,
-0.3408726155757904,
-0.8176741003990173,
-1.0378566980361938,
0.39924943447113037,
-0.019945766776800156,
-0.6882671117782593,
0.16621500253677368,
0.06329695880413055,
0.04806596413254738,
0.5533372163772583,
-0.41946396231651306,
0.47882822155952454,
-0.27933692932128906,
-0.13132210075855255,
-0.19153065979480743,
-0.5664801597595215,
0.7319852113723755,
-0.3880774676799774,
0.6922069787979126,
-0.5002116560935974,
-0.07973207533359528,
0.8938913345336914,
-0.15533776581287384,
0.5824236869812012,
-0.30340856313705444,
-0.4314061105251312,
-0.011448449455201626,
-0.029988113790750504,
0.05627282336354256,
-0.029532767832279205,
-0.42928358912467957,
0.5171319842338562,
-0.13149218261241913,
-0.6434113383293152,
-0.30324384570121765,
0.9295685887336731,
-0.518858790397644,
-0.5948290824890137,
-0.6513751149177551,
-0.4637954533100128,
-0.27497872710227966,
0.17819078266620636,
-0.019250482320785522,
0.07122670859098434,
-0.07234764099121094,
0.18562853336334229,
0.798416018486023,
-0.6282073259353638,
0.5857729911804199,
0.647469699382782,
-0.5961727499961853,
-0.15165747702121735,
0.9514531493186951,
0.10647376626729965,
0.2777933180332184,
0.2131696343421936,
0.0700511485338211,
-0.49398520588874817,
-0.784868061542511,
-0.06793135404586792,
0.09064523130655289,
-0.6276931166648865,
-0.27349230647087097,
-0.5609927773475647,
-0.20483818650245667,
-0.44429680705070496,
-0.02917317859828472,
-0.2532811760902405,
-0.4074760675430298,
0.025165975093841553,
0.1738155335187912,
0.13519015908241272,
1.0496796369552612,
-0.0791209414601326,
0.2000509351491928,
-0.38806721568107605,
0.22515693306922913,
0.21738646924495697,
0.6802771091461182,
0.27119046449661255,
-0.5418068170547485,
0.28136634826660156,
-0.03865564987063408,
-0.20312881469726562,
-0.2249373197555542,
0.12127901613712311,
-0.09703373163938522,
0.8453630208969116,
0.16559277474880219,
-0.08225002139806747,
0.13949604332447052,
-0.6169654726982117,
0.8185330629348755,
0.43331673741340637,
-0.8771646022796631,
0.09607291221618652,
-0.36725348234176636,
-0.10650239139795303,
0.18054448068141937,
0.360324501991272,
-0.7550584077835083,
-0.6753728985786438,
-0.27222970128059387,
-0.7530019879341125,
0.6304832100868225,
0.06997166574001312,
0.34408822655677795,
-0.03166637197136879,
0.1939341276884079,
0.26922690868377686,
0.46675536036491394,
-1.1094564199447632,
-0.505225658416748,
0.2161935716867447,
-0.3233654201030731,
-0.124155193567276,
-0.004471003543585539,
-0.04395577684044838,
-0.1301238238811493,
0.4628489017486572,
-0.0814473032951355,
0.03310589864850044,
-0.1688736528158188,
-0.21770189702510834,
0.016815874725580215,
0.6312471032142639,
0.535987377166748,
0.7405955791473389,
-0.03791482374072075,
0.17130300402641296,
0.20241454243659973,
-0.2892489731311798,
0.3064427375793457,
0.09937534481287003,
-0.2380450814962387,
-0.09510253369808197,
0.39114025235176086,
0.4322660267353058,
0.030907735228538513,
-0.8114877343177795,
0.7858086824417114,
-0.21778099238872528,
-0.35699936747550964,
0.017369337379932404,
-0.001941900816746056,
0.08399404585361481,
0.35256227850914,
0.29821282625198364,
-0.2803473174571991,
0.27535900473594666,
-0.6207700967788696,
-0.19370803236961365,
0.7089712023735046,
-0.23838359117507935,
-0.002046232344582677,
0.5532469749450684,
0.3177476227283478,
-0.2469051480293274,
0.5374574065208435,
-0.25995931029319763,
-0.42625051736831665,
0.4270080626010895,
0.2585936188697815,
0.641075611114502,
-0.1815207302570343,
-0.11598552763462067,
-0.21876326203346252,
0.2620856463909149,
-0.05919962003827095,
0.07417283207178116,
0.28567662835121155,
-0.5859161019325256,
-0.37258732318878174,
-1.0918028354644775,
-0.42667558789253235,
0.08394616842269897,
-0.3138177990913391,
0.00022115609317552298,
-0.4076625406742096,
-0.3906126320362091,
-0.047100115567445755,
0.10213173180818558,
-0.6567298769950867,
-0.024309823289513588,
0.5583277940750122,
1.0053025484085083,
-0.6797847151756287,
0.44588929414749146,
0.6914334893226624,
-0.07750958204269409,
-0.16709087789058685,
-0.18583546578884125,
0.1050511822104454,
-0.6660089492797852,
0.5355336666107178,
-0.06336092203855515,
0.03214481100440025,
-0.22277110815048218,
-0.6391953825950623,
-0.6612830758094788,
0.8186838030815125,
0.5978925824165344,
-0.8171784281730652,
0.0025443562772125006,
0.37189537286758423,
0.45258083939552307,
-0.11469504982233047,
0.19433468580245972,
0.5979467034339905,
0.4560224413871765,
-0.22349102795124054,
-1.1174113750457764,
-0.1695190817117691,
0.10600413382053375,
0.159084752202034,
0.09717843681573868,
-0.9408758878707886,
0.8883633613586426,
0.061632558703422546,
0.06440825015306473,
0.19611050188541412,
0.5250467658042908,
0.47744619846343994,
0.44155266880989075,
0.5433212518692017,
0.5338030457496643,
0.9864994287490845,
-0.2853653132915497,
0.9015952944755554,
0.1614498496055603,
0.4051137864589691,
0.9209921360015869,
-0.7099160552024841,
0.6090152859687805,
0.43774861097335815,
-0.47976821660995483,
0.10065001994371414,
0.9249595999717712,
0.13541163504123688,
0.35669127106666565,
0.9005259275436401,
-0.4036698639392853,
-0.27618786692619324,
-0.5304680466651917,
-0.49015772342681885,
0.3128472566604614,
0.2577068507671356,
-0.19776180386543274,
-0.28168171644210815,
0.07074371725320816,
0.03857859969139099,
0.27082791924476624,
-0.7803195714950562,
0.602603554725647,
0.43669411540031433,
-0.4595973789691925,
-0.033840324729681015,
0.483564168214798,
1.333177924156189,
-0.44629794359207153,
0.03758316487073898,
-0.48999515175819397,
0.03348962217569351,
-0.3326975107192993,
-1.0034104585647583,
0.07247137278318405,
0.1481798142194748,
-0.4910884499549866,
-0.14658308029174805,
0.5508370995521545,
-0.18850471079349518,
-0.3528931736946106,
0.4287818968296051,
0.6424998641014099,
0.27167704701423645,
0.2798261344432831,
-0.5127140879631042,
0.4567381739616394,
-0.2661074995994568,
-0.10516641288995743,
0.44888702034950256,
0.2935340106487274,
-0.35679730772972107,
1.0424067974090576,
0.3528211712837219,
0.1871650367975235,
0.3928694427013397,
0.44705381989479065,
0.5582383275032043,
-0.7270132899284363,
-0.1792699694633484,
-0.8399339914321899,
0.0060908314771950245,
0.1076294556260109,
-0.05250529199838638,
0.7470830082893372,
0.6555784940719604,
1.0845246315002441,
0.24320395290851593,
0.7845280766487122,
0.026226455345749855,
0.5692622065544128,
-0.5613777041435242,
0.7991694211959839,
-0.7013736367225647,
0.1823836863040924,
-0.373037725687027,
-0.9940111041069031,
-0.49985525012016296,
0.3364584147930145,
-0.2768067717552185,
0.4751623570919037,
0.2691994905471802,
0.6107218265533447,
0.052595626562833786,
0.029109302908182144,
0.2727489769458771,
0.18071642518043518,
0.2356746941804886,
0.4345744252204895,
1.2255949974060059,
-0.10582950711250305,
0.039116114377975464,
0.28449758887290955,
-0.2608347535133362,
-0.22774289548397064,
-0.9241601228713989,
-0.6825875639915466,
-0.22735626995563507,
-0.0912502259016037,
-0.14825905859470367,
0.32477450370788574,
0.9605389833450317,
0.7016921639442444,
-0.7663480043411255,
-0.4115194082260132,
0.3432650864124298,
0.6821239590644836,
0.46982526779174805,
-0.2153988778591156,
0.030029719695448875,
-0.34410756826400757,
-0.9629218578338623,
-0.13521891832351685,
0.17931492626667023,
-0.1562984585762024,
-0.26306506991386414,
-0.32486388087272644,
0.0914321094751358,
-0.014598779380321503,
0.8795182108879089,
0.1574447900056839,
-1.0393366813659668,
-0.09934482723474503,
-0.2851584851741791,
-0.2791396975517273,
-0.12276850640773773,
0.7423814535140991,
-0.5634417533874512,
0.0663682371377945,
0.2810691297054291,
0.7111313939094543,
-0.021555373445153236,
-0.47334903478622437,
0.37011054158210754,
-0.46001771092414856,
0.07852191478013992,
0.48000478744506836,
0.47725147008895874,
0.44635137915611267,
0.06008375436067581,
0.3710273504257202,
0.2473079264163971,
-0.6216961145401001,
-1.0846576690673828,
0.22254252433776855,
-0.8048257231712341,
-0.3373916745185852,
1.2376880645751953,
0.24522340297698975,
-0.08311279863119125,
-0.053624916821718216,
0.12030397355556488,
0.04059070721268654,
-0.2644045352935791,
0.5139275193214417,
0.8195177316665649,
0.131306454539299,
0.20489875972270966,
-0.6328973770141602,
0.4087986946105957,
0.452446848154068,
-0.9401042461395264,
0.04769381880760193,
0.7239398956298828,
0.45174524188041687,
-0.26168009638786316,
0.8989251255989075,
-0.4501384496688843,
0.1453118473291397,
-0.5962364077568054,
0.09653691202402115,
0.6278788447380066,
-0.11085500568151474,
-0.7627097368240356,
0.09256547689437866,
0.6413385272026062,
0.3794390559196472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00790v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00790v1
|
Rehearsal-Free Modular and Compositional Continual Learning for Language Models
| 2024-03-31T20:28:44 | 2024-03-31T20:28:44 |
Mingyang Wang, Heike Adel, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Continual learning aims at incrementally acquiring new knowledge while not
forgetting existing knowledge. To overcome catastrophic forgetting, methods are
either rehearsal-based, i.e., store data examples from previous tasks for data
replay, or isolate parameters dedicated to each task. However, rehearsal-based
methods raise privacy and memory issues, and parameter-isolation continual
learning does not consider interaction between tasks, thus hindering knowledge
transfer. In this work, we propose MoCL, a rehearsal-free Modular and
Compositional Continual Learning framework which continually adds new modules
to language models and composes them with existing modules. Experiments on
various benchmarks show that MoCL outperforms state of the art and effectively
facilitates knowledge transfer.
|
[
0.01051707286387682,
-0.4988735020160675,
0.49990639090538025,
0.3601720631122589,
-0.22625960409641266,
0.14183345437049866,
-0.2414923906326294,
-0.18378493189811707,
-0.15807712078094482,
0.5887804627418518,
-0.6718007922172546,
-0.46398788690567017,
-0.25309112668037415,
-0.4770890176296234,
-0.4605385363101959,
0.7912315726280212,
-0.16228093206882477,
-0.07870370894670486,
-0.7304539084434509,
-0.13083814084529877,
-0.594170868396759,
-0.6152817010879517,
-0.6755999326705933,
-0.4412130117416382,
0.43347030878067017,
0.6173147559165955,
0.15280422568321228,
0.6514334082603455,
0.11915525794029236,
0.17519141733646393,
0.1945466697216034,
0.098996601998806,
-0.4838234782218933,
0.44538483023643494,
-0.3880738615989685,
-0.4407808482646942,
-0.34994763135910034,
-0.04823819920420647,
0.9636305570602417,
0.6943668723106384,
-0.574396550655365,
0.07939565181732178,
-0.05248750001192093,
0.8257941007614136,
-0.7963104844093323,
0.3609239459037781,
-0.7899130582809448,
0.15940901637077332,
-0.0902988389134407,
-0.07361900806427002,
-0.6659615635871887,
-0.4596690535545349,
0.24199256300926208,
-0.5291485786437988,
-0.03137165307998657,
-0.22927655279636383,
0.23596543073654175,
-0.08576250821352005,
-0.42251044511795044,
-0.3974623382091522,
-0.6768198013305664,
0.8065361380577087,
-0.5163232684135437,
0.5187510848045349,
0.497019499540329,
0.3198259174823761,
0.024931544438004494,
-0.631483256816864,
-0.42133745551109314,
-0.3818279206752777,
0.16906480491161346,
0.17386651039123535,
0.27457094192504883,
-0.08485926687717438,
-0.07702170312404633,
0.5523810386657715,
-0.6784661412239075,
-0.2939668595790863,
-0.44205620884895325,
-0.3625657260417938,
0.43635040521621704,
0.3241795003414154,
0.3939844071865082,
0.186479851603508,
-0.6797993779182434,
0.059519778937101364,
-1.0610806941986084,
-0.002591927768662572,
0.18043866753578186,
-0.014556576497852802,
-0.23910735547542572,
0.07759875804185867,
-0.24898692965507507,
0.7352304458618164,
-0.1694881021976471,
-0.28352850675582886,
0.06916005164384842,
-0.09974461048841476,
-0.11184722930192947,
-0.09732922911643982,
0.4909067749977112,
-0.10140496492385864,
0.27103912830352783,
-0.6242932677268982,
-0.2991332411766052,
0.1629897952079773,
0.37923747301101685,
-0.2503055930137634,
-0.5784319043159485,
-0.008942642249166965,
-0.03577835485339165,
-0.28755295276641846,
0.10222448408603668,
-0.7449634671211243,
0.17012983560562134,
-0.6085647940635681,
0.7952666878700256,
-0.6255546808242798,
-0.4354056417942047,
0.06383442133665085,
0.01061568595468998,
-0.10567571222782135,
0.08596772700548172,
-1.0718201398849487,
0.6175411343574524,
0.5581305623054504,
0.8484611511230469,
-0.6534796953201294,
-0.3899141848087311,
-0.5421996116638184,
0.714292049407959,
-0.4203134775161743,
0.6144338846206665,
-0.45208829641342163,
-0.449584424495697,
0.19242632389068604,
0.16736412048339844,
-0.5004397630691528,
-0.6602993607521057,
-0.297370970249176,
-0.3932053744792938,
0.33468466997146606,
-0.013124893419444561,
-0.7639507055282593,
-0.3227829933166504,
0.19613556563854218,
-0.47506242990493774,
0.7975291013717651,
0.3131553828716278,
-0.0716116726398468,
0.0285500381141901,
-0.45749548077583313,
-0.5695692896842957,
0.00220930646173656,
0.0694538950920105,
-0.08983917534351349,
0.2677321135997772,
-0.12365495413541794,
0.3595534563064575,
-0.05558306723833084,
0.4078420102596283,
-0.16698633134365082,
-0.18979033827781677,
0.49919983744621277,
-0.2587811350822449,
0.35539302229881287,
0.2120993435382843,
-0.41603559255599976,
0.14355909824371338,
-0.8972834944725037,
0.18723131716251373,
-0.19896739721298218,
-0.5780299305915833,
-0.2145393043756485,
0.1556921899318695,
-0.322992205619812,
0.45974472165107727,
0.12302595376968384,
-0.290588915348053,
0.15111489593982697,
-0.16959472000598907,
0.5037400126457214,
0.9281541705131531,
0.219135582447052,
0.6391623020172119,
-0.9475829005241394,
0.6185276508331299,
0.28117966651916504,
0.08582719415426254,
-0.4652247726917267,
-0.11426431685686111,
-1.0256184339523315,
-0.14106351137161255,
0.12586146593093872,
0.40555986762046814,
-0.8949440121650696,
-0.040426142513751984,
-0.35612645745277405,
-0.4339863657951355,
-0.07477844506502151,
0.3392490744590759,
0.5870963931083679,
0.28661391139030457,
0.2362786829471588,
-0.5050753951072693,
-0.5832348465919495,
-0.6108651757240295,
0.12652543187141418,
-0.13319756090641022,
0.16685128211975098,
0.1084485575556755,
0.33779725432395935,
-0.05082647129893303,
0.7659562826156616,
-0.060902416706085205,
-0.10682328790426254,
-0.3116042912006378,
-0.07443393021821976,
-0.2955337464809418,
1.0531760454177856,
0.23516087234020233,
-0.4988551139831543,
-0.43569955229759216,
0.1053839698433876,
-0.7772876024246216,
0.2596012353897095,
-0.26001518964767456,
-0.2104114145040512,
0.4852871596813202,
0.3969850540161133,
-0.3812786936759949,
-0.029067473486065865,
0.8850736618041992,
0.017202574759721756,
0.6635571718215942,
-0.07326854765415192,
-0.07393757998943329,
-0.9596249461174011,
0.1087755411863327,
-0.7185640335083008,
-0.41012436151504517,
-0.5833341479301453,
0.2446458786725998,
0.2646016776561737,
-0.15564043819904327,
-0.7544252276420593,
0.7589093446731567,
-0.38007789850234985,
0.1785389631986618,
-0.21815527975559235,
0.14918677508831024,
-0.18196412920951843,
0.7089215517044067,
-0.012511183507740498,
0.810326337814331,
0.8478066921234131,
-1.12351393699646,
0.052410803735256195,
-0.1342809945344925,
-0.4540720283985138,
0.3350521922111511,
-0.26226556301116943,
0.39750418066978455,
0.30236631631851196,
-0.05149369314312935,
-0.8583184480667114,
-0.3013513386249542,
0.19423078000545502,
-0.1644790917634964,
0.4462674856185913,
-0.27231109142303467,
-0.3435409665107727,
-0.06455785781145096,
0.19050469994544983,
0.6561837792396545,
0.6934037208557129,
-0.36204013228416443,
0.4691058397293091,
0.47335320711135864,
-0.1075940951704979,
-0.12188978493213654,
-0.6842615008354187,
-0.27479425072669983,
-0.14664877951145172,
-0.546289324760437,
0.3023374378681183,
-0.3454425632953644,
-0.10898075252771378,
-0.013143206015229225,
-0.4378811717033386,
-0.4392814636230469,
0.08040240406990051,
0.38101762533187866,
0.07856449484825134,
-0.2535180449485779,
0.40917104482650757,
0.09457879513502121,
-0.25300174951553345,
-0.002673732116818428,
-0.9505019783973694,
0.7090311050415039,
-0.026418868452310562,
-0.388730525970459,
-0.5519410371780396,
0.44788095355033875,
0.8947200179100037,
-0.06360580027103424,
0.6979526877403259,
0.12160985916852951,
-0.2589244544506073,
-0.44892603158950806,
-0.8159372806549072,
-0.0038040822837501764,
-0.4689274728298187,
-0.042375192046165466,
-0.05559679865837097,
-1.1311215162277222,
0.7118715643882751,
-0.05198081210255623,
-0.12891480326652527,
0.134844109416008,
0.4905681014060974,
-0.02007354609668255,
0.5816158056259155,
0.7281084060668945,
-0.061594802886247635,
0.620875358581543,
-0.09500767290592194,
-0.2766491174697876,
-0.8061524629592896,
-0.300567626953125,
0.005432303063571453,
-0.10889144986867905,
0.03057578019797802,
-0.42890867590904236,
0.16781552135944366,
0.10784931480884552,
-0.1398978978395462,
0.448508620262146,
-0.08882281929254532,
0.4933870732784271,
0.4679221212863922,
0.15604466199874878,
0.3071904182434082,
-0.07966054975986481,
-0.4955759644508362,
0.07389618456363678,
-0.8374952673912048,
-0.1475011557340622,
1.0951957702636719,
-0.1258169710636139,
0.5313441157341003,
0.2681736946105957,
0.7301840782165527,
0.2649344801902771,
0.43652695417404175,
-0.39659833908081055,
0.6932649612426758,
0.12749116122722626,
-0.7612901926040649,
-0.08235301822423935,
-0.5878491997718811,
-0.5658318400382996,
0.21799106895923615,
0.17877724766731262,
-0.9531063437461853,
0.08526623249053955,
0.501660168170929,
0.06617876142263412,
0.44157126545906067,
-0.3927738070487976,
0.6281063556671143,
0.012277540750801563,
-0.6083300709724426,
-0.37816122174263,
-0.44171127676963806,
0.5977656841278076,
-0.10400553047657013,
0.3311517834663391,
-0.05928614363074303,
0.167398139834404,
0.6467821598052979,
-0.10766441375017166,
0.884394109249115,
-0.037990134209394455,
-0.07930941134691238,
0.5442861318588257,
0.6127126812934875,
0.6750380396842957,
0.09883520007133484,
-0.13107363879680634,
-0.17197640240192413,
0.15001347661018372,
-0.4868234395980835,
-0.5371755957603455,
0.746172308921814,
-0.2933324873447418,
-0.475036084651947,
-0.17463797330856323,
-0.8331072926521301,
-0.39975637197494507,
-0.020362844690680504,
0.07224210351705551,
0.6632336974143982,
-0.04653436690568924,
0.39469611644744873,
0.8438711166381836,
-0.007126123644411564,
0.5283034443855286,
0.6017493009567261,
-0.28390195965766907,
-0.7316923141479492,
1.228577971458435,
0.17952071130275726,
0.8429531455039978,
0.2786741852760315,
0.08640008419752121,
-0.12730905413627625,
-0.47161179780960083,
-0.17220772802829742,
0.17985545098781586,
-0.693853497505188,
0.023093216121196747,
-0.594456136226654,
-0.365550696849823,
-0.2403535395860672,
-0.29405465722084045,
-0.4174637794494629,
-0.6744024157524109,
-0.1195666640996933,
-0.1486884206533432,
-0.021632693707942963,
0.4842139482498169,
-0.32223838567733765,
0.14373576641082764,
-0.9930222630500793,
-0.09588808566331863,
0.522576630115509,
0.4006277620792389,
0.35759344696998596,
-0.4277823865413666,
-0.40654823184013367,
-0.09087904542684555,
-0.4268966019153595,
-0.6234988570213318,
0.24948962032794952,
0.2464871108531952,
0.6998380422592163,
0.30934208631515503,
0.03142533078789711,
0.7773750424385071,
-0.44803109765052795,
0.977534294128418,
0.3204182982444763,
-1.2274682521820068,
0.5957324504852295,
-0.6126875877380371,
0.5145204067230225,
0.576630175113678,
0.11577682197093964,
-0.7955015897750854,
-0.4668499529361725,
-0.6611941456794739,
-0.7664889097213745,
0.4586673676967621,
-0.05374385789036751,
0.19662539660930634,
-0.26884791254997253,
0.3906111717224121,
0.40279462933540344,
0.564111053943634,
-1.0159803628921509,
-0.004680866841226816,
0.11966203898191452,
-0.07217003405094147,
0.031215857714414597,
-0.40260252356529236,
-0.1254875659942627,
-0.3054125905036926,
0.7518525719642639,
0.022844595834612846,
0.44199270009994507,
0.018653184175491333,
-0.47922760248184204,
-0.07054245471954346,
0.30969658493995667,
0.9742933511734009,
1.0618433952331543,
0.15508078038692474,
0.22910469770431519,
0.3562224209308624,
-0.4192914366722107,
0.4545845091342926,
-0.7306268811225891,
-0.1166137307882309,
-0.16849175095558167,
0.33371129631996155,
0.5018780827522278,
0.8741115927696228,
-0.8553990125656128,
0.233897864818573,
0.4669898450374603,
-0.5029829740524292,
-0.5985324382781982,
0.575343668460846,
0.24995216727256775,
0.05026230216026306,
0.1038474515080452,
0.19396735727787018,
-0.2445359081029892,
-0.8293728828430176,
0.6932344436645508,
-0.02741190791130066,
-0.8965193629264832,
-0.5831872820854187,
0.5096755027770996,
-0.12068235129117966,
-0.22703532874584198,
0.5800508260726929,
-0.007625285070389509,
-0.40583181381225586,
0.3077971041202545,
0.9824377298355103,
0.741221010684967,
-0.4099867045879364,
0.2828695476055145,
0.27150121331214905,
0.0014691536780446768,
-0.5250686407089233,
0.3796413540840149,
-0.4681893289089203,
-0.311967134475708,
-0.3218935430049896,
-0.47869524359703064,
-0.4564800262451172,
-0.027908559888601303,
-0.9120013117790222,
-0.3339756429195404,
-0.6398826837539673,
0.3686036765575409,
-0.8200756907463074,
-0.4455420672893524,
-0.2756136953830719,
0.0041912212036550045,
-0.1921570599079132,
0.8345858454704285,
-0.5681317448616028,
1.3501006364822388,
0.39686647057533264,
-0.22695490717887878,
-0.6403477191925049,
-0.15190277993679047,
0.24634003639221191,
-0.5036987662315369,
0.4187866747379303,
0.12778809666633606,
-0.05951671674847603,
0.10843399167060852,
-0.3847210705280304,
-1.1125450134277344,
1.258528709411621,
0.5675368905067444,
-0.542647659778595,
0.12182140350341797,
-0.11674337089061737,
0.2843760550022125,
-0.4895365238189697,
-0.6360005736351013,
0.2629068195819855,
0.29730427265167236,
0.2255224585533142,
-0.6203151941299438,
-0.03636390343308449,
-0.23645538091659546,
-0.25133708119392395,
0.2222445011138916,
-0.6088505983352661,
1.113784909248352,
0.17321740090847015,
-0.4447682201862335,
0.44882917404174805,
0.45689260959625244,
0.17114509642124176,
0.3888329863548279,
0.2841227650642395,
0.6448944807052612,
0.880825936794281,
-0.13079717755317688,
0.9962051510810852,
-0.2534352242946625,
0.3151649832725525,
1.307847023010254,
-0.24057914316654205,
0.9519966244697571,
0.36690211296081543,
0.010900511406362057,
0.8235235214233398,
0.2707478106021881,
0.2581857442855835,
0.9271617531776428,
0.14534388482570648,
-0.7185043096542358,
-0.5655557513237,
0.24528811872005463,
-0.4323764741420746,
0.08364103734493256,
0.44853249192237854,
-0.14046117663383484,
-0.002288206946104765,
0.3120196759700775,
-0.04058867692947388,
0.042371392250061035,
-0.21486327052116394,
0.8934796452522278,
0.12400651723146439,
-0.9620318412780762,
0.4099537432193756,
-0.48356375098228455,
0.13669031858444214,
-0.9724313616752625,
0.20828396081924438,
-0.32240739464759827,
0.33135101199150085,
0.09862148761749268,
-0.16837193071842194,
0.5383180975914001,
-0.43326401710510254,
-0.3971782922744751,
-0.11864772439002991,
0.39923492074012756,
-0.7806352972984314,
-0.22765228152275085,
0.16567020118236542,
0.3697017431259155,
-0.05619977042078972,
0.053957127034664154,
-0.2860206067562103,
0.012212224304676056,
-0.09604492038488388,
0.1239480972290039,
0.7409254908561707,
0.3693229854106903,
0.042589083313941956,
1.0380446910858154,
0.8524469137191772,
0.003907402511686087,
0.32493123412132263,
-0.29884663224220276,
0.8719561696052551,
-0.7310845255851746,
-0.7264262437820435,
-0.7662038207054138,
0.7475182414054871,
0.19142882525920868,
-0.18150274455547333,
0.6295281052589417,
0.35206833481788635,
0.9655373692512512,
-0.3045402765274048,
0.6906236410140991,
0.1582641303539276,
0.10805772244930267,
-1.1122088432312012,
0.7604966759681702,
-0.5843963027000427,
0.2734084129333496,
-0.13589102029800415,
-0.7602439522743225,
-0.3827016055583954,
0.540172278881073,
-0.06264275312423706,
-0.17358626425266266,
1.0692347288131714,
0.6518750190734863,
-0.15670683979988098,
0.06535367667675018,
0.6413534879684448,
-0.09803668409585953,
0.29834017157554626,
0.8755331039428711,
0.9220415949821472,
-0.2613018751144409,
0.42616143822669983,
-0.2111680954694748,
0.12279433757066727,
-0.048698607832193375,
-0.7888699173927307,
-0.6998572945594788,
-0.8952072262763977,
-0.3840065896511078,
-0.03175004944205284,
0.37446048855781555,
0.7850889563560486,
1.0732940435409546,
-0.8577591180801392,
-0.4790765345096588,
-0.49939796328544617,
0.22963282465934753,
-0.6134365797042847,
-0.21419598162174225,
0.1180100068449974,
-0.7735592722892761,
-0.30642443895339966,
0.7783201336860657,
0.5425244569778442,
0.09033269435167313,
-0.3406578302383423,
-0.20355309545993805,
-0.19235260784626007,
0.1276984065771103,
0.5351261496543884,
0.4290124475955963,
-0.6393189430236816,
-0.5193970203399658,
-0.21592074632644653,
0.07695340365171432,
0.013091001659631729,
1.20615816116333,
-0.7622606158256531,
0.5864671468734741,
0.2166072577238083,
0.6184515953063965,
0.47765710949897766,
-0.3584069013595581,
0.8531032204627991,
-0.8229287266731262,
0.2785739302635193,
0.12736652791500092,
0.3063243329524994,
0.15211309492588043,
-0.061211783438920975,
0.4094601273536682,
0.5087183713912964,
-0.6177924871444702,
-0.7223520278930664,
0.40462785959243774,
-1.1332931518554688,
-0.21576786041259766,
1.0510501861572266,
-0.44420549273490906,
-0.09263681620359421,
-0.1938585788011551,
0.308820515871048,
-0.09238211065530777,
-0.06566421687602997,
0.7861060500144958,
0.7901421785354614,
0.12814170122146606,
-0.3001498878002167,
-0.7032570838928223,
0.4407253861427307,
0.26587262749671936,
-0.6646948456764221,
0.13366413116455078,
0.3872095048427582,
0.6242856383323669,
-0.050257910043001175,
0.6648510098457336,
-0.469521164894104,
0.5846867561340332,
-0.0012786495499312878,
-0.16194161772727966,
-0.2929723560810089,
-0.8310221433639526,
-0.18157586455345154,
0.5763763785362244,
-0.23711106181144714,
-0.14980533719062805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00758v1
|
From Robustness to Improved Generalization and Calibration in Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-03-31T18:08:37 | 2024-03-31T18:08:37 |
Josip Jukić, Jan Šnajder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Enhancing generalization and uncertainty quantification in pre-trained
language models (PLMs) is crucial for their effectiveness and reliability.
Building on machine learning research that established the importance of
robustness for improving generalization, we investigate the role of
representation smoothness, achieved via Jacobian and Hessian regularization, in
enhancing PLM performance. Although such regularization methods have proven
effective in computer vision, their application in natural language processing
(NLP), where PLM inputs are derived from a discrete domain, poses unique
challenges. We introduce a novel two-phase regularization approach, JacHess,
which minimizes the norms of the Jacobian and Hessian matrices within PLM
intermediate representations relative to their inputs. Our evaluation using the
GLUE benchmark demonstrates that JacHess significantly improves in-domain
generalization and calibration in PLMs, outperforming unregularized fine-tuning
and other similar regularization methods.
|
[
-0.43513673543930054,
-0.5857559442520142,
0.6049133539199829,
0.05843264237046242,
-0.3421117067337036,
0.23890802264213562,
-0.6133055090904236,
-0.053799819201231,
0.013805924914777279,
0.4472340941429138,
-0.05854948237538338,
-0.5820107460021973,
-0.9803938865661621,
-0.03944286331534386,
-0.06721389293670654,
0.7740936875343323,
-0.12901128828525543,
0.011739104054868221,
-0.253464937210083,
-0.10084705054759979,
-0.03145156428217888,
-0.38684314489364624,
-0.528643012046814,
-0.4135191738605499,
0.15659300982952118,
-0.08964425325393677,
1.2693052291870117,
0.4746513366699219,
0.3954765200614929,
0.37266257405281067,
-0.017829054966568947,
0.2628229856491089,
-0.27633270621299744,
0.5590593814849854,
-0.060930971056222916,
-0.6697851419448853,
-0.35280492901802063,
-0.07646704465150833,
0.8939729928970337,
1.178745985031128,
-0.031843189150094986,
-0.07294221967458725,
0.49488845467567444,
0.9236918091773987,
-0.8682052493095398,
0.5388019680976868,
-0.4093043804168701,
-0.1404203623533249,
-0.11313101649284363,
-0.20289750397205353,
-0.39935630559921265,
-0.4300847053527832,
0.4421597123146057,
-1.0641944408416748,
0.265749454498291,
-0.23421521484851837,
1.157036542892456,
0.4264181852340698,
-0.1640617400407791,
-0.029387079179286957,
-0.8640866875648499,
0.9594050049781799,
-0.8113822340965271,
0.4674762189388275,
0.7020618319511414,
0.28974097967147827,
-0.3620348572731018,
-0.7166909575462341,
-0.05700354278087616,
-0.06106789782643318,
-0.03386981785297394,
-0.046022187918424606,
0.06297119706869125,
0.4954870045185089,
0.37023839354515076,
0.13626188039779663,
-0.36591142416000366,
-0.2630887031555176,
0.11129660159349442,
-0.4385557770729065,
0.40735480189323425,
-0.34449002146720886,
0.007157234009355307,
0.4282158613204956,
-0.04607066139578819,
-0.42707639932632446,
-0.3928638696670532,
0.30001091957092285,
0.5001363158226013,
0.45184385776519775,
-0.11038561910390854,
0.1447630524635315,
0.0033831268083304167,
0.9804611802101135,
0.1012730523943901,
-0.40184885263442993,
0.08085209131240845,
-0.28607743978500366,
-0.15324360132217407,
-0.680504560470581,
0.4777821898460388,
0.05560128390789032,
0.5897924900054932,
-0.2388356328010559,
-0.3035014271736145,
0.04695670306682587,
0.26162901520729065,
-0.5766594409942627,
-0.3862783908843994,
-0.011739077046513557,
-0.41085782647132874,
-0.11447551101446152,
0.38635167479515076,
-0.7349847555160522,
-0.2677895426750183,
-0.6349222660064697,
0.46838244795799255,
-0.3797990381717682,
-0.2418486773967743,
0.2092800885438919,
0.13294623792171478,
0.08692395687103271,
0.42264437675476074,
-0.9375326037406921,
0.700114369392395,
0.5416234135627747,
0.5679211020469666,
0.0001643989817239344,
0.24360588192939758,
-0.4895142912864685,
0.046054430305957794,
-0.7964080572128296,
0.32035931944847107,
-0.7506545186042786,
-0.07221245765686035,
0.20862659811973572,
-0.1553354561328888,
-0.08803451806306839,
-0.5687993168830872,
0.1891259104013443,
-0.5216556787490845,
0.029551098123192787,
-0.18629631400108337,
-0.28924673795700073,
-0.3793412744998932,
0.09106656163930893,
-0.4231550693511963,
1.025294303894043,
0.30068308115005493,
-0.49672695994377136,
0.5143118500709534,
-0.1586298644542694,
-0.31901097297668457,
-0.10041473060846329,
-0.13874167203903198,
-0.7018364071846008,
0.4721836745738983,
0.3912751376628876,
0.40332916378974915,
-0.16250120103359222,
0.510993242263794,
-0.3729974329471588,
-0.5320954918861389,
0.08767680078744888,
-0.14684107899665833,
0.30109846591949463,
0.09598696231842041,
-0.21949541568756104,
0.05631764233112335,
-0.6674983501434326,
0.23716871440410614,
-0.10509718954563141,
-0.23641224205493927,
-0.5377357006072998,
0.2141910046339035,
-0.18235410749912262,
0.06828922033309937,
0.23792068660259247,
-0.12959523499011993,
-0.04637487232685089,
-0.8422122597694397,
0.014241321943700314,
0.5760442614555359,
-0.2355855256319046,
0.8458051681518555,
-0.18393349647521973,
0.5948018431663513,
0.18602721393108368,
0.06863007694482803,
-0.278989315032959,
-0.5603883862495422,
-1.1424518823623657,
-0.13153502345085144,
0.8735890984535217,
0.42259129881858826,
-0.9265862107276917,
0.5823086500167847,
-0.0771314948797226,
-0.166093111038208,
-0.45699813961982727,
0.17212769389152527,
0.32990944385528564,
0.27555418014526367,
0.37579748034477234,
-0.9030830264091492,
-0.4006405174732208,
-0.8360459208488464,
-0.38319411873817444,
0.0033226858358830214,
-0.4020310640335083,
-0.15135502815246582,
0.17779381573200226,
-0.09108024090528488,
1.0725921392440796,
-0.06709383428096771,
-0.142109215259552,
-0.010655847378075123,
0.48511072993278503,
0.09399489313364029,
0.6295245885848999,
0.6442001461982727,
-0.638407826423645,
-0.8417043685913086,
-0.15945184230804443,
-0.4425759017467499,
-0.16305522620677948,
-0.06819726526737213,
0.20366030931472778,
0.28965601325035095,
0.2394329458475113,
-0.1355026811361313,
0.6484574675559998,
0.5108647346496582,
-0.03038903698325157,
0.14204685389995575,
-0.40121525526046753,
0.11618652194738388,
-0.874853253364563,
-0.025213424116373062,
0.39023226499557495,
-0.6861227750778198,
-0.8548884987831116,
0.040217895060777664,
-0.005449358839541674,
-0.2053203284740448,
-0.06439973413944244,
-0.14276866614818573,
-0.6476399302482605,
-0.37481048703193665,
-0.24739669263362885,
0.21172583103179932,
0.12840962409973145,
0.431426465511322,
0.05751774087548256,
1.0269973278045654,
1.1610491275787354,
-0.4996686279773712,
-0.20770590007305145,
-0.1801675707101822,
-0.1007855162024498,
0.22274018824100494,
-0.7183859944343567,
0.17111527919769287,
-0.5136237144470215,
0.11736638844013214,
-0.9265152812004089,
-0.10812506079673767,
0.11790856719017029,
-0.27446234226226807,
0.9696996212005615,
-0.25362682342529297,
-0.541046679019928,
0.04060114920139313,
-0.6021433472633362,
0.22622349858283997,
0.7498036026954651,
-0.1162862628698349,
0.8218151330947876,
0.383921355009079,
-0.30091869831085205,
-0.4483000636100769,
-0.6676729917526245,
-0.11840455234050751,
0.01406943704932928,
-0.5603619813919067,
0.4253794848918915,
0.12000495940446854,
-0.15877848863601685,
-0.369401216506958,
-0.4424123764038086,
-0.3550804555416107,
0.19170911610126495,
0.15014751255512238,
0.11355142295360565,
-0.17088158428668976,
-0.14966680109500885,
0.3101072907447815,
-0.4276156425476074,
0.05757760629057884,
-0.3979005217552185,
0.463608980178833,
-0.23229816555976868,
-0.12720251083374023,
-0.6942945718765259,
0.296034038066864,
0.2644907534122467,
-0.02378479577600956,
0.7067049145698547,
0.6716820001602173,
-0.46256715059280396,
-0.2755286395549774,
-0.529866635799408,
-0.3270837366580963,
-0.5222328305244446,
0.13785021007061005,
-0.37087833881378174,
-1.064082384109497,
0.5054203271865845,
-0.3570072054862976,
-0.07071220874786377,
0.38261130452156067,
0.3587051033973694,
-0.09220711886882782,
1.2996772527694702,
1.0357630252838135,
0.007416687905788422,
0.3126232326030731,
-0.07559090852737427,
0.3614259958267212,
-0.40974950790405273,
-0.01429849211126566,
-0.6930450201034546,
-0.08889957517385483,
-0.7945877909660339,
-0.6492176055908203,
0.31132903695106506,
0.32427412271499634,
0.05434306338429451,
0.36223214864730835,
-0.35094913840293884,
0.4622299075126648,
0.5049904584884644,
-0.0231996588408947,
0.08276193588972092,
0.268344908952713,
-0.31771647930145264,
-0.5553408861160278,
-0.6603612899780273,
-0.8899806141853333,
1.028498888015747,
0.6916176676750183,
0.8874514698982239,
-0.06885875761508942,
0.6384758353233337,
-0.008943668566644192,
0.020316798239946365,
-0.4613126814365387,
0.36569657921791077,
-0.3364218473434448,
-0.11767229437828064,
-0.08358404040336609,
-0.4065914750099182,
-0.7749706506729126,
0.30229052901268005,
-0.3710455000400543,
-0.8199512362480164,
0.37322714924812317,
0.39889976382255554,
-0.46840402483940125,
0.13483744859695435,
-0.7287278771400452,
0.3978186547756195,
0.30193448066711426,
-0.42345643043518066,
-0.07133908569812775,
-1.0396993160247803,
-0.0006231543375179172,
-0.19229361414909363,
0.31742024421691895,
-0.10189367830753326,
-0.23854173719882965,
0.6129260659217834,
-0.3875589370727539,
0.8195295333862305,
-0.30330756306648254,
0.01618456467986107,
0.1818823665380478,
0.2271767556667328,
0.411139577627182,
0.2394319772720337,
-0.0162014439702034,
0.21170692145824432,
0.09006498754024506,
-0.46409228444099426,
-0.7572502493858337,
0.5139131546020508,
-0.7306711077690125,
-0.5360894203186035,
-0.45235326886177063,
-0.8090206384658813,
-0.7560901641845703,
-0.06670722365379333,
0.05214923992753029,
0.40530717372894287,
0.3161708414554596,
0.2583267390727997,
0.9267576932907104,
-0.20375077426433563,
0.42262962460517883,
0.2636926472187042,
-0.11603835970163345,
-0.24755632877349854,
0.8329076170921326,
0.1535644233226776,
0.3707108497619629,
0.2757861912250519,
-0.048814717680215836,
-0.17062103748321533,
-0.81514972448349,
-0.015509760938584805,
0.0008274867432191968,
-0.5577863454818726,
-0.2853143513202667,
-0.27045518159866333,
-0.13939988613128662,
-0.5470216870307922,
-0.22597336769104004,
-0.5172039866447449,
-0.5776275396347046,
-0.42710915207862854,
0.37304484844207764,
-0.12359881401062012,
0.7668516635894775,
-0.12622994184494019,
0.46461722254753113,
-0.5904300808906555,
0.32544228434562683,
0.3427407741546631,
0.5602084398269653,
-0.4993295669555664,
-0.5865081548690796,
-0.21816375851631165,
0.03296937048435211,
-0.208643838763237,
-0.7033156156539917,
0.3380157947540283,
0.45992791652679443,
0.47495049238204956,
0.4238928258419037,
-0.16928260028362274,
0.6897386908531189,
-0.1868489533662796,
0.7944806814193726,
0.11775504797697067,
-1.0542385578155518,
0.673533022403717,
-0.3474002778530121,
0.26938819885253906,
0.8009403944015503,
0.38200777769088745,
0.15423525869846344,
-0.6805905103683472,
-0.43962448835372925,
-0.7183039784431458,
0.5458449721336365,
0.42392662167549133,
0.09175144135951996,
0.4241558909416199,
0.5274158716201782,
0.14762558043003082,
0.23766838014125824,
-0.5961340665817261,
-0.5117617845535278,
-0.11820975691080093,
-0.31729254126548767,
0.034564703702926636,
-0.551756739616394,
-0.0005762259243056178,
-0.2762845456600189,
0.7277882099151611,
-0.28562241792678833,
0.07985126227140427,
0.022347277030348778,
-0.11476926505565643,
-0.28633999824523926,
0.23148226737976074,
0.5264248847961426,
0.7829825282096863,
-0.2500717341899872,
0.26958778500556946,
0.10934613645076752,
-0.48387008905410767,
0.07243110239505768,
0.3314329981803894,
-0.4881361722946167,
0.24280619621276855,
0.20649917423725128,
0.6422865986824036,
0.07460122555494308,
-0.22714556753635406,
0.6247860193252563,
-0.06125074625015259,
-0.2036862075328827,
0.11915886402130127,
0.0708317905664444,
-0.4060684144496918,
0.004561387002468109,
0.37022101879119873,
0.5364809036254883,
0.1174527183175087,
-0.07566694170236588,
0.22978727519512177,
0.40455135703086853,
-0.34317219257354736,
-0.4491589069366455,
0.6007586717605591,
-0.0639098659157753,
-0.06068909168243408,
0.005643787793815136,
-0.21118421852588654,
-0.42217835783958435,
0.20339232683181763,
0.5443985462188721,
0.7053775787353516,
-0.3572094142436981,
0.1372690498828888,
0.4192185401916504,
0.4621063470840454,
-0.23615121841430664,
0.2992781698703766,
-0.11935403943061829,
-0.6752861142158508,
-0.8183799982070923,
-0.6498438715934753,
-0.5635160803794861,
-0.09005728363990784,
-0.784841775894165,
0.12479106336832047,
-0.6755189299583435,
-0.5807119011878967,
-0.305132120847702,
0.001140153268352151,
-0.6055368781089783,
0.24381692707538605,
0.17587147653102875,
0.5084415674209595,
-0.8397318720817566,
0.94319087266922,
0.6392755508422852,
-0.1250782161951065,
-0.7197871804237366,
0.12215105444192886,
-0.2296091765165329,
-0.40764397382736206,
0.20939901471138,
0.13551080226898193,
-0.12463891506195068,
-0.16920651495456696,
-0.6064223051071167,
-1.099888801574707,
0.672306478023529,
0.8609390258789062,
-0.774978518486023,
0.21669229865074158,
0.3704836964607239,
0.5345790386199951,
-0.16201531887054443,
0.004932531155645847,
0.7793523073196411,
0.5306432247161865,
-0.2537153363227844,
-0.8766478300094604,
-0.1524471640586853,
-0.05490218475461006,
0.7010766267776489,
0.2779809534549713,
-0.0387522429227829,
0.4931848347187042,
0.05798507481813431,
-0.31380051374435425,
0.10369977355003357,
0.8066412210464478,
0.21136035025119781,
-0.0075946650467813015,
0.6578053832054138,
0.5512228012084961,
0.5288193225860596,
-0.6448882818222046,
0.8878178000450134,
-0.4142766296863556,
0.4813055992126465,
0.9045190215110779,
-0.048362188041210175,
0.37153366208076477,
0.6573648452758789,
-0.4041900336742401,
0.6192358732223511,
0.41364580392837524,
0.2928825914859772,
0.6172125935554504,
0.28830960392951965,
-0.26974403858184814,
-0.3923529386520386,
-0.09428705275058746,
-0.2588278651237488,
0.11378036439418793,
0.4787043631076813,
-0.2399289608001709,
-0.2958447337150574,
0.012659379281103611,
-0.020812438800930977,
0.5983775854110718,
-0.15143251419067383,
0.5470645427703857,
0.11264900118112564,
-0.5103247761726379,
0.49864062666893005,
0.14285212755203247,
0.8109796643257141,
-0.877149224281311,
-0.06872303038835526,
0.16324765980243683,
-0.05182350426912308,
-0.0456211194396019,
-0.43209341168403625,
0.45624062418937683,
-0.3309820294380188,
0.04721413925290108,
-0.4359147548675537,
1.125200867652893,
-0.622920036315918,
-0.3471037447452545,
0.2091285139322281,
0.3733918070793152,
-0.038770243525505066,
-0.016503263264894485,
-0.6622892618179321,
0.28625452518463135,
-0.23892128467559814,
-0.4026338458061218,
0.3774273693561554,
0.10701514035463333,
0.16898135840892792,
0.4915240406990051,
0.4772842526435852,
0.13255520164966583,
0.03448769822716713,
0.33385875821113586,
0.8964320421218872,
-0.16738146543502808,
-0.25776535272598267,
-0.5399202108383179,
0.5983328223228455,
0.013132228516042233,
-0.20918940007686615,
0.6473830342292786,
0.3344748318195343,
0.6729487180709839,
-0.10252463817596436,
0.5435241460800171,
0.1733962446451187,
0.46853843331336975,
-0.46814489364624023,
0.5738587379455566,
-0.24424061179161072,
0.14409980177879333,
-0.29256951808929443,
-1.0362001657485962,
-0.9180540442466736,
1.0641294717788696,
-0.2185051441192627,
0.3094993829727173,
0.5631329417228699,
0.90665602684021,
0.029530616477131844,
-0.266789048910141,
0.5534511208534241,
-0.00029276913846842945,
0.09773465245962143,
0.2849167585372925,
0.41208434104919434,
-0.7099536061286926,
0.14639541506767273,
-0.5713940858840942,
-0.2704713046550751,
0.2971498668193817,
-0.8555338978767395,
-0.9830162525177002,
-0.7080642580986023,
-0.5818884968757629,
-0.24632064998149872,
0.224113330245018,
0.7631674408912659,
1.1269701719284058,
-1.1590245962142944,
-0.10420466214418411,
-0.24668113887310028,
-0.16109740734100342,
-0.1061292365193367,
-0.19778382778167725,
0.17204733192920685,
-0.9634315371513367,
-0.7645093202590942,
0.5299143195152283,
0.5502985715866089,
0.2651405334472656,
-0.3503287434577942,
-0.05561848729848862,
0.0526939295232296,
0.1126411110162735,
0.5558692216873169,
-0.016022365540266037,
-0.7500354647636414,
-0.31442564725875854,
-0.2693985104560852,
0.016436340287327766,
0.16454997658729553,
0.7815340161323547,
-0.8664062023162842,
0.8283925652503967,
0.41205501556396484,
0.7081770896911621,
0.5970428586006165,
0.061747848987579346,
0.8852577805519104,
-1.083709478378296,
0.535782516002655,
0.4122929573059082,
0.39744487404823303,
0.5746548771858215,
0.06239151582121849,
0.5723255276679993,
0.09209894388914108,
-0.5455779433250427,
-0.4626242518424988,
0.2435842603445053,
-1.0649877786636353,
-0.013360768556594849,
0.8930366635322571,
-0.4657959043979645,
-0.06275589019060135,
-0.48543405532836914,
0.03729521110653877,
0.29496437311172485,
-0.4379344880580902,
0.5541465282440186,
0.6514777541160583,
0.2300700545310974,
-0.10972414165735245,
-0.5687574148178101,
0.7133846282958984,
0.6919867396354675,
-0.6731324195861816,
-0.31151217222213745,
0.286489874124527,
0.19487744569778442,
0.2535800337791443,
0.4061512053012848,
-0.14186573028564453,
0.08684269338846207,
-0.2564038038253784,
-0.15525203943252563,
0.16413314640522003,
-0.46656912565231323,
-0.5057883858680725,
0.3680252134799957,
0.32582932710647583,
-0.03733259066939354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00752v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00752v1
|
On the True Distribution Approximation of Minimum Bayes-Risk Decoding
| 2024-03-31T17:47:22 | 2024-03-31T17:47:22 |
Atsumoto Ohashi, Ukyo Honda, Tetsuro Morimura, Yuu Jinnai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Minimum Bayes-risk (MBR) decoding has recently gained renewed attention in
text generation. MBR decoding considers texts sampled from a model as
pseudo-references and selects the text with the highest similarity to the
others. Therefore, sampling is one of the key elements of MBR decoding, and
previous studies reported that the performance varies by sampling methods. From
a theoretical standpoint, this performance variation is likely tied to how
closely the samples approximate the true distribution of references. However,
this approximation has not been the subject of in-depth study. In this study,
we propose using anomaly detection to measure the degree of approximation. We
first closely examine the performance variation and then show that previous
hypotheses about samples do not correlate well with the variation, but our
introduced anomaly scores do. The results are the first to empirically support
the link between the performance and the core assumption of MBR decoding.
|
[
-0.27522072196006775,
-0.5566465258598328,
0.6563023924827576,
-0.05265797674655914,
-0.3208894729614258,
-0.18689030408859253,
0.40841856598854065,
-0.4339804947376251,
-0.0845797136425972,
0.369463175535202,
-0.717967689037323,
-0.4897328019142151,
-0.4636685252189636,
0.21287702023983002,
-0.16933323442935944,
0.7975713610649109,
0.35782355070114136,
-0.3393242359161377,
0.11004455387592316,
0.1968231052160263,
0.0022163274697959423,
-0.4933485686779022,
-0.19987711310386658,
0.09890434890985489,
0.18743470311164856,
0.09225370734930038,
0.5677675008773804,
0.828765869140625,
0.7411119937896729,
0.19174952805042267,
-0.28102463483810425,
0.12460533529520035,
-0.36676424741744995,
-0.3557239770889282,
-0.15463368594646454,
-0.8683619499206543,
-0.18529900908470154,
-0.22212031483650208,
1.0808755159378052,
0.5654487013816833,
-0.13983310759067535,
0.08375240862369537,
0.08363926410675049,
0.8860794305801392,
-0.9827851057052612,
-0.22206944227218628,
-0.47909384965896606,
0.0047370861284434795,
-0.28414928913116455,
-0.42223334312438965,
-0.6964636445045471,
-0.557226836681366,
-0.0707949846982956,
-0.2566204071044922,
1.0152597427368164,
0.06498995423316956,
0.7504096627235413,
0.043713729828596115,
-0.4113888442516327,
-0.12426348030567169,
-0.8604695796966553,
0.7388811707496643,
-0.5811386704444885,
0.08419416099786758,
0.3246740996837616,
0.4747028350830078,
-0.6206048130989075,
-0.21372781693935394,
-0.6834781169891357,
0.043747980147600174,
0.09494490921497345,
0.036308106034994125,
-0.6110942363739014,
0.012349825352430344,
0.22529654204845428,
0.43592360615730286,
-0.31370899081230164,
-0.07358373701572418,
-0.4137625992298126,
-0.1825711727142334,
0.6191602349281311,
0.46556922793388367,
-0.01703590713441372,
-0.3526870310306549,
-0.35910215973854065,
-0.5160357356071472,
-0.5172240734100342,
0.482894629240036,
0.7150787115097046,
-0.00521891238167882,
-0.3831353783607483,
0.48538440465927124,
-0.04166298732161522,
0.564931333065033,
0.052012648433446884,
-0.16972269117832184,
0.43040895462036133,
-0.3157854378223419,
-0.30495360493659973,
0.006497064605355263,
0.9115157723426819,
0.4296737313270569,
-0.09338398277759552,
0.017762884497642517,
-0.16121788322925568,
-0.1269984096288681,
0.36105361580848694,
-0.5918936729431152,
-0.64913010597229,
-0.17448507249355316,
-0.7611690759658813,
-0.3971433639526367,
0.3647013306617737,
-0.9721131920814514,
-0.21921281516551971,
0.310796320438385,
0.4438275098800659,
-0.5799528360366821,
-0.3200788199901581,
0.04411620646715164,
-0.590227484703064,
0.1383463740348816,
-0.20423538982868195,
-0.49716445803642273,
0.49252966046333313,
0.3511227071285248,
0.7699370980262756,
-0.18015137314796448,
-0.08186236768960953,
-0.39029914140701294,
0.05864591896533966,
-0.5769291520118713,
1.05508553981781,
-0.34226974844932556,
-0.7732977867126465,
-0.2226148098707199,
-0.021033650264143944,
-0.06213196739554405,
-0.6446114778518677,
0.7801907062530518,
-0.3699084520339966,
-0.4874380826950073,
-0.41335323452949524,
-0.5293983221054077,
-0.00021285083494149148,
-0.1388772428035736,
-0.8372750282287598,
0.9211337566375732,
0.31848761439323425,
-1.1362686157226562,
0.5562619566917419,
-0.5777021646499634,
-0.2590101957321167,
-0.22049649059772491,
0.017095670104026794,
-0.5605610609054565,
0.6908182501792908,
0.27342212200164795,
0.2913740873336792,
0.052077438682317734,
-0.34241077303886414,
-0.3707645833492279,
-0.7174679040908813,
0.6160488724708557,
-0.8553159832954407,
0.4968787431716919,
0.13210901618003845,
-0.19390849769115448,
-0.7538744807243347,
-0.7384245991706848,
0.10654730349779129,
0.07777625322341919,
-0.3430503010749817,
-0.5420156121253967,
0.1873009353876114,
-0.024897459894418716,
-0.24404923617839813,
-0.15392149984836578,
-0.49619773030281067,
0.08928413689136505,
-0.7124652862548828,
-0.10370104759931564,
0.5590519905090332,
0.5138803720474243,
0.3696218729019165,
-0.6394967436790466,
0.3920135796070099,
0.4681761562824249,
-0.04198342561721802,
-0.2502043843269348,
-0.5536647439002991,
-0.20111218094825745,
-0.6369659900665283,
0.3880997896194458,
0.50054532289505,
-0.5497286915779114,
0.7754231691360474,
-0.6443115472793579,
-0.6306331753730774,
-0.7074632048606873,
-0.11988361924886703,
0.5890877842903137,
0.247557133436203,
0.2799532115459442,
-0.11081749945878983,
-0.18658356368541718,
-1.0907888412475586,
-0.6564995646476746,
-0.23135246336460114,
-0.07334700971841812,
-0.06768824905157089,
0.2567673623561859,
-0.27606201171875,
1.3508756160736084,
-0.6811367273330688,
-0.08376163989305496,
-0.27567780017852783,
0.4025857746601105,
0.6323331594467163,
0.5885046720504761,
0.8296725749969482,
-0.6550893783569336,
-0.34154361486434937,
-0.2782781720161438,
-0.334423691034317,
-0.03131065145134926,
0.012949714437127113,
-0.21225783228874207,
0.25159698724746704,
-0.1242825835943222,
-0.15433593094348907,
0.7290439605712891,
0.5940351486206055,
-0.06039535999298096,
0.46315810084342957,
-0.44835707545280457,
0.24326753616333008,
-0.9693275690078735,
0.05317903682589531,
0.19495372474193573,
-0.09541229903697968,
-0.7404381632804871,
0.05299375206232071,
0.31479740142822266,
0.41257765889167786,
-0.03319384157657623,
0.06029076501727104,
-0.5208836197853088,
0.2395177036523819,
-0.4694679379463196,
-0.2822205424308777,
-0.05749787390232086,
-0.01721123978495598,
0.06673657149076462,
0.8454290628433228,
0.3601762354373932,
-0.8548451066017151,
-0.25464314222335815,
-0.014104141853749752,
-0.6420019865036011,
0.523547887802124,
-0.2906894087791443,
0.05426425114274025,
-0.5377848744392395,
0.06908789277076721,
-1.210159420967102,
-0.08771643042564392,
0.2396635115146637,
-0.5171135067939758,
0.4365401566028595,
-0.49322938919067383,
-0.2937989830970764,
-0.43194296956062317,
-0.4971393048763275,
0.3502853512763977,
0.8528905510902405,
-0.5695641040802002,
0.3099014163017273,
0.29899099469184875,
0.13264593482017517,
-0.858440101146698,
-0.9815689325332642,
-0.3117370009422302,
0.09623008221387863,
-0.309729665517807,
0.06744427233934402,
-0.29534071683883667,
0.026978157460689545,
0.055158015340566635,
-0.39946332573890686,
-0.3496556282043457,
-0.10292775183916092,
0.23527245223522186,
0.011225380003452301,
-0.39985138177871704,
-0.4348889887332916,
0.7195786833763123,
-0.04300476983189583,
0.33946165442466736,
0.04295777529478073,
0.03269198536872864,
0.2310066670179367,
-0.47175508737564087,
-0.4289141595363617,
0.2812071740627289,
0.12842373549938202,
0.4557539224624634,
0.7015726566314697,
0.27432873845100403,
-0.26551511883735657,
-0.07764124125242233,
-0.6918743848800659,
0.08405450731515884,
-0.5203008651733398,
0.06752803176641464,
-1.003828763961792,
-0.30706891417503357,
0.5201148986816406,
0.08563901484012604,
-0.16675271093845367,
0.513623833656311,
0.17005716264247894,
-0.4459584057331085,
0.8842347264289856,
0.7064185738563538,
-0.18686336278915405,
0.007204318884760141,
-0.2884514033794403,
0.4508957862854004,
-0.7365493178367615,
-0.17779183387756348,
-0.5508501529693604,
-0.2882315218448639,
-0.7440228462219238,
-0.41777193546295166,
0.4998324513435364,
0.2402336448431015,
0.42746102809906006,
0.033651839941740036,
-0.2669179439544678,
0.6288745403289795,
0.6900140643119812,
0.418270081281662,
0.1455639898777008,
0.4051164388656616,
-0.2629428505897522,
-0.34676533937454224,
-0.8344932794570923,
-0.3779863715171814,
0.9600998163223267,
0.05459148436784744,
0.7011528611183167,
0.31757208704948425,
0.8774918913841248,
0.4828614890575409,
0.370686411857605,
-0.34942761063575745,
0.11213933676481247,
0.07544750720262527,
-0.6895304918289185,
-0.04838547110557556,
-0.9226102828979492,
-1.019334316253662,
0.3029291033744812,
-0.2890024781227112,
-0.7746790051460266,
0.5659684538841248,
0.5089787244796753,
-0.2596663534641266,
0.3405754268169403,
-0.5511717200279236,
0.7848419547080994,
0.38984519243240356,
0.20340496301651,
0.1583784520626068,
-0.6840837001800537,
0.5506312251091003,
-0.0250991340726614,
0.6073126196861267,
0.09433144330978394,
-0.0009707441204227507,
0.4913049638271332,
-0.035477492958307266,
0.6619202494621277,
-0.29293158650398254,
0.13602401316165924,
0.4592394530773163,
0.5144006013870239,
0.561751663684845,
-0.10048913210630417,
-0.16336095333099365,
0.015100840479135513,
0.4449525773525238,
-0.6964468955993652,
-0.3197818696498871,
0.32464271783828735,
-0.6129136085510254,
-0.3987687826156616,
-0.5358718037605286,
-0.3581475019454956,
-0.054645273834466934,
0.05891614034771919,
0.9128729104995728,
0.3090781271457672,
-0.4103306829929352,
0.05294051766395569,
0.7574823498725891,
0.10802791267633438,
0.5392560362815857,
0.4160102605819702,
0.34253990650177,
-0.3135037422180176,
0.7291697263717651,
-0.12284848093986511,
0.13000810146331787,
0.7854469418525696,
0.3659234941005707,
-0.4515302777290344,
-0.7631350159645081,
-0.5773104429244995,
0.22448787093162537,
-0.5605404376983643,
-0.14378027617931366,
-0.7745375037193298,
-0.019332505762577057,
-0.3863915503025055,
-0.11582385748624802,
-0.07388594001531601,
0.09542176127433777,
-0.0955827534198761,
-0.2161794900894165,
0.22884821891784668,
0.42253297567367554,
-0.41169455647468567,
0.5755879878997803,
-1.3823422193527222,
0.35035383701324463,
-0.1447136104106903,
0.05694614723324776,
-0.06184951588511467,
-0.7463879585266113,
-0.2932341694831848,
0.1862364262342453,
-0.10398151725530624,
-1.2470545768737793,
0.3220064640045166,
0.25086408853530884,
0.7747524380683899,
0.6933199167251587,
0.4676176905632019,
0.5494166612625122,
-0.5736348628997803,
0.7797697186470032,
0.21554625034332275,
-0.7781364321708679,
0.3378862142562866,
-0.27571964263916016,
0.227757066488266,
0.7507068514823914,
0.45714399218559265,
0.07463468611240387,
-0.4109429121017456,
-0.7938537001609802,
-0.37709909677505493,
0.8192242980003357,
0.49695664644241333,
0.32905149459838867,
-0.09741511940956116,
0.35208603739738464,
0.08910098671913147,
0.09282977133989334,
-0.4982236623764038,
-0.5072150230407715,
0.016354039311408997,
-0.4907887279987335,
-0.20726245641708374,
-0.5593575835227966,
0.013666118495166302,
0.002955434378236532,
0.1813221424818039,
-0.036304689943790436,
0.7147371768951416,
0.31553933024406433,
-0.1211148127913475,
-0.3044701814651489,
0.17649976909160614,
0.6136195659637451,
0.6332353353500366,
-0.4968514144420624,
0.340317964553833,
0.17503578960895538,
-0.9487515091896057,
0.2808825969696045,
-0.026812834665179253,
-0.14894713461399078,
0.3367718458175659,
0.3732544481754303,
0.42947056889533997,
0.17669403553009033,
-0.7438879013061523,
0.8454068899154663,
0.010029962286353111,
-0.16211512684822083,
-0.02245412953197956,
0.46651938557624817,
-0.39083096385002136,
0.10858143866062164,
0.7691767811775208,
0.3617947995662689,
0.585686206817627,
-0.46244797110557556,
0.29919925332069397,
0.3442832827568054,
-0.3655908405780792,
-0.38888290524482727,
0.38063347339630127,
-0.3046828508377075,
-0.13164165616035461,
0.31095975637435913,
-0.6513761281967163,
-0.427776962518692,
0.6746805310249329,
0.732044517993927,
0.5771015882492065,
-0.37480297684669495,
-0.0026248760987073183,
0.3434780240058899,
0.8645226359367371,
-0.14835795760154724,
0.5971807241439819,
0.009422093629837036,
-0.5488343834877014,
-0.32370424270629883,
-0.5426120758056641,
-0.12775112688541412,
0.00381947448477149,
-0.9374551177024841,
-0.13071157038211823,
-0.1833794116973877,
-0.28934425115585327,
-0.24902187287807465,
-0.3166702687740326,
-0.4086076319217682,
0.36020779609680176,
-0.26966020464897156,
1.120958924293518,
-0.9236567616462708,
0.6403108835220337,
0.5064457654953003,
0.10511813312768936,
-0.5982282161712646,
0.4302660822868347,
-0.03727016597986221,
-0.3255423605442047,
0.19738249480724335,
-0.03222464397549629,
-0.22136376798152924,
-0.09904196113348007,
-0.05049322918057442,
-0.6870830655097961,
0.7078037261962891,
0.30641934275627136,
-0.4946126937866211,
0.19214369356632233,
0.1533506214618683,
0.3675268292427063,
-0.014703736640512943,
0.17996980249881744,
0.7215151190757751,
0.18712717294692993,
-0.19041311740875244,
-0.4800357222557068,
-0.04060514643788338,
-0.2994081377983093,
0.2390897274017334,
0.6325893998146057,
-0.08847780525684357,
0.4269026219844818,
-0.3189593553543091,
-0.19272369146347046,
0.15157903730869293,
0.6328254342079163,
0.39498624205589294,
0.7936652898788452,
0.4354652464389801,
0.4541409909725189,
0.6342166066169739,
0.09299667179584503,
1.3682383298873901,
-0.17787586152553558,
0.34030789136886597,
0.4747767448425293,
0.16771818697452545,
0.850738525390625,
0.12929996848106384,
-0.4849967062473297,
0.33925437927246094,
0.5187192559242249,
0.09363207966089249,
0.949819803237915,
0.12281965464353561,
-0.17025327682495117,
-0.05210983753204346,
0.6251039505004883,
-0.44437175989151,
-0.13245990872383118,
0.38653358817100525,
-0.5524148344993591,
-0.025850290432572365,
-0.2603324055671692,
-0.13366559147834778,
0.16979169845581055,
-0.3557267487049103,
0.5933146476745605,
0.06230829656124115,
-0.28065305948257446,
0.553389847278595,
0.2854338586330414,
0.7136734127998352,
-0.34962448477745056,
0.12217255681753159,
-0.16453205049037933,
0.07025902718305588,
0.04651094600558281,
-0.6959626078605652,
0.3010804057121277,
0.10510944575071335,
-0.5908857583999634,
0.5885704159736633,
0.6064170598983765,
0.038814935833215714,
-0.7260439395904541,
-0.12803798913955688,
0.11350596696138382,
0.43760985136032104,
0.022028515115380287,
-0.10024037957191467,
-0.2479885071516037,
-0.0576636977493763,
-0.11414244771003723,
0.33287808299064636,
0.6446034908294678,
0.37776273488998413,
0.3972550928592682,
0.671906590461731,
0.10745828598737717,
0.7447068691253662,
-0.5071279406547546,
0.3868718147277832,
-0.6263664364814758,
-0.7049851417541504,
-0.9437918663024902,
0.36893734335899353,
-0.1216546967625618,
-0.36341413855552673,
0.41798439621925354,
0.8076391220092773,
0.6373999118804932,
-0.5377126932144165,
0.8671416640281677,
0.10278243571519852,
0.5576376914978027,
-0.686045229434967,
0.4970856010913849,
-0.3272985517978668,
-0.10736563801765442,
-0.42496639490127563,
-1.043312907218933,
-0.020245419815182686,
0.6718223690986633,
-0.09936793148517609,
-0.2765096127986908,
0.6785542368888855,
0.7819089889526367,
-0.47702232003211975,
0.002063004532828927,
0.41282111406326294,
-0.04468308389186859,
-0.02176925353705883,
0.5091363191604614,
0.603430449962616,
-0.649509072303772,
0.6617674231529236,
-0.3956862688064575,
-0.39134764671325684,
-0.4131164252758026,
-0.8653447031974792,
-0.9379690885543823,
-0.2212352305650711,
-0.1421508938074112,
-0.3062271773815155,
0.181724414229393,
0.6787803769111633,
0.4276120066642761,
-0.7001971006393433,
-0.022547809407114983,
-0.04039400443434715,
0.0289271492511034,
-0.7217019200325012,
-0.1833406239748001,
0.3618875741958618,
-0.005557570606470108,
-0.7061787247657776,
0.5090652108192444,
0.004505959805101156,
0.23498594760894775,
0.32460469007492065,
0.12726379930973053,
0.2657904326915741,
0.4226582646369934,
0.1339886486530304,
0.1645539551973343,
-0.2543746829032898,
-0.07475877553224564,
-0.1387743204832077,
-0.2747378349304199,
0.20199866592884064,
0.8817660808563232,
-0.46890562772750854,
0.2586941123008728,
0.6569616794586182,
0.9079720377922058,
0.6013651490211487,
0.15291063487529755,
0.2735639810562134,
-0.9058462977409363,
0.10371348261833191,
0.03861594200134277,
-0.014779292978346348,
-0.1473880112171173,
-0.5867864489555359,
0.127954363822937,
0.5326186418533325,
-0.2583824098110199,
-1.0979307889938354,
0.2954378128051758,
-1.0655630826950073,
-0.02899743802845478,
0.7014678716659546,
-0.20928315818309784,
-0.5563326478004456,
-0.16234911978244781,
0.09739770740270615,
-0.041712742298841476,
-0.4542086720466614,
0.7850674986839294,
0.5011310577392578,
-0.2175663709640503,
-0.19217626750469208,
-0.4605655074119568,
0.37099194526672363,
0.08311527967453003,
-0.26554879546165466,
-0.2177932858467102,
0.349745512008667,
0.5342990756034851,
0.2664954364299774,
0.7198817729949951,
0.14619912207126617,
0.5346893072128296,
0.31403613090515137,
-0.24082660675048828,
0.16618801653385162,
-0.09368391335010529,
-0.2629204988479614,
0.31018826365470886,
0.1437160074710846,
-0.3119381070137024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00750v1
|
Can Language Models Recognize Convincing Arguments?
| 2024-03-31T17:38:33 | 2024-03-31T17:38:33 |
Paula Rescala, Manoel Horta Ribeiro, Tiancheng Hu, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The remarkable and ever-increasing capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs) have raised concerns about their potential misuse for creating
personalized, convincing misinformation and propaganda. To gain insights into
LLMs' persuasive capabilities without directly engaging in experimentation with
humans, we propose studying their performance on the related task of detecting
convincing arguments. We extend a dataset by Durmus & Cardie (2018) with
debates, votes, and user traits and propose tasks measuring LLMs' ability to
(1) distinguish between strong and weak arguments, (2) predict stances based on
beliefs and demographic characteristics, and (3) determine the appeal of an
argument to an individual based on their traits. We show that LLMs perform on
par with humans in these tasks and that combining predictions from different
LLMs yields significant performance gains, even surpassing human performance.
The data and code released with this paper contribute to the crucial ongoing
effort of continuously evaluating and monitoring the rapidly evolving
capabilities and potential impact of LLMs.
|
[
-0.44679707288742065,
-0.844175398349762,
0.7462852001190186,
0.06594570726156235,
-0.11736232787370682,
0.014117796905338764,
-0.4484897553920746,
-0.05427324026823044,
-0.16357791423797607,
0.5997229814529419,
-0.36682239174842834,
-0.4848511517047882,
-0.6895735263824463,
0.13096149265766144,
-0.37092190980911255,
0.710626482963562,
0.247270405292511,
0.19233760237693787,
-0.5656471252441406,
-0.02000807784497738,
-0.3282056152820587,
-0.8092923164367676,
-0.448519229888916,
-0.4797695577144623,
0.7300611138343811,
0.5598838329315186,
0.7398533225059509,
0.6000946760177612,
0.18158112466335297,
0.38389456272125244,
-0.09036041796207428,
-0.014868593774735928,
-0.43104875087738037,
0.2758495807647705,
-0.4538594186306,
-0.6028820872306824,
-0.22604043781757355,
0.21199572086334229,
0.6213356852531433,
0.5701464414596558,
-0.007142243906855583,
-0.06825464218854904,
0.01363951712846756,
0.39915865659713745,
-0.3042965829372406,
-0.19735929369926453,
-0.9968137741088867,
-0.234479621052742,
-0.5579909682273865,
-0.3678370714187622,
-0.563968300819397,
-0.28680968284606934,
0.09878277033567429,
-0.08826258778572083,
0.1362522393465042,
0.06567928194999695,
0.7994667887687683,
0.025599684566259384,
-0.5812345743179321,
-0.4193202555179596,
-0.7085445523262024,
0.8037669658660889,
-0.8738285899162292,
0.29521092772483826,
0.4310115575790405,
0.054259590804576874,
-0.40498363971710205,
-0.5443387031555176,
-0.6208660006523132,
-0.5308107733726501,
0.1526997685432434,
-0.1509719341993332,
-0.4659770131111145,
-0.02295815758407116,
0.5660349726676941,
0.244563490152359,
-0.5195438265800476,
0.4419846832752228,
-0.14527010917663574,
-0.25090309977531433,
0.8097916841506958,
0.21107180416584015,
0.33048883080482483,
-0.2788845896720886,
-0.28841325640678406,
-0.2654739022254944,
-0.5673507452011108,
0.1878872960805893,
0.5959644317626953,
-0.0028416612185537815,
-0.13041852414608002,
0.6127660274505615,
0.002134110312908888,
0.4158637821674347,
0.030909936875104904,
-0.13769647479057312,
-0.06263668090105057,
0.07756055146455765,
-0.26665741205215454,
-0.1766308695077896,
0.865390956401825,
0.06432163715362549,
0.32358893752098083,
0.024523012340068817,
-0.31169626116752625,
0.3320619463920593,
0.07254047691822052,
-0.6620044112205505,
-0.29856356978416443,
0.05079236254096031,
-0.42495325207710266,
-0.2489749938249588,
-0.05421943590044975,
-0.7541554570198059,
-0.931627631187439,
-0.2285684496164322,
0.17583748698234558,
-0.3413658142089844,
-0.39277970790863037,
0.3850765824317932,
-0.15675096213817596,
0.23936396837234497,
0.17103146016597748,
-0.8441593647003174,
0.3222404420375824,
0.9631442427635193,
0.6279535293579102,
-0.33152154088020325,
-0.15921731293201447,
-0.5185224413871765,
-0.12123030424118042,
-0.49326291680336,
1.0588750839233398,
-0.796191930770874,
-0.4188595116138458,
0.027399549260735512,
-0.07823815196752548,
-0.12303166836500168,
-0.761099636554718,
1.0653494596481323,
-0.5021763443946838,
0.0437350794672966,
-0.5810173749923706,
-0.8089246153831482,
-0.15096528828144073,
0.16883401572704315,
-0.6974709033966064,
0.5724742412567139,
-0.18410946428775787,
-0.6347492933273315,
0.3045650124549866,
-0.5034210085868835,
-0.3854646384716034,
0.15349294245243073,
-0.25172609090805054,
-0.30368754267692566,
0.5092941522598267,
0.039531391113996506,
0.6669831275939941,
-0.4225408732891083,
0.2774030566215515,
-0.601300835609436,
0.027055174112319946,
0.7657994627952576,
-0.608098566532135,
0.6583084464073181,
0.12138164043426514,
-0.2666756212711334,
0.21695876121520996,
-0.49268874526023865,
-0.17421086132526398,
0.33468300104141235,
-0.4563949406147003,
-0.3621087968349457,
0.3991319239139557,
-0.3873441517353058,
-0.021504508331418037,
0.17766815423965454,
-0.38461363315582275,
0.27156326174736023,
-0.4119005501270294,
0.3987036347389221,
0.8021498322486877,
-0.23335038125514984,
0.08737500011920929,
-0.2033989429473877,
0.7185195684432983,
-0.1376810222864151,
-0.2149496227502823,
-0.0708642229437828,
-0.3972419798374176,
-0.773988664150238,
-0.14578154683113098,
0.19285763800144196,
0.3817703425884247,
-0.35855016112327576,
0.23128582537174225,
-0.16628047823905945,
-0.5266652703285217,
-0.16519537568092346,
0.45125165581703186,
0.19779528677463531,
0.4250066876411438,
0.012300048023462296,
-0.007738794665783644,
-0.6828430891036987,
-0.975498378276825,
-0.5600889325141907,
-0.44662511348724365,
0.022615013644099236,
0.3271567225456238,
0.4359772205352783,
-0.1327778548002243,
0.7435850501060486,
-0.17138023674488068,
0.2526240646839142,
-0.49610039591789246,
0.32814282178878784,
0.11296387016773224,
0.06351818889379501,
0.45835021138191223,
-0.6886920928955078,
-0.15009883046150208,
0.039659298956394196,
-0.8300992846488953,
-0.49609121680259705,
-0.08468788117170334,
0.0643719956278801,
0.20664452016353607,
0.3617190718650818,
-0.5803194046020508,
0.07333006709814072,
0.7067229151725769,
-0.6520139575004578,
0.6678476929664612,
0.007512728683650494,
0.010651529766619205,
-0.7514678239822388,
-0.14112839102745056,
0.4237118065357208,
-0.21306456625461578,
-0.7070798873901367,
-0.25991591811180115,
-0.12504911422729492,
0.20562301576137543,
-0.24836945533752441,
0.5777601599693298,
-0.25070494413375854,
0.1568794995546341,
-0.4128921627998352,
0.0295975673943758,
-0.16061586141586304,
0.023271121084690094,
0.15828195214271545,
0.5292106866836548,
0.639701783657074,
-0.4754827618598938,
0.4626392126083374,
-0.028852656483650208,
-0.6006636023521423,
0.5597749352455139,
-0.6566620469093323,
0.2579491436481476,
-0.025573937222361565,
0.11689095944166183,
-1.2441457509994507,
-0.5017067790031433,
0.06979795545339584,
-0.42991727590560913,
0.05793098360300064,
-0.22413824498653412,
-0.39780113101005554,
-0.3687750995159149,
-0.10137639939785004,
-0.019318578764796257,
0.43614575266838074,
-0.45094385743141174,
0.7968398928642273,
0.41529223322868347,
-0.3439937233924866,
-0.3552783727645874,
-0.4129570722579956,
0.322578489780426,
-0.6817724704742432,
-0.6114984154701233,
0.005977565888315439,
0.07123266905546188,
-0.7584061622619629,
-0.2241930365562439,
0.08804292976856232,
0.1565505415201187,
0.24188672006130219,
0.43356573581695557,
0.23864594101905823,
-0.3355790972709656,
0.3114323914051056,
-0.23493775725364685,
-0.03764602541923523,
0.4522603750228882,
-0.021353183314204216,
0.4721538722515106,
-0.32034096121788025,
-0.48430144786834717,
-0.2960430979728699,
0.206316277384758,
0.7099848985671997,
-0.03736936300992966,
0.534687876701355,
0.38140976428985596,
-0.20791074633598328,
-0.3514156639575958,
-0.9972381591796875,
-0.29244810342788696,
-0.5120866298675537,
0.45745396614074707,
-0.4499395191669464,
-0.8138580322265625,
0.3183499276638031,
-0.26358410716056824,
0.12722216546535492,
0.4343028664588928,
0.7445433139801025,
-0.08984117209911346,
1.3116540908813477,
0.19824156165122986,
-0.0712323784828186,
0.22720231115818024,
0.010328691452741623,
0.0016711782664060593,
-0.4566577672958374,
-0.20823104679584503,
-0.5731881260871887,
-0.310021311044693,
-0.32069531083106995,
-0.3897661864757538,
0.024665284901857376,
0.2922300100326538,
-0.15895268321037292,
0.04459613561630249,
-0.3257730007171631,
0.3659801185131073,
0.2797209918498993,
-0.30729904770851135,
0.2894882559776306,
0.18536362051963806,
-0.09392087906599045,
-0.2711867094039917,
-0.5211135745048523,
-1.071785807609558,
0.9478835463523865,
0.7121193408966064,
0.7140802145004272,
0.02589724026620388,
0.22259777784347534,
0.5425133109092712,
0.6584206819534302,
-0.870470404624939,
0.9623181223869324,
-0.30138492584228516,
-0.4810738265514374,
-0.020310061052441597,
-0.5210798382759094,
-0.8970920443534851,
0.3070574700832367,
-0.34625890851020813,
-0.6830348372459412,
-0.021641701459884644,
0.3311477303504944,
-0.01988079398870468,
0.5872352719306946,
-0.634610116481781,
0.9092180728912354,
-0.7301567196846008,
-0.3174425959587097,
-0.5449356436729431,
0.01338979508727789,
0.30143100023269653,
0.10753980278968811,
0.09832946956157684,
-0.3916487991809845,
-0.0744141936302185,
1.0448263883590698,
0.06721695512533188,
0.859786868095398,
-0.2554999887943268,
-0.33662527799606323,
0.2823098301887512,
0.11835510283708572,
0.3030279278755188,
-0.06928908079862595,
-0.31066009402275085,
0.12182653695344925,
-0.1300337165594101,
-0.23613546788692474,
-0.5871607065200806,
0.7810059189796448,
-0.5964845418930054,
-1.1291192770004272,
-0.24320556223392487,
-0.3998577296733856,
-0.3137628436088562,
-0.12623916566371918,
-0.015703584998846054,
0.2610309422016144,
-0.4090448319911957,
0.4394950866699219,
0.5761969089508057,
-0.220065638422966,
0.3255710005760193,
0.5176098942756653,
-0.08538942784070969,
-0.37233293056488037,
1.0227935314178467,
-0.042225636541843414,
0.16328106820583344,
0.17249228060245514,
0.8151476383209229,
-0.6086801290512085,
-0.766344428062439,
-0.3355032205581665,
0.4070781171321869,
-0.7521308660507202,
0.04808112233877182,
-0.5830486416816711,
0.26712310314178467,
-0.2181457281112671,
0.00034443853655830026,
-0.17866995930671692,
-0.1750808209180832,
-0.1982945203781128,
-0.012053369544446468,
0.2834945619106293,
1.0172669887542725,
0.10672363638877869,
0.2687666416168213,
-0.42362698912620544,
0.03787288814783096,
0.5098147392272949,
0.15032003819942474,
-0.0765017569065094,
-0.6385334730148315,
0.037303853780031204,
0.10339264571666718,
-0.4434492290019989,
-0.952307939529419,
0.3870618939399719,
-0.05340122431516647,
0.7378631234169006,
0.7572020888328552,
-0.0739981159567833,
0.4272846281528473,
-0.016139352694153786,
0.7611479759216309,
0.07652372866868973,
-0.9478925466537476,
0.3312224745750427,
-0.35169750452041626,
-0.04748425632715225,
0.12808898091316223,
0.5637834072113037,
-0.2894759178161621,
-0.12111149728298187,
-0.40147313475608826,
-0.2880264222621918,
0.48269253969192505,
-0.13884268701076508,
0.22764575481414795,
-0.08729524165391922,
0.26897338032722473,
0.02363479882478714,
0.06280872225761414,
-0.7371565103530884,
0.20493701100349426,
0.013999012298882008,
-0.028106441721320152,
-0.04408082738518715,
-0.497991681098938,
-0.2387850284576416,
-0.2854536771774292,
0.48769906163215637,
-0.265851229429245,
-0.2309836596250534,
-0.0431281216442585,
0.13392996788024902,
0.0258047915995121,
0.487455815076828,
0.5627402067184448,
0.5034785866737366,
0.15315194427967072,
0.32462286949157715,
0.3676198422908783,
-0.08611476421356201,
0.13115531206130981,
-0.011575084179639816,
0.14336881041526794,
-0.15793591737747192,
0.6121279001235962,
0.960834264755249,
0.011269439943134785,
-0.9665811061859131,
0.5648815035820007,
-0.11138805747032166,
-0.3808593451976776,
-0.22371284663677216,
0.22577150166034698,
0.5166388154029846,
0.365449458360672,
0.20228509604930878,
-0.029995668679475784,
-0.2425965666770935,
-0.6831854581832886,
-0.015713723376393318,
0.7613717913627625,
-0.2265544831752777,
-0.6170362234115601,
0.5101034641265869,
0.19955559074878693,
-0.45295649766921997,
0.29281359910964966,
0.015738405287265778,
-0.5867780447006226,
0.4893912076950073,
0.4744509160518646,
0.738221287727356,
-0.2864323854446411,
0.012982803396880627,
0.14074189960956573,
-0.10166898369789124,
-0.25763723254203796,
0.1428849697113037,
0.09449505060911179,
-0.9032406210899353,
-0.3080052435398102,
-0.4252358675003052,
-0.37834760546684265,
0.4668726921081543,
-0.33564555644989014,
0.31680813431739807,
-0.5124263763427734,
-0.4173595607280731,
0.2823088765144348,
0.08590775728225708,
-0.4958760142326355,
-0.01508066151291132,
0.620403528213501,
0.8444631099700928,
-0.9171818494796753,
0.6601522564888,
0.8506805300712585,
0.00882621668279171,
-0.4615262746810913,
-0.06773224472999573,
0.13394464552402496,
-0.5592333078384399,
0.6541563272476196,
0.06692902743816376,
-0.4858604967594147,
-0.44906675815582275,
-0.7886222004890442,
-0.3761914372444153,
0.5427584648132324,
0.8993712663650513,
-0.5810464024543762,
0.1600528210401535,
0.08200527727603912,
0.5708101391792297,
-0.5699294805526733,
0.20440004765987396,
0.641169011592865,
0.6352089643478394,
-0.0000074689633038360626,
-0.6111078858375549,
-0.06211031973361969,
-0.11224402487277985,
-0.23432770371437073,
-0.36750346422195435,
-0.4175122082233429,
0.7259821891784668,
-0.373945027589798,
-0.40551814436912537,
0.10054317116737366,
0.8388245701789856,
0.34148484468460083,
0.3680708706378937,
0.8165475726127625,
0.3510309159755707,
0.8099974989891052,
-0.09877941012382507,
1.1658953428268433,
-0.2957172989845276,
-0.05927459895610809,
0.7984895706176758,
-0.4570443332195282,
1.0155409574508667,
0.23372316360473633,
-0.06495113670825958,
0.7129243612289429,
0.40657857060432434,
-0.023993495851755142,
-0.08261408656835556,
0.42333221435546875,
-0.44678375124931335,
-0.9394423365592957,
-0.2091623693704605,
0.07212261855602264,
0.6420331001281738,
0.6276546120643616,
-0.38497111201286316,
0.15446583926677704,
-0.0556868277490139,
0.19731688499450684,
0.5748680233955383,
-0.07045427709817886,
0.6903334856033325,
0.12950605154037476,
-0.9840053915977478,
0.7007389068603516,
0.06391146034002304,
0.7942116856575012,
-0.6162883639335632,
-0.06572385877370834,
0.04573830962181091,
0.22471372783184052,
-0.22651344537734985,
-1.0868191719055176,
0.018293822184205055,
0.1702338457107544,
-0.06570565700531006,
-0.15476126968860626,
0.8610350489616394,
-0.17192934453487396,
-0.39551693201065063,
0.42545393109321594,
0.5760869979858398,
0.11719410121440887,
0.08807458728551865,
-0.5516076683998108,
0.3733048141002655,
0.0278778113424778,
-0.470211923122406,
0.2289309948682785,
0.3229650557041168,
-0.0880633294582367,
1.034705638885498,
0.6923856735229492,
0.3506077527999878,
-0.09881339222192764,
0.1934674233198166,
0.7991845607757568,
-0.5783470869064331,
-0.018167033791542053,
-1.3037277460098267,
0.19347500801086426,
-0.22383913397789001,
-0.3839448094367981,
0.8867163062095642,
0.5190991759300232,
0.5744374394416809,
-0.006951853632926941,
0.8733720183372498,
0.1942291110754013,
0.560362696647644,
-0.35488033294677734,
0.47193601727485657,
-0.4207400679588318,
0.3124578595161438,
-0.051008716225624084,
-0.4467778205871582,
-0.03977245092391968,
0.6037928462028503,
-0.6897251009941101,
-0.06049160659313202,
0.2563881278038025,
0.9357800483703613,
-0.04204206541180611,
0.2533985674381256,
0.440819650888443,
0.4200228452682495,
0.5275382399559021,
0.5147804021835327,
1.2678062915802002,
0.23366235196590424,
0.5104811191558838,
0.12511934340000153,
-0.19463582336902618,
-0.1323656141757965,
-0.9990027546882629,
-1.2669512033462524,
-0.44306185841560364,
-0.40266287326812744,
-0.3788538873195648,
-0.0811132863163948,
0.897423267364502,
0.7420497536659241,
-0.8245012760162354,
-0.4685423970222473,
0.04723791405558586,
0.21825256943702698,
-0.05449458584189415,
-0.18102478981018066,
0.16574738919734955,
-0.1154043972492218,
-0.7342532277107239,
0.7159578800201416,
0.07178360223770142,
-0.16097092628479004,
-0.6301392316818237,
-0.30788516998291016,
0.044541135430336,
0.5087182521820068,
0.5790385603904724,
0.4814053177833557,
-1.0728726387023926,
-0.15692239999771118,
-0.14598311483860016,
-0.008016572333872318,
-0.03238720819354057,
1.0575562715530396,
-0.7266019582748413,
0.3896813690662384,
0.5921390652656555,
0.6172460913658142,
0.008346691727638245,
0.1958843469619751,
0.7012917399406433,
-0.3630753755569458,
-0.16623543202877045,
0.25529250502586365,
0.6198614835739136,
0.586475670337677,
-0.004329437389969826,
0.1792321801185608,
0.25326576828956604,
-0.5618324875831604,
-0.8729647994041443,
0.24376966059207916,
-0.8871332406997681,
-0.16615116596221924,
1.4625731706619263,
-0.18134380877017975,
-0.019506443291902542,
-0.1450435221195221,
-0.2934039235115051,
-0.18241208791732788,
-0.4338614344596863,
0.7195034623146057,
0.8710599541664124,
-0.08813680708408356,
-0.18394124507904053,
-0.5797486305236816,
0.5470705032348633,
0.6285662651062012,
-0.6758357286453247,
0.38942959904670715,
0.4729142487049103,
0.4197211265563965,
0.09532878547906876,
0.3069474697113037,
-0.02012239396572113,
0.047616053372621536,
-0.1142423152923584,
-0.3514832854270935,
-0.0067237853072583675,
-0.12703803181648254,
-0.41508185863494873,
0.46671393513679504,
0.43122321367263794,
0.23243430256843567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00748v1
|
Benchmark Transparency: Measuring the Impact of Data on Evaluation
| 2024-03-31T17:33:43 | 2024-03-31T17:33:43 |
Venelin Kovatchev, Matthew Lease
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper we present an exploratory research on quantifying the impact
that data distribution has on the performance and evaluation of NLP models. We
propose an automated framework that measures the data point distribution across
6 different dimensions: ambiguity, difficulty, discriminability, length, noise,
and perplexity.
We use disproportional stratified sampling to measure how much the data
distribution affects absolute (Acc/F1) and relative (Rank) model performance.
We experiment on 2 different datasets (SQUAD and MNLI) and test a total of 135
different models (125 on SQUAD and 10 on MNLI). We demonstrate that without
explicit control of the data distribution, standard evaluation frameworks are
inconsistent and unreliable. We find that the impact of the data is
statistically significant and is often larger than the impact of changing the
metric.
In a second set of experiments, we demonstrate that the impact of data on
evaluation is not just observable, but also predictable. We propose to use
benchmark transparency as a method for comparing datasets and quantifying the
similarity between them. We find that the ``dataset similarity vector'' can be
used to predict how well a model generalizes out of distribution.
|
[
-0.4232822358608246,
-0.45038098096847534,
0.39774131774902344,
0.5208624005317688,
0.004949844907969236,
-0.14441081881523132,
-0.18058033287525177,
-0.6011302471160889,
-0.037252362817525864,
0.19478416442871094,
-0.3468167185783386,
-0.5910038352012634,
-0.7406221032142639,
-0.006964387837797403,
-0.9357811808586121,
0.7093842029571533,
-0.0934673398733139,
0.10928041487932205,
-0.3144610822200775,
-0.2531985938549042,
-0.36870670318603516,
-0.4241805970668793,
-0.1414579451084137,
-0.40715429186820984,
0.08859913051128387,
-0.049737680703401566,
0.9367796778678894,
1.1281360387802124,
0.733599841594696,
0.22431164979934692,
-0.1365545392036438,
-0.337342768907547,
-0.4985126256942749,
-0.01527754869312048,
-0.4540710747241974,
-0.6019300222396851,
-0.21408966183662415,
0.2864469587802887,
1.1121145486831665,
1.1349583864212036,
-0.43091127276420593,
0.5238370299339294,
0.3964766263961792,
0.6650632619857788,
-1.0448541641235352,
0.3836461305618286,
-0.4620495140552521,
0.22307753562927246,
-0.14487116038799286,
0.025368869304656982,
-0.21275594830513,
-0.42908698320388794,
0.15829862654209137,
-0.41352155804634094,
0.3274151682853699,
0.13520218431949615,
0.7286124229431152,
0.3128514885902405,
-0.06302545964717865,
-0.25814399123191833,
-0.9269531965255737,
1.0107977390289307,
-0.5088757872581482,
0.3646160364151001,
0.2470100224018097,
0.7686769366264343,
0.15053753554821014,
-0.6902177333831787,
-0.520654022693634,
0.015332141891121864,
0.15495699644088745,
0.062004297971725464,
-0.19300462305545807,
-0.20519907772541046,
0.3315175473690033,
0.5579129457473755,
-0.36191627383232117,
-0.09513605386018753,
-0.2672916054725647,
0.2381269484758377,
0.8412976264953613,
0.42542290687561035,
-0.2049216628074646,
-0.1315767914056778,
-0.23293592035770416,
-0.6453176736831665,
-0.40545493364334106,
0.12092634290456772,
0.6297516226768494,
0.3017621636390686,
-0.2352638691663742,
0.3933125138282776,
-0.395437091588974,
0.5721475481987,
-0.4155582785606384,
0.11554750055074692,
0.5129356980323792,
-0.5863795280456543,
-0.36633750796318054,
-0.12510477006435394,
0.7008118629455566,
0.40740716457366943,
0.06869208812713623,
0.026113465428352356,
-0.2462967187166214,
0.19426293671131134,
0.2650705575942993,
-0.587259829044342,
-0.18185487389564514,
0.1805940419435501,
-0.6417859792709351,
-0.4322988986968994,
0.35192984342575073,
-0.9127669334411621,
-0.3951973021030426,
-0.4787687361240387,
0.5183693766593933,
-0.25969433784484863,
-0.319354772567749,
0.2684507668018341,
-0.2906569540500641,
0.16044004261493683,
0.22187721729278564,
-0.845369815826416,
0.7955337166786194,
1.053507685661316,
0.7680140137672424,
-0.3100018799304962,
-0.22595441341400146,
-0.13169579207897186,
0.021958602592349052,
-0.3563265800476074,
0.5116550326347351,
-0.7552632689476013,
-0.26767075061798096,
0.09469309449195862,
-0.247160404920578,
-0.134977787733078,
-0.9257798194885254,
0.5283394455909729,
0.0822119489312172,
-0.10685108602046967,
-0.2809115946292877,
-0.787793755531311,
-0.04881056398153305,
0.11209432035684586,
-0.7240122556686401,
1.14108407497406,
0.10972492396831512,
-0.7204791903495789,
0.6610771417617798,
-0.6993822455406189,
0.055866193026304245,
-0.08519358932971954,
-0.29564884305000305,
-0.40308845043182373,
0.22340989112854004,
0.1106051355600357,
0.34442588686943054,
-0.3269205093383789,
0.3282947242259979,
-0.32245269417762756,
-0.5563430190086365,
0.11881671845912933,
-0.479329377412796,
0.7625407576560974,
-0.09990524500608444,
-0.5344343781471252,
-0.05143572390079498,
-0.855483889579773,
0.36040791869163513,
-0.05605815351009369,
0.013887257315218449,
-0.20696422457695007,
0.05670939385890961,
0.20226410031318665,
0.052293140441179276,
-0.09042607247829437,
-0.336321085691452,
-0.17643043398857117,
-0.1652953326702118,
0.1681915670633316,
0.7629546523094177,
-0.08445869386196136,
0.3213810324668884,
-0.5050387382507324,
0.6685061454772949,
-0.11523602157831192,
0.7752645611763,
0.15721823275089264,
-0.5823768973350525,
-0.41970565915107727,
-0.19392693042755127,
0.7642630338668823,
0.21715305745601654,
-0.2611457407474518,
0.335928738117218,
-0.2796223759651184,
-0.6347559690475464,
-0.8642057776451111,
-0.09816308319568634,
0.375678688287735,
0.5397120714187622,
0.342509001493454,
-0.6242091059684753,
-0.2125920057296753,
-1.253843069076538,
-0.42915216088294983,
-0.25312307476997375,
-0.3249616324901581,
0.46687376499176025,
0.682384729385376,
0.06541534513235092,
0.9327565431594849,
-0.372463196516037,
-0.20557676255702972,
-0.010066538117825985,
0.24897809326648712,
0.2771594524383545,
0.6742651462554932,
0.425780326128006,
-0.7899848818778992,
-0.36369767785072327,
-0.5147978067398071,
-0.7154721021652222,
-0.301150381565094,
0.16348126530647278,
-0.10606218129396439,
-0.3831126093864441,
0.04516813904047012,
-0.12459894269704819,
0.6680572032928467,
0.7212206125259399,
-0.08393672853708267,
0.8108211159706116,
-0.02340310998260975,
0.12458427250385284,
-0.38471680879592896,
0.4432648718357086,
0.013193639926612377,
-0.001215263968333602,
-0.5133574604988098,
-0.04783743619918823,
0.27889734506607056,
-0.01424330659210682,
-0.42433640360832214,
0.40891462564468384,
-0.033268094062805176,
-0.630092203617096,
0.18370267748832703,
0.15983951091766357,
0.34029263257980347,
0.06027728319168091,
-0.07798457145690918,
0.5745884776115417,
0.4103582799434662,
-0.4558279812335968,
-0.02012775093317032,
0.4781463146209717,
-0.9084160923957825,
0.7216176390647888,
-0.9008250832557678,
-0.1573537141084671,
-0.03053620457649231,
0.1988346427679062,
-0.7254118919372559,
0.10439736396074295,
0.049243632704019547,
-0.3012033998966217,
0.018238753080368042,
0.12616577744483948,
-0.877477765083313,
-0.020069275051355362,
-0.5213224291801453,
0.30571505427360535,
0.3109295070171356,
-0.46575218439102173,
0.031545598059892654,
0.3913128077983856,
-0.00584980845451355,
-0.636894941329956,
-0.8533876538276672,
-0.10516848415136337,
-0.2399558573961258,
-0.569409191608429,
0.49821433424949646,
-0.23319275677204132,
-0.4705125391483307,
-0.10187012702226639,
-0.17586101591587067,
-0.15056782960891724,
0.19003255665302277,
0.38389822840690613,
0.003201246727257967,
0.0020037181675434113,
0.21251580119132996,
-0.07128706574440002,
0.01420682854950428,
0.32266685366630554,
0.13004349172115326,
0.28149333596229553,
-0.231154203414917,
-0.6339159607887268,
-0.4757120609283447,
0.38454630970954895,
0.011807314120233059,
-0.16607911884784698,
0.8932071328163147,
0.2860284745693207,
-0.28700387477874756,
-0.4659383296966553,
-0.3023532032966614,
-0.1626889854669571,
-0.43578165769577026,
0.16360685229301453,
-0.25975650548934937,
-0.1317671686410904,
0.6997283697128296,
0.011399948969483376,
0.02260502427816391,
0.37161973118782043,
0.27150458097457886,
0.014116758480668068,
1.2965621948242188,
0.9755499362945557,
0.09232524037361145,
0.4688595235347748,
-0.5282378196716309,
0.028559338301420212,
-0.9155494570732117,
-0.31509217619895935,
-0.7245624661445618,
-0.5450525283813477,
-0.6094012260437012,
-0.42994824051856995,
0.2782374322414398,
0.4407363831996918,
-0.11072366684675217,
-0.013510195538401604,
-0.6325002312660217,
0.46379849314689636,
0.45330485701560974,
0.018196705728769302,
0.5093224048614502,
-0.14167824387550354,
-0.12891682982444763,
-0.28183749318122864,
-0.685204803943634,
-0.5764000415802002,
1.4174423217773438,
0.5768815875053406,
0.4898277521133423,
0.038891684263944626,
0.5550248026847839,
0.2820332646369934,
0.48617884516716003,
-0.39688676595687866,
0.23591792583465576,
-0.11377101391553879,
-0.5188617706298828,
-0.26382553577423096,
-0.47997385263442993,
-0.753648579120636,
0.342597097158432,
-0.190172478556633,
-0.6375395059585571,
0.5678249001502991,
-0.18786507844924927,
0.10097873955965042,
-0.034337110817432404,
-0.6521385908126831,
0.9348970055580139,
0.06351540237665176,
-0.25384604930877686,
0.05464296042919159,
-0.43274158239364624,
0.28562816977500916,
-0.1736559122800827,
0.337353378534317,
-0.31874868273735046,
-0.1490585058927536,
0.9555854797363281,
-0.45592477917671204,
0.42384645342826843,
-0.322431355714798,
0.25068116188049316,
-0.1480816900730133,
-0.14718665182590485,
0.35875391960144043,
0.06086619570851326,
-0.651170015335083,
0.48663684725761414,
0.1116638034582138,
-0.3891313970088959,
-0.8477873206138611,
0.37387967109680176,
-0.5761488676071167,
-0.3749011158943176,
-0.1984044760465622,
-0.7783437967300415,
-0.3876790702342987,
0.020029764622449875,
0.10823449492454529,
0.3192773163318634,
-0.20756933093070984,
0.37556564807891846,
0.31312212347984314,
-0.17284587025642395,
0.20635215938091278,
0.6568117737770081,
-0.21134601533412933,
-0.08450035750865936,
0.46229395270347595,
0.3431243300437927,
0.4030751585960388,
0.05358199402689934,
0.30051207542419434,
-0.607931911945343,
-0.7858995199203491,
-0.22136998176574707,
0.026462748646736145,
-0.9422333836555481,
-0.056049395352602005,
-0.42862990498542786,
-0.08376092463731766,
-0.1482795923948288,
-0.021601524204015732,
-0.5017728209495544,
-0.4565167725086212,
0.1315746158361435,
-0.14831003546714783,
0.16411970555782318,
0.8864108920097351,
-0.2966088652610779,
0.3445701599121094,
-0.10475447028875351,
0.023443255573511124,
-0.09783954173326492,
0.7967625856399536,
0.02186139114201069,
-0.370341420173645,
-0.2710294723510742,
0.09979194402694702,
-0.2100761979818344,
-0.6410501003265381,
0.4246217906475067,
0.2356814444065094,
0.7510206699371338,
0.17616549134254456,
0.15603721141815186,
0.592629075050354,
-0.39837104082107544,
0.6400823593139648,
0.0850788876414299,
-1.20962393283844,
0.585623562335968,
-0.17327243089675903,
0.29458943009376526,
0.9598879218101501,
0.30587756633758545,
-0.22804467380046844,
-0.7254122495651245,
-0.8590297698974609,
-0.8438546061515808,
0.5816057920455933,
0.5255334377288818,
-0.14945879578590393,
0.17920427024364471,
0.10939538478851318,
0.2267344444990158,
0.644811749458313,
-0.30870065093040466,
-0.5157032012939453,
-0.16886639595031738,
-0.26289889216423035,
-0.13687843084335327,
0.0644521564245224,
-0.22190865874290466,
-0.26017260551452637,
0.21988707780838013,
0.03350543975830078,
0.1744079291820526,
0.07888370752334595,
0.13118582963943481,
0.1864601969718933,
0.10299704223871231,
0.2696998715400696,
1.2020657062530518,
-0.5697709918022156,
-0.06574437767267227,
-0.16076135635375977,
-0.5295407772064209,
-0.11155999451875687,
0.21084968745708466,
-0.23860785365104675,
0.3851167857646942,
0.35974955558776855,
0.5155219435691833,
0.21065732836723328,
-0.6276783347129822,
0.6697031259536743,
-0.15841986238956451,
-0.29660579562187195,
-0.1044427827000618,
0.030004283413290977,
-0.05806395411491394,
0.15371927618980408,
0.40762820839881897,
-0.03185287117958069,
0.45820051431655884,
-0.4656919836997986,
0.504406750202179,
0.22077012062072754,
-0.47044169902801514,
-0.07702804356813431,
0.7275823354721069,
-0.11096583306789398,
-0.1875234842300415,
0.5475928783416748,
0.07179246097803116,
-0.2464940845966339,
0.9645600914955139,
0.21188348531723022,
0.5801304578781128,
-0.42893075942993164,
0.39126095175743103,
0.1978459358215332,
0.4418286383152008,
-0.36519408226013184,
0.22384662926197052,
-0.02680685557425022,
-0.48296621441841125,
-0.10985886305570602,
-0.705566942691803,
-0.7817542552947998,
0.2325882464647293,
-1.2186388969421387,
0.10403680056333542,
-0.5519748330116272,
-0.11457483470439911,
0.5043579339981079,
0.26167386770248413,
-1.1057277917861938,
0.2505955994129181,
-0.17740868031978607,
1.185828447341919,
-0.9749264121055603,
0.6306841373443604,
0.15324565768241882,
-0.2656739056110382,
-0.7626931071281433,
-0.031241655349731445,
0.14573444426059723,
-0.622072696685791,
0.5311955213546753,
0.3515929579734802,
0.3064555525779724,
-0.24338746070861816,
-0.2985956072807312,
-0.8451517224311829,
1.1122477054595947,
0.5000787377357483,
-0.598697304725647,
0.5405043959617615,
0.6292496919631958,
0.8452741503715515,
-0.7018988132476807,
0.4817470610141754,
0.8003106117248535,
0.6432247757911682,
-0.36378079652786255,
-1.2462191581726074,
-0.10469292849302292,
-0.22982218861579895,
0.23556604981422424,
0.0403323695063591,
-0.3287643790245056,
0.8376653790473938,
0.21358832716941833,
-0.4329036474227905,
-0.2066899538040161,
0.018046114593744278,
0.37251463532447815,
0.37754401564598083,
0.4840129613876343,
0.37302955985069275,
0.8950061798095703,
-0.055261410772800446,
1.3929975032806396,
-0.18469762802124023,
0.5302405953407288,
1.2549253702163696,
-0.47864261269569397,
1.1800514459609985,
0.4448871612548828,
-0.47444188594818115,
0.26294705271720886,
0.31207624077796936,
-0.38831380009651184,
0.581699788570404,
0.6935509443283081,
-0.03807549178600311,
0.3612813651561737,
-0.5167623162269592,
-0.45841294527053833,
0.40216460824012756,
0.27430203557014465,
-0.6440879702568054,
-0.31607669591903687,
-0.13040593266487122,
-0.4316973388195038,
0.32444998621940613,
-0.23349407315254211,
0.4204273521900177,
-0.03163861483335495,
-0.12164579331874847,
0.6901903748512268,
-0.034534845501184464,
0.40936559438705444,
-0.4791474938392639,
-0.0956195741891861,
-0.2746904492378235,
0.21602758765220642,
-0.2768491208553314,
-0.9445527791976929,
0.7081413865089417,
-0.07444948703050613,
-0.3427031636238098,
-0.32854947447776794,
0.21403518319129944,
-0.22745010256767273,
-0.5216593146324158,
0.5967957973480225,
0.5668233036994934,
0.31733542680740356,
-0.14913953840732574,
-1.0307930707931519,
0.548389196395874,
-0.3261945843696594,
-0.4180212914943695,
0.4317539930343628,
0.11032696813344955,
0.07052603363990784,
0.7156479358673096,
0.47929108142852783,
0.1497785747051239,
-0.0006968546658754349,
0.39021992683410645,
0.6808224320411682,
-0.4517093300819397,
-0.6011545658111572,
-0.5404395461082458,
0.46764829754829407,
-0.402621328830719,
-0.20362068712711334,
0.8174771070480347,
0.6441786885261536,
0.870480477809906,
0.3062810003757477,
0.7012079358100891,
0.17001576721668243,
0.6368449330329895,
-0.10178259015083313,
0.7796828150749207,
-0.32225266098976135,
0.5622285604476929,
-0.28638967871665955,
-1.2188442945480347,
-0.15322373807430267,
0.4450259506702423,
-0.44765087962150574,
0.09617836773395538,
0.6072026491165161,
0.6303090453147888,
-0.14130546152591705,
0.19800825417041779,
0.26735639572143555,
-0.00487519009038806,
0.17053404450416565,
0.4063369035720825,
0.6304883360862732,
-0.8373096585273743,
0.43633386492729187,
-0.6137827038764954,
-0.42063796520233154,
-0.026173988357186317,
-0.886664628982544,
-0.4432356655597687,
-0.5157425403594971,
-0.489429771900177,
-0.037248022854328156,
0.31299662590026855,
0.1526128202676773,
0.9614573121070862,
-0.7263028025627136,
-0.356713205575943,
-0.12926608324050903,
0.15657781064510345,
-0.645677924156189,
-0.35576823353767395,
0.6233583688735962,
0.03522834554314613,
-0.838079571723938,
0.2625572085380554,
0.1793432980775833,
-0.20262496173381805,
-0.49773576855659485,
0.20423482358455658,
0.11410420387983322,
0.11373680830001831,
0.2536390423774719,
-0.15067139267921448,
-0.4234832227230072,
-0.2586842179298401,
-0.33514195680618286,
-0.010811099782586098,
0.0020034071058034897,
0.49947279691696167,
-0.7795841097831726,
0.6257518529891968,
0.4680710434913635,
0.4171544015407562,
0.6004578471183777,
0.1516161412000656,
0.8634699583053589,
-0.9316700100898743,
0.09613919258117676,
0.2375110387802124,
0.04393027722835541,
0.3769451975822449,
-0.2332657426595688,
0.9437704682350159,
-0.14376838505268097,
-0.4803003966808319,
-1.2722080945968628,
0.04366360977292061,
-0.6092535853385925,
-0.13319215178489685,
0.7671866416931152,
-0.2659001350402832,
-0.16081780195236206,
-0.22480127215385437,
0.5908878445625305,
-0.19561807811260223,
-0.2877512574195862,
0.9003053307533264,
0.8336551785469055,
-0.23399196565151215,
-0.17285475134849548,
-1.2421010732650757,
0.6976773738861084,
0.5194544196128845,
-0.7988831400871277,
0.25266048312187195,
0.17854972183704376,
0.2509820759296417,
0.14361275732517242,
0.413809597492218,
-0.344844788312912,
0.04070556163787842,
0.37037429213523865,
-0.09854773432016373,
-0.08049434423446655,
-0.17688210308551788,
-0.6590154767036438,
0.3015262484550476,
-0.3399920165538788,
-0.15957775712013245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00739v1
|
Opera Graeca Adnotata: Building a 34M+ Token Multilayer Corpus for Ancient Greek
| 2024-03-31T16:54:29 | 2024-03-31T16:54:29 |
Giuseppe G. A. Celano
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this article, the beta version 0.1.0 of Opera Graeca Adnotata (OGA), the
largest open-access multilayer corpus for Ancient Greek (AG) is presented. OGA
consists of 1,687 literary works and 34M+ tokens coming from the PerseusDL and
OpenGreekAndLatin GitHub repositories, which host AG texts ranging from about
800 BCE to about 250 CE. The texts have been enriched with seven annotation
layers: (i) tokenization layer; (ii) sentence segmentation layer; (iii)
lemmatization layer; (iv) morphological layer; (v) dependency layer; (vi)
dependency function layer; (vii) Canonical Text Services (CTS) citation layer.
The creation of each layer is described by highlighting the main technical and
annotation-related issues encountered. Tokenization, sentence segmentation, and
CTS citation are performed by rule-based algorithms, while morphosyntactic
annotation is the output of the COMBO parser trained on the data of the Ancient
Greek Dependency Treebank. For the sake of scalability and reusability, the
corpus is released in the standoff formats PAULA XML and its offspring LAULA
XML.
|
[
-0.8216902017593384,
-0.6240465641021729,
0.5340477228164673,
-0.057921990752220154,
-0.4203358292579651,
-0.11500275880098343,
-0.04010697081685066,
-0.823691189289093,
0.5041393637657166,
0.6817506551742554,
-0.07827580720186234,
-0.26091840863227844,
-0.3518354296684265,
-0.15723298490047455,
-0.2054034173488617,
1.107643961906433,
-0.07656512409448624,
0.19304700195789337,
0.06671159714460373,
-0.36646994948387146,
0.011441702954471111,
-0.462629109621048,
-1.12849760055542,
0.2500174343585968,
0.4620863199234009,
0.3766102194786072,
0.6795447468757629,
0.8666638731956482,
0.15966778993606567,
0.3765474557876587,
-0.41836902499198914,
0.11453257501125336,
-0.039058100432157516,
0.1984049379825592,
-0.1692885309457779,
-0.27435970306396484,
-0.7244470715522766,
0.0748242661356926,
0.7370449900627136,
0.28290554881095886,
-0.023902403190732002,
0.33955734968185425,
-0.2483045756816864,
0.6040098667144775,
-0.5912593603134155,
0.30190280079841614,
-0.4387787878513336,
-0.17995275557041168,
-0.6552069783210754,
-0.08922155946493149,
-0.09724996984004974,
-0.4895372688770294,
0.2294914573431015,
-1.022929310798645,
-0.1091909408569336,
-0.34206220507621765,
0.6210412383079529,
0.19814765453338623,
-0.6662749648094177,
-0.7011846899986267,
-0.6161527037620544,
0.3758125305175781,
-0.6033865213394165,
0.23152174055576324,
0.30491626262664795,
0.4771198630332947,
-0.14993146061897278,
-1.1365972757339478,
-0.46758440136909485,
-0.1693408340215683,
0.2338036298751831,
0.015216175466775894,
-0.028417274355888367,
-0.14334511756896973,
-0.13069096207618713,
0.8672016263008118,
-0.15356339514255524,
-0.14403410255908966,
-0.5915156602859497,
-0.2597285509109497,
0.21911583840847015,
-0.19084642827510834,
0.6020191311836243,
0.01586342602968216,
-0.14721116423606873,
-0.20147687196731567,
-0.37029892206192017,
-0.21431881189346313,
0.8583437204360962,
0.26704785227775574,
0.02311459556221962,
0.6114545464515686,
-0.10375356674194336,
0.3289277255535126,
-0.2948436141014099,
0.06508434563875198,
0.4179409146308899,
-0.0648036077618599,
-0.00804057251662016,
0.45031920075416565,
0.42961105704307556,
0.060238201171159744,
0.3246557414531708,
-0.24118874967098236,
0.22904860973358154,
0.7534138560295105,
0.5871937274932861,
-0.5681836009025574,
-0.10447899252176285,
0.21886594593524933,
-0.1577240377664566,
-0.2549084424972534,
0.07070234417915344,
-0.9878520369529724,
-0.46578991413116455,
-0.2597620487213135,
0.1429160237312317,
-0.629725992679596,
-0.08279967308044434,
0.10516805201768875,
0.004309838637709618,
-0.4056129455566406,
0.4037669003009796,
-0.7225537896156311,
0.5346242785453796,
0.5749938488006592,
0.7953369617462158,
0.17876407504081726,
-0.32143160700798035,
-0.37395986914634705,
0.1919567734003067,
-0.3096056580543518,
0.8336610198020935,
-0.33728790283203125,
0.0023406774271279573,
0.0711701363325119,
0.052628789097070694,
-0.18351136147975922,
-0.2495243102312088,
1.325464129447937,
-0.493623286485672,
0.4499710500240326,
0.2054409384727478,
-0.6082080602645874,
-0.6752071380615234,
-0.15941058099269867,
-1.0635567903518677,
0.9962133169174194,
0.2526718080043793,
-0.5710001587867737,
0.0500701442360878,
-0.834033727645874,
-0.1636897325515747,
0.1925162523984909,
-0.08632204681634903,
-0.13277095556259155,
0.39821839332580566,
0.26034995913505554,
0.07067283242940903,
0.06780914217233658,
-0.11770901829004288,
-0.17870807647705078,
-0.11534756422042847,
-0.21344105899333954,
-0.1146792620420456,
0.4985763430595398,
0.7621437907218933,
-0.4228673577308655,
0.01450254861265421,
-1.0452996492385864,
-0.0837935358285904,
0.07679415494203568,
-0.5767257213592529,
-0.5549634099006653,
-0.1670694798231125,
0.32182639837265015,
0.21734105050563812,
0.2351183146238327,
-0.6143609285354614,
0.4817584753036499,
-0.10388893634080887,
0.7584228515625,
0.5396888256072998,
-0.20586176216602325,
0.39044809341430664,
-0.2149147391319275,
0.5741235017776489,
-0.07508548349142075,
0.21896588802337646,
-0.42829781770706177,
-0.8142654895782471,
-0.4376733899116516,
-0.5754102468490601,
0.4321920573711395,
0.27096378803253174,
-0.780120849609375,
-0.14638279378414154,
-0.19166864454746246,
-0.6503852605819702,
-0.7741138339042664,
-0.1971968412399292,
0.31033584475517273,
0.37131065130233765,
0.2128210812807083,
-0.4947168529033661,
-0.5405179858207703,
-0.7708674073219299,
0.29630425572395325,
-0.3571001887321472,
0.4320140480995178,
0.3379361033439636,
0.3716295659542084,
-0.12440545856952667,
0.4491335153579712,
-0.24140706658363342,
-0.5253016352653503,
0.16237393021583557,
0.0749848410487175,
0.022464461624622345,
0.5617081522941589,
0.821986198425293,
-0.65743088722229,
-0.2130228579044342,
0.1396627128124237,
-0.4340476393699646,
-0.14640729129314423,
0.17130440473556519,
-0.2820200026035309,
0.2846361994743347,
0.45329105854034424,
-0.6706328988075256,
0.11139095574617386,
0.7740840315818787,
-0.7163135409355164,
0.7980175018310547,
-0.22027266025543213,
0.4444332420825958,
-1.1998499631881714,
0.32183536887168884,
-0.16819730401039124,
-0.3018129765987396,
-0.5370926856994629,
0.5256665945053101,
-0.09749925881624222,
-0.021956035867333412,
-0.6194330453872681,
0.8345001339912415,
-0.496052622795105,
0.029259037226438522,
-0.32305413484573364,
0.2711038589477539,
-0.15360049903392792,
0.34307876229286194,
-0.01677173376083374,
0.7368502616882324,
0.5593098998069763,
-0.5366379022598267,
0.3588724434375763,
0.38725215196609497,
-0.43556317687034607,
0.5934759378433228,
-0.22401461005210876,
0.15725181996822357,
-0.02981751784682274,
0.3199291527271271,
-0.8253036737442017,
-0.04199504479765892,
0.45813968777656555,
-0.5115770697593689,
0.014295876026153564,
-0.5083382725715637,
-0.25089016556739807,
-0.2192409336566925,
-0.25107476115226746,
0.4617528021335602,
-0.11544790118932724,
-0.36241161823272705,
0.7211832404136658,
0.6781488656997681,
-0.5188695788383484,
-0.5332664847373962,
-0.5000971555709839,
0.20408926904201508,
-0.38333505392074585,
-0.8353020548820496,
0.2650311589241028,
-0.18456818163394928,
-0.1447318196296692,
0.2818128764629364,
-0.07850870490074158,
0.044905006885528564,
0.17109817266464233,
0.2120758295059204,
0.15355955064296722,
-0.6178303956985474,
0.10815243422985077,
-0.15772226452827454,
-0.047837309539318085,
-0.5369576811790466,
-0.5119706988334656,
0.7690722942352295,
-0.3393014967441559,
-0.10437898337841034,
-0.346365362405777,
0.30494391918182373,
0.9997855424880981,
-0.009183031506836414,
0.7321882843971252,
0.41303837299346924,
-0.3827173411846161,
0.12045668065547943,
-0.6548413634300232,
0.14648105204105377,
-0.36021482944488525,
0.07933580875396729,
-0.5704315304756165,
-0.8989712595939636,
0.9932090044021606,
0.08139397948980331,
0.1372615396976471,
0.8173527717590332,
0.4091636836528778,
0.5037307143211365,
0.6352233290672302,
0.2721351683139801,
-0.212180495262146,
0.6466968655586243,
-0.21162420511245728,
-0.5482815504074097,
-0.9907451868057251,
0.03214656934142113,
-0.8404878377914429,
-0.29302483797073364,
-0.36061611771583557,
-0.14688003063201904,
0.11657791584730148,
0.3582955002784729,
-0.32499656081199646,
0.19484905898571014,
-0.45757535099983215,
0.15466122329235077,
0.8018714189529419,
-0.13674862682819366,
0.5148201584815979,
0.19294129312038422,
-0.3988913297653198,
0.3700738549232483,
-0.3002912402153015,
-0.9165343046188354,
1.3343360424041748,
0.6442205309867859,
0.357638955116272,
0.4430481493473053,
0.28450506925582886,
0.22730039060115814,
0.25856608152389526,
-0.6053882241249084,
0.35152724385261536,
-0.26535332202911377,
-0.9316903352737427,
-0.29905667901039124,
-0.4647436738014221,
-0.7361521124839783,
0.46756353974342346,
0.020910069346427917,
-0.9707967042922974,
0.3270687460899353,
-0.05900099128484726,
-0.44252675771713257,
0.4289592206478119,
-0.8141704201698303,
1.053920865058899,
0.1394624561071396,
0.08608269691467285,
0.05982566252350807,
-0.3686157464981079,
0.14983190596103668,
0.10527347028255463,
0.3475354313850403,
0.2463383972644806,
-0.21581938862800598,
0.7348681092262268,
-0.3824395537376404,
0.33818286657333374,
-0.05758662894368172,
-0.27777501940727234,
0.3917538523674011,
0.1986875981092453,
0.49697962403297424,
0.14204208552837372,
-0.07042570412158966,
-0.1923014521598816,
0.11099017411470413,
-0.4674701392650604,
-0.1202891618013382,
0.7715955376625061,
-0.842379093170166,
-0.16931739449501038,
-0.7119367122650146,
-0.24806712567806244,
-0.2768516540527344,
0.20035690069198608,
0.0503968745470047,
0.7010058760643005,
-0.1750222146511078,
0.2126326709985733,
0.2441522777080536,
0.008954010903835297,
0.5102270841598511,
0.49569201469421387,
-0.1834975779056549,
-0.9888421893119812,
0.640372633934021,
0.048311568796634674,
-0.04052894189953804,
-0.06365420669317245,
-0.07628627866506577,
-0.3255247175693512,
-0.9131330847740173,
-1.0971983671188354,
0.26580533385276794,
-0.6328973770141602,
0.2113143354654312,
-0.6428519487380981,
-0.014821689575910568,
-0.6168004274368286,
0.2645135819911957,
-0.6923524141311646,
-0.8770790696144104,
-0.3722415864467621,
-0.32960841059684753,
0.2879437804222107,
0.6999906897544861,
-0.009761541150510311,
0.5885617136955261,
-0.7399294376373291,
0.06308501213788986,
0.07069887965917587,
0.5380757451057434,
0.06458539515733719,
-0.24662688374519348,
-0.4245811402797699,
-0.34920334815979004,
-0.3435307741165161,
-0.751681387424469,
0.12960924208164215,
0.26681825518608093,
0.6109609603881836,
0.6757635474205017,
-0.138192281126976,
0.3250150680541992,
-0.6083590388298035,
0.9302747845649719,
0.11460088193416595,
-0.8312990665435791,
0.18083083629608154,
-0.45695367455482483,
0.2099665105342865,
0.6429740786552429,
0.31982406973838806,
-0.7022683620452881,
-0.5003579258918762,
-0.6146665811538696,
-1.0778379440307617,
0.8982155919075012,
0.3281356394290924,
0.11344677954912186,
-0.03903608024120331,
0.4350776672363281,
0.2726142704486847,
0.4073888063430786,
-0.47954800724983215,
-0.5135892629623413,
-0.31705978512763977,
-0.2988271117210388,
-0.4187310039997101,
-0.46073395013809204,
-0.1661997139453888,
0.12254449725151062,
1.0020848512649536,
-0.2532740831375122,
-0.038788650184869766,
0.42667117714881897,
0.0028939892072230577,
-0.26798373460769653,
0.42017701268196106,
0.9811594486236572,
0.8184276223182678,
-0.3698752224445343,
0.3719003200531006,
-0.3735482692718506,
-1.1980149745941162,
-0.12815047800540924,
0.4848775267601013,
-0.20751327276229858,
-0.07933379709720612,
0.25440746545791626,
1.058103322982788,
-0.11532928049564362,
-0.7074750661849976,
-0.10282837599515915,
-0.12716896831989288,
0.10100699961185455,
-0.5653042793273926,
-0.457577645778656,
0.12868168950080872,
0.4757138788700104,
0.8511373996734619,
-0.16301719844341278,
0.18581491708755493,
-1.014593482017517,
0.36274880170822144,
0.026622217148542404,
-0.5765470862388611,
-0.24781112372875214,
0.7962631583213806,
0.06521113216876984,
0.3023260831832886,
0.05307107791304588,
-0.10145748406648636,
-0.540277361869812,
0.2904438078403473,
0.16106285154819489,
0.7579614520072937,
-0.45096033811569214,
0.5568705201148987,
-0.07032862305641174,
0.3294895589351654,
-0.06920505315065384,
0.3593314290046692,
0.41832995414733887,
-0.547631561756134,
-0.2868708670139313,
-0.8039294481277466,
-0.28192681074142456,
0.2995584011077881,
-0.18154390156269073,
-0.049677345901727676,
-0.22518324851989746,
-0.30059418082237244,
0.38136163353919983,
0.23827768862247467,
-0.09199951589107513,
0.304267942905426,
0.32246384024620056,
0.9094230532646179,
-0.6761474013328552,
0.6901454925537109,
1.3292598724365234,
-0.5473192930221558,
-0.5824236273765564,
-0.5286917686462402,
0.018362991511821747,
-0.34785211086273193,
0.3026168644428253,
-0.24764001369476318,
0.21058134734630585,
0.07951895147562027,
-0.10905717313289642,
-0.7164965867996216,
0.9526042342185974,
0.6536905765533447,
-0.17598018050193787,
-0.08665545284748077,
0.001687508192844689,
0.7280253767967224,
-0.6725090146064758,
0.5950770378112793,
0.2207789570093155,
0.42979103326797485,
0.2679184675216675,
-0.9711523652076721,
0.1048722118139267,
-0.6243585348129272,
-0.09883365035057068,
0.11028743535280228,
-0.5357956290245056,
1.1674113273620605,
0.3300062119960785,
-0.20832520723342896,
0.5427500009536743,
0.5454094409942627,
0.052453771233558655,
0.4426981210708618,
0.503206729888916,
1.4347559213638306,
0.5366615056991577,
-0.23910462856292725,
1.2627824544906616,
-0.3963506519794464,
0.11470524966716766,
1.103451132774353,
0.2054823786020279,
0.6345741748809814,
0.4414701461791992,
0.044795263558626175,
0.5148828625679016,
0.8865706324577332,
0.49315112829208374,
0.48699304461479187,
0.25074172019958496,
-0.3756820261478424,
0.14728900790214539,
-0.24678899347782135,
-0.8115911483764648,
0.1125061959028244,
0.07718683034181595,
-0.4590207636356354,
-0.17659826576709747,
0.11295371502637863,
0.44274288415908813,
-0.11078676581382751,
-0.5274198651313782,
0.7855137586593628,
0.053731873631477356,
-0.5441098809242249,
0.169692724943161,
0.10389414429664612,
0.20692406594753265,
-0.6097261309623718,
0.11658809334039688,
-0.2692394554615021,
0.40064141154289246,
-0.0016330796061083674,
-0.3255723714828491,
-0.003230431815609336,
-0.253050297498703,
0.07493223249912262,
0.46565014123916626,
0.3498259484767914,
-0.1479010283946991,
-0.43418315052986145,
0.34813201427459717,
0.44830814003944397,
0.21401961147785187,
-0.5175933241844177,
-0.27251484990119934,
0.15923753380775452,
-0.3938756585121155,
-0.4935581088066101,
0.2036038041114807,
0.6808039546012878,
-0.12943106889724731,
0.49081042408943176,
0.7139908671379089,
0.5526747107505798,
0.5207429528236389,
0.08624984323978424,
1.0214780569076538,
-0.45776841044425964,
-0.950042724609375,
-0.37970849871635437,
0.4223511219024658,
0.043033383786678314,
-0.7135207653045654,
0.5941202044487,
0.6599988341331482,
0.8012463450431824,
-0.14298118650913239,
0.7504698634147644,
-0.01501607894897461,
0.35296764969825745,
-0.5267288088798523,
0.5705919861793518,
-0.6920579075813293,
-0.04844431206583977,
-0.5149223804473877,
-1.2646353244781494,
-0.08495038002729416,
0.22656182944774628,
-0.053124405443668365,
-0.1833152025938034,
0.8118814826011658,
0.1088990718126297,
-0.11618892848491669,
0.4111175239086151,
-0.06561446934938431,
0.13860656321048737,
0.16525615751743317,
0.3741479814052582,
0.7631911635398865,
-0.5119966864585876,
0.755314290523529,
-0.06471296399831772,
-0.4134278893470764,
-0.2144905924797058,
-0.7570419311523438,
-0.42820194363594055,
-0.6662222743034363,
-0.3512275218963623,
-0.4877531826496124,
0.16757933795452118,
0.6558984518051147,
0.5505509376525879,
-1.2082886695861816,
-0.11145751923322678,
0.09371118992567062,
-0.08463884890079498,
-0.4638051688671112,
-0.22026832401752472,
0.6297290921211243,
-0.2917449176311493,
-1.1467828750610352,
0.4607672691345215,
-0.010254516266286373,
0.06888194382190704,
-0.33025309443473816,
-0.16782516241073608,
-0.44837117195129395,
0.0678475946187973,
0.3082129955291748,
0.47391560673713684,
-0.28698456287384033,
-0.3982158899307251,
-0.4667310416698456,
-0.057189084589481354,
0.02857990376651287,
0.7706670165061951,
-0.34461677074432373,
0.42554575204849243,
0.5162978172302246,
0.47880062460899353,
0.5616388320922852,
0.03583519533276558,
0.3481111526489258,
-0.3151070773601532,
0.29668086767196655,
0.19675172865390778,
0.7280837893486023,
0.01823311671614647,
-0.15893036127090454,
0.8409430980682373,
0.44548219442367554,
-0.5044617056846619,
-0.6992940902709961,
0.017831820994615555,
-1.2991950511932373,
-0.508396327495575,
0.866464376449585,
-0.286023885011673,
-0.1708340346813202,
-0.3021332621574402,
-0.6489062905311584,
0.267258882522583,
-0.8073516488075256,
0.8781453371047974,
1.0226800441741943,
0.3400637209415436,
-0.2409619688987732,
-0.9191965460777283,
0.6294037103652954,
0.08000046014785767,
-0.7822582125663757,
-0.4328814148902893,
0.8050516247749329,
0.041038576513528824,
0.9532100558280945,
0.6262717843055725,
-0.6186503767967224,
0.259404718875885,
-0.006988889537751675,
0.2840476632118225,
-0.37621596455574036,
-0.5107578635215759,
-0.03967014327645302,
0.680729866027832,
-0.18318556249141693,
-0.4549919664859772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00727v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00727v2
|
A Controlled Reevaluation of Coreference Resolution Models
| 2024-03-31T16:00:41 | 2024-04-23T00:45:22 |
Ian Porada, Xiyuan Zou, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
All state-of-the-art coreference resolution (CR) models involve finetuning a
pretrained language model. Whether the superior performance of one CR model
over another is due to the choice of language model or other factors, such as
the task-specific architecture, is difficult or impossible to determine due to
lack of a standardized experimental setup. To resolve this ambiguity, we
systematically evaluate five CR models and control for certain design decisions
including the pretrained language model used by each. When controlling for
language model size, encoder-based CR models outperform more recent
decoder-based models in terms of both accuracy and inference speed.
Surprisingly, among encoder-based CR models, more recent models are not always
more accurate, and the oldest CR model that we test generalizes the best to
out-of-domain textual genres. We conclude that controlling for the choice of
language model reduces most, but not all, of the increase in F1 score reported
in the past five years.
|
[
-0.62700355052948,
-0.5167776346206665,
0.29004231095314026,
-0.012212788686156273,
-0.26796579360961914,
-0.0564076192677021,
-0.8951165080070496,
-0.7515490651130676,
-0.2798328697681427,
0.5182266235351562,
-0.25748276710510254,
-0.3355622887611389,
-1.043448567390442,
0.5467033386230469,
-0.21600773930549622,
0.927577018737793,
-0.32681357860565186,
-0.09223884344100952,
-0.480241060256958,
-0.127796471118927,
-0.47382789850234985,
-0.7521265745162964,
-0.14180180430412292,
-0.8896932005882263,
0.33743125200271606,
0.35710325837135315,
1.0635621547698975,
0.7974419593811035,
0.992262065410614,
0.24167419970035553,
-0.3392699956893921,
0.11168254166841507,
-0.38257497549057007,
-0.2711851894855499,
-0.32612180709838867,
-0.4926697313785553,
-0.5199133157730103,
0.20548515021800995,
0.3394891321659088,
0.7261562943458557,
0.024241046980023384,
-0.02090267278254032,
0.07661915570497513,
0.48288673162460327,
-0.8018757104873657,
-0.007764650508761406,
-0.4448383152484894,
-0.3536980152130127,
-0.03575557842850685,
-0.12115361541509628,
-0.8601930737495422,
-0.2404009848833084,
0.3010150194168091,
-0.5479357242584229,
0.5504294037818909,
0.09959075599908829,
1.0934247970581055,
0.33948054909706116,
-0.3914624750614166,
-0.5681182146072388,
-0.975111722946167,
1.0195233821868896,
-0.5559751987457275,
0.6065680384635925,
0.5295609831809998,
0.12564626336097717,
0.12300270050764084,
-0.6386050581932068,
-0.3009736239910126,
-0.39058589935302734,
-0.44782671332359314,
-0.23644673824310303,
-0.30623045563697815,
0.3376436233520508,
0.16283097863197327,
0.4531998634338379,
-0.38264065980911255,
0.20352229475975037,
-0.45170295238494873,
-0.4107573926448822,
0.30177220702171326,
0.08097843825817108,
-0.1054873988032341,
-0.14252722263336182,
-0.08967453241348267,
0.15397262573242188,
-0.6671757698059082,
0.11212336272001266,
-0.23891597986221313,
0.34980878233909607,
0.19816556572914124,
0.6032958030700684,
-0.326461523771286,
0.819389820098877,
0.7833318114280701,
-0.22220182418823242,
-0.05334339663386345,
-0.3517536222934723,
-0.2719295918941498,
0.0623905248939991,
0.4526548683643341,
0.561471164226532,
0.46053797006607056,
-0.23860470950603485,
-0.21923339366912842,
0.2712465524673462,
0.3969472348690033,
-0.80363529920578,
-0.058979637920856476,
0.18061663210391998,
-0.37438732385635376,
-0.013336237519979477,
-0.21883134543895721,
-0.19352586567401886,
-0.13982711732387543,
-0.8015199303627014,
0.14905916154384613,
-0.43787261843681335,
-0.09193172305822372,
0.2923876941204071,
0.0315961018204689,
0.14780351519584656,
0.35340145230293274,
-0.8031970858573914,
0.34605151414871216,
0.418366014957428,
0.6693215370178223,
-0.2804497182369232,
-0.173223614692688,
0.0713508352637291,
-0.08635488152503967,
-0.5906331539154053,
0.8348857164382935,
-0.9713514447212219,
-0.7627564668655396,
-0.07506680488586426,
-0.042275480926036835,
-0.07346303761005402,
-0.773514986038208,
0.739189624786377,
-0.6091973781585693,
0.27989235520362854,
-0.34144505858421326,
-0.6410920023918152,
-0.1492191106081009,
0.25226330757141113,
-0.5002326965332031,
0.5779458284378052,
0.05200909823179245,
-0.6789894700050354,
0.547478199005127,
-0.18533514440059662,
-0.2063816487789154,
-0.12838883697986603,
-0.24265514314174652,
-0.13423410058021545,
0.2242889255285263,
0.24549777805805206,
0.32923439145088196,
-0.5819007158279419,
0.5657301545143127,
0.11547031998634338,
-0.3456757664680481,
-0.03905264288187027,
0.0909477025270462,
0.36970439553260803,
0.267316073179245,
-0.1457846760749817,
0.35044315457344055,
-0.5112537741661072,
0.055397018790245056,
-0.37265545129776,
-0.4613070487976074,
-0.3886791467666626,
-0.12415996938943863,
-0.2884220480918884,
0.20499545335769653,
0.3688616454601288,
-0.542034924030304,
-0.08416157215833664,
-0.08460147678852081,
0.6243199110031128,
0.3120615780353546,
-0.15634417533874512,
0.8375884294509888,
-0.5766074657440186,
0.4080681800842285,
0.12789949774742126,
0.17770998179912567,
-0.07162526249885559,
-0.15721315145492554,
-0.959790050983429,
-0.12765565514564514,
0.4177175760269165,
0.3619474172592163,
-0.21716292202472687,
0.5873949527740479,
-0.348962664604187,
-0.8072071075439453,
-0.4089204668998718,
-0.03918985277414322,
0.485081285238266,
0.39163345098495483,
0.5383184552192688,
-0.35240331292152405,
-0.30414095520973206,
-1.093132734298706,
-0.3760465979576111,
-0.1758033186197281,
0.0757720097899437,
0.3110356628894806,
0.5032249689102173,
-0.09967061132192612,
1.1099228858947754,
-0.17331357300281525,
-0.21704252064228058,
-0.45372480154037476,
0.28591904044151306,
0.06667319685220718,
0.8702743649482727,
0.657356321811676,
-0.7389914989471436,
-0.17573627829551697,
0.002211274579167366,
-0.3526858389377594,
-0.1248161569237709,
-0.16728679835796356,
-0.06807154417037964,
0.03444766253232956,
0.35401052236557007,
-0.6193523406982422,
0.4653550982475281,
0.39872974157333374,
-0.09253956377506256,
0.9579112529754639,
-0.08287464082241058,
0.42514652013778687,
-0.5063482522964478,
0.15592625737190247,
-0.07018623501062393,
-0.209685817360878,
-0.431686669588089,
0.15114964544773102,
0.48231011629104614,
0.14534571766853333,
-0.24577192962169647,
0.23486684262752533,
-0.5212788581848145,
0.3299536406993866,
-0.3894246816635132,
0.16979405283927917,
0.2286892682313919,
0.5601252317428589,
0.43069323897361755,
0.6909257173538208,
0.26575443148612976,
-0.9646338820457458,
0.22636377811431885,
0.32449498772621155,
-0.47609713673591614,
0.41324087977409363,
-0.811946451663971,
0.2480352222919464,
-0.25825923681259155,
0.39776065945625305,
-0.792497456073761,
-0.0742669552564621,
-0.16279275715351105,
-0.5482613444328308,
0.31109586358070374,
0.13753120601177216,
-0.040502458810806274,
-0.1740468591451645,
0.31805646419525146,
0.472756028175354,
0.2544976770877838,
-0.3189810812473297,
0.8843399286270142,
0.0054678707383573055,
-0.011377903632819653,
-0.588331401348114,
-0.7819159626960754,
-0.2542036175727844,
-0.08405676484107971,
-0.31248319149017334,
0.7283005118370056,
-0.22724173963069916,
-0.29956522583961487,
-0.06941092014312744,
-0.25484219193458557,
-0.1573863923549652,
-0.28008580207824707,
0.5204200744628906,
0.19084835052490234,
-0.3133179843425751,
0.2540036737918854,
0.06494897603988647,
-0.22598746418952942,
-0.07252991944551468,
0.16477544605731964,
0.48073840141296387,
-0.13019123673439026,
-0.0963219702243805,
-0.566487729549408,
0.4101038873195648,
0.6702841520309448,
-0.7051909565925598,
0.6876916885375977,
-0.10841257125139236,
-0.473031610250473,
0.02675061672925949,
-0.8130246996879578,
-0.2784372866153717,
-0.4606429636478424,
0.24593929946422577,
-0.6415295600891113,
-1.2255520820617676,
0.4843282103538513,
-0.1971816122531891,
0.2622791826725006,
0.4109307825565338,
0.6369830965995789,
0.33307021856307983,
0.843501091003418,
0.7657111287117004,
0.16855043172836304,
0.47464877367019653,
0.019114399328827858,
0.17653317749500275,
-0.7793066501617432,
-0.11668086796998978,
-1.025443196296692,
-0.23148927092552185,
-0.3862229585647583,
-0.395587682723999,
-0.02160116471350193,
0.38728898763656616,
-0.3590394854545593,
0.5048107504844666,
-0.43160125613212585,
0.6394352912902832,
0.3161245882511139,
0.20135731995105743,
0.5620214343070984,
-0.32911670207977295,
-0.3223996162414551,
-0.24571090936660767,
-0.5722438097000122,
-0.6527435779571533,
0.8498762845993042,
0.2619059979915619,
0.697730302810669,
0.05140000954270363,
0.4303276240825653,
0.26419249176979065,
0.680037796497345,
-0.7027487754821777,
0.18417814373970032,
-0.3138440251350403,
-0.9781866669654846,
0.004919035825878382,
-0.20384542644023895,
-0.39476478099823,
0.1525239795446396,
-0.023807642981410027,
-0.4733729064464569,
0.6622357964515686,
0.378129243850708,
-0.7556049227714539,
-0.002713535213842988,
-0.6613335013389587,
0.8038962483406067,
0.07394509017467499,
-0.27724048495292664,
-0.4286353886127472,
-0.37070515751838684,
0.3375464677810669,
-0.1888442188501358,
0.18248385190963745,
-0.1261848360300064,
0.18892036378383636,
0.6920315623283386,
-0.07449281960725784,
0.7990966439247131,
0.22309496998786926,
0.19333940744400024,
0.43253323435783386,
0.45211613178253174,
0.5405495166778564,
-0.16593490540981293,
-0.37423309683799744,
0.06085783988237381,
0.19451849162578583,
-0.3393762409687042,
-0.5555660128593445,
0.6587513089179993,
-0.8547384142875671,
-0.8343060612678528,
-0.15597309172153473,
-0.29330864548683167,
-0.164991557598114,
0.34254375100135803,
0.7193060517311096,
0.6465901136398315,
-0.4489784836769104,
0.5023581385612488,
0.33441162109375,
-0.10528948903083801,
0.25215086340904236,
0.7005568742752075,
-0.1910429745912552,
-0.256694495677948,
0.15244756639003754,
0.08531544357538223,
0.597731351852417,
0.3923049867153168,
0.0406528040766716,
-0.26997441053390503,
-0.6479671597480774,
-0.20843446254730225,
0.382742702960968,
-0.9074969291687012,
-0.2847040295600891,
-0.4209309220314026,
-0.12657411396503448,
-0.6357136368751526,
-0.37401217222213745,
-0.5142660737037659,
-0.2535337507724762,
-0.4438701868057251,
-0.3144761323928833,
0.04386648163199425,
0.6507174372673035,
0.058973703533411026,
0.6828728318214417,
-0.7385659217834473,
-0.09587294608354568,
-0.09143856912851334,
0.36289265751838684,
-0.2530917227268219,
-0.9376286864280701,
-0.3752002716064453,
-0.16329500079154968,
-0.26782000064849854,
-0.7383829355239868,
0.2709622085094452,
0.46841394901275635,
0.4637952744960785,
0.5137813687324524,
0.35583823919296265,
0.6600136756896973,
-0.43149039149284363,
0.8043208718299866,
0.05367426574230194,
-1.1683731079101562,
0.5372246503829956,
-0.04605072736740112,
0.4960065484046936,
0.6084029674530029,
0.5310962200164795,
-0.4893642067909241,
-0.3467528820037842,
-0.47304853796958923,
-0.28763172030448914,
0.31060054898262024,
-0.048056963831186295,
0.03277657926082611,
-0.16798685491085052,
0.8255205154418945,
0.15330545604228973,
0.01454265508800745,
-0.3909831941127777,
0.08212176710367203,
-0.20263583958148956,
-0.018166251480579376,
-0.3327474594116211,
-0.44230976700782776,
-0.0033146259374916553,
-0.21334144473075867,
0.3622526526451111,
-0.01679532788693905,
0.08745738118886948,
0.6094987392425537,
-0.44260871410369873,
-0.5473676919937134,
0.46218204498291016,
0.7078373432159424,
0.9844222664833069,
-0.25212064385414124,
0.40223512053489685,
0.046689555048942566,
-0.36204954981803894,
0.08083552122116089,
-0.2977629601955414,
-0.02110312134027481,
0.009092375636100769,
0.6069799065589905,
0.7660895586013794,
0.30471280217170715,
-0.580558717250824,
0.25910744071006775,
0.06814611703157425,
-0.25473248958587646,
-0.1437186300754547,
0.18829979002475739,
-0.2181641012430191,
0.12630213797092438,
0.012623552232980728,
0.3594333231449127,
-0.189302459359169,
-0.10013986378908157,
0.38632142543792725,
0.11520590633153915,
-0.5894383788108826,
-0.3072817027568817,
0.6200315952301025,
0.43829694390296936,
-0.1304415464401245,
0.7895449995994568,
0.20054760575294495,
-0.6351433396339417,
0.4533155560493469,
0.499607652425766,
0.41978681087493896,
-0.4291185736656189,
0.13205552101135254,
0.8065573573112488,
0.6465951800346375,
-0.23935486376285553,
-0.1680002510547638,
0.06884066760540009,
-1.368395209312439,
-0.6269609928131104,
-0.5873355269432068,
-0.4138525724411011,
0.009946784004569054,
-1.1614525318145752,
0.06236658990383148,
-0.6981662511825562,
-0.7315825819969177,
0.0039848522283136845,
0.1518164724111557,
-0.79685378074646,
0.5823912024497986,
-0.05268515273928642,
1.2877155542373657,
-0.6982421875,
0.9561756253242493,
0.554585874080658,
-0.20849786698818207,
-0.5529078245162964,
-0.5187852382659912,
0.02772088348865509,
-0.33310410380363464,
0.6584244966506958,
0.09727165102958679,
-0.14747083187103271,
0.24250786006450653,
-0.5359477400779724,
-0.7631198167800903,
0.8536016941070557,
0.18139930069446564,
-0.8456713557243347,
-0.2205214500427246,
0.013591788709163666,
0.43770015239715576,
-0.6323029398918152,
0.1996694803237915,
1.0814142227172852,
0.41796600818634033,
-0.06197621300816536,
-1.5054190158843994,
-0.0671018660068512,
-0.03150027245283127,
-0.16751186549663544,
0.1722777783870697,
-0.5354015827178955,
0.8183778524398804,
-0.3646172285079956,
-0.2756624221801758,
0.05554032325744629,
0.9302918910980225,
0.1965092271566391,
-0.19130681455135345,
0.5418838858604431,
0.37851637601852417,
0.5765742063522339,
-0.3173966705799103,
0.9535509943962097,
-0.43765944242477417,
0.2964213490486145,
1.3096158504486084,
-0.19896739721298218,
0.8592591285705566,
0.4602881669998169,
0.04111490771174431,
0.3049197196960449,
0.8884745836257935,
0.24389059841632843,
0.3883756697177887,
-0.0425964891910553,
-0.08697652816772461,
-0.9299026727676392,
-0.3513132333755493,
-0.24925024807453156,
0.42653897404670715,
0.5764886736869812,
-0.654190719127655,
-0.2520035207271576,
0.07424221187829971,
-0.060695745050907135,
0.33265021443367004,
-0.3222026526927948,
0.452384352684021,
-0.10431601107120514,
-0.9092920422554016,
0.737846314907074,
0.1764499545097351,
0.6415320634841919,
-0.47669968008995056,
0.34912729263305664,
-0.35611391067504883,
0.4151463210582733,
-0.131465882062912,
-0.3074641823768616,
0.4622090756893158,
0.15507464110851288,
-0.5356001257896423,
-0.2645076513290405,
0.5795374512672424,
-0.357535719871521,
-0.30883803963661194,
0.38691315054893494,
0.4510023891925812,
0.04979195073246956,
-0.25123658776283264,
-0.4059923589229584,
0.3134673237800598,
0.02457180619239807,
-0.19007648527622223,
0.09119074791669846,
0.22182531654834747,
-0.1889640837907791,
0.5537808537483215,
0.3081689178943634,
0.0047592478804290295,
0.23454532027244568,
-0.14779116213321686,
0.8864634037017822,
-0.7144511938095093,
-0.3372841775417328,
-0.47546589374542236,
0.14761707186698914,
0.2996319830417633,
-0.6378834843635559,
0.28913936018943787,
0.3648725152015686,
1.0422929525375366,
0.0624823197722435,
0.5720621943473816,
-0.17075897753238678,
0.5953448414802551,
-0.40888240933418274,
0.4017094671726227,
-0.4208313822746277,
0.02484658546745777,
0.03410733491182327,
-0.5880012512207031,
-0.5161898732185364,
0.617235541343689,
-0.7339266538619995,
0.16322138905525208,
0.8441207408905029,
0.8768189549446106,
0.23463018238544464,
0.2659620940685272,
0.3921884298324585,
0.17989368736743927,
0.4677729904651642,
0.522463858127594,
0.692380964756012,
-0.05198640376329422,
0.41003650426864624,
-0.5855998992919922,
-0.45460543036460876,
-0.18526487052440643,
-0.9621272683143616,
-0.743054986000061,
-0.585523247718811,
-0.42972689867019653,
-0.20282302796840668,
0.021035687997937202,
1.0448908805847168,
0.7665470838546753,
-1.0697523355484009,
-0.15662218630313873,
0.13136373460292816,
-0.07921687513589859,
-0.4871830344200134,
-0.11858024448156357,
0.264974981546402,
-0.31313788890838623,
-0.7960938215255737,
0.20781484246253967,
-0.1011311337351799,
-0.10411164909601212,
0.01097103301435709,
-0.07729406654834747,
0.03230365738272667,
0.15442687273025513,
0.4089302718639374,
0.04093451052904129,
-1.1704812049865723,
-0.5498887300491333,
0.060624416917562485,
-0.431312620639801,
0.24495260417461395,
1.493260383605957,
-0.5253334045410156,
0.31803426146507263,
0.48280221223831177,
0.3646819591522217,
-0.011746522970497608,
0.3508535325527191,
0.8279516696929932,
-0.4323701560497284,
0.10251237452030182,
0.19508038461208344,
0.2775420546531677,
0.18438532948493958,
-0.35347703099250793,
0.08460868149995804,
0.11000508069992065,
-0.7380791306495667,
-0.5152269601821899,
0.3283630609512329,
-0.8138908743858337,
-0.4385882616043091,
0.927245020866394,
-0.2450253814458847,
-0.1966739147901535,
-0.16165466606616974,
-0.3008479177951813,
0.42297759652137756,
-0.24430334568023682,
0.6425620317459106,
1.139061689376831,
-0.4010087549686432,
-0.5006189942359924,
-0.23076345026493073,
0.7258017659187317,
0.45831120014190674,
-0.16700725257396698,
0.4741445779800415,
0.6959313750267029,
0.30478546023368835,
0.5108007192611694,
0.41066330671310425,
-0.2561954855918884,
0.2631455063819885,
-0.21959160268306732,
0.3708648681640625,
-0.05321746692061424,
-0.6561192274093628,
-0.2356693148612976,
0.1936963051557541,
0.32911914587020874,
0.19661255180835724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00725v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00725v1
|
The Larger the Better? Improved LLM Code-Generation via Budget Reallocation
| 2024-03-31T15:55:49 | 2024-03-31T15:55:49 |
Michael Hassid, Tal Remez, Jonas Gehring, Roy Schwartz, Yossi Adi
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
It is a common belief that large language models (LLMs) are better than
smaller-sized ones. However, larger models also require significantly more time
and compute during inference. This begs the question: what happens when both
models operate under the same budget? (e.g., compute, run-time). To address
this question, we analyze code generation LLMs of various sizes and make
comparisons such as running a 70B model once vs. generating five outputs from a
13B model and selecting one. Our findings reveal that, in a standard unit-test
setup, the repeated use of smaller models can yield consistent improvements,
with gains of up to 15% across five tasks. On the other hand, in scenarios
where unit-tests are unavailable, a ranking-based selection of candidates from
the smaller model falls short of the performance of a single output from larger
ones. Our results highlight the potential of using smaller models instead of
larger ones, and the importance of studying approaches for ranking LLM outputs.
|
[
-0.6697437167167664,
-0.3331071734428406,
0.6758251190185547,
-0.010384132154285908,
-0.2006554752588272,
0.06435184180736542,
-0.4855405390262604,
-0.47739309072494507,
0.041218508034944534,
0.40379342436790466,
-0.3628227710723877,
0.13311003148555756,
-0.5560306310653687,
0.1065157875418663,
-0.2469969242811203,
0.5284444093704224,
0.21196569502353668,
0.35494470596313477,
-0.4429296553134918,
0.061281390488147736,
-0.6843875646591187,
-0.5173266530036926,
-0.7581342458724976,
-0.5798735618591309,
0.6460050940513611,
0.49100443720817566,
0.8699284195899963,
0.8758875131607056,
0.8355910778045654,
0.28700798749923706,
-0.0583350844681263,
0.24070292711257935,
-0.40804392099380493,
-0.011954807676374912,
0.22619932889938354,
-0.4150800406932831,
-0.2463904470205307,
0.12383430451154709,
0.6057325005531311,
0.6137068271636963,
-0.20238269865512848,
0.28608012199401855,
-0.07004819065332413,
0.770765483379364,
-0.4962897300720215,
-0.03958334028720856,
-0.5692882537841797,
-0.16670753061771393,
-0.0025816869456321,
-0.030103305354714394,
-0.5353351831436157,
-0.6766785383224487,
-0.21560046076774597,
-0.09856870770454407,
0.06435977667570114,
0.23378877341747284,
0.9633453488349915,
0.3686157464981079,
-0.3319131135940552,
-0.406368225812912,
-0.7378458976745605,
1.042195439338684,
-0.9748056530952454,
0.48314157128334045,
-0.0184011310338974,
0.35971498489379883,
0.03187591955065727,
-0.7263768315315247,
-0.34597793221473694,
-0.7283762693405151,
-0.010378236882388592,
-0.018923306837677956,
-0.1978844404220581,
-0.04834179952740669,
0.380147248506546,
0.35404932498931885,
-0.47756698727607727,
0.5000666379928589,
-0.6361120343208313,
-0.0899931937456131,
0.7253063321113586,
0.0819520354270935,
0.1830708533525467,
-0.1680840700864792,
0.016559263691306114,
-0.22687454521656036,
-1.1817054748535156,
-0.37433674931526184,
0.4940204918384552,
0.32964056730270386,
0.20638783276081085,
0.6251015663146973,
0.07690191268920898,
0.660165011882782,
0.12895356118679047,
-0.4174089729785919,
-0.11172457784414291,
-0.3939894139766693,
-0.2702879309654236,
-0.02580544538795948,
0.44490981101989746,
0.39934036135673523,
0.5791599750518799,
-0.05724233016371727,
-0.24848389625549316,
0.05700012668967247,
0.5816550254821777,
-1.0469157695770264,
-0.39326438307762146,
0.06131742522120476,
-0.6769657731056213,
-0.3521600067615509,
-0.041205815970897675,
-0.31614619493484497,
-0.13589715957641602,
-0.4608089327812195,
0.22595515847206116,
-0.11931165307760239,
-0.17708681523799896,
-0.08352198451757431,
-0.05882009491324425,
0.10835687071084976,
0.13698314130306244,
-0.6323402523994446,
0.2282174527645111,
0.6574540734291077,
0.8607133626937866,
-0.24106602370738983,
-0.0542941614985466,
-0.7432116270065308,
-0.31079936027526855,
-0.8805997967720032,
0.653181791305542,
-0.31392335891723633,
-0.4964603781700134,
-0.16824615001678467,
-0.4559827744960785,
-0.02675236575305462,
-1.1718608140945435,
0.05047858506441116,
-0.5827397704124451,
0.08676998317241669,
-0.39259010553359985,
-0.6049086451530457,
0.44944754242897034,
-0.057613447308540344,
-0.7825194597244263,
0.9754108190536499,
0.18982787430286407,
-0.4962258040904999,
0.5917519330978394,
-0.500831663608551,
-0.22627323865890503,
-0.08485636115074158,
-0.32404518127441406,
-0.7027400135993958,
0.41099125146865845,
-0.061156924813985825,
0.46711650490760803,
-0.5981162190437317,
0.30767062306404114,
-0.34718239307403564,
-0.5111693739891052,
0.45901742577552795,
-0.21122099459171295,
0.4647968113422394,
0.4857043921947479,
-0.3556930124759674,
0.14700374007225037,
-0.6019935011863708,
0.1491883099079132,
0.22900477051734924,
-0.719340443611145,
-0.05586186423897743,
0.1185811311006546,
-0.28207018971443176,
0.017181705683469772,
0.03843949735164642,
-0.5076150298118591,
0.3394666314125061,
-0.3085143566131592,
0.4348190128803253,
0.7997394800186157,
0.04332993924617767,
0.8119459748268127,
-0.6104992628097534,
0.5959336161613464,
-0.2909872531890869,
0.06124633178114891,
0.09776437282562256,
-0.367885023355484,
-0.9247831702232361,
-0.39123570919036865,
0.6958028078079224,
0.19991075992584229,
-0.5772634744644165,
0.000009661885997047648,
-0.2939538061618805,
-0.4881056249141693,
-0.14849983155727386,
0.18972145020961761,
0.5585331320762634,
0.04245588183403015,
-0.05895676463842392,
-0.22085760533809662,
-0.6142420172691345,
-0.9972111582756042,
-0.08497628569602966,
-0.4002324044704437,
0.014545224606990814,
0.3808908462524414,
0.504289984703064,
-0.12095418572425842,
0.6636145114898682,
-0.7352752089500427,
0.12005750834941864,
-0.6768758893013,
-0.2578781545162201,
0.07038383930921555,
0.4660947918891907,
0.7738186120986938,
-0.4825652837753296,
-0.19938477873802185,
-0.15906602144241333,
-0.35386502742767334,
-0.3279346525669098,
-0.2368975132703781,
-0.03408432379364967,
0.3156090974807739,
0.5557467937469482,
-0.443430632352829,
0.1728527545928955,
0.5364710688591003,
-0.046067751944065094,
0.7895234227180481,
-0.3383009433746338,
0.0028009836096316576,
-0.9790589213371277,
-0.3750174641609192,
-0.13642358779907227,
-0.2603577971458435,
-0.249727264046669,
0.32346105575561523,
0.226193368434906,
-0.029432255774736404,
-0.23186850547790527,
0.38771212100982666,
-0.689485490322113,
-0.5595036149024963,
-0.1837160289287567,
0.023951053619384766,
0.04095960408449173,
0.17872479557991028,
-0.20806658267974854,
1.2513189315795898,
0.14049752056598663,
-0.7334707379341125,
0.24988919496536255,
-0.2369096577167511,
-0.6823219060897827,
-0.09705629199743271,
-0.5909727215766907,
0.11808530986309052,
0.14142926037311554,
0.10201586037874222,
-0.9429649710655212,
-0.3752753734588623,
-0.38343536853790283,
-0.37494662404060364,
0.39872393012046814,
0.05076795443892479,
-0.6145521402359009,
-0.5605776906013489,
-0.4000678062438965,
0.14353084564208984,
0.8635044693946838,
-0.7894158959388733,
0.10298604518175125,
0.23430576920509338,
-0.15733379125595093,
-0.3001749813556671,
-0.837919294834137,
-0.12955977022647858,
-0.4569673240184784,
-0.6723619699478149,
0.14327372610569,
-0.1477654129266739,
-0.7415186166763306,
-0.17260603606700897,
-0.26675915718078613,
0.030034510418772697,
0.2542817294597626,
0.29051172733306885,
0.2644248902797699,
-0.603405237197876,
0.20407430827617645,
0.0023695386480540037,
-0.017737045884132385,
-0.047840870916843414,
-0.11168842762708664,
0.6070123314857483,
-0.04595448821783066,
-0.4401020407676697,
-0.16589277982711792,
0.29050710797309875,
0.45595481991767883,
-0.2139546424150467,
0.7960307002067566,
0.17471836507320404,
-0.13426463305950165,
-0.3676903247833252,
-0.6585668921470642,
-0.21586231887340546,
-0.5320548415184021,
0.21567383408546448,
-0.4546247124671936,
-1.0016356706619263,
0.31199225783348083,
-0.14422690868377686,
0.292179137468338,
0.387566477060318,
0.6879388689994812,
0.04781158268451691,
1.0432195663452148,
0.6515388488769531,
0.11090642958879471,
0.6662508845329285,
-0.44444194436073303,
0.47288334369659424,
-0.7317481637001038,
0.005721978843212128,
-0.6828024387359619,
-0.25780725479125977,
-0.4946841895580292,
-0.6244350671768188,
0.15010996162891388,
0.24643205106258392,
-0.3279641568660736,
0.3946782946586609,
-0.5884687304496765,
0.6578836441040039,
0.6940723657608032,
-0.12486553937196732,
0.24074824154376984,
0.008435728028416634,
-0.06864334642887115,
-0.04290006682276726,
-1.0010254383087158,
-0.6996482610702515,
1.129811406135559,
0.22501584887504578,
0.6971076726913452,
0.3916477560997009,
1.0334956645965576,
0.19494588673114777,
0.7340607047080994,
-0.7347297668457031,
0.5703897476196289,
-0.16724158823490143,
-0.5081146359443665,
-0.20179855823516846,
-0.7122777700424194,
-1.0016411542892456,
0.42648494243621826,
0.0703018307685852,
-0.6052306294441223,
0.030063357204198837,
0.2711905539035797,
-0.5511207580566406,
0.3434343636035919,
-1.0578882694244385,
0.7242984175682068,
-0.20172008872032166,
-0.11748568713665009,
-0.2767837643623352,
0.019197281450033188,
0.41668301820755005,
-0.2333078682422638,
0.36278852820396423,
0.022339344024658203,
-0.01775672473013401,
0.6176396012306213,
-0.5188601613044739,
0.3807503879070282,
0.09038715809583664,
-0.11266505718231201,
0.4500051736831665,
0.22206157445907593,
0.3621112108230591,
0.11348053067922592,
-0.28181976079940796,
-0.12520959973335266,
-0.05445649474859238,
-0.40996402502059937,
-0.39577484130859375,
0.9030002355575562,
-0.7477884888648987,
-0.6974565386772156,
-0.19083383679389954,
-0.6073142886161804,
-0.11556639522314072,
0.017714068293571472,
0.42734259366989136,
0.8376494646072388,
-0.039925310760736465,
0.4018944799900055,
0.486380398273468,
-0.3843514919281006,
0.6213883757591248,
0.12114603072404861,
-0.5000585317611694,
-0.1085313931107521,
0.8526347875595093,
0.4630719721317291,
0.7272209525108337,
0.015370749868452549,
0.34421518445014954,
-0.1517046093940735,
-0.7359720468521118,
-0.5704253315925598,
0.36732926964759827,
-0.5393721461296082,
-0.40236592292785645,
-0.3908357620239258,
-0.06482428312301636,
-0.6362188458442688,
-0.3980400264263153,
-0.6561785340309143,
-0.5135934948921204,
-0.07343397289514542,
-0.170436292886734,
0.078514464199543,
0.9383907914161682,
-0.1906730681657791,
0.3830222487449646,
-0.47201892733573914,
0.14781495928764343,
0.505925178527832,
0.08749596029520035,
0.08378730714321136,
-0.5100162029266357,
-0.3090633153915405,
-0.21828173100948334,
-0.35422733426094055,
-0.6570984125137329,
0.39178600907325745,
0.03285016119480133,
0.4657270014286041,
0.24781033396720886,
-0.11060158163309097,
0.7309671640396118,
-0.5021203756332397,
0.9422427415847778,
0.29948627948760986,
-0.6160805821418762,
0.13434450328350067,
-0.13960199058055878,
0.5219475030899048,
0.1732805073261261,
-0.14549866318702698,
-0.10092271119356155,
-0.4839600920677185,
-0.7963789701461792,
-0.6496742367744446,
0.5999443531036377,
0.3119128346443176,
0.13581867516040802,
-0.11396806687116623,
0.44918134808540344,
-0.08624427765607834,
0.1902119368314743,
-0.5962954163551331,
-0.2257014513015747,
0.2746163010597229,
0.03443417698144913,
-0.029613928869366646,
-0.4077751338481903,
0.07120218873023987,
-0.04550103843212128,
0.6196048259735107,
-0.0749116763472557,
0.5556873083114624,
-0.09276629984378815,
-0.05086274817585945,
-0.09639628976583481,
0.20128411054611206,
0.6133868098258972,
1.0484275817871094,
-0.11931322515010834,
0.19098487496376038,
0.31674373149871826,
-0.30743110179901123,
-0.0029176899697631598,
-0.44261473417282104,
0.01543134730309248,
0.16972854733467102,
0.6054244041442871,
0.6996644139289856,
0.2552700936794281,
-0.864533007144928,
0.3387411832809448,
-0.08882660418748856,
-0.3151012063026428,
-0.26866450905799866,
0.3209427297115326,
0.38861849904060364,
0.30623435974121094,
0.23909835517406464,
-0.11109914630651474,
-0.09472614526748657,
-0.7612152695655823,
0.3199135959148407,
0.3694564998149872,
0.17255067825317383,
0.18533892929553986,
0.5522681474685669,
0.14294885098934174,
-0.48440515995025635,
0.46761953830718994,
-0.20301233232021332,
-0.45568129420280457,
1.2963305711746216,
0.6091234087944031,
0.48156651854515076,
0.0034138127230107784,
0.1965288370847702,
0.4766523540019989,
0.4635632634162903,
-0.39212194085121155,
0.06460826843976974,
0.13703502714633942,
-0.5392332077026367,
-0.650902509689331,
-0.6629368662834167,
-0.4098361134529114,
0.0845457911491394,
-0.7502619624137878,
-0.13168583810329437,
-0.607936680316925,
-0.2598184049129486,
0.12964583933353424,
0.26557645201683044,
-0.5136210918426514,
0.2612440884113312,
0.27091744542121887,
0.8107501268386841,
-0.4738089144229889,
0.8698762655258179,
0.6842200756072998,
-0.18476274609565735,
-1.2443387508392334,
-0.10632046312093735,
0.0035773818381130695,
-0.5959091782569885,
0.8015083074569702,
0.18284472823143005,
0.020278096199035645,
-0.1362973302602768,
-0.37346336245536804,
-1.1050232648849487,
1.07004976272583,
0.5964375734329224,
-0.8434422016143799,
0.021104048937559128,
-0.1406433880329132,
0.3944789469242096,
-0.777955949306488,
0.028450902551412582,
0.7119150161743164,
0.2442624717950821,
-0.002201512921601534,
-0.9853983521461487,
-0.20581987500190735,
0.2594468891620636,
0.31812983751296997,
0.5947768092155457,
-0.7559308409690857,
1.003327488899231,
-0.5685173273086548,
-0.11147134751081467,
0.26961761713027954,
0.646938145160675,
0.45608675479888916,
0.23425903916358948,
0.52251797914505,
0.37727147340774536,
0.7503284215927124,
-0.2214970886707306,
1.5577316284179688,
-0.15661579370498657,
0.43724051117897034,
1.1959517002105713,
-0.20387239754199982,
0.8900495171546936,
0.38932207226753235,
-0.29478031396865845,
0.37279027700424194,
0.8281088471412659,
0.06561040133237839,
0.3382698893547058,
0.5768583416938782,
0.12342940270900726,
-0.4099810719490051,
0.2525988817214966,
-0.41845494508743286,
0.06625490635633469,
-0.07953787595033646,
-0.3234284222126007,
-0.029719285666942596,
-0.08407115191221237,
0.16726753115653992,
0.04720837250351906,
-0.39968401193618774,
0.6528629660606384,
0.3105137348175049,
-0.8457262516021729,
0.5916422605514526,
0.06022222712635994,
0.526293158531189,
-0.23999442160129547,
0.21832282841205597,
-0.5381233096122742,
0.4235030710697174,
-0.12323222309350967,
-0.3031042814254761,
0.43991991877555847,
0.285178542137146,
-0.1911676526069641,
-0.32989591360092163,
0.7878320217132568,
-0.09047041833400726,
-0.6247573494911194,
0.22290167212486267,
0.6098504662513733,
0.17082618176937103,
0.011491355486214161,
-0.5293049216270447,
0.4367695152759552,
0.15575681626796722,
-0.44602081179618835,
0.5629609823226929,
0.08217450976371765,
-0.06650373339653015,
0.8276390433311462,
0.6842595934867859,
0.3230382800102234,
0.547462522983551,
0.2796085774898529,
0.7661777138710022,
-0.4796876609325409,
-0.18149755895137787,
-0.9208871722221375,
0.15576355159282684,
-0.2156267762184143,
-0.33218562602996826,
0.8031406402587891,
0.7267488241195679,
0.9822959899902344,
-0.054833948612213135,
0.5824035406112671,
-0.05520447716116905,
0.3637748956680298,
-0.5795374512672424,
0.3617810606956482,
-0.7078885436058044,
0.5986065864562988,
-0.07746748626232147,
-1.2726224660873413,
-0.11658291518688202,
0.6942057609558105,
-0.42912667989730835,
0.06371189653873444,
0.798821210861206,
0.851729154586792,
0.05469433590769768,
-0.39332324266433716,
0.532002329826355,
0.02736825682222843,
0.39845624566078186,
0.43522483110427856,
0.8429753184318542,
-0.20043455064296722,
0.6173540353775024,
-0.2998409569263458,
0.0700870081782341,
-0.2314368039369583,
-0.6361240148544312,
-0.7660090327262878,
-0.20218002796173096,
-0.5593728423118591,
-0.43816307187080383,
-0.11615443974733353,
0.8024601340293884,
0.754555881023407,
-0.5812304615974426,
-0.39580774307250977,
0.024622075259685516,
0.2638864815235138,
-0.15446491539478302,
-0.1768830418586731,
0.04377474635839462,
-0.3980904817581177,
-0.7592196464538574,
0.3140002489089966,
0.2393641173839569,
-0.13869407773017883,
-0.3446670472621918,
-0.2779618203639984,
-0.0016216961666941643,
0.6185728311538696,
0.5802552700042725,
-0.07429875433444977,
-0.6626084446907043,
-0.4025309979915619,
0.03128443658351898,
-0.27751612663269043,
0.011146174743771553,
1.0422452688217163,
-0.6031014323234558,
-0.024695927277207375,
0.43009358644485474,
0.7211796641349792,
0.41836073994636536,
-0.07463449239730835,
0.6019994020462036,
-0.5335685014724731,
-0.073092982172966,
-0.04683782905340195,
0.3816947042942047,
0.2610868811607361,
-0.20763756334781647,
0.8739079236984253,
-0.0976160541176796,
-0.8291121125221252,
-1.3060593605041504,
0.4669344425201416,
-0.7874005436897278,
-0.548252284526825,
1.3901323080062866,
0.06556129455566406,
-0.08768103271722794,
0.3661259412765503,
-0.2389345020055771,
0.11564887315034866,
-0.3246108889579773,
0.6822047233581543,
0.7181993126869202,
-0.3074600100517273,
-0.08347593992948532,
-0.629755437374115,
0.27502936124801636,
0.5029996633529663,
-0.7633748650550842,
-0.015439216047525406,
0.6623826622962952,
0.3311542272567749,
0.27321183681488037,
0.5310659408569336,
-0.014905203133821487,
0.22091728448867798,
0.12045921385288239,
-0.13057777285575867,
-0.059390611946582794,
-0.3675692081451416,
-0.19195887446403503,
0.3320617973804474,
0.5792327523231506,
-0.045852966606616974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08666v1
|
Revealing Trends in Datasets from the 2022 ACL and EMNLP Conferences
| 2024-03-31T15:13:15 | 2024-03-31T15:13:15 |
Jesse Atuhurra, Hidetaka Kamigaito
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Natural language processing (NLP) has grown significantly since the advent of
the Transformer architecture. Transformers have given birth to pre-trained
large language models (PLMs). There has been tremendous improvement in the
performance of NLP systems across several tasks. NLP systems are on par or, in
some cases, better than humans at accomplishing specific tasks. However, it
remains the norm that \emph{better quality datasets at the time of pretraining
enable PLMs to achieve better performance, regardless of the task.} The need to
have quality datasets has prompted NLP researchers to continue creating new
datasets to satisfy particular needs. For example, the two top NLP conferences,
ACL and EMNLP, accepted ninety-two papers in 2022, introducing new datasets.
This work aims to uncover the trends and insights mined within these datasets.
Moreover, we provide valuable suggestions to researchers interested in curating
datasets in the future.
|
[
-0.4756942689418793,
-0.5205791592597961,
0.30117854475975037,
0.1381208598613739,
-0.01936260424554348,
0.1704559028148651,
-0.1613481044769287,
-0.6518421173095703,
0.0855235680937767,
0.6637125611305237,
-0.41974788904190063,
-0.5854297280311584,
-0.6738395094871521,
0.390561044216156,
-0.8734893202781677,
0.8813117742538452,
0.23606471717357635,
-0.08377084881067276,
-0.3491792380809784,
-0.31586259603500366,
-0.7146599292755127,
-0.9124607443809509,
-0.7855680584907532,
-0.483906090259552,
0.2640027701854706,
0.20254074037075043,
0.7201822400093079,
0.8513489365577698,
0.6007459759712219,
0.1972149908542633,
-0.09238864481449127,
0.1414509415626526,
-0.15500913560390472,
0.3786727786064148,
0.1245100274682045,
-0.33685216307640076,
-0.38894739747047424,
0.21755647659301758,
0.6578509211540222,
0.9051500558853149,
-0.1694878488779068,
0.10087345540523529,
0.1566765457391739,
0.7068095207214355,
-0.3253333866596222,
0.23412860929965973,
-0.7117480039596558,
0.3382716774940491,
-0.5291616320610046,
-0.367724746465683,
-0.540274441242218,
-0.2196359634399414,
0.12013684213161469,
-0.450066477060318,
0.4540129005908966,
0.1894902139902115,
0.8537206649780273,
0.36394888162612915,
-0.17038549482822418,
-0.3372526466846466,
-0.5872275829315186,
0.929073691368103,
-0.7396774888038635,
0.7022529244422913,
0.3028440773487091,
0.15074802935123444,
-0.23252548277378082,
-1.0671868324279785,
-0.3449711203575134,
0.17143136262893677,
-0.16078807413578033,
-0.25019970536231995,
-0.4468102753162384,
-0.21875402331352234,
0.1833547055721283,
0.3476378917694092,
-0.8007294535636902,
0.5051538944244385,
0.111405149102211,
0.032778676599264145,
0.7380728721618652,
0.234014093875885,
0.30383995175361633,
0.0734206959605217,
-0.035895247012376785,
-0.08761714398860931,
-0.8407738208770752,
-0.19579346477985382,
0.07784903049468994,
0.3255293369293213,
-0.006980317644774914,
0.6069369912147522,
-0.2387898713350296,
0.8089401721954346,
-0.16644544899463654,
0.31753963232040405,
0.42869842052459717,
-0.7572218179702759,
-0.12221221625804901,
0.019931979477405548,
0.7983393669128418,
0.37277284264564514,
0.362954705953598,
-0.21973933279514313,
-0.06391706317663193,
-0.13088414072990417,
0.0770379826426506,
-0.4055786430835724,
-0.6313357949256897,
0.18077316880226135,
-0.6006396412849426,
-0.08764339983463287,
-0.09182138741016388,
-1.2413429021835327,
-0.6175007820129395,
-0.7890195250511169,
-0.19671837985515594,
0.05396589636802673,
-0.09595979750156403,
0.12000681459903717,
-0.23580846190452576,
0.4627700448036194,
0.25990864634513855,
-0.9312548041343689,
0.3653239607810974,
0.8035188317298889,
0.9089163541793823,
-0.4101353883743286,
0.13810884952545166,
-0.3406364619731903,
-0.2823287844657898,
-0.45592328906059265,
0.9581390619277954,
-0.5238127112388611,
-0.11370540410280228,
0.2946839928627014,
-0.1825888454914093,
0.07897315174341202,
-0.689590573310852,
0.7835932970046997,
-0.5750638246536255,
0.25243133306503296,
-0.2662682831287384,
-0.31565847992897034,
0.20401038229465485,
0.20101287961006165,
-0.8108567595481873,
1.0421608686447144,
-0.32579106092453003,
-0.7408432960510254,
0.6407039761543274,
-0.9988598227500916,
-0.4459894001483917,
0.05257474631071091,
-0.2699703872203827,
-0.43126335740089417,
-0.1538761854171753,
0.4980839490890503,
0.39316943287849426,
-0.3651300370693207,
0.44550058245658875,
-0.12671175599098206,
-0.0856194794178009,
0.1948419064283371,
-0.4571298062801361,
0.9706129431724548,
0.37911456823349,
-0.048822492361068726,
-0.09068341553211212,
-0.8273558020591736,
-0.06949228048324585,
0.026862766593694687,
-0.21153922379016876,
-0.006340425927191973,
0.3539572060108185,
0.2428337037563324,
0.4432373642921448,
0.15507860481739044,
-0.4727270305156708,
0.020950712263584137,
-0.5505217909812927,
0.552734375,
0.5057845115661621,
0.1419515162706375,
0.4544879198074341,
-0.40069296956062317,
0.3990032970905304,
-0.09053371846675873,
0.2629121243953705,
-0.2656310200691223,
-0.7587680220603943,
-0.8930470943450928,
0.274885356426239,
0.24716128408908844,
0.2302776724100113,
-0.5474259853363037,
0.7831020355224609,
-0.24047300219535828,
-0.5127565860748291,
-0.6746487021446228,
0.128775954246521,
-0.24023233354091644,
0.36076319217681885,
0.6362748146057129,
-0.14229847490787506,
-1.0173375606536865,
-0.7363150715827942,
-0.5385953187942505,
0.1497180014848709,
-0.054639797657728195,
0.15555334091186523,
0.0754605308175087,
-0.026321876794099808,
1.2216769456863403,
-0.4611634910106659,
-0.3980158567428589,
-0.4543846547603607,
0.3714407682418823,
0.43954309821128845,
0.48864468932151794,
0.4448085129261017,
-1.007757306098938,
-0.4233558177947998,
-0.19964660704135895,
-0.6930538415908813,
-0.25324374437332153,
-0.040352463722229004,
0.13415676355361938,
0.535742461681366,
0.7517950534820557,
-0.34854504466056824,
0.3205263912677765,
0.7475826144218445,
-0.3241821229457855,
0.32921233773231506,
0.1186804473400116,
-0.10972357541322708,
-0.8396602869033813,
0.20824874937534332,
-0.030390756204724312,
-0.19101673364639282,
-0.8480323553085327,
-0.3919077515602112,
-0.4195813536643982,
-0.24486930668354034,
-0.16883304715156555,
0.5130220055580139,
-0.36221808195114136,
-0.18754328787326813,
-0.23527757823467255,
0.073837049305439,
0.05363241210579872,
-0.0036248534452170134,
0.2665107548236847,
0.5793238878250122,
0.5578688383102417,
-0.7262090444564819,
0.3629389703273773,
0.6015563607215881,
-0.4093322157859802,
0.005276412237435579,
-0.5948015451431274,
0.251067578792572,
-0.007050348445773125,
0.3785019814968109,
-0.5746243000030518,
0.0867224633693695,
0.0380551852285862,
-0.40794965624809265,
0.18783584237098694,
0.1486910581588745,
-0.814064085483551,
-0.5054856538772583,
-0.15073981881141663,
0.09258449077606201,
0.39030036330223083,
-0.6697499752044678,
0.5477418899536133,
0.6086271405220032,
-0.2577967643737793,
-0.6844434142112732,
-0.8123047947883606,
0.4971356987953186,
-0.15394066274166107,
-0.26718807220458984,
0.20779363811016083,
-0.0781986340880394,
-0.3595612347126007,
-0.13424302637577057,
0.06812087446451187,
-0.043989598751068115,
0.06357978284358978,
0.13565917313098907,
0.20963698625564575,
-0.11256913840770721,
0.1593310683965683,
-0.3599698543548584,
-0.17034058272838593,
0.22091716527938843,
-0.3020094335079193,
1.028754711151123,
0.03781014308333397,
-0.02173629403114319,
-0.5068882703781128,
0.22887906432151794,
0.010327174328267574,
-0.3732607662677765,
0.6301584243774414,
0.5330169200897217,
-0.19181564450263977,
-0.2889383137226105,
-0.5391159653663635,
-0.23925183713436127,
-0.48606398701667786,
0.1795998066663742,
0.055632755160331726,
-0.8320428729057312,
0.2894958555698395,
0.00537267979234457,
0.5831747651100159,
0.4818512201309204,
0.5124159455299377,
-0.09976546466350555,
1.016701340675354,
0.6080514192581177,
-0.025780867785215378,
0.6654570698738098,
-0.21969284117221832,
0.4704661965370178,
-0.6554344296455383,
-0.2787025272846222,
-0.988812267780304,
-0.3508952856063843,
-0.9608631134033203,
-0.2530510127544403,
-0.09992469102144241,
-0.35817644000053406,
0.04033734276890755,
0.425107479095459,
-0.4847928285598755,
0.4577590227127075,
0.640303373336792,
-0.43108853697776794,
0.5264580249786377,
-0.14071092009544373,
0.2766645848751068,
-0.06208894029259682,
-0.8227649331092834,
-0.5374518632888794,
1.359454870223999,
0.3013562262058258,
0.5205643773078918,
-0.39151957631111145,
0.5431407690048218,
0.4346102178096771,
0.15319135785102844,
-0.5492116808891296,
0.524773120880127,
-0.3776608407497406,
-0.5488710999488831,
-0.2706829905509949,
-0.41062113642692566,
-1.2753080129623413,
-0.07316972315311432,
-0.2661542296409607,
-0.4146556556224823,
0.46842190623283386,
0.058289434760808945,
-0.019588470458984375,
0.1827961653470993,
-0.33110180497169495,
0.618424654006958,
-0.023515136912465096,
0.10778962820768356,
0.0749669298529625,
-0.7434704899787903,
-0.04627443104982376,
-0.09706012159585953,
0.14821437001228333,
-0.3969637155532837,
0.1310814619064331,
1.0376964807510376,
0.11923182755708694,
0.4836951196193695,
-0.058993276208639145,
-0.05312959477305412,
0.2793900966644287,
-0.41778382658958435,
0.42077478766441345,
0.017211342230439186,
-0.3459823727607727,
0.2533348500728607,
-0.13239865005016327,
-0.23901435732841492,
-0.37626075744628906,
0.6632289886474609,
-0.5119370222091675,
-0.26718536019325256,
-0.438289076089859,
-0.4440494179725647,
-0.37413811683654785,
0.027394041419029236,
0.2722909450531006,
0.6716402769088745,
-0.23666635155677795,
0.42161452770233154,
0.5923959612846375,
-0.329894095659256,
0.9044774770736694,
0.3341677486896515,
-0.11679773032665253,
-0.13413840532302856,
0.6235966086387634,
0.2989586889743805,
0.09381990134716034,
0.34269168972969055,
-0.06694276630878448,
-0.41522374749183655,
-0.7215237617492676,
-0.012172872200608253,
-0.030689662322402,
-0.5316774845123291,
-0.5112670660018921,
-0.7617806196212769,
-0.41686075925827026,
-0.66506427526474,
-0.06599225848913193,
-0.30337852239608765,
-0.46962520480155945,
-0.39096152782440186,
-0.005467935930937529,
0.16129033267498016,
0.8395214676856995,
-0.10483621060848236,
0.10282332450151443,
-0.5710194706916809,
0.3124833405017853,
0.10114606469869614,
0.4452301859855652,
-0.06508319079875946,
-0.38260725140571594,
-0.2892589867115021,
0.0159896407276392,
-0.421162873506546,
-0.3216729164123535,
0.847938597202301,
0.48046937584877014,
0.4918701946735382,
0.2578311860561371,
0.04905077815055847,
0.32412517070770264,
-0.42843809723854065,
0.9755560159683228,
-0.032383013516664505,
-0.6799986958503723,
0.7070661783218384,
-0.2938161790370941,
0.3709709346294403,
0.618906557559967,
0.46455541253089905,
-0.9210600852966309,
-0.4098212718963623,
-0.837577760219574,
-0.9247843027114868,
0.774480402469635,
0.14366163313388824,
0.1359310895204544,
0.1516055166721344,
0.24839664995670319,
0.26032912731170654,
0.407240092754364,
-0.6421180963516235,
-0.6094978451728821,
-0.16168919205665588,
-0.3200611472129822,
-0.1115117222070694,
0.09494826197624207,
0.002687901956960559,
-0.23794187605381012,
0.5266914367675781,
-0.12802155315876007,
0.46927037835121155,
-0.15099476277828217,
0.1424071043729782,
-0.0691302940249443,
0.31066617369651794,
0.21905721724033356,
0.866995632648468,
-0.20748461782932281,
0.25222426652908325,
0.08480604737997055,
-0.4619618058204651,
-0.08455288410186768,
0.1760159283876419,
-0.23785926401615143,
0.28117039799690247,
0.456630676984787,
0.5485790371894836,
-0.07239548116922379,
-0.7244609594345093,
0.3432275354862213,
-0.1293753683567047,
-0.1407664716243744,
-0.4407919645309448,
0.06593893468379974,
-0.2238687127828598,
-0.06009931117296219,
0.5414218306541443,
0.20399980247020721,
0.27520614862442017,
-0.6644852757453918,
0.4170224368572235,
0.1536068469285965,
-0.37307631969451904,
-0.40835967659950256,
0.3693627417087555,
0.16323700547218323,
-0.23729941248893738,
0.9230527281761169,
0.15242932736873627,
-0.2342601865530014,
0.3897596597671509,
0.49837207794189453,
0.7017495632171631,
-0.004868487827479839,
0.11574030667543411,
0.31731924414634705,
0.15188512206077576,
0.003380976151674986,
0.07339745759963989,
0.23066698014736176,
-1.0265007019042969,
-0.6000030040740967,
-0.7791468501091003,
-0.3101067543029785,
0.5444265007972717,
-0.6951977014541626,
0.48789048194885254,
-0.21161265671253204,
-0.08946605026721954,
0.0540265291929245,
0.3463857173919678,
-0.9404914379119873,
0.2657182216644287,
0.3110601305961609,
0.9843476414680481,
-0.9447540044784546,
0.826407253742218,
0.5111536383628845,
-0.07008485496044159,
-0.34145721793174744,
-0.17040321230888367,
0.11206303536891937,
-0.5894994139671326,
0.5160773396492004,
0.1529390960931778,
0.47332191467285156,
0.12833234667778015,
-0.7815582156181335,
-0.916208028793335,
0.9191089272499084,
0.02465173229575157,
-0.5988197326660156,
-0.261478066444397,
0.6038328409194946,
0.6628163456916809,
-0.44092145562171936,
-0.18070396780967712,
0.9861267805099487,
0.6329725384712219,
-0.2080557644367218,
-0.7780292630195618,
-0.35074013471603394,
-0.18087558448314667,
-0.14068523049354553,
0.49939724802970886,
-0.22650375962257385,
0.6125140190124512,
0.1747189313173294,
-0.39782556891441345,
-0.009099287912249565,
0.8087818026542664,
0.2980712950229645,
0.4548095762729645,
0.2996211647987366,
0.5531166791915894,
0.6993691325187683,
-0.5777847766876221,
0.8374007344245911,
-0.03085034154355526,
0.08135763555765152,
1.2719393968582153,
-0.24125297367572784,
1.0233724117279053,
0.4070085287094116,
-0.2299308329820633,
0.3199186623096466,
0.5059555768966675,
-0.45021796226501465,
0.2755121886730194,
0.02525387704372406,
0.0677841529250145,
-0.1846182942390442,
-0.5657291412353516,
-0.4161202907562256,
0.6653075218200684,
0.49761876463890076,
-0.45306074619293213,
-0.3798648715019226,
0.3449932038784027,
0.052751246839761734,
0.12639662623405457,
-0.176022469997406,
1.0927895307540894,
0.08055748790502548,
-0.5268933176994324,
0.03642575442790985,
-0.2667277157306671,
0.7955113053321838,
-0.37798044085502625,
-0.15163654088974,
-0.2672111392021179,
-0.06980551779270172,
-0.07157210260629654,
-1.1256378889083862,
0.5358755588531494,
-0.03561771661043167,
-0.014792297966778278,
-0.755357563495636,
0.7439911961555481,
-0.454332172870636,
-0.16786344349384308,
0.2223731130361557,
0.4861783981323242,
0.08386041969060898,
0.03629662096500397,
-0.6659536957740784,
0.07957614213228226,
-0.25077107548713684,
-0.07781095057725906,
0.3428764045238495,
0.3824273645877838,
0.1964825987815857,
0.6742039918899536,
0.6774445176124573,
0.25450214743614197,
0.30421528220176697,
0.21393434703350067,
0.8911430835723877,
-0.5076133012771606,
-0.1686258316040039,
-0.6012795567512512,
0.1734647899866104,
-0.21843492984771729,
-0.4585943818092346,
0.8218080401420593,
0.7313175797462463,
0.6810416579246521,
0.15419214963912964,
0.6377851963043213,
-0.2800253629684448,
0.7320080995559692,
-0.5503907799720764,
0.6395869255065918,
-0.1518525928258896,
0.1384948045015335,
0.12799593806266785,
-0.7846987843513489,
-0.5994375348091125,
0.25550350546836853,
-0.16163834929466248,
0.05813250690698624,
0.4018633961677551,
0.5432369112968445,
0.4138515293598175,
0.41544604301452637,
0.08405563235282898,
0.16597779095172882,
0.7581415772438049,
-0.00036676382296718657,
0.7385892271995544,
-0.5704836249351501,
0.39878907799720764,
-0.2627011239528656,
0.2045857459306717,
-0.25660109519958496,
-0.9729295969009399,
-0.5821865200996399,
-0.880894124507904,
-0.4052533507347107,
0.012010003440082073,
0.09044155478477478,
0.9914605617523193,
0.4638146162033081,
-1.2301836013793945,
-0.08519569039344788,
-0.508633553981781,
-0.07977904379367828,
-0.26776474714279175,
-0.30237987637519836,
0.4162205159664154,
-0.7629592418670654,
-0.6961883306503296,
0.4922334849834442,
0.07689963281154633,
0.07335969805717468,
0.028971727937459946,
0.29703375697135925,
-0.6535382866859436,
0.00723237032070756,
0.6424896121025085,
0.3130800724029541,
-0.4855945408344269,
-0.0983891710639,
-0.00868830643594265,
0.16420364379882812,
0.3549407720565796,
0.8684087991714478,
-0.9050387144088745,
0.3320191204547882,
0.6401405334472656,
0.5765026807785034,
0.19912342727184296,
0.09391520917415619,
0.9047437310218811,
-0.9471431970596313,
-0.15561068058013916,
0.6688765287399292,
0.17932827770709991,
0.4857960641384125,
-0.042397696524858475,
0.7448976039886475,
0.013950386084616184,
-0.8987427353858948,
-0.9574697613716125,
-0.1736723780632019,
-0.8435612320899963,
-0.09026560187339783,
0.9919191002845764,
0.23981554806232452,
0.20302824676036835,
-0.796834409236908,
0.128557488322258,
0.18657030165195465,
-0.28867459297180176,
0.6665101647377014,
0.6693834066390991,
-0.5324773192405701,
-0.21781393885612488,
-0.7846740484237671,
1.0782103538513184,
0.3326045870780945,
-1.2226364612579346,
0.40593692660331726,
0.14913080632686615,
-0.3269398808479309,
0.33892878890037537,
0.19413399696350098,
-0.3177669644355774,
0.003018277697265148,
-0.21223028004169464,
-0.025805409997701645,
0.14545343816280365,
-0.6920090913772583,
-0.3667554259300232,
0.2760840356349945,
0.12940141558647156,
0.16062192618846893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00699v1
|
How Much are LLMs Contaminated? A Comprehensive Survey and the LLMSanitize Library
| 2024-03-31T14:32:02 | 2024-03-31T14:32:02 |
Mathieu Ravaut, Bosheng Ding, Fangkai Jiao, Hailin Chen, Xingxuan Li, Ruochen Zhao, Chengwei Qin, Caiming Xiong, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) in recent years, new
opportunities are emerging, but also new challenges, and contamination is
quickly becoming critical. Business applications and fundraising in AI have
reached a scale at which a few percentage points gained on popular
question-answering benchmarks could translate into dozens of millions of
dollars, placing high pressure on model integrity. At the same time, it is
becoming harder and harder to keep track of the data that LLMs have seen; if
not impossible with closed-source models like GPT-4 and Claude-3 not divulging
any information on the training set. As a result, contamination becomes a
critical issue: LLMs' performance may not be reliable anymore, as the high
performance may be at least partly due to their previous exposure to the data.
This limitation jeopardizes the entire progress in the field of NLP, yet, there
remains a lack of methods on how to efficiently address contamination, or a
clear consensus on prevention, mitigation and classification of contamination.
In this paper, we survey all recent work on contamination with LLMs, and help
the community track contamination levels of LLMs by releasing an open-source
Python library named LLMSanitize implementing major contamination detection
algorithms, which link is: https://github.com/ntunlp/LLMSanitize.
|
[
-0.24624039232730865,
-0.539731502532959,
0.7048125267028809,
-0.12828898429870605,
-0.12811574339866638,
-0.09861226379871368,
-0.06417019665241241,
-0.8007111549377441,
-0.048839569091796875,
0.9271872043609619,
-0.3144552409648895,
-0.41083669662475586,
-0.886346161365509,
0.05521884560585022,
-0.6916798949241638,
1.0867109298706055,
0.14326748251914978,
-0.3452269434928894,
-0.39490067958831787,
0.03771675005555153,
-0.07331222295761108,
-0.6198975443840027,
-0.6095290184020996,
-0.4705367088317871,
0.7203817963600159,
0.3346809446811676,
0.4754025340080261,
0.7918264865875244,
0.638146698474884,
0.38002240657806396,
-0.5937960147857666,
-0.04436502233147621,
-0.4135012924671173,
0.393938809633255,
-0.43169230222702026,
-0.7293205261230469,
-0.33263710141181946,
-0.0129800820723176,
0.3286631107330322,
0.6327974796295166,
-0.17627328634262085,
0.3552185595035553,
0.24322916567325592,
0.6270580291748047,
-0.6863627433776855,
-0.034152451902627945,
-0.7867060303688049,
-0.11903542280197144,
-0.41899293661117554,
-0.20293910801410675,
-0.1849638819694519,
-0.19838881492614746,
-0.03761295601725578,
-0.4929814040660858,
-0.1678653210401535,
-0.28343766927719116,
0.7489970922470093,
0.6015932559967041,
-0.34937211871147156,
-0.1552429050207138,
-0.7296305298805237,
1.011545181274414,
-0.8055859208106995,
-0.15901094675064087,
0.6349887847900391,
-0.011367610655725002,
-0.27312344312667847,
-0.8958494663238525,
-0.1500331610441208,
-0.16513872146606445,
0.3151777684688568,
-0.1994275450706482,
-0.3651297092437744,
-0.1342974752187729,
0.13714848458766937,
0.30211958289146423,
-0.4308607280254364,
0.24935972690582275,
-0.1503373682498932,
-0.341106116771698,
0.6018916368484497,
0.1289929747581482,
0.6408579349517822,
-0.21487267315387726,
-0.5724434852600098,
0.10830558091402054,
-1.1287295818328857,
-0.27323535084724426,
0.30996283888816833,
0.024168170988559723,
0.16426731646060944,
0.741278350353241,
-0.1902625411748886,
0.4652901887893677,
-0.5553717613220215,
-0.010008640587329865,
-0.0017476017819717526,
-0.6861759424209595,
-0.2691710889339447,
-0.10214629024267197,
0.7390803098678589,
0.24673476815223694,
0.4422267973423004,
-0.14179278910160065,
-0.1825215369462967,
-0.06922261416912079,
0.18546457588672638,
-0.7688979506492615,
-0.24629360437393188,
0.4380342662334442,
-0.08660051226615906,
-0.4609120488166809,
-0.36223500967025757,
-0.47772279381752014,
-0.8107813596725464,
-0.2951194643974304,
0.4150420129299164,
0.06085857376456261,
-0.37464991211891174,
0.11964599788188934,
0.06696473062038422,
-0.2580612599849701,
0.471270889043808,
-0.8264478445053101,
-0.03112494759261608,
0.9370039105415344,
0.7571543455123901,
-0.0697830393910408,
-0.004002559930086136,
-0.3258821964263916,
0.03144083544611931,
-0.035379428416490555,
0.8543938994407654,
-0.18793609738349915,
-0.30786189436912537,
0.10952898114919662,
-0.14074575901031494,
0.24968993663787842,
-1.009769320487976,
0.5406028628349304,
-0.34069934487342834,
-0.04226403683423996,
-0.13147184252738953,
-0.5055758357048035,
-0.040009837597608566,
0.4166240096092224,
-0.6852890849113464,
0.8825414180755615,
-0.08496622741222382,
-1.0024421215057373,
0.03243895620107651,
-0.16695371270179749,
-0.09117922931909561,
0.31825292110443115,
0.007310406304895878,
-0.2716377079486847,
-0.13621945679187775,
0.10775990039110184,
0.3864266574382782,
-0.23742416501045227,
0.443246066570282,
-0.34189075231552124,
-0.40981024503707886,
0.40074557065963745,
-0.7237765192985535,
1.1124992370605469,
0.2718368172645569,
-0.2248389720916748,
0.13962121307849884,
-0.6664451360702515,
-0.005677581764757633,
-0.18224892020225525,
-0.5497510433197021,
-0.37105804681777954,
0.03261587768793106,
-0.009607948362827301,
0.2506881356239319,
0.41724637150764465,
-0.3978334665298462,
0.1481955349445343,
-0.277983158826828,
0.615148663520813,
0.9304244518280029,
0.2918630838394165,
0.2007606327533722,
-0.5186498165130615,
0.5558651685714722,
0.05944177880883217,
0.2906702160835266,
-0.13653524219989777,
-0.6024672389030457,
-0.8132156729698181,
-0.1313212513923645,
0.2659221589565277,
0.5686585903167725,
-0.7310143709182739,
0.43939054012298584,
-0.24624808132648468,
-0.6767835021018982,
-0.3854637145996094,
0.23317396640777588,
-0.0029238981660455465,
0.3261381983757019,
0.23778583109378815,
0.2184356302022934,
-0.32155758142471313,
-0.8870293498039246,
-0.38352352380752563,
-0.22491280734539032,
-0.5135690569877625,
0.3641548752784729,
0.6664824485778809,
-0.39751771092414856,
0.8141571879386902,
-0.38295140862464905,
-0.30593836307525635,
0.04039926826953888,
-0.04661876708269119,
0.09855476766824722,
0.4070667326450348,
0.21893759071826935,
-0.43006056547164917,
-0.23393085598945618,
-0.12772169709205627,
-0.7567644715309143,
-0.3626595735549927,
0.16994008421897888,
-0.19956789910793304,
-0.08892787992954254,
0.641886830329895,
-0.42963147163391113,
0.074172742664814,
0.7933703660964966,
-0.13681843876838684,
0.48196929693222046,
-0.02749887853860855,
-0.07196246832609177,
-1.086504578590393,
0.3416803479194641,
0.07764862477779388,
-0.26078954339027405,
-0.6364911794662476,
0.194724902510643,
-0.15972906351089478,
0.12427431344985962,
-0.7726756930351257,
0.359914094209671,
-0.18517948687076569,
0.21054072678089142,
-0.30529212951660156,
0.6372530460357666,
0.057762261480093,
0.05531514063477516,
-0.17076687514781952,
0.8856648802757263,
0.35101181268692017,
-0.3810792565345764,
0.47293153405189514,
0.19723515212535858,
-0.6407981514930725,
0.22844086587429047,
-0.6475046277046204,
0.06368967890739441,
0.17801018059253693,
0.15137609839439392,
-0.8005253672599792,
-0.10267559438943863,
0.36247217655181885,
-0.3018946945667267,
0.19856643676757812,
-0.3168376684188843,
-0.6609296202659607,
0.11926262825727463,
-0.23191383481025696,
0.37596142292022705,
0.15755605697631836,
-0.6201551556587219,
0.39932507276535034,
0.526265561580658,
-0.38105854392051697,
-0.8958211541175842,
-0.8988688588142395,
0.4751567542552948,
-0.31813645362854004,
-0.7089271545410156,
-0.24839380383491516,
-0.0649212971329689,
-0.5449259877204895,
0.12045367807149887,
-0.21758954226970673,
0.008252217434346676,
0.7116857171058655,
0.10289140790700912,
0.026457682251930237,
-0.0651896744966507,
0.08571363985538483,
-0.20025557279586792,
-0.05229738727211952,
0.3474508821964264,
-0.007864830084145069,
0.7524020075798035,
0.07230963557958603,
-0.5042704343795776,
-0.37947580218315125,
0.060713741928339005,
0.4550289213657379,
-0.35412150621414185,
0.5661941170692444,
0.15026013553142548,
-0.41185081005096436,
-0.15827511250972748,
-0.3747079074382782,
0.08333155512809753,
-0.5606333017349243,
0.6476800441741943,
0.20838406682014465,
-0.7346228957176208,
0.23705527186393738,
-0.14990225434303284,
-0.009025330655276775,
0.3954683840274811,
0.5177979469299316,
-0.22653746604919434,
0.44099411368370056,
0.48823627829551697,
-0.40766358375549316,
0.4089069068431854,
-0.22861869633197784,
0.08429348468780518,
-0.7723731994628906,
-0.2830379903316498,
-0.7970094680786133,
-0.1310470849275589,
-0.46784707903862,
-0.48824480175971985,
0.3413119614124298,
0.02193153277039528,
-0.17137597501277924,
0.15838651359081268,
-0.32907795906066895,
0.5697786211967468,
0.5825517773628235,
0.0830264538526535,
0.6906323432922363,
-0.16025100648403168,
0.2076595425605774,
0.11724860966205597,
-0.45714104175567627,
-0.7585039138793945,
1.0961036682128906,
0.46140334010124207,
0.8187240958213806,
0.15170782804489136,
0.950075626373291,
0.2342115342617035,
0.527725100517273,
-0.5976144075393677,
0.5809746384620667,
-0.09038953483104706,
-0.7990559935569763,
-0.34115540981292725,
-0.594165027141571,
-1.0212100744247437,
0.22467757761478424,
-0.08414831757545471,
-0.7830348610877991,
0.04628651589155197,
-0.14488485455513,
-0.02381082810461521,
0.5310834646224976,
-0.14872105419635773,
0.5566639304161072,
-0.13952843844890594,
-0.4097992181777954,
-0.08805129677057266,
-0.6034242510795593,
0.6932550072669983,
-0.3428254723548889,
0.3402113914489746,
-0.4477122128009796,
-0.12481347471475601,
0.6042878031730652,
-0.16640682518482208,
0.8425021767616272,
0.11117231100797653,
-0.600226104259491,
0.308860719203949,
0.09570550918579102,
0.450275182723999,
-0.045689161866903305,
0.04046129807829857,
0.3278312087059021,
0.13321273028850555,
-0.2652062475681305,
-0.16748042404651642,
0.6338909864425659,
-0.6564860939979553,
-0.5698930025100708,
-0.6323442459106445,
-0.5617428421974182,
-0.11460164934396744,
0.2511977255344391,
0.4181036055088043,
0.2195812463760376,
-0.031499095261096954,
0.3859802782535553,
0.9112056493759155,
-0.43653419613838196,
0.5687047243118286,
0.21700066328048706,
-0.2269212305545807,
-0.3588094413280487,
0.8983379602432251,
-0.03411982208490372,
0.5472286343574524,
0.372073233127594,
0.27167436480522156,
-0.191922128200531,
-0.6296252608299255,
-0.23952440917491913,
0.3830792307853699,
-0.6556934714317322,
-0.37535759806632996,
-0.589719831943512,
-0.3495688736438751,
-0.28140392899513245,
0.3758082091808319,
-0.28603848814964294,
-0.2945761978626251,
-0.6845293641090393,
0.0053536733612418175,
0.08384289592504501,
0.8446376919746399,
-0.06555111706256866,
0.2760368287563324,
-0.8639163970947266,
0.07083563506603241,
0.021105578169226646,
0.4094136953353882,
-0.16503101587295532,
-0.44189953804016113,
-0.32327795028686523,
0.2052471935749054,
-0.251971572637558,
-0.6932380795478821,
0.3136514723300934,
-0.09448498487472534,
0.5767608284950256,
0.6474696397781372,
0.13751079142093658,
0.23830154538154602,
-0.2720780372619629,
0.9600220918655396,
-0.10902900248765945,
-0.8461558222770691,
0.3263263702392578,
-0.51491779088974,
0.13296006619930267,
0.525295615196228,
0.4445362389087677,
-1.0404720306396484,
-0.8449327349662781,
-0.5150552988052368,
-1.0182045698165894,
0.5414212346076965,
0.10415342450141907,
0.14567673206329346,
0.10007774829864502,
0.20257319509983063,
-0.3987981081008911,
0.36197513341903687,
-0.6410743594169617,
-0.22670239210128784,
0.21248148381710052,
-0.18605290353298187,
-0.18475794792175293,
-0.6030500531196594,
-0.3549278974533081,
0.21200883388519287,
0.8014351725578308,
0.3155892789363861,
-0.28326407074928284,
-0.15911512076854706,
-0.366656631231308,
0.16790685057640076,
0.35509148240089417,
0.6899183392524719,
0.48608511686325073,
-0.089792899787426,
0.3132365047931671,
-0.16671684384346008,
-0.6942269802093506,
0.24626226723194122,
-0.23744119703769684,
-0.33013108372688293,
-0.3561498522758484,
0.5144044160842896,
0.05644488334655762,
0.05016997829079628,
-1.0248790979385376,
0.6833767294883728,
0.03953815996646881,
-0.24102558195590973,
-0.4427143633365631,
0.13477976620197296,
0.5297221541404724,
0.2920818328857422,
0.2472965568304062,
0.04020080342888832,
0.22640150785446167,
-0.5137906670570374,
0.3885631561279297,
0.29674771428108215,
0.011029071174561977,
0.16348151862621307,
0.7182812094688416,
0.2147926241159439,
-0.04033101350069046,
0.7080760598182678,
0.24552251398563385,
-0.4744339883327484,
0.6465233564376831,
0.15082713961601257,
0.6605575680732727,
-0.23596562445163727,
-0.05641024559736252,
0.03581154718995094,
0.643481433391571,
-0.15340103209018707,
0.056790608912706375,
0.13010506331920624,
-0.7546051740646362,
-0.539885401725769,
-0.5792011022567749,
-0.5245544910430908,
0.5581009387969971,
-0.6287832856178284,
0.018299339339137077,
-0.41160669922828674,
-0.14687970280647278,
-0.22724048793315887,
0.13855604827404022,
-0.16604262590408325,
-0.005216892808675766,
0.33205899596214294,
0.9329025149345398,
-1.0589033365249634,
0.553053081035614,
0.25247862935066223,
-0.4166845679283142,
-0.37641170620918274,
-0.013441537506878376,
0.10696472227573395,
-0.6492306590080261,
0.51048743724823,
0.09818919003009796,
-0.07567186653614044,
-0.10440878570079803,
-0.6059594750404358,
-1.1338517665863037,
0.7590940594673157,
0.36103853583335876,
-0.45638909935951233,
0.020722027868032455,
0.38564935326576233,
0.47932589054107666,
0.42260977625846863,
0.12723316252231598,
0.777305543422699,
0.5333580374717712,
-0.29516810178756714,
-0.6779154539108276,
-0.09246116876602173,
-0.2869897484779358,
-0.08706440031528473,
0.14545990526676178,
-0.4613555669784546,
0.5974725484848022,
0.13863974809646606,
-0.2219068855047226,
0.48293840885162354,
0.3088846802711487,
0.2503022253513336,
0.30576732754707336,
0.2928914725780487,
0.551471471786499,
0.800615131855011,
-0.2567804455757141,
0.724709689617157,
-0.22730854153633118,
0.3710741400718689,
1.197022795677185,
-0.22360065579414368,
1.0262277126312256,
0.4750783443450928,
-0.3375774621963501,
0.10945701599121094,
0.6563020348548889,
-0.2706558108329773,
0.1783934235572815,
0.5759544968605042,
-0.6205751299858093,
-0.1119336485862732,
-0.3314610421657562,
-0.12985935807228088,
0.4562109708786011,
0.39559417963027954,
-0.3674352765083313,
-0.4819107949733734,
0.05296286568045616,
0.3291358947753906,
0.04865138977766037,
-0.2064758539199829,
0.7618722319602966,
0.05807840824127197,
-0.5263884663581848,
0.43387794494628906,
-0.038956958800554276,
0.6656746864318848,
-0.39284181594848633,
0.05948197841644287,
-0.4274612069129944,
0.18754690885543823,
-0.40850263833999634,
-0.8468312621116638,
0.21097564697265625,
-0.020043043419718742,
0.0958767980337143,
-0.2849365174770355,
0.5775696635246277,
-0.49959179759025574,
-0.1720140278339386,
0.32620304822921753,
0.6137967109680176,
0.573463499546051,
-0.40045881271362305,
-0.3491659462451935,
0.27192431688308716,
0.023195352405309677,
-0.2782984972000122,
0.47536513209342957,
0.20890869200229645,
0.14269085228443146,
1.0010539293289185,
0.6630351543426514,
0.36924880743026733,
0.29609668254852295,
0.006200676783919334,
0.7618987560272217,
-0.39398548007011414,
0.05375910922884941,
-0.8550943732261658,
0.36079853773117065,
0.10789356380701065,
-0.17347995936870575,
0.5549747943878174,
0.7189108729362488,
0.6970505118370056,
0.3601979613304138,
0.7337793707847595,
0.411687970161438,
0.4246552288532257,
-0.5257957577705383,
0.878606379032135,
-0.6093403100967407,
0.6912744641304016,
-0.0622519925236702,
-0.8303395509719849,
-0.3086751699447632,
0.19921767711639404,
0.07353128492832184,
-0.05569273605942726,
0.5427796244621277,
0.6642822623252869,
0.14994485676288605,
-0.07814978063106537,
0.33645421266555786,
0.41903790831565857,
0.7283366918563843,
0.42764538526535034,
1.1035658121109009,
-0.06053880229592323,
0.7431991696357727,
-0.4538719654083252,
-0.1874820590019226,
-0.290940523147583,
-1.00455904006958,
-0.4695667028427124,
-0.2781883478164673,
-0.35164085030555725,
-0.3609688878059387,
-0.11090059578418732,
0.5711719989776611,
0.09954486787319183,
-0.5977774858474731,
-0.15210910141468048,
0.0004419976321514696,
0.13170021772384644,
-0.09139572083950043,
-0.14949040114879608,
0.3074687421321869,
-0.39527463912963867,
-0.9864922761917114,
0.39770835638046265,
-0.07376980781555176,
0.008988076820969582,
-0.35809269547462463,
0.6169992089271545,
-0.2816332280635834,
-0.018907466903328896,
0.6437870860099792,
0.20633916556835175,
-0.5066543817520142,
-0.27598974108695984,
-0.16934734582901,
-0.44417890906333923,
0.013517103157937527,
0.4542171359062195,
-0.24096457660198212,
0.14868606626987457,
0.5397224426269531,
0.8144931793212891,
0.40453094244003296,
0.07755250483751297,
0.22885644435882568,
-0.720676839351654,
-0.1423240751028061,
0.4319474399089813,
0.5458869338035583,
0.42546823620796204,
-0.5235465168952942,
0.6984875798225403,
0.15108497440814972,
-0.8858347535133362,
-1.0317507982254028,
0.2521744966506958,
-0.8320066928863525,
-0.5041859149932861,
1.4492571353912354,
-0.17388415336608887,
-0.18084347248077393,
-0.19600611925125122,
0.03549744933843613,
0.16747158765792847,
0.025063348934054375,
0.6625517010688782,
0.8863924741744995,
-0.1103789284825325,
0.0326237827539444,
-0.9307005405426025,
0.20490771532058716,
0.1944015473127365,
-0.9847580194473267,
0.3486591875553131,
0.5558568239212036,
0.8392212390899658,
0.09353388100862503,
0.5265174508094788,
-0.3281119465827942,
-0.12838320434093475,
-0.030287573114037514,
0.0711679756641388,
-0.0033611322287470102,
-0.32152238488197327,
-0.5566565990447998,
-0.0760047510266304,
0.23055000603199005,
-0.16453026235103607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00685v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00685v2
|
Scaling Properties of Speech Language Models
| 2024-03-31T13:30:12 | 2024-04-16T06:46:18 |
Santiago Cuervo, Ricard Marxer
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
Speech Language Models (SLMs) aim to learn language from raw audio, without
textual resources. Despite significant advances, our current models exhibit
weak syntax and semantic abilities. However, if the scaling properties of
neural language models hold for the speech modality, these abilities will
improve as the amount of compute used for training increases. In this paper, we
use models of this scaling behavior to estimate the scale at which our current
methods will yield a SLM with the English proficiency of text-based Large
Language Models (LLMs). We establish a strong correlation between pre-training
loss and downstream syntactic and semantic performance in SLMs and LLMs, which
results in predictable scaling of linguistic performance. We show that the
linguistic performance of SLMs scales up to three orders of magnitude more
slowly than that of text-based LLMs. Additionally, we study the benefits of
synthetic data designed to boost semantic understanding and the effects of
coarser speech tokenization.
|
[
-0.1022929921746254,
-0.5965585112571716,
0.4740975499153137,
0.04066367447376251,
-0.05040145665407181,
-0.12181743234395981,
-0.6316851377487183,
-0.5273182392120361,
0.31104692816734314,
0.48812299966812134,
-0.2446243017911911,
-0.09766082465648651,
-0.877753734588623,
-0.1564936339855194,
-0.4760996401309967,
1.0101639032363892,
0.39886993169784546,
0.4051891565322876,
-0.1808474212884903,
-0.20139272511005402,
-0.3260333836078644,
-0.6329631805419922,
-0.5943323373794556,
-0.6116164922714233,
0.6309845447540283,
-0.000050714268581941724,
0.9103724956512451,
0.9373473525047302,
0.5762543082237244,
0.3615029454231262,
-0.338623583316803,
-0.47778305411338806,
-0.4879380166530609,
0.11751808226108551,
-0.17048057913780212,
-0.8144587874412537,
-0.6283535361289978,
0.17308203876018524,
1.1156150102615356,
1.1409471035003662,
-0.07750304788351059,
0.3029429614543915,
-0.016060365363955498,
0.41699910163879395,
-0.2543529272079468,
0.1971229910850525,
-1.027569055557251,
-0.22726167738437653,
-0.013076113536953926,
-0.1638363003730774,
-0.43184971809387207,
0.06012305989861488,
0.26969242095947266,
-0.4701169729232788,
0.2574005424976349,
-0.11765219271183014,
0.7850490808486938,
0.21953654289245605,
-0.39146772027015686,
-0.2326887845993042,
-0.7230345010757446,
0.8176167607307434,
-1.012986660003662,
0.5700794458389282,
0.401827335357666,
0.12050478905439377,
0.2039150446653366,
-0.9133303165435791,
-0.3079783618450165,
-0.6402222514152527,
-0.09268295019865036,
-0.39114099740982056,
0.03518931195139885,
0.14940041303634644,
0.2279159128665924,
0.3349497318267822,
-0.38380008935928345,
0.45880571007728577,
-0.3350333273410797,
-0.3003433644771576,
0.6092110276222229,
0.32309868931770325,
0.3433685302734375,
-0.0326550267636776,
-0.2258351594209671,
-0.11670553684234619,
-0.46582233905792236,
0.010545402765274048,
0.15471169352531433,
0.8057824373245239,
-0.080619215965271,
0.6090280413627625,
0.24203678965568542,
0.6606139540672302,
-0.22142435610294342,
-0.6962958574295044,
0.29399722814559937,
-0.6115666031837463,
-0.07089483737945557,
0.03988084942102432,
0.53762286901474,
0.24183911085128784,
0.28462955355644226,
-0.2866956889629364,
-0.3041246235370636,
0.1360103338956833,
0.14611883461475372,
-0.8565642237663269,
0.06154120713472366,
-0.15442542731761932,
-0.513733983039856,
-0.0716341882944107,
-0.4540199339389801,
-0.16230177879333496,
-0.3283401429653168,
-0.6592597961425781,
0.816496729850769,
-0.41388365626335144,
-0.5008020401000977,
0.15413975715637207,
-0.037273894995450974,
0.21114012598991394,
0.26087161898612976,
-0.9666820168495178,
0.5424813032150269,
0.6205950975418091,
0.8980394005775452,
-0.19500261545181274,
-0.373701810836792,
-0.40980398654937744,
-0.12677177786827087,
-0.29092851281166077,
0.3784509003162384,
-0.4791538417339325,
-0.11477436870336533,
-0.08315624296665192,
-0.08216939121484756,
-0.1744513362646103,
-0.5686848163604736,
0.3210926651954651,
-0.39785996079444885,
-0.31246039271354675,
0.00011735465523088351,
-0.7108742594718933,
0.08139307051897049,
-0.06826193630695343,
-0.7360092401504517,
0.6793131828308105,
-0.07620731741189957,
-0.6797453165054321,
0.4604853093624115,
-0.35945063829421997,
-0.5613616704940796,
0.1312606781721115,
0.05513555556535721,
-0.2743481695652008,
0.438475638628006,
-0.16165290772914886,
0.5874916911125183,
-0.268056184053421,
0.22962938249111176,
-0.2521083652973175,
-0.29367324709892273,
0.30566489696502686,
-0.3361373543739319,
0.4601685404777527,
0.04795502871274948,
-0.07207342982292175,
0.04828145354986191,
-0.9455090165138245,
0.26432564854621887,
0.07073560357093811,
-0.3939080536365509,
-0.36197930574417114,
0.2287258803844452,
0.16183516383171082,
0.07145659625530243,
0.3762781620025635,
-0.3528493046760559,
-0.17754562199115753,
-0.6249133348464966,
0.7378823161125183,
0.6308915615081787,
-0.28523966670036316,
0.7369663119316101,
-0.13837270438671112,
0.490770548582077,
-0.11502822488546371,
-0.24883215129375458,
-0.2350742071866989,
-0.2842850685119629,
-0.7478535771369934,
-0.2502976953983307,
0.3706315755844116,
0.22330524027347565,
-0.25313010811805725,
0.3256763219833374,
-0.5522047877311707,
-0.5484131574630737,
-0.5132232904434204,
0.15339186787605286,
0.32017284631729126,
0.42835748195648193,
0.2440079301595688,
-0.1858675181865692,
-0.4394369125366211,
-0.944317638874054,
-0.5784239172935486,
-0.25274568796157837,
-0.38754802942276,
0.19707834720611572,
0.20233717560768127,
-0.023767493665218353,
0.8311397433280945,
-0.1533997654914856,
-0.2196962982416153,
-0.4820030927658081,
0.19543515145778656,
0.07567338645458221,
0.27592217922210693,
0.23101171851158142,
-0.6695368885993958,
-0.08106918632984161,
-0.031183429062366486,
-0.2763325572013855,
-0.2067422866821289,
0.01708362251520157,
0.4156207740306854,
0.1049051508307457,
0.5811929702758789,
-0.4337921440601349,
0.09395512193441391,
0.6989772915840149,
-0.32649123668670654,
0.5307773351669312,
-0.3293934762477875,
-0.2225344032049179,
-1.019845724105835,
-0.16705043613910675,
0.11737361550331116,
-0.10390421003103256,
-0.9287369847297668,
-0.16090787947177887,
0.05440075695514679,
-0.24320507049560547,
-0.5500031113624573,
0.4715600609779358,
-0.29252445697784424,
-0.4847964942455292,
-0.18931828439235687,
0.32580071687698364,
-0.08300881087779999,
0.3831923305988312,
0.23918308317661285,
0.8738138675689697,
0.4001719057559967,
-0.5470776557922363,
-0.06322182714939117,
-0.35338088870048523,
-0.20922169089317322,
0.2810821235179901,
-0.9875319600105286,
-0.10085707157850266,
-0.04782184958457947,
-0.024918675422668457,
-0.875865638256073,
-0.04357343167066574,
-0.9293611645698547,
-0.6138389110565186,
0.447424054145813,
-0.05290677770972252,
-0.4701915383338928,
-0.04107386991381645,
-0.08699347823858261,
0.3570546805858612,
0.47295108437538147,
-0.195303812623024,
0.6795742511749268,
0.5164799690246582,
-0.21852600574493408,
-0.07947240024805069,
-0.7183634638786316,
0.08356918394565582,
-0.26439738273620605,
-0.7140482068061829,
0.33403053879737854,
0.059903550893068314,
-0.3827776610851288,
-0.22014832496643066,
0.05210617184638977,
-0.11110877990722656,
0.1134418323636055,
0.16990719735622406,
0.16481800377368927,
-0.541832685470581,
0.5488983392715454,
-0.3689347803592682,
-0.009615462273359299,
0.31943950057029724,
-0.42393890023231506,
0.5794312953948975,
-0.5101199746131897,
0.04840335249900818,
-0.2925280034542084,
0.02875753864645958,
0.7369812726974487,
-0.2829720675945282,
0.9838254451751709,
0.3443773686885834,
-0.29582276940345764,
-0.17553497850894928,
-0.3982318937778473,
-0.2925090789794922,
-0.42746075987815857,
0.744776725769043,
-0.481661856174469,
-0.8959176540374756,
0.7048447728157043,
0.002200600691139698,
-0.16681711375713348,
0.6308051943778992,
0.7036521434783936,
0.039158593863248825,
1.2131847143173218,
0.7811680436134338,
0.026898426935076714,
0.4852263033390045,
-0.23405605554580688,
0.11100130528211594,
-0.6951673626899719,
-0.18187497556209564,
-0.7026922106742859,
-0.30905279517173767,
-0.821924090385437,
-0.48862937092781067,
0.3464001715183258,
-0.004421338438987732,
-0.22656095027923584,
0.3840448558330536,
-0.17207138240337372,
0.35353317856788635,
0.42062729597091675,
-0.001704132417216897,
0.28932976722717285,
-0.0515439547598362,
-0.0002219491288997233,
-0.4305327832698822,
-0.6321174502372742,
-0.4718867242336273,
1.1122568845748901,
0.6674427390098572,
0.8533721566200256,
-0.12154623121023178,
0.22379285097122192,
0.1864495426416397,
0.048886530101299286,
-0.977201521396637,
0.4856909215450287,
-0.16611970961093903,
-0.42589902877807617,
-0.6430454850196838,
-0.6224779486656189,
-0.7780415415763855,
0.28925439715385437,
-0.3224259316921234,
-0.40452706813812256,
-0.26036858558654785,
-0.0331522598862648,
0.06245090439915657,
0.283374160528183,
-0.9516484141349792,
0.5269956588745117,
-0.14702196419239044,
-0.24884898960590363,
-0.37444040179252625,
-0.6427686214447021,
-0.005708849988877773,
-0.26341739296913147,
0.2893015146255493,
-0.21057811379432678,
-0.46700406074523926,
0.8807539343833923,
-0.49308979511260986,
0.6961637139320374,
-0.06356248259544373,
-0.13898593187332153,
0.029867419973015785,
0.03283781558275223,
0.2895049750804901,
-0.06136789917945862,
-0.09482347965240479,
0.28544265031814575,
-0.12679147720336914,
-0.5358211398124695,
-0.649416983127594,
0.7062639594078064,
-0.9028609395027161,
-0.42611777782440186,
0.010260348208248615,
-0.7996387481689453,
-0.3840356469154358,
0.17059265077114105,
0.0968296229839325,
0.5281561017036438,
0.028763195499777794,
0.2108745276927948,
0.5749808549880981,
-0.03723412752151489,
0.5415002107620239,
0.5194531679153442,
-0.1601831614971161,
-0.2508363723754883,
0.8071361780166626,
0.626030445098877,
0.845661461353302,
0.18342870473861694,
0.3210357129573822,
-0.3941795229911804,
-0.7869688868522644,
-0.1283925324678421,
0.4133860766887665,
-0.6103482842445374,
0.0023988336324691772,
-0.46291080117225647,
-0.3694886565208435,
-0.4706542193889618,
-0.07010922580957413,
-0.5075154900550842,
-0.7465314865112305,
-0.2390047162771225,
-0.237098827958107,
0.3058689534664154,
0.7505150437355042,
0.040721140801906586,
0.3806551694869995,
-0.5172237157821655,
-0.039845164865255356,
0.25364455580711365,
0.3351587951183319,
-0.05948720499873161,
-1.1542843580245972,
-0.4507521092891693,
0.09933719784021378,
0.06360630691051483,
-0.49419260025024414,
0.5350330471992493,
0.5432204604148865,
0.3382587134838104,
0.2381439357995987,
-0.39772865176200867,
0.4783914089202881,
-0.7675544023513794,
0.8201988935470581,
0.2747029960155487,
-0.948176920413971,
0.5495513081550598,
-0.4294299781322479,
0.5457074046134949,
0.3210647404193878,
0.366104394197464,
-0.28734952211380005,
-0.5541313886642456,
-0.6179861426353455,
-0.7301223874092102,
0.5460696816444397,
0.13183815777301788,
0.5514200329780579,
0.062049850821495056,
0.35647982358932495,
-0.10927340388298035,
0.012956402264535427,
-0.8183167576789856,
-0.13432464003562927,
-0.0907694548368454,
0.029352648183703423,
-0.5348599553108215,
-0.2732574939727783,
0.21509070694446564,
-0.41092610359191895,
0.4519694447517395,
-0.09242834895849228,
0.05928892642259598,
-0.09701507538557053,
-0.163423091173172,
0.17299865186214447,
0.19316045939922333,
0.6689798831939697,
0.7307959794998169,
-0.10940475016832352,
0.4564076066017151,
0.3612506687641144,
-0.5853485465049744,
0.266935795545578,
-0.176309734582901,
0.08736643195152283,
-0.012536834925413132,
0.7457759976387024,
0.9929174780845642,
0.403217613697052,
-0.7609850168228149,
0.44204333424568176,
0.05813685059547424,
-0.20914217829704285,
-0.19411827623844147,
0.014728802256286144,
0.42075732350349426,
-0.018835660070180893,
0.34740328788757324,
-0.02249475009739399,
-0.0239032581448555,
-0.5004797577857971,
0.27985355257987976,
0.321294367313385,
-0.3065304160118103,
-0.46656519174575806,
0.6182560920715332,
0.05911842733621597,
-0.6193444132804871,
0.43942344188690186,
0.18883627653121948,
-0.35516905784606934,
0.7112956047058105,
0.7781492471694946,
0.5581691861152649,
-0.3354971706867218,
-0.07419613748788834,
0.3256494998931885,
0.376251757144928,
0.0843634381890297,
-0.19799618422985077,
0.05520418658852577,
-0.6598272919654846,
-0.6653985977172852,
-0.9631150364875793,
-0.157796248793602,
0.15362195670604706,
-0.7158490419387817,
0.36822599172592163,
-0.4425252079963684,
-0.510215163230896,
0.33393120765686035,
0.1299300193786621,
-0.5771359801292419,
0.2627688944339752,
0.14246277511119843,
0.8264967799186707,
-0.877190113067627,
0.8876661062240601,
0.5078513622283936,
-0.3429863452911377,
-1.0402188301086426,
-0.2333468347787857,
-0.19827774167060852,
-0.805565595626831,
0.9131372570991516,
0.19619177281856537,
-0.1825694590806961,
0.06773524731397629,
-0.1754055768251419,
-1.0837745666503906,
0.8178966045379639,
0.6935943365097046,
-0.5119814276695251,
-0.3175252079963684,
0.5046465992927551,
0.9061633348464966,
-0.5746353268623352,
0.3315361738204956,
0.680120050907135,
-0.03994714468717575,
0.15794460475444794,
-1.290448546409607,
-0.22753536701202393,
0.04351148009300232,
0.4883444607257843,
0.23783403635025024,
-0.2663445770740509,
0.9629838466644287,
-0.33857178688049316,
-0.0012943672481924295,
-0.24843350052833557,
0.7509645819664001,
-0.2380034625530243,
0.036515433341264725,
0.5182549357414246,
0.6494919061660767,
0.6195681095123291,
0.08384246379137039,
0.9003880023956299,
-0.3389361500740051,
0.286092072725296,
1.1677082777023315,
-0.1850252002477646,
1.1715340614318848,
0.4627280831336975,
-0.3750024139881134,
0.3547761142253876,
0.3130260705947876,
0.3626636862754822,
0.21093474328517914,
0.42616114020347595,
-0.2709504961967468,
-0.15685054659843445,
-0.28968119621276855,
-0.2081933468580246,
0.6093278527259827,
0.5381914377212524,
-0.607499361038208,
-0.053294587880373,
0.3339994549751282,
0.1406901329755783,
0.3790416717529297,
-0.6739622950553894,
0.7921254634857178,
0.03322688862681389,
-0.2798211872577667,
0.9115676283836365,
-0.08942991495132446,
0.6284828782081604,
-0.6554745435714722,
0.32583993673324585,
-0.10739810764789581,
0.05641014128923416,
-0.022004464641213417,
-0.47507527470588684,
0.47566384077072144,
-0.2134992480278015,
-0.4186252951622009,
-0.22310908138751984,
0.6710034012794495,
-0.5574063062667847,
-0.5903480052947998,
0.516177237033844,
0.28726857900619507,
0.347942590713501,
0.22731761634349823,
-0.42815467715263367,
0.2194821685552597,
-0.4138735234737396,
-0.22112613916397095,
0.631604015827179,
0.2792067527770996,
0.09915488958358765,
0.6572990417480469,
0.49880433082580566,
0.6075888872146606,
0.45277202129364014,
0.2559540271759033,
0.6404774785041809,
-0.39505475759506226,
-0.20924629271030426,
-0.7259620428085327,
0.15281632542610168,
-0.027641424909234047,
-0.08934275805950165,
0.6427904963493347,
0.4562545418739319,
0.8416604399681091,
0.11209821701049805,
0.3915327489376068,
0.21989428997039795,
0.5618045926094055,
-0.5613464117050171,
0.7153815031051636,
-0.5193029642105103,
0.2543630301952362,
0.02583075687289238,
-0.7943717837333679,
-0.20322372019290924,
0.46320223808288574,
-0.26132380962371826,
0.15452837944030762,
0.5826545357704163,
0.9032771587371826,
0.19122838973999023,
-0.226743683218956,
0.7185275554656982,
0.44926249980926514,
0.06431268900632858,
0.3121182918548584,
0.35221242904663086,
-0.26816314458847046,
0.41495639085769653,
0.02261606603860855,
-0.24097135663032532,
0.08641216158866882,
-0.7109083533287048,
-0.9038883447647095,
-0.7323874235153198,
-0.10877130925655365,
-0.3743263781070709,
-0.19776266813278198,
0.6379685997962952,
0.9162262678146362,
-0.3810213804244995,
-0.41358938813209534,
-0.15850912034511566,
-0.1679335981607437,
0.028649237006902695,
-0.22435344755649567,
0.22281090915203094,
-0.8065798282623291,
-0.6105031371116638,
0.3492497205734253,
0.16999240219593048,
0.07949059456586838,
-0.5906671285629272,
-0.11529956012964249,
-0.003528994508087635,
0.4957326650619507,
0.7522912621498108,
-0.007223957683891058,
-0.8088158369064331,
-0.2296895682811737,
0.07421305775642395,
-0.2488691508769989,
-0.059941019862890244,
0.8927900791168213,
-0.7226606011390686,
0.3377130329608917,
0.43476614356040955,
0.6675962805747986,
0.4705251157283783,
-0.39644497632980347,
0.6063258647918701,
-0.7282218933105469,
0.36080771684646606,
0.32737505435943604,
0.2838773727416992,
0.2865653932094574,
-0.0840168297290802,
0.21504893898963928,
0.19132991135120392,
-0.5622421503067017,
-0.89349365234375,
0.08997827023267746,
-0.6597763895988464,
-0.12498430162668228,
1.151236653327942,
-0.07802406698465347,
-0.20422564446926117,
0.26357555389404297,
0.11117668449878693,
0.058880407363176346,
-0.003878870280459523,
0.29965221881866455,
0.7765635848045349,
-0.0014724471839144826,
-0.11872079968452454,
-0.5984962582588196,
0.6050529479980469,
0.7327755689620972,
-0.5033057332038879,
0.3316039741039276,
0.32027924060821533,
0.2516004145145416,
0.19592715799808502,
0.5670866966247559,
-0.1581956148147583,
-0.06334540247917175,
0.1858111172914505,
-0.0365900844335556,
0.27214866876602173,
-0.3550543487071991,
-0.7043100595474243,
0.16829991340637207,
0.47880473732948303,
0.2683134973049164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00681v1
|
CoUDA: Coherence Evaluation via Unified Data Augmentation
| 2024-03-31T13:19:36 | 2024-03-31T13:19:36 |
Dawei Zhu, Wenhao Wu, Yifan Song, Fangwei Zhu, Ziqiang Cao, Sujian Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Coherence evaluation aims to assess the organization and structure of a
discourse, which remains challenging even in the era of large language models.
Due to the scarcity of annotated data, data augmentation is commonly used for
training coherence evaluation models. However, previous augmentations for this
task primarily rely on heuristic rules, lacking designing criteria as guidance.
In this paper, we take inspiration from linguistic theory of discourse
structure, and propose a data augmentation framework named CoUDA. CoUDA breaks
down discourse coherence into global and local aspects, and designs
augmentation strategies for both aspects, respectively. Especially for local
coherence, we propose a novel generative strategy for constructing augmentation
samples, which involves post-pretraining a generative model and applying two
controlling mechanisms to control the difficulty of generated samples. During
inference, CoUDA also jointly evaluates both global and local aspects to
comprehensively assess the overall coherence of a discourse. Extensive
experiments in coherence evaluation show that, with only 233M parameters, CoUDA
achieves state-of-the-art performance in both pointwise scoring and pairwise
ranking tasks, even surpassing recent GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 based metrics.
|
[
-0.5577126145362854,
-0.9588331580162048,
0.3296210467815399,
0.20444832742214203,
-0.6032938957214355,
0.25787970423698425,
-0.1231050193309784,
-0.6423580050468445,
0.34865525364875793,
0.1566755324602127,
-0.42938432097435,
-0.6132915616035461,
-0.2971307039260864,
-0.10376258194446564,
-0.30545666813850403,
0.9084056615829468,
0.10854333639144897,
0.11164479702711105,
-0.4966687262058258,
-0.23735924065113068,
-0.6319792866706848,
-0.4219852685928345,
-0.5601741075515747,
-0.33005407452583313,
0.12807923555374146,
0.29778414964675903,
0.6170278787612915,
0.17325641214847565,
0.39551177620887756,
0.28789421916007996,
-0.23711372911930084,
0.25811681151390076,
-0.5781893730163574,
0.23404699563980103,
-0.22649997472763062,
-0.4127464294433594,
-0.746005117893219,
-0.13947536051273346,
0.5474483966827393,
1.0548014640808105,
-0.19614353775978088,
0.0767325758934021,
0.3214482069015503,
0.38631197810173035,
-0.7445086240768433,
0.21782343089580536,
-0.4510711431503296,
0.12419535219669342,
-0.25110042095184326,
-0.18386390805244446,
-0.30622509121894836,
-0.4324462115764618,
0.37759968638420105,
-0.716891884803772,
0.34419822692871094,
0.1556733399629593,
0.8093332648277283,
0.08977337926626205,
-0.18277601897716522,
-0.15420712530612946,
-0.51610267162323,
0.7147977948188782,
-0.25276684761047363,
0.4031391143798828,
0.2533784508705139,
0.24587643146514893,
-0.17310312390327454,
-0.5741868019104004,
-0.3965716063976288,
-0.20953547954559326,
-0.08362530171871185,
0.47924402356147766,
-0.2257917821407318,
0.1946500986814499,
-0.09480234980583191,
0.8576955795288086,
-0.48273125290870667,
0.05129548907279968,
-0.2119712382555008,
-0.3824421763420105,
0.48455503582954407,
0.03157612308859825,
0.2728944420814514,
-0.2920669913291931,
-0.5959294438362122,
-0.04292925447225571,
-0.6904735565185547,
-0.0006054450059309602,
0.4398185610771179,
0.10351040959358215,
-0.22112397849559784,
0.274074912071228,
-0.16086259484291077,
0.8458133935928345,
0.2762400805950165,
0.14983953535556793,
0.09361778199672699,
-0.46330684423446655,
-0.255108505487442,
0.20103640854358673,
0.7469534277915955,
-0.03948308154940605,
-0.5742180943489075,
-0.22465988993644714,
0.12833832204341888,
0.1685905158519745,
0.3450459837913513,
-0.6618558168411255,
-0.22106945514678955,
0.1336391568183899,
-0.17929451167583466,
-0.27572017908096313,
0.08361703902482986,
-0.7285233736038208,
-0.09378588944673538,
-0.3129401206970215,
0.4789130389690399,
-0.5935375690460205,
-0.11045682430267334,
0.07923930138349533,
0.14267274737358093,
0.2097768783569336,
0.44866910576820374,
-0.8253641128540039,
0.6763737797737122,
0.9766697883605957,
0.8250978589057922,
-0.4926646053791046,
-0.08584385365247726,
-0.5487777590751648,
0.007534460164606571,
-0.3775084912776947,
0.9149575233459473,
-0.6085112690925598,
-0.27209538221359253,
-0.3858586251735687,
-0.22272032499313354,
0.04899787902832031,
-0.31570354104042053,
0.9854947328567505,
-0.7132323384284973,
0.638661801815033,
-0.20370902121067047,
-0.7491632103919983,
-0.5158103704452515,
0.18289215862751007,
-0.7857404947280884,
0.8716326951980591,
0.2659626603126526,
-0.7781499624252319,
0.5846512913703918,
-0.766826868057251,
-0.6311220526695251,
0.31961971521377563,
-0.24733519554138184,
-0.6473514437675476,
0.23884190618991852,
0.4166724681854248,
0.11948323249816895,
-0.5446521639823914,
0.7272771596908569,
-0.3144780397415161,
-0.7124101519584656,
-0.19751043617725372,
-0.6688575148582458,
1.0560064315795898,
-0.02104293182492256,
-0.15771202743053436,
0.1934133768081665,
-0.8054434061050415,
0.001086037722416222,
-0.372351735830307,
-0.25306010246276855,
-0.5839766263961792,
-0.23918046057224274,
-0.3007771074771881,
-0.1857685148715973,
0.0999208316206932,
-0.5461243987083435,
-0.14120112359523773,
-0.8370193839073181,
0.06422314792871475,
0.4738348126411438,
0.2671675384044647,
0.6165348887443542,
-0.12531881034374237,
0.4645613431930542,
-0.09506185352802277,
0.1867065727710724,
-0.3234389126300812,
-0.48638445138931274,
-0.8072766065597534,
-0.5371949076652527,
0.44994786381721497,
0.3307725787162781,
-0.7308449745178223,
0.8663210272789001,
-0.505840539932251,
-0.5839443206787109,
-0.8588781952857971,
-0.17785657942295074,
0.4069439470767975,
0.7389373183250427,
0.6056528687477112,
-0.7899865508079529,
-0.8153809905052185,
-0.739762544631958,
0.12382467091083527,
-0.024905214086174965,
-0.0003920911403838545,
0.027907000854611397,
0.45387503504753113,
0.2255428284406662,
0.8067178726196289,
-0.38404789566993713,
-0.1113191619515419,
0.012018808163702488,
0.28481537103652954,
0.13326211273670197,
0.4308837950229645,
0.13649408519268036,
-0.5586602687835693,
-0.20595122873783112,
-0.10347500443458557,
-0.8733174204826355,
0.03461781516671181,
0.03183465451002121,
-0.1923801749944687,
0.07702475786209106,
0.15534955263137817,
-0.190286323428154,
0.38980382680892944,
0.484789103269577,
-0.18617665767669678,
0.3459285795688629,
-0.4732142388820648,
0.28701579570770264,
-1.0753997564315796,
-0.010973193682730198,
-0.31112924218177795,
-0.26568928360939026,
-0.5149962902069092,
0.40015777945518494,
-0.17923195660114288,
0.010209805332124233,
-0.2815539538860321,
0.29184940457344055,
-0.5828271508216858,
-0.17230330407619476,
-0.07995156943798065,
0.10646971315145493,
0.5320767164230347,
0.4961639940738678,
-0.2059890627861023,
0.630420982837677,
0.6743023991584778,
-0.45156773924827576,
0.4419611096382141,
0.3266609311103821,
-0.7990713715553284,
1.165459394454956,
-0.8025528192520142,
0.33987337350845337,
-0.08489705622196198,
0.3143092393875122,
-1.0494496822357178,
-0.25824201107025146,
0.18743008375167847,
-0.07098358869552612,
0.1985016167163849,
-0.03454301878809929,
-0.12003076076507568,
-0.169218972325325,
-0.41370993852615356,
0.47436127066612244,
0.30637189745903015,
-0.7976884245872498,
0.24812166392803192,
0.6631646752357483,
-0.11287622153759003,
-0.34395140409469604,
-0.46081608533859253,
0.3532380163669586,
-0.24218890070915222,
-0.9464223980903625,
0.6932864785194397,
0.005679050926119089,
-0.1142999455332756,
-0.19501399993896484,
0.06743992865085602,
-0.09048990160226822,
0.13077037036418915,
0.2508198022842407,
0.34841030836105347,
-0.0665796548128128,
-0.021350804716348648,
0.729505181312561,
-0.15651434659957886,
-0.18751278519630432,
-0.3274545669555664,
0.6604503393173218,
-0.20435012876987457,
-0.5950755476951599,
-0.5854074954986572,
0.2850353419780731,
0.014790103770792484,
-0.087476447224617,
0.350713312625885,
0.457933634519577,
-0.07565802335739136,
0.12146040797233582,
-0.2794170379638672,
-0.12034105509519577,
-0.4141484797000885,
0.3103495240211487,
-0.557644248008728,
-0.8934922218322754,
0.4371238350868225,
0.026963068172335625,
-0.3448861241340637,
0.35283514857292175,
0.4910091757774353,
-0.10789988189935684,
0.6852699518203735,
0.36103391647338867,
0.04841192439198494,
0.3243420720100403,
-0.4250398576259613,
-0.029484888538718224,
-1.0328505039215088,
-0.21392734348773956,
-0.1866244375705719,
-0.2460131198167801,
-0.5036212801933289,
-0.6499715447425842,
0.6748519539833069,
0.012971139512956142,
-0.012381969019770622,
0.29407694935798645,
-0.5337492227554321,
0.2956527769565582,
0.34619930386543274,
0.1963171809911728,
0.5446467399597168,
0.39771023392677307,
-0.38249364495277405,
-0.21594782173633575,
-0.7253785133361816,
-0.23043043911457062,
0.6275217533111572,
0.19281761348247528,
0.4768146872520447,
0.06973137706518173,
0.7260644435882568,
0.33601269125938416,
0.3205025792121887,
-0.7129583358764648,
0.6269492506980896,
-0.038644321262836456,
-0.41271859407424927,
-0.2500867545604706,
-0.3065430521965027,
-1.2280006408691406,
0.5236982703208923,
-0.18452532589435577,
-0.5800375938415527,
0.5281296968460083,
-0.06850309669971466,
-0.4042474329471588,
-0.14414818584918976,
-0.3520634174346924,
0.4829871356487274,
-0.07797704637050629,
-0.7415090203285217,
-0.19764703512191772,
-0.5993183851242065,
0.36477938294410706,
0.0713859274983406,
0.08614397048950195,
0.0885060653090477,
-0.13520415127277374,
0.6299297213554382,
-0.54449462890625,
0.7462672591209412,
-0.19168482720851898,
-0.30910441279411316,
0.516468346118927,
-0.16464000940322876,
0.3112278878688812,
0.0926143229007721,
-0.3719286024570465,
0.4634130895137787,
-0.3118937015533447,
-0.3609260320663452,
-0.6891978979110718,
0.518848180770874,
-0.5244128108024597,
-0.3824525475502014,
-0.21939562261104584,
-0.5715491771697998,
-0.21631364524364471,
0.12593528628349304,
0.41192877292633057,
0.5000660419464111,
-0.7798739075660706,
0.12126079946756363,
0.34039774537086487,
-0.08570721745491028,
0.26388636231422424,
0.3603176772594452,
-0.02948131412267685,
-0.8444730043411255,
1.093578577041626,
0.19772496819496155,
0.12354271858930588,
0.3567142188549042,
0.2030859887599945,
-0.3847411870956421,
-0.5794016718864441,
-0.5365545749664307,
-0.2067750096321106,
-0.5144134163856506,
-0.02306821383535862,
-0.21289320290088654,
-0.035090915858745575,
-0.09265703707933426,
0.04739832878112793,
-0.2178715467453003,
-0.48687100410461426,
-0.046348657459020615,
-0.18340367078781128,
0.07752195000648499,
0.4043334126472473,
-0.01645684614777565,
0.36593714356422424,
-0.5048108696937561,
0.18115489184856415,
0.2154352068901062,
0.301300048828125,
-0.023216746747493744,
-0.5555346608161926,
-0.2508469820022583,
0.10293695330619812,
-0.331080824136734,
-0.6658219695091248,
0.35141700506210327,
0.24940088391304016,
0.4807141125202179,
0.20236513018608093,
-0.10722028464078903,
1.0298428535461426,
-0.2661714255809784,
0.6273676753044128,
0.17125432193279266,
-1.0752482414245605,
0.6273813843727112,
-0.29669591784477234,
0.24489954113960266,
0.8135998249053955,
0.17584128677845,
-0.14399786293506622,
-0.490715891122818,
-0.7758828997612,
-1.0124320983886719,
0.38459500670433044,
0.24536778032779694,
0.16605617105960846,
0.22268690168857574,
0.41668546199798584,
0.5047470927238464,
0.3600727319717407,
-0.273721843957901,
0.05471944436430931,
-0.005024251528084278,
-0.21849676966667175,
0.2938215732574463,
-0.1302368938922882,
-0.3108800947666168,
-0.5833595395088196,
0.39164894819259644,
-0.1299130916595459,
0.16663561761379242,
0.24408076703548431,
-0.2451256513595581,
-0.030597295612096786,
0.34451016783714294,
0.3609832227230072,
0.47177743911743164,
-0.019684256985783577,
0.22717662155628204,
0.31209391355514526,
-0.6063264012336731,
0.3145044147968292,
0.27002519369125366,
-0.72690749168396,
-0.07779952138662338,
0.5031808018684387,
1.1808017492294312,
0.34891974925994873,
-0.035502880811691284,
0.40546146035194397,
-0.1466449350118637,
0.06825684756040573,
-0.04108569025993347,
0.29680976271629333,
-0.19036750495433807,
0.05484533682465553,
0.19219975173473358,
0.18098868429660797,
0.44381463527679443,
-0.5262015461921692,
0.24285390973091125,
0.41407179832458496,
-0.49240854382514954,
-0.613675594329834,
0.3498454689979553,
0.13688717782497406,
-0.0976901575922966,
0.18061880767345428,
-0.6680840253829956,
-0.23392724990844727,
0.22439907491207123,
0.5660417675971985,
0.7639341950416565,
-0.4342329502105713,
0.3079949915409088,
0.4380623400211334,
0.06980512291193008,
0.06656931340694427,
0.6703969836235046,
-0.37872186303138733,
-0.5785387754440308,
-0.6260498762130737,
-0.734789252281189,
-0.6674778461456299,
-0.021771850064396858,
-0.9067326188087463,
0.13701483607292175,
-0.1425691694021225,
0.0350583977997303,
-0.21801230311393738,
0.2558702826499939,
-0.3955022096633911,
0.31746283173561096,
-0.14973649382591248,
0.47630807757377625,
-0.6531168818473816,
0.6639270782470703,
0.5547856688499451,
-0.3384421765804291,
-0.3930623531341553,
0.03409074991941452,
-0.28331294655799866,
-0.5975796580314636,
0.14626744389533997,
0.13100315630435944,
-0.24400357902050018,
-0.11931640654802322,
-0.333258718252182,
-0.8294880390167236,
1.1636683940887451,
0.8544397354125977,
-0.49103230237960815,
0.11178234964609146,
0.1159074530005455,
0.8166137933731079,
-0.37500110268592834,
0.20234639942646027,
0.6334654092788696,
0.4248804748058319,
0.46645388007164,
-0.631422221660614,
0.20905937254428864,
-0.2122887820005417,
0.04357212036848068,
-0.023129602894186974,
-0.49843236804008484,
0.7367410659790039,
-0.07214286178350449,
-0.42848578095436096,
0.03436684608459473,
1.0141297578811646,
0.30006954073905945,
0.35625362396240234,
0.5207358002662659,
0.8588342666625977,
1.278682827949524,
-0.1839912086725235,
1.073844075202942,
-0.23922336101531982,
0.28450438380241394,
1.6127686500549316,
-0.19910724461078644,
0.7350444793701172,
0.1613958477973938,
-0.25583764910697937,
0.7589932680130005,
0.5820910334587097,
-0.09830289334058762,
0.5866518020629883,
0.06659169495105743,
-0.5929595232009888,
0.014986810274422169,
-0.3172759413719177,
-0.3309078514575958,
0.8787235021591187,
0.3660151958465576,
0.015553416684269905,
-0.35996514558792114,
0.05253029242157936,
0.04970958083868027,
-0.007545106112957001,
-0.2703729271888733,
0.7944941520690918,
0.04375232756137848,
-0.9700484871864319,
0.752699613571167,
-0.09463252127170563,
0.3456628918647766,
-0.13493405282497406,
0.0008668007794767618,
-0.08917250484228134,
0.10748150944709778,
-0.18904128670692444,
-0.5861772298812866,
0.6874591708183289,
-0.15744724869728088,
0.15903741121292114,
0.1101127341389656,
0.9331651329994202,
-0.5350742936134338,
-0.5283070802688599,
0.3259483873844147,
0.5188314318656921,
0.12202295660972595,
0.008999337442219257,
-0.5462867021560669,
0.25954189896583557,
-0.3720565140247345,
-0.08661855757236481,
0.10903587192296982,
0.13192471861839294,
-0.16691803932189941,
0.10496516525745392,
0.6438441872596741,
0.09430676698684692,
-0.4264184832572937,
0.32361918687820435,
0.800062358379364,
-0.2395293116569519,
-0.6308562159538269,
-0.9356398582458496,
0.3493630886077881,
-0.4153110384941101,
-0.06128992885351181,
0.8888859152793884,
0.6084903478622437,
0.5426985025405884,
0.3790532052516937,
0.7053581476211548,
0.009667408652603626,
0.31829917430877686,
-0.3418083190917969,
0.6392018795013428,
-0.21394415199756622,
0.29940953850746155,
-0.31725189089775085,
-0.8238682746887207,
-0.3691031038761139,
0.7157173156738281,
-0.6665775775909424,
0.04850466921925545,
0.4391612410545349,
0.6451766490936279,
-0.15546143054962158,
0.4620784819126129,
0.3635566234588623,
0.3027804493904114,
0.2071697860956192,
0.4315391480922699,
0.7196513414382935,
-0.5342206954956055,
0.20381206274032593,
-0.18719974160194397,
-0.3045215606689453,
-0.08448886126279831,
-0.8157327175140381,
-0.6239470839500427,
-0.5135827660560608,
-0.1015557125210762,
-0.22761628031730652,
0.12742768228054047,
0.6292380690574646,
0.7195296287536621,
-0.8127321600914001,
-0.24103856086730957,
-0.5457371473312378,
0.21313327550888062,
-0.2045963704586029,
-0.19173792004585266,
0.691719114780426,
-0.22568057477474213,
-0.7128105759620667,
0.748447835445404,
0.7443846464157104,
-0.13805989921092987,
-0.5526115894317627,
0.05797681212425232,
-0.18015387654304504,
0.10715176910161972,
0.7171851992607117,
-0.12298097461462021,
-0.3128246068954468,
-0.3121604919433594,
-0.15202568471431732,
0.07734464854001999,
0.4579661786556244,
0.4468315541744232,
-0.8665438294410706,
0.8514831066131592,
0.52585768699646,
0.3847384750843048,
0.6269135475158691,
0.03570174053311348,
0.707290768623352,
-0.9413015246391296,
0.22722265124320984,
0.215490460395813,
0.37020188570022583,
0.6716316938400269,
-0.16965030133724213,
0.4575549066066742,
0.2415950894355774,
-0.19386395812034607,
-0.8017692565917969,
0.26881954073905945,
-0.9195018410682678,
0.1080302894115448,
0.4653753340244293,
-0.4245058596134186,
-0.361737459897995,
-0.41937434673309326,
-0.2842543125152588,
0.47060486674308777,
-0.16385842859745026,
0.9182473421096802,
0.47625336050987244,
-0.2292352169752121,
0.19490966200828552,
-0.15903687477111816,
0.4027083218097687,
0.43092188239097595,
-1.2500747442245483,
-0.3590315282344818,
0.5214357972145081,
-0.004202109295874834,
0.5036011338233948,
0.7463292479515076,
-0.14001798629760742,
0.3557991683483124,
0.06207994371652603,
-0.17554457485675812,
0.0261740293353796,
-0.3729548752307892,
-0.5210253000259399,
0.7161839008331299,
-0.35414838790893555,
-0.10595332831144333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00672v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00672v1
|
A General and Efficient Training for Transformer via Token Expansion
| 2024-03-31T12:44:24 | 2024-03-31T12:44:24 |
Wenxuan Huang, Yunhang Shen, Jiao Xie, Baochang Zhang, Gaoqi He, Ke Li, Xing Sun, Shaohui Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The remarkable performance of Vision Transformers (ViTs) typically requires
an extremely large training cost. Existing methods have attempted to accelerate
the training of ViTs, yet typically disregard method universality with accuracy
dropping. Meanwhile, they break the training consistency of the original
transformers, including the consistency of hyper-parameters, architecture, and
strategy, which prevents them from being widely applied to different
Transformer networks. In this paper, we propose a novel token growth scheme
Token Expansion (termed ToE) to achieve consistent training acceleration for
ViTs. We introduce an "initialization-expansion-merging" pipeline to maintain
the integrity of the intermediate feature distribution of original
transformers, preventing the loss of crucial learnable information in the
training process. ToE can not only be seamlessly integrated into the training
and fine-tuning process of transformers (e.g., DeiT and LV-ViT), but also
effective for efficient training frameworks (e.g., EfficientTrain), without
twisting the original training hyper-parameters, architecture, and introducing
additional training strategies. Extensive experiments demonstrate that ToE
achieves about 1.3x faster for the training of ViTs in a lossless manner, or
even with performance gains over the full-token training baselines. Code is
available at https://github.com/Osilly/TokenExpansion .
|
[
-0.4000096321105957,
-0.16233870387077332,
0.016516538336873055,
0.2135988473892212,
-0.7039868235588074,
0.4608768820762634,
-0.06275931000709534,
-0.27397310733795166,
0.2906877100467682,
0.20159724354743958,
-0.4022606909275055,
-0.1894291192293167,
-0.7692515850067139,
-0.2019287347793579,
-0.45266062021255493,
0.5377522110939026,
0.19290213286876678,
0.09181932359933853,
0.4118005037307739,
-0.4044378995895386,
-0.7023151516914368,
-0.2915661036968231,
-0.5241292119026184,
0.041566599160432816,
0.3039373457431793,
0.6483125686645508,
0.680766224861145,
1.1344009637832642,
0.8999870419502258,
0.3317798972129822,
-0.19906190037727356,
0.2698685824871063,
-0.4193655550479889,
-0.1191430389881134,
0.04968186840415001,
-0.4793335199356079,
-0.4219937026500702,
-0.3119201064109802,
0.8646554350852966,
0.4078778922557831,
-0.32049325108528137,
0.05082813277840614,
0.21472664177417755,
0.7026995420455933,
-0.36123427748680115,
0.09785971790552139,
-0.7018066644668579,
0.2547852694988251,
-0.012178539298474789,
-0.47517529129981995,
-0.4306994080543518,
-0.05207046866416931,
0.18857267498970032,
-0.4637310206890106,
0.5193042755126953,
-0.04345652833580971,
0.8346465826034546,
0.2820558547973633,
-0.17818212509155273,
0.4654233753681183,
-0.6225102543830872,
0.37543368339538574,
0.030669499188661575,
0.7936298251152039,
-0.7325767278671265,
0.5438900589942932,
0.30062976479530334,
-0.9397264122962952,
-0.3559790253639221,
0.20963667333126068,
-0.1444924771785736,
0.12576043605804443,
0.010461440309882164,
0.1953241229057312,
0.31899163126945496,
0.4265807271003723,
-0.1458875983953476,
0.016608115285634995,
-0.5603612661361694,
-0.24096474051475525,
0.14935487508773804,
0.20397278666496277,
-0.04725603759288788,
0.037793125957250595,
-1.0048333406448364,
-0.41704922914505005,
-0.4752918481826782,
0.4673359990119934,
0.2240922600030899,
0.3062789738178253,
-0.3053237199783325,
0.47622931003570557,
-0.0494079552590847,
0.26497581601142883,
0.4372272789478302,
0.37301546335220337,
0.4721199572086334,
-0.37190043926239014,
-0.08867544680833817,
0.050775885581970215,
0.42424261569976807,
0.6700406670570374,
0.17961521446704865,
-0.45516547560691833,
-0.1661028414964676,
0.25388649106025696,
0.5309059619903564,
-1.018437385559082,
-0.12189114093780518,
0.059236954897642136,
-0.23078691959381104,
-0.5348107218742371,
0.4032580554485321,
-0.8600187301635742,
-0.05675281956791878,
-0.3625293970108032,
0.5358025431632996,
-0.4271193742752075,
-0.5147455930709839,
0.15787889063358307,
-0.4974024295806885,
0.956429123878479,
0.028759535402059555,
-1.016705870628357,
0.13178709149360657,
1.0842550992965698,
0.9324227571487427,
-0.41250550746917725,
-0.4206969738006592,
-0.9033163785934448,
-0.20070324838161469,
-0.6631146669387817,
0.2147289663553238,
-0.3680930435657501,
-0.4280480742454529,
0.027429524809122086,
0.1787281185388565,
0.15997271239757538,
-0.3597847819328308,
0.25702059268951416,
-0.4491446316242218,
-0.2439577877521515,
-0.05118037760257721,
-0.12757599353790283,
0.24833858013153076,
0.1473229080438614,
-0.18973077833652496,
1.0595715045928955,
0.364736407995224,
-0.6891977787017822,
0.8616726994514465,
-0.7631243467330933,
-0.09340649098157883,
0.31563499569892883,
-0.17922185361385345,
-0.3598747253417969,
0.28033870458602905,
0.27408087253570557,
0.43725162744522095,
0.03047366626560688,
0.16987310349941254,
0.22652937471866608,
-0.9119401574134827,
-0.317524254322052,
-0.6688527464866638,
0.4916098415851593,
-0.3838554322719574,
-0.8417676091194153,
0.21213966608047485,
-0.6341248750686646,
0.04471278563141823,
-0.04201929643750191,
-0.19798485934734344,
0.09216912090778351,
-0.5291483998298645,
-0.15234631299972534,
-0.14533481001853943,
0.12129359692335129,
-0.853411078453064,
0.5230379700660706,
-0.7054718136787415,
0.22952307760715485,
1.101198434829712,
-0.10263034701347351,
0.7254152894020081,
0.2113291323184967,
0.33400946855545044,
0.4110892117023468,
0.7974820137023926,
-0.6622799634933472,
-0.5255317687988281,
-1.3667562007904053,
-0.24804390966892242,
0.44554686546325684,
0.2869551479816437,
-0.8952900171279907,
0.5135968923568726,
-0.9274064898490906,
-0.6833958029747009,
-0.34004250168800354,
-0.20666898787021637,
0.3632960319519043,
0.45633527636528015,
0.5352428555488586,
-0.519075870513916,
-0.3654026687145233,
-0.8104239702224731,
-0.10576159507036209,
-0.1378874033689499,
0.013854165561497211,
0.04607034847140312,
0.19033277034759521,
-0.06597951054573059,
1.1351163387298584,
-0.40989670157432556,
-0.04976149648427963,
0.11019227653741837,
-0.007947367615997791,
0.2961629331111908,
0.7208940386772156,
0.5388978719711304,
-0.8707035183906555,
-0.5169568657875061,
0.28244292736053467,
-0.31881606578826904,
0.38931551575660706,
-0.04072127491235733,
-0.28529441356658936,
-0.19537581503391266,
0.43150967359542847,
-0.41272875666618347,
0.670525848865509,
0.4322260022163391,
-0.5510222911834717,
0.2965661585330963,
-0.20872245728969574,
-0.03575007617473602,
-1.020451307296753,
-0.031862907111644745,
-0.1842208206653595,
-0.39516696333885193,
-0.49613046646118164,
0.2690599262714386,
0.3124958872795105,
-0.1256178915500641,
-0.680938184261322,
0.3886239528656006,
-0.1210097223520279,
0.22709618508815765,
-0.13951990008354187,
-0.22261963784694672,
-0.27333471179008484,
0.7723758816719055,
-0.164007768034935,
0.926522433757782,
1.1044983863830566,
-0.6805213689804077,
0.35123997926712036,
0.26623696088790894,
0.2893611490726471,
0.541669487953186,
-0.5121609568595886,
-0.07975416630506516,
-0.1967315971851349,
-0.15858779847621918,
-0.6834638714790344,
0.20876193046569824,
0.4255860447883606,
-0.5297406315803528,
0.35933917760849,
-0.3104221224784851,
-0.20103855431079865,
-0.587268590927124,
-0.40344300866127014,
0.2136758267879486,
0.9383975863456726,
-1.3032701015472412,
1.228247046470642,
-0.06988304108381271,
0.3948693573474884,
-1.0362465381622314,
-0.4017484486103058,
0.2647615969181061,
-0.2346644401550293,
-0.35340383648872375,
0.4799498915672302,
0.1933620423078537,
0.35887983441352844,
0.005276086274534464,
-0.5264264941215515,
0.08450759947299957,
-0.1839178502559662,
0.19429698586463928,
0.4200423061847687,
-0.4527667462825775,
0.09641668945550919,
-0.06926945596933365,
-0.5335649251937866,
-0.1681627482175827,
-0.64238440990448,
0.5974053144454956,
-0.41996312141418457,
-0.406127005815506,
-0.381420761346817,
-0.12689627707004547,
1.002665638923645,
-0.28162142634391785,
0.4753410518169403,
1.0516406297683716,
0.1365363597869873,
-0.07991224527359009,
-0.6126302480697632,
-0.43878111243247986,
-0.6414868831634521,
0.40786653757095337,
-0.47139233350753784,
-0.6743772029876709,
0.2699275314807892,
-0.30723288655281067,
0.42979830503463745,
0.5651394724845886,
0.19136053323745728,
0.22448226809501648,
0.6845751404762268,
0.9554935097694397,
0.03006643056869507,
0.6468997597694397,
-0.6700105667114258,
0.2958238422870636,
-0.921160101890564,
-0.3414883315563202,
-0.18809577822685242,
-0.6226361393928528,
-0.5722199082374573,
-0.8548822402954102,
0.13300155103206635,
0.031044036149978638,
-0.20868784189224243,
0.6580340266227722,
-0.9356897473335266,
0.7931353449821472,
0.8377295136451721,
0.13187219202518463,
0.15019439160823822,
0.19465669989585876,
-0.4051990211009979,
0.014179201796650887,
-0.9086368680000305,
0.01124932337552309,
1.1579645872116089,
0.4651656150817871,
0.22551895678043365,
-0.1139601618051529,
0.5722352266311646,
0.14990846812725067,
0.32507362961769104,
-0.7222470641136169,
0.5428358316421509,
-0.2025192379951477,
-0.07499553263187408,
-0.4498167335987091,
-0.2717287540435791,
-0.6194927096366882,
0.3171412944793701,
-0.21305415034294128,
-0.6101071238517761,
0.6341248750686646,
0.45041292905807495,
-0.12675441801548004,
0.8599931597709656,
-0.6320188045501709,
0.5322228670120239,
-0.32321077585220337,
-0.5289265513420105,
-0.09662648290395737,
-0.8354125022888184,
-0.11672261357307434,
-0.21431417763233185,
-0.5290119647979736,
0.15131776034832,
-0.17711804807186127,
0.5303288698196411,
-0.5572717785835266,
0.6538633704185486,
-0.5794016122817993,
0.242680162191391,
0.31460174918174744,
-0.40090394020080566,
0.6127671003341675,
0.1515493392944336,
0.4201064705848694,
0.5456181168556213,
-0.47604790329933167,
-0.5283825397491455,
-0.7464042901992798,
0.13399004936218262,
-0.3977859914302826,
-0.6988943815231323,
-0.1275617480278015,
0.009461674839258194,
-0.27586475014686584,
0.11768941581249237,
0.30995622277259827,
0.5396544933319092,
0.07347481697797775,
0.8340209126472473,
0.3905559778213501,
0.22051064670085907,
0.41024208068847656,
0.2215404510498047,
0.0026400238275527954,
-0.4395562410354614,
1.0010961294174194,
-0.4050675928592682,
0.29189568758010864,
0.2837694585323334,
0.3942025601863861,
-0.4109419882297516,
-0.36949920654296875,
-0.7227487564086914,
-0.07503482699394226,
-0.5396888256072998,
-0.41881582140922546,
-0.506513237953186,
-0.42178377509117126,
0.03485879674553871,
-0.3203531801700592,
-0.5689602494239807,
-0.20081587135791779,
0.1385444849729538,
-0.16958603262901306,
0.45304399728775024,
0.22538597881793976,
-0.1650458723306656,
0.8409479856491089,
-0.8734289407730103,
0.29431718587875366,
0.5464059114456177,
0.8362107872962952,
0.15380500257015228,
-0.5111984014511108,
-0.2564607560634613,
-0.10424000769853592,
-0.32670554518699646,
-0.24212177097797394,
-0.019245581701397896,
0.07247669249773026,
0.2540130317211151,
0.7931175231933594,
-0.28047895431518555,
1.117582082748413,
-0.7420653104782104,
0.8029782176017761,
0.9073972105979919,
-0.8510884046554565,
0.09673085063695908,
-0.18947412073612213,
0.02839191071689129,
0.4660234749317169,
-0.12652628123760223,
-0.4780210554599762,
-0.24353186786174774,
-0.874403715133667,
-1.0586013793945312,
0.5849738717079163,
0.42774060368537903,
0.6242566704750061,
0.10665661096572876,
0.3958224952220917,
0.03980309143662453,
-0.027044670656323433,
-0.23670615255832672,
-0.30205437541007996,
-0.44358029961586,
0.0015533112455159426,
0.005674165673553944,
-0.052565496414899826,
-0.015368501655757427,
-0.6041363477706909,
0.3998373746871948,
-0.36284005641937256,
0.39230048656463623,
0.18952934443950653,
0.26760292053222656,
0.050453584641218185,
-0.0876455307006836,
0.13294613361358643,
0.3549620807170868,
0.08217853307723999,
-0.20695599913597107,
0.5002617239952087,
-0.8589730858802795,
0.37433478236198425,
-0.3787745237350464,
0.13562488555908203,
0.12309849262237549,
-0.09903831779956818,
0.9890516400337219,
0.4662570655345917,
-0.3620537519454956,
1.006809115409851,
-0.26384788751602173,
-0.5052115321159363,
0.09261968731880188,
0.3397333323955536,
-0.12979497015476227,
0.405638188123703,
0.5559949278831482,
0.7760284543037415,
-0.23286721110343933,
-0.10654620826244354,
0.5798043012619019,
0.23013049364089966,
-0.7194340229034424,
-0.14070835709571838,
0.8723468780517578,
0.624932587146759,
-0.5784380435943604,
0.6980997323989868,
0.10053472220897675,
-0.660161018371582,
0.6999361515045166,
0.18652111291885376,
1.0843524932861328,
-0.07344087213277817,
0.1437210589647293,
0.30144423246383667,
0.46421387791633606,
-0.10142625123262405,
0.09577096998691559,
-0.1585243195295334,
-0.646899938583374,
-0.3812898099422455,
-0.6031045913696289,
-0.2613411545753479,
-0.3482702076435089,
-0.42890942096710205,
0.7605471014976501,
-0.4050544798374176,
-0.27157822251319885,
-0.5012233257293701,
-0.5127589106559753,
-1.0916376113891602,
0.1282852739095688,
-0.03704207390546799,
1.1599500179290771,
-0.5047038793563843,
0.40647491812705994,
0.2905730903148651,
-0.002220586407929659,
-0.9658450484275818,
0.12701229751110077,
-0.4797876477241516,
-0.9051929712295532,
0.5499567985534668,
0.3759029805660248,
-0.3030349910259247,
0.3310932219028473,
-0.0059716119430959225,
-0.5872790217399597,
1.119423747062683,
0.17944765090942383,
-0.7169390320777893,
-0.3312089443206787,
0.406514972448349,
0.33920785784721375,
-0.20733703672885895,
0.07985168695449829,
0.3659374415874481,
0.4440194368362427,
0.3170924186706543,
-0.6439180970191956,
-0.3411787748336792,
-0.007163849659264088,
0.15201131999492645,
0.37865012884140015,
-0.8155266642570496,
0.3955426514148712,
-0.31389299035072327,
-0.3008470833301544,
0.07503090798854828,
0.6343056559562683,
-0.3116312623023987,
-0.2580417990684509,
1.010093331336975,
0.4351523518562317,
0.5048263072967529,
-0.5529794692993164,
0.5343912839889526,
-0.8428161144256592,
0.4494844377040863,
0.5549920201301575,
0.4669050872325897,
0.5431085824966431,
0.6738293170928955,
0.03738204762339592,
0.07078906893730164,
0.3672066926956177,
-0.4542449116706848,
0.24496233463287354,
-0.022791042923927307,
0.15898491442203522,
-0.24829237163066864,
0.1038670539855957,
-0.5899524688720703,
0.7312591075897217,
-0.017210906371474266,
-0.3787325918674469,
0.020209886133670807,
-0.07757069915533066,
-0.5362423658370972,
-0.470802366733551,
-0.3496081531047821,
0.5414442420005798,
-0.29697343707084656,
-0.26771080493927,
0.2595999538898468,
-0.2094540148973465,
1.0283942222595215,
-0.5763598680496216,
-0.23062977194786072,
-0.17765480279922485,
0.10896914452314377,
-0.0607028491795063,
-0.6568173766136169,
0.17507368326187134,
0.045170415192842484,
0.3594960570335388,
-0.2557066082954407,
0.37351396679878235,
-0.012434720061719418,
-0.5831397771835327,
0.1916148066520691,
0.4480561912059784,
-0.1704159379005432,
0.12410437315702438,
-0.2580847442150116,
-0.23314952850341797,
-0.004748379811644554,
-0.006064440123736858,
-0.182233065366745,
0.5894361734390259,
0.25286194682121277,
0.42753466963768005,
0.6795367002487183,
0.20625722408294678,
0.41918957233428955,
-0.22967107594013214,
1.0998824834823608,
-0.5164467096328735,
-0.7058650851249695,
-0.8617604374885559,
0.8830564022064209,
-0.48067110776901245,
-0.5028643012046814,
0.30325958132743835,
0.8554766178131104,
0.6264206767082214,
-0.07972146570682526,
0.1957133263349533,
0.16707825660705566,
-0.14145781099796295,
-0.30016693472862244,
0.5546584725379944,
-0.5762201547622681,
0.12164362519979477,
-0.15260440111160278,
-1.3544490337371826,
-0.29317203164100647,
0.21440717577934265,
0.24382610619068146,
-0.1980779767036438,
0.7258352637290955,
0.5358750224113464,
-0.4947673976421356,
-0.16380181908607483,
0.5533239245414734,
-0.06599213927984238,
0.3504023253917694,
-0.08773128688335419,
0.3908303678035736,
-0.5666378140449524,
0.766994059085846,
-0.2898351848125458,
-0.2065117210149765,
-0.2732295095920563,
-0.5541039109230042,
-0.5263464450836182,
-0.2948015332221985,
-0.298757404088974,
-0.1585082709789276,
0.15224729478359222,
0.6644696593284607,
0.9847290515899658,
-0.31824415922164917,
0.2910654842853546,
-0.4403996467590332,
-0.22645345330238342,
-0.4564708471298218,
-0.261485755443573,
0.41105180978775024,
-0.4233930706977844,
-0.8260441422462463,
0.09731879085302353,
0.6365584135055542,
0.015225083567202091,
-0.3431216776371002,
-0.1244235411286354,
0.6820069551467896,
-0.015723537653684616,
0.4603552520275116,
0.11103781312704086,
-0.6898546814918518,
-0.654182493686676,
0.30772995948791504,
0.29964232444763184,
0.854177713394165,
0.9954058527946472,
-1.0040251016616821,
0.6664479374885559,
0.18177393078804016,
0.9078235626220703,
0.25330376625061035,
0.17953424155712128,
0.541643500328064,
-0.9728235602378845,
0.31679394841194153,
0.031882524490356445,
0.2650338113307953,
0.1460687667131424,
-0.36101922392845154,
0.672637939453125,
0.36913543939590454,
0.05861174315214157,
-0.7245166301727295,
0.04326974228024483,
-0.983199954032898,
0.3302724361419678,
0.615164041519165,
0.15831013023853302,
-0.15650157630443573,
0.1097450777888298,
-0.2838703691959381,
0.25425276160240173,
-0.2970848083496094,
0.616684079170227,
0.18152998387813568,
0.15267205238342285,
0.008993151597678661,
0.0630563423037529,
0.32636329531669617,
0.16948725283145905,
-0.26087281107902527,
0.21535752713680267,
-0.2357850819826126,
0.16759105026721954,
0.3671931326389313,
0.28265443444252014,
-0.3434896469116211,
0.42238911986351013,
0.3019668757915497,
-0.06469279527664185,
-0.1825454831123352,
-0.7439692616462708,
-0.2924923002719879,
0.2546951472759247,
-0.1730625331401825,
-0.7360921502113342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00657v1
|
Observations on Building RAG Systems for Technical Documents
| 2024-03-31T12:01:34 | 2024-03-31T12:01:34 |
Sumit Soman, Sujoy Roychowdhury
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) for technical documents creates
challenges as embeddings do not often capture domain information. We review
prior art for important factors affecting RAG and perform experiments to
highlight best practices and potential challenges to build RAG systems for
technical documents.
|
[
-0.48893144726753235,
-0.6008339524269104,
0.5677538514137268,
-0.11312418431043625,
-0.09580951184034348,
0.7571917176246643,
0.32417476177215576,
-0.7104707956314087,
0.5003081560134888,
0.593634307384491,
-0.14027678966522217,
-0.04748624190688133,
-0.6630553007125854,
0.1682106852531433,
-0.39429971575737,
0.8981854915618896,
-0.3597017228603363,
-0.3710918128490448,
-0.1837109476327896,
-0.138136625289917,
-0.8083711266517639,
-0.6926154494285583,
-0.7011018395423889,
-0.30507197976112366,
0.1951419711112976,
0.5633413195610046,
0.6600428223609924,
0.2738173007965088,
0.7914332151412964,
0.29728177189826965,
-0.07620663940906525,
0.7169889807701111,
-0.18273791670799255,
0.4220651090145111,
-0.09037049114704132,
-0.1841660439968109,
-0.6348050236701965,
0.177961066365242,
0.5127097368240356,
0.45418059825897217,
0.04030252620577812,
0.29157376289367676,
-0.12407798320055008,
0.7236338257789612,
-0.8261719942092896,
-0.2768288850784302,
-0.4674109220504761,
0.16734328866004944,
-0.5201367735862732,
-0.7108966112136841,
-0.5565151572227478,
-0.11298992484807968,
-0.0005413665203377604,
-0.8352116346359253,
0.8124374151229858,
0.3820819556713104,
1.3077759742736816,
0.07296138256788254,
-0.538072943687439,
-0.6957012414932251,
-0.9626149535179138,
0.5188808441162109,
-0.29355478286743164,
0.356285035610199,
0.6306074857711792,
0.25645238161087036,
-0.31388863921165466,
-1.0374071598052979,
-0.36830541491508484,
-0.2577706277370453,
-0.20983345806598663,
-0.020121268928050995,
0.18104523420333862,
-0.21579360961914062,
0.5313867926597595,
0.5400353670120239,
-0.5284974575042725,
-0.20365729928016663,
-0.5781291723251343,
-0.08481570333242416,
0.5293195247650146,
0.1399879902601242,
0.10869362205266953,
-0.5010596513748169,
-0.3219514787197113,
-0.12636545300483704,
-0.6509396433830261,
-0.3512329161167145,
0.40719377994537354,
0.16258551180362701,
0.4462059438228607,
0.9805241823196411,
0.1437409371137619,
0.5783243179321289,
0.3400549292564392,
0.04927407205104828,
0.5101022124290466,
-0.24608206748962402,
-0.16300390660762787,
-0.06108370050787926,
0.17550809681415558,
0.11368851363658905,
-0.1900007575750351,
-0.13643978536128998,
-0.6778618693351746,
-0.3955606520175934,
0.8030276894569397,
-0.3631370961666107,
0.02288641780614853,
0.0220260601490736,
-0.2411603480577469,
-0.19284385442733765,
0.37064599990844727,
-0.31850895285606384,
-0.6451438665390015,
-0.30840402841567993,
0.5891904830932617,
-0.3787793517112732,
-0.5190127491950989,
-0.27277448773384094,
-0.9756141901016235,
0.343931645154953,
0.26981407403945923,
-0.3629226088523865,
0.32572993636131287,
0.6979230642318726,
0.7495617270469666,
0.09093289077281952,
-0.03801542893052101,
-0.5082298517227173,
0.46451109647750854,
-0.5122215747833252,
1.1779643297195435,
-0.4629923105239868,
-1.0670790672302246,
0.04097508639097214,
0.10968774557113647,
0.21303167939186096,
-0.8930306434631348,
0.6268201470375061,
-0.8641639351844788,
0.10091082751750946,
-0.22617961466312408,
-0.5520790815353394,
0.1501130610704422,
-0.01393020898103714,
-0.5559259653091431,
1.1375317573547363,
0.5027579665184021,
-0.9121078848838806,
0.4589141011238098,
-0.4458772838115692,
-0.5078096389770508,
0.3341793119907379,
-0.3947857916355133,
-0.3728788495063782,
0.5121658444404602,
-0.2797688841819763,
0.21748194098472595,
-0.11413495987653732,
0.084374338388443,
0.008266990073025227,
-0.28763633966445923,
0.0092562111094594,
0.16648182272911072,
0.433176726102829,
0.6004343628883362,
-0.18698467314243317,
-0.49191734194755554,
-0.7720615267753601,
-0.0480697900056839,
0.2255406230688095,
-0.23034314811229706,
-0.7886101007461548,
-0.0627063661813736,
0.02996963821351528,
-0.20417307317256927,
0.4149988293647766,
-0.7109038829803467,
0.2141367495059967,
-0.14571474492549896,
-0.26719602942466736,
0.6661409735679626,
0.0967828556895256,
0.5659869313240051,
-0.7482931613922119,
0.6187194585800171,
-0.08571723103523254,
-0.22075994312763214,
-0.0696941539645195,
-0.4003600478172302,
-0.7135111093521118,
0.14437630772590637,
0.43393826484680176,
0.44395673274993896,
-1.3407403230667114,
-0.2422924041748047,
0.08555904030799866,
-0.21248874068260193,
-0.3922317624092102,
-0.02043922431766987,
0.5956076383590698,
0.6108245253562927,
0.1558665782213211,
-0.32086461782455444,
-0.7115533351898193,
-0.950147807598114,
-0.04656209424138069,
0.1196235716342926,
-0.0285959430038929,
0.6337434649467468,
0.3226495087146759,
-0.032769255340099335,
0.9590808153152466,
-0.6673975586891174,
-0.2243492603302002,
0.10746292769908905,
0.6789591312408447,
0.10754844546318054,
0.4825017750263214,
0.5961316227912903,
-1.19215989112854,
-0.7238594889640808,
0.22900010645389557,
-0.7921304106712341,
-0.11460311710834503,
0.03783928602933884,
0.2040206789970398,
0.768979549407959,
0.7039083242416382,
-0.48814743757247925,
0.6328542828559875,
0.2603774964809418,
-0.35215678811073303,
0.5405860543251038,
-0.413227379322052,
0.5485474467277527,
-1.0615675449371338,
0.3403518497943878,
-0.0907454788684845,
-0.3408604562282562,
-0.5938023328781128,
0.3058773875236511,
0.18594756722450256,
-0.34630030393600464,
-0.2699238657951355,
0.5309780836105347,
-0.8970326781272888,
-0.4777395725250244,
-0.6804348826408386,
0.2303052544593811,
0.4608258306980133,
-0.014736711047589779,
-0.10040527582168579,
1.2457541227340698,
-0.08351073414087296,
-0.7314361333847046,
0.06338877975940704,
0.1467704474925995,
-0.022417189553380013,
0.8965170979499817,
-0.6208104491233826,
0.4474959969520569,
-0.2738015949726105,
0.04562299698591232,
-0.518626868724823,
-0.4365427494049072,
0.014616772532463074,
-0.8037590384483337,
1.2594369649887085,
0.0871867835521698,
-0.5517284870147705,
-0.4514946937561035,
-0.38793542981147766,
0.1669408082962036,
0.6227422952651978,
-0.32559090852737427,
0.8687993288040161,
0.6835812330245972,
-0.1385306566953659,
-0.7000695466995239,
-0.49212533235549927,
0.25319817662239075,
0.009954338893294334,
-0.6139435172080994,
0.5933694839477539,
0.11064104735851288,
-0.4022757411003113,
0.4791043996810913,
-0.3204434812068939,
-0.24471242725849152,
0.08333268761634827,
0.2618798613548279,
-0.024017333984375,
-0.22941111028194427,
0.189112588763237,
0.01858494058251381,
-0.15155860781669617,
-0.26372355222702026,
-0.03702845424413681,
0.3324008285999298,
0.07739842683076859,
-0.27572011947631836,
-0.10704629123210907,
0.7666965126991272,
0.33310452103614807,
-0.17415353655815125,
0.4354689121246338,
0.4176248610019684,
-0.2809751033782959,
-0.29493260383605957,
-0.8917633295059204,
0.37657245993614197,
-0.5968172550201416,
0.1373864710330963,
-0.684246838092804,
-0.6379338502883911,
0.4284154772758484,
-0.28535470366477966,
0.2881697118282318,
0.9281206130981445,
0.11656227707862854,
-0.681226909160614,
0.5904866456985474,
0.9547807574272156,
0.7030433416366577,
0.4694306552410126,
-0.4856693148612976,
-0.17165982723236084,
-1.23115873336792,
-0.14832650125026703,
-1.0055639743804932,
-0.1531798243522644,
-0.5116928219795227,
-0.5379428267478943,
0.49442392587661743,
0.11516678333282471,
-0.19901420176029205,
0.46680524945259094,
-0.7444992661476135,
0.223349928855896,
0.7941499948501587,
0.16247014701366425,
0.435605525970459,
0.14638391137123108,
0.0016455005388706923,
0.027459969744086266,
-0.6292855143547058,
-0.4910264015197754,
0.9269604086875916,
0.11633805185556412,
0.7396469116210938,
-0.17755433917045593,
0.9638317823410034,
0.49748826026916504,
0.4252772927284241,
-0.48243430256843567,
0.27433836460113525,
-0.5501832962036133,
-0.8205564022064209,
-0.1681654304265976,
-0.20356778800487518,
-1.1371121406555176,
-0.3465380370616913,
-0.11088144779205322,
-0.12130928039550781,
0.3923954963684082,
0.12501408159732819,
-0.04037221521139145,
0.3121546804904938,
-0.8079261183738708,
0.1507854461669922,
0.06484227627515793,
0.12967102229595184,
-0.0024029621854424477,
-0.4207645356655121,
0.2753722369670868,
-0.4086204767227173,
0.275644987821579,
0.4551030695438385,
-0.15208932757377625,
0.7336580157279968,
-0.5608964562416077,
0.43061843514442444,
-0.18839730322360992,
-0.0164652019739151,
0.7675622701644897,
0.1675158441066742,
0.5500487089157104,
-0.3690851032733917,
-0.24803073704242706,
-0.357314795255661,
-0.09861458092927933,
-0.3694460391998291,
-0.6674026250839233,
0.6021130681037903,
-0.6522799134254456,
-0.988172709941864,
-0.6921988129615784,
-0.49529823660850525,
-0.30072712898254395,
0.14581748843193054,
0.3746497929096222,
0.6223958730697632,
-0.0012638627085834742,
0.37185797095298767,
0.7832472920417786,
-0.32642021775245667,
0.29817551374435425,
0.4849403500556946,
-0.17206133902072906,
-0.4916110634803772,
1.129660964012146,
0.6866073608398438,
0.24348680675029755,
0.19702455401420593,
-0.10563947260379791,
0.12857328355312347,
-0.6848093271255493,
-0.4576154053211212,
0.27190226316452026,
-0.6746252775192261,
-0.35319778323173523,
-0.6743341088294983,
-0.5037363767623901,
-0.6064260601997375,
-0.27674973011016846,
-0.34251272678375244,
-0.7840461134910583,
-0.5545459985733032,
0.015539443120360374,
0.4482826292514801,
1.4919339418411255,
-0.21849316358566284,
0.10751946270465851,
-1.089489221572876,
0.6707525253295898,
0.05394073575735092,
0.6662449836730957,
-0.1186341643333435,
-0.6150624752044678,
-0.5525322556495667,
-0.09865991771221161,
-0.6342740654945374,
-0.6937139630317688,
0.15404313802719116,
-0.007381165400147438,
0.6879374384880066,
-0.3021042048931122,
0.20260250568389893,
0.5923691391944885,
-0.795061469078064,
0.8776452541351318,
-0.1874924749135971,
-0.5367519855499268,
0.6436857581138611,
-0.42473921179771423,
-0.027146467939019203,
0.4046778678894043,
0.5241326689720154,
-0.07089664041996002,
-0.4568921625614166,
-1.040641188621521,
-0.7674025297164917,
0.4675222933292389,
-0.00402823043987155,
0.08958008885383606,
-0.1970854252576828,
0.688377857208252,
0.02780093066394329,
0.05746550112962723,
-0.05478808656334877,
-0.29572609066963196,
-0.08718521147966385,
0.30036213994026184,
0.03985971212387085,
-0.4456522464752197,
0.014492034912109375,
0.273115873336792,
0.6368921995162964,
0.2875741124153137,
0.19665396213531494,
0.7355979681015015,
-0.01776987686753273,
-0.19571025669574738,
-0.08692911267280579,
0.8520376682281494,
0.49249330163002014,
-0.44956541061401367,
-0.19309523701667786,
-0.13935643434524536,
-0.8297173380851746,
0.11849106848239899,
-0.012693577446043491,
-0.2926839590072632,
0.4575083255767822,
0.1956101506948471,
0.49727752804756165,
-0.035351406782865524,
-0.04383167624473572,
0.17707033455371857,
-0.08458678424358368,
-0.47046786546707153,
-0.4445003569126129,
-0.08617948740720749,
-0.30404675006866455,
0.14852508902549744,
0.8446782231330872,
0.1158786192536354,
0.21086502075195312,
-0.49452143907546997,
0.3965911865234375,
0.5327418446540833,
-0.11480314284563065,
-0.10725262016057968,
0.31159457564353943,
0.3645923137664795,
-0.9149362444877625,
0.23360440135002136,
-0.4221619665622711,
-0.32310402393341064,
0.7043859958648682,
0.6152528524398804,
0.9926679134368896,
-0.16386081278324127,
0.2775100767612457,
0.05168510973453522,
0.4052410423755646,
0.014615439809858799,
0.44837257266044617,
-0.029182948172092438,
-0.3467872440814972,
-0.3533233404159546,
-0.4959490895271301,
-0.8732757568359375,
-0.35876330733299255,
-0.5509496927261353,
0.3037232458591461,
-0.34969669580459595,
-0.7033299803733826,
-0.31121304631233215,
0.22900456190109253,
-0.6832196116447449,
0.016203295439481735,
-0.27971386909484863,
1.0072444677352905,
-0.47366756200790405,
0.32389897108078003,
0.9594018459320068,
-0.492266982793808,
-0.8124533891677856,
-0.2386615127325058,
-0.2255924642086029,
-0.5434355139732361,
1.1229292154312134,
-0.4864535629749298,
-0.17799502611160278,
-0.07145309448242188,
-0.36641448736190796,
-1.0124495029449463,
1.1212788820266724,
-0.10462919622659683,
0.009485714137554169,
-0.29174500703811646,
-0.12711463868618011,
0.5262179970741272,
-0.1575021892786026,
-0.10038246214389801,
-0.02138991467654705,
0.382656067609787,
0.3603527545928955,
-1.2261542081832886,
-0.08040188252925873,
-0.31192827224731445,
-0.015356415882706642,
0.4542996287345886,
-0.475228488445282,
0.9322760105133057,
-0.004394263494759798,
-0.6170300245285034,
0.19822385907173157,
0.6226772665977478,
0.38836508989334106,
0.8973869681358337,
0.20736418664455414,
0.8549898266792297,
0.5843979120254517,
0.11220459640026093,
1.4759231805801392,
-0.08584047853946686,
0.13732430338859558,
1.2608482837677002,
-0.33666402101516724,
0.7832393050193787,
0.4937746226787567,
-0.025253688916563988,
0.5773699283599854,
0.4357766807079315,
0.16310150921344757,
0.17048431932926178,
-0.020174246281385422,
-0.28410613536834717,
0.2985791862010956,
-0.5209893584251404,
-0.7911700010299683,
0.1847807765007019,
0.6361874938011169,
-0.32302233576774597,
-0.09726174175739288,
0.15780451893806458,
-0.29663026332855225,
0.27486902475357056,
-0.048773061484098434,
0.8159021139144897,
0.11247996240854263,
-0.4762808382511139,
0.39807674288749695,
-0.2323157638311386,
0.6657918095588684,
-0.2639078199863434,
-0.3010321855545044,
-0.30128854513168335,
-0.20104604959487915,
-0.29605063796043396,
-0.8487661480903625,
0.7440391778945923,
0.07293074578046799,
-0.27019616961479187,
-0.4480011463165283,
1.004442572593689,
0.2564230263233185,
-0.3090381920337677,
-0.06987104564905167,
0.6439606547355652,
0.035132866352796555,
0.34464219212532043,
-0.20956943929195404,
-0.022014476358890533,
-0.246352419257164,
-0.5633355379104614,
0.45546621084213257,
0.8983511328697205,
-0.015045291744172573,
0.38520291447639465,
0.435270756483078,
0.16477593779563904,
0.11053620278835297,
-0.10392821580171585,
0.9798020124435425,
-0.6841505765914917,
0.018763776868581772,
0.04819490760564804,
0.6635127663612366,
-0.24117428064346313,
-0.15656350553035736,
0.8422034978866577,
0.6192631125450134,
0.820676326751709,
-0.15747864544391632,
0.5835907459259033,
-0.3807750940322876,
0.9653010964393616,
-0.3354892134666443,
0.7581472992897034,
-0.87391197681427,
0.13317455351352692,
-0.33319106698036194,
-0.8462917804718018,
-0.27226173877716064,
0.17708653211593628,
0.23778006434440613,
-0.00472851051017642,
0.9017714262008667,
0.6825346946716309,
0.04377860575914383,
-0.24153530597686768,
0.30644533038139343,
0.0763206034898758,
0.36895477771759033,
0.007619285024702549,
0.8455212712287903,
-0.7531142830848694,
0.3908455967903137,
-0.24890099465847015,
-0.2483873814344406,
0.006542775314301252,
-0.8978963494300842,
-0.5084095597267151,
-0.7650649547576904,
-0.18539850413799286,
-0.5504871010780334,
0.09707757830619812,
0.5353980660438538,
0.4709779620170593,
-0.6532941460609436,
0.023698311299085617,
0.20819054543972015,
0.24970412254333496,
0.3903377950191498,
-0.2635307013988495,
0.30168306827545166,
-0.6949289441108704,
-0.6534947156906128,
0.3058225214481354,
0.10696613788604736,
0.31836843490600586,
-0.02476760558784008,
0.06617342680692673,
-0.4155504107475281,
-0.07131417095661163,
0.6881612539291382,
0.6748121976852417,
-0.3022545278072357,
-0.4750830829143524,
0.3076542913913727,
-0.30603715777397156,
0.06232333555817604,
1.0432862043380737,
-0.890799880027771,
0.40572333335876465,
0.673408031463623,
0.9548548460006714,
0.5452116131782532,
0.09600967913866043,
0.637984037399292,
-1.0533558130264282,
0.026402272284030914,
0.30729031562805176,
0.26849719882011414,
0.2389671355485916,
-0.5431526899337769,
0.7614949345588684,
0.2714149057865143,
-0.9404389262199402,
-1.0983067750930786,
0.05199854448437691,
-0.8885836005210876,
-0.21091830730438232,
0.9012629389762878,
0.038393158465623856,
-0.068812295794487,
-0.357334703207016,
-0.4674766957759857,
0.3078784942626953,
-0.05350930616259575,
0.6037963032722473,
0.5422714352607727,
-0.2554398477077484,
0.17392127215862274,
-0.8411053419113159,
0.48032015562057495,
0.035969462245702744,
-0.4131718873977661,
-0.3096487522125244,
0.5437583327293396,
-0.007216603960841894,
0.7943339943885803,
0.8245305418968201,
-0.12232118844985962,
0.449293315410614,
0.2749938368797302,
-0.16322091221809387,
-0.37553009390830994,
-0.5177825093269348,
-0.17199261486530304,
0.3575991094112396,
0.30048221349716187,
-0.026680810377001762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00656v1
|
WavLLM: Towards Robust and Adaptive Speech Large Language Model
| 2024-03-31T12:01:32 | 2024-03-31T12:01:32 |
Shujie Hu, Long Zhou, Shujie Liu, Sanyuan Chen, Hongkun Hao, Jing Pan, Xunying Liu, Jinyu Li, Sunit Sivasankaran, Linquan Liu, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized
the field of natural language processing, progressively broadening their scope
to multimodal perception and generation. However, effectively integrating
listening capabilities into LLMs poses significant challenges, particularly
with respect to generalizing across varied contexts and executing complex
auditory tasks. In this work, we introduce WavLLM, a robust and adaptive speech
large language model with dual encoders, and a prompt-aware LoRA weight
adapter, optimized by a two-stage curriculum learning approach. Leveraging dual
encoders, we decouple different types of speech information, utilizing a
Whisper encoder to process the semantic content of speech, and a WavLM encoder
to capture the unique characteristics of the speaker's identity. Within the
curriculum learning framework, WavLLM first builds its foundational
capabilities by optimizing on mixed elementary single tasks, followed by
advanced multi-task training on more complex tasks such as combinations of the
elementary tasks. To enhance the flexibility and adherence to different tasks
and instructions, a prompt-aware LoRA weight adapter is introduced in the
second advanced multi-task training stage. We validate the proposed model on
universal speech benchmarks including tasks such as ASR, ST, SV, ER, and also
apply it to specialized datasets like Gaokao English listening comprehension
set for SQA, and speech Chain-of-Thought (CoT) evaluation set. Experiments
demonstrate that the proposed model achieves state-of-the-art performance
across a range of speech tasks on the same model size, exhibiting robust
generalization capabilities in executing complex tasks using CoT approach.
Furthermore, our model successfully completes Gaokao tasks without specialized
training. The codes, models, audio, and Gaokao evaluation set can be accessed
at \url{aka.ms/wavllm}.
|
[
-0.12529554963111877,
-0.9932769536972046,
0.277168869972229,
0.3945004343986511,
-0.04753218591213226,
-0.08816702663898468,
-0.402454137802124,
-0.32127106189727783,
-0.3638131022453308,
0.5985185503959656,
-0.5564602613449097,
-0.5434573292732239,
-0.5917215943336487,
-0.15775161981582642,
-0.22031095623970032,
0.5721076130867004,
0.1785847544670105,
0.16885657608509064,
-0.10348981618881226,
-0.5209178924560547,
-1.2145652770996094,
-0.3435378968715668,
-0.769915759563446,
-0.2845795452594757,
0.38655349612236023,
0.3029005229473114,
0.2571706473827362,
0.3666738271713257,
0.020575856789946556,
0.28581440448760986,
-0.19410452246665955,
0.14820176362991333,
-0.37525954842567444,
0.2639467120170593,
-0.11547058820724487,
-0.5611065030097961,
-0.6233972311019897,
-0.17684532701969147,
0.8254185318946838,
0.6119205355644226,
-0.49849259853363037,
0.11389974504709244,
0.2842772901058197,
0.4195478856563568,
-0.34392955899238586,
0.3005184531211853,
-0.904339075088501,
-0.17590521275997162,
0.09652215987443924,
0.06442175805568695,
-0.4268803000450134,
-0.03902750834822655,
0.22255712747573853,
-0.4650666117668152,
-0.24923643469810486,
-0.03912728279829025,
0.1737256795167923,
0.4442892372608185,
-0.482921838760376,
-0.4829529821872711,
-0.5497432351112366,
1.108583927154541,
-0.7951079607009888,
0.505158007144928,
0.3148624300956726,
0.34212052822113037,
-0.19538196921348572,
-0.4575978219509125,
-0.3526577055454254,
-0.22569575905799866,
0.629403293132782,
0.2086215615272522,
-0.33186018466949463,
-0.09996803104877472,
0.29482904076576233,
0.11754709482192993,
-0.6264247298240662,
0.5781064033508301,
-0.1676519364118576,
-0.1814863383769989,
0.3321067690849304,
0.24706459045410156,
0.36623626947402954,
0.15910200774669647,
-0.44787025451660156,
0.06756877154111862,
-0.36752089858055115,
0.37816861271858215,
0.32489213347435,
0.5921570658683777,
-0.46589481830596924,
0.36568787693977356,
0.03901321813464165,
0.8357687592506409,
-0.09257158637046814,
-0.525894284248352,
0.16053131222724915,
-0.12623494863510132,
-0.17790105938911438,
0.20693272352218628,
0.6513403058052063,
-0.0857410877943039,
0.18752208352088928,
0.20143748819828033,
-0.09161560982465744,
0.17420700192451477,
0.047549113631248474,
-0.6817746162414551,
0.11619216203689575,
0.3070208728313446,
-0.3037022650241852,
-0.0762077122926712,
-0.4186919331550598,
-0.5558918714523315,
-0.35920050740242004,
-0.3964948356151581,
0.6858500838279724,
-0.5024263858795166,
-0.14623789489269257,
0.3422017991542816,
0.29922938346862793,
0.35120999813079834,
0.4757503271102905,
-0.7911403775215149,
0.37010371685028076,
0.5270636677742004,
0.8872325420379639,
-0.2695608139038086,
-0.3357591927051544,
-1.1753838062286377,
0.2020701915025711,
-0.04550845921039581,
0.3832627832889557,
-0.49917352199554443,
-0.35621917247772217,
0.014368179254233837,
-0.09417648613452911,
-0.20392249524593353,
-0.46004584431648254,
0.7306608557701111,
-0.43690764904022217,
0.1710149347782135,
-0.03744877874851227,
-0.4992198944091797,
-0.22537478804588318,
0.12602780759334564,
-0.47312337160110474,
0.8196458220481873,
0.019173283129930496,
-0.5136231780052185,
0.12089814990758896,
-0.5901141166687012,
-0.5826059579849243,
-0.06958015263080597,
0.2001577913761139,
-0.16398292779922485,
0.004816581029444933,
0.33652618527412415,
0.3933466076850891,
-0.3887213468551636,
0.28733208775520325,
-0.09831790626049042,
-0.25367650389671326,
0.16732849180698395,
-0.4146841764450073,
0.7668745517730713,
0.21965862810611725,
-0.026770181953907013,
0.5547990202903748,
-0.9663748145103455,
0.01433125976473093,
0.10851770639419556,
-0.7011692523956299,
-0.08684875816106796,
0.14498816430568695,
0.20863085985183716,
0.13556285202503204,
0.19874316453933716,
-0.3463292717933655,
0.018545713275671005,
-0.3655901253223419,
0.7202953100204468,
0.7117780447006226,
-0.22165259718894958,
0.2933841943740845,
-0.3104066550731659,
0.3980145752429962,
-0.09243379533290863,
-0.05191075801849365,
-0.3855898678302765,
-0.5416488647460938,
-0.5791997313499451,
-0.39399826526641846,
0.12036211043596268,
0.7961874604225159,
-0.38098499178886414,
0.6105220913887024,
0.034455057233572006,
-0.22092102468013763,
-0.6250753998756409,
0.32653090357780457,
0.10421991348266602,
0.7177269458770752,
0.49458861351013184,
-0.09249575436115265,
-0.5774050951004028,
-0.43436217308044434,
-0.1747715175151825,
-0.18631187081336975,
-0.1722184419631958,
0.03264594450592995,
0.12040836364030838,
-0.35619446635246277,
0.7336763739585876,
-0.1782130002975464,
-0.48399150371551514,
-0.4462627172470093,
0.0571494959294796,
0.39363953471183777,
0.3519369065761566,
0.1341966688632965,
-0.6877020001411438,
-0.07873840630054474,
-0.1499839723110199,
-0.5870290994644165,
-0.2667691707611084,
-0.05852749943733215,
0.26531803607940674,
-0.020977932959794998,
0.3976655602455139,
-0.26085034012794495,
0.04843204468488693,
0.6919569373130798,
-0.11307089030742645,
0.429830938577652,
-0.2541705369949341,
-0.17614945769309998,
-1.2590019702911377,
-0.14225861430168152,
-0.040400322526693344,
-0.40590980648994446,
-0.6853630542755127,
0.03070296347141266,
-0.053317341953516006,
-0.26508674025535583,
-0.46051257848739624,
0.39707180857658386,
-0.3612315356731415,
0.011852340772747993,
-0.6381723284721375,
0.2705709934234619,
-0.05019218474626541,
0.43538132309913635,
-0.04131836071610451,
0.5929855108261108,
1.0247416496276855,
-0.6935190558433533,
0.5469512939453125,
0.21795383095741272,
-0.44562655687332153,
0.8163145184516907,
-0.8601438999176025,
0.22553220391273499,
-0.0684572383761406,
0.2053501456975937,
-0.9380546808242798,
-0.10396959632635117,
-0.03366607427597046,
-0.2942562997341156,
0.3766096532344818,
-0.07857416570186615,
-0.20381076633930206,
-0.2891385555267334,
-0.14029692113399506,
0.20532450079917908,
0.795295000076294,
-0.5091992020606995,
0.8857959508895874,
0.4817053973674774,
-0.38020676374435425,
-0.3794216215610504,
-0.5747808218002319,
0.04174020141363144,
-0.3632252812385559,
-0.6906620860099792,
-0.09514998644590378,
-0.34887999296188354,
-0.09318572282791138,
-0.47895827889442444,
-0.12475797533988953,
0.017312802374362946,
0.12572956085205078,
0.3717547655105591,
0.27181363105773926,
-0.33135977387428284,
0.15664231777191162,
-0.09450268000364304,
-0.01830131746828556,
0.07914033532142639,
-0.4399927258491516,
0.6087363958358765,
-0.09058941155672073,
-0.36323150992393494,
-0.566336989402771,
0.3111647069454193,
0.7409719228744507,
-0.34088772535324097,
0.4322251081466675,
1.0080088376998901,
-0.5931679010391235,
-0.3682556450366974,
-0.609835147857666,
0.13932548463344574,
-0.4051603376865387,
0.7123124599456787,
-0.43276679515838623,
-0.9189290404319763,
0.4423154592514038,
-0.05033421888947487,
0.21074283123016357,
0.0961998850107193,
0.74639892578125,
0.06451443582773209,
0.9389187693595886,
0.45393893122673035,
-0.32713782787323,
0.43389570713043213,
0.0597919262945652,
-0.016095144674181938,
-1.0748450756072998,
-0.26447227597236633,
-0.6047825813293457,
-0.07291899621486664,
-0.1098463237285614,
-0.6213630437850952,
0.19982671737670898,
0.06387446075677872,
-0.19756509363651276,
0.13300351798534393,
-0.19450615346431732,
0.09226274490356445,
0.5392665863037109,
0.04314465448260307,
0.30560359358787537,
-0.1421729326248169,
0.1225673034787178,
0.04272470623254776,
-0.5640735626220703,
-0.4893832504749298,
0.9046837091445923,
0.5487973093986511,
1.0691879987716675,
0.08280627429485321,
0.2737918198108673,
0.2813393473625183,
-0.16913188993930817,
-1.1087721586227417,
0.48635438084602356,
-0.13887453079223633,
-0.015653615817427635,
-0.3999367654323578,
-0.36655423045158386,
-0.7901653051376343,
0.38039156794548035,
-0.2503105103969574,
-0.84507155418396,
-0.2049233317375183,
0.03490114212036133,
-0.18718533217906952,
0.21788372099399567,
-0.5429975390434265,
0.6058641076087952,
-0.21750080585479736,
-0.2523655593395233,
-0.2995229661464691,
-0.6274392604827881,
0.32756397128105164,
-0.35486122965812683,
0.5003743767738342,
-0.36221474409103394,
-0.13167978823184967,
0.9731693863868713,
-0.06331302970647812,
0.7720478773117065,
-0.3064229488372803,
-0.43898093700408936,
0.45850875973701477,
-0.2237975150346756,
0.5221773386001587,
0.07041769474744797,
-0.2688142955303192,
0.007896585389971733,
0.013890390284359455,
-0.39266568422317505,
-0.26780253648757935,
0.8547621369361877,
-0.8615057468414307,
-0.649970531463623,
-0.21045391261577606,
-1.0661675930023193,
-0.6105839610099792,
0.20415353775024414,
0.05307262763381004,
0.5966235995292664,
-0.2876818776130676,
0.173133984208107,
0.8319108486175537,
-0.3529544472694397,
0.4386415183544159,
0.6059961915016174,
-0.1952514499425888,
-0.3780438303947449,
0.7465541362762451,
-0.0418427512049675,
0.3758739233016968,
0.3883298635482788,
0.3837638199329376,
-0.41424310207366943,
-0.8741272687911987,
-0.3046875298023224,
-0.04109615832567215,
-0.6695052981376648,
-0.07220885157585144,
-0.7873777747154236,
-0.07011008262634277,
-0.43704697489738464,
0.08474771678447723,
-0.20798546075820923,
-0.02005930431187153,
-0.4654618203639984,
0.20933915674686432,
0.15433278679847717,
0.5636793375015259,
0.11963508278131485,
0.1963982731103897,
-0.6176325082778931,
0.7014756202697754,
0.7574443817138672,
-0.0377916544675827,
0.06225157901644707,
-1.0083589553833008,
-0.0421740859746933,
0.2048238217830658,
-0.1280636340379715,
-0.589414656162262,
0.17852291464805603,
0.35760897397994995,
0.5499604940414429,
0.1724923849105835,
-0.07193180173635483,
0.563663125038147,
-0.45940709114074707,
0.7214662432670593,
0.4240354299545288,
-1.0976790189743042,
0.6966311931610107,
-0.3802793622016907,
0.7843492031097412,
0.19753898680210114,
-0.04595908522605896,
-0.5054818987846375,
-0.2422896921634674,
-0.00417483551427722,
-0.7432141304016113,
0.6432157754898071,
-0.21136754751205444,
0.21569615602493286,
0.3701462149620056,
-0.018564336001873016,
0.21624040603637695,
-0.15888287127017975,
-0.5867244601249695,
0.08507545292377472,
-0.1976277232170105,
-0.4303784966468811,
0.10103872418403625,
-0.3355945944786072,
-0.03959375619888306,
-0.07076437026262283,
0.7211137413978577,
-0.3974344730377197,
-0.17796798050403595,
-0.1288406103849411,
-0.32517170906066895,
-0.04012160748243332,
0.7438468933105469,
0.5825517177581787,
0.6203154921531677,
-0.1682150959968567,
0.00827668234705925,
0.6161891222000122,
-0.5520765781402588,
0.20545798540115356,
0.13261033594608307,
0.16191047430038452,
-0.28413933515548706,
0.5831981897354126,
1.0165787935256958,
0.500912070274353,
-0.9105415344238281,
0.4325895607471466,
-0.1358596533536911,
-0.06308397650718689,
-0.10476432740688324,
0.36823737621307373,
0.4168127477169037,
0.3732081949710846,
0.5476929545402527,
-0.026662927120923996,
-0.06923878937959671,
-0.6659073829650879,
-0.041878968477249146,
0.4031190574169159,
-0.570289134979248,
-0.31774380803108215,
0.9391776323318481,
0.1017395481467247,
-0.34454232454299927,
0.33581820130348206,
0.25603047013282776,
-0.1456608921289444,
0.39227381348609924,
0.9216911792755127,
0.6377396583557129,
-0.5293434262275696,
-0.1811842918395996,
0.29350125789642334,
0.19173696637153625,
-0.1439235359430313,
0.4152739644050598,
0.07378015667200089,
-0.5807472467422485,
-0.3192000985145569,
-0.873863697052002,
-0.29388001561164856,
0.20779788494110107,
-0.924580454826355,
0.3861585855484009,
-0.4311660826206207,
-0.12661758065223694,
-0.154927060008049,
-0.2819766700267792,
-0.6993266940116882,
0.15249040722846985,
0.31987693905830383,
0.9627805948257446,
-0.6719464063644409,
1.0626550912857056,
0.605269193649292,
0.031477417796850204,
-0.7118279933929443,
-0.12369780242443085,
0.12167352437973022,
-1.0316253900527954,
0.21670997142791748,
0.2011650651693344,
-0.3124808371067047,
0.07810866832733154,
-0.23257221281528473,
-0.680501401424408,
1.1297369003295898,
0.4137766361236572,
-0.9568148851394653,
-0.0610656775534153,
-0.2160855084657669,
0.2830807864665985,
-0.43876132369041443,
-0.07739690691232681,
0.43598273396492004,
0.29650256037712097,
0.20938032865524292,
-1.0146092176437378,
0.04619719833135605,
0.22718150913715363,
0.13496990501880646,
-0.14237172901630402,
-0.5351197719573975,
0.6948530673980713,
-0.4777529239654541,
-0.010856039822101593,
0.34012165665626526,
0.8412889242172241,
0.39645683765411377,
0.1753319352865219,
0.6768888831138611,
0.3273638188838959,
1.0222080945968628,
-0.055567335337400436,
0.6112749576568604,
0.042924825102090836,
0.10996666550636292,
1.3282617330551147,
-0.5817058086395264,
0.958479106426239,
0.4046051502227783,
-0.2351868450641632,
0.2895622253417969,
0.2010076493024826,
0.14665019512176514,
0.452754944562912,
0.27836933732032776,
-0.3626757860183716,
-0.25226718187332153,
-0.3120342493057251,
-0.4025547504425049,
0.713687002658844,
0.48005563020706177,
0.005690544843673706,
0.03874997794628143,
0.47914114594459534,
-0.26610565185546875,
0.1629144251346588,
-0.6234065890312195,
0.8144300580024719,
0.29743972420692444,
-0.3291078805923462,
0.5460236072540283,
0.0310005322098732,
0.9363981485366821,
-0.9824597239494324,
0.12306438386440277,
0.2347438782453537,
0.08312392979860306,
-0.0961056798696518,
-0.5825380086898804,
0.0021339058876037598,
0.06216263771057129,
-0.24282535910606384,
0.051778506487607956,
0.7960785031318665,
-0.6060232520103455,
-0.42316070199012756,
0.44028037786483765,
0.4951406717300415,
-0.18039874732494354,
0.03428327664732933,
-0.5634517073631287,
0.584509015083313,
-0.16300390660762787,
-0.08202647417783737,
0.28024834394454956,
0.213908851146698,
0.036088839173316956,
0.700893223285675,
0.6985086798667908,
0.07982027530670166,
0.12592703104019165,
0.5049079656600952,
0.511762261390686,
-0.5453330278396606,
-0.7089966535568237,
-0.669600248336792,
0.39033547043800354,
0.3605111837387085,
-0.04792541638016701,
0.6639338135719299,
0.3756776452064514,
0.4785800874233246,
-0.0065053366124629974,
0.8818220496177673,
0.21700070798397064,
0.4528566002845764,
-0.8814689517021179,
0.4172428846359253,
-0.30752894282341003,
0.31946876645088196,
-0.2084125131368637,
-0.9609547257423401,
-0.13429006934165955,
0.5134581327438354,
-0.07023727148771286,
0.038972314447164536,
0.4406372010707855,
0.5016832947731018,
-0.024470629170536995,
0.1745576113462448,
0.526380717754364,
0.40158790349960327,
0.36236512660980225,
0.8201479315757751,
0.860035240650177,
-0.3582703471183777,
0.5790266990661621,
0.2949688732624054,
-0.31088438630104065,
-0.07271641492843628,
-0.7189990282058716,
-0.9526370167732239,
-0.5439771413803101,
-0.36534175276756287,
-0.2102481722831726,
-0.032376740127801895,
0.9509075880050659,
0.814098596572876,
-0.7806944251060486,
-0.2878470718860626,
0.18569332361221313,
0.06244901567697525,
-0.19177429378032684,
-0.2060365229845047,
0.1908237636089325,
-0.26972314715385437,
-0.8011748790740967,
0.9323670864105225,
0.43725132942199707,
-0.017917193472385406,
-0.1112477034330368,
-0.3284108638763428,
-0.14908720552921295,
0.14851529896259308,
0.7232292890548706,
0.17584604024887085,
-0.9836722016334534,
-0.2990935742855072,
-0.24544879794120789,
-0.00570304412394762,
0.05091384798288345,
0.6038268804550171,
-0.7293935418128967,
0.5841037034988403,
0.1620056927204132,
0.6535601019859314,
0.35195237398147583,
-0.10767443478107452,
0.3629445731639862,
-0.5192198753356934,
0.19811062514781952,
0.12347254157066345,
0.5738460421562195,
0.5088322162628174,
-0.060729775577783585,
0.14066362380981445,
-0.04263428598642349,
-0.385649710893631,
-0.8352708220481873,
0.2551406919956207,
-1.4778797626495361,
-0.20503222942352295,
1.0825181007385254,
-0.08080010116100311,
-0.09430486708879471,
-0.23223106563091278,
-0.5498116612434387,
0.35996827483177185,
-0.34928980469703674,
0.3686772882938385,
0.6212656497955322,
0.09670275449752808,
-0.199718177318573,
-0.6897343397140503,
-0.15502385795116425,
0.33184295892715454,
-0.8104037642478943,
0.029431505128741264,
0.3516954779624939,
0.5887225866317749,
-0.18524062633514404,
0.47667640447616577,
0.018208781257271767,
0.29162487387657166,
-0.2113039344549179,
-0.11836657673120499,
-0.27182191610336304,
-0.13603945076465607,
-0.6776645183563232,
0.2579062283039093,
0.2996813952922821,
-0.32073575258255005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01345v1
|
Enhancing Bangla Fake News Detection Using Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Units and Deep Learning Techniques
| 2024-03-31T09:52:25 | 2024-03-31T09:52:25 |
Utsha Roy, Mst. Sazia Tahosin, Md. Mahedi Hassan, Taminul Islam, Fahim Imtiaz, Md Rezwane Sadik, Yassine Maleh, Rejwan Bin Sulaiman, Md. Simul Hasan Talukder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rise of fake news has made the need for effective detection methods,
including in languages other than English, increasingly important. The study
aims to address the challenges of Bangla which is considered a less important
language. To this end, a complete dataset containing about 50,000 news items is
proposed. Several deep learning models have been tested on this dataset,
including the bidirectional gated recurrent unit (GRU), the long short-term
memory (LSTM), the 1D convolutional neural network (CNN), and hybrid
architectures. For this research, we assessed the efficacy of the model
utilizing a range of useful measures, including recall, precision, F1 score,
and accuracy. This was done by employing a big application. We carry out
comprehensive trials to show the effectiveness of these models in identifying
bogus news in Bangla, with the Bidirectional GRU model having a stunning
accuracy of 99.16%. Our analysis highlights the importance of dataset balance
and the need for continual improvement efforts to a substantial degree. This
study makes a major contribution to the creation of Bangla fake news detecting
systems with limited resources, thereby setting the stage for future
improvements in the detection process.
|
[
-0.20692549645900726,
-1.0850722789764404,
0.15874841809272766,
0.5089291930198669,
-0.5260413289070129,
0.379668265581131,
0.12118358165025711,
-0.6678081154823303,
0.16208085417747498,
0.21455660462379456,
-0.08748580515384674,
-0.320936381816864,
-0.5043246746063232,
0.009580498561263084,
-0.48527494072914124,
1.008584976196289,
-0.004929647780954838,
0.14701159298419952,
0.2336103767156601,
-0.08790229260921478,
-0.9798073172569275,
-0.18966476619243622,
-0.5954673886299133,
-0.20585153996944427,
0.5466355085372925,
0.1613040417432785,
0.5897921919822693,
0.0462985560297966,
0.2605281472206116,
0.16682696342468262,
-0.10483358800411224,
0.4598827064037323,
-0.47151267528533936,
-0.3431450426578522,
-0.42329689860343933,
-0.26086267828941345,
-0.17686985433101654,
-0.05407918244600296,
0.8253517150878906,
0.36803239583969116,
-0.12838038802146912,
0.05059623345732689,
-0.25727277994155884,
0.8170359134674072,
-0.49138638377189636,
0.017136158421635628,
-0.5976144671440125,
-0.07885660976171494,
-0.2811111807823181,
-0.10447115451097488,
-0.3379782736301422,
-0.6408714056015015,
-0.2257004678249359,
-0.042707640677690506,
0.19924283027648926,
-0.14154581725597382,
1.0918666124343872,
-0.07993318140506744,
-0.6539162397384644,
-0.38434892892837524,
-0.6693172454833984,
0.40286460518836975,
-0.882162868976593,
0.5268542170524597,
0.033833812922239304,
0.36421483755111694,
-0.36930420994758606,
-0.2240314483642578,
-0.8894023299217224,
-0.2049388587474823,
-0.06661493331193924,
0.2442646026611328,
-0.11030702292919159,
-0.12566550076007843,
-0.048846613615751266,
0.36043229699134827,
-0.8582107424736023,
0.08292470872402191,
-0.6806707978248596,
-0.21247470378875732,
0.6967965960502625,
-0.150868222117424,
0.2513418197631836,
-0.3953689932823181,
-0.41047078371047974,
0.23216195404529572,
-0.6935549378395081,
-0.09036856889724731,
0.5527842044830322,
0.4451710283756256,
-0.006554476451128721,
0.1911981850862503,
-0.4436914026737213,
0.9130839109420776,
0.10981972515583038,
-0.5446739196777344,
0.311266154050827,
-0.49067261815071106,
-0.5515288710594177,
0.2632589042186737,
0.31423816084861755,
0.11617523431777954,
0.08471468091011047,
0.006005604285746813,
-0.2510112524032593,
0.3112570345401764,
0.4045516848564148,
-0.7073701024055481,
0.02775922231376171,
0.04785432294011116,
-0.4937617778778076,
-0.3395897150039673,
0.058060381561517715,
-0.5498754382133484,
-0.4281993806362152,
-0.44698649644851685,
0.4597412943840027,
-0.34240248799324036,
-0.5764786601066589,
0.34386685490608215,
0.14237967133522034,
0.2968873381614685,
0.4866483211517334,
-0.3010711073875427,
-0.1825624704360962,
0.48515862226486206,
0.736253023147583,
-0.008198355324566364,
-0.009482348337769508,
-0.365283340215683,
-0.13780269026756287,
-0.6252068281173706,
0.692443311214447,
-0.49080514907836914,
-0.13287460803985596,
-0.09664102643728256,
0.17244169116020203,
-0.051424942910671234,
-0.4926515221595764,
0.6110294461250305,
-0.8674120903015137,
0.1322360336780548,
-0.13127575814723969,
-0.4219599962234497,
-0.5907950401306152,
0.2951801121234894,
-0.5292462706565857,
0.7260770201683044,
0.15795210003852844,
-0.482306569814682,
0.3356876075267792,
-0.10560227185487747,
-0.8699055910110474,
0.176825150847435,
-0.0608799122273922,
-0.6875542402267456,
0.3686259984970093,
0.30244582891464233,
0.4143981635570526,
0.1609722226858139,
0.5259114503860474,
0.04863452538847923,
-0.6805238723754883,
0.14624498784542084,
-0.7272083163261414,
0.7635766863822937,
0.40062907338142395,
-0.4056447446346283,
-0.1363265961408615,
-0.5370693206787109,
-0.30010658502578735,
-0.009823616594076157,
-0.44069579243659973,
-0.24719470739364624,
-0.4299958646297455,
0.16634336113929749,
0.11735167354345322,
-0.0028387641068547964,
-0.7066735029220581,
0.23769599199295044,
-0.33790141344070435,
-0.20858876407146454,
0.578673779964447,
0.05231242626905441,
-0.024191824719309807,
-0.30082860589027405,
0.41521307826042175,
0.3669372498989105,
0.0214220080524683,
-0.23368830978870392,
-0.43211618065834045,
-0.5070828199386597,
-0.23735065758228302,
0.49376004934310913,
0.42764875292778015,
-0.6980313062667847,
0.1556367427110672,
-0.144365131855011,
-0.3315355181694031,
-0.6003502607345581,
0.16501401364803314,
0.3260026276111603,
0.4406728446483612,
0.13318657875061035,
-0.19730651378631592,
-0.6704753041267395,
-0.9013856053352356,
-0.285178005695343,
0.030652783811092377,
0.38570886850357056,
0.01479833573102951,
0.5492073893547058,
-0.2660439908504486,
0.8728534579277039,
-0.0002596203703433275,
-0.09065722674131393,
-0.2529430091381073,
0.19590412080287933,
0.4176490306854248,
0.2493598908185959,
0.5755310654640198,
-1.469469428062439,
-0.45483145117759705,
0.08874813467264175,
-0.6525667905807495,
-0.04078331217169762,
-0.3882848024368286,
0.269771546125412,
0.8239732980728149,
0.1961819976568222,
-0.6006610989570618,
0.7431268692016602,
0.3589976727962494,
-0.35313111543655396,
0.7046432495117188,
0.03937026113271713,
0.4963238537311554,
-1.0101419687271118,
-0.13976392149925232,
0.13105599582195282,
-0.6184077858924866,
-0.6417232155799866,
0.18468497693538666,
0.17734165489673615,
-0.15051430463790894,
-0.5053248405456543,
0.5380325317382812,
-0.3083534240722656,
-0.023399844765663147,
-0.7269658446311951,
0.13182677328586578,
0.02024916745722294,
0.10634829103946686,
0.038904815912246704,
0.5770192742347717,
0.22814753651618958,
-0.42507505416870117,
0.6477769613265991,
-0.2494991421699524,
-0.5147403478622437,
0.4171144664287567,
-0.4730522930622101,
-0.10755182802677155,
-0.4335375130176544,
0.3882195055484772,
-1.071048378944397,
-0.293545663356781,
0.3644050657749176,
-0.5819770693778992,
0.5339388847351074,
-0.08007274568080902,
-0.6815700531005859,
-0.6626386046409607,
-0.0594291128218174,
0.2735722064971924,
0.32324156165122986,
-0.6672439575195312,
0.26029661297798157,
0.19649262726306915,
0.05883309617638588,
-0.6510370969772339,
-0.6175059676170349,
0.14667338132858276,
-0.006805501412600279,
-0.49121782183647156,
0.09387807548046112,
0.1754339337348938,
-0.04185173660516739,
0.08335608243942261,
-0.3844381868839264,
0.060655377805233,
-0.08222609758377075,
0.17328596115112305,
0.2622213065624237,
-0.24526166915893555,
0.2794227600097656,
0.08653073012828827,
0.09076718986034393,
-0.19463741779327393,
-0.13269290328025818,
0.39703163504600525,
-0.41289055347442627,
-0.4382375180721283,
-0.7012621760368347,
0.3136739134788513,
0.703438937664032,
0.010592199862003326,
0.8129734396934509,
0.8633416891098022,
-0.7410998940467834,
-0.06610672920942307,
-0.8820320963859558,
0.04691360145807266,
-0.3632795214653015,
0.4461140036582947,
-0.13105890154838562,
-0.5530616641044617,
0.18701164424419403,
0.04506784677505493,
-0.46816515922546387,
0.062022238969802856,
0.6435396075248718,
0.2566114366054535,
0.7766949534416199,
0.5358448624610901,
-0.6494734287261963,
0.1554904282093048,
0.05265680328011513,
0.7802993059158325,
-0.23329883813858032,
-0.3236548602581024,
0.031129896640777588,
-0.2862623333930969,
-0.529407262802124,
-0.46907925605773926,
0.01882847025990486,
0.2537841796875,
0.004560600500553846,
0.21595904231071472,
-0.47576871514320374,
0.5383182168006897,
0.43627992272377014,
0.3382009267807007,
0.4848814904689789,
0.16556094586849213,
0.38039565086364746,
0.15050356090068817,
-0.4156225025653839,
-0.5050100088119507,
0.7940318584442139,
0.4499812722206116,
0.840995728969574,
0.1458878368139267,
0.3507198095321655,
0.7181577086448669,
0.27832505106925964,
-0.5505829453468323,
0.3767814338207245,
0.03691081330180168,
-0.6962319612503052,
-0.03077763132750988,
-0.3923063576221466,
-0.6812142729759216,
0.24455009400844574,
0.07528497278690338,
-0.2677982449531555,
0.28755444288253784,
-0.07692227512598038,
-0.4609679579734802,
0.5781205892562866,
-0.7969330549240112,
0.465070515871048,
-0.2534545063972473,
-0.348497211933136,
-0.46254104375839233,
-0.3561228811740875,
0.6551337242126465,
-0.2072979211807251,
0.01570054516196251,
-0.0863928496837616,
0.3517076075077057,
0.38035520911216736,
0.12149199098348618,
0.9434413313865662,
-0.24357636272907257,
-0.17458359897136688,
0.3643271327018738,
-0.14508670568466187,
0.5524797439575195,
0.33587515354156494,
0.14126068353652954,
0.3148224353790283,
-0.3122982680797577,
-0.7731170058250427,
-0.2852751314640045,
0.8987504243850708,
-0.40739449858665466,
-0.6033286452293396,
-0.6393547058105469,
-0.8523061275482178,
0.05702296644449234,
0.0817606970667839,
-0.09311163425445557,
0.35959452390670776,
-0.03828687220811844,
0.3163726329803467,
0.6488041877746582,
-0.3135416507720947,
0.489330530166626,
0.6284003257751465,
-0.5382511615753174,
-0.056172486394643784,
0.9469296932220459,
0.29311197996139526,
-0.09352229535579681,
0.15726149082183838,
0.004282505251467228,
-0.235109344124794,
-0.7146007418632507,
-0.6280447244644165,
0.20171919465065002,
-0.25769737362861633,
-0.48121848702430725,
-0.325885534286499,
-0.5776403546333313,
-0.631635844707489,
-0.10267239809036255,
-0.30499011278152466,
-0.0990077406167984,
-0.01867055334150791,
-0.22227883338928223,
0.14689601957798004,
0.6426399350166321,
-0.10732914507389069,
0.18755599856376648,
-0.6351160407066345,
0.6775605082511902,
0.34234005212783813,
0.1934964507818222,
-0.06210501119494438,
-0.6984069347381592,
-0.3259687125682831,
0.4590240716934204,
-0.23421575129032135,
-0.8388339281082153,
0.589431643486023,
-0.250815749168396,
0.4377789795398712,
0.6858208775520325,
-0.09325302392244339,
0.698631227016449,
-0.09400562196969986,
0.4984528720378876,
0.011846731416881084,
-0.6965458989143372,
0.7755346298217773,
-0.6057366728782654,
0.014010208658874035,
0.22807331383228302,
0.7135660648345947,
-0.4370811879634857,
-0.10296029597520828,
-0.274946004152298,
-0.3428362309932709,
0.42897194623947144,
0.2143830806016922,
0.17214126884937286,
0.05137045681476593,
0.4305632412433624,
0.24470262229442596,
0.48379483819007874,
-1.160181999206543,
-0.19179467856884003,
-0.12090490013360977,
-0.025879239663481712,
0.26081782579421997,
-0.4405994415283203,
0.2643279433250427,
-0.393405020236969,
0.8920016884803772,
0.30217450857162476,
-0.022455327212810516,
0.2582547962665558,
-0.24529358744621277,
0.03688652813434601,
0.2418537586927414,
0.8126949071884155,
1.038586139678955,
-0.24056920409202576,
-0.20902912318706512,
0.011590121313929558,
-0.5236541628837585,
0.19216977059841156,
0.10952422022819519,
-0.47021663188934326,
0.4344847798347473,
0.15143771469593048,
0.7239303588867188,
-0.17892591655254364,
-0.7348260283470154,
0.5553914904594421,
0.41244935989379883,
0.06246479973196983,
-0.3267093002796173,
-0.18232624232769012,
0.00566215580329299,
0.37924760580062866,
0.7825281620025635,
0.14508570730686188,
0.02868756838142872,
-0.8027792572975159,
0.30928364396095276,
0.4738703668117523,
-0.34494805335998535,
-0.19204682111740112,
0.26126325130462646,
0.12227099388837814,
-0.2504245936870575,
0.4596007764339447,
-0.7258113622665405,
-0.726980447769165,
0.6454446911811829,
0.9560667872428894,
0.24100762605667114,
-0.5593454241752625,
0.729468584060669,
0.23185069859027863,
0.6412174701690674,
-0.24929356575012207,
0.01665029488503933,
0.2982282340526581,
-0.7460355758666992,
-0.3945218324661255,
-0.7882667779922485,
-0.036080796271562576,
0.6515442728996277,
-0.35728147625923157,
0.3019874095916748,
-0.2953849136829376,
0.21700698137283325,
-0.3453863561153412,
0.4716692268848419,
-0.2283594310283661,
0.3718838393688202,
0.5712959170341492,
0.8772295117378235,
-1.123916506767273,
0.8667405843734741,
0.4732624590396881,
-0.26399755477905273,
-0.5095431208610535,
-0.04706823080778122,
0.13435937464237213,
-0.6063060164451599,
0.7646836638450623,
0.46914711594581604,
-0.0250104907900095,
-0.24921241402626038,
-0.34054863452911377,
-0.46368706226348877,
0.740918755531311,
0.261631041765213,
-0.863840639591217,
0.10594318062067032,
0.23984718322753906,
0.4658220112323761,
-0.41821223497390747,
-0.11790357530117035,
0.59056556224823,
0.5421779751777649,
0.1349734663963318,
-0.6611437797546387,
0.1328355073928833,
-0.30284765362739563,
-0.08297356218099594,
0.3186906576156616,
-0.8408734202384949,
0.9086146950721741,
-0.1850598007440567,
-0.32102566957473755,
-0.18282780051231384,
0.8232064247131348,
0.1946386843919754,
0.9102593660354614,
0.22800703346729279,
0.8045644164085388,
0.8468829393386841,
0.05845269933342934,
0.7983217239379883,
0.26906803250312805,
0.3090185225009918,
1.134627103805542,
-0.25054869055747986,
0.47947654128074646,
0.13364267349243164,
-0.09829907864332199,
0.6695231795310974,
0.732715368270874,
-0.26430535316467285,
0.49924466013908386,
0.26665642857551575,
-0.5719518065452576,
-0.10290493816137314,
-0.2798733413219452,
-0.5273893475532532,
0.38502800464630127,
0.40210679173469543,
-0.2375493347644806,
-0.5526062250137329,
0.6233250498771667,
0.12218548357486725,
0.19904185831546783,
-0.5440812706947327,
0.1313309222459793,
-0.1420775055885315,
-0.34269699454307556,
0.5308928489685059,
-0.00020497884543146938,
0.7448025941848755,
-0.4195238947868347,
-0.11615663021802902,
-0.5138424634933472,
0.20807182788848877,
-0.25663304328918457,
-0.42644745111465454,
0.4053099453449249,
-0.08358199149370193,
-0.28694939613342285,
0.0584275983273983,
1.1771794557571411,
-0.5704476237297058,
-0.8957350850105286,
0.19290511310100555,
0.45397913455963135,
0.09137512743473053,
-0.4494224190711975,
-0.375014990568161,
0.09527766704559326,
0.08962510526180267,
-0.021192846819758415,
0.22053880989551544,
0.17675910890102386,
-0.10106450319290161,
0.5333806276321411,
0.7343298196792603,
0.515629231929779,
0.1458384245634079,
0.04225899279117584,
0.7268970608711243,
-0.719641387462616,
-0.2754238545894623,
-0.7107735872268677,
0.06717447191476822,
-0.3745342493057251,
0.027067815884947777,
1.0912541151046753,
0.7458100914955139,
1.0488848686218262,
-0.09008018672466278,
0.7615967988967896,
0.023394986987113953,
0.5679224729537964,
-0.48730915784835815,
0.7953791618347168,
-0.40900301933288574,
0.2634641230106354,
-0.1382298320531845,
-0.7266793847084045,
-0.2155493050813675,
0.39780133962631226,
-0.13430151343345642,
-0.0031324774026870728,
0.5153961777687073,
0.9544945955276489,
-0.2668929100036621,
0.14852535724639893,
0.5089190006256104,
0.3609504997730255,
0.1373790055513382,
0.6628808379173279,
0.8567359447479248,
-0.8435710072517395,
0.40896356105804443,
-0.11935271322727203,
-0.15591312944889069,
-0.5453472137451172,
-0.7282663583755493,
-1.0497770309448242,
-0.3915238380432129,
-0.4343785047531128,
-0.24868126213550568,
0.40882188081741333,
0.48852813243865967,
0.81932532787323,
-0.9182010889053345,
0.2274707853794098,
-0.04382594674825668,
0.4943484961986542,
-0.059844836592674255,
-0.320356547832489,
0.4274787902832031,
-0.24618491530418396,
-0.6887723207473755,
0.5175603032112122,
0.32694122195243835,
0.056251198053359985,
-0.1993989199399948,
0.2083345204591751,
-0.6069823503494263,
0.23160262405872345,
0.8635917901992798,
0.4217216670513153,
-0.7151654362678528,
-0.35030633211135864,
-0.3096385896205902,
-0.17405010759830475,
-0.10382621735334396,
0.5842081308364868,
-1.2076406478881836,
0.3455664813518524,
0.4811403155326843,
0.7562823295593262,
0.3865395188331604,
0.34949102997779846,
0.1368694007396698,
-0.702508807182312,
0.33660954236984253,
0.06011372432112694,
0.11842547357082367,
0.3763177692890167,
-0.6119386553764343,
0.45884424448013306,
0.5297185778617859,
-0.4968945384025574,
-0.9888675808906555,
0.14179907739162445,
-0.9979573488235474,
-0.581238329410553,
0.9904635548591614,
0.15932688117027283,
-0.24154937267303467,
-0.442260205745697,
-0.33947426080703735,
0.27541670203208923,
-0.3387872874736786,
1.0485974550247192,
0.5965003967285156,
0.15412066876888275,
-0.05814477428793907,
-0.5576027631759644,
0.13343587517738342,
0.21651653945446014,
-0.5819613337516785,
-0.3141063451766968,
0.5291688442230225,
0.15291140973567963,
0.2654021382331848,
0.46984443068504333,
-0.07662332057952881,
0.4972827732563019,
-0.1554047167301178,
-0.21274806559085846,
-0.2819952070713043,
-0.5860714316368103,
-0.3831464648246765,
0.11765651404857635,
-0.7317716479301453,
-0.36553916335105896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00629v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00629v1
|
Against The Achilles' Heel: A Survey on Red Teaming for Generative Models
| 2024-03-31T09:50:39 | 2024-03-31T09:50:39 |
Lizhi Lin, Honglin Mu, Zenan Zhai, Minghan Wang, Yuxia Wang, Renxi Wang, Junjie Gao, Yixuan Zhang, Wanxiang Che, Timothy Baldwin, Xudong Han, Haonan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative models are rapidly gaining popularity and being integrated into
everyday applications, raising concerns over their safety issues as various
vulnerabilities are exposed. Faced with the problem, the field of red teaming
is experiencing fast-paced growth, which highlights the need for a
comprehensive organization covering the entire pipeline and addressing emerging
topics for the community. Our extensive survey, which examines over 120 papers,
introduces a taxonomy of fine-grained attack strategies grounded in the
inherent capabilities of language models. Additionally, we have developed the
searcher framework that unifies various automatic red teaming approaches.
Moreover, our survey covers novel areas including multimodal attacks and
defenses, risks around multilingual models, overkill of harmless queries, and
safety of downstream applications. We hope this survey can provide a systematic
perspective on the field and unlock new areas of research.
|
[
-0.5873767137527466,
-0.6991779208183289,
0.325575053691864,
0.11612402647733688,
0.09269614517688751,
0.38349926471710205,
0.217206671833992,
-0.8130428194999695,
0.043688252568244934,
0.4287152588367462,
-0.4392097294330597,
-0.304141104221344,
-0.694851279258728,
0.09593520313501358,
-0.7328502535820007,
1.1250680685043335,
0.08286494016647339,
-0.10031390935182571,
-0.1916181445121765,
-0.6082422733306885,
-0.41142380237579346,
-0.6012639999389648,
-0.6768762469291687,
-0.12531082332134247,
0.6355122923851013,
0.11931100487709045,
0.6171990633010864,
0.16676078736782074,
0.7622726559638977,
0.3304142951965332,
-0.1347145140171051,
-0.43945008516311646,
-0.5585132837295532,
0.6624444127082825,
-0.2221662849187851,
-0.5325866937637329,
-0.4973825514316559,
0.06861747056245804,
0.2871854901313782,
0.5190902948379517,
-0.3255334794521332,
0.21134647727012634,
-0.23828454315662384,
0.8283969163894653,
-0.954157829284668,
-0.28101593255996704,
-0.7509326934814453,
0.23414094746112823,
-0.4633466899394989,
-0.09575162082910538,
-0.3432888686656952,
-0.27741244435310364,
0.2749544382095337,
-0.40795058012008667,
0.5366672277450562,
0.05956907942891121,
0.4294808506965637,
0.15087643265724182,
-0.1072663888335228,
-0.12846115231513977,
-0.6291478872299194,
0.6898275017738342,
0.06471634656190872,
-0.014045997522771358,
0.19469423592090607,
0.615750789642334,
0.2721918523311615,
-0.7308850884437561,
-0.2866821885108948,
-0.1147228330373764,
0.00869752001017332,
0.33743900060653687,
-0.8557112216949463,
0.03571033477783203,
-0.00875868834555149,
0.4511041045188904,
-0.8487135767936707,
0.34451431035995483,
-0.34449008107185364,
0.119223952293396,
0.876632034778595,
0.4129039943218231,
0.7776650786399841,
0.15703648328781128,
-0.6073757410049438,
-0.29956984519958496,
-0.7122762203216553,
-0.2581019699573517,
0.2799830734729767,
0.07747160643339157,
-0.28068721294403076,
0.43246763944625854,
-0.10553879290819168,
0.7748062610626221,
-0.08425067365169525,
0.6121279001235962,
-0.2181856483221054,
-0.6349923014640808,
-0.19298334419727325,
-0.1737900972366333,
0.842461347579956,
0.5491768717765808,
0.05363905802369118,
-0.46167054772377014,
-0.5303455591201782,
0.30273300409317017,
0.7384376525878906,
-0.33877313137054443,
-0.5379925966262817,
0.5192878246307373,
-0.3034985661506653,
-0.6252267956733704,
-0.03803266957402229,
-1.2586275339126587,
-0.7344452738761902,
0.3266606628894806,
0.0036520487628877163,
-0.20560315251350403,
-0.6094366312026978,
-0.24358004331588745,
-0.40344175696372986,
0.24655435979366302,
0.10832785815000534,
-0.6861661076545715,
0.31543096899986267,
0.654373824596405,
0.8491032719612122,
-0.22284720838069916,
-0.39963608980178833,
-0.5922574996948242,
-0.07483796775341034,
-0.31627339124679565,
0.8979588150978088,
-0.3833135664463043,
-0.6363325119018555,
0.1090986579656601,
-0.3510496914386749,
-0.028512516990303993,
-0.5153717994689941,
0.1355900913476944,
-0.6182253956794739,
0.010384752415120602,
0.11749894171953201,
-0.14683446288108826,
0.06760706752538681,
0.7444120645523071,
-0.7976686358451843,
0.8218265175819397,
-0.05774151533842087,
-0.9113189578056335,
0.1794244349002838,
-0.7991143465042114,
-0.33373692631721497,
0.296558141708374,
-0.2540031373500824,
-0.5281462073326111,
0.19985119998455048,
0.02040974609553814,
0.43958616256713867,
-0.671148955821991,
-0.014860679395496845,
-0.1332186758518219,
0.02950659580528736,
0.1284414678812027,
-0.16200442612171173,
1.0480926036834717,
0.22521145641803741,
-0.5423895716667175,
0.6276171803474426,
-0.4522444009780884,
0.08700940757989883,
0.4778614342212677,
0.03252806141972542,
-0.5999580025672913,
-0.13940119743347168,
0.22732923924922943,
0.08051476627588272,
-0.18055784702301025,
-0.3163386881351471,
0.18613706529140472,
-0.010605748742818832,
0.4019186794757843,
0.6511663794517517,
-0.0308437068015337,
0.4427521228790283,
-0.3789587616920471,
1.0896319150924683,
-0.18199196457862854,
0.29931217432022095,
0.04058408737182617,
-0.3369545638561249,
-0.7382075190544128,
0.13564643263816833,
0.3200606405735016,
0.4798790514469147,
-0.8665444254875183,
0.12120666354894638,
-0.1646602600812912,
-1.0716795921325684,
-0.45598506927490234,
-0.12809373438358307,
0.7951532602310181,
-0.007088835816830397,
0.46503618359565735,
-0.4157205820083618,
-0.3693774342536926,
-0.6612617373466492,
-0.1891060471534729,
-0.5113347768783569,
0.08802110701799393,
0.4582246243953705,
0.671167254447937,
-0.4250958561897278,
0.9327844381332397,
-0.5585480332374573,
-0.28590238094329834,
-0.6386389136314392,
0.4187847375869751,
-0.4018312692642212,
0.450917512178421,
0.9319608211517334,
-1.229107141494751,
-0.6022394299507141,
0.011957516893744469,
-0.7852042317390442,
0.09014879167079926,
0.01953250728547573,
-0.016699302941560745,
0.44183972477912903,
0.3870106339454651,
-0.6606602668762207,
0.12770316004753113,
0.9228886961936951,
-0.43783825635910034,
0.616133987903595,
0.16135351359844208,
0.04743197560310364,
-0.7331671714782715,
0.35628846287727356,
0.31281226873397827,
0.1752973347902298,
-0.7512682676315308,
0.8040568828582764,
-0.15761688351631165,
-0.3362336754798889,
-0.4678264856338501,
0.5079836845397949,
-0.5124554634094238,
0.05642528086900711,
0.18464377522468567,
0.0996285080909729,
-0.23332099616527557,
-0.06408322602510452,
0.134073406457901,
0.8283380270004272,
0.6445781588554382,
-0.6809312701225281,
0.6543940901756287,
0.08052600175142288,
-0.28926587104797363,
0.6709869503974915,
-0.8679186701774597,
0.17082346975803375,
-0.04928811639547348,
0.3212989866733551,
-0.5648778676986694,
-0.22453807294368744,
0.15611837804317474,
-0.5285640954971313,
0.3915221393108368,
-0.3968367576599121,
-0.3978848457336426,
-0.31160005927085876,
-0.31711074709892273,
0.7086436748504639,
0.3015129268169403,
-0.3497277796268463,
0.513816773891449,
0.8925870060920715,
-0.21494439244270325,
-0.7278556823730469,
-0.533569872379303,
0.33912214636802673,
-0.5772412419319153,
-0.5885475873947144,
0.37640222907066345,
0.0640774518251419,
-0.6718199253082275,
-0.12611804902553558,
0.06429830193519592,
-0.5758007764816284,
0.3690778613090515,
-0.05850352719426155,
0.01264179963618517,
-0.1838516891002655,
0.01681850105524063,
-0.8080592751502991,
-0.4014194905757904,
0.01325328927487135,
0.03867568075656891,
0.5612472295761108,
-0.22672024369239807,
-0.23248806595802307,
-0.11634581536054611,
0.5498483180999756,
0.9842203259468079,
-0.4921046793460846,
0.5555267930030823,
0.389316588640213,
-0.11876648664474487,
-0.025382982566952705,
-0.5319951772689819,
-0.29990243911743164,
-0.37019169330596924,
0.5813232064247131,
0.008220775052905083,
-0.6092196106910706,
0.4121991991996765,
0.18290682137012482,
0.023083504289388657,
0.5451064109802246,
0.263409823179245,
-0.2683993875980377,
0.7047045826911926,
0.9455437660217285,
-0.478105366230011,
0.20502865314483643,
-0.3019976019859314,
0.12633708119392395,
-0.452280730009079,
-0.04130661115050316,
-0.6243686079978943,
-0.17169460654258728,
-0.5238538384437561,
-0.15418818593025208,
0.4945155680179596,
-0.11455664783716202,
-0.038713399320840836,
0.5546045899391174,
-0.6761291027069092,
0.30097416043281555,
0.34219443798065186,
-0.40036824345588684,
0.14254488050937653,
-0.4054490923881531,
0.039896510541439056,
-0.03998766839504242,
-0.8934878706932068,
-0.17097759246826172,
0.8493626117706299,
0.45075666904449463,
0.872840940952301,
0.5570896863937378,
0.537710964679718,
0.24083511531352997,
0.25576919317245483,
-0.6866249442100525,
0.36779236793518066,
0.07178110629320145,
-0.9661273956298828,
-0.5120069980621338,
-0.3976053297519684,
-0.9652729630470276,
0.3099191188812256,
-0.1856127381324768,
-0.3968280553817749,
-0.06097417324781418,
0.3260258734226227,
-0.5208423137664795,
0.5155751705169678,
-0.5236856341362,
1.0107702016830444,
-0.5160046815872192,
-0.412702739238739,
-0.09723848849534988,
-0.676738977432251,
0.426702618598938,
-0.016316547989845276,
-0.02794804982841015,
0.19417205452919006,
0.25791528820991516,
0.6454684138298035,
-0.13607542216777802,
0.9489136338233948,
-0.07467964291572571,
-0.06977976113557816,
0.33579206466674805,
0.15701603889465332,
0.6158650517463684,
-0.14741623401641846,
0.03855366259813309,
0.24624866247177124,
-0.1592126190662384,
-0.3600805699825287,
-0.29977068305015564,
0.4192951023578644,
-0.3176068365573883,
-0.5282158255577087,
-0.8938600420951843,
-0.2031734436750412,
-0.15081527829170227,
-0.012061068788170815,
0.5464608669281006,
0.12146615982055664,
-0.5226410627365112,
0.2635684311389923,
0.5938462018966675,
-0.12554237246513367,
0.617513120174408,
0.370187908411026,
0.26752087473869324,
-0.2860506474971771,
0.963888943195343,
-0.09991681575775146,
0.4950174391269684,
0.23590300977230072,
-0.13192664086818695,
-0.1879107505083084,
-0.8435181379318237,
-0.5882787108421326,
-0.07752078771591187,
-0.3292470872402191,
-0.3890707492828369,
-0.6237998604774475,
-0.19537213444709778,
-0.22651326656341553,
-0.19025252759456635,
-0.905297577381134,
-0.16455239057540894,
0.044844698160886765,
-0.024117005988955498,
0.45044398307800293,
0.842562198638916,
0.36162275075912476,
-0.0019943101797252893,
-0.9892717599868774,
-0.008272230625152588,
0.5084766149520874,
0.33638787269592285,
0.048366885632276535,
0.2519179880619049,
0.005810148548334837,
-0.4114583730697632,
-0.4873179793357849,
-0.6737374663352966,
0.5123714208602905,
-0.2812357246875763,
0.6556099057197571,
0.21559476852416992,
0.6010259389877319,
0.4287097454071045,
-0.32642778754234314,
0.8598273992538452,
0.6491101384162903,
-0.5716787576675415,
0.6155288219451904,
-0.5432343482971191,
-0.005539363715797663,
0.6510658860206604,
0.6117609143257141,
-0.5111314058303833,
-0.30763933062553406,
-0.7327423095703125,
-1.0487629175186157,
0.41738301515579224,
0.5075491666793823,
0.020955221727490425,
0.0835685133934021,
-0.28750279545783997,
-0.2834097445011139,
0.11151271313428879,
-1.0025272369384766,
-0.4969561696052551,
0.03293098136782646,
0.1303194761276245,
0.07703036069869995,
-0.23638062179088593,
-0.5837506055831909,
0.11885648965835571,
0.3817276060581207,
-0.11163327097892761,
0.2439504861831665,
-0.03311087191104889,
-0.10887307673692703,
-0.03235092759132385,
0.40831851959228516,
0.6122271418571472,
0.5185761451721191,
0.016182180494070053,
0.19377581775188446,
0.16393448412418365,
-0.342474102973938,
0.1312061846256256,
0.07321292906999588,
-0.11550290882587433,
-0.15806961059570312,
0.42759647965431213,
0.3945273756980896,
0.24433012306690216,
-0.6574668884277344,
0.5450684428215027,
0.00526168430224061,
0.00902387872338295,
-0.4836054742336273,
0.05355992168188095,
-0.2115144431591034,
0.10743200778961182,
0.36980462074279785,
0.26822683215141296,
-0.027353573590517044,
-0.4588014781475067,
0.04140248894691467,
0.5847516655921936,
-0.9359248876571655,
-0.2865540087223053,
0.47560739517211914,
0.6540244817733765,
-0.23313383758068085,
0.4836759865283966,
-0.008510340005159378,
-0.7082216739654541,
0.7399128675460815,
0.4405454099178314,
0.9395791292190552,
-0.21603909134864807,
0.0025347969494760036,
0.15027251839637756,
0.2857641577720642,
-0.15729685127735138,
-0.41666775941848755,
0.011849243193864822,
-0.677005410194397,
0.19588863849639893,
-0.27658507227897644,
-0.5313621163368225,
0.1778361201286316,
-0.6945673823356628,
-0.006473894231021404,
-0.25691261887550354,
-0.3395991623401642,
-0.143814355134964,
-0.2593456506729126,
-0.19147980213165283,
0.151747465133667,
-0.2037453055381775,
0.8680441379547119,
-0.6072831153869629,
0.5682236552238464,
0.9140126705169678,
-0.7884262204170227,
0.1523713767528534,
0.16041411459445953,
0.34419840574264526,
-0.45376455783843994,
0.6131013035774231,
-0.05018196254968643,
-0.2958831489086151,
-0.16838595271110535,
-0.24554787576198578,
-0.5066953301429749,
0.9859020113945007,
0.11343875527381897,
-0.4821400046348572,
-0.1435275822877884,
-0.2373739331960678,
0.28058961033821106,
-0.13937124609947205,
-0.008088081143796444,
0.5822710394859314,
0.3081727623939514,
-0.17273971438407898,
-0.8998556733131409,
-0.2621576189994812,
-0.46506819128990173,
-0.07260169833898544,
0.25991594791412354,
-0.6211221218109131,
0.7800102233886719,
-0.30704328417778015,
-0.3751237690448761,
0.20111557841300964,
0.10210493952035904,
0.40836066007614136,
0.32635849714279175,
0.5330708622932434,
0.6343087553977966,
0.3815611004829407,
-0.06840453296899796,
1.433226227760315,
-0.23535345494747162,
0.34642890095710754,
0.9798826575279236,
-0.08600308746099472,
0.7988882660865784,
0.38394078612327576,
-0.3152141273021698,
0.10394016653299332,
0.3200025260448456,
-0.14651939272880554,
0.3124292492866516,
0.2732926905155182,
-0.38713693618774414,
-0.2293441742658615,
0.03053991124033928,
-0.5178989171981812,
0.49385929107666016,
0.197956845164299,
-0.3538763225078583,
-0.15104371309280396,
-0.4321722388267517,
-0.0395396463572979,
0.2762278914451599,
-0.21796534955501556,
0.8657716512680054,
-0.0038388154935091734,
-0.7005311846733093,
0.3288092613220215,
-0.112740658223629,
0.9712488055229187,
-0.4917868673801422,
0.088629812002182,
-0.15377475321292877,
0.0941525548696518,
-0.12252584099769592,
-0.773443877696991,
0.4101433753967285,
0.18629246950149536,
-0.21386370062828064,
-0.34621158242225647,
0.4223478436470032,
-0.054896168410778046,
-0.23891481757164001,
0.6128956079483032,
0.48917528986930847,
-0.20782841742038727,
-0.2064753621816635,
-0.7394768595695496,
0.2599892020225525,
-0.3123724162578583,
0.11063975840806961,
0.4962007701396942,
0.06387363374233246,
0.019887901842594147,
0.8854202628135681,
0.31495773792266846,
0.011452704668045044,
-0.020983682945370674,
0.005864644888788462,
0.7622445821762085,
-0.7672112584114075,
-0.29728010296821594,
-0.8450018763542175,
0.7588735222816467,
-0.37645119428634644,
-0.49914830923080444,
0.6972840428352356,
0.3869529962539673,
0.7687054872512817,
-0.09528271108865738,
0.7669419646263123,
-0.023128483444452286,
0.3673379719257355,
-0.4283229112625122,
1.4711023569107056,
-0.4916277825832367,
0.14966937899589539,
-0.5831614136695862,
-0.7007066607475281,
-0.5691297650337219,
0.6051198244094849,
0.030910244211554527,
0.16759397089481354,
0.4850297272205353,
0.5250100493431091,
0.05141085013747215,
0.025201495736837387,
0.3051774203777313,
0.10340315103530884,
0.3535139858722687,
0.5008663535118103,
0.9839233160018921,
-0.4204903244972229,
0.7020179629325867,
-0.09600072354078293,
-0.1485937088727951,
-0.24617750942707062,
-0.7968896627426147,
-0.5740091800689697,
-0.6542690992355347,
-0.5603170394897461,
-0.22421008348464966,
0.2626397907733917,
0.4430285394191742,
0.7251832485198975,
-0.8373652100563049,
-0.28115254640579224,
-0.46874821186065674,
0.1315254271030426,
-0.14067012071609497,
-0.19398733973503113,
0.04520258679986,
-0.398428350687027,
-0.5994172692298889,
0.3719167411327362,
0.12745530903339386,
0.2714042067527771,
-0.4584932029247284,
-0.08324980735778809,
-0.14723527431488037,
-0.5113916993141174,
0.5696825385093689,
0.9286056756973267,
-0.7807971835136414,
-0.0889337807893753,
-0.05298958346247673,
-0.2536661624908447,
-0.14270655810832977,
1.0129128694534302,
-0.5193979740142822,
0.6013045310974121,
0.3639988303184509,
0.849340558052063,
0.12131024152040482,
-0.18840375542640686,
1.1080340147018433,
-0.7666608095169067,
-0.02070310153067112,
0.5981130003929138,
0.33339303731918335,
0.3396821618080139,
-0.22761182487010956,
0.9994124174118042,
0.2890932559967041,
-0.3154245913028717,
-1.0678728818893433,
0.28040966391563416,
-0.7460361123085022,
-0.3212314248085022,
0.957050085067749,
-0.13507182896137238,
0.30710163712501526,
-0.4199032783508301,
0.2825482487678528,
-0.021009966731071472,
-0.1237553060054779,
0.93923020362854,
0.3756682574748993,
-0.19015200436115265,
-0.18782499432563782,
-0.5429881811141968,
0.5794623494148254,
0.3206234276294708,
-0.7799524068832397,
0.3863855302333832,
0.33521056175231934,
0.021087191998958588,
0.5833288431167603,
0.553471028804779,
-0.2550296187400818,
0.5128602981567383,
0.09730025380849838,
0.14809978008270264,
0.24699516594409943,
-0.5330492854118347,
-0.446607381105423,
0.5620266199111938,
0.09550046920776367,
-0.11969926208257675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00620v1
|
Reporting Eye-Tracking Data Quality: Towards a New Standard
| 2024-03-31T09:17:34 | 2024-03-31T09:17:34 |
Deborah N. Jakobi, Daniel G. Krakowczyk, Lena A. Jäger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Eye-tracking datasets are often shared in the format used by their creators
for their original analyses, usually resulting in the exclusion of data
considered irrelevant to the primary purpose. In order to increase re-usability
of existing eye-tracking datasets for more diverse and initially not considered
use cases, this work advocates a new approach of sharing eye-tracking data.
Instead of publishing filtered and pre-processed datasets, the eye-tracking
data at all pre-processing stages should be published together with data
quality reports. In order to transparently report data quality and enable
cross-dataset comparisons, we develop data quality reporting standards and
metrics that can be automatically applied to a dataset, and integrate them into
the open-source Python package pymovements
(https://github.com/aeye-lab/pymovements).
|
[
-0.1471528857946396,
-0.2734488546848297,
0.18926125764846802,
0.09493699669837952,
-0.5157359838485718,
-0.25436416268348694,
0.12725575268268585,
-0.9016514420509338,
0.5908469557762146,
0.694244384765625,
-0.1168334037065506,
-0.6921078562736511,
-0.40744057297706604,
0.13178712129592896,
-0.5715652108192444,
0.7462164759635925,
-0.44870132207870483,
-0.03769667446613312,
-0.31473439931869507,
-0.4895608425140381,
-0.170371413230896,
-0.1856992095708847,
-0.24462804198265076,
0.09390532225370407,
0.7319918870925903,
0.6010406613349915,
0.8076226711273193,
0.8360063433647156,
0.9741318225860596,
0.21748389303684235,
0.3920750319957733,
0.027247268706560135,
-0.42144912481307983,
0.08197895437479019,
-0.051753148436546326,
-0.40461036562919617,
-0.7560105323791504,
0.6641506552696228,
0.5152230262756348,
0.6934529542922974,
-0.31906670331954956,
0.5511128902435303,
0.21732084453105927,
0.694242000579834,
-0.7649433612823486,
0.16113826632499695,
0.0454038642346859,
0.1831398606300354,
-0.4153730869293213,
-0.26149246096611023,
-0.13831967115402222,
-0.6282712817192078,
0.19808784127235413,
-0.926363468170166,
0.27069953083992004,
0.2841135859489441,
0.6220900416374207,
0.02849634550511837,
-0.09957543015480042,
-0.07485877722501755,
-0.16575366258621216,
0.5114023685455322,
-0.39044931530952454,
0.24076315760612488,
0.36565810441970825,
0.4398820996284485,
0.4222572147846222,
-0.7870340943336487,
-0.016297727823257446,
-0.1604360044002533,
-0.1176103949546814,
-0.10839758813381195,
-0.2302493005990982,
-0.3062072992324829,
0.0004384542698971927,
0.572142481803894,
-0.595812201499939,
-0.03969478979706764,
-0.5623775124549866,
-0.2482762634754181,
0.8824142813682556,
0.423122376203537,
-0.019305719062685966,
0.44165676832199097,
-0.1468888372182846,
-0.033397313207387924,
-0.43625909090042114,
0.21556177735328674,
0.3806396722793579,
-0.14810052514076233,
-0.04984792694449425,
0.6208773255348206,
-1.0413734912872314,
0.5976254343986511,
0.33092156052589417,
0.34904399514198303,
0.6724452376365662,
-0.7406134605407715,
0.011151929385960102,
-0.015486802905797958,
0.4345391094684601,
0.9002559185028076,
-0.04333877936005592,
-0.3055870831012726,
-0.1448953002691269,
0.17456044256687164,
0.13308285176753998,
-0.6434183120727539,
-0.6149934530258179,
0.20863161981105804,
-0.7105395197868347,
-0.25314879417419434,
0.18074242770671844,
-0.8786538243293762,
-0.1945810168981552,
-0.5311338305473328,
0.7167787551879883,
-0.0782238021492958,
-0.277716726064682,
0.3142684996128082,
-0.10815802216529846,
0.060708437114953995,
0.7840294241905212,
-0.6159979701042175,
0.1744946539402008,
0.4022151827812195,
0.6959187984466553,
-0.18363045156002045,
-0.5873117446899414,
-0.6014240980148315,
-0.0829000398516655,
-0.444599449634552,
0.5896790623664856,
-0.3141215741634369,
0.09031327813863754,
-0.11969859898090363,
0.35728737711906433,
0.3109161853790283,
-0.7574521899223328,
0.3009586036205292,
-0.259573757648468,
0.1290583461523056,
-0.17937017977237701,
-0.6103541851043701,
-0.20613795518875122,
-0.17770949006080627,
-0.5051398277282715,
0.882209837436676,
0.10234438627958298,
-0.40508946776390076,
0.9174008965492249,
-0.2016618400812149,
-0.08533412218093872,
0.29216641187667847,
0.14921659231185913,
-0.6421163082122803,
0.2774258255958557,
0.11508560180664062,
0.20851387083530426,
0.037936314940452576,
0.12085482478141785,
-0.456828773021698,
-0.41356873512268066,
0.14749698340892792,
-0.10910829156637192,
0.869813859462738,
0.2031271904706955,
-0.030291572213172913,
0.07180938124656677,
-0.5990161299705505,
0.4482848346233368,
-0.24264608323574066,
-0.0558483712375164,
-0.140889972448349,
-0.22235901653766632,
-0.14577263593673706,
-0.15497583150863647,
0.581267774105072,
-0.7082146406173706,
-0.005006253253668547,
0.3976914882659912,
-0.010804680176079273,
0.3419189751148224,
-0.20520299673080444,
0.28465336561203003,
-0.277252197265625,
0.16315194964408875,
0.05101897940039635,
1.148995280265808,
-0.11682267487049103,
-0.4552434980869293,
-0.6515482068061829,
-0.08919177949428558,
0.10166977345943451,
0.29530733823776245,
-0.3548499345779419,
0.4232681095600128,
0.23842188715934753,
-0.6039396524429321,
-0.6526960730552673,
0.37579429149627686,
0.27816110849380493,
0.3129837214946747,
0.2785824239253998,
-0.7778090238571167,
-0.25060197710990906,
-0.7517170310020447,
-0.28963321447372437,
-0.013997805304825306,
0.0751161277294159,
0.17603565752506256,
0.537903368473053,
-0.016788393259048462,
0.9345306158065796,
-0.5455296635627747,
-0.16981394588947296,
0.15025007724761963,
0.10983751714229584,
0.08390501886606216,
0.784197211265564,
0.4077564775943756,
-0.6620116233825684,
-0.4116368293762207,
-0.47629550099372864,
-0.9505859613418579,
-0.23308387398719788,
0.5253998637199402,
-0.36052408814430237,
-0.05658087134361267,
0.42711788415908813,
-0.30137208104133606,
0.8350321054458618,
0.6850325465202332,
-0.536348283290863,
0.7981032133102417,
-0.11033336073160172,
0.5726616978645325,
-0.7432981729507446,
0.4154501259326935,
0.20072060823440552,
-0.4493902623653412,
-0.4179655611515045,
-0.12534140050411224,
0.10820277780294418,
-0.3012906014919281,
-0.6977033615112305,
0.16820122301578522,
-0.3798656761646271,
-0.1555401235818863,
0.08484188467264175,
-0.1494910717010498,
0.3097606599330902,
-0.17976532876491547,
0.023890815675258636,
0.4733482599258423,
0.957456648349762,
-0.6280415058135986,
0.9407344460487366,
0.352267324924469,
-0.6871004104614258,
1.0371029376983643,
-0.8458102345466614,
-0.1611851453781128,
0.07409755140542984,
-0.016429254785180092,
-0.43586769700050354,
-0.3682878911495209,
0.7423790097236633,
-0.8943521976470947,
0.09133976697921753,
-0.16798202693462372,
-0.38937848806381226,
-0.04318581148982048,
-0.45792609453201294,
0.4809182584285736,
0.3876263201236725,
-0.5154922008514404,
-0.10289482027292252,
0.5351118445396423,
0.06368112564086914,
-0.4028157591819763,
-0.4888934791088104,
0.29637137055397034,
-0.18359479308128357,
-0.583514392375946,
0.09151981770992279,
0.06067315489053726,
-0.2756146490573883,
0.5776863694190979,
-0.08082187920808792,
-0.43280380964279175,
-0.11436059325933456,
-0.09073333442211151,
0.40305188298225403,
-0.28681740164756775,
-0.2642640769481659,
-0.5410844683647156,
-0.23653742671012878,
0.057649917900562286,
-0.20070913434028625,
-0.2737763822078705,
0.2695615291595459,
-0.1638077199459076,
-1.2566173076629639,
0.49597805738449097,
0.4002346098423004,
-0.3983357548713684,
0.43813297152519226,
0.5547197461128235,
-0.28965023159980774,
-0.06663066148757935,
-0.46072858572006226,
-0.3157832622528076,
-0.5067030787467957,
0.12145122140645981,
0.07891926169395447,
-0.7529082894325256,
0.26121628284454346,
0.24590161442756653,
0.18317385017871857,
-0.08635693043470383,
0.01653212308883667,
-0.7517871260643005,
0.9180117845535278,
0.788491427898407,
0.09173945337533951,
0.7649385333061218,
0.06185917183756828,
0.26089099049568176,
-0.8561255931854248,
-0.3833802342414856,
-0.4354812204837799,
-0.13067546486854553,
-0.35025879740715027,
-0.2625506818294525,
0.16353920102119446,
0.30726033449172974,
0.12150494009256363,
0.23825035989284515,
-0.5507732033729553,
0.49454906582832336,
0.7595133185386658,
0.3674500286579132,
0.32685157656669617,
0.38235288858413696,
0.7175008654594421,
0.16754256188869476,
-0.3813391923904419,
-0.2849234640598297,
1.4405122995376587,
0.030325179919600487,
1.1525156497955322,
-0.2474157065153122,
0.7533372640609741,
0.3446776270866394,
0.3060019612312317,
-0.3367266058921814,
0.4232475757598877,
-0.21159839630126953,
-0.5390256643295288,
-0.335886687040329,
-0.7199811935424805,
-1.1436214447021484,
0.13906410336494446,
0.07148021459579468,
-1.0013320446014404,
0.4019843339920044,
0.5266618728637695,
-0.21443313360214233,
0.13739776611328125,
-0.6268375515937805,
1.0376900434494019,
-0.11836856603622437,
-0.735933780670166,
-0.1990945190191269,
-0.5384327173233032,
0.10806383192539215,
0.3096470534801483,
-0.3608752489089966,
-0.4347951114177704,
-0.012849920429289341,
1.0382802486419678,
-0.5528669953346252,
0.7561262845993042,
-0.2800787389278412,
0.2572285234928131,
0.6815718412399292,
-0.19140808284282684,
0.2611454725265503,
0.20716440677642822,
0.5717531442642212,
0.527356743812561,
-0.015207652933895588,
-0.5326278209686279,
-0.18934597074985504,
0.625404953956604,
-0.4082120358943939,
-0.3498927056789398,
-0.7172233462333679,
-0.40899282693862915,
0.14673469960689545,
0.028599971905350685,
0.13045825064182281,
0.514340341091156,
0.16617539525032043,
0.6280962824821472,
0.5760359168052673,
0.07098639011383057,
0.06594198942184448,
0.9253509640693665,
-0.08121316879987717,
-0.5769922137260437,
0.856806755065918,
0.3122625946998596,
0.15139129757881165,
-0.13453789055347443,
-0.2125827968120575,
-0.38363856077194214,
-0.5536659359931946,
-0.1579022854566574,
0.18676340579986572,
-0.5044749975204468,
0.09637787938117981,
-0.09379196166992188,
0.20609459280967712,
-0.5720818638801575,
-0.15593889355659485,
-0.4896659553050995,
-0.18298491835594177,
-0.37906694412231445,
0.1552896648645401,
0.30933570861816406,
0.377011775970459,
-0.48481425642967224,
0.10301549732685089,
-0.7260657548904419,
0.5123875737190247,
0.25946953892707825,
0.9513841271400452,
-0.5048465728759766,
-0.11256306618452072,
-0.7390577793121338,
0.043295878916978836,
-0.2647271156311035,
-0.4949488341808319,
0.40760642290115356,
-0.15073837339878082,
0.7163171172142029,
0.02445714734494686,
-0.10527802258729935,
0.41871947050094604,
0.04810572788119316,
0.7107163071632385,
0.5233866572380066,
-0.8965989351272583,
0.7302457690238953,
-0.10241428762674332,
-0.12018891423940659,
0.8125811815261841,
0.029324885457754135,
-0.5839009881019592,
-0.42298388481140137,
-0.416472464799881,
-0.9323707818984985,
0.8158921003341675,
0.31217366456985474,
-0.42239946126937866,
0.6803755760192871,
0.37998372316360474,
0.3073892295360565,
0.31246545910835266,
-0.21057739853858948,
-0.3633098602294922,
-0.3515702784061432,
-0.22969666123390198,
-0.6634417772293091,
0.12790720164775848,
-0.27643752098083496,
-0.4957672357559204,
0.17246468365192413,
-0.009010490030050278,
-0.020408995449543,
0.468217134475708,
-0.4523789584636688,
-0.16440892219543457,
-0.18818020820617676,
-0.36824339628219604,
1.1687450408935547,
-0.3214292824268341,
0.063029944896698,
-0.49933016300201416,
-0.7243492007255554,
0.1636175662279129,
-0.09469299018383026,
-0.5365877747535706,
0.11584220826625824,
-0.022837882861495018,
0.3227236568927765,
-0.18374991416931152,
-0.3726828098297119,
0.47548067569732666,
0.02981541119515896,
-0.14933888614177704,
-0.1360473483800888,
0.29360485076904297,
-0.27944642305374146,
0.120057113468647,
0.18782849609851837,
0.17476016283035278,
0.49013811349868774,
-0.4550674259662628,
0.7697321176528931,
-0.08600291609764099,
-0.38573363423347473,
-0.5253534317016602,
0.6849222183227539,
0.5812118053436279,
0.07430066913366318,
0.7057832479476929,
-0.10441131889820099,
0.03316689282655716,
0.874293327331543,
-0.018650367856025696,
0.619511604309082,
-0.37432411313056946,
0.6034620404243469,
0.35229942202568054,
0.3580913841724396,
-0.25751951336860657,
0.5886624455451965,
-0.06628822535276413,
-0.49698686599731445,
-0.2997283637523651,
-0.2606945037841797,
-0.7535733580589294,
-0.07651229947805405,
-1.088616132736206,
0.1297680139541626,
-0.11896699666976929,
-0.1783607453107834,
-0.13526053726673126,
0.13062773644924164,
-0.5781283974647522,
0.34332260489463806,
0.077113576233387,
0.9054474234580994,
-0.8094701170921326,
0.6030873656272888,
0.5590143203735352,
-0.4145963490009308,
-0.2386953979730606,
-0.29971349239349365,
0.10463157296180725,
-0.6189050078392029,
0.28280460834503174,
0.3461117148399353,
0.1341814547777176,
-0.15326336026191711,
-0.6757227778434753,
-0.7218473553657532,
1.063682198524475,
0.0674266442656517,
-0.4631485939025879,
0.44792279601097107,
0.23814769089221954,
0.2149750143289566,
-0.2124079018831253,
-0.16924698650836945,
0.4566080868244171,
0.5055356025695801,
-0.36417651176452637,
-0.8405843377113342,
-0.1945488452911377,
-0.2612530291080475,
-0.5617280602455139,
0.2186029851436615,
-0.7497032284736633,
0.9319941997528076,
-0.14795953035354614,
-0.1844729632139206,
0.09168172627687454,
0.3438321352005005,
-0.125997394323349,
0.995540976524353,
0.15965019166469574,
0.7767024636268616,
0.5654106140136719,
-0.16436105966567993,
0.6385406851768494,
-0.24657732248306274,
0.4774892032146454,
0.9797131419181824,
-0.45850732922554016,
0.6126900911331177,
0.6488358378410339,
-0.1372598260641098,
-0.24937745928764343,
0.5734580755233765,
-0.34944307804107666,
0.3267001509666443,
0.014220920391380787,
0.11264349520206451,
-0.13447149097919464,
-0.3097803294658661,
-0.42159342765808105,
0.23615726828575134,
0.013697604648768902,
-0.15495970845222473,
-0.08425437659025192,
-0.3820010721683502,
-0.25245800614356995,
-0.4497876465320587,
-0.4179515838623047,
0.4438023865222931,
-0.11210565268993378,
-0.33189964294433594,
0.22689560055732727,
-0.587146520614624,
0.6251442432403564,
-0.4948941767215729,
-0.10144274681806564,
-0.4149346947669983,
0.06896920502185822,
-0.49911558628082275,
-1.3309111595153809,
0.40777140855789185,
0.17577217519283295,
0.028523284941911697,
-0.06393839418888092,
0.30922725796699524,
-0.3964414894580841,
-0.4075562357902527,
0.14890533685684204,
0.46202602982521057,
0.24857062101364136,
-0.11641499400138855,
-0.4179180860519409,
0.009217874146997929,
-0.11012739688158035,
-0.33688440918922424,
0.29728737473487854,
0.2462790459394455,
0.23868121206760406,
0.707639217376709,
0.6451157331466675,
0.3470976650714874,
0.27161335945129395,
-0.13916805386543274,
0.584996223449707,
-0.7526744604110718,
-0.6449795365333557,
-0.13476434350013733,
0.5970237851142883,
-0.40523776412010193,
-0.6731013059616089,
1.0369727611541748,
0.8162458539009094,
0.8822034001350403,
0.23685765266418457,
0.4964863955974579,
-0.07449673116207123,
0.32948386669158936,
-0.3158296048641205,
0.5692546367645264,
-0.7203127145767212,
-0.023702694103121758,
0.08480766415596008,
-1.0130952596664429,
-0.3324747085571289,
0.5194203853607178,
0.19371283054351807,
-0.3633054196834564,
0.7365269064903259,
0.6455179452896118,
-0.20210710167884827,
-0.05794023722410202,
0.2564428448677063,
0.1682603657245636,
0.13743460178375244,
0.49893075227737427,
0.9717904925346375,
-0.500052273273468,
0.4576561152935028,
-0.6842777729034424,
-0.6031320691108704,
-0.6988467574119568,
-0.4554084539413452,
-0.3718869984149933,
-0.3681572377681732,
-0.9947788715362549,
-0.18975907564163208,
0.2595753073692322,
0.2025565356016159,
0.9949927926063538,
-0.6570688486099243,
-0.2927522659301758,
0.16196486353874207,
-0.2044152021408081,
-0.5487299561500549,
-0.2370891124010086,
0.3082956373691559,
-0.15402650833129883,
-0.52512526512146,
0.07128369808197021,
0.3055605888366699,
0.021051833406090736,
-0.12693534791469574,
-0.1640203893184662,
0.3440941870212555,
-0.29778093099594116,
0.12800216674804688,
0.37869933247566223,
-0.1942974328994751,
-0.3392188847064972,
-0.1672465205192566,
-0.10894124209880829,
0.40023839473724365,
0.8727961182594299,
-0.44453123211860657,
0.5366201996803284,
0.7226783633232117,
-0.01698867231607437,
0.11935459822416306,
-0.11329509317874908,
0.2959260642528534,
-0.2448275238275528,
0.011513395234942436,
0.37236103415489197,
0.4573127031326294,
0.151520237326622,
-0.3245750069618225,
0.43365341424942017,
0.36344319581985474,
-0.6430754065513611,
-0.9825021028518677,
0.050329577177762985,
-0.8348990082740784,
-0.03608613461256027,
0.5908094048500061,
-0.6144106984138489,
-0.4369993805885315,
-0.22083263099193573,
-0.08600340783596039,
0.1791888177394867,
-0.6153772473335266,
0.8251165151596069,
0.4428073465824127,
-0.46526679396629333,
-0.13972823321819305,
-0.4725550413131714,
0.425341933965683,
0.32009994983673096,
-0.889805257320404,
0.42065268754959106,
0.8308863043785095,
0.5450261235237122,
-0.08970355242490768,
0.3041582703590393,
-0.4995790719985962,
0.7236478328704834,
0.42078807950019836,
0.09073617309331894,
-0.24058909714221954,
-0.6700313091278076,
-0.1835692673921585,
0.004235527478158474,
-0.3370102047920227,
-0.8227090239524841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00614v1
|
Learning to Plan for Language Modeling from Unlabeled Data
| 2024-03-31T09:04:01 | 2024-03-31T09:04:01 |
Nathan Cornille, Marie-Francine Moens, Florian Mai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
By training to predict the next token in an unlabeled corpus, large language
models learn to perform many tasks without any labeled data. However, their
next-token-prediction objective arguably limits their performance in scenarios
that require planning, such as writing a coherent article. In this paper, we
train a module for planning the future writing process via a self-supervised
learning objective. By conditioning on generated latent plans, our model
extends the successful language model formula to more abstract planning in an
unsupervised way. Empirically, we demonstrate that our method improves language
modeling performance in general, particularly with respect to the text
structure. Because our framework uses a planner module that is unsupervised and
external to the language model, new planner modules can be trained at large
scale and easily be shared with the community.
|
[
-0.010595687665045261,
-0.38045188784599304,
0.6049742102622986,
0.18676619231700897,
-0.08701489120721817,
-0.08483228832483292,
-0.39140585064888,
-0.2407296597957611,
0.3392256498336792,
0.904793918132782,
-0.6523100137710571,
-0.6748117208480835,
-0.30268624424934387,
-0.17100514471530914,
-0.4458342492580414,
1.0807312726974487,
-0.07855920493602753,
-0.1330995261669159,
-0.23837469518184662,
0.2905656099319458,
-0.3052900433540344,
-0.6841341853141785,
-0.5794659852981567,
-0.391020804643631,
0.4348866641521454,
0.5810825228691101,
0.2421789914369583,
0.6562668085098267,
-0.115394726395607,
0.3174158036708832,
0.3104917109012604,
-0.040430568158626556,
-0.3605087399482727,
0.15789726376533508,
-0.254761666059494,
-0.2828730046749115,
-0.5017845034599304,
-0.023149210959672928,
0.5333861112594604,
1.1241657733917236,
-0.0534268356859684,
0.08295320719480515,
0.05782436206936836,
0.5190891027450562,
-0.5778852105140686,
0.6226693391799927,
-0.7531622648239136,
0.1236431896686554,
0.0236377976834774,
-0.10161568224430084,
-0.6521384119987488,
0.1440276950597763,
0.008970918133854866,
-0.48433494567871094,
0.21093271672725677,
-0.13684968650341034,
0.19773773849010468,
0.10187958180904388,
-0.22625362873077393,
-0.01923551596701145,
-0.8411809802055359,
0.66364985704422,
-0.6014363169670105,
0.25373852252960205,
0.6548700332641602,
0.003089597914367914,
-0.3087404668331146,
-0.6854196786880493,
-0.44282692670822144,
-0.016061948612332344,
-0.21061670780181885,
0.1917320191860199,
0.05425085872411728,
0.2815268039703369,
0.14107033610343933,
-0.09464630484580994,
-0.49181485176086426,
0.21906229853630066,
-0.5734285116195679,
-0.2161693274974823,
0.7207881212234497,
-0.03388358652591705,
0.08574558794498444,
-0.05445638298988342,
-0.3322126567363739,
0.15346691012382507,
-0.562279224395752,
-0.025763913989067078,
0.5184187293052673,
0.44629356265068054,
-0.05404601991176605,
0.8359973430633545,
-0.418931245803833,
0.34452328085899353,
-0.1059531420469284,
0.006928978022187948,
0.10941342264413834,
-0.0824175700545311,
-0.2589634954929352,
0.12658730149269104,
0.6092724204063416,
0.1879400610923767,
0.5549525022506714,
-0.5212042927742004,
-0.5943640470504761,
0.16291144490242004,
0.28455114364624023,
-0.7291125059127808,
-0.6601635813713074,
0.15256650745868683,
-0.3494754135608673,
-0.12770114839076996,
-0.3354625701904297,
-0.5204846262931824,
0.13934195041656494,
-0.5101085901260376,
0.27878233790397644,
-0.3326287567615509,
-0.33548539876937866,
0.14027529954910278,
0.056594692170619965,
-0.23461322486400604,
0.2020036280155182,
-1.30620276927948,
0.5352235436439514,
0.47786569595336914,
0.4995121359825134,
-0.19122187793254852,
-0.5115476250648499,
-0.5475043058395386,
0.5131503939628601,
-0.6239620447158813,
1.0494909286499023,
-0.47960102558135986,
-0.40871888399124146,
0.21064838767051697,
-0.11842923611402512,
-0.10684031993150711,
-0.17335309088230133,
0.2561822831630707,
-0.31692981719970703,
0.15212079882621765,
0.279323011636734,
-0.7038698792457581,
0.09443221241235733,
-0.07881012558937073,
-0.6419968605041504,
0.8653429746627808,
0.16139808297157288,
-0.5397413969039917,
0.49709004163742065,
-0.6132925748825073,
-0.5743383169174194,
-0.1096239686012268,
-0.18616293370723724,
-0.419951856136322,
0.174312025308609,
0.2656137943267822,
0.7580559849739075,
0.3216433525085449,
0.7218002676963806,
-0.08643601089715958,
-0.08313357084989548,
0.1875029355287552,
-0.18843062222003937,
0.2567145526409149,
0.17905496060848236,
-0.17779509723186493,
0.3482929766178131,
-0.8626355528831482,
0.16005189716815948,
-0.22342632710933685,
-0.5419856309890747,
-0.1334899216890335,
0.15959618985652924,
0.09779265522956848,
0.0935981273651123,
0.14260908961296082,
-0.5978384017944336,
0.344329297542572,
-0.7449186444282532,
0.14785636961460114,
0.8698397278785706,
-0.19903400540351868,
0.9372851252555847,
-0.04872246831655502,
0.49990156292915344,
-0.27755072712898254,
-0.05144992470741272,
-0.3352438509464264,
-0.26998233795166016,
-0.9635114073753357,
0.051765527576208115,
0.18866552412509918,
0.12622126936912537,
-0.5893721580505371,
0.42697542905807495,
-0.020939238369464874,
-0.41517841815948486,
-0.1336897611618042,
0.1702270656824112,
0.6083819270133972,
0.3341456949710846,
0.41971099376678467,
-0.18094435334205627,
-0.723802924156189,
-0.7581225037574768,
-0.17887750267982483,
-0.3238961398601532,
0.15071241557598114,
-0.37974587082862854,
0.3226892054080963,
-0.09260574728250504,
0.9215693473815918,
-0.557290256023407,
-0.5028302073478699,
-0.8989815711975098,
0.5110750794410706,
0.04096230864524841,
0.6368877291679382,
0.14269208908081055,
-0.4863201677799225,
-0.5343347787857056,
-0.12173415720462799,
-0.40139392018318176,
-0.35544535517692566,
-0.3148786425590515,
-0.13270306587219238,
0.5352088809013367,
0.949374794960022,
-0.47653430700302124,
0.5506264567375183,
0.6664865612983704,
-0.3142135441303253,
0.5293661952018738,
-0.40003782510757446,
-0.573459804058075,
-1.1312639713287354,
-0.011850403621792793,
-0.19132252037525177,
-0.1274811029434204,
-0.6467030048370361,
-0.3570704460144043,
0.04274420812726021,
-0.2391422688961029,
-0.2423820048570633,
0.7794146537780762,
-0.6770222187042236,
-0.18242502212524414,
-0.5150115489959717,
-0.347621887922287,
-0.28900495171546936,
0.6872144341468811,
0.4788988530635834,
0.698781430721283,
0.539315402507782,
-0.6050756573677063,
-0.2868432402610779,
0.2228098064661026,
-0.4670952558517456,
-0.10575500875711441,
-0.35506561398506165,
-0.03571305796504021,
-0.15846851468086243,
0.21077772974967957,
-0.8410813808441162,
-0.15755301713943481,
-0.1174536868929863,
-0.5766621232032776,
0.6399675011634827,
-0.2293919324874878,
-0.24357590079307556,
-0.22559498250484467,
0.07260233163833618,
0.24690718948841095,
0.18337956070899963,
-0.5569270849227905,
0.8593330383300781,
0.5935482382774353,
-0.2239377498626709,
-0.5015550851821899,
-0.8499849438667297,
-0.04233498498797417,
-0.0012831190833821893,
-0.14927180111408234,
0.37260058522224426,
-0.09177932888269424,
-0.07755356281995773,
0.17192433774471283,
0.09024133533239365,
-0.3671738803386688,
-0.016710180789232254,
0.5476465225219727,
0.06950310617685318,
0.030740857124328613,
0.4004477262496948,
0.12690190970897675,
-0.5375128388404846,
0.27265581488609314,
-0.5972627997398376,
0.632649302482605,
0.48830553889274597,
-0.1608022004365921,
-0.35534152388572693,
0.5594745874404907,
0.12613950669765472,
-0.4116553068161011,
0.5799053311347961,
0.3307616412639618,
-0.33300021290779114,
-0.627935528755188,
-0.2763567566871643,
-0.05793454125523567,
-0.4649113714694977,
0.47536349296569824,
-0.3724125325679779,
-0.7474655508995056,
0.16553756594657898,
-0.027107398957014084,
0.19375021755695343,
0.37253573536872864,
0.3973735272884369,
0.041454948484897614,
0.9045007824897766,
1.3540126085281372,
-0.013029076159000397,
0.3176627457141876,
-0.3311522305011749,
0.27791139483451843,
-0.5944724678993225,
-0.4172619581222534,
-0.27490678429603577,
-0.18777404725551605,
-0.42748913168907166,
-0.5269979238510132,
0.009106454439461231,
0.008519168011844158,
0.1299813836812973,
0.4519428312778473,
-0.3345031440258026,
0.6051830649375916,
0.6803772449493408,
-0.4030369818210602,
0.2772899568080902,
0.11428545415401459,
-0.3240925669670105,
0.02926274575293064,
-0.6113638877868652,
-0.6831880807876587,
1.4756511449813843,
0.03880074620246887,
0.870524525642395,
-0.40554797649383545,
0.8701030015945435,
0.0019225527066737413,
0.49990007281303406,
-0.4682624638080597,
0.6280198693275452,
-0.01339095737785101,
-0.5956448316574097,
-0.5398174524307251,
-0.22727590799331665,
-1.0690251588821411,
0.1567254215478897,
-0.2826458513736725,
-0.9536144733428955,
0.09656226634979248,
0.2479170709848404,
-0.09685437381267548,
0.33580562472343445,
-0.8441892266273499,
0.7689668536186218,
-0.2256111055612564,
-0.08986233919858932,
-0.20683038234710693,
-0.38121259212493896,
0.05154756084084511,
-0.46081042289733887,
0.1496656984090805,
-0.25181472301483154,
0.031668052077293396,
0.8491750359535217,
-0.24784962832927704,
1.1701244115829468,
-0.02858852595090866,
0.13358215987682343,
0.28264909982681274,
0.14071889221668243,
0.3492712080478668,
0.03213880583643913,
-0.171560600399971,
-0.18456614017486572,
-0.2538139522075653,
-0.3716506063938141,
-0.32838210463523865,
0.6229042410850525,
-0.6510841250419617,
-0.3973053991794586,
-0.2964959442615509,
-0.7124460935592651,
-0.32373711466789246,
0.2923932671546936,
0.29597100615501404,
0.49951326847076416,
-0.5315324664115906,
-0.2262563407421112,
0.30785006284713745,
-0.24660344421863556,
0.8802254796028137,
0.6086752414703369,
-0.41114774346351624,
-0.1742689162492752,
0.6293891668319702,
0.1635185033082962,
0.32872501015663147,
0.7836767435073853,
0.18266896903514862,
-0.5004692673683167,
-0.7782630920410156,
-0.11418893933296204,
0.09621928632259369,
-0.7433197498321533,
-0.06583720445632935,
-1.00904381275177,
-0.1720249503850937,
-0.7473787665367126,
-0.2938915193080902,
-0.6010501384735107,
-0.5829834938049316,
-0.28279703855514526,
-0.43077516555786133,
0.09032511711120605,
0.8988699913024902,
-0.3003218472003937,
0.5157421231269836,
-0.2994350790977478,
0.006451372057199478,
-0.016841618344187737,
0.229093536734581,
-0.08341493457555771,
-0.26114708185195923,
-0.29458844661712646,
-0.3038622736930847,
-0.10023042559623718,
-0.39515942335128784,
0.7573877573013306,
0.08465440571308136,
0.6086610555648804,
0.32192930579185486,
0.21337361633777618,
0.5897619128227234,
-0.677769124507904,
0.15659025311470032,
0.12896142899990082,
-0.7278189659118652,
0.654684841632843,
-0.3128557503223419,
0.3963139057159424,
0.633463978767395,
0.353930801153183,
-0.35348832607269287,
-0.4346383512020111,
-0.6913349628448486,
-0.8188868761062622,
0.6089758276939392,
0.07568583637475967,
0.37573495507240295,
-0.05415673553943634,
0.3131779730319977,
0.29975247383117676,
0.3444213271141052,
-1.184145212173462,
-0.009391682222485542,
0.10177207738161087,
-0.09566785395145416,
-0.4513271152973175,
-0.4708496332168579,
0.39608508348464966,
-0.3754265010356903,
0.6359366774559021,
-0.346518337726593,
0.3181733191013336,
-0.09604134410619736,
0.08005228638648987,
-0.173782616853714,
0.12106269598007202,
0.20597243309020996,
0.7051020860671997,
0.03697410225868225,
0.26695504784584045,
0.060741670429706573,
-0.19170017540454865,
-0.08476457744836807,
0.11695437878370285,
-0.14136062562465668,
-0.11993347853422165,
0.6381272077560425,
0.5094531178474426,
0.39231422543525696,
-0.6457523703575134,
0.44965165853500366,
-0.050296083092689514,
-0.3303493857383728,
-0.5539161562919617,
-0.002495472552254796,
0.2683829665184021,
0.15965640544891357,
0.04747409373521805,
-0.08491522073745728,
-0.0474594347178936,
-0.6774774193763733,
0.2894945442676544,
0.199186772108078,
-0.45053088665008545,
-0.3940254747867584,
0.5900440812110901,
0.003123257076367736,
-0.1016206443309784,
0.43425774574279785,
-0.23476527631282806,
-0.5587385892868042,
0.36621907353401184,
0.8963770866394043,
0.7423437833786011,
-0.42183229327201843,
0.4341808259487152,
0.3679303824901581,
0.29775068163871765,
-0.025660285726189613,
0.37149423360824585,
-0.08385014533996582,
-0.5936766266822815,
-0.6145172715187073,
-0.9430601596832275,
0.04067246615886688,
0.17836782336235046,
-0.18652333319187164,
0.32480213046073914,
-0.44185101985931396,
0.19114024937152863,
-0.06247797980904579,
-0.0015421055722981691,
-0.4509766399860382,
0.4600104093551636,
-0.18330641090869904,
0.6778241395950317,
-0.8794024586677551,
1.09598708152771,
0.6306849718093872,
-0.28779712319374084,
-1.0354052782058716,
-0.01650381088256836,
-0.2946798801422119,
-0.8033139705657959,
0.6602529287338257,
0.38456737995147705,
-0.06789879500865936,
0.01791389286518097,
-0.28475221991539,
-1.1156989336013794,
0.6314366459846497,
0.2895226776599884,
-0.4562607705593109,
-0.2419145107269287,
0.2640342116355896,
0.4759614169597626,
-0.5453994870185852,
-0.08210072666406631,
0.1976977437734604,
0.21389159560203552,
0.21851995587348938,
-0.6615010499954224,
-0.32362768054008484,
-0.05872329697012901,
-0.31212958693504333,
0.49298474192619324,
-0.12544435262680054,
0.9332963228225708,
-0.461689829826355,
-0.3510702848434448,
0.3610764443874359,
0.8942317962646484,
-0.4170289933681488,
0.1712770164012909,
0.28475531935691833,
0.5879012942314148,
0.6920688152313232,
0.08294789493083954,
0.8950310945510864,
-0.17869196832180023,
0.02574995532631874,
1.4831913709640503,
-0.08189814537763596,
1.0742177963256836,
0.3088870048522949,
0.35774803161621094,
0.38977932929992676,
0.45881733298301697,
0.1329849511384964,
0.7965073585510254,
0.1126503050327301,
-0.22902999818325043,
-0.42419055104255676,
-0.1083793118596077,
-0.07142964005470276,
0.6765521764755249,
0.19905608892440796,
-0.5080341100692749,
-0.3209246098995209,
0.11722603440284729,
0.20343957841396332,
0.5886199474334717,
-0.39524444937705994,
0.7629854083061218,
0.02376854605972767,
-0.9102779030799866,
0.038601286709308624,
0.18102338910102844,
0.37052303552627563,
-0.452335923910141,
0.2948908507823944,
-0.1696968376636505,
0.43666237592697144,
-0.12114692479372025,
-0.8078065514564514,
0.6022037863731384,
-0.039333704859018326,
-0.12247853726148605,
-0.5754685997962952,
0.7984395623207092,
-0.7098392248153687,
-0.8163905739784241,
0.49514472484588623,
0.513405442237854,
0.19575245678424835,
-0.1661515086889267,
-0.29008761048316956,
-0.30907270312309265,
-0.061580535024404526,
-0.1499563753604889,
0.4411577582359314,
0.6437501311302185,
-0.2651027739048004,
0.6838369369506836,
0.7198169231414795,
0.26941680908203125,
-0.0818338543176651,
0.028923150151968002,
1.0267131328582764,
-0.6250308752059937,
-0.7255386710166931,
-0.724359393119812,
0.2102263867855072,
0.035532914102077484,
-0.3714214861392975,
0.4848801791667938,
1.035059928894043,
1.1967823505401611,
-0.025915786623954773,
0.6074509024620056,
0.4110105037689209,
0.4997435510158539,
-0.699761688709259,
0.7321487069129944,
-0.4261564314365387,
0.022654730826616287,
-0.11156932264566422,
-0.8644226789474487,
-0.35051628947257996,
0.6127278804779053,
-0.4974938929080963,
-0.1630016714334488,
0.8009976744651794,
0.6616106033325195,
0.04858657717704773,
-0.1777508705854416,
0.5289767980575562,
-0.1046304777264595,
0.2980499863624573,
0.5757430791854858,
0.7221238613128662,
0.2611100375652313,
0.49398866295814514,
-0.4879034161567688,
-0.13378463685512543,
0.27205637097358704,
-0.882727861404419,
-1.5066394805908203,
-0.8918455243110657,
-0.14440342783927917,
0.1204715147614479,
0.11988550424575806,
0.7400319576263428,
0.8689361214637756,
-0.4969126582145691,
-0.5124110579490662,
-0.36084261536598206,
-0.16866019368171692,
0.2943141758441925,
-0.0975513681769371,
0.3697932958602905,
-0.626164972782135,
-0.7075374126434326,
0.43644410371780396,
0.3889393210411072,
0.1302458941936493,
-0.25139108300209045,
0.043987076729536057,
-0.23070628941059113,
-0.06702549755573273,
0.5690131783485413,
0.2496989518404007,
-0.3854435086250305,
-0.004530822858214378,
-0.3095179498195648,
-0.0034790276549756527,
-0.07225766032934189,
0.9472252726554871,
-0.8243657946586609,
0.41865670680999756,
0.05153081566095352,
0.48799949884414673,
0.7818474769592285,
-0.18081675469875336,
0.89432692527771,
-0.9643653035163879,
0.3404618501663208,
0.3050011992454529,
0.2968681752681732,
0.22433918714523315,
-0.37799695134162903,
0.42500314116477966,
-0.19164559245109558,
-0.4891015291213989,
-0.2998161017894745,
0.19219131767749786,
-0.61407470703125,
-0.6593657732009888,
1.2551521062850952,
0.04133852198719978,
-0.31673088669776917,
-0.22383220493793488,
-0.16110490262508392,
0.49711793661117554,
-0.4188135862350464,
0.7584360837936401,
0.3947935700416565,
-0.18467861413955688,
0.0756661519408226,
-0.6090244054794312,
0.6999261975288391,
0.3279455304145813,
-0.9220066666603088,
0.35120928287506104,
0.5135399699211121,
0.014650736935436726,
-0.03315890207886696,
1.2496613264083862,
0.09148479998111725,
-0.09245198220014572,
-0.15752027928829193,
0.23289754986763,
-0.0002586676855571568,
-0.7829286456108093,
0.14497651159763336,
0.033320121467113495,
0.20195606350898743,
0.007944745011627674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00610v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00610v1
|
RQ-RAG: Learning to Refine Queries for Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-03-31T08:58:54 | 2024-03-31T08:58:54 |
Chi-Min Chan, Chunpu Xu, Ruibin Yuan, Hongyin Luo, Wei Xue, Yike Guo, Jie Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable capabilities but are prone to
generating inaccurate or hallucinatory responses. This limitation stems from
their reliance on vast pretraining datasets, making them susceptible to errors
in unseen scenarios. To tackle these challenges, Retrieval-Augmented Generation
(RAG) addresses this by incorporating external, relevant documents into the
response generation process, thus leveraging non-parametric knowledge alongside
LLMs' in-context learning abilities. However, existing RAG implementations
primarily focus on initial input for context retrieval, overlooking the nuances
of ambiguous or complex queries that necessitate further clarification or
decomposition for accurate responses. To this end, we propose learning to
Refine Query for Retrieval Augmented Generation (RQ-RAG) in this paper,
endeavoring to enhance the model by equipping it with capabilities for explicit
rewriting, decomposition, and disambiguation. Our experimental results indicate
that our method, when applied to a 7B Llama2 model, surpasses the previous
state-of-the-art (SOTA) by an average of 1.9\% across three single-hop QA
datasets, and also demonstrates enhanced performance in handling complex,
multi-hop QA datasets. Our code is available at
https://github.com/chanchimin/RQ-RAG.
|
[
-0.4110991954803467,
-0.7176434993743896,
0.48578909039497375,
-0.08074510842561722,
-0.27489686012268066,
0.3103572428226471,
0.0560169480741024,
-0.43121641874313354,
0.31214746832847595,
0.7506868839263916,
-0.536701500415802,
-0.14986850321292877,
-0.2980758249759674,
0.27948257327079773,
-0.36190658807754517,
1.0251879692077637,
0.16170068085193634,
0.023542186245322227,
-0.3747423589229584,
-0.3101709187030792,
-0.4348301589488983,
-0.42418980598449707,
-0.7240864634513855,
-0.2315499484539032,
0.6650856137275696,
0.4812741279602051,
0.20096127688884735,
0.28276073932647705,
0.40147843956947327,
0.22672396898269653,
-0.16359056532382965,
0.8698616623878479,
-0.8499898910522461,
0.5739029049873352,
-0.3909890055656433,
-0.4786902666091919,
-0.3110494911670685,
-0.3212343454360962,
0.7068135738372803,
0.4014531373977661,
-0.23922036588191986,
0.6506226658821106,
0.013741410337388515,
0.8597044348716736,
-0.6794174313545227,
-0.0947994738817215,
-1.0553936958312988,
-0.4267330765724182,
-0.12854446470737457,
-0.5279567241668701,
-0.6104124784469604,
-0.17050661146640778,
-0.22691410779953003,
-0.7945906519889832,
0.33740079402923584,
0.3315047025680542,
0.8961495161056519,
0.5165534019470215,
-0.5503897070884705,
-0.35764846205711365,
-0.6077709794044495,
0.6504079699516296,
-0.40371695160865784,
0.5169618129730225,
0.5577014684677124,
0.49668261408805847,
-0.6025589108467102,
-1.1153209209442139,
-0.6598618030548096,
-0.2260114848613739,
-0.14259041845798492,
-0.005062554031610489,
0.12541450560092926,
-0.2315824329853058,
0.4406623840332031,
0.41904863715171814,
-0.3473644554615021,
-0.21085448563098907,
-0.4564041197299957,
0.16799402236938477,
0.5725988745689392,
0.1034775972366333,
0.10162096470594406,
-0.3435032367706299,
-0.4637168049812317,
-0.006339229177683592,
-0.8426083326339722,
-0.032322872430086136,
0.10106317698955536,
0.48477527499198914,
0.2741753160953522,
0.5518328547477722,
-0.2901107370853424,
0.7245888113975525,
0.3012312948703766,
-0.2510608434677124,
0.2685714066028595,
-0.23627270758152008,
-0.1414184272289276,
-0.3890431523323059,
0.42431268095970154,
-0.026800652965903282,
-0.240457221865654,
-0.1284918338060379,
-0.47622472047805786,
-0.4085395634174347,
0.519815981388092,
-0.6979609727859497,
-0.0057126921601593494,
0.11500509083271027,
-0.18305206298828125,
-0.17771016061306,
-0.20571310818195343,
-0.554789662361145,
-0.5583693981170654,
-0.5024665594100952,
0.39014768600463867,
-0.33690235018730164,
-0.11853160709142685,
-0.14287275075912476,
-0.016426483169198036,
0.4053557515144348,
0.22743280231952667,
-0.4955689311027527,
0.1655949205160141,
0.6162028312683105,
0.32092157006263733,
0.1627187430858612,
-0.07639048993587494,
-0.9694560766220093,
0.24868230521678925,
-0.381456583738327,
0.9469957947731018,
-0.6363822221755981,
-0.4192958474159241,
-0.2420315146446228,
-0.11660841107368469,
0.15909935534000397,
-0.7559942007064819,
0.5889560580253601,
-1.1017628908157349,
0.1353040635585785,
-0.33288151025772095,
-0.32727333903312683,
-0.15521852672100067,
0.3378009498119354,
-0.7343205809593201,
1.3420683145523071,
0.43007639050483704,
-0.8443277478218079,
0.31343087553977966,
-0.23173339664936066,
-0.3474332094192505,
0.09161268174648285,
-0.19581763446331024,
-0.601277232170105,
0.2684260308742523,
0.27687060832977295,
0.06656190752983093,
-0.6733624935150146,
0.2673659324645996,
-0.05125313624739647,
-0.4078269898891449,
0.11573953181505203,
0.08487655967473984,
0.555425763130188,
0.3385484218597412,
0.035064250230789185,
0.0772414281964302,
-0.969009518623352,
0.17767983675003052,
0.17154663801193237,
-0.5046416521072388,
-0.4461270272731781,
-0.23294757306575775,
-0.18694357573986053,
0.10947154462337494,
0.20442038774490356,
-0.3187732696533203,
0.22316214442253113,
-0.4957024157047272,
-0.014672576449811459,
0.48279309272766113,
0.2617959976196289,
0.3362639248371124,
-0.42744672298431396,
0.7001251578330994,
-0.2731481194496155,
-0.12977033853530884,
-0.14325682818889618,
-0.230106383562088,
-0.6723600625991821,
-0.2693464457988739,
0.47492218017578125,
0.2962910830974579,
-1.4021458625793457,
-0.13588847219944,
-0.12009329348802567,
-0.4025213122367859,
-0.6499798893928528,
0.13458028435707092,
0.6374825835227966,
0.8775984048843384,
0.5900698900222778,
0.022336861118674278,
-0.9842709302902222,
-0.5949810743331909,
-0.3422478437423706,
-0.22021304070949554,
-0.20717784762382507,
0.49138516187667847,
0.20636925101280212,
-0.4238535463809967,
0.8476788997650146,
-0.42569953203201294,
-0.2846653163433075,
-0.3000345826148987,
0.07328973710536957,
0.025343839079141617,
0.18021883070468903,
0.1906656175851822,
-1.0533976554870605,
-0.4258258640766144,
-0.08751071989536285,
-0.47635617852211,
-0.3340018093585968,
0.0943693220615387,
-0.2775557041168213,
0.244513139128685,
0.5441070199012756,
-0.3938899338245392,
0.33936113119125366,
0.3483576774597168,
-0.11415211111307144,
0.5939080119132996,
-0.21591809391975403,
0.18039658665657043,
-1.385840892791748,
0.3011876940727234,
-0.2712949514389038,
-0.32915782928466797,
-0.5868367552757263,
0.5654370784759521,
0.11739188432693481,
0.045903079211711884,
-0.3089391589164734,
0.7899709343910217,
-0.5321238040924072,
-0.21669523417949677,
-0.5198427438735962,
0.0719132348895073,
0.29051709175109863,
0.34380006790161133,
-0.10308719426393509,
0.917691171169281,
0.07211021333932877,
-0.7055188417434692,
0.19312797486782074,
0.395145446062088,
-0.1602681577205658,
0.3009580373764038,
-0.4625891149044037,
0.2667500376701355,
-0.3344263732433319,
0.4968911409378052,
-0.9248960018157959,
-0.4403833746910095,
0.08235182613134384,
-0.7204663753509521,
0.5043497085571289,
-0.24447093904018402,
-0.41697797179222107,
-0.10628996044397354,
-0.21903616189956665,
0.6463401913642883,
0.48484012484550476,
-0.8539096117019653,
0.9089211225509644,
0.49243032932281494,
0.09933111816644669,
-0.8965999484062195,
-0.24204614758491516,
-0.1818471997976303,
-0.2035471349954605,
-0.3034352660179138,
0.3629648983478546,
0.18213973939418793,
-0.16202688217163086,
-0.24497544765472412,
-0.14833152294158936,
-0.1228959858417511,
-0.01955891028046608,
0.15324091911315918,
0.12163671851158142,
0.06738554686307907,
0.33009788393974304,
-0.04668514057993889,
-0.07451248168945312,
-0.15673667192459106,
0.03658497333526611,
0.5297584533691406,
0.1693006008863449,
-0.18273280560970306,
-0.00960818026214838,
0.10211934894323349,
0.43881872296333313,
-0.7231345176696777,
0.6329958438873291,
0.592187225818634,
-0.2459491789340973,
-0.5286507606506348,
-0.5783141851425171,
-0.23497994244098663,
-0.4763406217098236,
0.31258565187454224,
-0.631596565246582,
-0.9234302639961243,
0.49168333411216736,
-0.2503497898578644,
-0.010614325292408466,
0.3234157860279083,
0.5346903800964355,
-0.1041533425450325,
0.7630742788314819,
0.6279106736183167,
0.3087935447692871,
0.32810136675834656,
-0.2692572772502899,
0.10059007257223129,
-1.3462437391281128,
-0.4071100652217865,
-0.5803372263908386,
-0.07108170539140701,
-0.7146867513656616,
-0.8237758278846741,
0.4758926331996918,
0.2848965525627136,
-0.31992754340171814,
-0.05035779997706413,
-0.4339599311351776,
0.40461719036102295,
0.45632630586624146,
0.22028641402721405,
0.3748241364955902,
0.16669437289237976,
-0.07273590564727783,
0.2097010612487793,
-0.6495248079299927,
-0.3820425868034363,
1.2185872793197632,
0.23848316073417664,
0.8116961717605591,
0.2458982914686203,
0.8409319519996643,
-0.0538986399769783,
0.5015748739242554,
-0.7039962410926819,
0.45123887062072754,
-0.11975803226232529,
-0.5805714726448059,
-0.30194541811943054,
-0.6649187803268433,
-1.0693451166152954,
0.3336142599582672,
-0.2721152901649475,
-0.2248133271932602,
0.1703324019908905,
0.21115891635417938,
-0.40812814235687256,
0.11949233710765839,
-0.47308316826820374,
0.23256756365299225,
-0.02010594867169857,
-0.5495991706848145,
0.03302398696541786,
-0.5232487320899963,
0.5910640358924866,
-0.27658337354660034,
0.25677987933158875,
-0.03076234832406044,
-0.12225643545389175,
0.4546923041343689,
-0.38481804728507996,
0.5066893696784973,
-0.18539446592330933,
-0.17018088698387146,
0.5626692771911621,
0.14513684809207916,
0.6423772573471069,
0.25516775250434875,
-0.149713397026062,
-0.41020467877388,
-0.007714313920587301,
-0.32424768805503845,
-0.7037569284439087,
0.5024961829185486,
-0.5157031416893005,
-0.7061758041381836,
-0.2285347580909729,
-0.5680021047592163,
-0.5359570980072021,
0.23118247091770172,
0.09079878777265549,
0.5034485459327698,
0.11633478105068207,
0.1581961065530777,
0.8068962097167969,
-0.3310723304748535,
-0.17160294950008392,
0.7556578516960144,
-0.6190919876098633,
-0.4382416009902954,
0.9092570543289185,
-0.008472285233438015,
0.13783343136310577,
0.47739896178245544,
0.14440886676311493,
-0.5609368085861206,
-0.5051537752151489,
-0.3034285306930542,
0.3935185372829437,
-0.5713502168655396,
-0.6109516024589539,
-0.4982338547706604,
-0.0881962776184082,
-0.4870296120643616,
0.2805544137954712,
-0.18176649510860443,
-0.39321982860565186,
-0.18036073446273804,
-0.027285724878311157,
0.5079295039176941,
0.6701428890228271,
0.006454624701291323,
0.10740929841995239,
-0.7842656970024109,
0.8788304924964905,
0.2821049988269806,
0.35361745953559875,
0.08938907086849213,
-0.8603137731552124,
-0.1762511432170868,
0.03145899996161461,
-0.24027615785598755,
-0.7182696461677551,
0.487789511680603,
0.22364726662635803,
0.4886828362941742,
-0.17132817208766937,
0.3684408366680145,
0.784644603729248,
-0.6343453526496887,
0.4613606631755829,
-0.24653907120227814,
-0.4604978561401367,
0.5025011897087097,
-0.3923405110836029,
0.20958079397678375,
0.6698212027549744,
0.41220623254776,
-0.2145160734653473,
-0.2657821476459503,
-0.6199080348014832,
-1.1039785146713257,
0.5928685069084167,
-0.07395528256893158,
0.01784479431807995,
-0.07899938523769379,
0.7877063751220703,
0.07697045803070068,
0.12465281039476395,
-0.438418447971344,
-0.1105652004480362,
0.16954746842384338,
0.08310585469007492,
0.13436855375766754,
-0.6879015564918518,
-0.07855884730815887,
-0.1376907080411911,
0.8661277890205383,
-0.17716166377067566,
0.010102796368300915,
0.1561102718114853,
-0.07783468067646027,
-0.11406853795051575,
0.17604757845401764,
0.43913719058036804,
0.8712190389633179,
-0.20685869455337524,
0.02952621318399906,
0.3258252739906311,
-0.31901413202285767,
0.19554615020751953,
0.01531981397420168,
-0.1218978688120842,
-0.06471919268369675,
0.23141860961914062,
0.49268215894699097,
0.05455826222896576,
-0.8701909184455872,
0.16784031689167023,
-0.27827784419059753,
0.033568888902664185,
-0.346445769071579,
-0.05047890171408653,
-0.03279652073979378,
0.32745954394340515,
0.6013139486312866,
-0.35507339239120483,
0.33714327216148376,
-0.525336742401123,
0.5550311207771301,
0.3756382465362549,
0.006419624201953411,
-0.003383651142939925,
0.6189112663269043,
-0.0021079054567962885,
-0.1458168476819992,
0.5696553587913513,
-0.4288792312145233,
-0.42248600721359253,
0.3434562385082245,
0.6742084622383118,
0.6386624574661255,
-0.32386723160743713,
0.04865438863635063,
0.6399346590042114,
0.06973057240247726,
-0.01264074258506298,
0.4745352864265442,
-0.09635093063116074,
-0.47397279739379883,
-0.5616446137428284,
-1.004447340965271,
-0.3994303345680237,
0.15397481620311737,
-0.8521984815597534,
0.26633673906326294,
-0.4120325446128845,
-0.17931850254535675,
-0.34846031665802,
0.14740002155303955,
-0.48415181040763855,
0.3919138014316559,
-0.15381371974945068,
0.7470726370811462,
-0.3534839451313019,
0.7189821600914001,
0.9269583821296692,
-0.6036480665206909,
-1.1177011728286743,
0.04950343072414398,
-0.345283180475235,
-0.809734046459198,
0.8990726470947266,
-0.12911896407604218,
-0.29987695813179016,
0.06462806463241577,
-0.4506833255290985,
-1.0410417318344116,
1.0310395956039429,
0.4075676202774048,
-0.4014971852302551,
-0.13193966448307037,
-0.023033756762742996,
0.6850799322128296,
-0.24567434191703796,
0.3489283323287964,
0.5190742015838623,
0.10263586789369583,
0.4873782694339752,
-0.9233229160308838,
0.047980573028326035,
-0.08726462721824646,
0.19367319345474243,
0.2944663465023041,
-0.7159628868103027,
0.7901297807693481,
-0.23057743906974792,
-0.27022668719291687,
0.1418716311454773,
0.7047763466835022,
0.8272873759269714,
0.43692320585250854,
0.22266876697540283,
0.7560045719146729,
0.8267180323600769,
0.04872557148337364,
1.1599206924438477,
-0.17569437623023987,
0.21747276186943054,
1.5981179475784302,
-0.22832196950912476,
1.2510212659835815,
0.4616853892803192,
-0.05355095490813255,
0.5288228988647461,
0.48339247703552246,
0.4709051847457886,
0.4156661629676819,
0.3333204686641693,
-0.3391413390636444,
-0.11599200963973999,
-0.27499377727508545,
-0.38486096262931824,
0.5153053998947144,
0.4767094850540161,
-0.3463011682033539,
-0.2707746922969818,
-0.07419757544994354,
-0.17943312227725983,
0.35550859570503235,
-0.37593841552734375,
0.9505931735038757,
0.13150350749492645,
-0.6421362161636353,
1.0661113262176514,
0.019069185480475426,
0.38746821880340576,
-0.41216230392456055,
-0.3832794725894928,
-0.489590585231781,
0.03338545188307762,
-0.36974239349365234,
-0.4809861481189728,
0.3783454895019531,
0.13298748433589935,
-0.35734400153160095,
-0.028779128566384315,
0.8069559931755066,
-0.3733746111392975,
-0.41312140226364136,
0.1085612028837204,
0.4315345883369446,
0.055088113993406296,
0.009921416640281677,
-0.5715091824531555,
0.16852614283561707,
0.21208643913269043,
-0.26295143365859985,
0.41591423749923706,
0.6606426239013672,
-0.14989303052425385,
0.8371201753616333,
0.6404744386672974,
-0.019910581409931183,
0.09937674552202225,
0.09932313114404678,
1.1110129356384277,
-0.526220440864563,
-0.23310120403766632,
-0.3701093792915344,
0.5792865753173828,
0.029915718361735344,
-0.008233410306274891,
0.7464639544487,
0.6041077971458435,
0.9271785616874695,
0.11220500618219376,
0.5786145329475403,
0.04481031745672226,
1.2477519512176514,
-0.5495443344116211,
0.6196993589401245,
-0.7911700010299683,
0.6329907178878784,
0.09574191272258759,
-0.8595040440559387,
-0.1732536256313324,
0.42077913880348206,
-0.25323644280433655,
0.1849752813577652,
0.33912384510040283,
0.9293324947357178,
0.16781321167945862,
-0.5245204567909241,
0.2641928195953369,
0.08315867185592651,
0.4245914816856384,
0.33665257692337036,
0.9309478998184204,
-0.5942182540893555,
0.5286223292350769,
-0.07841488718986511,
-0.16702815890312195,
-0.16911418735980988,
-0.6148862838745117,
-0.7653306722640991,
-0.7441662549972534,
-0.01511544082313776,
-0.5098201632499695,
0.03327421844005585,
0.762523889541626,
0.3278140127658844,
-0.540177047252655,
-0.15393389761447906,
0.21247200667858124,
0.17750334739685059,
0.18058501183986664,
-0.19644179940223694,
0.3597326874732971,
-0.7527387738227844,
-0.5923881530761719,
0.5660625696182251,
-0.11759137362241745,
-0.2242083102464676,
-0.1408209204673767,
-0.03268839418888092,
-0.3749212920665741,
0.10181371867656708,
0.7304667830467224,
0.5267177820205688,
-0.6607549786567688,
0.07609465718269348,
0.04747942090034485,
-0.03021162562072277,
-0.056071531027555466,
0.6655158996582031,
-1.2323360443115234,
0.6074385643005371,
0.5843605399131775,
0.9259217381477356,
0.5232957005500793,
0.49835383892059326,
0.44450053572654724,
-1.0414210557937622,
0.014630869962275028,
0.43049535155296326,
0.07152639329433441,
0.34594985842704773,
-0.3795842230319977,
0.6281747221946716,
-0.1814740002155304,
-0.6857603788375854,
-1.2125972509384155,
0.30724549293518066,
-0.5777610540390015,
-0.2562178671360016,
1.1946836709976196,
0.07113959640264511,
-0.3073868155479431,
-0.028378773480653763,
-0.455947607755661,
0.36961543560028076,
-0.14361149072647095,
0.8380521535873413,
0.08946465700864792,
-0.23203474283218384,
-0.26534244418144226,
-0.550082266330719,
0.7324349880218506,
0.3076857328414917,
-0.7297492623329163,
0.20033913850784302,
0.7052844762802124,
0.27853643894195557,
0.10204661637544632,
0.7021636962890625,
-0.1704224795103073,
0.36126741766929626,
-0.10597597062587738,
0.015897240489721298,
-0.22254377603530884,
-0.3533746004104614,
-0.15971533954143524,
0.24632138013839722,
0.44364264607429504,
-0.017861373722553253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00604v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00604v1
|
Extensive Self-Contrast Enables Feedback-Free Language Model Alignment
| 2024-03-31T08:30:15 | 2024-03-31T08:30:15 |
Xiao Liu, Xixuan Song, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has been a central
technique for recent large language model (LLM) alignment. However, its heavy
dependence on costly human or LLM-as-Judge preference feedback could stymie its
wider applications. In this work, we introduce Self-Contrast, a feedback-free
large language model alignment method via exploiting extensive self-generated
negatives. With only supervised fine-tuning (SFT) targets, Self-Contrast
leverages the LLM itself to generate massive diverse candidates, and harnesses
a pre-trained embedding model to filter multiple negatives according to text
similarity. Theoretically, we illustrate that in this setting, merely scaling
negative responses can still effectively approximate situations with more
balanced positive and negative preference annotations. Our experiments with
direct preference optimization (DPO) on three datasets show that, Self-Contrast
could consistently outperform SFT and standard DPO training by large margins.
And as the number of self-generated negatives increases, the performance of
Self-Contrast continues to grow. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/THUDM/Self-Contrast.
|
[
-0.4893094599246979,
-0.5580517053604126,
0.5190741419792175,
0.3081865608692169,
-0.23639918863773346,
-0.12808631360530853,
-0.3764649033546448,
-0.30272090435028076,
0.45340844988822937,
0.7707196474075317,
-0.5949901342391968,
-0.41980496048927307,
-0.2561451494693756,
0.1346559077501297,
-0.3837859332561493,
1.1707630157470703,
0.033755894750356674,
0.00046691790339536965,
-0.04587961360812187,
-0.3065904974937439,
-0.3308177888393402,
-0.4305930435657501,
-0.36525291204452515,
-0.3897516131401062,
0.6878140568733215,
0.5935867428779602,
0.5910892486572266,
0.9989812970161438,
0.21399962902069092,
0.32310962677001953,
0.3988974094390869,
0.01681872457265854,
-0.5943620800971985,
0.36233553290367126,
-0.49751609563827515,
-0.01717287488281727,
-0.17205460369586945,
0.11742672324180603,
0.5628015995025635,
0.197067990899086,
-0.11414980888366699,
-0.026972966268658638,
0.33486154675483704,
0.6833190321922302,
-0.7028186917304993,
-0.1668960303068161,
-0.44285279512405396,
0.03843042254447937,
-0.08684542775154114,
-0.21627233922481537,
-0.5669175386428833,
-0.1031179428100586,
0.029338568449020386,
-0.5737956166267395,
0.12068340182304382,
-0.06983235478401184,
0.8463446497917175,
0.5509471297264099,
-0.5644758343696594,
-0.1653338074684143,
-0.5891494154930115,
0.9373000860214233,
-0.8664177060127258,
0.2144792228937149,
0.16679900884628296,
0.11823467910289764,
-0.030664319172501564,
0.04010867699980736,
-0.5359752774238586,
-0.2838292717933655,
-0.14922621846199036,
0.3248169720172882,
0.02844206430017948,
0.09969222545623779,
-0.17320121824741364,
0.2879045903682709,
-0.512135922908783,
0.5775725841522217,
-0.12919451296329498,
-0.16775722801685333,
0.6254725456237793,
0.03429104760289192,
0.15800757706165314,
-0.11473116278648376,
-0.4089053273200989,
-0.24614016711711884,
-0.605617880821228,
-0.2599594295024872,
0.4406979978084564,
0.5293861627578735,
-0.2600710093975067,
0.49510452151298523,
-0.37770941853523254,
0.8000951409339905,
0.41074272990226746,
-0.013825586065649986,
0.31613075733184814,
-0.050139930099248886,
-0.23108184337615967,
0.09767978638410568,
0.9917113184928894,
0.4975179135799408,
0.11639595031738281,
-0.03617586940526962,
-0.31713879108428955,
0.15349219739437103,
0.23967942595481873,
-0.9767577648162842,
-0.22843371331691742,
0.13886195421218872,
-0.273483544588089,
-0.5234268307685852,
-0.253155916929245,
-0.8017973899841309,
-0.6422605514526367,
-0.4812815189361572,
0.6238297820091248,
-0.026348711922764778,
-0.1322150081396103,
0.10391726344823837,
0.2671179473400116,
0.2686889171600342,
0.4849660098552704,
-1.0416810512542725,
0.1734297126531601,
0.4636281728744507,
0.6277087330818176,
-0.27747511863708496,
-0.4855138063430786,
-0.8411361575126648,
-0.0184362530708313,
-0.5274466872215271,
0.7659555077552795,
-0.48325300216674805,
-0.08957403898239136,
-0.14733822643756866,
-0.1988069713115692,
0.2778879404067993,
-0.5280838012695312,
0.4483480453491211,
-0.36399924755096436,
0.43887966871261597,
0.01572510413825512,
-0.5429055094718933,
0.11910172551870346,
0.304900199174881,
-0.42456504702568054,
0.8140069246292114,
-0.0364907905459404,
-0.7367640733718872,
0.1595776379108429,
-0.10699042677879333,
-0.3493652045726776,
-0.24273687601089478,
-0.503678023815155,
-0.609844446182251,
0.05789412558078766,
0.3533724248409271,
0.4936582148075104,
-0.1562701016664505,
0.17747268080711365,
-0.8476022481918335,
-0.35655370354652405,
0.22228388488292694,
-0.3041076958179474,
0.3162572383880615,
0.2894292175769806,
-0.7145563364028931,
0.57591712474823,
-0.7394459843635559,
-0.08681115508079529,
0.07430749386548996,
-0.19239331781864166,
-0.4053654670715332,
-0.1621968150138855,
-0.3634907603263855,
0.6416198015213013,
0.3203560709953308,
-0.5658981800079346,
0.2150915116071701,
-0.3290078341960907,
0.19645902514457703,
0.9662470817565918,
-0.25816038250923157,
0.46876710653305054,
-0.10708706080913544,
0.5612924695014954,
-0.02608783170580864,
-0.005112986080348492,
-0.20795892179012299,
0.1643954962491989,
-0.9526829123497009,
-0.32778462767601013,
0.3082261085510254,
0.18132886290550232,
-0.4079829156398773,
0.48689696192741394,
-0.16292276978492737,
-0.2593480050563812,
-0.9062191247940063,
0.4026477634906769,
0.61021488904953,
0.7571544647216797,
0.5931537747383118,
-0.13605809211730957,
-0.3464530110359192,
-1.3124738931655884,
-0.012736981734633446,
0.16555091738700867,
0.09223273396492004,
0.5802168250083923,
0.058695387095212936,
-0.1958124190568924,
0.6468454003334045,
-0.6297650933265686,
-0.5273856520652771,
0.1382639855146408,
0.2202354073524475,
0.10304304212331772,
0.5102011561393738,
0.4428233504295349,
-0.27353155612945557,
-0.7533586621284485,
0.025975249707698822,
-0.4416615962982178,
-0.44791752099990845,
-0.25997990369796753,
-0.3066747188568115,
0.21556037664413452,
0.7223135232925415,
-0.028120379894971848,
-0.07723766565322876,
1.0360844135284424,
-0.4416043758392334,
0.4485665559768677,
-0.4760921895503998,
0.1762685626745224,
-0.9469187259674072,
0.06334578990936279,
0.14155471324920654,
-0.3198116719722748,
-0.3246581256389618,
0.08595144003629684,
0.3666914999485016,
0.09145567566156387,
-0.14379636943340302,
0.7779889106750488,
-0.3517642915248871,
0.15559911727905273,
-0.6082592606544495,
0.4407952129840851,
-0.06127748265862465,
0.6564224362373352,
0.12079737335443497,
0.79201340675354,
0.31450510025024414,
-0.5672244429588318,
0.07690979540348053,
0.05783475935459137,
-0.04637051373720169,
0.41046807169914246,
-0.4677523970603943,
0.21169456839561462,
-0.07017254084348679,
0.32654058933258057,
-1.1896523237228394,
-0.11497882753610611,
0.20498836040496826,
-0.14742553234100342,
0.4595155119895935,
-0.13899168372154236,
-0.08324731141328812,
-0.24604491889476776,
-0.5119566917419434,
0.35546618700027466,
0.2582043409347534,
-0.8772097229957581,
0.3160150945186615,
0.16484661400318146,
-0.22244606912136078,
-0.8802052140235901,
-0.7417353391647339,
-0.02954212762415409,
-0.07821726053953171,
-0.1249777302145958,
0.2878290116786957,
-0.21216781437397003,
0.02469806931912899,
-0.16787084937095642,
0.011014336720108986,
0.22913755476474762,
0.20761050283908844,
0.15508869290351868,
0.18386897444725037,
-0.09153371304273605,
0.3395731747150421,
0.13472771644592285,
-0.12035485357046127,
-0.21614350378513336,
-0.20584656298160553,
0.5890064835548401,
-0.18184557557106018,
-0.32947954535484314,
-0.40625128149986267,
0.16248613595962524,
0.3970452845096588,
-0.28530049324035645,
0.32775238156318665,
0.3364076316356659,
0.2055254727602005,
-0.2099309116601944,
-0.6853402256965637,
-0.2598312795162201,
-0.48328641057014465,
0.40316909551620483,
-0.18039467930793762,
-1.1599260568618774,
0.26062506437301636,
0.2558918595314026,
0.05750880390405655,
0.4882052540779114,
0.4401610195636749,
-0.0848979651927948,
1.1815617084503174,
0.4450749158859253,
-0.2199503481388092,
0.6995574235916138,
0.2254539430141449,
-0.10729758441448212,
-0.7613347768783569,
0.24332740902900696,
-0.48674678802490234,
-0.4791024625301361,
-0.8512207865715027,
-0.2489595115184784,
-0.18008528649806976,
0.12806196510791779,
-0.5857337713241577,
0.11800210922956467,
-0.7095980644226074,
0.5463583469390869,
0.4839428663253784,
0.14919142425060272,
0.1561400294303894,
-0.24964775145053864,
-0.22009199857711792,
-0.3433878421783447,
-0.35950836539268494,
-0.16039392352104187,
1.0007067918777466,
0.32498782873153687,
1.1612002849578857,
0.04455314204096794,
1.214634895324707,
0.1075749471783638,
0.6445420384407043,
-0.62183678150177,
0.33276569843292236,
-0.46787944436073303,
-0.3973003625869751,
-0.5369152426719666,
-0.5441060066223145,
-0.8944207429885864,
0.39320650696754456,
-0.37618133425712585,
-0.36910387873649597,
0.11376522481441498,
0.5987728238105774,
-0.45010387897491455,
-0.009590761736035347,
-0.7429540157318115,
0.7797425985336304,
-0.5414842367172241,
-0.6590092182159424,
-0.403827965259552,
-0.6318554282188416,
0.2673882842063904,
-0.06904790550470352,
0.17203643918037415,
-0.05755849555134773,
0.014648114331066608,
0.47906798124313354,
-0.07456720620393753,
1.0112463235855103,
-0.10688382387161255,
-0.545853853225708,
0.02895434945821762,
0.4363816976547241,
0.5642657279968262,
-0.10042626410722733,
-0.048889558762311935,
-0.31352758407592773,
-0.3675835132598877,
-0.38923707604408264,
-0.7084206938743591,
1.1328049898147583,
-0.8782703876495361,
-0.741613507270813,
-0.2675798237323761,
-0.23255833983421326,
-0.14827664196491241,
0.45765602588653564,
-0.08964618295431137,
0.3823532462120056,
-0.012413558550179005,
0.18257908523082733,
0.44893592596054077,
-0.48911771178245544,
0.24330264329910278,
0.7222187519073486,
-0.6895855665206909,
-0.745434045791626,
1.2083935737609863,
-0.11211773753166199,
0.3993679881095886,
0.5498126149177551,
0.5426720976829529,
-0.45550358295440674,
-0.34474658966064453,
-0.5619783997535706,
0.5024199485778809,
-0.5412627458572388,
-0.3826408386230469,
-0.5402682423591614,
0.06902991235256195,
-0.43385809659957886,
-0.252750426530838,
-0.6541390419006348,
-0.41449427604675293,
-0.32246634364128113,
-0.06825811415910721,
0.04033167287707329,
0.9148523807525635,
-0.220330610871315,
0.11507049202919006,
-0.4912632405757904,
0.2537836730480194,
0.5858445167541504,
0.6350513696670532,
0.026461202651262283,
-0.6905809044837952,
-0.2082221508026123,
-0.16292788088321686,
-0.4676872789859772,
-0.6312323808670044,
0.37128111720085144,
0.07823994755744934,
0.25317028164863586,
0.5170527100563049,
0.20227575302124023,
0.6525089740753174,
-0.32569342851638794,
0.6091877222061157,
0.29926997423171997,
-0.9097089767456055,
0.38039031624794006,
-0.5029988884925842,
0.5901505947113037,
0.7373943328857422,
0.12178460508584976,
-0.5807067155838013,
-0.47034752368927,
-0.3819253742694855,
-0.8442510366439819,
0.6321589350700378,
-0.23803390562534332,
0.21020548045635223,
-0.22625544667243958,
0.44373664259910583,
0.10543186217546463,
0.1095481812953949,
-1.0691906213760376,
-0.2826021909713745,
-0.44523707032203674,
-0.30222007632255554,
-0.3503352105617523,
-0.26961377263069153,
-0.1536267101764679,
-0.04387331381440163,
0.8748069405555725,
-0.49423331022262573,
0.0012603725772351027,
0.21298626065254211,
-0.13054317235946655,
-0.15416988730430603,
0.6091038584709167,
0.8311936259269714,
0.12824833393096924,
-0.11080527305603027,
0.32783615589141846,
0.14417764544487,
0.26697292923927307,
0.21337160468101501,
0.05779469758272171,
-0.042087070643901825,
-0.4036664068698883,
0.1175294816493988,
0.5995099544525146,
0.3039179742336273,
-0.42132768034935,
0.6499720215797424,
-0.07478407025337219,
-0.2942320704460144,
0.15244482457637787,
-0.004141551908105612,
0.16343346238136292,
0.24004535377025604,
-0.06696542352437973,
-0.3070095181465149,
0.09317675977945328,
-0.3386746942996979,
0.3006838262081146,
0.5166090726852417,
-0.6844549179077148,
-0.13214097917079926,
0.48594045639038086,
0.5082942843437195,
-0.03783457726240158,
0.647246241569519,
-0.22432398796081543,
-0.4915183484554291,
0.24229764938354492,
0.7874131202697754,
0.7979120016098022,
-0.3280981183052063,
0.3254002630710602,
0.49443483352661133,
-0.0893699899315834,
-0.07789576053619385,
0.04833277687430382,
-0.3641524314880371,
-0.7549328804016113,
-0.5566943883895874,
-0.4846457540988922,
-0.4085591435432434,
0.28974226117134094,
-0.6767642498016357,
0.3479231595993042,
-0.6448123455047607,
0.13578934967517853,
-0.1445467472076416,
0.0539712980389595,
-0.42478838562965393,
0.425956130027771,
0.30105969309806824,
0.3638768792152405,
-0.6879808306694031,
0.9080618023872375,
0.357138454914093,
-0.30094221234321594,
-0.7890382409095764,
0.042882610112428665,
-0.06352218240499496,
-0.8596034646034241,
0.55228590965271,
0.49843287467956543,
-0.5518313646316528,
0.021147266030311584,
-0.5643694400787354,
-0.8632311820983887,
0.8012661933898926,
0.6478068232536316,
-0.9297308921813965,
0.16236387193202972,
-0.28214865922927856,
0.8033298254013062,
-0.35065555572509766,
0.3483383357524872,
0.2133132666349411,
0.2676745653152466,
-0.14390914142131805,
-0.672064483165741,
0.26224759221076965,
-0.08371534943580627,
-0.22769120335578918,
0.43962374329566956,
-1.1004852056503296,
0.5743180513381958,
-0.21704484522342682,
-0.19348986446857452,
0.009130077436566353,
0.7579742670059204,
0.07844151556491852,
-0.3679744601249695,
0.6285315155982971,
0.7154816389083862,
0.434194415807724,
0.35967960953712463,
0.7947962284088135,
-0.5385022759437561,
0.5197837352752686,
1.8123915195465088,
-0.2527649402618408,
0.8126085996627808,
0.5613456964492798,
0.1752239167690277,
0.5188965797424316,
0.4624738097190857,
-0.051456473767757416,
0.5906325578689575,
0.38939303159713745,
0.07144840806722641,
-0.5977660417556763,
-0.15274463593959808,
-0.2730133831501007,
0.3203745484352112,
-0.05010133609175682,
-0.5120888948440552,
-0.3154519498348236,
-0.3667186498641968,
-0.2504512369632721,
0.3383992314338684,
-0.03894875943660736,
0.8913094997406006,
-0.04518726468086243,
-0.9829440712928772,
0.42826753854751587,
-0.1824488639831543,
1.0100774765014648,
-0.6597368121147156,
-0.10632031410932541,
-0.33161699771881104,
0.36424192786216736,
-0.27791714668273926,
-0.8150001764297485,
0.009935105219483376,
-0.29316580295562744,
-0.08191186934709549,
-0.36873674392700195,
0.4155212640762329,
-0.6535254716873169,
-0.05288181081414223,
0.7663982510566711,
0.20023056864738464,
-0.19730497896671295,
0.15842387080192566,
-0.6692107915878296,
-0.247245654463768,
0.24292942881584167,
-0.26728498935699463,
0.6270024180412292,
0.2534964084625244,
0.09283813834190369,
0.6968939900398254,
0.35355010628700256,
0.021689703688025475,
-0.26516398787498474,
0.30432549118995667,
0.7244875431060791,
-0.8368282914161682,
-0.6552165746688843,
-0.9279703497886658,
0.09504624456167221,
-0.03390625864267349,
-0.4829872250556946,
0.5984078049659729,
0.4872097671031952,
1.0116056203842163,
0.016419602558016777,
0.7008219361305237,
0.4090632200241089,
0.595016598701477,
-0.3940839469432831,
0.43680539727211,
-0.812633216381073,
0.1195758655667305,
-0.38054603338241577,
-0.6834335923194885,
-0.2566083073616028,
0.6340563297271729,
-0.3179830312728882,
-0.021736785769462585,
0.42235448956489563,
0.8599520325660706,
-0.08896097540855408,
-0.3890545070171356,
0.43684324622154236,
0.3572506010532379,
0.4258822500705719,
0.18842874467372894,
0.8010084629058838,
-0.05407893657684326,
0.7264736294746399,
-0.43169352412223816,
-0.1773286908864975,
-0.2968001663684845,
-0.9838381409645081,
-0.7198593616485596,
-0.3027956485748291,
-0.3404358923435211,
-0.5885654091835022,
-0.03558497503399849,
1.193758487701416,
0.7274399399757385,
-0.9332560896873474,
-0.2726036608219147,
-0.06645718216896057,
0.04393545538187027,
-0.03424209728837013,
-0.18430916965007782,
0.37474361062049866,
-0.5387044548988342,
-0.6437299847602844,
0.3153254985809326,
0.4441763460636139,
0.2666882574558258,
-0.393752783536911,
-0.3123946785926819,
-0.08250012248754501,
0.03149402514100075,
0.2831922471523285,
0.41718730330467224,
-0.6363117694854736,
-0.44158875942230225,
-0.1324540227651596,
-0.5456920266151428,
0.32526230812072754,
0.7515559196472168,
-0.5975605845451355,
0.6842902898788452,
0.27727067470550537,
0.8718506097793579,
0.6066507697105408,
0.10243025422096252,
0.8139966130256653,
-0.6896740794181824,
-0.20071382820606232,
0.07892132550477982,
0.30794593691825867,
0.5815267562866211,
-0.46125146746635437,
0.3166063725948334,
-0.23860426247119904,
-0.7320831418037415,
-0.45748746395111084,
0.3680350184440613,
-0.7824481725692749,
-0.3707566261291504,
1.335876703262329,
0.0457625612616539,
-0.016332319006323814,
0.26946404576301575,
-0.4426109492778778,
0.15274178981781006,
-0.7003884315490723,
1.152058720588684,
0.6415228843688965,
-0.2647751569747925,
-0.05077303573489189,
0.055042464286088943,
0.3917028605937958,
0.9449796676635742,
-0.6482601761817932,
0.39917632937431335,
0.5512212514877319,
0.44614362716674805,
0.12155396491289139,
0.6506848335266113,
-0.07170949876308441,
0.0931582897901535,
-0.3137277066707611,
0.33550193905830383,
0.08030978590250015,
-0.28282544016838074,
-1.0116301774978638,
-0.07022050768136978,
0.3480384051799774,
0.02666202373802662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00600v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00600v2
|
AI Act and Large Language Models (LLMs): When critical issues and privacy impact require human and ethical oversight
| 2024-03-31T08:14:25 | 2024-04-02T06:05:29 |
Nicola Fabiano
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The imposing evolution of artificial intelligence systems and, specifically,
of Large Language Models (LLM) makes it necessary to carry out assessments of
their level of risk and the impact they may have in the area of privacy,
personal data protection and at an ethical level, especially on the weakest and
most vulnerable. This contribution addresses human oversight, ethical
oversight, and privacy impact assessment.
|
[
-0.0785193219780922,
-0.7451229691505432,
0.6863830089569092,
0.061954885721206665,
0.2952544093132019,
0.035900212824344635,
0.0758763775229454,
-0.7522139549255371,
-0.20907066762447357,
1.0304994583129883,
-0.5740665197372437,
-0.12688662111759186,
-0.7031710743904114,
0.06099453940987587,
-0.48583170771598816,
0.8176602125167847,
0.028322886675596237,
0.16202907264232635,
-0.27256783843040466,
-0.1026511937379837,
-0.2739734947681427,
-0.6926059722900391,
-0.689460813999176,
-0.313799113035202,
0.5015895366668701,
0.13417762517929077,
0.8510993123054504,
0.6705349683761597,
1.0391770601272583,
0.5162907838821411,
-0.15612569451332092,
-0.16936446726322174,
-0.440055251121521,
-0.04828207939863205,
-0.40161392092704773,
-0.6909496784210205,
-0.532551646232605,
0.4124923050403595,
0.7355842590332031,
0.613594651222229,
-0.21172209084033966,
0.38595065474510193,
-0.24668212234973907,
0.7063141465187073,
-0.6029462218284607,
0.07962148636579514,
-0.3104499578475952,
-0.13961917161941528,
0.05554284155368805,
-0.1549414098262787,
-0.20939788222312927,
-0.525496780872345,
0.32767224311828613,
-0.17970015108585358,
-0.5050497651100159,
0.3535483479499817,
0.6464773416519165,
0.6184486746788025,
-0.5300279259681702,
-0.4047989249229431,
-0.7861840128898621,
0.9296829700469971,
-0.7061748504638672,
0.2439391016960144,
0.5177116990089417,
0.008907641284167767,
-0.42734652757644653,
-0.8384368419647217,
-0.6002261638641357,
-0.3883085250854492,
-0.05315583571791649,
-0.30621421337127686,
-0.18194545805454254,
0.38443467020988464,
0.44101372361183167,
0.4547625482082367,
0.05504747852683067,
0.4850217401981354,
-0.7570416331291199,
-0.07033143937587738,
1.0502127408981323,
0.6242457032203674,
0.6225435733795166,
-0.20785081386566162,
-0.19552919268608093,
0.12881378829479218,
-0.9680895805358887,
-0.016536008566617966,
0.7195685505867004,
0.06715667992830276,
-0.29210543632507324,
0.5456579923629761,
0.08111518621444702,
0.46500900387763977,
-0.3950924575328827,
-0.03863445296883583,
0.011308223009109497,
-0.3687669634819031,
-0.3052264451980591,
-0.013644840568304062,
0.7621956467628479,
0.2525142431259155,
0.4257590174674988,
0.1665293574333191,
-0.2886606454849243,
-0.026609988883137703,
0.396971732378006,
-0.5999111533164978,
0.2352564036846161,
0.5403863191604614,
-0.5325308442115784,
-0.40200766921043396,
0.28373420238494873,
-0.6678259372711182,
-0.7606409192085266,
-0.7600535750389099,
0.29698705673217773,
0.2184670865535736,
-0.13344912230968475,
0.10017739981412888,
0.1836818903684616,
0.49700868129730225,
0.30528557300567627,
-0.7239843010902405,
0.4068540334701538,
0.9704044461250305,
0.33460620045661926,
-0.0494849793612957,
-0.325764000415802,
-0.43413275480270386,
0.2752871513366699,
-0.39185765385627747,
0.46310245990753174,
-0.7007641792297363,
-0.5067833662033081,
0.06420611590147018,
0.1923741102218628,
0.03048687055706978,
-0.3850231170654297,
0.4547813832759857,
-0.4693228602409363,
0.1769798994064331,
-0.13028372824192047,
-0.7895443439483643,
-0.6146576404571533,
-0.009385526180267334,
-0.4516168534755707,
0.7567397356033325,
0.15203754603862762,
-0.4736148715019226,
0.06899186968803406,
-1.2592816352844238,
-0.6015888452529907,
0.2795928120613098,
-0.5162059664726257,
-0.3049357533454895,
-0.02753329463303089,
-0.13744525611400604,
0.6059784889221191,
-0.43681037425994873,
0.1462656855583191,
-0.28630051016807556,
-0.3001387119293213,
0.49132412672042847,
-0.44129130244255066,
1.2568066120147705,
0.0791003406047821,
-0.5732638239860535,
0.4831444025039673,
-0.8107457160949707,
0.03599066659808159,
0.12882690131664276,
-0.504940390586853,
-0.39919227361679077,
0.4585261940956116,
0.06496138870716095,
-0.028092004358768463,
0.447178453207016,
-0.09340774267911911,
0.02292153611779213,
-0.35757195949554443,
0.9330319762229919,
0.9917038083076477,
0.3027074933052063,
0.5078421235084534,
-0.5451763272285461,
0.6023683547973633,
-0.41816461086273193,
0.5028964281082153,
-0.0203897412866354,
-0.5118097066879272,
-0.5233611464500427,
-0.16060295701026917,
0.17307181656360626,
0.9418559074401855,
0.09726537764072418,
0.6798830628395081,
-0.0853615403175354,
-0.3241315484046936,
-0.6857319474220276,
0.3354739844799042,
0.19307518005371094,
-0.008514911867678165,
-0.17138397693634033,
-0.12855958938598633,
-0.3198769688606262,
-1.0347049236297607,
-0.21502435207366943,
-0.32939615845680237,
0.08658801019191742,
0.6232607364654541,
0.7303133606910706,
-0.6322968006134033,
0.7632914185523987,
-0.09495197236537933,
-0.1768035888671875,
-0.2144385576248169,
0.16919903457164764,
0.0576985739171505,
0.5333458781242371,
0.40222403407096863,
-1.1422439813613892,
-0.12061741948127747,
-0.20120824873447418,
-0.8130872845649719,
-0.06699210405349731,
-0.2563667595386505,
0.06833545863628387,
0.1437223106622696,
0.6506726741790771,
-0.7948362827301025,
0.6223920583724976,
0.35980284214019775,
-0.3264211416244507,
0.23992687463760376,
-0.2732779383659363,
0.2506294548511505,
-0.922268271446228,
0.07625318318605423,
-0.23304283618927002,
-0.29901647567749023,
-0.8944713473320007,
0.41139817237854004,
-0.061473313719034195,
0.08532306551933289,
-0.8332111239433289,
0.6289153099060059,
-0.4636309742927551,
-0.464013010263443,
-0.29689866304397583,
0.06213201954960823,
-0.10967171937227249,
-0.1968197077512741,
-0.5017412304878235,
0.716651439666748,
0.5038878917694092,
-0.9263827800750732,
0.4024798274040222,
0.17665714025497437,
-0.5401619076728821,
0.5115219354629517,
-0.53621506690979,
0.42215996980667114,
-0.1251593381166458,
-0.06104883551597595,
-0.5020648837089539,
-0.5480577945709229,
0.3034875988960266,
-0.35866501927375793,
0.29210227727890015,
0.4786128103733063,
-0.7515018582344055,
-0.40371039509773254,
-0.43773502111434937,
0.21605922281742096,
0.500230073928833,
-0.2039192020893097,
1.0615261793136597,
0.822517991065979,
-0.1433839201927185,
-0.6164524555206299,
-0.7063319683074951,
0.35522451996803284,
-0.4550420343875885,
-0.5967443585395813,
-0.23769959807395935,
-0.24026784300804138,
-1.0391572713851929,
-0.006357837934046984,
0.4257672131061554,
-0.0585632286965847,
0.7886341214179993,
0.6495614647865295,
0.3098929524421692,
-0.06639096885919571,
-0.3454509675502777,
-0.35715484619140625,
0.1841111034154892,
0.5573878884315491,
0.3641388416290283,
0.5479554533958435,
-0.10493255406618118,
-0.36987945437431335,
-0.9079139232635498,
0.45590686798095703,
0.8393783569335938,
-0.013815410435199738,
0.6147239208221436,
0.1771291345357895,
-0.45357272028923035,
0.02882368490099907,
-0.6887665390968323,
-0.14863646030426025,
-0.5845999121665955,
0.6138039231300354,
0.20524060726165771,
-1.1299091577529907,
0.5592107176780701,
0.09354551136493683,
0.17815810441970825,
0.4993753731250763,
1.0455015897750854,
-0.19025753438472748,
0.9297847151756287,
1.0158579349517822,
-0.7189624309539795,
0.5668355822563171,
0.10847301781177521,
0.25358647108078003,
-0.8942486643791199,
-0.09904243797063828,
-0.5538814067840576,
-0.34466370940208435,
-0.9717556238174438,
-0.2119414508342743,
0.052131205797195435,
-0.3133046627044678,
-0.4954839050769806,
-0.08794817328453064,
-0.3218732178211212,
0.5098362565040588,
0.6937926411628723,
0.08035411685705185,
0.3805522620677948,
-0.1610657274723053,
0.5187751054763794,
0.3173676133155823,
-0.15956738591194153,
-0.6898163557052612,
1.2391295433044434,
0.6777815818786621,
1.0579499006271362,
0.12338001281023026,
0.5382261276245117,
0.6132168769836426,
0.4008502960205078,
-0.7120385766029358,
0.6925903558731079,
0.0462271086871624,
-0.9811479449272156,
-0.5295593738555908,
-0.3349646031856537,
-0.9589306712150574,
-0.21705755591392517,
-0.1201072707772255,
-1.0856232643127441,
0.18068240582942963,
-0.12026634067296982,
-0.486990749835968,
0.1898912489414215,
-0.5635969638824463,
0.3372717797756195,
-0.521920382976532,
-0.18139293789863586,
-0.6711647510528564,
-0.8134798407554626,
0.47471103072166443,
-0.1050960123538971,
0.5226547122001648,
-0.3542587161064148,
-0.4119660556316376,
0.9099910855293274,
-0.19216841459274292,
1.1598353385925293,
0.1093822494149208,
-0.09958542138338089,
0.48201945424079895,
0.04570109397172928,
0.7063375115394592,
-0.03310750797390938,
0.08443263918161392,
0.26475492119789124,
-0.0858260914683342,
-0.02406270056962967,
-0.3281145393848419,
0.46623843908309937,
-0.9896708130836487,
-1.2197442054748535,
-0.5035624504089355,
-0.9222106337547302,
-0.0037173270247876644,
0.32826700806617737,
-0.1694328486919403,
-0.18708336353302002,
-0.12097293883562088,
0.1268848031759262,
0.4872310757637024,
-0.3089974522590637,
0.36026760935783386,
0.7659866213798523,
-0.26051121950149536,
-0.21142327785491943,
0.5848288536071777,
-0.056557606905698776,
0.2312408834695816,
0.015920326113700867,
0.2819053530693054,
-0.14599573612213135,
-0.6392590999603271,
-0.10249144583940506,
0.42533448338508606,
-0.8041892051696777,
0.05922326073050499,
-0.5411819219589233,
-0.5089247822761536,
-0.33992019295692444,
-0.12826046347618103,
-0.08130975812673569,
-0.026434490457177162,
-0.6135359406471252,
-0.05414458364248276,
0.5307761430740356,
1.281294584274292,
-0.06568828225135803,
0.4281735122203827,
-0.8507874011993408,
0.26761507987976074,
0.24861806631088257,
0.31413400173187256,
-0.293853223323822,
-0.5673269033432007,
0.20860567688941956,
-0.28295326232910156,
-0.15082348883152008,
-0.41613543033599854,
-0.10954266786575317,
0.11255719512701035,
0.7717032432556152,
0.5624681115150452,
-0.2354367971420288,
0.17346756160259247,
-0.5378718376159668,
0.8084506392478943,
0.08791929483413696,
-0.8966323137283325,
0.32566142082214355,
-0.3798585534095764,
-0.17612813413143158,
0.5635274648666382,
0.5086685419082642,
-0.4715385138988495,
-0.3201284408569336,
-0.5740613341331482,
-0.7701519727706909,
0.8206683397293091,
0.1581939458847046,
0.6006646156311035,
0.22080768644809723,
0.7049585580825806,
-0.34444838762283325,
0.33700451254844666,
-0.8270601630210876,
-0.22757358849048615,
0.7070500254631042,
-0.1549682468175888,
0.1582973450422287,
-0.377043753862381,
-0.3603760898113251,
-0.2706446945667267,
0.3502903878688812,
0.27904751896858215,
0.08922090381383896,
-0.013019259087741375,
0.15857136249542236,
-0.3723181486129761,
0.20033378899097443,
0.7847541570663452,
0.897310733795166,
0.16333141922950745,
-0.18952861428260803,
0.2845710217952728,
-0.5446250438690186,
0.22838518023490906,
-0.2218458503484726,
-0.24748924374580383,
-0.709522008895874,
0.49732959270477295,
0.6055354475975037,
0.21624356508255005,
-0.931647777557373,
0.5313828587532043,
0.1894245147705078,
-0.2826009690761566,
-0.4601794481277466,
0.2719150483608246,
0.13057397305965424,
0.40773093700408936,
0.2986605763435364,
-0.07009235769510269,
0.28076040744781494,
-0.878322958946228,
0.2176041156053543,
0.4129900336265564,
-0.18005064129829407,
-0.1568540334701538,
0.5776227712631226,
0.03296765312552452,
-0.7445932626724243,
0.6421557664871216,
0.2241826057434082,
-0.7145619988441467,
0.9945619702339172,
0.1343458890914917,
0.8795218467712402,
-0.721967875957489,
-0.15098172426223755,
-0.08488866686820984,
0.7696743011474609,
-0.47348475456237793,
0.6111817359924316,
0.4013136327266693,
-0.55398029088974,
-0.3954651653766632,
-0.38158130645751953,
-0.795849084854126,
0.2476654052734375,
-0.5173240900039673,
0.3710874617099762,
-0.9421166777610779,
-0.1543211042881012,
-0.07703714817762375,
-0.1935858577489853,
-0.5804645419120789,
0.2853846848011017,
0.32104793190956116,
0.7036159038543701,
-0.46707579493522644,
0.4724958837032318,
0.5577941536903381,
-0.110437773168087,
-0.7006334662437439,
-0.07203145325183868,
0.3159821629524231,
-1.1434173583984375,
0.7592732906341553,
0.003919058479368687,
0.07782325148582458,
-0.21726739406585693,
-0.7643133401870728,
-1.1693214178085327,
0.88299959897995,
0.3103860020637512,
-0.6751547455787659,
0.04412924870848656,
0.5737142562866211,
0.5137240290641785,
-0.579216718673706,
-0.12185383588075638,
0.867736279964447,
0.850960373878479,
-0.4417169690132141,
-0.8869975805282593,
0.039900533854961395,
0.1029382050037384,
-0.10161212086677551,
0.3114418685436249,
-0.9009676575660706,
0.9236937165260315,
-0.2581525444984436,
-0.12965527176856995,
-0.03240646421909332,
0.5178878307342529,
0.03795478120446205,
0.22617283463478088,
0.43607208132743835,
0.312851220369339,
0.8655575513839722,
0.24859821796417236,
1.4493892192840576,
-0.4205978512763977,
0.10569942742586136,
0.8868634104728699,
-0.4249536097049713,
0.8642746210098267,
0.36003804206848145,
-0.4680894911289215,
0.11948000639677048,
0.8340875506401062,
-0.32673782110214233,
0.16857199370861053,
0.5926206707954407,
-0.03662252426147461,
0.04164295271039009,
-0.2913680374622345,
0.022066310048103333,
0.6960345506668091,
0.7243589162826538,
-0.5355280637741089,
0.2801584303379059,
-0.14854930341243744,
0.08677398413419724,
-0.034914180636405945,
-0.7172160148620605,
0.7182977199554443,
0.4152188003063202,
-0.36983582377433777,
-0.1502372771501541,
-0.0774010717868805,
0.3918304145336151,
-0.3423416018486023,
-0.00036731184809468687,
0.1657457947731018,
0.007693745661526918,
-0.3680623173713684,
-0.7679559588432312,
0.23285254836082458,
-0.049225810915231705,
-0.03696783632040024,
0.1522485911846161,
0.45774486660957336,
0.11092399805784225,
-0.7227635979652405,
0.6067230105400085,
0.3243018686771393,
0.1555362194776535,
0.22370827198028564,
-1.0627974271774292,
0.21921837329864502,
-0.24808906018733978,
-0.7728022933006287,
0.2981202006340027,
0.061889201402664185,
-0.2281685471534729,
0.9668829441070557,
0.518725574016571,
0.28103867173194885,
0.23604325950145721,
0.1290998011827469,
0.7204988598823547,
-0.814022421836853,
-0.4877091348171234,
-1.1476936340332031,
0.25051701068878174,
-0.04785127565264702,
-0.21075978875160217,
0.4990180730819702,
0.22305190563201904,
0.22831472754478455,
0.4487805962562561,
0.9238912463188171,
-0.049544863402843475,
0.4722486436367035,
-0.5004666447639465,
1.018998622894287,
-0.5881940126419067,
0.4376666247844696,
-0.10503383725881577,
-0.9188210964202881,
-0.33819785714149475,
0.4020352065563202,
-0.4563068449497223,
0.3180193603038788,
0.5088099241256714,
0.6849865913391113,
0.33798298239707947,
0.05649186298251152,
0.3732445240020752,
0.5120010375976562,
0.29958438873291016,
0.2054469734430313,
0.9973015785217285,
-0.2703089118003845,
0.16187721490859985,
-0.07189865410327911,
-0.13811132311820984,
-0.14161138236522675,
-0.9200263023376465,
-1.020290493965149,
-0.27332472801208496,
-0.4416889250278473,
-0.21678690612316132,
-0.21545755863189697,
1.0370079278945923,
0.4390043616294861,
-0.8950644731521606,
-0.4435669779777527,
0.16088664531707764,
0.283926397562027,
0.1509157121181488,
-0.24922528862953186,
0.48875880241394043,
-0.0776396095752716,
-0.8458576798439026,
0.3873056471347809,
0.625215470790863,
0.03827724978327751,
-0.7401340007781982,
-0.010324656032025814,
-0.23101715743541718,
0.5400568246841431,
0.4659794569015503,
0.3402085602283478,
-0.9302383661270142,
-0.6898408532142639,
-0.33700239658355713,
-0.3400256633758545,
-0.04910927265882492,
0.7809402942657471,
-0.018629396334290504,
0.07084564864635468,
0.3512797951698303,
1.0293726921081543,
-0.2020157426595688,
-0.16705602407455444,
0.6769263744354248,
-0.12212271988391876,
0.1404268592596054,
0.28625574707984924,
0.508126437664032,
0.16206081211566925,
-1.0156242847442627,
0.6892964839935303,
0.06367719918489456,
-0.9049174785614014,
-0.9776071310043335,
0.20571523904800415,
-0.9762582182884216,
-0.1602233648300171,
1.2058755159378052,
-0.12288198620080948,
-0.6226356029510498,
-0.21571192145347595,
-0.0037844956386834383,
-0.2512874901294708,
-0.23986218869686127,
1.0883342027664185,
0.8479778170585632,
-0.18942226469516754,
-0.31397274136543274,
-1.074855089187622,
0.3755345940589905,
0.17128105461597443,
-1.1002781391143799,
0.08686509728431702,
0.24518994987010956,
0.17386597394943237,
0.06472131609916687,
0.5620461106300354,
-0.13268469274044037,
0.3374682664871216,
-0.26889073848724365,
-0.14322112500667572,
0.16348670423030853,
-0.13621890544891357,
-0.39912423491477966,
0.048534415662288666,
0.03149325028061867,
0.24705694615840912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00599v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00599v1
|
EvoCodeBench: An Evolving Code Generation Benchmark Aligned with Real-World Code Repositories
| 2024-03-31T08:10:50 | 2024-03-31T08:10:50 |
Jia Li, Ge Li, Xuanming Zhang, Yihong Dong, Zhi Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
How to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) in code generation is an open
question. Existing benchmarks demonstrate poor alignment with real-world code
repositories and are insufficient to evaluate the coding abilities of LLMs.
This paper proposes a new benchmark - EvoCodeBench to address the preceding
problems, which has three primary advances. (1) EvoCodeBench aligns with
real-world repositories in multiple dimensions, e.g., code distributions and
dependency distributions. (2) EvoCodeBench offers comprehensive annotations
(e.g., requirements, reference code, and reference dependencies), and robust
evaluation metrics (e.g., Pass@k and Recall@k). (3) EvoCodeBench is an evolving
benchmark to avoid data leakage. We build an automatic pipeline to update
EvoCodeBench from the latest repositories. We release the first version -
EvoCodeBench-2403, containing 275 samples from 25 real-world repositories.
Based on EvoCodeBench, we propose repository-level code generation and evaluate
10 popular LLMs (e.g., gpt-4, gpt-3.5, DeepSeek Coder, StarCoder 2, CodeLLaMa,
Gemma, and Qwen 1.5). Our experiments reveal the coding abilities of these LLMs
in real-world repositories. For example, the highest Pass@1 of gpt-4 only is
20.73% in our experiments. We also analyze failed cases and summarize the
shortcomings of existing LLMs in EvoCodeBench. We release EvoCodeBench, all
prompts, and LLMs' completions for further community analysis.
|
[
-0.5265635251998901,
-0.5384958386421204,
0.509064793586731,
0.15314114093780518,
-0.11102191358804703,
0.3302735686302185,
-0.30335721373558044,
-0.4873960614204407,
-0.03395548835396767,
0.2976650893688202,
-0.43272626399993896,
-0.6781617999076843,
-0.3533360958099365,
0.25825151801109314,
-0.31049787998199463,
0.621573805809021,
-0.32080960273742676,
0.14606837928295135,
-0.3622523546218872,
-0.2415577471256256,
-0.29077982902526855,
-0.3825596570968628,
-0.4005773663520813,
-0.0684303417801857,
0.2525215744972229,
0.4560564458370209,
0.14108090102672577,
0.659795343875885,
0.5255895256996155,
0.25133392214775085,
0.03398643061518669,
0.10791563242673874,
-0.47066694498062134,
0.46429359912872314,
-0.0558076873421669,
-0.1338045746088028,
-0.36165791749954224,
-0.2199055701494217,
0.3627833425998688,
0.1482805758714676,
-0.2631022334098816,
0.34266433119773865,
0.08034069836139679,
0.5665602684020996,
-0.7427098155021667,
-0.03502879664301872,
-0.5658496022224426,
0.21533705294132233,
-0.19236037135124207,
-0.18225975334644318,
-0.2624339461326599,
-0.44331881403923035,
-0.24772897362709045,
-0.10581063479185104,
0.21392607688903809,
0.11721932888031006,
0.6410675644874573,
0.15827831625938416,
-0.08592539280653,
-0.39204785227775574,
-0.5701238512992859,
0.5670783519744873,
-0.6443866491317749,
0.33384087681770325,
-0.09615636616945267,
0.5230040550231934,
-0.23666664958000183,
-0.8051144480705261,
-0.570165753364563,
-0.4954187273979187,
0.49334219098091125,
0.08431628346443176,
-0.09956352412700653,
-0.2023518979549408,
0.37034744024276733,
0.5138278603553772,
-0.6163411140441895,
0.3711239695549011,
-0.29069235920906067,
-0.13655176758766174,
0.40334028005599976,
0.09137050062417984,
-0.055900007486343384,
-0.07267799228429794,
-0.39173623919487,
-0.3322056531906128,
-1.098099946975708,
-0.36836469173431396,
0.6468344926834106,
-0.06824473291635513,
-0.0074545820243656635,
0.4444056451320648,
-0.11377052962779999,
0.4781056344509125,
-0.17731261253356934,
0.3889743983745575,
0.5793963074684143,
-0.3002373278141022,
-0.022604094818234444,
0.01997264288365841,
0.6997525691986084,
0.4538562595844269,
0.12768186628818512,
0.11611560732126236,
-0.27472686767578125,
-0.09550151973962784,
0.38266709446907043,
-0.9482386112213135,
-0.11900065839290619,
0.3560309410095215,
-0.2949751019477844,
-0.4866958260536194,
0.06703650951385498,
-1.0617313385009766,
-0.32072246074676514,
-0.03876199945807457,
0.05999775975942612,
-0.1810605674982071,
-0.1733214557170868,
-0.23438328504562378,
0.03914805129170418,
0.4062829613685608,
0.3059249818325043,
-0.6028916239738464,
0.23608431220054626,
1.070117473602295,
0.9571741819381714,
-0.05790385603904724,
-0.39464542269706726,
-0.716944694519043,
-0.09310600906610489,
-0.3129528760910034,
0.9706637859344482,
-0.4504002034664154,
-0.19397006928920746,
0.25360944867134094,
-0.1092178225517273,
0.27528318762779236,
-0.8129896521568298,
0.5203559398651123,
-0.35289761424064636,
-0.006522138137370348,
-0.04741641879081726,
-0.7473934292793274,
0.22925998270511627,
0.1963147670030594,
-0.7781444191932678,
1.0764518976211548,
0.28438639640808105,
-0.40904104709625244,
0.48520609736442566,
-0.335111141204834,
-0.09494540095329285,
0.21697403490543365,
-0.42222464084625244,
-0.5699116587638855,
0.14048655331134796,
-0.025168126448988914,
0.2055787444114685,
-0.578247606754303,
0.1895977407693863,
-0.5349330306053162,
-0.3485929071903229,
0.07873345166444778,
-0.2687455415725708,
0.5025646090507507,
0.5632758140563965,
-0.5760582685470581,
-0.03357551246881485,
-0.6638891100883484,
0.22572974860668182,
-0.05469027906656265,
-0.18015576899051666,
0.12435251474380493,
0.023225095123052597,
0.02154635451734066,
0.2861955761909485,
0.19221964478492737,
-0.4145928919315338,
0.22920185327529907,
-0.00750221312046051,
0.5323695540428162,
0.7780795693397522,
0.01931610144674778,
0.2171202003955841,
-0.22985538840293884,
0.8775203824043274,
-0.12686599791049957,
0.1716165542602539,
-0.25669434666633606,
-0.33567145466804504,
-0.6135016679763794,
-0.15601523220539093,
0.3829250633716583,
0.394728422164917,
-0.572063684463501,
0.6795941591262817,
-0.34563687443733215,
-0.48820120096206665,
-0.5587644577026367,
0.3913452625274658,
0.5463155508041382,
0.18209509551525116,
0.18162153661251068,
-0.44904276728630066,
-0.5638554096221924,
-0.9618152976036072,
-0.26077696681022644,
-0.23436951637268066,
-0.10183514654636383,
0.3024497628211975,
0.5591835975646973,
-0.16125735640525818,
0.5523405075073242,
-0.3221111297607422,
0.22367094457149506,
-0.18443550169467926,
0.09812784194946289,
0.054512303322553635,
0.4622874855995178,
0.5890961289405823,
-0.304841011762619,
-0.27305319905281067,
0.016413243487477303,
-0.5469580888748169,
-0.31471285223960876,
-0.0025010211393237114,
-0.13405591249465942,
0.256603479385376,
0.5312705636024475,
-0.4032776653766632,
-0.08503074944019318,
0.8224624395370483,
-0.12848368287086487,
0.4880742132663727,
-0.2536758780479431,
0.16684040427207947,
-1.0928142070770264,
0.09960910677909851,
-0.06787705421447754,
-0.17323771119117737,
-0.28328052163124084,
0.5328349471092224,
0.37784504890441895,
-0.1427793800830841,
-0.43475526571273804,
0.379628449678421,
-0.43014127016067505,
-0.2888162136077881,
-0.020198436453938484,
0.12171949446201324,
0.0061081163585186005,
0.15430684387683868,
-0.19073820114135742,
0.7524062991142273,
0.4110791087150574,
-0.23535965383052826,
0.7020862698554993,
-0.1415100246667862,
-0.7490251064300537,
0.39077210426330566,
-0.591171383857727,
0.49418342113494873,
0.2285783886909485,
0.35065218806266785,
-0.557722270488739,
-0.04923899099230766,
-0.0033054412342607975,
-0.20287644863128662,
0.2594902813434601,
-0.16500933468341827,
-0.5258634090423584,
-0.48877543210983276,
-0.6322060823440552,
0.07423233985900879,
0.6815305352210999,
-0.6008297204971313,
0.17425036430358887,
0.1058368980884552,
-0.1719941943883896,
-0.5211642384529114,
-0.5196993947029114,
0.3216717839241028,
-0.1939915418624878,
-0.5890697836875916,
0.11958322674036026,
-0.3195706605911255,
-0.3143165707588196,
-0.06184288486838341,
-0.2147606462240219,
0.12765805423259735,
0.0010929321870207787,
0.012843500822782516,
0.053422555327415466,
-0.25911885499954224,
0.0077479686588048935,
-0.01239557284861803,
-0.14113932847976685,
0.023287203162908554,
-0.3182917535305023,
0.6426476836204529,
-0.21536296606063843,
-0.5201669931411743,
0.027039293199777603,
0.1478477120399475,
0.5191172957420349,
-0.1370076686143875,
0.394827276468277,
0.2545663118362427,
-0.049179110676050186,
-0.6699191331863403,
-0.7079706788063049,
0.04663364216685295,
-0.4489847421646118,
0.5217774510383606,
-0.5935794115066528,
-0.9777781367301941,
0.5823683738708496,
-0.39904478192329407,
0.2159528136253357,
0.34238430857658386,
0.6749511361122131,
0.32548829913139343,
0.8135280013084412,
0.5308001637458801,
0.1816903054714203,
0.4655783176422119,
-0.18718726933002472,
0.2437210977077484,
-0.907430112361908,
-0.15441055595874786,
-0.7327221632003784,
-0.135420024394989,
-0.8038184642791748,
-0.561749279499054,
0.0010090641444548965,
0.3335483968257904,
-0.29953500628471375,
0.6743460297584534,
-0.5212999582290649,
0.5391653776168823,
0.34960606694221497,
-0.2504972517490387,
0.217086523771286,
0.06722357869148254,
-0.2098943293094635,
0.176932692527771,
-0.533635139465332,
-0.6111478805541992,
1.0799281597137451,
0.40186184644699097,
0.7331876754760742,
0.1263229101896286,
0.8843230605125427,
0.23897618055343628,
0.40694305300712585,
-0.35417109727859497,
0.3675319254398346,
0.0811009332537651,
-0.345731645822525,
0.07850281149148941,
-0.6295077204704285,
-0.6904063820838928,
0.23606626689434052,
0.15747182071208954,
-0.35322701930999756,
0.39049530029296875,
0.11168927699327469,
-0.1985992044210434,
0.06698691099882126,
-0.7252752184867859,
0.9603437185287476,
-0.2954970598220825,
-0.5992708206176758,
-0.30731436610221863,
-0.13828924298286438,
0.1803547441959381,
-0.40223127603530884,
0.24079923331737518,
-0.1604907512664795,
-0.16028280556201935,
0.3396451473236084,
-0.5630431771278381,
0.27366843819618225,
-0.22620269656181335,
-0.31965261697769165,
0.3305443227291107,
0.2053208351135254,
0.6561259627342224,
0.19711612164974213,
-0.4339747726917267,
0.19008105993270874,
-0.2554968297481537,
-0.217879056930542,
-0.4648975133895874,
1.128866195678711,
-0.5573418736457825,
-0.43262040615081787,
-0.3077529966831207,
-0.08322467654943466,
-0.058372847735881805,
0.015527080744504929,
0.34745481610298157,
0.3523847162723541,
-0.37352362275123596,
0.20540598034858704,
0.44673991203308105,
-0.41220149397850037,
0.303005188703537,
0.6481358408927917,
-0.13436280190944672,
-0.5187046527862549,
0.7424514293670654,
-0.079251229763031,
0.3715747594833374,
0.1287148892879486,
-0.07330509275197983,
-0.18111351132392883,
-0.688906729221344,
-0.5960786938667297,
-0.043530046939849854,
-0.7783480882644653,
-0.4098454713821411,
-0.4762464463710785,
-0.15203696489334106,
-0.3644767999649048,
-0.2943412661552429,
-0.39283502101898193,
-0.3259879946708679,
0.19050860404968262,
-0.25932255387306213,
0.463741272687912,
0.8106983304023743,
-0.11310186237096786,
-0.2824261486530304,
-0.6876839995384216,
-0.05436960607767105,
0.3360835611820221,
0.471265971660614,
0.013231835328042507,
-0.3228679597377777,
-0.2932770550251007,
-0.203154057264328,
-0.403293639421463,
-0.5313464403152466,
0.23308731615543365,
0.15161994099617004,
0.6300430297851562,
0.16388151049613953,
-0.031809352338314056,
0.6443164944648743,
-0.639028012752533,
0.70392906665802,
0.09535852074623108,
-0.9838410019874573,
0.6329823136329651,
-0.12942148745059967,
0.26948082447052,
0.8283199071884155,
-0.09032332897186279,
-0.42197203636169434,
-0.671363353729248,
-0.6393618583679199,
-1.0093247890472412,
0.5097443461418152,
0.24420882761478424,
0.10066509991884232,
-0.12687741219997406,
0.3301103413105011,
0.1850578337907791,
0.24913354218006134,
-0.4464883506298065,
0.06117645278573036,
-0.15275739133358002,
-0.11315081268548965,
-0.004309769254177809,
-0.18461094796657562,
-0.014121472835540771,
-0.026191961020231247,
0.3614000082015991,
-0.11342329531908035,
0.2514904737472534,
-0.02023717574775219,
-0.148000106215477,
-0.2629820704460144,
0.3308880627155304,
0.6895570158958435,
0.8506003022193909,
-0.27936819195747375,
0.18633925914764404,
0.22464792430400848,
-0.5035851001739502,
0.14528068900108337,
0.06214262545108795,
0.12366039305925369,
-0.10200074315071106,
0.5299682021141052,
0.7091190218925476,
0.1259741336107254,
-0.9229540228843689,
0.5697336196899414,
-0.1448364108800888,
-0.2507103383541107,
-0.488709956407547,
0.2731360197067261,
0.08795096725225449,
0.18739666044712067,
0.27430495619773865,
-0.01432775892317295,
-0.02033824473619461,
-0.5950319170951843,
0.3400781452655792,
0.10604066401720047,
-0.3080119490623474,
-0.17162571847438812,
0.5060547590255737,
0.4138800799846649,
-0.2705641984939575,
0.7618768811225891,
-0.28245440125465393,
-0.2794867753982544,
0.9089210033416748,
0.39506492018699646,
1.3026068210601807,
-0.2899892330169678,
-0.02218908816576004,
0.4474257528781891,
0.30260786414146423,
-0.12785907089710236,
0.2794228494167328,
-0.08532952517271042,
-0.5127828121185303,
-0.5344870686531067,
-0.709023654460907,
-0.524576723575592,
0.007298165000975132,
-0.5669703483581543,
0.37095940113067627,
-0.4174507260322571,
0.1242278590798378,
-0.11573386192321777,
0.0495171844959259,
-0.59183669090271,
-0.3896493911743164,
0.10822553932666779,
1.1123803853988647,
-0.5690763592720032,
0.8836075663566589,
0.6130991578102112,
-0.15014545619487762,
-0.3850599229335785,
-0.02947266772389412,
0.056430477648973465,
-0.8680170774459839,
0.5358322262763977,
0.19667667150497437,
0.007315357681363821,
0.014146857894957066,
-0.5952314138412476,
-0.563809871673584,
1.2469943761825562,
0.4773116707801819,
-1.0702909231185913,
0.4605000615119934,
-0.05650269240140915,
0.5792201161384583,
-0.627413809299469,
0.41886472702026367,
0.555752694606781,
0.42730873823165894,
0.053715940564870834,
-0.7670984864234924,
0.05301523953676224,
-0.6402514576911926,
0.248748317360878,
0.27977997064590454,
-0.6608231067657471,
0.7433128952980042,
-0.1954454928636551,
-0.1331414431333542,
0.31416553258895874,
0.2885517477989197,
0.5829955339431763,
0.014054111205041409,
0.31715089082717896,
0.7855336666107178,
0.5356802344322205,
-0.16762308776378632,
1.2420333623886108,
-0.673335611820221,
0.5334330201148987,
0.9899488091468811,
-0.763466477394104,
0.959047794342041,
0.2199552357196808,
-0.19191300868988037,
0.6411631107330322,
0.541101336479187,
-0.38300350308418274,
0.4556758999824524,
0.5554759502410889,
-0.3293355405330658,
-0.03587484359741211,
0.08886004984378815,
-0.6592344641685486,
0.035577576607465744,
0.08695243299007416,
-0.40392786264419556,
-0.18127186596393585,
-0.20217445492744446,
0.05353928729891777,
-0.21801696717739105,
0.1436285525560379,
0.6936120986938477,
0.13172252476215363,
-0.5611286163330078,
0.6305035352706909,
-0.06939690560102463,
0.4572148025035858,
-0.5741558074951172,
-0.3234816789627075,
-0.45415470004081726,
0.44377803802490234,
-0.135178342461586,
-0.6639626622200012,
-0.09018716961145401,
0.2405775785446167,
0.1439300775527954,
-0.31154754757881165,
0.3057248592376709,
-0.21001161634922028,
-0.318979948759079,
0.46118423342704773,
0.33699268102645874,
0.19917792081832886,
0.1784289926290512,
-0.6967421770095825,
0.4713996946811676,
0.08783772587776184,
-0.3864429295063019,
0.47678470611572266,
0.5555682182312012,
0.13610510528087616,
0.3947222828865051,
0.4893780052661896,
0.14442284405231476,
0.02041703648865223,
0.3210289478302002,
0.8901851177215576,
-0.65151447057724,
-0.2842104434967041,
-0.737649142742157,
0.1059551015496254,
-0.30236050486564636,
-0.5847477912902832,
0.843606173992157,
0.7555351853370667,
0.9345940947532654,
0.11571081727743149,
0.6675240993499756,
-0.2831370532512665,
0.20384825766086578,
-0.5093945860862732,
0.3909454643726349,
-0.28926363587379456,
0.4981147348880768,
-0.22302260994911194,
-1.56586492061615,
-0.06558965891599655,
0.5196558237075806,
-0.0886760875582695,
0.23847129940986633,
0.9163821339607239,
0.9476085305213928,
0.23635222017765045,
-0.06071940064430237,
0.20170997083187103,
0.29031795263290405,
0.5687509179115295,
0.7556954622268677,
1.0268880128860474,
-0.25740429759025574,
0.5099347233772278,
-0.32201072573661804,
-0.2839205861091614,
-0.1891557276248932,
-0.9527828693389893,
-0.5432896614074707,
-0.2639160454273224,
-0.42710739374160767,
-0.26138028502464294,
0.19811351597309113,
0.7808387875556946,
0.5495429635047913,
-0.8701492547988892,
-0.3214234709739685,
-0.541461169719696,
-0.14688436686992645,
-0.39514991641044617,
-0.2288770079612732,
0.2740544378757477,
-0.45811861753463745,
-0.776233434677124,
0.4704243540763855,
0.36447909474372864,
-0.16327330470085144,
-0.5878183841705322,
-0.385708212852478,
0.28263622522354126,
-0.20433297753334045,
0.41745883226394653,
0.2568892240524292,
-0.40319985151290894,
-0.29100301861763,
-0.16052234172821045,
-0.2071188986301422,
0.062415435910224915,
0.9838608503341675,
-0.6094136834144592,
0.4523145258426666,
0.609316349029541,
0.41702553629875183,
0.452665776014328,
-0.057309653609991074,
0.7074003219604492,
-0.5379992723464966,
0.01885553076863289,
0.3281046450138092,
0.39617568254470825,
0.19406871497631073,
-0.15185600519180298,
0.6173508167266846,
0.02153482846915722,
-0.7325776219367981,
-0.899897575378418,
0.11077141016721725,
-0.5763766169548035,
-0.32814037799835205,
1.099137544631958,
-0.1669393628835678,
-0.1918724924325943,
-0.09673523902893066,
0.21188560128211975,
-0.13458529114723206,
-0.5015273690223694,
0.6303026676177979,
0.6697462201118469,
0.06597113609313965,
-0.29306286573410034,
-0.849089503288269,
0.2952835261821747,
0.16443930566310883,
-0.9664803743362427,
0.18568305671215057,
0.7259625792503357,
0.24132710695266724,
0.03981293365359306,
0.40010514855384827,
-0.2973850667476654,
0.35140708088874817,
0.26393866539001465,
0.4640327990055084,
-0.08909479528665543,
-0.2127259075641632,
-0.5864526033401489,
0.16260316967964172,
0.3472890555858612,
0.18549413979053497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01344v1
|
Mind Your Neighbours: Leveraging Analogous Instances for Rhetorical Role Labeling for Legal Documents
| 2024-03-31T08:10:45 | 2024-03-31T08:10:45 |
T. Y. S. S Santosh, Hassan Sarwat, Ahmed Abdou, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rhetorical Role Labeling (RRL) of legal judgments is essential for various
tasks, such as case summarization, semantic search and argument mining.
However, it presents challenges such as inferring sentence roles from context,
interrelated roles, limited annotated data, and label imbalance. This study
introduces novel techniques to enhance RRL performance by leveraging knowledge
from semantically similar instances (neighbours). We explore inference-based
and training-based approaches, achieving remarkable improvements in challenging
macro-F1 scores. For inference-based methods, we explore interpolation
techniques that bolster label predictions without re-training. While in
training-based methods, we integrate prototypical learning with our novel
discourse-aware contrastive method that work directly on embedding spaces.
Additionally, we assess the cross-domain applicability of our methods,
demonstrating their effectiveness in transferring knowledge across diverse
legal domains.
|
[
-0.5858761072158813,
-0.37636125087738037,
0.5214515924453735,
-0.21275386214256287,
-0.14532987773418427,
0.06193995848298073,
-0.0816938653588295,
-0.41344717144966125,
0.41517558693885803,
0.6837595701217651,
-0.21813583374023438,
-0.6287218332290649,
-0.5764942765235901,
-0.0466010682284832,
0.12348998337984085,
1.1090691089630127,
0.5850830674171448,
0.3015768527984619,
-0.3801317512989044,
-0.6209063529968262,
-0.27618253231048584,
-0.7363710403442383,
-0.5177326798439026,
-0.4833051562309265,
0.57622230052948,
0.5150196552276611,
0.6806039810180664,
0.5166497826576233,
0.11697197705507278,
0.2603895366191864,
-0.18490275740623474,
-0.0911608561873436,
-0.13677363097667694,
0.2454642802476883,
-0.6983099579811096,
-0.5768883228302002,
-0.0323738195002079,
0.031100565567612648,
0.395743191242218,
0.37546053528785706,
-0.0605008639395237,
0.1491876095533371,
-0.0929633304476738,
0.6698780655860901,
-0.618594765663147,
0.2548920512199402,
-0.9384745359420776,
0.42764121294021606,
-0.23181010782718658,
-0.4229404330253601,
-0.460623174905777,
-0.43956488370895386,
0.20710879564285278,
-0.5765945315361023,
0.35132187604904175,
0.4114491641521454,
0.880590558052063,
0.3111836314201355,
-0.37428534030914307,
-0.3972817361354828,
-0.15621142089366913,
0.5871595740318298,
-0.7738416194915771,
0.2552565634250641,
0.6357837915420532,
0.3652953803539276,
0.07453654706478119,
-0.8792492151260376,
-0.2441043257713318,
-0.1522112786769867,
-0.509576141834259,
0.2642982006072998,
-0.2679302394390106,
0.21688248217105865,
0.47311586141586304,
0.01681380718946457,
-0.35936611890792847,
0.05920650064945221,
-0.4624853730201721,
-0.31908470392227173,
0.4295467734336853,
-0.12733496725559235,
0.19933395087718964,
-0.2665928304195404,
-0.140339195728302,
-0.03177272155880928,
-0.774095892906189,
0.1649172306060791,
0.6721979379653931,
0.5840744376182556,
0.16568435728549957,
0.514751136302948,
0.1259237378835678,
0.6695073843002319,
0.18792782723903656,
0.17919312417507172,
0.053350914269685745,
0.01905203051865101,
-0.04414445161819458,
0.3519034683704376,
0.645325243473053,
0.49911245703697205,
0.46137943863868713,
-0.057979781180620193,
0.0922534242272377,
-0.38990867137908936,
0.29180148243904114,
-0.5210569500923157,
-0.3608910143375397,
-0.031237972900271416,
-0.49578192830085754,
-0.2129899263381958,
-0.030498599633574486,
-1.143093228340149,
-0.4391383230686188,
-0.39298534393310547,
0.07085166871547699,
-0.5555269122123718,
-0.034658197313547134,
-0.2016511708498001,
-0.30111274123191833,
0.5304163098335266,
-0.14352601766586304,
-0.9870107769966125,
0.4956417679786682,
0.835639476776123,
0.708872377872467,
0.2763489782810211,
-0.11987239867448807,
-0.9481915235519409,
0.29190316796302795,
-0.11604969948530197,
0.8972614407539368,
-0.9839344024658203,
-0.3146180212497711,
0.11396075785160065,
-0.3152201771736145,
-0.2991602122783661,
-0.8931108117103577,
0.49002569913864136,
-0.6175152063369751,
0.1562233865261078,
-0.2833186388015747,
-0.31045740842819214,
-0.14529773592948914,
0.35304731130599976,
-0.6887710690498352,
1.0255078077316284,
0.039210245013237,
-1.0559687614440918,
0.44989728927612305,
-0.6011972427368164,
-0.6700642108917236,
0.032975632697343826,
-0.4151066839694977,
-0.6339543461799622,
0.06842925399541855,
0.29853829741477966,
0.4667890965938568,
0.23955130577087402,
0.11522198468446732,
-0.04476534202694893,
-0.12052416801452637,
0.1568233072757721,
0.009320038370788097,
0.8950197696685791,
0.24243730306625366,
-0.37867215275764465,
0.23167961835861206,
-0.4229753613471985,
0.06826427578926086,
-0.4898280203342438,
0.09527399390935898,
-0.7762494087219238,
-0.0440540537238121,
-0.22491192817687988,
0.11198312789201736,
-0.15075120329856873,
-0.37318262457847595,
-0.20503023266792297,
-0.41476014256477356,
0.42191728949546814,
0.5147372484207153,
0.1338864266872406,
0.3461602032184601,
-0.44830629229545593,
0.7961354851722717,
-0.1414322555065155,
-0.3694427013397217,
-0.035429518669843674,
-0.6487434506416321,
-0.26676255464553833,
-0.26753371953964233,
0.6886012554168701,
0.6293488144874573,
-0.8556035757064819,
0.29003894329071045,
-0.2613454759120941,
-0.17636573314666748,
-0.7776926755905151,
-0.15465882420539856,
0.5810589790344238,
0.5415359735488892,
0.6100203394889832,
-0.19015517830848694,
-0.6787287592887878,
-1.1288387775421143,
-0.6565473675727844,
-0.22211603820323944,
0.24271875619888306,
0.5437664985656738,
0.5354343056678772,
0.16509439051151276,
1.2851709127426147,
-0.528367817401886,
-0.6715303659439087,
-0.3045065402984619,
0.27851614356040955,
0.00737029081210494,
0.2610594630241394,
0.5615339875221252,
-0.9353275895118713,
-0.7611892223358154,
0.15809795260429382,
-0.4446793496608734,
-0.32430997490882874,
-0.11121874302625656,
-0.107752725481987,
-0.12321481853723526,
0.8219301700592041,
-0.22272302210330963,
0.3865542709827423,
0.12403780966997147,
-0.5319201946258545,
0.7626144289970398,
-0.4400242269039154,
0.10809679329395294,
-1.1882438659667969,
-0.2462622970342636,
0.2798939645290375,
-0.5343919396400452,
-0.4324151873588562,
0.4304160177707672,
-0.24686424434185028,
0.08779652416706085,
-0.4189799129962921,
0.4068167209625244,
-0.5555018782615662,
-0.3582634925842285,
0.030597979202866554,
0.17804747819900513,
-0.07840262353420258,
0.3989007771015167,
0.16946271061897278,
0.9723125696182251,
0.4402177929878235,
-0.24924883246421814,
0.01136713195592165,
0.15754511952400208,
-0.3830353319644928,
1.0646559000015259,
-0.20832480490207672,
-0.07328792661428452,
-0.2594699561595917,
0.17801544070243835,
-0.7699132561683655,
-0.05586368218064308,
0.36474308371543884,
-0.22109071910381317,
0.29858478903770447,
-0.6581892371177673,
-0.5220276713371277,
-0.17707639932632446,
-0.28760942816734314,
0.3167640268802643,
0.24477145075798035,
-0.5288976430892944,
0.8678745031356812,
0.5595378875732422,
-0.12092997878789902,
-0.7348524928092957,
-0.979059636592865,
0.06510601192712784,
-0.8702829480171204,
0.059564150869846344,
0.6321700215339661,
0.30440372228622437,
-0.6280457973480225,
0.40263986587524414,
0.21656057238578796,
-0.5000978708267212,
-0.3027323782444,
0.47986748814582825,
-0.41284164786338806,
-0.2602590322494507,
0.20014213025569916,
0.19233684241771698,
0.05633186921477318,
0.23535005748271942,
-0.13742858171463013,
0.11284594982862473,
-0.09667759388685226,
-0.19534753262996674,
-0.13236255943775177,
0.4567904770374298,
0.4666774570941925,
-0.4550767242908478,
0.45580658316612244,
0.3825313150882721,
-0.17612937092781067,
-0.4024569094181061,
-0.6452959775924683,
-0.07110993564128876,
-0.4415503442287445,
0.2675928771495819,
-0.7110117077827454,
-0.8980074524879456,
0.432301789522171,
-0.15055842697620392,
0.000009363535355078056,
0.05925784632563591,
0.2809111177921295,
-0.03986799716949463,
0.11850769072771072,
0.49828675389289856,
-0.2134402096271515,
0.4797845184803009,
-0.07859873026609421,
0.3574093282222748,
-1.0395961999893188,
-0.13559943437576294,
-0.4927031397819519,
-0.07844339311122894,
-0.4156818091869354,
-0.8783719539642334,
0.3391297161579132,
-0.1684662252664566,
-0.0863754078745842,
0.5702482461929321,
-0.5337376594543457,
0.8499134182929993,
0.5209411382675171,
0.11392232775688171,
0.36090290546417236,
0.26036322116851807,
-0.5272369384765625,
-0.512958288192749,
-0.749149739742279,
-0.5500842928886414,
1.0030808448791504,
0.16723836958408356,
0.23166930675506592,
0.23277990520000458,
0.9415381550788879,
0.542376697063446,
0.6338317394256592,
-0.951820969581604,
0.7027876377105713,
-0.31687894463539124,
-0.5375463962554932,
-0.2978857755661011,
-0.22511164844036102,
-0.9856878519058228,
0.8618754148483276,
-0.1115671917796135,
-0.8409621119499207,
-0.0329488180577755,
-0.1255573183298111,
-0.6570895314216614,
0.5748651623725891,
-0.33542323112487793,
0.6980201005935669,
0.012323054485023022,
-0.6918589472770691,
-0.32900649309158325,
-0.5615590810775757,
0.15712466835975647,
0.17979969084262848,
0.40613439679145813,
0.04768357053399086,
0.11399026215076447,
0.5621980428695679,
-0.3465471863746643,
0.9989815950393677,
-0.26114195585250854,
0.04951953887939453,
0.7416520118713379,
-0.18626274168491364,
0.14039169251918793,
0.0014823017409071326,
-0.45296981930732727,
-0.3588961362838745,
0.2209995687007904,
-0.13002273440361023,
-0.7310251593589783,
0.6509780883789062,
-0.3486536741256714,
-0.6950387954711914,
-0.4779662787914276,
-0.563755214214325,
-0.34776344895362854,
0.10408312827348709,
0.13397499918937683,
0.4330655336380005,
-0.33960625529289246,
0.13271987438201904,
0.6898258328437805,
-0.036171767860651016,
0.26533597707748413,
0.5612378120422363,
-0.056897908449172974,
-0.5682960748672485,
1.0486969947814941,
0.29929643869400024,
-0.23060551285743713,
0.6244606375694275,
0.3493635356426239,
-0.6323125958442688,
-0.3969126045703888,
-0.18078269064426422,
0.21947036683559418,
-0.7833461165428162,
-0.26481351256370544,
-0.746717631816864,
-0.0970672219991684,
-0.32834017276763916,
-0.24462994933128357,
-0.03976041078567505,
-0.2950489819049835,
0.0358944796025753,
-0.33400481939315796,
0.31156569719314575,
0.7603651881217957,
-0.23738007247447968,
0.28977736830711365,
-0.35814979672431946,
0.20007219910621643,
0.39293020963668823,
0.30595695972442627,
0.015141885727643967,
-0.5128594040870667,
-0.1094902828335762,
-0.16928482055664062,
-0.1989130824804306,
-0.9120699167251587,
0.36583083868026733,
0.044539183378219604,
0.8125430345535278,
0.2033311426639557,
0.2851010859012604,
0.8347642421722412,
-0.7914360761642456,
0.6025322675704956,
-0.007403210736811161,
-0.7966777086257935,
0.4601501226425171,
-0.33761706948280334,
-0.10335526615381241,
0.9181267619132996,
0.5405299663543701,
-0.1795988231897354,
-0.44580888748168945,
-0.6661677360534668,
-0.9113783240318298,
0.2467748075723648,
0.14472925662994385,
0.027991654351353645,
-0.061648737639188766,
0.46375882625579834,
-0.11175325512886047,
0.05411277338862419,
-0.9201846122741699,
0.004122753161936998,
-0.0986628606915474,
-0.19475112855434418,
0.24403713643550873,
-0.09407404065132141,
-0.2520561218261719,
-0.5278406739234924,
0.5857595205307007,
-0.33478492498397827,
-0.04743846878409386,
0.5571869015693665,
-0.1020120307803154,
0.405992716550827,
0.5023952722549438,
0.6502386331558228,
0.48868048191070557,
-0.03951004147529602,
0.3104552924633026,
0.4980495274066925,
-0.031338341534137726,
0.14094677567481995,
-0.09683771431446075,
-0.008742841891944408,
0.2943515479564667,
0.3630037307739258,
0.3564820885658264,
0.4953148365020752,
-0.5546669960021973,
0.4719811677932739,
0.14036880433559418,
-0.42174816131591797,
-0.4840589761734009,
-0.13838031888008118,
0.23339244723320007,
0.4845077693462372,
0.09318874776363373,
-0.05796279385685921,
0.3199761211872101,
-0.7788525819778442,
0.7073935270309448,
0.5372042655944824,
-0.810050904750824,
-0.007190922740846872,
0.6121195554733276,
0.07035886496305466,
-0.3391622304916382,
0.08848652988672256,
-0.2640312910079956,
-0.7293431758880615,
0.816815197467804,
0.5176071524620056,
0.7523357272148132,
-0.01391875185072422,
0.41278505325317383,
0.3220542371273041,
0.2298971712589264,
-0.08799812942743301,
-0.1273495852947235,
-0.3206367492675781,
-0.6556165814399719,
-0.3316747844219208,
-0.3013857901096344,
-0.6540147662162781,
0.09880423545837402,
-1.07669198513031,
-0.21691061556339264,
-0.5007182955741882,
-0.30057913064956665,
-0.14826253056526184,
0.1174357682466507,
-0.4201274812221527,
0.13281147181987762,
-0.0735582560300827,
0.8463977575302124,
-0.9102808833122253,
0.9359872937202454,
0.9289528727531433,
-0.16500873863697052,
-0.4979991018772125,
0.37188759446144104,
-0.025956394150853157,
-0.25237390398979187,
0.922909140586853,
0.20612342655658722,
-0.4869537353515625,
-0.15800611674785614,
-0.23795227706432343,
-0.22514420747756958,
0.9583768248558044,
-0.02842797338962555,
-0.48178550601005554,
0.027372702956199646,
0.3237546682357788,
0.8877416253089905,
-0.7921196818351746,
0.44718945026397705,
0.5199519395828247,
0.472478985786438,
-0.012822701595723629,
-0.5348520278930664,
0.09311255067586899,
-0.10333049297332764,
-0.01310366578400135,
-0.23802660405635834,
-0.7213281393051147,
0.27244454622268677,
-0.28687602281570435,
-0.05850357189774513,
0.08628710359334946,
0.7428786754608154,
0.24568529427051544,
0.4979064464569092,
0.3611084222793579,
0.66788649559021,
0.9469971060752869,
0.14333747327327728,
0.8065057396888733,
-0.4540698230266571,
0.035776738077402115,
1.8780990839004517,
-0.47541630268096924,
0.935584545135498,
0.5748984217643738,
-0.06976714730262756,
0.6713808178901672,
0.2221110463142395,
-0.16253331303596497,
0.5561541318893433,
0.6560965776443481,
-0.3608078062534332,
-0.251923143863678,
-0.3284997045993805,
-0.09943315386772156,
0.3047924339771271,
0.5719983577728271,
-0.4992683231830597,
-0.35213983058929443,
-0.12676659226417542,
-0.2707037925720215,
0.9624959230422974,
-0.17399658262729645,
0.7437626123428345,
0.21423642337322235,
-0.7456783056259155,
-0.11052823066711426,
-0.03192790970206261,
0.7638564705848694,
-0.3161487877368927,
-0.3445609509944916,
-0.17196190357208252,
-0.08588956296443939,
-0.3668082356452942,
-1.0104999542236328,
0.6408262252807617,
-0.07050445675849915,
-0.24497970938682556,
-0.3142806589603424,
0.5780766606330872,
-0.37808579206466675,
-0.22885599732398987,
0.48972898721694946,
0.4109596312046051,
0.28166458010673523,
0.054929498583078384,
-0.7741044759750366,
-0.36582913994789124,
0.08438912779092789,
0.15227852761745453,
0.40043193101882935,
0.7208172082901001,
-0.1409897804260254,
0.7120493650436401,
0.32087451219558716,
0.3882477879524231,
0.14788518846035004,
0.09300967305898666,
0.9094191193580627,
-0.6661437153816223,
-0.5054289698600769,
-0.6551944017410278,
0.4021408259868622,
-0.4645997881889343,
-0.3739522099494934,
0.6567512154579163,
0.8772326707839966,
0.8528592586517334,
-0.0332755483686924,
0.7529470324516296,
0.0472412146627903,
0.6273173093795776,
-0.692578136920929,
0.6689966320991516,
-0.023401159793138504,
0.300828754901886,
-0.09005624800920486,
-0.9386131167411804,
-0.3776692748069763,
0.8781074285507202,
-0.7711195945739746,
-0.247339129447937,
0.7333227396011353,
1.098868489265442,
-0.30269646644592285,
-0.1503114253282547,
0.6188384294509888,
-0.15735960006713867,
0.24205553531646729,
0.4303562343120575,
0.721279501914978,
-0.3378317952156067,
0.5866361260414124,
-0.27525269985198975,
0.12445174902677536,
0.03874830901622772,
-0.7809972763061523,
-1.2982733249664307,
-0.5126185417175293,
-0.6383954882621765,
-0.48145636916160583,
0.42690175771713257,
0.8466454744338989,
0.8616971373558044,
-0.7902586460113525,
-0.28394779562950134,
0.01870388723909855,
0.16163618862628937,
-0.17976798117160797,
-0.37397921085357666,
0.2477094829082489,
-0.4359543025493622,
-0.5700516104698181,
0.4543856978416443,
0.07855727523565292,
-0.2523537874221802,
0.08428619801998138,
0.04602087661623955,
-0.3787674605846405,
0.1244383454322815,
0.5752602815628052,
0.5937722325325012,
-0.8343249559402466,
-0.288217157125473,
-0.9347477555274963,
-0.11247000098228455,
0.20135407149791718,
1.1616778373718262,
-0.9253811836242676,
0.39163121581077576,
0.24999167025089264,
0.6024835109710693,
0.3509710729122162,
0.5066858530044556,
0.613258421421051,
-0.9234746098518372,
0.2235649973154068,
0.335822194814682,
0.4593721926212311,
0.3337109386920929,
-0.4220387041568756,
0.7814784049987793,
-0.038610659539699554,
-0.312330424785614,
-0.534810483455658,
0.5068731307983398,
-0.5737288594245911,
-0.5042884945869446,
1.097640872001648,
-0.5965813398361206,
-0.16751770675182343,
-0.5159345865249634,
-0.3070756196975708,
0.04776940122246742,
-0.3646869361400604,
0.578147292137146,
0.6222798228263855,
-0.08460541814565659,
-0.3224085569381714,
-0.7642537951469421,
0.7648188471794128,
0.6994971632957458,
-0.6769654750823975,
-0.014355842024087906,
0.3387337923049927,
0.5576955080032349,
0.29839929938316345,
0.6800062656402588,
-0.1751122772693634,
-0.12494916468858719,
0.11502391844987869,
-0.23386864364147186,
-0.19971899688243866,
-0.2927541732788086,
-0.3812564015388489,
0.4725898206233978,
-0.1249861866235733,
-0.04609481990337372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00596v1
|
ECtHR-PCR: A Dataset for Precedent Understanding and Prior Case Retrieval in the European Court of Human Rights
| 2024-03-31T08:06:54 | 2024-03-31T08:06:54 |
T. Y. S. S Santosh, Rashid Gustav Haddad, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In common law jurisdictions, legal practitioners rely on precedents to
construct arguments, in line with the doctrine of \emph{stare decisis}. As the
number of cases grow over the years, prior case retrieval (PCR) has garnered
significant attention. Besides lacking real-world scale, existing PCR datasets
do not simulate a realistic setting, because their queries use complete case
documents while only masking references to prior cases. The query is thereby
exposed to legal reasoning not yet available when constructing an argument for
an undecided case as well as spurious patterns left behind by citation masks,
potentially short-circuiting a comprehensive understanding of case facts and
legal principles. To address these limitations, we introduce a PCR dataset
based on judgements from the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), which
explicitly separate facts from arguments and exhibit precedential practices,
aiding us to develop this PCR dataset to foster systems' comprehensive
understanding. We benchmark different lexical and dense retrieval approaches
with various negative sampling strategies, adapting them to deal with long text
sequences using hierarchical variants. We found that difficulty-based negative
sampling strategies were not effective for the PCR task, highlighting the need
for investigation into domain-specific difficulty criteria. Furthermore, we
observe performance of the dense models degrade with time and calls for further
research into temporal adaptation of retrieval models. Additionally, we assess
the influence of different views , Halsbury's and Goodhart's, in practice in
ECtHR jurisdiction using PCR task.
|
[
-0.2790427803993225,
-0.7426234483718872,
0.7152349948883057,
-0.4604496359825134,
-0.5470698475837708,
-0.04087349772453308,
-0.19560202956199646,
-0.25376346707344055,
-0.2154351770877838,
0.5897455215454102,
-0.09030449390411377,
-0.3681342601776123,
-0.18302294611930847,
0.23747502267360687,
-0.4518606960773468,
0.8146944642066956,
0.08325430750846863,
0.19896933436393738,
-0.11455008387565613,
-0.21835000813007355,
-0.18499065935611725,
-1.3055882453918457,
-0.1280275583267212,
-0.07772155106067657,
0.8272945284843445,
0.4196722209453583,
0.1434950977563858,
0.5482752323150635,
0.8807995915412903,
0.22985486686229706,
-0.3480135202407837,
-0.2249196469783783,
-0.5933225750923157,
0.007441783789545298,
-0.07915225625038147,
-0.4211064577102661,
-0.4046580195426941,
-0.3586847484111786,
0.3328907787799835,
0.35460221767425537,
-0.38113752007484436,
0.09014585614204407,
-0.09114662557840347,
0.7599664926528931,
-0.7648753523826599,
-0.36139369010925293,
-0.4474461078643799,
0.4368829131126404,
-0.6916325092315674,
-0.582354724407196,
-0.3879084289073944,
-0.21133509278297424,
0.53148353099823,
-0.6227696537971497,
0.833954393863678,
0.057529255747795105,
0.5196520686149597,
0.08147796243429184,
-0.6015812158584595,
-0.19038692116737366,
-1.0361747741699219,
0.8053057193756104,
-0.5473623275756836,
0.3864270746707916,
0.17646750807762146,
0.6525350213050842,
-0.0718231350183487,
-0.9244542121887207,
-0.7151793241500854,
0.01805979199707508,
-0.04852699488401413,
0.24961026012897491,
-0.20510655641555786,
0.10716219246387482,
0.43303346633911133,
0.3194478750228882,
-0.8389278650283813,
-0.19162410497665405,
-0.9568954110145569,
-0.18627570569515228,
0.42046549916267395,
0.14685508608818054,
0.04575622081756592,
-0.31971096992492676,
-0.4356016218662262,
-0.1764734834432602,
-0.7107229232788086,
0.04139111191034317,
0.3198471665382385,
0.5698948502540588,
-0.03323043882846832,
0.5813701748847961,
-0.027290523052215576,
0.6983465552330017,
0.30415114760398865,
0.011057684198021889,
0.22584009170532227,
-0.0013967055128887296,
-0.12203127890825272,
0.4025534689426422,
0.37348315119743347,
0.20612701773643494,
0.148807093501091,
-0.03651804104447365,
0.09579240530729294,
0.06422056257724762,
0.3590344190597534,
-0.7051286101341248,
0.1092558354139328,
0.3036843240261078,
-0.844704806804657,
0.11608774960041046,
0.4305419921875,
-0.9367660284042358,
-0.24473492801189423,
-0.7077950239181519,
0.12404266744852066,
-0.19630467891693115,
0.08652825653553009,
0.3130282163619995,
-0.3252498507499695,
0.6459366679191589,
0.30268269777297974,
-0.1125345453619957,
0.6248971223831177,
0.7343922257423401,
0.45251038670539856,
-0.3052574396133423,
0.19583801925182343,
-0.5537979006767273,
0.12697120010852814,
0.06991837918758392,
0.77614426612854,
-0.7519208192825317,
-0.543830156326294,
0.1521819680929184,
0.2826325595378876,
0.051368407905101776,
-0.5607491135597229,
1.1255263090133667,
-0.6503598690032959,
0.26696187257766724,
-0.684371292591095,
-0.7057678699493408,
-0.19306626915931702,
0.11678630858659744,
-0.5256966352462769,
0.5609870553016663,
-0.392439603805542,
-1.0457714796066284,
0.6965060234069824,
-0.4478547275066376,
-0.486104279756546,
0.3705841302871704,
-0.45613405108451843,
-0.3286697268486023,
0.0688663199543953,
0.013273132033646107,
0.349029004573822,
-0.1674192100763321,
0.06957481801509857,
-0.4771711826324463,
-0.3603194057941437,
-0.10960911214351654,
-0.23832720518112183,
0.5935605764389038,
0.3537263572216034,
-0.2874619960784912,
-0.06084315851330757,
-0.8447641730308533,
-0.2993372976779938,
0.00941932201385498,
-0.24147434532642365,
-0.5362288951873779,
0.4016425609588623,
0.34903714060783386,
0.4154087007045746,
-0.017218105494976044,
-0.7395992279052734,
-0.07884577661752701,
0.0969066247344017,
0.5756680369377136,
0.6373088359832764,
0.30942776799201965,
-0.016647186130285263,
-0.40471890568733215,
0.5486236214637756,
0.007503093685954809,
0.0805460512638092,
0.15446427464485168,
-0.2176821380853653,
-0.6140440702438354,
0.14171849191188812,
0.15840354561805725,
0.6597951054573059,
-0.3062981367111206,
0.28994011878967285,
-0.4537382125854492,
0.020404258742928505,
-0.3231901228427887,
-0.16414320468902588,
0.22734375298023224,
0.6074705719947815,
0.46779897809028625,
-0.4113073945045471,
-0.8894447088241577,
-0.9682706594467163,
0.05700983479619026,
-0.20705299079418182,
-0.020176608115434647,
0.4915582537651062,
0.7089948058128357,
0.09195397049188614,
0.7803578972816467,
-0.010679293423891068,
-0.3126813471317291,
-0.2701484262943268,
0.03034176304936409,
0.22970259189605713,
0.2622918486595154,
0.11023265868425369,
-1.1474754810333252,
-0.13464219868183136,
0.1650121957063675,
-0.6022189259529114,
0.3568863272666931,
0.057677026838064194,
-0.024301545694470406,
0.12162493169307709,
0.7433612942695618,
-0.2608226537704468,
0.657024085521698,
-0.08485405892133713,
-0.27074918150901794,
0.38347113132476807,
-0.3427920341491699,
0.3742578327655792,
-0.7242345809936523,
0.35526159405708313,
0.07108588516712189,
-0.26884040236473083,
-0.47502195835113525,
0.004022798966616392,
-0.025592224672436714,
0.1510591208934784,
-0.6194472312927246,
0.33088403940200806,
-0.2083468735218048,
0.06755532324314117,
0.0705454871058464,
-0.07054293155670166,
-0.07887398451566696,
0.2784552276134491,
0.15131862461566925,
0.594502866268158,
-0.1349523365497589,
-0.6130008101463318,
0.04854201525449753,
0.41609591245651245,
-0.2147519439458847,
0.988048255443573,
-0.7641613483428955,
0.29259008169174194,
-0.28855791687965393,
0.062225982546806335,
-0.5007539987564087,
-0.09014154225587845,
0.0015193356666713953,
0.0435841865837574,
0.26450520753860474,
-0.5174447298049927,
-0.5441195368766785,
-0.827761173248291,
-0.11743529886007309,
0.5289149284362793,
0.5576823949813843,
-0.3662503659725189,
0.32300809025764465,
0.37282392382621765,
-0.31153589487075806,
-0.5298153758049011,
-0.542117714881897,
-0.002530102152377367,
-0.5294103622436523,
-0.010133950039744377,
0.5073980689048767,
-0.09261104464530945,
-0.5013524889945984,
-0.1942054182291031,
0.0351494625210762,
-0.2688392400741577,
-0.49283406138420105,
0.11807068437337875,
-0.13372249901294708,
-0.17897625267505646,
0.12197957187891006,
-0.14319798350334167,
0.036309342831373215,
-0.006157859694212675,
0.13084053993225098,
0.4255228042602539,
-0.006590231787413359,
-0.6895779371261597,
-0.517770528793335,
0.5238463282585144,
0.4016544222831726,
-0.18148604035377502,
-0.1078939139842987,
0.07180944830179214,
-0.4535794258117676,
0.151630699634552,
-0.8292832374572754,
-0.1251259595155716,
-0.3420012295246124,
0.07359637320041656,
-0.2952524721622467,
-0.7546138763427734,
0.4822661578655243,
0.4040965139865875,
-0.10711193084716797,
0.48495781421661377,
0.7004215121269226,
-0.24342381954193115,
0.5483783483505249,
0.5393922328948975,
-0.2837022840976715,
0.2588765323162079,
-0.0314757265150547,
0.08925202488899231,
-0.723464846611023,
-0.1821875125169754,
-0.6872028112411499,
-0.11722676455974579,
-0.6878024339675903,
-0.418879896402359,
0.18526126444339752,
-0.2754369378089905,
-0.5164912939071655,
0.0520138256251812,
-0.3816140592098236,
0.451801061630249,
0.36342912912368774,
0.5524255037307739,
0.526727557182312,
0.00227498821914196,
-0.2963239550590515,
-0.18942295014858246,
-0.6243472099304199,
-0.6923936605453491,
1.1787241697311401,
0.03215685859322548,
0.45646965503692627,
0.08118235319852829,
0.6276662945747375,
0.6109151244163513,
-0.005346465390175581,
-0.5934079885482788,
0.3160203993320465,
-0.31160759925842285,
-0.6657587289810181,
-0.013920693658292294,
-0.45150479674339294,
-1.0981730222702026,
0.12702390551567078,
0.13431598246097565,
-0.6270813345909119,
0.8541594743728638,
-0.002200944582000375,
-0.5054776668548584,
0.36607465147972107,
-0.07030089944601059,
0.6350405812263489,
-0.13238199055194855,
-0.5328088402748108,
-0.21726396679878235,
-0.9475365877151489,
0.1469399482011795,
0.16488029062747955,
0.18243184685707092,
0.2842678725719452,
0.35766729712486267,
0.6833184361457825,
-0.6816540956497192,
0.5661769509315491,
-0.11918734014034271,
0.06979004293680191,
0.40692493319511414,
-0.17185229063034058,
0.3403572142124176,
-0.34392133355140686,
0.034815702587366104,
-0.3490433394908905,
0.19511300325393677,
-0.44908034801483154,
-0.09052419662475586,
0.2742711007595062,
-0.4049270451068878,
-0.4528016149997711,
-0.5723859071731567,
-0.09629742801189423,
0.2429858297109604,
0.1521318107843399,
0.39035847783088684,
0.4983980655670166,
-0.6416314840316772,
0.5321950316429138,
0.677058756351471,
-0.2052147537469864,
0.2693159580230713,
0.5816960334777832,
0.23924626410007477,
-0.27940621972084045,
0.4967114329338074,
0.14742214977741241,
-0.22045855224132538,
0.7434052228927612,
0.012051545083522797,
-0.27827930450439453,
-0.47975707054138184,
-0.059694766998291016,
-0.05457107722759247,
-0.41789016127586365,
-0.1872793436050415,
-0.6228837966918945,
0.02795693650841713,
-0.0861150398850441,
-0.088468536734581,
-0.06632108241319656,
-0.48018988966941833,
-0.1436939537525177,
-0.18738681077957153,
0.43730801343917847,
0.5711182951927185,
-0.08187739551067352,
0.0013888351386412978,
-0.5776545405387878,
0.5795909762382507,
0.34522879123687744,
0.1534883677959442,
-0.19649344682693481,
-0.6399094462394714,
0.1797129511833191,
-0.16542808711528778,
-0.3392673432826996,
-0.5323923826217651,
0.4801769256591797,
0.1285727173089981,
0.5248876214027405,
0.4851376712322235,
0.24619323015213013,
0.9377340078353882,
-0.8582244515419006,
0.5175274014472961,
-0.2730228304862976,
-0.675015926361084,
0.7185732126235962,
-0.5336034893989563,
-0.15479497611522675,
0.7504695653915405,
0.23405100405216217,
-0.3976196050643921,
-0.012946847826242447,
-0.6657302379608154,
-1.0127110481262207,
0.3103655278682709,
0.2752903699874878,
-0.10378549247980118,
0.02225186675786972,
0.749155580997467,
0.10306058824062347,
0.16195927560329437,
-0.20700666308403015,
-0.028479749336838722,
-0.031166110187768936,
0.04086654260754585,
-0.2466253787279129,
-0.22312408685684204,
-0.2139773964881897,
-0.43517613410949707,
0.4203035235404968,
0.1920243203639984,
0.285013347864151,
0.9159254431724548,
-0.40210965275764465,
-0.1623590737581253,
0.6910848617553711,
0.46640947461128235,
0.8606579899787903,
-0.6762182712554932,
0.007338555064052343,
-0.024641897529363632,
-0.5127387046813965,
0.17893263697624207,
0.4356222152709961,
-0.06374362856149673,
-0.12223944813013077,
0.23751434683799744,
0.250801146030426,
0.11122635006904602,
-0.7331521511077881,
0.6002722382545471,
-0.31976771354675293,
-0.34880536794662476,
-0.5340918302536011,
-0.38140034675598145,
-0.49399736523628235,
0.16228412091732025,
0.5960684418678284,
-0.2805924713611603,
0.5812695622444153,
-0.4232957363128662,
0.7164787650108337,
0.05977595970034599,
-0.7160189151763916,
-0.2828510105609894,
0.555037796497345,
-0.030548101291060448,
0.06699162721633911,
0.498846173286438,
0.07154867798089981,
-0.44976329803466797,
0.71961909532547,
0.21688838303089142,
0.6022182106971741,
0.018993880599737167,
0.07336389273405075,
0.21158342063426971,
0.12833595275878906,
-0.18623945116996765,
0.7291264533996582,
-0.09481905400753021,
-0.4120253324508667,
-0.32322415709495544,
-0.29338282346725464,
-0.5102474093437195,
0.09086869657039642,
-1.285096526145935,
0.13298305869102478,
-0.39064618945121765,
-0.14613229036331177,
-0.22043295204639435,
0.14780293405056,
-0.9659236669540405,
-0.012656508944928646,
-0.005607214290648699,
0.9701876044273376,
-0.5555598735809326,
0.6080530285835266,
0.39617887139320374,
-0.2607864439487457,
-0.21196454763412476,
-0.13464801013469696,
0.33473774790763855,
-0.31314346194267273,
0.4714963138103485,
0.10179730504751205,
0.02956204116344452,
-0.2805459797382355,
-0.2944777011871338,
-0.2653781771659851,
1.0387020111083984,
0.1995634287595749,
-1.1245611906051636,
0.10240757465362549,
0.11421092599630356,
0.7749163508415222,
-0.24683871865272522,
-0.22420550882816315,
0.6183876991271973,
0.3223131597042084,
0.17580494284629822,
-0.6185977458953857,
0.05421728640794754,
-0.48694509267807007,
-0.1338636428117752,
0.1878718137741089,
-0.3192855715751648,
0.7542228102684021,
-0.2313631772994995,
-0.35718145966529846,
0.3195107877254486,
0.3454310894012451,
0.33181434869766235,
0.40961217880249023,
0.1680278331041336,
0.722628116607666,
0.7190570831298828,
-0.06931061297655106,
1.3153300285339355,
-0.30400219559669495,
0.3084743916988373,
1.1964433193206787,
-0.5808519124984741,
1.2369709014892578,
0.7666904926300049,
-0.24089711904525757,
0.4982275366783142,
0.6027356386184692,
-0.04081805422902107,
0.6568470001220703,
0.3325127065181732,
-0.06748427450656891,
-0.3810103237628937,
-0.2276502400636673,
-0.6622360944747925,
0.17671464383602142,
0.29775354266166687,
-0.3468087315559387,
-0.22264207899570465,
-0.23452116549015045,
-0.25287869572639465,
0.1466953307390213,
-0.2889432907104492,
0.8696913123130798,
0.0772082582116127,
0.003388982033357024,
0.2136625349521637,
-0.3539682924747467,
0.3582078218460083,
-0.20694802701473236,
-0.2601906657218933,
-0.048137880861759186,
0.35635077953338623,
0.030981697142124176,
-0.3280538320541382,
0.01264280267059803,
0.13368375599384308,
-0.26296308636665344,
0.12771762907505035,
0.4450724720954895,
0.08659124374389648,
-0.7966288924217224,
0.28002089262008667,
0.8321437239646912,
0.03460921347141266,
0.11665806174278259,
-0.6096516847610474,
-0.2000267207622528,
-0.4892197251319885,
-0.1130363717675209,
0.06677722930908203,
0.7861664891242981,
-0.06813594698905945,
0.4168547987937927,
0.5597177147865295,
0.1489488035440445,
0.01326229702681303,
0.35486143827438354,
0.8261282444000244,
-0.8391011953353882,
-0.34913113713264465,
-0.7471824288368225,
0.35853442549705505,
-0.15012134611606598,
-0.3366301655769348,
0.41813257336616516,
0.802391529083252,
0.8173310160636902,
0.22428271174430847,
0.867184579372406,
0.014119128696620464,
0.8704884648323059,
-0.5303986072540283,
0.3102000653743744,
-0.3374534547328949,
0.14081862568855286,
-0.4280538558959961,
-0.7148776054382324,
-0.5706843733787537,
0.5786951184272766,
-0.4046931564807892,
0.029898080974817276,
0.4487704932689667,
0.4965669512748718,
-0.3996430039405823,
-0.11569494754076004,
0.12348109483718872,
0.2980046570301056,
0.22006012499332428,
0.49084365367889404,
0.9035555124282837,
-0.38902485370635986,
0.430320680141449,
-0.191334530711174,
0.04318065196275711,
-0.38171911239624023,
-0.8312486410140991,
-0.7727742791175842,
-0.3827258348464966,
0.09388840198516846,
-0.17810969054698944,
0.56635981798172,
1.0115429162979126,
0.7768301367759705,
-1.1237332820892334,
-0.3270959258079529,
-0.41030606627464294,
-0.1008320152759552,
-0.07075569033622742,
-0.20116662979125977,
0.6819455027580261,
-0.12140345573425293,
-0.14674875140190125,
0.08882153034210205,
0.00007261295831995085,
0.20012739300727844,
0.31466546654701233,
0.012579402886331081,
-0.19690407812595367,
-0.010143156163394451,
0.6015022993087769,
0.7202510833740234,
-0.6804148554801941,
-0.334727019071579,
-0.16681665182113647,
0.1458195596933365,
0.543027937412262,
1.4690219163894653,
-0.6864169239997864,
0.46205443143844604,
0.34299731254577637,
0.46990469098091125,
0.5936640501022339,
0.11654854565858841,
0.7102675437927246,
-0.45105859637260437,
0.18082062900066376,
0.46903547644615173,
0.7521358728408813,
0.21895146369934082,
-0.18385371565818787,
0.2565203607082367,
0.0951678678393364,
-0.5851393938064575,
-0.737747311592102,
0.14285717904567719,
-1.1773350238800049,
-0.20845232903957367,
0.7339284420013428,
0.051373258233070374,
-0.10977478325366974,
-0.541883111000061,
-0.14508602023124695,
-0.05208619311451912,
-0.5628640651702881,
0.9728119373321533,
0.41951626539230347,
-0.12374266982078552,
-0.12962423264980316,
-0.7179213166236877,
0.39822736382484436,
-0.05485672131180763,
-0.6879595518112183,
0.18622849881649017,
0.5682697892189026,
0.05290023982524872,
-0.05380846560001373,
0.5487797856330872,
-0.5980933904647827,
0.3213067054748535,
-0.46929410099983215,
0.011113381944596767,
0.5592997074127197,
-0.40064695477485657,
-0.632102906703949,
0.3648035526275635,
-0.27541738748550415,
0.18837720155715942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00595v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00595v1
|
Query-driven Relevant Paragraph Extraction from Legal Judgments
| 2024-03-31T08:03:39 | 2024-03-31T08:03:39 |
T. Y. S. S Santosh, Elvin Quero Hernandez, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Legal professionals often grapple with navigating lengthy legal judgements to
pinpoint information that directly address their queries. This paper focus on
this task of extracting relevant paragraphs from legal judgements based on the
query. We construct a specialized dataset for this task from the European Court
of Human Rights (ECtHR) using the case law guides. We assess the performance of
current retrieval models in a zero-shot way and also establish fine-tuning
benchmarks using various models. The results highlight the significant gap
between fine-tuned and zero-shot performance, emphasizing the challenge of
handling distribution shift in the legal domain. We notice that the legal
pre-training handles distribution shift on the corpus side but still struggles
on query side distribution shift, with unseen legal queries. We also explore
various Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods to evaluate their
practicality within the context of information retrieval, shedding light on the
effectiveness of different PEFT methods across diverse configurations with
pre-training and model architectures influencing the choice of PEFT method.
|
[
-0.3982953131198883,
-0.8939579725265503,
0.7187422513961792,
-0.2918913662433624,
-0.6726052165031433,
-0.3471732437610626,
-0.16291871666908264,
-0.36582475900650024,
-0.1806837022304535,
0.8410095572471619,
-0.3060096204280853,
-0.503536581993103,
-0.4619443118572235,
-0.0785965695977211,
-0.7121060490608215,
1.0440813302993774,
0.293742835521698,
-0.030023127794265747,
0.15776768326759338,
-0.44793596863746643,
-0.35197943449020386,
-0.38891783356666565,
-0.2300092875957489,
-0.05127904564142227,
0.46955832839012146,
0.3506777286529541,
0.4443165361881256,
0.6846814155578613,
0.6587086915969849,
0.1628836840391159,
-0.1905912309885025,
-0.13242821395397186,
-0.49598613381385803,
0.26099899411201477,
-0.6941221356391907,
-0.6553855538368225,
-0.21703863143920898,
-0.08382531255483627,
0.29174572229385376,
0.4333007335662842,
-0.5103173851966858,
0.3935108780860901,
-0.11778397113084793,
0.802299439907074,
-0.9527601003646851,
-0.12601441144943237,
-0.8990111351013184,
0.3930880129337311,
-0.48102861642837524,
-0.48170575499534607,
-0.506043016910553,
-0.2848527431488037,
0.25919899344444275,
-0.6992962956428528,
0.7288559079170227,
0.2866676449775696,
1.0180470943450928,
0.3870464265346527,
-0.576656699180603,
-0.12174326181411743,
-0.5369922518730164,
0.6446900963783264,
-0.6743617057800293,
0.6537666916847229,
0.32222503423690796,
0.3030788004398346,
0.027866167947649956,
-0.956815242767334,
-0.48030325770378113,
0.02478981949388981,
0.1348031461238861,
0.2591780126094818,
-0.17502297461032867,
0.08266168087720871,
0.4129679501056671,
0.07781217992305756,
-0.4160930812358856,
0.16143015027046204,
-0.34916362166404724,
-0.14330801367759705,
0.6856571435928345,
0.14013855159282684,
-0.002129101427271962,
-0.3874753415584564,
-0.010442175902426243,
-0.15981730818748474,
-0.8682498335838318,
0.01727977767586708,
0.5829606056213379,
0.2646576762199402,
0.31867703795433044,
0.775982677936554,
-0.34785130620002747,
1.0128111839294434,
0.5287767052650452,
0.06675034016370773,
0.09593476355075836,
-0.3529459834098816,
-0.15831753611564636,
0.11477047204971313,
0.6366428136825562,
0.5700178742408752,
0.21894443035125732,
-0.08890409022569656,
-0.21598000824451447,
-0.6183611750602722,
0.4683687388896942,
-0.7738773226737976,
-0.10237444937229156,
0.1691034883260727,
-0.6602428555488586,
-0.08384449779987335,
0.34231898188591003,
-1.102882742881775,
-0.47690823674201965,
-0.47369518876075745,
-0.07321740686893463,
-0.34682363271713257,
0.12945868074893951,
0.40153318643569946,
-0.2793808579444885,
0.5562164187431335,
0.3934001922607422,
-0.7321905493736267,
-0.0907154232263565,
0.7095564603805542,
0.2938341200351715,
0.023501338437199593,
0.3457990288734436,
-0.8575387001037598,
0.2549441456794739,
-0.08706644922494888,
0.8733373284339905,
-0.760662853717804,
-0.13890381157398224,
0.3336983025074005,
0.1624702662229538,
-0.19150826334953308,
-0.7005540132522583,
1.2037595510482788,
-0.8274006247520447,
0.1244722232222557,
-0.35394051671028137,
-0.7469812631607056,
0.19516970217227936,
0.2859090268611908,
-0.5221009254455566,
0.736014187335968,
-0.07768178731203079,
-0.9331946969032288,
0.883095383644104,
-0.5131174921989441,
-0.5547074675559998,
0.2144128829240799,
-0.3819938600063324,
-0.40568533539772034,
0.25496551394462585,
0.2896115183830261,
0.3849725127220154,
-0.1452321857213974,
0.004958414472639561,
-0.31453174352645874,
-0.3016674816608429,
-0.2298802137374878,
-0.22626717388629913,
0.703251302242279,
0.5455517768859863,
-0.33978086709976196,
-0.10312981903553009,
-0.8608956933021545,
-0.017998013645410538,
-0.08414550125598907,
-0.4730868637561798,
-0.348239004611969,
0.23511680960655212,
-0.18462689220905304,
0.239383727312088,
0.167726069688797,
-0.5928140878677368,
0.0850289836525917,
-0.3188750743865967,
0.4766065180301666,
0.4201558232307434,
0.3724587857723236,
0.4818134307861328,
0.05367143824696541,
0.7108055949211121,
-0.06202569976449013,
0.0970538854598999,
0.10903450101613998,
-0.07066541165113449,
-0.5777915716171265,
-0.005221816245466471,
0.7450986504554749,
0.6903233528137207,
-0.641514241695404,
0.5657647848129272,
-0.23823407292366028,
-0.2455935776233673,
-0.75180584192276,
-0.059421174228191376,
0.02007490210235119,
0.6986917853355408,
0.35201719403266907,
0.08599669486284256,
-0.3758752644062042,
-0.7204676866531372,
-0.7083837389945984,
-0.11124793440103531,
-0.15066024661064148,
0.479256808757782,
0.23708339035511017,
0.11673810333013535,
0.8565284013748169,
-0.5601980090141296,
-0.30015137791633606,
-0.18979902565479279,
0.15675628185272217,
0.33261752128601074,
0.030160201713442802,
0.6107291579246521,
-0.9691066145896912,
-0.5198462605476379,
0.1522945910692215,
-0.602628767490387,
-0.24598459899425507,
-0.21210555732250214,
-0.2535780966281891,
-0.23325003683567047,
0.7149462699890137,
-0.5286411643028259,
0.4914727509021759,
-0.37082386016845703,
-0.6189826726913452,
0.47338464856147766,
-0.37185007333755493,
0.18953609466552734,
-0.5939182639122009,
0.061848707497119904,
0.17234507203102112,
-0.4942353665828705,
-0.27515584230422974,
0.38428348302841187,
0.4413822591304779,
0.1931833028793335,
-0.651725172996521,
0.20912078022956848,
-0.4133301377296448,
0.07988280057907104,
0.004996997769922018,
0.1638735681772232,
0.0528598427772522,
0.16008709371089935,
-0.12423722445964813,
0.6226471066474915,
0.28199371695518494,
-0.6832512021064758,
-0.03883492574095726,
0.4350505471229553,
-0.4187123477458954,
0.9117201566696167,
-0.44401583075523376,
0.036866359412670135,
-0.24897132813930511,
-0.1552080661058426,
-0.2753419578075409,
0.04384163022041321,
0.1585465967655182,
0.28685426712036133,
0.30297714471817017,
-0.5104830861091614,
-0.7353638410568237,
-0.34312406182289124,
-0.29930469393730164,
0.1390930563211441,
0.3541783392429352,
-0.22829794883728027,
0.27751296758651733,
0.5341132879257202,
-0.03981398418545723,
-0.5833765268325806,
-0.2520228326320648,
-0.22711428999900818,
-0.5779861807823181,
-0.1963205635547638,
0.5585111975669861,
0.19211634993553162,
-0.22657428681850433,
-0.16656479239463806,
-0.11318490654230118,
-0.07538051158189774,
-0.0018944218754768372,
0.08378641307353973,
-0.20568011701107025,
-0.06389318406581879,
0.07226856797933578,
0.3463320732116699,
0.2695901095867157,
0.0012608617544174194,
0.08725012838840485,
0.562146008014679,
0.090403251349926,
-0.5487133860588074,
-0.27191200852394104,
0.33556923270225525,
0.291301429271698,
-0.41885438561439514,
0.29562148451805115,
0.3495883345603943,
-0.03790981322526932,
-0.05893333628773689,
-0.6527646780014038,
-0.013233444653451443,
-0.4435912072658539,
0.3106345236301422,
-0.46437692642211914,
-0.6664485335350037,
0.5237550139427185,
-0.14037327468395233,
0.06323997676372528,
0.6886580586433411,
0.48996618390083313,
-0.2007388025522232,
0.8618554472923279,
0.7003443837165833,
0.02078239433467388,
0.9514168500900269,
-0.0471624955534935,
0.26927483081817627,
-0.6757563948631287,
-0.23484525084495544,
-0.7839348912239075,
-0.046906258910894394,
-0.51661217212677,
-0.04451409727334976,
0.40636950731277466,
0.3752731382846832,
-0.15601672232151031,
0.40256550908088684,
-0.39345690608024597,
0.5780807137489319,
0.5468303561210632,
0.3069961667060852,
0.29959291219711304,
0.07638759911060333,
-0.46396130323410034,
0.08317727595567703,
-0.5094324350357056,
-0.3822530210018158,
1.230332374572754,
0.016698582097887993,
0.5799925923347473,
-0.00037715796497650445,
0.6143432855606079,
0.47870221734046936,
-0.3280205726623535,
-0.6014893651008606,
0.5859655737876892,
-0.2115481048822403,
-0.35035282373428345,
-0.371762752532959,
-0.3078874945640564,
-1.2806823253631592,
0.32398346066474915,
-0.18093456327915192,
-0.695339560508728,
0.6013557314872742,
-0.26804760098457336,
-0.7074385285377502,
-0.01921788975596428,
-0.4740869700908661,
0.6615644693374634,
-0.023758405819535255,
-0.6254319548606873,
-0.3844945430755615,
-0.8303782343864441,
-0.24457016587257385,
-0.16579970717430115,
-0.04801972582936287,
-0.3671715259552002,
0.1654486209154129,
0.5903659462928772,
-0.47134849429130554,
0.10315757989883423,
-0.3372840881347656,
-0.029026834294199944,
0.3910510540008545,
-0.06780505180358887,
0.4489278793334961,
0.09939133375883102,
-0.6162333488464355,
-0.1612015813589096,
0.46546006202697754,
-0.2705248296260834,
-0.48343178629875183,
0.2587573230266571,
-0.3171324133872986,
-0.7595347166061401,
-0.2782890200614929,
-0.3655864894390106,
-0.16802801191806793,
0.5408517718315125,
0.3952755033969879,
0.13160903751850128,
-0.22029224038124084,
0.4074576795101166,
0.5478338003158569,
-0.09978605061769485,
0.5710600018501282,
0.9874860644340515,
0.25853604078292847,
-0.05834455043077469,
0.4160759747028351,
0.41329485177993774,
-0.4420028030872345,
0.568655788898468,
-0.001086415140889585,
-0.5907769203186035,
-0.8034750819206238,
-0.47045865654945374,
0.08535043895244598,
-0.5014657378196716,
-0.40087074041366577,
-0.5408509373664856,
-0.024095740169286728,
-0.4196135401725769,
0.11799631267786026,
-0.05078287795186043,
-0.4010795056819916,
-0.4699016511440277,
-0.2946026027202606,
0.18295888602733612,
0.32397380471229553,
0.13649196922779083,
0.024253729730844498,
-0.8188570737838745,
0.3251143991947174,
0.06564711779356003,
0.3093283474445343,
-0.5374169945716858,
-0.7528866529464722,
-0.14928415417671204,
-0.17780478298664093,
-0.47717323899269104,
-0.8077529072761536,
0.3916524052619934,
0.23391485214233398,
0.6856595873832703,
0.6691075563430786,
0.4912549555301666,
0.9044552445411682,
-0.8871563076972961,
0.6392217874526978,
-0.08449351787567139,
-0.5382760763168335,
0.8784700036048889,
-0.45242711901664734,
-0.022010045126080513,
1.0294162034988403,
0.16535325348377228,
-0.09717173874378204,
-0.2916896343231201,
-0.6322372555732727,
-0.9564040899276733,
0.5509921312332153,
0.05426187068223953,
0.2097412347793579,
-0.01892019994556904,
0.8719164133071899,
0.25207799673080444,
0.30422279238700867,
-0.06731726974248886,
0.12690690159797668,
0.1585199534893036,
-0.15378911793231964,
0.3440798223018646,
-0.21037647128105164,
-0.10608096420764923,
-0.6409047842025757,
0.3701600134372711,
-0.0748838260769844,
0.09886056184768677,
0.3810282349586487,
-0.39840537309646606,
-0.050239257514476776,
0.4783661663532257,
0.2418118566274643,
0.8250418305397034,
-0.3250408172607422,
-0.09172738343477249,
-0.09247788041830063,
-0.3378053605556488,
-0.04228223115205765,
0.43678489327430725,
-0.3742683231830597,
0.06369247287511826,
-0.022318409755825996,
0.5489853620529175,
0.09445027261972427,
-0.8453664779663086,
0.7006019353866577,
-0.26651617884635925,
-0.267823725938797,
-0.0949067622423172,
0.2378581315279007,
-0.46875640749931335,
0.46852508187294006,
0.35078951716423035,
-0.16333666443824768,
0.5701385736465454,
-0.3701663613319397,
0.6403002142906189,
0.3025672435760498,
-0.3311724364757538,
-0.17237170040607452,
0.8530591130256653,
0.04137212783098221,
-0.19955897331237793,
0.6768807768821716,
-0.0627097561955452,
-0.08504519611597061,
0.26155367493629456,
0.24614772200584412,
0.559034526348114,
0.2822857201099396,
0.2530515789985657,
0.10818258672952652,
-0.21633467078208923,
-0.22333355247974396,
0.3327867090702057,
-0.45456427335739136,
-0.5120568871498108,
-0.13353358209133148,
-0.5050455331802368,
-0.2735443115234375,
-0.1072041466832161,
-1.1180797815322876,
0.4282341003417969,
-0.2469567507505417,
-0.3247765898704529,
0.0843493714928627,
0.16067293286323547,
-0.9573001265525818,
-0.0649496391415596,
-0.17963807284832,
0.9971888661384583,
-0.4467083811759949,
0.8397586941719055,
0.43237224221229553,
-0.4522315561771393,
-0.5824775099754333,
0.047487642616033554,
-0.31168249249458313,
-0.572564959526062,
0.22111141681671143,
-0.21443457901477814,
0.28930801153182983,
-0.15482866764068604,
-0.3618946373462677,
-0.301620751619339,
1.0630974769592285,
0.8550572395324707,
-1.0870131254196167,
-0.14868758618831635,
0.3739059269428253,
0.7866443991661072,
0.0678454115986824,
0.19979824125766754,
0.9457343816757202,
0.12649330496788025,
0.11448534578084946,
-0.7102464437484741,
-0.03430837765336037,
-0.16647560894489288,
-0.3559085428714752,
0.31872597336769104,
-0.5586338639259338,
0.5434454679489136,
0.1069677397608757,
-0.12817861139774323,
-0.06687470525503159,
0.30253472924232483,
0.24555931985378265,
0.29586249589920044,
0.3675181567668915,
0.7609835267066956,
1.1024240255355835,
-0.02222362533211708,
1.2652063369750977,
-0.7053652405738831,
0.4416317641735077,
1.0993458032608032,
-0.4763681888580322,
1.0928640365600586,
0.6528956294059753,
-0.01833117939531803,
0.33156245946884155,
0.7599925994873047,
-0.15420807898044586,
0.8610603213310242,
-0.04048030450940132,
-0.20873834192752838,
-0.2905825078487396,
-0.1653698980808258,
-0.3189232647418976,
0.32280275225639343,
0.2455340474843979,
-0.6813729405403137,
-0.4653674066066742,
-0.22943520545959473,
-0.21245823800563812,
-0.039890117943286896,
-0.3976476788520813,
1.065406084060669,
0.00610679155215621,
-0.7952197790145874,
0.07628492265939713,
0.05214259400963783,
0.21077272295951843,
-0.1293853521347046,
-0.08404742181301117,
-0.3939726948738098,
0.13823454082012177,
-0.13843820989131927,
-0.9081069827079773,
0.23750226199626923,
0.18493545055389404,
-0.07287000864744186,
-0.35315629839897156,
0.8657811880111694,
-0.09612341225147247,
-0.33982565999031067,
0.0679933950304985,
0.6330813765525818,
0.12664636969566345,
-0.3175034523010254,
-0.9992496371269226,
-0.3954017162322998,
0.10224910825490952,
-0.3661167323589325,
0.41923537850379944,
0.9820752143859863,
-0.08096832036972046,
0.23473027348518372,
0.5304754972457886,
0.23951110243797302,
0.3261858820915222,
0.38621169328689575,
0.7069955468177795,
-0.857806384563446,
-0.5497334599494934,
-0.8144194483757019,
0.2660599946975708,
-0.31818127632141113,
-0.2643318176269531,
0.5619672536849976,
0.5872817635536194,
0.6323798298835754,
0.08564607053995132,
0.47828570008277893,
-0.01658027246594429,
0.4564371109008789,
-0.6666165590286255,
0.6493667960166931,
-0.3637336790561676,
0.4121416509151459,
-0.06794925779104233,
-0.9209427833557129,
-0.26867857575416565,
0.5127121210098267,
-0.548373281955719,
-0.4209643006324768,
0.41474685072898865,
0.6217194199562073,
-0.2679308354854584,
-0.036712922155857086,
0.30807358026504517,
-0.13330678641796112,
0.3193212151527405,
0.13504481315612793,
0.5663988590240479,
-0.4420015513896942,
0.5177211165428162,
-0.011067681945860386,
0.42457500100135803,
-0.3470512330532074,
-0.7774577140808105,
-0.6044835448265076,
-0.1221637949347496,
-0.29145005345344543,
-0.13004212081432343,
0.12612317502498627,
0.4925196170806885,
0.7868562340736389,
-0.8192408680915833,
0.22883503139019012,
-0.4902288615703583,
0.04207323119044304,
0.1011182889342308,
-0.24995221197605133,
0.489816278219223,
-0.42619600892066956,
-0.5513996481895447,
0.23451633751392365,
0.16034886240959167,
-0.21987664699554443,
0.3813154101371765,
0.29625600576400757,
-0.220041424036026,
0.15469859540462494,
0.539367139339447,
0.3790615200996399,
-0.4306521713733673,
-0.4636198878288269,
-0.3359664976596832,
0.04330664128065109,
0.4513726234436035,
1.0589011907577515,
-0.6211166381835938,
0.41183996200561523,
0.604965329170227,
0.7022880911827087,
0.9191468954086304,
0.38818737864494324,
0.5875703692436218,
-0.8840214610099792,
0.25902941823005676,
0.40773579478263855,
0.6849638819694519,
-0.04921964183449745,
-0.33001357316970825,
0.648004949092865,
-0.021685918793082237,
-0.5994340777397156,
-0.7941413521766663,
-0.06053347513079643,
-0.8799143433570862,
-0.2360350787639618,
1.0694191455841064,
-0.19278110563755035,
-0.17697419226169586,
-0.19495801627635956,
-0.23498012125492096,
0.246828094124794,
-0.447468101978302,
0.8582847714424133,
0.49597302079200745,
-0.3998682200908661,
-0.26353198289871216,
-0.6408230662345886,
0.3775160014629364,
0.5088556408882141,
-0.6787348389625549,
-0.16886989772319794,
0.570625364780426,
0.5005409121513367,
-0.09682513773441315,
0.45206141471862793,
-0.42936253547668457,
-0.0007810465176589787,
-0.2799701988697052,
-0.36368948221206665,
0.3711957037448883,
-0.14491704106330872,
-0.4525904655456543,
0.7255471348762512,
-0.1816561222076416,
-0.158731147646904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00594v1
|
LexAbSumm: Aspect-based Summarization of Legal Decisions
| 2024-03-31T08:00:40 | 2024-03-31T08:00:40 |
T. Y. S. S Santosh, Mahmoud Aly, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Legal professionals frequently encounter long legal judgments that hold
critical insights for their work. While recent advances have led to automated
summarization solutions for legal documents, they typically provide generic
summaries, which may not meet the diverse information needs of users. To
address this gap, we introduce LexAbSumm, a novel dataset designed for
aspect-based summarization of legal case decisions, sourced from the European
Court of Human Rights jurisdiction. We evaluate several abstractive
summarization models tailored for longer documents on LexAbSumm, revealing a
challenge in conditioning these models to produce aspect-specific summaries. We
release LexAbSum to facilitate research in aspect-based summarization for legal
domain.
|
[
-0.21808773279190063,
-0.40435612201690674,
0.935871422290802,
0.1469365507364273,
-0.49021756649017334,
0.0007865586085245013,
-0.10665740072727203,
-0.3809172809123993,
0.5041916966438293,
0.9009715914726257,
-0.19966259598731995,
-0.9803766012191772,
-0.4177738428115845,
-0.1863810420036316,
-0.4047382175922394,
1.1812411546707153,
0.0517733171582222,
0.0847872644662857,
-0.5223983526229858,
-0.768309473991394,
-0.3988729417324066,
-0.7554775476455688,
-0.44652634859085083,
-0.220712810754776,
0.3548492193222046,
0.5318914651870728,
0.6957522630691528,
0.2872622609138489,
0.568863570690155,
0.23212188482284546,
-0.4568277597427368,
-0.07646934688091278,
0.06828929483890533,
0.14998416602611542,
-0.4111204743385315,
-0.6210489869117737,
-0.9873817563056946,
-0.33382976055145264,
0.5400827527046204,
0.7763836979866028,
-0.404009073972702,
0.14572308957576752,
-0.3358975946903229,
1.0296857357025146,
-0.4838539958000183,
-0.002578308340162039,
-0.057723890990018845,
0.2920473515987396,
-0.023577971383929253,
-0.003969720099121332,
-0.3325592279434204,
-0.44956615567207336,
-0.19310997426509857,
-0.5037274360656738,
0.6129626631736755,
0.2322552502155304,
0.49153780937194824,
0.2607610523700714,
-0.5320002436637878,
-0.37964388728141785,
-0.7316072583198547,
0.42726874351501465,
-1.0112303495407104,
0.07173056155443192,
0.39462509751319885,
0.2524506449699402,
0.01815430261194706,
-0.7374266982078552,
-0.3915092647075653,
0.032569389790296555,
-0.34795674681663513,
0.42571645975112915,
-0.08739486336708069,
0.3217218816280365,
0.22435390949249268,
0.2746381163597107,
-0.4669998586177826,
0.1501825898885727,
-0.3883952796459198,
-0.3565632700920105,
0.7911095023155212,
0.5033501386642456,
0.24896441400051117,
-0.5557535886764526,
0.06022779643535614,
0.11717578023672104,
-0.7619789242744446,
0.22828026115894318,
0.4725055694580078,
0.39272022247314453,
-0.12018650025129318,
0.6604384779930115,
-0.2182336002588272,
0.5905498266220093,
-0.07748477905988693,
-0.0767941027879715,
0.050473470240831375,
-0.2522240877151489,
-0.00955645926296711,
0.5111807584762573,
0.5431414246559143,
0.6922315955162048,
-0.4148581624031067,
0.021146414801478386,
-0.47110795974731445,
-0.6053186058998108,
0.2047034502029419,
-1.0241539478302002,
-0.0026558421086519957,
0.6992091536521912,
-0.6440574526786804,
0.022927558049559593,
0.4188407063484192,
-0.6259714365005493,
-0.6131078600883484,
-0.6221433877944946,
-0.11806327104568481,
-0.5068385004997253,
0.03937865421175957,
0.18024004995822906,
-0.3132203221321106,
0.060409557074308395,
0.6158546805381775,
-0.5366758704185486,
0.5117962956428528,
0.974087119102478,
0.8807600736618042,
-0.1582321971654892,
0.15906201303005219,
-0.5272446870803833,
0.1033785492181778,
-0.37461698055267334,
0.6829907894134521,
-0.6332392692565918,
-0.7929452657699585,
0.1007225438952446,
0.09978470951318741,
0.38324302434921265,
-0.6594351530075073,
0.7006766200065613,
-0.4848848283290863,
0.0017701199976727366,
-0.3680603802204132,
-0.9046061635017395,
-0.4919726848602295,
0.07680154591798782,
-0.6334889531135559,
0.3473125994205475,
0.008193975314497948,
-0.7841695547103882,
0.8038485050201416,
-0.8249114155769348,
-0.8937118053436279,
0.29508623480796814,
-0.47601988911628723,
-0.7360841035842896,
0.5032943487167358,
0.06265535950660706,
0.3916797339916229,
0.15550149977207184,
0.2810460329055786,
-0.11108741164207458,
-0.09634266793727875,
0.06307277828454971,
0.223924458026886,
0.6280102729797363,
0.3436840772628784,
0.058432687073946,
0.48490357398986816,
-0.4399029314517975,
-0.5084356665611267,
-0.06872528046369553,
-0.1270306259393692,
-0.6562422513961792,
0.3997730016708374,
0.13896048069000244,
0.15749649703502655,
0.43506497144699097,
-0.4826435446739197,
0.030403809621930122,
0.0031462660990655422,
0.4177433252334595,
0.39740583300590515,
0.1800253838300705,
0.3430681526660919,
-0.6012402176856995,
0.8329208493232727,
0.07659228146076202,
0.009869260713458061,
-0.45181453227996826,
-0.20951658487319946,
-0.5950526595115662,
-0.09722620993852615,
0.5387744307518005,
0.3440735936164856,
-0.35602855682373047,
0.5227115154266357,
-0.4470423460006714,
-0.3406442105770111,
-0.4186561703681946,
-0.05746656656265259,
0.2724948525428772,
0.2829478979110718,
0.2682223916053772,
-0.35018858313560486,
-0.4304285943508148,
-1.0837798118591309,
-0.2477818876504898,
-0.2798502743244171,
0.04663484916090965,
0.37444692850112915,
0.7549998760223389,
-0.029909152537584305,
1.3508002758026123,
-0.35874009132385254,
-0.5093175172805786,
-0.7706897258758545,
0.4582178294658661,
0.3500533699989319,
0.2312239110469818,
0.7513770461082458,
-0.993378758430481,
-0.04934079945087433,
-0.05637901648879051,
-0.6212506294250488,
0.09445857256650925,
-0.45312073826789856,
0.2977214455604553,
0.15792717039585114,
0.6815770864486694,
-0.22740405797958374,
0.5734550952911377,
-0.014249807223677635,
-0.6545912623405457,
0.5900743007659912,
-0.6741200685501099,
0.33499687910079956,
-1.163049578666687,
-0.012629120610654354,
-0.07336155325174332,
-0.942762553691864,
-0.21127837896347046,
0.11580146849155426,
0.40433579683303833,
-0.032236285507678986,
-0.8005303144454956,
0.3657297194004059,
-0.25786522030830383,
-0.41013893485069275,
-0.4045616388320923,
0.08320296555757523,
0.0867186114192009,
0.26453906297683716,
0.2626248002052307,
0.613466203212738,
0.13112947344779968,
-0.6700403094291687,
0.07903550565242767,
0.456211656332016,
-0.35586926341056824,
0.8724753856658936,
-0.5953205227851868,
-0.22800253331661224,
-0.37593749165534973,
0.373150497674942,
-0.2274055778980255,
-0.4583508372306824,
-0.20619580149650574,
-0.19524015486240387,
0.2711595892906189,
-0.38643649220466614,
-0.5550941824913025,
-0.27391546964645386,
-0.4649715721607208,
0.5508432984352112,
0.3671768307685852,
-0.15408089756965637,
0.9713364839553833,
0.600373387336731,
-0.6410137414932251,
-0.13040868937969208,
-0.5547240376472473,
0.37790241837501526,
-0.396339476108551,
-0.1792064905166626,
0.5341678261756897,
0.09265314042568207,
-0.5230714082717896,
0.31967759132385254,
-0.06801557540893555,
0.15116047859191895,
-0.061396557837724686,
0.7635050415992737,
-0.09071595966815948,
0.022265156731009483,
0.03178612142801285,
0.5115689635276794,
0.22111688554286957,
0.33264726400375366,
0.2195497453212738,
0.3050772547721863,
-0.09032819420099258,
-0.7911845445632935,
-0.3723722994327545,
0.6926472783088684,
0.4648233950138092,
-0.02461542934179306,
0.163027822971344,
-0.0830516368150711,
-0.39451947808265686,
-0.05538465827703476,
-0.33000898361206055,
0.12774839997291565,
-0.3455876410007477,
0.5463711023330688,
-0.2168542444705963,
-0.6728121042251587,
0.8470920324325562,
0.13389469683170319,
0.4387170672416687,
0.664581835269928,
0.4677145481109619,
-0.1447516828775406,
0.6384034752845764,
0.516491174697876,
-0.24445174634456635,
0.38002800941467285,
-0.08713505417108536,
0.030505623668432236,
-0.8440669775009155,
-0.3235524594783783,
-0.3186325132846832,
-0.18136465549468994,
-0.18574874103069305,
-0.12559108436107635,
0.42785197496414185,
-0.22864237427711487,
0.14146588742733002,
0.28995010256767273,
-0.016161499544978142,
0.5730714201927185,
0.39271536469459534,
0.20130275189876556,
0.581256628036499,
-0.5506393909454346,
0.033475469797849655,
0.15707433223724365,
-0.5631442070007324,
-0.6124890446662903,
1.059453010559082,
0.16109448671340942,
0.4385157525539398,
0.41765570640563965,
0.9189870357513428,
0.8764687776565552,
0.23960700631141663,
-0.8893548846244812,
0.6512587666511536,
-0.24952572584152222,
-0.3748898208141327,
-0.19590459764003754,
-0.39840149879455566,
-0.9765579700469971,
0.02370613068342209,
-0.004004228860139847,
-0.2980906367301941,
0.2007966786623001,
-0.12383358925580978,
-0.8944571614265442,
0.3426440358161926,
-0.22918374836444855,
0.43176040053367615,
-0.1306786686182022,
-0.15479253232479095,
-0.5080500245094299,
-0.6304720044136047,
0.28567278385162354,
-0.11851608008146286,
0.7088429927825928,
-0.38954636454582214,
-0.04267328977584839,
1.1073776483535767,
-0.95842045545578,
0.596608579158783,
-0.14343933761119843,
0.10454431176185608,
0.40412071347236633,
0.18653912842273712,
0.15698394179344177,
0.42826977372169495,
0.16487523913383484,
-0.14952434599399567,
0.11523478478193283,
-0.42424970865249634,
-0.4386751651763916,
0.41870808601379395,
-0.3355448842048645,
-0.8174722790718079,
-0.694955050945282,
-0.6325283050537109,
0.009902553632855415,
0.28386440873146057,
0.17006149888038635,
0.5364054441452026,
-0.507953405380249,
0.049807608127593994,
0.2530832886695862,
-0.11148539185523987,
0.6401678323745728,
0.8852707147598267,
-0.4947626292705536,
-0.3767009377479553,
0.8235000371932983,
0.15614014863967896,
-0.17615869641304016,
0.23037676513195038,
-0.06327394396066666,
-0.3425564765930176,
-0.8468579053878784,
-0.2551591098308563,
0.17602436244487762,
-0.8093253970146179,
-0.2560814321041107,
-0.3652384281158447,
-0.1394340842962265,
-0.434810608625412,
-0.2032422423362732,
-0.2516883909702301,
-0.7500066161155701,
-0.007845507934689522,
-0.26368024945259094,
0.2475994974374771,
0.9881088733673096,
0.01941170170903206,
-0.06613264977931976,
-0.8774248957633972,
0.4738154411315918,
0.23276634514331818,
0.2153560221195221,
-0.5031124949455261,
-0.599241316318512,
-0.2196415662765503,
-0.14491599798202515,
-0.12931276857852936,
-0.4923405647277832,
0.4128429889678955,
0.1108051985502243,
0.2930738925933838,
0.5558611154556274,
0.3167690932750702,
0.37615567445755005,
-0.47266829013824463,
0.8505022525787354,
0.16469664871692657,
-0.7999983429908752,
0.7936407327651978,
-0.19304804503917694,
0.19166693091392517,
0.8132072687149048,
0.07019785046577454,
-0.6338849067687988,
-0.5848374366760254,
-0.7609176635742188,
-1.236687183380127,
0.6063334345817566,
0.2938289940357208,
0.1959710717201233,
0.277262419462204,
0.5581733584403992,
0.32712340354919434,
0.12731918692588806,
0.011589694768190384,
-0.019401216879487038,
-0.13699103891849518,
-0.18665772676467896,
-0.14125578105449677,
-0.2095724195241928,
-0.16438712179660797,
-0.23669558763504028,
0.626548171043396,
0.15588615834712982,
-0.24507488310337067,
0.35727524757385254,
-0.4773775041103363,
0.48685723543167114,
0.47056007385253906,
0.7852519154548645,
0.9350703954696655,
-0.46250906586647034,
0.033813901245594025,
0.003140995278954506,
-0.47217774391174316,
0.10576865077018738,
0.059058740735054016,
-0.31870290637016296,
0.411175936460495,
0.4426761269569397,
0.6469116806983948,
0.051990412175655365,
-0.7932467460632324,
0.6987592577934265,
-0.44351425766944885,
-0.36495742201805115,
-0.7423519492149353,
0.07640901952981949,
-0.09207095950841904,
0.1899905949831009,
0.20189520716667175,
-0.08884089440107346,
0.5102569460868835,
-0.46104124188423157,
0.29977503418922424,
-0.11799073219299316,
-0.4134824275970459,
-0.20108970999717712,
0.8479610681533813,
0.3594026267528534,
-0.2895318865776062,
0.2930837571620941,
-0.37400197982788086,
-0.2311895787715912,
0.876354455947876,
-0.04427405446767807,
0.8999183773994446,
0.1530596911907196,
0.16894638538360596,
0.18874448537826538,
-0.2232537418603897,
-0.2404763549566269,
0.14088664948940277,
-0.26216793060302734,
-0.281757116317749,
-0.339081346988678,
-0.47587183117866516,
-0.9158011674880981,
-0.20684735476970673,
-1.0953304767608643,
0.17866607010364532,
-0.45514968037605286,
-0.3002653121948242,
0.014077623374760151,
-0.3344334661960602,
-0.41264596581459045,
0.07400841265916824,
-0.10239964723587036,
0.8320842385292053,
-0.638956606388092,
0.5690997242927551,
0.6730023622512817,
-0.4925702214241028,
-0.03311752527952194,
-0.10356871038675308,
0.10366474837064743,
-0.36216863989830017,
0.13736814260482788,
0.05409202352166176,
0.09906472265720367,
-0.6126447916030884,
-0.13491451740264893,
-0.05416654050350189,
1.1568363904953003,
0.1339409202337265,
-0.7687652111053467,
0.005044015124440193,
0.39054372906684875,
0.3699458837509155,
-0.3246450424194336,
0.025992736220359802,
0.8015409708023071,
0.36319997906684875,
0.07360416650772095,
-0.3559596836566925,
0.14352333545684814,
-0.35170674324035645,
0.009318213909864426,
0.1819743663072586,
-0.4991728961467743,
0.44291940331459045,
-0.550153911113739,
-0.0667116567492485,
-0.15806840360164642,
1.0476250648498535,
0.1759406328201294,
0.42430564761161804,
0.4125286638736725,
0.5952372550964355,
0.8201935887336731,
-0.0639810636639595,
1.1098787784576416,
-0.5754983425140381,
0.2839004099369049,
1.6940745115280151,
-0.1751413494348526,
0.7180752158164978,
0.2983264923095703,
-0.14616961777210236,
0.3672068119049072,
0.8211299777030945,
0.10881813615560532,
0.29774537682533264,
0.0004322018940001726,
-0.20413270592689514,
-0.4525796175003052,
-0.04919783025979996,
-0.17100641131401062,
0.05388412997126579,
0.5212698578834534,
-0.34863176941871643,
-0.31636032462120056,
-0.19306132197380066,
0.21216697990894318,
0.31498461961746216,
-0.6220315098762512,
1.035494089126587,
0.17581087350845337,
-0.4998185336589813,
-0.29065394401550293,
0.18208079040050507,
0.37552809715270996,
-0.16318351030349731,
0.16903375089168549,
-0.6700701117515564,
-0.15313680469989777,
-0.5074948668479919,
-1.0465093851089478,
0.5350003242492676,
0.161817267537117,
-0.3079301714897156,
-0.01148265227675438,
0.15429487824440002,
-0.20388175547122955,
-0.8117769956588745,
-0.03457454964518547,
0.24291092157363892,
0.21203219890594482,
-0.24512465298175812,
-0.4627181589603424,
-0.36048415303230286,
-0.36201831698417664,
-0.19601836800575256,
0.2974834144115448,
0.5366348624229431,
-0.278275728225708,
0.6171693205833435,
0.1936415731906891,
0.3155750334262848,
-0.27343621850013733,
0.470788836479187,
0.5521044731140137,
-0.9856250882148743,
-0.8061139583587646,
-0.8592051267623901,
0.4064699113368988,
-0.3113081753253937,
-0.19697575271129608,
0.43137431144714355,
1.138741374015808,
0.32520467042922974,
0.27598798274993896,
1.0550318956375122,
-0.06977523118257523,
0.42037805914878845,
-0.8522515296936035,
0.8421148061752319,
-0.5525224208831787,
0.2696671783924103,
0.12589067220687866,
-0.6643788814544678,
-0.4739593267440796,
-0.016536574810743332,
-0.1693737506866455,
-0.1742309182882309,
0.5157439112663269,
0.38100770115852356,
-0.1463921070098877,
-0.027805985882878304,
0.30989938974380493,
-0.049068812280893326,
0.4588526487350464,
0.3908631205558777,
0.34876054525375366,
0.011277813464403152,
0.1563543975353241,
-0.14967216551303864,
0.03939029946923256,
-0.632028341293335,
-0.8610237240791321,
-0.8854750394821167,
-0.6224036812782288,
-0.45138439536094666,
-0.051057953387498856,
-0.11076783388853073,
0.9343864321708679,
0.47578421235084534,
-1.08066987991333,
-0.20443207025527954,
-0.18648916482925415,
0.23234251141548157,
0.04814454913139343,
-0.19482693076133728,
0.6680475473403931,
-0.48841387033462524,
-0.5531513690948486,
-0.025804514065384865,
0.3664873242378235,
0.2954265773296356,
0.15772509574890137,
-0.1951771080493927,
0.3681926727294922,
0.3174666166305542,
0.5014998912811279,
0.37815386056900024,
-0.625149130821228,
-0.034196510910987854,
-0.752016007900238,
-0.02488856576383114,
0.4058831036090851,
1.2352478504180908,
-0.237280935049057,
0.44610634446144104,
0.3286290168762207,
0.36778226494789124,
0.7368729114532471,
0.3191515803337097,
0.6328825354576111,
-0.5906867980957031,
0.4141148030757904,
0.43129637837409973,
1.0404256582260132,
0.17863164842128754,
-0.12884104251861572,
0.3174820840358734,
-0.1655801236629486,
-0.24955061078071594,
-0.42275097966194153,
0.06959205865859985,
-1.118369698524475,
-0.4891175627708435,
1.180227518081665,
-0.3626330494880676,
-0.3709145188331604,
-0.24531176686286926,
-0.30052661895751953,
0.046438079327344894,
-0.7786984443664551,
0.829418420791626,
0.598482608795166,
-0.2319786548614502,
0.20225146412849426,
-0.4109312891960144,
0.5394405126571655,
0.38460981845855713,
-1.022305965423584,
0.20334099233150482,
0.7747130393981934,
0.26803067326545715,
0.10788365453481674,
0.4511089324951172,
-0.3109928369522095,
0.3541184067726135,
-0.33573541045188904,
0.2524634897708893,
-0.35613566637039185,
-0.2776167392730713,
-0.44289618730545044,
0.4636286199092865,
-0.02780269831418991,
0.005124310031533241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00590v1
|
CuSINeS: Curriculum-driven Structure Induced Negative Sampling for Statutory Article Retrieval
| 2024-03-31T07:49:23 | 2024-03-31T07:49:23 |
T. Y. S. S Santosh, Kristina Kaiser, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce CuSINeS, a negative sampling approach to enhance
the performance of Statutory Article Retrieval (SAR). CuSINeS offers three key
contributions. Firstly, it employs a curriculum-based negative sampling
strategy guiding the model to focus on easier negatives initially and
progressively tackle more difficult ones. Secondly, it leverages the
hierarchical and sequential information derived from the structural
organization of statutes to evaluate the difficulty of samples. Lastly, it
introduces a dynamic semantic difficulty assessment using the being-trained
model itself, surpassing conventional static methods like BM25, adapting the
negatives to the model's evolving competence. Experimental results on a
real-world expert-annotated SAR dataset validate the effectiveness of CuSINeS
across four different baselines, demonstrating its versatility.
|
[
-0.3541938066482544,
-0.9332946538925171,
0.7025697231292725,
0.13160015642642975,
-0.3631240129470825,
0.11800385266542435,
-0.24684704840183258,
-0.3810708224773407,
0.225764662027359,
0.31957584619522095,
-0.44096001982688904,
-0.5412566065788269,
-0.7248131632804871,
0.07078725099563599,
-0.7857896685600281,
0.9701261520385742,
0.3803289532661438,
0.3887670636177063,
-0.004789072088897228,
0.015933217480778694,
-0.5894463658332825,
-0.2487165331840515,
-0.7610683441162109,
-0.20303839445114136,
0.5293305516242981,
0.3639235496520996,
0.3362431526184082,
0.13729943335056305,
0.4329870045185089,
0.2356746643781662,
-0.33729445934295654,
-0.0424157939851284,
-0.4652549624443054,
0.3199409544467926,
-0.5230235457420349,
-0.7460992336273193,
-0.06140558794140816,
0.3372969627380371,
0.25711435079574585,
0.5749632716178894,
-0.3088743984699249,
0.287788987159729,
-0.09505650401115417,
0.6150072813034058,
-1.1438533067703247,
-0.055203117430210114,
-0.8493691086769104,
0.008102080784738064,
-0.6472452878952026,
-0.3939814567565918,
-0.42818018794059753,
-0.46980732679367065,
0.4113834500312805,
-0.406526654958725,
0.7113568782806396,
0.11901678889989853,
0.7660945653915405,
-0.028117569163441658,
-0.8010225892066956,
-0.4967063069343567,
-0.332457035779953,
0.8763309121131897,
-0.6448447108268738,
0.5297257900238037,
0.5362280607223511,
0.35409048199653625,
-0.14251278340816498,
-0.5830418467521667,
-0.5006255507469177,
-0.7301666736602783,
0.16301053762435913,
-0.10609886795282364,
0.3062330186367035,
-0.11382954567670822,
0.22056269645690918,
0.581583559513092,
-0.36870038509368896,
0.1215495616197586,
-0.7673639059066772,
-0.18350353837013245,
0.6797573566436768,
0.18172606825828552,
0.3713728189468384,
-0.46186360716819763,
-0.18107976019382477,
-0.2029409557580948,
-0.9881982803344727,
0.28255951404571533,
0.5706928968429565,
0.2804345190525055,
-0.1859877109527588,
1.0287810564041138,
-0.07633604109287262,
0.5199307203292847,
0.4910619854927063,
0.1531451791524887,
0.1991552710533142,
-0.04912691190838814,
-0.17321376502513885,
0.12986385822296143,
0.17331580817699432,
-0.22842885553836823,
-0.10923099517822266,
-0.23379014432430267,
-0.31755688786506653,
0.3578627407550812,
0.6351688504219055,
-0.635819673538208,
-0.3405408561229706,
0.244413360953331,
-0.12398035824298859,
-0.5219207406044006,
0.16715991497039795,
-0.8720245957374573,
-0.5731778144836426,
-0.8090217709541321,
0.5058181285858154,
-0.6819074153900146,
0.14256393909454346,
-0.010672801174223423,
-0.4563324749469757,
0.25553014874458313,
0.40047532320022583,
-0.6719009876251221,
0.5745559930801392,
0.7958177924156189,
0.7079657912254333,
-0.4580034911632538,
0.2027071863412857,
-0.9293460845947266,
0.06663425266742706,
-0.39303871989250183,
0.9220239520072937,
-0.765340268611908,
-0.24662676453590393,
-0.24602003395557404,
0.09426859021186829,
-0.19538860023021698,
-0.5290042757987976,
0.7141486406326294,
-0.8881054520606995,
-0.04857971519231796,
-0.18426613509655,
-0.44065600633621216,
-0.25251713395118713,
0.5834389925003052,
-0.7984257340431213,
1.0440131425857544,
0.4787011444568634,
-0.5360219478607178,
0.4360167384147644,
-0.3249059319496155,
-0.5448200702667236,
-0.09888731688261032,
-0.4594304859638214,
-0.7593963146209717,
0.430477112531662,
-0.007556420750916004,
0.1632445603609085,
-0.2269413024187088,
0.1945197433233261,
-0.5255308747291565,
-0.40407484769821167,
-0.08165054768323898,
-0.3514270782470703,
1.1098452806472778,
0.39355191588401794,
-0.5655518174171448,
0.08296670764684677,
-0.7131432890892029,
0.05863047018647194,
-0.18094953894615173,
-0.09077412635087967,
-0.7359313368797302,
0.1262608766555786,
-0.1805010288953781,
0.09179519861936569,
0.0842190757393837,
-0.7610685229301453,
-0.11838903278112411,
-0.48919638991355896,
0.24931664764881134,
0.557873010635376,
0.4864436984062195,
0.6970824003219604,
-0.4769834578037262,
0.385964035987854,
0.326638787984848,
0.14234298467636108,
0.31450173258781433,
-0.286819726228714,
-0.5975446105003357,
-0.040964677929878235,
0.18897590041160583,
0.6382410526275635,
-0.7668979167938232,
0.01685861498117447,
0.05948282778263092,
-0.9975559711456299,
-0.17732279002666473,
0.31851065158843994,
0.41880038380622864,
0.5861626267433167,
0.5709915161132812,
-0.5238931179046631,
-0.5291348695755005,
-0.5972381830215454,
0.09531562775373459,
0.011435571126639843,
0.2608182430267334,
0.08663654327392578,
0.686465322971344,
0.08585408329963684,
0.434827595949173,
-0.5022071003913879,
-0.41731488704681396,
0.0014294128632172942,
0.3490276038646698,
0.19428135454654694,
0.4543282389640808,
0.5339065194129944,
-1.2352560758590698,
-0.2271711379289627,
-0.5687505006790161,
-0.3941403329372406,
-0.05144030228257179,
-0.0710185095667839,
-0.15308386087417603,
0.33014976978302,
0.21060599386692047,
-0.49059316515922546,
0.6861023306846619,
0.17318491637706757,
-0.25702542066574097,
1.02418851852417,
-0.16570335626602173,
0.32645919919013977,
-0.632085382938385,
-0.13863129913806915,
0.316516250371933,
0.3685972988605499,
-0.2775876820087433,
0.3991740047931671,
0.41119372844696045,
-0.15587347745895386,
-0.6999834775924683,
0.305327445268631,
-0.7673314809799194,
0.1767292618751526,
-0.00902277510613203,
0.0965026393532753,
0.1468547284603119,
0.3033595681190491,
0.07936710864305496,
1.1319146156311035,
0.20986667275428772,
-0.9898895025253296,
0.18733473122119904,
0.24184049665927887,
-0.3885311782360077,
1.1717764139175415,
-0.4429054260253906,
-0.18348488211631775,
-0.352603942155838,
0.03576528653502464,
-0.7984479665756226,
-0.08408454060554504,
-0.09991002082824707,
-0.14641012251377106,
0.5965768694877625,
-0.12091363221406937,
-0.042011894285678864,
-0.4649895429611206,
-0.8941426873207092,
0.35170820355415344,
0.007238829042762518,
-0.08967883139848709,
0.28766459226608276,
0.6509784460067749,
-0.023708723485469818,
-0.4868849813938141,
-0.6307753920555115,
0.26389896869659424,
-0.24394828081130981,
-0.318629652261734,
0.5651546120643616,
0.06941474229097366,
-0.3777099847793579,
0.23012839257717133,
-0.3117918074131012,
-0.3373205065727234,
0.15095371007919312,
0.1324739307165146,
0.2241140455007553,
-0.3184363543987274,
0.13668693602085114,
0.18089258670806885,
0.22870904207229614,
-0.043759796768426895,
0.055913154035806656,
0.5449782013893127,
-0.0878186896443367,
-0.7000581622123718,
-0.4925272762775421,
0.25750553607940674,
0.22122949361801147,
-0.5791624188423157,
0.31967124342918396,
0.3320402503013611,
-0.4061910808086395,
-0.11703947186470032,
-0.9764150381088257,
-0.1998392939567566,
-0.443660706281662,
0.19989624619483948,
-0.34813135862350464,
-0.635000467300415,
0.2510819435119629,
0.2739796042442322,
-0.11238448321819305,
0.496273398399353,
0.4809361696243286,
-0.18077057600021362,
0.5060157179832458,
0.4984937012195587,
0.16107280552387238,
0.5311164855957031,
-0.5573408007621765,
0.06277123093605042,
-0.9934431314468384,
-0.4662986099720001,
-0.8854781985282898,
-0.24022698402404785,
-0.5252242684364319,
-0.3617456257343292,
0.5685001611709595,
-0.029992228373885155,
-0.4488038122653961,
0.7201749086380005,
-0.5322115421295166,
0.08839753270149231,
0.6496567726135254,
0.5897458791732788,
0.2057024985551834,
-0.012253417633473873,
-0.022905675694346428,
-0.2185421586036682,
-0.30699479579925537,
-0.44176527857780457,
1.0095821619033813,
-0.35610195994377136,
0.9457862973213196,
0.47771626710891724,
0.9343881011009216,
0.4423484802246094,
0.4571399986743927,
-0.879289448261261,
0.5769113898277283,
-0.23288677632808685,
-0.8462467789649963,
-0.3543841540813446,
-0.2731035053730011,
-0.9821999073028564,
-0.11587658524513245,
-0.44762933254241943,
-0.7023685574531555,
0.5679004192352295,
-0.21044935286045074,
-0.5930904746055603,
0.2541574537754059,
-0.8381065130233765,
0.2851075232028961,
-0.2604462504386902,
-0.6302781701087952,
-0.5742700099945068,
-0.42246514558792114,
0.3681606352329254,
-0.22603540122509003,
-0.07312493771314621,
-0.0961010754108429,
-0.2569196820259094,
0.6052038073539734,
-0.2590717077255249,
0.8708188533782959,
-0.264975905418396,
0.03203277662396431,
0.8566383123397827,
0.4888025224208832,
0.4265270233154297,
0.2532578408718109,
-0.5446844696998596,
-0.21117530763149261,
0.4879211187362671,
-0.37530314922332764,
-0.835658073425293,
0.7540625929832458,
-0.5471906065940857,
-0.8921012282371521,
-0.6249750852584839,
-0.4329336881637573,
-0.16235432028770447,
0.22461391985416412,
-0.05007680505514145,
0.8683744072914124,
-0.06471295654773712,
0.3707854449748993,
0.7157445549964905,
-0.07806005328893661,
0.22268934547901154,
0.6790025234222412,
0.5198315978050232,
-0.2992050349712372,
0.7953737378120422,
0.8253568410873413,
-0.1320050209760666,
0.5219410061836243,
0.030449070036411285,
-0.5814970135688782,
-0.8271998763084412,
-0.2378012239933014,
0.12837301194667816,
-0.30177927017211914,
-0.3873395621776581,
-0.5296146273612976,
-0.3802667558193207,
-0.6320427060127258,
-0.3067341148853302,
-0.0905606597661972,
-0.6516452431678772,
-0.48891332745552063,
-0.0788341835141182,
0.15637007355690002,
0.4995691180229187,
-0.02719682641327381,
0.10744836926460266,
-0.6563634276390076,
0.5206617116928101,
0.05332118645310402,
0.42187416553497314,
0.148818701505661,
-0.5795627236366272,
0.13202625513076782,
-0.0743790790438652,
-0.7994692325592041,
-1.1604889631271362,
0.3249675929546356,
0.08537676185369492,
0.7513236403465271,
0.20149560272693634,
0.5172731876373291,
1.0254203081130981,
-0.4632098972797394,
0.7909189462661743,
-0.10728426277637482,
-0.6595873832702637,
0.6319268941879272,
-0.21136689186096191,
-0.1334083378314972,
0.9521251916885376,
0.4692293107509613,
-0.23394355177879333,
-0.5836295485496521,
-0.7616815567016602,
-0.8762320876121521,
0.3476130962371826,
0.1650620847940445,
0.45299485325813293,
-0.46935394406318665,
0.6007235050201416,
-0.10620169341564178,
0.05622651427984238,
-0.17701011896133423,
0.17697586119174957,
0.03687644004821777,
-0.32288873195648193,
0.16028036177158356,
-0.4836786091327667,
-0.04715301841497421,
-0.31119757890701294,
1.1110650300979614,
0.23144055902957916,
0.057512067258358,
0.483328640460968,
-0.4426632225513458,
0.10651034861803055,
0.6371891498565674,
0.6160433292388916,
0.5927937626838684,
-0.38434284925460815,
0.5132019519805908,
0.41026660799980164,
-0.7972788214683533,
0.42465245723724365,
0.07700590044260025,
-0.20976203680038452,
-0.3044869899749756,
0.02030760981142521,
0.0515686497092247,
0.6551056504249573,
-0.4723060429096222,
0.579950213432312,
0.2056300789117813,
0.10027656704187393,
-0.8231258392333984,
0.3917449712753296,
-0.3191782832145691,
0.2827260494232178,
0.737459123134613,
-0.037642065435647964,
0.3563437759876251,
-0.4528470039367676,
0.8346176147460938,
0.4494510889053345,
-0.5685240626335144,
-0.2628675699234009,
0.7731220722198486,
-0.10752703994512558,
-0.3170689642429352,
0.5070840716362,
-0.29285648465156555,
-0.07846204191446304,
0.8842481374740601,
0.6173126101493835,
0.5375943183898926,
0.029959583654999733,
0.15888668596744537,
0.5442963242530823,
0.30349984765052795,
-0.23497261106967926,
0.3200788199901581,
-0.3027825951576233,
-0.2201090008020401,
-0.35966384410858154,
-0.5483898520469666,
-0.45640403032302856,
0.06956245005130768,
-0.8634485006332397,
0.7775037288665771,
-0.4904053807258606,
-0.3947940170764923,
-0.17549368739128113,
0.7301697134971619,
-0.5022574067115784,
0.3681478500366211,
-0.11163942515850067,
1.4675514698028564,
-0.5836206078529358,
0.6211669445037842,
0.6605129241943359,
-0.7787336111068726,
-0.7244758605957031,
-0.38700437545776367,
0.33076193928718567,
-0.5089734792709351,
0.6234274506568909,
0.0069056348875164986,
-0.05844718590378761,
0.19469910860061646,
-0.5436863303184509,
-0.6938028931617737,
1.1922991275787354,
0.06646211445331573,
-0.41671106219291687,
-0.3379593789577484,
-0.08344872295856476,
0.5667855739593506,
0.11683643609285355,
0.31305375695228577,
0.27738645672798157,
0.3019196093082428,
0.1120317280292511,
-0.46479007601737976,
0.04215716943144798,
-0.3292877972126007,
0.016803814098238945,
0.17015565931797028,
-0.24955233931541443,
0.8314279317855835,
-0.2512727379798889,
-0.38756895065307617,
0.4570235311985016,
0.8642657995223999,
0.5277028679847717,
0.6125079989433289,
0.5316694378852844,
0.732020914554596,
0.6692594885826111,
0.042339082807302475,
0.936231255531311,
-0.31883230805397034,
0.2909165322780609,
1.3708223104476929,
-0.26872825622558594,
0.9854359030723572,
0.8108392357826233,
-0.06265625357627869,
0.7249088287353516,
0.5320161581039429,
-0.1569506824016571,
0.47098442912101746,
0.1722317487001419,
-0.4112147092819214,
-0.21289053559303284,
-0.08306432515382767,
-0.26708728075027466,
0.470445454120636,
0.5162615776062012,
-0.004749791231006384,
-1.0657192468643188,
-0.11701486259698868,
-0.20201776921749115,
0.44048041105270386,
-0.26957377791404724,
0.3556562662124634,
0.32864564657211304,
-0.657983124256134,
0.14657966792583466,
0.25067049264907837,
0.5474593639373779,
-0.5936759114265442,
-0.221989244222641,
0.0001445033267373219,
-0.06642675399780273,
-0.29666072130203247,
-0.9498254656791687,
0.7378123998641968,
-0.04979853332042694,
-0.09694653004407883,
0.2755185663700104,
0.732760488986969,
-0.1278442144393921,
-0.516132116317749,
-0.06847530603408813,
0.5349480509757996,
-0.11607608944177628,
-0.008368766866624355,
-0.5391882658004761,
-0.32963407039642334,
-0.5450730919837952,
-0.3515512943267822,
0.21541933715343475,
0.6029500365257263,
-0.7868843078613281,
0.478792279958725,
0.7326037883758545,
0.14865998923778534,
0.10554227232933044,
-0.06260425597429276,
0.8074767589569092,
-0.6852765083312988,
-0.39986228942871094,
-0.7124683260917664,
0.22888411581516266,
-0.2307719588279724,
-0.13609397411346436,
0.8132256865501404,
0.7577723860740662,
0.8156896829605103,
0.09764730930328369,
0.16376717388629913,
-0.3466619551181793,
0.42068928480148315,
-0.3260512351989746,
0.833019495010376,
-0.43371808528900146,
0.3412971496582031,
-0.19098424911499023,
-0.6739854216575623,
-0.4145931005477905,
0.4043940305709839,
-0.9994100332260132,
-0.3316306173801422,
0.5224313735961914,
1.269455075263977,
-0.4101702570915222,
0.1707308292388916,
0.06290784478187561,
-0.07821960747241974,
0.38232505321502686,
0.591642439365387,
0.649965763092041,
-0.4743820130825043,
0.37886112928390503,
-0.6648164391517639,
-0.00895614828914404,
0.02586078643798828,
-0.6799963116645813,
-0.6673395037651062,
-0.6706281304359436,
-0.15865391492843628,
-0.45360592007637024,
0.15124066174030304,
0.9763219356536865,
0.6692171692848206,
-1.0553522109985352,
-0.06625182926654816,
-0.030557118356227875,
0.13553045690059662,
-0.12148130685091019,
-0.2964666485786438,
0.6227120161056519,
-0.8688194751739502,
-0.6045498251914978,
0.26863476634025574,
0.007753830868750811,
-0.005330024752765894,
-0.02786843851208687,
0.19757355749607086,
-0.6402099132537842,
0.2114240974187851,
0.7193683385848999,
0.24969035387039185,
-0.20090651512145996,
-0.3533698618412018,
-0.02278994955122471,
-0.5661161541938782,
-0.08056453615427017,
0.9351270794868469,
-0.8845430016517639,
0.20364966988563538,
0.5549881458282471,
0.8124034404754639,
0.6565344333648682,
-0.05654500424861908,
0.12638066709041595,
-0.5471689701080322,
0.38350561261177063,
0.4119085967540741,
0.217973530292511,
0.0707131028175354,
-0.5621826648712158,
0.6480741500854492,
0.4776916205883026,
-0.031797196716070175,
-0.8027389645576477,
0.05087935924530029,
-1.1156845092773438,
-0.22692927718162537,
0.9812280535697937,
0.06729341298341751,
-0.6360947489738464,
-0.42396077513694763,
-0.22015537321567535,
0.46225297451019287,
-0.0899663120508194,
1.31037437915802,
0.44593191146850586,
0.13262063264846802,
-0.020759256556630135,
-0.7166889309883118,
0.14045587182044983,
0.4777880012989044,
-0.4693162143230438,
-0.6569204926490784,
0.6882328391075134,
0.6177600622177124,
0.10282015055418015,
0.6354075074195862,
-0.7000396847724915,
0.4800981283187866,
-0.2704513370990753,
-0.34981870651245117,
-0.35627281665802,
-0.2161080241203308,
-0.17707906663417816,
0.6167684197425842,
-0.1432342827320099,
0.28583279252052307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00589v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00589v2
|
Harnessing the Power of Large Language Model for Uncertainty Aware Graph Processing
| 2024-03-31T07:38:39 | 2024-04-12T14:30:10 |
Zhenyu Qian, Yiming Qian, Yuting Song, Fei Gao, Hai Jin, Chen Yu, Xia Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Handling graph data is one of the most difficult tasks. Traditional
techniques, such as those based on geometry and matrix factorization, rely on
assumptions about the data relations that become inadequate when handling large
and complex graph data. On the other hand, deep learning approaches demonstrate
promising results in handling large graph data, but they often fall short of
providing interpretable explanations. To equip the graph processing with both
high accuracy and explainability, we introduce a novel approach that harnesses
the power of a large language model (LLM), enhanced by an uncertainty-aware
module to provide a confidence score on the generated answer. We experiment
with our approach on two graph processing tasks: few-shot knowledge graph
completion and graph classification. Our results demonstrate that through
parameter efficient fine-tuning, the LLM surpasses state-of-the-art algorithms
by a substantial margin across ten diverse benchmark datasets. Moreover, to
address the challenge of explainability, we propose an uncertainty estimation
based on perturbation, along with a calibration scheme to quantify the
confidence scores of the generated answers. Our confidence measure achieves an
AUC of 0.8 or higher on seven out of the ten datasets in predicting the
correctness of the answer generated by LLM.
|
[
-0.26634129881858826,
-1.0665359497070312,
0.8759850859642029,
-0.2754732072353363,
-0.23160438239574432,
0.35785922408103943,
-0.4151281416416168,
-0.6184173822402954,
-0.16422170400619507,
0.3115313649177551,
-0.47572964429855347,
-0.7138367891311646,
-0.9772228002548218,
-0.12839674949645996,
-0.18971820175647736,
0.5579822063446045,
-0.26251736283302307,
-0.23235978186130524,
0.07007171213626862,
0.0036200296599417925,
0.03126220032572746,
-0.30069756507873535,
-0.965156078338623,
-0.5138673186302185,
0.6948051452636719,
0.5520212650299072,
0.9943479895591736,
0.7815146446228027,
0.27739739418029785,
0.27905428409576416,
-0.001256072660908103,
0.5495904684066772,
-0.642861008644104,
-0.12083888053894043,
-0.07094006985425949,
-0.4457097351551056,
-0.5518909096717834,
-0.1893906146287918,
0.7295562028884888,
1.111215353012085,
0.16344569623470306,
0.14392568171024323,
0.1195029616355896,
0.52851402759552,
-0.5304067134857178,
0.5167884826660156,
-0.7460784316062927,
-0.08048376441001892,
-0.07316750288009644,
-0.006197438575327396,
-0.4246496260166168,
-0.23875214159488678,
-0.04497022181749344,
-0.8475100994110107,
0.03249645605683327,
0.2186792492866516,
0.8316445350646973,
0.3361189365386963,
-0.30110153555870056,
-0.08580990135669708,
-0.8712958693504333,
0.43392008543014526,
-0.5853238701820374,
0.2726215720176697,
0.5305511951446533,
0.4692497253417969,
-0.312244176864624,
-0.9311855435371399,
-0.6695926785469055,
0.37003985047340393,
0.13392114639282227,
-0.1392444670200348,
-0.28775906562805176,
0.26078999042510986,
0.18273833394050598,
0.05832565203309059,
-0.3674542307853699,
0.4699074327945709,
0.05544121190905571,
-0.3758397102355957,
0.6373695135116577,
-0.06307429820299149,
-0.037640683352947235,
-0.06813595443964005,
0.08183369040489197,
-0.24578113853931427,
-0.6138752102851868,
0.17329201102256775,
0.5596534013748169,
0.5542367100715637,
0.2052735835313797,
0.6041006445884705,
-0.5184566378593445,
0.6740615367889404,
-0.07280435413122177,
0.05251897871494293,
0.03488204628229141,
0.03135921433568001,
-0.4405727982521057,
-0.05417975038290024,
0.9367533922195435,
0.16218802332878113,
0.5476598739624023,
-0.06974714249372482,
0.026942968368530273,
-0.10870661586523056,
-0.0796501412987709,
-0.8283419013023376,
-0.20708219707012177,
0.43100953102111816,
-0.0553860105574131,
-0.15556523203849792,
0.03807956725358963,
-0.6242650151252747,
-0.5232008099555969,
-0.002959628589451313,
0.18915224075317383,
-0.5831968784332275,
-0.1618880033493042,
0.2860485017299652,
0.2257707715034485,
-0.09652245044708252,
0.5647633671760559,
-0.5447016358375549,
0.15666770935058594,
0.8140522837638855,
0.6826908588409424,
-0.0025904967915266752,
-0.2128048837184906,
-0.5743420124053955,
0.03554550185799599,
-0.6910523176193237,
0.5442269444465637,
-0.6217060089111328,
-0.05038357526063919,
-0.18088790774345398,
-0.0968053936958313,
-0.001808773959055543,
-0.08072033524513245,
0.4028784930706024,
-0.7105566263198853,
-0.2972452640533447,
0.042265720665454865,
-0.747286856174469,
-0.4256519377231598,
0.21572409570217133,
-0.45055630803108215,
0.8821885585784912,
0.3263114094734192,
-0.8974440693855286,
0.3244638442993164,
-0.13092286884784698,
-0.39657390117645264,
0.2361864149570465,
-0.04915333166718483,
-0.5322455763816833,
-0.07291074842214584,
0.5096902251243591,
0.6528463363647461,
-0.11685264855623245,
0.2181292176246643,
-0.7563743591308594,
-0.32993054389953613,
0.4260108172893524,
-0.7284968495368958,
0.4710032641887665,
0.19389262795448303,
-0.04431867599487305,
-0.005636379588395357,
-0.6078165769577026,
0.40599673986434937,
0.06537969410419464,
-0.20988807082176208,
0.04182858392596245,
-0.0773003026843071,
-0.37746167182922363,
0.13524234294891357,
0.3665170669555664,
-0.38173869252204895,
-0.007813462056219578,
-0.4124627411365509,
0.4824458658695221,
0.8899239301681519,
0.07576584070920944,
0.36279937624931335,
0.07214989513158798,
0.5223874449729919,
-0.26831528544425964,
0.04886113852262497,
0.012612396851181984,
-0.4676637351512909,
-0.5247220396995544,
-0.10549287497997284,
0.4965130686759949,
0.4629979431629181,
-0.7771188616752625,
0.3403118848800659,
-0.6017075777053833,
-0.5991402864456177,
-0.4056919515132904,
0.34220001101493835,
0.27284857630729675,
0.7157489061355591,
0.1895938366651535,
-0.06461960077285767,
-0.32793736457824707,
-0.6072402596473694,
-0.08235913515090942,
-0.24538810551166534,
-0.1158752292394638,
0.6059638857841492,
0.29040154814720154,
-0.24487534165382385,
0.9195486903190613,
-0.840476393699646,
0.04035364091396332,
-0.23052705824375153,
0.3072535991668701,
0.24968741834163666,
0.31600862741470337,
0.13912633061408997,
-0.7242547869682312,
-0.4579254388809204,
0.24154970049858093,
-0.7069379091262817,
0.18148069083690643,
0.04018077999353409,
-0.14307375252246857,
0.04852216690778732,
0.5765681266784668,
-0.6177169680595398,
0.374396413564682,
0.5437915325164795,
-0.11666671931743622,
0.3295384347438812,
-0.29458433389663696,
-0.0374545082449913,
-0.9966721534729004,
-0.19316838681697845,
0.005913976579904556,
-0.6380998492240906,
-0.2810286283493042,
0.021999433636665344,
-0.15285158157348633,
-0.11621196568012238,
-0.18664094805717468,
0.2576952576637268,
-0.21725770831108093,
-0.10383996367454529,
-0.19262221455574036,
0.27213504910469055,
0.08358665555715561,
0.253388911485672,
-0.1901005208492279,
0.33245933055877686,
0.8784458637237549,
-0.4926780164241791,
0.49420931935310364,
-0.04610864445567131,
-0.42971256375312805,
0.255693644285202,
-0.5265458226203918,
0.2730196416378021,
-0.1888056844472885,
0.2806739807128906,
-1.3795058727264404,
-0.6796693801879883,
0.15343445539474487,
-0.6831462979316711,
0.5975137948989868,
-0.4331556558609009,
-0.6124162673950195,
-0.6796245574951172,
0.18175891041755676,
0.10976973176002502,
0.37822049856185913,
-0.3644164502620697,
0.6800978779792786,
0.27735474705696106,
-0.24860206246376038,
-0.6938701272010803,
-0.6944376826286316,
0.08266597241163254,
-0.16112849116325378,
-0.6826557517051697,
0.07646816223859787,
-0.07759717106819153,
-0.0662127435207367,
-0.048685286194086075,
-0.285934716463089,
-0.21659685671329498,
0.4270283281803131,
0.49332156777381897,
0.0005950054619461298,
-0.0785706639289856,
0.2988367974758148,
0.08553409576416016,
-0.40234261751174927,
-0.03103315271437168,
-0.4351504147052765,
0.7393315434455872,
0.04494369775056839,
-0.4812147617340088,
-0.46445536613464355,
-0.0710790604352951,
0.4512479305267334,
-0.05832097306847572,
0.5318007469177246,
0.7352786660194397,
-0.48218730092048645,
-0.36840832233428955,
-0.14804145693778992,
-0.07159392535686493,
-0.48498624563217163,
0.5441579222679138,
-0.5015639662742615,
-1.0366663932800293,
0.6336644887924194,
-0.4642445743083954,
-0.2910933792591095,
0.41163185238838196,
0.18897375464439392,
-0.2646062672138214,
1.1363279819488525,
0.49381521344184875,
-0.20683056116104126,
0.30615273118019104,
-0.24548164010047913,
0.3919376730918884,
-0.4154804050922394,
0.1269698292016983,
-0.44180113077163696,
-0.2590501308441162,
-0.5593894720077515,
-0.6060804128646851,
0.22902829945087433,
0.26004260778427124,
-0.4632430970668793,
0.04478352516889572,
-0.3873307406902313,
0.43119099736213684,
0.358359158039093,
0.3678204119205475,
0.29544970393180847,
0.08171065896749496,
0.06081591546535492,
0.28790080547332764,
-0.7208378314971924,
-0.47605735063552856,
1.0871936082839966,
0.464146226644516,
0.9847445487976074,
-0.2301998734474182,
0.5091407299041748,
-0.05696161463856697,
0.10852231085300446,
-0.8207573890686035,
0.3694676458835602,
-0.17960892617702484,
-0.19431324303150177,
-0.8127738833427429,
-0.7741934061050415,
-0.9598195552825928,
-0.016333380714058876,
-0.3575407564640045,
-1.0688527822494507,
-0.16424432396888733,
0.2594425082206726,
-0.5460044145584106,
0.42816361784935,
-0.6779547333717346,
0.6500231027603149,
-0.11390994489192963,
-0.2571118175983429,
-0.050587549805641174,
-0.5999986529350281,
0.11481612175703049,
-0.24801015853881836,
0.4486762583255768,
-0.2728671431541443,
0.21973487734794617,
0.5290561318397522,
-0.3429308533668518,
0.972446858882904,
-0.1401597410440445,
-0.119279645383358,
0.36610379815101624,
0.34785279631614685,
0.888235867023468,
0.2187708467245102,
-0.4368671178817749,
0.22852876782417297,
-0.38816413283348083,
-0.1975082904100418,
-0.7907070517539978,
0.6806166768074036,
-0.7378273606300354,
-0.5005546808242798,
0.0002154290850739926,
-0.8413944244384766,
-0.3553794324398041,
0.4706696569919586,
0.48044583201408386,
0.22644126415252686,
0.13240185379981995,
0.041128065437078476,
0.5875572562217712,
-0.14751191437244415,
0.32752716541290283,
0.16353999078273773,
-0.23216460645198822,
-0.22205835580825806,
0.8643257021903992,
0.528890073299408,
0.3794735074043274,
0.340483158826828,
0.2747000753879547,
-0.2119751274585724,
-0.8786966800689697,
-0.29313454031944275,
0.04087027534842491,
-0.6727965474128723,
-0.24783191084861755,
-0.6247494220733643,
-0.27752137184143066,
-0.43940481543540955,
-0.25759002566337585,
-0.43794846534729004,
-0.387649804353714,
-0.3208329975605011,
-0.5178372859954834,
0.5309372544288635,
0.7014710307121277,
0.1105775386095047,
0.62836092710495,
-0.36915671825408936,
0.23144401609897614,
0.45246177911758423,
0.7120855450630188,
-0.15767808258533478,
-0.3727775812149048,
-0.2424219697713852,
0.3018702566623688,
0.0996575653553009,
-0.649827778339386,
0.25910088419914246,
0.1812988817691803,
0.3189812898635864,
0.4461049735546112,
0.17697161436080933,
0.6545891761779785,
-0.2157907336950302,
0.5330860614776611,
-0.08359585702419281,
-1.039591670036316,
0.44325774908065796,
-0.2635020315647125,
0.17468483746051788,
0.48038631677627563,
0.3563989996910095,
-0.16567882895469666,
-0.48508572578430176,
-0.740249752998352,
-1.0892448425292969,
0.5199818015098572,
0.12286241352558136,
0.016049465164542198,
0.29217612743377686,
0.6897390484809875,
-0.086334727704525,
0.19730323553085327,
-0.4545169174671173,
-0.197688028216362,
-0.043231431394815445,
-0.3535204529762268,
-0.4378240406513214,
-0.11581561714410782,
-0.16662217676639557,
-0.13388879597187042,
0.5878247618675232,
-0.7514536380767822,
0.02070705220103264,
0.0796831026673317,
-0.09821368008852005,
-0.3614875376224518,
0.1799485981464386,
0.022959569469094276,
0.7827150821685791,
-0.18064060807228088,
0.4759231507778168,
0.2594947814941406,
-0.2993074059486389,
-0.13658888638019562,
0.36062267422676086,
-0.13060829043388367,
-0.2854457497596741,
0.5866879820823669,
0.740456759929657,
-0.06473538279533386,
-0.4629727005958557,
0.3437325656414032,
-0.0654987022280693,
-0.07985568791627884,
-0.12615203857421875,
0.07689723372459412,
0.2717730700969696,
0.1545446664094925,
0.3739279806613922,
-0.04245854169130325,
0.0383225753903389,
-0.084156334400177,
0.14999015629291534,
0.46585613489151,
-0.583096981048584,
-0.031711045652627945,
0.5177235007286072,
-0.3491131067276001,
-0.06083919480443001,
0.6600217223167419,
-0.3317728042602539,
-0.4259962737560272,
0.7761387825012207,
0.4659103453159332,
0.3486822843551636,
-0.13442741334438324,
0.3810345232486725,
0.3501867651939392,
0.3347747027873993,
0.09907499700784683,
0.23016926646232605,
0.25540199875831604,
-1.0792454481124878,
-0.665870726108551,
-0.5367673635482788,
-0.4585284888744354,
-0.11010662466287613,
-0.5176337361335754,
-0.10445284098386765,
-0.5786615014076233,
-0.25461968779563904,
0.1702011227607727,
0.1131758913397789,
-0.7993637919425964,
0.4172131419181824,
0.17284135520458221,
0.7803552150726318,
-0.9273136854171753,
0.8207078576087952,
0.42932286858558655,
-0.1610339730978012,
-1.290732979774475,
-0.17940086126327515,
-0.1863204836845398,
-0.947607696056366,
0.3421629071235657,
0.1737997680902481,
-0.2547397017478943,
0.05514831840991974,
-0.8714840412139893,
-1.030396819114685,
1.1628737449645996,
0.7776498198509216,
-0.6069733500480652,
0.18437735736370087,
0.2412140667438507,
0.5081971287727356,
-0.33100104331970215,
0.00009035976836457849,
0.541474461555481,
0.6886317133903503,
0.3819442689418793,
-0.6145507097244263,
0.2618844211101532,
0.21596749126911163,
-0.1668141633272171,
0.01862582564353943,
-0.5740344524383545,
0.9634107947349548,
-0.3903975784778595,
-0.28199896216392517,
-0.2568131685256958,
0.6813132762908936,
0.1046043112874031,
0.3608400225639343,
0.541293203830719,
0.42972302436828613,
1.540626049041748,
-0.16303955018520355,
1.3246097564697266,
-0.3099176287651062,
0.4948976933956146,
1.4718250036239624,
-0.23252466320991516,
0.7001892924308777,
0.19680853188037872,
-0.27549585700035095,
0.5098868012428284,
0.9460573196411133,
0.3196369409561157,
0.06023518741130829,
0.20273712277412415,
-0.03724823519587517,
-0.7133193612098694,
-0.0713350772857666,
0.09177587181329727,
0.5547874569892883,
0.6947314143180847,
-0.3973359763622284,
-0.18456563353538513,
-0.17199304699897766,
0.11917481571435928,
-0.01611017808318138,
-0.5092033743858337,
0.5912317037582397,
0.21076759696006775,
-0.3662719428539276,
0.3945572078227997,
-0.06878731399774551,
0.21215790510177612,
-0.6299667358398438,
0.06378892809152603,
0.23632247745990753,
0.14619871973991394,
-0.2823757827281952,
-1.1725090742111206,
0.07238324731588364,
-0.35670384764671326,
-0.1647484302520752,
-0.05919552966952324,
0.8162850737571716,
-0.24122585356235504,
-0.7261164784431458,
0.38207894563674927,
0.4596182405948639,
0.08954425901174545,
-0.2606041431427002,
-0.4945656955242157,
-0.06907264143228531,
-0.02894163317978382,
-0.2557535171508789,
0.1519726812839508,
0.7175596356391907,
-0.03517608717083931,
0.9949700832366943,
0.5388228297233582,
0.20537780225276947,
-0.10720799118280411,
-0.020680418238043785,
0.9062875509262085,
-0.07649070769548416,
-0.245675191283226,
-0.9159160852432251,
0.17976026237010956,
-0.04252491891384125,
-0.17041048407554626,
0.7777543663978577,
0.3611382246017456,
0.5611003041267395,
0.37511518597602844,
0.9566324949264526,
0.1246022954583168,
0.21351096034049988,
-0.48494571447372437,
0.6450487971305847,
-0.2483263611793518,
0.018657589331269264,
-0.41094541549682617,
-0.6435860395431519,
-0.5093530416488647,
0.6078709959983826,
-0.4699647128582001,
0.07593491673469543,
0.4927098751068115,
0.7148623466491699,
-0.03181103244423866,
-0.17509916424751282,
0.24809865653514862,
0.6080396771430969,
0.30483078956604004,
0.642946720123291,
0.24807752668857574,
-0.2697211802005768,
0.7027820944786072,
-0.28217265009880066,
-0.24095173180103302,
0.010080288164317608,
-0.9962068796157837,
-0.6445037722587585,
-0.3209216296672821,
-0.29668670892715454,
-0.6180446743965149,
-0.25059226155281067,
0.6718358397483826,
1.0058900117874146,
-0.6690002679824829,
0.24381473660469055,
-0.21898800134658813,
0.5855055451393127,
-0.3571265935897827,
-0.2101912498474121,
0.6128771901130676,
-0.18550965189933777,
-0.7242828011512756,
0.3608606457710266,
0.20077839493751526,
0.2350003570318222,
-0.08702495694160461,
-0.11770641058683395,
-0.013767130672931671,
0.1017773225903511,
0.34790897369384766,
0.1983744502067566,
-0.3668597638607025,
-0.8207288384437561,
-0.2132120579481125,
-0.03515959903597832,
0.13375213742256165,
0.3843137323856354,
-0.5404061079025269,
0.694928765296936,
0.3476153612136841,
0.6576003432273865,
0.8539007902145386,
0.1364932507276535,
0.6604509949684143,
-0.9479765892028809,
-0.08124297112226486,
0.06848257780075073,
0.588910698890686,
0.5837912559509277,
-0.8128547072410583,
0.5071693658828735,
-0.025411756709218025,
-0.49684154987335205,
-0.5725583434104919,
0.5308811664581299,
-0.9988254904747009,
-0.4333581030368805,
1.0614242553710938,
-0.5372395515441895,
-0.3952780067920685,
-0.17336055636405945,
-0.0284920372068882,
0.6150110363960266,
-0.30963560938835144,
0.42261889576911926,
0.8039308786392212,
-0.1763264536857605,
-0.1665997952222824,
-0.23380672931671143,
0.23345239460468292,
-0.07038155943155289,
-0.7956177592277527,
0.2895957827568054,
0.4446774125099182,
0.37181413173675537,
0.20072084665298462,
0.5450883507728577,
0.17640143632888794,
-0.07140884548425674,
0.13961440324783325,
0.006350686773657799,
-0.2457251399755478,
-0.39319106936454773,
-0.24773764610290527,
0.5981260538101196,
0.35120928287506104,
0.12335554510354996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01343v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01343v2
|
CHOPS: CHat with custOmer Profile Systems for Customer Service with LLMs
| 2024-03-31T07:11:48 | 2024-04-15T06:03:56 |
Jingzhe Shi, Jialuo Li, Qinwei Ma, Zaiwen Yang, Huan Ma, Lei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Businesses and software platforms are increasingly turning to Large Language
Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5, GPT-4, GLM-3, and LLaMa-2 for chat assistance
with file access or as reasoning agents for customer service. However, current
LLM-based customer service models have limited integration with customer
profiles and lack the operational capabilities necessary for effective service.
Moreover, existing API integrations emphasize diversity over the precision and
error avoidance essential in real-world customer service scenarios. To address
these issues, we propose an LLM agent named CHOPS (CHat with custOmer Profile
in existing System), designed to: (1) efficiently utilize existing databases or
systems for accessing user information or interacting with these systems
following existing guidelines; (2) provide accurate and reasonable responses or
carry out required operations in the system while avoiding harmful operations;
and (3) leverage a combination of small and large LLMs to achieve satisfying
performance at a reasonable inference cost. We introduce a practical dataset,
the CPHOS-dataset, which includes a database, guiding files, and QA pairs
collected from CPHOS, an online platform that facilitates the organization of
simulated Physics Olympiads for high school teachers and students. We have
conducted extensive experiments to validate the performance of our proposed
CHOPS architecture using the CPHOS-dataset, with the aim of demonstrating how
LLMs can enhance or serve as alternatives to human customer service. Code for
our proposed architecture and dataset can be found at
{https://github.com/JingzheShi/CHOPS}.
|
[
-0.3567109704017639,
-0.52580326795578,
0.4709700047969818,
0.3837665319442749,
-0.12838925421237946,
0.6288209557533264,
0.022051820531487465,
-0.6561071276664734,
0.5759769678115845,
0.8487734794616699,
-0.6877552270889282,
-0.26420918107032776,
-0.12646040320396423,
-0.04604951664805412,
-0.3551121652126312,
0.6323392987251282,
0.16791224479675293,
0.23996050655841827,
-0.2759772837162018,
0.34503403306007385,
-0.6370123028755188,
-0.709083080291748,
-0.8332036733627319,
-0.511658787727356,
0.2881704568862915,
0.7365849018096924,
0.8144307136535645,
0.6536075472831726,
0.6750070452690125,
0.3413737714290619,
0.0533868633210659,
0.4173556864261627,
-0.5683356523513794,
0.3680233955383301,
-0.2666972577571869,
-0.4968928098678589,
-0.70923912525177,
-0.12660466134548187,
0.42238959670066833,
0.6635177135467529,
-0.345939040184021,
-0.09769264608621597,
0.11839409917593002,
0.5011888146400452,
-0.23516511917114258,
-0.007417906075716019,
-0.7829723358154297,
-0.011917144991457462,
-0.21776238083839417,
-0.16799992322921753,
-0.32478490471839905,
-0.19929508864879608,
0.2225809544324875,
-0.7273730039596558,
-0.3570407032966614,
0.20180141925811768,
0.8554776906967163,
-0.031132560223340988,
-0.15233637392520905,
-0.2957802414894104,
-0.7642953395843506,
0.8436996340751648,
-0.4292270243167877,
0.2935650944709778,
0.4933680593967438,
0.7169737219810486,
-0.4466026723384857,
-0.6561831831932068,
-0.061725396662950516,
0.11025090515613556,
0.05297742038965225,
0.152547687292099,
-0.04030143842101097,
0.020558370277285576,
0.27030596137046814,
0.28564971685409546,
-0.43954870104789734,
0.3214532434940338,
-0.44959887862205505,
-0.19426515698432922,
0.587803840637207,
0.7234583497047424,
0.05317406356334686,
-0.06275606900453568,
-0.40245136618614197,
0.0379796028137207,
-0.4168974757194519,
0.3459585905075073,
0.5717501044273376,
0.5744766592979431,
-0.1732514649629593,
0.5671032667160034,
-0.3072268068790436,
0.38973119854927063,
-0.09131290763616562,
-0.4222352206707001,
0.030405806377530098,
0.054694853723049164,
-0.2163349986076355,
-0.21135936677455902,
0.7876027226448059,
0.34367835521698,
0.3519114553928375,
-0.10383075475692749,
-0.21178856492042542,
-0.10786779969930649,
0.2112991213798523,
-0.8790046572685242,
-0.2368309199810028,
0.37047064304351807,
-0.2986142039299011,
-0.34050264954566956,
-0.06941457092761993,
-0.7643103003501892,
-0.48599234223365784,
-0.40150636434555054,
-0.05669422447681427,
-0.6310820579528809,
-0.07912787050008774,
0.09188869595527649,
-0.13338300585746765,
0.27439549565315247,
0.401251882314682,
-0.7679466605186462,
0.9571723937988281,
0.965480625629425,
0.90156489610672,
-0.5046060681343079,
-0.313988596200943,
-0.5075998306274414,
0.17309097945690155,
-0.29889944195747375,
0.965775728225708,
-0.860895037651062,
-0.6279712915420532,
0.13497242331504822,
-0.07922324538230896,
0.331403911113739,
-0.8070048689842224,
0.5845295190811157,
-0.46601948142051697,
0.0033339466899633408,
-0.25304463505744934,
-0.6820260882377625,
0.1946302056312561,
0.4072829782962799,
-0.29570096731185913,
1.0079002380371094,
0.054333556443452835,
-0.3441958427429199,
-0.11390174925327301,
-0.5939949750900269,
-0.4144461750984192,
0.3768482804298401,
-0.12660138309001923,
-0.2598930299282074,
-0.17371483147144318,
0.1439645141363144,
0.3006178140640259,
-0.31879907846450806,
0.03141374513506889,
-0.649790346622467,
-0.6061475276947021,
0.4600300192832947,
-0.13926544785499573,
0.6608618497848511,
0.35543254017829895,
0.4897565245628357,
0.052263546735048294,
-0.4041610360145569,
0.14556893706321716,
0.18039998412132263,
-0.3558122217655182,
0.004090616479516029,
0.13458479940891266,
0.024589786306023598,
0.013928605243563652,
0.22442877292633057,
-0.4851424992084503,
0.4454273581504822,
-0.3360741436481476,
0.5273436307907104,
0.6371214985847473,
0.03931949660181999,
0.20915673673152924,
-0.48532629013061523,
0.7540712356567383,
0.031782831996679306,
0.3537924587726593,
-0.40287071466445923,
-0.5761725902557373,
-0.33141395449638367,
-0.48202893137931824,
-0.033309999853372574,
0.7202662825584412,
-0.6984369158744812,
0.27697762846946716,
-0.27813124656677246,
-0.5416474938392639,
-0.23372414708137512,
0.12593670189380646,
0.19408637285232544,
0.5248899459838867,
0.15648537874221802,
-0.26471129059791565,
-0.6597365736961365,
-1.1009178161621094,
-0.4360249936580658,
-0.1445230394601822,
-0.43244636058807373,
0.6671275496482849,
-0.030219707638025284,
-0.002446073107421398,
1.1778326034545898,
-0.7639715671539307,
-0.27866116166114807,
-0.16790582239627838,
-0.35420718789100647,
0.17591971158981323,
0.2992017865180969,
0.2185867875814438,
-0.5622637867927551,
-0.6327991485595703,
-0.15205018222332,
-0.4286588728427887,
-0.21025218069553375,
0.015700813382864,
-0.3187311887741089,
-0.04382527247071266,
0.17865177989006042,
-0.5351867079734802,
0.2428549975156784,
0.45691630244255066,
-0.160124734044075,
0.6957515478134155,
0.051200155168771744,
0.02985762618482113,
-1.0258678197860718,
-0.05493909493088722,
-0.037313129752874374,
-0.7335216403007507,
-0.7897851467132568,
-0.4443625211715698,
-0.10903575271368027,
-0.48096317052841187,
-0.7712035775184631,
0.43280544877052307,
-0.08176781237125397,
-0.6326569318771362,
-0.3654412627220154,
0.2540989816188812,
0.2525534927845001,
0.5501442551612854,
-0.08621545135974884,
1.0425313711166382,
0.5323663353919983,
-0.5039991736412048,
0.3742557466030121,
0.4838269054889679,
-0.10678590089082718,
0.8858224749565125,
-0.5357711315155029,
0.1759309023618698,
0.31170380115509033,
0.275362491607666,
-0.7128255367279053,
-0.449737548828125,
0.4117670953273773,
-0.368129700422287,
-0.06645891070365906,
-0.25566208362579346,
-0.44435402750968933,
-0.4967576861381531,
-0.3898889720439911,
0.04595709964632988,
0.6063897013664246,
-0.4555477201938629,
0.6180094480514526,
0.8132857084274292,
-0.07551147043704987,
-0.3806791603565216,
-0.573067843914032,
0.38533544540405273,
-0.27627286314964294,
-0.6483460068702698,
0.34965190291404724,
-0.1426529735326767,
-0.2417634129524231,
-0.252210408449173,
0.0675329715013504,
-0.5010120272636414,
0.0901244729757309,
0.3308914601802826,
0.3965183198451996,
0.056296207010746,
0.0013245379086583853,
-0.007350477389991283,
0.030281027778983116,
-0.009464757516980171,
-0.24305415153503418,
0.8468815088272095,
-0.3051608204841614,
-0.3202233910560608,
-0.6729081869125366,
0.23335672914981842,
0.708198070526123,
-0.014809397980570793,
0.25490862131118774,
0.005638599395751953,
-0.29984045028686523,
-0.07416386902332306,
-0.5837118029594421,
-0.31702667474746704,
-0.6120185852050781,
0.248930886387825,
-0.4894678592681885,
-0.8269972801208496,
0.9435527920722961,
-0.14376768469810486,
0.09676792472600937,
-0.24955318868160248,
0.48130765557289124,
-0.3359564542770386,
0.8829668164253235,
0.33188918232917786,
-0.10183011740446091,
0.5627862215042114,
0.04796750470995903,
0.09959861636161804,
-0.9079490303993225,
-0.232699915766716,
-0.5468518137931824,
-0.27639392018318176,
-0.3776189684867859,
-0.41992074251174927,
0.18650352954864502,
0.04100516438484192,
-0.3322833776473999,
0.21824496984481812,
-0.4755621552467346,
0.7329326272010803,
0.14052589237689972,
0.08887236565351486,
0.3606671392917633,
0.023033004254102707,
0.04279475659132004,
-0.19667762517929077,
-0.4252002537250519,
-0.6939767003059387,
0.688656747341156,
0.6532251238822937,
0.9036160707473755,
-0.09499663859605789,
0.45568013191223145,
0.17115874588489532,
0.30712059140205383,
-1.0318646430969238,
0.6680575013160706,
-0.17554810643196106,
-0.5481386184692383,
-0.3200444281101227,
-0.41358476877212524,
-0.8140608072280884,
0.28680238127708435,
0.11629138141870499,
-0.9480636715888977,
-0.01575889252126217,
0.12096023559570312,
-0.17295058071613312,
0.4367583692073822,
-0.4529370963573456,
0.4798642694950104,
-0.261726051568985,
-0.3407512605190277,
-0.025643659755587578,
-0.3238440454006195,
0.5115328431129456,
-0.005718712229281664,
0.22333016991615295,
-0.5265016555786133,
-0.21892447769641876,
0.6275049448013306,
-0.5228237509727478,
0.9184524416923523,
-0.18024897575378418,
0.17200788855552673,
0.3876021206378937,
0.39141565561294556,
0.6641737818717957,
0.07866623252630234,
-0.22699882090091705,
0.22527115046977997,
0.19210311770439148,
-0.31896209716796875,
-0.5559377670288086,
0.6653947830200195,
-0.7937929034233093,
-0.4420648217201233,
-0.10246303677558899,
-0.7399139404296875,
-0.5591223835945129,
0.27987468242645264,
-0.34312665462493896,
0.13417838513851166,
-0.1218542531132698,
0.14212998747825623,
0.2950853109359741,
-0.014550626277923584,
0.21359622478485107,
0.6774015426635742,
-0.733571469783783,
-0.37881213426589966,
0.8718199133872986,
0.05399063602089882,
0.119341179728508,
0.03224053606390953,
0.20939262211322784,
-0.22905798256397247,
-0.3549014627933502,
-0.2239154428243637,
0.2815406322479248,
-0.5448310971260071,
-0.45604828000068665,
-0.483447790145874,
-0.12875592708587646,
-0.2737313508987427,
-0.24184316396713257,
-0.6102712750434875,
-0.19105710089206696,
-0.3219392001628876,
0.14574699103832245,
0.3168603479862213,
0.5421434044837952,
0.27853184938430786,
0.6131824851036072,
-0.7143483757972717,
0.10651952028274536,
0.04901070147752762,
0.7279698252677917,
-0.1058267205953598,
-0.43361154198646545,
-0.194269061088562,
-0.05645138397812843,
-0.538231611251831,
-0.8032047152519226,
0.5423038601875305,
0.05260710045695305,
0.3723525404930115,
0.47822800278663635,
-0.041755225509405136,
0.8569309711456299,
-0.55223548412323,
0.78179931640625,
0.07146298140287399,
-1.067395567893982,
0.22514072060585022,
-0.6398932337760925,
0.04744464159011841,
0.6232125759124756,
0.3627740442752838,
-0.9937375783920288,
-0.569546103477478,
-0.3395600914955139,
-0.4606247842311859,
0.9804341793060303,
-0.08965248614549637,
0.31433019042015076,
0.11914196610450745,
0.6155496835708618,
0.06459575891494751,
0.20781616866588593,
-0.23147785663604736,
-0.07589662075042725,
-0.0993361622095108,
-0.05611195042729378,
0.45179837942123413,
-0.09478512406349182,
0.06278906017541885,
-0.016883758828043938,
0.6285272836685181,
-0.432285875082016,
-0.03390095382928848,
0.0461018905043602,
0.4426954686641693,
-0.17608389258384705,
-0.043512895703315735,
0.327164888381958,
0.7374768257141113,
-0.12232813239097595,
-0.16222776472568512,
0.42623916268348694,
-0.44471198320388794,
-0.13265545666217804,
-0.3455897271633148,
0.08308032155036926,
-0.2996240556240082,
-0.10679952800273895,
0.5409635901451111,
0.3680531978607178,
-0.9861322641372681,
0.3666783273220062,
-0.16113488376140594,
-0.22392815351486206,
-0.4004763662815094,
0.11888619512319565,
0.4383566081523895,
0.10993821173906326,
0.30780476331710815,
-0.22083386778831482,
0.15347325801849365,
-0.3493557572364807,
0.3033822774887085,
0.6084011793136597,
-0.4858689308166504,
-0.2642693519592285,
0.09560427069664001,
0.23146767914295197,
-0.8877689838409424,
0.6841709613800049,
0.09048167616128922,
-0.45817115902900696,
0.5013314485549927,
0.5385796427726746,
0.6269024014472961,
-0.3624574542045593,
0.2303282618522644,
-0.16013671457767487,
0.06847915053367615,
-0.038996800780296326,
0.33257588744163513,
0.3031133711338043,
-0.5996862053871155,
-0.5098833441734314,
-0.42702072858810425,
-1.1467384099960327,
0.21206998825073242,
-0.6135344505310059,
0.713485836982727,
-0.6932284832000732,
-0.1186530664563179,
-0.02234438620507717,
0.0640486404299736,
-0.5459421277046204,
-0.2227097451686859,
0.1995002031326294,
1.0903903245925903,
-0.5745807886123657,
0.8975131511688232,
0.5208057761192322,
-0.0191907100379467,
-0.7892118096351624,
-0.19844698905944824,
-0.013680477626621723,
-0.8469324707984924,
0.48893633484840393,
-0.0033209421671926975,
-0.14587236940860748,
-0.3486708998680115,
-0.48823997378349304,
-0.8905322551727295,
1.0172549486160278,
0.45981332659721375,
-0.5582514405250549,
-0.017099866643548012,
0.5638231039047241,
0.5123584270477295,
-0.6023091077804565,
0.3319813907146454,
0.6916846036911011,
0.3371986150741577,
0.41973015666007996,
-0.9049584269523621,
-0.21824409067630768,
0.16341440379619598,
-0.015580713748931885,
0.01087668351829052,
-0.8703517317771912,
0.7474993467330933,
0.3543572723865509,
-0.09212835878133774,
-0.022323010489344597,
0.5319896936416626,
0.3210522532463074,
0.13482356071472168,
0.4686802923679352,
0.2950942814350128,
0.8914952278137207,
0.11333691328763962,
1.0272855758666992,
-0.4173881411552429,
0.30282288789749146,
1.074776291847229,
-0.7433447241783142,
0.8019291162490845,
0.5690256357192993,
-0.4402465224266052,
0.3086124360561371,
0.6622906923294067,
-0.029512695968151093,
0.15107925236225128,
0.2893664836883545,
0.10110398381948471,
-0.45634129643440247,
-0.3614685833454132,
0.19241838157176971,
0.5700502395629883,
0.4978950619697571,
0.14413675665855408,
-0.2539605498313904,
-0.08106005936861038,
0.06217491626739502,
-0.030257174745202065,
-0.09104885160923004,
0.7358091473579407,
0.2205027937889099,
-0.5393422245979309,
0.31996485590934753,
-0.0064628152176737785,
0.5004457831382751,
-0.63494473695755,
0.0199157502502203,
-0.2646886110305786,
0.09334835410118103,
-0.28344807028770447,
-0.9754974842071533,
0.5891857147216797,
0.07352305203676224,
0.07441854476928711,
-0.17632509768009186,
0.863498330116272,
-0.13919921219348907,
-0.3357884883880615,
0.24366311728954315,
0.5038317441940308,
0.5716652870178223,
0.09569542855024338,
-0.8973415493965149,
0.513286828994751,
-0.2081519067287445,
-0.42118167877197266,
0.47992318868637085,
0.11976569145917892,
-0.09550061076879501,
1.0033987760543823,
0.7108047008514404,
0.14754334092140198,
-0.30775994062423706,
-0.051063328981399536,
1.083353877067566,
-0.3407023847103119,
-0.7468841075897217,
-0.6530537605285645,
0.2928912937641144,
-0.2962784171104431,
-0.26085811853408813,
0.7107290029525757,
0.8930695056915283,
0.5283629894256592,
0.28624242544174194,
0.6516181826591492,
0.4914630651473999,
1.0095776319503784,
-0.1779177337884903,
0.3834975063800812,
-0.291063517332077,
0.5014514923095703,
0.09508860856294632,
-0.7337743639945984,
-0.18105043470859528,
0.259300172328949,
-0.47107431292533875,
-0.19385550916194916,
0.35711634159088135,
0.7508264780044556,
-0.14674746990203857,
0.24291299283504486,
0.4220961630344391,
-0.027423478662967682,
1.0172662734985352,
0.34502801299095154,
0.897081196308136,
-0.10623252391815186,
0.762489914894104,
-0.23415261507034302,
-0.13449126482009888,
-0.4964752793312073,
-0.6372306942939758,
-0.8799329996109009,
-0.19502678513526917,
-0.09827447682619095,
-0.31050172448158264,
0.06639721989631653,
0.9491226077079773,
0.7254310846328735,
-0.5937983989715576,
-0.6509946584701538,
0.2065536379814148,
0.1618170440196991,
-0.04577292501926422,
-0.2627011239528656,
-0.010643561370670795,
-0.6282659769058228,
-0.8741488456726074,
0.5797371864318848,
0.2848147749900818,
0.020946580916643143,
-0.4854097068309784,
-0.10169768333435059,
0.3749213218688965,
0.4853365421295166,
0.33587929606437683,
0.4686829149723053,
-0.6094697117805481,
-0.2573598623275757,
0.24614615738391876,
-0.3082151710987091,
0.422198086977005,
0.9737045764923096,
-0.7406251430511475,
0.011513816192746162,
0.2899928689002991,
0.7361687421798706,
0.5461767315864563,
0.21249613165855408,
0.3367981016635895,
-0.6378213167190552,
0.11912010610103607,
0.4815618395805359,
0.203415185213089,
0.3308521509170532,
-0.4635876417160034,
0.2622782588005066,
-0.01186139602214098,
-0.6153856515884399,
-1.0123721361160278,
0.40501201152801514,
-1.013978362083435,
-0.3116685450077057,
0.8743058443069458,
-0.19259203970432281,
-0.32822689414024353,
-0.4043211042881012,
-0.4055989682674408,
-0.22854360938072205,
-0.7048646807670593,
0.6259174942970276,
0.5980325937271118,
-0.5252697467803955,
0.08211875706911087,
-0.5273786187171936,
0.44785070419311523,
0.28327518701553345,
-1.1280266046524048,
0.5402039289474487,
0.36912599205970764,
0.29096412658691406,
0.1182020828127861,
0.6808030605316162,
-0.061616647988557816,
-0.07901625335216522,
-0.2285003364086151,
-0.034900862723588943,
-0.3470645844936371,
-0.36807578802108765,
-0.22749903798103333,
0.23561930656433105,
0.00018798952805809677,
-0.07515877485275269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01342v1
|
DiffAgent: Fast and Accurate Text-to-Image API Selection with Large Language Model
| 2024-03-31T06:28:15 | 2024-03-31T06:28:15 |
Lirui Zhao, Yue Yang, Kaipeng Zhang, Wenqi Shao, Yuxin Zhang, Yu Qiao, Ping Luo, Rongrong Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text-to-image (T2I) generative models have attracted significant attention
and found extensive applications within and beyond academic research. For
example, the Civitai community, a platform for T2I innovation, currently hosts
an impressive array of 74,492 distinct models. However, this diversity presents
a formidable challenge in selecting the most appropriate model and parameters,
a process that typically requires numerous trials. Drawing inspiration from the
tool usage research of large language models (LLMs), we introduce DiffAgent, an
LLM agent designed to screen the accurate selection in seconds via API calls.
DiffAgent leverages a novel two-stage training framework, SFTA, enabling it to
accurately align T2I API responses with user input in accordance with human
preferences. To train and evaluate DiffAgent's capabilities, we present
DABench, a comprehensive dataset encompassing an extensive range of T2I APIs
from the community. Our evaluations reveal that DiffAgent not only excels in
identifying the appropriate T2I API but also underscores the effectiveness of
the SFTA training framework. Codes are available at
https://github.com/OpenGVLab/DiffAgent.
|
[
-0.3388126790523529,
-0.6591261029243469,
0.7275255918502808,
0.5200357437133789,
-0.3660159707069397,
0.49516183137893677,
-0.06260151416063309,
-0.39096689224243164,
-0.1422846019268036,
0.02367330528795719,
-0.31970152258872986,
-0.38311687111854553,
-0.851309597492218,
0.20949707925319672,
-0.6300516724586487,
0.45760178565979004,
-0.029288938269019127,
0.17751459777355194,
-0.1349165141582489,
0.033700861036777496,
-0.28591400384902954,
0.07601731270551682,
-0.786740779876709,
-0.5005783438682556,
0.3995814323425293,
0.2776776850223541,
0.5660815834999084,
0.5430305600166321,
0.2654041349887848,
0.2834218144416809,
-0.12602552771568298,
0.2517891526222229,
-0.7092921733856201,
0.047109752893447876,
-0.4083048701286316,
-0.43667227029800415,
-0.09353556483983994,
-0.09986386448144913,
0.31320998072624207,
0.42869770526885986,
0.05034370720386505,
0.32934752106666565,
0.07486364245414734,
0.749484658241272,
-0.6136332750320435,
0.006435592658817768,
-0.5142918825149536,
-0.08820827305316925,
-0.18424585461616516,
-0.0896967276930809,
-0.6952701807022095,
-0.26551324129104614,
0.34717226028442383,
-0.42157745361328125,
0.21269789338111877,
-0.07629173994064331,
0.6544665098190308,
0.7055764198303223,
-0.5558856725692749,
-0.37106215953826904,
-0.74337238073349,
0.767359733581543,
-0.3633337914943695,
0.4876607656478882,
0.44238904118537903,
0.39383867383003235,
-0.2869860827922821,
-0.8548486232757568,
-0.5458394289016724,
-0.29639261960983276,
0.11512327939271927,
0.1243048682808876,
-0.33882883191108704,
-0.14073723554611206,
0.07693582773208618,
0.2755386233329773,
-0.6541645526885986,
0.4212976396083832,
-0.07520899921655655,
0.0655568391084671,
0.4571358561515808,
-0.1147436797618866,
0.2862286865711212,
0.13414832949638367,
-0.5489397048950195,
-0.04631388559937477,
-0.5665543675422668,
-0.4344339370727539,
0.31756192445755005,
-0.10663151741027832,
-0.061021123081445694,
0.4072492718696594,
0.011736246757209301,
0.8358750343322754,
0.35293978452682495,
0.0955902487039566,
0.25696492195129395,
0.1170671284198761,
0.04655087739229202,
-0.0726671814918518,
0.9402399063110352,
0.3118972182273865,
0.07596747577190399,
-0.2223413735628128,
-0.3629133999347687,
0.0010491983266547322,
0.23374460637569427,
-1.1046055555343628,
-0.22787567973136902,
0.5325469970703125,
-0.2301790565252304,
-0.4811626374721527,
-0.08195442706346512,
-0.9298402070999146,
-0.6791060566902161,
-0.25342831015586853,
-0.0035338406451046467,
-0.25705453753471375,
-0.6290974617004395,
-0.08657553791999817,
-0.43649154901504517,
0.2801819443702698,
0.2148941457271576,
-0.9756051898002625,
0.061829276382923126,
0.7040174007415771,
0.9837436676025391,
-0.037153467535972595,
-0.2613777220249176,
-0.6471763849258423,
-0.013669868931174278,
-0.7157617211341858,
0.9141268134117126,
-0.38886189460754395,
-0.4952569007873535,
0.1925031691789627,
-0.37521108984947205,
0.2623809576034546,
-0.5061163902282715,
0.18673816323280334,
-0.8945124745368958,
-0.06263681501150131,
-0.20826880633831024,
-0.5655136704444885,
0.13942565023899078,
0.21169866621494293,
-1.032703161239624,
1.071022391319275,
0.3920535445213318,
-0.8287588953971863,
0.4216616749763489,
-0.5972354412078857,
-0.4697950482368469,
0.11491858214139938,
-0.16343188285827637,
-0.4853825867176056,
0.20556147396564484,
0.2523196339607239,
0.48798906803131104,
-0.4477648437023163,
0.26335951685905457,
-0.6895630359649658,
-0.4965755343437195,
0.48546749353408813,
-0.43251973390579224,
0.9122821092605591,
0.3606198728084564,
-0.5558399558067322,
-0.11448154598474503,
-0.6809727549552917,
-0.1613376885652542,
0.3791125416755676,
-0.36080244183540344,
-0.26303738355636597,
0.017913248389959335,
0.43657273054122925,
0.06536078453063965,
0.18412594497203827,
-0.5249853730201721,
0.1878102719783783,
-0.18797928094863892,
0.8211694955825806,
0.7527018189430237,
-0.28724905848503113,
0.4814679026603699,
0.0034975579474121332,
0.37505677342414856,
-0.29879823327064514,
0.10445549339056015,
0.2740863263607025,
-0.20455044507980347,
-0.605472207069397,
-0.740714967250824,
0.5940195322036743,
0.415280282497406,
-1.20867121219635,
0.38588130474090576,
-0.4237205982208252,
-0.6981250047683716,
-0.5453675389289856,
0.04949204996228218,
0.5056135058403015,
0.34817180037498474,
0.018012776970863342,
-0.02162139303982258,
-0.24853837490081787,
-0.7457813620567322,
0.24425272643566132,
-0.4573917090892792,
-0.27597498893737793,
0.0905827134847641,
0.48076653480529785,
-0.3906571567058563,
0.9998970627784729,
-0.7065181732177734,
-0.2715420722961426,
-0.1984768658876419,
0.44704723358154297,
0.0027709174901247025,
-0.07922694832086563,
1.1480544805526733,
-1.0859209299087524,
-0.6369069814682007,
-0.24651439487934113,
-0.550849974155426,
-0.37756434082984924,
-0.11473838239908218,
-0.5124228000640869,
0.3628213107585907,
0.44190680980682373,
-0.4204355776309967,
0.267960786819458,
0.7420670986175537,
-0.22685818374156952,
0.1823531687259674,
-0.1195412278175354,
0.2999178469181061,
-1.3851637840270996,
0.32666054368019104,
0.29634690284729004,
-0.6095030903816223,
-0.4662538766860962,
-0.04393384978175163,
0.3852956295013428,
0.16934117674827576,
-0.6216242909431458,
0.7587212920188904,
-0.6152788996696472,
-0.13215714693069458,
-0.5226953029632568,
-0.05189308896660805,
0.11928679049015045,
0.32842937111854553,
0.19990530610084534,
1.060941457748413,
0.4713858664035797,
-0.5023822784423828,
0.4536214768886566,
0.5420515537261963,
-0.3772139251232147,
0.4095042645931244,
-0.7182521820068359,
0.5672619938850403,
-0.09320789575576782,
0.3842197358608246,
-1.2163888216018677,
-0.43604907393455505,
0.12801726162433624,
-0.4558531939983368,
0.4492515027523041,
-0.37549474835395813,
-0.908190906047821,
-0.46015021204948425,
-0.4258634150028229,
0.4987991154193878,
0.6065899729728699,
-1.079702615737915,
0.6233819127082825,
0.5691829919815063,
0.017032068222761154,
-0.6444436311721802,
-0.8110971450805664,
0.19243484735488892,
0.028836563229560852,
-0.11863874644041061,
0.3341580927371979,
-0.1956123560667038,
-0.014252525754272938,
-0.04650513455271721,
0.050816167145967484,
-0.4981241226196289,
0.18107812106609344,
0.28359413146972656,
0.48730313777923584,
0.3643687963485718,
0.16910378634929657,
0.1573754996061325,
-0.25341489911079407,
-0.19653214514255524,
-0.3722936809062958,
0.7140325903892517,
-0.05374722182750702,
-0.33152344822883606,
-0.2801988422870636,
0.24199116230010986,
0.6104903221130371,
-0.37048909068107605,
0.4050983488559723,
0.5894628763198853,
-0.18751133978366852,
-0.31729650497436523,
-0.5371419191360474,
0.213759645819664,
-0.5009551644325256,
0.5893933773040771,
-0.3138207495212555,
-0.7406176924705505,
0.10323578864336014,
-0.2839123010635376,
0.149066761136055,
0.13483744859695435,
0.8697516322135925,
-0.06745586544275284,
0.8952624201774597,
0.6084148287773132,
-0.31737256050109863,
0.8472976684570312,
-0.3691822588443756,
0.01342751830816269,
-0.49597081542015076,
0.04440344497561455,
-0.37476250529289246,
-0.2537498474121094,
-0.5091295838356018,
-0.44861212372779846,
0.3005216121673584,
-0.2793612778186798,
-0.060572922229766846,
0.2942650318145752,
-0.5755383968353271,
0.6470860242843628,
0.33367231488227844,
0.2058812379837036,
0.040883902460336685,
0.13529276847839355,
0.2820695638656616,
0.31143248081207275,
-0.32350295782089233,
-0.6277380585670471,
1.1492644548416138,
0.4822212755680084,
0.9525877237319946,
0.3516222834587097,
0.6153799891471863,
0.376790314912796,
0.47990837693214417,
-0.878032922744751,
0.5273123979568481,
-0.42381125688552856,
-0.7906566858291626,
-0.09012207388877869,
-0.25957271456718445,
-0.8791505694389343,
0.028246499598026276,
-0.10793770104646683,
-0.4237794280052185,
0.12351248413324356,
0.3989323675632477,
-0.2942589223384857,
0.22934889793395996,
-0.7368183135986328,
0.5297726988792419,
-0.4705972671508789,
-0.5464325547218323,
-0.12480388581752777,
-0.6467194557189941,
-0.03894054517149925,
-0.24262140691280365,
-0.1640903651714325,
-0.19366750121116638,
-0.40527963638305664,
0.20508483052253723,
-0.14669044315814972,
0.9179825782775879,
-0.2869356572628021,
-0.1407748907804489,
0.38339218497276306,
0.007627544924616814,
0.25268393754959106,
0.12026156485080719,
-0.22189293801784515,
0.5611886978149414,
-0.1789657324552536,
-0.4336093068122864,
-0.4556342363357544,
0.6364251375198364,
-0.7650235295295715,
-0.2673400342464447,
-0.4086591899394989,
-0.0059895566664636135,
-0.1035577654838562,
0.22683930397033691,
0.4060263931751251,
0.3705258071422577,
-0.5307778716087341,
-0.1206459105014801,
0.8243253231048584,
-0.13846881687641144,
0.48806536197662354,
0.36037349700927734,
-0.3586810529232025,
-0.5447604656219482,
0.7700017690658569,
-0.2044418603181839,
0.23842845857143402,
0.6153125762939453,
-0.0043882993049919605,
-0.7704955339431763,
-0.602867066860199,
-0.9684603214263916,
0.2008032649755478,
-0.5544552206993103,
-0.22119228541851044,
-0.5025454163551331,
0.005412856116890907,
-0.2830800414085388,
-0.023106027394533157,
-0.5330033898353577,
-0.10510692745447159,
-0.6570882797241211,
-0.11393057554960251,
0.350307434797287,
0.5316188931465149,
0.27195051312446594,
0.11333101242780685,
-0.690744936466217,
0.44518861174583435,
0.3112437427043915,
0.561345636844635,
-0.18624690175056458,
-0.41157931089401245,
0.0578024759888649,
-0.12220615893602371,
-0.2812668979167938,
-0.9602630138397217,
0.13202373683452606,
0.3379196226596832,
0.39576953649520874,
0.46875324845314026,
0.1564871072769165,
0.567078173160553,
-0.6780643463134766,
0.5554365515708923,
0.32060128450393677,
-0.856144905090332,
0.5879483222961426,
-0.30536651611328125,
0.1200658455491066,
0.7184659242630005,
0.4883832335472107,
-0.2070910632610321,
-0.36873024702072144,
-0.07674333453178406,
-0.904715895652771,
0.42327365279197693,
0.08272920548915863,
0.20166800916194916,
-0.07831328362226486,
0.3775691092014313,
0.2966945171356201,
0.15735991299152374,
-0.6337422132492065,
0.047236621379852295,
-0.23617754876613617,
-0.5456618070602417,
0.031168511137366295,
-0.46135592460632324,
-0.029597541317343712,
0.09174220263957977,
0.675177812576294,
-0.3435233533382416,
0.2222571074962616,
0.1285639852285385,
-0.372798353433609,
-0.018541473895311356,
0.1939336359500885,
0.22214968502521515,
0.6650034189224243,
-0.015356617048382759,
-0.05432244390249252,
-0.05638747662305832,
-0.4645352065563202,
0.3488313555717468,
0.45531725883483887,
-0.09067963063716888,
0.07391718029975891,
0.4319620132446289,
0.8024073243141174,
-0.07037701457738876,
-0.9442886114120483,
0.8657021522521973,
-0.43312060832977295,
-0.31509488821029663,
-0.6389710903167725,
-0.10441867262125015,
-0.015056651085615158,
0.5650638341903687,
0.24164575338363647,
-0.15969038009643555,
0.44278743863105774,
-0.21362806856632233,
-0.007242853287607431,
0.24085554480552673,
-0.2605273425579071,
-0.16462798416614532,
0.7819805145263672,
0.6344542503356934,
-0.15227122604846954,
0.8945125937461853,
-0.37442514300346375,
-0.30273956060409546,
0.44381746649742126,
0.3298446238040924,
1.0546494722366333,
-0.07576283067464828,
0.5087589025497437,
0.20760369300842285,
0.03169971704483032,
-0.24328453838825226,
0.11968256533145905,
0.10168570280075073,
-0.4665931463241577,
-0.3312980532646179,
-0.6284992694854736,
-0.35166800022125244,
0.22028933465480804,
-0.5487348437309265,
0.3975732922554016,
-0.5220690369606018,
-0.48574554920196533,
0.262604683637619,
-0.172943115234375,
-0.6220042109489441,
-0.08813487738370895,
0.46634551882743835,
0.9797084331512451,
-0.9109370708465576,
0.7761899828910828,
0.9807798266410828,
-0.4342186748981476,
-0.6368310451507568,
0.3768041431903839,
0.20902538299560547,
-0.7014567255973816,
0.4465823173522949,
0.345548540353775,
-0.21480421721935272,
0.09601043164730072,
-0.5490627288818359,
-0.5167941451072693,
1.2721092700958252,
0.7321662902832031,
-0.8809072375297546,
0.17401088774204254,
0.17373886704444885,
0.6963057518005371,
-0.21015523374080658,
0.4401421844959259,
0.5743869543075562,
0.19189982116222382,
0.4441656470298767,
-0.7001298666000366,
-0.08202899247407913,
-0.31955987215042114,
0.5596504807472229,
0.21209804713726044,
-0.7312682271003723,
0.3909836411476135,
-0.2465292513370514,
-0.2734830975532532,
0.3598543107509613,
0.4313667416572571,
0.3300999402999878,
0.2919867932796478,
0.9284186363220215,
0.4032582640647888,
0.535977303981781,
-0.05702904984354973,
0.9958661198616028,
-0.18015335500240326,
0.3525066375732422,
0.9689416289329529,
-0.482623815536499,
1.0314514636993408,
0.5652309060096741,
-0.1461952179670334,
0.2826887369155884,
1.2285641431808472,
-0.3887052536010742,
0.8234272003173828,
0.05111660063266754,
-0.45670074224472046,
-0.1554122120141983,
-0.007362013217061758,
0.0967818945646286,
0.4873148202896118,
0.03538663685321808,
-0.2446967512369156,
-0.07941106706857681,
0.08839964866638184,
-0.176742821931839,
0.15434950590133667,
-0.00024611648404970765,
0.8547433018684387,
-0.06924194097518921,
-0.7196679711341858,
0.5662906765937805,
-0.1490258127450943,
0.5285351276397705,
-0.2748652994632721,
-0.25441011786460876,
-0.15025018155574799,
0.2257765233516693,
-0.10974437743425369,
-0.9171468615531921,
0.05665896460413933,
0.3795001804828644,
-0.17670182883739471,
-0.19097037613391876,
0.7623735666275024,
-0.5013396143913269,
-0.4167787730693817,
0.5845261812210083,
0.3097749650478363,
-0.00006297542131505907,
-0.10058051347732544,
-0.7396149039268494,
0.20594076812267303,
-0.0015385831939056516,
-0.3463376462459564,
0.06981851160526276,
0.29108765721321106,
0.017309172078967094,
0.6150647401809692,
0.44259870052337646,
-0.11766747385263443,
-0.282624751329422,
0.2925107479095459,
1.0025769472122192,
-0.22183702886104584,
-0.3585980236530304,
-1.005699634552002,
0.668777585029602,
-0.3177785277366638,
-0.09199825674295425,
0.06104877218604088,
0.6347091197967529,
0.7135623097419739,
-0.33733704686164856,
1.0184974670410156,
-0.2690986394882202,
0.41734230518341064,
-0.4265654981136322,
0.9945451021194458,
-0.7218708395957947,
0.12578809261322021,
-0.0020882815588265657,
-0.8340802788734436,
-0.0834488719701767,
0.20528730750083923,
-0.2930276691913605,
0.006608705502003431,
0.4539813697338104,
0.8843778371810913,
-0.11873380094766617,
-0.3383946716785431,
0.14084552228450775,
0.09969621896743774,
0.538574755191803,
0.37134942412376404,
1.0082025527954102,
-0.2065487802028656,
0.6985294222831726,
0.004052935633808374,
-0.7983835935592651,
-0.3830719292163849,
-0.9331157207489014,
-1.0773733854293823,
-0.7656230926513672,
-0.37022659182548523,
-0.26508283615112305,
-0.04022953286767006,
0.9981759190559387,
0.8294033408164978,
-0.4016602635383606,
0.00615440821275115,
-0.11966314166784286,
-0.11638113111257553,
0.010418425314128399,
-0.10757692158222198,
0.1842554807662964,
-0.17649824917316437,
-1.1567124128341675,
0.09701969474554062,
0.24244411289691925,
0.24360844492912292,
-0.10459184646606445,
-0.011313481256365776,
-0.07471156120300293,
0.09354789555072784,
0.5545921921730042,
0.142390176653862,
-0.5585386753082275,
-0.0026590623892843723,
-0.19270658493041992,
-0.4314950406551361,
-0.05033104494214058,
0.5478095412254333,
-0.35312968492507935,
0.6095572710037231,
0.3612208962440491,
0.9197567105293274,
0.6432857513427734,
-0.3092285692691803,
0.4048977792263031,
-0.8168579936027527,
0.43852391839027405,
0.11512134224176407,
0.26927706599235535,
0.4834873080253601,
-0.3457379937171936,
0.7550226449966431,
-0.08542970567941666,
-0.5124721527099609,
-0.7356302738189697,
0.3082626461982727,
-1.023001790046692,
-0.4898873567581177,
1.3749148845672607,
-0.23190732300281525,
-0.43525996804237366,
0.2061651647090912,
-0.4136386513710022,
0.38213175535202026,
-0.41271233558654785,
1.0364018678665161,
0.6647676825523376,
0.14836357533931732,
-0.08791427314281464,
-0.5117511749267578,
0.2206561118364334,
0.05686216801404953,
-0.7932196855545044,
-0.0025686391163617373,
0.7388911247253418,
0.6733059287071228,
0.01977252960205078,
0.8078823089599609,
-0.09727178514003754,
0.25588998198509216,
0.04553896188735962,
0.12848308682441711,
-0.13010816276073456,
-0.1661301702260971,
-0.2382834255695343,
-0.25473445653915405,
0.5254090428352356,
-0.5111498832702637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00571v1
|
Explainable Multi-hop Question Generation: An End-to-End Approach without Intermediate Question Labeling
| 2024-03-31T06:03:54 | 2024-03-31T06:03:54 |
Seonjeong Hwang, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In response to the increasing use of interactive artificial intelligence, the
demand for the capacity to handle complex questions has increased. Multi-hop
question generation aims to generate complex questions that requires multi-step
reasoning over several documents. Previous studies have predominantly utilized
end-to-end models, wherein questions are decoded based on the representation of
context documents. However, these approaches lack the ability to explain the
reasoning process behind the generated multi-hop questions. Additionally, the
question rewriting approach, which incrementally increases the question
complexity, also has limitations due to the requirement of labeling data for
intermediate-stage questions. In this paper, we introduce an end-to-end
question rewriting model that increases question complexity through sequential
rewriting. The proposed model has the advantage of training with only the final
multi-hop questions, without intermediate questions. Experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our model in generating complex questions,
particularly 3- and 4-hop questions, which are appropriately paired with input
answers. We also prove that our model logically and incrementally increases the
complexity of questions, and the generated multi-hop questions are also
beneficial for training question answering models.
|
[
-0.5727925300598145,
-1.3008313179016113,
0.67998868227005,
-0.048387229442596436,
-0.18308141827583313,
0.07970821857452393,
0.181305393576622,
-0.5798584222793579,
-0.10925102978944778,
0.5336138010025024,
-0.9351865649223328,
0.04846154898405075,
-0.4157041609287262,
0.43720194697380066,
-0.46592193841934204,
1.124813437461853,
-0.1957351565361023,
-0.33906498551368713,
-0.3455406427383423,
-0.022924022749066353,
-0.43461987376213074,
-0.3094151020050049,
-1.0836294889450073,
-0.1805732250213623,
0.7870699167251587,
0.7515547275543213,
0.5812574028968811,
0.48898446559906006,
0.28322097659111023,
0.3445359766483307,
-0.1081208661198616,
0.15064875781536102,
-0.25284475088119507,
0.40199393033981323,
0.11897892504930496,
-0.6849873065948486,
-0.24806730449199677,
-0.025308066979050636,
0.6197360157966614,
1.0587120056152344,
0.16197971999645233,
0.317966103553772,
-0.42311355471611023,
0.642906665802002,
-0.2340865135192871,
-0.3130701780319214,
-0.7342296838760376,
-0.0738210529088974,
0.10611989349126816,
-0.6342819333076477,
-0.4374905824661255,
-0.2873786687850952,
0.15328149497509003,
-0.4717777669429779,
0.11484845727682114,
0.09237595647573471,
0.5776858329772949,
0.18970702588558197,
-0.7154831290245056,
-0.5462040305137634,
-0.7748984098434448,
0.18849961459636688,
-0.48660585284233093,
0.3065562844276428,
0.12478294968605042,
0.4853406548500061,
-0.30597564578056335,
-0.8303212523460388,
-0.861763596534729,
-0.134642094373703,
0.11948557943105698,
0.26360583305358887,
0.15121278166770935,
-0.03565410524606705,
0.46211904287338257,
0.06767681986093521,
-0.7139683961868286,
-0.3499727249145508,
-0.3340921103954315,
0.15465684235095978,
0.315693736076355,
0.21577773988246918,
0.2800304591655731,
0.03929249197244644,
-0.31267020106315613,
0.1346512734889984,
-0.4884674847126007,
0.6642683744430542,
0.5571722388267517,
-0.0036944758612662554,
0.4423893094062805,
0.6304678320884705,
-0.2872820496559143,
0.9168542623519897,
0.2628074884414673,
-0.12239506095647812,
0.10619053244590759,
-0.5038332343101501,
0.003241503844037652,
-0.2584364712238312,
0.42096567153930664,
0.2954041659832001,
0.45705100893974304,
-0.14616985619068146,
0.1661674678325653,
-0.5113441348075867,
0.2101907730102539,
-0.8406299352645874,
0.2867673933506012,
0.6477882862091064,
-0.15404143929481506,
-0.21721413731575012,
-0.1685788631439209,
-0.31980547308921814,
0.2853694260120392,
-0.33390793204307556,
0.40498244762420654,
-0.6619474291801453,
-0.062335055321455,
0.22875633835792542,
-0.4477538466453552,
0.7109378576278687,
0.4980980455875397,
-0.6323390603065491,
0.06008176878094673,
0.46936118602752686,
0.5586072206497192,
0.29874736070632935,
-0.5899062752723694,
-0.3972596526145935,
0.3812918961048126,
-0.4582999050617218,
0.942750096321106,
-0.664743959903717,
-0.12640486657619476,
-0.35830196738243103,
0.20020364224910736,
-0.11069539189338684,
-0.22062291204929352,
0.1937410980463028,
-0.8504096865653992,
0.5177836418151855,
-0.04997735098004341,
-0.663681149482727,
-0.22765964269638062,
0.7097017168998718,
-0.35504457354545593,
0.6766626238822937,
-0.06539903581142426,
-0.8649280071258545,
0.16451068222522736,
-0.5093970894813538,
-0.5418057441711426,
-0.06370436400175095,
-0.19747446477413177,
-0.4246939718723297,
-0.064395971596241,
0.21924816071987152,
0.12415959686040878,
-0.4889839291572571,
0.5603535771369934,
0.040111981332302094,
-0.23872512578964233,
0.36002713441848755,
-0.48359182476997375,
0.7093002796173096,
0.04815216362476349,
-0.1746070235967636,
0.09201615303754807,
-0.8119615316390991,
0.19100315868854523,
0.2669176459312439,
-0.7331933975219727,
-0.1432817578315735,
-0.16217917203903198,
-0.5704296231269836,
0.28356266021728516,
0.1654375046491623,
-0.5474368333816528,
0.22593140602111816,
-0.19183231890201569,
0.22256071865558624,
0.5613709688186646,
0.3707566261291504,
0.3813941180706024,
-0.6227428913116455,
0.6417295932769775,
0.0929536446928978,
0.22342868149280548,
-0.9136515855789185,
-0.8643573522567749,
-0.7004403471946716,
0.2911042273044586,
0.03756040707230568,
0.5866613984107971,
-0.7272882461547852,
0.15882983803749084,
0.050855934619903564,
-0.5507615208625793,
-0.37886226177215576,
-0.23313629627227783,
0.2483258694410324,
1.0489085912704468,
0.3776228427886963,
0.1677982062101364,
-0.4030560255050659,
-0.8197286128997803,
-0.45864149928092957,
-0.11849252879619598,
0.07366449385881424,
0.30775517225265503,
0.7105522155761719,
-0.004572265315800905,
0.8525431156158447,
-0.5643166303634644,
0.5750010013580322,
-0.36548492312431335,
0.511152446269989,
0.07108926773071289,
0.4975285232067108,
0.014762753620743752,
-0.9895207285881042,
-0.49781620502471924,
-0.2948881983757019,
-0.7007280588150024,
0.04281334951519966,
-0.828258752822876,
-0.26848548650741577,
-0.16608890891075134,
0.7303206920623779,
-0.7318053245544434,
0.26078060269355774,
-0.11380743980407715,
-0.3398344814777374,
0.7481229901313782,
-0.290576308965683,
0.23663899302482605,
-1.0968049764633179,
-0.022275997325778008,
-0.403261661529541,
-0.11801840364933014,
-0.8359237313270569,
0.1902616322040558,
-0.10743086040019989,
-0.304787814617157,
-0.16380572319030762,
0.24304157495498657,
-0.47849342226982117,
0.03770282864570618,
-0.2237885296344757,
-0.02858547493815422,
0.333532452583313,
0.6513378620147705,
0.0452081523835659,
0.4023277461528778,
0.38123759627342224,
-0.6132134795188904,
0.27736571431159973,
0.32285723090171814,
0.05199860408902168,
0.22993367910385132,
-0.9561613202095032,
0.3350884020328522,
-0.6347982883453369,
0.6520434021949768,
-1.306810975074768,
-0.2580438256263733,
0.20748703181743622,
-0.9259248971939087,
0.16992701590061188,
-0.14679734408855438,
-0.21716971695423126,
-0.26763996481895447,
-0.36294475197792053,
0.6003657579421997,
0.38830551505088806,
-0.3946055769920349,
0.47826364636421204,
-0.22890889644622803,
-0.32170337438583374,
-0.4084509313106537,
-0.3577782213687897,
0.029290977865457535,
-0.20877580344676971,
-0.9591919779777527,
0.24213071167469025,
-0.46465954184532166,
0.06527044624090195,
-0.15898288786411285,
0.06448576599359512,
-0.1818772554397583,
-0.044770099222660065,
-0.16135764122009277,
-0.12740781903266907,
-0.1720479130744934,
0.15246091783046722,
0.4168889820575714,
-0.22462508082389832,
0.26186874508857727,
-0.35127168893814087,
0.3392065167427063,
0.15821126103401184,
-0.34352293610572815,
-0.28857117891311646,
1.0137115716934204,
0.8452182412147522,
-0.40078169107437134,
0.7421880960464478,
0.46555811166763306,
-0.3540816903114319,
-0.1475113034248352,
-0.17405351996421814,
-0.08478759974241257,
-0.415330708026886,
0.2953706979751587,
-0.7095983028411865,
-0.7857595086097717,
0.5588343739509583,
-0.4913381040096283,
0.3433608412742615,
0.24344418942928314,
0.5796639919281006,
-0.3050483465194702,
1.0062841176986694,
0.3530813157558441,
0.7653342485427856,
0.24473175406455994,
-0.04169107973575592,
0.3005475401878357,
-0.7671789526939392,
-0.7014036178588867,
-0.4296143352985382,
-0.1971951425075531,
-0.2918233871459961,
-0.3546976149082184,
0.3762787878513336,
0.385476678609848,
-0.5598938465118408,
0.058878034353256226,
-0.3830982744693756,
0.46814826130867004,
0.7964796423912048,
0.01911749690771103,
0.34218472242355347,
-0.1756761372089386,
0.11557682603597641,
0.3870280086994171,
-0.6668524742126465,
-0.27630549669265747,
1.1549345254898071,
0.18696090579032898,
0.5193187594413757,
0.07458274066448212,
0.6894609928131104,
0.001110225566662848,
-0.26813241839408875,
-0.5811744332313538,
0.29378369450569153,
0.5680570006370544,
-0.7209851145744324,
-0.7868868708610535,
-0.252282053232193,
-0.9057378768920898,
0.40974727272987366,
-0.06632233411073685,
-0.39162391424179077,
-0.038655418902635574,
0.05500689521431923,
-0.5163095593452454,
0.19857218861579895,
-0.7284700870513916,
0.6440480351448059,
-0.4574306011199951,
-0.282189279794693,
0.4409785568714142,
-1.1359620094299316,
0.5086687803268433,
-0.20803648233413696,
0.1897871196269989,
0.2244013249874115,
0.10409804433584213,
0.8349520564079285,
-0.8368698954582214,
0.5690357685089111,
-0.09706147760152817,
-0.03205917775630951,
0.7614391446113586,
-0.05671799182891846,
0.6164407134056091,
0.1934211552143097,
0.1277932971715927,
-0.4459385871887207,
-0.27861320972442627,
-0.2861177325248718,
-0.7436470985412598,
0.20978115499019623,
-0.6323485374450684,
-0.7397811412811279,
-0.15465708076953888,
-0.8749901652336121,
-0.30207112431526184,
0.24750979244709015,
0.3885959982872009,
0.4604133665561676,
0.4752635359764099,
-0.04411645233631134,
0.6660912036895752,
-0.4968697428703308,
0.25065144896507263,
0.268694132566452,
0.04912132769823074,
-0.21462227404117584,
0.5846683979034424,
0.13286428153514862,
0.46039125323295593,
0.3018873631954193,
0.303142786026001,
-0.4001540243625641,
-0.44427186250686646,
-0.5938500165939331,
0.1146288737654686,
-0.69162517786026,
0.004144732374697924,
-1.0779505968093872,
-0.2012729048728943,
-0.5618669390678406,
-0.32045355439186096,
-0.15384970605373383,
-0.5436964631080627,
0.03529397398233414,
-0.11801564693450928,
0.35379379987716675,
0.423569917678833,
0.042751144617795944,
0.3937816619873047,
-0.5952565670013428,
0.875066876411438,
0.49773842096328735,
0.2657090425491333,
0.2714691162109375,
-0.7745054364204407,
-0.07565229386091232,
-0.06709717214107513,
-0.37231171131134033,
-0.998923122882843,
-0.09713953733444214,
0.25734707713127136,
0.38051334023475647,
0.1973504275083542,
0.14859604835510254,
0.9076027274131775,
-0.9383017420768738,
0.505540132522583,
0.2099892646074295,
-0.7346097230911255,
0.7040402889251709,
-0.32688504457473755,
0.36167001724243164,
0.5201635956764221,
0.6730315089225769,
-0.4349900186061859,
-0.34238478541374207,
-0.5606780052185059,
-1.2125728130340576,
0.6166498064994812,
0.19454504549503326,
0.07880996912717819,
-0.18044646084308624,
0.666580855846405,
0.4492441713809967,
0.10221874713897705,
-0.7805464267730713,
-0.2110522836446762,
-0.2209501564502716,
0.2268468141555786,
0.38499772548675537,
-0.28894248604774475,
0.13542652130126953,
-0.3520316481590271,
0.44208213686943054,
0.05636083707213402,
0.2592538297176361,
0.2611812353134155,
-0.011963062919676304,
-0.05956863984465599,
0.42331773042678833,
0.48477983474731445,
0.44827476143836975,
-0.3510206341743469,
0.07847357541322708,
-0.14932513236999512,
-0.004535140004009008,
0.30330145359039307,
-0.205033540725708,
-0.4447508752346039,
-0.05625182017683983,
0.5772246718406677,
0.5745032429695129,
-0.22727243602275848,
-0.5340149998664856,
0.3108675479888916,
-0.14323928952217102,
-0.5783025622367859,
-0.4250163733959198,
-0.1161155179142952,
0.4829559028148651,
0.2844015657901764,
0.29943814873695374,
-0.05866304785013199,
0.13595426082611084,
-0.7112853527069092,
0.43793055415153503,
0.22044073045253754,
0.030687205493450165,
-0.10839301347732544,
0.9328863620758057,
0.039015963673591614,
-0.486709862947464,
0.7764570116996765,
-0.10513507574796677,
-0.3692476153373718,
0.7772873044013977,
0.9106237292289734,
0.44856569170951843,
-0.2151688188314438,
0.2706622779369354,
0.5808120369911194,
0.4912460148334503,
0.26224055886268616,
0.6377549767494202,
-0.3410036265850067,
-0.5668137669563293,
-0.384994775056839,
-0.3734922707080841,
-0.685519814491272,
0.1932186633348465,
-0.6299989819526672,
0.14057253301143646,
-0.32787957787513733,
0.20290201902389526,
0.037992872297763824,
-0.5377792716026306,
-0.34095314145088196,
0.5787051320075989,
-0.10905534774065018,
0.9152728915214539,
-0.6464073061943054,
0.29645097255706787,
0.5574601292610168,
-0.7349861860275269,
-0.7939186692237854,
0.11318561434745789,
-0.48832330107688904,
-0.5472835302352905,
0.28775906562805176,
0.33622440695762634,
-0.07296428084373474,
0.08356904983520508,
-0.7560973167419434,
-0.9080753326416016,
1.0579016208648682,
0.14756476879119873,
-0.24169766902923584,
-0.4701974093914032,
0.4505619704723358,
0.3324447572231293,
-0.3970857858657837,
0.5638902187347412,
0.4456993043422699,
0.47519639134407043,
0.6883087754249573,
-0.13750475645065308,
0.1032026931643486,
-0.4192037284374237,
-0.25878021121025085,
-0.12587213516235352,
-0.34611737728118896,
1.2258001565933228,
-0.7969213128089905,
0.06410761177539825,
-0.11923882365226746,
0.554785966873169,
0.5185314416885376,
0.5379391312599182,
0.5729436874389648,
0.28301918506622314,
0.6656825542449951,
0.09076271206140518,
0.9037848711013794,
-0.39401566982269287,
0.08456794917583466,
1.4545764923095703,
-0.08311253786087036,
0.5940166115760803,
0.5995339155197144,
0.04023192822933197,
0.49986571073532104,
1.0611095428466797,
0.25299039483070374,
0.29183492064476013,
0.5310888290405273,
0.004850852303206921,
-0.4942821264266968,
0.13477438688278198,
-0.5216231942176819,
0.49826785922050476,
0.13292525708675385,
-0.10453157126903534,
-0.46209537982940674,
-0.09028836339712143,
0.004097262863069773,
-0.1732960194349289,
-0.02788117341697216,
0.7193974256515503,
-0.19785189628601074,
-0.9812494516372681,
0.5195831656455994,
-0.0074487654492259026,
0.2491685003042221,
-0.7169821262359619,
-0.17244204878807068,
-0.44963133335113525,
-0.3623775541782379,
-0.12016821652650833,
-0.8196641206741333,
0.3861147463321686,
0.21832378208637238,
-0.353860080242157,
-0.0654895156621933,
0.39857834577560425,
-0.5819301605224609,
-0.6327909827232361,
0.1768583208322525,
1.0061607360839844,
0.5100456476211548,
-0.08166658133268356,
-0.6873477101325989,
-0.4761558175086975,
-0.005918328184634447,
-0.7383673191070557,
-0.014845199882984161,
0.9647279381752014,
-0.1230689287185669,
0.8409396409988403,
0.8442884087562561,
-0.2951076328754425,
0.444263219833374,
0.1021822988986969,
0.8567622900009155,
-0.8379002213478088,
-0.5444628596305847,
-0.701554536819458,
0.8458739519119263,
0.12404245138168335,
-0.18734702467918396,
0.4788508713245392,
0.5136539936065674,
0.6687801480293274,
0.18248985707759857,
1.0159552097320557,
-0.12414057552814484,
0.4535459578037262,
-0.230625718832016,
0.2526280879974365,
-0.8024861216545105,
0.16316761076450348,
-0.3551081717014313,
-0.6069242358207703,
-0.2785591185092926,
0.24686701595783234,
0.12280416488647461,
0.13410153985023499,
0.7704835534095764,
0.3789125978946686,
0.11207585781812668,
0.04999339580535889,
0.3750278651714325,
0.06373021751642227,
0.6183692812919617,
0.7533894777297974,
0.8918564319610596,
-0.44008246064186096,
0.85374915599823,
-0.05410259962081909,
-0.3746931850910187,
0.30264317989349365,
-0.5728957056999207,
-0.8875762820243835,
-0.6476993560791016,
-0.10629187524318695,
-0.10845106840133667,
-0.33255472779273987,
0.4025591313838959,
0.1714629977941513,
-0.37293797731399536,
0.09043031185865402,
-0.3827379047870636,
0.24052052199840546,
0.01779955066740513,
-0.17136923968791962,
0.36448997259140015,
-0.6176496744155884,
-0.5247129201889038,
0.3112388253211975,
0.2802927494049072,
0.08558003604412079,
0.04973647743463516,
0.11336850374937057,
-0.6404227614402771,
0.2916662096977234,
0.7504652142524719,
0.20605610311031342,
-0.5617449283599854,
-0.24158187210559845,
0.33094313740730286,
0.445509135723114,
0.12717004120349884,
0.7851982712745667,
-0.5706394910812378,
0.455207496881485,
0.36249953508377075,
0.818365752696991,
0.3338310420513153,
0.3368995785713196,
0.48932355642318726,
-0.5411643385887146,
-0.22980786859989166,
0.03857443481683731,
0.25143274664878845,
0.1278841495513916,
-0.4801355302333832,
0.3499518036842346,
0.15934234857559204,
-0.5144327282905579,
-0.4353152811527252,
0.549660325050354,
-0.8158245086669922,
-0.5345163941383362,
1.0621527433395386,
-0.19829513132572174,
-0.04753272980451584,
-0.45941755175590515,
-0.22609685361385345,
0.5885759592056274,
-0.10440967977046967,
0.5054008960723877,
0.49191635847091675,
-0.8284757733345032,
-0.15182062983512878,
-0.4788883626461029,
0.04350889474153519,
0.28507640957832336,
-0.9343065619468689,
0.1477414071559906,
0.2993428111076355,
0.3204473853111267,
-0.029670340940356255,
0.9669031500816345,
-0.03413904458284378,
0.29086223244667053,
0.28351104259490967,
-0.1758991926908493,
-0.3719780147075653,
-0.6105328798294067,
0.12281587719917297,
0.573875367641449,
-0.11135242134332657,
-0.3693672716617584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00570v1
|
ParaICL: Towards Robust Parallel In-Context Learning
| 2024-03-31T05:56:15 | 2024-03-31T05:56:15 |
Xingxuan Li, Xuan-Phi Nguyen, Shafiq Joty, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become the norm in natural language
processing (NLP), excelling in few-shot in-context learning (ICL) with their
remarkable abilities. Nonetheless, the success of ICL largely hinges on the
choice of few-shot demonstration examples, making the selection process
increasingly crucial. Existing methods have delved into optimizing the quantity
and semantic similarity of these examples to improve ICL performances. However,
our preliminary experiments indicate that the effectiveness of ICL is limited
by the length of the input context. Moreover, varying combinations of few-shot
demonstration examples can significantly boost accuracy across different test
samples. To address this, we propose a novel method named parallel in-context
learning (ParaICL) that effectively utilizes all demonstration examples without
exceeding the manageable input context length. ParaICL employs parallel
batching to distribute demonstration examples into different batches according
to the semantic similarities of the questions in the demonstrations to the test
question. It then computes normalized batch semantic scores for each batch. A
weighted average semantic objective, constrained by adaptive plausibility, is
applied to select the most appropriate tokens. Through extensive experiments,
we validate the effectiveness of ParaICL and conduct ablation studies to
underscore its design rationale. We further demonstrate that ParaICL can
seamlessly integrate with existing methods.
|
[
-0.5110666751861572,
-0.7549465894699097,
0.559892475605011,
0.2955003082752228,
-0.5293199419975281,
0.011424705386161804,
-0.5075229406356812,
-0.10909659415483475,
-0.3088141083717346,
0.2980414628982544,
-0.30579873919487,
-0.8746752738952637,
-0.5236208438873291,
0.3893210291862488,
-0.40717819333076477,
1.130515456199646,
-0.17565849423408508,
0.002813667291775346,
-0.605798602104187,
-0.7242458462715149,
-0.3008227050304413,
-0.17716528475284576,
-0.7790928483009338,
-0.20513619482517242,
0.2634561359882355,
0.7217477560043335,
0.30607229471206665,
0.6665177345275879,
0.31965145468711853,
0.25353381037712097,
0.056839652359485626,
0.19733589887619019,
-0.2927168905735016,
0.0978812500834465,
-0.19639985263347626,
-0.40291091799736023,
0.06336383521556854,
-0.3356090784072876,
0.9315774440765381,
0.8926215171813965,
-0.05580988526344299,
0.282694548368454,
0.6452385783195496,
0.3632429838180542,
-0.6824881434440613,
0.1612492799758911,
-0.8268515467643738,
-0.22881753742694855,
-0.34243714809417725,
0.02605169638991356,
-0.44549545645713806,
-0.04066764935851097,
0.0011416625929996371,
-0.4961777627468109,
0.08155234903097153,
0.2646462917327881,
0.5316333174705505,
0.3945072591304779,
-0.26046475768089294,
-0.268148809671402,
-0.48247620463371277,
1.0973492860794067,
-0.8547582030296326,
0.3139975368976593,
0.27573877573013306,
0.44637805223464966,
-0.06339243054389954,
-0.8632044792175293,
-0.546934962272644,
-0.288381427526474,
-0.025777868926525116,
-0.24249626696109772,
0.13431422412395477,
0.13954506814479828,
0.486971914768219,
0.006828696932643652,
-0.701075553894043,
0.222723126411438,
-0.04631632938981056,
-0.11553329229354858,
0.06283634155988693,
0.3828871548175812,
0.2574654221534729,
0.1801515519618988,
-0.6708911061286926,
-0.17653445899486542,
-0.6833930015563965,
0.26366010308265686,
-0.05496731027960777,
0.46414345502853394,
-0.1698351800441742,
0.29984039068222046,
-0.4392503798007965,
0.9078410863876343,
0.03833756595849991,
-0.38925448060035706,
0.11093875020742416,
-0.3042721748352051,
-0.3428252637386322,
0.0033738072961568832,
0.8178436756134033,
0.11544954031705856,
-0.20759838819503784,
-0.17985422909259796,
-0.1754343956708908,
0.042340341955423355,
-0.03930690139532089,
-0.8941386938095093,
0.08764860033988953,
0.16499532759189606,
-0.31790468096733093,
-0.016040492802858353,
-0.11695019155740738,
-0.745266854763031,
-0.03734995424747467,
-0.3743184506893158,
0.40353459119796753,
-0.49492356181144714,
0.4364584982395172,
0.03461652994155884,
0.023426873609423637,
0.12528374791145325,
0.11189425736665726,
-0.8171913623809814,
0.7127798199653625,
0.7249135971069336,
0.8035380244255066,
-0.4086308479309082,
-0.7759589552879333,
-0.8440278768539429,
0.34687498211860657,
-0.23306450247764587,
0.7285763025283813,
-0.5382739305496216,
0.0030332119204103947,
-0.11157254129648209,
-0.3467196822166443,
-0.05826585739850998,
-0.7940829992294312,
0.4660966694355011,
-0.34690845012664795,
0.00178815599065274,
-0.3708746135234833,
-0.6009104251861572,
0.03933706507086754,
0.4065949022769928,
-0.16596311330795288,
0.7903666496276855,
-0.03793059289455414,
-0.9585601091384888,
0.6564706563949585,
-0.4351081848144531,
-0.27625903487205505,
0.037342414259910583,
-0.47167250514030457,
-0.41824138164520264,
-0.07813846319913864,
0.35180720686912537,
0.4982849955558777,
-0.45463839173316956,
0.17094866931438446,
-0.45187893509864807,
-0.5218595266342163,
-0.10863866657018661,
-0.3779061734676361,
0.5974392294883728,
-0.015310882590711117,
-0.4632103741168976,
0.3315739631652832,
-0.5667141675949097,
-0.2396940439939499,
-0.210597425699234,
-0.3936750292778015,
-0.39506030082702637,
-0.16052965819835663,
0.06558304280042648,
0.2911692261695862,
0.11559876799583435,
-0.6307846307754517,
-0.2467903047800064,
-0.7291198372840881,
0.045517537742853165,
0.4641585350036621,
-0.021885741502046585,
0.5949680209159851,
-0.4504455029964447,
0.27420657873153687,
0.06754782795906067,
0.20983880758285522,
0.025730904191732407,
-0.23426707088947296,
-0.617282509803772,
-0.439194917678833,
0.05442771688103676,
0.31086766719818115,
-0.8975310325622559,
0.2378692924976349,
-0.12214919924736023,
-0.16277450323104858,
-0.15809762477874756,
0.7030865550041199,
0.5191079378128052,
1.0958155393600464,
0.47056153416633606,
-0.14340506494045258,
-0.2929237186908722,
-0.9630199074745178,
-0.511358380317688,
-0.09901867806911469,
-0.24950683116912842,
0.35595616698265076,
0.25977879762649536,
0.14636246860027313,
1.0440435409545898,
-0.14519843459129333,
-0.38278886675834656,
-0.4216754138469696,
0.23150932788848877,
0.18539363145828247,
0.2582739293575287,
0.5557511448860168,
-0.5639551877975464,
-0.7989344596862793,
-0.09796522557735443,
-0.8782208561897278,
-0.07677517831325531,
-0.1330033540725708,
0.056098539382219315,
-0.026965243741869926,
0.6605160236358643,
-0.4427832067012787,
0.24001654982566833,
0.2405637949705124,
0.021359482780098915,
0.27457812428474426,
-0.3228377401828766,
-0.1935003399848938,
-1.0357862710952759,
-0.28594717383384705,
0.1283017098903656,
-0.33157065510749817,
-0.32527896761894226,
0.12081419676542282,
0.23669365048408508,
-0.0686306431889534,
-0.9332164525985718,
0.7028390765190125,
-0.14995470643043518,
-0.14278118312358856,
-0.6040153503417969,
0.04020952060818672,
-0.11811513453722,
0.4465174078941345,
-0.14803698658943176,
0.8270330429077148,
0.8674824833869934,
-0.6527385115623474,
0.14287680387496948,
0.21162229776382446,
-0.4580923020839691,
0.41800597310066223,
-0.39660659432411194,
0.011820235289633274,
-0.28198909759521484,
0.5871006846427917,
-0.8151884078979492,
-0.40648895502090454,
0.14277136325836182,
0.042079679667949677,
0.17145758867263794,
0.24260054528713226,
-0.4943332076072693,
-0.004424496553838253,
-0.2631513178348541,
0.6161626577377319,
0.5786507725715637,
-0.8362880945205688,
0.4443036615848541,
0.12021494656801224,
-0.04933162406086922,
-0.6208097338676453,
-0.5246283411979675,
0.005791776347905397,
-0.673590898513794,
-0.34583231806755066,
0.3407663106918335,
0.016975242644548416,
-0.33449795842170715,
-0.23188316822052002,
-0.07525309175252914,
-0.04279301315546036,
0.053077518939971924,
0.1169377937912941,
-0.08053024858236313,
-0.2038552612066269,
0.11115951091051102,
0.2107691913843155,
-0.027037419378757477,
-0.09518890082836151,
-0.33334338665008545,
0.42895522713661194,
-0.3785235583782196,
-0.4427911341190338,
-0.7270559668540955,
0.4589664041996002,
0.566914439201355,
-0.06462088972330093,
0.8120666146278381,
0.48170801997184753,
-0.5090389251708984,
-0.7220473289489746,
-0.30402636528015137,
-0.30528542399406433,
-0.4656422436237335,
0.22768846154212952,
-0.3549690544605255,
-0.8433200716972351,
0.3539360463619232,
-0.24306325614452362,
0.06826251745223999,
0.06757181882858276,
0.6143470406532288,
0.022920675575733185,
0.7821633815765381,
0.5298787355422974,
-0.10301762819290161,
0.34623879194259644,
-0.11663725227117538,
0.1061050146818161,
-0.7056058645248413,
0.017336023971438408,
-0.28485116362571716,
-0.184096559882164,
-0.13921771943569183,
-0.4155070185661316,
0.45454150438308716,
0.34336116909980774,
-0.37076669931411743,
0.38626745343208313,
-0.08307505398988724,
0.7337771654129028,
0.4931577742099762,
0.3519761562347412,
0.09699990600347519,
-0.0748002752661705,
-0.4309908151626587,
0.06732285767793655,
-0.5949431657791138,
-0.5484611988067627,
1.083642601966858,
0.1423369199037552,
0.4469897449016571,
-0.13375672698020935,
0.9189510345458984,
-0.21813488006591797,
0.41906461119651794,
-0.5244492888450623,
0.6266505122184753,
-0.31982117891311646,
-0.17118187248706818,
-0.41403844952583313,
-0.02202349528670311,
-0.600263237953186,
0.15618132054805756,
0.04091709479689598,
-0.8662655353546143,
-0.009502733126282692,
0.18114052712917328,
-0.5290367603302002,
0.27712854743003845,
-0.4333362877368927,
0.9186601042747498,
-0.05182979255914688,
-0.5970033407211304,
-0.30285632610321045,
-0.8045237064361572,
0.288087397813797,
-0.2107681930065155,
0.11022262275218964,
-0.04478335380554199,
-0.25714024901390076,
0.5255001783370972,
-0.48119884729385376,
0.8839275240898132,
-0.14635837078094482,
0.39047038555145264,
0.2836531400680542,
-0.11562872678041458,
0.591905951499939,
0.32584312558174133,
-0.13921011984348297,
-0.11488816887140274,
-0.1541191190481186,
-0.6411164402961731,
-0.780415952205658,
0.9988390803337097,
-0.3488430976867676,
-0.7183759212493896,
-0.09650050103664398,
-0.7797951698303223,
-0.5926984548568726,
-0.03731952980160713,
0.25594714283943176,
0.5714944005012512,
0.036449212580919266,
0.37727731466293335,
0.434524804353714,
-0.3580052852630615,
0.7179417014122009,
0.13350136578083038,
0.08840852975845337,
-0.26762598752975464,
0.8615286946296692,
-0.22902943193912506,
0.33917611837387085,
0.4520252048969269,
0.5103599429130554,
-0.3799528181552887,
-0.9017172455787659,
-0.34977200627326965,
0.1304180920124054,
-0.8773192763328552,
-0.10227484256029129,
-0.664076030254364,
0.15815111994743347,
-0.21761180460453033,
-0.2611004710197449,
-0.24493153393268585,
0.12703301012516022,
-0.2486850619316101,
0.06618939340114594,
0.010280597023665905,
0.3252241611480713,
0.2531448304653168,
0.2579214870929718,
-0.4786260426044464,
0.4108625054359436,
0.43401989340782166,
0.24360930919647217,
0.0008879472152329981,
-0.35307127237319946,
-0.019850948825478554,
-0.15035249292850494,
-0.2208913266658783,
-0.5243944525718689,
0.308779776096344,
0.327840119600296,
0.531121015548706,
0.4418849050998688,
0.3450697660446167,
0.6897678971290588,
-0.5600296854972839,
0.6296564936637878,
0.00004332073876867071,
-0.8201093673706055,
0.4344373047351837,
-0.4074156880378723,
0.34080061316490173,
1.0467201471328735,
0.5696149468421936,
-0.15071111917495728,
-0.5470206141471863,
-0.44925209879875183,
-0.8642095327377319,
0.5356025695800781,
0.0340009406208992,
-0.02867521159350872,
-0.24787163734436035,
0.2082759439945221,
0.36008504033088684,
-0.037335172295570374,
-0.6132447123527527,
-0.13152626156806946,
0.2555878162384033,
-0.5416867733001709,
-0.14016303420066833,
0.028985442593693733,
-0.19058187305927277,
-0.35028019547462463,
0.36174899339675903,
-0.4515574872493744,
-0.26314449310302734,
0.07933919131755829,
-0.2524028718471527,
0.3729587495326996,
0.18242967128753662,
0.4788738489151001,
0.8688897490501404,
-0.1835176646709442,
0.23080769181251526,
0.730800449848175,
-0.04600872844457626,
0.042149532586336136,
-0.15685893595218658,
0.033930934965610504,
-0.10247451066970825,
0.3160402774810791,
0.8217136263847351,
0.39437177777290344,
-0.855056881904602,
0.8039769530296326,
-0.05505910515785217,
-0.09344891458749771,
-0.14167456328868866,
-0.25168460607528687,
-0.08392416685819626,
0.3941863477230072,
0.10347520560026169,
0.08826600760221481,
0.3153822422027588,
-0.3692125678062439,
0.6283051371574402,
0.42323753237724304,
-0.33055612444877625,
-0.038394004106521606,
0.8113789558410645,
-0.03125377371907234,
-0.3200540840625763,
0.4685884714126587,
-0.2612888813018799,
-0.23474586009979248,
0.6308233141899109,
0.7704106569290161,
0.8367050290107727,
0.21870456635951996,
0.053494397550821304,
0.19210459291934967,
-0.15393391251564026,
-0.27700501680374146,
-0.14446020126342773,
-0.536451518535614,
-0.5101927518844604,
-0.38825032114982605,
-0.8382505774497986,
-0.4929865896701813,
0.08276877552270889,
-0.5170406103134155,
0.5198331475257874,
-0.6698064208030701,
0.38176074624061584,
-0.17061759531497955,
-0.3246424198150635,
-0.7149162292480469,
0.08342200517654419,
0.25304850935935974,
0.883425235748291,
-1.165836215019226,
1.2249692678451538,
0.6084786057472229,
-0.21932901442050934,
-0.7766203880310059,
0.5147830843925476,
0.004050570540130138,
-0.4822402596473694,
0.8210949301719666,
0.34549838304519653,
0.08520438522100449,
-0.019344985485076904,
-0.20521169900894165,
-0.6116600036621094,
1.0859733819961548,
0.6105238795280457,
-0.3631698787212372,
0.13304893672466278,
0.2690061926841736,
0.5284030437469482,
-0.603382408618927,
0.2671397030353546,
0.45754972100257874,
0.008031047880649567,
0.09323461353778839,
-0.7883871793746948,
0.1400129348039627,
0.3045816421508789,
0.13233055174350739,
0.06882299482822418,
-0.642869770526886,
0.6401965022087097,
0.07101742178201675,
-0.06295725703239441,
0.12489305436611176,
0.751347005367279,
0.7486097812652588,
0.6190096139907837,
0.7422469258308411,
0.48693299293518066,
0.4573764204978943,
0.2926357686519623,
1.2940443754196167,
-0.26103514432907104,
0.16484087705612183,
1.1630923748016357,
-0.4041730463504791,
0.996294379234314,
0.7248988151550293,
-0.03618216514587402,
0.335746705532074,
0.5776320099830627,
0.38862502574920654,
0.7089771628379822,
0.1714521050453186,
-0.7293664216995239,
-0.39274537563323975,
-0.25283074378967285,
0.2624984383583069,
0.3718697726726532,
0.29278287291526794,
-0.18262414634227753,
-0.7510393857955933,
0.5520685911178589,
-0.33031943440437317,
0.42261770367622375,
-0.10653192549943924,
0.6793705224990845,
0.20289397239685059,
-0.5756961107254028,
0.5623104572296143,
-0.10948134958744049,
0.8148144483566284,
-0.3943956792354584,
-0.05858847498893738,
-0.2811541259288788,
0.2834426760673523,
0.1008128821849823,
-0.3385010361671448,
0.5247549414634705,
-0.10419067740440369,
-0.06919165700674057,
-0.3319675624370575,
0.5306553244590759,
-0.34120142459869385,
-0.3242136836051941,
0.4282149076461792,
0.2639743387699127,
0.25852304697036743,
-0.03947015479207039,
-0.6508863568305969,
0.004811280407011509,
-0.2650119364261627,
0.0918288454413414,
0.8495863080024719,
0.23163224756717682,
-0.3525007963180542,
0.6291552782058716,
0.38413938879966736,
-0.1205172911286354,
0.08645256608724594,
0.12502771615982056,
0.789850652217865,
-0.328721284866333,
-0.3465079963207245,
-1.0092263221740723,
0.29922306537628174,
-0.05360616743564606,
-0.38117337226867676,
0.8207352757453918,
0.756554365158081,
1.19347083568573,
0.034631866961717606,
0.517815113067627,
0.25706568360328674,
0.4994571805000305,
-0.507766842842102,
0.37194913625717163,
-0.4604039788246155,
0.4734414219856262,
-0.14152562618255615,
-0.8998098373413086,
-0.582706093788147,
0.22518792748451233,
-0.22576867043972015,
-0.31803610920906067,
1.034824252128601,
0.8426202535629272,
-0.2639629542827606,
-0.14685414731502533,
0.5453919768333435,
-0.08533819019794464,
0.13372014462947845,
0.7134734392166138,
0.6813977360725403,
-0.3039524555206299,
0.5660585165023804,
-0.6608344316482544,
-0.24942070245742798,
0.20278871059417725,
-0.801447331905365,
-1.0837249755859375,
-0.5101844072341919,
-0.3317464590072632,
-0.02358735352754593,
0.1768055558204651,
1.0892393589019775,
0.5919404029846191,
-0.9051135182380676,
-0.4213935136795044,
-0.5245905518531799,
0.05392172932624817,
-0.2690166234970093,
-0.17521421611309052,
0.44653910398483276,
-0.7723669409751892,
-0.9649327397346497,
0.6958891749382019,
0.43590304255485535,
-0.2882353961467743,
0.19826598465442657,
-0.05845816060900688,
-0.19831031560897827,
-0.2343674749135971,
0.44937390089035034,
0.4072713851928711,
-0.9471690654754639,
-0.2677929997444153,
-0.4275000989437103,
-0.05858907848596573,
0.02914951741695404,
0.6785640120506287,
-0.9855329394340515,
0.26487162709236145,
0.6612738370895386,
1.1113507747650146,
0.4302496314048767,
0.12051176279783249,
0.4975542724132538,
-0.9274800419807434,
0.4652787446975708,
0.2712600529193878,
0.4043445885181427,
0.23731957376003265,
-0.08379336446523666,
-0.019745588302612305,
0.14413028955459595,
-0.5237424373626709,
-0.8055814504623413,
0.10888160020112991,
-0.9638029336929321,
-0.43580636382102966,
1.1811258792877197,
-0.27863508462905884,
-0.3301003873348236,
-0.23723365366458893,
-0.03293861076235771,
0.24960683286190033,
-0.1765715777873993,
0.5237312912940979,
0.48041802644729614,
-0.38452044129371643,
-0.11543461680412292,
-0.5121917128562927,
0.540242612361908,
0.628783643245697,
-0.7579948902130127,
-0.0550672672688961,
0.058290500193834305,
0.5064120888710022,
-0.22919006645679474,
0.2892385721206665,
-0.016645079478621483,
0.10857362300157547,
-0.03245416283607483,
-0.33612194657325745,
-0.004777250345796347,
-0.42661985754966736,
-0.5802081823348999,
0.5297489166259766,
0.36444008350372314,
-0.42493826150894165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00569v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00569v1
|
CM-TTS: Enhancing Real Time Text-to-Speech Synthesis Efficiency through Weighted Samplers and Consistency Models
| 2024-03-31T05:38:08 | 2024-03-31T05:38:08 |
Xiang Li, Fan Bu, Ambuj Mehrish, Yingting Li, Jiale Han, Bo Cheng, Soujanya Poria
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Neural Text-to-Speech (TTS) systems find broad applications in voice
assistants, e-learning, and audiobook creation. The pursuit of modern models,
like Diffusion Models (DMs), holds promise for achieving high-fidelity,
real-time speech synthesis. Yet, the efficiency of multi-step sampling in
Diffusion Models presents challenges. Efforts have been made to integrate GANs
with DMs, speeding up inference by approximating denoising distributions, but
this introduces issues with model convergence due to adversarial training. To
overcome this, we introduce CM-TTS, a novel architecture grounded in
consistency models (CMs). Drawing inspiration from continuous-time diffusion
models, CM-TTS achieves top-quality speech synthesis in fewer steps without
adversarial training or pre-trained model dependencies. We further design
weighted samplers to incorporate different sampling positions into model
training with dynamic probabilities, ensuring unbiased learning throughout the
entire training process. We present a real-time mel-spectrogram generation
consistency model, validated through comprehensive evaluations. Experimental
results underscore CM-TTS's superiority over existing single-step speech
synthesis systems, representing a significant advancement in the field.
|
[
-0.18645818531513214,
-0.5949428081512451,
0.5954632759094238,
0.37066489458084106,
-0.1297014206647873,
0.3819185793399811,
-0.3047071099281311,
-0.030923783779144287,
0.1512506902217865,
0.13471335172653198,
-0.3989231586456299,
-0.6249545812606812,
-0.7003788352012634,
0.06908756494522095,
-0.6560922265052795,
0.8923035264015198,
0.26965925097465515,
0.33188894391059875,
0.1022828221321106,
0.0731615275144577,
-0.2523089349269867,
-0.2877267599105835,
-1.037257194519043,
-0.19505760073661804,
0.5112159848213196,
0.004379198886454105,
0.6082018613815308,
0.6330888867378235,
0.010313316248357296,
0.24625521898269653,
-0.2527805268764496,
0.238050177693367,
-0.12204986810684204,
0.474027544260025,
0.18206849694252014,
-0.4449940025806427,
-0.712566614151001,
0.0018100071465596557,
0.836130678653717,
0.6531532406806946,
-0.4511604309082031,
-0.06346099823713303,
0.25384432077407837,
0.5631557106971741,
-0.6781721115112305,
-0.29770565032958984,
-0.6944675445556641,
0.1979464441537857,
0.11454848945140839,
0.02685960941016674,
-0.5437347888946533,
-0.6038843393325806,
0.21321474015712738,
-0.8221640586853027,
0.32576265931129456,
-0.38829299807548523,
0.4464515149593353,
0.32322895526885986,
-0.37120017409324646,
-0.15334199368953705,
-0.7395039796829224,
0.6678395867347717,
-0.8460424542427063,
0.7704270482063293,
0.04146409407258034,
0.369212806224823,
-0.00479399599134922,
-0.953709065914154,
-0.6825977563858032,
-0.4194999039173126,
0.260196715593338,
0.24308083951473236,
0.003339706687256694,
0.09272751957178116,
-0.15727093815803528,
-0.131772980093956,
-0.34904202818870544,
-0.07860701531171799,
-0.06234850734472275,
-0.25976553559303284,
0.1558370590209961,
0.037219975143671036,
0.08542581647634506,
0.050501059740781784,
-0.27550429105758667,
-0.2074391394853592,
-0.6347918510437012,
-0.2870534062385559,
0.3383094072341919,
0.45386719703674316,
-0.25185254216194153,
0.5014674663543701,
0.261264443397522,
0.826616644859314,
0.29862865805625916,
-0.28117653727531433,
0.07098549604415894,
-0.360315203666687,
-0.3479110598564148,
0.0085456483066082,
0.8949748873710632,
-0.03030978888273239,
0.22224485874176025,
-0.2824413478374481,
-0.2797049283981323,
0.0838683694601059,
0.4586106240749359,
-0.7512449026107788,
-0.03509989380836487,
0.20879395306110382,
-0.28084301948547363,
-0.5689128041267395,
0.1176254153251648,
-0.6750922203063965,
0.004309330601245165,
-0.5343675017356873,
0.5631734132766724,
-0.49488046765327454,
-0.3787803649902344,
-0.07035540789365768,
-0.32426729798316956,
-0.32648465037345886,
0.15788713097572327,
-0.6667275428771973,
0.48993608355522156,
0.6243221759796143,
1.0212466716766357,
-0.4571492075920105,
-0.2228693813085556,
-0.7562044858932495,
0.1605885773897171,
-0.7541258931159973,
0.3545292615890503,
-0.18609744310379028,
-0.48606255650520325,
-0.18054607510566711,
-0.2950003743171692,
-0.05615641549229622,
-0.8295782804489136,
0.37954649329185486,
-0.3231937885284424,
0.049239806830883026,
-0.16768647730350494,
-0.5911317467689514,
0.41685712337493896,
0.2618575692176819,
-0.25400084257125854,
1.1186147928237915,
0.11104793101549149,
-0.32097968459129333,
0.28838831186294556,
-0.45235440135002136,
-0.38253921270370483,
-0.2740093767642975,
-0.10388659685850143,
-0.5776533484458923,
0.23985745012760162,
-0.1414693295955658,
0.2530302405357361,
-0.19263719022274017,
0.6639842391014099,
-0.06797128915786743,
-0.38949960470199585,
0.18765608966350555,
-0.8841179013252258,
0.6135850548744202,
0.5993927717208862,
-0.5559691786766052,
0.029714057222008705,
-1.0881400108337402,
0.10193522274494171,
-0.2186252772808075,
-0.5777304768562317,
-0.23024646937847137,
0.08972999453544617,
0.33766937255859375,
0.03912029787898064,
0.11414282768964767,
-0.6124288439750671,
-0.020769139751791954,
-0.23666906356811523,
0.5315006375312805,
0.48042529821395874,
-0.16415663063526154,
0.5191125273704529,
-0.2798519432544708,
0.45909813046455383,
0.14308561384677887,
0.030962178483605385,
-0.07856877148151398,
-0.4020695984363556,
-0.5457401871681213,
-0.5158950090408325,
0.6959224343299866,
0.5133460164070129,
-0.6985810399055481,
0.7421632409095764,
-0.5188961625099182,
-0.5506638884544373,
-0.5486181378364563,
-0.370318740606308,
0.4952596127986908,
0.5953371524810791,
0.32007986307144165,
-0.23851998150348663,
-0.5077388286590576,
-0.4427376091480255,
-0.026188986375927925,
-0.016888581216335297,
-0.6573896408081055,
-0.14937341213226318,
0.07548387348651886,
0.0520942285656929,
1.0519912242889404,
-0.22030575573444366,
-0.00044067297130823135,
0.10377425700426102,
0.19509291648864746,
-0.17133378982543945,
0.7374078035354614,
0.5615922212600708,
-0.7240119576454163,
-0.5048412084579468,
-0.3491969108581543,
-0.542173445224762,
-0.18057961761951447,
0.06945635378360748,
0.004929369781166315,
0.015064941719174385,
0.745924711227417,
-0.4432143270969391,
0.25788283348083496,
0.7619999051094055,
-0.2469956874847412,
0.6153351664543152,
-0.32764458656311035,
0.2537497282028198,
-1.2867763042449951,
0.12056643515825272,
-0.015285195782780647,
-0.3899097442626953,
-0.7834500670433044,
-0.17988616228103638,
0.0608799047768116,
-0.14754584431648254,
-0.46746569871902466,
0.46747225522994995,
-0.20748524367809296,
-0.2480456531047821,
-0.2364383488893509,
0.18738900125026703,
0.20554021000862122,
0.27975741028785706,
-0.03893900662660599,
1.0502150058746338,
0.5123046040534973,
-0.9042514562606812,
0.04030189663171768,
0.0727207139134407,
-0.050671204924583435,
1.0362112522125244,
-0.7943817377090454,
-0.03654252365231514,
-0.0012530270032584667,
0.3013556897640228,
-1.0182511806488037,
0.046392761170864105,
0.04596433416008949,
-0.6519841551780701,
0.32121798396110535,
-0.30059006810188293,
-0.3569353520870209,
0.03445086255669594,
-0.08801376074552536,
0.47093844413757324,
0.6446416974067688,
-0.501923143863678,
0.7935338020324707,
0.18465246260166168,
-0.13322877883911133,
-0.47401100397109985,
-1.0260924100875854,
0.1445559859275818,
0.0905897244811058,
-0.1621987372636795,
0.7019190192222595,
-0.27168935537338257,
-0.2418973594903946,
-0.0442848838865757,
-0.14419129490852356,
-0.17728298902511597,
-0.12598155438899994,
-0.06387333571910858,
0.11787576973438263,
-0.1077854335308075,
-0.057690445333719254,
0.15228457748889923,
0.01646539568901062,
-0.22905230522155762,
-0.9649835824966431,
0.42722100019454956,
0.5361583828926086,
-0.522249162197113,
-0.818365752696991,
0.15623785555362701,
0.97867751121521,
0.11269247531890869,
0.5973581671714783,
0.6556477546691895,
-0.30115097761154175,
-0.06725107133388519,
-0.44535356760025024,
-0.08419764786958694,
-0.4436715245246887,
0.25586196780204773,
-0.3004887104034424,
-0.5406111478805542,
0.3919523060321808,
0.07069466263055801,
0.15006963908672333,
0.4134986400604248,
0.4409247636795044,
-0.01908000186085701,
1.0115139484405518,
0.35503408312797546,
0.1343103051185608,
0.8535272479057312,
-0.07516413182020187,
-0.18409906327724457,
-0.7327701449394226,
-0.32024458050727844,
-0.5702036023139954,
-0.23697814345359802,
-0.4837726354598999,
-0.4148976802825928,
0.8557947874069214,
-0.3504338562488556,
-0.4086422622203827,
0.15254728496074677,
-0.6879582405090332,
0.09192609041929245,
0.7972564697265625,
0.25876516103744507,
0.1851891577243805,
0.23716890811920166,
-0.48700422048568726,
-0.16624920070171356,
-0.7263240814208984,
-0.3643494248390198,
1.158430576324463,
0.06482373178005219,
0.5491936206817627,
0.021527549251914024,
0.5851303339004517,
0.5076496005058289,
0.1992332935333252,
-0.7404080033302307,
0.5132476091384888,
-0.47899746894836426,
-0.3746802508831024,
-0.14376872777938843,
-0.6046516299247742,
-0.8172368407249451,
0.09283237159252167,
-0.34246060252189636,
-0.1255049854516983,
0.07096963375806808,
0.3249943256378174,
-0.3253164291381836,
0.533281683921814,
-0.5433385968208313,
0.45662984251976013,
0.24434314668178558,
-0.31882575154304504,
-0.029820529744029045,
-0.6634271740913391,
0.11417099088430405,
0.09287901967763901,
0.08212731033563614,
0.14186207950115204,
-0.08841549605131149,
0.6939433813095093,
-0.5022407174110413,
0.6941386461257935,
-0.5023140907287598,
-0.2511008381843567,
0.42188259959220886,
0.26040080189704895,
0.41237178444862366,
-0.06831324100494385,
-0.2958903908729553,
-0.08597675710916519,
0.025753919035196304,
-0.30352264642715454,
-0.4338342845439911,
0.5551816821098328,
-0.5262730121612549,
0.012161132879555225,
-0.030310196802020073,
-0.5196577906608582,
-0.27331939339637756,
0.14059707522392273,
0.4177207946777344,
0.7537330389022827,
-0.39537540078163147,
0.18461842834949493,
0.9549804925918579,
-0.05277428403496742,
0.32153332233428955,
0.29085561633110046,
0.10449019074440002,
-0.9227340817451477,
0.7634729146957397,
0.19664521515369415,
0.6900365352630615,
0.49638354778289795,
0.006541876588016748,
-0.23708069324493408,
-0.7911832332611084,
-0.6211381554603577,
-0.11431794613599777,
-0.35584986209869385,
-0.06522185355424881,
-0.5256096124649048,
-0.26853859424591064,
-0.6577492356300354,
-0.12905138731002808,
-0.8045521378517151,
-0.5755620002746582,
-0.47115135192871094,
0.09736844897270203,
0.09205519407987595,
0.5678908228874207,
-0.01801859401166439,
0.5628292560577393,
-0.8840792179107666,
0.723061203956604,
0.40778404474258423,
0.388288676738739,
0.02136058546602726,
-0.7755800485610962,
-0.20957283675670624,
0.27274420857429504,
-0.35073375701904297,
-0.7807782292366028,
0.33736589550971985,
0.11293596774339676,
0.26584377884864807,
0.026155948638916016,
-0.24918290972709656,
0.48461225628852844,
-0.8415488600730896,
0.9077188372612,
0.18497568368911743,
-1.0057947635650635,
0.14388565719127655,
-0.3925268054008484,
0.49120399355888367,
0.47620531916618347,
0.10339222103357315,
-0.6079438924789429,
-0.5993378758430481,
-0.6124302744865417,
-0.7101645469665527,
0.23194706439971924,
0.41202810406684875,
-0.040139734745025635,
-0.10644042491912842,
0.5878893136978149,
-0.1587742418050766,
0.3742374777793884,
-0.336713045835495,
-0.32287925481796265,
-0.3732040226459503,
-1.0062808990478516,
-0.05892935395240784,
-0.007639310788363218,
-0.124175526201725,
0.010720636695623398,
0.7498385310173035,
-0.03551012650132179,
0.16416792571544647,
0.4182593524456024,
0.16491852700710297,
0.04595125466585159,
0.34946510195732117,
0.8364935517311096,
0.389833927154541,
-0.0373237319290638,
0.1898336261510849,
-0.05228409916162491,
-0.8082931637763977,
0.5131261944770813,
0.11510763317346573,
-0.506608247756958,
0.2573130130767822,
-0.1348801851272583,
0.6183117032051086,
0.273277223110199,
-0.47678616642951965,
0.47276467084884644,
-0.08960648626089096,
-0.4452533423900604,
-0.3281053602695465,
0.009503276087343693,
0.30407050251960754,
0.03932083770632744,
0.6134076714515686,
0.46527090668678284,
-0.13294686377048492,
-0.3136032521724701,
0.32988858222961426,
0.5206238627433777,
-0.3091753125190735,
-0.3142874836921692,
1.218604564666748,
0.061656832695007324,
-0.5423341393470764,
0.3219713866710663,
-0.1028570681810379,
-0.10591386258602142,
0.6145662665367126,
0.34713712334632874,
0.8792963027954102,
-0.397159218788147,
0.1357656717300415,
0.3640904724597931,
0.09331116080284119,
-0.5279399156570435,
0.3099711537361145,
-0.09456770122051239,
-0.3541051149368286,
-0.18691444396972656,
-0.7653795480728149,
-0.6968432664871216,
-0.2502627670764923,
-0.6694426536560059,
0.3650178909301758,
-0.5159615874290466,
-0.49260053038597107,
-0.06945107132196426,
-0.5263648629188538,
-0.29675957560539246,
0.7130864262580872,
-0.08028849959373474,
0.8623418211936951,
-0.5743249654769897,
0.8551543354988098,
0.14765778183937073,
0.04205163195729256,
-0.7559738755226135,
0.12224429100751877,
0.043859243392944336,
-0.35032713413238525,
0.16679272055625916,
-0.4226548373699188,
-0.2882513105869293,
0.43313175439834595,
-0.42121297121047974,
-0.6886025071144104,
1.106935977935791,
0.5936734080314636,
-0.7417309880256653,
-0.18919365108013153,
-0.12993963062763214,
0.6138073205947876,
-0.3898804187774658,
0.051082443445920944,
0.41568028926849365,
0.339540958404541,
0.18224625289440155,
-0.9221383333206177,
-0.19301466643810272,
0.17685258388519287,
0.031106961891055107,
0.007260151673108339,
-0.30529412627220154,
0.7148107290267944,
0.06634896248579025,
0.0929495245218277,
0.3736315369606018,
0.6509523987770081,
0.7619867324829102,
0.3065056800842285,
0.594228208065033,
0.6063179969787598,
0.6838153004646301,
-0.26806551218032837,
0.7097547054290771,
-0.26079225540161133,
0.08505497127771378,
1.0658611059188843,
-0.12892311811447144,
0.8903507590293884,
0.3847053349018097,
-0.36110955476760864,
0.4872739613056183,
0.2698137164115906,
0.08844169974327087,
0.5690421462059021,
0.16108562052249908,
-0.5180502533912659,
0.049683693796396255,
0.0511242151260376,
-0.17756600677967072,
0.18197374045848846,
0.25525057315826416,
-0.5095612406730652,
0.1530754566192627,
0.12876580655574799,
-0.08502623438835144,
0.25977176427841187,
-0.12865808606147766,
0.6612499952316284,
-0.23531630635261536,
-0.8801993131637573,
0.6602903604507446,
-0.10260839015245438,
1.1355732679367065,
-0.9615402817726135,
0.10250864923000336,
0.0456148125231266,
-0.08352123945951462,
0.06635461747646332,
-0.4541099965572357,
0.3619348406791687,
0.15722595155239105,
-0.3142746090888977,
-0.31342044472694397,
0.30039024353027344,
-0.7743427157402039,
-0.44159939885139465,
0.061733897775411606,
0.5520138144493103,
-0.07642190158367157,
-0.01133914664387703,
-0.44253629446029663,
0.010057387873530388,
-0.22778427600860596,
-0.26168909668922424,
0.28712764382362366,
0.470962256193161,
0.368761271238327,
0.4582628905773163,
0.6743597388267517,
0.4548352360725403,
0.35698869824409485,
0.38295602798461914,
0.39185231924057007,
-0.46264779567718506,
-0.6041465997695923,
-0.7122753262519836,
0.49833983182907104,
0.19916383922100067,
-0.05331534147262573,
0.44387033581733704,
0.6699944734573364,
0.5411328673362732,
0.05440583452582359,
0.921498715877533,
-0.058684222400188446,
0.6605784296989441,
-0.5867674350738525,
0.8047903776168823,
-0.6119895577430725,
0.2184293270111084,
-0.19827115535736084,
-0.8125491738319397,
-0.06609655171632767,
0.18110518157482147,
0.37772420048713684,
0.2431941032409668,
0.4613770544528961,
0.7550649642944336,
-0.18905910849571228,
-0.21340063214302063,
0.5724826455116272,
0.13319745659828186,
0.39988335967063904,
0.0996289998292923,
0.40748777985572815,
-0.5432954430580139,
0.7176427245140076,
0.03599623963236809,
-0.07768156379461288,
0.2183132916688919,
-0.8629504442214966,
-0.27625587582588196,
-0.5418393611907959,
-0.24788227677345276,
-0.5232685804367065,
0.2560456693172455,
0.9480077028274536,
1.0015583038330078,
-0.7897469997406006,
-0.2281261384487152,
-0.5569824576377869,
-0.08895035088062286,
-0.4314899742603302,
-0.2643606960773468,
0.18391761183738708,
-0.3921259045600891,
-1.2291126251220703,
0.7748449444770813,
0.20883291959762573,
0.5700482130050659,
-0.3161003291606903,
-0.024144647642970085,
-0.07134769856929779,
0.26866069436073303,
0.39129066467285156,
0.11967632174491882,
-0.6975878477096558,
-0.041085924953222275,
0.07081720978021622,
-0.32696518301963806,
0.23280730843544006,
0.8462744355201721,
-0.9243144989013672,
0.3925783038139343,
0.43631285429000854,
0.6010550260543823,
0.5298819541931152,
-0.11651033163070679,
0.7153276205062866,
-1.0305384397506714,
0.1415528953075409,
0.24849382042884827,
0.21718893945217133,
0.5488755106925964,
-0.09425066411495209,
0.28968366980552673,
0.4381592273712158,
-0.4582272171974182,
-0.7939286231994629,
0.22396329045295715,
-0.9728792905807495,
-0.2755127549171448,
0.9950037598609924,
-0.13406416773796082,
-0.04444664716720581,
-0.008280100300908089,
-0.07397740334272385,
0.8423863649368286,
-0.28007349371910095,
0.6985674500465393,
0.43759098649024963,
0.15789198875427246,
0.24811135232448578,
-0.5710914134979248,
0.5425922274589539,
0.4872760474681854,
-0.6476472616195679,
0.11004568636417389,
0.4915800392627716,
0.7683533430099487,
0.2876927852630615,
0.8185636401176453,
-0.22272716462612152,
0.23013246059417725,
0.14549590647220612,
-0.03018939308822155,
-0.03344603255391121,
-0.4987146556377411,
-0.3863227367401123,
0.42228642106056213,
-0.21315579116344452,
-0.28209376335144043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00566v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00566v3
|
CodeBenchGen: Creating Scalable Execution-based Code Generation Benchmarks
| 2024-03-31T05:20:53 | 2024-05-08T03:14:48 |
Yiqing Xie, Alex Xie, Divyanshu Sheth, Pengfei Liu, Daniel Fried, Carolyn Rose
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
To facilitate evaluation of code generation systems across diverse scenarios,
we present CodeBenchGen, a framework to create scalable execution-based
benchmarks that only requires light guidance from humans. Specifically, we
leverage a large language model (LLM) to convert an arbitrary piece of code
into an evaluation example, including test cases for execution-based
evaluation. We illustrate the usefulness of our framework by creating a
dataset, Exec-CSN, which includes 1,931 examples involving 293 libraries
revised from code in 367 GitHub repositories taken from the CodeSearchNet
dataset. To demonstrate the complexity and solvability of examples in Exec-CSN,
we present a human study demonstrating that 81.3% of the examples can be solved
by humans and 61% are rated as "requires effort to solve". We conduct code
generation experiments on open-source and proprietary models and analyze the
performance of both humans and models. We provide the code at
https://github.com/Veronicium/CodeBenchGen.
|
[
-0.16980420053005219,
-0.44579944014549255,
0.43262550234794617,
0.42844679951667786,
-0.05494356527924538,
0.22908087074756622,
-0.3825052082538605,
-0.3993833065032959,
-0.15814930200576782,
0.5323701500892639,
-0.42630571126937866,
-0.4633054733276367,
-0.048223815858364105,
-0.03066250868141651,
-0.588836669921875,
0.8356633186340332,
0.01122034341096878,
0.22102411091327667,
-0.3201213479042053,
-0.09939374774694443,
-0.05809679254889488,
-0.36062684655189514,
-0.3775659501552582,
-0.23646238446235657,
0.2351370006799698,
0.7447943687438965,
0.43158966302871704,
1.00579035282135,
0.5776669383049011,
0.22986596822738647,
0.06637490540742874,
-0.3043353259563446,
-0.6778756380081177,
0.04110610857605934,
-0.05636436492204666,
-0.5316153764724731,
-0.16676655411720276,
-0.013749911449849606,
0.25892072916030884,
0.8422315716743469,
-0.4158734679222107,
0.5481793284416199,
-0.2908265292644501,
0.5907503366470337,
-0.628811240196228,
0.012464698404073715,
-0.6056870818138123,
0.2586965262889862,
-0.0727391168475151,
-0.10946565866470337,
-0.32883304357528687,
-0.5410227179527283,
-0.18811540305614471,
-0.39875128865242004,
0.592575192451477,
0.1676141768693924,
0.4657212793827057,
0.22506877779960632,
-0.09232780337333679,
-0.22094286978244781,
-0.5925774574279785,
0.8497692942619324,
-0.6751586198806763,
-0.03625743091106415,
-0.08097127825021744,
0.6071231365203857,
-0.13861079514026642,
-1.042013168334961,
-0.2890249192714691,
-0.39082956314086914,
0.18848969042301178,
-0.06560881435871124,
-0.3048819899559021,
-0.09449280053377151,
0.760690450668335,
0.661654531955719,
-0.7685660719871521,
-0.020593270659446716,
-0.45000359416007996,
0.014031275175511837,
0.5463953614234924,
0.3972805142402649,
0.2566443681716919,
-0.16577644646167755,
-0.3193025588989258,
-0.502162754535675,
-0.7483581900596619,
-0.10863181948661804,
0.5900149941444397,
0.12412713468074799,
-0.1788497269153595,
0.4683118164539337,
-0.429831326007843,
0.5764898061752319,
-0.1197461262345314,
0.6145201325416565,
0.5445136427879333,
-0.5464383959770203,
-0.17780286073684692,
-0.04299694299697876,
0.5332640409469604,
0.44074341654777527,
0.05369974300265312,
-0.263308584690094,
-0.1909862458705902,
0.41061174869537354,
0.5426891446113586,
-1.254855751991272,
-0.3583780825138092,
0.15977352857589722,
-0.6118470430374146,
-0.7773094773292542,
0.07677970826625824,
-1.0680497884750366,
-0.6154366135597229,
-0.016093429177999496,
0.040006306022405624,
-0.17673951387405396,
-0.29416218400001526,
-0.004169981461018324,
-0.4659890830516815,
0.5224100947380066,
-0.0808783695101738,
-0.667299211025238,
0.43583551049232483,
0.6290256977081299,
0.5715111494064331,
-0.31065648794174194,
-0.2924806475639343,
-0.75250643491745,
-0.11359870433807373,
-0.3995092213153839,
0.5788681507110596,
-0.44801047444343567,
-0.6216413378715515,
-0.1039872094988823,
-0.0970408171415329,
0.36401355266571045,
-0.6932904124259949,
0.6999912261962891,
-0.31866681575775146,
-0.13596773147583008,
-0.23569047451019287,
-0.6613502502441406,
0.2424192726612091,
-0.08573132753372192,
-0.6585620045661926,
1.088837742805481,
0.39189672470092773,
-0.6060366034507751,
0.4490537941455841,
-0.771835207939148,
-0.4660932421684265,
0.4039325416088104,
-0.7095740437507629,
-0.2932467758655548,
0.5245698690414429,
-0.0662628784775734,
0.29501816630363464,
-0.5759909152984619,
0.13300415873527527,
-0.2498699277639389,
-0.5644472241401672,
-0.017863664776086807,
-0.06609872728586197,
0.6507278680801392,
0.5171378254890442,
-0.8797217607498169,
0.3668559789657593,
-0.9971347451210022,
0.6071643233299255,
0.2159440666437149,
-0.4479999244213104,
0.19293668866157532,
0.2876906991004944,
0.41832247376441956,
0.13636964559555054,
0.1315399408340454,
-0.5275726318359375,
0.15138472616672516,
-0.3533533811569214,
0.47209444642066956,
0.6259052157402039,
-0.07894375920295715,
0.3044019639492035,
-0.37335404753685,
0.8342004418373108,
-0.3031340539455414,
0.1214405968785286,
-0.3386554419994354,
-0.20239968597888947,
-0.6298428177833557,
0.00875924900174141,
0.17128747701644897,
0.43266990780830383,
-0.7473267316818237,
0.3718292713165283,
-0.41315847635269165,
-0.7425650358200073,
0.037177953869104385,
0.40424948930740356,
0.785576343536377,
0.4422258734703064,
0.12674760818481445,
-0.2490137368440628,
-0.7551937699317932,
-1.2082886695861816,
-0.39870157837867737,
-0.1794302761554718,
-0.17680060863494873,
0.4067400097846985,
0.5125786066055298,
-0.27805402874946594,
0.7786153554916382,
-0.5750563740730286,
0.47678276896476746,
-0.39887335896492004,
0.26860326528549194,
0.20695021748542786,
0.5850692987442017,
0.5868684649467468,
-0.8091956377029419,
-0.19035932421684265,
0.16408920288085938,
-0.7567156553268433,
-0.41364046931266785,
0.10049806535243988,
-0.09106925129890442,
0.05375954508781433,
0.9187222123146057,
0.1718941628932953,
0.3462432324886322,
0.8003742694854736,
-0.2964572310447693,
0.48620525002479553,
-0.3605968654155731,
0.2381346970796585,
-0.9883658289909363,
0.32287535071372986,
-0.1530046910047531,
-0.3775077760219574,
-0.2696914076805115,
0.6662849187850952,
0.24484817683696747,
-0.5825982689857483,
-0.41990411281585693,
0.2619144320487976,
-0.2879689633846283,
-0.45353755354881287,
-0.22191818058490753,
-0.09537579119205475,
-0.004819085355848074,
0.3102799952030182,
-0.16777274012565613,
1.063658595085144,
0.29436367750167847,
-0.4031766653060913,
0.32525166869163513,
-0.26814621686935425,
-0.7282682657241821,
0.25733762979507446,
-1.0214074850082397,
0.14335128664970398,
0.5371849536895752,
0.07456742972135544,
-0.7885427474975586,
-0.5366507768630981,
-0.22840416431427002,
-0.029642000794410706,
-0.08864299207925797,
0.03519921749830246,
-0.8997750878334045,
-0.4996514618396759,
-0.32384565472602844,
0.47084593772888184,
0.8469582200050354,
-0.6335133910179138,
0.32422488927841187,
0.12234947085380554,
-0.0039362055249512196,
-0.14190460741519928,
-0.7958652377128601,
0.21029557287693024,
-0.1433507651090622,
-0.8084791302680969,
0.490853875875473,
-0.45689237117767334,
-0.25770822167396545,
-0.0610491968691349,
-0.041027408093214035,
-0.07782196998596191,
0.29604220390319824,
0.4332579970359802,
0.09813854098320007,
-0.1601407378911972,
0.09272588789463043,
-0.10618788003921509,
-0.10904480516910553,
0.051579054445028305,
-0.15553903579711914,
0.40754127502441406,
-0.4724407494068146,
-0.45004111528396606,
0.08258281648159027,
0.4166458249092102,
0.49057936668395996,
-0.11801017075777054,
0.09974613785743713,
0.4202842116355896,
-0.21927711367607117,
-0.5968101024627686,
-0.49348393082618713,
-0.01201753132045269,
-0.42717498540878296,
0.44281962513923645,
-0.2348189800977707,
-0.8740817308425903,
0.5580087304115295,
-0.4679478406906128,
-0.06277652084827423,
0.11310842633247375,
0.7643635869026184,
0.33920642733573914,
0.9827225208282471,
0.6073446869850159,
0.14405319094657898,
0.5832605361938477,
-0.14882081747055054,
-0.16953034698963165,
-0.45398253202438354,
0.3096594214439392,
-0.6260503530502319,
-0.24572347104549408,
-0.5670230388641357,
-0.6457260251045227,
0.27147790789604187,
0.16026729345321655,
-0.09260953217744827,
0.7344787120819092,
-0.8022584915161133,
0.7651793360710144,
0.43752074241638184,
0.04061831533908844,
0.15379245579242706,
-0.10136295855045319,
-0.27593106031417847,
0.16101031005382538,
-0.7558275461196899,
-0.40201497077941895,
1.1641960144042969,
-0.028201300650835037,
0.7859684824943542,
0.04093406721949577,
0.8199324011802673,
0.5798806548118591,
0.35045865178108215,
-0.2661498785018921,
0.5454710125923157,
0.08014454692602158,
-0.7552798390388489,
-0.01858048141002655,
-0.9617326855659485,
-0.8172639608383179,
0.0639423131942749,
0.180019810795784,
-0.6451046466827393,
0.10643218457698822,
0.05984045937657356,
-0.25525015592575073,
-0.04407621920108795,
-1.1170024871826172,
1.2253191471099854,
-0.4756585955619812,
-0.5804951786994934,
-0.44284412264823914,
-0.4099336564540863,
0.3891160488128662,
-0.24692882597446442,
0.22097213566303253,
0.12498458474874496,
-0.04653417319059372,
0.6069000363349915,
-0.7643552422523499,
0.6009015440940857,
-0.28888484835624695,
0.047692157328128815,
0.27804407477378845,
-0.016646239906549454,
0.4837927222251892,
-0.025911379605531693,
-0.44705355167388916,
-0.011145626194775105,
-0.059633366763591766,
-0.5558239817619324,
-0.4757179617881775,
0.7787154912948608,
-0.5099878907203674,
-0.2316700667142868,
-0.13999715447425842,
-0.31315726041793823,
-0.01943817175924778,
0.24451875686645508,
0.47695332765579224,
0.48477157950401306,
-0.4329483211040497,
0.5161193609237671,
0.49143022298812866,
-0.40227481722831726,
0.41663306951522827,
0.4695611000061035,
-0.6234721541404724,
-0.2700727581977844,
0.8552617430686951,
-0.21046052873134613,
0.23367750644683838,
-0.08671984821557999,
0.1868005245923996,
0.20165114104747772,
-0.5949327349662781,
-0.6156309247016907,
-0.3169621527194977,
-0.6527475118637085,
-0.1217804104089737,
-0.2620348036289215,
0.15610627830028534,
-0.02409699559211731,
-0.45798057317733765,
-0.4027300179004669,
-0.24195067584514618,
0.16897869110107422,
-0.023000193759799004,
0.32183143496513367,
0.6890542507171631,
-0.0848420187830925,
0.23374825716018677,
-0.5198360085487366,
0.31290102005004883,
0.2423209846019745,
0.5481858253479004,
-0.10183408856391907,
-0.09926546365022659,
-0.532554030418396,
-0.2512429654598236,
-0.24199670553207397,
-0.4387836158275604,
0.09150078892707825,
-0.013615216128528118,
0.6016983389854431,
0.14360623061656952,
0.07611344009637833,
0.4738708436489105,
-0.4416683316230774,
0.7433114647865295,
0.18624651432037354,
-1.2674304246902466,
0.6103857755661011,
-0.46021923422813416,
0.4612291753292084,
0.9946773648262024,
-0.22152861952781677,
-0.20719125866889954,
-0.2693348526954651,
-0.6754937171936035,
-0.9068796038627625,
0.7547155022621155,
0.3744438886642456,
0.04523443803191185,
0.054447874426841736,
0.3900739550590515,
-0.10468301922082901,
0.35539892315864563,
-0.3911108374595642,
-0.10364829003810883,
0.05264155939221382,
-0.036596547812223434,
-0.06593551486730576,
0.06270763278007507,
-0.23772528767585754,
0.02300386130809784,
0.2760747969150543,
-0.2760087847709656,
0.0961662009358406,
0.06785841286182404,
-0.24120526015758514,
-0.26460620760917664,
0.1513548642396927,
0.6304324865341187,
0.9343050122261047,
-0.315702885389328,
-0.13487277925014496,
0.1697772741317749,
-0.27270787954330444,
0.002498897723853588,
0.19312000274658203,
0.019581403583288193,
-0.30576449632644653,
0.31846103072166443,
0.32095664739608765,
0.6695901155471802,
-1.1897555589675903,
0.7229803800582886,
-0.5023730993270874,
-0.272649884223938,
-0.37889447808265686,
0.45308297872543335,
0.2824955880641937,
0.20453006029129028,
0.5033635497093201,
0.04511207714676857,
0.12926903367042542,
-0.47789812088012695,
0.44801065325737,
0.023946216329932213,
-0.2774125337600708,
-0.036458518356084824,
0.719590961933136,
0.23415729403495789,
-0.24776265025138855,
0.34845370054244995,
-0.6211111545562744,
-0.36631831526756287,
0.9948006272315979,
0.2375560849905014,
1.0372596979141235,
0.2237783968448639,
-0.010405604727566242,
0.22937829792499542,
0.09146931767463684,
-0.10969468951225281,
0.44310808181762695,
-0.30597829818725586,
-0.3960733115673065,
-0.4338248670101166,
-0.6557341814041138,
-0.5918196439743042,
-0.31250423192977905,
-0.713742196559906,
0.32495367527008057,
-0.7090826034545898,
0.12488097697496414,
0.2050509750843048,
-0.02768271043896675,
-0.7125831246376038,
-0.10175295919179916,
0.047867752611637115,
1.1630473136901855,
-0.5434898138046265,
0.7382539510726929,
0.6324235200881958,
-0.5016716122627258,
-0.7458796501159668,
-0.07851506769657135,
-0.09924179315567017,
-0.5491566061973572,
0.6459687352180481,
0.17131873965263367,
-0.14125992357730865,
0.011793595738708973,
-0.8483312129974365,
-0.363940954208374,
1.1646391153335571,
0.5170062184333801,
-0.5856963396072388,
0.1313554346561432,
-0.1535864770412445,
0.7233464121818542,
-0.624706506729126,
0.2510562539100647,
0.3774799704551697,
0.41823408007621765,
-0.15179134905338287,
-0.443805456161499,
0.08205199986696243,
-0.5872247815132141,
0.4012339413166046,
0.0334363654255867,
-0.5760208964347839,
0.951084315776825,
-0.038129135966300964,
-0.2401115894317627,
0.36169061064720154,
0.2430245727300644,
0.26964789628982544,
0.25197675824165344,
0.5427585244178772,
0.5225282907485962,
0.6356721520423889,
0.04371323063969612,
1.5459073781967163,
-0.7803522944450378,
0.37034422159194946,
1.1912798881530762,
-0.6235264539718628,
0.6792933940887451,
0.27008339762687683,
-0.18075096607208252,
0.6707440614700317,
0.31981757283210754,
-0.3396412134170532,
0.126958966255188,
0.8071667551994324,
-0.09842955321073532,
-0.3897140622138977,
0.0361928753554821,
-0.5059928297996521,
0.4113421142101288,
-0.05198259651660919,
-0.5629602074623108,
-0.360211044549942,
-0.34314075112342834,
-0.0552593357861042,
0.18180719017982483,
-0.13128603994846344,
0.4804435074329376,
-0.21021884679794312,
-0.5237919092178345,
0.5723141431808472,
0.10440041124820709,
0.5613113641738892,
-0.7210248112678528,
-0.2013639658689499,
-0.07596370577812195,
0.40215423703193665,
-0.36859628558158875,
-0.22377482056617737,
0.15308819711208344,
0.3921777606010437,
-0.3900650143623352,
-0.18186461925506592,
0.5364165902137756,
0.1772436499595642,
-0.7693969011306763,
0.5801163911819458,
0.6381571292877197,
0.18770886957645416,
0.028970221057534218,
-0.6375622749328613,
0.32317280769348145,
0.168052539229393,
-0.3691748380661011,
0.5213136076927185,
0.3355930745601654,
0.016249647364020348,
0.46125108003616333,
0.7118825912475586,
-0.06012508273124695,
0.1469501554965973,
0.08507683873176575,
1.086342453956604,
-0.7808421850204468,
-0.40936359763145447,
-0.5837396383285522,
0.28961560130119324,
-0.3827707767486572,
-0.4379355013370514,
0.9109888672828674,
0.9438538551330566,
0.8592252731323242,
-0.17683790624141693,
0.9460429549217224,
-0.3741351366043091,
0.3365979492664337,
-0.127468079328537,
0.6852737069129944,
-0.5351365208625793,
0.3456488847732544,
-0.4611957371234894,
-0.9473264813423157,
-0.09524615108966827,
0.3664696216583252,
-0.12782157957553864,
0.2621515095233917,
0.5659385919570923,
1.0453269481658936,
0.06940504908561707,
0.05417178198695183,
0.47681596875190735,
-0.10582983493804932,
0.42331463098526,
0.6796752214431763,
0.7483124732971191,
-0.3207126259803772,
0.9404574632644653,
-0.26307088136672974,
-0.39087173342704773,
-0.3897753357887268,
-1.168433427810669,
-0.564565896987915,
-0.1589498519897461,
-0.35762593150138855,
-0.31528526544570923,
-0.03684239089488983,
0.788501501083374,
0.9732474088668823,
-0.7171026468276978,
-0.5837841629981995,
-0.8589097261428833,
-0.08108801394701004,
-0.21924719214439392,
-0.2856696546077728,
-0.03140586242079735,
-0.5466601252555847,
-0.5624702572822571,
0.5980276465415955,
0.08556144684553146,
-0.41996902227401733,
-0.46012791991233826,
-0.054399024695158005,
0.22503505647182465,
-0.09896610677242279,
0.3026232421398163,
0.37813878059387207,
-0.20362620055675507,
-0.2191348671913147,
-0.06414397060871124,
-0.3326340913772583,
-0.05465000495314598,
1.2118308544158936,
-0.9066359400749207,
0.4746110141277313,
0.5189603567123413,
0.9671565890312195,
0.5707435011863708,
0.13662195205688477,
0.7835236191749573,
-0.9235358834266663,
-0.029793623834848404,
0.132626473903656,
0.3321179151535034,
0.21835847198963165,
-0.18884550034999847,
0.9259526133537292,
0.22027893364429474,
-0.7612231969833374,
-0.9144678115844727,
0.42517316341400146,
-0.8600553870201111,
-0.2694564461708069,
1.042567253112793,
-0.30481526255607605,
-0.30475589632987976,
0.19614602625370026,
0.028665689751505852,
-0.03283475711941719,
-0.383555144071579,
0.45947834849357605,
0.4929109513759613,
-0.1571510285139084,
0.047771334648132324,
-0.685295045375824,
0.24347786605358124,
0.4190124273300171,
-1.0551564693450928,
0.45478835701942444,
0.6015755534172058,
0.20898930728435516,
0.1928820013999939,
0.3368569016456604,
-0.19513863325119019,
0.6211265325546265,
0.5779758095741272,
0.6512295007705688,
-0.06207731366157532,
0.1806943565607071,
-0.6044423580169678,
0.31172171235084534,
0.10107800364494324,
0.14240851998329163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00565v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00565v1
|
Leveraging Corpus Metadata to Detect Template-based Translation: An Exploratory Case Study of the Egyptian Arabic Wikipedia Edition
| 2024-03-31T05:14:38 | 2024-03-31T05:14:38 |
Saied Alshahrani, Hesham Haroon, Ali Elfilali, Mariama Njie, Jeanna Matthews
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Wikipedia articles (content pages) are commonly used corpora in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) research, especially in low-resource languages other
than English. Yet, a few research studies have studied the three Arabic
Wikipedia editions, Arabic Wikipedia (AR), Egyptian Arabic Wikipedia (ARZ), and
Moroccan Arabic Wikipedia (ARY), and documented issues in the Egyptian Arabic
Wikipedia edition regarding the massive automatic creation of its articles
using template-based translation from English to Arabic without human
involvement, overwhelming the Egyptian Arabic Wikipedia with articles that do
not only have low-quality content but also with articles that do not represent
the Egyptian people, their culture, and their dialect. In this paper, we aim to
mitigate the problem of template translation that occurred in the Egyptian
Arabic Wikipedia by identifying these template-translated articles and their
characteristics through exploratory analysis and building automatic detection
systems. We first explore the content of the three Arabic Wikipedia editions in
terms of density, quality, and human contributions and utilize the resulting
insights to build multivariate machine learning classifiers leveraging
articles' metadata to detect the template-translated articles automatically. We
then publicly deploy and host the best-performing classifier, XGBoost, as an
online application called EGYPTIAN WIKIPEDIA SCANNER and release the extracted,
filtered, and labeled datasets to the research community to benefit from our
datasets and the online, web-based detection system.
|
[
-0.9778846502304077,
-0.3052946627140045,
0.1724439412355423,
-0.08742058277130127,
-0.5405783653259277,
0.018354833126068115,
-0.29053422808647156,
-0.5673466324806213,
0.4899996519088745,
0.6019089818000793,
-0.034805264323949814,
-0.881344199180603,
-0.6810557842254639,
0.39139166474342346,
-0.9168784618377686,
1.4322305917739868,
-0.25928449630737305,
-0.11602306365966797,
0.060940131545066833,
-0.45884042978286743,
0.11744162440299988,
-0.029831301420927048,
-0.3818466365337372,
0.10463409125804901,
0.6535006165504456,
0.44997620582580566,
0.7702757120132446,
0.9703548550605774,
0.22510619461536407,
0.09921500086784363,
0.057536207139492035,
0.32675981521606445,
-0.15504001080989838,
-0.05525103211402893,
-0.2338055968284607,
-0.18898561596870422,
-0.15548311173915863,
-0.13472789525985718,
0.5114285945892334,
0.44496968388557434,
-0.21177996695041656,
0.5845385789871216,
-0.02601127326488495,
0.5759063959121704,
-0.8516930937767029,
0.1285376101732254,
-0.4835425019264221,
0.04064984992146492,
-0.5167667269706726,
-0.15428659319877625,
-0.20317025482654572,
-0.2566561698913574,
-0.21124309301376343,
-0.425628662109375,
0.5168487429618835,
0.09046958386898041,
0.6577723622322083,
0.21350200474262238,
-0.5960395932197571,
-0.7174684405326843,
-0.4747256934642792,
0.592454731464386,
-0.504734218120575,
0.3343815505504608,
0.3758087754249573,
0.08781855553388596,
-0.18770043551921844,
-0.5114911794662476,
-0.9116356372833252,
-0.08061888068914413,
-0.05049436166882515,
0.10385872423648834,
-0.26013514399528503,
-0.38067325949668884,
0.048976436257362366,
0.2924326956272125,
-0.6515403985977173,
0.12167619913816452,
-0.5139464139938354,
-0.23346751928329468,
0.3259364664554596,
-0.2449808418750763,
0.5219473242759705,
-0.6660864353179932,
-0.11380542069673538,
-0.2614182233810425,
-0.8421111702919006,
-0.10199621319770813,
0.5996943712234497,
-0.03685261309146881,
-0.04719448834657669,
0.7348318099975586,
0.07036640495061874,
0.6620798110961914,
-0.02634250558912754,
0.007115822285413742,
0.42113226652145386,
-0.19801416993141174,
0.14967608451843262,
0.5305753350257874,
0.702762246131897,
0.09953141957521439,
-0.00922329444438219,
-0.19248586893081665,
-0.1496141254901886,
-0.15291175246238708,
0.48663556575775146,
-0.4918712377548218,
-0.0977686271071434,
0.1806391030550003,
-0.6063975691795349,
-0.39949432015419006,
-0.009854350239038467,
-0.6276503205299377,
-0.28622472286224365,
-0.015339557081460953,
0.1647375524044037,
-0.5427507758140564,
-0.30222341418266296,
-0.13094280660152435,
-0.12870845198631287,
0.1440616101026535,
0.312106192111969,
-0.9230688214302063,
-0.07686568796634674,
0.6125283241271973,
0.9685789346694946,
-0.2811747193336487,
-0.16447433829307556,
-0.21048226952552795,
0.6726924777030945,
-0.5045902132987976,
0.7925848960876465,
-0.19918397068977356,
-0.27757561206817627,
0.03172982856631279,
-0.31844255328178406,
0.31043195724487305,
-0.46066540479660034,
0.975213348865509,
-0.7931758761405945,
-0.04565282538533211,
-0.03631328046321869,
-0.52848881483078,
-0.19037647545337677,
0.3373648226261139,
-0.955691397190094,
0.9096933007240295,
0.3050975203514099,
-1.1761904954910278,
0.531703770160675,
-0.6342312097549438,
-0.4181426763534546,
-0.20871905982494354,
-0.1697017252445221,
-0.3932175636291504,
0.468719482421875,
0.28661105036735535,
0.20081466436386108,
-0.19578057527542114,
0.007744243368506432,
0.007519737351685762,
-0.1932513564825058,
0.0670459121465683,
-0.14205652475357056,
0.6138811111450195,
0.41027864813804626,
-0.44246140122413635,
-0.09245810657739639,
-0.9804381132125854,
-0.09608901292085648,
-0.19623680412769318,
-0.5494791865348816,
-0.5619147419929504,
0.08771885186433792,
0.34138044714927673,
0.5961010456085205,
0.09995927661657333,
-0.4849766194820404,
0.19356602430343628,
-0.24859800934791565,
-0.18562781810760498,
0.45811036229133606,
-0.1858161985874176,
0.45309266448020935,
-0.23414866626262665,
0.3774082362651825,
0.34602057933807373,
-0.13670934736728668,
-0.04602949693799019,
-0.689773678779602,
-1.0116324424743652,
-0.285591721534729,
0.3341183662414551,
0.31976744532585144,
-0.9829311370849609,
0.5044069886207581,
-0.5693172812461853,
-0.6936330795288086,
-0.7102582454681396,
0.34329313039779663,
0.050091005861759186,
0.6007124781608582,
0.6805205941200256,
-0.3735971748828888,
-0.49756723642349243,
-0.918117105960846,
-0.2214282900094986,
-0.36809924244880676,
-0.2859571874141693,
0.08845601230859756,
0.6857998371124268,
-0.2626766264438629,
0.9690170288085938,
-0.060821108520030975,
-0.4239945113658905,
-0.04965858906507492,
0.7034416198730469,
0.3302347958087921,
0.3237224221229553,
0.7555094361305237,
-0.9289843440055847,
-0.816518247127533,
0.23332571983337402,
-0.7216697931289673,
-0.31978413462638855,
-0.015451784245669842,
0.04355073347687721,
0.43462231755256653,
0.4128553867340088,
-0.41950321197509766,
0.4174724221229553,
0.5912410020828247,
-0.18389391899108887,
0.6211814284324646,
-0.2956782579421997,
0.11386962234973907,
-1.104066252708435,
0.4126361608505249,
-0.13556045293807983,
-0.14753150939941406,
-0.29645538330078125,
-0.047071054577827454,
0.3415524661540985,
0.01541945431381464,
-0.27405279874801636,
0.45818445086479187,
-0.39321717619895935,
-0.029033802449703217,
-0.4219939708709717,
-0.22345903515815735,
-0.11519152671098709,
0.09008610993623734,
0.2625979483127594,
0.7789472341537476,
0.027018969878554344,
-0.4542723000049591,
0.2045958787202835,
0.33122530579566956,
-0.7585000991821289,
0.4653454124927521,
-0.211175337433815,
0.15987199544906616,
-0.29612141847610474,
0.28062283992767334,
-0.7156621813774109,
-0.057664547115564346,
0.6534793972969055,
-0.4029819071292877,
0.28457534313201904,
-0.3043428361415863,
-0.7767626047134399,
-0.003403562353923917,
-0.35505762696266174,
0.12476179748773575,
0.15935438871383667,
-0.3491896688938141,
0.5087933540344238,
0.26434385776519775,
-0.3143279552459717,
-0.824924886226654,
-0.31757014989852905,
0.4821670949459076,
-0.2664615213871002,
-0.5322839021682739,
0.5615541338920593,
0.2262113094329834,
-0.0734214335680008,
0.4579105079174042,
-0.21647168695926666,
-0.20055268704891205,
0.1082393154501915,
0.0017959849210456014,
-0.018885470926761627,
-0.21273082494735718,
0.02303592674434185,
0.36781156063079834,
-0.30558866262435913,
0.18269237875938416,
-0.5708093643188477,
0.5064243674278259,
0.14238114655017853,
-0.3657740652561188,
-0.12520885467529297,
0.7052860856056213,
0.5890809893608093,
-0.3741775155067444,
1.2485271692276,
1.2883697748184204,
-0.18237975239753723,
0.07900907844305038,
-0.678073525428772,
0.20560334622859955,
-0.35555970668792725,
0.44908955693244934,
-0.20431827008724213,
-0.29070231318473816,
0.4558677673339844,
0.1760309636592865,
0.10859974473714828,
0.6557426452636719,
0.7074731588363647,
-0.3204042613506317,
0.8807464241981506,
0.5445104837417603,
-0.3096836507320404,
0.3916306495666504,
-0.2481328547000885,
0.2265108823776245,
-0.7300300002098083,
-0.16763974726200104,
-0.7042158842086792,
-0.45995643734931946,
-0.909256637096405,
-0.4219967722892761,
0.5866106748580933,
-0.008035026490688324,
0.038124315440654755,
0.4476042687892914,
-0.19742505252361298,
0.17475780844688416,
0.6874657273292542,
-0.11432448029518127,
0.5158504843711853,
0.2945343554019928,
-0.22577689588069916,
0.04929841309785843,
-0.6019739508628845,
-0.748613715171814,
1.2773679494857788,
-0.09556318074464798,
0.4290972054004669,
0.5200543403625488,
0.9065439701080322,
0.7250865697860718,
0.7076643109321594,
-0.5230535268783569,
-0.001965381670743227,
0.06139456480741501,
-0.718428909778595,
0.0014594390522688627,
-0.4403258264064789,
-0.906187117099762,
0.045658987015485764,
-0.28388428688049316,
-0.35804158449172974,
0.29504871368408203,
-0.044253285974264145,
0.06834794580936432,
0.40541377663612366,
-0.4392732083797455,
0.6806530952453613,
-0.2448793202638626,
-0.3008228540420532,
-0.5169736742973328,
-0.5821752548217773,
0.06643088907003403,
-0.49574577808380127,
0.4476796090602875,
0.11731503903865814,
-0.4270869791507721,
0.7036371231079102,
-0.1125616729259491,
0.29671430587768555,
0.09360090643167496,
-0.3230770528316498,
0.19996823370456696,
0.1904623657464981,
0.5322315096855164,
0.14662307500839233,
-0.12050972133874893,
0.3846397399902344,
0.019888145849108696,
-0.5179340839385986,
-0.500595211982727,
0.6774390339851379,
-0.9733664989471436,
-0.5209230184555054,
-0.4444271922111511,
-0.4032772481441498,
0.0035853746812790632,
0.2532009780406952,
0.5084130167961121,
-0.14968940615653992,
-0.14161166548728943,
0.144408717751503,
0.6260372400283813,
-0.35217535495758057,
0.18477430939674377,
0.6608250737190247,
-0.10519221425056458,
-0.3192593455314636,
1.1176553964614868,
0.2691110372543335,
-0.27095162868499756,
0.4067305326461792,
-0.050368532538414,
-0.17548751831054688,
-1.014417290687561,
-0.9203788638114929,
0.049681223928928375,
-0.8359795212745667,
-0.21319565176963806,
-0.7064851522445679,
0.009305154904723167,
-0.2739836275577545,
0.03861772641539574,
-0.11362223327159882,
-0.45350486040115356,
-0.4200274646282196,
0.1047317385673523,
-0.0067930989898741245,
0.6381509900093079,
-0.3282708525657654,
0.010832722298800945,
-1.0733561515808105,
0.4540856182575226,
-0.14469404518604279,
0.04085073247551918,
-0.019707541912794113,
-0.27935701608657837,
-0.635896623134613,
-0.03006274625658989,
-0.28569868206977844,
-1.0812585353851318,
0.5728132128715515,
0.23129284381866455,
0.4089514911174774,
0.7545682787895203,
0.02032604068517685,
0.22273190319538116,
-0.6357000470161438,
0.33663007616996765,
0.1715504676103592,
-0.753323495388031,
0.4824047088623047,
-0.42857518792152405,
0.011562986299395561,
0.3860264718532562,
0.7300423383712769,
-0.9357495903968811,
-0.3556286096572876,
-0.4258100092411041,
-1.0713679790496826,
0.4765254557132721,
0.4217388927936554,
0.29791152477264404,
-0.3293042778968811,
0.33783596754074097,
0.3769964873790741,
0.38307809829711914,
-0.45072320103645325,
-0.4822343587875366,
-0.44717681407928467,
-0.31330353021621704,
0.10585044324398041,
-0.36645591259002686,
0.04894266277551651,
-0.017416896298527718,
0.7790956497192383,
-0.1908365786075592,
0.07209384441375732,
0.03753653168678284,
-0.739417552947998,
0.06605881452560425,
0.35349681973457336,
0.4219747483730316,
0.5949774980545044,
-0.3496498465538025,
0.2647182047367096,
-0.1366032361984253,
-0.6180558204650879,
0.28648462891578674,
0.06912024319171906,
-0.36350342631340027,
0.403089314699173,
0.4251819849014282,
0.2214631736278534,
0.1067231073975563,
-0.5080981254577637,
0.36731618642807007,
0.007113124243915081,
0.46998974680900574,
-0.5164094567298889,
0.03852969408035278,
0.09514287859201431,
-0.07436453551054001,
0.6985504627227783,
0.13765661418437958,
0.2799004316329956,
-0.32795122265815735,
0.22625936567783356,
0.22307492792606354,
-0.22114622592926025,
-0.2633265554904938,
0.33465874195098877,
0.23275607824325562,
-0.03724352642893791,
0.6836950778961182,
-0.24880412220954895,
-0.43952783942222595,
0.5159372687339783,
0.3166748881340027,
0.41422292590141296,
-0.066546730697155,
0.40443968772888184,
0.265859454870224,
0.3912074863910675,
0.2770993411540985,
0.04594206064939499,
-0.3567715585231781,
-0.845915675163269,
-0.2983161211013794,
-0.6136134266853333,
-0.292113333940506,
0.06633999943733215,
-0.8997091054916382,
0.2618703544139862,
-0.16134773194789886,
-0.06138640269637108,
0.043840162456035614,
0.011666408739984035,
-0.8390498161315918,
-0.01940441131591797,
0.31581681966781616,
1.1904263496398926,
-0.7782996892929077,
1.0087790489196777,
0.6418145298957825,
-0.5379964113235474,
-0.06622719019651413,
-0.11927533149719238,
-0.04323872551321983,
-0.6061843633651733,
0.807115375995636,
-0.07064908742904663,
-0.09991418570280075,
0.2469862699508667,
-0.2540222108364105,
-0.8369089365005493,
0.7422323226928711,
0.5440254807472229,
-0.14728936553001404,
-0.02106345258653164,
0.33592724800109863,
0.4445398449897766,
0.09206494688987732,
0.1441672444343567,
0.21323390305042267,
0.6256991624832153,
-0.418000727891922,
-0.7215702533721924,
-0.30435627698898315,
-0.42105475068092346,
-0.2876235544681549,
0.23019453883171082,
-0.14776602387428284,
0.4950873553752899,
0.06210188567638397,
-0.07410454005002975,
0.17629827558994293,
0.8202794790267944,
-0.08688203990459442,
0.037265416234731674,
0.3413988947868347,
0.708147406578064,
0.7785533666610718,
0.09929415583610535,
1.09636652469635,
-0.4563007354736328,
0.3194776475429535,
0.9620833396911621,
-0.040878064930438995,
0.6892316341400146,
0.8758171796798706,
0.08766480535268784,
0.7339943647384644,
0.5384350419044495,
-0.10116484761238098,
0.7457693219184875,
0.2111470252275467,
-0.7297457456588745,
0.005835882853716612,
-0.4195989966392517,
-0.629875898361206,
0.7225018739700317,
0.5900464057922363,
-0.6514727473258972,
-0.533388614654541,
0.05603606253862381,
0.12892545759677887,
-0.2302081286907196,
-0.2259012907743454,
0.5940949320793152,
-0.12843678891658783,
-0.46184074878692627,
0.32415494322776794,
0.5883954167366028,
0.4978589713573456,
-0.5658442974090576,
0.02851414494216442,
-0.22726744413375854,
-0.029904846101999283,
-0.29325011372566223,
-0.5459356307983398,
0.6190614104270935,
0.19086690247058868,
-0.404735267162323,
-0.1331411600112915,
0.5061373114585876,
-0.1897309273481369,
-0.5497098565101624,
0.214104562997818,
0.7939454913139343,
0.1011798307299614,
-0.0350516140460968,
-0.4308730661869049,
-0.20898619294166565,
-0.29792216420173645,
-0.20061686635017395,
0.4996500313282013,
0.4902282953262329,
-0.28054162859916687,
0.4791988730430603,
0.8548660278320312,
0.34831005334854126,
0.05755580961704254,
-0.3352535665035248,
0.7849850058555603,
-0.40892425179481506,
-0.5390996336936951,
-0.8779312372207642,
0.08729686588048935,
-0.20519322156906128,
-0.14487583935260773,
0.841219961643219,
0.8231796026229858,
1.0688196420669556,
-0.14663006365299225,
0.8446229696273804,
-0.23140248656272888,
0.06428845971822739,
-0.45498374104499817,
1.1348308324813843,
-0.44655895233154297,
0.1348511129617691,
-0.17932437360286713,
-0.9295341968536377,
-0.31450343132019043,
0.756234347820282,
-0.028866995126008987,
-0.22329768538475037,
0.5307980179786682,
0.5759112238883972,
-0.3760836124420166,
-0.16681940853595734,
0.2336689978837967,
0.06308438628911972,
0.32262948155403137,
0.23561051487922668,
0.7913970351219177,
-0.21962755918502808,
0.7719377279281616,
-0.19319458305835724,
0.045746274292469025,
-0.3043113350868225,
-1.0547783374786377,
-0.6737687587738037,
-0.6881828904151917,
-0.23334893584251404,
-0.5638083219528198,
-0.08984202891588211,
1.004075050354004,
0.40525081753730774,
-1.110241174697876,
-0.11735247820615768,
0.15965145826339722,
0.3407242000102997,
-0.24642497301101685,
-0.1501782238483429,
0.7983946204185486,
-0.09787273406982422,
-0.6532336473464966,
0.1475956290960312,
0.25331076979637146,
-0.1397341638803482,
-0.3719964325428009,
0.08760606497526169,
-0.23836901783943176,
-0.22822271287441254,
0.2990928590297699,
0.1928432583808899,
-0.4225060045719147,
-0.284588485956192,
-0.17945167422294617,
-0.28456002473831177,
0.240372434258461,
0.8421257734298706,
-0.8398882746696472,
0.4444226920604706,
0.4095551371574402,
0.6004239320755005,
0.6059218049049377,
-0.4623104929924011,
0.439466267824173,
-0.8720264434814453,
0.09888650476932526,
0.13453449308872223,
0.5236025452613831,
0.37091702222824097,
-0.0611010417342186,
0.5478433966636658,
0.18097595870494843,
0.008149564266204834,
-0.4427260756492615,
0.14585748314857483,
-0.543272852897644,
-0.047594305127859116,
0.8039911985397339,
-0.38274407386779785,
-0.28627878427505493,
-0.6925311088562012,
-0.1409316062927246,
0.6197777390480042,
-0.30361583828926086,
1.448949933052063,
0.8386508226394653,
0.2122359722852707,
-0.052321530878543854,
-0.6468218564987183,
0.3376873731613159,
0.10549082607030869,
-0.6838425993919373,
-0.5387603640556335,
0.39095190167427063,
0.25540265440940857,
0.4933386445045471,
0.16160240769386292,
0.06295683234930038,
0.48781096935272217,
-0.38540324568748474,
0.09875968843698502,
-0.25557592511177063,
-0.09801822900772095,
-0.0955241322517395,
0.29432156682014465,
-0.02466377429664135,
0.0009812756907194853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00557v1
|
DivTOD: Unleashing the Power of LLMs for Diversifying Task-Oriented Dialogue Representations
| 2024-03-31T04:36:57 | 2024-03-31T04:36:57 |
Weihao Zeng, Dayuan Fu, Keqing He, Yejie Wang, Yukai Xu, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models pre-trained on general text have achieved impressive results
in diverse fields. Yet, the distinct linguistic characteristics of
task-oriented dialogues (TOD) compared to general text limit the practical
utility of existing language models. Current task-oriented dialogue
pre-training methods overlook the one-to-many property of conversations, where
multiple responses can be appropriate given the same conversation context. In
this paper, we propose a novel dialogue pre-training model called DivTOD, which
collaborates with LLMs to learn diverse task-oriented dialogue representations.
DivTOD guides LLMs in transferring diverse knowledge to smaller models while
removing domain knowledge that contradicts task-oriented dialogues. Experiments
show that our model outperforms strong TOD baselines on various downstream
dialogue tasks and learns the intrinsic diversity of task-oriented dialogues.
|
[
-0.34239277243614197,
-0.42980945110321045,
0.40874525904655457,
0.18303075432777405,
-0.6841396689414978,
0.6286532878875732,
-0.09357737749814987,
-0.04680579900741577,
-0.019696008414030075,
0.6656686663627625,
-0.8896421194076538,
-0.6106020212173462,
-0.8734613060951233,
-0.015540042892098427,
-0.2850845754146576,
1.2501975297927856,
0.18906550109386444,
0.3437468707561493,
-0.3629434108734131,
-0.3504221439361572,
-0.49468323588371277,
-0.5108567476272583,
-0.2696869671344757,
-0.268300861120224,
0.402248740196228,
0.21377043426036835,
0.13709640502929688,
0.12674358487129211,
0.2341737300157547,
0.35991981625556946,
0.038979705423116684,
0.21360071003437042,
-0.8764020204544067,
0.32772591710090637,
-0.29463931918144226,
-0.6188613176345825,
-0.2818846106529236,
-0.15101590752601624,
0.513085126876831,
0.8311110734939575,
-0.29487964510917664,
-0.1275830864906311,
0.2980963885784149,
0.43316468596458435,
-0.40825608372688293,
0.12888334691524506,
-0.9289618730545044,
-0.03754578158259392,
-0.10243842005729675,
-0.05063464865088463,
-0.31608882546424866,
0.007085268385708332,
0.5020334124565125,
-0.4432629942893982,
0.03698761388659477,
-0.21289096772670746,
0.3410833179950714,
0.5165675282478333,
-0.6359875202178955,
-0.2730182111263275,
-0.8836398720741272,
0.9296661019325256,
-0.4435083568096161,
0.16692250967025757,
0.10033402591943741,
0.19958040118217468,
0.10815131664276123,
-0.6437824964523315,
-0.5456012487411499,
0.11784487217664719,
0.22580888867378235,
0.2364567220211029,
-0.25473639369010925,
0.1569804698228836,
0.061988890171051025,
0.5898796319961548,
-0.14848169684410095,
0.13043418526649475,
-0.06958785653114319,
0.2209864854812622,
0.35495927929878235,
0.37037500739097595,
0.19159556925296783,
-0.0544973649084568,
-0.4869483709335327,
0.16495832800865173,
-0.5349278450012207,
0.07987269759178162,
0.15175080299377441,
0.33647918701171875,
-0.09105978906154633,
0.28430548310279846,
-0.21016691625118256,
0.6321800947189331,
0.09646646678447723,
-0.4707150459289551,
0.0906829908490181,
-0.561733603477478,
-0.3770538866519928,
-0.17769083380699158,
0.7693628072738647,
0.2048390507698059,
0.1274532526731491,
-0.2596838176250458,
-0.07060269266366959,
-0.27530455589294434,
0.4116556644439697,
-0.8490310311317444,
0.05660071596503258,
-0.09270668774843216,
-0.40825968980789185,
-0.23959632217884064,
-0.13046053051948547,
-0.47749510407447815,
-0.29968851804733276,
-0.34406474232673645,
0.26466789841651917,
-0.3106791079044342,
-0.3051128685474396,
0.1323460340499878,
-0.14563831686973572,
0.0005983234732411802,
0.5920435786247253,
-0.994066596031189,
0.5014522671699524,
0.5072051286697388,
0.5742518305778503,
-0.4937179386615753,
-0.2755530774593353,
-0.47475767135620117,
0.15996748208999634,
-0.05218485742807388,
0.4116397500038147,
-0.7486706376075745,
-0.8954784870147705,
-0.05750206857919693,
-0.16159623861312866,
0.1445743292570114,
-0.495686799287796,
0.17530351877212524,
-0.36556336283683777,
0.26730599999427795,
-0.28221508860588074,
-0.36067768931388855,
-0.14831233024597168,
0.3246997594833374,
-0.4419940412044525,
0.6917275190353394,
0.4266207218170166,
-0.8566678762435913,
0.45237571001052856,
-0.42260223627090454,
-0.48156917095184326,
0.2180136889219284,
-0.4327218532562256,
-0.412360280752182,
0.20418104529380798,
0.1809532642364502,
0.5316711664199829,
-0.6282841563224792,
0.4260852038860321,
-0.17415669560432434,
-0.14608953893184662,
0.04035356640815735,
-0.49830159544944763,
0.754802942276001,
0.2251831591129303,
-0.13001398742198944,
0.0811050608754158,
-0.5505098104476929,
-0.43107613921165466,
0.03451796621084213,
-0.2745458781719208,
-0.7549709677696228,
-0.13700829446315765,
-0.3684380352497101,
0.0838339552283287,
0.09003914147615433,
-0.6748468279838562,
0.4464844763278961,
-0.31024280190467834,
0.2593824863433838,
0.6718223094940186,
-0.011417925357818604,
0.6892998814582825,
-0.43685632944107056,
0.6143226027488708,
0.5002086162567139,
-0.006779633928090334,
-0.16068418323993683,
-0.6109032034873962,
-0.6888611912727356,
-0.6001933217048645,
-0.08171695470809937,
0.5030621290206909,
-0.9720059037208557,
0.3213292360305786,
-0.3848968744277954,
-0.5463771224021912,
-0.4507480263710022,
0.3927854597568512,
0.38008299469947815,
0.2595113515853882,
0.21809162199497223,
-0.5969981551170349,
-0.43841174244880676,
-0.6437219381332397,
-0.3367350995540619,
-0.1565944403409958,
0.07961907237768173,
0.2501891553401947,
0.36879536509513855,
-0.487651526927948,
1.2111949920654297,
-0.27885428071022034,
-0.3304156959056854,
-0.7091684341430664,
0.2065923810005188,
0.05866813287138939,
0.32043230533599854,
0.3492641746997833,
-0.8073891997337341,
-0.7506787180900574,
-0.05028776079416275,
-0.46453192830085754,
0.027448266744613647,
-0.12002646923065186,
-0.040416110306978226,
-0.22644586861133575,
0.2637422978878021,
-0.561722993850708,
0.35951730608940125,
0.5375191569328308,
0.03707132861018181,
0.25952082872390747,
-0.047734495252370834,
0.18380093574523926,
-1.581849455833435,
-0.44435423612594604,
-0.137005016207695,
-0.480938196182251,
-0.7901637554168701,
-0.5621879696846008,
-0.28792205452919006,
-0.09663432836532593,
-0.5002378821372986,
0.4400622546672821,
-0.4916456937789917,
-0.10105107724666595,
-0.1478693187236786,
-0.057001713663339615,
-0.08934421837329865,
0.6292585730552673,
0.15596801042556763,
0.6507075428962708,
0.7542921304702759,
-0.7884144186973572,
0.40166160464286804,
0.5480225086212158,
-0.45378562808036804,
0.6440895199775696,
-0.4317428767681122,
0.05849168077111244,
-0.22068648040294647,
0.26438480615615845,
-1.025747299194336,
0.2181524932384491,
-0.01997644267976284,
-0.08600238710641861,
0.43395256996154785,
-0.4344303011894226,
-0.1920192390680313,
-0.19384080171585083,
-0.1112949475646019,
0.696334183216095,
0.6051973104476929,
-0.61909419298172,
0.8412725329399109,
0.5097543001174927,
-0.5495896935462952,
-0.7333344221115112,
-0.5609885454177856,
-0.23734071850776672,
-0.25949132442474365,
-0.49504920840263367,
0.5559931397438049,
-0.09849753230810165,
-0.2002091109752655,
-0.21153734624385834,
-0.31286370754241943,
-0.24040938913822174,
0.08354984223842621,
0.31811457872390747,
0.12834779918193817,
0.01751701347529888,
0.23810520768165588,
0.0825757384300232,
0.0757555142045021,
-0.18089337646961212,
-0.5592961311340332,
0.6931031942367554,
0.11248478293418884,
-0.8058276176452637,
-0.21417008340358734,
0.4474298059940338,
0.6609786748886108,
-0.3475467264652252,
0.5495404005050659,
0.40552809834480286,
-0.0877181738615036,
-0.43350014090538025,
-0.5318852663040161,
-0.058430738747119904,
-0.48698413372039795,
0.7499879598617554,
-0.4087288975715637,
-1.2725579738616943,
0.3380991220474243,
-0.48125267028808594,
0.24024605751037598,
0.11665799468755722,
0.8038216233253479,
-0.08582562953233719,
0.7752353549003601,
0.8728163838386536,
-0.07083338499069214,
0.8189715147018433,
-0.22121170163154602,
0.28893163800239563,
-0.7956709265708923,
-0.27084001898765564,
-0.2139420211315155,
-0.14429378509521484,
-0.5101239085197449,
-0.9034823179244995,
0.12665405869483948,
0.04742412269115448,
-0.06537545472383499,
0.11533348262310028,
-0.38169625401496887,
0.4918721914291382,
0.48391637206077576,
-0.12963643670082092,
0.5167446136474609,
0.03683288022875786,
-0.08674150705337524,
-0.07229635864496231,
-0.6079686880111694,
-0.3970264792442322,
1.3453689813613892,
0.366611510515213,
0.9478538036346436,
0.02397860400378704,
1.1132750511169434,
0.19439786672592163,
0.30808424949645996,
-0.7074816823005676,
0.5505800247192383,
-0.46341848373413086,
-0.3638548254966736,
-0.44694283604621887,
-0.3679361641407013,
-0.8512425422668457,
0.36042729020118713,
0.12925985455513,
-0.7451793551445007,
-0.007938834838569164,
-0.2725829780101776,
-0.2840830981731415,
0.35405173897743225,
-0.5627968311309814,
0.7531777024269104,
-0.22107675671577454,
-0.1231907308101654,
-0.3456743061542511,
-0.44084519147872925,
0.40106335282325745,
-0.13137993216514587,
0.11012276262044907,
-0.08804070949554443,
0.19374652206897736,
0.6775763630867004,
-0.5626475811004639,
1.0859463214874268,
-0.15897831320762634,
-0.16041697561740875,
0.4745703637599945,
0.027675319463014603,
0.4433072805404663,
0.3529629111289978,
0.34062501788139343,
0.02424640767276287,
-0.2060898244380951,
-0.33889177441596985,
-0.44475239515304565,
0.5224237442016602,
-0.9226638078689575,
-0.9438027739524841,
-0.3372493088245392,
-0.6878570914268494,
-0.4510279595851898,
-0.029567748308181763,
0.22562548518180847,
0.5077114105224609,
-0.6685048937797546,
0.1950148046016693,
0.8135941028594971,
-0.09575186669826508,
0.46036022901535034,
0.6168540120124817,
-0.16092264652252197,
-0.11269524693489075,
0.8475649356842041,
-0.24020440876483917,
0.6594741940498352,
0.6646179556846619,
-0.17291852831840515,
-0.3200869560241699,
-0.6978404521942139,
-0.1290254443883896,
0.03625646233558655,
-0.9156981110572815,
0.03431515768170357,
-0.8697066903114319,
-0.09872330725193024,
-0.17399099469184875,
0.09708036482334137,
-0.4470699429512024,
-0.3326999843120575,
-0.4360690116882324,
-0.1797693967819214,
0.2024441808462143,
0.9886248707771301,
0.13590897619724274,
0.41327813267707825,
-0.8639919757843018,
0.4002464711666107,
0.9729728102684021,
0.16611213982105255,
-0.20703524351119995,
-0.5224114656448364,
-0.08957046270370483,
0.16139072179794312,
-0.5311301946640015,
-0.7556312084197998,
0.4441673159599304,
0.08634090423583984,
0.8697317242622375,
0.3086848258972168,
0.12657637894153595,
0.43544265627861023,
-0.4725249707698822,
0.8597406148910522,
0.663476288318634,
-0.9662520289421082,
0.4544167220592499,
-0.3100600838661194,
0.45573994517326355,
0.5540771484375,
0.5867565870285034,
-0.45136645436286926,
-0.605678141117096,
-0.3889308273792267,
-0.5137985944747925,
0.8057650327682495,
0.16475503146648407,
0.3852235972881317,
-0.03214624151587486,
-0.23706701397895813,
0.6191877126693726,
0.5069962739944458,
-0.8003686666488647,
-0.17213228344917297,
-0.5620624423027039,
-0.24218721687793732,
-0.11724840104579926,
-0.21322067081928253,
-0.3064122200012207,
-0.2769257724285126,
0.3215840756893158,
-0.07666750997304916,
0.31077781319618225,
0.1514175683259964,
-0.40386760234832764,
0.2551579475402832,
0.47044268250465393,
0.4015982747077942,
0.5192832946777344,
-0.0025149774737656116,
0.028437377884984016,
0.3876705467700958,
-0.48538103699684143,
0.3340800404548645,
-0.10751763731241226,
0.3674139976501465,
0.04800000041723251,
0.20233984291553497,
1.034141182899475,
-0.004136275965720415,
-0.5369619727134705,
0.6570186018943787,
-0.3288502097129822,
-0.3052673935890198,
0.09486192464828491,
0.046801257878541946,
0.33499613404273987,
0.31452512741088867,
0.4358779489994049,
0.24049541354179382,
0.043404415249824524,
-0.70140141248703,
0.20310866832733154,
0.5086175799369812,
-0.4895813763141632,
-0.1642560064792633,
0.369505375623703,
0.8345043063163757,
-0.38239508867263794,
0.4384452998638153,
-0.37838461995124817,
-0.6455727219581604,
0.417348176240921,
0.24828983843326569,
1.051194429397583,
-0.26330122351646423,
0.2952779233455658,
-0.023745661601424217,
0.01679822988808155,
0.15958081185817719,
0.05988288298249245,
-0.42021313309669495,
-0.8136457204818726,
-0.3790653347969055,
-0.7197329998016357,
-0.5037717819213867,
0.035148218274116516,
-0.5070561766624451,
0.1656179279088974,
-0.4364423155784607,
-0.15489351749420166,
-0.28780966997146606,
-0.2125154286623001,
-0.9264364242553711,
0.08932393789291382,
0.11163678020238876,
0.4179679751396179,
-0.5414959788322449,
1.1982333660125732,
0.5003594160079956,
-0.321208655834198,
-0.44255784153938293,
0.25209537148475647,
-0.12735895812511444,
-0.8542478084564209,
1.065514326095581,
0.09642831236124039,
-0.18484486639499664,
0.21566849946975708,
-0.20652368664741516,
-0.5857411026954651,
1.1924149990081787,
0.22905445098876953,
-0.9999001622200012,
-0.025932691991329193,
0.43614503741264343,
0.33521145582199097,
-0.7979880571365356,
0.4179622232913971,
0.3031684458255768,
-0.07655049115419388,
0.24497845768928528,
-1.0624339580535889,
-0.0880935937166214,
-0.13583378493785858,
0.22522495687007904,
-0.05964123085141182,
-0.5277819633483887,
0.857478141784668,
-0.1719028204679489,
-0.2114384025335312,
-0.03274605795741081,
0.41875410079956055,
0.18310631811618805,
0.036204393953084946,
0.6946882605552673,
0.45218363404273987,
0.7475685477256775,
-0.18278272449970245,
0.9111031889915466,
-0.19094596803188324,
0.13489508628845215,
1.0923069715499878,
-0.4265631139278412,
0.38361597061157227,
0.4831443130970001,
-0.2033664435148239,
0.6058233380317688,
0.3098164498806,
0.20018188655376434,
0.9617872834205627,
0.31664571166038513,
-0.6699848771095276,
-0.5294349193572998,
0.0011919495882466435,
-0.22625362873077393,
0.4408901333808899,
0.3537103831768036,
-0.0743764191865921,
-0.2725416421890259,
0.26862019300460815,
-0.5570148229598999,
0.13616158068180084,
-0.16731518507003784,
1.1664315462112427,
0.2363157719373703,
-0.6389778852462769,
0.5782643556594849,
-0.24822396039962769,
1.0550446510314941,
-0.730025589466095,
0.12169606983661652,
-0.18966330587863922,
0.1687782108783722,
0.10572987049818039,
-0.6197679042816162,
0.1923174411058426,
-0.07060334086418152,
-0.270643025636673,
-0.6624754071235657,
0.5489557385444641,
-0.6737456917762756,
-0.17536835372447968,
0.44071608781814575,
0.77118319272995,
-0.17905151844024658,
-0.0688319131731987,
-0.5239421129226685,
-0.1385049968957901,
0.29560351371765137,
-0.05493985489010811,
0.5534849762916565,
0.869200587272644,
0.08029178529977798,
0.9090271592140198,
0.42545372247695923,
-0.3210242986679077,
0.05557930842041969,
0.4034020006656647,
1.2454026937484741,
-0.4676244556903839,
-0.5657303333282471,
-0.854762852191925,
0.809967041015625,
-0.2104659527540207,
-0.33425116539001465,
0.567930281162262,
0.3113071620464325,
0.8818705081939697,
-0.24064351618289948,
1.199631929397583,
0.24808119237422943,
0.5639959573745728,
-0.35578230023384094,
0.43730252981185913,
-0.5207935571670532,
0.47575342655181885,
-0.26778149604797363,
-0.9608138799667358,
0.24542756378650665,
0.5166342854499817,
-0.17788459360599518,
0.14925897121429443,
0.797124981880188,
0.4789767861366272,
-0.14306871592998505,
0.14815931022167206,
0.45413896441459656,
0.23185770213603973,
0.42900219559669495,
0.6368075609207153,
1.326249122619629,
-0.03247276321053505,
0.7626262307167053,
0.059101808816194534,
-0.2445618063211441,
-0.17631995677947998,
-0.6856187582015991,
-1.4685620069503784,
-0.7332074642181396,
-0.3195106089115143,
0.17488020658493042,
0.03892391547560692,
0.7624825239181519,
0.8493304252624512,
-0.4979141652584076,
-0.41894978284835815,
-0.4147788882255554,
0.22471590340137482,
0.03465743735432625,
-0.08659582585096359,
-0.45959824323654175,
-0.4731442928314209,
-0.9475349187850952,
0.3883182108402252,
0.5701186060905457,
0.25101837515830994,
-0.3026213049888611,
-0.4015738368034363,
-0.10489943623542786,
0.0722748339176178,
0.5345988869667053,
-0.10953406989574432,
-0.7750576734542847,
0.1291983723640442,
-0.1743779480457306,
-0.2221524715423584,
0.09281718730926514,
1.0449624061584473,
-0.7317675352096558,
0.5484986305236816,
0.4285358786582947,
0.7478846907615662,
0.8116188049316406,
-0.1544038951396942,
1.0099531412124634,
-1.0995259284973145,
0.4572273790836334,
0.5237812995910645,
0.3206990361213684,
0.2921893000602722,
-0.0408816859126091,
0.07949762791395187,
0.30456286668777466,
-0.313933789730072,
-0.6636634469032288,
0.5989480018615723,
-1.156349778175354,
-0.5114225745201111,
1.0529053211212158,
-0.32878202199935913,
0.2565690875053406,
-0.4090659022331238,
-0.4420919716358185,
0.25844356417655945,
-0.4152962267398834,
0.48391300439834595,
0.7618053555488586,
0.28014543652534485,
-0.23115745186805725,
-0.13938084244728088,
0.7050142288208008,
0.6241682171821594,
-0.8496736288070679,
0.17990237474441528,
0.06992185115814209,
0.35532835125923157,
0.014388329349458218,
1.019612193107605,
0.13654550909996033,
-0.022953610867261887,
-0.129777729511261,
-0.06964046508073807,
0.0012960972962900996,
-0.21922609210014343,
-0.028154240921139717,
-0.12370681017637253,
0.2223753184080124,
-0.2148974984884262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00530v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00530v1
|
Comparing Bad Apples to Good Oranges: Aligning Large Language Models via Joint Preference Optimization
| 2024-03-31T02:05:40 | 2024-03-31T02:05:40 |
Hritik Bansal, Ashima Suvarna, Gantavya Bhatt, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang, Aditya Grover
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A common technique for aligning large language models (LLMs) relies on
acquiring human preferences by comparing multiple generations conditioned on a
fixed context. This only leverages the pairwise comparisons when the
generations are placed in an identical context. However, such conditional
rankings often fail to capture the complex and multidimensional aspects of
human preferences. In this work, we revisit the traditional paradigm of
preference acquisition and propose a new axis that is based on eliciting
preferences jointly over the instruction-response pairs. While prior preference
optimizations are designed for conditional ranking protocols (e.g., DPO), our
proposed preference acquisition protocol introduces DOVE, a new preference
optimization objective that upweights the joint probability of the chosen
instruction-response pair over the rejected instruction-response pair.
Interestingly, we find that the LLM trained with joint instruction-response
preference data using DOVE outperforms the LLM trained with DPO by 5.2% and
3.3% win-rate for the summarization and open-ended dialogue datasets,
respectively. Our findings reveal that joint preferences over instruction and
response pairs can significantly enhance the alignment of LLMs by tapping into
a broader spectrum of human preference elicitation. The data and code is
available at https://github.com/Hritikbansal/dove.
|
[
-0.417532742023468,
-0.5841538310050964,
0.7365896701812744,
-0.09311042726039886,
-0.16159696877002716,
0.11497630178928375,
-0.428735613822937,
-0.34228426218032837,
0.18788406252861023,
0.5647261142730713,
-0.20750762522220612,
-0.45958802103996277,
-0.8532503247261047,
-0.07595356553792953,
0.06462166458368301,
0.980926513671875,
0.11446208506822586,
0.03161931782960892,
-0.40747302770614624,
-0.3606858253479004,
-0.4350665211677551,
-0.2826519012451172,
-0.761088490486145,
-0.4914027452468872,
0.5003675222396851,
0.42446982860565186,
0.8485698699951172,
0.49709489941596985,
0.5306431651115417,
0.3538159132003784,
0.09731771051883698,
0.2538723945617676,
-0.6518477201461792,
0.10045414417982101,
0.018941039219498634,
-0.43094465136528015,
-0.6247730255126953,
0.27683913707733154,
0.5211846232414246,
0.8130729794502258,
-0.02132163755595684,
0.04304242879152298,
0.14618435502052307,
1.0173516273498535,
-0.8515255451202393,
0.0834113359451294,
-0.7346305847167969,
-0.015878619626164436,
-0.07037872821092606,
-0.4834766685962677,
-0.47023770213127136,
-0.34644758701324463,
0.37843066453933716,
-0.6324845552444458,
-0.26567232608795166,
0.1874903440475464,
0.6853766441345215,
0.26321592926979065,
-0.637117326259613,
-0.17427930235862732,
-0.5717981457710266,
1.1835910081863403,
-0.5874059200286865,
0.3482339382171631,
0.3960287868976593,
0.18871578574180603,
-0.34852176904678345,
-0.31155404448509216,
-0.340442955493927,
-0.2457980066537857,
0.0001264755701413378,
0.35641416907310486,
-0.05704721435904503,
0.15972092747688293,
-0.07180929183959961,
0.2385360449552536,
-0.5558417439460754,
0.2279921919107437,
-0.08854107558727264,
0.05822060629725456,
0.6605698466300964,
0.09741002321243286,
0.24142184853553772,
0.05857789143919945,
-0.5303425192832947,
-0.16918332874774933,
-0.7417097091674805,
0.4111762046813965,
0.4333837330341339,
0.4974946975708008,
-0.1407204568386078,
0.5768871903419495,
-0.28608402609825134,
0.962427020072937,
0.30608662962913513,
-0.3796767294406891,
0.3154449164867401,
-0.13517840206623077,
-0.3555891811847687,
0.2132037729024887,
0.8461965322494507,
0.7508150339126587,
0.046315815299749374,
-0.18321150541305542,
-0.18225756287574768,
0.20220087468624115,
0.1910668909549713,
-0.5050244927406311,
0.07005062699317932,
0.3253209888935089,
-0.5566700100898743,
-0.242379829287529,
0.000056631328334333375,
-0.7138971090316772,
-0.2690218389034271,
-0.6196717023849487,
0.4284849166870117,
-0.13644558191299438,
-0.10765624046325684,
0.47115790843963623,
-0.004025817383080721,
0.2708403170108795,
0.2781533896923065,
-1.1721826791763306,
0.2982405722141266,
1.1775223016738892,
0.4762454926967621,
-0.18113993108272552,
-0.3505114018917084,
-0.8578163385391235,
0.17015936970710754,
-0.33282649517059326,
0.5784488916397095,
-0.8472614884376526,
-0.3776000440120697,
-0.09070608764886856,
-0.2805807590484619,
-0.042197633534669876,
-0.49259501695632935,
0.5308524966239929,
-0.5650234222412109,
0.4296238124370575,
-0.3070675730705261,
-0.6325736045837402,
0.2308969348669052,
0.31231188774108887,
-0.364925354719162,
0.7080494165420532,
-0.1306244283914566,
-0.8214542865753174,
0.5909438133239746,
-0.418741375207901,
-0.1931544542312622,
-0.09189483523368835,
-0.40073704719543457,
-0.47068530321121216,
0.0036970290821045637,
0.34127262234687805,
0.42727887630462646,
-0.4552527964115143,
0.35241585969924927,
-0.655327320098877,
-0.3530525863170624,
0.3011808693408966,
-0.22711290419101715,
0.8665255308151245,
0.270153671503067,
-0.220628023147583,
-0.0034033015836030245,
-0.37314003705978394,
0.03537476807832718,
0.07039614766836166,
-0.46764057874679565,
-0.6661807894706726,
0.15761880576610565,
-0.7382272481918335,
-0.1021323874592781,
0.40240275859832764,
-0.4713093638420105,
0.4727340042591095,
-0.44836968183517456,
0.10778789967298508,
0.751130223274231,
-0.267737478017807,
0.8071452379226685,
-0.43487340211868286,
0.33632898330688477,
-0.13468213379383087,
0.15147745609283447,
0.20767554640769958,
-0.30180880427360535,
-0.8120885491371155,
-0.13236507773399353,
0.049646541476249695,
0.29396092891693115,
-0.5319314002990723,
0.5996367335319519,
-0.45563045144081116,
-0.13296595215797424,
-0.7829761505126953,
0.16695906221866608,
0.6101776957511902,
0.5521416068077087,
0.2786323130130768,
-0.16493213176727295,
-0.3995240330696106,
-1.0269368886947632,
-0.07710914313793182,
-0.47966301441192627,
0.018222343176603317,
0.3349466025829315,
-0.20775526762008667,
0.14213763177394867,
0.8114400506019592,
-0.5056915879249573,
-0.09078028053045273,
-0.34060534834861755,
0.14763610064983368,
0.26169610023498535,
0.2251938432455063,
0.7560321092605591,
-0.7573670148849487,
-0.5565587878227234,
0.004086637869477272,
-0.47309261560440063,
-0.12765784561634064,
0.19144167006015778,
-0.4572744071483612,
0.21261118352413177,
0.25121501088142395,
-0.3580884039402008,
-0.003579730400815606,
0.9285120964050293,
-0.04030033200979233,
0.16867312788963318,
0.017102506011724472,
0.5494668483734131,
-1.2726119756698608,
-0.040394969284534454,
-0.14576393365859985,
-0.13461676239967346,
-0.353330135345459,
-0.12207287549972534,
0.052989132702350616,
0.08710400015115738,
-0.4596550464630127,
0.45831701159477234,
-0.4512488543987274,
-0.29114019870758057,
-0.3193378746509552,
0.21581760048866272,
0.18505656719207764,
0.46654513478279114,
0.10314346104860306,
0.774945855140686,
0.48769786953926086,
-0.4216758608818054,
0.37793970108032227,
0.2917412519454956,
-0.10400284081697464,
0.7260984182357788,
-0.3889445662498474,
0.2501731514930725,
-0.11759055405855179,
0.3087143003940582,
-0.868624746799469,
0.024534786120057106,
0.20974315702915192,
-0.37961795926094055,
0.4769836664199829,
-0.37634405493736267,
0.05573218688368797,
-0.13822616636753082,
-0.6519564986228943,
0.40521931648254395,
0.5043022632598877,
-0.733802080154419,
0.26383352279663086,
0.5938646197319031,
-0.2368454933166504,
-1.0520896911621094,
-0.3520464599132538,
0.07284913212060928,
-0.34615767002105713,
-0.5123317241668701,
0.35752758383750916,
-0.09480223059654236,
-0.40399548411369324,
-0.02752901427447796,
-0.01104708295315504,
0.24811463057994843,
-0.028920156881213188,
0.056962158530950546,
0.5121844410896301,
-0.29371318221092224,
0.11448056250810623,
-0.05300068482756615,
-0.3974546790122986,
-0.18916098773479462,
-0.428295373916626,
0.43678006529808044,
-0.18332162499427795,
-0.3914877772331238,
-0.20026244223117828,
0.2494337558746338,
0.562450110912323,
-0.29464206099510193,
0.5958662033081055,
0.22555865347385406,
0.14570966362953186,
0.06986663490533829,
-0.6444694995880127,
-0.05955987051129341,
-0.46488165855407715,
0.22265702486038208,
-0.3139510452747345,
-0.7205954194068909,
-0.12592215836048126,
0.08250737190246582,
0.2510048449039459,
0.120957151055336,
0.47332972288131714,
-0.1361790895462036,
1.2777549028396606,
0.4901738464832306,
-0.5629490613937378,
0.4652820825576782,
-0.21961329877376556,
0.325788676738739,
-0.9773796200752258,
0.14641790091991425,
-0.563961923122406,
-0.5131227374076843,
-0.5567266345024109,
-0.09705386310815811,
0.2747628688812256,
-0.024710489436984062,
-0.1621939092874527,
0.13426420092582703,
-0.38355472683906555,
0.6024483442306519,
0.6224201917648315,
0.07595110684633255,
0.3440898656845093,
-0.1087847426533699,
-0.019019415602087975,
-0.08828840404748917,
-0.4398730397224426,
-0.6967214345932007,
1.2065426111221313,
0.24234983325004578,
0.7397303581237793,
0.10328516364097595,
1.046710729598999,
-0.1572161316871643,
0.11427166312932968,
-0.8208950161933899,
0.5800583362579346,
-0.4585025906562805,
-0.22091402113437653,
-0.33899402618408203,
-0.4584065079689026,
-1.2094030380249023,
0.205021470785141,
-0.33114859461784363,
-0.7798826098442078,
0.023875553160905838,
0.26058030128479004,
-0.4099511504173279,
0.25371748208999634,
-0.7188461422920227,
0.7986016273498535,
-0.6527173519134521,
-0.5918616652488708,
-0.09719392657279968,
-0.7322880029678345,
0.3646785616874695,
0.12637990713119507,
-0.006040116772055626,
-0.3199561536312103,
-0.16244420409202576,
0.6410832405090332,
-0.05279671028256416,
0.5603119730949402,
-0.03460836410522461,
0.04022921621799469,
-0.09126624464988708,
-0.03483310714364052,
0.24876898527145386,
0.10825999826192856,
-0.29275327920913696,
-0.1047888994216919,
-0.10991464555263519,
-0.4375516176223755,
-0.7339240908622742,
0.912514328956604,
-1.0620417594909668,
-0.7823933959007263,
-0.3212614059448242,
-0.5218551754951477,
-0.43917733430862427,
0.12791568040847778,
-0.007706054020673037,
0.4909552335739136,
-0.1661485731601715,
0.3155728578567505,
0.29455992579460144,
-0.1652054637670517,
0.22706875205039978,
0.6196021437644958,
-0.35901743173599243,
-0.35867127776145935,
0.9763020873069763,
-0.295544296503067,
0.605395495891571,
0.6830382943153381,
0.37292876839637756,
-0.31658950448036194,
-0.7020163536071777,
-0.2879435420036316,
0.1768040508031845,
-0.3703530728816986,
-0.26349401473999023,
-0.5449492931365967,
0.019565768539905548,
-0.42955586314201355,
-0.34357884526252747,
-0.43837666511535645,
-0.27939990162849426,
-0.009888916276395321,
0.007980992086231709,
0.009252287447452545,
0.47658318281173706,
0.08341021835803986,
0.008314816281199455,
-0.8514733910560608,
0.27160489559173584,
0.39510107040405273,
0.19094324111938477,
-0.24620774388313293,
-0.2606487274169922,
-0.10633666813373566,
0.29492995142936707,
-0.4574732780456543,
-0.47775059938430786,
0.3836955428123474,
-0.05826595798134804,
0.6764237880706787,
0.4109407067298889,
0.287846177816391,
0.6790745854377747,
-0.23988349735736847,
0.6084645986557007,
0.21642959117889404,
-0.668517529964447,
0.4667225480079651,
-0.22828325629234314,
0.2003137469291687,
0.8770961165428162,
0.48599743843078613,
-0.4199061393737793,
-0.596644401550293,
-0.471407949924469,
-0.6718270182609558,
0.8721383213996887,
-0.005338942166417837,
0.07650614529848099,
0.025459948927164078,
0.1435728669166565,
0.29322534799575806,
0.1740528792142868,
-0.5160568952560425,
-0.21957267820835114,
0.20210975408554077,
-0.2700091600418091,
-0.36191099882125854,
-0.21217162907123566,
-0.47159942984580994,
0.05123822018504143,
0.6200487017631531,
-0.042735692113637924,
0.1547316163778305,
-0.17047742009162903,
0.027703149244189262,
-0.19311073422431946,
0.3869302272796631,
0.2863791286945343,
0.5860279202461243,
-0.5030956268310547,
0.2497253715991974,
-0.09427642077207565,
-0.12201721966266632,
0.2615874111652374,
0.05889207869768143,
-0.09237927198410034,
-0.5205678939819336,
0.3595196604728699,
0.9112297892570496,
0.3687555491924286,
-0.3720833957195282,
0.5563958883285522,
-0.37031787633895874,
-0.07124298810958862,
0.17612634599208832,
0.18057246506214142,
0.15019363164901733,
0.1704789251089096,
0.12334202229976654,
-0.1175902932882309,
0.1988849639892578,
-0.5662534832954407,
0.0766763761639595,
0.7359078526496887,
-0.07193351536989212,
-0.06613186001777649,
0.227125883102417,
0.5729063749313354,
-0.3655252754688263,
0.5044806003570557,
-0.14265066385269165,
-0.4747005105018616,
0.5046946406364441,
0.508379340171814,
0.8000296354293823,
-0.049500349909067154,
0.24223686754703522,
0.2889080047607422,
-0.07177171111106873,
0.08578427135944366,
-0.12232723832130432,
-0.19056226313114166,
-0.9987848401069641,
-0.27882739901542664,
-0.5919579267501831,
-0.6249999403953552,
0.1760590672492981,
-0.7241359353065491,
0.501848578453064,
-0.1268743872642517,
-0.09075498580932617,
-0.0021872117649763823,
0.21881449222564697,
-0.5567207932472229,
-0.05301566794514656,
0.17246706783771515,
0.34164902567863464,
-0.8751081228256226,
0.8411310911178589,
0.7256794571876526,
-0.2438744753599167,
-0.7674213647842407,
0.24309125542640686,
0.22556385397911072,
-0.9618273973464966,
0.6399394273757935,
0.1740153431892395,
-0.19119468331336975,
-0.13027788698673248,
-0.1252283900976181,
-0.8405425548553467,
0.8785333633422852,
0.5312081575393677,
-0.6085799336433411,
0.16385821998119354,
0.1491757333278656,
0.3593050241470337,
-0.5330324172973633,
0.40102478861808777,
0.6932632923126221,
0.37568050622940063,
0.1614483892917633,
-0.8880081176757812,
-0.2587326765060425,
-0.12775366008281708,
-0.1649373471736908,
0.612507700920105,
-0.7231906056404114,
0.5854190587997437,
-0.14605502784252167,
-0.05849277228116989,
-0.03362177684903145,
0.368233859539032,
0.3236220180988312,
0.4647057354450226,
0.6902163624763489,
0.621713399887085,
0.4487825036048889,
0.033439796417951584,
1.0927143096923828,
-0.4001859724521637,
0.26785755157470703,
1.0878968238830566,
-0.477583110332489,
0.982702910900116,
0.7678772211074829,
-0.3995131254196167,
0.016122477129101753,
0.5289883017539978,
0.5393295288085938,
0.544803261756897,
-0.24101082980632782,
-0.2252849042415619,
-0.17998006939888,
-0.10707595199346542,
-0.4264628291130066,
0.61985182762146,
0.22349563241004944,
-0.09753227978944778,
-0.08902449160814285,
-0.2641851603984833,
-0.02111014351248741,
0.20821766555309296,
0.05513449013233185,
0.9619024991989136,
0.07194652408361435,
-1.1781240701675415,
0.5965458154678345,
-0.2981094419956207,
0.760255753993988,
-0.5702837109565735,
0.08408970385789871,
-0.2484312802553177,
0.16705770790576935,
-0.024866757914423943,
-0.7735037803649902,
0.022949352860450745,
-0.3102812170982361,
-0.08112093061208725,
-0.21753594279289246,
0.4022142291069031,
-0.7779369354248047,
-0.3127172291278839,
0.603283166885376,
0.33880630135536194,
-0.10652481019496918,
0.4991913437843323,
-0.8464062809944153,
0.46766969561576843,
0.014929342083632946,
-0.27763789892196655,
0.5697085857391357,
0.14343127608299255,
0.2645188271999359,
0.41713908314704895,
0.5827127695083618,
0.25798705220222473,
-0.19763967394828796,
0.17760249972343445,
0.7189915776252747,
-0.20502164959907532,
-0.36995020508766174,
-0.7704619765281677,
0.38651204109191895,
-0.21358811855316162,
-0.10855069011449814,
0.5190264582633972,
0.5285182595252991,
0.9920173287391663,
0.2273642122745514,
0.6972658634185791,
0.15944109857082367,
0.5308934450149536,
-0.8055984973907471,
0.34105655550956726,
-0.7365502715110779,
0.4703984260559082,
-0.339057981967926,
-1.179042100906372,
-0.20067262649536133,
0.5000010132789612,
-0.7005341053009033,
0.07247809320688248,
0.5850281119346619,
0.9503469467163086,
-0.2944360077381134,
-0.1993797868490219,
0.4131412208080292,
-0.0231541246175766,
0.5145094990730286,
0.8740403056144714,
0.956839382648468,
-0.05172824114561081,
0.42372745275497437,
-0.4724743962287903,
-0.4956372380256653,
-0.3747137486934662,
-1.0418919324874878,
-0.7026041746139526,
-0.5829912424087524,
-0.1533447504043579,
-0.14427050948143005,
0.41652587056159973,
1.3193144798278809,
0.6130744218826294,
-0.5444000959396362,
-0.4664674699306488,
0.17469562590122223,
0.14157657325267792,
0.016678471118211746,
-0.18043074011802673,
0.3157917559146881,
-0.5444127321243286,
-1.14229416847229,
0.3734210133552551,
0.5590752363204956,
0.011798222549259663,
-0.07788072526454926,
-0.5060944557189941,
-0.12404660880565643,
-0.11673050373792648,
0.4396306574344635,
0.2784336507320404,
-0.7706511616706848,
-0.3923226296901703,
-0.09148940443992615,
-0.3212500810623169,
0.16992619633674622,
0.8099315166473389,
-0.5474100112915039,
0.7226778864860535,
0.561101496219635,
0.9222620129585266,
0.280985951423645,
0.10247484594583511,
0.8916083574295044,
-0.4945242702960968,
0.3455609977245331,
0.03064107708632946,
0.45372024178504944,
0.3173685073852539,
-0.2416476607322693,
0.24106267094612122,
-0.2759746313095093,
-0.805561363697052,
-0.6637687087059021,
0.2449922263622284,
-1.158239722251892,
-0.1209130510687828,
1.0076398849487305,
-0.13282668590545654,
-0.11717148870229721,
0.10420965403318405,
-0.520064651966095,
0.14074602723121643,
-0.6436884999275208,
0.9547412991523743,
0.4244081676006317,
-0.20643754303455353,
0.1806103140115738,
-0.20595546066761017,
0.28103169798851013,
0.8247318863868713,
-0.7111777067184448,
0.01686534471809864,
0.46590837836265564,
0.015018097124993801,
0.017140377312898636,
0.7567586302757263,
-0.028941050171852112,
0.18148928880691528,
-0.37535104155540466,
-0.10140927135944366,
-0.06780444830656052,
-0.2963868975639343,
-0.29766845703125,
-0.14513860642910004,
0.40898677706718445,
-0.5169146656990051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00511v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00511v3
|
MIPS at SemEval-2024 Task 3: Multimodal Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction in Conversations with Multimodal Language Models
| 2024-03-31T01:16:02 | 2024-04-11T05:14:35 |
Zebang Cheng, Fuqiang Niu, Yuxiang Lin, Zhi-Qi Cheng, Bowen Zhang, Xiaojiang Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
This paper presents our winning submission to Subtask 2 of SemEval 2024 Task
3 on multimodal emotion cause analysis in conversations. We propose a novel
Multimodal Emotion Recognition and Multimodal Emotion Cause Extraction
(MER-MCE) framework that integrates text, audio, and visual modalities using
specialized emotion encoders. Our approach sets itself apart from
top-performing teams by leveraging modality-specific features for enhanced
emotion understanding and causality inference. Experimental evaluation
demonstrates the advantages of our multimodal approach, with our submission
achieving a competitive weighted F1 score of 0.3435, ranking third with a
margin of only 0.0339 behind the 1st team and 0.0025 behind the 2nd team.
Project: https://github.com/MIPS-COLT/MER-MCE.git
|
[
-0.5736647248268127,
-0.6514473557472229,
0.5867959856987,
0.43164271116256714,
-0.051186174154281616,
-0.23348818719387054,
-0.07439712435007095,
-0.5400686264038086,
0.39321842789649963,
0.3184443712234497,
-0.765500009059906,
-0.12176473438739777,
-0.8226624727249146,
0.12128965556621552,
0.0991768091917038,
0.7457699179649353,
-0.09600788354873657,
0.20324820280075073,
-0.3355438709259033,
-0.29949453473091125,
-0.45253732800483704,
-0.46026474237442017,
-0.6137765049934387,
-0.01931995339691639,
0.7845345735549927,
0.8074584007263184,
0.10604061931371689,
-0.16336052119731903,
0.6245867013931274,
0.30073484778404236,
0.4284329414367676,
0.1907430738210678,
-0.2740466892719269,
0.47827067971229553,
-0.14113382995128632,
-0.04562617465853691,
-0.8390178680419922,
-0.015161140821874142,
0.24671418964862823,
0.07127019017934799,
0.04646444693207741,
-0.05888707563281059,
0.05500020831823349,
0.6942797303199768,
-0.7793521881103516,
0.2981353998184204,
-0.43162745237350464,
-0.08419137448072433,
-0.2619395852088928,
-0.7813065052032471,
-0.3981599509716034,
0.17100900411605835,
0.03896266594529152,
-0.20112140476703644,
0.04853145405650139,
0.13501672446727753,
0.703960120677948,
0.22540298104286194,
-0.9507280588150024,
-0.39626437425613403,
-0.19335471093654633,
0.5619376301765442,
-0.6689739227294922,
0.6464956402778625,
0.23690247535705566,
0.15395879745483398,
0.007958912290632725,
-0.5251543521881104,
-0.6575735807418823,
0.1531388759613037,
0.07646868377923965,
0.41754454374313354,
-0.4133600890636444,
0.1626102775335312,
0.08684895187616348,
0.12582603096961975,
-0.6693734526634216,
-0.08524440973997116,
-0.25841501355171204,
-0.3697347939014435,
0.6299693584442139,
0.08880966156721115,
0.5205472111701965,
-0.2407439798116684,
-0.48990902304649353,
-0.036828141659498215,
-0.5058354139328003,
0.10500434041023254,
0.2716154456138611,
-0.05208747833967209,
-0.3477017283439636,
0.5799165964126587,
-0.2651172876358032,
0.13531982898712158,
-0.2691502571105957,
0.06434887647628784,
0.5158604383468628,
-0.4743540585041046,
-0.12338332831859589,
-0.15423627197742462,
0.9277384877204895,
0.6143937110900879,
-0.016389166936278343,
0.16238243877887726,
-0.06688990443944931,
0.018425533547997475,
0.018742121756076813,
-0.752994954586029,
-0.0642801970243454,
0.2642531096935272,
-0.5125356316566467,
-0.29264071583747864,
-0.0999012291431427,
-1.5335087776184082,
-0.682671844959259,
-0.16160763800144196,
0.7420720458030701,
-0.14053481817245483,
-0.4533524811267853,
0.035542041063308716,
-0.2534269690513611,
0.06328373402357101,
0.2857106328010559,
-0.8903727531433105,
0.04120275378227234,
0.4060593843460083,
0.6177974343299866,
0.023490697145462036,
-0.325166791677475,
-0.5777333974838257,
-0.05953893065452576,
0.052630387246608734,
0.7081766128540039,
-0.5198505520820618,
-0.28714433312416077,
-0.24858681857585907,
0.24029244482517242,
-0.2697649896144867,
-0.17488978803157806,
1.0596107244491577,
-0.2343859076499939,
0.4003192186355591,
-0.3411085307598114,
-0.076675184071064,
-0.26937371492385864,
0.37347596883773804,
-0.7088357210159302,
0.7545415163040161,
-0.19363269209861755,
-0.7990220785140991,
0.04118971526622772,
-0.927422821521759,
-0.3083382844924927,
0.0024146749638020992,
-0.19445230066776276,
-0.15868055820465088,
0.24958205223083496,
0.3711944818496704,
0.6800119280815125,
-0.5406614542007446,
0.36835137009620667,
-0.47110968828201294,
0.1897582709789276,
0.16165326535701752,
-0.5871486663818359,
0.40975871682167053,
0.34160375595092773,
-0.5707005262374878,
0.403958797454834,
-0.6332323551177979,
-0.25300297141075134,
0.218119814991951,
-0.17409004271030426,
-0.16643933951854706,
0.07985381036996841,
0.13972096145153046,
0.8398258686065674,
0.1782001256942749,
-0.7736296653747559,
-0.07706199586391449,
-0.008286858908832073,
0.37255915999412537,
0.7475634813308716,
0.3594134747982025,
0.38657739758491516,
-0.047996409237384796,
0.6994626522064209,
0.2732694745063782,
0.14822793006896973,
-0.478671669960022,
-0.5657274127006531,
-0.8994093537330627,
-0.39982932806015015,
-0.07780691236257553,
0.5419430136680603,
-0.9039031863212585,
-0.247925266623497,
-0.02133352868258953,
-0.39803895354270935,
-0.3183882236480713,
-0.18299070000648499,
0.31264516711235046,
0.5042700171470642,
0.24740764498710632,
-0.14626775681972504,
-0.958890974521637,
-1.0955777168273926,
-0.2080805003643036,
-0.13286828994750977,
0.2374822050333023,
0.6608150601387024,
0.6143689155578613,
-0.6189109086990356,
0.5604680180549622,
-0.15547382831573486,
-0.0758233442902565,
-0.14992649853229523,
0.5439586639404297,
-0.2777477204799652,
0.6742235422134399,
0.5950636267662048,
-0.8410607576370239,
-0.05058756470680237,
-0.08494982123374939,
-0.7909214496612549,
-0.6669261455535889,
-0.02063564956188202,
-0.15070053935050964,
0.4188503324985504,
0.512801468372345,
-0.4384547770023346,
0.2519897520542145,
0.9764814376831055,
-0.5718527436256409,
0.5018948316574097,
0.10861267149448395,
0.8964270353317261,
-1.2643359899520874,
-0.12348262220621109,
0.17439642548561096,
-0.022861385717988014,
-0.6184159517288208,
-0.25514745712280273,
-0.02478729747235775,
-0.4523007273674011,
-0.44022369384765625,
0.5163589715957642,
-0.20747585594654083,
0.06582916527986526,
0.043690379709005356,
0.095350481569767,
0.07320649921894073,
0.7114428281784058,
0.07534048706293106,
0.37160253524780273,
0.3314967751502991,
-0.22226829826831818,
0.5153639912605286,
0.04972849041223526,
0.04157109186053276,
0.6218247413635254,
-0.4885752201080322,
-0.015325096435844898,
-0.07903200387954712,
0.0922490805387497,
-1.248533844947815,
-0.50545734167099,
0.3300315737724304,
-0.6473766565322876,
0.22443756461143494,
0.06356722116470337,
-0.31271329522132874,
-0.20452231168746948,
-0.29004234075546265,
0.49810847640037537,
0.021733181551098824,
-0.2788224518299103,
0.8267744779586792,
0.5847494602203369,
-0.7340877056121826,
-0.19005653262138367,
-0.4977196156978607,
0.22686828672885895,
-0.34239625930786133,
-0.9762465953826904,
0.11142394691705704,
-0.26046156883239746,
-0.0037868651561439037,
-0.31613147258758545,
0.08799034357070923,
-0.12447299808263779,
0.08165112882852554,
0.47729554772377014,
0.06569063663482666,
-0.21867407858371735,
0.23369763791561127,
0.01735576242208481,
-0.2926389276981354,
0.2541884481906891,
0.4738066792488098,
0.5716074705123901,
-0.520779550075531,
-0.5397403836250305,
-0.36902883648872375,
0.8159610033035278,
1.0413743257522583,
-0.4393608570098877,
0.29902270436286926,
0.9646225571632385,
-0.4448406398296356,
0.2509087026119232,
-0.7548673152923584,
-0.29542094469070435,
-0.4058622419834137,
0.49942728877067566,
-0.47784706950187683,
-1.14191472530365,
0.3379749059677124,
-0.25707387924194336,
-0.35001981258392334,
0.5595768690109253,
0.7935326099395752,
-0.28410667181015015,
1.524704098701477,
0.6024869084358215,
0.025518840178847313,
0.51186603307724,
0.17016391456127167,
0.31976255774497986,
-0.697262704372406,
-0.5472215414047241,
-0.4960329830646515,
-0.31834685802459717,
-0.6475092172622681,
-0.34982672333717346,
0.5978643298149109,
-0.0051454356871545315,
0.11586697399616241,
0.15035925805568695,
0.09149881452322006,
0.07018209993839264,
0.4956398904323578,
-0.0766991525888443,
-0.06310365349054337,
-0.12823733687400818,
-0.06674934178590775,
-0.34949663281440735,
-0.6543131470680237,
-0.3494475185871124,
0.5843166708946228,
0.5885715484619141,
0.4020971655845642,
0.4303729832172394,
0.5960941910743713,
0.31616660952568054,
-0.02399001270532608,
-0.6608455181121826,
0.660269021987915,
0.32844462990760803,
-0.519462525844574,
0.1002337858080864,
-0.389105886220932,
-0.6090739965438843,
0.4670249819755554,
-0.45002344250679016,
-0.8716907501220703,
0.4146250784397125,
-0.027295010164380074,
0.04855891317129135,
-0.12855881452560425,
-0.8481520414352417,
1.3506295680999756,
-0.2531115710735321,
-0.35512301325798035,
-0.3385845720767975,
-0.7616360783576965,
0.5892384052276611,
0.0019021987682208419,
0.6201881766319275,
-0.3020418882369995,
0.12896789610385895,
0.7994779944419861,
-0.18636608123779297,
0.7304766178131104,
-0.29001909494400024,
0.009975451044738293,
0.19454744458198547,
0.2301836758852005,
0.37145769596099854,
0.07543293386697769,
0.15179984271526337,
0.09178709983825684,
0.09640622138977051,
-0.24049483239650726,
-0.5659446716308594,
0.5905117988586426,
-0.40715911984443665,
-0.14570599794387817,
-0.41663485765457153,
-0.5227876305580139,
-0.42254653573036194,
-0.01722482033073902,
0.2259930819272995,
0.7587096691131592,
0.008558792993426323,
0.4704643189907074,
0.3816083073616028,
-0.2638660967350006,
0.771162748336792,
0.582632839679718,
0.07472314685583115,
-0.7391040325164795,
1.1602362394332886,
-0.38867565989494324,
0.12020061910152435,
0.2197033017873764,
0.2867659330368042,
-0.1627226620912552,
-0.10925140231847763,
-0.3190240263938904,
0.13184130191802979,
-0.6911261081695557,
-0.21517407894134521,
-0.8842368721961975,
0.09642540663480759,
-0.633108913898468,
-0.15230360627174377,
-0.3908080756664276,
-0.4662854075431824,
-0.30382874608039856,
0.07341074198484421,
-0.07726100087165833,
0.3951388895511627,
-0.4640355408191681,
0.023873860016465187,
-1.190069317817688,
0.15971529483795166,
0.4093465209007263,
-0.04996039345860481,
-0.4403800070285797,
-0.20906171202659607,
-0.06789708882570267,
0.00857254583388567,
-0.5414043664932251,
-1.158202052116394,
0.6014899611473083,
0.2571062743663788,
0.6572070717811584,
0.46717536449432373,
-0.06295855343341827,
0.7001484036445618,
-0.261068731546402,
0.9506688714027405,
0.4420126974582672,
-1.0365201234817505,
0.8041935563087463,
-0.5945266485214233,
0.17595775425434113,
0.42730042338371277,
0.34008994698524475,
-0.8550735712051392,
-0.10184277594089508,
-0.7779624462127686,
-0.7240611910820007,
0.6748818159103394,
0.30505070090293884,
-0.12003154307603836,
-0.15323251485824585,
-0.19531026482582092,
-0.21287481486797333,
0.20361322164535522,
-0.6993904709815979,
0.03526929020881653,
0.05888993293046951,
-0.4931829273700714,
-0.03824448585510254,
-0.9845919609069824,
0.025988802313804626,
0.0859122946858406,
0.8626239895820618,
-0.12314262986183167,
0.6029901504516602,
0.1605607569217682,
-0.2469928115606308,
-0.12788398563861847,
0.7160587906837463,
1.1996960639953613,
0.24783658981323242,
-0.18769672513008118,
0.4079742133617401,
0.15208972990512848,
-0.16941826045513153,
-0.11080285906791687,
0.1313973367214203,
0.5452927947044373,
-0.09286245703697205,
0.6751453876495361,
0.7423051595687866,
0.48336687684059143,
-0.8951022028923035,
0.8627681732177734,
-0.15363246202468872,
-0.09361948072910309,
0.12338022142648697,
-0.418171763420105,
-0.1375204175710678,
0.7219517230987549,
0.14931751787662506,
0.2228931188583374,
0.5817364454269409,
-0.4363531768321991,
0.36806875467300415,
0.21906857192516327,
-0.6113020181655884,
-0.6735691428184509,
0.5533173680305481,
0.6498931050300598,
0.09074858576059341,
-0.038590967655181885,
-0.26663893461227417,
-0.9365368485450745,
0.5600280165672302,
0.5568450689315796,
0.9485204219818115,
-0.3951641321182251,
0.08088486641645432,
0.40251004695892334,
0.2898947298526764,
0.25782278180122375,
0.6264680624008179,
-0.20869071781635284,
-0.8395437002182007,
-0.26944541931152344,
-0.3810228705406189,
-0.3917636275291443,
-0.0852312445640564,
-0.518136203289032,
0.33104032278060913,
0.040997546166181564,
0.011949006468057632,
-0.1882273554801941,
-0.3147597908973694,
-0.4966443181037903,
0.1613394021987915,
0.5573022365570068,
0.46623653173446655,
-1.080884575843811,
0.44000717997550964,
0.7392772436141968,
-0.37056493759155273,
-0.5244210362434387,
-0.5681070685386658,
0.5951631665229797,
-0.5133266448974609,
0.8553603291511536,
0.2598797380924225,
-0.22084885835647583,
-0.03686102107167244,
-0.4212667644023895,
-0.6271457076072693,
1.0741009712219238,
0.25525006651878357,
-0.3457118570804596,
0.23586058616638184,
-0.11422992497682571,
0.1263148933649063,
-0.45474761724472046,
0.49081045389175415,
0.3091775178909302,
0.3485150635242462,
0.20468908548355103,
-1.060912013053894,
-0.2040414810180664,
-0.6328930258750916,
-0.33817392587661743,
0.2883455455303192,
-0.615745484828949,
0.6229588389396667,
-0.06334125250577927,
-0.08013344556093216,
-0.36982572078704834,
0.4661449193954468,
0.2770337462425232,
0.6604203581809998,
0.4514926075935364,
0.6040170788764954,
0.41422930359840393,
-0.1348571479320526,
0.7206536531448364,
-0.16083985567092896,
0.3981318771839142,
1.197579026222229,
-0.19430893659591675,
0.8506296277046204,
0.6877130270004272,
0.1321898251771927,
0.4769238233566284,
0.598067581653595,
0.5458171367645264,
0.5556849837303162,
-0.42738643288612366,
-0.37958452105522156,
-0.4896396994590759,
-0.277645081281662,
-0.37987852096557617,
0.8707247972488403,
0.4221004545688629,
-0.3685342073440552,
-0.2080625593662262,
0.45717233419418335,
0.1676809936761856,
-0.45403093099594116,
-0.09598011523485184,
0.64146488904953,
0.005629437044262886,
-0.40094712376594543,
-0.07166710495948792,
-0.007289370521903038,
0.5625974535942078,
-0.4501112103462219,
-0.11554386466741562,
-0.12257799506187439,
0.08989547938108444,
-0.20957079529762268,
-0.46440836787223816,
0.274581640958786,
-0.16913816332817078,
-0.1428425908088684,
-0.5046766400337219,
0.9976282119750977,
-0.5910166501998901,
-0.29105696082115173,
0.2128010243177414,
0.5248398780822754,
0.08093447238206863,
-0.33490559458732605,
-0.6711107492446899,
0.2931373715400696,
-0.17749544978141785,
-0.48149725794792175,
0.2407607138156891,
0.6826918721199036,
-0.038860779255628586,
0.4095134139060974,
0.5532345175743103,
-0.5058700442314148,
0.01952257938683033,
0.2856520116329193,
0.6314313411712646,
-0.5619138479232788,
-0.3695968985557556,
-0.9944825768470764,
0.8570676445960999,
-0.08280821144580841,
-0.4277523458003998,
0.7098246216773987,
0.4667753577232361,
0.3235497772693634,
-0.11277565360069275,
0.5060780644416809,
-0.3338618874549866,
0.2547243535518646,
-0.4593583643436432,
0.39715540409088135,
-0.9083694815635681,
-0.01071966253221035,
-0.7181515097618103,
-0.6044557690620422,
-0.18279089033603668,
0.40373560786247253,
-0.08451520651578903,
-0.20586374402046204,
0.8593109250068665,
0.9166224598884583,
0.24204294383525848,
0.41704919934272766,
0.3962004482746124,
0.07899011671543121,
0.5208188891410828,
0.9607431292533875,
1.0328125953674316,
-0.5607777237892151,
0.34433579444885254,
-0.24413245916366577,
-0.3700036406517029,
-0.43112465739250183,
-1.1278780698776245,
-0.5526768565177917,
-1.1377531290054321,
-0.3955260217189789,
-0.13252392411231995,
-0.4445374310016632,
1.0285953283309937,
0.6581632494926453,
-0.7059708833694458,
0.14365170896053314,
0.05012081563472748,
0.052866410464048386,
0.15661711990833282,
-0.30273109674453735,
-0.1834302544593811,
-0.3531714081764221,
-0.619073212146759,
0.7235900163650513,
0.6363983750343323,
-0.014588646590709686,
0.05572742223739624,
-0.2562197744846344,
-0.4448237121105194,
0.05821431428194046,
0.9492950439453125,
0.12308958172798157,
-0.6946322321891785,
-0.4361434578895569,
-0.15122811496257782,
-0.07829973846673965,
-0.2372836172580719,
0.9924232959747314,
-0.4046441316604614,
0.7146420478820801,
0.917274534702301,
0.5514492392539978,
0.364111989736557,
-0.2733987867832184,
0.5800091624259949,
-0.6321712732315063,
0.1633952111005783,
0.262050598859787,
0.8120711445808411,
0.10980319231748581,
-0.17246516048908234,
0.6787770986557007,
0.6863130927085876,
-0.817884624004364,
-0.707131564617157,
0.32078373432159424,
-1.4260146617889404,
0.1083424836397171,
1.222235918045044,
0.0599592924118042,
-0.05657067522406578,
0.17915530502796173,
-0.5385938882827759,
0.1040109246969223,
-0.4157972037792206,
0.27492451667785645,
0.9343938827514648,
-0.347250372171402,
-0.7287502288818359,
-0.7434413433074951,
0.15868884325027466,
0.6038951873779297,
-1.1649034023284912,
-0.28183531761169434,
0.8357074856758118,
-0.046494584530591965,
0.07838048040866852,
0.7892893552780151,
-0.15919993817806244,
0.3469865024089813,
-0.04752868041396141,
0.44411373138427734,
-0.08015435189008713,
-0.5358186960220337,
-0.46564799547195435,
0.3420158326625824,
-0.4233482778072357,
-0.2564373314380646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01339v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01339v1
|
Humane Speech Synthesis through Zero-Shot Emotion and Disfluency Generation
| 2024-03-31T00:38:02 | 2024-03-31T00:38:02 |
Rohan Chaudhury, Mihir Godbole, Aakash Garg, Jinsil Hwaryoung Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Contemporary conversational systems often present a significant limitation:
their responses lack the emotional depth and disfluent characteristic of human
interactions. This absence becomes particularly noticeable when users seek more
personalized and empathetic interactions. Consequently, this makes them seem
mechanical and less relatable to human users. Recognizing this gap, we embarked
on a journey to humanize machine communication, to ensure AI systems not only
comprehend but also resonate. To address this shortcoming, we have designed an
innovative speech synthesis pipeline. Within this framework, a cutting-edge
language model introduces both human-like emotion and disfluencies in a
zero-shot setting. These intricacies are seamlessly integrated into the
generated text by the language model during text generation, allowing the
system to mirror human speech patterns better, promoting more intuitive and
natural user interactions. These generated elements are then adeptly
transformed into corresponding speech patterns and emotive sounds using a
rule-based approach during the text-to-speech phase. Based on our experiments,
our novel system produces synthesized speech that's almost indistinguishable
from genuine human communication, making each interaction feel more personal
and authentic.
|
[
-0.528511643409729,
-0.9667002558708191,
0.40653249621391296,
0.09624197334051132,
-0.1633361428976059,
0.49100810289382935,
0.015290752053260803,
-0.520115315914154,
0.5035654306411743,
0.22195816040039062,
-0.9217222929000854,
-0.4734043776988983,
-0.10075583308935165,
0.26054707169532776,
-0.48370125889778137,
1.1030240058898926,
0.40461328625679016,
-0.1257583647966385,
0.18224605917930603,
-0.04011421650648117,
-0.2719312012195587,
-0.6229243278503418,
-0.24690252542495728,
-0.4502106308937073,
0.5654700994491577,
0.3830772936344147,
0.6377938985824585,
0.6813845038414001,
-0.00693807378411293,
0.2684790790081024,
0.0017429953441023827,
-0.16332367062568665,
-0.5257011651992798,
0.4442165791988373,
0.006979255471378565,
-0.022435642778873444,
-0.6352514028549194,
0.07226670533418655,
0.3558914363384247,
0.5769204497337341,
-0.18193911015987396,
-0.013960877433419228,
0.004890574607998133,
0.47483062744140625,
-0.5402617454528809,
-0.007704924792051315,
-0.7599633932113647,
0.42950165271759033,
-0.11945334821939468,
-0.03700548782944679,
-0.36135751008987427,
-0.180735245347023,
0.06061135604977608,
-0.38474103808403015,
0.2131449282169342,
-0.28477469086647034,
0.4819103181362152,
0.393192321062088,
-0.06827647238969803,
-0.2861732840538025,
-1.0710946321487427,
0.5351207852363586,
-0.8769147992134094,
0.15585128962993622,
0.07028614729642868,
0.2462599128484726,
-0.1692294478416443,
-0.6319836378097534,
-0.9784168601036072,
-0.22888733446598053,
0.37364473938941956,
0.25314033031463623,
-0.5290420055389404,
0.3300442695617676,
0.10191978514194489,
0.16949136555194855,
-0.5889723896980286,
0.1659950613975525,
-0.20635676383972168,
-0.29259228706359863,
0.6963401436805725,
0.40122950077056885,
0.6225807070732117,
-0.18451443314552307,
-0.04248122498393059,
-0.24966581165790558,
-0.3403029441833496,
-0.06460721790790558,
0.5347217917442322,
0.4820767045021057,
0.09821798652410507,
0.415431410074234,
-0.41786083579063416,
0.5282118916511536,
0.12951897084712982,
-0.05375473201274872,
0.3017796576023102,
0.02286437153816223,
-0.3956792950630188,
0.5693824887275696,
0.8243187665939331,
0.4607827663421631,
0.05362746864557266,
-0.12285806983709335,
-0.12788622081279755,
0.5624663233757019,
0.484886109828949,
-0.9153454899787903,
-0.07121318578720093,
0.3070318400859833,
-0.07660763710737228,
-0.748471200466156,
-0.1960889846086502,
-0.7615004777908325,
-0.2843914330005646,
-0.29647940397262573,
0.37632277607917786,
-0.3275720775127411,
-0.3027684688568115,
0.2023959457874298,
-0.06722664833068848,
0.01401591021567583,
0.11755523085594177,
-0.9458586573600769,
0.07484038174152374,
0.5313595533370972,
0.6171554923057556,
0.11053944379091263,
-0.2707856297492981,
-0.5452557802200317,
0.07487845420837402,
-0.3808077871799469,
0.5645834803581238,
-0.552567183971405,
-0.40872734785079956,
-0.09565712511539459,
-0.2912904620170593,
0.4888823926448822,
-0.45729315280914307,
0.6785813570022583,
0.09377571940422058,
0.3684360980987549,
0.05279943719506264,
-0.297019898891449,
-0.0778774619102478,
-0.06080661341547966,
-0.2050805389881134,
0.559299886226654,
0.14307479560375214,
-0.5142025947570801,
0.19291451573371887,
-0.9530980587005615,
-0.6154656410217285,
0.2515108287334442,
-0.09762001037597656,
-0.29496288299560547,
0.23963969945907593,
0.09565213322639465,
0.40480127930641174,
-0.11508211493492126,
0.23653441667556763,
-0.48524734377861023,
-0.34412550926208496,
0.29331254959106445,
-0.43734198808670044,
0.4816138744354248,
0.4776163101196289,
-0.7022122144699097,
0.10689714550971985,
-0.9669860005378723,
0.03309235721826553,
0.1914282739162445,
-0.10620921105146408,
-0.17792227864265442,
0.031362008303403854,
0.251779705286026,
0.453401654958725,
-0.11521488428115845,
-0.8605313897132874,
-0.20279677212238312,
-0.8683455586433411,
0.9203522801399231,
0.7029202580451965,
-0.025960925966501236,
0.5170931816101074,
-0.3478333652019501,
0.49069714546203613,
-0.03479383885860443,
0.12019596993923187,
-0.3545445203781128,
-0.32110220193862915,
-0.7022939920425415,
-0.36544060707092285,
-0.20904012024402618,
0.5808061361312866,
-0.4465191960334778,
0.4689922332763672,
0.02848212979733944,
-0.4630265533924103,
-1.0216925144195557,
-0.20602202415466309,
0.20916256308555603,
0.9222056865692139,
0.32475969195365906,
-0.41662856936454773,
-0.6594342589378357,
-0.8463871479034424,
-0.1305980235338211,
-0.4011591970920563,
-0.365224689245224,
0.11097341775894165,
0.07831241935491562,
-0.32941415905952454,
0.9812310934066772,
-0.3357234597206116,
-0.15320125222206116,
-0.11374057829380035,
0.24195945262908936,
0.0044050076976418495,
0.40473365783691406,
0.37353795766830444,
-0.46593567728996277,
-0.3482119143009186,
0.016853902488946915,
-0.711487889289856,
-0.41935497522354126,
-0.335614949464798,
-0.19982847571372986,
0.3491970896720886,
0.4507221579551697,
-0.573242723941803,
0.5476823449134827,
0.3653583824634552,
-0.0766088217496872,
0.18215541541576385,
0.0596233531832695,
0.28559404611587524,
-1.125335454940796,
0.24888139963150024,
-0.30625519156455994,
-0.2386101931333542,
-1.1084827184677124,
-0.26221325993537903,
-0.5233827233314514,
-0.6438800692558289,
-0.7683634161949158,
0.3139970600605011,
-0.12078164517879486,
-0.04920161888003349,
-0.262035071849823,
0.2878537178039551,
0.12819530069828033,
0.6437800526618958,
-0.1774289458990097,
0.6059381365776062,
0.5156057476997375,
-0.445665568113327,
0.46797236800193787,
0.5556420683860779,
0.027911584824323654,
0.9843254685401917,
-0.9235368371009827,
0.32752248644828796,
-0.15620583295822144,
0.3201190233230591,
-0.855907142162323,
-0.4134604036808014,
0.3830936551094055,
-0.8181455135345459,
-0.024491723626852036,
0.19265002012252808,
-0.16849863529205322,
-0.1808900684118271,
-0.34323757886886597,
0.1194022074341774,
0.8965379595756531,
-0.19227412343025208,
0.344035267829895,
0.6106568574905396,
-0.6815369129180908,
-0.06835903227329254,
-0.9427328109741211,
0.6351876258850098,
-0.22666753828525543,
-0.6246811747550964,
0.308712363243103,
-0.31364905834198,
-0.21387150883674622,
-0.18078087270259857,
0.25212785601615906,
-0.0032232296653091908,
0.09445223957300186,
0.4024175703525543,
0.10610045492649078,
-0.010526223108172417,
0.007822212763130665,
0.6057533621788025,
0.0009355179499834776,
-0.06442351639270782,
-0.01379417534917593,
0.4634028673171997,
0.00005939911716268398,
-0.3936035931110382,
-1.0271412134170532,
0.7775329351425171,
1.089593768119812,
-0.0727107971906662,
0.18563397228717804,
0.6780548095703125,
-0.431484192609787,
-0.11872290074825287,
-0.18969064950942993,
-0.4723864793777466,
-0.48351022601127625,
0.38510018587112427,
-0.22087012231349945,
-1.006739854812622,
0.315837025642395,
-0.07149472087621689,
0.09205381572246552,
0.20037366449832916,
0.7778807878494263,
-0.23625648021697998,
1.3309589624404907,
0.2827207148075104,
-0.023239852860569954,
0.611515462398529,
0.3041940927505493,
0.22479577362537384,
-0.6291390061378479,
-0.09891201555728912,
-0.37337183952331543,
-0.4894311726093292,
-0.5542574524879456,
-0.1336466372013092,
0.4266829788684845,
-0.10811564326286316,
-0.40940582752227783,
0.18489430844783783,
-0.9055542349815369,
0.17143186926841736,
0.5923136472702026,
-0.012001183815300465,
0.014391516335308552,
0.22898675501346588,
0.05619332566857338,
-0.31921589374542236,
-0.46578437089920044,
-0.6315938830375671,
0.6155357360839844,
0.303136944770813,
0.48419755697250366,
-0.010338901542127132,
1.0424429178237915,
0.5603945851325989,
0.13776440918445587,
-0.7540833353996277,
0.5310214757919312,
-0.02077694982290268,
-0.5370544791221619,
-0.4019896388053894,
-0.3496242165565491,
-0.9279115796089172,
-0.0033971737138926983,
-0.4296860694885254,
-0.8167956471443176,
-0.044939398765563965,
0.09947699308395386,
-0.3494585156440735,
0.15133006870746613,
-0.5561674237251282,
0.4951118230819702,
0.15036490559577942,
-0.28916579484939575,
-0.2182391881942749,
-0.7921470999717712,
0.11910107731819153,
-0.036768537014722824,
0.09877242147922516,
-0.2884642481803894,
0.37060439586639404,
0.38041892647743225,
-0.3216330111026764,
0.9738749265670776,
-0.15354348719120026,
-0.1300019770860672,
0.3465215563774109,
0.5630523562431335,
0.22113581001758575,
-0.10862478613853455,
-0.20259292423725128,
0.22460992634296417,
-0.35354238748550415,
-0.22746381163597107,
-0.4174628257751465,
0.6015974879264832,
-0.6127227544784546,
-0.5505552291870117,
-0.07992494106292725,
-0.5781766176223755,
-0.21032123267650604,
0.2891419529914856,
0.06633192300796509,
0.26002952456474304,
-0.7330552935600281,
-0.047723058611154556,
0.3293890357017517,
-0.5343488454818726,
0.6179041266441345,
0.6239232420921326,
-0.054106470197439194,
-0.7201749682426453,
1.0418922901153564,
-0.17029987275600433,
0.360289603471756,
0.2241820991039276,
0.04477875307202339,
-0.330922931432724,
-0.14325755834579468,
-0.8356999158859253,
0.05143775790929794,
-0.3490678369998932,
-0.08574000746011734,
-0.6995968222618103,
-0.09866378456354141,
-0.6766662001609802,
-0.48057955503463745,
-0.4176064729690552,
-0.4556784927845001,
-0.6768836379051208,
-0.15056616067886353,
0.1814684122800827,
0.8343022465705872,
-0.39831823110580444,
0.058262769132852554,
-0.9040824174880981,
0.47087860107421875,
0.48021259903907776,
0.13035345077514648,
-0.11894199997186661,
-0.5819540023803711,
0.22696100175380707,
0.47873198986053467,
-0.577918529510498,
-0.9275562167167664,
0.8186483383178711,
0.41059157252311707,
0.11005505919456482,
0.1825607419013977,
0.3887031376361847,
0.6848139762878418,
-0.7682930827140808,
0.8218751549720764,
0.5221607685089111,
-1.4518100023269653,
0.7532232403755188,
-0.3903341293334961,
0.21152833104133606,
0.32287511229515076,
-0.07419339567422867,
-0.8657079935073853,
-0.7388531565666199,
-0.6099994778633118,
-0.8330010771751404,
0.7459230422973633,
0.4225280284881592,
0.4166695177555084,
0.007078736089169979,
0.20284631848335266,
0.07043098658323288,
0.3441983759403229,
-0.31096717715263367,
-0.03362944349646568,
-0.49020621180534363,
-0.27119189500808716,
-0.08090226352214813,
-0.014337885193526745,
-0.24805417656898499,
-0.032780203968286514,
0.48699069023132324,
-0.06387932598590851,
0.32101038098335266,
0.39335426688194275,
0.18039068579673767,
-0.29950302839279175,
0.516329288482666,
0.9236182570457458,
0.06110270321369171,
-0.13051845133304596,
0.008388339541852474,
0.036643724888563156,
-0.07218299061059952,
0.3010483682155609,
-0.05745343118906021,
-0.1540379524230957,
0.21682290732860565,
-0.011346299201250076,
1.0324379205703735,
-0.1287292093038559,
-0.71636563539505,
0.3614572584629059,
-0.049494579434394836,
-0.3076949119567871,
-0.14182130992412567,
-0.014406821690499783,
0.2295641005039215,
0.35438108444213867,
0.20371080935001373,
0.17721553146839142,
0.4637066423892975,
-0.645635724067688,
0.39956969022750854,
0.18012520670890808,
-0.5705379247665405,
-0.5841522216796875,
0.8678101301193237,
0.5468859672546387,
-0.8603349328041077,
0.5548826456069946,
-0.1877834051847458,
-0.33298733830451965,
0.13605190813541412,
0.5018325448036194,
1.2082966566085815,
-0.37551620602607727,
0.6388540267944336,
0.10988087207078934,
0.07749525457620621,
0.3123761713504791,
0.2514648735523224,
-0.17388908565044403,
-0.5441602468490601,
-0.29216107726097107,
-0.7136502861976624,
-0.6237068176269531,
-0.02811521850526333,
-0.8205156326293945,
0.1294689029455185,
-0.5827417373657227,
-0.11765202134847641,
0.1474383920431137,
-0.5624640583992004,
-0.23870281875133514,
0.25372278690338135,
0.5789281129837036,
0.1895957589149475,
-0.9056833982467651,
0.5775285363197327,
0.429579496383667,
-0.4237348139286041,
-0.6287292242050171,
-0.13064785301685333,
0.038130950182676315,
-0.6610590219497681,
0.32380127906799316,
0.13768590986728668,
-0.36713671684265137,
0.17653168737888336,
-0.49691900610923767,
-0.06754529476165771,
0.8533782958984375,
0.877772867679596,
-0.6682352423667908,
0.2536471486091614,
0.5117312669754028,
0.9291459321975708,
-0.3885830044746399,
0.06936349719762802,
0.4201517701148987,
0.23367688059806824,
0.327589213848114,
-1.0958878993988037,
-0.00023170486383605748,
-0.2709253430366516,
0.06951791048049927,
-0.06188870221376419,
-0.4995407462120056,
0.7706290483474731,
-0.15605324506759644,
-0.5760913491249084,
-0.07056601345539093,
0.4180978238582611,
0.16423995792865753,
0.5890977382659912,
0.32332637906074524,
0.4755396842956543,
0.6477875113487244,
0.08767323940992355,
0.6874444484710693,
-0.30265432596206665,
0.0064161671325564384,
0.9884810447692871,
-0.6072649359703064,
0.9080808758735657,
0.5540016293525696,
0.0012135178549215198,
0.42934197187423706,
0.29504719376564026,
0.39913228154182434,
0.2755219638347626,
0.4547763466835022,
-0.6875107288360596,
-0.2780372202396393,
-0.608550488948822,
-0.3051789104938507,
0.7873133420944214,
0.12719129025936127,
-0.1725011020898819,
-0.056028153747320175,
0.17445436120033264,
0.0017953498754650354,
0.25581079721450806,
0.0831095427274704,
1.074284315109253,
-0.09004644304513931,
-0.31498879194259644,
0.8794763684272766,
-0.1302596479654312,
0.7208539247512817,
-0.3637385368347168,
-0.23775629699230194,
-0.3235202431678772,
-0.04036850854754448,
-0.16236378252506256,
-0.7336848378181458,
0.45017579197883606,
0.17827875912189484,
-0.17529438436031342,
-0.41632741689682007,
0.514727771282196,
-0.6246368885040283,
-0.27307841181755066,
0.08997596055269241,
0.3155701458454132,
0.34748780727386475,
-0.3111962676048279,
-0.7636939287185669,
0.4533250629901886,
0.32014065980911255,
-0.12391102313995361,
0.26180654764175415,
0.49242106080055237,
0.22314530611038208,
0.6128498315811157,
0.8772285580635071,
0.11886483430862427,
-0.15176348388195038,
0.14036855101585388,
0.9632735848426819,
-0.676150381565094,
-0.5296807289123535,
-0.9297693967819214,
0.7121090292930603,
0.04703136906027794,
-0.19038982689380646,
0.17503848671913147,
0.10610213875770569,
0.6066622734069824,
-0.1615343987941742,
1.1464942693710327,
-0.24181856215000153,
0.4748786389827728,
-0.012951645068824291,
1.0161418914794922,
-0.62264084815979,
-0.10975049436092377,
-0.7133116126060486,
-0.7294281125068665,
-0.44105997681617737,
0.7529135942459106,
0.3586672246456146,
-0.35971152782440186,
0.15418215095996857,
0.9559146761894226,
0.23789969086647034,
0.01192427147179842,
1.0012109279632568,
0.33197730779647827,
0.5579977631568909,
0.5837458968162537,
0.8832703828811646,
-0.3061297833919525,
0.6493037939071655,
-0.03267710655927658,
-0.32264259457588196,
-0.1935468316078186,
-0.9514033794403076,
-0.4530786871910095,
-0.6832408905029297,
-0.3204105794429779,
-0.2131229043006897,
0.11276887357234955,
0.9655880331993103,
0.6182506680488586,
-0.6340712308883667,
-0.18661873042583466,
-0.3192340135574341,
-0.20821569859981537,
0.15405552089214325,
-0.26378726959228516,
-0.28246238827705383,
-0.10316502302885056,
-1.0740447044372559,
0.6258009076118469,
0.8347205519676208,
0.31752753257751465,
-0.40618008375167847,
-0.21831142902374268,
0.2368415743112564,
0.3735550045967102,
0.678547739982605,
0.48359665274620056,
-0.7859735488891602,
-0.3062404990196228,
-0.03496099263429642,
-0.08337219804525375,
-0.000036890287447022274,
0.6002330183982849,
-0.7385008931159973,
0.765524685382843,
0.4459483027458191,
0.6339239478111267,
0.16656552255153656,
-0.1797787845134735,
0.7534773945808411,
-0.5532258749008179,
0.3754478693008423,
0.6455988883972168,
-0.09842076897621155,
0.47252434492111206,
-0.2801085412502289,
0.04745778068900108,
0.23766519129276276,
-0.530081570148468,
-1.1425410509109497,
0.5659459233283997,
-1.0938588380813599,
-0.08285870403051376,
0.8416142463684082,
-0.13565753400325775,
-0.13743513822555542,
0.09729830175638199,
-0.5895556807518005,
0.6391690373420715,
-0.7256962656974792,
1.0026235580444336,
0.3498530089855194,
-0.3798453211784363,
0.0682503804564476,
-0.09612393379211426,
0.34381091594696045,
0.4751910865306854,
-0.7108836770057678,
0.21778477728366852,
0.7521011829376221,
0.12089430540800095,
0.06331019103527069,
0.5327638983726501,
-0.13168933987617493,
0.09115195274353027,
0.24801857769489288,
0.5688311457633972,
-0.05691533908247948,
-0.11681662499904633,
-0.3119329810142517,
0.12243243306875229,
-0.1261318027973175,
-0.29646387696266174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00500v1
|
The Shape of Word Embeddings: Recognizing Language Phylogenies through Topological Data Analysis
| 2024-03-30T23:51:25 | 2024-03-30T23:51:25 |
Ondřej Draganov, Steven Skiena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, math.AT
|
Word embeddings represent language vocabularies as clouds of $d$-dimensional
points. We investigate how information is conveyed by the general shape of
these clouds, outside of representing the semantic meaning of each token.
Specifically, we use the notion of persistent homology from topological data
analysis (TDA) to measure the distances between language pairs from the shape
of their unlabeled embeddings. We use these distance matrices to construct
language phylogenetic trees over 81 Indo-European languages. Careful evaluation
shows that our reconstructed trees exhibit strong similarities to the reference
tree.
|
[
-0.18461889028549194,
-0.8908626437187195,
0.773410439491272,
-0.18191184103488922,
-0.6352823972702026,
0.339292049407959,
-0.0664997547864914,
-0.2749437391757965,
1.066702127456665,
0.08758597075939178,
-0.17775358259677887,
-0.40543466806411743,
-0.5964129567146301,
0.13843384385108948,
-0.5342437028884888,
0.25932466983795166,
-0.046123262494802475,
-0.21375954151153564,
-0.11973411589860916,
-0.28008562326431274,
-0.08445964008569717,
-0.6495699882507324,
-0.032919131219387054,
0.10612768679857254,
0.5392308831214905,
0.23041179776191711,
0.9380024075508118,
1.2535611391067505,
0.23229087889194489,
0.28706055879592896,
-0.27131175994873047,
-0.09444918483495712,
-0.38749268651008606,
0.3312033414840698,
0.046864259988069534,
-0.42967870831489563,
0.10668044537305832,
-0.2196471393108368,
1.1700057983398438,
1.1506249904632568,
-0.16970129311084747,
-0.0541970320045948,
0.008417343720793724,
0.6842136383056641,
-0.33207014203071594,
0.12426681816577911,
-0.8335491418838501,
0.13642631471157074,
-0.873681902885437,
-0.5189456939697266,
-0.1479056179523468,
-0.4469473659992218,
0.3003845512866974,
-0.5149944424629211,
-0.01676933653652668,
0.25061169266700745,
0.9503402709960938,
0.12614509463310242,
-0.16559351980686188,
-0.33053427934646606,
-0.8447354435920715,
0.46656733751296997,
-0.20271869003772736,
0.8313796520233154,
0.4443052113056183,
0.1455651819705963,
-0.47874966263771057,
-0.42358362674713135,
-0.48272278904914856,
0.15087200701236725,
-0.13112026453018188,
-0.15431377291679382,
-0.17384673655033112,
-0.05275397375226021,
-0.10211359709501266,
0.7026456594467163,
-0.6047866344451904,
0.010872550308704376,
-0.5368722677230835,
-0.05422627553343773,
0.5594510436058044,
-0.14179277420043945,
0.6387031078338623,
-0.11119113862514496,
-0.054726600646972656,
-0.1921171396970749,
-0.7772133946418762,
-0.14483383297920227,
0.3890291154384613,
0.44207391142845154,
0.05008118227124214,
0.7098665237426758,
0.38151395320892334,
0.6345001459121704,
-0.11880584061145782,
-0.27893152832984924,
0.2578894793987274,
0.018206346780061722,
-0.0613635778427124,
0.322826087474823,
0.3144332766532898,
-0.11348360776901245,
0.5100635290145874,
-0.6572909355163574,
0.25001809000968933,
-0.016658294945955276,
0.1265084147453308,
-0.24425901472568512,
-0.2736298739910126,
0.14640338718891144,
-0.4269677698612213,
-0.04422318562865257,
0.3354053497314453,
-0.707139253616333,
-0.28103500604629517,
-0.26881399750709534,
0.1704757809638977,
-0.6119720935821533,
-0.5042417049407959,
0.11590824276208878,
-0.3835907280445099,
0.3543800115585327,
0.033640407025814056,
-0.9212958216667175,
0.5766549110412598,
0.8027704954147339,
1.0751545429229736,
-0.13108696043491364,
-0.2798066735267639,
-0.029236599802970886,
0.5917314887046814,
-0.34232836961746216,
0.7702190279960632,
-1.0391762256622314,
-0.7180886268615723,
0.15466226637363434,
0.12952451407909393,
-0.049187324941158295,
-0.3491615056991577,
0.17850303649902344,
-0.22195930778980255,
0.24440015852451324,
-0.29126471281051636,
-0.8739290237426758,
-0.6182702779769897,
0.20603401958942413,
-0.42617112398147583,
0.9084861278533936,
0.22359928488731384,
-0.9298376441001892,
0.4247370660305023,
-0.0002586012415122241,
-0.09480000287294388,
0.4682025611400604,
-0.5339758992195129,
-0.1246807798743248,
0.3176177740097046,
-0.1701214760541916,
0.4298415780067444,
-0.025891099125146866,
-0.1149890199303627,
-0.5989586114883423,
-0.19079656898975372,
-0.332017183303833,
0.28483065962791443,
0.6573650240898132,
-0.025380562990903854,
-0.2222767025232315,
-0.10029300302267075,
-0.5448719263076782,
0.05847391113638878,
0.27742794156074524,
-0.2331654131412506,
-1.0848705768585205,
0.3034641444683075,
-0.0894676223397255,
-0.07791787385940552,
-0.14200492203235626,
-0.7552591562271118,
0.6914412379264832,
-0.4297814667224884,
0.44804680347442627,
0.5742490291595459,
-0.009015094488859177,
0.15538282692432404,
-0.13418059051036835,
0.39785632491111755,
0.05148077383637428,
-0.2106257528066635,
0.4000050127506256,
-0.7357875108718872,
-0.49790579080581665,
-0.24151860177516937,
0.11877814680337906,
0.3209378719329834,
-0.5021576881408691,
0.4414551258087158,
-0.6629580855369568,
-0.6685712337493896,
-0.33525899052619934,
-0.06485972553491592,
-0.039400599896907806,
-0.12366217374801636,
0.018666379153728485,
-0.5927815437316895,
-0.40252864360809326,
-0.7835285067558289,
0.007804081775248051,
-0.529587984085083,
0.09326259791851044,
0.23036710917949677,
0.5351424813270569,
-0.3719048798084259,
0.9800081253051758,
-0.41831979155540466,
-0.006776251830160618,
0.21384555101394653,
-0.3256562054157257,
-0.12008333951234818,
0.2214651256799698,
0.8132664561271667,
-0.534662127494812,
-0.3682324290275574,
0.15061324834823608,
-0.4174797534942627,
0.18106397986412048,
0.17509432137012482,
-0.12502728402614594,
0.0030361241661012173,
0.5027955770492554,
-0.40108582377433777,
0.3965066075325012,
0.6084157824516296,
-0.7208153605461121,
0.2935129404067993,
-0.06432986259460449,
-0.11393902450799942,
-1.159477949142456,
0.14687828719615936,
-0.47014668583869934,
-0.17288346588611603,
-0.519356906414032,
-0.34691372513771057,
-0.3373704254627228,
-0.02682356722652912,
-0.031183145940303802,
0.6748197674751282,
-0.4806756377220154,
-0.5139973759651184,
0.10783494263887405,
0.37643224000930786,
-0.2637164294719696,
0.3487726151943207,
0.16947831213474274,
0.3010129928588867,
0.5374522805213928,
-0.5159212350845337,
0.34827175736427307,
0.2250058352947235,
-0.1569986194372177,
0.5495685338973999,
-0.46958813071250916,
0.17317765951156616,
-0.13524825870990753,
0.10886319726705551,
-0.8721662163734436,
0.01760045252740383,
0.15715251863002777,
-0.33910155296325684,
0.3055020570755005,
-0.08662410080432892,
-0.23374512791633606,
-0.2796661853790283,
-0.4702606797218323,
0.7383244037628174,
0.3912968337535858,
-0.5548032522201538,
0.21514680981636047,
0.9644331932067871,
-0.20106646418571472,
-0.030524123460054398,
-0.4651849865913391,
-0.023765286430716515,
-0.5733213424682617,
-0.45207691192626953,
0.43017739057540894,
0.19101008772850037,
-0.6018913388252258,
0.25151872634887695,
0.1446601003408432,
-0.26688045263290405,
0.025592584162950516,
0.5432061553001404,
-0.28997746109962463,
-0.1298711597919464,
0.4612618684768677,
-0.3110615611076355,
0.2636408805847168,
-0.020408784970641136,
-0.6821461319923401,
0.6524513363838196,
-0.08026162534952164,
-0.3178577423095703,
-0.2417476773262024,
0.3114418387413025,
0.6847879886627197,
0.04035980626940727,
0.59827721118927,
0.11926678568124771,
-0.7742725014686584,
-0.2666572332382202,
-0.17325541377067566,
-0.09938207268714905,
-0.3702297806739807,
-0.019503196701407433,
-0.5017669200897217,
-0.8647790551185608,
0.4161798357963562,
-0.0036132321693003178,
-0.10695604979991913,
0.5131900906562805,
0.4817255437374115,
0.0889986976981163,
0.44069722294807434,
0.7595412731170654,
-0.28735414147377014,
0.34929439425468445,
-0.07778811454772949,
0.14066264033317566,
-0.5270557403564453,
-0.4128384590148926,
-0.8183402419090271,
-0.2476656287908554,
-0.8536005616188049,
-0.349894255399704,
0.10930182784795761,
0.16343910992145538,
-0.06931480020284653,
0.32068684697151184,
-0.49287137389183044,
0.24000723659992218,
0.4846949279308319,
-0.3423782289028168,
-0.028300443664193153,
0.3404523730278015,
-0.4115522801876068,
-0.07018198072910309,
-0.679549515247345,
-0.5361429452896118,
0.5782384872436523,
0.5911834239959717,
0.3095479905605316,
0.12456164509057999,
0.772269070148468,
0.06663741171360016,
-0.34926721453666687,
-0.9751828908920288,
0.14601030945777893,
-0.11536967009305954,
-0.17567747831344604,
-0.40825599431991577,
-0.21305294334888458,
-1.3019102811813354,
0.09088966995477676,
-0.033236097544431686,
-1.1626830101013184,
0.5736470818519592,
-0.14829644560813904,
0.0459599606692791,
0.7542970180511475,
-0.14702101051807404,
0.39156901836395264,
-0.07688391208648682,
0.2349700629711151,
-0.18952567875385284,
-0.26428303122520447,
0.2200779765844345,
-0.018134957179427147,
0.2272283285856247,
0.0012242452939972281,
0.02255655825138092,
1.0350321531295776,
-0.6007302403450012,
0.44887834787368774,
-0.023320719599723816,
-0.1827363818883896,
0.37760382890701294,
0.6382657289505005,
0.1477786749601364,
-0.16706430912017822,
0.1313706934452057,
0.31207963824272156,
0.6344560980796814,
-0.5093718767166138,
-0.3252986967563629,
0.6459749937057495,
-0.5562393665313721,
-0.37964144349098206,
-0.5944163799285889,
-0.4015902876853943,
-0.31920215487480164,
0.11791594326496124,
-0.06373368203639984,
0.5908529162406921,
-0.2740921080112457,
0.5946022272109985,
0.0739888995885849,
-0.3201630711555481,
0.2558515965938568,
0.06208566203713417,
-0.4133380949497223,
-0.15551719069480896,
0.8708900213241577,
0.30942264199256897,
-0.03429233655333519,
0.4219587445259094,
0.34680113196372986,
-0.33903688192367554,
-0.5449683666229248,
-0.21999569237232208,
0.3917570114135742,
-0.35026028752326965,
0.16339905560016632,
-0.3406625986099243,
-0.1259525567293167,
-0.18517446517944336,
-0.2473895251750946,
-0.237627774477005,
-0.6755779981613159,
0.23861807584762573,
-0.21446196734905243,
0.7549670934677124,
1.4625961780548096,
-0.10612434893846512,
0.24015749990940094,
-0.7789889574050903,
-0.0759836807847023,
0.29176732897758484,
0.5344365835189819,
-0.040844742208719254,
-0.15020804107189178,
0.0015334944473579526,
0.03531225025653839,
0.09532465785741806,
-1.0627914667129517,
0.47568970918655396,
0.6070139408111572,
0.4147450029850006,
0.5817108750343323,
-0.44320783019065857,
0.6697188019752502,
-0.6215176582336426,
0.8705804347991943,
-0.21600568294525146,
-0.7989378571510315,
0.315618634223938,
-0.46415096521377563,
0.2666569650173187,
0.2539721727371216,
0.6575577855110168,
-0.9635811448097229,
-0.4036020040512085,
-0.7805230021476746,
-0.5809985995292664,
0.29796072840690613,
0.32760563492774963,
-0.13377903401851654,
-0.21784371137619019,
0.5758663415908813,
0.06622274219989777,
-0.08348878473043442,
-0.17891435325145721,
-0.2816665768623352,
-0.11010794341564178,
-0.23924772441387177,
-0.1242712140083313,
-0.3646528124809265,
0.05973541736602783,
-0.34144461154937744,
0.2330550253391266,
0.1454431563615799,
0.33132269978523254,
0.18719567358493805,
-0.06426925212144852,
-0.07345009595155716,
0.00712652038782835,
0.39209508895874023,
0.6095267534255981,
-0.22940891981124878,
0.6494681239128113,
0.02407650649547577,
-0.9295384287834167,
0.044682472944259644,
-0.2593299448490143,
0.20138019323349,
0.3572114109992981,
0.618040144443512,
0.4174695909023285,
0.04534188285470009,
-0.262104332447052,
0.16770988702774048,
0.019078722223639488,
0.14292530715465546,
-0.24096812307834625,
-0.4094003140926361,
0.170238196849823,
-0.1444927304983139,
0.1276625692844391,
-0.7126544117927551,
0.06687279045581818,
-0.9036111831665039,
0.47741732001304626,
0.42043668031692505,
-0.6556210517883301,
-0.7227675318717957,
-0.014012760482728481,
0.04285743087530136,
-0.24312478303909302,
0.8065280914306641,
0.09252949804067612,
-0.8644378185272217,
0.45312556624412537,
0.4449770152568817,
0.8526247143745422,
-0.4175776541233063,
0.19878734648227692,
0.4463632106781006,
0.20845746994018555,
0.3652161657810211,
0.47772741317749023,
0.013972055166959763,
-0.5137771964073181,
0.2647894024848938,
-0.9791682958602905,
-0.15776869654655457,
-0.16364820301532745,
-0.3681311309337616,
0.09600987285375595,
-0.5998340249061584,
0.3448289930820465,
0.16129638254642487,
-0.09801317751407623,
-0.5588944554328918,
0.12784895300865173,
0.2630637586116791,
0.7038400173187256,
-0.7877147793769836,
1.0163778066635132,
0.5299556851387024,
-0.02516995556652546,
-0.9007632732391357,
-0.11330156773328781,
0.38142579793930054,
-0.9152169823646545,
0.6590173244476318,
0.12079799920320511,
-0.26616939902305603,
-0.04972311481833458,
-0.0829983726143837,
-1.175597906112671,
1.0192424058914185,
0.16031904518604279,
-0.5733515024185181,
0.09966285526752472,
0.572610080242157,
0.5619844794273376,
-0.39187362790107727,
0.06856420636177063,
0.6523720622062683,
0.44659677147865295,
-0.14198079705238342,
-0.8188053965568542,
0.03887401521205902,
-0.2640235126018524,
0.12464296817779541,
0.6079964637756348,
-0.09571012854576111,
0.7791985869407654,
0.2515043318271637,
-0.9543724656105042,
-0.1772949993610382,
0.2972765266895294,
0.0897965207695961,
-0.3965971767902374,
0.6127567887306213,
0.6635386943817139,
0.8911643028259277,
-0.3186323940753937,
1.2025165557861328,
-0.4360201358795166,
0.3496151566505432,
0.5862421989440918,
0.16011159121990204,
0.9162629842758179,
0.7178623080253601,
-0.3273758292198181,
0.6804882287979126,
0.895695686340332,
-0.010037209838628769,
0.26842182874679565,
0.5621342658996582,
0.14197395741939545,
0.06054157391190529,
-0.5404582023620605,
-0.6144024133682251,
0.523788332939148,
0.7215982675552368,
-0.15009358525276184,
-0.1262727975845337,
-0.4101853370666504,
-0.011765094473958015,
0.002878461265936494,
-0.11794745177030563,
0.6830804944038391,
0.3177381455898285,
-0.13102537393569946,
0.7050824761390686,
-0.4289255440235138,
0.3788937032222748,
-0.5176213979721069,
-0.09576158225536346,
-0.15779489278793335,
-0.060588497668504715,
-0.26658448576927185,
-0.9749701619148254,
0.6313422918319702,
-0.43882450461387634,
0.07229690998792648,
-0.01959402859210968,
0.28089815378189087,
-0.5943074226379395,
-0.2733864486217499,
0.5531647205352783,
0.5263590216636658,
0.5836294889450073,
0.21157380938529968,
-0.37940195202827454,
0.13291890919208527,
-0.3319843113422394,
-0.13721786439418793,
-0.23617048561573029,
0.6337496638298035,
-0.24082471430301666,
0.49941352009773254,
0.24627785384655,
0.3366019129753113,
0.16776436567306519,
-0.07516809552907944,
0.4201726019382477,
-0.7830001711845398,
-0.42232146859169006,
-0.8885125517845154,
0.07474952191114426,
0.19003920257091522,
-0.3806708753108978,
0.8411977887153625,
0.4442916512489319,
0.9129918217658997,
-0.0013430049875751138,
0.3314021825790405,
-0.20639656484127045,
0.3815324306488037,
-0.43411964178085327,
0.5606358051300049,
-0.707221269607544,
-0.17790500819683075,
-0.3816601037979126,
-1.2957041263580322,
-0.45979204773902893,
0.4138116240501404,
-0.2964245676994324,
-0.268973708152771,
0.7740907669067383,
0.5206960439682007,
-0.22730357944965363,
-0.24193815886974335,
0.28055867552757263,
0.23715096712112427,
0.2990131378173828,
0.37384721636772156,
0.6765286922454834,
-0.020043231546878815,
0.053870026022195816,
-0.2936972379684448,
-0.017750808969140053,
-0.003920949064195156,
-0.4985499083995819,
-0.7041782140731812,
-1.3414130210876465,
-0.07825075089931488,
-0.2076222002506256,
-0.023074796423316002,
0.7529647350311279,
0.6057071089744568,
-0.8913907408714294,
-0.35290318727493286,
-0.08852200210094452,
0.11238589137792587,
0.07586977630853653,
-0.19784866273403168,
0.9005151987075806,
-0.02809266932308674,
-0.5840896964073181,
0.3595779240131378,
0.5282490849494934,
0.36409616470336914,
-0.4206937551498413,
-0.07067809998989105,
-0.5229524374008179,
0.02844899892807007,
0.466438353061676,
0.4853448271751404,
-0.8875257968902588,
-0.8730239868164062,
-0.285366028547287,
-0.04723721742630005,
0.06353768706321716,
0.7981159090995789,
-0.6149064302444458,
0.6150609254837036,
0.8287294507026672,
0.5916691422462463,
0.06673747301101685,
-0.07252529263496399,
0.9167947173118591,
-0.7200729250907898,
0.4815135896205902,
0.11490350216627121,
0.6514157056808472,
0.44822263717651367,
-0.17590028047561646,
0.5558672547340393,
0.3590562641620636,
-0.21963436901569366,
-0.8298858404159546,
0.30345043540000916,
-0.949081540107727,
-0.36794281005859375,
1.1831847429275513,
-0.0978710725903511,
-0.5091708898544312,
-0.29108673334121704,
-0.21666985750198364,
0.12033086270093918,
0.1574779748916626,
0.8685773015022278,
0.7819217443466187,
0.1975882649421692,
0.00771415326744318,
-0.020650705322623253,
1.0347411632537842,
0.09792745858430862,
-0.8341699242591858,
-0.10087324678897858,
0.3749992847442627,
0.17836306989192963,
0.6227111220359802,
0.22230836749076843,
-0.33143195509910583,
-0.18034504354000092,
0.08171761780977249,
-0.23888090252876282,
0.27146977186203003,
-0.5424278974533081,
-0.3849559724330902,
0.03968201205134392,
0.19593025743961334,
-0.1652715504169464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00495v1
|
Configurable Safety Tuning of Language Models with Synthetic Preference Data
| 2024-03-30T23:28:05 | 2024-03-30T23:28:05 |
Victor Gallego
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
State-of-the-art language model fine-tuning techniques, such as Direct
Preference Optimization (DPO), restrict user control by hard-coding predefined
behaviors into the model. To address this, we propose a novel method,
Configurable Safety Tuning (CST), that augments DPO using synthetic preference
data to facilitate flexible safety configuration of LLMs at inference time. CST
overcomes the constraints of vanilla DPO by introducing a system prompt
specifying safety configurations, enabling LLM deployers to disable/enable
safety preferences based on their need, just changing the system prompt. Our
experimental evaluations indicate that CST successfully manages different
safety configurations and retains the original functionality of LLMs, showing
it is a robust method for configurable deployment. Data and models available at
https://github.com/vicgalle/configurable-safety-tuning
|
[
-0.315104603767395,
-0.6244534850120544,
0.5975210070610046,
0.2551734149456024,
-0.32060515880584717,
0.3521007001399994,
-0.3723229169845581,
-0.37056398391723633,
-0.13428157567977905,
0.5218712091445923,
-0.7226703763008118,
-0.4643833637237549,
-0.2888948917388916,
0.08881247788667679,
0.05566355958580971,
0.9357942342758179,
-0.034135397523641586,
-0.2825164198875427,
-0.010863837786018848,
0.16933421790599823,
-0.4619610011577606,
-0.6922359466552734,
-0.7364594340324402,
-0.28609713912010193,
0.4041663110256195,
0.5231778621673584,
1.0493866205215454,
0.8870691657066345,
0.35572901368141174,
0.2711436152458191,
-0.3351697623729706,
0.4113783836364746,
-0.3083273470401764,
0.14677226543426514,
-0.3875199854373932,
-0.19472062587738037,
-0.7427216172218323,
-0.0692528635263443,
0.571652352809906,
0.5246058702468872,
-0.26204901933670044,
-0.21284066140651703,
0.30731648206710815,
0.6557917594909668,
-0.7378366589546204,
-0.08421707898378372,
-0.8834590315818787,
0.08305968344211578,
0.08712870627641678,
-0.5677317976951599,
-0.5124928951263428,
-0.6121463775634766,
0.1116233542561531,
-0.628607451915741,
0.20314261317253113,
0.2111903429031372,
0.4785586893558502,
0.4412226974964142,
-0.6370798349380493,
0.0735999271273613,
-0.7700558304786682,
0.853041410446167,
-0.40392178297042847,
0.257185161113739,
0.37357378005981445,
0.2572145462036133,
-0.5630059242248535,
-0.45211413502693176,
-0.5151477456092834,
-0.40583279728889465,
-0.1878584325313568,
-0.17558173835277557,
-0.018805470317602158,
0.44286274909973145,
0.1354050636291504,
0.18382805585861206,
-0.6354546546936035,
0.3962014615535736,
0.11190275102853775,
-0.419565349817276,
0.5460916757583618,
0.2110704630613327,
0.1837928295135498,
0.08575975149869919,
-0.47025397419929504,
0.03447140008211136,
-0.8910042643547058,
-0.007864001207053661,
0.4324251115322113,
0.49105358123779297,
-0.20550726354122162,
0.26489630341529846,
-0.6480849981307983,
0.619466245174408,
0.25013190507888794,
0.000700168136972934,
0.15059998631477356,
-0.03174006566405296,
-0.33213010430336,
0.12482161819934845,
0.6157578229904175,
0.5415030121803284,
0.29989686608314514,
-0.00854475237429142,
-0.24053695797920227,
0.19580785930156708,
0.21913881599903107,
-0.613049328327179,
-0.08117581903934479,
0.1455262452363968,
-0.21208462119102478,
-0.7370182871818542,
-0.334322065114975,
-0.49467039108276367,
-0.50706946849823,
-0.4738733768463135,
0.04909082129597664,
-0.3354794383049011,
-0.4001534879207611,
0.4928901493549347,
0.14896172285079956,
-0.08917900919914246,
0.06614630669355392,
-1.2383209466934204,
0.2659244239330292,
0.7164346575737,
0.71101975440979,
-0.4383161962032318,
-0.06466403603553772,
-0.40868958830833435,
0.36134326457977295,
-0.15432989597320557,
0.5842474699020386,
-0.5832809805870056,
-0.586119532585144,
0.15463095903396606,
0.23197507858276367,
-0.05762811377644539,
-0.35398417711257935,
0.6978658437728882,
-0.5970780253410339,
-0.2564699649810791,
-0.10635080933570862,
-0.3544444143772125,
0.10165513306856155,
0.3767426609992981,
-0.3600713908672333,
0.7479608058929443,
-0.15822120010852814,
-0.5779309868812561,
0.3507700562477112,
-0.4528012275695801,
-0.5342755913734436,
-0.11474814265966415,
-0.05586937814950943,
-0.42456358671188354,
-0.08855455368757248,
0.007507708389312029,
0.385135680437088,
0.033098254352808,
0.3192768692970276,
-0.595227837562561,
-0.2847025990486145,
0.23501048982143402,
-0.4073784053325653,
0.6251987218856812,
0.41272738575935364,
0.029022978618741035,
0.23157945275306702,
-0.8852985501289368,
0.05488879606127739,
0.041874419897794724,
-0.5555333495140076,
-0.3196801245212555,
0.30360814929008484,
0.016418209299445152,
-0.004608665592968464,
0.6797178387641907,
-0.5026994943618774,
0.34826794266700745,
-0.42026278376579285,
0.38857489824295044,
0.9461455941200256,
0.02495560795068741,
0.5306708216667175,
-0.3052619695663452,
0.5748201608657837,
-0.15361005067825317,
0.5358067750930786,
0.40864792466163635,
0.04539408162236214,
-0.7611867189407349,
-0.24236465990543365,
-0.06662699580192566,
0.6913319826126099,
-0.48033103346824646,
0.5226113200187683,
0.17543333768844604,
-0.3598608672618866,
-0.0025047939270734787,
-0.028886253014206886,
0.49186596274375916,
0.6418757438659668,
0.2224545031785965,
0.26900672912597656,
-0.6745280027389526,
-1.142503261566162,
-0.1692146509885788,
-0.10040359944105148,
0.08669787645339966,
0.08901039510965347,
0.08569606393575668,
-0.22107215225696564,
0.9044519662857056,
-0.7273917198181152,
0.39902204275131226,
-0.24326615035533905,
-0.3065835237503052,
0.03619416803121567,
0.7436301112174988,
0.6047369241714478,
-0.7089680433273315,
-0.4597742557525635,
-0.005296583753079176,
-0.2731218636035919,
-0.21342772245407104,
0.05628513917326927,
-0.32635200023651123,
0.28775352239608765,
0.5978140234947205,
-0.2998500466346741,
0.1739647090435028,
0.6661612391471863,
-0.3439759612083435,
0.7154046297073364,
-0.5056243538856506,
0.08023484796285629,
-1.066838264465332,
-0.12540294229984283,
-0.1762409508228302,
-0.3201962411403656,
-0.6309784650802612,
-0.08090159296989441,
0.40407121181488037,
-0.03460894897580147,
-0.6981382369995117,
0.32994765043258667,
-0.1677473783493042,
0.40103018283843994,
-0.3835313618183136,
-0.20448081195354462,
-0.03236167132854462,
0.2459576576948166,
0.2836928069591522,
0.6801644563674927,
0.5998765826225281,
-0.9577642679214478,
0.04765506461262703,
0.19932110607624054,
-0.02499237470328808,
0.4548450708389282,
-0.7087841033935547,
0.3190794587135315,
0.08658949285745621,
0.2716197371482849,
-0.7448846697807312,
-0.24788717925548553,
0.22005562484264374,
0.19031710922718048,
0.2538042664527893,
-0.4734354615211487,
-0.36637723445892334,
0.1579383760690689,
-0.26215696334838867,
0.3279319703578949,
0.46817702054977417,
-0.43918368220329285,
0.11361121386289597,
0.3212984502315521,
-0.1806023269891739,
-0.4997895061969757,
-0.42571571469306946,
-0.10852151364088058,
-0.41942137479782104,
-0.4218912720680237,
0.5975624322891235,
-0.4262315630912781,
-0.18302883207798004,
-0.5672906041145325,
-0.1986982375383377,
-0.003918545786291361,
0.3825658857822418,
0.22687797248363495,
0.40873101353645325,
0.07082385569810867,
0.14490987360477448,
0.6755707263946533,
-0.4859705865383148,
-0.20337316393852234,
0.037091657519340515,
0.43708643317222595,
-0.02303360402584076,
-0.2499852478504181,
-0.2419532835483551,
0.3519703447818756,
0.41875919699668884,
-0.14666032791137695,
0.5911040902137756,
0.12020139396190643,
-0.10441221296787262,
-0.47289159893989563,
-0.22496166825294495,
-0.2771874666213989,
-0.675086259841919,
0.13316547870635986,
-0.3427868187427521,
-1.064280390739441,
0.24783667922019958,
-0.3609015643596649,
0.14027535915374756,
0.016021914780139923,
0.41424113512039185,
-0.0891072154045105,
1.176243543624878,
0.7848328948020935,
0.08081334829330444,
0.836787760257721,
0.23074179887771606,
-0.027256544679403305,
-0.4666063189506531,
0.026644662022590637,
-0.6180980801582336,
-0.17038202285766602,
-1.098192572593689,
0.1330639272928238,
0.5893383026123047,
-0.0466826856136322,
-0.4770129323005676,
0.20619353652000427,
-0.7013903260231018,
0.7017913460731506,
0.35018086433410645,
0.3787250220775604,
0.5189754962921143,
-0.2499190866947174,
-0.1970023214817047,
0.14222371578216553,
-0.45664462447166443,
-0.6658045649528503,
0.6704557538032532,
0.1518470197916031,
0.7285343408584595,
0.13998562097549438,
0.5405386090278625,
0.11948701739311218,
-0.12784206867218018,
-0.48417019844055176,
0.7376707196235657,
-0.2756063938140869,
-0.6891979575157166,
-0.15499810874462128,
-0.1402062624692917,
-0.7226675152778625,
-0.06427650153636932,
-0.22634637355804443,
-0.6965246796607971,
0.26722049713134766,
0.6800419688224792,
-0.5909140706062317,
-0.007190369535237551,
-0.7741900086402893,
0.5788865685462952,
-0.2859128415584564,
-0.25396108627319336,
-0.46283990144729614,
-0.5724860429763794,
0.2240695357322693,
-0.0410442017018795,
-0.09133423119783401,
-0.5009185671806335,
-0.2919147312641144,
0.17361955344676971,
-0.3536110818386078,
1.0832977294921875,
-0.11676231026649475,
-0.0956132560968399,
-0.22924651205539703,
0.41772815585136414,
0.8032416105270386,
0.38065195083618164,
-0.5232095718383789,
-0.014622082002460957,
0.24625639617443085,
-0.2527311444282532,
-0.4979099929332733,
0.9998000860214233,
-0.5883199572563171,
-0.6846016049385071,
-0.5335488319396973,
-0.6437447667121887,
-0.5049791932106018,
0.2613529860973358,
0.1590098887681961,
0.10052620619535446,
-0.39575397968292236,
0.11307456344366074,
0.6930996775627136,
-0.5175888538360596,
0.6530900597572327,
0.8653619289398193,
-0.02610878460109234,
-0.16897189617156982,
0.5821507573127747,
-0.06015631929039955,
0.6746336817741394,
0.46647098660469055,
0.34162068367004395,
-0.3973616361618042,
-0.8311654925346375,
-0.25426551699638367,
-0.23213766515254974,
-0.44299694895744324,
-0.03941471502184868,
-0.24188600480556488,
-0.23380593955516815,
-0.08868465572595596,
-0.5481798052787781,
-0.45533913373947144,
-0.5907564759254456,
-0.33507364988327026,
-0.39617857336997986,
0.7488501071929932,
0.34419795870780945,
-0.031398724764585495,
0.49324479699134827,
-0.3724580705165863,
0.15456770360469818,
0.14449235796928406,
0.8941149711608887,
-0.6187504529953003,
-0.30394265055656433,
-0.21062137186527252,
0.15924978256225586,
-0.4395621418952942,
-0.3477645218372345,
0.13687998056411743,
0.08472435176372528,
0.42677751183509827,
0.19840173423290253,
0.565610408782959,
0.28710517287254333,
-0.49973064661026,
0.4648362100124359,
-0.12196188420057297,
-0.6568903923034668,
0.7812678217887878,
-0.8689841032028198,
0.2379743456840515,
0.7345569133758545,
0.2059297114610672,
-0.23532940447330475,
-0.10040135681629181,
-0.150070458650589,
-0.660610556602478,
0.508985161781311,
0.04312007874250412,
0.30206844210624695,
-0.08191659301519394,
0.44064635038375854,
0.3389211595058441,
0.04415379464626312,
-0.4072244465351105,
-0.2550280690193176,
-0.05188479274511337,
-0.006994506809860468,
-0.18921545147895813,
-0.4856559932231903,
-0.196798637509346,
-0.26269781589508057,
0.5568324327468872,
-0.21619215607643127,
-0.11555410176515579,
-0.22336159646511078,
0.05642716959118843,
-0.05461358651518822,
0.5460767149925232,
0.6844117045402527,
0.4951738119125366,
-0.4675505757331848,
0.195560023188591,
0.4272255301475525,
-0.392383337020874,
0.399279922246933,
0.06065673008561134,
-0.5012402534484863,
-0.4218219220638275,
-0.2770770192146301,
0.8295579552650452,
0.27873098850250244,
-0.4260590672492981,
-0.14043226838111877,
-0.16532331705093384,
-0.14244921505451202,
-0.19926951825618744,
0.7181171178817749,
-0.02542118914425373,
0.061221979558467865,
-0.11333692818880081,
0.10489678382873535,
-0.010250262916088104,
-0.24157248437404633,
0.0873914435505867,
0.49502867460250854,
-0.2545824646949768,
-0.24046781659126282,
0.5578143000602722,
0.40013039112091064,
-0.3593624234199524,
0.09096843004226685,
0.08447365462779999,
0.01506095938384533,
0.4866577386856079,
0.6373403072357178,
1.0179051160812378,
-0.3145313560962677,
0.20817099511623383,
0.11976584047079086,
0.3994421660900116,
-0.11205314099788666,
0.5273248553276062,
0.16304169595241547,
-0.9115685820579529,
-0.14728716015815735,
-0.6464736461639404,
-0.7136086821556091,
0.28137922286987305,
-0.33085447549819946,
0.5171406865119934,
-0.9139000177383423,
-0.04778998717665672,
-0.07947922497987747,
-0.19334770739078522,
-0.44547075033187866,
0.19829364120960236,
-0.02070746384561062,
0.9157237410545349,
-0.614596426486969,
1.086591124534607,
0.5999665856361389,
-0.01638847589492798,
-0.5570029020309448,
0.13079723715782166,
0.08731824904680252,
-0.5308631658554077,
-0.11417799443006516,
-0.23203253746032715,
-0.40389880537986755,
0.12357009947299957,
-0.40349510312080383,
-0.7550312876701355,
0.9630041718482971,
0.9615968465805054,
-0.9764707684516907,
0.27391594648361206,
0.4280438721179962,
0.5123393535614014,
-0.1729796826839447,
-0.08547629415988922,
0.814550518989563,
0.5125579237937927,
-0.22599461674690247,
-1.0360578298568726,
0.32540592551231384,
-0.006681610830128193,
0.055448997765779495,
0.028207268565893173,
-0.927886426448822,
0.25880908966064453,
-0.0006165755330584943,
-0.11484289914369583,
-0.030236944556236267,
0.08931505680084229,
0.5031181573867798,
0.10650642961263657,
0.8824918270111084,
0.005934674292802811,
0.7404482960700989,
0.06682855635881424,
1.001312255859375,
-0.554651141166687,
0.13204286992549896,
1.1015868186950684,
-0.2516843378543854,
0.5961113572120667,
0.6121731996536255,
0.0342247411608696,
0.29501354694366455,
0.7899327278137207,
0.5235996246337891,
0.6903194189071655,
0.005174978636205196,
-0.598042905330658,
-0.5874152183532715,
-0.2782755196094513,
-0.405929297208786,
0.35882890224456787,
0.21499377489089966,
-0.3406215012073517,
0.03822258859872818,
-0.18808144330978394,
0.14056609570980072,
0.044278617948293686,
-0.05885043740272522,
0.7554725408554077,
0.08898685872554779,
-0.6929453611373901,
0.8537320494651794,
-0.09141403436660767,
0.6224786043167114,
-0.6998825669288635,
0.1448848843574524,
-0.21083030104637146,
0.3652907609939575,
-0.26747816801071167,
-0.716467559337616,
0.49240055680274963,
-0.013053154572844505,
-0.39671197533607483,
-0.5667105913162231,
0.7374258041381836,
-0.2943263053894043,
-0.3418658375740051,
0.13357236981391907,
0.04987163096666336,
-0.4065436124801636,
0.06515210121870041,
-0.4647260904312134,
0.06469709426164627,
-0.04734467342495918,
-0.44211459159851074,
0.630523145198822,
0.3120979070663452,
-0.2944866120815277,
0.848850429058075,
0.7907455563545227,
-0.026980509981513023,
-0.22531291842460632,
-0.0004992391332052648,
0.9577950835227966,
-0.5724254846572876,
-0.7787613868713379,
-1.015080213546753,
0.6304808259010315,
0.14325298368930817,
-0.30597180128097534,
0.48228466510772705,
0.42360401153564453,
0.5905392169952393,
-0.23278962075710297,
1.0607222318649292,
-0.016850685700774193,
0.5255563855171204,
-0.6170118451118469,
0.9560825228691101,
-0.2875552177429199,
0.43219640851020813,
-0.3189218044281006,
-0.5316526889801025,
-0.3110342025756836,
0.26469722390174866,
-0.32368314266204834,
-0.2445918619632721,
0.4951678216457367,
1.3085047006607056,
-0.3784658908843994,
-0.1266002506017685,
0.2600570023059845,
-0.03110036626458168,
0.4150116741657257,
0.3621140420436859,
0.8027476072311401,
0.28879621624946594,
0.4827510714530945,
-0.42170199751853943,
-0.2965610921382904,
-0.3564005196094513,
-1.494741678237915,
-0.7521646618843079,
-0.39061516523361206,
-0.27730074524879456,
-0.13420017063617706,
0.25848451256752014,
1.192305564880371,
0.8329249024391174,
-0.8702716827392578,
0.04822349548339844,
-0.34016913175582886,
0.2516127824783325,
-0.1573319435119629,
-0.1319076418876648,
0.10003934800624847,
-0.14399176836013794,
-0.6449761390686035,
0.8754940629005432,
0.2057788074016571,
0.27041903138160706,
-0.05462555214762688,
-0.33734458684921265,
0.11250996589660645,
0.20319992303848267,
0.4636833369731903,
0.2902098596096039,
-0.4432305097579956,
-0.7437965869903564,
-0.06119677424430847,
-0.03183498606085777,
-0.13942763209342957,
0.7993988394737244,
-0.40598639845848083,
0.471653014421463,
0.6090729236602783,
0.25534695386886597,
0.20790940523147583,
-0.22789081931114197,
0.9987766146659851,
-1.0117473602294922,
0.5541796088218689,
0.06683100014925003,
0.382081538438797,
0.08159656077623367,
-0.6758490204811096,
0.307202011346817,
0.039413340389728546,
-0.6040457487106323,
-0.9136043787002563,
0.5911561846733093,
-1.1591331958770752,
-0.015408717095851898,
1.2555768489837646,
0.06542912125587463,
0.22469979524612427,
-0.3358531594276428,
-0.5571922063827515,
0.3236779272556305,
-0.5933645963668823,
0.9596201181411743,
0.3795812726020813,
-0.1941290944814682,
-0.04312412068247795,
-0.3160408139228821,
0.9809560775756836,
0.3855527341365814,
-0.7439046502113342,
0.2247122824192047,
0.3947405517101288,
0.5967600345611572,
-0.42152395844459534,
0.4255800247192383,
0.19450460374355316,
0.2065393030643463,
-0.48224133253097534,
-0.0061888424679636955,
-0.313627153635025,
-0.12936840951442719,
-0.4061574935913086,
-0.08030851930379868,
0.2345605045557022,
-0.35595703125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00492v1
|
Multi-hop Question Answering under Temporal Knowledge Editing
| 2024-03-30T23:22:51 | 2024-03-30T23:22:51 |
Keyuan Cheng, Gang Lin, Haoyang Fei, Yuxuan zhai, Lu Yu, Muhammad Asif Ali, Lijie Hu, Di Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Multi-hop question answering (MQA) under knowledge editing (KE) has garnered
significant attention in the era of large language models. However, existing
models for MQA under KE exhibit poor performance when dealing with questions
containing explicit temporal contexts. To address this limitation, we propose a
novel framework, namely TEMPoral knowLEdge augmented Multi-hop Question
Answering (TEMPLE-MQA). Unlike previous methods, TEMPLE-MQA first constructs a
time-aware graph (TAG) to store edit knowledge in a structured manner. Then,
through our proposed inference path, structural retrieval, and joint reasoning
stages, TEMPLE-MQA effectively discerns temporal contexts within the question
query. Experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate that TEMPLE-MQA
significantly outperforms baseline models. Additionally, we contribute a new
dataset, namely TKEMQA, which serves as the inaugural benchmark tailored
specifically for MQA with temporal scopes.
|
[
-0.03134489431977272,
-1.2383337020874023,
0.8058332204818726,
0.1179165318608284,
-0.09294474124908447,
0.5651404857635498,
0.211186945438385,
-0.6045789122581482,
0.2814607322216034,
0.09196662902832031,
-0.6647249460220337,
-0.3206927478313446,
-0.47079765796661377,
0.0264449343085289,
-0.07270937412977219,
0.34556958079338074,
-0.325666606426239,
-0.12892332673072815,
0.14786019921302795,
-0.3513695001602173,
-0.5509049296379089,
-0.40087032318115234,
-0.7897176146507263,
-0.3360198736190796,
0.7317947149276733,
0.1767517477273941,
0.6378454566001892,
0.7748717665672302,
-0.2083236426115036,
0.23028072714805603,
-0.3633556663990021,
0.4922582805156708,
0.19680015742778778,
0.26504066586494446,
-0.10937469452619553,
-0.22291478514671326,
-0.7839235067367554,
-0.09308779239654541,
0.9313725829124451,
0.8047361969947815,
0.18627969920635223,
0.5338459610939026,
-0.2759201228618622,
0.4081600606441498,
-0.9024783968925476,
0.19074945151805878,
-0.7567249536514282,
0.1267734169960022,
-0.36549508571624756,
-0.4658312201499939,
-0.5215902328491211,
-0.3042141795158386,
0.025414591655135155,
-0.8892695307731628,
-0.3941798210144043,
0.10004095733165741,
0.7522919178009033,
0.4916155934333801,
-0.8539799451828003,
-0.016258668154478073,
-0.6126108169555664,
0.43764355778694153,
-0.40365415811538696,
0.9950721859931946,
0.3731527626514435,
0.4944876730442047,
-0.03551816940307617,
-0.7777099013328552,
-0.7027994990348816,
0.17519499361515045,
0.1337137669324875,
0.05503040552139282,
-0.2242640107870102,
-0.13033601641654968,
0.3803230822086334,
-0.1627398431301117,
-0.3693366050720215,
-0.32693126797676086,
-0.0842321440577507,
-0.2638099491596222,
-0.09428974986076355,
0.33629414439201355,
0.07967988401651382,
-0.5464907288551331,
-0.14476525783538818,
0.0966050773859024,
-0.46272069215774536,
0.5824519991874695,
0.10937809944152832,
-0.024419376626610756,
0.4676646292209625,
0.8211691975593567,
-0.5230817794799805,
0.8493426442146301,
0.08663584291934967,
-0.2744266092777252,
0.10707290470600128,
-0.37685590982437134,
-0.2871622145175934,
-0.1763095110654831,
0.26567232608795166,
0.3044431805610657,
0.11350568383932114,
-0.3675967752933502,
0.3358846604824066,
-0.15123793482780457,
0.06395513564348221,
-0.6016132235527039,
-0.056439630687236786,
0.4370163083076477,
-0.24242833256721497,
0.07849814742803574,
-0.45644864439964294,
-0.6511120796203613,
-0.014048507437109947,
-0.17143207788467407,
0.52167147397995,
-0.5088027715682983,
-0.1691105216741562,
-0.018911976367235184,
-0.3445703387260437,
0.2232242375612259,
0.46919649839401245,
-0.31388840079307556,
-0.06080184504389763,
0.5260805487632751,
0.7001235485076904,
0.5615397095680237,
-0.5108379125595093,
-0.8216015696525574,
0.7239208817481995,
-0.44587865471839905,
0.5785396695137024,
-0.8949779272079468,
-0.21852567791938782,
-0.41427451372146606,
-0.029368769377470016,
-0.31910446286201477,
-0.09795477986335754,
0.30205488204956055,
-1.4118603467941284,
-0.043626945465803146,
-0.37078896164894104,
-0.5662809014320374,
-0.052072908729314804,
0.5019088387489319,
-0.3875472843647003,
0.8373037576675415,
0.1560312956571579,
-0.8179261684417725,
0.6262944936752319,
-0.7210620641708374,
-0.3500615060329437,
-0.22593232989311218,
0.08581342548131943,
-0.19002199172973633,
-0.4611043930053711,
0.7313106656074524,
0.13472384214401245,
0.39958783984184265,
0.4162188470363617,
-0.33516255021095276,
-0.2412617951631546,
0.3364441990852356,
-0.22281211614608765,
0.7304727435112,
0.2909839451313019,
-0.0970039963722229,
-0.1836889237165451,
-0.6010186672210693,
0.27490177750587463,
0.009182662703096867,
-0.6913517117500305,
-0.4020676016807556,
0.13365335762500763,
-0.36669397354125977,
0.31443166732788086,
0.10433979332447052,
-0.8753826022148132,
0.5924107432365417,
-0.1447267085313797,
0.725824236869812,
0.7893426418304443,
0.4184265434741974,
0.37472137808799744,
-0.3142540454864502,
0.3995305597782135,
0.09778904914855957,
0.30903229117393494,
-0.05557098612189293,
-0.49305781722068787,
-0.34178149700164795,
0.1552274078130722,
0.2991054952144623,
0.6472052931785583,
-1.1228049993515015,
-0.2373514622449875,
-0.5144741535186768,
-0.5037137866020203,
-0.5335627794265747,
-0.11271988600492477,
0.4295435845851898,
0.8190045356750488,
0.751699686050415,
0.05143269523978233,
-0.3422705829143524,
-0.5008019804954529,
-0.6127185821533203,
-0.3842577338218689,
0.25583165884017944,
0.6929290294647217,
0.3727290630340576,
-0.2945743501186371,
0.9984920620918274,
-0.6314709782600403,
0.23680496215820312,
0.23997999727725983,
0.20025137066841125,
-0.024703560397028923,
0.35670551657676697,
0.4226450026035309,
-0.647268533706665,
-0.02635766938328743,
-0.3931216299533844,
-0.6230149865150452,
-0.05008300021290779,
-0.1437615007162094,
-0.41835373640060425,
-0.03320161625742912,
0.5451547503471375,
-0.6434037089347839,
0.33054327964782715,
0.38607537746429443,
-0.5911197662353516,
0.8870216012001038,
0.24669049680233002,
0.7382802963256836,
-1.3133776187896729,
-0.021832818165421486,
-0.569656491279602,
-0.17788831889629364,
-0.44934454560279846,
-0.10314362496137619,
0.3427492380142212,
-0.1271912157535553,
-0.36119022965431213,
0.9900032877922058,
-0.24429413676261902,
-0.06682059913873672,
0.04892544448375702,
0.0774102434515953,
0.3945709764957428,
0.7097164392471313,
-0.12614208459854126,
0.7785211205482483,
0.17340311408042908,
-0.6631669402122498,
-0.05210230126976967,
0.6830688714981079,
-0.2454250156879425,
0.229887917637825,
-0.6316438913345337,
0.388668954372406,
-0.060961268842220306,
0.5012924075126648,
-0.7290610074996948,
-0.2192527949810028,
0.34778448939323425,
-0.7881403565406799,
0.35753896832466125,
-0.7709030508995056,
-0.5739272236824036,
-0.2571943402290344,
-0.013628535903990269,
0.9459354877471924,
-0.12325145304203033,
-0.4698510468006134,
0.8783101439476013,
0.1452714502811432,
0.05499875918030739,
-1.1946399211883545,
-0.6443986892700195,
0.038980547338724136,
-0.09523463249206543,
-0.8411073088645935,
0.3929622173309326,
-0.16923029720783234,
-0.19242426753044128,
0.3100266456604004,
-0.4589732885360718,
-0.3459622263908386,
0.11591854691505432,
0.07676316052675247,
-0.009150016121566296,
-0.21578632295131683,
0.34728842973709106,
0.4328201115131378,
-0.11806924641132355,
-0.1049102246761322,
-0.3612135946750641,
0.4011739492416382,
0.014581439085304737,
-0.42871221899986267,
-0.34217414259910583,
0.33198535442352295,
0.6352053284645081,
-0.6440994739532471,
0.6074317097663879,
0.6310681700706482,
-0.4729509949684143,
0.15656039118766785,
-0.5981743335723877,
0.14176231622695923,
-0.3890211284160614,
0.0515318289399147,
-0.8478795886039734,
-1.189927577972412,
0.4616633653640747,
-0.21907062828540802,
0.2511628568172455,
0.2759135961532593,
0.2481750100851059,
-0.32115796208381653,
0.7147340178489685,
0.1141023188829422,
0.08468049764633179,
0.6204361319541931,
-0.17509905993938446,
0.0020168486516922712,
-1.227084755897522,
-0.11919019371271133,
-0.48311322927474976,
-0.3815068304538727,
-0.34448784589767456,
-0.47928741574287415,
0.8551220893859863,
0.3430313467979431,
-0.5655194520950317,
0.18523336946964264,
0.13184800744056702,
0.2546461224555969,
0.665192723274231,
0.33823105692863464,
0.6516872644424438,
-0.4882628321647644,
-0.22931337356567383,
0.07758325338363647,
-0.7128698229789734,
-0.2991061806678772,
1.0928281545639038,
0.03609807416796684,
0.5780587196350098,
0.31428229808807373,
0.409071683883667,
0.11416053771972656,
-0.09531993418931961,
-0.42935657501220703,
0.31190025806427,
0.2341945767402649,
-0.9243185520172119,
-0.3935687243938446,
-0.6705697774887085,
-0.8615338802337646,
0.1749650537967682,
-0.2474786788225174,
-0.7990412712097168,
0.07553581893444061,
0.3254089057445526,
-0.652063250541687,
0.8220624327659607,
-0.809019923210144,
0.9081767797470093,
-0.012071666307747364,
-0.31755363941192627,
-0.10998698323965073,
-0.7993137240409851,
0.3879593312740326,
0.060578085482120514,
0.3794881999492645,
-0.1920292228460312,
-0.12367900460958481,
0.7556667327880859,
-0.2211485058069229,
0.4164049029350281,
-0.39965295791625977,
0.5887985229492188,
0.24513983726501465,
0.5283940434455872,
0.33539214730262756,
0.44990313053131104,
-0.09209547936916351,
-0.12284030020236969,
0.5192009210586548,
-0.5832529067993164,
-0.7465857863426208,
0.449279248714447,
-0.7164180874824524,
-0.4441775977611542,
-0.1554175466299057,
-0.7882487177848816,
-0.7406237721443176,
0.15664619207382202,
-0.14414352178573608,
1.0805068016052246,
0.192306786775589,
-0.02929658815264702,
0.31819456815719604,
-0.23014910519123077,
0.5277653336524963,
0.44180721044540405,
-0.14454469084739685,
-0.3231234550476074,
0.14442132413387299,
0.36850300431251526,
0.13990509510040283,
0.720910370349884,
0.2971092760562897,
-0.4824525713920593,
-0.3673650324344635,
-0.8769769668579102,
0.12892311811447144,
-0.7682034373283386,
-0.17882347106933594,
-1.252429723739624,
-0.06645230203866959,
-0.5427506566047668,
-0.0625302866101265,
-0.32831406593322754,
-0.7685802578926086,
0.2777644693851471,
0.14594171941280365,
0.4534226953983307,
0.4145365357398987,
0.039373528212308884,
0.42055901885032654,
-1.0821893215179443,
0.5820292234420776,
0.5184745192527771,
0.6509262323379517,
0.05475917086005211,
-0.43783894181251526,
-0.08676755428314209,
-0.044030990451574326,
-0.15013673901557922,
-1.1572169065475464,
-0.37355169653892517,
0.15521380305290222,
0.49199041724205017,
0.028289077803492546,
0.007423474453389645,
1.0869704484939575,
-0.7420401573181152,
0.7071312665939331,
-0.4283944368362427,
-1.018596887588501,
0.725553572177887,
-0.3261605501174927,
0.5992060303688049,
0.3918102979660034,
0.2157345414161682,
-0.8533886075019836,
-0.31265535950660706,
-0.5818144679069519,
-0.6252629160881042,
0.379428505897522,
0.0094075258821249,
-0.22118397057056427,
-0.01199906412512064,
0.6381481885910034,
-0.13680540025234222,
0.34354278445243835,
-0.6814170479774475,
-0.3680371642112732,
-0.2094353586435318,
0.44088679552078247,
0.18183939158916473,
-0.337657630443573,
0.12012474983930588,
-0.3838442265987396,
0.6013333797454834,
0.03355245292186737,
0.3206551969051361,
0.42952004075050354,
-0.41024836897850037,
-0.20153571665287018,
0.6585578322410583,
0.1296718865633011,
1.0950918197631836,
-0.2933955490589142,
0.08683052659034729,
0.24018338322639465,
-0.19706061482429504,
0.15237866342067719,
-0.0007143622497096658,
-0.2517913579940796,
-0.07449553906917572,
0.5661266446113586,
0.29399943351745605,
0.284221887588501,
-0.24072681367397308,
0.2176533192396164,
-0.08401326090097427,
-0.04509725794196129,
0.04874485358595848,
-0.15421588718891144,
0.15694594383239746,
0.7620325088500977,
0.21380014717578888,
0.15832212567329407,
-0.005271758884191513,
-0.3088783621788025,
0.3422226309776306,
0.13103218376636505,
0.06942659616470337,
-0.08432672172784805,
0.9655717015266418,
-0.18224945664405823,
-0.0956726148724556,
0.5991073250770569,
-0.26922571659088135,
-0.574030339717865,
0.14520539343357086,
0.16482026875019073,
0.47668734192848206,
-0.22301024198532104,
0.06423437595367432,
0.6318807601928711,
0.34543657302856445,
0.6262359023094177,
0.41634806990623474,
-0.3662322163581848,
-0.7573252320289612,
-0.7500523924827576,
-0.6669906973838806,
-0.39704909920692444,
-0.11005473881959915,
-0.4034895598888397,
-0.1620621532201767,
-0.3540084958076477,
-0.3037071228027344,
0.09727005660533905,
0.11467477679252625,
-0.5635562539100647,
0.14670857787132263,
-0.2862637937068939,
1.0262914896011353,
-0.5118731260299683,
0.874272882938385,
0.6929795742034912,
-0.2727706730365753,
-1.0024231672286987,
0.05699716880917549,
0.053333401679992676,
-0.8169198632240295,
0.40653449296951294,
-0.2981949746608734,
-0.3178176283836365,
0.14668942987918854,
-0.24810799956321716,
-0.7357708215713501,
1.388311505317688,
0.06449691951274872,
-0.10816984623670578,
-0.3624900281429291,
-0.08834846317768097,
0.12461526691913605,
0.07720088958740234,
0.04620347544550896,
0.5084949731826782,
0.574135959148407,
0.2629702389240265,
-0.864712119102478,
-0.2837022542953491,
-0.30580660700798035,
-0.4708606004714966,
0.4463690221309662,
-0.557323157787323,
0.9088716506958008,
-0.28405439853668213,
-0.17838561534881592,
-0.1259443312883377,
0.48831140995025635,
0.2867595851421356,
0.6069806218147278,
0.6247180700302124,
0.7720053791999817,
0.7241743206977844,
-0.24021680653095245,
0.8193044662475586,
-0.41097626090049744,
0.012611248530447483,
1.5455069541931152,
0.21389779448509216,
0.8481679558753967,
0.5520145297050476,
-0.11669738590717316,
0.4045722782611847,
0.9513128995895386,
0.5241865515708923,
0.18063946068286896,
-0.12226815521717072,
-0.019985396414995193,
-0.4699896574020386,
-0.08026614785194397,
-0.5049928426742554,
0.6141946315765381,
0.04171695187687874,
0.18038393557071686,
-0.4457065165042877,
-0.14891132712364197,
0.2783689498901367,
-0.22605618834495544,
-0.4501681327819824,
0.5483613610267639,
-0.23688913881778717,
-0.5663464665412903,
0.037134356796741486,
0.1872299462556839,
0.13728855550289154,
-0.5537216663360596,
-0.022025758400559425,
-0.21592217683792114,
-0.18017806112766266,
0.0912228599190712,
-0.9742361307144165,
0.45844700932502747,
0.10602989792823792,
-0.31549447774887085,
-0.2495361864566803,
0.4784035086631775,
-0.3218833804130554,
-0.3208681643009186,
0.2765454053878784,
1.197403907775879,
-0.16548727452754974,
-0.17089277505874634,
-0.7956456542015076,
-0.22193242609500885,
-0.4953977167606354,
-0.29088112711906433,
-0.09171821177005768,
0.6340377330780029,
-0.1182476356625557,
0.8712060451507568,
0.5325111746788025,
-0.06774306297302246,
0.6203449368476868,
0.11689846962690353,
0.7759032845497131,
-0.6173179149627686,
-0.6151003837585449,
-0.5959199070930481,
0.47277170419692993,
0.27509239315986633,
-0.31520119309425354,
0.5744984745979309,
0.5496400594711304,
0.7863280773162842,
0.2645796239376068,
0.36917543411254883,
-0.24379922449588776,
0.6777743101119995,
-0.7306594848632812,
0.46469393372535706,
-0.9254644513130188,
0.027513999491930008,
-0.4913182258605957,
-0.7076930999755859,
0.051213063299655914,
-0.14588771760463715,
-0.3436489701271057,
0.0845567137002945,
0.6196922659873962,
0.6807518601417542,
-0.16350987553596497,
0.02720489352941513,
0.14341437816619873,
0.2347911298274994,
0.38339558243751526,
0.9537982940673828,
1.1171379089355469,
-0.5409116744995117,
0.7173942923545837,
-0.40797722339630127,
-0.05429457500576973,
0.2099408358335495,
-0.7646043300628662,
-0.6717442274093628,
-0.7573399543762207,
-0.1297907531261444,
-0.3580925762653351,
0.06745847314596176,
0.8996865749359131,
0.677072286605835,
-0.43438535928726196,
0.2931287884712219,
0.7672422528266907,
0.31332841515541077,
-0.3645029067993164,
-0.164947047829628,
0.6517385840415955,
-0.2217252552509308,
-0.4463803470134735,
0.6646701693534851,
0.2959999144077301,
-0.15296819806098938,
0.38155290484428406,
0.12271815538406372,
-0.7041102647781372,
-0.186753511428833,
0.7362430691719055,
0.14010567963123322,
-0.720973014831543,
-0.768636167049408,
0.3889009952545166,
0.22008980810642242,
0.2205224484205246,
0.9113603830337524,
-0.57716304063797,
0.7976111173629761,
0.2460119128227234,
1.1154637336730957,
0.5526372790336609,
0.11273365467786789,
0.12111160904169083,
-1.067766785621643,
-0.2826104462146759,
0.2020125538110733,
0.4168211817741394,
-0.0901075229048729,
-0.20973722636699677,
0.3562204837799072,
0.3692055642604828,
-0.6443342566490173,
-0.2561703026294708,
0.3385826349258423,
-1.1656981706619263,
-0.38908320665359497,
0.9520771503448486,
0.025753414258360863,
-0.1975771188735962,
-0.4668768644332886,
0.09190599620342255,
0.6461676359176636,
-0.17075398564338684,
0.5569113492965698,
0.845664918422699,
-0.36553022265434265,
-0.08907536417245865,
-0.8031236529350281,
0.455852746963501,
0.2805130183696747,
-0.6587568521499634,
0.03879740834236145,
0.6618902087211609,
0.38888978958129883,
0.01145124714821577,
0.9219825267791748,
-0.17249073088169098,
0.5328444838523865,
0.016795525327324867,
-0.5158213973045349,
-0.5813602209091187,
-0.6292844414710999,
0.14532722532749176,
0.2680529057979584,
0.13766323029994965,
-0.32575052976608276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00489v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00489v1
|
PROMPT-SAW: Leveraging Relation-Aware Graphs for Textual Prompt Compression
| 2024-03-30T23:07:58 | 2024-03-30T23:07:58 |
Muhammad Asif Ali, Zhengping Li, Shu Yang, Keyuan Cheng, Yang Cao, Tianhao Huang, Lijie Hu, Lu Yu, Di Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional abilities for multiple
different natural language processing tasks. While prompting is a crucial tool
for LLM inference, we observe that there is a significant cost associated with
exceedingly lengthy prompts. Existing attempts to compress lengthy prompts lead
to sub-standard results in terms of readability and interpretability of the
compressed prompt, with a detrimental impact on prompt utility. To address
this, we propose PROMPT-SAW: Prompt compresSion via Relation AWare graphs, an
effective strategy for prompt compression over task-agnostic and task-aware
prompts. PROMPT-SAW uses the prompt's textual information to build a graph,
later extracts key information elements in the graph to come up with the
compressed prompt. We also propose GSM8K-AUG, i.e., an extended version of the
existing GSM8k benchmark for task-agnostic prompts in order to provide a
comprehensive evaluation platform. Experimental evaluation using benchmark
datasets shows that prompts compressed by PROMPT-SAW are not only better in
terms of readability, but they also outperform the best-performing baseline
models by up to 14.3 and 13.7 respectively for task-aware and task-agnostic
settings while compressing the original prompt text by 33.0 and 56.7.
|
[
-0.3100486993789673,
-0.6464865207672119,
0.9155665040016174,
0.4296738803386688,
-0.5361001491546631,
-0.14728577435016632,
-0.17384834587574005,
-0.4044246971607208,
0.2649476230144501,
0.4267028570175171,
-1.0410352945327759,
-0.39893803000450134,
-0.5016031861305237,
0.6416224241256714,
-0.08177556097507477,
0.5770139694213867,
0.33240339159965515,
-0.1526462733745575,
-0.3236106336116791,
-0.0513630285859108,
-0.8893143534660339,
-0.5924636125564575,
-0.7791266441345215,
-0.3135211765766144,
0.7540735602378845,
0.08760210871696472,
0.7499553561210632,
0.8748742341995239,
0.0959458202123642,
0.25268709659576416,
-0.31329670548439026,
0.31611308455467224,
-0.24643534421920776,
0.6857683658599854,
0.04321835935115814,
-0.24026834964752197,
-0.5594757795333862,
0.01740974187850952,
0.5623741149902344,
0.7079418301582336,
0.12043727189302444,
-0.05220891907811165,
0.2200891375541687,
0.5054583549499512,
-0.37823012471199036,
0.4025024175643921,
-0.5568923950195312,
-0.16155306994915009,
-0.055819738656282425,
-0.4333737790584564,
-0.8839378952980042,
-0.39240792393684387,
-0.27749869227409363,
-0.6946148872375488,
-0.0716894119977951,
0.3157803416252136,
0.8421132564544678,
0.4790554642677307,
-0.46120837330818176,
-0.2733948826789856,
-0.2748117744922638,
0.5261690020561218,
-0.5679512619972229,
0.48512986302375793,
0.5296005606651306,
0.26710453629493713,
-0.3211767375469208,
-0.6367459893226624,
-0.2980008125305176,
-0.17123804986476898,
-0.17628520727157593,
0.0935617983341217,
-0.3122786283493042,
0.1963520646095276,
0.8346324563026428,
0.20172111690044403,
-0.5327947735786438,
0.2972119152545929,
0.18887081742286682,
-0.34692203998565674,
0.3106970191001892,
0.41387739777565,
0.37075772881507874,
-0.7166361808776855,
-0.3844555914402008,
-0.013764411211013794,
-0.9565457701683044,
-0.03963397070765495,
0.46812084317207336,
0.4741721451282501,
0.018823642283678055,
0.4945630133152008,
-0.3447069227695465,
1.0983574390411377,
-0.06732731312513351,
-0.20327059924602509,
0.04687676578760147,
-0.3492780923843384,
-0.30652928352355957,
0.06353363394737244,
0.9207374453544617,
0.5691691040992737,
0.28903764486312866,
-0.13635914027690887,
-0.12754052877426147,
0.30229896306991577,
-0.19534622132778168,
-0.9989000558853149,
-0.3522193431854248,
0.07240299135446548,
-0.43068015575408936,
0.11256197839975357,
-0.3836292624473572,
-0.742843508720398,
-0.8090994954109192,
-0.2459850013256073,
0.15746816992759705,
-0.4155345559120178,
0.15182514488697052,
0.11186235398054123,
-0.1849006712436676,
-0.23443447053432465,
0.5542656779289246,
-0.7864649891853333,
0.13765138387680054,
0.5192111730575562,
1.0079766511917114,
0.19072164595127106,
-0.06744571775197983,
-1.0662037134170532,
0.10706941038370132,
0.03215481713414192,
0.9623644948005676,
-0.5885854363441467,
-0.6658240556716919,
-0.14165793359279633,
-0.07035442441701889,
-0.09469093382358551,
-0.4437984824180603,
1.071470022201538,
-0.4372059106826782,
0.2855721116065979,
-0.397564560174942,
-0.6424217224121094,
0.07265477627515793,
0.3235461115837097,
-0.9299336075782776,
1.133978009223938,
0.1798689365386963,
-0.7702056169509888,
0.19524814188480377,
-0.14725758135318756,
-0.3026052415370941,
0.10314071923494339,
-0.18680241703987122,
-0.1449875831604004,
-0.22619962692260742,
0.8438122272491455,
0.6893810629844666,
-0.7058804035186768,
0.20102021098136902,
-0.3089277744293213,
-0.25800323486328125,
-0.002669060602784157,
-0.44495856761932373,
0.8287495374679565,
0.19902092218399048,
0.15878237783908844,
0.2628532648086548,
-0.5110734105110168,
-0.12940791249275208,
0.05336827412247658,
-0.2647041082382202,
-0.37632161378860474,
-0.2423114776611328,
-0.44147953391075134,
0.17483261227607727,
0.30068135261535645,
-0.5034983158111572,
0.549402117729187,
-0.3592982888221741,
0.4244663417339325,
0.6907654404640198,
0.30597591400146484,
0.3228941261768341,
-0.2540689706802368,
0.6464206576347351,
-0.29891452193260193,
0.20409634709358215,
-0.8950120210647583,
-0.517397940158844,
-0.41798296570777893,
-0.3704518675804138,
0.2407192885875702,
0.5083187222480774,
-0.9759287238121033,
0.4848213195800781,
-0.5126798152923584,
-0.39070773124694824,
-0.1964622586965561,
-0.21899637579917908,
0.3403586745262146,
1.097252368927002,
0.23613862693309784,
0.10179897397756577,
-0.4892725944519043,
-0.7246615886688232,
-0.48497527837753296,
-0.2827392816543579,
-0.2554139196872711,
0.410793662071228,
-0.13812857866287231,
0.09444797784090042,
0.8856455087661743,
-0.9400612115859985,
-0.12649716436862946,
-0.20125433802604675,
0.16409574449062347,
0.5844677686691284,
0.1527157574892044,
0.5292601585388184,
-0.46013882756233215,
-0.5425269603729248,
-0.3803635537624359,
-0.6402291655540466,
-0.4929046630859375,
-0.3251781165599823,
0.06402262300252914,
-0.2196243405342102,
0.4555034935474396,
-1.0363922119140625,
0.31995484232902527,
0.40112054347991943,
-0.5187148451805115,
0.8067513704299927,
-0.2090633660554886,
0.17531059682369232,
-1.105846881866455,
-0.15015371143817902,
0.1003679484128952,
-0.5822567939758301,
-0.49154242873191833,
-0.13887429237365723,
0.2073041945695877,
-0.3867785334587097,
-0.1245507150888443,
0.51828533411026,
-0.8395962715148926,
-0.09581308811903,
-0.1488388627767563,
0.2041211575269699,
0.2530495226383209,
0.5250101685523987,
-0.11765079200267792,
1.2168405055999756,
0.3887750208377838,
-0.584835410118103,
0.2503245174884796,
0.5341145992279053,
-0.2399977296590805,
0.45654016733169556,
-0.5184212923049927,
0.3861334025859833,
-0.07026731967926025,
0.41365909576416016,
-0.6505758762359619,
-0.12720586359500885,
0.5557625889778137,
-0.40102675557136536,
0.23436559736728668,
-0.3312692940235138,
-0.7691619992256165,
-0.10722833126783371,
-0.4450235664844513,
0.13414432108402252,
0.6633456349372864,
-0.5958782434463501,
0.7018545866012573,
0.15448257327079773,
-0.435627281665802,
-0.3942508399486542,
-0.258635938167572,
0.3708670735359192,
-0.3072112798690796,
-0.6768192052841187,
0.3824132978916168,
-0.19689731299877167,
0.06766393780708313,
-0.17079609632492065,
-0.2694619596004486,
0.1335880011320114,
-0.04189211502671242,
0.4339293837547302,
0.3702002465724945,
-0.017375081777572632,
0.13724695146083832,
0.06416218727827072,
-0.31930994987487793,
0.1954628974199295,
-0.07556150108575821,
0.7254670262336731,
0.35612285137176514,
-0.08343876898288727,
-0.2582641839981079,
0.4989950358867645,
0.24762722849845886,
-0.05850084125995636,
0.5035257339477539,
0.12708882987499237,
-0.3120688199996948,
-0.05142894759774208,
-0.25247207283973694,
-0.10186189413070679,
-0.5125590562820435,
-0.09688480198383331,
-0.5281885266304016,
-0.9681333899497986,
0.5929827094078064,
-0.5717512369155884,
-0.05301915109157562,
0.3156508803367615,
0.16234596073627472,
0.16085976362228394,
1.1648011207580566,
0.3643925189971924,
-0.0575801320374012,
0.543578028678894,
0.09706497192382812,
0.05598572641611099,
-0.9725737571716309,
-0.18282237648963928,
-0.8734664916992188,
0.1226312592625618,
0.02175460010766983,
-0.38719332218170166,
0.37971392273902893,
0.3002201020717621,
-0.16512972116470337,
0.46115246415138245,
-0.5358689427375793,
0.505944550037384,
0.20229975879192352,
0.2740567922592163,
0.33137765526771545,
-0.07568997144699097,
0.05268023535609245,
-0.18343855440616608,
-0.7967268228530884,
-0.4983150064945221,
0.43750518560409546,
0.15756960213184357,
0.6709815859794617,
-0.1173093393445015,
0.4816485345363617,
0.2828035056591034,
0.08247975260019302,
-1.0688329935073853,
0.8520481586456299,
0.0868786871433258,
0.07123387604951859,
-0.1477242410182953,
-0.6360217928886414,
-1.2454370260238647,
-0.02013096772134304,
-0.055549781769514084,
-0.9914344549179077,
0.14247025549411774,
0.24646662175655365,
-0.30002856254577637,
0.10433345288038254,
-0.8764778971672058,
0.5584272146224976,
0.2184104472398758,
-0.034671250730752945,
0.08004161715507507,
-0.6310805082321167,
0.07097194343805313,
0.1083272323012352,
0.14863044023513794,
-0.4123358428478241,
-0.1901455968618393,
0.8413540720939636,
-0.6576077938079834,
0.8991425037384033,
-0.19239741563796997,
-0.05565575882792473,
0.2401355504989624,
0.20858503878116608,
1.0514321327209473,
-0.046065960079431534,
-0.32104554772377014,
-0.190172478556633,
-0.4232252538204193,
-0.1772627979516983,
-1.0940896272659302,
0.6717535853385925,
-0.31111040711402893,
-0.790111780166626,
-0.2655720114707947,
-0.6766014695167542,
-0.4097234606742859,
0.2994542717933655,
0.37852656841278076,
1.0720617771148682,
0.25201135873794556,
-0.3256363868713379,
0.5045651197433472,
-0.09993597120046616,
0.44075873494148254,
0.18767766654491425,
-0.32006844878196716,
-0.5126858949661255,
0.6963426470756531,
0.03590559586882591,
0.04987339302897453,
0.3097793459892273,
0.2807305157184601,
-0.5605059266090393,
-0.4843370020389557,
-0.5713685154914856,
0.2160768210887909,
-0.9921155571937561,
-0.6389830708503723,
-0.7949686050415039,
0.06360403448343277,
-0.36016398668289185,
-0.1211169883608818,
0.1261233538389206,
-0.5481975674629211,
-0.46789631247520447,
-0.06636861711740494,
0.6832854747772217,
0.6842201948165894,
0.326252818107605,
0.5167746543884277,
-0.9549887180328369,
0.3947297930717468,
0.11726624518632889,
0.2044982761144638,
0.022888856008648872,
-0.24040864408016205,
-0.1315394937992096,
-0.2566753327846527,
0.10942628234624863,
-1.3673211336135864,
0.42742452025413513,
0.06912562996149063,
0.285165399312973,
0.2607078552246094,
0.5676583647727966,
0.6502953767776489,
-0.5946205258369446,
0.9473884701728821,
0.5335326194763184,
-0.9317349791526794,
0.4864078760147095,
-0.48944786190986633,
0.6409355998039246,
0.3475683331489563,
0.22016441822052002,
-0.4963688850402832,
-0.20088385045528412,
-0.4232568144798279,
-0.8387531638145447,
0.7030800580978394,
0.28263360261917114,
0.007899295538663864,
-0.2045709788799286,
0.2920999526977539,
0.18010056018829346,
0.08328449726104736,
-0.4735791087150574,
-0.2871939241886139,
-0.10460777580738068,
-0.2681736946105957,
0.024461597204208374,
-0.6114011406898499,
0.10951711982488632,
-0.004932515788823366,
0.2857038378715515,
-0.17109772562980652,
0.3760908544063568,
0.32474684715270996,
-0.132940411567688,
0.20440003275871277,
0.4076937437057495,
0.16857676208019257,
0.36349520087242126,
-0.1406136155128479,
0.3814602792263031,
0.10609856992959976,
-0.5392565131187439,
0.2780349552631378,
0.3206714987754822,
-0.10657654702663422,
0.243104487657547,
0.4799128472805023,
0.9848951101303101,
0.2819187343120575,
-0.4823131859302521,
0.2903108298778534,
-0.25995537638664246,
0.11715927720069885,
0.29543495178222656,
-0.025820357725024223,
0.2116716057062149,
0.037832435220479965,
0.29287809133529663,
-0.029849007725715637,
0.3654104173183441,
-0.2014855146408081,
-0.026149705052375793,
0.14696919918060303,
-0.33263900876045227,
-0.21563485264778137,
0.631384015083313,
0.4356039762496948,
-0.6051195859909058,
0.6013388633728027,
-0.20262721180915833,
-0.6394124031066895,
0.41279029846191406,
0.5807797312736511,
0.8201770782470703,
-0.2703094780445099,
0.03257875517010689,
0.4389457106590271,
0.24204090237617493,
0.005387833807617426,
0.2697571814060211,
-0.386755108833313,
-0.3518640398979187,
-0.7457871437072754,
-0.1612955629825592,
-0.49069127440452576,
-0.13593131303787231,
-0.7120011448860168,
0.3320673704147339,
-0.3873535692691803,
-0.4232475459575653,
0.06265735626220703,
-0.011910244822502136,
-0.5106893181800842,
0.19825877249240875,
-0.3081658184528351,
1.3268991708755493,
-0.44762566685676575,
0.8133707046508789,
0.4986051917076111,
-0.2005978673696518,
-1.2326593399047852,
-0.08991242200136185,
-0.24906449019908905,
-0.5631100535392761,
0.36308562755584717,
0.5519341230392456,
-0.20332513749599457,
0.21313874423503876,
-0.2923179566860199,
-0.5182501673698425,
1.0641146898269653,
0.9260339140892029,
-0.6128143072128296,
-0.10953672975301743,
-0.23061487078666687,
0.1330920159816742,
-0.2095537632703781,
0.3706696331501007,
0.39010247588157654,
0.37863409519195557,
0.0684516578912735,
-0.8871850967407227,
0.5914168357849121,
-0.21909108757972717,
-0.20845602452754974,
0.6957536339759827,
-0.43531081080436707,
0.6804262399673462,
0.0008162053418345749,
-0.6150500774383545,
0.10446476191282272,
0.6110895276069641,
0.2162606120109558,
0.4058660566806793,
0.7727379202842712,
0.249664306640625,
1.0334738492965698,
0.0751584842801094,
1.2303560972213745,
-0.31583884358406067,
0.17224274575710297,
1.2270952463150024,
-0.31088730692863464,
0.5709585547447205,
0.43340179324150085,
-0.1328595131635666,
0.39450326561927795,
0.8082082271575928,
0.2410113364458084,
0.3298635184764862,
-0.20619432628154755,
-0.5338995456695557,
-0.6170011162757874,
-0.5898456573486328,
-0.3673632740974426,
-0.23961763083934784,
0.21308983862400055,
-0.3608614504337311,
-0.39785951375961304,
-0.23880082368850708,
0.34783169627189636,
0.12741096317768097,
-0.3300994038581848,
0.6264498233795166,
0.403987318277359,
-0.7358936667442322,
0.6016641855239868,
-0.21197043359279633,
0.47372761368751526,
-0.795543909072876,
-0.09013969451189041,
-0.055286113172769547,
-0.5477500557899475,
-0.09906087815761566,
-0.9443269968032837,
0.13002750277519226,
0.26507341861724854,
-0.3664212226867676,
-0.5540334582328796,
1.1730692386627197,
-0.258480966091156,
0.07768220454454422,
0.23571516573429108,
0.46423041820526123,
0.22599713504314423,
-0.34727099537849426,
-0.4527532458305359,
0.33251041173934937,
0.06274010241031647,
-0.25142261385917664,
0.3024448752403259,
0.40158554911613464,
0.13193541765213013,
0.8133431673049927,
0.5855517983436584,
-0.013520315289497375,
-0.27501922845840454,
0.20557524263858795,
1.2798227071762085,
-0.6580278277397156,
-0.8432167768478394,
-1.0194435119628906,
0.3492729663848877,
-0.4066827595233917,
-0.27946481108665466,
1.0090171098709106,
0.5162346363067627,
0.08590444922447205,
0.01520439051091671,
0.4697039723396301,
0.2575623691082001,
0.3508540093898773,
-0.8290581703186035,
0.44209614396095276,
-0.19406065344810486,
0.40017443895339966,
-0.13915957510471344,
-0.8697645664215088,
-0.18876323103904724,
0.07388979941606522,
-0.32170918583869934,
-0.24417777359485626,
0.6706836819648743,
0.5481473803520203,
0.1630123257637024,
0.11206187307834625,
0.22575271129608154,
-0.059790488332509995,
0.21169185638427734,
0.5883867144584656,
0.8543409109115601,
-0.22919337451457977,
0.7789483070373535,
-0.03954082727432251,
0.043342042714357376,
0.07547830790281296,
-1.2737985849380493,
-1.088108777999878,
-0.5295548439025879,
-0.3386733829975128,
-0.4014436602592468,
-0.13255444169044495,
0.9897614121437073,
0.6039572954177856,
0.0011995942331850529,
0.04808817803859711,
-0.08075378835201263,
0.2702333927154541,
0.05727323144674301,
-0.13465628027915955,
0.5333405137062073,
-0.09463442862033844,
-0.5825629830360413,
0.6472957134246826,
0.408866822719574,
0.0948103666305542,
0.0751904770731926,
-0.12509416043758392,
0.09434680640697479,
0.09133630990982056,
0.6769877076148987,
0.11924712359905243,
-0.4481290578842163,
-0.20449404418468475,
0.031418174505233765,
0.07959981262683868,
0.1952243149280548,
1.041998267173767,
-1.3123441934585571,
0.46771055459976196,
0.5948494076728821,
0.3710421323776245,
0.25597503781318665,
0.19448484480381012,
0.8024977445602417,
-1.088489294052124,
0.3427715003490448,
0.19065864384174347,
0.5767563581466675,
0.6121471524238586,
-0.7743616104125977,
0.52986741065979,
0.07980965077877045,
-0.5258352756500244,
-1.010663390159607,
0.6086035370826721,
-1.2193291187286377,
-0.21227748692035675,
1.1716541051864624,
-0.4522547423839569,
-0.2418498396873474,
-0.1533765196800232,
-0.7336388230323792,
0.3821607828140259,
-0.7977806329727173,
0.22475510835647583,
0.5842387676239014,
-0.26933056116104126,
-0.47469714283943176,
-0.12038866430521011,
0.6303993463516235,
0.2787530720233917,
-0.9641473293304443,
0.40573081374168396,
0.6894282698631287,
-0.1393970400094986,
-0.11026221513748169,
0.7969130873680115,
0.34360766410827637,
0.04017685726284981,
0.2666971981525421,
-0.30401769280433655,
-0.4826261103153229,
-0.09150102734565735,
-0.5060951113700867,
0.3213963508605957,
0.1597713828086853,
-0.031537462025880814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00488v1
|
Noise-Aware Training of Layout-Aware Language Models
| 2024-03-30T23:06:34 | 2024-03-30T23:06:34 |
Ritesh Sarkhel, Xiaoqi Ren, Lauro Beltrao Costa, Guolong Su, Vincent Perot, Yanan Xie, Emmanouil Koukoumidis, Arnab Nandi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A visually rich document (VRD) utilizes visual features along with linguistic
cues to disseminate information. Training a custom extractor that identifies
named entities from a document requires a large number of instances of the
target document type annotated at textual and visual modalities. This is an
expensive bottleneck in enterprise scenarios, where we want to train custom
extractors for thousands of different document types in a scalable way.
Pre-training an extractor model on unlabeled instances of the target document
type, followed by a fine-tuning step on human-labeled instances does not work
in these scenarios, as it surpasses the maximum allowable training time
allocated for the extractor. We address this scenario by proposing a
Noise-Aware Training method or NAT in this paper. Instead of acquiring
expensive human-labeled documents, NAT utilizes weakly labeled documents to
train an extractor in a scalable way. To avoid degradation in the model's
quality due to noisy, weakly labeled samples, NAT estimates the confidence of
each training sample and incorporates it as uncertainty measure during
training. We train multiple state-of-the-art extractor models using NAT.
Experiments on a number of publicly available and in-house datasets show that
NAT-trained models are not only robust in performance -- it outperforms a
transfer-learning baseline by up to 6% in terms of macro-F1 score, but it is
also more label-efficient -- it reduces the amount of human-effort required to
obtain comparable performance by up to 73%.
|
[
-0.5019333362579346,
-0.6877281665802002,
0.17096829414367676,
0.25544631481170654,
-0.2949505150318146,
-0.05949774011969566,
-0.14188067615032196,
-0.6705892086029053,
-0.010550769977271557,
0.48471882939338684,
-0.263423353433609,
-0.4342724084854126,
-0.5424038767814636,
-0.025762461125850677,
-0.42024821043014526,
0.6701653599739075,
0.07941210269927979,
-0.10712622106075287,
-0.16950130462646484,
0.10975023359060287,
-0.25279930233955383,
-0.21870540082454681,
-0.43989822268486023,
0.04860135540366173,
0.163961723446846,
0.1971198171377182,
0.6482837200164795,
0.9027788639068604,
0.5688738822937012,
0.3859385848045349,
-0.3431887924671173,
0.41749563813209534,
-0.4269597828388214,
0.06718559563159943,
-0.07839558273553848,
-0.134715735912323,
-0.37527772784233093,
-0.1454157531261444,
0.58463454246521,
0.621109127998352,
-0.041289035230875015,
-0.0277386624366045,
0.07190141081809998,
0.49882379174232483,
-0.694781482219696,
0.35072630643844604,
-0.6425039172172546,
0.24790243804454803,
-0.1595325767993927,
-0.1307760626077652,
-0.46815627813339233,
-0.3253670930862427,
0.19630053639411926,
-0.8898597359657288,
0.42206934094429016,
0.014390427619218826,
1.3124008178710938,
0.33988988399505615,
-0.05007025599479675,
0.10464473813772202,
-0.8548109531402588,
0.6148217916488647,
-0.30385422706604004,
0.8130297660827637,
0.5197817087173462,
0.08541678637266159,
0.1608937829732895,
-0.537888765335083,
-0.3135608434677124,
0.24359779059886932,
-0.026401014998555183,
0.30750611424446106,
-0.08253273367881775,
0.06297048926353455,
0.4507632255554199,
0.5963298082351685,
-0.5000348091125488,
0.26096588373184204,
-0.6206416487693787,
-0.3818603754043579,
0.4153878092765808,
-0.2500440776348114,
0.20659148693084717,
-0.13508670032024384,
-0.2661437392234802,
-0.17884859442710876,
-0.2508648633956909,
-0.2496466487646103,
0.5245450139045715,
0.3672258257865906,
-0.2530600428581238,
0.1851135790348053,
-0.2932571768760681,
0.9795709848403931,
0.17436406016349792,
-0.4081592857837677,
0.436111718416214,
-0.4294779598712921,
-0.23747314512729645,
-0.03496737405657768,
0.7959960699081421,
-0.16715988516807556,
0.24234303832054138,
-0.37792786955833435,
-0.33120378851890564,
-0.10786837339401245,
0.5598458051681519,
-0.8986085653305054,
-0.5330597758293152,
0.03565822169184685,
-0.4250454008579254,
-0.6697389483451843,
-0.08239351958036423,
-0.9910862445831299,
-0.3046773672103882,
-0.5778795480728149,
0.4205636978149414,
-0.6885539293289185,
-0.4545395076274872,
0.05224194377660751,
-0.06165104731917381,
0.24382729828357697,
0.6116835474967957,
-0.9907720685005188,
0.2709232568740845,
0.5275372266769409,
0.8602409362792969,
-0.4367124140262604,
-0.004139325115829706,
-0.80987548828125,
-0.029184794053435326,
-0.508943498134613,
1.002933144569397,
-0.29797595739364624,
-0.46778541803359985,
0.0905894935131073,
-0.19251878559589386,
-0.10499105602502823,
-0.6663984060287476,
0.564200222492218,
-0.514278769493103,
0.19825834035873413,
-0.18753862380981445,
-0.3923175036907196,
0.12564337253570557,
0.3124634623527527,
-0.8551198840141296,
1.109778642654419,
0.4732270836830139,
-1.0098413228988647,
0.5826390385627747,
-0.556562066078186,
-0.428765207529068,
0.1415388435125351,
-0.16793549060821533,
-0.8512911200523376,
0.00821369607001543,
0.29595431685447693,
0.2560151219367981,
0.165344700217247,
0.039909087121486664,
-0.033714842051267624,
-0.3018622100353241,
0.025304216891527176,
-0.519116222858429,
0.836894154548645,
0.36495524644851685,
-0.29372438788414,
0.025196336209774017,
-1.2034056186676025,
-0.030535362660884857,
-0.15110057592391968,
-0.7820074558258057,
-0.49153080582618713,
-0.42476773262023926,
0.14013603329658508,
0.2816486656665802,
0.07899635285139084,
-0.4946601390838623,
0.03496705740690231,
-0.4154316484928131,
-0.24072876572608948,
0.7427718043327332,
-0.08417890965938568,
0.6636068820953369,
-0.11151342839002609,
0.5995461940765381,
0.051727622747421265,
-0.03534859046339989,
-0.09222333133220673,
-0.15655791759490967,
-0.7326309084892273,
-0.8374377489089966,
0.506228506565094,
0.367125004529953,
-0.6125866770744324,
0.4664628803730011,
-0.38173604011535645,
-0.3950721025466919,
-0.422294020652771,
0.5446402430534363,
0.48381099104881287,
0.6817354559898376,
0.2679840922355652,
-0.5523541569709778,
-0.5818614363670349,
-0.632638156414032,
-0.000017094245777116157,
0.06538721919059753,
0.17292721569538116,
0.2726261019706726,
0.2511858642101288,
-0.008990800939500332,
0.9304587244987488,
-0.32204487919807434,
-0.4191249907016754,
-0.34281039237976074,
0.45104971528053284,
-0.23255178332328796,
0.5411471724510193,
0.20044846832752228,
-0.9380254745483398,
-0.6692364811897278,
0.1518222838640213,
-0.7814003229141235,
-0.21498577296733856,
-0.2841930091381073,
-0.31522417068481445,
0.16835857927799225,
0.7978499531745911,
-0.5026049017906189,
0.5884588956832886,
0.38975444436073303,
0.0044271997176110744,
0.6537850499153137,
-0.2966323494911194,
-0.46280667185783386,
-1.1328827142715454,
-0.1458599865436554,
0.11781857907772064,
-0.174309641122818,
-0.5374582409858704,
-0.17470860481262207,
0.10756461322307587,
-0.2578631043434143,
-0.5113851428031921,
0.4540438652038574,
-0.8815733790397644,
-0.21355612576007843,
-0.20102721452713013,
-0.030232975259423256,
0.35306334495544434,
0.4670468270778656,
0.5553022027015686,
0.6750472187995911,
0.6676638722419739,
-0.6913843750953674,
-0.23397742211818695,
0.3607061207294464,
-0.5494965314865112,
0.8301855325698853,
-0.3817194402217865,
0.055716171860694885,
-0.15119676291942596,
-0.06494112312793732,
-0.7550742030143738,
-0.1939859688282013,
0.028815260156989098,
-0.028869634494185448,
0.8193432688713074,
-0.16721738874912262,
-0.5422194004058838,
-0.22439539432525635,
0.023591971024870872,
0.10785475373268127,
0.36460214853286743,
-0.7267739176750183,
0.5988973379135132,
0.4194616377353668,
0.21386836469173431,
-0.3355899155139923,
-0.5688064694404602,
-0.27841466665267944,
-0.290128231048584,
-0.5352421402931213,
0.22029587626457214,
0.06924273073673248,
-0.17299017310142517,
-0.1347150206565857,
-0.3078083097934723,
-0.4804443418979645,
0.19214506447315216,
0.4348057806491852,
0.10083802789449692,
-0.16957813501358032,
0.10376264154911041,
-0.18163782358169556,
-0.1900252103805542,
-0.04270268231630325,
-0.38871970772743225,
0.340721994638443,
-0.24282780289649963,
-0.4789264500141144,
-0.5062459707260132,
0.26915520429611206,
0.34840530157089233,
-0.4756701588630676,
0.7106637954711914,
1.0608056783676147,
-0.40586745738983154,
-0.1921405792236328,
-0.6375389099121094,
0.06376928836107254,
-0.5225996971130371,
0.5741270184516907,
-0.3670073449611664,
-0.5713324546813965,
0.3017387092113495,
-0.4439103901386261,
0.08608709275722504,
0.08262047171592712,
0.33418920636177063,
-0.1465337872505188,
0.656733512878418,
1.0274975299835205,
-0.02560199797153473,
0.9158395528793335,
-0.523654580116272,
0.06212640181183815,
-0.849674642086029,
-0.21762165427207947,
-0.622373640537262,
-0.1515660285949707,
-0.3523840010166168,
-0.495947927236557,
0.2032613456249237,
-0.04877249523997307,
-0.0746363028883934,
0.3769793212413788,
-0.6828896999359131,
0.5479225516319275,
0.6756353378295898,
-0.045982178300619125,
0.2756098210811615,
0.4864985942840576,
-0.06760269403457642,
-0.3166014552116394,
-0.6922367811203003,
-0.14583157002925873,
0.832865834236145,
0.2622472643852234,
0.936283528804779,
-0.05822736397385597,
0.8818163871765137,
-0.0644601359963417,
0.08187543600797653,
-0.6806864142417908,
0.2604992687702179,
0.03232342749834061,
-0.5446966290473938,
-0.4755256175994873,
-0.5212156772613525,
-1.0359704494476318,
0.4212368428707123,
-0.16054469347000122,
-0.9710134863853455,
0.6885215640068054,
0.03313033655285835,
-0.2920457124710083,
0.5481113791465759,
-0.6867979168891907,
0.861579954624176,
-0.37188655138015747,
-0.49839702248573303,
0.23680903017520905,
-0.40506383776664734,
0.2513255178928375,
-0.3019396960735321,
0.28321969509124756,
0.20536665618419647,
0.423406183719635,
0.7801791429519653,
-0.5113937854766846,
0.8412030339241028,
-0.08722793310880661,
-0.06621015071868896,
0.3512614071369171,
0.3490120768547058,
0.6432359218597412,
-0.3304736018180847,
-0.15512049198150635,
0.24496015906333923,
-0.3827744722366333,
-0.18797017633914948,
-0.3705419600009918,
0.2754325866699219,
-0.9877877235412598,
-0.18821652233600616,
-0.33875179290771484,
-0.7300298810005188,
-0.2148415893316269,
0.404233455657959,
0.6430506706237793,
0.6055200099945068,
-0.17156897485256195,
0.2641623020172119,
1.1803072690963745,
-0.2699340879917145,
0.2978682816028595,
0.518662691116333,
-0.010214198380708694,
-0.18363502621650696,
1.282794713973999,
0.24787865579128265,
0.3276093900203705,
0.6093846559524536,
0.1623222678899765,
-0.16825000941753387,
-0.5750187039375305,
-0.18552473187446594,
0.026692504063248634,
-0.6624849438667297,
-0.1150098592042923,
-0.9575714468955994,
-0.6872807741165161,
-0.1904352307319641,
-0.36950400471687317,
-0.8555475473403931,
-0.21678394079208374,
-0.44137173891067505,
-0.3966154456138611,
0.14798937737941742,
0.4688900411128998,
-0.3496628999710083,
0.3932821452617645,
-0.3921937942504883,
0.506994366645813,
0.4829299747943878,
0.5045914649963379,
-0.2349870204925537,
-0.7229161262512207,
-0.45698463916778564,
-0.34451228380203247,
-0.38617444038391113,
-0.5163337588310242,
0.7280033826828003,
0.1820799857378006,
0.5636917948722839,
0.7203367948532104,
0.021472491323947906,
0.6921749114990234,
-0.1672700196504593,
0.361066609621048,
0.040657125413417816,
-0.5592060685157776,
0.6421066522598267,
-0.3320600688457489,
0.3359753489494324,
0.6766317486763,
0.21228280663490295,
-0.02719886414706707,
-0.25149819254875183,
-0.8494792580604553,
-0.8319730162620544,
0.7628097534179688,
0.1222819834947586,
-0.16202515363693237,
0.1646394431591034,
0.04376192018389702,
0.15580202639102936,
0.0897732749581337,
-0.8071228265762329,
0.08281753212213516,
-0.3347088396549225,
-0.025441043078899384,
0.3403022885322571,
-0.34491482377052307,
0.045790430158376694,
-0.3361652195453644,
0.6087014675140381,
-0.032274018973112106,
0.15280473232269287,
0.12094750255346298,
-0.302651584148407,
-0.20222724974155426,
0.13730762898921967,
0.3456375002861023,
0.549630343914032,
-0.3793438971042633,
0.13453352451324463,
-0.03684781491756439,
-0.5919871926307678,
0.025195050984621048,
0.07353218644857407,
-0.5479853749275208,
0.3258134722709656,
0.2278631627559662,
0.9463946223258972,
0.21146979928016663,
-0.3881521224975586,
0.6256361603736877,
-0.2913851737976074,
-0.42679542303085327,
-0.1786981076002121,
0.0008237339789047837,
-0.0819411501288414,
-0.07026074826717377,
-0.2374877631664276,
0.2505960464477539,
0.15143316984176636,
-0.009688588790595531,
0.18619205057621002,
0.45766621828079224,
-0.7645345330238342,
-0.3359590172767639,
0.6858528256416321,
0.19751882553100586,
-0.39778995513916016,
0.6078630685806274,
-0.505565345287323,
-0.34505394101142883,
0.4522666037082672,
0.6568470001220703,
0.7978709936141968,
-0.04321213811635971,
0.4463344216346741,
0.4272482395172119,
0.4761456847190857,
-0.18799477815628052,
0.1643587350845337,
-0.26270878314971924,
-0.7746225595474243,
-0.29547181725502014,
-0.8758147954940796,
-0.39176294207572937,
0.33869004249572754,
-0.6094957590103149,
0.20424456894397736,
-0.39653828740119934,
0.16092944145202637,
-0.17080973088741302,
0.03472872078418732,
-0.9719783067703247,
0.2554221749305725,
0.3105182945728302,
0.8359321355819702,
-0.9111448526382446,
0.7279255390167236,
0.4037615954875946,
-0.3248501718044281,
-1.0227552652359009,
-0.1943531334400177,
0.04094637930393219,
-0.3597947359085083,
0.6377552151679993,
0.13515812158584595,
0.0773877501487732,
-0.23048017919063568,
-0.4817911386489868,
-1.0643795728683472,
0.7681220173835754,
0.5079954266548157,
-0.44470950961112976,
0.25446975231170654,
0.08774091303348541,
0.6711650490760803,
-0.16485294699668884,
0.18457244336605072,
0.3058904707431793,
0.3836138844490051,
0.0573439747095108,
-0.704506516456604,
-0.23575368523597717,
-0.34546035528182983,
0.061740580946207047,
-0.17461521923542023,
-0.6783674955368042,
0.6790843605995178,
0.03809240087866783,
-0.17496980726718903,
-0.16560205817222595,
0.8040691614151001,
0.0537705235183239,
0.07779373973608017,
0.553236722946167,
0.6300355792045593,
1.217482566833496,
-0.030025238171219826,
1.2234947681427002,
-0.12863565981388092,
-0.1392950713634491,
1.3419485092163086,
-0.03719841316342354,
0.46267595887184143,
0.2675102949142456,
0.14333607256412506,
0.43485891819000244,
0.5313498377799988,
0.017585737630724907,
0.6918796896934509,
0.13336068391799927,
-0.04842574521899223,
-0.46244320273399353,
-0.16975907981395721,
-0.33065876364707947,
0.5285098552703857,
0.3197736442089081,
-0.3058532476425171,
-0.17783328890800476,
-0.16512040793895721,
-0.10521102696657181,
-0.030651621520519257,
-0.04110473021864891,
1.1244287490844727,
0.019183622673153877,
-0.41154584288597107,
0.4628649055957794,
-0.22443532943725586,
0.6315881609916687,
-0.6334002017974854,
0.24009883403778076,
-0.27064764499664307,
0.1332029104232788,
-0.2546437084674835,
-0.2313171923160553,
0.2511591911315918,
-0.08417639881372452,
-0.21209381520748138,
-0.43853962421417236,
0.8206973075866699,
-0.3735511302947998,
-0.7668361067771912,
0.024383751675486565,
0.6475412249565125,
0.27391356229782104,
-0.1961071491241455,
-0.3903447091579437,
0.16839690506458282,
-0.08480450510978699,
-0.24864979088306427,
0.612966001033783,
0.8645089864730835,
-0.08695226907730103,
0.576250433921814,
0.7443405389785767,
0.44750910997390747,
0.2446766495704651,
0.18606184422969818,
0.8735440969467163,
-0.0589272603392601,
-0.7508192658424377,
-0.4822307527065277,
0.4255676865577698,
-0.36667701601982117,
-0.27660396695137024,
0.6759198307991028,
0.8040516972541809,
0.8406035900115967,
-0.042524758726358414,
0.7933269143104553,
0.3374910056591034,
0.27139800786972046,
-0.3576146960258484,
0.700546383857727,
-0.37076762318611145,
0.41444143652915955,
-0.6410208940505981,
-1.0326088666915894,
-0.16176368296146393,
0.8501386642456055,
-0.2632526755332947,
-0.10495775938034058,
0.5316876769065857,
0.8767739534378052,
-0.453896164894104,
-0.09853284060955048,
0.3662091791629791,
0.1079045906662941,
0.4376715421676636,
-0.04583193361759186,
0.6465542316436768,
-0.39026132225990295,
0.9104315638542175,
-0.650291919708252,
0.02130604162812233,
-0.07588593661785126,
-0.8284063935279846,
-0.8690223097801208,
-0.46525776386260986,
-0.8748413920402527,
-0.3255535066127777,
-0.06601199507713318,
0.3639318346977234,
1.156911849975586,
-0.6445017457008362,
0.00004085907494300045,
-0.22607474029064178,
0.307389497756958,
-0.4910763204097748,
-0.2656806707382202,
0.67188560962677,
-0.3425599932670593,
-0.5969062447547913,
0.30739083886146545,
0.28779128193855286,
0.22893556952476501,
-0.192533478140831,
-0.04574268311262131,
-0.08988400548696518,
-0.027906006202101707,
0.2523743808269501,
0.46945714950561523,
-0.1594090312719345,
-0.15088579058647156,
-0.3330937922000885,
-0.25767335295677185,
0.3508549630641937,
0.3879896104335785,
-0.6523126363754272,
0.8427708745002747,
0.5055556297302246,
0.7736027836799622,
0.717085599899292,
0.2487836629152298,
0.34809425473213196,
-1.2254555225372314,
0.5026909708976746,
-0.10397416353225708,
0.3910304605960846,
0.6300540566444397,
-0.5607789754867554,
0.5703108310699463,
0.2944386601448059,
-0.30678364634513855,
-0.7725771069526672,
-0.07891878485679626,
-1.0711532831192017,
-0.06722796708345413,
1.2174100875854492,
-0.11212588101625443,
-0.406726598739624,
-0.38806864619255066,
-0.27268534898757935,
0.14081712067127228,
-0.38452398777008057,
0.9841992259025574,
0.4526853561401367,
0.16477027535438538,
-0.23384220898151398,
-0.37401723861694336,
0.6400439143180847,
0.1366220861673355,
-0.8380092978477478,
-0.01992977410554886,
0.40442898869514465,
0.09757101535797119,
0.5972240567207336,
0.852679431438446,
-0.2663610279560089,
0.1841651350259781,
0.3596615493297577,
0.20139513909816742,
-0.3473778963088989,
-0.5101643800735474,
-0.24471363425254822,
0.2503427267074585,
-0.1523689478635788,
-0.2532491385936737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00486v1
|
Dialectical Alignment: Resolving the Tension of 3H and Security Threats of LLMs
| 2024-03-30T22:41:05 | 2024-03-30T22:41:05 |
Shu Yang, Jiayuan Su, Han Jiang, Mengdi Li, Keyuan Cheng, Muhammad Asif Ali, Lijie Hu, Di Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rise of large language models (LLMs), ensuring they embody the
principles of being helpful, honest, and harmless (3H), known as Human
Alignment, becomes crucial. While existing alignment methods like RLHF, DPO,
etc., effectively fine-tune LLMs to match preferences in the preference
dataset, they often lead LLMs to highly receptive human input and external
evidence, even when this information is poisoned. This leads to a tendency for
LLMs to be Adaptive Chameleons when external evidence conflicts with their
parametric memory. This exacerbates the risk of LLM being attacked by external
poisoned data, which poses a significant security risk to LLM system
applications such as Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). To address the
challenge, we propose a novel framework: Dialectical Alignment (DA), which (1)
utilizes AI feedback to identify optimal strategies for LLMs to navigate
inter-context conflicts and context-memory conflicts with different external
evidence in context window (i.e., different ratios of poisoned factual
contexts); (2) constructs the SFT dataset as well as the preference dataset
based on the AI feedback and strategies above; (3) uses the above datasets for
LLM alignment to defense poisoned context attack while preserving the
effectiveness of in-context knowledge editing. Our experiments show that the
dialectical alignment model improves poisoned data attack defense by 20 and
does not require any additional prompt engineering or prior declaration of
``you may be attacked`` to the LLMs' context window.
|
[
-0.23722606897354126,
-0.7482970952987671,
0.535116970539093,
-0.18154922127723694,
-0.09671711176633835,
0.02906010113656521,
-0.12751053273677826,
-0.3798532485961914,
0.12934257090091705,
0.7256984114646912,
-0.44798386096954346,
-0.21188472211360931,
-0.34508416056632996,
0.08474811911582947,
-0.20096924901008606,
1.005299687385559,
0.17028848826885223,
0.10266348719596863,
-0.020281754434108734,
-0.13163138926029205,
-0.7151095271110535,
-0.5694499015808105,
-0.343174546957016,
-0.3467939496040344,
0.46645456552505493,
0.5700361132621765,
0.9715091586112976,
0.8948912024497986,
0.6555992364883423,
0.3596750497817993,
0.04970519244670868,
-0.03492865711450577,
-0.434438556432724,
0.5543486475944519,
-0.5261774063110352,
-0.47901469469070435,
-0.6316779851913452,
-0.16749490797519684,
0.2058664858341217,
0.4327313005924225,
-0.33412471413612366,
-0.10189195722341537,
0.18111294507980347,
0.9924084544181824,
-0.5538323521614075,
-0.2878895103931427,
-1.1506919860839844,
-0.16654513776302338,
-0.6028088331222534,
-0.07512664794921875,
-0.3232618272304535,
-0.23653943836688995,
0.2597406804561615,
-0.619903564453125,
-0.06856719404459,
0.26685649156570435,
0.8746461272239685,
0.30948731303215027,
-0.38785216212272644,
-0.05785570293664932,
-0.3888917863368988,
0.4949716627597809,
-0.7536081671714783,
0.23687398433685303,
0.154680997133255,
0.34848180413246155,
-0.4432160556316376,
-0.3493090569972992,
-0.7343889474868774,
0.16252410411834717,
0.03958015888929367,
0.045884761959314346,
-0.08082355558872223,
0.17867392301559448,
0.024407729506492615,
-0.03898243606090546,
-0.6183414459228516,
0.14631080627441406,
-0.234117791056633,
-0.27525490522384644,
0.5155912041664124,
0.4340539574623108,
0.3086194396018982,
-0.19030989706516266,
-0.49110597372055054,
0.05406389757990837,
-0.9365875720977783,
-0.3870450258255005,
0.48170384764671326,
0.5593869090080261,
-0.10916529595851898,
0.5270829200744629,
-0.05183018371462822,
0.8660314679145813,
0.38943353295326233,
-0.043563831597566605,
-0.1323501169681549,
-0.2889528274536133,
-0.021898122504353523,
0.3129565119743347,
0.8035641312599182,
0.8404021263122559,
0.22008314728736877,
-0.1441013365983963,
-0.10674325376749039,
-0.01638898253440857,
0.6876447200775146,
-0.6272017359733582,
-0.12946034967899323,
0.38893651962280273,
-0.16496498882770538,
-0.5386098027229309,
0.09768117219209671,
-1.14566969871521,
-0.9479823112487793,
-0.31982460618019104,
0.42333731055259705,
-0.5908932089805603,
-0.054006028920412064,
0.007062648888677359,
0.01093631237745285,
0.23942705988883972,
0.33072447776794434,
-1.1016968488693237,
0.3315248489379883,
1.0842965841293335,
0.7667913436889648,
-0.12006103992462158,
-0.281052827835083,
-0.3675103783607483,
0.47119569778442383,
-0.3836449086666107,
0.4550175964832306,
-0.4254276156425476,
-0.15238860249519348,
-0.01540539413690567,
-0.2315288484096527,
-0.0016425058711320162,
-0.6412342190742493,
0.4107959270477295,
-0.7319220304489136,
0.4010764956474304,
-0.3622117340564728,
-0.49808305501937866,
-0.21389509737491608,
0.4126914143562317,
-0.638821542263031,
0.7029510140419006,
-0.020053237676620483,
-1.0578422546386719,
-0.016771910712122917,
-0.1791919469833374,
-0.2040589153766632,
0.011252978816628456,
-0.21872732043266296,
-0.46318620443344116,
-0.056646376848220825,
0.15475746989250183,
0.2614222466945648,
-0.36174535751342773,
0.39806127548217773,
-0.5615397691726685,
-0.29015377163887024,
0.4390876293182373,
-0.11960095912218094,
0.8391268253326416,
0.3184736967086792,
-0.5341441631317139,
0.13995279371738434,
-0.5095838308334351,
-0.22309255599975586,
0.15308864414691925,
0.045391593128442764,
-0.3775944411754608,
0.2623762786388397,
-0.3552040159702301,
0.06025701016187668,
0.40475568175315857,
-0.3157019019126892,
0.18935473263263702,
-0.5916697382926941,
0.2594113349914551,
1.1853312253952026,
0.1897278130054474,
0.5992943644523621,
-0.7622816562652588,
0.47088760137557983,
0.14384788274765015,
0.11372996121644974,
-0.07002019882202148,
-0.2866435647010803,
-0.5630999207496643,
-0.06842010468244553,
0.14335739612579346,
0.7682281136512756,
-0.6392733454704285,
0.6640118360519409,
-0.5178117156028748,
-0.30623602867126465,
-0.48855793476104736,
0.2748654782772064,
0.22624260187149048,
0.9229877591133118,
0.22439727187156677,
-0.28370004892349243,
-0.5575760006904602,
-0.9005661010742188,
-0.38775312900543213,
-0.4593867063522339,
0.10284199565649033,
0.231066033244133,
0.1612752377986908,
-0.22595973312854767,
1.064117670059204,
-0.33879324793815613,
-0.12336844205856323,
-0.017809592187404633,
-0.2218414843082428,
0.1970924288034439,
0.4053058624267578,
0.40475988388061523,
-0.5333418250083923,
-0.4446623623371124,
0.1509190946817398,
-0.7314082980155945,
-0.47317302227020264,
-0.1635410040616989,
-0.37548014521598816,
0.17583373188972473,
0.34797853231430054,
-0.3971203565597534,
-0.06485427170991898,
0.311320424079895,
-0.21524225175380707,
0.3779633641242981,
0.40588292479515076,
0.015075490809977055,
-1.2853659391403198,
0.07023072987794876,
-0.14317743480205536,
-0.24212999641895294,
-0.9888972043991089,
0.2536395788192749,
0.2445710450410843,
-0.07914028316736221,
-0.3671194016933441,
0.6551088690757751,
-0.2909298241138458,
0.393449604511261,
-0.16023696959018707,
0.33566468954086304,
0.04034176841378212,
0.3293394148349762,
-0.07069139182567596,
0.6985461115837097,
0.34644028544425964,
-0.3050435781478882,
0.42325615882873535,
0.12982192635536194,
0.011754763312637806,
1.0844331979751587,
-0.37003594636917114,
0.3383522033691406,
-0.013746310025453568,
0.10497933626174927,
-0.6797340512275696,
-0.4070764183998108,
0.6607019901275635,
-0.310288667678833,
0.5003607869148254,
-0.053654592484235764,
-0.11210889369249344,
0.12022285908460617,
-0.6776314377784729,
0.433315247297287,
0.18227513134479523,
-0.525542676448822,
0.5882331132888794,
0.4082966148853302,
-0.40363937616348267,
-0.9416704773902893,
-0.4844311773777008,
0.35507869720458984,
-0.7760372161865234,
-0.7079471349716187,
0.4426897168159485,
0.09974432736635208,
-0.6797731518745422,
-0.09297996014356613,
-0.23408229649066925,
0.22967027127742767,
0.2063455581665039,
0.1985127180814743,
0.5842880010604858,
-0.11727549880743027,
-0.3224925994873047,
-0.3606150448322296,
0.00617692805826664,
0.10420281440019608,
-0.19431954622268677,
0.31925633549690247,
0.030094368383288383,
-0.3349283039569855,
-0.40600576996803284,
0.3615362346172333,
0.5606580972671509,
0.19632455706596375,
0.5968269109725952,
0.0700531005859375,
-0.34883686900138855,
-0.01090758666396141,
-0.6457902789115906,
-0.28279349207878113,
-0.5459855794906616,
0.2804403305053711,
-0.10355708003044128,
-0.7125047445297241,
0.45720723271369934,
0.09961447864770889,
-0.03325030952692032,
0.13004666566848755,
0.5339028239250183,
-0.18020105361938477,
0.6887714862823486,
0.3744576573371887,
-0.6375129222869873,
0.493849515914917,
0.4307466149330139,
0.2830975651741028,
-0.9384425282478333,
-0.10939125716686249,
-0.43489503860473633,
-0.31787338852882385,
-0.536550760269165,
-0.10623709857463837,
0.6215813755989075,
0.13697464764118195,
-0.5397065877914429,
0.35368233919143677,
-0.5762150883674622,
0.48792681097984314,
0.27664297819137573,
0.26652926206588745,
0.014684845693409443,
-0.10366874188184738,
-0.1104663759469986,
-0.19481602311134338,
-0.5649674534797668,
-0.6005189418792725,
1.1628954410552979,
0.46170133352279663,
0.8709482550621033,
0.6588932871818542,
0.8452646732330322,
0.2194642722606659,
0.2193892002105713,
-0.599652111530304,
0.6260268092155457,
0.3701930642127991,
-0.675094723701477,
-0.10756109654903412,
-0.3794901669025421,
-0.9881267547607422,
0.23071050643920898,
-0.13769912719726562,
-0.9872923493385315,
0.1319005787372589,
0.13937389850616455,
-0.44745537638664246,
0.1297769397497177,
-0.5764213800430298,
0.7232427000999451,
-0.47876113653182983,
-0.6530476212501526,
-0.02350296452641487,
-1.001831293106079,
0.5950402021408081,
-0.3205488622188568,
0.18749122321605682,
-0.10895120352506638,
-0.23640652000904083,
0.5700814723968506,
-0.5733044743537903,
1.0344719886779785,
-0.11853744834661484,
-0.16995234787464142,
0.02025611698627472,
0.3926677405834198,
0.6429058909416199,
-0.0898185446858406,
-0.19601988792419434,
0.13574160635471344,
-0.02308354154229164,
-0.28648948669433594,
-0.5952134132385254,
0.5952938795089722,
-0.6783372759819031,
-1.1842254400253296,
-0.6671130061149597,
-0.41822466254234314,
-0.3059921860694885,
0.20114801824092865,
0.24243943393230438,
0.02955491654574871,
-0.31166160106658936,
-0.06766805797815323,
0.7338107228279114,
-0.004048739559948444,
0.2620326578617096,
0.5020447373390198,
-0.056386325508356094,
-0.7553117275238037,
0.9641610383987427,
-0.08023811131715775,
0.3884461224079132,
0.34581056237220764,
0.22055193781852722,
-0.21404698491096497,
-0.45690351724624634,
-0.5292826294898987,
0.17279963195323944,
-0.6348693370819092,
-0.6834380626678467,
-0.33769407868385315,
-0.1470097154378891,
-0.5358095765113831,
-0.380146861076355,
-0.14125779271125793,
-0.3873884975910187,
-0.20512454211711884,
0.14482879638671875,
0.3687494099140167,
0.5437447428703308,
-0.028468381613492966,
0.4263063073158264,
-0.6710708737373352,
0.1775582730770111,
0.2244834154844284,
-0.007604117970913649,
-0.17249926924705505,
-0.6378060579299927,
-0.09476720541715622,
-0.10200025141239166,
-0.6595548391342163,
-1.5763403177261353,
0.2300332635641098,
-0.01879124343395233,
0.3138413727283478,
0.6175280213356018,
0.13009034097194672,
0.5933720469474792,
-0.5138207077980042,
0.8855223059654236,
0.10052963346242905,
-1.038845419883728,
0.41720643639564514,
-0.6833360195159912,
-0.02213164046406746,
0.7027593851089478,
0.24559976160526276,
-0.7692536115646362,
-0.26132017374038696,
-0.5096310973167419,
-0.9446301460266113,
0.6730756759643555,
-0.035736922174692154,
-0.006965502630919218,
0.09321679174900055,
0.4972206950187683,
-0.09093232452869415,
0.173089861869812,
-0.7672267556190491,
-0.07692578434944153,
-0.22135592997074127,
-0.5846422910690308,
0.37849345803260803,
-0.18316136300563812,
-0.7115556001663208,
-0.01393167581409216,
0.8265150785446167,
-0.20724806189537048,
0.091920867562294,
-0.037025388330221176,
0.09492543339729309,
-0.088279590010643,
0.39963439106941223,
0.46059292554855347,
0.3159591853618622,
-0.13375899195671082,
0.39146438241004944,
0.19412226974964142,
-0.35389772057533264,
0.4832649528980255,
0.11365896463394165,
-0.2343737781047821,
-0.435346782207489,
0.4587511122226715,
0.26217377185821533,
0.0296871829777956,
-0.546305239200592,
0.6541764140129089,
0.13307811319828033,
0.18955300748348236,
-0.06260249763727188,
0.21530850231647491,
0.023760326206684113,
0.16165122389793396,
-0.013075795955955982,
-0.0730910673737526,
-0.007253400515764952,
-0.48421117663383484,
0.21653297543525696,
0.7388787269592285,
-0.15657590329647064,
-0.29732128977775574,
0.6330094337463379,
0.24946485459804535,
-0.3133466839790344,
0.49824368953704834,
0.12673504650592804,
-0.8347794413566589,
0.29704996943473816,
0.5713236331939697,
0.8930427432060242,
-0.5316632390022278,
-0.14283905923366547,
0.13751652836799622,
0.37946927547454834,
-0.03352712094783783,
0.14478667080402374,
-0.0524471290409565,
-1.0574841499328613,
0.2345518320798874,
-0.3069743812084198,
-0.5624971985816956,
0.1350882351398468,
-0.6624615788459778,
0.2646936774253845,
-0.5469800233840942,
-0.13016384840011597,
-0.18996992707252502,
-0.05050170049071312,
-0.1068718358874321,
-0.15756824612617493,
0.048636455088853836,
0.6470993757247925,
-0.6887791752815247,
0.8843043446540833,
0.3160386383533478,
-0.1631494015455246,
-0.5407869815826416,
0.3135249614715576,
0.8377555012702942,
-0.79148268699646,
0.16095195710659027,
0.08394884318113327,
-0.1514204740524292,
-0.39648640155792236,
-0.44121313095092773,
-0.8359431028366089,
0.8959622383117676,
0.6479596495628357,
-0.7472336292266846,
0.12691636383533478,
0.27549469470977783,
0.3929688632488251,
-0.2318614274263382,
-0.1359766572713852,
0.7776316404342651,
0.5494381189346313,
-0.17752595245838165,
-0.6696159243583679,
0.3255821466445923,
-0.3050103783607483,
-0.09126032888889313,
0.3384683430194855,
-0.7758042812347412,
0.42001134157180786,
-0.0486215204000473,
-0.25536659359931946,
0.10843373090028763,
0.49217483401298523,
0.3359392285346985,
0.21346750855445862,
0.45541462302207947,
0.7003869414329529,
0.7784780859947205,
-0.06312970817089081,
0.629385769367218,
-0.5290044546127319,
-0.3115023970603943,
1.287203311920166,
-0.7611945867538452,
0.7048559188842773,
0.600460946559906,
-0.00018587311205919832,
0.45033326745033264,
0.7418026924133301,
0.07608901709318161,
0.4634598195552826,
0.1603657454252243,
-0.39843958616256714,
0.2135755568742752,
-0.035158682614564896,
-0.4139719009399414,
0.26992055773735046,
0.4316704571247101,
-0.09188519418239594,
0.0012592073762789369,
-0.5074195861816406,
0.40409666299819946,
0.3334035277366638,
0.18757572770118713,
1.0526092052459717,
-0.08645962923765182,
-0.9634170532226562,
0.5396286249160767,
0.05091143772006035,
0.5449233055114746,
-0.504002034664154,
0.2963143289089203,
-0.28125879168510437,
0.07308927923440933,
-0.29256996512413025,
-0.6894831657409668,
0.39516085386276245,
0.02707860618829727,
-0.11946137994527817,
0.010380499064922333,
0.5250957012176514,
-0.4363120198249817,
0.025831378996372223,
0.26647353172302246,
0.2679974138736725,
-0.259418785572052,
0.042765673249959946,
-0.80450040102005,
0.22888265550136566,
0.05325959622859955,
-0.19709455966949463,
0.46640685200691223,
0.4971161484718323,
-0.07166562229394913,
0.4229932725429535,
0.3836022913455963,
0.3445468842983246,
-0.08870159089565277,
-0.185304194688797,
0.9927994608879089,
-0.7055058479309082,
-0.32906684279441833,
-1.2457548379898071,
0.20038899779319763,
-0.2630951404571533,
-0.0046793995425105095,
0.7849973440170288,
0.5041245222091675,
0.6298967003822327,
0.47370925545692444,
0.7438552379608154,
0.061777856200933456,
0.32823511958122253,
-0.6537035703659058,
0.5069547295570374,
-0.3210562765598297,
0.6058160066604614,
-0.35434049367904663,
-0.735866129398346,
-0.2458433210849762,
0.3820386528968811,
-0.1630282998085022,
-0.13592323660850525,
0.6248412132263184,
1.2832359075546265,
0.0738164559006691,
0.15236294269561768,
-0.07262241840362549,
0.23477129638195038,
0.34386396408081055,
0.5727235078811646,
0.8101571202278137,
-0.18582062423229218,
0.19113102555274963,
-0.2273138463497162,
-0.2353551834821701,
-0.07100298255681992,
-0.948059618473053,
-0.6730465292930603,
-0.6100649833679199,
-0.07152577489614487,
-0.614212691783905,
0.1831466555595398,
0.9993016123771667,
0.5866814255714417,
-0.6413145065307617,
-0.34013092517852783,
0.01701309345662594,
0.22679544985294342,
-0.22700098156929016,
-0.25896549224853516,
0.13852491974830627,
-0.27154025435447693,
-0.46114984154701233,
0.5332362055778503,
0.3712144196033478,
0.1364338994026184,
-0.1475117802619934,
-0.1577761471271515,
-0.03412313386797905,
0.3274143934249878,
0.04048096388578415,
0.36687564849853516,
-0.8443969488143921,
-0.4193284511566162,
-0.243886798620224,
-0.3309406340122223,
0.10338207334280014,
0.7105412483215332,
-0.41880014538764954,
0.6342144012451172,
0.5233598947525024,
0.8907472491264343,
-0.1360221952199936,
0.40492552518844604,
0.9148843288421631,
-0.7319914698600769,
0.12124248594045639,
0.2535928785800934,
0.420806348323822,
0.4698275923728943,
-0.7759330868721008,
0.5218461751937866,
0.2569165825843811,
-0.6872002482414246,
-0.8721237182617188,
0.3463112711906433,
-0.9502488970756531,
-0.39093488454818726,
1.0192996263504028,
0.14277417957782745,
-0.3014574646949768,
-0.21388986706733704,
-0.24959751963615417,
0.06359325349330902,
-0.36400747299194336,
1.157788634300232,
0.8171841502189636,
-0.23554207384586334,
0.1966601014137268,
-0.23516424000263214,
0.6891281008720398,
0.6292433738708496,
-0.7829617261886597,
0.3997752070426941,
0.6511340141296387,
0.18693050742149353,
0.12160592526197433,
0.5268594622612,
-0.19044707715511322,
0.14441075921058655,
-0.18580840528011322,
-0.09140289574861526,
0.19407959282398224,
-0.35909754037857056,
-0.6511969566345215,
0.22834184765815735,
0.0762995108962059,
-0.039597660303115845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00484v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00484v1
|
Edinburgh Clinical NLP at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Fine-tune your model unless you have access to GPT-4
| 2024-03-30T22:27:21 | 2024-03-30T22:27:21 |
Aryo Pradipta Gema, Giwon Hong, Pasquale Minervini, Luke Daines, Beatrice Alex
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The NLI4CT task assesses Natural Language Inference systems in predicting
whether hypotheses entail or contradict evidence from Clinical Trial Reports.
In this study, we evaluate various Large Language Models (LLMs) with multiple
strategies, including Chain-of-Thought, In-Context Learning, and
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT). We propose a PEFT method to improve the
consistency of LLMs by merging adapters that were fine-tuned separately using
triplet and language modelling objectives. We found that merging the two PEFT
adapters improves the F1 score (+0.0346) and consistency (+0.152) of the LLMs.
However, our novel methods did not produce more accurate results than GPT-4 in
terms of faithfulness and consistency. Averaging the three metrics, GPT-4 ranks
joint-first in the competition with 0.8328. Finally, our contamination analysis
with GPT-4 indicates that there was no test data leakage.
|
[
-0.03451170772314072,
-0.6233394742012024,
0.8477581739425659,
0.11060787737369537,
-0.19941382110118866,
-0.04611573368310928,
-0.2961549162864685,
-0.5273932814598083,
0.04334414377808571,
0.6814641356468201,
-0.16832490265369415,
-0.36547622084617615,
-0.8110822439193726,
0.3687378466129303,
-0.1846148669719696,
1.0497397184371948,
-0.37914928793907166,
0.3196054995059967,
0.18196724355220795,
-0.25655031204223633,
-0.5822794437408447,
-0.36563244462013245,
-0.7563061118125916,
-0.41527822613716125,
0.4737330675125122,
0.4299316704273224,
0.6425582766532898,
0.39953845739364624,
0.8985419869422913,
0.20541797578334808,
-0.19240635633468628,
0.25112831592559814,
-0.3729553818702698,
-0.008985101245343685,
-0.3937629163265228,
-0.3858516216278076,
-0.7964630722999573,
-0.005228884518146515,
0.41360780596733093,
0.7683765292167664,
-0.3197927176952362,
-0.22132523357868195,
0.3365830183029175,
0.4653778076171875,
-0.48496466875076294,
0.1609288454055786,
-0.6425579786300659,
-0.06301360577344894,
-0.15504190325737,
-0.28890055418014526,
-0.23872904479503632,
-0.24466398358345032,
0.27664679288864136,
-0.4856465756893158,
0.22243475914001465,
0.10406594723463058,
0.960155189037323,
0.25840452313423157,
-0.49501174688339233,
-0.328807532787323,
-0.4713885188102722,
0.7057428359985352,
-1.1696139574050903,
0.2625087797641754,
0.6852654218673706,
0.002833453705534339,
-0.21278901398181915,
-0.7697679996490479,
-0.37976863980293274,
-0.12375843524932861,
-0.12606088817119598,
0.05102052167057991,
-0.0012504354817792773,
0.385312557220459,
0.20354223251342773,
0.19754131138324738,
-0.4945274293422699,
0.05585068464279175,
-0.44811123609542847,
-0.2661777138710022,
0.48691725730895996,
0.0830363929271698,
0.15798039734363556,
0.020658014342188835,
-0.24192018806934357,
0.15290673077106476,
-0.9115949869155884,
-0.32810771465301514,
0.12345322221517563,
0.2856357991695404,
0.02305150218307972,
0.5453816056251526,
0.017742890864610672,
0.5289120078086853,
0.23577800393104553,
-0.14295172691345215,
0.4357660710811615,
-0.6607535481452942,
-0.24285779893398285,
-0.08314286172389984,
0.874657928943634,
0.4902380406856537,
0.07855572551488876,
-0.19352637231349945,
-0.17326954007148743,
-0.00018124478810932487,
0.3166387677192688,
-0.5206576585769653,
-0.46673086285591125,
0.23962785303592682,
-0.2633802592754364,
-0.3471643924713135,
-0.33847156167030334,
-0.45903727412223816,
-0.0008837395580485463,
-0.3595430850982666,
0.7960728406906128,
-0.6686460971832275,
-0.13482140004634857,
0.40708422660827637,
-0.013780433684587479,
0.03822588920593262,
0.3850933611392975,
-1.0633621215820312,
0.41523510217666626,
0.6633504033088684,
0.6612548828125,
-0.2805441915988922,
-0.4026837646961212,
-0.586599588394165,
0.20989656448364258,
-0.38445281982421875,
0.7656887769699097,
-0.3977927565574646,
-0.16046561300754547,
-0.12760576605796814,
0.3030521869659424,
-0.25126221776008606,
-0.476048082113266,
1.003771424293518,
-0.15867674350738525,
0.5276494026184082,
-0.47567203640937805,
-0.7398996353149414,
-0.017634738236665726,
0.3589017689228058,
-0.41304850578308105,
0.82640141248703,
0.1439037024974823,
-0.75422203540802,
0.5472020506858826,
-0.5805062055587769,
-0.37025776505470276,
0.20803135633468628,
-0.2690590023994446,
-0.4651390314102173,
0.0926160141825676,
0.46445098519325256,
0.48450878262519836,
0.004397942218929529,
0.6000211834907532,
-0.47826576232910156,
-0.3137803375720978,
-0.19974102079868317,
-0.3328465223312378,
0.35567429661750793,
0.07110622525215149,
-0.46943774819374084,
-0.11399032175540924,
-0.5750352740287781,
0.005132966209203005,
-0.1178039088845253,
-0.4091077744960785,
-0.22274255752563477,
-0.17510907351970673,
-0.08603549748659134,
0.11742497980594635,
0.16650645434856415,
-0.5359140038490295,
0.21556217968463898,
-0.6462550759315491,
0.6873549222946167,
0.5687283873558044,
0.10601553320884705,
0.1472010761499405,
-0.4972166121006012,
0.4256199300289154,
0.009000609628856182,
0.09048952162265778,
0.02996021881699562,
-0.6398761868476868,
-0.5591537356376648,
-0.02533121034502983,
0.5900681018829346,
0.1973414272069931,
-0.7676296830177307,
0.339973509311676,
-0.15688036382198334,
-0.23204287886619568,
-0.4240368902683258,
0.013281113468110561,
0.43542563915252686,
0.44901639223098755,
0.503131091594696,
-0.2801996171474457,
-0.39470091462135315,
-1.021360993385315,
-0.5167680382728577,
-0.06731318682432175,
-0.04839833080768585,
0.23309017717838287,
0.6480712890625,
-0.3484461307525635,
0.5118051767349243,
-0.06576801091432571,
-0.2993198335170746,
-0.07915337383747101,
0.23488613963127136,
0.24145899713039398,
0.5277547240257263,
0.3379589319229126,
-0.4525439143180847,
-0.4704529345035553,
0.07511496543884277,
-0.5582579970359802,
-0.23801007866859436,
0.12162469327449799,
0.07360593229532242,
0.11020869016647339,
0.3692135214805603,
-0.25229746103286743,
0.32365351915359497,
0.7505083084106445,
-0.4139220118522644,
0.3172243535518646,
-0.5152028203010559,
0.37739646434783936,
-0.824224054813385,
-0.07726505398750305,
-0.14465579390525818,
-0.43823546171188354,
-0.6109557747840881,
-0.004371298477053642,
0.29092028737068176,
0.17448511719703674,
-0.25270572304725647,
0.34151169657707214,
-0.31106287240982056,
0.35210758447647095,
-0.2577582895755768,
0.028221623972058296,
0.1888245791196823,
0.3084999620914459,
-0.08337177336215973,
0.6720606088638306,
0.34600019454956055,
-0.2712908983230591,
-0.18799100816249847,
0.3736461102962494,
-0.0009000154095701873,
0.20437252521514893,
-0.6715995073318481,
0.17991633713245392,
0.20722216367721558,
0.11435724794864655,
-0.9909803867340088,
-0.33911728858947754,
-0.11381977051496506,
-0.17140434682369232,
0.36655235290527344,
0.019187532365322113,
-0.3587821424007416,
-0.20990292727947235,
-0.2452118694782257,
0.37795552611351013,
0.265511691570282,
-0.4611237943172455,
0.5370874404907227,
0.32799386978149414,
-0.40825068950653076,
-0.38711878657341003,
-0.6746722459793091,
0.14041781425476074,
-0.27039751410484314,
-0.5760682225227356,
0.5709613561630249,
-0.013074683956801891,
0.05622759833931923,
-0.19381991028785706,
-0.19971734285354614,
-0.013248867355287075,
-0.1498667299747467,
-0.010307160206139088,
0.058533500880002975,
-0.24037495255470276,
0.03517764434218407,
0.25963613390922546,
0.08721043169498444,
0.03213569149374962,
0.03080815076828003,
0.38762059807777405,
-0.3200101852416992,
-0.43526721000671387,
-0.6280161142349243,
0.17816844582557678,
0.5408068299293518,
0.1299004852771759,
0.5067015886306763,
0.3124348521232605,
-0.47509798407554626,
0.11949414759874344,
-0.7668898105621338,
-0.21112515032291412,
-0.4670845568180084,
0.07583615928888321,
-0.3805897831916809,
-1.092266321182251,
0.28610679507255554,
-0.13609327375888824,
0.036619167774915695,
0.5725619196891785,
0.578525960445404,
-0.14669311046600342,
0.9725537300109863,
0.4600816071033478,
0.2508407533168793,
0.09541746228933334,
0.029165787622332573,
0.3951409161090851,
-0.8907473087310791,
0.007664460223168135,
-0.33067816495895386,
-0.09248501062393188,
-0.5647498965263367,
-0.2517828047275543,
0.5328351855278015,
0.18732444941997528,
-0.24678929150104523,
0.4047960937023163,
-0.4532770812511444,
0.43746569752693176,
0.28855547308921814,
0.30258846282958984,
0.3296692967414856,
-0.18194125592708588,
-0.3503674864768982,
-0.20877531170845032,
-0.7535247206687927,
-0.5296992063522339,
1.4642901420593262,
0.47790345549583435,
0.4171050190925598,
0.22765883803367615,
0.7204880714416504,
-0.11096243560314178,
0.20767082273960114,
-0.35993215441703796,
0.2359173595905304,
-0.1444558948278427,
-0.6213299632072449,
-0.2294292151927948,
-0.26215559244155884,
-0.9513096213340759,
0.19167418777942657,
-0.14982496201992035,
-0.6751294136047363,
0.12439769506454468,
0.15723612904548645,
-0.6278404593467712,
0.04497966542840004,
-0.7327815294265747,
0.7265841364860535,
-0.27271878719329834,
-0.4937206208705902,
0.02957141399383545,
-0.6265212893486023,
0.3984624445438385,
-0.48798543214797974,
0.20037789642810822,
-0.2350652813911438,
-0.08479417115449905,
0.6644241809844971,
-0.4246383607387543,
0.569905161857605,
0.10297536849975586,
-0.1489723175764084,
-0.133671835064888,
-0.034177325665950775,
0.6090651750564575,
0.1300797462463379,
-0.09386590868234634,
0.29861563444137573,
0.6150332093238831,
-0.4068969786167145,
-0.4083610773086548,
0.6147726774215698,
-0.6987262964248657,
-0.45304208993911743,
-0.4455435276031494,
-0.31076478958129883,
-0.46044206619262695,
0.2906763255596161,
0.4272347688674927,
0.49346867203712463,
-0.16882026195526123,
0.2283017933368683,
0.41616958379745483,
-0.3002704977989197,
0.1694084256887436,
0.5891274809837341,
0.0009244015673175454,
-0.3595815598964691,
0.3311830461025238,
-0.10833580046892166,
0.5574968457221985,
0.24032358825206757,
0.3979414403438568,
-0.3701772391796112,
-1.0298938751220703,
0.003274190239608288,
0.41951069235801697,
-0.5764548182487488,
-0.14633186161518097,
-0.630192220211029,
-0.2152097374200821,
-0.6095154881477356,
-0.07432093471288681,
-0.43203872442245483,
-0.2377854734659195,
-0.06420551985502243,
0.03836315870285034,
0.23777027428150177,
0.7665725350379944,
-0.14190152287483215,
0.38792747259140015,
-0.721462607383728,
0.2271149456501007,
-0.07776497304439545,
0.4210342466831207,
-0.5938183665275574,
-0.7702304720878601,
-0.043585650622844696,
-0.035923704504966736,
-0.47574156522750854,
-0.6605959534645081,
0.553744375705719,
0.21102005243301392,
0.3524028956890106,
0.3290134072303772,
-0.2884562313556671,
0.8234459161758423,
-0.776915967464447,
0.7481827139854431,
0.37592512369155884,
-0.9157845973968506,
0.636064350605011,
-0.772112250328064,
0.26032793521881104,
0.9058944582939148,
0.23340223729610443,
-0.24865801632404327,
-0.5553036332130432,
-0.8797041773796082,
-0.8618648648262024,
0.4988177716732025,
0.4961172044277191,
-0.3360816240310669,
-0.08646244555711746,
0.5507497787475586,
0.08000117540359497,
0.1265336573123932,
-0.613207221031189,
0.139047309756279,
0.2915644645690918,
-0.3240315616130829,
-0.16689640283584595,
-0.3819347620010376,
-0.3949069678783417,
-0.44578397274017334,
0.724670946598053,
-0.24669618904590607,
0.21749788522720337,
0.35354605317115784,
0.2866556942462921,
-0.19525209069252014,
0.32263821363449097,
0.5248925685882568,
1.006341814994812,
-0.3842657804489136,
0.14276345074176788,
0.47555965185165405,
-0.6280117034912109,
0.021526223048567772,
0.14722123742103577,
0.1778257042169571,
0.022564087063074112,
0.6207844614982605,
0.6389511823654175,
0.3881254196166992,
-0.5713605880737305,
0.6688634753227234,
-0.4319136142730713,
-0.6523966193199158,
-0.3205590546131134,
0.14406803250312805,
0.03303518518805504,
0.1252109408378601,
-0.15441173315048218,
0.3268967568874359,
0.28108346462249756,
-0.45713064074516296,
0.37584084272384644,
0.24297218024730682,
-0.40586093068122864,
-0.37092897295951843,
0.6837116479873657,
0.1459936946630478,
-0.2197096049785614,
0.23048104345798492,
0.019257280975580215,
-0.3993411362171173,
0.2875974178314209,
0.47682076692581177,
0.5334378480911255,
-0.20791450142860413,
-0.22954493761062622,
0.34809041023254395,
0.36659562587738037,
-0.5553568005561829,
0.48820534348487854,
0.4493507444858551,
-0.8634317517280579,
-0.7142667770385742,
-0.5019063949584961,
-0.5637985467910767,
0.4916672706604004,
-0.6811373829841614,
0.4665323793888092,
-0.26971903443336487,
-0.13940607011318207,
0.2638237178325653,
0.013025648891925812,
-0.6777905225753784,
0.12547987699508667,
0.001523033482953906,
0.705166757106781,
-0.6696270704269409,
1.06612229347229,
0.532390296459198,
-0.13193769752979279,
-1.2273825407028198,
-0.03688912093639374,
0.12538178265094757,
-0.6495058536529541,
0.26399457454681396,
0.013226797804236412,
0.07555754482746124,
-0.10250168293714523,
-0.45492950081825256,
-1.0073174238204956,
1.08322274684906,
0.33946433663368225,
-0.9734687209129333,
-0.22586342692375183,
0.0010004956275224686,
0.49299660325050354,
-0.224239319562912,
0.3163408041000366,
1.0203278064727783,
0.39190998673439026,
0.05152994021773338,
-1.4752391576766968,
-0.01064523495733738,
-0.05636359006166458,
-0.27886104583740234,
0.3792584240436554,
-0.3365376591682434,
0.6476136445999146,
-0.0888875424861908,
0.007217833306640387,
0.25432267785072327,
0.11046689748764038,
0.39463019371032715,
0.19774170219898224,
0.4368347227573395,
0.6731975674629211,
1.0115286111831665,
-0.2094479501247406,
0.8732373118400574,
-0.4512365758419037,
0.5382866859436035,
1.2528632879257202,
-0.6324825286865234,
0.8242936730384827,
0.5067605972290039,
-0.3174276351928711,
0.13905400037765503,
0.45585930347442627,
0.10839235037565231,
0.5911628603935242,
-0.1458398848772049,
-0.12374181300401688,
-0.11671006679534912,
0.3190397024154663,
-0.409492552280426,
0.4488820433616638,
0.442495197057724,
-0.4189915060997009,
-0.0891374871134758,
0.003923697397112846,
0.01377546414732933,
-0.08501436561346054,
0.05888330191373825,
0.874253511428833,
0.12068255990743637,
-0.9343442320823669,
0.7692559957504272,
-0.030656687915325165,
0.519284725189209,
-0.5499475598335266,
-0.027830103412270546,
-0.1472286581993103,
0.521602988243103,
-0.23264054954051971,
-0.6684178113937378,
0.4701208174228668,
-0.18095223605632782,
0.25653812289237976,
-0.19297298789024353,
0.5632482171058655,
-0.4334626793861389,
-0.4009227156639099,
0.3025050759315491,
0.34461092948913574,
0.1977922022342682,
0.019495420157909393,
-0.7335978150367737,
-0.020426778122782707,
0.23797756433486938,
-0.11971122026443481,
0.35734254121780396,
0.5856353044509888,
0.14280056953430176,
0.3455237150192261,
0.5549765825271606,
0.37629061937332153,
-0.3197588622570038,
0.16372154653072357,
0.7788269519805908,
-0.6563370823860168,
-0.2445300668478012,
-0.8671824336051941,
0.14986108243465424,
0.008223876357078552,
-0.575554370880127,
0.6105043888092041,
0.47883814573287964,
0.44566428661346436,
0.3762393891811371,
0.6722287535667419,
0.2837158441543579,
0.8074893951416016,
-0.6543158292770386,
0.37841227650642395,
-0.517470121383667,
0.488335520029068,
-0.3563891351222992,
-0.6403846740722656,
-0.5076239109039307,
0.4469018876552582,
-0.4946012496948242,
-0.12545649707317352,
1.1632492542266846,
0.6845324039459229,
-0.18230679631233215,
0.5169771313667297,
0.4463687837123871,
0.3409610390663147,
0.5613242387771606,
0.684695303440094,
0.5988720655441284,
-0.6143320202827454,
0.14986450970172882,
-0.08810894191265106,
-0.3989984095096588,
0.0030351176392287016,
-0.9471246600151062,
-0.8193536400794983,
-0.3012552261352539,
-0.318075954914093,
-0.4429762363433838,
0.3263930380344391,
0.7910544276237488,
0.6778243184089661,
-0.8956858515739441,
0.12435658276081085,
-0.3425566852092743,
-0.44451940059661865,
-0.18707041442394257,
-0.11801639199256897,
0.4598965644836426,
-0.47933924198150635,
-0.5014119744300842,
0.5181745290756226,
0.4539044499397278,
-0.18447810411453247,
0.06912584602832794,
-0.027490030974149704,
-0.24016845226287842,
-0.07653583586215973,
0.4920332133769989,
-0.20771723985671997,
-0.8557415008544922,
-0.42984700202941895,
-0.16722503304481506,
0.0389467217028141,
0.29536378383636475,
0.557718813419342,
-0.5093054175376892,
0.413788765668869,
0.34069961309432983,
0.6249613165855408,
0.5487344861030579,
-0.0024046471808105707,
0.9230266213417053,
-0.43978145718574524,
-0.11769386380910873,
0.5965209603309631,
0.7028018832206726,
0.2576383054256439,
-0.35508766770362854,
0.7338992953300476,
0.06226135790348053,
-1.1078486442565918,
-0.7026348114013672,
-0.01533548254519701,
-0.9423646926879883,
-0.25510960817337036,
1.312366008758545,
-0.04203151538968086,
0.02541162632405758,
-0.3528610169887543,
-0.24305149912834167,
-0.040585365146398544,
-0.24558573961257935,
0.5316118001937866,
0.9142935872077942,
-0.3075856566429138,
-0.07463464140892029,
-0.8749886155128479,
0.7339416146278381,
0.6231235861778259,
-0.6409427523612976,
-0.16263775527477264,
0.20292754471302032,
0.5855014324188232,
0.06985896825790405,
0.892682671546936,
-0.3260413408279419,
0.06276499480009079,
-0.33184120059013367,
-0.19273057579994202,
0.4291849434375763,
-0.1657688021659851,
-0.6192507743835449,
0.04239511862397194,
0.15531593561172485,
0.18628425896167755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00482v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00482v2
|
Cross-lingual Named Entity Corpus for Slavic Languages
| 2024-03-30T22:20:08 | 2024-04-07T16:56:35 |
Jakub Piskorski, Michał Marcińczuk, Roman Yangarber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a corpus manually annotated with named entities for six
Slavic languages - Bulgarian, Czech, Polish, Slovenian, Russian, and Ukrainian.
This work is the result of a series of shared tasks, conducted in 2017-2023 as
a part of the Workshops on Slavic Natural Language Processing. The corpus
consists of 5 017 documents on seven topics. The documents are annotated with
five classes of named entities. Each entity is described by a category, a
lemma, and a unique cross-lingual identifier. We provide two train-tune dataset
splits - single topic out and cross topics. For each split, we set benchmarks
using a transformer-based neural network architecture with the pre-trained
multilingual models - XLM-RoBERTa-large for named entity mention recognition
and categorization, and mT5-large for named entity lemmatization and linking.
|
[
-0.5174062848091125,
-0.20504987239837646,
0.3691810965538025,
0.33844438195228577,
-0.4038359224796295,
0.33837345242500305,
-0.4001864492893219,
-0.679810643196106,
0.6294376254081726,
0.6323071122169495,
-0.4522055387496948,
-0.6237287521362305,
-0.35670530796051025,
0.5053374767303467,
-0.28066113591194153,
0.9154144525527954,
0.0029519079253077507,
0.703382134437561,
0.07910025119781494,
-0.04014002904295921,
-0.3493089973926544,
-0.4842718839645386,
-0.25147032737731934,
-0.04233422502875328,
0.7055310010910034,
0.303134948015213,
0.21091417968273163,
0.3783705532550812,
0.36699968576431274,
0.3245895206928253,
0.13303974270820618,
-0.012913204729557037,
-0.041386984288692474,
0.1564207822084427,
-0.4042481780052185,
-0.5428008437156677,
-0.4714938700199127,
-0.27782803773880005,
0.8532685041427612,
0.7664146423339844,
0.2276475876569748,
0.2690833806991577,
-0.35641852021217346,
0.2985803782939911,
-0.28895169496536255,
0.1318928599357605,
-0.8960500955581665,
0.036860961467027664,
-0.49033358693122864,
0.0825377106666565,
-0.5528976917266846,
0.06273820251226425,
0.13994164764881134,
-0.6673246622085571,
0.06385737657546997,
0.19171343743801117,
0.7332707047462463,
-0.009130069054663181,
-0.2889719307422638,
-0.32676541805267334,
-0.4544864594936371,
0.9005618691444397,
-0.15895025432109833,
0.7823910117149353,
0.3194493353366852,
0.015267104841768742,
0.15475474298000336,
-0.6450126767158508,
-0.06780557334423065,
0.06078874692320824,
-0.09846430271863937,
-0.07593900710344315,
-0.13553358614444733,
-0.16056114435195923,
0.03980720788240433,
-0.05105552822351456,
-0.5219240784645081,
-0.0298458281904459,
-0.6037059426307678,
-0.39761805534362793,
0.6033943891525269,
-0.01482847798615694,
0.38635721802711487,
-0.1271141767501831,
-0.38112515211105347,
0.414034366607666,
-0.5576040148735046,
-0.3574417531490326,
0.7232137322425842,
0.6314745545387268,
0.1417350023984909,
0.6141348481178284,
-0.23955701291561127,
0.6318605542182922,
0.21606877446174622,
-0.20605060458183289,
0.5588086247444153,
-0.6008673906326294,
-0.27348029613494873,
0.5737078785896301,
0.6304583549499512,
0.028095537796616554,
0.3977261781692505,
-0.7536440491676331,
0.04131156578660011,
-0.11669577658176422,
0.2593759298324585,
-0.49772337079048157,
-0.3225759267807007,
0.019186396151781082,
-0.29031848907470703,
-0.07051875442266464,
-0.33655989170074463,
-0.7862535715103149,
0.025339772924780846,
-0.665317952632904,
0.04700206592679024,
-0.5145297050476074,
-0.3566412329673767,
-0.17573562264442444,
0.14670643210411072,
0.06297308951616287,
0.15802301466464996,
-0.9108573198318481,
0.36734071373939514,
0.4997052550315857,
0.45170092582702637,
-0.4437881410121918,
-0.4736439883708954,
-0.63507479429245,
0.09461287409067154,
-0.29357296228408813,
0.9813913106918335,
-0.6783091425895691,
-0.1282551884651184,
-0.0156667809933424,
0.48865076899528503,
-0.15549781918525696,
-0.41899213194847107,
0.45119717717170715,
-0.6411954164505005,
0.12809424102306366,
-0.20124447345733643,
-0.6441472172737122,
-0.13549408316612244,
0.17605368793010712,
-0.8291203379631042,
1.054099678993225,
-0.0032272276002913713,
-0.9447385668754578,
0.5822389721870422,
-0.47889840602874756,
-0.4082421660423279,
0.4620831608772278,
-0.03920461982488632,
-0.1978146731853485,
-0.07805947214365005,
-0.08899445086717606,
0.2801817059516907,
-0.1902523636817932,
0.4510369598865509,
-0.13215509057044983,
0.09395772218704224,
0.01051960326731205,
0.2590107321739197,
0.8846503496170044,
0.11617477238178253,
-0.3390561044216156,
0.22248587012290955,
-1.1175423860549927,
0.3623586893081665,
-0.41724246740341187,
-0.3483353853225708,
-0.6333799362182617,
-0.4596118628978729,
0.580380380153656,
0.3128182888031006,
0.36678043007850647,
-0.7314890027046204,
0.03796365484595299,
-0.2816021144390106,
0.0005129157798364758,
0.11581481248140335,
-0.17046749591827393,
0.6256741285324097,
0.3587050437927246,
0.602506697177887,
0.43611449003219604,
-0.3188132047653198,
0.08313409984111786,
-0.4927680492401123,
-0.8045223951339722,
-0.31291335821151733,
1.0564324855804443,
0.7261370420455933,
-1.0457156896591187,
0.4354458153247833,
-0.2287435084581375,
-0.4981142580509186,
-0.6008473038673401,
0.08520504832267761,
0.39664724469184875,
0.18731074035167694,
0.5847846269607544,
0.012659446336328983,
-1.0414432287216187,
-1.1244269609451294,
-0.320033460855484,
0.08204774558544159,
0.3276787996292114,
-0.0465877540409565,
0.7298259139060974,
-0.009241730906069279,
0.7114588618278503,
0.1797931045293808,
-0.2086905986070633,
-0.3204314410686493,
0.25752124190330505,
-0.15361535549163818,
0.4690329432487488,
0.45216551423072815,
-0.9040956497192383,
-0.8392382860183716,
0.10272013396024704,
-0.4178611934185028,
-0.13367228209972382,
-0.027647702023386955,
-0.22067350149154663,
0.7772337198257446,
0.33784711360931396,
-0.5733550190925598,
0.19527976214885712,
0.30766966938972473,
-0.45873403549194336,
0.432689905166626,
-0.0373709574341774,
0.03917312249541283,
-1.129657506942749,
0.1276746392250061,
-0.22705353796482086,
-0.3091948926448822,
-0.626415491104126,
-0.2361920177936554,
0.14850366115570068,
0.11813504248857498,
-0.8639616966247559,
0.6903887987136841,
-0.8657943606376648,
-0.47445085644721985,
-0.09452413767576218,
0.3337531089782715,
-0.4294985234737396,
0.34118109941482544,
0.581911563873291,
0.4651939272880554,
0.7292057871818542,
-0.3262649178504944,
0.5401107668876648,
0.16767984628677368,
-0.4404046833515167,
0.8304450511932373,
-0.2280368059873581,
-0.06753227114677429,
0.043661318719387054,
-0.09605464339256287,
-0.4347465932369232,
0.10405702888965607,
0.3526720702648163,
-0.38826805353164673,
0.3645811975002289,
-0.42580023407936096,
-0.5974271893501282,
0.21534444391727448,
0.2938963770866394,
0.2673321068286896,
-0.04636947065591812,
-0.20561955869197845,
0.5658246874809265,
0.5138278007507324,
-0.23461970686912537,
-0.6335263848304749,
-0.8088610172271729,
0.47523587942123413,
-0.4577292501926422,
-0.49765142798423767,
0.37888556718826294,
-0.01187842432409525,
-0.3118422329425812,
0.30941399931907654,
0.2857542335987091,
-0.38796159625053406,
-0.07900222390890121,
0.0858428031206131,
0.3022705614566803,
-0.4001973867416382,
0.5162149667739868,
-0.051947593688964844,
-0.1702357828617096,
-0.20165377855300903,
-0.6262866258621216,
0.5129076242446899,
-0.33071577548980713,
0.10942690074443817,
0.030749058350920677,
0.45218533277511597,
0.15562067925930023,
-0.385082483291626,
0.7645350694656372,
0.8251479268074036,
-0.5397670865058899,
-0.018631909042596817,
-0.37880125641822815,
0.27315980195999146,
-0.23775850236415863,
0.23798580467700958,
-0.7154513001441956,
-0.7201352119445801,
0.7353495955467224,
0.05537136644124985,
-0.08222197741270065,
0.512518584728241,
0.740226149559021,
0.3074589669704437,
0.432608425617218,
0.3466907739639282,
0.02393597736954689,
0.1137976124882698,
-0.08637107908725739,
0.1831595003604889,
-0.6591364741325378,
-0.29850703477859497,
-0.5522945523262024,
-0.2514987587928772,
-0.7398319840431213,
-0.4335835874080658,
-0.2988388240337372,
-0.08610149472951889,
0.13575822114944458,
0.7842517495155334,
-0.22229266166687012,
0.29957443475723267,
0.46793484687805176,
-0.5837850570678711,
0.4230978190898895,
0.021628079935908318,
-0.5447393655776978,
-0.23882731795310974,
-0.4677717983722687,
-0.6369898915290833,
0.9571948647499084,
0.13929705321788788,
0.4865213632583618,
-0.04679613187909126,
0.9502015113830566,
0.03668386489152908,
0.17503775656223297,
-0.5980017185211182,
0.5851823687553406,
-0.04562050849199295,
-1.1574782133102417,
-0.4241698384284973,
-0.21326294541358948,
-1.0285855531692505,
0.4135085642337799,
-0.1709853559732437,
-0.9281008243560791,
0.2397807538509369,
-0.14639881253242493,
-0.07135121524333954,
0.24282504618167877,
-0.41906461119651794,
1.0342901945114136,
-0.4634682536125183,
-0.3042660057544708,
-0.0762576013803482,
-0.644212543964386,
0.2819010317325592,
-0.2479095458984375,
0.07665061205625534,
-0.13484327495098114,
-0.29191330075263977,
0.7250679135322571,
0.057694971561431885,
0.628596305847168,
-0.07354117929935455,
0.04365512356162071,
0.20411308109760284,
-0.13162213563919067,
0.037060678005218506,
0.1990218311548233,
0.07559053599834442,
0.32405024766921997,
0.2797662615776062,
-0.39517563581466675,
-0.07093177735805511,
0.7941741943359375,
-0.44360440969467163,
0.024224242195487022,
-0.594597578048706,
-0.4518430531024933,
-0.1794034242630005,
0.7098779678344727,
0.34940508008003235,
0.34843042492866516,
-0.32389527559280396,
0.3529607951641083,
0.6777608394622803,
-0.18040767312049866,
0.39845919609069824,
0.6977894902229309,
-0.530650794506073,
-0.7099664807319641,
0.9166914224624634,
0.44841164350509644,
-0.003716219449415803,
0.5238269567489624,
-0.5289238691329956,
-0.1802036166191101,
-0.5159841775894165,
-0.7483624815940857,
0.32705914974212646,
-0.6957948803901672,
-0.16278183460235596,
-0.7474303245544434,
-0.0012033632956445217,
-0.5311228632926941,
0.15040579438209534,
-0.5800048112869263,
-0.5520020723342896,
-0.3485521674156189,
-0.12419331818819046,
0.046884264796972275,
0.4925929605960846,
0.14134815335273743,
0.012203112244606018,
-0.7115944027900696,
0.11995260417461395,
-0.2054157257080078,
0.4327370822429657,
-0.42318710684776306,
-0.0954800546169281,
-0.5153408646583557,
-0.07727999240159988,
0.029974164441227913,
-0.8336033821105957,
0.6475062370300293,
0.1844439059495926,
0.8616154193878174,
-0.1385643482208252,
0.0573561005294323,
0.43347546458244324,
-0.7216314077377319,
0.5995060801506042,
0.08342794328927994,
-0.8715237379074097,
0.2679978013038635,
-0.19594943523406982,
0.2724945545196533,
0.5217005014419556,
0.7095023393630981,
-0.5546371340751648,
-0.3100111484527588,
-0.7742639780044556,
-0.6442019939422607,
0.7849148511886597,
0.24140426516532898,
-0.30853337049484253,
-0.1571451723575592,
-0.02947772853076458,
0.2876843810081482,
0.29889875650405884,
-0.7581319808959961,
-0.4387127161026001,
-0.09347591549158096,
-0.2779655158519745,
0.13859619200229645,
-0.0892663225531578,
0.029707735404372215,
-0.07454157620668411,
0.9258787035942078,
-0.2297120839357376,
0.20236268639564514,
0.1575450748205185,
-0.6168847680091858,
-0.046252161264419556,
0.440533310174942,
0.8493903875350952,
0.7031845450401306,
0.12408523261547089,
0.17523154616355896,
0.44561681151390076,
-0.36429888010025024,
0.019002217799425125,
0.23994854092597961,
-0.22131697833538055,
0.45462965965270996,
0.27771326899528503,
0.9072197079658508,
0.7424130439758301,
-0.5744430422782898,
-0.102568119764328,
-0.151948019862175,
-0.2723875343799591,
-0.7979257702827454,
-0.40396973490715027,
0.6000193953514099,
0.2746554911136627,
0.16074888408184052,
-0.29217076301574707,
0.2557768225669861,
-0.548682689666748,
0.24087275564670563,
0.32155802845954895,
-0.40274521708488464,
-0.5206905007362366,
0.23704257607460022,
0.2642565667629242,
-0.2683368921279907,
0.3193020820617676,
-0.2633245289325714,
-0.652278482913971,
0.4334256947040558,
0.4464437961578369,
0.7744786143302917,
-0.2229401171207428,
0.2676725387573242,
0.326332688331604,
0.20532803237438202,
0.1548248529434204,
0.5533015727996826,
-0.13887058198451996,
-0.5978708863258362,
-0.33272555470466614,
-0.8938438892364502,
-0.15324616432189941,
0.13005785644054413,
-0.6324048042297363,
0.5226294994354248,
-0.03039718233048916,
-0.24603018164634705,
0.4382404088973999,
0.43047648668289185,
-0.725829541683197,
0.18826963007450104,
0.3733350336551666,
0.94388347864151,
-0.532408595085144,
1.2027984857559204,
1.0950267314910889,
-0.30958083271980286,
-0.43776005506515503,
-0.4767676889896393,
-0.3311162292957306,
-0.3537350594997406,
1.3680014610290527,
-0.10263604670763016,
0.13465753197669983,
-0.0864604040980339,
0.11143343895673752,
-1.2986046075820923,
0.7623142600059509,
0.2949473559856415,
-0.6735961437225342,
-0.3040795624256134,
0.27896445989608765,
0.7056329846382141,
-0.7803025245666504,
0.14957723021507263,
0.5351698398590088,
0.7933872938156128,
-0.22387346625328064,
-1.153671383857727,
-0.3648968040943146,
-0.3336303234100342,
-0.13567617535591125,
0.443411260843277,
-0.4822635352611542,
0.48983219265937805,
0.17414548993110657,
-0.10451147705316544,
0.19638551771640778,
0.7520419359207153,
0.019269945099949837,
0.339322954416275,
0.48430824279785156,
0.5942093133926392,
0.5911034345626831,
-0.10567890107631683,
0.3597660958766937,
-0.5457239151000977,
0.25369665026664734,
1.326878309249878,
-0.3330916166305542,
0.6765233874320984,
0.6158487796783447,
-0.1399204432964325,
0.41718238592147827,
0.7645149827003479,
-0.25344058871269226,
0.4123285710811615,
0.2952466309070587,
-0.021298138424754143,
-0.4857495427131653,
-0.17047908902168274,
-0.3247339725494385,
0.5713659524917603,
0.2921213209629059,
-0.537813663482666,
-0.2057168185710907,
0.16813035309314728,
-0.008111017756164074,
-0.23309975862503052,
-0.2288869023323059,
0.6313556432723999,
-0.016562845557928085,
-0.8828540444374084,
0.2195795476436615,
0.01873176544904709,
0.40037065744400024,
-0.36542561650276184,
0.18789541721343994,
0.09623664617538452,
0.08887533098459244,
-0.23574943840503693,
-0.6010103225708008,
0.3991333246231079,
0.009890411980450153,
-0.16175828874111176,
-0.28891539573669434,
0.8832544088363647,
-1.0450937747955322,
-0.8373069167137146,
0.5617297291755676,
0.3688373863697052,
0.5500502586364746,
0.2689104378223419,
-0.5392281413078308,
0.02121833898127079,
-0.07045363634824753,
-0.2657352387905121,
0.4505758583545685,
0.6817223429679871,
-0.21227723360061646,
0.34933754801750183,
0.25947853922843933,
0.398255318403244,
0.5486668348312378,
0.054721228778362274,
0.5063577890396118,
-0.6889718770980835,
-0.5609211325645447,
-0.4268913269042969,
0.5514362454414368,
-0.1405458152294159,
-0.4519757926464081,
0.8024978637695312,
0.8687891364097595,
1.128663420677185,
-0.326028048992157,
0.6348583698272705,
-0.07422921061515808,
0.8699707388877869,
-0.3868772089481354,
0.6798970699310303,
-0.47321292757987976,
0.011545134708285332,
-0.026230428367853165,
-1.0338038206100464,
-0.33528387546539307,
0.3170761168003082,
-0.3919390141963959,
-0.15354497730731964,
0.7186236381530762,
0.25163164734840393,
0.012962869368493557,
-0.07290492206811905,
0.6017136573791504,
-0.012476739473640919,
-0.08484748005867004,
0.3534524142742157,
0.5455698370933533,
-0.39504191279411316,
0.6376520395278931,
-0.47325143218040466,
0.5108366012573242,
-0.1316959708929062,
-0.7892419695854187,
-1.0166771411895752,
-0.7957969307899475,
-0.4840618073940277,
0.11446964740753174,
0.20580817759037018,
0.9796316027641296,
0.7440497875213623,
-1.0210657119750977,
-0.13270318508148193,
0.10187778621912003,
0.12843775749206543,
0.22857226431369781,
-0.16591790318489075,
0.08458702266216278,
-0.6458843946456909,
-0.8574172258377075,
0.4431397616863251,
0.24383842945098877,
-0.12592628598213196,
-0.4896709620952606,
0.018666135147213936,
-0.6139205694198608,
-0.32465481758117676,
0.2779894769191742,
0.07248616218566895,
-0.9161676168441772,
-0.1566895991563797,
0.18668028712272644,
-0.15988391637802124,
0.017654046416282654,
0.7453785538673401,
-0.8441299200057983,
0.3163242042064667,
0.4566580355167389,
0.5626906752586365,
0.5276234745979309,
-0.32066649198532104,
0.35723185539245605,
-0.6595046520233154,
0.15544407069683075,
0.2685532867908478,
0.5965355634689331,
0.5792760848999023,
-0.31091001629829407,
0.5110877156257629,
0.41348403692245483,
-0.40709224343299866,
-0.8807802200317383,
-0.011782140471041203,
-0.8470314741134644,
-0.13412386178970337,
0.9210306406021118,
-0.4301658868789673,
-0.33861544728279114,
-0.4830215573310852,
0.03940912336111069,
0.317473828792572,
-0.3584367334842682,
0.3311641812324524,
1.0239709615707397,
0.00808639544993639,
-0.30764544010162354,
-0.5495083332061768,
0.3907569944858551,
0.16354191303253174,
-0.9633216261863708,
-0.022585727274417877,
0.3239545226097107,
0.44800668954849243,
0.5243346691131592,
0.18414197862148285,
-0.1355993002653122,
0.2769831717014313,
0.14927802979946136,
0.43490901589393616,
0.20645104348659515,
-0.7102000117301941,
-0.1879463791847229,
0.08728071302175522,
-0.25540634989738464,
-0.021005600690841675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00474v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00474v2
|
Linguistic Calibration of Long-Form Generations
| 2024-03-30T20:47:55 | 2024-06-04T22:39:58 |
Neil Band, Xuechen Li, Tengyu Ma, Tatsunori Hashimoto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Language models (LMs) may lead their users to make suboptimal downstream
decisions when they confidently hallucinate. This issue can be mitigated by
having the LM verbally convey the probability that its claims are correct, but
existing models cannot produce long-form text with calibrated confidence
statements. Through the lens of decision-making, we define linguistic
calibration for long-form generations: an LM is linguistically calibrated if
its generations enable its users to make calibrated probabilistic predictions.
This definition enables a training framework where a supervised finetuning step
bootstraps an LM to emit long-form generations with confidence statements such
as "I estimate a 30% chance of..." or "I am certain that...", followed by a
reinforcement learning step which rewards generations that enable a user to
provide calibrated answers to related questions. We linguistically calibrate
Llama 2 7B and find in automated and human evaluations of long-form generations
that it is significantly more calibrated than strong finetuned factuality
baselines with comparable accuracy. These findings generalize under significant
domain shifts to scientific and biomedical questions and to an entirely
held-out person biography generation task. Our results demonstrate that
long-form generations may be calibrated end-to-end by constructing an objective
in the space of the predictions that users make in downstream decision-making.
|
[
-0.30367669463157654,
-0.5508637428283691,
0.7937378883361816,
0.1517588496208191,
0.016671422868967056,
0.17269305884838104,
-0.5969451665878296,
-0.522917628288269,
0.148307204246521,
0.6932193636894226,
-0.7524271607398987,
-0.18873167037963867,
-0.3483830988407135,
0.1839362531900406,
0.0627121552824974,
0.8660288453102112,
0.015156935900449753,
0.01443549431860447,
-0.4181598722934723,
0.13342496752738953,
-0.6153344511985779,
-0.4714185893535614,
-0.6019074320793152,
-0.808168888092041,
0.6287046074867249,
0.32077351212501526,
0.9100202918052673,
0.39297202229499817,
-0.13889990746974945,
0.18388532102108002,
-0.1453031748533249,
0.029165716841816902,
-0.821502685546875,
0.2285216897726059,
-0.38611075282096863,
-0.6980176568031311,
-0.09066908061504364,
-0.030836008489131927,
0.3705061972141266,
0.993759036064148,
0.010902384296059608,
0.22472797334194183,
0.128798246383667,
1.0223181247711182,
-0.5935054421424866,
0.1965767741203308,
-0.6764244437217712,
-0.0018825313309207559,
-0.30337563157081604,
-0.5086032748222351,
-0.7404810786247253,
-0.5362323522567749,
0.02217317558825016,
-0.3132985532283783,
0.18256314098834991,
-0.07382581382989883,
0.45901748538017273,
0.42037779092788696,
-0.4546359181404114,
-0.2615133821964264,
-0.7854700088500977,
0.7664505839347839,
-0.6620796918869019,
0.4413563907146454,
0.9211393594741821,
0.37010037899017334,
-0.502813458442688,
-0.4071263372898102,
-0.403724730014801,
-0.4835663437843323,
0.08554040640592575,
0.02361713908612728,
0.130705788731575,
0.2751232087612152,
0.29146620631217957,
0.07694930583238602,
-0.5619005560874939,
0.4063686728477478,
-0.7534324526786804,
-0.47055378556251526,
0.689521312713623,
-0.21259260177612305,
-0.16361825168132782,
-0.1683148592710495,
-0.2641996145248413,
-0.12270665913820267,
-1.0411772727966309,
-0.08299366384744644,
0.6305433511734009,
0.4235754609107971,
0.20428107678890228,
0.6353192925453186,
-0.5443248152732849,
0.6482437252998352,
0.29270943999290466,
-0.16299915313720703,
0.3257461488246918,
-0.07895319163799286,
-0.038362372666597366,
0.5239047408103943,
0.5698164105415344,
0.4714421331882477,
0.5769438147544861,
-0.17207235097885132,
-0.2256001979112625,
0.03394902125000954,
0.14766530692577362,
-0.7514408826828003,
-0.013388087972998619,
0.1958162933588028,
-0.24490338563919067,
-0.40096262097358704,
-0.2281998246908188,
-0.740837812423706,
-0.6087656617164612,
-0.4711019992828369,
0.48942890763282776,
-0.3743227422237396,
0.1419660449028015,
0.21286776661872864,
0.16224773228168488,
0.25127220153808594,
0.24505634605884552,
-0.8962612748146057,
-0.07269026339054108,
0.6576333045959473,
0.4661245048046112,
0.08847086131572723,
-0.1800818294286728,
-0.4810671806335449,
0.07281435281038284,
-0.4960988759994507,
0.6952894330024719,
-0.32605263590812683,
-0.4827846884727478,
0.11645887792110443,
-0.035438843071460724,
0.015765860676765442,
-0.67246413230896,
0.4278266727924347,
-0.42634257674217224,
0.34504860639572144,
-0.2520006000995636,
-0.3973059356212616,
-0.22865839302539825,
-0.010530740953981876,
-0.4988444745540619,
0.7342521548271179,
0.22572652995586395,
-0.24716266989707947,
0.6845247149467468,
0.03904613479971886,
-0.3379583954811096,
0.42403411865234375,
-0.38817068934440613,
-0.28406214714050293,
0.08844421058893204,
-0.022226525470614433,
0.5131192803382874,
-0.33486250042915344,
0.643946647644043,
-0.3656524419784546,
-0.07326751947402954,
0.29865720868110657,
-0.5831314921379089,
0.5158502459526062,
0.33642762899398804,
-0.5324798822402954,
-0.1953582912683487,
-0.7981624007225037,
0.20522001385688782,
-0.22493968904018402,
-0.40488383173942566,
-0.17807640135288239,
0.33862969279289246,
-0.3198488652706146,
0.257832795381546,
0.22203198075294495,
-0.4707610607147217,
-0.017302047461271286,
-0.48865070939064026,
0.4644642770290375,
0.6861932873725891,
-0.09906212985515594,
0.3402068316936493,
-0.6163253784179688,
0.4784846603870392,
-0.24946561455726624,
-0.0629211887717247,
-0.11357705295085907,
-0.4118775725364685,
-0.7901590466499329,
0.09966687858104706,
0.20046138763427734,
0.5127036571502686,
-0.6548053622245789,
0.700114905834198,
-0.54270339012146,
-0.44084450602531433,
-0.32414063811302185,
0.4207570254802704,
0.22155988216400146,
0.6164594888687134,
0.2856835722923279,
-0.303894579410553,
-0.5256791114807129,
-0.9596382975578308,
-0.0323113389313221,
-0.4454762637615204,
-0.04558294638991356,
0.08279024064540863,
0.38304638862609863,
-0.23977839946746826,
1.0317612886428833,
-0.20047655701637268,
-0.12689806520938873,
-0.18480649590492249,
0.32328906655311584,
0.05388998985290527,
0.3288560211658478,
0.26154226064682007,
-0.6684053540229797,
-0.048260096460580826,
-0.12683869898319244,
-0.5850302577018738,
-0.23330307006835938,
-0.48681315779685974,
-0.12333469837903976,
0.21806056797504425,
0.5625371336936951,
-0.5663737654685974,
0.34001630544662476,
0.5026054382324219,
-0.23158849775791168,
0.549457848072052,
-0.2697344124317169,
-0.0634852945804596,
-0.920492947101593,
-0.07995294779539108,
0.09819120913743973,
-0.3607645630836487,
-0.5288546681404114,
0.11862562596797943,
0.0449264757335186,
0.3227863609790802,
-0.29580503702163696,
0.38323235511779785,
-0.31527021527290344,
0.08388130366802216,
-0.13987842202186584,
0.016380013898015022,
-0.16311103105545044,
0.0751674622297287,
0.02824433706700802,
0.7629576325416565,
0.09502984583377838,
-0.5896531939506531,
0.2628777027130127,
-0.012593512423336506,
-0.5052964091300964,
0.5960371494293213,
-0.4116135537624359,
0.03498184680938721,
-0.5225839018821716,
0.6309306621551514,
-0.7942700386047363,
-0.3955496549606323,
-0.13710686564445496,
-0.4368152618408203,
0.27836528420448303,
0.14747679233551025,
-0.29140037298202515,
-0.45048388838768005,
-0.31200599670410156,
0.4994448125362396,
0.7014130353927612,
-0.36903437972068787,
0.5100231170654297,
0.14260545372962952,
-0.33029648661613464,
-0.39479005336761475,
-0.8857672214508057,
0.19429928064346313,
-0.15790590643882751,
-0.6673725843429565,
0.28052955865859985,
-0.12108928710222244,
-0.1783251017332077,
-0.5263361930847168,
0.0960141196846962,
0.23197278380393982,
-0.13164201378822327,
0.4066465198993683,
0.3138532042503357,
-0.24056477844715118,
0.3114861845970154,
0.06208227947354317,
-0.033682454377412796,
0.2305317372083664,
-0.03637062758207321,
0.7572159767150879,
0.26015332341194153,
-0.23091518878936768,
-0.09668679535388947,
-0.0021678886841982603,
0.5689257383346558,
-0.10703307390213013,
0.6897032260894775,
0.23808562755584717,
-0.41052305698394775,
-0.33912667632102966,
-0.9695170521736145,
-0.12231847643852234,
-0.4409826993942261,
0.4298630654811859,
-0.23791523277759552,
-0.8048686385154724,
0.4519951641559601,
-0.13554808497428894,
-0.12004544585943222,
0.7280020713806152,
0.7539124488830566,
0.015637598931789398,
1.01615571975708,
0.48584678769111633,
0.12704570591449738,
0.06777829676866531,
-0.009963287971913815,
0.14371398091316223,
-0.6453335881233215,
-0.40725427865982056,
-0.4254918694496155,
-0.2709789574146271,
-0.7712959051132202,
-0.5061006546020508,
0.06686653196811676,
0.12614214420318604,
-0.41839340329170227,
0.22093063592910767,
-0.32047751545906067,
0.46563392877578735,
0.6027563810348511,
0.35496601462364197,
0.12842883169651031,
-0.11301453411579132,
-0.008755366317927837,
0.009842123836278915,
-0.3254911005496979,
-0.712135374546051,
1.020686149597168,
0.4192664921283722,
0.9541357755661011,
-0.11994482576847076,
0.9009764194488525,
0.34549111127853394,
0.3901520371437073,
-0.856661319732666,
0.6178710460662842,
-0.10231492668390274,
-0.5624204874038696,
-0.22415854036808014,
-0.5479629635810852,
-0.8103293180465698,
-0.2574317157268524,
-0.21119804680347443,
-0.8200887441635132,
0.46491265296936035,
0.038134802132844925,
-0.5648438930511475,
0.03833959624171257,
-0.5111449956893921,
0.5995486378669739,
-0.41146934032440186,
-0.2600891888141632,
-0.2524715065956116,
-0.7790839076042175,
0.39910420775413513,
-0.5526264309883118,
0.32818928360939026,
-0.3661274015903473,
0.2022274285554886,
0.6451559066772461,
-0.27801188826560974,
0.9336127042770386,
-0.08201108872890472,
-0.16374152898788452,
0.2486802190542221,
0.25181815028190613,
0.30451422929763794,
-0.16801564395427704,
-0.3326398432254791,
-0.10263250023126602,
0.18470683693885803,
-0.06752707064151764,
-0.26776939630508423,
0.7199298143386841,
-0.7087534666061401,
-0.6043177247047424,
-0.39330732822418213,
-0.3841886818408966,
-0.3923235237598419,
0.10199201852083206,
0.4069066643714905,
0.1919127255678177,
-0.28820672631263733,
0.3408368229866028,
0.5302988290786743,
-0.36627084016799927,
0.0221745353192091,
0.10857398808002472,
-0.35446247458457947,
-0.4610689580440521,
0.698627769947052,
0.1917913854122162,
0.6575541496276855,
0.33720719814300537,
0.28059494495391846,
-0.45115143060684204,
-0.1725570261478424,
-0.39975735545158386,
0.4312930703163147,
-0.8401221036911011,
-0.29478615522384644,
-0.10016793012619019,
-0.27491673827171326,
-0.23464973270893097,
-0.2558170258998871,
-0.06225559860467911,
-0.39853817224502563,
-0.40847718715667725,
-0.20552963018417358,
0.08739852160215378,
0.5487678647041321,
0.052832137793302536,
0.2814613878726959,
-0.5512882471084595,
0.27125754952430725,
0.435503751039505,
0.032921526581048965,
-0.3246651589870453,
-0.546495795249939,
0.10213759541511536,
0.5928274393081665,
-0.4399024546146393,
-0.8963350653648376,
0.2317386418581009,
0.5746106505393982,
0.42546117305755615,
0.17602790892124176,
-0.01234397105872631,
0.8129011392593384,
-0.5047462582588196,
0.7803506255149841,
0.21885302662849426,
-0.6667240262031555,
0.5523138642311096,
-0.06279037147760391,
0.32423514127731323,
0.9456083178520203,
0.3017651438713074,
-0.604630708694458,
-0.28317955136299133,
-0.20760539174079895,
-0.7414373755455017,
0.3691869080066681,
-0.17378346621990204,
0.43466466665267944,
-0.1943928599357605,
0.49524927139282227,
0.3428335189819336,
0.12187156081199646,
-0.6003947257995605,
0.006415789946913719,
-0.04560254514217377,
-0.42380738258361816,
-0.47885000705718994,
-0.35027995705604553,
-0.01850992813706398,
-0.13210560381412506,
0.7157111763954163,
-0.22742429375648499,
-0.07428980618715286,
0.04031777381896973,
-0.15754291415214539,
-0.4074820578098297,
0.4252587556838989,
0.6479177474975586,
0.9027999043464661,
-0.17422933876514435,
0.19090156257152557,
0.07673259824514389,
-0.32013562321662903,
0.11591631174087524,
0.2438964545726776,
-0.49983376264572144,
-0.09404714405536652,
0.11116122454404831,
0.8801146745681763,
0.21788769960403442,
-0.7562434673309326,
0.4967386722564697,
0.2850152850151062,
-0.38883325457572937,
-0.47095584869384766,
-0.0192154161632061,
0.01076545100659132,
0.1357506364583969,
0.5175419449806213,
0.007047249004244804,
-0.10401738435029984,
-0.7326880097389221,
0.1473543345928192,
0.44923651218414307,
-0.24244527518749237,
-0.2344733625650406,
0.889184296131134,
0.07475749403238297,
-0.20344503223896027,
0.6889968514442444,
-0.1197335347533226,
-0.5105973482131958,
0.43164360523223877,
0.5846364498138428,
0.94455885887146,
-0.175815150141716,
0.42506036162376404,
0.3372932970523834,
0.204338937997818,
-0.51243656873703,
0.0605957917869091,
0.05787108838558197,
-0.6644290089607239,
-0.8234733939170837,
-1.0765845775604248,
-0.313891738653183,
0.15728874504566193,
-0.5975518226623535,
0.3540389835834503,
-0.23327365517616272,
-0.49316295981407166,
-0.0014328364050015807,
-0.2525310516357422,
-0.7178611159324646,
0.37005481123924255,
0.6207659840583801,
0.8620281219482422,
-0.7675985097885132,
0.5206320285797119,
0.2897385358810425,
-0.35496169328689575,
-0.6293867230415344,
-0.18886956572532654,
0.014442524872720242,
-1.0303997993469238,
0.9849547147750854,
0.4781514108181,
-0.22454500198364258,
-0.09707299619913101,
-0.5107817053794861,
-0.6738218665122986,
1.0392941236495972,
0.5934672355651855,
-0.6778428554534912,
-0.34214943647384644,
0.5159229040145874,
0.5378479957580566,
-0.18553218245506287,
0.12000146508216858,
0.5991548895835876,
0.35620322823524475,
0.21444709599018097,
-1.1488707065582275,
0.04725918546319008,
0.16152869164943695,
0.09659278392791748,
0.3012886345386505,
-0.30345022678375244,
0.6095396280288696,
-0.37227675318717957,
-0.22722077369689941,
0.3393247723579407,
0.7749730944633484,
0.38735222816467285,
0.34664803743362427,
0.4912247061729431,
0.4149264097213745,
0.5884060263633728,
-0.1953868418931961,
0.8306087851524353,
-0.5320829153060913,
0.33173105120658875,
0.9180803298950195,
-0.15376751124858856,
1.0610976219177246,
0.6929405331611633,
-0.27698230743408203,
0.5597937703132629,
0.7856594920158386,
0.2533627152442932,
0.4209694564342499,
0.4075276851654053,
-0.4358712136745453,
-0.41732943058013916,
-0.03652891889214516,
-0.23204608261585236,
0.5465816259384155,
0.5105653405189514,
-0.6147814989089966,
-0.0955519750714302,
0.027355600148439407,
0.143842875957489,
0.12443792074918747,
-0.4087040424346924,
0.56833815574646,
0.17052465677261353,
-1.0720033645629883,
0.7200116515159607,
-0.25931814312934875,
0.6773180365562439,
-0.6275430917739868,
0.12262066453695297,
0.03049267642199993,
0.16459469497203827,
-0.4043805003166199,
-0.9257795810699463,
-0.1815345138311386,
-0.2076071947813034,
-0.0586935430765152,
-0.3201775550842285,
0.505807638168335,
-0.5820519328117371,
-0.6223533749580383,
0.04012210667133331,
0.5874670743942261,
0.21426835656166077,
0.06413235515356064,
-0.32365989685058594,
-0.07556707412004471,
0.12654994428157806,
-0.3030725419521332,
0.25603386759757996,
0.046675439924001694,
-0.11510114371776581,
0.7035921812057495,
0.525051474571228,
0.5493758320808411,
0.25258317589759827,
0.329215407371521,
0.39214029908180237,
-0.4570005238056183,
-0.2764483094215393,
-0.7936897873878479,
0.24391254782676697,
0.10721530765295029,
-0.33558666706085205,
0.2727121114730835,
0.5167549252510071,
1.1417360305786133,
0.11601659655570984,
0.6985571384429932,
0.10260274261236191,
0.2536908984184265,
-0.5963984727859497,
0.5261181592941284,
-0.29775601625442505,
0.10979937762022018,
0.23616935312747955,
-1.1690378189086914,
-0.27781763672828674,
0.6391596794128418,
-0.5926360487937927,
0.3691062033176422,
0.4257025122642517,
0.7839005589485168,
0.221725732088089,
-0.02298298105597496,
0.33348363637924194,
0.1597416251897812,
0.20697525143623352,
0.5961061120033264,
0.605107843875885,
-0.06868188083171844,
0.17442181706428528,
-0.5689172744750977,
-0.22440475225448608,
-0.11329253017902374,
-0.9704631567001343,
-0.544044017791748,
-0.5267572999000549,
-0.16812747716903687,
-0.2980298101902008,
0.18598206341266632,
1.0870590209960938,
0.46714383363723755,
-0.7017731070518494,
-0.3159070611000061,
-0.025048408657312393,
-0.45272573828697205,
0.21750810742378235,
-0.2266082763671875,
0.04534543678164482,
-0.4567638635635376,
-0.4205147325992584,
0.27624696493148804,
0.22351093590259552,
0.058841120451688766,
-0.5438441038131714,
-0.23701247572898865,
0.19292651116847992,
0.06343133002519608,
0.6753948926925659,
0.5198789834976196,
-0.9330564141273499,
-0.6307597160339355,
-0.137598916888237,
-0.24218323826789856,
0.029524167999625206,
0.3934418559074402,
-1.1420645713806152,
0.766543447971344,
0.31903257966041565,
0.5113642811775208,
0.391194224357605,
0.10540195554494858,
0.6495004892349243,
-0.534331738948822,
-0.12662087380886078,
0.31503793597221375,
0.4138225018978119,
0.5258625745773315,
-0.2966366708278656,
0.3177485167980194,
-0.0625525489449501,
-0.9128310084342957,
-0.7201663851737976,
0.2993534803390503,
-0.8542320728302002,
0.03088708035647869,
1.382712483406067,
0.4139723777770996,
-0.16009782254695892,
0.14988493919372559,
-0.307780385017395,
0.25149908661842346,
-0.19151408970355988,
0.7140628695487976,
0.6736986041069031,
0.09219631552696228,
0.08281833678483963,
-0.936762809753418,
0.4387190043926239,
0.49070873856544495,
-0.5803080201148987,
0.16012924909591675,
0.7585631608963013,
0.20093534886837006,
0.1933823823928833,
0.3708888590335846,
0.1037367582321167,
0.27244266867637634,
-0.37640368938446045,
-0.05175162851810455,
0.2560441195964813,
-0.07132607698440552,
-0.2189074456691742,
-0.10089065879583359,
0.3643797039985657,
0.26972657442092896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00463v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00463v1
|
Addressing Both Statistical and Causal Gender Fairness in NLP Models
| 2024-03-30T20:05:41 | 2024-03-30T20:05:41 |
Hannah Chen, Yangfeng Ji, David Evans
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Statistical fairness stipulates equivalent outcomes for every protected
group, whereas causal fairness prescribes that a model makes the same
prediction for an individual regardless of their protected characteristics.
Counterfactual data augmentation (CDA) is effective for reducing bias in NLP
models, yet models trained with CDA are often evaluated only on metrics that
are closely tied to the causal fairness notion; similarly, sampling-based
methods designed to promote statistical fairness are rarely evaluated for
causal fairness. In this work, we evaluate both statistical and causal
debiasing methods for gender bias in NLP models, and find that while such
methods are effective at reducing bias as measured by the targeted metric, they
do not necessarily improve results on other bias metrics. We demonstrate that
combinations of statistical and causal debiasing techniques are able to reduce
bias measured through both types of metrics.
|
[
-0.34335586428642273,
-0.7323178052902222,
0.5843653082847595,
0.38837167620658875,
0.1159541979432106,
-0.12213762104511261,
0.11418744176626205,
-0.437993586063385,
-0.012449163012206554,
0.4736083745956421,
-0.6028033494949341,
-0.2871033847332001,
-0.6763195395469666,
0.03714314103126526,
-0.37964335083961487,
0.9300217032432556,
0.38843393325805664,
0.7483102679252625,
-0.3520474135875702,
-0.1725422888994217,
-1.090508222579956,
-0.600617527961731,
-0.6118997931480408,
-0.4625302851200104,
0.2503160536289215,
0.030962670221924782,
0.8880796432495117,
0.24437162280082703,
0.6017957329750061,
0.2601369321346283,
-0.18548963963985443,
0.08373317122459412,
-0.4386884868144989,
-0.1387014538049698,
-0.499245822429657,
-0.6492960453033447,
-0.6092035174369812,
0.3947293758392334,
0.49645936489105225,
1.1684443950653076,
-0.13519935309886932,
0.4528781771659851,
0.11707273125648499,
0.7262625098228455,
-0.9563366770744324,
-0.11468600481748581,
-0.6444927453994751,
0.31776317954063416,
0.07677436619997025,
-0.3370986580848694,
-0.3384154736995697,
-0.4843011498451233,
0.13826340436935425,
-0.5105746388435364,
0.5470271706581116,
0.15081290900707245,
0.35510948300361633,
0.3546869456768036,
-0.6569786667823792,
0.1651032418012619,
-0.8570207357406616,
1.1319724321365356,
-0.7185121178627014,
0.2702041268348694,
0.624973714351654,
0.22168315947055817,
-0.06450715661048889,
-0.13428200781345367,
-0.7413648366928101,
-0.13762739300727844,
-0.39760127663612366,
0.02347535267472267,
-0.43984803557395935,
0.04499195143580437,
0.6351698040962219,
-0.03895413503050804,
-0.541509211063385,
0.31328198313713074,
-0.44365617632865906,
0.09866826236248016,
0.6687322854995728,
0.1229807436466217,
0.32238155603408813,
-0.2655635476112366,
-0.27451765537261963,
-0.10346465557813644,
-0.7131789326667786,
-0.17256423830986023,
0.7359252572059631,
0.287653386592865,
-0.16565006971359253,
0.5184651017189026,
-0.13685625791549683,
0.43148016929626465,
0.005951690021902323,
0.1175665333867073,
0.4378052055835724,
-0.04360417276620865,
-0.28468555212020874,
0.17184750735759735,
0.39245012402534485,
0.6930954456329346,
0.0940890908241272,
-0.4272083640098572,
0.08516934514045715,
0.4347592890262604,
0.3000265657901764,
-0.47764408588409424,
0.15603779256343842,
0.22804875671863556,
-0.8038793802261353,
-0.3917817771434784,
0.0625803992152214,
-0.8823390007019043,
-0.4327192008495331,
-0.5337534546852112,
0.31894955039024353,
0.1796400547027588,
-0.2057056427001953,
0.2674933969974518,
-0.655427098274231,
0.08095674961805344,
0.2029786854982376,
-0.9159759879112244,
0.4379473626613617,
0.8698641061782837,
0.5208078622817993,
0.08008909225463867,
0.06293646991252899,
-0.6217326521873474,
0.21015571057796478,
-0.5399291515350342,
0.4661860466003418,
-0.6366828083992004,
-0.19011779129505157,
-0.1878621131181717,
-0.06253999471664429,
-0.10798684507608414,
-0.49286067485809326,
0.4437493681907654,
-0.403496116399765,
0.48335570096969604,
-0.71734619140625,
-0.35548707842826843,
-0.3398418724536896,
0.0507337786257267,
-0.7012822031974792,
0.6907049417495728,
-0.08137019723653793,
-1.0684922933578491,
1.0613772869110107,
-0.6395460367202759,
-0.24279306828975677,
-0.43046626448631287,
-0.13067854940891266,
-0.46404916048049927,
0.27953383326530457,
0.39196497201919556,
0.08529035747051239,
-0.485216349363327,
0.7979040145874023,
-0.72111576795578,
-0.3070314824581146,
0.23270981013774872,
-0.7989431619644165,
1.0046497583389282,
0.020257974043488503,
-0.516964852809906,
-0.012870971113443375,
-0.8064841628074646,
-0.27222302556037903,
0.10715147852897644,
0.24642987549304962,
-0.5746690034866333,
0.16684864461421967,
0.08907098323106766,
0.3351741135120392,
-0.17098282277584076,
-0.6504284739494324,
-0.17967887222766876,
-0.3740813136100769,
-0.13829940557479858,
0.8586810231208801,
-0.41581106185913086,
0.6577487587928772,
-0.610298752784729,
0.3600378930568695,
-0.06024864315986633,
0.2779301106929779,
0.6469133496284485,
-0.5110583901405334,
-0.5403168201446533,
-0.34493589401245117,
0.37126317620277405,
0.7111173868179321,
-0.6465557217597961,
0.5332788228988647,
-0.10511477291584015,
-0.28892087936401367,
-0.4428316354751587,
-0.17094287276268005,
0.4968932867050171,
0.801214337348938,
0.7558456063270569,
-0.4861907660961151,
-0.5544291734695435,
-0.9113399386405945,
-0.7184733748435974,
-0.26570597290992737,
-0.236551433801651,
0.058223024010658264,
0.34500983357429504,
0.07631842792034149,
1.1754497289657593,
-0.44997429847717285,
-0.5122312903404236,
0.0026041280943900347,
0.20513835549354553,
0.2776154577732086,
0.937351405620575,
1.0781540870666504,
-0.7717888951301575,
0.010844666510820389,
-0.6617779731750488,
-0.79548579454422,
-0.512696385383606,
0.022607605904340744,
-0.11736835539340973,
0.16964653134346008,
0.2476625293493271,
-0.21558906137943268,
0.9675690531730652,
0.29616981744766235,
-0.6860938668251038,
0.38467803597450256,
-0.06093023717403412,
0.619757890701294,
-0.3239503502845764,
-0.03529493138194084,
0.07366514950990677,
-0.2965298593044281,
-0.7342206239700317,
-0.019590912386775017,
-0.2249971181154251,
0.2957935035228729,
-0.4665507376194,
0.6058407425880432,
-0.08203380554914474,
-0.1924431174993515,
-0.3662683665752411,
0.05604696273803711,
0.14199630916118622,
0.17731092870235443,
0.05554874241352081,
0.25830262899398804,
0.307373970746994,
-0.5565821528434753,
0.024976667016744614,
0.378351628780365,
-0.08891206979751587,
0.9549888372421265,
-0.7532453536987305,
-0.0694943442940712,
-0.652579665184021,
0.46824198961257935,
-0.9738696217536926,
0.39630553126335144,
0.2584426701068878,
-0.41351720690727234,
-0.06231217086315155,
-0.09921610355377197,
-0.5161007642745972,
-0.32447168231010437,
-0.42528364062309265,
0.6094399094581604,
0.6420636773109436,
-0.7592166066169739,
0.33650311827659607,
0.32945066690444946,
0.08111890405416489,
-0.9022880792617798,
-1.110418677330017,
-0.10005934536457062,
-0.5668815970420837,
-0.4408477246761322,
0.5584867596626282,
0.005428136792033911,
-0.5012726783752441,
0.020529834553599358,
-0.04096432030200958,
-0.03999677300453186,
0.06775086373090744,
0.1014673188328743,
0.34926798939704895,
0.27402162551879883,
0.2860351800918579,
0.3346860408782959,
-0.3710106909275055,
0.11292863637208939,
0.041780244559049606,
0.48753899335861206,
0.4663825035095215,
-0.5165756940841675,
-0.40273699164390564,
0.4973317086696625,
-0.2829223871231079,
0.03384683281183243,
1.0358809232711792,
0.8503090143203735,
-0.4818532466888428,
0.025282857939600945,
-0.7737166285514832,
-0.44256705045700073,
-0.3993755877017975,
0.10007252544164658,
-0.08718737214803696,
-0.6732040643692017,
0.5678547620773315,
0.3739478886127472,
0.19369946420192719,
0.5003570914268494,
0.32389897108078003,
0.06637975573539734,
1.2250674962997437,
0.46832334995269775,
0.024792123585939407,
0.23555710911750793,
0.039041660726070404,
0.2716153860092163,
-0.6724129319190979,
-0.04982632398605347,
-0.9771733283996582,
-0.41591876745224,
-0.7996001839637756,
-0.3263349235057831,
0.1213429868221283,
0.10032027959823608,
-0.5178472399711609,
-0.017735255882143974,
-0.5379194021224976,
0.24501579999923706,
0.8060727119445801,
0.42044684290885925,
0.395306795835495,
0.004960314370691776,
0.37310972809791565,
-0.43490615487098694,
-0.8158349394798279,
-0.45071378350257874,
1.4375094175338745,
0.414278119802475,
0.646796464920044,
0.3457913398742676,
0.3248765468597412,
0.5697309374809265,
0.2209949493408203,
0.02669277787208557,
0.42474260926246643,
-0.5777997970581055,
-1.010050892829895,
-0.20449857413768768,
-0.833599328994751,
-0.7162095904350281,
0.5397389531135559,
-0.7238139510154724,
-0.6966166496276855,
0.7578344941139221,
0.295040100812912,
0.038499318063259125,
0.46742549538612366,
-0.5723057389259338,
0.6002194881439209,
0.19670818746089935,
-0.42671874165534973,
-0.5071460008621216,
-0.4343007206916809,
0.5227047204971313,
-0.006813629064708948,
0.40648767352104187,
-0.33359596133232117,
0.16634714603424072,
0.8900969624519348,
-0.5884295105934143,
0.8231715559959412,
-0.4909955561161041,
-0.10696161538362503,
-0.14606353640556335,
-0.1131715252995491,
0.048234425485134125,
0.21572768688201904,
-0.11893238872289658,
0.5356243848800659,
-0.048471998423337936,
-0.5316343307495117,
-0.616956889629364,
0.4582425355911255,
-0.4778544306755066,
-0.6210635304450989,
-0.45033183693885803,
-0.5737870931625366,
-0.2370629459619522,
-0.009799736551940441,
-0.31741487979888916,
0.39724281430244446,
-0.19675007462501526,
0.03618131950497627,
0.503553569316864,
-0.829778790473938,
0.40796831250190735,
0.6570473909378052,
-0.15847039222717285,
-0.12219609320163727,
0.15766987204551697,
0.162037193775177,
0.3027082085609436,
0.3486013114452362,
0.20739948749542236,
-0.44454890489578247,
-0.16509157419204712,
-0.10416335612535477,
-0.09521448612213135,
-0.6760156750679016,
-0.1338178515434265,
-0.8071208000183105,
0.2026619017124176,
-0.7483318448066711,
-0.18743740022182465,
-0.17200542986392975,
-0.7716600894927979,
0.034597862511873245,
-0.23050656914710999,
0.28907689452171326,
0.14235226809978485,
-0.5969725847244263,
0.49314770102500916,
-0.36419859528541565,
0.9507111310958862,
0.48183146119117737,
0.07727415859699249,
0.2120572179555893,
-0.47949087619781494,
0.4670078456401825,
0.09685204923152924,
-0.14452916383743286,
-0.871881365776062,
0.42841991782188416,
-0.1962093859910965,
0.36935916543006897,
0.05132617801427841,
0.23341616988182068,
0.6985043287277222,
-0.5730957388877869,
0.7093707323074341,
0.44165951013565063,
-1.1827943325042725,
0.5230928659439087,
-0.12879638373851776,
-0.08339380472898483,
0.3829481303691864,
0.15771453082561493,
-0.19345872104167938,
-0.542390763759613,
-0.5305337309837341,
-0.7432187795639038,
0.7858526110649109,
0.45390209555625916,
0.09058912098407745,
-0.1474895477294922,
0.1945399045944214,
0.15248411893844604,
0.45569902658462524,
-0.8556365966796875,
-0.5958176255226135,
0.10388275980949402,
-0.11321747303009033,
-0.04914035275578499,
-0.23858614265918732,
-0.3750174641609192,
-0.24356330931186676,
0.6486058831214905,
0.09934277087450027,
0.1075669452548027,
0.2874900996685028,
-0.0819336399435997,
-0.01592576690018177,
0.35162845253944397,
0.25425785779953003,
0.9066913723945618,
-0.35559698939323425,
-0.0008656344725750387,
0.42600488662719727,
-0.3253180682659149,
0.23079456388950348,
0.27578967809677124,
-0.5712059140205383,
0.1144072636961937,
0.38375160098075867,
0.72639000415802,
-0.09512235969305038,
-0.3350015878677368,
0.5583558678627014,
-0.13231664896011353,
-0.10087594389915466,
-0.01952703855931759,
0.028380917385220528,
-0.3828827142715454,
0.38031429052352905,
0.4362115263938904,
0.05666626617312431,
0.5705205798149109,
-0.393707275390625,
0.14526651799678802,
0.6490049362182617,
-0.5165579915046692,
0.1812429577112198,
1.0605196952819824,
0.03637971356511116,
0.07759486138820648,
0.32922714948654175,
-0.056627485901117325,
-0.20123083889484406,
0.9894299507141113,
0.6349391341209412,
0.7950693368911743,
-0.19538889825344086,
0.3779957592487335,
0.5060884356498718,
0.6371158957481384,
-0.018211882561445236,
0.15198369324207306,
0.27310097217559814,
-0.6985158920288086,
-0.40591490268707275,
-0.37503722310066223,
-0.2197570651769638,
-0.1965695172548294,
-0.7108295559883118,
0.22160878777503967,
-0.15841642022132874,
-0.41278937458992004,
0.05774915963411331,
-0.01297601405531168,
-0.9847526550292969,
0.5945500135421753,
-0.22794806957244873,
0.48757678270339966,
-1.1040892601013184,
0.19352145493030548,
0.2420179545879364,
-0.5066593885421753,
-0.3491414785385132,
-0.2101534754037857,
0.026509158313274384,
-0.5270493030548096,
0.8380705714225769,
0.07348597794771194,
0.06624383479356766,
-0.575974702835083,
-0.2873031795024872,
-0.453767865896225,
0.8207354545593262,
0.6114479303359985,
-0.6239843964576721,
0.1551770716905594,
0.49514901638031006,
0.338776558637619,
-0.0415659062564373,
0.6635774374008179,
0.5868241786956787,
0.6473207473754883,
-0.49628108739852905,
-1.0968883037567139,
0.2191564440727234,
0.147768035531044,
0.1770077347755432,
-0.19879744946956635,
-0.32418954372406006,
0.5634567141532898,
-0.10929767787456512,
-0.028881043195724487,
-0.23562833666801453,
0.5311585068702698,
0.5676376223564148,
0.7282811999320984,
0.9201695919036865,
0.717234194278717,
0.6879779696464539,
-0.22665365040302277,
0.9006519913673401,
0.24396589398384094,
0.3122921288013458,
1.1039727926254272,
-0.4007720947265625,
0.13874399662017822,
0.3166869580745697,
-0.583524763584137,
0.19727212190628052,
0.3346879482269287,
0.10419559478759766,
0.530247688293457,
0.27546676993370056,
0.019133521243929863,
-0.09041984379291534,
-0.2673639953136444,
-0.6530662178993225,
0.4301222264766693,
-0.060404401272535324,
-0.3224635720252991,
-0.21406283974647522,
-0.023648701608181,
0.365107923746109,
0.4036320149898529,
-0.4123223125934601,
0.6000444293022156,
0.06346321105957031,
-0.4328242838382721,
0.132802352309227,
0.23149658739566803,
0.8217595815658569,
-0.3346294164657593,
-0.11925170570611954,
-0.19448477029800415,
0.02271747589111328,
-0.34614741802215576,
-0.46969524025917053,
0.5631007552146912,
0.11949654668569565,
-0.5665521025657654,
-0.08463113754987717,
0.6976282000541687,
-0.3962908685207367,
-0.586845338344574,
0.4967721104621887,
0.5113519430160522,
-0.25031691789627075,
0.2153409868478775,
-0.6727400422096252,
-0.3411202132701874,
-0.24382328987121582,
0.02615980990231037,
0.12906411290168762,
0.06261879950761795,
-0.1728130280971527,
0.6764894723892212,
0.8265005946159363,
0.2283516377210617,
0.06323636323213577,
0.5708901882171631,
0.49633556604385376,
-0.6745217442512512,
-0.6734811067581177,
-0.9297782182693481,
0.309002161026001,
-0.3849369287490845,
-0.04556749388575554,
0.7421080470085144,
0.22280395030975342,
0.6125149130821228,
-0.12722504138946533,
0.5201510787010193,
0.05658400431275368,
0.6486043930053711,
-0.6282610893249512,
0.7248391509056091,
-0.5192323923110962,
0.40747886896133423,
-0.8895787000656128,
-1.1292617321014404,
-0.5399704575538635,
0.5138193964958191,
-0.5284663438796997,
0.4407918453216553,
0.39193668961524963,
0.6299343109130859,
0.04736851155757904,
0.10888025909662247,
0.1245986744761467,
-0.14185230433940887,
0.4768944978713989,
0.4902172088623047,
0.5927484631538391,
-0.6152005791664124,
-0.09522794187068939,
-0.07972127944231033,
-0.4632832407951355,
0.17841781675815582,
-1.055586576461792,
-0.9483215808868408,
-0.14612364768981934,
-0.35696840286254883,
-0.18789750337600708,
0.41432616114616394,
0.5846855640411377,
0.7889766097068787,
-0.6834210157394409,
0.14780336618423462,
-0.0545046366751194,
0.5096254944801331,
-0.34874385595321655,
-0.2618372142314911,
0.4295777678489685,
-0.3401068150997162,
-0.8367999196052551,
0.008309969678521156,
0.007974803447723389,
-0.3641546666622162,
-0.2568940818309784,
0.24906499683856964,
-0.12612983584403992,
0.34732586145401,
0.5360565781593323,
-0.25968486070632935,
-0.314368337392807,
-0.30970513820648193,
-0.5065704584121704,
0.1853756457567215,
-0.31728309392929077,
0.5428428053855896,
-1.0483217239379883,
0.3774150311946869,
0.7223548889160156,
0.3892673850059509,
0.0895301029086113,
0.09933774173259735,
0.7939180135726929,
-0.5929647088050842,
0.5554060339927673,
-0.06772860884666443,
0.29964184761047363,
0.21867549419403076,
-0.3920738995075226,
0.8076235055923462,
0.1926242709159851,
-0.44082173705101013,
-1.0473672151565552,
0.2571946084499359,
-0.7100547552108765,
-0.506975531578064,
0.926231861114502,
0.11624697595834732,
0.26281043887138367,
-0.3585653007030487,
0.03166006878018379,
0.28825050592422485,
-0.1269131302833557,
0.9933058619499207,
0.34955257177352905,
0.18254858255386353,
0.2806488275527954,
-0.7380769848823547,
0.4141845703125,
0.8007388710975647,
-0.7667431235313416,
-0.18898077309131622,
0.5973301529884338,
0.016483791172504425,
-0.06826569885015488,
0.7295963764190674,
-0.2466173619031906,
0.35862094163894653,
-0.045923832803964615,
0.029462704434990883,
0.28812119364738464,
-0.08987777680158615,
-0.3021504282951355,
0.06614471226930618,
-0.5365034341812134,
-0.1467389017343521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00461v1
|
Shortcuts Arising from Contrast: Effective and Covert Clean-Label Attacks in Prompt-Based Learning
| 2024-03-30T20:02:36 | 2024-03-30T20:02:36 |
Xiaopeng Xie, Ming Yan, Xiwen Zhou, Chenlong Zhao, Suli Wang, Yong Zhang, Joey Tianyi Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Prompt-based learning paradigm has demonstrated remarkable efficacy in
enhancing the adaptability of pretrained language models (PLMs), particularly
in few-shot scenarios. However, this learning paradigm has been shown to be
vulnerable to backdoor attacks. The current clean-label attack, employing a
specific prompt as a trigger, can achieve success without the need for external
triggers and ensure correct labeling of poisoned samples, which is more
stealthy compared to the poisoned-label attack, but on the other hand, it faces
significant issues with false activations and poses greater challenges,
necessitating a higher rate of poisoning. Using conventional negative data
augmentation methods, we discovered that it is challenging to trade off between
effectiveness and stealthiness in a clean-label setting. In addressing this
issue, we are inspired by the notion that a backdoor acts as a shortcut and
posit that this shortcut stems from the contrast between the trigger and the
data utilized for poisoning. In this study, we propose a method named
Contrastive Shortcut Injection (CSI), by leveraging activation values,
integrates trigger design and data selection strategies to craft stronger
shortcut features. With extensive experiments on full-shot and few-shot text
classification tasks, we empirically validate CSI's high effectiveness and high
stealthiness at low poisoning rates. Notably, we found that the two approaches
play leading roles in full-shot and few-shot settings, respectively.
|
[
-0.16925238072872162,
-0.6894448399543762,
0.6442593336105347,
-0.12985999882221222,
-0.3575485050678253,
0.08952121436595917,
-0.06978994607925415,
-0.23413366079330444,
-0.009952234104275703,
0.26498672366142273,
-0.6212136149406433,
-0.8845990300178528,
-0.5287767052650452,
0.13025864958763123,
-0.131971076130867,
1.1555509567260742,
0.22526463866233826,
-0.14552254974842072,
0.21651104092597961,
-0.30872049927711487,
-0.690400242805481,
-0.6073253154754639,
-0.6791518926620483,
-0.15383532643318176,
0.9301202297210693,
0.4485939145088196,
0.8333590626716614,
0.5610406994819641,
0.25872567296028137,
0.18651194870471954,
-0.1571628749370575,
-0.2965252697467804,
-0.4444253742694855,
-0.032629940658807755,
-0.523655354976654,
-0.6328290104866028,
0.07130137830972672,
0.20549975335597992,
0.46093297004699707,
0.6175556778907776,
0.2924853563308716,
-0.1102895438671112,
0.3653387129306793,
0.5592002868652344,
-1.0453282594680786,
-0.3354804217815399,
-0.5127450227737427,
-0.06389729678630829,
-0.32243070006370544,
-0.09569883346557617,
-0.47906410694122314,
-0.2689705789089203,
0.018597805872559547,
-0.6557486057281494,
-0.01420433260500431,
-0.06001807004213333,
0.7735720276832581,
0.29894545674324036,
-0.49673837423324585,
-0.46252986788749695,
-0.1662231683731079,
0.8757650256156921,
-0.6082119941711426,
0.31686002016067505,
0.17109645903110504,
0.40492621064186096,
-0.23080331087112427,
-0.6813591122627258,
-0.32239800691604614,
-0.11890868842601776,
-0.3229694962501526,
0.15078935027122498,
-0.03127075731754303,
0.2594103515148163,
0.352532297372818,
0.09154658019542694,
-0.6056666374206543,
0.5642678737640381,
-0.1788926124572754,
-0.47057288885116577,
0.2204151451587677,
0.4397309422492981,
0.39185068011283875,
-0.21615619957447052,
-0.5650082230567932,
-0.26565390825271606,
-1.0505255460739136,
0.2664680480957031,
0.5284145474433899,
0.5180801153182983,
-0.1536761373281479,
0.282042533159256,
-0.2566329538822174,
0.7564221620559692,
-0.1677360236644745,
-0.12249797582626343,
0.24026817083358765,
-0.5744529366493225,
-0.06469877809286118,
0.06280086934566498,
0.7669118642807007,
0.18325549364089966,
-0.043380510061979294,
0.15551139414310455,
-0.15047571063041687,
0.12373051792383194,
-0.09753498435020447,
-1.180379867553711,
-0.4525741934776306,
0.21653831005096436,
-0.39534395933151245,
-0.5541356205940247,
-0.14501191675662994,
-0.8558419346809387,
-0.4226967990398407,
0.05041485279798508,
0.7491081357002258,
-0.3637748956680298,
0.2556418776512146,
-0.08087654411792755,
-0.5066309571266174,
0.30901190638542175,
0.34681496024131775,
-0.5452705025672913,
0.27943217754364014,
0.6073253154754639,
0.8587411046028137,
-0.3238712549209595,
-0.1936943084001541,
-0.8550883531570435,
0.12934920191764832,
-0.31381797790527344,
0.5654205083847046,
-0.7315977811813354,
-0.6591179370880127,
-0.03749840334057808,
-0.14747624099254608,
0.10499876737594604,
-0.6189053058624268,
0.3336159884929657,
-0.42390480637550354,
0.4782150685787201,
-0.37367579340934753,
-0.24672000110149384,
-0.12042771279811859,
0.4052553176879883,
-0.5599701404571533,
0.6569113731384277,
-0.14716771245002747,
-0.7861971855163574,
0.3135392367839813,
-0.51133131980896,
-0.622080385684967,
-0.04855409264564514,
-0.16413544118404388,
-0.5364738702774048,
-0.08760973066091537,
0.16839218139648438,
0.17205028235912323,
0.1189669594168663,
-0.09818308800458908,
-0.28793710470199585,
-0.6692184805870056,
0.3051082491874695,
-0.42584070563316345,
1.0805333852767944,
0.1350211650133133,
-0.3321438133716583,
0.15104539692401886,
-0.7656662464141846,
-0.12772256135940552,
-0.003246356500312686,
-0.17438186705112457,
-0.7192949652671814,
-0.2840364873409271,
-0.4010930359363556,
0.4506095051765442,
-0.007728065829724073,
-0.3990325331687927,
0.10425552725791931,
-0.6164425611495972,
-0.0789923369884491,
0.5943949818611145,
0.5313939452171326,
0.5091307163238525,
-0.32018089294433594,
0.49056559801101685,
0.23995348811149597,
0.2911873459815979,
-0.7041807174682617,
-0.4087807536125183,
-0.466836154460907,
-0.6794882416725159,
0.2781558036804199,
0.8090769648551941,
-1.1065963506698608,
0.13514865934848785,
0.16827800869941711,
-0.5234209895133972,
-0.44568344950675964,
0.20563893020153046,
0.8628828525543213,
0.9567587375640869,
0.7128006815910339,
-0.22404246032238007,
0.021543625742197037,
-0.787586510181427,
-0.7439101934432983,
0.05823838710784912,
-0.21403768658638,
0.37067463994026184,
0.4396141767501831,
-0.10908778011798859,
0.7259443402290344,
-0.8284310698509216,
-0.3488621413707733,
-0.16550062596797943,
0.3253852427005768,
0.2504594922065735,
0.49436211585998535,
0.5189544558525085,
-0.5918381810188293,
-0.5763292908668518,
-0.5365942120552063,
-0.534511148929596,
-0.33943140506744385,
-0.38051837682724,
0.01970456726849079,
-0.24358020722866058,
0.5034445524215698,
-0.14763695001602173,
0.6827936172485352,
0.10486665368080139,
-0.09881541132926941,
0.5857324004173279,
0.0852091908454895,
0.18484359979629517,
-0.9427541494369507,
0.09278645366430283,
-0.06600938737392426,
0.11143695563077927,
-0.9486268162727356,
0.14922261238098145,
0.3308924734592438,
-0.5095492601394653,
-1.2163609266281128,
0.9204607605934143,
-0.40440037846565247,
0.24120746552944183,
-0.2899428904056549,
-0.06963825225830078,
0.22314049303531647,
0.6514461636543274,
-0.033818360418081284,
0.8694301247596741,
0.4878508448600769,
-0.7326211333274841,
-0.07490327209234238,
0.25211822986602783,
-0.030694277957081795,
0.5614716410636902,
-0.4999319612979889,
0.12014351040124893,
0.02102685160934925,
0.3954325020313263,
-0.9781029224395752,
-0.08796923607587814,
0.7139192819595337,
-0.17251062393188477,
0.47079262137413025,
-0.09723395109176636,
-0.4104720950126648,
0.030049152672290802,
-0.8332899808883667,
0.5813755393028259,
0.6922174692153931,
-0.860672116279602,
0.2675699293613434,
-0.36631304025650024,
-0.1914529949426651,
-0.7915529608726501,
-0.5839930772781372,
0.11078447848558426,
-0.3835674524307251,
-0.31830042600631714,
0.3312373757362366,
-0.09039716422557831,
-0.1942761391401291,
-0.2927238345146179,
-0.12235137075185776,
0.08346839994192123,
0.45495909452438354,
0.19461844861507416,
0.16322223842144012,
0.09774729609489441,
0.07686471194028854,
0.367429256439209,
-0.2636793553829193,
-0.09409323334693909,
0.28708359599113464,
0.08014217019081116,
0.1486913412809372,
-0.32138970494270325,
-0.8684695363044739,
0.5102260708808899,
0.2406429946422577,
-0.20177064836025238,
0.7050966620445251,
0.08159713447093964,
-0.017615223303437233,
-0.3781515657901764,
-0.14989537000656128,
-0.6890095472335815,
-0.5916927456855774,
0.16715432703495026,
-0.3935151994228363,
-0.45007747411727905,
0.5017065405845642,
-0.27036142349243164,
-0.07490984350442886,
0.004053374286741018,
0.09728767722845078,
-0.23960450291633606,
0.6126134991645813,
0.349420964717865,
0.1666470170021057,
0.7566377520561218,
-0.009813761338591576,
0.02239760383963585,
-0.6764930486679077,
-0.14339086413383484,
-0.6006961464881897,
-0.29801979660987854,
-0.45384082198143005,
-0.00487971305847168,
0.37692132592201233,
0.11849363893270493,
-0.20342501997947693,
0.10272905230522156,
-0.3018210232257843,
0.6152510643005371,
0.5973979234695435,
0.4098120331764221,
0.08145630359649658,
-0.32676830887794495,
-0.2856485843658447,
-0.20107313990592957,
-0.5953509211540222,
-0.23708543181419373,
0.8382331132888794,
0.1808459311723709,
0.9542243480682373,
-0.08301591128110886,
1.156399130821228,
-0.01607036218047142,
0.2459813803434372,
-0.7361879348754883,
0.621557891368866,
-0.029788559302687645,
-0.5247591733932495,
-0.11405221372842789,
-0.16516956686973572,
-0.9438135027885437,
0.2614760398864746,
-0.2512878477573395,
-0.44484537839889526,
0.45447397232055664,
0.3323237895965576,
-0.4910462498664856,
-0.07073531299829483,
-1.1071515083312988,
1.0299674272537231,
-0.32789307832717896,
-0.7159734964370728,
0.1330445110797882,
-1.1455014944076538,
0.42019152641296387,
-0.2837572395801544,
0.24831676483154297,
0.14797049760818481,
-0.28911277651786804,
0.7104324102401733,
-0.5247581005096436,
1.1370993852615356,
-0.2328246384859085,
0.11504730582237244,
0.2206054925918579,
0.20179243385791779,
0.6243455410003662,
-0.21472325921058655,
0.11892805993556976,
0.19629476964473724,
-0.4902311861515045,
-0.4676665663719177,
-0.7962659001350403,
0.36158186197280884,
-0.33905836939811707,
-0.8653884530067444,
-0.4790208041667938,
-0.20791901648044586,
-0.2908519506454468,
0.2891230583190918,
0.44954365491867065,
0.593904972076416,
-0.08051235228776932,
-0.10249808430671692,
0.7292363047599792,
-0.7780398726463318,
0.6504473090171814,
0.552601158618927,
0.2242927849292755,
-0.5145724415779114,
1.0890703201293945,
0.0051033711060881615,
0.6951934099197388,
0.4211760461330414,
0.4319891035556793,
-0.2353818267583847,
-0.6499080657958984,
-0.032842300832271576,
0.2205713391304016,
-0.9286958575248718,
-0.403586208820343,
-0.3569534122943878,
-0.030542317777872086,
-0.31890997290611267,
-0.45159193873405457,
-0.11667110025882721,
-0.22286249697208405,
-0.5944254994392395,
-0.01082379836589098,
0.009659996256232262,
0.19702425599098206,
-0.20759204030036926,
0.578956663608551,
-0.8195434212684631,
0.5225910544395447,
0.42718127369880676,
-0.03563977777957916,
-0.23863980174064636,
-0.3613610565662384,
-0.1253085732460022,
-0.10208325833082199,
-0.44489961862564087,
-1.4265421628952026,
0.30084478855133057,
0.16908635199069977,
0.4777243733406067,
0.4514100253582001,
0.4213711619377136,
0.412662535905838,
-0.5228504538536072,
0.9279274344444275,
0.3451032042503357,
-0.8728720545768738,
0.8232194781303406,
-0.08252570778131485,
0.5136117339134216,
0.8895397782325745,
0.526451051235199,
-0.38871872425079346,
-0.6076087951660156,
-0.4243102967739105,
-0.8427357077598572,
0.4845081865787506,
0.08333940804004669,
-0.06444329023361206,
0.014842290431261063,
-0.031325388699769974,
0.4536193311214447,
0.32924607396125793,
-0.4842849671840668,
-0.361501544713974,
-0.32053622603416443,
-0.3364887237548828,
0.037218641489744186,
-0.206833153963089,
-0.09737909585237503,
0.16595371067523956,
0.5604043006896973,
-0.00018101181194651872,
-0.14112435281276703,
-0.024749524891376495,
-0.27497419714927673,
0.6330397725105286,
0.8056933879852295,
0.472782164812088,
0.30312249064445496,
-0.10319361835718155,
0.3138408958911896,
0.07819662243127823,
-0.5329321622848511,
0.2998608350753784,
0.19608306884765625,
-0.3972915709018707,
0.05878926068544388,
0.3596622347831726,
0.4845777451992035,
0.5076583623886108,
-0.5422767996788025,
0.78988116979599,
0.2461131364107132,
0.2324526458978653,
0.42371973395347595,
0.318482369184494,
-0.4158343970775604,
0.017378486692905426,
0.3171284794807434,
-0.052440956234931946,
0.3442442715167999,
-0.6805009245872498,
0.18754693865776062,
0.4659098982810974,
-0.3440154790878296,
-0.28343260288238525,
0.2836579978466034,
0.38825514912605286,
-0.3398803174495697,
0.6021480560302734,
-0.019636282697319984,
-0.8108437657356262,
0.4588674306869507,
0.4239480197429657,
0.9028762578964233,
-0.49393078684806824,
0.03923598676919937,
0.24492433667182922,
0.3040809631347656,
0.31587663292884827,
0.11478486657142639,
-0.39289480447769165,
-0.3985508680343628,
-0.06084469333291054,
-0.2312517762184143,
-0.47497808933258057,
0.07101254910230637,
-0.6855363249778748,
0.4179072678089142,
-0.45264932513237,
0.1813758760690689,
-0.11103645712137222,
-0.026786016300320625,
-0.5307945609092712,
0.3827502727508545,
-0.18287673592567444,
1.0526493787765503,
-1.190011739730835,
0.8704586029052734,
0.23411276936531067,
-0.4795505702495575,
-0.5947327613830566,
0.3081664741039276,
0.1082555428147316,
-0.6435059309005737,
0.7605106830596924,
0.3931996524333954,
-0.07005194574594498,
-0.16635040938854218,
-0.6231609582901001,
-0.32085201144218445,
0.7417567372322083,
0.09726960211992264,
-0.4797965884208679,
-0.1219906210899353,
0.1177295595407486,
0.37654003500938416,
0.15124942362308502,
-0.09093748778104782,
0.5085840225219727,
0.3528653681278229,
0.18036895990371704,
-0.5227063298225403,
0.3759349584579468,
0.02909848280251026,
-0.31287819147109985,
0.20626786351203918,
-0.4104793965816498,
0.5147960782051086,
-0.32753491401672363,
-0.5007064342498779,
-0.03802667558193207,
0.4601658880710602,
0.4082212746143341,
0.7453874945640564,
0.23571088910102844,
0.4593459665775299,
0.5437769889831543,
0.03619842976331711,
0.8609463572502136,
0.04784687981009483,
-0.23162660002708435,
1.4963319301605225,
-0.30592966079711914,
0.7769939303398132,
0.6988963484764099,
0.23544859886169434,
0.5575484037399292,
0.580062210559845,
-0.07543616741895676,
1.2019823789596558,
0.13270056247711182,
-0.3160630762577057,
0.028499990701675415,
-0.15028585493564606,
-0.4455958306789398,
0.0485057532787323,
0.6839414238929749,
-0.29977014660835266,
-0.4205566942691803,
0.3706754744052887,
0.24020922183990479,
0.08555535972118378,
-0.4084617495536804,
0.951434314250946,
0.277221143245697,
-0.5285372734069824,
0.48923778533935547,
-0.25347545742988586,
0.7855457663536072,
-0.6654474139213562,
-0.12082050740718842,
-0.30405154824256897,
-0.1550525277853012,
-0.2158270627260208,
-0.8714589476585388,
0.14355406165122986,
-0.12451840192079544,
0.29483962059020996,
-0.25977349281311035,
0.8529025316238403,
-0.3564561903476715,
0.19298993051052094,
0.05623658001422882,
0.240988090634346,
0.019245319068431854,
-0.010233784094452858,
-0.6923505067825317,
0.1572737842798233,
-0.14438919723033905,
-0.046535711735486984,
0.40658754110336304,
0.21901331841945648,
0.1056440994143486,
0.35180941224098206,
0.57308429479599,
0.03243589028716087,
0.13287335634231567,
-0.2964513301849365,
1.0248212814331055,
-0.7662001848220825,
-0.9026270508766174,
-0.8200438618659973,
0.5775822401046753,
-0.12037614732980728,
-0.1786165088415146,
0.9401955008506775,
0.5985181331634521,
0.6976936459541321,
-0.01710178703069687,
0.653339684009552,
0.683892011642456,
0.4626602232456207,
-0.6569167971611023,
0.7379406690597534,
-0.43084853887557983,
0.34280291199684143,
-0.34435519576072693,
-0.5912255048751831,
-0.4021212160587311,
-0.03053865395486355,
-0.49239659309387207,
-0.0723930224776268,
1.0325795412063599,
0.946773886680603,
0.03049476444721222,
-0.25249359011650085,
0.394321084022522,
0.10973850637674332,
0.5094922184944153,
0.6973668336868286,
0.9553166627883911,
-0.3341713547706604,
0.7133527398109436,
-0.4131453037261963,
-0.30724069476127625,
-0.23841983079910278,
-0.9289201498031616,
-1.2246464490890503,
-0.2214706391096115,
-0.40571197867393494,
-0.506750762462616,
0.42132583260536194,
0.5105755925178528,
0.3423464298248291,
-0.674150288105011,
0.30492523312568665,
0.05054355412721634,
0.4984801709651947,
-0.11311496794223785,
-0.20359212160110474,
0.5007040500640869,
-0.4137328565120697,
-0.4826967716217041,
0.6267277598381042,
0.29916420578956604,
0.45844051241874695,
0.2020559012889862,
0.06628090143203735,
0.07067413628101349,
0.19026194512844086,
0.14718352258205414,
0.7348328828811646,
-0.4750021696090698,
-0.1673078089952469,
-0.27787095308303833,
-0.3651120960712433,
-0.009264158084988594,
0.9073541164398193,
-1.1085094213485718,
0.5209094882011414,
0.5982294678688049,
0.654351532459259,
0.24366417527198792,
0.06919275224208832,
0.3199959397315979,
-1.0836849212646484,
0.4222949147224426,
0.3630923926830292,
0.003890840569511056,
0.4390667676925659,
-0.40022948384284973,
0.12976862490177155,
0.2539174556732178,
-0.07346733659505844,
-0.9271510243415833,
0.48349905014038086,
-0.7918479442596436,
-0.721527636051178,
1.2596170902252197,
-0.15877097845077515,
-0.4036884307861328,
-0.3093688488006592,
-0.2571685016155243,
0.17367172241210938,
-0.3891575336456299,
0.5427101850509644,
0.2782771587371826,
0.026165012270212173,
0.19980871677398682,
-0.08382544666528702,
0.8282135725021362,
0.28640925884246826,
-0.9527710676193237,
-0.20149657130241394,
0.5523034930229187,
0.36613866686820984,
0.16588792204856873,
0.193374365568161,
-0.01711004599928856,
0.4952991008758545,
0.05660271272063255,
-0.3761520981788635,
-0.3388842046260834,
-0.6265103220939636,
-0.7246999144554138,
0.4409775733947754,
-0.2504815459251404,
-0.6478032469749451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00459v1
|
NumeroLogic: Number Encoding for Enhanced LLMs' Numerical Reasoning
| 2024-03-30T19:46:59 | 2024-03-30T19:46:59 |
Eli Schwartz, Leshem Choshen, Joseph Shtok, Sivan Doveh, Leonid Karlinsky, Assaf Arbelle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models struggle with handling numerical data and performing
arithmetic operations. We hypothesize that this limitation can be partially
attributed to non-intuitive textual numbers representation. When a digit is
read or generated by a causal language model it does not know its place value
(e.g. thousands vs. hundreds) until the entire number is processed. To address
this issue, we propose a simple adjustment to how numbers are represented by
including the count of digits before each number. For instance, instead of
"42", we suggest using "{2:42}" as the new format. This approach, which we term
NumeroLogic, offers an added advantage in number generation by serving as a
Chain of Thought (CoT). By requiring the model to consider the number of digits
first, it enhances the reasoning process before generating the actual number.
We use arithmetic tasks to demonstrate the effectiveness of the NumeroLogic
formatting. We further demonstrate NumeroLogic applicability to general natural
language modeling, improving language understanding performance in the MMLU
benchmark.
|
[
-0.5108844041824341,
-0.6111756563186646,
0.6386780142784119,
0.40720757842063904,
-0.7500733733177185,
-0.12987789511680603,
-0.2746298015117645,
-0.15757399797439575,
0.21042829751968384,
0.7819926738739014,
-0.44710469245910645,
-0.5340514183044434,
-0.4995157718658447,
0.7184450626373291,
0.07704073190689087,
0.7628790736198425,
0.2340133935213089,
0.23906761407852173,
-0.25318312644958496,
-0.165070578455925,
-0.2714826166629791,
-0.8915011286735535,
-0.6217474341392517,
-0.507771372795105,
0.4374369978904724,
0.27159327268600464,
1.0242687463760376,
0.8027500510215759,
0.7795854806900024,
0.33233949542045593,
-0.06681576371192932,
0.4286002218723297,
-0.24651044607162476,
0.09162039309740067,
0.20567432045936584,
-0.6315014362335205,
-0.779449999332428,
-0.2758539319038391,
0.6865184903144836,
0.9847503304481506,
-0.2654772400856018,
-0.03735866770148277,
-0.5043672919273376,
0.9756481051445007,
-0.5631203055381775,
0.2023279368877411,
-0.513604462146759,
0.13697823882102966,
-0.15008445084095,
-0.46842071413993835,
-0.6719558238983154,
-0.587066650390625,
-0.28628307580947876,
-0.6633292436599731,
-0.060958899557590485,
-0.036043379455804825,
0.1178315281867981,
0.4193175137042999,
-0.5478042364120483,
-0.3989587128162384,
-0.6052519679069519,
0.5753220915794373,
-1.0497100353240967,
0.24106355011463165,
0.6608765721321106,
0.09478258341550827,
-0.04312146082520485,
-0.38666707277297974,
-0.28399693965911865,
-0.2122361809015274,
0.07117951661348343,
-0.031817127019166946,
-0.22599086165428162,
0.11148399114608765,
0.731235146522522,
0.5332826972007751,
-0.5500956177711487,
0.01170248445123434,
-0.35347428917884827,
-0.08900171518325806,
0.7443531155586243,
0.46750617027282715,
0.3037460446357727,
0.0008525370503775775,
-0.03854917734861374,
0.09021451324224472,
-0.8146893978118896,
-0.33789414167404175,
0.2797216773033142,
0.014367937110364437,
-0.1302725374698639,
0.5642126798629761,
-0.3244740664958954,
0.8899131417274475,
0.06519928574562073,
0.004980835597962141,
0.224900022149086,
-0.03373003751039505,
-0.5662702322006226,
0.36657869815826416,
0.49014410376548767,
0.4021504521369934,
0.6385371088981628,
0.04711352661252022,
-0.09644932299852371,
0.35222184658050537,
0.18234379589557648,
-1.0144975185394287,
-0.09449569880962372,
0.09035371243953705,
-0.044193483889102936,
-0.6035152077674866,
-0.008840936236083508,
-0.398268461227417,
-0.499409556388855,
-0.45982784032821655,
0.0016048247925937176,
-0.6119946837425232,
-0.20667237043380737,
0.5822348594665527,
0.1217651292681694,
0.04854821041226387,
0.5427496433258057,
-1.380237340927124,
0.3591316342353821,
0.8448207974433899,
0.49709275364875793,
0.4843912422657013,
0.210523322224617,
-0.3236077129840851,
0.06635507941246033,
-0.7462925910949707,
0.7061830759048462,
-0.6791216731071472,
-0.5028665661811829,
-0.35649773478507996,
-0.13020941615104675,
0.07745847851037979,
-0.5802230834960938,
0.13205446302890778,
-0.7106577754020691,
0.20459969341754913,
-0.18326915800571442,
-0.5930978059768677,
-0.20951350033283234,
0.04319994896650314,
-0.8621614575386047,
0.8411298394203186,
0.03844114765524864,
-0.47843703627586365,
0.09518638253211975,
-0.5225754976272583,
-0.1941736489534378,
0.3300151228904724,
-0.16911612451076508,
-0.08869785815477371,
0.7263801097869873,
0.16788369417190552,
0.02465217560529709,
-0.4861234128475189,
0.6122404932975769,
-0.3366934657096863,
-0.5113811492919922,
0.509787380695343,
-0.764937698841095,
0.811377227306366,
0.2821245491504669,
-0.15782706439495087,
-0.11046802252531052,
-0.7856131196022034,
0.130812868475914,
0.025685355067253113,
-0.33648812770843506,
-0.4539652168750763,
-0.3662866950035095,
-0.610101044178009,
0.08065089583396912,
0.19062386453151703,
-0.053405728191137314,
0.3855435252189636,
-0.6311246156692505,
0.12558512389659882,
0.6230430006980896,
0.009536724537611008,
0.8039394021034241,
-0.2444106787443161,
0.6260387897491455,
-0.08440671116113663,
-0.12679725885391235,
-0.36267462372779846,
-0.6924917697906494,
-0.8830839395523071,
0.2041930854320526,
0.25074997544288635,
0.4659201502799988,
-0.914050281047821,
0.18207527697086334,
-0.14994312822818756,
-0.31758183240890503,
-0.5331164002418518,
0.10287141799926758,
0.4056108593940735,
0.2109055072069168,
0.11574506759643555,
-0.430101215839386,
-0.6797086596488953,
-0.45665714144706726,
-0.0963362380862236,
-0.05153755843639374,
-0.11191502958536148,
0.20313867926597595,
0.2081092894077301,
-0.005790055729448795,
0.4703899919986725,
-0.5469024777412415,
0.25841090083122253,
0.008000396192073822,
0.42178240418434143,
0.4534074664115906,
0.28067919611930847,
0.23889395594596863,
-0.7196347713470459,
-0.26911839842796326,
-0.09566337615251541,
-1.1217387914657593,
-0.40176811814308167,
0.04207997769117355,
-0.2721293270587921,
0.5340331196784973,
0.445827841758728,
-0.5075132846832275,
0.4948500990867615,
0.5852338671684265,
-0.6712114810943604,
0.4331941604614258,
-0.5003997087478638,
0.15851843357086182,
-0.7402915954589844,
-0.3008440136909485,
0.08445524424314499,
-0.036404579877853394,
-0.8957498073577881,
-0.10673724114894867,
0.17122986912727356,
-0.18099096417427063,
-0.2668728530406952,
0.3158840835094452,
-0.6905754208564758,
-0.1990773230791092,
-0.45664697885513306,
0.03521787002682686,
0.2924630045890808,
0.3700219988822937,
0.19314071536064148,
0.7626751065254211,
0.22895199060440063,
-0.530422031879425,
0.3215946555137634,
-0.09789256751537323,
-0.17546585202217102,
0.5598689317703247,
-0.502088189125061,
0.35781365633010864,
-0.2921224534511566,
0.2964531481266022,
-0.6740255951881409,
-0.09851714968681335,
0.22774146497249603,
-0.42087116837501526,
0.238382488489151,
-0.21379266679286957,
-0.5829781293869019,
0.057711854577064514,
-0.2607969045639038,
0.714816689491272,
0.6316498517990112,
-0.06776372343301773,
0.4497982859611511,
0.1453177034854889,
-0.21874436736106873,
-0.16730374097824097,
-0.5500819087028503,
0.16148079931735992,
-0.6055121421813965,
-0.7414923906326294,
0.24022842943668365,
-0.12133211642503738,
-0.868293046951294,
-0.29588231444358826,
-0.11291676759719849,
-0.04446050524711609,
0.17571277916431427,
-0.053014252334833145,
0.5035951733589172,
-0.4638828933238983,
0.3717828094959259,
-0.0810229554772377,
-0.5465891361236572,
0.4067455232143402,
-0.2524789869785309,
0.6343048214912415,
-0.15030533075332642,
-0.31692200899124146,
-0.10143877565860748,
0.350875586271286,
0.5504397749900818,
-0.371662974357605,
0.6623523235321045,
0.500903844833374,
-0.5403862595558167,
0.17626255750656128,
-0.4036964476108551,
-0.17988881468772888,
-0.4916921854019165,
-0.05266037583351135,
-0.39981427788734436,
-0.7004755735397339,
0.34095633029937744,
-0.059575315564870834,
-0.34174251556396484,
0.4917517900466919,
0.6623911261558533,
0.10946483165025711,
1.3336737155914307,
0.21575000882148743,
0.45009270310401917,
0.283943235874176,
-0.10072524845600128,
0.09865853190422058,
-0.9339560270309448,
-0.3272548019886017,
-0.32905104756355286,
0.1101464256644249,
-0.5111526846885681,
-0.7857635617256165,
0.2326236218214035,
0.28962114453315735,
-0.3725895285606384,
0.05580773577094078,
-0.4515196681022644,
0.6091981530189514,
0.29469528794288635,
0.12596598267555237,
0.4536297619342804,
0.16628804802894592,
-0.0007523565436713398,
-0.5107430815696716,
-0.5034746527671814,
-0.6857524514198303,
0.9030572772026062,
0.10360870510339737,
0.9180800318717957,
0.5500152707099915,
0.7595109343528748,
0.18962499499320984,
0.638220489025116,
-0.6505209803581238,
0.5765621662139893,
-0.4390113353729248,
-0.4416449964046478,
-0.40918222069740295,
-0.6053684949874878,
-0.6901175379753113,
0.39890071749687195,
-0.054384078830480576,
-0.7497749328613281,
0.27103063464164734,
-0.0012127533555030823,
-0.35140347480773926,
0.2035084217786789,
-0.5016264915466309,
0.37721049785614014,
-0.42650893330574036,
-0.29320597648620605,
-0.17731285095214844,
-0.40760281682014465,
0.48243606090545654,
-0.09802025556564331,
0.5548453330993652,
-0.44695109128952026,
-0.14012815058231354,
0.655389130115509,
-0.6637289524078369,
1.0077524185180664,
-0.018722062930464745,
-0.33232781291007996,
0.15660670399665833,
0.4356120228767395,
0.4808814823627472,
0.03274446725845337,
-0.3223586678504944,
0.057694993913173676,
-0.3776046931743622,
-0.1801391839981079,
-0.8614226579666138,
0.5443372130393982,
-0.5198314189910889,
-0.7640680074691772,
-0.49069303274154663,
-0.78947514295578,
-0.0927867665886879,
0.020512891933321953,
0.16086630523204803,
0.83991539478302,
0.1566905677318573,
0.21787923574447632,
0.8996546268463135,
-0.13653752207756042,
0.37420517206192017,
0.4468097686767578,
-0.32624533772468567,
-0.789319634437561,
0.6483320593833923,
0.18881899118423462,
0.43542423844337463,
0.49344727396965027,
0.23488114774227142,
-0.4339514970779419,
-0.2806060314178467,
-0.4028675854206085,
0.29194527864456177,
-1.0139198303222656,
-0.21649281680583954,
-0.46057602763175964,
0.019621586427092552,
-0.5173740386962891,
-0.1812966763973236,
0.3185213804244995,
-0.8145288825035095,
-0.4926110506057739,
-0.07600660622119904,
0.8139439225196838,
0.8256296515464783,
-0.17554090917110443,
0.28539401292800903,
-0.8223549127578735,
0.4609610140323639,
0.20471003651618958,
0.4733711779117584,
0.1019839346408844,
-0.8059171438217163,
-0.2381165623664856,
0.08944546431303024,
0.15214978158473969,
-1.0443378686904907,
0.5260999202728271,
0.07883521914482117,
0.24460504949092865,
0.41938820481300354,
-0.11173921078443527,
0.81541907787323,
-0.5022578239440918,
0.17530839145183563,
0.22021833062171936,
-0.9453721046447754,
0.35433483123779297,
-0.28866279125213623,
0.5737434029579163,
0.3721533715724945,
0.2223520129919052,
-0.5736040472984314,
-0.1828112006187439,
-0.7653973698616028,
-0.7863141298294067,
0.5164995789527893,
0.20778323709964752,
0.21121376752853394,
-0.3559618592262268,
0.24218103289604187,
-0.09842944890260696,
0.14166101813316345,
-0.5370242595672607,
-0.22634980082511902,
-0.16800826787948608,
-0.2234436571598053,
-0.1141415536403656,
-0.5948703289031982,
-0.015857962891459465,
-0.28142863512039185,
0.4823135435581207,
-0.1638530045747757,
0.13994865119457245,
-0.014576470479369164,
-0.23432916402816772,
0.10114098340272903,
0.4180695414543152,
0.990378201007843,
0.7121460437774658,
-0.2548106610774994,
0.4557143449783325,
0.27373117208480835,
-0.4463435411453247,
0.24211646616458893,
-0.0686594694852829,
0.08513594418764114,
0.1739325076341629,
0.4174046218395233,
0.8082690834999084,
0.7281391620635986,
-0.2826805114746094,
0.020380515605211258,
-0.042877741158008575,
-0.21309061348438263,
-0.31787344813346863,
0.056317828595638275,
0.1987631618976593,
0.0022982554510235786,
0.2735762298107147,
-0.11423219740390778,
0.24872639775276184,
-0.4119536578655243,
0.14064791798591614,
0.07003501057624817,
-0.2716561555862427,
-0.17440934479236603,
0.549854040145874,
0.21149465441703796,
-0.6737202405929565,
0.7764984369277954,
-0.18864718079566956,
-0.23976460099220276,
1.0519826412200928,
0.8521953821182251,
0.8155176639556885,
-0.2180718183517456,
0.23842909932136536,
0.4364143908023834,
0.2645586431026459,
-0.07690771669149399,
0.460772305727005,
-0.04528616741299629,
-0.8294421434402466,
-0.5233797430992126,
-0.5622563362121582,
-0.503742516040802,
-0.4253952205181122,
-0.8000495433807373,
0.1751488596200943,
-0.6745452284812927,
-0.2841598689556122,
0.30071404576301575,
-0.24308310449123383,
-0.5128633379936218,
0.3867018222808838,
0.716549277305603,
1.006312370300293,
-0.7608127593994141,
0.732032299041748,
0.6398493051528931,
-0.3070080876350403,
-0.7679120302200317,
-0.5929126143455505,
0.10616055876016617,
-1.2437329292297363,
0.34079357981681824,
0.3310537338256836,
-0.020261110737919807,
0.2976892292499542,
-0.39815783500671387,
-0.8019521236419678,
1.1171895265579224,
0.3689424693584442,
-0.6219570636749268,
0.14498910307884216,
0.3148178160190582,
0.6359933018684387,
-0.611804187297821,
0.2681085169315338,
0.6693981289863586,
0.5884308218955994,
0.3498585820198059,
-0.4232354462146759,
0.2579781413078308,
-0.5322672128677368,
0.20562925934791565,
0.573196530342102,
-0.176543727517128,
0.9019847512245178,
-0.5623171329498291,
-0.17238172888755798,
-0.053257979452610016,
0.2205227166414261,
0.7641545534133911,
0.49287086725234985,
0.2480747103691101,
0.72396320104599,
0.9660652279853821,
-0.3654324412345886,
1.3549249172210693,
-0.19660930335521698,
0.20626364648342133,
0.902716338634491,
-0.15536294877529144,
0.29085245728492737,
0.4026843011379242,
-0.3637333810329437,
0.5918889045715332,
0.584460437297821,
-0.03962311893701553,
0.43830573558807373,
0.30077534914016724,
-0.6571142077445984,
-0.40669840574264526,
-0.24318256974220276,
-0.3962242603302002,
0.2754214107990265,
0.4386851191520691,
-0.45848381519317627,
-0.09210187196731567,
-0.3004380464553833,
0.38331592082977295,
0.12461207062005997,
-0.49155616760253906,
1.0823994874954224,
0.4168877899646759,
-0.48628899455070496,
0.6795312762260437,
0.1041802391409874,
0.32161253690719604,
-0.42154592275619507,
-0.3451020121574402,
-0.4710962772369385,
-0.17473557591438293,
-0.32407429814338684,
-0.6930281519889832,
0.2277483493089676,
0.038776420056819916,
-0.12915261089801788,
-0.20907649397850037,
0.6108009815216064,
-0.5166957378387451,
-0.9860883951187134,
-0.16894349455833435,
0.3586544692516327,
0.44195258617401123,
-0.08408661186695099,
-0.3293282091617584,
0.18213261663913727,
0.0033192276023328304,
-0.02504105493426323,
0.06800780445337296,
1.0920296907424927,
-0.46518203616142273,
0.5384045243263245,
0.8127480745315552,
-0.09941272437572479,
-0.07035236060619354,
0.7430092096328735,
0.5836676955223083,
-1.1608532667160034,
-0.4765882194042206,
-1.4010835886001587,
0.446181982755661,
0.05034192278981209,
-0.06033103168010712,
0.5480911135673523,
0.25529882311820984,
0.2532327175140381,
0.029863480478525162,
0.47529029846191406,
0.2637639343738556,
-0.41238972544670105,
-0.7851443290710449,
0.1868717223405838,
-0.11855284124612808,
0.6340368986129761,
-0.0424102284014225,
-0.8485087156295776,
-0.7476385831832886,
0.5642498135566711,
-0.5224571228027344,
0.03889105096459389,
0.657455325126648,
0.49776676297187805,
0.36982494592666626,
0.2600439190864563,
0.5800723433494568,
0.030601264908909798,
0.0238000750541687,
0.6773179769515991,
0.8426036238670349,
-0.2464907467365265,
0.22780224680900574,
-0.3031209707260132,
-0.2306843400001526,
-0.16903263330459595,
-0.9041122794151306,
-0.6521373391151428,
0.0852799341082573,
-0.14869336783885956,
-0.34398120641708374,
-0.17502500116825104,
0.8263528347015381,
0.3069530129432678,
-0.5345819592475891,
-0.31171438097953796,
-0.1543683409690857,
0.21085408329963684,
0.14642751216888428,
-0.16138264536857605,
-0.014431695453822613,
-0.07440464198589325,
-0.47439539432525635,
0.10860050469636917,
0.5677019357681274,
0.471151739358902,
-0.3253454267978668,
-0.1980268359184265,
0.18928147852420807,
0.24398133158683777,
0.6413946747779846,
-0.00641166465356946,
-0.6873610019683838,
0.11026500910520554,
0.21107494831085205,
-0.1604345589876175,
0.23883451521396637,
1.0191179513931274,
-0.7549353241920471,
0.5392631888389587,
0.2760290801525116,
0.2747723460197449,
0.38005125522613525,
0.28555840253829956,
0.8648960590362549,
-0.3577934801578522,
0.3942470848560333,
0.27166417241096497,
0.42278948426246643,
0.5783877968788147,
-0.48470538854599,
0.6530495882034302,
0.07901810854673386,
-0.20941688120365143,
-0.7286569476127625,
0.3131409287452698,
-0.7328910231590271,
-0.052649252116680145,
1.046752691268921,
0.08857771754264832,
-0.0465574748814106,
-0.019127221778035164,
-0.12618210911750793,
-0.07906915247440338,
-0.33921781182289124,
0.7435625791549683,
0.7367568016052246,
-0.1319223791360855,
-0.44626080989837646,
-0.3479866087436676,
0.3902094066143036,
0.27684617042541504,
-0.9026997685432434,
-0.023068897426128387,
0.5159211754798889,
-0.05759532377123833,
0.023322971537709236,
1.029577612876892,
-0.4364114999771118,
0.41673651337623596,
0.22915874421596527,
0.002584477886557579,
-0.04646407440304756,
-0.06611532717943192,
-0.7940220236778259,
-0.250843346118927,
0.287286639213562,
0.35983410477638245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00458v1
|
Beyond One-Size-Fits-All: Multi-Domain, Multi-Task Framework for Embedding Model Selection
| 2024-03-30T19:45:04 | 2024-03-30T19:45:04 |
Vivek Khetan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This position paper proposes a systematic approach towards developing a
framework to help select the most effective embedding models for natural
language processing (NLP) tasks, addressing the challenge posed by the
proliferation of both proprietary and open-source encoder models.
|
[
-0.7759041786193848,
-0.6917300224304199,
0.5873537063598633,
0.5588075518608093,
-0.03132060542702675,
-0.14728319644927979,
-0.04942813515663147,
-0.35032495856285095,
0.27470818161964417,
0.5712660551071167,
-0.49156680703163147,
-0.408245325088501,
-0.9261905550956726,
0.1360568404197693,
-0.3527452051639557,
0.7038795351982117,
-0.18000361323356628,
0.12529563903808594,
-0.5538252592086792,
-0.16668282449245453,
-0.5350643396377563,
-0.3980174958705902,
-0.5453996658325195,
-0.5420505404472351,
0.10340255498886108,
0.13268913328647614,
0.8063468933105469,
0.5099952816963196,
0.5813758373260498,
0.04728969931602478,
-0.03195369616150856,
0.128198504447937,
-0.10284522920846939,
0.5000128149986267,
-0.283890962600708,
-0.14230890572071075,
-0.3827364444732666,
0.03177880495786667,
0.5575959086418152,
0.5570285320281982,
-0.2943514883518219,
0.4301248788833618,
0.1149587407708168,
0.33366212248802185,
-0.9780259132385254,
-0.16888120770454407,
-0.424742192029953,
0.3737086057662964,
-0.01626085862517357,
0.05137931555509567,
-0.4291301667690277,
-0.07093669474124908,
0.4265129566192627,
-0.5403457880020142,
0.13963860273361206,
0.2427346259355545,
0.21018707752227783,
0.3307269513607025,
-0.510094165802002,
-0.25300392508506775,
-0.558735191822052,
0.959404706954956,
-0.7660927772521973,
0.7938185334205627,
0.4918995499610901,
0.13015100359916687,
-0.022599712014198303,
-0.6485139727592468,
-0.2557310163974762,
0.035951219499111176,
0.07194890826940536,
-0.261903315782547,
-0.14208200573921204,
0.18663251399993896,
0.14503708481788635,
0.32708001136779785,
-0.7843683362007141,
-0.03518741950392723,
0.06568768620491028,
0.08646818995475769,
0.3322460353374481,
-0.15415851771831512,
0.24146592617034912,
0.06375420838594437,
-0.27817681431770325,
0.29571419954299927,
-0.5585777759552002,
-0.39185914397239685,
0.08176419883966446,
0.39838290214538574,
0.01915079541504383,
0.6580321788787842,
0.016406215727329254,
0.9820526242256165,
0.07675018906593323,
-0.0446254201233387,
-0.08630792051553726,
-0.17821626365184784,
-0.6737823486328125,
-0.04153924807906151,
0.46085578203201294,
0.011613999493420124,
0.061206310987472534,
-0.42260757088661194,
-0.13143378496170044,
0.08271941542625427,
0.6720258593559265,
-0.723025381565094,
0.11083247512578964,
0.45828303694725037,
-0.6720373034477234,
-0.08675295114517212,
0.10593497008085251,
-0.8782339692115784,
-0.2949945628643036,
-0.32083967328071594,
0.2739436626434326,
-0.2092045247554779,
-0.3581647276878357,
0.4689231812953949,
-0.40079233050346375,
0.023117436096072197,
-0.059036217629909515,
-0.8841120004653931,
0.593528151512146,
0.6518228650093079,
1.0792107582092285,
-0.4004747271537781,
-0.1933305859565735,
-0.30857834219932556,
0.2704242765903473,
-0.17571114003658295,
0.7903358340263367,
-0.884069561958313,
-0.6335864067077637,
0.2319982498884201,
-0.18026624619960785,
-0.4041031002998352,
-0.22943882644176483,
0.614565372467041,
-0.4318457543849945,
0.06467168033123016,
-0.33624210953712463,
-0.71517413854599,
-0.31315961480140686,
0.5018277764320374,
-0.8600969910621643,
0.9321987628936768,
0.19294114410877228,
-0.7881547808647156,
0.36897340416908264,
-1.1578278541564941,
-0.3799172341823578,
-0.21558596193790436,
-0.0851786881685257,
-0.37967848777770996,
0.03524445742368698,
0.406650185585022,
0.7813857197761536,
-0.5781375765800476,
0.382876455783844,
-0.5087869763374329,
-0.10153459012508392,
-0.08717839419841766,
-0.10459116846323013,
0.8340849876403809,
0.40287715196609497,
-0.18307915329933167,
0.275410920381546,
-0.42980554699897766,
0.04886258766055107,
0.18515358865261078,
-0.15253764390945435,
-0.4092770218849182,
0.05339377000927925,
0.542131781578064,
0.5376790165901184,
0.22977116703987122,
-0.7290812134742737,
0.26140111684799194,
-0.11459869146347046,
0.5835309028625488,
0.31355521082878113,
-0.02075565792620182,
0.8531414866447449,
-0.5716665983200073,
0.8810665607452393,
-0.3139019012451172,
0.2120048552751541,
-0.0964210033416748,
-0.7366046905517578,
-0.2534492313861847,
-0.30936959385871887,
0.2960956394672394,
0.4777001440525055,
-0.40480050444602966,
0.5165368914604187,
-0.042226821184158325,
-0.5077680945396423,
-0.6674342751502991,
0.17050965130329132,
0.23601876199245453,
-0.1586403250694275,
0.44908055663108826,
-0.24354076385498047,
-0.6581548452377319,
-1.0512769222259521,
-0.07668941468000412,
0.41967105865478516,
0.026770509779453278,
0.041672829538583755,
0.7109590768814087,
-0.4786129593849182,
1.1791163682937622,
-0.558336615562439,
-0.5340958833694458,
-0.27465930581092834,
-0.08895101398229599,
-0.014080948196351528,
0.7402791380882263,
0.9619962573051453,
-0.9977445006370544,
-0.5855581164360046,
-0.052840977907180786,
-0.5598230957984924,
0.2696119248867035,
-0.03860236331820488,
-0.23417025804519653,
-0.140419602394104,
0.2542930543422699,
-0.8475778698921204,
0.5014116168022156,
0.8210037350654602,
-0.3554902672767639,
0.40072494745254517,
-0.20612066984176636,
0.10958119481801987,
-1.1225801706314087,
0.2036450058221817,
0.3194192349910736,
-0.37749195098876953,
-0.5781974792480469,
0.5094046592712402,
0.1719738245010376,
-0.2429301142692566,
-0.23905234038829803,
0.6193904280662537,
-0.4935401976108551,
-0.21364350616931915,
-0.09885147958993912,
0.04003894701600075,
0.25019970536231995,
0.3924694359302521,
0.1426624208688736,
0.5783159136772156,
0.6881225109100342,
-0.6167431473731995,
0.006265756208449602,
0.6669318675994873,
-0.18404226005077362,
0.6345271468162537,
-0.8548449277877808,
0.214874267578125,
-0.21031461656093597,
0.18630683422088623,
-0.8259524703025818,
-0.01484690885990858,
-0.10468915849924088,
-0.09402261674404144,
0.290513813495636,
-0.276467889547348,
-0.6413693428039551,
-0.3050028681755066,
-0.30928778648376465,
0.19065384566783905,
0.03392507880926132,
-0.5356022715568542,
0.9136324524879456,
0.8198702931404114,
-0.28868433833122253,
-0.6344111561775208,
-0.7733291983604431,
-0.16682925820350647,
0.0017742420313879848,
-0.5257350206375122,
0.9452801942825317,
-0.2260829210281372,
-0.017168298363685608,
0.06483636051416397,
-0.299554705619812,
-0.38221797347068787,
0.12273921817541122,
0.21397633850574493,
0.12814243137836456,
-0.35822319984436035,
0.004705339670181274,
0.3041698634624481,
-0.0477929413318634,
-0.1487104296684265,
-0.48118856549263,
0.4883415699005127,
0.17825035750865936,
-0.603289783000946,
-0.10488050431013107,
1.063715934753418,
0.5688989758491516,
-0.719887375831604,
0.6881680488586426,
0.5839176774024963,
-0.5678332448005676,
-0.4861898422241211,
-0.48703625798225403,
-0.02313745580613613,
-0.4191659986972809,
0.41933220624923706,
-0.44016948342323303,
-1.0813512802124023,
0.3670888841152191,
-0.092008575797081,
0.36120662093162537,
0.24297571182250977,
0.4010578393936157,
0.426273912191391,
1.3549624681472778,
1.1106877326965332,
-0.18080873787403107,
0.520098865032196,
-0.25401580333709717,
0.4138244688510895,
-1.019700527191162,
-0.1205463632941246,
-0.6288841366767883,
-0.19068467617034912,
-0.1648864448070526,
-0.5355643630027771,
0.14377905428409576,
0.06971065700054169,
-0.38701704144477844,
0.5798088312149048,
-1.0058300495147705,
0.3373352885246277,
0.5687628388404846,
-0.15886038541793823,
0.019608892500400543,
-0.1913309544324875,
-0.3252619802951813,
0.09317401051521301,
-0.831272304058075,
-0.6242231130599976,
1.2569444179534912,
0.4709838032722473,
0.5095311403274536,
0.3825114965438843,
0.47686269879341125,
0.2033161222934723,
0.12981536984443665,
-0.7336325645446777,
0.2613869309425354,
-0.4719544053077698,
-1.0349332094192505,
-0.29494982957839966,
0.11656244099140167,
-0.7908719778060913,
0.5786004066467285,
-0.5393220782279968,
-0.8137714862823486,
0.2886054515838623,
-0.07738170027732849,
-0.4297271966934204,
0.5779298543930054,
-0.4570173919200897,
1.1559091806411743,
0.19148226082324982,
0.2008489966392517,
-0.12179948389530182,
-0.3229525685310364,
0.14655150473117828,
-0.12821994721889496,
0.2801160216331482,
-0.1392802894115448,
-0.1062433198094368,
0.7428712248802185,
0.3678836524486542,
0.6926551461219788,
-0.2191276252269745,
0.03243637830018997,
0.16077575087547302,
0.3646470010280609,
0.28878888487815857,
0.1394464522600174,
-0.2558341920375824,
0.197546124458313,
0.33816248178482056,
-0.31345653533935547,
-0.47192853689193726,
0.5739981532096863,
-0.655677080154419,
-0.26380154490470886,
-0.15430830419063568,
-0.45514050126075745,
-0.36359328031539917,
0.15463665127754211,
0.1988498419523239,
0.443930059671402,
-0.5386914014816284,
0.5840678215026855,
0.7377645373344421,
-0.10498818755149841,
0.4802424907684326,
0.09262928366661072,
-0.357372909784317,
-0.17002582550048828,
0.5191187858581543,
0.12373509258031845,
0.0598427876830101,
0.5397257804870605,
0.04551547393202782,
-0.20235759019851685,
-0.45629626512527466,
-0.26593446731567383,
-0.10672567039728165,
-0.8325343132019043,
-0.23190724849700928,
-0.9413530230522156,
-0.1315140575170517,
-0.7765747904777527,
-0.4140113890171051,
-0.6966281533241272,
-0.3814173936843872,
-0.32623419165611267,
-0.15775354206562042,
0.15302908420562744,
0.9877593517303467,
0.18194670975208282,
0.47667810320854187,
-0.820844829082489,
0.42172467708587646,
0.139590784907341,
0.6212002635002136,
0.07887855172157288,
-0.3059917390346527,
-0.28039824962615967,
-0.00456283101812005,
-0.49513253569602966,
-0.9194778800010681,
0.5244649648666382,
0.23180796205997467,
1.1049071550369263,
0.2073393613100052,
-0.02182655967772007,
0.2768595218658447,
-0.5922977924346924,
0.8498545289039612,
0.3430682122707367,
-0.9746768474578857,
0.62628573179245,
-0.17666621506214142,
0.33504316210746765,
0.33994144201278687,
0.8252034187316895,
-0.589900016784668,
-0.048513393849134445,
-0.41550886631011963,
-0.7685473561286926,
0.3901396691799164,
0.07955067604780197,
-0.08273892849683762,
-0.10322800278663635,
0.18080060184001923,
0.316163033246994,
0.30564171075820923,
-0.6367513537406921,
-0.38973721861839294,
-0.14072036743164062,
-0.337473064661026,
0.024362236261367798,
-0.14091670513153076,
-0.15678636729717255,
-0.1577879637479782,
0.5182914733886719,
-0.37223485112190247,
0.7059937119483948,
0.20803767442703247,
-0.2742467224597931,
-0.20628581941127777,
0.21803444623947144,
0.4126613438129425,
0.8983712196350098,
-0.08522603660821915,
-0.07056758552789688,
-0.12659072875976562,
-0.31697937846183777,
-0.1660115122795105,
0.17374221980571747,
0.030434921383857727,
0.05030398443341255,
0.3379209041595459,
0.8070125579833984,
0.3890571892261505,
-0.46416738629341125,
0.6692079305648804,
0.11385932564735413,
-0.39091286063194275,
-0.1884557008743286,
-0.10844811797142029,
-0.06626193225383759,
0.26003336906433105,
0.47101593017578125,
0.35258492827415466,
0.30486127734184265,
-0.38700228929519653,
0.5387133359909058,
0.5800001621246338,
-0.42709746956825256,
-0.21980486810207367,
0.7568831443786621,
0.05237000063061714,
-0.42955881357192993,
0.2585352957248688,
-0.20674638450145721,
-0.5404042601585388,
0.5242060422897339,
0.7433386445045471,
1.1057051420211792,
-0.3853939175605774,
0.5689247250556946,
0.21870718896389008,
0.26211464405059814,
-0.6202543377876282,
0.26989468932151794,
0.034537412226200104,
-0.915846049785614,
-0.6259362101554871,
-0.6558594703674316,
-0.45843425393104553,
-0.2384834587574005,
-0.8953270316123962,
0.054011255502700806,
-0.4964248239994049,
-0.51365065574646,
0.19450204074382782,
-0.2066558301448822,
-0.9320132732391357,
0.11359445750713348,
0.21163570880889893,
0.8700698018074036,
-0.7065117955207825,
1.0381070375442505,
0.8430851101875305,
-0.30615440011024475,
-0.32051125168800354,
-0.19148719310760498,
0.12821516394615173,
-0.37730327248573303,
0.39879313111305237,
-0.07040847092866898,
0.19503153860569,
0.02063765935599804,
-0.573783278465271,
-1.2272928953170776,
1.0274744033813477,
0.35703158378601074,
-0.3436974585056305,
-0.4095463156700134,
-0.2602118253707886,
0.1658841371536255,
-0.9710645079612732,
0.01343165896832943,
0.5227541923522949,
0.4312182068824768,
-0.19342638552188873,
-1.2934441566467285,
0.09077005833387375,
-0.13049063086509705,
0.14001700282096863,
0.21247567236423492,
-0.10830820351839066,
1.0435380935668945,
-0.03375003859400749,
0.05223451927304268,
-0.03762003034353256,
0.15576086938381195,
0.3122742474079132,
-0.03455599024891853,
0.49855005741119385,
0.4680246114730835,
0.5095990896224976,
0.19825774431228638,
1.1539887189865112,
-0.4199521839618683,
0.49030545353889465,
1.1856751441955566,
-0.2982189357280731,
1.0109835863113403,
0.5405341982841492,
-0.26855236291885376,
0.2733728885650635,
0.5312240719795227,
-0.04341253638267517,
0.7658360600471497,
-0.07571179419755936,
0.07369080930948257,
-0.2216649353504181,
-0.10481484234333038,
-0.2920452058315277,
0.39741143584251404,
0.4636079967021942,
-0.23756401240825653,
-0.1845352202653885,
0.23827296495437622,
-0.3736205995082855,
-0.020231373608112335,
-0.19202551245689392,
0.5287611484527588,
0.3444710373878479,
-0.4462287724018097,
0.06523984670639038,
0.3007756769657135,
1.1034513711929321,
-0.7228412628173828,
-0.14795981347560883,
0.46891990303993225,
-0.11501914262771606,
-0.13451406359672546,
-0.7541590332984924,
0.6347225308418274,
-0.37999027967453003,
-0.3068689703941345,
-0.48059549927711487,
0.9121630787849426,
-0.42557862401008606,
-0.2278573364019394,
0.6971727013587952,
0.6267867088317871,
-0.4463628828525543,
-0.5321395993232727,
-0.9628421664237976,
0.04719164967536926,
-0.1522495299577713,
-0.5324070453643799,
0.37165871262550354,
0.16866426169872284,
0.14604870975017548,
0.7854161858558655,
0.7153932452201843,
0.006558902096003294,
0.08224286884069443,
0.036753490567207336,
0.5637480020523071,
-0.6464880704879761,
-0.7563410997390747,
-0.5921310782432556,
0.4967893362045288,
-0.1761702597141266,
-0.443200021982193,
0.48033612966537476,
0.33100005984306335,
0.8114870190620422,
-0.21033012866973877,
0.9803084135055542,
-0.24236910045146942,
0.3862782120704651,
-0.26585862040519714,
0.569693386554718,
-0.6067637801170349,
-0.14103639125823975,
-0.41067755222320557,
-1.283078908920288,
-0.5698099732398987,
1.1060045957565308,
-0.12147314846515656,
-0.00792532879859209,
0.8683502078056335,
0.553433895111084,
-0.05246003717184067,
0.2994069755077362,
0.5008318424224854,
-0.2897863984107971,
0.24449466168880463,
0.3079012632369995,
0.30172646045684814,
-0.28026872873306274,
0.10555307567119598,
-0.0999186635017395,
0.022516626864671707,
-0.18595539033412933,
-0.8414111137390137,
-0.8344255685806274,
-0.8670687675476074,
-0.2760103940963745,
0.08424786478281021,
-0.32568320631980896,
1.420159935951233,
1.1750991344451904,
-0.9100696444511414,
-0.17353083193302155,
0.20567841827869415,
0.19272881746292114,
-0.5506446361541748,
-0.15970902144908905,
0.16595648229122162,
-0.1696665734052658,
-0.6391792297363281,
0.40754005312919617,
0.5051820874214172,
-0.014281128533184528,
-0.49737095832824707,
-0.06480136513710022,
-0.5912079811096191,
0.132964089512825,
0.8583611845970154,
-0.028937367722392082,
-0.7708293795585632,
-0.14297214150428772,
0.11050846427679062,
-0.08612335473299026,
-0.1376350224018097,
1.0370216369628906,
-0.2694302499294281,
0.2375471442937851,
0.3842344284057617,
1.035447597503662,
0.5276336073875427,
-0.4958515763282776,
0.9857598543167114,
-0.9317804574966431,
0.19305898249149323,
0.3037324845790863,
0.5997385382652283,
0.2949475646018982,
-0.3495050370693207,
0.7070836424827576,
-0.13280168175697327,
-0.5987184643745422,
-0.7920191884040833,
0.1902064085006714,
-1.0168765783309937,
-0.8203958868980408,
1.164451003074646,
-0.14957380294799805,
0.05705814063549042,
-0.40131381154060364,
-0.1298549324274063,
0.08829544484615326,
-0.22575415670871735,
0.15106838941574097,
0.7492923736572266,
-0.04200807958841324,
-0.1340445727109909,
-0.9538105130195618,
0.4190598428249359,
0.03167733550071716,
-0.5028162002563477,
-0.13829036056995392,
0.13568070530891418,
0.22512942552566528,
0.4617096781730652,
0.6584200859069824,
0.029110407456755638,
0.017139650881290436,
0.1608409881591797,
0.2377277910709381,
-0.012216856703162193,
-0.513198733329773,
-0.1401100903749466,
0.5243284702301025,
0.0242525152862072,
-0.10242442786693573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00457v1
|
MetaIE: Distilling a Meta Model from LLM for All Kinds of Information Extraction Tasks
| 2024-03-30T19:43:45 | 2024-03-30T19:43:45 |
Letian Peng, Zilong Wang, Feng Yao, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Information extraction (IE) is a fundamental area in natural language
processing where prompting large language models (LLMs), even with in-context
examples, cannot defeat small LMs tuned on very small IE datasets. We observe
that IE tasks, such as named entity recognition and relation extraction, all
focus on extracting important information, which can be formalized as a
label-to-span matching. In this paper, we propose a novel framework MetaIE to
build a small LM as meta-model by learning to extract "important information",
i.e., the meta-understanding of IE, so that this meta-model can be adapted to
all kind of IE tasks effectively and efficiently. Specifically, MetaIE obtains
the small LM via a symbolic distillation from an LLM following the
label-to-span scheme. We construct the distillation dataset via sampling
sentences from language model pre-training datasets (e.g., OpenWebText in our
implementation) and prompting an LLM to identify the typed spans of "important
information". We evaluate the meta-model under the few-shot adaptation setting.
Extensive results on 13 datasets from 6 IE tasks confirm that MetaIE can offer
a better starting point for few-shot tuning on IE datasets and outperform other
meta-models from (1) vanilla language model pre-training, (2) multi-IE-task
pre-training with human annotations, and (3) single-IE-task symbolic
distillation from LLM. Moreover, we provide comprehensive analyses of MetaIE,
such as the size of the distillation dataset, the meta-model architecture, and
the size of the meta-model.
|
[
-0.3604922592639923,
-0.7143360376358032,
0.5969666838645935,
-0.04838097468018532,
-0.12282940745353699,
-0.2698178291320801,
-0.132266104221344,
-0.6025358438491821,
0.2446204572916031,
0.38943254947662354,
-0.7370969653129578,
-0.38968396186828613,
-0.7927099466323853,
0.3194551467895508,
-0.23849418759346008,
1.1013237237930298,
0.08491532504558563,
-0.2648566961288452,
0.07272401452064514,
0.06208673119544983,
-0.4460044205188751,
-0.08347231894731522,
-0.35205787420272827,
-0.1659720540046692,
0.5858765840530396,
0.47472628951072693,
0.08071954548358917,
0.7297641634941101,
0.43811237812042236,
0.2025642842054367,
0.2502450942993164,
0.20880042016506195,
-0.5518691539764404,
-0.09056168794631958,
-0.32404375076293945,
-0.6265799403190613,
-0.4667617976665497,
0.2943612337112427,
0.5087085962295532,
0.49574214220046997,
-0.03752724081277847,
0.8319594264030457,
0.3221968710422516,
0.496674507856369,
-1.0295073986053467,
0.3626613914966583,
-0.7987202405929565,
-0.20908521115779877,
-0.3583073616027832,
-0.16762591898441315,
-0.5583937168121338,
-0.04334554448723793,
0.15095819532871246,
-0.6326461434364319,
-0.07178813219070435,
0.09475549310445786,
0.9787367582321167,
0.4275497496128082,
-0.41994723677635193,
-0.23699428141117096,
-0.8119984865188599,
0.7143261432647705,
-0.6910071969032288,
0.09986252337694168,
0.23486459255218506,
0.37109923362731934,
0.0058258152566850185,
-0.9546056389808655,
-0.6008110642433167,
0.21614210307598114,
-0.2686285376548767,
0.17208708822727203,
-0.5514605045318604,
0.05668560788035393,
0.2683315575122833,
0.0317503958940506,
-0.30586865544319153,
-0.010024805553257465,
-0.35965320467948914,
0.13705672323703766,
0.26830562949180603,
-0.026524681597948074,
0.2932592034339905,
-0.25570204854011536,
-0.25987526774406433,
0.06497732549905777,
-0.6025596857070923,
-0.10458442568778992,
0.1273089349269867,
0.36823561787605286,
0.335584431886673,
0.533561110496521,
-0.10167504847049713,
0.721183180809021,
0.3689827620983124,
-0.5182070732116699,
0.15855860710144043,
-0.1309729963541031,
-0.45012396574020386,
-0.08585499227046967,
0.8627411127090454,
0.19594544172286987,
0.39890170097351074,
-0.1137576624751091,
-0.06011851131916046,
-0.27032291889190674,
0.0922967791557312,
-1.0023162364959717,
-0.23575633764266968,
0.044896963983774185,
-0.6149598956108093,
-0.3239635229110718,
0.21459388732910156,
-0.8117675185203552,
0.004603330045938492,
-0.3575632572174072,
0.5613875985145569,
-0.22081950306892395,
-0.31470614671707153,
-0.015050970017910004,
-0.27047646045684814,
0.04482663795351982,
0.15867120027542114,
-0.9855706691741943,
0.18140040338039398,
0.6084045767784119,
0.7079672813415527,
-0.03578255698084831,
-0.2773258686065674,
-0.7797449231147766,
0.42696326971054077,
-0.02007393166422844,
0.6420524716377258,
-0.7223330140113831,
0.1354324370622635,
-0.3311665654182434,
0.13646343350410461,
-0.3480411469936371,
-0.5453058481216431,
0.36349084973335266,
-0.520072340965271,
0.17610490322113037,
-0.14337188005447388,
-0.44548743963241577,
-0.24811527132987976,
0.2567816972732544,
-1.0379949808120728,
0.9708566069602966,
-0.1389734447002411,
-1.0301477909088135,
0.4920510947704315,
-0.7934483289718628,
-0.3053314983844757,
-0.06902313977479935,
-0.0716782808303833,
-0.20538365840911865,
0.353257954120636,
0.20228536427021027,
0.5228186249732971,
-0.4500519931316376,
0.305214524269104,
-0.3668764531612396,
-0.10785000771284103,
-0.1099715456366539,
-0.4203915596008301,
0.6252740025520325,
0.11499152332544327,
-0.3039032220840454,
-0.38405153155326843,
-0.901621401309967,
-0.035219140350818634,
-0.03410923108458519,
-0.4804587960243225,
-0.5862623453140259,
0.030231324955821037,
-0.10437609255313873,
0.4044617712497711,
0.14018739759922028,
-0.3649860918521881,
0.2965252101421356,
-0.3227609097957611,
0.4934810400009155,
0.5390172004699707,
0.06440422683954239,
0.5414015054702759,
0.09144265204668045,
0.3448893427848816,
-0.1077687069773674,
-0.07777832448482513,
-0.12007017433643341,
-0.15095335245132446,
-0.5170974135398865,
-0.8034710884094238,
0.760460376739502,
0.7985855937004089,
-0.5690858960151672,
0.4044395089149475,
-0.5456376075744629,
-0.22467128932476044,
-0.736804187297821,
0.23987963795661926,
0.1309141367673874,
0.6492800116539001,
0.4318045675754547,
0.2522542476654053,
-0.6648353338241577,
-0.9462851881980896,
-0.36255747079849243,
-0.12386760115623474,
-0.1576535701751709,
0.19301213324069977,
0.5448755025863647,
-0.31186288595199585,
1.3001863956451416,
-0.6691330671310425,
-0.34344834089279175,
-0.5044623613357544,
0.7451609373092651,
0.43309202790260315,
-0.07092279195785522,
0.5305583477020264,
-0.7571923136711121,
-0.5621711611747742,
-0.16533263027668,
-0.8251229524612427,
-0.4583032727241516,
0.003570629982277751,
-0.1796659231185913,
-0.377262681722641,
0.3928253948688507,
-0.6314935088157654,
0.3457144796848297,
0.35618698596954346,
0.029357125982642174,
0.2797626852989197,
0.21309781074523926,
0.00043310402543284,
-1.3956362009048462,
0.4218474328517914,
0.09521453827619553,
-0.5716119408607483,
-0.6310510039329529,
0.039914894849061966,
0.035100918263196945,
-0.009259714744985104,
-0.4388822317123413,
0.5876770615577698,
-0.5512769818305969,
0.19237060844898224,
-0.5447129011154175,
0.16950711607933044,
0.2039375752210617,
0.3727858364582062,
0.16261020302772522,
0.4859226942062378,
0.3483075499534607,
-0.6944453716278076,
0.15139278769493103,
0.07078951597213745,
-0.19573217630386353,
0.38513198494911194,
-0.47055527567863464,
-0.08236448466777802,
-0.3723546862602234,
0.19873230159282684,
-0.7395684123039246,
-0.0924159437417984,
0.1947961002588272,
-0.13544976711273193,
0.4638940691947937,
-0.30694249272346497,
-0.41179975867271423,
-0.29538723826408386,
-0.2955552637577057,
0.22689184546470642,
0.277384489774704,
-0.5106085538864136,
1.0128051042556763,
0.4316762685775757,
-0.24167683720588684,
-0.9247394800186157,
-0.5279255509376526,
0.09264878928661346,
-0.4293968081474304,
-0.4536855220794678,
0.37098225951194763,
0.018616540357470512,
-0.27929702401161194,
0.2224763035774231,
-0.17237477004528046,
-0.2699057161808014,
0.30721160769462585,
0.12277494370937347,
0.21912482380867004,
-0.15419445931911469,
0.3133483827114105,
-0.02945704758167267,
-0.24174414575099945,
-0.05745762586593628,
-0.36189669370651245,
0.15661226212978363,
0.12440415471792221,
0.0777592808008194,
-0.4892040193080902,
0.2986530363559723,
0.3777872920036316,
-0.1200784370303154,
0.7084250450134277,
0.7510135769844055,
-0.5445215106010437,
-0.19510026276111603,
-0.5870155096054077,
-0.4002869427204132,
-0.36426398158073425,
0.43996572494506836,
-0.5954225659370422,
-0.6273638010025024,
0.031189553439617157,
-0.583459734916687,
0.3236266076564789,
0.6799920201301575,
0.20706526935100555,
-0.5151953101158142,
0.617504358291626,
1.0820634365081787,
-0.5825891494750977,
0.528075098991394,
-0.14325322210788727,
0.0550413653254509,
-0.5771105885505676,
0.14384736120700836,
-0.4708358347415924,
-0.5665366053581238,
-0.3017825782299042,
-0.08472873270511627,
0.2979738414287567,
0.38762959837913513,
0.3529985845088959,
0.43827545642852783,
-0.0920693576335907,
0.6014556288719177,
0.488242506980896,
0.0033765065018087626,
0.19227831065654755,
-0.07226976007223129,
0.1810522973537445,
0.04827781766653061,
-0.6025614738464355,
-0.833390474319458,
1.0747617483139038,
0.3070976138114929,
0.8851600885391235,
0.007340097799897194,
0.9858303666114807,
0.2641335129737854,
0.3642005920410156,
-0.7313464283943176,
0.308260440826416,
-0.2481687366962433,
-0.7210955619812012,
-0.38197681307792664,
-0.3842756152153015,
-0.7927491068840027,
0.22730021178722382,
-0.35900577902793884,
-0.8544248938560486,
0.1744166910648346,
0.27787649631500244,
-0.434799462556839,
0.1698545664548874,
-0.550532341003418,
0.9896913170814514,
-0.04950471594929695,
-0.30496251583099365,
0.017055384814739227,
-0.8867771029472351,
0.5147932767868042,
-0.23967187106609344,
0.4374029338359833,
-0.1528823971748352,
0.13577574491500854,
0.7397204637527466,
-0.2142173945903778,
1.0393272638320923,
-0.16390395164489746,
0.014890577644109726,
0.5016248822212219,
0.1270960569381714,
0.7604105472564697,
-0.11784408986568451,
0.029682883992791176,
0.027959775179624557,
0.23683935403823853,
-0.0009858425473794341,
-0.6891518235206604,
0.13931138813495636,
-0.4587843716144562,
-0.5741813778877258,
-0.180789977312088,
-0.1315971165895462,
0.14533957839012146,
0.3224160671234131,
0.4122801721096039,
0.10242752730846405,
-0.3424362242221832,
0.07544022053480148,
0.7246295213699341,
0.2597450017929077,
0.7410764694213867,
0.5426170825958252,
0.019736986607313156,
-0.1489148586988449,
0.841508150100708,
0.01272730715572834,
0.09764686226844788,
0.9314568042755127,
0.21489062905311584,
-0.12552860379219055,
-0.18121398985385895,
-0.3476651906967163,
0.24795520305633545,
-0.6531837582588196,
-0.40320560336112976,
-0.8506627678871155,
-0.07286794483661652,
-0.20662787556648254,
0.41294148564338684,
-0.32328495383262634,
-0.4860893785953522,
-0.6257644891738892,
-0.18779243528842926,
-0.030399976298213005,
0.6709774136543274,
-0.22629213333129883,
0.3112167716026306,
-1.067055583000183,
0.4668632745742798,
0.47758227586746216,
-0.3906570374965668,
-0.35129404067993164,
-0.4411277174949646,
-0.23024338483810425,
0.03430074453353882,
-0.24438224732875824,
-1.0728727579116821,
0.2574155032634735,
0.6404125690460205,
0.5125885605812073,
0.5011416077613831,
-0.02877180464565754,
0.8268489241600037,
-0.7620127201080322,
0.4771316349506378,
0.12031756341457367,
-1.0231022834777832,
0.7015751004219055,
0.12967270612716675,
-0.05598863959312439,
0.9845806360244751,
0.5571745038032532,
-0.27384641766548157,
-0.030329003930091858,
-0.4981509745121002,
-0.7513778805732727,
0.711519181728363,
0.01925831101834774,
-0.23869432508945465,
-0.07144609093666077,
0.49858346581459045,
0.22193066775798798,
0.34072259068489075,
-1.3398284912109375,
-0.020216571167111397,
0.15499480068683624,
-0.6163504123687744,
0.19447143375873566,
-0.3125109076499939,
-0.06391794234514236,
0.10588130354881287,
0.6723647713661194,
-0.2833612561225891,
0.003915703855454922,
-0.10917714983224869,
-0.7218500971794128,
0.08212243765592575,
0.39457234740257263,
0.10382932424545288,
0.5877496600151062,
-0.2296053171157837,
0.4844139814376831,
0.326067715883255,
-0.3339281976222992,
0.0673738345503807,
0.058347929269075394,
0.029203835874795914,
0.0696432963013649,
0.7357708215713501,
0.6433236598968506,
0.17059683799743652,
-0.4385775029659271,
0.7474759817123413,
0.0794556736946106,
-0.11877533793449402,
0.1409551203250885,
0.008666211739182472,
-0.011601821519434452,
0.4035227298736572,
0.36513981223106384,
-0.2317219078540802,
0.50089430809021,
-0.6522392630577087,
0.2750512957572937,
0.4921761751174927,
-0.015350489877164364,
-0.5362058281898499,
0.4525243043899536,
0.2097672075033188,
0.10151692479848862,
0.44908443093299866,
-0.23264238238334656,
-0.20595486462116241,
0.23495161533355713,
0.5665411353111267,
1.0034089088439941,
-0.2572989761829376,
0.23185594379901886,
0.48439785838127136,
0.48328539729118347,
-0.22450751066207886,
0.03785840421915054,
-0.2076747566461563,
-0.5304943323135376,
-0.49853742122650146,
-0.8032720685005188,
0.12916532158851624,
0.28409311175346375,
-0.7268884778022766,
0.45461609959602356,
0.014695149846374989,
-0.2593967616558075,
0.13434989750385284,
-0.23355887830257416,
-0.8607839345932007,
0.2761507034301758,
0.22372154891490936,
0.8663642406463623,
-1.1583201885223389,
0.7944820523262024,
0.3692970871925354,
-0.3235636055469513,
-0.7055826783180237,
0.2152470052242279,
-0.1123562827706337,
-0.6892901659011841,
1.0549668073654175,
0.250355988740921,
-0.18783672153949738,
0.019838029518723488,
-0.42512863874435425,
-0.9044920802116394,
1.3957854509353638,
0.5336229205131531,
-1.0285097360610962,
-0.4883212149143219,
0.07648163288831711,
0.23718535900115967,
-0.535271406173706,
0.37025460600852966,
0.7229437232017517,
0.6421923637390137,
0.024115560576319695,
-0.8442158102989197,
0.05585791915655136,
-0.06949301809072495,
-0.27489569783210754,
0.22226202487945557,
-0.33808624744415283,
0.7085047960281372,
-0.04165729507803917,
-0.47387635707855225,
-0.2943497598171234,
0.4107111096382141,
-0.02890036627650261,
0.19946011900901794,
0.5877899527549744,
0.6141597628593445,
0.8451120853424072,
0.04670219123363495,
0.5217085480690002,
-0.18101638555526733,
0.2889472246170044,
1.4330123662948608,
-0.25792238116264343,
0.9992212057113647,
0.48069775104522705,
0.037144359201192856,
0.5349230766296387,
0.6163519024848938,
0.11910004168748856,
0.800084114074707,
0.02957361750304699,
-0.12472608685493469,
-0.20818857848644257,
0.23645950853824615,
-0.1294756531715393,
0.5682689547538757,
0.23361678421497345,
-0.5415986776351929,
-0.4080180525779724,
0.16287420690059662,
-0.03223622590303421,
-0.3906960189342499,
-0.15037082135677338,
1.2733190059661865,
0.04058995470404625,
-0.4441203773021698,
0.21778914332389832,
0.12730582058429718,
0.46246179938316345,
-0.5873950719833374,
-0.0698949471116066,
0.14757272601127625,
-0.1505771428346634,
-0.21940991282463074,
-0.2822030484676361,
0.28384628891944885,
0.10325796902179718,
-0.5487697720527649,
-0.10427842289209366,
0.9053981900215149,
-0.5274204611778259,
-0.5314610600471497,
0.26936593651771545,
0.5966554284095764,
0.26869016885757446,
-0.2794816195964813,
-0.5519124865531921,
-0.21092350780963898,
-0.02154235728085041,
-0.33563148975372314,
0.07855764776468277,
0.7957555651664734,
0.17060203850269318,
0.26408812403678894,
0.2627769708633423,
0.11262745410203934,
0.010311667807400227,
-0.11533541977405548,
0.8323391675949097,
-0.6406199932098389,
-0.4054029583930969,
-1.3938956260681152,
0.6028443574905396,
-0.17490974068641663,
0.038217246532440186,
0.4573728144168854,
0.528098464012146,
0.3349531888961792,
-0.09168022125959396,
0.992020845413208,
-0.15422844886779785,
0.29919740557670593,
-0.6943399906158447,
0.29324251413345337,
-0.5351612567901611,
0.09333545714616776,
-0.39276203513145447,
-1.1909205913543701,
0.027266725897789,
0.44342201948165894,
-0.19869109988212585,
-0.1468920111656189,
0.7796959280967712,
0.44089847803115845,
-0.3795294463634491,
-0.0988452360033989,
0.220706507563591,
0.15061749517917633,
0.2681351602077484,
0.6151513457298279,
0.5998499989509583,
-0.37213796377182007,
0.6063594818115234,
0.2831040918827057,
-0.6071376204490662,
-0.2648158073425293,
-1.232181429862976,
-0.9694075584411621,
-0.4212464988231659,
-0.31523847579956055,
0.02295273169875145,
-0.09456057101488113,
0.9045941829681396,
0.9918291568756104,
-0.5708369612693787,
0.07455643266439438,
-0.014838283881545067,
0.012779497541487217,
-0.16110090911388397,
-0.21191547811031342,
0.1647479236125946,
-0.3762880861759186,
-0.839009165763855,
0.4971317946910858,
0.45758649706840515,
0.07289697229862213,
0.19142472743988037,
0.44506821036338806,
-0.35496121644973755,
0.11911675333976746,
0.5725569725036621,
0.2580540180206299,
-0.5333428978919983,
-0.25823456048965454,
-0.16505935788154602,
-0.006167927756905556,
-0.006165104452520609,
0.7607431411743164,
-0.5566710829734802,
0.31372949481010437,
0.34087932109832764,
0.7383561134338379,
0.7705262303352356,
0.048405133187770844,
0.5058373808860779,
-1.0276731252670288,
-0.07069513201713562,
-0.06864723563194275,
0.3426191508769989,
-0.1136353611946106,
-0.40504467487335205,
0.5706436634063721,
0.16363391280174255,
-0.23878374695777893,
-0.6057273745536804,
0.2486405223608017,
-0.6777417659759521,
-0.43230488896369934,
1.0601458549499512,
-0.25708818435668945,
-0.43893200159072876,
0.20501336455345154,
-0.14456301927566528,
0.30181998014450073,
-0.1293104588985443,
0.6605629920959473,
0.8537915945053101,
0.06975407153367996,
-0.1371142864227295,
-0.42282605171203613,
0.42331621050834656,
-0.09275780618190765,
-1.066840648651123,
0.17971467971801758,
0.26327264308929443,
0.6409541964530945,
0.32292646169662476,
0.5267423987388611,
0.1694883555173874,
-0.09978622198104858,
-0.2662532329559326,
0.17177899181842804,
-0.11604079604148865,
-0.7685156464576721,
0.008298010565340519,
0.32233425974845886,
-0.02957385592162609,
-0.42814210057258606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00450v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00450v2
|
Planning and Editing What You Retrieve for Enhanced Tool Learning
| 2024-03-30T18:41:51 | 2024-04-04T05:33:07 |
Tenghao Huang, Dongwon Jung, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in integrating external tools with Large Language Models
(LLMs) have opened new frontiers, with applications in mathematical reasoning,
code generators, and smart assistants. However, existing methods, relying on
simple one-time retrieval strategies, fall short on effectively and accurately
shortlisting relevant tools. This paper introduces a novel PLUTO (Planning,
Learning, and Understanding for TOols) approach, encompassing
`Plan-and-Retrieve (P&R)` and `Edit-and-Ground (E&G)` paradigms. The P&R
paradigm consists of a neural retrieval module for shortlisting relevant tools
and an LLM-based query planner that decomposes complex queries into actionable
tasks, enhancing the effectiveness of tool utilization. The E&G paradigm
utilizes LLMs to enrich tool descriptions based on user scenarios, bridging the
gap between user queries and tool functionalities. Experiment results
demonstrate that these paradigms significantly improve the recall and NDCG in
tool retrieval tasks, significantly surpassing current state-of-the-art models.
|
[
-0.3488601744174957,
-0.8546318411827087,
0.9105073809623718,
-0.07721704989671707,
-0.01962852291762829,
0.23120227456092834,
-0.5155777931213379,
-0.1651618927717209,
0.6583799719810486,
0.6192058324813843,
-0.5377116799354553,
-0.5852615237236023,
-0.21478906273841858,
-0.14282217621803284,
-0.3256346583366394,
0.5397220849990845,
0.044898681342601776,
-0.12291128188371658,
-0.2794983685016632,
0.19967928528785706,
-0.5115333199501038,
-0.45794767141342163,
-0.5339526534080505,
-0.39119693636894226,
0.6858860850334167,
0.6626455187797546,
0.8054160475730896,
0.4700779318809509,
0.30747097730636597,
0.26493874192237854,
-0.12026366591453552,
0.18221688270568848,
-0.39286932349205017,
0.16582252085208893,
-0.4314238131046295,
-0.5796841979026794,
-0.5556151866912842,
-0.13029871881008148,
0.35108399391174316,
0.7987672686576843,
-0.23167642951011658,
0.003331667510792613,
0.06642752140760422,
0.4849947690963745,
-0.8768064379692078,
-0.07339788973331451,
-0.8798866868019104,
0.02550412528216839,
0.03781730309128761,
-0.23642931878566742,
-0.6739600300788879,
-0.2897479236125946,
0.09508268535137177,
-1.1125849485397339,
0.12054724991321564,
-0.017352964729070663,
0.45001107454299927,
0.06943679600954056,
0.0010599360102787614,
-0.2562011778354645,
-0.7377379536628723,
0.6451855897903442,
-0.3915847837924957,
0.6400814652442932,
0.5921385288238525,
0.27019888162612915,
-0.24195021390914917,
-1.0407230854034424,
-0.5249269008636475,
-0.0012226219987496734,
-0.19966411590576172,
0.13884033262729645,
0.21541740000247955,
0.08357198536396027,
0.47540542483329773,
0.10879078507423401,
-0.254778653383255,
0.2799908220767975,
-0.4324522018432617,
-0.33367493748664856,
0.6824759840965271,
0.2607775032520294,
0.08097384124994278,
-0.4087340235710144,
-0.06571981310844421,
-0.11866189539432526,
-1.0993461608886719,
-0.16629740595817566,
0.33172258734703064,
0.2183256894350052,
0.19636207818984985,
0.6764196157455444,
-0.3944513201713562,
0.7068432569503784,
-0.12109982222318649,
-0.24500036239624023,
-0.05913771688938141,
-0.3047455847263336,
-0.37953993678092957,
-0.261344850063324,
0.6144197583198547,
0.2407773733139038,
-0.05873368680477142,
-0.4983554780483246,
-0.26425275206565857,
-0.46822625398635864,
0.4872789680957794,
-0.4592500627040863,
-0.6807655692100525,
0.11017045378684998,
-0.3019772171974182,
-0.03724164888262749,
-0.09382100403308868,
-0.7286667823791504,
-0.5500531792640686,
-0.533197283744812,
0.5648407936096191,
-0.42733561992645264,
-0.2391701638698578,
0.20708659291267395,
-0.15707674622535706,
0.021478701382875443,
0.7180603742599487,
-0.606291651725769,
0.36699607968330383,
0.8751398324966431,
0.5451491475105286,
0.017339283600449562,
-0.31460222601890564,
-0.8221902847290039,
0.06075295805931091,
-0.3296331763267517,
0.7420466542243958,
-0.670515775680542,
-0.8048659563064575,
-0.13200929760932922,
0.04722457751631737,
0.0727226510643959,
-0.4966345727443695,
0.32770320773124695,
-0.7221580147743225,
0.6218992471694946,
-0.4654064476490021,
-0.31692424416542053,
-0.46243226528167725,
0.13227856159210205,
-0.6213023066520691,
1.275375247001648,
0.1070781946182251,
-0.6818812489509583,
0.5774630308151245,
-0.6024528741836548,
-0.4064319431781769,
0.07944455742835999,
-0.22994635999202728,
-0.3794978857040405,
0.004088630899786949,
0.22782544791698456,
0.4441540837287903,
-0.18582569062709808,
0.37908217310905457,
-0.34102877974510193,
-0.37258821725845337,
-0.0012738244840875268,
0.28155553340911865,
0.5061957836151123,
0.037762351334095,
-0.07535019516944885,
0.5940889120101929,
-0.4297366738319397,
0.23704615235328674,
0.13632184267044067,
-0.4158335328102112,
-0.3095686435699463,
0.41284987330436707,
-0.04361923038959503,
0.3616332411766052,
0.1894368976354599,
-0.6640781760215759,
0.4425743520259857,
-0.3781341314315796,
0.497867614030838,
0.7037884593009949,
-0.1405351161956787,
0.6921311616897583,
-0.08720771223306656,
0.3744884133338928,
-0.4092157781124115,
0.08504924923181534,
-0.3071039915084839,
0.04090027138590813,
-0.8568801283836365,
0.16304907202720642,
0.3285869061946869,
0.7870428562164307,
-1.0014444589614868,
0.2940153181552887,
-0.2643992602825165,
-0.48283660411834717,
-0.1939464956521988,
0.2680826783180237,
0.22110219299793243,
0.41031137108802795,
0.3082767724990845,
-0.2968340516090393,
-0.4967479407787323,
-0.8350661396980286,
-0.35714420676231384,
-0.14034509658813477,
-0.37501469254493713,
0.5274450778961182,
0.24230027198791504,
0.14068518579006195,
1.0343440771102905,
-0.65824294090271,
-0.174400195479393,
-0.7078913450241089,
-0.24971996247768402,
0.21089211106300354,
0.17978574335575104,
0.03772822022438049,
-0.8800525665283203,
-0.4957702159881592,
-0.16661830246448517,
-0.514590859413147,
0.143617644906044,
-0.2795250415802002,
-0.23369553685188293,
-0.28215762972831726,
0.5560365915298462,
-0.5070316791534424,
0.48510298132896423,
-0.3289940357208252,
-0.15498456358909607,
0.526067316532135,
-0.26406875252723694,
-0.22622643411159515,
-0.9472824931144714,
0.12557020783424377,
-0.16355741024017334,
-0.30376577377319336,
-0.35988369584083557,
0.12002472579479218,
0.6162197589874268,
-0.04082240164279938,
-0.7321557402610779,
0.6385535001754761,
-0.5563331246376038,
-0.3964676260948181,
-0.28023281693458557,
0.40306854248046875,
0.24583503603935242,
0.4846278727054596,
0.04677730053663254,
0.9814963936805725,
0.43098658323287964,
-0.806999146938324,
0.1367948204278946,
0.2683676779270172,
-0.04285016655921936,
0.28421998023986816,
-0.5637295842170715,
0.4758947193622589,
-0.17016172409057617,
-0.0836050882935524,
-0.3496031165122986,
-0.13943713903427124,
0.08481720089912415,
-0.12065710127353668,
0.45017898082733154,
-0.2991824448108673,
-1.02735435962677,
-0.14631907641887665,
-0.492704302072525,
-0.20130555331707,
0.46192190051078796,
-0.6484917402267456,
1.0212011337280273,
0.5651324987411499,
-0.4687594771385193,
-0.5387255549430847,
-0.06564731150865555,
0.029591122642159462,
-0.28289660811424255,
-0.34217843413352966,
0.5598408579826355,
0.2242857813835144,
-0.27694371342658997,
-0.0017285457579419017,
-0.13727828860282898,
0.18678581714630127,
0.28566354513168335,
0.21981902420520782,
0.490423321723938,
0.18238447606563568,
0.40480270981788635,
0.04974424093961716,
-0.08144062012434006,
0.049000851809978485,
-0.14836904406547546,
0.5931481719017029,
0.2646910846233368,
-0.34870445728302,
-0.0787244439125061,
0.17826548218727112,
0.18918752670288086,
-0.4446643590927124,
0.15385979413986206,
0.38524553179740906,
-0.30242282152175903,
-0.06568623334169388,
-0.8070020079612732,
-0.43579861521720886,
-0.5521544814109802,
0.5342066287994385,
-0.5238356590270996,
-0.7397323846817017,
0.35523444414138794,
-0.4374616742134094,
0.39883753657341003,
0.2232312113046646,
0.19249339401721954,
-0.0005303602665662766,
0.7932100892066956,
1.0762780904769897,
-0.08210162818431854,
0.5663049221038818,
-0.4848346710205078,
0.19888882339000702,
-1.4789094924926758,
-0.4204453229904175,
-0.34433579444885254,
-0.5250704884529114,
-0.18666261434555054,
-0.4452665448188782,
0.4588693678379059,
0.397755891084671,
0.046660326421260834,
0.46194422245025635,
-0.5513297915458679,
0.7484530210494995,
0.6760269999504089,
0.1429828703403473,
0.30002114176750183,
-0.08658293634653091,
-0.43009743094444275,
-0.18382534384727478,
-0.791639506816864,
-0.6179726123809814,
1.5264986753463745,
-0.011592845432460308,
0.7707183361053467,
-0.265982061624527,
0.8076225519180298,
-0.16002947092056274,
0.2600218653678894,
-0.9610496163368225,
0.8237009644508362,
-0.027022674679756165,
-0.35292792320251465,
-0.3027244508266449,
0.0059744794853031635,
-0.8560178875923157,
0.4937533736228943,
-0.15825285017490387,
-0.959209680557251,
0.1843249499797821,
-0.009783295914530754,
-0.4571102559566498,
0.6034694314002991,
-0.6250860691070557,
0.6867385506629944,
-0.5327261686325073,
-0.7166011333465576,
-0.4845082759857178,
-0.37963080406188965,
-0.06772008538246155,
0.0532551035284996,
0.2161276489496231,
-0.13672351837158203,
-0.3510831296443939,
0.569269597530365,
0.030583443120121956,
0.4959673583507538,
-0.21465076506137848,
0.3775796890258789,
0.2892961800098419,
0.5470077395439148,
0.6542856693267822,
0.330594003200531,
-0.3273932933807373,
-0.44979745149612427,
-0.2823725640773773,
-0.04568355903029442,
-0.6870538592338562,
0.7433757781982422,
-0.48930981755256653,
-0.6992829442024231,
-0.11729459464550018,
-0.631808876991272,
-0.009971662424504757,
0.529853105545044,
-0.03915143013000488,
0.4446706473827362,
-0.33797839283943176,
0.00917904358357191,
0.7240698933601379,
-0.6465144157409668,
0.4949344992637634,
0.561150848865509,
-0.5260568857192993,
-0.3081403076648712,
0.7363811135292053,
0.033741723746061325,
0.23404406011104584,
0.46152815222740173,
0.040483344346284866,
-0.21545520424842834,
-0.5683161020278931,
-0.17597761750221252,
0.24957822263240814,
-0.870044469833374,
-0.09086012095212936,
-0.9781255125999451,
0.15106862783432007,
-0.07233285158872604,
-0.3356154263019562,
-0.30885910987854004,
-0.7436098456382751,
-0.07627679407596588,
-0.1578432023525238,
0.3228166699409485,
0.6908341646194458,
-0.11885630339384079,
0.31387224793434143,
-0.4259137511253357,
0.26540622115135193,
0.09505948424339294,
0.29867976903915405,
-0.2891601026058197,
0.06284263730049133,
-0.23324596881866455,
-0.14771734178066254,
-0.7013944983482361,
-0.7889426350593567,
0.5487208962440491,
0.19258135557174683,
0.5540193319320679,
-0.11836627870798111,
0.06099918857216835,
0.5367750525474548,
-0.5839402675628662,
0.5957209467887878,
-0.049033693969249725,
-0.6406475305557251,
0.9258074760437012,
-0.01542514469474554,
0.14595475792884827,
0.5875965356826782,
0.38717350363731384,
-0.6677849292755127,
-0.13542093336582184,
-0.7780550718307495,
-1.0718404054641724,
0.7384037375450134,
-0.29308706521987915,
-0.03467801958322525,
0.11341280490159988,
0.48340675234794617,
0.3911915123462677,
0.2586507797241211,
-0.435760498046875,
0.04068728908896446,
0.1337519884109497,
0.27341228723526,
0.034924205392599106,
-0.11939366906881332,
-0.058405667543411255,
-0.25319021940231323,
0.5976371169090271,
-0.22682516276836395,
0.3149030804634094,
0.20717349648475647,
-0.3014830946922302,
-0.01974673382937908,
0.5203266739845276,
0.049632832407951355,
1.0978734493255615,
-0.06550861150026321,
-0.04942469671368599,
0.39303991198539734,
-0.3496374189853668,
-0.29061925411224365,
0.08067286759614944,
-0.2726220190525055,
0.041951000690460205,
-0.059931378811597824,
0.46434900164604187,
0.5191476941108704,
-0.7481503486633301,
0.08106578141450882,
0.055460598319768906,
-0.06667371094226837,
-0.532922625541687,
0.24730218946933746,
0.24632899463176727,
0.04033472016453743,
0.18259930610656738,
-0.21598994731903076,
0.3607310950756073,
-0.4429164528846741,
0.24427659809589386,
0.5009448528289795,
-0.06119970977306366,
-0.2889554500579834,
0.576716423034668,
0.04006773605942726,
-0.5132527351379395,
0.8381604552268982,
-0.30410948395729065,
-0.5152866840362549,
0.4033547341823578,
0.19760547578334808,
0.7587178349494934,
0.24939334392547607,
0.1798037886619568,
0.4746479392051697,
0.30529409646987915,
-0.008266241289675236,
0.6805908679962158,
-0.17771877348423004,
-0.40304431319236755,
-0.7186833024024963,
-0.31752604246139526,
-0.44024530053138733,
0.19789358973503113,
-0.6077094674110413,
0.6103873252868652,
-0.6117807030677795,
-0.11256566643714905,
-0.047762732952833176,
0.08913113176822662,
-0.8576244711875916,
-0.17791303992271423,
-0.41767042875289917,
0.9705809950828552,
-0.3219224512577057,
0.9988506436347961,
0.8226372599601746,
-0.20015773177146912,
-1.1053595542907715,
-0.2604503929615021,
0.042501505464315414,
-0.6656904220581055,
0.6186999082565308,
-0.049820393323898315,
0.19578076899051666,
-0.1260405033826828,
-0.25316768884658813,
-0.8556423783302307,
1.2273746728897095,
0.11585979908704758,
-0.5865601301193237,
-0.31236153841018677,
-0.24354061484336853,
0.10786406695842743,
-0.09320062398910522,
0.3046184778213501,
0.5466693639755249,
0.332514226436615,
0.026108233258128166,
-1.289469599723816,
-0.029733795672655106,
-0.1333685666322708,
-0.18195830285549164,
0.8565638065338135,
-0.15307237207889557,
0.8535277843475342,
-0.4571969509124756,
-0.2751471698284149,
-0.019682765007019043,
0.10270297527313232,
0.11160266399383545,
0.3188372254371643,
0.2743997573852539,
0.6410748958587646,
0.46886637806892395,
-0.2194521278142929,
1.129227876663208,
-0.14657187461853027,
0.12555170059204102,
1.396913766860962,
-0.2747180461883545,
1.1724520921707153,
0.5206443071365356,
-0.15808215737342834,
0.3488832712173462,
0.6568509936332703,
0.3748132884502411,
0.6084680557250977,
-0.0697966143488884,
0.027985377237200737,
-0.42375168204307556,
0.14996640384197235,
-0.24061976373195648,
0.23231029510498047,
0.6717144846916199,
-0.3221975266933441,
-0.32929113507270813,
0.11166412383317947,
0.10248218476772308,
0.2006363719701767,
-0.27074044942855835,
1.0560359954833984,
0.08775188773870468,
-0.6775721907615662,
0.2367347925901413,
0.1838226020336151,
0.6550419330596924,
-0.4564906358718872,
-0.09025364369153976,
0.09902288019657135,
0.21269676089286804,
-0.2034480720758438,
-0.9351086020469666,
0.36921989917755127,
-0.3685169517993927,
0.09665276110172272,
-0.44506722688674927,
1.018838882446289,
-0.2394426017999649,
-0.4133429527282715,
0.20912662148475647,
0.7785602807998657,
-0.04079858213663101,
-0.24357590079307556,
-0.7418644428253174,
-0.014377040788531303,
-0.15921220183372498,
-0.023477651178836823,
0.520534098148346,
0.32295072078704834,
0.009674266912043095,
0.9086366295814514,
0.6546164155006409,
0.27410227060317993,
-0.03492771461606026,
-0.10808289796113968,
1.170623779296875,
-0.6596233248710632,
-0.6376110315322876,
-0.5997097492218018,
0.6260968446731567,
-0.273470014333725,
0.044801343232393265,
0.6679823994636536,
0.8542712926864624,
1.184906244277954,
0.020481055602431297,
0.6464950442314148,
-0.22897331416606903,
0.826593816280365,
-0.6818283200263977,
0.3571287989616394,
-0.3672490417957306,
0.5605347156524658,
-0.2154512107372284,
-1.1040047407150269,
-0.14784471690654755,
0.7140454649925232,
-0.8364112377166748,
-0.23541034758090973,
0.6244235038757324,
0.6209136843681335,
-0.2900114059448242,
-0.07100401818752289,
0.016948441043496132,
-0.260081946849823,
0.39845120906829834,
0.556538999080658,
0.807422399520874,
-0.10750717669725418,
0.2617523670196533,
-0.7730244398117065,
0.0036555947735905647,
-0.23331239819526672,
-0.7666700482368469,
-0.699140191078186,
-0.3414403200149536,
-0.21305912733078003,
0.005951649509370327,
0.13045550882816315,
0.9891292452812195,
0.6656619906425476,
-0.1622980535030365,
-0.46389251947402954,
0.10616589337587357,
0.46043500304222107,
-0.0861540287733078,
-0.19876505434513092,
0.3998253047466278,
-0.3328781723976135,
-0.40175262093544006,
0.6204476952552795,
0.5020081400871277,
-0.3571311831474304,
-0.19231189787387848,
-0.0753309577703476,
-0.06735020130872726,
-0.47021982073783875,
0.7317662239074707,
0.39583930373191833,
-0.88955157995224,
-0.2626325190067291,
0.6176173686981201,
0.3800254762172699,
0.07389906793832779,
1.1473697423934937,
-1.461793065071106,
0.7326226830482483,
0.43555402755737305,
0.4992470145225525,
0.5227195024490356,
-0.27213358879089355,
0.6977956891059875,
-0.5495764017105103,
0.2622363865375519,
0.6248720288276672,
0.3767765760421753,
0.3159638047218323,
-0.6351842284202576,
0.6132853031158447,
-0.300701379776001,
-0.46062636375427246,
-0.7308469414710999,
0.37873077392578125,
-0.6514500975608826,
-0.30864864587783813,
0.8601655960083008,
0.0503481850028038,
0.15561507642269135,
-0.1946965754032135,
-0.517265796661377,
0.018530646339058876,
-0.11056798696517944,
0.8794897794723511,
0.497641921043396,
-0.3268979787826538,
-0.151213601231575,
-0.8879687786102295,
0.41051459312438965,
0.3860253691673279,
-0.8207941651344299,
0.024970643222332,
0.6067378520965576,
0.44701147079467773,
0.21094070374965668,
0.5949977040290833,
-0.19721482694149017,
0.5230427980422974,
-0.3454166054725647,
-0.04214354604482651,
-0.30961641669273376,
-0.5398575663566589,
0.09577634930610657,
0.023520713672041893,
0.33940014243125916,
0.12901540100574493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00439v1
|
DOCMASTER: A Unified Platform for Annotation, Training, & Inference in Document Question-Answering
| 2024-03-30T18:11:39 | 2024-03-30T18:11:39 |
Alex Nguyen, Zilong Wang, Jingbo Shang, Dheeraj Mekala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The application of natural language processing models to PDF documents is
pivotal for various business applications yet the challenge of training models
for this purpose persists in businesses due to specific hurdles. These include
the complexity of working with PDF formats that necessitate parsing text and
layout information for curating training data and the lack of
privacy-preserving annotation tools. This paper introduces DOCMASTER, a unified
platform designed for annotating PDF documents, model training, and inference,
tailored to document question-answering. The annotation interface enables users
to input questions and highlight text spans within the PDF file as answers,
saving layout information and text spans accordingly. Furthermore, DOCMASTER
supports both state-of-the-art layout-aware and text models for comprehensive
training purposes. Importantly, as annotations, training, and inference occur
on-device, it also safeguards privacy. The platform has been instrumental in
driving several research prototypes concerning document analysis such as the AI
assistant utilized by University of California San Diego's (UCSD) International
Services and Engagement Office (ISEO) for processing a substantial volume of
PDF documents.
|
[
-0.5083172917366028,
-0.7839446663856506,
0.5248951315879822,
0.30245453119277954,
-0.08658147603273392,
-0.06632373481988907,
0.11123428493738174,
-0.3810131251811981,
-0.12496367841959,
0.7106199264526367,
-0.48276689648628235,
-0.5376704335212708,
-0.6675958633422852,
0.3574907183647156,
-0.4475831091403961,
0.766225278377533,
-0.19020460546016693,
0.28755077719688416,
-0.6057259440422058,
-0.20379315316677094,
-0.3718743324279785,
-0.4259383976459503,
-0.8145290613174438,
-0.3359992206096649,
0.1512136310338974,
0.3584611415863037,
0.3860878050327301,
0.644905686378479,
0.5769350528717041,
0.27358269691467285,
0.17260271310806274,
0.19286400079727173,
0.16216877102851868,
0.2664855420589447,
-0.13602957129478455,
-0.4320630431175232,
-0.5937042832374573,
0.38197237253189087,
0.41766858100891113,
0.689656674861908,
-0.13746531307697296,
0.1280898153781891,
-0.12908166646957397,
0.3982214331626892,
-0.6854960322380066,
0.01661296747624874,
-0.2871555984020233,
0.1746886670589447,
0.1917722076177597,
-0.4401412308216095,
-0.2020656317472458,
-0.40703827142715454,
-0.06170010194182396,
-0.9723395705223083,
0.646563708782196,
0.07925263792276382,
0.8326811790466309,
0.246552973985672,
-0.30285727977752686,
-0.3343634009361267,
-0.6152402758598328,
0.16291138529777527,
-0.16500888764858246,
0.46840837597846985,
0.7449592351913452,
0.4875085949897766,
0.08582673221826553,
-1.0355250835418701,
-0.6878015398979187,
0.25859835743904114,
-0.2705807089805603,
0.255424827337265,
0.04511519894003868,
0.2862710952758789,
0.12466228008270264,
0.398713082075119,
-0.4829064905643463,
0.13291014730930328,
-0.44956326484680176,
-0.2577560245990753,
0.5842497944831848,
-0.019553324207663536,
0.4311786890029907,
-0.07717445492744446,
-0.31469303369522095,
-0.14125998318195343,
-0.08697140961885452,
0.2180105745792389,
0.5060544610023499,
-0.02431430295109749,
0.05927066132426262,
0.3719233572483063,
-0.14070172607898712,
0.5421621799468994,
-0.011155495420098305,
-0.10118214786052704,
-0.15701532363891602,
0.12443157285451889,
-0.6223821640014648,
0.13585948944091797,
0.9592934846878052,
0.3987656235694885,
0.09544315934181213,
-0.5594293475151062,
-0.11733970791101456,
-0.1527857482433319,
0.4209219515323639,
-0.7717233896255493,
-0.38456088304519653,
0.46676984429359436,
-0.153250053524971,
-0.2753196060657501,
0.42279744148254395,
-0.7752337455749512,
-0.7253118753433228,
-0.4573960602283478,
0.1293812394142151,
-0.3579760193824768,
-0.11438598483800888,
0.11457047611474991,
-0.7756816148757935,
0.2743580937385559,
0.7689852118492126,
-1.191503643989563,
0.6644457578659058,
0.8130730390548706,
0.7270845174789429,
-0.003033277578651905,
-0.51242595911026,
-0.8922631144523621,
0.39724066853523254,
-0.24260492622852325,
0.901142418384552,
-0.5882692337036133,
-0.8076873421669006,
0.014806353487074375,
0.11444517225027084,
-0.44166383147239685,
-0.517389714717865,
0.8098292946815491,
-0.43587273359298706,
0.4291178286075592,
-0.028513668105006218,
-0.6054884195327759,
-0.1993815153837204,
0.7510968446731567,
-0.7234917879104614,
1.0667680501937866,
0.239607036113739,
-1.0463011264801025,
0.3085126280784607,
-1.0755184888839722,
-0.3669601380825043,
0.09508658945560455,
-0.39936062693595886,
-0.1676981896162033,
-0.10512572526931763,
0.45548009872436523,
0.4185827076435089,
-0.2785893380641937,
0.3223908245563507,
-0.11892876774072647,
-0.30654433369636536,
0.1284400373697281,
-0.24369890987873077,
0.7363072633743286,
0.01435287855565548,
-0.2469419687986374,
0.06682296097278595,
-0.9334980845451355,
-0.4025062322616577,
0.1155405268073082,
-0.5986859798431396,
-0.1556730717420578,
-0.4785124659538269,
0.2652086317539215,
0.0464022234082222,
0.19614529609680176,
-0.7663987874984741,
0.3222813308238983,
0.1282218098640442,
0.3195047676563263,
0.5771943926811218,
0.19466368854045868,
0.6770018935203552,
-0.1217583492398262,
0.8430052399635315,
-0.18201173841953278,
0.38990914821624756,
-0.20011094212532043,
-0.4411581754684448,
-0.3739752173423767,
-0.5602589249610901,
0.3530619740486145,
0.7553190588951111,
-0.0842907652258873,
0.151700958609581,
-0.36237841844558716,
-0.40807855129241943,
-0.6511318683624268,
0.3998538553714752,
0.05469336733222008,
0.8843159079551697,
0.22894887626171112,
-0.42642727494239807,
-0.3618335723876953,
-1.025006890296936,
-0.11945401877164841,
-0.1637762486934662,
-0.2212391346693039,
-0.03946709632873535,
0.2815224230289459,
-0.3312438130378723,
1.2294176816940308,
-0.41552314162254333,
-0.585743248462677,
-0.218708336353302,
0.3678746223449707,
-0.3321199417114258,
0.4308512210845947,
0.3318319022655487,
-1.3312342166900635,
-0.4134769141674042,
-0.10362353920936584,
-0.9602735042572021,
-0.2145506739616394,
-0.10010811686515808,
-0.22762374579906464,
0.16031520068645477,
0.6850822567939758,
-0.8020930290222168,
0.3883209824562073,
0.1714545488357544,
0.12530361115932465,
0.4001500606536865,
-0.6152737736701965,
0.1358179897069931,
-1.060415506362915,
0.3977106213569641,
-0.02681395597755909,
-0.22542735934257507,
-0.5205695629119873,
0.12510384619235992,
0.2868984639644623,
-0.41899895668029785,
-0.04824770614504814,
0.7025526762008667,
-0.42651796340942383,
-0.08124343305826187,
-0.2256699800491333,
0.5424269437789917,
0.7294508814811707,
0.3147708773612976,
0.19720156490802765,
0.8781148791313171,
0.5012180805206299,
-0.3872753381729126,
0.08031775802373886,
0.8634053468704224,
0.33955514430999756,
1.0072306394577026,
-0.5471107363700867,
0.4031926691532135,
-0.25886496901512146,
0.07172658294439316,
-1.0644487142562866,
-0.2882399260997772,
0.3525724709033966,
-0.41099491715431213,
0.4976399838924408,
-0.30234500765800476,
-1.0705348253250122,
-0.35190558433532715,
-0.4817899763584137,
-0.4997827708721161,
-0.03791693598031998,
-0.5016117095947266,
0.9918371438980103,
0.3581562638282776,
-0.12456077337265015,
-0.4858732223510742,
-0.6261799335479736,
0.2817375957965851,
-0.048483144491910934,
-0.7489029765129089,
0.0037437966093420982,
-0.13434761762619019,
-0.1810450553894043,
-0.1658024787902832,
-0.2816620171070099,
-0.17513705790042877,
0.5154138803482056,
0.7533984184265137,
0.20794904232025146,
0.09361739456653595,
0.04743015393614769,
0.349340558052063,
-0.36656415462493896,
0.2105962038040161,
-0.21590551733970642,
0.2724224925041199,
0.0897613987326622,
-0.20041131973266602,
-0.17634251713752747,
0.5649973154067993,
0.5622965693473816,
-0.8048263788223267,
0.4975670576095581,
0.6720474362373352,
-0.3753625154495239,
-0.1279151886701584,
-0.4801500737667084,
0.09481118619441986,
-0.4913701117038727,
-0.015555137768387794,
-0.44335806369781494,
-0.5925707221031189,
0.3049677312374115,
-0.29041147232055664,
0.42283791303634644,
0.33312270045280457,
0.13997280597686768,
-0.2622196078300476,
0.8037208914756775,
0.9370205402374268,
0.11404731124639511,
0.2296886295080185,
-0.37584665417671204,
0.10097028315067291,
-1.041434645652771,
-0.3635675311088562,
-0.6930278539657593,
-0.1122678816318512,
-0.031785737723112106,
-0.14060261845588684,
0.01450157631188631,
0.337837278842926,
-0.2027248740196228,
0.21618831157684326,
-0.8418863415718079,
0.27958524227142334,
0.8146091103553772,
-0.44532132148742676,
0.4170955717563629,
-0.054512668401002884,
-0.2702603340148926,
0.24063533544540405,
-0.3169744610786438,
-1.0215336084365845,
1.0700262784957886,
0.1243128776550293,
0.6515098810195923,
-0.1528211086988449,
0.7389692068099976,
0.3174390494823456,
0.5656164288520813,
-0.2635759115219116,
0.49271392822265625,
0.12421715259552002,
-0.8630809783935547,
-0.30143436789512634,
0.010174165479838848,
-0.6927176117897034,
0.35126209259033203,
-0.08137327432632446,
-1.1046987771987915,
0.11563733965158463,
-0.06350670754909515,
-0.00939137116074562,
0.4432082772254944,
-0.8155277371406555,
1.2731207609176636,
-0.18916423618793488,
-0.1682089865207672,
0.4350976347923279,
-0.7048361897468567,
0.05613363906741142,
-0.21676504611968994,
0.08164171129465103,
-0.03175068646669388,
-0.1260680854320526,
0.8028096556663513,
-0.3598063290119171,
0.6444727182388306,
-0.17615272104740143,
0.017491130158305168,
0.034055739641189575,
0.139298677444458,
0.20211158692836761,
0.2788381278514862,
-0.23602376878261566,
-0.22511160373687744,
0.3037704527378082,
-0.25870847702026367,
-0.6151208281517029,
0.4134798049926758,
-0.7948640584945679,
-0.5910970568656921,
-0.3429785668849945,
-0.6664610505104065,
-0.38328760862350464,
0.5285645723342896,
0.3322763741016388,
0.38034361600875854,
-0.35884711146354675,
-0.04738742858171463,
0.7043887376785278,
0.15317490696907043,
0.39547738432884216,
0.6634410619735718,
-0.27272042632102966,
-0.3915450870990753,
0.44976139068603516,
0.06049169600009918,
-0.14929883182048798,
0.6763461232185364,
0.004928783047944307,
-0.5131707787513733,
-0.7079488635063171,
-0.6553201675415039,
0.07133463770151138,
-1.1576427221298218,
0.17299635708332062,
-1.2859444618225098,
-0.08408384770154953,
-0.4779578149318695,
-0.4223075807094574,
0.1045415922999382,
-0.35970866680145264,
-0.2701387405395508,
-0.5429912805557251,
0.1707993447780609,
0.4887339174747467,
0.08239541202783585,
0.4853026568889618,
-0.7247164845466614,
0.5888530015945435,
0.48295435309410095,
0.33781328797340393,
-0.39754384756088257,
-0.09822932630777359,
0.05576596409082413,
-0.15948815643787384,
-0.5716938972473145,
-0.9647689461708069,
-0.09460137039422989,
0.23773376643657684,
0.6655020117759705,
0.3840017020702362,
0.15588776767253876,
0.07367148995399475,
-0.16937029361724854,
0.6070162653923035,
0.0051733083091676235,
-0.580467700958252,
0.6273428797721863,
-0.36489105224609375,
0.13976427912712097,
1.1355921030044556,
0.463283509016037,
-0.6307325959205627,
-0.5793488621711731,
-0.7206300497055054,
-0.6758078336715698,
0.8361881971359253,
0.07285326719284058,
0.016813170164823532,
0.24926653504371643,
0.3347380757331848,
0.44053182005882263,
0.5755307674407959,
-0.22850850224494934,
-0.2158059924840927,
-0.3512337803840637,
-0.1973697394132614,
-0.08671964704990387,
0.06620413810014725,
-0.40276652574539185,
-0.20668825507164001,
0.601125180721283,
-0.3277287781238556,
0.10196393728256226,
0.4611029326915741,
-0.47294479608535767,
-0.07086807489395142,
0.27584823966026306,
0.3136172890663147,
0.8832955956459045,
-0.673765242099762,
0.10325457900762558,
-0.23376548290252686,
-0.7889803647994995,
0.01952754147350788,
0.8865291476249695,
-0.34321895241737366,
0.2219383418560028,
0.12966012954711914,
0.5626624822616577,
-0.0600188784301281,
-0.5337770581245422,
0.5437992811203003,
-0.5204228162765503,
-0.5057802200317383,
-0.48430803418159485,
0.08625868707895279,
0.40131092071533203,
-0.09725417196750641,
0.4260111451148987,
0.04284531623125076,
0.3439788818359375,
-0.34114935994148254,
-0.023366540670394897,
0.11560823768377304,
-0.6392973065376282,
0.04202789440751076,
1.1726595163345337,
0.18048520386219025,
-0.6026977300643921,
0.5651816129684448,
-0.1773359179496765,
-0.44342878460884094,
0.6571428775787354,
0.20252907276153564,
0.9470574259757996,
0.2589932084083557,
0.5586376786231995,
-0.011301567777991295,
0.45065245032310486,
0.14497806131839752,
0.16370873153209686,
-0.47645172476768494,
-0.23941366374492645,
0.315458208322525,
-0.6597461700439453,
-0.8994143605232239,
-0.099069744348526,
-0.5905332565307617,
0.060833126306533813,
-0.8142316341400146,
0.0000527905322087463,
0.3308390974998474,
0.21037285029888153,
-0.7368021607398987,
0.3871098458766937,
0.12209736555814743,
1.446381688117981,
-0.629148006439209,
0.748930037021637,
1.1746325492858887,
-0.819580078125,
-0.7150794863700867,
-0.19106055796146393,
0.006438364274799824,
-0.352071076631546,
0.42211857438087463,
0.6075032949447632,
-0.01667056418955326,
0.002166110323742032,
-0.44419214129447937,
0.17193806171417236,
1.357655644416809,
0.4045972526073456,
-0.14237792789936066,
-0.07282113283872604,
0.5278236865997314,
0.5383343696594238,
-0.2179924100637436,
0.243536114692688,
0.55867999792099,
0.6377151012420654,
-0.29775863885879517,
-0.5362187623977661,
0.032597485929727554,
-0.5230644941329956,
-0.26124805212020874,
0.12229807674884796,
-0.3404199481010437,
0.47294381260871887,
0.22979876399040222,
-0.04622410237789154,
-0.029481280595064163,
0.24980008602142334,
0.09421258419752121,
0.5208272337913513,
0.37101826071739197,
0.6016908288002014,
1.0818467140197754,
-0.08640768378973007,
1.3068158626556396,
-0.31879234313964844,
0.039953988045454025,
1.1414076089859009,
-0.22164286673069,
0.540820837020874,
0.4873437285423279,
0.020366953685879707,
0.305209755897522,
0.6747151613235474,
-0.12264170497655869,
0.17884723842144012,
-0.10315944999456406,
-0.09499746561050415,
-0.2089875042438507,
-0.03176909685134888,
-0.08237334340810776,
0.08635950088500977,
0.07489824295043945,
-0.24556061625480652,
-0.35622474551200867,
-0.017935406416654587,
0.1187119260430336,
0.253117173910141,
0.016309956088662148,
0.782995343208313,
0.1311570107936859,
-0.4685800075531006,
-0.0015349783934652805,
0.30424660444259644,
0.3990774154663086,
-0.9561923146247864,
0.14966602623462677,
-0.5594216585159302,
-0.0488215871155262,
-0.1549592912197113,
-0.6818131804466248,
-0.0020261649042367935,
-0.01708896830677986,
-0.2385932207107544,
-0.2527942359447479,
0.6859796047210693,
-0.177363321185112,
-0.328665554523468,
0.3079483211040497,
0.3231894075870514,
-0.07410624623298645,
-0.5452038049697876,
-0.6770510673522949,
-0.28500890731811523,
-0.5709322690963745,
-0.01741575263440609,
0.2668322026729584,
0.51740962266922,
-0.06886988878250122,
0.672387421131134,
0.7240020036697388,
-0.19590170681476593,
0.18884757161140442,
0.1617298722267151,
0.6176277995109558,
-0.1467878669500351,
-0.9486216902732849,
-0.4284260869026184,
0.5086946487426758,
-0.5109902620315552,
-0.5941405296325684,
0.6532545685768127,
0.9089210033416748,
0.47440409660339355,
-0.0793655663728714,
1.0247331857681274,
0.026118526235222816,
0.19077463448047638,
-0.03694998100399971,
1.007102608680725,
-0.6972730159759521,
-0.10502197593450546,
-0.1936226189136505,
-1.0334128141403198,
-0.2884911894798279,
0.1489359587430954,
-0.5221710205078125,
-0.29865512251853943,
0.57712322473526,
0.590249240398407,
-0.416963130235672,
0.3746894896030426,
0.07812961935997009,
-0.3990311622619629,
0.625630795955658,
-0.018544353544712067,
0.4295281171798706,
-0.46980220079421997,
0.645209789276123,
-0.4089299738407135,
0.12263470888137817,
-0.1927989274263382,
-0.5483503937721252,
-1.0055389404296875,
-0.6504828929901123,
-0.3329807221889496,
-0.017629969865083694,
-0.1094031035900116,
0.6179590225219727,
0.7052941918373108,
-0.5307056307792664,
0.05867217481136322,
-0.016742289066314697,
-0.0438288189470768,
-0.013955681584775448,
-0.2048400342464447,
0.6555942296981812,
-0.1407751590013504,
-0.7191925644874573,
0.1402253806591034,
0.655911922454834,
0.14598000049591064,
-0.17864498496055603,
-0.2792632281780243,
-0.40878361463546753,
0.17616909742355347,
0.16561156511306763,
0.5895053148269653,
-0.17073243856430054,
0.05458257347345352,
-0.027380675077438354,
-0.41269582509994507,
0.3543398976325989,
0.7476711869239807,
-0.21548281610012054,
0.8016300797462463,
0.2876048982143402,
1.0648667812347412,
0.5606439709663391,
0.15458296239376068,
0.6068001985549927,
-0.784442663192749,
0.163911372423172,
-0.046888258308172226,
0.4326632618904114,
0.9280081391334534,
-0.3316495716571808,
0.7939394116401672,
0.14123964309692383,
-0.24946029484272003,
-0.6647323369979858,
-0.16416732966899872,
-1.0836175680160522,
-0.27422666549682617,
0.7322998642921448,
-0.1554422229528427,
-0.33634644746780396,
-0.31929200887680054,
-0.6756104826927185,
0.3851023316383362,
-0.22785884141921997,
0.6509864926338196,
0.6882789731025696,
0.14143593609333038,
-0.3679547905921936,
-0.8434590101242065,
0.3205205500125885,
0.035462554544210434,
-1.124805212020874,
-0.03513319045305252,
0.24755539000034332,
0.3044903874397278,
0.3391573429107666,
1.0712335109710693,
-0.07827336341142654,
0.5279001593589783,
0.07965864986181259,
0.12454450875520706,
-0.7117055654525757,
-0.22424262762069702,
-0.3391304910182953,
0.4123057425022125,
0.18906213343143463,
-0.4694879651069641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00437v1
|
Automatic explanation of the classification of Spanish legal judgments in jurisdiction-dependent law categories with tree estimators
| 2024-03-30T17:59:43 | 2024-03-30T17:59:43 |
Jaime González-González, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Silvia García-Méndez, Andrea Busto-Castiñeira, Francisco J. González-Castaño
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Automatic legal text classification systems have been proposed in the
literature to address knowledge extraction from judgments and detect their
aspects. However, most of these systems are black boxes even when their models
are interpretable. This may raise concerns about their trustworthiness.
Accordingly, this work contributes with a system combining Natural Language
Processing (NLP) with Machine Learning (ML) to classify legal texts in an
explainable manner. We analyze the features involved in the decision and the
threshold bifurcation values of the decision paths of tree structures and
present this information to the users in natural language. This is the first
work on automatic analysis of legal texts combining NLP and ML along with
Explainable Artificial Intelligence techniques to automatically make the
models' decisions understandable to end users. Furthermore, legal experts have
validated our solution, and this knowledge has also been incorporated into the
explanation process as "expert-in-the-loop" dictionaries. Experimental results
on an annotated data set in law categories by jurisdiction demonstrate that our
system yields competitive classification performance, with accuracy values well
above 90%, and that its automatic explanations are easily understandable even
to non-expert users.
|
[
-0.35238420963287354,
-0.7673215270042419,
0.5483206510543823,
0.2623082101345062,
-0.49173668026924133,
0.17014744877815247,
-0.07303059846162796,
-0.701203465461731,
-0.000979508156888187,
0.6476447582244873,
-0.1594615876674652,
-0.4460575580596924,
-0.7163704037666321,
0.18652759492397308,
-0.5854822397232056,
1.1245938539505005,
-0.05338713526725769,
-0.038576558232307434,
-0.01415413897484541,
-0.2757795453071594,
-0.4787440001964569,
-0.47833120822906494,
-0.3383890986442566,
-0.36034560203552246,
0.31811797618865967,
0.12899859249591827,
0.8479272723197937,
0.7714409828186035,
0.4824843108654022,
0.4358755052089691,
-0.16615712642669678,
-0.21557115018367767,
0.05957487225532532,
-0.014085819944739342,
-0.5003219246864319,
-0.6970804333686829,
-0.3062969744205475,
-0.25495681166648865,
0.2784320116043091,
0.36563897132873535,
-0.3221440613269806,
0.015379649586975574,
-0.027424782514572144,
0.7486222386360168,
-0.3557828664779663,
0.4805022180080414,
-0.781712532043457,
0.498620867729187,
-0.04501897469162941,
-0.6459463238716125,
-0.48524391651153564,
-0.5207332372665405,
0.4044106602668762,
-0.38967958092689514,
0.3863092064857483,
0.31237122416496277,
0.9653146266937256,
0.6274609565734863,
-0.5058718323707581,
-0.7357332110404968,
-0.6185701489448547,
0.46139994263648987,
-0.3029530942440033,
0.29296308755874634,
0.27719295024871826,
0.6074159741401672,
-0.28802230954170227,
-0.44585856795310974,
-0.40955349802970886,
-0.3094329237937927,
-0.12046948820352554,
0.21932457387447357,
-0.6145792007446289,
0.1375485360622406,
-0.012550896033644676,
0.16353939473628998,
-0.6786207556724548,
0.36505624651908875,
-0.25266146659851074,
-0.3485322892665863,
0.6249591112136841,
-0.25294995307922363,
0.25568100810050964,
-0.37583646178245544,
-0.058421894907951355,
0.2161587029695511,
-0.3974734842777252,
0.24314598739147186,
0.3745802342891693,
0.10323824733495712,
0.06997721642255783,
0.6566072106361389,
0.08163988590240479,
0.5413377285003662,
0.23262114822864532,
-0.06403087079524994,
0.09742937982082367,
0.00412822887301445,
-0.595501720905304,
0.43303996324539185,
1.0028213262557983,
0.2053501307964325,
0.28549206256866455,
-0.26163947582244873,
-0.27644670009613037,
-0.012451639398932457,
0.24316240847110748,
-0.349568247795105,
-0.07930997014045715,
0.2856591045856476,
-0.5702864527702332,
-0.5174688100814819,
0.3309142291545868,
-0.6907145977020264,
-0.3977292478084564,
-0.4425016939640045,
0.14654584228992462,
-0.13107119500637054,
-0.12663432955741882,
0.32775500416755676,
-0.04459664598107338,
-0.1535293012857437,
0.4310503602027893,
-0.6157390475273132,
0.4216746985912323,
0.3969254493713379,
0.4617603123188019,
-0.026555219665169716,
0.1453377604484558,
-0.4232485294342041,
-0.018560513854026794,
-0.1394762545824051,
0.6442430019378662,
-0.40174540877342224,
-0.053512923419475555,
0.013656621798872948,
0.2673359513282776,
0.12169419229030609,
-0.49690067768096924,
0.6682056784629822,
-0.7504021525382996,
0.37807509303092957,
0.19074958562850952,
-0.4280886650085449,
-0.6230950951576233,
0.06589462608098984,
-0.6093694567680359,
0.7501847743988037,
-0.09450752288103104,
-0.8335937261581421,
0.872413694858551,
-0.8382017612457275,
-0.46127045154571533,
0.455131858587265,
-0.09070209413766861,
-0.5401761531829834,
0.041115351021289825,
0.1961260288953781,
0.470219224691391,
-0.22834868729114532,
0.7826383113861084,
-0.1576770395040512,
0.1891980767250061,
0.24333564937114716,
-0.5269572138786316,
1.3349699974060059,
0.4594212472438812,
-0.5581374764442444,
0.2389219105243683,
-0.4926179349422455,
-0.2347240000963211,
0.03608888387680054,
-0.43087995052337646,
-0.26236602663993835,
0.2646576464176178,
-0.11830967664718628,
0.3141663670539856,
0.12924827635288239,
-0.30950602889060974,
-0.10574021935462952,
-0.43007728457450867,
0.21902477741241455,
0.5070311427116394,
0.11745692044496536,
0.24453936517238617,
-0.11575265973806381,
0.7928112745285034,
0.12547115981578827,
0.12565670907497406,
0.1938190907239914,
-0.6447880864143372,
-0.575312077999115,
0.09694723039865494,
0.46074187755584717,
0.739962637424469,
-0.5223260521888733,
0.8074279427528381,
-0.25833794474601746,
-0.1106378585100174,
-0.30445238947868347,
-0.03975779563188553,
0.27638450264930725,
0.44974836707115173,
0.40650463104248047,
-0.15373626351356506,
-0.6479467749595642,
-0.8299316167831421,
-0.25277355313301086,
-0.5573634505271912,
0.029470376670360565,
0.17707151174545288,
0.9419240951538086,
-0.1254609227180481,
1.1981701850891113,
0.033914655447006226,
-0.14896203577518463,
-0.10305511206388474,
0.4514719843864441,
0.16383928060531616,
0.13072241842746735,
0.4877949059009552,
-1.063814401626587,
-0.45694148540496826,
0.5243189334869385,
-0.7897638082504272,
-0.3316783607006073,
-0.17279165983200073,
0.04191730543971062,
0.16060097515583038,
0.27179545164108276,
-0.0996965616941452,
0.4853791296482086,
-0.03555621579289436,
-0.7362952828407288,
0.6230345368385315,
-0.5100867748260498,
0.05100087821483612,
-0.47586798667907715,
-0.23477703332901,
0.3300168216228485,
-0.5825027823448181,
-0.4538433849811554,
0.05166249722242355,
0.03356827795505524,
0.5746086835861206,
-0.3563827574253082,
0.18304027616977692,
-0.3175716698169708,
-0.1989334672689438,
-0.20474447309970856,
-0.02088823914527893,
-0.06012459844350815,
0.4735407531261444,
0.15571089088916779,
0.13292990624904633,
0.46780332922935486,
-0.6105236411094666,
0.3416317105293274,
0.029800623655319214,
-0.22597424685955048,
0.6406251192092896,
-0.34405091404914856,
-0.2563263177871704,
-0.2891256511211395,
0.0074251024052500725,
-0.4385823905467987,
-0.2069886177778244,
0.45298436284065247,
-0.29341891407966614,
0.023355761542916298,
-0.6522486209869385,
-0.5383136868476868,
-0.5737534761428833,
0.08142279088497162,
-0.10931328684091568,
0.28074911236763,
-0.5318196415901184,
0.4895472526550293,
0.7736799716949463,
-0.012431083247065544,
-0.6871516108512878,
-0.6484753489494324,
0.3163893222808838,
-0.610909640789032,
-0.1746034473180771,
0.1812019944190979,
0.22091567516326904,
-0.47976696491241455,
0.4707440435886383,
0.026654476299881935,
-0.4459105134010315,
0.3556470274925232,
0.46764320135116577,
0.11967967450618744,
-0.23142676055431366,
0.273397296667099,
0.5604548454284668,
0.09795576333999634,
0.5447192192077637,
-0.41765159368515015,
0.09538175910711288,
-0.38422074913978577,
-0.27402883768081665,
-0.6472969055175781,
-0.06250707805156708,
0.6945276856422424,
-0.27598437666893005,
0.44191277027130127,
-0.07454775273799896,
-0.45789602398872375,
-0.2529914677143097,
-0.34702256321907043,
0.43060213327407837,
-0.3773818612098694,
0.10625987499952316,
-0.5171921253204346,
-0.6926276087760925,
0.5250973105430603,
0.13280075788497925,
0.1295444518327713,
0.9771124124526978,
0.88669753074646,
-0.025744356215000153,
1.0087641477584839,
0.6014928817749023,
-0.16836996376514435,
0.35518062114715576,
-0.06811033934354782,
0.07149703800678253,
0.05876365676522255,
-0.48107999563217163,
-0.9315000176429749,
0.04683836176991463,
-0.6268432140350342,
-0.23813705146312714,
0.08888375014066696,
0.07883848249912262,
-0.05504076927900314,
0.4485448896884918,
-0.6284289956092834,
0.7733455300331116,
0.3406411111354828,
-0.12484858185052872,
0.6206450462341309,
0.09792283177375793,
-0.44615358114242554,
0.23562407493591309,
-0.7351091504096985,
-0.7877563238143921,
0.9112270474433899,
0.6495611667633057,
0.38475853204727173,
0.1563255935907364,
0.7435894012451172,
0.5987796783447266,
0.38580501079559326,
-1.0319925546646118,
0.23401623964309692,
-0.22837229073047638,
-0.6143373847007751,
-0.3064868748188019,
-0.47415944933891296,
-1.092703938484192,
0.40875160694122314,
-0.40722906589508057,
-0.6354926824569702,
0.49657413363456726,
-0.06432239711284637,
-0.388311505317688,
0.11647440493106842,
-0.5204824209213257,
0.7212803363800049,
-0.44048818945884705,
-0.15678858757019043,
-0.17884865403175354,
-0.5653314590454102,
0.39680176973342896,
-0.1798461377620697,
0.527552604675293,
0.10793149471282959,
0.20391486585140228,
0.9440863728523254,
-0.6679143905639648,
0.48278090357780457,
-0.3487538695335388,
-0.05831138789653778,
0.4891055226325989,
0.24118512868881226,
0.22328054904937744,
-0.12435042858123779,
-0.1671696901321411,
-0.16975659132003784,
0.30691879987716675,
0.12227428704500198,
-0.6735603213310242,
0.18484438955783844,
-0.5162502527236938,
-0.23506340384483337,
-0.5558009743690491,
-0.407866895198822,
0.13980279862880707,
0.18347817659378052,
0.005937329493463039,
0.1418711543083191,
0.007486653979867697,
0.3335821330547333,
0.3411142826080322,
-0.036732759326696396,
0.33798542618751526,
0.7272198796272278,
-0.29324257373809814,
-0.05706514045596123,
0.7633131742477417,
0.34438374638557434,
-0.47619736194610596,
0.31326761841773987,
0.5041255950927734,
-0.7008207440376282,
-0.9509395360946655,
-0.4839325249195099,
-0.0750848576426506,
-0.6720620393753052,
-0.1341969221830368,
-0.5572664141654968,
-0.0935635045170784,
0.16870622336864471,
-0.025601573288440704,
0.21780656278133392,
-0.47593656182289124,
-0.0834038034081459,
-0.29941248893737793,
0.11895059049129486,
0.9587968587875366,
0.2816457450389862,
0.19525425136089325,
-0.5491435527801514,
0.36746084690093994,
0.12187812477350235,
0.40213724970817566,
-0.2751977741718292,
-0.6488764882087708,
-0.23210541903972626,
-0.24156615138053894,
-0.057401884347200394,
-1.067017912864685,
0.472513884305954,
-0.032233916223049164,
0.5719078183174133,
0.6260733604431152,
-0.026606349274516106,
0.5268968343734741,
-0.32676494121551514,
0.19251693785190582,
0.18132027983665466,
-0.8736329078674316,
0.6697294116020203,
-0.12241025269031525,
-0.2539346516132355,
0.6370984315872192,
0.36885562539100647,
-0.1835675686597824,
-0.9496645927429199,
-0.6090880632400513,
-0.451565146446228,
0.7565509676933289,
0.22133919596672058,
-0.3426970839500427,
0.19569042325019836,
0.38408470153808594,
0.4099138379096985,
0.1061929315328598,
-0.8946436047554016,
0.019285233691334724,
-0.26971080899238586,
-0.5328319072723389,
0.26361432671546936,
-0.06070064380764961,
-0.09527529776096344,
-0.4126255214214325,
0.6021264791488647,
-0.06506039947271347,
-0.10980616509914398,
0.11903544515371323,
-0.6507851481437683,
-0.23010316491127014,
0.41311609745025635,
0.3322436809539795,
0.8154981136322021,
-0.2128407508134842,
0.30322781205177307,
-0.047394316643476486,
-0.3636493682861328,
0.24233558773994446,
0.11755521595478058,
-0.17300760746002197,
0.17419923841953278,
0.34180620312690735,
0.6754340529441833,
-0.13306424021720886,
-0.4522501528263092,
0.32083848118782043,
-0.2550196051597595,
-0.5409755706787109,
-0.2735404074192047,
0.06401289254426956,
-0.1802641600370407,
0.2571421265602112,
0.3799571990966797,
0.1930021494626999,
0.5123658180236816,
-0.4989665448665619,
0.2657908499240875,
0.358018696308136,
-0.36526229977607727,
-0.005251995287835598,
0.7368561029434204,
0.1662943810224533,
-0.3714124858379364,
-0.09575905650854111,
-0.4020131826400757,
-0.7114764451980591,
0.9171307682991028,
0.31695184111595154,
0.8182328939437866,
0.17094863951206207,
0.4848696291446686,
0.15142637491226196,
0.37675392627716064,
-0.32703500986099243,
-0.08919277042150497,
-0.26131677627563477,
-0.6685411930084229,
-0.3315412402153015,
-0.632824718952179,
-0.5399746894836426,
-0.008678516373038292,
-0.7167636156082153,
-0.046568259596824646,
-0.5192931890487671,
-0.08418583124876022,
0.3107663691043854,
0.022884076461195946,
-0.622448205947876,
0.28590595722198486,
-0.12518899142742157,
0.7008717060089111,
-0.9233532547950745,
0.8037512302398682,
0.4388468265533447,
-0.4063023030757904,
-0.505391538143158,
0.023160409182310104,
0.05630979314446449,
-0.5724800229072571,
0.7215200066566467,
0.038784269243478775,
-0.3242326080799103,
-0.24850939214229584,
-0.31331509351730347,
-0.09716633707284927,
0.6175833344459534,
0.31415146589279175,
-0.7781944870948792,
0.16909320652484894,
0.30902883410453796,
0.9719482064247131,
-0.34076887369155884,
0.27255481481552124,
0.7897651791572571,
0.6447770595550537,
-0.04285665601491928,
-0.8827807307243347,
-0.06762246787548065,
-0.323262095451355,
-0.4194749891757965,
0.10624589771032333,
0.2562735974788666,
0.2245316058397293,
0.1305381804704666,
-0.31261885166168213,
-0.41049274802207947,
0.41446560621261597,
-0.1672598421573639,
0.5393210649490356,
0.7845403552055359,
0.4271901249885559,
1.1583325862884521,
-0.3195168673992157,
1.0277751684188843,
-0.4004851281642914,
0.5877163410186768,
1.059644103050232,
0.10319492965936661,
0.5780235528945923,
0.4387802481651306,
-0.36021488904953003,
0.7732121348381042,
0.7295352816581726,
-0.2570943534374237,
0.07409664988517761,
0.19777171313762665,
0.03671202436089516,
-0.0687243863940239,
-0.0729718804359436,
0.17069274187088013,
0.542670488357544,
0.2569896876811981,
-0.646957278251648,
-0.19244572520256042,
0.08482155203819275,
-0.24048462510108948,
0.1324518620967865,
-0.4900466203689575,
0.7775712013244629,
-0.22362679243087769,
-0.7547292113304138,
0.2471095770597458,
0.27974390983581543,
0.39230138063430786,
-0.1779700666666031,
0.06314650177955627,
0.12972263991832733,
-0.09308494627475739,
-0.6036199927330017,
-1.2613805532455444,
0.4523099362850189,
0.5836645364761353,
-0.17644083499908447,
-0.5183624625205994,
0.4550667703151703,
-0.2967612147331238,
-0.6227135062217712,
0.3866893947124481,
0.4622868299484253,
0.5155762434005737,
-0.09342765808105469,
-1.156272530555725,
-0.412630558013916,
-0.13710401952266693,
-0.09656877815723419,
-0.11022922396659851,
0.7450764775276184,
-0.5599713921546936,
0.7532276511192322,
0.38029658794403076,
0.06676732748746872,
0.1852494329214096,
0.24148589372634888,
0.5212810039520264,
-0.536834716796875,
-0.6531203389167786,
-0.9496580958366394,
0.6032750606536865,
0.007932129316031933,
-0.025845687836408615,
0.4953741431236267,
0.6164485812187195,
0.3919312059879303,
0.16093800961971283,
0.7174073457717896,
-0.2135392725467682,
0.3204675316810608,
-0.5833925008773804,
0.7281759977340698,
-0.40588846802711487,
0.3678818345069885,
0.01870037242770195,
-0.7285215854644775,
-0.5579671263694763,
0.609315812587738,
-0.3054249882698059,
-0.2117452323436737,
0.7586349248886108,
0.4594414234161377,
-0.1744074672460556,
-0.028525931760668755,
0.10804574191570282,
0.2701171040534973,
0.26555919647216797,
0.3573993444442749,
0.6068369746208191,
0.012997260317206383,
0.6353088021278381,
-0.27177754044532776,
-0.2504926323890686,
-0.3875575661659241,
-0.7917332649230957,
-0.7806846499443054,
-0.43137115240097046,
-0.3385818302631378,
-0.22491614520549774,
-0.08032051473855972,
0.6661537885665894,
0.4360547661781311,
-1.055004358291626,
-0.3703858256340027,
-0.5567486882209778,
0.6926957964897156,
0.033175695687532425,
-0.28368547558784485,
0.42984941601753235,
-0.300762414932251,
-0.5118720531463623,
0.25321605801582336,
0.39496541023254395,
-0.012145696207880974,
-0.18343231081962585,
-0.27533411979675293,
-0.06900724023580551,
-0.10735730826854706,
0.5150583386421204,
0.4410637617111206,
-0.9380003809928894,
-0.22211171686649323,
-0.5695767402648926,
0.013548516668379307,
0.35975882411003113,
0.724133312702179,
-0.6521321535110474,
0.8169445395469666,
0.4550829827785492,
0.417651891708374,
0.4324703812599182,
0.06211201846599579,
0.39386290311813354,
-0.1334340125322342,
0.008212356828153133,
0.3322363495826721,
0.6004361510276794,
-0.17998340725898743,
-0.21869823336601257,
0.5298835039138794,
0.07940425723791122,
-0.3968101441860199,
-0.7551324367523193,
-0.11438167095184326,
-0.9469965696334839,
-0.4047068953514099,
0.551805317401886,
-0.23648418486118317,
-0.3339175283908844,
-0.7826427221298218,
-0.24433845281600952,
0.42816922068595886,
-0.20338425040245056,
0.9662975072860718,
0.7475487589836121,
-0.06997863203287125,
-0.1181984469294548,
-0.7261189222335815,
0.4410354495048523,
0.034623101353645325,
-1.0417957305908203,
-0.1807333379983902,
0.5696682929992676,
0.30822455883026123,
0.16934247314929962,
0.22536055743694305,
-0.3479735553264618,
0.3643271327018738,
-0.31866922974586487,
0.01867278851568699,
-0.033824365586042404,
-0.4001387655735016,
-0.7504096031188965,
0.46694520115852356,
-0.05315762013196945,
0.07476702332496643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01338v1
|
Automatic detection of relevant information, predictions and forecasts in financial news through topic modelling with Latent Dirichlet Allocation
| 2024-03-30T17:49:34 | 2024-03-30T17:49:34 |
Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Ana Barros-Vila, Francisco J. González-Castaño, Enrique Costa-Montenegro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.IR, cs.LG, q-fin.ST
|
Financial news items are unstructured sources of information that can be
mined to extract knowledge for market screening applications. Manual extraction
of relevant information from the continuous stream of finance-related news is
cumbersome and beyond the skills of many investors, who, at most, can follow a
few sources and authors. Accordingly, we focus on the analysis of financial
news to identify relevant text and, within that text, forecasts and
predictions. We propose a novel Natural Language Processing (NLP) system to
assist investors in the detection of relevant financial events in unstructured
textual sources by considering both relevance and temporality at the discursive
level. Firstly, we segment the text to group together closely related text.
Secondly, we apply co-reference resolution to discover internal dependencies
within segments. Finally, we perform relevant topic modelling with Latent
Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) to separate relevant from less relevant text and
then analyse the relevant text using a Machine Learning-oriented temporal
approach to identify predictions and speculative statements. We created an
experimental data set composed of 2,158 financial news items that were manually
labelled by NLP researchers to evaluate our solution. The ROUGE-L values for
the identification of relevant text and predictions/forecasts were 0.662 and
0.982, respectively. To our knowledge, this is the first work to jointly
consider relevance and temporality at the discursive level. It contributes to
the transfer of human associative discourse capabilities to expert systems
through the combination of multi-paragraph topic segmentation and co-reference
resolution to separate author expression patterns, topic modelling with LDA to
detect relevant text, and discursive temporality analysis to identify forecasts
and predictions within this text.
|
[
-0.1787726879119873,
-0.9493228197097778,
0.37114614248275757,
0.34208229184150696,
-0.5015473961830139,
0.39409059286117554,
0.10207758843898773,
-0.632135808467865,
0.4113181233406067,
0.48653140664100647,
-0.5364795923233032,
-0.416353315114975,
-0.39055657386779785,
-0.26708561182022095,
-0.7436765432357788,
1.1383326053619385,
0.09129899740219116,
-0.10299650579690933,
-0.03403053805232048,
0.17777667939662933,
-0.3591179847717285,
-0.5233125686645508,
-0.8928304314613342,
-0.13167373836040497,
0.22103740274906158,
0.07058347761631012,
0.4992136061191559,
0.4896855056285858,
0.6963656544685364,
0.3116872310638428,
-0.17385491728782654,
0.0041641537100076675,
0.0010342559544369578,
-0.029562264680862427,
-0.2710135579109192,
-0.27220219373703003,
-0.42003703117370605,
0.11454462260007858,
0.4907086193561554,
0.6067166328430176,
-0.2143271565437317,
0.004362241830676794,
0.09918265789747238,
0.5867063999176025,
-0.26595577597618103,
0.42900389432907104,
-0.738423228263855,
0.14825743436813354,
-0.38456442952156067,
-0.6829728484153748,
-0.3618730902671814,
-0.10398053377866745,
0.5065919756889343,
-0.5534688234329224,
0.341915488243103,
0.06615913659334183,
0.9417551159858704,
0.32642874121665955,
-0.34435707330703735,
-0.5253915786743164,
-0.6548423171043396,
0.727003812789917,
-0.6409426331520081,
0.2243354469537735,
0.36765679717063904,
0.2064839005470276,
-0.018935849890112877,
-0.46775829792022705,
-0.36165162920951843,
0.022618945688009262,
-0.2596454620361328,
-0.030716340988874435,
-0.33163854479789734,
-0.20763419568538666,
-0.0604831762611866,
0.15104012191295624,
-0.6053464412689209,
0.16022397577762604,
-0.25908634066581726,
-0.36256977915763855,
0.45151183009147644,
-0.08160807192325592,
0.12764602899551392,
-0.3380392789840698,
-0.39257317781448364,
0.13881435990333557,
-0.3083794414997101,
-0.08789205551147461,
0.5778114199638367,
0.4009634256362915,
-0.2348385453224182,
0.2783206105232239,
-0.09071248024702072,
0.5789306163787842,
0.29077261686325073,
-0.32747435569763184,
0.1153181940317154,
-0.33362945914268494,
0.08299516886472702,
0.5049425959587097,
0.3743840157985687,
0.3607172966003418,
-0.06974905729293823,
-0.14335881173610687,
-0.2500722408294678,
-0.0033948274794965982,
0.14296789467334747,
-0.5533990263938904,
-0.2231730818748474,
0.2726089060306549,
-0.5064539313316345,
-0.4068599045276642,
0.1548420637845993,
-1.0277254581451416,
-0.16151489317417145,
-0.39673709869384766,
0.11683385074138641,
-0.18980616331100464,
-0.08842401951551437,
0.10867896676063538,
-0.30857083201408386,
0.11094528436660767,
0.32224512100219727,
-0.9109912514686584,
0.2123183161020279,
0.8157409429550171,
0.7297564744949341,
-0.17283564805984497,
0.06266836076974869,
-0.737190306186676,
0.5069261789321899,
-0.21994484961032867,
1.1377559900283813,
-0.5151656270027161,
-0.018154829740524292,
-0.10474825650453568,
-0.2523435652256012,
-0.04043653607368469,
-0.2906000316143036,
0.4239738881587982,
-0.862849771976471,
0.3664383590221405,
0.16903941333293915,
-0.6058275699615479,
-0.07476183027029037,
-0.06278201937675476,
-0.8412012457847595,
0.7484269142150879,
-0.15633432567119598,
-1.1281065940856934,
0.6711251139640808,
-0.8623864054679871,
-0.4926704168319702,
0.0443701446056366,
-0.12140683829784393,
-0.4679202139377594,
-0.3531484007835388,
0.5780465006828308,
0.504366934299469,
-0.3269902169704437,
0.7780559062957764,
-0.17491790652275085,
-0.09102753549814224,
0.43623706698417664,
-0.5302454829216003,
0.2025783360004425,
0.1198575347661972,
-0.26115480065345764,
0.2801281809806824,
-0.7137709856033325,
-0.5188656449317932,
0.050023630261421204,
0.14004461467266083,
-0.6286013722419739,
0.32661569118499756,
0.22199562191963196,
0.17549331486225128,
0.4385664761066437,
-0.2576409578323364,
0.01770803891122341,
-0.6074661612510681,
0.5066601037979126,
0.9606493711471558,
0.35538774728775024,
0.6273941993713379,
-0.22639232873916626,
0.41273555159568787,
0.3085852861404419,
0.0003714369668159634,
-0.3357517123222351,
-0.3219349980354309,
-0.4362686574459076,
-0.12934038043022156,
0.3413793742656708,
0.6715714335441589,
-0.5846601724624634,
0.5137787461280823,
0.18345791101455688,
-0.2176370918750763,
-0.08873556554317474,
-0.0902550220489502,
-0.1774957925081253,
0.48950985074043274,
0.1019742414355278,
-0.09025933593511581,
-0.6889362931251526,
-0.8777783513069153,
-0.18979492783546448,
-0.2784895598888397,
-0.0242867823690176,
-0.012315219268202782,
0.33263182640075684,
-0.05764613673090935,
1.196993350982666,
-0.8395283222198486,
-0.37169721722602844,
-0.08736114948987961,
0.5752120018005371,
0.5267237424850464,
0.2846710681915283,
0.8119215369224548,
-1.280964732170105,
-0.23725423216819763,
0.17183515429496765,
-0.5473582148551941,
0.015476735308766365,
-0.5780863165855408,
0.0526127964258194,
0.3520340025424957,
0.6393358707427979,
-0.2745603919029236,
0.4862991273403168,
0.22198458015918732,
-0.5931791663169861,
0.19574210047721863,
-0.21199023723602295,
-0.14690721035003662,
-1.2149711847305298,
0.08482951670885086,
0.47696566581726074,
-0.3056356608867645,
-0.3373524844646454,
-0.5264778137207031,
-0.4084590971469879,
-0.11917353421449661,
0.02390209585428238,
0.8977808356285095,
-0.08877334743738174,
-0.26168233156204224,
-0.4568673372268677,
0.3769058883190155,
-0.12229688465595245,
0.45968157052993774,
0.2529352009296417,
0.6766793727874756,
0.4091339409351349,
-0.5013360977172852,
0.15128907561302185,
-0.02505619451403618,
-0.3960523009300232,
0.2615588903427124,
-0.4587617516517639,
-0.21504580974578857,
0.05565701425075531,
0.13495533168315887,
-0.9436375498771667,
0.06722553819417953,
0.4444030821323395,
-0.3195613920688629,
0.11351891607046127,
0.04655861482024193,
-0.5670791268348694,
-0.2131890058517456,
-0.08692675083875656,
0.06973761320114136,
0.044109560549259186,
-0.2707499563694,
0.5533442497253418,
0.6099230051040649,
-0.8390213847160339,
-0.5339036583900452,
-0.20599882304668427,
0.06425133347511292,
-0.29929256439208984,
-0.4156617820262909,
0.5007711052894592,
0.09280121326446533,
-0.3886150121688843,
0.3069543242454529,
-0.3211231827735901,
-0.26565513014793396,
0.3195106089115143,
0.1397988498210907,
0.7552186846733093,
-0.04095249995589256,
0.1820283979177475,
0.19345758855342865,
-0.4868439733982086,
-0.05177461728453636,
-0.4669707715511322,
0.4299910068511963,
-0.0766313448548317,
-0.10908448696136475,
-0.6002395749092102,
0.4301651120185852,
0.11451960355043411,
-0.2845489978790283,
0.7470571398735046,
0.6023489236831665,
-0.5744926929473877,
-0.017313307151198387,
-0.44563019275665283,
-0.22567033767700195,
-0.4641902446746826,
0.29185813665390015,
-0.01854013465344906,
-0.8477013111114502,
0.7128139734268188,
0.14914461970329285,
0.0778130292892456,
1.0750665664672852,
0.4749220907688141,
-0.03881269693374634,
0.8299329876899719,
0.8338592648506165,
-0.3925601541996002,
0.7422611117362976,
-0.20916101336479187,
0.4499932527542114,
-0.12914332747459412,
-0.11129704862833023,
-0.5098451375961304,
-0.2288210093975067,
-0.43469247221946716,
-0.2758490741252899,
-0.10619065910577774,
0.11076609790325165,
0.16054975986480713,
0.3115993142127991,
-0.4323398172855377,
0.31341353058815,
0.4321351945400238,
-0.18520087003707886,
0.496573269367218,
0.017754938453435898,
-0.14077912271022797,
-0.14455151557922363,
-0.31447505950927734,
-0.6441137194633484,
0.935071587562561,
0.520648717880249,
0.691940188407898,
-0.3133750259876251,
0.38732293248176575,
0.8518242835998535,
0.42814186215400696,
-0.4919659495353699,
0.3437805473804474,
-0.31956496834754944,
-0.4056059420108795,
-0.33273565769195557,
-0.5746701955795288,
-0.5147404670715332,
-0.14563849568367004,
-0.05486806854605675,
-0.8254196643829346,
0.4229886531829834,
-0.3434520363807678,
-0.6810712814331055,
0.32710880041122437,
-0.39556437730789185,
0.7142724394798279,
-0.11151781678199768,
0.025534505024552345,
-0.38213297724723816,
-0.4146440625190735,
0.013037499971687794,
-0.5287089943885803,
0.30315548181533813,
-0.34516653418540955,
-0.05677172169089317,
1.126343846321106,
-0.09463171660900116,
0.8892982602119446,
-0.03636246174573898,
-0.5252134799957275,
0.298700213432312,
-0.390595018863678,
0.4025869369506836,
0.589573860168457,
-0.12383311241865158,
0.10990350693464279,
0.1788998544216156,
-0.3099183738231659,
-0.4996105432510376,
0.5014721751213074,
-0.5981539487838745,
-0.53230220079422,
-0.7745321989059448,
-0.6509478688240051,
0.06613912433385849,
0.03778056800365448,
-0.06249605864286423,
0.28138089179992676,
-0.1952323019504547,
0.01515897549688816,
0.20759548246860504,
0.02495856210589409,
0.6956287026405334,
0.7730216979980469,
-0.18842855095863342,
-0.3389054238796234,
0.9530885219573975,
0.0044747451320290565,
-0.40181756019592285,
0.8273837566375732,
0.11782771348953247,
-0.3474748730659485,
-0.6272974610328674,
-0.11751697212457657,
-0.025281762704253197,
-0.5313810706138611,
-0.2376200258731842,
-0.6951577067375183,
-0.3113892376422882,
-0.40170034766197205,
-0.35100629925727844,
-0.3137340545654297,
-0.4347330331802368,
-0.6989939212799072,
-0.1632629930973053,
0.36968907713890076,
0.5072787404060364,
-0.22076071798801422,
0.16797447204589844,
-0.9216132164001465,
0.49570590257644653,
0.2714773714542389,
0.17510433495044708,
-0.06669305264949799,
-0.4294787049293518,
-0.44567397236824036,
0.011151300743222237,
-0.3859386146068573,
-0.6081861853599548,
0.7736789584159851,
0.0817916989326477,
0.5400598645210266,
0.7416684627532959,
0.14051666855812073,
0.3436027765274048,
-0.14891286194324493,
0.3916066288948059,
0.09896787256002426,
-0.7785810828208923,
0.8047606348991394,
-0.4786115288734436,
-0.04939385503530502,
0.3323618471622467,
0.347092866897583,
-0.6015998125076294,
-0.593709409236908,
-0.5394238233566284,
-0.9113208055496216,
0.829848051071167,
0.13646888732910156,
-0.17834363877773285,
-0.10131015628576279,
0.6115968823432922,
0.3438497483730316,
0.44825610518455505,
-0.6550108790397644,
-0.1969672441482544,
0.06745899468660355,
-0.06845036894083023,
-0.030847955495119095,
-0.32374224066734314,
0.1005312129855156,
-0.0403999462723732,
0.6930319666862488,
-0.2577817440032959,
0.2401457130908966,
0.024695616215467453,
0.22800537943840027,
-0.3318553864955902,
0.18716008961200714,
0.24329042434692383,
0.9747448563575745,
-0.530525803565979,
-0.3820698857307434,
-0.18147465586662292,
-0.289268434047699,
-0.003874563379213214,
0.8432786464691162,
-0.18998505175113678,
0.19421617686748505,
0.5068352818489075,
0.5203948020935059,
0.530812680721283,
-0.7352001070976257,
0.3365766704082489,
-0.22032558917999268,
0.020433682948350906,
-0.6002151966094971,
-0.24216684699058533,
-0.07002339512109756,
0.6502653360366821,
0.9769269227981567,
0.26065754890441895,
0.20570878684520721,
-0.7683488130569458,
0.7804188132286072,
0.14115941524505615,
-0.40073463320732117,
-0.33861517906188965,
0.8365654945373535,
0.27603796124458313,
0.021953869611024857,
0.6104979515075684,
-0.27736857533454895,
-0.510397732257843,
0.8110926151275635,
0.3261604905128479,
1.0453683137893677,
-0.06611721217632294,
0.5830026865005493,
0.00016641488764435053,
-0.08451671153306961,
-0.02555381879210472,
0.30727848410606384,
0.1623224914073944,
-0.8173301219940186,
-0.7140816450119019,
-0.8119199275970459,
-0.3439057469367981,
0.0524909570813179,
-0.6707772612571716,
0.2123386114835739,
-0.26416653394699097,
-0.26608553528785706,
0.6914486289024353,
0.3465317189693451,
-0.4122411012649536,
-0.05040779709815979,
0.22333618998527527,
0.7508257031440735,
-0.8483403325080872,
0.7631691098213196,
0.47560280561447144,
-0.25001177191734314,
-0.21976158022880554,
0.30378344655036926,
-0.06376725435256958,
-0.2980636656284332,
0.9373950362205505,
0.21061855554580688,
0.3956237733364105,
-0.2461049109697342,
-0.07229524105787277,
-0.579150915145874,
0.9121383428573608,
0.42778539657592773,
-0.6303120851516724,
-0.514447808265686,
-0.11441468447446823,
0.38316890597343445,
-0.4227316081523895,
-0.2712639272212982,
0.36101779341697693,
0.46331867575645447,
0.4799765944480896,
-0.8240424990653992,
-0.36879876255989075,
-0.30901575088500977,
-0.4004088342189789,
0.5358726978302002,
-0.47661614418029785,
0.8087456822395325,
-0.13133268058300018,
-0.1562267243862152,
0.08862167596817017,
0.9638839364051819,
0.03330322727560997,
0.823895275592804,
0.4478578567504883,
0.3751578629016876,
0.7338932752609253,
-0.0970473513007164,
0.9669913649559021,
-0.5598521828651428,
0.4475153982639313,
1.0101183652877808,
-0.38425207138061523,
0.8720459938049316,
0.3980903625488281,
-0.11443907767534256,
0.4286215007305145,
0.7911374568939209,
-0.08484558016061783,
0.7976111173629761,
0.05994699150323868,
-0.2019915133714676,
-0.24230122566223145,
-0.422666072845459,
-0.21597975492477417,
0.5319840312004089,
0.4923761785030365,
-0.3470000922679901,
-0.3119809031486511,
0.040577057749032974,
-0.32356104254722595,
0.07013265043497086,
-0.2489410638809204,
0.7668142914772034,
0.23189055919647217,
-0.44302013516426086,
-0.40001562237739563,
0.3005848824977875,
0.6445791721343994,
-0.7415117025375366,
-0.08457881957292557,
-0.017145482823252678,
0.1887069195508957,
0.1673153042793274,
-0.6907712817192078,
0.6663370132446289,
-0.04118693992495537,
-0.2802360951900482,
-0.40314775705337524,
1.002764344215393,
-0.30916884541511536,
-0.7124451994895935,
0.382132351398468,
0.4294130504131317,
-0.3124763071537018,
-0.3340766727924347,
-0.6361443400382996,
-0.41660553216934204,
-0.02776183746755123,
-0.11650722473859787,
0.25221022963523865,
0.6225847005844116,
0.014679497107863426,
0.6383675932884216,
0.8419718146324158,
-0.09050652384757996,
-0.5093992948532104,
-0.02884761430323124,
0.9524931311607361,
-0.8657812476158142,
-1.030112862586975,
-0.7986505031585693,
-0.06352300196886063,
-0.08368881046772003,
-0.13648919761180878,
0.6189883351325989,
0.7675135135650635,
0.4420603811740875,
0.2138366848230362,
0.4511817693710327,
0.367776095867157,
0.5471085906028748,
-0.7029163837432861,
0.6630774140357971,
-0.3375209867954254,
0.6513974666595459,
-0.4615696966648102,
-0.665976345539093,
-0.2281699925661087,
0.5158987045288086,
-0.7492666840553284,
-0.2903852164745331,
0.4170317053794861,
0.29668933153152466,
0.14948438107967377,
0.4503191113471985,
-0.001720910076983273,
-0.022213131189346313,
0.1987811177968979,
0.21200022101402283,
0.617546021938324,
-0.16420552134513855,
0.4269874691963196,
-0.3963785767555237,
0.08696579933166504,
-0.5453048944473267,
-0.9062449336051941,
-0.8512685894966125,
-0.8707942962646484,
-0.6200748085975647,
0.19592739641666412,
0.11636053025722504,
0.6833006739616394,
0.3830125331878662,
-0.8054068088531494,
-0.22219602763652802,
0.07469739019870758,
0.3592563569545746,
-0.2790912985801697,
-0.35143452882766724,
0.8004762530326843,
-0.1852806806564331,
-0.4869178235530853,
0.23397815227508545,
0.7783790826797485,
0.151017427444458,
-0.3237055838108063,
0.2782021760940552,
-0.448907732963562,
0.02941444329917431,
0.5339878797531128,
0.010797805152833462,
-0.33801308274269104,
-0.24010266363620758,
-0.1632179468870163,
0.05417526513338089,
-0.07268377393484116,
0.8819869160652161,
-0.7568140029907227,
0.029882026836276054,
0.42031893134117126,
0.580937922000885,
0.4497556686401367,
0.04977881908416748,
0.6722389459609985,
-0.7689401507377625,
0.5374200940132141,
0.3979377746582031,
0.27777454257011414,
-0.054200805723667145,
-0.6347638964653015,
0.36267343163490295,
0.3112269341945648,
-0.30113527178764343,
-0.5257552862167358,
-0.29400205612182617,
-0.8004075288772583,
-0.4640333950519562,
0.662565290927887,
0.11402168869972229,
-0.3096667230129242,
-0.19825348258018494,
-0.12189895659685135,
0.09581073373556137,
-0.8426300883293152,
0.8894004225730896,
0.7909234762191772,
0.10292473435401917,
-0.15801560878753662,
-0.7747634053230286,
0.3771575093269348,
0.07231048494577408,
-0.8002817034721375,
-0.021710751578211784,
0.18770933151245117,
-0.14751911163330078,
0.3116944432258606,
0.6597491502761841,
0.06031259149312973,
0.2766651511192322,
-0.09566573798656464,
-0.35704514384269714,
0.27837058901786804,
-0.38383814692497253,
0.02511506713926792,
0.2642228603363037,
-0.30259060859680176,
-0.04674334079027176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00419v1
|
Do Vision-Language Models Understand Compound Nouns?
| 2024-03-30T16:54:45 | 2024-03-30T16:54:45 |
Sonal Kumar, Sreyan Ghosh, S Sakshi, Utkarsh Tyagi, Dinesh Manocha
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Open-vocabulary vision-language models (VLMs) like CLIP, trained using
contrastive loss, have emerged as a promising new paradigm for text-to-image
retrieval. However, do VLMs understand compound nouns (CNs) (e.g., lab coat) as
well as they understand nouns (e.g., lab)? We curate Compun, a novel benchmark
with 400 unique and commonly used CNs, to evaluate the effectiveness of VLMs in
interpreting CNs. The Compun benchmark challenges a VLM for text-to-image
retrieval where, given a text prompt with a CN, the task is to select the
correct image that shows the CN among a pair of distractor images that show the
constituent nouns that make up the CN. Next, we perform an in-depth analysis to
highlight CLIPs' limited understanding of certain types of CNs. Finally, we
present an alternative framework that moves beyond hand-written templates for
text prompts widely used by CLIP-like models. We employ a Large Language Model
to generate multiple diverse captions that include the CN as an object in the
scene described by the caption. Our proposed method improves CN understanding
of CLIP by 8.25% on Compun. Code and benchmark are available at:
https://github.com/sonalkum/Compun
|
[
-0.2565406560897827,
-0.6287410259246826,
0.5299239754676819,
0.207523375749588,
-0.5658697485923767,
0.17347227036952972,
-0.34596115350723267,
-0.3299015462398529,
-0.19084544479846954,
0.28896796703338623,
-0.4629364609718323,
-0.4746197760105133,
-0.5825608372688293,
0.36105868220329285,
-0.4184691309928894,
0.5753642320632935,
0.0352308452129364,
0.13960351049900055,
-0.32037028670310974,
-0.22037576138973236,
-0.4660521447658539,
-0.6373230814933777,
-0.47805166244506836,
-0.26175856590270996,
0.7119827270507812,
0.27894508838653564,
0.7871743440628052,
1.0345171689987183,
0.7182877659797668,
0.33476513624191284,
-0.2457604855298996,
0.4179052412509918,
-0.566694438457489,
-0.3534151613712311,
-0.1889474242925644,
-0.2526586353778839,
0.034425657242536545,
-0.23855239152908325,
0.4930152893066406,
0.9641414284706116,
0.11167828738689423,
-0.33671247959136963,
0.021825114265084267,
0.3774430751800537,
-0.9353256821632385,
0.2634701430797577,
-0.7853524088859558,
0.06996086239814758,
-0.09092070907354355,
-0.21343688666820526,
-0.5373702049255371,
0.06731924414634705,
0.40000542998313904,
-0.9979411363601685,
0.5003462433815002,
0.3681304454803467,
1.234215497970581,
-0.08377121388912201,
-0.30428093671798706,
0.005789385177195072,
-0.37441888451576233,
0.9511485695838928,
-0.19226208329200745,
0.4865540564060211,
-0.1439480185508728,
0.4167610704898834,
0.06321068108081818,
-0.7920596599578857,
-0.6764066815376282,
-0.10401633381843567,
-0.14079086482524872,
0.3292904198169708,
-0.13603270053863525,
-0.04750935360789299,
-0.026600560173392296,
0.8053051829338074,
-0.49196282029151917,
-0.05463053658604622,
-0.39448854327201843,
-0.07847633957862854,
0.32999053597450256,
0.22615477442741394,
0.4192269742488861,
-0.31967201828956604,
-1.042384147644043,
-0.47981634736061096,
-0.5332295298576355,
0.12326325476169586,
-0.06706571578979492,
0.3326376974582672,
-0.16143210232257843,
0.6633615493774414,
0.03319065645337105,
0.7845107316970825,
-0.1555374413728714,
-0.04663939028978348,
0.24035324156284332,
-0.5113106966018677,
-0.3696295917034149,
-0.2416289746761322,
0.7930358648300171,
0.7221266627311707,
0.40501806139945984,
-0.33882758021354675,
-0.13365480303764343,
0.22463388741016388,
0.10208200663328171,
-0.5842676162719727,
-0.765637218952179,
-0.2477491945028305,
-0.3878532350063324,
-0.16999411582946777,
0.3286915421485901,
-0.28664204478263855,
-0.38007500767707825,
-0.6052646636962891,
0.5404161214828491,
-0.5480908155441284,
0.00988035835325718,
0.43602558970451355,
-0.5931606888771057,
0.28071609139442444,
0.4705885946750641,
-0.6088898181915283,
0.9406416416168213,
0.6688946485519409,
1.0324206352233887,
-0.904447078704834,
-0.3840430676937103,
-0.6053383946418762,
-0.10151715576648712,
-0.3429919481277466,
1.0706684589385986,
-0.2857153117656708,
-0.5243003964424133,
0.019082823768258095,
0.09648216515779495,
-0.39154088497161865,
-0.9579343795776367,
0.14149487018585205,
-0.43336015939712524,
-0.22263038158416748,
-0.3727967441082001,
-0.41089874505996704,
-0.18992836773395538,
0.3623528778553009,
-0.7155212163925171,
0.7772395014762878,
-0.13442105054855347,
-0.6187566518783569,
0.2844589352607727,
-0.16223964095115662,
-0.16267572343349457,
0.013639076612889767,
-0.4023088216781616,
-0.2606460154056549,
0.13977573812007904,
0.39674559235572815,
0.31214097142219543,
-0.2352212369441986,
0.26249995827674866,
-0.18870966136455536,
-0.32213807106018066,
0.5095419883728027,
-0.14551319181919098,
0.6041913628578186,
-0.14504891633987427,
0.21456339955329895,
0.3198190927505493,
-0.5821850895881653,
-0.26845496892929077,
0.15008661150932312,
-0.009718390181660652,
-0.4865923821926117,
-0.03362898901104927,
0.3288717269897461,
0.06619884073734283,
0.13087333738803864,
-0.7492572069168091,
-0.11809185147285461,
-0.18538689613342285,
0.07555528730154037,
0.7116490006446838,
-0.12224550545215607,
0.3515658974647522,
-0.40160292387008667,
0.24572288990020752,
0.3032882809638977,
0.06105962023139,
-0.5668810606002808,
-0.2931649088859558,
-0.760510265827179,
-0.5731610059738159,
-0.04276494309306145,
0.47457796335220337,
-0.9530293345451355,
-0.029747992753982544,
-0.22647415101528168,
-0.25819629430770874,
-0.08310994505882263,
0.036224476993083954,
0.6525307893753052,
0.7922224402427673,
0.49428701400756836,
-0.4853562116622925,
-0.4826466739177704,
-1.0365025997161865,
-0.3103415369987488,
-0.031144216656684875,
-0.09912977367639542,
0.7760130167007446,
0.5659016370773315,
0.19639113545417786,
0.8343381881713867,
-0.8026405572891235,
-0.32219308614730835,
-0.1651434302330017,
0.32756325602531433,
0.17703212797641754,
0.23079891502857208,
0.38904091715812683,
-1.002084732055664,
-0.22464211285114288,
-0.005088878329843283,
-0.7326847910881042,
-0.01969950646162033,
-0.06707219779491425,
0.07814908027648926,
-0.13284249603748322,
0.7068215608596802,
-0.36996686458587646,
0.4379870891571045,
0.4360675811767578,
-0.386117547750473,
0.8360500335693359,
-0.3022535443305969,
-0.07379366457462311,
-0.6836325526237488,
0.1800045520067215,
0.14813095331192017,
-0.4195827543735504,
-0.3589005768299103,
0.1850423812866211,
0.12019209563732147,
-0.058443643152713776,
-0.9639120101928711,
0.742598831653595,
-0.5257702469825745,
-0.27212709188461304,
-0.24367393553256989,
0.3599170744419098,
0.39603814482688904,
0.5800651907920837,
0.5162749290466309,
0.95052570104599,
0.669747531414032,
-0.8057371377944946,
0.36734554171562195,
0.48233988881111145,
-0.4658382534980774,
0.6908557415008545,
-0.9614201188087463,
-0.12983787059783936,
-0.21937142312526703,
0.0733710527420044,
-0.7793363928794861,
-0.16758577525615692,
0.3069496154785156,
-0.19911538064479828,
0.023403707891702652,
0.10803166031837463,
-0.6431394815444946,
-0.22367678582668304,
-0.3743208348751068,
0.6139902472496033,
0.13471762835979462,
-0.8000949025154114,
0.3322857916355133,
0.21083740890026093,
-0.016500741243362427,
-0.4145756661891937,
-0.631619930267334,
0.11103057861328125,
0.1925238072872162,
-0.35349327325820923,
0.6897042393684387,
-0.27531084418296814,
-0.25969648361206055,
-0.05966739356517792,
-0.08606545627117157,
-0.4451259672641754,
-0.1038898304104805,
0.27122586965560913,
0.5994016528129578,
-0.19693146646022797,
0.2219182699918747,
-0.2967461943626404,
0.15551473200321198,
-0.06996265053749084,
-0.024716325104236603,
0.48876142501831055,
-0.2617025673389435,
-0.02923249453306198,
-0.18092848360538483,
0.2520129680633545,
0.26516929268836975,
-0.23745745420455933,
0.520957887172699,
0.27645236253738403,
-0.02443317510187626,
-0.03215394169092178,
-0.18122845888137817,
-0.21669787168502808,
-0.44801753759384155,
0.23978093266487122,
-0.5863716006278992,
-0.6190956830978394,
0.5602819323539734,
-0.11190846562385559,
-0.3155464231967926,
0.31551939249038696,
0.46028932929039,
-0.1396249383687973,
0.4928804636001587,
0.633629560470581,
0.3908379077911377,
0.3650355041027069,
-0.4271986782550812,
-0.055485643446445465,
-0.9437222480773926,
-0.4851354658603668,
-0.1326846480369568,
-0.2566313147544861,
-0.3096357583999634,
-0.6499156951904297,
0.422487735748291,
-0.1313132792711258,
-0.02248089574277401,
0.46939390897750854,
-0.36662447452545166,
0.5839986801147461,
0.40610846877098083,
0.4569861888885498,
0.6130576729774475,
0.007272953167557716,
-0.2518063187599182,
-0.006254175677895546,
-0.7291256785392761,
-0.12119555473327637,
0.6820561289787292,
0.2816949486732483,
0.7200921177864075,
-0.24480687081813812,
0.4626094400882721,
0.03996209055185318,
0.08274948596954346,
-1.1541036367416382,
0.6839824318885803,
-0.5891550779342651,
-0.43884602189064026,
0.05875831097364426,
-0.20318882167339325,
-1.0131683349609375,
0.5348052978515625,
-0.011171114630997181,
-0.5279666185379028,
0.6289116740226746,
0.1142403781414032,
-0.31492045521736145,
0.31749042868614197,
-0.3743060529232025,
1.149633526802063,
-0.11152201145887375,
-0.31617796421051025,
0.0067001148127019405,
-0.5827159285545349,
0.49244779348373413,
0.12568722665309906,
0.0992971807718277,
-0.1255773901939392,
-0.6224469542503357,
0.6000849008560181,
-0.6925678849220276,
0.6869158148765564,
0.27627265453338623,
0.10854903608560562,
0.2821938097476959,
-0.055528298020362854,
-0.11632014065980911,
-0.12664738297462463,
-0.04140717536211014,
0.3544721305370331,
-0.007090214639902115,
-0.3338035047054291,
-0.543509304523468,
0.4798107147216797,
-0.5461533665657043,
-0.06128361448645592,
-0.4971851408481598,
-0.8148627877235413,
0.1861318200826645,
0.1111549660563469,
0.43715938925743103,
0.7040665745735168,
-0.2153346687555313,
0.28272053599357605,
0.6954379081726074,
-0.35629913210868835,
0.36292925477027893,
0.3894008696079254,
-0.3890383541584015,
-0.46565112471580505,
0.9635469317436218,
-0.0946580097079277,
0.3131319284439087,
0.3686414957046509,
0.32731446623802185,
-0.16143076121807098,
-0.4341992437839508,
-0.40050628781318665,
0.30823880434036255,
-0.7401220798492432,
-0.3205145001411438,
-0.4923279285430908,
-0.11967684328556061,
0.040796101093292236,
-0.10785496234893799,
-0.3214944005012512,
-0.14348211884498596,
-0.42832332849502563,
0.24942146241664886,
0.45458880066871643,
0.45866578817367554,
0.08261340856552124,
0.6028808951377869,
-0.6594165563583374,
0.9788172841072083,
0.3489641547203064,
0.5059305429458618,
-0.2720344662666321,
-0.6469710469245911,
-0.10912954062223434,
-0.24717220664024353,
-0.1333923488855362,
-0.74404376745224,
0.43595778942108154,
0.4820953905582428,
0.22336769104003906,
0.3296095132827759,
0.2004106342792511,
0.7234547138214111,
-0.7422661185264587,
0.8230537176132202,
0.419950008392334,
-0.9643806219100952,
0.35342976450920105,
-0.47615304589271545,
0.4964178502559662,
0.5513664484024048,
0.20454534888267517,
-0.4806283712387085,
-0.2628472149372101,
-0.4159080982208252,
-0.8362727761268616,
0.5849059820175171,
0.2849070727825165,
0.2309531569480896,
-0.3755088150501251,
-0.030813101679086685,
0.3820837736129761,
0.2658531069755554,
-0.6889772415161133,
-0.427278995513916,
-0.1573512852191925,
-0.05283430591225624,
0.16552680730819702,
-0.10622618347406387,
0.12012737989425659,
-0.26092466711997986,
0.2807651162147522,
-0.17635469138622284,
0.20936094224452972,
0.5144811868667603,
-0.31079334020614624,
0.18623915314674377,
-0.04289389029145241,
0.3505377769470215,
0.3620256185531616,
-0.3165530562400818,
0.32551273703575134,
-0.06467264145612717,
-0.5361443758010864,
-0.17600899934768677,
-0.008868534117937088,
-0.09637800604104996,
0.5555612444877625,
0.2454838901758194,
0.7972182631492615,
0.7682642340660095,
-0.9065254926681519,
0.866388738155365,
-0.08620598912239075,
-0.367622047662735,
-0.1692465990781784,
-0.15356600284576416,
-0.296793133020401,
-0.16448372602462769,
0.3653363287448883,
0.16203995048999786,
0.3027210235595703,
-0.7133174538612366,
0.33451902866363525,
0.2905782163143158,
-0.2716313898563385,
-0.2042965441942215,
0.34181541204452515,
0.12663131952285767,
-0.10362311452627182,
0.3035670220851898,
-0.16168589890003204,
-0.6183285117149353,
0.673101544380188,
0.49003130197525024,
0.6769055128097534,
0.2262585610151291,
0.2363256961107254,
0.3120654225349426,
0.0067119598388671875,
-0.2712326943874359,
0.5721969604492188,
0.02110988087952137,
-0.7660782933235168,
-0.3797354996204376,
-0.25267311930656433,
-0.7008472681045532,
0.10874907672405243,
-0.6554281115531921,
0.33152446150779724,
-0.6825239658355713,
-0.027570096775889397,
0.12988638877868652,
-0.5046118497848511,
-0.7770731449127197,
0.37230706214904785,
0.30449703335762024,
0.9826390147209167,
-0.7163604497909546,
0.5401779413223267,
0.6283863186836243,
-0.3426786959171295,
-0.654792308807373,
-0.23029446601867676,
-0.17733673751354218,
-0.6112779378890991,
1.0568995475769043,
0.23473431169986725,
-0.34525027871131897,
-0.174368754029274,
-0.7098373174667358,
-0.6564954519271851,
0.7428609728813171,
0.32446372509002686,
-0.4670264720916748,
-0.0322643481194973,
0.0149641502648592,
0.3017480671405792,
-0.4409886300563812,
0.039856117218732834,
0.27991965413093567,
0.2579667866230011,
0.1301897168159485,
-1.0246593952178955,
-0.2690080404281616,
-0.23938687145709991,
0.21908502280712128,
-0.10043791681528091,
-0.4159051477909088,
1.3044084310531616,
-0.18483570218086243,
-0.4238489866256714,
0.3906027674674988,
0.7066088914871216,
0.2591482400894165,
0.6793563365936279,
0.5376651287078857,
0.34623968601226807,
0.35475796461105347,
-0.0988221988081932,
1.3669023513793945,
-0.04841488227248192,
0.1991729587316513,
1.4356387853622437,
-0.053274206817150116,
1.0889443159103394,
0.7086470723152161,
0.022336503490805626,
0.6308071613311768,
0.34158211946487427,
-0.30879896879196167,
0.5029851794242859,
0.41567304730415344,
-0.1401761770248413,
-0.4267212748527527,
-0.5815609693527222,
0.07089222222566605,
0.415671169757843,
0.15558286011219025,
-0.42828255891799927,
-0.2733744978904724,
0.31463050842285156,
-0.4400547742843628,
0.5988032817840576,
-0.42651277780532837,
0.7597132921218872,
0.3321290612220764,
-0.4249570369720459,
0.710784375667572,
-0.3443121910095215,
0.6573437452316284,
-0.21248182654380798,
0.03049808368086815,
0.055921781808137894,
0.3086372911930084,
-0.00998416543006897,
-0.8823251724243164,
0.18369223177433014,
-0.08849255740642548,
-0.13483956456184387,
0.0039582387544214725,
0.632908046245575,
-0.4844040274620056,
-0.6128514409065247,
0.3243193030357361,
0.559883177280426,
0.30360278487205505,
-0.3224375545978546,
-0.5702548027038574,
0.39849960803985596,
-0.5249818563461304,
0.270668089389801,
-0.20046012103557587,
0.27229389548301697,
0.03281335160136223,
0.6003350019454956,
0.4298667907714844,
0.06535140424966812,
0.10609302669763565,
0.13199955224990845,
0.9250307083129883,
-0.34159722924232483,
-0.30045974254608154,
-0.7525262832641602,
0.3455568850040436,
-0.2781696021556854,
-0.19914975762367249,
0.6848393678665161,
0.8917385339736938,
1.0835317373275757,
-0.6532220244407654,
0.4610988199710846,
0.33896422386169434,
0.46908730268478394,
-0.5280359387397766,
0.42391690611839294,
-0.6388266086578369,
-0.03961532562971115,
-0.355031818151474,
-0.6880543828010559,
-0.6120059490203857,
0.41797110438346863,
-0.42102959752082825,
-0.49566489458084106,
0.9012342691421509,
0.8296934962272644,
-0.3786846101284027,
-0.37302517890930176,
0.41626545786857605,
-0.17211352288722992,
-0.06218808889389038,
0.459046870470047,
0.838295578956604,
-0.8787698149681091,
0.8682404160499573,
-0.4317162334918976,
0.1389857679605484,
-0.36138916015625,
-0.8591791987419128,
-0.9292377233505249,
-0.42260223627090454,
-0.7369899749755859,
0.11980682611465454,
0.21320179104804993,
0.7234063744544983,
0.8038821220397949,
-0.6820721626281738,
-0.3548355996608734,
-0.23923800885677338,
0.024200022220611572,
-0.3401053845882416,
-0.15668101608753204,
0.34388938546180725,
-0.3039308488368988,
-0.707361102104187,
0.28165382146835327,
0.3169364929199219,
0.05814429372549057,
0.15793795883655548,
-0.05972797051072121,
-0.26256078481674194,
0.09018555283546448,
0.8027827143669128,
0.3375247120857239,
-0.9341599345207214,
-0.13447648286819458,
0.3837183117866516,
-0.28183794021606445,
0.40696367621421814,
0.9940570592880249,
-1.0875741243362427,
0.6355643272399902,
0.6076070666313171,
0.5387540459632874,
0.1798252910375595,
0.019544703885912895,
0.554922342300415,
-0.7839201092720032,
0.1630794107913971,
0.04850776121020317,
0.4160371720790863,
0.660063624382019,
-0.011180552653968334,
0.26618024706840515,
0.4836328625679016,
-0.04930443316698074,
-0.6144168376922607,
0.3146629333496094,
-1.5489999055862427,
-0.4325267970561981,
1.02873694896698,
-0.2649470269680023,
-0.6327579021453857,
-0.09964349120855331,
-0.7337074875831604,
0.2546769380569458,
-0.3988901972770691,
0.5315930843353271,
0.27776965498924255,
0.13001325726509094,
-0.6595413088798523,
-0.2414732128381729,
0.28337225317955017,
0.4622991979122162,
-0.6696950197219849,
0.24878636002540588,
0.480195552110672,
-0.07340019196271896,
0.27678918838500977,
0.09582336246967316,
-0.10192085057497025,
0.6854172348976135,
-0.1818498820066452,
-0.07121673226356506,
-0.2647336721420288,
-0.4201081395149231,
-0.31791651248931885,
-0.04314660653471947,
-0.03438282012939453,
-0.6000716686248779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00415v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00415v1
|
CoDa: Constrained Generation based Data Augmentation for Low-Resource NLP
| 2024-03-30T16:47:06 | 2024-03-30T16:47:06 |
Chandra Kiran Reddy Evuru, Sreyan Ghosh, Sonal Kumar, Ramaneswaran S, Utkarsh Tyagi, Dinesh Manocha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present CoDa (Constrained Generation based Data Augmentation), a
controllable, effective, and training-free data augmentation technique for
low-resource (data-scarce) NLP. Our approach is based on prompting
off-the-shelf instruction-following Large Language Models (LLMs) for generating
text that satisfies a set of constraints. Precisely, we extract a set of simple
constraints from every instance in the low-resource dataset and verbalize them
to prompt an LLM to generate novel and diverse training instances. Our findings
reveal that synthetic data that follows simple constraints in the downstream
dataset act as highly effective augmentations, and CoDa can achieve this
without intricate decoding-time constrained generation techniques or
fine-tuning with complex algorithms that eventually make the model biased
toward the small number of training instances. Additionally, CoDa is the first
framework that provides users explicit control over the augmentation generation
process, thereby also allowing easy adaptation to several domains. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of CoDa across 11 datasets spanning 3 tasks and 3
low-resource settings. CoDa outperforms all our baselines, qualitatively and
quantitatively, with improvements of 0.12%-7.19%. Code is available here:
https://github.com/Sreyan88/CoDa
|
[
-0.3331913650035858,
-0.6354700922966003,
0.49860554933547974,
0.420324444770813,
-0.3830287456512451,
0.216772198677063,
-0.49696779251098633,
-0.5268399715423584,
0.37254709005355835,
0.4818457067012787,
-0.862166702747345,
-0.5723992586135864,
-0.3599778115749359,
0.3791525065898895,
-0.14498162269592285,
0.7282431125640869,
0.2318427413702011,
-0.12892653048038483,
-0.41363948583602905,
-0.17107366025447845,
-0.817516028881073,
-0.5181249380111694,
-0.30740806460380554,
-0.20193840563297272,
0.4033033847808838,
0.6060083508491516,
0.756680428981781,
0.7575708031654358,
0.25928202271461487,
0.16255472600460052,
-0.18307076394557953,
0.8384690880775452,
-0.5775703191757202,
-0.08338028937578201,
-0.22927719354629517,
-0.4489789605140686,
-0.3018629550933838,
-0.224282369017601,
0.3891621232032776,
0.8707823753356934,
-0.12543071806430817,
0.3660670518875122,
0.07672855257987976,
0.7589694857597351,
-0.8613627552986145,
0.13041448593139648,
-1.06877863407135,
0.08708509057760239,
-0.19201482832431793,
-0.24866372346878052,
-0.4555078446865082,
-0.21092143654823303,
-0.052619919180870056,
-0.9628965258598328,
0.16650433838367462,
-0.03738705813884735,
0.579956591129303,
0.6221377849578857,
-0.252275288105011,
-0.35795825719833374,
-0.6866355538368225,
0.8593510389328003,
-0.6162787079811096,
0.1486940085887909,
0.40420523285865784,
-0.08778902888298035,
-0.002695772098377347,
-0.6925209164619446,
-0.7550952434539795,
-0.1513393074274063,
-0.02196476235985756,
0.055458080023527145,
-0.09054059535264969,
0.08220001310110092,
0.5682852268218994,
0.3557204306125641,
-0.357767254114151,
0.3032003343105316,
-0.3815518021583557,
-0.006275023799389601,
0.5800331234931946,
0.05898914486169815,
0.2976275384426117,
-0.21946516633033752,
-0.2749757766723633,
-0.11216990649700165,
-0.8853477239608765,
-0.13229209184646606,
0.42808201909065247,
0.7600197792053223,
-0.2689037621021271,
0.7838274836540222,
-0.3620339632034302,
0.8079295754432678,
-0.033363454043865204,
0.28780490159988403,
0.39585670828819275,
-0.33867529034614563,
-0.16523945331573486,
0.07292929291725159,
0.5540544986724854,
0.1289547085762024,
-0.0946606695652008,
0.06230168789625168,
-0.365579754114151,
0.20633281767368317,
0.2896691560745239,
-0.5540378093719482,
0.0001600491814315319,
0.17498037219047546,
-0.23176687955856323,
-0.41270774602890015,
-0.1682797521352768,
-0.8528455495834351,
-0.32612481713294983,
-0.2181091606616974,
0.14732590317726135,
-0.32567650079727173,
0.0951836109161377,
0.11040816456079483,
0.21029214560985565,
0.12833397090435028,
-0.0784645825624466,
-1.121259331703186,
0.24814587831497192,
0.5773864984512329,
1.0199753046035767,
-0.3427041172981262,
0.12770976126194,
-0.7930952310562134,
0.10983650386333466,
-0.3917931020259857,
0.44976890087127686,
-0.7166151404380798,
-0.5455844402313232,
0.24869601428508759,
-0.1880267858505249,
0.2701626718044281,
-0.5588691234588623,
0.5940285325050354,
-0.5599802732467651,
0.06573019176721573,
-0.05764058604836464,
-0.5902716517448425,
0.03274134173989296,
0.05488395690917969,
-0.8863967061042786,
0.9629614949226379,
0.27910116314888,
-0.2486879825592041,
0.4037654995918274,
-0.7559643387794495,
-0.45147421956062317,
0.19088123738765717,
-0.07989111542701721,
-0.282204806804657,
0.16592323780059814,
0.7333019971847534,
-0.02004840038716793,
-0.29779085516929626,
0.15867111086845398,
-0.14903715252876282,
-0.07923763990402222,
0.13007967174053192,
-0.4890843331813812,
0.5137863159179688,
0.3050013780593872,
-0.054790690541267395,
-0.028266822919249535,
-1.02537202835083,
0.3178999125957489,
0.09464432299137115,
-0.5178846716880798,
-0.1262357532978058,
0.05703921616077423,
0.08451969921588898,
0.1422458440065384,
0.4094963073730469,
-0.5395237803459167,
0.6251204609870911,
-0.6480339169502258,
0.21690788865089417,
0.5873305797576904,
0.1863136738538742,
0.5181711912155151,
-0.27052831649780273,
0.7132696509361267,
-0.3681129813194275,
0.20107068121433258,
-0.20004896819591522,
-0.5046291947364807,
-0.5119515061378479,
-0.06523425877094269,
0.45405998826026917,
0.5822651386260986,
-1.1719709634780884,
0.5546471476554871,
-0.3825475573539734,
-0.22845521569252014,
-0.5462985634803772,
0.49535641074180603,
0.30692431330680847,
0.39404651522636414,
0.7213267087936401,
-0.26328450441360474,
-0.7729945182800293,
-0.654353678226471,
0.07557609677314758,
0.03710773214697838,
-0.20644637942314148,
0.22964513301849365,
-0.01855071634054184,
-0.17469418048858643,
0.8998864889144897,
-0.587371826171875,
-0.48922082781791687,
-0.561271607875824,
0.00845423899590969,
0.28073644638061523,
0.6639676094055176,
0.43553730845451355,
-0.6859691739082336,
-0.2650573253631592,
-0.1393359750509262,
-0.6572798490524292,
-0.5125173330307007,
-0.4992004334926605,
0.09979099035263062,
0.2665167450904846,
0.3585608899593353,
-0.5249883532524109,
0.23214416205883026,
0.8113409280776978,
-0.08729495108127594,
0.25525131821632385,
-0.28001582622528076,
-0.4187942147254944,
-1.1043479442596436,
-0.09136395901441574,
-0.2880820631980896,
-0.18654878437519073,
-0.5316771864891052,
0.06057709455490112,
-0.10808069258928299,
-0.5044107437133789,
-0.4017412066459656,
0.35116204619407654,
-0.5087423324584961,
-0.007390374783426523,
-0.3903593420982361,
0.21468307077884674,
0.008009045384824276,
0.5668734312057495,
0.079343281686306,
0.8907762169837952,
0.38817232847213745,
-0.5629463791847229,
0.11350331455469131,
0.7545631527900696,
-0.29111525416374207,
0.10252895951271057,
-0.619483232498169,
0.3872583210468292,
0.16523782908916473,
0.29931095242500305,
-0.3398652970790863,
-0.20797865092754364,
0.1558174341917038,
-0.20052805542945862,
0.07549312710762024,
-0.32600054144859314,
-0.41780731081962585,
-0.19020280241966248,
-0.1648074835538864,
0.5231307148933411,
0.7619198560714722,
-0.7792103290557861,
0.5637916922569275,
0.38152235746383667,
-0.12364683300256729,
-0.5689420700073242,
-0.8248298168182373,
0.31949761509895325,
0.2883389890193939,
-0.47661200165748596,
0.6287060976028442,
-0.14191170036792755,
-0.05295747146010399,
-0.07420840859413147,
0.016704870387911797,
-0.05634003505110741,
-0.10204210132360458,
0.2120983600616455,
0.37666139006614685,
-0.004741019103676081,
0.24937599897384644,
0.2639569342136383,
-0.011882591061294079,
-0.18121270835399628,
-0.46693217754364014,
0.6040313243865967,
0.17614810168743134,
-0.47360125184059143,
-0.48821893334388733,
0.31043437123298645,
0.10306406766176224,
-0.22545398771762848,
0.5096737742424011,
0.47482895851135254,
-0.23311668634414673,
-0.6864337921142578,
-0.25731903314590454,
-0.19180011749267578,
-0.5258810520172119,
0.15651452541351318,
-0.15082170069217682,
-0.7079987525939941,
0.2745564579963684,
-0.07352668046951294,
-0.01971863955259323,
0.2319423407316208,
0.3810075521469116,
0.2603093683719635,
0.9811459183692932,
0.6593090295791626,
-0.017938785254955292,
0.4928876459598541,
-0.42558759450912476,
0.004115775693207979,
-0.6606633067131042,
-0.11000978946685791,
-0.18537822365760803,
-0.46922680735588074,
-0.6846767663955688,
-0.6027964949607849,
0.353234201669693,
0.007467098534107208,
0.45012620091438293,
0.10725142061710358,
-0.6885928511619568,
0.6732885837554932,
0.5848014950752258,
0.1886792927980423,
0.21946385502815247,
-0.08848802000284195,
0.25280800461769104,
0.05539112538099289,
-0.9969114065170288,
-0.42370957136154175,
1.3216899633407593,
-0.07377826422452927,
0.6354440450668335,
-0.12162620574235916,
0.7925899028778076,
0.5897576212882996,
0.13909754157066345,
-0.9354715347290039,
0.5630848407745361,
-0.23331086337566376,
-0.3046633005142212,
-0.20097671449184418,
-0.5782154202461243,
-0.7589359879493713,
-0.17301823198795319,
-0.7015213370323181,
-0.3702164590358734,
0.39582207798957825,
0.4538494944572449,
-0.5038254261016846,
0.33995771408081055,
-0.7117981910705566,
0.36047399044036865,
-0.08794456720352173,
-0.33808839321136475,
-0.12944909930229187,
-0.5135284066200256,
0.2670077681541443,
-0.3088417947292328,
0.025358540937304497,
-0.07211291790008545,
-0.3413527011871338,
0.4949159324169159,
-0.8121723532676697,
0.9060432314872742,
-0.46380388736724854,
-0.24554717540740967,
0.5017818212509155,
-0.04494067654013634,
0.8599331378936768,
0.27933862805366516,
0.023382822051644325,
0.04418879747390747,
-0.3182372450828552,
-0.5102354884147644,
-0.7454672455787659,
0.6295326352119446,
-0.44447529315948486,
-0.40189501643180847,
-0.22429896891117096,
-0.8556095361709595,
-0.6115946173667908,
0.1494787037372589,
0.24262051284313202,
0.5438656806945801,
-0.1716277003288269,
0.2068513184785843,
0.5467861294746399,
-0.47693315148353577,
0.39174720644950867,
0.38799455761909485,
-0.04118267819285393,
-0.4756554961204529,
1.0499613285064697,
-0.003899229224771261,
0.36819860339164734,
0.343586266040802,
0.0370447151362896,
-0.34433481097221375,
-0.9432253241539001,
-0.48270463943481445,
-0.02918233722448349,
-0.4811868965625763,
-0.4118477404117584,
-0.44872039556503296,
0.006686530541628599,
-0.307611882686615,
-0.3069351315498352,
-0.43959468603134155,
-0.7274065613746643,
-0.4238104820251465,
-0.22036124765872955,
0.32768988609313965,
0.6908727884292603,
-0.29105356335639954,
0.4291573166847229,
-0.9583353400230408,
0.5384470224380493,
0.3462250530719757,
0.22910787165164948,
-0.3670397102832794,
-0.316325306892395,
-0.2612846791744232,
0.115181565284729,
-0.14226122200489044,
-0.6127617359161377,
0.5068615078926086,
0.47221824526786804,
0.10428091883659363,
0.20843638479709625,
0.31684252619743347,
0.3227371573448181,
-0.4771130681037903,
1.0328844785690308,
0.03188306838274002,
-1.0279028415679932,
0.640634298324585,
-0.2639644145965576,
0.4712296426296234,
0.6383371353149414,
-0.1117670089006424,
-0.17433807253837585,
-0.3868545591831207,
-0.5133289694786072,
-1.1325238943099976,
0.7438513040542603,
0.34616661071777344,
0.5025550127029419,
-0.0452713780105114,
0.3519153594970703,
0.1632937341928482,
0.11578833311796188,
-0.5765963196754456,
-0.10022703558206558,
-0.16036750376224518,
-0.344524085521698,
0.16548965871334076,
-0.38944244384765625,
-0.2844768464565277,
0.05935946851968765,
0.8717585206031799,
-0.4497632086277008,
-0.03497491031885147,
0.18189477920532227,
-0.3205513656139374,
-0.0021469146013259888,
0.22581277787685394,
0.6149580478668213,
0.7939146757125854,
-0.1472705751657486,
-0.1492234766483307,
0.5260025858879089,
-0.5465092658996582,
0.1602754294872284,
0.11734889447689056,
-0.5846231579780579,
0.15996292233467102,
0.30337756872177124,
0.8285874128341675,
0.019459431990981102,
-0.8053367733955383,
0.35841283202171326,
0.07682276517152786,
-0.13222327828407288,
-0.09604748338460922,
0.052437085658311844,
-0.2229023277759552,
0.08886142820119858,
0.41666296124458313,
-0.022202899679541588,
-0.21613086760044098,
-0.05277891829609871,
0.21357251703739166,
0.3496389091014862,
-0.21120497584342957,
-0.1979636698961258,
0.7323917150497437,
0.3986109793186188,
0.0018901594448834658,
0.4048687815666199,
-0.41223621368408203,
0.012969635426998138,
0.42375504970550537,
0.5627543926239014,
0.8055545687675476,
0.15486541390419006,
0.42738059163093567,
0.24973848462104797,
0.4928550720214844,
0.1030951514840126,
0.6102298498153687,
-0.040501441806554794,
-0.9017104506492615,
-0.6946327090263367,
-0.6367784142494202,
-0.5634098649024963,
0.22463560104370117,
-0.7251601815223694,
0.17841823399066925,
-0.6673412322998047,
-0.17991408705711365,
-0.1975114941596985,
-0.11159318685531616,
-0.4762979745864868,
0.15583692491054535,
0.19517776370048523,
1.147443175315857,
-0.5932409763336182,
0.662092924118042,
0.2735554277896881,
-0.5547316074371338,
-0.7316688895225525,
0.0031485992949455976,
-0.0038396285381168127,
-0.8165225386619568,
0.44169995188713074,
-0.04791570454835892,
-0.2033064216375351,
0.06743729114532471,
-0.754094660282135,
-0.6717414259910583,
0.9300988912582397,
0.5962076187133789,
-0.5297991037368774,
-0.07173673808574677,
0.3388873040676117,
0.5456513166427612,
-0.4164254367351532,
-0.47789162397384644,
0.428068608045578,
0.4584677517414093,
-0.1556205451488495,
-0.49396827816963196,
0.07074496895074844,
-0.28827691078186035,
0.20131735503673553,
-0.03418643772602081,
-0.43041887879371643,
0.26011839509010315,
-0.31645238399505615,
-0.38647764921188354,
0.17933480441570282,
0.9621662497520447,
0.12607403099536896,
0.1516706347465515,
0.6825579404830933,
0.625518262386322,
0.8323275446891785,
-0.07920721918344498,
1.1639498472213745,
-0.5360254049301147,
0.09974145144224167,
1.1985496282577515,
-0.3294370472431183,
0.661146342754364,
0.5534999370574951,
-0.03800283372402191,
0.39982932806015015,
0.3353967070579529,
-0.05940129607915878,
0.4807298183441162,
0.07337259501218796,
-0.4431779384613037,
-0.13927780091762543,
-0.6665588021278381,
-0.3629705607891083,
0.5765519738197327,
0.3687020540237427,
-0.1800130307674408,
0.11311217397451401,
0.15523368120193481,
-0.15258680284023285,
0.3056248128414154,
-0.3390375077724457,
0.9420084357261658,
-0.023285895586013794,
-0.5251188278198242,
0.8925904631614685,
-0.09840342402458191,
0.6937779188156128,
-0.8395363688468933,
-0.03697730973362923,
-0.2241249680519104,
-0.1369686722755432,
-0.29845306277275085,
-0.456289142370224,
0.36064743995666504,
0.2956099808216095,
-0.2898043096065521,
-0.3512955904006958,
0.6901063323020935,
-0.6440510153770447,
-0.5072019100189209,
0.11747866868972778,
0.5587610006332397,
-0.3056854009628296,
0.1238788515329361,
-0.3976016938686371,
0.11744564771652222,
0.05428875982761383,
-0.10037587583065033,
0.12713706493377686,
0.27230632305145264,
0.14527076482772827,
0.6034228205680847,
0.9954534769058228,
0.6346713900566101,
0.12045641243457794,
0.21896077692508698,
1.0170785188674927,
-0.28697869181632996,
-0.5646886825561523,
-0.37005433440208435,
0.15561696887016296,
-0.17133747041225433,
-0.2529333531856537,
0.36843764781951904,
0.49016273021698,
0.902188777923584,
-0.24809888005256653,
1.060600996017456,
-0.08452509343624115,
0.4597712755203247,
-1.0260987281799316,
0.5362129807472229,
-0.41190895438194275,
0.450829416513443,
0.12096072733402252,
-0.9750540256500244,
-0.2768601179122925,
0.027069583535194397,
-0.16351968050003052,
-0.20959095656871796,
0.5104747414588928,
0.9221805930137634,
-0.10455114394426346,
-0.09440074861049652,
0.19470185041427612,
-0.12191979587078094,
0.3484274744987488,
0.5885925889015198,
0.6414727568626404,
0.012859680689871311,
0.7827610969543457,
-0.4063205122947693,
-0.19001974165439606,
0.09078987687826157,
-0.8190156817436218,
-0.46225693821907043,
-0.47956594824790955,
-0.12772533297538757,
-0.2350592166185379,
-0.015645066276192665,
1.4321081638336182,
0.6418262124061584,
-0.9010593295097351,
-0.03538454324007034,
-0.24995602667331696,
0.1028076782822609,
-0.3554466664791107,
-0.21566011011600494,
0.22517162561416626,
-0.7509257197380066,
-1.0201427936553955,
1.07413911819458,
0.0884217694401741,
0.09344493597745895,
-0.1696091741323471,
-0.06132127717137337,
-0.2887824475765228,
0.27824628353118896,
0.5517269968986511,
0.5741071105003357,
-0.35063043236732483,
-0.2646426558494568,
-0.26707205176353455,
0.09449673444032669,
0.05379738286137581,
1.0642731189727783,
-0.8570995330810547,
0.6668344140052795,
0.5284895896911621,
1.0988246202468872,
0.27471306920051575,
0.2294013351202011,
0.8208286762237549,
-1.540639042854309,
0.46460291743278503,
0.37543049454689026,
0.22919882833957672,
0.43872711062431335,
-0.43249645829200745,
0.6850658655166626,
0.20755870640277863,
-0.2462972104549408,
-0.9779812097549438,
0.4515215754508972,
-1.078183650970459,
-0.018661657348275185,
1.100417137145996,
0.11956099420785904,
-0.062495384365320206,
0.020129775628447533,
-0.12667959928512573,
0.23875972628593445,
-0.4768249988555908,
0.9065647721290588,
0.29367271065711975,
0.016421260312199593,
0.12038905173540115,
-0.3557509481906891,
0.8621471524238586,
0.5314348936080933,
-1.1384328603744507,
0.2466425746679306,
0.7400037050247192,
-0.30070725083351135,
0.20772452652454376,
0.4748057723045349,
0.07185722887516022,
0.12314461171627045,
-0.23062126338481903,
0.0900687649846077,
-0.5180573463439941,
-0.22239506244659424,
-0.49462294578552246,
0.28701266646385193,
-0.2066042721271515,
-0.3168792128562927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08665v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08665v1
|
Targeted aspect-based emotion analysis to detect opportunities and precaution in financial Twitter messages
| 2024-03-30T16:46:25 | 2024-03-30T16:46:25 |
Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Ana Barros-Vila, Francisco J. González-Castaño
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI, q-fin.TR
|
Microblogging platforms, of which Twitter is a representative example, are
valuable information sources for market screening and financial models. In
them, users voluntarily provide relevant information, including educated
knowledge on investments, reacting to the state of the stock markets in
real-time and, often, influencing this state. We are interested in the user
forecasts in financial, social media messages expressing opportunities and
precautions about assets. We propose a novel Targeted Aspect-Based Emotion
Analysis (TABEA) system that can individually discern the financial emotions
(positive and negative forecasts) on the different stock market assets in the
same tweet (instead of making an overall guess about that whole tweet). It is
based on Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques and Machine Learning
streaming algorithms. The system comprises a constituency parsing module for
parsing the tweets and splitting them into simpler declarative clauses; an
offline data processing module to engineer textual, numerical and categorical
features and analyse and select them based on their relevance; and a stream
classification module to continuously process tweets on-the-fly. Experimental
results on a labelled data set endorse our solution. It achieves over 90%
precision for the target emotions, financial opportunity, and precaution on
Twitter. To the best of our knowledge, no prior work in the literature has
addressed this problem despite its practical interest in decision-making, and
we are not aware of any previous NLP nor online Machine Learning approaches to
TABEA.
|
[
-0.1982598751783371,
-0.8858597278594971,
0.26782146096229553,
0.6196842193603516,
-0.43535563349723816,
0.5637917518615723,
-0.04781158268451691,
-0.4577556252479553,
0.741583526134491,
0.47231632471084595,
-0.612744927406311,
-0.8058578968048096,
-0.35833609104156494,
-0.3741671144962311,
-0.44356733560562134,
0.8859215378761292,
-0.1565495729446411,
-0.2431635856628418,
0.44409164786338806,
-0.14293348789215088,
-0.1281968355178833,
-0.2779519259929657,
-0.9848837852478027,
0.11215344071388245,
0.583270788192749,
0.3903595805168152,
0.2608330249786377,
-0.08963381499052048,
0.9453139901161194,
0.32639238238334656,
0.13305729627609253,
0.025183159857988358,
-0.3096272051334381,
0.07627463340759277,
-0.11051293462514877,
-0.1383436769247055,
-0.6478061676025391,
-0.11341575533151627,
0.35994836688041687,
0.15007805824279785,
-0.3953264355659485,
0.4034963548183441,
0.36801081895828247,
0.7989023327827454,
-0.6611302495002747,
0.3193519115447998,
-0.4928319454193115,
0.22272831201553345,
-0.3154083788394928,
-0.5982993841171265,
-0.17083647847175598,
-0.4853271543979645,
0.3041427433490753,
-0.3011839985847473,
-0.01742403581738472,
0.2539040744304657,
0.9273914098739624,
-0.07143063843250275,
-0.25855153799057007,
-0.26324641704559326,
-0.6504445672035217,
0.764328122138977,
-0.6384821534156799,
0.16443586349487305,
0.1385035365819931,
0.39394742250442505,
0.08171509206295013,
-0.26967814564704895,
-0.3426379859447479,
0.2758052945137024,
0.05959675461053848,
-0.033729758113622665,
-0.6930169463157654,
0.25327399373054504,
-0.12104234844446182,
0.05108943581581116,
-0.35911041498184204,
-0.13443619012832642,
-0.16466295719146729,
-0.2742553949356079,
0.5041126012802124,
-0.17295709252357483,
0.09656265377998352,
-0.48660755157470703,
-0.29244714975357056,
-0.2971256971359253,
-0.3431505262851715,
0.3947541415691376,
0.6036795973777771,
0.5003862977027893,
-0.1933591663837433,
0.3719028830528259,
-0.1443343460559845,
0.07927785068750381,
0.01988890953361988,
0.035074371844530106,
0.2813163697719574,
0.2702770233154297,
-0.2934500277042389,
0.19475607573986053,
0.64771968126297,
0.4781574308872223,
-0.0761718675494194,
0.0869462713599205,
-0.35654303431510925,
-0.1042264923453331,
0.4463256895542145,
-0.6214437484741211,
-0.10625342279672623,
0.7950712442398071,
-0.5043759346008301,
-0.4168710708618164,
0.20688897371292114,
-1.136675238609314,
-0.471785306930542,
-0.0980370044708252,
0.5536746382713318,
-0.4537598490715027,
-0.289779394865036,
-0.11621124297380447,
-0.01019282266497612,
-0.016830073669552803,
0.132929265499115,
-0.5727551579475403,
0.11063823848962784,
0.9183792471885681,
0.7355007529258728,
0.18038271367549896,
-0.0017383157974109054,
-0.7444085478782654,
0.06189943104982376,
-0.12117233872413635,
1.0500319004058838,
-0.3638967275619507,
-0.11001170426607132,
0.2557545304298401,
-0.39233875274658203,
0.04380440339446068,
-0.23239625990390778,
0.41816824674606323,
-0.5264217257499695,
-0.20522023737430573,
-0.44891178607940674,
-0.43837299942970276,
-0.3703658878803253,
0.3271620571613312,
-0.6634579300880432,
0.6991768479347229,
0.13221843540668488,
-0.9797031879425049,
0.7136176824569702,
-1.2390350103378296,
-0.4479556083679199,
0.050236232578754425,
0.11329732090234756,
-0.5592190623283386,
0.0757913887500763,
0.4902886152267456,
0.4971100687980652,
-0.1714528352022171,
0.385842889547348,
-0.7104639410972595,
0.1219138503074646,
0.5302876830101013,
-0.37054452300071716,
0.17598684132099152,
0.09175590425729752,
-0.6222018599510193,
0.5086273550987244,
-0.47657832503318787,
-0.07192541658878326,
0.08424130827188492,
0.3631868362426758,
-0.4664815366268158,
0.28098851442337036,
0.2361513078212738,
0.1633750945329666,
0.406229704618454,
-0.697898268699646,
-0.12884826958179474,
-0.2785419225692749,
0.38448473811149597,
0.8981099128723145,
0.24013879895210266,
0.3192140460014343,
-0.09140195697546005,
0.671188473701477,
0.3820051848888397,
0.5326141715049744,
0.253745973110199,
-0.13301758468151093,
-0.7601965665817261,
-0.026108624413609505,
0.11618965864181519,
0.6077076196670532,
-0.672989010810852,
0.3735361099243164,
0.04204355180263519,
-0.3489704728126526,
-0.6325927972793579,
0.03971880301833153,
0.057750701904296875,
0.1791544109582901,
0.24832935631275177,
-0.04119720682501793,
-0.6992580890655518,
-1.0128989219665527,
-0.3544788658618927,
-0.3125971853733063,
0.08009113371372223,
0.22261084616184235,
0.09875287115573883,
0.026679515838623047,
1.049102544784546,
-0.6921788454055786,
-0.20892953872680664,
-0.46820011734962463,
0.5646424293518066,
0.08974196761846542,
0.1803048849105835,
0.7817205190658569,
-1.0438790321350098,
-0.29828357696533203,
0.22130747139453888,
-0.42933809757232666,
-0.10854924470186234,
-0.2918799817562103,
-0.290944904088974,
0.16613610088825226,
0.04590746760368347,
-0.18029886484146118,
0.6997286677360535,
0.47208791971206665,
-0.42343732714653015,
-0.005833672825247049,
0.21990835666656494,
0.30994683504104614,
-1.171486735343933,
-0.0749136283993721,
0.6790884137153625,
-0.21868543326854706,
-0.7150813937187195,
-0.36472395062446594,
-0.026154907420277596,
0.15087254345417023,
-0.40118440985679626,
0.6904984712600708,
0.02443969063460827,
0.08068888634443283,
-0.4767860174179077,
0.21221891045570374,
-0.24685396254062653,
0.39802443981170654,
-0.1338605433702469,
0.3120570182800293,
0.4469992220401764,
-0.2085411697626114,
0.07281875610351562,
-0.15380018949508667,
-0.1792869120836258,
0.44412335753440857,
-0.21419110894203186,
0.047810859978199005,
0.06901977956295013,
0.07369868457317352,
-0.9082608819007874,
-0.2314138114452362,
0.48229891061782837,
-0.31606870889663696,
0.05199722573161125,
0.27230334281921387,
-0.09901854395866394,
-0.6153411269187927,
-0.6289333701133728,
0.15752458572387695,
0.1540967971086502,
-0.23043635487556458,
0.8296633958816528,
0.5773733258247375,
-0.5133744478225708,
-0.6184769868850708,
-0.48227065801620483,
0.2023065835237503,
-0.569037139415741,
-0.4078778922557831,
0.10587937384843826,
0.4254879057407379,
-0.4085932672023773,
0.24169135093688965,
-0.2254488170146942,
-0.04196774959564209,
0.14641988277435303,
0.3129179775714874,
0.5282707810401917,
-0.024432770907878876,
-0.03277071192860603,
0.2988360524177551,
-0.10616546124219894,
0.058840516954660416,
-0.24419885873794556,
0.5338173508644104,
-0.47008684277534485,
-0.3475305140018463,
-0.5076329112052917,
0.39485323429107666,
-0.05198569968342781,
-0.12606601417064667,
0.814431369304657,
0.7847772240638733,
-0.6375372409820557,
-0.3028368055820465,
-0.7442868947982788,
-0.055564019829034805,
-0.5400026440620422,
0.30952054262161255,
0.09658931940793991,
-1.0521641969680786,
0.9452933669090271,
0.2840607166290283,
0.12777180969715118,
0.7535935640335083,
0.4655068516731262,
-0.26359063386917114,
0.5438753962516785,
0.8796780705451965,
-0.23592619597911835,
0.7905541658401489,
-0.416326642036438,
0.6393927335739136,
-0.43553078174591064,
-0.09942807257175446,
-0.2710016369819641,
-0.8027356863021851,
-0.47359272837638855,
-0.19649571180343628,
0.21157926321029663,
-0.1421545296907425,
-0.007577278185635805,
0.43987661600112915,
-0.3008163273334503,
0.2086528092622757,
0.550008237361908,
0.32340681552886963,
-0.1540158987045288,
-0.1595108062028885,
0.27861079573631287,
-0.07520365715026855,
-0.2098865956068039,
-0.6516637206077576,
0.9848478436470032,
0.6500590443611145,
0.5730360150337219,
-0.0021428207401186228,
0.8622105121612549,
0.7892951965332031,
0.9685647487640381,
-0.6439454555511475,
0.4138288199901581,
-0.2537183463573456,
-0.3394606411457062,
-0.2890688180923462,
-0.7052599787712097,
-0.5606411695480347,
-0.24385252594947815,
-0.17455333471298218,
-1.2347791194915771,
0.4480218291282654,
0.12911322712898254,
-0.7249085903167725,
0.6436001062393188,
-0.7657404541969299,
0.9089873433113098,
-0.24040140211582184,
-0.14760154485702515,
-0.2309783697128296,
-0.34899523854255676,
0.29607293009757996,
-0.377668172121048,
0.24586454033851624,
-0.3926314413547516,
0.048325810581445694,
0.8332233428955078,
-0.24346163868904114,
0.8152062892913818,
-0.3880079686641693,
-0.017993373796343803,
0.5085641741752625,
0.13591311872005463,
0.29475298523902893,
0.0512031614780426,
0.010713868774473667,
0.09256957471370697,
-0.14802928268909454,
-0.40993696451187134,
-0.4472929537296295,
0.5183944702148438,
-0.3784369230270386,
-0.3861754238605499,
-0.23678547143936157,
-0.3626881241798401,
-0.2992442846298218,
-0.11716911941766739,
-0.08516508340835571,
0.1362539827823639,
-0.24954937398433685,
0.19686679542064667,
-0.16762375831604004,
0.023778514936566353,
0.6142873167991638,
0.33216652274131775,
-0.3481110632419586,
-0.5316372513771057,
1.1785725355148315,
0.08196156471967697,
-0.1542162448167801,
0.5580040812492371,
0.24488972127437592,
-0.41824641823768616,
-0.5583476424217224,
0.1572468876838684,
-0.150442436337471,
-0.47258466482162476,
-0.46473732590675354,
-0.4874148368835449,
-0.06047368794679642,
-0.36683350801467896,
-0.23156507313251495,
-0.4334554374217987,
-0.05544860288500786,
-0.30017179250717163,
-0.287482351064682,
0.358927458524704,
0.6680734157562256,
-0.1422208696603775,
0.4130145311355591,
-1.1278228759765625,
0.19873736798763275,
0.1392289400100708,
0.3993906080722809,
0.1382523477077484,
-0.10122948884963989,
-0.3932305574417114,
0.22392971813678741,
-0.5882954001426697,
-0.9531623125076294,
0.7226383686065674,
0.0012393438955768943,
0.04743746295571327,
0.8851743340492249,
0.3695008456707001,
0.6294276118278503,
0.17357565462589264,
0.30725327134132385,
0.161529541015625,
-1.0108352899551392,
0.6225489377975464,
-0.38979727029800415,
-0.36319833993911743,
0.5873010158538818,
0.10689834505319595,
-0.7737773656845093,
-0.7265507578849792,
-0.6502735018730164,
-1.0361649990081787,
0.7302072048187256,
0.4649084210395813,
-0.14953705668449402,
-0.07770337909460068,
0.2738986909389496,
-0.029821330681443214,
0.5505342483520508,
-0.6493235230445862,
0.0719374343752861,
-0.12061423063278198,
-0.47333723306655884,
0.18611665070056915,
-0.16988347470760345,
0.006906544789671898,
-0.010438842698931694,
0.644135057926178,
-0.040887005627155304,
0.1761976033449173,
0.07928811758756638,
0.2493201196193695,
-0.347371369600296,
0.36723828315734863,
0.15826208889484406,
0.5757154226303101,
-0.7193283438682556,
-0.221359983086586,
-0.012363316491246223,
-0.2774369418621063,
0.051879193633794785,
0.4604162871837616,
0.08301489055156708,
-0.23361635208129883,
0.17701761424541473,
0.8614253401756287,
0.41513654589653015,
-0.7222602963447571,
0.4825994372367859,
-0.10100366920232773,
-0.1481974869966507,
-0.32046985626220703,
-0.29242533445358276,
-0.03695233166217804,
0.8675134778022766,
0.8553540110588074,
0.05466541275382042,
0.4019235670566559,
-0.6105432510375977,
0.1965942680835724,
0.24505850672721863,
-0.6024882197380066,
-0.5234376192092896,
0.5067979693412781,
0.3962435722351074,
-0.31481367349624634,
0.31728431582450867,
-0.438995361328125,
-0.8505882024765015,
0.6881174445152283,
0.06003032624721527,
1.7267190217971802,
-0.17395439743995667,
0.6706038117408752,
-0.14487379789352417,
0.3598781228065491,
0.10050436854362488,
0.6313656568527222,
0.1838611513376236,
-0.8746253252029419,
-0.4512661099433899,
-0.8459300398826599,
-0.6955326199531555,
0.11336446553468704,
-0.76176518201828,
0.22681744396686554,
-0.5492090582847595,
-0.6379575133323669,
0.21579109132289886,
-0.13535062968730927,
-0.6187058091163635,
0.2643321752548218,
0.2339412271976471,
0.6520079374313354,
-0.8860268592834473,
0.4714653193950653,
0.690841019153595,
-0.05037606135010719,
-0.8952951431274414,
0.37507164478302,
0.014496928080916405,
-0.4346112012863159,
0.30395689606666565,
0.37325409054756165,
-0.02005426585674286,
-0.430171400308609,
-0.2646736800670624,
-0.34127166867256165,
0.6976823210716248,
0.2801409959793091,
-0.5172713398933411,
-0.07015851140022278,
0.22567594051361084,
0.5259540677070618,
-0.43086153268814087,
0.01869584061205387,
0.5551691055297852,
0.42847004532814026,
0.18420441448688507,
-0.6184666156768799,
-0.246677428483963,
-0.34490492939949036,
-0.3716801404953003,
0.7374341487884521,
-0.6158336997032166,
0.46440571546554565,
0.12088306993246078,
-0.21791556477546692,
-0.5699594020843506,
0.8156645894050598,
-0.06454037129878998,
0.8534652590751648,
0.7594823241233826,
0.41766291856765747,
0.4810568392276764,
-0.2843228578567505,
0.8625565767288208,
-0.4350681006908417,
0.8353795409202576,
0.8119834661483765,
-0.2990669906139374,
1.3160256147384644,
0.4105868935585022,
-0.3131340742111206,
0.28177934885025024,
0.8661927580833435,
0.32711976766586304,
0.2696116268634796,
-0.13533999025821686,
-0.2473135143518448,
-0.23295430839061737,
-0.19720344245433807,
0.09969191998243332,
0.38148239254951477,
0.5968121886253357,
-0.1402834951877594,
-0.08747553825378418,
0.13535171747207642,
-0.11685919016599655,
-0.23210741579532623,
-0.3086795210838318,
0.6736540794372559,
0.19246076047420502,
-0.25880077481269836,
-0.45055922865867615,
-0.028075791895389557,
0.6303524374961853,
-0.5801166892051697,
0.40556252002716064,
-0.08434715867042542,
0.20488746464252472,
-0.11793556809425354,
-0.9535921812057495,
0.5816822052001953,
0.24296732246875763,
0.3386364281177521,
-0.29797661304473877,
0.8881583213806152,
-0.24164505302906036,
-0.7444535493850708,
0.4422506093978882,
0.27738577127456665,
-0.30808284878730774,
-0.6057993173599243,
-0.7062105536460876,
-0.29821258783340454,
0.1856839954853058,
-0.6824954152107239,
0.04143252968788147,
0.5922578573226929,
0.09495724737644196,
0.7047204971313477,
0.4957892894744873,
-0.10103588551282883,
-0.3977420926094055,
0.07037868350744247,
0.9503944516181946,
-0.964526355266571,
-0.8916405439376831,
-0.9743281006813049,
0.4856259524822235,
-0.31600162386894226,
-0.15990905463695526,
0.4426896274089813,
0.4611254632472992,
0.15334896743297577,
0.24240456521511078,
0.6016427278518677,
0.006879475899040699,
0.6350254416465759,
-0.29171261191368103,
0.6002440452575684,
-0.6576937437057495,
0.381148099899292,
-0.7050362229347229,
-0.9042906761169434,
-0.25725507736206055,
0.2741595506668091,
-0.6975511312484741,
-0.06105827912688255,
0.6344661712646484,
0.43374550342559814,
-0.10906170308589935,
0.37628090381622314,
-0.03849002718925476,
-0.03381174057722092,
0.4983840882778168,
0.3553828001022339,
0.3791751265525818,
-0.1457061916589737,
0.45769572257995605,
-0.6815721392631531,
-0.1835183948278427,
-0.6909264326095581,
-0.965345025062561,
-0.7125721573829651,
-0.5659474730491638,
-0.3620353937149048,
-0.4136277139186859,
-0.1725374013185501,
1.1176972389221191,
0.11988211423158646,
-0.9565280079841614,
-0.14437586069107056,
0.22220267355442047,
0.1176166981458664,
-0.01918453350663185,
-0.31186404824256897,
0.6463990211486816,
-0.17188501358032227,
-0.2988189160823822,
-0.10564298927783966,
0.9346287846565247,
0.11408000439405441,
-0.20909450948238373,
0.29204192757606506,
-0.13495604693889618,
0.389052152633667,
0.44834569096565247,
0.1983126401901245,
-0.4471553862094879,
-0.5461459159851074,
-0.041200190782547,
0.03636882081627846,
0.11508329212665558,
0.7090699076652527,
-0.11086080968379974,
0.25315865874290466,
0.35990747809410095,
0.5742773413658142,
0.35210978984832764,
0.2969706356525421,
0.38381773233413696,
-0.7117525935173035,
0.267748087644577,
0.44812002778053284,
0.4786452353000641,
0.1632741242647171,
-0.32510167360305786,
0.11332442611455917,
-0.07362699508666992,
-0.3281199336051941,
-0.5792173147201538,
-0.3940306305885315,
-1.1506396532058716,
-0.03191808983683586,
0.8648064732551575,
-0.06787275522947311,
-0.6662060618400574,
0.20124812424182892,
-0.22214442491531372,
0.22446104884147644,
-1.0089538097381592,
1.162611484527588,
0.670118510723114,
0.12350180000066757,
0.004896904341876507,
-0.5525124073028564,
0.33862870931625366,
0.2008618414402008,
-0.9920268058776855,
0.09898640215396881,
0.0019440768519416451,
-0.14865493774414062,
0.1642698347568512,
0.6143333315849304,
0.44597092270851135,
0.27688536047935486,
-0.22216938436031342,
0.23373231291770935,
0.26417815685272217,
-0.27352944016456604,
0.06984426081180573,
0.405379056930542,
-0.2793116271495819,
-0.4232621490955353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01337v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01337v1
|
Detection of Temporality at Discourse Level on Financial News by Combining Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning
| 2024-03-30T16:40:10 | 2024-03-30T16:40:10 |
Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Ana Barros-Vila, Francisco J. González-Castaño
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.IR, cs.LG, q-fin.ST
|
Finance-related news such as Bloomberg News, CNN Business and Forbes are
valuable sources of real data for market screening systems. In news, an expert
shares opinions beyond plain technical analyses that include context such as
political, sociological and cultural factors. In the same text, the expert
often discusses the performance of different assets. Some key statements are
mere descriptions of past events while others are predictions. Therefore,
understanding the temporality of the key statements in a text is essential to
separate context information from valuable predictions. We propose a novel
system to detect the temporality of finance-related news at discourse level
that combines Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning techniques, and
exploits sophisticated features such as syntactic and semantic dependencies.
More specifically, we seek to extract the dominant tenses of the main
statements, which may be either explicit or implicit. We have tested our system
on a labelled dataset of finance-related news annotated by researchers with
knowledge in the field. Experimental results reveal a high detection precision
compared to an alternative rule-based baseline approach. Ultimately, this
research contributes to the state-of-the-art of market screening by identifying
predictive knowledge for financial decision making.
|
[
-0.0035851048305630684,
-1.095240831375122,
0.6346303224563599,
0.49761348962783813,
-0.5125808119773865,
0.4846816658973694,
0.0008991500362753868,
-0.6687052845954895,
0.289036363363266,
0.4130566120147705,
-0.46943604946136475,
-0.6242393255233765,
-0.5059629678726196,
-0.18591301143169403,
-0.45064258575439453,
1.0949574708938599,
0.09395959228277206,
0.02276444062590599,
-0.04976288601756096,
-0.10862638801336288,
-0.179812952876091,
-0.3704611659049988,
-0.9420047998428345,
-0.23839379847049713,
0.14608797430992126,
0.03406604379415512,
0.8171452283859253,
0.587113082408905,
0.25410205125808716,
0.34404000639915466,
-0.2684404253959656,
-0.09352628886699677,
0.20652790367603302,
0.2364387959241867,
-0.14957170188426971,
-0.3334018886089325,
-0.5001227259635925,
0.13790804147720337,
0.6295455098152161,
0.5406986474990845,
0.09627335518598557,
0.1859249472618103,
0.17801475524902344,
0.6379848122596741,
-0.5568775534629822,
0.61216801404953,
-0.581446647644043,
0.32890379428863525,
-0.4020601809024811,
-0.4911249279975891,
-0.40765580534935,
-0.3968329429626465,
0.24799573421478271,
-0.46153244376182556,
0.07651662081480026,
0.02778853289783001,
1.1764079332351685,
0.20069120824337006,
-0.7534853219985962,
-0.14608123898506165,
-0.8377372026443481,
0.5827071666717529,
-0.6762561798095703,
0.35366344451904297,
0.48974609375,
0.5115405917167664,
0.10791979730129242,
-0.6516149640083313,
-0.5467419028282166,
-0.1269010305404663,
-0.3242371678352356,
0.12473820894956589,
-0.47282400727272034,
-0.1721886247396469,
0.15089736878871918,
0.14278613030910492,
-0.5962170958518982,
0.10370411723852158,
-0.3412315249443054,
-0.5329283475875854,
0.09594378620386124,
-0.08039975166320801,
-0.10198506712913513,
-0.3618086278438568,
-0.3156128525733948,
0.16993257403373718,
-0.40237995982170105,
0.24050162732601166,
0.40334028005599976,
0.1466466784477234,
-0.12941622734069824,
0.32592400908470154,
-0.17930714786052704,
0.4929019510746002,
0.05546386539936066,
-0.3362988531589508,
0.14254717528820038,
-0.4233967065811157,
-0.22996431589126587,
0.2596219480037689,
0.46490004658699036,
0.21013979613780975,
0.08124974370002747,
0.07276313006877899,
-0.11764836311340332,
0.06421833485364914,
-0.013369947671890259,
-0.5742239356040955,
0.12653127312660217,
0.13165350258350372,
-0.5381063222885132,
-0.41371068358421326,
0.06291542202234268,
-0.8087435364723206,
-0.12651360034942627,
-0.3595505356788635,
-0.047149039804935455,
-0.3073963224887848,
-0.0829964429140091,
-0.11692886054515839,
-0.27937206625938416,
0.5134077668190002,
-0.003144453978165984,
-0.4189099669456482,
0.18432828783988953,
0.7633610367774963,
0.7811915874481201,
0.2882590591907501,
0.06369511038064957,
-0.8401334881782532,
0.4114076495170593,
-0.27420246601104736,
0.8503748178482056,
-0.4848988652229309,
-0.24693328142166138,
-0.12852074205875397,
-0.07834797352552414,
0.09985439479351044,
-0.34673359990119934,
0.6080453991889954,
-0.7261225581169128,
0.43031907081604004,
0.23896950483322144,
-0.5102810859680176,
0.0431133471429348,
0.34995001554489136,
-0.6757834553718567,
0.8088064193725586,
-0.04127199947834015,
-0.8283231258392334,
1.0346219539642334,
-0.6677330732345581,
-0.7116127014160156,
0.05603881925344467,
-0.15679240226745605,
-0.8386766910552979,
-0.288481742143631,
0.7108563184738159,
0.2769412398338318,
0.09224122017621994,
0.8198879957199097,
-0.2730221152305603,
-0.0500296875834465,
0.6822815537452698,
-0.712009847164154,
0.5432822704315186,
0.1998535841703415,
-0.48471611738204956,
0.021002642810344696,
-0.8841565251350403,
-0.4011213183403015,
0.043748416006565094,
-0.052836623042821884,
-0.4429360032081604,
0.33256763219833374,
-0.02150939777493477,
0.09944310039281845,
0.31534767150878906,
-0.4825049638748169,
0.08545419573783875,
-0.49099257588386536,
0.5856567025184631,
0.8969019055366516,
0.3378940224647522,
0.475150465965271,
-0.3698634207248688,
0.4028167426586151,
0.30702000856399536,
0.38205716013908386,
-0.3273419737815857,
-0.16585633158683777,
-0.6457346081733704,
-0.21712026000022888,
0.35665854811668396,
0.7195166945457458,
-0.5717577338218689,
0.40807968378067017,
-0.014662381261587143,
-0.13896653056144714,
-0.0623091422021389,
-0.13988929986953735,
0.10279697179794312,
0.47073501348495483,
0.1283332258462906,
0.14417506754398346,
-0.8603296279907227,
-0.9923915863037109,
-0.6381931304931641,
-0.2817896008491516,
-0.05153850093483925,
0.11841613054275513,
0.3899148106575012,
0.02420252189040184,
1.3231291770935059,
-0.7173105478286743,
-0.21463541686534882,
-0.03343107923865318,
0.6031994819641113,
0.4826146960258484,
0.2956202030181885,
0.6774767637252808,
-1.1353013515472412,
-0.07503501325845718,
0.06831671297550201,
-0.4485921859741211,
-0.02867160364985466,
-0.5634494423866272,
0.1579475849866867,
0.4594889283180237,
0.8366987705230713,
-0.09187443554401398,
0.5629446506500244,
0.2836610972881317,
-0.6318939328193665,
0.29066404700279236,
-0.12788937985897064,
0.019292399287223816,
-1.0440622568130493,
0.08415454626083374,
0.27299609780311584,
-0.5823903679847717,
-0.21756862103939056,
-0.5844569802284241,
-0.07421443611383438,
-0.1763710379600525,
-0.08686819672584534,
0.7102758288383484,
-0.24842894077301025,
-0.23146972060203552,
-0.23796717822551727,
0.20082910358905792,
0.07032068818807602,
0.5510645508766174,
0.039729416370391846,
0.5511412620544434,
0.20447196066379547,
-0.5393993258476257,
-0.0973333939909935,
-0.20905862748622894,
-0.5142611861228943,
0.5208098888397217,
-0.5915541052818298,
-0.09597403556108475,
-0.11153697222471237,
0.37918880581855774,
-0.99271160364151,
-0.02376643940806389,
0.30614402890205383,
-0.6063224077224731,
0.08855254203081131,
-0.3888225555419922,
-0.346516877412796,
-0.2799287736415863,
-0.1644163429737091,
0.07197607308626175,
0.22882412374019623,
-0.20799733698368073,
0.6176550984382629,
0.5558379292488098,
-0.5866237282752991,
-0.7301595211029053,
-0.5206816792488098,
0.21818716824054718,
-0.16184550523757935,
-0.5717725157737732,
0.4069625437259674,
0.3909417688846588,
-0.3920322358608246,
0.20945607125759125,
-0.4141668677330017,
-0.2770478427410126,
0.42389512062072754,
0.22745858132839203,
0.9675843715667725,
-0.16052906215190887,
0.10595358908176422,
0.3687083125114441,
-0.3498390316963196,
0.13527056574821472,
-0.7310400009155273,
0.3861681818962097,
-0.1580117642879486,
-0.048497945070266724,
-0.5295091271400452,
0.18487700819969177,
0.6825050115585327,
-0.24867166578769684,
0.9221186637878418,
0.5842388272285461,
-0.5129666924476624,
0.10821463912725449,
-0.5254920721054077,
0.06013643741607666,
-0.4589109420776367,
-0.06895636767148972,
-0.0467953085899353,
-0.9843642711639404,
0.6488493084907532,
0.08253922313451767,
0.12847661972045898,
0.8639511466026306,
0.2780543267726898,
-0.0033353036269545555,
1.0209753513336182,
0.5896013975143433,
-0.2918740212917328,
0.8762361407279968,
-0.14253228902816772,
0.26723524928092957,
-0.03001582622528076,
-0.2179051637649536,
-0.47969603538513184,
-0.48601841926574707,
-0.41199633479118347,
-0.010635830461978912,
0.37634849548339844,
-0.18188689649105072,
-0.1785680204629898,
0.13559283316135406,
-0.025750702247023582,
0.5395642518997192,
0.4098476469516754,
0.06792942434549332,
0.5487192273139954,
-0.2518705129623413,
-0.27617624402046204,
-0.12848202884197235,
-0.1301720291376114,
-0.5384435653686523,
0.8451471924781799,
0.3363019526004791,
0.330267995595932,
-0.1852697730064392,
0.2140612006187439,
0.7059715390205383,
0.1870557963848114,
-0.5590669512748718,
0.3795018792152405,
-0.11571003496646881,
-0.39325544238090515,
-0.10959700495004654,
-0.6844307780265808,
-0.8563503623008728,
-0.2258627861738205,
-0.24267621338367462,
-0.566611647605896,
0.31789469718933105,
-0.19823315739631653,
-0.605799674987793,
0.22983399033546448,
-0.33402538299560547,
0.7902700901031494,
-0.0755334123969078,
-0.09186365455389023,
-0.18570342659950256,
-0.6704643368721008,
0.267350435256958,
-0.11034718155860901,
0.537223219871521,
-0.29447194933891296,
-0.16436463594436646,
0.9254763722419739,
-0.3243696689605713,
1.0720036029815674,
-0.22918279469013214,
-0.043449223041534424,
0.13032066822052002,
-0.07961294800043106,
0.4932423233985901,
0.47517091035842896,
0.327822208404541,
-0.09605849534273148,
0.04668812081217766,
-0.49540749192237854,
-0.43906697630882263,
0.436484158039093,
-0.45229798555374146,
-0.3036089241504669,
-0.6509353518486023,
-0.4145556390285492,
-0.2588411271572113,
0.025085385888814926,
0.09209936112165451,
0.3392593562602997,
-0.5284571647644043,
0.05294521152973175,
0.16213387250900269,
0.06016207113862038,
0.5997219681739807,
0.711728572845459,
-0.25584182143211365,
-0.3962746262550354,
0.7115552425384521,
0.1802108883857727,
-0.3236532211303711,
0.5343744158744812,
0.4053530693054199,
-0.2031334936618805,
-0.3437449038028717,
-0.06583639234304428,
0.027108533307909966,
-0.3115377426147461,
-0.22589263319969177,
-0.6909452080726624,
-0.27432408928871155,
-0.7291081547737122,
-0.2136232554912567,
-0.3039969801902771,
-0.7071619033813477,
-0.2852665185928345,
-0.35876473784446716,
0.39406323432922363,
0.36046433448791504,
-0.1282828450202942,
0.18589502573013306,
-0.9417877197265625,
0.38049688935279846,
0.44874781370162964,
0.09862643480300903,
-0.3654899001121521,
-0.3604256808757782,
-0.31407928466796875,
-0.066746786236763,
-0.33622732758522034,
-0.7353535890579224,
0.6282383799552917,
0.27454760670661926,
0.4799021780490875,
0.7703449726104736,
0.027418050915002823,
0.28481608629226685,
0.020210247486829758,
0.6293725371360779,
-0.16007445752620697,
-1.0908252000808716,
0.9792085289955139,
-0.3609549105167389,
0.35427096486091614,
0.3902246356010437,
0.3997493088245392,
-0.720965564250946,
-0.8564116954803467,
-0.6758973002433777,
-0.881162703037262,
0.5361656546592712,
0.17366057634353638,
-0.31780847907066345,
-0.05563703179359436,
0.28960466384887695,
0.26687052845954895,
0.2255692481994629,
-0.6951348185539246,
-0.08715317398309708,
0.019698211923241615,
0.04866953194141388,
0.2606263756752014,
-0.28591281175613403,
-0.00555458664894104,
-0.16344860196113586,
0.6266515851020813,
-0.14145199954509735,
-0.009838564321398735,
0.028094498440623283,
-0.134587824344635,
0.0795597955584526,
0.5373306274414062,
0.4356321394443512,
0.7879680395126343,
-0.28307875990867615,
-0.08045291900634766,
-0.11730937659740448,
-0.4110622704029083,
0.019600531086325645,
0.41508859395980835,
-0.24713170528411865,
0.2426801472902298,
0.44396939873695374,
0.6302131414413452,
0.669325590133667,
-0.6374606490135193,
0.5884374380111694,
-0.2003745138645172,
-0.19211313128471375,
-0.7362095713615417,
-0.39652952551841736,
-0.28535351157188416,
0.6533960700035095,
0.7949857711791992,
0.41865813732147217,
0.2384066879749298,
-0.8481181859970093,
0.4502842426300049,
0.026101063936948776,
-0.37860116362571716,
-0.3225648105144501,
0.7479718327522278,
0.1139296442270279,
0.07892642170190811,
0.5826310515403748,
-0.2803094983100891,
-0.6966227293014526,
0.7355945110321045,
0.3251350522041321,
1.0832290649414062,
0.009779727086424828,
0.4741970896720886,
0.08773122727870941,
0.09979261457920074,
-0.05278463289141655,
0.26443272829055786,
-0.1615295112133026,
-0.6764853596687317,
-0.7719053626060486,
-0.5512518882751465,
-0.3727076053619385,
-0.0438070073723793,
-0.8146781325340271,
0.2656400799751282,
-0.533578634262085,
-0.5984590649604797,
0.317270427942276,
0.035001739859580994,
-0.45871639251708984,
-0.11853257566690445,
0.26720282435417175,
0.6749259233474731,
-0.8367488384246826,
0.6668393015861511,
0.3087196946144104,
-0.019263263791799545,
-0.1480134129524231,
0.1764734983444214,
0.2833248972892761,
-0.508805513381958,
0.8798388242721558,
0.118991419672966,
0.07775713503360748,
-0.4909040927886963,
-0.4383777379989624,
-0.4545675814151764,
1.034924864768982,
0.5093746781349182,
-0.4049511253833771,
-0.4311540424823761,
-0.20758503675460815,
0.36065298318862915,
-0.24537500739097595,
-0.2386658489704132,
0.6286561489105225,
0.6996098756790161,
0.3001905381679535,
-0.8666383624076843,
-0.416279137134552,
-0.41484683752059937,
-0.4790663719177246,
0.5922024846076965,
-0.35091257095336914,
0.762567937374115,
-0.0031601209193468094,
-0.6036996841430664,
-0.13328605890274048,
1.0654239654541016,
-0.03711795061826706,
0.9687527418136597,
0.6213724613189697,
0.25406938791275024,
0.8820680975914001,
-0.2975282371044159,
0.868975818157196,
-0.5242070555686951,
0.27625590562820435,
1.0350440740585327,
-0.2670780420303345,
0.7060133814811707,
0.29389992356300354,
-0.1992679089307785,
0.6880533695220947,
0.49591490626335144,
0.07824461907148361,
0.2895238995552063,
0.049686744809150696,
-0.29691049456596375,
-0.25688305497169495,
-0.2697618007659912,
-0.12382050603628159,
0.6690533757209778,
0.5540999174118042,
-0.4259757995605469,
-0.16136208176612854,
0.2637174129486084,
0.29331979155540466,
0.04588571563363075,
-0.2785731852054596,
0.7069615125656128,
0.06514623016119003,
-0.5568324327468872,
-0.25137239694595337,
0.02188354730606079,
0.5804777145385742,
-0.7206293940544128,
0.14480862021446228,
-0.2739901840686798,
0.27733877301216125,
0.0997621938586235,
-0.7757282257080078,
0.6617363691329956,
0.10645025223493576,
-0.17184686660766602,
-0.40509796142578125,
0.7576892971992493,
-0.24138139188289642,
-0.5882085561752319,
0.16812515258789062,
0.5992978811264038,
-0.2603914737701416,
-0.21814170479774475,
-0.48130497336387634,
-0.4415931701660156,
-0.2924599349498749,
-0.11212515830993652,
0.11544448137283325,
0.5854789614677429,
0.04540923982858658,
0.5776815414428711,
0.6404163837432861,
-0.027830924838781357,
-0.3115057945251465,
-0.04587845876812935,
0.8032956123352051,
-0.9147502183914185,
-0.9615828990936279,
-0.9930960536003113,
-0.12336865067481995,
-0.3949177861213684,
-0.3894692063331604,
0.6083688139915466,
0.7448236346244812,
0.6342443227767944,
0.3729831874370575,
0.3794107139110565,
0.4347969889640808,
0.519981861114502,
-0.8682904839515686,
0.6588801145553589,
-0.2506873309612274,
0.45618337392807007,
-0.12395261228084564,
-0.5619752407073975,
-0.3434683680534363,
0.2943713963031769,
-0.588977575302124,
-0.2169923484325409,
0.7305183410644531,
0.3347281217575073,
0.1589399129152298,
0.4409582316875458,
0.03311675041913986,
0.18799452483654022,
0.14690138399600983,
0.39375388622283936,
0.7244641780853271,
-0.10348869860172272,
0.8925468921661377,
-0.2544947564601898,
-0.014783306047320366,
-0.4030172824859619,
-0.9918216466903687,
-0.7775977849960327,
-0.776390016078949,
-0.5425336956977844,
-0.24909532070159912,
0.15084199607372284,
0.5634526610374451,
0.30949723720550537,
-0.5626678466796875,
-0.0904330313205719,
0.29673686623573303,
0.2435518354177475,
-0.5135069489479065,
-0.33093127608299255,
0.5095519423484802,
-0.20334719121456146,
-0.543255627155304,
0.5389425158500671,
0.7263831496238708,
0.25206974148750305,
-0.1419297307729721,
0.409511536359787,
-0.18991313874721527,
0.15738913416862488,
0.48915472626686096,
0.3108697831630707,
-0.17514823377132416,
-0.28305375576019287,
0.1373848170042038,
-0.09860166907310486,
-0.02384048141539097,
1.2754276990890503,
-1.024537444114685,
0.10625958442687988,
0.5094632506370544,
0.4097289443016052,
0.684382438659668,
-0.22766412794589996,
0.6950488686561584,
-0.903755247592926,
0.36601826548576355,
0.3352809250354767,
0.5360283851623535,
-0.11214939504861832,
-0.45385780930519104,
0.3874530792236328,
0.36751502752304077,
-0.46709293127059937,
-0.4000944197177887,
0.016847889870405197,
-0.9360849857330322,
-0.605572521686554,
0.6291558146476746,
0.051103148609399796,
-0.5407321453094482,
-0.45084014534950256,
-0.08976592123508453,
0.3271976113319397,
-0.6825441718101501,
0.6515447497367859,
0.7073788046836853,
0.25196585059165955,
0.11107426881790161,
-0.6476700305938721,
0.23856136202812195,
0.1649155169725418,
-0.5195319652557373,
-0.04520150274038315,
0.38053178787231445,
-0.12444642931222916,
0.052879445254802704,
0.6136441230773926,
-0.16888391971588135,
0.43578365445137024,
0.08505944907665253,
-0.6031349301338196,
-0.12789052724838257,
-0.1787659227848053,
-0.11651484668254852,
0.38899463415145874,
-0.4649163484573364,
-0.20350699126720428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00406v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00406v1
|
TACO -- Twitter Arguments from COnversations
| 2024-03-30T16:14:46 | 2024-03-30T16:14:46 |
Marc Feger, Stefan Dietze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Twitter has emerged as a global hub for engaging in online conversations and
as a research corpus for various disciplines that have recognized the
significance of its user-generated content. Argument mining is an important
analytical task for processing and understanding online discourse.
Specifically, it aims to identify the structural elements of arguments, denoted
as information and inference. These elements, however, are not static and may
require context within the conversation they are in, yet there is a lack of
data and annotation frameworks addressing this dynamic aspect on Twitter. We
contribute TACO, the first dataset of Twitter Arguments utilizing 1,814 tweets
covering 200 entire conversations spanning six heterogeneous topics annotated
with an agreement of 0.718 Krippendorff's alpha among six experts. Second, we
provide our annotation framework, incorporating definitions from the Cambridge
Dictionary, to define and identify argument components on Twitter. Our
transformer-based classifier achieves an 85.06\% macro F1 baseline score in
detecting arguments. Moreover, our data reveals that Twitter users tend to
engage in discussions involving informed inferences and information. TACO
serves multiple purposes, such as training tweet classifiers to manage tweets
based on inference and information elements, while also providing valuable
insights into the conversational reply patterns of tweets.
|
[
-0.4844704568386078,
-1.1840250492095947,
0.47932878136634827,
0.291745662689209,
-0.395761638879776,
0.38647282123565674,
-0.09684287756681442,
-0.4413434565067291,
0.40370339155197144,
0.1395513266324997,
-0.43925824761390686,
-0.48085445165634155,
-0.4482014775276184,
0.1391322910785675,
-0.4581605792045593,
1.0326963663101196,
0.09875396639108658,
-0.11094269901514053,
0.10224545747041702,
-0.21517573297023773,
-0.18684707581996918,
-0.09149704873561859,
-0.9424989819526672,
-0.02638532966375351,
1.0783096551895142,
0.6593402624130249,
0.6343651413917542,
0.6394674777984619,
-0.151597797870636,
0.33435261249542236,
0.13261736929416656,
0.2418481856584549,
-0.23777924478054047,
0.26739370822906494,
-0.4149152934551239,
-0.022338317707180977,
-0.05565466731786728,
-0.3674924075603485,
0.3397601842880249,
0.4988744854927063,
0.06775633990764618,
0.2138473242521286,
-0.20984241366386414,
0.08386080712080002,
-0.5876222848892212,
-0.14097003638744354,
-0.8283309936523438,
0.004785703029483557,
-0.2721380889415741,
-0.5037182569503784,
-0.32310304045677185,
-0.7263951301574707,
0.0038968247827142477,
-0.5092082023620605,
0.12593092024326324,
-0.05257750675082207,
1.2370191812515259,
0.10589579492807388,
-0.38395652174949646,
-0.3503952622413635,
-0.7356804609298706,
0.5527616143226624,
-0.4285998046398163,
0.06024597957730293,
0.21883754432201385,
0.4454147517681122,
-0.04255453124642372,
-0.9502540230751038,
-0.6058027148246765,
0.31972968578338623,
0.09677933156490326,
0.14076197147369385,
-0.30166998505592346,
-0.04164471477270126,
0.21113979816436768,
0.2593887746334076,
0.14156335592269897,
0.10868288576602936,
-0.295126348733902,
-0.14356566965579987,
0.3369539678096771,
0.014616460539400578,
0.2679385840892792,
-0.07831555604934692,
-0.566740870475769,
-0.07673481106758118,
-0.20010727643966675,
0.04146892577409744,
0.5233211517333984,
0.03271113336086273,
-0.2108382284641266,
0.3744736313819885,
0.08212263882160187,
0.42168715596199036,
-0.04880679026246071,
0.3186705708503723,
-0.15008804202079773,
-0.06778836995363235,
-0.3445269763469696,
-0.06476262956857681,
1.3187472820281982,
0.5446051359176636,
0.39932113885879517,
-0.16576747596263885,
0.13770610094070435,
-0.14398914575576782,
0.29282549023628235,
-0.7133455872535706,
-0.16074839234352112,
0.4902955889701843,
-0.25926628708839417,
-0.46826472878456116,
0.3940427899360657,
-1.0072587728500366,
-0.77500981092453,
0.37085840106010437,
-0.005426719784736633,
-0.1625707447528839,
-0.4691561758518219,
-0.2062889039516449,
-0.622718870639801,
0.36991292238235474,
0.43642911314964294,
-0.8268811106681824,
0.3646998703479767,
0.7754305005073547,
1.0381056070327759,
0.17521384358406067,
0.03825438767671585,
-0.2870784401893616,
0.18622197210788727,
-0.7154724597930908,
1.4969626665115356,
-0.7296133637428284,
-0.2742488980293274,
0.30707019567489624,
0.11029846221208572,
0.12036941200494766,
-0.27785927057266235,
1.072108507156372,
-0.3649958670139313,
0.3089355230331421,
-0.8206689357757568,
-0.6110689043998718,
-0.08906523883342743,
0.24363718926906586,
-0.7829585671424866,
0.9541372656822205,
0.07762371003627777,
-1.0008310079574585,
0.7280297875404358,
-1.2812787294387817,
-0.5288811326026917,
0.5623138546943665,
-0.2934197187423706,
-0.11729715019464493,
0.16287551820278168,
0.2867520749568939,
0.45852845907211304,
-0.7477023005485535,
0.15748737752437592,
-0.36381885409355164,
-0.20222534239292145,
0.19278950989246368,
0.047346487641334534,
0.9714715480804443,
0.3624880611896515,
-0.2742271423339844,
0.10011085867881775,
-0.1759849190711975,
-0.0248282290995121,
0.37618064880371094,
0.13225284218788147,
-0.28934764862060547,
0.29231178760528564,
0.21047736704349518,
0.025458620861172676,
-0.21256236732006073,
-0.9086839556694031,
0.050596848130226135,
-0.3930300176143646,
1.0505902767181396,
0.7062912583351135,
0.5796729326248169,
0.08511441946029663,
-0.2929132282733917,
0.43952104449272156,
0.07075237482786179,
0.2010386884212494,
-0.20679499208927155,
-0.6005032658576965,
-0.4552641212940216,
0.026715898886322975,
0.4496556520462036,
0.26041924953460693,
-0.7189550995826721,
0.13167516887187958,
-0.3413906991481781,
-0.47458407282829285,
-0.5629463195800781,
-0.4258757531642914,
-0.12959344685077667,
0.5915037989616394,
0.18397781252861023,
0.3851628601551056,
-0.9391143321990967,
-1.1078156232833862,
-0.527556836605072,
-0.2172217071056366,
-0.04915520176291466,
0.10937736183404922,
0.3059453070163727,
0.02894689328968525,
1.113513469696045,
-0.22029811143875122,
0.15095315873622894,
-0.11791887879371643,
0.2024369239807129,
-0.11301199346780777,
0.10067207366228104,
0.7204905152320862,
-0.7111027240753174,
-0.6976696252822876,
0.34857216477394104,
-0.5890955328941345,
-0.23227721452713013,
-0.20342323184013367,
-0.28733453154563904,
0.1585361361503601,
0.32909202575683594,
-0.3152167797088623,
0.24950487911701202,
0.15542997419834137,
-0.30674469470977783,
0.06344936043024063,
0.5234690308570862,
0.44167959690093994,
-1.4919872283935547,
-0.2994759678840637,
0.406869113445282,
-0.4630061686038971,
-0.5104082226753235,
-0.4326074421405792,
-0.3045816719532013,
0.30579861998558044,
-0.4092548191547394,
0.7940731644630432,
0.09535925090312958,
0.5094801783561707,
-0.2503361999988556,
-0.3267896771430969,
0.05541396141052246,
0.020340345799922943,
-0.03425084799528122,
0.6732419729232788,
0.4027717709541321,
-0.2423151731491089,
0.4367223083972931,
-0.06647728383541107,
-0.340433806180954,
0.3681769073009491,
-0.8332093358039856,
0.3298777639865875,
0.4762173593044281,
0.29532885551452637,
-1.2259787321090698,
-0.42136630415916443,
0.42803552746772766,
-0.5763323903083801,
-0.4419848322868347,
-0.4467775523662567,
-0.8182963132858276,
-0.24030059576034546,
-0.5894219279289246,
0.12281954288482666,
0.02020805887877941,
-0.6092426180839539,
0.7325538992881775,
0.7838608026504517,
0.1707434207201004,
-0.5795313119888306,
-0.634279191493988,
0.4519239664077759,
-0.5679382681846619,
-0.444454550743103,
0.42921677231788635,
0.27704858779907227,
-0.4710598289966583,
0.10074055939912796,
-0.008128131739795208,
-0.25014224648475647,
0.14442305266857147,
0.4420657455921173,
-0.17793165147304535,
-0.13514277338981628,
0.2297067642211914,
0.14203350245952606,
-0.003923709504306316,
0.40914565324783325,
-0.2470727264881134,
0.7472234964370728,
-0.2903697192668915,
0.16639599204063416,
-0.33184337615966797,
0.5474082231521606,
0.4496321380138397,
0.415730744600296,
0.8442823886871338,
0.8126060962677002,
-0.6866312026977539,
-0.22821566462516785,
-0.7601432204246521,
-0.06254410743713379,
-0.45793288946151733,
0.08512861281633377,
-0.3282385766506195,
-0.6667211651802063,
0.875342071056366,
-0.15849608182907104,
0.5879598259925842,
0.7601751685142517,
0.781201958656311,
-0.40048733353614807,
0.7598822116851807,
0.06040516868233681,
0.2407533973455429,
0.5977283716201782,
-0.1466555893421173,
0.21383801102638245,
-0.22339355945587158,
-0.2181895673274994,
-0.6040613055229187,
-0.28501075506210327,
-0.7326782941818237,
-0.1953420639038086,
-0.32380059361457825,
-0.5660589933395386,
-0.3402723968029022,
0.3331562876701355,
-0.3820764422416687,
0.6980037689208984,
0.22138699889183044,
-0.014116900973021984,
-0.04498327523469925,
0.0966387391090393,
-0.06622336059808731,
-0.010422475636005402,
-0.6542154550552368,
-0.895319402217865,
0.6791037321090698,
0.6346312761306763,
0.3840855658054352,
-0.0606829971075058,
0.5219440460205078,
0.8980309963226318,
0.4272681176662445,
-0.9906664490699768,
0.4756273329257965,
0.2466011643409729,
-0.734856903553009,
0.014559687115252018,
-0.5773388743400574,
-0.8944888710975647,
-0.1535244733095169,
-0.35348910093307495,
-0.7876569628715515,
-0.1262940913438797,
-0.11995469033718109,
-0.4135008454322815,
0.734094500541687,
-1.1890140771865845,
0.9915235638618469,
-0.03274141624569893,
-0.6064921617507935,
0.14343015849590302,
-0.32733622193336487,
0.3058411478996277,
0.1740400195121765,
0.22119735181331635,
-0.0007223692955449224,
-0.12427836656570435,
1.0644479990005493,
-0.6121723055839539,
0.6809078454971313,
-0.36882466077804565,
-0.050013549625873566,
0.5895097851753235,
-0.15395410358905792,
-0.18676349520683289,
0.3033325672149658,
-0.049671825021505356,
0.17979717254638672,
0.322946697473526,
-0.4544353485107422,
-0.38705936074256897,
0.7109066247940063,
-0.5850055813789368,
-0.538895308971405,
-0.2783839702606201,
-0.22545446455478668,
-0.1828562170267105,
-0.01947985589504242,
0.3768274486064911,
0.19347721338272095,
-0.20469917356967926,
0.561690628528595,
0.11188904941082001,
0.041692137718200684,
0.8207012414932251,
-0.29146555066108704,
0.21714560687541962,
-0.6518386602401733,
0.7729790806770325,
0.019932890310883522,
-0.17698487639427185,
0.4158506393432617,
0.9383092522621155,
-0.5227609276771545,
-0.38643142580986023,
-0.3641729950904846,
-0.18479958176612854,
-0.6751168370246887,
-0.42407768964767456,
-0.8484985828399658,
0.09286224842071533,
-0.19833707809448242,
-0.16028213500976562,
-0.5053498148918152,
-0.5509864687919617,
0.1651799976825714,
-0.2581103444099426,
0.6581410765647888,
0.8879377245903015,
0.23224127292633057,
0.392133504152298,
-0.4842163324356079,
0.0648660957813263,
0.02183958701789379,
0.44638490676879883,
0.09248445928096771,
-0.10262467712163925,
-0.35316526889801025,
0.06915634125471115,
-0.3957189917564392,
-1.1126044988632202,
-0.05295046418905258,
0.00818590447306633,
0.21417729556560516,
0.5986317992210388,
0.3625774681568146,
0.8864732980728149,
0.0075996979139745235,
0.8125958442687988,
0.13710825145244598,
-0.8372684717178345,
0.6287248730659485,
-0.41462376713752747,
-0.14485013484954834,
0.545269787311554,
0.3142150938510895,
-0.45947468280792236,
-0.35090768337249756,
-0.8332075476646423,
-0.8321852684020996,
0.6014261245727539,
0.13938985764980316,
0.051798004657030106,
-0.6293861865997314,
0.25206446647644043,
0.1850246787071228,
-0.07221861183643341,
-0.8151223063468933,
0.09014707803726196,
-0.3549303710460663,
-0.14017929136753082,
0.7482411861419678,
-0.09119191765785217,
-0.38606059551239014,
-0.31210950016975403,
0.22213441133499146,
0.0032955300994217396,
0.29402652382850647,
-0.06756332516670227,
0.1450190246105194,
-0.1380673497915268,
0.19737829267978668,
0.6950538754463196,
0.7361637949943542,
-0.13520044088363647,
0.06779544800519943,
0.33881285786628723,
-0.27226656675338745,
-0.23422296345233917,
-0.09743225574493408,
0.10066119581460953,
0.20873162150382996,
0.4171088635921478,
0.5619615912437439,
-0.03489169478416443,
-0.3778764605522156,
0.3369115889072418,
-0.5192244648933411,
-0.42375919222831726,
-0.518903374671936,
-0.018510567024350166,
0.2917782962322235,
0.24415917694568634,
0.6073993444442749,
-0.018592827022075653,
-0.14276200532913208,
-0.770067036151886,
0.04025238752365112,
0.18742035329341888,
-0.39034703373908997,
-0.4145749807357788,
0.5744954943656921,
0.281389981508255,
-0.42590096592903137,
-0.018457457423210144,
0.03382004797458649,
-0.45188796520233154,
0.4886549711227417,
0.18160410225391388,
1.0363717079162598,
0.05529726296663284,
0.19138938188552856,
0.43959686160087585,
0.02088012546300888,
0.09567856043577194,
0.10554413497447968,
-0.3418755829334259,
-0.7785382270812988,
-0.29933130741119385,
-0.10834924876689911,
-0.6034276485443115,
0.21893857419490814,
-0.41410550475120544,
0.5040013194084167,
-0.9020619988441467,
-0.4376305639743805,
0.3563306927680969,
0.2502914369106293,
-0.5577731728553772,
-0.04791419208049774,
0.0182354599237442,
0.8023579716682434,
-1.0283437967300415,
0.6158461570739746,
0.8572672009468079,
-0.4661235213279724,
-0.4490233063697815,
0.30036821961402893,
-0.20585006475448608,
-0.4937622845172882,
0.2614404559135437,
0.06235615164041519,
-0.4370344281196594,
-0.19544126093387604,
-0.8088177442550659,
0.16279301047325134,
0.7686997056007385,
0.5754200220108032,
-0.04682665690779686,
0.03497716784477234,
0.15594404935836792,
0.5393751859664917,
-0.6553546786308289,
0.7943815588951111,
0.2892357110977173,
0.4361790716648102,
0.4003547132015228,
-0.421215683221817,
0.1115134209394455,
-0.3322993814945221,
-0.2076064944267273,
0.07112336158752441,
-0.5697376728057861,
0.5146005153656006,
-0.18781840801239014,
-0.5966800451278687,
-0.5086097717285156,
0.503085196018219,
-0.04504290223121643,
0.4624195694923401,
0.7986270189285278,
0.3785173296928406,
0.5829285383224487,
-0.4665256142616272,
1.0091111660003662,
-0.16273826360702515,
0.31356266140937805,
0.8953762650489807,
-0.11219149827957153,
0.6811721324920654,
0.5337203145027161,
0.14408177137374878,
0.5920822620391846,
1.1201539039611816,
0.056365784257650375,
0.15385326743125916,
-0.17781278491020203,
-0.11143702268600464,
-0.33015701174736023,
-0.5873258113861084,
-0.28452178835868835,
0.3806404769420624,
0.5786932706832886,
-0.2814830243587494,
-0.30226773023605347,
-0.3706640601158142,
0.34558334946632385,
0.294899582862854,
0.06065652519464493,
0.9336913228034973,
-0.18296116590499878,
-0.5875164270401001,
0.3540511727333069,
-0.11652592569589615,
0.282419890165329,
-0.11593916267156601,
-0.010756555944681168,
-0.20632493495941162,
-0.22336040437221527,
-0.6513371467590332,
-1.128059983253479,
0.43555083870887756,
0.4828239679336548,
0.1591118574142456,
-0.28988829255104065,
0.49722811579704285,
0.0814443975687027,
-0.28703024983406067,
0.31603720784187317,
0.5132673382759094,
-0.11010037362575531,
-0.015734286978840828,
-0.6319122314453125,
0.0636180117726326,
-0.19609495997428894,
-0.22577987611293793,
-0.1276780217885971,
0.8392549157142639,
-0.04192851856350899,
0.3920145332813263,
0.5724403858184814,
-0.14803187549114227,
0.027437692508101463,
0.4625578820705414,
1.0590449571609497,
-0.7769100069999695,
-0.4363463819026947,
-1.2581735849380493,
0.5387889742851257,
-0.6303020119667053,
-0.4333261251449585,
0.4387575387954712,
0.6661276817321777,
0.5949290990829468,
0.109112948179245,
0.7281769514083862,
-0.30866119265556335,
0.6501645445823669,
-0.18526390194892883,
0.5221606492996216,
-0.4247674345970154,
0.30925679206848145,
-0.2274221032857895,
-0.6741986870765686,
-0.30239927768707275,
0.7110819220542908,
-0.30669158697128296,
0.16124428808689117,
0.8519735932350159,
0.2278819978237152,
-0.11200808733701706,
0.4557960033416748,
-0.03263647109270096,
0.012018849141895771,
0.8159950971603394,
0.48679813742637634,
1.09238600730896,
-0.5598437786102295,
0.6375200152397156,
-0.12006073445081711,
0.11741729080677032,
-0.25480926036834717,
-1.0765072107315063,
-1.06107759475708,
-0.931932270526886,
-0.4905647039413452,
-0.6508735418319702,
-0.1757338047027588,
1.3677464723587036,
0.6308342218399048,
-0.847815215587616,
-0.2036680281162262,
-0.20008373260498047,
0.4202955663204193,
0.016622155904769897,
-0.31059783697128296,
0.09488176554441452,
-0.33215078711509705,
-0.8020665049552917,
0.03680383414030075,
0.083468958735466,
-0.3802940845489502,
0.17770102620124817,
0.1754135638475418,
-0.5599918365478516,
0.17796678841114044,
0.5370367765426636,
0.6202317476272583,
-0.8621572852134705,
-0.5986317992210388,
-0.1279982328414917,
0.14805564284324646,
0.500617504119873,
0.8020519018173218,
-0.5839049816131592,
0.5899479389190674,
0.35154950618743896,
0.7834619283676147,
0.4549243152141571,
0.36918529868125916,
0.5195168852806091,
-0.7350267171859741,
0.12254542112350464,
0.4236922562122345,
0.4372738003730774,
0.45176711678504944,
0.024907534942030907,
0.4313487410545349,
0.17701409757137299,
-0.2080589085817337,
-0.9503552317619324,
-0.0986843928694725,
-1.2440581321716309,
0.06611072272062302,
1.1701120138168335,
-0.04616421088576317,
-0.3853175640106201,
-0.4002946615219116,
0.022952871397137642,
0.3756386339664459,
-0.9344357252120972,
0.8920088410377502,
0.9148159623146057,
0.2004050761461258,
-0.5214062929153442,
-0.6525239944458008,
0.49754756689071655,
-0.0006843024748377502,
-0.9031510353088379,
0.15553109347820282,
-0.018722638487815857,
0.19096170365810394,
0.0927668884396553,
0.5653795599937439,
-0.07735277712345123,
0.11664246767759323,
-0.07172583788633347,
-0.22382007539272308,
-0.01606261357665062,
-0.17814821004867554,
0.2109459936618805,
0.7233862280845642,
-0.11101000010967255,
-0.6650470495223999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00403v1
|
UniMEEC: Towards Unified Multimodal Emotion Recognition and Emotion Cause
| 2024-03-30T15:59:17 | 2024-03-30T15:59:17 |
Guimin Hu, Zhihong Zhu, Daniel Hershcovich, Hasti Seifi, Jiayuan Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal emotion recognition in conversation (MERC) and multimodal
emotion-cause pair extraction (MECPE) has recently garnered significant
attention. Emotions are the expression of affect or feelings; responses to
specific events, thoughts, or situations are known as emotion causes. Both are
like two sides of a coin, collectively describing human behaviors and intents.
However, most existing works treat MERC and MECPE as separate tasks, which may
result in potential challenges in integrating emotion and cause in real-world
applications. In this paper, we propose a Unified Multimodal Emotion
recognition and Emotion-Cause analysis framework (UniMEEC) to explore the
causality and complementarity between emotion and emotion cause. Concretely,
UniMEEC reformulates the MERC and MECPE tasks as two mask prediction problems,
enhancing the interaction between emotion and cause. Meanwhile, UniMEEC shares
the prompt learning among modalities for probing modality-specific knowledge
from the Pre-trained model. Furthermore, we propose a task-specific
hierarchical context aggregation to control the information flow to the task.
Experiment results on four public benchmark datasets verify the model
performance on MERC and MECPE tasks and achieve consistent improvements
compared with state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.5317660570144653,
-0.4943469166755676,
0.5550618767738342,
0.26506319642066956,
-0.21310947835445404,
-0.13117368519306183,
-0.10217032581567764,
-0.3772830665111542,
0.32448527216911316,
0.2342194765806198,
-0.9919877648353577,
-0.08217024058103561,
-0.46388939023017883,
-0.01849435083568096,
0.20347833633422852,
0.858681321144104,
-0.1997944861650467,
0.0834772065281868,
-0.21308843791484833,
-0.45795056223869324,
-0.6585673093795776,
-0.47264519333839417,
-0.5208240747451782,
-0.07093619555234909,
0.5943095684051514,
0.6193917989730835,
0.08253985643386841,
-0.19009314477443695,
0.19961322844028473,
0.3672887086868286,
0.4586782157421112,
0.223471537232399,
-0.08513465523719788,
0.270920991897583,
-0.18926815688610077,
-0.10373446345329285,
-0.5509957671165466,
0.22239366173744202,
0.08820878714323044,
0.414754182100296,
-0.08398804068565369,
0.07290917634963989,
0.22270359098911285,
0.673923671245575,
-1.0623077154159546,
0.11959973722696304,
-0.3174777030944824,
-0.05844855681061745,
-0.14371590316295624,
-0.5537198781967163,
-0.11639180779457092,
0.3208651840686798,
-0.03438940271735191,
-0.4246373772621155,
-0.020083021372556686,
0.1357271373271942,
0.3240320086479187,
0.19284506142139435,
-0.9953609108924866,
-0.2782564163208008,
-0.2724369466304779,
0.7782367467880249,
-0.568437933921814,
0.41340407729148865,
-0.0019960463978350163,
0.08677969127893448,
-0.07516322284936905,
-0.49873608350753784,
-0.7619516849517822,
0.22182822227478027,
-0.18441353738307953,
0.45091712474823,
-0.6198518872261047,
0.03641580417752266,
0.09272882342338562,
0.13223497569561005,
-0.7355238199234009,
0.05935615673661232,
-0.061694372445344925,
-0.6084409952163696,
0.22900940477848053,
0.312558114528656,
0.5224846005439758,
-0.3509086072444916,
-0.7251693606376648,
-0.07941514253616333,
-0.640039324760437,
0.5525939464569092,
0.000921884027775377,
-0.0961265042424202,
-0.3065693974494934,
0.12394958734512329,
-0.29660317301750183,
0.29506227374076843,
-0.17339850962162018,
0.12119366973638535,
0.05674729123711586,
-0.2730254828929901,
-0.2656133472919464,
-0.05248986557126045,
0.9621214866638184,
0.32564154267311096,
0.03599407896399498,
-0.15546433627605438,
0.20084692537784576,
0.22970575094223022,
0.12002317607402802,
-0.7907657027244568,
0.025469539687037468,
0.4057866632938385,
-0.39138928055763245,
-0.10865841060876846,
0.16021552681922913,
-1.3726890087127686,
-0.34837400913238525,
-0.6543161273002625,
0.4768504798412323,
0.1287548691034317,
-0.2623318135738373,
-0.058592069894075394,
-0.007832508534193039,
-0.18644940853118896,
0.31866440176963806,
-0.5329374670982361,
0.07723703235387802,
0.21685318648815155,
0.39849355816841125,
0.01800055056810379,
-0.34860268235206604,
-0.5889793634414673,
-0.1886104941368103,
0.06588363647460938,
0.8173408508300781,
-0.33015042543411255,
-0.06808814406394958,
-0.01631748117506504,
0.271901935338974,
-0.2757261097431183,
-0.14076420664787292,
0.7463526129722595,
-0.4322851002216339,
0.5710207223892212,
-0.39905107021331787,
-0.11737918853759766,
-0.3836229741573334,
0.2471546232700348,
-0.6197023987770081,
0.4272885322570801,
-0.053480617702007294,
-0.8477011322975159,
0.15880396962165833,
-0.8108773231506348,
-0.28928500413894653,
-0.26975440979003906,
-0.17632918059825897,
-0.2574000060558319,
0.21748054027557373,
0.41748830676078796,
0.7104604244232178,
-0.8072865009307861,
0.5964049100875854,
-0.3125896155834198,
0.03703499585390091,
0.23909273743629456,
-0.6648567914962769,
0.7040553689002991,
0.3823598325252533,
-0.6552018523216248,
0.356447696685791,
-0.766242265701294,
-0.15189889073371887,
-0.17476427555084229,
-0.05774121731519699,
-0.39303967356681824,
-0.0014296835288405418,
0.197861909866333,
0.7850954532623291,
0.23201371729373932,
-0.7646616697311401,
-0.13836397230625153,
0.44097018241882324,
0.21859876811504364,
0.7995777726173401,
0.1519278585910797,
0.31199899315834045,
0.044154345989227295,
0.314872145652771,
0.4830664098262787,
0.28595900535583496,
-0.30483344197273254,
-0.23757410049438477,
-0.5096102356910706,
-0.553291916847229,
-0.11220087110996246,
0.6198428869247437,
-0.6533964276313782,
0.1497802883386612,
0.16388122737407684,
-0.04436406120657921,
-0.3116143047809601,
0.10390197485685349,
0.5107709169387817,
0.7381842732429504,
0.3185126483440399,
-0.28743776679039,
-0.875125527381897,
-0.5853396058082581,
-0.1269022673368454,
0.005256228614598513,
-0.2041342556476593,
0.6176528334617615,
0.332855224609375,
-0.5236455202102661,
0.8611056208610535,
-0.26172974705696106,
-0.4153408110141754,
0.1023695170879364,
0.7810434699058533,
0.04449918493628502,
0.5361185669898987,
0.46107998490333557,
-0.8766563534736633,
-0.10416699200868607,
-0.23733356595039368,
-1.0135730504989624,
-0.5933505296707153,
-0.22630511224269867,
-0.06466378271579742,
0.16302841901779175,
0.43477556109428406,
-0.20014770328998566,
0.47981634736061096,
0.7515897154808044,
-0.49244117736816406,
0.5322607755661011,
-0.1791299730539322,
0.9595268368721008,
-1.1542253494262695,
0.07615626603364944,
0.04950341954827309,
0.17605715990066528,
-0.5340558290481567,
-0.5353071689605713,
0.1336846649646759,
-0.29958364367485046,
-0.460401326417923,
0.44641509652137756,
-0.3736934959888458,
0.09777284413576126,
-0.07016308605670929,
0.01612156629562378,
0.21408911049365997,
1.0558570623397827,
-0.025226028636097908,
0.4389673173427582,
0.6345519423484802,
-0.569485068321228,
0.4725857377052307,
-0.05473952367901802,
-0.09023534506559372,
0.9629234671592712,
-0.42811304330825806,
0.006714140065014362,
-0.1462525874376297,
-0.05859121307730675,
-1.077075719833374,
-0.35064902901649475,
0.10575798898935318,
-0.33210134506225586,
0.35906973481178284,
0.4072665274143219,
-0.29384472966194153,
-0.22237329185009003,
-0.29484403133392334,
0.6312757730484009,
0.2140396684408188,
-0.8324483633041382,
0.8360542058944702,
0.22639575600624084,
-0.10729566961526871,
-0.48943325877189636,
-0.31601423025131226,
-0.022864358499646187,
-0.3517645299434662,
-0.7923797965049744,
0.04442595690488815,
-0.22834433615207672,
-0.13879629969596863,
-0.3031991720199585,
0.021327519789338112,
-0.20502282679080963,
0.0005585816688835621,
0.7296611070632935,
0.10805172473192215,
-0.008466820232570171,
0.2823541760444641,
0.17684325575828552,
-0.2287028431892395,
0.2078196257352829,
0.08802906423807144,
0.29778438806533813,
-0.05578974261879921,
-0.3578781485557556,
-0.572399377822876,
0.6944524049758911,
0.9578486680984497,
-0.4090867340564728,
0.2883754074573517,
0.8209337592124939,
-0.1846430003643036,
0.2698172330856323,
-0.8010214567184448,
-0.3998832404613495,
-0.36049193143844604,
0.1962311565876007,
-0.15317505598068237,
-0.970275342464447,
0.5509960651397705,
-0.6208718419075012,
-0.24493061006069183,
0.3498539328575134,
0.5406785011291504,
-0.3292134404182434,
0.944636881351471,
0.5230122804641724,
-0.450278639793396,
0.41536998748779297,
0.2382533699274063,
0.14194631576538086,
-1.0877610445022583,
-0.38992419838905334,
-0.33766669034957886,
-0.3530929386615753,
-0.4077986180782318,
-0.2960983216762543,
0.7414650917053223,
0.06443772464990616,
-0.2002464234828949,
0.21690961718559265,
-0.07092161476612091,
0.04623204842209816,
0.40465566515922546,
0.039523541927337646,
0.22955429553985596,
-0.11082057654857635,
-0.13472557067871094,
-0.2667348086833954,
-0.4603583812713623,
-0.18023541569709778,
0.6985783576965332,
0.059087470173835754,
0.6027926206588745,
0.1362389773130417,
0.3328793942928314,
0.3805733323097229,
0.10618488490581512,
-0.290223628282547,
0.4103056490421295,
-0.01596931181848049,
-0.7214657068252563,
0.11344487965106964,
-0.4754677414894104,
-0.8657279014587402,
0.27587518095970154,
-0.4002942740917206,
-1.0991870164871216,
0.6004041433334351,
0.13191652297973633,
0.02246212214231491,
0.29697316884994507,
-0.5591119527816772,
1.2469426393508911,
-0.3106711208820343,
-0.4747049808502197,
-0.44373369216918945,
-0.9061692953109741,
0.4924354553222656,
-0.010987237095832825,
0.4128710627555847,
-0.24824130535125732,
0.5504403114318848,
0.7380473017692566,
-0.2747335731983185,
0.9175874590873718,
-0.04611408710479736,
0.23268654942512512,
0.5275171995162964,
0.24471324682235718,
0.34882405400276184,
0.03698771446943283,
0.38818156719207764,
0.26491791009902954,
-0.16333825886249542,
-0.23771992325782776,
-0.6856877207756042,
0.5491408109664917,
-0.503076434135437,
-0.025025244802236557,
-0.2471388429403305,
-0.7703163027763367,
-0.2695249319076538,
-0.05579519271850586,
0.23821203410625458,
0.7881433367729187,
-0.2685287296772003,
0.1320951133966446,
0.4590315520763397,
-0.040980905294418335,
0.8458461761474609,
0.9684298634529114,
0.38593992590904236,
-0.47958579659461975,
0.84046471118927,
-0.5428178310394287,
0.010789996944367886,
0.5001168251037598,
0.357266366481781,
-0.16482305526733398,
0.45445239543914795,
-0.21553808450698853,
-0.02537616528570652,
-0.4606740176677704,
-0.3585149049758911,
-0.44365233182907104,
0.5014700889587402,
-0.3443734347820282,
-0.16800174117088318,
-0.2917076051235199,
-0.024979930371046066,
-0.4109574854373932,
0.30539238452911377,
0.20778615772724152,
0.22026292979717255,
-0.526782751083374,
0.2505227029323578,
-0.8330157995223999,
0.26451942324638367,
0.855733335018158,
-0.05484282970428467,
-0.12237178534269333,
-0.19481106102466583,
0.20676563680171967,
0.1510459929704666,
-0.5096238255500793,
-1.0040346384048462,
0.3933779001235962,
0.13099849224090576,
0.21564464271068573,
0.9932427406311035,
0.16321486234664917,
0.6925262212753296,
-0.29507648944854736,
0.44052115082740784,
0.7107774019241333,
-1.203210473060608,
0.3404577970504761,
-0.27725955843925476,
-0.11271534115076065,
0.27833840250968933,
0.535347580909729,
-0.7898176312446594,
0.06643422693014145,
-0.6468959450721741,
-0.4670437276363373,
0.5315721035003662,
0.2139461785554886,
-0.27566587924957275,
0.1473933905363083,
-0.10372507572174072,
-0.2966344356536865,
0.30164462327957153,
-0.4383944272994995,
-0.04228545352816582,
-0.1360078603029251,
-0.20716972649097443,
-0.009766977280378342,
-0.6030304431915283,
0.04418656602501869,
0.04697077348828316,
0.3444039821624756,
-0.13092000782489777,
0.35508471727371216,
0.21584002673625946,
-0.2550175189971924,
-0.4351162016391754,
0.7359968423843384,
0.6206194758415222,
0.11150775849819183,
-0.35613813996315,
0.3633722960948944,
0.016437243670225143,
0.03550565615296364,
-0.023519152775406837,
-0.04832514002919197,
0.5902398228645325,
-0.2673795223236084,
0.5295447707176208,
0.6811512112617493,
0.6869006752967834,
-0.8021089434623718,
0.6964200139045715,
0.025694100186228752,
0.08401937782764435,
0.09224905073642731,
-0.4043295979499817,
-0.20004186034202576,
0.6543939113616943,
0.15824836492538452,
0.10748495906591415,
0.5510737895965576,
-0.8308647274971008,
0.46834856271743774,
0.4918774366378784,
-0.5715011954307556,
-0.5869056582450867,
0.6540346741676331,
0.2868521809577942,
0.27972155809402466,
0.4948815405368805,
-0.26701316237449646,
-0.843229353427887,
0.6472834944725037,
0.372149795293808,
0.7018291354179382,
-0.5216390490531921,
0.14070841670036316,
0.32209667563438416,
-0.04133319482207298,
0.35266590118408203,
0.3436274528503418,
-0.5109659433364868,
-0.7566497325897217,
-0.32626181840896606,
-0.19914618134498596,
-0.28332656621932983,
-0.13467562198638916,
-0.7597581744194031,
-0.0627780556678772,
0.021564120426774025,
0.08011385798454285,
-0.2379409223794937,
-0.10982391983270645,
-0.5833823084831238,
0.3005425035953522,
0.2399008721113205,
0.147633358836174,
-1.299020767211914,
0.43866589665412903,
0.55260169506073,
-0.4768488109111786,
-0.799642026424408,
-0.4867735803127289,
0.47846245765686035,
-0.6085138320922852,
0.7245705723762512,
0.20137783885002136,
-0.011724703945219517,
-0.33420756459236145,
-0.47600454092025757,
-0.4218006432056427,
1.2653782367706299,
0.008403316140174866,
-0.2618285119533539,
0.37722501158714294,
-0.09770645201206207,
0.3822425305843353,
-0.649756908416748,
0.3778831660747528,
0.22813186049461365,
0.4607912003993988,
0.26905176043510437,
-0.79991215467453,
0.07726095616817474,
-0.2271450012922287,
-0.34764185547828674,
0.27792420983314514,
-0.46135029196739197,
0.9353016018867493,
-0.21539035439491272,
-0.16327744722366333,
-0.36823946237564087,
0.4266708195209503,
0.13919499516487122,
0.8230302333831787,
0.4075270891189575,
0.6161262392997742,
0.5129390954971313,
-0.028337882831692696,
0.6858291625976562,
-0.0892547070980072,
0.37315070629119873,
0.9470425844192505,
-0.2711268961429596,
0.5195935964584351,
0.5206941366195679,
-0.11113543063402176,
0.7009356021881104,
0.3832976222038269,
0.4219460189342499,
0.5187419652938843,
-0.29945242404937744,
-0.4329386055469513,
-0.45718419551849365,
-0.4582393169403076,
0.12151650339365005,
0.6864129900932312,
0.22093577682971954,
-0.13938090205192566,
-0.5048004388809204,
0.26497969031333923,
0.3704482614994049,
-0.2532970905303955,
-0.4600142538547516,
0.6025615334510803,
-0.011045782826840878,
-0.49651989340782166,
0.0653059110045433,
-0.2364308089017868,
0.5450078248977661,
-0.5012648105621338,
-0.060256827622652054,
-0.29547861218452454,
0.17772361636161804,
-0.24131153523921967,
-0.3005187213420868,
0.22549287974834442,
-0.031248664483428,
-0.29962119460105896,
-0.015564373694360256,
0.7200686931610107,
-0.5088972449302673,
-0.07270544022321701,
0.3260928690433502,
0.510850191116333,
0.10196159780025482,
-0.6561869382858276,
-0.5589492917060852,
-0.057807695120573044,
-0.0685628205537796,
-0.17086362838745117,
0.600936770439148,
0.8100736141204834,
-0.2854197919368744,
0.28999951481819153,
0.749501645565033,
-0.5497735738754272,
-0.10920394957065582,
0.014094044454395771,
0.7928239107131958,
-0.4578593075275421,
-0.23815704882144928,
-0.7312422394752502,
0.9923508763313293,
-0.026881331577897072,
-0.34495922923088074,
0.30413466691970825,
-0.014933912083506584,
0.08967936784029007,
-0.17021037638187408,
0.1537715047597885,
-0.3273191750049591,
0.19130821526050568,
-0.41170647740364075,
0.4397982060909271,
-0.9671919345855713,
-0.14667603373527527,
-0.6777641773223877,
-0.6375763416290283,
-0.18532772362232208,
0.2541051506996155,
0.09582314640283585,
-0.15506769716739655,
0.9630705118179321,
0.6631481647491455,
0.0522245354950428,
0.06776342540979385,
0.4687650501728058,
-0.07161859422922134,
0.28981927037239075,
1.1969084739685059,
0.6250267028808594,
-0.3626580834388733,
0.23730619251728058,
-0.4233619272708893,
-0.5516310334205627,
-0.12613700330257416,
-1.1496118307113647,
-0.8227629065513611,
-1.049461841583252,
-0.3796829283237457,
0.010649287141859531,
-0.36049720644950867,
0.828599214553833,
0.6257707476615906,
-0.7982574105262756,
0.043360207229852676,
-0.1166590079665184,
0.17074719071388245,
-0.13310393691062927,
-0.22887323796749115,
0.4254671037197113,
-0.37745729088783264,
-0.38079819083213806,
0.3962739408016205,
0.5909476280212402,
-0.20749658346176147,
0.0919010117650032,
0.016506794840097427,
-0.12254103273153305,
-0.05490924045443535,
0.5996991395950317,
0.6812676191329956,
-0.5145238041877747,
-0.11918587237596512,
-0.13953439891338348,
0.07837449014186859,
-0.1555655151605606,
1.4076274633407593,
-0.548859715461731,
0.7267304062843323,
0.49898192286491394,
0.29659906029701233,
0.05596289783716202,
-0.10966100543737411,
0.33862870931625366,
-0.9043003916740417,
0.3173610270023346,
-0.022873325273394585,
0.837705135345459,
0.034768689423799515,
-0.2943054139614105,
0.37837153673171997,
0.5374615788459778,
-0.6681233644485474,
-0.35157421231269836,
0.4730837047100067,
-1.3282411098480225,
-0.1313178390264511,
0.7018693685531616,
-0.19798368215560913,
-0.14201682806015015,
0.0454794317483902,
-0.23858176171779633,
0.4173303246498108,
-0.38254886865615845,
0.7195122838020325,
0.40494397282600403,
-0.36502185463905334,
-0.32023417949676514,
-0.3297228515148163,
0.048541441559791565,
0.5699352025985718,
-1.050020694732666,
0.07650598883628845,
0.7819193601608276,
0.10971419513225555,
0.26535189151763916,
0.4819926917552948,
-0.12138283252716064,
0.42573779821395874,
-0.23343588411808014,
0.670194685459137,
-0.195622980594635,
-0.5797147154808044,
-0.2892611026763916,
0.09023440629243851,
-0.7157006859779358,
-0.27271541953086853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00401v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00401v1
|
How Robust are the Tabular QA Models for Scientific Tables? A Study using Customized Dataset
| 2024-03-30T15:48:49 | 2024-03-30T15:48:49 |
Akash Ghosh, B Venkata Sahith, Niloy Ganguly, Pawan Goyal, Mayank Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Question-answering (QA) on hybrid scientific tabular and textual data deals
with scientific information, and relies on complex numerical reasoning. In
recent years, while tabular QA has seen rapid progress, understanding their
robustness on scientific information is lacking due to absence of any benchmark
dataset. To investigate the robustness of the existing state-of-the-art QA
models on scientific hybrid tabular data, we propose a new dataset, "SciTabQA",
consisting of 822 question-answer pairs from scientific tables and their
descriptions. With the help of this dataset, we assess the state-of-the-art
Tabular QA models based on their ability (i) to use heterogeneous information
requiring both structured data (table) and unstructured data (text) and (ii) to
perform complex scientific reasoning tasks. In essence, we check the capability
of the models to interpret scientific tables and text. Our experiments show
that "SciTabQA" is an innovative dataset to study question-answering over
scientific heterogeneous data. We benchmark three state-of-the-art Tabular QA
models, and find that the best F1 score is only 0.462.
|
[
-0.2161356657743454,
-1.0043166875839233,
0.6546414494514465,
0.2753395140171051,
-0.18520201742649078,
0.31489211320877075,
0.2905645966529846,
-0.34261447191238403,
0.16281314194202423,
0.2932955026626587,
-0.21099823713302612,
-0.581669270992279,
0.10736224800348282,
0.3770512342453003,
-0.4410189688205719,
1.1778234243392944,
-0.011292561888694763,
0.3356988728046417,
-0.8875200152397156,
-0.22266846895217896,
-0.5049027800559998,
-0.19493414461612701,
0.2299041599035263,
0.05488826707005501,
0.22106607258319855,
0.43016287684440613,
0.99837327003479,
0.6134587526321411,
0.8010304570198059,
0.1800854504108429,
-0.013673098757863045,
0.12167472392320633,
-0.22453159093856812,
0.24771150946617126,
-0.3144153356552124,
-0.565710186958313,
-0.5834190249443054,
-0.15942701697349548,
0.8086407780647278,
0.6479831337928772,
-0.13188908994197845,
0.5884775519371033,
-0.26851004362106323,
0.3049168288707733,
-0.172525554895401,
0.36267054080963135,
-0.9288334250450134,
0.05978061258792877,
-0.07449930906295776,
-0.20395228266716003,
-0.4848947525024414,
-0.9034847617149353,
0.06064104288816452,
-0.8860868215560913,
0.009403715841472149,
0.37348759174346924,
0.8321642875671387,
0.1798274666070938,
-0.36093005537986755,
0.0898941308259964,
-0.8158964514732361,
0.3441755175590515,
-0.6746227741241455,
0.32819366455078125,
0.28130394220352173,
0.46763521432876587,
-0.3044750690460205,
-0.8544906973838806,
-0.7668505311012268,
-0.5528879761695862,
0.09591599553823471,
0.17934250831604004,
-0.1046186238527298,
-0.21455024182796478,
0.4024670124053955,
0.155949667096138,
-1.1184765100479126,
0.005414751823991537,
-0.35572028160095215,
-0.04637730121612549,
0.38252419233322144,
0.3506515920162201,
0.5049956440925598,
-0.14955422282218933,
-0.36520880460739136,
-0.1710657775402069,
-0.522172749042511,
0.39650577306747437,
-0.026217391714453697,
0.18183737993240356,
0.1272467076778412,
0.8272109627723694,
-0.3509024679660797,
0.5598546862602234,
-0.062385834753513336,
0.004134443588554859,
-0.00813492201268673,
-0.7070302963256836,
-0.05890630558133125,
-0.237175852060318,
0.6795885562896729,
0.3970421850681305,
0.07280221581459045,
-0.5372072458267212,
0.05966637283563614,
0.3172575831413269,
0.13152383267879486,
-0.5915161371231079,
-0.38872286677360535,
0.44658929109573364,
-0.21318507194519043,
-0.23017168045043945,
0.04319994896650314,
-0.9087544083595276,
-0.0456719808280468,
0.13587439060211182,
0.5937269926071167,
-0.1909492313861847,
-0.02378513105213642,
-0.16944529116153717,
0.058092668652534485,
0.046388205140829086,
0.25931650400161743,
-0.4796263575553894,
0.4588376581668854,
0.40736666321754456,
0.7420864701271057,
-0.3844071328639984,
-0.13231106102466583,
-0.49275368452072144,
0.02790510468184948,
-0.3063614070415497,
1.142085075378418,
-0.5271565914154053,
-0.2707701623439789,
-0.37246572971343994,
-0.1019202321767807,
-0.23012501001358032,
-0.5623806715011597,
0.5130115151405334,
-0.6911636590957642,
0.350238561630249,
-0.561448335647583,
-0.3899010121822357,
-0.1572262942790985,
0.24924130737781525,
-1.000313639640808,
0.8732824921607971,
0.14869306981563568,
-0.8267507553100586,
0.6830084919929504,
-0.5262800455093384,
-0.24250879883766174,
0.39248034358024597,
-0.09796416014432907,
-0.5651666522026062,
-0.28696703910827637,
0.12945325672626495,
0.06103738397359848,
-0.377328097820282,
0.5348808765411377,
-0.8327446579933167,
-0.2129451185464859,
0.7413922548294067,
-0.05503694713115692,
0.4057607054710388,
0.16689205169677734,
0.05744914337992668,
0.07596231997013092,
-0.6969084143638611,
0.5299621820449829,
-0.14440329372882843,
-0.2681742012500763,
-0.00883621908724308,
0.003058327827602625,
0.11310958862304688,
0.42448335886001587,
0.00048784603131935,
-0.7731869220733643,
0.12966954708099365,
-0.01318651158362627,
0.42659246921539307,
0.2928071618080139,
0.11472901701927185,
0.26863595843315125,
-0.6165401339530945,
0.6580298542976379,
-0.054196879267692566,
0.04950328543782234,
0.5057641863822937,
-0.571670413017273,
0.11318662017583847,
-0.08584414422512054,
0.6849963068962097,
0.7285059094429016,
-0.6741542816162109,
0.14033666253089905,
-0.20399826765060425,
-0.7181077599525452,
-0.31625932455062866,
-0.2699171006679535,
0.3212392032146454,
0.8890015482902527,
0.5485180616378784,
-0.17826831340789795,
-0.3034819960594177,
-0.9468310475349426,
-0.3106949031352997,
-0.3185216188430786,
0.08602006733417511,
0.21046140789985657,
0.7903401255607605,
0.1937544345855713,
1.0406440496444702,
-0.2246469408273697,
0.31303566694259644,
-0.17765899002552032,
-0.02040235325694084,
0.2426062524318695,
0.42319217324256897,
0.3834686875343323,
-1.0359586477279663,
-0.4920017719268799,
-0.055516671389341354,
-0.8516871333122253,
-0.03012324683368206,
-0.0004928658017888665,
-0.17614883184432983,
0.03216519206762314,
-0.08411390334367752,
-0.7211141586303711,
0.4158242642879486,
0.2484503984451294,
-0.6578124761581421,
0.885249137878418,
0.03287931904196739,
0.31532183289527893,
-0.9730358719825745,
0.4244249165058136,
0.1904890090227127,
-0.062014006078243256,
-0.9076338410377502,
0.06599865853786469,
0.24249885976314545,
-0.168471559882164,
-0.3196845054626465,
0.26696696877479553,
-0.18130746483802795,
-0.18431389331817627,
0.03654276579618454,
-0.057987894862890244,
0.26257291436195374,
0.3182814121246338,
0.0434127002954483,
0.8077051043510437,
0.13374978303909302,
-0.29720038175582886,
0.24188470840454102,
0.7404245138168335,
-0.40884414315223694,
0.4981481432914734,
-0.9866591691970825,
-0.06582965701818466,
-0.05248573422431946,
0.3506704568862915,
-0.8738246560096741,
-0.322550892829895,
-0.007723698858171701,
-0.37182727456092834,
0.043965112417936325,
0.35070931911468506,
-0.41272199153900146,
-0.44962626695632935,
-0.217253640294075,
0.35966575145721436,
0.17528873682022095,
-0.18206796050071716,
0.6279553771018982,
0.3408050835132599,
-0.4143712520599365,
-0.5368924736976624,
-0.4730866551399231,
-0.2286563217639923,
-0.20361964404582977,
-0.7592158317565918,
0.36128202080726624,
-0.12093061953783035,
-0.3089916408061981,
0.27214598655700684,
-0.5314236879348755,
-0.46848487854003906,
0.032609015703201294,
0.35800549387931824,
0.5950554609298706,
-0.26854458451271057,
-0.023405956104397774,
0.16851918399333954,
0.1750527173280716,
0.21097014844417572,
0.24783273041248322,
0.3452584445476532,
-0.49621960520744324,
-0.010021182708442211,
-0.6571349501609802,
0.33268672227859497,
0.7574993371963501,
-0.40934062004089355,
0.7802897691726685,
0.3039357364177704,
-0.5782753229141235,
0.0039197220467031,
-0.3661382496356964,
-0.35255590081214905,
-0.4025386869907379,
0.6664400696754456,
-0.30565813183784485,
-0.5621373057365417,
0.9279248118400574,
0.36662840843200684,
0.18511615693569183,
0.4149510860443115,
0.4775004982948303,
-0.41806209087371826,
0.9218918681144714,
0.16875100135803223,
0.22823263704776764,
-0.18920594453811646,
0.052897728979587555,
0.0990132987499237,
-0.3721362054347992,
-0.7931709885597229,
-1.0566190481185913,
-0.012442278675734997,
-0.5316893458366394,
-0.11312662065029144,
0.7100321650505066,
-0.21738362312316895,
-0.24452778697013855,
0.19036245346069336,
-0.27594295144081116,
0.3051421344280243,
0.5799564719200134,
0.22448515892028809,
0.5222711563110352,
-0.020563414320349693,
0.007737317588180304,
0.06714793294668198,
-0.8317049741744995,
-0.7497979998588562,
0.9368614554405212,
0.41706839203834534,
0.8443208932876587,
-0.11628120392560959,
0.13233473896980286,
0.3111168146133423,
0.12582264840602875,
-0.14283260703086853,
0.4930568039417267,
0.0368569940328598,
-0.7932659983634949,
-0.47319841384887695,
-0.7761093378067017,
-0.5409975647926331,
0.20365025103092194,
-0.676600456237793,
-0.6147346496582031,
0.23297782242298126,
0.2800535559654236,
-0.5957192182540894,
0.2551612854003906,
-0.6968182325363159,
1.1954303979873657,
-0.20388171076774597,
-0.4449978768825531,
0.2631145119667053,
-0.7360233664512634,
0.38746798038482666,
-0.2258458137512207,
0.14355355501174927,
-0.023488106206059456,
0.29495033621788025,
0.917140781879425,
-0.2603754699230194,
0.28561052680015564,
-0.05455927923321724,
0.26467597484588623,
0.26736924052238464,
0.35732531547546387,
0.4266033470630646,
0.39641788601875305,
-0.1719290018081665,
-0.25850576162338257,
0.9587370157241821,
-0.46736228466033936,
-0.6330921053886414,
0.5818442702293396,
-0.6168383359909058,
-0.3773766756057739,
-0.553179144859314,
-0.9340391755104065,
-0.675381600856781,
-0.0023957686498761177,
0.199225515127182,
0.4807468354701996,
-0.11251816153526306,
0.5042799115180969,
0.6893248558044434,
-0.09685990959405899,
0.02869020402431488,
0.4458538591861725,
0.07092031836509705,
-0.2959567904472351,
0.7685230374336243,
0.3046753406524658,
0.3311445713043213,
0.4977014660835266,
0.04853535816073418,
-0.6838476657867432,
-0.772709310054779,
-0.5410455465316772,
0.08172852545976639,
-0.3169964551925659,
-0.4481804072856903,
-0.6136955618858337,
-0.010861251503229141,
-0.22997306287288666,
0.19373701512813568,
0.09390861541032791,
-0.7588809728622437,
-0.22943051159381866,
-0.22260141372680664,
0.1611592173576355,
0.44307929277420044,
0.43231111764907837,
-0.21993491053581238,
-0.8570517301559448,
0.5162941217422485,
0.3111557364463806,
0.31935423612594604,
-0.27048608660697937,
-0.4552936255931854,
0.0730002373456955,
0.058146100491285324,
-0.056320302188396454,
-1.2040408849716187,
0.23385925590991974,
0.2536424696445465,
0.6135174632072449,
-0.03420637547969818,
0.19448591768741608,
0.2631397843360901,
-0.19752268493175507,
0.5936495661735535,
-0.15447084605693817,
-0.6895509958267212,
0.15703105926513672,
-0.43173137307167053,
0.2692602872848511,
0.7352246642112732,
0.6225999593734741,
-0.05208500102162361,
-0.5317903161048889,
-0.3360176086425781,
-0.4054674804210663,
0.41531315445899963,
0.03016745112836361,
-0.3729798197746277,
0.47360989451408386,
0.47771546244621277,
0.464370995759964,
0.3588230609893799,
-1.1341336965560913,
0.2740277051925659,
-0.5334086418151855,
-0.38947004079818726,
0.3869653642177582,
0.023250257596373558,
-0.14236091077327728,
-0.1755802482366562,
0.5596171021461487,
-0.22272774577140808,
0.03476981446146965,
-0.010396057739853859,
-0.0000823164009489119,
-0.29730460047721863,
0.5001638531684875,
0.40482720732688904,
0.7811795473098755,
-0.5502775311470032,
0.08175135403871536,
0.23247647285461426,
-0.8073256611824036,
0.12448034435510635,
0.28595995903015137,
-0.5852696299552917,
-0.2579386234283447,
0.1619137078523636,
0.4309994876384735,
-0.18540853261947632,
-0.766686201095581,
0.11002478748559952,
-0.14446747303009033,
-0.31967437267303467,
0.3016877770423889,
0.12697094678878784,
-0.049759458750486374,
0.26144227385520935,
0.4766140580177307,
-0.022887930274009705,
0.3682110011577606,
-0.6770121455192566,
0.2787838578224182,
0.609596848487854,
0.058544326573610306,
-0.38375619053840637,
0.9835887551307678,
-0.2218862622976303,
0.04896191135048866,
0.4231279790401459,
0.07195889204740524,
-0.497420996427536,
0.716420590877533,
0.709009051322937,
0.1455213725566864,
0.009545454755425453,
0.8752589821815491,
0.18764309585094452,
0.3766839802265167,
0.04749078303575516,
0.8114499449729919,
0.10504864156246185,
-0.4086315929889679,
-0.09784867614507675,
-0.6707378029823303,
-0.7854048013687134,
0.11745031177997589,
-0.7617843747138977,
-0.4437301754951477,
-0.5297152400016785,
-0.3576808571815491,
0.18713881075382233,
0.30124738812446594,
-0.5405964255332947,
0.3734171688556671,
-0.5739830136299133,
0.9469307065010071,
-1.0671916007995605,
0.4227812588214874,
0.8140459656715393,
-0.4247836470603943,
-1.1241552829742432,
-0.3770018219947815,
-0.4854198694229126,
-0.29209911823272705,
0.2361503392457962,
-0.25450384616851807,
0.28487712144851685,
-0.2341671735048294,
-0.5541554689407349,
-0.8875917196273804,
0.956581711769104,
0.2918064594268799,
-0.5025301575660706,
-0.15390868484973907,
0.5109329223632812,
0.8814051151275635,
-0.07302950322628021,
0.18808318674564362,
0.4694468080997467,
0.583621084690094,
-0.023656627163290977,
-0.959545910358429,
0.3182393014431,
-0.576004147529602,
-0.31629475951194763,
0.0008495695074088871,
-0.4741192162036896,
0.6517061591148376,
-0.17927849292755127,
-0.053258154541254044,
0.23618647456169128,
0.6783683896064758,
0.5163644552230835,
0.8833531737327576,
0.26452192664146423,
0.4951249063014984,
0.7538536787033081,
-0.4745144844055176,
0.6569538712501526,
0.08291664719581604,
0.08374123275279999,
0.872729480266571,
-0.634085476398468,
0.8563079237937927,
0.3260507583618164,
-0.23300331830978394,
0.4907790422439575,
0.6365354657173157,
-0.41540077328681946,
0.5523408651351929,
0.0943535566329956,
0.05538703128695488,
-0.3068496286869049,
-0.0786985456943512,
-0.4943622350692749,
0.28906211256980896,
0.17079071700572968,
0.03636515513062477,
-0.13082239031791687,
-0.05240003764629364,
-0.3891964256763458,
0.26108676195144653,
-0.23289811611175537,
0.4962013363838196,
-0.1413421779870987,
-0.5547584295272827,
0.3943840563297272,
-0.2297852486371994,
-0.0249799694865942,
-0.34621360898017883,
-0.0041481805965304375,
-0.2523109018802643,
-0.3821963369846344,
-0.5308218002319336,
-0.8265777230262756,
-0.0113348588347435,
0.1352575421333313,
-0.15772230923175812,
0.314388245344162,
0.4517107307910919,
-0.49606651067733765,
-0.3722820281982422,
-0.563524603843689,
0.723283588886261,
0.02902800589799881,
0.17594364285469055,
-0.3565995395183563,
-0.18528465926647186,
-0.24947895109653473,
0.02747376263141632,
0.15570606291294098,
0.1260984241962433,
-0.4137223958969116,
0.8430665731430054,
0.5828304886817932,
-0.053523849695920944,
0.33853381872177124,
-0.2851368188858032,
0.9371045827865601,
-0.5171918869018555,
-0.6066714525222778,
-0.2414642870426178,
0.22906139492988586,
0.02145470306277275,
-0.43328890204429626,
0.7348942756652832,
0.6217865347862244,
0.39291125535964966,
-0.24730271100997925,
0.5470845103263855,
0.016313428059220314,
0.5783430337905884,
-0.48415637016296387,
0.797240674495697,
-0.3932856023311615,
-0.006119870115071535,
-0.4246284067630768,
-1.0165925025939941,
-0.43932807445526123,
0.30450114607810974,
-0.23340864479541779,
0.19190773367881775,
0.6718688607215881,
0.6159819960594177,
0.03368587791919708,
0.6370736360549927,
-0.09959445148706436,
0.33593809604644775,
0.2742035984992981,
0.49322566390037537,
0.882702648639679,
-0.059277553111314774,
0.44197556376457214,
-0.2580190896987915,
-0.2385217547416687,
-0.15066684782505035,
-0.5897762775421143,
-0.631926953792572,
-0.5967824459075928,
-0.26817622780799866,
-0.5474762916564941,
0.09186330437660217,
0.7062607407569885,
0.35341164469718933,
-1.1164041757583618,
0.02096063643693924,
0.005307573359459639,
0.0004689719353336841,
-0.1893327385187149,
-0.2197030931711197,
0.7180690765380859,
0.2977094352245331,
-0.2542174458503723,
0.31559574604034424,
0.08426128327846527,
0.20237739384174347,
-0.13178786635398865,
0.33607304096221924,
-0.15491826832294464,
0.14535307884216309,
0.1756138801574707,
0.7081359028816223,
-0.26294755935668945,
-0.11012892425060272,
0.6081739664077759,
-0.12076583504676819,
0.04571950435638428,
0.30988195538520813,
-0.5965462923049927,
0.2660585939884186,
0.6387866139411926,
0.5831437110900879,
0.3603529632091522,
0.44254982471466064,
0.37227222323417664,
-0.06610163301229477,
-0.4068659842014313,
0.7377039790153503,
0.18790970742702484,
0.1383228451013565,
-0.26005974411964417,
0.25136879086494446,
-0.04614201560616493,
-0.7996323704719543,
-1.4071145057678223,
-0.11151448637247086,
-1.4189958572387695,
-0.05542856454849243,
0.7947761416435242,
0.042919766157865524,
-0.4386945068836212,
-0.316545307636261,
-0.0035875788889825344,
0.06600528210401535,
-0.41218510270118713,
1.159980297088623,
0.48632994294166565,
-0.23272810876369476,
0.14623193442821503,
-0.32393354177474976,
0.46607506275177,
0.5967156887054443,
-1.3922946453094482,
-0.3024766147136688,
0.572334885597229,
0.3509015142917633,
0.20504064857959747,
0.12029138952493668,
-0.24082300066947937,
0.9400094151496887,
0.032576411962509155,
-0.3090074360370636,
-0.41605034470558167,
-0.7797313332557678,
-0.01576140709221363,
0.7349362373352051,
-0.02779168263077736,
0.0566646009683609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00399v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00399v2
|
Aurora-M: The First Open Source Multilingual Language Model Red-teamed according to the U.S. Executive Order
| 2024-03-30T15:38:54 | 2024-04-23T13:45:48 |
Taishi Nakamura, Mayank Mishra, Simone Tedeschi, Yekun Chai, Jason T Stillerman, Felix Friedrich, Prateek Yadav, Tanmay Laud, Vu Minh Chien, Terry Yue Zhuo, Diganta Misra, Ben Bogin, Xuan-Son Vu, Marzena Karpinska, Arnav Varma Dantuluri, Wojciech Kusa, Tommaso Furlanello, Rio Yokota, Niklas Muennighoff, Suhas Pai, Tosin Adewumi, Veronika Laippala, Xiaozhe Yao, Adalberto Junior, Alpay Ariyak, Aleksandr Drozd, Jordan Clive, Kshitij Gupta, Liangyu Chen, Qi Sun, Ken Tsui, Noah Persaud, Nour Fahmy, Tianlong Chen, Mohit Bansal, Nicolo Monti, Tai Dang, Ziyang Luo, Tien-Tung Bui, Roberto Navigli, Virendra Mehta, Matthew Blumberg, Victor May, Huu Nguyen, Sampo Pyysalo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pretrained language models underpin several AI applications, but their high
computational cost for training limits accessibility. Initiatives such as BLOOM
and StarCoder aim to democratize access to pretrained models for collaborative
community development. However, such existing models face challenges: limited
multilingual capabilities, continual pretraining causing catastrophic
forgetting, whereas pretraining from scratch is computationally expensive, and
compliance with AI safety and development laws. This paper presents Aurora-M, a
15B parameter multilingual open-source model trained on English, Finnish,
Hindi, Japanese, Vietnamese, and code. Continually pretrained from
StarCoderPlus on 435 billion additional tokens, Aurora-M surpasses 2 trillion
tokens in total training token count. It is the first open-source multilingual
model fine-tuned on human-reviewed safety instructions, thus aligning its
development not only with conventional red-teaming considerations, but also
with the specific concerns articulated in the Biden-Harris Executive Order on
the Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Development and Use of Artificial
Intelligence. Aurora-M is rigorously evaluated across various tasks and
languages, demonstrating robustness against catastrophic forgetting and
outperforming alternatives in multilingual settings, particularly in safety
evaluations. To promote responsible open-source LLM development, Aurora-M and
its variants are released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/aurora-m/aurora-m-models-65fdfdff62471e09812f5407 .
|
[
-0.23734809458255768,
-0.5460881590843201,
0.21649090945720673,
0.4083486497402191,
0.038017041981220245,
0.32626867294311523,
-0.15671424567699432,
-0.49019429087638855,
0.3087339997291565,
0.7234547734260559,
-0.5410400629043579,
-0.3620385229587555,
-0.42186081409454346,
0.24029679596424103,
-0.33035993576049805,
0.952575147151947,
-0.06464221328496933,
-0.032597120851278305,
0.04986193776130676,
-0.3847188949584961,
-0.06445631384849548,
-0.9881494045257568,
-0.4413330554962158,
-0.041350360959768295,
0.8780351281166077,
0.5103700757026672,
0.7770181894302368,
0.31762316823005676,
0.5932421088218689,
0.28298845887184143,
0.030286632478237152,
-0.1316889524459839,
-0.2957463562488556,
-0.3208874762058258,
0.04033990204334259,
-0.4806387424468994,
-0.8310006260871887,
0.1446133852005005,
0.7150042057037354,
0.585993230342865,
-0.3250984251499176,
0.10268343985080719,
-0.07884284853935242,
0.7676998376846313,
-0.91156005859375,
0.04348652809858322,
-0.6507906913757324,
-0.18609479069709778,
-0.23346470296382904,
0.31754249334335327,
-0.5024985074996948,
0.00260226265527308,
-0.03909788280725479,
-0.7513760924339294,
-0.24875186383724213,
0.43611374497413635,
0.8147796988487244,
0.08922647684812546,
-0.11022065579891205,
-0.11142703890800476,
-0.6890513896942139,
1.1535887718200684,
-0.3063184320926666,
0.5440390706062317,
0.40866291522979736,
0.24685044586658478,
0.20020267367362976,
-0.603369414806366,
-0.5236173868179321,
-0.3085663616657257,
0.16178403794765472,
0.28000888228416443,
-0.29064539074897766,
0.035917434841394424,
-0.14861300587654114,
0.3063966631889343,
-0.6288609504699707,
0.40880024433135986,
-0.6053873300552368,
-0.11154858022928238,
0.45747506618499756,
-0.033884547650814056,
0.18318277597427368,
-0.024014879018068314,
-0.16599026322364807,
0.08717605471611023,
-0.8052887916564941,
-0.2911422848701477,
0.3703662157058716,
0.4604165852069855,
-0.4190473258495331,
0.6397408246994019,
-0.08791877329349518,
0.19367022812366486,
-0.3458397686481476,
0.16470003128051758,
0.5529484152793884,
-0.3961601257324219,
-0.11021336168050766,
-0.21806219220161438,
1.058348536491394,
0.19027307629585266,
0.1787339746952057,
-0.2130235731601715,
-0.23316200077533722,
-0.08455653488636017,
0.26309970021247864,
-0.49439531564712524,
-0.02981281653046608,
0.31751173734664917,
-0.3945152163505554,
0.0038650433998554945,
-0.1578652560710907,
-0.6154984831809998,
0.0884329080581665,
-0.3623347878456116,
0.40152326226234436,
-0.4217427670955658,
-0.5583133697509766,
0.17173998057842255,
0.4392516314983368,
-0.23612461984157562,
0.2529705762863159,
-0.9481770992279053,
0.12277835607528687,
0.66520756483078,
0.8893499970436096,
0.045001059770584106,
-0.8614287376403809,
-0.5048805475234985,
-0.1338844895362854,
-0.38411745429039,
0.3055126965045929,
-0.31840959191322327,
-0.027528047561645508,
0.01837010495364666,
0.10241030156612396,
-0.1518508791923523,
-0.26202714443206787,
0.13357432186603546,
-0.6356794834136963,
0.29661980271339417,
0.16706909239292145,
-0.1877087950706482,
-0.08265556395053864,
0.26287391781806946,
-0.6456146836280823,
0.6471648812294006,
0.09897934645414352,
-0.7045561075210571,
0.43214115500450134,
-0.7430638074874878,
-0.10746095329523087,
0.2721894681453705,
-0.0837218314409256,
-0.5708751678466797,
-0.15332864224910736,
0.2133943885564804,
0.22231082618236542,
-0.46608683466911316,
0.3242391347885132,
-0.2607784867286682,
-0.23595726490020752,
-0.3130068778991699,
-0.17317132651805878,
1.042773962020874,
0.44634419679641724,
-0.06103387102484703,
0.4884691536426544,
-0.7613881826400757,
-0.015857890248298645,
0.23156094551086426,
-0.2835049033164978,
-0.27137404680252075,
-0.023598892614245415,
0.1510397344827652,
0.015344700776040554,
0.3078691065311432,
-0.34170639514923096,
-0.20110578835010529,
-0.38298019766807556,
0.3699660301208496,
0.6549636721611023,
-0.3552802801132202,
0.5070369243621826,
-0.30549395084381104,
0.6910615563392639,
0.021485809236764908,
0.48398932814598083,
-0.5974880456924438,
-0.3265633285045624,
-0.7703624963760376,
-0.5275915265083313,
0.16867798566818237,
0.7921267747879028,
-0.6778764724731445,
0.5726577639579773,
0.05706455931067467,
-0.6550236344337463,
-0.8526734113693237,
-0.03218785673379898,
0.5847181677818298,
0.04125737026333809,
0.5013684034347534,
0.078437939286232,
-0.43482232093811035,
-0.9554412961006165,
-0.1392945796251297,
-0.3447023928165436,
0.1669541746377945,
0.1614050567150116,
0.7816861271858215,
-0.47649234533309937,
0.6965653300285339,
-0.017529893666505814,
-0.21052993834018707,
-0.40161097049713135,
0.23715607821941376,
0.13378892838954926,
0.6976239681243896,
0.6145051717758179,
-0.6049924492835999,
-0.43348079919815063,
0.051378119736909866,
-0.8379434943199158,
0.2039027065038681,
0.018822362646460533,
-0.019338946789503098,
0.3338196575641632,
0.5143539309501648,
-0.32781851291656494,
-0.022758258506655693,
1.0673651695251465,
-0.06603964418172836,
0.7678678035736084,
-0.49467572569847107,
0.23898136615753174,
-1.2702220678329468,
0.1274605393409729,
-0.31481993198394775,
0.14721910655498505,
-0.5397149324417114,
0.4769190549850464,
0.18540574610233307,
-0.32772114872932434,
-0.7897246479988098,
0.5254923701286316,
-0.5137667655944824,
0.16575807332992554,
-0.01787312887609005,
-0.029943957924842834,
-0.2865099608898163,
0.2121516764163971,
-0.028071889653801918,
0.8100395202636719,
0.8458062410354614,
-0.6645727157592773,
0.16187089681625366,
0.2533247172832489,
-0.3010435104370117,
0.42076653242111206,
-0.5704197883605957,
0.22199368476867676,
-0.12548980116844177,
-0.3892512023448944,
-0.1126684918999672,
-0.10727722942829132,
0.17823979258537292,
-0.16511383652687073,
0.060618672519922256,
-0.030415713787078857,
-0.8166786432266235,
-0.18125028908252716,
0.05235590785741806,
0.5218210220336914,
0.46628594398498535,
-0.4921278953552246,
0.46851998567581177,
0.5851483345031738,
-0.20334012806415558,
-0.6605880856513977,
-0.5697330236434937,
0.22766581177711487,
-0.10430480539798737,
-0.6419736742973328,
0.13134466111660004,
-0.30563485622406006,
-0.3759024739265442,
-0.09536914527416229,
0.5153822898864746,
-0.3431876301765442,
0.23784847557544708,
0.0550285279750824,
0.21945418417453766,
-0.20841260254383087,
0.11688120663166046,
-0.07514053583145142,
-0.34705668687820435,
-0.0793672576546669,
-0.09475471824407578,
0.3638606667518616,
-0.5160136818885803,
-0.5424866676330566,
-0.2849378287792206,
0.5508453249931335,
0.9481189250946045,
-0.6796874403953552,
1.1972380876541138,
0.28868260979652405,
-0.3603096604347229,
0.03815516084432602,
-0.4567664861679077,
-0.05766788497567177,
-0.402584433555603,
0.5453064441680908,
-0.2754332721233368,
-1.185645341873169,
0.2926885783672333,
-0.04916561767458916,
0.3984411656856537,
0.2949739992618561,
0.26781585812568665,
0.1579662710428238,
1.0201327800750732,
0.9408869743347168,
-0.38821205496788025,
0.44787684082984924,
0.10175611823797226,
0.11004038155078888,
-0.5900318026542664,
-0.14487871527671814,
-0.5963510870933533,
0.1304224133491516,
-0.43905219435691833,
-0.18170227110385895,
0.4297162592411041,
0.18169713020324707,
-0.43573737144470215,
0.3511855900287628,
-0.2952798306941986,
0.4871852695941925,
0.7780975699424744,
-0.27234581112861633,
0.35183990001678467,
-0.18115685880184174,
-0.34166035056114197,
-0.15012162923812866,
-0.7071585059165955,
-0.6274052262306213,
1.1693062782287598,
0.3845321238040924,
0.8072049021720886,
0.10947995632886887,
0.8190034031867981,
-0.041088689118623734,
0.31151577830314636,
-0.3124764561653137,
0.3540113568305969,
-0.14845769107341766,
-0.8783349394798279,
-0.1510932296514511,
-0.48199382424354553,
-0.8910377621650696,
0.22089460492134094,
-0.5572275519371033,
-0.4437818229198456,
-0.40906697511672974,
0.3515762388706207,
-0.2310594618320465,
0.3362295925617218,
-0.8085455298423767,
1.0517300367355347,
-0.622763991355896,
-0.24061472713947296,
-0.5055035352706909,
-0.4955776333808899,
0.4097229242324829,
-0.5409753322601318,
0.7019656300544739,
-0.15843580663204193,
0.20969444513320923,
0.5325815677642822,
-0.33788368105888367,
0.5827743411064148,
0.03919706866145134,
0.25177687406539917,
0.21365368366241455,
-0.05340047553181648,
0.30016788840293884,
-0.08195386081933975,
-0.21141979098320007,
0.5181325674057007,
-0.27637043595314026,
-0.39496859908103943,
0.012275753542780876,
0.5092387199401855,
-0.9634447693824768,
-0.5009326934814453,
-0.4471917450428009,
-0.4506012499332428,
0.24532853066921234,
0.5371164679527283,
0.3463464081287384,
0.0880412682890892,
-0.3780178427696228,
0.29921796917915344,
0.22496849298477173,
-0.48413288593292236,
0.30680355429649353,
0.7850714325904846,
-0.6489851474761963,
-0.7266879677772522,
0.8937569260597229,
0.10897766798734665,
0.3575180172920227,
0.38467729091644287,
0.0661802887916565,
0.11827462911605835,
-0.559770405292511,
-0.41630423069000244,
0.4143560528755188,
-0.4014403820037842,
0.15504997968673706,
-0.7974041104316711,
-0.18696214258670807,
-0.11363101750612259,
-0.4005928039550781,
-0.8894762396812439,
-0.22103801369667053,
-0.3108137249946594,
-0.015382925979793072,
0.16338521242141724,
0.6635867357254028,
-0.10191577672958374,
0.29695358872413635,
-0.9740580916404724,
0.2370648831129074,
0.09099913388490677,
0.5058778524398804,
-0.36643803119659424,
-0.10872379690408707,
-0.5900482535362244,
0.06678104400634766,
-0.2358654886484146,
-0.4539797604084015,
0.2735307216644287,
0.13676831126213074,
0.550538182258606,
0.13335955142974854,
0.14777466654777527,
0.4528951644897461,
-0.7689992189407349,
0.7139955163002014,
0.5731084942817688,
-0.9694397449493408,
0.6179549098014832,
-0.1596875637769699,
0.35663408041000366,
0.45530614256858826,
0.3619517683982849,
-0.3749517798423767,
-0.8851326704025269,
-0.4710763096809387,
-0.8459264039993286,
0.9124096035957336,
0.3780750334262848,
0.07380523532629013,
-0.3194924592971802,
0.22916167974472046,
0.10751613229513168,
0.3454330861568451,
-1.0488778352737427,
-0.3998807370662689,
-0.28717052936553955,
-0.10777288675308228,
-0.4151492416858673,
-0.18859484791755676,
0.035392578691244125,
0.02119649201631546,
0.6683946251869202,
-0.002543798880651593,
0.027795301750302315,
-0.13158434629440308,
-0.26111599802970886,
-0.20831602811813354,
0.33459657430648804,
0.5941686630249023,
0.5357069969177246,
-0.10106821358203888,
0.08886988461017609,
0.10451235622167587,
-0.3623395562171936,
0.10725370049476624,
0.047520607709884644,
-0.39838361740112305,
-0.2310483157634735,
0.3778221607208252,
0.6087727546691895,
0.17894820868968964,
-0.7248648405075073,
0.5148621797561646,
0.054131511598825455,
-0.3081730008125305,
-0.5363205075263977,
-0.07617022097110748,
0.02765623852610588,
0.20023398101329803,
0.11444894969463348,
0.36922135949134827,
-0.30276504158973694,
-0.4555894434452057,
0.19401425123214722,
0.5106844305992126,
-0.5425477623939514,
-0.5422242879867554,
0.9580362439155579,
0.35285723209381104,
-0.32176539301872253,
0.8078917264938354,
-0.3510550558567047,
-0.49636340141296387,
0.39095354080200195,
0.46766766905784607,
0.9604448080062866,
-0.4247119724750519,
0.029135853052139282,
0.7141776084899902,
0.9446393847465515,
-0.20068670809268951,
0.3804570138454437,
0.5277420878410339,
-0.7443440556526184,
-0.34153977036476135,
-0.5053110718727112,
-0.6307966113090515,
0.10278736799955368,
-0.5302332043647766,
0.5340914726257324,
-0.511339008808136,
-0.10083496570587158,
-0.39001598954200745,
-0.36266279220581055,
-0.4718438684940338,
0.10838088393211365,
0.007799413055181503,
0.876338541507721,
-0.6994972229003906,
0.7120654582977295,
0.6542235016822815,
-0.5705791711807251,
-0.4317421019077301,
-0.3620958924293518,
0.14271675050258636,
-0.8293125629425049,
0.40824925899505615,
0.28995436429977417,
-0.2113412469625473,
0.12454669922590256,
-0.33356085419654846,
-0.8617154359817505,
1.0545796155929565,
0.6160427331924438,
-0.7530856132507324,
-0.0564887709915638,
0.05766315385699272,
0.24528923630714417,
-0.4838961660861969,
0.22360587120056152,
0.02467627264559269,
0.3273228704929352,
-0.2296331226825714,
-1.1619677543640137,
-0.392132043838501,
-0.20492544770240784,
-0.38919371366500854,
0.31797176599502563,
-0.9795403480529785,
1.1740212440490723,
-0.5353837609291077,
-0.20031291246414185,
0.17665033042430878,
0.466315358877182,
0.393978476524353,
0.22590851783752441,
0.44688680768013,
0.5618724822998047,
0.6915917992591858,
-0.011907889507710934,
0.8808140754699707,
-0.5808171629905701,
0.2581050395965576,
0.822960376739502,
-0.36464616656303406,
1.014386773109436,
0.34764784574508667,
-0.052481357008218765,
0.36811545491218567,
0.2979167699813843,
0.10217354446649551,
0.5846993327140808,
-0.175143763422966,
-0.2026023119688034,
-0.111908920109272,
-0.031330566853284836,
-0.3054695427417755,
0.20264515280723572,
0.15541638433933258,
-0.3486194610595703,
0.09370255470275879,
0.16103921830654144,
0.17207275331020355,
0.002506292425096035,
-0.3695988059043884,
0.711280107498169,
0.191149041056633,
-0.7733379602432251,
0.550337016582489,
-0.01464020274579525,
0.6018421053886414,
-0.6915469169616699,
0.23316821455955505,
-0.003707081777974963,
0.3776452839374542,
-0.08469972014427185,
-0.365853488445282,
0.4709468185901642,
0.29888689517974854,
-0.19808700680732727,
-0.2871745824813843,
-0.01863030530512333,
-0.46034881472587585,
-0.6477972865104675,
0.7843904495239258,
0.5490760803222656,
0.0627007931470871,
-0.23765380680561066,
-0.8438851237297058,
0.268962562084198,
-0.2288970947265625,
-0.023019319400191307,
0.24540679156780243,
0.1602395623922348,
0.11750603467226028,
0.7597138285636902,
0.583418071269989,
0.04131195694208145,
0.16818805038928986,
0.10848692804574966,
0.6263149976730347,
-0.5710017681121826,
-0.6305639743804932,
-0.6697114109992981,
0.768519401550293,
0.4210473597049713,
-0.3750261664390564,
0.5932862162590027,
0.6290531754493713,
0.7689487934112549,
-0.026276664808392525,
0.8207312226295471,
0.1446533203125,
0.6742064356803894,
-0.6353058815002441,
0.9937410354614258,
-0.8379704356193542,
0.23754458129405975,
-0.29555246233940125,
-0.9869601130485535,
-0.6228629350662231,
0.4362412691116333,
-0.003407603595405817,
0.10468778014183044,
0.8289668560028076,
0.7218894958496094,
0.07485242933034897,
-0.14173609018325806,
0.4023493528366089,
0.10744046419858932,
0.3714560866355896,
0.5284848213195801,
0.8797086477279663,
-0.3877725899219513,
0.6832204461097717,
-0.361014187335968,
-0.4365765154361725,
-0.20969483256340027,
-0.7920594215393066,
-1.0241851806640625,
-0.5477781295776367,
-0.4812585413455963,
0.06832165271043777,
0.04996924102306366,
1.1751805543899536,
0.8616625666618347,
-0.7648852467536926,
-0.36718761920928955,
-0.32862600684165955,
0.005683675408363342,
-0.18255913257598877,
-0.09499330818653107,
0.0025571277365088463,
-0.44219979643821716,
-0.6935684084892273,
0.6572436690330505,
0.46230801939964294,
0.11994495242834091,
-0.3315527141094208,
-0.5117540955543518,
-0.14916816353797913,
-0.10460696369409561,
0.46201902627944946,
0.2723325192928314,
-0.9165133833885193,
-0.29877540469169617,
0.250234454870224,
-0.09722423553466797,
0.051805175840854645,
0.3063514828681946,
-0.29412591457366943,
0.6891145706176758,
-0.09509513527154922,
0.4040580093860626,
0.06298574060201645,
-0.3435828387737274,
0.7066230773925781,
-0.5763439536094666,
0.31628450751304626,
0.24051587283611298,
0.5456578731536865,
0.2878490090370178,
-0.020264841616153717,
0.25559139251708984,
0.10095018148422241,
-0.7386181354522705,
-0.6920267939567566,
0.38747867941856384,
-0.47674134373664856,
-0.0559961199760437,
0.63956218957901,
-0.2827487885951996,
0.04318654164671898,
-0.15901066362857819,
-0.11340779811143875,
-0.0673610046505928,
-0.28515782952308655,
0.7243760824203491,
0.5895487070083618,
0.2834301292896271,
-0.6898671984672546,
-0.35036537051200867,
0.1615287959575653,
0.42345210909843445,
-0.8025045394897461,
0.09223771840333939,
0.3829995393753052,
-0.1744709461927414,
0.49997252225875854,
0.7303218245506287,
-0.08142662793397903,
0.38156893849372864,
0.16217829287052155,
0.4502990245819092,
-0.12043610960245132,
-0.8376545310020447,
-0.44211190938949585,
0.23577052354812622,
0.41295474767684937,
-0.20079049468040466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00397v1
|
An Analysis of BPE Vocabulary Trimming in Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-30T15:29:49 | 2024-03-30T15:29:49 |
Marco Cognetta, Tatsuya Hiraoka, Naoaki Okazaki, Rico Sennrich, Yuval Pinter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore threshold vocabulary trimming in Byte-Pair Encoding subword
tokenization, a postprocessing step that replaces rare subwords with their
component subwords. The technique is available in popular tokenization
libraries but has not been subjected to rigorous scientific scrutiny. While the
removal of rare subwords is suggested as best practice in machine translation
implementations, both as a means to reduce model size and for improving model
performance through robustness, our experiments indicate that, across a large
space of hyperparameter settings, vocabulary trimming fails to improve
performance, and is even prone to incurring heavy degradation.
|
[
-0.6997401118278503,
-0.7006280422210693,
-0.019990429282188416,
0.0326688289642334,
-0.7190870046615601,
-0.11733317375183105,
0.014059058390557766,
-0.45680609345436096,
0.3646593689918518,
0.5497558116912842,
-0.399441123008728,
-0.32651329040527344,
-0.8845944404602051,
-0.01675473339855671,
-0.2998044788837433,
1.030758023262024,
0.1482180655002594,
0.17002584040164948,
0.17482417821884155,
-0.16478672623634338,
-0.8313547968864441,
-0.8424230217933655,
-0.7415618896484375,
-0.30878761410713196,
0.5063788890838623,
-0.07960856705904007,
0.8657830357551575,
0.8970484733581543,
0.853549063205719,
0.2204779088497162,
-0.6574459671974182,
0.19403840601444244,
-0.34803301095962524,
0.18905256688594818,
-0.3325895667076111,
-0.3303115665912628,
-0.6873658895492554,
-0.06728462874889374,
0.8314829468727112,
1.346012830734253,
0.21438661217689514,
-0.14439791440963745,
0.09529026597738266,
0.5681514143943787,
-0.564114511013031,
-0.1419992744922638,
-0.9611068367958069,
0.19173334538936615,
-0.3166499435901642,
-0.1307789534330368,
-0.2011982649564743,
0.38746321201324463,
0.1590804159641266,
-0.16785749793052673,
0.3478015065193176,
0.11170518398284912,
1.0638070106506348,
0.36242637038230896,
-0.09912897646427155,
0.17852266132831573,
-0.424609512090683,
0.9380408525466919,
-0.6926021575927734,
0.3931257128715515,
0.4841206967830658,
-0.28904739022254944,
-0.16781221330165863,
-0.8055865168571472,
-0.09394898265600204,
0.16621336340904236,
0.008074373938143253,
-0.040624357759952545,
-0.4718194603919983,
0.5137795209884644,
0.36143800616264343,
0.509008526802063,
-0.4088541269302368,
0.24132251739501953,
-0.6795922517776489,
-0.45067015290260315,
0.15201829373836517,
0.16567572951316833,
0.11823344975709915,
-0.3604755699634552,
-0.44300878047943115,
0.4161768853664398,
-0.6788426637649536,
-0.05572495982050896,
0.2583368122577667,
0.2930344045162201,
0.3546496331691742,
0.6372178792953491,
0.1704031527042389,
0.7762060165405273,
-0.32591691613197327,
0.4314725697040558,
0.16187836229801178,
-0.49018770456314087,
-0.34226563572883606,
-0.209690123796463,
0.3778848946094513,
0.7174698710441589,
0.1680176556110382,
-0.4191752076148987,
-0.45329782366752625,
-0.04919365793466568,
0.4619743824005127,
-0.781525194644928,
0.0714774876832962,
0.3968665301799774,
-0.7187606692314148,
0.15535585582256317,
-0.15996022522449493,
-0.4360322654247284,
-0.09455947577953339,
-0.09369716048240662,
0.18236149847507477,
-0.7007156014442444,
-0.05542782321572304,
0.15434342622756958,
-0.5472670197486877,
0.16761590540409088,
-0.15331773459911346,
-0.8824173212051392,
0.45995157957077026,
0.8656458854675293,
1.1816118955612183,
-0.45418012142181396,
-0.4393867552280426,
-0.4636060893535614,
-0.0493241511285305,
-0.654828667640686,
0.2709611654281616,
-0.33592331409454346,
-0.6948689818382263,
-0.17029619216918945,
0.0009374980581924319,
-0.13918717205524445,
-0.9595900774002075,
0.45992305874824524,
-0.6789482831954956,
-0.5340335965156555,
-0.24323789775371552,
-0.837050199508667,
-0.09985238313674927,
0.020734941586852074,
-0.481669157743454,
0.757887601852417,
0.17464643716812134,
-0.5396249890327454,
0.7700127959251404,
-0.41901353001594543,
-0.4068199098110199,
0.3553845286369324,
0.2572663128376007,
-0.14639246463775635,
0.49864858388900757,
0.027555497363209724,
0.4255598783493042,
-0.02120799757540226,
-0.11942001432180405,
0.09179768711328506,
-0.7000989317893982,
0.11482515186071396,
-0.26102250814437866,
0.48133063316345215,
0.3442193269729614,
-0.1619451642036438,
0.07161583006381989,
-0.5047348141670227,
0.16282767057418823,
-0.26455503702163696,
-0.22364981472492218,
-0.5926347374916077,
-0.13035725057125092,
0.21139895915985107,
0.1453767567873001,
0.2938825786113739,
-0.5880721211433411,
0.30459168553352356,
-0.8423111438751221,
0.5955163240432739,
0.5436352491378784,
0.3253382742404938,
0.4324842095375061,
-0.33493342995643616,
0.3680986166000366,
0.3950314223766327,
0.08074481785297394,
0.0498834066092968,
-0.6111668944358826,
-0.7940326929092407,
-0.4437914192676544,
0.6284039616584778,
0.5325314402580261,
-0.4516533315181732,
0.6464266777038574,
-0.22447887063026428,
-0.262586772441864,
-0.6897239089012146,
0.41819220781326294,
0.49865734577178955,
0.2853860855102539,
0.6481578946113586,
-0.9095256924629211,
-0.6283683776855469,
-1.1843277215957642,
-0.3767368197441101,
0.1937522143125534,
-0.2189430296421051,
-0.005135738756507635,
0.48212167620658875,
-0.3286968767642975,
0.7272619605064392,
0.011809765361249447,
-0.11641375720500946,
-0.3487299084663391,
0.4002130329608917,
0.25666454434394836,
1.0444124937057495,
0.43208685517311096,
-0.6380678415298462,
-0.08935277163982391,
-0.26135173439979553,
-0.25485241413116455,
0.07535499334335327,
-0.11847385764122009,
-0.11249358206987381,
0.3314337730407715,
0.7326791286468506,
-0.6620038151741028,
0.7157462239265442,
0.22183269262313843,
-0.030016610398888588,
0.266761839389801,
-0.26435983180999756,
-0.08466288447380066,
-0.841788113117218,
0.0373699888586998,
-0.16745033860206604,
-0.17242896556854248,
-0.6926785111427307,
0.2575645446777344,
-0.21301871538162231,
0.13433049619197845,
-0.7743174433708191,
0.24993139505386353,
-0.5675979256629944,
-0.20944291353225708,
-0.550754725933075,
-0.06399627774953842,
-0.1567377895116806,
0.15048184990882874,
0.1568361520767212,
0.7628879547119141,
0.5168471932411194,
-0.765564501285553,
0.0856316015124321,
0.2172098010778427,
-0.29252293705940247,
0.2660585343837738,
-0.849009096622467,
0.21084275841712952,
-0.22866110503673553,
-0.24861998856067657,
-0.8352848291397095,
0.17754697799682617,
0.060304734855890274,
-0.5225749015808105,
0.4166097640991211,
-0.47251439094543457,
-0.46195629239082336,
-0.08962111920118332,
-0.13963064551353455,
0.3130381107330322,
0.709719181060791,
0.028897123411297798,
0.00786587130278349,
0.4567461907863617,
-0.10926862806081772,
-0.5801800489425659,
-1.069156289100647,
0.3929206430912018,
-0.035438746213912964,
-0.49930375814437866,
0.7334099411964417,
0.18364208936691284,
-0.251154363155365,
0.1580812633037567,
-0.33135896921157837,
-0.20547173917293549,
0.20028835535049438,
0.032109975814819336,
0.2136506289243698,
-0.04842827841639519,
0.09262416511774063,
0.1290847510099411,
-0.12089210748672485,
0.032236963510513306,
-0.4023202657699585,
1.0165190696716309,
-0.1846872717142105,
-0.12418236583471298,
-0.2458891123533249,
0.644058883190155,
0.4456532299518585,
-0.2742673456668854,
1.1141772270202637,
0.8051689267158508,
-0.6752488017082214,
-0.08112749457359314,
-0.2785148322582245,
-0.3040889799594879,
-0.4193621277809143,
0.8041019439697266,
-0.779094934463501,
-0.7508609890937805,
0.6807894706726074,
0.05709628760814667,
0.19685029983520508,
0.3505941927433014,
0.39365240931510925,
-0.25631675124168396,
0.9330220222473145,
0.6570668816566467,
0.06856730580329895,
0.33122682571411133,
-0.33769339323043823,
0.2750968039035797,
-0.9633861184120178,
0.07196549326181412,
-0.41356563568115234,
-0.5397872924804688,
-0.7834136486053467,
-0.5546370148658752,
0.3416121006011963,
0.36026737093925476,
0.1613767445087433,
0.47242799401283264,
-0.39505720138549805,
0.5668216943740845,
0.8351641893386841,
0.11112769693136215,
-0.09321533143520355,
0.059168633073568344,
-0.17186713218688965,
-0.38257351517677307,
-0.8430081009864807,
-0.47365424036979675,
0.7886941432952881,
0.21679341793060303,
0.12445743381977081,
-0.17498187720775604,
0.6294209957122803,
0.3157051205635071,
-0.06774662435054779,
-1.2430015802383423,
0.6288407444953918,
-0.38566282391548157,
-0.9143418669700623,
-0.38240933418273926,
-0.512903094291687,
-1.1802153587341309,
0.32622551918029785,
-0.20555898547172546,
-0.7582733631134033,
0.012547567486763,
-0.01715259440243244,
-0.251249760389328,
0.6410737037658691,
-0.461876779794693,
0.8923168778419495,
0.26107263565063477,
-0.22657927870750427,
-0.44337254762649536,
-0.894517183303833,
0.08003571629524231,
-0.034150101244449615,
-0.18825842440128326,
0.1629437953233719,
-0.5295079350471497,
0.8503591418266296,
-0.7591904997825623,
0.5963844060897827,
-0.16555437445640564,
0.3184068500995636,
0.2494584321975708,
0.33650678396224976,
0.2948826849460602,
-0.5066987872123718,
-0.046192966401576996,
0.5232186913490295,
0.2431953102350235,
-0.9873890280723572,
-0.2910919189453125,
0.34135371446609497,
-0.4795011281967163,
-0.6722837090492249,
-0.3618607223033905,
-0.7897034883499146,
-0.4640194773674011,
0.29411283135414124,
0.555292010307312,
0.15135470032691956,
0.019522791728377342,
0.42702242732048035,
0.6535341739654541,
-0.19400519132614136,
0.5868418216705322,
-0.0224571842700243,
0.022490007802844048,
-0.40263471007347107,
0.8246914744377136,
0.6057894825935364,
0.24814511835575104,
0.25291574001312256,
-0.14466507732868195,
-0.16698084771633148,
-1.2531598806381226,
-0.3410118818283081,
0.14382070302963257,
-0.6308647990226746,
0.17637479305267334,
-0.5852988362312317,
-0.43347829580307007,
-0.5811858177185059,
-0.1515367329120636,
-0.35157281160354614,
-0.46288493275642395,
0.0645250678062439,
-0.23229140043258667,
0.03298139199614525,
0.44907253980636597,
-0.062335867434740067,
0.5791913866996765,
-1.313530683517456,
-0.08071339875459671,
-0.041621096432209015,
0.050738561898469925,
-0.3041418194770813,
-0.6918187141418457,
-0.3677130937576294,
-0.30862271785736084,
0.0832495167851448,
-0.7728320956230164,
0.5186826586723328,
0.05504949390888214,
0.5370270609855652,
0.2285514771938324,
-0.18492630124092102,
0.6153616309165955,
-0.4925055503845215,
0.992662787437439,
0.1609850376844406,
-1.2817829847335815,
0.2791736125946045,
-0.3805173635482788,
0.3564821183681488,
0.44768476486206055,
0.4823963940143585,
-0.8622850179672241,
-0.21483176946640015,
-0.6241391897201538,
-1.3509994745254517,
0.31727880239486694,
0.16901491582393646,
0.4454485774040222,
-0.10203205794095993,
0.6169942021369934,
0.16311408579349518,
0.5186001658439636,
-0.24203771352767944,
-0.5011496543884277,
-0.003456398379057646,
0.06382417678833008,
-0.04379555210471153,
-0.41939789056777954,
0.15498369932174683,
-0.27075710892677307,
0.777533233165741,
0.23819108307361603,
0.07081668078899384,
0.15730689465999603,
-0.04901991784572601,
-0.0649048313498497,
0.1214015856385231,
0.2763727605342865,
0.6698042750358582,
-0.2034527212381363,
0.06671243160963058,
0.30624160170555115,
-0.6773789525032043,
-0.17953169345855713,
-0.1764001101255417,
-0.37877339124679565,
0.30451101064682007,
0.3702520728111267,
0.571692168712616,
-0.07285737991333008,
-0.5707254409790039,
0.40885111689567566,
0.2103368639945984,
-0.1872672140598297,
0.2079983800649643,
-0.2738795280456543,
0.0006343452841974795,
-0.2843979299068451,
0.09572501480579376,
0.4365975856781006,
0.13935230672359467,
-0.44948872923851013,
0.4785308837890625,
0.47136813402175903,
-0.6952123641967773,
-0.18284353613853455,
0.4787217378616333,
0.0785495936870575,
-0.22365710139274597,
0.7219625115394592,
-0.2792973816394806,
-0.515993058681488,
0.5920212864875793,
0.39752933382987976,
0.7749131917953491,
0.081666961312294,
-0.09358138591051102,
0.16183724999427795,
0.922758162021637,
0.3785676658153534,
0.3177596628665924,
0.10723048448562622,
-0.6426280736923218,
-0.6658677458763123,
-0.7666774392127991,
-0.34959876537323,
0.38286131620407104,
-0.6343055367469788,
0.08671605587005615,
-0.639463484287262,
-0.5647129416465759,
0.07315139472484589,
-0.18019996583461761,
-0.44335201382637024,
0.25510674715042114,
0.010876921936869621,
0.9001950025558472,
-0.5486615300178528,
0.8469468355178833,
0.9587815999984741,
-0.5917340517044067,
-0.5199130177497864,
0.016861947253346443,
-0.2599777579307556,
-0.6320165991783142,
0.702250599861145,
-0.056453097611665726,
0.01878422498703003,
-0.08795661479234695,
-0.21025443077087402,
-0.7537760138511658,
0.3302747309207916,
0.19804760813713074,
-0.4472159445285797,
-0.02866167575120926,
0.3580861985683441,
0.585426926612854,
0.11474736779928207,
-0.11556269973516464,
0.7006961107254028,
0.4267810583114624,
-0.17153522372245789,
-1.0132005214691162,
-0.020477106794714928,
-0.35777029395103455,
0.2785934507846832,
0.3792343735694885,
-0.7651558518409729,
0.9447113871574402,
0.40421703457832336,
0.0923401340842247,
0.24548490345478058,
0.6764699816703796,
-0.26082950830459595,
0.00927459541708231,
0.5924622416496277,
0.6795522570610046,
0.6007310152053833,
-0.052966248244047165,
0.6987654566764832,
-0.5716053247451782,
-0.004268859978765249,
0.6740401387214661,
-0.07989410310983658,
0.6682643890380859,
0.9119961857795715,
-0.09370946884155273,
-0.18858300149440765,
0.8081641793251038,
0.03134974092245102,
0.36715584993362427,
0.5713954567909241,
-0.21348418295383453,
-0.4158354699611664,
-0.45695754885673523,
-0.2624422609806061,
0.5689810514450073,
0.44030338525772095,
-0.5565350651741028,
0.0817798599600792,
-0.07728827744722366,
0.1573558896780014,
-0.08086369186639786,
-0.6371934413909912,
0.5506470799446106,
0.2596219778060913,
-0.6642400026321411,
0.7929841876029968,
0.33850353956222534,
0.7125035524368286,
-0.44644615054130554,
0.08180619031190872,
-0.35574406385421753,
0.13287568092346191,
-0.1533007025718689,
-0.4149239659309387,
0.9374832510948181,
0.016576644033193588,
-0.18435801565647125,
-0.2617928981781006,
0.7308809757232666,
-0.10690394788980484,
-0.1107872873544693,
0.32492390275001526,
0.8871006965637207,
0.7142188549041748,
-0.038427382707595825,
-0.6820505857467651,
-0.08006566017866135,
-0.31524592638015747,
-0.2868264615535736,
0.3756367862224579,
0.36889323592185974,
-0.010878062807023525,
0.384822279214859,
0.5455795526504517,
0.6436451077461243,
0.45550814270973206,
0.0952553078532219,
0.6232935786247253,
-0.6640393733978271,
-0.24129116535186768,
-0.835971474647522,
0.15140679478645325,
0.029423430562019348,
-0.5333613753318787,
0.7538782954216003,
0.7856610417366028,
0.9926045536994934,
-0.1244732066988945,
0.7205135822296143,
0.010548889636993408,
0.2471238523721695,
-0.5499044060707092,
0.6508467197418213,
-0.5564289093017578,
0.11590801179409027,
-0.21583327651023865,
-0.9365853667259216,
-0.44181302189826965,
0.25867682695388794,
-0.18830640614032745,
-0.06882647424936295,
0.9794567227363586,
0.9059861302375793,
-0.0002515781670808792,
-0.2747589945793152,
0.8406739234924316,
0.10091255605220795,
-0.1406581550836563,
0.3373701572418213,
0.5959494709968567,
-0.46717700362205505,
0.6078387498855591,
-0.23795895278453827,
-0.20471136271953583,
0.0902341976761818,
-0.6443657279014587,
-0.7955284118652344,
-0.47225508093833923,
-0.21806621551513672,
-0.3824653625488281,
0.2793916165828705,
1.1676299571990967,
0.8564261198043823,
-0.83240807056427,
-0.16534607112407684,
-0.36133885383605957,
0.021749794483184814,
-0.6934541463851929,
-0.1675959676504135,
0.16054122149944305,
-0.6974608898162842,
-1.0966099500656128,
0.4415672719478607,
0.20180906355381012,
0.15445861220359802,
-0.11123902350664139,
0.3174561858177185,
-0.1263311207294464,
0.33121636509895325,
0.24361735582351685,
-0.08186419308185577,
-0.5105024576187134,
-0.2541845142841339,
-0.010637742467224598,
-0.07669493556022644,
0.061047278344631195,
0.8219019770622253,
-0.28269240260124207,
0.11790934205055237,
0.6589635610580444,
1.0185391902923584,
0.4940478801727295,
-0.06023962050676346,
0.36750298738479614,
-1.0661946535110474,
0.37461090087890625,
0.562692403793335,
0.5654422044754028,
0.13791082799434662,
-0.16564202308654785,
0.3841768503189087,
0.7612701654434204,
-0.2666099965572357,
-0.7691712379455566,
0.35300737619400024,
-0.8041335344314575,
-0.4709469974040985,
0.9552611112594604,
-0.37038683891296387,
-0.49097511172294617,
-0.4025033712387085,
-0.14923785626888275,
0.3494437038898468,
-0.1471806764602661,
0.42171570658683777,
1.0656311511993408,
0.01709672436118126,
0.09726565331220627,
-0.4448522627353668,
0.3165026605129242,
1.2103195190429688,
-0.18535809218883514,
-0.034876059740781784,
0.44520482420921326,
0.13553979992866516,
0.15990106761455536,
0.4246987998485565,
-0.18103766441345215,
0.15925146639347076,
0.33402132987976074,
0.22084997594356537,
-0.005411235615611076,
-0.21410001814365387,
-0.36114609241485596,
0.36991506814956665,
0.09317656606435776,
-0.5227041244506836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00386v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00386v1
|
Jetsons at FinNLP 2024: Towards Understanding the ESG Impact of a News Article using Transformer-based Models
| 2024-03-30T14:58:44 | 2024-03-30T14:58:44 |
Parag Pravin Dakle, Alolika Gon, Sihan Zha, Liang Wang, SaiKrishna Rallabandi, Preethi Raghavan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we describe the different approaches explored by the Jetsons
team for the Multi-Lingual ESG Impact Duration Inference (ML-ESG-3) shared
task. The shared task focuses on predicting the duration and type of the ESG
impact of a news article. The shared task dataset consists of 2,059 news titles
and articles in English, French, Korean, and Japanese languages. For the impact
duration classification task, we fine-tuned XLM-RoBERTa with a custom
fine-tuning strategy and using self-training and DeBERTa-v3 using only English
translations. These models individually ranked first on the leaderboard for
Korean and Japanese and in an ensemble for the English language, respectively.
For the impact type classification task, our XLM-RoBERTa model fine-tuned using
a custom fine-tuning strategy ranked first for the English language.
|
[
-0.48226162791252136,
-0.7549580335617065,
0.4934905469417572,
0.16072894632816315,
-0.3023812770843506,
0.016572410240769386,
-0.2396111637353897,
-0.7258248925209045,
0.36997735500335693,
0.6769964098930359,
-0.7975397109985352,
-0.2141052633523941,
-0.8844373226165771,
0.49470141530036926,
-0.13969045877456665,
1.3116703033447266,
0.08013739436864853,
0.19882333278656006,
0.06654834002256393,
-0.0765015184879303,
-0.11142058670520782,
-0.07787668704986572,
-0.6992817521095276,
-0.14844438433647156,
0.8052661418914795,
0.22171944379806519,
0.5037155151367188,
0.3377872705459595,
0.4693029224872589,
0.18968386948108673,
-0.5451539754867554,
0.28086477518081665,
-0.4272717535495758,
-0.26788896322250366,
-0.10129555314779282,
-0.40567725896835327,
-0.10342659056186676,
0.0008300160989165306,
0.592923104763031,
0.5791800618171692,
0.037914857268333435,
0.19026218354701996,
0.13561703264713287,
0.571560800075531,
-0.37917113304138184,
0.03530634194612503,
-0.37636879086494446,
0.39068475365638733,
-0.04654344171285629,
0.08068876713514328,
-0.6103153228759766,
0.11220119893550873,
0.12983274459838867,
-0.7537429332733154,
0.16422787308692932,
-0.07149259746074677,
1.1650770902633667,
0.25696614384651184,
-0.9897696375846863,
-0.2311421036720276,
-0.7884970903396606,
1.0848653316497803,
-0.6053586602210999,
0.6823650598526001,
-0.0707276463508606,
0.072817862033844,
0.054875630885362625,
-0.7293209433555603,
-0.30260488390922546,
-0.016782443970441818,
-0.2875771224498749,
0.31448423862457275,
-0.1304379105567932,
0.21112096309661865,
0.23129403591156006,
0.13006189465522766,
-0.7777323722839355,
0.12968482077121735,
-0.8146632313728333,
0.40419283509254456,
0.7612109184265137,
0.07657388597726822,
0.16080617904663086,
-0.5173822641372681,
-0.46780773997306824,
0.4035451114177704,
-0.8704266548156738,
-0.19416889548301697,
0.6079645752906799,
0.4779621362686157,
-0.1893008053302765,
0.6067225337028503,
-0.2553406059741974,
0.8149555921554565,
0.047911372035741806,
0.059179965406656265,
0.0926331877708435,
-0.3104270100593567,
-0.2544485926628113,
0.036343496292829514,
0.652093768119812,
0.46129900217056274,
-0.04383036494255066,
-0.1766553670167923,
0.08021364361047745,
-0.5596240758895874,
0.5912918448448181,
-0.8516058921813965,
0.30282410979270935,
-0.006719463504850864,
-0.5156446695327759,
-0.34824541211128235,
0.05192083492875099,
-0.5741003155708313,
-0.29055270552635193,
-0.3328736424446106,
0.6846200227737427,
0.02513507753610611,
-0.33685392141342163,
0.5862088203430176,
-0.17749491333961487,
-0.05738984793424606,
0.2512114942073822,
-0.8660143613815308,
0.11657749861478806,
0.6794343590736389,
0.7228403091430664,
-0.21913184225559235,
-0.4346383810043335,
-0.2037513256072998,
0.42162033915519714,
0.2122100293636322,
0.8794752359390259,
-0.23007985949516296,
-0.49552443623542786,
-0.1755530685186386,
0.3346713185310364,
-0.44724565744400024,
0.004929359536617994,
0.7815935611724854,
-0.39591076970100403,
0.6123817563056946,
-0.30603480339050293,
-0.9390760660171509,
-0.7078221440315247,
0.11085769534111023,
-0.897003710269928,
0.7007748484611511,
-0.1171591728925705,
-0.7743520736694336,
0.4703187346458435,
-0.9155884385108948,
-0.6384897232055664,
0.2564984858036041,
-0.26720720529556274,
-0.8161264061927795,
0.12370387464761734,
0.28950315713882446,
0.692400336265564,
0.03165268152952194,
0.2745378315448761,
-0.07053418457508087,
-0.38822394609451294,
-0.2683422565460205,
-0.3036711812019348,
0.9362767338752747,
0.3149217963218689,
-0.4078105688095093,
-0.10813890397548676,
-0.4967891275882721,
-0.19197680056095123,
-0.010031798854470253,
-0.23845025897026062,
-0.09010325372219086,
0.2883932888507843,
0.30475956201553345,
0.10255035758018494,
0.09062318503856659,
-0.5617437958717346,
0.3196905851364136,
0.027186118066310883,
0.233636736869812,
0.3519282937049866,
0.3371839225292206,
0.350782573223114,
-0.18480683863162994,
0.5894879698753357,
-0.24510906636714935,
0.5011645555496216,
-0.15269136428833008,
-0.6892523765563965,
-0.5962903499603271,
0.04149800166487694,
-0.06062315031886101,
0.1665153056383133,
-0.5932704210281372,
0.043701689690351486,
-0.35794028639793396,
-0.6604505777359009,
-0.10336998850107193,
-0.22940972447395325,
0.1387781798839569,
0.11410824209451675,
0.3696463406085968,
0.3584628403186798,
-0.8738709092140198,
-0.8991016745567322,
-0.8514000177383423,
-0.10555399954319,
0.0652981698513031,
0.34066757559776306,
0.42728742957115173,
-0.01332178059965372,
0.6451468467712402,
-0.5195894241333008,
-0.029768140986561775,
-0.7108896970748901,
0.49675822257995605,
0.4675051271915436,
0.14769022166728973,
0.5295400619506836,
-1.0658538341522217,
-0.705894947052002,
0.10365362465381622,
-0.6036163568496704,
0.04463406652212143,
-0.2860797345638275,
0.5118309855461121,
0.28770899772644043,
0.5418035984039307,
-0.6132354736328125,
0.16293154656887054,
0.8277167677879333,
-0.623252809047699,
0.6863345503807068,
0.16987420618534088,
0.5411436557769775,
-1.2459980249404907,
-0.21667158603668213,
0.3069815933704376,
-0.16027601063251495,
-0.7455950975418091,
-0.2674423158168793,
0.09492813795804977,
-0.3949262499809265,
-0.9180881977081299,
0.6294422745704651,
-0.3478524684906006,
-0.19254648685455322,
-0.11299993097782135,
-0.326587051153183,
0.41688233613967896,
0.2030358910560608,
0.33667999505996704,
0.5553472638130188,
-0.007017536088824272,
-0.4379432201385498,
-0.19322054088115692,
-0.06220497936010361,
-0.3219771385192871,
0.3733123540878296,
-0.7463266253471375,
-0.011105284094810486,
-0.011006158776581287,
0.15175695717334747,
-0.5080000162124634,
-0.006452555768191814,
-0.13361677527427673,
-0.4938398003578186,
0.2400587648153305,
-0.4538426101207733,
-0.3350502848625183,
-0.5263866186141968,
-0.05013100430369377,
0.05612587183713913,
0.19056105613708496,
-0.5970317125320435,
0.803673267364502,
0.36202889680862427,
-0.01993156224489212,
-0.7801181674003601,
-0.5643205046653748,
0.11898846179246902,
-0.6444071531295776,
-0.743320107460022,
0.5124437808990479,
0.15519435703754425,
-0.09644629806280136,
0.24091583490371704,
-0.1111266165971756,
-0.08820239454507828,
0.18704380095005035,
0.19729705154895782,
0.1277303695678711,
-0.2387504130601883,
-0.1160183772444725,
0.19827409088611603,
0.10571329295635223,
-0.17114359140396118,
0.03453504666686058,
0.11393968015909195,
-0.3463618755340576,
-0.17928458750247955,
-0.3786679208278656,
0.36612430214881897,
0.6110167503356934,
-0.10456372797489166,
1.1163017749786377,
0.8987438678741455,
-0.30412018299102783,
-0.08849119395017624,
-0.6032246947288513,
-0.24455378949642181,
-0.4605262279510498,
0.7890098690986633,
-0.3885928690433502,
-1.0765105485916138,
0.46200358867645264,
0.12149147689342499,
0.08956260979175568,
0.7289137840270996,
0.3914075493812561,
-0.2481956034898758,
1.0059939622879028,
0.8131619095802307,
-0.020952783524990082,
0.477433443069458,
-0.4038167893886566,
0.2301454395055771,
-0.5938092470169067,
-0.3381258547306061,
-0.4564272463321686,
-0.06518976390361786,
-0.4487532377243042,
-0.10967736691236496,
0.48858797550201416,
0.17745964229106903,
-0.01377891656011343,
0.7622503042221069,
-0.2498035579919815,
0.7169771790504456,
0.0644262507557869,
-0.1687813550233841,
0.31033265590667725,
-0.11874309927225113,
0.5049205422401428,
-0.1116008460521698,
-0.7784352898597717,
-0.23541036248207092,
1.1235976219177246,
0.34162354469299316,
0.6402893662452698,
-0.07741744071245193,
0.5323742032051086,
0.38280805945396423,
0.09857085347175598,
-0.7094683051109314,
0.3054927885532379,
-0.4557282328605652,
-0.7451028823852539,
-0.3131884038448334,
-0.37910860776901245,
-1.0406235456466675,
0.15279008448123932,
0.004237036220729351,
-0.6445445418357849,
-0.35406678915023804,
-0.359598845243454,
-0.4212277829647064,
0.48715004324913025,
-0.6258068084716797,
0.8316670656204224,
-0.25038427114486694,
-0.038695819675922394,
-0.5498095154762268,
-0.3103051483631134,
0.1799217164516449,
0.0962354838848114,
0.3163750469684601,
-0.2631078362464905,
0.11045339703559875,
1.126517415046692,
0.030781123787164688,
0.8114265203475952,
-0.24399566650390625,
-0.000849383242893964,
0.1575346291065216,
-0.44028425216674805,
0.5297431349754333,
0.18317925930023193,
-0.0701511949300766,
0.5261176228523254,
-0.23292016983032227,
-0.1957436054944992,
-0.5724997520446777,
0.5442019104957581,
-0.9433751702308655,
-0.49529507756233215,
-0.24177555739879608,
-0.535743772983551,
-0.10247965902090073,
0.20891577005386353,
0.4196989834308624,
0.3085760176181793,
-0.21459631621837616,
0.26886579394340515,
0.33243805170059204,
-0.19235609471797943,
0.5454421043395996,
1.1604679822921753,
-0.22224795818328857,
-0.5419156551361084,
0.5815511345863342,
0.39247453212738037,
0.020630311220884323,
0.4101436138153076,
0.07621943950653076,
-0.40044909715652466,
-0.496938556432724,
-0.5613436698913574,
0.3959468901157379,
-0.49945691227912903,
0.009702985174953938,
-0.9445926547050476,
-0.43412452936172485,
-0.30437564849853516,
-0.3193749189376831,
-0.7687832713127136,
-0.42325708270072937,
-0.2678207457065582,
-0.3087262511253357,
0.23224371671676636,
1.175187110900879,
0.09135668724775314,
0.43006446957588196,
-0.957545816898346,
0.031313326209783554,
0.17021691799163818,
0.3187199532985687,
-0.6649803519248962,
-0.7054410576820374,
-1.0044426918029785,
-0.1933009773492813,
-0.3719184696674347,
-0.7217962741851807,
0.2896023988723755,
0.04654249548912048,
0.6595970988273621,
0.2520830035209656,
-0.3755345940589905,
0.5188551545143127,
-0.5757416486740112,
1.1966614723205566,
0.200381800532341,
-0.8217791318893433,
0.5297811031341553,
-0.6574943661689758,
0.2046562284231186,
0.25446900725364685,
0.6801411509513855,
-0.9040207266807556,
-0.34988921880722046,
-0.6694494485855103,
-0.6345341205596924,
0.7408030033111572,
0.25241097807884216,
-0.02443590946495533,
-0.20934072136878967,
0.1596878319978714,
0.19294297695159912,
-0.09547353535890579,
-0.9823389053344727,
-0.2429192066192627,
0.16985782980918884,
0.12885518372058868,
-0.12555955350399017,
-0.3042115569114685,
0.12605853378772736,
-0.1744600236415863,
1.0069146156311035,
-0.021211756393313408,
0.2413775622844696,
-0.09876608103513718,
-0.1585458517074585,
-0.13242417573928833,
0.13027772307395935,
0.8883804082870483,
0.3873300850391388,
-0.2758519947528839,
-0.0433957502245903,
0.4004186689853668,
-0.45589399337768555,
0.0320441909134388,
0.26365935802459717,
-0.16603240370750427,
0.5102306604385376,
0.45527294278144836,
1.0040011405944824,
0.36556923389434814,
-0.4214147925376892,
0.4473032057285309,
-0.29268938302993774,
-0.2546612322330475,
-0.3527856469154358,
-0.3688006103038788,
0.1651535928249359,
0.3654913306236267,
0.5631539225578308,
-0.03288498893380165,
0.3213609457015991,
0.08575421571731567,
0.40000489354133606,
0.019054468721151352,
-0.44535452127456665,
-0.544263482093811,
0.7310908436775208,
0.4443032443523407,
-0.1469610035419464,
0.0748790055513382,
-0.23149865865707397,
-0.6643690466880798,
0.9877510070800781,
0.5678750276565552,
1.0860316753387451,
-0.5291436314582825,
0.3745747208595276,
0.6398845314979553,
0.368289977312088,
-0.3918142318725586,
0.16876041889190674,
0.4226897060871124,
-0.8055955767631531,
-0.9064043760299683,
-0.3788335919380188,
-0.3739250898361206,
0.5247892737388611,
-0.954246461391449,
0.775411069393158,
0.3786156475543976,
-0.010904020629823208,
0.06533010303974152,
0.3316677212715149,
-0.6560882925987244,
0.21322137117385864,
0.43161994218826294,
0.6692237854003906,
-1.211606740951538,
0.5972974300384521,
0.9122435450553894,
-0.11686011403799057,
-0.7358070015907288,
-0.13212543725967407,
0.2845199406147003,
-0.4191298186779022,
0.6874550580978394,
0.4749366044998169,
0.0375811904668808,
0.04734602943062782,
0.17383164167404175,
-1.03937566280365,
1.1338168382644653,
0.19961202144622803,
-0.6741578578948975,
-0.09880075603723526,
0.38321393728256226,
0.30239224433898926,
-0.13063429296016693,
0.3531845211982727,
0.2954794466495514,
0.4156675636768341,
-0.42010098695755005,
-1.088850736618042,
-0.4923994243144989,
-0.10795924812555313,
-0.04408806934952736,
0.4067375361919403,
-0.9184818863868713,
0.5452772974967957,
-0.16154660284519196,
-0.06721360981464386,
-0.37164705991744995,
0.6320934295654297,
0.06728319078683853,
0.27557462453842163,
0.5854521989822388,
0.8109316229820251,
0.380453884601593,
0.17430007457733154,
1.1715821027755737,
-0.603682816028595,
0.890622079372406,
1.1451563835144043,
0.1261063665151596,
0.5570451617240906,
0.47896701097488403,
-0.36742833256721497,
0.30952250957489014,
0.6362060308456421,
-0.0477101169526577,
0.5369874238967896,
-0.1495410054922104,
-0.5027737617492676,
0.16933874785900116,
-0.31067028641700745,
-0.19191107153892517,
0.616119921207428,
0.4695410430431366,
-0.4982278645038605,
-0.24144534766674042,
0.42908573150634766,
0.3769405484199524,
-0.24661636352539062,
-0.41834402084350586,
0.6221020817756653,
0.02426457591354847,
-0.6293812394142151,
0.22017250955104828,
0.12463923543691635,
0.5777393579483032,
-0.35212481021881104,
0.3712744414806366,
-0.1430387645959854,
0.005275994539260864,
-0.20394206047058105,
-0.8793376088142395,
0.715339183807373,
0.039290688931941986,
-0.1756095141172409,
-0.3224307894706726,
0.599541425704956,
-0.5665567517280579,
-0.715607762336731,
0.47268015146255493,
0.5423277616500854,
-0.052374958992004395,
-0.09241842478513718,
-0.7856945991516113,
0.339036762714386,
0.08130457252264023,
-0.8588858842849731,
-0.023715559393167496,
0.2570819854736328,
0.4277092218399048,
0.36133962869644165,
-0.09857118874788284,
-0.07788974046707153,
0.003456605365499854,
0.32128018140792847,
0.4210515022277832,
-0.4962902069091797,
-0.40261325240135193,
-0.8937726020812988,
0.4810961186885834,
-0.039856769144535065,
-0.20067721605300903,
1.0562306642532349,
0.9548264741897583,
0.8373137712478638,
-0.3380656838417053,
0.9034769535064697,
-0.047848571091890335,
0.4093449115753174,
-0.5344176292419434,
0.8280510902404785,
-0.7381241321563721,
0.1145973652601242,
-0.18363972008228302,
-0.64532071352005,
-0.233421191573143,
0.26260653138160706,
-0.34556806087493896,
-0.024499038234353065,
0.8020620942115784,
0.6338059902191162,
0.02118586376309395,
0.277919739484787,
0.5042673349380493,
-0.014471782371401787,
0.4571986198425293,
0.42826271057128906,
0.7377117276191711,
-0.5706740617752075,
0.6458941102027893,
-0.41185182332992554,
0.37344327569007874,
-0.1465546190738678,
-0.8481941223144531,
-1.0568903684616089,
-0.7935478091239929,
-0.5207400321960449,
-0.19441840052604675,
0.2676326036453247,
0.7117603421211243,
0.8670228719711304,
-0.4821607172489166,
-0.1708766222000122,
-0.29498302936553955,
0.09213767200708389,
-0.1789073646068573,
-0.3123672306537628,
0.436012864112854,
-0.28929877281188965,
-0.9157213568687439,
0.5209928750991821,
0.43688616156578064,
-0.02576494961977005,
-0.02189674787223339,
-0.08888085186481476,
-0.10699571669101715,
-0.05994080752134323,
0.6693297028541565,
-0.038658738136291504,
-0.80585116147995,
-0.5672401785850525,
0.10325561463832855,
0.011527631431818008,
-0.15100213885307312,
0.7768185138702393,
-0.4809083342552185,
0.34406253695487976,
0.2681799530982971,
0.5887898206710815,
0.8393415808677673,
-0.22982586920261383,
0.6137940287590027,
-0.8349885940551758,
0.07280407845973969,
0.1355496644973755,
0.4627910256385803,
0.06498553603887558,
-0.7197051644325256,
0.8305839896202087,
0.40971845388412476,
-0.7032305598258972,
-0.7151224613189697,
0.25486519932746887,
-0.8044642806053162,
-0.47756150364875793,
1.466728925704956,
-0.3142516314983368,
0.005209277383983135,
-0.16491195559501648,
0.023156875744462013,
0.4172367453575134,
-0.0797952190041542,
0.8462345004081726,
0.6917005777359009,
-0.2793726921081543,
-0.5432584881782532,
-0.5735464096069336,
0.5796821117401123,
0.39502444863319397,
-0.8406658172607422,
-0.26029542088508606,
0.09117879718542099,
0.2709369659423828,
0.026383163407444954,
0.3483557403087616,
0.0322037972509861,
0.15407578647136688,
0.030399106442928314,
0.1761009842157364,
-0.2638806700706482,
-0.4424962103366852,
-0.39125439524650574,
-0.14253894984722137,
-0.3818674385547638,
0.09662765264511108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01336v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01336v2
|
FineFake: A Knowledge-Enriched Dataset for Fine-Grained Multi-Domain Fake News Detection
| 2024-03-30T14:39:09 | 2024-04-28T07:26:08 |
Ziyi Zhou, Xiaoming Zhang, Litian Zhang, Jiacheng Liu, Xi Zhang, Chaozhuo Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM
|
Existing benchmarks for fake news detection have significantly contributed to
the advancement of models in assessing the authenticity of news content.
However, these benchmarks typically focus solely on news pertaining to a single
semantic topic or originating from a single platform, thereby failing to
capture the diversity of multi-domain news in real scenarios. In order to
understand fake news across various domains, the external knowledge and
fine-grained annotations are indispensable to provide precise evidence and
uncover the diverse underlying strategies for fabrication, which are also
ignored by existing benchmarks. To address this gap, we introduce a novel
multi-domain knowledge-enhanced benchmark with fine-grained annotations, named
\textbf{FineFake}. FineFake encompasses 16,909 data samples spanning six
semantic topics and eight platforms. Each news item is enriched with
multi-modal content, potential social context, semi-manually verified common
knowledge, and fine-grained annotations that surpass conventional binary
labels. Furthermore, we formulate three challenging tasks based on FineFake and
propose a knowledge-enhanced domain adaptation network. Extensive experiments
are conducted on FineFake under various scenarios, providing accurate and
reliable benchmarks for future endeavors. The entire FineFake project is
publicly accessible as an open-source repository at
\url{https://github.com/Accuser907/FineFake}.
|
[
-0.7079995274543762,
-1.0607177019119263,
0.4138503074645996,
0.06519582122564316,
-0.05990444868803024,
-0.004706807434558868,
0.026229698210954666,
-0.5958476662635803,
0.03538677841424942,
0.3611683249473572,
-0.7659395337104797,
-0.49277329444885254,
-0.6639217734336853,
-0.17781400680541992,
-0.45709532499313354,
1.0955849885940552,
-0.03490056097507477,
-0.03820133954286575,
-0.21939386427402496,
-0.2635238468647003,
-0.2695019245147705,
-0.15727292001247406,
-0.3892117440700531,
-0.24198557436466217,
0.2483673393726349,
0.5264539122581482,
0.5714479088783264,
0.3719526529312134,
0.13269804418087006,
0.18334318697452545,
0.38390249013900757,
0.8678807616233826,
-0.4727656841278076,
-0.41091763973236084,
-0.4094800353050232,
0.02004966512322426,
-0.4120519161224365,
0.26341742277145386,
0.1739405393600464,
0.4754319190979004,
0.21537218987941742,
0.3099276125431061,
-0.08828902989625931,
0.5493024587631226,
-0.9512264132499695,
0.02362474799156189,
-0.8240739107131958,
-0.1383764147758484,
-0.3997056186199188,
-0.15885618329048157,
-0.33054789900779724,
-0.21698150038719177,
-0.17437216639518738,
-1.018641471862793,
0.37602734565734863,
0.020641222596168518,
1.0100572109222412,
0.0904512032866478,
-0.4658726751804352,
-0.039718177169561386,
-0.3363763988018036,
0.5291568040847778,
-0.5536354780197144,
0.3861220180988312,
0.3072555959224701,
0.5928234457969666,
-0.3500782549381256,
-0.8731806874275208,
-0.9050742983818054,
0.16191938519477844,
0.02030515857040882,
0.03904242441058159,
-0.10011254251003265,
-0.3308427333831787,
-0.1416698843240738,
0.39015063643455505,
-0.4091625213623047,
-0.1104297861456871,
-0.016750629991292953,
-0.6310408711433411,
0.30253925919532776,
-0.13755357265472412,
0.2603175938129425,
0.03228141367435455,
-0.5917283296585083,
0.025409508496522903,
-0.2676553428173065,
-0.1309581995010376,
0.3679075837135315,
0.5297374129295349,
-0.2575072646141052,
0.18064771592617035,
-1.0557997226715088,
0.7051263451576233,
0.25530967116355896,
-0.06751357764005661,
0.4845587909221649,
-0.160491943359375,
-0.2797548472881317,
-0.024030141532421112,
0.4979807138442993,
0.503386914730072,
0.24138134717941284,
-0.10642349720001221,
-0.11644715070724487,
0.280215322971344,
0.25128984451293945,
-0.7746713161468506,
-0.32404598593711853,
0.06158725544810295,
-0.2749154269695282,
-0.34930792450904846,
0.3184078633785248,
-0.7370162606239319,
-0.5806082487106323,
-0.3972054123878479,
0.9114062190055847,
-0.3925376832485199,
-0.2894574701786041,
0.3317759335041046,
-0.35311514139175415,
-0.08274554461240768,
0.7265599370002747,
-0.3479488492012024,
0.31568247079849243,
0.9327029585838318,
0.7264119982719421,
-0.1541758030653,
-0.5357605218887329,
-0.9569798707962036,
0.11911685019731522,
-0.268092542886734,
1.16007661819458,
-0.41928887367248535,
0.32371318340301514,
-0.010566716082394123,
0.3003816306591034,
0.218868225812912,
-0.44654083251953125,
0.7096378207206726,
-0.7117945551872253,
-0.08246181905269623,
-0.134439155459404,
-0.6116681694984436,
-0.3819459080696106,
0.4352280795574188,
-0.7107167840003967,
0.8680192232131958,
0.2252029925584793,
-0.5804303884506226,
0.724520206451416,
-0.4982515275478363,
-0.659512460231781,
-0.05170252546668053,
0.0917859748005867,
-0.36687907576560974,
0.11111536622047424,
0.2732310891151428,
0.8945812582969666,
0.038648247718811035,
0.27273648977279663,
-0.6790944337844849,
-0.15911489725112915,
0.034405581653118134,
-0.623532772064209,
0.5185966491699219,
0.13300946354866028,
-0.48150527477264404,
-0.1298350989818573,
-0.974094808101654,
-0.17055904865264893,
0.16319814324378967,
-0.036107636988162994,
-0.6272172927856445,
-0.5071544051170349,
0.27394232153892517,
0.24462686479091644,
0.11431803554296494,
-0.7111696004867554,
0.0019235718064010143,
-0.0989222303032875,
-0.032661229372024536,
0.7372406721115112,
0.20075681805610657,
0.30391931533813477,
-0.601963222026825,
-0.2593889534473419,
0.29610830545425415,
0.18954874575138092,
-0.09040287137031555,
-0.3863140940666199,
-0.5725599527359009,
-0.23902182281017303,
0.40980079770088196,
0.21593479812145233,
-0.8972424864768982,
0.034698449075222015,
-0.20483191311359406,
-0.3666546642780304,
-0.3388219475746155,
0.11273380368947983,
0.42906180024147034,
0.3254097104072571,
0.6509094834327698,
-0.40896475315093994,
-0.269552081823349,
-0.8593063950538635,
-0.7434592247009277,
0.5391759276390076,
0.13292379677295685,
0.08101042360067368,
0.6285700798034668,
-0.19082002341747284,
0.7929970622062683,
-0.46782758831977844,
-0.723429799079895,
0.3846508264541626,
0.34338176250457764,
-0.1027577668428421,
0.5964818596839905,
0.6756007075309753,
-1.0323028564453125,
-0.5313339829444885,
0.21816548705101013,
-0.4247639775276184,
0.017338482663035393,
-0.297281414270401,
-0.34037110209465027,
0.2739448845386505,
0.414013534784317,
-0.7168694138526917,
0.30925118923187256,
0.5782936215400696,
-0.5480226874351501,
0.731219470500946,
0.2101939469575882,
0.618024468421936,
-0.8084873557090759,
-0.11930093169212341,
0.0928841158747673,
-0.4984503984451294,
-0.7755742073059082,
0.1807461827993393,
0.17873089015483856,
0.2310110330581665,
-0.6099445223808289,
0.9268288612365723,
-0.14753757417201996,
-0.01272837445139885,
-0.4515281021595001,
0.14981450140476227,
0.5060362219810486,
0.4120508134365082,
-0.18790490925312042,
0.7239686250686646,
0.23247835040092468,
-0.5252159237861633,
0.18026015162467957,
0.1212492436170578,
-0.38486504554748535,
0.6901243329048157,
-0.09828650206327438,
-0.012523957528173923,
0.17887867987155914,
0.3859975337982178,
-0.7985923886299133,
-0.6769382357597351,
0.24408382177352905,
-0.6818867325782776,
0.09886456280946732,
-0.3200288414955139,
-0.9050646424293518,
-0.08235618472099304,
-0.19557468593120575,
0.045933257788419724,
-0.14835554361343384,
-0.7722495198249817,
0.5191240906715393,
0.346257746219635,
0.3187127411365509,
-0.38540294766426086,
-0.687363862991333,
-0.023038772866129875,
0.1728948950767517,
-0.67392498254776,
0.5228657126426697,
-0.11363903433084488,
-0.09636835008859634,
0.18682724237442017,
-0.5851385593414307,
-0.41382747888565063,
0.1675630360841751,
0.05414386838674545,
-0.1728084236383438,
-0.37538012862205505,
-0.005749300122261047,
0.42356738448143005,
0.028211545199155807,
-0.14384636282920837,
-0.3121880292892456,
0.40476977825164795,
-0.32192137837409973,
-0.3256250023841858,
-0.5885577201843262,
0.26227840781211853,
0.7408850193023682,
-0.10852552950382233,
0.7914151549339294,
0.9999160170555115,
-0.8120890259742737,
-0.5365819931030273,
-0.7206201553344727,
-0.30050915479660034,
-0.4511423408985138,
0.0016094631282612681,
-0.4704439640045166,
-0.862307071685791,
0.3780648708343506,
-0.6157997250556946,
-0.012389752082526684,
0.6960736513137817,
0.3000021278858185,
0.3766132891178131,
0.7603591680526733,
0.38186708092689514,
0.039592526853084564,
0.05793256312608719,
-0.1793011575937271,
-0.09256821125745773,
-0.26048722863197327,
-0.13951236009597778,
-0.1604531854391098,
-0.10257978737354279,
-0.00043952310807071626,
-0.691238284111023,
-0.27447113394737244,
0.22318342328071594,
-0.34621480107307434,
0.2627446949481964,
-0.4039609432220459,
0.5796171426773071,
0.5566223859786987,
0.36532849073410034,
0.5799355506896973,
0.09705635905265808,
-0.07953967154026031,
0.15638414025306702,
-0.3722130060195923,
-0.2856016457080841,
0.8600885272026062,
0.15386420488357544,
0.3358519673347473,
0.11508204787969589,
0.37657850980758667,
0.7909031510353088,
0.24711541831493378,
-0.5262441039085388,
0.28330790996551514,
-0.6213403344154358,
-0.8342392444610596,
-0.002922327257692814,
-0.31519776582717896,
-0.3302377164363861,
0.17403310537338257,
-0.3811643421649933,
-0.24721184372901917,
0.23179136216640472,
0.04998907446861267,
-0.5564975142478943,
0.43060967326164246,
-0.9197535514831543,
0.9649686813354492,
0.038672298192977905,
-0.528489887714386,
-0.23353014886379242,
-0.38899746537208557,
0.5791527032852173,
-0.4415835440158844,
0.5846753716468811,
-0.5146023631095886,
0.22605609893798828,
0.45829737186431885,
-0.31602367758750916,
1.0472652912139893,
-0.4776439070701599,
0.10424075275659561,
0.215709388256073,
0.3134850561618805,
0.5165794491767883,
0.32768160104751587,
0.10120608657598495,
0.49156898260116577,
-0.061090826988220215,
-0.41785070300102234,
-0.22688360512256622,
1.0706788301467896,
-0.5122663378715515,
-0.26868513226509094,
-0.2263319492340088,
-0.6486031413078308,
-0.5251907706260681,
0.5731597542762756,
-0.01928478293120861,
0.514674961566925,
-0.20670412480831146,
0.1842586100101471,
0.5490145087242126,
-0.06110987067222595,
0.11831710487604141,
0.7082777619361877,
0.05426674336194992,
-0.27849772572517395,
1.0572175979614258,
0.011601155623793602,
0.10408388823270798,
0.23790603876113892,
0.21271613240242004,
0.062390394508838654,
-0.36161768436431885,
-0.5883200764656067,
-0.30164337158203125,
-0.7165972590446472,
-0.6076938509941101,
-0.8462446928024292,
-0.15087474882602692,
-0.46241769194602966,
-0.3163830637931824,
-0.6998950242996216,
-0.46738383173942566,
-0.3066307306289673,
0.13023681938648224,
0.7292798161506653,
0.369390070438385,
-0.24909985065460205,
0.36519283056259155,
-0.6978851556777954,
0.9549376368522644,
0.29779142141342163,
0.6303873658180237,
-0.04015210270881653,
-0.4747335612773895,
-0.2808004915714264,
0.22930839657783508,
-0.3475196957588196,
-0.3611975610256195,
0.09877295047044754,
0.40089553594589233,
0.5873832106590271,
0.5258259177207947,
0.46236374974250793,
0.7753555178642273,
-0.5763240456581116,
0.6174765825271606,
0.08068627119064331,
-0.9841983914375305,
0.42060860991477966,
-0.47040000557899475,
0.14451183378696442,
0.7790102362632751,
0.5141634345054626,
-0.22566325962543488,
-0.32158222794532776,
-0.5905623435974121,
-0.6350234150886536,
0.6683406233787537,
0.05395064130425453,
0.1925388127565384,
0.016251733526587486,
0.3218993544578552,
0.7952312231063843,
0.21093425154685974,
-0.7005375623703003,
-0.22893184423446655,
-0.43734031915664673,
-0.2288891226053238,
0.2682645916938782,
0.20665007829666138,
-0.3125883638858795,
-0.2504771947860718,
0.8111385703086853,
-0.5032200813293457,
0.12871350347995758,
0.12325675785541534,
-0.32831400632858276,
-0.11397165805101395,
-0.02382008358836174,
0.7059745788574219,
0.44580328464508057,
0.009911848232150078,
0.2655983567237854,
0.054525166749954224,
-0.5313268303871155,
-0.19515712559223175,
0.4371890723705292,
-0.031417373567819595,
0.03503147140145302,
0.26721635460853577,
0.4251497685909271,
0.19633710384368896,
-0.3654482960700989,
0.7800720930099487,
0.11743572354316711,
-0.42693373560905457,
-0.09913527965545654,
0.10049234330654144,
-0.16164833307266235,
0.5147553086280823,
0.7069900631904602,
0.6770846247673035,
0.453923761844635,
-0.4986700713634491,
0.8341517448425293,
0.3245912492275238,
-0.34625986218452454,
-0.24015434086322784,
0.6738714575767517,
0.18255090713500977,
0.1380583494901657,
-0.2653059661388397,
-0.38450199365615845,
-0.4787207841873169,
0.47572848200798035,
0.3823844790458679,
0.44237571954727173,
0.03610704094171524,
0.39597806334495544,
0.033542584627866745,
0.2775217294692993,
-0.40995070338249207,
0.09433604031801224,
0.15110895037651062,
-0.9690908193588257,
-0.40095004439353943,
-0.7378045916557312,
-0.17590229213237762,
0.5008299946784973,
-0.3174920976161957,
0.26030251383781433,
-0.5695837736129761,
0.07234147936105728,
0.3798687756061554,
0.2910495400428772,
-0.5768656730651855,
0.4422251582145691,
0.21253015100955963,
1.1846071481704712,
-0.9825823307037354,
0.6728166341781616,
0.6425468921661377,
-0.12335005402565002,
-0.4411683976650238,
0.3655330538749695,
0.46018022298812866,
-0.7033328413963318,
0.2979254722595215,
0.5380179286003113,
-0.14798122644424438,
0.1623554527759552,
-0.538665771484375,
-0.49690261483192444,
0.7766019701957703,
0.2919778525829315,
-0.3111303150653839,
0.45617666840553284,
0.12431107461452484,
0.13576462864875793,
-0.49605339765548706,
-0.30707091093063354,
0.4752752482891083,
0.708142876625061,
-0.10446041822433472,
-0.5936732888221741,
0.2532197833061218,
-0.2168681025505066,
-0.5350837707519531,
0.21861203014850616,
-0.8766584992408752,
0.8160171508789062,
0.061458028852939606,
-0.02726881019771099,
-0.09449232369661331,
0.7158588767051697,
0.13162215054035187,
1.077990174293518,
0.4704006612300873,
0.5537108778953552,
0.48198202252388,
-0.15296705067157745,
0.6720038652420044,
-0.26553013920783997,
0.3611213266849518,
1.299465298652649,
-0.12973716855049133,
0.6989140510559082,
0.2616886794567108,
0.22090257704257965,
0.5828624963760376,
0.5851529240608215,
-0.22804327309131622,
0.7859480381011963,
-0.17238961160182953,
-0.25506705045700073,
-0.5078033208847046,
-0.17185959219932556,
-0.22412407398223877,
0.3885234296321869,
0.390694797039032,
0.05848203971982002,
-0.5050205588340759,
0.325015127658844,
0.1389976292848587,
0.25619643926620483,
-0.5035532116889954,
0.5020485520362854,
-0.018979961052536964,
-0.24002978205680847,
0.40255963802337646,
0.12039998173713684,
0.8240488171577454,
-0.4137493371963501,
-0.14462792873382568,
-0.25029492378234863,
0.3017229735851288,
-0.42146536707878113,
-0.7348780632019043,
0.2641477584838867,
-0.20123162865638733,
-0.281211256980896,
0.08769407868385315,
1.2040146589279175,
-0.2055606096982956,
-0.15729346871376038,
0.2854120135307312,
0.5413551330566406,
-0.2503226101398468,
-0.627020537853241,
-0.6246174573898315,
0.21239562332630157,
-0.2580259442329407,
-0.39488905668258667,
0.3598816990852356,
0.8436025381088257,
-0.156880721449852,
0.30218300223350525,
1.0167557001113892,
-0.272344708442688,
0.06569918245077133,
0.130301371216774,
0.9984443783760071,
-0.28297460079193115,
-0.3793899416923523,
-0.5414194464683533,
0.5198137760162354,
-0.3336544930934906,
-0.48128554224967957,
0.8241055607795715,
0.6412363648414612,
1.1757006645202637,
-0.34230682253837585,
0.8039664626121521,
-0.04317691549658775,
0.5193207859992981,
-0.5216642022132874,
0.9502578377723694,
-0.9972800016403198,
-0.06889960914850235,
-0.4121992886066437,
-0.5220557451248169,
-0.37919583916664124,
0.3348985016345978,
0.06064457446336746,
-0.04313794896006584,
0.5099627375602722,
0.6712441444396973,
-0.5981038212776184,
0.029170257970690727,
0.4608069658279419,
0.19736886024475098,
-0.06818370521068573,
0.27340614795684814,
0.5125850439071655,
-0.6963555812835693,
0.4912170469760895,
-0.43353718519210815,
-0.22838880121707916,
-0.5119509100914001,
-0.8637381196022034,
-0.9265372157096863,
-0.5190389156341553,
-0.4666566550731659,
-0.3204038441181183,
0.0787443295121193,
0.642645537853241,
1.0586621761322021,
-1.046513319015503,
0.599931001663208,
-0.21827036142349243,
-0.1342550367116928,
-0.3813875913619995,
-0.3380414545536041,
0.30209168791770935,
-0.16766655445098877,
-0.5244700908660889,
0.45609715580940247,
0.07937197387218475,
0.0933530405163765,
0.042199522256851196,
0.04282711073756218,
-0.44697269797325134,
0.33360663056373596,
0.8035217523574829,
0.18565994501113892,
-0.5254208445549011,
-0.585725724697113,
-0.2747041881084442,
-0.015121247619390488,
-0.2547953128814697,
0.5780455470085144,
-0.9112362861633301,
0.17003899812698364,
0.1815943568944931,
0.9327783584594727,
0.3496895432472229,
0.00288805877789855,
0.07944482564926147,
-1.0729975700378418,
0.24180905520915985,
-0.22453869879245758,
0.05742530897259712,
0.2592032253742218,
-0.5883408784866333,
0.37642261385917664,
0.6580858826637268,
-0.22006119787693024,
-0.7579375505447388,
0.1638450026512146,
-1.08147394657135,
-0.7698628902435303,
1.115302562713623,
0.012474026530981064,
-0.15068461000919342,
-0.4777477979660034,
0.04132434353232384,
0.22528015077114105,
-0.6515001654624939,
0.663621723651886,
0.6178249716758728,
0.21824218332767487,
-0.02639712393283844,
-0.9618254899978638,
0.6707649230957031,
0.06725947558879852,
-0.9603910446166992,
0.1870485544204712,
0.6563447713851929,
0.3990860879421234,
0.2351394146680832,
0.3409028947353363,
0.009162821806967258,
0.5619200468063354,
0.13191968202590942,
-0.07181889563798904,
-0.4212055206298828,
-0.6764143109321594,
0.1325380504131317,
0.3383634686470032,
-0.4367683529853821,
-0.05132149159908295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00376v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00376v2
|
Small Language Models Learn Enhanced Reasoning Skills from Medical Textbooks
| 2024-03-30T14:09:00 | 2024-06-30T09:24:12 |
Hyunjae Kim, Hyeon Hwang, Jiwoo Lee, Sihyeon Park, Dain Kim, Taewhoo Lee, Chanwoong Yoon, Jiwoong Sohn, Donghee Choi, Jaewoo Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While recent advancements in commercial large language models (LM) have shown
promising results in medical tasks, their closed-source nature poses
significant privacy and security concerns, hindering their widespread use in
the medical field. Despite efforts to create open-source models, their limited
parameters often result in insufficient multi-step reasoning capabilities
required for solving complex medical problems. To address this, we introduce
Meerkat, a new family of medical AI systems ranging from 7 to 70 billion
parameters. The models were trained using our new synthetic dataset consisting
of high-quality chain-of-thought reasoning paths sourced from 18 medical
textbooks, along with diverse instruction-following datasets. Our systems
achieved remarkable accuracy across six medical benchmarks, surpassing the
previous best models such as MediTron and BioMistral, and GPT-3.5 by a large
margin. Notably, Meerkat-7B surpassed the passing threshold of the United
States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) for the first time for a
7B-parameter model, while Meerkat-70B outperformed GPT-4 by an average of 1.3%.
Additionally, Meerkat-70B correctly diagnosed 21 out of 38 complex clinical
cases, outperforming humans' 13.8 and closely matching GPT-4's 21.8. Our
systems offered more detailed free-form responses to clinical queries compared
to existing small models, approaching the performance level of large commercial
models. This significantly narrows the performance gap with large LMs,
showcasing its effectiveness in addressing complex medical challenges.
|
[
-0.1947072297334671,
-0.5546886324882507,
0.7013505697250366,
-0.03314080834388733,
-0.07867518812417984,
0.11293353885412216,
-0.06693089753389359,
-0.5428095459938049,
-0.01490144245326519,
0.5056808590888977,
-0.4389265179634094,
-0.2515345811843872,
-0.6430056691169739,
0.2539922595024109,
0.07092765718698502,
0.827521800994873,
0.11836738884449005,
0.5790231823921204,
-0.088707834482193,
-0.28876951336860657,
-0.3375430405139923,
-0.5213989019393921,
-0.5553994178771973,
-0.7224529385566711,
0.6009721159934998,
0.5293708443641663,
1.0769250392913818,
0.5938374400138855,
0.460656076669693,
0.17527508735656738,
0.09480490535497665,
0.002246004296466708,
0.01609456166625023,
-0.024148616939783096,
-0.3954041600227356,
-0.6094833612442017,
-0.36769813299179077,
-0.1626410037279129,
0.39637646079063416,
0.8786666393280029,
-0.23030798137187958,
-0.048271335661411285,
-0.2613122761249542,
0.7970264554023743,
-0.39565643668174744,
0.26705145835876465,
-0.20126287639141083,
0.11295560002326965,
-0.08727026730775833,
0.09726903587579727,
-0.7360544204711914,
-0.28252118825912476,
0.23756743967533112,
-0.6991918087005615,
-0.07998932152986526,
-0.0035761462058871984,
0.7206314206123352,
0.6045035719871521,
-0.2535695731639862,
-0.5440164804458618,
-0.5849772095680237,
0.7014973759651184,
-0.7893356084823608,
0.6032778024673462,
0.22505345940589905,
0.6881351470947266,
-0.5440807938575745,
-0.8136129975318909,
-0.40542399883270264,
-0.3700711131095886,
0.026779428124427795,
0.0770907998085022,
-0.21003985404968262,
0.10458730161190033,
0.2948257029056549,
0.06284599751234055,
-0.7106567621231079,
0.21513943374156952,
-0.7654681205749512,
-0.23942798376083374,
0.37437424063682556,
0.17785146832466125,
0.40861696004867554,
-0.13927064836025238,
0.11990519613027573,
-0.4061906337738037,
-0.8167206048965454,
0.09860752522945404,
-0.22208929061889648,
0.07784435898065567,
0.004305652808398008,
0.5785731673240662,
-0.28968945145606995,
0.7763482332229614,
-0.051828064024448395,
-0.5551359057426453,
0.16701829433441162,
0.018943151459097862,
-0.3689843714237213,
0.2408432960510254,
0.8659951090812683,
0.04475996270775795,
0.4108861982822418,
0.014376195147633553,
0.09567838907241821,
-0.04479370266199112,
0.12002863734960556,
-0.8257097005844116,
-0.5134310722351074,
0.35619962215423584,
-0.6928658485412598,
-0.11841434985399246,
-0.46271464228630066,
-0.5179807543754578,
-0.5311828851699829,
-0.3777361810207367,
0.35065463185310364,
-0.6951402425765991,
-0.20745022594928741,
0.44627645611763,
0.11445696651935577,
0.14217509329319,
0.5109458565711975,
-0.9239939451217651,
0.40063077211380005,
0.5321610569953918,
0.5982237458229065,
0.29416924715042114,
-0.07850725948810577,
-0.35424864292144775,
0.10500738024711609,
-0.4831075668334961,
0.8295158743858337,
-0.9122945666313171,
-0.25186687707901,
-0.4725068211555481,
-0.1835750937461853,
-0.012685388326644897,
-0.8973875641822815,
0.2962628901004791,
-0.2202935516834259,
0.06826973706483841,
0.04969548434019089,
-0.3976321518421173,
-0.11846964061260223,
0.2701704502105713,
-0.5143234729766846,
0.6733295321464539,
0.11226879060268402,
-0.33774295449256897,
0.2354099154472351,
-0.7966099977493286,
-0.37893161177635193,
-0.019689422100782394,
-0.47331008315086365,
-0.09361733496189117,
0.08952543884515762,
0.3940812647342682,
0.6377715468406677,
-0.7103971838951111,
0.40670180320739746,
-0.20224347710609436,
-0.09920525550842285,
0.08294536173343658,
-0.32798221707344055,
0.5795528292655945,
0.39810818433761597,
-0.035546302795410156,
-0.06929971277713776,
-0.698096752166748,
0.07777458429336548,
0.16812315583229065,
-0.44837382435798645,
-0.44295239448547363,
-0.32410362362861633,
-0.4593762457370758,
0.3454907536506653,
0.04299277439713478,
-0.4790756106376648,
0.33608436584472656,
-0.6664923429489136,
0.5492858290672302,
0.453306645154953,
-0.10408393293619156,
0.4454229772090912,
-0.2706487774848938,
0.6125211715698242,
0.02437114156782627,
0.45002543926239014,
-0.3180834650993347,
-0.9232310056686401,
-0.474276065826416,
-0.37884968519210815,
0.5260183215141296,
0.4762200117111206,
-0.7343801259994507,
0.04314117506146431,
-0.268524169921875,
-0.7722347974777222,
-0.6904131174087524,
-0.13969896733760834,
0.524595320224762,
0.5147028565406799,
0.5156851410865784,
0.007090878672897816,
0.019571665674448013,
-1.0447760820388794,
-0.29541149735450745,
-0.1780809909105301,
-0.22400763630867004,
0.5990264415740967,
0.6178765296936035,
-0.3381195664405823,
0.5987257361412048,
-0.48994749784469604,
-0.1548113077878952,
-0.08811254799365997,
0.09426940977573395,
0.41084274649620056,
0.72199547290802,
0.42194753885269165,
-0.5219668745994568,
-0.3195382356643677,
0.23826952278614044,
-0.7870950102806091,
0.007233325857669115,
-0.03416135162115097,
0.04689440131187439,
0.031887900084257126,
0.4209906756877899,
-0.5271389484405518,
0.21339738368988037,
0.5371743440628052,
-0.4636448919773102,
0.5718292593955994,
-0.6597491502761841,
0.08359099924564362,
-1.0824787616729736,
0.07324577867984772,
-0.1265086978673935,
-0.22067518532276154,
-0.33886638283729553,
0.010046608746051788,
0.20073175430297852,
-0.1823287457227707,
-0.3411821126937866,
0.8531619310379028,
-0.440545916557312,
0.05586875230073929,
-0.060180917382240295,
-0.33984261751174927,
-0.11089713126420975,
0.244306743144989,
-0.13074009120464325,
0.44547051191329956,
0.4298843443393707,
-0.5689696073532104,
0.29499661922454834,
0.26695865392684937,
-0.17225858569145203,
0.5398919582366943,
-0.6609947681427002,
0.015551186166703701,
0.06290246546268463,
0.32300636172294617,
-0.503718376159668,
-0.6966497302055359,
0.30774474143981934,
-0.5476950407028198,
0.4862595200538635,
-0.10224351286888123,
-0.7885470986366272,
-0.5321009755134583,
0.1474979668855667,
0.4735688269138336,
0.7985446453094482,
-0.5216498970985413,
0.7524164915084839,
0.4263359010219574,
-0.2922091782093048,
-0.6052562594413757,
-0.44754451513290405,
0.06677591800689697,
0.28420382738113403,
-0.5991226434707642,
-0.11673511564731598,
-0.07734797149896622,
-0.10840771347284317,
-0.06119710952043533,
-0.15419811010360718,
-0.2626765966415405,
-0.13194306194782257,
0.0983639657497406,
0.13958346843719482,
-0.34700220823287964,
0.457334041595459,
0.5815904140472412,
-0.39092642068862915,
-0.1317245364189148,
-0.2581528425216675,
0.46913909912109375,
-0.13270056247711182,
-0.49035248160362244,
-0.3799746632575989,
0.14360295236110687,
0.8990190029144287,
-0.2757965624332428,
0.6158791780471802,
0.07948046177625656,
-0.7002730965614319,
-0.07057232409715652,
-0.4762849509716034,
-0.4567587971687317,
-0.41967299580574036,
0.3964148759841919,
-0.5778449773788452,
-0.9328416585922241,
0.2751564681529999,
-0.21051597595214844,
0.029605409130454063,
0.4007457494735718,
0.5882046222686768,
0.019640542566776276,
1.507991075515747,
0.20093795657157898,
0.1611766815185547,
-0.1591643989086151,
0.14296217262744904,
0.10339774936437607,
-0.5088291168212891,
-0.49200624227523804,
-0.4718171954154968,
-0.2550470530986786,
-0.5161097645759583,
-0.7077367305755615,
0.6734808087348938,
0.008697263896465302,
-0.5355284810066223,
-0.12921978533267975,
-0.7982026934623718,
0.6334550976753235,
0.6064508557319641,
0.33987289667129517,
0.37135910987854004,
-0.14437255263328552,
-0.7355384230613708,
-0.008553608320653439,
-0.7337972521781921,
-0.5527658462524414,
1.324440598487854,
0.5544243454933167,
1.0751243829727173,
0.0017625107429921627,
0.4508599042892456,
0.15677466988563538,
0.6468824744224548,
-0.7541713118553162,
0.4335715174674988,
-0.38700130581855774,
-0.9198594689369202,
-0.12442576140165329,
-0.3562138080596924,
-0.7113829255104065,
0.20463858544826508,
-0.27772626280784607,
-0.6808159351348877,
-0.13452322781085968,
0.34523433446884155,
-0.5679174065589905,
0.2270234376192093,
-0.7952442169189453,
0.8329350352287292,
-0.29421672224998474,
-0.3356843590736389,
-0.378023236989975,
-0.9349926114082336,
0.3027186393737793,
-0.18892870843410492,
0.1937146633863449,
-0.12716606259346008,
-0.030216874554753304,
0.7476752400398254,
-0.5120726227760315,
0.8353996872901917,
-0.23337331414222717,
0.11020179837942123,
-0.07344409078359604,
0.1280837506055832,
0.3324124813079834,
-0.054633334279060364,
-0.07764878869056702,
0.10188557952642441,
0.41596007347106934,
-0.5335816740989685,
-0.6489612460136414,
0.7903040647506714,
-0.6620100736618042,
-0.5003723502159119,
-0.6441543102264404,
-0.68825364112854,
-0.44634154438972473,
0.4359606206417084,
-0.03946257382631302,
0.5542665123939514,
0.04158700630068779,
0.2899155616760254,
0.5541519522666931,
-0.4651964604854584,
-0.016881486400961876,
0.6665503978729248,
-0.136766254901886,
-0.4156910479068756,
0.7405951619148254,
0.07990502566099167,
0.23794251680374146,
0.3976966142654419,
0.5669228434562683,
-0.4855882227420807,
-0.537006139755249,
-0.81734699010849,
0.6762458086013794,
-0.8111599683761597,
-0.07367108017206192,
-0.7820960283279419,
-0.14472968876361847,
-0.19047217071056366,
-0.15115058422088623,
-0.5859063267707825,
-0.44197651743888855,
-0.09558355063199997,
0.09479775279760361,
0.20548079907894135,
1.0402963161468506,
0.04367055371403694,
0.22833816707134247,
-1.271087884902954,
0.06252912431955338,
0.061927612870931625,
0.4327864646911621,
0.03013780526816845,
-0.3412192165851593,
-0.04792623594403267,
0.04942275956273079,
-0.2811465263366699,
-0.8073708415031433,
0.27305537462234497,
-0.060577232390642166,
0.5974776744842529,
0.5485132336616516,
-0.1413596123456955,
0.6224460601806641,
-0.7736745476722717,
0.5172722339630127,
0.4410310387611389,
-0.7109717130661011,
0.5169793367385864,
-0.4034820795059204,
0.22694027423858643,
0.3398953080177307,
0.36218389868736267,
-0.3476373255252838,
-0.31412041187286377,
-0.7336600422859192,
-0.29950621724128723,
0.6120026111602783,
0.11921492218971252,
-0.1436491161584854,
0.104582279920578,
0.8121657967567444,
0.3645232319831848,
0.10232426971197128,
-0.5334067344665527,
-0.09828109294176102,
-0.02311253920197487,
-0.7746721506118774,
-0.1103980615735054,
0.08491397649049759,
0.11838468164205551,
-0.6014039516448975,
0.518066942691803,
-0.38355544209480286,
0.05392627790570259,
0.3083620071411133,
0.09223979711532593,
-0.011119239032268524,
0.24904276430606842,
0.6599720120429993,
0.5559818148612976,
-0.06881029903888702,
0.11223655194044113,
0.030632702633738518,
-0.6485183835029602,
0.2964445650577545,
0.189388245344162,
0.08749385178089142,
-0.19645649194717407,
0.2537122666835785,
0.25475767254829407,
0.2662990391254425,
-1.16673743724823,
0.28938037157058716,
-0.015879228711128235,
-0.16310013830661774,
-0.08926066756248474,
0.35845446586608887,
0.27306848764419556,
0.4601040482521057,
-0.005745749920606613,
0.3010231852531433,
0.13109582662582397,
-0.31589093804359436,
0.2942483425140381,
0.3502040207386017,
-0.5966587662696838,
-0.5037031173706055,
0.8862621188163757,
0.17627418041229248,
-0.1492307037115097,
0.4212394654750824,
0.11024417728185654,
-0.175540491938591,
0.6464716792106628,
0.7507113814353943,
0.1969815045595169,
-0.5843818187713623,
0.19108720123767853,
0.5156247019767761,
0.41148993372917175,
-0.5179111361503601,
0.24093572795391083,
0.10978274792432785,
-0.5289340019226074,
-0.3420133590698242,
-0.7336210012435913,
-0.7054236531257629,
0.3451509177684784,
-0.31298360228538513,
0.2149064838886261,
-0.6682832837104797,
0.1421467810869217,
0.2823406457901001,
-0.24716931581497192,
-0.515889585018158,
0.5855420827865601,
0.09192797541618347,
1.1293634176254272,
-0.6782050132751465,
0.8148580193519592,
0.9996389150619507,
-0.5371416211128235,
-1.0698026418685913,
-0.2820013463497162,
-0.12335436046123505,
-1.057191014289856,
0.42886295914649963,
0.25288814306259155,
0.15314345061779022,
0.14362196624279022,
-0.5927745699882507,
-0.7044415473937988,
1.0176217555999756,
0.5711830854415894,
-0.5899062752723694,
-0.28327855467796326,
0.2741827666759491,
0.6457747220993042,
-0.5184327363967896,
0.33470529317855835,
0.7677749991416931,
0.3595934808254242,
0.29931333661079407,
-1.2203236818313599,
0.18803778290748596,
-0.23010143637657166,
-0.5183746218681335,
0.29474887251853943,
-0.5029078125953674,
0.8729565143585205,
-0.6671576499938965,
0.2815805971622467,
0.22710753977298737,
-0.10741709172725677,
0.5015655159950256,
0.38994690775871277,
0.26303160190582275,
0.5210046172142029,
1.0385054349899292,
-0.020196231082081795,
1.3627454042434692,
-0.058871977031230927,
-0.06118069961667061,
0.8893184661865234,
-0.20476272702217102,
0.9297788739204407,
0.39188307523727417,
-0.03741833567619324,
0.43231576681137085,
0.6788598299026489,
0.19494615495204926,
0.4075601100921631,
0.06716380268335342,
-0.16393548250198364,
-0.6264986991882324,
-0.057091884315013885,
-0.30829375982284546,
0.31750252842903137,
0.722733199596405,
-0.585774838924408,
-0.15773741900920868,
0.15288852155208588,
0.1893434226512909,
-0.11896426230669022,
-0.3598383069038391,
0.70131516456604,
0.3938121497631073,
-0.7903164029121399,
0.5931839942932129,
-0.20138533413410187,
0.17670650780200958,
-0.6294199228286743,
-0.2621780037879944,
0.07834888249635696,
0.6510049700737,
-0.08477770537137985,
-0.6967370510101318,
-0.07267263531684875,
-0.10522326827049255,
-0.18235911428928375,
0.19767558574676514,
0.8069435954093933,
-0.007578372955322266,
-0.590796947479248,
0.26006463170051575,
0.6170536279678345,
0.37412822246551514,
-0.02899482101202011,
-0.7795581817626953,
-0.30941319465637207,
0.024176588281989098,
-0.07833732664585114,
0.24336250126361847,
0.31284603476524353,
-0.25608330965042114,
1.0680714845657349,
0.9076341390609741,
0.20354041457176208,
0.056699104607105255,
0.03417745232582092,
0.9847903251647949,
-0.7303879857063293,
-0.4834568500518799,
-0.7865373492240906,
0.371078759431839,
0.06114557385444641,
-0.12687593698501587,
0.05071614310145378,
0.37401920557022095,
0.5323021411895752,
-0.12015124410390854,
0.8702197074890137,
0.25853314995765686,
0.7205662727355957,
-0.46589985489845276,
0.8854877352714539,
-0.8834777474403381,
0.16815368831157684,
0.029935048893094063,
-0.4643908143043518,
-0.7050718069076538,
0.6229831576347351,
-0.4669860601425171,
0.13204839825630188,
0.8120507001876831,
0.6890286207199097,
-0.2842752933502197,
0.08656804263591766,
0.5491793751716614,
0.5558393597602844,
0.6300138235092163,
0.7843611240386963,
0.8363171219825745,
-0.22603857517242432,
0.5635748505592346,
-0.11260948330163956,
-0.6212272047996521,
-0.32491394877433777,
-0.5040199756622314,
-1.0457508563995361,
-0.18877223134040833,
0.019228743389248848,
-0.29677921533584595,
0.16310644149780273,
1.0621018409729004,
0.774700403213501,
-0.8176332712173462,
0.11866123974323273,
-0.02633500099182129,
-0.1634688526391983,
0.06544643640518188,
-0.11226649582386017,
0.325607031583786,
-0.18939444422721863,
-0.5668543577194214,
0.32059410214424133,
0.539775550365448,
0.10976789146661758,
-0.13428768515586853,
-0.3564407229423523,
0.10327904671430588,
0.30719295144081116,
0.38588401675224304,
0.36848315596580505,
-0.7763039469718933,
-0.2763127386569977,
0.2112017422914505,
-0.16870850324630737,
0.16731756925582886,
0.5723060965538025,
-0.8377220630645752,
0.7407366037368774,
0.22639943659305573,
0.5211104154586792,
0.12156727910041809,
-0.2383824586868286,
0.646327793598175,
-0.1387024074792862,
0.2473902404308319,
0.5124326944351196,
0.48611849546432495,
0.3664446473121643,
-0.09667017310857773,
0.4932861924171448,
0.09078121185302734,
-0.583503782749176,
-0.7219151854515076,
0.09439635276794434,
-0.6912631988525391,
-0.4380921423435211,
0.9517515897750854,
0.1314486265182495,
-0.3262135684490204,
-0.3625647723674774,
-0.3859579265117645,
0.15889526903629303,
-0.4472518265247345,
0.6960914134979248,
0.42576974630355835,
-0.5620630383491516,
0.004679852165281773,
-0.7407056093215942,
0.4780586361885071,
0.5061355233192444,
-0.9797056317329407,
-0.3503459692001343,
0.43211016058921814,
0.4415321350097656,
0.3603438436985016,
0.7517855763435364,
-0.4444904923439026,
0.6134423017501831,
-0.04253043234348297,
0.0234176367521286,
-0.03540225327014923,
-0.4385095238685608,
-0.046760402619838715,
0.09052062779664993,
0.2251196652650833,
-0.08352313935756683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00361v1
|
Controllable and Diverse Data Augmentation with Large Language Model for Low-Resource Open-Domain Dialogue Generation
| 2024-03-30T13:28:51 | 2024-03-30T13:28:51 |
Zhenhua Liu, Tong Zhu, Jianxiang Xiang, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data augmentation (DA) is crucial to mitigate model training instability and
over-fitting problems in low-resource open-domain dialogue generation. However,
traditional DA methods often neglect semantic data diversity, restricting the
overall quality. Recently, large language models (LLM) have been used for DA to
generate diversified dialogues. However, they have limited controllability and
tend to generate dialogues with a distribution shift compared to the seed
dialogues. To maximize the augmentation diversity and address the
controllability problem, we propose \textbf{S}ummary-based \textbf{D}ialogue
\textbf{A}ugmentation with LLM (SDA). Our approach enhances the controllability
of LLM by using dialogue summaries as a planning tool. Based on summaries, SDA
can generate high-quality and diverse dialogue data even with a small seed
dataset. To evaluate the efficacy of data augmentation methods for open-domain
dialogue, we designed a clustering-based metric to characterize the semantic
diversity of the augmented dialogue data. The experimental results show that
SDA can augment high-quality and semantically diverse dialogues given a small
seed dataset and an LLM, and the augmented data can boost the performance of
open-domain dialogue models.
|
[
-0.49637895822525024,
-0.7818108797073364,
0.1892371028661728,
0.2796283960342407,
-0.3245537579059601,
0.2922387421131134,
-0.53678297996521,
-0.34658801555633545,
0.4165287911891937,
0.6112631559371948,
-0.5594872832298279,
-0.5831089615821838,
-0.3889118432998657,
-0.05342528969049454,
-0.17820675671100616,
0.8645922541618347,
-0.07036907970905304,
0.07506798952817917,
-0.1914723515510559,
-0.4479353427886963,
-0.3459654152393341,
-0.5465212464332581,
-0.336740106344223,
-0.157573863863945,
0.24874114990234375,
0.3136628270149231,
1.045426845550537,
0.6767352819442749,
0.24679628014564514,
0.33208325505256653,
-0.3989455997943878,
0.5667983293533325,
-0.6407867074012756,
0.21253104507923126,
-0.2453252226114273,
-0.2851242125034332,
-0.5346184968948364,
-0.23360085487365723,
0.9239937663078308,
1.0595847368240356,
-0.33227041363716125,
-0.19846977293491364,
0.07775155454874039,
0.3305779993534088,
-0.5873312950134277,
0.20574155449867249,
-0.6393341422080994,
-0.0643787831068039,
0.025277897715568542,
0.005614669527858496,
-0.16678179800510406,
-0.3206811547279358,
0.09159215539693832,
-0.557834804058075,
-0.030622296035289764,
-0.08769790828227997,
0.4517378509044647,
0.2901516556739807,
-0.1533493548631668,
-0.1933879256248474,
-1.1493581533432007,
0.9887553453445435,
-0.8784478306770325,
0.17779235541820526,
0.12861034274101257,
0.15868023037910461,
-0.35487794876098633,
-0.27982550859451294,
-0.764166533946991,
-0.11416854709386826,
-0.014462466351687908,
0.024531910195946693,
-0.37317007780075073,
0.08964943885803223,
0.2778848707675934,
0.4722546637058258,
-0.22818052768707275,
0.5825366973876953,
-0.1536279171705246,
-0.13756594061851501,
0.6434271335601807,
0.3611260950565338,
0.2535034120082855,
0.10852266103029251,
-0.19428597390651703,
-0.1690831482410431,
-0.5548259615898132,
-0.04833313077688217,
0.47381001710891724,
0.496676504611969,
-0.07482574135065079,
0.8494566679000854,
-0.5260851383209229,
0.7019855380058289,
0.048557352274656296,
-0.319457471370697,
0.22136279940605164,
-0.5365340113639832,
-0.27129051089286804,
-0.09986326098442078,
0.576282262802124,
0.5110712051391602,
0.09286674112081528,
-0.12764380872249603,
-0.11025791615247726,
0.02922661602497101,
-0.02225469797849655,
-0.902981162071228,
-0.02381378412246704,
0.28405097126960754,
-0.38300684094429016,
-0.2752186059951782,
-0.1406329870223999,
-0.7753596901893616,
-0.2621579170227051,
-0.363551527261734,
-0.05607551336288452,
-0.37139004468917847,
-0.3779573440551758,
0.11854209750890732,
0.2693995237350464,
-0.038354143500328064,
0.5955424904823303,
-0.8958966732025146,
0.2636255621910095,
0.3811430037021637,
0.6692469120025635,
-0.6963979601860046,
-0.06525931507349014,
-0.512018620967865,
0.3057189881801605,
-0.39129653573036194,
0.4136786162853241,
-0.7886072397232056,
-0.6149128079414368,
0.010801050812005997,
-0.24183502793312073,
0.015565902926027775,
-0.6535770893096924,
0.26084113121032715,
-0.37317296862602234,
0.22651977837085724,
0.20636287331581116,
-0.36329030990600586,
-0.02195572480559349,
0.05922688543796539,
-0.5935481786727905,
0.6374187469482422,
0.2314758002758026,
-0.5623289942741394,
0.5251415967941284,
-0.5918750762939453,
-0.24684613943099976,
0.03791140764951706,
-0.36307239532470703,
-0.2897990643978119,
0.0013061590725556016,
0.41275280714035034,
0.10150224715471268,
-0.2012021839618683,
0.4696318805217743,
-0.2971855103969574,
-0.030946705490350723,
0.4642396569252014,
-0.5882828831672668,
0.4998367428779602,
0.2510122060775757,
-0.01225601602345705,
0.2429792582988739,
-0.8438934683799744,
-0.0012803123099729419,
-0.11250187456607819,
-0.3525468111038208,
-0.32985174655914307,
-0.02333075739443302,
-0.13210134208202362,
0.20044410228729248,
0.09975560754537582,
-0.6232503652572632,
0.38889065384864807,
-0.5722333192825317,
0.004417788702994585,
0.6354956030845642,
0.09362244606018066,
0.697691023349762,
-0.3068928122520447,
0.5235897898674011,
0.3953818082809448,
-0.04619370028376579,
-0.16869404911994934,
-0.3854677379131317,
-0.6798409223556519,
-0.5708972215652466,
0.267718642950058,
0.5792492628097534,
-0.8348984122276306,
0.7014564871788025,
-0.2620243430137634,
-0.34190964698791504,
-0.6766717433929443,
0.2057601660490036,
0.12686417996883392,
0.1841939091682434,
0.32688993215560913,
-0.5044471025466919,
-0.2980661392211914,
-0.7636415958404541,
0.05479530617594719,
-0.05893496796488762,
-0.1511497050523758,
0.5048396587371826,
0.0464533194899559,
-0.35753709077835083,
1.1927350759506226,
-0.5842176079750061,
-0.1993926763534546,
-0.5709959864616394,
0.06088792532682419,
0.22218197584152222,
0.6242484450340271,
0.44262638688087463,
-0.6815600991249084,
-0.2233942598104477,
0.02814289554953575,
-0.500565767288208,
-0.12621690332889557,
-0.18971136212348938,
-0.26635390520095825,
0.22292868793010712,
0.0989011749625206,
-0.73145592212677,
0.6566632390022278,
0.5081700682640076,
-0.10181475430727005,
0.39960384368896484,
-0.18551591038703918,
0.09549102932214737,
-1.3142935037612915,
-0.17250527441501617,
-0.20482106506824493,
0.020571742206811905,
-0.7054265737533569,
-0.14146746695041656,
-0.315888911485672,
-0.20575492084026337,
-0.34433239698410034,
0.5044090151786804,
-0.17830108106136322,
-0.0010929254349321127,
-0.42728903889656067,
0.08620957285165787,
-0.2440073937177658,
0.6307780742645264,
0.14028377830982208,
0.6517356038093567,
0.5180152654647827,
-0.7529944181442261,
0.43124356865882874,
0.661693811416626,
-0.37718862295150757,
0.5471165180206299,
-0.5735424757003784,
-0.15829162299633026,
-0.18227633833885193,
0.4205399751663208,
-0.89467453956604,
-0.3190765082836151,
0.11905258893966675,
-0.2479184865951538,
0.1936255693435669,
-0.060193635523319244,
-0.4911815822124481,
-0.07830146700143814,
-0.0366351455450058,
0.4775667190551758,
0.42803123593330383,
-0.726587176322937,
0.5413349866867065,
0.43878403306007385,
-0.6498166918754578,
-0.49104487895965576,
-0.42034950852394104,
-0.019639762118458748,
-0.2148752212524414,
-0.7174359560012817,
0.2829335331916809,
-0.36012834310531616,
-0.3868458569049835,
-0.048636049032211304,
-0.07324250042438507,
-0.03422103449702263,
-0.1246374174952507,
0.20094728469848633,
0.3229585587978363,
0.019243167713284492,
0.10163860768079758,
0.4981440305709839,
-0.07377129048109055,
-0.2863274812698364,
-0.37906068563461304,
0.6435067653656006,
0.2296692579984665,
-0.49164122343063354,
-0.20326033234596252,
0.6201099753379822,
0.412602037191391,
-0.33927807211875916,
0.8102333545684814,
0.3905721604824066,
-0.19857241213321686,
-0.29266372323036194,
-0.29918143153190613,
-0.09143809974193573,
-0.44150829315185547,
0.23861336708068848,
-0.2601996660232544,
-1.3003873825073242,
0.6228622794151306,
-0.14411526918411255,
0.19623617827892303,
0.2602122128009796,
0.8039020895957947,
0.15281131863594055,
1.2315410375595093,
0.5215103626251221,
-0.23156926035881042,
0.46630701422691345,
-0.14554649591445923,
0.15964403748512268,
-0.6142629981040955,
0.038575101643800735,
-0.4367954432964325,
-0.2961123287677765,
-0.7870298624038696,
-0.511703372001648,
0.31852126121520996,
0.17513319849967957,
0.0933576449751854,
0.010544724762439728,
-0.27302518486976624,
0.3164350092411041,
0.3948608636856079,
-0.056666139513254166,
0.5879800319671631,
0.2737651467323303,
-0.04719874635338783,
-0.14269736409187317,
-0.6584615707397461,
-0.31569498777389526,
0.9871696829795837,
0.3673090636730194,
1.184899091720581,
0.21313504874706268,
0.6391894221305847,
0.15942154824733734,
0.06259091943502426,
-0.723094642162323,
0.5679728984832764,
-0.10627453029155731,
-0.10440564155578613,
-0.5337467193603516,
-0.6861772537231445,
-0.8021771907806396,
0.3174290657043457,
-0.2791878879070282,
-0.9091073870658875,
0.4429174065589905,
0.088249072432518,
-0.19720043241977692,
0.3423210382461548,
-0.3623908460140228,
0.42910465598106384,
0.09074752032756805,
-0.12614695727825165,
-0.23117727041244507,
-0.42803797125816345,
0.27186813950538635,
-0.19725407660007477,
0.08235345780849457,
0.012546521611511707,
0.1882239580154419,
0.4900849163532257,
-0.73487788438797,
0.9196906685829163,
-0.22833387553691864,
-0.44228336215019226,
0.3713787794113159,
0.039548978209495544,
0.7951576113700867,
0.03587754815816879,
0.21405841410160065,
0.01827767863869667,
-0.4208652079105377,
-0.40039506554603577,
-0.6865090131759644,
0.8293166756629944,
-0.6768430471420288,
-0.528229832649231,
-0.008493294008076191,
-0.8075428009033203,
-0.4559800624847412,
0.05386533588171005,
0.05410186946392059,
0.47101157903671265,
-0.2414351999759674,
0.3145785927772522,
0.6099628210067749,
-0.33040738105773926,
0.39102408289909363,
0.5115529894828796,
-0.22253809869289398,
-0.5164267420768738,
0.9343052506446838,
0.03430395945906639,
0.7314357757568359,
0.15485112369060516,
0.008768439292907715,
-0.2340785712003708,
-0.8169008493423462,
-0.5471449494361877,
0.07092663645744324,
-0.41914308071136475,
-0.11323040723800659,
-0.7975683212280273,
-0.24094928801059723,
-0.31665822863578796,
0.043633729219436646,
-0.18302233517169952,
-0.8814170360565186,
-0.1403154879808426,
-0.23656980693340302,
0.44331997632980347,
0.4851643741130829,
-0.1302342712879181,
0.6331183314323425,
-0.7831193804740906,
0.3576202690601349,
0.23886176943778992,
0.4572242200374603,
-0.1546834260225296,
-0.38085615634918213,
-0.36581891775131226,
0.31328296661376953,
-0.20210924744606018,
-0.5805484056472778,
0.4636097848415375,
0.10319001227617264,
0.6699254512786865,
0.31557244062423706,
0.10493551939725876,
0.41417354345321655,
-0.2646816670894623,
0.7979673743247986,
0.1508001685142517,
-0.5705237984657288,
0.5854243040084839,
-0.49073174595832825,
0.3878820240497589,
0.42071059346199036,
0.05943210795521736,
-0.2595513164997101,
-0.8735387921333313,
-0.6415588855743408,
-0.9225824475288391,
0.7960798740386963,
0.3414282500743866,
0.3174108862876892,
0.21642224490642548,
-0.14818812906742096,
0.26971614360809326,
0.39257097244262695,
-0.45703914761543274,
-0.1772812008857727,
-0.17096179723739624,
-0.16299931704998016,
-0.019926074892282486,
-0.07002504169940948,
-0.43049582839012146,
-0.036901094019412994,
0.47453773021698,
-0.3244466781616211,
0.03790048137307167,
-0.15074576437473297,
-0.03325076773762703,
-0.2457982897758484,
0.524350643157959,
0.46351754665374756,
0.581381618976593,
-0.1645226627588272,
-0.32995083928108215,
0.0848497673869133,
-0.4528403580188751,
0.16044053435325623,
0.2411089390516281,
-0.3664437532424927,
0.05768650025129318,
0.03176574781537056,
1.0642173290252686,
-0.1659485548734665,
-0.5741776823997498,
0.2690470516681671,
0.07116300612688065,
-0.05504562333226204,
0.10537157952785492,
0.2638671398162842,
-0.3004535138607025,
0.31264835596084595,
0.24984490871429443,
0.026143420487642288,
0.03282323107123375,
-0.307182252407074,
0.1656455248594284,
0.44873443245887756,
-0.09309520572423935,
0.05555881932377815,
0.43144363164901733,
0.3014827370643616,
0.0534362718462944,
0.397866815328598,
-0.2149115949869156,
-0.1635468304157257,
0.28288528323173523,
0.5772914290428162,
0.8245729207992554,
-0.3108004331588745,
0.3008519113063812,
0.2490936666727066,
0.18371598422527313,
0.19135704636573792,
0.27795955538749695,
-0.24899476766586304,
-0.930159866809845,
-0.685706377029419,
-0.6701099276542664,
-0.7141647934913635,
0.12796816229820251,
-0.6589794158935547,
-0.07395055890083313,
-0.3590790331363678,
-0.02891780622303486,
-0.2621660828590393,
-0.2603771388530731,
-0.38448747992515564,
0.35566017031669617,
-0.2095630168914795,
0.7743762135505676,
-0.5993739366531372,
0.7138736248016357,
0.35665395855903625,
-0.23809947073459625,
-0.5276971459388733,
0.11012014746665955,
-0.23284655809402466,
-0.5910195112228394,
0.3865356743335724,
-0.1202773004770279,
0.006296081002801657,
-0.11018503457307816,
-0.5895061492919922,
-0.7539780139923096,
0.9197709560394287,
0.0208994559943676,
-0.4403436779975891,
0.04754975810647011,
0.3895096480846405,
0.47668471932411194,
-0.8016821146011353,
0.031266313046216965,
0.6184207201004028,
0.3468146026134491,
0.5108657479286194,
-0.9256232380867004,
-0.12105882912874222,
-0.30084747076034546,
0.15432675182819366,
0.23883968591690063,
-0.4354414939880371,
0.5307299494743347,
-0.216220885515213,
-0.21223865449428558,
0.25674620270729065,
0.8901295065879822,
0.3351269066333771,
0.1048806831240654,
0.6614278554916382,
0.6316424608230591,
0.5891135931015015,
-0.15720239281654358,
0.8331496119499207,
-0.12110325694084167,
0.044708531349897385,
1.1887069940567017,
-0.2946411073207855,
0.5612156391143799,
0.2591821849346161,
-0.12459070235490799,
0.3313896656036377,
0.362439900636673,
0.13238875567913055,
0.5101866126060486,
0.2725994288921356,
-0.5074507594108582,
-0.1444178819656372,
-0.4734012186527252,
-0.3222079873085022,
0.5757481455802917,
0.6434502601623535,
-0.21530325710773468,
-0.22865384817123413,
0.2266986221075058,
-0.08331123739480972,
0.14226359128952026,
-0.29464954137802124,
1.1412051916122437,
-0.20815707743167877,
-0.5208967924118042,
0.67628413438797,
-0.0060747647657990456,
0.5763670206069946,
-0.6460317969322205,
0.012059122323989868,
-0.4061811864376068,
-0.03841637074947357,
-0.16328637301921844,
-0.6996094584465027,
0.1284252405166626,
0.15961533784866333,
-0.19544407725334167,
-0.14851190149784088,
0.5698192715644836,
-0.8924899101257324,
-0.37429583072662354,
0.14638954401016235,
0.5458356738090515,
-0.009927110746502876,
0.23412950336933136,
-0.2145729660987854,
0.05519988387823105,
0.061803895980119705,
-0.04899963364005089,
0.3864162266254425,
0.34598928689956665,
-0.2791999578475952,
0.5558923482894897,
0.7145342826843262,
0.3705652952194214,
-0.06829142570495605,
0.30558067560195923,
1.3249670267105103,
-0.4226548671722412,
-0.6905488967895508,
-0.43787315487861633,
0.557420551776886,
-0.3970283567905426,
-0.11732460558414459,
0.6015551090240479,
0.4103549122810364,
0.8600790500640869,
0.011997907422482967,
1.07964289188385,
0.04880242794752121,
0.758945643901825,
-0.6335694789886475,
0.505236029624939,
-0.3064139187335968,
0.25454452633857727,
-0.30806344747543335,
-1.2177592515945435,
-0.11988149583339691,
0.35926756262779236,
-0.12277467548847198,
0.11496124416589737,
0.20046032965183258,
0.8971726894378662,
-0.13981926441192627,
0.06971569359302521,
0.35554924607276917,
0.3112529218196869,
0.5174137353897095,
0.33863121271133423,
0.982671320438385,
0.19816270470619202,
0.47976377606391907,
-0.0361236147582531,
-0.65425044298172,
-0.16755948960781097,
-0.630160391330719,
-0.859144389629364,
-0.3477005362510681,
-0.16673211753368378,
-0.47185418009757996,
-0.26204344630241394,
1.025607943534851,
0.5518708229064941,
-0.8895313739776611,
-0.25428104400634766,
-0.02025246061384678,
0.09164594858884811,
-0.03199975565075874,
-0.23007865250110626,
0.08656422048807144,
-0.284636914730072,
-1.0257657766342163,
0.6977020502090454,
0.42557623982429504,
0.39101696014404297,
-0.38454824686050415,
-0.20832014083862305,
0.15934595465660095,
0.2859303057193756,
0.5178770422935486,
0.3189128041267395,
-0.532162606716156,
-0.09668738394975662,
-0.14185290038585663,
0.05269160494208336,
-0.011220285668969154,
0.9853237867355347,
-0.489913672208786,
0.7412220239639282,
0.36355021595954895,
0.7624733448028564,
0.45791375637054443,
0.16778749227523804,
0.9811064600944519,
-0.9564473628997803,
0.33664730191230774,
0.20975711941719055,
0.19688397645950317,
0.2703526020050049,
-0.20297151803970337,
0.3295935094356537,
0.07519219070672989,
-0.4076266288757324,
-0.6820723414421082,
0.611544668674469,
-1.0766608715057373,
-0.06022533029317856,
1.1529009342193604,
-0.06986936926841736,
0.14848476648330688,
0.058864254504442215,
-0.5359194278717041,
0.12600205838680267,
-0.6228033304214478,
0.5788663029670715,
0.6611687541007996,
-0.18236839771270752,
0.04577744007110596,
-0.03957665339112282,
0.6425850987434387,
0.3354188799858093,
-1.0868557691574097,
0.27971744537353516,
0.8719404339790344,
-0.2294856607913971,
0.2553427517414093,
0.5877106189727783,
-0.10465336591005325,
0.03120505064725876,
-0.24741533398628235,
-0.22292989492416382,
-0.04025344178080559,
-0.4420309066772461,
-0.2986210286617279,
-0.02530651167035103,
-0.006557433400303125,
-0.26184651255607605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00344v1
|
Can LLMs Master Math? Investigating Large Language Models on Math Stack Exchange
| 2024-03-30T12:48:31 | 2024-03-30T12:48:31 |
Ankit Satpute, Noah Giessing, Andre Greiner-Petter, Moritz Schubotz, Olaf Teschke, Akiko Aizawa, Bela Gipp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional capabilities in
various natural language tasks, often achieving performances that surpass those
of humans. Despite these advancements, the domain of mathematics presents a
distinctive challenge, primarily due to its specialized structure and the
precision it demands. In this study, we adopted a two-step approach for
investigating the proficiency of LLMs in answering mathematical questions.
First, we employ the most effective LLMs, as identified by their performance on
math question-answer benchmarks, to generate answers to 78 questions from the
Math Stack Exchange (MSE). Second, a case analysis is conducted on the LLM that
showed the highest performance, focusing on the quality and accuracy of its
answers through manual evaluation. We found that GPT-4 performs best (nDCG of
0.48 and P@10 of 0.37) amongst existing LLMs fine-tuned for answering
mathematics questions and outperforms the current best approach on ArqMATH3
Task1, considering P@10. Our Case analysis indicates that while the GPT-4 can
generate relevant responses in certain instances, it does not consistently
answer all questions accurately. This paper explores the current limitations of
LLMs in navigating complex mathematical problem-solving. Through case analysis,
we shed light on the gaps in LLM capabilities within mathematics, thereby
setting the stage for future research and advancements in AI-driven
mathematical reasoning. We make our code and findings publicly available for
research: \url{https://github.com/gipplab/LLM-Investig-MathStackExchange}
|
[
-0.44142258167266846,
-0.9670028686523438,
0.8330116868019104,
0.22136111557483673,
-0.1528780311346054,
0.4641834497451782,
-0.1874765306711197,
-0.39593684673309326,
-0.19824527204036713,
0.37792378664016724,
-0.5821912288665771,
-0.3915437161922455,
-0.9116860032081604,
0.3003201484680176,
-0.23823237419128418,
0.7956119775772095,
-0.29999440908432007,
0.19648194313049316,
-0.6283977031707764,
0.014945756644010544,
-0.5861777663230896,
-0.7477807998657227,
-0.7008513808250427,
-0.31071019172668457,
0.24868696928024292,
0.1813848912715912,
0.5802591443061829,
0.26947522163391113,
0.810147225856781,
0.2881582975387573,
-0.05437136068940163,
0.2193981260061264,
-0.4755227863788605,
0.03288944438099861,
0.11522406339645386,
-0.6889440417289734,
-0.800701379776001,
0.0016331839142367244,
0.4974934756755829,
0.796807050704956,
-0.16140499711036682,
0.0626644566655159,
0.11136820912361145,
0.6899757385253906,
-0.279999703168869,
0.25639551877975464,
-0.7205557823181152,
-0.03682832792401314,
-0.39082029461860657,
-0.06297113746404648,
-0.15449093282222748,
-0.3611571192741394,
0.134983092546463,
-0.5210738182067871,
0.0979214683175087,
-0.0856223851442337,
0.46448978781700134,
0.1572984904050827,
-0.40439459681510925,
-0.4326547682285309,
-0.6875014305114746,
0.8450241088867188,
-0.7362351417541504,
0.20938265323638916,
0.2419503629207611,
0.48221704363822937,
-0.11608407646417618,
-0.5061208009719849,
-0.2979651093482971,
0.01023904886096716,
0.14748245477676392,
0.16143150627613068,
-0.38964033126831055,
-0.11371758580207825,
0.4807127118110657,
0.39989832043647766,
-0.6386076211929321,
-0.04347856715321541,
-0.3492124676704407,
-0.21740540862083435,
0.52921062707901,
0.36992302536964417,
0.24590255320072174,
0.06349926441907883,
-0.0028527947142720222,
0.13064424693584442,
-0.8434306383132935,
0.03290347009897232,
0.2685393989086151,
0.08378632366657257,
0.10386666655540466,
0.8145475387573242,
0.06646805256605148,
0.5566032528877258,
-0.17085476219654083,
-0.10380382090806961,
-0.07000745087862015,
-0.307049036026001,
-0.1325201690196991,
-0.32462239265441895,
0.5556197762489319,
0.1613292545080185,
0.6309974193572998,
-0.0062797293066978455,
-0.32987430691719055,
-0.11529595404863358,
0.24488875269889832,
-0.6851358413696289,
-0.18238089978694916,
0.1075577437877655,
0.0667543113231659,
0.052557650953531265,
-0.0499269999563694,
-0.4492887556552887,
-0.18008331954479218,
-0.2737957537174225,
0.47067704796791077,
-0.17212821543216705,
-0.24544638395309448,
0.24377962946891785,
0.2843834459781647,
0.15502052009105682,
0.3661533296108246,
-0.653132975101471,
0.5529967546463013,
0.977303147315979,
0.8128629922866821,
-0.40306565165519714,
-0.05320998281240463,
-0.5398863554000854,
-0.13848735392093658,
-0.47212791442871094,
0.6809701919555664,
-0.45542261004447937,
-0.5470841526985168,
0.03620734065771103,
-0.4352768361568451,
-0.3155904710292816,
-0.86688232421875,
0.5977632999420166,
-0.8720465302467346,
0.05543074384331703,
-0.30830222368240356,
-0.6305130124092102,
0.0856403335928917,
0.4709485173225403,
-0.4379884600639343,
0.7933117151260376,
-0.027033401653170586,
-0.4643018841743469,
-0.24193714559078217,
-0.6501108407974243,
-0.2655668556690216,
-0.0026602616999298334,
-0.32972443103790283,
-0.42882126569747925,
0.2803102433681488,
0.3387623131275177,
0.4497426152229309,
-0.3769521415233612,
0.3005087971687317,
-0.23676809668540955,
-0.35293036699295044,
0.667145311832428,
-0.5590970516204834,
0.5276919603347778,
-0.03059731237590313,
-0.1301899552345276,
-0.2294038087129593,
-0.4172097146511078,
0.022069137543439865,
0.36006075143814087,
-0.21110162138938904,
-0.028160888701677322,
-0.21256162226200104,
-0.5022284984588623,
0.18363738059997559,
0.4056849777698517,
-0.32725468277931213,
0.25561749935150146,
-0.30344101786613464,
0.4633884131908417,
0.9407278299331665,
-0.13819684088230133,
0.36439815163612366,
-0.32837751507759094,
0.9197467565536499,
-0.1355326920747757,
-0.157724067568779,
-0.04776082932949066,
-0.6466518640518188,
-0.6258363723754883,
-0.07748374342918396,
0.3729071617126465,
0.6435370445251465,
-0.5661827921867371,
-0.002740640891715884,
-0.2736320197582245,
-0.13042382895946503,
-0.33570361137390137,
0.358877569437027,
0.4131302535533905,
0.4910012483596802,
0.3150204122066498,
0.03996635600924492,
-0.2777014970779419,
-1.0126451253890991,
-0.46714943647384644,
0.00048543408047407866,
-0.18767805397510529,
0.5099335312843323,
0.5912359356880188,
-0.0809805691242218,
0.8754381537437439,
-0.7302454710006714,
-0.14802546799182892,
-0.21660655736923218,
0.07950259000062943,
0.4376291334629059,
0.06418793648481369,
0.2850936949253082,
-0.6424497365951538,
-0.4753483533859253,
-0.08019071072340012,
-0.8446570038795471,
-0.2915981113910675,
0.16212275624275208,
-0.12181488424539566,
0.08417785167694092,
0.3962509334087372,
-0.7026450634002686,
0.244729146361351,
0.49059051275253296,
0.001862179720774293,
0.6672195196151733,
-0.08346516638994217,
-0.09054387360811234,
-0.9025527834892273,
-0.01734725758433342,
0.025375433266162872,
-0.1156017854809761,
-0.6472147703170776,
-0.07638806849718094,
0.12893275916576385,
-0.023627646267414093,
-0.2185087352991104,
0.47274455428123474,
-0.4974546730518341,
-0.31415072083473206,
-0.2897765636444092,
0.22942830622196198,
-0.2527017891407013,
0.4909532368183136,
-0.274013489484787,
0.9749389290809631,
0.6171707510948181,
-0.5416149497032166,
0.24468384683132172,
0.07892250269651413,
-0.2192591279745102,
0.6160971522331238,
-0.8215239644050598,
0.1671188473701477,
-0.016420433297753334,
0.059129126369953156,
-1.1356091499328613,
-0.09946921467781067,
0.2052222639322281,
-0.6077713370323181,
0.1777791827917099,
-0.15828979015350342,
-0.6799115538597107,
-0.4000413119792938,
-0.08187147974967957,
0.4990546703338623,
0.4630829989910126,
-0.10501182079315186,
0.7544993758201599,
0.20249134302139282,
-0.6305361390113831,
-0.5300095081329346,
-0.427019864320755,
0.11470340192317963,
-0.022136222571134567,
-0.6864721775054932,
0.04220898449420929,
-0.473720908164978,
-0.5487643480300903,
-0.09660981595516205,
-0.40704110264778137,
-0.049201179295778275,
0.22512684762477875,
0.013600088655948639,
0.3967898488044739,
-0.25068092346191406,
0.0835324302315712,
0.02058301493525505,
-0.39149990677833557,
0.4377201795578003,
-0.1374465525150299,
0.49761801958084106,
-0.3351742625236511,
-0.7373253107070923,
-0.23130665719509125,
0.18597687780857086,
0.6434796452522278,
-0.2782961130142212,
0.2587808072566986,
0.19987225532531738,
-0.44414404034614563,
0.06046542897820473,
-0.5498160719871521,
-0.2037307620048523,
-0.48596253991127014,
0.2630920112133026,
-0.6139858365058899,
-1.1198681592941284,
0.540565013885498,
-0.06895707547664642,
0.35581308603286743,
0.5373019576072693,
0.5264504551887512,
-0.14748333394527435,
1.116493582725525,
0.2951047420501709,
-0.043932974338531494,
-0.0597495473921299,
-0.32335910201072693,
0.2651006877422333,
-0.9025098085403442,
-0.17059457302093506,
-0.3914318382740021,
-0.3047739863395691,
-0.2566888928413391,
-0.4557308852672577,
0.7630888223648071,
0.13190770149230957,
-0.06240216642618179,
-0.0464555062353611,
-0.13152992725372314,
0.597770631313324,
0.33823052048683167,
-0.1294032633304596,
0.4809417724609375,
-0.021144215017557144,
-0.18485136330127716,
-0.17186205089092255,
-0.5689916610717773,
-0.4236932396888733,
1.260338544845581,
0.3431852161884308,
0.4913523495197296,
0.359516978263855,
0.4185347855091095,
-0.017227938398718834,
0.3831290304660797,
-0.6956868171691895,
0.7736011147499084,
-0.006863000802695751,
-0.5512765049934387,
-0.2856980860233307,
-0.64389568567276,
-0.8691466450691223,
0.32659170031547546,
-0.07553231716156006,
-0.31790369749069214,
-0.5243886709213257,
-0.09487564861774445,
-0.22830675542354584,
0.27277690172195435,
-0.33261409401893616,
0.5676449537277222,
-0.4805707335472107,
-0.27271273732185364,
-0.09504495561122894,
-0.44164538383483887,
0.397293359041214,
-0.4155105650424957,
0.37423235177993774,
-0.2288919985294342,
-0.15071989595890045,
0.6379628777503967,
-0.38416600227355957,
0.7286564111709595,
0.08225630968809128,
-0.4842190444469452,
0.317411869764328,
0.33449047803878784,
0.49556487798690796,
0.209347665309906,
-0.005836572963744402,
0.2377852350473404,
-0.17473819851875305,
-0.5711862444877625,
-0.7773835062980652,
0.823891282081604,
-0.7792686820030212,
-0.8988199234008789,
-0.5302817225456238,
-0.5929886102676392,
-0.5254440307617188,
0.08933380246162415,
-0.038462426513433456,
0.5437189936637878,
0.17662933468818665,
0.02272871695458889,
0.8358851671218872,
0.07217837125062943,
0.44515421986579895,
0.4482288062572479,
-0.24154667556285858,
-0.3986741900444031,
0.6963911652565002,
0.384380042552948,
0.2296539545059204,
0.4183446764945984,
0.31409952044487,
-0.5541890859603882,
-0.8480082750320435,
-0.533710241317749,
0.5762425661087036,
-0.6808469891548157,
-0.13115756213665009,
-0.6661227941513062,
-0.3470342755317688,
-0.2841782569885254,
-0.014894291758537292,
-0.27589499950408936,
-0.26873305439949036,
-0.27122408151626587,
-0.031071605160832405,
0.23430904746055603,
0.7958943843841553,
0.1870310753583908,
0.04650497809052467,
-0.7141548991203308,
0.32860907912254333,
0.8255326747894287,
0.3189994990825653,
-0.0635485053062439,
-0.646111011505127,
0.04576272889971733,
0.1868409514427185,
-0.26287317276000977,
-0.5905784964561462,
0.03736792504787445,
-0.10084903985261917,
0.6250844597816467,
0.2389586865901947,
-0.15857940912246704,
0.7813631892204285,
-0.5832889080047607,
0.5965545773506165,
0.08002522587776184,
-0.8921105861663818,
0.2900206744670868,
-0.45189324021339417,
0.39510461688041687,
0.31751081347465515,
0.3518957793712616,
-0.3674587607383728,
-0.3583803176879883,
-0.5529981255531311,
-0.47332674264907837,
0.38533836603164673,
0.48663631081581116,
0.2507549822330475,
0.141752228140831,
0.690428614616394,
0.02713518589735031,
0.3639351725578308,
-0.5118209719657898,
-0.2949460446834564,
0.4100000560283661,
-0.030202951282262802,
-0.1756209284067154,
-0.18251633644104004,
-0.21432198584079742,
-0.15199539065361023,
0.4408092796802521,
-0.08161560446023941,
0.339356005191803,
-0.13999506831169128,
-0.1253226399421692,
-0.0945572778582573,
0.1924072504043579,
0.834568440914154,
1.1469752788543701,
-0.010676027275621891,
0.24236343801021576,
0.4546496272087097,
-0.4730720520019531,
-0.0823727697134018,
0.11044801771640778,
0.20166555047035217,
-0.137498676776886,
0.41242510080337524,
0.30848556756973267,
0.16753403842449188,
-0.7704467177391052,
0.6691145300865173,
-0.12392689287662506,
-0.538809597492218,
-0.4414152204990387,
0.008525651879608631,
0.3054162561893463,
0.32263612747192383,
0.6768993735313416,
-0.05371527373790741,
-0.012029639445245266,
-0.4460712671279907,
0.057855501770973206,
0.7058032751083374,
0.013955247588455677,
-0.3388274312019348,
0.6035875678062439,
0.08886964619159698,
-0.3890537917613983,
0.5924792885780334,
0.009360390715301037,
-0.6794403195381165,
0.7590184807777405,
0.5497864484786987,
0.574467658996582,
-0.04101340472698212,
-0.03391534835100174,
0.0680469423532486,
0.2787232995033264,
-0.08766494691371918,
0.21719910204410553,
0.1867218017578125,
-0.6545079946517944,
-0.6805303692817688,
-0.47812119126319885,
-0.7126526236534119,
0.03272834047675133,
-0.4703414738178253,
-0.013264822773635387,
-0.5202288031578064,
-0.006761986296623945,
-0.22870498895645142,
0.17631091177463531,
-0.5059621930122375,
-0.0066184611059725285,
0.10286078602075577,
0.539300799369812,
-0.5957381129264832,
0.3604470193386078,
0.7329350709915161,
0.09717417508363724,
-0.5062177181243896,
-0.15807993710041046,
0.004003216978162527,
-1.1453704833984375,
0.48821038007736206,
0.06830344349145889,
-0.321278840303421,
0.14109010994434357,
-0.5796287059783936,
-0.5969421863555908,
1.0511096715927124,
0.3131761848926544,
-0.5916178822517395,
0.15682072937488556,
0.44590067863464355,
0.5634480714797974,
-0.19466687738895416,
0.34912654757499695,
0.4396792948246002,
0.35177791118621826,
0.29088181257247925,
-0.9576773643493652,
-0.2391495555639267,
-0.22151650488376617,
-0.07144692540168762,
0.3226891756057739,
-0.5753659009933472,
0.9523637294769287,
-0.1996019035577774,
-0.05638408660888672,
0.14743512868881226,
0.562556266784668,
0.5465491414070129,
0.5737931728363037,
0.2895967662334442,
0.5889747142791748,
0.8769655227661133,
-0.14981505274772644,
0.8796106576919556,
-0.24125418066978455,
0.34842872619628906,
0.7436832785606384,
-0.29653745889663696,
0.8268764615058899,
0.28900715708732605,
-0.4644223153591156,
0.16567327082157135,
0.5473295450210571,
0.1862829178571701,
0.078212209045887,
0.5362252593040466,
-0.3982817232608795,
-0.5675411820411682,
0.29975512623786926,
-0.4219914674758911,
0.11479613184928894,
0.3754112720489502,
0.02638828568160534,
-0.19382990896701813,
-0.037678711116313934,
0.2180052399635315,
0.17968341708183289,
-0.4682601988315582,
0.49732163548469543,
0.27457162737846375,
-0.47394615411758423,
0.5165636539459229,
0.027919413521885872,
0.567726194858551,
-0.5816583037376404,
-0.08244076371192932,
-0.46504828333854675,
0.13396872580051422,
0.019640905782580376,
-0.9574882984161377,
0.2186463177204132,
0.16062889993190765,
0.007341578137129545,
-0.2652498185634613,
0.47860053181648254,
-0.19546526670455933,
-0.7183162569999695,
-0.09468600898981094,
1.0820956230163574,
0.3087543547153473,
-0.2593754529953003,
-0.7697677612304688,
0.09376257658004761,
-0.3453839123249054,
0.019444338977336884,
0.4540345370769501,
0.5118196606636047,
-0.0675620511174202,
0.9647523760795593,
0.6986881494522095,
-0.14710012078285217,
0.16623768210411072,
-0.08315446227788925,
0.8188856244087219,
-0.503504753112793,
-0.08399725705385208,
-1.115632176399231,
0.25044727325439453,
0.11696081608533859,
-0.32987120747566223,
0.837395429611206,
0.7212719917297363,
0.7202438712120056,
0.0036686297971755266,
0.8162875771522522,
0.39685288071632385,
0.5277950167655945,
-0.5511371493339539,
0.29368856549263,
-0.4942554235458374,
0.5615455508232117,
-0.18808774650096893,
-1.023537278175354,
-0.6340899467468262,
0.5207459926605225,
-0.5859485864639282,
0.12026520818471909,
0.7214195132255554,
0.6638857126235962,
-0.04336844012141228,
0.02717270888388157,
0.4257075786590576,
0.20710217952728271,
0.4543338716030121,
0.873254120349884,
0.9930171370506287,
-0.22869247198104858,
0.8629257082939148,
0.08166284114122391,
-0.1533520519733429,
-0.25483736395835876,
-0.6352902054786682,
-1.0777918100357056,
-0.16513675451278687,
-0.23340721428394318,
-0.18887139856815338,
-0.013647661544382572,
0.6501093506813049,
0.1454000622034073,
-0.523739755153656,
-0.4254525601863861,
-0.11061549931764603,
0.19957925379276276,
-0.16705195605754852,
-0.15925008058547974,
0.3859516382217407,
-0.13956385850906372,
-0.8896580934524536,
0.20762914419174194,
0.3589959740638733,
0.1009845957159996,
-0.31977424025535583,
-0.0497315376996994,
0.17006133496761322,
0.06919687986373901,
0.6790944337844849,
0.10476890951395035,
-0.6460046768188477,
-0.10479066520929337,
0.5374074578285217,
-0.2239508032798767,
0.16838474571704865,
1.0003515481948853,
-0.35918164253234863,
0.21338072419166565,
0.28193235397338867,
1.0633867979049683,
0.4699588119983673,
0.04147551953792572,
0.3752707540988922,
-0.44281005859375,
-0.6088438630104065,
0.4071758985519409,
0.3304680585861206,
0.08497388660907745,
-0.13155561685562134,
0.41006550192832947,
0.400603711605072,
-0.5849048495292664,
-0.5816850662231445,
0.20218530297279358,
-1.0325896739959717,
-0.2797764539718628,
1.3190371990203857,
0.06232321634888649,
0.020449835807085037,
-0.16427700221538544,
-0.2046200931072235,
-0.19788677990436554,
-0.2710059881210327,
0.6533613801002502,
1.0148403644561768,
-0.42513230443000793,
-0.39019250869750977,
-0.9291219711303711,
0.03923148289322853,
0.5171567797660828,
-0.8112874627113342,
0.004412516485899687,
0.3852390944957733,
0.39394059777259827,
0.06680060178041458,
0.7015144228935242,
-0.24376609921455383,
0.3013405501842499,
-0.4365341365337372,
-0.34602048993110657,
-0.20141486823558807,
-0.20929445326328278,
-0.36762699484825134,
0.35812005400657654,
0.1949928253889084,
0.04157134145498276
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.