id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01914v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01914v1
|
SCANNER: Knowledge-Enhanced Approach for Robust Multi-modal Named Entity Recognition of Unseen Entities
| 2024-04-02T13:05:41 | 2024-04-02T13:05:41 |
Hyunjong Ok, Taeho Kil, Sukmin Seo, Jaeho Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in named entity recognition (NER) have pushed the boundary of
the task to incorporate visual signals, leading to many variants, including
multi-modal NER (MNER) or grounded MNER (GMNER). A key challenge to these tasks
is that the model should be able to generalize to the entities unseen during
the training, and should be able to handle the training samples with noisy
annotations. To address this obstacle, we propose SCANNER (Span CANdidate
detection and recognition for NER), a model capable of effectively handling all
three NER variants. SCANNER is a two-stage structure; we extract entity
candidates in the first stage and use it as a query to get knowledge,
effectively pulling knowledge from various sources. We can boost our
performance by utilizing this entity-centric extracted knowledge to address
unseen entities. Furthermore, to tackle the challenges arising from noisy
annotations in NER datasets, we introduce a novel self-distillation method,
enhancing the robustness and accuracy of our model in processing training data
with inherent uncertainties. Our approach demonstrates competitive performance
on the NER benchmark and surpasses existing methods on both MNER and GMNER
benchmarks. Further analysis shows that the proposed distillation and knowledge
utilization methods improve the performance of our model on various benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6900535225868225,
-0.3751249611377716,
0.557486355304718,
-0.08961520344018936,
-0.41826409101486206,
0.22498847544193268,
0.06440762430429459,
-0.8887512683868408,
0.4397519528865814,
0.28483477234840393,
-0.33953797817230225,
-0.12647315859794617,
-0.9135696887969971,
0.282560795545578,
-0.4250153601169586,
0.9828758239746094,
0.05957947298884392,
0.2090911865234375,
-0.004891549237072468,
-0.11244131624698639,
-0.36168402433395386,
-0.23586180806159973,
-0.9047308564186096,
-0.22768045961856842,
0.3267596960067749,
-0.0064373197965323925,
0.2873707413673401,
0.5605213642120361,
0.6354501247406006,
0.3272642493247986,
-0.09105442464351654,
0.3039446771144867,
-0.08825425058603287,
0.5269156098365784,
-0.13975754380226135,
-0.24054673314094543,
-0.37679150700569153,
-0.0686231181025505,
0.4914970099925995,
0.5102514624595642,
-0.009888744913041592,
-0.02317972481250763,
-0.043938759714365005,
0.45188021659851074,
-0.9947482347488403,
0.21639789640903473,
-0.8139008283615112,
-0.09639434516429901,
-0.2673330307006836,
-0.17246145009994507,
-0.14671167731285095,
-0.09007755666971207,
0.04114742577075958,
-0.8200961947441101,
0.2661685645580292,
-0.13988879323005676,
0.9685791730880737,
0.7400215864181519,
-0.5539979338645935,
-0.45782333612442017,
-0.8278956413269043,
0.5307793617248535,
-0.262784868478775,
0.4874477684497833,
0.42569124698638916,
0.6450533270835876,
0.02200286276638508,
-0.9623191356658936,
-0.5237364172935486,
-0.09499835222959518,
0.05963234603404999,
0.37648168206214905,
-0.27613186836242676,
0.06922812759876251,
0.324655145406723,
0.3479959964752197,
0.029738303273916245,
-0.023368345573544502,
-0.3291580379009247,
-0.329052209854126,
0.2573806941509247,
-0.00716801593080163,
0.003431445686146617,
0.010952639393508434,
-0.6053928136825562,
-0.05595184117555618,
-0.13323204219341278,
-0.07873284816741943,
0.27882081270217896,
0.13681606948375702,
0.24057544767856598,
0.5192055106163025,
-0.5504663586616516,
0.7087375521659851,
0.5680869817733765,
-0.40517759323120117,
0.35793057084083557,
-0.09688576310873032,
-0.13975076377391815,
0.07507182657718658,
0.5550801157951355,
0.08443953841924667,
-0.15726527571678162,
-0.08875994384288788,
-0.6577700972557068,
0.08431185036897659,
0.1016189232468605,
-0.906639039516449,
-0.3660990595817566,
-0.09585624188184738,
-0.3813817501068115,
-0.46861526370048523,
-0.005723048932850361,
-0.8992792367935181,
-0.782886266708374,
-0.26206204295158386,
0.4151041805744171,
-0.6102591156959534,
-0.43520525097846985,
-0.012777620926499367,
-0.38169339299201965,
0.21873262524604797,
0.6152687072753906,
-0.7081120610237122,
0.06908505409955978,
0.3468181788921356,
0.5869705080986023,
0.04564390704035759,
0.05355915054678917,
-0.5837329030036926,
0.2710237205028534,
-0.07878412306308746,
0.7289808988571167,
-0.6318661570549011,
-0.27252957224845886,
-0.6161500215530396,
-0.35386204719543457,
-0.23548834025859833,
-0.48765817284584045,
0.5144137740135193,
-0.8097763657569885,
0.010661388747394085,
0.06310281157493591,
-0.689242422580719,
-0.19359253346920013,
0.41668543219566345,
-1.0166316032409668,
1.0800516605377197,
-0.08281675726175308,
-1.2022162675857544,
0.7609308362007141,
-0.782465398311615,
-0.12189088016748428,
0.3020714223384857,
-0.4036886990070343,
-0.4188636839389801,
0.32793882489204407,
0.5777648091316223,
0.32329219579696655,
-0.09023600071668625,
0.3805221915245056,
-0.3444730043411255,
-0.1629345417022705,
0.0440010242164135,
-0.5440473556518555,
0.6262049078941345,
0.32037803530693054,
-0.3669932782649994,
-0.28869175910949707,
-1.0112333297729492,
0.037391453981399536,
0.11384686827659607,
-0.4096633791923523,
-0.7255457639694214,
-0.09946990758180618,
0.025471391156315804,
0.2489139884710312,
0.21870015561580658,
-0.5453991293907166,
0.23997901380062103,
-0.16000249981880188,
0.18065287172794342,
0.34491440653800964,
0.19745054841041565,
0.3088781535625458,
0.09066949784755707,
0.5568463206291199,
0.23406469821929932,
0.06674912571907043,
-0.09368402510881424,
-0.19272826611995697,
-0.8652940988540649,
-0.7788031101226807,
0.6174253225326538,
0.3544695973396301,
-0.9738383889198303,
0.2730344533920288,
-0.23443067073822021,
-0.6033239364624023,
-0.5047969818115234,
-0.16375412046909332,
0.19304940104484558,
0.6856210231781006,
0.47244584560394287,
-0.2649611234664917,
-0.8453883528709412,
-0.712393581867218,
-0.19601987302303314,
-0.18059042096138,
0.007787812501192093,
0.2969958186149597,
0.5450174808502197,
-0.44684892892837524,
0.9711814522743225,
-0.32440418004989624,
-0.6364040970802307,
-0.15932805836200714,
0.525840163230896,
0.14042286574840546,
0.4303973317146301,
0.43157196044921875,
-0.8482488989830017,
-0.2850998640060425,
-0.1183670237660408,
-0.7640873193740845,
-0.016864176839590073,
-0.30425339937210083,
0.2108684480190277,
-0.005682194605469704,
0.7633245587348938,
-0.3084559440612793,
0.3843415379524231,
0.34203580021858215,
-0.01743229851126671,
0.38848239183425903,
0.01844797469675541,
-0.10511202365159988,
-1.4033321142196655,
0.10513714700937271,
-0.08861178904771805,
-0.37527522444725037,
-0.34116998314857483,
0.010739980265498161,
0.1833379715681076,
0.047726891934871674,
-0.1190343126654625,
0.4798511564731598,
-1.0252699851989746,
0.08976452797651291,
-0.5127553939819336,
-0.13818515837192535,
0.18939979374408722,
0.08452467620372772,
0.2958241105079651,
0.8242349624633789,
0.8453905582427979,
-0.5245574712753296,
0.2500269412994385,
0.03912939131259918,
-0.30437734723091125,
0.8333683609962463,
-0.5177968144416809,
0.05647559091448784,
-0.37383970618247986,
0.05159696936607361,
-0.5353260040283203,
-0.20691324770450592,
0.19268415868282318,
-0.5435235500335693,
0.8154841065406799,
-0.5227864384651184,
-0.17354802787303925,
-0.33638668060302734,
0.027116235345602036,
0.40771591663360596,
0.008915993385016918,
-0.6379172205924988,
1.0577144622802734,
0.6614635586738586,
0.3466625511646271,
-0.7965452075004578,
-0.48364290595054626,
0.18960219621658325,
-0.5054230690002441,
-0.1356947273015976,
0.3420788645744324,
0.254433810710907,
0.007640267722308636,
-0.018983298912644386,
-0.6377087235450745,
-0.6028074622154236,
0.3227159380912781,
0.3982875645160675,
0.331195592880249,
-0.11393719166517258,
0.3026133179664612,
0.053879451006650925,
-0.4063361585140228,
-0.011927042156457901,
-0.2766410708427429,
0.2732290029525757,
-0.25890007615089417,
-0.3670095205307007,
-0.34044814109802246,
0.1564544439315796,
0.5569276213645935,
-0.47236427664756775,
0.5676566362380981,
0.830359935760498,
-0.5880550146102905,
0.09687148779630661,
-0.7772140502929688,
-0.2011168748140335,
-0.4721943736076355,
0.36205124855041504,
-0.817741870880127,
-0.7541475892066956,
0.422573059797287,
-0.5717952251434326,
-0.3951030373573303,
0.48881879448890686,
0.15817734599113464,
-0.189191073179245,
0.9324209690093994,
0.9002079367637634,
-0.3089456856250763,
0.5963820219039917,
-0.12466304004192352,
0.16641567647457123,
-1.058424711227417,
-0.36317530274391174,
-0.5296008586883545,
-0.19072462618350983,
-0.4447384178638458,
-0.3361448347568512,
0.533401370048523,
0.40142127871513367,
0.09226258844137192,
0.3483636975288391,
-0.6011089086532593,
0.6245572566986084,
0.6131687760353088,
0.001902680960483849,
0.48882928490638733,
-0.10523168742656708,
-0.4045436978340149,
-0.08438995480537415,
-0.2869214117527008,
-0.2795807719230652,
0.9339584708213806,
0.2131485790014267,
1.0214169025421143,
-0.13893738389015198,
1.0949387550354004,
0.037908848375082016,
0.023706668987870216,
-0.8184518814086914,
0.30248361825942993,
0.3916592597961426,
-0.9677352905273438,
-0.2945786714553833,
-0.2779134213924408,
-0.8865987062454224,
0.26262375712394714,
-0.32678812742233276,
-0.7392265796661377,
0.6309178471565247,
0.02064971625804901,
-0.31786924600601196,
0.41744932532310486,
-0.4105243682861328,
0.48472416400909424,
-0.4333944618701935,
0.05585230141878128,
0.1166997179389,
-0.7137928605079651,
0.3038650155067444,
-0.38446298241615295,
-0.08542890101671219,
-0.10470905900001526,
-0.1914946585893631,
0.5871925950050354,
-0.2650565207004547,
0.5983883142471313,
-0.4190184772014618,
0.2816559374332428,
0.20652024447917938,
0.14336253702640533,
0.5765848755836487,
0.3246513903141022,
-0.0957362949848175,
0.30925899744033813,
-0.0853516235947609,
0.0631590336561203,
-0.3970513343811035,
0.24279917776584625,
-0.6207686066627502,
-0.39905786514282227,
-0.6511844396591187,
-0.4709038734436035,
-0.04635467380285263,
0.8124842643737793,
0.47265639901161194,
0.17691655457019806,
-0.09038780629634857,
0.2743355929851532,
0.624660313129425,
0.20738935470581055,
0.5584850907325745,
0.4784228503704071,
-0.15585345029830933,
-0.4419458210468292,
0.6157150268554688,
-0.05134553462266922,
-0.2334391474723816,
0.4691137969493866,
-0.21018964052200317,
-0.46214553713798523,
-0.7495056390762329,
-0.4466070234775543,
-0.0031670352909713984,
-0.6012355089187622,
-0.627685546875,
-1.0337738990783691,
-0.3157680928707123,
-0.1619151532649994,
0.16379515826702118,
-0.7024330496788025,
-0.35738056898117065,
-0.45119795203208923,
0.002363239647820592,
0.305056095123291,
0.5329460501670837,
-0.17876827716827393,
0.12020525336265564,
-0.5853644609451294,
0.42133814096450806,
0.3807515799999237,
0.48758578300476074,
-0.3370857238769531,
-0.28591856360435486,
-0.12545014917850494,
0.0034569506533443928,
-0.055472470819950104,
-1.1373180150985718,
0.306167334318161,
0.34400081634521484,
0.757240355014801,
0.6854082345962524,
0.3118866980075836,
0.843416154384613,
-0.046689409762620926,
0.13090737164020538,
0.14760556817054749,
-1.0113184452056885,
0.7847992181777954,
-0.2103716880083084,
-0.09559661149978638,
1.00022554397583,
0.41442012786865234,
-0.1433563381433487,
-0.2082032412290573,
-0.4305116832256317,
-0.9032285213470459,
0.5550972819328308,
0.12079709023237228,
-0.1849353164434433,
0.05324185639619827,
0.11204615980386734,
-0.08144422620534897,
0.27082374691963196,
-0.8626615405082703,
-0.15409798920154572,
-0.29640018939971924,
0.05816493183374405,
0.44661852717399597,
-0.1400003731250763,
0.01209339965134859,
-0.21800145506858826,
0.7064181566238403,
-0.3384437561035156,
0.19796423614025116,
0.32913511991500854,
-0.3566223978996277,
0.22415541112422943,
0.21073926985263824,
-0.024755792692303658,
0.2274712473154068,
-0.20467624068260193,
0.19723297655582428,
0.1699683964252472,
-0.5741834044456482,
0.007078961003571749,
0.4273534417152405,
-0.24950237572193146,
0.16183769702911377,
0.07433518767356873,
0.6341308355331421,
-0.10782603174448013,
-0.28249531984329224,
0.5518774390220642,
-0.2867109179496765,
-0.008978599682450294,
-0.506208598613739,
0.001906121033243835,
-0.00799653958529234,
0.49711087346076965,
0.3855593502521515,
0.4189773499965668,
0.5975303649902344,
0.04391772672533989,
0.08658386766910553,
0.5828713774681091,
-0.5360627770423889,
0.07918539643287659,
0.8810137510299683,
0.026828238740563393,
0.2920060157775879,
0.6940081119537354,
-0.5402212738990784,
-0.326351135969162,
0.5601847767829895,
0.5088288187980652,
0.8072059154510498,
-0.17051419615745544,
-0.05569950491189957,
0.4376755952835083,
0.3199993669986725,
-0.04375474154949188,
0.2373981475830078,
-0.387696772813797,
-0.8563221096992493,
-0.11229079961776733,
-0.6186689138412476,
-0.22897109389305115,
0.21994882822036743,
-1.090598702430725,
0.4168681502342224,
-0.25094109773635864,
-0.43242111802101135,
0.3417094945907593,
-0.0901721641421318,
-0.758742094039917,
0.24910776317119598,
0.3321734666824341,
0.8251056671142578,
-0.6934599876403809,
0.9517491459846497,
1.0127540826797485,
-0.5886667966842651,
-1.0878819227218628,
0.00859389454126358,
0.035628072917461395,
-0.6446568965911865,
0.5081420540809631,
0.4044506847858429,
-0.2505643665790558,
0.13385701179504395,
-0.14920322597026825,
-1.1836305856704712,
1.2169982194900513,
0.2692403793334961,
-0.588809072971344,
0.0243664663285017,
-0.24748435616493225,
0.46466466784477234,
-0.22331902384757996,
0.5325634479522705,
0.3372187614440918,
0.5169267654418945,
0.3231816291809082,
-0.8494941592216492,
-0.10514894872903824,
-0.4685980975627899,
0.056834910064935684,
0.3706718981266022,
-0.3006795048713684,
0.6631773710250854,
-0.24443697929382324,
-0.4260270297527313,
-0.09572922438383102,
0.6082943081855774,
0.18972326815128326,
0.5222138166427612,
0.673420250415802,
0.6931331753730774,
1.144697666168213,
-0.053377680480480194,
0.6495192646980286,
-0.4373184144496918,
0.36266136169433594,
1.4243861436843872,
-0.3627505302429199,
0.40357649326324463,
0.5432775020599365,
0.0697740688920021,
0.3676423728466034,
0.5085261464118958,
-0.32085734605789185,
0.6604925990104675,
-0.08576667308807373,
-0.2842108905315399,
-0.3369462490081787,
-0.2243202030658722,
-0.6179083585739136,
0.9635974764823914,
0.4271463453769684,
-0.4527319073677063,
-0.5450212359428406,
-0.0005599272553808987,
-0.07807020097970963,
-0.29513317346572876,
-0.29848340153694153,
1.0358569622039795,
-0.13391776382923126,
-0.36066102981567383,
0.3322135806083679,
0.10719481110572815,
0.9015368819236755,
-0.36274996399879456,
-0.0005706915981136262,
-0.12128890305757523,
0.10979574173688889,
-0.15855713188648224,
-0.33956179022789,
0.4277024269104004,
0.009375431574881077,
-0.30862465500831604,
0.005771582014858723,
1.2053743600845337,
-0.13395313918590546,
-0.5888488292694092,
0.35063785314559937,
0.8622003197669983,
0.2853890359401703,
-0.4619569480419159,
-0.5253545641899109,
-0.3260880410671234,
-0.21717514097690582,
-0.12858788669109344,
0.15180547535419464,
0.6248272657394409,
-0.10631699860095978,
0.6968862414360046,
0.44731077551841736,
0.033191900700330734,
0.2850325405597687,
0.033326685428619385,
1.1383686065673828,
-0.49423202872276306,
-0.45106032490730286,
-0.6092040538787842,
0.26120176911354065,
-0.24653054773807526,
-0.23737803101539612,
0.5973337888717651,
0.7651277184486389,
0.8316460847854614,
-0.05558621138334274,
0.6694061160087585,
-0.2794703543186188,
0.5333319902420044,
-0.18476520478725433,
0.7855169177055359,
-0.5906870365142822,
0.32981038093566895,
-0.27197638154029846,
-0.7788102626800537,
-0.24804756045341492,
0.7211161851882935,
-0.07324518263339996,
0.30470696091651917,
0.47797316312789917,
0.7328253388404846,
-0.2239585518836975,
-0.01517716608941555,
0.25839799642562866,
-0.06258385628461838,
0.06773894280195236,
0.42469045519828796,
1.058154582977295,
-0.5126253962516785,
0.4953836500644684,
-0.28840935230255127,
0.028758801519870758,
-0.07072748243808746,
-0.9770749807357788,
-0.8203123807907104,
-0.44611620903015137,
-0.4377615749835968,
-0.12377142906188965,
-0.10919302701950073,
0.6948503255844116,
0.9175271391868591,
-0.6813231706619263,
0.4321223497390747,
-0.23166176676750183,
0.021406695246696472,
-0.25783661007881165,
-0.20415474474430084,
0.10287640243768692,
-0.2186327874660492,
-0.8175594806671143,
0.6162815093994141,
0.23166947066783905,
0.24316458404064178,
0.17670783400535583,
0.23936766386032104,
-0.06818302720785141,
-0.18602193892002106,
0.16278308629989624,
0.2770301401615143,
-0.4709981083869934,
-0.02859652228653431,
-0.08657170087099075,
-0.22435486316680908,
-0.007349079474806786,
0.623005211353302,
-1.0896775722503662,
0.7768441438674927,
0.2608931362628937,
0.7447040677070618,
0.7258774042129517,
-0.0938546285033226,
0.023940475657582283,
-0.7359294295310974,
0.11030332744121552,
0.4575943052768707,
0.5847595930099487,
0.20516259968280792,
-0.46347230672836304,
0.6807228326797485,
0.25623977184295654,
-0.30075734853744507,
-0.7143245339393616,
0.1636209934949875,
-1.053587555885315,
-0.09073464572429657,
0.7407415509223938,
-0.11855249851942062,
0.22836633026599884,
-0.4311814308166504,
-0.019544854760169983,
0.5815902352333069,
-0.39180999994277954,
0.946625292301178,
0.32731732726097107,
-0.19081054627895355,
-0.17285792529582977,
-0.2555672228336334,
0.29110997915267944,
0.18966113030910492,
-0.7304019331932068,
-0.42635154724121094,
0.6306951642036438,
0.4290088415145874,
0.28435805439949036,
0.7544387578964233,
-0.3129843771457672,
0.06644453853368759,
0.23224413394927979,
0.3192923665046692,
-0.6125566959381104,
-0.5680795311927795,
-0.4503873884677887,
0.17259222269058228,
0.13883399963378906,
-0.5103784203529358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01907v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01907v1
|
Humanizing Machine-Generated Content: Evading AI-Text Detection through Adversarial Attack
| 2024-04-02T12:49:22 | 2024-04-02T12:49:22 |
Ying Zhou, Ben He, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
With the development of large language models (LLMs), detecting whether text
is generated by a machine becomes increasingly challenging in the face of
malicious use cases like the spread of false information, protection of
intellectual property, and prevention of academic plagiarism. While
well-trained text detectors have demonstrated promising performance on unseen
test data, recent research suggests that these detectors have vulnerabilities
when dealing with adversarial attacks such as paraphrasing. In this paper, we
propose a framework for a broader class of adversarial attacks, designed to
perform minor perturbations in machine-generated content to evade detection. We
consider two attack settings: white-box and black-box, and employ adversarial
learning in dynamic scenarios to assess the potential enhancement of the
current detection model's robustness against such attacks. The empirical
results reveal that the current detection models can be compromised in as
little as 10 seconds, leading to the misclassification of machine-generated
text as human-written content. Furthermore, we explore the prospect of
improving the model's robustness over iterative adversarial learning. Although
some improvements in model robustness are observed, practical applications
still face significant challenges. These findings shed light on the future
development of AI-text detectors, emphasizing the need for more accurate and
robust detection methods.
|
[
-0.38236555457115173,
-1.1913979053497314,
0.49018558859825134,
-0.30128636956214905,
-0.14420168101787567,
0.20335501432418823,
-0.21561992168426514,
-0.25280874967575073,
-0.2433975785970688,
0.7761640548706055,
-0.36526739597320557,
-0.4155561923980713,
-0.8105301260948181,
0.2990509271621704,
-0.729766309261322,
0.9910345077514648,
0.12493253499269485,
-0.47049397230148315,
-0.1673232913017273,
-0.018402742221951485,
-0.1892208307981491,
-0.7074597477912903,
-0.7611209750175476,
-0.24279332160949707,
0.4435552954673767,
0.1369984894990921,
0.9472076892852783,
0.6172723174095154,
0.4597478210926056,
0.3420705497264862,
-0.12687192857265472,
0.2516874372959137,
-0.34927433729171753,
0.1946481466293335,
0.05242006853222847,
-0.5135667324066162,
-0.1283714324235916,
-0.0907871425151825,
0.6194251179695129,
0.2958419620990753,
0.15359409153461456,
-0.06888438016176224,
0.18259815871715546,
0.4318000078201294,
-0.6395761966705322,
-0.22591477632522583,
-0.8701887130737305,
-0.002280661603435874,
-0.2886633276939392,
-0.2634584307670593,
-0.599102795124054,
0.0761042907834053,
0.026728136464953423,
-0.393354594707489,
0.37861207127571106,
-0.03495854511857033,
0.9298605918884277,
0.3824763000011444,
-0.18747304379940033,
-0.5740610361099243,
-0.6981014609336853,
0.6753368973731995,
-0.6927613019943237,
-0.04954884201288223,
0.4722383916378021,
0.26310017704963684,
-0.20815573632717133,
-0.8924716711044312,
-0.7094573378562927,
-0.4721827208995819,
-0.027247820049524307,
-0.07900746166706085,
-0.5624123811721802,
-0.1560439020395279,
0.30868223309516907,
0.14791446924209595,
-0.6583352088928223,
0.08935684710741043,
-0.13008710741996765,
-0.23925983905792236,
0.6382320523262024,
0.22102031111717224,
0.7399210333824158,
-0.28528308868408203,
-0.407319575548172,
-0.20478804409503937,
-0.78033047914505,
-0.15545189380645752,
0.7880305051803589,
0.08421539515256882,
0.0666671171784401,
0.5136617422103882,
-0.032499417662620544,
0.47246479988098145,
-0.13948103785514832,
0.07111013680696487,
-0.3477349281311035,
-0.23462450504302979,
-0.10831819474697113,
-0.08300789445638657,
1.1325044631958008,
0.006667725276201963,
0.2976091802120209,
-0.34260547161102295,
-0.4036300778388977,
0.3152306079864502,
0.6373888254165649,
-0.6911966800689697,
-0.4625498652458191,
-0.0708140954375267,
-0.3930160403251648,
-0.8971061706542969,
0.15530303120613098,
-0.847041130065918,
-0.7847078442573547,
-0.04420625790953636,
0.42093852162361145,
-0.4860016107559204,
0.016814343631267548,
-0.08846926689147949,
-0.13237912952899933,
-0.040161505341529846,
0.18653985857963562,
-0.6434963345527649,
0.2452598512172699,
0.6176059246063232,
0.7063744068145752,
-0.20061467587947845,
-0.451930969953537,
-0.6201457381248474,
0.115186408162117,
-0.2254365235567093,
0.8783233761787415,
-0.35223299264907837,
-0.4506291151046753,
0.06399066001176834,
-0.18565250933170319,
0.06344855576753616,
-0.6000944375991821,
0.6547820568084717,
-0.6636883616447449,
0.17935135960578918,
0.01005107443779707,
-0.3942868113517761,
-0.0500444732606411,
0.5068914890289307,
-0.8214125633239746,
0.7394759058952332,
-0.17372485995292664,
-0.984422504901886,
-0.008877290412783623,
-0.5463155508041382,
-0.749770998954773,
-0.03124377690255642,
-0.194327712059021,
-0.8292739987373352,
0.04129477217793465,
0.45032238960266113,
0.33806857466697693,
-0.25487059354782104,
0.23763522505760193,
-0.3128279447555542,
-0.535802960395813,
0.5998152494430542,
-1.0931628942489624,
0.8661754131317139,
0.364277184009552,
-0.48232272267341614,
0.017394162714481354,
-0.6971350312232971,
-0.38027223944664,
0.48908907175064087,
-0.39757856726646423,
-0.3513507544994354,
0.21743659675121307,
0.02393784001469612,
-0.11659225076436996,
0.2647744119167328,
-0.21084223687648773,
-0.00682295486330986,
-0.40538713335990906,
0.5110291242599487,
0.8007388710975647,
0.07050593942403793,
0.515809953212738,
-0.4454256594181061,
0.7739734053611755,
-0.2637684941291809,
0.0359046645462513,
-0.408147931098938,
-0.35756540298461914,
-0.5866533517837524,
-0.13005268573760986,
0.34543392062187195,
0.673904538154602,
-1.2120842933654785,
0.23805338144302368,
0.00012627843534573913,
-0.3793717920780182,
-0.48752325773239136,
0.35908085107803345,
0.503963828086853,
0.5033317804336548,
0.3614988625049591,
0.16797207295894623,
-0.4023803472518921,
-0.6551544070243835,
-0.7065151333808899,
-0.28091543912887573,
-0.43499964475631714,
0.035073164850473404,
0.6045008301734924,
-0.3929891288280487,
0.6265130043029785,
-0.477710098028183,
-0.11678744852542877,
-0.36326226592063904,
0.4694654047489166,
-0.3984205722808838,
0.3807523250579834,
0.3927355110645294,
-1.0353505611419678,
-0.5171747207641602,
-0.20463010668754578,
-1.022234320640564,
-0.19872547686100006,
-0.3390768766403198,
0.09440194070339203,
0.11746136099100113,
0.5868297219276428,
-0.5592788457870483,
0.6745166182518005,
0.2511747479438782,
-0.20294632017612457,
0.5092822909355164,
-0.23191729187965393,
0.11036885529756546,
-0.9348106980323792,
0.0178118534386158,
0.03686580806970596,
-0.27035996317863464,
-0.7820830345153809,
0.37125736474990845,
0.011472540907561779,
-0.4615643620491028,
-0.473073810338974,
0.5851565599441528,
-0.2863203287124634,
0.21774917840957642,
-0.7041890621185303,
0.10087806731462479,
0.16971154510974884,
0.2853582203388214,
-0.14759007096290588,
0.8397471308708191,
0.23056012392044067,
-0.543362021446228,
0.3034890592098236,
0.08155424892902374,
-0.11122006177902222,
0.7109501361846924,
-0.7244632244110107,
0.35159367322921753,
-0.19125916063785553,
0.2677854895591736,
-0.8269140124320984,
-0.3267538249492645,
0.5073322653770447,
-0.7950725555419922,
0.3444324731826782,
-0.006673821713775396,
-0.7379069924354553,
-0.19893929362297058,
-0.5419927835464478,
0.1400555521249771,
0.46104779839515686,
-0.5512840747833252,
0.639350175857544,
0.352115660905838,
-0.11457318067550659,
-0.4759048521518707,
-0.6474156975746155,
0.6751872897148132,
-0.4524238705635071,
-0.6034085154533386,
0.4760565161705017,
-0.04427724331617355,
-0.3839552402496338,
-0.12651962041854858,
0.24758192896842957,
-0.19543206691741943,
0.5970020294189453,
-0.007571788504719734,
0.18774138391017914,
0.012419883161783218,
-0.282518595457077,
-0.1755439192056656,
-0.21042151749134064,
0.19943401217460632,
-0.15249866247177124,
0.5012918710708618,
0.09226114302873611,
-0.4089929759502411,
-0.8705844879150391,
0.3109755218029022,
0.6474423408508301,
-0.17850361764431,
0.5748956799507141,
0.794381320476532,
-0.7167021036148071,
-0.16579864919185638,
-0.26092833280563354,
-0.20075520873069763,
-0.5503836274147034,
0.36734655499458313,
-0.227017343044281,
-0.417344868183136,
0.19042682647705078,
0.19595561921596527,
0.007549711503088474,
0.47842949628829956,
0.5050120949745178,
-0.3058571219444275,
1.2171478271484375,
0.39328819513320923,
-0.14609967172145844,
0.4988488256931305,
-0.16241450607776642,
0.032637834548950195,
-0.6317669153213501,
0.032896991819143295,
-0.6002445816993713,
-0.18839392066001892,
-0.5255407094955444,
-0.13148607313632965,
0.19810056686401367,
-0.11710016429424286,
-0.059459131211042404,
0.45771366357803345,
-0.35363468527793884,
0.4653155207633972,
0.7008225917816162,
0.34680768847465515,
0.1991199105978012,
0.07704012840986252,
0.23828473687171936,
0.07163237035274506,
-0.5262593626976013,
-0.9117929339408875,
1.2451382875442505,
0.4214171767234802,
0.7903613448143005,
-0.0035257632844150066,
0.6363537311553955,
0.8089795112609863,
0.33505141735076904,
-0.4946574866771698,
0.5527477860450745,
-0.4694862365722656,
-0.49043384194374084,
-0.0873224139213562,
-0.26463907957077026,
-0.9018217325210571,
0.14344212412834167,
-0.2679186761379242,
-0.5543454885482788,
-0.29657700657844543,
0.14417196810245514,
-0.2500414550304413,
0.5471916198730469,
-0.5653718709945679,
0.8360674977302551,
-0.2617224454879761,
-0.32386016845703125,
-0.0818294957280159,
-0.47585153579711914,
0.24597935378551483,
-0.182478666305542,
0.14414407312870026,
0.25889351963996887,
0.00991430226713419,
0.6640781760215759,
-0.20502109825611115,
1.0401057004928589,
-0.17808230221271515,
-0.10496576875448227,
0.5103939175605774,
0.2590027153491974,
0.8265790939331055,
0.062475431710481644,
0.08140325546264648,
-0.026273414492607117,
-0.33512964844703674,
-0.6056599020957947,
-0.5522454380989075,
0.39745548367500305,
-0.5580703020095825,
-0.7512518763542175,
-0.34362319111824036,
-0.5490543246269226,
0.09701535850763321,
0.14171333611011505,
0.5476340055465698,
0.41314390301704407,
-0.2986091375350952,
0.16813476383686066,
0.8261972665786743,
-0.44349679350852966,
0.36559557914733887,
0.20843686163425446,
0.23242069780826569,
-0.5013722777366638,
1.2844607830047607,
-0.2744036316871643,
0.21803618967533112,
0.476032555103302,
0.2711915075778961,
-0.2767571806907654,
-0.8448868989944458,
-0.6880955696105957,
-0.08485116064548492,
-0.673766553401947,
-0.1373034119606018,
-0.6105678081512451,
-0.21285386383533478,
-0.4245438277721405,
-0.25908565521240234,
-0.1570117324590683,
-0.013435174711048603,
-0.6851038336753845,
0.24775710701942444,
-0.08482219278812408,
0.7556667923927307,
0.3930811583995819,
0.5443875789642334,
-0.6764498353004456,
0.5335059762001038,
0.2952691316604614,
-0.360252320766449,
-0.0972752645611763,
-0.6799857020378113,
-0.0674571841955185,
0.19468873739242554,
-0.6018295288085938,
-0.8266234397888184,
0.4588411748409271,
-0.06921807676553726,
0.39244383573532104,
0.4376225769519806,
0.2689736485481262,
0.3059178292751312,
-0.5000767707824707,
0.7265071272850037,
-0.06384580582380295,
-0.8540171384811401,
0.5104720592498779,
-0.33622172474861145,
0.259729266166687,
0.49103018641471863,
0.2284841686487198,
-0.3088568449020386,
-0.6904770135879517,
-0.7724751234054565,
-0.5414480566978455,
0.4264097213745117,
0.4849650263786316,
0.3837527632713318,
0.1301981806755066,
0.32669878005981445,
-0.03864981606602669,
0.17569290101528168,
-0.8573789000511169,
-0.0018485885811969638,
-0.1799299418926239,
-0.41810616850852966,
-0.022758787497878075,
-0.1259605884552002,
-0.05661610886454582,
0.2973613142967224,
0.4310956299304962,
-0.08392485976219177,
0.27184098958969116,
0.05887191742658615,
-0.5405462980270386,
0.25624072551727295,
0.1517670452594757,
0.6514654755592346,
0.1536693572998047,
0.17755350470542908,
0.36647266149520874,
0.1631428301334381,
-0.342024564743042,
0.12962296605110168,
0.3236214816570282,
-0.598686158657074,
-0.15072757005691528,
0.6578479409217834,
0.663969099521637,
-0.033186230808496475,
-0.768799901008606,
0.5992451310157776,
-0.16887851059436798,
-0.02622901275753975,
-0.3248479962348938,
0.10144869983196259,
-0.16543927788734436,
0.2851985991001129,
0.3047005236148834,
0.2333166003227234,
0.1248621866106987,
-0.49771514534950256,
0.3987368047237396,
0.6095045208930969,
-0.4008491039276123,
-0.5270414352416992,
0.9631290435791016,
0.033280979841947556,
-0.7230139970779419,
0.30002734065055847,
-0.23609820008277893,
-0.969427764415741,
0.8171178698539734,
0.5902561545372009,
0.8872328400611877,
-0.10756868124008179,
0.1803322583436966,
-0.19058987498283386,
0.49421414732933044,
-0.007217659614980221,
-0.25276798009872437,
-0.15446124970912933,
-0.5175987482070923,
0.1244707852602005,
-0.44647905230522156,
-0.4457044303417206,
0.3270052671432495,
-0.415455162525177,
0.4167376458644867,
-0.6048585772514343,
0.0021814957726746798,
0.0931057259440422,
-0.19538143277168274,
-0.37284591794013977,
0.23727406561374664,
0.48549550771713257,
0.6100890040397644,
-0.6680624485015869,
0.7391290068626404,
0.6829605102539062,
-0.4351927936077118,
-0.09584913402795792,
0.6089609861373901,
0.22213780879974365,
-0.6590338945388794,
0.3035615086555481,
0.25950220227241516,
-0.191371351480484,
-0.12503132224082947,
-0.4592389762401581,
-0.3187173902988434,
0.8635503053665161,
0.3543592691421509,
-0.14443451166152954,
-0.2500160336494446,
0.19656343758106232,
0.577435314655304,
-0.1261465847492218,
-0.10571540147066116,
0.5981149673461914,
0.3578360378742218,
-0.24329355359077454,
-0.22893042862415314,
0.10712845623493195,
-0.14715416729450226,
-0.04290556535124779,
-0.016939423978328705,
-0.47962284088134766,
0.8680542707443237,
0.10118286311626434,
-0.30861860513687134,
0.2950311601161957,
0.7076280117034912,
0.14324675500392914,
0.515671968460083,
0.5102372169494629,
0.509508490562439,
0.6240116953849792,
0.12255559861660004,
1.2133454084396362,
-0.12266670912504196,
0.08917548507452011,
0.7465115189552307,
-0.1298673003911972,
0.6989162564277649,
0.21471266448497772,
-0.23673805594444275,
0.2996309697628021,
0.44394081830978394,
-0.22134089469909668,
0.3695071041584015,
0.2082139402627945,
-0.5344856381416321,
-0.09730011224746704,
0.07122449576854706,
-0.03528199344873428,
0.4532669186592102,
0.3340996503829956,
-0.42542532086372375,
-0.1177404373884201,
0.24645884335041046,
0.3728158175945282,
0.5973049402236938,
-0.08967030793428421,
0.682818591594696,
-0.05942157283425331,
-0.7576452493667603,
0.6343761682510376,
0.33055365085601807,
0.864269495010376,
-0.3985239863395691,
0.19978976249694824,
-0.05578780546784401,
0.2855744957923889,
0.03881377354264259,
-0.6334224343299866,
0.3498559594154358,
0.46233296394348145,
0.0032071610912680626,
-0.16465921700000763,
1.1443028450012207,
-0.20682507753372192,
-0.507691502571106,
0.17339542508125305,
0.11866284906864166,
-0.15588349103927612,
-0.3502899408340454,
-0.7415677309036255,
0.1494864523410797,
0.09315244853496552,
-0.18428254127502441,
0.5217782855033875,
0.22449573874473572,
0.12514187395572662,
0.7139785289764404,
0.7497717142105103,
-0.030900433659553528,
-0.07352982461452484,
-0.1432204395532608,
0.7021700739860535,
-0.5428941249847412,
-0.5036882758140564,
-1.2646795511245728,
0.23749130964279175,
-0.154806450009346,
-0.01697620190680027,
0.6368926167488098,
0.2956785261631012,
0.7544983625411987,
0.15896368026733398,
1.0600073337554932,
0.16719967126846313,
0.25845569372177124,
-0.5047591328620911,
0.9990107417106628,
-0.5590619444847107,
0.6193132996559143,
-0.330483078956604,
-0.5267304182052612,
-0.38849395513534546,
0.3778512477874756,
-0.22714972496032715,
-0.20277152955532074,
0.5336124300956726,
0.6981561779975891,
0.02648252435028553,
0.08412658423185349,
0.296798974275589,
-0.02190997079014778,
0.6555901765823364,
0.4475955367088318,
1.1328054666519165,
-0.5713317394256592,
1.0741760730743408,
-0.3458116948604584,
-0.13536541163921356,
-0.06752101331949234,
-0.7953922748565674,
-1.2509042024612427,
-0.29944202303886414,
-0.2528667449951172,
-0.4368802607059479,
0.2609875500202179,
0.3814425766468048,
0.30771008133888245,
-0.7084815502166748,
0.02307111956179142,
-0.28632694482803345,
0.17068517208099365,
0.09382617473602295,
-0.25479668378829956,
0.3907955586910248,
-0.3232532739639282,
-0.9709689021110535,
0.5433429479598999,
0.10529559850692749,
0.25841471552848816,
-0.46361857652664185,
0.005959648173302412,
-0.09448698163032532,
0.2667143642902374,
0.4030531346797943,
0.34834057092666626,
-0.6523398160934448,
-0.1656423956155777,
-0.11574999988079071,
-0.31147927045822144,
-0.08562228083610535,
0.7385427951812744,
-0.7393163442611694,
0.34057462215423584,
0.41575711965560913,
1.1134730577468872,
0.2170354425907135,
0.19472868740558624,
0.590319037437439,
-0.6946431994438171,
0.18757885694503784,
0.2983805537223816,
0.26581159234046936,
0.5096312165260315,
-0.5654067993164062,
0.13240179419517517,
0.5302276015281677,
-0.40692955255508423,
-1.0788776874542236,
0.3809739649295807,
-0.30425333976745605,
-0.6419906616210938,
1.0108731985092163,
-0.34039533138275146,
-0.27953940629959106,
-0.0862036719918251,
-0.2536433935165405,
0.3005993068218231,
-0.2086339294910431,
1.0423197746276855,
0.7090926766395569,
0.2747876048088074,
0.1255778819322586,
-0.6087808012962341,
0.45174968242645264,
0.3396568298339844,
-0.9292666912078857,
0.08507756143808365,
0.26460644602775574,
0.16419698297977448,
0.05360833927989006,
0.3461274802684784,
-0.06835761666297913,
0.4434807300567627,
0.16211117804050446,
-0.35702040791511536,
-0.10103936493396759,
-0.5525144338607788,
-0.4148148000240326,
0.3885868191719055,
-0.09374239295721054,
-0.2159181386232376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04279v1
|
When Abel Kills Cain: What Machine Translation Cannot Capture
| 2024-04-02T12:46:00 | 2024-04-02T12:46:00 |
Aurélien Bénel, Joris Falip, Philippe Lacour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The article aims at identifying what, from a structural point of view, AI
based automatic translators cannot fully capture. It focuses on the machine's
mistakes, in order to try to explain its causes. The biblical story of Ca\"in
and Abel has been chosen because of its rich interpretive and critical
tradition, but also because of its semantic difficulty. The investigation
begins with the observation, for the translation of this text, of the language
pairs and interfaces offered by the best known machine translation services
(Google Translate, DeepL). A typology of the most frequent translation errors
is then established. Finally, contemporary translations are compared, in order
to underline the unique contribution of each. In conclusion, the article
suggests a revision of translation theory and, corArtificial Intelligence,
Translation, Limitations, Interpretation, Comparison, Unicityelatively, a
reformulation of its technology concerning cultural texts.
|
[
-0.4122958779335022,
-0.6009933352470398,
0.5823204517364502,
0.19725337624549866,
-0.20904017984867096,
0.2971581816673279,
0.36126041412353516,
-0.7570094466209412,
0.459756076335907,
0.2133391797542572,
-0.2841109037399292,
-0.09980280697345734,
-0.7988759875297546,
0.552217960357666,
-1.1200002431869507,
1.1648563146591187,
-0.3085804879665375,
-0.0040763067081570625,
0.2332334667444229,
-0.46963661909103394,
-0.18315161764621735,
-0.5163019895553589,
-0.963671088218689,
-0.25891929864883423,
0.841106653213501,
0.024265268817543983,
1.2685188055038452,
0.9681118726730347,
0.7417824864387512,
0.3712325692176819,
-0.5821881294250488,
0.14152559638023376,
-0.4836495816707611,
0.06051066890358925,
-0.06300275027751923,
-0.7398597002029419,
-0.23048970103263855,
0.07896783202886581,
0.7104582786560059,
1.0144087076187134,
0.34486210346221924,
0.06127454340457916,
0.14626456797122955,
0.6900889277458191,
-0.2731149196624756,
-0.3150101602077484,
-0.9306847453117371,
0.4300178587436676,
-0.3398486375808716,
-0.02585655078291893,
-0.3243354558944702,
-0.7317096590995789,
-0.12481001764535904,
-0.4075210690498352,
0.21126699447631836,
0.10619928687810898,
1.0170499086380005,
0.7159690856933594,
-0.4769620895385742,
-0.49947285652160645,
-0.7632350325584412,
0.8572317957878113,
-0.6321684718132019,
-0.20197921991348267,
0.42421460151672363,
0.06570896506309509,
-0.5722268223762512,
-0.6003167033195496,
-0.7902622222900391,
-0.3007478713989258,
-0.012218303978443146,
-0.1428711861371994,
-0.48588961362838745,
-0.10031934827566147,
0.2799348831176758,
0.4785368740558624,
-0.4204954504966736,
-0.20966501533985138,
-0.4919787347316742,
-0.2768420875072479,
0.5658558011054993,
0.16633276641368866,
0.7854155898094177,
-0.17258889973163605,
-0.24478305876255035,
-0.17885708808898926,
-0.5437795519828796,
0.06931488960981369,
0.5920096039772034,
-0.14648441970348358,
0.19789385795593262,
0.9327925443649292,
0.4644102454185486,
0.362623006105423,
-0.00412294315174222,
0.1317734718322754,
0.4150414764881134,
-0.21386492252349854,
-0.19750790297985077,
0.12693649530410767,
0.9596964716911316,
0.7143162488937378,
0.16290637850761414,
-0.2980615198612213,
-0.020514504984021187,
0.17819781601428986,
0.7180576324462891,
-0.5800492167472839,
0.1347520798444748,
0.22365978360176086,
-0.49665385484695435,
-0.3578731119632721,
-0.008541516028344631,
-0.6564600467681885,
-0.30814021825790405,
-0.04260215163230896,
0.15862245857715607,
-0.2685343623161316,
0.4467562437057495,
-0.2699427604675293,
-0.4333399832248688,
0.526004433631897,
0.2319599688053131,
-0.4141407608985901,
-0.21501588821411133,
0.3946395814418793,
0.8852514624595642,
-0.3131657540798187,
-0.40129098296165466,
-0.40000391006469727,
-0.031729817390441895,
-0.8218337893486023,
0.5499606132507324,
0.06210258603096008,
-0.321198433637619,
-0.11692154407501221,
0.278734028339386,
0.10068701952695847,
-0.3824698030948639,
0.5658240914344788,
-0.4975333511829376,
-0.1761644184589386,
-0.4066177010536194,
-0.29462459683418274,
-0.6474157571792603,
0.1107160896062851,
-0.7305082678794861,
0.7247444987297058,
-0.21634499728679657,
-0.5245766043663025,
0.21624018251895905,
-0.4146164059638977,
-0.6868296265602112,
0.056865643709897995,
-0.19869451224803925,
-0.5390201210975647,
0.33073654770851135,
-0.19641593098640442,
0.16947811841964722,
-0.09029151499271393,
0.5524231195449829,
-0.2231348603963852,
-0.4378853738307953,
0.3435342311859131,
-0.3094361424446106,
1.432267665863037,
0.48149898648262024,
-0.5249204039573669,
-0.03586637228727341,
-0.5352609157562256,
-0.2333446443080902,
0.5690114498138428,
-0.2165263295173645,
-0.10162630677223206,
0.43294110894203186,
-0.07683295011520386,
-0.30038580298423767,
0.1962820589542389,
-0.5845896601676941,
0.1661188006401062,
-0.4248881936073303,
0.3232274651527405,
0.27540916204452515,
-0.28400206565856934,
0.41123008728027344,
-0.38098034262657166,
0.5101695656776428,
-0.28946131467819214,
0.30232515931129456,
-0.1643299162387848,
-0.7596966624259949,
-0.7584643363952637,
0.34036365151405334,
0.1685560941696167,
0.89811110496521,
-0.9999446272850037,
0.39274439215660095,
0.08020573109388351,
-0.837552011013031,
-0.5999825596809387,
0.24725940823554993,
0.49448221921920776,
0.3100237250328064,
0.5455693602561951,
-0.6762180924415588,
-0.5367249846458435,
-0.6007266044616699,
-0.5618058443069458,
-0.4663373529911041,
0.10629554837942123,
-0.047031283378601074,
0.6383728384971619,
-0.4308900535106659,
0.8291502594947815,
-0.08924905210733414,
-0.28778132796287537,
-0.3161633014678955,
0.3246303200721741,
0.3057757616043091,
0.5314528346061707,
0.9588873982429504,
-0.9893221855163574,
-0.3308025300502777,
0.23894351720809937,
-1.1854230165481567,
0.03387754410505295,
-0.35948172211647034,
0.14447027444839478,
-0.30993250012397766,
0.6469043493270874,
-0.23861445486545563,
1.0028482675552368,
0.5386416912078857,
-0.3851581811904907,
0.39171189069747925,
-0.3318297564983368,
0.3505688011646271,
-1.0247726440429688,
0.007947659119963646,
-0.2603224515914917,
-0.01777750626206398,
-0.41376182436943054,
0.27157020568847656,
-0.10624530166387558,
-0.08697715401649475,
-0.8327917456626892,
0.24122682213783264,
-0.10656541585922241,
-0.2467508614063263,
-0.7305505275726318,
-0.09492117166519165,
0.19834144413471222,
0.26882198452949524,
-0.5773594379425049,
0.8903613090515137,
-0.02180902101099491,
-0.6834577322006226,
0.8084636926651001,
0.6775882244110107,
-0.02471550926566124,
0.45871448516845703,
-0.7823517918586731,
0.12270835787057877,
-0.3044126033782959,
0.13280579447746277,
-0.8842619061470032,
-0.480196088552475,
0.545742928981781,
-0.9244880676269531,
0.04041323438286781,
0.14665009081363678,
-0.4515531361103058,
-0.13413295149803162,
-0.19818001985549927,
0.7189605832099915,
0.2851237654685974,
-0.01913725957274437,
0.9210084676742554,
0.37522396445274353,
-0.3313106894493103,
-0.6452528238296509,
-1.1916495561599731,
0.6962490081787109,
-0.20241855084896088,
-0.39731132984161377,
0.27069079875946045,
-0.12372847646474838,
-0.5365228056907654,
0.11953592300415039,
0.05510107800364494,
-0.09392067044973373,
0.4940969944000244,
0.15555329620838165,
-0.02463044412434101,
-0.15601204335689545,
-0.009106751531362534,
0.3469051122665405,
-0.20652687549591064,
0.12593567371368408,
0.14838045835494995,
0.0352143757045269,
-0.012820838019251823,
-0.4170812666416168,
-0.7860975861549377,
0.8412635922431946,
1.0683103799819946,
-0.023142455145716667,
0.9486561417579651,
0.24810169637203217,
-0.3152036964893341,
0.598153293132782,
-0.433174729347229,
0.22024697065353394,
-0.34943053126335144,
0.24015052616596222,
-0.1048613041639328,
-0.14724023640155792,
0.9727150797843933,
-0.031180592253804207,
0.24560442566871643,
1.0394431352615356,
0.24002724885940552,
-0.4846965968608856,
0.9064738154411316,
0.461715430021286,
-0.33570924401283264,
0.46529334783554077,
-0.28456252813339233,
0.05474214628338814,
-0.781549870967865,
-0.32271528244018555,
-1.1211824417114258,
-0.5224233269691467,
-0.4161040484905243,
0.19829891622066498,
0.4470517337322235,
0.04629075154662132,
-0.27272629737854004,
0.9535994529724121,
-0.3924773037433624,
0.5061630010604858,
1.0349539518356323,
-0.23159657418727875,
0.3800361454486847,
-0.06415364146232605,
-0.1667945683002472,
-0.02785356156527996,
-0.35678523778915405,
-0.7248407602310181,
0.8106152415275574,
0.22575746476650238,
0.4633254110813141,
0.09041197597980499,
0.3032497465610504,
0.48567020893096924,
0.07720822840929031,
-0.7211441993713379,
0.39619943499565125,
-0.30371636152267456,
-0.8558384776115417,
-0.28367435932159424,
-0.25004512071609497,
-1.2065913677215576,
-0.025737669318914413,
-0.15085306763648987,
-0.42470189929008484,
0.5446799993515015,
0.1295863687992096,
-0.28541040420532227,
0.576870322227478,
-0.7700347304344177,
1.032228708267212,
-0.47411683201789856,
0.1611640751361847,
0.16469505429267883,
-1.0133522748947144,
-0.30529364943504333,
-0.21542441844940186,
0.3350493311882019,
0.08870396018028259,
-0.002627668669447303,
0.7151108384132385,
-0.24418558180332184,
0.8171613812446594,
0.31969591975212097,
-0.0014270782703533769,
0.6669707298278809,
0.2927122712135315,
0.5168502926826477,
-0.5345445871353149,
-0.2581001818180084,
0.3548065721988678,
-0.009087005630135536,
-0.5163685083389282,
-0.3942842483520508,
0.055411484092473984,
-0.7725329399108887,
-0.07327844202518463,
-0.6222268342971802,
-0.5201568007469177,
0.48580145835876465,
0.07541119307279587,
0.7474372386932373,
0.06629515439271927,
-0.09034914523363113,
0.22949206829071045,
0.0959978923201561,
-0.404590904712677,
0.8627364039421082,
-0.10098856687545776,
-0.35867494344711304,
-0.7109655141830444,
0.7904520630836487,
0.10815980285406113,
0.12105764448642731,
-0.048391301184892654,
-0.19605718553066254,
-0.05887318029999733,
-0.7238686680793762,
-0.9161261320114136,
0.06488791108131409,
-0.7957098484039307,
-0.22419200837612152,
-0.5889246463775635,
-0.34008491039276123,
0.17582835257053375,
-0.4383901059627533,
-0.3282364308834076,
0.20412130653858185,
-0.7957108616828918,
-0.07503358274698257,
0.07929921895265579,
0.7423117756843567,
0.3025861978530884,
0.8122859597206116,
-1.0878757238388062,
0.5084604620933533,
0.13200193643569946,
-0.27700915932655334,
-0.23633986711502075,
-0.4607357680797577,
-0.03128271922469139,
0.17803549766540527,
-0.5862809419631958,
-1.2774921655654907,
0.3623029291629791,
0.047781385481357574,
0.14324015378952026,
0.38099047541618347,
0.011240526102483273,
0.826907753944397,
-0.37832701206207275,
0.6005746126174927,
0.32892799377441406,
-1.0553401708602905,
0.5702987909317017,
-0.07708517462015152,
0.27456435561180115,
0.6033709049224854,
0.35333651304244995,
-0.6388903260231018,
-1.0716537237167358,
-0.5065962076187134,
-0.8268705010414124,
0.43159401416778564,
0.4704241156578064,
0.530659019947052,
-0.10471862554550171,
0.3995687961578369,
0.18525077402591705,
0.1206759437918663,
-1.2698032855987549,
-0.42926284670829773,
-0.06558091938495636,
-0.15652719140052795,
0.09688999503850937,
-0.1928647756576538,
0.10772599279880524,
-0.36977383494377136,
0.5409294366836548,
-0.0657317116856575,
0.18156300485134125,
0.3799445629119873,
-0.3454950153827667,
-0.3012717664241791,
0.043857790529727936,
0.3561457693576813,
0.8574138879776001,
0.2993421256542206,
-0.06240040808916092,
0.18046878278255463,
-0.5147796869277954,
0.24331054091453552,
-0.05229819938540459,
-0.8755316138267517,
0.3817243278026581,
0.5909926295280457,
0.7668222784996033,
-0.0882987305521965,
-0.7287670969963074,
0.31811076402664185,
0.21811449527740479,
-0.1896793395280838,
-0.7688832879066467,
-0.12840192019939423,
-0.40074512362480164,
0.6072017550468445,
0.8394938707351685,
0.4593958556652069,
0.21761548519134521,
-0.6466610431671143,
-0.0838807001709938,
0.370479017496109,
-0.5243882536888123,
-0.020762044936418533,
0.9818877577781677,
0.0010433857096359134,
-0.600314736366272,
0.5734149813652039,
-0.4938912093639374,
-0.7633917927742004,
0.8735069632530212,
0.2667774260044098,
0.8233374357223511,
-0.2982160449028015,
0.25729596614837646,
0.07270058989524841,
0.6387202143669128,
0.008532106876373291,
0.013788626529276371,
0.4330015182495117,
-0.6694563627243042,
-0.9716111421585083,
-0.3822645843029022,
-0.31421807408332825,
-0.279141366481781,
-0.3647140562534332,
-0.09093425422906876,
-0.061793286353349686,
-0.4098346531391144,
-0.016990745440125465,
-0.659989595413208,
-0.17677636444568634,
0.19826488196849823,
-0.057794757187366486,
0.38317224383354187,
-0.6932910084724426,
0.4027646481990814,
0.5678581595420837,
-0.5090604424476624,
-0.6025285124778748,
-0.002224109135568142,
0.04145960137248039,
-0.763335108757019,
0.45669639110565186,
-0.04869189113378525,
-0.19234800338745117,
0.18055443465709686,
-0.6736747026443481,
-0.5433746576309204,
0.634781002998352,
0.7323920726776123,
-0.32870882749557495,
-0.29186150431632996,
-0.06283410638570786,
0.609110414981842,
0.06115519627928734,
-0.013138074427843094,
0.46454766392707825,
0.5745396018028259,
0.297515332698822,
-1.1426916122436523,
-0.26614558696746826,
0.04124726355075836,
0.012924118898808956,
0.567319929599762,
-0.15742072463035583,
0.5721956491470337,
-0.37188318371772766,
-0.326384574174881,
0.35742926597595215,
0.725119948387146,
-0.6537113785743713,
0.8099372982978821,
0.15455394983291626,
0.8101311922073364,
0.3472011983394623,
-0.16281963884830475,
1.0957401990890503,
0.05290292948484421,
0.30949005484580994,
0.7469263076782227,
0.14329373836517334,
0.5154081583023071,
0.5353832244873047,
-0.3680127263069153,
0.33103713393211365,
0.4284264147281647,
-0.4628508687019348,
0.2769600450992584,
-0.029481710866093636,
-0.07812362909317017,
0.15339744091033936,
-0.16794604063034058,
-0.30512702465057373,
0.6258670091629028,
0.15923675894737244,
-0.6958354711532593,
-0.11137743294239044,
0.4685373604297638,
0.26680466532707214,
0.16170156002044678,
-0.5068246126174927,
1.0166012048721313,
0.12143509835004807,
-0.761756181716919,
0.3556329905986786,
0.004630663897842169,
0.12095098197460175,
-0.130828395485878,
-0.06002482771873474,
-0.042617131024599075,
0.10073333233594894,
-0.18491794168949127,
-0.5332703590393066,
1.025938630104065,
0.20428644120693207,
-0.066138356924057,
-0.18350568413734436,
0.23720398545265198,
-0.0076054357923567295,
-0.5790800452232361,
0.49204230308532715,
0.39871537685394287,
0.5973252654075623,
-0.42964181303977966,
-0.5921288728713989,
0.27808353304862976,
0.24512538313865662,
0.20818309485912323,
-0.2491583675146103,
0.36827322840690613,
0.08348061144351959,
0.6573225855827332,
0.34158316254615784,
0.10196083039045334,
0.40289953351020813,
-0.5463553667068481,
0.32886382937431335,
-0.9360123872756958,
-0.009093527682125568,
-1.0501735210418701,
0.4596634805202484,
0.10101055353879929,
-0.41608378291130066,
0.4442864954471588,
0.47174757719039917,
0.8688384294509888,
0.025949498638510704,
0.4148520529270172,
-0.28193381428718567,
0.16404329240322113,
-0.22032530605793,
0.7672116160392761,
-0.7946320176124573,
-0.20385190844535828,
-0.32993456721305847,
-1.2496987581253052,
-0.48752710223197937,
0.6094995141029358,
-0.09574815630912781,
-0.22519998252391815,
1.0815610885620117,
0.1963091343641281,
0.4967102110385895,
0.004013685043901205,
0.12490979582071304,
0.2115406095981598,
0.10531529784202576,
0.3535252511501312,
0.6241514682769775,
-0.8714277744293213,
1.045892596244812,
0.3975086212158203,
-0.2067207396030426,
-0.5247189998626709,
-0.7696996331214905,
-0.590560257434845,
-0.6394707560539246,
-0.3086170256137848,
-0.3212290406227112,
-0.15557783842086792,
0.5362154841423035,
0.08532417565584183,
-0.7504160404205322,
-0.012235194444656372,
-0.2657361626625061,
0.3766452372074127,
-0.42317327857017517,
-0.11539559811353683,
0.38118356466293335,
-0.3367270827293396,
-0.9762353897094727,
0.4211546778678894,
0.20697946846485138,
0.6076312065124512,
-0.0025154701434075832,
0.12528838217258453,
0.058771729469299316,
-0.19421899318695068,
0.3333946168422699,
0.6263808012008667,
-1.0720798969268799,
-0.242522194981575,
-0.15321969985961914,
-0.21599797904491425,
0.29062724113464355,
0.6883837580680847,
-0.43445149064064026,
0.4738236367702484,
0.2779453992843628,
1.2067070007324219,
0.14401166141033173,
-0.30003535747528076,
0.6527581810951233,
-0.2078850120306015,
0.11333958804607391,
0.49379467964172363,
0.5798903703689575,
0.023470943793654442,
-0.2917437255382538,
0.4163260757923126,
0.47282183170318604,
-0.6135558485984802,
-0.5637528896331787,
0.4131185710430145,
-1.034555196762085,
-0.3257773518562317,
0.5471532344818115,
-0.2591656744480133,
-0.14413966238498688,
-0.5687313079833984,
-0.41884297132492065,
0.6463369727134705,
0.028394117951393127,
0.858832597732544,
0.9831361174583435,
0.3554880917072296,
0.4429677724838257,
-0.7618703246116638,
0.19000142812728882,
0.4156058728694916,
-0.6130947470664978,
-0.5992134809494019,
0.40306708216667175,
-0.28442761301994324,
0.6897953748703003,
0.16490256786346436,
-0.1671421378850937,
0.38637545704841614,
0.07176651060581207,
0.20125997066497803,
0.1490630954504013,
-0.3845468759536743,
0.09951595216989517,
0.50633704662323,
0.1183091402053833,
-0.4502396881580353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01903v1
|
Activation Steering for Robust Type Prediction in CodeLLMs
| 2024-04-02T12:44:44 | 2024-04-02T12:44:44 |
Francesca Lucchetti, Arjun Guha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Contemporary LLMs pretrained on code are capable of succeeding at a wide
variety of programming tasks. However, their performance is very sensitive to
syntactic features, such as the names of variables and types, the structure of
code, and presence of type hints. We contribute an inference-time technique to
make CodeLLMs more robust to syntactic distractors that are semantically
irrelevant. Our methodology relies on activation steering, which involves
editing internal model activations to steer the model towards the correct
prediction. We contribute a novel way to construct steering vectors by taking
inspiration from mutation testing, which constructs minimal semantics-breaking
code edits. In contrast, we construct steering vectors from
semantics-preserving code edits. We apply our approach to the task of type
prediction for the gradually typed languages Python and TypeScript. This
approach corrects up to 90% of type mispredictions. Finally, we show that
steering vectors calculated from Python activations reliably correct type
mispredictions in TypeScript, and vice versa. This result suggests that LLMs
may be learning to transfer knowledge of types across programming languages.
|
[
0.037662994116544724,
-0.5210387110710144,
0.45791101455688477,
0.42598092555999756,
-0.0075706858187913895,
0.4309905767440796,
-0.22680166363716125,
-0.32215720415115356,
0.032130226492881775,
0.1914471685886383,
-0.35339733958244324,
-0.3910684585571289,
-0.7715182304382324,
-0.002301325323060155,
-0.4883626401424408,
0.8118138909339905,
-0.213089719414711,
0.1038297787308693,
-0.43099692463874817,
-0.06041259318590164,
-0.09923621267080307,
-0.4127221405506134,
-0.2899560332298279,
-0.41035011410713196,
0.4200116991996765,
0.19445939362049103,
0.7365957498550415,
0.47548264265060425,
0.19221805036067963,
0.28495025634765625,
-0.10398272424936295,
-0.0012322479160502553,
-0.4418685734272003,
0.23939834535121918,
-0.008488740772008896,
-0.9534002542495728,
-0.3665204346179962,
-0.25935861468315125,
0.3130786716938019,
0.6147538423538208,
0.04174589365720749,
-0.1834603250026703,
0.012834861874580383,
0.49535277485847473,
-0.6767454147338867,
0.3695451617240906,
-0.9551419019699097,
0.08526798337697983,
-0.007220296189188957,
-0.354961633682251,
-0.47288501262664795,
-0.40838944911956787,
-0.024838780984282494,
-0.6642275452613831,
0.09059558063745499,
-0.07847096771001816,
0.43269139528274536,
0.6232806444168091,
-0.2584135830402374,
-0.29243430495262146,
-0.6117242574691772,
0.6428006887435913,
-0.5794070959091187,
0.26714181900024414,
0.42117127776145935,
-0.016043351963162422,
-0.2253950536251068,
-0.6546822786331177,
-0.20215541124343872,
-0.479202538728714,
0.12710067629814148,
0.05617159977555275,
-0.016440344974398613,
0.31346163153648376,
0.30491113662719727,
0.024318527430295944,
-0.45176762342453003,
0.4584140181541443,
-0.17009438574314117,
-0.39701464772224426,
0.38248446583747864,
-0.03947226330637932,
0.2108204960823059,
0.09654905647039413,
-0.47293519973754883,
0.2175135612487793,
-0.8512803316116333,
-0.025985319167375565,
0.28390005230903625,
0.061816077679395676,
-0.21310381591320038,
0.7769898176193237,
-0.13809914886951447,
0.6988804936408997,
0.308345228433609,
-0.15235619246959686,
0.368599534034729,
-0.19816270470619202,
-0.10265811532735825,
-0.03299913555383682,
0.42027589678764343,
0.248941570520401,
0.558064341545105,
-0.2584841847419739,
-0.27988094091415405,
0.326189249753952,
0.36255943775177,
-0.47251036763191223,
-0.3206629157066345,
0.36484119296073914,
-0.24198244512081146,
-0.6346112489700317,
-0.1176113560795784,
-0.5927698612213135,
-0.442170113325119,
-0.15756136178970337,
0.3803943991661072,
-0.5257681012153625,
-0.2848437428474426,
0.18510274589061737,
-0.10124033689498901,
0.16276057064533234,
0.3488721251487732,
-0.8424299359321594,
-0.2954874038696289,
0.6586015224456787,
0.5964533686637878,
-0.4563383460044861,
-0.3344092071056366,
-0.5372365713119507,
0.16354437172412872,
-0.265015572309494,
0.8498780131340027,
-0.49871543049812317,
-0.2566949427127838,
0.22703376412391663,
-0.3618375062942505,
-0.2718638777732849,
-0.5993649363517761,
0.19557566940784454,
-0.5408426523208618,
-0.0005692797130905092,
0.3505864143371582,
-0.7184943556785583,
0.04815663397312164,
0.14272798597812653,
-0.4979398548603058,
1.1959888935089111,
0.46742579340934753,
-0.8223441243171692,
0.5275682806968689,
-0.5099462866783142,
-0.7228806614875793,
-0.11189461499452591,
-0.15859176218509674,
-0.650047779083252,
0.20290528237819672,
0.04708462581038475,
0.3898938298225403,
0.31093427538871765,
0.339385449886322,
-0.6218459606170654,
-0.09510374069213867,
0.5138002038002014,
0.07793515920639038,
0.393048495054245,
0.12282133847475052,
-0.4331539571285248,
0.5505962371826172,
-0.8778212070465088,
0.16920851171016693,
-0.2777261734008789,
-0.32192692160606384,
-0.2301284223794937,
0.22648969292640686,
-0.24764269590377808,
0.3034789562225342,
0.13636134564876556,
-0.13452085852622986,
0.2967861294746399,
-0.2668634057044983,
0.41842371225357056,
0.7091474533081055,
0.02471296489238739,
0.794975221157074,
-0.39867520332336426,
0.8554378151893616,
0.09762661159038544,
0.07620173692703247,
0.1389729082584381,
-0.6716642379760742,
-0.9463467597961426,
-0.26661166548728943,
0.02756783552467823,
0.4535297751426697,
-1.1131041049957275,
0.4843624234199524,
-0.20807810127735138,
-0.4922902584075928,
-0.26753002405166626,
0.256961852312088,
0.48558324575424194,
0.45226964354515076,
0.45271384716033936,
-0.02365064062178135,
-0.5578327178955078,
-0.5244646668434143,
-0.44397464394569397,
-0.3249501883983612,
0.11556084454059601,
-0.24166752398014069,
0.29432862997055054,
-0.31314265727996826,
0.8756503462791443,
-0.34669435024261475,
0.24875088036060333,
-0.6939733028411865,
0.13821901381015778,
-0.047404732555150986,
0.6664005517959595,
0.34904685616493225,
-0.7639272809028625,
-0.378807932138443,
-0.26825734972953796,
-0.3915705382823944,
-0.33660265803337097,
-0.14526456594467163,
-0.03180781006813049,
0.21244953572750092,
0.680401086807251,
-0.49506834149360657,
0.3728730380535126,
0.55327308177948,
-0.3014458119869232,
0.7543805837631226,
0.17714358866214752,
-0.35638856887817383,
-0.7798033356666565,
-0.11712565273046494,
-0.14653165638446808,
-0.19486761093139648,
-0.6501966714859009,
-0.07829169183969498,
0.3764132857322693,
0.12964606285095215,
-0.5104613304138184,
0.4489561915397644,
-0.4409598410129547,
-0.12279345840215683,
-0.08529014140367508,
-0.17710736393928528,
-0.16783356666564941,
0.35302016139030457,
0.17422601580619812,
0.7932590842247009,
0.8226000666618347,
-0.720173180103302,
-0.03609507530927658,
-0.005492846947163343,
-0.5492754578590393,
0.31146708130836487,
-0.35969051718711853,
0.09227079898118973,
0.06647275388240814,
-0.05259018391370773,
-0.8643345236778259,
-0.013638714328408241,
-0.011607982218265533,
-0.47919991612434387,
0.4466992914676666,
-0.43472281098365784,
-0.19533000886440277,
-0.26798099279403687,
-0.22195006906986237,
0.21334081888198853,
0.4127618074417114,
-0.2812318503856659,
0.5300410389900208,
0.11636488139629364,
0.024839071556925774,
-0.4940495789051056,
-0.6595878601074219,
-0.3126721978187561,
-0.33685463666915894,
-0.5228763222694397,
0.2290426790714264,
-0.1570882499217987,
-0.17422813177108765,
-0.06113843992352486,
-0.44962114095687866,
-0.14148138463497162,
0.48188915848731995,
0.46693021059036255,
0.40005549788475037,
-0.18790897727012634,
0.052405908703804016,
0.08991517126560211,
-0.199911966919899,
-0.012703035026788712,
-0.5317392349243164,
0.5067519545555115,
0.152475968003273,
-0.4822203516960144,
-0.13534465432167053,
-0.19891752302646637,
0.5496979355812073,
-0.27210476994514465,
0.4715757369995117,
0.6794107556343079,
-0.0563998818397522,
-0.4979502260684967,
-0.33928999304771423,
-0.07329467684030533,
-0.49020591378211975,
0.5820897817611694,
-0.30325961112976074,
-0.8915255069732666,
0.3940746486186981,
-0.09588666260242462,
-0.2605802118778229,
0.23701392114162445,
0.6904995441436768,
-0.0057060918770730495,
0.7452298998832703,
0.800832986831665,
-0.0951678454875946,
0.7776061296463013,
-0.3798244893550873,
-0.004892201628535986,
-0.5240479111671448,
-0.18913951516151428,
-0.4980018734931946,
-0.2602262794971466,
-0.45258432626724243,
-0.6860942244529724,
0.2877506613731384,
0.16416287422180176,
-0.048093996942043304,
0.4095216691493988,
-0.15431882441043854,
0.1984001249074936,
0.5200674533843994,
-0.05322521552443504,
0.16166923940181732,
0.05327106639742851,
-0.3179563879966736,
-0.012769890949130058,
-0.7847657799720764,
-0.17114046216011047,
1.3399763107299805,
0.2326265573501587,
1.171318531036377,
-0.1795135736465454,
0.6592748761177063,
0.32604607939720154,
0.49640506505966187,
-0.7586747407913208,
0.3084956109523773,
0.1853851079940796,
-0.4584122598171234,
-0.06654389202594757,
-0.32617610692977905,
-0.6426500678062439,
-0.008935084566473961,
-0.28783082962036133,
-0.6363353729248047,
0.04639551788568497,
0.25154542922973633,
-0.232929989695549,
0.2175936996936798,
-0.7521534562110901,
0.8014049530029297,
-0.3751929700374603,
-0.2742529511451721,
-0.19159190356731415,
-0.5783600211143494,
0.2524915039539337,
-0.07818330079317093,
0.10653255134820938,
-0.1749439686536789,
-0.2688843905925751,
0.3260078728199005,
-0.24195779860019684,
0.9448196887969971,
-0.09896627068519592,
-0.22209185361862183,
0.2636137008666992,
0.43637049198150635,
0.6540545225143433,
-0.006748557556420565,
-0.298481285572052,
-0.12696270644664764,
-0.3228529393672943,
-0.2610611617565155,
-0.632108747959137,
0.4457707405090332,
-0.6181765198707581,
-0.3505520224571228,
-0.2057080864906311,
-0.6028467416763306,
-0.47257623076438904,
0.07267459481954575,
0.5245233178138733,
0.4775201678276062,
0.034919656813144684,
-0.1261255443096161,
0.5875670909881592,
0.12201321125030518,
0.5275801420211792,
0.3920976221561432,
-0.38390296697616577,
-0.2783443033695221,
0.7625178098678589,
-0.25141963362693787,
0.8437142968177795,
0.6981506943702698,
0.038900088518857956,
-0.35956302285194397,
-1.0724856853485107,
-0.150761678814888,
-0.08764369785785675,
-0.7041215896606445,
-0.24142670631408691,
-0.4705336391925812,
-0.30828189849853516,
-0.23636206984519958,
-0.48777666687965393,
-0.38563770055770874,
-0.7850452065467834,
-0.4477290213108063,
-0.31766554713249207,
0.2817747890949249,
0.7364628911018372,
0.14614441990852356,
0.24992847442626953,
-0.4622499644756317,
0.14890249073505402,
0.09144100546836853,
0.2725207507610321,
-0.3880467414855957,
-0.6328799724578857,
-0.23337480425834656,
-0.23568712174892426,
-0.3031613230705261,
-0.6786580085754395,
0.37917637825012207,
0.3842390179634094,
0.667874813079834,
0.4572142958641052,
0.009575776755809784,
0.41893383860588074,
-0.14752700924873352,
0.6964792013168335,
0.12589798867702484,
-0.8861987590789795,
0.4984329044818878,
-0.16641898453235626,
0.19734780490398407,
0.45849665999412537,
0.5363139510154724,
-0.3523477017879486,
-0.9081060886383057,
-0.6166892051696777,
-0.5023358464241028,
0.33478954434394836,
0.1858719438314438,
-0.2377038300037384,
0.12800706923007965,
0.2468634396791458,
0.31455132365226746,
0.4091256260871887,
-0.8614811301231384,
-0.41202032566070557,
-0.21039964258670807,
-0.3400370478630066,
-0.1436893492937088,
-0.3928212523460388,
0.033927999436855316,
-0.17625658214092255,
0.4292716681957245,
-0.3112749755382538,
0.2679988443851471,
0.04440560191869736,
-0.533907413482666,
-0.09336227178573608,
0.18949051201343536,
0.8364548087120056,
0.8755925297737122,
-0.12264884263277054,
0.4859771430492401,
-0.06319373100996017,
-0.4558876156806946,
0.16045911610126495,
-0.1120816171169281,
-0.4111800789833069,
-0.13638907670974731,
0.6216092109680176,
0.8090459704399109,
0.6700998544692993,
-0.4940315783023834,
0.3550144135951996,
0.30787190794944763,
-0.036795664578676224,
-0.186221182346344,
0.3202721178531647,
0.04717230051755905,
0.05616629496216774,
0.18733157217502594,
0.4807978868484497,
-0.25119027495384216,
-0.20160046219825745,
0.22839827835559845,
0.35729143023490906,
-0.49402374029159546,
-0.5535752773284912,
0.8156532049179077,
0.38063594698905945,
-0.21706566214561462,
0.14817063510417938,
-0.39127644896507263,
-0.8897697329521179,
0.7901999950408936,
0.7190165519714355,
1.1252013444900513,
-0.08563410490751266,
0.11591862142086029,
0.26838254928588867,
0.2740425765514374,
0.026843378320336342,
0.420598566532135,
0.02128019370138645,
-0.9540219902992249,
-0.5014945864677429,
-0.6013491153717041,
-0.37959688901901245,
-0.16892756521701813,
-0.3887254595756531,
0.3410913646221161,
-0.5071022510528564,
-0.04642198607325554,
-0.3015771210193634,
-0.4707041382789612,
-0.4316366910934448,
-0.1652379035949707,
0.2950911819934845,
1.1064305305480957,
-0.7324692606925964,
1.1808269023895264,
0.7021093368530273,
-0.26422542333602905,
-0.47192662954330444,
-0.02331358939409256,
0.10183010995388031,
-1.096293330192566,
0.7116230726242065,
0.14574365317821503,
-0.04817964881658554,
0.11449365317821503,
-0.5293204188346863,
-0.9768943786621094,
0.9481751322746277,
0.272146612405777,
-0.3732185959815979,
-0.058329176157712936,
0.09581267833709717,
0.4026412069797516,
-0.40323111414909363,
0.2903631925582886,
0.4932848811149597,
0.4591045081615448,
-0.16864438354969025,
-0.9213778972625732,
-0.15869413316249847,
0.016443924978375435,
0.12117070704698563,
0.1240418553352356,
-0.2075977623462677,
0.6702377200126648,
-0.511959433555603,
-0.08097046613693237,
0.24623151123523712,
0.7222021222114563,
0.13044804334640503,
0.09937427937984467,
0.45857512950897217,
0.5279839634895325,
0.6210920214653015,
-0.14242768287658691,
1.021499752998352,
-0.6286159753799438,
0.2932479977607727,
1.039663314819336,
-0.22081604599952698,
0.7282570600509644,
0.580089271068573,
-0.3926357328891754,
0.6832982897758484,
0.3853081166744232,
0.10320862382650375,
0.5158383250236511,
0.29963746666908264,
-0.4169219732284546,
-0.3644498288631439,
0.28180333971977234,
-0.39778146147727966,
0.37196531891822815,
0.6196479201316833,
-0.20226958394050598,
-0.07169226557016373,
-0.03047536127269268,
0.06336560845375061,
0.1320589929819107,
-0.4059408903121948,
0.5539900064468384,
-0.0018342050025239587,
-0.8571677803993225,
0.6239235997200012,
-0.18943911790847778,
0.936927080154419,
-0.7746712565422058,
0.21054832637310028,
-0.2128869593143463,
0.25607365369796753,
-0.24011152982711792,
-0.8466207385063171,
0.274370402097702,
-0.22804275155067444,
0.0019608133006840944,
-0.3201322555541992,
0.9486578106880188,
-0.5952614545822144,
-0.26272809505462646,
0.28784725069999695,
0.4932360351085663,
-0.18636268377304077,
-0.1975657194852829,
-0.6767272353172302,
0.05653667449951172,
0.17314834892749786,
0.07999926060438156,
0.3751852810382843,
0.24140699207782745,
0.050999078899621964,
1.1338775157928467,
0.4960137605667114,
0.24162478744983673,
0.7021682858467102,
0.035245612263679504,
0.7666655778884888,
-0.5050951242446899,
-0.4629916250705719,
-0.6028957366943359,
0.5823614001274109,
0.24336621165275574,
-0.4062863886356354,
0.747683048248291,
0.5470319390296936,
0.6978248953819275,
-0.4075559973716736,
0.8416783213615417,
-0.18391428887844086,
0.20298077166080475,
-0.880181610584259,
0.5627743601799011,
-0.06481651961803436,
0.155772864818573,
-0.030330317094922066,
-0.8911566138267517,
-0.2555408179759979,
0.28050538897514343,
-0.37612882256507874,
-0.11323882639408112,
0.75057452917099,
0.9551224112510681,
0.012982946820557117,
-0.3309294581413269,
0.29202014207839966,
0.23803623020648956,
0.2914287745952606,
0.624433696269989,
1.1516282558441162,
0.017695873975753784,
0.5030086636543274,
-0.46828553080558777,
-0.07139531522989273,
-0.4225001037120819,
-1.1213698387145996,
-0.8854216933250427,
-0.40116044878959656,
-0.5562823414802551,
-0.5317579507827759,
-0.037164121866226196,
0.8722040057182312,
0.677645742893219,
-0.8007479906082153,
-0.19692619144916534,
-0.3439164459705353,
0.6399924159049988,
-0.2611011862754822,
-0.2088405042886734,
0.06828116625547409,
-0.7589157819747925,
-0.4683552086353302,
0.6215543746948242,
0.4086416959762573,
0.15887588262557983,
-0.22133155167102814,
-0.2241474986076355,
-0.02635415457189083,
-0.3939792811870575,
0.5690279006958008,
0.5201670527458191,
-0.6478238701820374,
-0.3110108971595764,
-0.10100963711738586,
-0.23621676862239838,
0.24913500249385834,
1.0344624519348145,
-0.8406473398208618,
0.4550250470638275,
0.4677973985671997,
0.628302276134491,
0.327747106552124,
-0.0051085432060062885,
0.6352818012237549,
-0.7089632153511047,
0.4459734559059143,
0.2900989353656769,
0.47861605882644653,
0.18754388391971588,
-0.08900289982557297,
0.4765820801258087,
0.5234927535057068,
-0.37915533781051636,
-0.6412703990936279,
0.34700730443000793,
-1.0085909366607666,
0.06164423003792763,
1.5702345371246338,
-0.13127805292606354,
-0.1571531891822815,
-0.3589616119861603,
0.04440085589885712,
0.04742732271552086,
-0.23519647121429443,
0.5827171206474304,
0.33638495206832886,
-0.20441004633903503,
0.03609025850892067,
-0.27970126271247864,
0.8498446345329285,
0.5077446699142456,
-0.7857795357704163,
-0.0721050277352333,
0.2623790204524994,
0.5865445733070374,
0.11493480205535889,
0.42376020550727844,
-0.003481511725112796,
0.3403412997722626,
-0.09732168167829514,
0.2801339626312256,
-0.08653800934553146,
-0.3265083134174347,
-0.45266735553741455,
-0.10380204021930695,
0.515099287033081,
-0.1319500058889389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01869v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01869v1
|
Beyond Accuracy: Evaluating the Reasoning Behavior of Large Language Models -- A Survey
| 2024-04-02T11:46:31 | 2024-04-02T11:46:31 |
Philipp Mondorf, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown impressive performance on
tasks involving reasoning, leading to a lively debate on whether these models
possess reasoning capabilities similar to humans. However, despite these
successes, the depth of LLMs' reasoning abilities remains uncertain. This
uncertainty partly stems from the predominant focus on task performance,
measured through shallow accuracy metrics, rather than a thorough investigation
of the models' reasoning behavior. This paper seeks to address this gap by
providing a comprehensive review of studies that go beyond task accuracy,
offering deeper insights into the models' reasoning processes. Furthermore, we
survey prevalent methodologies to evaluate the reasoning behavior of LLMs,
emphasizing current trends and efforts towards more nuanced reasoning analyses.
Our review suggests that LLMs tend to rely on surface-level patterns and
correlations in their training data, rather than on genuine reasoning
abilities. Additionally, we identify the need for further research that
delineates the key differences between human and LLM-based reasoning. Through
this survey, we aim to shed light on the complex reasoning processes within
LLMs.
|
[
-0.19042494893074036,
-0.8816637992858887,
1.0829052925109863,
-0.14744877815246582,
0.11153051257133484,
0.21539543569087982,
-0.5146487951278687,
-0.49759960174560547,
-0.39871472120285034,
0.4768093228340149,
-0.362973153591156,
-0.5494309663772583,
-0.804834246635437,
0.044056348502635956,
-0.23187567293643951,
0.3838786780834198,
0.024770477786660194,
0.12710560858249664,
-0.49587929248809814,
0.031377434730529785,
-0.3872475326061249,
-0.7522846460342407,
-0.5535331964492798,
-0.701228678226471,
0.5382999777793884,
0.34724161028862,
0.7001767158508301,
0.4533770680427551,
0.5320560336112976,
0.2991839647293091,
-0.3604908287525177,
0.4886227548122406,
-0.4822772443294525,
0.21595098078250885,
-0.4284048080444336,
-0.8270198106765747,
-0.563578188419342,
-0.024516643956303596,
0.6783418655395508,
0.9374597072601318,
0.03522869199514389,
0.11114916950464249,
0.09725653380155563,
0.5679991245269775,
-0.6424841284751892,
0.09868469089269638,
-0.6826075911521912,
-0.16362115740776062,
-0.36997872591018677,
0.0479755662381649,
-0.5246268510818481,
-0.16624601185321808,
0.1598406732082367,
-0.23152099549770355,
0.11031823605298996,
0.06748209148645401,
0.3909931778907776,
0.1950920969247818,
-0.4674433171749115,
-0.355722039937973,
-0.8508794903755188,
1.0706768035888672,
-1.0123082399368286,
0.5781443119049072,
0.49292197823524475,
0.0812583938241005,
-0.3260594606399536,
-0.600372850894928,
-0.3281671702861786,
-0.63125079870224,
0.12477301061153412,
-0.28373804688453674,
-0.1142558604478836,
0.02382359281182289,
0.48981785774230957,
0.26124921441078186,
-0.45378929376602173,
0.33389362692832947,
0.028267603367567062,
0.023888446390628815,
0.8160873651504517,
0.23401787877082825,
0.10145799070596695,
0.03165966272354126,
0.046677928417921066,
-0.029233219102025032,
-0.6907906532287598,
0.24517977237701416,
0.27677327394485474,
0.12410229444503784,
0.12466290593147278,
0.674003005027771,
-0.2963550388813019,
0.7392443418502808,
-0.19011865556240082,
-0.3947625160217285,
0.0026402196381241083,
-0.10974051803350449,
-0.2444296032190323,
-0.1800529509782791,
0.5846935510635376,
0.36676475405693054,
0.4359530210494995,
-0.2693937122821808,
-0.44726142287254333,
-0.060517992824316025,
0.3151092231273651,
-0.4744188189506531,
-0.07990985363721848,
0.2874452471733093,
-0.4801260232925415,
-0.11073560267686844,
0.09970545768737793,
-0.35106778144836426,
-0.4822234511375427,
-0.6534468531608582,
0.21318911015987396,
-0.3599686920642853,
-0.3605237901210785,
0.31925925612449646,
0.11975166946649551,
0.22323927283287048,
0.6338475346565247,
-0.5765669345855713,
0.3400278091430664,
1.1894038915634155,
0.7865546941757202,
-0.30310413241386414,
-0.3597722351551056,
-0.22550658881664276,
0.06843489408493042,
-0.5534756779670715,
0.8446555137634277,
-0.6833109259605408,
-0.40465155243873596,
0.007828560657799244,
-0.18184354901313782,
-0.07672274112701416,
-0.5821880102157593,
0.7412543296813965,
-0.6092987656593323,
-0.14252541959285736,
-0.6692251563072205,
-0.8536148071289062,
-0.38483840227127075,
0.6298615336418152,
-0.5046401023864746,
1.0235456228256226,
-0.22910486161708832,
-0.6719619631767273,
0.3179709017276764,
-0.5795670747756958,
-0.31975889205932617,
-0.19023583829402924,
-0.10584872961044312,
-0.07072717696428299,
0.3273657560348511,
0.15590046346187592,
0.6787000298500061,
-0.5712894797325134,
0.38639378547668457,
-0.5267002582550049,
-0.532762885093689,
0.6284706592559814,
-0.555915892124176,
0.6563071012496948,
0.2000247687101364,
-0.2540602684020996,
0.08746971935033798,
-0.6469891667366028,
0.09025310724973679,
0.07038521766662598,
-0.08004230260848999,
-0.30330929160118103,
0.24389341473579407,
-0.41184893250465393,
0.18018309772014618,
0.30741217732429504,
-0.3801257014274597,
0.36807867884635925,
-0.3289141058921814,
0.5827357172966003,
0.633708119392395,
-0.31573155522346497,
0.4922076463699341,
-0.4289810061454773,
0.4465758800506592,
-0.33384793996810913,
0.22613514959812164,
0.006756506860256195,
-0.5142124891281128,
-0.6665568947792053,
0.00005081969720777124,
0.18141983449459076,
0.5071900486946106,
-0.302148699760437,
0.33251112699508667,
-0.4046202003955841,
-0.8017044067382812,
-0.26672878861427307,
0.2448088824748993,
0.4713638722896576,
0.29786768555641174,
0.2056988924741745,
-0.116024449467659,
-0.3021281361579895,
-0.6819352507591248,
-0.5295634269714355,
-0.3342292308807373,
0.16719985008239746,
0.3263233006000519,
0.6971520185470581,
-0.16670407354831696,
0.7864181995391846,
-0.39608702063560486,
0.272819846868515,
-0.44500428438186646,
0.10741955041885376,
0.07014445215463638,
0.3818446397781372,
0.24601441621780396,
-0.4898577630519867,
-0.04734484478831291,
0.10829333961009979,
-0.6660078167915344,
-0.05263441428542137,
0.13438208401203156,
0.02935449592769146,
0.3421505093574524,
0.6660871505737305,
-0.9415727853775024,
0.2754962146282196,
0.4875769019126892,
-0.12337210029363632,
0.6877416372299194,
-0.16101215779781342,
0.28149160742759705,
-0.4513184726238251,
0.1435125470161438,
0.06010737642645836,
-0.08968500792980194,
-0.5940214991569519,
0.09976565092802048,
-0.13304157555103302,
0.42478320002555847,
-0.15834210813045502,
0.6819160580635071,
-0.6833800673484802,
-0.4419828951358795,
-0.3474719226360321,
0.11230100691318512,
0.17857298254966736,
0.07620992511510849,
0.18578402698040009,
0.6697083711624146,
0.5103259682655334,
-0.49886301159858704,
0.543896496295929,
-0.11418460309505463,
-0.6860345602035522,
0.5580720901489258,
-0.6972756385803223,
0.3420718014240265,
-0.008446424268186092,
0.24430756270885468,
-1.0147485733032227,
-0.23474904894828796,
0.15262773633003235,
-0.4816892147064209,
0.33898743987083435,
-0.18754011392593384,
-0.6904706954956055,
-0.2867334485054016,
-0.1364419013261795,
0.3377685248851776,
0.5414520502090454,
-0.20829187333583832,
0.3917970061302185,
0.3032059967517853,
-0.1263865828514099,
-0.6514378190040588,
-0.7032976746559143,
0.24506814777851105,
-0.2526324391365051,
-0.7609965205192566,
0.022977828979492188,
0.11430055648088455,
-0.9435077905654907,
-0.3073691129684448,
-0.17992348968982697,
-0.1395588219165802,
0.20438720285892487,
0.030402634292840958,
-0.01583334244787693,
-0.3410317003726959,
0.2256084680557251,
-0.3026638925075531,
0.10637389123439789,
0.2816520035266876,
-0.06285225600004196,
0.4335643947124481,
-0.27564388513565063,
-0.8093948364257812,
-0.4060669243335724,
-0.008541619405150414,
0.593839168548584,
-0.17148621380329132,
0.6932552456855774,
0.3353811800479889,
-0.3293808400630951,
-0.0874394103884697,
-0.9303152561187744,
-0.2566053569316864,
-0.38050442934036255,
0.313087522983551,
-0.5519830584526062,
-1.0145351886749268,
0.5365692973136902,
-0.12429329752922058,
0.06309329718351364,
0.3373797535896301,
0.6229481101036072,
-0.33251819014549255,
1.1637811660766602,
0.3606114685535431,
0.32948148250579834,
0.11040805280208588,
-0.15915437042713165,
0.14537784457206726,
-0.8491465449333191,
-0.5809541344642639,
-0.687903642654419,
-0.2498256415128708,
-0.29200953245162964,
-0.7782807946205139,
0.004975031595677137,
0.23060914874076843,
-0.31951791048049927,
0.01281845010817051,
-0.29461029171943665,
0.33191388845443726,
0.36633196473121643,
0.0032675541006028652,
0.554418683052063,
-0.3196934759616852,
0.159489706158638,
-0.02707061544060707,
-0.5870089530944824,
-0.9861494898796082,
0.9372926354408264,
0.5102705955505371,
0.8368039131164551,
0.03366923704743385,
0.22784015536308289,
0.21484366059303284,
0.27908995747566223,
-0.801161527633667,
0.601145327091217,
-0.018436303362250328,
-0.6263579726219177,
-0.5338074564933777,
-0.3849237859249115,
-0.9193427562713623,
0.34865105152130127,
0.027659395709633827,
-0.8553890585899353,
0.033905066549777985,
0.09986992180347443,
-0.10781289637088776,
0.5958617329597473,
-0.48041704297065735,
0.8229260444641113,
-0.5939299464225769,
-0.22283555567264557,
-0.2703946828842163,
-0.6983912587165833,
0.6145241856575012,
0.004506686236709356,
0.3259589672088623,
-0.3388909697532654,
-0.1703362613916397,
0.4382226765155792,
-0.249524787068367,
0.8129238486289978,
0.03336859121918678,
-0.5762765407562256,
0.3337622880935669,
0.2676297426223755,
0.5816640853881836,
-0.11806930601596832,
-0.3187140226364136,
0.34669527411460876,
0.04657788574695587,
-0.38497015833854675,
-0.7327920794487,
0.6010959148406982,
-0.492608904838562,
-0.7626403570175171,
-0.30708393454551697,
-0.6836238503456116,
-0.5146779417991638,
0.021038532257080078,
0.04354577139019966,
0.3267863988876343,
-0.18201690912246704,
0.15619826316833496,
0.9014365673065186,
-0.11474650353193283,
0.20242545008659363,
0.2720969319343567,
-0.24751004576683044,
0.028454411774873734,
0.6027321815490723,
0.20899592339992523,
0.3744127154350281,
0.5286228060722351,
0.14358890056610107,
-0.5940175652503967,
-0.9879427552223206,
-0.4003930389881134,
0.2723333537578583,
-0.7801831364631653,
0.18417854607105255,
-0.4936080873012543,
-0.05776213854551315,
-0.44434046745300293,
-0.033624887466430664,
-0.5712408423423767,
-0.22986958920955658,
-0.30843794345855713,
0.11551658064126968,
0.20974227786064148,
0.9769781827926636,
0.1970834583044052,
0.1775866001844406,
-0.9087933301925659,
0.07941006869077682,
0.22144989669322968,
0.32544219493865967,
0.1239551529288292,
-0.7950946092605591,
0.04545903578400612,
0.19677861034870148,
0.019844718277454376,
-0.592548668384552,
0.09752698242664337,
-0.045015182346105576,
0.8379016518592834,
0.32065558433532715,
-0.19561715424060822,
0.6775885820388794,
-0.29409173130989075,
0.8555417656898499,
-0.14048203825950623,
-0.9777543544769287,
0.4154164791107178,
-0.302396684885025,
0.2767983078956604,
0.2965278923511505,
0.31949958205223083,
-0.3581163287162781,
-0.28827720880508423,
-0.578583836555481,
-0.38571858406066895,
0.6109231114387512,
0.18614749610424042,
0.11081937700510025,
0.33609718084335327,
0.5291838645935059,
0.08741964399814606,
0.13966114819049835,
-0.39589065313339233,
-0.016156010329723358,
0.2185918390750885,
0.07225386053323746,
-0.20130334794521332,
-0.278226375579834,
-0.020933276042342186,
-0.3605267107486725,
0.4849886894226074,
-0.13234210014343262,
-0.13313986361026764,
0.056941624730825424,
-0.27624088525772095,
0.023010820150375366,
0.3539140522480011,
0.6986396312713623,
1.1601229906082153,
-0.07202479243278503,
0.2456168532371521,
0.39904749393463135,
-0.15420523285865784,
0.1487886607646942,
-0.14110271632671356,
0.12518849968910217,
-0.1731598824262619,
0.7377532720565796,
0.6731674671173096,
0.3281894624233246,
-1.0347840785980225,
0.5958164930343628,
0.016702229157090187,
-0.11217733472585678,
-0.2965385913848877,
0.21973875164985657,
0.3174843192100525,
0.56468665599823,
0.04178538918495178,
0.02360551245510578,
0.1815759688615799,
-0.6362922191619873,
-0.17904864251613617,
0.5207505822181702,
-0.2228003740310669,
-0.21767273545265198,
0.40674659609794617,
0.05910041183233261,
-0.3293844759464264,
0.6725538372993469,
-0.04110996425151825,
-0.33170026540756226,
0.531689465045929,
0.217534139752388,
0.642513632774353,
-0.14776521921157837,
-0.0003938498848583549,
0.11703087389469147,
0.5341055393218994,
-0.49469324946403503,
0.202158585190773,
-0.042547065764665604,
-0.8710088133811951,
-1.0182243585586548,
-0.39556702971458435,
-0.6311264634132385,
0.1701873242855072,
-0.5376331806182861,
0.10467558354139328,
-0.3814936876296997,
-0.3262586295604706,
-0.15746267139911652,
-0.007654939312487841,
-0.360474556684494,
0.2617948353290558,
0.42660069465637207,
1.0241780281066895,
-0.5578561425209045,
0.7531257271766663,
1.0372589826583862,
-0.07768793404102325,
-0.5333605408668518,
-0.07339875400066376,
-0.04317040368914604,
-0.7020415663719177,
0.6357347965240479,
0.14430052042007446,
-0.3879533112049103,
-0.22652126848697662,
-0.7923611998558044,
-0.9584328532218933,
0.8387144207954407,
0.6436828374862671,
-0.6910251379013062,
-0.029627393931150436,
0.07609070837497711,
0.6151882410049438,
-0.1570047289133072,
0.302812397480011,
1.0463566780090332,
0.5992067456245422,
0.2294967621564865,
-1.0332224369049072,
-0.07652188092470169,
0.009889328852295876,
0.16920843720436096,
-0.028126588091254234,
-0.6330227851867676,
0.7788448333740234,
-0.33692753314971924,
0.028761856257915497,
0.024892549961805344,
0.576939582824707,
0.6443962454795837,
0.3315805196762085,
0.34621483087539673,
0.6338326930999756,
0.864883303642273,
-0.12864916026592255,
1.1253916025161743,
0.055654413998126984,
0.19134438037872314,
1.0377564430236816,
-0.5929135680198669,
0.727773129940033,
0.2722017765045166,
-0.4248756766319275,
0.5064111948013306,
0.6089574694633484,
0.0300150066614151,
0.006399227771908045,
0.30991795659065247,
-0.1061655655503273,
-0.7919342517852783,
0.03280290216207504,
-0.13785472512245178,
0.5192493200302124,
0.5513930916786194,
-0.12381275743246078,
-0.0260776337236166,
-0.33232560753822327,
0.11738918721675873,
0.1990429162979126,
-0.44168519973754883,
0.5981208682060242,
0.2925978899002075,
-0.7925158739089966,
0.4157373309135437,
0.14350147545337677,
0.6459892392158508,
-0.25359559059143066,
-0.09637747704982758,
0.031513381749391556,
0.06476308405399323,
-0.24529224634170532,
-1.2723184823989868,
0.27182435989379883,
0.12429875135421753,
-0.16846705973148346,
-0.25660988688468933,
0.911069393157959,
-0.06688623130321503,
-0.25822913646698,
0.15417984127998352,
0.8541476130485535,
0.4885465204715729,
-0.259225070476532,
-0.847436785697937,
0.411036878824234,
-0.2214692384004593,
-0.5092078447341919,
0.18249747157096863,
0.554070770740509,
-0.07102540135383606,
0.9702450037002563,
0.6754224300384521,
0.19349859654903412,
0.1293053925037384,
0.24938294291496277,
0.4546031057834625,
-0.6411474943161011,
0.035713281482458115,
-1.1003427505493164,
0.47078922390937805,
-0.10835319012403488,
-0.3967606723308563,
0.8252516388893127,
0.36547306180000305,
0.8633394837379456,
0.02726844698190689,
0.754166305065155,
0.13474813103675842,
0.6468614935874939,
-0.6711247563362122,
0.33803442120552063,
-0.5463348627090454,
0.36538225412368774,
-0.258912056684494,
-0.9954809546470642,
-0.37782910466194153,
0.7682237029075623,
-0.6601994633674622,
0.38321444392204285,
0.44430503249168396,
0.6978307962417603,
-0.0011100618867203593,
0.13286279141902924,
0.514098584651947,
0.3545593023300171,
0.24429747462272644,
0.4589935839176178,
1.4317766427993774,
-0.02159646525979042,
0.31083956360816956,
-0.14678578078746796,
0.09896443039178848,
-0.359393447637558,
-1.0269713401794434,
-0.9384781718254089,
-0.23046740889549255,
-0.20672249794006348,
-0.04878119006752968,
0.0017640150617808104,
0.8012539148330688,
0.6491616368293762,
-0.7444275617599487,
-0.3063787519931793,
-0.1524011343717575,
0.2866978049278259,
-0.09415034204721451,
-0.1907694786787033,
0.26586389541625977,
-0.37325936555862427,
-0.8800724148750305,
0.4325689971446991,
0.21072068810462952,
-0.09317732602357864,
-0.4732324779033661,
-0.16784511506557465,
-0.06006147712469101,
0.11056975275278091,
0.7150074243545532,
0.15498803555965424,
-1.1331425905227661,
-0.2606750428676605,
-0.042929451912641525,
-0.26979860663414,
0.02448691427707672,
0.858745276927948,
-0.42767924070358276,
0.16715410351753235,
0.6677637696266174,
0.6072944402694702,
0.2861212491989136,
0.062211327254772186,
0.483323335647583,
-0.31932973861694336,
-0.20684947073459625,
0.4256899058818817,
0.3839687407016754,
0.5137378573417664,
-0.14423757791519165,
0.43677568435668945,
0.15528441965579987,
-0.8715044260025024,
-1.1270285844802856,
0.20038872957229614,
-0.8919601440429688,
-0.4929596185684204,
1.3534001111984253,
-0.26749759912490845,
-0.014740807004272938,
-0.31529149413108826,
-0.24027346074581146,
0.1711713820695877,
-0.1661769598722458,
0.5891020894050598,
0.9566620588302612,
-0.5217718482017517,
-0.3182834982872009,
-0.757338285446167,
0.3327323794364929,
0.3284618854522705,
-0.8467659950256348,
0.20109489560127258,
0.5706562995910645,
0.36020201444625854,
0.0223508570343256,
0.47751885652542114,
-0.10859180986881256,
0.13241678476333618,
-0.12247736752033234,
-0.02194449119269848,
0.12087409198284149,
-0.38875365257263184,
-0.3569909334182739,
0.1471341997385025,
0.6534525156021118,
0.4936669170856476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01860v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01860v1
|
Self-StrAE at SemEval-2024 Task 1: Making Self-Structuring AutoEncoders Learn More With Less
| 2024-04-02T11:38:11 | 2024-04-02T11:38:11 |
Mattia Opper, N. Siddharth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents two simple improvements to the Self-Structuring
AutoEncoder (Self-StrAE). Firstly, we show that including reconstruction to the
vocabulary as an auxiliary objective improves representation quality. Secondly,
we demonstrate that increasing the number of independent channels leads to
significant improvements in embedding quality, while simultaneously reducing
the number of parameters. Surprisingly, we demonstrate that this trend can be
followed to the extreme, even to point of reducing the total number of
non-embedding parameters to seven. Our system can be pre-trained from scratch
with as little as 10M tokens of input data, and proves effective across
English, Spanish and Afrikaans.
|
[
-0.7458528280258179,
-0.12022818624973297,
0.23783941566944122,
0.2838967442512512,
-0.389903724193573,
-0.16802425682544708,
0.034265000373125076,
-0.3849360942840576,
0.7906200289726257,
0.3518376350402832,
-0.15030288696289062,
-0.2593081295490265,
-0.8620067238807678,
0.22176121175289154,
-0.2593279778957367,
0.5471138954162598,
-0.229417622089386,
0.18825219571590424,
-0.07076689600944519,
-0.43777966499328613,
-0.27252501249313354,
-0.6939859390258789,
-0.7162349820137024,
-0.1503385752439499,
0.5541126132011414,
0.49503713846206665,
0.36641964316368103,
1.0486664772033691,
0.21811583638191223,
0.3534044325351715,
0.45216116309165955,
-0.046258535236120224,
-0.4322673976421356,
0.29046812653541565,
-0.08306748420000076,
0.08244859427213669,
-0.0686715766787529,
-0.3734631836414337,
0.4653300344944,
0.5316293239593506,
-0.0702982246875763,
0.2574043869972229,
0.2884855568408966,
0.7223443388938904,
-0.5328283309936523,
0.1695549041032791,
0.16896682977676392,
0.046722412109375,
0.10333394259214401,
-0.3551013171672821,
-0.13723474740982056,
0.2492203265428543,
-0.12872540950775146,
-0.25882700085639954,
0.29392287135124207,
-0.2810768783092499,
0.7761452198028564,
0.7959432005882263,
-0.5761114358901978,
-0.3706417977809906,
-0.466697633266449,
0.43554991483688354,
-0.536653995513916,
0.9625127911567688,
0.4713045060634613,
0.2853468358516693,
0.05627097561955452,
-0.902504563331604,
0.06516368687152863,
0.12754888832569122,
0.03556187078356743,
0.21125486493110657,
-0.10311103612184525,
-0.10835961997509003,
0.019390178844332695,
0.4213908314704895,
-0.42228463292121887,
0.09199700504541397,
-0.8555248975753784,
-0.5085029602050781,
0.8685606718063354,
-0.09388893097639084,
0.026886645704507828,
-0.3413129448890686,
-0.3157166838645935,
-0.34956425428390503,
-0.5374855399131775,
-0.1082531288266182,
0.40256422758102417,
-0.07449590414762497,
0.027763621881604195,
0.2998913526535034,
-0.1778184324502945,
0.2569164037704468,
0.2568628489971161,
0.07625045627355576,
0.44843047857284546,
-0.36533570289611816,
-0.36866816878318787,
0.22461524605751038,
0.636033833026886,
-0.006182594690471888,
-0.2038515955209732,
0.03862500190734863,
-0.23666994273662567,
0.007763486355543137,
0.5365740060806274,
-0.845973551273346,
-0.7829559445381165,
-0.057612787932157516,
-0.6877387762069702,
-0.07903604209423065,
-0.24130035936832428,
-0.3710514307022095,
0.04608297348022461,
-0.4711264967918396,
0.6853868365287781,
-0.5051630139350891,
0.13891662657260895,
0.05872817710042,
-0.07112199068069458,
0.31599298119544983,
0.5387153029441833,
-0.8637535572052002,
0.3246307671070099,
0.043652746826410294,
0.6043614745140076,
0.0691300481557846,
-0.3315492570400238,
-0.4285668432712555,
-0.09685945510864258,
-0.575352668762207,
0.8690825700759888,
-0.2525603175163269,
-0.4483121335506439,
-0.5301642417907715,
0.03784806281328201,
0.3717174530029297,
-0.3878355920314789,
0.052018605172634125,
-0.41987574100494385,
0.20092996954917908,
-0.48453640937805176,
-0.6131669282913208,
-0.12438271194696426,
-0.04240864887833595,
-0.6834042072296143,
1.1788233518600464,
0.18349945545196533,
-0.2494036853313446,
0.28624066710472107,
-0.26791664958000183,
-0.5438683032989502,
-0.1007954552769661,
-0.4454006254673004,
-0.28222301602363586,
0.4042811095714569,
0.4364660978317261,
0.5149467587471008,
-0.01023910939693451,
0.041643619537353516,
-0.1291530281305313,
-0.10571210086345673,
-0.33765214681625366,
-0.47419992089271545,
0.5851836204528809,
0.5290746688842773,
-0.620101809501648,
-0.1393362432718277,
-0.8096737861633301,
-0.06655721366405487,
-0.07732724398374557,
-0.4276227653026581,
-0.25856563448905945,
-0.2398572564125061,
-0.4242130219936371,
0.46650102734565735,
0.3056248426437378,
-0.4627091884613037,
0.15073509514331818,
-0.5972177982330322,
0.49952957034111023,
0.7312489151954651,
0.27061834931373596,
0.763576090335846,
-0.1421259343624115,
0.4247422218322754,
0.053953345865011215,
0.12606073915958405,
-0.3002603352069855,
-0.08516859263181686,
-1.2723828554153442,
-0.4432554244995117,
0.5295504927635193,
-0.19475311040878296,
-0.9178953170776367,
0.23413227498531342,
-0.006405290681868792,
-0.49407336115837097,
-0.637962818145752,
0.4415537118911743,
0.353732705116272,
0.18314170837402344,
0.7017726898193359,
-0.5958837866783142,
-0.9645395278930664,
-1.0766483545303345,
0.03882664442062378,
0.02305627055466175,
0.22654350101947784,
0.05276422202587128,
0.7903202176094055,
-0.28118592500686646,
0.47616511583328247,
0.009217518381774426,
-0.251389741897583,
-0.06595733761787415,
0.09248609840869904,
-0.11204086244106293,
0.731704592704773,
0.6531681418418884,
-0.4477696716785431,
-0.5127107501029968,
-0.480295866727829,
-0.7255630493164062,
-0.029602982103824615,
-0.031382426619529724,
-0.06492707133293152,
0.1133032962679863,
0.9273328185081482,
0.036577630788087845,
0.6474581360816956,
0.5560724139213562,
-0.30024564266204834,
0.21436284482479095,
-0.5595585703849792,
0.1881866455078125,
-0.8582349419593811,
-0.5083505511283875,
-0.3709985911846161,
-0.4962741732597351,
-0.5587044358253479,
0.046547431498765945,
0.18454843759536743,
-0.1609647423028946,
-0.5011186003684998,
0.5813924670219421,
-0.7507009506225586,
-0.3002925217151642,
-0.3474186658859253,
-0.2508176565170288,
0.1596512794494629,
0.6658003330230713,
0.1180165633559227,
0.7891372442245483,
0.5635690689086914,
-0.9643217325210571,
0.18985269963741302,
0.3491135835647583,
-0.21041181683540344,
0.23370198905467987,
-0.8849489092826843,
0.18381288647651672,
-0.5505778193473816,
0.09367210417985916,
-1.0932121276855469,
-0.2415122091770172,
0.19798998534679413,
-0.4744757115840912,
0.4070016145706177,
-0.13178133964538574,
-0.13932067155838013,
-0.3622537851333618,
-0.2242359071969986,
0.4372134208679199,
0.4492764174938202,
-0.8730649948120117,
0.7103644609451294,
0.4668735861778259,
-0.024889323860406876,
-0.2911406457424164,
-1.0129992961883545,
0.19520515203475952,
0.10838291049003601,
-0.31728842854499817,
0.28764596581459045,
0.025324538350105286,
0.2575955390930176,
0.21421502530574799,
-0.3348644971847534,
0.08950220048427582,
0.05374851077795029,
0.31088241934776306,
-0.24072270095348358,
-0.1161937490105629,
0.4832707643508911,
0.07644569873809814,
-0.4420965015888214,
-0.04207123816013336,
-0.7461605072021484,
0.5022423267364502,
-0.1763731688261032,
-0.5609158873558044,
-0.36496543884277344,
0.3937804698944092,
0.20807550847530365,
-0.40683484077453613,
0.49601030349731445,
0.37790772318840027,
-0.16361558437347412,
-0.20359985530376434,
-0.5847436189651489,
-0.21415455639362335,
-0.5608115196228027,
0.21051594614982605,
-0.7290751338005066,
-1.1033921241760254,
0.27064773440361023,
0.2503919303417206,
-0.018243491649627686,
0.7455876469612122,
0.4920535385608673,
-0.4828735291957855,
1.0415880680084229,
0.5669203400611877,
0.15441779792308807,
0.3694894313812256,
-0.5763076543807983,
0.02833440899848938,
-0.7597488760948181,
-0.3052172362804413,
-0.4081892669200897,
-0.4088905453681946,
-0.5316622853279114,
-0.6985476613044739,
0.22577792406082153,
0.08284963667392731,
-0.43159300088882446,
0.7492702603340149,
-0.771226704120636,
0.17904016375541687,
0.7452179193496704,
0.10042869299650192,
-0.17139184474945068,
0.09248367697000504,
-0.17266909778118134,
-0.12680725753307343,
-1.2046476602554321,
-0.39256229996681213,
0.8470082879066467,
0.6256370544433594,
0.856880784034729,
0.18708555400371552,
1.6392892599105835,
0.34599581360816956,
0.14488789439201355,
-0.6547508835792542,
0.30345696210861206,
-0.19542717933654785,
-0.4952680766582489,
-0.510973334312439,
-0.4903188645839691,
-0.961269199848175,
0.28211620450019836,
0.12264400720596313,
-0.10351677983999252,
0.9752078652381897,
0.4041116535663605,
-0.396354079246521,
0.12313167750835419,
-0.5521149039268494,
0.8428864479064941,
-0.6579059958457947,
-0.22786511480808258,
-0.1976761817932129,
-0.3490524888038635,
-0.33464235067367554,
0.04601161181926727,
0.19059494137763977,
-0.1645527482032776,
-0.19765791296958923,
0.86329185962677,
-0.769344687461853,
0.8600384593009949,
-0.4065421223640442,
-0.07301704585552216,
0.5590858459472656,
0.17795224487781525,
0.4701499342918396,
-0.05897361412644386,
-0.09189241379499435,
0.09532663226127625,
0.21221256256103516,
-0.7460313439369202,
-0.6849298477172852,
0.5334190130233765,
-0.9544699192047119,
-0.4608542323112488,
-0.37013158202171326,
0.11446898430585861,
-0.015801958739757538,
0.08313301205635071,
0.5607886910438538,
1.0052999258041382,
-0.2992435097694397,
0.49138718843460083,
0.49281370639801025,
-0.22842830419540405,
0.563198447227478,
0.2248961478471756,
0.055652085691690445,
-0.8678799867630005,
0.8531135320663452,
0.5089876055717468,
-0.043797291815280914,
-0.009917049668729305,
0.038931068032979965,
-0.5823690295219421,
-0.4011874198913574,
-0.5648951530456543,
0.22394095361232758,
-1.1639374494552612,
-0.40850308537483215,
-0.8150959610939026,
-0.22264133393764496,
-0.7766478657722473,
-0.21617230772972107,
-0.793591320514679,
-0.5858888030052185,
-0.45484650135040283,
-0.17144091427326202,
-0.025442851707339287,
0.917716383934021,
-0.5928114056587219,
0.32093825936317444,
-0.763096809387207,
0.14511428773403168,
0.5895874500274658,
0.2640087306499481,
0.0015676248585805297,
-1.0087393522262573,
-0.4663928747177124,
-0.14040523767471313,
0.2571538984775543,
-0.7744373679161072,
0.6537113189697266,
0.5035513043403625,
0.7541576027870178,
0.20100894570350647,
0.08087752759456635,
0.9937308430671692,
-0.5030601024627686,
0.5665669441223145,
0.28148141503334045,
-0.87779700756073,
0.5757867693901062,
0.16508565843105316,
0.4174157381057739,
0.9338847994804382,
0.5712346434593201,
-0.24502700567245483,
-0.040598198771476746,
-0.9659777283668518,
-0.6611385345458984,
0.37625372409820557,
0.22558987140655518,
0.32381847500801086,
-0.19584064185619354,
0.37619319558143616,
0.10880198329687119,
0.0067620789632201195,
-0.4336458146572113,
-0.4508854150772095,
-0.9397980570793152,
-0.31860849261283875,
-0.35056865215301514,
-0.613304853439331,
0.16654810309410095,
-0.49217090010643005,
0.8694877624511719,
-0.1153007373213768,
0.6996989250183105,
0.6571115851402283,
-0.41064250469207764,
0.30217939615249634,
0.10981050878763199,
0.3783239424228668,
0.23277978599071503,
0.30431535840034485,
0.6766760349273682,
0.5755829215049744,
0.018915383145213127,
0.6588736772537231,
-0.04974004626274109,
-0.027146749198436737,
0.1152368113398552,
0.5117185115814209,
1.00569748878479,
0.5868997573852539,
-0.12033973634243011,
0.48553961515426636,
-0.03869324550032616,
-0.6571863293647766,
-0.5856711268424988,
0.14038337767124176,
-0.10556294769048691,
0.2718649208545685,
0.2830263674259186,
0.1274222880601883,
0.2718617022037506,
-0.46219465136528015,
0.5367620587348938,
-0.10610295087099075,
-0.5707495808601379,
-0.26831066608428955,
0.6023702025413513,
0.3489484488964081,
-0.25560611486434937,
0.14652661979198456,
-0.4215962588787079,
-0.5132876634597778,
0.5945543050765991,
0.6181950569152832,
0.5051012635231018,
-0.47005414962768555,
0.2584894299507141,
0.5989604592323303,
0.3450153172016144,
-0.18937702476978302,
0.34073570370674133,
-0.45757442712783813,
-0.7490371465682983,
-0.4412822723388672,
-0.5856612324714661,
0.009163450449705124,
-0.15129293501377106,
-0.6887882947921753,
0.0920943096280098,
-0.4888504445552826,
0.04608742520213127,
-0.09151876717805862,
-0.06978169083595276,
-1.0150785446166992,
0.45894262194633484,
-0.08535657078027725,
0.9548408389091492,
-0.4904784560203552,
0.9458396434783936,
0.7441098093986511,
-0.42903992533683777,
-1.0080379247665405,
-0.7184811234474182,
-0.24093542993068695,
-0.8129906058311462,
0.7645957469940186,
0.17024746537208557,
-0.2584778368473053,
0.4794842004776001,
-0.474052369594574,
-1.482309103012085,
0.9277797937393188,
0.31402021646499634,
-0.733951985836029,
-0.042766228318214417,
-0.18530909717082977,
0.5196157693862915,
-0.3531201481819153,
0.07393791526556015,
0.2970768213272095,
0.3810924291610718,
0.06254751980304718,
-0.5655087232589722,
-0.20019200444221497,
-0.37235334515571594,
-0.06009650230407715,
0.3187509775161743,
-0.5819820761680603,
0.44932815432548523,
0.1725751757621765,
-0.5346466898918152,
-0.13745653629302979,
1.1052308082580566,
-0.44959208369255066,
-0.016471311450004578,
0.4245622158050537,
0.7158735990524292,
0.7105462551116943,
0.06175524368882179,
1.0492990016937256,
-0.48642638325691223,
0.2966878116130829,
1.4137974977493286,
0.16310468316078186,
0.5602726936340332,
0.3448316752910614,
0.04625609889626503,
0.5668782591819763,
0.7201862931251526,
-0.07753574848175049,
0.622292160987854,
-0.15937429666519165,
0.13780151307582855,
-0.6002312898635864,
0.3146817088127136,
-0.4344915747642517,
0.7679648399353027,
0.16066716611385345,
-0.45573481917381287,
-0.3727838099002838,
0.6444132924079895,
-0.3523224890232086,
-0.12832315266132355,
-0.2946251928806305,
0.8950530886650085,
0.1753886193037033,
-0.5287583470344543,
0.6681699156761169,
-0.08048223704099655,
0.40648430585861206,
-0.4478476643562317,
0.03710818663239479,
-0.26520708203315735,
-0.06873881816864014,
-0.12149693071842194,
-0.3905719518661499,
0.5064975619316101,
-0.3824375867843628,
0.19058333337306976,
-0.5929164290428162,
1.0776937007904053,
-0.3968508541584015,
-0.3130672872066498,
0.4804569184780121,
0.570612370967865,
0.5024058222770691,
0.09114528447389603,
-0.6253437995910645,
0.03225293010473251,
0.1790231466293335,
-0.21941590309143066,
0.17095673084259033,
0.3439260423183441,
0.2842521071434021,
0.6404716968536377,
0.4936637282371521,
0.05394633859395981,
0.11559677124023438,
0.1630334109067917,
0.8939679861068726,
-0.8455297946929932,
-0.5630459189414978,
-0.6124986410140991,
0.2655702531337738,
0.026599597185850143,
-0.19101913273334503,
0.9129946827888489,
0.45202401280403137,
1.0168756246566772,
-0.008100984618067741,
0.6735892295837402,
-0.08202079683542252,
0.19230413436889648,
-0.38774731755256653,
0.2953605055809021,
-0.6546939611434937,
0.16055379807949066,
0.24860595166683197,
-0.7397401928901672,
-0.07460872828960419,
1.0524109601974487,
-0.3224334418773651,
0.06129179894924164,
0.43443095684051514,
0.7677631974220276,
-0.027921807020902634,
-0.3166710138320923,
0.6127604842185974,
0.01053325179964304,
0.22181786596775055,
0.16195131838321686,
1.012709379196167,
-0.8320037722587585,
0.5418131351470947,
-0.5908147692680359,
0.045189373195171356,
-0.36443573236465454,
-0.5686590075492859,
-0.8507779836654663,
-0.7189679741859436,
-0.39911139011383057,
-0.2527020573616028,
0.1410244107246399,
1.0780422687530518,
0.998632550239563,
-0.9278276562690735,
0.061908792704343796,
-0.12352417409420013,
-0.32094138860702515,
0.03730545938014984,
-0.08188588172197342,
0.30262133479118347,
-0.6641616225242615,
-0.387243390083313,
0.7462633848190308,
0.49053508043289185,
0.32096877694129944,
-0.38498809933662415,
-0.4631139934062958,
-0.08155347406864166,
0.1354650855064392,
0.7015377879142761,
0.4852502942085266,
-0.279453307390213,
-0.7568970918655396,
-0.0800553560256958,
-0.3049265444278717,
0.36307665705680847,
0.7828335165977478,
-0.8943597078323364,
0.6464552879333496,
0.6244176030158997,
0.8090835809707642,
1.0577619075775146,
0.07235293835401535,
0.5207445025444031,
-0.6695704460144043,
0.06556989252567291,
0.17512966692447662,
0.6482367515563965,
0.2777228057384491,
-0.2680848240852356,
0.6908904910087585,
0.04830847680568695,
-0.5986574292182922,
-0.28168419003486633,
0.22634094953536987,
-0.32462939620018005,
-0.4189586639404297,
0.8045012354850769,
-0.038326799869537354,
-0.4226459860801697,
-0.4788878560066223,
-0.1432000994682312,
0.31327351927757263,
-0.207135409116745,
0.4790040850639343,
0.46622833609580994,
-0.4196735620498657,
-0.461714506149292,
-0.3183121383190155,
0.5054268836975098,
0.6802843809127808,
-0.5619083046913147,
-0.6108958125114441,
0.5593889951705933,
0.4389875829219818,
0.15518108010292053,
1.0362313985824585,
-0.14470137655735016,
0.3860684335231781,
0.22966283559799194,
0.31143468618392944,
-0.3806494176387787,
-0.6753299236297607,
-0.5037583112716675,
0.1181950643658638,
0.07483402639627457,
-0.25908681750297546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01857v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01857v1
|
Detecting Gender Bias in Course Evaluations
| 2024-04-02T11:35:05 | 2024-04-02T11:35:05 |
Sarah Lindau, Linnea Nilsson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
An outtake from the findnings of a master thesis studying gender bias in
course evaluations through the lense of machine learning and nlp. We use
different methods to examine and explore the data and find differences in what
students write about courses depending on gender of the examiner. Data from
English and Swedish courses are evaluated and compared, in order to capture
more nuance in the gender bias that might be found. Here we present the results
from the work so far, but this is an ongoing project and there is more work to
do.
|
[
-0.16354411840438843,
-0.6799159049987793,
0.36639928817749023,
0.009408391080796719,
0.37463122606277466,
0.20400477945804596,
0.1022987961769104,
-0.25100892782211304,
-0.05544572323560715,
0.5656312108039856,
-0.890923023223877,
-0.6062601208686829,
-0.42711666226387024,
0.27729734778404236,
-0.5175130367279053,
0.7235106825828552,
-0.07136533409357071,
1.0027562379837036,
-0.4910472333431244,
-0.11232130229473114,
-1.0185025930404663,
-0.37423765659332275,
-0.6703741550445557,
-0.47857677936553955,
0.25300168991088867,
0.5409359335899353,
0.3119928538799286,
0.21121396124362946,
0.4620015621185303,
0.1602136343717575,
-0.14145123958587646,
-0.2778884172439575,
0.023028701543807983,
0.04779519885778427,
-0.42433640360832214,
-0.8996157050132751,
-0.26191437244415283,
0.28534939885139465,
0.6716992855072021,
0.8849305510520935,
0.1589222550392151,
0.5596417784690857,
0.1351495087146759,
1.1516315937042236,
-0.7744166851043701,
0.26796755194664,
-0.22650887072086334,
0.5461993217468262,
-0.08764245361089706,
0.02536650002002716,
-0.5585532784461975,
-0.39412644505500793,
0.5072009563446045,
0.0919632539153099,
0.48526322841644287,
0.07795092463493347,
0.4386546015739441,
-0.158572718501091,
-0.32027748227119446,
-0.4294043481349945,
-0.4503566324710846,
1.1044678688049316,
-0.5926731824874878,
0.4755440056324005,
0.4920806586742401,
0.4638737738132477,
0.10182506591081619,
-0.06893853098154068,
-0.21331974864006042,
-0.2676766812801361,
-0.0890507623553276,
0.031729698181152344,
-0.08782832324504852,
-0.25698384642601013,
0.31259530782699585,
0.36215996742248535,
-0.550495982170105,
0.05909174308180809,
-0.36963263154029846,
-0.112372025847435,
0.9028086066246033,
0.16498878598213196,
0.41671693325042725,
-0.44665035605430603,
0.16173985600471497,
-0.13144740462303162,
-0.6970642805099487,
-0.049035005271434784,
1.3651514053344727,
0.3306025564670563,
0.09309195727109909,
0.7675263285636902,
0.11465665698051453,
0.5800094604492188,
-0.10411622375249863,
0.26118871569633484,
0.08732020109891891,
0.13137806951999664,
-0.13269498944282532,
0.29105883836746216,
0.35388174653053284,
0.39804789423942566,
0.10055036097764969,
0.16790719330310822,
-0.25456520915031433,
-0.017479224130511284,
0.32997485995292664,
-0.26148420572280884,
-0.17227081954479218,
0.11785250157117844,
-0.9149010181427002,
-0.4780566692352295,
0.12620900571346283,
-0.9412558674812317,
-0.45065343379974365,
-0.6659562587738037,
0.46121564507484436,
-0.09190400689840317,
-0.3302856683731079,
0.10826529562473297,
-0.590755045413971,
0.15375007688999176,
-0.012532038614153862,
-0.7285560965538025,
0.19176985323429108,
0.6642172336578369,
0.5712770819664001,
-0.32477810978889465,
-0.2724381387233734,
0.005795810371637344,
-0.2833302617073059,
-0.26636090874671936,
0.2811823785305023,
-0.5470457077026367,
-0.39279234409332275,
0.29196396470069885,
0.13267675042152405,
0.1665475070476532,
-0.725261926651001,
0.6785028576850891,
0.04526156187057495,
0.9126870036125183,
-0.1986030489206314,
-0.6778928637504578,
-0.30771592259407043,
0.026282411068677902,
-0.6273617148399353,
1.2895458936691284,
0.3818340301513672,
-1.0692291259765625,
0.6179802417755127,
-1.0737367868423462,
-0.1858988255262375,
-0.3627016842365265,
-0.44643262028694153,
-0.6124540567398071,
0.02155068702995777,
0.03596740588545799,
0.34138911962509155,
-0.10674126446247101,
0.47970420122146606,
-0.18486441671848297,
-0.3284817337989807,
0.16317245364189148,
-0.26023563742637634,
1.2580068111419678,
-0.15273495018482208,
-0.6230832934379578,
0.1143956407904625,
-0.806271493434906,
-0.12978969514369965,
0.11894827336072922,
-0.22025300562381744,
-0.5014525055885315,
0.11388982087373734,
-0.055873189121484756,
0.3011638820171356,
-0.008508436381816864,
-0.40946096181869507,
0.19407795369625092,
-0.2048875093460083,
-0.0005694284336641431,
0.9336172342300415,
-0.38072365522384644,
0.6768548488616943,
-0.2774660587310791,
0.6967917084693909,
-0.05785544961690903,
0.13986092805862427,
0.14083687961101532,
-0.5710840225219727,
-0.9403557777404785,
0.12608131766319275,
0.7070972919464111,
0.5673104524612427,
-0.7971428036689758,
0.5469576120376587,
0.3087277412414551,
-0.4030212461948395,
-0.9858874082565308,
-0.009271405637264252,
0.49122679233551025,
0.4125453531742096,
0.09841436892747879,
-0.37070271372795105,
-0.9733580350875854,
-0.9809302091598511,
-0.8430410027503967,
-0.21478824317455292,
-0.3553614318370819,
0.1344364434480667,
0.992953360080719,
-0.18148326873779297,
1.2294198274612427,
-0.7345578670501709,
-0.38886192440986633,
-0.28142663836479187,
0.1682262420654297,
0.04960022121667862,
0.8852731585502625,
0.6717381477355957,
-0.418244868516922,
-0.014525482431054115,
-0.32187867164611816,
-0.8782288432121277,
-0.43169140815734863,
0.0700690895318985,
-0.4632289707660675,
0.2899756133556366,
0.28687286376953125,
0.08731666952371597,
0.7847175598144531,
0.050799477845430374,
-0.6820359826087952,
0.7911729216575623,
0.043061044067144394,
0.17549172043800354,
-0.40255996584892273,
-0.06132935732603073,
0.15810543298721313,
-0.20335155725479126,
-0.1879686564207077,
-0.15557770431041718,
-0.10424281656742096,
0.09558776021003723,
-0.3701638877391815,
0.5886754989624023,
-0.44402647018432617,
-0.3916172981262207,
-0.20287659764289856,
-0.2314174771308899,
0.13815714418888092,
0.26747116446495056,
0.046078018844127655,
0.4313904643058777,
0.5675055980682373,
-0.4198656678199768,
-0.0785738155245781,
0.31225693225860596,
-0.3109545409679413,
0.9530958533287048,
-0.1068459078669548,
0.3137446343898773,
-0.329028844833374,
0.12628386914730072,
-0.9143583178520203,
-0.04041266441345215,
0.41251108050346375,
-0.6702455878257751,
0.23389321565628052,
-0.5404659509658813,
-0.20653082430362701,
-0.6008473038673401,
-0.5954589247703552,
-0.07850688695907593,
0.2338290959596634,
-0.5168073773384094,
0.5852105021476746,
0.3992106318473816,
-0.011771336197853088,
-0.933526873588562,
-0.7035270929336548,
-0.09443074464797974,
-0.25815480947494507,
-0.39193931221961975,
-0.21239545941352844,
-0.07953979074954987,
-0.6147637367248535,
-0.2857745289802551,
-0.05870112404227257,
-0.35981008410453796,
0.3466642200946808,
0.4402671158313751,
0.4971525967121124,
-0.20717853307724,
0.060624152421951294,
0.5674485564231873,
0.06440602242946625,
0.6058411598205566,
-0.3897199034690857,
0.5663378834724426,
-0.016039635986089706,
-0.6366519331932068,
-0.519225001335144,
0.7278714179992676,
0.16017824411392212,
0.22647817432880402,
0.6338793039321899,
0.6238267421722412,
-0.45570892095565796,
-0.04940957948565483,
-0.49108585715293884,
-0.4740251302719116,
-0.4159219264984131,
0.2673964500427246,
-0.30614182353019714,
-0.5527569651603699,
0.48246273398399353,
0.11110105365514755,
0.23148611187934875,
0.8306054472923279,
0.3332523703575134,
-0.39273300766944885,
1.1975270509719849,
0.8347735404968262,
0.028447870165109634,
0.4301927089691162,
-0.5082831382751465,
-0.08647967875003815,
-0.7844693660736084,
-0.4166063666343689,
-0.8494096398353577,
-0.4195496439933777,
-0.6326945424079895,
-0.05141124129295349,
-0.19123394787311554,
-0.1805879920721054,
-0.18862305581569672,
-0.043284229934215546,
-0.5397951006889343,
0.479869544506073,
0.6532478928565979,
0.1969262957572937,
0.09673553705215454,
-0.2783080041408539,
-0.1448364108800888,
-0.5626301765441895,
-0.6525696516036987,
-0.8736413717269897,
1.4980477094650269,
0.47128263115882874,
0.22044812142848969,
0.027497297152876854,
0.39837148785591125,
0.9520035982131958,
0.4209616184234619,
-0.5787801742553711,
0.5432803630828857,
-0.203107088804245,
-1.0208497047424316,
-0.18251590430736542,
-0.3107376992702484,
-0.820737898349762,
0.2676425576210022,
-0.3288269639015198,
-0.273940771818161,
0.11282332241535187,
-0.21803268790245056,
0.5004989504814148,
0.5181428790092468,
-0.5582490563392639,
0.8610217571258545,
-0.005505006294697523,
-0.40053483843803406,
0.18057969212532043,
-0.8202943205833435,
0.4613225758075714,
0.03442053869366646,
0.1845475435256958,
-0.0934494286775589,
0.5230672955513,
1.3032292127609253,
-0.052867937833070755,
0.860916793346405,
-0.40416523814201355,
-0.2917717695236206,
0.2252865582704544,
0.1924719214439392,
-0.21908828616142273,
-0.07617011666297913,
-0.28764814138412476,
0.3357070982456207,
-0.09354735165834427,
-0.4563409090042114,
-0.2616390585899353,
0.30223163962364197,
-0.5708532929420471,
-0.31247642636299133,
-0.4754904806613922,
-0.3829202353954315,
0.07454141974449158,
0.10606012493371964,
0.10614778846502304,
0.2589993476867676,
-0.35222962498664856,
-0.41350242495536804,
0.5926560759544373,
-0.4470570683479309,
0.32803967595100403,
0.6138378977775574,
-0.46783292293548584,
0.016643419861793518,
0.5602299571037292,
0.21066232025623322,
0.003913544118404388,
0.17511866986751556,
0.43824222683906555,
-0.44042468070983887,
-0.1499301642179489,
-0.6985015273094177,
-0.09553301334381104,
-0.9965242147445679,
-0.005991377867758274,
-0.6490712761878967,
-0.09511435031890869,
-0.6254395842552185,
-0.2880520522594452,
-0.23883967101573944,
-0.5253034234046936,
-0.23496244847774506,
-0.18276797235012054,
0.04318501427769661,
0.8617599606513977,
0.019931720569729805,
0.5270989537239075,
-0.2279745489358902,
0.11322217434644699,
0.22731241583824158,
0.24636876583099365,
0.16577325761318207,
-0.568691074848175,
0.1503051221370697,
-0.1693202257156372,
-0.48218461871147156,
-0.9317046403884888,
0.432597279548645,
-0.19760854542255402,
0.5370433926582336,
0.5484378337860107,
-0.2502046227455139,
0.033444855362176895,
-0.25000467896461487,
0.9367427229881287,
0.09267900139093399,
-1.30791175365448,
0.9876226186752319,
-0.2804774343967438,
0.08600857108831406,
0.7818280458450317,
0.45763346552848816,
-0.4361826181411743,
-0.6621389985084534,
-0.8086316585540771,
-0.7395956516265869,
0.7276857495307922,
0.1595524400472641,
-0.07029659301042557,
0.24096186459064484,
0.5733041167259216,
0.8071130514144897,
0.5317267179489136,
-0.7284746766090393,
-0.6984472274780273,
0.3104567527770996,
-0.33636948466300964,
0.32961615920066833,
-0.5276164412498474,
-0.11836006492376328,
-0.5879740715026855,
0.7493836283683777,
-0.16497887670993805,
0.21840350329875946,
0.016211412847042084,
-0.33435261249542236,
0.052092257887125015,
0.3806934356689453,
0.585774838924408,
1.06730318069458,
-0.4527195990085602,
0.1283898800611496,
0.4665953516960144,
-0.8140733242034912,
0.16791248321533203,
-0.4359498620033264,
-0.25962281227111816,
0.696027934551239,
0.4785114824771881,
0.446071982383728,
-0.09294293075799942,
-0.6379422545433044,
0.6936429738998413,
-0.29179641604423523,
-0.2614741921424866,
-0.5044346451759338,
-0.015799924731254578,
-0.4275122880935669,
0.1039663702249527,
0.5774974226951599,
0.21849067509174347,
0.7047260999679565,
-0.5414415001869202,
0.24820560216903687,
0.1792963445186615,
-0.7424675226211548,
-0.1462678611278534,
0.6909000873565674,
0.361248254776001,
-0.38476017117500305,
0.41262033581733704,
0.03124493733048439,
-0.7814681529998779,
0.8637850880622864,
0.4500943720340729,
1.2011470794677734,
-0.4181620180606842,
0.19673366844654083,
0.36815083026885986,
0.3945823013782501,
-0.12499755620956421,
0.6258507370948792,
0.1877640336751938,
-0.10611850768327713,
-0.3875582814216614,
-0.3398772180080414,
-0.6556764245033264,
-0.05226002261042595,
-1.0018491744995117,
0.7081756591796875,
-0.19779442250728607,
-0.09225454926490784,
-0.009516172111034393,
-0.039913494139909744,
-0.6770309209823608,
0.2787524461746216,
-0.003623255295678973,
0.7803840637207031,
-1.4268444776535034,
0.3225189745426178,
0.7411751747131348,
0.014385220594704151,
-0.11129003763198853,
-0.22365328669548035,
0.3870713412761688,
-0.46021220088005066,
1.020644187927246,
0.4376427233219147,
-0.13967572152614594,
-0.6101068258285522,
-0.4809894263744354,
-0.08671802282333374,
0.6109103560447693,
0.30774298310279846,
-0.5401953458786011,
0.05806292966008186,
0.23465648293495178,
0.4088185727596283,
-0.39131981134414673,
0.6304266452789307,
0.8583863377571106,
0.7471472024917603,
-0.6203105449676514,
-0.7027411460876465,
-0.38595324754714966,
-0.08976808190345764,
-0.26991012692451477,
-0.0051519740372896194,
-0.0685870572924614,
0.7503365278244019,
0.08954765647649765,
0.18057973682880402,
-0.410706102848053,
0.6617798805236816,
0.22255244851112366,
0.8785666823387146,
0.4562167823314667,
0.2628771662712097,
0.9193960428237915,
-0.37289977073669434,
0.8085484504699707,
0.40175530314445496,
0.25043752789497375,
1.2234101295471191,
-0.14337734878063202,
0.4415949881076813,
0.5074687600135803,
-0.4559696912765503,
0.5242993831634521,
0.6772997975349426,
-0.06883640587329865,
0.156838059425354,
0.7009269595146179,
-0.03514900803565979,
0.15029673278331757,
0.024341627955436707,
-0.46834897994995117,
0.601944625377655,
0.1402553915977478,
-0.5300680994987488,
0.14578555524349213,
0.3542416989803314,
0.22240452468395233,
0.13334420323371887,
-0.4204009771347046,
0.5028330087661743,
0.011573955416679382,
-0.5109281539916992,
-0.18193982541561127,
0.15277093648910522,
0.8650084733963013,
-0.2632732689380646,
-0.22739075124263763,
-0.1972002238035202,
0.19567091763019562,
-0.3126043677330017,
-1.035353183746338,
0.4564216136932373,
0.00836666114628315,
-0.48006901144981384,
-0.2923682928085327,
0.9244550466537476,
-0.44926682114601135,
-0.7367421984672546,
0.20435407757759094,
0.7443720102310181,
0.2494606077671051,
0.06020483374595642,
-0.725907564163208,
-0.11687266826629639,
0.20736034214496613,
0.17158716917037964,
0.22008980810642242,
0.2566455602645874,
-0.13519565761089325,
0.7327362895011902,
0.41144588589668274,
-0.061524830758571625,
0.17830780148506165,
0.32412609457969666,
0.20384928584098816,
-0.7309266924858093,
-0.434133380651474,
-1.1215999126434326,
0.28099775314331055,
-0.341825395822525,
-0.40203729271888733,
0.9056206941604614,
0.9820814728736877,
0.8205663561820984,
-0.4456920027732849,
0.7052622437477112,
0.1804281771183014,
0.6335470080375671,
-0.4612284004688263,
0.8406755924224854,
-0.24316149950027466,
0.39193296432495117,
-0.6028955578804016,
-0.833696186542511,
-0.3230034112930298,
0.7435135841369629,
-0.23002752661705017,
0.029223570600152016,
0.5364311337471008,
0.1337451934814453,
0.1365758776664734,
0.24452967941761017,
0.03968061879277229,
-0.44583290815353394,
0.22513467073440552,
-0.007259103003889322,
1.2728413343429565,
-0.5376420617103577,
-0.1400107741355896,
-0.16849251091480255,
0.015380225144326687,
-0.4323080778121948,
-0.8133140206336975,
-1.2011245489120483,
-0.6218935251235962,
-0.7895788550376892,
-0.5765442848205566,
0.09101945906877518,
0.5352611541748047,
0.47768986225128174,
-0.7293556928634644,
-0.4487958550453186,
0.20948845148086548,
0.8081631064414978,
-0.22868584096431732,
-0.3282291293144226,
0.5171498656272888,
0.05059906840324402,
-0.6700353026390076,
-0.07639127969741821,
-0.06365644186735153,
0.04119246453046799,
-0.6364715099334717,
0.20029659569263458,
-0.18481193482875824,
0.03843403607606888,
0.4755043387413025,
-0.45354902744293213,
-0.3143332004547119,
-0.3851466774940491,
-0.26918265223503113,
0.13971365988254547,
0.13756118714809418,
1.0159809589385986,
-0.4646437466144562,
0.40535274147987366,
0.5871322154998779,
0.2558073401451111,
0.2745027244091034,
-0.6078009009361267,
0.6574217081069946,
-1.0042095184326172,
-0.0161182451993227,
0.2745318114757538,
0.33454909920692444,
0.3487122654914856,
-0.4184490740299225,
0.7937535643577576,
0.08980613946914673,
-0.423065185546875,
-1.0834654569625854,
-0.07331690192222595,
-0.8475689888000488,
-0.6450185179710388,
0.8635244369506836,
-0.06773655116558075,
-0.19423353672027588,
-0.4132766127586365,
-0.6397791504859924,
0.29310286045074463,
-0.08608999848365784,
0.9079716205596924,
1.1181622743606567,
-0.14557071030139923,
0.2504207491874695,
-1.171531319618225,
0.4882507026195526,
0.5393626093864441,
-0.8063161373138428,
-0.07543578743934631,
0.251723051071167,
0.41799283027648926,
-0.018268052488565445,
0.1888916790485382,
-0.28824400901794434,
0.24961772561073303,
-0.17430706322193146,
0.43761304020881653,
0.3306542634963989,
-0.20951354503631592,
-0.6120043992996216,
-0.024067940190434456,
-0.2776281535625458,
-0.2753952741622925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01856v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01856v2
|
Poro 34B and the Blessing of Multilinguality
| 2024-04-02T11:34:12 | 2024-04-24T12:37:23 |
Risto Luukkonen, Jonathan Burdge, Elaine Zosa, Aarne Talman, Ville Komulainen, Väinö Hatanpää, Peter Sarlin, Sampo Pyysalo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The pretraining of state-of-the-art large language models now requires
trillions of words of text, which is orders of magnitude more than available
for the vast majority of languages. While including text in more than one
language is an obvious way to acquire more pretraining data, multilinguality is
often seen as a curse, and most model training efforts continue to focus
near-exclusively on individual large languages. We believe that multilinguality
can be a blessing and that it should be possible to substantially improve over
the capabilities of monolingual models for small languages through multilingual
training. In this study, we introduce Poro 34B, a 34 billion parameter model
trained for 1 trillion tokens of Finnish, English, and programming languages,
and demonstrate that a multilingual training approach can produce a model that
not only substantially advances over the capabilities of existing models for
Finnish, but also excels in translation and is competitive in its class in
generating English and programming languages. We release the model parameters,
scripts, and data under open licenses at
https://huggingface.co/LumiOpen/Poro-34B.
|
[
-0.3037702143192291,
-0.167768657207489,
0.3024347722530365,
0.5952059030532837,
-0.510158360004425,
-0.151789590716362,
-0.6605014204978943,
-0.7035271525382996,
0.0374118871986866,
0.5149528980255127,
-0.23870323598384857,
-0.1203504279255867,
-0.7461662292480469,
0.24203766882419586,
0.19164644181728363,
1.232692003250122,
0.13097073137760162,
0.600736677646637,
0.128226175904274,
0.0004012584686279297,
-0.3662601113319397,
-0.4351886212825775,
-0.6497344970703125,
-0.18822161853313446,
0.7344129681587219,
0.5116698145866394,
0.4509250819683075,
0.38646945357322693,
0.459852010011673,
0.3199279010295868,
0.271793007850647,
0.28959450125694275,
-0.6275448203086853,
-0.2617330551147461,
-0.1083049327135086,
-0.6703847050666809,
-0.42150548100471497,
-0.04493909701704979,
1.094502329826355,
0.7520329356193542,
-0.058063484728336334,
0.27148351073265076,
-0.006882024463266134,
0.5782419443130493,
-0.37427541613578796,
0.3847249150276184,
-0.8597238659858704,
-0.1271931380033493,
-0.5672520995140076,
0.2726459205150604,
-0.476270467042923,
-0.00847409013658762,
0.022194378077983856,
-0.7437113523483276,
0.1166737824678421,
0.0976530909538269,
0.7899154424667358,
0.005152961704879999,
-0.28444525599479675,
-0.35089218616485596,
-0.5424809455871582,
1.0107747316360474,
-0.7164784669876099,
0.737816333770752,
0.3265746235847473,
0.0709657296538353,
0.18148410320281982,
-0.33071964979171753,
-0.31369537115097046,
-0.4135834276676178,
0.2091483771800995,
0.1453448086977005,
0.5734545588493347,
-0.03668186441063881,
0.056506186723709106,
0.3522295355796814,
-0.3199160397052765,
0.35070115327835083,
-0.7633536458015442,
-0.17620167136192322,
0.713294267654419,
-0.09277445822954178,
0.3943265974521637,
-0.2519521117210388,
-0.3267691731452942,
-0.13492481410503387,
-0.6366075277328491,
-0.34009498357772827,
0.7746654152870178,
0.7512568831443787,
-0.1899828463792801,
0.4648442566394806,
0.04935357719659805,
0.8088497519493103,
-0.7043061852455139,
-0.6103394627571106,
0.11329694092273712,
-0.3778412342071533,
-0.01393736433237791,
0.0023860058281570673,
1.0616605281829834,
0.010089285671710968,
0.4939624071121216,
-0.4357307255268097,
0.06110415607690811,
-0.10904034972190857,
0.2882983982563019,
-0.7391265630722046,
0.34089797735214233,
0.0860196202993393,
-0.36007875204086304,
0.13318069279193878,
0.3242202401161194,
-0.8917725086212158,
-0.4065452218055725,
-0.3402651846408844,
0.06738138198852539,
-0.5407731533050537,
-0.4876053035259247,
0.48475098609924316,
-0.1717650592327118,
-0.016214774921536446,
0.3167460262775421,
-1.0663334131240845,
0.14255648851394653,
0.6132199764251709,
0.659256637096405,
-0.026967009529471397,
-1.0426017045974731,
-0.08364592492580414,
0.14614544808864594,
-0.4520443379878998,
0.40813228487968445,
-0.3952251970767975,
-0.3775850534439087,
-0.06792136281728745,
0.03431843966245651,
-0.35762670636177063,
-0.5364906191825867,
0.4450569748878479,
-0.28175628185272217,
-0.009844483807682991,
-0.15252718329429626,
-0.3320280909538269,
0.027953339740633965,
0.049169257283210754,
-0.6086637377738953,
0.9414135217666626,
-0.025235433131456375,
-0.5288075804710388,
0.4443267285823822,
-0.5323747396469116,
-0.33033376932144165,
0.12882566452026367,
-0.06689286977052689,
-0.26215851306915283,
0.42008325457572937,
-0.3020216226577759,
0.29013627767562866,
-0.48373082280158997,
0.2520507574081421,
-0.4785795509815216,
-0.062349386513233185,
-0.13591042160987854,
-0.3323094844818115,
0.5553087592124939,
0.48917752504348755,
-0.06731356680393219,
-0.2069922536611557,
-0.8399630784988403,
-0.09534796327352524,
0.2673172652721405,
-0.5558155179023743,
-0.36331188678741455,
-0.43686559796333313,
0.13001218438148499,
0.30151328444480896,
0.5186156034469604,
-0.7748553156852722,
0.23269109427928925,
-0.587303102016449,
0.17956990003585815,
0.383451372385025,
-0.4600922763347626,
0.45788994431495667,
-0.1474500596523285,
0.6034380197525024,
-0.18490536510944366,
0.19209147989749908,
-0.32325902581214905,
-0.8294650912284851,
-0.5246552228927612,
-0.3625634014606476,
0.2571064531803131,
0.5579938292503357,
-0.22537939250469208,
-0.10638681799173355,
-0.16176532208919525,
-0.7435285449028015,
-0.5916319489479065,
0.4166037440299988,
0.5671994090080261,
0.18275858461856842,
0.1518680602312088,
-0.23361966013908386,
-0.7657515406608582,
-0.8123775720596313,
-0.21073845028877258,
-0.17331279814243317,
0.10622502118349075,
0.38926735520362854,
0.3866676390171051,
-0.06939531117677689,
0.22479715943336487,
-0.22294771671295166,
-0.3604722321033478,
-0.27039259672164917,
0.0909901037812233,
0.27360108494758606,
0.5759868025779724,
0.636033833026886,
-0.7075194716453552,
-0.6549638509750366,
0.5292218923568726,
-0.7272835373878479,
0.21485674381256104,
-0.05181315541267395,
-0.1820438951253891,
-0.08041991293430328,
0.4214312732219696,
-0.5805297493934631,
-0.16862785816192627,
0.5132603049278259,
0.06026124581694603,
0.7932183146476746,
-0.6174601316452026,
0.03249872848391533,
-1.1222217082977295,
0.2348380833864212,
-0.24419313669204712,
-0.032964807003736496,
-0.4675517976284027,
0.28392231464385986,
0.14873360097408295,
-0.5221999287605286,
-0.5846784114837646,
0.849936306476593,
-0.6009724736213684,
0.11292484402656555,
-0.2312232255935669,
-0.02606087550520897,
-0.18106971681118011,
0.16079013049602509,
0.15722471475601196,
0.64273601770401,
0.6888115406036377,
-0.4321526288986206,
0.3311263620853424,
0.2322271764278412,
-0.20051078498363495,
0.20472416281700134,
-0.42318663001060486,
0.09371326863765717,
-0.44535383582115173,
-0.09543009847402573,
-0.6656674146652222,
-0.39770200848579407,
-0.1502314954996109,
-0.2453664243221283,
0.4690569043159485,
-0.19725291430950165,
-0.41855722665786743,
-0.5302045345306396,
-0.16972962021827698,
0.3083041310310364,
0.01695280149579048,
-0.24146468937397003,
0.3921600878238678,
0.38621023297309875,
-0.24072812497615814,
-0.7890176177024841,
-0.7280710935592651,
0.07064960896968842,
-0.27256882190704346,
-0.4968097507953644,
0.20595517754554749,
-0.2104477882385254,
0.11439348757266998,
-0.3134489059448242,
0.1401679962873459,
-0.0712236538529396,
0.09853659570217133,
0.04265867546200752,
0.3499578535556793,
-0.23910363018512726,
0.1988513171672821,
-0.1409384161233902,
-0.03405184671282768,
-0.13396941125392914,
-0.7811594605445862,
0.755326509475708,
-0.41331836581230164,
-0.1586342602968216,
-0.2009173482656479,
0.351616233587265,
0.7378247380256653,
-0.5890117883682251,
1.2572753429412842,
0.5790543556213379,
-0.512350857257843,
-0.04764959588646889,
-0.5596318244934082,
0.1246984526515007,
-0.4107660949230194,
0.5711033940315247,
-0.6355274319648743,
-0.608859658241272,
0.684502124786377,
-0.044004231691360474,
-0.07524341344833374,
0.3292558193206787,
0.6475884914398193,
0.45473936200141907,
0.8087469339370728,
0.7114537954330444,
-0.1740528643131256,
0.7623490691184998,
-0.10680797696113586,
0.12831920385360718,
-0.575284481048584,
-0.4515690505504608,
-0.6144307255744934,
0.17619311809539795,
-0.6566970944404602,
-0.4239727556705475,
0.07861815392971039,
0.38166168332099915,
-0.23791997134685516,
0.4761916697025299,
-0.22014881670475006,
0.46594807505607605,
0.5968559384346008,
0.019691726192831993,
0.13175058364868164,
-0.15544192492961884,
-0.451368123292923,
-0.12814289331436157,
-0.7636046409606934,
-0.6211568117141724,
1.2817468643188477,
0.28630417585372925,
0.7718967795372009,
-0.03728615492582321,
0.9630164504051208,
-0.30704474449157715,
0.47199690341949463,
-0.6833186149597168,
0.19598129391670227,
-0.5386240482330322,
-0.8833256363868713,
-0.5170425772666931,
-0.44802382588386536,
-0.9065334796905518,
0.2635723650455475,
-0.056171827018260956,
-0.8405539989471436,
0.0431046336889267,
0.09828325361013412,
-0.30490946769714355,
0.19135357439517975,
-1.1906845569610596,
1.3092939853668213,
-0.4238209128379822,
-0.3664701282978058,
-0.1506909728050232,
-0.4930877089500427,
0.2690061032772064,
-0.47988444566726685,
0.5617027878761292,
-0.2167125940322876,
-0.09407338500022888,
0.6414612531661987,
-0.2645885646343231,
0.6540351510047913,
-0.1759748011827469,
-0.31383630633354187,
0.0801827609539032,
-0.3399917185306549,
0.472551554441452,
0.43727564811706543,
-0.34924426674842834,
0.1239754855632782,
0.04758094623684883,
-0.5913206338882446,
-0.11652125418186188,
0.6670635938644409,
-0.932281494140625,
-0.3590700030326843,
-0.17939338088035583,
-0.5873860120773315,
-0.39206674695014954,
0.7197229266166687,
0.4460314214229584,
0.14707736670970917,
-0.14444246888160706,
0.09351778030395508,
0.4962088167667389,
-0.38281819224357605,
0.3473692834377289,
0.6175634860992432,
-0.4348008334636688,
-0.47320324182510376,
1.1960042715072632,
0.2263908088207245,
0.36945798993110657,
0.40303635597229004,
0.25713810324668884,
-0.3483263850212097,
-0.5246480107307434,
-0.5579763650894165,
0.7929510474205017,
-0.4254603981971741,
-0.004697844386100769,
-0.4922519624233246,
-0.0401974655687809,
-0.6498174071311951,
0.17273198068141937,
-0.9899095892906189,
-0.18025848269462585,
-0.11433754116296768,
0.023790890350937843,
-0.09038785845041275,
0.7307408452033997,
-0.1884802281856537,
0.4256731867790222,
-0.9409739971160889,
0.26408103108406067,
0.28987976908683777,
0.6008043885231018,
0.0328264981508255,
-0.32306233048439026,
-0.5989614129066467,
0.10799520462751389,
-0.14878563582897186,
-0.8632374405860901,
0.19628986716270447,
0.5149920582771301,
0.7030498385429382,
0.5253159403800964,
-0.3086163401603699,
0.5477480888366699,
-0.9140182137489319,
0.4737432301044464,
0.45762985944747925,
-0.8379198312759399,
0.5135772824287415,
-0.523936927318573,
0.2407556176185608,
0.44318804144859314,
0.6499333381652832,
-0.7272798418998718,
-0.6003015637397766,
-0.5682196021080017,
-0.6020469665527344,
0.9453590512275696,
-0.22918444871902466,
0.44094160199165344,
-0.012447874061763287,
0.22534316778182983,
0.4513918459415436,
0.5042914152145386,
-0.933175802230835,
-0.09196533262729645,
-0.4688747823238373,
-0.1960708200931549,
-0.2722843289375305,
-0.18063010275363922,
0.11646280437707901,
-0.024784252047538757,
0.8157893419265747,
-0.2666902542114258,
0.14354771375656128,
-0.14703035354614258,
-0.05606354773044586,
0.09980721026659012,
0.19357076287269592,
0.5380175113677979,
0.8292344212532043,
-0.1082386001944542,
0.04294509440660477,
0.1761283576488495,
-0.587152361869812,
-0.03414837643504143,
0.4222392439842224,
0.10417275875806808,
-0.12767939269542694,
0.20211635529994965,
1.0336732864379883,
0.1940154880285263,
-0.6933740377426147,
0.11610890179872513,
0.02517138235270977,
0.1674133539199829,
0.024446306750178337,
-0.14247843623161316,
0.3164590895175934,
-0.06755427271127701,
0.29171884059906006,
-0.05672841891646385,
-0.07557081431150436,
-0.6012040376663208,
0.0037078068125993013,
0.4081633687019348,
-0.23841749131679535,
-0.4427725672721863,
0.8053041696548462,
0.06770452111959457,
-0.10798884183168411,
0.318656861782074,
-0.36220499873161316,
-0.47208699584007263,
0.4850035607814789,
0.8179263472557068,
0.2660474181175232,
-0.5153133869171143,
0.4387277066707611,
0.7266114354133606,
0.6097491383552551,
-0.38685956597328186,
0.37451258301734924,
0.1912173330783844,
-0.9351866841316223,
-0.4123189449310303,
-1.0567541122436523,
-0.423030287027359,
0.2639227509498596,
-0.5545077323913574,
0.4288231134414673,
-0.2901570796966553,
-0.1930282711982727,
0.16959813237190247,
0.005495712626725435,
-0.7731007933616638,
0.4430486857891083,
0.6073428392410278,
0.7326883673667908,
-0.9029964208602905,
0.9941367506980896,
0.9859676361083984,
-0.5060312747955322,
-0.7957956790924072,
-0.5147868990898132,
-0.304654985666275,
-0.8363335728645325,
0.4100905656814575,
0.36347535252571106,
0.26042115688323975,
0.07778972387313843,
-0.16335277259349823,
-0.9440919160842896,
0.4414890706539154,
1.0606614351272583,
-0.5904930233955383,
-0.07492987811565399,
0.5205658674240112,
0.4940575957298279,
-0.2640777826309204,
0.13053618371486664,
0.17495912313461304,
0.540734052658081,
-0.33760127425193787,
-1.2487401962280273,
-0.3646639883518219,
-0.21227779984474182,
0.19407448172569275,
0.2543824315071106,
-0.9614573121070862,
0.8110687136650085,
-0.28109094500541687,
0.0183038879185915,
0.1090373769402504,
0.47642600536346436,
0.26664963364601135,
-0.0223652645945549,
0.2175024449825287,
0.43646109104156494,
1.0206191539764404,
-0.01508064940571785,
1.2502408027648926,
-0.5142947435379028,
0.5092918872833252,
1.1762058734893799,
-0.009480923414230347,
0.684897780418396,
0.4819735288619995,
-0.38085633516311646,
0.24635912477970123,
0.5919753313064575,
0.16614635288715363,
0.38335296511650085,
0.15646149218082428,
-0.2969978451728821,
-0.3403272032737732,
-0.3704059422016144,
-0.5479204654693604,
0.4943314492702484,
0.22390620410442352,
-0.156691774725914,
-0.17906148731708527,
0.6059603095054626,
0.24833427369594574,
-0.04490220174193382,
-0.25714531540870667,
0.4212549030780792,
0.32440540194511414,
-0.858937680721283,
0.4582606554031372,
0.11355435103178024,
0.6174495220184326,
-1.0953283309936523,
0.3934490382671356,
-0.21300119161605835,
0.44198352098464966,
-0.012751180678606033,
-0.28392162919044495,
0.2849411070346832,
0.003799761412665248,
-0.21273495256900787,
-0.435720294713974,
0.5136513113975525,
-0.550395131111145,
-0.8246113061904907,
0.5820447206497192,
0.5465521812438965,
0.3384041488170624,
-0.23431597650051117,
-0.6089236736297607,
0.023426078259944916,
-0.19811058044433594,
0.035461779683828354,
0.3145975172519684,
0.5728880167007446,
0.11803893744945526,
0.43464550375938416,
0.5920963287353516,
0.5362715125083923,
0.5610135793685913,
0.2409384548664093,
0.5391808748245239,
-0.31927207112312317,
-0.6405601501464844,
-0.7062557339668274,
0.34119459986686707,
-0.010255999863147736,
-0.6790810823440552,
0.9271553158760071,
0.6826286315917969,
1.2006169557571411,
-0.524154782295227,
0.6675872206687927,
-0.07190404087305069,
0.2979883551597595,
-0.3214204013347626,
0.6979222297668457,
-0.8073089122772217,
-0.08797819912433624,
-0.1911827176809311,
-0.918333888053894,
-0.20512638986110687,
0.42804333567619324,
-0.2827487289905548,
0.08571906387805939,
0.6743183732032776,
0.5848146677017212,
0.016881830990314484,
-0.004471682943403721,
0.32055947184562683,
0.033044103533029556,
0.004306131973862648,
0.4917812645435333,
0.7831512093544006,
-0.47095510363578796,
0.5484785437583923,
-0.2040349692106247,
-0.3471677303314209,
0.12116259336471558,
-0.7668788433074951,
-0.6919650435447693,
-0.4700239598751068,
0.03260188549757004,
-0.03328584507107735,
-0.03682539984583855,
0.7273247838020325,
1.0029610395431519,
-0.9428966045379639,
-0.6376940011978149,
-0.23834475874900818,
0.13247741758823395,
-0.0998755544424057,
-0.07639206200838089,
-0.14673854410648346,
-0.7761213779449463,
-1.0029559135437012,
0.49908724427223206,
0.20747089385986328,
0.16095323860645294,
-0.24507638812065125,
-0.25950971245765686,
-0.27469363808631897,
0.10684820264577866,
0.432844340801239,
0.3881039321422577,
-0.513508677482605,
0.17478524148464203,
0.0406675785779953,
-0.06920886784791946,
0.05627230927348137,
0.78384929895401,
-0.2526865601539612,
0.6542108654975891,
0.2995728552341461,
0.5376179218292236,
0.7318565249443054,
-0.46211546659469604,
0.7363261580467224,
-0.8457345366477966,
0.6584846377372742,
-0.13369625806808472,
0.503804624080658,
0.4856845438480377,
-0.31237128376960754,
0.3841703534126282,
0.3392447829246521,
-0.36699843406677246,
-0.8840100169181824,
0.09940839558839798,
-0.6120499968528748,
-0.22716452181339264,
1.0153908729553223,
-0.383131742477417,
-0.18503466248512268,
0.19393357634544373,
-0.3730096220970154,
0.3585580587387085,
-0.19639575481414795,
0.7034056782722473,
1.0379799604415894,
0.3034361004829407,
-0.004095531068742275,
-0.6977621912956238,
0.44059380888938904,
0.5243821144104004,
-0.9847734570503235,
0.053808003664016724,
0.10847730934619904,
0.09092982113361359,
0.5545887351036072,
0.6136723160743713,
-0.17868468165397644,
0.12309718877077103,
0.2731556296348572,
-0.007589933928102255,
-0.0042557851411402225,
-0.7525800466537476,
-0.0056921811774373055,
0.10051537305116653,
0.3825065493583679,
-0.09105247259140015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01854v1
|
IndoCulture: Exploring Geographically-Influenced Cultural Commonsense Reasoning Across Eleven Indonesian Provinces
| 2024-04-02T11:32:58 | 2024-04-02T11:32:58 |
Fajri Koto, Rahmad Mahendra, Nurul Aisyah, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although commonsense reasoning is greatly shaped by cultural and geographical
factors, previous studies on language models have predominantly centered on
English cultures, potentially resulting in an Anglocentric bias. In this paper,
we introduce IndoCulture, aimed at understanding the influence of geographical
factors on language model reasoning ability, with a specific emphasis on the
diverse cultures found within eleven Indonesian provinces. In contrast to prior
works that relied on templates (Yin et al., 2022) and online scrapping (Fung et
al., 2024), we created IndoCulture by asking local people to manually develop
the context and plausible options based on predefined topics. Evaluations of 23
language models reveal several insights: (1) even the best open-source model
struggles with an accuracy of 53.2%, (2) models often provide more accurate
predictions for specific provinces, such as Bali and West Java, and (3) the
inclusion of location contexts enhances performance, especially in larger
models like GPT-4, emphasizing the significance of geographical context in
commonsense reasoning.
|
[
-0.42063021659851074,
-0.40129154920578003,
0.5484157800674438,
0.3267954885959625,
-0.07634793221950531,
-0.58375483751297,
-0.47715115547180176,
-0.4850306212902069,
0.21707282960414886,
0.565785825252533,
-0.30822890996932983,
-0.5611437559127808,
-0.2664102017879486,
0.5418720245361328,
0.34580954909324646,
0.48164796829223633,
-0.02904687076807022,
-0.14126436412334442,
-0.20888285338878632,
-0.5676437616348267,
-0.374440997838974,
-0.47325876355171204,
-0.019199121743440628,
-0.17366720736026764,
0.14494779706001282,
0.6676581501960754,
0.4405912458896637,
0.6563003063201904,
0.2700175642967224,
0.3213769197463989,
-0.30193158984184265,
0.18302546441555023,
-0.09921552985906601,
0.09699420630931854,
-0.5619152784347534,
-0.5955461859703064,
0.051416389644145966,
0.02774607203900814,
0.051465194672346115,
0.6846070885658264,
-0.10934989899396896,
0.19610153138637543,
-0.10798940062522888,
0.34746724367141724,
-0.6832948327064514,
0.19439612329006195,
-0.49502867460250854,
-0.16993080079555511,
-0.21454021334648132,
-0.09981150925159454,
-0.3800049424171448,
-0.5799986720085144,
0.4071318507194519,
-0.7804254293441772,
-0.12221280485391617,
-0.006346553098410368,
0.6827508807182312,
0.061303772032260895,
-0.9190778136253357,
-0.17829665541648865,
-0.7576658725738525,
0.9100236892700195,
-0.5101155638694763,
0.18849818408489227,
0.8020225167274475,
0.3387882709503174,
0.20121122896671295,
-0.5926121473312378,
-0.5323878526687622,
0.11015792191028595,
-0.2774631977081299,
0.1955086588859558,
0.0005034830537624657,
-0.1675768792629242,
0.22944287955760956,
0.1629515141248703,
-0.5176615118980408,
-0.05294734239578247,
-0.6946977972984314,
0.10839441418647766,
0.6756111979484558,
-0.11105051636695862,
0.6520577669143677,
-0.6651991009712219,
-0.33791640400886536,
0.08435831218957901,
-0.9291099905967712,
0.20847110450267792,
0.424656480550766,
0.20749066770076752,
-0.15111497044563293,
0.3839651644229889,
-0.3965098261833191,
0.6060907244682312,
-0.2927015423774719,
-0.31274744868278503,
0.04467427358031273,
-0.20340049266815186,
0.010125680826604366,
-0.05215618759393692,
0.32741162180900574,
0.6023220419883728,
0.5470301508903503,
0.3696160614490509,
-0.07010873407125473,
0.049695152789354324,
-0.13300803303718567,
-0.2909937798976898,
-0.415885865688324,
0.23932835459709167,
-0.6738033294677734,
-0.19970224797725677,
-0.15196821093559265,
-0.40244200825691223,
-0.2643461227416992,
-0.3942570090293884,
-0.05773378908634186,
-0.38897815346717834,
-0.6800058484077454,
-0.19598250091075897,
-0.383938193321228,
0.3421539068222046,
0.12729251384735107,
-1.0555022954940796,
-0.2431156486272812,
0.7535504698753357,
0.7080517411231995,
-0.08798035979270935,
-0.4207248091697693,
0.228238046169281,
0.2262759506702423,
-0.4321347177028656,
0.9731802344322205,
-0.9974946975708008,
-0.35121166706085205,
0.12960337102413177,
-0.02574637532234192,
0.0380915068089962,
-0.5978550314903259,
0.6732602119445801,
-0.37491294741630554,
0.39019471406936646,
-0.709682822227478,
-0.07474002242088318,
-0.6917015314102173,
0.3906290531158447,
-0.6274524927139282,
0.8496211171150208,
-0.035791411995887756,
-0.700448751449585,
0.8498334884643555,
-0.7381114363670349,
-0.5740838646888733,
0.2732275724411011,
-0.06140470877289772,
0.32150983810424805,
0.15393349528312683,
0.6801798939704895,
0.2918855547904968,
-0.10815958678722382,
0.44901442527770996,
-0.48069629073143005,
-0.32290321588516235,
0.13313885033130646,
-0.5477533936500549,
1.3006725311279297,
0.6360474824905396,
-0.19961225986480713,
0.0247522983700037,
-0.6688957810401917,
-0.37881729006767273,
-0.004954394418746233,
-0.04357604682445526,
-1.2881848812103271,
-0.03676250949501991,
-0.015235017985105515,
0.13366730511188507,
-0.14265112578868866,
-0.4699881374835968,
0.37628239393234253,
-0.36419999599456787,
0.646932065486908,
0.5155906677246094,
0.12416481226682663,
0.5398954749107361,
-0.3410601317882538,
0.5022072792053223,
-0.03296230733394623,
0.253290593624115,
-0.31697773933410645,
-0.7884919047355652,
-0.21791401505470276,
-0.3225158751010895,
-0.07388600707054138,
0.50190669298172,
-0.8916472792625427,
-0.15252895653247833,
-0.2861054241657257,
-0.699411153793335,
-0.31838881969451904,
-0.11543266475200653,
-0.10663040727376938,
0.4252634048461914,
0.09811277687549591,
-0.4004705250263214,
-0.4323946535587311,
-0.9986330270767212,
-0.422739714384079,
-0.31985852122306824,
-0.1956297606229782,
0.5566875338554382,
0.503618061542511,
0.014193707145750523,
1.037912130355835,
-0.4952130913734436,
-0.18839655816555023,
-0.3487425148487091,
0.06752540916204453,
0.26787474751472473,
0.18814419209957123,
0.7071268558502197,
-0.9975441098213196,
-0.4949894845485687,
-0.07559080421924591,
-0.6543238759040833,
-0.3373940885066986,
0.2782773971557617,
-0.081566222012043,
0.36412733793258667,
0.13893793523311615,
-0.4707447290420532,
0.3863144516944885,
0.59691321849823,
-0.2688768208026886,
0.47323793172836304,
-0.23272614181041718,
0.3111122250556946,
-1.2117500305175781,
0.10797025263309479,
0.1780078113079071,
0.3638301491737366,
-0.35970282554626465,
0.3269699513912201,
0.0467790849506855,
-0.22982294857501984,
-0.5302448272705078,
0.629592776298523,
-0.3667861223220825,
0.09254270046949387,
0.08682411909103394,
-0.06323052942752838,
0.04690030217170715,
0.3467501401901245,
0.6824951767921448,
0.8865414261817932,
0.29294878244400024,
-0.314409077167511,
0.08192150294780731,
0.10929340869188309,
-0.7863482236862183,
0.8741084337234497,
-0.44818106293678284,
-0.30154141783714294,
-0.22892482578754425,
0.44887465238571167,
-1.0499552488327026,
-0.6545045375823975,
0.09247426688671112,
-0.13736535608768463,
-0.4175816774368286,
-0.5070077776908875,
-0.30898287892341614,
-0.2456521838903427,
0.13077454268932343,
0.6290985345840454,
0.47542697191238403,
-0.7312446236610413,
0.7179543375968933,
0.431550532579422,
-0.2633609473705292,
-0.5388415455818176,
-0.8674256801605225,
-0.16683444380760193,
-0.7655251622200012,
-0.7577576637268066,
-0.2878790497779846,
0.2747081220149994,
-0.7476085424423218,
-0.06511806696653366,
0.1682782769203186,
-0.2574957609176636,
0.16474327445030212,
0.15620413422584534,
0.013125553727149963,
-0.2663501799106598,
0.031186239793896675,
-0.008369038812816143,
0.25457826256752014,
0.15902197360992432,
-0.6626005172729492,
0.061623647809028625,
-0.053929928690195084,
-0.2359517514705658,
-0.19273974001407623,
0.3438577950000763,
0.6839373111724854,
-0.6629951596260071,
0.5448727607727051,
0.20043636858463287,
-0.2739919126033783,
-0.2285774201154709,
-0.5327420830726624,
-0.26038432121276855,
-0.4857621192932129,
0.04326055198907852,
-0.36730194091796875,
-0.6202273964881897,
0.6895876526832581,
-0.1370498538017273,
-0.07993543893098831,
0.4403473138809204,
0.36706095933914185,
0.14886876940727234,
0.6676731109619141,
0.6226713061332703,
0.2618795931339264,
0.06311430782079697,
-0.05558299273252487,
0.38998499512672424,
-0.5053294897079468,
-0.023169009014964104,
-0.4377046227455139,
-0.1655578315258026,
-1.0407694578170776,
-0.5075477361679077,
0.46722936630249023,
-0.418815553188324,
-0.42107146978378296,
0.1759188324213028,
-0.5006093382835388,
0.9447836875915527,
0.6554766297340393,
-0.31746819615364075,
0.3736797571182251,
0.0822630226612091,
-0.48763206601142883,
-0.13772039115428925,
-0.9770189523696899,
-0.6645644903182983,
1.0187233686447144,
0.20004956424236298,
0.6158345937728882,
0.493240624666214,
0.4397520422935486,
-0.14150549471378326,
0.6679322123527527,
-0.16706252098083496,
0.2698150873184204,
-0.31046873331069946,
-0.9983417391777039,
-0.15733332931995392,
-0.08187005668878555,
-0.738907516002655,
0.2751421630382538,
0.2405802458524704,
-0.8193117380142212,
0.44090232253074646,
0.016744030639529228,
-0.378047913312912,
0.4041820764541626,
-0.9367486834526062,
0.722327470779419,
-0.02960733324289322,
-0.5057035088539124,
0.021279361099004745,
-0.655021607875824,
0.7653293013572693,
0.3437800407409668,
0.5584090948104858,
-0.11466025561094284,
0.3433478772640228,
0.3612395226955414,
-0.032536957412958145,
1.038077473640442,
-0.18753400444984436,
-0.2562016546726227,
0.5834086537361145,
0.2009027600288391,
0.060019347816705704,
0.12732669711112976,
-0.1085064634680748,
0.2889147698879242,
0.27558302879333496,
-0.35536518692970276,
-0.4450317621231079,
0.9400756359100342,
-0.9092479348182678,
-0.6510559916496277,
-0.29931849241256714,
-0.5963758230209351,
-0.056316930800676346,
0.2518731951713562,
0.24719929695129395,
0.6114814281463623,
0.2503102123737335,
0.18805500864982605,
0.6267356276512146,
-0.5739665031433105,
0.17960375547409058,
0.3643982410430908,
-0.1680050790309906,
-0.2996496856212616,
0.8298169374465942,
0.41420331597328186,
0.14929716289043427,
0.35252711176872253,
0.32896775007247925,
-0.5347298383712769,
0.11729230731725693,
-0.28140729665756226,
0.08324006199836731,
-1.2422367334365845,
0.19119928777217865,
-0.41529276967048645,
0.270806223154068,
-0.5390135645866394,
-0.43341517448425293,
-0.1501278430223465,
-0.40785813331604004,
0.34608006477355957,
-0.1393943727016449,
0.2520272433757782,
0.8713562488555908,
-0.29867881536483765,
0.09631599485874176,
-0.4473661482334137,
-0.2564631700515747,
0.41369616985321045,
0.5323726534843445,
0.04347393289208412,
-0.14962099492549896,
0.28904879093170166,
-0.20407406985759735,
0.004365276079624891,
-1.0040613412857056,
0.36521419882774353,
-0.28402525186538696,
0.3924959599971771,
0.5710496306419373,
0.3277643024921417,
0.5335345268249512,
-0.16163823008537292,
1.069933295249939,
-0.5224611759185791,
-0.5194931030273438,
0.5976640582084656,
-0.5645714998245239,
0.6043190360069275,
0.36743637919425964,
0.7863175868988037,
-0.7747678160667419,
-0.37309709191322327,
-0.4623667895793915,
-0.956831157207489,
0.24655939638614655,
-0.1669253706932068,
0.3909249007701874,
-0.20516766607761383,
0.07548322528600693,
0.3161817491054535,
-0.23997345566749573,
-0.8030877709388733,
-0.056439079344272614,
-0.29530438780784607,
0.10185147821903229,
0.013807994313538074,
-0.26184406876564026,
-0.28069597482681274,
-0.34101730585098267,
0.44372376799583435,
-0.08788293600082397,
-0.11795205622911453,
0.2702004611492157,
-0.11337651312351227,
-0.00145230651833117,
0.31715309619903564,
0.8175989389419556,
1.147727131843567,
-0.023873263970017433,
0.2345062643289566,
0.3247832655906677,
-0.21238426864147186,
0.08015219122171402,
-0.013808929361402988,
-0.3465425968170166,
-0.12422802299261093,
0.3335154354572296,
0.5600664615631104,
0.08750920742750168,
-0.3665105402469635,
0.31681764125823975,
-0.25703465938568115,
0.07368216663599014,
-0.6231440901756287,
-0.12465710192918777,
0.03230610862374306,
0.2083306759595871,
0.4867478311061859,
0.0003501524042803794,
0.05524077266454697,
-0.35785239934921265,
0.04704529419541359,
-0.03628511354327202,
-0.026297440752387047,
-0.2387305498123169,
0.8655619025230408,
0.47504743933677673,
0.14219239354133606,
0.8524694442749023,
-0.21374022960662842,
-0.6397100687026978,
0.581946611404419,
0.3660241365432739,
0.6146746277809143,
-0.22352755069732666,
0.18082356452941895,
0.7343857884407043,
0.4965762794017792,
0.1695709526538849,
0.17897836863994598,
-0.24330687522888184,
-0.6808992624282837,
-0.8279770016670227,
-0.4431932866573334,
-0.36334940791130066,
0.056900203227996826,
-0.3170865476131439,
0.30025508999824524,
-0.1342979073524475,
0.13435886800289154,
-0.43184390664100647,
-0.1459081768989563,
-0.7037750482559204,
0.2843778729438782,
0.25389933586120605,
1.2866594791412354,
-1.478192687034607,
0.7307443618774414,
1.1104170083999634,
-0.29176241159439087,
-1.0686297416687012,
0.25486743450164795,
0.3625996708869934,
-0.5554553866386414,
0.8122264742851257,
0.3530869483947754,
0.193970188498497,
-0.30775269865989685,
-0.6553925275802612,
-1.078212022781372,
0.8202195167541504,
-0.25087472796440125,
-0.16657696664333344,
0.3494185209274292,
-0.130870521068573,
0.5228583216667175,
-0.22399578988552094,
0.5285854339599609,
0.5249226689338684,
0.5048415064811707,
0.00044536590576171875,
-0.8724529147148132,
-0.10515783727169037,
-0.4073212146759033,
0.25466349720954895,
-0.15108470618724823,
-0.5759648680686951,
0.6241081357002258,
-0.13709834218025208,
-0.05589795857667923,
-0.11940774321556091,
0.7783875465393066,
0.6276134848594666,
0.25456878542900085,
0.2774810194969177,
0.45234864950180054,
0.5799747109413147,
-0.17124824225902557,
1.180662751197815,
-0.48521944880485535,
0.02032950520515442,
0.8046354055404663,
-0.3624576926231384,
0.775344967842102,
0.41561564803123474,
-0.0025323028676211834,
0.6853891611099243,
0.7936006188392639,
0.22154811024665833,
0.5784268975257874,
-0.0321749784052372,
-0.24371567368507385,
-0.14047150313854218,
-0.44843271374702454,
-0.23961520195007324,
1.1467390060424805,
0.3557046949863434,
-0.03921370580792427,
-0.2056593894958496,
0.07399505376815796,
0.19058382511138916,
0.20799461007118225,
-0.15141063928604126,
0.437420129776001,
-0.19776447117328644,
-1.2238025665283203,
0.2522788941860199,
0.09710296988487244,
0.6187347173690796,
-0.4769638478755951,
-0.09468764066696167,
-0.6843315362930298,
0.006635367404669523,
-0.07728586345911026,
-0.9190494418144226,
0.4731658399105072,
-0.10859920084476471,
0.07887891680002213,
-0.3668345808982849,
0.8968166708946228,
-0.520603358745575,
-0.18302683532238007,
-0.2657855451107025,
0.22662289440631866,
0.2011389136314392,
0.18490639328956604,
-0.0882657915353775,
0.06852909922599792,
-0.05147861689329147,
-0.1822637915611267,
-0.029622327536344528,
0.8145769238471985,
-0.6410051584243774,
0.5612010955810547,
0.6365697383880615,
0.091703861951828,
-0.3324356973171234,
-0.3652362525463104,
0.22216786444187164,
-0.2917109727859497,
-0.8337529301643372,
-0.5949265956878662,
0.40500763058662415,
-0.16357657313346863,
-0.6165741086006165,
0.8823114037513733,
0.26250144839286804,
1.3074860572814941,
-0.18384748697280884,
1.0408610105514526,
-0.2423991858959198,
0.26749545335769653,
-0.15880194306373596,
0.9209765791893005,
-0.5192325711250305,
0.21124112606048584,
-0.11133071780204773,
-0.8551389575004578,
-0.39552566409111023,
0.7244004011154175,
-1.1192336082458496,
0.13619504868984222,
0.37245500087738037,
0.7358369827270508,
-0.2890344262123108,
0.4712711274623871,
0.11271501332521439,
0.19437238574028015,
0.23379255831241608,
0.30070045590400696,
0.9413732886314392,
0.3118986487388611,
0.19115488231182098,
-0.8501637578010559,
-0.29815760254859924,
-0.0014672676334157586,
-1.1362755298614502,
-0.5324996113777161,
-0.8039329648017883,
-0.14697234332561493,
0.010134045965969563,
-0.15661203861236572,
1.0870471000671387,
0.5936310887336731,
-0.6651248335838318,
-0.25909680128097534,
0.34674426913261414,
0.1466177999973297,
-0.24967598915100098,
-0.24659579992294312,
0.33834436535835266,
-0.006329159718006849,
-0.638699471950531,
0.07856843620538712,
0.42514315247535706,
-0.33897170424461365,
-0.28016772866249084,
0.1420833319425583,
-0.2295542061328888,
0.1436905711889267,
0.7486169338226318,
0.35252389311790466,
-0.871724009513855,
-0.37078335881233215,
0.019840087741613388,
-0.15305782854557037,
-0.17621837556362152,
0.7323552966117859,
-0.524834930896759,
0.7550957202911377,
0.5866832137107849,
0.294811874628067,
-0.15374301373958588,
0.06640341132879257,
0.7734358310699463,
-0.6644075512886047,
0.39092907309532166,
-0.019112102687358856,
0.2818831503391266,
0.6613423228263855,
-0.020989907905459404,
0.644012451171875,
0.5392621755599976,
-0.6789038181304932,
-0.5026043057441711,
0.2603731155395508,
-0.2283514440059662,
-0.5525467991828918,
1.460708498954773,
-0.050664544105529785,
-0.4860444664955139,
-0.1714639961719513,
-0.19266395270824432,
-0.07556095719337463,
0.16478322446346283,
0.9157068133354187,
0.8443233370780945,
0.1348530799150467,
-0.17978201806545258,
-0.7643077969551086,
0.4274962842464447,
0.6356462836265564,
-0.3624792993068695,
-0.013441416434943676,
0.5348013043403625,
0.5297152996063232,
0.08875235170125961,
0.4401954412460327,
0.05498362332582474,
0.3193739950656891,
-0.1528242975473404,
-0.14191967248916626,
0.21704895794391632,
-0.300637811422348,
-0.09544360637664795,
0.15016186237335205,
0.17805984616279602,
0.24665993452072144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01822v1
|
A (More) Realistic Evaluation Setup for Generalisation of Community Models on Malicious Content Detection
| 2024-04-02T10:32:21 | 2024-04-02T10:32:21 |
Ivo Verhoeven, Pushkar Mishra, Rahel Beloch, Helen Yannakoudakis, Ekaterina Shutova
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Community models for malicious content detection, which take into account the
context from a social graph alongside the content itself, have shown remarkable
performance on benchmark datasets. Yet, misinformation and hate speech continue
to propagate on social media networks. This mismatch can be partially
attributed to the limitations of current evaluation setups that neglect the
rapid evolution of online content and the underlying social graph. In this
paper, we propose a novel evaluation setup for model generalisation based on
our few-shot subgraph sampling approach. This setup tests for generalisation
through few labelled examples in local explorations of a larger graph,
emulating more realistic application settings. We show this to be a challenging
inductive setup, wherein strong performance on the training graph is not
indicative of performance on unseen tasks, domains, or graph structures.
Lastly, we show that graph meta-learners trained with our proposed few-shot
subgraph sampling outperform standard community models in the inductive setup.
We make our code publicly available.
|
[
-0.22423405945301056,
-0.6534175276756287,
0.1887635588645935,
-0.4152927100658417,
-0.3697979152202606,
0.06716641038656235,
-0.13776962459087372,
-0.18275244534015656,
0.3318297564983368,
0.4376063048839569,
-0.6221137046813965,
-0.7439271807670593,
-0.7864079475402832,
0.012229342013597488,
-0.534127414226532,
0.9435628056526184,
0.5665821433067322,
-0.39040589332580566,
-0.07763075083494186,
-0.332732230424881,
-0.24649471044540405,
-0.27300700545310974,
-0.8058530688285828,
-0.1833740472793579,
0.511020302772522,
0.26795855164527893,
0.4610084593296051,
0.25843170285224915,
0.613418459892273,
0.18287596106529236,
0.10834288597106934,
0.3323638141155243,
-0.9341599345207214,
-0.24065092206001282,
-0.4023558497428894,
-0.15219196677207947,
0.016292518004775047,
0.09439894556999207,
0.32309263944625854,
0.4020780622959137,
-0.11438880860805511,
0.15634627640247345,
0.0024582170881330967,
0.25346285104751587,
-0.9177557826042175,
-0.15382403135299683,
-0.942201554775238,
-0.0737830102443695,
-0.023459725081920624,
0.042988914996385574,
-0.636294960975647,
-0.2703205943107605,
-0.0581078827381134,
-0.6549177765846252,
0.5636796951293945,
-0.06012151762843132,
0.5370485782623291,
-0.1386748105287552,
-0.2975591719150543,
-0.2225343883037567,
-0.7574406266212463,
0.4797576069831848,
-0.6555057764053345,
0.07429101318120956,
0.3226482570171356,
0.8496139645576477,
-0.2941167950630188,
-1.0432311296463013,
-0.46897387504577637,
-0.017250653356313705,
-0.0065732551738619804,
0.020525000989437103,
-0.6835444569587708,
0.016677284613251686,
0.1408883035182953,
0.05009591951966286,
-0.5330902338027954,
0.1160195916891098,
-0.6520233750343323,
-0.3444054424762726,
0.5630184412002563,
0.32083773612976074,
0.07283467054367065,
-0.38762012124061584,
-0.16855651140213013,
0.014968876726925373,
-0.6168287992477417,
0.042353853583335876,
0.7137001752853394,
0.7581624984741211,
-0.1382942646741867,
0.27726900577545166,
-0.17669780552387238,
0.5989131331443787,
0.04083661735057831,
-0.28765401244163513,
0.23031644523143768,
-0.35652807354927063,
-0.2400403618812561,
-0.4892520308494568,
0.7818964719772339,
0.5257744193077087,
0.4360600709915161,
0.13777007162570953,
-0.005960158538073301,
0.30777841806411743,
0.5192802548408508,
-0.739447832107544,
-0.7194682955741882,
0.021976947784423828,
-0.6591398119926453,
-0.7017045617103577,
0.077241912484169,
-0.7289571762084961,
-0.7238383889198303,
0.2997778058052063,
0.1475706696510315,
-0.4009498059749603,
-0.4714164137840271,
0.13680396974086761,
-0.4441274404525757,
-0.17050611972808838,
0.3495500087738037,
-0.5399246215820312,
0.5605982542037964,
0.5955967307090759,
0.6749204993247986,
-0.09902460873126984,
-0.04511474072933197,
-0.5987920165061951,
0.04802439361810684,
-0.143875390291214,
0.8711060285568237,
-0.983187198638916,
-0.19704514741897583,
0.157159686088562,
-0.08483780920505524,
-0.009504205547273159,
-0.6844180822372437,
0.3181435465812683,
-0.675165593624115,
-0.3002645969390869,
-0.05981718376278877,
-0.31737732887268066,
-0.07900728285312653,
0.5177561044692993,
-0.6582645177841187,
0.911773681640625,
0.5123812556266785,
-0.8834275007247925,
0.5422726273536682,
-0.4186515808105469,
-0.38521769642829895,
0.14583720266819,
0.10291954129934311,
-0.5213290452957153,
-0.07241299748420715,
0.24120189249515533,
0.4378642737865448,
0.10807538777589798,
-0.09436745196580887,
-0.8015121221542358,
-0.5958796143531799,
-0.005743151064962149,
-0.2818831205368042,
0.6969335675239563,
0.3182540535926819,
-0.14841027557849884,
-0.06672583520412445,
-0.5081758499145508,
-0.2630656957626343,
0.10400639474391937,
-0.12375875562429428,
-0.597244918346405,
0.017471885308623314,
-0.14739607274532318,
0.009445484727621078,
-0.3192000687122345,
-0.6857057809829712,
0.15780381858348846,
-0.16884681582450867,
0.48027732968330383,
0.620960533618927,
0.4164799153804779,
0.20615220069885254,
-0.23746232688426971,
0.702136754989624,
0.23629365861415863,
0.49566471576690674,
-0.16148193180561066,
-0.5630663633346558,
-0.3608992099761963,
-0.20526161789894104,
0.3225425183773041,
0.35177919268608093,
-0.9138177037239075,
0.10180193185806274,
-0.31446683406829834,
-0.49596211314201355,
-0.36257198452949524,
0.3131067156791687,
0.49748390913009644,
0.2986205816268921,
0.3813198506832123,
-0.3057032525539398,
-0.5546571016311646,
-0.7753294706344604,
-0.2475706934928894,
-0.016556765884160995,
-0.03392074257135391,
0.35700348019599915,
0.700115978717804,
-0.24948590993881226,
0.8845576643943787,
-0.4434819221496582,
-0.2265322357416153,
-0.746932864189148,
0.11891207844018936,
0.22434835135936737,
0.1632726937532425,
0.6421286463737488,
-0.6457162499427795,
-0.5503360629081726,
-0.2059580534696579,
-0.5222667455673218,
-0.020908011123538017,
0.3099340498447418,
0.1551905870437622,
-0.5427712202072144,
0.3362567722797394,
-0.11532340943813324,
0.6918319463729858,
0.5009129643440247,
0.1407507359981537,
0.44536155462265015,
0.34773948788642883,
0.17086535692214966,
-0.9743074178695679,
-0.3173971474170685,
0.23344504833221436,
-0.6591141223907471,
-0.6657576560974121,
0.4838739335536957,
-0.2313840538263321,
-0.20631492137908936,
-0.7410944700241089,
0.3090222179889679,
-0.08274296671152115,
-0.007184653077274561,
-0.26651236414909363,
0.4736531674861908,
-0.0548250786960125,
0.24424554407596588,
-0.2915506958961487,
0.29199427366256714,
0.37940290570259094,
-0.5734537839889526,
0.5513156652450562,
-0.21946203708648682,
-0.43319135904312134,
0.6074188947677612,
-0.43703538179397583,
0.3058696389198303,
-0.2887435555458069,
0.6500363349914551,
-1.103040337562561,
-0.3620813190937042,
0.4551396071910858,
-0.5845363140106201,
-0.10080306231975555,
-0.618391752243042,
-0.6116012334823608,
-0.6297030448913574,
-0.41395843029022217,
0.5757176876068115,
0.40039896965026855,
-0.5181113481521606,
0.48352813720703125,
0.31950971484184265,
0.4946952164173126,
-0.49521204829216003,
-0.46177753806114197,
-0.18442825973033905,
-0.25068554282188416,
-0.6127785444259644,
-0.1764020174741745,
0.11432862281799316,
-0.29682135581970215,
0.08255866914987564,
0.15546470880508423,
-0.07400482892990112,
0.16780869662761688,
0.251207560300827,
-0.2777853310108185,
-0.06298892945051193,
0.21827776730060577,
0.06960161030292511,
0.056714002043008804,
-0.3334249258041382,
-0.3478038012981415,
0.6935944557189941,
0.13868430256843567,
-0.6510631442070007,
-0.38361337780952454,
0.2177567332983017,
-0.01243989635258913,
0.012094185687601566,
0.4995943307876587,
0.46221598982810974,
-0.6513040065765381,
-0.5029359459877014,
-0.44112202525138855,
-0.21738260984420776,
-0.476030558347702,
0.2969171702861786,
-0.14513349533081055,
-0.8443782329559326,
0.6000033617019653,
-0.12403488904237747,
-0.022152703255414963,
0.4845588803291321,
0.26379770040512085,
-0.12489254027605057,
0.7779959440231323,
0.5406714677810669,
-0.18600599467754364,
0.15614457428455353,
-0.43415752053260803,
0.16300693154335022,
-0.4932728707790375,
-0.019102398306131363,
-0.36093398928642273,
-0.3915886878967285,
-0.40813857316970825,
-0.3760377764701843,
0.4262150228023529,
-0.024064911529421806,
-0.009465123526751995,
0.610944926738739,
-0.4282495081424713,
0.8663075566291809,
0.23832407593727112,
0.377219557762146,
0.4134705066680908,
0.22389718890190125,
-0.30351904034614563,
0.015347795560956001,
-0.8849726915359497,
-0.5468493103981018,
1.229093313217163,
0.25322872400283813,
0.6180907487869263,
0.18265122175216675,
0.6817682981491089,
0.8758453726768494,
0.8517594337463379,
-0.4818269908428192,
0.23366688191890717,
-0.4803624749183655,
-0.9153181910514832,
-0.19852527976036072,
-0.13231343030929565,
-0.9407601952552795,
0.33681344985961914,
-0.21136343479156494,
-0.7857040762901306,
0.07878422737121582,
0.15214218199253082,
-0.6702158451080322,
0.677744448184967,
-0.3777165710926056,
0.606673002243042,
0.5957071185112,
0.0037986694369465113,
-0.3230106830596924,
-0.3964005410671234,
0.703886091709137,
0.04591192305088043,
0.5658469796180725,
-0.06076395511627197,
0.4082101583480835,
0.4228559732437134,
-0.2567393183708191,
1.3172767162322998,
-0.3410129249095917,
0.4603182077407837,
0.779479444026947,
0.11150448769330978,
0.4525485336780548,
0.04290571063756943,
-0.14231200516223907,
-0.07672015577554703,
-0.15805210173130035,
-0.4863763451576233,
-0.5961027145385742,
0.34291696548461914,
-0.5624436736106873,
-0.2993861138820648,
0.014542692340910435,
-0.20693206787109375,
0.027476532384753227,
0.11184502393007278,
0.5929827690124512,
0.6228166222572327,
-0.45285460352897644,
0.2114594280719757,
0.7475236058235168,
-0.265329509973526,
0.13210371136665344,
0.2895393967628479,
-0.3723457455635071,
-0.4845271408557892,
0.7761908173561096,
-0.15861205756664276,
0.4228436350822449,
0.22203528881072998,
0.2706899046897888,
0.097458116710186,
-0.6361469626426697,
-0.3283138573169708,
-0.07825025171041489,
-1.024709939956665,
-0.4620758891105652,
-0.7223214507102966,
-0.1744498312473297,
-0.90406334400177,
-0.12820880115032196,
-0.19935688376426697,
-0.14316467940807343,
0.022075599059462547,
-0.292248010635376,
0.09134528785943985,
1.009421706199646,
-0.1885388344526291,
0.8492431044578552,
-0.5154317617416382,
0.3296901285648346,
0.33502131700515747,
0.15361835062503815,
0.2435658723115921,
-0.7037891149520874,
-0.2547154724597931,
0.05581502988934517,
-0.4606315493583679,
-0.9476535320281982,
0.17563818395137787,
0.09988673031330109,
0.5634613633155823,
0.7008441090583801,
0.24340525269508362,
0.5435891151428223,
-0.24889081716537476,
0.6976505517959595,
-0.07776501774787903,
-0.40004414319992065,
0.5720428228378296,
-0.48107701539993286,
-0.1091376543045044,
1.0052789449691772,
0.5122467279434204,
-0.5733417272567749,
-0.5377445816993713,
-0.6550304293632507,
-0.360563188791275,
0.36084091663360596,
0.2688787281513214,
0.51326984167099,
-0.27641260623931885,
0.48458313941955566,
0.0901578962802887,
0.04556340351700783,
-1.0705357789993286,
-0.193996861577034,
-0.3292163610458374,
0.1062917485833168,
0.10582103580236435,
-0.15594518184661865,
-0.33993032574653625,
-0.2901037335395813,
0.4334244132041931,
-0.13808806240558624,
0.23459674417972565,
-0.15235109627246857,
-0.18480908870697021,
-0.14813365042209625,
-0.047719333320856094,
0.20669718086719513,
0.5452395081520081,
-0.1165412962436676,
0.2092694640159607,
0.21856723725795746,
-0.3336922228336334,
0.06668565422296524,
-0.3298238515853882,
-0.16945859789848328,
0.01763824000954628,
0.81560879945755,
0.4177621603012085,
0.21039935946464539,
-0.3125602602958679,
1.1053284406661987,
-0.013046585023403168,
-0.10946186631917953,
-0.30278563499450684,
0.21992968022823334,
-0.02489730902016163,
0.23602046072483063,
0.35192644596099854,
-0.11039315909147263,
0.4129337668418884,
-0.5637066960334778,
0.27607229351997375,
0.3535081744194031,
-0.4747622609138489,
-0.3481687307357788,
0.34453970193862915,
0.08284541964530945,
-0.34189504384994507,
0.8226845264434814,
-0.6939936280250549,
-0.6046269536018372,
0.8233683705329895,
0.5560215711593628,
0.880765438079834,
-0.07624415308237076,
0.4913976192474365,
0.5403947830200195,
0.7305225133895874,
0.4080045819282532,
-0.027084944769740105,
0.04920679330825806,
-0.9626134634017944,
0.025880156084895134,
-0.6927549839019775,
-0.31916752457618713,
0.329306036233902,
-0.2980869710445404,
0.4308187961578369,
-0.7465916872024536,
-0.14327746629714966,
0.06309531629085541,
-0.22177399694919586,
-0.5920501351356506,
0.3149600028991699,
0.03318959102034569,
1.174342155456543,
-1.37508225440979,
0.7867660522460938,
0.2300083190202713,
-0.33795222640037537,
-0.6599416136741638,
-0.007754350546747446,
0.2119956612586975,
-0.6332648396492004,
0.3213273584842682,
0.3663116991519928,
-0.1310003101825714,
-0.17871320247650146,
-0.9593428373336792,
-0.4532804787158966,
0.9484090209007263,
0.023339977487921715,
-0.4581710696220398,
0.14217343926429749,
0.10282307863235474,
0.7922015190124512,
-0.7744947671890259,
0.28910431265830994,
0.3788432776927948,
0.25025302171707153,
0.303043395280838,
-0.41104814410209656,
0.013891920447349548,
-0.36286282539367676,
-0.04103998467326164,
-0.10976357758045197,
-0.5998360514640808,
0.7482323050498962,
-0.07523295283317566,
-0.28214383125305176,
-0.08175671845674515,
0.6071553230285645,
0.3104051351547241,
0.6036463975906372,
0.7017166018486023,
0.5888366103172302,
0.4805639088153839,
0.14572100341320038,
1.308837890625,
0.11039937287569046,
0.39968568086624146,
1.249849557876587,
-0.028893165290355682,
0.5605644583702087,
-0.1735064536333084,
-0.2806759178638458,
0.7534081339836121,
0.8290607929229736,
-0.21302634477615356,
0.6710684299468994,
0.4509214460849762,
-0.34666627645492554,
-0.516257107257843,
-0.07432640343904495,
-0.24478547275066376,
0.309757798910141,
0.38550087809562683,
-0.5003038048744202,
-0.5275145769119263,
-0.007019603159278631,
-0.1339767724275589,
0.17936643958091736,
-0.4077376425266266,
0.5645940899848938,
-0.020464390516281128,
-0.3027098774909973,
0.19967743754386902,
0.3108108341693878,
0.7158417105674744,
-0.4527810215950012,
0.022730369120836258,
-0.19480472803115845,
-0.03162819519639015,
-0.4305628836154938,
-0.4362102150917053,
0.5006657838821411,
-0.007596559822559357,
-0.0012943893671035767,
0.3704107701778412,
1.1297885179519653,
0.03145715221762657,
-0.470830500125885,
0.3935949504375458,
-0.030050622299313545,
0.4334004819393158,
-0.057928457856178284,
-0.4393641948699951,
-0.1921783685684204,
-0.22292742133140564,
0.08464137464761734,
0.25471067428588867,
0.1712137758731842,
-0.26890578866004944,
0.38874107599258423,
0.7596542239189148,
-0.1482231169939041,
0.19397911429405212,
0.3951292037963867,
1.1459598541259766,
-0.0975022092461586,
-0.3643181622028351,
-0.8705165386199951,
0.37743642926216125,
-0.28473135828971863,
-0.2746088206768036,
0.5963205099105835,
0.6288389563560486,
1.0727643966674805,
0.16930656135082245,
1.0223203897476196,
-0.08185624331235886,
0.5542928576469421,
-0.1593545824289322,
0.5642734169960022,
-0.339038610458374,
0.20617805421352386,
-0.6155632734298706,
-0.8330559134483337,
-0.27386805415153503,
0.3402070701122284,
-0.34810876846313477,
0.11753451824188232,
0.48656007647514343,
0.8477758765220642,
-0.5085142850875854,
-0.06941870599985123,
0.5656832456588745,
0.006588504184037447,
0.39968395233154297,
0.46072155237197876,
0.8591508865356445,
-0.45735761523246765,
0.632935643196106,
-0.40370869636535645,
-0.2769980728626251,
-0.21108031272888184,
-0.9175114035606384,
-1.18782639503479,
-0.20344442129135132,
-0.049347277730703354,
-0.647479772567749,
0.2580708861351013,
0.7024512887001038,
0.8064340353012085,
-0.8680077791213989,
0.1105155497789383,
0.2294352501630783,
0.12542837858200073,
-0.09585032612085342,
-0.20887121558189392,
-0.1474650353193283,
0.025952132418751717,
-0.49845853447914124,
0.24152474105358124,
0.17667339742183685,
-0.260338693857193,
-0.4786466956138611,
0.07346633821725845,
-0.3264308571815491,
0.2566593587398529,
0.4794631004333496,
0.2278146594762802,
-0.4714816212654114,
-0.4594842493534088,
-0.311500608921051,
-0.09368112683296204,
0.05279448255896568,
0.8179558515548706,
-0.7812183499336243,
0.40568041801452637,
0.40621694922447205,
0.45419394969940186,
0.7638014554977417,
0.2004479467868805,
0.052455540746450424,
-1.0437222719192505,
0.04793170839548111,
0.058283258229494095,
0.164822056889534,
0.37250834703445435,
-0.41339603066444397,
0.6216407418251038,
0.6891388297080994,
-0.08144690841436386,
-0.7394551038742065,
0.5355916023254395,
-0.5700836777687073,
-0.3222940266132355,
1.1282892227172852,
-0.4592442512512207,
-0.071609728038311,
-0.3696816563606262,
0.3093228340148926,
0.22569303214550018,
-0.3323793411254883,
0.7403841018676758,
0.5900441408157349,
0.10122720152139664,
-0.07410702109336853,
-0.4722147583961487,
0.1972174197435379,
-0.3242819011211395,
-0.6127015948295593,
-0.1767314374446869,
0.47505563497543335,
0.7328227162361145,
0.1571248173713684,
0.9951831698417664,
-0.05682838335633278,
0.4065793454647064,
0.10853487253189087,
-0.16962972283363342,
-0.16429206728935242,
-0.6464976072311401,
-0.39637359976768494,
0.44144776463508606,
-0.23893631994724274,
0.09129701554775238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01800v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01800v2
|
Sentiment Analysis of Citations in Scientific Articles Using ChatGPT: Identifying Potential Biases and Conflicts of Interest
| 2024-04-02T09:59:49 | 2024-04-06T19:08:08 |
Walid Hariri
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL
|
Scientific articles play a crucial role in advancing knowledge and informing
research directions. One key aspect of evaluating scientific articles is the
analysis of citations, which provides insights into the impact and reception of
the cited works. This article introduces the innovative use of large language
models, particularly ChatGPT, for comprehensive sentiment analysis of citations
within scientific articles. By leveraging advanced natural language processing
(NLP) techniques, ChatGPT can discern the nuanced positivity or negativity of
citations, offering insights into the reception and impact of cited works.
Furthermore, ChatGPT's capabilities extend to detecting potential biases and
conflicts of interest in citations, enhancing the objectivity and reliability
of scientific literature evaluation. This study showcases the transformative
potential of artificial intelligence (AI)-powered tools in enhancing citation
analysis and promoting integrity in scholarly research.
|
[
-0.3903651237487793,
-0.5389416813850403,
0.5343796610832214,
0.39943262934684753,
-0.34011638164520264,
0.2608048617839813,
0.09216203540563583,
-0.6014969944953918,
0.17931371927261353,
0.14226491749286652,
-0.14209972321987152,
-0.2931801676750183,
-0.6427114605903625,
0.33363500237464905,
-0.29684653878211975,
1.3195780515670776,
0.22200296819210052,
0.636617124080658,
-0.5149934887886047,
-0.04365271329879761,
-0.06927474588155746,
-0.6417754292488098,
-0.5178279280662537,
-0.3800279200077057,
0.7484092712402344,
-0.13472510874271393,
0.6554053425788879,
-0.03710449859499931,
0.9466231465339661,
0.1944946050643921,
-0.3511420488357544,
0.0598597526550293,
-0.2999631464481354,
0.26122674345970154,
-0.4453355371952057,
-0.12927715480327606,
-0.4149682819843292,
0.1287059783935547,
0.6070314049720764,
0.5981970429420471,
0.3698303699493408,
0.19824795424938202,
0.14204524457454681,
0.854259192943573,
-0.17894752323627472,
0.46695688366889954,
-0.6739208698272705,
0.2406345158815384,
-0.30560302734375,
-0.4981880187988281,
-0.5011181235313416,
-0.6970846652984619,
0.5019707083702087,
-0.3841879069805145,
0.03951147571206093,
0.1594948023557663,
0.8199784159660339,
0.29584062099456787,
-0.2615547776222229,
-0.266130268573761,
-0.3861493170261383,
0.9121606945991516,
-0.7689065933227539,
0.23075181245803833,
-0.00735430559143424,
-0.18139027059078217,
-0.2427622228860855,
-0.7575061917304993,
-0.4766061007976532,
-0.47058120369911194,
0.012876099906861782,
0.2336135357618332,
-0.40389490127563477,
-0.09028363227844238,
0.26772841811180115,
0.15640394389629364,
-0.7233657240867615,
-0.40510058403015137,
-0.3667077124118805,
0.060536861419677734,
0.6183370351791382,
-0.31151092052459717,
0.4202781915664673,
-0.3967836797237396,
-0.3233446478843689,
-0.09961653500795364,
-0.5314607620239258,
-0.17076033353805542,
0.365637868642807,
0.32181063294410706,
0.370271772146225,
0.6561098694801331,
0.176552414894104,
0.2744602859020233,
-0.06563251465559006,
0.42012110352516174,
0.2591448724269867,
-0.2644854187965393,
-0.047418151050806046,
0.2886487543582916,
0.963601291179657,
0.3241825997829437,
0.1884627491235733,
-0.14802129566669464,
0.2635890245437622,
-0.059797391295433044,
0.26233962178230286,
-0.7967667579650879,
-0.1869349628686905,
0.29615136981010437,
-0.7286501526832581,
-0.5427802205085754,
0.21591834723949432,
-1.2232297658920288,
-0.7748827934265137,
-0.29484573006629944,
0.11157694458961487,
-0.3820534944534302,
-0.2977214753627777,
-0.041272953152656555,
-0.39507102966308594,
0.2804572284221649,
0.30815589427948,
-0.28403815627098083,
0.03900414705276489,
0.7106969356536865,
1.2277716398239136,
-0.18423686921596527,
-0.09478029608726501,
-0.3313407003879547,
-0.1522897481918335,
0.07401371747255325,
0.9355361461639404,
-0.8757942318916321,
-0.5062837600708008,
-0.05805860087275505,
-0.3399687707424164,
-0.2972414195537567,
-0.26449674367904663,
0.9593825340270996,
-0.8137161135673523,
0.08962681889533997,
-0.43853655457496643,
-0.6604854464530945,
-0.3747830092906952,
0.28037029504776,
-0.6204689741134644,
0.8233280181884766,
-0.032186537981033325,
-1.100385069847107,
0.19010668992996216,
-1.2261408567428589,
-0.45924511551856995,
0.20542103052139282,
0.10847002267837524,
-0.5581038594245911,
0.13239188492298126,
0.08760449290275574,
0.16720549762248993,
-0.21686767041683197,
0.5395810604095459,
-0.4975180923938751,
0.23513978719711304,
0.6940192580223083,
-0.39095044136047363,
0.8184319138526917,
0.42549967765808105,
-0.3326691687107086,
0.2652781307697296,
-0.44019535183906555,
-0.012541748583316803,
-0.021552570164203644,
-0.10353583842515945,
-0.4479513466358185,
0.4357767105102539,
0.3622231185436249,
0.10938022285699844,
0.31044140458106995,
-0.673805296421051,
0.4142514169216156,
-0.15125195682048798,
0.6356794834136963,
0.41009077429771423,
0.41611531376838684,
0.26104357838630676,
-0.07461864501237869,
0.478798508644104,
-0.11150479316711426,
0.1951303333044052,
0.07671330869197845,
-0.800609290599823,
-0.39528271555900574,
0.10928254574537277,
0.5119336247444153,
0.4766455590724945,
-0.24291811883449554,
0.4003048241138458,
-0.2094241976737976,
-0.47984883189201355,
-0.40645313262939453,
-0.028255416080355644,
0.00808275118470192,
0.4488288462162018,
0.4445088803768158,
-0.29162347316741943,
-0.7985982894897461,
-0.6848433017730713,
-0.5257178544998169,
-0.363020658493042,
0.058641526848077774,
0.16948799788951874,
0.6475993990898132,
-0.1701972335577011,
1.1459312438964844,
-0.2974284589290619,
-0.05992445349693298,
0.01166581828147173,
0.5108399391174316,
0.047599997371435165,
0.5682350993156433,
0.38210952281951904,
-1.1542333364486694,
-0.5931127071380615,
0.20528654754161835,
-0.897121012210846,
-0.17507736384868622,
-0.10426098108291626,
-0.22669149935245514,
-0.1311003863811493,
0.5548565983772278,
-0.6936315894126892,
0.10604395717382431,
0.24921394884586334,
-0.48804590106010437,
0.6118321418762207,
0.33362987637519836,
0.2605278789997101,
-0.5634004473686218,
0.4854562282562256,
0.24527020752429962,
-0.0388273186981678,
-0.5180780291557312,
-0.15253715217113495,
-0.06687461584806442,
-0.2900247871875763,
-0.2499767392873764,
0.29164421558380127,
-0.2912258803844452,
0.1542307585477829,
-0.2660716474056244,
-0.01202480960637331,
0.25302180647850037,
-0.048305317759513855,
0.1798783391714096,
0.5233812928199768,
0.19118355214595795,
-0.1395646184682846,
0.0975206270813942,
0.28300461173057556,
-0.14176824688911438,
0.48252734541893005,
-0.8643531799316406,
-0.008364526554942131,
-0.1056084856390953,
0.3031651973724365,
-0.6974611878395081,
-0.004606545902788639,
0.22804385423660278,
-0.651154100894928,
0.2928430438041687,
-0.43381166458129883,
-0.33376577496528625,
-0.09247205406427383,
-0.4622092545032501,
0.202813521027565,
0.1283455342054367,
-0.3376159965991974,
0.41829994320869446,
0.456607848405838,
-0.42543745040893555,
-0.5438726544380188,
-0.10068676620721817,
0.39311301708221436,
-0.26997432112693787,
-0.546017587184906,
0.1983303427696228,
-0.17242391407489777,
-0.6177040934562683,
0.20940715074539185,
-0.04120325669646263,
-0.09770909696817398,
-0.03535814955830574,
0.2892342507839203,
0.5476094484329224,
-0.19011665880680084,
0.10634321719408035,
0.0024578615557402372,
0.014905407093465328,
0.14788083732128143,
-0.33675244450569153,
0.6438498497009277,
-0.627537190914154,
-0.25038671493530273,
-0.227953240275383,
0.43289902806282043,
0.8169727921485901,
-0.37308335304260254,
0.5760179758071899,
0.6591764092445374,
-0.02054058574140072,
0.5194506049156189,
-0.4615687429904938,
0.0314805842936039,
-0.349015474319458,
0.5135788321495056,
0.4048030376434326,
-0.6967530250549316,
0.33339956402778625,
-0.09494750946760178,
-0.01658097468316555,
0.6325232982635498,
0.3713666498661041,
-0.08875622600317001,
1.0146570205688477,
0.3625219762325287,
-0.5065217614173889,
0.6779205799102783,
0.048887286335229874,
0.465983510017395,
-0.8268663883209229,
-0.2517680823802948,
-0.8776416182518005,
0.0020136188250035048,
-0.4380512535572052,
-0.3606298267841339,
0.42281460762023926,
-0.043489083647727966,
-0.24193619191646576,
-0.1296137422323227,
-0.7832056879997253,
0.4926981031894684,
0.6464056968688965,
-0.14974278211593628,
0.40871748328208923,
0.028683429583907127,
0.2799459993839264,
-0.1036134660243988,
-0.3746282756328583,
-0.9995943903923035,
0.8953588008880615,
0.49665704369544983,
0.5229499340057373,
-0.16113220155239105,
0.44317665696144104,
0.6970933079719543,
0.30956682562828064,
-1.034436583518982,
0.37801048159599304,
0.2932128608226776,
-0.5784090161323547,
-0.1472455859184265,
-0.2928652763366699,
-0.9840396046638489,
0.26626262068748474,
-0.2104274183511734,
-0.5646799206733704,
0.4228123426437378,
-0.16173569858074188,
-0.16272349655628204,
0.25449761748313904,
-0.6706888675689697,
0.8761568069458008,
-0.2641576826572418,
-0.475347638130188,
-0.18133527040481567,
-0.5533115267753601,
0.27170053124427795,
0.21634536981582642,
0.019739395007491112,
-0.02432314306497574,
0.26069632172584534,
0.9157846570014954,
0.0776466354727745,
0.7127718925476074,
-0.33079254627227783,
0.14010286331176758,
0.26030635833740234,
0.05922224000096321,
0.34277525544166565,
0.4506415128707886,
-0.4020712375640869,
0.4755847156047821,
0.21016371250152588,
-0.3170504868030548,
-0.30280783772468567,
0.820200502872467,
-0.7483911514282227,
-0.3666323721408844,
-0.8403285145759583,
-0.5407004356384277,
-0.16819941997528076,
0.27768829464912415,
0.04390152916312218,
0.02943645976483822,
-0.48212602734565735,
0.19384954869747162,
0.6085370779037476,
-0.23633836209774017,
0.44986358284950256,
0.18039590120315552,
-0.05898650363087654,
-0.29721930623054504,
0.9565718770027161,
-0.0349610410630703,
-0.1352747529745102,
0.17885084450244904,
0.28720352053642273,
-0.2887606620788574,
-0.7844569087028503,
-0.2890198528766632,
0.17204789817333221,
-0.39787665009498596,
-0.4410926401615143,
-0.6879280209541321,
-0.14406804740428925,
-0.4827319383621216,
-0.02588423155248165,
-0.34959137439727783,
-0.4773379862308502,
-0.1725117415189743,
0.1006745770573616,
0.33011889457702637,
0.6412157416343689,
0.07054878026247025,
0.10949835181236267,
-0.9866570830345154,
-0.16991053521633148,
0.280749648809433,
0.24037788808345795,
0.0030214220751076937,
0.032492298632860184,
-0.2276371717453003,
-0.20762746036052704,
-0.668056309223175,
-0.9520244598388672,
0.7587088942527771,
0.12129262089729309,
0.41921424865722656,
0.5766476392745972,
-0.004544790834188461,
0.3596522808074951,
-0.4861120283603668,
0.9243688583374023,
0.11070647090673447,
-0.8785184025764465,
0.6369107365608215,
-0.5349467396736145,
-0.0749027281999588,
0.6167576909065247,
0.5796698927879333,
-0.4992024004459381,
-0.17511743307113647,
-0.6829814314842224,
-1.0541315078735352,
0.3033696413040161,
0.2533981502056122,
-0.1573968380689621,
-0.06356386095285416,
0.04125165566802025,
0.0365324430167675,
0.23935289680957794,
-0.9785675406455994,
0.07469476759433746,
-0.5178447365760803,
-0.19618773460388184,
0.2526484727859497,
-0.21431155502796173,
-0.5024507641792297,
-0.1925356239080429,
0.9951022267341614,
-0.09422767907381058,
0.43378663063049316,
0.4815213978290558,
-0.30910173058509827,
0.004971970804035664,
0.4742623269557953,
0.5146986842155457,
0.5045230984687805,
-0.38663530349731445,
0.08024340122938156,
-0.24607403576374054,
-0.6635973453521729,
-0.4045928418636322,
0.30221542716026306,
-0.3793715536594391,
0.13843165338039398,
0.2122950702905655,
0.43634462356567383,
-0.07362555712461472,
-0.6038574576377869,
0.3561910390853882,
-0.12087453156709671,
0.0840948224067688,
-0.374586820602417,
-0.2599667012691498,
0.016572631895542145,
0.3698042929172516,
0.5826917290687561,
0.556034505367279,
0.5231116414070129,
-0.36002907156944275,
0.005038215313106775,
0.8125088810920715,
-0.5128409266471863,
-0.35789361596107483,
0.4256211519241333,
0.18620508909225464,
-0.007378270383924246,
0.3631580173969269,
-0.04025167226791382,
-0.7899221777915955,
0.5478838682174683,
0.3102981150150299,
0.8452455401420593,
0.019665410742163658,
0.48018765449523926,
0.31576070189476013,
0.12772886455059052,
0.08288612961769104,
-0.12756110727787018,
0.07643505185842514,
-0.5272073149681091,
-0.3701001703739166,
-0.8820858597755432,
-0.6946383118629456,
0.0184608343988657,
-0.651037871837616,
0.030123449862003326,
-0.30262133479118347,
-0.26778292655944824,
0.408698171377182,
0.22092680633068085,
-0.33458271622657776,
-0.3112001419067383,
0.13154204189777374,
0.536137044429779,
-0.8607850670814514,
0.6302352547645569,
0.6894834041595459,
-0.6931280493736267,
-0.3412543535232544,
-0.015731683000922203,
0.15226422250270844,
-0.24039149284362793,
0.7359070777893066,
-0.00007243578875204548,
-0.1263507455587387,
-0.12295201420783997,
-0.8214438557624817,
-0.8392733931541443,
0.5765693783760071,
0.23611058294773102,
-0.2705848813056946,
0.26290178298950195,
-0.14738143980503082,
0.6489474177360535,
-0.21869927644729614,
0.43285098671913147,
0.5454856753349304,
0.8134766221046448,
0.04955238103866577,
-0.7117574214935303,
-0.11681119352579117,
-0.6271543502807617,
-0.32278943061828613,
0.03492395579814911,
-0.44512858986854553,
0.6419655084609985,
0.1793321818113327,
0.05738447979092598,
-0.21939736604690552,
0.6466266512870789,
0.14134688675403595,
0.6192300915718079,
0.279174268245697,
0.13762332499027252,
0.9972313046455383,
-0.05613774061203003,
0.7831059098243713,
-0.23452167212963104,
0.5000664591789246,
0.7241423726081848,
-0.40439870953559875,
0.8284249305725098,
0.8300781846046448,
-0.4646141231060028,
0.6663334369659424,
0.43138858675956726,
-0.3675970137119293,
0.2878893315792084,
0.008340772241353989,
-0.4807701110839844,
0.02234276570379734,
-0.3545796573162079,
-0.5862913727760315,
0.28276246786117554,
0.49939391016960144,
-0.4422124922275543,
-0.09694579988718033,
0.00004692499715019949,
0.38826557993888855,
-0.029363753274083138,
-0.3483199179172516,
0.5697076916694641,
0.10089683532714844,
-0.636639416217804,
-0.008421806618571281,
-0.2324495166540146,
0.6605218052864075,
-0.5867963433265686,
-0.05441862344741821,
0.08385787159204483,
0.0894252359867096,
-0.5621015429496765,
-0.8582860827445984,
0.39943134784698486,
0.2929479479789734,
-0.3788311183452606,
-0.12058502435684204,
0.8820764422416687,
-0.04531185328960419,
-0.46803662180900574,
0.06583830714225769,
0.3498340845108032,
0.09420707821846008,
-0.22672683000564575,
-0.8330857753753662,
-0.025648685172200203,
0.06477021425962448,
-0.5036033987998962,
0.5185961127281189,
0.2656137943267822,
0.05844555422663689,
0.41775044798851013,
0.993069589138031,
0.2966403663158417,
-0.10595789551734924,
0.33185890316963196,
0.8281266093254089,
-0.5703373551368713,
-0.1556645929813385,
-1.0825413465499878,
0.19392192363739014,
-0.652007520198822,
-0.08404595404863358,
0.9996222853660583,
0.7113640308380127,
0.25087079405784607,
-0.18207138776779175,
1.1430455446243286,
-0.3458932340145111,
0.40994012355804443,
-0.144784078001976,
0.9084597229957581,
-0.11958547681570053,
0.24045102298259735,
-0.8309438824653625,
-0.714185893535614,
-0.758866012096405,
0.9374635815620422,
-0.508569598197937,
-0.043597642332315445,
0.682335376739502,
0.4835062325000763,
0.12071350961923599,
0.43288663029670715,
-0.22117365896701813,
0.16513049602508545,
0.6700240969657898,
-0.017855577170848846,
0.971871554851532,
-0.17678242921829224,
0.5181393027305603,
-0.003002454759553075,
-0.16636495292186737,
-0.26839685440063477,
-1.1894603967666626,
-0.6396499276161194,
-0.36194536089897156,
-0.44657638669013977,
-0.39954009652137756,
-0.15597979724407196,
0.9851112365722656,
0.3915722668170929,
-0.9767830967903137,
-0.0805078074336052,
-0.10974857956171036,
0.3232288062572479,
-0.2030438631772995,
-0.3628889322280884,
0.7360348701477051,
-0.6770088076591492,
-0.8010141849517822,
0.20650549232959747,
0.4970998764038086,
-0.23364858329296112,
-0.2240111231803894,
-0.01874662935733795,
-0.4550953209400177,
0.1533176153898239,
0.8436266779899597,
0.5375910401344299,
-0.27404382824897766,
-0.25585702061653137,
0.04244793951511383,
0.11458895355463028,
0.20789699256420135,
0.970078706741333,
-0.584729790687561,
0.36109459400177,
0.5499549508094788,
0.46235981583595276,
0.4484597146511078,
0.09826526045799255,
0.4542413055896759,
-0.2647206485271454,
-0.07425843924283981,
0.6879504323005676,
0.4327995777130127,
0.38820597529411316,
-0.34478428959846497,
0.5771129727363586,
0.1809161901473999,
-1.0612720251083374,
-1.0480035543441772,
-0.198880136013031,
-1.4388552904129028,
-0.14286527037620544,
1.0514265298843384,
-0.15488667786121368,
-0.06336687505245209,
-0.36098814010620117,
-0.592034101486206,
0.23747579753398895,
-0.6075566411018372,
1.0719841718673706,
0.7632887959480286,
-0.5437102317810059,
0.1305011510848999,
-0.6585792303085327,
0.48035094141960144,
0.39760616421699524,
-0.8827957510948181,
0.06520333886146545,
0.4481004476547241,
-0.06626977026462555,
0.4362010657787323,
0.1702096313238144,
-0.5467961430549622,
0.10200691968202591,
-0.14735418558120728,
0.04743671789765358,
0.04279756173491478,
0.0781574472784996,
-0.2170962244272232,
0.43262478709220886,
0.2799311578273773,
0.17752528190612793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01799v1
|
PATCH -- Psychometrics-AssisTed benCHmarking of Large Language Models: A Case Study of Mathematics Proficiency
| 2024-04-02T09:58:57 | 2024-04-02T09:58:57 |
Qixiang Fang, Daniel L. Oberski, Dong Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Many existing benchmarks of large (multimodal) language models (LLMs) focus
on measuring LLMs' academic proficiency, often with also an interest in
comparing model performance with human test takers. While these benchmarks have
proven key to the development of LLMs, they suffer from several limitations,
including questionable measurement quality (e.g., Do they measure what they are
supposed to in a reliable way?), lack of quality assessment on the item level
(e.g., Are some items more important or difficult than others?) and unclear
human population reference (e.g., To whom can the model be compared?). In
response to these challenges, we propose leveraging knowledge from
psychometrics - a field dedicated to the measurement of latent variables like
academic proficiency - into LLM benchmarking. We make three primary
contributions. First, we introduce PATCH: a novel framework for
Psychometrics-AssisTed benCHmarking of LLMs. PATCH addresses the aforementioned
limitations, presenting a new direction for LLM benchmark research. Second, we
implement PATCH by measuring GPT-4 and Gemini-Pro-Vision's proficiency in 8th
grade mathematics against 56 human populations. We show that adopting a
psychometrics-based approach yields evaluation outcomes that diverge from those
based on existing benchmarking practices. Third, we release 4 datasets to
support measuring and comparing LLM proficiency in grade school mathematics and
science against human populations.
|
[
-0.5978239178657532,
-0.7394306659698486,
0.5434883236885071,
0.5074672698974609,
0.16101951897144318,
0.5011078119277954,
-0.39719513058662415,
-0.5901995897293091,
0.1464087963104248,
0.4333566427230835,
-0.5155177712440491,
-0.38801029324531555,
-0.5675451755523682,
0.040037013590335846,
-0.055606659501791,
0.6653295755386353,
-0.260049968957901,
0.21692077815532684,
-0.6768790483474731,
-0.18632081151008606,
-0.3406410813331604,
-0.6154475808143616,
-0.507491946220398,
-0.38350993394851685,
0.4008231461048126,
0.12779578566551208,
0.23545001447200775,
0.5507304668426514,
0.9853652715682983,
0.3298995792865753,
-0.07970103621482849,
0.19184216856956482,
-0.3038381338119507,
0.036892615258693695,
-0.061365194618701935,
-0.694613516330719,
-0.898627758026123,
0.21757914125919342,
0.908706784248352,
1.0085108280181885,
-0.13039669394493103,
0.18904611468315125,
0.09201128035783768,
0.6817878484725952,
-0.777579665184021,
0.2661868929862976,
-0.4997086524963379,
-0.17139959335327148,
-0.553361177444458,
0.09287773072719574,
-0.13498589396476746,
-0.44420114159584045,
-0.32781511545181274,
-0.5476139187812805,
0.2770049273967743,
-0.21046020090579987,
0.5120218396186829,
0.09391500055789948,
-0.38548147678375244,
0.03279335796833038,
-0.43114379048347473,
0.8701780438423157,
-0.7916421294212341,
0.4130535125732422,
0.7129344344139099,
0.5546697974205017,
-0.18178649246692657,
-0.4342096149921417,
-0.27420806884765625,
-0.13147009909152985,
0.1473272144794464,
0.023518487811088562,
0.1876133382320404,
-0.23513537645339966,
0.41670212149620056,
0.4169204533100128,
-0.31233516335487366,
0.06436660140752792,
-0.4216165840625763,
-0.3329172134399414,
0.8582607507705688,
0.39150211215019226,
-0.023545285686850548,
0.24506574869155884,
-0.10257353633642197,
-0.3023959696292877,
-0.9842870831489563,
0.12589378654956818,
0.4895871877670288,
0.23822057247161865,
-0.15090736746788025,
0.4877234697341919,
-0.10729285329580307,
0.845700740814209,
-0.40833863615989685,
-0.20149385929107666,
0.4471474587917328,
-0.25218909978866577,
0.2035714089870453,
-0.6411254405975342,
0.7426874041557312,
0.31154125928878784,
0.2112896889448166,
-0.1672932207584381,
-0.4440405070781708,
0.38296204805374146,
-0.15953290462493896,
-0.5268605351448059,
-0.41600993275642395,
-0.07498124986886978,
0.14147734642028809,
-0.21670641005039215,
-0.13240689039230347,
-1.047004222869873,
-0.5065509676933289,
-0.35988789796829224,
0.322356641292572,
-0.3096829950809479,
-0.3892463445663452,
-0.08536243438720703,
0.20054008066654205,
-0.1862488090991974,
0.24956057965755463,
-1.0099461078643799,
0.5492805242538452,
0.9800290465354919,
0.7553455829620361,
-0.4709318280220032,
-0.4945458769798279,
-0.451757550239563,
-0.15046894550323486,
-0.5367066860198975,
0.9873840808868408,
-0.6046263575553894,
-0.27362537384033203,
0.07954525947570801,
-0.15237334370613098,
-0.04135327786207199,
-0.8051134347915649,
0.16555258631706238,
-0.2603876292705536,
-0.0138431116938591,
-0.49233195185661316,
-0.6741102933883667,
0.3149285614490509,
0.5218330025672913,
-0.47904878854751587,
1.212134599685669,
0.38184434175491333,
-0.396840900182724,
0.4284554719924927,
-0.5402053594589233,
-0.03308471664786339,
0.027338461950421333,
-0.2709822654724121,
-0.3946198523044586,
0.19608403742313385,
0.24678011238574982,
0.10949457436800003,
-0.4386090934276581,
0.268525630235672,
-0.6627786159515381,
-0.3929516077041626,
0.5896042585372925,
-0.5640888810157776,
0.6979863047599792,
-0.05690867453813553,
0.13240256905555725,
-0.1647110879421234,
-0.8912847638130188,
0.23850411176681519,
-0.2153303176164627,
-0.29419779777526855,
-0.28182363510131836,
-0.07997342944145203,
0.17025142908096313,
0.1443766951560974,
0.28293856978416443,
-0.6788891553878784,
0.29378312826156616,
-0.37982091307640076,
0.4599169194698334,
0.8354014754295349,
-0.20993450284004211,
0.10123507678508759,
-0.5583770871162415,
0.5585490465164185,
-0.2304130345582962,
0.1393122524023056,
-0.30394044518470764,
-0.44622504711151123,
-0.5555965304374695,
-0.7634320259094238,
0.619239091873169,
0.3449322581291199,
-0.3814559280872345,
0.2636610269546509,
-0.08760686218738556,
-0.5893447995185852,
-0.5734547972679138,
0.5115792155265808,
0.5748053789138794,
0.21779292821884155,
0.20647059381008148,
-0.5287990570068359,
-0.41227635741233826,
-0.705716609954834,
-0.5477970242500305,
-0.27961286902427673,
-0.21735289692878723,
0.32086417078971863,
0.40071794390678406,
0.020645970478653908,
0.9274382591247559,
-0.5239126682281494,
-0.46511563658714294,
0.21033234894275665,
0.20107214152812958,
0.17101284861564636,
0.47068649530410767,
0.45885908603668213,
-0.42153236269950867,
-0.32384026050567627,
-0.2974465489387512,
-0.7342626452445984,
-0.46630460023880005,
0.459934264421463,
0.027087045833468437,
0.007417426444590092,
0.6100190281867981,
-0.17725679278373718,
0.18379206955432892,
0.8633546233177185,
-0.43484655022621155,
0.6717966794967651,
-0.28532981872558594,
0.24611176550388336,
-0.6731109023094177,
0.06149464473128319,
0.10536792874336243,
-0.15492618083953857,
-0.2864871919155121,
0.25348207354545593,
0.264226496219635,
0.12100274115800858,
-0.29725202918052673,
0.7764478325843811,
-0.3001578450202942,
-0.2823333442211151,
-0.04244380071759224,
0.14443615078926086,
-0.11124907433986664,
0.3736345171928406,
-0.23944294452667236,
1.0221951007843018,
0.3734915852546692,
-0.17771878838539124,
0.4631386995315552,
-0.03811001405119896,
-0.48862650990486145,
1.026018500328064,
-0.38541004061698914,
0.04622507840394974,
0.36626699566841125,
0.031678903847932816,
-0.9893335700035095,
-0.23187746107578278,
-0.031269896775484085,
-0.28961318731307983,
0.2075006663799286,
-0.10380687564611435,
-0.7590196132659912,
-0.30015045404434204,
-0.25823330879211426,
0.7847234606742859,
0.4981437027454376,
-0.2347644865512848,
0.40261632204055786,
0.51736980676651,
-0.31325680017471313,
-0.12154322117567062,
-0.5386759042739868,
0.17174872756004333,
-0.17497456073760986,
-0.47597426176071167,
0.2707916796207428,
-0.43386104702949524,
-0.42328014969825745,
-0.1709790825843811,
0.10022637993097305,
-0.3108214735984802,
-0.02173888497054577,
0.09121999144554138,
0.3517490327358246,
-0.3969612121582031,
0.08490902185440063,
-0.28391480445861816,
-0.3764098882675171,
0.2541671097278595,
0.1991710662841797,
0.41622403264045715,
-0.31190136075019836,
-0.9166088700294495,
0.10975760966539383,
0.03437896445393562,
0.5966306328773499,
-0.4550130069255829,
0.2252526730298996,
0.3319137394428253,
-0.37241482734680176,
0.16658474504947662,
-1.1020928621292114,
-0.39011716842651367,
-0.47651705145835876,
0.41379567980766296,
-0.31857535243034363,
-0.7760818600654602,
0.5393543839454651,
-0.4756324291229248,
0.09921151399612427,
0.1858789026737213,
0.4436068832874298,
-0.19549894332885742,
0.8867155313491821,
0.6212438941001892,
-0.010334361344575882,
0.40901845693588257,
-0.03785969316959381,
-0.13124100863933563,
-1.1322660446166992,
-0.0594780296087265,
-0.38750284910202026,
-0.40812963247299194,
-0.5112723708152771,
-0.6645886301994324,
0.5092487931251526,
0.1699138581752777,
-0.2395327389240265,
0.11470643430948257,
-0.12464100122451782,
0.6330569982528687,
0.48107287287712097,
0.11670960485935211,
0.42069074511528015,
0.19201675057411194,
-0.18324975669384003,
-0.5970004796981812,
-0.30979791283607483,
-0.29341262578964233,
1.3713734149932861,
0.2750476896762848,
0.6297484636306763,
0.16644103825092316,
0.5730341672897339,
0.12301841378211975,
0.7494080662727356,
-0.170120969414711,
0.6372224688529968,
-0.17534469068050385,
-0.6188595294952393,
-0.30539944767951965,
-0.5443036556243896,
-0.7004667520523071,
0.14116394519805908,
-0.3646408021450043,
-1.0652168989181519,
0.14284539222717285,
0.16656039655208588,
0.004143902100622654,
0.34902095794677734,
-0.5459203124046326,
0.7347943186759949,
-0.21349753439426422,
-0.6147977709770203,
-0.1949140876531601,
-0.20506709814071655,
0.45366427302360535,
-0.48574239015579224,
0.5066583752632141,
-0.4080289602279663,
-0.2100387066602707,
0.8020009994506836,
-0.3096740245819092,
0.8787063360214233,
-0.014103267341852188,
-0.08314185589551926,
-0.032640241086483,
0.07710891216993332,
0.23417159914970398,
0.05889636650681496,
-0.26408451795578003,
0.3424224257469177,
0.3342045247554779,
-0.6209101676940918,
-0.6309775710105896,
0.8189167976379395,
-0.8250439763069153,
-0.5377756953239441,
-0.5544583201408386,
-0.9210172891616821,
-0.8649129271507263,
0.03941414877772331,
-0.16971038281917572,
0.4313388168811798,
-0.17547065019607544,
0.14504913985729218,
0.5261441469192505,
-0.0838209018111229,
0.3141865134239197,
0.8915879726409912,
-0.4619128406047821,
-0.6857184767723083,
1.1250569820404053,
0.18668575584888458,
0.3024190664291382,
0.1826033592224121,
0.2549777328968048,
-0.29729655385017395,
-0.2746301293373108,
-0.2964126765727997,
0.516402006149292,
-0.5451644062995911,
-0.2236187607049942,
-0.17067357897758484,
-0.20921073853969574,
-0.346644788980484,
0.01865227334201336,
-0.43061894178390503,
-0.21996088325977325,
0.27280691266059875,
0.19811248779296875,
0.4782898426055908,
0.8277761936187744,
-0.3582566976547241,
0.18352463841438293,
-0.436968594789505,
0.2054620385169983,
0.313724160194397,
0.8382019996643066,
-0.2529347836971283,
-0.35691288113594055,
-0.13484038412570953,
0.11149425804615021,
-0.4168397784233093,
-0.6028328537940979,
0.14779271185398102,
0.0353265218436718,
0.4617742598056793,
0.23443642258644104,
-0.21050626039505005,
0.8110591173171997,
-0.415681391954422,
0.6158953309059143,
0.19888557493686676,
-0.8640882968902588,
0.28026214241981506,
-0.44468411803245544,
0.29938921332359314,
0.6062743067741394,
-0.19849629700183868,
-0.45690879225730896,
-0.6720205545425415,
-0.46443018317222595,
-0.6130752563476562,
0.606955349445343,
0.18838083744049072,
-0.08075842261314392,
0.029847534373402596,
0.276348739862442,
-0.08237913250923157,
0.25606539845466614,
-0.2529383897781372,
-0.0391588993370533,
0.20929373800754547,
-0.25978317856788635,
-0.5984686017036438,
-0.24515892565250397,
-0.3586310148239136,
-0.3595625162124634,
0.44712862372398376,
-0.040042225271463394,
0.03706067427992821,
-0.17246437072753906,
-0.03333219513297081,
-0.0796152725815773,
0.22368185222148895,
0.7264891266822815,
1.094333291053772,
-0.19206897914409637,
0.09039299190044403,
0.32378852367401123,
-0.6776280403137207,
0.28291216492652893,
0.21880851686000824,
-0.03870772942900658,
-0.24614723026752472,
0.5947279334068298,
0.22418835759162903,
0.3100973665714264,
-0.8091145157814026,
0.4851473867893219,
0.03732075169682503,
-0.2015189230442047,
-0.15215270221233368,
0.017293782904744148,
0.17984552681446075,
0.2499823123216629,
0.2607944905757904,
0.11188501119613647,
-0.3449373245239258,
-0.38718676567077637,
0.29276639223098755,
0.33955061435699463,
-0.434731125831604,
-0.3935193121433258,
0.3878791928291321,
0.08482979238033295,
-0.6136576533317566,
0.46650490164756775,
0.06325357407331467,
-0.25363990664482117,
0.7514312863349915,
0.579728364944458,
0.38440996408462524,
-0.4615134298801422,
0.002257715445011854,
0.2694125175476074,
0.3703734278678894,
-0.20589382946491241,
0.3373270630836487,
0.05928656458854675,
-0.4333250820636749,
-0.5005104541778564,
-0.5589743852615356,
-0.5541985630989075,
0.12436268478631973,
-0.6526814103126526,
0.19742511212825775,
-0.3970004618167877,
-0.34894150495529175,
-0.12882204353809357,
0.24137410521507263,
-0.8138684630393982,
0.168412446975708,
-0.1510685384273529,
0.9847514629364014,
-1.037800908088684,
0.6856587529182434,
0.6870636343955994,
-0.21152357757091522,
-0.49871736764907837,
-0.21985431015491486,
0.08153267949819565,
-0.9854514002799988,
0.47824278473854065,
-0.12458309531211853,
0.35363295674324036,
-0.0785076767206192,
-0.10521270334720612,
-0.6953521966934204,
0.9269439578056335,
0.6364737153053284,
-0.7548624873161316,
0.13107338547706604,
0.49023422598838806,
0.789336085319519,
-0.30967000126838684,
0.5607298612594604,
0.59010910987854,
0.47262251377105713,
-0.09709879010915756,
-0.9691541194915771,
-0.18568669259548187,
-0.3978453576564789,
-0.10034968703985214,
0.38377678394317627,
-0.5738242864608765,
0.9193731546401978,
0.09742682427167892,
0.28670886158943176,
0.1258855164051056,
0.3865824341773987,
0.699225127696991,
0.5065008401870728,
0.46281999349594116,
0.6218708753585815,
0.6619062423706055,
-0.37700146436691284,
0.8304489254951477,
-0.6309427618980408,
0.2809954285621643,
1.0261454582214355,
-0.28450697660446167,
1.164139747619629,
0.732176661491394,
-0.7850763201713562,
0.2998711168766022,
0.5001695156097412,
-0.09739290177822113,
0.2651347219944,
0.43143323063850403,
-0.45366451144218445,
-0.39034777879714966,
-0.07213159650564194,
-0.520288348197937,
0.20868292450904846,
0.5143483877182007,
-0.03730045631527901,
-0.1600065678358078,
0.006083181127905846,
-0.23178209364414215,
0.3029068112373352,
-0.16266347467899323,
0.6933563351631165,
0.20410287380218506,
-0.7192555069923401,
0.3536137044429779,
-0.04182911664247513,
0.4614489674568176,
-0.7418199777603149,
-0.08646662533283234,
-0.5416076183319092,
0.5718351006507874,
-0.010801060125231743,
-0.7945654988288879,
0.2792976498603821,
-0.019590234383940697,
-0.11956837028265,
0.03809152543544769,
0.16517917811870575,
-0.5437308549880981,
-0.9931163191795349,
0.16513758897781372,
0.7603805661201477,
0.20126497745513916,
0.00541346101090312,
-0.5043858885765076,
0.43988290429115295,
-0.6059477925300598,
0.028486138209700584,
0.6945021748542786,
0.39917629957199097,
-0.32322952151298523,
0.8099932074546814,
0.7530340552330017,
0.6758884787559509,
-0.025282764807343483,
0.10748816281557083,
0.8598271608352661,
-0.5256224274635315,
-0.4277159869670868,
-0.8911380767822266,
0.08077086508274078,
-0.13236640393733978,
-0.44395479559898376,
0.6867772936820984,
0.6240878105163574,
0.7125009894371033,
0.2251538187265396,
0.5090190768241882,
0.3332614004611969,
0.6528342366218567,
-0.26694589853286743,
0.6155955195426941,
-0.5959448218345642,
0.5572320818901062,
-0.4547513723373413,
-0.9927500486373901,
-0.4420357942581177,
0.43491095304489136,
-0.47963061928749084,
0.20023885369300842,
0.5915266275405884,
0.900969386100769,
-0.22974084317684174,
-0.31850844621658325,
0.5592603087425232,
0.0847536101937294,
0.34745487570762634,
0.7867164611816406,
0.7282851338386536,
-0.39730900526046753,
0.37200701236724854,
-0.08521638810634613,
-0.5228811502456665,
-0.032720897346735,
-0.8792029619216919,
-1.160292387008667,
-0.5344139933586121,
-0.3916073441505432,
-0.28405168652534485,
0.406303346157074,
0.633120596408844,
0.6925584077835083,
-0.7432249784469604,
-0.5492082834243774,
0.03912030905485153,
-0.09293399006128311,
-0.4838619530200958,
-0.176132470369339,
0.44149795174598694,
-0.18372516334056854,
-0.5348365902900696,
0.21414990723133087,
0.24438157677650452,
-0.02975127473473549,
-0.7777621746063232,
-0.05304139107465744,
0.14393188059329987,
0.1130998432636261,
0.3179934620857239,
0.333859920501709,
-0.9145222306251526,
-0.011148362420499325,
0.08720561861991882,
-0.10508985072374344,
0.023007778450846672,
0.9660143256187439,
-0.8807947039604187,
0.6128053665161133,
0.34744423627853394,
0.5946359038352966,
0.3455750048160553,
-0.3133489191532135,
0.7827940583229065,
-0.693936288356781,
0.1645296961069107,
0.10298698395490646,
0.29504847526550293,
0.5783757567405701,
0.16155801713466644,
0.5658040642738342,
0.43511396646499634,
-0.47338590025901794,
-1.157769799232483,
0.16227948665618896,
-0.5055984258651733,
0.054536059498786926,
0.8682294487953186,
-0.40267959237098694,
-0.09068822860717773,
-0.13161598145961761,
-0.024388153105974197,
-0.3000905215740204,
-0.11509450525045395,
1.127236008644104,
0.9741744995117188,
0.17794261872768402,
-0.38278165459632874,
-0.600006639957428,
0.3646581768989563,
0.45563480257987976,
-0.8228350281715393,
0.17040744423866272,
0.08910135924816132,
0.3849354088306427,
0.20454686880111694,
0.8511461615562439,
-0.3621326982975006,
0.318674236536026,
0.09162841737270355,
-0.007036740891635418,
-0.22000285983085632,
-0.1134253740310669,
-0.09483412653207779,
0.027941344305872917,
0.09193414449691772,
0.21769236028194427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02929v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02929v2
|
Using Large Language Models to Understand Telecom Standards
| 2024-04-02T09:54:51 | 2024-04-12T09:08:30 |
Athanasios Karapantelakis, Mukesh Thakur, Alexandros Nikou, Farnaz Moradi, Christian Orlog, Fitsum Gaim, Henrik Holm, Doumitrou Daniil Nimara, Vincent Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Third Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) has successfully introduced
standards for global mobility. However, the volume and complexity of these
standards has increased over time, thus complicating access to relevant
information for vendors and service providers. Use of Generative Artificial
Intelligence (AI) and in particular Large Language Models (LLMs), may provide
faster access to relevant information. In this paper, we evaluate the
capability of state-of-art LLMs to be used as Question Answering (QA)
assistants for 3GPP document reference. Our contribution is threefold. First,
we provide a benchmark and measuring methods for evaluating performance of
LLMs. Second, we do data preprocessing and fine-tuning for one of these LLMs
and provide guidelines to increase accuracy of the responses that apply to all
LLMs. Third, we provide a model of our own, TeleRoBERTa, that performs on-par
with foundation LLMs but with an order of magnitude less number of parameters.
Results show that LLMs can be used as a credible reference tool on telecom
technical documents, and thus have potential for a number of different
applications from troubleshooting and maintenance, to network operations and
software product development.
|
[
-0.45661672949790955,
-0.7348629236221313,
0.6981753706932068,
0.16009844839572906,
-0.3126112222671509,
-0.2463696151971817,
-0.09616021811962128,
-0.7386143207550049,
-0.21598388254642487,
0.606659471988678,
-0.1483420431613922,
-0.3632133901119232,
-0.2711552679538727,
0.4373597800731659,
-0.561333954334259,
0.4027009904384613,
-0.11578518897294998,
0.15807490050792694,
-0.10022004693746567,
-0.18113523721694946,
-0.2309390753507614,
-0.4949265718460083,
-0.7638299465179443,
-0.543287992477417,
0.21682575345039368,
0.40312904119491577,
1.1146776676177979,
0.41324856877326965,
0.4907578229904175,
0.34327924251556396,
-0.40532156825065613,
0.28017929196357727,
-0.03160109743475914,
-0.17140400409698486,
-0.015146330930292606,
-0.6616166830062866,
-0.5980087518692017,
0.23714809119701385,
0.692826509475708,
0.5801541209220886,
-0.2773887515068054,
0.26860079169273376,
-0.010942626744508743,
0.707400381565094,
-0.25260815024375916,
0.32836392521858215,
-0.7160372734069824,
-0.10331164300441742,
-0.06211765855550766,
-0.32872122526168823,
-0.34459030628204346,
-0.5500412583351135,
0.21899281442165375,
-0.5930055379867554,
0.13227948546409607,
0.02669375389814377,
1.0784636735916138,
0.1582629531621933,
-0.3274317979812622,
-0.5886189937591553,
-0.839613139629364,
0.47261232137680054,
-0.8949496150016785,
0.48389309644699097,
0.46574386954307556,
0.3808556795120239,
-0.12050288915634155,
-0.6557941436767578,
-0.964136004447937,
-0.31990325450897217,
0.18441222608089447,
-0.09902318567037582,
-0.12451791018247604,
0.04857781529426575,
0.41448625922203064,
0.35002875328063965,
-0.2585988938808441,
0.32879123091697693,
-0.5992631912231445,
-0.06865286827087402,
0.6223115921020508,
0.1282963752746582,
0.3658898174762726,
0.00043066032230854034,
0.10800741612911224,
0.33172690868377686,
-0.9111428260803223,
-0.32366707921028137,
0.43548670411109924,
0.12886442244052887,
-0.1759267896413803,
0.6601178050041199,
-0.27909740805625916,
1.0878850221633911,
-0.22517083585262299,
-0.15741340816020966,
0.2633301615715027,
-0.2343136966228485,
-0.3353276252746582,
-0.34225815534591675,
0.8357557058334351,
0.3004295825958252,
0.5525359511375427,
-0.4814499020576477,
0.021683266386389732,
-0.4499979317188263,
0.13866841793060303,
-0.8142397403717041,
0.18521127104759216,
0.2576179802417755,
-0.553146243095398,
0.20612770318984985,
-0.004301905632019043,
-0.6459653377532959,
-0.2722068428993225,
-0.484491765499115,
0.08739320933818817,
-0.40343523025512695,
-0.18322573602199554,
0.42768394947052,
0.16590848565101624,
0.8012252449989319,
0.45194751024246216,
-0.8633103966712952,
0.11829186230897903,
0.7359853386878967,
0.9408417344093323,
0.2723677456378937,
-0.20404694974422455,
-0.5433829426765442,
0.09689885377883911,
-0.4248727560043335,
0.6302372813224792,
-0.49356916546821594,
-0.485416978597641,
0.30452677607536316,
0.011778373271226883,
-0.041104771196842194,
-0.7747463583946228,
0.7429513931274414,
-1.1148210763931274,
0.1630592942237854,
0.04745788872241974,
-0.37789663672447205,
-0.30120936036109924,
0.15264809131622314,
-0.8592454791069031,
0.8411728143692017,
0.07646223902702332,
-0.44499021768569946,
0.051811810582876205,
-0.5789397954940796,
-0.17251650989055634,
0.25346365571022034,
0.0059289829805493355,
-0.31910955905914307,
-0.10152632743120193,
0.25228703022003174,
0.5046957731246948,
-0.7727382779121399,
0.1030532568693161,
-0.3487345576286316,
-0.30085432529449463,
0.22059881687164307,
-0.1996336132287979,
0.8348491191864014,
0.38702157139778137,
0.00929332710802555,
-0.1331302523612976,
-0.6967891454696655,
0.23378674685955048,
-0.14880438148975372,
-0.4620857238769531,
-0.0060881939716637135,
0.0954948365688324,
-0.308052659034729,
0.3355552852153778,
0.15458959341049194,
-0.5110264420509338,
0.0448969341814518,
-0.3539596498012543,
0.7835880517959595,
0.3978125751018524,
-0.18600483238697052,
0.30803194642066956,
-0.193370521068573,
0.5754867196083069,
-0.23969128727912903,
0.16977566480636597,
0.04184068739414215,
-0.6390625834465027,
-0.9551143646240234,
0.15606296062469482,
0.4318409264087677,
0.5131508111953735,
-0.9685423970222473,
0.2896788418292999,
-0.469257116317749,
-0.6029888391494751,
-0.5416476726531982,
0.45562419295310974,
0.09412644803524017,
0.3815964460372925,
0.43507930636405945,
0.20978905260562897,
-0.21331577003002167,
-0.9387959837913513,
-0.0671483725309372,
-0.5087717771530151,
-0.3467578589916229,
0.3809795379638672,
0.24650314450263977,
-0.13784833252429962,
0.9136499166488647,
-0.252432256937027,
-0.20150071382522583,
-0.43297478556632996,
0.07277970761060715,
0.17253151535987854,
-0.03307119384407997,
0.46698492765426636,
-1.0140719413757324,
-0.2070894092321396,
0.026423804461956024,
-0.6880316138267517,
-0.3535730838775635,
0.03197803720831871,
0.19247671961784363,
0.16499020159244537,
0.7190985083580017,
-0.6699399352073669,
-0.0908198207616806,
0.7750926613807678,
-0.24230115115642548,
0.2658644914627075,
-0.3033820688724518,
-0.09073853492736816,
-1.1103487014770508,
0.04250502586364746,
0.4374890625476837,
-0.2523249685764313,
-0.6248055696487427,
0.2321963608264923,
0.21497583389282227,
-0.5205649733543396,
-0.5566172003746033,
0.5025307536125183,
-0.5194713473320007,
-0.41145914793014526,
-0.13675574958324432,
0.4225195348262787,
-0.014953706413507462,
0.03195110708475113,
-0.06123201549053192,
1.3377983570098877,
0.18375474214553833,
-0.640586256980896,
0.5129262208938599,
0.32338249683380127,
-0.4828290343284607,
0.44853776693344116,
-0.817933976650238,
0.2777727246284485,
-0.07164329290390015,
0.17507889866828918,
-0.5769684910774231,
-0.025812121108174324,
0.08221009373664856,
-0.20860916376113892,
-0.1433989405632019,
-0.23345714807510376,
-1.0334206819534302,
-0.4270913600921631,
0.14259034395217896,
0.2707192897796631,
0.4432481527328491,
-0.5522292256355286,
0.9723241329193115,
0.6074073314666748,
-0.3604883551597595,
-0.07316362112760544,
-0.3437609374523163,
0.27796754240989685,
-0.1999543309211731,
-0.9123215079307556,
0.31688448786735535,
0.1056753620505333,
-0.19566978514194489,
-0.20947128534317017,
0.12273870408535004,
-0.29753193259239197,
0.13673394918441772,
0.1548394113779068,
0.23790405690670013,
-0.24821165204048157,
0.18116074800491333,
-0.6184195280075073,
-0.03878670558333397,
0.27212104201316833,
-0.1070106253027916,
0.6105496287345886,
-0.41398608684539795,
-0.18834637105464935,
-0.6914061307907104,
0.24374103546142578,
0.7092235088348389,
-0.47635403275489807,
0.5213490128517151,
0.40830639004707336,
-0.050815824419260025,
-0.05637994781136513,
-0.8022985458374023,
0.4189816415309906,
-0.5385940670967102,
0.1706022471189499,
-0.42073333263397217,
-0.7878885865211487,
0.6295701861381531,
-0.25393280386924744,
-0.14325818419456482,
0.4482349455356598,
0.47283121943473816,
0.09914343804121017,
0.917498767375946,
0.8479154109954834,
-0.24315588176250458,
0.3759169280529022,
-0.20122069120407104,
0.32446667551994324,
-0.9823068380355835,
-0.4665806293487549,
-1.0047807693481445,
0.12879976630210876,
-0.6237135529518127,
-0.6371833682060242,
0.552991509437561,
0.26062387228012085,
-0.050881922245025635,
0.24473656713962555,
0.09158340841531754,
0.5252015590667725,
0.3279901146888733,
0.016291506588459015,
0.4234630763530731,
-0.19656288623809814,
0.11825638264417648,
0.49216827750205994,
-0.7060893774032593,
-0.995302677154541,
0.9256803393363953,
0.6723715662956238,
0.8863831162452698,
0.2524719536304474,
0.220857635140419,
-0.019200671464204788,
0.4878735840320587,
-0.8238067030906677,
0.8894780278205872,
-0.22460588812828064,
-0.30157285928726196,
-0.22542424499988556,
-0.5395128130912781,
-0.6696741580963135,
0.07800264656543732,
-0.02737537771463394,
-0.769176721572876,
0.028596796095371246,
0.02737511321902275,
-0.43838009238243103,
0.31640660762786865,
-0.6772039532661438,
0.419550359249115,
-0.06101274862885475,
-0.173723503947258,
-0.2592783570289612,
-0.2712075412273407,
0.1760561764240265,
-0.12027907371520996,
0.13141804933547974,
-0.2774293124675751,
-0.3285229802131653,
0.6918292045593262,
-0.3992619216442108,
0.5691277980804443,
0.13960599899291992,
-0.5580395460128784,
0.47801995277404785,
-0.26885783672332764,
0.3705764412879944,
0.0726853758096695,
-0.8070090413093567,
0.35966673493385315,
-0.024526692926883698,
-0.3197038173675537,
-0.5542799234390259,
0.7082794904708862,
-1.0766828060150146,
-0.7079880237579346,
-0.029851442202925682,
-0.5792238712310791,
-0.5520635843276978,
0.30057692527770996,
-0.20866453647613525,
0.4019624590873718,
0.023989977315068245,
0.3215634524822235,
0.5941975712776184,
-0.21488425135612488,
0.5876421928405762,
0.7828739881515503,
-0.050472624599933624,
-0.11964955925941467,
0.6238236427307129,
0.015402178280055523,
0.38398367166519165,
0.27746346592903137,
-0.06836772710084915,
-0.5932271480560303,
-0.8301971554756165,
-0.5713068246841431,
0.3685375452041626,
-0.803234875202179,
-0.1437862068414688,
-0.6516339182853699,
-0.3957434296607971,
-0.13257254660129547,
0.09597977995872498,
0.016643352806568146,
-0.26621851325035095,
-0.4567009508609772,
0.23990485072135925,
0.06160486489534378,
0.5984517335891724,
0.3758351504802704,
0.3403216600418091,
-0.9351316690444946,
0.6103916764259338,
0.46470147371292114,
0.5456372499465942,
-0.2806892395019531,
-0.4331125020980835,
-0.19916605949401855,
0.03398188576102257,
-0.33400464057922363,
-0.8928465843200684,
0.12615346908569336,
0.17682747542858124,
0.5780524015426636,
0.09190196543931961,
-0.16457627713680267,
0.43193209171295166,
-0.4708337187767029,
0.9771072268486023,
-0.2028595507144928,
-1.0549449920654297,
0.2832774519920349,
-0.43529996275901794,
0.17603954672813416,
0.2816946506500244,
0.48278284072875977,
-0.4193781018257141,
-0.21350117027759552,
-0.539277970790863,
-0.6120453476905823,
0.35402271151542664,
0.05848788470029831,
0.4714154303073883,
0.11090743541717529,
0.7104184627532959,
-0.40606755018234253,
0.09281572699546814,
-0.5281352996826172,
0.028205545619130135,
0.16456489264965057,
0.06526333838701248,
-0.019973892718553543,
-0.5505738854408264,
-0.018349558115005493,
0.09698515385389328,
0.7333856225013733,
-0.3118916451931,
0.05629422515630722,
0.09955859929323196,
0.10534803569316864,
0.08735980093479156,
0.5139607787132263,
0.5661263465881348,
1.162934422492981,
-0.12842661142349243,
-0.20001421868801117,
0.39502406120300293,
-0.2800759971141815,
0.25289684534072876,
0.26432833075523376,
-0.2012341171503067,
0.14078158140182495,
0.235961452126503,
0.32191312313079834,
-0.38632655143737793,
-0.67228102684021,
0.39748644828796387,
-0.06093905121088028,
-0.2422291338443756,
-0.3587302267551422,
0.15262752771377563,
0.11824897676706314,
0.14822803437709808,
0.34864237904548645,
-0.3859507739543915,
-0.07292215526103973,
-0.5980260968208313,
-0.021410275250673294,
0.5373418927192688,
-0.22733812034130096,
-0.08901798725128174,
0.6237442493438721,
0.73209148645401,
-0.4357492923736572,
0.6479393243789673,
-0.10128042846918106,
-0.39920106530189514,
0.6753119230270386,
0.526183009147644,
0.6923120617866516,
-0.1529773771762848,
0.3678876459598541,
0.05328575149178505,
0.35780569911003113,
-0.2318301796913147,
0.4706724286079407,
0.23947648704051971,
-0.8468359112739563,
-0.640899121761322,
-0.4822806417942047,
-0.5344128012657166,
0.537903368473053,
-0.5381956696510315,
0.3510715365409851,
-0.49999403953552246,
-0.10313236713409424,
0.20616990327835083,
0.08887111395597458,
-0.9026631116867065,
0.24968448281288147,
0.06414158642292023,
1.3176331520080566,
-0.6163739562034607,
0.8936744332313538,
0.6997942924499512,
-0.34833312034606934,
-1.0910747051239014,
0.3422609269618988,
-0.3380041718482971,
-0.9603996872901917,
0.8903218507766724,
-0.0063805659301579,
-0.26858165860176086,
0.16300800442695618,
-0.16447612643241882,
-0.6855283975601196,
1.1102300882339478,
0.29243993759155273,
-0.4888176918029785,
-0.30262458324432373,
0.491144061088562,
0.5638930201530457,
-0.23051482439041138,
0.49228519201278687,
0.5941454172134399,
0.19363808631896973,
-0.034632597118616104,
-1.2350478172302246,
-0.031528860330581665,
-0.26310765743255615,
0.3240112066268921,
0.24223355948925018,
-0.9135634303092957,
0.644408106803894,
-0.20699910819530487,
-0.2525143623352051,
0.33732953667640686,
0.6071138978004456,
-0.13656017184257507,
-0.04073501005768776,
0.5494645833969116,
0.4528203010559082,
0.5061773657798767,
-0.0340249203145504,
1.1101677417755127,
-0.5836135149002075,
0.0710965171456337,
0.8470885157585144,
-0.40069127082824707,
0.9519163966178894,
0.47321251034736633,
-0.22341230511665344,
0.4260873794555664,
0.36610424518585205,
0.008418796584010124,
0.0607406310737133,
0.3160270154476166,
-0.20268554985523224,
-0.21822285652160645,
-0.1964048147201538,
-0.32362303137779236,
0.5114344358444214,
0.3957710266113281,
-0.410116970539093,
-0.505257248878479,
-0.2606370747089386,
-0.0323963537812233,
0.04084968566894531,
-0.5069052577018738,
0.7448498606681824,
0.008496743626892567,
-0.6996463537216187,
0.6447225213050842,
0.41946321725845337,
0.1962708681821823,
-0.4381466507911682,
-0.08393432199954987,
-0.2537767291069031,
0.09828189760446548,
-0.06303568184375763,
-0.8742489814758301,
0.1782272607088089,
0.14326535165309906,
-0.00894062127918005,
-0.08421509712934494,
0.31344008445739746,
-0.10864577442407608,
-0.45703959465026855,
0.05012119561433792,
0.44115740060806274,
0.05844811350107193,
0.07522991299629211,
-0.6779525279998779,
0.20805907249450684,
-0.1892736405134201,
0.13930588960647583,
0.05143702030181885,
0.46146154403686523,
0.05881045013666153,
1.3107686042785645,
0.5481393337249756,
0.49256670475006104,
-0.058888956904411316,
0.2622559666633606,
0.9624016880989075,
-0.37571248412132263,
-0.5264865756034851,
-0.6792582273483276,
0.13315673172473907,
-0.161145880818367,
-0.4194943308830261,
0.5495901703834534,
0.5573123693466187,
0.8234589695930481,
0.23454664647579193,
0.7738011479377747,
0.22187219560146332,
0.36119526624679565,
-1.0405882596969604,
0.24404320120811462,
-0.3362966775894165,
0.7897450923919678,
-0.0015369390603154898,
-0.9497810006141663,
-0.19078832864761353,
0.4551447033882141,
-0.6835392713546753,
-0.0028889793902635574,
0.375458687543869,
0.9266191124916077,
-0.0500774160027504,
0.21735608577728271,
0.10426522046327591,
-0.10621786117553711,
0.7026186585426331,
0.4645615220069885,
0.9617593288421631,
-0.45617616176605225,
0.8793571591377258,
0.043690070509910583,
-0.0015389584004878998,
-0.2599226236343384,
-0.973071277141571,
-0.9709492325782776,
-0.42773178219795227,
-0.19463373720645905,
-0.43184375762939453,
0.2301430106163025,
0.6827030181884766,
0.8139023780822754,
-0.2825726568698883,
-0.2569402754306793,
-0.13002488017082214,
0.0371064655482769,
0.11243078112602234,
-0.17313478887081146,
0.25942009687423706,
-0.42846331000328064,
-0.7391376495361328,
0.2525002658367157,
0.14092735946178436,
0.33999356627464294,
-0.5602236390113831,
0.04307073727250099,
0.10392864048480988,
0.016748353838920593,
0.5440507531166077,
0.3790304362773895,
-0.7476990818977356,
-0.24764883518218994,
-0.09525862336158752,
-0.11221842467784882,
-0.09431998431682587,
0.9210847020149231,
-0.6117194294929504,
0.21266119182109833,
0.45719635486602783,
0.697730302810669,
0.12801781296730042,
0.28893738985061646,
0.9056673049926758,
-0.29510948061943054,
0.1955678015947342,
0.3664934039115906,
0.445849746465683,
0.39233389496803284,
-0.19904038310050964,
0.5953910946846008,
-0.35141003131866455,
-0.7689023613929749,
-0.43796300888061523,
0.3986760973930359,
-0.6838660836219788,
0.003539271652698517,
1.4883222579956055,
-0.21283483505249023,
0.04749027639627457,
-0.3189964294433594,
-0.16517439484596252,
-0.05839267745614052,
-0.17937931418418884,
0.8322461843490601,
0.6070218086242676,
-0.07045642286539078,
-0.3622061312198639,
-0.9034726023674011,
0.5476313233375549,
0.31000789999961853,
-1.2071235179901123,
0.05773334950208664,
0.4279249310493469,
0.3066723048686981,
0.20392043888568878,
0.7668919563293457,
-0.22030100226402283,
0.10582655668258667,
-0.43810558319091797,
-0.3674301505088806,
-0.12187391519546509,
-0.26999980211257935,
-0.15896514058113098,
0.2527244985103607,
0.43096238374710083,
-0.07898362725973129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01786v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01786v1
|
Generative AI-Based Text Generation Methods Using Pre-Trained GPT-2 Model
| 2024-04-02T09:49:53 | 2024-04-02T09:49:53 |
Rohit Pandey, Hetvi Waghela, Sneha Rakshit, Aparna Rangari, Anjali Singh, Rahul Kumar, Ratnadeep Ghosal, Jaydip Sen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work delved into the realm of automatic text generation, exploring a
variety of techniques ranging from traditional deterministic approaches to more
modern stochastic methods. Through analysis of greedy search, beam search,
top-k sampling, top-p sampling, contrastive searching, and locally typical
searching, this work has provided valuable insights into the strengths,
weaknesses, and potential applications of each method. Each text-generating
method is evaluated using several standard metrics and a comparative study has
been made on the performance of the approaches. Finally, some future directions
of research in the field of automatic text generation are also identified.
|
[
-0.2570309042930603,
-1.0425457954406738,
0.7963584661483765,
-0.061736855655908585,
-0.22803041338920593,
-0.06614472717046738,
0.008959557861089706,
-0.231570765376091,
-0.1665896773338318,
0.16763252019882202,
-0.6666860580444336,
-0.3030768036842346,
-0.6438256502151489,
0.41583043336868286,
-0.486552357673645,
1.0830976963043213,
-0.28105685114860535,
-0.0520595945417881,
-0.07053714245557785,
0.5151218175888062,
-0.5538569688796997,
-0.22874018549919128,
-0.9563900828361511,
-0.14920085668563843,
0.18257242441177368,
0.2501335144042969,
0.6000613570213318,
0.47530505061149597,
0.6826996803283691,
0.2761089503765106,
0.2604004144668579,
0.20541009306907654,
-0.2666185796260834,
0.26374369859695435,
0.0008624616893939674,
-0.35158810019493103,
-0.07825787365436554,
0.31202054023742676,
0.4103323519229889,
-0.10866906493902206,
-0.11550569534301758,
-0.017420323565602303,
-0.14274312555789948,
0.5546144843101501,
-0.4665031135082245,
0.04724389314651489,
-0.7044804096221924,
0.4156387150287628,
-0.5533847212791443,
-0.46428540349006653,
-0.3597024381160736,
-0.4477902948856354,
0.1447685807943344,
-0.5570350885391235,
0.7024062871932983,
-0.05729521065950394,
0.8440244197845459,
0.4111715853214264,
-0.5057197213172913,
-0.8753978610038757,
-0.7996844053268433,
0.8657881617546082,
-0.6779307723045349,
-0.036696672439575195,
0.6219888925552368,
0.345163494348526,
-0.15377309918403625,
-0.9468105435371399,
-0.49930354952812195,
-0.5343930721282959,
-0.12299063056707382,
0.49297016859054565,
-0.025095302611589432,
0.017646849155426025,
0.16326893866062164,
0.5891169905662537,
-0.8661305904388428,
0.15796703100204468,
-0.16738587617874146,
0.056611567735672,
0.8902387022972107,
0.07695258408784866,
0.5242683291435242,
-0.20322208106517792,
-0.1350633203983307,
-0.3256300687789917,
-0.6213544011116028,
-0.3344810903072357,
0.5132482647895813,
-0.038494449108839035,
0.0360347256064415,
0.7814453840255737,
-0.001580019947141409,
0.6572352647781372,
0.089429572224617,
-0.030069954693317413,
-0.0019935928285121918,
-0.7852291464805603,
-0.25065383315086365,
-0.3372025489807129,
1.1191846132278442,
0.12242238223552704,
0.36037886142730713,
-0.16181734204292297,
-0.29995638132095337,
-0.02533767931163311,
0.39227214455604553,
-0.6846036911010742,
-0.31148964166641235,
0.08153830468654633,
-0.6912873387336731,
-0.7799831032752991,
-0.18672771751880646,
-0.6725524663925171,
0.12896747887134552,
-0.29754191637039185,
0.32621997594833374,
-0.5744000673294067,
-0.2062084823846817,
-0.4885386824607849,
-0.3043559789657593,
0.12380176037549973,
0.19543935358524323,
-1.0900899171829224,
-0.1260378211736679,
0.14061996340751648,
0.7703166604042053,
-0.13199354708194733,
-0.10974454879760742,
-0.2572549283504486,
0.06377402693033218,
-0.7299796342849731,
0.8667349815368652,
-0.3432174623012543,
-0.5000088214874268,
0.163564994931221,
-0.6809436678886414,
-0.0509498193860054,
-0.4515288174152374,
0.43003249168395996,
-0.5502249002456665,
0.661236584186554,
0.06819527596235275,
-0.49498146772384644,
0.08948050439357758,
0.024638695642352104,
-0.6638669967651367,
1.2730512619018555,
0.23276185989379883,
-0.8948046565055847,
0.6063905954360962,
-0.7666656970977783,
-0.7681799530982971,
0.12407434731721878,
-0.5569016933441162,
-0.8310136795043945,
0.40952906012535095,
0.40197938680648804,
0.3750748932361603,
-0.6036357283592224,
0.32849541306495667,
0.47783201932907104,
-0.17635288834571838,
0.06364847719669342,
-0.5820152163505554,
0.5985133051872253,
0.6607548594474792,
-0.6594148278236389,
0.12007419764995575,
-0.5033506155014038,
0.16439825296401978,
0.5909278988838196,
-0.29429084062576294,
-0.07195936888456345,
0.18556848168373108,
0.24844488501548767,
0.08327656239271164,
0.22616547346115112,
-0.06085687875747681,
0.34601154923439026,
-0.46326762437820435,
0.45559045672416687,
0.4776439666748047,
0.06883908808231354,
0.28964272141456604,
-0.29724815487861633,
0.5765652656555176,
-0.05366047844290733,
-0.0691714957356453,
-0.43491318821907043,
-0.5688467025756836,
-0.529646635055542,
0.025912664830684662,
0.2538798153400421,
0.6645188331604004,
-1.2467241287231445,
0.32054099440574646,
0.23118098080158234,
-0.637347936630249,
-0.2004861831665039,
-0.03277834877371788,
0.4917604625225067,
0.2544468641281128,
0.3326466679573059,
-0.31551700830459595,
-0.4206761419773102,
-0.6877872943878174,
-0.027516016736626625,
-0.23484137654304504,
-0.13409192860126495,
0.29774022102355957,
0.45750725269317627,
-0.3643310070037842,
0.9707947969436646,
-0.6267068982124329,
-0.12990988790988922,
-0.28444138169288635,
0.8207221627235413,
-0.23993901908397675,
0.4678773283958435,
0.6929944753646851,
-1.0073745250701904,
-0.6107465028762817,
-0.2284308820962906,
-0.9233811497688293,
0.06043366715312004,
-0.40726059675216675,
-0.03373138606548309,
0.32551851868629456,
0.4764586091041565,
-0.8776893615722656,
0.7536877989768982,
0.220720574259758,
0.056770045310258865,
0.7744640707969666,
-0.3845686614513397,
0.35829073190689087,
-1.432573914527893,
-0.14173713326454163,
0.09929526597261429,
0.027288120239973068,
-0.6510396599769592,
0.27173948287963867,
-0.23533283174037933,
-0.3040188252925873,
-0.17728488147258759,
0.41287195682525635,
-0.5971625447273254,
0.0027239015325903893,
-0.5594736337661743,
0.043099142611026764,
-0.38982999324798584,
0.1787761151790619,
0.20327168703079224,
1.2934528589248657,
0.38267117738723755,
-0.6369198560714722,
0.4231398403644562,
0.2396085262298584,
-0.29344049096107483,
0.17971371114253998,
-0.647530734539032,
0.35072314739227295,
-0.3592927157878876,
0.250139445066452,
-1.1069022417068481,
-0.3017909526824951,
0.23257477581501007,
-0.5596657395362854,
0.4459557831287384,
0.2536355257034302,
-0.6633551120758057,
-0.6122172474861145,
-0.14613348245620728,
0.5794349908828735,
0.6651222109794617,
-0.20016540586948395,
0.08516963571310043,
0.1467321515083313,
-0.6894538998603821,
-0.23024600744247437,
-0.6119084358215332,
0.24426107108592987,
-0.253633588552475,
-0.3276180922985077,
0.5237554907798767,
-0.04899534583091736,
-0.11484198272228241,
-0.3362685441970825,
0.47453388571739197,
0.02867097780108452,
0.10524263232946396,
-0.2690257728099823,
0.1319768726825714,
-0.1110154390335083,
0.11380752176046371,
0.2527807354927063,
-0.25760242342948914,
-0.2711520493030548,
-0.46848589181900024,
0.628150999546051,
0.24606099724769592,
-0.1826065480709076,
-0.5232388973236084,
0.7523183226585388,
0.0018117940053343773,
-0.3919118642807007,
0.19104930758476257,
0.8127422332763672,
-0.32688605785369873,
-0.13112731277942657,
-0.3323570787906647,
-0.18794411420822144,
-0.4529443383216858,
0.5728074908256531,
-0.23615555465221405,
-0.6665154695510864,
0.03470002859830856,
-0.0072843702509999275,
0.00008535551751265302,
0.6867067813873291,
1.0376675128936768,
-0.13561882078647614,
1.1888465881347656,
0.6711087226867676,
0.12435170263051987,
0.6373043656349182,
-0.030472731217741966,
0.17423443496227264,
-0.22144991159439087,
0.0913599357008934,
-0.6221205592155457,
-0.04706911742687225,
-1.0535986423492432,
-0.26686710119247437,
0.23413899540901184,
0.14678135514259338,
-0.29938650131225586,
0.29285481572151184,
-0.8686543107032776,
0.19808728992938995,
1.1122493743896484,
-0.24678269028663635,
0.10073655098676682,
0.23523719608783722,
-0.16917303204536438,
-0.11433146893978119,
-0.5859793424606323,
-0.45383384823799133,
1.4241622686386108,
-0.01637621410191059,
0.5442612171173096,
-0.033839043229818344,
0.9034374952316284,
0.45534446835517883,
0.5635632276535034,
-0.5627216696739197,
0.3063306510448456,
-0.240404412150383,
-0.5939328670501709,
-0.5411695837974548,
-0.5395352244377136,
-0.9450752139091492,
-0.2416297048330307,
-0.16847389936447144,
-0.5294927358627319,
-0.3936150074005127,
0.31433871388435364,
-0.12804928421974182,
0.015487194061279297,
-0.5330731272697449,
0.5408111810684204,
-0.5231160521507263,
-0.056232865899801254,
-0.02786828763782978,
-0.5193765163421631,
0.16629470884799957,
-0.17222243547439575,
-0.14878953993320465,
0.41307592391967773,
0.379421591758728,
0.6552193760871887,
-0.20208851993083954,
0.3624449670314789,
-0.1983702927827835,
-0.31350770592689514,
0.6672002673149109,
-0.10682519525289536,
0.8564116954803467,
-0.07742013782262802,
0.16164875030517578,
-0.137171670794487,
-0.43813928961753845,
-0.13983553647994995,
-0.26567700505256653,
0.2141733020544052,
-0.8131794929504395,
-0.3745655119419098,
-0.30388975143432617,
-0.5645959973335266,
-0.09504007548093796,
0.39456942677497864,
1.1525341272354126,
0.19198289513587952,
-0.3449065685272217,
-0.35286280512809753,
0.4634797275066376,
-0.46354231238365173,
0.6324169039726257,
-0.11688024550676346,
-0.01958172768354416,
-0.5924030542373657,
0.9190853238105774,
-0.010866469703614712,
-0.06281869113445282,
0.699245274066925,
-0.012180667370557785,
-0.3421012759208679,
-0.8111054301261902,
-0.7592828273773193,
-0.0980907753109932,
-0.16989962756633759,
-0.27993133664131165,
-0.3606707751750946,
-0.44932428002357483,
-0.6706904172897339,
-0.349652498960495,
-0.18296435475349426,
-0.18412166833877563,
-0.5018599033355713,
-0.179539754986763,
0.10708384960889816,
0.808952808380127,
0.08181443065404892,
0.5958148837089539,
-0.6353551149368286,
0.4634852409362793,
0.4074819087982178,
-0.06814967840909958,
-0.11600516736507416,
0.17291121184825897,
-0.21427837014198303,
0.012906483374536037,
-0.7410723567008972,
-0.9644269347190857,
0.5966557264328003,
0.07246612757444382,
0.5032422542572021,
0.2768101692199707,
-0.2739301323890686,
0.10209770500659943,
-0.7810707688331604,
0.9578064680099487,
0.3542807102203369,
-0.5288517475128174,
1.0291011333465576,
-0.6630403399467468,
0.11974158883094788,
0.5322829484939575,
0.4274463653564453,
-0.0455501414835453,
-0.4234943091869354,
-0.5977510213851929,
-0.8486530780792236,
0.5119926333427429,
0.7938525080680847,
0.12516918778419495,
-0.12349718064069748,
0.45706918835639954,
0.09854482114315033,
0.42016902565956116,
-0.6862601637840271,
-0.24102100729942322,
-0.44862887263298035,
-0.6787651777267456,
-0.2379101812839508,
-0.22068987786769867,
0.05849889665842056,
0.2613803446292877,
0.5727190971374512,
-0.13211706280708313,
0.785081148147583,
0.2191733866930008,
0.05735452100634575,
0.04746390879154205,
0.20982296764850616,
0.8040988445281982,
0.40677610039711,
0.024067604914307594,
-0.21548601984977722,
-0.17820246517658234,
-0.5986793637275696,
0.3779654800891876,
0.4838298559188843,
-0.7284478545188904,
-0.009913811460137367,
0.17950040102005005,
0.8017213344573975,
-0.43188735842704773,
-0.4670189321041107,
0.2806151211261749,
-0.08593621850013733,
-0.5001599192619324,
-0.45128333568573,
0.1682525873184204,
-0.18418218195438385,
-0.01839042641222477,
0.6401380300521851,
-0.1265232264995575,
0.3024502396583557,
-0.3807658553123474,
0.32233741879463196,
0.5454261302947998,
-0.25990480184555054,
-0.10229921340942383,
1.0082122087478638,
0.18180637061595917,
-0.467364639043808,
0.87330561876297,
-0.5070265531539917,
-0.21152938902378082,
0.6680178642272949,
0.834287703037262,
1.1949793100357056,
-0.1978660672903061,
0.44773250818252563,
0.2780081331729889,
0.3466734290122986,
-0.05862419307231903,
0.11726559698581696,
-0.35471075773239136,
-0.5083361268043518,
-0.3609878122806549,
-0.46273770928382874,
-0.23961204290390015,
0.3058761954307556,
-0.36068248748779297,
0.039651092141866684,
-0.11910111457109451,
-0.4512869119644165,
-0.089176245033741,
0.1569887399673462,
-0.7451242804527283,
0.6128762364387512,
-0.023090451955795288,
0.6277738809585571,
-0.5336836576461792,
0.46371224522590637,
0.8415414690971375,
-0.6715148091316223,
-0.6373828649520874,
0.47457438707351685,
0.054321009665727615,
-0.6939976811408997,
0.673263430595398,
0.03703897073864937,
0.018662186339497566,
0.2603888213634491,
-0.5954206585884094,
-0.7631543874740601,
1.2197235822677612,
-0.064146488904953,
-0.38270488381385803,
-0.5309779644012451,
0.19025196135044098,
0.5398348569869995,
-0.21214695274829865,
0.5653733015060425,
0.3363451361656189,
0.4200379550457001,
-0.09274980425834656,
-0.7498044371604919,
-0.14207127690315247,
-0.44645804166793823,
0.5592204928398132,
0.0682850182056427,
-0.6938917636871338,
0.8925206065177917,
-0.11629612743854523,
-0.3706112802028656,
0.5497280955314636,
0.6776130795478821,
0.3126252591609955,
0.4183618128299713,
0.008113269694149494,
0.5745961666107178,
0.6281476616859436,
-0.0706811249256134,
1.0321049690246582,
-0.15630477666854858,
0.43753597140312195,
0.8590607047080994,
-0.14079324901103973,
0.3349260985851288,
0.11350474506616592,
-0.24742987751960754,
0.29441946744918823,
0.7562786936759949,
-0.2637220323085785,
0.8137189745903015,
0.2507920563220978,
-0.24401505291461945,
0.032219890505075455,
0.25644341111183167,
-0.5088678002357483,
0.38270244002342224,
0.12195779383182526,
-0.590070903301239,
-0.19583389163017273,
0.03843510523438454,
-0.07232078909873962,
0.11109993606805801,
-0.13738135993480682,
0.9969258308410645,
-0.020044540986418724,
-0.8982561826705933,
0.1155972108244896,
0.4508032202720642,
0.7966499328613281,
-0.4395582675933838,
-0.048706796020269394,
-0.1871994584798813,
-0.07930151373147964,
0.20510154962539673,
-0.457672119140625,
0.10022725909948349,
0.19750207662582397,
-0.25010308623313904,
-0.3524985909461975,
1.0802597999572754,
-0.1652470827102661,
-0.5994789004325867,
-0.2787186801433563,
0.6743406057357788,
0.021054832264780998,
0.07730186730623245,
-0.5252037644386292,
-0.47578728199005127,
0.17235223948955536,
-0.43315455317497253,
0.1883237063884735,
0.40930822491645813,
-0.016158059239387512,
0.30878710746765137,
0.6054795384407043,
0.03818332403898239,
-0.07520583271980286,
-0.05737664923071861,
0.3720124065876007,
-0.7672757506370544,
-0.6110592484474182,
-0.7050301432609558,
0.3165825605392456,
0.0459953248500824,
-0.561636745929718,
0.5890388488769531,
0.4912862181663513,
0.8859073519706726,
-0.20814161002635956,
1.3210636377334595,
-0.1585778445005417,
0.48648110032081604,
-0.9182488322257996,
0.9168408513069153,
-0.43407464027404785,
-0.3466375768184662,
-0.48276376724243164,
-0.8573631048202515,
-0.220829576253891,
0.8718109726905823,
-0.25599080324172974,
0.5468538403511047,
0.49343979358673096,
0.4944938123226166,
0.25780588388442993,
0.07586058974266052,
-0.06508465856313705,
-0.21224744617938995,
0.5350181460380554,
0.5523263216018677,
0.8572809100151062,
-0.625872015953064,
0.46280914545059204,
0.17863216996192932,
-0.25966665148735046,
-0.19237320125102997,
-0.7034707069396973,
-0.7556942701339722,
-0.7917655110359192,
-0.141987144947052,
0.008030029013752937,
0.18660421669483185,
0.44239816069602966,
0.6603894233703613,
-0.5148103833198547,
0.1607029139995575,
-0.8526683449745178,
-0.23501981794834137,
-0.1514340192079544,
-0.3043273687362671,
0.5597372055053711,
-0.683678925037384,
-0.8947897553443909,
0.32074716687202454,
-0.03253502771258354,
0.463412344455719,
-0.12235900014638901,
-0.022198433056473732,
-0.06601126492023468,
0.08814483135938644,
0.5356380939483643,
0.0371740348637104,
-0.20829755067825317,
-0.009250673465430737,
-0.11513855308294296,
-0.31419575214385986,
-0.047151174396276474,
1.0605056285858154,
-0.6923857927322388,
0.20650577545166016,
0.538455605506897,
0.5851603746414185,
0.6327787637710571,
0.22540952265262604,
0.7617473602294922,
-0.7666787505149841,
0.10708492994308472,
0.3211789131164551,
-0.20097246766090393,
0.17366428673267365,
-0.43487295508384705,
0.4829433560371399,
0.22131837904453278,
-0.762908935546875,
-0.46949106454849243,
0.4908251464366913,
-0.36255839467048645,
-0.17776167392730713,
0.9470559358596802,
0.2499215453863144,
0.330697625875473,
0.10747501999139786,
-0.33874377608299255,
0.5815401673316956,
-0.15934361517429352,
0.8689076900482178,
0.5626579523086548,
-0.338356077671051,
-0.0490289106965065,
-0.6164222359657288,
0.8888751268386841,
0.3304819166660309,
-1.0753170251846313,
-0.2873170077800751,
0.6375848650932312,
-0.12218007445335388,
0.2520923614501953,
1.084549903869629,
-0.09018656611442566,
0.3071291446685791,
0.4044129550457001,
-0.026816535741090775,
-0.0426362119615078,
-0.32476791739463806,
0.2941933572292328,
0.1157384067773819,
0.05054039880633354,
0.03151415288448334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01785v1
|
Can Humans Identify Domains?
| 2024-04-02T09:49:07 | 2024-04-02T09:49:07 |
Maria Barrett, Max Müller-Eberstein, Elisa Bassignana, Amalie Brogaard Pauli, Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Textual domain is a crucial property within the Natural Language Processing
(NLP) community due to its effects on downstream model performance. The concept
itself is, however, loosely defined and, in practice, refers to any
non-typological property, such as genre, topic, medium or style of a document.
We investigate the core notion of domains via human proficiency in identifying
related intrinsic textual properties, specifically the concepts of genre
(communicative purpose) and topic (subject matter). We publish our annotations
in *TGeGUM*: A collection of 9.1k sentences from the GUM dataset (Zeldes, 2017)
with single sentence and larger context (i.e., prose) annotations for one of 11
genres (source type), and its topic/subtopic as per the Dewey Decimal library
classification system (Dewey, 1979), consisting of 10/100 hierarchical topics
of increased granularity. Each instance is annotated by three annotators, for a
total of 32.7k annotations, allowing us to examine the level of human
disagreement and the relative difficulty of each annotation task. With a
Fleiss' kappa of at most 0.53 on the sentence level and 0.66 at the prose
level, it is evident that despite the ubiquity of domains in NLP, there is
little human consensus on how to define them. By training classifiers to
perform the same task, we find that this uncertainty also extends to NLP
models.
|
[
-0.502186119556427,
-0.8496201038360596,
0.39073604345321655,
0.11012300103902817,
-0.269557386636734,
0.39351794123649597,
-0.6143093705177307,
-0.5218826532363892,
0.0772591158747673,
0.6585609912872314,
-0.43200910091400146,
-0.6123756170272827,
-0.84035325050354,
0.10907217860221863,
-0.10574033856391907,
1.0505143404006958,
0.05297083407640457,
-0.5270093679428101,
-0.46922340989112854,
-0.21779826283454895,
-0.5356895923614502,
-0.9818733334541321,
-0.4078362286090851,
-0.4735983610153198,
0.3884127736091614,
0.11233192682266235,
0.49964895844459534,
0.4277222752571106,
0.4311220049858093,
0.2960563600063324,
-0.08329872041940689,
0.17442895472049713,
-0.3906559348106384,
0.17803151905536652,
-0.5128188133239746,
-0.5264354348182678,
-0.29969388246536255,
0.2455349862575531,
0.3036491274833679,
1.0802741050720215,
0.14574825763702393,
0.20753070712089539,
0.15418082475662231,
0.5835351347923279,
-0.4351949095726013,
0.1456071436405182,
-0.8123898506164551,
-0.06680700927972794,
-0.6805758476257324,
-0.7081915140151978,
-0.570856511592865,
-0.0648677870631218,
0.5588929057121277,
-0.9467251300811768,
0.6684296131134033,
0.32790616154670715,
1.3526403903961182,
0.3158544600009918,
-0.5519703030586243,
-0.26108071208000183,
-0.6753678917884827,
0.9251722693443298,
-0.25999554991722107,
0.27664172649383545,
0.9107810258865356,
-0.09742444008588791,
0.007141348905861378,
-0.5530757308006287,
-0.3755005896091461,
0.0236757081001997,
-0.2944200038909912,
-0.2669311463832855,
-0.1565423458814621,
-0.08764427155256271,
0.2511688768863678,
0.2323082536458969,
-0.5615585446357727,
-0.1815447360277176,
-0.36437124013900757,
-0.4522271454334259,
0.6950921416282654,
0.09164708107709885,
0.5296494364738464,
-0.34006020426750183,
-0.387764573097229,
0.29450082778930664,
-0.5607964992523193,
0.4386399984359741,
0.13667213916778564,
0.33037808537483215,
0.2015526443719864,
0.5043318867683411,
-0.1117376759648323,
0.7096735835075378,
0.0546775683760643,
-0.41262108087539673,
0.11709773540496826,
-0.155291348695755,
-0.17202073335647583,
-0.07142392545938492,
0.603190004825592,
0.1827559620141983,
0.5737000703811646,
-0.2880760133266449,
0.02674025669693947,
0.26626598834991455,
0.6470340490341187,
-0.37443530559539795,
-0.22220201790332794,
0.09667299687862396,
-0.30284440517425537,
-0.019908621907234192,
0.009381653741002083,
-0.40535491704940796,
-0.3477022051811218,
-0.5640866160392761,
0.21977119147777557,
-0.5705370306968689,
-0.30712372064590454,
0.13204734027385712,
-0.24616606533527374,
0.03966173902153969,
0.3130561113357544,
-1.1188204288482666,
0.7609413266181946,
0.988304078578949,
0.6024948358535767,
-0.43509870767593384,
-0.437366783618927,
-0.0918210819363594,
0.043981458991765976,
-0.2879038453102112,
0.9982008934020996,
-0.6127663850784302,
-0.25110337138175964,
-0.046930842101573944,
-0.05540205538272858,
-0.3346102833747864,
-0.6717644333839417,
0.7869971990585327,
-0.5920977592468262,
0.045901745557785034,
-0.174557164311409,
-0.8117662072181702,
-0.3898564577102661,
-0.07233252376317978,
-0.5988245606422424,
1.0181852579116821,
0.2452240288257599,
-0.8156737089157104,
0.6276455521583557,
-0.35859811305999756,
-0.5485890507698059,
0.29788628220558167,
-0.10323590785264969,
-0.17485707998275757,
0.014192195609211922,
-0.21319371461868286,
0.5847291946411133,
-0.33078035712242126,
0.8222148418426514,
0.020709995180368423,
-0.29089656472206116,
0.5809570550918579,
-0.22826015949249268,
0.699170708656311,
-0.13045468926429749,
-0.32706719636917114,
0.007386072538793087,
-0.5826727151870728,
-0.016423221677541733,
-0.17525285482406616,
-0.1087268590927124,
-0.819491982460022,
0.02595272846519947,
0.3368496596813202,
0.1921444833278656,
0.10745657980442047,
-0.40210670232772827,
0.11154599487781525,
-0.3288356363773346,
0.5254361033439636,
0.5328614115715027,
0.2968570590019226,
0.3625076711177826,
-0.5106992125511169,
0.4830804467201233,
-0.19057364761829376,
-0.33013540506362915,
0.06786078959703445,
-0.9528217315673828,
-0.6680085062980652,
-0.3985650837421417,
0.6386408805847168,
0.40485459566116333,
-0.3977106809616089,
0.8046690821647644,
-0.3908742666244507,
-0.3938189148902893,
-0.3900500237941742,
-0.008624736219644547,
0.39050987362861633,
0.4938843846321106,
0.3325582444667816,
-0.3658232092857361,
-0.2301149219274521,
-0.9357914924621582,
-0.25252994894981384,
-0.23914329707622528,
-0.10350321978330612,
0.3866468369960785,
0.6695196032524109,
0.1345990151166916,
1.4199519157409668,
-0.6057212948799133,
-0.5740352869033813,
-0.17548906803131104,
0.6095735430717468,
-0.24901530146598816,
0.17177759110927582,
0.5180623531341553,
-1.0443464517593384,
-0.42002254724502563,
0.009247377514839172,
-0.7982656955718994,
-0.3603476583957672,
-0.1831209361553192,
-0.18674476444721222,
0.2787861227989197,
0.18299390375614166,
-0.5417644381523132,
0.5072786211967468,
0.0779801458120346,
-0.6137521862983704,
0.44251716136932373,
-0.016949303448200226,
0.02339949645102024,
-0.6866421699523926,
0.17464151978492737,
0.30930793285369873,
-0.1467241793870926,
-0.7285181283950806,
-0.04970075935125351,
-0.08686510473489761,
-0.02224162593483925,
-0.27403131127357483,
0.7214087843894958,
-0.1233580932021141,
0.059852875769138336,
-0.2470245659351349,
0.3166041672229767,
0.4401834309101105,
0.7974568605422974,
0.5063278079032898,
0.7013870477676392,
0.40885376930236816,
-0.7246055603027344,
-0.06621016561985016,
0.3854099214076996,
-0.3001450002193451,
0.8260175585746765,
-0.48888295888900757,
-0.08045224100351334,
-0.029160426929593086,
0.2509761154651642,
-0.6002353429794312,
-0.29739636182785034,
0.16692973673343658,
-0.6071426272392273,
0.3087523281574249,
-0.16978046298027039,
-0.21461084485054016,
0.0586833655834198,
-0.03950515016913414,
0.2999975085258484,
0.2909546494483948,
0.03088267892599106,
0.46056729555130005,
0.651736855506897,
-0.3740207850933075,
-0.5774362683296204,
-0.5025743246078491,
0.30896440148353577,
-0.4225182831287384,
-0.7127456665039062,
0.5930359959602356,
0.08535116910934448,
-0.48617276549339294,
0.17385759949684143,
0.021365180611610413,
-0.577516496181488,
0.37448129057884216,
0.533477246761322,
0.13535307347774506,
-0.2217387557029724,
0.451331228017807,
0.05688920244574547,
-0.21514981985092163,
0.05869314819574356,
-0.4355076849460602,
0.28377676010131836,
-0.0413573756814003,
0.0835542380809784,
-0.5134174227714539,
0.41917291283607483,
0.16876894235610962,
-0.4029214680194855,
0.3510690927505493,
0.21525439620018005,
-0.541252613067627,
-0.44607141613960266,
-0.2583286464214325,
0.1500757336616516,
-0.3719475269317627,
0.10517849773168564,
-0.6029120683670044,
-0.9228537678718567,
0.30595093965530396,
-0.01269999798387289,
-0.28094282746315,
0.765127956867218,
0.5013635754585266,
-0.05974629893898964,
0.0683136135339737,
0.7580764889717102,
0.16675911843776703,
-0.05617832764983177,
-0.4130343198776245,
0.2495618611574173,
-0.9469605684280396,
-0.2039676457643509,
-0.6167494654655457,
-0.22897672653198242,
-0.5690136551856995,
-0.38246050477027893,
-0.028661781921982765,
0.10931012779474258,
0.07081679254770279,
0.500478208065033,
-0.4814004600048065,
0.1992025524377823,
0.48586660623550415,
-0.11574622988700867,
0.33033648133277893,
-0.04263095557689667,
-0.04158562794327736,
-0.5368298888206482,
-0.2651727795600891,
-1.080612063407898,
1.0446715354919434,
0.35372406244277954,
0.2175525724887848,
-0.09162116050720215,
0.6051036715507507,
0.71976238489151,
0.3949689269065857,
-0.92083740234375,
0.532581627368927,
-0.1574023813009262,
-0.8973557353019714,
-0.3921051323413849,
-0.08885569125413895,
-1.0400246381759644,
0.3140901029109955,
-0.2812325358390808,
-0.9963257312774658,
0.365075021982193,
-0.2965943217277527,
-0.3549994230270386,
0.22560638189315796,
-0.5090033411979675,
0.94509357213974,
0.07057873159646988,
-0.24406003952026367,
0.158052459359169,
-0.6259371638298035,
0.12540803849697113,
-0.4041404128074646,
0.12608613073825836,
-0.5516864657402039,
-0.21200817823410034,
0.9845428466796875,
-0.17294012010097504,
0.9506450891494751,
0.06347248703241348,
-0.049503013491630554,
0.5013426542282104,
0.03941818326711655,
-0.27406391501426697,
-0.014290560968220234,
0.005805048625916243,
0.36964383721351624,
-0.15388000011444092,
-0.3257957994937897,
-0.6390308141708374,
0.24551720917224884,
-0.8375311493873596,
-0.5748255848884583,
-0.5494895577430725,
-0.2707199156284332,
-0.34380409121513367,
0.2639235854148865,
0.37816575169563293,
0.7347137331962585,
-0.4469534456729889,
0.1301872283220291,
0.6543522477149963,
0.08661849796772003,
0.22051891684532166,
0.3850666880607605,
0.10552361607551575,
-0.001651184749789536,
1.2239677906036377,
0.02436172217130661,
0.1144753247499466,
0.5871517658233643,
0.1736898422241211,
-0.23041167855262756,
-0.6608765721321106,
-0.3188178241252899,
0.24102629721164703,
-0.6962303519248962,
-0.16151511669158936,
-1.058994174003601,
-0.204660564661026,
-0.11697980016469955,
-0.25749868154525757,
0.06374511122703552,
-0.5421306490898132,
-0.42434701323509216,
-0.051830124109983444,
0.2514800429344177,
0.806625485420227,
0.48297443985939026,
0.22097375988960266,
-0.6761423945426941,
0.5153722167015076,
0.2573755979537964,
0.2418777197599411,
-0.2657729387283325,
-0.7405573725700378,
-0.008423296734690666,
-0.13049238920211792,
-0.34680911898612976,
-0.5978577136993408,
0.5382182002067566,
0.5506696105003357,
0.40656420588493347,
0.1812024563550949,
0.19393280148506165,
0.24035432934761047,
-0.5394507646560669,
1.0362718105316162,
-0.4344581365585327,
-1.199570655822754,
0.5286046862602234,
-0.4933559000492096,
-0.32589325308799744,
0.7865493297576904,
0.7233126759529114,
-0.5719248652458191,
-0.7227858901023865,
-0.8976547718048096,
-0.7759740352630615,
0.6905714273452759,
0.43365171551704407,
0.14470528066158295,
0.01473190076649189,
0.43250226974487305,
0.4262033700942993,
0.40353497862815857,
-0.5064743757247925,
-0.4170053005218506,
-0.16652972996234894,
-0.049266114830970764,
-0.03324687108397484,
-0.085832878947258,
-0.16026046872138977,
-0.0466640405356884,
0.40548235177993774,
-0.24736635386943817,
0.2342832386493683,
0.26513567566871643,
-0.2882893681526184,
-0.07231861352920532,
0.4707144498825073,
0.8029450178146362,
0.9619814157485962,
-0.4061248004436493,
0.28685349225997925,
-0.419389009475708,
-0.6548824906349182,
0.31104356050491333,
-0.03332674875855446,
-0.2722634971141815,
0.0392451249063015,
0.7405220866203308,
0.6824778914451599,
0.2255144864320755,
-0.49206700921058655,
0.6402674317359924,
-0.07066428661346436,
-0.33062946796417236,
-0.21433037519454956,
0.012681415304541588,
-0.0790189802646637,
-0.15046510100364685,
0.6331116557121277,
0.33504241704940796,
0.2059672623872757,
-0.5324649810791016,
0.5001603960990906,
0.09408614039421082,
-0.3949585258960724,
-0.5961664915084839,
0.5457582473754883,
0.35838583111763,
-0.5346593260765076,
0.3075158894062042,
-0.3610125482082367,
-0.7592729330062866,
0.5842740535736084,
0.37943315505981445,
1.0179400444030762,
0.19846534729003906,
0.49218976497650146,
0.1283256560564041,
0.13307316601276398,
0.16037647426128387,
-0.161446213722229,
0.0009650044376030564,
-0.928259015083313,
-0.3909783959388733,
-0.7701621651649475,
-0.4900800585746765,
-0.1462870091199875,
-0.6233909130096436,
0.12524697184562683,
-0.33064720034599304,
-0.34579768776893616,
0.6688399314880371,
0.29502829909324646,
-0.5426504611968994,
0.4919019043445587,
0.12651896476745605,
0.5904960632324219,
-0.8522146940231323,
0.8804730176925659,
0.7218879461288452,
-0.3282833397388458,
-0.39280951023101807,
0.35493454337120056,
0.13250569999217987,
-0.3421173095703125,
1.0681040287017822,
0.17518821358680725,
-0.003608540864661336,
-0.13369573652744293,
-0.27989572286605835,
-0.6467732191085815,
0.8686475157737732,
-0.11760439723730087,
0.05159075930714607,
0.015654150396585464,
0.25195804238319397,
0.933129072189331,
-0.6760921478271484,
-0.10658714920282364,
0.5254536271095276,
0.39592963457107544,
-0.2844254970550537,
-1.024315357208252,
0.08993110805749893,
-0.3776826560497284,
-0.05341595038771629,
0.226873978972435,
-0.35537028312683105,
0.7606946229934692,
0.04677807167172432,
-0.48447346687316895,
-0.22366762161254883,
0.6585965752601624,
-0.0003654544416349381,
0.4501829445362091,
0.3880922496318817,
0.3216996490955353,
1.1021581888198853,
-0.2928010821342468,
1.1462996006011963,
-0.16599155962467194,
0.42156314849853516,
0.951391339302063,
-0.4117869734764099,
0.87315434217453,
0.18911944329738617,
-0.20961029827594757,
0.6360947489738464,
0.7608376741409302,
0.2253546267747879,
0.40366554260253906,
0.34286677837371826,
-0.15592965483665466,
-0.29854658246040344,
-0.49985411763191223,
0.016980938613414764,
0.5352199673652649,
0.779187023639679,
0.045941323041915894,
0.1659565269947052,
0.023492153733968735,
-0.008306154981255531,
0.48196592926979065,
0.0714111253619194,
0.7584145069122314,
0.16051574051380157,
-0.7864373922348022,
0.6221093535423279,
0.19880695641040802,
0.7537616491317749,
-0.50876384973526,
-0.025554459542036057,
0.11901039630174637,
-0.26082322001457214,
-0.16622157394886017,
-0.97176194190979,
0.49007564783096313,
-0.255876362323761,
-0.3608860969543457,
-0.2885517477989197,
0.8404337763786316,
-0.39712250232696533,
-0.17757967114448547,
0.15795207023620605,
0.5762292742729187,
0.0432487353682518,
-0.2416345775127411,
-0.4206313192844391,
-0.09751620143651962,
-0.2680569887161255,
-0.12199526280164719,
0.22619055211544037,
0.7357678413391113,
-0.40263745188713074,
0.6369575262069702,
0.3808821141719818,
0.10260208696126938,
-0.11839908361434937,
-0.0857059434056282,
0.6048881411552429,
-0.7976951599121094,
-0.3220336139202118,
-0.453172892332077,
0.37502020597457886,
-0.09449668228626251,
-0.7565323710441589,
0.5333412289619446,
0.3747028708457947,
0.9328718781471252,
-0.01171537209302187,
0.9718111753463745,
-0.125762477517128,
0.6070849299430847,
-0.4693538248538971,
0.5812467932701111,
-0.408009797334671,
0.10970553755760193,
-0.19778816401958466,
-0.7948144674301147,
-0.36447176337242126,
0.5864306092262268,
-0.3439064621925354,
-0.15190626680850983,
1.0847692489624023,
0.2524607479572296,
0.10437426716089249,
0.13991911709308624,
0.28284525871276855,
-0.18504707515239716,
0.12035409361124039,
0.38306963443756104,
0.8121735453605652,
-0.23924459517002106,
0.01989683136343956,
-0.49933379888534546,
-0.20927874743938446,
-0.13570459187030792,
-0.6302899122238159,
-1.0878214836120605,
-0.9470534324645996,
-0.5574362874031067,
-0.10308985412120819,
-0.045501433312892914,
0.9123038053512573,
0.6343883872032166,
-0.652911901473999,
-0.22961430251598358,
0.3149981200695038,
0.21160542964935303,
-0.27453258633613586,
-0.2785128355026245,
0.5640460848808289,
-0.3781582713127136,
-0.6590441465377808,
0.018293367698788643,
0.43016305565834045,
-0.22300437092781067,
-0.24939386546611786,
0.22275735437870026,
-0.3020259439945221,
0.1538999229669571,
0.655952513217926,
0.19224335253238678,
-1.06660795211792,
-0.416747123003006,
0.10182008892297745,
-0.36768481135368347,
0.31057268381118774,
1.3196260929107666,
-0.6422057151794434,
0.2575368881225586,
0.23857709765434265,
0.7410998344421387,
0.07541105896234512,
0.21683427691459656,
0.4645788371562958,
-1.0525410175323486,
0.04848168045282364,
0.38933366537094116,
0.234806090593338,
0.4826849102973938,
-0.5233246684074402,
0.6587063074111938,
0.6347824931144714,
-0.5106454491615295,
-0.4832192659378052,
0.03310675173997879,
-1.262879729270935,
-0.32760247588157654,
1.1284140348434448,
-0.36310243606567383,
-0.21655945479869843,
-0.9577445983886719,
-0.2607651948928833,
-0.1660536825656891,
-0.4312579035758972,
0.567356526851654,
0.9867922067642212,
-0.11872181296348572,
0.2048729956150055,
-0.7778633832931519,
0.8772839903831482,
0.14102692902088165,
-0.9068301916122437,
0.3676745891571045,
0.31695911288261414,
0.24024152755737305,
0.6014004945755005,
0.9770579934120178,
0.10196831077337265,
0.031872112303972244,
-0.18302859365940094,
0.04789195582270622,
0.32781919836997986,
-0.45023709535598755,
-0.07776659727096558,
0.37540626525878906,
0.0639045387506485,
0.2848243713378906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01768v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01768v1
|
Auditing Large Language Models for Enhanced Text-Based Stereotype Detection and Probing-Based Bias Evaluation
| 2024-04-02T09:31:32 | 2024-04-02T09:31:32 |
Zekun Wu, Sahan Bulathwela, Maria Perez-Ortiz, Adriano Soares Koshiyama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
increased their presence in human-facing Artificial Intelligence (AI)
applications. However, LLMs could reproduce and even exacerbate stereotypical
outputs from training data. This work introduces the Multi-Grain Stereotype
(MGS) dataset, encompassing 51,867 instances across gender, race, profession,
religion, and stereotypical text, collected by fusing multiple previously
publicly available stereotype detection datasets. We explore different machine
learning approaches aimed at establishing baselines for stereotype detection,
and fine-tune several language models of various architectures and model sizes,
presenting in this work a series of stereotypes classifier models for English
text trained on MGS. To understand whether our stereotype detectors capture
relevant features (aligning with human common sense) we utilise a variety of
explanainable AI tools, including SHAP, LIME, and BertViz, and analyse a series
of example cases discussing the results. Finally, we develop a series of
stereotype elicitation prompts and evaluate the presence of stereotypes in text
generation tasks with popular LLMs, using one of our best performing previously
presented stereotypes detectors. Our experiments yielded several key findings:
i) Training stereotype detectors in a multi-dimension setting yields better
results than training multiple single-dimension classifiers.ii) The integrated
MGS Dataset enhances both the in-dataset and cross-dataset generalisation
ability of stereotype detectors compared to using the datasets separately. iii)
There is a reduction in stereotypes in the content generated by GPT Family LLMs
with newer versions.
|
[
-0.5490770936012268,
-0.3927459716796875,
0.574364185333252,
0.049841586500406265,
-0.05071982368826866,
-0.0796607956290245,
-0.23055480420589447,
-0.4641282558441162,
0.06551431119441986,
0.3832564651966095,
-0.21334733068943024,
-0.700967013835907,
-0.7441021800041199,
0.4020446836948395,
-0.44415828585624695,
0.9577269554138184,
-0.036419063806533813,
0.274366170167923,
-0.42873069643974304,
-0.13412046432495117,
-0.3873617649078369,
-0.8041366338729858,
-0.5637087821960449,
-0.3301272988319397,
0.14841437339782715,
0.20884859561920166,
0.5139138102531433,
0.6398433446884155,
0.3209296464920044,
0.24653570353984833,
-0.1362697035074234,
0.46973344683647156,
-0.31875863671302795,
0.08898721635341644,
0.11240900307893753,
-0.3552170991897583,
-0.3215470314025879,
0.30416223406791687,
0.378854364156723,
0.4406203031539917,
0.242383673787117,
0.19781361520290375,
0.22389061748981476,
0.33663737773895264,
-0.6672237515449524,
0.45715761184692383,
-0.8076887130737305,
0.18524406850337982,
-0.12845179438591003,
0.08775417506694794,
-0.5661099553108215,
-0.35797351598739624,
0.115994893014431,
-0.3215774893760681,
0.30970466136932373,
0.07842685282230377,
0.7264841198921204,
0.2425726056098938,
-0.6877970695495605,
-0.6969528198242188,
-0.47252118587493896,
0.9063071012496948,
-0.6219913959503174,
0.49533385038375854,
0.450708270072937,
0.23885422945022583,
0.0993499830365181,
-0.3273339569568634,
-0.294204443693161,
-0.3954373300075531,
-0.3421098291873932,
0.09118572622537613,
0.03912941738963127,
0.05886336416006088,
0.2348012775182724,
0.46684545278549194,
-0.4879142642021179,
0.2063295841217041,
-0.2392660230398178,
-0.5087782144546509,
0.6230939626693726,
0.048396602272987366,
0.20600773394107819,
-0.12444567680358887,
-0.07586260885000229,
-0.15776033699512482,
-0.5460686683654785,
-0.25931301712989807,
0.5961437225341797,
0.3479757606983185,
-0.1826159805059433,
0.4141402244567871,
0.06473961472511292,
0.595421314239502,
-0.029478909447789192,
-0.2190391719341278,
0.5480757355690002,
-0.2803228199481964,
-0.039299190044403076,
0.09275645017623901,
0.7958331108093262,
0.28257763385772705,
0.81296306848526,
-0.020668193697929382,
-0.3095037043094635,
0.2762901186943054,
-0.003768480382859707,
-0.8414073586463928,
-0.21307702362537384,
0.14786922931671143,
-0.3526999354362488,
-0.4643763601779938,
-0.0885387659072876,
-0.8198593854904175,
-0.5477802753448486,
-0.33854615688323975,
0.11785542964935303,
-0.5674132704734802,
-0.034653253853321075,
0.24351681768894196,
-0.34806814789772034,
0.2203817218542099,
0.17849968373775482,
-0.9996116161346436,
-0.08465186506509781,
0.6310213804244995,
0.7238146066665649,
0.09809787571430206,
-0.17991454899311066,
-0.38898900151252747,
0.029566576704382896,
-0.3537273406982422,
0.6551550030708313,
-0.6102921366691589,
-0.1659860908985138,
0.1842610388994217,
-0.36974963545799255,
0.1285753697156906,
-0.5671781301498413,
0.5876514911651611,
-0.24436940252780914,
0.41529956459999084,
-0.0633164793252945,
-0.5107829570770264,
0.007023261860013008,
0.6567736268043518,
-0.6589725017547607,
1.2147026062011719,
-0.1497473567724228,
-0.9424821734428406,
0.6959335207939148,
-0.4068291485309601,
-0.37913453578948975,
-0.25468048453330994,
-0.5175853371620178,
-0.5695493221282959,
0.07911235839128494,
0.7469571232795715,
0.5293333530426025,
-0.23663778603076935,
0.3956199884414673,
-0.5013503432273865,
-0.2071767896413803,
-0.0027650664560496807,
-0.5905051231384277,
0.6982403993606567,
0.17516610026359558,
-0.14507673680782318,
-0.04241718351840973,
-0.7328751683235168,
-0.2176457792520523,
0.01789061911404133,
-0.25229161977767944,
-0.5963122844696045,
-0.04672075808048248,
-0.023350119590759277,
0.2629731595516205,
0.15516698360443115,
-0.44225189089775085,
0.014648424461483955,
-0.16877895593643188,
0.20245911180973053,
0.8247816562652588,
-0.23779059946537018,
0.2080908566713333,
-0.15352612733840942,
0.355948269367218,
0.17954608798027039,
0.09675121307373047,
-0.45834478735923767,
-0.5046388506889343,
-0.5241525769233704,
-0.7409656643867493,
0.2493692934513092,
0.5514836311340332,
-0.45946770906448364,
0.642886757850647,
-0.245157852768898,
-0.300983190536499,
-0.6066729426383972,
0.20390552282333374,
0.4818696677684784,
0.2898329496383667,
0.10555347800254822,
-0.3155452609062195,
-0.6010618209838867,
-1.0526140928268433,
-0.5608912706375122,
-0.4242069721221924,
-0.3153145909309387,
0.46465083956718445,
0.4594341814517975,
-0.2726445496082306,
1.159252643585205,
-0.38845396041870117,
-0.21248330175876617,
-0.18473723530769348,
0.334555059671402,
0.025629226118326187,
0.10654202103614807,
0.6881426572799683,
-0.6719494462013245,
-0.2624109089374542,
-0.006547225173562765,
-1.0606054067611694,
-0.304559588432312,
-0.07989464700222015,
0.20905421674251556,
0.11502023786306381,
0.6492971777915955,
-0.3894425928592682,
0.1038525253534317,
0.6203893423080444,
-0.23914745450019836,
0.7281196117401123,
0.02239307016134262,
0.03130846470594406,
-1.1715813875198364,
-0.28237468004226685,
0.42885372042655945,
-0.28852540254592896,
-0.5859501957893372,
-0.011695023626089096,
0.14015838503837585,
0.03964903950691223,
-0.24462759494781494,
0.5725470781326294,
-0.7004871368408203,
-0.44071727991104126,
-0.035452842712402344,
0.14058756828308105,
0.1339208483695984,
0.11690372973680496,
0.01001045573502779,
0.921294629573822,
0.4852946400642395,
-0.5482058525085449,
0.2950388789176941,
0.24075648188591003,
-0.48436596989631653,
0.303240031003952,
-0.3087823688983917,
0.3674892485141754,
-0.464156836271286,
0.25501877069473267,
-0.9012234807014465,
-0.2701370120048523,
-0.15622785687446594,
-0.46337318420410156,
0.16351813077926636,
-0.2762189209461212,
-0.5491532683372498,
-0.337501585483551,
-0.5361699461936951,
0.322827011346817,
0.334837406873703,
-0.7648470401763916,
0.6190770268440247,
0.47210049629211426,
-0.14962084591388702,
-0.6300504207611084,
-0.5654629468917847,
0.13524147868156433,
-0.3687397837638855,
-0.6285324096679688,
-0.10639762133359909,
0.22789427638053894,
-0.4970918893814087,
-0.40671807527542114,
0.010308566503226757,
-0.04123920947313309,
0.07855315506458282,
-0.05046572536230087,
0.33972272276878357,
-0.2436276227235794,
0.19976767897605896,
0.053599290549755096,
0.2087973654270172,
0.13581854104995728,
-0.25709977746009827,
0.7932531833648682,
-0.16732364892959595,
-0.29623714089393616,
-0.21445348858833313,
0.10249128937721252,
0.6971496343612671,
-0.20731611549854279,
0.6329696178436279,
0.7193664312362671,
-0.25509971380233765,
-0.18199510872364044,
-0.5520973801612854,
-0.16996778547763824,
-0.45153576135635376,
0.6448799967765808,
-0.5657185912132263,
-0.9528690576553345,
0.4222787022590637,
0.1011260375380516,
0.3079140782356262,
0.2522828280925751,
0.5992540717124939,
0.1381143182516098,
1.0534299612045288,
0.6514247059822083,
-0.5043403506278992,
0.3621979057788849,
0.17473524808883667,
0.3038676679134369,
-0.46103206276893616,
-0.17777054011821747,
-0.6694432497024536,
0.015131872147321701,
-0.600470244884491,
-0.4350906014442444,
0.5075578093528748,
-0.1588185429573059,
-0.1342468559741974,
0.05883514881134033,
-0.28874045610427856,
0.5424579381942749,
0.34772545099258423,
-0.0639110654592514,
0.42072147130966187,
0.0750567764043808,
-0.1819375902414322,
0.02272898703813553,
-0.5085987448692322,
-0.7725781202316284,
1.3063303232192993,
0.6036308407783508,
0.8017796277999878,
-0.2903052866458893,
0.7719047665596008,
0.29165467619895935,
0.5678525567054749,
-0.9482290148735046,
0.4437892735004425,
-0.31572604179382324,
-0.7528898119926453,
-0.1943979114294052,
-0.6419724225997925,
-0.4034433662891388,
0.2851302921772003,
-0.12555080652236938,
-0.5891380906105042,
0.08397258818149567,
0.3853490352630615,
-0.02313234657049179,
0.2443820834159851,
-0.8650425672531128,
0.6480884552001953,
-0.31810152530670166,
-0.008547076024115086,
0.12651990354061127,
-0.19829733669757843,
0.6981699466705322,
-0.20924440026283264,
0.37048661708831787,
0.04185188561677933,
0.23866140842437744,
0.5751029253005981,
0.22288013994693756,
0.9278719425201416,
0.03867576643824577,
-0.5196136236190796,
0.0027465082239359617,
0.018854446709156036,
0.48925313353538513,
-0.020530737936496735,
-0.2426491528749466,
0.4550599753856659,
-0.2708379626274109,
-0.1616288721561432,
-0.4432469308376312,
0.36727291345596313,
-0.7479602098464966,
-0.49109557271003723,
-0.2599175274372101,
-0.8658633232116699,
-0.4849880635738373,
-0.08574195951223373,
0.3183281421661377,
0.4120658040046692,
-0.4783271551132202,
-0.11179108917713165,
0.7014117240905762,
-0.5321415662765503,
0.044539764523506165,
0.06292377412319183,
-0.454459011554718,
-0.26373136043548584,
0.6307384371757507,
-0.291217178106308,
0.2693541646003723,
0.19644124805927277,
0.2234741896390915,
-0.21073028445243835,
-0.5116406083106995,
-0.5975151062011719,
0.15654143691062927,
-0.6263121962547302,
-0.03085649013519287,
-0.7920337915420532,
-0.27266353368759155,
-0.9389418959617615,
-0.029608841985464096,
-0.31783053278923035,
-0.08349141478538513,
-0.008946018293499947,
-0.14204727113246918,
0.3644576370716095,
0.764305591583252,
0.05368710309267044,
0.19168663024902344,
-0.7145342230796814,
0.35716816782951355,
0.22768042981624603,
0.22133179008960724,
-0.250448077917099,
-0.5957950353622437,
-0.0959155261516571,
-0.08906546980142593,
-0.02388596348464489,
-0.8020361661911011,
0.5227832198143005,
0.026138396933674812,
0.41744381189346313,
0.7579395771026611,
-0.35930314660072327,
0.37513190507888794,
-0.49433353543281555,
0.6941936612129211,
0.07685083895921707,
-0.859769344329834,
0.33197087049484253,
-0.3440784215927124,
0.09508456289768219,
0.5148867964744568,
0.5973537564277649,
-0.6774654984474182,
-0.481340229511261,
-0.057578738778829575,
-0.632418692111969,
0.6511092782020569,
0.1597604602575302,
0.08676813542842865,
-0.04057848080992699,
0.2692994177341461,
0.3049848973751068,
0.27182549238204956,
-0.7685034275054932,
-0.22015120089054108,
-0.20969846844673157,
-0.6105380058288574,
-0.24729011952877045,
-0.2768194079399109,
-0.05540485680103302,
-0.11515642702579498,
0.6685299873352051,
-0.2907552719116211,
0.05812257528305054,
-0.06455079466104507,
-0.2688911259174347,
0.6330167055130005,
0.46213167905807495,
0.20148269832134247,
0.2779527008533478,
-0.3641711175441742,
0.2724795639514923,
0.07703438401222229,
-0.6716719269752502,
0.07593277096748352,
0.03673762083053589,
-0.415552020072937,
0.2507665753364563,
0.34727418422698975,
0.7183678150177002,
-0.3195658326148987,
-0.6018040776252747,
0.33043745160102844,
-0.022318461909890175,
-0.27769172191619873,
-0.1350831538438797,
-0.16935420036315918,
-0.06559430062770844,
-0.042004674673080444,
0.022798193618655205,
-0.18618623912334442,
0.218298077583313,
-0.8400586843490601,
0.17222997546195984,
0.6765305399894714,
-0.2888169288635254,
-0.08783426135778427,
0.26958784461021423,
0.2648378610610962,
-0.03345051407814026,
0.5185062885284424,
-0.2921442687511444,
-0.7904071807861328,
0.6764243245124817,
0.5924688577651978,
0.9562556743621826,
-0.16510280966758728,
0.19742286205291748,
0.3049218952655792,
0.6924640536308289,
-0.15340971946716309,
-0.1036943793296814,
0.021519673988223076,
-1.1871803998947144,
-0.2749563157558441,
-0.7613251209259033,
-0.3781854212284088,
0.4152878522872925,
-0.5918165445327759,
0.39439448714256287,
-0.35162675380706787,
0.0934901088476181,
0.051517680287361145,
-0.2810514569282532,
-0.540151059627533,
0.11694919317960739,
0.498176246881485,
0.9836799502372742,
-1.2701454162597656,
0.5045245289802551,
0.7104521989822388,
-0.22020654380321503,
-0.51577228307724,
0.3518133759498596,
0.3522101938724518,
-0.9281221628189087,
0.6861003637313843,
0.4953835904598236,
-0.21832983195781708,
-0.3257558345794678,
-0.529457688331604,
-0.6643344759941101,
0.7017554640769958,
0.416216105222702,
-0.6416945457458496,
-0.2223203480243683,
0.4217512905597687,
0.5651037693023682,
-0.5009642839431763,
0.5512310862541199,
0.9731647372245789,
0.5344716906547546,
-0.15143638849258423,
-0.8825044631958008,
-0.2570072114467621,
-0.10543378442525864,
-0.04878315329551697,
0.18525515496730804,
-0.43105214834213257,
0.7001956105232239,
0.11814296990633011,
0.02173510380089283,
-0.10812363028526306,
0.5373392701148987,
0.37254491448402405,
0.3504129648208618,
0.6071182489395142,
0.5929052829742432,
0.8758801817893982,
0.002862272085621953,
0.8996721506118774,
-0.2321568727493286,
0.19013790786266327,
1.0432096719741821,
-0.5014767646789551,
0.3058735132217407,
0.3789307177066803,
0.08075832575559616,
0.29644709825515747,
0.42971569299697876,
-0.05334284156560898,
0.11498651653528214,
0.25778090953826904,
-0.3197993338108063,
-0.29158687591552734,
-0.03995978832244873,
-0.19212599098682404,
0.7210741639137268,
0.3317500650882721,
-0.6110509037971497,
-0.38288208842277527,
0.14506518840789795,
0.12986205518245697,
0.05350060760974884,
-0.3678898215293884,
0.7583051919937134,
-0.08455976098775864,
-0.4931194484233856,
0.20321714878082275,
0.011452500708401203,
1.1335537433624268,
-0.41317105293273926,
0.15439541637897491,
-0.49636489152908325,
0.43509572744369507,
-0.05684615299105644,
-0.6347721219062805,
0.11145354807376862,
0.41999807953834534,
-0.24732893705368042,
-0.207295760512352,
0.7857881784439087,
-0.3534240126609802,
-0.6593396067619324,
0.3113923966884613,
0.44919028878211975,
0.41490763425827026,
-0.13599275052547455,
-0.5010777711868286,
0.009404368698596954,
0.09093017876148224,
-0.003524316940456629,
0.417680948972702,
0.6289061307907104,
-0.2347484678030014,
0.5684095621109009,
0.3876194953918457,
0.08634564280509949,
0.1361365020275116,
0.35189342498779297,
0.6956250071525574,
-0.5569233894348145,
-0.39291346073150635,
-0.9290715456008911,
0.027831677347421646,
-0.23578117787837982,
-0.2907811999320984,
0.9320708513259888,
0.9595838785171509,
0.9871233105659485,
-0.05079340934753418,
1.1210814714431763,
0.252046138048172,
0.3309935927391052,
-0.6386744379997253,
0.6121297478675842,
-0.34309613704681396,
0.31304511427879333,
-0.34162452816963196,
-0.8039220571517944,
-0.18923158943653107,
0.5759096741676331,
-0.4291509985923767,
0.197041854262352,
0.40055567026138306,
0.9828413724899292,
-0.23334327340126038,
0.12574049830436707,
0.37592998147010803,
0.3072489798069,
0.42917752265930176,
0.32426711916923523,
0.8106961250305176,
-0.2924855351448059,
0.608134925365448,
0.15412503480911255,
-0.380718469619751,
-0.021257121115922928,
-0.7685596942901611,
-1.1779955625534058,
-0.3808247447013855,
-0.1016802191734314,
-0.3157864212989807,
0.10182687640190125,
0.7659956812858582,
0.5844507217407227,
-0.777969479560852,
-0.2892410159111023,
0.12076815962791443,
-0.03847094625234604,
0.13162633776664734,
-0.2536316514015198,
0.10612059384584427,
-0.5972320437431335,
-0.9040133357048035,
0.26907649636268616,
0.26545268297195435,
-0.05773717910051346,
-0.3634321093559265,
0.1190267875790596,
0.024313461035490036,
0.24615488946437836,
0.8641022443771362,
-0.003727483097463846,
-0.33378347754478455,
-0.2814682126045227,
-0.16344749927520752,
-0.11864111572504044,
0.09903204441070557,
0.9200575351715088,
-0.6926801204681396,
0.20267616212368011,
0.33727318048477173,
0.7041997909545898,
0.4549050033092499,
-0.17394158244132996,
0.6354615688323975,
-1.0640995502471924,
0.24298164248466492,
0.24564871191978455,
0.5848888158798218,
0.4700912833213806,
-0.3389529883861542,
0.3577033281326294,
0.060513466596603394,
-0.30865707993507385,
-0.8659222722053528,
0.4174864888191223,
-0.5972321629524231,
-0.3109360933303833,
1.3709200620651245,
0.005341465584933758,
-0.11315038055181503,
-0.26874712109565735,
-0.11094801127910614,
0.28227362036705017,
-0.39697420597076416,
0.9848084449768066,
0.9805707931518555,
0.08793462812900543,
0.11709045618772507,
-0.5648332834243774,
0.5067121386528015,
0.3962160646915436,
-1.097123146057129,
0.36655837297439575,
0.8688576221466064,
0.24533897638320923,
0.21093732118606567,
0.4064699113368988,
-0.3414899706840515,
-0.10346826910972595,
0.0028081329073756933,
0.34928473830223083,
-0.028559112921357155,
-0.5310114622116089,
-0.5157809853553772,
0.04144086688756943,
-0.20669151842594147,
-0.12505608797073364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01767v1
|
Class-Incremental Few-Shot Event Detection
| 2024-04-02T09:31:14 | 2024-04-02T09:31:14 |
Kailin Zhao, Xiaolong Jin, Long Bai, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Event detection is one of the fundamental tasks in information extraction and
knowledge graph. However, a realistic event detection system often needs to
deal with new event classes constantly. These new classes usually have only a
few labeled instances as it is time-consuming and labor-intensive to annotate a
large number of unlabeled instances. Therefore, this paper proposes a new task,
called class-incremental few-shot event detection. Nevertheless, this task
faces two problems, i.e., old knowledge forgetting and new class overfitting.
To solve these problems, this paper further presents a novel knowledge
distillation and prompt learning based method, called Prompt-KD. Specifically,
to handle the forgetting problem about old knowledge, Prompt-KD develops an
attention based multi-teacher knowledge distillation framework, where the
ancestor teacher model pre-trained on base classes is reused in all learning
sessions, and the father teacher model derives the current student model via
adaptation. On the other hand, in order to cope with the few-shot learning
scenario and alleviate the corresponding new class overfitting problem,
Prompt-KD is also equipped with a prompt learning mechanism. Extensive
experiments on two benchmark datasets, i.e., FewEvent and MAVEN, demonstrate
the superior performance of Prompt-KD.
|
[
-0.5028358697891235,
-0.68672114610672,
0.7167522311210632,
-0.2989085018634796,
-0.3443395495414734,
0.006723423022776842,
0.06390365958213806,
-0.14232087135314941,
-0.2869294285774231,
-0.11334849894046783,
-0.697077214717865,
-0.5429906845092773,
-0.6048625707626343,
0.09671370685100555,
0.12490703910589218,
0.8830706477165222,
-0.020604759454727173,
-0.21323151886463165,
-0.20408998429775238,
-0.1903373748064041,
-0.8361422419548035,
-0.3036927282810211,
-0.9928280711174011,
-0.47276273369789124,
0.4389873445034027,
0.9143240451812744,
-0.052844345569610596,
0.3186645209789276,
0.07125888764858246,
0.1968151181936264,
-0.1609741449356079,
0.1752183437347412,
-0.40361469984054565,
0.2306334525346756,
-0.02914898470044136,
-0.4770817458629608,
-0.045011378824710846,
-0.039868682622909546,
0.6512460112571716,
0.39548832178115845,
0.07457268238067627,
0.2669993042945862,
0.32144150137901306,
0.8353332281112671,
-1.0059841871261597,
0.432876855134964,
-0.6098959445953369,
0.2708025574684143,
-0.16780985891819,
-0.3656674027442932,
-0.4142381250858307,
-0.26522237062454224,
0.1519133299589157,
-0.644523561000824,
0.2407488077878952,
-0.25804710388183594,
0.4225601851940155,
0.364960253238678,
-0.34623196721076965,
-0.27522826194763184,
-0.2863781452178955,
0.6156097650527954,
-0.43454092741012573,
0.2193404734134674,
0.30201631784439087,
0.7678191065788269,
-0.316616028547287,
-0.5964163541793823,
-0.7646582126617432,
0.11640685796737671,
0.059210047125816345,
0.08806843310594559,
-0.01705172471702099,
-0.21699027717113495,
0.5166510343551636,
0.071370929479599,
-0.48131313920021057,
0.04282968491315842,
-0.0553230345249176,
-0.006655422504991293,
0.1509925276041031,
0.37037208676338196,
-0.04809688404202461,
-0.3339698314666748,
-0.6230939030647278,
0.023775052279233932,
-0.4219381809234619,
0.1045321375131607,
0.12418901920318604,
0.36963149905204773,
-0.053680989891290665,
0.14138422906398773,
-0.4487314522266388,
0.7326938509941101,
0.2957819402217865,
-0.6381182670593262,
0.2403469681739807,
-0.17346987128257751,
-0.12806488573551178,
0.49966567754745483,
0.38075003027915955,
0.340488076210022,
0.29187944531440735,
0.04273398220539093,
0.21321134269237518,
0.0838479995727539,
-0.2868330478668213,
-0.9213714003562927,
-0.47639384865760803,
0.0585128478705883,
-0.3975012004375458,
-0.2596718668937683,
-0.5919693112373352,
-0.7633200883865356,
-0.7858308553695679,
-0.2641324996948242,
0.54494309425354,
-0.7474780678749084,
-0.0944930762052536,
-0.2232237011194229,
-0.4787682294845581,
0.15505215525627136,
0.720782995223999,
-0.5776719450950623,
-0.1608928143978119,
0.41228964924812317,
0.9601430892944336,
-0.22799009084701538,
-0.47071489691734314,
-0.7350515127182007,
0.1816030740737915,
-0.02041739970445633,
0.8379074335098267,
-0.5308132171630859,
-0.3467961549758911,
-0.2894226312637329,
-0.03077419474720955,
0.1223711296916008,
-0.32716482877731323,
0.34729939699172974,
-0.6131516098976135,
0.2088286131620407,
-0.5058097243309021,
-1.0646371841430664,
-0.246429443359375,
0.587618887424469,
-0.24978309869766235,
0.867927610874176,
0.22046977281570435,
-0.8600649237632751,
1.009466290473938,
-0.3685077130794525,
-0.19660338759422302,
0.31673479080200195,
-0.19155792891979218,
-0.6755620837211609,
-0.3708230257034302,
0.20686233043670654,
0.5609402656555176,
-0.0896761566400528,
0.2264823317527771,
-0.3397179841995239,
-0.20280787348747253,
-0.16478608548641205,
-0.40590065717697144,
0.758616030216217,
0.18770216405391693,
-0.05100439116358757,
-0.11104873567819595,
-1.0821857452392578,
-0.16875267028808594,
0.0452207587659359,
-0.29729190468788147,
-0.49458393454551697,
-0.3016737699508667,
-0.35862472653388977,
0.27625900506973267,
0.06066271290183067,
-0.5991724729537964,
0.7515370845794678,
0.042879506945610046,
-0.008650248870253563,
0.7268120646476746,
0.7072246670722961,
0.6278521418571472,
-0.2863975167274475,
0.5050705075263977,
0.5147190093994141,
0.14932946860790253,
-0.9755585789680481,
-0.5571343302726746,
-0.4772835671901703,
-0.35647615790367126,
-0.05833008140325546,
0.4882340133190155,
-1.1894601583480835,
0.16030535101890564,
0.08994671702384949,
-0.44729530811309814,
-0.08235631138086319,
0.14093543589115143,
0.11792315542697906,
1.0257725715637207,
0.44833359122276306,
-0.003993642516434193,
-0.5461570024490356,
-0.20697154104709625,
-0.2149650752544403,
-0.23808182775974274,
0.05699635669589043,
0.11928125470876694,
0.3900517523288727,
0.16442765295505524,
1.2812541723251343,
-0.8372377157211304,
-0.7937889099121094,
-0.19994384050369263,
0.30978089570999146,
0.1248999610543251,
0.5413992404937744,
0.8509737253189087,
-0.41421768069267273,
-0.6779546737670898,
-0.12324441224336624,
-0.8455349206924438,
0.033672984689474106,
-0.2420821338891983,
0.03218887001276016,
0.35006797313690186,
0.4388847053050995,
-0.2909441888332367,
0.46727126836776733,
-0.34884896874427795,
-0.43306252360343933,
0.42531391978263855,
0.0679117739200592,
0.4347321391105652,
-0.9730755686759949,
-0.17779897153377533,
-0.125702902674675,
-0.3122720420360565,
-0.43513214588165283,
-0.2620067596435547,
0.304546594619751,
-0.17827817797660828,
-0.6572896242141724,
0.7541526556015015,
-0.34602057933807373,
0.0995367243885994,
-0.6011247038841248,
0.2067573368549347,
-0.005872339475899935,
0.70831298828125,
0.09180589020252228,
0.24857854843139648,
0.6854318976402283,
-0.8621469736099243,
0.5592983961105347,
0.3688991963863373,
-0.3550344705581665,
0.9634465575218201,
-0.058350153267383575,
0.1202704980969429,
-0.45829567313194275,
0.23741836845874786,
-1.0943623781204224,
-0.10787198692560196,
0.4619821608066559,
-0.5849984884262085,
0.385869562625885,
-0.7983120679855347,
-0.4409340023994446,
-0.4263523519039154,
-0.31784847378730774,
0.2563980519771576,
0.4988439083099365,
-0.7464494705200195,
0.47937241196632385,
0.011351928114891052,
-0.07605341821908951,
-0.3716489374637604,
-0.14230433106422424,
-0.20352664589881897,
-0.2816596031188965,
-0.3864689767360687,
-0.16429387032985687,
0.08370155841112137,
0.19568651914596558,
0.1536911278963089,
-0.22364799678325653,
-0.2787482440471649,
0.1893407553434372,
0.19719870388507843,
0.33038923144340515,
-0.11921941488981247,
0.4790845513343811,
0.08426174521446228,
-0.33611631393432617,
-0.27991268038749695,
-0.5179448127746582,
0.39698153734207153,
0.3580232560634613,
-0.42544081807136536,
-0.7855346202850342,
0.26556697487831116,
0.4453035891056061,
0.23659737408161163,
0.6375094056129456,
0.6853458881378174,
-0.4827280342578888,
-0.15596824884414673,
-0.585645854473114,
-0.5939340591430664,
-0.43765154480934143,
0.23821265995502472,
-0.49569424986839294,
-0.6281020641326904,
0.45242100954055786,
-0.4187968671321869,
0.03646884113550186,
0.2730346620082855,
0.25154614448547363,
-0.02700830064713955,
0.569893479347229,
0.5715177059173584,
-0.3489329218864441,
0.7062622904777527,
-0.17700523138046265,
-0.2727392911911011,
-0.4971619248390198,
-0.2443501502275467,
-0.4618995785713196,
-0.530974268913269,
-0.09526676684617996,
0.010936452075839043,
0.6326916217803955,
0.29902946949005127,
-0.3158339560031891,
0.1616765707731247,
-0.5134860277175903,
0.6866781711578369,
0.6601992249488831,
0.012339352630078793,
0.5999353528022766,
-0.2633714973926544,
0.1081668809056282,
-0.16511014103889465,
-0.9519233107566833,
-0.13732679188251495,
1.0286740064620972,
-0.0017158187692984939,
0.6148645281791687,
-0.2357831597328186,
0.982912003993988,
0.25836247205734253,
0.19695964455604553,
-0.8319525122642517,
0.36448076367378235,
0.24517680704593658,
-0.5589610934257507,
-0.5135114789009094,
-0.33920592069625854,
-0.6951029896736145,
0.130783811211586,
-0.04720966890454292,
-0.6592492461204529,
0.4152812063694,
0.27665773034095764,
-0.6157665252685547,
0.4539693295955658,
-0.8651434779167175,
0.9068974256515503,
0.3487561047077179,
-0.3234390616416931,
0.01985044963657856,
-0.6677210927009583,
0.4671803116798401,
-0.12536406517028809,
-0.006292679812759161,
-0.2905275523662567,
0.28901901841163635,
0.6187710762023926,
-0.3714887499809265,
0.856748640537262,
-0.829010546207428,
0.15292510390281677,
0.7076103091239929,
-0.012412709183990955,
0.981865406036377,
0.12060999125242233,
0.08089661598205566,
-0.3546178638935089,
0.10489896684885025,
-0.4000825881958008,
-0.5968582034111023,
0.5523385405540466,
-0.5640144348144531,
-0.4079846143722534,
-0.48061513900756836,
-0.20231272280216217,
-0.06312060356140137,
0.07708749920129776,
0.433118999004364,
0.34824275970458984,
0.09473894536495209,
-0.23061701655387878,
0.6222013831138611,
-0.14541877806186676,
0.8373510837554932,
0.9174568057060242,
-0.16640019416809082,
-0.1651216447353363,
0.8841685652732849,
0.36906880140304565,
0.18061286211013794,
0.17998401820659637,
0.23994885385036469,
-0.001658175722695887,
-0.1848117560148239,
-0.7417234778404236,
-0.26061010360717773,
-0.8883275985717773,
-0.6025107502937317,
-0.9398687481880188,
0.045478835701942444,
-0.4864405393600464,
-0.27294251322746277,
-0.19454391300678253,
-0.3785161077976227,
-0.5940383076667786,
0.035282403230667114,
0.7529028654098511,
0.07671505212783813,
-0.03255201876163483,
0.5109879374504089,
-0.9140216708183289,
0.5068132877349854,
0.5730300545692444,
0.00004089027061127126,
0.27555862069129944,
-0.6150785684585571,
0.005268401000648737,
-0.428195595741272,
-0.5543973445892334,
-0.8216670155525208,
0.13997429609298706,
0.36312633752822876,
0.4720059335231781,
0.6036141514778137,
0.5326293110847473,
0.542340099811554,
-0.5209143161773682,
0.4979359805583954,
0.38187089562416077,
-0.7123430967330933,
0.9014358520507812,
0.028731338679790497,
0.8067708611488342,
0.7072343230247498,
0.6049106121063232,
-0.7187442183494568,
-0.21045425534248352,
-0.5912743210792542,
-0.6800050139427185,
1.0488203763961792,
-0.2983141839504242,
-0.1983373612165451,
-0.0850992277264595,
0.4277692139148712,
0.5876465439796448,
0.19812826812267303,
-0.43942928314208984,
-0.5442910194396973,
0.01634516380727291,
-0.05929258465766907,
0.21373750269412994,
-0.3567068576812744,
0.28372249007225037,
-0.08222713321447372,
0.7372469902038574,
-0.2305612862110138,
-0.16712407767772675,
0.13581761717796326,
-0.26412203907966614,
-0.012332719750702381,
0.3626153767108917,
0.1944018006324768,
0.3612285852432251,
-0.10652969777584076,
0.2173829823732376,
0.5331032276153564,
-0.5415367484092712,
0.5223701596260071,
0.00960820447653532,
-0.2833747863769531,
0.120583176612854,
0.3158167600631714,
0.6740192770957947,
0.23008044064044952,
-0.28812283277511597,
0.6264455914497375,
0.21414649486541748,
0.17000499367713928,
-0.1994788497686386,
0.18357539176940918,
-0.28168851137161255,
0.6150988936424255,
0.7048353552818298,
0.1499323546886444,
0.28778666257858276,
-0.6015483736991882,
0.5349301099777222,
0.1020427942276001,
-0.4396597743034363,
-0.1393876075744629,
0.518300473690033,
0.1843060851097107,
0.10767944902181625,
0.37896957993507385,
-0.8620424866676331,
-0.5574812889099121,
0.5994952917098999,
0.2920621633529663,
0.7246872186660767,
-0.3589155077934265,
0.15763387084007263,
0.6293774247169495,
0.016277384012937546,
0.07081161439418793,
0.3884168565273285,
-0.39946645498275757,
-0.641021728515625,
-0.3335822820663452,
-0.44628676772117615,
-0.25378769636154175,
0.14294154942035675,
-0.43526026606559753,
0.6885083317756653,
-0.3405703008174896,
-0.13108251988887787,
0.22638042271137238,
0.16706563532352448,
-0.6351020336151123,
-0.06751794368028641,
0.12791678309440613,
0.8407445549964905,
-1.043384313583374,
0.8563000559806824,
0.49704626202583313,
-0.36021965742111206,
-0.5083774328231812,
-0.19683250784873962,
0.3965005576610565,
-0.5413223505020142,
0.8910769820213318,
0.11053521186113358,
0.28684669733047485,
0.40258219838142395,
-0.32288405299186707,
-0.4908716678619385,
1.1990069150924683,
0.32625067234039307,
-0.8162806034088135,
-0.0071036010049283504,
-0.4432927966117859,
0.01944596879184246,
-0.011981908231973648,
0.032471664249897,
0.596811830997467,
0.5475955009460449,
0.6317821145057678,
-0.5351930856704712,
-0.25589191913604736,
0.2773885726928711,
-0.4851109981536865,
0.46293535828590393,
-0.5355198979377747,
0.8489848375320435,
-0.3963363766670227,
-0.3851690888404846,
-0.21925991773605347,
0.539836585521698,
0.40301772952079773,
1.036199927330017,
0.4123006761074066,
0.6188708543777466,
0.8562509417533875,
-0.03555280715227127,
0.7016863226890564,
0.07916896045207977,
0.4563385844230652,
1.4974011182785034,
-0.44446852803230286,
0.26995402574539185,
0.28659194707870483,
-0.35903361439704895,
0.06297355145215988,
0.5300763249397278,
0.005375969223678112,
0.902741551399231,
-0.09749948233366013,
-0.5785647630691528,
-0.36844027042388916,
0.0047365049831569195,
-0.4910610020160675,
0.15166868269443512,
0.038631074130535126,
-0.026611361652612686,
-0.8242430686950684,
0.730868399143219,
0.006732650566846132,
-0.3170633912086487,
-0.6144964098930359,
1.116902470588684,
-0.06509373337030411,
-0.5206927061080933,
0.4559172987937927,
-0.31620529294013977,
0.5557366013526917,
-0.3682403862476349,
-0.19254368543624878,
-0.2158239185810089,
0.21157734096050262,
-0.07686298340559006,
-0.5033570528030396,
-0.137250155210495,
0.013353114016354084,
-0.34888407588005066,
0.2290867120027542,
1.0925393104553223,
-0.603650689125061,
-0.24865607917308807,
-0.009727184660732746,
0.5695691704750061,
0.17363128066062927,
-0.21907901763916016,
-0.11529998481273651,
0.032254986464977264,
-0.08084842562675476,
-0.16509027779102325,
0.37279263138771057,
1.0349862575531006,
-0.08619317412376404,
0.682141125202179,
0.2531643509864807,
-0.3175103962421417,
0.24686969816684723,
-0.028694437816739082,
0.8848665952682495,
-0.5212010145187378,
-0.7247083783149719,
-1.0603395700454712,
0.3345819115638733,
-0.01416186336427927,
-0.3380090296268463,
0.6492800116539001,
0.49264994263648987,
0.675270140171051,
-0.21682001650333405,
0.8028165102005005,
0.11976608633995056,
0.5546708106994629,
-0.462250679731369,
0.5579771399497986,
-0.1611916869878769,
-0.0109859062358737,
-0.38503533601760864,
-0.6509900689125061,
-0.0945914089679718,
0.27795857191085815,
-0.14412184059619904,
-0.11370899528265,
0.6176713109016418,
0.16807453334331512,
0.06846366822719574,
0.10539142787456512,
0.5281587243080139,
-0.1200733408331871,
0.2502121031284332,
0.7363888621330261,
1.0023187398910522,
-0.37407296895980835,
0.3964884877204895,
-0.228081613779068,
-0.3384608328342438,
-0.516089916229248,
-1.0165057182312012,
-0.9125171899795532,
-0.777142345905304,
-0.8018338084220886,
0.11369120329618454,
0.055185023695230484,
0.9496362209320068,
0.5329698920249939,
-0.8654667139053345,
0.5205888748168945,
-0.11355513334274292,
0.38103169202804565,
-0.16964569687843323,
-0.28662794828414917,
0.4457627236843109,
-0.8371032476425171,
-0.6375584602355957,
0.22488389909267426,
0.37102648615837097,
0.37210240960121155,
0.15715819597244263,
0.19178973138332367,
-0.27940598130226135,
-0.4646731913089752,
0.7285134792327881,
0.31217628717422485,
-0.14398647844791412,
-0.41183626651763916,
-0.33031830191612244,
0.08136220276355743,
0.0196603462100029,
0.7008752822875977,
-1.4106014966964722,
0.529775083065033,
0.4881746470928192,
0.6311675310134888,
0.6814439296722412,
-0.2696685194969177,
-0.06944103538990021,
-1.186373233795166,
0.5329934358596802,
0.13172166049480438,
0.21524742245674133,
0.11495675891637802,
-0.41908711194992065,
0.4401225447654724,
0.5642263293266296,
-0.44756782054901123,
-0.7810206413269043,
0.1858953833580017,
-0.7298598885536194,
-0.36880287528038025,
0.8138404488563538,
-0.27845197916030884,
-0.017588339745998383,
-0.41728317737579346,
-0.43409115076065063,
0.5144643783569336,
-0.5777907371520996,
0.8701038956642151,
0.7571349143981934,
-0.16846732795238495,
-0.26902222633361816,
-0.4372825026512146,
0.6458992958068848,
-0.20151165127754211,
-0.7494301795959473,
0.021108970046043396,
0.7578665018081665,
0.3279924690723419,
0.0871649757027626,
0.6854855418205261,
0.2751237750053406,
0.5695866346359253,
0.04054095223546028,
0.07884872704744339,
-0.3297627568244934,
-0.5455664992332458,
-0.15145213901996613,
0.5017786026000977,
-0.12756551802158356,
-0.7220561504364014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01753v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01753v3
|
M2SA: Multimodal and Multilingual Model for Sentiment Analysis of Tweets
| 2024-04-02T09:11:58 | 2024-06-12T07:12:36 |
Gaurish Thakkar, Sherzod Hakimov, Marko Tadić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, multimodal natural language processing, aimed at learning
from diverse data types, has garnered significant attention. However, there
needs to be more clarity when it comes to analysing multimodal tasks in
multi-lingual contexts. While prior studies on sentiment analysis of tweets
have predominantly focused on the English language, this paper addresses this
gap by transforming an existing textual Twitter sentiment dataset into a
multimodal format through a straightforward curation process. Our work opens up
new avenues for sentiment-related research within the research community.
Additionally, we conduct baseline experiments utilising this augmented dataset
and report the findings. Notably, our evaluations reveal that when comparing
unimodal and multimodal configurations, using a sentiment-tuned large language
model as a text encoder performs exceptionally well.
|
[
-0.35458922386169434,
-0.7072198390960693,
0.26924359798431396,
0.4814348816871643,
-0.44301700592041016,
0.3519287109375,
-0.20301225781440735,
-0.25331202149391174,
0.5516302585601807,
0.17647725343704224,
-0.6228014826774597,
-0.45703887939453125,
-0.9610379934310913,
0.28214284777641296,
-0.130228191614151,
0.8489504456520081,
-0.003854746464639902,
0.3463798761367798,
-0.10766372084617615,
-0.479473739862442,
-0.30703094601631165,
-0.3867746889591217,
-0.79642254114151,
0.03611493483185768,
0.6462868452072144,
0.36246177554130554,
0.628884494304657,
-0.17965549230575562,
0.560782253742218,
0.23752622306346893,
0.048992179334163666,
0.7788981795310974,
-0.22150862216949463,
0.10293616354465485,
-0.01753242127597332,
-0.05604616180062294,
-0.6470836400985718,
0.20776592195034027,
0.6213444471359253,
0.6138752698898315,
0.05754728615283966,
0.10697370022535324,
0.24595923721790314,
0.5330593585968018,
-0.5087197422981262,
0.16175827383995056,
-0.315836101770401,
0.06375250220298767,
-0.19652891159057617,
-0.309292197227478,
-0.41386184096336365,
-0.2510499656200409,
-0.2613365352153778,
-0.17966775596141815,
-0.1543603539466858,
-0.06653229147195816,
0.5955042243003845,
-0.05787477269768715,
-0.935540497303009,
-0.12019061297178268,
-0.4510068893432617,
1.0371711254119873,
-0.5006717443466187,
0.5193668603897095,
0.24955211579799652,
0.3597545921802521,
0.3161121606826782,
-0.41834956407546997,
-0.6751400828361511,
0.04644583538174629,
0.014070517383515835,
0.23696614801883698,
-0.09203317016363144,
-0.23299455642700195,
-0.12722444534301758,
0.3027271628379822,
-0.3925732374191284,
-0.27034708857536316,
-0.20155420899391174,
-0.1990928202867508,
0.59108567237854,
0.17503313720226288,
0.30976417660713196,
-0.5359504818916321,
-0.25460052490234375,
0.13599124550819397,
-0.3878571391105652,
0.08572392165660858,
0.2106582075357437,
0.42056119441986084,
-0.3479730784893036,
0.9243844151496887,
-0.013691486790776253,
0.4670114517211914,
-0.35530099272727966,
-0.1709890514612198,
0.5906046628952026,
-0.36112409830093384,
-0.2913512885570526,
-0.5825862288475037,
0.9514696002006531,
0.7821175456047058,
0.29316088557243347,
-0.07714356482028961,
-0.44400903582572937,
0.23215025663375854,
0.15632708370685577,
-0.7826834917068481,
-0.09640982002019882,
0.28344959020614624,
-0.5642556548118591,
-0.40864378213882446,
0.07119527459144592,
-1.0448973178863525,
-0.6933149099349976,
-0.3576897978782654,
0.4295206665992737,
-0.3621790409088135,
-0.5445571541786194,
0.053952109068632126,
-0.3291202783584595,
0.05421753227710724,
0.3129666745662689,
-0.6204599142074585,
-0.1095179095864296,
0.48083728551864624,
0.9317892789840698,
0.23525112867355347,
-0.13518980145454407,
-0.36714205145835876,
0.15235498547554016,
-0.47424501180648804,
0.8516398668289185,
-0.8144522309303284,
-0.5597509741783142,
0.1464269757270813,
-0.00372061668895185,
-0.0694531798362732,
-0.21898320317268372,
0.6025089025497437,
-0.40529587864875793,
0.3140287697315216,
-0.5117589235305786,
-0.24714983999729156,
-0.14169004559516907,
0.5644709467887878,
-0.6733984351158142,
0.9250137805938721,
0.1305743008852005,
-0.7637704014778137,
0.45917147397994995,
-1.1257493495941162,
-0.6220531463623047,
-0.3658028542995453,
0.08498668670654297,
-0.10868337750434875,
0.29348230361938477,
0.595601499080658,
0.6939498782157898,
-0.2945151925086975,
0.1702917516231537,
-0.5530849695205688,
0.13535098731517792,
0.48761704564094543,
-0.5619024038314819,
0.8271855711936951,
0.32576093077659607,
0.06962987780570984,
0.01005692407488823,
-0.4633468687534332,
-0.1804845631122589,
0.026881959289312363,
-0.22060684859752655,
-0.2706318795681,
0.006148842163383961,
0.5171283483505249,
0.4144253432750702,
0.2957446277141571,
-0.8687372803688049,
0.1493915617465973,
0.0006284457631409168,
0.574470043182373,
0.6970763802528381,
0.11142835021018982,
0.627021312713623,
-0.0639462098479271,
0.36435577273368835,
0.3720112442970276,
0.39780402183532715,
-0.19396090507507324,
-0.5030763745307922,
-0.5966066122055054,
-0.4180511236190796,
0.11037014424800873,
0.2723373472690582,
-1.0060508251190186,
0.044539496302604675,
-0.37175074219703674,
-0.19831609725952148,
-0.9569977521896362,
0.3908975124359131,
0.04565027356147766,
0.2551078200340271,
0.21233655512332916,
0.15702229738235474,
-0.9472593069076538,
-0.9379168152809143,
-0.10945764183998108,
-0.051925595849752426,
0.2186163067817688,
-0.04963184520602226,
0.32950255274772644,
-0.8127008080482483,
0.7783454060554504,
-0.31916528940200806,
-0.44261398911476135,
-0.36944809556007385,
0.3494676649570465,
-0.1046609953045845,
0.26523202657699585,
0.6024360060691833,
-1.0007221698760986,
-0.41861972212791443,
0.032757245004177094,
-0.9859936833381653,
0.05040562525391579,
0.2174985259771347,
-0.16899335384368896,
0.3985172510147095,
0.4681967496871948,
-0.7912362217903137,
0.18046805262565613,
0.8988542556762695,
-0.3837663531303406,
0.20501556992530823,
0.36237213015556335,
0.4903213381767273,
-1.5894410610198975,
-0.05456838756799698,
0.19121719896793365,
-0.35957884788513184,
-0.4460195302963257,
-0.06130853295326233,
0.23438188433647156,
0.044021375477313995,
-0.30172890424728394,
0.6881796717643738,
-0.3972874581813812,
0.12751488387584686,
-0.2716546952724457,
0.07138083875179291,
0.32260531187057495,
0.1958368569612503,
-0.21324609220027924,
0.795907735824585,
0.36096832156181335,
-0.1837845742702484,
0.3831803500652313,
0.16086971759796143,
-0.15918610990047455,
0.6168146133422852,
-0.41956543922424316,
-0.09832137823104858,
-0.28370770812034607,
0.08531403541564941,
-1.3788444995880127,
-0.3470286726951599,
0.13642029464244843,
-0.8317544460296631,
0.2598830461502075,
-0.08366289734840393,
-0.7965051531791687,
-0.2711089849472046,
-0.520211398601532,
0.1844410002231598,
0.22435231506824493,
-0.4258897304534912,
0.9323093891143799,
0.7559624314308167,
-0.02560720220208168,
-0.418863445520401,
-0.8594262599945068,
0.4556945860385895,
-0.1521085649728775,
-0.6228746175765991,
-0.037704192101955414,
-0.1077786386013031,
-0.38289371132850647,
-0.030368592590093613,
0.15537232160568237,
-0.06129032000899315,
-0.09846039116382599,
0.23343923687934875,
0.174126997590065,
-0.1464729905128479,
0.21659491956233978,
0.2678942382335663,
-0.10801952332258224,
-0.01684168167412281,
0.09697172045707703,
0.5334323644638062,
-0.03501070663332939,
-0.09515321254730225,
-0.4403209984302521,
0.6437114477157593,
0.7816214561462402,
-0.21741726994514465,
0.947852611541748,
1.0883369445800781,
-0.5290714502334595,
0.029481038451194763,
-0.4633404016494751,
0.03343364596366882,
-0.4317916929721832,
0.10266408324241638,
-0.4928903579711914,
-0.8785786628723145,
0.24952130019664764,
0.1867237240076065,
0.22488805651664734,
0.4977709949016571,
0.6404604315757751,
-0.6341800093650818,
1.4857065677642822,
0.6259449124336243,
-0.13699078559875488,
0.4051644206047058,
-0.18587958812713623,
0.32572466135025024,
-0.73154616355896,
-0.2620358467102051,
-0.3491474986076355,
-0.2896801233291626,
-0.5530419945716858,
-0.37662121653556824,
0.3647092580795288,
-0.3081599473953247,
-0.020531244575977325,
0.005671047605574131,
0.0985584482550621,
0.19098405539989471,
0.15883027017116547,
0.21206779778003693,
-0.010679211467504501,
0.046708907932043076,
-0.027117284014821053,
-0.2945478558540344,
-0.269907683134079,
-0.7171890735626221,
1.0242571830749512,
0.3431675136089325,
0.5856134295463562,
0.5299730896949768,
0.44528841972351074,
0.6935996413230896,
0.5102692246437073,
-0.7779514789581299,
0.4941181540489197,
-0.557778537273407,
-0.5019164681434631,
-0.08398213237524033,
-0.3700830638408661,
-0.7260943055152893,
0.254100501537323,
-0.287800669670105,
-0.33920106291770935,
-0.03744954615831375,
-0.1322852522134781,
-0.06959149986505508,
0.2871023714542389,
-0.9200310111045837,
0.8031385540962219,
0.19861072301864624,
-0.12975046038627625,
-0.20425719022750854,
-0.22230218350887299,
0.3624551296234131,
0.044353146106004715,
0.6149092316627502,
-0.31357908248901367,
-0.27226054668426514,
0.7474220991134644,
-0.10423924773931503,
0.9728803038597107,
-0.46015942096710205,
-0.21118056774139404,
0.10255851596593857,
0.1057673841714859,
0.1530916690826416,
0.3874874413013458,
-0.2039269655942917,
0.02690110169351101,
-0.11913228780031204,
-0.6640644073486328,
-0.5600408315658569,
0.7361885905265808,
-0.8246944546699524,
-0.21762947738170624,
-0.0899505689740181,
-0.5821977853775024,
-0.6433835029602051,
-0.017472248524427414,
0.039693377912044525,
0.6730155348777771,
-0.20614029467105865,
0.2789364457130432,
0.38280701637268066,
0.1323809027671814,
0.7547592520713806,
0.19121424853801727,
-0.35863953828811646,
-0.6205675005912781,
0.7610594034194946,
0.11744676530361176,
-0.08048392832279205,
0.6052309274673462,
0.11377034336328506,
-0.4966925382614136,
-0.17227980494499207,
-0.6157897710800171,
0.016905292868614197,
-0.7812434434890747,
-0.3449659049510956,
-0.9476696252822876,
0.027492882683873177,
-0.7130902409553528,
-0.12168614566326141,
-0.33541741967201233,
-0.5865504741668701,
-0.21029314398765564,
-0.30318939685821533,
0.42244940996170044,
0.6569293737411499,
-0.07476439327001572,
0.504141092300415,
-1.034592866897583,
0.5343000888824463,
0.3446463644504547,
0.261950820684433,
-0.246065154671669,
-0.5611228346824646,
-0.2376631498336792,
0.34485986828804016,
-0.10549493879079819,
-0.8631787896156311,
0.6092268228530884,
0.2130788415670395,
0.3141046166419983,
0.5978239178657532,
-0.24880383908748627,
0.8279896378517151,
-0.28883087635040283,
0.8756680488586426,
0.3237725496292114,
-0.807098388671875,
0.41398870944976807,
-0.594340980052948,
0.17505641281604767,
0.4024055600166321,
0.27820107340812683,
-0.6430878043174744,
-0.1587836742401123,
-0.17191648483276367,
-0.48853734135627747,
0.2893355190753937,
-0.002060955623164773,
0.5667611956596375,
-0.15923823416233063,
-0.161627396941185,
0.26990073919296265,
0.264360249042511,
-0.6370763182640076,
0.028362464159727097,
-0.3037092983722687,
-0.583855152130127,
-0.651718258857727,
-0.5268192291259766,
-0.247585728764534,
-0.2938888967037201,
0.4901527464389801,
-0.10894769430160522,
0.5240580439567566,
-0.2897409498691559,
-0.4409768581390381,
0.010345240123569965,
0.13057301938533783,
0.441920667886734,
0.4624011814594269,
-0.24969355762004852,
0.2761336863040924,
-0.08620472252368927,
-0.2980017364025116,
-0.04439190775156021,
-0.062378812581300735,
0.15568362176418304,
0.1660209596157074,
0.2913663983345032,
0.6154882907867432,
0.21313908696174622,
-0.45975351333618164,
0.6044676303863525,
-0.17866204679012299,
-0.13401885330677032,
-0.11949560046195984,
-0.49533939361572266,
0.16446435451507568,
0.17998211085796356,
0.4931669235229492,
0.4226588308811188,
0.23207853734493256,
-0.6629595756530762,
0.09732166677713394,
0.51482093334198,
-0.549157977104187,
-0.626808762550354,
0.2195572406053543,
0.4810536801815033,
0.005633500404655933,
0.3340446650981903,
-0.21985259652137756,
-0.35403966903686523,
0.14713364839553833,
0.2889523208141327,
1.0590879917144775,
-0.20379193127155304,
0.5105850696563721,
0.1990724354982376,
0.5359614491462708,
0.1694931834936142,
0.7110840082168579,
0.12024345993995667,
-0.8815410733222961,
-0.46874022483825684,
-0.7566486597061157,
-0.260393351316452,
-0.28021493554115295,
-0.4836234748363495,
0.13256272673606873,
-0.370170921087265,
-0.5041866302490234,
0.2296106517314911,
-0.08983104676008224,
-0.5551936030387878,
0.5267819762229919,
0.14031819999217987,
0.7490667700767517,
-1.03708016872406,
0.7687252163887024,
0.967536985874176,
-0.42270541191101074,
-0.32453620433807373,
-0.12981079518795013,
0.17370228469371796,
-0.7216299176216125,
0.35417047142982483,
0.3689449727535248,
-0.1538735032081604,
-0.2137174755334854,
-0.560049295425415,
-0.5209764242172241,
0.7790893912315369,
0.14247021079063416,
-0.0006124819628894329,
0.12477842718362808,
0.3344042897224426,
0.5583769679069519,
-0.46284952759742737,
0.1908339560031891,
0.3279414772987366,
0.5194517970085144,
-0.15889695286750793,
-0.5922391414642334,
-0.29633453488349915,
-0.691936194896698,
-0.12042640149593353,
0.35860058665275574,
-0.6204513311386108,
0.8720160722732544,
-0.0017820891225710511,
-0.0005915479268878698,
-0.2583305239677429,
0.6636531949043274,
-0.05973859131336212,
0.38770511746406555,
0.3370613157749176,
0.4336421489715576,
0.48247411847114563,
-0.2063867747783661,
0.9345011711120605,
-0.07134481519460678,
0.20734944939613342,
0.5877268314361572,
-0.25660064816474915,
1.109392762184143,
0.8212842345237732,
-0.2035721242427826,
0.5303146243095398,
0.4962899088859558,
0.34914183616638184,
0.39633387327194214,
-0.6662073731422424,
-0.2963072955608368,
-0.36306771636009216,
-0.26054638624191284,
0.025682849809527397,
0.5611066222190857,
0.5437864661216736,
-0.17913329601287842,
-0.2241167277097702,
0.4561746120452881,
0.15863898396492004,
0.09351485967636108,
-0.4395551383495331,
0.7253862619400024,
0.1570465862751007,
-0.3417643904685974,
-0.10003785043954849,
0.30857208371162415,
0.9154149293899536,
-0.4822426736354828,
0.26424679160118103,
-0.37798458337783813,
0.13374751806259155,
-0.36111631989479065,
-1.2225918769836426,
0.6787431240081787,
0.09824761003255844,
-0.26123863458633423,
-0.35171476006507874,
0.6083025932312012,
-0.16866041719913483,
-0.7339706420898438,
0.47395455837249756,
0.671067476272583,
-0.1940995752811432,
-0.13754317164421082,
-0.7105140089988708,
0.05554935336112976,
0.03646941855549812,
-0.4238811135292053,
0.25846976041793823,
0.6046630144119263,
-0.009110131300985813,
0.6026154160499573,
0.7181193232536316,
-0.288255512714386,
0.14402617514133453,
0.43866705894470215,
0.733832836151123,
-0.7263292074203491,
-0.37477514147758484,
-0.9752202033996582,
0.7832064032554626,
-0.20346610248088837,
-0.32568439841270447,
0.9622578024864197,
0.4840157926082611,
0.4252382516860962,
-0.18934223055839539,
0.9157989025115967,
-0.24387845396995544,
0.669958233833313,
-0.4610220789909363,
0.634621262550354,
-0.8206623196601868,
0.025810331106185913,
-0.21093931794166565,
-0.6664358973503113,
-0.4161207675933838,
0.36704421043395996,
-0.14885303378105164,
0.22910675406455994,
0.46856871247291565,
0.8806219696998596,
-0.1330590397119522,
0.18904811143875122,
0.37088674306869507,
0.048510655760765076,
0.2773641049861908,
0.13171115517616272,
0.8620964884757996,
-0.4708309471607208,
0.37431609630584717,
-0.3607017695903778,
-0.02910027652978897,
-0.15195216238498688,
-0.8382949233055115,
-1.060528039932251,
-0.8310745358467102,
-0.0771719217300415,
-0.40150734782218933,
-0.17390282452106476,
1.0931687355041504,
0.4918507933616638,
-0.7601019144058228,
-0.15199804306030273,
0.5285404324531555,
-0.11854048818349838,
-0.030331559479236603,
-0.2714208960533142,
0.16453447937965393,
-0.5653918385505676,
-0.7674076557159424,
0.2813519239425659,
0.36640068888664246,
-0.0871889665722847,
-0.14005973935127258,
-0.11048467457294464,
-0.3090689182281494,
0.4762912392616272,
1.2114348411560059,
-0.2996530532836914,
-0.4195325970649719,
-0.1145312637090683,
0.07538966834545135,
-0.4114885926246643,
0.09640298783779144,
0.6562867164611816,
-0.28374481201171875,
0.4903908669948578,
0.4679142236709595,
0.5810089111328125,
0.14251866936683655,
-0.18930086493492126,
0.34292367100715637,
-0.9864358305931091,
0.07972175627946854,
0.054620154201984406,
0.659257173538208,
0.5916793346405029,
0.03624122962355614,
0.32966601848602295,
0.24230165779590607,
-0.11327964067459106,
-0.8462360501289368,
-0.0026784788351505995,
-1.2540624141693115,
-0.1559976488351822,
1.4448918104171753,
0.28544965386390686,
-0.11725319176912308,
-0.045072298496961594,
-0.43378493189811707,
0.24683745205402374,
-0.5579071640968323,
0.6727381348609924,
0.6296316385269165,
0.2611473798751831,
-0.37357503175735474,
-0.5303909778594971,
0.1646510511636734,
0.2092481255531311,
-0.7692146897315979,
-0.09503337740898132,
0.533454954624176,
0.1293773651123047,
-0.019594445824623108,
0.7016630172729492,
-0.25440746545791626,
0.24394747614860535,
-0.026723826304078102,
0.01166543923318386,
-0.07549788057804108,
-0.35368627309799194,
-0.2620731592178345,
0.5132114887237549,
0.013196855783462524,
-0.33366158604621887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01744v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01744v5
|
Octopus v2: On-device language model for super agent
| 2024-04-02T09:01:32 | 2024-04-16T16:39:51 |
Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models have shown effectiveness in a variety of software
applications, particularly in tasks related to automatic workflow. These models
possess the crucial ability to call functions, which is essential in creating
AI agents. Despite the high performance of large-scale language models in cloud
environments, they are often associated with concerns over privacy and cost.
Current on-device models for function calling face issues with latency and
accuracy. Our research presents a new method that empowers an on-device model
with 2 billion parameters to surpass the performance of GPT-4 in both accuracy
and latency, and decrease the context length by 95\%. When compared to Llama-7B
with a RAG-based function calling mechanism, our method enhances latency by
35-fold. This method reduces the latency to levels deemed suitable for
deployment across a variety of edge devices in production environments,
aligning with the performance requisites for real-world applications.
|
[
-0.27777063846588135,
-0.8355982303619385,
0.5585896372795105,
0.03619467839598656,
-0.32772839069366455,
0.04870852455496788,
0.18022826313972473,
-1.0392807722091675,
0.2820119559764862,
0.7078683376312256,
-0.2797465920448303,
0.017129482701420784,
-0.14341658353805542,
-0.014556928537786007,
-0.21841134130954742,
0.6033995747566223,
0.30734875798225403,
-0.24942101538181305,
-0.13452358543872833,
0.019013382494449615,
-0.019949626177549362,
-0.36680975556373596,
-0.7821963429450989,
-0.28378012776374817,
0.3520858883857727,
0.5142096877098083,
1.2252837419509888,
0.9878224730491638,
0.5969598293304443,
0.31273671984672546,
-0.1767583191394806,
0.03179008886218071,
-0.2308175265789032,
0.2491101175546646,
-0.037287529557943344,
-0.6986861228942871,
-1.0207024812698364,
-0.24864250421524048,
0.5013484954833984,
0.19339050352573395,
-0.18740132451057434,
-0.04476986452937126,
-0.3528265953063965,
0.30755487084388733,
-0.22772756218910217,
0.28056201338768005,
-0.6527835130691528,
-0.01566418819129467,
-0.22421838343143463,
0.13369131088256836,
-0.3257367014884949,
-0.04853663966059685,
0.15637609362602234,
-0.823333203792572,
0.023263661190867424,
-0.1841752976179123,
0.8734648823738098,
0.5546450614929199,
-0.26424938440322876,
0.1993766576051712,
-0.9803690314292908,
0.6031996011734009,
-0.9313639402389526,
0.6249015927314758,
0.5897347331047058,
0.1954406350851059,
-0.01169196330010891,
-1.1066064834594727,
-0.8955762386322021,
-0.5128734111785889,
0.2841665744781494,
-0.058895647525787354,
-0.02559242956340313,
0.15658287703990936,
0.27098676562309265,
-0.034500136971473694,
-0.2862399220466614,
0.34163588285446167,
-0.3501070737838745,
-0.08756636828184128,
0.7873522639274597,
0.13321071863174438,
0.16639626026153564,
0.19758635759353638,
-0.08466804027557373,
0.09252676367759705,
-0.9347785115242004,
-0.06136242300271988,
0.27298447489738464,
0.004321484360843897,
-0.12037696689367294,
0.418931245803833,
-0.503294825553894,
0.4438861608505249,
0.00913900975137949,
-0.41723379492759705,
0.19739769399166107,
-0.23915183544158936,
0.18345868587493896,
-0.10209693014621735,
0.4986244738101959,
0.6153367161750793,
-0.0843365266919136,
-0.19378189742565155,
-0.19769246876239777,
0.0626523494720459,
0.47046273946762085,
-0.9389609098434448,
-0.049154918640851974,
0.4286312162876129,
-0.16521048545837402,
-0.24410399794578552,
-0.30387550592422485,
-0.4367477297782898,
-0.43532639741897583,
-0.02825816161930561,
0.18644572794437408,
-0.25360023975372314,
-0.5217227935791016,
-0.14950653910636902,
0.3695340156555176,
0.30251240730285645,
0.2638915181159973,
-0.904357373714447,
0.6057444214820862,
0.698482096195221,
0.9119815826416016,
-0.10246872901916504,
-0.30757269263267517,
-0.5851045846939087,
0.26546236872673035,
-0.48209047317504883,
0.8886392712593079,
-0.8057550191879272,
-0.42703378200531006,
-0.37638914585113525,
-0.1455509066581726,
0.03317926079034805,
-0.46196824312210083,
0.4391885995864868,
-0.5059021711349487,
0.06750887632369995,
0.15319304168224335,
-0.4210049510002136,
-0.38852816820144653,
-0.24895019829273224,
-0.6710732579231262,
1.1468327045440674,
0.22547432780265808,
-0.37156736850738525,
0.1874857395887375,
-0.9891822338104248,
-0.5155184268951416,
0.5463046431541443,
-0.03639847785234451,
-0.7183850407600403,
0.1013559028506279,
-0.0038960352540016174,
0.6782201528549194,
-0.3891581594944,
0.0042461068369448185,
-0.4150751531124115,
-0.49131911993026733,
-0.03641337528824806,
-0.10472367703914642,
0.3735078275203705,
0.4545252025127411,
-0.625786542892456,
-0.1429133117198944,
-0.7179921269416809,
0.0984671413898468,
0.05846323072910309,
-0.10391302406787872,
-0.29040956497192383,
0.27583491802215576,
-0.0033893503714352846,
0.18234200775623322,
0.19204622507095337,
-0.6381859183311462,
0.32251036167144775,
-0.5213656425476074,
0.7959681153297424,
0.15970373153686523,
-0.2689010202884674,
0.3207778334617615,
-0.16011449694633484,
0.4310447573661804,
-0.3388002812862396,
0.24022579193115234,
-0.20386113226413727,
-0.8282856345176697,
-0.3597790002822876,
-0.4042622148990631,
0.11845355480909348,
0.7742581367492676,
-0.8789297938346863,
0.22217483818531036,
-0.26361173391342163,
-0.9980062246322632,
-0.3719690144062042,
0.14282362163066864,
0.5071547031402588,
0.46369847655296326,
0.2582768201828003,
-0.40555647015571594,
-0.3099554777145386,
-0.6708084940910339,
0.11807332932949066,
-0.6084392070770264,
-0.06427744776010513,
0.6514689326286316,
0.1753913164138794,
-0.762105405330658,
1.0792500972747803,
-0.1871102750301361,
-0.0009507167851552367,
-0.3731544315814972,
-0.13593536615371704,
0.17737779021263123,
0.35006967186927795,
0.4251706302165985,
-0.8919258713722229,
-0.3314272165298462,
0.2750670611858368,
-0.49361974000930786,
-0.5361728668212891,
0.1407444030046463,
0.3830278813838959,
0.6240554451942444,
0.39201581478118896,
-0.8574323654174805,
0.3356519043445587,
0.5802953243255615,
-0.37128832936286926,
0.591781497001648,
-0.47014138102531433,
-0.028615551069378853,
-1.066328525543213,
-0.060941342264413834,
-0.0004359749727882445,
-0.1251850426197052,
-0.8090739250183105,
0.21021556854248047,
0.12491907179355621,
-0.13783803582191467,
-1.0763776302337646,
0.6132279634475708,
-0.2524745762348175,
-0.260135680437088,
-0.30554014444351196,
-0.17180553078651428,
-0.06889857351779938,
0.20025299489498138,
0.23020458221435547,
1.0721880197525024,
0.6287950277328491,
-0.8850274085998535,
0.49323755502700806,
-0.04006301611661911,
0.18994124233722687,
0.6642632484436035,
-1.0219734907150269,
0.20961761474609375,
0.3289436101913452,
0.24220141768455505,
-1.0241361856460571,
-0.1680058240890503,
0.025962388142943382,
-0.19720715284347534,
0.053894199430942535,
-0.11952081322669983,
-0.6267284750938416,
-0.24896305799484253,
-0.20241409540176392,
0.4928910732269287,
0.6246439218521118,
-0.3555523455142975,
0.5501797795295715,
0.6760250926017761,
-0.45247817039489746,
-0.03500818461179733,
-0.40155163407325745,
0.12875288724899292,
-0.46648484468460083,
-0.8634323477745056,
0.6868895292282104,
0.0563175305724144,
-0.12610438466072083,
-0.22538258135318756,
-0.014910741709172726,
-0.1774212121963501,
0.22422145307064056,
0.3183101713657379,
0.11398402601480484,
-0.28588631749153137,
0.07931649684906006,
0.2683493494987488,
-0.3982636630535126,
-0.2093236744403839,
-0.29549315571784973,
0.48028773069381714,
-0.18995264172554016,
-0.1352640986442566,
-0.7042874693870544,
0.1503489911556244,
0.8675937056541443,
-0.2561591565608978,
0.5722610950469971,
0.45997586846351624,
-0.49359938502311707,
0.02553603984415531,
-0.5810194611549377,
-0.4273110628128052,
-0.558597207069397,
0.5786170959472656,
-0.5644423961639404,
-0.7083582282066345,
0.5742478370666504,
-0.033759571611881256,
0.0023264093324542046,
0.2933084964752197,
0.5707338452339172,
-0.014824829064309597,
0.9970024228096008,
0.6651970744132996,
-0.015269237570464611,
0.6074183583259583,
-0.2336975485086441,
0.30726608633995056,
-0.7622863054275513,
-0.1838713139295578,
-0.4480406641960144,
0.15965187549591064,
-0.6233960390090942,
-0.5220413208007812,
0.5099875330924988,
0.04878631979227066,
-0.33349350094795227,
0.6575393080711365,
-0.4171241819858551,
0.460345983505249,
0.35854920744895935,
-0.07058034837245941,
0.20676788687705994,
0.20065224170684814,
-0.07629599422216415,
-0.034998077899217606,
-0.6842405200004578,
-0.718085527420044,
1.0834698677062988,
0.720050573348999,
0.6610181331634521,
0.21884317696094513,
0.3274456560611725,
0.4971507787704468,
0.06815613061189651,
-0.2975473403930664,
0.7932963371276855,
-0.007152164820581675,
-0.2652917504310608,
-0.6820205450057983,
-0.19705724716186523,
-0.8581734895706177,
0.5006091594696045,
0.14514409005641937,
-1.2459262609481812,
-0.15690013766288757,
0.1340378224849701,
-0.5895509719848633,
0.32036057114601135,
-0.7697113752365112,
0.5456612706184387,
-0.11009106785058975,
-0.748629093170166,
-0.19423727691173553,
-0.458716481924057,
-0.07411640137434006,
-0.0013947042170912027,
0.06972271203994751,
-0.23699471354484558,
-0.45553433895111084,
0.6121760010719299,
-0.8229487538337708,
0.706998884677887,
-0.09540590643882751,
-0.41118910908699036,
0.46906206011772156,
0.17487536370754242,
0.8639495372772217,
0.1606249064207077,
-0.3025261163711548,
0.38670384883880615,
-0.031582191586494446,
-0.18129122257232666,
-0.4150518774986267,
0.6371567845344543,
-0.8306500911712646,
-0.40071943402290344,
-0.08463246375322342,
-0.28719285130500793,
-0.05308341234922409,
0.180524542927742,
0.2627391219139099,
0.39670729637145996,
0.1336621791124344,
0.10799295455217361,
0.45624276995658875,
-0.004021536558866501,
0.725720226764679,
0.7215670943260193,
-0.24141782522201538,
-0.1919707953929901,
1.1854459047317505,
0.44228777289390564,
0.3804534077644348,
0.13577859103679657,
0.061886489391326904,
-0.8131893873214722,
-0.2969227433204651,
-0.7554791569709778,
0.3087228536605835,
-0.1509082168340683,
0.04996998980641365,
-0.8909426927566528,
0.041252102702856064,
-0.40729856491088867,
-0.07455804198980331,
-0.8913983702659607,
-0.7222558856010437,
-0.17775516211986542,
-0.12604685127735138,
0.5318200588226318,
0.6115056872367859,
-0.11030252277851105,
0.9370158314704895,
-0.5922011733055115,
0.3140747845172882,
0.25022175908088684,
0.6201933026313782,
-0.37137654423713684,
-0.5180304050445557,
-0.21334047615528107,
0.017660144716501236,
-0.49645984172821045,
-0.9872041344642639,
0.3863183259963989,
0.42111170291900635,
0.5332838892936707,
0.4646875262260437,
-0.082060307264328,
0.30038371682167053,
-0.4134492874145508,
0.8265385031700134,
-0.13169164955615997,
-1.0999335050582886,
0.4157152771949768,
-0.49765413999557495,
0.033398911356925964,
-0.027255048975348473,
0.08123674988746643,
-0.4797622263431549,
-0.5013399720191956,
-0.8453986048698425,
-1.1194783449172974,
0.7617961764335632,
0.3356381356716156,
0.18260261416435242,
0.3803442120552063,
0.401573121547699,
-0.10003965348005295,
0.15737944841384888,
-0.4036377966403961,
-0.10299500077962875,
-0.055387504398822784,
0.13939529657363892,
-0.16107335686683655,
-0.20026841759681702,
0.33860671520233154,
-0.21798376739025116,
0.597995936870575,
-0.2650659382343292,
0.4730323851108551,
0.24942328035831451,
0.03928425535559654,
-0.1455180048942566,
0.030737126246094704,
0.8421280980110168,
0.646503210067749,
0.19850315153598785,
0.034352004528045654,
0.6202832460403442,
-0.72279953956604,
0.21596573293209076,
0.2508225739002228,
-0.3620792329311371,
-0.12550561130046844,
0.16645587980747223,
0.6097736954689026,
0.04072701930999756,
-0.5732775330543518,
0.17364254593849182,
0.09482742100954056,
0.23759996891021729,
-0.23747806251049042,
0.4260764420032501,
0.09657178074121475,
0.3341740369796753,
0.3875562250614166,
-0.31963256001472473,
0.3537459671497345,
-0.258963406085968,
0.4259960949420929,
0.10964681208133698,
-0.4861430525779724,
-0.4605226516723633,
0.9142342209815979,
0.4406084716320038,
-0.6915291547775269,
0.36461907625198364,
-0.2917357385158539,
-0.5379617214202881,
0.907882034778595,
0.7095161080360413,
0.6924536824226379,
-0.6960819959640503,
0.4339804947376251,
-0.17917363345623016,
0.3821851909160614,
-0.14103548228740692,
0.5271895527839661,
0.0358002744615078,
-0.4730888903141022,
-0.4143778681755066,
-0.36623331904411316,
-0.8023302555084229,
0.05316236615180969,
-0.061851345002651215,
-0.005141265224665403,
-0.35217612981796265,
-0.3781484067440033,
-0.23556259274482727,
0.1747693121433258,
-0.4245145618915558,
0.2537306845188141,
0.21976158022880554,
0.6857802867889404,
-0.5723855495452881,
0.9832943677902222,
0.865157961845398,
-0.14381398260593414,
-0.845248281955719,
-0.14808166027069092,
-0.019024159759283066,
-0.36047059297561646,
0.18309935927391052,
0.3273477554321289,
-0.3324413001537323,
0.1592131108045578,
-0.3910733759403229,
-0.9533140659332275,
1.1722029447555542,
0.493040531873703,
-0.5056605935096741,
0.4368986189365387,
0.5156300067901611,
0.8567943572998047,
-0.6257839202880859,
0.8605769276618958,
0.5532887578010559,
0.36641383171081543,
-0.1412772834300995,
-1.3911147117614746,
0.040031496435403824,
-0.41641664505004883,
0.36209478974342346,
-0.11242809891700745,
-0.9364804029464722,
0.9466112852096558,
-0.5815469026565552,
-0.12309448421001434,
-0.021249864250421524,
0.6390079259872437,
0.281851202249527,
0.42696473002433777,
0.3964219391345978,
0.389326810836792,
0.8329565525054932,
0.007171052973717451,
1.1182544231414795,
-0.5537580251693726,
0.3038676679134369,
0.6621304154396057,
-0.799480140209198,
0.9614396095275879,
0.3468037545681,
-0.15870150923728943,
0.3518039882183075,
0.5908458232879639,
0.3501130938529968,
0.45641136169433594,
0.0645037591457367,
-0.2493760585784912,
-0.06736645102500916,
-0.17740753293037415,
-0.5766963958740234,
0.22591155767440796,
0.45864519476890564,
0.09096859395503998,
0.21865783631801605,
-0.1384226381778717,
0.2829296886920929,
-0.3046390116214752,
-0.22963842749595642,
0.6944305896759033,
-0.09365537017583847,
-0.6310038566589355,
0.5709545612335205,
0.2614727020263672,
0.37192755937576294,
-0.32709112763404846,
-0.11235446482896805,
-0.4030607342720032,
0.3971947133541107,
-0.2153775691986084,
-0.5046370029449463,
0.3922331631183624,
-0.07716185599565506,
0.19518592953681946,
0.2211851179599762,
0.68255215883255,
-0.22051116824150085,
-0.31944960355758667,
0.32135939598083496,
0.26096102595329285,
0.4470127820968628,
-0.1794409155845642,
-0.6238844990730286,
0.4204603135585785,
-0.3960071802139282,
-0.4102987051010132,
-0.1638435423374176,
0.19570279121398926,
-0.23984868824481964,
1.151980996131897,
0.7376921772956848,
-0.04785357043147087,
0.24636726081371307,
-0.35605430603027344,
0.7213158011436462,
-0.47844886779785156,
-0.9157921671867371,
-0.7146276235580444,
0.5766382813453674,
-0.103938527405262,
-0.45867085456848145,
0.37415745854377747,
0.6516909003257751,
0.7752207517623901,
0.01965317130088806,
0.8053416013717651,
-0.12491688877344131,
0.3699047863483429,
-0.2931690514087677,
0.7608546018600464,
-0.628438413143158,
0.5712602734565735,
-0.4249495267868042,
-1.0259428024291992,
-0.30990657210350037,
0.6338759064674377,
-0.31963494420051575,
0.0461638979613781,
0.4958108067512512,
1.14779794216156,
-0.1993863731622696,
0.13104142248630524,
0.5602388381958008,
0.26935771107673645,
0.4088359475135803,
0.39003825187683105,
0.6087361574172974,
-0.5745109915733337,
0.35437870025634766,
-0.20128947496414185,
-0.29466989636421204,
-0.6003974080085754,
-0.8088471293449402,
-0.47043508291244507,
-0.5907261967658997,
-0.3865874409675598,
-0.30639708042144775,
0.43408751487731934,
0.6598044633865356,
1.078787922859192,
-0.4901764690876007,
-0.34536483883857727,
0.03524674102663994,
0.14604058861732483,
-0.4451158344745636,
-0.08597853034734726,
0.12902286648750305,
-0.028983639553189278,
-0.6766383647918701,
0.47425493597984314,
0.36496829986572266,
0.01696435734629631,
-0.2972390651702881,
-0.6252687573432922,
0.31446245312690735,
0.32512256503105164,
0.5711642503738403,
0.5276097655296326,
-0.7321032881736755,
-0.34567779302597046,
-0.057924482971429825,
-0.22974680364131927,
-0.0008188746287487447,
0.5379471778869629,
-0.6263558268547058,
0.2508290708065033,
0.3333163261413574,
0.531624972820282,
0.42906832695007324,
-0.09542502462863922,
0.5465491414070129,
-0.34816601872444153,
0.17309045791625977,
-0.0118258660659194,
0.20432110130786896,
0.07343727350234985,
-0.565321147441864,
0.7602687478065491,
0.4270764887332916,
-0.482979416847229,
-0.8625363111495972,
0.3387599289417267,
-0.8978986144065857,
0.19146759808063507,
1.2202454805374146,
-0.2076365053653717,
-0.17636846005916595,
-0.3625822067260742,
-0.44449296593666077,
0.07771360129117966,
-0.6232087016105652,
0.7583716511726379,
0.11920775473117828,
-0.3611123561859131,
-0.36882948875427246,
-0.44875413179397583,
0.30339160561561584,
0.38616302609443665,
-1.0005260705947876,
-0.20943588018417358,
0.23172642290592194,
0.14364905655384064,
0.2600398361682892,
0.7823028564453125,
0.031241081655025482,
0.5377742648124695,
0.18441711366176605,
0.1217397004365921,
-0.23950636386871338,
-0.639447033405304,
-0.04268468916416168,
0.2228153944015503,
0.061239443719387054,
-0.13052307069301605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01737v1
|
Transfer Learning from Whisper for Microscopic Intelligibility Prediction
| 2024-04-02T08:53:51 | 2024-04-02T08:53:51 |
Paul Best, Santiago Cuervo, Ricard Marxer
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Macroscopic intelligibility models predict the expected human word-error-rate
for a given speech-in-noise stimulus. In contrast, microscopic intelligibility
models aim to make fine-grained predictions about listeners' perception, e.g.
predicting phonetic or lexical responses. State-of-the-art macroscopic models
use transfer learning from large scale deep learning models for speech
processing, whereas such methods have rarely been used for microscopic
modeling. In this paper, we study the use of transfer learning from Whisper, a
state-of-the-art deep learning model for automatic speech recognition, for
microscopic intelligibility prediction at the level of lexical responses. Our
method outperforms the considered baselines, even in a zero-shot setup, and
yields a relative improvement of up to 66\% when fine-tuned to predict
listeners' responses. Our results showcase the promise of large scale deep
learning based methods for microscopic intelligibility prediction.
|
[
-0.24137245118618011,
-0.4989319443702698,
0.5289697647094727,
-0.10020440816879272,
-0.13213355839252472,
0.1467989683151245,
-0.3569141626358032,
-0.7577344179153442,
0.10779841989278793,
0.027573851868510246,
-0.5389315485954285,
-0.34249013662338257,
-0.5424686670303345,
-0.1843116730451584,
-0.41822826862335205,
0.4157712459564209,
0.6504482626914978,
0.16232658922672272,
-0.06546211987733841,
0.3021477460861206,
-0.318610817193985,
-0.12979882955551147,
-0.5491211414337158,
-0.22541922330856323,
0.30254191160202026,
0.5211052894592285,
0.5710465312004089,
0.3073051869869232,
0.5226923227310181,
0.24842749536037445,
-0.3225610852241516,
0.06298183649778366,
-0.259890615940094,
-0.3038618266582489,
-0.06657200306653976,
-0.39151936769485474,
-0.3897724747657776,
-0.1409447342157364,
0.587603747844696,
0.862815260887146,
-0.3377905786037445,
-0.01298606675118208,
0.22346171736717224,
0.5628108382225037,
-0.4306787848472595,
0.429322749376297,
-1.033065676689148,
0.4933755397796631,
0.24989888072013855,
-0.0359107181429863,
-0.4901127517223358,
-0.4606940448284149,
0.6036436557769775,
-0.6107289791107178,
0.23575566709041595,
-0.2269008904695511,
0.22360444068908691,
0.06280684471130371,
-0.10176654160022736,
-0.1747385561466217,
-0.9066399931907654,
0.436923623085022,
-0.896552562713623,
0.5718572735786438,
0.40693408250808716,
0.48141464591026306,
0.07393480092287064,
-0.7435461282730103,
-0.5441217422485352,
-0.7102570533752441,
0.16455066204071045,
0.2694992423057556,
-0.33224332332611084,
0.2273666262626648,
0.0025430929381400347,
0.16038410365581512,
-0.4585582911968231,
0.11301737278699875,
-0.7639153003692627,
-0.5445332527160645,
0.41303884983062744,
-0.010455874726176262,
0.19072484970092773,
-0.054952412843704224,
-0.349163681268692,
-0.10059399902820587,
-0.10291998088359833,
0.11671502888202667,
-0.13865965604782104,
0.7882238626480103,
-0.026378056034445763,
0.05795958265662193,
-0.04161810874938965,
0.6075232625007629,
0.12681706249713898,
-0.1767662912607193,
0.2874380946159363,
0.006687217392027378,
-0.053693242371082306,
0.6685119271278381,
0.6510199308395386,
0.14842505753040314,
0.6307880282402039,
-0.22744940221309662,
0.1185060441493988,
-0.19513225555419922,
0.2605378329753876,
-0.8085305690765381,
-0.23735137283802032,
-0.09703385084867477,
-0.4224998652935028,
-0.40030965209007263,
-0.02623714506626129,
-0.746756374835968,
-0.4456600546836853,
-0.4182572662830353,
0.7542015910148621,
-0.7285621762275696,
-0.4365140497684479,
0.2434152215719223,
0.03348425403237343,
-0.27091580629348755,
0.28176072239875793,
-0.7426934242248535,
0.18347585201263428,
0.499549925327301,
1.187251329421997,
0.020059965550899506,
-0.38065677881240845,
-0.803891122341156,
0.37685632705688477,
-0.2966144382953644,
0.9266629219055176,
-0.5367947816848755,
-0.7358686923980713,
0.0676628053188324,
-0.35707131028175354,
-0.19609561562538147,
-0.7641687393188477,
0.513932466506958,
-0.0916212722659111,
-0.5639858245849609,
0.31663984060287476,
-0.7486171126365662,
-0.07519138604402542,
-0.2581603527069092,
-0.4373510181903839,
0.2436007410287857,
0.17788264155387878,
-0.3567919135093689,
0.1921001672744751,
-0.4598415791988373,
-0.6082586646080017,
-0.011248534545302391,
0.1567266881465912,
-0.2435770034790039,
0.6027966141700745,
0.002974139526486397,
0.5403671264648438,
0.285205215215683,
0.16310563683509827,
-0.6119116544723511,
-0.3783608376979828,
0.37229442596435547,
-0.578982949256897,
0.2544982135295868,
0.3473889231681824,
-0.20258782804012299,
0.13499611616134644,
-1.119214653968811,
0.012890947051346302,
-0.4696486294269562,
-0.16373185813426971,
-0.03056809864938259,
-0.18588560819625854,
-0.3543253242969513,
0.11167467385530472,
-0.06336255371570587,
-0.6900166273117065,
-0.06497959047555923,
-0.7280312776565552,
0.773770809173584,
0.7000474333763123,
-0.12804323434829712,
0.5846919417381287,
-0.06543570011854172,
0.3489393889904022,
0.2716602385044098,
0.2928800880908966,
-0.07458557188510895,
-0.3265284299850464,
-0.4124765694141388,
-0.10624952614307404,
0.4910084009170532,
0.3792712986469269,
-0.15298891067504883,
0.3218291103839874,
-0.2863173186779022,
-0.7689939141273499,
-0.5902916193008423,
-0.1764584630727768,
0.2767583727836609,
1.0040420293807983,
0.5282120704650879,
0.1914583146572113,
-0.6332997679710388,
-0.9731384515762329,
-0.20069919526576996,
-0.5929120779037476,
-0.17035262286663055,
0.610694408416748,
0.06236894428730011,
-0.2639305293560028,
0.7180313467979431,
-0.5447121262550354,
-0.4412965476512909,
-0.05520377680659294,
0.27864503860473633,
-0.09943541139364243,
0.38677743077278137,
0.03691703453660011,
-0.6110905408859253,
-0.2997681200504303,
0.2737375497817993,
-0.35328584909439087,
0.12138734757900238,
0.23060861229896545,
0.1387636363506317,
-0.033179931342601776,
0.9023287296295166,
-0.47106677293777466,
0.4095976650714874,
0.6862499117851257,
-0.11093970388174057,
0.7144728302955627,
-0.08208712935447693,
-0.2559396028518677,
-1.2605053186416626,
-0.1713007390499115,
0.0010423804633319378,
-0.23143431544303894,
-0.5420122742652893,
-0.41791146993637085,
0.19806253910064697,
-0.4317439794540405,
-0.6936635971069336,
0.507439911365509,
-0.09095340967178345,
-0.11800190806388855,
-0.3000383675098419,
-0.004313272889703512,
-0.26650556921958923,
0.15438547730445862,
0.14200513064861298,
1.1063483953475952,
0.7482659220695496,
-0.840205192565918,
0.1945773810148239,
0.13069204986095428,
-0.4659998416900635,
0.30160847306251526,
-0.7457872033119202,
-0.0016531766159459949,
0.17550818622112274,
0.372250497341156,
-1.0271538496017456,
-0.1816328465938568,
-0.41214433312416077,
-0.8455421328544617,
0.4107665419578552,
-0.04621497169137001,
-0.045986294746398926,
-0.24937045574188232,
-0.06723133474588394,
0.1129167452454567,
0.8557314276695251,
-0.6243658065795898,
0.7806289196014404,
0.2830526828765869,
-0.14482873678207397,
-0.028130000457167625,
-0.7512314915657043,
-0.0716370940208435,
0.022611621767282486,
-0.41403475403785706,
0.4171625077724457,
-0.22734445333480835,
0.05927359685301781,
-0.08788387477397919,
-0.14032594859600067,
-0.11262557655572891,
-0.016574259847402573,
0.4490499198436737,
0.14182288944721222,
-0.34859997034072876,
0.4125054180622101,
-0.020838547497987747,
-0.22176048159599304,
0.15491406619548798,
-0.39578524231910706,
0.45580601692199707,
-0.295087993144989,
0.004909691866487265,
-0.5942702293395996,
-0.0756508931517601,
0.5375824570655823,
-0.023527158424258232,
0.5571436285972595,
0.7933213114738464,
-0.30436232686042786,
-0.15867488086223602,
-0.40861329436302185,
-0.35363662242889404,
-0.4854623079299927,
0.502139687538147,
-0.374183714389801,
-0.8406515717506409,
0.33736345171928406,
-0.5243754386901855,
-0.428496778011322,
0.3409935534000397,
0.19610461592674255,
-0.2636738419532776,
0.8903599381446838,
0.5909053683280945,
-0.3816733956336975,
0.41789281368255615,
-0.18030211329460144,
-0.033680181950330734,
-0.9934296607971191,
-0.24062255024909973,
-0.51181960105896,
-0.35726627707481384,
-0.4065994322299957,
-0.4106532037258148,
0.5108416080474854,
0.04255848377943039,
0.02848164550960064,
0.33898741006851196,
-0.2861178517341614,
0.2414296418428421,
0.2895376682281494,
0.4754936695098877,
0.3200230300426483,
0.18015500903129578,
-0.2822538912296295,
0.22368262708187103,
-0.48178496956825256,
-0.05300140753388405,
0.7838589549064636,
0.3604815900325775,
0.634570300579071,
-0.05139147862792015,
0.50955730676651,
0.296827107667923,
-0.0897054597735405,
-0.9056179523468018,
0.6041607856750488,
-0.3448084592819214,
-0.2016531527042389,
-0.6424857974052429,
-0.500878095626831,
-0.7736576199531555,
-0.0028361580334603786,
-0.35069364309310913,
-0.7323593497276306,
0.3568894863128662,
0.1448121815919876,
-0.687832236289978,
0.389852911233902,
-0.7556594014167786,
0.1019030511379242,
0.3865041434764862,
0.10255755484104156,
-0.39739957451820374,
-0.5487384796142578,
0.21149535477161407,
-0.13332632184028625,
0.36708274483680725,
-0.2878102958202362,
-0.012007729150354862,
0.6365384459495544,
-0.11293432861566544,
1.1244145631790161,
-0.2649250030517578,
-0.07923250645399094,
0.08226839452981949,
0.3625504970550537,
0.4076491892337799,
-0.03905273601412773,
-0.3638778328895569,
0.3461807370185852,
-0.23135560750961304,
0.03390365466475487,
-0.5345038175582886,
0.6262525916099548,
-0.6334646344184875,
-0.4330315589904785,
0.005353630520403385,
-0.4967432916164398,
-0.7154256701469421,
0.005609144922345877,
0.4922763407230377,
0.6971988677978516,
-0.42350292205810547,
0.24973687529563904,
1.0561562776565552,
-0.006323940586298704,
0.6275089979171753,
0.5865941047668457,
-0.1709236055612564,
-0.3828110098838806,
1.091231107711792,
0.3565971553325653,
0.3314225375652313,
0.3778330981731415,
0.6832535266876221,
-0.20923587679862976,
-0.689781665802002,
-0.46297961473464966,
-0.1257435828447342,
-0.19054125249385834,
-0.3828814923763275,
-0.7209831476211548,
-0.6611590385437012,
-0.5179969668388367,
-0.1507626324892044,
-0.44211381673812866,
-0.44545289874076843,
-0.6936449408531189,
-0.3833569586277008,
0.33207210898399353,
0.4607956111431122,
-0.43042799830436707,
-0.015049785375595093,
-1.2461764812469482,
0.2976461350917816,
0.7733792066574097,
0.29203224182128906,
0.25932350754737854,
-1.1995896100997925,
-0.21731583774089813,
-0.022526094689965248,
-0.0575796402990818,
-0.6442070007324219,
0.34133848547935486,
0.8630191087722778,
0.2511880695819855,
0.4455988109111786,
0.15598101913928986,
0.8952927589416504,
-0.9122158288955688,
0.6703953742980957,
0.3562278151512146,
-1.0662165880203247,
0.939124345779419,
-0.13994121551513672,
0.2702443599700928,
0.5235016942024231,
0.22070004045963287,
-0.1694849729537964,
-0.37826719880104065,
-0.7635316252708435,
-0.5473065376281738,
0.3438878357410431,
-0.0675201341509819,
0.3634474277496338,
0.10979096591472626,
0.37878328561782837,
0.25987789034843445,
-0.039378900080919266,
-0.013368960469961166,
0.17279855906963348,
0.05150536075234413,
-0.016353560611605644,
-0.5145207047462463,
-0.32507118582725525,
0.2609989047050476,
-0.617441713809967,
0.49923446774482727,
-0.26373693346977234,
0.2052137851715088,
0.44370725750923157,
-0.14195150136947632,
-0.27834999561309814,
0.07755308598279953,
0.7028058767318726,
0.6918679475784302,
-0.38427382707595825,
0.1510859727859497,
0.4059911370277405,
-0.6789388656616211,
0.16222327947616577,
0.07566425204277039,
0.06628674268722534,
0.20128463208675385,
0.6747840046882629,
0.9021025896072388,
0.4807108938694,
-0.5973971486091614,
0.5812384486198425,
-0.04919828101992607,
-0.5512158274650574,
-0.4427432715892792,
0.3580349087715149,
0.29650914669036865,
0.46965235471725464,
0.3783858120441437,
0.2922556400299072,
0.7292168736457825,
-0.6830136179924011,
0.32407131791114807,
0.40118736028671265,
-0.7641639709472656,
-0.4762015640735626,
0.573119044303894,
0.27015259861946106,
-0.4673115611076355,
0.5370299220085144,
0.19442258775234222,
-0.33873865008354187,
0.7463679313659668,
0.792670726776123,
1.1595956087112427,
-0.6163690090179443,
0.32855716347694397,
0.4984813928604126,
-0.09635309129953384,
0.19796518981456757,
-0.08776449412107468,
-0.21328452229499817,
-0.5724548697471619,
-0.24087658524513245,
-0.8474539518356323,
-0.5572347640991211,
-0.09373532980680466,
-0.779981255531311,
-0.04822642728686333,
-0.4285980761051178,
-0.12543578445911407,
0.3535129427909851,
-0.13420197367668152,
-0.41072332859039307,
0.2625308334827423,
0.6423896551132202,
1.2599468231201172,
-0.7296836376190186,
0.9322370886802673,
0.322794109582901,
-0.06552021205425262,
-1.0540410280227661,
0.3898776173591614,
-0.10882528871297836,
-1.1206697225570679,
0.6278751492500305,
0.34309306740760803,
-0.4332255423069,
0.14972473680973053,
-0.32550233602523804,
-0.9112877249717712,
1.0307615995407104,
0.7122304439544678,
-1.0926998853683472,
0.2474370300769806,
0.12339175492525101,
0.5267766714096069,
-0.10620351880788803,
0.16999368369579315,
0.6628828644752502,
0.31473737955093384,
0.3522948920726776,
-1.2244962453842163,
-0.27033552527427673,
0.09185915440320969,
0.31468984484672546,
-0.1712242215871811,
-0.6272624731063843,
0.6230129599571228,
-0.5515499114990234,
-0.06783171743154526,
-0.012469073757529259,
1.0667132139205933,
0.11112786829471588,
0.4901203215122223,
0.6482418179512024,
0.3782791495323181,
0.9875215888023376,
0.23914839327335358,
0.6884805560112,
-0.20690587162971497,
0.19814665615558624,
0.9715966582298279,
-0.11349859833717346,
1.333479642868042,
0.08623257279396057,
-0.3810961842536926,
0.40148642659187317,
0.3082596957683563,
0.27428188920021057,
0.7028130292892456,
0.09828536212444305,
-0.6338346004486084,
-0.033675238490104675,
-0.199520081281662,
-0.5260972380638123,
0.44210153818130493,
0.34076976776123047,
-0.23616762459278107,
0.10668081045150757,
0.6294419765472412,
-0.33808672428131104,
0.033279236406087875,
-0.8226413726806641,
1.2482277154922485,
0.185828298330307,
-0.22600696980953217,
0.5190193057060242,
-0.6624788641929626,
0.7457735538482666,
-0.4007596969604492,
-0.15523888170719147,
-0.20754261314868927,
0.3208535611629486,
-0.36360546946525574,
-0.7885032892227173,
0.37687867879867554,
-0.4563957452774048,
-0.39330801367759705,
0.3636990487575531,
1.0112947225570679,
-0.3560958802700043,
-0.7490176558494568,
0.4246251583099365,
0.17315055429935455,
0.2797187268733978,
-0.23621612787246704,
-0.5608794093132019,
-0.10308456420898438,
-0.008396811783313751,
-0.03983541578054428,
0.6801487803459167,
0.5475906133651733,
0.6937833428382874,
0.74563068151474,
0.6409685611724854,
0.3050966262817383,
0.28449714183807373,
0.05987989902496338,
0.7201533317565918,
-0.6779757738113403,
-0.5287879109382629,
-0.9464026689529419,
0.12605388462543488,
0.14236491918563843,
-0.10122179239988327,
0.34048324823379517,
0.43218523263931274,
0.5301687121391296,
-0.3146918714046478,
0.675765335559845,
0.47103121876716614,
0.7845586538314819,
-0.7039231061935425,
0.5378017425537109,
-0.27546778321266174,
-0.07599499821662903,
-0.1776229590177536,
-0.7513919472694397,
-0.039249736815690994,
0.5729733109474182,
0.07761086523532867,
0.01772087998688221,
0.5318624377250671,
0.731198251247406,
-0.14905191957950592,
0.23452676832675934,
0.8166033029556274,
0.4960234463214874,
0.08934000134468079,
0.6051042079925537,
0.6731196641921997,
0.004399137105792761,
0.6285998225212097,
-0.6055117249488831,
-0.2543196380138397,
-0.544426679611206,
-0.7882617115974426,
-0.5110681056976318,
-0.6560368537902832,
-0.33758753538131714,
-0.35402798652648926,
0.10603255033493042,
0.7270113229751587,
1.0638034343719482,
-0.6230642795562744,
-0.08253728598356247,
-0.29354405403137207,
-0.40913480520248413,
-0.13859239220619202,
-0.21639011800289154,
0.38248106837272644,
-0.5387442111968994,
-0.5146262049674988,
0.7074557542800903,
0.31222715973854065,
0.1608016937971115,
-0.19642512500286102,
0.09443873912096024,
0.3628724217414856,
0.37659573554992676,
0.7308725714683533,
0.328457236289978,
-0.4617348611354828,
-0.2244235873222351,
-0.312105268239975,
0.04634610936045647,
0.04316489398479462,
0.4157310128211975,
-1.138036847114563,
0.26476699113845825,
0.07184997200965881,
0.46509799361228943,
0.3593786060810089,
-0.2572782635688782,
0.25713929533958435,
-0.5742963552474976,
0.16790907084941864,
0.4788922071456909,
0.12690243124961853,
0.026015497744083405,
-0.540876030921936,
0.48202720284461975,
-0.02342473343014717,
-0.5773485898971558,
-0.7133484482765198,
0.168667271733284,
-1.1488522291183472,
-0.43729716539382935,
1.1244826316833496,
-0.065772145986557,
-0.3566266894340515,
0.3919112980365753,
-0.33205750584602356,
0.3644579350948334,
-0.5966388583183289,
0.7169568538665771,
0.3513892889022827,
-0.1970515102148056,
-0.21726259589195251,
-0.45370787382125854,
0.5319303274154663,
0.23638449609279633,
-0.6888516545295715,
0.21968236565589905,
0.28954455256462097,
0.2590617835521698,
0.2849418818950653,
0.2891579568386078,
0.019156839698553085,
0.339826762676239,
0.011715244501829147,
-0.18928994238376617,
-0.3137374818325043,
-0.4864676892757416,
-0.6285686492919922,
0.2444697618484497,
0.0013740153517574072,
-0.33916354179382324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01722v1
|
Sentence-level Media Bias Analysis with Event Relation Graph
| 2024-04-02T08:16:03 | 2024-04-02T08:16:03 |
Yuanyuan Lei, Ruihong Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Media outlets are becoming more partisan and polarized nowadays. In this
paper, we identify media bias at the sentence level, and pinpoint bias
sentences that intend to sway readers' opinions. As bias sentences are often
expressed in a neutral and factual way, considering broader context outside a
sentence can help reveal the bias. In particular, we observe that events in a
bias sentence need to be understood in associations with other events in the
document. Therefore, we propose to construct an event relation graph to
explicitly reason about event-event relations for sentence-level bias
identification. The designed event relation graph consists of events as nodes
and four common types of event relations: coreference, temporal, causal, and
subevent relations. Then, we incorporate event relation graph for bias
sentences identification in two steps: an event-aware language model is built
to inject the events and event relations knowledge into the basic language
model via soft labels; further, a relation-aware graph attention network is
designed to update sentence embedding with events and event relations
information based on hard labels. Experiments on two benchmark datasets
demonstrate that our approach with the aid of event relation graph improves
both precision and recall of bias sentence identification.
|
[
-0.5368029475212097,
-0.9208595156669617,
0.7597256898880005,
0.06076502799987793,
-0.19112882018089294,
-0.18952420353889465,
-0.1252875179052353,
-0.2921426594257355,
0.2428845465183258,
0.49069878458976746,
-0.7864149212837219,
-0.3482329249382019,
-0.5636243224143982,
-0.10605546832084656,
-0.18633002042770386,
1.2180308103561401,
0.0048647718504071236,
0.20017710328102112,
0.08773121982812881,
-0.38073447346687317,
-0.20416317880153656,
-0.5095052123069763,
-0.5346587896347046,
-0.3042078912258148,
0.42821037769317627,
0.14203578233718872,
0.5358744263648987,
0.5288344621658325,
0.34945714473724365,
0.10243981331586838,
-0.3778833746910095,
-0.0726795420050621,
-0.6662139892578125,
0.0492447093129158,
-0.28884750604629517,
-0.14778147637844086,
-0.5368912220001221,
0.3307393789291382,
0.585830807685852,
0.7398537993431091,
0.5318676233291626,
0.2700336277484894,
-0.14256787300109863,
0.713129460811615,
-0.5745298862457275,
0.3256080448627472,
-0.729408323764801,
0.3364759683609009,
-0.3936088979244232,
-0.22816090285778046,
-0.5348193645477295,
-0.3059370815753937,
0.034398842602968216,
-0.5674575567245483,
0.38932639360427856,
0.005995337851345539,
1.08998441696167,
-0.058285877108573914,
-0.8793491721153259,
-0.32845380902290344,
-0.4955039620399475,
0.4394630491733551,
-0.397927463054657,
0.37792491912841797,
0.33468371629714966,
-0.11737020313739777,
-0.023273931816220284,
-0.43115365505218506,
-0.47722432017326355,
-0.04448109492659569,
-0.06888361275196075,
0.3319232165813446,
-0.1102074459195137,
-0.057268839329481125,
0.5239395499229431,
0.1092771664261818,
-0.3343643844127655,
-0.26019176840782166,
-0.19202862679958344,
-0.08668946474790573,
0.4641292989253998,
0.1506047248840332,
0.4571896195411682,
-0.5475956201553345,
-0.17651191353797913,
0.4201353192329407,
-0.7117779850959778,
-0.11855769902467728,
0.781470537185669,
0.17536315321922302,
-0.04279336333274841,
0.7369108200073242,
-0.37559953331947327,
0.575334906578064,
0.44328930974006653,
-0.11336594074964523,
0.3162235617637634,
-0.6361846327781677,
-0.049535952508449554,
0.2886522710323334,
0.9315339922904968,
0.651635468006134,
0.81180739402771,
-0.049542807042598724,
0.3414461612701416,
0.16889582574367523,
0.03128531575202942,
-0.8445724248886108,
0.08773401379585266,
0.0434589758515358,
-0.8205972909927368,
-0.3247816562652588,
0.008117979392409325,
-1.0867435932159424,
-0.6109960675239563,
-0.08883865177631378,
-0.02431715466082096,
-0.11947456747293472,
-0.21439890563488007,
-0.2981579005718231,
-0.3249548077583313,
0.010530227795243263,
-0.05526122823357582,
-0.4548894762992859,
0.17013615369796753,
0.506199061870575,
0.6907118558883667,
0.1813247799873352,
0.010970027185976505,
-0.6952298283576965,
0.4344416856765747,
-0.31021979451179504,
0.659401535987854,
-0.6332191228866577,
0.021812409162521362,
0.3397579491138458,
-0.026235343888401985,
0.1289893388748169,
-0.22011056542396545,
0.8577264547348022,
-0.7673733234405518,
0.5392480492591858,
-0.41669467091560364,
-0.6944798827171326,
0.07710106670856476,
0.13822543621063232,
-0.8548450469970703,
0.521597146987915,
0.009296963922679424,
-1.4602404832839966,
0.5943151712417603,
-0.38442960381507874,
-0.6967366933822632,
-0.32456058263778687,
-0.10880501568317413,
-0.6665436625480652,
-0.10990899801254272,
0.6210432648658752,
0.2815079689025879,
-0.013709528371691704,
0.3869166374206543,
-0.7241913080215454,
0.04683081805706024,
0.02021799050271511,
-0.034094955772161484,
0.9718520641326904,
0.021747076883912086,
-0.32131004333496094,
0.006108333822339773,
-0.7313392162322998,
-0.5472881197929382,
-0.07867803424596786,
-0.20342494547367096,
-0.5452919602394104,
0.2924935221672058,
-0.06487015634775162,
0.3679150938987732,
-0.04267777130007744,
-0.5964363813400269,
0.2388731986284256,
-0.19434042274951935,
0.44758209586143494,
0.5072459578514099,
0.5334062576293945,
1.0908925533294678,
0.33755558729171753,
0.40244078636169434,
0.17618528008460999,
0.1761140376329422,
-0.4047167897224426,
-0.3847753405570984,
-0.7004541754722595,
0.2786963880062103,
-0.016953041777014732,
0.5216831564903259,
-0.6663407683372498,
0.2882464528083801,
-0.10503438115119934,
0.1837446391582489,
-0.2778202295303345,
0.05251959338784218,
0.1966119259595871,
0.9517431259155273,
0.17043454945087433,
0.07178686559200287,
-0.7321745753288269,
-1.0133620500564575,
-0.6934683918952942,
-0.24192264676094055,
0.24411718547344208,
0.32539018988609314,
0.13896648585796356,
0.07428206503391266,
1.0078498125076294,
-0.5762964487075806,
-0.6227990388870239,
-0.37762385606765747,
0.2973102629184723,
0.1751607358455658,
-0.10804356634616852,
0.4297616183757782,
-0.6036940813064575,
-0.3666720688343048,
-0.10594849288463593,
-0.8246344327926636,
-0.5931102633476257,
-0.23991768062114716,
-0.15910804271697998,
0.20659774541854858,
0.6177066564559937,
-0.4311531186103821,
0.34566935896873474,
0.39055874943733215,
-0.7980087399482727,
0.2408987134695053,
0.5854743123054504,
0.016159608960151672,
-0.8593108654022217,
-0.2906164824962616,
0.39345982670783997,
-0.39453038573265076,
-0.5979600548744202,
-0.300055593252182,
-0.057469166815280914,
0.003337305039167404,
-0.3209766447544098,
0.2840697169303894,
-0.6099191308021545,
-0.162366583943367,
-0.2438357025384903,
0.4661983847618103,
0.275200217962265,
0.3579915761947632,
0.1277894675731659,
0.18697744607925415,
0.3979652523994446,
-0.23085622489452362,
-0.015745386481285095,
0.20971786975860596,
-0.4123084247112274,
0.5694858431816101,
-0.3674735724925995,
-0.009949917905032635,
-0.4994261562824249,
0.6219854354858398,
-0.6739460825920105,
0.11473498493432999,
0.3885662853717804,
-0.42980384826660156,
0.06044244393706322,
-0.4293399751186371,
-0.23970937728881836,
-0.18791349232196808,
-0.04556401073932648,
0.34670254588127136,
-0.016744855791330338,
-0.17733079195022583,
0.5517956614494324,
0.6794848442077637,
-0.13739986717700958,
-0.6711571216583252,
-0.4599054455757141,
-0.163189098238945,
-0.24809110164642334,
-0.7111490964889526,
0.1300830990076065,
0.2623754143714905,
-0.4613199532032013,
0.33335360884666443,
-0.024598753079771996,
-0.2069185972213745,
-0.4411730170249939,
0.21648302674293518,
0.05434533953666687,
-0.2720649540424347,
0.19025664031505585,
-0.016457004472613335,
-0.09745340049266815,
0.12997639179229736,
-0.11592431366443634,
0.3813380002975464,
0.026256639510393143,
0.1328779011964798,
-0.6686825156211853,
0.4977511763572693,
0.4849068820476532,
-0.15361571311950684,
0.5979965329170227,
0.7908283472061157,
-0.3285331130027771,
0.036377374082803726,
-0.5870344638824463,
-0.21948179602622986,
-0.3091348111629486,
0.5523358583450317,
-0.3122634291648865,
-0.6894996762275696,
0.5745527148246765,
0.21422167122364044,
-0.33562421798706055,
0.3773888647556305,
0.6771684885025024,
0.07173654437065125,
1.1936511993408203,
0.3132425844669342,
-0.45552903413772583,
0.7460816502571106,
-0.12593118846416473,
0.27815818786621094,
-0.8938365578651428,
-0.11462946236133575,
-0.2722485363483429,
-0.24882538616657257,
-0.22518552839756012,
-0.0009455530089326203,
0.1735728234052658,
0.16524113714694977,
-0.34799331426620483,
0.18721508979797363,
-0.25590217113494873,
0.47318777441978455,
0.3716566860675812,
-0.05134125053882599,
0.38133206963539124,
-0.2566913068294525,
0.2298680543899536,
-0.24560151994228363,
-0.7028700709342957,
-0.2770005166530609,
0.6280232071876526,
0.38095977902412415,
0.566802978515625,
-0.23491857945919037,
0.3995828330516815,
0.285494863986969,
0.45562368631362915,
-0.5421715378761292,
0.17973345518112183,
0.24270173907279968,
-0.9320966005325317,
-0.11869224160909653,
-0.47467634081840515,
-0.8074027299880981,
0.24046391248703003,
-0.10252926498651505,
-0.7872728705406189,
0.5019915103912354,
-0.15972387790679932,
0.12032648175954819,
0.06277590990066528,
-0.7938787937164307,
0.8750240206718445,
0.1571546196937561,
-0.37885695695877075,
-0.04005515202879906,
-0.4689890444278717,
0.4298405945301056,
0.3810800015926361,
0.5515007972717285,
-0.40956687927246094,
0.16133993864059448,
1.0464142560958862,
-0.20683681964874268,
0.7067687511444092,
0.030218319967389107,
0.3697485327720642,
0.4530094265937805,
0.12324052304029465,
0.48353147506713867,
0.4091373085975647,
-0.1366923749446869,
-0.2080027312040329,
-0.3121146559715271,
-0.22865042090415955,
-0.35865530371665955,
0.6898766160011292,
-0.8028684854507446,
-0.381619393825531,
-0.2468307465314865,
-0.6802705526351929,
-0.2527664601802826,
0.4088440239429474,
0.30156370997428894,
0.5642934441566467,
-0.2989320158958435,
-0.09064676612615585,
0.40756040811538696,
0.056689344346523285,
0.6340153217315674,
0.4549231231212616,
-0.21996274590492249,
-0.3726959824562073,
0.4866710603237152,
0.18955819308757782,
0.08517398685216904,
0.2995370626449585,
0.08881081640720367,
0.035520270466804504,
-0.1334018111228943,
-0.37797045707702637,
0.24294885993003845,
-0.5650820732116699,
-0.2407580018043518,
-1.006101131439209,
0.03075820580124855,
-0.5875457525253296,
-0.2698926031589508,
-0.13168185949325562,
-0.374848335981369,
-0.40878212451934814,
-0.3703393042087555,
0.13611449301242828,
0.644679844379425,
0.22003541886806488,
0.41958558559417725,
-0.2771347463130951,
0.48998674750328064,
-0.08755864202976227,
0.208542138338089,
-0.1703362762928009,
-0.2990301549434662,
-0.04087318107485771,
-0.3951106667518616,
-0.555576741695404,
-1.7244209051132202,
0.39725252985954285,
0.06818358600139618,
0.3185335397720337,
0.7443322539329529,
-0.02458890713751316,
0.2391546666622162,
-0.7557169198989868,
0.6005887985229492,
0.09745834022760391,
-1.0610754489898682,
0.7917730808258057,
-0.6781697869300842,
0.29659196734428406,
0.35111746191978455,
0.5071666836738586,
-0.29460129141807556,
-0.7215838432312012,
-0.9906758069992065,
-0.6566195487976074,
0.8570659756660461,
0.2616250216960907,
0.008130555041134357,
-0.2596452832221985,
0.22627438604831696,
-0.3086012005805969,
0.3326244652271271,
-1.1047767400741577,
-0.2555896043777466,
-0.18116100132465363,
-0.19793792068958282,
0.11455032974481583,
-0.4680652916431427,
-0.2943849563598633,
-0.09784023463726044,
0.639444887638092,
-0.04426542669534683,
-0.05818257853388786,
0.22721219062805176,
-0.18226636946201324,
-0.16348682343959808,
0.27735474705696106,
0.24129636585712433,
0.8011614680290222,
-0.35499295592308044,
0.29929083585739136,
-0.02822767198085785,
-0.257089763879776,
-0.09034650027751923,
0.10052966326475143,
-0.4676996171474457,
0.24791266024112701,
0.6048188805580139,
0.7577697038650513,
-0.01893041655421257,
-0.22224067151546478,
0.8194960355758667,
0.24706196784973145,
0.06259971857070923,
-0.036800894886255264,
-0.5030628442764282,
0.41251951456069946,
0.24150796234607697,
0.29769936203956604,
-0.3028319776058197,
0.4892449378967285,
-0.9282094836235046,
0.4240798354148865,
0.44172021746635437,
-0.8658626079559326,
-0.14130094647407532,
0.7449316382408142,
0.45636627078056335,
-0.20112396776676178,
0.4610104262828827,
-0.27681446075439453,
-0.6991366147994995,
0.7013950347900391,
0.5161038041114807,
0.5629351735115051,
-0.05218428745865822,
0.5430881381034851,
0.38695502281188965,
0.5961334705352783,
0.4370957314968109,
-0.004838061053305864,
0.4078502058982849,
-0.9595485329627991,
-0.5323371887207031,
-0.35947468876838684,
0.026234770193696022,
0.22273091971874237,
-0.7551187872886658,
0.24666675925254822,
-0.29532942175865173,
-0.46444272994995117,
0.4514458477497101,
-0.006721578538417816,
-0.5240147113800049,
0.2058284431695938,
0.2592572271823883,
0.5924876928329468,
-1.3458455801010132,
0.6114404201507568,
0.38301676511764526,
-0.7029919624328613,
-0.5163946151733398,
-0.0446336604654789,
0.17810697853565216,
-0.43722566962242126,
0.6985318064689636,
0.0374533012509346,
0.2794123888015747,
-0.25065532326698303,
-0.2792561650276184,
-0.6844989657402039,
0.6304466724395752,
0.39818713068962097,
-0.5210082530975342,
-0.007401829119771719,
-0.20478318631649017,
0.439940869808197,
-0.8896453976631165,
0.358400821685791,
0.5710136294364929,
0.4466923773288727,
-0.22450076043605804,
-0.4254911541938782,
0.20933528244495392,
0.06737696379423141,
-0.07573370635509491,
0.42878276109695435,
-0.704082190990448,
0.610130250453949,
0.06323059648275375,
-0.18319885432720184,
-0.7163310050964355,
1.0070934295654297,
-0.08267425745725632,
0.7334996461868286,
0.4435819387435913,
0.3720628619194031,
0.5042579174041748,
-0.06805866956710815,
1.0251613855361938,
-0.19753730297088623,
0.3310086727142334,
1.2873495817184448,
-0.31838563084602356,
0.4667077958583832,
0.5381609201431274,
0.1402503252029419,
0.7735900282859802,
0.45109960436820984,
0.12171180546283722,
0.5523812174797058,
0.04484263435006142,
-0.169269859790802,
-0.22060978412628174,
-0.3645625114440918,
-0.26821169257164,
-0.13387717306613922,
0.31266552209854126,
-0.8549730777740479,
-0.3996392786502838,
0.20962707698345184,
0.6231807470321655,
0.00469845300540328,
-0.5326913595199585,
0.5882307887077332,
0.06761924922466278,
-0.6829193234443665,
-0.22965894639492035,
-0.12808941304683685,
0.11212002485990524,
-0.17955382168293,
0.366072416305542,
-0.10965336114168167,
0.13939782977104187,
-0.3087490200996399,
-0.8989183902740479,
0.3025839030742645,
-0.12848657369613647,
-0.6129986047744751,
0.0599786676466465,
0.9522771835327148,
-0.441519558429718,
-0.5302965044975281,
0.3609904944896698,
0.5376307964324951,
-0.1487322747707367,
-0.044124916195869446,
-0.5116587281227112,
0.5013884902000427,
0.007079106755554676,
-0.5166099071502686,
0.2454477846622467,
0.502035915851593,
-0.09455382078886032,
0.233407661318779,
0.2844761610031128,
0.0860050693154335,
0.09449828416109085,
0.5324116349220276,
0.6967151761054993,
-0.42297136783599854,
-0.4712401330471039,
-0.8031364679336548,
0.16249117255210876,
-0.5848239064216614,
-0.4254676401615143,
0.7082453370094299,
0.5554591417312622,
0.5026752948760986,
0.1333569586277008,
0.8657400608062744,
-0.07112244516611099,
0.40705710649490356,
-0.3640630543231964,
0.48156481981277466,
-0.12262566387653351,
-0.1821446269750595,
-0.42052125930786133,
-1.0107654333114624,
-0.32238003611564636,
0.4421745836734772,
-0.6795433163642883,
-0.023838279768824577,
0.9265164732933044,
0.5831441283226013,
-0.13099704682826996,
0.11051619797945023,
-0.11227347701787949,
0.4534330368041992,
0.27780774235725403,
0.5673943758010864,
0.8254486322402954,
-0.15402230620384216,
0.7594699263572693,
-0.16930252313613892,
-0.4197872579097748,
-0.2666298449039459,
-1.0489851236343384,
-1.0700691938400269,
-0.6682912707328796,
-0.6080085039138794,
-0.710748553276062,
0.22933925688266754,
0.2675868272781372,
0.5481619238853455,
-0.4680149555206299,
0.04285062104463577,
-0.10318326950073242,
0.5249983668327332,
-0.05810241773724556,
-0.39570146799087524,
0.4317421019077301,
-0.4204649329185486,
-0.7636455297470093,
0.04355473816394806,
0.34913957118988037,
-0.5140662789344788,
-0.005550278816372156,
0.40518319606781006,
-0.37335705757141113,
0.27525585889816284,
0.6720560789108276,
0.1781734973192215,
-0.5263233184814453,
-0.5161849856376648,
-0.19127632677555084,
-0.061573319137096405,
-0.04607677832245827,
1.24836003780365,
-0.6413232684135437,
0.37569594383239746,
0.7008695602416992,
0.17580844461917877,
0.6721665263175964,
0.19196316599845886,
0.6628081798553467,
-0.7497467398643494,
0.31098610162734985,
0.14157119393348694,
0.4302043616771698,
0.3891192376613617,
-0.4271796941757202,
0.4488285183906555,
0.35000720620155334,
-0.6238083839416504,
-0.6940963864326477,
0.6135165095329285,
-1.3700189590454102,
-0.19729411602020264,
1.6186033487319946,
0.10465183854103088,
-0.19649122655391693,
-0.2857150435447693,
-0.28701457381248474,
0.4424211084842682,
-0.2827504277229309,
0.6414951086044312,
1.0129456520080566,
-0.4021301567554474,
-0.22708293795585632,
-0.5187930464744568,
0.5534194111824036,
0.06523512303829193,
-0.5756292343139648,
-0.08026320487260818,
0.6860532760620117,
0.2995546758174896,
0.20089082419872284,
1.0023605823516846,
-0.04081667959690094,
-0.03367257118225098,
-0.08252450823783875,
-0.05873310565948486,
0.16223061084747314,
-0.32347753643989563,
0.12211673706769943,
0.4178469181060791,
-0.4158741235733032,
-0.0490180104970932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01720v1
|
Self-Improvement Programming for Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering
| 2024-04-02T08:14:27 | 2024-04-02T08:14:27 |
Zhuo Chen, Zhao Zhang, Zixuan Li, Fei Wang, Yutao Zeng, Xiaolong Jin, Yongjun Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering (TKGQA) aims to answer questions
with temporal intent over Temporal Knowledge Graphs (TKGs). The core challenge
of this task lies in understanding the complex semantic information regarding
multiple types of time constraints (e.g., before, first) in questions. Existing
end-to-end methods implicitly model the time constraints by learning time-aware
embeddings of questions and candidate answers, which is far from understanding
the question comprehensively. Motivated by semantic-parsing-based approaches
that explicitly model constraints in questions by generating logical forms with
symbolic operators, we design fundamental temporal operators for time
constraints and introduce a novel self-improvement Programming method for TKGQA
(Prog-TQA). Specifically, Prog-TQA leverages the in-context learning ability of
Large Language Models (LLMs) to understand the combinatory time constraints in
the questions and generate corresponding program drafts with a few examples
given. Then, it aligns these drafts to TKGs with the linking module and
subsequently executes them to generate the answers. To enhance the ability to
understand questions, Prog-TQA is further equipped with a self-improvement
strategy to effectively bootstrap LLMs using high-quality self-generated
drafts. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of the proposed
Prog-TQA on MultiTQ and CronQuestions datasets, especially in the Hits@1
metric.
|
[
0.07980410754680634,
-0.6768190860748291,
0.7879143357276917,
0.2883296012878418,
-0.16005650162696838,
0.5933923125267029,
0.1897810697555542,
-0.23669514060020447,
0.06769499182701111,
0.3917066156864166,
-1.0408769845962524,
-0.6153808236122131,
-0.3430044949054718,
0.1390150785446167,
-0.04502245411276817,
0.5926116704940796,
-0.23983339965343475,
-0.14352145791053772,
-0.006282554008066654,
0.00969482772052288,
-0.5449025630950928,
-0.155819371342659,
-0.5802608728408813,
-0.30611586570739746,
0.3735772371292114,
0.3045901656150818,
0.4283300042152405,
0.7591591477394104,
0.005312472581863403,
0.27177032828330994,
0.3452726900577545,
0.13889427483081818,
-0.37175804376602173,
0.08080737292766571,
-0.14534442126750946,
-0.19849035143852234,
-0.2772029638290405,
-0.05414746329188347,
0.6172690391540527,
0.6188284158706665,
-0.15277409553527832,
0.5697374939918518,
-0.14771811664104462,
0.4663684368133545,
-0.6313125491142273,
0.6199797987937927,
-0.4873674809932709,
0.3624487817287445,
-0.13700154423713684,
-0.36981457471847534,
-0.061782341450452805,
-0.6323205232620239,
-0.1070532277226448,
-0.9551869034767151,
-0.016788357868790627,
-0.06803575158119202,
0.7563657164573669,
0.6731621623039246,
-0.596416711807251,
-0.052956920117139816,
-0.5424959659576416,
0.7002382278442383,
-0.8790491223335266,
0.631152868270874,
0.1543220579624176,
0.5308688879013062,
-0.3230699598789215,
-0.7519713640213013,
-0.5319064259529114,
-0.012088551186025143,
0.0005463880370371044,
0.20747995376586914,
0.13911870121955872,
0.14658375084400177,
0.23040126264095306,
0.041593994945287704,
-0.669208288192749,
-0.02141689322888851,
-0.14343653619289398,
-0.3862426280975342,
0.32076093554496765,
0.45104020833969116,
0.09140504896640778,
-0.38689476251602173,
-0.10068684816360474,
0.2068246603012085,
-0.44795721769332886,
0.11479105800390244,
0.16712060570716858,
-0.19719675183296204,
0.3402935564517975,
0.5318002700805664,
-0.6548303961753845,
0.8297553658485413,
0.13090036809444427,
-0.1311718225479126,
0.0282034520059824,
-0.39113226532936096,
-0.06571995466947556,
-0.13387717306613922,
0.4034455418586731,
0.25955930352211,
0.1323845535516739,
-0.4738609492778778,
-0.006791193038225174,
0.058489639312028885,
0.17818613350391388,
-0.6941010355949402,
-0.23633135855197906,
0.5244979858398438,
-0.3066071569919586,
-0.2745554745197296,
-0.38047170639038086,
-0.31554731726646423,
0.15133726596832275,
-0.4362722337245941,
0.7034735679626465,
-0.4887969493865967,
-0.17519576847553253,
0.10427509248256683,
-0.12770669162273407,
0.2698776125907898,
0.2445971667766571,
-0.3925299644470215,
0.10011018812656403,
0.6069598197937012,
0.42023345828056335,
0.3582213819026947,
-0.22260840237140656,
-0.6816816926002502,
0.6858476400375366,
-0.46949172019958496,
0.6448870301246643,
-0.5502665042877197,
-0.17097243666648865,
-0.3566429018974304,
-0.12490588426589966,
-0.2010180801153183,
-0.3177169859409332,
0.18263337016105652,
-0.8040524125099182,
0.3544769287109375,
-0.3629915714263916,
-0.7946373224258423,
0.016788143664598465,
0.5102829933166504,
-0.08478065580129623,
1.0380948781967163,
0.6611905694007874,
-0.5041293501853943,
0.306037575006485,
-0.8009506464004517,
-0.07921139150857925,
0.16343055665493011,
-0.1566443145275116,
-0.35474708676338196,
-0.06815963983535767,
0.4886658191680908,
0.394713819026947,
-0.12463290989398956,
0.5610597729682922,
-0.3012828826904297,
0.0722583681344986,
0.06219160929322243,
0.2752188742160797,
0.686765193939209,
0.3834693431854248,
-0.2798978090286255,
0.20547699928283691,
-0.6268422603607178,
0.6924157738685608,
0.3698236048221588,
-0.23448804020881653,
-0.05847658962011337,
0.0648711547255516,
-0.6643958687782288,
0.43896085023880005,
0.37628665566444397,
-0.7967644333839417,
0.46908268332481384,
-0.24635544419288635,
0.6518352031707764,
0.9274612069129944,
0.33703845739364624,
0.093516506254673,
-0.1563439518213272,
0.6340267658233643,
-0.11524952203035355,
0.7330293655395508,
0.14039544761180878,
-0.017645105719566345,
-0.5251021981239319,
0.2947945296764374,
0.3008558452129364,
0.4633954167366028,
-1.242583990097046,
0.18959940969944,
-0.3026295006275177,
-0.47005489468574524,
-0.3306986689567566,
0.16682149469852448,
0.6810349822044373,
0.9403412342071533,
0.4642963409423828,
-0.10183045268058777,
-0.3135569095611572,
-0.8087203502655029,
-0.40168091654777527,
-0.5126655697822571,
-0.027819255366921425,
0.2775989770889282,
0.3621836304664612,
-0.033573295921087265,
0.9753845930099487,
-0.9053339958190918,
-0.10048530250787735,
-0.1195494756102562,
0.16521410644054413,
0.04509503021836281,
0.2992185950279236,
0.5607380867004395,
-0.3121538758277893,
-0.4202328622341156,
-0.45359280705451965,
-0.8177749514579773,
-0.507996678352356,
-0.0555959977209568,
-0.3599056899547577,
0.004605815280228853,
0.4799858331680298,
-0.33689436316490173,
0.14101342856884003,
0.4104357957839966,
-0.6353977918624878,
0.8535738587379456,
0.06837984919548035,
0.16163678467273712,
-0.8802230358123779,
-0.31725960969924927,
-0.5154734253883362,
-0.20210348069667816,
-0.5706583261489868,
-0.04322683438658714,
0.04971807822585106,
-0.2791944444179535,
-0.22184553742408752,
0.6620066165924072,
-0.20915290713310242,
0.03661567345261574,
0.06827064603567123,
0.011678182519972324,
-0.018813345581293106,
0.7290751338005066,
-0.16019023954868317,
0.4628008306026459,
0.1853100061416626,
-0.6401677131652832,
0.12357760220766068,
0.31041231751441956,
-0.09658365696668625,
0.07535862922668457,
-0.7599143385887146,
0.3692631721496582,
-0.210821732878685,
0.14520801603794098,
-0.8181741833686829,
-0.21143989264965057,
0.4474656879901886,
-0.4535921812057495,
0.39337173104286194,
-0.3949875831604004,
-0.4937872588634491,
-0.5260996222496033,
-0.09205826371908188,
0.3998488187789917,
0.2745329737663269,
-0.5569117069244385,
0.9039149284362793,
0.1602800488471985,
-0.005210058763623238,
-0.7328261137008667,
-0.08242261409759521,
-0.03497641533613205,
0.0953126847743988,
-0.8600395917892456,
0.3689630925655365,
-0.027124516665935516,
-0.08796494454145432,
0.23809973895549774,
-0.5314249396324158,
0.02859172597527504,
0.18194077908992767,
-0.2051958590745926,
-0.053494349122047424,
0.09588057547807693,
0.35450446605682373,
0.3931223452091217,
-0.36600035429000854,
0.2473132312297821,
-0.9467006921768188,
0.5940365195274353,
0.08918587863445282,
-0.12702776491641998,
-0.31256967782974243,
0.23704281449317932,
0.0486316978931427,
-0.31338539719581604,
0.5451143980026245,
0.8356221318244934,
-0.17358841001987457,
-0.15570104122161865,
-0.773194432258606,
-0.03697708621621132,
-0.493901789188385,
0.249252051115036,
-0.47726815938949585,
-1.0950345993041992,
0.4331905245780945,
-0.08552669733762741,
0.20839321613311768,
0.5042474269866943,
0.15503832697868347,
-0.29129818081855774,
0.8437473773956299,
0.33637309074401855,
0.19756418466567993,
0.5597359538078308,
-0.4529988169670105,
-0.11546379327774048,
-0.6930491328239441,
-0.3492199182510376,
-0.4158145785331726,
-0.12084154039621353,
-0.35954830050468445,
-0.27187100052833557,
0.659552812576294,
0.2583681046962738,
-0.45928245782852173,
0.22392958402633667,
-0.4957793056964874,
0.3264557421207428,
0.7060121893882751,
0.21831174194812775,
0.05985739082098007,
-0.42552319169044495,
0.05217766761779785,
-0.07749046385288239,
-1.0372936725616455,
-0.19519934058189392,
1.0405532121658325,
0.09497644007205963,
0.667079508304596,
0.15040861070156097,
0.9237042665481567,
0.20891061425209045,
0.11583586782217026,
-0.39009055495262146,
0.6442335844039917,
-0.00252734636887908,
-0.43832263350486755,
-0.5643518567085266,
-0.8620555400848389,
-0.7830148339271545,
-0.1424282193183899,
0.18096697330474854,
-0.686933159828186,
-0.04934921860694885,
0.5084360837936401,
-0.29360413551330566,
0.19899344444274902,
-0.8320003151893616,
1.230189561843872,
-0.4572714865207672,
-0.17976567149162292,
-0.2668828070163727,
-0.7788094282150269,
0.1655655950307846,
0.012536007910966873,
-0.0926409512758255,
-0.4119645357131958,
-0.12115069478750229,
0.8460485339164734,
-0.7151023149490356,
0.7457524538040161,
-0.5864799618721008,
0.07618971168994904,
0.5514324903488159,
0.5172901749610901,
0.5507421493530273,
0.07594109326601028,
0.2705918252468109,
0.11109922081232071,
0.529159665107727,
-0.7474963665008545,
-1.0364058017730713,
0.2883843183517456,
-0.8011409044265747,
-0.8885306119918823,
-0.16843754053115845,
-0.5190351605415344,
-0.42198795080184937,
0.09496340155601501,
-0.08721384406089783,
0.8420178294181824,
0.14200085401535034,
-0.21486589312553406,
0.32640165090560913,
-0.37818408012390137,
0.44781213998794556,
0.6046376824378967,
-0.1541224867105484,
-0.40388911962509155,
0.7769917845726013,
0.3618812561035156,
0.4733723998069763,
0.736592710018158,
0.5097606778144836,
-0.6893314123153687,
-0.4796166718006134,
-0.36606544256210327,
0.4189883768558502,
-0.6592177152633667,
-0.35933947563171387,
-0.8793221712112427,
-0.19510473310947418,
-0.8257371783256531,
0.008554250933229923,
-0.2368924468755722,
-0.9773540496826172,
-0.008333909325301647,
0.21990203857421875,
0.241853728890419,
0.5340901613235474,
0.05716114863753319,
0.22964021563529968,
-0.9178897142410278,
0.48377591371536255,
0.6044630408287048,
0.4637639820575714,
-0.04752890020608902,
-0.35906311869621277,
-0.12823458015918732,
-0.3871228098869324,
-0.4481285810470581,
-1.0065903663635254,
0.15655995905399323,
0.1742323637008667,
0.6209196448326111,
0.16017061471939087,
0.289106160402298,
0.7762641906738281,
-0.4476836025714874,
0.7592471241950989,
-0.16547928750514984,
-1.0555062294006348,
0.7404798865318298,
-0.5021259784698486,
0.75680011510849,
0.23115144670009613,
0.21448715031147003,
-0.7118260860443115,
-0.49244463443756104,
-0.5973610877990723,
-0.5535538196563721,
0.5788315534591675,
0.4968990087509155,
-0.3316164016723633,
-0.1272462010383606,
0.6847308874130249,
-0.09771841019392014,
0.27743056416511536,
-0.5059537291526794,
-0.10925256460905075,
-0.7098549008369446,
-0.1314426064491272,
0.126836359500885,
-0.44373825192451477,
-0.03698555380105972,
-0.10076117515563965,
0.7211700081825256,
-0.4777074158191681,
0.39984625577926636,
0.23137886822223663,
-0.10423766821622849,
0.020128680393099785,
0.6163330078125,
0.2179117351770401,
0.9470874071121216,
-0.146738201379776,
-0.023517893627285957,
0.26751214265823364,
-0.08136133849620819,
0.13614630699157715,
0.16391119360923767,
-0.1668449193239212,
-0.2976556420326233,
0.4824824631214142,
0.25682294368743896,
-0.03678528219461441,
-0.3346298635005951,
0.03612615913152695,
-0.027950499206781387,
0.07233072817325592,
-0.46353545784950256,
0.20512624084949493,
-0.061442889273166656,
0.4132523834705353,
0.3341248333454132,
-0.6508247256278992,
0.016490766778588295,
-0.28568035364151,
-0.07649130374193192,
0.24303363263607025,
-0.10478780418634415,
-0.22565868496894836,
0.8702883720397949,
0.06757830083370209,
-0.2624445855617523,
0.7782108783721924,
-0.3949156701564789,
-0.8392561078071594,
0.7008183598518372,
0.4875246584415436,
0.985260009765625,
-0.26676976680755615,
0.40955254435539246,
0.48832187056541443,
0.23326660692691803,
0.36526206135749817,
0.7392844557762146,
-0.3163008391857147,
-0.6446031928062439,
-0.6758770942687988,
-0.5498321652412415,
-0.15627309679985046,
-0.18076923489570618,
-0.28724953532218933,
-0.09164686501026154,
-0.4058362543582916,
-0.16879017651081085,
-0.23120544850826263,
0.2126256674528122,
-0.6778044104576111,
0.13480110466480255,
-0.5296059846878052,
0.7056042551994324,
-0.39573124051094055,
0.6019612550735474,
0.3910154402256012,
-0.3153524100780487,
-1.074669361114502,
-0.16752614080905914,
-0.15966840088367462,
-0.7098366022109985,
0.8266730904579163,
-0.20175538957118988,
-0.07173097878694534,
0.25152549147605896,
-0.6460570693016052,
-1.0139524936676025,
1.3232070207595825,
0.34924790263175964,
-0.3567623794078827,
-0.4241592288017273,
0.23060224950313568,
0.5135214924812317,
-0.09750906378030777,
-0.06517154723405838,
0.3871361315250397,
0.42654597759246826,
-0.07855867594480515,
-0.8162384629249573,
0.11707358807325363,
-0.037457019090652466,
-0.07445328682661057,
0.6537526845932007,
-0.8700923919677734,
0.3532364070415497,
-0.3085499405860901,
-0.27293696999549866,
-0.15926404297351837,
0.7359851002693176,
0.06988449394702911,
0.3907526433467865,
0.6399356126785278,
0.653544008731842,
0.3476431369781494,
-0.3342859447002411,
1.1077749729156494,
-0.49289965629577637,
0.3436823785305023,
1.397099494934082,
0.2050531655550003,
0.06920131295919418,
0.30709120631217957,
-0.21152013540267944,
0.43705514073371887,
0.8080080151557922,
0.2689569294452667,
0.3156836926937103,
0.09081260859966278,
-0.12763747572898865,
-0.7428193688392639,
-0.23820249736309052,
-0.3467269539833069,
0.3646824061870575,
0.24674540758132935,
-0.04345129802823067,
-0.5271028876304626,
-0.3095111548900604,
-0.08597837388515472,
-0.20940348505973816,
-0.3215709626674652,
0.6906929016113281,
-0.13047142326831818,
-0.6415247917175293,
0.3123565912246704,
-0.012979845516383648,
-0.20505094528198242,
-0.8296383619308472,
-0.1436123251914978,
-0.16204111278057098,
0.04012201726436615,
-0.0710877999663353,
-0.8716906905174255,
0.36969295144081116,
-0.3514999747276306,
0.07358907163143158,
-0.30318599939346313,
0.5631051659584045,
-0.2566351890563965,
-0.38587960600852966,
0.25043874979019165,
0.6606811285018921,
-0.03628940135240555,
0.0917101502418518,
-0.9332228302955627,
-0.3353866934776306,
-0.1462194323539734,
-0.1335219144821167,
-0.04041513055562973,
0.4942290186882019,
-0.06639817357063293,
1.092329502105713,
0.31705063581466675,
-0.15508468449115753,
0.33488988876342773,
0.20155295729637146,
0.9157910943031311,
-0.6230657696723938,
-0.5588961839675903,
-0.5124831199645996,
0.21554942429065704,
0.1104838103055954,
-0.23150096833705902,
0.6434255838394165,
0.4979947507381439,
0.996595561504364,
-0.0557369738817215,
0.3640791177749634,
-0.24441561102867126,
0.6001682281494141,
-0.8618608117103577,
0.2795482873916626,
-0.5754410624504089,
0.15905174612998962,
-0.40566274523735046,
-0.8000795841217041,
-0.04520361125469208,
0.03722105547785759,
-0.37759995460510254,
0.03903042525053024,
0.6082805395126343,
0.6410625576972961,
0.21926814317703247,
-0.2970499098300934,
0.17768502235412598,
0.18970206379890442,
0.5876489877700806,
0.8601158261299133,
0.9426673054695129,
-0.21887007355690002,
0.7889055609703064,
-0.6058593988418579,
0.004492976237088442,
0.4452623724937439,
-0.7721312046051025,
-0.8379610180854797,
-0.6004982590675354,
-0.5507216453552246,
-0.601458728313446,
0.21010582149028778,
1.1344560384750366,
0.5973686575889587,
-0.5406470894813538,
0.062074631452560425,
0.23848573863506317,
0.1592390537261963,
-0.2915895879268646,
-0.28216561675071716,
0.6364051699638367,
-0.5961944460868835,
-0.38637498021125793,
0.27696073055267334,
0.2984275817871094,
-0.03952585905790329,
-0.17837807536125183,
-0.03771093487739563,
-0.0781431496143341,
-0.202112078666687,
0.67388516664505,
0.43079063296318054,
-0.5975039601325989,
-0.7087034583091736,
0.3237553536891937,
0.3877141773700714,
-0.07846321165561676,
1.0738749504089355,
-0.7559118270874023,
0.6807212829589844,
0.4837602376937866,
0.6904544830322266,
0.6850076913833618,
0.1609753668308258,
0.4533495306968689,
-0.926669180393219,
-0.4408760070800781,
0.31847792863845825,
0.1884598284959793,
-0.1040547639131546,
-0.45274221897125244,
0.8298377990722656,
0.42587921023368835,
-0.6664075255393982,
-0.3504388630390167,
0.6132750511169434,
-0.7997893691062927,
-0.35471978783607483,
0.8928923010826111,
-0.05083253234624863,
-0.2853323817253113,
-0.41872498393058777,
0.10416307300329208,
0.5423031449317932,
-0.2361770123243332,
1.2464358806610107,
0.5271596908569336,
-0.6015442609786987,
-0.1631234884262085,
-0.27519455552101135,
0.3695013225078583,
0.20470568537712097,
-0.9047335386276245,
-0.00540068419650197,
0.5634993314743042,
0.5993614792823792,
-0.09362048655748367,
0.9784523844718933,
-0.3229011297225952,
0.253271222114563,
-0.13290686905384064,
-0.09528329223394394,
-0.5705130696296692,
-0.35340437293052673,
0.15074799954891205,
0.1767229437828064,
-0.10796356201171875,
-0.1231311485171318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01716v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01716v1
|
Effective internal language model training and fusion for factorized transducer model
| 2024-04-02T08:01:05 | 2024-04-02T08:01:05 |
Jinxi Guo, Niko Moritz, Yingyi Ma, Frank Seide, Chunyang Wu, Jay Mahadeokar, Ozlem Kalinli, Christian Fuegen, Mike Seltzer
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The internal language model (ILM) of the neural transducer has been widely
studied. In most prior work, it is mainly used for estimating the ILM score and
is subsequently subtracted during inference to facilitate improved integration
with external language models. Recently, various of factorized transducer
models have been proposed, which explicitly embrace a standalone internal
language model for non-blank token prediction. However, even with the adoption
of factorized transducer models, limited improvement has been observed compared
to shallow fusion. In this paper, we propose a novel ILM training and decoding
strategy for factorized transducer models, which effectively combines the
blank, acoustic and ILM scores. Our experiments show a 17% relative improvement
over the standard decoding method when utilizing a well-trained ILM and the
proposed decoding strategy on LibriSpeech datasets. Furthermore, when compared
to a strong RNN-T baseline enhanced with external LM fusion, the proposed model
yields a 5.5% relative improvement on general-sets and an 8.9% WER reduction
for rare words. The proposed model can achieve superior performance without
relying on external language models, rendering it highly efficient for
production use-cases. To further improve the performance, we propose a novel
and memory-efficient ILM-fusion-aware minimum word error rate (MWER) training
method which improves ILM integration significantly.
|
[
-0.4265176057815552,
-0.15704454481601715,
0.17607103288173676,
-0.11712341010570526,
-0.6300296187400818,
0.18891462683677673,
-0.29342585802078247,
-0.5399088859558105,
-0.09271331876516342,
0.3739430606365204,
-0.23192662000656128,
-0.4907933473587036,
-0.45091313123703003,
0.1279411017894745,
-0.24225907027721405,
0.6447046995162964,
0.27583834528923035,
0.6094912886619568,
-0.15575318038463593,
-0.4084070920944214,
-0.4474662244319916,
-0.5514071583747864,
-0.6124768257141113,
-0.7994006872177124,
0.3545786142349243,
0.11691401898860931,
0.23116764426231384,
0.4756210446357727,
0.43885621428489685,
0.2915474474430084,
-0.224178746342659,
0.4849846065044403,
-0.24081765115261078,
-0.2451598346233368,
-0.2466718703508377,
-0.15460041165351868,
-0.17706280946731567,
-0.05841285362839699,
0.674795389175415,
0.866683840751648,
0.0028787977062165737,
0.008488424122333527,
0.12334008514881134,
0.29051482677459717,
-0.43482860922813416,
0.2174023687839508,
-0.6223312020301819,
0.10041117668151855,
0.20181037485599518,
-0.4370759427547455,
-0.7216212153434753,
-0.27329763770103455,
-0.031398847699165344,
-0.1576446145772934,
0.19919894635677338,
-0.09656571596860886,
0.3352468013763428,
0.09923244267702103,
-0.6212438344955444,
-0.12555211782455444,
-1.0259865522384644,
0.6107028722763062,
-0.9426403641700745,
0.6321046352386475,
0.381772518157959,
-0.20791643857955933,
-0.1286439150571823,
-0.5016285181045532,
-0.6170449256896973,
-0.4353099465370178,
-0.2903729975223541,
0.11880411207675934,
0.00004287113551981747,
0.2914775609970093,
-0.0904102772474289,
0.39624741673469543,
-0.4018656611442566,
0.12435496598482132,
-0.3521745800971985,
-0.32485419511795044,
0.5513580441474915,
0.10363470017910004,
0.02074516750872135,
0.00872134417295456,
-0.44604477286338806,
-0.10603898763656616,
-0.5379407405853271,
0.04789074882864952,
0.21735058724880219,
0.7733197212219238,
-0.09651248157024384,
0.5831364989280701,
0.05734546482563019,
0.6927668452262878,
0.14853766560554504,
-0.4609696865081787,
0.2986583113670349,
-0.5184727311134338,
0.043712642043828964,
0.3214689791202545,
0.6827958822250366,
-0.013945759274065495,
-0.24509990215301514,
-0.3995547294616699,
-0.6002852916717529,
0.023337112739682198,
0.11629828065633774,
-0.5121282339096069,
0.21405456960201263,
0.19151754677295685,
-0.384050190448761,
-0.09123986214399338,
0.05417768284678459,
-0.24472187459468842,
-0.43956488370895386,
-0.49862802028656006,
0.7458584308624268,
-0.8728589415550232,
-0.586059033870697,
0.10918620973825455,
0.08123544603586197,
0.28019723296165466,
0.022241774946451187,
-0.530670702457428,
0.24392591416835785,
0.7978750467300415,
0.9853342771530151,
0.011619223281741142,
0.018964286893606186,
-0.816061794757843,
0.16627204418182373,
-0.30788928270339966,
0.7265880703926086,
-0.37752166390419006,
-0.7901076674461365,
-0.016232356429100037,
-0.4029715359210968,
-0.2041884958744049,
-0.49682506918907166,
0.498310923576355,
-0.31440457701683044,
0.3057987689971924,
0.10805182158946991,
-0.9887288808822632,
-0.4723365306854248,
0.20353436470031738,
-0.6252148151397705,
0.9239668846130371,
0.18792176246643066,
-0.639593780040741,
0.14366848766803741,
-0.7449368834495544,
-0.6160556077957153,
0.19585208594799042,
0.0924135148525238,
-0.17539599537849426,
0.4878929555416107,
0.21971885859966278,
0.2746618390083313,
-0.32251253724098206,
0.08379112929105759,
-0.18717822432518005,
-0.763613760471344,
0.34486454725265503,
-0.21668784320354462,
0.5727880001068115,
-0.02847501076757908,
-0.492921382188797,
0.14742907881736755,
-0.7504633665084839,
0.058794569224119186,
-0.0985955148935318,
-0.4389329254627228,
-0.37045398354530334,
-0.26744434237480164,
0.017480023205280304,
0.1854773759841919,
0.005525643937289715,
-0.6358781456947327,
0.13815166056156158,
-0.769529402256012,
0.05082142353057861,
0.6984184980392456,
-0.013322032988071442,
0.6304954886436462,
-0.19797556102275848,
0.3215789496898651,
0.2744624614715576,
-0.15470708906650543,
-0.17771759629249573,
-0.10972665995359421,
-1.1463699340820312,
-0.37727662920951843,
0.554262101650238,
0.5824496150016785,
-0.9267523288726807,
0.7204033136367798,
-0.331342488527298,
-0.613122820854187,
-0.7996494770050049,
0.13183410465717316,
0.44839608669281006,
0.7639442086219788,
0.34968841075897217,
-0.23009759187698364,
-0.41297340393066406,
-0.8053857684135437,
-0.18661554157733917,
-0.13109201192855835,
0.08953490853309631,
-0.00298544904217124,
0.32322272658348083,
-0.10816314071416855,
0.6139259338378906,
-0.062110092490911484,
-0.5070191621780396,
-0.7447325587272644,
0.24112600088119507,
0.4381253719329834,
0.6485740542411804,
0.18588252365589142,
-0.39809325337409973,
-0.3604966700077057,
0.11931593716144562,
-0.48330849409103394,
0.2845120131969452,
-0.07927121222019196,
-0.08875826746225357,
0.2614368200302124,
0.4297269582748413,
-0.6198925375938416,
0.33603113889694214,
0.47979286313056946,
-0.3719066083431244,
-0.042772967368364334,
-0.2411908209323883,
-0.19321785867214203,
-1.2102510929107666,
0.06301728636026382,
0.18264567852020264,
-0.27472594380378723,
-0.783271849155426,
-0.016702892258763313,
0.10262560099363327,
-0.19663308560848236,
-0.4847401976585388,
0.5669181942939758,
-0.527886152267456,
-0.0028882247861474752,
-0.561586320400238,
-0.13874463737010956,
-0.3060406446456909,
0.519557774066925,
0.17537160217761993,
0.8905491828918457,
0.3928080201148987,
-0.5725289583206177,
0.10991446673870087,
0.15187564492225647,
-0.4967448115348816,
0.2915470004081726,
-0.5400884747505188,
0.5634583830833435,
-0.3231308162212372,
0.30681905150413513,
-0.8627194762229919,
0.33840715885162354,
0.0199789647012949,
-0.11195064336061478,
0.7394520044326782,
-0.1213502585887909,
-0.5885367393493652,
-0.2186303585767746,
-0.15302985906600952,
0.42314866185188293,
0.5500791668891907,
-0.7118554711341858,
1.2224076986312866,
0.1883784532546997,
0.16291303932666779,
-0.34367239475250244,
-0.5455895066261292,
-0.11882255226373672,
-0.16886959969997406,
-0.6416053175926208,
0.34162354469299316,
-0.04575556144118309,
0.08507617563009262,
-0.04410083219408989,
-0.12981796264648438,
0.1553872674703598,
-0.11642308533191681,
0.11744403094053268,
0.2268325835466385,
-0.3650769293308258,
0.2607569992542267,
-0.38778629899024963,
-0.6074019074440002,
-0.21706092357635498,
-0.4981461465358734,
0.7313879728317261,
-0.12519361078739166,
-0.33320215344429016,
-0.5006909370422363,
0.3990475535392761,
0.37928810715675354,
-0.4752383232116699,
1.0268100500106812,
0.907336413860321,
-0.4748915731906891,
-0.24262328445911407,
-0.611337423324585,
-0.5412476658821106,
-0.47231847047805786,
0.2030249685049057,
-0.21410620212554932,
-0.7082693576812744,
0.3382728695869446,
-0.15095935761928558,
-0.03942195326089859,
0.22733241319656372,
0.3151749074459076,
-0.009811106137931347,
1.1656239032745361,
0.6994602084159851,
-0.3601718544960022,
0.4044094383716583,
-0.5340856313705444,
0.576322078704834,
-0.9733238220214844,
-0.3002378046512604,
-0.3904840648174286,
-0.23879067599773407,
-0.450090229511261,
-0.5154222846031189,
0.5920343995094299,
-0.16277486085891724,
-0.06562153249979019,
0.09215140342712402,
-0.3680555820465088,
0.3656219244003296,
0.7020479440689087,
0.2547425627708435,
0.3594207763671875,
0.2676781713962555,
-0.44441914558410645,
0.030900822952389717,
-0.7539904117584229,
-0.08078184723854065,
0.9071245193481445,
0.3299421966075897,
0.6655301451683044,
-0.018306171521544456,
0.7503352165222168,
0.07199982553720474,
0.4619157910346985,
-0.7523890137672424,
0.4715747833251953,
-0.30841946601867676,
-0.4939984977245331,
-0.016648059710860252,
-0.5515642762184143,
-0.38993537425994873,
0.5980724096298218,
-0.2122677117586136,
-0.6411635875701904,
0.17372065782546997,
0.10944598913192749,
-0.2381625920534134,
0.4812037944793701,
-0.715732216835022,
0.44340065121650696,
-0.28942933678627014,
-0.2671980559825897,
-0.24054983258247375,
-0.2064075917005539,
0.47473371028900146,
-0.005000712350010872,
0.08832855522632599,
-0.2308811992406845,
-0.08993183821439743,
0.46953293681144714,
-0.5887479186058044,
0.7604597210884094,
-0.3653113842010498,
-0.0843828096985817,
0.2056218534708023,
0.014682233333587646,
0.6150473952293396,
0.01579374633729458,
-0.556256115436554,
0.41852131485939026,
-0.5596016645431519,
-0.163421630859375,
-0.344287246465683,
0.6394930481910706,
-0.7343901991844177,
-0.3891085684299469,
-0.6358643770217896,
-0.5694873332977295,
-0.6243346929550171,
0.023808041587471962,
0.4683205187320709,
0.7971469759941101,
0.026312369853258133,
0.28023943305015564,
0.6054823398590088,
-0.031048143282532692,
0.6198192238807678,
0.7900995016098022,
0.2993653416633606,
-0.6216796636581421,
0.9520401954650879,
-0.03161236643791199,
0.07897085696458817,
0.5056908130645752,
0.212576761841774,
-0.5957686901092529,
-0.641859769821167,
-0.136668860912323,
0.4155313968658447,
-0.8269981145858765,
-0.6434337496757507,
-0.5878503322601318,
-0.5382483601570129,
-0.13679148256778717,
0.061033476144075394,
-0.4543469548225403,
-0.06598963588476181,
-0.2436974197626114,
-0.2626907527446747,
0.364623099565506,
0.6155251264572144,
-0.10061625391244888,
0.2125474214553833,
-0.9426783919334412,
0.1895025372505188,
0.1146312728524208,
0.45339494943618774,
0.19099389016628265,
-0.6800308227539062,
-0.2994457185268402,
0.09500064700841904,
0.1900106817483902,
-0.6016146540641785,
0.3212715983390808,
0.3584372103214264,
0.6091345548629761,
0.0913865938782692,
0.08162909746170044,
0.6778765320777893,
-0.16615653038024902,
0.4064120352268219,
0.2701023817062378,
-1.0735182762145996,
0.2747102379798889,
-0.18159934878349304,
0.7330393195152283,
0.6361286044120789,
0.22213062644004822,
-0.5002256631851196,
-0.36423662304878235,
-0.19976268708705902,
-0.8639388084411621,
0.9319943189620972,
0.17830801010131836,
0.2264886051416397,
0.1366136372089386,
0.13976290822029114,
0.23336254060268402,
0.038836780935525894,
-0.8998055458068848,
-0.23492933809757233,
-0.1117100641131401,
-0.5273163318634033,
-0.23921360075473785,
-0.2849869430065155,
-0.03695686161518097,
-0.6895714998245239,
1.0461609363555908,
-0.32704034447669983,
0.339037150144577,
0.012667492032051086,
-0.24403411149978638,
-0.14464855194091797,
0.04544375464320183,
0.5888318419456482,
0.41846293210983276,
-0.1306953877210617,
0.1426224559545517,
0.35808396339416504,
-0.41329720616340637,
0.3013368546962738,
0.17734280228614807,
-0.26322662830352783,
0.16594326496124268,
0.6852883696556091,
0.9537132978439331,
0.34443244338035583,
-0.41189250349998474,
0.39496397972106934,
-0.2528277039527893,
-0.0805414691567421,
-0.5085697770118713,
0.09302624315023422,
0.4195258319377899,
0.21127326786518097,
0.5381184816360474,
-0.04192991927266121,
-0.12650512158870697,
-0.2691877484321594,
-0.07067153602838516,
0.4226972162723541,
-0.4138326644897461,
-0.17212733626365662,
0.26373291015625,
0.41344791650772095,
-0.08456001430749893,
0.8380667567253113,
-0.16685141623020172,
-0.4473705291748047,
0.309226930141449,
0.753402590751648,
0.9661474227905273,
-0.40972593426704407,
0.14301428198814392,
0.5926175713539124,
0.4839252233505249,
0.14776961505413055,
0.5061289072036743,
0.07288017123937607,
-0.8679559230804443,
-0.4951688349246979,
-0.7603294849395752,
-0.13427428901195526,
0.468944787979126,
-0.36278823018074036,
0.10399176180362701,
-0.5115161538124084,
-0.0694332867860794,
-0.16272561252117157,
-0.0370318666100502,
-0.771209716796875,
0.14561456441879272,
0.3162183463573456,
0.9709261655807495,
-0.35487258434295654,
1.0102301836013794,
0.5368783473968506,
-0.4247893691062927,
-0.9724651575088501,
-0.07866121828556061,
-0.1180041953921318,
-0.6310461163520813,
0.42473849654197693,
0.27852663397789,
-0.15292370319366455,
0.02424783632159233,
-0.05183956027030945,
-1.0485880374908447,
0.9241377711296082,
0.4893239140510559,
-0.5772255659103394,
0.2612254023551941,
0.500434398651123,
0.40043532848358154,
-0.7058936953544617,
0.25369060039520264,
0.5065461993217468,
0.46351832151412964,
0.03126534819602966,
-0.7002098560333252,
-0.001502608647570014,
-0.26737451553344727,
0.2334703803062439,
0.39430999755859375,
-0.3961314260959625,
0.6516658663749695,
-0.08134972304105759,
-0.3150492310523987,
0.027717698365449905,
0.8251215219497681,
-0.08684977144002914,
0.06663062423467636,
0.835230827331543,
0.37294501066207886,
0.5628875494003296,
-0.1980515718460083,
1.0147994756698608,
-0.5862037539482117,
0.13155078887939453,
1.0683263540267944,
-0.34385108947753906,
0.8559026718139648,
0.32987701892852783,
0.2857598662376404,
0.31616103649139404,
0.30660000443458557,
0.19425280392169952,
0.6369723677635193,
-0.20198681950569153,
-0.7682346105575562,
-0.45033714175224304,
-0.38718777894973755,
-0.4068491458892822,
0.980383038520813,
0.3069812059402466,
-0.4081173837184906,
-0.18624790012836456,
0.26309633255004883,
-0.20242084562778473,
-0.027989260852336884,
-0.33465301990509033,
1.1797031164169312,
0.17548169195652008,
-0.44896358251571655,
0.5662266612052917,
0.17218153178691864,
0.8223258256912231,
-0.8631277680397034,
0.09585215151309967,
-0.4753166735172272,
0.4385903477668762,
-0.15291503071784973,
-0.21846625208854675,
0.012237302958965302,
-0.24980054795742035,
-0.05980004742741585,
-0.11543677002191544,
0.8519873023033142,
-0.9602395296096802,
-0.8238483667373657,
0.4666306972503662,
0.35690897703170776,
-0.4355364739894867,
-0.010337014682590961,
-0.41563647985458374,
0.1302814483642578,
0.004200362134724855,
0.04813012853264809,
0.2658665180206299,
-0.003499114653095603,
0.29408925771713257,
0.39874687790870667,
0.7827619314193726,
-0.079525426030159,
-0.17190337181091309,
0.21432806551456451,
0.8454969525337219,
-0.6982065439224243,
-0.6243135333061218,
-0.537534236907959,
0.7516486048698425,
-0.04909956082701683,
-0.280406653881073,
0.5574126839637756,
0.5008462071418762,
0.7383497953414917,
-0.14034108817577362,
0.6710667014122009,
0.4553045332431793,
0.5967777371406555,
-0.6669541001319885,
0.5599347949028015,
-0.4816896915435791,
0.16196312010288239,
0.07872311025857925,
-1.0656933784484863,
-0.0076316241174936295,
0.5759550929069519,
0.09956156462430954,
0.2455335408449173,
0.658305287361145,
0.8520452976226807,
-0.14872150123119354,
0.12181957811117172,
0.3006722629070282,
0.16299507021903992,
0.258562833070755,
0.5042426586151123,
0.7005019187927246,
-0.41833990812301636,
0.4177570939064026,
-0.8044009804725647,
0.19749727845191956,
-0.36518585681915283,
-0.7797792553901672,
-0.9279934763908386,
-0.6884500980377197,
-0.2713152766227722,
-0.24210751056671143,
-0.14826850593090057,
1.1317863464355469,
0.7911081910133362,
-0.7725743651390076,
-0.35878410935401917,
0.14286859333515167,
0.02093871869146824,
-0.2803630828857422,
-0.17265737056732178,
0.10830788314342499,
-0.18297594785690308,
-0.5144118666648865,
0.9576351046562195,
0.2996169924736023,
0.17633387446403503,
-0.4523070752620697,
-0.16841213405132294,
-0.28344210982322693,
0.2702418267726898,
0.5815399289131165,
0.02997611276805401,
-0.539434015750885,
-0.4400932490825653,
-0.15397636592388153,
-0.11019148677587509,
-0.01946336217224598,
1.114937424659729,
-0.8062877655029297,
0.49836716055870056,
0.46962133049964905,
0.5584478974342346,
0.5161908864974976,
-0.1578773409128189,
0.8573278784751892,
-0.9389158487319946,
0.6577338576316833,
0.4958263635635376,
0.5626214742660522,
0.8019592761993408,
-0.4327789843082428,
0.6913760900497437,
0.11898846924304962,
0.12505488097667694,
-0.8686131238937378,
-0.041735950857400894,
-0.8004899621009827,
-0.14880779385566711,
1.0803115367889404,
0.11343920975923538,
-0.1499657928943634,
-0.016283715143799782,
-0.08196502178907394,
0.2578657567501068,
-0.41298022866249084,
0.5088324546813965,
0.3712969720363617,
-0.008746569976210594,
-0.21302646398544312,
0.16400867700576782,
0.2658178210258484,
0.33791905641555786,
-0.5787785053253174,
-0.298572301864624,
0.34912171959877014,
0.2855495810508728,
0.17340399324893951,
0.4831608235836029,
0.09150437265634537,
0.2459203004837036,
0.09434595704078674,
0.10767772793769836,
-0.44849148392677307,
-0.07221303135156631,
-0.5711605548858643,
0.268088161945343,
0.05394773185253143,
-0.08115527778863907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01715v1
|
EMONA: Event-level Moral Opinions in News Articles
| 2024-04-02T07:57:19 | 2024-04-02T07:57:19 |
Yuanyuan Lei, Md Messal Monem Miah, Ayesha Qamar, Sai Ramana Reddy, Jonathan Tong, Haotian Xu, Ruihong Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most previous research on moral frames has focused on social media short
texts, little work has explored moral sentiment within news articles. In news
articles, authors often express their opinions or political stance through
moral judgment towards events, specifically whether the event is right or wrong
according to social moral rules. This paper initiates a new task to understand
moral opinions towards events in news articles. We have created a new dataset,
EMONA, and annotated event-level moral opinions in news articles. This dataset
consists of 400 news articles containing over 10k sentences and 45k events,
among which 9,613 events received moral foundation labels. Extracting event
morality is a challenging task, as moral judgment towards events can be very
implicit. Baseline models were built for event moral identification and
classification. In addition, we also conduct extrinsic evaluations to integrate
event-level moral opinions into three downstream tasks. The statistical
analysis and experiments show that moral opinions of events can serve as
informative features for identifying ideological bias or subjective events.
|
[
-0.31552523374557495,
-0.7825829386711121,
0.7210949063301086,
0.07274716347455978,
-0.6016841530799866,
-0.35212546586990356,
0.030592747032642365,
-0.4665466547012329,
0.22304369509220123,
0.3319397270679474,
-0.3023815155029297,
-0.6358938217163086,
-0.6236632466316223,
0.17408592998981476,
-0.3757146894931793,
1.3679401874542236,
0.22093288600444794,
0.17817652225494385,
-0.06944131851196289,
-0.521857500076294,
-0.014147400856018066,
-0.5454580187797546,
-1.130350947380066,
0.013673186302185059,
0.622326672077179,
0.3787478506565094,
0.40774601697921753,
0.4693824350833893,
0.1745299994945526,
0.16438806056976318,
-0.22126109898090363,
-0.1866639405488968,
-0.6637743711471558,
-0.1260003298521042,
-0.388071745634079,
-0.5986748933792114,
-0.47558802366256714,
0.4848427474498749,
0.03476247191429138,
-0.07276757061481476,
0.1515275090932846,
0.5772178769111633,
-0.09560658037662506,
0.7084764242172241,
-0.44444936513900757,
0.0030918954871594906,
-0.6230455040931702,
0.48726657032966614,
-0.1640295386314392,
-0.3450847268104553,
-0.4096219539642334,
-0.6564903855323792,
0.2123102992773056,
-0.6241687536239624,
0.0013783671893179417,
0.051955703645944595,
0.9000166654586792,
0.053467150777578354,
-0.8040228486061096,
-0.4988408088684082,
-0.2926398515701294,
1.2690201997756958,
-0.5421604514122009,
0.4416179060935974,
0.4860868752002716,
-0.37834131717681885,
0.3943856656551361,
-0.14696136116981506,
-0.3917481601238251,
0.2553770840167999,
0.06868550926446915,
0.10346334427595139,
-0.39900463819503784,
-0.16388270258903503,
0.23085764050483704,
0.09034211933612823,
-0.13617636263370514,
-0.34169578552246094,
-0.3041623830795288,
0.40542230010032654,
0.7167153358459473,
0.02622590959072113,
0.251590371131897,
-0.8664171099662781,
-0.32227373123168945,
0.21878010034561157,
-0.7199283838272095,
0.4163285195827484,
0.7865884304046631,
-0.1721702218055725,
-0.3849453628063202,
0.8037087917327881,
-0.10221508890390396,
0.3414155840873718,
0.45103758573532104,
-0.06766865402460098,
0.4236927926540375,
-0.5420812368392944,
-0.17801515758037567,
0.16061308979988098,
0.4943731427192688,
1.0492461919784546,
0.7616948485374451,
0.45660194754600525,
0.0072481040842831135,
-0.22128058969974518,
0.40956708788871765,
-0.879970133304596,
0.3286898136138916,
0.312295138835907,
-1.147871971130371,
-0.9785850644111633,
0.11391863226890564,
-1.0745998620986938,
-0.7293747663497925,
-0.32006925344467163,
-0.05922360718250275,
-0.10188426822423935,
-0.0175678301602602,
0.06486745178699493,
-0.3762010633945465,
0.3777976334095001,
0.5915542840957642,
-0.42456161975860596,
-0.42397692799568176,
0.7124142050743103,
0.5095219016075134,
0.21735580265522003,
0.23479314148426056,
-0.7170894742012024,
0.17679554224014282,
-0.28924500942230225,
0.6521900296211243,
-1.117368221282959,
-0.12802864611148834,
-0.11167780309915543,
0.13422171771526337,
0.26365405321121216,
0.1447649449110031,
1.0818287134170532,
-0.30255618691444397,
0.11194265633821487,
-0.2544451653957367,
-0.5771299004554749,
-0.2227708399295807,
0.17904284596443176,
-0.3089216649532318,
0.5812088847160339,
-0.5415565967559814,
-1.0968021154403687,
0.7467074990272522,
-0.35992616415023804,
-0.5434218645095825,
-0.33942896127700806,
-0.22520768642425537,
-0.2776535153388977,
0.5949007868766785,
0.502728283405304,
0.4832814931869507,
0.13658179342746735,
0.18886153399944305,
-0.6279897689819336,
0.0505497008562088,
0.22249150276184082,
-0.3785937428474426,
0.8582491874694824,
0.1446302831172943,
-0.3153960108757019,
-0.21274398267269135,
-0.8387643098831177,
-0.23224058747291565,
-0.11228086054325104,
-0.34463655948638916,
-1.017024278640747,
0.39241042733192444,
-0.02964690327644348,
0.15213997662067413,
0.39297646284103394,
-0.9882807731628418,
-0.1186070591211319,
-0.3725660443305969,
0.20450446009635925,
0.7767091989517212,
0.5928540825843811,
0.6923352479934692,
-0.32111436128616333,
0.16266146302223206,
-0.14838628470897675,
0.8199716806411743,
0.20967942476272583,
-0.6709285378456116,
-0.7599260210990906,
0.26993006467819214,
-0.3618693947792053,
0.4239313006401062,
-0.307483971118927,
0.5246833562850952,
0.3208903670310974,
-0.2781725227832794,
-0.3977264165878296,
-0.17382481694221497,
0.3363324999809265,
0.23841559886932373,
0.10266199707984924,
0.2404009848833084,
-0.6669889092445374,
-0.7164261341094971,
-0.7749529480934143,
-0.5211580991744995,
0.3528521656990051,
0.4254380762577057,
0.3733760416507721,
0.25881826877593994,
0.6815589666366577,
-0.1561836451292038,
-0.3591085374355316,
0.04042469710111618,
0.2731466591358185,
0.2066522091627121,
0.22239543497562408,
0.7022641897201538,
-1.1277772188186646,
-0.10494301468133926,
0.2795751094818115,
-0.7929438948631287,
-0.04742901399731636,
-0.09106041491031647,
-0.28582292795181274,
0.35213667154312134,
0.20381438732147217,
-0.13098719716072083,
0.7112201452255249,
0.5212582945823669,
-0.6185227036476135,
-0.20450083911418915,
0.3781846761703491,
0.6522229313850403,
-0.9588168263435364,
-0.44047945737838745,
0.0529472790658474,
-0.1812019795179367,
-0.3058350682258606,
-0.40165308117866516,
-0.26772943139076233,
0.34318768978118896,
-0.7234828472137451,
0.4035464823246002,
0.08712637424468994,
-0.13278290629386902,
-0.18913686275482178,
0.19885697960853577,
0.41529831290245056,
0.21899840235710144,
0.1366567760705948,
-0.04390954226255417,
0.23467448353767395,
-0.14801065623760223,
0.3082108199596405,
0.5722187161445618,
-0.1868167668581009,
0.9930770397186279,
-0.509476363658905,
0.06378516554832458,
-0.2955971360206604,
0.11944764852523804,
-0.4961731731891632,
-0.03239811211824417,
0.08381296694278717,
-0.5666014552116394,
-0.3910861909389496,
-0.662203848361969,
-0.20796608924865723,
0.1091696247458458,
-0.6088616847991943,
0.3611471951007843,
0.2678297758102417,
-0.34448859095573425,
0.6169618368148804,
0.8402081727981567,
-0.09285905212163925,
-0.8112667202949524,
-0.46844521164894104,
-0.15029211342334747,
-0.5018313527107239,
-0.472330778837204,
-0.1784353405237198,
0.344395250082016,
-0.5567411184310913,
0.48624271154403687,
-0.017090866342186928,
0.0006622619112022221,
-0.259703129529953,
0.37513887882232666,
-0.025243325158953667,
-0.08652567118406296,
0.32764574885368347,
0.31282132863998413,
-0.037033356726169586,
0.11600679159164429,
-0.012606125324964523,
0.26145219802856445,
-0.6129023432731628,
-0.10999096930027008,
-0.5168657898902893,
0.47596362233161926,
0.5593010187149048,
-0.3970929980278015,
0.6121601462364197,
0.4287814795970917,
-0.5720264911651611,
0.012695827521383762,
-0.5462163090705872,
0.10561953485012054,
-0.3377240300178528,
0.26585713028907776,
0.0006683783140033484,
-0.6596549153327942,
0.30209311842918396,
0.6482846140861511,
0.4451357424259186,
0.5817628502845764,
0.6377780437469482,
-0.48265302181243896,
1.211717963218689,
0.20501884818077087,
0.006162975914776325,
0.6663050055503845,
0.005932260304689407,
0.08068900555372238,
-0.5835559368133545,
-0.12778550386428833,
-0.5606952905654907,
-0.2799512445926666,
-0.38194355368614197,
-0.11986850202083588,
0.23954102396965027,
0.09334427863359451,
-0.45095255970954895,
0.01922697015106678,
-0.1915103793144226,
0.7192237973213196,
0.11149166524410248,
0.09220175445079803,
0.7449697852134705,
0.026696499437093735,
0.3792650103569031,
0.01542326994240284,
-0.3631468117237091,
-0.8091776967048645,
0.948764443397522,
0.28852370381355286,
0.7954460978507996,
-0.16687265038490295,
0.7859845757484436,
0.545667290687561,
0.3120744228363037,
-0.6334254741668701,
0.14262013137340546,
-0.5316599607467651,
-0.750460684299469,
-0.3150443434715271,
-0.20304633677005768,
-0.6195197105407715,
-0.08970651775598526,
-0.3211362957954407,
-0.5452781915664673,
0.9103173017501831,
-0.3585869073867798,
-0.4413836598396301,
0.5021323561668396,
-0.2044677734375,
0.47446051239967346,
-0.30940014123916626,
-0.11551453173160553,
-0.7895646691322327,
-0.41116446256637573,
0.15763027966022491,
-0.1498931348323822,
0.3756457567214966,
-0.6183314919471741,
-0.2701854109764099,
0.8736554980278015,
-0.027047157287597656,
0.8926873207092285,
-0.05556929484009743,
-0.0760331079363823,
0.2502477765083313,
-0.2736278772354126,
0.513795018196106,
0.6608499884605408,
-0.4138239920139313,
0.15385471284389496,
0.09539096802473068,
-0.1051124781370163,
-0.2929726541042328,
0.7184097766876221,
-0.7829938530921936,
-0.28331002593040466,
-0.25494059920310974,
-0.22449123859405518,
0.014522207900881767,
-0.13145147264003754,
0.2864778935909271,
0.944649338722229,
-0.23061615228652954,
0.6135442852973938,
0.4214930236339569,
-0.41990306973457336,
0.4300137162208557,
0.31699350476264954,
-0.17242540419101715,
-0.5868204832077026,
0.6356759071350098,
0.04975196346640587,
-0.20518480241298676,
0.34837883710861206,
0.2976635694503784,
-0.1938154697418213,
-0.3182055354118347,
-0.7324497103691101,
-0.07137573510408401,
-0.7214393019676208,
-0.17710526287555695,
-0.8167365193367004,
0.17043732106685638,
0.2718331813812256,
-0.6997117400169373,
-0.6469195485115051,
-0.6241768598556519,
-0.37900736927986145,
-0.32545384764671326,
0.5448381304740906,
0.9988373517990112,
0.17952364683151245,
-0.07517299801111221,
-0.8842331171035767,
0.1974847912788391,
-0.07922235131263733,
0.2989431321620941,
-0.2957693040370941,
-0.3037920594215393,
-0.024350205436348915,
-0.005266245920211077,
-0.199137344956398,
-1.0002409219741821,
0.1039232611656189,
0.07336504757404327,
0.40723466873168945,
0.9790348410606384,
0.5056034326553345,
0.4409113824367523,
-0.1862003207206726,
0.5776001214981079,
-0.030384594574570656,
-1.0181477069854736,
0.9391250610351562,
-0.5848296880722046,
-0.5150488615036011,
0.654484212398529,
0.4373919367790222,
-0.1606789082288742,
-0.9027575254440308,
-0.9641847014427185,
-0.35968998074531555,
0.5982308983802795,
0.4754306674003601,
0.23510731756687164,
-0.3132682144641876,
0.5054296851158142,
0.19917479157447815,
0.5453208684921265,
-0.720862865447998,
-0.1358095109462738,
-0.26006338000297546,
-0.34557610750198364,
0.20363794267177582,
-0.2543245553970337,
-0.3326052725315094,
-0.22069305181503296,
0.5758364796638489,
0.06527368724346161,
-0.15066076815128326,
0.338105171918869,
-0.05470496788620949,
-0.20171833038330078,
0.2959415912628174,
0.18666234612464905,
0.8298099637031555,
-0.23698371648788452,
-0.005190735682845116,
0.3166249394416809,
-0.19886775314807892,
0.27810314297676086,
-0.27029934525489807,
-0.24609701335430145,
0.053537704050540924,
0.3613824248313904,
0.6041998863220215,
0.31403252482414246,
-0.31989771127700806,
0.9102105498313904,
-0.39761558175086975,
0.18439613282680511,
-0.5092446208000183,
-0.09815991669893265,
-0.15800324082374573,
0.660934329032898,
0.2795235514640808,
0.24352821707725525,
0.25330477952957153,
-0.7480522394180298,
0.4499188959598541,
0.22116442024707794,
-0.49105942249298096,
-0.46395939588546753,
0.5098192095756531,
0.7589192986488342,
0.11864085495471954,
0.3782288730144501,
0.0017217942513525486,
-0.2720066010951996,
0.8109663128852844,
0.053075410425662994,
0.8047090768814087,
-0.009386557154357433,
0.41366639733314514,
0.4227822422981262,
0.4136403203010559,
0.3211597502231598,
0.523013174533844,
0.27712011337280273,
-0.8752578496932983,
-0.2898274064064026,
-1.02719247341156,
-0.1873278021812439,
-0.13633181154727936,
-0.7892614006996155,
0.4355223476886749,
-0.40511319041252136,
-0.3966541588306427,
-0.04739200696349144,
0.07820426672697067,
-0.3008354604244232,
0.23320460319519043,
0.1701684147119522,
0.6133503913879395,
-0.8118917942047119,
0.6083506345748901,
0.5932592749595642,
-0.34551912546157837,
-0.31064093112945557,
0.08386309444904327,
0.1083618700504303,
-0.5991224646568298,
0.19767814874649048,
0.012669702060520649,
-0.0357033833861351,
-0.1490359902381897,
-0.3871747553348541,
-0.5000344514846802,
0.6231397986412048,
0.2586561441421509,
-0.3743947744369507,
-0.08361516147851944,
-0.1481153666973114,
0.44559091329574585,
-0.9669659733772278,
-0.07448465377092361,
0.27407312393188477,
0.8134694695472717,
-0.23025721311569214,
-0.24407213926315308,
-0.0688348188996315,
-0.25500383973121643,
-0.39864638447761536,
0.25946635007858276,
-0.7912263870239258,
0.7654101252555847,
-0.26843932271003723,
-0.052228111773729324,
-0.17682093381881714,
0.5187994837760925,
0.10646992921829224,
0.8326625227928162,
0.7971463203430176,
0.24824678897857666,
0.7350098490715027,
-0.037786733359098434,
1.1094731092453003,
-0.26580506563186646,
0.5426774621009827,
0.7079519629478455,
-0.04975239187479019,
0.7716612219810486,
0.3658299148082733,
0.20439045131206512,
0.43522873520851135,
0.5693110227584839,
-0.17236147820949554,
0.4489752948284149,
-0.26576751470565796,
-0.12451915442943573,
-0.36318477988243103,
-0.4721626937389374,
-0.23514698445796967,
0.6054658889770508,
0.3217235803604126,
-0.47263652086257935,
-0.3170672059059143,
0.2279801219701767,
0.1583103984594345,
-0.24245549738407135,
-0.677665114402771,
0.6256298422813416,
0.3524840176105499,
-0.29635941982269287,
-0.4120486378669739,
0.026426048949360847,
0.2835176885128021,
-0.06332956999540329,
-0.21042880415916443,
-0.10578978061676025,
0.12046363204717636,
-0.4972107410430908,
-1.1831881999969482,
0.6715579628944397,
0.4952394962310791,
-0.2707292139530182,
-0.13114474713802338,
0.7468182444572449,
-0.040040068328380585,
-0.3872206211090088,
0.3887380361557007,
0.5616652965545654,
0.1765912026166916,
-0.08048658072948456,
-0.5955327749252319,
0.10117316991090775,
0.2354356348514557,
-0.6520083546638489,
-0.008462944068014622,
0.7183417677879333,
-0.18755000829696655,
0.10172828286886215,
0.6856052279472351,
-0.2300124317407608,
0.05052638798952103,
0.17577387392520905,
0.5312998294830322,
-0.7191416621208191,
-0.42000946402549744,
-0.9595769047737122,
0.29385271668434143,
-0.5041937828063965,
-0.7084800601005554,
0.6246698498725891,
0.5770012736320496,
0.8238564729690552,
0.15852205455303192,
0.6058365106582642,
-0.19232891499996185,
0.19059871137142181,
-0.6377534866333008,
0.8259161114692688,
-0.7296571731567383,
-0.050092149525880814,
-0.14481355249881744,
-0.5958110690116882,
0.2052391916513443,
0.7619611024856567,
-0.41309598088264465,
-0.008608467876911163,
0.5321693420410156,
0.3561025559902191,
0.2080155909061432,
0.7352468371391296,
0.2059480845928192,
0.23892509937286377,
0.042121522128582,
0.5293844938278198,
1.3581392765045166,
-0.12453531473875046,
0.5591574311256409,
-0.23774918913841248,
-0.10299824923276901,
-0.14745554327964783,
-1.041891098022461,
-1.0331144332885742,
-0.6115624308586121,
-0.21423965692520142,
-0.17647461593151093,
0.12074575573205948,
0.9032918810844421,
0.5193087458610535,
-0.8192266821861267,
0.17742614448070526,
-0.030694304034113884,
0.3802381455898285,
0.14137549698352814,
-0.27065080404281616,
0.37936994433403015,
-0.22818097472190857,
-1.0203254222869873,
0.13223189115524292,
0.3113587200641632,
-0.33449676632881165,
0.3432641327381134,
0.15426447987556458,
-0.19803588092327118,
0.5383333563804626,
0.6941725015640259,
-0.2006036937236786,
-0.5703660845756531,
-0.9355370998382568,
-0.4527817368507385,
-0.14123134315013885,
-0.11825093626976013,
0.7250436544418335,
-0.30420082807540894,
-0.06864724308252335,
0.686797559261322,
0.29196688532829285,
0.2961864769458771,
0.3080466091632843,
0.6461517810821533,
-0.6827526688575745,
0.18442198634147644,
0.21583908796310425,
0.5839950442314148,
0.036184608936309814,
-0.6706643104553223,
0.5703097581863403,
0.32023003697395325,
-0.45479634404182434,
-0.5948473811149597,
0.1538964807987213,
-1.1388870477676392,
0.029716940596699715,
1.265176773071289,
-0.04341176524758339,
-0.24120160937309265,
-0.3787926435470581,
-0.2462339550256729,
0.07080983370542526,
-0.526409924030304,
0.4756818115711212,
0.7417289018630981,
-0.41042351722717285,
0.04250520095229149,
-0.7357723712921143,
0.5396589040756226,
0.12297835201025009,
-0.9383546113967896,
0.05337952822446823,
0.49932920932769775,
0.04450368136167526,
-0.03549903631210327,
0.39737799763679504,
-0.4145251214504242,
0.3247237503528595,
-0.18766093254089355,
-0.1841098666191101,
-0.06984248012304306,
-0.49826642870903015,
-0.2444683462381363,
0.3939283788204193,
-0.6825882792472839,
-0.21443219482898712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01713v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01713v1
|
Generative AI for Immersive Communication: The Next Frontier in Internet-of-Senses Through 6G
| 2024-04-02T07:57:05 | 2024-04-02T07:57:05 |
Nassim Sehad, Lina Bariah, Wassim Hamidouche, Hamed Hellaoui, Riku Jäntti, Mérouane Debbah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.MM, cs.NI
|
Over the past two decades, the Internet-of-Things (IoT) has been a
transformative concept, and as we approach 2030, a new paradigm known as the
Internet of Senses (IoS) is emerging. Unlike conventional Virtual Reality (VR),
IoS seeks to provide multi-sensory experiences, acknowledging that in our
physical reality, our perception extends far beyond just sight and sound; it
encompasses a range of senses. This article explores existing technologies
driving immersive multi-sensory media, delving into their capabilities and
potential applications. This exploration includes a comparative analysis
between conventional immersive media streaming and a proposed use case that
leverages semantic communication empowered by generative Artificial
Intelligence (AI). The focal point of this analysis is the substantial
reduction in bandwidth consumption by 99.93% in the proposed scheme. Through
this comparison, we aim to underscore the practical applications of generative
AI for immersive media while addressing the challenges and outlining future
trajectories.
|
[
-1.0308805704116821,
-0.4841506779193878,
0.29302698373794556,
0.3154979646205902,
-0.24350999295711517,
0.0718095451593399,
0.3051619231700897,
-1.0996456146240234,
0.47681066393852234,
0.22604234516620636,
-0.7296038866043091,
0.002180378418415785,
-0.6047737002372742,
0.10424168407917023,
-0.7831565141677856,
0.30569395422935486,
0.2952638566493988,
-0.28250446915626526,
-0.20978012681007385,
-0.0980895385146141,
-0.49247509241104126,
-0.263222336769104,
-0.5835968255996704,
-0.46094995737075806,
0.5357956290245056,
0.26086559891700745,
0.5244223475456238,
0.3719225227832794,
0.7521740794181824,
0.3700241148471832,
0.32165762782096863,
0.11347094923257828,
-0.11538728326559067,
-0.160342738032341,
0.31761524081230164,
-0.4634121060371399,
-0.10214752703905106,
0.19971537590026855,
0.40245527029037476,
0.5030562281608582,
-0.04370959848165512,
-0.2758690118789673,
-0.27661874890327454,
0.9157240986824036,
-0.6049150228500366,
0.08005733042955399,
-0.6960679292678833,
0.38241568207740784,
-0.04039069637656212,
-0.5358227491378784,
-0.2244982272386551,
0.2575560510158539,
0.1346057802438736,
-0.7279308438301086,
-0.004251264967024326,
0.2884449362754822,
0.7783647775650024,
0.7267568707466125,
-0.44832563400268555,
-0.0065736970864236355,
-1.2283498048782349,
0.28564950823783875,
-0.41835564374923706,
0.829617440700531,
0.4639825224876404,
0.40354475378990173,
0.13547202944755554,
-0.892469048500061,
-0.9317689538002014,
-0.3576410412788391,
0.5546786189079285,
0.5715665817260742,
-0.44636064767837524,
0.013882399536669254,
-0.022150874137878418,
0.6207006573677063,
-0.5164166688919067,
0.24859850108623505,
-0.5580219626426697,
0.12208308279514313,
0.5446252226829529,
-0.03026878461241722,
0.3238721489906311,
0.19177398085594177,
-0.7655614018440247,
0.057907991111278534,
-0.6099820137023926,
-0.2791368067264557,
0.3929860293865204,
-0.30280232429504395,
-0.39378586411476135,
0.5689555406570435,
-0.4885978400707245,
0.896014392375946,
0.14945350587368011,
-0.16532213985919952,
0.22028721868991852,
-0.2923003137111664,
0.11768374592065811,
0.3654283583164215,
0.6074843406677246,
0.6770559549331665,
-0.2022617608308792,
-0.1872873455286026,
0.10119092464447021,
0.3357015550136566,
0.8633442521095276,
-0.5433332920074463,
-0.34513598680496216,
0.381552129983902,
-0.5178631544113159,
0.17246674001216888,
0.26753753423690796,
-0.38659024238586426,
-0.2935941219329834,
-0.28368958830833435,
0.3255825936794281,
-0.4160725176334381,
-0.5863522291183472,
0.3767005503177643,
-0.5829498171806335,
0.3724357783794403,
0.48539766669273376,
-1.131974697113037,
-0.0047080363146960735,
0.5741785764694214,
0.9883641600608826,
0.07545328885316849,
-0.3786223828792572,
-0.15182100236415863,
0.4470888674259186,
-0.0989651158452034,
0.9199479818344116,
-0.18265488743782043,
-0.5956376194953918,
-0.3591332733631134,
-0.5291966199874878,
0.2752748131752014,
-0.5146141648292542,
0.4878259599208832,
-0.48087868094444275,
0.07456763088703156,
0.26154428720474243,
-0.4032292068004608,
-0.2863854765892029,
0.3325461447238922,
-0.8094698786735535,
0.18829213082790375,
0.0624825581908226,
-0.4869522452354431,
0.4741418957710266,
-1.018497347831726,
-0.33677414059638977,
0.5814113020896912,
0.020263245329260826,
-0.30042311549186707,
0.38136106729507446,
-0.03158550709486008,
0.1513185352087021,
-0.22333668172359467,
-0.28968310356140137,
-0.3486538231372833,
-0.42470070719718933,
0.09264866262674332,
-0.8450290560722351,
0.25367316603660583,
0.6928375363349915,
-0.4982287883758545,
0.09919963032007217,
-0.6904436349868774,
0.1218138337135315,
-0.34568434953689575,
-0.37000077962875366,
-0.09981416165828705,
0.436725914478302,
0.23009417951107025,
0.19733549654483795,
-0.012428564950823784,
-0.8026919960975647,
-0.24699005484580994,
-0.3888826072216034,
1.029736876487732,
0.653515636920929,
-0.4191393256187439,
0.3798426687717438,
-0.4676356613636017,
0.408503919839859,
0.23862600326538086,
0.5779509544372559,
-0.4163190722465515,
-0.6934236288070679,
-0.8100919127464294,
-0.19576609134674072,
-0.06807246059179306,
0.3743799328804016,
-1.059140920639038,
0.6222299337387085,
-0.6109735369682312,
-0.6615833640098572,
-0.7646928429603577,
-0.14922797679901123,
-0.07158244401216507,
0.5025379657745361,
0.3316271901130676,
-0.16408465802669525,
-0.29395386576652527,
-0.7847370505332947,
0.008006652817130089,
-0.3774877190589905,
0.03813985735177994,
0.40634384751319885,
-0.0406845286488533,
-0.5072683691978455,
0.8623872399330139,
-0.13002893328666687,
-0.4123873710632324,
-0.10284610837697983,
0.31800785660743713,
-0.13251926004886627,
0.4689541757106781,
0.5376066565513611,
-1.4998648166656494,
-0.2914964556694031,
0.5095539093017578,
-1.1377284526824951,
0.12956039607524872,
-0.12138529866933823,
0.40296512842178345,
-0.015253995545208454,
0.6260935664176941,
-0.762214720249176,
0.3995005190372467,
0.8146516680717468,
-0.2104976922273636,
0.286668986082077,
-0.3266278803348541,
0.4059794843196869,
-0.7983651161193848,
-0.31850311160087585,
0.06782995164394379,
0.33120468258857727,
-0.4754912555217743,
-0.057194411754608154,
-0.1661188304424286,
-0.3056811988353729,
-0.7434388399124146,
0.4200668931007385,
-0.3038317859172821,
-0.1332341879606247,
-0.3868003487586975,
-0.11807282269001007,
0.2318476140499115,
0.13848043978214264,
-0.02163100801408291,
0.9046465158462524,
0.48427122831344604,
-0.5999996066093445,
0.8074455261230469,
0.1426084339618683,
-0.29049721360206604,
0.7651506066322327,
-0.6484758257865906,
-0.13851341605186462,
-0.1711939573287964,
0.3682127296924591,
-0.6854609251022339,
0.04551858454942703,
0.16497468948364258,
-0.7172682881355286,
-0.434917151927948,
0.20669913291931152,
-0.5130053162574768,
-0.5351055264472961,
-0.2119157612323761,
0.454986035823822,
0.4345147907733917,
-0.8015450239181519,
0.915944516658783,
0.24868808686733246,
0.07655882090330124,
-0.19872017204761505,
-0.8733330368995667,
0.6050354838371277,
-0.7886236310005188,
-0.6585474610328674,
0.652383029460907,
-0.4066092371940613,
-0.210214301943779,
0.20332393050193787,
0.07242489606142044,
0.20198096334934235,
0.3739122748374939,
0.5312488675117493,
-0.1455056220293045,
-0.15813009440898895,
0.025671709328889847,
0.11297821253538132,
-0.39523857831954956,
0.1920020878314972,
-0.8039711117744446,
0.4430943429470062,
-0.11601906269788742,
-0.8238191604614258,
-0.7273649573326111,
0.9463551640510559,
0.5899243354797363,
-0.4247455298900604,
0.42029881477355957,
0.9485570788383484,
-0.17229054868221283,
0.24638143181800842,
-0.8130070567131042,
-0.4084375202655792,
-0.5482630133628845,
-0.04615290090441704,
-0.5436257719993591,
-0.972905695438385,
0.39335793256759644,
-0.41618436574935913,
-0.3046703338623047,
0.415034681558609,
0.1977989226579666,
-0.6249109506607056,
0.8766229748725891,
0.5883786082267761,
-0.044445838779211044,
0.7780176401138306,
-0.3458695113658905,
0.823714554309845,
-0.835355818271637,
-0.40153756737709045,
-0.3261095881462097,
-0.42716890573501587,
-0.8789356350898743,
0.013412638567388058,
1.0529993772506714,
0.18338337540626526,
-0.1034320518374443,
-0.00026476490893401206,
-0.4182299077510834,
0.26888445019721985,
1.2038218975067139,
0.041648056358098984,
0.5858553647994995,
0.01238070148974657,
0.5366637706756592,
0.29258206486701965,
-0.9174291491508484,
-0.2622796297073364,
0.6163807511329651,
0.18994782865047455,
0.6091309785842896,
0.3894507586956024,
0.16902215778827667,
0.7500718832015991,
0.30454686284065247,
-0.7116311192512512,
0.3516940474510193,
0.02362406626343727,
-0.3598887622356415,
-0.12800678610801697,
-0.08453750610351562,
-0.8026593327522278,
0.14454536139965057,
-0.41465047001838684,
-0.5320277810096741,
0.20935127139091492,
0.09547349065542221,
-0.0209672749042511,
0.41791319847106934,
-0.9890099763870239,
0.16558663547039032,
-0.37053805589675903,
-0.1677965372800827,
-0.4470358192920685,
-0.679426372051239,
0.0014745539519935846,
0.12704111635684967,
-0.10824760049581528,
-0.10771972686052322,
-0.012941702269017696,
0.15323235094547272,
-0.13141927123069763,
0.6259647011756897,
0.14598843455314636,
-0.011743864975869656,
0.46963611245155334,
-0.5799712538719177,
-0.13671067357063293,
-0.0266709141433239,
0.15957073867321014,
0.6910986304283142,
-0.27546605467796326,
-0.26937437057495117,
-0.4737582206726074,
0.7734735608100891,
-0.7756202816963196,
-0.4926398694515228,
-0.2672162652015686,
-0.3463102877140045,
-0.26875054836273193,
0.3841516673564911,
0.5368334650993347,
0.347834974527359,
-0.13772797584533691,
0.5168505311012268,
0.4659079909324646,
-0.14332561194896698,
0.7066313624382019,
0.134859099984169,
0.14495447278022766,
-0.2229827642440796,
1.1713027954101562,
-0.06106451153755188,
0.10784562677145004,
0.47452569007873535,
0.06983793526887894,
-0.4573616087436676,
-0.7432377934455872,
-0.6252933144569397,
-0.18053027987480164,
-0.4228823482990265,
-0.33552423119544983,
-0.7669673562049866,
-0.39402487874031067,
-0.17558808624744415,
-0.3673608899116516,
-0.19299550354480743,
0.11401624977588654,
-0.3373083770275116,
-0.30982837080955505,
0.23675072193145752,
0.7200009226799011,
-0.35599908232688904,
0.7032453417778015,
-0.7588906288146973,
0.5951325297355652,
0.44233962893486023,
0.48235973715782166,
-0.0863439068198204,
0.09595006704330444,
-0.3854999840259552,
0.2542780041694641,
-0.3347180485725403,
-0.30038443207740784,
0.4084011912345886,
0.5122586488723755,
0.5306466817855835,
0.8168044090270996,
0.0282279122620821,
0.5242250561714172,
-0.3044706881046295,
0.9322225451469421,
0.5419861078262329,
-0.6961786150932312,
0.41388586163520813,
-0.4717581868171692,
0.356471449136734,
0.10570390522480011,
0.3980006277561188,
-0.5287411212921143,
-0.047866400331258774,
-0.7195877432823181,
-0.7069794535636902,
0.11760548502206802,
-0.1800709217786789,
0.5710867643356323,
-0.15541338920593262,
-0.0457301028072834,
0.07399717718362808,
0.23813892900943756,
-0.46478742361068726,
-0.004233233630657196,
-0.5967654585838318,
0.04220085218548775,
-0.236026331782341,
-0.1244761198759079,
-0.10996194183826447,
-0.14742986857891083,
0.10577427595853806,
-0.22864507138729095,
0.7267001867294312,
0.03761899098753929,
0.3524303436279297,
0.24725233018398285,
-0.12608809769153595,
0.5223925709724426,
0.650299072265625,
0.10671747475862503,
0.1244189590215683,
-0.3826207220554352,
-0.4378962814807892,
-0.11799811571836472,
0.16632255911827087,
-0.023835930973291397,
-0.22939229011535645,
0.4685158431529999,
1.1008265018463135,
-0.27390626072883606,
-0.7067748308181763,
0.25065597891807556,
-0.08281783759593964,
-0.41035956144332886,
-0.6999544501304626,
0.04130161926150322,
0.05872342362999916,
0.29278138279914856,
0.47614267468452454,
0.1538771241903305,
0.5367497205734253,
-0.5094296932220459,
-0.09380818903446198,
0.4862437844276428,
-0.3786005675792694,
-0.16397477686405182,
1.1093978881835938,
0.7133384346961975,
-0.3252083957195282,
0.873590886592865,
0.25821438431739807,
0.0600658543407917,
0.41666123270988464,
0.3680940270423889,
0.8036271929740906,
-0.10276710242033005,
0.07067000865936279,
-0.26781323552131653,
0.2437906265258789,
0.49540820717811584,
0.2722131311893463,
-0.4776100516319275,
-1.0100886821746826,
-0.0855708122253418,
-0.31927019357681274,
-0.08230803906917572,
0.09941494464874268,
-0.4903658330440521,
-0.3060353100299835,
-0.20041395723819733,
-0.22735606133937836,
0.16073296964168549,
-0.4669342041015625,
-0.40903857350349426,
0.40816575288772583,
0.3013598322868347,
0.7428301572799683,
-0.6037129759788513,
0.6704034805297852,
0.49399274587631226,
-0.30288368463516235,
-0.33314815163612366,
-0.1984855979681015,
-0.021734286099672318,
-0.5318756699562073,
0.5488116145133972,
0.0257297120988369,
-0.48402053117752075,
0.4308152496814728,
-0.3739400804042816,
-0.505678117275238,
1.1286046504974365,
-0.0006565771182067692,
-0.4119121730327606,
0.24066562950611115,
0.3007681965827942,
0.41089919209480286,
-0.13188806176185608,
0.3249492347240448,
-0.008693787269294262,
0.7229968309402466,
0.25035789608955383,
-0.6668427586555481,
-0.9201398491859436,
-0.6407065987586975,
0.39421913027763367,
0.058555781841278076,
-0.6129551529884338,
0.6042481660842896,
-0.16210563480854034,
0.05939599126577377,
-0.11631747335195541,
0.9297318458557129,
-0.3466612994670868,
0.5103428363800049,
0.556235134601593,
0.7320577502250671,
0.14675411581993103,
-0.30769985914230347,
1.1182729005813599,
-0.2714715898036957,
-0.35089704394340515,
0.5230844020843506,
-0.04471415653824806,
0.6889075040817261,
0.8902419209480286,
0.03068079985678196,
0.00035079888766631484,
0.5790737271308899,
0.2062080204486847,
0.7385058403015137,
-0.11778311431407928,
-1.0483211278915405,
0.08608680963516235,
-0.656988263130188,
-0.5092688798904419,
0.829376757144928,
0.5977998971939087,
0.22963930666446686,
-0.013811133801937103,
0.8378266096115112,
-0.43916675448417664,
0.04738408699631691,
-0.2674666941165924,
1.1534687280654907,
0.017590325325727463,
-0.5520268678665161,
0.45216718316078186,
-0.10335277020931244,
0.9279550313949585,
-0.48680034279823303,
-0.4992437958717346,
-0.30250078439712524,
0.16379031538963318,
-0.09026170521974564,
-0.8118662238121033,
0.5151373744010925,
-0.3190798759460449,
-0.2678973972797394,
-0.35431984066963196,
0.6559527516365051,
-0.11005721986293793,
0.02557447925209999,
0.36100926995277405,
0.5943157076835632,
-0.04150456562638283,
-0.36833518743515015,
-0.619929313659668,
0.6117407083511353,
-0.3858678936958313,
0.24859420955181122,
0.316896915435791,
0.4440329968929291,
-0.0804353579878807,
1.105843424797058,
0.8157415390014648,
0.02086237631738186,
0.3180847764015198,
-0.1745181530714035,
0.8719402551651001,
-0.41002169251441956,
-0.6877034306526184,
-0.31028756499290466,
0.5087751746177673,
-0.022999752312898636,
-0.3796246647834778,
0.6177276372909546,
0.3177073895931244,
1.4087343215942383,
-0.18068508803844452,
1.0318307876586914,
-0.463186651468277,
-0.18431320786476135,
-0.4081566333770752,
0.5854436159133911,
-0.5818558931350708,
-0.06557366997003555,
0.16948164999485016,
-0.8600595593452454,
-0.2261817753314972,
0.44429272413253784,
-0.11217833310365677,
0.04765060916543007,
0.371621698141098,
0.30334824323654175,
-0.1743035614490509,
0.43765363097190857,
0.6947405934333801,
-0.08443056046962738,
0.6457166075706482,
0.2934987246990204,
0.9412460923194885,
-0.40230998396873474,
-0.04202917590737343,
-0.3545014262199402,
-0.09385381639003754,
-0.5688862204551697,
-0.8127848505973816,
-0.08865489810705185,
-1.2949717044830322,
0.014892556704580784,
0.07718782871961594,
0.2478283792734146,
0.4078032970428467,
1.038763403892517,
-0.20462699234485626,
-0.11317437142133713,
-0.43206101655960083,
-0.2838759422302246,
-0.4477652907371521,
-0.11548653990030289,
-0.1883285790681839,
0.11615891009569168,
-0.7923291921615601,
0.6247833371162415,
0.7404028177261353,
0.2204306423664093,
-0.5047125220298767,
-0.04497962445020676,
-0.2209995836019516,
-0.3018627464771271,
1.0353349447250366,
0.5518221259117126,
-0.899062991142273,
-0.43321555852890015,
-0.31410160660743713,
0.2362663596868515,
0.3160060942173004,
0.6224212646484375,
-0.9826540350914001,
0.710387110710144,
0.3376031219959259,
0.6949428915977478,
0.6341608762741089,
0.4052611291408539,
0.46303918957710266,
-0.19056423008441925,
0.5188065767288208,
0.29654988646507263,
-0.08943439275026321,
0.24966777861118317,
-0.21743707358837128,
0.38882550597190857,
0.2799548804759979,
-0.24251937866210938,
-0.2964912950992584,
0.34500741958618164,
-1.3225657939910889,
-0.06429152190685272,
0.6161500215530396,
-0.14213904738426208,
-0.014762845821678638,
-0.04167431592941284,
-0.12041230499744415,
-0.3103017210960388,
-0.06655887514352798,
0.9460078477859497,
0.3019031882286072,
-0.4541070759296417,
-0.714102566242218,
-0.7342142462730408,
0.0885973572731018,
0.23773160576820374,
-1.0932419300079346,
-0.5989832282066345,
0.4731111526489258,
-0.3888963758945465,
0.23791363835334778,
0.5651060342788696,
-0.014077435247600079,
0.050680987536907196,
0.3374917209148407,
-0.18773198127746582,
-0.2206486463546753,
-0.7038978934288025,
0.005096649285405874,
0.10414543002843857,
0.014964100904762745,
-0.5167115926742554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01706v1
|
Polarity Calibration for Opinion Summarization
| 2024-04-02T07:43:12 | 2024-04-02T07:43:12 |
Yuanyuan Lei, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Ruihong Huang, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Opinion summarization is automatically generating summaries from a variety of
subjective information, such as product reviews or political opinions. The
challenge of opinions summarization lies in presenting divergent or even
conflicting opinions. We conduct an analysis of previous summarization models,
which reveals their inclination to amplify the polarity bias, emphasizing the
majority opinions while ignoring the minority opinions. To address this issue
and make the summarizer express both sides of opinions, we introduce the
concept of polarity calibration, which aims to align the polarity of output
summary with that of input text. Specifically, we develop a reinforcement
training approach for polarity calibration. This approach feeds the polarity
distance between output summary and input text as reward into the summarizer,
and also balance polarity calibration with content preservation and language
naturality. We evaluate our Polarity Calibration model (PoCa) on two types of
opinions summarization tasks: summarizing product reviews and political
opinions articles. Automatic and human evaluation demonstrate that our approach
can mitigate the polarity mismatch between output summary and input text, as
well as maintain the content semantic and language quality.
|
[
-0.6241361498832703,
-0.3596031069755554,
0.35747066140174866,
0.1302487552165985,
-0.6655126214027405,
0.1350298672914505,
-0.1827206164598465,
0.09698280692100525,
0.5008195638656616,
0.5834132432937622,
-0.4729997217655182,
-0.4007934033870697,
-0.4485950767993927,
0.09424373507499695,
0.2766428589820862,
1.9666520357131958,
-0.11822705715894699,
0.2906537652015686,
-0.3560183048248291,
-0.6048453450202942,
-0.48034846782684326,
-0.5650468468666077,
-0.4074268937110901,
-0.6273669600486755,
0.5211602449417114,
0.4787095785140991,
0.729082465171814,
0.0729612410068512,
0.256291002035141,
0.18689963221549988,
-0.210565447807312,
0.19295242428779602,
-0.7482833862304688,
-0.000050166298024123535,
-0.35864385962486267,
-0.3915049731731415,
-0.6120936870574951,
0.3348403573036194,
0.46675020456314087,
0.5136892199516296,
-0.08401908725500107,
0.17007488012313843,
0.12659992277622223,
1.2011040449142456,
-0.6644816994667053,
0.12497217953205109,
-0.22255286574363708,
0.1913459599018097,
0.38508477807044983,
-0.31699860095977783,
-0.2906615436077118,
-0.761980414390564,
0.1463717222213745,
-0.5035213828086853,
0.4134592115879059,
0.03128053620457649,
0.7048323154449463,
0.18002773821353912,
-0.7158999443054199,
-0.2930772602558136,
-0.9709024429321289,
0.838301420211792,
-0.9112522006034851,
-0.08494862914085388,
0.24234172701835632,
0.30113980174064636,
0.23425698280334473,
0.09570822864770889,
-0.6175358891487122,
0.07743635028600693,
0.1033674031496048,
0.8070541620254517,
0.3053963780403137,
0.1980500966310501,
0.011374964378774166,
0.579351544380188,
-0.4242648184299469,
-0.3601507842540741,
-0.29302504658699036,
-0.16795291006565094,
0.8225283026695251,
0.2062324732542038,
0.02264074608683586,
-0.16400843858718872,
-0.27591243386268616,
-0.415226548910141,
-0.643676221370697,
0.30287814140319824,
0.9953957796096802,
0.15728633105754852,
-0.08738201856613159,
0.7134262323379517,
-0.27688780426979065,
0.39344945549964905,
0.3225238621234894,
0.03865295648574829,
0.29788997769355774,
-0.5997918844223022,
-0.05065148323774338,
0.3055163621902466,
0.8065497875213623,
0.8763273358345032,
0.011234281584620476,
0.12319940328598022,
-0.30058911442756653,
-0.05095202848315239,
0.3764425814151764,
-0.7965460419654846,
-0.09375276416540146,
0.23077183961868286,
-0.4225528836250305,
-0.63731449842453,
0.40981781482696533,
-0.7400931119918823,
-0.7383054494857788,
-0.37996906042099,
0.41330277919769287,
0.023306531831622124,
-0.40633878111839294,
0.21307054162025452,
-0.547387421131134,
0.20930269360542297,
0.41142186522483826,
-0.9856153726577759,
0.2493874579668045,
0.7795218825340271,
0.5010017156600952,
-0.08457046002149582,
-0.17259392142295837,
-0.3684574067592621,
-0.04999953880906105,
-0.2637571692466736,
0.8696273565292358,
-0.0457916259765625,
-0.3419661521911621,
-0.18498826026916504,
-0.07996830344200134,
0.1772516518831253,
-0.48548978567123413,
0.16986136138439178,
-0.6019788384437561,
0.4960717558860779,
-0.6181068420410156,
-0.4074089527130127,
-0.45353958010673523,
0.37192362546920776,
-0.6226271986961365,
0.5034013986587524,
0.10315553843975067,
-1.0573656558990479,
0.3950647711753845,
-0.11412174999713898,
-0.5286835432052612,
-0.39737045764923096,
-0.02466227114200592,
-0.7257513999938965,
0.21245355904102325,
0.25608161091804504,
-0.0092494897544384,
-0.20535427331924438,
0.26850831508636475,
-0.2826843559741974,
-0.13511089980602264,
0.23333747684955597,
-0.11480216681957245,
0.8254019618034363,
-0.03901028260588646,
-0.2404685616493225,
0.26529353857040405,
-0.2926582992076874,
-0.284737765789032,
-0.16148079931735992,
-0.312399297952652,
-0.21570225059986115,
0.34207746386528015,
-0.11858484148979187,
0.15796814858913422,
0.32199952006340027,
-0.6568977236747742,
0.10589446127414703,
-0.9315196871757507,
0.2615177631378174,
0.6623282432556152,
0.26955437660217285,
0.7735466957092285,
-0.6980217695236206,
0.6463205218315125,
0.2470005303621292,
0.26273322105407715,
0.05815064534544945,
-0.4460819363594055,
-0.7112324237823486,
0.08650437742471695,
0.0961453840136528,
0.8665577173233032,
-0.7757830023765564,
0.6409770250320435,
-0.13880077004432678,
-0.46112683415412903,
-0.22816118597984314,
0.3425947427749634,
0.46450063586235046,
0.7318213582038879,
0.16900096833705902,
-0.7662097811698914,
-0.42828652262687683,
-0.9834165573120117,
-0.4882161617279053,
-0.5553306937217712,
-0.07634308189153671,
0.04611901938915253,
0.37581825256347656,
0.30497756600379944,
1.223456859588623,
-0.29443520307540894,
-0.4622993767261505,
-0.6297736763954163,
0.792461633682251,
0.39998859167099,
0.22162973880767822,
0.320858895778656,
-0.7132304310798645,
-0.3830904960632324,
-0.16378143429756165,
-0.5210319757461548,
-0.12455148249864578,
-0.12821751832962036,
-0.04779747501015663,
0.14497114717960358,
0.06104932352900505,
-0.18992358446121216,
0.2528587579727173,
0.5668379664421082,
-0.3547185957431793,
0.4687253534793854,
-0.20765608549118042,
0.3694568872451782,
-1.1021666526794434,
-0.04788179695606232,
0.006159061565995216,
-0.5507688522338867,
-0.33106279373168945,
-0.39488425850868225,
-0.0036726396065205336,
0.04258977249264717,
-0.47189947962760925,
0.06482722610235214,
-0.1933528333902359,
-0.02954590506851673,
-0.5856170058250427,
0.2650379240512848,
0.49055275321006775,
0.46126145124435425,
0.00023105622676666826,
0.6823701858520508,
-0.16097025573253632,
-0.3197678327560425,
0.49043288826942444,
0.2391820102930069,
-0.15898063778877258,
0.6258341073989868,
-0.6312223672866821,
-0.11123938113451004,
-0.5824637413024902,
0.5336562991142273,
-0.9040848612785339,
0.09266868978738785,
0.09293565154075623,
-0.5057833194732666,
0.1694287359714508,
-0.038670629262924194,
-0.16238051652908325,
-0.09848957508802414,
-0.931645929813385,
0.49106428027153015,
0.37517663836479187,
-0.16163012385368347,
0.7466868162155151,
0.696395754814148,
-0.5507671236991882,
-0.708827793598175,
-0.4473399817943573,
-0.25103819370269775,
0.10296686738729477,
-0.3302450478076935,
0.272105872631073,
-0.17061172425746918,
-0.054630860686302185,
0.004338079132139683,
-0.11825396865606308,
0.3638293743133545,
-0.29852941632270813,
0.3041224479675293,
0.48446226119995117,
-0.2155277132987976,
-0.072880819439888,
0.1813608855009079,
-0.205536887049675,
0.2707613706588745,
0.24434447288513184,
0.4405395984649658,
-0.31091198325157166,
-0.19307157397270203,
-0.401817262172699,
0.3205486238002777,
0.5768163800239563,
-0.17985938489437103,
0.7622012495994568,
0.06297392398118973,
0.07556569576263428,
-0.10602053254842758,
-0.5914816856384277,
-0.20500671863555908,
-0.3563236594200134,
0.33907046914100647,
0.21735435724258423,
-0.3358028531074524,
0.46965402364730835,
0.28615859150886536,
0.3553194999694824,
0.5106244683265686,
0.5526964068412781,
-0.08174480497837067,
1.4542946815490723,
0.6763415336608887,
-0.4253406524658203,
0.6210376620292664,
-0.17114265263080597,
0.5093961358070374,
-0.7705005407333374,
-0.05144086107611656,
-0.2597263753414154,
-0.38589316606521606,
-0.19135577976703644,
0.0227776151150465,
0.22841066122055054,
-0.04007086157798767,
-0.23774220049381256,
0.13988220691680908,
-0.49210092425346375,
0.7893276810646057,
0.5203784108161926,
0.24988868832588196,
0.2465066909790039,
-0.1866069734096527,
0.1785038858652115,
-0.20226524770259857,
-0.501025378704071,
-0.6324183344841003,
0.9692827463150024,
0.22267860174179077,
0.6270953416824341,
-0.1009698286652565,
0.6337140798568726,
0.3735513389110565,
0.7777811288833618,
-0.8143523931503296,
0.370829701423645,
-0.2311822474002838,
-0.3771284520626068,
-0.16471697390079498,
-0.652002215385437,
-0.19443857669830322,
0.09665422886610031,
-0.26049739122390747,
-0.05178707465529442,
0.24136829376220703,
0.3097113072872162,
-0.3934765160083771,
0.3861393332481384,
-0.5800090432167053,
0.9303012490272522,
-0.20447413623332977,
-0.09179181605577469,
-0.4724063575267792,
-0.5565378069877625,
0.5638691782951355,
0.38907983899116516,
0.17171688377857208,
-0.13385383784770966,
0.09578421711921692,
0.873981237411499,
-0.40528973937034607,
0.8664174675941467,
-0.3640613257884979,
0.039279501885175705,
0.2340060919523239,
0.010896598920226097,
0.28081122040748596,
0.3120991289615631,
0.013837986625730991,
0.1187439113855362,
-0.05833674222230911,
-0.27623987197875977,
-0.4972640872001648,
0.41612130403518677,
-1.0468558073043823,
-0.6302959322929382,
-0.7315642833709717,
-0.5320947170257568,
-0.12420633435249329,
0.0813000351190567,
0.36466455459594727,
0.21385103464126587,
-0.5097066164016724,
-0.12835806608200073,
0.7820278406143188,
-0.2955838441848755,
0.2533837556838989,
0.5167058706283569,
-0.16416281461715698,
-1.1391935348510742,
1.035956621170044,
-0.015822624787688255,
0.30141207575798035,
0.4198165535926819,
0.23487882316112518,
-0.09560501575469971,
-0.2290564775466919,
-0.4639770984649658,
0.44351926445961,
-0.6774147152900696,
-0.33803144097328186,
-0.421943724155426,
-0.2521235942840576,
-0.3549727499485016,
-0.41043105721473694,
-0.5770667195320129,
-0.6891149282455444,
-0.27176815271377563,
-0.033644530922174454,
0.1015472561120987,
0.7958226799964905,
0.27581822872161865,
0.26460057497024536,
-0.6073311567306519,
0.5712127685546875,
0.5003023743629456,
0.27185991406440735,
-0.4507591426372528,
-0.5744353532791138,
-0.05660945177078247,
0.21171654760837555,
-0.6769852042198181,
-1.1521193981170654,
0.4264967143535614,
0.009528775699436665,
0.1405559778213501,
0.486279159784317,
0.4167450964450836,
0.15699928998947144,
-0.1327236145734787,
0.8855410218238831,
0.4745423197746277,
-0.8726475834846497,
0.6244125366210938,
-0.1326710730791092,
0.5762573480606079,
0.9720255732536316,
0.10795420408248901,
-0.4188894033432007,
-0.8829810619354248,
-0.4501720666885376,
-0.8253315091133118,
0.769615113735199,
0.04157773777842522,
0.08279768377542496,
0.15330110490322113,
0.17794519662857056,
0.3716742694377899,
0.565981924533844,
-0.6842502355575562,
0.0009745152201503515,
-0.7885628938674927,
-0.5227864980697632,
-0.42739352583885193,
-0.35609906911849976,
-0.5730354189872742,
-0.009136836044490337,
1.1898654699325562,
-0.22182662785053253,
-0.1269114464521408,
0.2019283026456833,
-0.2745189368724823,
-0.2883484959602356,
0.3349025547504425,
0.7325506806373596,
0.5991168022155762,
-0.4611204266548157,
0.09737268835306168,
0.04847472906112671,
-0.5511085987091064,
0.05761304870247841,
-0.05554833263158798,
-0.5189142227172852,
-0.05382091924548149,
-0.03575495630502701,
0.669195294380188,
-0.10697091370820999,
-0.48445212841033936,
1.13600754737854,
-0.5066596269607544,
-0.14181122183799744,
-0.31499284505844116,
-0.12540659308433533,
-0.06451404839754105,
0.07902699708938599,
0.07506843656301498,
0.3692549765110016,
0.03136158734560013,
-0.5956194996833801,
-0.25985631346702576,
0.6176294088363647,
-0.3424340784549713,
-0.42993250489234924,
0.7130138278007507,
0.3502974510192871,
-0.0690465196967125,
0.4599480926990509,
-0.14335587620735168,
-0.6754410862922668,
0.8578789234161377,
0.22335827350616455,
1.1342802047729492,
-0.10429303348064423,
0.5584947466850281,
0.530283510684967,
0.44279050827026367,
-0.044381916522979736,
0.23442575335502625,
-0.24514524638652802,
-0.6950873732566833,
-0.2781549096107483,
-0.55368572473526,
-0.9852170348167419,
-0.2672348618507385,
-0.8248246312141418,
0.3196137249469757,
-0.6858242750167847,
-0.3088703453540802,
-0.017641764134168625,
-0.05842607095837593,
-0.12069907784461975,
0.11007457971572876,
0.06397812068462372,
0.45644068717956543,
-1.3392446041107178,
0.17692112922668457,
0.7658506631851196,
-0.6250030398368835,
-0.317361980676651,
-0.26257240772247314,
0.03653675690293312,
-0.28248995542526245,
0.27841126918792725,
0.3502579629421234,
-0.3966101408004761,
-0.5034074783325195,
-0.22804942727088928,
-0.3037622570991516,
0.9195549488067627,
0.40086081624031067,
-0.36188212037086487,
0.22553512454032898,
0.24337445199489594,
0.5178868174552917,
-0.5274075865745544,
0.31255337595939636,
0.25021374225616455,
0.23754552006721497,
-0.3577519953250885,
-0.4892425537109375,
-0.014235444366931915,
-0.41208019852638245,
-0.03664177283644676,
0.059773825109004974,
-0.7635304927825928,
0.7379509210586548,
-0.10230085998773575,
-0.1282743364572525,
-0.2751680612564087,
0.6960123181343079,
0.17360131442546844,
0.39615997672080994,
0.7334268689155579,
0.3940240144729614,
0.1523611843585968,
0.015916267409920692,
0.780461847782135,
-0.4992254376411438,
0.3702183663845062,
1.1610254049301147,
-0.427388072013855,
0.6763290166854858,
0.6847275495529175,
0.14992780983448029,
0.5588400959968567,
0.36106768250465393,
0.15308059751987457,
0.6681012511253357,
-0.1316453218460083,
-0.47780951857566833,
-0.13695180416107178,
0.009817885234951973,
-0.16165682673454285,
-0.05308181419968605,
0.1228828951716423,
-0.31836622953414917,
-0.2440195530653,
0.11759942024946213,
-0.06858166307210922,
0.17334993183612823,
-0.3104700744152069,
1.1602638959884644,
-0.030477985739707947,
-1.1874468326568604,
0.19981785118579865,
0.007304029073566198,
0.368902325630188,
-0.4913787543773651,
0.024077532812952995,
-0.41887471079826355,
0.25656846165657043,
-0.2738731801509857,
-0.797578752040863,
0.3301972448825836,
-0.019038068130612373,
-0.5666002631187439,
-0.525546133518219,
0.25750887393951416,
-0.30731427669525146,
-0.286636084318161,
0.0150138633325696,
-0.04057329520583153,
-0.12731841206550598,
-0.09699098765850067,
-0.32301172614097595,
-0.282012015581131,
0.01438149157911539,
-0.549693763256073,
0.2870689034461975,
0.11987369507551193,
0.29393109679222107,
0.029734769836068153,
0.45471128821372986,
0.3726445734500885,
-0.2907765209674835,
0.3875840902328491,
0.9762873649597168,
-0.584237813949585,
-0.7366165518760681,
-0.6371121406555176,
0.3471669852733612,
-0.2679828107357025,
-0.5386824607849121,
0.5556947588920593,
0.7477540373802185,
0.7132272720336914,
-0.09280884265899658,
0.7544844150543213,
0.1569286584854126,
0.34475013613700867,
-0.3790229260921478,
0.9411837458610535,
-0.32665738463401794,
0.2686460614204407,
0.09778102487325668,
-1.07014799118042,
-0.21780432760715485,
0.6659522652626038,
-0.5904458165168762,
-0.15364593267440796,
0.7438086271286011,
0.8770845532417297,
0.05065717548131943,
0.26142627000808716,
-0.07982364296913147,
0.11510633677244186,
0.18014132976531982,
0.45330291986465454,
0.6702399253845215,
-0.3760368824005127,
0.4768367111682892,
-0.540648341178894,
-0.6076792478561401,
-0.256442666053772,
-0.9245992302894592,
-0.9424065947532654,
-0.3873247802257538,
-0.47672855854034424,
-0.5406766533851624,
-0.10584522038698196,
0.6082301139831543,
0.46370500326156616,
-1.101505994796753,
-0.31121912598609924,
-0.35785794258117676,
0.3379248082637787,
-0.29687607288360596,
-0.26717451214790344,
-0.05342913419008255,
-0.20406106114387512,
-0.4912528395652771,
0.016249272972345352,
0.49112969636917114,
-0.07628163695335388,
-0.4570591151714325,
-0.2066129595041275,
0.14367252588272095,
0.41473034024238586,
0.4048539996147156,
0.5800114870071411,
-0.4337947368621826,
-0.16524221003055573,
-0.24742451310157776,
-0.16599918901920319,
0.2052401900291443,
1.1036163568496704,
-0.6534468531608582,
0.6776828169822693,
0.8737455010414124,
0.4243677854537964,
0.5113813877105713,
0.35172605514526367,
0.836292028427124,
-0.5878190994262695,
0.10131661593914032,
0.5001784563064575,
0.1817455142736435,
0.47956448793411255,
-0.30399975180625916,
-0.06347878277301788,
-0.005297141615301371,
-0.7175225019454956,
-0.6237204670906067,
0.2791427671909332,
-1.1743367910385132,
0.08137427270412445,
0.8233019113540649,
0.0025225137360394,
-0.3419899344444275,
0.059251997619867325,
-0.5490189790725708,
0.5033739805221558,
-0.36745378375053406,
1.1271480321884155,
0.6935449838638306,
0.056783996522426605,
-0.049831148236989975,
-0.4483637809753418,
0.3169977068901062,
0.7779192924499512,
-0.7287920713424683,
0.16321367025375366,
0.5221335887908936,
0.35741403698921204,
0.13917873799800873,
0.6338284015655518,
-0.1939404308795929,
0.5240285992622375,
-0.1669694185256958,
0.3729005753993988,
-0.0249819103628397,
-0.12790809571743011,
-0.699898898601532,
0.14399287104606628,
-0.09620668739080429,
-0.015648994594812393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01701v1
|
On the Role of Summary Content Units in Text Summarization Evaluation
| 2024-04-02T07:09:44 | 2024-04-02T07:09:44 |
Marcel Nawrath, Agnieszka Nowak, Tristan Ratz, Danilo C. Walenta, Juri Opitz, Leonardo F. R. Ribeiro, João Sedoc, Daniel Deutsch, Simon Mille, Yixin Liu, Lining Zhang, Sebastian Gehrmann, Saad Mahamood, Miruna Clinciu, Khyathi Chandu, Yufang Hou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
At the heart of the Pyramid evaluation method for text summarization lie
human written summary content units (SCUs). These SCUs are concise sentences
that decompose a summary into small facts. Such SCUs can be used to judge the
quality of a candidate summary, possibly partially automated via natural
language inference (NLI) systems. Interestingly, with the aim to fully automate
the Pyramid evaluation, Zhang and Bansal (2021) show that SCUs can be
approximated by automatically generated semantic role triplets (STUs). However,
several questions currently lack answers, in particular: i) Are there other
ways of approximating SCUs that can offer advantages? ii) Under which
conditions are SCUs (or their approximations) offering the most value? In this
work, we examine two novel strategies to approximate SCUs: generating SCU
approximations from AMR meaning representations (SMUs) and from large language
models (SGUs), respectively. We find that while STUs and SMUs are competitive,
the best approximation quality is achieved by SGUs. We also show through a
simple sentence-decomposition baseline (SSUs) that SCUs (and their
approximations) offer the most value when ranking short summaries, but may not
help as much when ranking systems or longer summaries.
|
[
-0.23603671789169312,
-0.16570690274238586,
0.48788878321647644,
0.19918708503246307,
-0.2660558521747589,
-0.013465587981045246,
-0.31984564661979675,
-0.23152410984039307,
0.406959593296051,
0.21269893646240234,
-0.06893812865018845,
-0.16641171276569366,
-0.3711235523223877,
0.32594364881515503,
-0.27430880069732666,
1.1832199096679688,
0.10805849730968475,
-0.023211099207401276,
-0.18738704919815063,
-0.015253291465342045,
-0.11158578097820282,
-0.42509302496910095,
-0.4626501500606537,
-0.2704949676990509,
0.40920981764793396,
0.3001331686973572,
0.9475780129432678,
0.5030730962753296,
0.4130938649177551,
0.3199695646762848,
-0.0985369011759758,
-0.05328337475657463,
-0.2968226969242096,
0.020530246198177338,
0.10720831155776978,
-0.38817325234413147,
-0.5744325518608093,
0.32183903455734253,
0.9979965090751648,
1.0727850198745728,
-0.051411211490631104,
0.1493297815322876,
0.2637338936328888,
0.8746094107627869,
-0.8171243071556091,
0.27482378482818604,
-0.17755937576293945,
-0.04483490809798241,
0.15564627945423126,
-0.3472249209880829,
-0.752119779586792,
-0.42787283658981323,
0.42766791582107544,
-0.5199359059333801,
0.07655376195907593,
-0.0258825421333313,
0.8719250559806824,
0.14065223932266235,
-0.4983658492565155,
-0.5939884185791016,
-0.5310272574424744,
1.1923856735229492,
-0.6933895945549011,
-0.11062280088663101,
0.18033424019813538,
0.12850187718868256,
-0.23188689351081848,
-0.46739357709884644,
-0.37391382455825806,
-0.3431982696056366,
-0.4974781572818756,
0.4404350221157074,
-0.3506658375263214,
0.41600528359413147,
0.070883609354496,
0.9166398644447327,
-0.2038370668888092,
-0.0035257195122539997,
-0.5920153260231018,
0.05238724499940872,
0.9700639843940735,
0.26845309138298035,
0.4066879153251648,
-0.8447270393371582,
-0.2866774797439575,
-0.12663598358631134,
-0.4662911295890808,
0.4334929585456848,
0.29212671518325806,
-0.04417929798364639,
-0.03209987282752991,
0.7885839343070984,
-0.055127233266830444,
0.569509744644165,
-0.2828305661678314,
-0.2929612696170807,
-0.03821109980344772,
-0.6434926986694336,
-0.3155246675014496,
-0.0007528433343395591,
0.8011601567268372,
0.7224142551422119,
0.2340754121541977,
-0.23982079327106476,
-0.20696963369846344,
0.1846327781677246,
0.41692808270454407,
-0.7927356362342834,
0.017541470006108284,
0.0512312687933445,
-0.8253531455993652,
-0.2916857600212097,
0.4556674063205719,
-0.4416691064834595,
-0.08335760235786438,
-0.3290836215019226,
0.2779345214366913,
-0.3041881322860718,
0.12467353790998459,
-0.15637899935245514,
-0.4676705598831177,
0.27433234453201294,
0.38166067004203796,
-0.9693583846092224,
0.6370400190353394,
0.41403698921203613,
0.7553370594978333,
-0.32331904768943787,
-0.2992783188819885,
-0.5142247676849365,
0.19308169186115265,
-0.5164123773574829,
0.6735796332359314,
-0.28702738881111145,
-0.608770489692688,
-0.33706384897232056,
-0.18707118928432465,
-0.3098528981208801,
-0.3196771740913391,
0.5680603384971619,
-0.2804115414619446,
0.34121960401535034,
-0.23033462464809418,
-0.5804963707923889,
-0.19070908427238464,
-0.2085389345884323,
-0.8788607716560364,
1.0054824352264404,
0.25744369626045227,
-0.8529877066612244,
0.2340170443058014,
-0.6861851811408997,
-0.578375518321991,
-0.07380019128322601,
0.05408542603254318,
-0.1715153604745865,
0.4655715823173523,
0.2825714349746704,
0.8309345245361328,
-0.2148503214120865,
-0.16245228052139282,
-0.010960389859974384,
-0.5404940247535706,
0.3348953127861023,
-0.3219623267650604,
0.48101627826690674,
0.17403513193130493,
0.03710632026195526,
0.260859876871109,
-0.4226047992706299,
-0.014661499299108982,
-0.20679700374603271,
-0.3453958332538605,
-0.6562271118164062,
0.038775499910116196,
-0.15320931375026703,
-0.26091063022613525,
-0.1008213683962822,
-0.15552008152008057,
0.056986212730407715,
-0.43843644857406616,
0.3429073691368103,
0.5599912405014038,
0.20219318568706512,
0.8661100268363953,
-0.3690551221370697,
0.7043420672416687,
-0.5778641700744629,
-0.05801912769675255,
-0.41915059089660645,
-0.4390864074230194,
-0.5231917500495911,
-0.4651626646518707,
0.67936110496521,
0.3630950152873993,
-0.5985046625137329,
0.33360806107521057,
-0.6019912362098694,
-0.6284001469612122,
-0.6010841131210327,
-0.24197930097579956,
0.3472540080547333,
0.006497741676867008,
0.24026355147361755,
-0.1513962596654892,
-0.4305840730667114,
-0.8850945234298706,
-0.2792622148990631,
-0.3720491826534271,
-0.4753683805465698,
0.043121445924043655,
0.5783331394195557,
0.31075960397720337,
0.948789656162262,
-0.482194185256958,
-0.13088510930538177,
-0.6687746644020081,
0.19918282330036163,
0.14807389676570892,
0.060618456453084946,
0.6226522326469421,
-0.7092805504798889,
-0.38051310181617737,
-0.1571267545223236,
-0.7920122742652893,
-0.10596542805433273,
-0.4060564935207367,
0.2714734673500061,
0.22853504121303558,
0.3319786787033081,
-0.4615277945995331,
0.7738624215126038,
0.5567985773086548,
-0.1258884072303772,
0.7324055433273315,
-0.38685694336891174,
0.519308865070343,
-0.913693904876709,
0.13743601739406586,
0.09778343141078949,
-0.1746249496936798,
-0.5712975859642029,
0.11625639349222183,
-0.07140377163887024,
0.11482260376214981,
-0.012888771481812,
0.3442005217075348,
-0.6544120907783508,
-0.5190093517303467,
-0.44695693254470825,
0.5833234190940857,
0.11937008798122406,
0.3250759243965149,
-0.026256710290908813,
0.8476783037185669,
0.04711991176009178,
-0.8578060865402222,
0.1557147204875946,
0.012750532478094101,
-0.5275396108627319,
0.4654141366481781,
-0.6803275346755981,
-0.6242644786834717,
-0.1767062395811081,
0.6579602360725403,
-0.8434541821479797,
-0.18471753597259521,
-0.08570040017366409,
-0.46642598509788513,
0.08226030319929123,
-0.15173739194869995,
-0.2618660628795624,
-0.33295512199401855,
-0.7959282398223877,
0.3150516450405121,
0.4154054522514343,
-0.2490784376859665,
0.6482349038124084,
0.6194097399711609,
-0.3078452944755554,
-0.7932318449020386,
-0.7155715227127075,
0.3552980124950409,
-0.1953604370355606,
-0.5217980742454529,
0.5784497261047363,
0.024569164961576462,
-0.48366448283195496,
0.2214445322751999,
-0.21176467835903168,
0.33520635962486267,
0.23167553544044495,
0.2806721329689026,
0.20150825381278992,
-0.2144402116537094,
-0.08763397485017776,
0.21965056657791138,
-0.4998217523097992,
-0.009056522510945797,
0.07240647822618484,
0.13800348341464996,
-0.4559568762779236,
-0.09776660799980164,
-0.5620691180229187,
0.4005544185638428,
0.3478134572505951,
0.037437718361616135,
0.5343626737594604,
0.25056692957878113,
-0.3473138213157654,
-0.038519613444805145,
-0.2901904881000519,
0.14717166125774384,
-0.3592625558376312,
0.16296617686748505,
-0.4218021333217621,
-0.45022889971733093,
0.4019581973552704,
0.3928079307079315,
0.23819473385810852,
0.7446861267089844,
0.44108837842941284,
-0.1426345705986023,
0.7830421328544617,
0.36102914810180664,
0.11836555600166321,
0.24002884328365326,
-0.4797181487083435,
0.1510871797800064,
-1.1207716464996338,
-0.049284927546978,
-0.4722845256328583,
-0.10912780463695526,
-0.6536375284194946,
-0.2728572487831116,
0.49558746814727783,
0.47407418489456177,
0.5003380179405212,
0.4849291145801544,
-0.15176618099212646,
0.4550417959690094,
0.6024489402770996,
-0.03715217858552933,
0.4658365547657013,
-0.11344630271196365,
0.20408852398395538,
-0.05881940945982933,
-0.8194478154182434,
-0.9747714400291443,
0.7404572367668152,
0.3520094156265259,
0.6540746092796326,
0.1193605288863182,
0.507127583026886,
0.47856858372688293,
0.5968220829963684,
-1.1814870834350586,
0.47692009806632996,
-0.14616753160953522,
-0.12907971441745758,
-0.511398196220398,
-0.5115103125572205,
-0.9433064460754395,
0.5880330801010132,
-0.1561555564403534,
-0.4458756446838379,
-0.14822445809841156,
-0.14831425249576569,
-0.6243236660957336,
0.28516748547554016,
-0.964483380317688,
0.5998226404190063,
0.392701655626297,
0.15281857550144196,
-0.4102315604686737,
-0.609957754611969,
0.24456363916397095,
0.4981841444969177,
0.2812616229057312,
0.163431778550148,
-0.24342046678066254,
1.0084912776947021,
-0.41492271423339844,
0.5264345407485962,
0.041970159858465195,
0.061462901532649994,
0.5135239958763123,
-0.04392926022410393,
-0.020792324095964432,
0.18563415110111237,
-0.3745657503604889,
-0.10147514939308167,
0.27163997292518616,
-0.7429719567298889,
-0.8330911993980408,
0.5646610856056213,
-0.5510106682777405,
-0.5669743418693542,
-0.6355228424072266,
-0.2719883322715759,
0.26256075501441956,
-0.0717330127954483,
0.15408271551132202,
0.49768680334091187,
-0.5165466666221619,
0.4347667992115021,
0.13929679989814758,
-0.101282499730587,
0.876101553440094,
-0.19321459531784058,
0.017597060650587082,
-0.6539803743362427,
0.5118666291236877,
0.049163006246089935,
0.4606213867664337,
0.44524598121643066,
0.31202515959739685,
-0.08926627039909363,
-0.5947403907775879,
-0.8441687822341919,
0.2112221121788025,
-0.7715271711349487,
-0.21283307671546936,
-0.7308160662651062,
-0.16873064637184143,
-0.24398580193519592,
-0.5677303671836853,
-0.15166807174682617,
-0.6314999461174011,
0.025128761306405067,
-0.21196746826171875,
-0.09831451624631882,
1.035603642463684,
-0.024136057123541832,
0.4557861089706421,
-0.8122893571853638,
0.30094611644744873,
0.20197801291942596,
0.20118801295757294,
0.1479993760585785,
-0.296686589717865,
-0.4570305049419403,
0.05096496269106865,
0.008706055581569672,
-0.970005452632904,
0.21097047626972198,
0.04585980251431465,
0.623149037361145,
0.23857653141021729,
0.16325587034225464,
0.711652934551239,
-0.2616051733493805,
1.0985338687896729,
0.22526775300502777,
-1.0410330295562744,
0.2737134099006653,
-0.025624332949519157,
0.2532344460487366,
0.6420143842697144,
0.20842672884464264,
-0.6535936594009399,
-0.4163552224636078,
-0.5105156302452087,
-0.7718901038169861,
0.8782362341880798,
0.7548465132713318,
0.19604456424713135,
-0.1267722100019455,
0.2823123633861542,
-0.002149067120626569,
0.011061928234994411,
-0.7512876987457275,
-0.3784734606742859,
-0.1794392168521881,
-0.2545698583126068,
0.06591030210256577,
-0.5396482944488525,
0.1490364819765091,
0.18563826382160187,
0.906154215335846,
-0.16044430434703827,
0.12297478318214417,
0.4060042202472687,
-0.41976794600486755,
-0.05290794372558594,
0.4673411250114441,
0.44589129090309143,
0.8059408664703369,
-0.07775597274303436,
0.08589692413806915,
0.46770474314689636,
-0.5151726007461548,
-0.168491929769516,
-0.15555277466773987,
-0.23306463658809662,
0.2079617828130722,
0.6102193593978882,
0.5227140784263611,
0.48147210478782654,
-0.5317838191986084,
0.8827719688415527,
-0.2129729688167572,
0.1930687427520752,
-0.39671653509140015,
-0.06981004774570465,
-0.1281622052192688,
-0.09517033398151398,
0.6474945545196533,
0.226225346326828,
0.34363046288490295,
-0.5197166204452515,
0.1525934785604477,
0.2688520848751068,
-0.4382234811782837,
-0.39746367931365967,
0.3367914855480194,
0.3112398087978363,
-0.030559280887246132,
0.17624811828136444,
-0.25192075967788696,
-0.5041484236717224,
0.5261236429214478,
0.19621029496192932,
0.6021155714988708,
-0.4038607180118561,
0.3959466218948364,
0.5189529061317444,
0.3878720998764038,
-0.11505965143442154,
-0.1393173784017563,
-0.07138115912675858,
-0.39710533618927,
-0.703538715839386,
-0.5941327214241028,
-0.3690875470638275,
-0.2784498333930969,
-0.8221904635429382,
0.4011850357055664,
-0.19176539778709412,
0.24285586178302765,
0.17301326990127563,
0.33554473519325256,
-0.1834104061126709,
0.269402414560318,
0.10456010699272156,
0.645503580570221,
-0.6137319207191467,
0.5131163001060486,
0.37537500262260437,
-0.5033665299415588,
-0.6106064915657043,
0.0829533115029335,
-0.2179567515850067,
-0.2554863393306732,
0.11834055930376053,
0.24614062905311584,
-0.4823462963104248,
-0.23551148176193237,
0.027828587219119072,
-0.5030773282051086,
1.14423406124115,
0.1296662539243698,
0.16235153377056122,
-0.321725994348526,
-0.1147899404168129,
0.5061173439025879,
-0.5810825228691101,
0.7024353742599487,
0.41461700201034546,
0.4313538670539856,
0.01817326247692108,
-0.9512247443199158,
0.18924261629581451,
-0.3450509309768677,
0.03739878162741661,
-0.042354948818683624,
-0.39914223551750183,
0.311183363199234,
-0.6188798546791077,
-0.5865449905395508,
0.449795663356781,
0.9510903358459473,
0.1898987740278244,
0.34877660870552063,
0.7240850329399109,
0.16300639510154724,
0.5793328881263733,
0.012519929558038712,
1.5238686800003052,
-0.1465197652578354,
0.2755880057811737,
0.8887763619422913,
0.28746044635772705,
0.6609821915626526,
0.287863165140152,
-0.22866801917552948,
0.7095892429351807,
0.6215085387229919,
-0.05355179309844971,
0.23373283445835114,
0.2905319929122925,
-0.029629066586494446,
-0.02887035720050335,
0.09246419370174408,
-0.274592787027359,
0.5040485858917236,
0.3653615713119507,
-0.4158012866973877,
-0.2066713273525238,
-0.23725344240665436,
0.26852983236312866,
0.260157972574234,
-0.286956250667572,
0.8167462348937988,
0.1978464275598526,
-0.8460465669631958,
0.22956079244613647,
0.44151756167411804,
0.42225801944732666,
-0.5238227248191833,
-0.056560881435871124,
-0.14361993968486786,
-0.10855276882648468,
-0.38883447647094727,
-0.8288735151290894,
0.4516908824443817,
-0.007360908202826977,
-0.14728346467018127,
-0.26167336106300354,
0.46905264258384705,
-0.22882413864135742,
-0.46308377385139465,
0.13940085470676422,
0.16586266458034515,
0.17382021248340607,
-0.09374216198921204,
-0.23943252861499786,
-0.34175705909729004,
-0.15763719379901886,
-0.4337301552295685,
-0.05126466602087021,
0.32152247428894043,
-0.17286540567874908,
0.6082971096038818,
0.376813679933548,
-0.037327829748392105,
-0.17595678567886353,
0.10824372619390488,
0.5879554152488708,
-0.9111288189888,
-0.7874096035957336,
-0.8579047322273254,
0.50667804479599,
-0.3437038064002991,
-0.24981966614723206,
0.9336883425712585,
0.8686522245407104,
0.5811363458633423,
0.13293980062007904,
1.0066088438034058,
-0.172956645488739,
0.13109812140464783,
-0.6359589695930481,
0.6233969926834106,
-0.39598318934440613,
0.3762882649898529,
-0.5126146078109741,
-1.0784598588943481,
-0.3422057032585144,
0.38073432445526123,
-0.2483188956975937,
-0.11354336887598038,
0.8835999965667725,
0.29761263728141785,
-0.003960025496780872,
0.5598411560058594,
0.24858726561069489,
-0.011891134083271027,
0.1183118000626564,
0.25563013553619385,
0.8734529614448547,
-0.8497703075408936,
0.5710437893867493,
-0.2030312418937683,
-0.5745100975036621,
-0.11385808885097504,
-0.6800262928009033,
-0.818668782711029,
-0.6291838884353638,
-0.1708659529685974,
-0.4527760446071625,
-0.28830426931381226,
1.0238723754882812,
0.6541520357131958,
-0.7859587669372559,
-0.4751873314380646,
0.4146460294723511,
0.5272795557975769,
-0.36883848905563354,
-0.16265162825584412,
0.8306912779808044,
-0.20579439401626587,
-0.8640846610069275,
0.39458149671554565,
0.375108927488327,
-0.10639671981334686,
-0.24983491003513336,
-0.19034315645694733,
0.09332992136478424,
0.15796838700771332,
0.8785218596458435,
-0.21501798927783966,
-0.7702826857566833,
-0.2454947531223297,
0.01957629807293415,
-0.18753930926322937,
-0.017726803198456764,
1.1867355108261108,
-0.7666984796524048,
0.166656956076622,
0.5555191040039062,
0.4546447992324829,
0.4437289237976074,
0.20578716695308685,
0.6719976663589478,
-0.6131443977355957,
-0.21627970039844513,
0.030885983258485794,
0.3871062099933624,
0.42780864238739014,
-0.2838761806488037,
0.721502959728241,
0.06295276433229446,
-0.2209494709968567,
-0.668263852596283,
0.19536185264587402,
-1.133129358291626,
-0.31890183687210083,
1.1715328693389893,
-0.28691986203193665,
-0.45298460125923157,
-0.08466631919145584,
-0.07523457705974579,
0.19901564717292786,
-0.25465118885040283,
0.6498641967773438,
0.5707709193229675,
-0.1710280328989029,
0.2602619528770447,
-0.45436468720436096,
0.5264057517051697,
0.2525569498538971,
-0.7055791020393372,
0.2207484096288681,
0.3717866837978363,
-0.05511670559644699,
0.26408886909484863,
0.5721319317817688,
-0.34806838631629944,
0.33714208006858826,
-0.019166206941008568,
0.06386394798755646,
0.16804805397987366,
-0.21228183805942535,
-0.27198848128318787,
0.15775911509990692,
-0.24992534518241882,
-0.0065194894559681416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01679v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01679v2
|
Event Detection from Social Media for Epidemic Prediction
| 2024-04-02T06:31:17 | 2024-05-24T17:58:11 |
Tanmay Parekh, Anh Mac, Jiarui Yu, Yuxuan Dong, Syed Shahriar, Bonnie Liu, Eric Yang, Kuan-Hao Huang, Wei Wang, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI, physics.soc-ph
|
Social media is an easy-to-access platform providing timely updates about
societal trends and events. Discussions regarding epidemic-related events such
as infections, symptoms, and social interactions can be crucial for informing
policymaking during epidemic outbreaks. In our work, we pioneer exploiting
Event Detection (ED) for better preparedness and early warnings of any upcoming
epidemic by developing a framework to extract and analyze epidemic-related
events from social media posts. To this end, we curate an epidemic event
ontology comprising seven disease-agnostic event types and construct a Twitter
dataset SPEED with human-annotated events focused on the COVID-19 pandemic.
Experimentation reveals how ED models trained on COVID-based SPEED can
effectively detect epidemic events for three unseen epidemics of Monkeypox,
Zika, and Dengue; while models trained on existing ED datasets fail miserably.
Furthermore, we show that reporting sharp increases in the extracted events by
our framework can provide warnings 4-9 weeks earlier than the WHO epidemic
declaration for Monkeypox. This utility of our framework lays the foundations
for better preparedness against emerging epidemics.
|
[
-0.23482531309127808,
-0.7917978763580322,
0.5347365736961365,
0.41954466700553894,
-0.4157171845436096,
0.07001159340143204,
0.0013139208313077688,
-0.8453648686408997,
0.8227782845497131,
0.11996445059776306,
-0.6359630227088928,
-0.6877376437187195,
-0.4408292770385742,
-0.021302349865436554,
-0.589352011680603,
0.8121868968009949,
0.19693835079669952,
-0.3750971555709839,
0.0981154590845108,
0.3656706213951111,
0.07154690474271774,
-0.26436305046081543,
-1.018805742263794,
-0.2625156342983246,
0.6365441083908081,
0.5498835444450378,
0.4174076020717621,
0.4090636074542999,
0.6726423501968384,
0.06984143704175949,
0.14547626674175262,
0.13233014941215515,
-0.7429516315460205,
-0.10490144044160843,
-0.14190231263637543,
-0.09999718517065048,
-0.6051158905029297,
0.03668706491589546,
-0.01845078356564045,
0.15461282432079315,
-0.2022460550069809,
0.438411682844162,
-0.04602700099349022,
0.1857733130455017,
-0.5208930373191833,
-0.048455849289894104,
-0.6185060143470764,
0.20814336836338043,
-0.3531906008720398,
-0.6819408535957336,
-0.17241181433200836,
-0.17885777354240417,
0.14437031745910645,
-0.7265093922615051,
0.38867637515068054,
-0.22494745254516602,
0.4974181354045868,
-0.15678927302360535,
-0.25819581747055054,
-0.06355339288711548,
-0.7396717667579651,
0.2931279242038727,
-0.22373506426811218,
0.12105374038219452,
0.5994704365730286,
0.4964733421802521,
-0.19065438210964203,
-0.9575920104980469,
-0.4191485345363617,
0.36224740743637085,
0.3451082110404968,
-0.07556891441345215,
-0.6183876395225525,
-0.17025010287761688,
0.032910071313381195,
-0.1413963884115219,
-0.7469863295555115,
0.05780771002173424,
-0.38960883021354675,
-0.21403032541275024,
1.006484031677246,
0.17037884891033173,
0.5495815873146057,
-0.40441903471946716,
-0.3894311785697937,
0.4063643515110016,
-0.5656049251556396,
0.1693226844072342,
0.007452672813087702,
-0.004578207153826952,
-0.5752815008163452,
0.1094982773065567,
-0.05369923263788223,
0.14380225539207458,
0.10430482774972916,
-0.0048875766806304455,
0.14117003977298737,
-0.5198307633399963,
0.06700358539819717,
0.30255791544914246,
0.8113558888435364,
0.6098794341087341,
0.036209870129823685,
-0.06315601617097855,
-0.07346909493207932,
0.11370396614074707,
0.21428585052490234,
-0.9111616611480713,
-0.7308646440505981,
0.21716804802417755,
-0.7718505859375,
-0.5258036255836487,
-0.13421113789081573,
-0.899735152721405,
-0.8082529902458191,
0.2507331073284149,
0.34006574749946594,
-0.29174602031707764,
-0.42727845907211304,
-0.04326615482568741,
-0.5175544023513794,
-0.024819202721118927,
0.5720219016075134,
-0.5627119541168213,
0.10403380542993546,
0.8723389506340027,
0.9244431257247925,
0.0669005885720253,
0.18677857518196106,
-0.5681201815605164,
0.12985889613628387,
-0.42601263523101807,
1.1122552156448364,
-0.43575355410575867,
-0.3106856644153595,
0.12095965445041656,
-0.024066606536507607,
0.09189596772193909,
-0.11852284520864487,
0.4463440477848053,
-0.4478561282157898,
-0.5807214975357056,
-0.37784847617149353,
-0.21808473765850067,
-0.04414200782775879,
0.09761575609445572,
-0.4752044975757599,
0.6495150923728943,
-0.169973686337471,
-0.8179605007171631,
0.6858927011489868,
-0.6211049556732178,
-0.6638666987419128,
0.36264505982398987,
-0.1083880364894867,
-0.4400060474872589,
-0.08912838995456696,
0.3744349181652069,
0.827584445476532,
-0.27411967515945435,
0.3144601881504059,
-0.7571394443511963,
-0.3306927978992462,
0.03058100864291191,
-0.061524275690317154,
0.7348416447639465,
0.09803316742181778,
-0.10710630565881729,
0.07256079465150833,
-0.8799484968185425,
-0.26063355803489685,
0.3756897747516632,
0.14153733849525452,
-0.6412544846534729,
0.49073293805122375,
0.15048979222774506,
-0.03610225021839142,
0.11251264065504074,
-0.680480420589447,
0.1474321037530899,
-0.13688120245933533,
0.5462296009063721,
0.6493816375732422,
0.6010802984237671,
0.17267414927482605,
-0.2825562655925751,
0.6469511389732361,
0.006552739068865776,
0.6583852767944336,
-0.06993872672319412,
-0.9622448086738586,
0.04897116497159004,
-0.08452186733484268,
-0.25602033734321594,
0.5243099927902222,
-0.762222170829773,
0.42855921387672424,
-0.23608510196208954,
-0.7835168838500977,
0.07189866155385971,
-0.05211885645985603,
-0.12088506668806076,
0.21438279747962952,
0.2378096878528595,
0.0749131441116333,
-0.9951314926147461,
-0.23194032907485962,
-0.21132995188236237,
-0.05619349330663681,
0.05829225480556488,
-0.13984425365924835,
0.4197106659412384,
-0.29469966888427734,
0.5933759808540344,
-0.6273747682571411,
-0.08530391752719879,
-0.4157469570636749,
0.377469927072525,
-0.04811274632811546,
0.053938206285238266,
0.770060658454895,
-0.8361030220985413,
-0.5843713283538818,
0.26498016715049744,
-0.649368941783905,
-0.16415360569953918,
0.09116149693727493,
0.1217786893248558,
-0.3689959645271301,
0.5853172540664673,
0.02891239896416664,
0.8263934850692749,
0.4611620604991913,
-0.34984198212623596,
0.2035224437713623,
-0.05628190562129021,
0.22131885588169098,
-1.2916873693466187,
-0.1922733038663864,
0.1396612972021103,
-0.3334163427352905,
-0.9579786658287048,
-0.660282552242279,
0.11217246204614639,
-0.3547930419445038,
-0.2204010784626007,
0.3757283091545105,
-0.04623688757419586,
0.019024401903152466,
-0.2914157807826996,
0.10841403901576996,
0.15303687751293182,
-0.25620850920677185,
0.01021617092192173,
0.44035810232162476,
0.48560836911201477,
-0.5839087963104248,
0.22704005241394043,
0.14878058433532715,
-0.5969940423965454,
0.20987920463085175,
-0.5013710260391235,
0.021033883094787598,
-0.07917403429746628,
0.40624529123306274,
-0.6351225972175598,
-0.32108813524246216,
0.4320940673351288,
-0.7068719863891602,
-0.3215852975845337,
-0.008381998166441917,
-0.20347054302692413,
-0.6421942114830017,
-0.5503866672515869,
0.21769286692142487,
0.24702830612659454,
-0.5374476313591003,
0.49559056758880615,
0.7168875932693481,
-0.15172448754310608,
-0.35707661509513855,
-0.5779064297676086,
0.011055763810873032,
-0.11836164444684982,
-0.6451614499092102,
0.3128591775894165,
0.3419000506401062,
-0.326435923576355,
0.22037337720394135,
-0.038552768528461456,
-0.3491913378238678,
0.40852025151252747,
0.4597070515155792,
0.07509505748748779,
-0.01929338648915291,
0.200653538107872,
0.0631253719329834,
0.0486757829785347,
0.07801829278469086,
-0.1118568554520607,
0.48302698135375977,
0.4232405126094818,
-0.1600029468536377,
-0.819061815738678,
0.4372691214084625,
0.1719798445701599,
-0.054346516728401184,
0.6465404033660889,
0.7792401909828186,
-0.9580093026161194,
0.030117971822619438,
-0.23720869421958923,
-0.41624292731285095,
-0.4192700684070587,
0.14418074488639832,
0.03493600711226463,
-0.38225647807121277,
0.708054780960083,
0.14756478369235992,
-0.10251737385988235,
0.34366703033447266,
0.10308221727609634,
0.07508964091539383,
1.138184666633606,
0.6106630563735962,
-0.1209932342171669,
0.6933087706565857,
-0.1770087629556656,
0.17619864642620087,
-0.555813193321228,
-0.15976281464099884,
-0.48889464139938354,
-0.04250556230545044,
-0.4683123826980591,
-0.45100143551826477,
0.4612351953983307,
-0.012312195263803005,
0.04315093532204628,
0.3990894854068756,
-0.2915321886539459,
0.33890458941459656,
0.23060579597949982,
0.3000192642211914,
0.18873806297779083,
0.0033807987347245216,
0.44665560126304626,
0.12370967864990234,
-0.9564000964164734,
-0.27082109451293945,
1.175874948501587,
-0.01281864382326603,
0.7073344588279724,
-0.10268402099609375,
0.7470449209213257,
0.80718594789505,
0.41800814867019653,
-0.41944968700408936,
0.24104614555835724,
-0.24635060131549835,
-0.6187016367912292,
-0.16372878849506378,
-0.20513194799423218,
-1.2126004695892334,
-0.3917612135410309,
-0.5181694030761719,
-0.9901260733604431,
0.662160336971283,
0.09689800441265106,
-0.8978789448738098,
0.12446410953998566,
-0.5285958647727966,
0.6772005558013916,
0.0720091164112091,
0.013818313367664814,
-0.5875491499900818,
-0.5307936072349548,
0.2222289890050888,
-0.23463773727416992,
0.5883381962776184,
-0.4834572374820709,
-0.044035714119672775,
0.8851445913314819,
-0.22179284691810608,
0.9313291311264038,
0.07931613177061081,
0.270423948764801,
0.5770560503005981,
-0.252308189868927,
0.550329327583313,
0.4254091680049896,
-0.07284073531627655,
0.2840481698513031,
0.09567700326442719,
-0.37813279032707214,
-0.11892522871494293,
0.4322926104068756,
-0.9076749086380005,
-0.19663135707378387,
-0.34589144587516785,
-0.12658275663852692,
0.21637849509716034,
-0.04710385948419571,
0.37032949924468994,
0.6940062642097473,
-0.43902111053466797,
-0.044318195432424545,
0.38484838604927063,
-0.14102812111377716,
0.46182122826576233,
0.44695359468460083,
-0.29570382833480835,
-0.407443642616272,
0.9469571709632874,
0.28929731249809265,
-0.033089958131313324,
0.43985843658447266,
0.5519970655441284,
0.1328957974910736,
-0.432900607585907,
-0.027820320799946785,
-0.15676003694534302,
-0.7171606421470642,
-0.2263883650302887,
-0.7646327614784241,
-0.057975057512521744,
-0.9681277871131897,
-0.39738929271698,
-0.12743398547172546,
-0.16205643117427826,
-0.5836658477783203,
-0.12487521767616272,
0.8635535836219788,
0.9975311160087585,
-0.5832225680351257,
0.4172526001930237,
-1.0380058288574219,
0.3246139883995056,
0.06431116163730621,
0.1313989758491516,
-0.031881190836429596,
-0.07778577506542206,
-0.2103741616010666,
-0.008150885812938213,
-0.3051914870738983,
-0.9295358657836914,
0.516430675983429,
0.42362990975379944,
0.2763274312019348,
1.292227864265442,
0.3284419775009155,
0.6848006844520569,
-0.365724116563797,
0.6462061405181885,
0.3779403865337372,
-0.6741970777511597,
0.8853610754013062,
-0.4871232807636261,
-0.02843061275780201,
0.14150476455688477,
0.7222166061401367,
-0.7779045701026917,
-0.00047336320858448744,
-0.7232158780097961,
-0.6276824474334717,
0.5736788511276245,
-0.013992746360599995,
-0.251040518283844,
-0.3483218848705292,
0.2058544009923935,
0.20130088925361633,
0.03217789903283119,
-0.2430400848388672,
-0.09798935800790787,
-0.1306242048740387,
0.1801948845386505,
-0.32336142659187317,
-0.35661056637763977,
-0.1983516961336136,
-0.19905704259872437,
0.29844796657562256,
0.08200740069150925,
0.19585874676704407,
0.2928786873817444,
0.16506938636302948,
-0.5086041688919067,
-0.11293482780456543,
0.4657030701637268,
0.847517192363739,
-0.32652202248573303,
0.12204475700855255,
-0.12447095662355423,
-0.6683543920516968,
-0.10794895142316818,
0.4523579776287079,
-0.0046949018724262714,
-0.0006428937194868922,
0.5003297328948975,
0.519749104976654,
0.24797768890857697,
-0.5907452702522278,
0.6798312664031982,
-0.19570206105709076,
0.16190335154533386,
-0.5834986567497253,
-0.045185282826423645,
0.06625782698392868,
0.43176183104515076,
0.6698821187019348,
0.032013341784477234,
0.46626949310302734,
-0.5765892863273621,
0.3072108328342438,
0.28806832432746887,
-0.29818007349967957,
-0.8811524510383606,
0.7186471819877625,
0.37764638662338257,
-0.3667586147785187,
0.03799067810177803,
-0.29819661378860474,
-0.45403367280960083,
1.011501431465149,
0.36844876408576965,
0.5652329325675964,
-0.6339938044548035,
0.30642446875572205,
0.15896129608154297,
0.44061073660850525,
0.17328476905822754,
0.6127685308456421,
0.20875701308250427,
-0.813087522983551,
-0.2687091529369354,
-0.3988531529903412,
-0.10556897521018982,
0.46271926164627075,
-0.6070377826690674,
0.5355559587478638,
-0.3847867250442505,
-0.5193271636962891,
0.6013195514678955,
-0.17353229224681854,
-0.5740156769752502,
0.06589069962501526,
0.3173830211162567,
0.9447515606880188,
-1.2329821586608887,
0.4838849604129791,
0.5783652663230896,
-0.1113830953836441,
-0.6617287397384644,
0.1768161505460739,
0.17749452590942383,
-0.6840962171554565,
0.2789481282234192,
0.5357635617256165,
0.3799874484539032,
-0.1044272929430008,
-0.5085322856903076,
-0.7367058992385864,
1.1083335876464844,
-0.04842313379049301,
-0.4941990077495575,
0.1125226691365242,
-0.016807015985250473,
0.49585196375846863,
-0.5254377126693726,
0.036621879786252975,
0.3079948127269745,
0.3250071108341217,
0.07988598942756653,
-0.6492865085601807,
-0.17755724489688873,
-0.19021953642368317,
-0.1257038563489914,
0.23694300651550293,
-0.3131648004055023,
0.5873711109161377,
-0.3611263632774353,
-0.19312705099582672,
-0.2561097741127014,
0.6135534644126892,
-0.13370449841022491,
1.1892577409744263,
0.2977422773838043,
0.2505173087120056,
0.822738528251648,
0.0926063060760498,
1.0911840200424194,
-0.3281281888484955,
-0.022663472220301628,
0.8063610196113586,
-0.2601981461048126,
0.7435364127159119,
0.15138615667819977,
-0.0483817420899868,
0.2195168286561966,
1.0274547338485718,
0.44503241777420044,
0.5439947247505188,
-0.17363552749156952,
-0.5102918744087219,
-0.5250203609466553,
-0.3974739611148834,
-0.7088403105735779,
0.2905474901199341,
0.8671520352363586,
-0.3252183198928833,
-0.30442291498184204,
0.47996723651885986,
-0.03578876331448555,
-0.08999454975128174,
-0.8326482176780701,
0.5548982620239258,
-0.0015451033832505345,
-0.1308804452419281,
0.2557446360588074,
-0.234324112534523,
0.3526557683944702,
-0.2888743579387665,
-0.05720364302396774,
0.2885480225086212,
0.233505517244339,
-0.18380708992481232,
-0.660758376121521,
0.449139267206192,
-0.1878288835287094,
-0.20721594989299774,
0.17900201678276062,
1.2252306938171387,
-0.2201458066701889,
-0.4148065447807312,
0.5541077852249146,
0.4130305349826813,
0.27365410327911377,
-0.3558849096298218,
-0.5055136680603027,
0.1867803931236267,
-0.37511005997657776,
-0.28568723797798157,
0.1630983203649521,
0.4767107367515564,
-0.23809783160686493,
0.7561789155006409,
0.6518507599830627,
0.0373988002538681,
-0.07274796068668365,
-0.19254684448242188,
0.5760490298271179,
-0.23678120970726013,
-0.6164121627807617,
-0.8450123071670532,
0.06522200256586075,
-0.44103747606277466,
0.013545193709433079,
0.5581735372543335,
0.4360676109790802,
0.4212075471878052,
-0.02362838387489319,
1.1212468147277832,
-0.2220466434955597,
0.49844425916671753,
0.18175767362117767,
0.7863667607307434,
-0.4660071134567261,
-0.030445797368884087,
0.043493468314409256,
-0.11302315443754196,
-0.1509941965341568,
0.3037503957748413,
-0.6535590887069702,
-0.47266626358032227,
0.45204654335975647,
0.38933998346328735,
0.27236250042915344,
0.2107970267534256,
0.18318131566047668,
-0.0388537161052227,
0.3153090476989746,
0.13943473994731903,
0.658804714679718,
-0.12170373648405075,
0.4403815269470215,
-0.3008127510547638,
-0.3798154294490814,
-0.9022932648658752,
-0.8762396574020386,
-0.8889856338500977,
-0.6274706125259399,
-0.3682633340358734,
-0.5986493229866028,
0.5571974515914917,
1.2998684644699097,
0.4873795211315155,
-0.8224169611930847,
0.11251651495695114,
-0.08379334956407547,
0.2620152235031128,
-0.32890012860298157,
-0.24159172177314758,
0.31773826479911804,
0.1869398057460785,
-0.24208953976631165,
0.28204962611198425,
0.34723129868507385,
-0.012908472679555416,
0.14160676300525665,
0.43849068880081177,
-0.5060703158378601,
0.15484164655208588,
0.8211084604263306,
0.43370187282562256,
-0.16097842156887054,
-0.4453306794166565,
-0.003122262191027403,
-0.2338411957025528,
-0.1282655894756317,
0.5440941452980042,
-0.5596585869789124,
0.2560490369796753,
0.7867053151130676,
0.33282437920570374,
0.24669265747070312,
-0.1308741718530655,
0.6267910003662109,
-0.4333384335041046,
0.08178664743900299,
0.16930340230464935,
0.2571397125720978,
0.2622280418872833,
-0.7111883759498596,
0.4679049551486969,
0.5076251029968262,
-0.46888941526412964,
-0.8585212826728821,
0.11088521033525467,
-0.7955731153488159,
-0.0112124839797616,
1.0970916748046875,
-0.18125037848949432,
-0.45001596212387085,
-0.4749968349933624,
0.13717903196811676,
0.43236467242240906,
-0.5546490550041199,
1.1098673343658447,
0.2704831659793854,
-0.15900595486164093,
0.13027432560920715,
-0.5181866884231567,
0.7372457385063171,
-0.3512696623802185,
-0.7774782180786133,
-0.22683340311050415,
-0.07713285833597183,
0.23900696635246277,
0.10651789605617523,
0.8845487236976624,
0.4466170370578766,
0.7739379405975342,
0.00402948958799243,
0.19770605862140656,
0.11145006865262985,
-0.469230592250824,
0.07210976630449295,
0.05141663923859596,
-0.29778194427490234,
-0.2019619196653366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01677v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01677v2
|
Towards Generalizable and Faithful Logic Reasoning over Natural Language via Resolution Refutation
| 2024-04-02T06:28:44 | 2024-04-03T09:28:31 |
Zhouhao Sun, Xiao Ding, Li Du, Bibo Cai, Jinglong Gao, Ting Liu, Qin Bing
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant performance in various
natural language reasoning tasks. However, they still struggle with performing
first-order logic reasoning over formal logical theories expressed in natural
language. This is because the previous LLMs-based reasoning systems have the
theoretical incompleteness issue. As a result, it can only address a limited
set of simple reasoning problems, which significantly decreases their
generalization ability. To address this issue, we propose a novel framework,
named Generalizable and Faithful Reasoner (GFaiR), which introduces the
paradigm of resolution refutation. Resolution refutation has the capability to
solve all first-order logic reasoning problems by extending reasoning rules and
employing the principle of proof by contradiction, so our system's completeness
can be improved by introducing resolution refutation. Experimental results
demonstrate that our system outperforms previous works by achieving
state-of-the-art performances in complex scenarios while maintaining
performances in simple scenarios. Besides, we observe that GFaiR is faithful to
its reasoning process.
|
[
-0.22831620275974274,
-0.7154380679130554,
0.9240531325340271,
-0.1896987408399582,
-0.2525242567062378,
0.11828051507472992,
-0.3301957845687866,
-0.455046147108078,
-0.0005991742364130914,
0.6362046003341675,
-0.6151618361473083,
-0.1751052886247635,
-0.4603082835674286,
0.21134060621261597,
-0.26811572909355164,
0.6913906335830688,
-0.14809730648994446,
-0.11018054187297821,
-0.415932834148407,
-0.4482249319553375,
-0.3157695531845093,
-0.6131749749183655,
-0.5122051239013672,
-0.7179811596870422,
0.29778656363487244,
0.30979034304618835,
0.8419457674026489,
0.6175833940505981,
0.510787844657898,
0.4246530830860138,
0.05318759009242058,
0.36250606179237366,
-0.45432496070861816,
0.17367978394031525,
-0.8111369609832764,
-0.3485149145126343,
-0.06445832550525665,
-0.19320493936538696,
0.6262707114219666,
0.6365898251533508,
-0.3236558139324188,
-0.11287294328212738,
-0.07345281541347504,
1.1036350727081299,
-0.5831126570701599,
-0.05431225150823593,
-0.8440035581588745,
-0.2360541671514511,
0.10532212257385254,
0.0011954905930906534,
-0.5524119138717651,
-0.37437182664871216,
-0.057815805077552795,
-0.746566653251648,
0.7195266485214233,
0.07560479640960693,
1.1639429330825806,
0.369994193315506,
-0.3486359119415283,
-0.3274323642253876,
-1.164941668510437,
0.876518189907074,
-0.678381621837616,
0.5456047058105469,
0.08545615524053574,
0.7415807247161865,
-0.6797835826873779,
-0.7740391492843628,
-0.6084702610969543,
-0.3385176956653595,
-0.4302257299423218,
-0.24895653128623962,
-0.3763964772224426,
0.21873243153095245,
0.3002730906009674,
0.6889233589172363,
-0.3892543911933899,
-0.44179099798202515,
0.09907422214746475,
-0.4035184383392334,
0.36152443289756775,
0.10716621577739716,
-0.02580508030951023,
0.34425413608551025,
-0.1643144190311432,
0.41733911633491516,
-0.4619400203227997,
0.03378542512655258,
0.02306181937456131,
0.12354918569326401,
0.3215271234512329,
0.34464094042778015,
-0.5457327961921692,
0.9628995656967163,
0.22205132246017456,
-0.2542870044708252,
0.002668105997145176,
-0.4924319386482239,
-0.44420647621154785,
-0.3471304178237915,
0.5324193239212036,
0.04279465228319168,
0.3746744990348816,
-0.44474998116493225,
-0.23903365433216095,
0.2707534730434418,
0.15229731798171997,
-0.6204168200492859,
0.09084897488355637,
0.27187544107437134,
-0.2325703501701355,
0.1603529155254364,
0.06554688513278961,
-0.4776298701763153,
-0.19205740094184875,
-0.6254176497459412,
0.3278612196445465,
-0.5116945505142212,
-0.04678692668676376,
0.4142917990684509,
0.23393398523330688,
0.2144477814435959,
0.6305528283119202,
-0.8338281512260437,
0.6673955321311951,
1.0257147550582886,
0.4358573257923126,
0.5321642160415649,
0.05296222120523453,
-0.9184173345565796,
0.45853787660598755,
-0.3697819411754608,
0.6429771184921265,
-0.8016018271446228,
0.006660711020231247,
-0.15671628713607788,
-0.08630074560642242,
0.13591687381267548,
-0.7021169662475586,
0.8491519689559937,
-0.5742000937461853,
0.2513587772846222,
-0.36589497327804565,
-0.525826096534729,
-0.34897419810295105,
0.41096261143684387,
-0.5443161129951477,
0.5019943714141846,
-0.10963039100170135,
-0.5988209247589111,
0.03534737974405289,
-0.37502580881118774,
-0.29459676146507263,
-0.18908096849918365,
-0.43258965015411377,
-0.04176076501607895,
0.26342758536338806,
0.2213205099105835,
0.048424672335386276,
-0.6700626015663147,
0.6985622644424438,
-0.021990498527884483,
-0.5608436465263367,
-0.12466409057378769,
-0.3635677099227905,
0.3711448013782501,
0.29121023416519165,
-0.19381727278232574,
0.1744653880596161,
-0.7978696227073669,
0.09160557389259338,
0.16886436939239502,
-0.45580777525901794,
-0.301118403673172,
0.22573675215244293,
-0.6227961182594299,
0.04176972433924675,
0.16458602249622345,
-0.7567982077598572,
0.2685943841934204,
-0.7475360035896301,
0.35431089997291565,
0.7425121068954468,
-0.19828183948993683,
0.4782828986644745,
-0.4486987292766571,
0.16576115787029266,
-0.0834466889500618,
0.0613945797085762,
-0.17197605967521667,
-0.42389652132987976,
-0.8897606730461121,
-0.4998636841773987,
0.31063780188560486,
0.6204566955566406,
-0.7030223608016968,
0.22070355713367462,
-0.3267507553100586,
-0.17795611917972565,
-0.563043475151062,
0.3731519281864166,
0.4360446631908417,
0.7548174858093262,
0.6189162731170654,
0.241659477353096,
-0.5468405485153198,
-1.2040212154388428,
-0.5130295157432556,
-0.2800547480583191,
-0.3863794505596161,
0.0329381488263607,
0.3523273468017578,
-0.47295358777046204,
1.2657912969589233,
-0.2164788693189621,
-0.3684951066970825,
-0.19362741708755493,
-0.10927233099937439,
0.6044405698776245,
0.32085099816322327,
0.2385001927614212,
-0.7595421671867371,
0.07383153587579727,
-0.06662225723266602,
-0.7040112614631653,
-0.040010400116443634,
-0.05853566527366638,
-0.2290254533290863,
0.45910176634788513,
0.25493788719177246,
-0.5585086345672607,
0.5386446118354797,
0.3566913902759552,
-0.3870736360549927,
0.5970949530601501,
-0.2706434726715088,
0.11892138421535492,
-0.7624868750572205,
0.13140538334846497,
0.07252160459756851,
-0.4165876805782318,
-0.7899289727210999,
0.20482243597507477,
-0.2633105218410492,
0.25452810525894165,
-0.003327192272990942,
0.689538836479187,
-0.23113171756267548,
0.38033604621887207,
-0.32840991020202637,
0.024219287559390068,
0.3796052932739258,
0.2793438136577606,
-0.05238555744290352,
0.33600232005119324,
0.13201434910297394,
-0.6333989500999451,
0.5352101922035217,
0.04248823598027229,
0.029002903029322624,
0.505954921245575,
-0.7283728122711182,
0.20610617101192474,
-0.39764055609703064,
0.36308351159095764,
-1.133268117904663,
-0.11303967237472534,
0.5768861770629883,
-0.48228204250335693,
0.2542605996131897,
-0.19479580223560333,
-0.36966627836227417,
-0.2243964523077011,
0.0376155711710453,
0.41717109084129333,
0.29386651515960693,
-0.6475289463996887,
1.1542118787765503,
-0.26939475536346436,
0.06997493654489517,
-0.6110220551490784,
-0.6078672409057617,
-0.00813538208603859,
0.25239062309265137,
-0.7340055108070374,
0.5759157538414001,
-0.14572890102863312,
-0.6771600246429443,
0.2417127937078476,
-0.3738251030445099,
-0.0012857154943048954,
-0.10297103226184845,
0.018124127760529518,
0.22406169772148132,
-0.23709718883037567,
0.2606865465641022,
-0.22919149696826935,
-0.35956335067749023,
0.08433372527360916,
-0.10511841624975204,
0.37095633149147034,
-0.6262338161468506,
-0.6160292029380798,
-0.36108943819999695,
0.637642502784729,
0.3758047819137573,
-0.25967222452163696,
0.4725170433521271,
0.11649202555418015,
-0.6973220109939575,
0.12400733679533005,
-1.155775785446167,
-0.18955601751804352,
-0.5028681755065918,
-0.0060549103654921055,
-0.47886648774147034,
-1.2885664701461792,
0.531592845916748,
-0.09335777163505554,
0.2639346420764923,
0.42817509174346924,
0.21715708076953888,
0.2304956167936325,
0.7990833520889282,
0.5311086773872375,
-0.17872504889965057,
-0.14914987981319427,
0.26370102167129517,
0.32252949476242065,
-0.4972369074821472,
-0.13143035769462585,
-0.7812068462371826,
-0.10451074689626694,
-0.2697368264198303,
-0.33816418051719666,
-0.3186458349227905,
0.4206382632255554,
-0.4997660517692566,
-0.23619674146175385,
-0.45938611030578613,
0.8044957518577576,
0.42566153407096863,
-0.08888977020978928,
0.7707118391990662,
0.1730642318725586,
-0.6053406596183777,
-0.07672321796417236,
-0.23155313730239868,
-0.7396876811981201,
0.46382418274879456,
0.30498242378234863,
0.3852585256099701,
0.4849976897239685,
0.8238358497619629,
0.17791630327701569,
0.5004460215568542,
-0.7180120944976807,
0.6523270606994629,
-0.21363140642642975,
-0.597032904624939,
-0.16411229968070984,
-0.7476164102554321,
-0.6344683170318604,
0.42026153206825256,
0.10521968454122543,
-0.9267947673797607,
-0.004105039872229099,
0.11122164875268936,
-0.2039012759923935,
0.3938685953617096,
-0.5182597637176514,
0.48663732409477234,
0.08903129398822784,
-0.5346075892448425,
-0.1915176808834076,
-0.47469085454940796,
0.6215724349021912,
0.01826346665620804,
0.5656898021697998,
-0.16806632280349731,
0.05027816817164421,
0.444552481174469,
-0.8798176646232605,
0.519048273563385,
-0.3327471911907196,
-0.08902762830257416,
0.15902654826641083,
0.33923831582069397,
0.7064605355262756,
0.16480576992034912,
-0.234834223985672,
-0.06809480488300323,
-0.27477824687957764,
-0.4738413095474243,
-0.9916835427284241,
0.781858503818512,
-0.21564657986164093,
-1.2688308954238892,
-0.5502724647521973,
-0.2974033057689667,
-0.5575951337814331,
0.24346180260181427,
0.014715427532792091,
0.27331840991973877,
0.005029583349823952,
-0.18223905563354492,
0.7329248785972595,
0.04290774092078209,
0.14742954075336456,
0.7539742588996887,
-0.6271123290061951,
-0.7494761943817139,
0.6644189357757568,
0.02689465694129467,
0.2258174866437912,
0.3996218740940094,
0.24024029076099396,
-0.2588224709033966,
-0.31087371706962585,
-0.315093070268631,
0.5319646000862122,
-0.7592079043388367,
-0.35068827867507935,
-0.1330641508102417,
-0.3495892286300659,
-0.0472395233809948,
-0.2619708180427551,
-0.2839934527873993,
-0.18518158793449402,
-0.0028227476868778467,
0.10912391543388367,
0.21417821943759918,
0.3909602165222168,
-0.1295424997806549,
-0.2580767869949341,
-0.7385530471801758,
0.9918484091758728,
0.609216570854187,
0.5648647546768188,
-0.07968644797801971,
-0.640515923500061,
0.2244243174791336,
0.30582091212272644,
-0.13186050951480865,
-0.4949837923049927,
-0.11594517529010773,
0.2761428952217102,
0.8628021478652954,
0.34185782074928284,
0.17255955934524536,
0.8458200097084045,
-0.5438925623893738,
0.44243383407592773,
0.2894693911075592,
-1.0192760229110718,
0.7009077668190002,
-0.2742437422275543,
0.3348676264286041,
0.7048473954200745,
0.10133085399866104,
-0.5345059037208557,
-0.4191586673259735,
-0.500586211681366,
-0.8508011102676392,
0.36480507254600525,
0.2310938835144043,
0.039171140640974045,
-0.10157432407140732,
0.7009334564208984,
0.09293868392705917,
0.03890258073806763,
-0.4349820017814636,
-0.20795927941799164,
-0.1599481999874115,
-0.13019207119941711,
-0.018640365451574326,
-0.3087470829486847,
-0.1478864848613739,
-0.5221202373504639,
0.8876532316207886,
-0.21143518388271332,
0.3594968318939209,
0.5639693140983582,
0.04882330819964409,
-0.14720766246318817,
0.653617799282074,
0.6306183338165283,
0.8207318186759949,
-0.27706021070480347,
0.21562731266021729,
-0.2287425398826599,
-0.24789369106292725,
0.5760142207145691,
0.24228540062904358,
-0.32016509771347046,
0.04228832945227623,
0.31887540221214294,
0.14496459066867828,
-0.017847580835223198,
-0.5470953583717346,
0.34949564933776855,
-0.26183393597602844,
-0.3421076536178589,
-0.1219867542386055,
0.05019300431013107,
0.193220853805542,
0.2901454269886017,
0.707074761390686,
0.32638436555862427,
-0.012869208119809628,
-0.505967378616333,
0.34009483456611633,
0.3637080490589142,
-0.2785026729106903,
0.0469602532684803,
0.680303692817688,
-0.012242121621966362,
-0.177888423204422,
0.8294991850852966,
-0.3715653419494629,
-0.4269257187843323,
0.2525297701358795,
0.5996960401535034,
0.7064996957778931,
-0.10550593584775925,
0.2361936718225479,
0.3038790822029114,
0.4591961205005646,
-0.22364580631256104,
0.30230048298835754,
0.20535555481910706,
-1.069658637046814,
-0.8495039343833923,
-0.7458370327949524,
-0.5357732176780701,
0.2921126186847687,
-0.3995440900325775,
-0.2334141731262207,
-0.9497789740562439,
0.012207618914544582,
-0.1752747893333435,
-0.03730178624391556,
-0.48417821526527405,
0.1889684945344925,
0.03093988448381424,
1.0499792098999023,
-0.3821185529232025,
0.8404812216758728,
0.7295264601707458,
-0.26807689666748047,
-0.738484799861908,
0.03404057398438454,
0.09958137571811676,
-0.343808114528656,
0.41151759028434753,
0.40804627537727356,
-0.5340183973312378,
-0.18621528148651123,
-0.6545032262802124,
-0.551654577255249,
0.8631139993667603,
0.9249238967895508,
-0.7183824181556702,
0.23260775208473206,
0.3418632745742798,
0.5848987102508545,
-0.2865091860294342,
-0.041130565106868744,
0.675464391708374,
0.5940139293670654,
0.5357277989387512,
-0.7850944399833679,
0.4811422824859619,
-0.3703523576259613,
0.061413154006004333,
0.18602904677391052,
-0.6156061887741089,
0.4558846056461334,
-0.4131227433681488,
-0.17385171353816986,
0.28328680992126465,
0.9600114822387695,
0.5971335768699646,
0.3329927623271942,
0.41725221276283264,
0.8981325030326843,
1.033799648284912,
-0.36227723956108093,
0.760699987411499,
0.35318949818611145,
0.18556547164916992,
1.363802433013916,
-0.380481094121933,
0.7198836803436279,
0.7284350991249084,
-0.12725214660167694,
0.7139055728912354,
0.10628078132867813,
0.20699630677700043,
0.45671403408050537,
0.49559882283210754,
-0.5997262001037598,
-0.7537292242050171,
-0.23328125476837158,
-0.3802630603313446,
0.020086582750082016,
0.1564568281173706,
-0.17230042815208435,
-0.5360010862350464,
-0.27987140417099,
0.01340449322015047,
0.5256325006484985,
-0.4651931822299957,
0.5491229891777039,
-0.10854892432689667,
-0.5264794826507568,
0.9274432063102722,
0.22701449692249298,
0.4525624215602875,
-0.6561424136161804,
-0.39529240131378174,
-0.471289724111557,
0.43036702275276184,
-0.32042500376701355,
-0.45269545912742615,
0.5538392066955566,
-0.11584386229515076,
-0.5335987210273743,
0.10009267181158066,
0.9390018582344055,
-0.06791483610868454,
-0.611553430557251,
0.39154475927352905,
0.24619260430335999,
-0.3048739731311798,
-0.22567389905452728,
-0.46379682421684265,
-0.04650707170367241,
0.1881563514471054,
-0.2452346384525299,
0.2081347554922104,
0.5938020944595337,
0.08565034717321396,
1.0073916912078857,
0.5827192664146423,
-0.1929871141910553,
-0.1877339482307434,
0.07472186535596848,
1.1314972639083862,
-0.748196542263031,
-0.00810729619115591,
-1.0124903917312622,
0.5152124762535095,
0.019016291946172714,
0.21162638068199158,
0.1650395542383194,
0.4906822144985199,
0.6094949245452881,
0.014095720835030079,
0.6934167742729187,
0.10773107409477234,
0.6140576004981995,
-0.5377501845359802,
0.1217648983001709,
-0.4074593186378479,
0.5144224762916565,
-0.21989956498146057,
-0.7745840549468994,
-0.6072819232940674,
0.614658772945404,
-0.36177122592926025,
-0.09489892423152924,
0.5633623003959656,
0.7995384931564331,
-0.024785712361335754,
0.15526314079761505,
0.3526991307735443,
0.3202798366546631,
0.513201892375946,
0.8486548066139221,
0.716780960559845,
-0.46072179079055786,
0.5323924422264099,
-0.12768596410751343,
-0.2620454728603363,
-0.052834007889032364,
-0.9865063428878784,
-0.4705936312675476,
-0.25388994812965393,
-0.21153810620307922,
-0.3689003586769104,
0.28014418482780457,
0.8880021572113037,
0.0954580157995224,
-0.9097570180892944,
0.1961592584848404,
-0.2537194490432739,
0.4676740765571594,
-0.15631069242954254,
-0.23613855242729187,
-0.006772138644009829,
-0.47751912474632263,
-0.24440565705299377,
0.4550442397594452,
0.23128768801689148,
-0.26354971528053284,
0.05645051971077919,
-0.31939366459846497,
-0.38870176672935486,
0.2951211929321289,
0.3354216516017914,
0.5281370878219604,
-1.1283377408981323,
-0.8946560621261597,
-0.26829418540000916,
0.1028393805027008,
0.13639849424362183,
0.4990993142127991,
-1.1610710620880127,
0.2147931009531021,
0.34389030933380127,
0.6371000409126282,
-0.008424780331552029,
0.2857162654399872,
0.5312052369117737,
-0.5390194058418274,
-0.06343956291675568,
0.07961732149124146,
0.47581443190574646,
0.25953149795532227,
-0.15132224559783936,
0.699692964553833,
0.4379071891307831,
-0.5673022270202637,
-0.552082359790802,
0.6018880009651184,
-0.8603907823562622,
-0.15418432652950287,
1.005595088005066,
-0.21200302243232727,
-0.07731115072965622,
-0.31394779682159424,
-0.23434560000896454,
0.08130298554897308,
-0.35565146803855896,
0.4811914563179016,
0.9151231050491333,
-0.15032486617565155,
-0.0006821476272307336,
-0.25318625569343567,
0.25269266963005066,
0.4005410969257355,
-0.34114396572113037,
0.32934054732322693,
0.8437203168869019,
0.5594266057014465,
0.44635865092277527,
0.7588291764259338,
-0.25420141220092773,
0.16930405795574188,
-0.43803539872169495,
-0.16887521743774414,
-0.3126111328601837,
-0.34787583351135254,
-0.2077283412218094,
0.4226897060871124,
0.22389410436153412,
0.09865390509366989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01667v1
|
METAL: Towards Multilingual Meta-Evaluation
| 2024-04-02T06:14:54 | 2024-04-02T06:14:54 |
Rishav Hada, Varun Gumma, Mohamed Ahmed, Kalika Bali, Sunayana Sitaram
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rising human-like precision of Large Language Models (LLMs) in
numerous tasks, their utilization in a variety of real-world applications is
becoming more prevalent. Several studies have shown that LLMs excel on many
standard NLP benchmarks. However, it is challenging to evaluate LLMs due to
test dataset contamination and the limitations of traditional metrics. Since
human evaluations are difficult to collect, there is a growing interest in the
community to use LLMs themselves as reference-free evaluators for subjective
metrics. However, past work has shown that LLM-based evaluators can exhibit
bias and have poor alignment with human judgments. In this study, we propose a
framework for an end-to-end assessment of LLMs as evaluators in multilingual
scenarios. We create a carefully curated dataset, covering 10 languages
containing native speaker judgments for the task of summarization. This dataset
is created specifically to evaluate LLM-based evaluators, which we refer to as
meta-evaluation (METAL). We compare the performance of LLM-based evaluators
created using GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and PaLM2. Our results indicate that
LLM-based evaluators based on GPT-4 perform the best across languages, while
GPT-3.5-Turbo performs poorly. Additionally, we perform an analysis of the
reasoning provided by LLM-based evaluators and find that it often does not
match the reasoning provided by human judges.
|
[
-0.4434279799461365,
-0.34372198581695557,
0.6432496309280396,
0.058401186019182205,
-0.1057889461517334,
0.18803119659423828,
-0.5332870483398438,
-0.18793277442455292,
0.19473370909690857,
0.15131191909313202,
-0.4784948229789734,
-0.5797203779220581,
-0.5363877415657043,
0.6103854775428772,
-0.060406312346458435,
1.1982383728027344,
-0.2583904564380646,
0.1515081375837326,
-0.406904935836792,
-0.33281585574150085,
-0.42534223198890686,
-0.6193708181381226,
-0.13709084689617157,
-0.6270124316215515,
0.6649733185768127,
0.3878307640552521,
0.7861198782920837,
0.2493523508310318,
0.6793831586837769,
0.311348021030426,
0.0010610067984089255,
0.26176655292510986,
-0.01472201757133007,
-0.21290715038776398,
-0.5433018803596497,
-0.4298644959926605,
-0.6432149410247803,
0.09269389510154724,
0.43051502108573914,
0.7784178853034973,
-0.046993188560009,
0.5439092516899109,
-0.02544519677758217,
0.7148778438568115,
-0.829647421836853,
0.02168862149119377,
-0.46760690212249756,
0.19751393795013428,
-0.20970205962657928,
-0.23925404250621796,
-0.40046530961990356,
-0.37626323103904724,
-0.07855375111103058,
-0.294529527425766,
-0.010495489463210106,
-0.17123591899871826,
0.6505354046821594,
0.3336086571216583,
-0.4659891128540039,
-0.25820523500442505,
-0.6749099493026733,
0.7501508593559265,
-0.8687177300453186,
0.3071434497833252,
0.31477171182632446,
0.4185764789581299,
0.07690434902906418,
-0.4366587996482849,
-0.4773513078689575,
0.02152281068265438,
-0.06973322480916977,
0.4468161463737488,
-0.02638210728764534,
-0.06891369819641113,
-0.000010078336345031857,
0.35864484310150146,
-0.8419454097747803,
-0.03991403803229332,
-0.22305898368358612,
-0.28758704662323,
0.5451518893241882,
0.1997329294681549,
0.30321335792541504,
-0.4336308538913727,
-0.24034377932548523,
0.1901550590991974,
-0.4649878740310669,
-0.32088640332221985,
0.4940224587917328,
0.5246742963790894,
-0.21101509034633636,
0.6099257469177246,
-0.03174009174108505,
0.7536382675170898,
-0.010667980648577213,
-0.21042783558368683,
0.6181879043579102,
-0.549989640712738,
-0.1193818598985672,
-0.23193126916885376,
1.056356430053711,
0.7363495826721191,
0.4417058229446411,
-0.4430055022239685,
-0.08663240075111389,
0.2787422239780426,
-0.0920448750257492,
-0.7088190913200378,
0.32777658104896545,
0.37178677320480347,
-0.48098063468933105,
-0.03279021009802818,
0.23522037267684937,
-0.7532738447189331,
-0.25230318307876587,
-0.4241768717765808,
0.30769509077072144,
0.020149312913417816,
-0.4101457893848419,
0.3054562211036682,
0.08190794289112091,
0.09070402383804321,
-0.06483911722898483,
-0.7910237908363342,
0.3854394257068634,
0.7396014928817749,
0.8974247574806213,
-0.17938806116580963,
-0.507180392742157,
-0.6530529260635376,
0.04690995439887047,
-0.24526230990886688,
0.7680491805076599,
-0.3988364338874817,
-0.21200057864189148,
-0.12665599584579468,
0.020995261147618294,
-0.0977177545428276,
-0.5305103063583374,
0.9294110536575317,
-0.4136562645435333,
0.47686684131622314,
-0.4614252746105194,
-0.15078839659690857,
-0.35633721947669983,
0.41788095235824585,
-0.7075066566467285,
0.7445235252380371,
0.17853787541389465,
-0.9498746991157532,
0.5040637254714966,
-0.7250508666038513,
-0.4827801287174225,
-0.13221663236618042,
-0.07302431017160416,
-0.18689362704753876,
0.14395365118980408,
0.2918865978717804,
0.39933711290359497,
-0.44161516427993774,
0.4474024474620819,
-0.5405535101890564,
-0.6341940760612488,
0.23867559432983398,
-0.5848231315612793,
0.534018337726593,
0.28289011120796204,
-0.3620622456073761,
0.20365957915782928,
-0.6513498425483704,
0.016530390828847885,
-0.3828008770942688,
-0.4119683802127838,
-0.16602306067943573,
0.021915236487984657,
0.15283600986003876,
0.5694989562034607,
0.20335222780704498,
-0.48052865266799927,
-0.050379429012537,
-0.5333467721939087,
0.23117583990097046,
0.7632699608802795,
-0.35298675298690796,
0.2622121274471283,
-0.3126978576183319,
0.7056276202201843,
-0.34611016511917114,
-0.03633534908294678,
-0.05488021299242973,
0.014397650957107544,
-0.5282630324363708,
-0.09249458461999893,
0.687703549861908,
0.8757653832435608,
-0.609225869178772,
0.43211764097213745,
-0.6187151670455933,
-0.3459899425506592,
-0.5590457916259766,
0.44979438185691833,
0.4171430468559265,
0.21935658156871796,
0.06139104813337326,
-0.19065377116203308,
-0.5108528733253479,
-1.0014910697937012,
-0.49251416325569153,
-0.06797410547733307,
-0.15901172161102295,
0.190486878156662,
0.5270496606826782,
-0.3679763078689575,
1.1054948568344116,
-0.10420064628124237,
-0.19693049788475037,
-0.44430243968963623,
0.16510611772537231,
0.6426830291748047,
-0.08187323808670044,
0.3677383363246918,
-0.5636554956436157,
-0.690373420715332,
0.24829445779323578,
-0.9276933073997498,
-0.5658109188079834,
-0.0233527310192585,
0.13715393841266632,
0.12919451296329498,
0.2755674123764038,
-0.5265336036682129,
-0.020505663007497787,
0.6868278384208679,
-0.3088141083717346,
0.7179647088050842,
-0.10324086993932724,
0.17954576015472412,
-1.087997555732727,
0.48241522908210754,
-0.024197060614824295,
-0.4631650149822235,
-0.3618455231189728,
0.17557691037654877,
0.06553909927606583,
0.012297019362449646,
-0.5702366828918457,
0.6899718642234802,
-0.4574558734893799,
-0.42274922132492065,
-0.47717300057411194,
0.4861484169960022,
0.0627591609954834,
0.5526009202003479,
-0.05930738151073456,
0.8576896786689758,
0.14943799376487732,
-0.4772816300392151,
0.3796657919883728,
0.03855039179325104,
-0.4010624885559082,
0.7358748912811279,
-0.5710165500640869,
0.10539387166500092,
-0.20309540629386902,
0.2895021438598633,
-0.8265762329101562,
-0.10479482263326645,
0.19829161465168,
-0.35574647784233093,
0.1682528555393219,
0.030116498470306396,
-0.8078176379203796,
-0.26235613226890564,
-0.5025748014450073,
0.45245376229286194,
-0.11315376311540604,
-0.33112266659736633,
0.9044756293296814,
0.18603567779064178,
-0.34641093015670776,
-0.8405493497848511,
-0.7580995559692383,
0.41741862893104553,
-0.4436519742012024,
-0.6333922147750854,
0.197015643119812,
-0.3194439709186554,
-0.5506449341773987,
-0.14119049906730652,
-0.08201854676008224,
0.21208977699279785,
0.18935120105743408,
-0.0021174969151616096,
0.14308913052082062,
0.18711373209953308,
0.09157773852348328,
-0.11389579623937607,
-0.41822659969329834,
0.017240002751350403,
0.006785196252167225,
0.6207451820373535,
-0.4654492437839508,
-0.6556511521339417,
-0.3371451497077942,
0.21942082047462463,
0.7311754822731018,
-0.4280768036842346,
0.22753775119781494,
0.8150553107261658,
-0.058826882392168045,
0.17551752924919128,
-0.5789639353752136,
0.1523967683315277,
-0.41791483759880066,
0.4227445721626282,
-0.5634986162185669,
-0.5614020228385925,
0.7270154356956482,
-0.09873848408460617,
0.43114936351776123,
0.6020546555519104,
0.8310962915420532,
-0.01129064243286848,
0.852377712726593,
0.31323879957199097,
-0.2265244722366333,
0.07864764332771301,
-0.0472235232591629,
-0.01311956811696291,
-1.1282130479812622,
0.13466612994670868,
-0.24367065727710724,
-0.45589667558670044,
-0.36728358268737793,
-0.28562361001968384,
0.5265888571739197,
-0.2221062034368515,
-0.003338690148666501,
0.22850750386714935,
-0.02845623716711998,
0.6054103374481201,
0.025545109063386917,
-0.025150993838906288,
0.39551493525505066,
-0.2759672999382019,
-0.34990978240966797,
-0.07083426415920258,
-0.5721448659896851,
-0.7499884366989136,
1.3330793380737305,
0.3796868920326233,
0.6519478559494019,
0.3795538544654846,
0.4366895854473114,
0.329693466424942,
0.5218176245689392,
-0.7788782119750977,
0.3751545250415802,
-0.3267936110496521,
-0.709482729434967,
-0.12087970227003098,
-0.5815718173980713,
-0.6684116125106812,
0.7086111903190613,
0.0964856892824173,
-0.4669487476348877,
-0.10301121324300766,
-0.3146238327026367,
-0.4798259139060974,
0.3257029056549072,
-0.5546582937240601,
0.8619290590286255,
-0.5732665657997131,
-0.42029666900634766,
0.02210223861038685,
-0.7206798791885376,
0.5335074067115784,
-0.3363795280456543,
0.8149212598800659,
-0.1930621862411499,
-0.026246558874845505,
0.5904442071914673,
-0.26754891872406006,
0.804872989654541,
-0.06544338166713715,
-0.3429681062698364,
0.1294187605381012,
0.09237661212682724,
0.2731597423553467,
-0.12153063714504242,
-0.457974374294281,
0.10990220308303833,
-0.020357202738523483,
-0.08748392760753632,
-0.7422274947166443,
0.33704879879951477,
-0.5482103824615479,
-0.2916049659252167,
-0.4862160384654999,
-0.575486421585083,
-0.35012975335121155,
0.0959462970495224,
0.14555765688419342,
0.4272116720676422,
-0.14438673853874207,
0.039033323526382446,
0.06326696276664734,
-0.2877773344516754,
0.6257831454277039,
0.7306151986122131,
-0.39253127574920654,
-0.7289472222328186,
1.0201103687286377,
-0.00983412191271782,
0.36122646927833557,
0.418412983417511,
0.41951435804367065,
-0.40399980545043945,
-0.2770175337791443,
-0.7065476775169373,
0.35715335607528687,
-0.8131720423698425,
-0.18334108591079712,
-0.4492555260658264,
0.2115478813648224,
-0.11335881799459457,
0.04233063384890556,
-0.17727701365947723,
-0.3915257453918457,
-0.06541337817907333,
-0.31532615423202515,
-0.20728132128715515,
0.4617514908313751,
-0.3504765033721924,
0.2852950990200043,
-0.7552652955055237,
0.2500794231891632,
0.10305597633123398,
0.46893829107284546,
-0.17175941169261932,
-0.5857973694801331,
-0.45625850558280945,
-0.07184574753046036,
-0.27409493923187256,
-0.6830149292945862,
0.16432344913482666,
0.24533239006996155,
0.5735571384429932,
0.4218071699142456,
-0.12222493439912796,
0.7369687557220459,
-0.603967010974884,
0.6621299386024475,
0.12828890979290009,
-1.1428126096725464,
0.1811865121126175,
-0.42143136262893677,
0.5390868782997131,
0.9993973970413208,
0.114310123026371,
-0.8125527501106262,
-0.31804293394088745,
-0.2372029572725296,
-0.8026541471481323,
0.5621516108512878,
-0.16231657564640045,
0.0941072478890419,
0.1002703532576561,
0.21916818618774414,
0.2341601699590683,
0.32172685861587524,
-1.0422567129135132,
-0.16121046245098114,
-0.07364363968372345,
-0.20182715356349945,
-0.2747047543525696,
-0.24380135536193848,
-0.14993944764137268,
-0.027220679447054863,
0.5854088068008423,
-0.3352905213832855,
-0.07670567184686661,
0.0015668397536501288,
-0.4318433701992035,
0.030109044164419174,
0.6172532439231873,
0.7748262286186218,
1.0101535320281982,
-0.33270683884620667,
0.196773499250412,
0.4416436553001404,
-0.029095623642206192,
0.18083332479000092,
-0.15934482216835022,
-0.09777510166168213,
0.303022563457489,
0.6223806142807007,
0.48921194672584534,
0.4382513463497162,
-0.7301278114318848,
0.6819111704826355,
-0.08031603693962097,
-0.2711511254310608,
-0.32468393445014954,
-0.39807090163230896,
0.13554221391677856,
-0.005299312062561512,
0.11428391188383102,
-0.052529528737068176,
0.2587320804595947,
-0.6785022020339966,
0.33112356066703796,
0.5779391527175903,
-0.24048955738544464,
-0.5437608957290649,
0.49288856983184814,
0.46422359347343445,
-0.11050549149513245,
0.25302854180336,
-0.3657795786857605,
-0.7615756392478943,
0.18287751078605652,
0.3918364346027374,
1.12350332736969,
-0.29463595151901245,
0.12737569212913513,
0.3261508345603943,
0.5044258832931519,
0.1309054046869278,
0.35528382658958435,
-0.06772197037935257,
-0.6859928369522095,
-0.953900158405304,
-0.6635962128639221,
-0.520500659942627,
-0.015098960138857365,
-0.4883456230163574,
0.46781468391418457,
-0.16731806099414825,
-0.42479291558265686,
-0.417071670293808,
0.08516037464141846,
-0.4464018642902374,
-0.05953659862279892,
0.17346079647541046,
0.808890163898468,
-1.0052512884140015,
0.2818945050239563,
0.4788186252117157,
-0.2564179301261902,
-0.3473512828350067,
-0.032007310539484024,
0.13321244716644287,
-0.3146250247955322,
0.7053945064544678,
0.22696742415428162,
-0.26087939739227295,
-0.5592641234397888,
0.2695696949958801,
-0.7569742798805237,
0.9142059683799744,
0.6073010563850403,
-0.413342148065567,
-0.15667389333248138,
0.3405267298221588,
0.4894126057624817,
-0.11106383800506592,
0.8743018507957458,
0.5511001348495483,
0.9311227798461914,
-0.13496997952461243,
-1.3990042209625244,
-0.1465243399143219,
-0.3524574041366577,
-0.37193620204925537,
0.094426728785038,
-0.7976294755935669,
0.7695450186729431,
-0.053393036127090454,
-0.3970675468444824,
-0.19713681936264038,
0.4338971972465515,
0.21359653770923615,
0.25777578353881836,
0.5097593069076538,
0.6044663786888123,
0.6081790924072266,
0.016560334712266922,
1.0190755128860474,
-0.4700181186199188,
0.369692862033844,
1.2095998525619507,
-0.5712177753448486,
0.7539693117141724,
0.3295825719833374,
-0.4564707577228546,
0.6105347871780396,
0.709955632686615,
-0.036469604820013046,
0.29366058111190796,
0.3216796815395355,
-0.22533096373081207,
-0.2500195801258087,
0.00843359250575304,
-0.15961392223834991,
0.6338834166526794,
-0.027172012254595757,
-0.19023579359054565,
-0.6552730202674866,
-0.038015175610780716,
0.13768967986106873,
0.1716436743736267,
-0.16811597347259521,
0.7056045532226562,
0.10056769102811813,
-0.4864480197429657,
0.382657527923584,
0.4523993730545044,
0.9341958165168762,
-0.5680165886878967,
0.28073886036872864,
-0.07183212041854858,
0.11464005708694458,
-0.6104190945625305,
-0.5417176485061646,
0.6258957386016846,
0.2990976870059967,
-0.3220013678073883,
-0.16059741377830505,
0.35586264729499817,
-0.43887898325920105,
-0.7468171715736389,
0.3918626606464386,
0.722978413105011,
0.48487210273742676,
-0.11755330860614777,
-0.5990334749221802,
0.08429013937711716,
-0.13266052305698395,
-0.15713971853256226,
0.21274709701538086,
0.21034473180770874,
-0.026097683236002922,
0.7213863730430603,
0.6491063237190247,
0.21453826129436493,
-0.2774263322353363,
0.4740314185619354,
0.35437285900115967,
-0.5222579836845398,
-0.4024694859981537,
-1.295179009437561,
0.5065648555755615,
0.28372031450271606,
-0.058105193078517914,
0.8665387034416199,
1.0154337882995605,
0.6615363955497742,
0.018111689016222954,
0.9477432370185852,
0.0981808602809906,
0.6978513598442078,
-0.47364553809165955,
0.5934841632843018,
-0.6135927438735962,
0.3121829032897949,
-0.6024871468544006,
-1.1682580709457397,
-0.24804909527301788,
0.47973349690437317,
-0.2328832447528839,
0.23596763610839844,
0.6682518124580383,
0.4245542883872986,
-0.12983079254627228,
-0.17155106365680695,
0.3327639400959015,
-0.17842161655426025,
0.42210525274276733,
0.6683475375175476,
0.7844262719154358,
-0.4168247580528259,
0.543639600276947,
0.12956006824970245,
-0.3098330795764923,
0.015673089772462845,
-1.079992413520813,
-0.9505532383918762,
-0.2900489866733551,
0.008961892686784267,
0.109635129570961,
-0.3243800401687622,
1.055663824081421,
0.3977404832839966,
-0.5723604559898376,
-0.6411529779434204,
0.31210651993751526,
0.22305728495121002,
-0.22237853705883026,
-0.22604665160179138,
0.45224785804748535,
-0.347156286239624,
-0.9321415424346924,
0.42591118812561035,
0.27616623044013977,
-0.370822012424469,
-0.5590649843215942,
-0.09055501967668533,
-0.03175709769129753,
-0.15405629575252533,
0.8514073491096497,
-0.0816570594906807,
-0.8319445848464966,
-0.1480785459280014,
-0.06387209892272949,
0.16003429889678955,
-0.02700698748230934,
0.7130748629570007,
-0.6631248593330383,
0.3960087299346924,
0.44258126616477966,
0.621936023235321,
0.12135876715183258,
0.2366536259651184,
0.8430906534194946,
-0.6469601392745972,
-0.3123634159564972,
0.0717126727104187,
0.442314475774765,
0.5721753835678101,
-0.0031986692920327187,
0.7370561957359314,
0.10122261196374893,
-0.4576725959777832,
-0.972424328327179,
0.1927199363708496,
-0.749928891658783,
-0.18996965885162354,
1.323455572128296,
-0.00510852737352252,
-0.010282509960234165,
-0.06668664515018463,
0.015900082886219025,
0.11204112321138382,
-0.024333424866199493,
0.612547755241394,
1.2201465368270874,
-0.10555944591760635,
-0.007562997750937939,
-0.7218941450119019,
0.12219444662332535,
0.3962109386920929,
-0.9645859599113464,
0.3044418692588806,
0.2412296086549759,
0.5165470242500305,
0.449954092502594,
0.6186506748199463,
-0.3441261947154999,
0.2570440471172333,
-0.46580132842063904,
0.22312237322330475,
-0.18744748830795288,
-0.3595699667930603,
-0.5551674365997314,
0.1286143809556961,
-0.08224600553512573,
0.07842625677585602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01663v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01663v2
|
CMAT: A Multi-Agent Collaboration Tuning Framework for Enhancing Small Language Models
| 2024-04-02T06:07:35 | 2024-04-04T12:40:03 |
Xuechen Liang, Meiling Tao, Tianyu Shi, Yiting Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of
natural language processing, showcasing impressive performance across various
tasks.Despite the significant advancements in LLMs, their effective operation
still relies heavily on human input to accurately guide the dialogue flow, with
agent tuning being a crucial optimization technique that involves human
adjustments to the model for better response to such guidance.Addressing this
dependency, our work introduces the TinyAgent model, trained on a meticulously
curated high-quality dataset. We also present the Collaborative Multi-Agent
Tuning (CMAT) framework, an innovative system designed to augment language
agent capabilities through adaptive weight updates based on environmental
feedback. This framework fosters collaborative learning and real-time
adaptation among multiple intelligent agents, enhancing their context-awareness
and long-term memory. In this research, we propose a new communication agent
framework that integrates multi-agent systems with environmental feedback
mechanisms, offering a scalable method to explore cooperative behaviors.
Notably, our TinyAgent-7B model exhibits performance on par with GPT-3.5,
despite having fewer parameters, signifying a substantial improvement in the
efficiency and effectiveness of LLMs.
|
[
-0.5741065740585327,
-0.7943978309631348,
0.7165147662162781,
0.01386511791497469,
-0.21642915904521942,
0.3122785985469818,
-0.775013267993927,
-0.5118194222450256,
0.23039716482162476,
0.5326589941978455,
-0.7571056485176086,
-0.40951189398765564,
-0.406974732875824,
-0.01872120052576065,
0.3661501407623291,
0.7846251130104065,
0.4184759259223938,
0.12068968266248703,
-0.08176322281360626,
-0.5424556136131287,
-0.8092707395553589,
-0.18939457833766937,
-1.0319796800613403,
-0.49017465114593506,
0.5556756854057312,
0.9203389286994934,
1.0169093608856201,
0.6529994606971741,
0.5826529264450073,
0.5168871283531189,
0.1032378301024437,
0.542392909526825,
-0.5380063056945801,
0.10134321451187134,
-0.3482695519924164,
-0.39172059297561646,
-0.6970624923706055,
0.04926008731126785,
0.5214873552322388,
0.41068196296691895,
-0.2361687421798706,
0.1433531492948532,
0.10567110031843185,
0.49189749360084534,
-0.362021803855896,
0.44385820627212524,
-0.745147168636322,
-0.4968158006668091,
0.27295544743537903,
-0.21253909170627594,
-0.43548667430877686,
-0.1036953553557396,
-0.0005661550676450133,
-0.7075623273849487,
0.1455860733985901,
0.3269520699977875,
0.5123603940010071,
0.6189910173416138,
-0.324480801820755,
-0.3689248859882355,
-0.4538491368293762,
0.9186173677444458,
-0.4869191348552704,
0.08298291265964508,
0.2410154640674591,
0.3635651171207428,
-0.365943044424057,
-0.3663578927516937,
-0.423795223236084,
-0.4374643564224243,
-0.11333596706390381,
0.13405530154705048,
0.0016823061741888523,
0.2414446324110031,
-0.3468077778816223,
0.1673571765422821,
-0.37100839614868164,
0.25147897005081177,
0.18968911468982697,
-0.19224952161312103,
0.332314670085907,
0.380497545003891,
0.22488875687122345,
0.176288902759552,
-0.05712060257792473,
-0.1897561103105545,
-0.22393755614757538,
-0.126227006316185,
0.028106853365898132,
0.8046184778213501,
-0.4383465647697449,
0.30380427837371826,
-0.13477584719657898,
0.44135457277297974,
0.09856455773115158,
0.012637613341212273,
-0.04591219127178192,
-0.7080787420272827,
-0.04282967001199722,
-0.19675350189208984,
0.7038687467575073,
0.32514581084251404,
-0.005891268607228994,
-0.10081128776073456,
-0.15848968923091888,
0.3054230809211731,
0.05692673102021217,
-0.7200842499732971,
-0.2938642203807831,
-0.07150739431381226,
-0.2931928038597107,
-0.34262093901634216,
0.037300705909729004,
-0.7436908483505249,
-0.3476792871952057,
-0.5838608741760254,
0.4544267952442169,
-0.3073231875896454,
-0.36854347586631775,
0.0269035454839468,
0.05122601240873337,
-0.03574492782354355,
0.43872565031051636,
-0.7380181550979614,
0.5288413763046265,
0.8134526610374451,
0.903657078742981,
0.09322144836187363,
-0.586929976940155,
-0.9087512493133545,
0.11920440942049026,
-0.2693846821784973,
0.9796712398529053,
-0.8083570599555969,
-0.17590899765491486,
-0.439291387796402,
0.1446237862110138,
-0.30670881271362305,
-0.4771409332752228,
0.2834656238555908,
-0.37651655077934265,
0.04778800159692764,
-0.29783007502555847,
-0.34833768010139465,
0.1255342960357666,
0.32356590032577515,
-0.7057402729988098,
0.7548627257347107,
0.09844450652599335,
-0.31727832555770874,
0.15492810308933258,
-1.073536992073059,
0.013733030296862125,
0.07016196101903915,
-0.047531258314847946,
-0.47888779640197754,
0.057128917425870895,
0.29222962260246277,
0.11517740041017532,
-0.5319836139678955,
-0.142096608877182,
-0.4420382082462311,
-0.5362691879272461,
0.06667378544807434,
-0.09948945045471191,
0.2503241002559662,
0.16439369320869446,
-0.10812988132238388,
0.5880959033966064,
-0.5990461111068726,
0.2097407430410385,
-0.07517076283693314,
-0.3842049837112427,
-0.27700451016426086,
-0.17798840999603271,
-0.06662248820066452,
0.17045742273330688,
0.30823880434036255,
-0.3620586395263672,
0.1561592072248459,
-0.2894482910633087,
0.4766967296600342,
0.8891404271125793,
0.18130262196063995,
0.6422306299209595,
-0.7295184135437012,
0.4409985840320587,
-0.14694006741046906,
0.1718926578760147,
-0.05728650838136673,
-0.30864548683166504,
-0.6565318703651428,
-0.676154375076294,
0.06866932660341263,
0.23895779252052307,
-0.8152613043785095,
0.4314105212688446,
-0.40332701802253723,
-0.5750353932380676,
-0.5992628931999207,
0.28721022605895996,
0.2755509316921234,
0.008025023154914379,
0.13465049862861633,
-0.15701940655708313,
-0.3471176028251648,
-0.615928590297699,
-0.07465417683124542,
-0.13742069900035858,
0.040450334548950195,
0.5003370046615601,
0.42794081568717957,
-0.35540395975112915,
0.9771311283111572,
-0.2213251292705536,
-0.41329121589660645,
-0.3254658877849579,
0.0894084945321083,
-0.08607275784015656,
0.360628604888916,
0.5550071597099304,
-0.5966454744338989,
-0.6552562713623047,
0.2438930869102478,
-0.25375863909721375,
-0.1539291888475418,
0.19644735753536224,
-0.2913523018360138,
0.058844104409217834,
0.3829589784145355,
-0.6084276437759399,
-0.08045470714569092,
0.9390764832496643,
-0.5584791898727417,
0.2984832525253296,
-0.30244579911231995,
0.1767565906047821,
-1.1749988794326782,
-0.33653733134269714,
-0.24029411375522614,
-0.4427286386489868,
-0.33040791749954224,
0.1499626189470291,
-0.10387426614761353,
-0.001946684904396534,
-0.28782525658607483,
0.5920175313949585,
-0.6076643466949463,
0.15595915913581848,
-0.6497447490692139,
0.5059376358985901,
-0.09970101714134216,
0.6270686388015747,
-0.24278627336025238,
0.9909842014312744,
0.45304712653160095,
-0.4825788140296936,
0.3938309848308563,
0.25281915068626404,
0.1725768744945526,
0.8823180198669434,
-0.3339957594871521,
0.4150327146053314,
-0.0009096903377212584,
0.22548197209835052,
-0.8015897870063782,
-0.2455286681652069,
0.1393754631280899,
-0.47552207112312317,
-0.1049586609005928,
-0.1445511132478714,
-0.743403971195221,
0.007348708342760801,
-0.40145787596702576,
0.15730789303779602,
0.09979698061943054,
-0.6157023906707764,
0.798761248588562,
0.3610037863254547,
-0.10397464781999588,
0.10965464264154434,
-0.2510427236557007,
0.08249853551387787,
-0.19145552814006805,
-0.7709679007530212,
-0.009196494705975056,
-0.45323941111564636,
-0.30961906909942627,
0.052242688834667206,
0.058327220380306244,
-0.10922031849622726,
0.0899650901556015,
0.19418586790561676,
0.03508341312408447,
-0.2955140471458435,
0.35829979181289673,
-0.13330712914466858,
-0.15408028662204742,
-0.18604589998722076,
-0.29941973090171814,
0.4851250946521759,
-0.6820792555809021,
-0.13636155426502228,
-0.17375251650810242,
0.35187873244285583,
0.641334593296051,
-0.18125750124454498,
0.9702418446540833,
0.726121723651886,
-0.1768251657485962,
-0.29864364862442017,
-0.4363078773021698,
-0.5041218400001526,
-0.5581228137016296,
0.23613984882831573,
-0.3722066283226013,
-1.31600022315979,
0.575988233089447,
-0.30899468064308167,
-0.24350333213806152,
0.18381154537200928,
0.7211296558380127,
0.28063467144966125,
1.0527201890945435,
1.139196515083313,
-0.19954180717468262,
0.6725572943687439,
0.09048668295145035,
-0.1262766420841217,
-0.6873875260353088,
0.18727676570415497,
-0.6509809494018555,
0.00569888623431325,
-0.8365654945373535,
-0.527608335018158,
0.43778228759765625,
-0.34959474205970764,
-0.26134955883026123,
0.3527785539627075,
-0.34303638339042664,
0.8778535723686218,
0.49162158370018005,
0.27867743372917175,
0.4836205244064331,
-0.33321475982666016,
-0.25315600633621216,
0.0651613175868988,
-0.7467150092124939,
-0.6423425078392029,
0.7189707159996033,
0.10532477498054504,
0.7247450351715088,
0.537355899810791,
0.4086892008781433,
0.2200804054737091,
0.45383962988853455,
-0.823086142539978,
0.5745079517364502,
0.058640047907829285,
-0.39989787340164185,
-0.5299565196037292,
-0.5137249827384949,
-0.985837459564209,
0.589414119720459,
-0.15825410187244415,
-0.8000751733779907,
-0.18178154528141022,
-0.004219747614115477,
-0.2526314854621887,
0.011292962357401848,
-0.9044025540351868,
0.8720970153808594,
-0.0034657788928598166,
-0.5958877205848694,
-0.5983556509017944,
-0.6465684771537781,
0.05739757791161537,
-0.3409232795238495,
0.3698442280292511,
-0.38340872526168823,
-0.2836165428161621,
0.2041608840227127,
-0.6020397543907166,
0.9569171667098999,
-0.037453487515449524,
0.05535609647631645,
0.26568078994750977,
-0.017570028081536293,
0.832016110420227,
0.3126116096973419,
-0.1709546148777008,
-0.1346370130777359,
0.1083834171295166,
-0.501743733882904,
-0.4493424892425537,
0.9136408567428589,
-1.0142625570297241,
-0.29130348563194275,
-0.12952855229377747,
-0.6125444173812866,
-0.38244861364364624,
0.2744816541671753,
-0.12368382513523102,
0.052044399082660675,
-0.2783074676990509,
0.32410475611686707,
0.36067360639572144,
-0.05194510146975517,
0.4864674210548401,
0.9790560007095337,
0.1448366791009903,
-0.5110427141189575,
0.8545790910720825,
-0.27124592661857605,
0.5432252287864685,
0.3376360833644867,
0.33026739954948425,
-0.03150317445397377,
-0.30834680795669556,
-0.09968265891075134,
0.39167386293411255,
-0.5039862394332886,
-0.23051805794239044,
-0.3415432870388031,
0.05270308256149292,
-0.23612356185913086,
-0.11216302961111069,
-0.5863016843795776,
0.09132734686136246,
-0.2502606511116028,
0.16213954985141754,
0.2729205787181854,
0.6741716861724854,
-0.1495334953069687,
0.7209216356277466,
-0.8459909558296204,
0.17242960631847382,
0.3171308934688568,
0.579757809638977,
-0.18774327635765076,
-0.30222535133361816,
-0.7435027956962585,
0.12129442393779755,
-0.39471235871315,
-0.45237916707992554,
0.18256701529026031,
0.3263894021511078,
0.5986490249633789,
-0.07005003839731216,
0.03886351361870766,
0.535342812538147,
-0.17290720343589783,
0.6010187268257141,
-0.21780668199062347,
-0.9350081086158752,
0.4374755024909973,
-0.6819794774055481,
0.5850425958633423,
0.7246712446212769,
-0.45581039786338806,
-0.38514629006385803,
-0.5711142420768738,
-0.5305448770523071,
-0.4091379940509796,
0.8781428933143616,
0.35208430886268616,
-0.14063650369644165,
0.050398387014865875,
0.03310379013419151,
-0.043240778148174286,
0.3327402174472809,
-0.43013590574264526,
0.09737516939640045,
0.01157973613590002,
-0.2920675575733185,
-0.3082791566848755,
0.24702055752277374,
-0.20521724224090576,
-0.126792311668396,
0.6993785500526428,
-0.7213677763938904,
0.18440473079681396,
-0.08952190726995468,
-0.1798737347126007,
-0.5208306312561035,
0.47304847836494446,
0.6698065400123596,
0.4394734501838684,
-0.23803585767745972,
-0.02649206481873989,
0.27143579721450806,
-0.4075767993927002,
0.17219604551792145,
0.008091041818261147,
0.39285218715667725,
-0.3176160454750061,
0.17157822847366333,
0.5937100648880005,
0.2732365131378174,
-0.5324269533157349,
0.5147349238395691,
-0.63116055727005,
-0.11358017474412918,
-0.04514962062239647,
0.30093666911125183,
0.22901013493537903,
0.5370105504989624,
-0.03700951114296913,
0.37739577889442444,
-0.15946070849895477,
-0.5367345809936523,
0.14924375712871552,
0.49817991256713867,
-0.42919763922691345,
-0.4140406548976898,
0.4050365388393402,
0.4406908452510834,
-0.3531275987625122,
0.17045292258262634,
-0.27941247820854187,
-0.19290156662464142,
0.7716854810714722,
0.22680971026420593,
0.768816351890564,
-0.11822988837957382,
0.14171963930130005,
0.07849355041980743,
0.633209764957428,
-0.16662874817848206,
0.039082735776901245,
-0.022361693903803825,
-0.9483392834663391,
-0.42396560311317444,
-0.44838806986808777,
-0.8824287056922913,
0.02717367745935917,
-0.3314530551433563,
0.21841643750667572,
-0.3949010372161865,
-0.23086394369602203,
-0.09829201549291611,
0.42373332381248474,
-0.7871572971343994,
-0.009049943648278713,
-0.1335563361644745,
0.59536212682724,
-0.7016604542732239,
1.0352301597595215,
0.9092886447906494,
-0.29391324520111084,
-0.9388283491134644,
0.046217888593673706,
0.23708520829677582,
-0.6025500893592834,
-0.12274671345949173,
0.22066235542297363,
-0.5254451036453247,
0.25523802638053894,
-0.7699674963951111,
-0.983468234539032,
1.1968830823898315,
0.5211915373802185,
-0.5820371508598328,
0.3515787422657013,
0.19641268253326416,
0.9020639657974243,
-0.6871349215507507,
0.2066265344619751,
0.6793946623802185,
0.556846022605896,
0.0885392278432846,
-1.1140538454055786,
0.14390777051448822,
-0.15114128589630127,
0.003052306827157736,
0.22723853588104248,
-1.416234016418457,
0.641602098941803,
-0.19845637679100037,
0.0232949610799551,
0.40216559171676636,
0.37201130390167236,
0.3896690607070923,
0.23452523350715637,
0.6883807182312012,
0.17749860882759094,
0.8545863032341003,
0.02065546065568924,
0.6895406246185303,
-0.4613076448440552,
0.4512883424758911,
1.4032536745071411,
-0.2807244062423706,
0.6567645072937012,
0.4333348572254181,
0.26392680406570435,
0.2551235556602478,
0.4685288071632385,
0.16320917010307312,
0.5562668442726135,
-0.0752812847495079,
-0.36342915892601013,
-0.4242652356624603,
-0.2505718767642975,
-0.05002811923623085,
0.5680983066558838,
0.46925365924835205,
-0.07658696919679642,
-0.06568567454814911,
0.07935367524623871,
-0.09280167520046234,
0.25134778022766113,
-0.2958778142929077,
1.01473867893219,
0.0335170216858387,
-0.6770527958869934,
0.19081100821495056,
0.06232487037777901,
0.6961368918418884,
-0.4476695954799652,
-0.01144071202725172,
-0.21095405519008636,
0.4370217025279999,
0.08561849594116211,
-0.18104982376098633,
0.0476217046380043,
-0.3615404963493347,
-0.16839109361171722,
0.04556049033999443,
0.7243790030479431,
-0.49025553464889526,
-0.18746601045131683,
0.5028949975967407,
0.6769355535507202,
-0.18379947543144226,
-0.1911851167678833,
-0.7720210552215576,
0.28197184205055237,
-0.3685387372970581,
-0.16556085646152496,
0.293555349111557,
0.7197560667991638,
0.0162349846214056,
0.6489611268043518,
0.6703481078147888,
0.18167684972286224,
-0.18939445912837982,
0.19761458039283752,
0.977198600769043,
-0.5984669923782349,
-0.6372724771499634,
-0.7443211674690247,
0.2675110697746277,
-0.05199793353676796,
0.09479521960020065,
0.6320448517799377,
0.2765464186668396,
0.6395677328109741,
0.07712938636541367,
0.734093964099884,
0.28471070528030396,
0.6454532146453857,
-0.35526612401008606,
0.6502782106399536,
-0.3165353834629059,
0.45944803953170776,
-0.25034382939338684,
-0.9689680337905884,
-0.04251423478126526,
0.32982778549194336,
-0.048208750784397125,
0.2573363184928894,
0.8770251870155334,
1.1387473344802856,
-0.10811401903629303,
0.011416031047701836,
0.47633785009384155,
0.288497656583786,
0.5541191697120667,
0.47601518034935,
0.7021293640136719,
-0.24638891220092773,
0.7696617841720581,
-0.006147526204586029,
-0.2524355351924896,
-0.2751944065093994,
-0.740856409072876,
-1.0203073024749756,
-0.2751831114292145,
-0.1172749325633049,
0.0438217855989933,
0.16218653321266174,
1.3370471000671387,
1.0303219556808472,
-0.5033069849014282,
-0.20168228447437286,
-0.16904988884925842,
0.1329883337020874,
-0.2810300588607788,
-0.24181948602199554,
-0.06738211214542389,
-0.3615061044692993,
-0.6796307563781738,
0.666051983833313,
0.3355899751186371,
0.018718663603067398,
-0.14822359383106232,
-0.47440457344055176,
-0.04359129071235657,
0.4085325300693512,
0.4673132300376892,
-0.020567666739225388,
-0.5250870585441589,
-0.6896831393241882,
-0.2554202973842621,
-0.3422127068042755,
0.20619338750839233,
0.5679962635040283,
-0.5823851823806763,
0.264328271150589,
0.07435394823551178,
0.4207417368888855,
0.22609731554985046,
0.03539057448506355,
0.4864737391471863,
-0.937010645866394,
0.24367237091064453,
-0.033474404364824295,
0.1335468739271164,
0.412689208984375,
-0.3471474051475525,
0.5490114688873291,
0.1429484635591507,
-0.9821942448616028,
-0.5077000260353088,
0.01303094532340765,
-0.9899459481239319,
-0.16670894622802734,
0.97835373878479,
0.21336054801940918,
-0.26315826177597046,
-0.12902936339378357,
-0.6125872731208801,
0.19714127480983734,
-0.8503124713897705,
0.5852235555648804,
0.8351706266403198,
-0.10452619940042496,
-0.38298794627189636,
-0.4050181806087494,
0.3700871467590332,
0.3988289535045624,
-1.0620567798614502,
0.02717810682952404,
0.5763079524040222,
0.3439963757991791,
0.060917679220438004,
0.8518602252006531,
0.3672313988208771,
0.2177950143814087,
0.1186540424823761,
-0.12738394737243652,
-0.11397187411785126,
-0.31414997577667236,
-0.26663026213645935,
0.03977004438638687,
0.523185133934021,
-0.20134717226028442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01657v1
|
Release of Pre-Trained Models for the Japanese Language
| 2024-04-02T05:59:43 | 2024-04-02T05:59:43 |
Kei Sawada, Tianyu Zhao, Makoto Shing, Kentaro Mitsui, Akio Kaga, Yukiya Hono, Toshiaki Wakatsuki, Koh Mitsuda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
AI democratization aims to create a world in which the average person can
utilize AI techniques. To achieve this goal, numerous research institutes have
attempted to make their results accessible to the public. In particular, large
pre-trained models trained on large-scale data have shown unprecedented
potential, and their release has had a significant impact. However, most of the
released models specialize in the English language, and thus, AI
democratization in non-English-speaking communities is lagging significantly.
To reduce this gap in AI access, we released Generative Pre-trained Transformer
(GPT), Contrastive Language and Image Pre-training (CLIP), Stable Diffusion,
and Hidden-unit Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers
(HuBERT) pre-trained in Japanese. By providing these models, users can freely
interface with AI that aligns with Japanese cultural values and ensures the
identity of Japanese culture, thus enhancing the democratization of AI.
Additionally, experiments showed that pre-trained models specialized for
Japanese can efficiently achieve high performance in Japanese tasks.
|
[
-0.6095917224884033,
-0.612062931060791,
0.37261831760406494,
0.1847269982099533,
-0.27734601497650146,
-0.043881360441446304,
-0.4077432453632355,
-0.30467963218688965,
0.2827560007572174,
0.639149010181427,
-0.46102043986320496,
-0.32357335090637207,
-0.758173406124115,
0.14596860110759735,
-0.3755098581314087,
0.8618088364601135,
-0.20685815811157227,
0.027475429698824883,
-0.28690484166145325,
0.1882867068052292,
-0.18663127720355988,
-0.6032833456993103,
-0.5575888156890869,
-0.46506860852241516,
0.29705139994621277,
0.14393505454063416,
0.9515054225921631,
0.5705468058586121,
0.6650428175926208,
0.38126468658447266,
0.549327552318573,
-0.3540235459804535,
-0.2658892869949341,
-0.1563398689031601,
0.03249412029981613,
-0.6929963231086731,
-0.506782591342926,
0.3945792317390442,
0.6923633217811584,
0.4219004511833191,
-0.011116232722997665,
0.13184747099876404,
-0.09843703359365463,
0.39928629994392395,
-0.6018781661987305,
0.5503597855567932,
-0.2310011088848114,
0.006953713018447161,
-0.5258311033248901,
0.2415047436952591,
-0.37767598032951355,
-0.4060039222240448,
-0.16191542148590088,
-1.0642293691635132,
0.1640986055135727,
-0.4367043673992157,
1.0389068126678467,
0.34801146388053894,
-0.1322518140077591,
0.0665496289730072,
-0.8651509881019592,
0.4585268795490265,
-0.5357577204704285,
0.5592571496963501,
0.5880290269851685,
0.5310942530632019,
0.014751452952623367,
-0.875679075717926,
-0.5625803470611572,
-0.3478037714958191,
0.013251679949462414,
0.24695739150047302,
-0.046838339418172836,
0.17724470794200897,
0.27236244082450867,
0.13212794065475464,
-0.5557169914245605,
0.31444570422172546,
-0.340557724237442,
-0.22934770584106445,
0.901543378829956,
-0.1287006139755249,
0.4592439532279968,
-0.06449295580387115,
-0.07033324241638184,
-0.3720528781414032,
-0.6734215617179871,
-0.1640739142894745,
0.6203491687774658,
0.10249955207109451,
-0.3205163776874542,
0.47928160429000854,
-0.21667632460594177,
0.3341633081436157,
-0.20283682644367218,
-0.009618391282856464,
0.2314673215150833,
-0.2487320452928543,
0.0025893847923725843,
-0.3086569905281067,
1.1596823930740356,
-0.009659134782850742,
0.5362529158592224,
0.040521904826164246,
-0.27679964900016785,
0.01241542212665081,
0.3001819849014282,
-0.9466116428375244,
-0.15721821784973145,
-0.22046136856079102,
-0.5376513600349426,
-0.05013681575655937,
0.2965731918811798,
-0.6210061311721802,
0.04139174520969391,
-0.29335689544677734,
0.5873734951019287,
-0.12227966636419296,
-0.5930582880973816,
0.08389601111412048,
-0.08130436390638351,
0.15249057114124298,
0.4272565245628357,
-0.7571129202842712,
0.1658858358860016,
0.5926508903503418,
0.7018790245056152,
0.07720717042684555,
-0.35281288623809814,
0.11716444045305252,
0.13013479113578796,
-0.4668724238872528,
0.4481661319732666,
-0.6749142408370972,
-0.6732897162437439,
-0.0723959431052208,
0.09076332300901413,
0.04406009986996651,
-0.46958673000335693,
0.16671212017536163,
-0.5950906872749329,
0.3687528073787689,
0.10635485500097275,
-0.18700607120990753,
-0.024645037949085236,
0.06611498445272446,
-0.6839318871498108,
0.5128610730171204,
0.013324655592441559,
-0.6815578937530518,
0.16788223385810852,
-1.002586841583252,
-0.3678945004940033,
0.20177346467971802,
-0.23117764294147491,
-0.5140784978866577,
0.17912603914737701,
0.3750920593738556,
0.5124754309654236,
-0.03662426397204399,
0.5043242573738098,
-0.2767353355884552,
-0.46274152398109436,
0.0033615962602198124,
-0.6879313588142395,
0.8210753202438354,
0.32019829750061035,
-0.3196399509906769,
0.22570306062698364,
-0.3869941234588623,
-0.30700209736824036,
0.4076131582260132,
-0.01988215744495392,
-0.22487102448940277,
-0.1456705778837204,
0.0059205940924584866,
0.12967921793460846,
0.3401983380317688,
-0.3868178427219391,
0.17126713693141937,
-0.2326088398694992,
0.2956683933734894,
0.846060037612915,
-0.30957597494125366,
0.4315246641635895,
0.015647416934370995,
0.9596787095069885,
0.11014887690544128,
0.47100022435188293,
-0.4360046982765198,
-0.509830892086029,
-0.6173211932182312,
-0.5262434482574463,
0.4238322973251343,
0.463279128074646,
-0.9077044725418091,
0.5362178087234497,
-0.3871222734451294,
-0.5814513564109802,
-1.0794590711593628,
-0.2720804512500763,
0.17130471765995026,
0.3309922218322754,
0.11355042457580566,
-0.34052523970603943,
-0.2986012399196625,
-1.085161566734314,
0.03577125072479248,
-0.27806979417800903,
-0.2312403917312622,
0.20666345953941345,
0.5747475028038025,
-0.49113884568214417,
0.8684278726577759,
-0.4240195155143738,
-0.15557001531124115,
-0.34133991599082947,
0.2572287321090698,
0.02561250329017639,
0.37616628408432007,
0.0878656804561615,
-0.8167917132377625,
-0.4164983034133911,
0.113900326192379,
-0.6156399250030518,
0.1528296172618866,
0.0356881283223629,
-0.05401141196489334,
-0.03660214692354202,
0.43055620789527893,
-0.5746473073959351,
0.5068075060844421,
0.6320409774780273,
0.19976571202278137,
0.4283890426158905,
-0.3834962248802185,
0.4076641798019409,
-1.3807928562164307,
0.2789180874824524,
-0.12685637176036835,
-0.46531274914741516,
-0.4598419964313507,
0.06478076428174973,
0.008853021077811718,
-0.6961227655410767,
-0.4638282060623169,
0.49942031502723694,
-0.3401244878768921,
-0.07251486927270889,
-0.2630053162574768,
0.15647108852863312,
-0.18674595654010773,
0.062247127294540405,
0.484129399061203,
1.0340430736541748,
0.5930076837539673,
-0.4623720943927765,
0.15442878007888794,
0.16987822949886322,
-0.3613015413284302,
-0.1147390678524971,
-0.8039196729660034,
0.238114595413208,
-0.4414220452308655,
0.3513094484806061,
-0.47569355368614197,
-0.38990676403045654,
0.272737056016922,
-0.39999455213546753,
0.3643335700035095,
-0.13369767367839813,
-0.2166593223810196,
-0.3746866285800934,
-0.03176447004079819,
0.27414193749427795,
0.885344922542572,
-0.4094822406768799,
0.35179921984672546,
0.5984238982200623,
-0.16546852886676788,
-0.6346867680549622,
-0.5164129137992859,
-0.3171464800834656,
0.013514206744730473,
-0.4597112238407135,
0.07179974764585495,
0.17909973859786987,
-0.10735728591680527,
0.16905094683170319,
0.41283586621284485,
-0.20981058478355408,
0.3291082978248596,
0.17508265376091003,
0.34046804904937744,
-0.3056575655937195,
-0.0638459101319313,
0.03931943327188492,
-0.4658038020133972,
0.05496247857809067,
0.08560428023338318,
0.6548131704330444,
-0.013235093094408512,
-0.6111764907836914,
-0.7500325441360474,
0.2632496953010559,
0.45217961072921753,
-0.5999085903167725,
0.7518599629402161,
0.7471678256988525,
-0.3083973824977875,
0.0560237281024456,
-0.3732067048549652,
-0.3611258864402771,
-0.4480469226837158,
0.8282390832901001,
-0.4654994010925293,
-0.8868146538734436,
0.28224363923072815,
-0.2586863040924072,
-0.00951457116752863,
0.30759716033935547,
0.3996557593345642,
0.039799321442842484,
1.332903265953064,
0.8384196162223816,
-0.37934455275535583,
0.6730746030807495,
-0.29491958022117615,
0.3767523467540741,
-0.5734065771102905,
-0.22044745087623596,
-0.7570875883102417,
-0.050010986626148224,
-0.7421815395355225,
-0.49822402000427246,
0.3206861913204193,
0.17831435799598694,
-0.08773641288280487,
0.11086659133434296,
-0.367708295583725,
0.5863662958145142,
0.5981220602989197,
-0.150081068277359,
0.1397026777267456,
-0.14403291046619415,
0.3503592610359192,
-0.18506690859794617,
-0.3854846656322479,
-0.6622828245162964,
1.1470600366592407,
0.3486149311065674,
0.8041754364967346,
-0.3097952604293823,
1.021401286125183,
0.08950494229793549,
0.5341440439224243,
-0.6216960549354553,
0.49504801630973816,
-0.27243003249168396,
-0.5884321331977844,
-0.30189430713653564,
-0.46349096298217773,
-0.9344754219055176,
0.01123488787561655,
0.020155055448412895,
-0.257467120885849,
-0.0757649764418602,
0.1488010287284851,
0.09643155336380005,
0.16389821469783783,
-0.6442171335220337,
0.9964062571525574,
-0.13237813115119934,
0.22938671708106995,
-0.469967246055603,
-0.6148843765258789,
0.2903086245059967,
-0.14253763854503632,
0.3179972469806671,
-0.19669891893863678,
0.025259319692850113,
0.800844132900238,
-0.19190365076065063,
0.7167817950248718,
-0.35651421546936035,
0.29888325929641724,
0.052966829389333725,
-0.22242392599582672,
0.348614364862442,
0.04522908478975296,
0.12761357426643372,
0.675512969493866,
-0.31990525126457214,
-0.33803242444992065,
-0.5869832634925842,
0.2638570964336395,
-1.2816879749298096,
-0.9491645693778992,
-0.1888398677110672,
-0.2384217530488968,
0.05164296180009842,
0.34122371673583984,
0.6243671774864197,
0.06762295961380005,
-0.46071091294288635,
0.20858149230480194,
0.4858843982219696,
-0.0663779079914093,
0.4516880512237549,
0.4700379967689514,
-0.4539521336555481,
-0.28000521659851074,
0.8660619854927063,
0.19835180044174194,
0.15559186041355133,
0.23097416758537292,
0.10982470214366913,
-0.28143373131752014,
-0.43690574169158936,
-0.3926005959510803,
0.3828902542591095,
-0.2982517182826996,
0.05580670386552811,
-0.5310604572296143,
-0.42558610439300537,
-0.5527681708335876,
-0.1761500984430313,
-0.7750228047370911,
-0.3047400116920471,
-0.3378754258155823,
-0.015273495577275753,
-0.18438594043254852,
0.97221440076828,
-0.0868874117732048,
0.4104166626930237,
-0.7137697339057922,
0.3733843266963959,
0.09931939095258713,
0.3009849488735199,
-0.33626922965049744,
-0.39381104707717896,
-0.43010732531547546,
0.26390916109085083,
-0.29840728640556335,
-0.7424359917640686,
0.25108346343040466,
0.1108781024813652,
0.5405014157295227,
0.5715863108634949,
-0.05909639969468117,
0.7306725382804871,
-0.5261970162391663,
0.8863673806190491,
0.2834385633468628,
-1.002557635307312,
0.7934626340866089,
-0.17278288304805756,
0.13635645806789398,
0.4229098856449127,
0.874646008014679,
-0.5957571864128113,
-0.4752426743507385,
-0.6522737741470337,
-0.6498780846595764,
0.8382225036621094,
-0.194252610206604,
0.6131459474563599,
-0.11571704596281052,
0.06160695105791092,
0.3090158700942993,
0.3052031993865967,
-0.718960165977478,
-0.2266070544719696,
-0.7365484833717346,
-0.25771668553352356,
-0.4806985557079315,
0.08158186078071594,
0.14380083978176117,
-0.3190506398677826,
0.8674169182777405,
-0.10486714541912079,
0.27023595571517944,
0.11096253991127014,
-0.07134535163640976,
0.1432465761899948,
0.31360387802124023,
0.22729279100894928,
0.5327560305595398,
0.22462932765483856,
-0.24588222801685333,
-0.4458295702934265,
-0.6973217129707336,
0.36962053179740906,
0.2734070420265198,
-0.6583371162414551,
0.03696274384856224,
0.29471054673194885,
1.0619384050369263,
-0.3015391230583191,
-0.4794255197048187,
0.6696590185165405,
0.007165552582591772,
-0.045254893600940704,
-0.39793306589126587,
0.08316923677921295,
-0.00623498298227787,
-0.02854805625975132,
0.039111390709877014,
-0.006819204892963171,
0.04488929361104965,
-0.47346267104148865,
0.09233264625072479,
0.4812314510345459,
-0.2232525795698166,
-0.7061704993247986,
0.7465794682502747,
0.3916704058647156,
-0.3891009986400604,
1.0801929235458374,
-0.10053199529647827,
-0.4715636670589447,
0.44638118147850037,
0.7757515907287598,
0.9114834070205688,
-0.5548133850097656,
0.6780001521110535,
0.4117429852485657,
0.36516261100769043,
-0.3349440395832062,
-0.08667964488267899,
-0.09761074185371399,
-0.9199835658073425,
-0.41186052560806274,
-0.3885551393032074,
-0.2762066423892975,
0.10321901738643646,
-0.8697525262832642,
0.18775862455368042,
-0.36987704038619995,
-0.4837847650051117,
-0.5590905547142029,
0.06931552290916443,
-0.6956804990768433,
0.1424023061990738,
0.20396742224693298,
0.6625557541847229,
-1.1704703569412231,
0.9933738112449646,
0.7532205581665039,
-0.5955469608306885,
-0.8901163339614868,
0.1329599916934967,
-0.45643046498298645,
-0.7202315926551819,
0.576228141784668,
0.21183086931705475,
0.19539959728717804,
0.22542804479599,
-0.4298284947872162,
-0.7466872334480286,
0.872927188873291,
0.7533040642738342,
-0.6032570004463196,
-0.027830418199300766,
0.36591964960098267,
0.4232662320137024,
-0.3214927911758423,
0.566297173500061,
0.3392443060874939,
0.5963758826255798,
-0.30933091044425964,
-0.8783791065216064,
-0.3906894624233246,
-0.3245176672935486,
0.24981001019477844,
0.3063066005706787,
-0.7231143116950989,
0.6007078886032104,
-0.05912311375141144,
-0.2452968806028366,
-0.1807744950056076,
0.7389228940010071,
0.022533822804689407,
0.1780444234609604,
0.16715820133686066,
0.4360376000404358,
0.7386670112609863,
-0.3910229802131653,
1.1925045251846313,
-0.004214101005345583,
0.02348172850906849,
0.7678544521331787,
-0.18902063369750977,
0.8818992376327515,
0.21333560347557068,
-0.26586711406707764,
0.4334539771080017,
0.48686683177948,
0.16248688101768494,
0.5950926542282104,
-0.10234175622463226,
-0.24828565120697021,
-0.24288566410541534,
-0.3334204852581024,
-0.48757055401802063,
0.527457058429718,
0.13590799272060394,
-0.233474999666214,
0.09076301008462906,
0.43305504322052,
0.28550711274147034,
0.008075110614299774,
-0.3232833743095398,
0.8959184288978577,
-0.008336806669831276,
-0.6189709305763245,
0.18772859871387482,
-0.0558842308819294,
0.6974350214004517,
-0.920373797416687,
0.08378779888153076,
-0.291513592004776,
0.03113720379769802,
0.061558451503515244,
-0.5483113527297974,
0.24946419894695282,
0.09946166723966599,
-0.0828627496957779,
-0.30022335052490234,
0.5384615659713745,
-0.35944029688835144,
-0.4934329092502594,
0.32474958896636963,
0.40499094128608704,
0.35713323950767517,
0.004343455657362938,
-0.5806399583816528,
0.1990867257118225,
-0.04291786998510361,
-0.43170419335365295,
0.3694067597389221,
0.012895000167191029,
-0.3245062232017517,
0.5194469690322876,
0.49778953194618225,
0.3753354251384735,
0.16129125654697418,
0.32927563786506653,
0.7275234460830688,
-0.28372520208358765,
-0.2775287926197052,
-0.6635264158248901,
0.6767244338989258,
0.005729282274842262,
-0.14676329493522644,
0.6473841667175293,
0.5145754814147949,
1.2923170328140259,
-0.26160019636154175,
0.9659327268600464,
0.028957080096006393,
-0.022670462727546692,
-0.38860803842544556,
1.0072847604751587,
-0.564569354057312,
-0.27330729365348816,
-0.012554421089589596,
-0.8831437826156616,
-0.1627476066350937,
0.5967252850532532,
-0.32138654589653015,
0.34062737226486206,
0.3249584138393402,
0.7712993621826172,
-0.09882353991270065,
-0.1208186075091362,
0.5145483016967773,
0.20930513739585876,
0.48184558749198914,
0.32745179533958435,
0.8447479009628296,
-0.35354217886924744,
0.12426017224788666,
-0.6234754920005798,
-0.2629540264606476,
0.06677840650081635,
-0.5472273230552673,
-0.7127875685691833,
-0.7013161182403564,
-0.38221707940101624,
0.1714954972267151,
0.19477839767932892,
0.8621897101402283,
1.0510536432266235,
-0.6324064135551453,
-0.23906180262565613,
0.12725356221199036,
-0.11371052265167236,
0.1375332921743393,
-0.21669703722000122,
0.16235846281051636,
-0.276540607213974,
-1.0013850927352905,
0.3714424967765808,
0.1661684811115265,
0.13737456500530243,
-0.47384920716285706,
-0.24506758153438568,
0.25835877656936646,
0.06471871584653854,
0.2267346978187561,
0.21453632414340973,
-0.4320441484451294,
-0.18321307003498077,
-0.2087433636188507,
0.006883057300001383,
0.07971679419279099,
0.9664162397384644,
-0.7344171404838562,
0.5664360523223877,
0.5417038202285767,
0.5893248915672302,
0.5124934911727905,
0.12903669476509094,
0.7149965167045593,
-0.6924093961715698,
0.6949149966239929,
0.3583492338657379,
0.2448287010192871,
0.3163506090641022,
-0.23185481131076813,
0.2841954231262207,
0.0911150723695755,
-0.5064705014228821,
-0.6687262058258057,
0.3196222484111786,
-0.25050410628318787,
-0.12065092474222183,
0.5533499717712402,
-0.4185468554496765,
-0.32778823375701904,
0.0688837319612503,
0.011806080117821693,
0.5798827409744263,
-0.2499704211950302,
0.5679129362106323,
0.6144110560417175,
0.19165553152561188,
-0.2283780872821808,
-0.3674829304218292,
0.3915664553642273,
0.10120011121034622,
-1.19266939163208,
-0.06033893674612045,
0.29667696356773376,
0.1397150456905365,
0.26811903715133667,
0.9828751087188721,
-0.42191827297210693,
0.1961703896522522,
-0.03892789036035538,
0.36488795280456543,
-0.30845198035240173,
-0.6228861212730408,
-0.5004329085350037,
0.037203140556812286,
0.1867893785238266,
-0.28169888257980347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01652v1
|
Towards Better Generalization in Open-Domain Question Answering by Mitigating Context Memorization
| 2024-04-02T05:44:50 | 2024-04-02T05:44:50 |
Zixuan Zhang, Revanth Gangi Reddy, Kevin Small, Tong Zhang, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Open-domain Question Answering (OpenQA) aims at answering factual questions
with an external large-scale knowledge corpus. However, real-world knowledge is
not static; it updates and evolves continually. Such a dynamic characteristic
of knowledge poses a vital challenge for these models, as the trained models
need to constantly adapt to the latest information to make sure that the
answers remain accurate. In addition, it is still unclear how well an OpenQA
model can transfer to completely new knowledge domains. In this paper, we
investigate the generalization performance of a retrieval-augmented QA model in
two specific scenarios: 1) adapting to updated versions of the same knowledge
corpus; 2) switching to completely different knowledge domains. We observe that
the generalization challenges of OpenQA models stem from the reader's
over-reliance on memorizing the knowledge from the external corpus, which
hinders the model from generalizing to a new knowledge corpus. We introduce
Corpus-Invariant Tuning (CIT), a simple but effective training strategy, to
mitigate the knowledge over-memorization by controlling the likelihood of
retrieved contexts during training. Extensive experimental results on multiple
OpenQA benchmarks show that CIT achieves significantly better generalizability
without compromising the model's performance in its original corpus and domain.
|
[
-0.4286492168903351,
-0.7777924537658691,
0.473299115896225,
-0.32584232091903687,
-0.20824742317199707,
-0.03915020078420639,
-0.3617364168167114,
-0.2738156318664551,
-0.21953265368938446,
0.33813878893852234,
-0.3293185830116272,
-0.44450199604034424,
-0.41017264127731323,
-0.22959648072719574,
-0.14716225862503052,
1.061863660812378,
-0.2247665971517563,
-0.1531856507062912,
-0.49453625082969666,
-0.4417248070240021,
-0.5401392579078674,
-0.7182416915893555,
-0.5908362865447998,
0.08042231947183609,
0.23328036069869995,
0.1893615573644638,
0.6724600195884705,
0.24757738411426544,
0.3316906988620758,
0.15151381492614746,
-0.12642279267311096,
0.30091333389282227,
-0.681350827217102,
0.13940516114234924,
-0.5492992401123047,
-0.7015991806983948,
-0.23258481919765472,
-0.248308002948761,
0.6939213871955872,
0.5981166362762451,
-0.1608313024044037,
0.4344607889652252,
0.022418653592467308,
0.7141506671905518,
-1.00945246219635,
-0.05617724359035492,
-0.8934558033943176,
-0.3140380382537842,
0.07263798266649246,
-0.3567386269569397,
-0.2557326555252075,
-0.4292384684085846,
0.334275484085083,
-1.074987530708313,
0.4655986428260803,
0.034965191036462784,
0.9171644449234009,
0.27851602435112,
-0.5104691982269287,
-0.17439131438732147,
-1.0371545553207397,
0.6594188809394836,
-0.3006141483783722,
0.44304966926574707,
0.44451695680618286,
0.6161143779754639,
0.0902743712067604,
-0.6185129284858704,
-0.38581210374832153,
0.23483212292194366,
0.2578890323638916,
0.3263799846172333,
-0.24421045184135437,
-0.10503903031349182,
0.17629598081111908,
0.37543433904647827,
-0.4124632477760315,
-0.361288845539093,
-0.5448929667472839,
-0.07380984723567963,
0.11654471606016159,
-0.07932642102241516,
0.28997957706451416,
0.465622216463089,
-0.3435174822807312,
-0.0950050875544548,
-0.73648601770401,
0.4332898259162903,
0.064056895673275,
0.153416708111763,
0.26954466104507446,
0.29378920793533325,
-0.3991893231868744,
0.6591587662696838,
0.29107803106307983,
0.3241893947124481,
0.04870975762605667,
-0.26310738921165466,
-0.2387058287858963,
-0.30992868542671204,
-0.04112399369478226,
0.2993527352809906,
0.4888910949230194,
-0.43917497992515564,
-0.075792096555233,
-0.1476442664861679,
0.5764833688735962,
-0.6352002024650574,
-0.21009561419487,
0.2558903694152832,
-0.23553895950317383,
0.3470434546470642,
0.07869333773851395,
-0.5258965492248535,
-0.013538801111280918,
-0.3881131410598755,
0.8157243728637695,
-0.6802757978439331,
-0.21205905079841614,
0.2950267791748047,
-0.19435660541057587,
0.2977810502052307,
0.3343493342399597,
-0.9644955992698669,
0.38934195041656494,
0.5101893544197083,
0.6143017411231995,
-0.09039977192878723,
-0.08239445835351944,
-0.6786621809005737,
0.4230554699897766,
-0.31231486797332764,
0.7205347418785095,
-0.6387184262275696,
-0.1016014963388443,
0.23679068684577942,
-0.07318592816591263,
-0.644599199295044,
-0.7300992608070374,
0.39463120698928833,
-1.301533579826355,
0.1493985652923584,
-0.42159968614578247,
-0.5244180560112,
-0.28218117356300354,
0.46144241094589233,
-0.5854212641716003,
0.8780790567398071,
0.35427939891815186,
-0.6278773546218872,
0.4600204825401306,
-0.5772307515144348,
0.002619281178340316,
-0.25090402364730835,
0.20992861688137054,
-0.27360785007476807,
0.27469727396965027,
0.3926706910133362,
-0.04390045627951622,
-0.24715057015419006,
-0.01855652406811714,
-0.05216222628951073,
-0.6280556917190552,
0.28407251834869385,
0.06293082982301712,
0.3890826106071472,
0.17287801206111908,
0.013755495660007,
0.02345944568514824,
-0.5063195824623108,
0.32109570503234863,
-0.14820116758346558,
-0.4627978503704071,
-0.8702759146690369,
-0.015722576528787613,
-0.4487913250923157,
0.08265796303749084,
0.12232493609189987,
-0.6300836801528931,
0.3472229838371277,
-0.49377018213272095,
0.35159724950790405,
0.49815842509269714,
0.3419030010700226,
0.6550007462501526,
-0.7998968362808228,
0.597785472869873,
0.32878828048706055,
0.14409853518009186,
0.11885244399309158,
-0.4513704478740692,
-0.6789228916168213,
-0.1018160954117775,
0.6615274548530579,
0.5930722951889038,
-0.9401513934135437,
-0.1227499321103096,
-0.3828732669353485,
-0.15451793372631073,
-0.7536711692810059,
0.013919276185333729,
0.37819063663482666,
0.3887219727039337,
0.7229812741279602,
-0.30635565519332886,
-0.2176366001367569,
-0.5578354597091675,
-0.7162753343582153,
-0.11059874296188354,
-0.14640240371227264,
0.30182886123657227,
0.4616889953613281,
-0.008986243978142738,
1.1436651945114136,
-0.5657793283462524,
-0.22194643318653107,
0.20211946964263916,
-0.10268997400999069,
-0.10494174063205719,
0.42508628964424133,
0.5548755526542664,
-1.093336820602417,
-0.4465779662132263,
0.07411663234233856,
-0.4277626872062683,
0.16094881296157837,
-0.06322157382965088,
-0.5285524129867554,
0.2095600962638855,
0.4979393482208252,
-0.607620894908905,
0.3614322245121002,
0.12606802582740784,
-0.23398956656455994,
0.525500476360321,
-0.07284095883369446,
0.32744544744491577,
-0.8014444708824158,
0.22561365365982056,
-0.402233362197876,
0.02321642078459263,
-0.6592307090759277,
0.5228960514068604,
0.4548317790031433,
0.1451273411512375,
-0.5342202186584473,
0.7230369448661804,
-0.3541702926158905,
0.3055054247379303,
0.13410206139087677,
0.06353791058063507,
0.08055630326271057,
0.7410496473312378,
-0.08819638192653656,
0.9820460677146912,
0.3616180717945099,
-1.0255348682403564,
-0.13223175704479218,
0.46502095460891724,
-0.3059736490249634,
0.44673392176628113,
-0.3905530869960785,
0.288406640291214,
-0.37386655807495117,
0.07169593870639801,
-0.8685518503189087,
0.02100175991654396,
0.03502405062317848,
-0.6132023334503174,
0.23776575922966003,
-0.383683443069458,
-0.24644054472446442,
-0.0873013436794281,
-0.2699030339717865,
0.7337081432342529,
0.4699225127696991,
-0.6944920420646667,
0.7264139652252197,
-0.08450450748205185,
0.029658056795597076,
-0.48346835374832153,
-0.32487836480140686,
-0.5474551916122437,
-0.3557341992855072,
-0.5800406336784363,
0.5623396635055542,
-0.3240397572517395,
-0.09968357533216476,
0.03160623461008072,
-0.4669801592826843,
-0.4309774935245514,
0.02103443443775177,
-0.09851746261119843,
-0.002566604409366846,
-0.38086140155792236,
0.5329012274742126,
0.3762147128582001,
0.28345349431037903,
-0.030941594392061234,
-0.688039243221283,
0.2713814079761505,
0.015468676574528217,
-0.21016402542591095,
0.047695208340883255,
0.3465654253959656,
0.4557013511657715,
-0.5539626479148865,
0.974932074546814,
0.4264180362224579,
-0.32318925857543945,
-0.2465091049671173,
-0.528159499168396,
-0.10701259970664978,
-0.43113797903060913,
0.17403601109981537,
-0.7823676466941833,
-1.002458095550537,
0.6195246577262878,
-0.3330599069595337,
0.15749546885490417,
0.4434187114238739,
0.38302910327911377,
-0.0518658347427845,
0.7788739204406738,
0.7111223936080933,
0.1880570352077484,
0.5002436637878418,
-0.15049150586128235,
-0.12046778202056885,
-1.1248164176940918,
0.007933921180665493,
-0.4755961298942566,
-0.13829977810382843,
-0.2927093505859375,
-0.47484222054481506,
0.4694371521472931,
0.3492462933063507,
-0.5654209852218628,
-0.004562049172818661,
-0.30398985743522644,
0.5904880166053772,
0.7048363089561462,
0.3269940912723541,
0.419363796710968,
0.10294964164495468,
-0.3525291979312897,
0.1794349104166031,
-0.7022196650505066,
-0.2360677868127823,
1.4723875522613525,
0.045391183346509933,
0.3543468713760376,
0.6655285358428955,
0.4801705777645111,
0.11894570291042328,
0.26466888189315796,
-0.44524839520454407,
0.10338721424341202,
-0.2436913102865219,
-0.7601271271705627,
-0.38756775856018066,
-0.43538960814476013,
-0.9816480278968811,
0.4560669958591461,
-0.11640949547290802,
-0.5385156273841858,
0.34083449840545654,
0.2547224164009094,
-0.6106964349746704,
0.31958162784576416,
-0.7178362607955933,
0.751998782157898,
0.318877249956131,
-0.26757800579071045,
0.04707220196723938,
-0.5034005045890808,
0.33887171745300293,
-0.17007821798324585,
0.07611094415187836,
0.2637087404727936,
-0.10150445997714996,
0.402597576379776,
-0.041628189384937286,
0.6315485835075378,
-0.31194260716438293,
0.0422336645424366,
0.499832421541214,
0.03903143107891083,
0.3107683062553406,
0.18269968032836914,
-0.15825390815734863,
-0.18952523171901703,
0.5094366073608398,
-0.8750088214874268,
-0.8118329644203186,
0.38332048058509827,
-1.0729135274887085,
-0.7448515295982361,
-0.13996557891368866,
-0.44280776381492615,
-0.7789605855941772,
0.002637507626786828,
0.41749605536460876,
0.3407343327999115,
-0.541224479675293,
0.05638638883829117,
1.174729824066162,
-0.2907616198062897,
-0.09327390789985657,
0.7593273520469666,
-0.10197723656892776,
-0.27809280157089233,
0.7965880036354065,
0.14222583174705505,
0.6832965016365051,
0.7193493247032166,
-0.009282625280320644,
-0.2644357979297638,
-0.6049517393112183,
-0.5925775766372681,
0.11532024294137955,
-0.6861702799797058,
-0.2338738888502121,
-0.5867761969566345,
-0.15377043187618256,
-0.5767687559127808,
0.0798872709274292,
0.04636653512716293,
-0.6094244122505188,
-0.32677561044692993,
0.13815878331661224,
0.35310858488082886,
0.1353391408920288,
0.14325135946273804,
0.25807011127471924,
-0.6893196702003479,
0.5002102255821228,
0.6761000156402588,
0.5276941657066345,
-0.08685766160488129,
-0.8757854700088501,
-0.3725549876689911,
0.09896650165319443,
-0.42882561683654785,
-0.7010155320167542,
0.11808279901742935,
0.6287887692451477,
0.45815563201904297,
-0.006198152434080839,
0.44828638434410095,
0.5294322371482849,
-0.3216182291507721,
0.557953953742981,
-0.325251966714859,
-0.7114116549491882,
0.4332067370414734,
-0.6007173657417297,
0.847479522228241,
0.7823360562324524,
0.45480647683143616,
-0.48301371932029724,
-0.38439181447029114,
-0.2498205006122589,
-0.7556350231170654,
0.5310519337654114,
0.06633105874061584,
0.1784614473581314,
-0.00668185343965888,
0.7468640208244324,
0.20276157557964325,
0.24004454910755157,
-0.260694682598114,
0.13204899430274963,
-0.33042797446250916,
-0.14500799775123596,
0.22817932069301605,
-0.1376412808895111,
-0.3361193537712097,
-0.2483270764350891,
0.7725675702095032,
-0.42826300859451294,
0.3731721341609955,
0.39723700284957886,
-0.5074809789657593,
-0.1821792721748352,
0.47671398520469666,
0.5747026205062866,
0.671515941619873,
-0.45788994431495667,
-0.10655887424945831,
0.24678543210029602,
-0.5895923972129822,
-0.024936044588685036,
-0.128900408744812,
-0.3885338306427002,
-0.3333978056907654,
-0.01050015538930893,
0.6666924953460693,
0.21982593834400177,
-0.5841994881629944,
0.4488089680671692,
-0.1936524510383606,
-0.32204556465148926,
-0.25118011236190796,
0.37354493141174316,
0.0422615185379982,
0.2255750596523285,
0.5037881731987,
0.1909792721271515,
0.03595493361353874,
-0.5772178173065186,
0.13700838387012482,
0.3032284677028656,
-0.23844656348228455,
-0.24874933063983917,
0.7371208667755127,
-0.06300514936447144,
-0.0005325829843059182,
0.6599462032318115,
-0.034305110573768616,
-0.38506245613098145,
0.7803988456726074,
0.5262336730957031,
0.681983470916748,
-0.25645744800567627,
0.06743329018354416,
0.4578268527984619,
0.18458078801631927,
-0.010418115183711052,
0.41379299759864807,
-0.18813399970531464,
-0.7713656425476074,
-0.2718949019908905,
-0.6332249641418457,
-0.5607496500015259,
-0.032975319772958755,
-1.0130661725997925,
-0.09301576018333435,
-0.4404606521129608,
-0.12820711731910706,
-0.3157139718532562,
-0.14609602093696594,
-0.8309332132339478,
0.38952702283859253,
-0.42214828729629517,
0.9987332224845886,
-0.4439260959625244,
0.9492709636688232,
0.906946063041687,
-0.3930252492427826,
-0.42314088344573975,
0.3235149681568146,
-0.358123242855072,
-0.5665786862373352,
0.3192669153213501,
-0.11184552311897278,
0.12159352004528046,
0.13271526992321014,
-0.4516356885433197,
-1.1119565963745117,
1.162310242652893,
0.27408236265182495,
-0.380429208278656,
-0.161426842212677,
0.10579338669776917,
0.6444073915481567,
-0.266781747341156,
0.14574286341667175,
0.6612375974655151,
0.22511422634124756,
0.04050741717219353,
-0.9133020043373108,
0.040317386388778687,
-0.24468490481376648,
-0.015233896672725677,
0.3597835898399353,
-0.8604496121406555,
0.8220250606536865,
-0.24657073616981506,
-0.34224724769592285,
0.2857641875743866,
0.7594287991523743,
0.10551179945468903,
0.3829098343849182,
0.37757277488708496,
0.4164338707923889,
0.8079819679260254,
0.017629805952310562,
0.7455928921699524,
-0.23747776448726654,
0.2489261031150818,
1.226576805114746,
-0.06381246447563171,
0.8741496205329895,
0.2175397127866745,
-0.0037323276046663523,
0.5342987179756165,
0.4393374025821686,
0.3126954436302185,
0.6414785981178284,
0.25853872299194336,
-0.4177513122558594,
-0.3049660623073578,
0.3392219841480255,
-0.5728636384010315,
0.2674340009689331,
0.38787606358528137,
-0.13529425859451294,
-0.13495242595672607,
0.1615341752767563,
-0.2130451202392578,
0.34959396719932556,
-0.5317263603210449,
0.8001435995101929,
-0.17040924727916718,
-0.95648193359375,
1.0713104009628296,
0.008407321758568287,
0.45856404304504395,
-0.5900564193725586,
0.13076607882976532,
-0.30735135078430176,
0.17937496304512024,
-0.005095429252833128,
-0.2659664452075958,
0.4526965916156769,
-0.14121867716312408,
-0.6530429124832153,
0.03539066016674042,
0.4941391348838806,
-0.5205854177474976,
-0.12119361013174057,
0.2412204146385193,
0.588670015335083,
-0.07512599974870682,
-0.48895588517189026,
-0.3055707514286041,
-0.2686324715614319,
-0.09054279327392578,
-0.1283464878797531,
0.7205712199211121,
0.5700730085372925,
-0.3741239607334137,
0.4847566485404968,
0.5310338139533997,
-0.28739526867866516,
0.344276487827301,
-0.09784679114818573,
1.0133217573165894,
-0.679731547832489,
-0.5165476202964783,
-0.2030017226934433,
0.3107437789440155,
0.1351068615913391,
-0.5742750763893127,
0.3962082266807556,
0.436176061630249,
0.8957854509353638,
-0.27503976225852966,
0.7317181825637817,
0.21995209157466888,
0.8341392278671265,
-0.7344881892204285,
0.7090559601783752,
-0.5410181879997253,
0.28013065457344055,
0.06797631829977036,
-0.8305571675300598,
-0.16566818952560425,
0.08553064614534378,
-0.44723206758499146,
0.07546915858983994,
0.7688520550727844,
0.6042927503585815,
-0.15354062616825104,
0.09007497876882553,
0.4280488193035126,
0.16283772885799408,
0.15932507812976837,
0.9236948490142822,
0.6138600707054138,
-0.4862635135650635,
0.7826583385467529,
0.09624004364013672,
-0.3544328510761261,
-0.005041264463216066,
-0.3280945420265198,
-0.8326443433761597,
-0.7071369886398315,
-0.35637056827545166,
-0.30719345808029175,
0.5217493176460266,
0.3087921142578125,
0.5375467538833618,
-0.8468806147575378,
0.1779288798570633,
0.19107668101787567,
0.05523066222667694,
-0.6044182777404785,
-0.2572019696235657,
0.4939905107021332,
-0.5310909748077393,
-0.5867472290992737,
0.2892046272754669,
-0.1352153867483139,
-0.1664956957101822,
0.2491305023431778,
0.2597445249557495,
-0.30889564752578735,
0.46962547302246094,
0.5795573592185974,
0.7114871740341187,
-0.40037885308265686,
-0.4767863154411316,
0.20651531219482422,
0.1370970755815506,
0.21089936792850494,
0.8373143672943115,
-1.1110193729400635,
0.4916817545890808,
0.20506715774536133,
0.8237152695655823,
0.6678782105445862,
0.365953266620636,
0.5332054495811462,
-0.800571620464325,
-0.392964631319046,
0.08479376882314682,
-0.1213332936167717,
0.09460612386465073,
-0.4140367805957794,
0.5742256045341492,
0.08272800594568253,
-0.6123897433280945,
-0.5104165077209473,
0.24656663835048676,
-0.836669385433197,
-0.5305376052856445,
1.095481276512146,
-0.24601715803146362,
-0.1268245279788971,
-0.4941434860229492,
-0.11822199821472168,
0.2698134779930115,
-0.36506780982017517,
0.9475005269050598,
0.7115826606750488,
0.04946821928024292,
0.12049297243356705,
-0.6808582544326782,
0.5943406224250793,
0.6297769546508789,
-0.5645313262939453,
-0.016301460564136505,
0.3073599338531494,
0.6497639417648315,
-0.021151185035705566,
0.6593277454376221,
-0.12055467814207077,
0.6776541471481323,
-0.3223618268966675,
-0.10252486169338226,
0.012784905731678009,
-0.2772265374660492,
-0.31734904646873474,
0.5069026947021484,
0.1641709953546524,
-0.31822049617767334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01651v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01651v1
|
NLP Systems That Can't Tell Use from Mention Censor Counterspeech, but Teaching the Distinction Helps
| 2024-04-02T05:36:41 | 2024-04-02T05:36:41 |
Kristina Gligoric, Myra Cheng, Lucia Zheng, Esin Durmus, Dan Jurafsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.SI
|
The use of words to convey speaker's intent is traditionally distinguished
from the `mention' of words for quoting what someone said, or pointing out
properties of a word. Here we show that computationally modeling this
use-mention distinction is crucial for dealing with counterspeech online.
Counterspeech that refutes problematic content often mentions harmful language
but is not harmful itself (e.g., calling a vaccine dangerous is not the same as
expressing disapproval of someone for calling vaccines dangerous). We show that
even recent language models fail at distinguishing use from mention, and that
this failure propagates to two key downstream tasks: misinformation and hate
speech detection, resulting in censorship of counterspeech. We introduce
prompting mitigations that teach the use-mention distinction, and show they
reduce these errors. Our work highlights the importance of the use-mention
distinction for NLP and CSS and offers ways to address it.
|
[
-0.5308166742324829,
-0.6872221231460571,
0.14142538607120514,
0.29738497734069824,
-0.22097580134868622,
-0.044176191091537476,
-0.16687041521072388,
-0.7971910834312439,
0.27138417959213257,
0.32626453042030334,
-0.15908415615558624,
0.13045912981033325,
-1.007509708404541,
0.22387617826461792,
-0.7232335805892944,
0.9926928877830505,
0.2555772066116333,
-0.0755816325545311,
-0.08413781970739365,
-0.0274431761354208,
-0.4258894622325897,
-0.5881466865539551,
-0.916816234588623,
-0.3761930465698242,
0.6113014221191406,
0.29471495747566223,
0.7246043682098389,
0.22906455397605896,
0.4625769257545471,
0.21961914002895355,
-0.3075329661369324,
0.03665201738476753,
-0.3685056269168854,
0.26793205738067627,
-0.48867782950401306,
-0.404459148645401,
0.10628101229667664,
-0.023321062326431274,
0.3909948170185089,
0.5309113264083862,
0.06703820824623108,
0.008024913258850574,
0.24450713396072388,
0.3052865266799927,
-0.8543171882629395,
-0.2144557386636734,
-0.9978510737419128,
0.19967636466026306,
-0.37760481238365173,
-0.021038951352238655,
-0.5371755361557007,
-0.1188727468252182,
0.002999573713168502,
-0.5796665549278259,
0.05679566040635109,
-0.09670782089233398,
0.6814631223678589,
0.1552613079547882,
0.05923191457986832,
-0.3960843086242676,
-0.5475600957870483,
0.9841405749320984,
-0.7635981440544128,
0.45458662509918213,
0.916775643825531,
0.20543013513088226,
-0.159574493765831,
-0.6658058166503906,
-0.7057072520256042,
-0.21630173921585083,
-0.20053604245185852,
-0.11334365606307983,
-0.6335622072219849,
-0.07197234779596329,
0.7251543998718262,
-0.1866973489522934,
-0.3159209191799164,
0.07513211667537689,
-0.4162193834781647,
-0.2601280212402344,
0.3120444118976593,
-0.22544606029987335,
0.4393449127674103,
-0.381664901971817,
-0.6289129257202148,
0.07278668135404587,
-0.9789562821388245,
-0.12062335014343262,
0.03393849730491638,
0.2791064381599426,
0.02985561266541481,
0.44591084122657776,
0.10982096940279007,
0.5314729809761047,
-0.050121910870075226,
0.09657714515924454,
-0.05815873667597771,
0.1621517688035965,
-0.20050272345542908,
-0.23160986602306366,
0.7972375750541687,
0.3936375081539154,
0.509212851524353,
-0.120882548391819,
0.30680763721466064,
0.2930716872215271,
0.5072830319404602,
-0.5353771448135376,
-0.29557839035987854,
0.0062508732080459595,
-0.12076633423566818,
-0.09472662210464478,
-0.2615431547164917,
-0.8959481120109558,
-0.6067249178886414,
0.2211250364780426,
0.5095788240432739,
-0.14076115190982819,
-0.19198061525821686,
-0.2834184169769287,
-0.6575551629066467,
-0.0577087476849556,
0.3525773882865906,
-1.0103017091751099,
0.5207919478416443,
0.5305215120315552,
0.6456258893013,
-0.1456936001777649,
-0.12926094233989716,
-0.4717656970024109,
-0.0024386493023484945,
-0.3909992277622223,
0.9543496966362,
-0.6977947950363159,
-0.7374756932258606,
0.017038965597748756,
-0.3699638843536377,
0.04744361340999603,
-0.7503922581672668,
0.45425447821617126,
-0.41949018836021423,
-0.022000236436724663,
-0.571278989315033,
-0.4980165660381317,
-0.1019003838300705,
0.10875558853149414,
-0.5166917443275452,
0.996627151966095,
0.016899216920137405,
-1.0760347843170166,
0.2627563774585724,
-0.349809467792511,
-0.463431715965271,
0.3824516236782074,
-0.19694548845291138,
-0.29930830001831055,
0.10661031305789948,
-0.1434873342514038,
0.304677277803421,
0.011431428603827953,
0.22978146374225616,
-0.28973129391670227,
-0.3283599019050598,
0.40334051847457886,
-0.08620048314332962,
0.95146244764328,
0.3095859885215759,
-0.4776766300201416,
-0.02598794735968113,
-0.34930965304374695,
-0.20929132401943207,
-0.03921348601579666,
-0.09035195410251617,
-0.6244578957557678,
0.254750519990921,
0.07957512885332108,
0.3616040349006653,
-0.246318981051445,
-0.4488055408000946,
-0.031121661886572838,
-0.18779629468917847,
0.4452155828475952,
0.39835190773010254,
-0.161060631275177,
0.19560439884662628,
-0.5737841725349426,
0.6605181097984314,
-0.1578771322965622,
0.1312764436006546,
0.12164146453142166,
-1.0034986734390259,
-0.6703891754150391,
-0.002764841541647911,
0.21094390749931335,
0.6246013641357422,
-0.981133759021759,
0.07334965467453003,
0.15577629208564758,
-0.5866799354553223,
-0.27830925583839417,
0.06892035156488419,
0.7735187411308289,
0.8266969919204712,
0.6869215965270996,
-0.30493199825286865,
-0.7292116284370422,
-0.8867698311805725,
-0.8569788932800293,
-0.37834057211875916,
-0.01706906221807003,
0.23036381602287292,
0.35950735211372375,
0.10697032511234283,
0.6079210638999939,
-0.436608225107193,
-0.01641411893069744,
-0.22960177063941956,
0.33927229046821594,
-0.3964640200138092,
0.20243969559669495,
0.5347466468811035,
-0.7570469975471497,
-0.7146682143211365,
-0.5588296055793762,
-0.4242715537548065,
-0.44347983598709106,
-0.10490988940000534,
0.15242934226989746,
-0.241769939661026,
0.7333338260650635,
-0.3340267241001129,
0.7396950721740723,
0.3753925859928131,
-0.36162734031677246,
0.7345254421234131,
0.15120813250541687,
0.032620035111904144,
-0.7699325680732727,
0.1311943084001541,
0.03902386128902435,
-0.33728304505348206,
-0.7657869458198547,
0.11821819096803665,
0.004380034748464823,
-0.16782823204994202,
-0.7893381714820862,
0.7383482456207275,
0.02308686263859272,
0.31485193967819214,
-0.4135250449180603,
0.21603702008724213,
-0.016825513914227486,
0.25939956307411194,
0.30012446641921997,
0.6478763818740845,
0.42843934893608093,
-0.9312449097633362,
-0.04465183615684509,
0.40578460693359375,
-0.2722919285297394,
0.8331111073493958,
-0.39133012294769287,
0.016043422743678093,
0.271065354347229,
0.01980467699468136,
-0.6757155060768127,
0.15619999170303345,
0.4890778660774231,
-0.7474794387817383,
0.16456089913845062,
-0.26598218083381653,
-0.4696580469608307,
-0.27980300784111023,
-0.365207701921463,
0.3371822237968445,
0.39954328536987305,
-0.3980647921562195,
0.15640009939670563,
0.6715810894966125,
-0.18619342148303986,
-0.8197859525680542,
-1.1551458835601807,
0.32622990012168884,
-0.3678227365016937,
-0.058609165251255035,
0.5647121667861938,
-0.24175074696540833,
-0.44654661417007446,
-0.09494335204362869,
-0.007514297030866146,
-0.09026839584112167,
0.48428958654403687,
0.38102081418037415,
-0.059051986783742905,
0.32237598299980164,
0.41492387652397156,
-0.022371383383870125,
-0.18185150623321533,
0.0647435188293457,
0.09570656716823578,
0.3446599543094635,
0.3808719515800476,
-0.31271493434906006,
-0.3555242121219635,
0.7199504375457764,
0.14515379071235657,
0.07483656704425812,
0.7838454246520996,
0.3466217815876007,
-0.5293101668357849,
-0.5513424277305603,
-0.514289915561676,
-0.2580619752407074,
-0.4272562563419342,
0.08084417134523392,
0.08265731483697891,
-0.9292181134223938,
0.42599862813949585,
0.036711435765028,
0.11572932451963425,
0.5901988744735718,
0.10117653757333755,
-0.34543469548225403,
0.6221949458122253,
0.512531578540802,
0.27851685881614685,
0.6016221642494202,
0.24647507071495056,
0.2611275315284729,
-0.8180581331253052,
-0.05334535613656044,
-1.0507042407989502,
-0.09727735072374344,
-0.5673559904098511,
-0.3400500416755676,
0.29554545879364014,
0.3274708092212677,
-0.19362197816371918,
0.7964502573013306,
-0.6090262532234192,
0.3814085125923157,
0.44678598642349243,
-0.22820547223091125,
0.2435276359319687,
0.2403574436903,
-0.2419433891773224,
-0.3991168439388275,
-0.6642424464225769,
-0.31075602769851685,
0.7122502326965332,
0.020905187353491783,
0.4478330910205841,
0.1695738136768341,
0.45614245533943176,
0.6821322441101074,
0.40613409876823425,
-0.7900357246398926,
0.7834869027137756,
-0.29817304015159607,
-0.7685734629631042,
-0.057136714458465576,
-0.2815580666065216,
-1.026678204536438,
0.41346436738967896,
-0.4123893678188324,
-0.9844194650650024,
0.21753904223442078,
0.37271183729171753,
-0.2514342963695526,
0.5838900804519653,
-0.6484954357147217,
0.6059442758560181,
0.26967206597328186,
-0.11778343468904495,
-0.4278346598148346,
-0.330314964056015,
0.12236670404672623,
-0.04403090476989746,
0.6653426885604858,
0.010767105966806412,
0.16114716231822968,
0.9834464192390442,
-0.3617821931838989,
1.1437619924545288,
-0.09698589891195297,
0.09086775779724121,
0.5432830452919006,
0.39616915583610535,
0.14494428038597107,
-0.36324238777160645,
-0.13557355105876923,
0.39461538195610046,
-0.06161663681268692,
-0.15301817655563354,
-0.25028368830680847,
0.6178992390632629,
-0.4248950481414795,
-0.6183425784111023,
-0.4621874988079071,
0.00798107124865055,
-0.2334233969449997,
0.25156646966934204,
0.5627051591873169,
0.08545858412981033,
-0.23164378106594086,
0.006372896488755941,
0.4019816517829895,
-0.181178018450737,
0.5120757818222046,
0.5321881175041199,
-0.30042004585266113,
-0.31893619894981384,
0.9156960248947144,
0.2695850431919098,
0.34734398126602173,
0.21721719205379486,
0.3959892988204956,
-0.30741673707962036,
-0.3627012073993683,
-0.2899622321128845,
0.2154804766178131,
-1.0221649408340454,
-0.31824570894241333,
-0.6857143044471741,
-0.3141305148601532,
-0.39754918217658997,
-0.3702733814716339,
-0.13119162619113922,
-0.6257778406143188,
-0.29750901460647583,
-0.01377318799495697,
0.3387303352355957,
0.9548656940460205,
-0.4230876863002777,
0.43140771985054016,
-0.6081134080886841,
0.4462609589099884,
0.5465988516807556,
0.352190762758255,
0.24998188018798828,
-0.7259848117828369,
-0.0874173492193222,
-0.22294577956199646,
-0.40345367789268494,
-1.2281808853149414,
0.3753450810909271,
0.0975429117679596,
0.5509979128837585,
0.3609479069709778,
0.24309949576854706,
0.5302151441574097,
-0.5815961360931396,
0.9348915219306946,
0.33527660369873047,
-1.1748219728469849,
0.7154747843742371,
-0.04491773247718811,
0.2439446896314621,
0.37550777196884155,
0.7157844305038452,
-1.1572630405426025,
-0.6807090044021606,
-0.8504088521003723,
-0.953813374042511,
0.5237758159637451,
0.13901358842849731,
0.23099485039710999,
-0.7733543515205383,
0.02558271214365959,
0.03507392853498459,
0.18898262083530426,
-0.9034073352813721,
-0.3835069239139557,
-0.2496272325515747,
0.4070640206336975,
0.2336612194776535,
-0.6673939824104309,
-0.306724488735199,
-0.17766554653644562,
0.6983473300933838,
0.27484092116355896,
0.21148797869682312,
0.1481231451034546,
-0.3821728229522705,
-0.033089835196733475,
0.4487222731113434,
0.6480063796043396,
0.60298091173172,
0.31480756402015686,
0.5070764422416687,
0.26760920882225037,
-0.5584636330604553,
-0.29388946294784546,
-0.07771849632263184,
-0.4628196060657501,
0.02219340205192566,
0.46557971835136414,
0.4918936491012573,
0.5939052104949951,
-0.5100879669189453,
0.44694778323173523,
0.2064516246318817,
-0.13858847320079803,
-0.22688385844230652,
0.26283058524131775,
0.3815876543521881,
-0.14651064574718475,
0.20550547540187836,
0.19812598824501038,
-0.022438911721110344,
-0.2381850779056549,
0.288920134305954,
0.4570629596710205,
-0.5278851985931396,
-0.2517862319946289,
0.5725238919258118,
0.2301357239484787,
-0.48089468479156494,
0.5227361917495728,
-0.1112939640879631,
-0.5678093433380127,
0.5633540153503418,
0.6826583743095398,
0.7471616268157959,
-0.6050096750259399,
0.31927213072776794,
0.5603022575378418,
0.07313891500234604,
0.08766432106494904,
0.21449372172355652,
-0.22389887273311615,
-0.7546389698982239,
-0.18821875751018524,
-0.49195361137390137,
-0.7075205445289612,
0.26408177614212036,
-0.5206338763237,
0.16321226954460144,
-0.9703907370567322,
-0.4981372058391571,
0.539986789226532,
-0.40458714962005615,
-0.5152812600135803,
0.17308753728866577,
0.22704748809337616,
0.8433707356452942,
-1.0550755262374878,
0.5011072754859924,
0.2931300699710846,
-0.35804635286331177,
-0.49464452266693115,
-0.13482286036014557,
0.2664003074169159,
-0.5279592871665955,
0.6277281045913696,
0.1360531449317932,
-0.4684706926345825,
-0.31282058358192444,
-0.7007622718811035,
-0.5133488178253174,
0.2604970932006836,
0.06189307942986488,
-0.5601540207862854,
0.43871110677719116,
-0.026923449710011482,
0.5116990208625793,
-0.06525322049856186,
0.42894020676612854,
-0.055135466158390045,
0.37001317739486694,
0.16930758953094482,
-1.1051114797592163,
0.1018902137875557,
-0.07633469998836517,
-0.3036974370479584,
0.006723091471940279,
-0.38327938318252563,
0.6883075833320618,
-0.2706442177295685,
-0.5318089723587036,
-0.5310678482055664,
0.20239700376987457,
-0.021225541830062866,
0.1363074630498886,
0.5859820246696472,
0.5287850499153137,
0.5123975872993469,
0.10395155847072601,
0.8522669672966003,
0.3055313229560852,
0.12241247296333313,
1.3315032720565796,
-0.15491324663162231,
1.3075228929519653,
0.3863831162452698,
-0.45186087489128113,
0.5924187302589417,
0.1376807689666748,
-0.058160651475191116,
0.12482905387878418,
0.351385235786438,
-0.41545358300209045,
-0.240729421377182,
-0.2868115305900574,
-0.37888503074645996,
0.3962889611721039,
0.9680528044700623,
-0.3400385081768036,
-0.5470965504646301,
-0.08793086558580399,
0.4284760057926178,
0.42083296179771423,
-0.20744578540325165,
0.892695963382721,
0.47316956520080566,
-0.8059718608856201,
0.7606230974197388,
-0.0422576442360878,
0.756891667842865,
-0.6419106125831604,
-0.1595958173274994,
0.14457528293132782,
-0.1413058042526245,
-0.3832576274871826,
-0.8136128783226013,
0.7835447788238525,
0.28744709491729736,
-0.15881672501564026,
-0.2656027674674988,
0.9137841463088989,
-0.18652699887752533,
-0.06637228280305862,
0.6595607399940491,
0.32709968090057373,
0.38763073086738586,
-0.13695910573005676,
-0.8089204430580139,
-0.11491319537162781,
-0.09258747845888138,
0.092119500041008,
0.42331090569496155,
-0.15820381045341492,
-0.3923191428184509,
0.8251374959945679,
0.6308566331863403,
0.3004048764705658,
0.06320749968290329,
0.22863063216209412,
0.7567700147628784,
-0.6766427755355835,
-0.5009555220603943,
-0.855434775352478,
0.4606618285179138,
-0.17660298943519592,
-0.17508690059185028,
0.7500004172325134,
0.22791825234889984,
1.0111985206604004,
-0.04396408423781395,
0.8862378001213074,
-0.062371715903282166,
0.8533638715744019,
-0.0064904941245913506,
0.9441554546356201,
-0.23880058526992798,
0.19048334658145905,
-0.38838690519332886,
-0.5675235390663147,
-0.6125920414924622,
0.6567105650901794,
-0.33023396134376526,
-0.018718523904681206,
0.785812258720398,
0.6157286167144775,
0.16986685991287231,
0.11818347871303558,
0.5684834122657776,
0.2731997072696686,
0.26837319135665894,
0.22352087497711182,
0.7659116983413696,
-0.08890342712402344,
0.6661312580108643,
-0.25049078464508057,
-0.19695693254470825,
-0.2430570125579834,
-1.0718401670455933,
-0.9253156781196594,
-0.6072710156440735,
-0.5528452396392822,
-0.4864182770252228,
0.09435518831014633,
0.5596972107887268,
0.7102065086364746,
-1.0522572994232178,
0.01003633439540863,
0.10549453645944595,
0.4211574196815491,
-0.4340025782585144,
-0.18905459344387054,
0.2711638808250427,
-0.34625008702278137,
-0.45451924204826355,
0.5511202216148376,
0.2083233892917633,
-0.04621293023228645,
-0.1385219246149063,
0.4287318289279938,
-0.31117767095565796,
0.26067692041397095,
0.5111502408981323,
0.8770335912704468,
-0.840560257434845,
-0.4075047969818115,
-0.3909841477870941,
-0.06857901811599731,
-0.005526128690689802,
0.8133942484855652,
-0.8308705687522888,
0.803109884262085,
0.7080286741256714,
0.3609446883201599,
0.1970517486333847,
-0.23105798661708832,
0.28025761246681213,
-0.6624234318733215,
-0.04484231397509575,
0.4708130955696106,
0.24035024642944336,
0.47271355986595154,
-0.3885160982608795,
0.14223672449588776,
0.44156473875045776,
-0.3717500865459442,
-0.5490925312042236,
0.6767447590827942,
-0.7985496520996094,
-0.5056347250938416,
0.9185810089111328,
-0.3124382197856903,
-0.06098141148686409,
-0.7352817058563232,
0.006395835895091295,
0.18754372000694275,
-0.29156869649887085,
0.8704981803894043,
0.8552759885787964,
0.01105224248021841,
-0.29640182852745056,
-0.669014573097229,
1.0661863088607788,
0.5127138495445251,
-0.5054149627685547,
0.21976587176322937,
0.1405636966228485,
0.4247673749923706,
0.3980925381183624,
0.7399170994758606,
-0.30000609159469604,
0.30467402935028076,
0.25418561697006226,
0.06768270581960678,
0.07119206339120865,
-0.3400166928768158,
-0.1577058732509613,
0.1354694962501526,
0.20534361898899078,
-0.036009449511766434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08567v1
|
CATP: Cross-Attention Token Pruning for Accuracy Preserved Multimodal Model Inference
| 2024-04-02T04:35:35 | 2024-04-02T04:35:35 |
Ruqi Liao, Chuqing Zhao, Jin Li, Weiqi Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In response to the rising interest in large multimodal models, we introduce
Cross-Attention Token Pruning (CATP), a precision-focused token pruning method.
Our approach leverages cross-attention layers in multimodal models, exemplified
by BLIP-2, to extract valuable information for token importance determination.
CATP employs a refined voting strategy across model heads and layers. In
evaluations, CATP achieves up to 12.1X higher accuracy compared to existing
token pruning methods, addressing the trade-off between computational
efficiency and model precision.
|
[
-0.3325681686401367,
-0.685313880443573,
0.29527774453163147,
0.7162743210792542,
-0.2761605679988861,
0.15656131505966187,
-0.14715668559074402,
-0.3812856674194336,
0.3348730504512787,
0.3125554025173187,
-0.6025645136833191,
-0.2909707725048065,
-0.438556432723999,
-0.2509462535381317,
-0.20763640105724335,
0.7569843530654907,
0.385500431060791,
0.1920860856771469,
-0.347407728433609,
0.029483839869499207,
-0.589348316192627,
-0.6772821545600891,
-0.6318286657333374,
-0.025735627859830856,
0.7445844411849976,
0.6117650270462036,
0.6021002531051636,
0.8902773261070251,
0.8996814489364624,
0.19198855757713318,
-0.25994572043418884,
0.4247528910636902,
-0.3192049562931061,
-0.16598616540431976,
-0.4608931839466095,
-0.8820295929908752,
-0.5556581616401672,
0.0822187066078186,
0.5906505584716797,
0.6352450847625732,
0.14520017802715302,
0.6310466527938843,
0.05693203955888748,
0.4522258937358856,
-1.091050624847412,
0.04028195142745972,
-0.687971830368042,
0.24341973662376404,
-0.36764299869537354,
-0.5184503793716431,
-0.7434574365615845,
-0.03666391968727112,
-0.08026433736085892,
-0.44582846760749817,
0.6276808977127075,
0.15884993970394135,
0.9126913547515869,
0.3382859230041504,
-0.596830427646637,
0.21398226916790009,
-0.666292667388916,
1.117887258529663,
-0.5121630430221558,
0.517803966999054,
0.37465667724609375,
0.18617601692676544,
0.020761163905262947,
-1.2238277196884155,
-0.46070972084999084,
0.12519854307174683,
0.11627835780382156,
0.1444443017244339,
0.1151006817817688,
0.414096862077713,
0.3673804998397827,
0.3309093117713928,
-0.274175763130188,
-0.18315987288951874,
-0.2285023331642151,
-0.4280102550983429,
0.393174946308136,
0.01574576087296009,
0.049754418432712555,
-0.2208780199289322,
-0.9207246899604797,
-0.39368364214897156,
-0.7218160629272461,
0.3719817101955414,
0.02309001423418522,
0.18277540802955627,
0.19710789620876312,
0.9262378215789795,
-0.14589454233646393,
0.5219924449920654,
0.42064544558525085,
-0.25270578265190125,
0.3045181632041931,
-0.8056389689445496,
-0.41420575976371765,
-0.05994952842593193,
0.46221786737442017,
0.705366849899292,
0.02232879213988781,
-0.08295980095863342,
0.021106461063027382,
0.12829305231571198,
0.3119431138038635,
-0.6406568884849548,
-0.083220936357975,
0.5255107879638672,
-0.8186852931976318,
-0.09744857996702194,
0.20182962715625763,
-1.0575554370880127,
0.16894817352294922,
-0.2548525929450989,
0.3551035225391388,
-0.11314167827367783,
-0.29597949981689453,
-0.03570450097322464,
-0.6005141139030457,
-0.0017538843676447868,
0.27937793731689453,
-1.015950322151184,
-0.00025625136913731694,
1.1562752723693848,
1.0862147808074951,
-0.34788528084754944,
-0.37916725873947144,
-0.8048734068870544,
0.43855953216552734,
-0.5616962313652039,
0.5661165118217468,
-0.8295025825500488,
-0.3054768741130829,
-0.3016939163208008,
0.1705443114042282,
-0.12217345088720322,
-0.3217616379261017,
0.7102470397949219,
-0.24783855676651,
-0.1850103884935379,
-0.5090279579162598,
-0.39791542291641235,
-0.3317829966545105,
0.48450127243995667,
-0.6655643582344055,
1.1941285133361816,
-0.1753724068403244,
-0.9151362776756287,
0.8735806941986084,
-0.5586224794387817,
-0.14582256972789764,
-0.1116974726319313,
0.18791519105434418,
-0.567375659942627,
0.44611403346061707,
0.5061342120170593,
0.5082310438156128,
-0.09980699419975281,
0.3770187497138977,
-0.87760329246521,
-0.08279088139533997,
-0.04540524631738663,
-0.5597180724143982,
0.7553808689117432,
-0.060596343129873276,
-0.29535436630249023,
0.39006564021110535,
-0.6729741096496582,
0.1496312916278839,
-0.09583838284015656,
-0.09188123047351837,
-0.28260788321495056,
-0.2953657805919647,
0.3050804138183594,
0.495143324136734,
0.30402159690856934,
-0.8094441890716553,
0.13073232769966125,
-0.4416774809360504,
0.7316704988479614,
0.7085186243057251,
0.05763333663344383,
0.35995328426361084,
-0.3805064260959625,
0.5651144981384277,
0.06000238284468651,
0.5298428535461426,
-0.2749069035053253,
-0.8177199363708496,
-0.6761058568954468,
-0.47408273816108704,
0.6495521068572998,
0.3986318111419678,
-0.5843209028244019,
0.0913166031241417,
-0.2742387652397156,
-0.5819538235664368,
-0.3381630778312683,
-0.09643152356147766,
0.6956826448440552,
0.2646387219429016,
0.26847079396247864,
-0.6501407623291016,
-0.5711345672607422,
-1.0597175359725952,
-0.18078692257404327,
-0.31804394721984863,
0.02392791211605072,
0.2796877920627594,
0.46798059344291687,
0.13232830166816711,
1.1373448371887207,
-0.18475621938705444,
-0.21002811193466187,
-0.16504691541194916,
0.24402323365211487,
-0.23619112372398376,
0.8437206149101257,
0.5025355219841003,
-1.101097822189331,
-0.279496431350708,
-0.04371579363942146,
-0.10755404829978943,
0.18265773355960846,
-0.23095481097698212,
-0.17742250859737396,
-0.1791374683380127,
0.43223583698272705,
-1.0068359375,
0.7010951638221741,
0.49196839332580566,
-0.22092275321483612,
0.5381585955619812,
0.11657090485095978,
0.2121012657880783,
-0.833865761756897,
0.45483776926994324,
-0.07152135670185089,
-0.47964322566986084,
-0.5500735640525818,
0.24332605302333832,
0.29819488525390625,
-0.1063641831278801,
-0.6163340210914612,
0.8533637523651123,
-0.4849133789539337,
-0.4842967689037323,
0.07472416013479233,
-0.20517054200172424,
0.3645700514316559,
0.8615795373916626,
0.36731433868408203,
0.6667236089706421,
0.07319362461566925,
-0.41772228479385376,
0.18273873627185822,
0.1849011480808258,
-0.05203228443861008,
0.368828684091568,
-0.6098470687866211,
0.23827362060546875,
0.2687179446220398,
0.08142488449811935,
-1.4311285018920898,
-0.17591866850852966,
0.06587320566177368,
-0.7176682949066162,
0.24957437813282013,
-0.22827066481113434,
-0.43770426511764526,
-0.385753333568573,
-0.5792124271392822,
0.7829928398132324,
-0.13320274651050568,
-0.4798851013183594,
0.6574822664260864,
0.5345871448516846,
-0.16963155567646027,
-0.902475893497467,
-0.8153502345085144,
0.13965730369091034,
-0.15164737403392792,
-0.4118902087211609,
0.5203081369400024,
0.20913287997245789,
0.09598030149936676,
-0.1793309897184372,
-0.011727792210876942,
-0.15686248242855072,
0.04078393802046776,
0.44167155027389526,
0.027966760098934174,
-0.1616915762424469,
0.31581249833106995,
-0.044155921787023544,
-0.24825334548950195,
-0.0545206256210804,
0.03709901124238968,
0.8016902208328247,
0.2755795419216156,
-0.760295033454895,
-0.7614353895187378,
0.36356768012046814,
0.6770753860473633,
-0.6796678304672241,
0.1469859629869461,
0.7441204190254211,
-0.3875291347503662,
-0.039792049676179886,
-0.5888849496841431,
-0.46816158294677734,
-0.41034039855003357,
0.39942774176597595,
-0.48928090929985046,
-0.6241860389709473,
0.4329788386821747,
-0.04403621703386307,
0.29791468381881714,
0.21983441710472107,
0.6673956513404846,
0.32368746399879456,
1.5079177618026733,
0.7360718250274658,
0.14416103065013885,
0.7249575853347778,
0.08753390610218048,
0.027874458581209183,
-0.8924595713615417,
-0.3739050626754761,
-0.6061951518058777,
-0.48280277848243713,
-0.23437108099460602,
-0.8463070392608643,
0.13323725759983063,
-0.0010846714721992612,
-0.021295741200447083,
-0.057746872305870056,
-0.7022683024406433,
0.14716488122940063,
0.9930806756019592,
0.4208090305328369,
0.13278011977672577,
0.12390536069869995,
0.0772419422864914,
-0.2368081659078598,
-0.8821232914924622,
-0.09983819723129272,
1.364148497581482,
0.7253926992416382,
0.34144020080566406,
-0.11465948820114136,
0.08674104511737823,
0.14367841184139252,
0.2238541543483734,
-0.7411095499992371,
0.42125099897384644,
0.17113494873046875,
-1.2193225622177124,
-0.43897074460983276,
-0.17518728971481323,
-0.7166282534599304,
0.25784558057785034,
-0.0797140821814537,
-0.7570897936820984,
0.6426885724067688,
0.646623432636261,
-0.5430604219436646,
0.26809749007225037,
-0.8352898359298706,
1.151689052581787,
0.00069883291143924,
-0.5848180055618286,
-0.46680891513824463,
-0.8498836755752563,
0.49154922366142273,
0.27083921432495117,
-0.19364513456821442,
-0.07144458591938019,
-0.4399206340312958,
0.7501957416534424,
-0.38597238063812256,
1.0484251976013184,
-0.16314134001731873,
0.35643282532691956,
0.250654399394989,
0.07136695832014084,
0.5266416072845459,
0.17709128558635712,
0.18549089133739471,
0.3199518322944641,
0.1372614949941635,
-0.584921658039093,
-0.5031261444091797,
0.25816887617111206,
-0.29850220680236816,
-0.5504265427589417,
-0.15865398943424225,
-0.5505803227424622,
-0.12871244549751282,
0.15816065669059753,
0.04209453985095024,
0.5807641744613647,
0.11117465049028397,
0.5651142001152039,
0.27062177658081055,
0.0738753080368042,
0.6888912916183472,
-0.1187853068113327,
-0.27405446767807007,
-0.700391948223114,
0.9433413743972778,
0.11206051707267761,
0.5116590857505798,
0.7242531776428223,
0.04376210272312164,
-0.5058860778808594,
-0.4559767246246338,
-0.49080637097358704,
0.12045399844646454,
-0.6849950551986694,
-0.207034632563591,
-0.7879156470298767,
0.029956450685858727,
-0.3672691583633423,
-0.08444428443908691,
-0.6980382800102234,
-0.8002896308898926,
-0.12793654203414917,
-0.0062581803649663925,
0.04752345755696297,
0.12777189910411835,
-0.3592625856399536,
0.42765945196151733,
-0.7960765361785889,
0.3313548266887665,
0.3565170168876648,
0.19133393466472626,
0.11219140887260437,
-0.1424015611410141,
0.015295030549168587,
0.06036752834916115,
-0.25914356112480164,
-0.7699663043022156,
0.4148702621459961,
0.3453482389450073,
0.4709348678588867,
0.6093658804893494,
-0.17169377207756042,
1.151537537574768,
-0.18916942179203033,
0.7881864309310913,
0.34553566575050354,
-1.2358750104904175,
0.5345150828361511,
-0.09460258483886719,
0.3195052146911621,
0.5717606544494629,
0.02303752861917019,
-0.5470932126045227,
-0.2688522934913635,
-0.7650737762451172,
-0.7133223414421082,
0.7526494860649109,
0.06433318555355072,
-0.25590550899505615,
-0.1136792004108429,
0.3069929778575897,
-0.0751766487956047,
0.5146143436431885,
-0.6908832788467407,
0.07949089258909225,
-0.23787446320056915,
-0.17053550481796265,
-0.18741293251514435,
-0.6075141429901123,
-0.13895054161548615,
-0.2087283730506897,
0.366426944732666,
-0.28305670619010925,
0.2543333172798157,
0.5654088854789734,
0.01282891072332859,
-0.0669514462351799,
-0.2704961895942688,
0.7292934656143188,
0.9769649505615234,
-0.19661876559257507,
0.24390527606010437,
0.07938763499259949,
-0.8013383746147156,
-0.02360483445227146,
-0.3817155063152313,
-0.08857307583093643,
0.11109612137079239,
0.5594925880432129,
0.5821455121040344,
0.28457674384117126,
-0.6829851865768433,
0.840899646282196,
-0.04053797200322151,
0.016511807218194008,
0.03253718093037605,
-0.17493493854999542,
-0.19185854494571686,
0.1000353991985321,
0.35913437604904175,
0.3065676987171173,
0.33320680260658264,
-0.3959425091743469,
0.4978475272655487,
0.7192543148994446,
-0.8038948774337769,
-0.24372786283493042,
0.8058910965919495,
0.3457172214984894,
-0.38307780027389526,
0.1887027621269226,
0.13888303935527802,
-0.5248920917510986,
0.9999421834945679,
0.41980239748954773,
0.7499707937240601,
-0.34571003913879395,
0.21893243491649628,
0.5184545516967773,
0.45088547468185425,
-0.11660879850387573,
0.1735723912715912,
-0.4620702862739563,
-0.5193458199501038,
-0.8100561499595642,
-0.4011536240577698,
-0.5748539566993713,
-0.08297736197710037,
-0.8493682146072388,
0.33886006474494934,
-0.8454293608665466,
-0.6077569723129272,
0.24344101548194885,
-0.07721030712127686,
-0.3163999021053314,
0.4581117630004883,
-0.09793326258659363,
0.9118186831474304,
-0.7917293310165405,
0.5840625762939453,
0.649824857711792,
-0.10021530091762543,
-0.7077312469482422,
-0.11561103910207748,
-0.0848139300942421,
-0.7895970940589905,
0.8156360387802124,
0.4734582304954529,
0.07534182816743851,
0.07799676060676575,
-0.5273745059967041,
-1.0380760431289673,
0.7402758002281189,
0.2690950930118561,
-0.9261626601219177,
-0.13697485625743866,
0.18426676094532013,
0.09330134093761444,
-0.10295634716749191,
0.5007292628288269,
0.23456545174121857,
0.42383918166160583,
0.16750843822956085,
-1.2348381280899048,
-0.08342385292053223,
-0.16428853571414948,
-0.016802169382572174,
0.33294031023979187,
-1.0333211421966553,
0.9270147085189819,
-0.11267834156751633,
-0.3363599479198456,
-0.2962995171546936,
0.7049016356468201,
0.38715898990631104,
0.6460305452346802,
0.7780711650848389,
0.6257790327072144,
0.482643723487854,
-0.007831841707229614,
0.7454962134361267,
-0.39093708992004395,
0.44063013792037964,
0.9765024781227112,
-0.09232073277235031,
0.8783969283103943,
0.970833957195282,
-0.13375236093997955,
-0.03916560113430023,
1.0123945474624634,
0.003548866603523493,
0.49465394020080566,
-0.45638352632522583,
0.21646307408809662,
-0.7026379704475403,
-0.190977081656456,
-0.21058809757232666,
0.6804770827293396,
0.3392219543457031,
-0.32074254751205444,
-0.005238322541117668,
0.017443334683775902,
-0.04785933718085289,
-0.3354945480823517,
-0.4520960748195648,
0.6339051127433777,
-0.11905503273010254,
-1.0470151901245117,
0.2918653190135956,
-0.07361328601837158,
0.3195236027240753,
-0.19020074605941772,
-0.4099874198436737,
0.16186906397342682,
0.3783903121948242,
-0.059505365788936615,
-0.6939980983734131,
0.33567461371421814,
-0.46566107869148254,
-0.3666006624698639,
-0.04623701423406601,
0.6745607852935791,
-0.3156774640083313,
-0.7046093940734863,
0.14767900109291077,
0.12624254822731018,
0.027055298909544945,
-0.20302557945251465,
-0.8454325795173645,
0.005906847305595875,
0.2997257709503174,
-0.37904947996139526,
0.006810233928263187,
0.4618019461631775,
-0.32950812578201294,
0.8493872284889221,
1.0490788221359253,
0.056078922003507614,
0.292400598526001,
-0.15439675748348236,
0.68470698595047,
-0.5490349531173706,
-0.6718646883964539,
-1.0012645721435547,
0.6023310422897339,
-0.4345264136791229,
-0.8170486688613892,
0.7377750277519226,
0.7324219346046448,
0.6672595739364624,
0.06063730642199516,
0.42858821153640747,
0.06517324596643448,
0.6692523956298828,
-0.4580967128276825,
0.11820229142904282,
-0.7535316944122314,
-0.2266366183757782,
-0.17752447724342346,
-0.7924568057060242,
-0.5506021976470947,
0.38144588470458984,
-0.3133968114852905,
-0.07331347465515137,
0.6088921427726746,
0.905937910079956,
-0.28853198885917664,
-0.19647842645645142,
0.286461740732193,
-0.20156195759773254,
0.25947800278663635,
0.6066027879714966,
0.5946933627128601,
-0.11821069568395615,
0.5890035629272461,
-0.6284750699996948,
-0.2886507213115692,
-0.6340566873550415,
-0.8629871010780334,
-1.0656968355178833,
-0.5552862286567688,
-0.2082095891237259,
-0.09984099119901657,
-0.07537717372179031,
0.7646121978759766,
1.2807698249816895,
-0.6623488068580627,
0.23418155312538147,
-0.09352969378232956,
0.22226482629776,
-0.49790534377098083,
-0.20261868834495544,
0.5731210112571716,
-0.4065498411655426,
-0.9398564696311951,
-0.12021879106760025,
0.6811704039573669,
-0.17282186448574066,
-0.3712540864944458,
0.36058443784713745,
-0.3606846034526825,
0.09565704315900803,
0.48868483304977417,
0.17882297933101654,
-0.9209177494049072,
-0.4354507625102997,
-0.07178594917058945,
-0.06274084001779556,
0.2913488745689392,
0.8637061715126038,
-0.4329189658164978,
0.56830894947052,
0.7253148555755615,
0.6216913461685181,
0.7983512878417969,
0.5114963054656982,
0.7242809534072876,
-0.9202686548233032,
0.7990119457244873,
0.3591557741165161,
0.23609089851379395,
0.3251725435256958,
-0.32496458292007446,
0.41399234533309937,
0.4711555242538452,
-0.5837551355361938,
-1.3110359907150269,
0.19720974564552307,
-1.2120051383972168,
-0.25280430912971497,
1.0736935138702393,
-0.29636675119400024,
-0.7642498016357422,
-0.1906920224428177,
-0.49714434146881104,
0.09363967925310135,
-0.25713059306144714,
0.5466768145561218,
0.5670361518859863,
0.2218989133834839,
-0.5573762059211731,
-0.4702123701572418,
0.6217013597488403,
0.8309043049812317,
-0.4631231725215912,
0.21545438468456268,
0.09047221392393112,
-0.09272773563861847,
0.6044992804527283,
0.372158020734787,
-0.08002036064863205,
0.6103128790855408,
0.36687472462654114,
0.3828948438167572,
0.06266183406114578,
-0.6376011967658997,
0.07552444189786911,
0.846671462059021,
0.021918797865509987,
-0.6597930192947388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01626v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01626v2
|
Entity Disambiguation via Fusion Entity Decoding
| 2024-04-02T04:27:54 | 2024-05-08T01:06:24 |
Junxiong Wang, Ali Mousavi, Omar Attia, Ronak Pradeep, Saloni Potdar, Alexander M. Rush, Umar Farooq Minhas, Yunyao Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Entity disambiguation (ED), which links the mentions of ambiguous entities to
their referent entities in a knowledge base, serves as a core component in
entity linking (EL). Existing generative approaches demonstrate improved
accuracy compared to classification approaches under the standardized ZELDA
benchmark. Nevertheless, generative approaches suffer from the need for
large-scale pre-training and inefficient generation. Most importantly, entity
descriptions, which could contain crucial information to distinguish similar
entities from each other, are often overlooked. We propose an encoder-decoder
model to disambiguate entities with more detailed entity descriptions. Given
text and candidate entities, the encoder learns interactions between the text
and each candidate entity, producing representations for each entity candidate.
The decoder then fuses the representations of entity candidates together and
selects the correct entity. Our experiments, conducted on various entity
disambiguation benchmarks, demonstrate the strong and robust performance of
this model, particularly +1.5% in the ZELDA benchmark compared with GENRE.
Furthermore, we integrate this approach into the retrieval/reader framework and
observe +1.5% improvements in end-to-end entity linking in the GERBIL benchmark
compared with EntQA.
|
[
-0.6588950753211975,
-0.6539692878723145,
0.429065078496933,
-0.1924566626548767,
-0.4770090878009796,
0.29609671235084534,
-0.006509928964078426,
-0.8295916318893433,
0.30314138531684875,
0.2124694287776947,
-0.44548940658569336,
-0.5830881595611572,
-0.43061769008636475,
0.4681074619293213,
-0.47526195645332336,
0.7516263723373413,
-0.006675833836197853,
0.008478830568492413,
-0.5632283091545105,
-0.07001286745071411,
-0.1702573001384735,
-0.19058556854724884,
-0.41251546144485474,
-0.3665785491466522,
0.33784952759742737,
-0.028130942955613136,
0.6189347505569458,
0.601917028427124,
0.399222195148468,
0.23168961703777313,
-0.22443698346614838,
0.27248597145080566,
-0.446747750043869,
0.32401496171951294,
-0.41427361965179443,
-0.3842240571975708,
-0.30682626366615295,
-0.4925965368747711,
0.5898757576942444,
0.743644118309021,
-0.21111103892326355,
0.08096952736377716,
0.11701768636703491,
0.38810208439826965,
-0.7222047448158264,
0.21454687416553497,
-0.7571046948432922,
-0.2159806787967682,
-0.42561572790145874,
0.010637388564646244,
-0.4932127892971039,
-0.06886055320501328,
0.15848186612129211,
-0.8087683320045471,
0.5202866792678833,
0.4142460525035858,
1.0803641080856323,
0.310860276222229,
-0.5125673413276672,
-0.23436212539672852,
-0.7903796434402466,
0.3353932499885559,
-0.25889092683792114,
0.745764434337616,
0.16983918845653534,
0.12873566150665283,
-0.07442077994346619,
-0.5606138706207275,
-0.9067122340202332,
0.03522000461816788,
-0.21384771168231964,
0.07564838230609894,
-0.3238174617290497,
0.34222865104675293,
0.2829640805721283,
0.533923327922821,
-0.6292443871498108,
0.2131338119506836,
-0.23629465699195862,
-0.11323008686304092,
0.44656607508659363,
0.03712669014930725,
0.26328521966934204,
-0.28621000051498413,
-0.5897539854049683,
-0.13143348693847656,
-0.9439927935600281,
-0.4808669984340668,
0.34782400727272034,
-0.1363552212715149,
0.4936944842338562,
0.5413937568664551,
-0.25630804896354675,
0.7866040468215942,
0.39928382635116577,
0.0924941897392273,
0.28947779536247253,
-0.2697312533855438,
-0.16738763451576233,
0.4175493121147156,
0.5038998126983643,
0.39054781198501587,
-0.3862561583518982,
-0.606090784072876,
-0.27280116081237793,
0.21207942068576813,
0.0813770592212677,
-0.816990315914154,
-0.4251822531223297,
0.27215826511383057,
-0.37496379017829895,
0.18612350523471832,
-0.046416766941547394,
-0.9306743144989014,
-0.37327390909194946,
-0.058824196457862854,
0.5402920246124268,
-0.6601521372795105,
-0.3141001760959625,
0.2945230007171631,
-0.2012508064508438,
0.1568259745836258,
0.19091612100601196,
-0.9762876033782959,
0.13054724037647247,
0.5528557300567627,
0.5156419277191162,
-0.07646356523036957,
-0.16835655272006989,
-0.14830726385116577,
0.7247985005378723,
0.05572620406746864,
0.918635904788971,
-0.6635915040969849,
-0.5171206593513489,
-0.13993942737579346,
-0.21492430567741394,
-0.06416168063879013,
-0.606468915939331,
0.42783036828041077,
-0.8420885801315308,
-0.004001041408628225,
-0.29727354645729065,
-0.9217944741249084,
-0.23687398433685303,
0.23373328149318695,
-1.1338720321655273,
0.5680437088012695,
0.11888892948627472,
-0.7692275643348694,
0.5930390357971191,
-0.5730646252632141,
-0.4248861074447632,
0.3924754858016968,
-0.24315129220485687,
-0.26570212841033936,
-0.06664937734603882,
0.3273686468601227,
0.23215961456298828,
-0.5708826184272766,
0.2537200152873993,
-0.14732231199741364,
-0.3995550870895386,
-0.07662274688482285,
-0.12605741620063782,
0.6687818169593811,
0.11172008514404297,
-0.2414567768573761,
-0.1437452882528305,
-0.7601407766342163,
-0.36650580167770386,
0.23273122310638428,
-0.28419244289398193,
-0.7334095239639282,
-0.05668989568948746,
-0.15696372091770172,
-0.16312658786773682,
0.24242444336414337,
-0.5669170022010803,
0.0636347234249115,
-0.4289338290691376,
0.14340709149837494,
0.2528466582298279,
0.2118624746799469,
0.6175116300582886,
0.08842384815216064,
0.2657436728477478,
0.3908516466617584,
-0.15218356251716614,
-0.1699291169643402,
-0.2855975329875946,
-0.8160330653190613,
0.015448462218046188,
0.6877614259719849,
0.2757869362831116,
-1.3765183687210083,
0.631621778011322,
-0.47271212935447693,
-0.5233004689216614,
-0.8587672114372253,
-0.07404840737581253,
0.4990675747394562,
0.7488833665847778,
0.714796781539917,
-0.33430716395378113,
-0.40713831782341003,
-0.8227061033248901,
-0.130539670586586,
-0.43572601675987244,
-0.3579752445220947,
-0.0008632826502434909,
0.4958685636520386,
-0.32860755920410156,
0.7046796679496765,
-0.503572940826416,
-0.2477281093597412,
-0.060765888541936874,
0.04142693802714348,
-0.2870216369628906,
0.44452935457229614,
0.5248535871505737,
-1.2288146018981934,
-0.2204688936471939,
-0.11393338441848755,
-0.6359574794769287,
0.3457842171192169,
-0.10097636282444,
-0.507270336151123,
-0.15056224167346954,
0.20935238897800446,
-0.8483469486236572,
0.04513076692819595,
0.07860611379146576,
-0.2757052779197693,
0.20005539059638977,
0.022913312539458275,
0.31650495529174805,
-1.2358888387680054,
0.0497504360973835,
0.0755770355463028,
0.08605656772851944,
-0.4882553219795227,
0.20305944979190826,
0.05203542858362198,
0.11603692919015884,
-0.17388629913330078,
0.1932627558708191,
-0.8836581707000732,
-0.028853537514805794,
0.17638731002807617,
0.3901929259300232,
0.27155154943466187,
0.3140123188495636,
0.1937595009803772,
0.5003061890602112,
0.6185316443443298,
-0.6903175115585327,
0.7142000198364258,
0.5472716689109802,
-0.3055597245693207,
0.7588407397270203,
-0.564211905002594,
0.037162620574235916,
-0.4481237232685089,
0.33947551250457764,
-0.5146193504333496,
-0.2833288609981537,
0.34715715050697327,
-0.0999641865491867,
0.6435330510139465,
-0.05968332663178444,
-0.7512342929840088,
-0.31956183910369873,
-0.019388966262340546,
0.3893890678882599,
0.4678775668144226,
-0.6919435262680054,
0.7897128462791443,
0.5653069019317627,
0.19192329049110413,
-0.3523048758506775,
-0.5737900137901306,
-0.04864158481359482,
-0.27919188141822815,
-0.5306746959686279,
0.8959546089172363,
0.11299450695514679,
-0.019399352371692657,
0.40567106008529663,
-0.19243381917476654,
-0.22568698227405548,
0.04603821039199829,
0.16259680688381195,
0.4115360677242279,
-0.2875412702560425,
0.5753265619277954,
0.47596457600593567,
-0.14308451116085052,
0.0472135953605175,
-0.30503353476524353,
0.3909621238708496,
0.05499120429158211,
-0.5654625296592712,
0.1613347828388214,
0.5165407657623291,
0.21836306154727936,
-0.6196849346160889,
1.0111359357833862,
0.48671185970306396,
-0.7871776819229126,
-0.045762140303850174,
-0.3457011878490448,
-0.19791674613952637,
-0.42190495133399963,
0.44191184639930725,
-0.6470280289649963,
-0.7676607966423035,
0.44056251645088196,
-0.3839668333530426,
0.023748153820633888,
0.6035114526748657,
0.07121001929044724,
0.03230658173561096,
0.8128414750099182,
0.5191088914871216,
0.14264073967933655,
0.16596858203411102,
-0.07536999136209488,
0.36573663353919983,
-1.0362520217895508,
-0.5906552672386169,
-0.47144588828086853,
-0.268900066614151,
-0.44934797286987305,
-0.3777017295360565,
0.22591960430145264,
0.4737303853034973,
-0.09110905230045319,
0.6628390550613403,
-0.6168105602264404,
0.6877294182777405,
0.34498780965805054,
0.33043110370635986,
0.4926344156265259,
0.015690002590417862,
0.021785972639918327,
0.04338531941175461,
-0.6406774520874023,
-0.43018248677253723,
0.7450248003005981,
0.1443335860967636,
0.7727986574172974,
0.5431877374649048,
1.0911078453063965,
-0.04140887409448624,
0.08548691123723984,
-0.3659152090549469,
0.5079408288002014,
0.08414781838655472,
-0.5681756734848022,
-0.2870470881462097,
-0.25085335969924927,
-0.8927931189537048,
0.3007594645023346,
-0.505745530128479,
-0.5626851916313171,
0.416152685880661,
0.19281063973903656,
-0.4186973571777344,
0.31340932846069336,
-0.6030845046043396,
0.8679983019828796,
-0.019698558375239372,
-0.14890556037425995,
-0.11298788338899612,
-0.5971441864967346,
0.23560293018817902,
-0.025558702647686005,
-0.29979225993156433,
0.07575373351573944,
-0.05600728839635849,
0.6107773184776306,
0.10374516248703003,
0.295380175113678,
-0.011765350587666035,
-0.08098714798688889,
0.23120823502540588,
0.10004492849111557,
0.3916216194629669,
0.1325649470090866,
-0.15727835893630981,
0.2911430299282074,
-0.1804376244544983,
-0.2923390567302704,
-0.6294164061546326,
0.6476366519927979,
-0.425875186920166,
-0.7200957536697388,
-0.1260085254907608,
-0.10596002638339996,
-0.2846994996070862,
0.23887863755226135,
0.48962584137916565,
0.31088924407958984,
-0.3715302646160126,
0.08612804859876633,
1.2959296703338623,
0.03073245659470558,
0.07114698737859726,
0.3710605204105377,
0.006215347908437252,
0.032049279659986496,
0.8141435384750366,
-0.06839290261268616,
0.1865604668855667,
0.7466394305229187,
-0.5917351245880127,
-0.5969994068145752,
-0.5446012020111084,
-0.9221644997596741,
0.2111491560935974,
-0.838249921798706,
-0.49661368131637573,
-0.8045498728752136,
0.01884634606540203,
-0.28729403018951416,
-0.009397088550031185,
-0.11364112794399261,
0.03901764750480652,
-0.44272127747535706,
-0.3424641191959381,
0.36509260535240173,
0.49799200892448425,
0.3059189021587372,
-0.13943660259246826,
-0.8419807553291321,
0.4378131330013275,
0.17762060463428497,
0.4074810743331909,
0.072739377617836,
-0.028406893834471703,
-0.12162129580974579,
0.1739201694726944,
0.01146654598414898,
-1.410247802734375,
-0.08412092924118042,
0.3743705749511719,
0.7235692739486694,
0.3250197172164917,
0.47789624333381653,
0.7772568464279175,
-0.5560163259506226,
0.6891379952430725,
0.2785075306892395,
-0.859720766544342,
0.7333086729049683,
0.09422121942043304,
0.06813355535268784,
0.4712728261947632,
0.6343835592269897,
-0.2494809776544571,
-0.2966182827949524,
-0.4842185080051422,
-1.060994029045105,
0.30866020917892456,
0.11259564012289047,
0.03822967782616615,
-0.38404932618141174,
0.23367449641227722,
0.1538122445344925,
0.17081961035728455,
-0.39252784848213196,
-0.4484465420246124,
0.07265151292085648,
-0.22962737083435059,
0.15460988879203796,
-0.3622313439846039,
-0.07269088923931122,
0.05006367713212967,
0.6367875337600708,
0.11379729211330414,
0.367068350315094,
0.1270679384469986,
-0.669633686542511,
-0.017240826040506363,
0.352614164352417,
-0.01950300671160221,
0.46036458015441895,
0.0790679082274437,
0.2827877104282379,
0.23111678659915924,
-0.3311624228954315,
-0.02229413576424122,
0.5023912191390991,
-0.3463863730430603,
0.4828469157218933,
0.08467695116996765,
0.9163230061531067,
0.4812513589859009,
-0.5731047987937927,
0.297952800989151,
0.06243544816970825,
0.23002412915229797,
0.04907677322626114,
0.14231476187705994,
0.3520857095718384,
0.34304457902908325,
0.3672451972961426,
-0.09243959933519363,
0.5334827303886414,
-0.33278167247772217,
0.3059093654155731,
0.10594784468412399,
-0.10688315331935883,
-0.19500257074832916,
0.8854106068611145,
0.6105017066001892,
0.07858934998512268,
0.7859807014465332,
-0.42128872871398926,
-0.503540575504303,
0.4080740809440613,
0.689891517162323,
0.8181045055389404,
-0.14138561487197876,
0.15201133489608765,
0.45911672711372375,
0.1385340690612793,
-0.030795596539974213,
-0.09920068830251694,
-0.4034319221973419,
-0.6624369025230408,
-0.07575424015522003,
-0.7851818203926086,
-0.2116895169019699,
-0.4629402160644531,
-0.9956724047660828,
0.19159317016601562,
0.10154915601015091,
-0.03149549290537834,
0.10598447173833847,
-0.2523638606071472,
-0.7811504006385803,
0.056223995983600616,
0.20915156602859497,
0.8724780678749084,
-0.6918204426765442,
0.6952645182609558,
0.8108695149421692,
-0.9724553227424622,
-0.6910159587860107,
0.061513397842645645,
-0.2332078218460083,
-0.2847350239753723,
0.299922913312912,
0.05113395303487778,
0.032316163182258606,
0.3779333829879761,
0.04059666767716408,
-0.6534327268600464,
1.4842077493667603,
0.5719563961029053,
-0.883908748626709,
-0.26177164912223816,
-0.008441132493317127,
0.5242210030555725,
-0.3267638683319092,
0.18234281241893768,
0.510676383972168,
0.141370952129364,
0.11929726600646973,
-0.8528134822845459,
0.18303364515304565,
-0.23645521700382233,
0.2184566855430603,
0.5242710113525391,
-0.3482154905796051,
0.702742874622345,
-0.2025892436504364,
-0.7749603986740112,
-0.07835612446069717,
0.9836045503616333,
0.1404396891593933,
0.2706652283668518,
0.46242961287498474,
0.6554665565490723,
0.9433048367500305,
-0.27912935614585876,
0.8350635170936584,
-0.4075901508331299,
0.46839439868927,
1.0933517217636108,
-0.43440142273902893,
0.9330397248268127,
0.40526509284973145,
-0.15247294306755066,
0.5295400023460388,
0.7337321043014526,
-0.19647593796253204,
0.572202205657959,
-0.01622530072927475,
-0.6394271850585938,
-0.2661130428314209,
-0.2137191891670227,
-0.5248513221740723,
0.05645288899540901,
0.31442010402679443,
-0.40393203496932983,
-0.3838045597076416,
0.21594393253326416,
-0.2321842759847641,
0.1971961259841919,
-0.3790864646434784,
0.8048035502433777,
-0.11914519220590591,
-0.40424370765686035,
0.23233464360237122,
-0.10558310896158218,
0.6948632597923279,
-0.27682560682296753,
-0.39559993147850037,
0.0038142381235957146,
-0.048147331923246384,
-0.27032265067100525,
-0.8533321619033813,
0.08015371114015579,
0.01731209270656109,
-0.40667808055877686,
-0.004685666877776384,
0.83432537317276,
-0.9012120962142944,
-0.06362233310937881,
0.25706183910369873,
0.29781752824783325,
0.16355934739112854,
0.040575139224529266,
-0.47120898962020874,
0.007352953311055899,
0.02947724424302578,
0.03793611004948616,
0.3418810963630676,
0.4935884177684784,
0.13852910697460175,
0.4568900465965271,
0.3385489583015442,
-0.3193306624889374,
0.1555800884962082,
-0.04122282937169075,
0.9573534727096558,
-0.4192085564136505,
-0.46874189376831055,
-0.7080211043357849,
0.491001695394516,
-0.2385832816362381,
-0.20275427401065826,
0.6334635019302368,
0.6357066631317139,
1.3402295112609863,
-0.14268027245998383,
0.4854651093482971,
-0.33884355425834656,
0.22041694819927216,
-0.6100792288780212,
0.7653754353523254,
-0.2980455160140991,
0.44231465458869934,
-0.03206493332982063,
-1.1600301265716553,
0.009571380913257599,
0.44415661692619324,
0.043615229427814484,
-0.022331977263092995,
0.47500717639923096,
0.6819327473640442,
-0.09157416224479675,
0.05341586843132973,
0.19852077960968018,
-0.013333170674741268,
0.09871392697095871,
0.7626360654830933,
0.5618438720703125,
-0.6289857625961304,
0.4862186908721924,
-0.20651863515377045,
0.11516409367322922,
-0.17137029767036438,
-0.45108333230018616,
-0.6922491788864136,
-0.8192421793937683,
-0.6294761896133423,
-0.39754629135131836,
0.2641834318637848,
0.7699655890464783,
0.25439509749412537,
-0.5796728730201721,
0.4598786234855652,
0.14830611646175385,
0.27203142642974854,
-0.03702196478843689,
-0.13502071797847748,
0.316652774810791,
0.16626262664794922,
-1.0450180768966675,
0.08383003622293472,
0.27614936232566833,
0.09872540831565857,
-0.4348650276660919,
-0.21475842595100403,
-0.15777434408664703,
-0.27280959486961365,
0.38012173771858215,
0.12932941317558289,
-0.8621456623077393,
-0.19962243735790253,
-0.03865774720907211,
-0.276745468378067,
-0.24589601159095764,
0.48948103189468384,
-0.8102426528930664,
0.6818405389785767,
0.33180031180381775,
0.9063006043434143,
0.33961161971092224,
-0.029891500249505043,
0.3713229298591614,
-0.5466126799583435,
-0.11570757627487183,
0.4838930070400238,
0.3879846930503845,
0.36714789271354675,
-0.5460379719734192,
0.31530341506004333,
0.14221742749214172,
-0.12275077402591705,
-0.7998925447463989,
0.3378669321537018,
-0.7580859065055847,
-0.06299158185720444,
0.9039790034294128,
-0.3715643286705017,
-0.39973902702331543,
-0.07370757311582565,
0.05880293622612953,
0.4243794083595276,
-0.2880454361438751,
0.6546891927719116,
0.5053241848945618,
-0.010430955328047276,
-0.13804788887500763,
0.05667564272880554,
0.3332483768463135,
0.0632028579711914,
-0.6465096473693848,
-0.2077237069606781,
0.754452645778656,
0.1399744302034378,
0.4051249325275421,
0.26425084471702576,
-0.02961115352809429,
0.3627307713031769,
0.5858610272407532,
0.15471898019313812,
-0.10875832289457321,
-0.18991130590438843,
-0.15329815447330475,
0.093244269490242,
0.021079588681459427,
-0.40230420231819153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01616v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01616v2
|
Transforming LLMs into Cross-modal and Cross-lingual Retrieval Systems
| 2024-04-02T03:42:28 | 2024-04-04T01:51:22 |
Frank Palma Gomez, Ramon Sanabria, Yun-hsuan Sung, Daniel Cer, Siddharth Dalmia, Gustavo Hernandez Abrego
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large language models (LLMs) are trained on text-only data that go far beyond
the languages with paired speech and text data. At the same time, Dual Encoder
(DE) based retrieval systems project queries and documents into the same
embedding space and have demonstrated their success in retrieval and bi-text
mining. To match speech and text in many languages, we propose using LLMs to
initialize multi-modal DE retrieval systems. Unlike traditional methods, our
system doesn't require speech data during LLM pre-training and can exploit
LLM's multilingual text understanding capabilities to match speech and text in
languages unseen during retrieval training. Our multi-modal LLM-based retrieval
system is capable of matching speech and text in 102 languages despite only
training on 21 languages. Our system outperforms previous systems trained
explicitly on all 102 languages. We achieve a 10% absolute improvement in
Recall@1 averaged across these languages. Additionally, our model demonstrates
cross-lingual speech and text matching, which is further enhanced by readily
available machine translation data.
|
[
-0.12278840690851212,
-0.5014386177062988,
0.6297116279602051,
0.1425793468952179,
-0.3212457299232483,
0.28707948327064514,
-0.3009706139564514,
-0.5761541128158569,
0.20674127340316772,
0.4721498191356659,
-0.30602380633354187,
-0.323930948972702,
-0.5072197914123535,
0.30870017409324646,
-0.3646725118160248,
0.6735249161720276,
0.11047178506851196,
0.6540648937225342,
-0.04026990383863449,
-0.07991752028465271,
-0.3758276402950287,
-0.7319360375404358,
-0.48899537324905396,
-0.4163300096988678,
0.5313002467155457,
0.19617517292499542,
0.5705949664115906,
0.40502485632896423,
0.24504582583904266,
0.2872803807258606,
-0.04886091500520706,
0.30728232860565186,
-0.6408494710922241,
0.22876617312431335,
-0.1407497227191925,
-0.6450398564338684,
-0.2124885767698288,
-0.31627926230430603,
0.8993842601776123,
0.6990898251533508,
-0.027263950556516647,
-0.20078587532043457,
0.02144753374159336,
0.42109742760658264,
-0.5518500208854675,
0.24484531581401825,
-0.9093491435050964,
0.0934402197599411,
-0.36323830485343933,
-0.49460187554359436,
-0.5972586274147034,
-0.07442986965179443,
-0.08445846289396286,
-0.37136781215667725,
-0.05833258107304573,
0.1560998409986496,
0.5446951389312744,
0.01930396817624569,
-0.8966187238693237,
-0.31329965591430664,
-0.6275835037231445,
0.7729407548904419,
-0.4079878032207489,
1.0528693199157715,
0.46478042006492615,
0.1656619757413864,
0.0010057996260002255,
-0.4576926827430725,
-0.4959190785884857,
-0.1818300485610962,
-0.19870156049728394,
-0.02934068627655506,
0.05483110249042511,
-0.06824289262294769,
0.11314180493354797,
0.40733715891838074,
-0.6728192567825317,
0.1330421268939972,
-0.19118444621562958,
-0.27960318326950073,
0.5785771608352661,
0.10500910133123398,
0.4055681526660919,
-0.2081366628408432,
-0.5994395613670349,
-0.07177557051181793,
-0.8024032115936279,
-0.19631308317184448,
0.16852615773677826,
0.6381335258483887,
-0.032893043011426926,
0.772358775138855,
0.08559878915548325,
0.6102365255355835,
-0.03369968757033348,
-0.30000680685043335,
0.3428451120853424,
-0.6401136517524719,
-0.3218088746070862,
0.2770337462425232,
0.7798096537590027,
0.10708484798669815,
0.2412702888250351,
-0.42215877771377563,
-0.4696534276008606,
0.01647207885980606,
-0.10549777001142502,
-0.6625401973724365,
0.18273450434207916,
-0.31707319617271423,
-0.39987707138061523,
0.09605672210454941,
-0.03061964549124241,
-0.6398401260375977,
-0.3441903591156006,
-0.47379136085510254,
0.6164436340332031,
-0.42950212955474854,
-0.3100949227809906,
0.22857682406902313,
-0.02429298684000969,
0.5188229084014893,
0.04372362792491913,
-0.9274221062660217,
0.2581191062927246,
0.5020415782928467,
0.7332040071487427,
-0.19787843525409698,
-0.20776841044425964,
-0.6882283687591553,
0.38410577178001404,
-0.35488346219062805,
0.5335947275161743,
-0.7319653034210205,
-0.5065795183181763,
0.21669329702854156,
0.18333800137043,
-0.21807268261909485,
-0.6458413004875183,
0.4880222976207733,
-1.0046002864837646,
0.2822975516319275,
-0.3552754819393158,
-0.3676369786262512,
-0.28001850843429565,
0.22557784616947174,
-0.6986126899719238,
1.174113154411316,
-0.22186769545078278,
-0.6170042753219604,
0.19472384452819824,
-0.29060667753219604,
-0.6890925765037537,
-0.04854639992117882,
-0.3090607225894928,
0.01491833757609129,
0.10101670026779175,
0.2967469096183777,
0.36858025193214417,
-0.6786873936653137,
0.21011880040168762,
-0.06031711399555206,
-0.4106733798980713,
-0.02545880526304245,
-0.4865023195743561,
0.648826539516449,
0.0819232165813446,
-0.14193321764469147,
-0.10186004638671875,
-0.6655356884002686,
0.005816794466227293,
0.04310150444507599,
-0.8389901518821716,
-0.651851236820221,
-0.08503305166959763,
0.4582456052303314,
0.3647864758968353,
0.501171350479126,
-0.6860465407371521,
0.05922431871294975,
-0.4222947061061859,
0.29022282361984253,
0.5072859525680542,
-0.4532835781574249,
0.5150748491287231,
-0.2762162983417511,
0.40584033727645874,
-0.0170697383582592,
-0.36498117446899414,
-0.3368641138076782,
-0.2507760226726532,
-0.7368132472038269,
-0.2820407450199127,
0.32834184169769287,
0.9076321721076965,
-0.9021914005279541,
0.3946790099143982,
-0.5599517226219177,
-0.08728177845478058,
-0.5039613246917725,
0.301525741815567,
0.4879806637763977,
0.2269296646118164,
0.4683537781238556,
-0.31576621532440186,
-0.729141891002655,
-1.0081689357757568,
-0.208754763007164,
-0.0376146137714386,
-0.0838160514831543,
0.3734901249408722,
0.20639094710350037,
-0.44241607189178467,
0.7007911801338196,
-0.04569707065820694,
-0.34190240502357483,
-0.36330172419548035,
-0.14448495209217072,
0.1359758973121643,
0.18447956442832947,
0.3832393288612366,
-0.9928569197654724,
-0.7354414463043213,
0.2524324953556061,
-0.8157414793968201,
-0.08485808968544006,
0.18348734080791473,
0.005316693801432848,
0.44532570242881775,
0.6588417887687683,
-0.392964243888855,
0.12365517020225525,
0.6489230394363403,
-0.25501006841659546,
0.055608246475458145,
-0.2533096373081207,
0.2954455614089966,
-1.1782981157302856,
0.09288173168897629,
-0.2936096489429474,
-0.3795696496963501,
-0.5467569828033447,
-0.26566118001937866,
0.28869691491127014,
-0.2046574503183365,
-0.40962833166122437,
0.7457115054130554,
-0.7242429852485657,
-0.3250848948955536,
-0.31131628155708313,
0.2839495539665222,
0.011783107183873653,
0.3100079298019409,
0.13207419216632843,
0.8949713110923767,
0.6392979621887207,
-0.6533939838409424,
0.3975366950035095,
0.3962191939353943,
-0.3705909252166748,
0.6673588156700134,
-0.49086689949035645,
0.2299339324235916,
-0.30646637082099915,
0.19797006249427795,
-0.9388916492462158,
0.031338807195425034,
-0.004926604684442282,
-0.20044636726379395,
0.5625545978546143,
-0.17374500632286072,
-0.6594824194908142,
-0.13744519650936127,
-0.23832660913467407,
0.52901291847229,
0.22598682343959808,
-0.8518521189689636,
0.7775523066520691,
0.4935786724090576,
-0.31108349561691284,
-0.705022394657135,
-0.7840240001678467,
0.3125948905944824,
0.02624339982867241,
-0.5723062753677368,
0.5184425711631775,
-0.2902541756629944,
-0.021424749866127968,
-0.11660435795783997,
-0.11330314725637436,
-0.1070837676525116,
-0.16263049840927124,
-0.024893902242183685,
0.2642239034175873,
-0.11967302113771439,
0.38634806871414185,
0.035916347056627274,
-0.04294443503022194,
-0.21285668015480042,
-0.22448258101940155,
0.8334999680519104,
0.061382368206977844,
-0.43946459889411926,
-0.2108510285615921,
0.6412739753723145,
0.7317160964012146,
-0.47412845492362976,
0.632591724395752,
0.5195696949958801,
-0.4251953661441803,
-0.027724694460630417,
-0.764165461063385,
-0.12039167433977127,
-0.4701652228832245,
0.5201571583747864,
-0.8104920983314514,
-0.9800894856452942,
0.3858734369277954,
0.06350602209568024,
-0.15371562540531158,
0.21187633275985718,
0.7739022374153137,
0.2216346114873886,
1.0764936208724976,
0.7970747351646423,
-0.26406386494636536,
0.6039885878562927,
0.04007922112941742,
0.13877621293067932,
-0.7892654538154602,
-0.6548104882240295,
-0.43619564175605774,
-0.33913126587867737,
-0.42681193351745605,
-0.5922141075134277,
0.40323370695114136,
0.0680655911564827,
-0.09246329963207245,
0.3059448003768921,
-0.22017303109169006,
0.46914443373680115,
0.5718302130699158,
0.12096042186021805,
0.5772969722747803,
0.1860298216342926,
-0.31110748648643494,
-0.09656744450330734,
-0.6259863972663879,
-0.4070577025413513,
1.1741671562194824,
0.11613086611032486,
0.9962807297706604,
0.23151010274887085,
0.7084164619445801,
0.015155553817749023,
0.006437583826482296,
-0.919719398021698,
0.5708642601966858,
-0.35110121965408325,
-0.6388818025588989,
-0.1966807097196579,
-0.4895075857639313,
-1.0892469882965088,
0.621222972869873,
-0.24195189774036407,
-0.3951282203197479,
0.216512992978096,
-0.4852442443370819,
-0.031793590635061264,
0.35941630601882935,
-0.4075485169887543,
0.5069263577461243,
-0.6490271091461182,
-0.2456667572259903,
-0.3809010982513428,
-0.5030864477157593,
0.25151437520980835,
-0.37898018956184387,
0.29283496737480164,
-0.0933096781373024,
-0.35427695512771606,
0.7582688331604004,
0.1597442924976349,
0.7418083548545837,
-0.003643439384177327,
-0.38148656487464905,
-0.11671210080385208,
0.16722318530082703,
0.28408583998680115,
0.09519319236278534,
-0.3156989812850952,
0.12311513721942902,
0.07386787980794907,
-0.1529874950647354,
-0.42234715819358826,
0.978611171245575,
-0.7115391492843628,
-0.5084862112998962,
-0.4790802001953125,
-0.6887357234954834,
-0.19049020111560822,
0.3664249777793884,
-0.09118766337633133,
0.3748399317264557,
-0.3252604305744171,
0.39674112200737,
0.7841758728027344,
-0.19113041460514069,
0.5151537656784058,
0.9808234572410583,
-0.34232765436172485,
-0.5210196375846863,
0.6683259606361389,
0.04469791054725647,
0.16569200158119202,
0.8731575012207031,
-0.05803149566054344,
-0.547482967376709,
-0.28664565086364746,
-0.46834951639175415,
0.4694325029850006,
-0.6635259985923767,
-0.33427509665489197,
-0.7438802719116211,
-0.12431726604700089,
-0.49401405453681946,
0.13148930668830872,
-0.24810001254081726,
-0.20803235471248627,
-0.3106321096420288,
0.0435580313205719,
0.19012267887592316,
0.7285609841346741,
-0.2826673984527588,
0.05783902853727341,
-1.0551280975341797,
0.5267578363418579,
0.31534111499786377,
0.40505310893058777,
-0.2950630784034729,
-0.6852759718894958,
-0.29420366883277893,
0.08851233869791031,
-0.03901907429099083,
-0.9232206344604492,
0.5844630002975464,
0.4309210181236267,
0.8681684732437134,
0.1598590761423111,
-0.21999096870422363,
0.4665071964263916,
-0.7731956243515015,
0.5505471229553223,
0.15051132440567017,
-0.993189811706543,
0.4428042769432068,
-0.11265736073255539,
0.10041769593954086,
0.49317118525505066,
0.7156758904457092,
-0.8355871438980103,
0.2470685839653015,
0.011189034208655357,
-0.69564288854599,
0.9607316851615906,
-0.2684204876422882,
0.18824198842048645,
-0.04892199486494064,
0.2457410842180252,
0.2027038037776947,
0.15523549914360046,
-0.8750987648963928,
-0.1366955041885376,
0.0058864024467766285,
-0.3466324210166931,
-0.3190869092941284,
-0.3643210828304291,
-0.2885493040084839,
-0.12502102553844452,
0.6536094546318054,
-0.2711040675640106,
0.2869175970554352,
0.029017707332968712,
-0.4701169431209564,
-0.08706439286470413,
0.4301009178161621,
0.23485755920410156,
0.4034402072429657,
-0.021105458959937096,
0.31692934036254883,
0.3389841318130493,
-0.20416082441806793,
0.2941390573978424,
0.4230533540248871,
-0.08309362083673477,
0.0758371576666832,
0.1253764033317566,
0.8385387063026428,
0.6406195759773254,
-0.903884768486023,
0.36298802495002747,
0.051412295550107956,
0.06939736008644104,
-0.2123020589351654,
-0.31558218598365784,
0.22356998920440674,
0.41316643357276917,
0.5074889063835144,
-0.3914329707622528,
0.13161714375019073,
-0.8386427760124207,
0.24021407961845398,
0.8477380871772766,
-0.335429310798645,
-0.36288896203041077,
0.6344438791275024,
0.09327160567045212,
-0.3968162536621094,
0.5680977702140808,
0.1320115178823471,
-0.5215780138969421,
0.1315508484840393,
0.842934250831604,
0.7708641886711121,
-0.3577381670475006,
0.011203601025044918,
0.20322799682617188,
0.24444694817066193,
-0.2036133110523224,
0.5411806106567383,
-0.09285185486078262,
-0.794052004814148,
-0.3391268253326416,
-0.7872381210327148,
-0.18844789266586304,
-0.06675016134977341,
-0.5365758538246155,
0.5001583099365234,
0.005275188945233822,
0.0033403695560991764,
-0.31074631214141846,
0.06789689511060715,
-0.6840195655822754,
0.01856795884668827,
0.6273252964019775,
0.8903989791870117,
-0.742123544216156,
1.0975419282913208,
0.7522215247154236,
-0.3134273588657379,
-0.47705310583114624,
-0.35829442739486694,
-0.12046598643064499,
-1.0453448295593262,
0.9574517011642456,
0.12186411768198013,
-0.31469717621803284,
0.058646295219659805,
-0.12800733745098114,
-1.0910660028457642,
1.203619122505188,
0.5517581105232239,
-0.6735391616821289,
-0.32138100266456604,
0.3353932499885559,
0.41910308599472046,
-0.35438650846481323,
0.3448895514011383,
0.431772381067276,
0.5351017117500305,
0.013677600771188736,
-1.433790922164917,
-0.049687765538692474,
-0.08121801912784576,
0.036085113883018494,
0.24005049467086792,
-0.5211082100868225,
0.8375529646873474,
-0.009580317884683609,
-0.4560444951057434,
0.03269148990511894,
0.38621628284454346,
0.04518381133675575,
0.1948380172252655,
0.4826464056968689,
0.5894736647605896,
0.7512263059616089,
0.005450291093438864,
0.9249165654182434,
-0.4698447585105896,
0.13762155175209045,
0.9126353859901428,
-0.517507791519165,
1.0653597116470337,
0.5535369515419006,
0.01941303350031376,
0.41045713424682617,
0.4566408693790436,
0.21194960176944733,
0.6060130000114441,
-0.015255661681294441,
-0.47981715202331543,
-0.6365141868591309,
-0.2774926722049713,
-0.4835474193096161,
0.5826635360717773,
0.37635114789009094,
-0.41404688358306885,
-0.3669036030769348,
0.2098003774881363,
-0.16317161917686462,
0.18387997150421143,
-0.2159339189529419,
0.7777684330940247,
0.18614009022712708,
-0.2572419047355652,
0.7265527248382568,
0.2726811468601227,
1.1276443004608154,
-0.8937608599662781,
0.1549193263053894,
-0.1827169954776764,
0.12078694254159927,
-0.08446798473596573,
-0.5266042947769165,
0.05299116298556328,
-0.2756407856941223,
-0.3051394820213318,
-0.4296886622905731,
0.6883971691131592,
-1.004990816116333,
-0.5016973614692688,
0.7961891889572144,
0.8626340627670288,
0.08169633150100708,
0.04665900394320488,
-0.5592330098152161,
0.18984369933605194,
-0.027917703613638878,
-0.18615394830703735,
0.5279929041862488,
0.4755083918571472,
-0.0037398107815533876,
0.5606239438056946,
0.6144070029258728,
-0.10899818688631058,
0.35849401354789734,
0.2281447798013687,
0.9300666451454163,
-0.7604641914367676,
-0.3192550539970398,
-0.6802973747253418,
0.06192118301987648,
0.27661916613578796,
0.1572520136833191,
0.7377362251281738,
0.9962774515151978,
0.8667848706245422,
-0.03190966695547104,
0.8888391852378845,
-0.04824122413992882,
0.5896496176719666,
-0.6241751313209534,
0.4965305030345917,
-0.7740885615348816,
0.19643904268741608,
0.16056889295578003,
-1.1331422328948975,
-0.23376432061195374,
0.5879632234573364,
-0.09079498797655106,
0.09641984105110168,
0.6532936096191406,
1.0293328762054443,
-0.2519502341747284,
-0.11811961233615875,
0.5390720963478088,
0.07789198309183121,
0.320789098739624,
0.8218517899513245,
0.7953743934631348,
-0.5965260863304138,
0.8032611012458801,
0.09384039789438248,
-0.18013827502727509,
-0.22468231618404388,
-0.5058460235595703,
-0.923083484172821,
-0.51131272315979,
0.13231924176216125,
-0.20231664180755615,
0.07796426862478256,
0.8875923156738281,
0.5875113010406494,
-0.7104408740997314,
-0.4959103763103485,
0.43875908851623535,
-0.03224257752299309,
0.13757967948913574,
-0.1858353316783905,
0.13921807706356049,
-0.4160255789756775,
-1.1877610683441162,
1.2584893703460693,
0.2985641658306122,
0.008770367130637169,
-0.3847699761390686,
-0.2548082768917084,
-0.67474365234375,
0.047305576503276825,
0.8270624279975891,
0.2359301894903183,
-0.643972635269165,
-0.3157217800617218,
0.3797951340675354,
-0.39167189598083496,
0.14982929825782776,
0.9337018728256226,
-1.0187978744506836,
0.48087021708488464,
0.6702069640159607,
0.8439573645591736,
0.6895384788513184,
-0.4386206865310669,
0.6439545750617981,
-0.5098510384559631,
0.24568864703178406,
0.23856885731220245,
0.5035220384597778,
0.5354163646697998,
-0.15833264589309692,
0.4080447554588318,
0.23300889134407043,
-0.4219833314418793,
-0.8112884759902954,
0.37486734986305237,
-0.9951369762420654,
-0.19051651656627655,
1.2543591260910034,
0.15963169932365417,
0.14788858592510223,
-0.29069530963897705,
-0.27745717763900757,
0.3059532344341278,
-0.2733008861541748,
0.44500741362571716,
0.4649812877178192,
0.07457587867975235,
-0.037105921655893326,
-0.40112143754959106,
0.14085695147514343,
0.4781247079372406,
-0.459218829870224,
-0.0025182825047522783,
0.5196231603622437,
0.32985302805900574,
0.1668914407491684,
0.694732666015625,
-0.35803988575935364,
-0.06213783100247383,
-0.17953267693519592,
0.0990418866276741,
-0.029622774571180344,
-0.44093960523605347,
-0.5215529203414917,
0.13272878527641296,
-0.09231144189834595,
-0.08549822866916656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01602v1
|
Helmsman of the Masses? Evaluate the Opinion Leadership of Large Language Models in the Werewolf Game
| 2024-04-02T02:46:18 | 2024-04-02T02:46:18 |
Silin Du, Xiaowei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited memorable strategic behaviors in
social deductive games. However, the significance of opinion leadership
exhibited by LLM-based agents has been overlooked, which is crucial for
practical applications in multi-agent and human-AI interaction settings.
Opinion leaders are individuals who have a noticeable impact on the beliefs and
behaviors of others within a social group. In this work, we employ the Werewolf
game as a simulation platform to assess the opinion leadership of LLMs. The
game features the role of the Sheriff, tasked with summarizing arguments and
recommending decision options, and therefore serves as a credible proxy for an
opinion leader. We develop a framework integrating the Sheriff role and devise
two novel metrics for evaluation based on the critical characteristics of
opinion leaders. The first metric measures the reliability of the opinion
leader, and the second assesses the influence of the opinion leader on other
players' decisions. We conduct extensive experiments to evaluate LLMs of
different scales. In addition, we collect a Werewolf question-answering dataset
(WWQA) to assess and enhance LLM's grasp of the game rules, and we also
incorporate human participants for further analysis. The results suggest that
the Werewolf game is a suitable test bed to evaluate the opinion leadership of
LLMs and few LLMs possess the capacity for opinion leadership.
|
[
-0.657498300075531,
-0.572216272354126,
0.7695526480674744,
0.15975970029830933,
-0.2777180075645447,
0.25084036588668823,
-0.34230759739875793,
-0.17105668783187866,
0.4744783043861389,
0.8201444745063782,
-0.20454488694667816,
-0.60260409116745,
-0.7304198145866394,
0.2838636636734009,
-0.23588387668132782,
0.8853387832641602,
0.4740910530090332,
0.21551698446273804,
-0.28632980585098267,
-0.09063630551099777,
-0.39018142223358154,
-0.658265233039856,
-0.7335789203643799,
-0.7299264669418335,
0.4767066240310669,
0.2747606337070465,
1.2387993335723877,
0.39021238684654236,
0.36578142642974854,
0.3877606987953186,
-0.1511336714029312,
0.15828217566013336,
-0.8478779196739197,
0.18042594194412231,
-0.5159208178520203,
-0.27379417419433594,
-0.6360328197479248,
0.2995889484882355,
0.2936755418777466,
0.23141561448574066,
-0.36709922552108765,
0.1364273577928543,
-0.09372344613075256,
0.45829737186431885,
-0.30742502212524414,
0.32768580317497253,
-0.7214865684509277,
-0.12099656462669373,
0.07373643666505814,
-0.10856157541275024,
-0.533631443977356,
-0.5434191823005676,
0.09054599702358246,
-0.4184917211532593,
-0.11999784409999847,
0.25188887119293213,
0.28960591554641724,
0.08785167336463928,
-0.6299970149993896,
-0.4148126244544983,
-0.8416730165481567,
0.9083844423294067,
-0.9120751619338989,
-0.02344142459332943,
0.35121920704841614,
0.33132627606391907,
-0.33079928159713745,
-0.193032905459404,
-0.7108509540557861,
-0.1293533742427826,
0.08581294864416122,
0.6099568605422974,
-0.18941760063171387,
0.2549753189086914,
-0.13778042793273926,
0.28352785110473633,
-0.17686346173286438,
0.3310319185256958,
-0.41264164447784424,
0.08845033496618271,
1.1236207485198975,
0.5725414752960205,
-0.11791235953569412,
-0.3802311420440674,
-0.3009299039840698,
-0.31848400831222534,
-0.45275986194610596,
0.3020421266555786,
0.35815751552581787,
0.14430072903633118,
-0.000900566577911377,
0.41690751910209656,
0.005211257375776768,
0.5957742929458618,
0.5900955200195312,
-0.3359832167625427,
0.14594393968582153,
0.2558847665786743,
-0.11742012947797775,
0.22161060571670532,
0.8505654335021973,
0.9359298348426819,
0.17690974473953247,
-0.16443033516407013,
-0.3922618627548218,
-0.08467026054859161,
0.5233190655708313,
-0.7362984418869019,
0.08314106613397598,
0.4208000898361206,
-0.6834741234779358,
-0.6820968389511108,
0.28279417753219604,
-0.9794344305992126,
-1.159156322479248,
-0.049812398850917816,
0.44997814297676086,
-0.07388904690742493,
-0.4953957796096802,
0.11941438168287277,
-0.28256168961524963,
0.6044332981109619,
0.57163405418396,
-0.943286657333374,
0.33458083868026733,
0.7439586520195007,
0.5309297442436218,
-0.5528036952018738,
-0.3177151679992676,
-0.26035961508750916,
0.04074808210134506,
-0.671875536441803,
0.582848310470581,
-0.5399506688117981,
-0.8622905015945435,
-0.2549254894256592,
-0.08115532994270325,
0.2273898422718048,
-0.8688139915466309,
0.47079718112945557,
-0.5457668900489807,
-0.5306926369667053,
-0.5043408870697021,
-0.5609561800956726,
-0.0766974613070488,
0.46382734179496765,
-0.48941951990127563,
0.7234659790992737,
0.2572747468948364,
-0.2472350001335144,
0.4415816068649292,
-0.36387065052986145,
-0.39087575674057007,
0.26790568232536316,
-0.2703210115432739,
0.032810743898153305,
0.4064902067184448,
0.19499938189983368,
0.5938156247138977,
-0.6578544974327087,
0.33669203519821167,
-0.38145479559898376,
-0.212315633893013,
0.3957971930503845,
0.2854221761226654,
0.47494199872016907,
0.060831889510154724,
-0.20947445929050446,
0.07502543926239014,
-0.23572751879692078,
0.12550872564315796,
0.041716162115335464,
-0.12077140808105469,
-0.33658185601234436,
0.49299922585487366,
-0.15275974571704865,
0.17867791652679443,
-0.09773724526166916,
-0.40871885418891907,
0.30273425579071045,
-0.009645461104810238,
0.11913973838090897,
1.106497883796692,
0.40405911207199097,
0.5457793474197388,
-0.41828230023384094,
0.5024470686912537,
-0.27923592925071716,
0.6129906177520752,
0.4884164035320282,
-0.3713291883468628,
-0.518062949180603,
-0.19042590260505676,
-0.08274529129266739,
0.5511791706085205,
-0.8078855276107788,
0.4587385356426239,
-0.049904804676771164,
-1.1055781841278076,
-0.26412883400917053,
-0.028879305347800255,
0.03909750655293465,
0.056065261363983154,
0.276333212852478,
-0.3427799642086029,
-0.23527179658412933,
-0.9856526255607605,
-0.3465456962585449,
-0.8056095242500305,
0.166237473487854,
0.479082852602005,
0.5750099420547485,
-0.1621173471212387,
1.2641202211380005,
-0.39201292395591736,
-0.2748604416847229,
-0.7084558010101318,
-0.023674091324210167,
0.5619024634361267,
0.1902574747800827,
0.5267878174781799,
-0.6794595718383789,
-0.10087283700704575,
-0.14019125699996948,
-0.8461492657661438,
-0.1586514562368393,
-0.03941404074430466,
0.08579766750335693,
-0.5082074403762817,
0.1891685277223587,
-0.4654095470905304,
0.09647079557180405,
0.567218542098999,
-0.15532810986042023,
0.8735325336456299,
0.03069872036576271,
0.6352348923683167,
-0.7813318371772766,
-0.453670859336853,
-0.23919057846069336,
0.017989303916692734,
-0.7736023664474487,
0.07656707614660263,
-0.46075376868247986,
0.14672967791557312,
-0.3491581082344055,
0.6437833309173584,
-0.34820207953453064,
-0.2331816554069519,
-0.2535093128681183,
0.41180020570755005,
-0.2055688351392746,
0.12844201922416687,
0.010853898711502552,
0.5559338331222534,
0.5444982647895813,
-0.6757028102874756,
0.885230302810669,
0.40200531482696533,
-0.6617140173912048,
0.8375921845436096,
-0.830731213092804,
0.20880748331546783,
-0.08192792534828186,
0.04024761915206909,
-0.7620480060577393,
-0.2657415270805359,
-0.1796485036611557,
-0.4217219352722168,
-0.12539727985858917,
0.039052531123161316,
-0.827808678150177,
-0.4502902626991272,
-0.2364281862974167,
-0.1078517958521843,
0.7264706492424011,
-0.11806008219718933,
0.7837293148040771,
0.8589359521865845,
-0.0776829868555069,
-0.43742287158966064,
-0.3817231059074402,
0.24870623648166656,
-0.2447909712791443,
-0.5391212105751038,
-0.10981789231300354,
0.0175331924110651,
-0.9417093992233276,
-0.3444069027900696,
-0.06013001874089241,
-0.009146164171397686,
0.10784164071083069,
0.39649951457977295,
0.2818334996700287,
0.02839035540819168,
0.08878074586391449,
0.09003881365060806,
0.19133798778057098,
0.18485841155052185,
0.15523761510849,
0.34747740626335144,
-0.28831756114959717,
-0.2650154232978821,
0.20041005313396454,
0.09038947522640228,
0.9694531559944153,
-0.09634321928024292,
0.6270470023155212,
-0.02663026563823223,
0.07831757515668869,
-0.38860875368118286,
-0.7439389228820801,
-0.3766317665576935,
-0.45710018277168274,
0.6211215853691101,
0.12580302357673645,
-0.6131130456924438,
0.5484545230865479,
-0.1909143626689911,
0.31774383783340454,
0.38551610708236694,
0.6240227818489075,
-0.05925816297531128,
0.9493387937545776,
0.2900063991546631,
-0.2988523244857788,
-0.1847737729549408,
-0.13638097047805786,
0.016535617411136627,
-0.7050036787986755,
-0.1676955670118332,
-0.3284132182598114,
-0.554019033908844,
-0.0651598870754242,
-0.2875206172466278,
0.7320272922515869,
0.146218404173851,
-0.29559391736984253,
0.20415098965168,
-0.4158715009689331,
0.5528959631919861,
-0.1171937882900238,
0.20116537809371948,
0.3312230706214905,
-0.3968159854412079,
0.11442144960165024,
0.018536463379859924,
-0.45116370916366577,
-0.8032866716384888,
0.6028338670730591,
-0.0036662211641669273,
1.1626218557357788,
0.19362370669841766,
0.5566723942756653,
0.8850807547569275,
0.4283349812030792,
-0.8941872119903564,
0.9252519607543945,
-0.03382638841867447,
-0.8897734880447388,
-0.5592288970947266,
-0.25363653898239136,
-0.5939636826515198,
0.6621479988098145,
-0.5865412950515747,
-0.5431299805641174,
0.1617940366268158,
-0.20084118843078613,
-0.3871855139732361,
0.5723615288734436,
-0.18530550599098206,
0.8367297649383545,
-0.24780061841011047,
-0.01118569727987051,
-0.45416557788848877,
-0.47944435477256775,
0.34818798303604126,
-0.10781150311231613,
0.4234989881515503,
-0.19635099172592163,
-0.1720060557126999,
0.8177029490470886,
-0.37512338161468506,
0.7908799648284912,
-0.33787617087364197,
-0.15758973360061646,
0.30314695835113525,
0.15821054577827454,
0.6142687201499939,
0.008605722337961197,
-0.6189033389091492,
0.16320428252220154,
-0.15564332902431488,
0.010833053849637508,
-0.6475977897644043,
0.4158930778503418,
-0.9708046317100525,
-0.8679704666137695,
-0.40420448780059814,
-0.43829473853111267,
-0.38646790385246277,
-0.07690366357564926,
0.27361807227134705,
0.48549365997314453,
-0.6416157484054565,
0.3215261995792389,
0.3427865207195282,
-0.2713637948036194,
0.23461341857910156,
0.47434356808662415,
-0.6381859183311462,
-0.5862962007522583,
0.46000024676322937,
0.0970863401889801,
0.4929391145706177,
-0.017431672662496567,
0.4221816062927246,
-0.10296288132667542,
-0.6558526754379272,
-0.6536576151847839,
0.03755634278059006,
-0.728710412979126,
-0.09804286807775497,
-0.541500985622406,
-0.03360819071531296,
-0.02817085012793541,
-0.5091838240623474,
-0.32139503955841064,
-0.06488846987485886,
0.17564016580581665,
-0.10969188809394836,
0.4131297767162323,
0.9764167070388794,
0.1812773048877716,
0.7604973316192627,
-0.5854299664497375,
-0.0038401547353714705,
0.5390608310699463,
-0.16713231801986694,
0.3179411292076111,
-0.484267920255661,
-0.13930781185626984,
-0.17281444370746613,
-0.18580017983913422,
-1.190321683883667,
0.29571256041526794,
-0.09772689640522003,
0.8243981599807739,
0.6596148610115051,
0.5265891551971436,
0.45299386978149414,
-0.23225516080856323,
1.0877348184585571,
0.24309921264648438,
-0.9551331400871277,
0.11525477468967438,
-0.30544203519821167,
0.22571124136447906,
0.6519841551780701,
-0.050286706537008286,
-0.625033438205719,
-1.0410525798797607,
-0.5188745856285095,
-0.33356523513793945,
0.8021109104156494,
0.17190174758434296,
0.007690104190260172,
-0.2548328936100006,
0.20892202854156494,
0.15592855215072632,
0.45272859930992126,
-0.3594886362552643,
-0.4179493486881256,
0.042990513145923615,
0.35837018489837646,
-0.26251232624053955,
-0.27157557010650635,
0.09496183693408966,
-0.1674186885356903,
0.5449995398521423,
0.17683283984661102,
-0.2758179008960724,
0.10252759605646133,
-0.10923212021589279,
0.06674255430698395,
0.5059769749641418,
0.3828774094581604,
1.0840848684310913,
-0.13638398051261902,
0.27455419301986694,
0.6967629194259644,
-0.7991634011268616,
0.4213930368423462,
-0.563838005065918,
-0.3611517548561096,
0.09143205732107162,
0.47700199484825134,
0.4640780985355377,
0.1615588217973709,
-0.4420020580291748,
0.6911787390708923,
0.12199592590332031,
-0.02247464656829834,
-0.30790475010871887,
-0.08430930972099304,
-0.057741131633520126,
0.5454413890838623,
0.8674692511558533,
0.05838969722390175,
-0.01625679060816765,
-0.8008705377578735,
0.036366984248161316,
0.47024938464164734,
-0.4621361494064331,
-0.23663467168807983,
0.3455468416213989,
0.35030877590179443,
-0.22054685652256012,
0.2267036736011505,
-0.2299080193042755,
-0.8110837936401367,
0.8324733376502991,
0.39201581478118896,
0.8208277225494385,
-0.4807281494140625,
0.4323509931564331,
0.30316588282585144,
0.8048520684242249,
-0.10998554527759552,
0.03788993880152702,
0.25986820459365845,
-0.768222451210022,
-0.23273465037345886,
-0.5515958070755005,
-0.6108411550521851,
-0.12574024498462677,
-0.6498415470123291,
0.23996083438396454,
-0.6820458173751831,
-0.7452449798583984,
-0.18246930837631226,
-0.018461592495441437,
-0.022782117128372192,
0.07355783134698868,
-0.22520139813423157,
0.7248250246047974,
-0.4948529005050659,
0.500918447971344,
0.2850513458251953,
-0.02022096887230873,
-0.6388309001922607,
-0.13900691270828247,
0.14658115804195404,
-0.7430557012557983,
0.759946882724762,
-0.2067137509584427,
-0.4324587285518646,
-0.16729603707790375,
-0.8055136799812317,
-0.3391481339931488,
1.0319024324417114,
0.06750304251909256,
-0.3411930501461029,
0.21072277426719666,
-0.2606995105743408,
0.40384426712989807,
-0.6036719679832458,
0.23958666622638702,
0.31289049983024597,
0.8034098744392395,
0.12376782298088074,
-0.9762462973594666,
-0.08250690996646881,
0.2451113611459732,
-0.2547648251056671,
0.17816618084907532,
-0.7162498235702515,
0.9046990871429443,
-0.45648324489593506,
-0.2519586980342865,
0.1142759621143341,
0.6090633273124695,
0.2973894476890564,
0.0799330547451973,
0.9540703892707825,
0.07278557121753693,
0.6467041969299316,
0.01724664308130741,
1.0751336812973022,
-0.10488211363554001,
0.34999018907546997,
0.7073426842689514,
-0.732978105545044,
0.6799623370170593,
0.24191614985466003,
-0.11868336796760559,
0.3587720990180969,
0.39007672667503357,
-0.3683311343193054,
0.4625628888607025,
0.5370627641677856,
-0.13904891908168793,
-0.6464439630508423,
0.0799957662820816,
-0.36672526597976685,
0.6570712327957153,
0.008250176906585693,
-0.26628196239471436,
-0.24450428783893585,
0.022112445905804634,
0.05849103257060051,
0.20465917885303497,
-0.8840796947479248,
0.7726573944091797,
0.12029583007097244,
-0.3722919225692749,
0.47671133279800415,
0.07544240355491638,
0.4941225051879883,
-0.7670370936393738,
0.019305216148495674,
-0.0865117609500885,
0.30365028977394104,
-0.29232633113861084,
-0.9484912157058716,
0.005485508590936661,
0.10729171335697174,
-0.2873593866825104,
-0.026880409568548203,
0.28440991044044495,
0.03875526413321495,
-0.19325290620326996,
0.5050307512283325,
0.7006744742393494,
0.526800811290741,
-0.1440851390361786,
-0.38034188747406006,
0.16802692413330078,
-0.47898566722869873,
-0.07307806611061096,
0.18142962455749512,
0.28317055106163025,
0.005600405391305685,
0.5041249394416809,
0.42132917046546936,
0.27979862689971924,
-0.33256953954696655,
-0.2249545454978943,
0.7558963298797607,
-0.6132132411003113,
-0.30142825841903687,
-1.2820141315460205,
-0.024058202281594276,
-0.46062803268432617,
-0.33610406517982483,
1.2469099760055542,
0.7326385974884033,
0.34068939089775085,
-0.29806435108184814,
0.5605158805847168,
-0.3203417956829071,
0.24863147735595703,
-0.3347179591655731,
1.2711594104766846,
-0.2766124904155731,
-0.10659914463758469,
-0.599867582321167,
-1.0354996919631958,
0.21770471334457397,
0.3934893310070038,
-0.42224469780921936,
-0.2370709776878357,
0.5267117023468018,
0.775107204914093,
0.36327874660491943,
0.22192497551441193,
0.6298143863677979,
0.38302454352378845,
0.10348410904407501,
0.4228517711162567,
1.1925042867660522,
0.0008484588470309973,
0.3889416456222534,
0.3589257001876831,
-0.5163644552230835,
0.0644131675362587,
-0.6518239378929138,
-1.2782455682754517,
-0.5583460330963135,
0.22232788801193237,
-0.421572208404541,
-0.13469535112380981,
1.2111165523529053,
0.8170168995857239,
-0.5604097843170166,
-0.8162828087806702,
0.8051888346672058,
0.3542776107788086,
-0.4266723096370697,
-0.18513764441013336,
0.11847607046365738,
0.15422818064689636,
-0.39637571573257446,
0.3712901771068573,
0.40107086300849915,
-0.39010196924209595,
-0.3635551929473877,
-0.3854389786720276,
0.02922953851521015,
0.5182299613952637,
0.99064701795578,
-0.017907999455928802,
-1.0629942417144775,
-0.17184628546237946,
0.2240266501903534,
-0.270650714635849,
-0.18858622014522552,
0.8742464780807495,
-0.5116695165634155,
0.45445361733436584,
0.07842247188091278,
0.29214000701904297,
0.27455711364746094,
0.13025011122226715,
0.6134278774261475,
-0.08356375247240067,
-0.09446321427822113,
0.4420199394226074,
0.160962775349617,
0.029482509940862656,
-0.2665940523147583,
0.4144524037837982,
0.10272996127605438,
-0.7641496658325195,
-0.5796490907669067,
0.11630836129188538,
-1.0994035005569458,
-0.20264284312725067,
1.270921230316162,
0.19480690360069275,
-0.17858439683914185,
-0.23899735510349274,
-0.3671870827674866,
-0.40382349491119385,
-0.6983892917633057,
0.7070033550262451,
0.989129900932312,
0.014323141425848007,
-0.19466471672058105,
-0.6661584377288818,
0.39427798986434937,
-0.2814829349517822,
-0.760657012462616,
0.36947762966156006,
0.6586325168609619,
-0.14051951467990875,
0.24733267724514008,
0.600826621055603,
-0.2654368579387665,
0.08371469378471375,
-0.08277907967567444,
0.08651811629533768,
-0.11788606643676758,
-0.06941264122724533,
-0.1035178005695343,
0.11993113905191422,
-0.009009946137666702,
0.2897108495235443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01589v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01589v1
|
Classifying Cancer Stage with Open-Source Clinical Large Language Models
| 2024-04-02T02:30:47 | 2024-04-02T02:30:47 |
Chia-Hsuan Chang, Mary M. Lucas, Grace Lu-Yao, Christopher C. Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cancer stage classification is important for making treatment and care
management plans for oncology patients. Information on staging is often
included in unstructured form in clinical, pathology, radiology and other
free-text reports in the electronic health record system, requiring extensive
work to parse and obtain. To facilitate the extraction of this information,
previous NLP approaches rely on labeled training datasets, which are
labor-intensive to prepare. In this study, we demonstrate that without any
labeled training data, open-source clinical large language models (LLMs) can
extract pathologic tumor-node-metastasis (pTNM) staging information from
real-world pathology reports. Our experiments compare LLMs and a BERT-based
model fine-tuned using the labeled data. Our findings suggest that while LLMs
still exhibit subpar performance in Tumor (T) classification, with the
appropriate adoption of prompting strategies, they can achieve comparable
performance on Metastasis (M) classification and improved performance on Node
(N) classification.
|
[
0.10144037008285522,
-0.4467099905014038,
0.7736417055130005,
0.21803928911685944,
-0.4295703172683716,
-0.23953783512115479,
-0.28078699111938477,
-0.45308810472488403,
0.1807953268289566,
0.7608614563941956,
-0.4848659634590149,
-1.000228762626648,
-0.7451331615447998,
0.01627054251730442,
-0.3732641935348511,
1.1055476665496826,
0.40305787324905396,
0.4886012375354767,
-0.1425594687461853,
0.03132835775613785,
-0.04355793446302414,
-0.1770102083683014,
-0.9468424916267395,
-0.3628156781196594,
0.9625726342201233,
0.4179534912109375,
0.6263828873634338,
1.0824172496795654,
0.4969138503074646,
0.21326076984405518,
-0.10623258352279663,
-0.05268578603863716,
-0.07640478014945984,
0.3550300896167755,
-0.04201110079884529,
-0.36548489332199097,
-0.3463212847709656,
0.030841248109936714,
0.3785049617290497,
0.8165539503097534,
-0.17629531025886536,
-0.1308451145887375,
-0.040773313492536545,
0.4055352807044983,
-0.4849715232849121,
0.4541970491409302,
-0.5004352927207947,
0.34836727380752563,
-0.2074655145406723,
-0.21678879857063293,
-0.6557291150093079,
-0.7551254630088806,
0.10881125181913376,
-0.5962036848068237,
0.14164020121097565,
-0.39641568064689636,
0.5720347166061401,
0.04209718480706215,
-0.49705570936203003,
-0.47777310013771057,
-0.8606661558151245,
0.43682432174682617,
-0.9334756731987,
0.21322506666183472,
0.31063112616539,
0.5747644901275635,
-0.029194649308919907,
-0.974232017993927,
-0.04611290618777275,
-0.24093309044837952,
-0.051125045865774155,
0.01993219554424286,
-0.0257053654640913,
0.5768826603889465,
0.3920353651046753,
0.3363502323627472,
-0.4714776277542114,
0.6577726602554321,
-0.3772885799407959,
-0.2597167491912842,
0.40268829464912415,
0.29615312814712524,
0.21501955389976501,
-0.27014827728271484,
-0.2041761875152588,
-0.07440376281738281,
-0.8657935261726379,
-0.20379287004470825,
-0.3750389516353607,
0.6930352449417114,
0.24726900458335876,
0.6583952307701111,
-0.3796018362045288,
0.7277684807777405,
-0.30945655703544617,
-0.3356843590736389,
0.032119281589984894,
0.07875828444957733,
-0.3518948554992676,
0.20756390690803528,
0.9357890486717224,
0.21623685956001282,
0.07791461795568466,
-0.2355950027704239,
0.15271034836769104,
-0.1221245750784874,
0.23411184549331665,
-0.8500444889068604,
-0.2900907099246979,
0.2815178334712982,
-0.6774613261222839,
-0.3841024935245514,
-0.22789251804351807,
-0.8288760781288147,
-0.7680265307426453,
0.07683876901865005,
0.6046756505966187,
-0.21082328259944916,
0.0235613826662302,
0.07083320617675781,
0.10911517590284348,
-0.17062406241893768,
0.6328292489051819,
-0.3828928768634796,
0.16052831709384918,
0.681769847869873,
0.9193048477172852,
0.1982227861881256,
0.2681419849395752,
-0.9024727940559387,
0.16510343551635742,
-0.23413251340389252,
0.5782566666603088,
-0.7162975072860718,
-0.35673314332962036,
0.34083694219589233,
0.2334330528974533,
-0.21083897352218628,
-0.5212199091911316,
0.6332583427429199,
-0.3779180645942688,
0.48562121391296387,
-0.20462311804294586,
-0.6758944988250732,
-0.03202846646308899,
0.213521808385849,
-0.764126718044281,
0.6649964451789856,
0.10293914377689362,
-0.6816220283508301,
0.528265118598938,
-0.7462753057479858,
-0.23889370262622833,
0.2630036175251007,
-0.12312394380569458,
-0.33707380294799805,
-0.004074875731021166,
0.21212153136730194,
0.8320026397705078,
-0.1917371153831482,
0.17635297775268555,
-0.17698219418525696,
-0.11039162427186966,
0.08270082622766495,
-0.0068574463948607445,
0.5422921776771545,
0.3426806330680847,
-0.14511415362358093,
0.029554560780525208,
-0.9551544785499573,
0.0970219150185585,
0.04236506670713425,
-0.552815854549408,
-0.4209862947463989,
0.3398604094982147,
-0.3870656490325928,
0.606453537940979,
-0.05014849826693535,
-0.8230710625648499,
0.25797414779663086,
-0.620894193649292,
0.1893439143896103,
0.3212845027446747,
-0.19596035778522491,
0.06478013843297958,
-0.2665329575538635,
0.5260490775108337,
0.016641002148389816,
0.09719652682542801,
-0.11888767033815384,
-0.8221896290779114,
-0.5517838001251221,
-0.24411310255527496,
0.5398210287094116,
0.57232266664505,
-0.6941298246383667,
0.14747174084186554,
-0.3871784210205078,
-0.6081798672676086,
-0.30026182532310486,
-0.35255634784698486,
0.42543303966522217,
0.8410014510154724,
0.42845991253852844,
-0.22351276874542236,
-0.5082959532737732,
-0.6451010704040527,
0.05365736782550812,
-0.16833513975143433,
-0.43008652329444885,
0.3692968785762787,
-0.08076316863298416,
0.048901449888944626,
0.5703805685043335,
-0.6507148742675781,
-0.4763742685317993,
-0.2319185733795166,
0.26835861802101135,
0.2436034083366394,
0.08225570619106293,
-0.04433417692780495,
-0.27615150809288025,
-0.39415478706359863,
0.20293036103248596,
-0.6531810164451599,
-0.5913677215576172,
0.1538996398448944,
0.11121392250061035,
-0.13698774576187134,
0.5799565315246582,
-0.4224121868610382,
0.48797836899757385,
0.5166575908660889,
-0.19438284635543823,
0.2432214468717575,
-0.3239468038082123,
0.02908731997013092,
-0.8951734304428101,
0.13995613157749176,
0.15388789772987366,
-0.49181878566741943,
-0.7608197927474976,
-0.272854208946228,
-0.010545112192630768,
-0.07032632827758789,
-0.3496004343032837,
0.3591296672821045,
-0.2715508043766022,
-0.23714867234230042,
-0.2825107276439667,
0.09140735864639282,
-0.03803649917244911,
0.13795067369937897,
0.6329711079597473,
0.08470592647790909,
0.22152535617351532,
-0.6248541474342346,
-0.0006216410547494888,
0.17431046068668365,
-0.507887065410614,
0.041174884885549545,
-0.40828609466552734,
-0.06125279888510704,
0.0697699710726738,
0.37276560068130493,
-0.6344587206840515,
-0.28235965967178345,
0.37699320912361145,
-0.18081636726856232,
0.3299395740032196,
-0.48381859064102173,
-0.4780566394329071,
-0.4939441978931427,
0.1724119633436203,
0.01689869537949562,
0.49970877170562744,
-0.22468437254428864,
0.21734382212162018,
0.09653721004724503,
-0.345863401889801,
-0.41234299540519714,
-0.7078632116317749,
-0.17353396117687225,
-0.15871401131153107,
-0.28748995065689087,
0.18217454850673676,
0.29060718417167664,
0.0014042984694242477,
-0.05062670260667801,
0.15168693661689758,
-0.28889426589012146,
-0.1114516481757164,
0.3920244574546814,
-0.03630194067955017,
-0.30092760920524597,
0.3720632791519165,
0.08522001653909683,
0.027865372598171234,
0.111536905169487,
-0.06727655977010727,
0.4636240601539612,
0.6901463270187378,
-0.5289629101753235,
-0.3704228401184082,
0.30479592084884644,
0.6683233976364136,
-0.03982752561569214,
0.8698921203613281,
0.42736387252807617,
-0.6046116948127747,
-0.14992015063762665,
-0.2473369687795639,
-0.12596489489078522,
-0.3103627860546112,
0.2535449266433716,
0.27530673146247864,
-1.0398595333099365,
0.4155927002429962,
-0.31349819898605347,
0.29299822449684143,
0.570684552192688,
0.7142390012741089,
-0.07862523943185806,
1.1831040382385254,
0.26899343729019165,
0.2341495305299759,
0.23900596797466278,
0.133919820189476,
-0.26421797275543213,
-0.6604329943656921,
-0.5203696489334106,
-0.8906145691871643,
-0.1781720668077469,
-0.3701922297477722,
-0.6982381939888,
0.7628218531608582,
-0.3068263828754425,
-0.19509904086589813,
0.020219312980771065,
-0.7141079902648926,
0.21607309579849243,
0.14231479167938232,
0.5667768120765686,
0.46271705627441406,
0.000015252800949383527,
0.03205304592847824,
-0.3357224762439728,
-0.7910699844360352,
-0.4247172474861145,
1.3407407999038696,
0.5313605666160583,
0.5026757121086121,
-0.08036491274833679,
0.6213263869285583,
0.07403270900249481,
0.47406214475631714,
-0.7683212757110596,
0.4759531319141388,
-0.7322824001312256,
-0.5826259851455688,
-0.3289022445678711,
-0.6034635901451111,
-1.2790892124176025,
0.23793219029903412,
-0.2548602521419525,
-0.770187258720398,
0.14774242043495178,
-0.10559958219528198,
-0.5754150748252869,
0.29733556509017944,
-0.284334272146225,
0.7494877576828003,
-0.249360129237175,
0.1791761964559555,
-0.007995044812560081,
-0.6621848344802856,
0.34851282835006714,
-0.10369895398616791,
0.5790601372718811,
-0.0775437131524086,
-0.1392003446817398,
0.9154323935508728,
-0.7008766531944275,
0.9042664766311646,
-0.5019407868385315,
-0.09294953942298889,
-0.03045148216187954,
0.2737310826778412,
0.5164293050765991,
-0.05891599506139755,
-0.09735247492790222,
-0.002320717554539442,
-0.00008006727148313075,
-0.16268393397331238,
-0.47332775592803955,
0.5389919281005859,
-0.5043342113494873,
-0.20586055517196655,
-0.3324611783027649,
-0.4178575575351715,
-0.49376964569091797,
0.19787946343421936,
0.3419432044029236,
0.5965321660041809,
-0.1933203935623169,
0.3128274977207184,
0.9307054281234741,
-0.5121944546699524,
0.2269309014081955,
0.609572172164917,
-0.4025150239467621,
-0.27571025490760803,
0.5998455882072449,
0.14021702110767365,
0.35210123658180237,
0.6019389033317566,
0.5517063140869141,
-0.15994231402873993,
-0.8323861956596375,
-0.19621771574020386,
0.06449577957391739,
-0.6789836287498474,
-0.2526262402534485,
-0.9849693179130554,
-0.43215876817703247,
-0.30392009019851685,
0.14859887957572937,
-0.28521841764450073,
-0.6173120737075806,
-0.37324103713035583,
-0.03328733146190643,
0.3545295298099518,
0.827900230884552,
-0.18810786306858063,
0.43678250908851624,
-1.159426212310791,
-0.08496421575546265,
0.23589372634887695,
0.3755258619785309,
-0.06115737929940224,
-0.4647237956523895,
-0.5684653520584106,
0.09317004680633545,
-0.08353755623102188,
-1.0661005973815918,
0.506192684173584,
0.48639488220214844,
0.4878677725791931,
0.5598898530006409,
0.019697699695825577,
0.47040751576423645,
-0.3079357147216797,
0.6871997714042664,
0.10937809944152832,
-0.5238105654716492,
0.7735349535942078,
-0.5688745379447937,
0.3827243745326996,
0.43096959590911865,
0.6921438574790955,
-0.6527915000915527,
-0.4007318317890167,
-0.3851914405822754,
-0.6642683744430542,
1.2081520557403564,
0.06636068969964981,
-0.34934303164482117,
-0.08464942872524261,
0.13481897115707397,
0.25221285223960876,
0.23302242159843445,
-0.8396320343017578,
0.170082226395607,
-0.07466068863868713,
-0.22349147498607635,
-0.12502998113632202,
-0.2599618136882782,
-0.5803640484809875,
-0.21525272727012634,
0.29544171690940857,
-0.0566939078271389,
0.4725898206233978,
0.2789876461029053,
-0.03370700031518936,
-0.16877765953540802,
0.21805161237716675,
0.4302839934825897,
0.3062087893486023,
-0.3382498323917389,
0.0008884862763807178,
0.04897203668951988,
-0.36520686745643616,
-0.12860117852687836,
0.022454675287008286,
0.11428357660770416,
0.10603545606136322,
0.7492362260818481,
0.5780586004257202,
0.40389284491539,
-0.604206383228302,
0.6407545804977417,
-0.1284400224685669,
-0.3031075596809387,
0.19962701201438904,
0.05863048508763313,
0.04126868396997452,
0.2707701325416565,
0.1276100128889084,
-0.4458717107772827,
0.28352612257003784,
-0.30389612913131714,
0.08095985651016235,
0.24744181334972382,
-0.6176887154579163,
-0.07334314286708832,
0.47244879603385925,
0.04206740856170654,
-0.07483058422803879,
0.6664956212043762,
0.11479882150888443,
-0.1327577829360962,
0.5194101333618164,
0.6110355854034424,
0.6929122805595398,
-0.28997528553009033,
0.5584777593612671,
0.43608155846595764,
0.20050667226314545,
-0.16821566224098206,
0.1032722145318985,
0.24785922467708588,
-0.34150493144989014,
-0.7062153816223145,
-0.7630385160446167,
-0.4568498134613037,
0.34438279271125793,
-0.5498409867286682,
0.2074815034866333,
-0.8239016532897949,
-0.019228866323828697,
0.09559857845306396,
-0.24011588096618652,
-0.345763623714447,
0.673099160194397,
0.3664223253726959,
1.0317546129226685,
-0.922995388507843,
0.9150022864341736,
0.5575240254402161,
-0.008681286126375198,
-0.9414267539978027,
-0.22565966844558716,
-0.031305525451898575,
-0.5540341734886169,
0.5557439923286438,
0.2924535274505615,
0.5406696200370789,
-0.21056872606277466,
-0.3900339603424072,
-0.8371370434761047,
1.0776481628417969,
0.11826740950345993,
-0.4611842632293701,
-0.4517923593521118,
0.3338724672794342,
0.8538026809692383,
-0.5572502613067627,
0.505021870136261,
-0.06212250143289566,
0.4073445796966553,
0.5382114052772522,
-1.155748724937439,
0.07079198211431503,
0.2104930728673935,
-0.1916104108095169,
0.28725019097328186,
-0.25155109167099,
0.8395432829856873,
0.16414190828800201,
-0.23463724553585052,
0.03486216440796852,
0.13156373798847198,
-0.012113919481635094,
0.6361347436904907,
0.5030362010002136,
0.6798410415649414,
0.634306788444519,
-0.3644983172416687,
0.8888742327690125,
0.020965201780200005,
0.19763486087322235,
0.6309958100318909,
-0.1834024041891098,
0.6967687606811523,
-0.22166289389133453,
-0.25322434306144714,
0.7707321047782898,
0.7774868607521057,
0.24880418181419373,
0.46880438923835754,
0.07003825902938843,
-0.018829334527254105,
-0.5794709920883179,
0.026597602292895317,
-0.531424880027771,
0.4389331340789795,
0.6304618716239929,
-0.7568312883377075,
-0.4924984276294708,
0.12094797194004059,
0.2884686291217804,
-0.18134582042694092,
-0.4848518967628479,
0.9735115170478821,
0.10061058402061462,
-0.5228379368782043,
0.4865392744541168,
-0.03730432689189911,
0.40437227487564087,
-0.9162225723266602,
0.07785683870315552,
-0.07174407690763474,
-0.09801401197910309,
-0.45255526900291443,
-0.7039054036140442,
0.4659518599510193,
0.0621124692261219,
-0.04734424129128456,
0.004157218616455793,
0.7616451978683472,
-0.416421502828598,
-0.597208559513092,
0.27114126086235046,
0.35839205980300903,
0.38040828704833984,
-0.08417824655771255,
-0.5449320673942566,
-0.05598006397485733,
-0.10841812938451767,
-0.17285166680812836,
0.7856400012969971,
0.4613085091114044,
-0.05755322426557541,
0.7974259257316589,
0.5741773843765259,
0.3448546826839447,
-0.0007333042449317873,
-0.07231809943914413,
0.8711534142494202,
-0.6350493431091309,
-0.2777557969093323,
-0.5981471538543701,
0.35537636280059814,
-0.03962988033890724,
-0.1409199982881546,
0.43156230449676514,
0.2620205283164978,
0.4284316599369049,
0.10829085856676102,
0.547656774520874,
-0.08121463656425476,
0.8970128297805786,
-0.6752641201019287,
0.6192079782485962,
-0.6196430921554565,
0.3509634733200073,
-0.36240044236183167,
-0.6240737438201904,
-0.5968871116638184,
0.13393904268741608,
-0.41067883372306824,
0.19104263186454773,
0.7046541571617126,
0.6159118413925171,
0.12332870066165924,
-0.09782838076353073,
0.367762953042984,
0.46292492747306824,
0.3137369453907013,
0.7807121872901917,
0.4614156186580658,
0.005115494132041931,
0.6271923184394836,
-0.30903834104537964,
-0.4208272695541382,
-0.377344012260437,
-0.8349424004554749,
-0.7919559478759766,
-0.4542725384235382,
-0.3726843297481537,
-0.48532989621162415,
0.03931063041090965,
0.8536375761032104,
0.8433005213737488,
-0.6734145283699036,
-0.011142756789922714,
0.3152170777320862,
-0.010140926577150822,
-0.11746983975172043,
-0.1269308477640152,
0.31853756308555603,
-0.07771420478820801,
-0.6015766859054565,
0.7835891842842102,
0.3174595236778259,
-0.2958413064479828,
-0.13193902373313904,
0.1377774477005005,
-0.2784624695777893,
-0.13904835283756256,
0.604403555393219,
0.41666027903556824,
-0.4074343740940094,
0.006765072233974934,
-0.16325132548809052,
-0.32449471950531006,
0.1431908756494522,
0.7806412577629089,
-0.8712923526763916,
0.6177093386650085,
0.4187823534011841,
0.29964524507522583,
0.307523638010025,
-0.10650501400232315,
0.4930829405784607,
-0.6723488569259644,
-0.23718789219856262,
0.5133543014526367,
0.03592979907989502,
0.13649912178516388,
-0.4418379068374634,
0.33097630739212036,
0.18550370633602142,
-0.808447003364563,
-0.8364565968513489,
0.12234271317720413,
-0.9128418564796448,
-0.45550110936164856,
1.3873882293701172,
-0.31565776467323303,
-0.0980835035443306,
-0.2673752009868622,
-0.050798896700143814,
0.433083176612854,
-0.3219108283519745,
0.666620671749115,
0.489082008600235,
-0.4247855842113495,
-0.27427223324775696,
-0.4343513548374176,
0.6017648577690125,
0.023614590987563133,
-0.8151845932006836,
-0.0802820473909378,
0.6131360530853271,
0.2630253732204437,
-0.028422720730304718,
0.8290244936943054,
-0.47978636622428894,
0.22546875476837158,
-0.43021360039711,
0.03381478413939476,
-0.12154222279787064,
-0.28317928314208984,
-0.34913620352745056,
0.499362051486969,
0.2227620929479599,
-0.050217028707265854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01588v1
|
Hallucination Diversity-Aware Active Learning for Text Summarization
| 2024-04-02T02:30:27 | 2024-04-02T02:30:27 |
Yu Xia, Xu Liu, Tong Yu, Sungchul Kim, Ryan A. Rossi, Anup Rao, Tung Mai, Shuai Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown propensity to generate hallucinated
outputs, i.e., texts that are factually incorrect or unsupported. Existing
methods for alleviating hallucinations typically require costly human
annotations to identify and correct hallucinations in LLM outputs. Moreover,
most of these methods focus on a specific type of hallucination, e.g., entity
or token errors, which limits their effectiveness in addressing various types
of hallucinations exhibited in LLM outputs. To our best knowledge, in this
paper we propose the first active learning framework to alleviate LLM
hallucinations, reducing costly human annotations of hallucination needed. By
measuring fine-grained hallucinations from errors in semantic frame, discourse
and content verifiability in text summarization, we propose HAllucination
Diversity-Aware Sampling (HADAS) to select diverse hallucinations for
annotations in active learning for LLM finetuning. Extensive experiments on
three datasets and different backbone models demonstrate advantages of our
method in effectively and efficiently mitigating LLM hallucinations.
|
[
-0.1703224778175354,
-0.8861578702926636,
0.34175434708595276,
0.36847326159477234,
-0.4623207449913025,
0.02691631019115448,
-0.30424389243125916,
-0.42279553413391113,
0.6184495091438293,
0.6417380571365356,
-0.391633003950119,
-0.6992479562759399,
-0.47216325998306274,
0.4020645320415497,
-0.6166114211082458,
1.0444848537445068,
-0.14440332353115082,
0.10711618512868881,
0.10017004609107971,
-0.3451782166957855,
-0.3363548219203949,
-0.41141000390052795,
-0.4828910231590271,
-0.1330246925354004,
0.594314455986023,
0.31972455978393555,
0.5772165656089783,
0.3133704960346222,
0.45492079854011536,
0.2518593668937683,
-0.36677876114845276,
0.6577757596969604,
-0.7551817893981934,
0.4361155927181244,
-0.028492184355854988,
-0.5016743540763855,
-0.5626193881034851,
-0.2859668731689453,
0.6045646071434021,
0.9824244379997253,
-0.15582877397537231,
-0.172475665807724,
0.1890224665403366,
0.59334796667099,
-0.8141480684280396,
-0.10997486859560013,
-0.8486365079879761,
0.4392533302307129,
0.0670987144112587,
-0.053207822144031525,
-0.29139387607574463,
-0.39643311500549316,
-0.10491388291120529,
-0.5324848294258118,
0.45590823888778687,
-0.10727740079164505,
0.691356897354126,
0.6470240950584412,
-0.4165802597999573,
-0.502392053604126,
-0.6757672429084778,
0.7059045433998108,
-0.5433230400085449,
0.19389377534389496,
0.4616638422012329,
0.22185662388801575,
0.08179064095020294,
-0.6536897420883179,
-0.548694908618927,
0.2745048999786377,
-0.08025617152452469,
0.3103424906730652,
0.010335268452763557,
0.1005106121301651,
0.08067168295383453,
0.6917895078659058,
-0.39046502113342285,
0.1267932504415512,
-0.5374230742454529,
-0.4255492687225342,
0.5923482179641724,
0.11965020000934601,
0.10192717611789703,
-0.14506648480892181,
-0.18871842324733734,
0.013716711662709713,
-0.5423909425735474,
-0.3607894778251648,
0.3871356248855591,
0.3064163029193878,
0.009040500037372112,
0.7635172605514526,
-0.08507665246725082,
0.4468417167663574,
-0.11545310169458389,
-0.06788524985313416,
0.336815744638443,
-0.37244781851768494,
-0.32300975918769836,
0.34300699830055237,
0.45449507236480713,
0.2601073980331421,
0.28131261467933655,
-0.4820566773414612,
-0.4668945074081421,
-0.02663353830575943,
0.3373672664165497,
-0.7535200715065002,
-0.3667202591896057,
0.41317233443260193,
-0.42688170075416565,
-0.3458980619907379,
0.12863130867481232,
-0.9548594951629639,
-0.7236524224281311,
-0.07695868611335754,
0.506625771522522,
-0.2776491940021515,
-0.1285836547613144,
0.24487735331058502,
-0.12654118239879608,
-0.007495943456888199,
0.5301091074943542,
-0.9478498101234436,
0.3974279463291168,
0.31657907366752625,
1.0097486972808838,
-0.8113777041435242,
-0.4400158226490021,
-0.726209819316864,
0.18692253530025482,
-0.1582956314086914,
0.932055652141571,
-0.09315438568592072,
-0.36338043212890625,
0.08458545804023743,
-0.09380530565977097,
0.08767343312501907,
-0.7166111469268799,
0.4755365550518036,
-0.15117381513118744,
0.009451370686292648,
-0.2159864604473114,
-0.3222431242465973,
-0.5344738364219666,
0.19245408475399017,
-0.898632287979126,
0.7706604599952698,
0.0015705497935414314,
-0.7789003849029541,
0.4376259744167328,
-0.1691938191652298,
-0.8166335225105286,
-0.17053784430027008,
-0.3177643120288849,
-0.7703254818916321,
0.13672973215579987,
0.2789146900177002,
0.5274211764335632,
0.407733678817749,
0.3071524202823639,
-0.08513862639665604,
-0.5351067185401917,
0.051474299281835556,
-0.41428786516189575,
0.7542392015457153,
0.13084961473941803,
-0.567282497882843,
0.5667870044708252,
-0.8192797303199768,
-0.6274588108062744,
-0.06437664479017258,
-0.26878514885902405,
-0.4374084770679474,
0.020710701122879982,
0.07907207310199738,
-0.2691238224506378,
-0.11169248819351196,
-0.20917880535125732,
0.09146254509687424,
-0.5928269028663635,
-0.2144608199596405,
0.6601500511169434,
0.1336802840232849,
0.46166521310806274,
-0.5992012023925781,
0.37535712122917175,
0.11039916425943375,
-0.24709758162498474,
-0.1392546147108078,
-0.43533363938331604,
-0.8111125826835632,
-0.6646454930305481,
0.07508722692728043,
0.565417468547821,
-0.6116043925285339,
0.6357256174087524,
-0.046486031264066696,
-0.3403923511505127,
-0.32305583357810974,
0.2295074164867401,
0.051698941737413406,
0.14213216304779053,
0.44527050852775574,
-0.17927922308444977,
-0.8176797032356262,
-0.585091769695282,
-0.20149345695972443,
-0.0812312662601471,
-0.10536453872919083,
0.12138902395963669,
0.5564762949943542,
-0.3435037434101105,
0.7064684629440308,
-0.39623427391052246,
-0.8244169354438782,
-0.5043866634368896,
0.19906304776668549,
-0.11319379508495331,
0.2091396600008011,
0.38796889781951904,
-0.6737079620361328,
-0.0579395592212677,
-0.26189205050468445,
-0.8846198916435242,
-0.13421261310577393,
-0.49645277857780457,
0.023111408576369286,
0.26359015703201294,
0.33969420194625854,
-0.5126760005950928,
0.3918078541755676,
0.552147388458252,
-0.4993875026702881,
0.4135688245296478,
0.032401710748672485,
0.20410555601119995,
-0.9922347068786621,
-0.1195082738995552,
-0.2996801733970642,
-0.1885104477405548,
-0.2936517000198364,
-0.19686263799667358,
-0.07879571616649628,
0.04351833462715149,
-0.13093803822994232,
0.5279810428619385,
-0.5927749276161194,
-0.11480490118265152,
-0.36613136529922485,
0.3229692578315735,
-0.09139256924390793,
0.4716391861438751,
0.10805512219667435,
0.5216431617736816,
0.5057739615440369,
-0.6867679953575134,
0.16298377513885498,
0.3596287667751312,
-0.22623877227306366,
-0.05484740436077118,
-0.26839679479599,
-0.4388037323951721,
-0.3544725477695465,
0.19366495311260223,
-1.1506288051605225,
-0.4926941692829132,
0.3037240207195282,
-0.31934523582458496,
0.09157220274209976,
0.37989646196365356,
-0.17240741848945618,
0.08014651387929916,
-0.41797491908073425,
0.34051427245140076,
0.3293541669845581,
-0.6444786190986633,
0.8581311106681824,
0.4576233923435211,
-0.13334523141384125,
-0.6141486167907715,
-0.8892949223518372,
0.08036571741104126,
0.001747701084241271,
-0.36486685276031494,
0.44702890515327454,
0.00950581580400467,
-0.4306413233280182,
-0.13024279475212097,
-0.38116711378097534,
0.06624376773834229,
0.4069008529186249,
0.2271834909915924,
0.004802755545824766,
-0.03609243780374527,
0.22199343144893646,
0.38851505517959595,
0.14103588461875916,
-0.001551831141114235,
0.07790175080299377,
0.48067596554756165,
0.1613573431968689,
-0.4988652765750885,
-0.1697244495153427,
0.41250547766685486,
0.34593236446380615,
-0.12089581787586212,
0.6454263925552368,
0.5555571913719177,
-0.772216260433197,
-0.6099254488945007,
-0.534139096736908,
-0.5906727910041809,
-0.34125834703445435,
0.5640011429786682,
0.030750492587685585,
-0.9283145666122437,
0.9078152775764465,
0.1952686756849289,
0.5794573426246643,
0.48661062121391296,
0.7521992325782776,
0.22537682950496674,
0.6251896023750305,
0.4438846707344055,
0.3607253432273865,
0.3393092751502991,
-0.18290548026561737,
0.22942493855953217,
-0.2398492395877838,
-0.2483358383178711,
-0.41827821731567383,
-0.35621362924575806,
-0.2782553434371948,
-0.4495421051979065,
0.04848344624042511,
0.021715624257922173,
0.20309139788150787,
-0.3249136805534363,
-0.47040584683418274,
0.5226671695709229,
0.32017889618873596,
0.20040275156497955,
0.571052074432373,
0.2431080937385559,
0.08077102154493332,
-0.02308276854455471,
-0.5748254656791687,
-0.4561983346939087,
0.8823167681694031,
0.3257317841053009,
0.8428385257720947,
0.2661374807357788,
0.8511202931404114,
0.41569793224334717,
0.3907535970211029,
-0.991389274597168,
0.5674872398376465,
-0.15777969360351562,
-0.506456732749939,
-0.5677886009216309,
-0.6215723156929016,
-0.7743802070617676,
0.4147598445415497,
-0.42519402503967285,
-0.5190522074699402,
0.30161741375923157,
0.17440906167030334,
-0.49928608536720276,
0.6401822566986084,
-0.41535285115242004,
0.6115596890449524,
-0.055508874356746674,
-0.30897945165634155,
-0.2241714596748352,
-0.38913071155548096,
0.7600671052932739,
-0.13051071763038635,
0.2068551480770111,
0.10377496480941772,
-0.12100144475698471,
0.8130172491073608,
0.04222070798277855,
1.2373307943344116,
-0.04166646674275398,
-0.225017249584198,
0.28666841983795166,
0.1696814000606537,
0.5859013795852661,
0.21612291038036346,
0.03253260254859924,
0.04500412195920944,
-0.6668071746826172,
-0.2628808617591858,
-0.3200320601463318,
0.658811092376709,
-0.7219523787498474,
-0.4555894434452057,
-0.4617328643798828,
-0.47897517681121826,
-0.042306531220674515,
0.06048557162284851,
0.308396577835083,
0.19761846959590912,
-0.2560301721096039,
0.23550887405872345,
1.1392489671707153,
-0.1427450329065323,
0.5172873735427856,
0.12800760567188263,
-0.4240979254245758,
-0.6496343016624451,
0.8031309843063354,
0.261711448431015,
-0.05254052206873894,
0.11947273463010788,
0.01679074577987194,
-0.03208388388156891,
-1.0904384851455688,
-0.2456224113702774,
0.2667255699634552,
-1.0093066692352295,
-0.3961670696735382,
-1.3206464052200317,
-0.26772603392601013,
-0.4504079222679138,
-0.4294785261154175,
-0.2905321419239044,
-0.6045159697532654,
-0.505196213722229,
-0.5226879119873047,
0.32103708386421204,
0.47662708163261414,
0.05022904649376869,
0.24100275337696075,
-0.6440338492393494,
0.7024795413017273,
0.43741461634635925,
0.36213457584381104,
0.09732358157634735,
-0.6014952063560486,
-0.20004849135875702,
-0.11073528230190277,
-0.2487357258796692,
-1.0807547569274902,
0.413830041885376,
0.16381222009658813,
0.7323936223983765,
0.5670951008796692,
0.3227096498012543,
0.3595961332321167,
-0.02711690217256546,
0.9389815926551819,
0.11739587783813477,
-0.8362708687782288,
0.3934532105922699,
-0.11145918071269989,
0.29631397128105164,
0.7187538743019104,
0.22600126266479492,
-0.3778044879436493,
-0.8970559239387512,
-0.3699534833431244,
-1.1392292976379395,
0.42068132758140564,
0.4260248839855194,
0.10346132516860962,
-0.18483220040798187,
0.2224833369255066,
0.6481809616088867,
0.13108384609222412,
-1.1172618865966797,
-0.17229437828063965,
-0.5276600122451782,
-0.4227803945541382,
0.06571388244628906,
-0.37847232818603516,
-0.07554017007350922,
-0.11410728842020035,
0.9912118315696716,
-0.13556797802448273,
-0.15781819820404053,
0.39726877212524414,
-0.4860246777534485,
-0.22727631032466888,
0.045023113489151,
0.7662209272384644,
0.690569281578064,
-0.2941896915435791,
0.41570180654525757,
0.4479186534881592,
-0.6980880498886108,
-0.07328881323337555,
-0.014139454811811447,
-0.38112872838974,
0.4386226236820221,
0.48644348978996277,
0.7624837160110474,
0.2438122183084488,
-0.8999861478805542,
0.5006478428840637,
-0.22212360799312592,
-0.308688759803772,
-0.36442235112190247,
0.25954100489616394,
-0.11356872320175171,
0.05935782566666603,
0.6491250395774841,
0.06296992301940918,
0.31245070695877075,
-0.41625043749809265,
0.3977870047092438,
0.1704738289117813,
-0.49176788330078125,
-0.11378050595521927,
0.6969859004020691,
0.43088605999946594,
-0.2987026572227478,
0.47030308842658997,
-0.24732470512390137,
-0.36626601219177246,
0.5012655854225159,
0.5176368355751038,
1.2547869682312012,
-0.211970254778862,
0.08881928771734238,
0.5452117919921875,
0.45802590250968933,
-0.18938252329826355,
0.3108818531036377,
-0.07353761792182922,
-0.661188006401062,
-0.4053904116153717,
-0.6927834153175354,
-0.40010908246040344,
-0.06407878547906876,
-0.4351104199886322,
0.5193222761154175,
-0.33017775416374207,
0.08864517509937286,
-0.20492248237133026,
-0.1792280077934265,
0.029750922694802284,
0.04570462182164192,
0.18867696821689606,
0.6385552883148193,
-1.0312026739120483,
0.4492521584033966,
0.6576229929924011,
-0.380654513835907,
-0.25004151463508606,
0.30574074387550354,
-0.08251529932022095,
-0.3893139362335205,
0.2172771841287613,
0.374138206243515,
-0.1906946897506714,
0.016425319015979767,
-0.38259774446487427,
-0.36416149139404297,
0.9913980960845947,
0.01837729476392269,
-0.4939138889312744,
-0.04530830681324005,
-0.23885640501976013,
0.28554511070251465,
-0.3245914876461029,
-0.09677296131849289,
0.228288471698761,
0.30723509192466736,
0.2793591320514679,
-0.44958025217056274,
0.1822727620601654,
-0.13663792610168457,
-0.41388794779777527,
0.1613767147064209,
-0.4896857738494873,
0.6935583353042603,
-0.48505327105522156,
-0.31804022192955017,
-0.11171217262744904,
1.113623857498169,
0.4028572738170624,
0.4445818364620209,
0.6028025150299072,
0.2993338108062744,
1.0901684761047363,
0.008084673434495926,
0.5977030396461487,
0.03570990636944771,
0.04945219308137894,
1.1236218214035034,
-0.28761062026023865,
0.4226396977901459,
0.5522329807281494,
0.21526937186717987,
0.04130776971578598,
0.5749823451042175,
-0.21173451840877533,
0.4810642898082733,
0.3110187351703644,
-0.3952628970146179,
-0.3003080487251282,
0.18735958635807037,
-0.18065063655376434,
0.3077460825443268,
0.369475394487381,
-0.3151278495788574,
-0.3461098074913025,
0.42236706614494324,
0.016655463725328445,
0.35053232312202454,
-0.3629819452762604,
1.0852073431015015,
0.023396875709295273,
-0.705478847026825,
0.6094794273376465,
0.040557652711868286,
0.8985528349876404,
-0.5738807320594788,
-0.1744753122329712,
-0.7275683283805847,
0.05833455175161362,
-0.3916019797325134,
-0.48810961842536926,
0.6257198452949524,
0.1009809821844101,
-0.3269808292388916,
-0.051594823598861694,
0.6249147057533264,
-0.516088604927063,
-0.5296527147293091,
0.2442655712366104,
0.41453787684440613,
0.255315363407135,
-0.1455218642950058,
-0.09111461788415909,
0.02265966311097145,
0.28791114687919617,
-0.257858544588089,
0.140313982963562,
0.6901153326034546,
-0.15543705224990845,
0.441275954246521,
0.29022863507270813,
0.20253850519657135,
0.05875781551003456,
0.27171146869659424,
0.8189147710800171,
-0.729088306427002,
-0.5895252823829651,
-0.8475148677825928,
0.44397658109664917,
-0.23930571973323822,
-0.35367920994758606,
0.6889124512672424,
0.8387702703475952,
0.6001936793327332,
-0.04306722804903984,
0.8108041286468506,
0.21096372604370117,
0.4325214922428131,
-0.6152871251106262,
0.9412232041358948,
-0.6159540414810181,
0.4534744322299957,
-0.12963217496871948,
-1.0825822353363037,
-0.6616445183753967,
0.7001490592956543,
0.1905936449766159,
-0.13312262296676636,
0.8653994798660278,
0.7610180974006653,
-0.13140973448753357,
0.2327895611524582,
0.46255019307136536,
0.37676623463630676,
0.03812924027442932,
0.058389801532030106,
0.645229160785675,
-0.27319222688674927,
0.8124104738235474,
-0.16346211731433868,
-0.4004770517349243,
-0.4469325542449951,
-0.5704149603843689,
-1.2578637599945068,
-0.43294593691825867,
-0.4276156425476074,
-0.38243868947029114,
0.1919993907213211,
0.7955722808837891,
0.14615803956985474,
-1.0968408584594727,
-0.09842194616794586,
-0.06266938149929047,
0.49754565954208374,
-0.43333494663238525,
-0.14253762364387512,
0.47835201025009155,
-0.5170140862464905,
-0.6487721800804138,
0.12199067324399948,
0.23867979645729065,
0.37662380933761597,
-0.4179837703704834,
0.009803741239011288,
-0.17564374208450317,
0.1639491319656372,
0.6310275197029114,
-0.12506692111492157,
-0.7019197940826416,
-0.1299910545349121,
0.0350499302148819,
-0.2621694803237915,
0.13999219238758087,
0.8131815791130066,
-0.599738597869873,
0.25715821981430054,
0.6450433135032654,
0.7740191221237183,
0.30085429549217224,
-0.1903526932001114,
0.3018665015697479,
-0.7128037214279175,
0.23434102535247803,
0.5942690968513489,
0.33891066908836365,
0.3713494539260864,
-0.3292087912559509,
0.48248252272605896,
0.33711040019989014,
-0.2609253525733948,
-1.0273064374923706,
-0.01786271296441555,
-1.161498785018921,
-0.6201597452163696,
1.2414312362670898,
0.07855317741632462,
-0.1926446408033371,
-0.3329533338546753,
-0.39568737149238586,
0.4859427809715271,
-0.18219177424907684,
1.4568921327590942,
0.607815146446228,
0.24720078706741333,
-0.03226181119680405,
-0.18787699937820435,
0.5885365009307861,
0.505186140537262,
-1.0431344509124756,
0.5449540019035339,
0.7032231092453003,
-0.27146896719932556,
0.06262920796871185,
0.3568529486656189,
0.04284505546092987,
0.39443734288215637,
0.03659443184733391,
0.3536373972892761,
-0.05442460626363754,
-0.5443445444107056,
-0.3554447591304779,
0.46666353940963745,
-0.194129079580307,
0.009575924836099148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01569v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01569v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models Using Contrast Sets: An Experimental Approach
| 2024-04-02T02:03:28 | 2024-04-02T02:03:28 |
Manish Sanwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the domain of Natural Language Inference (NLI), especially in tasks
involving the classification of multiple input texts, the Cross-Entropy Loss
metric is widely employed as a standard for error measurement. However, this
metric falls short in effectively evaluating a model's capacity to understand
language entailments. In this study, we introduce an innovative technique for
generating a contrast set for the Stanford Natural Language Inference (SNLI)
dataset. Our strategy involves the automated substitution of verbs, adverbs,
and adjectives with their synonyms to preserve the original meaning of
sentences. This method aims to assess whether a model's performance is based on
genuine language comprehension or simply on pattern recognition. We conducted
our analysis using the ELECTRA-small model. The model achieved an accuracy of
89.9% on the conventional SNLI dataset but showed a reduced accuracy of 72.5%
on our contrast set, indicating a substantial 17% decline. This outcome led us
to conduct a detailed examination of the model's learning behaviors. Following
this, we improved the model's resilience by fine-tuning it with a
contrast-enhanced training dataset specifically designed for SNLI, which
increased its accuracy to 85.5% on the contrast sets. Our findings highlight
the importance of incorporating diverse linguistic expressions into datasets
for NLI tasks. We hope that our research will encourage the creation of more
inclusive datasets, thereby contributing to the development of NLI models that
are both more sophisticated and effective.
|
[
-0.3442661464214325,
-0.622767448425293,
0.26731598377227783,
0.08019249141216278,
-0.18829700350761414,
-0.31616634130477905,
-0.3427383303642273,
-0.23162761330604553,
0.22868983447551727,
0.2831084430217743,
-0.25032752752304077,
-0.24591699242591858,
-0.38301071524620056,
0.3285140097141266,
-0.3682290315628052,
0.9294798970222473,
-0.12070516496896744,
0.22226950526237488,
-0.034347642213106155,
-0.4065806269645691,
-0.30554625391960144,
-0.052235085517168045,
-0.8548105955123901,
-0.49259138107299805,
0.5827387571334839,
0.10670480877161026,
0.6829846501350403,
0.6124128699302673,
0.4924713671207428,
0.28493887186050415,
-0.19380004703998566,
0.06441591680049896,
-0.515893816947937,
-0.10494433343410492,
-0.3554673194885254,
-0.560834527015686,
0.17513199150562286,
0.03102732263505459,
0.792700469493866,
0.970831573009491,
-0.1853431612253189,
-0.06471055001020432,
0.06311824917793274,
0.5706554055213928,
-0.8356857299804688,
0.01671012118458748,
-0.8037716746330261,
0.20425477623939514,
-0.04944013059139252,
0.05654457211494446,
-0.4905880391597748,
-0.07896046340465546,
0.167658269405365,
-0.5171564221382141,
0.2728673815727234,
0.1513652801513672,
0.9201385378837585,
0.305697500705719,
-0.21904058754444122,
-0.3456323742866516,
-0.5035474896430969,
1.028428077697754,
-1.0542094707489014,
0.36726969480514526,
0.12361214309930801,
0.13538292050361633,
-0.09389723092317581,
-0.48447123169898987,
-0.9058171510696411,
-0.41826382279396057,
-0.256625235080719,
0.45935097336769104,
-0.27489805221557617,
-0.060330796986818314,
0.0451081246137619,
0.43079042434692383,
-0.563084065914154,
0.6138152480125427,
-0.2912699580192566,
0.0831630676984787,
0.5661336183547974,
0.3628609776496887,
0.24080081284046173,
-0.21060287952423096,
0.023443380370736122,
-0.3026569187641144,
-0.48302751779556274,
-0.20906385779380798,
0.38194942474365234,
0.5489475131034851,
-0.07889978587627411,
0.3948046565055847,
-0.30830544233322144,
0.7431398630142212,
-0.25047582387924194,
0.10743069648742676,
0.3372572064399719,
-0.5200976133346558,
-0.5269626379013062,
-0.1319103240966797,
0.606753945350647,
0.5156142115592957,
0.10810132324695587,
-0.17927780747413635,
-0.2869119942188263,
0.31505900621414185,
0.08580847829580307,
-0.635976254940033,
-0.3078588843345642,
0.0872228741645813,
-0.643046498298645,
-0.42118221521377563,
0.07094752788543701,
-0.746855616569519,
-0.6821885108947754,
-0.3775552809238434,
0.5387293696403503,
-0.5097424387931824,
-0.052689433097839355,
0.201529860496521,
-0.3254743218421936,
0.3294587731361389,
0.3199644684791565,
-0.5454287528991699,
0.49187469482421875,
0.47772330045700073,
0.7148001790046692,
-0.26904964447021484,
-0.3950524926185608,
-0.36334648728370667,
-0.0857888013124466,
-0.3895266652107239,
0.4618046283721924,
-0.4924306273460388,
-0.28299251198768616,
0.05618138983845711,
-0.14408446848392487,
-0.29977744817733765,
-0.6917032599449158,
0.456467866897583,
-0.3485710918903351,
0.27289503812789917,
0.12379850447177887,
-0.7790875434875488,
-0.06485151499509811,
0.22401997447013855,
-0.9287353754043579,
0.8882408142089844,
-0.18258881568908691,
-0.9909889101982117,
0.04269162565469742,
-0.4417571425437927,
-0.3561646342277527,
-0.3496277928352356,
-0.14677806198596954,
-0.4165288805961609,
0.44862499833106995,
0.033862121403217316,
0.33662495017051697,
-0.42566728591918945,
0.07718531042337418,
-0.38293954730033875,
-0.4092540740966797,
0.3540280759334564,
-0.4103567600250244,
0.7501855492591858,
0.057453881949186325,
-0.30013543367385864,
-0.0554458424448967,
-0.8469095230102539,
-0.14936308562755585,
0.27234143018722534,
-0.20163767039775848,
-0.6722403168678284,
-0.06343761086463928,
0.008219229988753796,
0.1067231297492981,
-0.07162510603666306,
-0.5558652281761169,
-0.30811944603919983,
-0.5879696607589722,
0.16117747128009796,
0.7692387700080872,
-0.206145241856575,
0.3015247881412506,
-0.38158440589904785,
0.21480226516723633,
-0.001822684658691287,
-0.1236949935555458,
-0.07889003306627274,
-0.2843306064605713,
-1.0992146730422974,
-0.035317108035087585,
0.5235376954078674,
0.5288625955581665,
-0.9418954849243164,
0.49373331665992737,
-0.44427490234375,
-0.5806703567504883,
-0.7934305667877197,
0.046667419373989105,
0.5151010751724243,
0.5743239521980286,
0.18638183176517487,
-0.13002385199069977,
-0.6249217391014099,
-1.1744133234024048,
-0.2558801770210266,
0.06133858114480972,
-0.2802483141422272,
0.374068021774292,
0.6835557222366333,
-0.19769582152366638,
0.6845293045043945,
-0.39661651849746704,
0.04933805391192436,
-0.4525715410709381,
0.29660850763320923,
0.2857734262943268,
0.47952014207839966,
0.4260140359401703,
-0.7323249578475952,
-0.3745356798171997,
0.09909690171480179,
-0.5683909058570862,
-0.138334721326828,
-0.16629865765571594,
-0.19089382886886597,
0.005812420044094324,
0.4682425856590271,
-0.19951212406158447,
0.6007966995239258,
0.6821715831756592,
-0.22837404906749725,
0.475333034992218,
-0.1956787407398224,
0.1335972249507904,
-1.0323193073272705,
0.258356511592865,
0.2174844741821289,
0.2301877737045288,
-0.8301339149475098,
0.15829506516456604,
-0.22957785427570343,
0.010055247694253922,
-0.3034451901912689,
0.7168745398521423,
-0.05283261463046074,
0.004877811763435602,
-0.19184933602809906,
0.29650169610977173,
0.13386529684066772,
0.3605611026287079,
0.17224548757076263,
0.5678377747535706,
0.4240593910217285,
-0.6282353401184082,
0.2816254794597626,
0.014464383013546467,
-0.49316444993019104,
0.4502010941505432,
-0.7883042097091675,
0.09587512910366058,
-0.34542316198349,
0.14402976632118225,
-0.9822331666946411,
-0.1647711992263794,
0.03932976350188255,
-0.031986135989427567,
0.11500318348407745,
0.38404980301856995,
-0.3626268208026886,
-0.027263257652521133,
-0.5133494138717651,
0.18489579856395721,
0.40617862343788147,
-0.6567937135696411,
0.7371106743812561,
0.1477944701910019,
-0.07801434397697449,
-0.4759143888950348,
-0.9116660952568054,
0.07895500957965851,
-0.34553641080856323,
-0.3206268846988678,
0.4808019697666168,
-0.09130807965993881,
-0.6391897797584534,
-0.047615163028240204,
0.04137939587235451,
-0.13291260600090027,
0.05507931113243103,
-0.036848992109298706,
0.2365545779466629,
-0.2130831778049469,
0.35549601912498474,
-0.11827806383371353,
0.16569966077804565,
-0.3159210681915283,
0.12266459316015244,
0.46111321449279785,
-0.2626519203186035,
-0.15568077564239502,
-0.60930335521698,
0.36735185980796814,
0.21108782291412354,
-0.12048165500164032,
1.035379409790039,
0.4645315110683441,
-0.38658714294433594,
-0.2909831404685974,
-0.6093194484710693,
-0.1623183935880661,
-0.39307665824890137,
0.5072389841079712,
-0.3225852847099304,
-0.5050526857376099,
0.6885793209075928,
0.17701317369937897,
0.09986762702465057,
0.3961884379386902,
0.16494789719581604,
-0.11514689028263092,
0.7628488540649414,
0.43843212723731995,
-0.10558915138244629,
0.7073148488998413,
-0.23634469509124756,
0.17107293009757996,
-0.7147468328475952,
0.12356259673833847,
-0.6941554546356201,
-0.38558435440063477,
-0.5775097608566284,
-0.30610963702201843,
0.150043323636055,
-0.062447965145111084,
-0.1605583280324936,
0.12118587642908096,
-0.13045378029346466,
0.4990859627723694,
0.606052577495575,
0.37302976846694946,
0.16578295826911926,
-0.028708064928650856,
0.23953095078468323,
-0.13840684294700623,
-0.7081201672554016,
-0.5079732537269592,
0.88947993516922,
0.2708316743373871,
0.7705999612808228,
0.21176595985889435,
0.742270827293396,
0.20014944672584534,
0.4187697470188141,
-0.788650393486023,
0.5678681135177612,
-0.5673195719718933,
-0.13454532623291016,
-0.43019619584083557,
-0.63517826795578,
-0.9931958317756653,
0.4399028718471527,
-0.26904311776161194,
-0.42213958501815796,
0.2247554510831833,
0.16094902157783508,
-0.2567217946052551,
0.2260623723268509,
-0.8481588363647461,
0.9092962145805359,
0.05193014815449715,
-0.16112348437309265,
-0.37680456042289734,
-0.5259557962417603,
0.3195299208164215,
-0.13637125492095947,
0.11504627764225006,
0.1552620828151703,
0.021020418033003807,
0.8314889073371887,
-0.18198826909065247,
0.8630525469779968,
0.149196058511734,
-0.04269706457853317,
0.09605266153812408,
0.052979011088609695,
0.47777533531188965,
-0.2624334692955017,
-0.7239934802055359,
0.0662451758980751,
-0.3679710030555725,
-0.3964368999004364,
-0.9634747505187988,
0.6932520866394043,
-0.5232521295547485,
-0.3212032914161682,
0.01606188714504242,
-0.38218754529953003,
0.017173726111650467,
0.10522204637527466,
0.09063900262117386,
0.5221644639968872,
-0.3725009560585022,
0.17455369234085083,
0.5494304895401001,
-0.4014650881290436,
0.37552595138549805,
0.4094693660736084,
0.14920972287654877,
-0.23109062016010284,
1.0159690380096436,
-0.035989630967378616,
0.4420095384120941,
0.13848353922367096,
0.5341392755508423,
-0.12812981009483337,
-0.7216405272483826,
-0.18119953572750092,
0.35012492537498474,
-0.9103661775588989,
-0.05162922665476799,
-0.255858838558197,
-0.06225528568029404,
-0.3566443920135498,
-0.12524950504302979,
-0.1471046656370163,
-0.3299620747566223,
-0.14898720383644104,
-0.08041344583034515,
0.13710521161556244,
0.6098740100860596,
0.19360022246837616,
0.2853047847747803,
-0.41222554445266724,
0.14066842198371887,
0.3043462336063385,
0.2124462127685547,
-0.06376190483570099,
-0.7851969003677368,
-0.23106840252876282,
-0.07585348933935165,
0.1033853068947792,
-0.7410094738006592,
0.40466243028640747,
0.6129552125930786,
0.5748187303543091,
0.29077666997909546,
0.15112338960170746,
0.6504567861557007,
-0.6278942227363586,
0.6602204442024231,
0.1815410554409027,
-0.9882583618164062,
0.611653208732605,
-0.05167115852236748,
0.25075462460517883,
0.7193706035614014,
0.14124278724193573,
-0.5188520550727844,
-0.6042407751083374,
-0.7110923528671265,
-0.6884652972221375,
0.5534760355949402,
0.31677472591400146,
0.16150757670402527,
-0.040306076407432556,
0.29504066705703735,
0.047440703958272934,
0.2531292736530304,
-0.8340486288070679,
-0.20477433502674103,
-0.004567121155560017,
-0.6007555723190308,
-0.17216934263706207,
0.10470698028802872,
-0.08357264846563339,
-0.06778385490179062,
0.7861464619636536,
-0.10690770298242569,
0.08215300738811493,
0.0940505713224411,
-0.19061754643917084,
0.35281094908714294,
0.2955888509750366,
0.3316778242588043,
0.5075656175613403,
-0.06460770219564438,
0.37359338998794556,
0.5502262115478516,
-0.17287535965442657,
-0.2622605860233307,
0.23320236802101135,
-0.08233227580785751,
0.23108232021331787,
0.48445191979408264,
1.0037086009979248,
0.062488216906785965,
-0.9195653796195984,
0.3079809248447418,
-0.05416201800107956,
0.13453297317028046,
-0.0494220033288002,
-0.0018633961444720626,
-0.18988244235515594,
0.0006315968930721283,
-0.17661210894584656,
0.05296788737177849,
0.35047608613967896,
-0.6143975853919983,
0.10102536529302597,
0.275457501411438,
-0.22623252868652344,
-0.13729776442050934,
0.09339652955532074,
0.13365048170089722,
-0.28623610734939575,
0.7582279443740845,
-0.13008275628089905,
-0.1987493336200714,
0.7472141981124878,
0.483112633228302,
0.6741613149642944,
-0.3570772111415863,
0.12310967594385147,
0.27788111567497253,
0.3056352436542511,
-0.17214903235435486,
-0.06670081615447998,
0.3151419460773468,
-1.1421822309494019,
-0.20553329586982727,
-0.4800722002983093,
-0.393926739692688,
0.3067605197429657,
-0.7888767123222351,
0.13890454173088074,
-0.3669305145740509,
0.11192246526479721,
0.280264675617218,
-0.31963425874710083,
-0.7021957635879517,
0.4756085276603699,
0.0905521884560585,
0.8371095657348633,
-1.3329287767410278,
0.6429068446159363,
0.6495641469955444,
-0.4126041829586029,
-0.5163811445236206,
0.17244073748588562,
-0.20043382048606873,
-0.5749377012252808,
0.7481986880302429,
0.2590929865837097,
-0.29556146264076233,
-0.16961577534675598,
-0.4219473898410797,
-0.49436989426612854,
0.7400730848312378,
0.1971883922815323,
-0.30548176169395447,
0.15320828557014465,
-0.10990487039089203,
0.7913079261779785,
-0.4523095488548279,
0.39375942945480347,
0.8545225262641907,
0.27082356810569763,
-0.10740871727466583,
-0.8939974904060364,
0.04329186677932739,
-0.4560079574584961,
0.38072624802589417,
0.049613215029239655,
-0.378940612077713,
0.7749413251876831,
-0.002771097468212247,
-0.19394321739673615,
0.16882570087909698,
0.5765095353126526,
0.19043101370334625,
0.32964733242988586,
0.8487874865531921,
0.6081604957580566,
0.7013726234436035,
0.0086453752592206,
1.1200780868530273,
-0.03147752955555916,
0.3046000599861145,
1.2135703563690186,
-0.3004527688026428,
1.180668830871582,
0.6157540082931519,
-0.009976756758987904,
0.43954628705978394,
0.40714484453201294,
-0.05811912566423416,
0.55379718542099,
0.5296474695205688,
-0.40549367666244507,
-0.12985005974769592,
-0.3836705684661865,
0.10158775746822357,
0.39761000871658325,
0.4412381649017334,
-0.48448365926742554,
-0.12113968282938004,
0.1857132464647293,
-0.11662914603948593,
0.32670432329177856,
-0.24900832772254944,
0.6518328785896301,
-0.1010475754737854,
-0.5755694508552551,
0.47204071283340454,
-0.01382340956479311,
0.7425283193588257,
-0.4625517725944519,
-0.06598822772502899,
-0.37748533487319946,
0.21685025095939636,
-0.03769630938768387,
-0.5520763397216797,
0.3847004473209381,
-0.020129647105932236,
-0.029093528166413307,
0.11816264688968658,
0.3876532018184662,
-0.45834073424339294,
-0.66962730884552,
0.20811967551708221,
0.15666063129901886,
0.1765419989824295,
0.4076355993747711,
-0.7765059471130371,
0.15325355529785156,
0.03176558017730713,
-0.05613430589437485,
0.11854139715433121,
0.23016390204429626,
0.17775318026542664,
0.5432525277137756,
0.16612818837165833,
0.14896592497825623,
-0.09870493412017822,
0.4819609522819519,
0.7716729044914246,
-0.4955504834651947,
-0.527877926826477,
-0.7207016944885254,
0.5282064080238342,
-0.48637405037879944,
-0.40320390462875366,
0.8019514083862305,
0.43666911125183105,
0.8569353222846985,
-0.1824169158935547,
0.8355698585510254,
0.03138558939099312,
0.6301411390304565,
-0.7465248107910156,
0.3006208539009094,
-0.6291972994804382,
0.24385833740234375,
-0.3591260313987732,
-0.571959376335144,
-0.488567054271698,
0.7894561886787415,
-0.32958048582077026,
0.03549975901842117,
0.7124487161636353,
1.0428643226623535,
-0.11933465301990509,
-0.05114377662539482,
0.2836897075176239,
0.3002164959907532,
0.1653241068124771,
0.34693804383277893,
0.7798983454704285,
-0.6712424159049988,
0.48512405157089233,
-0.3167627453804016,
-0.19595426321029663,
-0.059734977781772614,
-0.7880799770355225,
-0.9445770978927612,
-0.25618496537208557,
-0.5680893063545227,
-0.48689571022987366,
0.2439221441745758,
0.7278879880905151,
0.34039607644081116,
-1.1061029434204102,
-0.30839985609054565,
-0.27088770270347595,
-0.0016041994094848633,
-0.2596922516822815,
-0.21408776938915253,
0.6235741376876831,
-0.368927925825119,
-0.9613458514213562,
0.557236909866333,
0.006681977305561304,
0.09349851310253143,
-0.1240943893790245,
-0.010894075967371464,
-0.13006384670734406,
0.2505502998828888,
0.34930419921875,
0.09867509454488754,
-0.8521689176559448,
-0.33494406938552856,
-0.21278758347034454,
0.01311502605676651,
-0.1685992181301117,
0.7180822491645813,
-0.4957968592643738,
0.5900646448135376,
0.5558522939682007,
0.9029279947280884,
0.10820251703262329,
-0.25039705634117126,
0.7411558032035828,
-0.7730514407157898,
0.2879253923892975,
0.16082653403282166,
0.6270873546600342,
0.45956969261169434,
0.035733792930841446,
0.6043847799301147,
0.12336216121912003,
-0.25862905383110046,
-0.9018212556838989,
0.3121635317802429,
-0.6707416772842407,
-0.37140312790870667,
1.027328610420227,
-0.22105297446250916,
-0.20802120864391327,
-0.1161646619439125,
-0.2637106776237488,
0.18673597276210785,
-0.16222825646400452,
0.8892463445663452,
0.6468144655227661,
-0.020990494638681412,
-0.1546519249677658,
-0.3821040987968445,
0.46728286147117615,
0.7753906846046448,
-0.8555291295051575,
0.0962609052658081,
0.38437598943710327,
0.09511116147041321,
0.3227538764476776,
0.08419648557901382,
0.24051964282989502,
0.058789849281311035,
0.14979396760463715,
0.07771706581115723,
0.30047333240509033,
0.04055967554450035,
-0.8487529754638672,
-0.19744084775447845,
-0.18828989565372467,
-0.28376680612564087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01549v1
|
Octopus: On-device language model for function calling of software APIs
| 2024-04-02T01:29:28 | 2024-04-02T01:29:28 |
Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li, Mingyuan Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
In the rapidly evolving domain of artificial intelligence, Large Language
Models (LLMs) play a crucial role due to their advanced text processing and
generation abilities. This study introduces a new strategy aimed at harnessing
on-device LLMs in invoking software APIs. We meticulously compile a dataset
derived from software API documentation and apply fine-tuning to LLMs with
capacities of 2B, 3B and 7B parameters, specifically to enhance their
proficiency in software API interactions. Our approach concentrates on refining
the models' grasp of API structures and syntax, significantly enhancing the
accuracy of API function calls. Additionally, we propose \textit{conditional
masking} techniques to ensure outputs in the desired formats and reduce error
rates while maintaining inference speeds. We also propose a novel benchmark
designed to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs in API interactions,
establishing a foundation for subsequent research. Octopus, the fine-tuned
model, is proved to have better performance than GPT-4 for the software APIs
calling. This research aims to advance automated software development and API
integration, representing substantial progress in aligning LLM capabilities
with the demands of practical software engineering applications.
|
[
-0.4537930488586426,
-0.5946596264839172,
0.5440212488174438,
0.26223355531692505,
-0.27775052189826965,
0.050963327288627625,
-0.13769274950027466,
-0.7496002316474915,
0.1047854796051979,
0.9484099745750427,
-0.41417601704597473,
-0.4671497941017151,
-0.23524007201194763,
0.3738991916179657,
-0.19775691628456116,
0.4350176453590393,
0.09227122366428375,
-0.04417754337191582,
-0.12007800489664078,
0.07615649700164795,
-0.42715346813201904,
-0.02736474946141243,
-0.518704891204834,
-0.15802550315856934,
0.37362197041511536,
0.4496866464614868,
0.6203939914703369,
0.9078671932220459,
0.44397255778312683,
0.3349965214729309,
-0.002558050211519003,
0.25892359018325806,
-0.06677460670471191,
0.00451269606128335,
-0.001904907519929111,
-0.8093698620796204,
-0.7903615832328796,
-0.056794241070747375,
0.4708672761917114,
0.5497217774391174,
0.0758199691772461,
0.2897300124168396,
-0.08756683021783829,
0.33057844638824463,
-0.32766807079315186,
0.42299431562423706,
-0.8590166568756104,
-0.006605902686715126,
-0.07705485075712204,
-0.2123463898897171,
-0.530763566493988,
-0.3067525625228882,
0.2199176698923111,
-0.7177597880363464,
-0.36954542994499207,
0.19423119723796844,
0.4311217665672302,
0.6883299350738525,
-0.177511066198349,
-0.27363863587379456,
-0.7289637923240662,
0.7820416688919067,
-1.0363949537277222,
0.5403257608413696,
0.45029160380363464,
-0.16638965904712677,
-0.20097853243350983,
-0.8853842616081238,
-0.631056547164917,
-0.5183660984039307,
0.2773923873901367,
-0.29783886671066284,
-0.03476688638329506,
0.28105998039245605,
0.31663060188293457,
0.08907324820756912,
-0.27773332595825195,
0.2258395552635193,
-0.49276623129844666,
-0.07954522967338562,
0.8239084482192993,
-0.056770872324705124,
0.4175778031349182,
0.13664168119430542,
-0.24572515487670898,
0.24709422886371613,
-1.021156668663025,
0.07177237421274185,
0.42101454734802246,
0.4351736009120941,
-0.15107910335063934,
0.8233546018600464,
-0.16986945271492004,
0.7258841395378113,
-0.06573604047298431,
-0.2609471380710602,
0.22835449874401093,
0.0448070727288723,
-0.0002650938113220036,
0.02978116273880005,
0.4602912366390228,
0.5175795555114746,
0.24490629136562347,
-0.18533024191856384,
-0.350823312997818,
-0.025494564324617386,
0.5559817552566528,
-0.6798814535140991,
-0.10928261280059814,
0.5260738730430603,
-0.39873820543289185,
-0.11852625757455826,
-0.15808767080307007,
-0.39571842551231384,
-0.557954728603363,
-0.553639829158783,
0.30987289547920227,
-0.42490866780281067,
-0.36560189723968506,
0.06333079934120178,
0.04310476779937744,
0.2344903200864792,
0.07065435498952866,
-0.8036118149757385,
0.4414267838001251,
0.9306912422180176,
0.7297773957252502,
-0.26589128375053406,
-0.2658943235874176,
-0.527625322341919,
0.364991694688797,
-0.3297334909439087,
0.8501859903335571,
-0.7239698767662048,
-0.3287702202796936,
-0.007938898168504238,
-0.2657700777053833,
0.1555514633655548,
-0.5827476978302002,
0.45932266116142273,
-0.4178915023803711,
-0.261669397354126,
0.26449254155158997,
-0.8043683767318726,
-0.2906246483325958,
0.07676379382610321,
-0.6647455096244812,
0.9370814561843872,
0.1234922856092453,
-0.3665190637111664,
0.3070347011089325,
-1.0156108140945435,
-0.3952626883983612,
0.46624329686164856,
-0.0350998230278492,
-0.4049350321292877,
0.054915670305490494,
0.04738900065422058,
0.3689320981502533,
-0.18611060082912445,
-0.09185820072889328,
-0.7123892307281494,
-0.4611488878726959,
0.23065170645713806,
0.00356860738247633,
0.4850876033306122,
0.3071773648262024,
-0.2048678994178772,
0.12086457014083862,
-0.8165608048439026,
0.2489219307899475,
-0.3443913757801056,
-0.40473484992980957,
-0.46285390853881836,
0.3663206696510315,
-0.22678175568580627,
-0.19654028117656708,
0.27939319610595703,
-0.7188094258308411,
0.3868325352668762,
-0.664198637008667,
0.9321304559707642,
0.35028964281082153,
-0.16478948295116425,
0.6292895078659058,
-0.11839141696691513,
0.2126915603876114,
-0.3395020067691803,
0.31247764825820923,
-0.41439709067344666,
-0.6440531015396118,
-0.35484591126441956,
-0.6565842032432556,
0.4503069221973419,
0.659281849861145,
-0.6129959225654602,
0.4946507215499878,
-0.08325038850307465,
-0.6624318361282349,
-0.7014542818069458,
0.3745236098766327,
0.2213428020477295,
0.42980363965034485,
0.27369824051856995,
-0.29804080724716187,
-0.5045490860939026,
-0.5689663290977478,
-0.19377706944942474,
-0.4182981848716736,
-0.36582574248313904,
0.6504843235015869,
0.047972582280635834,
-0.4780578017234802,
1.1824389696121216,
-0.240338534116745,
-0.02859879843890667,
-0.3315218687057495,
-0.011284751817584038,
0.3630947470664978,
0.34802913665771484,
0.4596818685531616,
-0.8508945107460022,
-0.28915664553642273,
-0.014210088178515434,
-0.38085517287254333,
-0.623875081539154,
0.18259499967098236,
0.1795317679643631,
0.3483181893825531,
0.5543179512023926,
-0.7371087670326233,
0.18650169670581818,
0.44669657945632935,
-0.18197040259838104,
0.4304099678993225,
-0.2525826394557953,
-0.24260461330413818,
-0.7618468999862671,
-0.11365561187267303,
0.05590610206127167,
-0.038542240858078,
-0.5058953762054443,
0.15092316269874573,
0.22180815041065216,
-0.23145753145217896,
-0.9080234169960022,
0.8104223608970642,
-0.37801411747932434,
-0.31464797258377075,
-0.41403859853744507,
-0.07044694572687149,
-0.20164938271045685,
0.1717745065689087,
0.05221937596797943,
0.6932789087295532,
0.6461495161056519,
-0.7866261601448059,
0.5604918003082275,
0.07798793911933899,
0.05011242255568504,
0.5481158494949341,
-0.8666840195655823,
-0.011280643753707409,
0.39768847823143005,
0.13054794073104858,
-1.067725419998169,
-0.08178316801786423,
0.10982304811477661,
-0.21516156196594238,
-0.0724920853972435,
-0.4015124440193176,
-0.7290952205657959,
-0.5597613453865051,
-0.5137998461723328,
0.2972908318042755,
0.4395098090171814,
-0.4010128676891327,
0.9805522561073303,
0.6157843470573425,
-0.566305935382843,
-0.017475619912147522,
-0.38574376702308655,
-0.12781450152397156,
-0.5374172925949097,
-0.8214545845985413,
0.4817838668823242,
-0.0015212349826470017,
-0.17208954691886902,
-0.29975032806396484,
0.0016830586828291416,
0.08124018460512161,
0.12932248413562775,
0.32802876830101013,
0.4673983156681061,
-0.4199391007423401,
0.054226066917181015,
0.2228197455406189,
-0.20497378706932068,
0.014032743871212006,
-0.5793977975845337,
0.65805983543396,
0.018942518159747124,
-0.4454994201660156,
-0.5954627394676208,
-0.05258088558912277,
0.5738722681999207,
-0.41865304112434387,
0.24379631876945496,
0.25637146830558777,
-0.33900490403175354,
-0.18123820424079895,
-0.6425202488899231,
-0.3903495669364929,
-0.5884961485862732,
0.16821834444999695,
-0.4764174222946167,
-0.6339038610458374,
0.611579954624176,
-0.45290622115135193,
0.20547041296958923,
0.11259758472442627,
0.47284892201423645,
-0.13379068672657013,
1.0115028619766235,
0.6983405351638794,
-0.15817248821258545,
0.4923137426376343,
-0.16542048752307892,
0.21879662573337555,
-0.8718718886375427,
0.022535767406225204,
-0.42432543635368347,
-0.15152594447135925,
-0.7146134972572327,
-0.17693570256233215,
0.3345969319343567,
0.05349285155534744,
-0.43523988127708435,
0.37459269165992737,
-0.5280607342720032,
0.5710059404373169,
0.5165295600891113,
-0.06985757499933243,
0.35817307233810425,
0.07537821680307388,
-0.14940805733203888,
0.07791464775800705,
-0.44528841972351074,
-0.7065436840057373,
1.3615821599960327,
0.7584447264671326,
0.9748696088790894,
0.009253929369151592,
0.42350107431411743,
0.4847041070461273,
0.23986442387104034,
-0.5371933579444885,
0.6365825533866882,
-0.04336066171526909,
-0.1598227322101593,
-0.4263814389705658,
-0.07957779616117477,
-0.7398941516876221,
0.1250821352005005,
0.0024777869693934917,
-1.0457446575164795,
-0.10753898322582245,
0.17618834972381592,
-0.5954586863517761,
0.09085433185100555,
-1.015546441078186,
0.5330143570899963,
-0.3971635699272156,
-0.3494035601615906,
-0.10762173682451248,
-0.4810750186443329,
0.051829803735017776,
0.13058200478553772,
0.10211104154586792,
-0.2815878093242645,
-0.3952086567878723,
0.3558170199394226,
-0.4381253123283386,
1.0521072149276733,
-0.1293424665927887,
-0.5215476155281067,
0.3691587448120117,
0.017407231032848358,
0.48729050159454346,
0.28494489192962646,
-0.3692757487297058,
0.2940613925457001,
0.01747668907046318,
-0.07298649102449417,
-0.18722280859947205,
0.6684933304786682,
-0.8253932595252991,
-0.2991790473461151,
0.009173818863928318,
-0.6459119915962219,
-0.16614574193954468,
0.42245033383369446,
-0.03521152585744858,
0.3058028519153595,
0.2088834047317505,
-0.13939431309700012,
0.6155857443809509,
-0.21717435121536255,
0.5448379516601562,
0.7925055027008057,
-0.5260775685310364,
-0.2727910578250885,
1.1061912775039673,
0.059563059359788895,
0.1530848741531372,
0.017008068040013313,
-0.10790327191352844,
-0.7967908978462219,
-0.5531777143478394,
-0.6661552786827087,
0.3552710711956024,
-0.2223535180091858,
-0.2771269679069519,
-0.5496333837509155,
-0.0703015998005867,
-0.40534844994544983,
-0.12696094810962677,
-0.4971008598804474,
-0.42172327637672424,
-0.15936240553855896,
0.09857203811407089,
0.5446584224700928,
0.5910542607307434,
0.16460749506950378,
0.39769816398620605,
-0.8132855296134949,
0.40711167454719543,
-0.02171642892062664,
0.7573347091674805,
-0.24797822535037994,
-0.19413723051548004,
0.07727793604135513,
0.06101216748356819,
-0.5586763620376587,
-0.7796973586082458,
0.2809112071990967,
0.3010662794113159,
0.6191367506980896,
0.46880432963371277,
0.12337812036275864,
0.34001293778419495,
-0.5469772219657898,
0.595645546913147,
-0.2700895667076111,
-1.0456950664520264,
0.6428765654563904,
-0.43666312098503113,
0.009306114166975021,
0.04662380367517471,
0.11146359145641327,
-0.2805885076522827,
-0.6694062948226929,
-0.5892753005027771,
-1.108502984046936,
0.6957269310951233,
-0.025146661326289177,
0.21517413854599,
0.2704750597476959,
0.608635663986206,
0.04954223334789276,
0.26412728428840637,
-0.596485435962677,
0.034111589193344116,
0.13272146880626678,
-0.259178102016449,
0.32823407649993896,
0.050607480108737946,
-0.02884722128510475,
-0.32902541756629944,
0.35399115085601807,
-0.33331048488616943,
0.21097448468208313,
-0.07955663651227951,
-0.11634574830532074,
-0.001093409489840269,
0.06686355918645859,
0.5136939883232117,
0.7140347957611084,
0.11810930073261261,
0.09307733178138733,
0.3917998969554901,
-0.5574936270713806,
-0.14309008419513702,
0.4025392532348633,
-0.26930445432662964,
-0.26732492446899414,
0.1868916153907776,
0.5718539357185364,
0.24121488630771637,
-0.8636496663093567,
0.013957023620605469,
0.10061506181955338,
0.26726627349853516,
-0.43425363302230835,
0.5146439075469971,
0.1600475162267685,
0.5117235779762268,
0.5264438986778259,
-0.3273308277130127,
0.27044984698295593,
-0.3111232817173004,
0.2916574478149414,
0.4397642910480499,
-0.15138716995716095,
-0.26736289262771606,
0.6119452118873596,
0.5966845154762268,
-0.7177156805992126,
0.4801298975944519,
-0.203460231423378,
-0.3773878514766693,
0.7078502178192139,
0.7503119707107544,
0.49300941824913025,
-0.38876602053642273,
0.10308104008436203,
-0.082921601831913,
0.2687811851501465,
0.04518233612179756,
0.6373361945152283,
-0.025299591943621635,
-0.5742969512939453,
-0.49526259303092957,
-0.6095195412635803,
-0.7089909315109253,
0.06008433178067207,
-0.14300797879695892,
0.6227602958679199,
-0.3759517967700958,
-0.13351385295391083,
-0.019757384434342384,
0.07642839103937149,
-0.24688799679279327,
-0.056263625621795654,
0.43593457341194153,
1.1138808727264404,
-0.4979536235332489,
0.7634252309799194,
0.9290336966514587,
-0.27485403418540955,
-0.8903568983078003,
-0.13681960105895996,
-0.03631046414375305,
-0.6019913554191589,
0.3322346806526184,
0.2342062145471573,
-0.09106775373220444,
0.27303919196128845,
-0.6092345118522644,
-0.7249780893325806,
0.9587222933769226,
0.44700056314468384,
-0.4260999262332916,
0.2937164306640625,
0.7841744422912598,
0.620050311088562,
-0.8939555287361145,
0.5162824392318726,
0.6843080520629883,
0.5681672096252441,
-0.11583476513624191,
-1.2278636693954468,
-0.14528129994869232,
-0.3287007212638855,
0.2957218289375305,
0.05679897964000702,
-0.460764080286026,
0.7662182450294495,
-0.3209010660648346,
0.18541111052036285,
0.2330530434846878,
0.5836827158927917,
0.5150020122528076,
0.4226636588573456,
0.5077949166297913,
0.3603593111038208,
0.7529550194740295,
0.0008414416224695742,
0.9791479110717773,
-0.6440185904502869,
0.08626310527324677,
0.700233519077301,
-0.7538843750953674,
1.2354826927185059,
0.5619248151779175,
-0.08799828588962555,
0.14050062000751495,
0.737237811088562,
-0.14866581559181213,
0.40617793798446655,
0.37688785791397095,
-0.1640714406967163,
0.09908054769039154,
0.09667428582906723,
-0.31263402104377747,
0.34457796812057495,
0.608918309211731,
-0.07630299031734467,
0.13790108263492584,
0.1362156867980957,
-0.13030827045440674,
-0.1792825311422348,
-0.5594284534454346,
0.8662967681884766,
0.05059182271361351,
-0.678311824798584,
0.42797380685806274,
0.12082347273826599,
0.7143082022666931,
-0.2512667179107666,
-0.11148817092180252,
-0.19260452687740326,
0.47131460905075073,
-0.24483852088451385,
-0.8390955328941345,
0.32242634892463684,
0.08523748070001602,
-0.019010134041309357,
0.17166058719158173,
0.8261778950691223,
-0.3429411053657532,
-0.4176345467567444,
0.3940037488937378,
0.12709246575832367,
0.26036471128463745,
-0.16662128269672394,
-0.555292010307312,
0.5165300369262695,
-0.21907751262187958,
-0.01090813335031271,
-0.08598684519529343,
0.48312100768089294,
-0.07839085161685944,
1.0963072776794434,
0.7159391045570374,
0.2682022452354431,
0.31523117423057556,
-0.14528119564056396,
0.8027238845825195,
-0.33878058195114136,
-0.7044907212257385,
-0.7849105596542358,
0.638069212436676,
-0.0945894867181778,
-0.34502512216567993,
0.45227593183517456,
0.7577480673789978,
0.7602852582931519,
-0.13449417054653168,
0.8227249979972839,
0.0013921769568696618,
0.6471428275108337,
-0.430928111076355,
0.8308907747268677,
-0.3915787637233734,
0.869719922542572,
-0.22980374097824097,
-1.126838207244873,
-0.3336770236492157,
0.5404917597770691,
-0.47203442454338074,
-0.178141787648201,
0.1501930058002472,
0.9045276641845703,
-0.3836081027984619,
0.2864840626716614,
-0.019707486033439636,
0.2975359559059143,
0.31923553347587585,
0.12257912009954453,
0.6862767338752747,
-0.21264567971229553,
0.40004152059555054,
0.0722891241312027,
-0.36881256103515625,
-0.42895808815956116,
-0.8219789862632751,
-0.640876054763794,
-0.5186120867729187,
-0.24831904470920563,
-0.08982004970312119,
0.09466595947742462,
0.8887728452682495,
0.6842949986457825,
-0.537182629108429,
-0.43622079491615295,
-0.019267307594418526,
0.20141969621181488,
-0.10973254591226578,
-0.16459712386131287,
-0.0653119832277298,
-0.5310243964195251,
-0.7312485575675964,
0.24239520728588104,
0.4366286098957062,
-0.16389063000679016,
-0.387860506772995,
-0.40915408730506897,
0.2696250379085541,
0.27431488037109375,
0.6941304206848145,
0.5264272689819336,
-0.8383615612983704,
-0.25803905725479126,
0.10431010276079178,
0.001853287685662508,
0.0030353618785738945,
0.6886323094367981,
-0.6820001602172852,
0.1094188541173935,
0.23420119285583496,
0.6115187406539917,
0.14761695265769958,
-0.14446012675762177,
0.6876446604728699,
-0.6053754091262817,
0.1746288686990738,
0.13904310762882233,
0.3172721266746521,
0.18852144479751587,
-0.3278551399707794,
0.5610271692276001,
-0.14885851740837097,
-0.5201473832130432,
-1.0768654346466064,
0.22573764622211456,
-0.954402506351471,
-0.004369359463453293,
1.2093374729156494,
-0.21090683341026306,
-0.1451094001531601,
-0.378790944814682,
-0.4800698459148407,
0.04012737050652504,
-0.4798530042171478,
0.8826181888580322,
0.41805338859558105,
-0.526741623878479,
-0.2940669357776642,
-0.3802531063556671,
0.36011677980422974,
0.11502949893474579,
-0.9740148186683655,
0.06696443259716034,
0.26615774631500244,
0.3664449453353882,
0.33607783913612366,
0.474364697933197,
-0.1082008108496666,
0.295169472694397,
-0.2514476478099823,
0.1267862766981125,
0.04535014182329178,
-0.34111589193344116,
0.03283049538731575,
0.02706228569149971,
0.3479222059249878,
-0.14313547313213348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01536v1
|
Laying Anchors: Semantically Priming Numerals in Language Modeling
| 2024-04-02T00:02:00 | 2024-04-02T00:02:00 |
Mandar Sharma, Rutuja Murlidhar Taware, Pravesh Koirala, Nikhil Muralidhar, Naren Ramakrishnan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Off-the-shelf pre-trained language models have become the de facto standard
in NLP pipelines for a multitude of downstream tasks. However, the inability of
these models to properly encode numerals limits their performance on tasks
requiring numeric comprehension. We introduce strategies to semantically prime
numerals in any corpus by generating anchors governed by the distribution of
numerals in said corpus, thereby enabling mathematically grounded
representations of these numeral tokens. We establish the superiority of our
proposed techniques through evaluation on a range of numeracy tasks for both
in-domain (seen) and out-domain (unseen) numerals. Further, we expand our
empirical evaluations to numerals ranging from 1 to 10 billion, a significantly
broader range compared to previous studies of the same nature, and we
demonstrate significant improvements in the mathematical grounding of our
learned embeddings.
|
[
-0.27104252576828003,
-0.28272148966789246,
0.5474812388420105,
0.5722874999046326,
-0.4102140963077545,
0.022625941783189774,
-0.18809689581394196,
0.14980579912662506,
-0.02686353400349617,
0.7236775159835815,
-0.20345832407474518,
-0.6838683485984802,
-0.4922274351119995,
0.22680175304412842,
-0.2251811921596527,
0.8649375438690186,
0.34533625841140747,
-0.013400041498243809,
-0.49153977632522583,
0.03715553507208824,
-0.5046305656433105,
-0.6463662385940552,
0.044153425842523575,
-0.1943715363740921,
0.17465205490589142,
0.5310966968536377,
1.088383674621582,
0.9825016856193542,
0.45220786333084106,
0.2907106578350067,
-0.056458730250597,
0.055968206375837326,
-0.5440922379493713,
0.10008913278579712,
-0.09954661875963211,
-0.42779529094696045,
-0.44322893023490906,
-0.048525821417570114,
0.8868598937988281,
1.4390535354614258,
0.18125951290130615,
0.17083007097244263,
-0.0660325437784195,
0.8448911905288696,
-0.9665913581848145,
0.4732290804386139,
-0.6859357953071594,
-0.11760861426591873,
-0.19577854871749878,
-0.3799276649951935,
-0.8205444812774658,
-0.3464908301830292,
0.34470897912979126,
-0.6386526226997375,
-0.12017238140106201,
-0.022081708535552025,
0.6006237864494324,
0.3819954991340637,
-0.41711175441741943,
-0.29175713658332825,
-0.36147332191467285,
0.8840093612670898,
-0.8203900456428528,
0.3696519136428833,
0.7340909242630005,
-0.23996950685977936,
0.04455074667930603,
-0.6526800990104675,
0.07029092311859131,
-0.3302842676639557,
0.019515385851264,
-0.08551505208015442,
0.17226259410381317,
0.08128093183040619,
0.5219592452049255,
0.4048137664794922,
-0.5327143669128418,
-0.03769034892320633,
-0.2981991767883301,
0.13868771493434906,
0.49133336544036865,
-0.2081335037946701,
0.44752031564712524,
-0.10960703343153,
-0.17153549194335938,
-0.1648665815591812,
-1.1741019487380981,
-0.19987741112709045,
0.3849475383758545,
0.3151571452617645,
-0.10510432720184326,
0.6489324569702148,
-0.26099199056625366,
0.7039387822151184,
0.054748959839344025,
0.06414362788200378,
0.18042340874671936,
0.0031477066222578287,
-0.28949254751205444,
0.2692336142063141,
0.18764236569404602,
0.32045936584472656,
0.7404930591583252,
-0.5030696392059326,
-0.058702994138002396,
0.39632412791252136,
0.29641592502593994,
-0.7448923587799072,
-0.17824143171310425,
-0.03826740011572838,
-0.0962660163640976,
-0.45575982332229614,
0.06435362994670868,
-0.19407175481319427,
-0.1942271739244461,
-0.27788853645324707,
0.26173874735832214,
-0.4118807315826416,
-0.17624904215335846,
0.5401941537857056,
-0.12502381205558777,
0.2531338036060333,
-0.08431381732225418,
-1.1289522647857666,
0.451915979385376,
0.9906210899353027,
0.4303605258464813,
0.31526127457618713,
0.1605009138584137,
-0.2656362056732178,
0.009602710604667664,
-0.7207260727882385,
0.3915010690689087,
-0.7208763957023621,
-0.339279443025589,
0.2413928210735321,
-0.16915370523929596,
-0.1489621251821518,
-0.3993235230445862,
0.48794659972190857,
-0.9432837963104248,
-0.09662344306707382,
-0.00686125922948122,
-0.6719818711280823,
-0.2506985068321228,
0.05293580889701843,
-0.7401870489120483,
0.7823566794395447,
-0.11797452718019485,
-0.4302352964878082,
0.18042507767677307,
-0.4968939423561096,
-0.24729245901107788,
0.18294748663902283,
0.05154372379183769,
-0.2768036425113678,
0.5396214127540588,
0.19204840064048767,
0.38328078389167786,
-0.2697710394859314,
0.4005581736564636,
-0.2836804986000061,
-0.3533235192298889,
0.2413419932126999,
-0.4685900807380676,
0.8951484560966492,
-0.0005921298870816827,
-0.43002524971961975,
-0.2761486768722534,
-0.796217679977417,
0.5300173759460449,
-0.08718764036893845,
0.2140485793352127,
-0.64154452085495,
-0.15943901240825653,
-0.2668358087539673,
0.10564406216144562,
0.008434999734163284,
-0.1560317575931549,
0.08706299215555191,
-0.9651817083358765,
0.4513402283191681,
0.413400262594223,
-0.08394118398427963,
1.0854706764221191,
-0.17226020991802216,
0.4510043263435364,
-0.30713051557540894,
-0.3486756384372711,
-0.5953935384750366,
-0.6520649790763855,
-0.9020622968673706,
-0.05632459744811058,
0.6878208518028259,
0.4329802989959717,
-0.5382705926895142,
0.3773615062236786,
-0.640958845615387,
-0.33363664150238037,
-0.3806496560573578,
0.02032129094004631,
0.6786108016967773,
0.21566370129585266,
0.10462404787540436,
-0.35592904686927795,
-0.40369296073913574,
-0.589937686920166,
-0.14361508190631866,
-0.097339928150177,
0.029266739264130592,
0.04560475051403046,
0.47875699400901794,
0.261661171913147,
1.1162348985671997,
-0.39559653401374817,
0.002804222982376814,
0.1824694722890854,
0.4332801401615143,
0.17584513127803802,
0.6625762581825256,
0.33906012773513794,
-1.0307903289794922,
-0.35530269145965576,
-0.28152626752853394,
-0.8416752219200134,
-0.21314850449562073,
0.032324884086847305,
0.08200730383396149,
0.10431824624538422,
0.63881915807724,
-0.43876004219055176,
0.656654953956604,
0.5467296242713928,
-0.3075350821018219,
0.17505204677581787,
-0.224552720785141,
-0.3192972242832184,
-0.6033179759979248,
0.07573046535253525,
-0.33302444219589233,
-0.12171749025583267,
-0.7716407775878906,
0.09634841233491898,
0.31696659326553345,
-0.4277057647705078,
-0.5930583477020264,
0.42083942890167236,
-0.894450843334198,
-0.12055054306983948,
-0.1330450028181076,
-0.02826429158449173,
0.29974740743637085,
0.48972126841545105,
0.35701480507850647,
0.5369859933853149,
0.46306803822517395,
-0.4864194095134735,
-0.20752327144145966,
0.19253134727478027,
-0.4083985686302185,
0.15807382762432098,
-0.8084926009178162,
0.18106932938098907,
-0.33484023809432983,
0.18696977198123932,
-0.9755825996398926,
0.1710813343524933,
-0.017943672835826874,
-0.4348612129688263,
0.34657022356987,
-0.7125836610794067,
-0.37031787633895874,
0.12159259617328644,
-0.11907444894313812,
0.8796526789665222,
0.6250950694084167,
-0.12305042892694473,
0.27846717834472656,
0.4907243549823761,
-0.3537105619907379,
-0.5870940685272217,
-0.3906480371952057,
0.16233667731285095,
-0.2970280051231384,
-0.7139796018600464,
0.7070366740226746,
0.3060630261898041,
-0.5552380084991455,
0.037430472671985626,
-0.04050133749842644,
-0.15498033165931702,
0.305472731590271,
0.5462909936904907,
0.1869453638792038,
-0.5094995498657227,
0.42581796646118164,
-0.2968440651893616,
-0.7438265681266785,
0.2522367835044861,
-0.5904834270477295,
0.4934074580669403,
-0.46716615557670593,
-0.5284660458564758,
0.05966488644480705,
0.3987767696380615,
0.6233859658241272,
-0.5393868088722229,
0.6867902874946594,
0.03945890814065933,
-0.6338689923286438,
-0.22373439371585846,
-0.4248127043247223,
-0.24697569012641907,
-0.43211260437965393,
0.07643567025661469,
-0.4158311188220978,
-0.6510940790176392,
0.23931917548179626,
-0.22937926650047302,
-0.023063823580741882,
0.3788001537322998,
0.5027322173118591,
0.1853928118944168,
1.1162947416305542,
0.7640900015830994,
0.2982997000217438,
0.04721914976835251,
-0.6235775351524353,
0.4325580894947052,
-0.5835013389587402,
0.15229979157447815,
-0.49831223487854004,
0.09836924076080322,
-0.5542290210723877,
-0.7308449149131775,
0.20611795783042908,
0.38690364360809326,
-0.18525731563568115,
0.39655110239982605,
-0.3571915924549103,
0.717003345489502,
0.42784208059310913,
-0.18942789733409882,
0.27131929993629456,
-0.10106460750102997,
-0.2722257077693939,
-0.36447879672050476,
-0.7831841111183167,
-0.8940521478652954,
1.1652990579605103,
0.4248904883861542,
0.6010668873786926,
0.000028174750696052797,
0.5358062386512756,
0.000913623021915555,
0.5515749454498291,
-0.6718156933784485,
0.3426002264022827,
-0.11513935774564743,
-0.7182643413543701,
-0.582234799861908,
-0.0893978551030159,
-0.7447773814201355,
0.2713163197040558,
-0.18734125792980194,
-0.41663625836372375,
0.21748414635658264,
-0.14260876178741455,
-0.46027934551239014,
0.07886090874671936,
-0.6263151168823242,
1.066796898841858,
-0.18288575112819672,
-0.2527461647987366,
-0.07276095449924469,
-0.7120493650436401,
0.2597307562828064,
-0.11763124167919159,
0.29347503185272217,
-0.46396785974502563,
-0.1721167415380478,
0.6303412914276123,
-0.680424153804779,
1.1086370944976807,
0.01157145481556654,
-0.17241165041923523,
0.2638789713382721,
-0.03798975422978401,
0.33832716941833496,
0.2553696036338806,
-0.12311582267284393,
0.1169392317533493,
-0.1852187067270279,
-0.4359566569328308,
-0.7251319289207458,
0.5705453753471375,
-0.541841447353363,
-0.4199277460575104,
-0.5224689841270447,
-0.5364626049995422,
-0.3050408959388733,
0.1557241678237915,
0.19499796628952026,
0.9448844194412231,
-0.13310246169567108,
0.525467038154602,
0.8138816952705383,
0.053386736661195755,
0.6261131167411804,
0.2861629128456116,
0.15158429741859436,
-0.42476168274879456,
0.7506170272827148,
0.3320115804672241,
0.24005438387393951,
0.6640226244926453,
0.04913610219955444,
-0.556976854801178,
-0.3730659782886505,
-0.43831419944763184,
0.20366692543029785,
-0.6786729693412781,
-0.18457357585430145,
-0.5558565258979797,
-0.14007668197155,
-0.6101034283638,
-0.4622299075126648,
-0.2754703164100647,
-0.8053308725357056,
-0.19042818248271942,
-0.19148719310760498,
0.3982810080051422,
0.39606016874313354,
-0.21408934891223907,
0.37690290808677673,
-0.7974871397018433,
0.22151465713977814,
0.3357863426208496,
0.25249427556991577,
-0.007549698930233717,
-0.5698963403701782,
-0.13049279153347015,
0.16448889672756195,
0.05495619401335716,
-0.8556450605392456,
0.5220277309417725,
0.2825518548488617,
0.24049974977970123,
0.7052741050720215,
0.42004314064979553,
0.8398061394691467,
-0.8084416389465332,
0.267389178276062,
-0.06825454533100128,
-1.1192058324813843,
0.11324996501207352,
-0.39917635917663574,
0.2762742340564728,
0.6395525336265564,
0.6581197381019592,
-0.32549405097961426,
-0.04732443019747734,
-0.9646731615066528,
-1.041682481765747,
0.2799231708049774,
0.36168429255485535,
0.419353723526001,
-0.362796813249588,
0.05405165255069733,
-0.1634684056043625,
0.3229632079601288,
-0.5220640301704407,
-0.24627584218978882,
-0.08511528372764587,
-0.045701634138822556,
-0.06368400901556015,
-0.5256444215774536,
0.004595301114022732,
0.07928621023893356,
0.5512288212776184,
-0.28730106353759766,
0.012489654123783112,
-0.18660636246204376,
-0.6076133251190186,
0.2726507782936096,
0.2830383777618408,
0.6243857145309448,
1.018345832824707,
-0.21950703859329224,
0.3216596841812134,
0.14927902817726135,
-0.307736337184906,
0.07797885686159134,
-0.04413944482803345,
-0.3007223606109619,
0.2467564344406128,
0.40610989928245544,
0.5461239218711853,
1.128188133239746,
-0.5991711616516113,
0.5367198586463928,
0.4529518485069275,
-0.027075927704572678,
-0.5448541641235352,
-0.5530721545219421,
0.10491596162319183,
-0.41897761821746826,
0.3942672610282898,
-0.1417023092508316,
-0.05083923414349556,
-0.531567394733429,
0.5105633735656738,
0.3539707064628601,
-0.5727953910827637,
-0.3243269920349121,
0.41454586386680603,
0.23149991035461426,
-0.25256043672561646,
0.7822730541229248,
-0.14524368941783905,
-0.6238941550254822,
0.6238561272621155,
0.7239633798599243,
0.8936643004417419,
0.09938733279705048,
0.29398787021636963,
0.16183657944202423,
0.22559280693531036,
-0.09525976330041885,
0.08465855568647385,
-0.20768025517463684,
-0.8676062822341919,
-0.6994985342025757,
-0.42424580454826355,
-0.47396308183670044,
-0.30382460355758667,
-0.8254910111427307,
0.1843990832567215,
-0.44911155104637146,
-0.40520644187927246,
0.05091068148612976,
-0.16328570246696472,
-0.6121000051498413,
0.28617385029792786,
0.5201467275619507,
0.9429700374603271,
-0.9748862385749817,
0.495501309633255,
0.7543604969978333,
-0.46012187004089355,
-0.5275610685348511,
-0.5512896180152893,
-0.23692472279071808,
-1.0903596878051758,
0.9283339977264404,
0.36649271845817566,
0.05940708890557289,
0.47550517320632935,
-0.44245508313179016,
-1.1326115131378174,
0.5196717977523804,
0.14815883338451385,
-0.04186169058084488,
-0.4121922552585602,
0.6010341048240662,
0.2805037200450897,
-0.5354744791984558,
0.431296706199646,
0.35153335332870483,
0.4878617823123932,
-0.07673393189907074,
-0.7163142561912537,
-0.06559281051158905,
-0.3981483280658722,
0.15002591907978058,
0.13581305742263794,
-0.04360777884721756,
0.7293642163276672,
-0.2803381383419037,
-0.49146246910095215,
0.21752603352069855,
0.6314698457717896,
0.3474041223526001,
0.10984985530376434,
0.49161630868911743,
0.9315434098243713,
0.5100858807563782,
-0.28776153922080994,
0.7639223337173462,
-0.6672240495681763,
0.06725172698497772,
0.8628423810005188,
-0.16951879858970642,
0.7568570375442505,
0.45255014300346375,
0.10842353105545044,
0.5616622567176819,
0.21057716012001038,
0.2628032863140106,
0.5589993000030518,
0.5637956857681274,
-0.23905500769615173,
-0.5724649429321289,
-0.4066650867462158,
-0.4887973666191101,
0.3295246362686157,
0.6805546879768372,
-0.2416357845067978,
-0.534400224685669,
-0.05719427019357681,
0.19334742426872253,
0.37548747658729553,
-0.3344373106956482,
0.6783137321472168,
0.5012109875679016,
-0.6392787098884583,
0.8054749369621277,
0.06821349263191223,
0.1817203015089035,
-0.45425888895988464,
-0.27480700612068176,
0.020607301965355873,
0.23654745519161224,
-0.048960134387016296,
-0.44647443294525146,
0.2562134861946106,
-0.13665704429149628,
-0.1433534175157547,
-0.9382439255714417,
0.6630746722221375,
-0.37142330408096313,
-0.516270637512207,
-0.11563374102115631,
0.5634292960166931,
0.17448970675468445,
-0.45508265495300293,
-0.2568221390247345,
0.04381221532821655,
-0.5033368468284607,
0.015953166410326958,
0.22932256758213043,
0.833213210105896,
-0.46349653601646423,
0.5604398846626282,
0.9494892954826355,
-0.24958699941635132,
0.26583898067474365,
0.14720210433006287,
0.7559431195259094,
-0.7720966935157776,
-0.6060377955436707,
-0.8144097328186035,
0.6816942095756531,
0.04578294977545738,
-0.4454989433288574,
0.8756157755851746,
0.4692641794681549,
0.6693506240844727,
-0.2779574990272522,
0.38011282682418823,
0.2625105082988739,
0.12059244513511658,
-0.40856093168258667,
0.4705672860145569,
0.040749937295913696,
0.10733461380004883,
-0.13971467316150665,
-1.0032662153244019,
-0.6565274000167847,
0.7060803771018982,
-0.5345956087112427,
-0.3112143576145172,
0.5878803730010986,
0.6039806008338928,
0.24573105573654175,
0.06278453767299652,
0.4918763041496277,
-0.1393967866897583,
-0.20452913641929626,
0.513327956199646,
0.9733777046203613,
-0.56203693151474,
0.30534276366233826,
-0.3249841034412384,
-0.27472376823425293,
-0.25360599160194397,
-1.2686883211135864,
-0.9267463088035583,
-0.3553811311721802,
-0.31602081656455994,
-0.22464928030967712,
0.11005853116512299,
0.7244313359260559,
0.8539832234382629,
-0.8400436639785767,
-0.2544457018375397,
-0.0815422460436821,
0.19454945623874664,
-0.11407121270895004,
-0.12639640271663666,
0.3637712895870209,
-0.640449583530426,
-0.671256422996521,
0.381963312625885,
0.44002434611320496,
0.10273405909538269,
-0.25576886534690857,
0.13795839250087738,
-0.009063996374607086,
-0.02266623266041279,
0.5796129107475281,
0.4694104790687561,
-0.5581541657447815,
-0.08559691905975342,
0.4124530553817749,
-0.15623296797275543,
-0.22071541845798492,
0.9468846321105957,
-1.1249598264694214,
0.2305426299571991,
0.6546926498413086,
0.8145362138748169,
0.16134090721607208,
0.19327016174793243,
0.976923406124115,
-0.6478544473648071,
0.36882972717285156,
0.5358611345291138,
0.31620723009109497,
0.3464055061340332,
0.15777693688869476,
0.555046796798706,
0.08592090755701065,
-0.1413196474313736,
-0.9170112013816833,
0.14598798751831055,
-0.699580192565918,
0.16958686709403992,
1.0029126405715942,
-0.20010873675346375,
-0.19572842121124268,
-0.36328762769699097,
0.34864604473114014,
-0.20007796585559845,
0.01957060769200325,
0.5160238146781921,
0.526996910572052,
0.6750513911247253,
0.163299560546875,
-0.3287956118583679,
0.7040992975234985,
0.7730221152305603,
-0.2509365677833557,
-0.03709336370229721,
0.13282978534698486,
-0.0404566265642643,
0.475212961435318,
0.5346423387527466,
-0.46938803791999817,
0.24347221851348877,
0.06297336518764496,
-0.11830507963895798,
-0.0049504186026751995,
-0.5399209856987,
-0.3155233860015869,
0.27588722109794617,
-0.026863744482398033,
-0.08270078152418137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01532v1
|
Set-Aligning Framework for Auto-Regressive Event Temporal Graph Generation
| 2024-04-01T23:46:00 | 2024-04-01T23:46:00 |
Xingwei Tan, Yuxiang Zhou, Gabriele Pergola, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Event temporal graphs have been shown as convenient and effective
representations of complex temporal relations between events in text. Recent
studies, which employ pre-trained language models to auto-regressively generate
linearised graphs for constructing event temporal graphs, have shown promising
results. However, these methods have often led to suboptimal graph generation
as the linearised graphs exhibit set characteristics which are instead treated
sequentially by language models. This discrepancy stems from the conventional
text generation objectives, leading to erroneous penalisation of correct
predictions caused by the misalignment of elements in target sequences. To
address these challenges, we reframe the task as a conditional set generation
problem, proposing a Set-aligning Framework tailored for the effective
utilisation of Large Language Models (LLMs). The framework incorporates data
augmentations and set-property regularisations designed to alleviate text
generation loss penalties associated with the linearised graph edge sequences,
thus encouraging the generation of more relation edges. Experimental results
show that our framework surpasses existing baselines for event temporal graph
generation. Furthermore, under zero-shot settings, the structural knowledge
introduced through our framework notably improves model generalisation,
particularly when the training examples available are limited.
|
[
0.11511409282684326,
-0.4513586163520813,
0.2995641231536865,
0.03560731187462807,
-0.12941141426563263,
-0.07340683043003082,
-0.13459628820419312,
-0.4638901352882385,
0.2063072770833969,
0.24932020902633667,
-0.844426155090332,
-0.3835117518901825,
-0.31226858496665955,
0.14694519340991974,
-0.35353997349739075,
1.0320426225662231,
-0.22853656113147736,
-0.3222575783729553,
-0.021347202360630035,
-0.21967847645282745,
-0.4797572195529938,
-0.42925941944122314,
-0.7642018795013428,
-0.6209825277328491,
0.564760684967041,
0.07778119295835495,
0.8837546706199646,
1.0209481716156006,
0.5407546162605286,
0.13673636317253113,
0.2927091419696808,
0.25906142592430115,
-0.5279922485351562,
0.3496159315109253,
-0.19023463129997253,
-0.09384415298700333,
-0.39838898181915283,
0.034342244267463684,
0.753437340259552,
0.7263157367706299,
0.09154470264911652,
0.16891585290431976,
-0.05209263786673546,
0.30002421140670776,
-0.5429510474205017,
0.2618160843849182,
-0.576984167098999,
0.4058245122432709,
-0.18514566123485565,
-0.34252646565437317,
-0.36069121956825256,
-0.158273845911026,
-0.22813111543655396,
-0.7956362366676331,
0.36726438999176025,
0.10436435788869858,
1.2181894779205322,
0.6153267025947571,
-0.41262516379356384,
0.1278606802225113,
-0.7263420820236206,
0.45796528458595276,
-0.8726866245269775,
0.3146247863769531,
0.17493361234664917,
0.2422800064086914,
-0.31761422753334045,
-0.8410638570785522,
-0.6177881360054016,
0.14529620110988617,
-0.2519955635070801,
0.21567043662071228,
-0.013747980818152428,
-0.0013129153521731496,
0.4388200342655182,
0.10669704526662827,
-0.7527592778205872,
0.6087309718132019,
0.13409323990345,
-0.050018370151519775,
0.7378304600715637,
0.45112714171409607,
0.20436958968639374,
-0.18315450847148895,
-0.15146130323410034,
-0.04455507546663284,
-0.8390573263168335,
-0.14611244201660156,
0.604523241519928,
0.625027060508728,
-0.14194416999816895,
0.7407819032669067,
-0.11102715134620667,
0.8187456130981445,
0.44990479946136475,
-0.09012430906295776,
0.17349368333816528,
-0.7217588424682617,
-0.09987989813089371,
0.03871028125286102,
0.9048680067062378,
0.39606836438179016,
0.48387905955314636,
-0.07765106111764908,
-0.21681854128837585,
0.2052663266658783,
-0.12285975366830826,
-0.974659264087677,
-0.24722923338413239,
0.1122858002781868,
-0.298776775598526,
-0.44975754618644714,
-0.2560388147830963,
-0.3577291965484619,
-0.06679990887641907,
-0.33386269211769104,
0.24318499863147736,
-0.42395490407943726,
-0.009225341491401196,
0.07260303199291229,
-0.051096849143505096,
0.180414617061615,
0.05191371962428093,
-0.5693806409835815,
-0.0844849944114685,
0.3247521221637726,
0.5708752274513245,
-0.03429514542222023,
-0.17160676419734955,
-0.7620358467102051,
0.6411469578742981,
-0.5361190438270569,
0.48514628410339355,
-0.7941568493843079,
-0.21731796860694885,
0.20285405218601227,
-0.03561747446656227,
0.11793392896652222,
0.05156577378511429,
0.16829819977283478,
-0.4620637595653534,
0.6545875072479248,
0.04700246453285217,
-0.6584822535514832,
0.5086055994033813,
0.007243169937282801,
-0.45877450704574585,
0.9411805272102356,
-0.14537373185157776,
-0.767328679561615,
0.7222898602485657,
-0.2657182812690735,
-0.7735982537269592,
0.056355856359004974,
-0.5420415997505188,
-0.714839518070221,
-0.31411173939704895,
0.4730033576488495,
0.434507817029953,
-0.000017292994016315788,
0.5609164237976074,
-0.5224831104278564,
0.060351863503456116,
0.036737747490406036,
-0.21935617923736572,
0.310709685087204,
0.1839289516210556,
-0.4420996606349945,
-0.07950466871261597,
-0.7379998564720154,
-0.018327884376049042,
0.09808909147977829,
-0.10619539022445679,
-0.11871586740016937,
0.4747944176197052,
-0.02922040969133377,
0.40209993720054626,
0.3364689350128174,
-0.4163772165775299,
0.3636072278022766,
-0.5130918622016907,
0.22150354087352753,
0.86505126953125,
0.39805880188941956,
0.42598652839660645,
-0.33757415413856506,
0.45834881067276,
0.23058444261550903,
-0.05550063028931618,
-0.5474755764007568,
-0.1759868711233139,
-0.5064308047294617,
-0.021165378391742706,
0.2808598279953003,
0.5351810455322266,
-0.8232080936431885,
0.8184822797775269,
-0.3729531466960907,
-0.0056641800329089165,
-0.11590627580881119,
-0.03867296129465103,
0.6485049724578857,
0.7560139894485474,
0.012254699133336544,
-0.1099989265203476,
-0.7927451729774475,
-0.8950585126876831,
0.001448312308639288,
-0.15251697599887848,
0.19963707029819489,
0.08173219859600067,
0.1871020793914795,
-0.04161760210990906,
1.1188942193984985,
-0.6651401519775391,
-0.24007001519203186,
0.09654731303453445,
0.13263669610023499,
0.12107840180397034,
0.6080313920974731,
0.5563188791275024,
-0.6589246988296509,
-0.4164119362831116,
0.12677708268165588,
-0.8327128291130066,
-0.41551151871681213,
-0.3481612205505371,
-0.08720559626817703,
0.49341097474098206,
0.5709891319274902,
-0.21347661316394806,
0.812809944152832,
0.4040077030658722,
-0.3989519476890564,
0.38336604833602905,
-0.024811068549752235,
0.008092405274510384,
-1.3324037790298462,
0.12878599762916565,
0.06499671936035156,
-0.5987955927848816,
-0.3466070890426636,
-0.42779436707496643,
-0.18801884353160858,
-0.5346456170082092,
0.03902963176369667,
0.7130905389785767,
-0.3383580148220062,
-0.11712560057640076,
-0.25505372881889343,
0.4324168264865875,
0.2648168206214905,
0.41206881403923035,
0.254597008228302,
0.4673629403114319,
0.24325641989707947,
-0.5587412118911743,
-0.027907921001315117,
0.44037100672721863,
0.054045386612415314,
0.6573625802993774,
-0.5105881094932556,
-0.20287400484085083,
-0.051206424832344055,
0.3225290775299072,
-0.7073341012001038,
-0.30395475029945374,
0.038280125707387924,
-0.5891205668449402,
0.6096598505973816,
-0.21520183980464935,
-0.47552618384361267,
-0.2185947299003601,
-0.04475872591137886,
0.3002912998199463,
0.501986563205719,
-0.5007317066192627,
0.42084506154060364,
0.3040270507335663,
-0.0837717056274414,
-0.9606229662895203,
-0.6409170627593994,
-0.026995612308382988,
0.020448192954063416,
-0.7900761961936951,
0.5508944392204285,
-0.12535086274147034,
-0.20040351152420044,
0.30086207389831543,
-0.22840122878551483,
0.24737119674682617,
-0.20785754919052124,
0.1985674947500229,
0.17592620849609375,
-0.2661615014076233,
0.4274600148200989,
0.04203684628009796,
-0.26049357652664185,
-0.4925778806209564,
-0.5793256759643555,
0.5680683255195618,
0.3773401081562042,
-0.44697490334510803,
-0.5422759056091309,
0.3608390986919403,
0.24955150485038757,
-0.18950730562210083,
0.6546550393104553,
0.5314017534255981,
-0.7425479888916016,
-0.21939511597156525,
-0.35826900601387024,
-0.04027910903096199,
-0.4285374581813812,
0.3074827492237091,
-0.3700447678565979,
-0.7022832632064819,
0.7477893829345703,
0.37005069851875305,
0.4406059980392456,
0.6374671459197998,
0.4576629102230072,
-0.09141550958156586,
1.2393630743026733,
0.6300522089004517,
-0.1484742909669876,
0.7893125414848328,
0.02349504642188549,
0.3297896683216095,
-0.42863985896110535,
0.023777320981025696,
-0.3594425320625305,
-0.3329720199108124,
-0.5146467685699463,
0.027709264308214188,
0.09006065875291824,
0.16262318193912506,
-0.5840831398963928,
0.2654722034931183,
-0.3988126814365387,
0.31672242283821106,
0.02849389985203743,
-0.04679376631975174,
0.25237053632736206,
-0.08533169329166412,
0.02635686844587326,
-0.026755008846521378,
-1.0670711994171143,
-0.5234602689743042,
0.9138418436050415,
-0.010840056464076042,
0.7557332515716553,
-0.13971613347530365,
0.9119994044303894,
0.3757918179035187,
0.3311564028263092,
-0.3398875594139099,
0.2877601087093353,
-0.22631286084651947,
-0.481612890958786,
-0.5558607578277588,
-0.6304259300231934,
-1.0112407207489014,
-0.32873764634132385,
-0.24557241797447205,
-0.5716211795806885,
0.4871267080307007,
0.40439659357070923,
-0.36085522174835205,
0.1703639030456543,
-0.4615108370780945,
0.7462826371192932,
-0.033216044306755066,
-0.38147681951522827,
0.23086592555046082,
-0.5167582035064697,
0.14387397468090057,
-0.17121730744838715,
0.10934492200613022,
-0.2369615137577057,
-0.07659096270799637,
0.7029836773872375,
-0.5674277544021606,
1.0677604675292969,
-0.0842348262667656,
0.0022561766672879457,
0.1840335875749588,
0.15238240361213684,
0.912049412727356,
0.19371439516544342,
-0.1282016932964325,
-0.3865395188331604,
-0.2073693871498108,
-0.30188417434692383,
-0.4611283242702484,
0.7048263549804688,
-0.6205861568450928,
-0.273669570684433,
-0.1397334486246109,
-0.7038337588310242,
-0.2055353820323944,
0.20120815932750702,
0.45566242933273315,
0.883344829082489,
-0.232673779129982,
-0.3436771333217621,
0.4378112256526947,
-0.015356801450252533,
0.7608184814453125,
0.5233482122421265,
-0.38843539357185364,
-0.4626884460449219,
0.7972434163093567,
0.2136152684688568,
0.3659631013870239,
0.39424243569374084,
-0.13844944536685944,
-0.09893740713596344,
-0.376177042722702,
-0.3031468391418457,
0.27428266406059265,
-0.564435601234436,
-0.6531387567520142,
-0.41590219736099243,
-0.3046881854534149,
-0.7568656206130981,
-0.585822343826294,
-0.10969903320074081,
-0.8792351484298706,
-0.525299072265625,
-0.3493674695491791,
0.41060101985931396,
0.5439736843109131,
-0.4517562985420227,
0.42446160316467285,
-0.5101149678230286,
0.23723198473453522,
0.0031093391589820385,
0.30829229950904846,
-0.3494936525821686,
-0.5346709489822388,
-0.12634213268756866,
-0.17126363515853882,
-0.30923905968666077,
-0.7065865993499756,
0.5346851944923401,
0.5598277449607849,
0.4380737543106079,
0.4601795971393585,
0.038938745856285095,
0.8640474081039429,
-0.795912504196167,
0.5123924016952515,
0.2900061011314392,
-0.8048213720321655,
0.6431484222412109,
-0.6616884469985962,
0.15119411051273346,
0.36253586411476135,
0.2574741244316101,
-0.5531429052352905,
-0.5347713828086853,
-1.031771183013916,
-0.835031270980835,
0.666577935218811,
0.48976457118988037,
-0.28261053562164307,
-0.13824966549873352,
0.7361605763435364,
-0.05121217295527458,
0.19681811332702637,
-1.0911142826080322,
-0.08610601723194122,
-0.20247051119804382,
-0.6750888228416443,
-0.21435630321502686,
-0.021203799173235893,
-0.25406092405319214,
0.29483848810195923,
0.8215259909629822,
-0.2758834660053253,
0.056487660855054855,
0.18974614143371582,
0.0027603870257735252,
-0.5125384330749512,
-0.11270077526569366,
0.33876779675483704,
0.7685403227806091,
-0.07890154421329498,
-0.15212813019752502,
-0.020552795380353928,
-0.012211942113935947,
0.1765274554491043,
0.5288758873939514,
-0.31712865829467773,
-0.04263179749250412,
0.6766523718833923,
0.6673410534858704,
0.011138301342725754,
-0.36589086055755615,
0.2928498387336731,
0.16159744560718536,
-0.037384893745183945,
-0.29821863770484924,
-0.07006814330816269,
-0.1751207709312439,
0.22026069462299347,
0.24239858984947205,
-0.4157715141773224,
-0.31418493390083313,
-0.32538506388664246,
0.5390446782112122,
0.44603079557418823,
-0.49647659063339233,
-0.2124594897031784,
0.6924684643745422,
0.2636033594608307,
-0.49416637420654297,
0.4862080216407776,
-0.36705583333969116,
-0.3878669738769531,
0.7458949089050293,
0.6784064769744873,
0.6078104972839355,
-0.19128908216953278,
-0.09168106317520142,
0.3946002721786499,
0.4354006350040436,
0.22884678840637207,
0.2603518068790436,
0.2631411850452423,
-0.8200434446334839,
-0.6442636847496033,
-0.691838800907135,
-0.16133661568164825,
0.10355772078037262,
-0.5017685294151306,
0.3559396266937256,
-0.28525254130363464,
-0.3770044445991516,
-0.07689638435840607,
-0.06936731934547424,
-0.6632707715034485,
0.31878861784935,
0.13424554467201233,
0.6397418975830078,
-1.0406036376953125,
0.5934193134307861,
0.34886106848716736,
-0.6441437602043152,
-0.7528051733970642,
-0.0612550787627697,
-0.2487936019897461,
-0.6092215776443481,
0.6679250597953796,
0.020781079307198524,
0.057733215391635895,
0.09714218974113464,
-0.3941958546638489,
-1.0298501253128052,
0.9912897944450378,
0.23024120926856995,
-0.8655335903167725,
-0.32206469774246216,
0.07151476293802261,
0.5423570275306702,
-0.7799032330513,
-0.28025874495506287,
0.32617610692977905,
0.44151994585990906,
0.010689012706279755,
-0.9045683145523071,
0.0837319940328598,
-0.24851860105991364,
-0.09170081466436386,
0.6978867053985596,
-0.43684718012809753,
0.47088587284088135,
0.017164548859000206,
-0.5281485915184021,
-0.07528699189424515,
0.8589127659797668,
0.11911359429359436,
0.30728527903556824,
0.24329431354999542,
0.7728351354598999,
0.6797934770584106,
-0.20362886786460876,
0.9326015710830688,
-0.5129922032356262,
0.09063469618558884,
1.3689072132110596,
-0.6033490300178528,
0.38557469844818115,
0.09377525001764297,
0.13030900061130524,
0.4330888092517853,
0.7012965679168701,
0.21273654699325562,
0.3854226768016815,
0.09965772926807404,
-0.03955432027578354,
-0.5852076411247253,
-0.012388773262500763,
-0.40493443608283997,
0.14629583060741425,
0.44433829188346863,
-0.35833290219306946,
-0.22524800896644592,
0.05650133639574051,
0.042617134749889374,
0.14425788819789886,
-0.29053065180778503,
0.5356301069259644,
0.07452967017889023,
-0.5054841637611389,
0.21026499569416046,
-0.14171072840690613,
0.3284878432750702,
-0.6630296111106873,
0.05038220062851906,
-0.2769726514816284,
0.17386996746063232,
-0.12470211088657379,
-0.6955873370170593,
0.43688273429870605,
-0.05781480297446251,
-0.4853443503379822,
-0.22044490277767181,
0.6997342705726624,
-0.5171079039573669,
-0.6070117950439453,
0.06104782968759537,
0.42124122381210327,
-0.27965521812438965,
0.5759802460670471,
-0.4659465253353119,
-0.0562625527381897,
0.011201919056475163,
-0.1480899453163147,
0.20444265007972717,
0.5899487137794495,
-0.32496264576911926,
0.5043078660964966,
0.4914657175540924,
-0.015983199700713158,
-0.0025907866656780243,
0.20152981579303741,
0.6977975964546204,
-0.5837685465812683,
-0.4951111972332001,
-0.7263656258583069,
0.5024670958518982,
-0.34004804491996765,
-0.34473347663879395,
0.5072347521781921,
0.6920067071914673,
0.634777307510376,
0.4804045557975769,
0.647189736366272,
0.03306859731674194,
0.28347694873809814,
-0.6251453161239624,
0.46408626437187195,
-0.4328550398349762,
0.09462874382734299,
-0.13086362183094025,
-0.6583967804908752,
-0.46021586656570435,
0.33226174116134644,
-0.3576861321926117,
-0.034736309200525284,
0.5014243125915527,
0.7359839081764221,
0.05745859816670418,
-0.323872447013855,
0.1942821592092514,
0.014530851505696774,
0.5560631155967712,
0.4976479709148407,
0.6282473206520081,
-0.3251974582672119,
0.6755443811416626,
-0.02919771336019039,
-0.2790747284889221,
0.0324997715651989,
-1.3023884296417236,
-0.8364782333374023,
-0.7743167281150818,
-0.5817955136299133,
-0.4051533043384552,
0.3581914007663727,
0.7736955881118774,
0.5589473247528076,
-0.4802124798297882,
-0.005259034223854542,
0.04808080941438675,
-0.06693143397569656,
0.12990324199199677,
-0.270079642534256,
0.4865168631076813,
-0.7575497627258301,
-0.6256089806556702,
0.40851065516471863,
0.35995450615882874,
0.34956443309783936,
-0.0216637272387743,
0.06931547820568085,
-0.20233890414237976,
0.24622753262519836,
0.36415061354637146,
0.5479166507720947,
-0.10975255817174911,
-0.543318510055542,
-0.20454025268554688,
-0.14392419159412384,
0.07215068489313126,
0.789840817451477,
-0.9471548199653625,
0.14306093752384186,
0.3637033700942993,
0.3456750810146332,
0.5915765166282654,
-0.1254146844148636,
1.035658597946167,
-1.1680541038513184,
0.35355344414711,
0.30607494711875916,
0.7353924512863159,
0.2882986068725586,
-0.5336616039276123,
0.6008475422859192,
0.20029808580875397,
-0.5812041759490967,
-1.0269604921340942,
0.6748906373977661,
-0.7538915276527405,
-0.10136134177446365,
0.9716773629188538,
0.013726651668548584,
-0.12641291320323944,
-0.0037660482339560986,
0.30371442437171936,
0.5776840448379517,
-0.17552624642848969,
0.5640837550163269,
0.41224414110183716,
-0.3824789822101593,
0.3129290044307709,
0.05506838858127594,
0.571533203125,
0.19616468250751495,
-0.7823664546012878,
0.22106008231639862,
0.8852112293243408,
0.027095399796962738,
0.2726914584636688,
0.6084978580474854,
-0.0878138542175293,
0.20890089869499207,
-0.13857324421405792,
0.2640594244003296,
-0.35610833764076233,
-0.3939141631126404,
-0.21614082157611847,
-0.03818951174616814,
-0.16654907166957855,
0.13555222749710083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01490v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01490v2
|
AAdaM at SemEval-2024 Task 1: Augmentation and Adaptation for Multilingual Semantic Textual Relatedness
| 2024-04-01T21:21:15 | 2024-06-07T14:02:55 |
Miaoran Zhang, Mingyang Wang, Jesujoba O. Alabi, Dietrich Klakow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents our system developed for the SemEval-2024 Task 1:
Semantic Textual Relatedness for African and Asian Languages. The shared task
aims at measuring the semantic textual relatedness between pairs of sentences,
with a focus on a range of under-represented languages. In this work, we
propose using machine translation for data augmentation to address the
low-resource challenge of limited training data. Moreover, we apply
task-adaptive pre-training on unlabeled task data to bridge the gap between
pre-training and task adaptation. For model training, we investigate both full
fine-tuning and adapter-based tuning, and adopt the adapter framework for
effective zero-shot cross-lingual transfer. We achieve competitive results in
the shared task: our system performs the best among all ranked teams in both
subtask A (supervised learning) and subtask C (cross-lingual transfer).
|
[
-0.37431803345680237,
-0.4802667796611786,
0.33444225788116455,
0.3855395019054413,
-0.44166088104248047,
-0.12504856288433075,
-0.295086145401001,
-0.7442099452018738,
0.333135187625885,
0.767375111579895,
-0.7892361283302307,
-0.31426873803138733,
-0.5893125534057617,
0.45941856503486633,
-0.03309129923582077,
0.9409865140914917,
-0.41337791085243225,
-0.18017660081386566,
-0.29637113213539124,
-0.6495195031166077,
-0.8296921849250793,
-0.643240749835968,
-0.34419137239456177,
-0.25809404253959656,
0.3351433277130127,
0.732964277267456,
0.47834575176239014,
0.40933966636657715,
0.5775841474533081,
0.2528749406337738,
0.5421791076660156,
0.36691227555274963,
-0.4028381407260895,
0.22443035244941711,
-0.6449174284934998,
-0.4385102093219757,
-0.7072705626487732,
-0.3780684173107147,
0.2802101969718933,
0.657944917678833,
0.47139105200767517,
0.12501312792301178,
0.2392968088388443,
0.5133051872253418,
-0.5346409678459167,
0.1952115148305893,
-0.6819645762443542,
-0.15692752599716187,
-0.24966032803058624,
-0.46710899472236633,
-0.004619445651769638,
0.17271365225315094,
-0.05247969925403595,
-1.0250948667526245,
0.10913581401109695,
-0.10822027921676636,
0.76485276222229,
0.6306228041648865,
-0.5439951419830322,
-0.3507237434387207,
-0.3187660872936249,
0.7649378776550293,
-0.44889870285987854,
0.17581625282764435,
0.6558601260185242,
0.1487855166196823,
0.22056613862514496,
-0.5153225064277649,
-0.4363197684288025,
0.2245965152978897,
-0.11062958836555481,
0.31995731592178345,
0.11041474342346191,
-0.13306643068790436,
-0.11065364629030228,
0.1520426869392395,
-0.5088566541671753,
0.0468515008687973,
-0.19559717178344727,
-0.2890428602695465,
0.774876594543457,
0.028706390410661697,
0.5168604850769043,
-0.11991415172815323,
-0.4312751889228821,
0.005984044633805752,
-0.36525994539260864,
-0.2609519958496094,
0.14348921179771423,
0.5136857032775879,
-0.25871333479881287,
0.5224381685256958,
-0.40714511275291443,
0.5358279347419739,
-0.06730034947395325,
0.40745285153388977,
0.5537878274917603,
-1.0462043285369873,
-0.03160277381539345,
0.40777426958084106,
0.526784360408783,
0.3824103772640228,
0.23940609395503998,
-0.058113910257816315,
-0.06541772186756134,
0.14523176848888397,
0.21043556928634644,
-0.6235285997390747,
-0.07098504900932312,
-0.1290944218635559,
-0.23158788681030273,
-0.055676452815532684,
-0.37303221225738525,
-0.5552507638931274,
-0.2745864689350128,
-0.5193625688552856,
0.9892321228981018,
-0.4673885107040405,
-0.11773306131362915,
0.09117920696735382,
0.15688486397266388,
0.15039724111557007,
0.47948089241981506,
-0.9480494856834412,
0.23273728787899017,
0.5400984287261963,
0.6939975619316101,
-0.3824073076248169,
-0.6603026390075684,
-0.4417237639427185,
0.29742687940597534,
-0.2012474238872528,
0.8005344867706299,
-0.41903191804885864,
-0.2317008227109909,
-0.2218882292509079,
0.6534634828567505,
-0.2751830816268921,
-0.39177772402763367,
0.9750114679336548,
-0.23569537699222565,
0.060027118772268295,
-0.30875763297080994,
-0.525985836982727,
-0.3776308298110962,
0.21476654708385468,
-0.5834000110626221,
1.0619399547576904,
0.217782124876976,
-0.617899477481842,
0.4917026162147522,
-0.8429895639419556,
-0.6783206462860107,
0.10004918277263641,
0.1290978193283081,
-0.32106709480285645,
-0.04373323172330856,
0.5662785172462463,
0.4735587537288666,
-0.05439415201544762,
-0.08877010643482208,
-0.33101677894592285,
-0.44907262921333313,
-0.19028331339359283,
-0.2542864680290222,
0.7115386724472046,
0.2575187087059021,
-0.29432517290115356,
0.22824756801128387,
-0.7328124046325684,
-0.12843897938728333,
-0.03994247317314148,
-0.05724417790770531,
-0.7071396112442017,
-0.4485835134983063,
0.19911633431911469,
0.2676432430744171,
0.6673581004142761,
-0.40106886625289917,
0.10250651091337204,
-0.44706490635871887,
0.17848703265190125,
0.624214768409729,
0.06874007731676102,
0.7010813355445862,
-0.28866928815841675,
0.4737778306007385,
0.2770931124687195,
-0.16453123092651367,
-0.5647844076156616,
-0.08521129935979843,
-0.9716230630874634,
0.039170607924461365,
0.5170600414276123,
0.8574517369270325,
-1.1862472295761108,
0.33359047770500183,
-0.5769590735435486,
-0.36178213357925415,
-0.7209262847900391,
0.3090333342552185,
0.029373103752732277,
0.36911138892173767,
0.5606814026832581,
-0.3169822096824646,
-0.8023014664649963,
-0.8771603107452393,
-0.18703976273536682,
0.21726039052009583,
0.04459885507822037,
0.16643299162387848,
0.4918200373649597,
-0.40992268919944763,
0.31422460079193115,
-0.02617606893181801,
-0.5542997121810913,
-0.00997441541403532,
0.12224110215902328,
0.15392445027828217,
0.5612738132476807,
0.6791277527809143,
-0.7520542740821838,
-0.5787023901939392,
0.5131606459617615,
-0.9679059982299805,
-0.3983580768108368,
-0.05083247646689415,
-0.36145272850990295,
0.4130271077156067,
0.5915123224258423,
0.07306163012981415,
0.29652586579322815,
0.6531223058700562,
-0.3597094714641571,
0.07809466123580933,
-0.3969954252243042,
0.5832967758178711,
-1.4644954204559326,
-0.06615516543388367,
-0.38588955998420715,
-0.5400152206420898,
-0.5707613229751587,
-0.08217233419418335,
0.03246472775936127,
-0.22965574264526367,
-0.32274875044822693,
0.7011614441871643,
-0.35430169105529785,
-0.16597174108028412,
-0.671346127986908,
0.10237560421228409,
-0.06601189076900482,
0.4658359885215759,
0.09044435620307922,
1.0156371593475342,
0.46491771936416626,
-0.6074223518371582,
0.25456535816192627,
0.36275333166122437,
-0.1142830029129982,
0.9217267036437988,
-0.4994650185108185,
0.16068801283836365,
0.043214842677116394,
0.0018157802987843752,
-0.5889606475830078,
-0.15305927395820618,
0.24811416864395142,
-0.5771973133087158,
0.058756038546562195,
0.1361600011587143,
-0.1943991482257843,
-0.01623573713004589,
-0.10256795585155487,
0.6343685984611511,
0.12057583034038544,
-0.44002947211265564,
0.42835667729377747,
0.4217240810394287,
-0.6206082701683044,
-0.3895288407802582,
-0.8161798119544983,
0.2848193943500519,
-0.12398310750722885,
-0.7841187119483948,
0.39313071966171265,
0.1787184476852417,
0.24474452435970306,
0.3301445543766022,
-0.08643487840890884,
-0.23801113665103912,
0.2022750824689865,
0.1715560406446457,
0.17830608785152435,
-0.30211275815963745,
0.12661245465278625,
0.22810016572475433,
-0.15739156305789948,
-0.2492019236087799,
-0.4429675340652466,
0.24134984612464905,
0.12073735892772675,
-0.3460487425327301,
-0.023627348244190216,
0.4214557111263275,
0.23492643237113953,
-0.2053770124912262,
0.7879930734634399,
0.8748177289962769,
-0.45030683279037476,
0.07667794823646545,
-0.22061371803283691,
-0.008380139246582985,
-0.38394296169281006,
0.603844165802002,
-0.7393678426742554,
-1.101855754852295,
0.4447004497051239,
-0.18483595550060272,
0.028388934209942818,
0.593826413154602,
0.5589918494224548,
-0.07157886028289795,
0.7678886651992798,
0.8743413686752319,
-0.056953638792037964,
0.34538283944129944,
0.1212395429611206,
-0.03732207417488098,
-0.697580873966217,
0.05598370358347893,
-0.5723260641098022,
-0.25589972734451294,
-0.8188281059265137,
-0.7466347813606262,
0.1464616358280182,
0.06462011486291885,
-0.13114625215530396,
0.7236419320106506,
-0.2524764835834503,
0.2086096853017807,
0.3594125509262085,
0.020409895107150078,
0.22711344063282013,
0.054111845791339874,
0.040407732129096985,
-0.2750837504863739,
-0.6568779349327087,
-0.3607591986656189,
0.9664101004600525,
0.018950169906020164,
0.48722127079963684,
-0.029280230402946472,
0.6205344796180725,
0.45563986897468567,
-0.14020466804504395,
-0.4845406413078308,
0.3607245087623596,
-0.46533718705177307,
-0.4158376455307007,
-0.4346838891506195,
-0.24687738716602325,
-0.948005735874176,
0.2653597295284271,
-0.2591450810432434,
-0.37928956747055054,
0.30805864930152893,
-0.12308655679225922,
0.15139494836330414,
-0.2279253602027893,
-0.5323769450187683,
1.0113445520401,
-0.3263324201107025,
-0.39519211649894714,
-0.2423505038022995,
-0.7297210097312927,
0.021894413977861404,
-0.5863114595413208,
0.36220020055770874,
-0.17013846337795258,
-0.31147482991218567,
0.6508004665374756,
-0.34823548793792725,
0.5589063167572021,
-0.06001820042729378,
-0.011873842217028141,
0.10554333031177521,
-0.18821868300437927,
0.3531735837459564,
-0.13636508584022522,
-0.3494226038455963,
0.22411252558231354,
0.16038896143436432,
-0.8517616987228394,
-0.5079314708709717,
0.6516289114952087,
-0.7773800492286682,
-0.27394792437553406,
-0.42691537737846375,
-0.7540472745895386,
-0.31936267018318176,
0.41407859325408936,
0.12662068009376526,
0.0722755417227745,
-0.2890450656414032,
0.29997318983078003,
0.3194623291492462,
-0.2945795953273773,
0.2607489824295044,
0.44776293635368347,
-0.08604153990745544,
-0.40602511167526245,
1.112143635749817,
-0.0007130531594157219,
0.18949584662914276,
0.5411295890808105,
-0.2514958381652832,
-0.3679271936416626,
-0.44563227891921997,
-0.7599650025367737,
-0.06771969050168991,
-0.6152071356773376,
-0.10137060284614563,
-0.6482159495353699,
-0.257540225982666,
-0.6317644715309143,
-0.3221096396446228,
-0.20708204805850983,
-0.674159049987793,
-0.3715137839317322,
-0.02295939065515995,
0.45697981119155884,
0.4049466550350189,
-0.20900914072990417,
0.2415710836648941,
-1.0248793363571167,
0.26618561148643494,
0.09310545027256012,
0.007804696913808584,
-0.5609979629516602,
-0.8686912655830383,
-0.5636800527572632,
0.08974962681531906,
-0.07390103489160538,
-0.5048786401748657,
0.29089808464050293,
0.4733197093009949,
0.5726193785667419,
-0.22597961127758026,
0.20102135837078094,
0.8539585471153259,
-0.5384615063667297,
0.5847388505935669,
0.004333351273089647,
-0.9379141330718994,
0.7048826217651367,
-0.3735679090023041,
0.6637584567070007,
1.0329276323318481,
0.3927846848964691,
-0.5611261129379272,
-0.026545925065875053,
-0.23615935444831848,
-0.8062999248504639,
0.7932383418083191,
0.2699780762195587,
0.20573125779628754,
0.401937335729599,
0.14054706692695618,
0.3945173919200897,
0.0565364696085453,
-0.4842936098575592,
-0.03076072782278061,
-0.45024383068084717,
-0.492279589176178,
-0.353503942489624,
0.0737546756863594,
0.22509008646011353,
-0.1389031559228897,
0.9415827989578247,
-0.5117158889770508,
-0.01782279461622238,
0.2560748755931854,
-0.5631000399589539,
-0.035856425762176514,
0.47496160864830017,
0.4359210133552551,
0.5412982106208801,
0.10608374327421188,
-0.012307682074606419,
0.7419817447662354,
-0.43019235134124756,
0.29999303817749023,
0.5435028076171875,
-0.15226919949054718,
-0.007601042278110981,
0.4732034206390381,
1.2101463079452515,
0.4533378481864929,
-0.4599902927875519,
0.3694654405117035,
0.011938901618123055,
-0.25486528873443604,
0.01289350539445877,
-0.16554370522499084,
0.054081909358501434,
0.06841343641281128,
0.2075810581445694,
0.1919185072183609,
0.18631526827812195,
-0.5457056164741516,
0.4594399034976959,
0.08503229171037674,
-0.7590503096580505,
-0.4675035774707794,
0.5521353483200073,
0.5231983065605164,
0.006242669187486172,
-0.02687402069568634,
-0.177612766623497,
-0.6611434817314148,
0.43819230794906616,
0.5030239224433899,
0.5326167941093445,
-0.44923916459083557,
0.052699413150548935,
0.42927286028862,
0.4247890114784241,
0.20974114537239075,
0.45854076743125916,
-0.10547555983066559,
-0.6321612000465393,
-0.7201447486877441,
-0.7514077425003052,
-0.23104867339134216,
-0.14974938333034515,
-0.5451808571815491,
0.6597071886062622,
0.23638799786567688,
0.2292841374874115,
-0.0938001349568367,
0.16689476370811462,
-0.7444255352020264,
0.2777482271194458,
-0.004158528055995703,
0.7360011339187622,
-0.8644996881484985,
0.9586667418479919,
1.0952612161636353,
-0.3785179853439331,
-0.5778658986091614,
-0.30069440603256226,
-0.2113494873046875,
-0.8318160772323608,
0.3892689645290375,
0.046292971819639206,
0.12069307267665863,
-0.008994313888251781,
0.07566652446985245,
-0.6926901340484619,
1.1464402675628662,
0.3949428200721741,
-0.562556266784668,
0.12047001719474792,
0.48677611351013184,
0.4906904697418213,
-0.3476191759109497,
-0.004035888239741325,
0.5158509016036987,
0.49266400933265686,
0.11687156558036804,
-1.2137099504470825,
-0.01186299230903387,
-0.2353312373161316,
-0.20149660110473633,
0.37400949001312256,
-0.5070518851280212,
0.5048631429672241,
0.10958495736122131,
-0.08805591613054276,
0.11424596607685089,
0.7094587683677673,
-0.1051354706287384,
0.5316428542137146,
0.5265026688575745,
0.6123932003974915,
0.59613436460495,
0.02528274990618229,
0.688437819480896,
-0.33754417300224304,
0.10519014298915863,
1.476434588432312,
-0.504144012928009,
0.5982934832572937,
0.3818417489528656,
-0.0019649991299957037,
0.15972743928432465,
0.6790270209312439,
0.30606114864349365,
0.5431308150291443,
-0.2835662066936493,
-0.28362521529197693,
-0.2435462772846222,
-0.6169487237930298,
-0.5373758673667908,
0.6290378570556641,
0.32724738121032715,
-0.12912629544734955,
-0.2215135097503662,
0.32500019669532776,
-0.20340944826602936,
0.3062821924686432,
-0.49233806133270264,
0.9562958478927612,
0.2395208775997162,
-0.6327953934669495,
0.3288225829601288,
-0.19947035610675812,
0.7641655802726746,
-0.46659937500953674,
-0.04439463093876839,
-0.06649906933307648,
0.24844880402088165,
-0.2483682781457901,
-0.7124990820884705,
0.601631760597229,
-0.10889694094657898,
-0.13675421476364136,
-0.19394026696681976,
1.2626087665557861,
-0.717637300491333,
-0.7299351692199707,
0.42804062366485596,
0.6617641448974609,
0.02571762166917324,
-0.007325652055442333,
-0.6940152645111084,
0.0667346641421318,
0.09084908664226532,
0.30484887957572937,
0.48278456926345825,
0.8340479731559753,
-0.3583831489086151,
0.200484499335289,
0.5126462578773499,
0.15922744572162628,
0.11015993356704712,
0.19538535177707672,
0.5828461050987244,
-0.6018899083137512,
-0.5552922487258911,
-0.4945005178451538,
0.10261543840169907,
-0.10056795924901962,
-0.18705667555332184,
0.9327857494354248,
0.5639318227767944,
1.0772367715835571,
0.005844377912580967,
0.9638847708702087,
0.08842823654413223,
0.5897651314735413,
-0.4272329807281494,
0.6000142097473145,
-0.8007983565330505,
0.0017305422807112336,
-0.2724466919898987,
-1.1126055717468262,
0.017832506448030472,
0.3853772282600403,
-0.19530189037322998,
-0.2800295054912567,
0.6207457780838013,
0.6696040630340576,
-0.3295736312866211,
0.16822749376296997,
0.516727864742279,
-0.07740302383899689,
-0.15383271872997284,
0.7051219344139099,
0.5298980474472046,
-0.8629565834999084,
0.6071171164512634,
-0.2821623682975769,
-0.11624419689178467,
-0.20204265415668488,
-0.8569301962852478,
-0.7031016945838928,
-0.8287684917449951,
-0.25258415937423706,
-0.026922332122921944,
0.3318040370941162,
0.8386085033416748,
0.6171566247940063,
-1.0837810039520264,
-0.12201976776123047,
0.026482604444026947,
-0.21973134577274323,
-0.059640247374773026,
-0.1714666187763214,
0.2849011719226837,
-0.42078647017478943,
-0.7190319895744324,
0.39552852511405945,
0.552237868309021,
-0.04690471664071083,
0.12324666231870651,
-0.1608319729566574,
-0.4289798140525818,
-0.0521576814353466,
0.6426470875740051,
0.09132393449544907,
-0.2590276896953583,
-0.4211752414703369,
0.04087403416633606,
0.014156604185700417,
-0.06967934221029282,
0.6146000027656555,
-0.6373976469039917,
0.6330296993255615,
0.48173001408576965,
1.2937413454055786,
0.5878782272338867,
0.03796929866075516,
0.6087734699249268,
-0.6356961727142334,
0.4838857650756836,
0.1826390027999878,
0.2789257764816284,
0.48144787549972534,
-0.2905658781528473,
0.9155949354171753,
0.13345231115818024,
-0.7280489206314087,
-0.5848669409751892,
0.058851659297943115,
-0.8927891850471497,
-0.15258120000362396,
0.7983049154281616,
-0.2588180899620056,
-0.32031816244125366,
-0.4318317472934723,
-0.3174799382686615,
0.5208985209465027,
-0.09607192873954773,
0.2585805058479309,
0.8448305726051331,
-0.027764279395341873,
-0.054699767380952835,
-0.6900306940078735,
0.23904924094676971,
0.6859889626502991,
-1.166015386581421,
-0.21234279870986938,
0.2638545632362366,
0.10166019201278687,
0.08317961543798447,
0.692151665687561,
0.08269349485635757,
0.5396541357040405,
-0.08984196931123734,
-0.043057870119810104,
0.121112160384655,
-0.04712787643074989,
-0.4506877660751343,
-0.24500884115695953,
-0.09002086520195007,
-0.36900854110717773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01481v1
|
A Study on Scaling Up Multilingual News Framing Analysis
| 2024-04-01T21:02:18 | 2024-04-01T21:02:18 |
Syeda Sabrina Akter, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Media framing is the study of strategically selecting and presenting specific
aspects of political issues to shape public opinion. Despite its relevance to
almost all societies around the world, research has been limited due to the
lack of available datasets and other resources. This study explores the
possibility of dataset creation through crowdsourcing, utilizing non-expert
annotators to develop training corpora. We first extend framing analysis beyond
English news to a multilingual context (12 typologically diverse languages)
through automatic translation. We also present a novel benchmark in Bengali and
Portuguese on the immigration and same-sex marriage domains. Additionally, we
show that a system trained on our crowd-sourced dataset, combined with other
existing ones, leads to a 5.32 percentage point increase from the baseline,
showing that crowdsourcing is a viable option. Last, we study the performance
of large language models (LLMs) for this task, finding that task-specific
fine-tuning is a better approach than employing bigger non-specialized models.
|
[
-0.6755887269973755,
-0.4949336647987366,
0.11547814309597015,
0.4306418001651764,
-0.1835176646709442,
0.14940273761749268,
-0.37984851002693176,
-0.3822324275970459,
0.23359572887420654,
0.4938724935054779,
-0.2754266858100891,
-0.3166158199310303,
-1.0264462232589722,
0.4582318365573883,
-0.2798176109790802,
1.1237833499908447,
0.032344553619623184,
0.4850219786167145,
0.25559645891189575,
-0.5272075533866882,
-0.2746978998184204,
-0.4277786910533905,
-0.4241276681423187,
0.26076585054397583,
0.18899314105510712,
0.5354997515678406,
0.8322615027427673,
0.7358325719833374,
0.38325944542884827,
0.167225182056427,
-0.020396284759044647,
0.3089016377925873,
-0.5944746732711792,
-0.27685078978538513,
-0.42082327604293823,
-0.40990573167800903,
-0.10776378214359283,
0.4597238004207611,
0.6992289423942566,
0.8412218689918518,
0.1145104244351387,
0.599166750907898,
-0.02352036163210869,
0.9784753322601318,
-0.4773816764354706,
0.11244069039821625,
-0.6906271576881409,
-0.059967413544654846,
-0.4301527142524719,
-0.010175577364861965,
-0.1252729743719101,
-0.33033546805381775,
-0.07395574450492859,
-0.5287181735038757,
0.3399654030799866,
0.3149608373641968,
0.6529368162155151,
0.17088128626346588,
-0.7705232501029968,
-0.36367252469062805,
-0.29135259985923767,
0.5230175852775574,
-0.318259596824646,
0.3775632083415985,
0.6242201924324036,
0.10453861206769943,
-0.00034786193282343447,
-0.10322519391775131,
-0.19402018189430237,
-0.043390173465013504,
-0.10442536324262619,
-0.07466929405927658,
-0.13304145634174347,
-0.3737047612667084,
0.12244637310504913,
0.16049088537693024,
-0.6167726516723633,
-0.09033288806676865,
-0.8485395908355713,
-0.19219699501991272,
0.7263137698173523,
-0.005999322514981031,
0.279385507106781,
-0.6988122463226318,
-0.2531616687774658,
0.2755933403968811,
-0.46389997005462646,
-0.174781933426857,
0.6792824268341064,
0.6142326593399048,
-0.22581373155117035,
0.7390329241752625,
-0.348417729139328,
0.8473008871078491,
0.15309326350688934,
0.059243131428956985,
0.14269892871379852,
-0.5750467777252197,
0.12942029535770416,
0.00711239455267787,
0.5618589520454407,
0.6181511878967285,
0.4509366452693939,
0.2715294659137726,
0.04963372275233269,
-0.16641384363174438,
0.2967393696308136,
-0.6933611631393433,
0.04426024109125137,
-0.09532201290130615,
-0.6459137201309204,
-0.2849600315093994,
-0.03957685828208923,
-0.8977407813072205,
-0.3942461311817169,
-0.5366817712783813,
-0.09155973792076111,
-0.11275218427181244,
-0.5070099830627441,
-0.00217192224226892,
-0.08015358448028564,
0.11253752559423447,
0.2177281230688095,
-0.6800104975700378,
-0.045309871435165405,
0.6146491765975952,
1.0484933853149414,
-0.2320982813835144,
-0.18948109447956085,
-0.5810030698776245,
-0.04172089695930481,
-0.6267085075378418,
0.9406577944755554,
-0.7871923446655273,
-0.13736124336719513,
0.07381714880466461,
-0.0019999139476567507,
-0.02423216588795185,
-0.4182014465332031,
0.1812416911125183,
-0.7119082808494568,
0.569564163684845,
-0.21201857924461365,
-0.4901890754699707,
0.0463121235370636,
0.48826679587364197,
-0.9708967804908752,
0.9497261047363281,
0.06937579065561295,
-0.865580677986145,
0.5316765308380127,
-0.6386141180992126,
-0.42125600576400757,
-0.11823013424873352,
-0.2335563451051712,
-0.23544181883335114,
0.22344103455543518,
0.7334756255149841,
0.40863606333732605,
-0.10869671404361725,
0.7410264015197754,
-0.3887213170528412,
-0.05272010341286659,
0.09134431928396225,
-0.3980103135108948,
0.8082357048988342,
0.40299609303474426,
-0.23849348723888397,
0.07332662492990494,
-0.9191994667053223,
-0.27142637968063354,
-0.32549259066581726,
-0.48028627038002014,
-0.34058618545532227,
-0.2537596523761749,
0.3884256184101105,
0.28111597895622253,
0.006710200570523739,
-0.47994065284729004,
0.2459660768508911,
-0.20427043735980988,
0.5942514538764954,
0.5123478770256042,
0.07829844951629639,
0.5801569223403931,
-0.25922203063964844,
0.4421910047531128,
-0.21135851740837097,
-0.16886496543884277,
-0.3196353018283844,
-0.5756916403770447,
-0.29630982875823975,
-0.2566935420036316,
0.5081371068954468,
0.37889015674591064,
-0.8889206051826477,
-0.08091497421264648,
-0.276195228099823,
-0.2363528311252594,
-0.7101936340332031,
0.17822571098804474,
0.3063996434211731,
0.0710870549082756,
0.05901336669921875,
-0.3735879361629486,
-0.5379914045333862,
-1.0526710748672485,
-0.4912446439266205,
-0.02136666141450405,
0.004361680243164301,
-0.1805085986852646,
0.5140647292137146,
0.31656280159950256,
1.1286416053771973,
-0.3629569411277771,
-0.3370424509048462,
-0.15805883705615997,
0.38065648078918457,
0.034611113369464874,
0.33675163984298706,
0.46015265583992004,
-1.276922345161438,
-0.36014628410339355,
-0.20862673223018646,
-0.6844342947006226,
-0.2278551459312439,
-0.11367666721343994,
-0.055911775678396225,
0.40113991498947144,
0.5441722869873047,
-0.08017970621585846,
0.3239629864692688,
0.8201173543930054,
-0.2806958556175232,
0.46964314579963684,
-0.0811195969581604,
0.4902664124965668,
-1.3850575685501099,
-0.05350376293063164,
0.27390897274017334,
-0.3354051113128662,
-0.4806941747665405,
-0.032068051397800446,
0.02052251808345318,
-0.7209751009941101,
-0.4407728314399719,
0.622262179851532,
-0.6375676393508911,
-0.16426126658916473,
-0.5388697385787964,
0.3555438220500946,
-0.003922770731151104,
0.32440003752708435,
0.24163192510604858,
0.8082963824272156,
0.18922576308250427,
-0.07233158499002457,
0.2539885342121124,
0.1572498381137848,
-0.7133499383926392,
0.9798031449317932,
-0.22161677479743958,
-0.006555702071636915,
-0.35998496413230896,
0.35357794165611267,
-1.1737873554229736,
-0.637703537940979,
0.15955327451229095,
-0.5310701131820679,
0.06638900190591812,
-0.308192640542984,
-0.3761899471282959,
-0.19593313336372375,
-0.23322807252407074,
0.39194637537002563,
-0.30685657262802124,
-0.4480837881565094,
0.08145148307085037,
0.739712655544281,
-0.4159584045410156,
-0.36665716767311096,
-0.6181976199150085,
0.44462674856185913,
-0.250672847032547,
-0.6986096501350403,
-0.037837523967027664,
0.14743734896183014,
-0.4839419424533844,
0.2275373488664627,
0.08344190567731857,
-0.38329607248306274,
-0.08300107717514038,
-0.09262276440858841,
0.036360349506139755,
-0.33976849913597107,
0.4964604377746582,
-0.06078016012907028,
-0.2904559373855591,
-0.3018503785133362,
-0.26452088356018066,
0.1037808433175087,
-0.16969886422157288,
-0.3606545925140381,
-0.3164989948272705,
0.9012575745582581,
0.5092588663101196,
-0.6131850481033325,
0.7159178256988525,
0.6210225820541382,
-0.2870989143848419,
0.018699482083320618,
-0.7909116148948669,
0.060833610594272614,
-0.3174533247947693,
0.5743878483772278,
-0.28230342268943787,
-0.966377317905426,
0.2145451456308365,
-0.056394170969724655,
-0.08970887213945389,
0.4222716987133026,
0.8057752251625061,
0.26982295513153076,
0.7077592611312866,
0.7840398550033569,
-0.4718370735645294,
0.4427849054336548,
0.06254308670759201,
0.006931542418897152,
-0.41385942697525024,
0.06319571286439896,
-0.43105342984199524,
-0.42042332887649536,
-0.7361500263214111,
-0.6395934820175171,
0.4393363893032074,
-0.09231012314558029,
-0.020683737471699715,
0.3653791844844818,
-0.6801838874816895,
0.5970324277877808,
0.5598160624504089,
-0.29139500856399536,
0.6510409712791443,
0.1372385025024414,
0.5371384620666504,
-0.1846412718296051,
-0.6249682307243347,
-0.6901349425315857,
1.2364546060562134,
-0.04226374626159668,
0.37856525182724,
-0.010631265118718147,
0.41125935316085815,
0.4184887409210205,
0.8123689889907837,
-0.4009742736816406,
0.18118099868297577,
0.03173163905739784,
-1.235444188117981,
-0.456985205411911,
-0.46636247634887695,
-0.7817930579185486,
0.7266526818275452,
-0.28870028257369995,
-0.45851466059684753,
0.26454198360443115,
-0.3388366401195526,
-0.19074955582618713,
0.46325352787971497,
-0.670100748538971,
0.5076701045036316,
-0.15258091688156128,
-0.2844976782798767,
-0.31206032633781433,
-0.5380825996398926,
0.4056950509548187,
-0.3608727753162384,
0.9668710827827454,
-0.42518192529678345,
-0.1784943789243698,
0.8162834048271179,
0.03887099027633667,
0.7774133682250977,
-0.14735744893550873,
-0.13309414684772491,
0.13525672256946564,
-0.28174200654029846,
0.03545728325843811,
0.3648073375225067,
-0.5138230919837952,
0.42415282130241394,
-0.04122556746006012,
-0.5801842212677002,
-0.30139511823654175,
0.41524988412857056,
-0.7017034888267517,
-0.6947770118713379,
-0.16849413514137268,
-0.8691644668579102,
-0.25791797041893005,
0.050699133425951004,
0.15021200478076935,
0.47747406363487244,
-0.2173081934452057,
0.3364582359790802,
0.1308385133743286,
0.1548917293548584,
0.47596484422683716,
0.7614986896514893,
-0.13262252509593964,
-0.7902625799179077,
0.743726372718811,
0.7492536306381226,
-0.06164105609059334,
0.2811504900455475,
0.08163991570472717,
0.07951091974973679,
-0.36247652769088745,
-1.001550555229187,
-0.015009722672402859,
-0.3822493851184845,
-0.18027880787849426,
-0.23459187150001526,
0.16912902891635895,
-0.28615307807922363,
-0.18543817102909088,
-0.5104767084121704,
-0.45710286498069763,
0.10234367102384567,
-0.21531806886196136,
0.29056861996650696,
0.7286778092384338,
-0.29356124997138977,
0.14467714726924896,
-0.7435794472694397,
0.29689115285873413,
0.06224417686462402,
0.5657033324241638,
-0.3865155875682831,
-0.39945220947265625,
-0.4783114790916443,
0.058328039944171906,
-0.2497125118970871,
-1.0338068008422852,
0.41245976090431213,
-0.006635461002588272,
0.3772585093975067,
0.27087393403053284,
0.18766358494758606,
0.6891301870346069,
-0.47647348046302795,
0.7845627665519714,
0.006951562594622374,
-0.8089607954025269,
0.5422764420509338,
-0.6681943535804749,
0.1556016206741333,
0.8065636157989502,
0.6984825134277344,
-0.5522398352622986,
-0.5074982047080994,
-0.4504084885120392,
-0.6519556045532227,
0.7264696955680847,
0.24340872466564178,
0.4750514030456543,
-0.05152919888496399,
0.29471632838249207,
0.24114644527435303,
0.4018952250480652,
-0.716536283493042,
0.1479768455028534,
-0.013654006645083427,
-0.042109180241823196,
-0.2185666561126709,
-0.10315567255020142,
-0.263389527797699,
-0.37949129939079285,
0.5730363130569458,
-0.24774616956710815,
-0.3022010922431946,
0.2681785523891449,
-0.22786568105220795,
-0.20182980597019196,
0.32021117210388184,
0.5676262378692627,
0.9974563121795654,
0.14450789988040924,
-0.05248349905014038,
0.09912609308958054,
-0.10330075025558472,
0.22351565957069397,
0.160849466919899,
-0.001328328507952392,
0.1729380190372467,
0.500823438167572,
0.668555736541748,
0.3383152484893799,
-0.47291311621665955,
0.5364241003990173,
0.1564159095287323,
-0.2846944332122803,
-0.03103037364780903,
-0.5153164863586426,
0.24382920563220978,
0.40658703446388245,
0.6783249378204346,
-0.0470997653901577,
-0.0583060160279274,
-0.6361753344535828,
0.44331711530685425,
0.2455320507287979,
-0.26783427596092224,
-0.15156309306621552,
0.6647068858146667,
0.52791827917099,
-0.44118908047676086,
0.516960859298706,
-0.29343482851982117,
-0.24911020696163177,
0.5269719958305359,
0.23242980241775513,
0.4065122902393341,
-0.09170972555875778,
0.3878518044948578,
0.38054537773132324,
0.5471295714378357,
-0.19255001842975616,
-0.26839321851730347,
-0.05068707838654518,
-0.6757925152778625,
-0.5787708163261414,
-0.46989527344703674,
-0.5063910484313965,
-0.07135087996721268,
-0.9279187917709351,
0.11183245480060577,
-0.0193276759237051,
-0.25213709473609924,
0.05686524510383606,
0.38374829292297363,
-0.46459725499153137,
0.0954778641462326,
0.48572707176208496,
0.8797980546951294,
-1.1388174295425415,
0.5581678748130798,
0.7432608008384705,
-0.21525469422340393,
-0.4972352385520935,
0.05470426753163338,
0.40489688515663147,
-0.8394129872322083,
0.5347390174865723,
0.3555944561958313,
0.238338902592659,
-0.2931937277317047,
-0.5406963229179382,
-1.0755282640457153,
0.5414573550224304,
0.5848919749259949,
-0.5340096950531006,
-0.040306754410266876,
0.2809514105319977,
0.4391915798187256,
-0.6100815534591675,
0.07849109172821045,
0.49683618545532227,
0.6911071538925171,
-0.22400546073913574,
-1.0067721605300903,
-0.1532450020313263,
-0.41467249393463135,
0.15942174196243286,
0.24388261139392853,
-0.9236658215522766,
0.6583349704742432,
-0.026669656857848167,
0.0055388654582202435,
-0.403093159198761,
0.6695756316184998,
-0.04057973250746727,
0.4805453419685364,
0.3905997574329376,
0.19873397052288055,
0.8041122555732727,
0.016711093485355377,
0.919711709022522,
-0.6450737714767456,
0.3493814170360565,
1.1144717931747437,
-0.1084742620587349,
0.756026029586792,
0.34858986735343933,
-0.14527159929275513,
0.24163158237934113,
0.6419862508773804,
-0.29589927196502686,
0.20692670345306396,
0.2687646746635437,
0.15234257280826569,
-0.27443927526474,
-0.16412945091724396,
-0.16485010087490082,
0.7471211552619934,
0.18689027428627014,
-0.19540582597255707,
-0.6465229392051697,
0.7293954491615295,
0.16163335740566254,
0.48014891147613525,
-0.5169621706008911,
0.6527042984962463,
-0.006819949951022863,
-0.7187337279319763,
0.16298730671405792,
0.15787597000598907,
0.7165303230285645,
-0.38087335228919983,
0.1748187392950058,
-0.26127320528030396,
-0.27490293979644775,
-0.3592733144760132,
-0.7274320721626282,
0.8354593515396118,
0.28816935420036316,
-0.4184713065624237,
-0.43962469696998596,
0.5376920104026794,
-0.5473588705062866,
-0.8842264413833618,
0.22227489948272705,
0.8372523188591003,
0.3300996720790863,
-0.2934439778327942,
-0.45242249965667725,
0.3407423794269562,
-0.06120096147060394,
-0.643456757068634,
0.46531441807746887,
0.46072664856910706,
-0.4295514225959778,
0.40590229630470276,
0.5458786487579346,
0.12351525574922562,
0.017019951716065407,
-0.12530280649662018,
0.6786985993385315,
-0.5076660513877869,
-0.33405840396881104,
-0.7534114718437195,
0.3384447991847992,
-0.318771094083786,
-0.4528619945049286,
0.8378252387046814,
0.7703325152397156,
1.133508324623108,
0.0889045000076294,
0.8187239766120911,
0.04385385662317276,
0.36788496375083923,
-0.25703489780426025,
0.789882242679596,
-0.4347122609615326,
-0.1754050999879837,
-0.010214626789093018,
-0.7244788408279419,
-0.2996382713317871,
0.4259868264198303,
-0.6994048357009888,
-0.2806229591369629,
0.29831671714782715,
0.8933544754981995,
0.15863314270973206,
0.34115028381347656,
0.2032448798418045,
-0.10957727581262589,
0.04842729866504669,
0.1879517138004303,
0.546787440776825,
0.014691189862787724,
0.7001644968986511,
-0.02310660108923912,
-0.3735332190990448,
0.0502610020339489,
-0.8290489315986633,
-0.8853506445884705,
-0.7963374853134155,
-0.29254528880119324,
-0.0022546660620719194,
0.1272837519645691,
0.9321717023849487,
1.030397891998291,
-0.6355358958244324,
-0.29431772232055664,
0.43279218673706055,
0.10843315720558167,
-0.06670725345611572,
-0.24857041239738464,
0.4051469564437866,
-0.49745291471481323,
-0.8600875735282898,
0.16955839097499847,
0.19716866314411163,
-0.6898565888404846,
-0.44490307569503784,
0.5878223776817322,
-0.29918062686920166,
0.17248298227787018,
0.5816863179206848,
0.0014833130408078432,
-0.43243539333343506,
-0.3507167398929596,
-0.4610125720500946,
-0.06435798853635788,
0.26434892416000366,
1.0320788621902466,
-0.5342027544975281,
0.6128437519073486,
0.1563907116651535,
0.6677588224411011,
0.5177233219146729,
0.23347114026546478,
0.5415570139884949,
-0.9364476203918457,
0.38585105538368225,
-0.07560420781373978,
0.10339231789112091,
0.7077637910842896,
-0.21640440821647644,
0.609944760799408,
0.2333647757768631,
-0.28322458267211914,
-0.7319061160087585,
0.1961507350206375,
-0.5370733141899109,
-0.45802387595176697,
1.2308975458145142,
0.11544904112815857,
-0.13374829292297363,
-0.3498338460922241,
-0.29741960763931274,
0.2374235838651657,
-0.4629240930080414,
0.8190470337867737,
1.1236395835876465,
0.012686883099377155,
-0.030410556122660637,
-0.8175678849220276,
0.06574370712041855,
0.016464659944176674,
-0.7085937261581421,
0.10697369277477264,
0.4082101881504059,
0.5511349439620972,
0.39577585458755493,
0.938408613204956,
-0.09195777773857117,
0.0007081085932441056,
-0.04789721220731735,
-0.12274032831192017,
-0.30929985642433167,
-0.10193139314651489,
-0.4290122985839844,
0.7771320939064026,
-0.4723847806453705,
-0.12304873764514923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01476v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01476v1
|
TraveLER: A Multi-LMM Agent Framework for Video Question-Answering
| 2024-04-01T20:58:24 | 2024-04-01T20:58:24 |
Chuyi Shang, Amos You, Sanjay Subramanian, Trevor Darrell, Roei Herzig
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recently, Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have made significant progress in
video question-answering using a frame-wise approach by leveraging large-scale,
image-based pretraining in a zero-shot manner. While image-based methods for
videos have shown impressive performance, a current limitation is that they
often overlook how key timestamps are selected and cannot adjust when incorrect
timestamps are identified. Moreover, they are unable to extract details
relevant to the question, instead providing general descriptions of the frame.
To overcome this, we design a multi-LMM agent framework that travels along the
video, iteratively collecting relevant information from keyframes through
interactive question-asking until there is sufficient information to answer the
question. Specifically, we propose TraveLER, a model that can create a plan to
"Traverse" through the video, ask questions about individual frames to "Locate"
and store key information, and then "Evaluate" if there is enough information
to answer the question. Finally, if there is not enough information, our method
is able to "Replan" based on its collected knowledge. Through extensive
experiments, we find that the proposed TraveLER approach improves performance
on several video question-answering benchmarks, such as NExT-QA, STAR, and
Perception Test, without the need to fine-tune on specific datasets.
|
[
-0.7085657715797424,
-0.9530787467956543,
0.8190083503723145,
-0.09554826468229294,
-0.27208104729652405,
0.08965424448251724,
0.14053022861480713,
-0.09897448867559433,
0.40996792912483215,
0.6580784916877747,
-0.9533438086509705,
0.01491535734385252,
-0.5321788191795349,
-0.09443967044353485,
-0.2743905484676361,
0.6727234721183777,
-0.3161771893501282,
-0.2259332239627838,
-0.13151144981384277,
-0.44410789012908936,
-0.4565550684928894,
-0.2618558406829834,
-0.4244729280471802,
0.06120219826698303,
0.7564861178398132,
0.45134082436561584,
0.8193100690841675,
0.4104883074760437,
0.7448102831840515,
0.3516121804714203,
0.16758553683757782,
0.37454402446746826,
-0.2074020355939865,
0.30237913131713867,
-0.3068016469478607,
-0.2990730106830597,
-0.36283448338508606,
-0.270303875207901,
0.7635412216186523,
0.2623860836029053,
-0.06905419379472733,
0.6882335543632507,
-0.6448454260826111,
0.1897648274898529,
-0.8194246888160706,
-0.19660887122154236,
-0.447623074054718,
0.22043657302856445,
0.14369142055511475,
-0.6435791850090027,
-0.15957601368427277,
-0.19818784296512604,
0.24984844028949738,
-0.7523260116577148,
0.2484140396118164,
-0.11458850651979446,
0.7558868527412415,
0.5314274430274963,
-0.5260989665985107,
0.12621794641017914,
-0.916952908039093,
0.24698054790496826,
-0.17060628533363342,
0.3415602445602417,
0.3959023952484131,
0.9159596562385559,
0.35789284110069275,
-0.5777153968811035,
-0.6848033666610718,
0.19803470373153687,
0.42612355947494507,
-0.0014054815983399749,
0.07077533006668091,
0.03786211460828781,
0.16968171298503876,
0.05165928229689598,
-0.9091208577156067,
-0.13953040540218353,
-0.3021153509616852,
-0.315458744764328,
0.3932536840438843,
0.3052045702934265,
0.2475239783525467,
0.09371979534626007,
-0.3476695120334625,
-0.25759321451187134,
-0.32461777329444885,
0.45808595418930054,
0.004258183762431145,
0.021755149587988853,
0.16863533854484558,
0.6497330069541931,
-0.27489516139030457,
0.6885405778884888,
-0.0141294589266181,
-0.22282837331295013,
0.09530916810035706,
-0.31598690152168274,
-0.32965999841690063,
-0.147356316447258,
0.2874657213687897,
0.9361990690231323,
0.31266161799430847,
-0.2209741324186325,
0.0422273688018322,
-0.1751369833946228,
0.31292858719825745,
-1.3328806161880493,
-0.006016711238771677,
0.3770114779472351,
-0.25569501519203186,
0.2189699113368988,
0.13313935697078705,
-0.8454491496086121,
-0.3584228456020355,
-0.035968631505966187,
0.8413194417953491,
-0.13001962006092072,
-0.622289776802063,
0.1022956520318985,
-0.3837071657180786,
0.8647476434707642,
0.625113844871521,
-0.5305163860321045,
-0.16184020042419434,
0.1405031830072403,
0.6610370874404907,
0.21949701011180878,
-0.548774242401123,
-1.1477231979370117,
0.3482101559638977,
-0.3264957368373871,
1.0372624397277832,
-0.5982460975646973,
-0.2057524472475052,
0.25973984599113464,
0.39100557565689087,
-0.1627711057662964,
-0.2484683394432068,
-0.14703449606895447,
-1.1065489053726196,
-0.00895936880260706,
-0.5077909827232361,
-0.27021706104278564,
-0.48435407876968384,
1.002558708190918,
-0.7435905933380127,
0.45830315351486206,
-0.027718625962734222,
-0.5003232359886169,
0.09351181238889694,
-0.5203676223754883,
-0.04968692734837532,
-0.18770870566368103,
-0.10315080732107162,
-0.29484397172927856,
-0.18204781413078308,
0.5903504490852356,
0.23345132172107697,
-0.13492025434970856,
0.28243690729141235,
-0.4026849567890167,
-0.3881697356700897,
0.4966331422328949,
-0.42127305269241333,
0.21715107560157776,
0.21280401945114136,
0.25220513343811035,
0.08453962951898575,
-0.5296860337257385,
0.29591983556747437,
-0.037140198051929474,
-0.21333445608615875,
0.21884115040302277,
-0.40715348720550537,
-0.19231705367565155,
0.27669721841812134,
-0.017543524503707886,
-0.4254492521286011,
0.25382810831069946,
0.17439663410186768,
0.3553909659385681,
0.8917350172996521,
0.3925858736038208,
0.639345109462738,
-0.44575056433677673,
1.1797637939453125,
0.1149572879076004,
0.3859557509422302,
-0.7869814038276672,
-0.2902175188064575,
-0.5615105628967285,
0.21807517111301422,
-0.20687530934810638,
0.4480840563774109,
-1.125558853149414,
-0.42454594373703003,
-0.3050919771194458,
-0.35919153690338135,
-0.6565993428230286,
0.11706698685884476,
0.2022974193096161,
0.42679673433303833,
0.45904916524887085,
-0.21404506266117096,
-0.25164082646369934,
-0.511183500289917,
0.12152455747127533,
-0.3411064147949219,
0.10684432089328766,
0.25543349981307983,
0.6213899254798889,
-0.09936180710792542,
0.8787120580673218,
-0.8841142058372498,
-0.21739841997623444,
-0.18659287691116333,
-0.08961381763219833,
-0.13540968298912048,
0.10178392380475998,
0.44248154759407043,
-1.0171611309051514,
-0.2265922576189041,
-0.2883545458316803,
-0.843597948551178,
0.529028594493866,
-0.24165648221969604,
-0.21788237988948822,
-0.3933367431163788,
0.6848029494285583,
-0.7405157089233398,
0.14349979162216187,
0.2627219557762146,
-0.2744058668613434,
0.44433119893074036,
-0.48929283022880554,
0.34739047288894653,
-0.9901753664016724,
0.05437997728586197,
-0.3541649281978607,
-0.2909334897994995,
-0.5496969819068909,
0.4677480459213257,
-0.17877352237701416,
-0.4937833845615387,
-0.763642430305481,
0.5361348986625671,
-0.18046846985816956,
-0.26688235998153687,
-0.2263401597738266,
0.2872190475463867,
0.2473738193511963,
0.8912179470062256,
0.21304267644882202,
0.871555507183075,
0.7203505039215088,
-0.6956909894943237,
0.5835962891578674,
0.28682997822761536,
-0.22765527665615082,
0.9086499214172363,
-0.422488808631897,
0.4612979590892792,
-0.8498716354370117,
0.1545545607805252,
-1.0527894496917725,
-0.2983057498931885,
0.07975078374147415,
-0.5935348868370056,
0.0724412202835083,
-0.3233194053173065,
-0.16976381838321686,
-0.1794934719800949,
-0.1863439530134201,
0.6591951251029968,
0.02756618708372116,
-0.2819848954677582,
0.9365319013595581,
0.36863628029823303,
0.019973471760749817,
-0.6097874641418457,
-0.39610689878463745,
0.25915586948394775,
-0.47992298007011414,
-0.7945685386657715,
0.017664138227701187,
-0.4785846471786499,
0.06337226927280426,
0.02918860875070095,
-0.2990259826183319,
-0.5115129351615906,
0.027900079265236855,
0.043726205825805664,
0.17084994912147522,
-0.2630963623523712,
0.4032101631164551,
-0.3790470063686371,
-0.08334729075431824,
0.03264278918504715,
-0.27006906270980835,
0.29430335760116577,
-0.15762490034103394,
-0.1430194228887558,
-0.1905410885810852,
0.7911523580551147,
0.5976989269256592,
-0.7268855571746826,
0.3286367654800415,
0.8400291204452515,
-0.10541293025016785,
-0.07232382893562317,
-0.5727680921554565,
-0.11455147713422775,
-0.46193253993988037,
0.5228921175003052,
-0.7159398198127747,
-0.784328281879425,
0.5875979661941528,
0.03521092236042023,
-0.07809697836637497,
-0.12669123709201813,
0.4203810691833496,
-0.4494570195674896,
0.7465800046920776,
0.6940255165100098,
0.1948004961013794,
0.5491133332252502,
-0.579484224319458,
-0.1443319320678711,
-0.5713939666748047,
-0.3010421395301819,
-0.33126401901245117,
-0.1998755782842636,
-0.24077989161014557,
-0.733122706413269,
0.7407858371734619,
-0.22141043841838837,
-0.5905044674873352,
0.23775814473628998,
-0.06897453963756561,
0.6993694305419922,
0.3697894811630249,
0.02879522182047367,
0.36391526460647583,
-0.301116019487381,
0.06641369313001633,
0.42089012265205383,
-0.5955601930618286,
-0.21402907371520996,
0.9436641335487366,
0.12845610082149506,
0.8493350148200989,
0.44273990392684937,
0.2121344655752182,
0.25971269607543945,
0.004675388336181641,
-0.4820348620414734,
0.8152567744255066,
0.37355509400367737,
-0.9674645662307739,
-0.4275210201740265,
-0.14721223711967468,
-0.7257842421531677,
0.4591163694858551,
-0.048989053815603256,
-0.5141464471817017,
0.04806993529200554,
0.14271296560764313,
-0.8934440016746521,
0.5223559737205505,
-0.6147460341453552,
1.0204756259918213,
-0.3415304124355316,
-0.5481230616569519,
-0.0909021645784378,
-1.0304003953933716,
0.2075311243534088,
0.07591265439987183,
0.19917945563793182,
-0.041057415306568146,
-0.035844992846250534,
0.4509505033493042,
-0.45095598697662354,
0.38932928442955017,
-0.3821742534637451,
0.08209468424320221,
0.6431553959846497,
0.3106170892715454,
0.22931253910064697,
0.19081749022006989,
0.3261339068412781,
-0.4110865294933319,
0.4130583703517914,
-0.2380492240190506,
-0.9101983904838562,
0.13517987728118896,
-0.7538172602653503,
-0.6764066815376282,
-0.2744649648666382,
-0.4389905631542206,
-0.15526825189590454,
0.16155719757080078,
0.07601477950811386,
0.5272817015647888,
-0.004775181878358126,
0.057439327239990234,
0.700929582118988,
-0.3454204499721527,
0.6996161937713623,
0.6848160624504089,
-0.4503202736377716,
-0.50896817445755,
0.8545618057250977,
0.11399561166763306,
0.26551395654678345,
0.7317887544631958,
-0.15538202226161957,
-0.4740389287471771,
-0.31221041083335876,
-0.9189956784248352,
0.06686121225357056,
-0.8089861273765564,
-0.15280196070671082,
-0.3923056721687317,
-0.18208768963813782,
-0.16799408197402954,
-0.010892224498093128,
-0.4646547734737396,
-0.2092706710100174,
0.00565334502607584,
-0.4808655381202698,
0.15550962090492249,
0.00969059206545353,
0.24488358199596405,
0.6140879988670349,
-0.8516951203346252,
0.5840110778808594,
0.8691493272781372,
0.305645227432251,
-0.1283930391073227,
-0.5558610558509827,
-0.36949416995048523,
-0.11216073483228683,
-0.6077733635902405,
-0.9282021522521973,
0.07649577409029007,
0.15466099977493286,
0.5112550258636475,
0.6891903877258301,
0.08022204786539078,
1.206869125366211,
-0.4627576768398285,
0.7453691363334656,
0.11310199648141861,
-0.35445037484169006,
0.5061037540435791,
-0.3216352164745331,
0.4367302358150482,
0.7364509701728821,
0.18052873015403748,
-0.6920372247695923,
-0.19568124413490295,
-0.3342195451259613,
-0.38045239448547363,
0.4223077893257141,
0.03734106943011284,
0.1920342594385147,
0.35661056637763977,
0.1683073192834854,
-0.1689608097076416,
0.3943106532096863,
-0.6197454929351807,
0.1022074967622757,
-0.40307220816612244,
0.49301162362098694,
-0.3405761420726776,
0.053089868277311325,
-0.041468821465969086,
-0.056814003735780716,
0.28789854049682617,
-0.38979673385620117,
0.2514876425266266,
0.6028209328651428,
-0.5738617777824402,
-0.2885797619819641,
0.3016032576560974,
0.5060603618621826,
0.7912585735321045,
-0.7721830010414124,
0.4003049433231354,
0.07049733400344849,
-0.22565066814422607,
0.5992605090141296,
-0.03687799349427223,
-0.31486430764198303,
-0.044338032603263855,
0.3682013750076294,
0.7774472236633301,
-0.38641607761383057,
-0.9855475425720215,
0.6137811541557312,
0.0174546018242836,
-0.2127164900302887,
-0.6581202745437622,
0.02047177031636238,
-0.09287915378808975,
0.6217508316040039,
0.1617528647184372,
0.010099422186613083,
-0.07928308844566345,
-0.718073308467865,
0.2193547636270523,
0.454670786857605,
-0.36911553144454956,
-0.3411034047603607,
0.9327898621559143,
0.22428038716316223,
-0.5422956347465515,
0.6203731298446655,
-0.14299173653125763,
-0.30928218364715576,
0.7706957459449768,
-0.1249854788184166,
0.8152506351470947,
-0.22748418152332306,
0.7024062275886536,
0.43920236825942993,
0.4653843641281128,
-0.09345345944166183,
0.34043222665786743,
-0.48818933963775635,
-0.8347955942153931,
-0.563936710357666,
-0.11555253714323044,
-0.5342978239059448,
-0.08595049381256104,
-0.5969864726066589,
0.1406054049730301,
-0.18184055387973785,
-0.33587202429771423,
-0.21867437660694122,
-0.18672220408916473,
-0.9127749800682068,
0.21794824302196503,
0.24523207545280457,
0.7976769208908081,
-0.5637884140014648,
0.7441795468330383,
0.5952617526054382,
-0.8664580583572388,
-0.7561917901039124,
-0.06971223652362823,
-0.2253742665052414,
-0.7802212238311768,
0.13173562288284302,
0.46765822172164917,
-0.19336505234241486,
-0.04933559149503708,
-0.3675735294818878,
-0.7867559194564819,
1.343959093093872,
0.3283241391181946,
-0.15568234026432037,
-0.5620193481445312,
0.20295652747154236,
0.32708296179771423,
-0.30210137367248535,
0.6947377920150757,
0.3113398551940918,
0.3965422511100769,
0.5766282677650452,
-0.7451180219650269,
-0.30035528540611267,
-0.23470427095890045,
-0.19048883020877838,
-0.031382005661726,
-0.8097564578056335,
0.7463635802268982,
-0.7605721354484558,
0.026243967935442924,
0.12421365827322006,
0.30254513025283813,
0.04865838587284088,
0.6021628379821777,
0.7279179692268372,
0.37892916798591614,
0.6835121512413025,
0.3299941122531891,
0.7456626892089844,
0.054233502596616745,
0.0677054226398468,
1.3044480085372925,
-0.2394508421421051,
0.6665542721748352,
0.7134194374084473,
0.025362662971019745,
0.45144373178482056,
0.7055011987686157,
0.06498195976018906,
0.6420466899871826,
0.09622655808925629,
-0.17100828886032104,
-0.8981045484542847,
-0.05281025916337967,
-0.27954229712486267,
0.7092649340629578,
-0.23307517170906067,
-0.0949406549334526,
-0.6722439527511597,
0.37403905391693115,
-0.2770957946777344,
-0.15035134553909302,
-0.5959876775741577,
0.6999415755271912,
-0.19322620332241058,
-1.1273829936981201,
0.39236608147621155,
-0.06949042528867722,
-0.04979212209582329,
-0.8255860805511475,
0.04620252177119255,
-0.5920672416687012,
0.08000160753726959,
0.20166495442390442,
-0.7445449829101562,
0.15107771754264832,
0.1638052612543106,
-0.021611860021948814,
-0.38510042428970337,
0.32620134949684143,
-0.5378106832504272,
-0.37653201818466187,
-0.0026057460345327854,
0.787967324256897,
0.3214312791824341,
-0.3596649467945099,
-0.28378230333328247,
-0.13048289716243744,
-0.23354949057102203,
-0.21660952270030975,
0.25007808208465576,
0.3716069757938385,
-0.05730582773685455,
1.1277990341186523,
0.30081790685653687,
-0.22819334268569946,
0.04555291682481766,
-0.10713373869657516,
0.8838018178939819,
-0.7968828082084656,
-0.6620967984199524,
-0.7770014405250549,
0.7197937965393066,
0.13168641924858093,
-0.1453728973865509,
0.424267053604126,
0.46236374974250793,
0.6097244024276733,
-0.07607916742563248,
0.5520843267440796,
0.24876663088798523,
0.20135842263698578,
-0.6047618985176086,
0.12087266892194748,
-0.7736384272575378,
0.22377021610736847,
-0.29663512110710144,
-0.816875159740448,
-0.06347687542438507,
0.4880600869655609,
0.06758663803339005,
-0.22790339589118958,
0.48880648612976074,
1.1295640468597412,
-0.045317307114601135,
-0.11232352256774902,
0.27770981192588806,
-0.11194019019603729,
0.7033900022506714,
0.9948756694793701,
1.2095592021942139,
-0.374908983707428,
1.2001032829284668,
0.04704169183969498,
0.19832079112529755,
-0.11353637278079987,
-0.7760298848152161,
-0.7814640402793884,
-0.6656023859977722,
-0.35858726501464844,
-0.24781696498394012,
-0.06200132891535759,
0.7330056428909302,
0.812667965888977,
-0.03403547778725624,
-0.25654685497283936,
0.4406730532646179,
0.2627592384815216,
-0.3419390022754669,
-0.10595870763063431,
0.36271482706069946,
0.13234774768352509,
-0.41888031363487244,
0.25589048862457275,
0.18105308711528778,
-0.006133891176432371,
-0.5588266849517822,
-0.03423511981964111,
-0.14291134476661682,
0.15661010146141052,
0.5075641870498657,
0.3602754771709442,
-0.2394368052482605,
-0.45277678966522217,
0.55746990442276,
0.38685673475265503,
0.17435957491397858,
0.9967992305755615,
-0.6879382133483887,
0.8718132376670837,
0.299957275390625,
0.7912276387214661,
1.0392102003097534,
0.22073349356651306,
0.3086779713630676,
-0.454145222902298,
0.1668161004781723,
0.040943246334791183,
0.18414795398712158,
0.1562540978193283,
0.05837481468915939,
0.32270193099975586,
0.08448919653892517,
-0.6437024474143982,
-0.7738118171691895,
0.4141083359718323,
-1.227925181388855,
-0.46055296063423157,
1.1572766304016113,
-0.08445296436548233,
-0.12303028255701065,
-0.048744600266218185,
-0.2958229184150696,
-0.05020105838775635,
-0.17202337086200714,
0.5473837852478027,
0.6798559427261353,
-0.05314585566520691,
-0.6281184554100037,
-0.7824631333351135,
0.11302384734153748,
0.07870885729789734,
-0.5850059986114502,
-0.14596207439899445,
0.49048981070518494,
0.5155928134918213,
0.009131129831075668,
1.2371960878372192,
0.27166885137557983,
0.44374310970306396,
-0.23272667825222015,
-0.26122063398361206,
-0.3859049081802368,
-0.6742913722991943,
-0.27919068932533264,
0.6580950021743774,
-0.04558186233043671,
-0.7155112624168396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01474v1
|
Finding Replicable Human Evaluations via Stable Ranking Probability
| 2024-04-01T20:50:13 | 2024-04-01T20:50:13 |
Parker Riley, Daniel Deutsch, George Foster, Viresh Ratnakar, Ali Dabirmoghaddam, Markus Freitag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reliable human evaluation is critical to the development of successful
natural language generation models, but achieving it is notoriously difficult.
Stability is a crucial requirement when ranking systems by quality: consistent
ranking of systems across repeated evaluations is not just desirable, but
essential. Without it, there is no reliable foundation for hill-climbing or
product launch decisions. In this paper, we use machine translation and its
state-of-the-art human evaluation framework, MQM, as a case study to understand
how to set up reliable human evaluations that yield stable conclusions. We
investigate the optimal configurations for item allocation to raters, number of
ratings per item, and score normalization. Our study on two language pairs
provides concrete recommendations for designing replicable human evaluation
studies. We also collect and release the largest publicly available dataset of
multi-segment translations rated by multiple professional translators,
consisting of nearly 140,000 segment annotations across two language pairs.
|
[
-0.2805253267288208,
-0.3063226640224457,
0.2987927198410034,
0.5904396772384644,
-0.22776608169078827,
0.34832483530044556,
-0.30994313955307007,
-0.35079747438430786,
-0.2605867385864258,
0.33692699670791626,
-0.13724274933338165,
-0.21352462470531464,
-0.5456175208091736,
0.2734161913394928,
-0.37970784306526184,
1.0454044342041016,
0.04199115186929703,
0.17739708721637726,
-0.24588996171951294,
-0.5182543992996216,
-0.4516274333000183,
-0.8027467727661133,
-0.6567630767822266,
-0.4916110336780548,
0.30474725365638733,
0.3983258008956909,
1.2560430765151978,
0.6546792387962341,
0.5235554575920105,
0.3143438696861267,
0.09444960951805115,
0.18403451144695282,
-0.6135072708129883,
0.2640039324760437,
-0.16189277172088623,
-0.14329564571380615,
-0.38922086358070374,
0.2562708556652069,
0.9282100796699524,
0.7586134672164917,
-0.3366624712944031,
0.16105423867702484,
0.23489807546138763,
0.7689797878265381,
-0.5072352886199951,
-0.18956361711025238,
-0.5211878418922424,
-0.017062488943338394,
-0.04239574819803238,
-0.07433560490608215,
-0.5198605060577393,
-0.687068521976471,
0.2464989870786667,
-0.2573966681957245,
-0.026247579604387283,
0.06370900571346283,
0.9032270312309265,
0.0035031221341341734,
-0.3914450407028198,
0.028107941150665283,
-0.7973695993423462,
1.0744460821151733,
-0.3885105550289154,
0.49117061495780945,
0.4858090579509735,
0.47435155510902405,
-0.41911593079566956,
-0.4104166626930237,
-0.42831069231033325,
-0.43331849575042725,
0.038745440542697906,
-0.011993613094091415,
-0.10058183968067169,
-0.24835103750228882,
-0.1068815365433693,
0.2601240277290344,
-0.3630191683769226,
0.047372836619615555,
-0.10123680531978607,
-0.28544577956199646,
0.7489301562309265,
0.30936548113822937,
0.34553611278533936,
-0.45448192954063416,
-0.5423570871353149,
-0.25844016671180725,
-0.3262474238872528,
0.1498384326696396,
0.41771477460861206,
0.10430778563022614,
0.27860596776008606,
0.6905863881111145,
-0.38502588868141174,
0.6064347624778748,
0.16162918508052826,
-0.1678030788898468,
0.5121245980262756,
-0.7788291573524475,
-0.0327126607298851,
-0.137581467628479,
0.946220874786377,
0.7602347731590271,
0.16437044739723206,
-0.31135237216949463,
-0.5285341739654541,
0.002102944301441312,
0.797484815120697,
-0.6113979816436768,
-0.08520067483186722,
0.1605144888162613,
-0.6150520443916321,
-0.5989184975624084,
0.3041935861110687,
-0.5809968113899231,
-0.28703561425209045,
-0.21672649681568146,
0.5780802369117737,
-0.24814894795417786,
-0.11419837921857834,
0.11181515455245972,
-0.115212082862854,
-0.04773006960749626,
0.06952574849128723,
-0.8241787552833557,
0.15585161745548248,
0.6240115761756897,
0.5933005213737488,
-0.3263935148715973,
-0.46652716398239136,
-0.47052204608917236,
0.0048898025415837765,
-0.5437038540840149,
0.5273106098175049,
-0.19312535226345062,
-0.26991236209869385,
-0.05262384191155434,
0.05821552127599716,
0.02112441696226597,
-0.6382571458816528,
1.1068065166473389,
-0.41809290647506714,
0.3683265447616577,
-0.009205490350723267,
-0.3320465087890625,
0.1144578754901886,
0.4707432985305786,
-0.4688299000263214,
0.9090158939361572,
0.2657773196697235,
-0.5856024622917175,
0.5309476256370544,
-0.43105465173721313,
-0.49232953786849976,
-0.02205755189061165,
0.057874783873558044,
-0.7421953082084656,
0.16967317461967468,
0.03697613254189491,
0.2584914267063141,
-0.09612145274877548,
0.26672250032424927,
-0.13591280579566956,
-0.2858147621154785,
0.43996986746788025,
-0.3658071458339691,
0.551737904548645,
0.4028465449810028,
-0.3701465427875519,
0.2634739577770233,
-0.5301245450973511,
0.21085099875926971,
-0.08755004405975342,
-0.8289689421653748,
-0.09613773226737976,
0.2583716809749603,
0.14123070240020752,
0.3784501552581787,
0.12484242022037506,
-0.36679109930992126,
0.17071126401424408,
-0.1948009878396988,
0.48442572355270386,
0.5728601813316345,
0.1433665156364441,
0.5055052638053894,
-0.6983302235603333,
0.6277832388877869,
-0.20707347989082336,
0.2739447057247162,
0.04927965998649597,
-0.6452295184135437,
-0.6483387351036072,
0.13363024592399597,
0.3788936734199524,
0.5091635584831238,
-0.5823302268981934,
0.6286187767982483,
-0.45065250992774963,
-0.5865170955657959,
-0.9327068328857422,
0.23532095551490784,
0.5555927157402039,
0.40037801861763,
0.26672670245170593,
-0.3089205324649811,
-0.360338419675827,
-1.0672883987426758,
-0.4016565978527069,
-0.21611015498638153,
-0.24187344312667847,
-0.022657807916402817,
0.09783703833818436,
-0.5771375298500061,
0.8215972781181335,
-0.1312728375196457,
-0.17866092920303345,
-0.2937554121017456,
0.22538147866725922,
0.13531848788261414,
0.6239557862281799,
0.4756056070327759,
-0.6044611930847168,
-0.20673641562461853,
-0.1146642193198204,
-0.5755327939987183,
-0.0029401250649243593,
-0.2613036632537842,
-0.6708014011383057,
0.14731618762016296,
-0.053069546818733215,
-0.41169771552085876,
0.08650163561105728,
0.6112977862358093,
-0.09259886294603348,
0.6511878967285156,
-0.2664988934993744,
0.6113801002502441,
-1.183843970298767,
0.12203791737556458,
0.017020821571350098,
-0.4959664046764374,
-0.3436388671398163,
-0.0024333554320037365,
-0.10112475603818893,
-0.05975472927093506,
-0.26187947392463684,
0.4519554376602173,
-0.2423270046710968,
0.05628417804837227,
-0.16857273876667023,
0.40858519077301025,
0.09863770753145218,
-0.02618776634335518,
-0.4039572477340698,
0.5873869061470032,
0.018560035154223442,
-0.509411096572876,
0.08580699563026428,
0.42477768659591675,
-0.674385666847229,
0.7584924101829529,
-0.6152378916740417,
0.19996269047260284,
0.17106880247592926,
0.10460817813873291,
-0.7842509150505066,
-0.24799291789531708,
0.35777127742767334,
-0.5713384747505188,
0.14018844068050385,
-0.18276768922805786,
-0.613381028175354,
-0.28399422764778137,
-0.41267991065979004,
0.18354091048240662,
0.5659816861152649,
-0.3279159665107727,
-0.0699833333492279,
0.8261363506317139,
-0.0749901607632637,
-0.5519129037857056,
-0.2658197581768036,
0.22791241109371185,
-0.06901386380195618,
-0.905135452747345,
0.20926795899868011,
-0.08660174161195755,
-0.21044184267520905,
-0.11647150665521622,
-0.20394012331962585,
0.15177232027053833,
0.49966126680374146,
0.3104700446128845,
0.10650543868541718,
0.02835269644856453,
0.08044226467609406,
-0.06648705154657364,
-0.43602651357650757,
-0.06272383034229279,
-0.33341184258461,
0.2649186849594116,
-0.2748812437057495,
-0.11494674533605576,
-0.4550437033176422,
0.24269217252731323,
0.6577101945877075,
-0.05102451890707016,
0.6428893208503723,
0.5594809055328369,
-0.6230158805847168,
0.01222184393554926,
-0.457870215177536,
0.06797385960817337,
-0.37826135754585266,
0.4112297296524048,
-0.46654316782951355,
-0.6755296587944031,
0.16660629212856293,
0.11844204366207123,
0.26916757225990295,
0.5400488376617432,
0.8343219757080078,
-0.3496144711971283,
1.5251798629760742,
0.37637704610824585,
-0.21931713819503784,
0.4452441334724426,
0.028874596580863,
0.00932447798550129,
-0.7278560996055603,
-0.1350989043712616,
-0.5746984481811523,
-0.4947474002838135,
-0.5201593041419983,
-0.3518766462802887,
0.2805607318878174,
0.5410756468772888,
0.03784957900643349,
0.21536482870578766,
-0.5064481496810913,
0.3991672396659851,
0.5401674509048462,
-0.04381189122796059,
0.3894142806529999,
0.21172304451465607,
-0.416064977645874,
-0.08201514929533005,
-0.4662359952926636,
-1.1089907884597778,
0.8969259858131409,
0.3489748537540436,
0.5052797198295593,
0.1336992383003235,
0.5697316527366638,
0.43718627095222473,
0.5226441621780396,
-0.6550690531730652,
0.20147913694381714,
-0.2837444245815277,
-0.5889820456504822,
-0.541923463344574,
-0.6178237795829773,
-1.2745699882507324,
0.37116891145706177,
-0.6038100123405457,
-0.509935200214386,
-0.13908252120018005,
0.08097625523805618,
-0.2009783685207367,
-0.09378274530172348,
-0.5320618748664856,
1.0093631744384766,
-0.5715667009353638,
-0.2970592677593231,
-0.43208035826683044,
-0.7874214053153992,
0.32703402638435364,
-0.1406582146883011,
0.32295385003089905,
-0.3245195746421814,
0.29438504576683044,
0.7145618796348572,
-0.430820494890213,
-0.0011549568735063076,
0.012906190939247608,
0.23477067053318024,
0.10720991343259811,
0.20524084568023682,
0.053796786814928055,
0.24887718260288239,
-0.5802744626998901,
-0.07073179632425308,
0.06403139978647232,
-0.6123226881027222,
-0.5708460211753845,
0.7011623978614807,
-1.0509657859802246,
-0.40986788272857666,
-0.31210029125213623,
-0.18397219479084015,
-0.0866193026304245,
0.4036526381969452,
0.3387380838394165,
0.19361481070518494,
-0.33398669958114624,
0.34131133556365967,
0.10365733504295349,
0.045949745923280716,
0.0514039471745491,
0.1746775507926941,
-0.3888951539993286,
-0.897962749004364,
0.915494978427887,
0.09377323091030121,
0.28994885087013245,
0.13958148658275604,
0.28251442313194275,
-0.3088480830192566,
-0.5815991759300232,
-0.9161185622215271,
-0.09195276349782944,
-0.46185967326164246,
-0.033566709607839584,
-0.4891103506088257,
-0.02080187387764454,
0.1260034739971161,
-0.18232400715351105,
-0.4246615171432495,
-0.5450773239135742,
0.11629413068294525,
-0.2037743479013443,
-0.26844605803489685,
0.7502902150154114,
0.045995939522981644,
0.13430911302566528,
-0.9415072798728943,
0.4014096260070801,
0.17048479616641998,
0.360434889793396,
-0.12257823348045349,
-0.3145800232887268,
-0.5660703182220459,
0.3423713445663452,
-0.49938851594924927,
-0.6030541658401489,
0.10875365883111954,
0.09917429834604263,
0.9080290794372559,
0.402639240026474,
0.18615394830703735,
0.4735170900821686,
-0.24279780685901642,
0.6949057579040527,
0.10255546867847443,
-0.870401918888092,
0.36608123779296875,
-0.2916387617588043,
0.2518021762371063,
1.0089457035064697,
0.25306156277656555,
-0.7908657789230347,
-0.4336329698562622,
-0.39049291610717773,
-0.9266895055770874,
0.5330365300178528,
0.3860394358634949,
0.16418609023094177,
-0.17992401123046875,
0.32344889640808105,
0.23306238651275635,
0.4236476719379425,
-0.47194674611091614,
-0.13697628676891327,
-0.24363583326339722,
-0.17247167229652405,
-0.32025665044784546,
-0.2734992504119873,
-0.1770412027835846,
-0.06754819303750992,
0.7071927189826965,
0.19376401603221893,
-0.06451863050460815,
-0.05546432361006737,
-0.34001705050468445,
-0.2358299344778061,
0.3791429102420807,
0.6089985966682434,
0.8284112215042114,
-0.38949811458587646,
0.21069182455539703,
-0.32092732191085815,
-0.3049777150154114,
0.5773321986198425,
-0.09788769483566284,
-0.44328421354293823,
0.04551799222826958,
0.0384083092212677,
0.4871045649051666,
0.4540970027446747,
-0.5090723633766174,
0.45986512303352356,
-0.19361060857772827,
0.09662678837776184,
-0.16124889254570007,
-0.14948828518390656,
0.1369428038597107,
-0.14086072146892548,
0.37476417422294617,
0.36452776193618774,
0.012542923912405968,
-0.5163556933403015,
0.5938097238540649,
0.29765260219573975,
-0.6012647151947021,
-0.34746885299682617,
0.7131778597831726,
0.5335047245025635,
-0.6056678891181946,
1.1346855163574219,
-0.482556015253067,
-0.7169918417930603,
0.17635171115398407,
0.3116231858730316,
1.0418884754180908,
-0.1606331616640091,
0.47703710198402405,
0.29720571637153625,
0.5178542137145996,
-0.610431432723999,
0.2724296450614929,
0.21343253552913666,
-0.8101154565811157,
-0.0759367123246193,
-0.810876727104187,
-0.6484172344207764,
-0.5052098035812378,
-0.5697810053825378,
0.339990496635437,
-0.23638559877872467,
-0.7923851013183594,
-0.16747549176216125,
-0.005371885374188423,
-0.5003960728645325,
0.05561487004160881,
0.028997743502259254,
0.4841732084751129,
-0.7055968642234802,
0.6675012707710266,
0.8040014505386353,
-0.4976354241371155,
-0.48757562041282654,
-0.10302174836397171,
-0.09966854751110077,
-0.3598025143146515,
0.1921556442975998,
0.1638018637895584,
-0.2706606388092041,
-0.11397643387317657,
-0.158131942152977,
-0.6209968328475952,
0.9165036082267761,
0.45641645789146423,
-0.3697432577610016,
0.33930280804634094,
-0.06485278904438019,
0.6504783630371094,
-0.4580838680267334,
0.14150942862033844,
0.5303888916969299,
0.5442720651626587,
-0.25939175486564636,
-1.0232104063034058,
-0.02172006107866764,
-0.2170279622077942,
-0.0312834270298481,
0.30818992853164673,
-0.6421287059783936,
0.44589492678642273,
-0.3137541711330414,
-0.29725906252861023,
0.44189754128456116,
0.293530136346817,
0.6602572798728943,
0.4065161645412445,
0.5875118374824524,
0.5929145216941833,
0.7919713854789734,
-0.051334742456674576,
1.101882815361023,
-0.4269503653049469,
0.42219433188438416,
1.04129958152771,
0.018330497667193413,
1.1419581174850464,
0.315803200006485,
-0.2553146183490753,
0.4903661608695984,
0.8280003666877747,
-0.09587482362985611,
0.2142256200313568,
0.5668879151344299,
-0.06570013612508774,
-0.46414268016815186,
-0.09234828501939774,
-0.22444799542427063,
0.28448134660720825,
-0.13437819480895996,
-0.5409792065620422,
0.1478329598903656,
-0.3031153082847595,
0.009496320970356464,
0.10739421099424362,
0.04300543665885925,
0.5556277632713318,
0.11259149014949799,
-0.7541889548301697,
0.7163708209991455,
0.29302626848220825,
0.42275750637054443,
-0.24827931821346283,
0.08240921050310135,
-0.14527486264705658,
0.11797215789556503,
-0.4320652186870575,
-0.6887519955635071,
0.17042545974254608,
-0.21961399912834167,
-0.5196400880813599,
-0.35846248269081116,
0.3453388512134552,
-0.30378711223602295,
-0.7386945486068726,
0.10746528208255768,
0.6647363901138306,
0.337274968624115,
0.08174439519643784,
-0.5675530433654785,
0.052457284182310104,
-0.05204382166266441,
-0.2521181106567383,
0.454474538564682,
0.21833394467830658,
-0.31330758333206177,
0.8276428580284119,
0.7966258525848389,
-0.0632571280002594,
0.30858755111694336,
0.16233472526073456,
0.28943127393722534,
-0.6477370858192444,
-0.26626327633857727,
-0.7929946184158325,
0.7245851755142212,
-0.04321600869297981,
-0.49315395951271057,
0.7609953880310059,
0.7115863561630249,
0.7135482430458069,
0.001515352283604443,
0.8063696622848511,
0.36792266368865967,
0.23522122204303741,
-0.15200449526309967,
0.9843429923057556,
-0.27537864446640015,
0.22762376070022583,
-0.5182833075523376,
-1.3256770372390747,
-0.3879634439945221,
0.6587626934051514,
0.22182577848434448,
-0.06002076342701912,
0.4166274964809418,
0.3465555012226105,
0.26909416913986206,
-0.39169585704803467,
0.23637984693050385,
0.0898447185754776,
0.40780043601989746,
0.3203367590904236,
1.1134326457977295,
-0.446880042552948,
0.7992992997169495,
-0.15081627666950226,
-0.2420486956834793,
-0.3937903940677643,
-0.9333629012107849,
-0.3364969789981842,
-0.2803301215171814,
-0.4373011291027069,
-0.4972259998321533,
0.02867630496621132,
1.0311990976333618,
0.8151298761367798,
-0.7290645837783813,
-0.5754573345184326,
0.39894601702690125,
0.5117824673652649,
-0.3651540279388428,
-0.21425482630729675,
0.12373824417591095,
-0.36727961897850037,
-0.7415068745613098,
0.29926547408103943,
0.40443238615989685,
-0.152118518948555,
-0.4505227208137512,
-0.37934398651123047,
0.04584662243723869,
-0.13864432275295258,
0.5981850028038025,
0.053697481751441956,
-0.7141513228416443,
-0.5277307629585266,
-0.038312144577503204,
-0.40829038619995117,
0.11597394198179245,
0.5295378565788269,
-0.6703395843505859,
0.8470820188522339,
0.5395086407661438,
0.8003256916999817,
0.055731479078531265,
0.634187638759613,
0.9781174659729004,
-0.4613138735294342,
-0.3979770839214325,
0.2169058620929718,
0.24742946028709412,
0.5347529649734497,
0.11871231347322464,
0.6062182784080505,
0.14851216971874237,
-1.0032740831375122,
-0.8724607229232788,
0.1829468309879303,
-1.0123525857925415,
0.3184974491596222,
0.9036231637001038,
-0.16481320559978485,
0.21449100971221924,
-0.32232725620269775,
-0.23683011531829834,
0.04151013121008873,
-0.538104772567749,
1.0735105276107788,
0.9372866153717041,
-0.36429136991500854,
0.0680394247174263,
-0.43590834736824036,
0.4005386531352997,
0.39993199706077576,
-0.4354369044303894,
-0.2718762755393982,
0.34798663854599,
0.35575562715530396,
0.40030211210250854,
0.4800017178058624,
-0.19327357411384583,
0.20130373537540436,
-0.21141429245471954,
-0.03283977881073952,
0.30473655462265015,
-0.03551996126770973,
-0.3345547914505005,
0.2924864888191223,
0.6253709197044373,
-0.394593209028244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01462v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01462v1
|
OpenChemIE: An Information Extraction Toolkit For Chemistry Literature
| 2024-04-01T20:16:21 | 2024-04-01T20:16:21 |
Vincent Fan, Yujie Qian, Alex Wang, Amber Wang, Connor W. Coley, Regina Barzilay
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Information extraction from chemistry literature is vital for constructing
up-to-date reaction databases for data-driven chemistry. Complete extraction
requires combining information across text, tables, and figures, whereas prior
work has mainly investigated extracting reactions from single modalities. In
this paper, we present OpenChemIE to address this complex challenge and enable
the extraction of reaction data at the document level. OpenChemIE approaches
the problem in two steps: extracting relevant information from individual
modalities and then integrating the results to obtain a final list of
reactions. For the first step, we employ specialized neural models that each
address a specific task for chemistry information extraction, such as parsing
molecules or reactions from text or figures. We then integrate the information
from these modules using chemistry-informed algorithms, allowing for the
extraction of fine-grained reaction data from reaction condition and substrate
scope investigations. Our machine learning models attain state-of-the-art
performance when evaluated individually, and we meticulously annotate a
challenging dataset of reaction schemes with R-groups to evaluate our pipeline
as a whole, achieving an F1 score of 69.5%. Additionally, the reaction
extraction results of \ours attain an accuracy score of 64.3% when directly
compared against the Reaxys chemical database. We provide OpenChemIE freely to
the public as an open-source package, as well as through a web interface.
|
[
-0.144746333360672,
-0.6142048239707947,
0.7634658813476562,
-0.027157267555594444,
0.07013127207756042,
-0.1099976971745491,
-0.27161577343940735,
-0.3119890093803406,
0.08792676031589508,
0.5967240333557129,
-0.5317707657814026,
-0.9200319647789001,
-0.2840459644794464,
-0.03647514432668686,
-0.01460168045014143,
0.9163469672203064,
-0.45447590947151184,
0.22520923614501953,
-0.19116398692131042,
0.22424595057964325,
0.18246746063232422,
0.2261846661567688,
-0.16490145027637482,
-0.28684720396995544,
0.6849708557128906,
0.4918746054172516,
0.3136243522167206,
0.4459829032421112,
0.5887838006019592,
0.21583789587020874,
0.24573282897472382,
-0.015365523286163807,
-0.3150348663330078,
0.425901859998703,
-0.49846726655960083,
-0.4030047357082367,
-0.3920033872127533,
0.4449599087238312,
0.32267501950263977,
0.47305169701576233,
-0.014919587410986423,
0.42823347449302673,
-0.2727261781692505,
0.8716282248497009,
-1.2226148843765259,
0.4251651167869568,
-0.4271245300769806,
0.3837313652038574,
-0.18090324103832245,
0.08945394307374954,
-0.4302426874637604,
-0.38928428292274475,
0.212800532579422,
-0.8984586596488953,
0.14519049227237701,
-0.13622955977916718,
0.7643537521362305,
0.10280601680278778,
-0.1943833827972412,
-0.3304454982280731,
-0.6157823801040649,
0.6154130101203918,
-0.2562684714794159,
0.42718467116355896,
0.043126337230205536,
0.49909865856170654,
-0.3250090479850769,
-1.247232437133789,
-0.4607798159122467,
-0.12263667583465576,
-0.0594177171587944,
0.423846572637558,
-0.07112718373537064,
0.07049661874771118,
0.214178666472435,
0.593601644039154,
-0.6025905013084412,
-0.2610270380973816,
-0.4238061010837555,
-0.4117562770843506,
0.22932861745357513,
0.2809702754020691,
0.2538462281227112,
-0.16736577451229095,
-0.61219722032547,
-0.14578311145305634,
-0.3134526312351227,
-0.19315116107463837,
0.39352700114250183,
0.44246745109558105,
0.37870362401008606,
0.8363229632377625,
-0.3828858733177185,
0.3595798909664154,
-0.3170766234397888,
0.39381328225135803,
0.1586502641439438,
-0.4042310118675232,
-0.41622164845466614,
0.27999407052993774,
1.0165939331054688,
0.051094405353069305,
-0.10807272791862488,
-0.41080930829048157,
-0.25886043906211853,
0.006632287986576557,
0.22737812995910645,
-1.2596579790115356,
-0.7057859897613525,
0.6453392505645752,
-0.3258573114871979,
-0.4207475483417511,
0.3312344551086426,
-1.3046280145645142,
-0.5429129004478455,
-0.2887308895587921,
0.6737451553344727,
-0.3031459152698517,
-0.2904435396194458,
-0.09719057381153107,
-0.6787821054458618,
0.03990650922060013,
0.49631810188293457,
-0.6064878702163696,
0.21552713215351105,
0.3504323363304138,
1.0224357843399048,
-0.5318308472633362,
0.11326129734516144,
-0.7266595959663391,
0.18422572314739227,
-0.14703942835330963,
0.6172544360160828,
-0.43854203820228577,
0.05384129285812378,
-0.18487203121185303,
0.15096038579940796,
0.10772459208965302,
-0.5480701327323914,
0.2787071466445923,
-0.5625653266906738,
0.2770346701145172,
-0.12008918076753616,
-0.2534361779689789,
0.1458406001329422,
-0.05260784551501274,
-1.1288396120071411,
0.778658926486969,
0.2912103831768036,
-0.7376498579978943,
0.10550262778997421,
-0.851967990398407,
-0.06346633285284042,
-0.08228299766778946,
-0.07427956163883209,
-0.12529265880584717,
0.2777940332889557,
-0.008070663549005985,
0.050268590450286865,
-0.5989238023757935,
-0.17359258234500885,
-0.43563777208328247,
-0.04837752506136894,
0.3280932605266571,
0.18266887962818146,
0.8752332329750061,
0.4508885145187378,
0.029698127880692482,
0.3242550790309906,
-1.04874587059021,
0.26442667841911316,
0.07370318472385406,
-0.6701688170433044,
-0.19406789541244507,
-0.3448159098625183,
0.36187347769737244,
0.4443330466747284,
0.2375834882259369,
-1.0651479959487915,
0.1718330830335617,
-0.5003786087036133,
0.30049771070480347,
0.7181142568588257,
0.19407229125499725,
0.4886021912097931,
0.20297397673130035,
0.2866170406341553,
0.09887664765119553,
-0.18734420835971832,
-0.11741979420185089,
-0.40282025933265686,
-0.49359259009361267,
-0.44861969351768494,
0.6951505541801453,
0.3317745327949524,
-0.4786263406276703,
0.34461769461631775,
-0.17182262241840363,
-0.7720593214035034,
-0.7149179577827454,
0.08693087100982666,
0.210707426071167,
0.4732550084590912,
0.3578317165374756,
-0.3547573685646057,
-0.4674229621887207,
-0.7727842330932617,
-0.5416274070739746,
-0.07085578143596649,
-0.22463738918304443,
-0.14049839973449707,
0.6188564300537109,
-0.05441030114889145,
1.2278531789779663,
-1.0008004903793335,
-0.4604432284832001,
0.12017815560102463,
0.3586348593235016,
0.11761568486690521,
0.12897635996341705,
0.15336796641349792,
-0.6976026296615601,
-0.5540904998779297,
0.45629945397377014,
-0.8018273115158081,
-0.21393123269081116,
0.43550702929496765,
-0.5767564177513123,
0.4136084020137787,
0.49163466691970825,
-0.7671076059341431,
0.5089021921157837,
0.12481492012739182,
0.009378835558891296,
0.5298256874084473,
0.15326642990112305,
0.023051362484693527,
-0.9319841265678406,
0.6638697981834412,
0.12219792604446411,
0.10428750514984131,
-0.6095746159553528,
0.09098149836063385,
0.21940341591835022,
-0.3536449074745178,
-0.8695497512817383,
0.727177619934082,
-0.325239360332489,
-0.04164980351924896,
0.024184396490454674,
0.09920060634613037,
0.21001426875591278,
0.5711643695831299,
0.1923065334558487,
0.3364969491958618,
0.28810787200927734,
-0.2530355155467987,
0.36107510328292847,
0.07054685056209564,
-0.43460243940353394,
0.014287078753113747,
-0.28196030855178833,
0.10075931251049042,
-0.04153691604733467,
0.1424115002155304,
-1.4528506994247437,
-0.7403593063354492,
0.5180019736289978,
-0.3303717076778412,
0.35319435596466064,
-0.024083072319626808,
-0.5576891303062439,
0.0840221643447876,
-0.3813907504081726,
-0.1558229923248291,
0.14028587937355042,
-0.482710599899292,
1.0687122344970703,
0.26835042238235474,
-0.058944664895534515,
-0.5890142917633057,
-0.25266802310943604,
-0.4083741307258606,
-0.09275125712156296,
-0.3593025207519531,
0.3363259732723236,
-0.12646347284317017,
-0.2656221091747284,
0.08896657824516296,
-0.6049203872680664,
-0.31183403730392456,
-0.12203296273946762,
0.30954793095588684,
0.24731656908988953,
0.18230046331882477,
0.18431204557418823,
-0.0305646825581789,
-0.27538448572158813,
0.18942561745643616,
-0.23717127740383148,
0.4419533610343933,
0.08306518197059631,
0.10349050909280777,
-0.27527883648872375,
0.26154306530952454,
0.7840056419372559,
-0.23460975289344788,
0.5367212891578674,
0.7450170516967773,
-0.4809427559375763,
0.04814627766609192,
-0.000650636269710958,
-0.34302809834480286,
-0.408507376909256,
0.326277494430542,
-0.42090481519699097,
-0.21366660296916962,
0.54920494556427,
-0.32490605115890503,
0.2412281483411789,
0.5504252314567566,
0.4368561804294586,
-0.04205602779984474,
0.9078688621520996,
0.3356766104698181,
0.182957723736763,
0.325756311416626,
-0.007027760613709688,
0.12933805584907532,
-0.5083242058753967,
-0.38866159319877625,
-0.7211921811103821,
-0.23810051381587982,
-0.09528490155935287,
-0.27358371019363403,
0.41619551181793213,
-0.016165196895599365,
-0.18651746213436127,
0.276382714509964,
-0.4045720100402832,
0.4420350193977356,
0.2326640635728836,
0.30683648586273193,
0.4207480549812317,
0.5367172956466675,
-0.2833564281463623,
0.016126584261655807,
-0.33479490876197815,
-0.3256642520427704,
1.2606408596038818,
0.3139655888080597,
1.102779746055603,
0.3280205726623535,
0.7503884434700012,
0.16172805428504944,
0.34335342049598694,
-0.9472625255584717,
0.6084123849868774,
0.27178943157196045,
-0.7470389604568481,
-0.19958139955997467,
-0.5485026836395264,
-0.8987642526626587,
0.3054124414920807,
-0.25358113646507263,
-0.7527673840522766,
-0.07702691107988358,
-0.331610769033432,
0.06027504429221153,
-0.17435848712921143,
-0.724895715713501,
1.0700193643569946,
0.017677349969744682,
-0.8333368301391602,
0.09292178601026535,
-0.851970374584198,
0.39712268114089966,
-0.4081985056400299,
0.1888192594051361,
0.012351393699645996,
-0.2486434131860733,
0.7096440196037292,
-0.540992021560669,
0.5413922667503357,
0.02875273860991001,
-0.19932274520397186,
0.26229381561279297,
0.2723877429962158,
0.1801060140132904,
-0.3423954248428345,
-0.03957943618297577,
0.0800204798579216,
0.19953636825084686,
-0.21619345247745514,
-0.5491171479225159,
0.8122197389602661,
-0.5969967246055603,
-0.24600759148597717,
-0.39866840839385986,
-0.622404158115387,
0.12865526974201202,
0.587924063205719,
0.3810773193836212,
0.09281033277511597,
-0.3564453721046448,
-0.16579276323318481,
0.5423154830932617,
-0.0897027999162674,
0.4967619776725769,
0.578413188457489,
-0.6005145907402039,
-0.6516069769859314,
1.0523884296417236,
0.04846171289682388,
0.3971642851829529,
0.37757736444473267,
0.25566840171813965,
-0.2974802851676941,
-0.07854805886745453,
-0.3976513147354126,
0.08921075612306595,
-1.1643309593200684,
-0.10160544514656067,
-0.6208552718162537,
0.04175201803445816,
-0.5910738706588745,
0.2874062955379486,
-0.3106621503829956,
-0.8416544198989868,
-0.26664379239082336,
-0.03447876125574112,
0.07313787937164307,
0.4514349400997162,
-0.08104852586984634,
-0.10050863772630692,
-0.9386789202690125,
0.3927856683731079,
-0.017572209239006042,
0.19029702246189117,
-0.28791534900665283,
0.2239190936088562,
-0.12122062593698502,
-0.4527163505554199,
-0.49960121512413025,
-1.374069333076477,
0.12403954565525055,
0.1397835910320282,
0.5374371409416199,
0.15982873737812042,
0.21306510269641876,
0.25228872895240784,
-0.1466224640607834,
0.6508091688156128,
0.23882505297660828,
-0.690092921257019,
0.8021464347839355,
-0.27253109216690063,
0.3233896493911743,
0.637428879737854,
0.8696649670600891,
-0.15113167464733124,
-0.030723977833986282,
-0.31756526231765747,
-1.0373754501342773,
0.963129997253418,
0.22133593261241913,
-0.6736839413642883,
0.11345856636762619,
0.22633060812950134,
0.2639371454715729,
0.23736236989498138,
-0.6553139090538025,
-0.07386913895606995,
-0.04767923802137375,
-0.5246198177337646,
0.27302637696266174,
0.48734885454177856,
-0.3226989209651947,
-0.10965721309185028,
0.9505916237831116,
-0.15590175986289978,
-0.011151216924190521,
0.2509516179561615,
-0.43523144721984863,
-0.46145814657211304,
0.1696580946445465,
0.02201908268034458,
0.5514928698539734,
-0.6880351305007935,
0.09448815882205963,
-0.4053504467010498,
-0.5908733010292053,
-0.040513526648283005,
0.22237586975097656,
0.1763649880886078,
0.01177931297570467,
0.11403601616621017,
0.24328376352787018,
-0.16780713200569153,
-0.9846044778823853,
0.477785587310791,
-0.26632365584373474,
-0.11102597415447235,
0.01224115863442421,
0.16066184639930725,
-0.0017410903237760067,
0.3076677620410919,
0.12886038422584534,
0.17687635123729706,
0.5042670965194702,
-0.6559267640113831,
0.20960283279418945,
0.4341053366661072,
-0.6569861173629761,
-0.00806516408920288,
0.4179471433162689,
-0.054281339049339294,
-0.041410624980926514,
0.5709136724472046,
0.13453540205955505,
-0.14402028918266296,
0.4444245994091034,
0.35686540603637695,
0.8351921439170837,
-0.22067366540431976,
0.14487150311470032,
0.6378063559532166,
-0.049999870359897614,
0.2197243720293045,
0.43972504138946533,
-0.13684725761413574,
-0.28964874148368835,
0.20899929106235504,
-0.83710116147995,
-0.41536203026771545,
0.1950312703847885,
-0.4717552065849304,
0.556801438331604,
-0.5643817782402039,
-0.0734071359038353,
0.49211424589157104,
-0.03963961452245712,
-0.601748526096344,
-0.0881553441286087,
-0.14635705947875977,
1.0953083038330078,
-0.8274844288825989,
0.5131212472915649,
0.8328365683555603,
-0.8343286514282227,
-0.26807641983032227,
0.000730920466594398,
0.04812749847769737,
-0.06429001688957214,
0.7285215854644775,
0.44026458263397217,
-0.04204598814249039,
0.08920004218816757,
-0.6333920359611511,
-0.5100334882736206,
1.0302010774612427,
0.26798519492149353,
-0.09280190616846085,
-0.06888680160045624,
-0.0003400372515898198,
0.3534119725227356,
-0.37694501876831055,
0.4020443856716156,
0.6963067650794983,
0.753167450428009,
0.2029205709695816,
-0.5064679980278015,
0.3134268820285797,
-0.3844185471534729,
-0.5611807703971863,
0.4763279855251312,
-0.19952121376991272,
1.007432460784912,
-0.04799676686525345,
-0.3803299069404602,
0.08795303851366043,
0.3477674126625061,
-0.00975118950009346,
0.4633280634880066,
0.1863706409931183,
0.6918410062789917,
0.5965162515640259,
-0.17302076518535614,
0.6431226134300232,
0.004235061351209879,
0.28792470693588257,
0.8578413724899292,
-0.28447458148002625,
0.8272417783737183,
0.5486257672309875,
0.008641977794468403,
0.6372150182723999,
0.69327712059021,
0.1690305769443512,
0.858349621295929,
0.27271947264671326,
-0.41027069091796875,
-0.10138814151287079,
-0.10073065757751465,
-0.04183373600244522,
0.31031534075737,
0.6507246494293213,
-0.6083090305328369,
-0.6246874928474426,
-0.08424828201532364,
-0.026218311861157417,
-0.31823354959487915,
-0.1674869954586029,
0.7705582976341248,
-0.30387407541275024,
-1.0176225900650024,
0.38733765482902527,
-0.04312683641910553,
-0.2473905384540558,
-0.6215313076972961,
-0.3423933684825897,
0.18770375847816467,
0.400424063205719,
-0.4869827628135681,
-0.8039540648460388,
-0.05868832394480705,
-0.26031389832496643,
-0.33131861686706543,
0.2893110513687134,
1.0145847797393799,
-0.5635663270950317,
0.052822791039943695,
0.23816105723381042,
0.4878460168838501,
0.3681510388851166,
-0.26913514733314514,
-0.36526742577552795,
0.22596938908100128,
0.09299762547016144,
-0.29539158940315247,
0.5579193830490112,
0.2360624074935913,
0.04984685778617859,
0.008432069793343544,
0.8326257467269897,
-0.17735056579113007,
-0.21564942598342896,
-0.31271660327911377,
1.2205921411514282,
-0.5432206392288208,
-0.1845378577709198,
-0.6760460734367371,
0.7450107932090759,
-0.26708367466926575,
-0.16153404116630554,
0.4968712329864502,
0.7926534414291382,
0.447436660528183,
-0.484276682138443,
0.9770858287811279,
-0.011402764357626438,
0.05739204213023186,
-0.6435680985450745,
0.5670754909515381,
-0.48765745759010315,
-0.012786641716957092,
-0.3789265751838684,
-1.3202953338623047,
-0.20063240826129913,
0.47752973437309265,
-0.06331615149974823,
-0.3142561614513397,
0.9551166892051697,
0.8424226641654968,
-0.25435876846313477,
0.28484001755714417,
-0.33493512868881226,
0.22144512832164764,
0.6532219648361206,
0.4206624925136566,
0.5948694944381714,
-0.3986132740974426,
0.5539150834083557,
-0.022348526865243912,
-0.4177538752555847,
-0.18376769125461578,
-0.8734082579612732,
-0.9153576493263245,
-0.45681387186050415,
-0.2941100597381592,
-0.7470113635063171,
-0.31126949191093445,
0.9086053967475891,
0.2398916482925415,
-0.5011790990829468,
-0.13570432364940643,
-0.22030805051326752,
-0.025352900847792625,
0.05175086855888367,
-0.30551302433013916,
0.35533833503723145,
-0.5023226737976074,
-0.6107767224311829,
0.5524747967720032,
0.2862957715988159,
-0.14844489097595215,
-0.3114306926727295,
0.08064619451761246,
-0.1722724586725235,
0.11220914125442505,
0.3496186137199402,
0.3670577108860016,
-0.4702206552028656,
-0.045647233724594116,
-0.12742295861244202,
-0.11927352100610733,
0.09170839190483093,
0.7571370005607605,
-0.7748624682426453,
0.9341105818748474,
1.0257607698440552,
0.4379799962043762,
0.9025732278823853,
-0.2362988144159317,
0.44241002202033997,
-0.6825761198997498,
-0.2862192690372467,
-0.057312339544296265,
0.06767416000366211,
0.11829052865505219,
-0.18617916107177734,
0.7952393293380737,
0.40461301803588867,
-0.4249127209186554,
-0.7494684457778931,
0.23897624015808105,
-1.044002890586853,
-0.7162138223648071,
0.7718502283096313,
-0.2795788645744324,
-0.6682076454162598,
0.05837525427341461,
-0.4114777147769928,
0.5077484250068665,
-0.5966901779174805,
0.5253767371177673,
0.8283399343490601,
-0.3436703681945801,
0.31824207305908203,
-0.6123303771018982,
0.45010673999786377,
0.0256196241825819,
-1.0208901166915894,
0.3595692813396454,
0.883132815361023,
0.37175253033638,
0.6906234622001648,
0.35888752341270447,
-0.38975265622138977,
0.27849531173706055,
-0.155246302485466,
0.19714248180389404,
-0.1773240864276886,
-0.666704535484314,
-0.17651936411857605,
0.5906530618667603,
-0.4234238862991333,
-0.16928288340568542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01461v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01461v2
|
Will the Real Linda Please Stand up...to Large Language Models? Examining the Representativeness Heuristic in LLMs
| 2024-04-01T20:15:06 | 2024-05-11T05:44:39 |
Pengda Wang, Zilin Xiao, Hanjie Chen, Frederick L. Oswald
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Although large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
proficiency in "understanding" text and generating human-like text, they may
exhibit biases acquired from training data in doing so. Specifically, LLMs may
be susceptible to a common cognitive trap in human decision-making called the
representativeness heuristic. This is a concept in psychology that refers to
judging the likelihood of an event based on how closely it resembles a
well-known prototype or typical example versus considering broader facts or
statistical evidence. This work investigates the impact of the
representativeness heuristic on LLM reasoning. We created ReHeAT
(Representativeness Heuristic AI Testing), a dataset containing a series of
problems spanning six common types of representativeness heuristics.
Experiments reveal that four LLMs applied to REHEAT all exhibited
representativeness heuristic biases. We further identify that the model's
reasoning steps are often incorrectly based on a stereotype rather than the
problem's description. Interestingly, the performance improves when adding a
hint in the prompt to remind the model of using its knowledge. This suggests
the uniqueness of the representativeness heuristic compared to traditional
biases. It can occur even when LLMs possess the correct knowledge while failing
in a cognitive trap. This highlights the importance of future research focusing
on the representativeness heuristic in model reasoning and decision-making and
on developing solutions to address it.
|
[
-0.33740106225013733,
-0.5259395837783813,
0.8855957984924316,
0.22576284408569336,
-0.0962538942694664,
0.13824917376041412,
-0.5016576647758484,
-0.2283642739057541,
0.11284461617469788,
0.7187356352806091,
-0.5888257622718811,
-0.4365345239639282,
-0.5731343030929565,
0.30384504795074463,
-0.45132654905319214,
0.3728773891925812,
-0.05739373713731766,
0.012671786360442638,
-0.43203696608543396,
-0.09843601286411285,
-0.5748056173324585,
-0.6930859684944153,
-0.5592891573905945,
-0.6209755539894104,
0.5806494355201721,
0.3389723300933838,
0.7698005437850952,
0.67641681432724,
0.39049050211906433,
0.27378177642822266,
0.10182047635316849,
0.004965600091964006,
-0.3512546420097351,
0.5029329061508179,
-0.16247473657131195,
-0.8972220420837402,
-0.10562586039304733,
0.5011149048805237,
0.6134982109069824,
0.57671719789505,
-0.42517900466918945,
0.1521923989057541,
-0.10032030194997787,
0.559116542339325,
-0.3158404231071472,
0.012282077223062515,
-1.0260462760925293,
-0.05734019726514816,
-0.007790491916239262,
0.01789926365017891,
-0.7632534503936768,
-0.26295480132102966,
0.08066421747207642,
-0.45314309000968933,
0.3864566385746002,
0.39069852232933044,
0.9209160208702087,
0.64238041639328,
-0.3740193843841553,
-0.25249841809272766,
-0.6463991403579712,
1.0484741926193237,
-0.7838167548179626,
0.40398135781288147,
0.3260158896446228,
0.7250465750694275,
-0.3372189998626709,
-0.42565715312957764,
-0.5038003325462341,
-0.850979745388031,
0.016647370532155037,
-0.13365361094474792,
-0.15167267620563507,
-0.550866961479187,
0.5069093108177185,
0.012374111451208591,
-0.4692554771900177,
0.3217003643512726,
-0.27768874168395996,
-0.06511463224887848,
0.7281525731086731,
0.239399716258049,
0.3409445583820343,
-0.0682334154844284,
-0.317575067281723,
-0.06678173691034317,
-0.7941031455993652,
-0.19334638118743896,
0.2518905699253082,
0.32897332310676575,
0.04551982879638672,
0.39917778968811035,
-0.019625388085842133,
0.4893589913845062,
-0.042717188596725464,
-0.0367276556789875,
-0.08890391141176224,
0.01886110007762909,
-0.12889772653579712,
0.1587224304676056,
0.6449047923088074,
0.21618641912937164,
0.7995919585227966,
-0.09001065045595169,
-0.18171188235282898,
-0.13341124355793,
0.4319082796573639,
-0.5886391997337341,
-0.22740505635738373,
0.08554191142320633,
-0.5458967089653015,
-0.34859558939933777,
0.10599502176046371,
-0.3331838846206665,
-0.5498873591423035,
-0.2572914958000183,
0.06180231273174286,
-0.33845236897468567,
-0.31615254282951355,
-0.15556567907333374,
-0.13110269606113434,
0.03422754630446434,
0.36581599712371826,
-0.6271560788154602,
0.23980072140693665,
0.7463712096214294,
0.6682153940200806,
-0.11093705892562866,
-0.1710892617702484,
-0.3615488111972809,
-0.02138238586485386,
-0.3386877477169037,
0.7576776742935181,
-0.8078095316886902,
-0.3503211736679077,
-0.300375372171402,
-0.08043552935123444,
0.011758089065551758,
-0.8977048993110657,
0.5101956725120544,
-0.3269219398498535,
0.44531866908073425,
-0.6299555897712708,
-0.41819947957992554,
-0.02448851242661476,
0.5236923098564148,
-0.6443895697593689,
0.8807929158210754,
0.049931518733501434,
-0.5408700108528137,
0.31218698620796204,
-0.12596936523914337,
-0.19180715084075928,
-0.2893984317779541,
-0.47677674889564514,
-0.5886802673339844,
0.18260321021080017,
0.21998007595539093,
0.3922939896583557,
-0.7219918966293335,
0.3450102210044861,
-0.5043689012527466,
-0.35364818572998047,
0.8126891255378723,
-0.6128457188606262,
0.8339234590530396,
0.051365967839956284,
-0.44778016209602356,
0.056852735579013824,
-0.8180429935455322,
0.08946199715137482,
0.43662163615226746,
-0.4072154760360718,
-0.37936893105506897,
0.03419393301010132,
-0.3855726420879364,
0.1324365884065628,
0.03216936066746712,
-0.29446372389793396,
0.40675193071365356,
-0.12263022363185883,
0.33732351660728455,
0.9802742600440979,
-0.13649487495422363,
0.4325485825538635,
-0.4972701370716095,
0.74860018491745,
-0.1317964345216751,
0.026761213317513466,
-0.16256821155548096,
-0.6812825798988342,
-0.5904020071029663,
-0.34274038672447205,
0.48445284366607666,
0.6239949464797974,
-0.5942367315292358,
0.19592924416065216,
0.011831928975880146,
-0.3761014938354492,
-0.56488037109375,
0.13233858346939087,
0.5845487713813782,
0.31743502616882324,
-0.02600018121302128,
-0.05311058461666107,
-0.7960690259933472,
-1.1212645769119263,
-0.33069419860839844,
-0.08835412561893463,
-0.22932377457618713,
0.1937388777732849,
0.5531453490257263,
0.05715985968708992,
0.8623871207237244,
-0.45365458726882935,
-0.24586832523345947,
-0.2762846052646637,
0.012881594710052013,
0.11732270568609238,
0.28604328632354736,
0.6475435495376587,
-0.523786723613739,
-0.39190971851348877,
-0.3251997232437134,
-0.9061821699142456,
-0.24830931425094604,
-0.026628177613019943,
-0.031852249056100845,
0.22516867518424988,
0.37626326084136963,
-0.5523072481155396,
0.17315131425857544,
0.4790188670158386,
-0.3001166880130768,
0.6732068657875061,
-0.30524110794067383,
-0.03232590854167938,
-1.2344236373901367,
-0.39811787009239197,
0.19972170889377594,
-0.024923114106059074,
-0.19234305620193481,
0.15641318261623383,
-0.16116537153720856,
0.11441725492477417,
-0.06744527816772461,
0.6513714790344238,
-0.6843029260635376,
-0.38000139594078064,
-0.24700865149497986,
0.1510137915611267,
0.0446171872317791,
-0.06042173132300377,
0.07030051201581955,
0.8388496041297913,
0.3169768154621124,
-0.29825854301452637,
0.5542895793914795,
-0.21036992967128754,
-0.3835951089859009,
0.6125649809837341,
-0.7342272996902466,
0.24296601116657257,
-0.0801493376493454,
0.5167625546455383,
-1.0431913137435913,
-0.185824453830719,
0.11396422982215881,
-0.6569643616676331,
0.09475017338991165,
0.15062594413757324,
-0.5855890512466431,
-0.44143998622894287,
-0.11962570250034332,
0.004690608941018581,
0.6469836831092834,
-0.5101845264434814,
0.44844093918800354,
0.06331705302000046,
0.1737060546875,
-0.5117691159248352,
-0.44035086035728455,
0.2595136761665344,
-0.3175489902496338,
-0.6563519239425659,
0.04386588931083679,
-0.0341167189180851,
-0.832410991191864,
-0.07594381272792816,
-0.03874662145972252,
-0.1172213926911354,
0.2332029938697815,
0.1916467249393463,
0.13535107672214508,
-0.3398643136024475,
-0.07921937108039856,
-0.45251116156578064,
-0.41136085987091064,
0.33007264137268066,
-0.2015414983034134,
0.5892277956008911,
-0.034628305584192276,
-0.4047466814517975,
-0.5388331413269043,
0.416378378868103,
0.6730254292488098,
0.03591650351881981,
0.8333886861801147,
0.5309771299362183,
-0.40993422269821167,
-0.3730330169200897,
-0.6187506914138794,
-0.5363708138465881,
-0.4049929678440094,
0.134859099984169,
-0.49150919914245605,
-0.5264756679534912,
0.7470369338989258,
0.36490321159362793,
0.09098456054925919,
0.13060683012008667,
0.704654335975647,
-0.3568475842475891,
1.2355220317840576,
0.5608090758323669,
-0.06280238926410675,
0.2742752134799957,
-0.16398049890995026,
0.21226894855499268,
-0.7811682820320129,
-0.07355396449565887,
-0.8706327080726624,
-0.4525441825389862,
-0.5950659513473511,
-0.44892022013664246,
0.25181496143341064,
-0.516433835029602,
-0.2014075368642807,
0.2603689730167389,
-0.6482361555099487,
0.545369029045105,
0.6567831635475159,
0.08083276450634003,
0.4152528941631317,
-0.004517813213169575,
-0.051294613629579544,
-0.47037866711616516,
-0.6855767369270325,
-0.6970307230949402,
0.9785778522491455,
0.5431374311447144,
0.8660569190979004,
0.20521779358386993,
0.7912719249725342,
0.31607794761657715,
0.7659541368484497,
-0.512435257434845,
0.6044886112213135,
0.0035467937123030424,
-0.8105738759040833,
-0.16825518012046814,
-0.5178446173667908,
-0.7523883581161499,
0.200602725148201,
-0.12157542258501053,
-0.6204647421836853,
0.08235275000333786,
0.20271272957324982,
-0.19649508595466614,
0.23919609189033508,
-0.60882967710495,
0.5409990549087524,
-0.3169628083705902,
-0.17736901342868805,
-0.008842338807880878,
-0.36056116223335266,
0.5901868343353271,
0.14187072217464447,
0.41739094257354736,
-0.3625042140483856,
0.08774057775735855,
0.6418365836143494,
-0.2358183115720749,
0.9796133041381836,
0.01598198711872101,
-0.47142505645751953,
0.09463150799274445,
0.2716453969478607,
0.6043463945388794,
0.06666230410337448,
-0.4366455674171448,
-0.013378222472965717,
-0.01465418841689825,
-0.5394197702407837,
-0.9004242420196533,
0.5769486427307129,
-0.6784150004386902,
-1.1566725969314575,
-0.45543530583381653,
-0.47313034534454346,
-0.08398062735795975,
-0.1947542428970337,
0.3189353346824646,
0.06954257190227509,
-0.07470976561307907,
0.17582647502422333,
0.9311429858207703,
-0.14990295469760895,
0.0030884682200849056,
0.5540611743927002,
-0.3081524968147278,
-0.1828088015317917,
1.0235595703125,
0.2589365839958191,
0.5463645458221436,
0.05189044028520584,
0.41521987318992615,
-0.02208194136619568,
-0.3339759111404419,
-0.49363067746162415,
0.32459375262260437,
-0.7002720236778259,
0.05844179913401604,
-0.3475038707256317,
-0.06381680816411972,
-0.3168880343437195,
-0.2889576554298401,
-0.4864523410797119,
-0.24404621124267578,
-0.19200189411640167,
0.05730457603931427,
0.10053233802318573,
0.7068235278129578,
0.261584997177124,
0.09551132470369339,
-0.5424771904945374,
0.11294738203287125,
0.2929871082305908,
0.04738936573266983,
0.007038438227027655,
-0.7991452217102051,
0.11045388132333755,
-0.030050119385123253,
0.007821517065167427,
-0.8899756073951721,
0.2984059453010559,
-0.27414724230766296,
0.8213903307914734,
0.42921486496925354,
0.17251139879226685,
0.2554926574230194,
-0.2633915841579437,
0.7568619847297668,
0.11416124552488327,
-0.5335694551467896,
0.3063126504421234,
-0.3233942985534668,
0.25355958938598633,
0.33627739548683167,
0.28887903690338135,
-0.3131163418292999,
-0.6298770904541016,
-0.7307666540145874,
-0.45709311962127686,
0.35529807209968567,
0.1817653775215149,
0.40808674693107605,
0.0032146295998245478,
0.508979082107544,
0.20096707344055176,
0.17750923335552216,
-0.6406150460243225,
-0.025302404537796974,
0.15958718955516815,
-0.0567566342651844,
0.10390733927488327,
-0.294156551361084,
-0.2126055657863617,
-0.21235515177249908,
0.6484213471412659,
-0.18534600734710693,
0.19861921668052673,
-0.038045063614845276,
0.13613645732402802,
0.09103132039308548,
0.33729636669158936,
0.8177991509437561,
0.7498460412025452,
-0.39343971014022827,
0.27800774574279785,
0.23023544251918793,
-0.12321451306343079,
0.25393131375312805,
-0.2805808484554291,
-0.3101866841316223,
0.12301009148359299,
0.5897780060768127,
0.5203495621681213,
0.21273984014987946,
-0.6966688632965088,
0.15473201870918274,
-0.22913160920143127,
-0.19227279722690582,
-0.6090105175971985,
0.1962999403476715,
0.21624748408794403,
0.41208887100219727,
0.3986087441444397,
-0.22313301265239716,
-0.3145211338996887,
-1.0553460121154785,
0.09307169169187546,
0.583893895149231,
-0.1963868886232376,
-0.1512681096792221,
0.7702969312667847,
0.23725512623786926,
-0.6723744869232178,
0.8194015622138977,
-0.22352741658687592,
-0.7156673073768616,
0.9988772869110107,
0.7500553131103516,
0.7773302793502808,
-0.17102336883544922,
0.21439068019390106,
0.1917422115802765,
0.525712788105011,
-0.15201731026172638,
-0.008648836053907871,
0.009865915402770042,
-0.92822265625,
-0.15909214317798615,
-0.3717609941959381,
-0.6171117424964905,
-0.18892766535282135,
-0.512101948261261,
0.10128176957368851,
-0.7634525299072266,
-0.20028632879257202,
-0.06540252268314362,
-0.034012507647275925,
-0.5047543048858643,
0.16249515116214752,
0.2846064865589142,
1.0956497192382812,
-0.7315706610679626,
0.7844657897949219,
0.595916211605072,
-0.5157145857810974,
-0.708121657371521,
0.33646321296691895,
0.22537705302238464,
-1.0191375017166138,
0.8523768782615662,
0.08799279481172562,
0.023462949320673943,
-0.08780302107334137,
-0.7267128229141235,
-0.8214686512947083,
1.0458959341049194,
0.6425289511680603,
-0.6322228908538818,
-0.28138068318367004,
-0.3306223154067993,
0.35384443402290344,
-0.8247500061988831,
0.24583782255649567,
0.8233996629714966,
0.6696805357933044,
0.23561567068099976,
-0.9912565350532532,
0.31340256333351135,
0.09558271616697311,
0.16223160922527313,
-0.16610386967658997,
-0.6859018206596375,
0.9077427387237549,
-0.6881710290908813,
0.09771260619163513,
0.05978798121213913,
0.6427084803581238,
0.658397376537323,
0.4065009355545044,
0.39166978001594543,
0.5800740718841553,
0.9813897013664246,
-0.17571207880973816,
1.311975121498108,
0.17455478012561798,
0.2721423804759979,
1.0514181852340698,
-0.6717440485954285,
0.7600710391998291,
0.3471613824367523,
-0.2315860241651535,
0.5683591961860657,
0.734738290309906,
-0.033760689198970795,
0.2647777497768402,
0.48737865686416626,
-0.3593604564666748,
-0.5397462248802185,
0.053652454167604446,
-0.3141923248767853,
0.4170491397380829,
0.2566473186016083,
-0.5421778559684753,
-0.30442938208580017,
0.07928832620382309,
0.37403008341789246,
0.6242569088935852,
0.10281745344400406,
0.4769607484340668,
0.37230613827705383,
-0.7237499356269836,
0.7039452791213989,
0.04835287481546402,
0.5488063097000122,
-0.13330097496509552,
-0.05728459358215332,
-0.2845330834388733,
0.21855776011943817,
-0.13290058076381683,
-0.8156386613845825,
0.34552615880966187,
-0.0438162125647068,
-0.5659796595573425,
-0.37060508131980896,
0.47064515948295593,
-0.07076521962881088,
-0.5506491661071777,
0.1549062728881836,
0.5401397347450256,
0.311770498752594,
-0.2961268126964569,
-0.7902159690856934,
0.4801957905292511,
0.1519627571105957,
-0.3766906261444092,
0.34591951966285706,
0.37003642320632935,
-0.46015676856040955,
0.9929177761077881,
0.6985604763031006,
-0.16301564872264862,
-0.07912784069776535,
0.2783564329147339,
0.6189892292022705,
-0.751905083656311,
-0.11546128988265991,
-0.972259521484375,
0.12429508566856384,
-0.23473384976387024,
-0.1360960453748703,
0.6637384295463562,
0.2824774980545044,
0.5561555624008179,
0.12206792086362839,
0.9426112771034241,
0.15178290009498596,
0.5001600980758667,
-0.7215875387191772,
0.7055788636207581,
-0.3362540602684021,
0.6743216514587402,
0.19404277205467224,
-0.9571642875671387,
-0.11882826685905457,
0.7576565146446228,
-0.7081710696220398,
0.3328682482242584,
0.5945705771446228,
0.7574155330657959,
0.19393697381019592,
-0.09735468775033951,
0.4700341820716858,
0.36452236771583557,
0.4538339376449585,
0.5207313299179077,
0.8801826238632202,
-0.06727460026741028,
0.3430473506450653,
-0.12128858268260956,
-0.1559913605451584,
-0.33901461958885193,
-0.8366878032684326,
-1.0685033798217773,
-0.6684210896492004,
-0.31103068590164185,
-0.7077393531799316,
0.19813665747642517,
1.1341071128845215,
0.7437942028045654,
-0.5097780823707581,
-0.039251960813999176,
0.2815202474594116,
0.6238502264022827,
-0.15446512401103973,
-0.30455562472343445,
0.0179095808416605,
-0.21843816339969635,
-0.6721972823143005,
0.25140509009361267,
0.03956787288188934,
-0.1738310307264328,
-0.7125879526138306,
-0.09492211788892746,
-0.008189540356397629,
0.33543917536735535,
0.46448931097984314,
0.19740206003189087,
-0.9968709945678711,
-0.46995747089385986,
0.22337305545806885,
-0.26939597725868225,
0.07021056860685349,
0.8703056573867798,
-0.8647862076759338,
0.12585575878620148,
0.2609001100063324,
0.3600434362888336,
0.09293880313634872,
0.07867441326379776,
0.8068337440490723,
-0.6500447988510132,
0.007150834426283836,
0.09093790501356125,
0.36359214782714844,
0.5021571516990662,
-0.4919106066226959,
0.34617793560028076,
0.44558262825012207,
-0.46214693784713745,
-1.1203018426895142,
0.46911028027534485,
-0.8478180766105652,
-0.4093658924102783,
1.1794840097427368,
-0.11747176945209503,
-0.5692766308784485,
0.017736434936523438,
-0.43000656366348267,
-0.020322438329458237,
-0.5332344174385071,
1.21847403049469,
1.0142709016799927,
-0.20219936966896057,
-0.7913931012153625,
-0.9681085348129272,
0.16538581252098083,
0.40775829553604126,
-0.6970210671424866,
0.16424298286437988,
0.33540666103363037,
0.7457277774810791,
0.2559090256690979,
0.5920596718788147,
0.237139031291008,
0.3221087157726288,
-0.042658351361751556,
0.009467685595154762,
-0.2002618908882141,
-0.19528749585151672,
-0.027919156476855278,
0.1868848204612732,
0.26771554350852966,
-0.04477071017026901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01453v1
|
Unveiling Divergent Inductive Biases of LLMs on Temporal Data
| 2024-04-01T19:56:41 | 2024-04-01T19:56:41 |
Sindhu Kishore, Hangfeng He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Unraveling the intricate details of events in natural language necessitates a
subtle understanding of temporal dynamics. Despite the adeptness of Large
Language Models (LLMs) in discerning patterns and relationships from data,
their inherent comprehension of temporal dynamics remains a formidable
challenge. This research meticulously explores these intrinsic challenges
within LLMs, with a specific emphasis on evaluating the performance of GPT-3.5
and GPT-4 models in the analysis of temporal data. Employing two distinct
prompt types, namely Question Answering (QA) format and Textual Entailment (TE)
format, our analysis probes into both implicit and explicit events. The
findings underscore noteworthy trends, revealing disparities in the performance
of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. Notably, biases toward specific temporal relationships
come to light, with GPT-3.5 demonstrating a preference for "AFTER'' in the QA
format for both implicit and explicit events, while GPT-4 leans towards
"BEFORE''. Furthermore, a consistent pattern surfaces wherein GPT-3.5 tends
towards "TRUE'', and GPT-4 exhibits a preference for "FALSE'' in the TE format
for both implicit and explicit events. This persistent discrepancy between
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in handling temporal data highlights the intricate nature of
inductive bias in LLMs, suggesting that the evolution of these models may not
merely mitigate bias but may introduce new layers of complexity.
|
[
-0.1893957257270813,
-0.881470263004303,
1.1247414350509644,
0.33042800426483154,
-0.21782559156417847,
0.126045361161232,
-0.026821564882993698,
-0.6450790166854858,
-0.2656075954437256,
0.016068110242486,
-1.018686294555664,
-0.3828118145465851,
-0.5081344842910767,
0.24218350648880005,
-0.3832668960094452,
1.1932425498962402,
-0.2666550874710083,
0.05727911740541458,
-0.13527044653892517,
-0.08591035008430481,
-0.35468780994415283,
-0.6988711357116699,
-0.6783475279808044,
-0.7530399560928345,
0.565740168094635,
-0.14041557908058167,
0.7020571827888489,
0.5225014686584473,
0.23049041628837585,
0.09633798897266388,
-0.2450099140405655,
0.045635342597961426,
-0.34885403513908386,
0.3296366333961487,
-0.11744119226932526,
-0.45307672023773193,
-0.18961051106452942,
0.29890623688697815,
0.5826705694198608,
0.7479871511459351,
0.06072678789496422,
0.14522701501846313,
-0.0780775398015976,
0.6054351329803467,
-0.41150444746017456,
0.4412855803966522,
-0.5773338079452515,
0.14883863925933838,
-0.5743973851203918,
-0.4860331118106842,
-0.27496635913848877,
-0.6124722361564636,
0.33657732605934143,
-0.6700554490089417,
0.49235016107559204,
-0.17714540660381317,
0.9167159795761108,
0.3066197335720062,
-0.4875166416168213,
-0.40458548069000244,
-0.8816692233085632,
0.6191633343696594,
-0.5322233438491821,
0.2899892032146454,
0.2918485403060913,
0.13930223882198334,
-0.03985314816236496,
-0.7973082065582275,
-0.6360422372817993,
-0.15898491442203522,
-0.055672965943813324,
0.15341925621032715,
-0.14052726328372955,
-0.11684874445199966,
0.6253674626350403,
0.24767933785915375,
-0.583197832107544,
0.2930748462677002,
0.018618809059262276,
0.1044248417019844,
0.36621901392936707,
0.5763300061225891,
0.30580058693885803,
-0.12686824798583984,
-0.2374187409877777,
0.2941327691078186,
-0.9215013980865479,
0.06383278965950012,
0.6243033409118652,
0.20669277012348175,
-0.19005520641803741,
0.6460379362106323,
-0.18144385516643524,
0.15827831625938416,
0.23222187161445618,
0.20940937101840973,
0.08140503615140915,
-0.5806231498718262,
-0.04408791661262512,
0.08437158912420273,
0.7547529339790344,
0.2890782952308655,
0.43137773871421814,
-0.29050397872924805,
-0.115602046251297,
0.1540820300579071,
-0.27275386452674866,
-0.8393861055374146,
-0.17877580225467682,
0.26180851459503174,
-0.15253524482250214,
0.07348553836345673,
-0.13631494343280792,
-0.7307575345039368,
-0.4021115303039551,
-0.4885549247264862,
0.2542486786842346,
-0.37825676798820496,
-0.1545972228050232,
0.18040813505649567,
-0.07491310685873032,
0.5061654448509216,
0.4594842493534088,
-0.827930748462677,
0.17351815104484558,
0.7300959825515747,
0.7912684082984924,
-0.24220700562000275,
-0.26872846484184265,
-0.5012824535369873,
0.30747395753860474,
-0.3001297414302826,
0.7463260293006897,
-0.8784338235855103,
-0.450019896030426,
0.027282124385237694,
0.08837171643972397,
-0.15695682168006897,
-0.3668653964996338,
0.6361937522888184,
-0.7291608452796936,
0.6851490139961243,
-0.6046860814094543,
-0.530693531036377,
-0.04667950049042702,
0.03447304666042328,
-0.6811287999153137,
1.0917952060699463,
-0.051249485462903976,
-1.0211931467056274,
0.7751402854919434,
-0.7449325323104858,
-0.34851041436195374,
-0.09722916781902313,
-0.5608745217323303,
-0.3380684554576874,
-0.1464974284172058,
0.5045837759971619,
0.2849285900592804,
-0.39573580026626587,
0.4130059480667114,
-0.30378538370132446,
-0.4400767385959625,
0.294854074716568,
-0.5385645627975464,
0.6313993334770203,
-0.03527096286416054,
-0.60837322473526,
-0.08397461473941803,
-0.567606508731842,
-0.3279916048049927,
0.21765582263469696,
-0.30216941237449646,
-0.06652233749628067,
0.3355885446071625,
-0.30285200476646423,
0.1840575486421585,
0.12372956424951553,
-0.4179720878601074,
0.2932136356830597,
-0.27607715129852295,
0.5818683505058289,
0.9132936000823975,
0.3017587959766388,
0.6092414259910583,
-0.35580772161483765,
0.5977216958999634,
0.23779597878456116,
0.30673128366470337,
-0.24175867438316345,
-0.5658141374588013,
-0.47480908036231995,
0.23360751569271088,
-0.0444946363568306,
0.3747420310974121,
-0.7745622396469116,
-0.19321274757385254,
-0.3798663914203644,
-0.05200515314936638,
-0.4182712733745575,
-0.16881832480430603,
0.10775044560432434,
0.41172683238983154,
0.3372790813446045,
0.23426271975040436,
-0.397179514169693,
-0.7594867944717407,
-0.37781822681427,
-0.38910922408103943,
-0.0716172531247139,
0.08245594799518585,
0.39291033148765564,
-0.21225421130657196,
1.0413469076156616,
-0.2595168352127075,
0.16750697791576385,
-0.030086517333984375,
0.4140706956386566,
0.35631516575813293,
0.24400530755519867,
0.4501570463180542,
-0.6503016948699951,
-0.2739851474761963,
-0.04435065761208534,
-0.66678786277771,
-0.4075673520565033,
-0.32345345616340637,
0.06685750186443329,
0.4495324492454529,
0.36460861563682556,
-0.6356024742126465,
0.415236234664917,
0.28008732199668884,
-0.5773157477378845,
0.5363712310791016,
0.2984379231929779,
0.0033943182788789272,
-0.5383857488632202,
-0.16951754689216614,
-0.041863445192575455,
0.048624712973833084,
-0.541805624961853,
-0.23406898975372314,
-0.0040639047510921955,
0.558915376663208,
-0.2593027651309967,
0.5515871644020081,
-0.6680623888969421,
-0.049152303487062454,
0.1229676902294159,
0.16022561490535736,
0.04494648054242134,
0.3183554708957672,
0.0495019368827343,
0.6760178804397583,
0.25365909934043884,
-0.6529841423034668,
0.09920543432235718,
0.1648245006799698,
-0.2167060375213623,
0.13679984211921692,
-0.591385006904602,
0.2866189777851105,
-0.3626936078071594,
0.15266238152980804,
-0.6418523788452148,
-0.0969608798623085,
0.3103032410144806,
-0.43229392170906067,
0.31963685154914856,
-0.5700841546058655,
-0.8224264979362488,
0.032170891761779785,
-0.24591657519340515,
0.5916903614997864,
0.4418606162071228,
-0.5338642001152039,
0.6826168894767761,
0.08466003090143204,
-0.3423202335834503,
-0.5059868097305298,
-0.6380940079689026,
-0.12498382478952408,
-0.2693420946598053,
-0.5665491223335266,
0.21620599925518036,
-0.11867579072713852,
-0.6246843934059143,
-0.03024817816913128,
-0.3529404401779175,
0.16047905385494232,
-0.14785236120224,
0.24436171352863312,
0.3126942813396454,
-0.3123980462551117,
0.16538602113723755,
-0.11034443229436874,
0.060335803776979446,
0.3602314591407776,
-0.1208106055855751,
0.5905685424804688,
-0.0006472694803960621,
-0.5219280123710632,
-0.28580114245414734,
0.26810193061828613,
0.549072802066803,
-0.11357556283473969,
0.6523526310920715,
0.6779016852378845,
-0.2729477286338806,
0.005764959380030632,
-0.6846843361854553,
-0.19101566076278687,
-0.4081436097621918,
0.03269166871905327,
-0.3767401874065399,
-0.9337686896324158,
0.86930251121521,
0.41699349880218506,
-0.015158015303313732,
0.5768110752105713,
0.6263702511787415,
0.04690783843398094,
1.054957389831543,
0.2194194346666336,
0.1296396106481552,
0.6037365794181824,
-0.017444521188735962,
0.05856035649776459,
-0.9959105253219604,
-0.5866439342498779,
-0.4259893000125885,
0.00967969186604023,
-0.8051455616950989,
-0.2900659143924713,
0.3772605359554291,
-0.18802964687347412,
-0.5020630359649658,
-0.3969169557094574,
-0.12977828085422516,
0.41729068756103516,
0.2858082056045532,
-0.1281016618013382,
0.4201085567474365,
-0.34721124172210693,
0.07941839098930359,
-0.22108350694179535,
-0.5922294855117798,
-0.5500299334526062,
0.9789278507232666,
0.4520731270313263,
0.9631583094596863,
0.24453434348106384,
0.2187650054693222,
-0.010493038222193718,
0.1265956610441208,
-0.43775564432144165,
0.3601287007331848,
0.21847771108150482,
-0.48506587743759155,
-0.323968768119812,
-0.43774914741516113,
-1.1056139469146729,
0.1389729231595993,
0.008396586403250694,
-0.5668790936470032,
0.3058629333972931,
-0.22347325086593628,
-0.29026246070861816,
0.32334989309310913,
-0.6435403823852539,
0.6112470626831055,
-0.08442188054323196,
-0.608160674571991,
0.2730166018009186,
-0.6816983819007874,
0.3549842834472656,
0.07428968697786331,
0.12096509337425232,
-0.5782573223114014,
-0.15523090958595276,
0.6122604608535767,
-0.038444217294454575,
0.7983870506286621,
-0.10951933264732361,
-0.21248780190944672,
0.1930621713399887,
0.35183224081993103,
0.8491001129150391,
0.4428536593914032,
0.12327767163515091,
-0.11522887647151947,
0.13901673257350922,
-0.4430951178073883,
-0.6048128604888916,
0.6093241572380066,
-0.805310845375061,
-0.5488970875740051,
-0.5438555479049683,
-0.4437997043132782,
-0.272264301776886,
-0.17047415673732758,
0.3223145008087158,
0.667890727519989,
-0.20066846907138824,
-0.2027057558298111,
0.9728068113327026,
-0.2359529584646225,
0.7729476690292358,
0.8463938236236572,
-0.1451483517885208,
0.337677925825119,
0.2889917194843292,
0.20005111396312714,
0.3197578489780426,
0.5001190900802612,
0.12729595601558685,
-0.5496414303779602,
-0.7174105644226074,
-0.29008516669273376,
0.380622535943985,
-0.6213691234588623,
0.12197552621364594,
-0.9505845308303833,
-0.1588858813047409,
-0.4444059729576111,
0.139409601688385,
-0.056506965309381485,
-0.37401649355888367,
-0.602755606174469,
-0.31712669134140015,
0.4782221019268036,
1.0113636255264282,
0.22680893540382385,
0.05987522006034851,
-0.5280260443687439,
0.21741656959056854,
0.2625601887702942,
0.3350867033004761,
-0.17941027879714966,
-0.5487625598907471,
0.10201407223939896,
-0.2502940893173218,
-0.13077227771282196,
-1.0980792045593262,
0.21538977324962616,
0.05794769152998924,
0.6530200242996216,
0.31742826104164124,
-0.050479501485824585,
0.46371886134147644,
-0.6737259030342102,
1.171141505241394,
-0.3213672637939453,
-0.7729246020317078,
0.5750516057014465,
-0.7954702377319336,
0.5471642017364502,
0.20116779208183289,
0.5230709314346313,
-0.5810365676879883,
-0.5714974999427795,
-0.6151911616325378,
-0.9420400857925415,
0.7469385862350464,
0.26006636023521423,
-0.1209326758980751,
-0.16782663762569427,
0.4478538930416107,
0.3810049295425415,
0.1404651254415512,
-0.9741305708885193,
-0.12120718508958817,
-0.05923580005764961,
0.17641529440879822,
-0.004245677497237921,
-0.40526026487350464,
-0.08528392016887665,
0.05781583487987518,
0.3601490557193756,
-0.11007285863161087,
0.22280141711235046,
0.2782232463359833,
-0.10447153449058533,
-0.00003884374746121466,
0.4730061888694763,
0.6355234384536743,
0.9524067044258118,
-0.29595762491226196,
0.17577813565731049,
0.1484663188457489,
-0.47016099095344543,
-0.1042129397392273,
0.2743217349052429,
-0.23511245846748352,
0.10253489762544632,
0.7330837249755859,
0.713952362537384,
-0.02745978534221649,
-0.29844042658805847,
0.49370402097702026,
-0.12820279598236084,
0.07155095785856247,
-0.4204150140285492,
-0.2656782865524292,
-0.12463028728961945,
0.31843292713165283,
0.5198938250541687,
-0.3418266177177429,
0.15467716753482819,
-0.767816424369812,
-0.08783090859651566,
0.24978311359882355,
-0.2928561270236969,
-0.6405446529388428,
0.7912421226501465,
0.04078689217567444,
0.28022339940071106,
0.6014611124992371,
-0.35198280215263367,
-0.3853111267089844,
0.503886878490448,
0.27738168835639954,
1.0446277856826782,
-0.06801081448793411,
0.09644247591495514,
0.22567850351333618,
0.6036936044692993,
0.11013579368591309,
0.40112215280532837,
0.07293703407049179,
-0.6623166799545288,
-0.7843145728111267,
-0.5774231553077698,
-0.30481085181236267,
0.27173691987991333,
-0.7573053240776062,
-0.10794523358345032,
-0.2559868395328522,
-0.23356832563877106,
-0.038657981902360916,
-0.04821491986513138,
-0.9796896576881409,
-0.12558375298976898,
0.05362989008426666,
0.7011518478393555,
-0.7826041579246521,
0.5851216316223145,
0.4112575650215149,
-0.5364099740982056,
-0.5182832479476929,
0.2605392634868622,
0.2022571563720703,
-0.6566026210784912,
0.806183397769928,
-0.13880106806755066,
-0.0814017727971077,
-0.37202188372612,
-0.46838101744651794,
-0.732823371887207,
1.0825711488723755,
0.2229253202676773,
-0.45073202252388,
-0.4245459735393524,
0.13981333374977112,
0.5943998694419861,
-0.2317895144224167,
0.36086127161979675,
0.9129602313041687,
0.5404515862464905,
-0.02900218963623047,
-0.9416337609291077,
0.2216367870569229,
-0.09756080061197281,
-0.058732692152261734,
0.3655819296836853,
-0.5389601588249207,
0.9769675135612488,
-0.18290108442306519,
-0.7877735495567322,
-0.22026962041854858,
0.5638678073883057,
0.0559760257601738,
0.6262141466140747,
0.1143484115600586,
0.17820629477500916,
0.6185760498046875,
-0.539068877696991,
1.1726560592651367,
0.1298629194498062,
-0.0338771678507328,
1.3064335584640503,
-0.5294549465179443,
0.38677978515625,
0.5914652347564697,
-0.5394461750984192,
0.5669010877609253,
0.8598812818527222,
0.28234171867370605,
0.27012431621551514,
0.05168325826525688,
-0.37064626812934875,
-0.07485392689704895,
0.009853647090494633,
-0.5172629952430725,
0.09164762496948242,
0.4262881875038147,
-0.017178770154714584,
-0.35225948691368103,
-0.23362398147583008,
0.2372066229581833,
-0.1435786336660385,
-0.33511534333229065,
0.7601187229156494,
-0.1702290028333664,
-0.5971315503120422,
0.037823159247636795,
-0.2372756004333496,
0.5541523098945618,
-0.6312466859817505,
0.03454054519534111,
-0.43898725509643555,
-0.2706638276576996,
-0.13695968687534332,
-1.139959454536438,
0.18803510069847107,
0.026256950572133064,
-0.39851072430610657,
-0.15929530560970306,
0.18897947669029236,
-0.3117924928665161,
-0.1088828444480896,
0.3530113101005554,
0.5721744298934937,
-0.0152653269469738,
-0.21031193435192108,
-0.3384243845939636,
0.19077357649803162,
-0.05975126847624779,
-0.2565135657787323,
0.16452153027057648,
0.9781896471977234,
-0.1924225091934204,
0.7907321453094482,
0.5229120850563049,
0.10984417051076889,
0.4667755365371704,
0.5511936545372009,
0.8068444132804871,
-0.7553001046180725,
-0.38560378551483154,
-1.1386051177978516,
0.27104243636131287,
0.14109060168266296,
-0.2966669201850891,
0.7843227386474609,
0.6134661436080933,
0.8105069994926453,
0.24320879578590393,
0.6342077851295471,
0.28535687923431396,
0.5885022878646851,
-1.0469229221343994,
0.18324726819992065,
-0.09907659143209457,
0.6328006982803345,
-0.05231725051999092,
-0.6785526275634766,
0.02560316026210785,
-0.04524780437350273,
-0.49113625288009644,
0.3174816966056824,
0.8208374381065369,
0.4558224678039551,
0.34715536236763,
0.31654924154281616,
0.02220366708934307,
0.3266674280166626,
0.5123085379600525,
0.6893613338470459,
1.5828216075897217,
-0.06900493800640106,
0.4425971806049347,
0.1537153571844101,
-0.10586095601320267,
-0.07654444873332977,
-0.9543445110321045,
-0.9272947907447815,
-0.6888516545295715,
-0.2838992178440094,
-0.24171259999275208,
0.15547779202461243,
0.8850535750389099,
0.3303920030593872,
-0.6187218427658081,
0.13832926750183105,
0.17058925330638885,
0.07770680636167526,
0.14795330166816711,
-0.32651859521865845,
0.3730703294277191,
-0.45419400930404663,
-0.8345568776130676,
0.24978971481323242,
0.2571007311344147,
0.4378397762775421,
-0.08824217319488525,
0.1458086222410202,
-0.03752247244119644,
0.13319896161556244,
0.6884255409240723,
0.22244371473789215,
-0.8574912548065186,
-0.26530811190605164,
0.0019606442656368017,
-0.030354922637343407,
-0.04489939659833908,
1.0109447240829468,
-0.7975215911865234,
0.1933201253414154,
0.434593141078949,
0.445268452167511,
0.7641514539718628,
-0.10135375708341599,
0.6977107524871826,
-0.7717053890228271,
-0.13071788847446442,
0.47617337107658386,
0.3111502528190613,
0.3417164087295532,
-0.4999612271785736,
0.6441695690155029,
0.35692620277404785,
-0.7608681321144104,
-0.7920043468475342,
0.41766005754470825,
-0.9491984248161316,
-0.3061473071575165,
1.4079450368881226,
0.3884405493736267,
0.17633572220802307,
-0.329339861869812,
0.038067080080509186,
0.18234199285507202,
-0.3457191288471222,
0.6895552277565002,
0.9530001282691956,
-0.5754489898681641,
-0.10383065789937973,
-0.955904483795166,
0.899330198764801,
0.22422774136066437,
-0.6417568325996399,
0.09634531289339066,
0.6191564798355103,
0.2862793505191803,
-0.15374808013439178,
0.7288591861724854,
-0.4435751736164093,
0.2062099725008011,
-0.1460372507572174,
-0.32617318630218506,
-0.0023052191827446222,
-0.17820580303668976,
-0.44598913192749023,
-0.022189326584339142,
-0.0024426484014838934,
-0.0008562810253351927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01443v1
|
Enterprise Use Cases Combining Knowledge Graphs and Natural Language Processing
| 2024-04-01T19:28:52 | 2024-04-01T19:28:52 |
Phillip Schneider, Tim Schopf, Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge management is a critical challenge for enterprises in today's
digital world, as the volume and complexity of data being generated and
collected continue to grow incessantly. Knowledge graphs (KG) emerged as a
promising solution to this problem by providing a flexible, scalable, and
semantically rich way to organize and make sense of data. This paper builds
upon a recent survey of the research literature on combining KGs and Natural
Language Processing (NLP). Based on selected application scenarios from
enterprise context, we discuss synergies that result from such a combination.
We cover various approaches from the three core areas of KG construction,
reasoning as well as KG-based NLP tasks. In addition to explaining innovative
enterprise use cases, we assess their maturity in terms of practical
applicability and conclude with an outlook on emergent application areas for
the future.
|
[
-0.8055669069290161,
-0.7470254302024841,
0.6100565791130066,
0.10739459842443466,
-0.07517290115356445,
0.20631733536720276,
0.04622078314423561,
-0.8379867076873779,
0.2895236015319824,
0.833256721496582,
-0.4552203416824341,
-0.5352198481559753,
-0.3409906327724457,
0.10716670006513596,
-0.39120951294898987,
0.6032023429870605,
-0.15324687957763672,
-0.17802919447422028,
-0.5002253651618958,
-0.42825913429260254,
-0.8202658891677856,
-0.733257532119751,
-0.9086282849311829,
-0.5567176938056946,
0.40230515599250793,
0.5269730091094971,
0.9698352813720703,
0.37944334745407104,
0.5038235783576965,
0.3041020929813385,
0.15678438544273376,
0.3325425386428833,
0.10791438072919846,
0.4366549849510193,
-0.09212885051965714,
-0.2621276080608368,
-0.6428035497665405,
-0.16452869772911072,
0.301496297121048,
1.1439940929412842,
-0.3766725957393646,
-0.1804163157939911,
-0.12538844347000122,
1.024616003036499,
-0.45717188715934753,
0.1800200641155243,
-0.2836305797100067,
0.32678845524787903,
-0.12146821618080139,
-0.1627381592988968,
-0.19613772630691528,
-0.2221124768257141,
0.1803598254919052,
-0.6304742097854614,
-0.2005234807729721,
0.5015669465065002,
0.7515894174575806,
-0.15405581891536713,
-0.6101453900337219,
-0.730652928352356,
-0.9214849472045898,
0.6355178952217102,
-0.6182231903076172,
0.6056751012802124,
0.32887548208236694,
0.6606435179710388,
-0.34178388118743896,
-1.3165546655654907,
-0.5770837068557739,
0.22640196979045868,
-0.3904827833175659,
0.13785909116268158,
-0.6023125648498535,
-0.0043214717879891396,
0.15520727634429932,
0.3628500998020172,
-0.5085685849189758,
0.2988373935222626,
-0.48435312509536743,
-0.01274972502142191,
0.3976726830005646,
0.40112704038619995,
0.5127254724502563,
-0.06748427450656891,
-0.19896258413791656,
-0.13703206181526184,
-0.48758068680763245,
-0.1256987750530243,
0.28522732853889465,
0.25189200043678284,
0.3414645195007324,
0.889758825302124,
-0.5034661889076233,
1.285484790802002,
-0.33004656434059143,
0.07982237637042999,
0.12108439952135086,
-0.24394367635250092,
-0.6058515310287476,
0.07705072313547134,
0.7106929421424866,
0.6365607976913452,
0.36727800965309143,
-0.6981757879257202,
0.15360058844089508,
0.11354086548089981,
0.430563747882843,
-0.4754909574985504,
-0.30223819613456726,
0.47354593873023987,
-0.3223787248134613,
-0.13750594854354858,
-0.19294938445091248,
-0.7093549966812134,
-0.5825203061103821,
-0.5571394562721252,
0.068893663585186,
-0.7240844964981079,
-0.272726833820343,
0.19732330739498138,
-0.5370249152183533,
0.10065284371376038,
0.23632153868675232,
-0.8652709126472473,
0.5971077084541321,
0.637748122215271,
0.6484358906745911,
0.04143610596656799,
-0.050859007984399796,
-0.08722911030054092,
0.6741159558296204,
-0.1530032753944397,
0.7782655358314514,
-0.292896568775177,
-0.22605471312999725,
-0.08093799650669098,
-0.33835113048553467,
-0.01675170660018921,
-0.9451143145561218,
0.8071119785308838,
-0.8559013605117798,
0.21218355000019073,
-0.16200274229049683,
-0.7876660227775574,
-0.3892304599285126,
0.6092174649238586,
-0.8603277206420898,
0.9857251048088074,
-0.025719687342643738,
-0.7245488166809082,
0.838539183139801,
-0.8045760989189148,
-0.7022400498390198,
0.37453198432922363,
0.2174224853515625,
-0.29005634784698486,
-0.22458043694496155,
0.2836456298828125,
0.7122052907943726,
-0.14750568568706512,
0.09253110736608505,
-0.29411953687667847,
0.291443407535553,
-0.07617053389549255,
0.4756186306476593,
0.6542791724205017,
0.4361027479171753,
0.20946885645389557,
-0.2949381470680237,
-0.8435949683189392,
0.5206828117370605,
0.15203866362571716,
-0.09329626709222794,
-0.8695024847984314,
0.26184597611427307,
-0.16622819006443024,
0.1331024318933487,
0.1833990514278412,
-0.16890756785869598,
0.12614797055721283,
-0.21816234290599823,
0.48453396558761597,
0.015463086776435375,
0.13544774055480957,
0.5980998873710632,
-0.2073034942150116,
0.3371715545654297,
0.04317041486501694,
0.015453029423952103,
0.25287601351737976,
-0.5957632660865784,
-0.5496519804000854,
0.019647574052214622,
0.011429798789322376,
0.5453943014144897,
-1.0542325973510742,
0.24706585705280304,
-0.13048014044761658,
-0.7120137214660645,
-0.03581540659070015,
0.11037369072437286,
-0.34738612174987793,
0.6764054298400879,
0.4905215799808502,
-0.4102444648742676,
-0.7471362948417664,
-0.9557190537452698,
-0.5933118462562561,
-0.36496075987815857,
-0.12503276765346527,
0.5003668069839478,
0.09778261184692383,
-0.3157225251197815,
1.5451905727386475,
-0.6779859066009521,
-0.46203184127807617,
-0.7023530006408691,
0.3462557792663574,
0.35206812620162964,
-0.009524021297693253,
0.4484175443649292,
-1.321731686592102,
-0.5459682941436768,
0.3548901379108429,
-0.9651640057563782,
-0.10495910048484802,
0.1597457081079483,
-0.18066512048244476,
0.03195016831159592,
0.35427209734916687,
-0.4427102506160736,
0.11813101172447205,
0.37687748670578003,
-0.4027516841888428,
0.5225002765655518,
-0.13502240180969238,
0.2676100730895996,
-0.9799064993858337,
-0.07636166363954544,
-0.11490268260240555,
-0.3752971291542053,
-1.053936243057251,
-0.14650537073612213,
0.007909220643341541,
-0.3679552376270294,
-0.15993741154670715,
0.42723095417022705,
-0.3630695939064026,
-0.259551465511322,
-0.15912187099456787,
0.3655529320240021,
0.13534842431545258,
0.19780340790748596,
0.06760497391223907,
0.464931845664978,
0.3772446811199188,
-0.9244683980941772,
0.8302763104438782,
0.32213732600212097,
-0.42116209864616394,
0.8758705854415894,
-0.4558720886707306,
-0.10952119529247284,
-0.02705124206840992,
-0.11025182902812958,
-0.3570380210876465,
-0.24134916067123413,
-0.0143740838393569,
-0.23092864453792572,
0.053075242787599564,
0.035367611795663834,
-0.8579628467559814,
-0.8160800337791443,
0.03986931964755058,
-0.20663808286190033,
0.3402392268180847,
-0.34435197710990906,
0.8831881880760193,
0.6168361902236938,
-0.21238474547863007,
-0.22511154413223267,
-0.8546817898750305,
0.5619627237319946,
-0.5393686294555664,
-1.1462972164154053,
0.4476925730705261,
0.3598070442676544,
-0.39032116532325745,
0.5532509684562683,
-0.2229033261537552,
-0.5177242159843445,
0.06454312801361084,
0.05952136591076851,
0.023888835683465004,
-0.033095259219408035,
-0.0074975634925067425,
-0.26990023255348206,
-0.05462932214140892,
-0.10902848094701767,
-0.4857853949069977,
0.3187134563922882,
-0.11399459838867188,
-0.29216817021369934,
0.029493998736143112,
0.42604315280914307,
0.5533164739608765,
0.0806884765625,
1.1088168621063232,
0.4709593951702118,
-0.5963401794433594,
-0.19084571301937103,
-0.5612760186195374,
0.11430204659700394,
-0.46429502964019775,
0.20308397710323334,
-0.04974997416138649,
-0.9033007025718689,
0.4754675328731537,
-0.5504007935523987,
0.003122568130493164,
0.20683486759662628,
0.3884495794773102,
-0.4973146617412567,
0.7520356178283691,
0.8034120798110962,
0.0675099715590477,
0.3746362626552582,
-0.15583436191082,
1.0827207565307617,
-0.6491957902908325,
-0.45713886618614197,
-0.4499240815639496,
-0.27812162041664124,
-0.22344814240932465,
0.06457217037677765,
0.5753465890884399,
0.6667075753211975,
0.06447834521532059,
0.6640120148658752,
-0.17097005248069763,
0.4285740256309509,
0.41799846291542053,
-0.3934256434440613,
0.5673953890800476,
0.010663529857993126,
-0.25150129199028015,
-0.15556007623672485,
-0.8723673224449158,
-0.6058008670806885,
0.6607066988945007,
-0.0795360803604126,
0.36249488592147827,
0.17312265932559967,
0.4680405557155609,
0.5941147804260254,
0.21395644545555115,
-0.7430262565612793,
0.6707415580749512,
-0.3448215425014496,
-0.6469924449920654,
-0.3528098464012146,
-0.6324307918548584,
-1.0018645524978638,
0.17890824377536774,
-0.21060463786125183,
-1.0799373388290405,
-0.23598387837409973,
0.23194508254528046,
-0.0346842035651207,
0.4521040916442871,
-1.2922176122665405,
1.1118171215057373,
-0.25696995854377747,
0.01240958645939827,
-0.03251734375953674,
-0.3660862445831299,
0.38716962933540344,
0.11795511841773987,
0.46150532364845276,
0.11021865159273148,
0.38567090034484863,
0.8787944912910461,
-0.6790549755096436,
0.42122408747673035,
-0.10754507035017014,
0.32490304112434387,
0.5174917578697205,
-0.04010828584432602,
0.5308204889297485,
-0.3467058837413788,
-0.06522975116968155,
-0.105904720723629,
-0.0031528682447969913,
-0.08124619722366333,
-0.7201805710792542,
0.26857689023017883,
-0.32643866539001465,
-0.3359079957008362,
-0.22101330757141113,
-0.5048476457595825,
-0.7338408827781677,
0.5355339050292969,
-0.15423327684402466,
0.32210689783096313,
-0.15831077098846436,
0.257572203874588,
0.22544996440410614,
-0.07890183478593826,
0.5543527007102966,
0.4178240895271301,
-0.19911198318004608,
-0.3708323538303375,
0.6364665031433105,
0.36205363273620605,
0.24979963898658752,
0.27395105361938477,
0.030264122411608696,
-0.28085777163505554,
-0.5120190382003784,
-0.330490380525589,
0.06768229603767395,
-0.8333448171615601,
-0.2480020523071289,
-0.6750335097312927,
-0.07367512583732605,
-0.37369033694267273,
-0.5320870280265808,
-0.10500289499759674,
-0.5568273067474365,
0.1558152437210083,
-0.12792076170444489,
0.38261041045188904,
0.8629555702209473,
0.124061219394207,
0.1814001500606537,
-0.9185032844543457,
0.3594546616077423,
0.4997943937778473,
0.4766364097595215,
0.19269976019859314,
0.46652400493621826,
-0.6450160145759583,
-0.1512620598077774,
-0.3301908075809479,
-0.9440265893936157,
0.6348984241485596,
-0.15726864337921143,
0.7381507754325867,
-0.009009232744574547,
0.09370025992393494,
0.6677410006523132,
-0.30274495482444763,
0.6705427765846252,
0.29275384545326233,
-0.5971421003341675,
0.34985411167144775,
-0.3197290003299713,
0.007257917430251837,
0.5451558828353882,
0.48623016476631165,
-1.0675371885299683,
-0.32228153944015503,
-0.5046830177307129,
-1.4081960916519165,
0.7587108612060547,
0.3858858644962311,
-0.4066111147403717,
0.22438299655914307,
0.10719060897827148,
-0.24192586541175842,
0.35516422986984253,
-0.5379692912101746,
-0.43716782331466675,
0.09777827560901642,
-0.19942285120487213,
0.35382235050201416,
-0.10060633718967438,
-0.1339876800775528,
-0.10848084837198257,
0.6891067028045654,
0.05585510656237602,
0.12206871062517166,
-0.12587861716747284,
-0.2293352633714676,
0.3491915166378021,
0.40288597345352173,
-0.13841429352760315,
0.7126608490943909,
-0.135925754904747,
0.267871618270874,
0.20527143776416779,
-0.40401896834373474,
-0.2687831223011017,
-0.11363194137811661,
-0.09856237471103668,
-0.30902212858200073,
0.08409785479307175,
0.7181670069694519,
-0.11386366933584213,
-0.5219584703445435,
0.13440069556236267,
-0.029990561306476593,
-0.1035209372639656,
-0.2900828421115875,
0.01699204556643963,
0.5505671501159668,
0.36585214734077454,
0.3891477882862091,
-0.0568372942507267,
0.16789457201957703,
-0.6009551882743835,
0.12581202387809753,
0.27375251054763794,
-0.21109044551849365,
0.215103879570961,
0.48709532618522644,
0.09119143337011337,
-0.14125695824623108,
0.6882040500640869,
-0.5123928189277649,
-0.6203413605690002,
0.7415367364883423,
0.6095170974731445,
0.6235664486885071,
0.33822008967399597,
0.21848919987678528,
-0.049864765256643295,
0.20930267870426178,
-0.03075249493122101,
0.11889141798019409,
-0.14069527387619019,
-1.1328215599060059,
-0.4085932970046997,
-0.610690712928772,
-0.7613343000411987,
-0.06081438437104225,
-0.6046066284179688,
0.49200963973999023,
-0.05147923529148102,
-0.17603318393230438,
0.27589190006256104,
0.1434321254491806,
-0.6601054072380066,
0.3397441804409027,
-0.004671735689043999,
0.9637307524681091,
-0.8749059438705444,
0.5989338755607605,
1.109539270401001,
-0.09164126217365265,
-0.7429348230361938,
-0.4547296464443207,
-0.10420140624046326,
-0.6915326714515686,
0.5530454516410828,
-0.03740943223237991,
0.06691182404756546,
-0.024036461487412453,
0.08215709030628204,
-0.42182910442352295,
1.3242170810699463,
-0.08576472848653793,
-0.2201193869113922,
0.29739853739738464,
0.4048703610897064,
0.5564109683036804,
-0.1891229748725891,
-0.1512310653924942,
0.9355194568634033,
0.6888144016265869,
0.28900060057640076,
-0.47141990065574646,
-0.19875967502593994,
-0.03430790826678276,
-0.2157224863767624,
0.6036562323570251,
-0.18647697567939758,
0.39130881428718567,
0.14233750104904175,
-0.45974811911582947,
-0.46919217705726624,
0.6017023921012878,
0.08114846795797348,
0.8100649118423462,
0.5370635390281677,
1.093625783920288,
0.9181254506111145,
-0.12020193785429001,
0.9380942583084106,
-0.22812829911708832,
0.14537903666496277,
0.7809751033782959,
-0.4363381266593933,
0.41415730118751526,
0.5525838136672974,
-0.4968128800392151,
0.6629665493965149,
0.349918007850647,
0.06858492642641068,
0.4143025279045105,
-0.18208809196949005,
-0.26356807351112366,
0.04049158841371536,
-0.1660757213830948,
-0.14172877371311188,
0.06741098314523697,
0.5864468216896057,
0.04750031232833862,
-0.3953498601913452,
-0.05237165465950966,
0.33829420804977417,
0.04947719722986221,
-0.38225671648979187,
0.8132593631744385,
0.18269886076450348,
-0.5047509670257568,
-0.19286420941352844,
0.29870152473449707,
0.350775808095932,
-0.7358090877532959,
0.13557544350624084,
0.17936241626739502,
-0.057569023221731186,
-0.47719964385032654,
-1.2076964378356934,
0.9003088474273682,
0.08803390711545944,
-0.2343508005142212,
-0.8222610950469971,
1.1348121166229248,
-0.14605489373207092,
-0.10196871310472488,
0.4913850724697113,
0.6539984941482544,
-0.17766152322292328,
-0.027223816141486168,
-0.21548543870449066,
-0.4458009600639343,
-0.2679716944694519,
-0.24114221334457397,
0.1519472748041153,
0.7375698685646057,
-0.16554874181747437,
0.7323664426803589,
0.43653130531311035,
0.09774643927812576,
0.21736620366573334,
0.19109715521335602,
0.8093029260635376,
-0.7565241456031799,
-0.6743879318237305,
-0.6991612911224365,
0.3947293758392334,
-0.518290102481842,
-0.006264417432248592,
0.8252283334732056,
0.5802220702171326,
0.6460872292518616,
0.24428296089172363,
0.7755679488182068,
-0.7620075941085815,
0.40918755531311035,
-0.6317339539527893,
0.5046364068984985,
-0.46424394845962524,
0.1381172239780426,
-0.26773419976234436,
-0.7865644097328186,
-0.5721269845962524,
0.1973637491464615,
-0.5234702825546265,
0.03343850001692772,
0.7546961307525635,
0.3298099637031555,
-0.08110277354717255,
0.4291117489337921,
0.32086119055747986,
0.021632926538586617,
0.23425084352493286,
0.4554321765899658,
0.5108680725097656,
-0.11816895753145218,
0.6088380217552185,
-0.33339494466781616,
0.06015999615192413,
-0.09760017693042755,
-1.1434937715530396,
-0.5067139863967896,
-0.623063862323761,
-0.16694992780685425,
-0.19823703169822693,
-0.29684701561927795,
0.34720900654792786,
0.559009850025177,
-0.6497817039489746,
-0.16179457306861877,
-0.3718280792236328,
0.41106361150741577,
-0.32534292340278625,
-0.3093942701816559,
0.12525497376918793,
-0.3626316785812378,
-0.4467177391052246,
0.3449540138244629,
0.5691879987716675,
0.0884835422039032,
0.1815282702445984,
-0.0659523606300354,
0.013437594287097454,
-0.31390002369880676,
0.6361513137817383,
0.5945315957069397,
-0.03799659386277199,
-0.059974510222673416,
-0.02600010670721531,
0.1419534534215927,
-0.21568788588047028,
1.0686570405960083,
-0.9975206255912781,
0.5570359826087952,
0.5716301798820496,
0.7554481625556946,
0.8744815587997437,
-0.19607993960380554,
0.7698138356208801,
-0.9560768008232117,
-0.10786265879869461,
0.35147756338119507,
0.49074313044548035,
0.5848290920257568,
-0.2432083934545517,
0.7103641629219055,
0.35941264033317566,
-0.39574483036994934,
-0.6972403526306152,
0.45778632164001465,
-1.031735897064209,
-0.3588753044605255,
0.7418729066848755,
0.3276572823524475,
0.1847480833530426,
-0.5528634190559387,
0.17274951934814453,
0.23557214438915253,
-0.044419076293706894,
0.5361164212226868,
1.1524509191513062,
-0.684635579586029,
0.07326719909906387,
-0.9223834872245789,
0.2088494449853897,
0.21989503502845764,
-1.0080126523971558,
-0.13060374557971954,
0.29054734110832214,
-0.13895678520202637,
0.22006304562091827,
0.6086792349815369,
-0.01426193118095398,
-0.1726246327161789,
-0.06961292773485184,
0.07564669847488403,
-0.3078577518463135,
-0.303053617477417,
0.2085421234369278,
0.472356379032135,
0.052470821887254715,
0.14296771585941315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01439v1
|
Creating emoji lexica from unsupervised sentiment analysis of their descriptions
| 2024-04-01T19:22:58 | 2024-04-01T19:22:58 |
Milagros Fernández-Gavilanes, Jonathan Juncal-Martínez, Silvia García-Méndez, Enrique Costa-Montenegro, Francisco Javier González-Castaño
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Online media, such as blogs and social networking sites, generate massive
volumes of unstructured data of great interest to analyze the opinions and
sentiments of individuals and organizations. Novel approaches beyond Natural
Language Processing are necessary to quantify these opinions with polarity
metrics. So far, the sentiment expressed by emojis has received little
attention. The use of symbols, however, has boomed in the past four years.
About twenty billion are typed in Twitter nowadays, and new emojis keep
appearing in each new Unicode version, making them increasingly relevant to
sentiment analysis tasks. This has motivated us to propose a novel approach to
predict the sentiments expressed by emojis in online textual messages, such as
tweets, that does not require human effort to manually annotate data and saves
valuable time for other analysis tasks. For this purpose, we automatically
constructed a novel emoji sentiment lexicon using an unsupervised sentiment
analysis system based on the definitions given by emoji creators in Emojipedia.
Additionally, we automatically created lexicon variants by also considering the
sentiment distribution of the informal texts accompanying emojis. All these
lexica are evaluated and compared regarding the improvement obtained by
including them in sentiment analysis of the annotated datasets provided by
Kralj Novak et al. (2015). The results confirm the competitiveness of our
approach.
|
[
-0.6698086857795715,
-0.5182000398635864,
0.300358384847641,
0.28566494584083557,
-0.6638069152832031,
0.42034685611724854,
-0.4345610439777374,
-0.474018394947052,
1.031205415725708,
0.27776992321014404,
-0.45744237303733826,
-0.6089954972267151,
-0.5332889556884766,
0.41169920563697815,
-0.013781508430838585,
1.1004186868667603,
0.03533078357577324,
0.008275311440229416,
-0.21438057720661163,
-0.3088090121746063,
-0.022531883791089058,
-0.35030069947242737,
-0.1804661899805069,
0.09817864000797272,
0.47466349601745605,
0.33742082118988037,
0.6993957161903381,
0.015971338376402855,
0.4733208417892456,
0.21379421651363373,
-0.22350844740867615,
0.22857098281383514,
-0.07261849194765091,
-0.027676882222294807,
0.1384495049715042,
-0.1250799149274826,
-0.23888564109802246,
-0.032507337629795074,
0.18622413277626038,
0.5643638372421265,
-0.16407573223114014,
0.0342353992164135,
0.010707566514611244,
0.5373520851135254,
-0.6598291397094727,
0.2360585629940033,
-0.6902834177017212,
0.3088780343532562,
-0.23538105189800262,
-0.2692298889160156,
-0.1355752944946289,
-0.5122846364974976,
-0.03736189752817154,
-0.30155879259109497,
-0.13541734218597412,
-0.18647396564483643,
0.5893901586532593,
-0.13259769976139069,
-0.12332743406295776,
-0.42210114002227783,
-0.5374502539634705,
0.7593194842338562,
-0.6161577701568604,
0.03635463863611221,
-0.08654634654521942,
0.3031761646270752,
-0.04704636335372925,
-0.399753212928772,
-0.45232170820236206,
0.047087162733078,
0.20148591697216034,
0.3141271770000458,
-0.1610921323299408,
-0.2076791226863861,
-0.12817463278770447,
0.2776567041873932,
-0.26921650767326355,
-0.03434813395142555,
-0.03453705087304115,
0.053236305713653564,
0.5530319213867188,
0.037806108593940735,
0.3889463245868683,
-0.45677071809768677,
-0.27286335825920105,
0.14547640085220337,
-0.5931993722915649,
0.054504264146089554,
0.3782157897949219,
0.32719239592552185,
-0.14870037138462067,
0.6861604452133179,
-0.3598192036151886,
0.2043933868408203,
0.007592472713440657,
0.13294914364814758,
0.5838571190834045,
-0.23553629219532013,
-0.10119106620550156,
-0.0693282037973404,
1.0761696100234985,
0.7040743231773376,
0.6968229413032532,
-0.2196856290102005,
-0.25226855278015137,
0.25089675188064575,
0.28613024950027466,
-0.5759584903717041,
-0.291145920753479,
0.28437045216560364,
-0.5696956515312195,
-0.7724506855010986,
0.25645115971565247,
-1.0764453411102295,
-0.730044960975647,
-0.048940692096948624,
0.0353504903614521,
-0.12297537177801132,
-0.2101786881685257,
-0.3725331425666809,
-0.2432749718427658,
-0.1856551468372345,
0.2813664972782135,
-0.6833467483520508,
-0.12610088288784027,
0.5836507081985474,
0.9110974669456482,
0.21508845686912537,
0.3139547109603882,
-0.056108247488737106,
-0.09326466172933578,
-0.3823007643222809,
0.8245546221733093,
-0.680522620677948,
-0.4171175956726074,
0.33856940269470215,
-0.27718013525009155,
0.3165223300457001,
-0.03711134195327759,
0.5387054681777954,
-0.3635709285736084,
-0.010016116313636303,
-0.32470157742500305,
-0.5704762935638428,
-0.05872460827231407,
0.18515074253082275,
-0.6276682019233704,
0.6117132306098938,
-0.04455985128879547,
-1.3727052211761475,
0.5029786825180054,
-0.8479158878326416,
-0.5078531503677368,
0.37775281071662903,
-0.19697855412960052,
-0.39950045943260193,
0.4866112470626831,
0.7594936490058899,
0.8314417004585266,
-0.33550015091896057,
-0.09619291871786118,
-0.5851160287857056,
-0.04235917329788208,
0.7496982216835022,
0.15871819853782654,
0.9291694164276123,
0.35051241517066956,
-0.28305524587631226,
-0.1350867599248886,
-0.37551242113113403,
-0.0724676251411438,
0.18748772144317627,
0.08777819573879242,
-0.5396775603294373,
0.06932809948921204,
0.2256244719028473,
0.013649605214595795,
0.3439301550388336,
-1.04011869430542,
0.06958754360675812,
-0.5131143927574158,
0.4499634802341461,
0.7395637035369873,
0.16402223706245422,
0.41625815629959106,
0.1000119224190712,
0.40456339716911316,
-0.061372190713882446,
0.5904891490936279,
-0.004989180248230696,
-0.7647969126701355,
-0.4994039237499237,
-0.3306998610496521,
0.11303775012493134,
0.26120564341545105,
-0.8572889566421509,
0.6400417685508728,
-0.5271023511886597,
-0.6959596872329712,
-0.46248137950897217,
0.06550951302051544,
0.02774232067167759,
0.04596543312072754,
0.13130760192871094,
-0.3010663688182831,
-0.581863284111023,
-0.7046594619750977,
-0.5723341703414917,
-0.25857287645339966,
-0.08287665992975235,
0.32404232025146484,
0.16581295430660248,
-0.3216860294342041,
0.9864324331283569,
-0.4733012020587921,
-0.40441808104515076,
-0.4560813307762146,
0.37028768658638,
0.11069924384355545,
-0.08449280261993408,
0.48683542013168335,
-0.699903130531311,
-0.5365314483642578,
0.16577643156051636,
-0.7407364845275879,
-0.21174746751785278,
-0.0581766739487648,
0.10737469047307968,
0.41863182187080383,
0.23220305144786835,
-0.3132203221321106,
0.24433009326457977,
0.46757492423057556,
-0.21977753937244415,
-0.013747906312346458,
0.3277817368507385,
0.3153321146965027,
-1.2596120834350586,
-0.001636676723137498,
0.24065335094928741,
0.0462375208735466,
-0.4386371970176697,
-0.06624992936849594,
0.003297509392723441,
0.10689637809991837,
-0.4817662239074707,
0.33460596203804016,
-0.4953758120536804,
-0.04647161066532135,
-0.15663990378379822,
0.21239855885505676,
-0.30330342054367065,
0.3581112027168274,
-0.24552218616008759,
0.2243945598602295,
0.46111974120140076,
-0.06538322567939758,
0.5246015191078186,
0.17007103562355042,
-0.3892330229282379,
0.234389066696167,
-0.3907390832901001,
0.12974417209625244,
-0.20509324967861176,
0.19617781043052673,
-0.8771869540214539,
-0.1187155470252037,
0.533751904964447,
-0.7647768259048462,
0.021459484472870827,
-0.18947859108448029,
-0.5856837630271912,
-0.4157043993473053,
-0.6025815606117249,
0.18197408318519592,
0.5294579267501831,
-0.6855018734931946,
0.8898412585258484,
0.9047334790229797,
-0.05884691700339317,
-0.47097036242485046,
-0.7933645248413086,
0.4150479733943939,
-0.17942993342876434,
-0.4610806405544281,
-0.12899594008922577,
0.09901504963636398,
-0.25864359736442566,
-0.059798549860715866,
0.377493292093277,
0.05018754303455353,
0.18936771154403687,
0.4453600347042084,
0.26044169068336487,
0.2754751443862915,
0.07461531460285187,
0.22240076959133148,
0.19691964983940125,
0.27529972791671753,
0.006237563211470842,
0.4144526720046997,
-0.1454378068447113,
0.10757263004779816,
-0.4942353665828705,
0.2893269956111908,
0.5698366165161133,
-0.20158249139785767,
0.7153221368789673,
0.6768113970756531,
-0.40312039852142334,
-0.16097819805145264,
-0.5517839789390564,
0.06903549283742905,
-0.4447031319141388,
0.04535912349820137,
-0.1993005871772766,
-0.6370545029640198,
0.4494076371192932,
0.1894981861114502,
0.1570746898651123,
0.43111181259155273,
0.6234918832778931,
-0.03612597659230232,
1.179020881652832,
0.2925337851047516,
-0.17395810782909393,
0.6352384090423584,
-0.09163858741521835,
0.47748276591300964,
-0.503315806388855,
-0.36672407388687134,
-0.3740232288837433,
-0.05438493937253952,
-0.9962367415428162,
-0.2161290943622589,
0.21524015069007874,
-0.45032015442848206,
0.23909388482570648,
0.30899766087532043,
-0.5592607259750366,
0.3366782069206238,
0.08934219926595688,
0.058287106454372406,
-0.07187383621931076,
0.4716033935546875,
-0.054170310497283936,
0.054793260991573334,
-0.41635647416114807,
-0.6434217095375061,
1.3214340209960938,
0.4785078465938568,
0.6071580052375793,
-0.0021804587449878454,
0.8920732736587524,
0.5172317624092102,
0.5688749551773071,
-0.7848056554794312,
0.5665472149848938,
-0.4184226989746094,
-0.13331876695156097,
0.011101018637418747,
-0.5216559767723083,
-0.6807854771614075,
0.05403532087802887,
-0.4904116094112396,
-0.607361912727356,
-0.07551262527704239,
-0.12109401077032089,
-0.15424315631389618,
0.3536272943019867,
-0.39300256967544556,
0.5999647378921509,
-0.022464077919721603,
0.13624075055122375,
-0.23256534337997437,
-0.5650861263275146,
0.08483537286520004,
-0.04193532466888428,
0.4241480827331543,
-0.31050780415534973,
-0.16203853487968445,
0.783420741558075,
-0.2783489227294922,
0.8905718922615051,
-0.2734171748161316,
-0.03326290845870972,
0.5287811160087585,
0.013396335765719414,
0.2855333387851715,
0.30224576592445374,
0.07880647480487823,
0.5944737792015076,
-0.09466949850320816,
-0.27708694338798523,
-0.5649772882461548,
0.9676898121833801,
-0.6911675930023193,
-0.0017331548733636737,
-0.2704731523990631,
0.020039014518260956,
-0.18519406020641327,
-0.023126285523176193,
0.2329871505498886,
0.46198180317878723,
-0.6204649806022644,
-0.02000732719898224,
0.14046061038970947,
-0.07924076914787292,
0.7116864919662476,
-0.1393888294696808,
0.030157336965203285,
-0.8931482434272766,
0.8004794716835022,
0.02994397282600403,
-0.42055559158325195,
0.5145398378372192,
0.44617152214050293,
-0.44168272614479065,
-0.12814687192440033,
-0.5988613367080688,
0.10145081579685211,
-0.6957517862319946,
-0.2250625193119049,
-0.869842529296875,
0.2397855520248413,
-0.6374918818473816,
-0.3354538083076477,
-0.26363256573677063,
-0.6240369081497192,
-0.42378321290016174,
0.1812862753868103,
0.5908857583999634,
0.9113985896110535,
0.05613661929965019,
0.01393645815551281,
-0.8853044509887695,
-0.036647554486989975,
0.05520470067858696,
0.15900209546089172,
0.0517544262111187,
-0.13321532309055328,
-0.23128542304039001,
0.276919424533844,
-0.09301839023828506,
-0.9675627946853638,
0.6842096447944641,
0.1280842274427414,
0.17908413708209991,
0.6768247485160828,
0.23360608518123627,
0.13604319095611572,
-0.2180490493774414,
0.7855988144874573,
0.604300856590271,
-0.8859918117523193,
0.6134206056594849,
-0.3499886095523834,
-0.13850077986717224,
0.30944928526878357,
0.27408909797668457,
-0.44601771235466003,
-0.5918731689453125,
-0.5539819002151489,
-0.744754433631897,
0.28245240449905396,
0.5805190205574036,
0.3409096598625183,
-0.3450745642185211,
0.346221387386322,
0.16399824619293213,
0.27444666624069214,
-0.42367586493492126,
-0.20917940139770508,
-0.48644766211509705,
-0.7759506106376648,
-0.11494327336549759,
-0.20778769254684448,
-0.03559207543730736,
-0.0894724577665329,
0.4221266210079193,
-0.19675752520561218,
0.5085578560829163,
-0.1365015059709549,
-0.08393820375204086,
-0.05390452593564987,
0.22950349748134613,
-0.05752187967300415,
0.18841108679771423,
-0.1627800464630127,
0.10480263084173203,
0.0746232271194458,
-0.3333178460597992,
-0.27695703506469727,
-0.24083243310451508,
-0.13607735931873322,
0.1325322389602661,
-0.010269745253026485,
0.6278933882713318,
-0.1450793743133545,
-0.6171503067016602,
0.8317763209342957,
-0.2607426941394806,
0.30735674500465393,
-0.6839442253112793,
-0.48453599214553833,
-0.0034857038408517838,
-0.03718606010079384,
0.12571150064468384,
0.0860983282327652,
0.31568706035614014,
-0.7057850956916809,
-0.05740285664796829,
0.5259392857551575,
-0.46451908349990845,
-0.5999600291252136,
0.1342591792345047,
0.5582162737846375,
0.04299426078796387,
0.34266334772109985,
-0.18493549525737762,
-0.5082560777664185,
0.49672460556030273,
0.133049875497818,
1.3689191341400146,
-0.03008430078625679,
0.5807061791419983,
0.2813784182071686,
0.13564403355121613,
0.019932547584176064,
0.3856760263442993,
-0.04225621744990349,
-0.788910448551178,
0.012212647125124931,
-0.6900740265846252,
-0.14631034433841705,
-0.5395021438598633,
-0.5260022282600403,
0.3149813115596771,
-0.8079915642738342,
-0.44358548521995544,
0.20633694529533386,
-0.2032380998134613,
-0.6955211162567139,
0.4440198242664337,
0.4140218496322632,
0.2887587249279022,
-1.1449553966522217,
0.32031652331352234,
0.9678774476051331,
-0.5114445686340332,
-0.3972410559654236,
0.0961446762084961,
-0.18593904376029968,
-0.6115881204605103,
0.2239852398633957,
0.47668033838272095,
-0.031099457293748856,
-0.24309302866458893,
-0.45849084854125977,
-0.4951746165752411,
0.6034674644470215,
-0.06680682301521301,
-0.33693259954452515,
0.326498419046402,
0.1891600638628006,
0.8338555693626404,
-0.6819453835487366,
0.573761522769928,
0.20281164348125458,
0.2602309584617615,
-0.00538318557664752,
-0.4843558669090271,
0.21753816306591034,
-0.5000264048576355,
0.14836542308330536,
0.23347267508506775,
-0.37054362893104553,
0.7610758543014526,
-0.28172969818115234,
-0.4358912706375122,
0.08838105946779251,
0.5768922567367554,
-0.28223058581352234,
0.2537708878517151,
0.5448476672172546,
0.3812629282474518,
0.3096010386943817,
-0.06334380805492401,
0.9760637283325195,
-0.3618148863315582,
0.5432363152503967,
0.6280330419540405,
0.017311744391918182,
0.9023327231407166,
0.5449714660644531,
0.04693204164505005,
0.7186482548713684,
0.6798052191734314,
-0.2901928424835205,
0.33862370252609253,
0.0593673475086689,
-0.2787702977657318,
-0.38688287138938904,
-0.4872879385948181,
0.01672372594475746,
0.4399297535419464,
0.25886279344558716,
-0.5064138174057007,
-0.03252033889293671,
0.13584774732589722,
0.005059028044342995,
0.16938969492912292,
-0.381350040435791,
0.7951734662055969,
0.05738715082406998,
-0.4175053834915161,
0.23795285820960999,
0.03831103444099426,
0.7891651391983032,
0.15238997340202332,
0.43939533829689026,
-0.20096786320209503,
0.11120095103979111,
-0.3372427821159363,
-0.9653307795524597,
0.18039363622665405,
0.2649701237678528,
0.21542711555957794,
0.044634535908699036,
0.5349700450897217,
-0.034697189927101135,
-0.7042531967163086,
0.46909770369529724,
0.339442640542984,
0.18012532591819763,
-0.18529066443443298,
-0.7265500426292419,
-0.07082805037498474,
-0.023974524810910225,
-0.20806197822093964,
0.0951792374253273,
0.48324301838874817,
0.020645922049880028,
0.5529468059539795,
0.3752560019493103,
0.02559722773730755,
-0.024652326479554176,
0.5530906319618225,
1.0681815147399902,
-0.5625050663948059,
-0.8042547106742859,
-0.69039386510849,
0.2772311270236969,
-0.2163698822259903,
-0.32333481311798096,
0.7555367946624756,
0.19374370574951172,
0.5962722301483154,
-0.2825823426246643,
0.987158477306366,
-0.4562126398086548,
0.6025813221931458,
-0.2899843752384186,
0.8282814025878906,
-0.8625704050064087,
0.1358044147491455,
-0.5705968737602234,
-0.8574198484420776,
-0.448761910200119,
0.4732075333595276,
-0.00736196618527174,
0.1497163325548172,
0.5158329606056213,
0.7406294345855713,
0.21628698706626892,
0.29127588868141174,
0.011589533649384975,
0.0473695807158947,
0.1746722012758255,
0.2287965714931488,
0.9847807884216309,
-0.2986571192741394,
0.3227694034576416,
-0.5025339126586914,
-0.2811296582221985,
-0.41041213274002075,
-0.8636453747749329,
-1.2641412019729614,
-0.4814707338809967,
-0.5829185247421265,
-0.34817686676979065,
-0.10883481055498123,
1.2115761041641235,
-0.105479396879673,
-0.9828868508338928,
0.062084876000881195,
-0.2606404423713684,
-0.07743965834379196,
0.046650417149066925,
-0.23005449771881104,
0.2653307616710663,
-0.27106228470802307,
-0.5801615118980408,
0.03433380275964737,
0.16918474435806274,
0.06227009370923042,
-0.18052910268306732,
0.1423162966966629,
0.12820576131343842,
0.5215266346931458,
0.493976891040802,
0.08956611901521683,
-0.7510591745376587,
-0.3259856104850769,
-0.09615285694599152,
-0.0015680145006626844,
-0.02389545366168022,
0.8890225291252136,
-0.4083236753940582,
0.6357454061508179,
0.7186266183853149,
0.3851831257343292,
-0.0226169154047966,
-0.10963752865791321,
0.17442165315151215,
-0.5340932607650757,
-0.10612967610359192,
0.32655084133148193,
0.5332043766975403,
0.8350277543067932,
-0.24590592086315155,
0.23306718468666077,
0.3078252971172333,
-0.16208554804325104,
-0.5467270612716675,
-0.019818119704723358,
-1.1884831190109253,
-0.25742021203041077,
1.3581312894821167,
-0.1045423224568367,
-0.4437927007675171,
-0.07602370530366898,
-0.07347481697797775,
0.43677881360054016,
-0.7764806747436523,
1.1733938455581665,
0.014919809065759182,
0.24561168253421783,
0.24357256293296814,
0.3837741017341614,
0.2741682231426239,
0.18572856485843658,
-0.7007995843887329,
0.08401920646429062,
0.2814696133136749,
0.31188783049583435,
0.16488929092884064,
0.38689544796943665,
-0.2862067222595215,
-0.02392633818089962,
-0.0894637256860733,
0.5768697261810303,
0.005095314234495163,
-0.24979624152183533,
-0.3208525478839874,
0.33077168464660645,
-0.17085939645767212,
-0.45345279574394226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01430v1
|
Position-Aware Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning Approach for Reducing Positional Bias in LLMs
| 2024-04-01T19:04:17 | 2024-04-01T19:04:17 |
Zheng Zhang, Fan Yang, Ziyan Jiang, Zheng Chen, Zhengyang Zhao, Chengyuan Ma, Liang Zhao, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have enhanced their ability
to process long input contexts. This development is particularly crucial for
tasks that involve retrieving knowledge from an external datastore, which can
result in long inputs. However, recent studies show a positional bias in LLMs,
demonstrating varying performance depending on the location of useful
information within the input sequence. In this study, we conduct extensive
experiments to investigate the root causes of positional bias. Our findings
indicate that the primary contributor to LLM positional bias stems from the
inherent positional preferences of different models. We demonstrate that merely
employing prompt-based solutions is inadequate for overcoming the positional
preferences. To address this positional bias issue of a pre-trained LLM, we
developed a Position-Aware Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PAPEFT) approach
which is composed of a data augmentation technique and a parameter efficient
adapter, enhancing a uniform attention distribution across the input context.
Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed approach effectively reduces
positional bias, improving LLMs' effectiveness in handling long context
sequences for various tasks that require externally retrieved knowledge.
|
[
-0.6165481805801392,
-0.8422861099243164,
0.888556182384491,
0.11742759495973587,
-0.35207581520080566,
-0.33993974328041077,
-0.5500614643096924,
-0.30349335074424744,
-0.09405659139156342,
0.2581521272659302,
-0.5330745577812195,
-0.45785167813301086,
-0.7895510196685791,
-0.09979165345430374,
-0.026173673570156097,
0.5878804326057434,
-0.07524760067462921,
0.011812727898359299,
-0.19497622549533844,
-0.06888086348772049,
-0.5254518389701843,
-0.5647875070571899,
-0.9174154996871948,
-0.17189733684062958,
0.4908744990825653,
0.5471519827842712,
0.49615809321403503,
0.6104101538658142,
0.37830036878585815,
0.20703351497650146,
-0.2800232470035553,
0.461181640625,
-0.4517519474029541,
0.28103628754615784,
-0.35061103105545044,
-0.3558928966522217,
-0.2955154478549957,
-0.1739702671766281,
0.8654776811599731,
0.8621207475662231,
-0.002746207406744361,
0.01994958333671093,
0.31617799401283264,
0.6515352129936218,
-0.8309631943702698,
0.08627041429281235,
-0.5971129536628723,
0.01868014968931675,
-0.2144729495048523,
-0.49014928936958313,
-0.35242509841918945,
-0.19382311403751373,
0.07887330651283264,
-0.5775392651557922,
0.18397320806980133,
-0.16678765416145325,
0.5517845749855042,
0.4882122874259949,
-0.4535120725631714,
0.05139901489019394,
-0.682233989238739,
0.9149982333183289,
-0.7978988885879517,
0.6828830242156982,
0.493080735206604,
-0.014608980156481266,
-0.45235756039619446,
-0.3128677308559418,
-0.3362730145454407,
-0.18449126183986664,
-0.012035802006721497,
-0.1885247677564621,
0.1917271912097931,
0.18681372702121735,
0.36375680565834045,
-0.02455257810652256,
-0.23438331484794617,
0.4210975170135498,
-0.003669943194836378,
-0.07480082660913467,
0.44413691759109497,
-0.06842013448476791,
-0.1018877699971199,
0.03595981001853943,
-0.12416518479585648,
-0.10393227636814117,
-0.8978862762451172,
0.265869677066803,
0.3986973166465759,
0.4950677454471588,
0.2034130096435547,
0.40739506483078003,
-0.4158349335193634,
0.9015777111053467,
0.6035982966423035,
-0.11954985558986664,
0.06275579333305359,
-0.1278604120016098,
-0.08495331555604935,
0.1307457685470581,
0.5463593602180481,
0.3671545684337616,
-0.00834069587290287,
0.042228661477565765,
-0.24988946318626404,
-0.4645371437072754,
0.1217745691537857,
-0.7753305435180664,
0.04277152568101883,
0.25042909383773804,
-0.33498847484588623,
-0.04117782413959503,
-0.10231262445449829,
-0.5378718972206116,
-0.6360384821891785,
-0.45400533080101013,
0.27549293637275696,
-0.4391438066959381,
0.12195999920368195,
-0.05876976624131203,
0.18985669314861298,
0.4692172408103943,
0.4647439420223236,
-1.0749071836471558,
-0.009620695374906063,
0.7073653340339661,
0.6062168478965759,
-0.48006901144981384,
-0.20755058526992798,
-0.852038562297821,
0.31724733114242554,
-0.21131475269794464,
0.8588081002235413,
-0.6816741824150085,
-0.37527358531951904,
-0.11095479875802994,
0.033173155039548874,
-0.16991324722766876,
-0.6495978236198425,
0.7271303534507751,
-0.590747058391571,
0.3658405542373657,
-0.4309914708137512,
-0.7067274451255798,
-0.014300431124866009,
0.23008610308170319,
-0.37701913714408875,
1.0114222764968872,
-0.18211808800697327,
-0.5867244005203247,
0.48731473088264465,
-0.6886045336723328,
-0.5342022180557251,
-0.25934454798698425,
-0.2294432520866394,
-0.23742032051086426,
0.234371617436409,
0.5818815231323242,
0.6005136966705322,
-0.2028782069683075,
0.34099099040031433,
-0.37369656562805176,
-0.5422958135604858,
0.17100045084953308,
-0.5913426876068115,
0.3276563882827759,
0.1426021158695221,
-0.36370256543159485,
0.18894807994365692,
-0.69240403175354,
-0.11450169235467911,
-0.0030869310721755028,
-0.5123571753501892,
-0.5406447649002075,
0.22597171366214752,
-0.23573681712150574,
0.1481398493051529,
0.464766263961792,
-0.26523372530937195,
0.3242611885070801,
-0.6115726828575134,
0.1612604856491089,
0.8575098514556885,
0.14071020483970642,
0.8174070715904236,
0.010577552020549774,
0.3430924415588379,
0.009798922576010227,
0.0933220386505127,
0.004263053182512522,
-0.007437352556735277,
-0.571488618850708,
-0.17141157388687134,
0.2917317748069763,
0.36829277873039246,
-0.5025742053985596,
0.6223474740982056,
0.08759501576423645,
-0.14716887474060059,
-0.2603539824485779,
0.22997435927391052,
0.14028984308242798,
0.8931629061698914,
0.2788134813308716,
-0.07875292003154755,
-0.2303394377231598,
-1.0632489919662476,
-0.3105146586894989,
0.14531642198562622,
-0.1926693171262741,
0.39010441303253174,
-0.058454759418964386,
-0.044451963156461716,
0.8044186234474182,
-0.5375436544418335,
-0.20710551738739014,
0.008315175771713257,
-0.20432113111019135,
0.3870241343975067,
0.5261130928993225,
0.3759554922580719,
-0.5689769983291626,
-0.20333798229694366,
-0.25408995151519775,
-0.3647634983062744,
-0.22918981313705444,
-0.07558552920818329,
-0.2080521136522293,
0.3337404131889343,
0.7227725386619568,
-0.7697266340255737,
0.13364599645137787,
0.3771344721317291,
-0.36871665716171265,
0.250141978263855,
-0.26653799414634705,
0.17946894466876984,
-1.051527738571167,
0.11449229717254639,
0.1089051365852356,
-0.29078641533851624,
-0.49916502833366394,
0.008413921110332012,
0.2186458259820938,
0.046955134719610214,
-0.46920862793922424,
0.6761465668678284,
-0.41516387462615967,
0.057907551527023315,
-0.45921382308006287,
0.15552353858947754,
0.07924269139766693,
0.5095973014831543,
0.20124880969524384,
0.88629549741745,
0.4583891034126282,
-0.7978900671005249,
0.08679681271314621,
0.09511307626962662,
-0.20105941593647003,
0.4596866965293884,
-0.5087680220603943,
0.17696593701839447,
-0.06026729568839073,
0.16869309544563293,
-1.1238573789596558,
-0.02849460579454899,
0.39319151639938354,
-0.17465730011463165,
0.5567530989646912,
-0.3424907922744751,
-0.47153082489967346,
0.053039297461509705,
-0.3370867669582367,
0.43367746472358704,
0.3680773973464966,
-0.6397308111190796,
0.28863993287086487,
0.22551780939102173,
-0.4040276110172272,
-0.618427038192749,
-0.31112587451934814,
-0.24462634325027466,
-0.5340604186058044,
-0.425930380821228,
0.5055187940597534,
0.0009466516203247011,
-0.051894571632146835,
-0.5262458324432373,
-0.4204637408256531,
0.0245708916336298,
0.18563944101333618,
-0.0560382604598999,
-0.01579497940838337,
-0.09442819654941559,
0.2983962893486023,
0.22909732162952423,
-0.14292779564857483,
0.04755762219429016,
-0.3954142928123474,
0.7167081236839294,
0.11637622863054276,
-0.4631510078907013,
-0.48411473631858826,
0.24980050325393677,
0.586535632610321,
-0.22074611485004425,
0.8881052136421204,
0.6000674962997437,
-0.2607908546924591,
-0.28570735454559326,
-0.6978036761283875,
-0.5159386396408081,
-0.5397411584854126,
0.446800172328949,
-0.13012956082820892,
-0.8532435894012451,
0.48030033707618713,
-0.3134388327598572,
-0.15790703892707825,
0.09402549266815186,
0.46745672821998596,
-0.2335137128829956,
1.046616792678833,
0.5441418886184692,
-0.2360389232635498,
0.8414590358734131,
0.03853648155927658,
0.2138189822435379,
-0.9611120223999023,
-0.012864436022937298,
-0.3569290339946747,
-0.5005347728729248,
-0.4101686179637909,
-0.41171756386756897,
0.35610154271125793,
0.17741170525550842,
-0.25837528705596924,
-0.16723503172397614,
-0.5210977792739868,
0.5439301133155823,
0.6566674709320068,
0.14870963990688324,
0.09249508380889893,
-0.024917159229516983,
-0.11565383523702621,
-0.06934425234794617,
-0.70115065574646,
-0.33350422978401184,
0.8710280656814575,
0.40358495712280273,
0.7296536564826965,
-0.029573552310466766,
0.5021466016769409,
-0.1045319065451622,
-0.3034934401512146,
-0.8364534378051758,
0.5546924471855164,
-0.16426785290241241,
-0.16821570694446564,
-0.5112284421920776,
-0.18789547681808472,
-0.9152066707611084,
0.20360583066940308,
0.07320918142795563,
-0.7670365571975708,
0.4203689396381378,
0.3966163098812103,
-0.5443043112754822,
0.1092330738902092,
-0.7246624827384949,
0.702673077583313,
-0.36090657114982605,
-0.7514354586601257,
-0.08133135735988617,
-0.5126994848251343,
0.05156456306576729,
-0.007503346540033817,
-0.035753846168518066,
-0.20812390744686127,
-0.1529238373041153,
0.7108510732650757,
-0.5161714553833008,
0.7923226952552795,
-0.7316654324531555,
-0.5012726187705994,
-0.12192438542842865,
0.036299530416727066,
0.8878054022789001,
0.3701319098472595,
-0.3063756227493286,
-0.08546891063451767,
-0.13837338984012604,
-0.3564741611480713,
-0.6176384687423706,
0.8663985729217529,
-0.7464187741279602,
-0.8363407254219055,
-0.1935880333185196,
-0.7147629261016846,
-0.8327134251594543,
0.17653928697109222,
0.3459876775741577,
0.35877782106399536,
0.16401134431362152,
0.2772411108016968,
1.1108380556106567,
-0.3903603255748749,
0.5760008692741394,
0.5940899848937988,
0.022101420909166336,
0.043773915618658066,
0.49903103709220886,
0.12460620701313019,
0.05697723478078842,
0.5432128310203552,
0.19552305340766907,
-0.542205274105072,
-0.9053893089294434,
-0.15163066983222961,
0.034772779792547226,
-0.5633074045181274,
-0.11795670539140701,
-0.32134687900543213,
-0.02413155324757099,
-0.3439690172672272,
-0.27870094776153564,
-0.5027352571487427,
-0.3676603138446808,
-0.47232529520988464,
0.0321882963180542,
0.4758569896221161,
0.06685499101877213,
0.24134890735149384,
0.49240565299987793,
-0.566398561000824,
0.36438220739364624,
0.2665010690689087,
0.6835953593254089,
-0.1909109503030777,
-0.7776270508766174,
-0.09814488887786865,
-0.011158987879753113,
-0.06963331252336502,
-0.6447734832763672,
0.32654449343681335,
0.1563994288444519,
0.7500491142272949,
0.3252042829990387,
0.05045180022716522,
0.7024597525596619,
-0.3492421805858612,
0.62562096118927,
-0.2189159393310547,
-0.7393427491188049,
0.8156737685203552,
-0.6117740869522095,
0.7905983328819275,
0.7091379761695862,
0.15772202610969543,
-0.3279874324798584,
-0.16152748465538025,
-0.31017228960990906,
-1.0905673503875732,
0.8435925245285034,
-0.16502529382705688,
-0.017431659623980522,
0.1058996394276619,
0.6881631016731262,
0.2156713306903839,
0.24096204340457916,
-0.4059353470802307,
-0.13531965017318726,
0.2741612493991852,
-0.13122816383838654,
-0.19152972102165222,
-0.34139248728752136,
-0.09964882582426071,
-0.37079116702079773,
0.7106760144233704,
-0.34828922152519226,
0.2700227200984955,
0.2860107421875,
-0.2663763165473938,
-0.06009615957736969,
0.3412759602069855,
0.789466917514801,
0.8126084208488464,
-0.16801011562347412,
-0.014253982342779636,
0.39835357666015625,
-0.2701658010482788,
0.029810024425387383,
0.45593932271003723,
-0.3638128936290741,
-0.12636330723762512,
-0.03774942457675934,
0.8391848802566528,
0.3271888792514801,
-0.503169596195221,
0.4695364534854889,
0.03869105130434036,
0.03252117335796356,
-0.32559406757354736,
0.11193976551294327,
0.18374072015285492,
0.39118751883506775,
0.40121760964393616,
0.0483916737139225,
0.242375910282135,
-0.1324213147163391,
0.16847620904445648,
0.6016035079956055,
-0.2768721580505371,
-0.026923559606075287,
0.5473178029060364,
0.19554747641086578,
-0.17424997687339783,
0.3786863088607788,
0.10425185412168503,
-0.13529469072818756,
0.4070241451263428,
0.4622959792613983,
0.5613560080528259,
-0.3930487334728241,
-0.07296443730592728,
0.13088396191596985,
-0.012209449894726276,
-0.09536555409431458,
0.2828279733657837,
-0.162519633769989,
-0.713691771030426,
-0.5687243938446045,
-0.6537489295005798,
-0.26450294256210327,
0.40061670541763306,
-0.47376516461372375,
0.36306700110435486,
-0.6425135135650635,
-0.099075548350811,
-0.3027486205101013,
-0.06429854780435562,
-0.7092702388763428,
0.06100308895111084,
0.36553454399108887,
0.8913638591766357,
-0.480929970741272,
0.9524398446083069,
0.8723124861717224,
0.04701639711856842,
-0.8535140156745911,
0.21768152713775635,
-0.23912115395069122,
-0.8570680022239685,
0.5225158929824829,
0.011887315660715103,
-0.2112615704536438,
-0.05517660081386566,
-0.4260927438735962,
-1.105153203010559,
0.9643489718437195,
0.743960440158844,
-0.842682421207428,
-0.00596547219902277,
0.0972626581788063,
0.4446853995323181,
-0.12143184244632721,
-0.016963234171271324,
0.5789352655410767,
0.4733290374279022,
-0.0397026389837265,
-0.9079414010047913,
0.15596948564052582,
-0.026210207492113113,
0.024617023766040802,
0.38144686818122864,
-0.8567409515380859,
0.49228259921073914,
0.15467683970928192,
0.20338088274002075,
-0.24603703618049622,
0.44802719354629517,
0.6225681900978088,
0.13115526735782623,
0.4790723919868469,
0.3047716021537781,
0.8549526333808899,
0.024018440395593643,
0.9326342940330505,
-0.4374995827674866,
0.13435640931129456,
1.3930244445800781,
-0.35049647092819214,
0.8624643683433533,
0.9119826555252075,
0.04173777624964714,
0.09589631110429764,
0.7972238659858704,
0.17908509075641632,
0.7474121451377869,
0.0961635559797287,
-0.2215564250946045,
-0.2473841905593872,
-0.07607854902744293,
-0.4014296233654022,
0.5114911198616028,
0.41711878776550293,
-0.5315398573875427,
-0.13112081587314606,
0.12186739593744278,
-0.06437398493289948,
-0.017391007393598557,
-0.4881019592285156,
0.7974579334259033,
0.08721613883972168,
-0.7976621389389038,
0.6038069128990173,
0.11510244011878967,
0.8490766882896423,
-0.658313512802124,
0.1397704929113388,
-0.3110450506210327,
0.2716602683067322,
-0.10004955530166626,
-0.6155531406402588,
0.07228010892868042,
-0.31710484623908997,
-0.3683021068572998,
-0.41063815355300903,
0.9274448752403259,
-0.4879155158996582,
-0.2981910705566406,
0.14321403205394745,
0.5352370142936707,
-0.22846344113349915,
-0.3534732162952423,
-0.5319927930831909,
0.044106967747211456,
-0.1257999837398529,
-0.5999913215637207,
0.5322588682174683,
0.3254234492778778,
-0.06880919635295868,
0.503315806388855,
0.4811602532863617,
0.12055186182260513,
-0.043943554162979126,
0.06767480075359344,
0.6832175850868225,
-0.6246517300605774,
-0.5629825592041016,
-0.9191650748252869,
0.20165038108825684,
0.06748348474502563,
-0.20499740540981293,
0.6688464283943176,
0.32562848925590515,
0.6636494994163513,
-0.1167193204164505,
0.7122052907943726,
0.27082642912864685,
0.48931562900543213,
-0.7267743945121765,
0.6798831224441528,
-0.42754849791526794,
0.5700023174285889,
-0.12428989261388779,
-1.2730308771133423,
-0.38491201400756836,
0.6958073377609253,
-0.7519299983978271,
0.1447153389453888,
0.4851866066455841,
0.6995057463645935,
-0.1811418980360031,
-0.25449123978614807,
0.1878809779882431,
0.1379724144935608,
0.24101699888706207,
0.6061821579933167,
0.8730258345603943,
-0.19721613824367523,
0.2704527676105499,
-0.24986979365348816,
0.019326025620102882,
-0.3380890488624573,
-1.0023741722106934,
-0.6248964667320251,
-0.42180413007736206,
-0.2001032531261444,
0.06989788264036179,
0.21626928448677063,
1.1436864137649536,
0.8298491835594177,
-0.9481709003448486,
0.05938588082790375,
-0.10991638898849487,
0.132211372256279,
-0.009649999439716339,
-0.2354440987110138,
0.5286074876785278,
-0.403026819229126,
-0.7984622120857239,
0.7551407217979431,
0.16573092341423035,
-0.0922902449965477,
0.06764022260904312,
-0.006916351616382599,
-0.18242794275283813,
-0.13456010818481445,
0.6842321753501892,
0.30381643772125244,
-0.6919143795967102,
-0.6169895529747009,
-0.01086378749459982,
0.040342409163713455,
0.25494012236595154,
0.6842436790466309,
-0.8812899589538574,
0.20142534375190735,
0.5719615817070007,
0.6974322199821472,
0.29016217589378357,
0.2388298511505127,
0.9196880459785461,
-1.141563892364502,
0.3222936689853668,
0.18577802181243896,
0.4574197828769684,
0.30887410044670105,
-0.7200005650520325,
0.2271459847688675,
-0.08436908572912216,
-0.6109925508499146,
-0.75157630443573,
0.08449886739253998,
-0.9522731304168701,
-0.42414963245391846,
1.3340576887130737,
0.195137619972229,
-0.009266985580325127,
0.07676675915718079,
-0.4744691252708435,
0.2457830160856247,
-0.5930336713790894,
0.8304610252380371,
0.6341797709465027,
-0.4210423231124878,
-0.3346092700958252,
-0.3079746961593628,
0.6706711649894714,
0.8270220160484314,
-0.693688154220581,
0.13134734332561493,
0.5726062655448914,
0.36472225189208984,
-0.2060817927122116,
0.47085803747177124,
-0.028074070811271667,
0.21176347136497498,
-0.5737207531929016,
-0.1664770394563675,
-0.11816722899675369,
-0.23211850225925446,
-0.707480251789093,
0.38875487446784973,
0.5544702410697937,
-0.18357284367084503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01413v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01413v2
|
Is Model Collapse Inevitable? Breaking the Curse of Recursion by Accumulating Real and Synthetic Data
| 2024-04-01T18:31:24 | 2024-04-29T23:13:42 |
Matthias Gerstgrasser, Rylan Schaeffer, Apratim Dey, Rafael Rafailov, Henry Sleight, John Hughes, Tomasz Korbak, Rajashree Agrawal, Dhruv Pai, Andrey Gromov, Daniel A. Roberts, Diyi Yang, David L. Donoho, Sanmi Koyejo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET, stat.ML
|
The proliferation of generative models, combined with pretraining on
web-scale data, raises a timely question: what happens when these models are
trained on their own generated outputs? Recent investigations into model-data
feedback loops proposed that such loops would lead to a phenomenon termed model
collapse, under which performance progressively degrades with each model-data
feedback iteration until fitted models become useless. However, those studies
largely assumed that new data replace old data over time, where an arguably
more realistic assumption is that data accumulate over time. In this paper, we
ask: what effect does accumulating data have on model collapse? We empirically
study this question by pretraining sequences of language models on text
corpora. We confirm that replacing the original real data by each generation's
synthetic data does indeed tend towards model collapse, then demonstrate that
accumulating the successive generations of synthetic data alongside the
original real data avoids model collapse; these results hold across a range of
model sizes, architectures, and hyperparameters. We obtain similar results for
deep generative models on other types of real data: diffusion models for
molecule conformation generation and variational autoencoders for image
generation. To understand why accumulating data can avoid model collapse, we
use an analytically tractable framework introduced by prior work in which a
sequence of linear models are fit to the previous models' outputs. Previous
work used this framework to show that if data are replaced, the test error
increases with the number of model-fitting iterations; we extend this argument
to prove that if data instead accumulate, the test error has a finite upper
bound independent of the number of iterations, meaning model collapse no longer
occurs.
|
[
-0.5296276807785034,
-0.6202171444892883,
0.5833912491798401,
-0.38421764969825745,
-0.020528389140963554,
0.18960663676261902,
0.00007126488344511017,
-0.54984450340271,
-0.3414804935455322,
0.6393309235572815,
-0.42837733030319214,
-0.04153497517108917,
-0.5696789026260376,
-0.04892083629965782,
-1.1339330673217773,
0.9058296084403992,
-0.030867507681250572,
-0.039430197328329086,
-0.7651907205581665,
0.035583022981882095,
-0.42313623428344727,
-0.6959130167961121,
-0.37624916434288025,
-0.40281614661216736,
0.1750340759754181,
0.08103729039430618,
0.71364426612854,
0.7706146240234375,
0.38967227935791016,
0.38204458355903625,
0.07408779859542847,
0.24968181550502777,
-0.6467528939247131,
0.2544506788253784,
0.06215336173772812,
-0.7983869910240173,
-0.14907300472259521,
0.274306058883667,
0.7400249242782593,
0.9624019861221313,
-0.34513962268829346,
-0.08471447229385376,
0.1910942643880844,
0.6649782061576843,
-0.31055891513824463,
-0.0503695048391819,
-0.4862079918384552,
0.07098811119794846,
0.023391248658299446,
-0.17406398057937622,
-0.5433515310287476,
-0.4928944408893585,
0.11556344479322433,
-0.4292639493942261,
0.6405141353607178,
-0.22487206757068634,
0.7992399334907532,
0.1875087469816208,
-0.2424250990152359,
-0.3361634612083435,
-1.2160563468933105,
0.6362739205360413,
-0.7805662155151367,
0.29552099108695984,
0.20501777529716492,
0.25689923763275146,
-0.21848858892917633,
-0.8393076658248901,
-0.6847546100616455,
-0.2649540305137634,
-0.0578058697283268,
0.10116118937730789,
-0.21482402086257935,
-0.0455702468752861,
0.25448447465896606,
0.7324623465538025,
-0.4609850347042084,
0.03346613794565201,
-0.8388601541519165,
0.18268918991088867,
0.2828858494758606,
0.28655439615249634,
0.42668747901916504,
0.07490232586860657,
-0.21985864639282227,
-0.2727992832660675,
-0.9880969524383545,
-0.44272199273109436,
0.5237000584602356,
0.31292346119880676,
-0.0501336045563221,
0.5632163286209106,
0.2418884038925171,
0.6623130440711975,
-0.042585473507642746,
0.169993057847023,
0.08424943685531616,
-0.4230242371559143,
-0.26700255274772644,
-0.13106998801231384,
0.5639584064483643,
0.18907670676708221,
0.4875546097755432,
-0.2466306835412979,
-0.09528807550668716,
0.2304607480764389,
0.5322173237800598,
-0.5965337157249451,
-0.46166056394577026,
0.3431430757045746,
-0.31796008348464966,
-0.38211676478385925,
0.2719994783401489,
-0.39025601744651794,
-0.14066754281520844,
-0.4906383156776428,
0.2539834678173065,
-0.3674425482749939,
-0.42957866191864014,
0.2131601870059967,
-0.06205105036497116,
-0.1739148050546646,
0.17610090970993042,
-0.511083722114563,
0.40723368525505066,
0.5537970662117004,
0.9540557861328125,
0.11623919010162354,
-0.4189745783805847,
-0.26725900173187256,
-0.1405383050441742,
-0.6082732081413269,
0.476481169462204,
-0.42172273993492126,
-0.6824082732200623,
0.110533706843853,
0.22435475885868073,
0.00545995170250535,
-0.8012657761573792,
0.058571722358465195,
-0.559697687625885,
0.2674383521080017,
0.03132339194417,
-0.7938542366027832,
-0.10181234031915665,
0.12903879582881927,
-0.8224879503250122,
0.5048985481262207,
-0.045255210250616074,
-0.49956825375556946,
0.348492830991745,
-0.37925922870635986,
-0.4629466235637665,
-0.17820081114768982,
-0.06815718859434128,
-0.6861040592193604,
0.31531140208244324,
-0.3697231411933899,
0.27478206157684326,
-0.40919801592826843,
0.23963697254657745,
-0.5766622424125671,
-0.1558334082365036,
0.4192638695240021,
-0.42575815320014954,
0.5598366260528564,
0.22306905686855316,
-0.0660315752029419,
-0.5249401330947876,
-0.7410327196121216,
-0.019888177514076233,
0.06499434262514114,
-0.326672226190567,
-0.2747798562049866,
0.23029465973377228,
-0.29361650347709656,
0.23718520998954773,
-0.1179998591542244,
-0.35318723320961,
0.3757253885269165,
-0.24354752898216248,
0.5463865399360657,
0.7620843648910522,
0.14606088399887085,
0.4480747878551483,
-0.5927402973175049,
0.6810871362686157,
0.1868218183517456,
-0.20157098770141602,
-0.5608144998550415,
-0.27103036642074585,
-0.7589457631111145,
0.3536060154438019,
0.5408169031143188,
0.21641309559345245,
-0.24292750656604767,
0.31822988390922546,
-0.5315515995025635,
-0.6711905598640442,
-0.1867314577102661,
0.06694726645946503,
0.25453630089759827,
0.4479540288448334,
0.20792104303836823,
-0.4674670994281769,
-0.675464928150177,
-0.7113742828369141,
0.051286567002534866,
-0.3189370632171631,
-0.14015662670135498,
0.02594146318733692,
0.6007630825042725,
-0.42482832074165344,
0.8256595134735107,
-0.49500977993011475,
0.1308867335319519,
-0.05881088227033615,
0.45305851101875305,
-0.013466200791299343,
0.8036510944366455,
0.43779662251472473,
-0.7411399483680725,
0.27535971999168396,
-0.12297959625720978,
-0.7326563596725464,
0.3144102692604065,
-0.5134953260421753,
0.12250221520662308,
0.20880767703056335,
0.16999214887619019,
-0.6894217729568481,
0.4088471829891205,
0.589031457901001,
-0.0796234980225563,
0.82725590467453,
-0.406216561794281,
0.0771588385105133,
-0.777380108833313,
-0.03208930790424347,
-0.1804785281419754,
-0.20208176970481873,
-0.5895442962646484,
-0.06369610875844955,
-0.21362455189228058,
-0.0723864734172821,
-0.0763721838593483,
0.2828245162963867,
-0.42188704013824463,
-0.23971252143383026,
-0.1901053935289383,
0.05088832229375839,
0.1193094477057457,
-0.05362445116043091,
0.055887412279844284,
0.3893667757511139,
0.3286433815956116,
-0.9941583275794983,
0.11601919680833817,
0.3487504720687866,
-0.4083593189716339,
0.07585033029317856,
-0.6476485133171082,
0.044177696108818054,
-0.2612815201282501,
0.2555208206176758,
-0.9847837090492249,
-0.42543676495552063,
-0.07197209447622299,
-0.5924791693687439,
0.43939468264579773,
-0.06178222969174385,
-0.2543565332889557,
-0.538250744342804,
-0.19672322273254395,
0.3779805302619934,
0.5834673047065735,
-0.7243705987930298,
0.15778277814388275,
0.1635677069425583,
0.15550434589385986,
-0.3008878529071808,
-1.2176743745803833,
0.038072701543569565,
0.033772729337215424,
-0.5778607130050659,
0.08989176899194717,
-0.2927105724811554,
-0.2572603225708008,
0.308158278465271,
-0.03609189763665199,
0.017578724771738052,
0.01187257282435894,
0.45073723793029785,
0.2163548767566681,
0.01702762395143509,
0.2899925708770752,
-0.021895600482821465,
0.2198333889245987,
0.1752050668001175,
-0.33461815118789673,
0.7622207999229431,
-0.005680331960320473,
-0.3952566683292389,
-0.2759096026420593,
0.20430487394332886,
0.9425005316734314,
-0.07778079807758331,
0.9357802867889404,
0.10780377686023712,
-0.43815016746520996,
-0.08580886572599411,
-0.31294015049934387,
-0.1075371578335762,
-0.4463924467563629,
0.12238940596580505,
-0.2494317591190338,
-0.33485549688339233,
0.5970861315727234,
-0.021297182887792587,
0.1926879733800888,
0.4356599748134613,
0.49337664246559143,
-0.15986499190330505,
0.9911525845527649,
0.6211022138595581,
0.37731632590293884,
0.3414909839630127,
-1.0246469974517822,
0.13737420737743378,
-0.6010971665382385,
-0.11537376046180725,
-0.21113328635692596,
-0.10605435073375702,
-0.6459436416625977,
-0.3987652361392975,
0.14198718965053558,
0.06871605664491653,
-0.32314422726631165,
0.29250606894493103,
-0.4852730929851532,
0.3749227821826935,
0.47105151414871216,
0.10675103217363358,
0.26493945717811584,
-0.017480388283729553,
0.25759968161582947,
0.1105291023850441,
-0.8339573740959167,
-0.37371382117271423,
1.0518293380737305,
0.1851637065410614,
0.8809227347373962,
-0.07151632755994797,
0.7829668521881104,
0.4918467700481415,
0.47894689440727234,
-0.6012542843818665,
0.03633912652730942,
-0.2097957730293274,
-0.5296565294265747,
-0.04681102931499481,
-0.499574214220047,
-1.0561349391937256,
-0.13319642841815948,
0.07843904942274094,
-0.24042779207229614,
0.7982810139656067,
0.5754929184913635,
-0.2674669623374939,
0.3756612539291382,
-0.6219484806060791,
0.5762390494346619,
-0.20416435599327087,
-0.34065482020378113,
-0.16746416687965393,
-0.44181764125823975,
0.8425387740135193,
-0.17725691199302673,
0.3209035098552704,
0.2514287829399109,
0.2425920069217682,
0.668170154094696,
-0.7906036376953125,
0.8697527647018433,
-0.1009274497628212,
-0.10953786969184875,
0.4356292188167572,
0.27041056752204895,
0.5253799557685852,
-0.2766738831996918,
0.1392645537853241,
-0.021560484543442726,
0.027017910033464432,
-0.45175302028656006,
-0.610304057598114,
0.531566321849823,
-0.692234456539154,
-0.40092626214027405,
-0.4376896321773529,
-0.22394651174545288,
-0.12235040217638016,
-0.05665118992328644,
0.5494625568389893,
0.8432202935218811,
-0.11281982809305191,
0.19780370593070984,
0.3515566885471344,
0.05680739879608154,
0.18625053763389587,
0.10017425566911697,
-0.2892618477344513,
-0.37516137957572937,
0.8122298717498779,
0.5244956016540527,
0.8772712349891663,
-0.20680107176303864,
-0.05773394554853439,
-0.24673549830913544,
-0.6638962626457214,
-0.3017992377281189,
0.2590011656284332,
-0.6014317274093628,
-0.29657620191574097,
-0.3856818377971649,
-0.34243401885032654,
-0.3422394096851349,
-0.2700352370738983,
-0.4736383557319641,
-0.5771266222000122,
-0.27363109588623047,
-0.33616161346435547,
0.07952126115560532,
1.02974534034729,
-0.43065860867500305,
0.26590076088905334,
-0.898921012878418,
0.13352316617965698,
0.14583367109298706,
0.09785366803407669,
0.34900733828544617,
-0.595937192440033,
-0.4282447397708893,
0.27365052700042725,
-0.28308600187301636,
-0.7047898173332214,
0.6755648851394653,
0.42239153385162354,
0.3172515332698822,
0.6184956431388855,
-0.08794812858104706,
0.7835620641708374,
-0.4466804265975952,
0.7426652312278748,
0.36074909567832947,
-0.7207212448120117,
0.3216651380062103,
-0.4112405776977539,
0.5243824124336243,
0.3453657627105713,
0.39526811242103577,
-0.5695298314094543,
-0.6221996545791626,
-0.9131039381027222,
-0.8978632688522339,
0.3139539361000061,
0.18064694106578827,
0.4528076946735382,
-0.1712428778409958,
0.6504216194152832,
0.15072114765644073,
0.3825261890888214,
-0.4982565641403198,
-0.18530921638011932,
-0.29391491413116455,
0.097181037068367,
0.08694208413362503,
-0.3141443729400635,
-0.057103294879198074,
-0.2028142511844635,
0.5173701047897339,
0.0646841898560524,
0.2476090043783188,
0.14409731328487396,
-0.1695011854171753,
-0.16215786337852478,
-0.027842843905091286,
0.3287806212902069,
0.8093104958534241,
-0.09668806940317154,
0.09210846573114395,
-0.29735884070396423,
-0.3949263095855713,
0.3742114007472992,
-0.08888345211744308,
-0.4015544056892395,
-0.1609603464603424,
0.5027519464492798,
0.6296616196632385,
0.26049792766571045,
-0.6776056289672852,
0.053956106305122375,
-0.0667174905538559,
-0.2710152864456177,
-0.7022320032119751,
0.11540861427783966,
-0.005126526113599539,
-0.1871192902326584,
0.3999059796333313,
0.34806352853775024,
0.04579457268118858,
-0.9707940220832825,
0.6007222533226013,
0.20447158813476562,
-0.014488493092358112,
-0.5153307914733887,
1.0179048776626587,
-0.040028754621744156,
0.058083634823560715,
0.8447182774543762,
-0.04798516258597374,
-0.39238056540489197,
0.7817968726158142,
0.7064602971076965,
0.700814425945282,
-0.5597007870674133,
0.2664501965045929,
0.7125075459480286,
0.274155855178833,
-0.5159050226211548,
-0.05176736041903496,
0.008065973408520222,
-0.789405345916748,
-0.39688512682914734,
-0.6517016887664795,
-0.28529325127601624,
0.16261492669582367,
-0.7623875141143799,
0.07844822108745575,
-0.46967488527297974,
-0.14897365868091583,
-0.129686638712883,
-0.3584105670452118,
-0.5792146325111389,
0.529720664024353,
0.11907052248716354,
0.6278996467590332,
-0.8315208554267883,
0.5878008604049683,
0.12917356193065643,
-0.6742938756942749,
-0.31084340810775757,
0.05995897576212883,
-0.0024795217905193567,
-0.4978579878807068,
0.5257905721664429,
0.27712732553482056,
-0.14694280922412872,
-0.01830100640654564,
-0.6583423614501953,
-0.9414069056510925,
0.9098076224327087,
0.49206241965293884,
-0.709247350692749,
-0.3210611045360565,
0.06076181307435036,
0.6308005452156067,
-0.4991760551929474,
-0.11842527240514755,
0.6272547245025635,
0.4258100092411041,
0.2923905849456787,
-0.5524725317955017,
-0.03499174490571022,
-0.29299959540367126,
-0.07744155824184418,
0.3337792754173279,
-0.4035711884498596,
0.9457051157951355,
-0.4782558083534241,
-0.6239315867424011,
0.4208523631095886,
0.4650142788887024,
-0.06399074196815491,
0.07456280291080475,
0.5971333980560303,
0.8972905874252319,
0.7019878029823303,
-0.10587373375892639,
1.4467827081680298,
-0.3541971445083618,
0.42871972918510437,
1.2391712665557861,
0.0599641278386116,
0.7587360739707947,
0.0686158537864685,
-0.4741838872432709,
0.5821929574012756,
0.7640582323074341,
-0.25872480869293213,
0.21606002748012543,
0.3352247476577759,
-0.0902869775891304,
-0.33434954285621643,
0.06353749334812164,
-0.32449260354042053,
0.40867534279823303,
0.4067457318305969,
-0.5379079580307007,
-0.12116466462612152,
0.07679133862257004,
0.0018048286437988281,
0.10603128373622894,
-0.015103079378604889,
0.35765546560287476,
0.19447939097881317,
-0.6639840602874756,
0.9191548824310303,
-0.4548392593860626,
0.1745356172323227,
-0.43810755014419556,
0.029388532042503357,
-0.22128261625766754,
0.2702493667602539,
-0.26685547828674316,
-0.36570438742637634,
0.5643596649169922,
-0.22262434661388397,
-0.2364061325788498,
-0.12979771196842194,
0.4556736648082733,
-0.587542712688446,
-0.6757544875144958,
0.30013197660446167,
0.49069976806640625,
0.137731671333313,
0.2423141747713089,
-0.294342041015625,
0.21275928616523743,
-0.010859557427465916,
-0.3994937837123871,
0.2245120406150818,
-0.12250333279371262,
0.3999935984611511,
0.7188063263893127,
0.619108259677887,
0.17408473789691925,
0.18655182421207428,
-0.19267426431179047,
0.8982292413711548,
-0.5048357844352722,
-0.15131694078445435,
-0.651616632938385,
0.7381892800331116,
-0.09603538364171982,
-0.05674988776445389,
0.6615952849388123,
0.6550076603889465,
0.9305758476257324,
0.05427801236510277,
1.0860133171081543,
-0.056579653173685074,
0.3858286738395691,
-0.46315619349479675,
0.5491812229156494,
-0.7542551755905151,
0.26787909865379333,
0.04872725531458855,
-0.6651038527488708,
-0.2829415798187256,
0.2342628836631775,
-0.43849870562553406,
0.26563653349876404,
0.3949214518070221,
0.5151099562644958,
-0.05163711681962013,
-0.3333696722984314,
0.36161568760871887,
0.46670541167259216,
0.4199660122394562,
0.11706658452749252,
0.703194260597229,
-0.37760093808174133,
0.5977981686592102,
-0.2834351360797882,
-0.01030128076672554,
-0.03489084541797638,
-0.40216541290283203,
-0.37519291043281555,
-1.0314183235168457,
-0.316633403301239,
-0.6482583284378052,
-0.013666005805134773,
0.37275996804237366,
0.6908813118934631,
-0.7138160467147827,
-0.0876004546880722,
-0.5121102929115295,
0.030522340908646584,
-0.013285527005791664,
-0.2259611189365387,
0.20071662962436676,
-0.5704664587974548,
-0.8312163352966309,
0.26586660742759705,
0.09517852216959,
0.5830917358398438,
-0.6860883831977844,
-0.0012009143829345703,
-0.12053639441728592,
0.18794189393520355,
0.4554089903831482,
0.752263069152832,
-0.4485313594341278,
-0.041346225887537,
-0.12531022727489471,
0.29954707622528076,
0.21347318589687347,
0.9879779815673828,
-0.9968118071556091,
0.8051223158836365,
0.5028731226921082,
0.4240669906139374,
0.5041815638542175,
0.22727686166763306,
1.1788421869277954,
-0.6437289118766785,
-0.01999644562602043,
0.08332023024559021,
0.4037882089614868,
0.47293099761009216,
-0.24104292690753937,
0.6022683382034302,
0.2795524597167969,
-0.6200708746910095,
-1.3269250392913818,
0.46004775166511536,
-0.34039440751075745,
-0.37711209058761597,
0.5943608283996582,
-0.18103869259357452,
-0.2621322274208069,
0.0709393247961998,
0.3979051113128662,
0.22583100199699402,
-0.05946803838014603,
1.0337961912155151,
0.7436113357543945,
-0.46620479226112366,
-0.11046893894672394,
-0.595333456993103,
0.4461836814880371,
0.17963187396526337,
-0.6827254295349121,
0.4553793668746948,
0.7701475620269775,
0.06357795745134354,
0.5204687714576721,
0.3382343053817749,
-0.2549118399620056,
0.3539240062236786,
0.20836012065410614,
-0.16093990206718445,
0.029672307893633842,
-0.37482893466949463,
-0.4885024130344391,
0.18096986413002014,
-0.012157817371189594,
-0.0503549724817276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01399v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01399v3
|
Safe and Responsible Large Language Model : Can We Balance Bias Reduction and Language Understanding in Large Language Models?
| 2024-04-01T18:10:05 | 2024-07-01T17:40:13 |
Shaina Raza, Oluwanifemi Bamgbose, Shardul Ghuge, Fatemeh Tavakol, Deepak John Reji, Syed Raza Bashir
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced various NLP tasks.
However, these models often risk generating unsafe text that perpetuates
biases. Current approaches to produce unbiased outputs from LLMs can reduce
biases but at the expense of knowledge retention. In this research, we address
the question of whether producing safe (unbiased) outputs through LLMs can
retain knowledge and language understanding. In response, we developed the
Safety and Responsible Large Language Model (\textbf{SR}$_{\text{LLM}}$), an
LLM that has been instruction fine-tuned on top of already safe LLMs (e.g.,
Llama2 or related) to diminish biases in generated text. To achieve our goals,
we compiled a specialized dataset designed to train our model in identifying
and correcting biased text. We conduct experiments, both on this custom data
and out-of-distribution test sets, to show the bias reduction and knowledge
retention. The results confirm that \textbf{SR}$_{\text{LLM}}$ outperforms
traditional fine-tuning and prompting methods in both reducing biases and
preserving the integrity of language knowledge. The significance of our
findings lies in demonstrating that instruction fine-tuning can provide a more
robust solution for bias reduction in LLMs. We have made our code and data
available at
\href{https://github.com/shainarazavi/Safe-Responsible-LLM}{Safe-LLM}.
|
[
-0.10561709851026535,
-0.7763352394104004,
0.3557667136192322,
0.10478434711694717,
-0.28220564126968384,
-0.2891801595687866,
-0.5733447074890137,
-0.4426517188549042,
-0.19159241020679474,
0.8703629374504089,
-0.2927716374397278,
-0.5723863840103149,
-0.5888714790344238,
-0.22031761705875397,
-0.3982369899749756,
1.21135413646698,
-0.11130665242671967,
0.32571280002593994,
-0.3701116144657135,
-0.04820546135306358,
-0.6941102147102356,
-0.5665196776390076,
-0.8295212984085083,
-0.7089906930923462,
0.4216943681240082,
0.42889440059661865,
0.3980792462825775,
0.8690359592437744,
0.3737277388572693,
0.17725376784801483,
-0.4059615135192871,
0.08228494226932526,
-0.7895969152450562,
0.21864978969097137,
-0.3765694200992584,
-0.4979773163795471,
-0.5011440515518188,
-0.0021578241139650345,
0.7772434949874878,
0.7131252288818359,
-0.3030967712402344,
0.1466141790151596,
0.3846536874771118,
0.7494575381278992,
-0.6109445095062256,
0.18731573224067688,
-0.7323504090309143,
0.19710293412208557,
-0.26193001866340637,
-0.42254310846328735,
-0.8319417834281921,
-0.2766523063182831,
-0.1486465185880661,
-0.2089603841304779,
0.14185097813606262,
0.05898208171129227,
0.537861168384552,
0.3327758014202118,
-0.655866265296936,
-0.08967899531126022,
-0.7932651042938232,
0.9710285663604736,
-0.7727047204971313,
0.3323326110839844,
0.4006257951259613,
-0.13113971054553986,
-0.35998770594596863,
-0.3125239312648773,
-0.30955106019973755,
-0.15108229219913483,
0.12872491776943207,
0.09933029860258102,
0.044348347932100296,
0.027160655707120895,
0.3192790746688843,
0.1353680044412613,
-0.2284637838602066,
0.6090633869171143,
-0.2181929349899292,
-0.4289044141769409,
0.6206150054931641,
0.1329541653394699,
0.15483427047729492,
-0.026183903217315674,
-0.33175337314605713,
-0.009301678277552128,
-1.1429632902145386,
-0.10772092640399933,
0.44156214594841003,
0.22784988582134247,
-0.1296474188566208,
0.6517962217330933,
-0.01653314381837845,
0.2626696825027466,
0.005703323055058718,
-0.2531982660293579,
0.08914665132761002,
-0.23009459674358368,
-0.17135854065418243,
0.21001359820365906,
0.6184920072555542,
0.6183537840843201,
0.7479496002197266,
-0.136884868144989,
-0.22116395831108093,
-0.03179313987493515,
0.2981880307197571,
-0.7470280528068542,
-0.18907712399959564,
-0.10178589820861816,
-0.5527624487876892,
-0.4125358462333679,
-0.18117393553256989,
-0.5583652257919312,
-0.5299074053764343,
-0.29933154582977295,
0.13150201737880707,
-0.19220374524593353,
-0.1117715984582901,
0.20134490728378296,
0.1901409775018692,
0.13087515532970428,
0.3402021825313568,
-0.8403162360191345,
0.1959131956100464,
0.6344394683837891,
0.43960055708885193,
-0.33077573776245117,
-0.12377730011940002,
-0.6702294945716858,
0.46904486417770386,
-0.3720150291919708,
0.3918379843235016,
-0.25552353262901306,
-0.2656296491622925,
0.27491676807403564,
-0.14540787041187286,
0.16326552629470825,
-0.6305352449417114,
0.6653802990913391,
-0.6504223346710205,
0.10607311874628067,
-0.39897340536117554,
-0.7247776985168457,
-0.05541916564106941,
0.2912493050098419,
-0.4695920944213867,
0.630358099937439,
-0.4759076237678528,
-0.9257938265800476,
0.29966995120048523,
-0.15775218605995178,
-0.6132166385650635,
-0.3509281277656555,
-0.042901214212179184,
-0.5045697093009949,
0.06396349519491196,
0.23005273938179016,
0.39135774970054626,
-0.2853792607784271,
0.47650793194770813,
-0.3951222896575928,
-0.22113974392414093,
0.39179423451423645,
-0.6832435727119446,
0.7544485926628113,
0.09347660094499588,
-0.3190036416053772,
0.18612979352474213,
-0.5693426728248596,
0.026082443073391914,
0.07435242086648941,
-0.6170638799667358,
-0.49524566531181335,
0.14978791773319244,
0.05353051424026489,
0.038498636335134506,
0.3493136763572693,
-0.36751165986061096,
-0.010254360735416412,
-0.23671193420886993,
0.20843014121055603,
1.1702816486358643,
0.02004512958228588,
0.7788174748420715,
-0.15109658241271973,
0.3557412624359131,
0.048620324581861496,
0.11735576391220093,
0.015178960748016834,
-0.2004869133234024,
-0.9532201290130615,
-0.11499923467636108,
0.28438547253608704,
0.6787992119789124,
-0.353827565908432,
0.5468137264251709,
0.010454688221216202,
-0.07278154790401459,
-0.14116521179676056,
0.3713725805282593,
0.6854247450828552,
0.671675980091095,
0.29908397793769836,
-0.3525320291519165,
-0.4770323932170868,
-0.9504976272583008,
-0.3064192235469818,
-0.026648517698049545,
-0.09520231187343597,
0.09734207391738892,
0.2520797848701477,
-0.4104859232902527,
0.7334288358688354,
-0.35894864797592163,
-0.3846770226955414,
-0.3692610263824463,
-0.013221995905041695,
-0.028636736795306206,
0.7140187621116638,
0.45655566453933716,
-0.42297443747520447,
-0.2659549117088318,
-0.183223158121109,
-0.8574581146240234,
-0.4698420763015747,
-0.018441705033183098,
-0.20618651807308197,
0.4081811308860779,
0.5589048266410828,
-0.7391287684440613,
0.1691386103630066,
0.4642711877822876,
-0.20293328166007996,
0.5072532296180725,
-0.18451718986034393,
-0.1614227145910263,
-1.2308886051177979,
-0.06833212822675705,
0.04545542597770691,
-0.3203919529914856,
-0.6406717896461487,
0.05244632065296173,
0.16996830701828003,
0.26240912079811096,
-0.3061107099056244,
0.45976054668426514,
-0.3875647187232971,
0.016351500526070595,
-0.40609413385391235,
0.05227086693048477,
0.0268802959471941,
0.19081559777259827,
0.08048705756664276,
0.625838041305542,
0.398998498916626,
-0.6517431735992432,
-0.09037069231271744,
0.1308773010969162,
-0.41110414266586304,
0.3328578472137451,
-0.7237948179244995,
0.17073556780815125,
-0.16931678354740143,
0.29670900106430054,
-0.4339333176612854,
-0.19837690889835358,
0.3266429603099823,
-0.14226320385932922,
0.47052639722824097,
-0.16226714849472046,
-0.6155821681022644,
0.007900773547589779,
-0.22328877449035645,
0.15105727314949036,
0.6377487182617188,
-0.43711748719215393,
0.24082839488983154,
0.6978956460952759,
-0.2884136140346527,
-0.8811356425285339,
-0.7310686111450195,
-0.22562453150749207,
-0.208156555891037,
-0.35082414746284485,
0.0942070484161377,
-0.002975963056087494,
-0.3750150203704834,
-0.08660817891359329,
-0.350085973739624,
-0.07266122847795486,
0.014807729050517082,
0.05497458577156067,
0.3245711624622345,
0.05716635659337044,
0.39972835779190063,
0.29154181480407715,
-0.18175433576107025,
0.4951322078704834,
-0.22631601989269257,
0.6297135353088379,
0.005993231665343046,
-0.357205331325531,
-0.31816473603248596,
0.2374490201473236,
0.380477637052536,
-0.2596399784088135,
0.9265021085739136,
0.49404019117355347,
-0.44952088594436646,
-0.35680079460144043,
-0.5802452564239502,
-0.39490756392478943,
-0.4721779227256775,
0.41407808661460876,
0.1351499855518341,
-1.1622904539108276,
0.5839364528656006,
0.16695527732372284,
0.2168108969926834,
0.2912006080150604,
0.7012545466423035,
-0.11026109755039215,
0.9976596832275391,
0.7485436201095581,
-0.2803889513015747,
0.41721460223197937,
-0.01289021223783493,
0.32513704895973206,
-0.6802399158477783,
-0.22430822253227234,
-0.44514307379722595,
-0.14859771728515625,
-0.49946293234825134,
-0.31739309430122375,
0.15727508068084717,
0.11254703253507614,
-0.2844600975513458,
-0.13954918086528778,
-0.35014039278030396,
0.6694141626358032,
0.6251675486564636,
0.25457027554512024,
0.4020133912563324,
-0.08636389672756195,
0.08815249800682068,
-0.17429158091545105,
-0.635858416557312,
-0.6879462003707886,
1.2030831575393677,
0.5045855045318604,
1.1964772939682007,
-0.1276545375585556,
0.7505726218223572,
0.21109376847743988,
0.30980387330055237,
-0.644500732421875,
0.7302354574203491,
-0.1492004692554474,
-0.594780683517456,
-0.14560054242610931,
-0.9095141887664795,
-0.7231945395469666,
0.031233683228492737,
-0.41705262660980225,
-0.5311007499694824,
-0.23077762126922607,
0.46720778942108154,
0.03691394254565239,
0.4304283559322357,
-0.6990334987640381,
0.8159128427505493,
-0.32612502574920654,
-0.4352189004421234,
-0.4434038996696472,
-0.56736820936203,
0.6293724179267883,
-0.16909074783325195,
0.1569359004497528,
-0.06229709833860397,
0.19961756467819214,
0.9422305226325989,
-0.13277700543403625,
1.1037975549697876,
-0.22617937624454498,
-0.4017814099788666,
0.19204990565776825,
0.058704860508441925,
0.6608569622039795,
0.3270885944366455,
-0.028578685596585274,
0.08785116672515869,
-0.31751418113708496,
-0.28688979148864746,
-0.34550660848617554,
0.8895493745803833,
-0.7926265001296997,
-0.6654031872749329,
-0.3765941858291626,
-0.9141112565994263,
-0.07076884061098099,
0.4695289134979248,
0.08273672312498093,
0.22564858198165894,
-0.14523029327392578,
0.37189170718193054,
1.3003203868865967,
-0.3732098639011383,
0.2227124571800232,
0.5819274187088013,
-0.19263856112957,
-0.12470433861017227,
0.5012677907943726,
0.11151514947414398,
0.299294650554657,
0.3592148423194885,
0.3038768470287323,
-0.3503245711326599,
-0.8892974853515625,
-0.05642947554588318,
0.14639712870121002,
-0.8064445853233337,
-0.31313642859458923,
-0.5182798504829407,
-0.29980096220970154,
-0.35759225487709045,
-0.04526088386774063,
-0.48526135087013245,
-0.1810096949338913,
-0.4198170006275177,
-0.28773584961891174,
0.22756896913051605,
0.6806219816207886,
-0.010580407455563545,
0.30768290162086487,
-0.8695219159126282,
0.08841530233621597,
0.2127673178911209,
0.2747707664966583,
-0.08880044519901276,
-0.5794438123703003,
-0.29159900546073914,
0.15585827827453613,
-0.18108457326889038,
-0.5638290643692017,
0.3018091320991516,
-0.0892087072134018,
0.518137514591217,
0.4638464152812958,
0.29017043113708496,
0.43670815229415894,
-0.6301540732383728,
0.5405867695808411,
0.17148704826831818,
-0.9256419539451599,
0.48511290550231934,
-0.5168900489807129,
0.35637786984443665,
0.5196442604064941,
0.01521417498588562,
-0.3006823658943176,
-0.6269939541816711,
-0.452208936214447,
-0.8731791973114014,
0.6087017059326172,
0.0693444237112999,
0.286948561668396,
-0.03126922622323036,
0.461568146944046,
0.12832702696323395,
0.26084625720977783,
-0.9873254895210266,
-0.06713971495628357,
0.3194817304611206,
-0.2666417956352234,
-0.066708505153656,
-0.6058555841445923,
-0.40419697761535645,
-0.05152364447712898,
0.7908525466918945,
0.06026070564985275,
0.0543571375310421,
-0.2707473039627075,
-0.11918579787015915,
-0.1946297138929367,
0.48868465423583984,
0.488971471786499,
0.542372465133667,
-0.12472204118967056,
0.3797312080860138,
0.3793847858905792,
-0.5735810995101929,
0.005264091305434704,
-0.09731882810592651,
-0.524955689907074,
-0.3593709170818329,
0.3710951805114746,
0.5546017289161682,
0.11482180655002594,
-0.6728741526603699,
0.3184282183647156,
-0.006873901933431625,
-0.05398542806506157,
-0.4325824975967407,
0.14434361457824707,
0.14900889992713928,
0.19621224701404572,
0.10645881295204163,
0.3003673255443573,
-0.1583365648984909,
-0.3920740783214569,
0.23931382596492767,
0.5723612904548645,
-0.1796639859676361,
-0.050459686666727066,
0.7795940637588501,
0.41755950450897217,
-0.1177048608660698,
0.7154611945152283,
-0.04759034514427185,
-0.392751544713974,
0.5558171272277832,
0.7582300305366516,
0.5861943960189819,
-0.06449643522500992,
0.011369037441909313,
0.15442630648612976,
0.6378610730171204,
-0.32946324348449707,
0.03812597692012787,
0.2810196578502655,
-0.9397979974746704,
-0.5793014764785767,
-0.5162062048912048,
-0.4508066475391388,
0.2345346063375473,
-0.7468745112419128,
0.07600901275873184,
-0.4429629147052765,
-0.03880650922656059,
-0.48161759972572327,
-0.1357397735118866,
-0.3246965706348419,
0.08656390011310577,
0.10648681223392487,
0.7505291104316711,
-0.9791907072067261,
0.9549071192741394,
0.5899642109870911,
-0.10418173670768738,
-0.789977490901947,
0.19741813838481903,
0.08414290100336075,
-0.6094672083854675,
0.48854169249534607,
0.2979525029659271,
-0.22917382419109344,
-0.2117868810892105,
-0.634637713432312,
-0.6831597089767456,
0.8450549244880676,
0.7141622304916382,
-0.7415459156036377,
0.21680782735347748,
0.08168911188840866,
0.48342859745025635,
-0.2420031875371933,
-0.15033064782619476,
0.36655133962631226,
0.34219738841056824,
-0.2178943008184433,
-0.7794517874717712,
0.1060897707939148,
-0.09907533973455429,
0.014732995070517063,
0.32966065406799316,
-0.4474506974220276,
0.6887375116348267,
-0.2908601462841034,
-0.1056288555264473,
-0.15122844278812408,
0.6932128071784973,
0.40556666254997253,
0.3826122581958771,
0.4416871964931488,
0.773723304271698,
0.7941594123840332,
0.009649618528783321,
0.8303622007369995,
-0.07543683052062988,
0.29387524724006653,
1.2145172357559204,
-0.4912584722042084,
0.7351042628288269,
0.6422443389892578,
0.19575592875480652,
0.07616069167852402,
0.44709643721580505,
0.379740446805954,
0.5609226822853088,
0.19946560263633728,
-0.19092416763305664,
-0.4009052813053131,
-0.19848956167697906,
-0.3356083929538727,
0.3318866193294525,
0.14153985679149628,
-0.5232142806053162,
0.04013962298631668,
-0.10783590376377106,
0.371269166469574,
0.1605176478624344,
-0.3958097994327545,
0.6326903104782104,
0.26308032870292664,
-0.5444897413253784,
0.43021249771118164,
-0.001354265259578824,
0.6020773649215698,
-0.5656924247741699,
0.12264904379844666,
-0.18590296804904938,
0.643530011177063,
-0.1369943767786026,
-0.9725812077522278,
0.3951166868209839,
0.14335818588733673,
-0.44006508588790894,
-0.5543842911720276,
0.9783911108970642,
-0.717964768409729,
-0.3241206407546997,
0.33514487743377686,
0.4226583242416382,
-0.05096561834216118,
0.2647921144962311,
-0.35445499420166016,
0.20123672485351562,
0.12031256407499313,
-0.26011499762535095,
0.5869879126548767,
0.3477388322353363,
-0.10666470229625702,
0.7750664949417114,
0.6269059777259827,
0.12919272482395172,
0.09634368121623993,
0.3325284421443939,
0.7420833110809326,
-0.37767526507377625,
-0.22774429619312286,
-0.8134732246398926,
0.32571643590927124,
-0.18834348022937775,
-0.18174822628498077,
0.8239911198616028,
0.4387105703353882,
0.9935395121574402,
-0.2608095705509186,
0.8683655858039856,
0.061416447162628174,
0.3693864345550537,
-0.9155203700065613,
0.9392739534378052,
-0.38240301609039307,
0.4285030961036682,
-0.11468386650085449,
-1.0342317819595337,
-0.4596118628978729,
0.6695311665534973,
-0.28223463892936707,
-0.00820385105907917,
0.5618165135383606,
0.8751987218856812,
0.021772675216197968,
-0.118165522813797,
-0.009538206271827221,
0.33211448788642883,
0.2442934364080429,
0.4673583209514618,
0.7120208144187927,
-0.0774637907743454,
0.6348389387130737,
-0.2730807065963745,
-0.3607129752635956,
-0.16042986512184143,
-0.9534131288528442,
-1.2037010192871094,
-0.1140882596373558,
-0.21774359047412872,
-0.28540605306625366,
0.2998049259185791,
0.8493205308914185,
0.3566107451915741,
-0.8349744081497192,
-0.26827770471572876,
-0.2962600290775299,
0.3342416286468506,
-0.1904105842113495,
-0.18447011709213257,
0.10420455783605576,
-0.3664851486682892,
-0.660252034664154,
0.25129005312919617,
0.07884305715560913,
-0.004256145562976599,
-0.19109265506267548,
-0.24164213240146637,
0.041379790753126144,
-0.024221191182732582,
0.712819516658783,
0.07017126679420471,
-0.5199737548828125,
-0.5341489315032959,
0.0329391211271286,
-0.20687444508075714,
-0.21249398589134216,
0.6626425981521606,
-0.3390462100505829,
0.23734943568706512,
0.569981575012207,
0.6418367624282837,
0.32506832480430603,
-0.17583422362804413,
0.8083080649375916,
-0.7005167603492737,
0.06427080929279327,
0.17867422103881836,
0.5580242276191711,
0.26702556014060974,
-0.3753093481063843,
0.41144996881484985,
-0.0754581093788147,
-0.8790004849433899,
-0.784649133682251,
0.5056494474411011,
-1.0331765413284302,
0.017765671014785767,
1.4412931203842163,
-0.08836522698402405,
0.000892556388862431,
0.05820555239915848,
-0.27813035249710083,
0.5654047131538391,
-0.5272413492202759,
1.0136761665344238,
0.5374625325202942,
0.09613649547100067,
-0.37276405096054077,
-0.4025822877883911,
0.2718410789966583,
0.7460929155349731,
-0.9107416272163391,
0.36601805686950684,
0.6751859188079834,
0.36675888299942017,
-0.023375872522592545,
0.5579290986061096,
-0.11218827962875366,
0.149575874209404,
-0.36825504899024963,
0.1923656016588211,
0.04584387317299843,
-0.43309035897254944,
-0.20065197348594666,
-0.06100698187947273,
0.19100366532802582,
-0.03997569903731346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01299v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01299v2
|
CausalChaos! Dataset for Comprehensive Causal Action Question Answering Over Longer Causal Chains Grounded in Dynamic Visual Scenes
| 2024-04-01T17:59:53 | 2024-06-14T17:46:02 |
Paritosh Parmar, Eric Peh, Ruirui Chen, Ting En Lam, Yuhan Chen, Elston Tan, Basura Fernando
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Causal video question answering (QA) has garnered increasing interest, yet
existing datasets often lack depth in causal reasoning. To address this gap, we
capitalize on the unique properties of cartoons and construct CausalChaos!, a
novel, challenging causal Why-QA dataset built upon the iconic "Tom and Jerry"
cartoon series. Cartoons use the principles of animation that allow animators
to create expressive, unambiguous causal relationships between events to form a
coherent storyline. Utilizing these properties, along with thought-provoking
questions and multi-level answers (answer and detailed causal explanation), our
questions involve causal chains that interconnect multiple dynamic interactions
between characters and visual scenes. These factors demand models to solve more
challenging, yet well-defined causal relationships. We also introduce hard
incorrect answer mining, including a causally confusing version that is even
more challenging. While models perform well, there is much room for
improvement, especially, on open-ended answers. We identify more
advanced/explicit causal relationship modeling & joint modeling of vision and
language as the immediate areas for future efforts to focus upon. Along with
the other complementary datasets, our new challenging dataset will pave the way
for these developments in the field.
|
[
-0.2054104208946228,
-0.8495590090751648,
0.5879687070846558,
0.39166462421417236,
-0.35388943552970886,
0.11612042039632797,
0.261059045791626,
-0.45671921968460083,
0.41220197081565857,
0.650802731513977,
-0.7529938817024231,
0.16405045986175537,
-0.470274418592453,
0.07319487631320953,
-0.31650108098983765,
1.0175009965896606,
0.05511385202407837,
0.24286536872386932,
-0.3113553524017334,
-0.17651988565921783,
-0.7902326583862305,
-0.026042183861136436,
-0.843788743019104,
-0.05381104722619057,
0.957126259803772,
0.247964546084404,
0.9128638505935669,
0.7168117165565491,
0.7198870778083801,
0.3961344361305237,
0.17926253378391266,
0.18738240003585815,
-0.7507262229919434,
0.30102968215942383,
-0.3400401771068573,
-0.38651683926582336,
-0.06359812617301941,
-0.38821882009506226,
0.32247135043144226,
0.9917272925376892,
-0.004848097916692495,
0.46265608072280884,
-0.17639757692813873,
0.4527699053287506,
-0.8016076683998108,
0.3404656648635864,
-0.3673302233219147,
-0.047084517776966095,
0.07156485319137573,
-0.299769788980484,
-0.1131771057844162,
-0.6729951500892639,
0.006197253242135048,
-1.0123382806777954,
0.28889524936676025,
-0.12459738552570343,
0.979749858379364,
0.32757025957107544,
-0.9486362338066101,
-0.08979655057191849,
-0.9550294876098633,
0.24133585393428802,
-0.23990662395954132,
0.18310829997062683,
0.2185654491186142,
0.5489544868469238,
-0.2760199010372162,
-0.9205207824707031,
-0.5609399080276489,
0.07044877111911774,
0.22300685942173004,
0.22508180141448975,
-0.25874224305152893,
-0.034728579223155975,
0.34082961082458496,
0.1040942445397377,
-0.6507366895675659,
-0.23427751660346985,
-0.41445159912109375,
0.1721101552248001,
0.8187239766120911,
0.6599991321563721,
0.563553512096405,
-0.13308031857013702,
-0.44146135449409485,
-0.30528438091278076,
-0.5795925855636597,
0.4139619469642639,
0.2963317632675171,
-0.08965731412172318,
0.009777573868632317,
0.5545570850372314,
-0.09439215809106827,
0.31845688819885254,
0.14610324800014496,
0.17225541174411774,
-0.2972809374332428,
-0.1977144479751587,
-0.32627663016319275,
-0.006674133241176605,
0.5748993754386902,
0.4627535045146942,
0.25101417303085327,
0.04381909221410751,
0.1293504238128662,
-0.17307059466838837,
0.25558823347091675,
-0.6466116905212402,
-0.37288689613342285,
0.17516326904296875,
-0.3637371361255646,
-0.29391103982925415,
0.16419687867164612,
-0.9401947259902954,
-0.8253294825553894,
-0.3793150782585144,
0.5430697202682495,
-0.04873683303594589,
-0.3030700385570526,
0.2691496014595032,
-0.6429129242897034,
0.2760351002216339,
0.7334694266319275,
-0.7111561894416809,
0.16178883612155914,
0.49806201457977295,
0.3748445212841034,
0.44945958256721497,
-0.1675945222377777,
-0.5207915306091309,
0.5798792839050293,
-0.740943193435669,
0.7528114914894104,
-0.5564420223236084,
0.041870810091495514,
0.054703667759895325,
0.17865632474422455,
-0.007794626522809267,
-0.3998453915119171,
0.18707866966724396,
-0.802262544631958,
0.15600793063640594,
-0.7060608267784119,
-0.3718051016330719,
-0.31157663464546204,
0.12835928797721863,
-0.8758543729782104,
0.6683416366577148,
-0.23624742031097412,
-0.6947304010391235,
0.30480971932411194,
-0.29597851634025574,
-0.5362173318862915,
-0.0314563512802124,
-0.24433650076389313,
-0.261274129152298,
0.0955023467540741,
0.27500924468040466,
0.20223277807235718,
-0.6711717844009399,
0.9504035711288452,
-0.7795072793960571,
-0.15726527571678162,
0.29385918378829956,
-0.6293357610702515,
0.9044572710990906,
0.14077673852443695,
-0.1825147122144699,
0.1544652283191681,
-0.5946902632713318,
-0.3406885266304016,
0.6531119346618652,
0.22267182171344757,
-0.553657591342926,
0.2819115221500397,
-0.21520885825157166,
0.3032892942428589,
0.3108975291252136,
-0.3515281081199646,
0.0003182697982992977,
0.26399126648902893,
0.04987331107258797,
0.9387955069541931,
0.28678300976753235,
-0.19900116324424744,
-0.26923108100891113,
0.7905773520469666,
0.009147796779870987,
0.5955266952514648,
-0.3581746816635132,
-0.7127772569656372,
-0.7442501783370972,
0.07539631426334381,
-0.4617409408092499,
0.5120044350624084,
-1.0054137706756592,
0.07037194818258286,
-0.3593592345714569,
-0.536190390586853,
0.23062458634376526,
-0.21563024818897247,
0.42819973826408386,
0.8430822491645813,
0.3384828269481659,
-0.20505675673484802,
-0.432606965303421,
-0.6773238778114319,
-0.015788301825523376,
-0.4888838231563568,
-0.053684648126363754,
0.26910242438316345,
0.5093423128128052,
0.3415442109107971,
0.7632020711898804,
-0.9441887140274048,
0.1891593188047409,
-0.22568097710609436,
0.1273331493139267,
0.3962932229042053,
0.30293434858322144,
0.509628415107727,
-0.8649644255638123,
-0.17580163478851318,
-0.14229407906532288,
-1.0741766691207886,
0.12889909744262695,
-0.44473761320114136,
0.04111677035689354,
-0.7515015602111816,
0.4792802929878235,
-0.5931296348571777,
0.3001524806022644,
0.2603875696659088,
-0.5320949554443359,
0.6044436097145081,
-0.08183183521032333,
0.39729073643684387,
-0.9426523447036743,
0.3668168783187866,
-0.08422375470399857,
0.026701798662543297,
-0.6328092217445374,
0.01828746497631073,
-0.20220671594142914,
-0.6603707075119019,
-0.4978567957878113,
0.453125536441803,
-0.14523905515670776,
-0.10004410147666931,
0.1616920381784439,
0.030588502064347267,
0.12775838375091553,
0.7984704375267029,
-0.11462763696908951,
0.6717323660850525,
0.6182554960250854,
-0.6144590377807617,
0.7560864090919495,
0.5299089550971985,
-0.13925796747207642,
0.5648718476295471,
-0.9284246563911438,
-0.18477968871593475,
-0.39144188165664673,
0.4416731297969818,
-1.08756685256958,
-0.6358550190925598,
0.1902913600206375,
-0.34314534068107605,
-0.01804983615875244,
0.04606539383530617,
-0.44993385672569275,
-0.5152005553245544,
-0.36930152773857117,
0.6566140651702881,
0.270696222782135,
-0.7441503405570984,
0.39741137623786926,
0.48332515358924866,
-0.2152772694826126,
-0.7353124022483826,
-0.2607547640800476,
0.26776883006095886,
-0.35369518399238586,
-0.7179849743843079,
-0.08722051233053207,
0.06338997930288315,
-0.11272093653678894,
0.033024609088897705,
-0.3029809296131134,
-0.556643009185791,
0.02528209425508976,
0.17628246545791626,
0.14581835269927979,
-0.4210047721862793,
0.36278748512268066,
0.2136024385690689,
0.0935521051287651,
0.33939749002456665,
0.12573778629302979,
0.24229291081428528,
0.29155147075653076,
-0.285282164812088,
-0.45296069979667664,
0.5108844041824341,
0.7246877551078796,
-0.19147351384162903,
0.2331850826740265,
0.2755776345729828,
-0.4778117537498474,
0.21517282724380493,
-0.3625161349773407,
-0.1379345953464508,
-0.5094319581985474,
0.42037931084632874,
-0.20499800145626068,
-0.7577844262123108,
0.8130977153778076,
-0.1463892161846161,
-0.14457041025161743,
0.35458695888519287,
0.25853264331817627,
-0.3290523886680603,
1.3699296712875366,
0.4044218063354492,
-0.07117926329374313,
0.43741825222969055,
-0.06493724137544632,
0.20571792125701904,
-0.3146922290325165,
-0.566146969795227,
-0.4538460373878479,
-0.17958630621433258,
-0.4076772928237915,
-0.27775317430496216,
0.5288587808609009,
0.33278968930244446,
-0.6115682721138,
0.35876333713531494,
0.08295630663633347,
0.6169313192367554,
0.3134321868419647,
0.2354009747505188,
0.18859495222568512,
-0.19740930199623108,
0.3818977475166321,
0.2926417589187622,
-0.8287182450294495,
-0.2078028917312622,
0.835376501083374,
0.21044526994228363,
1.006985068321228,
0.38004183769226074,
0.05541708320379257,
0.1409267783164978,
-0.05246016010642052,
-0.23565128445625305,
0.7375217080116272,
-0.25334903597831726,
-0.8363245725631714,
-0.3844544589519501,
-0.2880653142929077,
-1.3478028774261475,
0.014911833219230175,
-0.0845508947968483,
-0.581697404384613,
0.49824491143226624,
0.2556672990322113,
-0.18584342300891876,
0.2826140820980072,
-0.6032079458236694,
1.0520614385604858,
-0.18086391687393188,
-0.5973846912384033,
-0.45334798097610474,
-1.0472636222839355,
0.6253050565719604,
0.25660374760627747,
-0.1653003692626953,
0.008610382676124573,
0.15740607678890228,
0.6144818663597107,
-0.6117428541183472,
1.0463720560073853,
0.0622178316116333,
-0.10289385914802551,
0.680451512336731,
-0.022968485951423645,
0.4211258590221405,
0.3610280454158783,
0.48031488060951233,
0.11807918548583984,
0.04360722005367279,
-0.3853652775287628,
-1.0092276334762573,
0.47439467906951904,
-0.5328437685966492,
-0.5725703239440918,
-0.4769189953804016,
-0.4604116976261139,
-0.2273390144109726,
0.25157707929611206,
-0.22460642457008362,
0.5985134243965149,
-0.2059175670146942,
0.04582535848021507,
0.6553282737731934,
-0.42591753602027893,
0.3864896893501282,
0.33822256326675415,
-0.1556270271539688,
-0.6102849841117859,
0.9348611831665039,
-0.37695249915122986,
0.08752002567052841,
0.5181459784507751,
0.17975954711437225,
-0.32008036971092224,
0.08822523057460785,
-0.4248531460762024,
0.3222973346710205,
-0.8022978901863098,
-0.21039700508117676,
-0.36592334508895874,
-0.04855804890394211,
-0.3368936777114868,
-0.05481874942779541,
-0.1415376514196396,
-0.47735920548439026,
-0.2845394015312195,
-0.0008629473159089684,
0.28213202953338623,
0.7343676686286926,
0.09564770758152008,
-0.009276571683585644,
-0.8340602517127991,
0.7980682253837585,
0.9790757894515991,
0.3952842950820923,
-0.018676912412047386,
-0.01717429794371128,
-0.10788273811340332,
-0.11235447973012924,
-0.5485153794288635,
-1.259136438369751,
0.0176874790340662,
0.07260660082101822,
0.271792471408844,
0.7286945581436157,
0.004979890771210194,
1.2669169902801514,
-0.6059147119522095,
0.8830108046531677,
0.4659891128540039,
-0.6431018710136414,
0.5990409851074219,
-0.6182323694229126,
0.011568878777325153,
0.18808384239673615,
0.5286478996276855,
-0.5889080166816711,
-0.4866064190864563,
-0.648692786693573,
-0.5728546977043152,
0.6285013556480408,
0.3802182674407959,
0.26322752237319946,
-0.21924199163913727,
0.19064006209373474,
-0.03751884028315544,
0.21792058646678925,
-0.3511471748352051,
-0.23660172522068024,
-0.21559573709964752,
-0.042647503316402435,
-0.08138105273246765,
0.10636605322360992,
-0.21038851141929626,
-0.251662015914917,
0.2425551414489746,
-0.22276318073272705,
0.23475465178489685,
0.2504962980747223,
0.004786659497767687,
-0.5843472480773926,
-0.1537657529115677,
0.49394750595092773,
0.7906310558319092,
-0.24774974584579468,
0.118885837495327,
-0.11454614251852036,
-0.4818771481513977,
0.033621955662965775,
0.01644565351307392,
-0.04425518959760666,
-0.021761011332273483,
0.6382218599319458,
0.9203120470046997,
0.2092326432466507,
-1.134209394454956,
0.6313973069190979,
-0.08247235417366028,
0.26042768359184265,
-0.2882620096206665,
0.12836551666259766,
-0.2425437867641449,
0.44917067885398865,
0.5215892791748047,
-0.017707860097289085,
0.3400137722492218,
-0.4902682900428772,
0.2491382360458374,
0.2929416596889496,
-0.3338881731033325,
-0.4231376349925995,
1.013314962387085,
0.17003653943538666,
0.08331265300512314,
0.5815219283103943,
0.31753939390182495,
-0.26709502935409546,
1.44893217086792,
0.45640164613723755,
0.9322900176048279,
-0.2352333515882492,
0.5538205504417419,
0.547335684299469,
0.2858915328979492,
0.12045782804489136,
0.37126731872558594,
0.030600180849432945,
-0.453249990940094,
-0.4131644666194916,
-0.029010821133852005,
-0.5411121249198914,
0.20008231699466705,
-0.8661988973617554,
0.555375337600708,
-0.5854726433753967,
0.049560900777578354,
-0.11158004403114319,
-0.47880885004997253,
-0.4150770306587219,
0.6117842793464661,
-0.11373932659626007,
0.59663325548172,
-1.1490052938461304,
0.5457411408424377,
0.5811864137649536,
-0.9528139233589172,
-0.6937965750694275,
-0.03268366679549217,
-0.23891818523406982,
-0.7930299043655396,
0.8841572403907776,
0.020572802051901817,
0.12223272025585175,
-0.09416194260120392,
-0.767785906791687,
-0.9605756402015686,
1.1029690504074097,
0.5361454486846924,
-0.2554464638233185,
-0.05888543277978897,
0.1766183227300644,
0.6584822535514832,
0.051319897174835205,
0.2605680823326111,
0.236662358045578,
0.2343052178621292,
0.16416476666927338,
-0.5632768273353577,
0.13036909699440002,
-0.3198457956314087,
-0.12818129360675812,
0.23314569890499115,
-0.7894255518913269,
0.5450920462608337,
-0.5691982507705688,
-0.2372068166732788,
0.003923074807971716,
0.6609697341918945,
0.3477494418621063,
0.83331698179245,
0.541269063949585,
0.4027807414531708,
0.47169142961502075,
-0.0013005795190110803,
1.0718047618865967,
-0.09013571590185165,
0.3691253066062927,
1.1688874959945679,
-0.10562262684106827,
0.44397178292274475,
0.678131639957428,
-0.35141387581825256,
0.5167815685272217,
0.787894606590271,
0.0423775352537632,
0.39592471718788147,
-0.07085210829973221,
-0.0712629184126854,
-0.608825147151947,
-0.40685561299324036,
-0.42546674609184265,
0.20308315753936768,
0.10503260046243668,
0.025522643700242043,
-0.39169755578041077,
-0.09163564443588257,
-0.2107766717672348,
-0.01866292767226696,
-0.2160293310880661,
0.5130271315574646,
-0.12093423306941986,
-0.5234917998313904,
0.17111898958683014,
-0.36872315406799316,
-0.2721307873725891,
-0.83338862657547,
-0.28685489296913147,
-0.5377771258354187,
-0.30880579352378845,
0.21543137729167938,
-0.9210264682769775,
0.11466565728187561,
-0.05304279923439026,
0.00533952796831727,
0.04703422635793686,
0.4059949815273285,
-0.36742958426475525,
-0.37720245122909546,
-0.0927058532834053,
0.04630592092871666,
-0.017373183742165565,
0.28121379017829895,
-0.6673250198364258,
-0.31219565868377686,
-0.3753350079059601,
0.06762544810771942,
0.019364681094884872,
0.6725580096244812,
-0.43729934096336365,
0.931933581829071,
0.5602090954780579,
-0.2682498097419739,
0.31120553612709045,
0.05169259384274483,
0.9139161705970764,
-0.6480826735496521,
-0.6372586488723755,
-0.3566014766693115,
0.6037694811820984,
-0.22245080769062042,
-0.6124945878982544,
0.7585456967353821,
0.45574817061424255,
0.5897836089134216,
-0.4606567621231079,
0.27400171756744385,
-0.07642654329538345,
-0.1097760796546936,
-0.5849719047546387,
0.350117564201355,
-0.848023533821106,
-0.0026934382040053606,
-0.5715879201889038,
-0.7111496329307556,
-0.4682421386241913,
0.10167525708675385,
-0.07904183119535446,
-0.05348183214664459,
0.7934420108795166,
0.44721558690071106,
-0.09340468049049377,
0.29302215576171875,
0.17398585379123688,
0.22201400995254517,
0.6442463397979736,
0.854383111000061,
0.984248697757721,
-0.5820019245147705,
0.6292116641998291,
-0.1640596240758896,
-0.14997558295726776,
-0.17659862339496613,
-0.7363526821136475,
-0.7624301314353943,
-0.6676039099693298,
-0.60188227891922,
-0.062102943658828735,
0.14895376563072205,
0.4243156313896179,
0.39774468541145325,
-0.7626814246177673,
-0.32892322540283203,
-0.4201505482196808,
0.43788444995880127,
-0.5643301606178284,
-0.22743816673755646,
0.6298027038574219,
-0.26061829924583435,
-0.5477717518806458,
0.19615697860717773,
0.4757935702800751,
-0.15067461133003235,
-0.08038806915283203,
0.22004210948944092,
-0.18867610394954681,
0.29721999168395996,
0.5779693126678467,
0.6070763468742371,
-0.4948609173297882,
-0.3633373975753784,
0.016577061265707016,
0.18131451308727264,
-0.1349390149116516,
1.268810510635376,
-0.5291839241981506,
0.762713611125946,
0.9364399313926697,
0.7736731171607971,
0.23099471628665924,
-0.06133917346596718,
0.520095705986023,
-0.4964287579059601,
0.11097688972949982,
0.16449394822120667,
0.26922380924224854,
-0.07211369276046753,
-0.3768998384475708,
0.34919145703315735,
0.5647798776626587,
-0.38992080092430115,
-0.8060598969459534,
0.47088655829429626,
-1.2280255556106567,
-0.39246994256973267,
0.7050905823707581,
-0.11713064461946487,
-0.0162421353161335,
-0.26001977920532227,
-0.2105492204427719,
0.43652960658073425,
-0.08141264319419861,
1.0055581331253052,
0.3018307387828827,
-0.3062365651130676,
-0.10865257680416107,
-0.2538414001464844,
0.14517363905906677,
0.5030223727226257,
-0.9780687093734741,
0.09276483207941055,
0.8255749940872192,
0.06322719901800156,
0.037393514066934586,
0.357048362493515,
-0.009190537966787815,
0.7100971937179565,
-0.017334895208477974,
-0.20814678072929382,
0.1148490384221077,
-0.7327738404273987,
-0.32284772396087646,
0.37269356846809387,
-0.38263919949531555,
-0.337497740983963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01295v1
|
Towards Safety and Helpfulness Balanced Responses via Controllable Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T17:59:06 | 2024-04-01T17:59:06 |
Yi-Lin Tuan, Xilun Chen, Eric Michael Smith, Louis Martin, Soumya Batra, Asli Celikyilmaz, William Yang Wang, Daniel M. Bikel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As large language models (LLMs) become easily accessible nowadays, the
trade-off between safety and helpfulness can significantly impact user
experience. A model that prioritizes safety will cause users to feel less
engaged and assisted while prioritizing helpfulness will potentially cause
harm. Possible harms include teaching people how to build a bomb, exposing
youth to inappropriate content, and hurting users' mental health. In this work,
we propose to balance safety and helpfulness in diverse use cases by
controlling both attributes in LLM. We explore training-free and fine-tuning
methods that do not require extra human annotations and analyze the challenges
of controlling safety and helpfulness in LLMs. Our experiments demonstrate that
our method can rewind a learned model and unlock its controllability.
|
[
-0.3444468677043915,
-0.6810835599899292,
0.2773977220058441,
0.24424725770950317,
-0.17177973687648773,
0.020966948941349983,
-0.3920881152153015,
-0.6896119713783264,
-0.07613541930913925,
0.4513437747955322,
-0.39971283078193665,
-0.05314021185040474,
-0.6798890233039856,
-0.07324271649122238,
-0.13568396866321564,
1.451080083847046,
0.04765325412154198,
-0.051140472292900085,
-0.04171133041381836,
-0.09585841745138168,
-0.4902348518371582,
-0.7110474109649658,
-0.9529131650924683,
-0.4241712689399719,
1.2331942319869995,
0.5318963527679443,
1.1695613861083984,
0.46455779671669006,
0.6422615647315979,
0.27697038650512695,
-0.3303823173046112,
-0.055327072739601135,
-0.5154876112937927,
0.06519865989685059,
-0.5992457270622253,
-0.2867840826511383,
-0.8827353119850159,
-0.2174406349658966,
0.19407042860984802,
0.7042233347892761,
-0.14912988245487213,
-0.09899028390645981,
0.47064125537872314,
0.25503942370414734,
-0.699476957321167,
-0.1543707400560379,
-0.6385350227355957,
-0.21442770957946777,
0.1011447161436081,
-0.17805272340774536,
-0.32132160663604736,
-0.2805613875389099,
-0.08173340559005737,
-0.590025782585144,
-0.06791643053293228,
-0.0525948628783226,
0.46186259388923645,
0.46656498312950134,
-0.5167011618614197,
-0.43039682507514954,
-0.5522648096084595,
1.2267588376998901,
-0.7188230156898499,
0.2813622057437897,
0.5621719360351562,
0.07214297354221344,
-0.2935773432254791,
-0.23785008490085602,
-0.43330132961273193,
-0.28215286135673523,
0.006183031480759382,
-0.16497603058815002,
-0.04819071292877197,
0.1836133897304535,
0.18266819417476654,
0.044854238629341125,
-0.2450888305902481,
0.5111604928970337,
-0.09984597563743591,
-0.38503512740135193,
0.9111679792404175,
0.15654896199703217,
0.6067251563072205,
0.006245550233870745,
-0.3193409740924835,
-0.22017036378383636,
-0.6844961643218994,
0.36528468132019043,
0.253024160861969,
0.4789207875728607,
-0.3317585587501526,
0.7267940640449524,
-0.18948359787464142,
0.5152229070663452,
-0.12376286834478378,
-0.3907470703125,
0.15355269610881805,
-0.3007093667984009,
-0.3535023033618927,
-0.3440174162387848,
0.6652587652206421,
0.67680823802948,
0.5972402691841125,
-0.25210729241371155,
-0.2711629569530487,
0.05671501159667969,
0.4907359778881073,
-0.7692952156066895,
-0.09484954923391342,
0.15659837424755096,
-0.32281163334846497,
-0.39549511671066284,
-0.33344146609306335,
-0.4486553966999054,
-0.5042996406555176,
-0.3435361981391907,
0.28240400552749634,
-0.34965240955352783,
-0.3991169035434723,
0.11021922528743744,
0.21850761771202087,
-0.07431764900684357,
0.37560421228408813,
-1.2003535032272339,
0.08648495376110077,
0.6045465469360352,
0.47775763273239136,
-0.1411380022764206,
-0.10174790024757385,
-0.6900116801261902,
0.3518426716327667,
-0.09314548224210739,
0.3451384902000427,
-0.4969080686569214,
-0.4963224530220032,
0.00022302196884993464,
0.0082997502759099,
0.3058459758758545,
-0.38666701316833496,
0.5873258113861084,
-0.5095431804656982,
-0.16779616475105286,
-0.4072997272014618,
-0.24421079456806183,
-0.06987979263067245,
0.1474238932132721,
-0.3989599645137787,
0.4519854485988617,
-0.025594055652618408,
-0.932521402835846,
0.5776388049125671,
-0.3421069085597992,
-0.6840479373931885,
-0.16380713880062103,
0.01913333125412464,
-0.5734604597091675,
0.15805305540561676,
0.05945442616939545,
0.5107899308204651,
0.14014844596385956,
0.40130847692489624,
-0.6534630656242371,
-0.053484708070755005,
0.3354586064815521,
-0.3197551667690277,
0.8709282875061035,
0.23123230040073395,
-0.17619648575782776,
0.7018408179283142,
-0.4573778510093689,
0.1269146054983139,
-0.10400684922933578,
-0.7375973463058472,
-0.5490456819534302,
0.020660925656557083,
0.35071897506713867,
0.42424312233924866,
0.30909931659698486,
-0.3220095932483673,
0.0687563493847847,
-0.2805306613445282,
-0.032777395099401474,
0.8574204444885254,
-0.1308276504278183,
0.49043717980384827,
-0.5941347479820251,
0.5094861388206482,
-0.19976270198822021,
0.4008278250694275,
0.18156133592128754,
-0.3118058443069458,
-0.6309095025062561,
-0.37989136576652527,
-0.0599413700401783,
0.5817746520042419,
-0.807590126991272,
0.6304909586906433,
0.11808214336633682,
-0.2994440197944641,
-0.3115059733390808,
0.6006284356117249,
0.5581803917884827,
0.29855111241340637,
0.3179001808166504,
-0.20333734154701233,
-0.32657918334007263,
-0.8610457181930542,
-0.17682592570781708,
-0.2188347429037094,
-0.431386262178421,
0.302101731300354,
0.12468770146369934,
-0.25591662526130676,
0.6407474875450134,
-0.2627600133419037,
-0.050844017416238785,
-0.3699357211589813,
-0.19631259143352509,
-0.22207103669643402,
0.6301131844520569,
0.45510709285736084,
-0.9063494205474854,
-0.2922881245613098,
-0.001904074801132083,
-0.7613617777824402,
-0.38620007038116455,
0.08607304096221924,
0.033422622829675674,
0.06321445107460022,
0.46761706471443176,
-0.3287004828453064,
0.13107289373874664,
0.27816689014434814,
-0.45393604040145874,
0.1352321356534958,
-0.19664424657821655,
-0.059007853269577026,
-1.1038594245910645,
0.11301810294389725,
0.006685109343379736,
-0.29059940576553345,
-0.655163586139679,
0.29808929562568665,
0.18839360773563385,
0.16617926955223083,
-0.6236357688903809,
0.45903465151786804,
-0.15928184986114502,
0.3389092683792114,
-0.5660344958305359,
-0.012547255493700504,
-0.30487963557243347,
0.3050479590892792,
-0.05273072421550751,
0.6490628719329834,
0.3385915458202362,
-0.7047896981239319,
0.09156448394060135,
0.049380820244550705,
0.10633508116006851,
0.6453439593315125,
-0.8267344832420349,
-0.08376622945070267,
-0.13179908692836761,
-0.06480104476213455,
-0.7477085590362549,
-0.4111073613166809,
0.072051040828228,
-0.17669272422790527,
0.4455570876598358,
0.08821579813957214,
-0.41358131170272827,
-0.1774672418832779,
-0.38241180777549744,
0.2795863151550293,
0.4543083608150482,
-0.23928505182266235,
0.21774975955486298,
0.6745103001594543,
-0.4732542037963867,
-0.5882197618484497,
-0.573787271976471,
-0.0548163466155529,
-0.504270076751709,
-0.4587353467941284,
0.04897349700331688,
-0.4918519854545593,
-0.4075164496898651,
-0.3569450378417969,
-0.12387976795434952,
-0.02619197405874729,
0.723354160785675,
0.5147871971130371,
0.28645673394203186,
0.4068678021430969,
0.29910510778427124,
0.15326736867427826,
-0.3211120367050171,
-0.009627241641283035,
0.17611177265644073,
0.23343206942081451,
-0.032460179179906845,
-0.19995130598545074,
-0.2727261781692505,
0.6354265809059143,
0.4477076530456543,
-0.2999821603298187,
0.929283618927002,
0.3251837491989136,
-0.35081449151039124,
-0.05485469102859497,
-0.45004090666770935,
-0.38411539793014526,
-0.5334135890007019,
0.2725018262863159,
0.07555004954338074,
-1.4323726892471313,
0.4348103106021881,
0.24153251945972443,
0.5037503838539124,
-0.08379585295915604,
0.7224456667900085,
-0.14683488011360168,
1.1038734912872314,
1.0138713121414185,
-0.10506278276443481,
0.6487702131271362,
0.3331041634082794,
0.4403810501098633,
-0.42896705865859985,
-0.22676800191402435,
-0.565639317035675,
-0.24237634241580963,
-0.6300975680351257,
-0.061097342520952225,
0.2903819978237152,
0.36899489164352417,
-0.4564294219017029,
0.07851243764162064,
-0.42458489537239075,
0.3488861620426178,
0.3025623559951782,
0.12041965126991272,
0.37941253185272217,
-0.11740048229694366,
-0.01829698123037815,
-0.12966306507587433,
-0.6078771948814392,
-0.5018719434738159,
0.9127627611160278,
0.5504181981086731,
1.3408764600753784,
0.32297226786613464,
0.6751222014427185,
0.015434623695909977,
0.7131488919258118,
-0.784217357635498,
0.5732156038284302,
-0.004937939811497927,
-0.6343455910682678,
-0.4097236692905426,
-0.5087153911590576,
-0.8404219150543213,
-0.06097061559557915,
-0.352527379989624,
-0.8160251379013062,
-0.24189206957817078,
0.4954748749732971,
-0.5198334455490112,
0.22189119458198547,
-0.8315232396125793,
0.43557971715927124,
-0.4255419671535492,
-0.718473494052887,
-0.2423774003982544,
-0.7184544801712036,
0.24353665113449097,
-0.16210708022117615,
0.5082136988639832,
-0.13535575568675995,
-0.09173455834388733,
0.6008368730545044,
-0.07922269403934479,
1.1801902055740356,
-0.12639988958835602,
-0.4383947253227234,
-0.08331622183322906,
0.14119462668895721,
0.2664030194282532,
0.050529398024082184,
0.034291334450244904,
-0.21424272656440735,
-0.27349531650543213,
-0.6167186498641968,
-0.3623248338699341,
1.1500805616378784,
-0.7413227558135986,
-0.8890254497528076,
-0.17996230721473694,
-0.9186888933181763,
-0.2019680291414261,
0.5921684503555298,
0.010773603804409504,
-0.0012306615244597197,
0.06435612589120865,
0.3681541681289673,
0.925679087638855,
-0.3418305516242981,
0.7882473468780518,
0.5745639801025391,
-0.2902930676937103,
-0.32085567712783813,
0.5674856305122375,
0.14901697635650635,
0.48076075315475464,
0.19424979388713837,
0.08876056224107742,
-0.371782511472702,
-0.6286376714706421,
0.002260251436382532,
-0.05536586418747902,
-0.5814113020896912,
-0.32913240790367126,
-0.5548351407051086,
-0.07563620060682297,
-0.2886011004447937,
-0.6106582880020142,
-0.2774539291858673,
-0.31916698813438416,
-0.171730175614357,
-0.4379167854785919,
0.40043723583221436,
0.594279944896698,
-0.19683101773262024,
0.37455135583877563,
-0.5720688700675964,
0.2561577558517456,
0.4809019863605499,
0.6337023377418518,
0.12583808600902557,
-0.11084430664777756,
-0.4172542691230774,
-0.10499164462089539,
-0.45288580656051636,
-0.503812313079834,
0.014428802765905857,
-0.18082565069198608,
0.5693283677101135,
0.4221785366535187,
0.3934483528137207,
0.11176244169473648,
-0.3631180226802826,
0.6712405681610107,
0.42555487155914307,
-0.72613126039505,
0.4985526204109192,
-0.5192320942878723,
0.23407378792762756,
0.5634425282478333,
0.44242602586746216,
-0.3277933597564697,
-0.49048566818237305,
-0.428689181804657,
-1.0980428457260132,
0.28696975111961365,
0.17358644306659698,
0.4221261143684387,
-0.0782163217663765,
0.068442702293396,
0.08062564581632614,
0.1868874877691269,
-0.9832340478897095,
-0.006573098246008158,
-0.2642720341682434,
-0.16348780691623688,
-0.11659074574708939,
-0.5094727277755737,
-0.45583194494247437,
0.017583075910806656,
0.692700982093811,
-0.03200758621096611,
-0.3388015925884247,
-0.1363605111837387,
0.038958076387643814,
-0.27978941798210144,
0.8336426019668579,
0.42226481437683105,
0.5435534119606018,
-0.06283829361200333,
0.4536590278148651,
0.2894722819328308,
-0.20564724504947662,
0.3491543233394623,
-0.0862785205245018,
-0.2180042862892151,
-0.7303932905197144,
0.35127419233322144,
0.4653974175453186,
0.5100991725921631,
-0.563046932220459,
0.256364643573761,
0.04675858095288277,
0.11649924516677856,
0.05648012086749077,
0.7710068821907043,
0.30155888199806213,
0.15701228380203247,
0.13535484671592712,
-0.1337689310312271,
-0.14351946115493774,
-0.25530415773391724,
0.24919256567955017,
0.7203491926193237,
-0.16571223735809326,
-0.1957031488418579,
0.7227839827537537,
0.4417562186717987,
-0.5744725465774536,
0.12802426517009735,
0.10510142892599106,
-0.2269497513771057,
0.28708186745643616,
0.5533362627029419,
0.7263205647468567,
-0.5118870139122009,
0.03922245651483536,
0.1788787841796875,
0.5329909324645996,
0.2518596649169922,
0.3590332567691803,
0.026172230020165443,
-0.7323462963104248,
-0.35565775632858276,
-0.4301840662956238,
-0.4233812689781189,
0.35686442255973816,
-0.861420214176178,
-0.06915745139122009,
-0.7984465956687927,
-0.4368601143360138,
0.06707482784986496,
-0.0048278700560331345,
-0.4641069173812866,
0.4421952962875366,
0.03682157024741173,
0.878175675868988,
-0.9026164412498474,
0.8033888339996338,
0.7128946185112,
-0.4242208003997803,
-0.9170026183128357,
0.13345250487327576,
-0.02542291395366192,
-0.23265452682971954,
0.25088420510292053,
0.1922924518585205,
-0.30243104696273804,
-0.3009377717971802,
-0.7574306130409241,
-0.44539621472358704,
0.8223742246627808,
0.48671630024909973,
-0.6302674412727356,
0.03619283437728882,
-0.06646379083395004,
0.5525695085525513,
-0.14750050008296967,
-0.03258835896849632,
0.3858264684677124,
0.31630373001098633,
-0.09954535961151123,
-1.0907231569290161,
0.13580067455768585,
-0.23983240127563477,
0.10617166012525558,
0.13697506487369537,
-0.6558056473731995,
0.5436564087867737,
-0.37553003430366516,
-0.0023036820348352194,
-0.0685616284608841,
0.5932708978652954,
0.35374483466148376,
0.4813459515571594,
0.6833996176719666,
0.43546062707901,
0.6879952549934387,
0.15909501910209656,
1.1426199674606323,
0.061722513288259506,
0.08101421594619751,
1.1593470573425293,
-0.19779881834983826,
0.7248732447624207,
0.8739200830459595,
0.0031097554601728916,
0.016280097886919975,
0.3999318778514862,
0.48261186480522156,
0.603706419467926,
0.21781566739082336,
-0.5508102178573608,
-0.5026009678840637,
-0.45836591720581055,
-0.31571638584136963,
0.14870722591876984,
0.2869090437889099,
-0.20292910933494568,
-0.27965548634529114,
0.1735692322254181,
0.5091397762298584,
0.1926516890525818,
-0.46342167258262634,
0.7855706810951233,
0.32087498903274536,
-0.6268486380577087,
0.5524690747261047,
0.02333897352218628,
0.9935057759284973,
-0.6417801976203918,
0.24085025489330292,
-0.15867666900157928,
0.1791338324546814,
-0.40780338644981384,
-1.01676607131958,
0.4603230059146881,
0.30477505922317505,
-0.46825510263442993,
-0.21612848341464996,
0.7553377747535706,
-0.40071558952331543,
-0.4389830529689789,
0.5827845335006714,
0.2999916970729828,
-0.2660786509513855,
0.33834517002105713,
-0.29006505012512207,
0.006806202698498964,
0.06311985850334167,
-0.17463673651218414,
0.6409838795661926,
0.20743128657341003,
-0.4685308635234833,
0.9195384383201599,
0.7008922696113586,
-0.005279765464365482,
-0.056136325001716614,
-0.07325492054224014,
1.063359022140503,
-0.3544040620326996,
-0.5986086130142212,
-0.7680816650390625,
0.7669752836227417,
-0.04988739266991615,
-0.14995771646499634,
0.7112534046173096,
0.07136707752943039,
0.9825328588485718,
-0.0694335475564003,
0.8968983292579651,
-0.050724443048238754,
0.45195263624191284,
-0.3249891996383667,
1.0291739702224731,
-0.5959147810935974,
0.34776246547698975,
-0.38728928565979004,
-0.51935875415802,
-0.609752893447876,
0.6314215064048767,
-0.34018734097480774,
0.20983414351940155,
0.10873828828334808,
0.7836553454399109,
-0.12484832853078842,
-0.24066901206970215,
0.4450030028820038,
0.04007839038968086,
0.6394398808479309,
0.7087230086326599,
0.6126163601875305,
0.3817167282104492,
0.2758658826351166,
-0.27668771147727966,
-0.5533708333969116,
-0.19759882986545563,
-1.200427532196045,
-1.1009818315505981,
-0.11994729936122894,
-0.15347135066986084,
-0.34933435916900635,
-0.062428321689367294,
0.8961755037307739,
0.7044538259506226,
-0.9945226907730103,
-0.10824132710695267,
0.007251993287354708,
0.3809814453125,
0.011071635410189629,
-0.14560943841934204,
0.007814123295247555,
-0.2600120007991791,
-0.4871058464050293,
0.34387797117233276,
0.09432521462440491,
0.3145330250263214,
-0.13372907042503357,
-0.14903460443019867,
0.12958456575870514,
0.03935001790523529,
0.4976542592048645,
0.4171852171421051,
-0.5889506936073303,
-0.6442347764968872,
-0.16883428394794464,
-0.21341447532176971,
-0.3202032744884491,
0.7964882254600525,
-0.2387869656085968,
0.4218011796474457,
0.40481460094451904,
0.6405136585235596,
-0.1677236557006836,
-0.20067398250102997,
0.6665794849395752,
-0.7766633629798889,
0.35985884070396423,
0.07776076346635818,
0.29808005690574646,
0.6097095012664795,
-0.636572539806366,
0.31050100922584534,
-0.3670336902141571,
-0.696659505367279,
-0.6670011878013611,
0.4285002648830414,
-1.0522569417953491,
-0.06387191265821457,
1.1644232273101807,
-0.40353506803512573,
0.19795796275138855,
-0.15657906234264374,
-0.4752674400806427,
0.49971598386764526,
-0.4004376232624054,
1.005778193473816,
0.5672303438186646,
0.02281302772462368,
-0.31075555086135864,
-0.3631485402584076,
0.7083557844161987,
0.6967864036560059,
-0.944270670413971,
0.2417621910572052,
0.5030081272125244,
0.5735710263252258,
0.11546915769577026,
0.48807674646377563,
0.09431452304124832,
0.29075101017951965,
-0.5369008779525757,
0.06701197475194931,
-0.250742107629776,
-0.6307967305183411,
-0.4535698890686035,
0.27161911129951477,
0.48567745089530945,
0.10729467868804932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01291v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01291v2
|
Evaluating Text-to-Visual Generation with Image-to-Text Generation
| 2024-04-01T17:58:06 | 2024-06-18T07:09:55 |
Zhiqiu Lin, Deepak Pathak, Baiqi Li, Jiayao Li, Xide Xia, Graham Neubig, Pengchuan Zhang, Deva Ramanan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Despite significant progress in generative AI, comprehensive evaluation
remains challenging because of the lack of effective metrics and standardized
benchmarks. For instance, the widely-used CLIPScore measures the alignment
between a (generated) image and text prompt, but it fails to produce reliable
scores for complex prompts involving compositions of objects, attributes, and
relations. One reason is that text encoders of CLIP can notoriously act as a
"bag of words", conflating prompts such as "the horse is eating the grass" with
"the grass is eating the horse". To address this, we introduce the VQAScore,
which uses a visual-question-answering (VQA) model to produce an alignment
score by computing the probability of a "Yes" answer to a simple "Does this
figure show '{text}'?" question. Though simpler than prior art, VQAScore
computed with off-the-shelf models produces state-of-the-art results across
many (8) image-text alignment benchmarks. We also compute VQAScore with an
in-house model that follows best practices in the literature. For example, we
use a bidirectional image-question encoder that allows image embeddings to
depend on the question being asked (and vice versa). Our in-house model,
CLIP-FlanT5, outperforms even the strongest baselines that make use of the
proprietary GPT-4V. Interestingly, although we train with only images, VQAScore
can also align text with video and 3D models. VQAScore allows researchers to
benchmark text-to-visual generation using complex texts that capture the
compositional structure of real-world prompts. We introduce GenAI-Bench, a more
challenging benchmark with 1,600 compositional text prompts that require
parsing scenes, objects, attributes, relationships, and high-order reasoning
like comparison and logic. GenAI-Bench also offers over 15,000 human ratings
for leading image and video generation models such as Stable Diffusion, DALL-E
3, and Gen2.
|
[
-0.4945726692676544,
-0.7652344107627869,
0.7000803351402283,
0.22539880871772766,
-0.2699301242828369,
-0.049414124339818954,
-0.04363272711634636,
-0.4241783022880554,
-0.27794790267944336,
0.3393554091453552,
-0.5786231756210327,
-0.375426709651947,
-0.4559726119041443,
0.18719087541103363,
-0.6098783612251282,
0.902795135974884,
-0.2694506049156189,
0.02518954686820507,
-0.867522656917572,
-0.16113600134849548,
-0.7122006416320801,
-0.1375034898519516,
-0.2813776731491089,
-0.04975418746471405,
0.297360897064209,
0.37674418091773987,
0.6385472416877747,
0.658764660358429,
0.5564197897911072,
0.32289615273475647,
0.16829724609851837,
0.2689070999622345,
-0.5325239896774292,
0.12115167826414108,
-0.13419529795646667,
-0.18986357748508453,
-0.05894571170210838,
-0.03888390585780144,
0.5963184833526611,
0.25236284732818604,
0.05281737819314003,
0.2862311899662018,
0.08643835783004761,
0.487815260887146,
-0.7939106225967407,
-0.10980582237243652,
-0.4737006723880768,
0.104684017598629,
-0.012717724777758121,
-0.241397887468338,
-0.23906642198562622,
-0.4804694950580597,
0.2345157265663147,
-0.7580698132514954,
0.23173794150352478,
0.07070177048444748,
1.2804230451583862,
0.2860964238643646,
-0.315034419298172,
-0.2916383445262909,
-0.5915741920471191,
0.7038837671279907,
-0.18059782683849335,
0.18140767514705658,
0.05525968596339226,
0.4952827990055084,
0.15052685141563416,
-0.9923767447471619,
-0.7862001061439514,
-0.0953698679804802,
0.2849331498146057,
0.5694442391395569,
-0.3801824152469635,
-0.13639089465141296,
0.3295254707336426,
0.5589269995689392,
-0.6986077427864075,
-0.1528952717781067,
-0.25873175263404846,
0.021315254271030426,
0.4299018979072571,
0.39216411113739014,
0.6226291656494141,
-0.39380890130996704,
-0.8086357712745667,
-0.48621928691864014,
-0.3857041895389557,
0.29028213024139404,
0.1613551378250122,
-0.3106904923915863,
0.12767969071865082,
0.9414221048355103,
-0.171099454164505,
0.5505495071411133,
0.1624639332294464,
0.1512322872877121,
0.05586110055446625,
-0.5927965641021729,
-0.2093445360660553,
-0.18262715637683868,
1.1758716106414795,
0.921118974685669,
0.3887025713920593,
0.09845538437366486,
-0.15431798994541168,
0.27797016501426697,
0.41137105226516724,
-0.9860565066337585,
-0.3141123950481415,
0.012407808564603329,
-0.2248830944299698,
-0.25626102089881897,
0.0748828798532486,
-0.9136328101158142,
-0.2901475429534912,
-0.12057512253522873,
0.8198837637901306,
-0.637995183467865,
0.273235559463501,
-0.026557588949799538,
-0.6189256310462952,
0.6332139372825623,
0.49725213646888733,
-0.6891795992851257,
0.09988740086555481,
0.49475833773612976,
0.7738011479377747,
-0.21570812165737152,
-0.43468618392944336,
-0.653831958770752,
-0.0023478760849684477,
-0.4400988817214966,
1.2458583116531372,
-0.5090211033821106,
-0.43422985076904297,
0.09512750804424286,
-0.10183599591255188,
0.008946758694946766,
-0.57412189245224,
0.5365788340568542,
-0.27885591983795166,
0.577471911907196,
-0.6216304302215576,
-0.6262034177780151,
-0.1034587174654007,
0.45345449447631836,
-0.611976683139801,
1.1822832822799683,
0.18914176523685455,
-0.7010958790779114,
0.5481393337249756,
-0.26160210371017456,
-0.10939860343933105,
0.24083535373210907,
-0.518401563167572,
-0.5478724241256714,
0.028728650882840157,
0.7054992318153381,
0.029007747769355774,
-0.7458909749984741,
0.23674437403678894,
-0.00776105048134923,
-0.45268741250038147,
0.3202076554298401,
-0.5652279257774353,
0.46477746963500977,
-0.03866450861096382,
-0.3798089623451233,
0.3002300262451172,
-0.6227729916572571,
0.1848166286945343,
0.29900410771369934,
-0.04349595308303833,
-0.2432914674282074,
-0.060971327126026154,
0.19179534912109375,
0.09838133305311203,
0.21452634036540985,
-0.4507560729980469,
0.057774219661951065,
-0.03181673213839531,
0.25159329175949097,
0.5930011868476868,
0.20632334053516388,
0.34916195273399353,
-0.40965956449508667,
0.7472732067108154,
-0.07912858575582504,
0.22660911083221436,
-0.5459381937980652,
-0.6462089419364929,
-0.6858080625534058,
-0.2056737244129181,
0.24050910770893097,
0.7099140286445618,
-0.9798509478569031,
0.270834743976593,
-0.29234838485717773,
-0.538937509059906,
-0.5543587803840637,
0.00020817101176362485,
0.47492337226867676,
0.8297070860862732,
0.4254879951477051,
-0.5056421756744385,
-0.15917252004146576,
-0.8057550191879272,
-0.17336204648017883,
-0.21122030913829803,
-0.225721538066864,
0.20976011455059052,
0.4907431900501251,
0.06534457206726074,
0.9171124696731567,
-0.5134740471839905,
-0.07278743386268616,
-0.04129866510629654,
0.37864741683006287,
-0.2787075340747833,
0.3489197790622711,
0.7226052284240723,
-0.7451704740524292,
-0.3851322531700134,
-0.148912250995636,
-0.899726390838623,
-0.07433544844388962,
-0.3078519403934479,
-0.2969244122505188,
-0.2939275801181793,
0.3618907034397125,
-0.6062893867492676,
0.4788210690021515,
0.40937668085098267,
-0.3745884299278259,
0.6116992831230164,
-0.132992222905159,
0.5866184234619141,
-1.1619452238082886,
0.05549752712249756,
0.1977260410785675,
-0.17730148136615753,
-0.33456283807754517,
0.05854513496160507,
0.05539628118276596,
-0.279659241437912,
-0.4039566218852997,
0.3895215392112732,
-0.3880543112754822,
-0.14888730645179749,
-0.08486060053110123,
0.2704160511493683,
0.4984971880912781,
0.28908205032348633,
-0.02656581997871399,
1.1717736721038818,
0.41417965292930603,
-0.427743136882782,
0.4442180097103119,
0.6509326696395874,
-0.6689021587371826,
1.0594899654388428,
-1.0003718137741089,
0.06588348746299744,
-0.3364473879337311,
0.07164443284273148,
-1.225053310394287,
-0.25510507822036743,
0.2772439122200012,
-0.5231122970581055,
0.024055026471614838,
0.20958371460437775,
-0.3853977918624878,
-0.35048484802246094,
-0.6041409373283386,
0.6498696804046631,
0.6299710273742676,
-0.7043739557266235,
0.4718037247657776,
0.09411855041980743,
-0.06724147498607635,
-0.4748590886592865,
-0.5956921577453613,
0.25179019570350647,
-0.15823231637477875,
-0.7596030235290527,
0.45521479845046997,
-0.25815099477767944,
0.08821804076433182,
0.19801102578639984,
0.2582184076309204,
0.07782483100891113,
-0.15569306910037994,
0.24989666044712067,
0.3376551568508148,
-0.3383660912513733,
0.09192340821027756,
0.09127617627382278,
0.12403261661529541,
0.15097132325172424,
-0.09563962370157242,
0.2960076928138733,
-0.08696623146533966,
-0.4206796884536743,
-0.31310153007507324,
0.5332450866699219,
0.5538445115089417,
-0.4679941236972809,
0.38126125931739807,
0.6728880405426025,
-0.2649933993816376,
-0.08733926713466644,
-0.3492458164691925,
0.19986461102962494,
-0.46847736835479736,
0.4483897387981415,
-0.24806416034698486,
-0.6433896422386169,
0.2541288137435913,
-0.13068096339702606,
0.026698213070631027,
0.6305692791938782,
0.5062844753265381,
-0.30704835057258606,
1.1870297193527222,
0.49007880687713623,
0.3208736479282379,
0.5975856781005859,
-0.2378053367137909,
-0.07611659914255142,
-0.8262931108474731,
-0.2656218409538269,
-0.40959498286247253,
-0.17914776504039764,
-0.4127548038959503,
-0.5961942672729492,
0.505706250667572,
0.16982401907444,
-0.3276737928390503,
0.26897692680358887,
-0.6674308776855469,
0.5661869645118713,
0.6174287796020508,
0.10292968899011612,
0.11552369594573975,
0.09695716947317123,
0.011070888489484787,
-0.2069857269525528,
-0.6347072124481201,
-0.5347112417221069,
0.8057354092597961,
0.14087601006031036,
0.5564410090446472,
-0.13675442337989807,
0.5080968737602234,
0.23519234359264374,
0.2711220979690552,
-0.7905642986297607,
0.5560104250907898,
-0.24064888060092926,
-0.16755369305610657,
-0.20666463673114777,
-0.16489259898662567,
-0.7555431723594666,
0.1643909513950348,
-0.5121879577636719,
-0.6523028612136841,
0.149428591132164,
0.1323409229516983,
-0.3168768882751465,
0.0946221575140953,
-0.6212142109870911,
1.186806082725525,
-0.3965241014957428,
-0.5408303141593933,
0.27723532915115356,
-0.4004712402820587,
0.5182027220726013,
0.25824081897735596,
-0.18292561173439026,
0.16357122361660004,
-0.00026960522518493235,
0.5641798377037048,
-0.4836737811565399,
0.5861889123916626,
0.13229165971279144,
0.07076313346624374,
0.6636145114898682,
-0.18948057293891907,
0.19181419909000397,
-0.0750400647521019,
0.249580979347229,
-0.10078167915344238,
0.13127261400222778,
-0.29413866996765137,
-0.688753068447113,
0.4621654152870178,
-0.7408322095870972,
-0.49433454871177673,
-0.3409107029438019,
-0.304397314786911,
-0.08742057532072067,
-0.05556366220116615,
0.8586700558662415,
0.4893556237220764,
-0.5098451972007751,
0.14456520974636078,
0.6486985087394714,
-0.558085024356842,
0.29400205612182617,
-0.062340278178453445,
-0.28568071126937866,
-0.8658673167228699,
0.9598971009254456,
-0.19206203520298004,
0.21124330163002014,
0.41540929675102234,
0.19975636899471283,
-0.3818489909172058,
-0.16033148765563965,
-0.9582897424697876,
0.013319907709956169,
-0.7858442068099976,
-0.371102511882782,
-0.5267454385757446,
-0.3512021601200104,
-0.11594505608081818,
-0.14990292489528656,
-0.1619279384613037,
-0.07462066411972046,
-0.5349348187446594,
-0.07507538050413132,
0.2939274311065674,
0.604410707950592,
0.3261544406414032,
0.274188756942749,
-0.8121770620346069,
0.45151177048683167,
0.7106918692588806,
0.1845720261335373,
-0.03593422472476959,
-0.410297155380249,
0.0911528691649437,
-0.20299896597862244,
-0.6689349412918091,
-1.0857211351394653,
0.1455008089542389,
0.37208491563796997,
0.29427286982536316,
0.29903659224510193,
-0.04087606072425842,
0.8849132061004639,
-0.6382583379745483,
1.200134038925171,
0.5335996150970459,
-1.066074252128601,
0.6175901293754578,
-0.2818997800350189,
0.5470383167266846,
0.6421040892601013,
0.18926022946834564,
-0.4475230872631073,
-0.2637918293476105,
-0.2812994122505188,
-0.704836368560791,
0.18985828757286072,
0.3001589775085449,
0.17883548140525818,
-0.16026709973812103,
0.12697145342826843,
0.061803050339221954,
0.2624717950820923,
-0.5006858110427856,
0.1880795657634735,
-0.6019312143325806,
-0.439657986164093,
0.06872797012329102,
-0.30919384956359863,
0.014247607439756393,
-0.3099904954433441,
0.15841175615787506,
-0.2234654277563095,
0.2641783058643341,
0.3764297664165497,
-0.04683000594377518,
-0.20077252388000488,
0.18202169239521027,
0.6012480854988098,
0.4472145736217499,
0.1362089365720749,
-0.024181900545954704,
-0.066234290599823,
-0.43407517671585083,
0.023751843720674515,
-0.0155844297260046,
-0.46926742792129517,
0.015474079176783562,
0.44026467204093933,
1.0325270891189575,
0.10539153963327408,
-0.921477198600769,
0.9129535555839539,
-0.3357515037059784,
-0.5031402111053467,
-0.2599365711212158,
0.03931033983826637,
-0.1046949028968811,
0.21487635374069214,
0.20821082592010498,
-0.06396859139204025,
0.23866605758666992,
-0.5645118355751038,
0.20545080304145813,
0.4105698764324188,
-0.6160962581634521,
-0.2688905894756317,
0.9368748068809509,
0.22982318699359894,
-0.23798483610153198,
0.7818813920021057,
-0.13708335161209106,
-0.6576716303825378,
0.7412589192390442,
0.46576276421546936,
0.9920466542243958,
0.07944644242525101,
0.5774643421173096,
0.5445822477340698,
0.3275405168533325,
-0.013381294906139374,
0.5101744532585144,
-0.15757521986961365,
-0.5196160674095154,
-0.29896488785743713,
-0.4672129154205322,
-0.5204067230224609,
-0.05729012191295624,
-0.6605653762817383,
0.202941432595253,
-0.34927770495414734,
-0.311300665140152,
-0.05852305516600609,
-0.38456985354423523,
-0.7848673462867737,
0.35903283953666687,
0.12852171063423157,
0.7672684788703918,
-0.8846091628074646,
0.31912416219711304,
0.8076984882354736,
-0.7592670917510986,
-0.6073617339134216,
0.19196106493473053,
-0.14488300681114197,
-0.6009753942489624,
0.30844584107398987,
0.3937005400657654,
0.03022131323814392,
-0.10835125297307968,
-0.8865744471549988,
-0.5321075916290283,
1.267236351966858,
0.24422337114810944,
-0.4626259505748749,
0.05573028698563576,
0.08496851474046707,
0.6371462941169739,
-0.3372107446193695,
0.365242600440979,
0.3899449110031128,
0.2993001341819763,
0.2855048179626465,
-0.4527663588523865,
0.00834635365754366,
-0.45441141724586487,
0.2778348922729492,
0.15605217218399048,
-0.5977169275283813,
0.8555341362953186,
-0.18887366354465485,
-0.4620291292667389,
0.4901224672794342,
0.8100122809410095,
0.2712975740432739,
0.5100995302200317,
0.4249715209007263,
0.5891646146774292,
0.5908782482147217,
-0.24193540215492249,
1.128928303718567,
-0.15776631236076355,
0.03704085946083069,
0.9716679453849792,
-0.15914610028266907,
0.8851573467254639,
0.6040026545524597,
-0.03304191306233406,
0.5514044761657715,
0.48504066467285156,
-0.38114598393440247,
0.4730587601661682,
0.18223007023334503,
-0.13200944662094116,
-0.27469778060913086,
-0.40873250365257263,
-0.22584989666938782,
0.4322812259197235,
0.06709707528352737,
-0.3638872504234314,
-0.08911324292421341,
0.0014997749822214246,
-0.5109133124351501,
0.522913932800293,
-0.14877910912036896,
0.8464105129241943,
-0.09783265739679337,
-0.8007702231407166,
0.3528769314289093,
-0.237695574760437,
0.3967466950416565,
-0.36150994896888733,
-0.30051183700561523,
-0.11992937326431274,
-0.1048160046339035,
0.1251407116651535,
-1.1039780378341675,
-0.05638595297932625,
0.3442607522010803,
-0.18394091725349426,
-0.12539216876029968,
0.5529856085777283,
-0.47420063614845276,
-0.6061201095581055,
-0.06525442004203796,
0.46854114532470703,
-0.12306329607963562,
0.012441444210708141,
-0.5335062146186829,
0.052862316370010376,
-0.19733354449272156,
-0.0839368924498558,
0.12947890162467957,
0.5698446035385132,
-0.11107127368450165,
0.2773582637310028,
0.36456161737442017,
-0.23864606022834778,
0.02108825370669365,
0.2145843803882599,
0.8073700666427612,
-0.7351747155189514,
-0.4153091609477997,
-0.6124675869941711,
0.669838547706604,
-0.30118894577026367,
-0.7911168932914734,
0.5055833458900452,
0.5220391750335693,
0.7079952955245972,
-0.1642581820487976,
0.7143137454986572,
0.13034211099147797,
-0.03619326278567314,
-0.6266958117485046,
0.5207545757293701,
-0.7251102328300476,
-0.025142835453152657,
-0.5158257484436035,
-1.118770956993103,
0.07458077371120453,
0.25327855348587036,
-0.14160360395908356,
-0.06926753371953964,
0.710045576095581,
0.492902934551239,
0.08322535455226898,
0.09969597309827805,
0.27141696214675903,
-0.3000819683074951,
0.3745822012424469,
0.6910516619682312,
1.228594183921814,
-0.8093870878219604,
0.7766488194465637,
-0.16431741416454315,
-0.24664786458015442,
0.09417814761400223,
-0.8281025886535645,
-0.8340047597885132,
-0.7598297595977783,
-0.421485960483551,
-0.12654125690460205,
0.026870986446738243,
0.4903079569339752,
0.3521338999271393,
-0.4991717040538788,
-0.019835226237773895,
-0.13624849915504456,
-0.1665266752243042,
-0.27564379572868347,
-0.26373863220214844,
0.25542452931404114,
-0.10955636203289032,
-0.7133162617683411,
0.12269669026136398,
0.44986051321029663,
0.20944318175315857,
-0.28973132371902466,
0.07942218333482742,
0.07783547043800354,
0.2594028413295746,
0.5643796920776367,
0.26615801453590393,
-0.5525527596473694,
-0.4093467593193054,
0.17195792496204376,
-0.3310580551624298,
0.18672320246696472,
0.604119062423706,
-0.7872503399848938,
0.6839286088943481,
0.6867100596427917,
0.8426146507263184,
0.460559606552124,
0.5051482319831848,
0.718360960483551,
-0.5770361423492432,
-0.30360761284828186,
0.11811835318803787,
0.13814596831798553,
0.6423163414001465,
-0.2044098973274231,
0.24623720347881317,
0.13435956835746765,
-0.6004353165626526,
-0.6035854816436768,
0.22735998034477234,
-1.0435800552368164,
-0.11728399246931076,
0.8102245926856995,
0.08851008117198944,
-0.6158623695373535,
0.5651727914810181,
-0.5632032752037048,
0.12970253825187683,
-0.1891997903585434,
0.6872686147689819,
0.6517994403839111,
0.03060089237987995,
-0.4954087436199188,
-0.4192977249622345,
0.3917526602745056,
0.4088764786720276,
-0.995360255241394,
-0.3461570143699646,
0.7381384968757629,
0.10077466815710068,
0.043419331312179565,
0.4062720835208893,
-0.02978350780904293,
0.6368756294250488,
0.24502788484096527,
0.07802010327577591,
0.08669109642505646,
-0.28594955801963806,
-0.2674063444137573,
0.1858866959810257,
-0.06863928586244583,
-0.5597901940345764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01288v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01288v1
|
Large Language Models are Capable of Offering Cognitive Reappraisal, if Guided
| 2024-04-01T17:56:30 | 2024-04-01T17:56:30 |
Hongli Zhan, Allen Zheng, Yoon Kyung Lee, Jina Suh, Junyi Jessy Li, Desmond C. Ong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have offered new opportunities for emotional
support, and recent work has shown that they can produce empathic responses to
people in distress. However, long-term mental well-being requires emotional
self-regulation, where a one-time empathic response falls short. This work
takes a first step by engaging with cognitive reappraisals, a strategy from
psychology practitioners that uses language to targetedly change negative
appraisals that an individual makes of the situation; such appraisals is known
to sit at the root of human emotional experience. We hypothesize that
psychologically grounded principles could enable such advanced psychology
capabilities in LLMs, and design RESORT which consists of a series of
reappraisal constitutions across multiple dimensions that can be used as LLM
instructions. We conduct a first-of-its-kind expert evaluation (by clinical
psychologists with M.S. or Ph.D. degrees) of an LLM's zero-shot ability to
generate cognitive reappraisal responses to medium-length social media messages
asking for support. This fine-grained evaluation showed that even LLMs at the
7B scale guided by RESORT are capable of generating empathic responses that can
help users reappraise their situations.
|
[
-0.39066994190216064,
-0.747629702091217,
0.8265217542648315,
0.38809260725975037,
-0.35320839285850525,
0.3092927038669586,
-0.7144779562950134,
-0.2979544997215271,
0.6111528873443604,
0.40438735485076904,
-0.5730863809585571,
-0.4018799960613251,
-0.4862005114555359,
0.1054253950715065,
-0.1016843244433403,
0.8149547576904297,
-0.11371159553527832,
-0.12085237354040146,
-0.08207236975431442,
-0.06645499914884567,
-0.6485369205474854,
-0.7198916673660278,
-0.7883707284927368,
-0.5214559435844421,
0.7576797604560852,
0.3817134201526642,
0.5564641356468201,
-0.10200012475252151,
0.413656622171402,
0.1604311615228653,
0.14713703095912933,
0.026035001501441002,
-0.6651118397712708,
0.10579850524663925,
-0.42216336727142334,
-0.36373624205589294,
-0.5363888740539551,
0.13305850327014923,
0.15369585156440735,
0.2791341245174408,
-0.7108960151672363,
0.19082418084144592,
-0.031984154134988785,
0.6567814350128174,
-0.6940557360649109,
0.07995769381523132,
-0.4768422544002533,
0.21932220458984375,
0.34909480810165405,
-0.32811641693115234,
-0.5830066204071045,
-0.2814638018608093,
0.09468220174312592,
-0.46811172366142273,
-0.19060388207435608,
0.04076884686946869,
0.49903416633605957,
0.10266498476266861,
-0.5881973505020142,
-0.27467185258865356,
-0.6709679961204529,
0.819848895072937,
-0.47410765290260315,
0.34017762541770935,
0.5046265125274658,
0.33583948016166687,
0.0060374499298632145,
-0.20337516069412231,
-0.3369152545928955,
-0.4478484094142914,
0.1779489666223526,
0.17760427296161652,
-0.2741810977458954,
-0.03905193880200386,
0.17987576127052307,
0.1403685361146927,
-0.0068318601697683334,
0.17639772593975067,
-0.11666600406169891,
-0.05035541206598282,
0.8939707279205322,
0.4351593852043152,
0.19887381792068481,
0.08216533064842224,
0.04698378965258598,
0.15267544984817505,
-0.476850688457489,
0.16328124701976776,
-0.24335654079914093,
0.1499001681804657,
-0.23408931493759155,
0.4548514485359192,
-0.09734520316123962,
0.2445434033870697,
0.2722415030002594,
-0.11495627462863922,
-0.064358651638031,
0.38440901041030884,
-0.14329873025417328,
0.32448187470436096,
0.41209322214126587,
0.873085618019104,
0.6248016357421875,
-0.07722733169794083,
-0.16338156163692474,
0.4342694878578186,
0.7215372920036316,
-0.7172988653182983,
-0.016443975269794464,
0.34711161255836487,
-0.49075162410736084,
-0.3212558925151825,
-0.43668943643569946,
-0.7343727946281433,
-0.7016391754150391,
-0.48587778210639954,
0.17136211693286896,
-0.2501150071620941,
-0.6791148781776428,
0.3849453032016754,
0.050224125385284424,
0.3994356095790863,
0.5734493136405945,
-0.8080832362174988,
0.5316542983055115,
0.5947604775428772,
0.6803616285324097,
0.18668729066848755,
-0.21500001847743988,
-0.2291400134563446,
0.009367297403514385,
-0.44381019473075867,
0.7059908509254456,
-0.6908919811248779,
-0.41026267409324646,
0.2841842770576477,
-0.13125619292259216,
0.23565629124641418,
-0.2436700314283371,
0.6624762415885925,
-0.391035258769989,
-0.0032054169569164515,
-0.3260042071342468,
-0.24279235303401947,
0.0882246345281601,
0.613132119178772,
-0.12599804997444153,
0.6420213580131531,
0.21750375628471375,
-0.30326640605926514,
0.31097522377967834,
-0.42556971311569214,
-0.42614099383354187,
-0.18653683364391327,
-0.06887435168027878,
-0.05575300380587578,
0.8106071352958679,
0.30677279829978943,
0.3193328380584717,
-0.5063930749893188,
0.11693807691335678,
-0.537495493888855,
-0.15462355315685272,
0.40547019243240356,
-0.32864147424697876,
0.1970818191766739,
0.24223482608795166,
-0.2011212706565857,
-0.31668370962142944,
-0.815290093421936,
0.4086812138557434,
0.17071792483329773,
-0.48349276185035706,
-0.5284766554832458,
-0.033114418387413025,
0.03093680739402771,
0.40856170654296875,
0.1439351737499237,
-0.6880309581756592,
0.12990836799144745,
-0.1887402981519699,
0.4595792889595032,
0.8789277076721191,
0.21149377524852753,
0.2348863035440445,
-0.20839452743530273,
0.8013426661491394,
-0.16169704496860504,
0.1862749457359314,
-0.23657220602035522,
-0.15978102385997772,
-0.66612309217453,
-0.34430524706840515,
-0.3391692042350769,
0.3125133812427521,
-0.3822997212409973,
0.17130817472934723,
-0.2271917164325714,
-0.5743910670280457,
-0.5649096369743347,
0.00019721989519894123,
0.44249653816223145,
0.3023710250854492,
0.35932156443595886,
-0.20685681700706482,
-0.35705509781837463,
-0.7374392747879028,
-0.5815008282661438,
-0.04083114489912987,
0.13997815549373627,
0.4605409502983093,
0.17425690591335297,
-0.06968510895967484,
0.7029608488082886,
-0.5466431975364685,
-0.3589448928833008,
0.1383962333202362,
-0.07962846755981445,
0.11887479573488235,
0.17051082849502563,
0.3380335867404938,
-0.27055877447128296,
-0.3073510527610779,
0.026773016899824142,
-1.0159088373184204,
-0.17820896208286285,
-0.12429498881101608,
-0.1441953480243683,
0.03131500259041786,
0.36614203453063965,
-0.6784698367118835,
0.2950756847858429,
0.3183048367500305,
-0.5249897837638855,
0.17331328988075256,
-0.4128590226173401,
0.41754525899887085,
-0.696603000164032,
-0.20882010459899902,
0.041431013494729996,
-0.06955607235431671,
-0.43900299072265625,
0.08239680528640747,
0.0283298809081316,
-0.1720772385597229,
-0.2833362817764282,
0.5075803399085999,
-0.5186077356338501,
0.3181631565093994,
-0.36662721633911133,
0.3757806718349457,
-0.03370307758450508,
0.3951475918292999,
0.13619108498096466,
-0.08862075954675674,
0.6563529968261719,
-0.46704626083374023,
0.38321980834007263,
0.20283319056034088,
-0.03180763125419617,
1.1522263288497925,
-0.7120531797409058,
0.33595937490463257,
-0.25229382514953613,
0.3855760395526886,
-1.1200828552246094,
-0.10455109924077988,
0.029844097793102264,
-0.2985362708568573,
0.28904685378074646,
0.03375675156712532,
-0.035030629485845566,
-0.49879539012908936,
-0.3170664608478546,
0.3248150050640106,
0.4780716896057129,
-0.3930181562900543,
0.993941605091095,
0.31157058477401733,
-0.05281079560518265,
-0.22548836469650269,
-0.7829349637031555,
0.5307462215423584,
-0.39245301485061646,
-0.5394867658615112,
0.03448110073804855,
0.03830362856388092,
-0.5406724810600281,
-0.16210249066352844,
0.07313564419746399,
0.316442608833313,
0.03857168182730675,
0.4370788335800171,
-0.08140671998262405,
-0.0010525869438424706,
0.36838263273239136,
0.11647945642471313,
-0.21918171644210815,
0.3707258403301239,
-0.0392373651266098,
0.4892669916152954,
-0.3362818658351898,
-0.3886610269546509,
-0.41714751720428467,
0.3229391574859619,
0.655419111251831,
-0.1981911063194275,
0.6350955367088318,
0.29942917823791504,
-0.6409685611724854,
0.08067746460437775,
-1.046330451965332,
-0.26282641291618347,
-0.4133617579936981,
0.05556952580809593,
-0.49054673314094543,
-0.9517268538475037,
0.5016422271728516,
0.03398864343762398,
-0.04268775135278702,
0.057644687592983246,
0.7952952980995178,
-0.08972419798374176,
0.9663866758346558,
0.7007662057876587,
-0.11167477071285248,
0.32933509349823,
0.027598053216934204,
0.6249432563781738,
-0.9840796589851379,
-0.26074302196502686,
-0.1735329031944275,
-0.37257617712020874,
-0.34790724515914917,
-0.12870442867279053,
0.15169930458068848,
-0.06832681596279144,
-0.49183389544487,
-0.1234649196267128,
-0.4604492485523224,
0.17451860010623932,
-0.044552937150001526,
0.36940819025039673,
-0.003856266848742962,
0.02867816761136055,
-0.00801869947463274,
-0.28562819957733154,
-0.4131908118724823,
-0.6945667266845703,
0.8517299890518188,
0.6582435369491577,
1.1499979496002197,
0.24397575855255127,
0.7897149920463562,
0.5177726745605469,
0.922336757183075,
-0.7689965963363647,
0.5727618932723999,
0.24723467230796814,
-0.4884650707244873,
-0.10271162539720535,
-0.061640337109565735,
-0.8170477151870728,
0.2199467122554779,
-0.25374147295951843,
-0.7882127165794373,
0.32716578245162964,
0.08005298674106598,
-0.48338958621025085,
-0.16824503242969513,
-0.8954647183418274,
0.40148577094078064,
-0.42226067185401917,
-0.4497793912887573,
-0.7085561156272888,
-0.22535499930381775,
0.29533830285072327,
-0.4411258399486542,
0.45688021183013916,
-0.3250472843647003,
-0.15008078515529633,
0.5658791661262512,
-0.2509169280529022,
0.9065642356872559,
-0.404934287071228,
-0.4548235535621643,
0.3306848406791687,
0.6379268169403076,
0.3154372274875641,
0.10753878206014633,
-0.13679303228855133,
-0.17620190978050232,
-0.0992269441485405,
-0.31712982058525085,
-0.9239673614501953,
1.1337828636169434,
-0.828385591506958,
-0.9112053513526917,
-0.2554686963558197,
-0.08691757172346115,
-0.3115846514701843,
0.06937279552221298,
-0.26708778738975525,
0.19720937311649323,
-0.3536166548728943,
0.12737303972244263,
0.2666034400463104,
-0.39279407262802124,
0.3893873691558838,
0.9543752074241638,
-0.369415819644928,
-0.7566618919372559,
0.5803531408309937,
-0.049150463193655014,
0.18626584112644196,
0.14412568509578705,
0.4390278458595276,
-0.23850412666797638,
-0.006494312081485987,
0.1586454063653946,
0.2937222421169281,
-0.7415348291397095,
-0.2515684962272644,
-0.5509517192840576,
0.37075328826904297,
-0.2891923785209656,
-0.7356348633766174,
-0.5169563293457031,
-0.31905168294906616,
0.04623936116695404,
-0.5040455460548401,
0.47125348448753357,
0.738959789276123,
-0.18369470536708832,
0.1327446550130844,
-0.6040798425674438,
0.1119382306933403,
0.02822970598936081,
0.40056121349334717,
0.3508436977863312,
-0.6442727446556091,
-0.4419778883457184,
0.0782930850982666,
-0.2615092694759369,
-0.632128894329071,
0.34455129504203796,
0.20796160399913788,
0.4948837161064148,
0.3542475998401642,
0.17043627798557281,
0.7607711553573608,
-0.48427438735961914,
0.8604757785797119,
0.42103034257888794,
-0.9768983125686646,
0.777192234992981,
-0.42326560616493225,
0.033960502594709396,
0.3398936688899994,
0.1927383989095688,
-0.6644046306610107,
-0.34893715381622314,
-0.6830481886863708,
-0.7541430592536926,
0.46145883202552795,
-0.21127915382385254,
0.781200110912323,
-0.39108285307884216,
0.6952236890792847,
-0.45194074511528015,
0.34044530987739563,
-0.6011974215507507,
-0.052661679685115814,
-0.23361316323280334,
-0.09671056270599365,
-0.3786275088787079,
-0.5554989576339722,
-0.4576181471347809,
0.05310218781232834,
0.37825483083724976,
-0.10452442616224289,
0.48593541979789734,
0.4054379463195801,
0.14585059881210327,
-0.5503106713294983,
0.3826909363269806,
0.5361946225166321,
0.6219695210456848,
-0.1751629114151001,
0.345590740442276,
0.3093297481536865,
-0.0303579680621624,
0.39534056186676025,
-0.4518076479434967,
0.48993992805480957,
-0.6333560347557068,
0.36886101961135864,
0.278828889131546,
0.4547516703605652,
-0.5661516785621643,
0.3101755678653717,
-0.09487567096948624,
-0.0017219021683558822,
-0.30629950761795044,
-0.1332809329032898,
0.3191940486431122,
0.31517377495765686,
0.17859964072704315,
-0.4980911612510681,
-0.2590568959712982,
-0.9301798939704895,
0.18107753992080688,
0.30806368589401245,
-0.4477876126766205,
-0.25472599267959595,
0.47964659333229065,
0.14048413932323456,
-0.6583463549613953,
0.7871695160865784,
0.2616954743862152,
-0.3677401840686798,
0.11416812241077423,
0.569549024105072,
0.9554830193519592,
-0.4121711254119873,
0.22219350934028625,
0.3091546893119812,
0.30549612641334534,
0.06421994417905807,
0.405158132314682,
0.0948295071721077,
-0.9063422083854675,
-0.14414489269256592,
-0.5293578505516052,
-0.2584174573421478,
-0.3833995461463928,
-0.9542699456214905,
0.20708847045898438,
-0.900148868560791,
-0.48886844515800476,
-0.3251173496246338,
-0.16250145435333252,
-0.6840497851371765,
0.47235140204429626,
0.2796896696090698,
0.9905382394790649,
-0.7306215167045593,
0.5073468685150146,
0.6961907148361206,
-0.5122158527374268,
-0.8024965524673462,
-0.183019757270813,
-0.02281220816075802,
-1.1341191530227661,
0.6853233575820923,
-0.0014403051463887095,
-0.35847601294517517,
-0.14971107244491577,
-0.3444726765155792,
-0.523251473903656,
1.1233527660369873,
0.33765047788619995,
-0.41331732273101807,
0.20191411674022675,
-0.09862836450338364,
1.1643744707107544,
-0.7757396697998047,
0.4705234467983246,
0.5066366195678711,
0.3440246284008026,
-0.19283568859100342,
-0.8625704050064087,
0.3051428496837616,
-0.15300297737121582,
0.067051462829113,
-0.051067568361759186,
-1.0471950769424438,
0.3822545111179352,
-0.3884696364402771,
0.09901472181081772,
-0.21798250079154968,
0.4553106427192688,
0.3729570508003235,
0.2580609917640686,
0.3377929627895355,
0.575413703918457,
0.63337641954422,
-0.002576409839093685,
1.1665124893188477,
-0.7076428532600403,
0.5498764514923096,
0.8575283288955688,
-0.4594305157661438,
1.165070652961731,
0.6577005982398987,
0.0317414253950119,
0.7588021159172058,
0.592759370803833,
0.25704535841941833,
0.5582805275917053,
0.6022487878799438,
-0.4334108531475067,
-0.448453813791275,
-0.5294503569602966,
-0.21245847642421722,
0.24335606396198273,
0.7093265056610107,
-0.4604261815547943,
-0.26354679465293884,
0.09137928485870361,
0.11002704501152039,
0.26562419533729553,
-0.4654967188835144,
0.335550993680954,
0.6045670509338379,
-0.702346920967102,
0.6805470585823059,
0.1343100666999817,
0.26510900259017944,
-0.49331459403038025,
0.08831874281167984,
-0.2812579870223999,
0.4779498875141144,
-0.27329155802726746,
-0.9362819790840149,
0.13989421725273132,
0.04045594483613968,
0.08574138581752777,
-0.4443342089653015,
0.835317075252533,
-0.20421245694160461,
-0.4716566801071167,
0.5920509099960327,
0.4840424060821533,
0.06694982200860977,
-0.15667372941970825,
-0.5596833229064941,
0.2823173403739929,
-0.33552801609039307,
-0.5543231964111328,
0.33929741382598877,
0.741921067237854,
-0.052919890731573105,
1.0134438276290894,
0.564738929271698,
-0.06821642071008682,
-0.1945132464170456,
0.31256428360939026,
0.8835055828094482,
-0.9131215810775757,
-0.3566013276576996,
-0.9592220783233643,
0.5045947432518005,
0.14600078761577606,
-0.2870352864265442,
0.7670627236366272,
0.09715943038463593,
0.4410048723220825,
-0.05647246167063713,
0.6263110637664795,
-0.03136034309864044,
0.07587563991546631,
-0.366524338722229,
0.18114542961120605,
-0.5366902351379395,
0.27920982241630554,
-0.46370384097099304,
-0.9119052290916443,
-0.43100109696388245,
0.9003446102142334,
-0.6416431665420532,
0.2607347369194031,
0.4991922378540039,
0.7139186859130859,
0.42457181215286255,
-0.02841602824628353,
0.6039188504219055,
0.23627009987831116,
0.819936215877533,
0.81450355052948,
1.2138649225234985,
-0.02960055135190487,
0.030036473646759987,
-0.056094225496053696,
-0.33644428849220276,
-0.16528034210205078,
-1.1180387735366821,
-0.9195650219917297,
-0.07775998115539551,
-0.31993940472602844,
-0.6502100825309753,
0.11028599739074707,
1.3515626192092896,
0.263222873210907,
-0.3406583070755005,
-0.2884787917137146,
0.19675442576408386,
-0.17182408273220062,
-0.051423896104097366,
-0.20567627251148224,
0.24677890539169312,
-0.19466611742973328,
-0.09105916321277618,
0.1592920869588852,
0.6613075733184814,
-0.1966017782688141,
-0.6458085179328918,
-0.20378240942955017,
0.028814256191253662,
0.37090787291526794,
0.9022035002708435,
0.023763662204146385,
-0.777027428150177,
-0.586727499961853,
0.04504915699362755,
-0.07354645431041718,
-0.10011353343725204,
1.08124577999115,
-0.5951687097549438,
0.38802075386047363,
-0.06273549795150757,
0.5151536464691162,
0.1554705947637558,
-0.1515035182237625,
0.6574095487594604,
-0.2796386480331421,
-0.2187591940164566,
0.03218720853328705,
0.40159469842910767,
0.1892474740743637,
-0.7206871509552002,
0.5225495100021362,
0.009714657440781593,
-0.5014331936836243,
-0.7539270520210266,
0.11201537400484085,
-0.8926128149032593,
0.2496630847454071,
1.268109917640686,
-0.3606787621974945,
-0.13036249577999115,
0.12811830639839172,
-0.559306263923645,
-0.24730411171913147,
-0.5066647529602051,
1.196020483970642,
1.0687536001205444,
-0.35287702083587646,
-0.4926336407661438,
-0.18425926566123962,
0.16930736601352692,
0.4424339830875397,
-0.4199969172477722,
0.376479834318161,
0.4545428156852722,
0.49771007895469666,
0.22236108779907227,
0.9870433807373047,
-0.03993137180805206,
0.04319670423865318,
-0.1511283963918686,
0.1132325679063797,
-0.01777017116546631,
-0.06601240485906601,
-0.4890907406806946,
0.0950961634516716,
0.42223745584487915,
0.291183739900589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01365v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01365v2
|
Prompt-prompted Mixture of Experts for Efficient LLM Generation
| 2024-04-01T17:56:06 | 2024-04-05T14:31:21 |
Harry Dong, Beidi Chen, Yuejie Chi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the development of transformer-based large language models (LLMs), they
have been applied to many fields due to their remarkable utility, but this
comes at a considerable computational cost at deployment. Fortunately, some
methods such as pruning or constructing a mixture of experts (MoE) aim at
exploiting sparsity in transformer feedforward (FF) blocks to gain boosts in
speed and reduction in memory requirements. However, these techniques can be
very costly and inflexible in practice, as they often require training or are
restricted to specific types of architectures. To address this, we introduce
GRIFFIN, a novel training-free MoE that selects unique FF experts at the
sequence level for efficient generation across a plethora of LLMs with
different non-ReLU activation functions. This is possible due to a critical
observation that many trained LLMs naturally produce highly structured FF
activation patterns within a sequence, which we call flocking. Despite our
method's simplicity, we show with 50% of the FF parameters, GRIFFIN maintains
the original model's performance with little to no degradation on a variety of
classification and generation tasks, all while improving latency (e.g.
1.25$\times$ speed-up in Llama 2 13B on an NVIDIA L40). Code is available at
https://github.com/hdong920/GRIFFIN.
|
[
-0.5865245461463928,
-0.5492854118347168,
0.14359425008296967,
0.6047042012214661,
-0.1608673632144928,
0.22633357346057892,
-0.09565451741218567,
-0.15082459151744843,
0.2157404124736786,
0.3526518940925598,
-0.5985497832298279,
-0.026552099734544754,
-0.511755108833313,
0.16971977055072784,
-0.38988444209098816,
0.7112754583358765,
0.2462644726037979,
-0.11648651212453842,
-0.13383278250694275,
-0.09879673272371292,
-0.3512934744358063,
-0.20284312963485718,
-0.5883778929710388,
-0.41027772426605225,
0.45230233669281006,
0.40634143352508545,
0.7726629376411438,
0.8795275092124939,
0.15691952407360077,
0.3280397653579712,
-0.22792795300483704,
0.3623141348361969,
-0.6074893474578857,
0.28052839636802673,
0.01369536854326725,
-0.3998395800590515,
-0.3204064965248108,
-0.06045045331120491,
0.4445977807044983,
0.5665111541748047,
-0.21782544255256653,
-0.04769928753376007,
0.11481507867574692,
0.5886671543121338,
-0.5088117122650146,
-0.12596401572227478,
-1.1676695346832275,
0.32305908203125,
-0.23437876999378204,
-0.5005183219909668,
-0.37540873885154724,
-0.11403956264257431,
-0.10974140465259552,
-0.644955039024353,
0.6631889939308167,
0.2974243760108948,
0.5061465501785278,
0.4326098561286926,
-0.31303855776786804,
0.09250333160161972,
-0.22313807904720306,
0.9506742358207703,
-0.5524744391441345,
0.366281121969223,
0.03032390959560871,
0.12161152809858322,
-0.6440242528915405,
-0.6650503277778625,
-0.48124098777770996,
-0.029792575165629387,
0.26550787687301636,
0.24680323898792267,
-0.2167755365371704,
-0.052771709859371185,
0.10807105898857117,
0.4436006247997284,
-0.3785521388053894,
0.29002586007118225,
-0.16534234583377838,
-0.2075137197971344,
0.7104101777076721,
0.23834355175495148,
0.06182148680090904,
0.06861188262701035,
-0.40978601574897766,
0.018252046778798103,
-0.728060781955719,
0.34044694900512695,
0.5433990359306335,
0.21828176081180573,
0.2144981175661087,
0.445901483297348,
-0.06799517571926117,
0.6116539239883423,
0.8709554076194763,
-0.2785671353340149,
0.15984567999839783,
0.06387536972761154,
0.02979859709739685,
-0.2302148938179016,
0.9820210933685303,
0.30317169427871704,
0.12597697973251343,
-0.49851080775260925,
-0.5175366997718811,
-0.2539958655834198,
0.3668845593929291,
-0.826984167098999,
-0.5470353960990906,
0.2892276644706726,
-0.2475801557302475,
-0.5856626629829407,
0.0902002826333046,
-0.7562310695648193,
-0.3990813195705414,
-0.09771253168582916,
-0.17771679162979126,
-0.408369779586792,
-0.47200337052345276,
-0.1596885621547699,
-0.4257732629776001,
0.29375162720680237,
0.191991925239563,
-1.1098815202713013,
-0.08505077660083771,
0.8193345069885254,
0.710107147693634,
-0.4268885850906372,
-0.43955618143081665,
-1.1896216869354248,
0.01347667258232832,
-0.46944016218185425,
1.0143963098526,
-0.7881141901016235,
-0.6822094917297363,
-0.1490718573331833,
-0.17682713270187378,
-0.1450779289007187,
-0.8949543237686157,
0.4159097969532013,
-0.5370684862136841,
-0.1852526068687439,
-0.07347290962934494,
-0.4406018555164337,
-0.12046393007040024,
-0.10166465491056442,
-0.5373170971870422,
1.3552173376083374,
0.2671951353549957,
-0.5073434710502625,
0.6210443377494812,
-0.1523643434047699,
-0.5866408348083496,
0.4760608375072479,
-0.3906746506690979,
-0.44446852803230286,
0.3249826431274414,
0.47370630502700806,
0.876903772354126,
0.039169780910015106,
0.5720567107200623,
-0.27452704310417175,
-0.08558157086372375,
0.18728896975517273,
-0.241594135761261,
0.45962417125701904,
0.22011509537696838,
-0.33177754282951355,
0.2837480306625366,
-1.0497280359268188,
0.053978290408849716,
-0.06327508389949799,
-0.5978695750236511,
0.057054467499256134,
-0.03704692795872688,
-0.18629641830921173,
0.18877120316028595,
0.03846845030784607,
-0.20275093615055084,
0.22609080374240875,
-0.11815808713436127,
0.38947102427482605,
0.8133105039596558,
0.10367213934659958,
0.7016683220863342,
-0.6911407709121704,
0.7236208319664001,
0.27645206451416016,
-0.1864227056503296,
-0.36132553219795227,
-0.7814935445785522,
-0.6630932688713074,
-0.6000500917434692,
0.052715327590703964,
0.5031140446662903,
-0.8960806131362915,
0.7052831053733826,
0.03319505602121353,
-0.6718583106994629,
-0.5847179293632507,
0.5527631044387817,
0.1560715287923813,
0.6022118926048279,
0.3941495716571808,
-0.06359231472015381,
-0.31576862931251526,
-0.7266659736633301,
-0.24484066665172577,
-0.03970196470618248,
-0.18860091269016266,
0.3423846960067749,
0.04756193980574608,
-0.16081172227859497,
1.2460815906524658,
-0.282414048910141,
0.11550440639257431,
-0.4609982669353485,
0.23402109742164612,
0.25258228182792664,
0.4377218186855316,
0.6293782591819763,
-0.5693153738975525,
-0.5102806687355042,
0.015405124053359032,
-0.4277131259441376,
-0.5759986639022827,
-0.5004063844680786,
-0.2968914806842804,
-0.04866689816117287,
0.32268163561820984,
-0.6475110054016113,
0.011800943873822689,
0.42916738986968994,
0.09225795418024063,
0.6043945550918579,
-0.026697546243667603,
-0.2172156572341919,
-0.8390708565711975,
-0.10317569971084595,
0.37543046474456787,
-0.32673153281211853,
-0.8460504412651062,
0.16003674268722534,
0.05082686245441437,
-0.02743270806968212,
-0.5462750196456909,
0.5039123892784119,
-0.547617495059967,
0.22683434188365936,
-0.30982986092567444,
-0.06725061684846878,
-0.1402757614850998,
0.7727100849151611,
0.18984931707382202,
1.185141682624817,
0.8747062087059021,
-0.856755793094635,
0.19400037825107574,
0.3923797905445099,
-0.14267230033874512,
0.2813514173030853,
-0.6314530372619629,
0.23747454583644867,
-0.1316329389810562,
0.05590367689728737,
-0.6829232573509216,
-0.3024163246154785,
0.2822185754776001,
-0.20764198899269104,
0.2667287588119507,
-0.21481524407863617,
-0.14855319261550903,
-0.3440800607204437,
-0.3815612196922302,
0.2949024438858032,
0.8464024066925049,
-0.7805723547935486,
0.7564157843589783,
0.4636067748069763,
-0.30914735794067383,
-0.48643234372138977,
-0.3786922097206116,
0.056397538632154465,
-0.28800782561302185,
-0.9359114766120911,
0.33838969469070435,
-0.006360461004078388,
-0.24260175228118896,
-0.26131877303123474,
-0.08575649559497833,
0.06889433413743973,
0.18253818154335022,
0.13093620538711548,
0.008266353979706764,
-0.25437450408935547,
-0.17294776439666748,
0.3018149733543396,
-0.23276163637638092,
-0.03503842651844025,
-0.20676209032535553,
0.41410738229751587,
-0.01788703352212906,
-0.31351086497306824,
-0.260468453168869,
0.4638610780239105,
0.5221779346466064,
-0.37022408843040466,
0.5025801658630371,
0.6836941242218018,
0.2631019651889801,
-0.7171273827552795,
-0.7174509763717651,
-0.13964153826236725,
-0.5481627583503723,
0.3603525757789612,
-0.3629806637763977,
-0.7917512059211731,
0.6110787987709045,
-0.2974627614021301,
0.41143786907196045,
0.3807497024536133,
0.5763530731201172,
0.16454537212848663,
0.7604413628578186,
0.4347420334815979,
-0.19161273539066315,
0.49679312109947205,
-0.07477275282144547,
0.20008622109889984,
-0.6721361875534058,
-0.3006414771080017,
-0.3170497715473175,
-0.27570629119873047,
-0.2135038822889328,
-0.5838998556137085,
0.3520944118499756,
0.3501577079296112,
-0.03574357181787491,
0.07312095910310745,
-0.6091516017913818,
0.5106021761894226,
0.7296125292778015,
-0.009658940136432648,
0.07488475739955902,
0.17765213549137115,
-0.0844026580452919,
0.2951156497001648,
-1.2167049646377563,
-0.4374043643474579,
0.8524170517921448,
0.20292267203330994,
0.8465930223464966,
-0.2494768500328064,
0.7413040399551392,
0.21983589231967926,
0.2629208564758301,
-0.9547060132026672,
0.8706737160682678,
-0.0011453914921730757,
-0.07147505134344101,
-0.2311672419309616,
-0.4581165611743927,
-0.964677631855011,
0.4064096212387085,
-0.4042586386203766,
-0.3339935839176178,
0.110222227871418,
0.27772265672683716,
-0.6241908073425293,
0.4956156015396118,
-0.3162374198436737,
0.2129771113395691,
-0.133452370762825,
-0.5164793729782104,
-0.035599853843450546,
-0.4300640821456909,
0.35508155822753906,
-0.4529515504837036,
-0.13003063201904297,
-0.10011892020702362,
-0.1102500632405281,
0.6516494154930115,
-0.631213366985321,
0.7314755320549011,
-0.25864940881729126,
-0.1874924749135971,
0.6530108451843262,
0.04026896134018898,
0.8009964823722839,
-0.015424728393554688,
-0.18845538794994354,
0.10959897190332413,
-0.710361897945404,
-0.267669677734375,
-0.4528648853302002,
0.4631882607936859,
-0.8522946834564209,
-0.9219607710838318,
0.06308696419000626,
-0.603363037109375,
-0.2589097023010254,
-0.08146284520626068,
0.36846116185188293,
0.5840848684310913,
0.17421631515026093,
0.23833565413951874,
0.666407585144043,
-0.10658545792102814,
0.5375560522079468,
0.25440922379493713,
-0.06558232754468918,
-0.5861596465110779,
1.0154995918273926,
-0.039593640714883804,
-0.1260703206062317,
0.13316670060157776,
0.21236202120780945,
-0.15392997860908508,
-0.8177979588508606,
-0.5868523120880127,
0.02097354270517826,
-0.30405014753341675,
-0.2921919822692871,
-0.8476216197013855,
-0.17599253356456757,
-0.19539645314216614,
-0.422359824180603,
-0.24900802969932556,
-0.43988296389579773,
-0.6389464735984802,
-0.1243525817990303,
0.385415256023407,
0.6469837427139282,
0.10355629026889801,
0.6660782098770142,
-1.1977397203445435,
0.2982088327407837,
0.492545485496521,
0.06631181389093399,
0.25361329317092896,
-0.5737019181251526,
-0.11478807777166367,
-0.16253475844860077,
-0.8053845763206482,
-0.7135291695594788,
0.462446391582489,
0.3953559994697571,
1.0660293102264404,
0.7039145231246948,
0.09228552132844925,
0.8344674706459045,
-0.6260813474655151,
0.8763418793678284,
0.3282042145729065,
-0.8051794171333313,
0.11281026154756546,
-0.5544634461402893,
-0.008334510959684849,
0.3277079164981842,
0.13883237540721893,
-0.21503962576389313,
-0.8505482077598572,
-0.5358445048332214,
-0.956571638584137,
0.5783841013908386,
0.11026734858751297,
0.10011614859104156,
-0.1089516207575798,
0.25897035002708435,
0.6551206707954407,
0.236617311835289,
-0.35802778601646423,
-0.14476947486400604,
-0.3369605839252472,
-0.07527230679988861,
0.1760888546705246,
-0.23307156562805176,
-0.08329195529222488,
-0.1808060109615326,
0.8474667072296143,
-0.2621670067310333,
0.12379279732704163,
0.059815891087055206,
-0.10387175530195236,
-0.28594544529914856,
0.1222425103187561,
0.4831414818763733,
0.4517134726047516,
0.2693633735179901,
-0.07521206885576248,
0.22304318845272064,
-0.29909414052963257,
0.21310102939605713,
-0.13370417058467865,
-0.14224840700626373,
0.04989917203783989,
0.33123862743377686,
0.8258750438690186,
0.33487680554389954,
-0.424451619386673,
0.5198026299476624,
0.29204657673835754,
-0.48823243379592896,
-0.17360727488994598,
0.5788769721984863,
-0.1161186695098877,
0.44795477390289307,
0.797590970993042,
0.5087445974349976,
-0.2431972771883011,
0.027469532564282417,
0.41143998503685,
0.48937785625457764,
0.17154693603515625,
-0.3209778666496277,
0.8040811419487,
0.6929413676261902,
-0.4344189465045929,
0.6465864777565002,
-0.3311781883239746,
-0.46670806407928467,
0.5868504643440247,
0.4395674765110016,
1.0937920808792114,
-0.09519548714160919,
0.12559790909290314,
0.10097122192382812,
-0.09783599525690079,
-0.39208194613456726,
0.05865746736526489,
-0.19395676255226135,
-0.8508955240249634,
-0.4058998227119446,
-0.45897409319877625,
-0.4469837546348572,
0.05285230651497841,
-0.538989782333374,
0.2573213577270508,
-0.38038116693496704,
-0.3110600411891937,
-0.34596359729766846,
-0.33603590726852417,
-0.4722931981086731,
-0.2582401931285858,
0.1771598756313324,
1.1905728578567505,
-0.6749639511108398,
0.5565985441207886,
0.7485765814781189,
0.2591606080532074,
-0.8403024077415466,
0.16389665007591248,
-0.24445396661758423,
-0.8862801194190979,
0.5027227401733398,
0.21445785462856293,
-0.20332074165344238,
0.10139298439025879,
-0.6531619429588318,
-0.36201852560043335,
1.0220692157745361,
0.20177441835403442,
-0.830041766166687,
0.11848681420087814,
0.007739691529422998,
0.22080421447753906,
-0.43003347516059875,
0.3320167064666748,
0.3663589060306549,
0.4204516112804413,
0.4038810133934021,
-0.5542988181114197,
-0.09136801958084106,
-0.5246223211288452,
-0.11386121064424515,
0.05086904391646385,
-1.0221407413482666,
0.8357136249542236,
-0.2982728183269501,
-0.17122815549373627,
0.14480994641780853,
1.1541593074798584,
0.6848849654197693,
0.24576881527900696,
0.6294503808021545,
0.42876124382019043,
1.1598860025405884,
0.09514988213777542,
0.6960316300392151,
-0.9002038836479187,
-0.06270920485258102,
0.5767817497253418,
-0.24184785783290863,
0.4883532226085663,
0.5369945168495178,
-0.14732280373573303,
0.2419259399175644,
0.5706658959388733,
-0.3384326696395874,
0.48890212178230286,
0.16723836958408356,
-0.3492874205112457,
-0.7383584976196289,
0.15338735282421112,
-0.3293529152870178,
0.12801554799079895,
0.057655155658721924,
-0.1387903243303299,
-0.15468859672546387,
-0.17273283004760742,
-0.042522214353084564,
-0.12309092283248901,
-0.5709675550460815,
0.7022169828414917,
0.127683624625206,
-0.9743759036064148,
0.5651867389678955,
-0.15984372794628143,
1.0194250345230103,
-0.5885722637176514,
0.15978635847568512,
-0.41882047057151794,
-0.0773526281118393,
-0.4016415774822235,
-0.7984068989753723,
-0.07953231781721115,
0.06061660125851631,
-0.12069045007228851,
-0.3612651526927948,
0.6455703973770142,
-0.5348444581031799,
-0.5483565926551819,
-0.12740133702754974,
0.7738617658615112,
0.13268893957138062,
-0.02990741655230522,
-0.3439432382583618,
-0.3141826391220093,
0.06281696259975433,
-0.4659339487552643,
0.3401901125907898,
0.5542354583740234,
0.05125119164586067,
1.0458871126174927,
0.7200025320053101,
0.1766722947359085,
0.5648724436759949,
-0.020127156749367714,
1.180065631866455,
-0.5252315998077393,
-0.6046608090400696,
-0.7959826588630676,
0.593592643737793,
0.11900912970304489,
-0.3428490459918976,
0.8384044170379639,
0.5120382905006409,
0.5170997381210327,
-0.3608270585536957,
0.9832703471183777,
0.2603227198123932,
0.08735864609479904,
-0.4865427613258362,
0.520656406879425,
-0.42929840087890625,
0.11642365902662277,
-0.03262804076075554,
-0.8365817666053772,
-0.10831652581691742,
0.43138182163238525,
-0.09066695719957352,
-0.05084961652755737,
0.3423592746257782,
0.9812829494476318,
-0.04498850181698799,
0.20493154227733612,
0.359427273273468,
-0.045621857047080994,
0.463400274515152,
0.42525672912597656,
1.1673223972320557,
0.22231709957122803,
0.5846895575523376,
-0.15722011029720306,
-0.25811314582824707,
-0.228621706366539,
-0.9090901613235474,
-1.1724863052368164,
-0.24926406145095825,
-0.38294750452041626,
0.07191544026136398,
-0.3414209187030792,
1.2685120105743408,
0.7290395498275757,
-0.629768967628479,
-0.008276631124317646,
-0.23851189017295837,
-0.07338526099920273,
-0.36131763458251953,
-0.2300001084804535,
-0.034933388233184814,
-0.715110182762146,
-0.676314115524292,
0.7285280823707581,
0.2442159503698349,
0.07757807523012161,
-0.1459362804889679,
-0.2161177545785904,
0.5304405093193054,
0.06601469963788986,
0.40105101466178894,
0.22545486688613892,
-0.5886623859405518,
0.050278324633836746,
-0.006967914756387472,
0.15210789442062378,
0.34739571809768677,
1.02940833568573,
-0.9173917770385742,
-0.0690736472606659,
0.6386805176734924,
0.790303647518158,
0.08168285340070724,
0.424086332321167,
0.6430255770683289,
-0.7115352153778076,
0.19501864910125732,
0.18810348212718964,
0.5177394151687622,
0.18569456040859222,
-0.48629286885261536,
0.2914823293685913,
0.4385914206504822,
-0.6973326206207275,
-0.662336528301239,
0.11302219331264496,
-1.0257635116577148,
0.044385120272636414,
1.3463224172592163,
-0.07436654716730118,
-0.3027938902378082,
-0.20637470483779907,
-0.3389870226383209,
0.03734566271305084,
-0.906719446182251,
0.7519862651824951,
0.3618902266025543,
-0.212434783577919,
-0.2025621384382248,
-0.0492432676255703,
0.31504741311073303,
0.36058834195137024,
-0.3154107630252838,
-0.01585172861814499,
0.25125300884246826,
0.20880991220474243,
-0.028965946286916733,
0.4170837700366974,
0.34993669390678406,
0.03589998930692673,
0.15848632156848907,
-0.02915380708873272,
-0.7267346382141113,
-0.4638863205909729,
-0.1555749922990799,
0.546435534954071,
-0.016911547631025314,
-0.02200905792415142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01273v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01273v2
|
TWIN-GPT: Digital Twins for Clinical Trials via Large Language Model
| 2024-04-01T17:48:55 | 2024-06-29T01:28:02 |
Yue Wang, Tianfan Fu, Yinlong Xu, Zihan Ma, Hongxia Xu, Yingzhou Lu, Bang Du, Honghao Gao, Jian Wu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ME
|
Clinical trials are indispensable for medical research and the development of
new treatments. However, clinical trials often involve thousands of
participants and can span several years to complete, with a high probability of
failure during the process. Recently, there has been a burgeoning interest in
virtual clinical trials, which simulate real-world scenarios and hold the
potential to significantly enhance patient safety, expedite development, reduce
costs, and contribute to the broader scientific knowledge in healthcare.
Existing research often focuses on leveraging electronic health records (EHRs)
to support clinical trial outcome prediction. Yet, trained with limited
clinical trial outcome data, existing approaches frequently struggle to perform
accurate predictions. Some research has attempted to generate EHRs to augment
model development but has fallen short in personalizing the generation for
individual patient profiles. Recently, the emergence of large language models
has illuminated new possibilities, as their embedded comprehensive clinical
knowledge has proven beneficial in addressing medical issues. In this paper, we
propose a large language model-based digital twin creation approach, called
TWIN-GPT. TWIN-GPT can establish cross-dataset associations of medical
information given limited data, generating unique personalized digital twins
for different patients, thereby preserving individual patient characteristics.
Comprehensive experiments show that using digital twins created by TWIN-GPT can
boost the clinical trial outcome prediction, exceeding various previous
prediction approaches.
|
[
-0.2518092095851898,
-0.911841630935669,
0.9349064230918884,
-0.0593024305999279,
-0.23871374130249023,
0.10953901708126068,
-0.06685861945152283,
-0.5964124202728271,
0.48399195075035095,
0.5042256116867065,
-0.28060638904571533,
-0.43387100100517273,
-0.5759900808334351,
-0.061299800872802734,
-0.33369016647338867,
1.2931643724441528,
-0.23730124533176422,
0.6364918947219849,
-0.2081783413887024,
0.06453701108694077,
-0.5644755363464355,
-0.9865676164627075,
-0.7976168394088745,
-0.3132442533969879,
0.6203162670135498,
0.17230230569839478,
0.5923133492469788,
0.5333698987960815,
0.750456690788269,
0.17811428010463715,
0.18570572137832642,
-0.2170446366071701,
-0.37661248445510864,
0.02159644104540348,
0.12580688297748566,
-0.41301465034484863,
-0.5739297866821289,
-0.2957855463027954,
0.6175737380981445,
0.7010374069213867,
-0.2084680199623108,
-0.1097649410367012,
-0.20304681360721588,
0.6575717926025391,
-0.01443987712264061,
0.22784021496772766,
-0.46864208579063416,
0.04804547503590584,
-0.0008434139890596271,
0.017969565466046333,
0.113411083817482,
-0.606536328792572,
0.3872309625148773,
-0.4521996080875397,
0.6464454531669617,
-0.10889723896980286,
0.5121456384658813,
-0.10269279778003693,
-0.5262113213539124,
-0.27023571729660034,
-1.1023074388504028,
0.523080050945282,
-0.6716899871826172,
-0.0062623959966003895,
0.22708991169929504,
0.6061347723007202,
-0.10317362844944,
-0.8923426866531372,
-0.7350738644599915,
-0.3723868131637573,
-0.09043827652931213,
0.11245306581258774,
0.2241535484790802,
0.1985533982515335,
0.26071038842201233,
0.32307183742523193,
-0.6484705805778503,
-0.024644842371344566,
-0.3950081467628479,
0.10383502393960953,
0.8032901287078857,
0.5865329504013062,
0.5125076770782471,
0.04392346367239952,
-0.19898463785648346,
-0.023037659004330635,
-0.5584847927093506,
-0.15226809680461884,
0.15915392339229584,
0.48401227593421936,
-0.32455533742904663,
0.6266469359397888,
-0.10803478211164474,
-0.005809623282402754,
0.2052985429763794,
0.015032847411930561,
0.32055139541625977,
-0.48185455799102783,
-0.0006540980539284647,
0.3239991068840027,
0.8013785481452942,
0.4110815227031708,
0.19593656063079834,
-0.23194223642349243,
-0.12168475985527039,
0.39194801449775696,
0.46856942772865295,
-0.9675068259239197,
-0.2684369385242462,
0.7272327542304993,
-0.6787353157997131,
-0.4127248525619507,
0.039076514542102814,
-0.8386836647987366,
-0.4833754897117615,
-0.46936097741127014,
0.7712543606758118,
-0.31381019949913025,
-0.6344205737113953,
0.4321506917476654,
-0.10183871537446976,
-0.0694495141506195,
0.12264502048492432,
-0.844031572341919,
0.39939188957214355,
0.8680172562599182,
0.8642536401748657,
-0.2377471923828125,
-0.3322669267654419,
-0.5428778529167175,
0.20012858510017395,
-0.06936522573232651,
0.6452200412750244,
-0.42099249362945557,
-0.6377436518669128,
0.15650469064712524,
-0.08611132204532623,
-0.031038641929626465,
-0.20551797747612,
0.48616960644721985,
-0.32785671949386597,
0.37728258967399597,
-0.3902723789215088,
-0.6262621283531189,
0.102540984749794,
0.15863418579101562,
-0.7539805173873901,
0.34921449422836304,
-0.11113790422677994,
-0.9401728510856628,
0.39122289419174194,
-0.6590781211853027,
-0.6309659481048584,
0.49166977405548096,
-0.606597363948822,
-1.0415854454040527,
0.4012487828731537,
0.24746710062026978,
0.3286932706832886,
-0.37764185667037964,
0.41454586386680603,
-0.5870850086212158,
-0.310598224401474,
-0.011404610238969326,
-0.05681730806827545,
0.30917125940322876,
-0.22995726764202118,
-0.4730777144432068,
-0.06687857955694199,
-0.4995352327823639,
-0.024414697661995888,
0.5179007053375244,
-0.16964924335479736,
-0.41034331917762756,
-0.0809554010629654,
0.445173054933548,
0.10232950747013092,
0.06313398480415344,
-0.9353054761886597,
0.39977359771728516,
-0.2641054391860962,
0.27103134989738464,
0.4282572865486145,
0.07579868286848068,
-0.07367008179426193,
-0.7014467120170593,
0.5222363471984863,
0.08460316061973572,
0.43968474864959717,
-0.05248820409178734,
-0.7336008548736572,
-0.45218488574028015,
-0.10356771945953369,
0.5375446081161499,
0.4577986001968384,
-0.7780799865722656,
0.2322787642478943,
-0.7721928358078003,
-0.3149862289428711,
-0.5511471033096313,
-0.3559581935405731,
0.43323707580566406,
0.20882676541805267,
0.21455660462379456,
-0.4753480553627014,
-0.3496461808681488,
-1.0626882314682007,
-0.15111222863197327,
-0.17246760427951813,
-0.034655407071113586,
0.32708749175071716,
0.656403124332428,
-0.3146582245826721,
0.6761022806167603,
-0.6201142072677612,
-0.590811014175415,
-0.26806342601776123,
0.17026469111442566,
0.20152966678142548,
0.4935174584388733,
0.38061317801475525,
-1.167898178100586,
-0.6408059597015381,
0.0774209201335907,
-0.6720781922340393,
0.13759900629520416,
-0.25202763080596924,
0.10879631340503693,
-0.06052064895629883,
0.12304035574197769,
-0.5627999305725098,
0.5023795962333679,
0.6275005340576172,
-0.2787390351295471,
0.5871804356575012,
-0.8438155651092529,
0.32739773392677307,
-1.2992085218429565,
0.16654852032661438,
-0.17607863247394562,
-0.13446557521820068,
-0.8091801404953003,
-0.2749685049057007,
0.17904095351696014,
-0.0036349082365632057,
-0.05040808022022247,
0.6065703630447388,
-0.3177255392074585,
0.13054119050502777,
-0.2156943529844284,
-0.4392835199832916,
-0.24995528161525726,
0.15719540417194366,
0.29707080125808716,
0.5090348720550537,
0.4454360008239746,
-0.04653926566243172,
0.3292770981788635,
0.3846018612384796,
-0.10039843618869781,
0.7002248764038086,
-1.016965627670288,
0.33964329957962036,
-0.2601896822452545,
0.3889647424221039,
-0.6051821708679199,
-0.3649022579193115,
-0.22739648818969727,
-0.4707488417625427,
0.31054988503456116,
-0.30904096364974976,
-0.7752538323402405,
-0.7675721645355225,
-0.3203599154949188,
0.4963628053665161,
0.6076855659484863,
-0.3575670123100281,
0.6126511096954346,
0.5451993942260742,
-0.5977832674980164,
-0.07824518531560898,
-0.7738351821899414,
0.32663166522979736,
-0.17074592411518097,
-0.6819512248039246,
0.36659130454063416,
-0.1546085625886917,
-0.014073219150304794,
0.05977872386574745,
0.3773972988128662,
-0.02614058367908001,
-0.4732694625854492,
0.6121809482574463,
0.4099379777908325,
-0.34307852387428284,
0.4493327736854553,
0.11599154025316238,
-0.25628530979156494,
0.04143356531858444,
-0.40063679218292236,
0.43040984869003296,
0.001234673778526485,
-0.646216869354248,
-0.6169334650039673,
1.1615090370178223,
0.7278063893318176,
-0.1176365464925766,
0.9790503978729248,
0.42032143473625183,
-0.7495216727256775,
0.09001775830984116,
-1.0708036422729492,
-0.18264147639274597,
-0.4309557378292084,
0.32695701718330383,
-0.3519202768802643,
-0.7390934824943542,
0.3421558737754822,
0.12298211455345154,
0.09952187538146973,
0.13979695737361908,
0.9404029846191406,
-0.01283402182161808,
1.409257411956787,
0.4383605420589447,
0.07291815429925919,
0.33373740315437317,
-0.11496121436357498,
0.30387556552886963,
-0.6230614185333252,
-0.19178447127342224,
-0.17433114349842072,
-0.24604780972003937,
-0.5926836133003235,
-0.3305785655975342,
0.9702540636062622,
-0.3258073329925537,
-0.2643314599990845,
-0.0007468064432032406,
-0.5282248258590698,
0.4259127974510193,
0.7359230518341064,
0.45944324135780334,
0.5557789206504822,
0.17049171030521393,
-0.27988606691360474,
-0.1453200727701187,
-0.31348490715026855,
-0.4332837164402008,
1.7358430624008179,
0.11085029691457748,
0.3366137444972992,
-0.010042439214885235,
0.8709509372711182,
0.23575417697429657,
0.3380003571510315,
-0.294148325920105,
0.013060986064374447,
-0.33384454250335693,
-0.7361581325531006,
0.006752084009349346,
-0.49580246210098267,
-1.034546971321106,
-0.09587661176919937,
-0.41739004850387573,
-0.37622344493865967,
-0.1802382916212082,
0.23756787180900574,
-0.7293174266815186,
0.498226523399353,
-0.7685515880584717,
0.6606254577636719,
-0.5585272312164307,
-0.24293440580368042,
-0.28325432538986206,
-0.6341801881790161,
0.1421341598033905,
-0.6029180288314819,
0.14833539724349976,
0.2532898485660553,
0.0502539686858654,
0.45222485065460205,
-0.4162503480911255,
0.6240274310112,
-0.06932187080383301,
0.29156792163848877,
-0.16770295798778534,
0.011165713891386986,
0.7235519289970398,
0.19257783889770508,
0.1614643931388855,
0.37337082624435425,
0.3531990051269531,
-0.45364129543304443,
-0.38824570178985596,
0.9670839309692383,
-0.6269064545631409,
-0.4690561890602112,
-0.42274099588394165,
-0.6161321401596069,
-0.31818854808807373,
0.2453915774822235,
0.07497259974479675,
0.4145876467227936,
-0.3475576341152191,
-0.18497440218925476,
0.2879062592983246,
-0.47158104181289673,
0.02754278853535652,
0.521605372428894,
-0.15503427386283875,
-0.6946507096290588,
0.7153281569480896,
-0.004978524520993233,
0.359250545501709,
0.26061058044433594,
0.5497286915779114,
-0.22879160940647125,
-0.9937632083892822,
-0.27593526244163513,
0.6151314973831177,
-0.13380032777786255,
0.21180811524391174,
-0.9737029671669006,
-0.1817801594734192,
-0.5761258006095886,
-0.12237933278083801,
-0.28592026233673096,
-0.2509464919567108,
0.17505669593811035,
0.1373874545097351,
0.25480449199676514,
1.0424165725708008,
-0.04396428167819977,
0.29345548152923584,
-1.0740786790847778,
0.7575006484985352,
0.5245944261550903,
0.44066381454467773,
-0.14324335753917694,
0.013414427638053894,
-0.04227251932024956,
0.33019378781318665,
-0.1754366010427475,
-0.6223968267440796,
0.3973163068294525,
-0.20005720853805542,
0.37027835845947266,
0.0701427161693573,
-0.16871070861816406,
0.6025813221931458,
-0.7668616771697998,
0.6640866994857788,
0.5174097418785095,
-0.5177310705184937,
0.5396902561187744,
-0.6452968120574951,
0.0018679590430110693,
0.5108045339584351,
0.2853949964046478,
-0.684312105178833,
0.19663499295711517,
-0.805492639541626,
-0.5911424160003662,
0.5616903901100159,
0.31413209438323975,
0.05206526815891266,
0.38338834047317505,
0.49393123388290405,
0.4027847349643707,
0.26325201988220215,
-0.3528066873550415,
-0.09927709400653839,
0.2165777087211609,
-0.4259725511074066,
-0.2200881987810135,
-0.12626296281814575,
-0.1272181272506714,
-0.1878943294286728,
0.5332901477813721,
-0.05702109634876251,
0.333210289478302,
0.2477145791053772,
0.34366583824157715,
-0.20768822729587555,
-0.008824865333735943,
0.3310534954071045,
0.3207654654979706,
-0.1949193775653839,
-0.1363971084356308,
0.063393734395504,
-0.8290404081344604,
-0.09249088913202286,
0.27184662222862244,
-0.25428780913352966,
-0.08829962462186813,
0.12167399376630783,
0.6061902642250061,
-0.17484435439109802,
-0.5411909818649292,
0.8124558925628662,
-0.5221931338310242,
-0.22464680671691895,
-0.6661302447319031,
-0.4001666307449341,
0.32110655307769775,
0.35066893696784973,
0.08784855902194977,
-0.3217664957046509,
0.05053478851914406,
-0.40216079354286194,
0.33270326256752014,
0.5687440037727356,
-0.21901842951774597,
-0.4140813946723938,
0.925304651260376,
0.31480225920677185,
-0.41958388686180115,
0.5261532664299011,
0.047506123781204224,
-0.5712307691574097,
0.8061709403991699,
0.48795807361602783,
1.0229439735412598,
-0.0854695662856102,
0.05900761857628822,
0.39258742332458496,
0.11439730226993561,
-0.4908050298690796,
0.3377719819545746,
0.3796948492527008,
-0.3521668314933777,
-0.04582787677645683,
-0.5888669490814209,
-0.4474292993545532,
0.30284583568573,
-0.4259825348854065,
0.5971516370773315,
-0.30796968936920166,
-0.41349923610687256,
0.15510176122188568,
0.20406484603881836,
-0.9112957715988159,
-0.007681162096560001,
0.5755548477172852,
0.3806355893611908,
-0.8020887970924377,
1.026067852973938,
0.5706868767738342,
-0.3272753357887268,
-0.48420190811157227,
0.007570954505354166,
0.16313202679157257,
-0.6891396045684814,
0.3740130662918091,
0.14400799572467804,
0.3134664297103882,
-0.1668141633272171,
-0.0264427587389946,
-0.613410472869873,
1.0642659664154053,
0.24229489266872406,
-0.878105878829956,
-0.6107121109962463,
0.7298548221588135,
0.834498941898346,
-0.4904800057411194,
0.3200755715370178,
0.49269601702690125,
0.29597336053848267,
0.23111391067504883,
-1.306192398071289,
-0.0398101881146431,
-0.12331744283437729,
0.12341034412384033,
0.36843141913414,
-0.42896202206611633,
0.8895331621170044,
-0.6632673740386963,
-0.327689528465271,
0.2514999806880951,
0.05992807447910309,
0.13938024640083313,
0.509651780128479,
0.4053269028663635,
0.5462953448295593,
0.4437882602214813,
-0.009663853794336319,
1.383065104484558,
-0.3197701871395111,
0.523341953754425,
1.157902479171753,
-0.37821996212005615,
0.6865880489349365,
0.40567857027053833,
-0.3225826621055603,
0.10809415578842163,
0.18992823362350464,
0.016846949234604836,
0.39110469818115234,
0.18758030235767365,
-0.48169052600860596,
-0.3695853054523468,
-0.06616423279047012,
-0.736540675163269,
-0.04248068481683731,
0.36594951152801514,
-0.592595636844635,
0.03565387427806854,
0.13680191338062286,
0.013253195211291313,
-0.07879525423049927,
-0.00995844416320324,
0.7346873879432678,
0.19059458374977112,
-0.5300419926643372,
0.28717029094696045,
-0.34818771481513977,
0.6053750514984131,
-0.6905450820922852,
-0.19586119055747986,
-0.02342664822936058,
0.6107672452926636,
-0.05858789384365082,
-0.6018441915512085,
0.0914950892329216,
-0.10847393423318863,
-0.09389906376600266,
0.0481644906103611,
0.2988118827342987,
-0.5366619825363159,
-1.0938236713409424,
0.31095966696739197,
0.498627245426178,
-0.022592686116695404,
-0.3154878616333008,
-0.6920425891876221,
-0.0029010730795562267,
-0.21867579221725464,
0.06546591222286224,
0.3540867567062378,
0.2940598130226135,
0.018608340993523598,
0.3732396364212036,
0.8059196472167969,
0.8459314703941345,
0.013122878037393093,
0.12494508177042007,
0.7547683715820312,
-0.6964837312698364,
-0.5483343601226807,
-0.6787565350532532,
0.15513524413108826,
-0.22342607378959656,
-0.25771117210388184,
0.30230632424354553,
0.689095139503479,
0.4709189832210541,
-0.0067300330847501755,
1.313417673110962,
0.10531428456306458,
0.8355681300163269,
-0.2235243022441864,
0.7969492077827454,
-0.5184383392333984,
-0.03456754982471466,
-0.16321390867233276,
-0.52187579870224,
-0.5070512294769287,
-0.09147865325212479,
-0.4381524622440338,
0.083929143846035,
0.7600977420806885,
0.709535539150238,
-0.16757594048976898,
0.25554439425468445,
0.34699547290802,
0.31616368889808655,
0.7807590365409851,
1.1988030672073364,
0.49892234802246094,
-0.6182159781455994,
0.337644100189209,
-0.4287174940109253,
-0.4515290856361389,
-0.26595330238342285,
-0.655996561050415,
-1.0911123752593994,
-0.6173112392425537,
-0.23130446672439575,
-0.32794052362442017,
0.2612474858760834,
1.1624436378479004,
0.6411699652671814,
-0.9395775198936462,
0.09912758320569992,
0.06074728071689606,
-0.4871123731136322,
-0.12971901893615723,
-0.08046026527881622,
0.753345251083374,
0.17171239852905273,
-0.7583603858947754,
-0.23932211101055145,
0.1666257381439209,
0.3210143744945526,
-0.14357738196849823,
0.09420247375965118,
0.21159107983112335,
-0.10184066742658615,
0.2245815545320511,
0.2083103209733963,
-0.5512611865997314,
-0.23696285486221313,
-0.2971959114074707,
-0.21154120564460754,
0.07349999994039536,
1.204606533050537,
-0.8852725028991699,
0.8736410737037659,
0.40523624420166016,
0.7252418994903564,
0.6839253902435303,
-0.03982130065560341,
0.855521559715271,
0.13195912539958954,
-0.13834887742996216,
0.4276691973209381,
0.3540631830692291,
0.30843386054039,
-0.57509845495224,
0.29718220233917236,
0.2992572784423828,
-0.6466102600097656,
-0.7632086277008057,
0.04849928617477417,
-0.9369632005691528,
0.049990296363830566,
1.3048063516616821,
0.0820145308971405,
0.20847781002521515,
-0.35392606258392334,
-0.2603672742843628,
0.2900492548942566,
-0.19479385018348694,
1.3564062118530273,
0.4141187071800232,
-0.1291545033454895,
0.45499467849731445,
-0.8467411994934082,
0.37682974338531494,
0.371742308139801,
-1.0241799354553223,
0.14221586287021637,
0.2935752868652344,
0.3578069508075714,
-0.054847002029418945,
0.5908548831939697,
-0.3998267948627472,
0.29182684421539307,
0.027441486716270447,
0.11390344053506851,
-0.12798526883125305,
-0.06688925623893738,
-0.40252721309661865,
0.12010398507118225,
-0.3780607283115387,
-0.22967086732387543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01268v1
|
Mapping the Increasing Use of LLMs in Scientific Papers
| 2024-04-01T17:45:15 | 2024-04-01T17:45:15 |
Weixin Liang, Yaohui Zhang, Zhengxuan Wu, Haley Lepp, Wenlong Ji, Xuandong Zhao, Hancheng Cao, Sheng Liu, Siyu He, Zhi Huang, Diyi Yang, Christopher Potts, Christopher D Manning, James Y. Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Scientific publishing lays the foundation of science by disseminating
research findings, fostering collaboration, encouraging reproducibility, and
ensuring that scientific knowledge is accessible, verifiable, and built upon
over time. Recently, there has been immense speculation about how many people
are using large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT in their academic writing,
and to what extent this tool might have an effect on global scientific
practices. However, we lack a precise measure of the proportion of academic
writing substantially modified or produced by LLMs. To address this gap, we
conduct the first systematic, large-scale analysis across 950,965 papers
published between January 2020 and February 2024 on the arXiv, bioRxiv, and
Nature portfolio journals, using a population-level statistical framework to
measure the prevalence of LLM-modified content over time. Our statistical
estimation operates on the corpus level and is more robust than inference on
individual instances. Our findings reveal a steady increase in LLM usage, with
the largest and fastest growth observed in Computer Science papers (up to
17.5%). In comparison, Mathematics papers and the Nature portfolio showed the
least LLM modification (up to 6.3%). Moreover, at an aggregate level, our
analysis reveals that higher levels of LLM-modification are associated with
papers whose first authors post preprints more frequently, papers in more
crowded research areas, and papers of shorter lengths. Our findings suggests
that LLMs are being broadly used in scientific writings.
|
[
-0.147086039185524,
-0.45733335614204407,
0.6394639611244202,
0.48098573088645935,
-0.23090055584907532,
0.30902281403541565,
-0.20419783890247345,
-0.7024635672569275,
0.31047192215919495,
0.3940792679786682,
-0.04709119722247124,
-0.6934446692466736,
-0.9889340400695801,
0.4361456632614136,
-0.4824192225933075,
1.0084365606307983,
-0.1380968689918518,
0.07256026566028595,
-0.4898362457752228,
0.10293243080377579,
0.14573688805103302,
-0.6511172652244568,
-0.29927384853363037,
-0.2949710488319397,
0.9486859440803528,
-0.08184479176998138,
0.3378031849861145,
0.7285352945327759,
0.9383977651596069,
0.26763737201690674,
-0.5023378133773804,
0.011261150240898132,
-0.5811030268669128,
0.009044171310961246,
0.06810740381479263,
-0.643366813659668,
-0.5763294100761414,
-0.013385770842432976,
1.141113042831421,
0.981880247592926,
0.07964570820331573,
0.14866140484809875,
0.2823463976383209,
0.6905028820037842,
-0.36276140809059143,
0.1895189881324768,
-0.5822426676750183,
0.01718025468289852,
-0.5178973078727722,
-0.4198519289493561,
-0.3276260793209076,
-0.43613550066947937,
0.0646042451262474,
-0.610816240310669,
0.13926135003566742,
0.07236045598983765,
0.3695187270641327,
-0.12076964229345322,
-0.34966009855270386,
-0.4066058397293091,
-0.3821026682853699,
0.8437894582748413,
-0.6439487934112549,
0.3530427813529968,
0.08755001425743103,
-0.29643651843070984,
-0.7056540846824646,
-0.891951858997345,
-0.36088958382606506,
-0.4183584749698639,
-0.010855701752007008,
0.0242609940469265,
-0.2283380925655365,
0.019681589677929878,
0.35190048813819885,
0.1716030240058899,
-0.4813753068447113,
-0.029938524588942528,
-0.5592859387397766,
-0.03740676864981651,
0.5711468458175659,
0.2016083151102066,
0.41310691833496094,
0.2824559211730957,
-0.135671466588974,
-0.05900045856833458,
-1.030227541923523,
-0.04712049663066864,
0.12488961219787598,
0.10531484335660934,
0.17828814685344696,
0.93699711561203,
0.41698509454727173,
0.6387190222740173,
-0.4872121810913086,
-0.16953618824481964,
-0.045661211013793945,
-0.6702491044998169,
-0.11982082575559616,
0.026342319324612617,
0.9553924202919006,
0.4973646402359009,
0.10215792804956436,
0.14548955857753754,
0.12221521139144897,
-0.07583736628293991,
0.009298164397478104,
-0.8442779183387756,
-0.06926493346691132,
-0.259986937046051,
-0.2512000799179077,
-0.19988438487052917,
0.016558142378926277,
-0.6117692589759827,
-0.7667900323867798,
-0.08281610906124115,
-0.24786007404327393,
-0.101871058344841,
-0.022582029923796654,
0.2024916112422943,
0.04306996986269951,
-0.03957308083772659,
0.42144879698753357,
-0.6331070065498352,
0.16709309816360474,
1.0059905052185059,
1.3949946165084839,
-0.4299524128437042,
-0.37466010451316833,
0.07848076522350311,
0.1656576693058014,
-0.6595226526260376,
0.9522804617881775,
-0.341600239276886,
-0.7232909798622131,
-0.03156415373086929,
-0.13822562992572784,
-0.030882978811860085,
-0.392218679189682,
0.5246835350990295,
-0.5962213277816772,
0.0974629744887352,
-0.3305019736289978,
-0.4933231770992279,
0.07895056903362274,
0.09989935159683228,
-0.5621654391288757,
0.9109333753585815,
0.026604343205690384,
-0.6436045169830322,
0.6259030103683472,
-0.5485503673553467,
-0.355979859828949,
-0.15546171367168427,
0.1109643504023552,
-0.61216801404953,
0.15328076481819153,
-0.26525840163230896,
0.4017493724822998,
-0.3442019522190094,
0.3471298813819885,
-0.338534414768219,
-0.310912549495697,
0.6904162764549255,
-0.195760577917099,
0.4782525300979614,
0.2259792536497116,
0.30470365285873413,
-0.046611156314611435,
-0.5515300035476685,
-0.3714241683483124,
-0.22841612994670868,
-0.5404878258705139,
-0.38892310857772827,
0.1920814961194992,
0.033301737159490585,
-0.10910865664482117,
0.3207841217517853,
-0.8500256538391113,
0.47891226410865784,
-0.3453468978404999,
0.744103729724884,
0.36694657802581787,
0.2623530328273773,
0.21378488838672638,
-0.7379148602485657,
0.49006181955337524,
-0.20518678426742554,
-0.16660082340240479,
-0.25034812092781067,
-0.6652579307556152,
-0.37120866775512695,
-0.47789284586906433,
0.26732099056243896,
0.06064508110284805,
0.23512189090251923,
0.15795454382896423,
-0.4172442555427551,
-0.7413356304168701,
-0.3766769766807556,
0.11771833151578903,
0.030117053538560867,
0.3645140528678894,
0.18367724120616913,
-0.08461899310350418,
-0.5144683122634888,
-0.708606481552124,
-0.5637493133544922,
-0.2249700427055359,
-0.05648611858487129,
0.08502546697854996,
0.6302891969680786,
-0.2558259665966034,
0.8676323890686035,
-0.493278831243515,
-0.1915501058101654,
0.11068287491798401,
0.44164684414863586,
0.2676905393600464,
0.27668091654777527,
0.4056628346443176,
-0.48444098234176636,
-0.765887975692749,
-0.01452590525150299,
-0.6173064708709717,
-0.48075661063194275,
-0.1652338206768036,
-0.0605342797935009,
0.34360942244529724,
0.7069341540336609,
-0.382199227809906,
0.2014094442129135,
0.4752180874347687,
-0.25084778666496277,
0.49447324872016907,
-0.1207805871963501,
0.1564432978630066,
-0.6491161584854126,
0.20363786816596985,
0.29720354080200195,
-0.1056220605969429,
-0.38332048058509827,
-0.09043175727128983,
0.008732786402106285,
0.02805456332862377,
-0.2182789146900177,
0.3810873329639435,
-0.8090766668319702,
0.016334040090441704,
-0.22034871578216553,
0.3052118122577667,
-0.04713326692581177,
-0.1905311644077301,
-0.13103093206882477,
1.010528802871704,
0.21983255445957184,
-0.25865668058395386,
-0.10998550802469254,
0.09434555470943451,
-0.5860889554023743,
0.04655181244015694,
-0.8509882092475891,
-0.14923201501369476,
-0.20659752190113068,
0.47284382581710815,
-1.0617914199829102,
-0.08064554631710052,
-0.12589146196842194,
-0.2873418927192688,
0.12094936519861221,
-0.09554149210453033,
-0.6092644333839417,
-0.2702253460884094,
-0.3529362082481384,
0.029747609049081802,
0.32106098532676697,
-0.09704206138849258,
0.5285360813140869,
0.34613296389579773,
-0.6564333438873291,
-0.25052252411842346,
-0.7499428391456604,
0.5203998684883118,
-0.0651986226439476,
-0.8805186748504639,
0.4002719521522522,
-0.2132049947977066,
-0.469563364982605,
-0.05626131594181061,
-0.21916669607162476,
0.2710055708885193,
0.0659276619553566,
0.2099127620458603,
0.3262101411819458,
-0.11016419529914856,
0.12948541343212128,
-0.10972540080547333,
0.14254894852638245,
0.3822801113128662,
0.07821448892354965,
0.4892551302909851,
-0.16786691546440125,
-0.41176339983940125,
0.028889842331409454,
0.3401485085487366,
0.7453319430351257,
0.02266005054116249,
0.6983604431152344,
0.21774937212467194,
0.022001046687364578,
-0.0549602285027504,
-0.39399415254592896,
-0.05632705241441727,
-0.4009265899658203,
0.5617291331291199,
0.09859929978847504,
-1.1134165525436401,
0.5700987577438354,
-0.19088371098041534,
0.26689597964286804,
0.37766653299331665,
0.5085884928703308,
-0.18565046787261963,
0.5791926383972168,
0.5662709474563599,
0.10553836077451706,
0.49184030294418335,
-0.07691937685012817,
0.3350634276866913,
-0.8837893605232239,
-0.2859635353088379,
-0.70541912317276,
-0.14468535780906677,
-0.929481565952301,
-0.6034379601478577,
0.6785188317298889,
0.05271127074956894,
-0.08044199645519257,
-0.08620810508728027,
-0.5965257883071899,
0.524598240852356,
0.43090152740478516,
-0.29869088530540466,
0.6691316366195679,
0.09233226627111435,
0.17579972743988037,
-0.3797796368598938,
-0.5250312685966492,
-0.7224860191345215,
1.2339316606521606,
0.26528221368789673,
0.651964008808136,
0.014866681769490242,
0.6274048686027527,
0.3573291003704071,
0.7934927344322205,
-0.6145431399345398,
0.6102190613746643,
-0.18451093137264252,
-0.28549736738204956,
-0.17454373836517334,
-0.37211599946022034,
-1.0171138048171997,
0.2658802568912506,
-0.16056586802005768,
-0.4932929575443268,
0.051499366760253906,
-0.09272640198469162,
-0.07303821295499802,
0.2775278091430664,
-0.39764004945755005,
0.22181914746761322,
-0.19798192381858826,
-0.5065740346908569,
-0.1442059874534607,
-0.4605181813240051,
0.30480021238327026,
-0.4404730498790741,
0.3363625407218933,
-0.19798080623149872,
-0.28610554337501526,
1.0633600950241089,
-0.22930766642093658,
0.9503515362739563,
0.2327270805835724,
-0.2484651654958725,
0.3361128866672516,
0.08384605497121811,
0.5484938621520996,
0.12416719645261765,
-0.14371702075004578,
0.3616617023944855,
0.3254733681678772,
-0.2637077271938324,
-0.3159904181957245,
0.7914853692054749,
-0.7500582933425903,
-0.6907184720039368,
-1.144988775253296,
-0.5835316181182861,
-0.0344361886382103,
0.164284810423851,
0.1298046112060547,
0.1144552081823349,
-0.3275211453437805,
0.5615323781967163,
0.6130613088607788,
-0.11119230836629868,
0.36896321177482605,
0.7341439723968506,
-0.36540892720222473,
-0.40209898352622986,
0.6669211983680725,
0.43815314769744873,
0.1652069389820099,
0.24683471024036407,
0.4631669521331787,
-0.054892804473638535,
-0.8732494711875916,
0.26040080189704895,
0.607586145401001,
-0.3576502799987793,
-0.04453341290354729,
-0.9105654358863831,
-0.2799290120601654,
-0.48419252038002014,
-0.44178953766822815,
0.0843440368771553,
-0.25081026554107666,
-0.5589275360107422,
0.12569433450698853,
0.4382573664188385,
0.7221721410751343,
-0.253234326839447,
0.518988311290741,
-0.6148633360862732,
0.10007822513580322,
0.019727297127246857,
0.4029391407966614,
-0.1403844803571701,
-0.4412113428115845,
-0.20277392864227295,
0.07873521745204926,
-0.2589055299758911,
-0.750985324382782,
0.565108060836792,
0.29138579964637756,
0.3806745111942291,
0.055202633142471313,
-0.2879452109336853,
0.39254406094551086,
-0.36248406767845154,
0.8650449514389038,
0.22574453055858612,
-0.5234414935112,
0.17997270822525024,
-0.7548534870147705,
0.2620711028575897,
0.3373176157474518,
0.46656352281570435,
-0.9996469616889954,
-0.4167274236679077,
-0.3788917064666748,
-0.9689679145812988,
0.27995121479034424,
-0.20075677335262299,
0.2204698771238327,
0.13500221073627472,
0.24652348458766937,
-0.005315836053341627,
0.2848787009716034,
-0.8236019611358643,
0.08473311364650726,
0.2787455916404724,
-0.19565899670124054,
0.04464317858219147,
-0.4814702272415161,
-0.3994906544685364,
-0.140480637550354,
0.6291832327842712,
0.0009082945762202144,
0.2527024745941162,
0.3253985643386841,
0.014412558637559414,
-0.08002636581659317,
0.41514015197753906,
0.8531448245048523,
1.001416563987732,
-0.3772331178188324,
0.1652858853340149,
-0.2335221916437149,
-0.9970681071281433,
-0.19727082550525665,
0.05804822966456413,
-0.4493541717529297,
-0.15354163944721222,
0.5575106739997864,
0.29180118441581726,
0.0732090175151825,
-0.6218860149383545,
0.1776561588048935,
0.23853297531604767,
-0.4357473850250244,
-0.42833298444747925,
0.15186192095279694,
0.2358430176973343,
0.07050235569477081,
0.5203922390937805,
0.04511485993862152,
-0.06197981536388397,
-0.5023310780525208,
-0.030430028215050697,
0.45660996437072754,
-0.21084406971931458,
-0.3017284572124481,
0.4437064826488495,
-0.0222785547375679,
-0.14956779778003693,
0.028350796550512314,
0.07658403366804123,
-0.24610696732997894,
0.6321523189544678,
0.6857767701148987,
0.5122354030609131,
0.27867379784584045,
0.1791590452194214,
0.2478707730770111,
0.49643972516059875,
-0.17966169118881226,
0.19783250987529755,
0.3861931264400482,
-0.5003132820129395,
-0.4586779475212097,
-0.7517594695091248,
-0.5020500421524048,
0.2045414000749588,
-0.18896745145320892,
0.2930891513824463,
-0.37116390466690063,
-0.2908351719379425,
0.2973843812942505,
0.2771524488925934,
-0.2529851198196411,
-0.3250809907913208,
-0.13698405027389526,
0.7517613768577576,
-0.8752302527427673,
0.48409324884414673,
0.8073667883872986,
-0.2341729700565338,
-0.11914709955453873,
-0.3403218388557434,
0.30701613426208496,
-0.5900172591209412,
0.5539094805717468,
-0.24186773598194122,
-0.07014653086662292,
-0.026865124702453613,
-0.8899700045585632,
-1.118212103843689,
1.0250566005706787,
0.07743126153945923,
-0.786468505859375,
0.3264789581298828,
0.3643239736557007,
1.0647059679031372,
-0.3712046146392822,
0.04617886245250702,
0.32166144251823425,
0.590490460395813,
0.16816392540931702,
-0.4803984463214874,
-0.17103002965450287,
-0.3230854868888855,
-0.025908008217811584,
0.44382384419441223,
-0.7127074003219604,
0.7867494225502014,
-0.07293470203876495,
-0.1679094284772873,
-0.1753937304019928,
0.6415219902992249,
0.7351061701774597,
0.48803189396858215,
0.013510460965335369,
0.18796877562999725,
0.807386577129364,
-0.06933898478746414,
0.47830909490585327,
-0.44768232107162476,
0.007629268802702427,
0.9155484437942505,
-0.4264112710952759,
0.7270088791847229,
0.7569557428359985,
-0.5768217444419861,
0.4043116569519043,
0.5389065742492676,
-0.47211378812789917,
0.12621495127677917,
0.7182204127311707,
-0.49606284499168396,
0.16443757712841034,
-0.39059364795684814,
-0.49739521741867065,
0.07684933394193649,
0.71001136302948,
-0.6659215092658997,
0.030892523005604744,
0.011818240396678448,
0.7478692531585693,
0.1755627989768982,
-0.1674657016992569,
0.7250955700874329,
0.23870345950126648,
-0.662324070930481,
0.34513160586357117,
-0.032208651304244995,
0.7080493569374084,
-0.7578585147857666,
0.03380652144551277,
-0.3279518187046051,
-0.15429776906967163,
-0.25900185108184814,
-1.2068707942962646,
0.41993290185928345,
0.42143920063972473,
-0.3070932924747467,
-0.5832312107086182,
0.7159157991409302,
-0.4697393774986267,
-0.7660976052284241,
0.07422623783349991,
0.5280722379684448,
0.18109309673309326,
0.1838509440422058,
-0.07867748290300369,
0.1194799616932869,
-0.07205229997634888,
-0.5000611543655396,
0.6022976636886597,
0.4024859368801117,
-0.1526164561510086,
0.6848263740539551,
0.8803879618644714,
0.6790229082107544,
0.260313481092453,
-0.07659384608268738,
0.9061538577079773,
-0.44363701343536377,
-0.052146077156066895,
-0.8705390691757202,
0.24637416005134583,
-0.20442086458206177,
-0.4305669963359833,
0.9273967742919922,
0.6154567003250122,
0.3741721212863922,
0.17493663728237152,
0.9993383288383484,
0.06188405677676201,
0.4176543653011322,
-0.2861252725124359,
0.8482445478439331,
-0.3938753306865692,
0.35220107436180115,
-0.2228153944015503,
-0.8250962495803833,
-0.6788330078125,
0.2230076789855957,
-0.43619221448898315,
-0.12132306396961212,
0.5296440124511719,
0.6961503624916077,
0.13520926237106323,
0.032125700265169144,
0.05306238681077957,
0.4061596095561981,
0.5212741494178772,
-0.08959430456161499,
0.5492232441902161,
-0.018266471102833748,
0.3516803979873657,
-0.03740144520998001,
-0.36568382382392883,
-0.21463531255722046,
-1.3800145387649536,
-0.6139580011367798,
-0.5398837924003601,
-0.4187765121459961,
-0.20742318034172058,
0.19780968129634857,
0.6871100068092346,
0.06971440464258194,
-0.6734276413917542,
-0.3514021039009094,
-0.16945399343967438,
-0.08181647956371307,
0.09713489562273026,
-0.19831359386444092,
0.46603378653526306,
-0.09895545244216919,
-0.32443785667419434,
0.1876399666070938,
0.3662925660610199,
0.08431288599967957,
-0.41284823417663574,
0.34503743052482605,
-0.3382735550403595,
0.2421194314956665,
0.7589393258094788,
0.40739166736602783,
-0.44301244616508484,
0.0795367956161499,
0.5048527121543884,
-0.34596478939056396,
0.20135396718978882,
0.7964639663696289,
-0.280317097902298,
0.371551513671875,
0.7679749727249146,
0.3528095781803131,
0.6108921766281128,
-0.1560116410255432,
0.5034511089324951,
-0.5845217704772949,
-0.3193762004375458,
0.34381458163261414,
0.3066864013671875,
0.4793917238712311,
-0.22753410041332245,
0.6982447504997253,
0.434797465801239,
-1.0876564979553223,
-1.028982400894165,
-0.3006102442741394,
-0.9725320935249329,
-0.15516696870326996,
1.1484607458114624,
-0.033583033829927444,
-0.340562105178833,
0.04392349347472191,
-0.11639133095741272,
0.1566309630870819,
-0.582277238368988,
1.0164260864257812,
0.9765653610229492,
-0.24428683519363403,
-0.14079488813877106,
-0.7582405209541321,
0.4296450912952423,
0.1371144950389862,
-0.8931401968002319,
0.2923097312450409,
0.6063170433044434,
0.13822510838508606,
0.23945480585098267,
0.6711065173149109,
-0.31365931034088135,
-0.07294930517673492,
-0.22903238236904144,
0.004834552761167288,
-0.07989152520895004,
-0.10710309445858002,
-0.08302483707666397,
0.1730431318283081,
0.16939105093479156,
0.6100853085517883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01266v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01266v2
|
IsoBench: Benchmarking Multimodal Foundation Models on Isomorphic Representations
| 2024-04-01T17:43:27 | 2024-04-02T15:46:13 |
Deqing Fu, Ghazal Khalighinejad, Ollie Liu, Bhuwan Dhingra, Dani Yogatama, Robin Jia, Willie Neiswanger
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current foundation models exhibit impressive capabilities when prompted
either with text only or with both image and text inputs. But do their
capabilities change depending on the input modality? In this work, we propose
$\textbf{IsoBench}$, a benchmark dataset containing problems from four major
areas: math, science, algorithms, and games. Each example is presented with
multiple $\textbf{isomorphic representations}$ of inputs, such as visual,
textual, and mathematical presentations. IsoBench provides fine-grained
feedback to diagnose performance gaps caused by the form of the representation.
Across various foundation models, we observe that on the same problem, models
have a consistent preference towards textual representations. Most prominently,
when evaluated on all IsoBench problems, Claude-3 Opus performs 28.7 points
worse when provided with images instead of text; similarly, GPT-4 Turbo is 18.7
points worse and Gemini Pro is 14.9 points worse. Finally, we present two
prompting techniques, $\textit{IsoCombination}$ and $\textit{IsoScratchPad}$,
which improve model performance by considering combinations of, and
translations between, different input representations.
|
[
-0.5299394130706787,
-0.5259349346160889,
0.5206792950630188,
0.6340207457542419,
-0.33130714297294617,
-0.2207341492176056,
-0.3788159489631653,
-0.6186890602111816,
-0.1527356058359146,
0.1768583506345749,
-0.5076625347137451,
-0.3885871469974518,
-0.7854208946228027,
0.34977272152900696,
-0.49714869260787964,
0.4944334328174591,
-0.5148735642433167,
0.5481958985328674,
-0.7483762502670288,
-0.2747301459312439,
-0.44592294096946716,
-0.16027341783046722,
-0.2699703872203827,
-0.5504182577133179,
0.24420160055160522,
0.3122069239616394,
0.6000760793685913,
0.5655443072319031,
0.656435489654541,
0.3100525736808777,
0.1456681191921234,
-0.12361284345388412,
-0.42310813069343567,
0.47228550910949707,
0.004998920019716024,
-0.47040683031082153,
0.21908925473690033,
0.08169959485530853,
0.7712025046348572,
0.4412153661251068,
-0.08954989165067673,
0.2678754925727844,
0.1295187622308731,
0.4001463055610657,
-0.9338182806968689,
0.3565868139266968,
-0.3445327579975128,
0.19404336810112,
-0.1567777693271637,
-0.03585321083664894,
-0.5776771306991577,
-0.1779574155807495,
-0.20409151911735535,
-0.6532196402549744,
0.2091684341430664,
-0.30783453583717346,
0.7775112390518188,
0.36803293228149414,
-0.4409014880657196,
-0.14819292724132538,
-0.6800018548965454,
0.6246539950370789,
-0.25415632128715515,
0.7963059544563293,
0.3908398747444153,
0.3917319178581238,
0.04220794141292572,
-0.7471034526824951,
-0.32928666472435,
-0.41257941722869873,
-0.0146985724568367,
0.17244738340377808,
-0.3270711302757263,
0.05087181553244591,
0.4028076231479645,
0.20332665741443634,
-0.29605531692504883,
-0.021078910678625107,
-0.3394041657447815,
-0.34889742732048035,
0.2065831422805786,
0.07633626461029053,
-0.03496851772069931,
-0.15644727647304535,
-0.4745536148548126,
-0.8472406268119812,
-0.8168336153030396,
0.21793462336063385,
0.23009197413921356,
-0.036292750388383865,
-0.0927446186542511,
0.7080729007720947,
-0.13700029253959656,
1.052656888961792,
0.005410599987953901,
0.05227378383278847,
0.10114555805921555,
-0.15674825012683868,
0.061668720096349716,
-0.2300407737493515,
0.7988980412483215,
0.367664635181427,
0.01852046325802803,
0.0859857127070427,
-0.2374936193227768,
0.2844022512435913,
0.031004449352622032,
-1.1110559701919556,
-0.2835717797279358,
-0.18158753216266632,
-0.5460671782493591,
-0.14403417706489563,
0.24975280463695526,
-0.803737998008728,
-0.7027407288551331,
-0.3113057315349579,
0.5151404142379761,
-0.6793348789215088,
0.08076862245798111,
0.005008611362427473,
-0.15069426596164703,
-0.04300939291715622,
0.35851261019706726,
-0.8113272190093994,
0.3969433009624481,
0.32035401463508606,
0.7903008460998535,
0.012940065003931522,
-0.11537226289510727,
-0.5065975785255432,
0.01294695120304823,
-0.29021555185317993,
0.9160789847373962,
-0.8569985032081604,
-0.5098890066146851,
-0.28026217222213745,
-0.31644895672798157,
-0.12947851419448853,
-0.6517748236656189,
0.369710773229599,
-0.24224890768527985,
0.20509539544582367,
-0.37746429443359375,
-0.5397698879241943,
-0.07345371693372726,
0.3442237973213196,
-1.155275583267212,
1.1288243532180786,
0.11874283105134964,
-0.5697129964828491,
0.4209215044975281,
-0.5652965903282166,
-0.0804930180311203,
-0.18399864435195923,
-0.6041595935821533,
-0.17176733911037445,
0.3212231397628784,
0.279588907957077,
0.4639504551887512,
-0.857653796672821,
0.2339659482240677,
-0.3059651255607605,
-0.48589852452278137,
0.20880471169948578,
-0.3147108852863312,
0.461465448141098,
0.06172426417469978,
-0.5489132404327393,
-0.008502231910824776,
-0.9958712458610535,
0.18689081072807312,
-0.05536948889493942,
-0.4039788842201233,
-0.06047980114817619,
0.15975983440876007,
0.3417603075504303,
0.3600572645664215,
-0.024303099140524864,
-0.462414413690567,
0.04898978769779205,
0.16342958807945251,
0.23356400430202484,
0.702010452747345,
-0.13577523827552795,
0.0475710853934288,
-0.28380993008613586,
0.5917885899543762,
0.13359254598617554,
-0.1803409457206726,
-0.10732048004865646,
-0.5181275010108948,
-0.4668644964694977,
-0.4743068218231201,
0.6183993220329285,
0.2536047399044037,
-0.7012335062026978,
-0.1861276626586914,
-0.16647520661354065,
-0.4499514698982239,
-0.2958184480667114,
0.20225712656974792,
0.5279294848442078,
0.3353777229785919,
0.4235900640487671,
-0.5741038918495178,
-0.3442794382572174,
-1.1191250085830688,
-0.29871654510498047,
-0.35412752628326416,
-0.10892260074615479,
0.19569577276706696,
0.4188503921031952,
0.01517853606492281,
0.8010981678962708,
-0.3278583884239197,
-0.1491096466779709,
0.1695764809846878,
0.4650922417640686,
-0.18961292505264282,
0.5115917921066284,
0.8357886672019958,
-0.9298415780067444,
-0.41453099250793457,
-0.3051146864891052,
-0.595663845539093,
-0.10972375422716141,
0.09158143401145935,
0.20706216990947723,
-0.18982169032096863,
0.5604112148284912,
-0.5761518478393555,
0.48664262890815735,
0.881543755531311,
-0.1986505687236786,
0.5311902761459351,
0.15906551480293274,
0.49972113966941833,
-0.8952016234397888,
0.15882304310798645,
0.07514797896146774,
-0.07735750824213028,
-0.13635483384132385,
0.23188261687755585,
0.33935800194740295,
-0.4111228585243225,
-0.23695753514766693,
0.5315700769424438,
-0.5552096366882324,
-0.08660328388214111,
0.19072645902633667,
-0.09478874504566193,
0.0015619815094396472,
0.1964166760444641,
0.07348400354385376,
0.8007263541221619,
0.6345856785774231,
-0.34898149967193604,
0.5880561470985413,
0.13611653447151184,
-0.521000325679779,
0.7009442448616028,
-0.7301616072654724,
-0.03370857983827591,
-0.12220291793346405,
0.4780246317386627,
-1.0957098007202148,
-0.31483694911003113,
0.1273440420627594,
-0.24899142980575562,
0.2354329526424408,
0.048939842730760574,
-0.7638922929763794,
-0.01798885501921177,
-0.4524867832660675,
0.5620300769805908,
0.21344879269599915,
-0.474546879529953,
0.7684891223907471,
-0.2939644455909729,
0.12145348638296127,
-0.5604031682014465,
-0.519426167011261,
-0.07648338377475739,
0.1290743052959442,
-0.835213303565979,
0.6515291333198547,
-0.15807810425758362,
-0.07827688753604889,
0.4051923155784607,
-0.2674110233783722,
-0.07922081649303436,
0.052768774330616,
0.3969119191169739,
-0.055043842643499374,
-0.45358243584632874,
0.14605054259300232,
-0.04068122059106827,
-0.14728572964668274,
-0.008349855430424213,
0.00587477395310998,
0.5803031921386719,
-0.3832373023033142,
-0.7005590796470642,
-0.25175416469573975,
0.3173849284648895,
0.6017054915428162,
-0.3548906147480011,
0.8138977885246277,
0.49438396096229553,
-0.5201529860496521,
0.00996796041727066,
-0.47135162353515625,
-0.4253939390182495,
-0.4074989855289459,
0.19723770022392273,
-0.6101049184799194,
-0.6944032311439514,
0.6012936234474182,
-0.19623121619224548,
-0.00495450384914875,
0.36789652705192566,
0.5344731211662292,
0.011330246925354004,
1.0114954710006714,
0.7027114033699036,
0.25692862272262573,
0.725121021270752,
-0.34875330328941345,
-0.2759304940700531,
-0.6327961087226868,
-0.31994032859802246,
-0.6154086589813232,
-0.6508045196533203,
-0.23061704635620117,
-0.5523321032524109,
0.3551882803440094,
0.36758726835250854,
-0.027387747541069984,
0.5993943810462952,
-0.22238080203533173,
0.6042684316635132,
0.5214906334877014,
0.20808912813663483,
0.3579457998275757,
0.12364062666893005,
-0.5318031907081604,
-0.2468460649251938,
-0.7319297790527344,
-0.35564473271369934,
1.1785683631896973,
0.01788691058754921,
0.9489498734474182,
0.17849169671535492,
0.7041944861412048,
-0.008639019913971424,
0.6815086603164673,
-0.49765658378601074,
0.5298509001731873,
-0.13686339557170868,
-0.8424447178840637,
0.1627717912197113,
-0.6374940276145935,
-0.6208570599555969,
0.4188936650753021,
-0.5615422129631042,
-0.8429651260375977,
0.624578595161438,
0.2690310478210449,
-0.1264800876379013,
0.18478752672672272,
-0.6184684038162231,
1.0614677667617798,
-0.24094973504543304,
-0.5540745258331299,
-0.2598772943019867,
-0.4483003616333008,
0.4379604160785675,
0.09022622555494308,
-0.055208154022693634,
-0.06110760569572449,
-0.05599866062402725,
0.5600683093070984,
-0.10427910834550858,
0.6782272458076477,
-0.14884798228740692,
0.04687850549817085,
-0.0035995717626065016,
0.4481228291988373,
0.27740222215652466,
0.11134129762649536,
-0.23698140680789948,
-0.07653426378965378,
0.20946156978607178,
-0.2631359398365021,
-0.6817178726196289,
0.6866426467895508,
-0.9541763067245483,
-0.32047387957572937,
-0.2701559066772461,
-0.28366875648498535,
-0.6893167495727539,
0.1747925579547882,
0.6400085687637329,
0.8111580610275269,
-0.4969022870063782,
0.8752865195274353,
0.5172572135925293,
0.12342650443315506,
0.13608887791633606,
0.30437153577804565,
-0.10632173717021942,
-0.2881632447242737,
0.6323878169059753,
-0.1396351158618927,
0.2797721326351166,
0.3717360198497772,
0.0030704056844115257,
-0.3543330132961273,
-0.32328325510025024,
-0.7098878026008606,
0.0938480943441391,
-1.102310299873352,
-0.4362424612045288,
-0.35904788970947266,
0.13374656438827515,
-0.12239771336317062,
-0.0024559542071074247,
-0.357927531003952,
-0.628221333026886,
-0.30758869647979736,
-0.14605437219142914,
0.1723729521036148,
0.5699865221977234,
-0.2232515960931778,
0.3692065477371216,
-0.6688846349716187,
0.5802266597747803,
0.2627771496772766,
0.724232017993927,
-0.16417789459228516,
-0.06310093402862549,
-0.06183284521102905,
-0.011929900385439396,
-0.5155346989631653,
-1.1219496726989746,
-0.4053525924682617,
0.37201422452926636,
0.5481909513473511,
0.47692230343818665,
-0.24919955432415009,
0.8306601047515869,
-0.21104396879673004,
0.5185874104499817,
0.3415599763393402,
-0.8848772644996643,
0.20281818509101868,
-0.18546396493911743,
0.21781061589717865,
0.9932650327682495,
0.48025190830230713,
-0.5851291418075562,
-0.12882228195667267,
-0.6282675862312317,
-0.5264579653739929,
0.8631486296653748,
0.3134402632713318,
-0.042577020823955536,
0.19280453026294708,
0.01386353187263012,
0.011536561883985996,
0.31335070729255676,
-0.9040321707725525,
0.0002918045502156019,
-0.3625461459159851,
-0.32466498017311096,
-0.0732964426279068,
-0.08527392148971558,
-0.4209122359752655,
-0.09727688878774643,
0.5253866314888,
-0.08198253065347672,
0.25998425483703613,
-0.02727377787232399,
-0.4028417468070984,
-0.25023144483566284,
0.04826643690466881,
0.5664864778518677,
0.7854622602462769,
-0.020124200731515884,
0.2716028392314911,
-0.32455453276634216,
-0.3219798803329468,
0.37738537788391113,
0.4723619520664215,
-0.16263309121131897,
0.027477316558361053,
0.6866497993469238,
0.8102148175239563,
0.43372517824172974,
-0.8473509550094604,
0.4148515462875366,
-0.21172049641609192,
-0.2148626446723938,
0.1194702684879303,
0.03746112436056137,
0.061156097799539566,
-0.016440078616142273,
0.12856118381023407,
0.3430640995502472,
0.15630018711090088,
-0.4758407175540924,
0.08542845398187637,
0.1463031768798828,
-0.5722166299819946,
-0.16542623937129974,
0.7708998322486877,
0.18822327256202698,
0.09089816361665726,
0.7114835977554321,
0.13534681499004364,
-0.35539498925209045,
0.6181714534759521,
0.5746431946754456,
0.6477311253547668,
-0.263273686170578,
0.40300363302230835,
0.3620469272136688,
0.3702356815338135,
-0.30239811539649963,
0.09009601175785065,
-0.2721906304359436,
-0.7863659262657166,
-0.20039547979831696,
-0.3483040928840637,
-0.4860101044178009,
-0.03871910646557808,
-0.6903004050254822,
0.35345321893692017,
-0.616710364818573,
-0.2676263153553009,
0.048973605036735535,
-0.26831158995628357,
-0.7965414524078369,
0.0804567039012909,
0.11517646163702011,
0.9401558041572571,
-1.0121351480484009,
0.2652797996997833,
1.0444047451019287,
-0.3333182632923126,
-0.7076826095581055,
-0.2062375843524933,
0.3843728303909302,
-0.5532233715057373,
0.6410840153694153,
0.26370808482170105,
-0.41018539667129517,
-0.03127455338835716,
-0.5857973098754883,
-0.7968078255653381,
0.9549788236618042,
0.7418661713600159,
-0.29195913672447205,
0.3290118873119354,
0.039866335690021515,
0.43917128443717957,
-0.4068479835987091,
0.3254798650741577,
0.2828437089920044,
0.6651231646537781,
-0.016895869746804237,
-0.6996021270751953,
0.08751868456602097,
-0.5774679780006409,
0.14739364385604858,
0.18905211985111237,
-0.5600624084472656,
1.0330818891525269,
0.2347968965768814,
-0.3469529151916504,
0.2251659333705902,
0.38935601711273193,
0.520829975605011,
-0.05170019716024399,
0.6725224852561951,
0.7336416840553284,
0.400081068277359,
-0.39068499207496643,
1.1273561716079712,
-0.42715445160865784,
0.25273874402046204,
0.7871813774108887,
-0.23236866295337677,
0.7206377387046814,
0.4674583971500397,
0.002265757415443659,
0.7731909155845642,
0.7047086358070374,
-0.06483761221170425,
0.4420933425426483,
0.25461405515670776,
-0.08108200132846832,
-0.45900484919548035,
0.10653698444366455,
-0.6043363809585571,
0.5108304023742676,
0.3282240927219391,
-0.23254580795764923,
-0.6102092266082764,
0.1811695396900177,
-0.24269302189350128,
0.21135418117046356,
0.266850084066391,
0.5070716142654419,
-0.174321711063385,
-0.6412028670310974,
0.636448323726654,
0.4763276278972626,
0.24627438187599182,
-0.967551052570343,
-0.33696189522743225,
-0.2586295008659363,
0.19440610706806183,
-0.022454923018813133,
-0.3464210033416748,
-0.3103252649307251,
-0.14066310226917267,
-0.292672723531723,
-0.3089205324649811,
0.5179787278175354,
-0.3650912940502167,
-0.6669201254844666,
0.35015374422073364,
0.387209415435791,
-0.11962797492742538,
-0.1638660728931427,
-0.8229668140411377,
0.5617547035217285,
-0.30410414934158325,
-0.38800740242004395,
0.006112765520811081,
0.4250812232494354,
-0.5029777884483337,
0.5977942943572998,
0.4785560965538025,
-0.24894878268241882,
0.1336982548236847,
0.019053440541028976,
1.0403544902801514,
-0.5088828802108765,
-0.2962757647037506,
-0.622161328792572,
0.3116716742515564,
-0.12444838136434555,
-0.5974587202072144,
0.569309651851654,
0.6569352746009827,
0.7536225914955139,
-0.1992422640323639,
0.3938465714454651,
-0.4309942424297333,
-0.07628047466278076,
-0.6556199789047241,
0.28173479437828064,
-0.6249282360076904,
0.016982046887278557,
-0.483730286359787,
-1.3808319568634033,
-0.2870016098022461,
0.8357128500938416,
-0.07739285379648209,
0.23291043937206268,
0.8814841508865356,
0.6931913495063782,
-0.45616206526756287,
0.19152714312076569,
0.00594723504036665,
-0.01942181959748268,
0.2621431052684784,
0.5315171480178833,
1.0206044912338257,
-0.38820043206214905,
0.5729687809944153,
-0.36153456568717957,
-0.3296545445919037,
-0.3558780252933502,
-0.9334527254104614,
-0.7174584865570068,
-0.7515411972999573,
-0.05868153274059296,
-0.260942667722702,
-0.21638211607933044,
0.7192119359970093,
0.9305301904678345,
-0.8044695854187012,
-0.42029574513435364,
0.16175100207328796,
-0.020181575790047646,
-0.45320925116539,
-0.13395078480243683,
0.25240230560302734,
0.1447216123342514,
-0.40987446904182434,
0.4754694104194641,
0.03975707292556763,
0.06684257090091705,
-0.3781881332397461,
0.18666021525859833,
0.06744877249002457,
-0.1680336743593216,
0.38203129172325134,
0.24015741050243378,
-0.5606436133384705,
-0.2483750879764557,
0.19158966839313507,
-0.004804127849638462,
0.08904236555099487,
1.285819172859192,
-0.7725456953048706,
0.7189057469367981,
0.5651216506958008,
0.6506763696670532,
0.9752565622329712,
0.19812873005867004,
0.6232545971870422,
-0.8440238237380981,
0.36837342381477356,
0.4177444577217102,
0.5033758878707886,
0.46701639890670776,
-0.01704254373908043,
0.5344565510749817,
0.33732450008392334,
0.07967448234558105,
-0.6788655519485474,
0.3400171995162964,
-0.6820471286773682,
-0.40602952241897583,
0.6947965621948242,
0.07219220697879791,
-0.05978028103709221,
0.3729901611804962,
-0.12800312042236328,
-0.3135412633419037,
-0.25917595624923706,
0.6322389841079712,
1.3638262748718262,
-0.29239681363105774,
-0.3906634449958801,
-0.4151048958301544,
0.2902323603630066,
0.489555686712265,
-0.5960901379585266,
-0.17665447294712067,
0.9436670541763306,
0.23250456154346466,
0.399617075920105,
0.6901651620864868,
-0.4925999939441681,
0.626420795917511,
0.15781158208847046,
0.13970832526683807,
-0.19563157856464386,
-0.6444445848464966,
-0.2018396109342575,
0.22586137056350708,
-0.007440670859068632,
0.12120935320854187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01263v1
|
Artificial Intelligence and the Spatial Documentation of Languages
| 2024-04-01T17:35:57 | 2024-04-01T17:35:57 |
Hakam Ghanim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advancement in technology has made interdisciplinary research more
accessible. Particularly the breakthrough in Artificial Intelligence AI has
given huge advantages to researchers working in interdisciplinary and
multidisciplinary fields. This study investigates the ability of AI models,
particularly GPT4 and GPT Data Analyst in creating language maps for language
documentation. The study Integrates documentary linguistics linguistic
geography and AI by showcasing how AI models facilitate the spatial
documentation of languages through the creation of language maps with minimal
cartographic expertise. The study is conducted using a CSV file and a GeoJSON
file both obtained from HDX and from the researchers fieldwork. The study data
is then applied in realtime conversations with the AI models in order to
generate the language distribution maps. The study highlights the two AI models
capabilities in generating highquality static and interactive web maps and
streamlining the mapmaking process, despite facing challenges like
inconsistencies and difficulties in adding legends. The findings suggest a
promising future for AI in generating language maps and enhancing the work of
documentary linguists as they collect their data in the field pointing towards
the need for further development to fully harness AI potential in this field.
|
[
-0.5999802947044373,
-0.6890506744384766,
0.8116652369499207,
0.11817359179258347,
0.24299466609954834,
0.0477340966463089,
-0.4552828371524811,
-0.6335727572441101,
0.11067668348550797,
0.5426850318908691,
-0.1583164632320404,
-0.9806178212165833,
-0.5776851177215576,
0.09604217857122421,
-0.47812074422836304,
0.8875299692153931,
-0.230791836977005,
-0.2014211118221283,
-0.15823394060134888,
-0.47328871488571167,
-0.30559706687927246,
-0.5713228583335876,
-0.5906988978385925,
-0.4265093207359314,
0.24211034178733826,
0.21036924421787262,
1.1040290594100952,
0.8668138980865479,
0.5440483093261719,
0.5203675031661987,
0.21135331690311432,
0.023096563294529915,
-0.14673814177513123,
0.0526144914329052,
-0.07816636562347412,
-0.5042853951454163,
-0.5737054347991943,
0.18774472177028656,
0.6503008008003235,
0.6416688561439514,
-0.1573217362165451,
0.06545104086399078,
-0.48774784803390503,
0.31927093863487244,
0.157321959733963,
0.4969286024570465,
-0.4504644274711609,
-0.008285308256745338,
-0.2290979027748108,
-0.23836295306682587,
-0.060484379529953,
-0.4336603283882141,
0.3137577474117279,
-0.9646658897399902,
0.26522549986839294,
0.11875520646572113,
0.931472897529602,
0.25350695848464966,
-0.1911332905292511,
-0.3806663751602173,
-1.019655704498291,
0.45563387870788574,
-0.7313142418861389,
0.1816873848438263,
0.7006585597991943,
0.47004520893096924,
0.17396306991577148,
-0.43973758816719055,
-0.48607203364372253,
-0.33683332800865173,
-0.10995284467935562,
-0.0008509269100613892,
-0.009645294398069382,
-0.22519230842590332,
0.2239537388086319,
0.07588447630405426,
-0.7148004770278931,
0.30749160051345825,
-0.5655155181884766,
-0.08027240633964539,
0.789692759513855,
0.271102637052536,
0.7978731989860535,
-0.04288994520902634,
0.23436951637268066,
-0.0461483895778656,
-0.7407661080360413,
-0.34711754322052,
0.43655627965927124,
0.3751673400402069,
-0.36482489109039307,
0.4939439296722412,
-0.1633276790380478,
0.38922712206840515,
-0.6178500652313232,
-0.2915429472923279,
0.11637423187494278,
-0.5335081219673157,
0.16937394440174103,
-0.31900325417518616,
0.8898416757583618,
0.12033222615718842,
0.5986732840538025,
-0.28235504031181335,
-0.07481067627668381,
-0.02485554665327072,
0.08830809593200684,
-0.19649715721607208,
-0.7086396813392639,
-0.01591469720005989,
-0.15396663546562195,
0.0717887431383133,
-0.15695779025554657,
-0.7141287922859192,
-0.3558709919452667,
-0.6383923292160034,
-0.06893761456012726,
-0.4957635700702667,
-0.5729283094406128,
-0.1547100841999054,
-0.2497871369123459,
-0.010986601002514362,
0.3335669934749603,
-0.8271796107292175,
0.030060335993766785,
0.496094286441803,
0.7740176916122437,
0.14040598273277283,
-0.638897716999054,
0.17848533391952515,
0.35824814438819885,
-0.23708583414554596,
0.9933713674545288,
-0.5280342698097229,
-0.36302265524864197,
0.21464337408542633,
-0.4440860450267792,
0.096047542989254,
-0.4642849564552307,
0.21299198269844055,
-0.39508193731307983,
0.14760205149650574,
-0.0022063415963202715,
-0.09245583415031433,
-0.4821600317955017,
0.2702905237674713,
-0.8497586250305176,
0.8780998587608337,
0.2664146423339844,
-0.2475983053445816,
0.40612855553627014,
-0.8523147106170654,
-0.3677746057510376,
0.5757086873054504,
-0.42499592900276184,
-0.31758615374565125,
-0.31378430128097534,
0.38036713004112244,
-0.024516699835658073,
-0.23341691493988037,
0.5805313587188721,
-0.03193538263440132,
-0.2568163573741913,
0.01547579001635313,
-0.1455676555633545,
0.758687436580658,
0.05391957238316536,
-0.5921359658241272,
-0.05176026374101639,
-0.2762598991394043,
-0.13883787393569946,
0.19518165290355682,
-0.7079105377197266,
-0.15633171796798706,
0.1929933726787567,
0.06356100738048553,
0.14309512078762054,
0.004402736201882362,
-0.06164676323533058,
0.4708970785140991,
-0.3044554591178894,
0.25445306301116943,
0.4901795983314514,
-0.3937091827392578,
0.7182340621948242,
-0.17951299250125885,
0.8987622261047363,
-0.16414356231689453,
-0.14592742919921875,
-0.2289213240146637,
-0.8377149105072021,
-0.6429991722106934,
-0.10926975309848785,
0.35479897260665894,
0.6631448268890381,
-0.7407364249229431,
0.3369311988353729,
-0.741593599319458,
-0.6543700695037842,
-0.6089590787887573,
0.05860196053981781,
0.1364634782075882,
0.3286096751689911,
0.05245254188776016,
-0.17711983621120453,
-0.529183030128479,
-0.5044552683830261,
0.06759125739336014,
-0.3884451687335968,
0.06167614832520485,
0.4094269573688507,
0.4232541620731354,
-0.5261432528495789,
0.9787325859069824,
-0.17453311383724213,
-0.29686281085014343,
-0.398265540599823,
0.5872902870178223,
0.04035788029432297,
0.224862739443779,
1.101641297340393,
-0.6809746623039246,
-0.32476934790611267,
0.1172659620642662,
-1.1039541959762573,
-0.23396062850952148,
-0.059577826410532,
-0.15732184052467346,
0.3302944302558899,
-0.008052819408476353,
-0.9136496186256409,
0.6245206594467163,
0.2973759174346924,
-0.4112755060195923,
0.4169551432132721,
-0.4239286482334137,
0.37644797563552856,
-0.569923996925354,
0.18557778000831604,
0.24885793030261993,
-0.12746937572956085,
-0.6139233112335205,
0.45858412981033325,
-0.39365342259407043,
-0.558234453201294,
-0.19743967056274414,
0.5019775629043579,
-0.5166882872581482,
-0.14672371745109558,
-0.05072120949625969,
0.4021746814250946,
-0.272468626499176,
0.44465702772140503,
0.06190451979637146,
0.599033772945404,
0.7717612385749817,
-0.3984469473361969,
0.3128448724746704,
0.5337450504302979,
-0.19609259068965912,
-0.10884667187929153,
-0.2977946698665619,
0.08337866514921188,
-0.09734440594911575,
0.40598052740097046,
-0.8029895424842834,
-0.23840078711509705,
0.2424781322479248,
-0.41534703969955444,
-0.03962549939751625,
-0.1102791354060173,
-0.6192651391029358,
-0.45479971170425415,
-0.22110499441623688,
0.39583373069763184,
0.6019105315208435,
-0.259154349565506,
0.5693584680557251,
0.7878424525260925,
-0.6157156825065613,
0.12502627074718475,
-0.8489519357681274,
0.2795030176639557,
-0.33390235900878906,
-0.7183627486228943,
-0.1797618567943573,
-0.18916679918766022,
-0.6345959901809692,
0.04404111206531525,
0.433818519115448,
-0.3746492266654968,
0.0794941782951355,
0.3985864222049713,
0.23062381148338318,
-0.5259957313537598,
-0.13952776789665222,
-0.2893739342689514,
-0.1178072914481163,
0.3109864890575409,
-0.30311864614486694,
0.32817599177360535,
0.01007651723921299,
-0.4153802692890167,
-0.5491288304328918,
0.7666028738021851,
0.7061200141906738,
-0.4018338620662689,
0.49360981583595276,
0.5744057297706604,
-0.32497692108154297,
0.025311581790447235,
-0.35647812485694885,
0.15561318397521973,
-0.4269745945930481,
0.07227304577827454,
-0.27797868847846985,
-0.6348515748977661,
0.562771737575531,
-0.39407387375831604,
0.05424117669463158,
0.6255919933319092,
0.5708657503128052,
-0.04128245264291763,
1.065843105316162,
0.6409929990768433,
-0.43534815311431885,
0.1972050666809082,
-0.5635603666305542,
0.7359236478805542,
-0.24016401171684265,
-0.13876697421073914,
-0.836285412311554,
-0.254850834608078,
-0.677932858467102,
-0.23762108385562897,
0.6766051054000854,
-0.3044965863227844,
0.07525813579559326,
0.004422150086611509,
-0.5160385966300964,
0.41877567768096924,
0.9987084865570068,
-0.3511429727077484,
0.10857244580984116,
0.2688709795475006,
0.0707862600684166,
-0.12889884412288666,
-0.5810735821723938,
-0.6410393714904785,
1.1383881568908691,
0.18795615434646606,
0.45861947536468506,
0.08610276877880096,
0.5312190651893616,
0.5739045143127441,
0.16738760471343994,
-0.4405466616153717,
0.5463351607322693,
0.05365724116563797,
-0.25503310561180115,
-0.5973849892616272,
-0.045675408095121384,
-0.749621570110321,
-0.09323729574680328,
-0.29217231273651123,
-0.3922163248062134,
-0.0745764970779419,
0.14744454622268677,
-0.23551999032497406,
0.18223634362220764,
-0.8807300329208374,
0.592491626739502,
-0.2997641861438751,
0.030261432752013206,
-0.38259992003440857,
-0.6077933311462402,
0.1616329848766327,
-0.11291191726922989,
0.6212912201881409,
-0.17111152410507202,
0.4621328115463257,
0.588376522064209,
-0.13218775391578674,
0.538174569606781,
-0.3861014246940613,
-0.13762542605400085,
0.40126603841781616,
0.23556852340698242,
0.2606680989265442,
0.1395847201347351,
-0.48401373624801636,
0.620278537273407,
-0.4171125292778015,
-0.23130637407302856,
-0.3353893458843231,
0.7693364024162292,
-0.8922654390335083,
-0.6653642058372498,
-0.18439452350139618,
-0.8556326031684875,
0.2486303448677063,
0.12303958833217621,
-0.10942739248275757,
0.421003133058548,
-0.07527317851781845,
-0.5351961851119995,
0.29337775707244873,
-0.34664928913116455,
0.43866342306137085,
0.5351329445838928,
-0.10123983770608902,
-0.023955630138516426,
0.9499459862709045,
0.2370416522026062,
-0.42858853936195374,
0.21358968317508698,
0.11618639528751373,
-0.37026581168174744,
-0.8946000337600708,
-0.6298682689666748,
0.4110565483570099,
-0.767092227935791,
-0.10216990113258362,
-0.34900227189064026,
-0.3050146698951721,
-0.7459470629692078,
-0.5203046202659607,
0.22031135857105255,
-0.5969241857528687,
-0.030024565756320953,
-0.15063169598579407,
0.49541178345680237,
1.2340521812438965,
-0.21209824085235596,
0.257742702960968,
-0.604048490524292,
0.5038813352584839,
-0.09653201699256897,
-0.06865912675857544,
-0.2673242390155792,
0.004371991381049156,
-0.4244441092014313,
0.1291320025920868,
-0.26814013719558716,
-0.7600626945495605,
0.614759624004364,
0.19985710084438324,
0.6307244896888733,
0.17847511172294617,
-0.4428243041038513,
0.6123162508010864,
-0.7543199062347412,
1.0336710214614868,
-0.2775397300720215,
-0.7662891149520874,
0.7554250359535217,
-0.8223282694816589,
0.6629441380500793,
0.1741124838590622,
0.44487181305885315,
-0.34012600779533386,
-1.081657886505127,
-0.4190998077392578,
-0.9931378960609436,
0.7321245670318604,
0.01533520594239235,
-0.018412956967949867,
0.07771522551774979,
0.2907978594303131,
0.27271705865859985,
-0.10100685060024261,
-0.6797073483467102,
-0.09077509492635727,
-0.29389628767967224,
-0.27406370639801025,
-0.06811840832233429,
-0.027613196521997452,
-0.2274470031261444,
-0.5479162335395813,
0.6361584663391113,
-0.0332922525703907,
0.2773856222629547,
-0.09769290685653687,
-0.24253489077091217,
0.046297039836645126,
0.08489910513162613,
0.6732844114303589,
1.1906667947769165,
0.24498853087425232,
0.0262161772698164,
-0.027837706729769707,
-0.23733483254909515,
-0.04974332079291344,
0.3594657778739929,
-0.38377827405929565,
0.18578454852104187,
0.6398424506187439,
0.8361730575561523,
-0.14276787638664246,
-0.7574493288993835,
0.23939654231071472,
0.11987157166004181,
-0.3045855462551117,
-0.6145304441452026,
-0.10931754112243652,
0.24118095636367798,
0.16192446649074554,
0.3014408349990845,
-0.11749639362096786,
0.21319200098514557,
-0.418667197227478,
0.05934913083910942,
0.3352716565132141,
0.44517087936401367,
-0.5045871734619141,
0.8879683017730713,
0.34216830134391785,
-0.6297155022621155,
1.199995994567871,
-0.12456861883401871,
-0.5674517750740051,
0.7484698295593262,
0.46089857816696167,
0.41839954257011414,
-0.38235026597976685,
0.38692063093185425,
0.3312888741493225,
0.31794989109039307,
0.28415247797966003,
0.17268072068691254,
-0.15594814717769623,
-0.3741922080516815,
-0.08883073180913925,
-0.46734726428985596,
-0.28380435705184937,
-0.10396763682365417,
-0.09995073825120926,
0.17644675076007843,
-0.18470604717731476,
-0.10384686291217804,
-0.02409415878355503,
-0.19172075390815735,
-1.011939287185669,
0.2619513273239136,
0.43412402272224426,
0.6063517928123474,
-1.07829749584198,
0.7637732028961182,
0.7461007833480835,
-0.45411086082458496,
-0.8277139663696289,
-0.13353028893470764,
0.06969743967056274,
-0.8805294632911682,
0.6345673203468323,
-0.1140163242816925,
-0.08869753777980804,
-0.07627016305923462,
-0.4008694887161255,
-0.8007156252861023,
1.072182297706604,
0.3876461982727051,
-0.24168284237384796,
-0.3309932351112366,
0.7325167059898376,
1.0053406953811646,
-0.2253304421901703,
0.5880098938941956,
0.7218446731567383,
0.835159957408905,
-0.33071720600128174,
-0.8945399522781372,
-0.1524728685617447,
-0.3830680549144745,
-0.051453277468681335,
0.1430140882730484,
-0.21838851273059845,
0.5901381969451904,
-0.1318872720003128,
-0.41393986344337463,
0.05896708741784096,
0.5001114010810852,
0.13507148623466492,
0.25510698556900024,
0.13825269043445587,
0.5928025245666504,
0.6885281205177307,
-0.4387786090373993,
1.2123043537139893,
-0.4011785089969635,
-0.09116192162036896,
0.8167537450790405,
-0.15402092039585114,
0.517390787601471,
0.14704012870788574,
0.013470853678882122,
0.7489522099494934,
0.45678800344467163,
-0.11487868428230286,
0.2840881943702698,
0.18488864600658417,
-0.17596904933452606,
0.2080744355916977,
-0.23915530741214752,
-0.10732390731573105,
0.6221957206726074,
0.5087285041809082,
-0.07941876351833344,
-0.35474807024002075,
0.12719854712486267,
0.08920002728700638,
0.39399978518486023,
-0.072591632604599,
0.772007405757904,
-0.2807905375957489,
-0.8842854499816895,
0.4831213355064392,
0.06486313045024872,
0.31429171562194824,
-0.6278186440467834,
-0.2543829083442688,
-0.4752306342124939,
-0.2356518805027008,
-0.012367715127766132,
-0.9369263052940369,
0.5129130482673645,
0.05451415106654167,
-0.03335446119308472,
-0.5178534984588623,
0.2945095896720886,
-0.6790844798088074,
-0.32962390780448914,
0.27320581674575806,
0.5275602340698242,
0.4762069880962372,
0.2780741751194,
-0.5046976804733276,
0.16973315179347992,
-0.11219140887260437,
-0.025254083797335625,
-0.12004638463258743,
0.5544711351394653,
-0.525540292263031,
0.7332872748374939,
0.3785213530063629,
0.42570215463638306,
0.3328365087509155,
0.3183690905570984,
0.514042854309082,
-0.6179801821708679,
-0.511342465877533,
-0.7594792246818542,
0.5262156128883362,
0.03509572520852089,
-0.1752804070711136,
0.6902629733085632,
0.5930176973342896,
0.6091359257698059,
-0.2169073224067688,
1.1230665445327759,
-0.06283332407474518,
0.15724867582321167,
-0.28097841143608093,
1.1013984680175781,
-0.2267713099718094,
-0.03617490828037262,
0.1214413270354271,
-0.6009609699249268,
-0.4950184226036072,
0.18089519441127777,
-0.23839667439460754,
-0.13554809987545013,
0.6678128242492676,
0.7425265312194824,
-0.10014845430850983,
-0.1935155987739563,
0.03603867068886757,
0.1331750452518463,
0.644416332244873,
0.5554038882255554,
0.6227479577064514,
-0.12561792135238647,
0.3898770213127136,
-0.0350276418030262,
-0.2515237629413605,
0.08374606817960739,
-0.4463256895542145,
-0.7444488406181335,
-0.8629093766212463,
-0.2140047550201416,
0.4818589985370636,
-0.007743360474705696,
0.09547098726034164,
0.8682079911231995,
-0.5553281903266907,
-0.3416244685649872,
0.10806009918451309,
0.1704263687133789,
0.1244792491197586,
-0.2567911446094513,
0.3159858286380768,
0.03798419609665871,
-0.9666252136230469,
0.678072988986969,
0.5256711840629578,
0.113265760242939,
-0.4869877099990845,
-0.15920595824718475,
-0.3937493860721588,
-0.05781099945306778,
0.25818929076194763,
0.39199891686439514,
-0.9162583351135254,
-0.10756667703390121,
-0.5447344183921814,
-0.04604430869221687,
0.12526778876781464,
0.8425284028053284,
-0.8260416388511658,
0.32647955417633057,
0.5816478133201599,
0.583674967288971,
0.37894806265830994,
-0.00029006562544964254,
0.8513246178627014,
-0.6027976274490356,
0.37063872814178467,
0.03737155348062515,
0.3336431384086609,
0.7224875092506409,
-0.6092467904090881,
0.6511020064353943,
0.13026824593544006,
-0.7127171754837036,
-0.4779552221298218,
-0.005571895278990269,
-0.7360419034957886,
0.06474941968917847,
1.023034691810608,
-0.17723974585533142,
-0.06009233370423317,
-0.22572243213653564,
-0.2696906626224518,
0.3773302733898163,
-0.18841642141342163,
0.9882948398590088,
0.781822144985199,
-0.17932039499282837,
0.0804145559668541,
-0.6918424367904663,
0.3845849633216858,
0.054218269884586334,
-1.0641251802444458,
-0.15979595482349396,
0.6728883385658264,
0.08751969784498215,
0.371482253074646,
0.9931789040565491,
0.09647037088871002,
0.2014155089855194,
0.08607753366231918,
0.038873229175806046,
0.06709830462932587,
-0.46067139506340027,
-0.2247546911239624,
0.17922215163707733,
0.23469507694244385,
0.15543076395988464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01261v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01261v1
|
FABLES: Evaluating faithfulness and content selection in book-length summarization
| 2024-04-01T17:33:38 | 2024-04-01T17:33:38 |
Yekyung Kim, Yapei Chang, Marzena Karpinska, Aparna Garimella, Varun Manjunatha, Kyle Lo, Tanya Goyal, Mohit Iyyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While long-context large language models (LLMs) can technically summarize
book-length documents (>100K tokens), the length and complexity of the
documents have so far prohibited evaluations of input-dependent aspects like
faithfulness. In this paper, we conduct the first large-scale human evaluation
of faithfulness and content selection on LLM-generated summaries of fictional
books. Our study mitigates the issue of data contamination by focusing on
summaries of books published in 2023 or 2024, and we hire annotators who have
fully read each book prior to the annotation task to minimize cost and
cognitive burden. We collect FABLES, a dataset of annotations on 3,158 claims
made in LLM-generated summaries of 26 books, at a cost of $5.2K USD, which
allows us to rank LLM summarizers based on faithfulness: Claude-3-Opus
significantly outperforms all closed-source LLMs, while the open-source Mixtral
is on par with GPT-3.5-Turbo. An analysis of the annotations reveals that most
unfaithful claims relate to events and character states, and they generally
require indirect reasoning over the narrative to invalidate. While LLM-based
auto-raters have proven reliable for factuality and coherence in other
settings, we implement several LLM raters of faithfulness and find that none
correlates strongly with human annotations, especially with regard to detecting
unfaithful claims. Our experiments suggest that detecting unfaithful claims is
an important future direction not only for summarization evaluation but also as
a testbed for long-context understanding. Finally, we move beyond faithfulness
by exploring content selection errors in book-length summarization: we develop
a typology of omission errors related to crucial narrative elements and also
identify a systematic over-emphasis on events occurring towards the end of the
book.
|
[
-0.359150767326355,
-0.312776118516922,
0.5334103107452393,
0.31619563698768616,
-0.5761896967887878,
0.04646497964859009,
-0.013962049037218094,
-0.7559725642204285,
0.06653496623039246,
0.6127088069915771,
-0.2844356596469879,
-0.22565406560897827,
-0.5809445977210999,
0.4619137644767761,
-0.30939123034477234,
1.2283453941345215,
-0.03537020459771156,
-0.1322762370109558,
-0.5614951252937317,
-0.16148550808429718,
-0.2561291754245758,
-0.21921607851982117,
-0.27555426955223083,
-0.4054320752620697,
0.3485664129257202,
-0.14821304380893707,
0.8688599467277527,
0.7261847257614136,
0.4271981716156006,
0.28904297947883606,
-0.3637053370475769,
0.46950507164001465,
-0.7586987018585205,
0.19394972920417786,
-0.2804466485977173,
-0.4737469255924225,
-0.5327084064483643,
0.10575533658266068,
0.5914392471313477,
0.43324014544487,
0.17177775502204895,
0.41812464594841003,
0.2845335900783539,
0.7851568460464478,
-0.7299102544784546,
0.25441721081733704,
-0.35751062631607056,
0.06145457923412323,
-0.21211554110050201,
-0.10461124777793884,
-0.4644094705581665,
-0.6304815411567688,
0.30503222346305847,
-0.5607068538665771,
0.2124517410993576,
0.2531265616416931,
0.7248239517211914,
0.1381320059299469,
-0.3500968813896179,
-0.42009419202804565,
-0.4496525228023529,
1.1095576286315918,
-0.6245946884155273,
0.34105056524276733,
0.745220422744751,
-0.1712874174118042,
-0.20056195557117462,
-0.578133761882782,
-0.3662920892238617,
-0.36740928888320923,
-0.2198009192943573,
0.3864727020263672,
-0.4173389971256256,
-0.09113675355911255,
0.2096746563911438,
0.5403081178665161,
-0.3948502838611603,
-0.23091797530651093,
-0.3516235947608948,
-0.4926424026489258,
0.8674203157424927,
0.19420555233955383,
0.3480912446975708,
-0.167596235871315,
-0.26623302698135376,
-0.047428250312805176,
-0.635184645652771,
0.0906638354063034,
0.4206547141075134,
-0.31302040815353394,
0.12004386633634567,
0.6986549496650696,
0.1962011456489563,
0.45379921793937683,
-0.10870154201984406,
-0.6083142161369324,
0.09899494051933289,
-0.5045864582061768,
-0.2530464231967926,
0.2976283133029938,
0.7543056011199951,
0.6795174479484558,
0.3619532287120819,
-0.299092561006546,
-0.29710304737091064,
-0.057461269199848175,
0.28760188817977905,
-0.6403536200523376,
0.17935556173324585,
0.25883978605270386,
-0.5727762579917908,
-0.3446616530418396,
0.017384355887770653,
-0.6349620819091797,
-0.6030233502388,
-0.21898774802684784,
0.2331278920173645,
-0.7063372135162354,
0.10250849276781082,
0.11306007206439972,
-0.36851415038108826,
0.1358874887228012,
0.5518746376037598,
-0.6858906149864197,
0.24735906720161438,
0.6606214046478271,
0.8740118741989136,
-0.39622795581817627,
-0.6291638612747192,
-0.5434369444847107,
0.4842340052127838,
-0.629933774471283,
0.7391486167907715,
-0.16148419678211212,
-0.5349038243293762,
-0.08977778255939484,
-0.21213316917419434,
0.2667262554168701,
-0.32830432057380676,
0.9426916837692261,
-0.6745150089263916,
-0.03735107555985451,
-0.5075280666351318,
-0.6558554172515869,
-0.24439504742622375,
0.3060011863708496,
-0.8329797983169556,
0.6550115942955017,
0.10250210016965866,
-0.9491854906082153,
0.3473162353038788,
-0.20254266262054443,
-0.5607053637504578,
-0.16843588650226593,
0.05989200249314308,
-0.37238574028015137,
0.18200543522834778,
0.2535102069377899,
0.11900060623884201,
-0.3628850281238556,
0.2292180359363556,
-0.13282953202724457,
-0.7259030938148499,
0.4983927309513092,
-0.6074700355529785,
0.7922164797782898,
0.14977407455444336,
-0.15163707733154297,
-0.3881818354129791,
-0.2542355954647064,
-0.1757023185491562,
0.12336243689060211,
-0.31313997507095337,
-0.594278872013092,
0.05377441644668579,
-0.05252156779170036,
-0.34848839044570923,
0.29307857155799866,
-0.5472427606582642,
0.27761420607566833,
-0.5112432837486267,
0.007739214692264795,
0.5801158547401428,
0.13164132833480835,
0.1525491327047348,
-0.7891762852668762,
0.3568606674671173,
-0.04968314617872238,
0.2707676887512207,
-0.4859693646430969,
-0.41333240270614624,
-0.4559725224971771,
-0.31829553842544556,
0.4597947597503662,
0.45866715908050537,
-0.43477848172187805,
0.4590291976928711,
-0.34821006655693054,
-0.49996617436408997,
-0.2306138575077057,
0.14191529154777527,
0.7667418122291565,
0.22141636908054352,
0.3454074263572693,
-0.3105102777481079,
-0.17048177123069763,
-0.9801024198532104,
-0.7095996141433716,
-0.4202558398246765,
-0.19563134014606476,
0.051025185734033585,
0.5440084338188171,
-0.1260000616312027,
1.163417100906372,
-0.5504394173622131,
-0.4248768985271454,
-0.21097061038017273,
0.29115647077560425,
-0.023223113268613815,
0.20809707045555115,
0.7881108522415161,
-0.7602618336677551,
-0.2670891582965851,
-0.1064363569021225,
-0.8743978142738342,
-0.10957284271717072,
0.055445507168769836,
0.047452326864004135,
0.30039477348327637,
0.3165615200996399,
-0.41266024112701416,
0.500861644744873,
0.3060809075832367,
-0.35033077001571655,
0.6241270303726196,
-0.16932272911071777,
0.44631290435791016,
-0.7722768187522888,
-0.1727989912033081,
-0.09759897738695145,
-0.28996434807777405,
0.007914458401501179,
-0.13148871064186096,
0.09410427510738373,
0.376830130815506,
-0.21348819136619568,
0.46091413497924805,
-0.5215855836868286,
-0.04882783815264702,
0.05648426711559296,
0.18543076515197754,
0.2752600610256195,
0.23789644241333008,
-0.2572457194328308,
0.8846778869628906,
0.05670490115880966,
-0.3917674124240875,
0.32543912529945374,
0.5463544726371765,
-0.19269119203090668,
0.4185870587825775,
-0.4122723937034607,
0.018321556970477104,
-0.16143937408924103,
0.4156566262245178,
-0.9018193483352661,
-0.3527260422706604,
0.1194382905960083,
-0.43137219548225403,
0.2614474594593048,
-0.2570662498474121,
-0.6195054650306702,
0.09239060431718826,
-0.8738242983818054,
0.35622796416282654,
0.5063409209251404,
-0.3154538869857788,
0.7910205125808716,
0.31604108214378357,
-0.24165114760398865,
-0.7783927917480469,
-0.8659411668777466,
0.34442952275276184,
0.03277895972132683,
-0.5486195087432861,
0.3048429787158966,
-0.22781382501125336,
-0.4613613784313202,
-0.02083641290664673,
-0.28201761841773987,
0.09415054321289062,
-0.20226091146469116,
0.19242876768112183,
0.23267778754234314,
-0.05238337069749832,
-0.07361763715744019,
0.4162547290325165,
-0.03869353607296944,
0.1975148469209671,
-0.21344482898712158,
0.15579484403133392,
-0.44960781931877136,
-0.5058823227882385,
-0.18543089926242828,
0.2634839117527008,
0.6622336506843567,
-0.40755006670951843,
0.4201188385486603,
0.42220109701156616,
-0.40250471234321594,
0.04605010151863098,
-0.9663819670677185,
0.25179967284202576,
-0.3710343539714813,
0.2684920132160187,
-0.023593727499246597,
-0.7176219820976257,
0.6182725429534912,
0.11682957410812378,
0.308060884475708,
0.6192929744720459,
0.2585671544075012,
-0.05549313873052597,
0.6502693295478821,
0.32121291756629944,
-0.1854594349861145,
0.11811129003763199,
-0.052732620388269424,
-0.12222356349229813,
-0.7231355309486389,
-0.15038441121578217,
-0.2143985480070114,
-0.06833016872406006,
-0.4541252851486206,
-0.22063285112380981,
0.47564896941185,
0.2160009890794754,
0.08788412064313889,
0.013471019454300404,
-0.07225439697504044,
0.8831745982170105,
0.3830133080482483,
0.189138725399971,
0.859707772731781,
-0.1024298295378685,
-0.03751765564084053,
-0.3011055886745453,
-0.12116246670484543,
-0.7795101404190063,
1.2437082529067993,
0.3113135099411011,
0.6065686941146851,
0.34166285395622253,
0.5666393041610718,
0.7554309964179993,
0.5495786070823669,
-0.6340842843055725,
0.37511390447616577,
-0.07038988918066025,
-0.5451262593269348,
-0.4192882478237152,
-0.20115001499652863,
-0.682914137840271,
0.18131263554096222,
-0.11129216104745865,
-0.7223096489906311,
0.2508067786693573,
-0.07626727223396301,
-0.44037818908691406,
0.2885919213294983,
-0.42696431279182434,
0.4552980661392212,
-0.3145126700401306,
-0.4876769185066223,
-0.1285676509141922,
-0.6827136874198914,
0.6542304158210754,
-0.4675324559211731,
0.05617184564471245,
0.2390909641981125,
-0.30012956261634827,
0.7787410616874695,
-0.14328533411026,
0.6329140067100525,
0.34963637590408325,
-0.30565330386161804,
0.3887130618095398,
0.6065346002578735,
0.42398977279663086,
0.36955752968788147,
-0.16969378292560577,
0.27078986167907715,
0.40117645263671875,
-0.20671385526657104,
-0.5024388432502747,
0.3139760196208954,
-0.6531251072883606,
-0.3989199101924896,
-0.8112877011299133,
-0.49044764041900635,
-0.3268465995788574,
0.32975780963897705,
0.4942905008792877,
0.4705459475517273,
-0.44446054100990295,
0.24185943603515625,
0.9948891401290894,
-0.3197709321975708,
0.4434814155101776,
0.43053725361824036,
-0.3788629174232483,
-0.7837406992912292,
0.8634845614433289,
0.06202420964837074,
0.11941789835691452,
0.1489177644252777,
0.1702682077884674,
-0.2931641638278961,
-0.8099194169044495,
-0.49069735407829285,
0.26468971371650696,
-0.6311072111129761,
-0.3604985773563385,
-0.6526238322257996,
-0.2116759866476059,
-0.11826480180025101,
-0.14745314419269562,
-0.590033233165741,
0.03189057484269142,
-0.21534647047519684,
-0.06420375406742096,
0.13119414448738098,
0.9845826625823975,
0.1033351719379425,
0.07993427664041519,
-1.0661731958389282,
0.3908470869064331,
0.22245892882347107,
0.3089105188846588,
-0.06146513670682907,
-0.5372098684310913,
-0.129081591963768,
-0.04424454644322395,
-0.4575345814228058,
-0.8738337159156799,
0.28303977847099304,
0.005749160889536142,
0.2742142677307129,
0.7622584700584412,
0.3699122965335846,
0.5361817479133606,
-0.22164922952651978,
0.9369176626205444,
0.11118220537900925,
-1.065232515335083,
0.3223028779029846,
-0.541504979133606,
-0.03496452420949936,
0.734824001789093,
0.27992767095565796,
-0.4287806451320648,
-0.5602061152458191,
-0.5191468596458435,
-0.6385685801506042,
0.7477084398269653,
0.5494933724403381,
0.17164064943790436,
0.03723428025841713,
0.590010941028595,
0.35556864738464355,
0.34255293011665344,
-0.6954189538955688,
-0.3828761875629425,
-0.06579627096652985,
-0.009072698652744293,
-0.08456331491470337,
-0.7315424680709839,
-0.26238423585891724,
-0.16422690451145172,
0.550768256187439,
-0.061966102570295334,
-0.041265737265348434,
0.4968055486679077,
-0.32321518659591675,
-0.3250061869621277,
0.18401502072811127,
0.6769737005233765,
1.2289159297943115,
-0.28543901443481445,
-0.0665203258395195,
0.3512990474700928,
-0.8776541948318481,
0.01789015159010887,
0.0795888751745224,
-0.26379159092903137,
0.033969730138778687,
0.9549752473831177,
0.2882865369319916,
0.24824455380439758,
-0.8280792832374573,
0.9182333946228027,
-0.2879992127418518,
-0.02680588699877262,
-0.5785481333732605,
-0.0012264699907973409,
0.014300592243671417,
0.39279705286026,
0.46855807304382324,
-0.032444871962070465,
0.22702528536319733,
-0.433172345161438,
0.07983770966529846,
0.2998473346233368,
-0.24952378869056702,
-0.16946391761302948,
0.4762161374092102,
-0.05548492819070816,
-0.03154239431023598,
0.6156148910522461,
-0.4482751488685608,
-0.5332475900650024,
0.3395894765853882,
0.440682053565979,
0.7693086266517639,
-0.06946877390146255,
0.14379897713661194,
-0.04641184210777283,
0.6920261979103088,
-0.3329645097255707,
-0.056275706738233566,
0.16566066443920135,
-0.5130361318588257,
-0.49559399485588074,
-0.8089942932128906,
-0.562822163105011,
0.22252973914146423,
-0.6098834872245789,
0.24002280831336975,
-0.06518280506134033,
-0.02357245236635208,
-0.33682066202163696,
0.07959826290607452,
-0.15344084799289703,
0.12248150259256363,
0.0877077579498291,
0.9122279286384583,
-0.6363680362701416,
0.2270369976758957,
0.3984659016132355,
-0.5943290591239929,
-0.4116125702857971,
0.3250564932823181,
-0.016347715631127357,
-0.49927136301994324,
0.3545033037662506,
-0.1446104794740677,
-0.14845792949199677,
-0.10854135453701019,
-0.6443986296653748,
-0.5760502815246582,
1.3553351163864136,
0.8744754791259766,
-0.3718835115432739,
-0.10070746392011642,
0.04808754473924637,
0.5356199741363525,
-0.08347558975219727,
0.32392823696136475,
0.5680680871009827,
0.5264645218849182,
0.1811540573835373,
-0.9084501266479492,
-0.034924764186143875,
-0.03688335418701172,
-0.15409229695796967,
0.07263904809951782,
-0.7105525732040405,
0.7243027687072754,
-0.19829320907592773,
0.050812527537345886,
0.15292254090309143,
0.79137122631073,
0.45913165807724,
0.6590061783790588,
0.4595976769924164,
0.40535423159599304,
0.6956457495689392,
-0.03427540883421898,
1.1660501956939697,
-0.08220937848091125,
0.2723122239112854,
0.8720391988754272,
-0.06047268956899643,
0.475859671831131,
0.3136040270328522,
-0.4032537341117859,
0.15898913145065308,
0.6853501796722412,
-0.17035730183124542,
0.26508983969688416,
0.12070727348327637,
-0.20907336473464966,
-0.2184145152568817,
-0.22955013811588287,
-0.44881880283355713,
0.35932448506355286,
0.0888538658618927,
-0.46450650691986084,
-0.2494194507598877,
-0.24290817975997925,
0.3530074954032898,
-0.06209033355116844,
-0.292948842048645,
0.7381534576416016,
0.2831772565841675,
-0.8023241758346558,
0.18478156626224518,
0.09748063236474991,
0.4705582857131958,
-0.8147965669631958,
-0.08556481450796127,
-0.4632384181022644,
0.02380475215613842,
-0.26921191811561584,
-0.7290215492248535,
0.12409018725156784,
0.07704850286245346,
-0.18386411666870117,
-0.08229366689920425,
0.7131543159484863,
-0.18032985925674438,
-0.46943169832229614,
0.2256776988506317,
0.5186951756477356,
0.14186857640743256,
-0.373909592628479,
-0.17877498269081116,
0.1009942963719368,
-0.07505029439926147,
-0.47059282660484314,
0.3409670889377594,
0.5799303650856018,
-0.22650840878486633,
0.5783427953720093,
0.6389918923377991,
0.23968592286109924,
-0.4034416675567627,
-0.18833929300308228,
0.894758939743042,
-0.5758988857269287,
-0.6295518279075623,
-1.116281270980835,
0.2557470202445984,
-0.07828975468873978,
-0.3004530966281891,
0.7957020998001099,
0.858456015586853,
0.5962513089179993,
-0.05711327865719795,
0.9316480159759521,
0.3283189833164215,
0.14016740024089813,
-0.5408979058265686,
0.9610936641693115,
-0.5006912350654602,
0.33155718445777893,
-0.6099976897239685,
-1.0972986221313477,
-0.06504420936107635,
0.23398704826831818,
-0.18410055339336395,
0.04669993743300438,
0.770902156829834,
0.20775654911994934,
-0.08460097014904022,
0.5054288506507874,
0.17243458330631256,
0.14263682067394257,
0.12719136476516724,
0.26116707921028137,
1.0383296012878418,
-0.40981030464172363,
0.6152066588401794,
0.0705774798989296,
-0.3217066824436188,
-0.10011163353919983,
-1.1827703714370728,
-0.9786697030067444,
-0.4530464708805084,
-0.15327805280685425,
-0.4230128228664398,
0.15965446829795837,
0.7405766844749451,
-0.02701875939965248,
-0.5805456042289734,
-0.10879433900117874,
0.261231392621994,
0.21452292799949646,
-0.20849408209323883,
-0.134945809841156,
0.5270740985870361,
-0.15081025660037994,
-0.5819198489189148,
0.12386512011289597,
0.367395281791687,
0.12426727265119553,
-0.3775029182434082,
-0.12041611224412918,
0.18765151500701904,
0.2331019639968872,
0.6883617043495178,
-0.08699405193328857,
-0.736042320728302,
-0.16326215863227844,
-0.15566200017929077,
-0.02136368118226528,
-0.058543648570775986,
0.7785988450050354,
-0.4961456060409546,
0.3004390001296997,
0.25847211480140686,
0.640936553478241,
0.41785743832588196,
0.17476032674312592,
0.5356700420379639,
-0.47716546058654785,
-0.33816489577293396,
0.3977017402648926,
0.4016994535923004,
0.12339255213737488,
-0.46514269709587097,
0.44761922955513,
0.32051724195480347,
-0.5186636447906494,
-0.9741570353507996,
0.042116258293390274,
-1.002005696296692,
-0.12144841253757477,
1.1077147722244263,
-0.27895405888557434,
-0.3635880649089813,
-0.312500536441803,
-0.31124022603034973,
0.2702912986278534,
-0.2600664496421814,
0.8339176774024963,
1.107741117477417,
-0.23062869906425476,
0.34920889139175415,
-0.6145915985107422,
0.6397401094436646,
0.06648030132055283,
-0.6943869590759277,
0.45907026529312134,
0.7127423882484436,
0.24133256077766418,
0.4610080122947693,
0.4938974976539612,
-0.38952600955963135,
0.20574039220809937,
-0.11119864881038666,
-0.117927186191082,
-0.4652675986289978,
-0.0613446943461895,
-0.1700037270784378,
0.07695896178483963,
-0.06942965090274811,
0.1767195165157318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01253v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01253v1
|
UniArk: Improving Generalisation and Consistency for Factual Knowledge Extraction through Debiasing
| 2024-04-01T17:22:07 | 2024-04-01T17:22:07 |
Yijun Yang, Jie He, Pinzhen Chen, Víctor Gutiérrez-Basulto, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Several recent papers have investigated the potential of language models as
knowledge bases as well as the existence of severe biases when extracting
factual knowledge. In this work, we focus on the factual probing performance
over unseen prompts from tuning, and using a probabilistic view we show the
inherent misalignment between pre-training and downstream tuning objectives in
language models for probing knowledge. We hypothesize that simultaneously
debiasing these objectives can be the key to generalisation over unseen
prompts. We propose an adapter-based framework, UniArk, for generalised and
consistent factual knowledge extraction through simple methods without
introducing extra parameters. Extensive experiments show that UniArk can
significantly improve the model's out-of-domain generalisation as well as
consistency under various prompts. Additionally, we construct ParaTrex, a
large-scale and diverse dataset for measuring the inconsistency and
out-of-domain generation of models. Further, ParaTrex offers a reference method
for constructing paraphrased datasets using large language models.
|
[
-0.11854851990938187,
-0.6196211576461792,
0.6706809997558594,
0.037868134677410126,
-0.18117517232894897,
-0.09538791328668594,
-0.34799763560295105,
-0.11043979227542877,
-0.10282563418149948,
0.6249814033508301,
-0.2510066628456116,
-0.5268251299858093,
-0.6558716893196106,
-0.04368862509727478,
-0.5000291466712952,
0.984089195728302,
0.08843395859003067,
-0.004142413381487131,
-0.16926011443138123,
-0.3731508255004883,
-0.3560166358947754,
-0.2946837544441223,
-0.2996754050254822,
-0.25247013568878174,
0.1673947423696518,
0.5779288411140442,
0.7597992420196533,
0.4577363133430481,
0.2837798595428467,
0.20851583778858185,
0.019901776686310768,
0.3103923499584198,
-0.2251962274312973,
0.233353391289711,
-0.5755729675292969,
-0.4567638337612152,
0.02154197357594967,
0.03799554333090782,
0.6732146739959717,
0.9227297306060791,
-0.28069645166397095,
0.18493232131004333,
0.3535955548286438,
0.5280113816261292,
-0.8808553218841553,
0.2646370232105255,
-0.7096146941184998,
-0.3512246310710907,
-0.06485561281442642,
-0.028425343334674835,
-0.34652838110923767,
-0.4888328015804291,
0.1728869378566742,
-0.9536586999893188,
0.4737761318683624,
0.13716602325439453,
0.7598492503166199,
0.48163506388664246,
-0.5054823756217957,
-0.2742876410484314,
-0.8739625215530396,
0.8375642895698547,
-0.8814737200737,
0.5351889729499817,
0.2360454797744751,
0.25378021597862244,
-0.1835666000843048,
-0.7651524543762207,
-0.6700091361999512,
-0.14847104251384735,
-0.20254257321357727,
-0.03284482657909393,
-0.3860034942626953,
0.08168889582157135,
0.31407204270362854,
0.16846254467964172,
-0.3511452078819275,
-0.09465034306049347,
-0.3184373676776886,
-0.22038856148719788,
0.388542115688324,
-0.09431295096874237,
0.1042792871594429,
-0.15521924197673798,
-0.27834147214889526,
-0.11415969580411911,
-0.8142902851104736,
0.16274034976959229,
0.49978765845298767,
0.33484193682670593,
-0.015558289363980293,
0.38089698553085327,
-0.515101969242096,
0.7960261106491089,
0.3949841260910034,
0.11935047805309296,
0.033519990742206573,
-0.07090296596288681,
-0.09765941649675369,
-0.09552270919084549,
0.6769663095474243,
0.3849625587463379,
0.28454601764678955,
-0.37882834672927856,
-0.010903717018663883,
0.12972897291183472,
0.1556629091501236,
-0.43550369143486023,
-0.5422242879867554,
-0.0525037907063961,
-0.26852813363075256,
-0.4236627519130707,
0.04032866656780243,
-1.321000576019287,
-0.5394573211669922,
-0.4113333523273468,
0.46119925379753113,
-0.2695208489894867,
-0.38232114911079407,
0.30325260758399963,
-0.1074325367808342,
0.11298447847366333,
0.1353396624326706,
-0.935766875743866,
0.24857500195503235,
0.381700724363327,
0.3796576261520386,
-0.010203298181295395,
-0.02022080309689045,
-0.7020446062088013,
0.11182578653097153,
-0.48271483182907104,
0.9126746654510498,
-0.7564244270324707,
-0.24756233394145966,
-0.10668671876192093,
-0.05894850939512253,
-0.06551743298768997,
-0.6652033925056458,
0.8395966291427612,
-0.6852734684944153,
0.17029955983161926,
-0.7476038336753845,
-0.5139374136924744,
-0.45095786452293396,
0.07007938623428345,
-0.5292545557022095,
1.0169130563735962,
0.058035921305418015,
-0.8023943305015564,
0.5915794968605042,
-0.6408860087394714,
-0.14179886877536774,
-0.1769443154335022,
-0.24410265684127808,
-0.06218063458800316,
0.3666858673095703,
0.45809406042099,
0.14604896306991577,
-0.6151179075241089,
0.7373310327529907,
-0.4475911259651184,
-0.08800070732831955,
0.2001180201768875,
-0.6180931329727173,
0.70448899269104,
0.3027690649032593,
-0.5883750915527344,
-0.2742137610912323,
-0.9719484448432922,
-0.09750480204820633,
-0.317742258310318,
-0.37893998622894287,
-0.6948109269142151,
0.002737377304583788,
-0.18985359370708466,
-0.06576801836490631,
0.04648591950535774,
-0.8137412667274475,
0.07892651855945587,
-0.3619287610054016,
-0.012555384077131748,
0.5784106254577637,
0.10806603729724884,
0.455410361289978,
-0.13184185326099396,
0.4297804832458496,
0.23123851418495178,
-0.08936921507120132,
0.26456156373023987,
-0.22781579196453094,
-0.8485490679740906,
-0.2180139720439911,
0.8894624710083008,
0.42059317231178284,
-0.5909572839736938,
0.4269123375415802,
-0.18950234353542328,
-0.19628076255321503,
-0.7300854325294495,
0.35352814197540283,
0.4403930604457855,
0.9196003079414368,
0.4019060730934143,
-0.16333281993865967,
-0.6298044323921204,
-0.8801393508911133,
-0.7145816683769226,
-0.1134791374206543,
-0.09146346896886826,
-0.07127326726913452,
0.3095698058605194,
-0.3358306288719177,
1.07590913772583,
-0.48069268465042114,
0.0492296926677227,
-0.14907221496105194,
0.5185865759849548,
0.28439199924468994,
0.4572775363922119,
0.5099291801452637,
-0.7908381223678589,
-0.5099602937698364,
0.0448564775288105,
-1.0698131322860718,
-0.2504182755947113,
-0.025091424584388733,
0.019266711547970772,
-0.014526253566145897,
0.42856213450431824,
-0.7185888290405273,
0.45512598752975464,
0.22169876098632812,
-0.17344911396503448,
0.49217700958251953,
-0.06283646821975708,
0.2539813816547394,
-0.9852519631385803,
0.3635307550430298,
-0.06363754719495773,
-0.18938319385051727,
-0.4609535336494446,
-0.04466160014271736,
0.09485957026481628,
0.15804128348827362,
-0.06256773322820663,
0.6202580332756042,
-0.43981215357780457,
0.155171737074852,
-0.3459344208240509,
0.052314259111881256,
0.22003954648971558,
0.27261897921562195,
-0.028009949252009392,
0.659616231918335,
0.783229649066925,
-0.8346697688102722,
0.50458163022995,
0.3330358862876892,
-0.7444846034049988,
0.43265098333358765,
-0.6386561393737793,
0.03682452812790871,
-0.1342715471982956,
-0.10749287903308868,
-0.9589670300483704,
-0.28206387162208557,
0.2347639799118042,
-0.5268105864524841,
0.43393197655677795,
-0.3419867157936096,
-0.3138769268989563,
-0.0056230598129332066,
-0.023024652153253555,
0.3003764748573303,
0.7225268483161926,
-0.7669339179992676,
0.5580002665519714,
0.3214280605316162,
-0.17884643375873566,
-0.900248646736145,
-0.19783486425876617,
-0.13825774192810059,
-0.4532893896102905,
-0.24238549172878265,
-0.012217645533382893,
0.038815148174762726,
-0.6703521013259888,
0.07011735439300537,
-0.5402462482452393,
-0.17984923720359802,
-0.008092881180346012,
-0.011572286486625671,
-0.038436681032180786,
-0.28737398982048035,
0.0925373062491417,
0.274541974067688,
-0.06378564238548279,
0.2565988004207611,
-0.526828944683075,
0.07132045179605484,
0.15991203486919403,
-0.431639164686203,
-0.15081502497196198,
0.35190242528915405,
0.5620638728141785,
-0.04761652648448944,
0.5726169347763062,
0.3307592272758484,
-0.22113095223903656,
-0.19955697655677795,
-0.7161664962768555,
-0.22473634779453278,
-0.44726306200027466,
0.080498605966568,
-0.21437902748584747,
-0.6159074902534485,
0.5525978803634644,
-0.38649782538414,
0.12617596983909607,
0.610013484954834,
0.2626856863498688,
-0.21763095259666443,
0.9394216537475586,
0.9117422699928284,
-0.06628381460905075,
-0.1259816288948059,
0.13437917828559875,
0.09695549309253693,
-0.6301568746566772,
-0.11247161775827408,
-0.4754617214202881,
-0.1226990669965744,
-0.4329826831817627,
-0.05544840171933174,
0.5540980696678162,
0.2936682105064392,
0.029197247698903084,
0.0751032754778862,
-0.12155941873788834,
0.5061624646186829,
0.7142327427864075,
0.012314456515014172,
0.382048100233078,
0.20100431144237518,
-0.37357425689697266,
-0.11403339356184006,
-0.6489110589027405,
-0.5230509638786316,
1.6010990142822266,
-0.050509437918663025,
0.9644258618354797,
0.09630685299634933,
0.1994583010673523,
0.4400382936000824,
0.167741060256958,
-0.2881982624530792,
0.19464004039764404,
-0.05824491009116173,
-1.0484328269958496,
-0.15609346330165863,
-0.4518607556819916,
-0.7252398133277893,
0.10640906542539597,
-0.10295448452234268,
-0.6738759875297546,
0.6738378405570984,
0.38373318314552307,
-0.763617217540741,
0.40688857436180115,
-0.39246466755867004,
0.6530903577804565,
-0.04007451981306076,
-0.3142159581184387,
-0.115178681910038,
-0.7848566174507141,
0.41604864597320557,
-0.29095056653022766,
0.3247702419757843,
0.0433017797768116,
0.5171424150466919,
0.9490464329719543,
-0.11165836453437805,
1.0486719608306885,
-0.3995361328125,
-0.12285001575946808,
0.4502243995666504,
0.14561691880226135,
0.4740263819694519,
0.39177730679512024,
-0.041955072432756424,
0.061833418905735016,
0.12664340436458588,
-0.25979724526405334,
-0.874921441078186,
0.49030667543411255,
-0.7345680594444275,
-0.7143200635910034,
-0.4006997048854828,
-0.7288927435874939,
-0.7079135179519653,
0.09505452960729599,
0.4355563819408417,
0.7463304400444031,
-0.2905874252319336,
0.36078017950057983,
1.0697035789489746,
-0.08973822742700577,
0.07610969990491867,
0.8638824224472046,
0.007456181570887566,
-0.09314385801553726,
0.6481159925460815,
-0.10115567594766617,
-0.011813042685389519,
0.6065379977226257,
0.2569786310195923,
-0.6329468488693237,
-0.3687398135662079,
-0.3915095925331116,
-0.03317045420408249,
-0.7900827527046204,
-0.3493655323982239,
-0.6552832126617432,
0.1265791356563568,
-0.8088089227676392,
0.23228175938129425,
-0.3805168867111206,
-0.6118668913841248,
-0.19437052309513092,
-0.28495436906814575,
0.5061385035514832,
0.7477132678031921,
-0.8034123778343201,
0.5207943320274353,
-0.7137414216995239,
0.47199076414108276,
0.41315126419067383,
0.08497898280620575,
-0.41102662682533264,
-0.9924736022949219,
-0.18681658804416656,
0.36411982774734497,
-0.24736665189266205,
-0.9454861283302307,
0.31744498014450073,
0.14486064016819,
0.8492934703826904,
0.8247553110122681,
0.38253113627433777,
0.3838571608066559,
-0.12471682578325272,
0.3953435719013214,
-0.017972543835639954,
-0.8477724194526672,
0.37499403953552246,
-0.6078866124153137,
-0.10871902853250504,
0.9083260893821716,
0.6102897524833679,
-0.47535961866378784,
-0.03654911741614342,
-0.671460747718811,
-0.5136814713478088,
0.4485400319099426,
-0.04472958296537399,
-0.15388095378875732,
0.15608638525009155,
0.564978837966919,
0.49582424759864807,
0.5024048686027527,
-0.540076732635498,
-0.12246379256248474,
-0.11442720144987106,
-0.4028415083885193,
-0.24541087448596954,
-0.4782423973083496,
-0.44629961252212524,
-0.4749699831008911,
0.6585490703582764,
-0.19530245661735535,
0.01960529200732708,
0.08783544600009918,
-0.3359164595603943,
-0.09267298132181168,
0.44890961050987244,
0.3642522096633911,
0.9000672101974487,
-0.23699688911437988,
0.25735461711883545,
0.3093779385089874,
-0.2948388159275055,
0.13021951913833618,
0.24653925001621246,
-0.49130821228027344,
0.1596476286649704,
0.4357997179031372,
0.662926971912384,
0.5264519453048706,
-0.5002013444900513,
0.3139890730381012,
0.13630050420761108,
-0.1497730165719986,
-0.016696589067578316,
0.062119632959365845,
-0.19587638974189758,
0.30002540349960327,
0.1873723417520523,
0.28256654739379883,
0.300300657749176,
-0.4191208779811859,
0.36300379037857056,
0.35602867603302,
-0.34312108159065247,
-0.6426535844802856,
0.8448446989059448,
0.16518576443195343,
0.36812373995780945,
0.6519737839698792,
-0.13046692311763763,
-0.41633155941963196,
0.2827543020248413,
0.36987173557281494,
0.7638265490531921,
-0.39777258038520813,
0.32154175639152527,
0.19779916107654572,
0.33880358934402466,
-0.26305678486824036,
0.3375711143016815,
-0.1939324289560318,
-0.9027983546257019,
-0.2227293848991394,
-0.8190271854400635,
-0.43878185749053955,
0.3029642105102539,
-0.9078558683395386,
0.0064985076896846294,
-0.19433560967445374,
0.08952558785676956,
-0.18432550132274628,
-0.07424294203519821,
-0.5796308517456055,
0.3371775150299072,
-0.275757372379303,
0.7657356858253479,
-1.050140619277954,
0.8026047348976135,
0.8142156600952148,
-0.2877441942691803,
-0.8064614534378052,
0.06231238692998886,
0.035191211849451065,
-0.8102602958679199,
0.5249238610267639,
-0.22563536465168,
-0.025773609057068825,
0.09663743525743484,
-0.6504165530204773,
-0.9579301476478577,
0.6098374724388123,
0.6562356352806091,
-0.5708459615707397,
-0.12321103364229202,
0.11427407711744308,
0.2845988869667053,
-0.3099580407142639,
0.08378463983535767,
0.8232550024986267,
0.6733564138412476,
-0.004827736411243677,
-0.7846340537071228,
-0.023462649434804916,
0.048031192272901535,
-0.5504045486450195,
-0.017911624163389206,
-0.3433079719543457,
0.7774474024772644,
-0.2513764202594757,
-0.08487169444561005,
-0.04997621104121208,
0.6329724192619324,
-0.002441949909552932,
0.20610082149505615,
0.39653804898262024,
0.6905692219734192,
0.9591363072395325,
0.11456327885389328,
0.6252740621566772,
-0.2615603804588318,
0.22784510254859924,
1.2032760381698608,
-0.3445489704608917,
0.33986014127731323,
0.3070828318595886,
-0.032916512340307236,
0.6320068836212158,
0.48481133580207825,
0.22944174706935883,
0.9707320332527161,
-0.11696615815162659,
-0.3975604772567749,
-0.5514750480651855,
0.02549395151436329,
-0.4500623345375061,
0.5947385430335999,
0.24759739637374878,
-0.23680630326271057,
-0.6507775187492371,
-0.1457194685935974,
0.1952553540468216,
0.17918278276920319,
-0.14629139006137848,
0.7910404801368713,
0.049813877791166306,
-0.8214714527130127,
0.5719178318977356,
0.024157198145985603,
0.49813175201416016,
-0.6250940561294556,
-0.005201396532356739,
-0.4518314003944397,
0.487839013338089,
0.05260516330599785,
-0.4577515423297882,
0.395925909280777,
0.018845951184630394,
-0.3324742615222931,
0.015216301195323467,
0.7735590934753418,
-0.35351312160491943,
-0.6326296329498291,
0.15552471578121185,
0.6779126524925232,
0.06743191927671432,
-0.27242451906204224,
-0.3198692202568054,
-0.1878172755241394,
0.27092868089675903,
-0.2543124854564667,
0.3376191556453705,
0.7599493265151978,
-0.004020490683615208,
0.41511890292167664,
0.6485862135887146,
0.11103556305170059,
0.04750772938132286,
-0.26618319749832153,
0.8231308460235596,
-0.507017195224762,
-0.2985170781612396,
-0.8369816541671753,
0.4068366289138794,
-0.08153737336397171,
-0.46402284502983093,
0.9448359608650208,
0.45436784625053406,
0.5459088087081909,
-0.02543902024626732,
1.0307139158248901,
0.03979659825563431,
0.7773295044898987,
-0.5312138199806213,
0.8627470135688782,
-0.46042710542678833,
0.14188829064369202,
-0.13935807347297668,
-0.7008059024810791,
0.10084208101034164,
0.46755486726760864,
-0.24406442046165466,
-0.19559763371944427,
0.5490554571151733,
0.7950109243392944,
-0.445549339056015,
0.08271615207195282,
0.3531387448310852,
0.38097020983695984,
-0.03755522891879082,
0.18677525222301483,
0.7332905530929565,
-0.28515949845314026,
0.41406717896461487,
-0.047772858291864395,
-0.4022422432899475,
0.1587393879890442,
-0.8278952836990356,
-0.9349764585494995,
-0.7129274606704712,
-0.299987256526947,
-0.13803666830062866,
0.3147065043449402,
0.5030233860015869,
0.5419641733169556,
-1.1148712635040283,
-0.09247837215662003,
-0.1274920254945755,
0.12253645062446594,
-0.15558356046676636,
-0.16335207223892212,
0.26496362686157227,
-0.5600022077560425,
-0.39909738302230835,
0.7280840277671814,
-0.13666066527366638,
-0.39480844140052795,
0.048977527767419815,
0.23327277600765228,
-0.056817829608917236,
0.2671422064304352,
0.16493232548236847,
0.6136652231216431,
-0.35503414273262024,
-0.3869917690753937,
-0.11171332001686096,
0.45580026507377625,
-0.12402085959911346,
0.7586566209793091,
-0.8631554841995239,
0.3561422824859619,
0.22868746519088745,
0.6564862728118896,
0.2733692526817322,
0.21918576955795288,
0.8211350440979004,
-0.9128175973892212,
0.07261759787797928,
-0.07809680700302124,
0.29775726795196533,
0.31438422203063965,
-0.28010472655296326,
0.3615424931049347,
0.5464271903038025,
-0.5409186482429504,
-0.9392618536949158,
0.32112979888916016,
-0.5221130847930908,
-0.27846261858940125,
1.3055135011672974,
-0.21369008719921112,
0.006989185232669115,
-0.4363684356212616,
0.15560297667980194,
0.4104788601398468,
-0.2901005446910858,
1.035832166671753,
0.6878648996353149,
0.06431753933429718,
0.12400058656930923,
-0.5924916863441467,
0.7503150105476379,
0.5713943839073181,
-0.5956516265869141,
0.3938470482826233,
0.5403499007225037,
0.8286276459693909,
0.04995810613036156,
0.3887014091014862,
0.02339465729892254,
0.19373857975006104,
0.04264181852340698,
0.103423111140728,
0.21863697469234467,
-0.5808700919151306,
-0.2214263677597046,
0.058558132499456406,
-0.011819956824183464,
-0.21404944360256195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01247v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01247v3
|
An image speaks a thousand words, but can everyone listen? On image transcreation for cultural relevance
| 2024-04-01T17:08:50 | 2024-06-19T18:07:19 |
Simran Khanuja, Sathyanarayanan Ramamoorthy, Yueqi Song, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Given the rise of multimedia content, human translators increasingly focus on
culturally adapting not only words but also other modalities such as images to
convey the same meaning. While several applications stand to benefit from this,
machine translation systems remain confined to dealing with language in speech
and text. In this work, we take a first step towards translating images to make
them culturally relevant. First, we build three pipelines comprising
state-of-the-art generative models to do the task. Next, we build a two-part
evaluation dataset: i) concept: comprising 600 images that are cross-culturally
coherent, focusing on a single concept per image, and ii) application:
comprising 100 images curated from real-world applications. We conduct a
multi-faceted human evaluation of translated images to assess for cultural
relevance and meaning preservation. We find that as of today, image-editing
models fail at this task, but can be improved by leveraging LLMs and retrievers
in the loop. Best pipelines can only translate 5% of images for some countries
in the easier concept dataset and no translation is successful for some
countries in the application dataset, highlighting the challenging nature of
the task. Our code and data is released here:
https://github.com/simran-khanuja/image-transcreation.
|
[
-0.41802412271499634,
-0.10596416145563126,
0.42317304015159607,
0.5316281914710999,
-0.8415379524230957,
-0.05615086108446121,
-0.24382203817367554,
-0.7488824725151062,
-0.15952615439891815,
0.6040351986885071,
-0.445561945438385,
-0.5937273502349854,
-0.8846244812011719,
0.2049807757139206,
-0.754338264465332,
0.8881394267082214,
-0.088081955909729,
0.2762720286846161,
-0.188932865858078,
-0.5155210494995117,
-0.6762974858283997,
0.020609304308891296,
-0.41522330045700073,
0.038022249937057495,
0.10895873606204987,
0.28180572390556335,
0.737992525100708,
0.7955213189125061,
0.5440548062324524,
0.23190651834011078,
-0.1393568068742752,
0.2093573957681656,
-0.47380441427230835,
0.1535828411579132,
-0.20047935843467712,
-0.42646607756614685,
0.016677699983119965,
0.07475622743368149,
0.3083447515964508,
0.5451316237449646,
0.2847851514816284,
0.5264425277709961,
-0.08560261130332947,
0.6314264535903931,
-0.399867445230484,
0.10962823778390884,
-0.5626347064971924,
0.1443292647600174,
-0.3660609722137451,
-0.36641862988471985,
-0.41609692573547363,
-0.23511341214179993,
0.17889142036437988,
-0.5276362895965576,
0.03536032885313034,
-0.027981096878647804,
0.5402894020080566,
0.3529317080974579,
-0.5650541186332703,
-0.4336954355239868,
-0.838922917842865,
0.6958320140838623,
0.06107102334499359,
0.4065062701702118,
0.28958821296691895,
0.13914236426353455,
0.148173525929451,
-0.8083758354187012,
-0.5357327461242676,
0.2688884139060974,
0.20034724473953247,
0.12360285967588425,
-0.30496567487716675,
-0.4321843981742859,
0.056503549218177795,
0.539778470993042,
-0.33497363328933716,
-0.28475651144981384,
-0.7491489052772522,
-0.4018447995185852,
0.42914730310440063,
0.1012134701013565,
0.8093711733818054,
-0.17956146597862244,
-0.3371632397174835,
-0.3504340648651123,
-0.5991238951683044,
-0.19865809381008148,
-0.07561008632183075,
-0.03749675676226616,
-0.15207825601100922,
0.4045971930027008,
-0.027599966153502464,
0.43987807631492615,
-0.21633024513721466,
-0.06325193494558334,
0.11099981516599655,
-0.29330381751060486,
0.10103193670511246,
0.08728935569524765,
0.8157540559768677,
0.723984956741333,
0.51976078748703,
-0.32811594009399414,
-0.014093610458076,
0.17345283925533295,
0.24476003646850586,
-0.9157558679580688,
0.1882852166891098,
0.034397419542074203,
-0.539477527141571,
-0.16145090758800507,
0.07204675674438477,
-0.5137317180633545,
-0.48111492395401,
-0.11203330755233765,
0.29569631814956665,
-0.37990814447402954,
0.0355452336370945,
0.12135079503059387,
-0.08822009712457657,
0.3245124816894531,
0.2993202209472656,
-0.5979734659194946,
-0.17147904634475708,
0.485152006149292,
1.0667283535003662,
-0.03134673833847046,
-0.27196186780929565,
-0.203627809882164,
0.20768237113952637,
-0.5992780327796936,
0.7848489880561829,
-0.33955806493759155,
-0.5730472207069397,
-0.061827246099710464,
0.23916664719581604,
0.4290332496166229,
-0.5923654437065125,
1.1011757850646973,
-0.5285372138023376,
0.23265448212623596,
-0.33484989404678345,
0.02157200127840042,
-0.06681515276432037,
-0.16100814938545227,
-0.6410987973213196,
0.45685845613479614,
0.03177815303206444,
-0.35488787293434143,
0.40863746404647827,
-0.6772900223731995,
-0.7482455372810364,
0.3937544524669647,
0.025260576978325844,
-0.2519969642162323,
0.3760208487510681,
0.39206427335739136,
0.28932029008865356,
-0.380153626203537,
0.03604353219270706,
-0.07054796814918518,
-0.7544440627098083,
0.34432828426361084,
-0.21743835508823395,
0.650033175945282,
0.7705805897712708,
-0.19576281309127808,
-0.2683403789997101,
-0.19726994633674622,
0.0026237040292471647,
0.10649295896291733,
-0.26947617530822754,
-0.17610356211662292,
-0.20303145051002502,
0.348326176404953,
0.4295782446861267,
-0.057206202298402786,
-0.6861547231674194,
-0.04229983687400818,
-0.09626970440149307,
0.6703717112541199,
0.7276953458786011,
-0.2114919275045395,
0.6789280772209167,
-0.27524805068969727,
0.6860920190811157,
0.30749839544296265,
0.2136175036430359,
-0.5344380736351013,
-0.7057175636291504,
-0.6171252727508545,
-0.18590211868286133,
0.2997709810733795,
0.5724719762802124,
-0.8249021172523499,
0.09854056686162949,
-0.8006197810173035,
-0.4559522569179535,
-1.1242836713790894,
0.29449838399887085,
0.005278685595840216,
0.14671023190021515,
0.37520068883895874,
-0.6521100401878357,
-0.3767413794994354,
-0.9778240323066711,
-0.44471246004104614,
-0.10130809247493744,
-0.4062798321247101,
0.23176254332065582,
0.21278001368045807,
-0.33924368023872375,
0.5178160071372986,
-0.30292758345603943,
-0.6178561449050903,
0.185006245970726,
0.18645139038562775,
0.14293624460697174,
0.3332419693470001,
0.4084966480731964,
-0.7934964299201965,
-0.4776920676231384,
0.3660580813884735,
-1.0138119459152222,
-0.0014543207362294197,
-0.2626494765281677,
-0.4263267517089844,
-0.07522279024124146,
0.2531622052192688,
-0.48878777027130127,
0.5569600462913513,
0.5996635556221008,
0.013518709689378738,
-0.1253105103969574,
-0.07826369255781174,
0.4807995557785034,
-1.053401231765747,
0.11658413708209991,
-0.034545447677373886,
-0.3368300497531891,
-0.40614545345306396,
0.1474963277578354,
0.19304269552230835,
-0.7001670598983765,
-0.5978358387947083,
0.5789888501167297,
-0.47061359882354736,
-0.10279015451669693,
-0.4285973608493805,
-0.06918446719646454,
0.004818091168999672,
0.03207460790872574,
0.20978674292564392,
0.9071652293205261,
0.642419695854187,
-0.44635432958602905,
0.5401052236557007,
0.5283054113388062,
-0.9099250435829163,
1.018810510635376,
-0.5839259624481201,
0.6311866044998169,
-0.34668219089508057,
0.5587722659111023,
-0.6470694541931152,
-0.14463600516319275,
0.4460162818431854,
-0.40951043367385864,
-0.01342982891947031,
-0.11972058564424515,
-0.3943411707878113,
-0.22228498756885529,
0.016311220824718475,
0.5330730676651001,
0.5760660767555237,
-0.4844540059566498,
0.3204037547111511,
0.31427648663520813,
-0.08071541786193848,
-0.2505826950073242,
-0.9295966625213623,
0.7406904697418213,
-0.36751073598861694,
-0.949532687664032,
0.2646242678165436,
-0.12037353962659836,
0.18905285000801086,
-0.06331935524940491,
0.03335549682378769,
0.05083485692739487,
0.18046191334724426,
0.26855799555778503,
-0.01871017925441265,
0.058763276785612106,
0.28038880228996277,
-0.15755528211593628,
-0.006136947777122259,
-0.025858242064714432,
-0.6328421235084534,
0.10354644060134888,
-0.25061947107315063,
-0.3335127830505371,
-0.538765013217926,
0.7806522250175476,
0.9055443406105042,
-0.22211748361587524,
0.5718531012535095,
1.0939995050430298,
-0.31439030170440674,
0.14860086143016815,
-0.4049955904483795,
0.020179226994514465,
-0.38618355989456177,
0.3523162007331848,
-0.5163494944572449,
-0.5864109992980957,
0.27170899510383606,
-0.4907081127166748,
-0.11598104983568192,
0.22327245771884918,
0.34918028116226196,
-0.4978862702846527,
0.8761747479438782,
0.5039120316505432,
-0.07990972697734833,
0.2581181526184082,
-0.2986546754837036,
0.2507377564907074,
-0.8563960790634155,
-0.16446776688098907,
-0.3188806176185608,
-0.6050145030021667,
-0.912011444568634,
-0.598994255065918,
0.7705074548721313,
-0.2053123563528061,
0.32604703307151794,
0.2945641875267029,
-0.5192724466323853,
0.5736024379730225,
0.400307297706604,
0.3794555366039276,
0.383827805519104,
0.4685122072696686,
0.37564241886138916,
-0.18108271062374115,
-0.273296594619751,
-0.6493749618530273,
0.9185447096824646,
0.2617276608943939,
0.7444040179252625,
0.21960636973381042,
0.2446277141571045,
0.528235673904419,
0.5795958638191223,
-0.9548993706703186,
0.5430635213851929,
-0.6119810938835144,
-0.6308297514915466,
-0.03046121634542942,
-0.07539096474647522,
-0.859542727470398,
0.1933189332485199,
-0.204514741897583,
-0.2144383043050766,
0.23139461874961853,
-0.06580108404159546,
0.12007252126932144,
0.22054733335971832,
-0.5521644353866577,
0.6650920510292053,
-0.4240403473377228,
-0.21839918196201324,
-0.22725889086723328,
-0.7790088057518005,
0.15516042709350586,
-0.3722757399082184,
0.5509781241416931,
-0.016267336905002594,
-0.16606071591377258,
0.45551323890686035,
0.12856072187423706,
0.4636293053627014,
0.08073874562978745,
-0.14708252251148224,
0.16635949909687042,
0.21525609493255615,
0.11222386360168457,
-0.4059349298477173,
-0.15724097192287445,
0.444345623254776,
0.12042903155088425,
-0.5829119086265564,
-0.5615724325180054,
0.27582094073295593,
-0.7541700601577759,
-0.5980033278465271,
-0.03226512297987938,
-0.4670015275478363,
-0.01810038648545742,
0.04381013661623001,
0.2863404154777527,
0.11323188245296478,
-0.23688994348049164,
0.5937286019325256,
0.33447787165641785,
-0.33534249663352966,
0.15538738667964935,
-0.06351582705974579,
0.017594506964087486,
-0.3499540388584137,
0.9456916451454163,
-0.16671788692474365,
0.11294586956501007,
0.09791914373636246,
0.1545501947402954,
-0.44112804532051086,
-0.41267332434654236,
-1.1174908876419067,
0.1182219609618187,
-1.148398995399475,
-0.03323010355234146,
-0.4163544178009033,
0.23240716755390167,
-0.261079341173172,
-0.08263695985078812,
-0.10853645205497742,
-0.1300964057445526,
-0.26949670910835266,
0.2550376355648041,
0.10999352484941483,
0.770302414894104,
0.01115684024989605,
0.17714324593544006,
-0.9661000967025757,
0.31366121768951416,
0.3660179674625397,
0.29614534974098206,
-0.2851734757423401,
-0.7454966902732849,
-0.32042720913887024,
0.17966800928115845,
-0.3982272744178772,
-0.7800410985946655,
0.38128983974456787,
0.4868670403957367,
0.2860211730003357,
0.3060968518257141,
-0.0512315109372139,
0.9494400024414062,
-0.40397194027900696,
0.5958540439605713,
0.10432343184947968,
-1.1098204851150513,
0.8042410612106323,
-0.1641114205121994,
0.6393800973892212,
0.45840775966644287,
0.5115240216255188,
-1.3035893440246582,
-0.20448113977909088,
-0.26104336977005005,
-0.6846430897712708,
0.5024774670600891,
0.03500042483210564,
0.8499881625175476,
0.039041630923748016,
0.28797420859336853,
-0.03910320624709129,
0.04173880070447922,
-0.6589465141296387,
-0.003935663960874081,
-0.4948050379753113,
-0.15206068754196167,
0.16139264404773712,
0.02265504002571106,
-0.3049624562263489,
-0.09368189424276352,
0.40342608094215393,
-0.35380515456199646,
0.22186648845672607,
0.1401086449623108,
-0.5878843069076538,
-0.2996683716773987,
0.32226893305778503,
0.45186561346054077,
0.4649902880191803,
0.05728793889284134,
-0.05454464256763458,
0.11862897127866745,
-0.5891382098197937,
0.4494526982307434,
-0.44989174604415894,
-0.41130053997039795,
-0.0977405235171318,
0.3399837017059326,
1.0087348222732544,
-0.17094945907592773,
-0.3742790222167969,
0.40281981229782104,
-0.23497581481933594,
0.029061727225780487,
-0.042707741260528564,
-0.25743281841278076,
0.10415675491094589,
0.06870173662900925,
0.4412379860877991,
0.3006337583065033,
0.05016856640577316,
-0.8228479027748108,
-0.03411833941936493,
0.27855241298675537,
-0.533216118812561,
-0.29462286829948425,
0.6828681826591492,
0.5377017259597778,
-0.25389015674591064,
0.8488036394119263,
0.010417651385068893,
-0.49025416374206543,
0.22938862442970276,
0.3366301953792572,
0.900998055934906,
-0.016879677772521973,
0.262543261051178,
0.2096831500530243,
0.38658761978149414,
-0.10213517397642136,
0.04999435320496559,
-0.13003170490264893,
-0.6499669551849365,
-0.5539681911468506,
-0.5863673686981201,
-0.24691647291183472,
-0.08226865530014038,
-0.5405527353286743,
0.30594736337661743,
0.0013588255969807506,
-0.3232448101043701,
-0.1498730629682541,
-0.48983150720596313,
-0.9564712047576904,
0.259440541267395,
0.5441799163818359,
0.6285889148712158,
-1.1074079275131226,
0.652642011642456,
1.0084166526794434,
-0.21747508645057678,
-0.25748494267463684,
0.07754433900117874,
-0.20142357051372528,
-0.8050385117530823,
0.9206276535987854,
0.05666080489754677,
-0.020809128880500793,
0.12013418972492218,
-0.6947168111801147,
-0.5575841665267944,
1.0884703397750854,
0.6206015348434448,
-0.24337175488471985,
0.42928794026374817,
0.4129171669483185,
0.5964351296424866,
-0.4433242678642273,
0.1945745050907135,
0.3585909307003021,
0.6622511744499207,
0.41564056277275085,
-0.7666422724723816,
-0.0396428257226944,
-0.18027937412261963,
0.3841421902179718,
-0.15498752892017365,
-0.48406487703323364,
0.2985272705554962,
-0.4188123941421509,
-0.6716092228889465,
0.22471681237220764,
0.679177463054657,
-0.02307989075779915,
0.13567273318767548,
0.6773232221603394,
0.40645602345466614,
0.4900895059108734,
-0.1891774833202362,
1.1873031854629517,
-0.270011305809021,
-0.046314459294080734,
0.6004250049591064,
0.1351778656244278,
0.5708214044570923,
0.4975548982620239,
-0.18454593420028687,
0.20619571208953857,
0.9054373502731323,
0.07693451642990112,
0.4910430908203125,
0.3794310390949249,
-0.5192105770111084,
-0.412455290555954,
-0.8701399564743042,
-0.2543489634990692,
0.906775176525116,
0.31183940172195435,
-0.5487300753593445,
0.10144326835870743,
0.1583627611398697,
-0.18645843863487244,
0.08223846554756165,
-0.08001897484064102,
0.6417220830917358,
0.2616647481918335,
-0.6358542442321777,
0.48493844270706177,
0.001127657014876604,
0.5105206370353699,
-0.1981578767299652,
-0.022703731432557106,
-0.3461226224899292,
-0.20475074648857117,
-0.19325274229049683,
-0.78946453332901,
0.33568161725997925,
0.08911536633968353,
-0.07045088708400726,
-0.5731813311576843,
0.5834811329841614,
-0.4462519884109497,
-0.6554419994354248,
0.03438528999686241,
0.4368264377117157,
0.5364278554916382,
-0.11719474196434021,
-0.5096368193626404,
0.3995954096317291,
0.07912547141313553,
0.25718191266059875,
0.08519915491342545,
0.5373120307922363,
-0.5091425180435181,
0.6501831412315369,
0.6433352828025818,
0.37382712960243225,
-0.1254696100950241,
0.2339021861553192,
0.4528448283672333,
-0.5882863402366638,
-0.18353238701820374,
-0.7101646661758423,
0.3880389332771301,
0.1862683892250061,
-0.1498754918575287,
0.21104702353477478,
0.18508782982826233,
0.8934270143508911,
-0.35476920008659363,
0.8238340020179749,
0.08473938703536987,
-0.2720548212528229,
-0.26220420002937317,
0.7228319048881531,
-0.4256502091884613,
0.0184212327003479,
-0.2028602659702301,
-0.82338947057724,
-0.21401365101337433,
0.49313750863075256,
-0.022854313254356384,
-0.22669833898544312,
0.47248604893684387,
0.5649772882461548,
-0.05559873208403587,
0.2900641858577728,
0.5043637156486511,
-0.005480352323502302,
0.2615872025489807,
0.3428133428096771,
1.0734859704971313,
-0.7528601884841919,
0.8797962665557861,
-0.3175075948238373,
0.007811599876731634,
0.21709376573562622,
-1.0977389812469482,
-0.1581421047449112,
-0.7279610633850098,
-0.33987730741500854,
-0.10766936093568802,
-0.16603608429431915,
0.5407077074050903,
1.087460994720459,
-0.618407130241394,
-0.24875961244106293,
0.45119598507881165,
-0.20735445618629456,
-0.027468763291835785,
-0.05805486813187599,
0.2133181095123291,
0.20291492342948914,
-1.0448048114776611,
0.18639974296092987,
0.39660200476646423,
0.13081596791744232,
-0.5074179172515869,
-0.005298367235809565,
0.18201656639575958,
-0.3039781451225281,
0.7615841031074524,
0.05921754986047745,
-0.7297335267066956,
-0.4016243815422058,
-0.056477997452020645,
0.019439905881881714,
0.03147472068667412,
0.8468399047851562,
-0.518343985080719,
0.8010516166687012,
0.35275065898895264,
0.8861918449401855,
0.7015557885169983,
0.09714710712432861,
0.6083019971847534,
-0.7116243839263916,
0.23772917687892914,
0.012604814022779465,
0.2660216689109802,
0.8375673294067383,
-0.39839452505111694,
0.7210045456886292,
0.45904088020324707,
-0.3156275153160095,
-0.410971462726593,
0.22328847646713257,
-0.8990393280982971,
-0.028635535389184952,
0.85532146692276,
-0.21397823095321655,
-0.2893482744693756,
-0.09983862191438675,
-0.23162518441677094,
0.24186201393604279,
-0.16433188319206238,
0.690561056137085,
0.992331862449646,
0.18833722174167633,
-0.2831747829914093,
-0.6107038259506226,
-0.0449872687458992,
0.4370218813419342,
-0.6824694871902466,
-0.29513540863990784,
0.4054074287414551,
0.3113185465335846,
0.2538768947124481,
0.5596297383308411,
-0.36661964654922485,
0.3379765748977661,
-0.5435774326324463,
0.17263518273830414,
0.2346566617488861,
0.016758037731051445,
-0.3410138487815857,
-0.16885732114315033,
0.1405523121356964,
-0.4546670615673065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01245v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01245v1
|
A Statistical Framework of Watermarks for Large Language Models: Pivot, Detection Efficiency and Optimal Rules
| 2024-04-01T17:03:41 | 2024-04-01T17:03:41 |
Xiang Li, Feng Ruan, Huiyuan Wang, Qi Long, Weijie J. Su
|
math.ST
|
math.ST, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG, stat.ML, stat.TH
|
Since ChatGPT was introduced in November 2022, embedding (nearly)
unnoticeable statistical signals into text generated by large language models
(LLMs), also known as watermarking, has been used as a principled approach to
provable detection of LLM-generated text from its human-written counterpart. In
this paper, we introduce a general and flexible framework for reasoning about
the statistical efficiency of watermarks and designing powerful detection
rules. Inspired by the hypothesis testing formulation of watermark detection,
our framework starts by selecting a pivotal statistic of the text and a secret
key -- provided by the LLM to the verifier -- to enable controlling the false
positive rate (the error of mistakenly detecting human-written text as
LLM-generated). Next, this framework allows one to evaluate the power of
watermark detection rules by obtaining a closed-form expression of the
asymptotic false negative rate (the error of incorrectly classifying
LLM-generated text as human-written). Our framework further reduces the problem
of determining the optimal detection rule to solving a minimax optimization
program. We apply this framework to two representative watermarks -- one of
which has been internally implemented at OpenAI -- and obtain several findings
that can be instrumental in guiding the practice of implementing watermarks. In
particular, we derive optimal detection rules for these watermarks under our
framework. These theoretically derived detection rules are demonstrated to be
competitive and sometimes enjoy a higher power than existing detection
approaches through numerical experiments.
|
[
-0.28459614515304565,
-0.9034532904624939,
0.648630678653717,
0.21182820200920105,
-0.5192599892616272,
-0.1866614669561386,
-0.31027185916900635,
-0.15729117393493652,
-0.024946244433522224,
0.7237768173217773,
-0.2798047363758087,
-0.6114528179168701,
-0.6165658831596375,
-0.15513181686401367,
-0.5506485104560852,
0.8452423810958862,
-0.051202110946178436,
-0.20227935910224915,
0.10198716819286346,
-0.13676564395427704,
0.0295864250510931,
-0.7101155519485474,
-0.35235530138015747,
-0.29280510544776917,
0.2702997922897339,
0.4456540048122406,
0.685662567615509,
0.9529831409454346,
0.7591577172279358,
0.23806704580783844,
-0.1620616763830185,
0.11425326019525528,
-0.4646870493888855,
0.2623217701911926,
0.012999540194869041,
-0.6971308588981628,
-0.2633948028087616,
-0.11214528232812881,
0.6611074805259705,
0.3091638386249542,
0.09477042406797409,
0.11962462961673737,
0.12331295758485794,
0.6514725685119629,
-0.8778044581413269,
0.565682590007782,
-0.6866247057914734,
0.12636399269104004,
-0.611395537853241,
-0.5067993998527527,
-0.5533571839332581,
-0.33882957696914673,
-0.2049281746149063,
-0.47836220264434814,
0.06787671148777008,
0.26041480898857117,
0.8848201632499695,
0.12915827333927155,
-0.14732801914215088,
-0.3428751528263092,
-0.7297234535217285,
0.8267930746078491,
-0.7272944450378418,
0.23524357378482819,
0.30331236124038696,
0.5023890733718872,
-0.34085512161254883,
-0.4957108795642853,
-0.6052676439285278,
-0.010198352858424187,
0.20261752605438232,
-0.09152313321828842,
-0.5556913018226624,
-0.1370992660522461,
0.35879501700401306,
0.31002968549728394,
-0.5221254229545593,
-0.1593167781829834,
0.14149358868598938,
-0.19224883615970612,
0.5996909141540527,
0.20108991861343384,
0.3840545117855072,
0.3955560028553009,
-0.1379980444908142,
-0.26014646887779236,
-0.9637728333473206,
-0.1987665593624115,
0.4674707055091858,
0.4389135241508484,
-0.04824690520763397,
0.764316976070404,
-0.16870586574077606,
0.5080465078353882,
-0.29259440302848816,
-0.23571795225143433,
0.11095017939805984,
-0.1854850947856903,
-0.15333740413188934,
0.006831614300608635,
0.8768635988235474,
0.3337741792201996,
0.8460126519203186,
-0.07396800816059113,
-0.2985788583755493,
0.2147933691740036,
-0.16215340793132782,
-0.8877342343330383,
-0.20548340678215027,
-0.254698783159256,
-0.39110541343688965,
-0.48135828971862793,
-0.0379936508834362,
-0.8173018097877502,
-0.5506541132926941,
-0.12322036176919937,
0.6071162819862366,
-0.38066086173057556,
-0.4143992066383362,
0.26259469985961914,
-0.15403182804584503,
0.24851088225841522,
0.09602759778499603,
-0.8263641595840454,
0.3839322030544281,
0.8806643486022949,
0.8015915155410767,
-0.20239713788032532,
0.04452145844697952,
-0.527292013168335,
0.19756603240966797,
-0.411918044090271,
0.9587277770042419,
-0.6630952954292297,
0.021361544728279114,
0.16289572417736053,
-0.23042988777160645,
-0.004707660060375929,
-0.4931444525718689,
0.615999698638916,
-0.607696533203125,
0.17728419601917267,
-0.184024378657341,
-0.8862953186035156,
-0.10054147988557816,
0.01753055676817894,
-0.5809194445610046,
0.747968852519989,
-0.2035522758960724,
-0.9528895616531372,
0.5441445112228394,
-0.9544610381126404,
-0.32440605759620667,
0.24035806953907013,
0.011996683664619923,
-0.8050299286842346,
-0.16922688484191895,
0.0670914426445961,
0.537574052810669,
-0.3989967703819275,
0.26707524061203003,
-0.3386850655078888,
-0.4042794108390808,
0.4177634119987488,
-0.6993333101272583,
0.6579522490501404,
0.12002021074295044,
-0.6944728493690491,
0.03250199928879738,
-0.49080169200897217,
0.2138533890247345,
0.3174229860305786,
-0.4093150198459625,
-0.39510378241539,
0.21418191492557526,
0.1449417918920517,
-0.39955759048461914,
0.0037258495576679707,
-0.4559536874294281,
0.02383546158671379,
-0.058248862624168396,
0.4238288104534149,
0.5559902787208557,
0.2512991726398468,
0.36315488815307617,
-0.18021011352539062,
0.4527992904186249,
-0.11110284179449081,
0.18864336609840393,
-0.37999221682548523,
-0.8328054547309875,
-0.6651424765586853,
-0.6373827457427979,
0.3972797691822052,
0.43417927622795105,
-0.5233791470527649,
0.4580322206020355,
-0.3990497589111328,
-0.43948298692703247,
-0.10572754591703415,
0.19088731706142426,
0.2917531430721283,
0.2209547609090805,
0.2781130373477936,
0.06434106826782227,
-0.24924758076667786,
-0.9634724855422974,
-0.649932861328125,
-0.2450065314769745,
0.08499210327863693,
-0.05470285564661026,
0.653938353061676,
-0.014516778290271759,
1.067578673362732,
-0.5436919927597046,
-0.24826909601688385,
-0.4124387800693512,
0.10120024532079697,
0.3155323266983032,
0.2690962851047516,
0.4702812433242798,
-1.0633147954940796,
-0.7012323141098022,
-0.03895045071840286,
-0.587266743183136,
-0.6106634736061096,
0.12462622672319412,
-0.1622454822063446,
0.08572148531675339,
0.487739235162735,
-0.3832273781299591,
0.7849442958831787,
0.49849021434783936,
-0.44649672508239746,
0.5647408366203308,
-0.09103716909885406,
0.15415318310260773,
-0.5392764806747437,
0.10483481734991074,
0.14036774635314941,
-0.31375783681869507,
-0.7543303966522217,
0.06412160396575928,
0.22312277555465698,
0.023746822029352188,
-0.05462813004851341,
0.6060985922813416,
-0.3478027582168579,
0.16660255193710327,
-0.6282638907432556,
-0.024687569588422775,
-0.15867294371128082,
0.5487346053123474,
-0.07656199485063553,
0.7423892617225647,
0.32648172974586487,
-0.5309259295463562,
0.2631547451019287,
-0.18025219440460205,
-0.514560341835022,
0.5220228433609009,
-0.7565507292747498,
-0.1596069633960724,
-0.039773959666490555,
-0.034902989864349365,
-1.0370893478393555,
0.04935621842741966,
0.555586576461792,
-0.1840955764055252,
0.23017221689224243,
-0.4991908073425293,
-0.8526176810264587,
0.10864488780498505,
-0.28638434410095215,
0.23630109429359436,
0.6322837471961975,
-0.549116313457489,
0.3981136381626129,
0.630317211151123,
-0.011927957646548748,
-0.2988186776638031,
-0.6976896524429321,
0.048365138471126556,
-0.4700636565685272,
-0.6800695061683655,
0.35312604904174805,
0.039767611771821976,
-0.3767664134502411,
0.08635610342025757,
-0.03769560903310776,
-0.20818689465522766,
0.14572903513908386,
0.3256882131099701,
-0.0003080593887716532,
-0.33394914865493774,
-0.06051604449748993,
-0.007037687115371227,
-0.467129111289978,
-0.151075541973114,
-0.20154620707035065,
0.6711260676383972,
-0.17245319485664368,
-0.7598075270652771,
-0.40477609634399414,
0.18651096522808075,
0.5215636491775513,
-0.08255089819431305,
0.7179737687110901,
0.34058329463005066,
-0.45291054248809814,
-0.18419954180717468,
-0.5744040012359619,
-0.005744846072047949,
-0.4558890163898468,
0.20204299688339233,
-0.2682438790798187,
-0.6607824563980103,
0.44293874502182007,
-0.019254200160503387,
0.15816020965576172,
0.38060444593429565,
0.824907124042511,
0.21479995548725128,
0.9914924502372742,
0.7431073784828186,
-0.25317978858947754,
0.6374418139457703,
-0.08843116462230682,
0.4634082317352295,
-0.5548933744430542,
-0.013211874291300774,
-0.6268516182899475,
0.03669656068086624,
-0.5834484696388245,
-0.5505712032318115,
0.36763569712638855,
0.26100075244903564,
-0.4621898829936981,
0.38747406005859375,
-0.34729281067848206,
0.7236250638961792,
0.5857163071632385,
-0.00553552433848381,
0.42886286973953247,
0.24387192726135254,
-0.2830386459827423,
-0.1447463482618332,
-0.673125684261322,
-0.7068752646446228,
1.1304500102996826,
0.3355894684791565,
0.7168768644332886,
0.09327757358551025,
0.5371362566947937,
0.5925727486610413,
0.5653247833251953,
-0.6632686257362366,
0.5518760681152344,
0.04049111157655716,
-0.7335914373397827,
-0.5037432909011841,
-0.5098131895065308,
-0.9776504039764404,
0.484478622674942,
-0.11378093808889389,
-0.687605619430542,
0.05434377118945122,
0.17120273411273956,
0.15651758015155792,
0.5328942537307739,
-0.6081862449645996,
0.8846737146377563,
-0.16561062633991241,
-0.5839368104934692,
-0.18027330935001373,
0.017710017040371895,
0.09611614048480988,
-0.24123156070709229,
0.38513755798339844,
-0.4204811751842499,
-0.21435803174972534,
0.7778900265693665,
-0.4852645993232727,
0.7538859844207764,
-0.5206753015518188,
-0.09651888161897659,
0.24720197916030884,
0.24808618426322937,
0.573408842086792,
-0.24959592521190643,
-0.16574867069721222,
0.037397027015686035,
-0.08023391664028168,
-0.34239462018013,
-0.4548017680644989,
0.18693991005420685,
-0.31046050786972046,
-0.358066201210022,
-0.48241057991981506,
-0.06556598097085953,
-0.01986090838909149,
0.42155346274375916,
0.26371487975120544,
0.3195066452026367,
-0.10516064614057541,
0.2747097909450531,
0.594007134437561,
-0.27443793416023254,
0.3078670799732208,
0.5495827198028564,
-0.346538782119751,
-0.16734528541564941,
1.0249210596084595,
0.006004218943417072,
-0.01074130181223154,
0.49062564969062805,
0.5041838884353638,
-0.27424389123916626,
-0.7529429197311401,
-0.33671998977661133,
0.3209676742553711,
-0.7191945314407349,
-0.30236655473709106,
-0.277202308177948,
-0.2043810784816742,
-0.05019288510084152,
0.1282680332660675,
-0.3459618091583252,
-0.2108192890882492,
0.15731030702590942,
0.354889839887619,
0.4109947085380554,
0.395183265209198,
-0.0788748636841774,
0.5069839954376221,
-0.4198015630245209,
0.27609750628471375,
0.158758744597435,
0.40709149837493896,
-0.09404268115758896,
-0.6897392868995667,
-0.1776774376630783,
0.22924292087554932,
-0.30438658595085144,
-0.646377444267273,
0.5017001032829285,
0.3301759958267212,
0.7296656966209412,
0.5840399265289307,
0.11846045404672623,
0.42204567790031433,
-0.6227296590805054,
0.39266642928123474,
0.17466305196285248,
-1.0709768533706665,
0.37407615780830383,
-0.32308220863342285,
0.0022904721554368734,
0.2723870873451233,
0.2609080970287323,
-0.6277714371681213,
-0.41239050030708313,
-0.3831973075866699,
-0.8629075288772583,
0.387356162071228,
0.49502095580101013,
0.11178333312273026,
0.17134913802146912,
0.29403382539749146,
-0.039637207984924316,
0.25369974970817566,
-0.6605136394500732,
-0.20185168087482452,
0.03519919887185097,
-0.34364601969718933,
0.13968133926391602,
-0.42854517698287964,
-0.08089420199394226,
0.0989958792924881,
0.7569612860679626,
-0.40207746624946594,
0.4167141914367676,
-0.07192318141460419,
-0.24444283545017242,
-0.021367119625210762,
0.21941615641117096,
0.4851973056793213,
0.5303357839584351,
-0.01770881377160549,
0.08170629292726517,
-0.15373748540878296,
-0.47844505310058594,
0.09185715019702911,
-0.23437881469726562,
-0.3726271390914917,
-0.06349240243434906,
0.7386569976806641,
0.7096995711326599,
0.20634989440441132,
-0.669194221496582,
0.8638488054275513,
-0.09529561549425125,
-0.08095182478427887,
-0.27781352400779724,
0.2675569951534271,
0.058409638702869415,
0.2614782750606537,
0.5569813251495361,
-0.25093746185302734,
0.06765109300613403,
-0.3524426221847534,
0.17257390916347504,
0.6118209362030029,
-0.035426557064056396,
-0.2894449830055237,
0.5186290144920349,
-0.09243558347225189,
-0.3325375020503998,
0.26231589913368225,
-0.10123401135206223,
-1.0268988609313965,
0.43248388171195984,
0.33273565769195557,
0.8227083086967468,
0.06052783504128456,
0.15751530230045319,
0.04991336166858673,
0.3007259964942932,
-0.2704883813858032,
0.22854068875312805,
-0.14390741288661957,
-1.1147961616516113,
-0.1910172402858734,
-0.5512046813964844,
-0.6692396402359009,
-0.0016654795035719872,
-0.46826857328414917,
0.3461771309375763,
-0.43614715337753296,
-0.29127806425094604,
0.4314744472503662,
-0.04398046433925629,
-0.5544044971466064,
-0.050862688571214676,
0.3193212151527405,
0.7922636270523071,
-0.7969777584075928,
0.6651638746261597,
0.27194127440452576,
0.04078289866447449,
-0.3345698416233063,
0.09369216859340668,
0.2051987200975418,
-1.0666583776474,
0.610593855381012,
0.09021268039941788,
-0.21299609541893005,
-0.31621021032333374,
-0.7715638279914856,
-0.6931772232055664,
0.6904096603393555,
0.5760329365730286,
-0.5138071179389954,
0.406737357378006,
0.5000692009925842,
0.695256233215332,
-0.4003554880619049,
0.1889052838087082,
0.4578343629837036,
0.679164469242096,
-0.18164105713367462,
-0.6597590446472168,
0.0987914428114891,
-0.3966669738292694,
-0.06722727417945862,
0.30442455410957336,
-0.5327805876731873,
0.5107097625732422,
-0.020982475951313972,
-0.3684353828430176,
0.04619881510734558,
0.219297394156456,
0.2969631254673004,
0.3459855616092682,
0.5257899761199951,
0.2416492998600006,
0.5993356108665466,
-0.424429327249527,
1.033125638961792,
-0.4210720956325531,
0.3872207999229431,
0.6129170060157776,
-0.20978578925132751,
0.8409916758537292,
0.43680381774902344,
-0.2779121398925781,
0.28603821992874146,
0.28562894463539124,
-0.3021272122859955,
0.6106584668159485,
0.4558499753475189,
-0.22673192620277405,
-0.44739463925361633,
-0.012816122733056545,
-0.28521764278411865,
0.38358092308044434,
0.30696940422058105,
-0.4301549196243286,
-0.16919410228729248,
-0.20111368596553802,
0.20637911558151245,
0.05640636757016182,
-0.057479385286569595,
0.5989652872085571,
0.08058372884988785,
-0.24966095387935638,
0.5030490756034851,
0.31799808144569397,
0.7831501364707947,
-0.6429185271263123,
0.047362860292196274,
-0.21686042845249176,
0.4737502932548523,
-0.0976097583770752,
-0.9244660139083862,
0.1528833508491516,
0.2749188542366028,
-0.15306305885314941,
-0.233233243227005,
0.7865402698516846,
-0.3982912600040436,
-0.3506520688533783,
0.2825827896595001,
0.31406983733177185,
0.3242417871952057,
-0.39704519510269165,
-0.6700195670127869,
0.3600965440273285,
-0.0015548575902357697,
-0.46428242325782776,
0.2640347182750702,
0.6287883520126343,
-0.1551477164030075,
0.9307209253311157,
0.8059675693511963,
0.28407153487205505,
0.004758121445775032,
0.10425553470849991,
0.6674705743789673,
-0.4917273223400116,
-0.6107439398765564,
-1.1774131059646606,
0.09382293373346329,
-0.31073111295700073,
-0.04843708500266075,
0.7478418946266174,
0.6494911313056946,
0.38924703001976013,
0.11473607271909714,
0.9055691957473755,
0.19229447841644287,
0.3375738561153412,
-0.46070584654808044,
0.8104516267776489,
-0.4535558521747589,
0.34698790311813354,
-0.48383474349975586,
-1.0104647874832153,
-0.5433257818222046,
0.7525739073753357,
-0.38233932852745056,
-0.06070045754313469,
0.429134726524353,
0.8881850838661194,
-0.11604443192481995,
0.3689834177494049,
0.435759574174881,
-0.20386803150177002,
0.6155908107757568,
0.5131526589393616,
0.714769184589386,
-0.4440441131591797,
0.6880751848220825,
-0.36168354749679565,
-0.4837566614151001,
-0.34981995820999146,
-1.1092053651809692,
-0.8480645418167114,
-0.5700872540473938,
-0.6194300055503845,
-0.19635902345180511,
0.1757047176361084,
0.6813005805015564,
0.6608784794807434,
-1.0163308382034302,
-0.2831496000289917,
-0.0618448369204998,
0.20063525438308716,
-0.04694046080112457,
-0.27263760566711426,
0.5301828384399414,
-0.07667176425457001,
-0.6228317618370056,
0.006040589883923531,
0.510543942451477,
0.2105589359998703,
-0.08024054020643234,
-0.14281930029392242,
0.1608043760061264,
0.10381032526493073,
0.40459877252578735,
0.29902222752571106,
-0.19341988861560822,
-0.16347528994083405,
-0.2670891582965851,
-0.17766854166984558,
0.0183094535022974,
1.1029757261276245,
-0.26546669006347656,
0.22228555381298065,
0.5276042819023132,
0.6720438003540039,
0.6052900552749634,
-0.2712768018245697,
0.4800744354724884,
-0.25683701038360596,
0.1277138888835907,
0.13617673516273499,
0.4549373388290405,
0.3690521717071533,
-0.006455759517848492,
0.6156250834465027,
0.5307110548019409,
-0.3943200409412384,
-1.079473614692688,
-0.011854260228574276,
-0.5417631268501282,
-0.11713497340679169,
1.2080786228179932,
-0.5202561616897583,
-0.34044238924980164,
-0.21043114364147186,
-0.02742469683289528,
0.07008908689022064,
-0.34821149706840515,
0.6843986511230469,
0.6723139882087708,
-0.07995564490556717,
-0.03347190096974373,
-0.3985554873943329,
0.5445452928543091,
0.30754560232162476,
-0.6711125373840332,
0.33488351106643677,
0.11832625418901443,
0.49116843938827515,
0.1446494609117508,
0.39637085795402527,
-0.26370567083358765,
0.10636436939239502,
0.09073356539011002,
-0.06353135406970978,
-0.13650129735469818,
-0.10785628855228424,
-0.11025843769311905,
0.2652551531791687,
-0.058450665324926376,
-0.12348923832178116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01242v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01242v1
|
Effectively Prompting Small-sized Language Models for Cross-lingual Tasks via Winning Tickets
| 2024-04-01T17:03:16 | 2024-04-01T17:03:16 |
Mingqi Li, Feng Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current soft prompt methods yield limited performance when applied to
small-sized models (fewer than a billion parameters). Deep prompt-tuning, which
entails prepending parameters in each layer for enhanced efficacy, presents a
solution for prompting small-sized models, albeit requiring carefully designed
implementation. In this paper, we introduce the Lottery Ticket Prompt-learning
(LTP) framework that integrates winning tickets with soft prompts. The LTP
offers a simpler implementation and requires only a one-time execution. We
demonstrate LTP on cross-lingual tasks, where prior works rely on external
tools like human-designed multilingual templates and bilingual dictionaries,
which may not be feasible in a low-resource regime. Specifically, we select a
subset of parameters that have been changed the most during the fine-tuning
with the Masked Language Modeling objective. Then, we prepend soft prompts to
the original pre-trained language model and only update the selected parameters
together with prompt-related parameters when adapting to the downstream tasks.
We verify the effectiveness of our LTP framework on cross-lingual tasks,
specifically targeting low-resource languages. Our approach outperforms the
baselines by only updating 20\% of the original parameters.
|
[
-0.23062479496002197,
-0.47451961040496826,
0.3871455490589142,
0.4635079801082611,
-0.45193541049957275,
-0.06978940218687057,
-0.6621045470237732,
-0.06860377639532089,
0.03939244896173477,
0.3316955268383026,
-0.8464868664741516,
-0.40371641516685486,
-0.12901730835437775,
0.27880239486694336,
0.16311687231063843,
1.0226057767868042,
0.17973460257053375,
0.19393207132816315,
0.21876178681850433,
0.061300572007894516,
-0.7094103693962097,
0.07286897301673889,
-1.0538296699523926,
-0.2973526120185852,
0.9988922476768494,
0.831039309501648,
0.4549168646335602,
0.3277558386325836,
-0.12361176311969757,
0.3035460412502289,
-0.026900824159383774,
0.24204353988170624,
-0.3351324498653412,
0.08232912421226501,
-0.4078676998615265,
-0.7078083157539368,
0.050816189497709274,
0.0353095605969429,
0.5979675054550171,
0.975763201713562,
-0.16759486496448517,
0.1333424150943756,
0.521567165851593,
0.58409184217453,
-0.4845854341983795,
0.20001012086868286,
-0.7397418022155762,
0.35118937492370605,
-0.05154862254858017,
-0.5696935653686523,
-0.593055784702301,
-0.4010656177997589,
-0.1767515391111374,
-0.6027721762657166,
0.1856124848127365,
0.15529713034629822,
0.5407645106315613,
0.18200020492076874,
-0.32795751094818115,
-0.36757975816726685,
-0.4999043941497803,
0.6865849494934082,
-0.4185391962528229,
0.20921242237091064,
0.09063922613859177,
0.4373569190502167,
-0.1656285524368286,
-0.4065312445163727,
-0.34276720881462097,
-0.5299802422523499,
-0.05123085901141167,
-0.03783499076962471,
0.06457260996103287,
0.055042337626218796,
0.32246139645576477,
-0.20400744676589966,
-0.722483217716217,
0.48928603529930115,
-0.1821545511484146,
-0.22926868498325348,
0.3595278859138489,
0.25490039587020874,
0.1940927952528,
-0.19189855456352234,
-0.32672497630119324,
-0.12411171942949295,
-0.8843942880630493,
0.4450454115867615,
0.38247427344322205,
0.9854413866996765,
-0.3201789855957031,
0.43646469712257385,
-0.29243260622024536,
0.8856231570243835,
0.6867740154266357,
-0.14061497151851654,
-0.0061437636613845825,
-0.39897042512893677,
-0.12623362243175507,
0.17268310487270355,
0.6916163563728333,
0.17177844047546387,
0.6151807308197021,
-0.2690953314304352,
-0.3854485750198364,
-0.45185017585754395,
-0.37594571709632874,
-0.6873825192451477,
0.08929157257080078,
0.1449713408946991,
-0.45736053586006165,
-0.1623852401971817,
-0.3106244206428528,
-0.8557072877883911,
-0.6857718229293823,
-0.47764313220977783,
0.67540043592453,
-0.3214573562145233,
-0.15690355002880096,
0.1392725259065628,
-0.03138921782374382,
0.14118055999279022,
0.247476264834404,
-1.2132631540298462,
-0.2110486477613449,
0.7429197430610657,
0.7409279346466064,
0.0797371044754982,
-0.5379860401153564,
-1.2588586807250977,
-0.13840945065021515,
-0.5248383283615112,
0.6982092261314392,
-0.47417792677879333,
-0.3897886276245117,
0.21968311071395874,
0.09640835970640182,
-0.3043119013309479,
-0.6163298487663269,
0.32997071743011475,
-0.5337651968002319,
0.26882633566856384,
-0.28797489404678345,
-0.24031181633472443,
0.31378141045570374,
0.0944414734840393,
-0.6171863079071045,
0.6557431221008301,
0.04944509267807007,
-0.3363504111766815,
0.6896222233772278,
-0.46488112211227417,
-0.7290331125259399,
0.2044139802455902,
-0.21879903972148895,
-0.0430985651910305,
0.40521708130836487,
0.4279927909374237,
0.4115399420261383,
-0.09174904227256775,
0.228061243891716,
-0.2014036476612091,
-0.5221025347709656,
0.0722113624215126,
-0.5192794799804688,
0.8975206613540649,
0.05846323072910309,
-0.481993705034256,
0.1298636645078659,
-0.7239904403686523,
0.03795047104358673,
-0.016679896041750908,
-0.3412425220012665,
-0.24786105751991272,
-0.49637824296951294,
0.04081336781382561,
0.354770302772522,
0.290444016456604,
-0.2849885821342468,
0.4992735683917999,
-0.8248888850212097,
-0.024725917726755142,
0.9390000104904175,
-0.21457602083683014,
0.8224684000015259,
-0.05560395494103432,
0.8501911759376526,
0.10655425488948822,
0.25221553444862366,
-0.3405025601387024,
-0.43049755692481995,
-0.47971317172050476,
0.02351130172610283,
0.6886523365974426,
0.7036903500556946,
-1.26436448097229,
0.10463713109493256,
-0.27566322684288025,
-0.3565092086791992,
-0.44522586464881897,
0.4723375737667084,
0.23131456971168518,
0.520382285118103,
-0.046160999685525894,
0.13009171187877655,
-0.2951957881450653,
-0.6704756617546082,
-0.5992202758789062,
-0.04642459750175476,
-0.21067070960998535,
0.6034618616104126,
0.26191338896751404,
0.3154919147491455,
0.9820016026496887,
-0.2116067111492157,
-0.5170808434486389,
-0.45852917432785034,
0.3071031868457794,
0.5665366053581238,
0.5270838737487793,
0.6318021416664124,
-0.7506930828094482,
-0.7764979600906372,
0.10028831660747528,
-0.288239449262619,
-0.33808836340904236,
-0.4059535562992096,
0.19487571716308594,
0.48219749331474304,
0.3153151273727417,
-0.5006750226020813,
0.04866096377372742,
0.4323546588420868,
-0.8088968396186829,
0.4584072530269623,
-0.4162478744983673,
0.33881115913391113,
-0.9005131721496582,
-0.16688396036624908,
-0.02897782064974308,
-0.06961613148450851,
-0.3009220361709595,
-0.15402261912822723,
0.10363546013832092,
-0.3880784809589386,
-0.6445916891098022,
0.9567295908927917,
-0.46592679619789124,
0.11471254378557205,
-0.24066700041294098,
0.05712663382291794,
-0.120670847594738,
0.5585424900054932,
0.2750890552997589,
0.7734584212303162,
0.6416172385215759,
-0.6118178367614746,
0.2495710402727127,
-0.3128523826599121,
-0.5064823627471924,
0.81436687707901,
-0.603905200958252,
-0.11618809401988983,
-0.2667655646800995,
0.020750345662236214,
-0.9096706509590149,
-0.09804438054561615,
0.4537702202796936,
-0.32230356335639954,
0.44054481387138367,
-0.4846900701522827,
-0.5716248750686646,
-0.21671167016029358,
-0.07581643760204315,
0.21418693661689758,
0.6400447487831116,
-0.7948203682899475,
0.8594687581062317,
-0.18238921463489532,
-0.426643967628479,
-0.605076014995575,
-0.4007590115070343,
0.15863917768001556,
-0.2517833709716797,
-0.4832617938518524,
0.08020225167274475,
0.00998785998672247,
-0.0003749779425561428,
-0.25463244318962097,
0.28114062547683716,
0.15012142062187195,
-0.008932017721235752,
0.016691414639353752,
0.03250131383538246,
-0.3637451231479645,
0.2533843219280243,
0.22263775765895844,
-0.39857861399650574,
-0.19230960309505463,
-0.5788967609405518,
0.4720180928707123,
0.19160281121730804,
-0.11610500514507294,
-0.24762745201587677,
0.48046988248825073,
0.265727698802948,
-0.036018308252096176,
0.6024437546730042,
0.7369949221611023,
-0.1854148954153061,
-0.6646027565002441,
-0.35754281282424927,
-0.6088436841964722,
-0.5678431391716003,
0.14133486151695251,
-0.7006437182426453,
-0.9482531547546387,
0.5083579421043396,
-0.14204415678977966,
-0.021513795480132103,
0.13281132280826569,
0.5291669368743896,
0.05021214112639427,
1.2976815700531006,
0.7197383642196655,
-0.04266899451613426,
0.6754330396652222,
0.28639450669288635,
0.023151354864239693,
-0.17153111100196838,
-0.12518075108528137,
-0.7674832940101624,
-0.259473979473114,
-0.5037888884544373,
-0.4476211965084076,
0.4188575744628906,
-0.044297050684690475,
-0.19393911957740784,
0.06870655715465546,
-0.32070106267929077,
0.6557692289352417,
0.8221489787101746,
0.04410224407911301,
0.1744583398103714,
0.0667780190706253,
-0.37064188718795776,
-0.1488827019929886,
-1.1583342552185059,
-0.1996065080165863,
0.7921640276908875,
0.12012041360139847,
0.9278561472892761,
-0.23234064877033234,
0.7668536305427551,
0.08842433243989944,
0.1432187408208847,
-0.4123213589191437,
0.6545887589454651,
-0.18452034890651703,
-0.5070908665657043,
-0.5079662203788757,
-0.6423960328102112,
-1.0095463991165161,
0.03217174857854843,
-0.0869511216878891,
-0.7107815146446228,
0.5947521924972534,
0.36760345101356506,
-0.8912374377250671,
0.024191632866859436,
-0.9294775724411011,
1.129738450050354,
-0.29819628596305847,
-0.47135236859321594,
-0.06542689353227615,
-0.39031898975372314,
0.1320420354604721,
-0.013852465897798538,
0.2509807348251343,
0.09105273336172104,
-0.3440919816493988,
0.5881965756416321,
-0.2830560803413391,
1.2364903688430786,
-0.4622083604335785,
-0.4834316372871399,
0.18117454648017883,
0.15002498030662537,
0.8879533410072327,
0.3015124797821045,
-0.17472513020038605,
-0.16159524023532867,
-0.2208537608385086,
-0.2820611000061035,
-0.8082451224327087,
0.8091202974319458,
-0.31977686285972595,
-0.4987514019012451,
-0.1784573346376419,
-0.3613048791885376,
-0.3212653696537018,
0.10886050760746002,
0.38391736149787903,
0.6154651641845703,
0.2703106999397278,
0.07834502309560776,
0.6140151023864746,
-0.45996570587158203,
0.6341254115104675,
0.8569316864013672,
-0.09516066312789917,
-0.27301275730133057,
1.0950113534927368,
0.16063837707042694,
0.08991020172834396,
0.4463793635368347,
0.4175112545490265,
-0.5088272094726562,
-0.33310243487358093,
-0.8112902045249939,
0.17435599863529205,
-0.6554160118103027,
-0.10522361844778061,
-0.3980961740016937,
0.3562699556350708,
-0.5644278526306152,
-0.36180058121681213,
-0.3821982443332672,
-0.3068006634712219,
-0.32260027527809143,
0.191975936293602,
0.3115288019180298,
0.30975669622421265,
-0.4736878275871277,
0.2538835406303406,
-0.6976657509803772,
0.3124126195907593,
0.5422532558441162,
0.5640978813171387,
-0.02151983417570591,
-0.6054482460021973,
-0.2872776687145233,
-0.02390952594578266,
0.27129480242729187,
-0.7231102585792542,
0.2257503867149353,
0.326064795255661,
0.3464653491973877,
0.45794788002967834,
0.3088584244251251,
0.5466517210006714,
-0.7020828723907471,
0.8571184873580933,
0.25354740023612976,
-0.8805873394012451,
0.7487328052520752,
-0.4418594241142273,
0.5334543585777283,
0.7154253125190735,
0.22891484200954437,
-0.46436256170272827,
-0.2203657478094101,
-0.3182184398174286,
-0.6036432385444641,
0.8309401273727417,
-0.3602389097213745,
0.3520859181880951,
0.15485408902168274,
0.22624678909778595,
0.3603077232837677,
0.2903774678707123,
-0.8107161521911621,
-0.2939170300960541,
0.008484554477036,
-0.40121909976005554,
-0.34955793619155884,
-0.11664114147424698,
0.053073812276124954,
-0.1604137271642685,
0.4825710952281952,
-0.6297979354858398,
-0.23471488058567047,
-0.13065402209758759,
0.019103627651929855,
-0.22187195718288422,
0.4033242166042328,
0.6901155710220337,
0.5325939059257507,
0.08718344569206238,
-0.09706586599349976,
0.29710444808006287,
-0.1922636479139328,
0.10805687308311462,
0.31964999437332153,
-0.4799843430519104,
0.15552052855491638,
0.34979456663131714,
0.775959849357605,
0.7712950110435486,
-0.8220064043998718,
0.47891464829444885,
-0.05536612123250961,
0.03767130523920059,
0.04852711781859398,
0.11978083848953247,
-0.07606858760118484,
0.3761124014854431,
0.5861898064613342,
-0.20723038911819458,
0.11362455040216446,
-0.4549911916255951,
0.12512043118476868,
0.49936410784721375,
-0.5424454212188721,
-0.0241900235414505,
0.6238806247711182,
0.48396581411361694,
-0.5973880887031555,
0.3033333122730255,
-0.42028820514678955,
-0.42806538939476013,
0.5437438488006592,
0.4046226441860199,
0.8348890542984009,
-0.13376392424106598,
0.6039211750030518,
0.3240993320941925,
0.38942548632621765,
0.045598141849040985,
0.3762824237346649,
-0.3307565748691559,
-0.38153794407844543,
-0.6659742593765259,
-0.5472835302352905,
-0.3459022343158722,
-0.04476558417081833,
-0.28759244084358215,
0.3424789607524872,
-0.137055903673172,
0.07900940626859665,
-0.17460373044013977,
0.22922873497009277,
-0.7939181923866272,
0.23846597969532013,
0.31915807723999023,
1.1722663640975952,
-0.855259895324707,
0.5568838119506836,
0.5712481141090393,
-0.39039573073387146,
-1.1308116912841797,
-0.222725048661232,
-0.18137285113334656,
-0.6996976733207703,
0.8514609932899475,
-0.001523293787613511,
0.10506785660982132,
0.16930589079856873,
-0.4247942566871643,
-0.5288660526275635,
0.5499587059020996,
0.4953095614910126,
-0.9176234602928162,
-0.10481761395931244,
0.45212262868881226,
0.2519989609718323,
-0.38839879631996155,
0.24236708879470825,
0.2975529432296753,
0.5969278216362,
0.08757789433002472,
-1.071501612663269,
0.07091466337442398,
0.11367029696702957,
-0.20393283665180206,
-0.08225622773170471,
-0.3730453550815582,
0.752437949180603,
-0.4198369085788727,
-0.2469939887523651,
0.11620359122753143,
0.6249154210090637,
0.3768679201602936,
0.4138050973415375,
0.9172744750976562,
-0.09883543848991394,
0.6629161238670349,
-0.18773990869522095,
0.9635880589485168,
-0.35057786107063293,
0.10359977930784225,
0.9921762943267822,
-0.44496145844459534,
0.6040022969245911,
0.7320689558982849,
0.18777641654014587,
0.40674784779548645,
0.7369832396507263,
0.17840512096881866,
0.6803420782089233,
0.1522447019815445,
-0.15175704658031464,
-0.629228949546814,
-0.2569948732852936,
-0.3710837960243225,
0.29176825284957886,
0.06638629734516144,
-0.1974659264087677,
-0.4936765730381012,
0.5591503977775574,
-0.37352970242500305,
-0.04312150925397873,
-0.6623974442481995,
0.6802119612693787,
0.27292734384536743,
-1.040324091911316,
0.3828720152378082,
-0.12336365133523941,
0.9446849822998047,
-0.6946650743484497,
-0.0187055766582489,
-0.3478475511074066,
0.28490105271339417,
0.18964864313602448,
-0.6480739116668701,
-0.2854063808917999,
-0.12863953411579132,
-0.0973936915397644,
-0.38354936242103577,
0.6477800011634827,
-0.7801355719566345,
-0.5264089703559875,
0.13685207068920135,
0.47343534231185913,
-0.24495936930179596,
-0.10859901458024979,
-0.9327799081802368,
-0.019599586725234985,
-0.12994801998138428,
-0.3425879180431366,
0.4361839294433594,
0.9099330306053162,
0.1902228146791458,
0.6908891201019287,
0.6474006772041321,
0.37661394476890564,
-0.1898026317358017,
0.5512687563896179,
0.5431659817695618,
-0.6799531579017639,
-0.9837863445281982,
-0.7665025591850281,
0.7070422172546387,
-0.08411795645952225,
-0.5774489045143127,
0.8637641072273254,
0.3889583945274353,
0.7624472379684448,
-0.4572288393974304,
0.5096122026443481,
0.26274991035461426,
0.4376872777938843,
-0.7235924601554871,
0.6045629978179932,
-0.8168826103210449,
0.2511832118034363,
-0.1209598034620285,
-0.5549461841583252,
-0.09366502612829208,
0.27255627512931824,
-0.3669840097427368,
0.2880210876464844,
0.41587987542152405,
0.9931226968765259,
0.0340573787689209,
-0.24326832592487335,
0.3420283794403076,
-0.18127618730068207,
-0.060927972197532654,
0.856602668762207,
0.8905550241470337,
-0.11856133490800858,
0.7730244398117065,
-0.30878645181655884,
-0.31482642889022827,
-0.6087521314620972,
-1.1072337627410889,
-1.046470284461975,
-0.5084236264228821,
-0.4502030313014984,
-0.4484078586101532,
0.1911669373512268,
1.2071044445037842,
0.7606511116027832,
-0.7321188449859619,
-0.12428455054759979,
0.132032111287117,
0.6297960877418518,
-0.4629310667514801,
-0.25896769762039185,
0.3250219225883484,
-0.6761088371276855,
-0.9205129742622375,
0.4008643329143524,
0.2592422068119049,
0.10898644477128983,
-0.32797473669052124,
-0.1168491393327713,
0.34065037965774536,
0.17865516245365143,
0.49464571475982666,
0.43325331807136536,
-0.42584770917892456,
-0.23157644271850586,
0.2296537607908249,
-0.29128044843673706,
-0.37054479122161865,
0.990578293800354,
-0.9869365096092224,
0.18471573293209076,
0.42342403531074524,
0.4691524803638458,
-0.07554643601179123,
-0.2877933979034424,
0.86143958568573,
-0.8645603656768799,
0.35734522342681885,
0.3511323630809784,
0.19525447487831116,
0.17669105529785156,
-0.46380162239074707,
0.2303076684474945,
0.20824532210826874,
-0.25718292593955994,
-0.9947797656059265,
0.08391452580690384,
-0.8016582727432251,
-0.46514126658439636,
1.2495362758636475,
0.2546819746494293,
-0.34538668394088745,
-0.1363162249326706,
-0.35345935821533203,
-0.12353121489286423,
-0.35043665766716003,
0.7251328825950623,
0.3860894441604614,
0.33539533615112305,
-0.4211192727088928,
-0.09089911729097366,
0.8296880722045898,
0.5354480147361755,
-0.4122713506221771,
0.08468043804168701,
0.3077487051486969,
0.19782669842243195,
-0.11654544621706009,
0.7252143025398254,
0.33348721265792847,
0.7040914297103882,
0.08878257870674133,
-0.3224186897277832,
-0.13377192616462708,
-0.44667932391166687,
-0.6693912744522095,
0.5301688313484192,
-0.07051078975200653,
-0.0588311105966568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01240v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01240v1
|
AURORA: Navigating UI Tarpits via Automated Neural Screen Understanding
| 2024-04-01T16:58:32 | 2024-04-01T16:58:32 |
Safwat Ali Khan, Wenyu Wang, Yiran Ren, Bin Zhu, Jiangfan Shi, Alyssa McGowan, Wing Lam, Kevin Moran
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC
|
Nearly a decade of research in software engineering has focused on automating
mobile app testing to help engineers in overcoming the unique challenges
associated with the software platform. Much of this work has come in the form
of Automated Input Generation tools (AIG tools) that dynamically explore app
screens. However, such tools have repeatedly been demonstrated to achieve
lower-than-expected code coverage - particularly on sophisticated proprietary
apps. Prior work has illustrated that a primary cause of these coverage
deficiencies is related to so-called tarpits, or complex screens that are
difficult to navigate.
In this paper, we take a critical step toward enabling AIG tools to
effectively navigate tarpits during app exploration through a new form of
automated semantic screen understanding. We introduce AURORA, a technique that
learns from the visual and textual patterns that exist in mobile app UIs to
automatically detect common screen designs and navigate them accordingly. The
key idea of AURORA is that there are a finite number of mobile app screen
designs, albeit with subtle variations, such that the general patterns of
different categories of UI designs can be learned. As such, AURORA employs a
multi-modal, neural screen classifier that is able to recognize the most common
types of UI screen designs. After recognizing a given screen, it then applies a
set of flexible and generalizable heuristics to properly navigate the screen.
We evaluated AURORA both on a set of 12 apps with known tarpits from prior
work, and on a new set of five of the most popular apps from the Google Play
store. Our results indicate that AURORA is able to effectively navigate tarpit
screens, outperforming prior approaches that avoid tarpits by 19.6% in terms of
method coverage. The improvements can be attributed to AURORA's UI design
classification and heuristic navigation techniques.
|
[
-0.407729834318161,
-0.7756184935569763,
1.0658477544784546,
0.2814692258834839,
-0.049120768904685974,
0.6151309013366699,
0.3468937873840332,
-0.25448453426361084,
0.25866538286209106,
0.43986305594444275,
-0.4706079363822937,
-0.8782618641853333,
-0.4113658666610718,
-0.16127492487430573,
-0.4876289963722229,
0.5533261299133301,
-0.3146587908267975,
-0.5815826058387756,
0.016227366402745247,
0.14526495337486267,
-0.7910215258598328,
0.07622325420379639,
-0.6256352066993713,
-0.16893132030963898,
0.4526692032814026,
0.8511685729026794,
0.9461944103240967,
0.35639363527297974,
0.1304747313261032,
0.2109490931034088,
-0.10391607880592346,
0.2899726629257202,
-0.13446809351444244,
0.1467810869216919,
0.2913306951522827,
-0.6290963888168335,
0.04263892397284508,
-0.1722242832183838,
0.20301881432533264,
0.541296660900116,
-0.04315111041069031,
0.2688208818435669,
0.16215303540229797,
0.8908577561378479,
-0.8151153922080994,
0.3196609318256378,
-0.47367703914642334,
0.3550981283187866,
0.012452900409698486,
-0.07922519743442535,
-0.6769767999649048,
0.020398598164319992,
-0.1258086860179901,
-1.037868618965149,
0.1192210465669632,
0.7120739221572876,
0.6941523551940918,
0.5219038724899292,
-0.8608911037445068,
0.059826578944921494,
-0.8068822026252747,
0.6902139782905579,
-0.14084835350513458,
0.34654828906059265,
0.6016693711280823,
0.49170780181884766,
-0.3663378655910492,
-0.7786168456077576,
-0.4764728844165802,
-0.494878888130188,
-0.30427366495132446,
0.08711159229278564,
-0.46236613392829895,
0.21218231320381165,
0.0036383450496941805,
0.15280446410179138,
-0.6194686889648438,
-0.00034634897019714117,
-0.21910007297992706,
-0.45188429951667786,
0.6759327054023743,
0.29329439997673035,
0.8259642720222473,
-0.3072262704372406,
-0.35926541686058044,
-0.032019175589084625,
-0.3958476185798645,
0.40597325563430786,
-0.1645166128873825,
-0.15028396248817444,
-0.2321319729089737,
0.33208808302879333,
-0.31394076347351074,
0.9189364910125732,
0.17908082902431488,
0.24799109995365143,
0.27461478114128113,
-0.3310917615890503,
-0.11703343689441681,
0.4352656900882721,
0.66794753074646,
0.5455006957054138,
-0.2912505269050598,
-0.3636133670806885,
-0.05937710776925087,
-0.06820705533027649,
0.6393069624900818,
-0.3010321855545044,
-0.37363123893737793,
0.4634992480278015,
-0.6403295397758484,
-0.5779799222946167,
-0.32307955622673035,
-0.5297162532806396,
-0.8038194179534912,
-0.10508254170417786,
0.504185676574707,
-0.3126490116119385,
-0.18820203840732574,
0.07995644211769104,
-0.4081651568412781,
0.004101117607206106,
0.4992136061191559,
-0.8949479460716248,
0.23911519348621368,
0.6429385542869568,
1.0506075620651245,
0.017363812774419785,
-0.12483017146587372,
-0.8039043545722961,
-0.04183681309223175,
-0.8636439442634583,
0.786209762096405,
-0.2914842963218689,
-0.22919650375843048,
-0.3911172151565552,
-0.32108137011528015,
-0.36796775460243225,
-0.18287354707717896,
0.24753417074680328,
-0.5309439301490784,
0.23545515537261963,
0.2546454071998596,
-0.15774083137512207,
-0.9057481288909912,
0.338299036026001,
-0.6250646114349365,
0.8277841210365295,
0.04316050931811333,
-0.6937835216522217,
0.4069671928882599,
-0.6427559852600098,
-0.3756096363067627,
0.22778135538101196,
-0.35039353370666504,
-0.4498468339443207,
0.40844041109085083,
0.34679940342903137,
0.21600662171840668,
-0.13107623159885406,
-0.07618009299039841,
0.07491517812013626,
-0.5931697487831116,
-0.18831418454647064,
0.12603378295898438,
0.6677542328834534,
0.4392618238925934,
-0.9694005846977234,
0.5823301672935486,
-0.8053996562957764,
0.4179913103580475,
-0.15001006424427032,
0.27774670720100403,
-0.7634013295173645,
0.19992168247699738,
0.1308981478214264,
-0.0725761130452156,
-0.3284579813480377,
-0.17871183156967163,
-0.019006934016942978,
-0.06779719144105911,
0.4308136999607086,
0.5539988279342651,
0.048933446407318115,
0.7877642512321472,
-0.323687881231308,
0.7637487649917603,
-0.12207118421792984,
0.4494337737560272,
-0.48031240701675415,
-0.5342687368392944,
-0.7239807844161987,
-0.19219346344470978,
0.20008127391338348,
0.49720802903175354,
-1.071268916130066,
0.3899345397949219,
0.17531651258468628,
-0.6181721687316895,
-0.2771914303302765,
0.003498230129480362,
0.29435989260673523,
0.4427412450313568,
0.3291999101638794,
-0.5242577791213989,
-0.05088707432150841,
-0.7319682240486145,
-0.35811272263526917,
-0.24437111616134644,
-0.044206731021404266,
0.5503843426704407,
0.4198383688926697,
-0.5166378617286682,
0.9340152144432068,
-0.2555638253688812,
-0.46110275387763977,
-0.3187038004398346,
0.435834139585495,
0.2561836242675781,
0.331209272146225,
0.552455484867096,
-1.1242262125015259,
-0.8138227462768555,
0.1635342538356781,
-0.7175432443618774,
-0.12918640673160553,
-0.7446888089179993,
-0.131215438246727,
-0.08879860490560532,
0.7332870960235596,
-0.26440954208374023,
0.6738497614860535,
0.7108235955238342,
-0.8641571998596191,
0.3981006443500519,
-0.03692248836159706,
0.3072323203086853,
-0.930275559425354,
-0.13235193490982056,
-0.04626346379518509,
-0.20225122570991516,
-0.6964388489723206,
0.24235180020332336,
0.2746317386627197,
-0.09410610049962997,
-0.363791286945343,
0.7028086185455322,
-0.6056005358695984,
0.024343620985746384,
-0.08512864261865616,
-0.055460963398218155,
0.3516232669353485,
0.2735624611377716,
-0.07105809450149536,
0.8974742889404297,
0.6974548101425171,
-0.695665180683136,
0.31798428297042847,
0.32186031341552734,
-0.4089910089969635,
0.21670371294021606,
-0.45764344930648804,
-0.008661212399601936,
-0.11324065178632736,
0.2717640995979309,
-1.327691674232483,
-0.05501558259129524,
0.3324989378452301,
-0.3912249505519867,
-0.16717222332954407,
-0.35434097051620483,
-0.44634732604026794,
-0.027030793949961662,
-0.2608114778995514,
0.26502761244773865,
0.686241865158081,
-0.7376973032951355,
1.356114149093628,
0.2111034393310547,
-0.0581555999815464,
-0.4445590078830719,
-0.35287007689476013,
0.4051932096481323,
-0.5344170928001404,
-0.9706376194953918,
0.46879589557647705,
0.3311774432659149,
-0.6085271835327148,
-0.11370278894901276,
-0.20419569313526154,
-0.1337742954492569,
0.420102059841156,
0.6507310271263123,
0.17259278893470764,
-0.1575244516134262,
0.3601120710372925,
0.10979432612657547,
-0.3454775810241699,
-0.0837603434920311,
-0.19291169941425323,
0.6178723573684692,
-0.3210107684135437,
-0.237665057182312,
-0.7355511784553528,
0.13511379063129425,
0.76005619764328,
-0.391736775636673,
0.508152186870575,
0.7024019360542297,
-0.14371275901794434,
-0.21810872852802277,
-0.6940011382102966,
-0.1408260613679886,
-0.5082691311836243,
0.05683375149965286,
-0.3695898950099945,
-0.3060346841812134,
0.8058942556381226,
-0.24921250343322754,
0.05951928347349167,
0.31896084547042847,
-0.0521044097840786,
-0.1474132239818573,
1.2857321500778198,
1.0395010709762573,
-0.02893066219985485,
0.5824583768844604,
-0.2886428236961365,
0.08953572809696198,
-0.9265531897544861,
-0.35729172825813293,
-0.31212204694747925,
-0.45355018973350525,
-0.16746218502521515,
-0.09036765247583389,
0.7293210029602051,
0.031107867136597633,
-0.1503700166940689,
0.10375073552131653,
-0.6378535628318787,
0.43584415316581726,
0.8574955463409424,
0.1683419644832611,
0.5794400572776794,
-0.024139845743775368,
-0.47995108366012573,
0.15084196627140045,
-0.8742305636405945,
-0.30491408705711365,
0.9068379402160645,
0.44174644351005554,
1.0027949810028076,
0.0991438701748848,
0.7968974113464355,
0.34921732544898987,
0.18221741914749146,
-0.76693195104599,
0.40551328659057617,
0.14078202843666077,
-0.47029033303260803,
-0.1918235570192337,
-0.41353729367256165,
-0.9823752045631409,
0.38444414734840393,
-0.4330589175224304,
-0.7443952560424805,
0.18522074818611145,
0.2993325889110565,
-0.9831419587135315,
0.2047038972377777,
-1.2074681520462036,
0.8759635090827942,
-0.6223710775375366,
-0.7374805808067322,
-0.41014087200164795,
-0.5078582167625427,
0.3246726989746094,
-0.06809242069721222,
0.4338876008987427,
0.09820276498794556,
0.05256425216794014,
0.47175049781799316,
-0.37078166007995605,
0.6958217620849609,
-0.06329147517681122,
0.1168864369392395,
0.26430633664131165,
0.5006863474845886,
0.3062140941619873,
0.09930209815502167,
0.3367019295692444,
-0.10070668905973434,
-0.2259720116853714,
-0.16820396482944489,
-0.547573447227478,
0.4166995882987976,
-0.39684370160102844,
-0.26948752999305725,
-0.8047330975532532,
-0.4403787851333618,
0.031746748834848404,
0.39144936203956604,
0.2994583547115326,
0.3348965048789978,
0.12676051259040833,
0.28104323148727417,
0.6152237057685852,
-0.6917804479598999,
0.39178141951560974,
0.40842562913894653,
-0.5560798645019531,
-0.025795243680477142,
0.46335935592651367,
-0.2813260853290558,
0.06686164438724518,
0.13202272355556488,
0.16369234025478363,
-0.29977190494537354,
-0.6206735372543335,
-0.8163660168647766,
-0.3749735951423645,
-0.27664560079574585,
0.07513211667537689,
-0.4505321979522705,
0.0048305620439350605,
0.016441280022263527,
-0.35232242941856384,
-0.254495769739151,
-0.38051077723503113,
0.06402400881052017,
0.03986860439181328,
0.4623919427394867,
0.6602402925491333,
-0.04562826827168465,
0.5376158952713013,
-0.8743533492088318,
0.5189219117164612,
0.32627934217453003,
0.29649490118026733,
0.0060963756404817104,
-0.1762920767068863,
0.01776217110455036,
-0.2614663243293762,
-0.3293539881706238,
-0.729424238204956,
0.41618990898132324,
-0.004482078831642866,
0.5868526101112366,
0.1479663997888565,
0.15973226726055145,
0.5926393270492554,
-0.4592691957950592,
0.8391835689544678,
0.47541090846061707,
-0.7567089200019836,
0.664856493473053,
-0.25847476720809937,
0.427627831697464,
0.8274507522583008,
0.29151004552841187,
-0.8836154341697693,
-0.27418798208236694,
-0.8356704711914062,
-1.1909286975860596,
0.5238168239593506,
0.3719024360179901,
0.03061736933887005,
0.382449746131897,
0.37221264839172363,
-0.10747059434652328,
0.0312355924397707,
-0.4237481951713562,
-0.067550890147686,
-0.0955473929643631,
-0.2805519104003906,
-0.26279184222221375,
0.06924112886190414,
-0.2894960343837738,
0.05926910787820816,
0.3922852873802185,
0.003959433175623417,
-0.03512689471244812,
0.2515420615673065,
-0.30693307518959045,
0.05425404757261276,
0.15243425965309143,
0.33914944529533386,
0.4159180521965027,
-0.0936785414814949,
0.3706953823566437,
-0.08141114562749863,
-0.6627570390701294,
0.196238175034523,
0.1999773234128952,
-0.4450854957103729,
0.18143929541110992,
0.12965239584445953,
0.7461937665939331,
-0.008039779961109161,
-0.6192412376403809,
0.37737008929252625,
-0.6161956191062927,
-0.08675749599933624,
-0.7255198359489441,
0.4704430401325226,
-0.4118342399597168,
0.4072762131690979,
0.6118334531784058,
0.3012006878852844,
0.43837612867355347,
-0.6625046730041504,
0.3851262331008911,
0.34826594591140747,
-0.6271395683288574,
0.19328080117702484,
0.9779558777809143,
0.5812035202980042,
-0.41239094734191895,
0.9176220893859863,
-0.26038405299186707,
-0.5067278742790222,
0.942367672920227,
0.19452881813049316,
1.0276150703430176,
0.07540643960237503,
0.4153980612754822,
0.3513542711734772,
0.36772799491882324,
-0.11390089243650436,
-0.05305153504014015,
-0.37424930930137634,
-0.4235880970954895,
-0.4088730812072754,
-0.1431320756673813,
-0.5391333103179932,
-0.06529095023870468,
-0.34430721402168274,
0.1654229313135147,
-0.46908101439476013,
-0.1655038744211197,
-0.1890346258878708,
-0.2294723391532898,
-0.440021276473999,
0.09232636541128159,
0.23289968073368073,
0.9793813228607178,
-0.7342128753662109,
0.07021262496709824,
0.5534378290176392,
-0.4109992980957031,
-0.8834287524223328,
0.09850294888019562,
0.40538105368614197,
-0.7578946948051453,
0.5472043752670288,
0.4371916651725769,
-0.4357185363769531,
0.17421822249889374,
-0.3085770308971405,
-0.6350025534629822,
1.0996930599212646,
-0.29826149344444275,
-0.5053338408470154,
-0.12165955454111099,
-0.22852568328380585,
0.1766727864742279,
-0.23843161761760712,
0.5905061364173889,
0.20768603682518005,
0.491164892911911,
-0.13395746052265167,
-1.082078456878662,
0.0036083832383155823,
-0.5524706840515137,
-0.12924350798130035,
0.2059086114168167,
-0.5270244479179382,
0.37839168310165405,
-0.5022331476211548,
-0.1742122322320938,
0.1302524209022522,
0.1021173745393753,
0.2836149036884308,
0.9470722675323486,
0.7701831459999084,
0.3090152144432068,
0.5487207174301147,
-0.15352346003055573,
1.042704701423645,
-0.44770172238349915,
0.0741846114397049,
0.7707116007804871,
0.14095698297023773,
0.5774352550506592,
0.369955837726593,
0.3024163544178009,
0.8082857131958008,
0.7689067125320435,
0.20060059428215027,
0.6710410118103027,
0.18956559896469116,
-0.32034316658973694,
-0.1956341713666916,
0.16678956151008606,
-0.35659486055374146,
0.48921915888786316,
0.5098022222518921,
-0.4682082235813141,
-0.22805936634540558,
0.2821919023990631,
-0.1054554209113121,
0.1066473126411438,
-0.5519227385520935,
0.9668623805046082,
0.05155894160270691,
-0.7384020090103149,
0.6985485553741455,
-0.11560652405023575,
0.4223368763923645,
-0.631186842918396,
-0.28224989771842957,
-0.2556836009025574,
0.20078285038471222,
-0.5589547753334045,
-0.6374717354774475,
0.16030293703079224,
-0.18295255303382874,
0.23408757150173187,
-0.3740241527557373,
0.8121642470359802,
0.17961306869983673,
-0.22164936363697052,
0.11896788328886032,
0.3324693739414215,
-0.10029846429824829,
-0.4201813042163849,
-0.49439871311187744,
0.08792879432439804,
0.152000293135643,
-0.07787616550922394,
-0.01191003154963255,
0.1646278202533722,
-0.11501804739236832,
1.0239577293395996,
0.5382954478263855,
-0.3532242774963379,
0.1830187290906906,
-0.10596054792404175,
0.5145431160926819,
-0.7378895878791809,
-0.9418956637382507,
-0.6134005188941956,
0.9154106378555298,
-0.24177050590515137,
-0.22189399600028992,
0.7607218623161316,
0.7740644216537476,
0.4624581038951874,
0.12030614912509918,
0.8146623969078064,
-0.08312426507472992,
0.2447028011083603,
-0.761648416519165,
0.8670516014099121,
-0.6613375544548035,
0.3939574956893921,
-0.1514529287815094,
-0.9353681206703186,
-0.672607421875,
1.1020481586456299,
-0.482485830783844,
-0.3269943594932556,
0.7515581846237183,
0.5210679769515991,
-0.34038785099983215,
-0.06499851495027542,
-0.007907027378678322,
0.1409795880317688,
0.39864981174468994,
0.6283848881721497,
1.112483024597168,
-0.3632206916809082,
0.4624447822570801,
-0.3483429253101349,
-0.7233865857124329,
-0.2815810739994049,
-0.7650032639503479,
-0.6980195045471191,
-0.623908519744873,
-0.19564509391784668,
-0.5005935430526733,
0.12661197781562805,
0.5602211356163025,
0.9635712504386902,
-0.22337284684181213,
-0.1745762676000595,
-0.5606930255889893,
0.28577181696891785,
-0.40770387649536133,
-0.24487772583961487,
0.3672262728214264,
-0.4594886004924774,
-0.20740090310573578,
0.5107240676879883,
0.1347336322069168,
-0.042111851274967194,
0.035444535315036774,
0.05577351897954941,
0.4647284746170044,
-0.3924253284931183,
0.5760725736618042,
0.4725485146045685,
-0.39935651421546936,
-0.3286720812320709,
0.11164229363203049,
0.14075718820095062,
0.11732224375009537,
0.4839012622833252,
-1.2422025203704834,
0.7339355945587158,
0.31474849581718445,
0.5444232821464539,
0.6387477517127991,
0.024727683514356613,
0.5904161930084229,
-0.39094600081443787,
0.09779509902000427,
0.2351277619600296,
0.14582520723342896,
-0.04177907109260559,
-0.5088105201721191,
0.5592235326766968,
-0.22910448908805847,
-0.34539827704429626,
-0.6666753888130188,
0.4304901361465454,
-0.9113554954528809,
-0.34800001978874207,
1.106154203414917,
0.5406438708305359,
-0.20692844688892365,
-0.5810319185256958,
-0.5864197611808777,
-0.30742204189300537,
-0.39810508489608765,
1.4351472854614258,
0.32533976435661316,
-0.6153121590614319,
-0.4684458374977112,
-0.740757167339325,
0.5251359343528748,
0.5404737591743469,
-0.7478291392326355,
-0.2498507797718048,
0.32556480169296265,
0.2763906419277191,
0.6668792963027954,
0.7573232650756836,
-0.021626923233270645,
0.7393642067909241,
0.1640518307685852,
-0.023104997351765633,
-0.1468788981437683,
-0.4848337769508362,
-0.27436363697052,
-0.052572138607501984,
0.06503783166408539,
-0.5070615410804749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01234v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01234v1
|
GFLean: An Autoformalisation Framework for Lean via GF
| 2024-04-01T16:51:50 | 2024-04-01T16:51:50 |
Shashank Pathak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, math.LO, I.2.7
|
We present an autoformalisation framework for the Lean theorem prover, called
GFLean. GFLean uses a high-level grammar writing tool called Grammatical
Framework (GF) for parsing and linearisation. GFLean is implemented in Haskell.
We explain the functionalities of GFLean, its inner working and discuss its
limitations. We also discuss how we can use neural network based translation
programs and rule based translation programs together complimenting each other
to build robust autoformalisation frameworks.
|
[
0.1204439252614975,
-0.5452525615692139,
0.4026564061641693,
0.2694801688194275,
0.19981512427330017,
0.021521182730793953,
0.09650600701570511,
-0.5449219346046448,
0.28222760558128357,
0.3146440088748932,
-0.5784451961517334,
-0.30282312631607056,
-0.37471091747283936,
0.07036120444536209,
-0.7460588812828064,
0.7598089575767517,
-0.23561467230319977,
0.41032522916793823,
-0.25705575942993164,
-0.25728467106819153,
0.13714155554771423,
-0.810817539691925,
-0.4734450876712799,
-0.42142513394355774,
0.04376201704144478,
0.4687969982624054,
1.2328827381134033,
1.02741539478302,
0.6030170917510986,
0.5064863562583923,
0.1100328117609024,
-0.1590074896812439,
-0.05269867181777954,
0.2293005883693695,
-0.10345884412527084,
-0.3885745704174042,
-0.5292628407478333,
-0.5033491253852844,
0.565429151058197,
0.8405271172523499,
0.05471411719918251,
0.10511761158704758,
-0.35941794514656067,
0.782461941242218,
-0.8579646944999695,
0.2900272607803345,
-0.24638321995735168,
0.2566107511520386,
-0.13319306075572968,
0.30843108892440796,
0.11828666180372238,
-0.6405329704284668,
-0.3822905421257019,
-0.5248869061470032,
0.15115946531295776,
0.09030969440937042,
1.201581358909607,
0.4303375482559204,
-0.5077313184738159,
-0.7973710298538208,
-0.7146927714347839,
0.5907501578330994,
-0.8174689412117004,
0.48435330390930176,
0.19419969618320465,
0.534211277961731,
-0.25384029746055603,
-1.0551117658615112,
-0.6779321432113647,
-0.0697655975818634,
-0.25213927030563354,
-0.08948566764593124,
0.04081782326102257,
0.2657158076763153,
0.2877902686595917,
1.129989504814148,
-0.7411606311798096,
-0.02155841700732708,
-0.3377082943916321,
-0.18085838854312897,
0.6426053047180176,
0.027534084394574165,
0.40991857647895813,
-0.3046902120113373,
-0.3211822509765625,
0.13036595284938812,
-0.4869970679283142,
-0.1364295333623886,
0.38773682713508606,
0.006235536187887192,
0.055525146424770355,
0.6694739460945129,
-0.23910345137119293,
0.6677759289741516,
0.12590591609477997,
0.013385887257754803,
0.3370250463485718,
-0.4856604337692261,
-0.8911100029945374,
0.002366092288866639,
0.7757202982902527,
-0.1045069620013237,
0.5509225726127625,
-0.19749285280704498,
-0.32663044333457947,
0.005885559134185314,
-0.08989612758159637,
-0.9499212503433228,
-0.32272225618362427,
0.13119857013225555,
-0.42430076003074646,
-0.4817371368408203,
0.21690471470355988,
-0.45290717482566833,
-0.032497111707925797,
-0.2833773195743561,
0.28637367486953735,
-0.44360238313674927,
-0.24601280689239502,
0.29152148962020874,
0.02391050010919571,
0.5930536985397339,
0.060600169003009796,
-1.3055503368377686,
0.8670213222503662,
0.5397072434425354,
0.7009251713752747,
0.2524993419647217,
-0.39993757009506226,
-0.7631263136863708,
0.3783407509326935,
-0.5226744413375854,
0.6388852596282959,
-0.0563712976872921,
-0.3117676377296448,
0.3899151086807251,
0.10980866849422455,
-0.33402079343795776,
-0.613486647605896,
0.5925133228302002,
-0.10701695084571838,
0.6572765707969666,
-0.28884512186050415,
-0.8138338327407837,
-0.26452386379241943,
0.02673981711268425,
-0.7110716104507446,
1.1706503629684448,
0.4814414978027344,
-0.393652081489563,
0.7574955821037292,
-0.8313444256782532,
-1.0146907567977905,
0.1163867861032486,
-0.4730851352214813,
-0.3283204436302185,
0.12448788434267044,
0.08263880759477615,
0.44513270258903503,
-0.27962836623191833,
0.2837187945842743,
-0.39473581314086914,
-0.3748440146446228,
0.23322278261184692,
0.02028786577284336,
1.0372933149337769,
0.3587648570537567,
-0.819069504737854,
0.4729175269603729,
-0.9600602388381958,
0.4765182137489319,
-0.3030226230621338,
-0.42703938484191895,
0.038616590201854706,
0.17167794704437256,
0.11273987591266632,
0.47132864594459534,
-0.02235654927790165,
-0.14875029027462006,
0.19116277992725372,
-0.6058739423751831,
0.6383002400398254,
0.3421344459056854,
-0.15150907635688782,
0.3345496952533722,
-0.2800910174846649,
0.2819768190383911,
-0.07502267509698868,
0.22150756418704987,
0.17355850338935852,
-0.29957887530326843,
-1.2139216661453247,
-0.5042577385902405,
0.04793958738446236,
0.847667396068573,
-0.48556894063949585,
0.543775737285614,
0.05835830420255661,
0.029484594240784645,
-0.31632697582244873,
0.8415632843971252,
0.13141924142837524,
0.35255900025367737,
0.5259997248649597,
-0.050065428018569946,
-0.5193482637405396,
-1.0647186040878296,
-0.13512836396694183,
-0.5521885752677917,
0.06488510221242905,
-0.3798729181289673,
0.5609918832778931,
-0.36608314514160156,
0.7617762088775635,
-0.22289808094501495,
-0.5271453857421875,
-0.3662891089916229,
0.12353068590164185,
0.4622419774532318,
0.6987700462341309,
0.9357110857963562,
-0.8388444185256958,
-0.41560837626457214,
-0.04440257325768471,
-1.0014110803604126,
0.02859974279999733,
-0.09051579236984253,
-0.2799137234687805,
0.35513317584991455,
0.9372851848602295,
-0.6410635709762573,
0.4099048674106598,
0.19615665078163147,
-0.7648138403892517,
0.4653145670890808,
-0.016537142917513847,
0.23905709385871887,
-1.0297200679779053,
0.18179970979690552,
-0.32295241951942444,
-0.7184687256813049,
-0.5736185908317566,
0.005516934208571911,
-0.05953234061598778,
-0.18714705109596252,
-0.18419843912124634,
0.2519982159137726,
-0.45838576555252075,
-0.20536868274211884,
-0.034490764141082764,
-0.42802897095680237,
0.1800159513950348,
0.19879169762134552,
-0.1427851766347885,
0.7359774112701416,
0.562904953956604,
-0.4981381297111511,
0.5606560111045837,
0.14054206013679504,
-0.07886756211519241,
0.7434242367744446,
-0.882136344909668,
-0.1972675621509552,
0.06630626320838928,
-0.45555776357650757,
-1.2193753719329834,
-0.6207056641578674,
0.5633676052093506,
-0.0740761011838913,
0.4215150773525238,
-0.31361162662506104,
-0.47479507327079773,
-0.4217807948589325,
-0.016952382400631905,
0.26167479157447815,
0.2949034571647644,
-0.48182445764541626,
0.6735944151878357,
-0.11554446071386337,
-0.1072002649307251,
-0.48711153864860535,
-1.0020430088043213,
0.11819884181022644,
-0.26783835887908936,
-0.9131454825401306,
0.1370832324028015,
-0.2634192407131195,
-0.5438342094421387,
0.2148558795452118,
0.009931475855410099,
-0.5014090538024902,
0.08624725788831711,
0.37395405769348145,
0.1296585202217102,
-0.6205938458442688,
0.018781431019306183,
-0.10388091206550598,
-0.013418109156191349,
0.27902886271476746,
-0.7546951174736023,
0.03826649487018585,
-0.6695151925086975,
-0.48916757106781006,
-0.30201616883277893,
0.7841926217079163,
0.9772546887397766,
0.08172807097434998,
0.4121648371219635,
0.5783025026321411,
-0.5494629144668579,
-0.24699723720550537,
-0.4621807336807251,
0.3566785156726837,
-0.5527003407478333,
0.33509498834609985,
-0.2586054801940918,
-0.6389822363853455,
0.4656221568584442,
0.03525380790233612,
-0.24717912077903748,
0.7167304754257202,
0.8284141421318054,
0.13212528824806213,
0.6639106273651123,
0.9452168345451355,
-0.25383061170578003,
0.23964178562164307,
-0.25045958161354065,
0.08830156177282333,
0.16423004865646362,
-0.15574535727500916,
-0.642157256603241,
-0.14750108122825623,
-0.10176706314086914,
-0.33026185631752014,
-0.12379857152700424,
0.49481090903282166,
-0.48876264691352844,
0.23831619322299957,
-0.29982009530067444,
0.6293089985847473,
0.3891657292842865,
-0.6894187927246094,
0.3557415008544922,
0.008490814827382565,
-0.4252451956272125,
-0.02543099783360958,
-0.7005826830863953,
-0.2470913529396057,
0.5065334439277649,
0.33227863907814026,
0.7270419597625732,
0.4510314166545868,
0.5677525997161865,
0.5200923681259155,
0.3588961660861969,
-1.1499873399734497,
0.4188288748264313,
-0.27181610465049744,
-0.899756908416748,
-0.2797320485115051,
-0.3677102029323578,
0.011257851496338844,
0.04713234677910805,
-0.007754497695714235,
-0.5427644848823547,
0.45160454511642456,
0.2770984172821045,
-0.029976243153214455,
0.26983752846717834,
-0.8988021612167358,
1.2660633325576782,
-0.5798325538635254,
-0.20580057799816132,
0.11028560996055603,
-0.3989684283733368,
0.2467767745256424,
0.4759722948074341,
0.2552771270275116,
0.11631642282009125,
0.27340373396873474,
0.42548587918281555,
-1.0157448053359985,
0.7408789992332458,
-0.15240070223808289,
-0.16951414942741394,
0.3632749915122986,
0.16419586539268494,
0.10114854574203491,
0.19587942957878113,
-0.079421766102314,
-0.26008903980255127,
0.19238178431987762,
-0.47704580426216125,
-0.8449438810348511,
0.5455025434494019,
-0.7587636709213257,
-0.17928975820541382,
-0.6805101037025452,
-0.11912793666124344,
-0.2678844928741455,
0.5868278741836548,
0.41443976759910583,
0.4786246418952942,
-0.4342022240161896,
-0.10206253081560135,
0.39880967140197754,
0.49259743094444275,
0.711835503578186,
-0.017161933705210686,
-0.4982464909553528,
-0.9352052807807922,
0.6852878928184509,
0.03638704866170883,
0.34120485186576843,
0.40235045552253723,
-0.029103241860866547,
-0.2992560863494873,
-0.34478235244750977,
-0.7969149947166443,
0.14354804158210754,
-1.2284775972366333,
-0.4130769670009613,
0.031535930931568146,
-0.3917737603187561,
-0.5506405234336853,
-0.5871937870979309,
-0.518308162689209,
-0.9517161250114441,
0.10493656992912292,
-0.13865788280963898,
0.09565352648496628,
1.2138651609420776,
-0.26710307598114014,
0.13894464075565338,
-0.12741594016551971,
0.317065954208374,
0.4383052885532379,
0.3823038637638092,
-0.5596860647201538,
0.10372655093669891,
-0.5510077476501465,
-0.22085627913475037,
0.055764272809028625,
-0.7896280884742737,
0.005888698622584343,
0.68683260679245,
0.5636062622070312,
0.5679219961166382,
-0.20369276404380798,
0.6796471476554871,
-0.22514453530311584,
0.626305103302002,
0.49761757254600525,
-1.4798166751861572,
0.26796990633010864,
-0.19014042615890503,
0.23029187321662903,
0.8022273182868958,
0.4927474856376648,
-0.4303753972053528,
-0.15909770131111145,
-0.2741920053958893,
-0.9906334280967712,
0.0921194851398468,
0.10459243506193161,
-0.2599107623100281,
0.11846703290939331,
0.5313618779182434,
-0.07321877032518387,
0.3235209584236145,
-0.7887607216835022,
-0.11892788857221603,
-0.8865925073623657,
-0.42549043893814087,
0.044808343052864075,
-0.3317898213863373,
-0.3953407108783722,
-0.3211645185947418,
0.6883689761161804,
-0.5423673391342163,
0.2860901653766632,
0.5754798650741577,
-0.45895323157310486,
-0.17835573852062225,
0.2744133174419403,
0.4639468491077423,
0.653563916683197,
0.14636912941932678,
0.14479781687259674,
0.00879104807972908,
-0.546575665473938,
0.48915794491767883,
0.275741308927536,
-0.372275710105896,
0.06308335065841675,
0.7254552841186523,
0.5762012600898743,
0.33213189244270325,
-0.22569285333156586,
0.564060389995575,
-0.028788898140192032,
-0.7585105299949646,
-0.6756887435913086,
0.3599514663219452,
-0.04997292533516884,
0.19984957575798035,
0.3867103159427643,
0.03090454265475273,
0.3294789493083954,
-0.5296894907951355,
0.3903529644012451,
-0.028745567426085472,
-0.6695598363876343,
-0.2633266746997833,
0.8524424433708191,
-0.2141042947769165,
-0.1470320075750351,
0.3787080645561218,
-0.16802334785461426,
-0.5842506289482117,
0.32232967019081116,
0.5478308200836182,
1.2721858024597168,
-0.08880427479743958,
0.2704716622829437,
0.14203158020973206,
0.22011789679527283,
0.13787171244621277,
0.6045848727226257,
-0.2001769244670868,
-0.4450777769088745,
-0.7452636361122131,
-0.7435974478721619,
-0.35387784242630005,
-0.1257849782705307,
-0.5036218762397766,
0.19629855453968048,
-0.9247211217880249,
-0.052619848400354385,
0.0004426055238582194,
0.05381780490279198,
-0.612504780292511,
0.35332590341567993,
0.04494643956422806,
0.8521509766578674,
-0.709457516670227,
0.7644394636154175,
1.139020562171936,
-0.5555607080459595,
-0.8995632529258728,
0.143183171749115,
0.39926454424858093,
-0.4406481385231018,
0.9377502202987671,
-0.039524272084236145,
-0.6783757209777832,
-0.3878386318683624,
-0.43674543499946594,
-0.8341200947761536,
1.0636950731277466,
0.6718549728393555,
-0.0389585867524147,
-0.29646021127700806,
0.5679226517677307,
0.4482875466346741,
-0.6013444662094116,
-0.04748835787177086,
0.2235957533121109,
0.6012887954711914,
0.4886862635612488,
-0.7060211896896362,
0.11630067974328995,
-0.7025145888328552,
-0.02545437216758728,
-0.2362542450428009,
-0.622167706489563,
0.7923789024353027,
0.04091756418347359,
-0.009906713850796223,
0.3284376561641693,
1.1366982460021973,
-0.6008754968643188,
-0.10736381262540817,
0.3199249505996704,
0.5386108160018921,
1.0360157489776611,
-0.07272745668888092,
0.7460423111915588,
-0.15263716876506805,
0.28216683864593506,
0.898359477519989,
-0.46762755513191223,
0.43738847970962524,
0.44494104385375977,
0.05096858739852905,
0.9086166620254517,
0.18052250146865845,
-0.0017290936084464192,
0.22152455151081085,
0.3857925832271576,
-0.19410522282123566,
-0.38080376386642456,
0.43457865715026855,
-0.3764670193195343,
0.5565511584281921,
0.30114391446113586,
-0.2740338146686554,
-0.21021448075771332,
-0.1963663548231125,
0.45166170597076416,
0.17243553698062897,
-0.30069077014923096,
0.4707513749599457,
-0.07059158384799957,
-0.3869166970252991,
0.9623119235038757,
0.10620231926441193,
0.1607249528169632,
-0.8742815256118774,
0.09737325459718704,
-0.20369145274162292,
0.8295025825500488,
-0.4531819522380829,
-0.36300885677337646,
0.7812803387641907,
-0.4011525511741638,
-0.32657963037490845,
-0.19429929554462433,
0.903826117515564,
-0.4481116831302643,
-0.8167808651924133,
0.47886940836906433,
0.5889379382133484,
-0.32104629278182983,
0.45115235447883606,
-0.7534427046775818,
0.023324530571699142,
-0.35357362031936646,
-0.1942778378725052,
-0.09184788912534714,
0.8085819482803345,
0.22401081025600433,
0.7216248512268066,
0.18776631355285645,
-0.02327696792781353,
0.06147882714867592,
0.08234012126922607,
0.9942680597305298,
-0.7923271656036377,
-0.6716163754463196,
-0.7318601608276367,
0.5562004446983337,
-0.24763242900371552,
-0.41782110929489136,
0.6787545680999756,
0.8034417033195496,
0.6048458814620972,
-0.17689208686351776,
0.919750452041626,
-0.38254478573799133,
0.2284507006406784,
-0.8850192427635193,
0.830223023891449,
-0.5523911714553833,
-0.1311410516500473,
-0.5417678356170654,
-0.7680730223655701,
-0.6889395117759705,
0.9152373671531677,
-0.07787762582302094,
0.05890524759888649,
0.8813846707344055,
0.653526782989502,
-0.353689968585968,
0.21476101875305176,
0.4010722041130066,
0.16762138903141022,
0.4789027273654938,
0.49351438879966736,
0.5464478135108948,
-0.5879939794540405,
0.5787575244903564,
-0.024326428771018982,
-0.187307208776474,
-0.013205663301050663,
-1.0369045734405518,
-1.1163536310195923,
-0.6208520531654358,
-0.42516180872917175,
-0.6869497895240784,
0.3947472870349884,
0.7764996886253357,
1.0311301946640015,
-1.1944804191589355,
-0.815322995185852,
-0.2207651138305664,
0.20329664647579193,
-0.21169674396514893,
-0.24358871579170227,
0.20464979112148285,
-0.8809614181518555,
-0.4814995527267456,
0.5927994251251221,
0.3756922483444214,
0.16858091950416565,
-0.5426295399665833,
-0.4118082523345947,
-0.46429672837257385,
-0.13559551537036896,
0.2709623873233795,
0.7517933249473572,
-0.007520583923906088,
-0.5607311725616455,
0.06932391971349716,
-0.12970228493213654,
0.039944857358932495,
1.152712106704712,
-0.44681718945503235,
-0.12034544348716736,
0.26107922196388245,
0.5955320596694946,
0.4546247124671936,
-0.18570011854171753,
1.0265763998031616,
-0.3685399293899536,
0.28732845187187195,
0.07549988478422165,
0.600713312625885,
0.5270432233810425,
-0.44332754611968994,
0.5158134698867798,
0.7148759961128235,
-0.7092350125312805,
-0.3531762957572937,
0.5845518708229065,
-0.5723147988319397,
-0.05061473324894905,
0.9018653035163879,
-0.14977334439754486,
-0.41866251826286316,
-0.2733643054962158,
0.06294198334217072,
-0.18903744220733643,
0.1086135059595108,
0.21679039299488068,
0.839032769203186,
-0.2125522941350937,
0.25342094898223877,
-0.33729851245880127,
0.9708396792411804,
0.3942946195602417,
-0.7232320308685303,
-0.03026103414595127,
0.7746077179908752,
0.45208150148391724,
0.2112971842288971,
0.8275461792945862,
-0.27386245131492615,
0.2597663402557373,
-0.050705719739198685,
-0.16054527461528778,
-0.342006653547287,
-0.49061819911003113,
-0.21883268654346466,
0.47167718410491943,
0.24756675958633423,
0.21750900149345398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01232v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01232v2
|
Open-Vocabulary Federated Learning with Multimodal Prototyping
| 2024-04-01T16:51:13 | 2024-04-02T15:03:33 |
Huimin Zeng, Zhenrui Yue, Dong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Existing federated learning (FL) studies usually assume the training label
space and test label space are identical. However, in real-world applications,
this assumption is too ideal to be true. A new user could come up with queries
that involve data from unseen classes, and such open-vocabulary queries would
directly defect such FL systems. Therefore, in this work, we explicitly focus
on the under-explored open-vocabulary challenge in FL. That is, for a new user,
the global server shall understand her/his query that involves arbitrary
unknown classes. To address this problem, we leverage the pre-trained
vision-language models (VLMs). In particular, we present a novel adaptation
framework tailored for VLMs in the context of FL, named as Federated Multimodal
Prototyping (Fed-MP). Fed-MP adaptively aggregates the local model weights
based on light-weight client residuals, and makes predictions based on a novel
multimodal prototyping mechanism. Fed-MP exploits the knowledge learned from
the seen classes, and robustifies the adapted VLM to unseen categories. Our
empirical evaluation on various datasets validates the effectiveness of Fed-MP.
|
[
-0.4477161765098572,
-0.49974071979522705,
0.25889721512794495,
0.26750174164772034,
0.08182170242071152,
0.1833523064851761,
-0.21651962399482727,
-0.4802912771701813,
0.24269698560237885,
0.37777507305145264,
-0.6180591583251953,
-0.28895649313926697,
-0.17155764997005463,
0.0031443224288523197,
-0.1173308864235878,
0.975403904914856,
-0.04407639056444168,
-0.07017345726490021,
-0.5990189909934998,
-0.39963874220848083,
-0.09810077399015427,
-0.38673800230026245,
-0.20746566355228424,
-0.03680349513888359,
0.7399911284446716,
0.4303608238697052,
0.6536712050437927,
0.3080365061759949,
0.5094839334487915,
0.303303599357605,
0.411857545375824,
0.22479532659053802,
-0.5042599439620972,
0.05151640996336937,
-0.30060526728630066,
-0.4914908707141876,
-0.5528286695480347,
-0.0341804139316082,
0.6590328216552734,
0.8850516080856323,
-0.09683807939291,
0.2393205165863037,
-0.11196476221084595,
0.5235805511474609,
-1.19864821434021,
0.38384148478507996,
-0.6436847448348999,
0.376280277967453,
-0.2925613820552826,
-0.14827683568000793,
-0.6891554594039917,
0.12368638068437576,
0.28608056902885437,
-0.8812806606292725,
0.35476821660995483,
-0.00460269907489419,
0.7766361236572266,
-0.12175793945789337,
-0.14095701277256012,
-0.11175065487623215,
-0.7592396140098572,
0.47640207409858704,
-0.13964468240737915,
0.678363561630249,
0.13364022970199585,
0.7043378949165344,
-0.08634165674448013,
-1.055141568183899,
-0.6377758383750916,
-0.03143998607993126,
-0.06866840273141861,
0.2462255358695984,
-0.3367423713207245,
0.07774704694747925,
-0.10223589092493057,
0.46590301394462585,
-0.5696766972541809,
0.21931864321231842,
-0.2840977609157562,
-0.3147927224636078,
0.37225601077079773,
-0.1600182056427002,
-0.026905855163931847,
0.20344725251197815,
-0.9958552718162537,
-0.44695234298706055,
-0.24479685723781586,
0.05586864799261093,
0.08131537586450577,
0.6492179036140442,
-0.17930269241333008,
0.5003702640533447,
-0.3511916697025299,
0.947777509689331,
-0.0752139762043953,
-0.1002923995256424,
0.4938875138759613,
-0.2662162184715271,
-0.4165480434894562,
-0.4512588381767273,
0.5373809933662415,
0.23974965512752533,
0.11071734130382538,
-0.32460224628448486,
-0.5308202505111694,
-0.28801777958869934,
0.09732841700315475,
-0.5157896876335144,
-0.2591429352760315,
0.09676384925842285,
-0.25644227862358093,
-0.29733800888061523,
0.2894125282764435,
-0.9702911376953125,
-0.3399972915649414,
-0.010332095436751842,
0.9076508283615112,
-0.09321065247058868,
-0.6174864768981934,
0.039232246577739716,
-0.09941090643405914,
0.1639443337917328,
0.46331122517585754,
-1.0613216161727905,
0.22355344891548157,
0.5290639400482178,
0.9102684855461121,
0.10218291729688644,
-0.5365585684776306,
-0.810399055480957,
0.005103317089378834,
-0.040016837418079376,
0.6543012857437134,
-0.4401072561740875,
-0.23563280701637268,
0.008201438933610916,
-0.06943249702453613,
-0.3610830307006836,
-0.27186518907546997,
-0.09756602346897125,
-0.586033284664154,
0.45393118262290955,
0.011523122899234295,
-0.378527969121933,
-0.11084806174039841,
0.4130273461341858,
-0.4717651605606079,
0.4284120202064514,
0.4113641381263733,
-0.7429523468017578,
0.5205211043357849,
-0.8633708953857422,
0.010628223419189453,
0.20946276187896729,
-0.09862204641103745,
-0.27249085903167725,
0.29869773983955383,
0.2467336803674698,
0.5731989145278931,
0.06614585220813751,
-0.026338335126638412,
-0.6051770448684692,
-0.07889214903116226,
0.10440385341644287,
-0.3070128262042999,
0.6313156485557556,
0.28849080204963684,
0.08507959544658661,
0.44712457060813904,
-0.8517988324165344,
0.1676231324672699,
0.1477978527545929,
-0.23462966084480286,
-0.4007644057273865,
-0.2504578232765198,
0.15770158171653748,
0.07074181735515594,
0.18318286538124084,
-0.5872980952262878,
0.29804685711860657,
-0.5124409198760986,
0.1126941367983818,
0.8740132451057434,
-0.35215675830841064,
0.5107954740524292,
-0.3155476450920105,
0.53001868724823,
0.17261125147342682,
0.3643914461135864,
-0.2627483010292053,
-0.2543875277042389,
-0.8006632328033447,
-0.2803528308868408,
0.15423402190208435,
0.16287042200565338,
-1.401633381843567,
-0.2894459366798401,
-0.3932468593120575,
-0.5265021324157715,
-0.37137576937675476,
-0.0070299021899700165,
0.46124953031539917,
0.4264235496520996,
0.4151400327682495,
-0.4535064697265625,
-0.43255484104156494,
-0.4702725410461426,
-0.049559686332941055,
-0.28501826524734497,
-0.20196686685085297,
0.5134103894233704,
0.4875180125236511,
-0.23773813247680664,
1.0048682689666748,
-0.6348515748977661,
-0.6072865128517151,
0.058411791920661926,
0.10516897588968277,
-0.17242485284805298,
0.391623318195343,
0.8219337463378906,
-0.9124348759651184,
-0.3693719506263733,
0.08537627011537552,
-0.5018458366394043,
0.20828765630722046,
-0.00791118573397398,
0.0011024727718904614,
0.2783654034137726,
0.2852233946323395,
-0.3752802610397339,
0.16482755541801453,
0.8757560849189758,
-0.5449835658073425,
0.7736288905143738,
-0.3602741062641144,
-0.28225499391555786,
-1.0927340984344482,
-0.06293608993291855,
-0.09949881583452225,
-0.1603802591562271,
-0.5039373636245728,
0.5191154479980469,
0.010159462690353394,
-0.32143434882164,
-0.5427277088165283,
0.8151321411132812,
-0.6506243944168091,
-0.546901524066925,
-0.17117951810359955,
-0.02345305308699608,
0.035284705460071564,
0.4946632981300354,
0.1192084550857544,
0.7752171754837036,
0.807689905166626,
-0.329632431268692,
0.3489031493663788,
0.13559472560882568,
-0.18137694895267487,
0.5147920846939087,
-0.12409114837646484,
0.011095997877418995,
-0.1645243614912033,
0.09457448124885559,
-0.8771358728408813,
-0.3810786008834839,
0.13379202783107758,
-0.4698614478111267,
0.041041940450668335,
-0.00636443542316556,
-0.409849613904953,
-0.3804953694343567,
-0.0012061941670253873,
0.2032080590724945,
0.04597000032663345,
-0.8731532692909241,
0.7635769248008728,
0.1369791328907013,
0.2741444706916809,
-0.8076426386833191,
-0.366163969039917,
-0.18893283605575562,
0.23007184267044067,
-0.5435126423835754,
0.18620418012142181,
-0.005758778657764196,
-0.10917290300130844,
-0.11550013720989227,
-0.10098696500062943,
-0.38497018814086914,
0.30228641629219055,
0.28232672810554504,
0.06779854744672775,
-0.6921260952949524,
0.35130739212036133,
-0.29601746797561646,
0.11838773638010025,
-0.05705449730157852,
-0.4580804109573364,
0.48812493681907654,
-0.4762178063392639,
-0.4474818706512451,
0.13984480500221252,
0.09062489122152328,
0.7135566473007202,
-0.6907311677932739,
0.8462528586387634,
1.114158034324646,
-0.21395207941532135,
-0.29867443442344666,
-0.34060612320899963,
-0.28915607929229736,
-0.5168911218643188,
0.29724961519241333,
-0.5533877611160278,
-0.9581495523452759,
0.44876453280448914,
-0.10845765471458435,
0.22871345281600952,
-0.026181062683463097,
0.3886236548423767,
-0.1736588031053543,
0.5085898041725159,
1.253453016281128,
0.35060232877731323,
0.5126416087150574,
-0.13548347353935242,
-0.13706132769584656,
-0.4042830169200897,
-0.4177011251449585,
-0.2091832160949707,
-0.26445242762565613,
-0.4021022915840149,
-0.6702736616134644,
0.2932397723197937,
0.015718897804617882,
0.06435080617666245,
0.04988422617316246,
-0.12270767986774445,
0.5076923370361328,
0.5639381408691406,
0.29846805334091187,
0.17969028651714325,
0.2743513882160187,
-0.46035778522491455,
0.15814155340194702,
-0.792481005191803,
0.23127147555351257,
1.1834267377853394,
0.17310109734535217,
0.5240004658699036,
0.37101519107818604,
0.6006274819374084,
0.06734298169612885,
0.6890825033187866,
-0.6320699453353882,
0.43457093834877014,
-0.0990733951330185,
-0.5764119625091553,
-0.19384434819221497,
-0.4407382905483246,
-0.7562555074691772,
0.6621317863464355,
-0.5293388366699219,
-0.6869928240776062,
0.40272441506385803,
0.2226889282464981,
-0.3683757483959198,
0.5680770874023438,
-0.8784524202346802,
0.9421283006668091,
-0.2233864814043045,
-0.5049616098403931,
0.1644279658794403,
-0.8275155425071716,
0.40840837359428406,
-0.10996740311384201,
0.23694245517253876,
0.0542759969830513,
0.10425466299057007,
0.5068643093109131,
-0.36702045798301697,
0.9066036343574524,
-0.49928852915763855,
0.066920205950737,
-0.09344044327735901,
0.032165396958589554,
0.056065741926431656,
0.015247487463057041,
0.19626395404338837,
-0.03957343101501465,
-0.09588497132062912,
-0.48241686820983887,
-0.5964518189430237,
0.5034503936767578,
-0.7059491276741028,
-0.4868720471858978,
-0.46721315383911133,
-0.7307166457176208,
-0.5788077712059021,
0.5080920457839966,
-0.05744772404432297,
0.41725262999534607,
-0.2536233365535736,
0.3034217953681946,
0.4620332717895508,
-0.2350541353225708,
0.5156663060188293,
0.9081361889839172,
-0.7920873761177063,
-0.32063448429107666,
1.0081325769424438,
-0.1954980194568634,
0.6439366936683655,
0.7070019245147705,
0.23619017004966736,
-0.17223197221755981,
-0.381422221660614,
-0.39342713356018066,
0.0871681496500969,
-0.6820746660232544,
-0.20820458233356476,
-0.5431317090988159,
-0.03983727842569351,
-0.4745637774467468,
-0.24944478273391724,
-0.48325681686401367,
-0.16005568206310272,
-0.4713294506072998,
0.022729968652129173,
0.2455490678548813,
0.2384427934885025,
-0.23506976664066315,
0.42832693457603455,
-0.7469785213470459,
0.09165492653846741,
0.39466091990470886,
0.7107831239700317,
0.0819106474518776,
-0.10460330545902252,
-0.152614563703537,
0.22675713896751404,
-0.05760525166988373,
-0.5221520066261292,
0.3346250057220459,
0.5800859332084656,
0.42768073081970215,
0.6690064072608948,
0.11014526337385178,
0.7566385865211487,
-0.40071213245391846,
0.5215731263160706,
0.3016929626464844,
-0.522749662399292,
0.39666420221328735,
-0.24534645676612854,
0.3497161567211151,
0.48751524090766907,
0.5259284377098083,
-0.2256624698638916,
-0.14793601632118225,
-0.46166014671325684,
-0.4581015706062317,
0.5896346569061279,
-0.05016299709677696,
0.15584777295589447,
0.212119922041893,
0.09800540655851364,
0.3329686224460602,
0.19183872640132904,
-0.7841631174087524,
-0.21730144321918488,
-0.5244261622428894,
-0.0037202436942607164,
-0.41229239106178284,
-0.09007121622562408,
-0.1855422407388687,
-0.3069899082183838,
0.16007502377033234,
-0.5875827074050903,
0.33087682723999023,
-0.020577287301421165,
-0.33258292078971863,
-0.05537118390202522,
0.19522413611412048,
0.8007519841194153,
0.7265859246253967,
-0.3824392557144165,
0.10218078643083572,
-0.39015382528305054,
-0.6010984182357788,
0.06722044944763184,
0.29829704761505127,
0.005496697966009378,
0.014867820776998997,
0.4111259877681732,
1.0380253791809082,
0.44761011004447937,
-0.7278010249137878,
0.7345970869064331,
-0.10668850690126419,
-0.29535695910453796,
-0.2093922197818756,
0.0562342032790184,
-0.13014045357704163,
0.36007416248321533,
0.3860240876674652,
0.47087398171424866,
-0.2951790392398834,
-0.5715975165367126,
0.47942638397216797,
0.5227899551391602,
-0.5045393109321594,
-0.5092566013336182,
0.7395350933074951,
0.24117733538150787,
-0.11320731043815613,
0.44077152013778687,
-0.005718862172216177,
-0.2125067114830017,
0.25705692172050476,
0.6478064060211182,
0.6769596338272095,
-0.2401607781648636,
0.6899604201316833,
-0.038416825234889984,
0.2160222977399826,
0.14847137033939362,
0.4034017026424408,
-0.4081795811653137,
-1.076486587524414,
-0.11969812214374542,
-0.9798122048377991,
-0.44156113266944885,
-0.040623489767313004,
-0.7800460457801819,
0.028846755623817444,
-0.6208564639091492,
0.02239075116813183,
0.10263215005397797,
-0.21301107108592987,
-0.7027751207351685,
0.08832335472106934,
0.05940045043826103,
0.9805514216423035,
-0.9015268087387085,
0.8642797470092773,
0.987808346748352,
-0.5131477117538452,
-0.6402603387832642,
-0.13931210339069366,
-0.034890443086624146,
-0.9949706792831421,
0.6168127059936523,
0.17462871968746185,
0.15392081439495087,
0.3029998540878296,
-0.2415299415588379,
-0.9469265937805176,
1.1621642112731934,
0.2665250599384308,
-0.3046202063560486,
-0.1142670288681984,
0.09508509933948517,
0.5409679412841797,
-0.49570101499557495,
0.1447683572769165,
-0.1297348588705063,
0.24362702667713165,
0.23376600444316864,
-1.115501880645752,
-0.3275160491466522,
0.01231339666992426,
-0.22083160281181335,
0.00780617818236351,
-0.6219221353530884,
1.2182964086532593,
-0.4749097526073456,
-0.11873872578144073,
-0.13162758946418762,
0.9525043368339539,
-0.04330826550722122,
0.4991423487663269,
0.6386970281600952,
0.4020233452320099,
0.5919087529182434,
-0.05225251242518425,
0.7036918997764587,
0.16481715440750122,
0.45447081327438354,
1.2878494262695312,
-0.3957769572734833,
0.9329708218574524,
0.5909278988838196,
-0.08277390897274017,
0.4149748384952545,
0.23284277319908142,
0.04307401552796364,
0.604968249797821,
-0.19651754200458527,
-0.40103280544281006,
-0.10257723927497864,
0.03140542656183243,
-0.3495696485042572,
0.986196756362915,
0.43816661834716797,
-0.3793835937976837,
-0.7494691610336304,
0.7998711466789246,
-0.3142693042755127,
0.05707401782274246,
-0.46212267875671387,
0.7923778295516968,
-0.23974920809268951,
-0.2587597370147705,
0.577479898929596,
-0.012816384434700012,
0.6762774586677551,
-0.5140398740768433,
0.10757925361394882,
-0.4076330065727234,
0.37679341435432434,
-0.07018386572599411,
-0.4758128225803375,
0.06762748211622238,
-0.27708277106285095,
-0.18029817938804626,
-0.37703272700309753,
0.7836375832557678,
-0.3932510316371918,
-0.4168945550918579,
0.22055527567863464,
0.8088535070419312,
-0.10782673209905624,
-0.02378039062023163,
-0.4607257544994354,
-0.025244971737265587,
-0.10773978382349014,
-0.016194339841604233,
0.6725502610206604,
0.3157512843608856,
0.011280281469225883,
0.9214007258415222,
0.6807090044021606,
-0.04913279414176941,
0.2175656259059906,
-0.05231520161032677,
0.9564417004585266,
-0.13259892165660858,
-0.5051198601722717,
-0.4320700168609619,
0.3425196409225464,
0.19457416236400604,
-0.1821962296962738,
0.8817410469055176,
0.36226344108581543,
1.3247042894363403,
-0.34489351511001587,
0.34480586647987366,
0.0005617691786028445,
0.24995116889476776,
-0.5046898126602173,
0.9609720706939697,
-0.834103524684906,
-0.045324478298425674,
-0.37821412086486816,
-0.817615807056427,
-0.4120458662509918,
0.36140182614326477,
0.024925481528043747,
-0.17995209991931915,
0.2890004515647888,
0.680429220199585,
-0.42624086141586304,
-0.02382121980190277,
0.48275089263916016,
0.1395358443260193,
0.24787406623363495,
0.5236912965774536,
0.4254761338233948,
-0.2396785169839859,
0.3320344388484955,
-0.5720957517623901,
-0.3172966241836548,
-0.3234803378582001,
-0.7565557956695557,
-0.7552379369735718,
-0.8458699584007263,
-0.1516900658607483,
-0.03543109819293022,
0.1202671229839325,
0.6764098405838013,
0.6821076273918152,
-0.5898140668869019,
-0.15288911759853363,
-0.02139570564031601,
0.09738384187221527,
-0.4759502708911896,
-0.2597668468952179,
0.09773804992437363,
-0.19712045788764954,
-0.4017584025859833,
0.439581960439682,
0.14512236416339874,
0.36642736196517944,
-0.6054266095161438,
0.17159414291381836,
-0.37950611114501953,
-0.3225206732749939,
0.7379913926124573,
0.4954358637332916,
-0.6010903716087341,
-0.46481865644454956,
-0.040052853524684906,
0.19533884525299072,
-0.03366610035300255,
0.7004521489143372,
-1.0517724752426147,
0.9676880240440369,
0.35596200823783875,
0.6569194197654724,
0.1683403104543686,
-0.0840761661529541,
0.5125378370285034,
-1.3351287841796875,
0.5530205368995667,
0.2892463505268097,
0.17380742728710175,
0.1817200481891632,
-0.06663156300783157,
0.27794259786605835,
0.5310360193252563,
-0.01269080862402916,
-1.1606419086456299,
0.21678288280963898,
-0.7914093136787415,
-0.3621883988380432,
0.6246437430381775,
-0.43071356415748596,
-0.1838248074054718,
0.21930600702762604,
0.3469149172306061,
-0.08478793501853943,
0.10539136826992035,
0.4938960075378418,
0.4359043538570404,
0.09025093168020248,
-0.46891605854034424,
-0.3611813485622406,
0.34761592745780945,
0.19884444773197174,
-0.618062436580658,
0.09141931682825089,
0.5876033306121826,
0.21714439988136292,
0.3284054100513458,
0.7176220417022705,
0.14215323328971863,
0.3068116307258606,
0.21867792308330536,
0.08157188445329666,
-0.5403712391853333,
-0.6798778772354126,
-0.16830512881278992,
0.6173192858695984,
-0.0515112429857254,
-0.4112761914730072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01230v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01230v1
|
LLM as a Mastermind: A Survey of Strategic Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T16:50:54 | 2024-04-01T16:50:54 |
Yadong Zhang, Shaoguang Mao, Tao Ge, Xun Wang, Adrian de Wynter, Yan Xia, Wenshan Wu, Ting Song, Man Lan, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a comprehensive survey of the current status and
opportunities for Large Language Models (LLMs) in strategic reasoning, a
sophisticated form of reasoning that necessitates understanding and predicting
adversary actions in multi-agent settings while adjusting strategies
accordingly. Strategic reasoning is distinguished by its focus on the dynamic
and uncertain nature of interactions among multi-agents, where comprehending
the environment and anticipating the behavior of others is crucial. We explore
the scopes, applications, methodologies, and evaluation metrics related to
strategic reasoning with LLMs, highlighting the burgeoning development in this
area and the interdisciplinary approaches enhancing their decision-making
performance. It aims to systematize and clarify the scattered literature on
this subject, providing a systematic review that underscores the importance of
strategic reasoning as a critical cognitive capability and offers insights into
future research directions and potential improvements.
|
[
-0.3719538450241089,
-1.0171568393707275,
1.1629161834716797,
0.08229127526283264,
0.082686647772789,
0.5671424269676208,
-0.49170082807540894,
-0.10450456291437149,
0.13745512068271637,
0.556264340877533,
-0.9452047348022461,
-0.47912654280662537,
-0.7146790623664856,
-0.13956540822982788,
0.03210613131523132,
0.2478916496038437,
-0.12155938893556595,
0.33852139115333557,
-0.09754744917154312,
-0.18355399370193481,
-0.6894844770431519,
-0.6002537608146667,
-0.8730251789093018,
-0.5236291289329529,
0.4648965895175934,
0.4634067118167877,
0.733101487159729,
0.299972802400589,
0.75889652967453,
0.42746633291244507,
-0.025721246376633644,
0.3490772545337677,
-0.49622368812561035,
0.7398603558540344,
-0.6401374936103821,
-0.5045915246009827,
-0.5336563587188721,
0.07483342289924622,
0.7936264872550964,
0.6628550887107849,
-0.42055627703666687,
0.08754978328943253,
-0.24181781709194183,
0.6092773675918579,
-0.7169875502586365,
0.29229995608329773,
-0.9416521787643433,
-0.02365867607295513,
-0.15660779178142548,
0.050879765301942825,
-0.36877506971359253,
0.08126936107873917,
0.33647167682647705,
-0.38218849897384644,
-0.5506194233894348,
0.17073026299476624,
0.33031243085861206,
0.4423452615737915,
-0.4861898124217987,
-0.339285671710968,
-1.0041049718856812,
1.0688698291778564,
-0.5139479041099548,
0.3559342324733734,
0.0857158750295639,
0.6366453766822815,
-0.2824341654777527,
-0.7068241834640503,
-0.23022960126399994,
-0.19007425010204315,
0.36890438199043274,
0.31622517108917236,
-0.40005356073379517,
0.17118020355701447,
0.07344678044319153,
-0.1064646765589714,
-0.3494592607021332,
0.282495379447937,
-0.05751608684659004,
0.0811486542224884,
1.045717477798462,
0.5462717413902283,
0.05267411842942238,
0.2759508788585663,
-0.24458250403404236,
0.28157731890678406,
-0.5820785760879517,
-0.056662701070308685,
0.11602258682250977,
0.07089737057685852,
0.22508849203586578,
0.5380085110664368,
-0.23178231716156006,
0.6721654534339905,
-0.001164889894425869,
-0.34373265504837036,
-0.3944787383079529,
-0.36124518513679504,
-0.3024247884750366,
-0.02464703842997551,
0.7666981220245361,
0.3582109808921814,
0.41732707619667053,
-0.11067847907543182,
-0.2153165638446808,
-0.043043121695518494,
0.2967647612094879,
-0.4228982627391815,
-0.11324227601289749,
0.3101605474948883,
-0.4373410642147064,
-0.05564076080918312,
-0.2040507197380066,
-0.6334763169288635,
-0.3679548501968384,
-0.38532453775405884,
0.10668598115444183,
-0.33955055475234985,
-0.3417229652404785,
0.3089786469936371,
-0.23335720598697662,
0.3014402985572815,
0.38181382417678833,
-0.5555785894393921,
0.11692246049642563,
0.8672764897346497,
0.5749263763427734,
-0.34767550230026245,
-0.4802667498588562,
0.057733140885829926,
0.5129523873329163,
-0.6286529302597046,
0.797188401222229,
-0.6434312462806702,
-0.5602813363075256,
0.08303888887166977,
-0.34712105989456177,
-0.15915368497371674,
-0.6164402365684509,
0.7748231291770935,
-0.539110541343689,
-0.17907525599002838,
-0.4572789967060089,
-0.4219418168067932,
-0.45866936445236206,
0.6842710971832275,
-0.4975787103176117,
0.4792517125606537,
-0.33498290181159973,
-0.2228558212518692,
0.1934836208820343,
-0.6736308932304382,
-0.43924546241760254,
0.35072723031044006,
-0.4150390625,
-0.03952030837535858,
0.02059471793472767,
0.08502616733312607,
0.5578811168670654,
-0.6748558878898621,
0.587433934211731,
-0.3761664628982544,
-0.09730897098779678,
0.7532215714454651,
-0.3220236599445343,
0.6886517405509949,
0.28588932752609253,
-0.20612528920173645,
0.38188642263412476,
-0.06867292523384094,
0.1909080445766449,
0.5220212340354919,
-0.3674193024635315,
-0.09878329932689667,
0.527460515499115,
-0.772942841053009,
0.2559932470321655,
0.5303671360015869,
0.00885100569576025,
0.3713516592979431,
-0.005166623741388321,
0.5668242573738098,
0.8585242033004761,
0.15947581827640533,
0.5776534080505371,
-0.23702439665794373,
0.5313072800636292,
-0.22076767683029175,
0.34059208631515503,
0.13208962976932526,
-0.48687827587127686,
-0.6799600720405579,
-0.3021361231803894,
-0.019081449136137962,
0.7269589900970459,
-0.8045702576637268,
0.06611476093530655,
-0.34295541048049927,
-0.5966589450836182,
-0.2770881950855255,
0.06563784927129745,
0.27786985039711,
-0.22043171525001526,
-0.016618499532341957,
0.24583645164966583,
-0.653166651725769,
-0.9772454500198364,
-0.5542998313903809,
-0.21150167286396027,
0.41273370385169983,
0.6063805222511292,
0.5054665803909302,
-0.4155288636684418,
0.7062594294548035,
-0.701938271522522,
-0.16313736140727997,
-0.9255282282829285,
-0.12654556334018707,
0.19240330159664154,
0.13821393251419067,
0.2125381976366043,
-0.5530843138694763,
-0.27143511176109314,
-0.26934316754341125,
-0.9887608885765076,
0.20979882776737213,
-0.1402009278535843,
-0.2325967401266098,
-0.10172081738710403,
0.8502740859985352,
-0.9425984025001526,
-0.08788185566663742,
0.4286482036113739,
-0.20923903584480286,
0.730557382106781,
-0.04044346138834953,
0.12668496370315552,
-0.7196844220161438,
-0.2961048483848572,
-0.04662354663014412,
0.167616605758667,
-0.7846429347991943,
0.62532639503479,
-0.3055803179740906,
0.18175917863845825,
-0.22279129922389984,
0.5627570748329163,
-0.738680899143219,
0.09206327795982361,
-0.21571682393550873,
0.24634870886802673,
-0.42201632261276245,
0.3182241916656494,
0.11959175765514374,
0.6294324398040771,
0.6469968557357788,
-0.41988080739974976,
0.6164988875389099,
-0.16005505621433258,
-0.3488484025001526,
0.6608871817588806,
-0.4633294641971588,
-0.11312922835350037,
-0.04348254203796387,
0.32079142332077026,
-0.8486703634262085,
-0.10150918364524841,
0.23221923410892487,
-0.43608516454696655,
0.3011612296104431,
-0.037774138152599335,
-0.5820579528808594,
-0.553110659122467,
0.0140219796448946,
0.20790567994117737,
0.3265756666660309,
0.0603555329144001,
0.8536490201950073,
0.7028784155845642,
-0.2127646952867508,
-0.6184074282646179,
-0.6107203364372253,
0.29924827814102173,
-0.27585068345069885,
-0.46434181928634644,
-0.02795208804309368,
-0.08242908865213394,
-0.9823788404464722,
-0.2449985295534134,
-0.047391377389431,
-0.10545767843723297,
0.2313813865184784,
0.24524402618408203,
0.2381114810705185,
-0.3224864900112152,
-0.02577454037964344,
-0.24111288785934448,
-0.0842331200838089,
0.5355907082557678,
-0.4744828939437866,
0.42884528636932373,
-0.24903905391693115,
-0.49403998255729675,
0.10079990327358246,
0.39307844638824463,
0.6969238519668579,
-0.44719958305358887,
0.6812871694564819,
0.2663949131965637,
-0.3369539678096771,
-0.530328631401062,
-0.6504364013671875,
-0.20459091663360596,
-0.484620064496994,
0.44963201880455017,
-0.36299824714660645,
-0.8981214761734009,
0.49117311835289,
-0.5821405053138733,
0.010654428973793983,
0.43209108710289,
0.8109558820724487,
-0.2483385056257248,
1.0704774856567383,
0.3031335771083832,
-0.1329668164253235,
0.0896311029791832,
-0.37283048033714294,
0.45739811658859253,
-0.6148515939712524,
-0.470732718706131,
-0.16932979226112366,
-0.553053081035614,
-0.3481370210647583,
-0.6580770015716553,
0.3635675311088562,
-0.19940397143363953,
-0.36007750034332275,
-0.24878665804862976,
-0.22258929908275604,
0.5573129653930664,
0.49687373638153076,
-0.03280114755034447,
0.17745134234428406,
-0.40819859504699707,
-0.372609943151474,
-0.06275151669979095,
-0.601955771446228,
-0.5081021189689636,
0.953136146068573,
0.35535916686058044,
0.6262816786766052,
0.665338397026062,
0.33275771141052246,
0.13831666111946106,
-0.009136623702943325,
-1.060774564743042,
1.1210441589355469,
0.05819707736372948,
-1.0002470016479492,
-0.4750007390975952,
-0.3456130623817444,
-0.9605394005775452,
0.35645657777786255,
-0.35241997241973877,
-0.7319281697273254,
-0.2348877638578415,
-0.3693598508834839,
-0.5578325986862183,
0.5647262930870056,
-0.39852437376976013,
0.6542977690696716,
-0.5360183119773865,
-0.34527453780174255,
-0.5211367607116699,
-0.4396806061267853,
0.621326208114624,
-0.021894995123147964,
0.10678336769342422,
-0.27167966961860657,
-0.43929070234298706,
0.5883194208145142,
0.14175257086753845,
0.6408475041389465,
0.04901682585477829,
-0.052984267473220825,
0.5132783651351929,
0.32501327991485596,
0.3942151665687561,
-0.09078682959079742,
-0.026386944577097893,
0.16552504897117615,
-0.29430168867111206,
-0.19060833752155304,
-0.5154251456260681,
0.6996836066246033,
-0.5467633605003357,
-1.069608211517334,
-0.5205990076065063,
-0.7402468919754028,
-0.412710964679718,
0.21309523284435272,
-0.03575999289751053,
-0.024671269580721855,
-0.42822951078414917,
0.15788868069648743,
1.0113931894302368,
0.05601121112704277,
0.5250991582870483,
0.7873526215553284,
-0.12149660289287567,
-0.33756759762763977,
0.7020412087440491,
0.39495909214019775,
0.17701603472232819,
0.28520917892456055,
-0.00846411008387804,
-0.36462166905403137,
-1.0995407104492188,
-0.2177194207906723,
0.3760628402233124,
-0.8949050307273865,
-0.04560898616909981,
-0.597405195236206,
-0.29844340682029724,
-0.04485628381371498,
-0.38798001408576965,
-0.34061428904533386,
-0.1746758371591568,
0.10958293825387955,
-0.02602175995707512,
-0.11722920089960098,
0.9534643888473511,
0.08855495601892471,
0.3330085873603821,
-0.46361044049263,
0.026635976508259773,
0.47662320733070374,
0.09431552141904831,
0.2558436989784241,
-0.25607064366340637,
-0.08008921891450882,
-0.12409178167581558,
-0.31168442964553833,
-1.1067051887512207,
0.2714341878890991,
-0.20771156251430511,
1.191019892692566,
0.51450514793396,
-0.10559628903865814,
0.34306350350379944,
-0.4816019833087921,
0.8565552830696106,
0.013616177253425121,
-0.5777431726455688,
0.5127412676811218,
-0.6093268990516663,
0.5451400279998779,
0.43976014852523804,
0.5584408640861511,
-0.27678513526916504,
-0.21325203776359558,
-0.6363654732704163,
-0.5690130591392517,
0.36758220195770264,
-0.14127855002880096,
-0.33412256836891174,
0.1079481989145279,
0.16051745414733887,
-0.4862075746059418,
0.26647040247917175,
-0.3350033760070801,
-0.40496283769607544,
0.6747422218322754,
0.04989113286137581,
-0.3643542230129242,
-0.24844656884670258,
-0.35175520181655884,
-0.24791878461837769,
0.6929949522018433,
-0.06421925872564316,
0.18728405237197876,
-0.30342188477516174,
-0.100068598985672,
-0.06965754926204681,
0.30094802379608154,
0.6241068840026855,
0.8300653696060181,
-0.057169895619153976,
0.052478667348623276,
0.49871551990509033,
-0.27246174216270447,
0.279864639043808,
-0.15359102189540863,
0.05108356475830078,
-0.185444176197052,
0.39367154240608215,
0.24806350469589233,
0.2966488003730774,
-0.9842632412910461,
0.6205849647521973,
-0.043109677731990814,
-0.48217374086380005,
-0.5450231432914734,
-0.025934580713510513,
0.4226740598678589,
0.7736452221870422,
0.4001544713973999,
0.13806644082069397,
0.17145270109176636,
-0.7637010812759399,
-0.12630823254585266,
0.8705583214759827,
-0.13128025829792023,
0.07972857356071472,
0.3239462375640869,
0.1196894571185112,
-0.1483025699853897,
0.49514561891555786,
-0.3350755274295807,
-0.7953943610191345,
0.418760746717453,
0.17006990313529968,
0.950378954410553,
-0.4018925130367279,
0.05252465233206749,
0.1774047613143921,
0.6490040421485901,
-0.02577066980302334,
0.3050532042980194,
0.172743558883667,
-0.850492537021637,
-0.5232568979263306,
-0.31021058559417725,
-0.6201371550559998,
0.19034217298030853,
-0.20687279105186462,
-0.10944787412881851,
-0.7547039985656738,
-0.48264119029045105,
0.06910508871078491,
0.26246315240859985,
-0.6142387390136719,
-0.12081607431173325,
0.4517890214920044,
1.0092084407806396,
-0.47899556159973145,
0.5149521231651306,
0.8158990740776062,
-0.1879408061504364,
-0.6039655804634094,
-0.04875966161489487,
0.5209759473800659,
-0.8608619570732117,
0.745198667049408,
-0.25602486729621887,
-0.41755804419517517,
-0.2683054506778717,
-0.5269911289215088,
-1.0742400884628296,
1.096977949142456,
0.19364890456199646,
-0.4555300772190094,
-0.03528951480984688,
0.020436154678463936,
0.2754952609539032,
-0.5086183547973633,
0.15046243369579315,
0.9075037837028503,
0.7884432673454285,
0.18282055854797363,
-0.6292647123336792,
0.072830431163311,
0.2164260894060135,
-0.27309298515319824,
0.24739854037761688,
-1.0311449766159058,
0.8465266227722168,
-0.46359243988990784,
-0.1586838811635971,
-0.08259603381156921,
0.6549962759017944,
0.41284751892089844,
0.2746979594230652,
0.19533072412014008,
0.5720345377922058,
0.6585796475410461,
-0.31688231229782104,
0.688248336315155,
-0.1011403277516365,
-0.11912615597248077,
1.0221571922302246,
-0.5218691825866699,
0.934124231338501,
0.16185681521892548,
-0.15127994120121002,
0.607862114906311,
0.46945419907569885,
0.0837656632065773,
0.21210990846157074,
0.3548656702041626,
-0.3756144642829895,
-0.7543699145317078,
-0.12264154106378555,
0.04807893931865692,
0.901351273059845,
0.9394489526748657,
-0.31676676869392395,
-0.08909022808074951,
-0.4601043164730072,
0.24842126667499542,
0.14961113035678864,
-0.49800652265548706,
1.0009177923202515,
0.2094578891992569,
-0.9893654584884644,
0.18771255016326904,
0.1649993360042572,
0.6256256699562073,
-0.6503018736839294,
0.2676108479499817,
0.0813460499048233,
0.45708784461021423,
0.14463819563388824,
-1.2057570219039917,
0.18584805727005005,
-0.2564985156059265,
-0.15317434072494507,
-0.37670043110847473,
0.8005961775779724,
-0.27365779876708984,
-0.2821645736694336,
0.44641515612602234,
1.1736838817596436,
-0.01863592118024826,
-0.25556427240371704,
-1.2069233655929565,
0.20106199383735657,
-0.13991861045360565,
-0.15920588374137878,
0.17320610582828522,
0.7068696022033691,
0.042580775916576385,
1.075154185295105,
0.5296263694763184,
0.13067328929901123,
-0.14758779108524323,
-0.09496597200632095,
0.6080940961837769,
-0.7290489673614502,
-0.237523153424263,
-1.2106611728668213,
0.1400509923696518,
-0.2683078348636627,
-0.1238633394241333,
0.8994620442390442,
0.4489479660987854,
0.5152633786201477,
-0.03576454892754555,
0.8143085837364197,
0.48196202516555786,
0.3509373366832733,
-0.43448010087013245,
0.7264937162399292,
-0.2044050693511963,
0.05373070761561394,
0.0490715429186821,
-0.706055760383606,
-0.1353360414505005,
0.35845187306404114,
-0.7156183123588562,
0.03604797646403313,
0.6297750473022461,
0.626254677772522,
0.15240420401096344,
0.027878567576408386,
0.38959208130836487,
0.2806088328361511,
0.1771191656589508,
0.8263359069824219,
1.2696959972381592,
0.24948543310165405,
0.4779009222984314,
0.2931160032749176,
-0.16530507802963257,
-0.41944384574890137,
-0.766896665096283,
-0.9855974912643433,
-0.4934377372264862,
-0.1552739292383194,
0.03657517582178116,
0.12010905146598816,
0.8733834028244019,
0.7294881343841553,
-0.34950506687164307,
-0.588257908821106,
0.35252583026885986,
0.5329304337501526,
-0.26718056201934814,
-0.1360708773136139,
-0.20622430741786957,
-0.2144547700881958,
-0.39601296186447144,
0.5193661451339722,
0.5811740756034851,
0.028932692483067513,
-0.5776307582855225,
-0.3114389479160309,
-0.5694565773010254,
0.7438386678695679,
0.8158230185508728,
0.1560514122247696,
-1.0846248865127563,
0.2875165045261383,
0.03671984001994133,
-0.12534449994564056,
-0.34722742438316345,
0.8230499029159546,
-0.32407158613204956,
0.18820513784885406,
0.328580766916275,
0.686642050743103,
0.1079883798956871,
-0.380062997341156,
0.5254794955253601,
-0.2775454521179199,
-0.1612301617860794,
0.4609723389148712,
0.6312200427055359,
0.11771130561828613,
-0.17892861366271973,
0.533965528011322,
0.13210880756378174,
-0.5971261858940125,
-0.508152425289154,
0.5090059041976929,
-0.8371891975402832,
-0.900530993938446,
1.2662853002548218,
0.020155368372797966,
-0.2096487134695053,
0.025762321427464485,
-0.17428374290466309,
-0.13157853484153748,
-0.39189374446868896,
0.22849233448505402,
1.0071052312850952,
0.07287729531526566,
-0.26971057057380676,
-0.8554069995880127,
0.44710463285446167,
0.27071383595466614,
-0.6980434060096741,
0.06058941036462784,
0.5731459259986877,
-0.08804697543382645,
0.19887441396713257,
0.6230518817901611,
0.25551626086235046,
0.10573498159646988,
0.11398280411958694,
-0.37057003378868103,
0.15842826664447784,
-0.5726097822189331,
-0.10252215713262558,
0.2752646505832672,
0.3503662943840027,
0.12140975147485733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01226v1
|
Stable Code Technical Report
| 2024-04-01T16:39:36 | 2024-04-01T16:39:36 |
Nikhil Pinnaparaju, Reshinth Adithyan, Duy Phung, Jonathan Tow, James Baicoianu, Ashish Datta, Maksym Zhuravinskyi, Dakota Mahan, Marco Bellagente, Carlos Riquelme, Nathan Cooper
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Stable Code, the first in our new-generation of code language
models series, which serves as a general-purpose base code language model
targeting code completion, reasoning, math, and other software
engineering-based tasks. Additionally, we introduce an instruction variant
named Stable Code Instruct that allows conversing with the model in a natural
chat interface for performing question-answering and instruction-based tasks.
In this technical report, we detail the data and training procedure leading to
both models. Their weights are available via Hugging Face for anyone to
download and use at https://huggingface.co/stabilityai/stable-code-3b and
https://huggingface.co/stabilityai/stable-code-instruct-3b. This report
contains thorough evaluations of the models, including multilingual programming
benchmarks, and the MT benchmark focusing on multi-turn dialogues. At the time
of its release, Stable Code is the state-of-the-art open model under 3B
parameters and even performs comparably to larger models of sizes 7 billion and
15 billion parameters on the popular Multi-PL benchmark. Stable Code Instruct
also exhibits state-of-the-art performance on the MT-Bench coding tasks and on
Multi-PL completion compared to other instruction tuned models. Given its
appealing small size, we also provide throughput measurements on a number of
edge devices. In addition, we open source several quantized checkpoints and
provide their performance metrics compared to the original model.
|
[
-0.17386460304260254,
-0.6723772883415222,
0.06602586060762405,
0.4207366704940796,
-0.02575446292757988,
0.050503067672252655,
-0.2231583446264267,
-0.6896538734436035,
-0.05806421861052513,
0.6607791185379028,
-0.17513777315616608,
-0.5169582366943359,
-0.360295832157135,
-0.13940685987472534,
-0.46030193567276,
1.0160102844238281,
-0.19404210150241852,
0.34102576971054077,
-0.40311354398727417,
-0.3937520980834961,
-0.668454110622406,
-0.7355380654335022,
-0.3889409303665161,
-0.062386415898799896,
0.10553066432476044,
0.35854572057724,
0.8318719863891602,
0.6070191860198975,
0.5600980520248413,
0.27400869131088257,
0.006414956878870726,
-0.37332847714424133,
-0.6435828804969788,
0.08139127492904663,
0.3655533194541931,
-0.4103783369064331,
-0.7527861595153809,
0.10954931378364563,
0.5386992692947388,
0.543228030204773,
-0.4527546763420105,
0.11959759145975113,
-0.1063397079706192,
0.7636480331420898,
-0.44683822989463806,
0.27716538310050964,
-0.623465895652771,
-0.26616334915161133,
-0.060272715985774994,
0.10346103459596634,
-0.9216851592063904,
-0.4905802011489868,
-0.06977353990077972,
-0.38910722732543945,
-0.147325798869133,
-0.3531050980091095,
0.9900066256523132,
0.16599823534488678,
-0.3448079228401184,
-0.3573228716850281,
-0.4638650715351105,
0.6600022315979004,
-0.638912558555603,
0.4697873592376709,
0.416242390871048,
0.2894718050956726,
0.25999292731285095,
-0.7089402675628662,
-0.15064756572246552,
-0.6917296648025513,
0.22654516994953156,
-0.04393870756030083,
0.04720224812626839,
0.20803606510162354,
0.19668102264404297,
0.520114004611969,
-0.30434849858283997,
0.0872456356883049,
-0.4850024878978729,
-0.11637464165687561,
0.2801835834980011,
-0.015235219150781631,
0.39536410570144653,
0.15999598801136017,
-0.2350679188966751,
0.06063326075673103,
-0.7783533334732056,
0.07287623733282089,
0.273253470659256,
0.1793595254421234,
-0.49061769247055054,
0.5639023780822754,
-0.2783561050891876,
0.7929796576499939,
-0.09297268092632294,
0.023733440786600113,
0.3169293701648712,
-0.37139028310775757,
-0.02634401246905327,
-0.06749587506055832,
0.3360990583896637,
0.5707319974899292,
0.2459673285484314,
-0.2375270575284958,
-0.3105064034461975,
0.277085542678833,
0.48432111740112305,
-1.0466046333312988,
-0.44031235575675964,
0.15306785702705383,
-0.6151943206787109,
-0.2767004072666168,
0.058812178671360016,
-0.4563320577144623,
-0.22949674725532532,
-0.2865108549594879,
0.3144404888153076,
-0.38664451241493225,
-0.4806632399559021,
0.2902667224407196,
0.14431530237197876,
0.17032702267169952,
0.2760762572288513,
-0.7257170677185059,
0.3682284951210022,
0.6036193370819092,
0.6708311438560486,
0.053607646375894547,
-0.15795665979385376,
-0.7150331139564514,
-0.06161326542496681,
-0.2005935162305832,
0.2610081732273102,
-0.5761908888816833,
-0.2590639591217041,
0.11868866533041,
0.05284387990832329,
0.105105459690094,
-0.3158881962299347,
0.4388897120952606,
-0.5992313623428345,
0.11141707003116608,
0.005720995832234621,
-0.4391329288482666,
-0.04276540130376816,
0.35624366998672485,
-0.8066397309303284,
0.9223500490188599,
0.38560178875923157,
-0.8176881670951843,
0.0006420582067221403,
-0.5160307884216309,
-0.15108689665794373,
0.00026133694336749613,
-0.05353030562400818,
-0.5444831252098083,
-0.12521301209926605,
-0.2502044141292572,
0.10232561826705933,
-0.056659504771232605,
0.12547482550144196,
-0.48343706130981445,
-0.5471469759941101,
0.18832705914974213,
-0.11260246485471725,
0.7688953280448914,
0.2152990996837616,
-0.14624808728694916,
0.1952158510684967,
-0.6491747498512268,
0.28926193714141846,
0.01672453247010708,
-0.48378223180770874,
0.059471022337675095,
0.1040060818195343,
-0.0885075107216835,
-0.021540159359574318,
0.32650458812713623,
-0.571858823299408,
0.3426305651664734,
-0.13275980949401855,
0.6368233561515808,
0.2822738289833069,
-0.1509794443845749,
0.5218901634216309,
-0.19145390391349792,
0.6335646510124207,
-0.11595328897237778,
0.345647931098938,
-0.38252416253089905,
-0.4757789075374603,
-0.6236674785614014,
-0.006777002941817045,
0.5687896609306335,
0.843417763710022,
-0.7472532987594604,
-0.20123982429504395,
-0.19953079521656036,
-0.39874503016471863,
-0.4199495315551758,
0.14704109728336334,
0.7176119685173035,
0.35115131735801697,
0.2875947654247284,
-0.16137997806072235,
-0.5384177565574646,
-0.7073065638542175,
0.04501154273748398,
-0.41493871808052063,
0.24385645985603333,
-0.27207115292549133,
0.1853744387626648,
-0.275920033454895,
0.6233037710189819,
-0.15718266367912292,
0.3971855640411377,
-0.2737700045108795,
0.2777697741985321,
0.07346795499324799,
0.7686908841133118,
0.8384061455726624,
-0.6621295809745789,
-0.43391191959381104,
0.12958553433418274,
-0.6210618615150452,
0.0839996412396431,
0.23868300020694733,
-0.3207308351993561,
0.5333829522132874,
0.44039782881736755,
-0.5654382109642029,
0.2418123036623001,
0.9083558917045593,
-0.10448025912046432,
0.37122735381126404,
0.0340893492102623,
0.2772516906261444,
-0.8235982656478882,
-0.024038271978497505,
0.05322724208235741,
-0.25491154193878174,
-0.5463895797729492,
0.4963736832141876,
0.46340614557266235,
-0.26875272393226624,
-0.49501925706863403,
0.11710210144519806,
-0.5880809426307678,
0.09073364734649658,
-0.1429957151412964,
0.004977086093276739,
-0.0258820578455925,
0.4973748028278351,
-0.04210545867681503,
0.9137042164802551,
0.5388832688331604,
-0.48907172679901123,
-0.03923896700143814,
0.13246233761310577,
-0.2167583703994751,
0.08499734103679657,
-0.9880937933921814,
0.3992255926132202,
0.13326868414878845,
-0.012779281474649906,
-0.5831537246704102,
-0.2059328407049179,
0.08821989595890045,
-0.6014173030853271,
0.5291630029678345,
-0.6645699143409729,
-0.37215641140937805,
-0.3027578592300415,
-0.23759663105010986,
0.4165327847003937,
0.668094277381897,
-0.15061460435390472,
0.20698772370815277,
0.7358687520027161,
-0.06254072487354279,
-0.5498688817024231,
-0.588300347328186,
-0.1654195934534073,
0.109327532351017,
-0.647060751914978,
0.09684379398822784,
-0.24966585636138916,
-0.2757096588611603,
-0.03426041081547737,
-0.18503567576408386,
-0.3911075294017792,
0.20366060733795166,
0.385104238986969,
0.4001043736934662,
-0.3426138460636139,
-0.1836329847574234,
-0.16014732420444489,
-0.22665739059448242,
0.1387501060962677,
-0.21789056062698364,
0.37676534056663513,
-0.7562676072120667,
-0.1865081489086151,
-0.34345078468322754,
0.22070005536079407,
0.6362321376800537,
-0.42199090123176575,
0.8055118322372437,
0.2576932907104492,
-0.4607461392879486,
0.0375475212931633,
-0.24065633118152618,
0.1882738620042801,
-0.46685323119163513,
0.2547357976436615,
-0.2968226969242096,
-0.9682137966156006,
0.5506706833839417,
0.17377354204654694,
0.3408161997795105,
0.1996452510356903,
0.35021287202835083,
0.06500773131847382,
1.1705832481384277,
0.9181700944900513,
-0.040968067944049835,
0.5454022288322449,
-0.21080510318279266,
-0.033583760261535645,
-0.21252281963825226,
-0.16755850613117218,
-0.8259305357933044,
0.10088355839252472,
-0.3265514373779297,
-0.2939765155315399,
0.1763068586587906,
0.6890630125999451,
-0.3909324109554291,
0.5454074740409851,
-0.6456863880157471,
0.5742596387863159,
0.2914336025714874,
0.056959524750709534,
0.05960382521152496,
-0.18265272676944733,
0.08472692221403122,
0.12627728283405304,
-0.5498096346855164,
-0.6624638438224792,
0.9007778167724609,
0.5762917399406433,
0.7858376502990723,
0.07464975118637085,
0.5290323495864868,
0.22701653838157654,
0.5134604573249817,
-0.37062299251556396,
0.46581974625587463,
-0.21561770141124725,
-0.5064738988876343,
0.04223093017935753,
-0.609926164150238,
-0.6234194040298462,
-0.35356706380844116,
0.043040912598371506,
-0.6030732989311218,
-0.3653610050678253,
0.3630576431751251,
-0.21441806852817535,
0.09891511499881744,
-1.0393288135528564,
1.2222565412521362,
-0.2781131863594055,
-0.20774783194065094,
-0.25594329833984375,
-0.8215177655220032,
0.520870566368103,
0.3323749005794525,
-0.03976791724562645,
-0.09465381503105164,
0.12181772291660309,
0.35291343927383423,
-0.42296290397644043,
0.714838445186615,
-0.39714115858078003,
-0.10386211425065994,
0.5222815871238708,
0.2700698673725128,
0.28933072090148926,
0.3174697160720825,
-0.4706571698188782,
0.2594727575778961,
0.365544855594635,
-0.47684913873672485,
-0.45582371950149536,
0.5812693238258362,
-0.7840121388435364,
-0.20723943412303925,
-0.057274896651506424,
-0.4382569491863251,
-0.069069504737854,
0.26120197772979736,
0.080287866294384,
1.0013436079025269,
-0.0020080669783055782,
0.4504275619983673,
0.845810055732727,
-0.11509334295988083,
0.4253770709037781,
0.4788060784339905,
-0.5441038608551025,
-0.5585839748382568,
0.7593497633934021,
-0.014073969796299934,
0.6131521463394165,
0.4513680636882782,
-0.41173264384269714,
0.0466662235558033,
-0.725990355014801,
-0.7054498195648193,
-0.10405789315700531,
-0.8036556839942932,
-0.473309189081192,
-0.6095089316368103,
-0.47242337465286255,
-0.08492347598075867,
-0.14262017607688904,
-0.6435723900794983,
-0.5052490234375,
0.07765974849462509,
-0.06024771183729172,
0.4356045722961426,
0.885841965675354,
0.3990251123905182,
0.28371527791023254,
-1.091597318649292,
0.30144041776657104,
-0.1965295821428299,
0.7134604454040527,
-0.3987211585044861,
-0.023732803761959076,
-0.772262692451477,
0.3381095230579376,
-0.32309404015541077,
-0.8945094347000122,
-0.07966986298561096,
0.10209307074546814,
0.6159441471099854,
0.16254928708076477,
0.21939261257648468,
0.36940068006515503,
-0.2439679503440857,
0.7740738391876221,
0.22229477763175964,
-1.1603116989135742,
0.6606257557868958,
-0.5020295977592468,
0.4347550570964813,
0.8975074887275696,
0.09740637242794037,
-0.2495492398738861,
-0.6237529516220093,
-0.21042606234550476,
-0.5239161849021912,
0.69895339012146,
0.1197294071316719,
0.29689615964889526,
-0.2357901632785797,
0.5115911960601807,
0.2339370846748352,
0.3877335786819458,
-0.9163438081741333,
-0.0962366908788681,
-0.4300919473171234,
-0.29527249932289124,
0.5268744230270386,
-0.2970169186592102,
-0.04900926724076271,
-0.22873423993587494,
0.5141919851303101,
-0.26202622056007385,
0.5219298005104065,
-0.1786608099937439,
-0.24171172082424164,
-0.23197883367538452,
0.05236305296421051,
0.7340797781944275,
0.9167222380638123,
-0.38146549463272095,
-0.12651567161083221,
-0.186977818608284,
-0.6517190337181091,
-0.15976712107658386,
0.04008829593658447,
-0.20624566078186035,
-0.19891531765460968,
0.06308244168758392,
0.6316512823104858,
0.4399817883968353,
-0.704634964466095,
0.5391111969947815,
-0.25752463936805725,
-0.24896633625030518,
-0.21253804862499237,
0.12231618911027908,
-0.061068255454301834,
-0.14243386685848236,
-0.040359802544116974,
0.44108396768569946,
-0.1634238213300705,
-0.4922674596309662,
0.321304053068161,
0.2987821698188782,
-0.5053563714027405,
-0.4514666199684143,
0.9035441875457764,
0.5805557370185852,
-0.10914812237024307,
1.0428489446640015,
-0.46652013063430786,
-0.5584987998008728,
0.5666958689689636,
0.5040538907051086,
0.8053985834121704,
0.0802513062953949,
0.33947861194610596,
0.39646172523498535,
0.41476672887802124,
-0.19730928540229797,
0.7137212753295898,
0.13725179433822632,
-0.47443726658821106,
-0.6476750373840332,
-0.4737285077571869,
-0.5149692296981812,
-0.36329707503318787,
-0.8219615817070007,
0.385255366563797,
-0.6650784611701965,
-0.17843373119831085,
-0.5278003811836243,
0.019076911732554436,
-0.17757061123847961,
-0.16878741979599,
0.3056500256061554,
1.205368995666504,
-0.40809038281440735,
1.1673388481140137,
0.8859220147132874,
-0.574844241142273,
-0.8236212134361267,
-0.18012462556362152,
-0.10454967617988586,
-0.4135265648365021,
0.17199164628982544,
0.4970167577266693,
-0.21835502982139587,
-0.07371579110622406,
-0.973983883857727,
-0.7623595595359802,
0.9792202115058899,
0.7063416838645935,
-0.3417045772075653,
0.0987299457192421,
-0.2976851165294647,
0.3923313319683075,
-0.47839558124542236,
0.2623603641986847,
0.18626241385936737,
0.133435919880867,
0.01660839468240738,
-1.0850720405578613,
-0.20148330926895142,
-0.8572605848312378,
-0.008530376479029655,
0.622743546962738,
-0.6817558407783508,
0.8506589531898499,
-0.19253294169902802,
-0.24068327248096466,
0.57342129945755,
0.7902978658676147,
0.45824605226516724,
0.39552372694015503,
0.3333853781223297,
0.6873041987419128,
0.498309850692749,
-0.3031542897224426,
1.139975905418396,
-1.0081740617752075,
0.18814896047115326,
0.949553370475769,
-0.35510510206222534,
1.078954815864563,
0.03685290366411209,
0.04374411329627037,
0.7810131907463074,
0.5186790823936462,
-0.03323120251297951,
0.37501057982444763,
-0.01979943737387657,
0.13428299129009247,
-0.10205084085464478,
0.10550180077552795,
-0.5994912385940552,
0.057786278426647186,
0.14016078412532806,
0.07394883036613464,
0.0727800503373146,
-0.02071332558989525,
0.1837599128484726,
0.028265198692679405,
-0.38380166888237,
0.4379895031452179,
-0.0962117463350296,
-0.767666757106781,
0.7699937224388123,
0.16267108917236328,
0.3206234872341156,
-0.6794799566268921,
-0.22045987844467163,
-0.14774703979492188,
0.3142058253288269,
-0.10617198050022125,
-0.7476456761360168,
0.522628128528595,
-0.015116769820451736,
-0.26246383786201477,
-0.45520633459091187,
0.4619564712047577,
-0.39400142431259155,
-0.22050397098064423,
0.07397568225860596,
0.07608132809400558,
0.10892071574926376,
0.270686537027359,
-0.7873762845993042,
0.4969407021999359,
0.04714944213628769,
0.09894222021102905,
0.16490761935710907,
0.37939536571502686,
-0.09159998595714569,
0.755456268787384,
0.19896575808525085,
-0.3453078866004944,
0.41771766543388367,
0.33800607919692993,
0.9190976023674011,
-0.5088321566581726,
-0.39704629778862,
-0.18034520745277405,
0.9845188856124878,
0.008845362812280655,
-0.36734309792518616,
0.8080127835273743,
0.6148403286933899,
0.8643167018890381,
-0.003452859353274107,
0.4656468629837036,
-0.3050461411476135,
0.2655801773071289,
-0.7375996708869934,
0.49959462881088257,
-0.20589977502822876,
0.4349590241909027,
-0.23025096952915192,
-0.7583904266357422,
-0.11936043202877045,
0.1746843308210373,
-0.01666310988366604,
0.17697025835514069,
0.6621565222740173,
0.6476801633834839,
0.1462136209011078,
0.3950352668762207,
-0.14216630160808563,
0.17885097861289978,
0.07845130562782288,
0.43520665168762207,
0.8815759420394897,
-0.5337619781494141,
0.8483391404151917,
-0.3482888638973236,
-0.22188520431518555,
-0.0752764418721199,
-0.7252735495567322,
-0.6985772252082825,
-0.26902884244918823,
-0.7060665488243103,
-0.6488012671470642,
0.08544901013374329,
0.6771848201751709,
0.9901759624481201,
-0.8288801908493042,
-0.339744508266449,
-0.35838398337364197,
0.05071273073554039,
-0.30615851283073425,
-0.18673506379127502,
-0.26829078793525696,
-0.49585607647895813,
-0.6195182204246521,
0.3840028941631317,
0.3815898299217224,
0.07321926206350327,
-0.19926095008850098,
-0.5989157557487488,
0.011838708072900772,
-0.2344527691602707,
0.41790086030960083,
0.4053814113140106,
-0.45808595418930054,
-0.07122735679149628,
0.35169175267219543,
-0.40309008955955505,
0.1269417107105255,
0.857289731502533,
-0.4696381986141205,
0.39021122455596924,
0.4329172968864441,
0.672068178653717,
0.21085825562477112,
0.17515361309051514,
0.7892096638679504,
-0.6162493228912354,
0.19821369647979736,
0.2041739672422409,
0.3175823986530304,
0.20759636163711548,
-0.26060357689857483,
0.6968584656715393,
-0.11339304596185684,
-0.8885107636451721,
-0.9669567346572876,
0.2941732108592987,
-1.2765718698501587,
-0.07258822023868561,
0.8856258988380432,
-0.23805251717567444,
-0.06352739781141281,
0.028505004942417145,
-0.11981348693370819,
0.07542973011732101,
-0.36713114380836487,
0.395851194858551,
0.6224316954612732,
-0.05499099940061569,
-0.5407845973968506,
-0.8419448137283325,
0.27463704347610474,
0.33201926946640015,
-0.584597647190094,
-0.0149441659450531,
0.7093797326087952,
0.08470820635557175,
0.17969638109207153,
0.5980217456817627,
-0.5291179418563843,
0.49543675780296326,
0.3376975357532501,
0.37495842576026917,
-0.12574005126953125,
-0.45198696851730347,
-0.2405945509672165,
0.30637454986572266,
0.29234564304351807,
-0.203513041138649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01210v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01210v2
|
AILS-NTUA at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Efficient model tuning for hallucination detection and analysis
| 2024-04-01T16:10:15 | 2024-04-12T12:27:48 |
Natalia Grigoriadou, Maria Lymperaiou, Giorgos Filandrianos, Giorgos Stamou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present our team's submissions for SemEval-2024 Task-6 -
SHROOM, a Shared-task on Hallucinations and Related Observable Overgeneration
Mistakes. The participants were asked to perform binary classification to
identify cases of fluent overgeneration hallucinations. Our experimentation
included fine-tuning a pre-trained model on hallucination detection and a
Natural Language Inference (NLI) model. The most successful strategy involved
creating an ensemble of these models, resulting in accuracy rates of 77.8% and
79.9% on model-agnostic and model-aware datasets respectively, outperforming
the organizers' baseline and achieving notable results when contrasted with the
top-performing results in the competition, which reported accuracies of 84.7%
and 81.3% correspondingly.
|
[
-0.4451773762702942,
-0.7156137824058533,
0.5495316386222839,
0.23836611211299896,
-0.10222219675779343,
-0.315743625164032,
-0.0008559530833736062,
-0.8310596942901611,
0.12942244112491608,
0.5827791690826416,
-0.698454737663269,
-0.3079013228416443,
-0.45633164048194885,
0.37759602069854736,
-0.38771164417266846,
0.4502168893814087,
0.2142338901758194,
0.24093970656394958,
-0.2814587950706482,
-0.13805077970027924,
-0.8128877282142639,
-0.5864425301551819,
-0.6205342411994934,
-0.2659059762954712,
0.09901618957519531,
0.35964852571487427,
0.4358396828174591,
0.3944007456302643,
0.31829866766929626,
0.30381739139556885,
0.10118047893047333,
0.37959611415863037,
-0.3752877414226532,
0.1656300127506256,
-0.18586787581443787,
-0.24724583327770233,
-0.5187630653381348,
-0.14457812905311584,
0.21230098605155945,
0.5483629107475281,
-0.276252806186676,
0.0628640353679657,
-0.034705549478530884,
0.6338264346122742,
-0.5547168254852295,
0.15685799717903137,
-0.8639881014823914,
0.28722792863845825,
-0.0266212560236454,
-0.6768665909767151,
-0.6107951998710632,
-0.3716907799243927,
-0.23953165113925934,
-0.5550568103790283,
0.4299982190132141,
0.1919875293970108,
0.7067659497261047,
1.0002683401107788,
-0.20649263262748718,
-0.2751474380493164,
-0.5627740621566772,
0.9368180632591248,
-0.8192142248153687,
0.46584567427635193,
0.7295393943786621,
0.28371918201446533,
-0.09676377475261688,
-0.590482771396637,
-0.2381192147731781,
0.02393263578414917,
-0.1436355859041214,
-0.16051825881004333,
-0.09370118379592896,
0.10179530829191208,
0.45742809772491455,
0.11217179894447327,
-0.6379502415657043,
0.2248491644859314,
-0.6980561017990112,
-0.40170082449913025,
0.7955783009529114,
0.2897132933139801,
0.058036427944898605,
-0.03485780581831932,
-0.04607078433036804,
0.11967787891626358,
-0.31014886498451233,
-0.5724067091941833,
0.27295899391174316,
0.2714390158653259,
0.36887404322624207,
0.3784411549568176,
-0.376242458820343,
0.7377966046333313,
0.039198242127895355,
0.44201332330703735,
0.5739082098007202,
-0.48130834102630615,
-0.2350614368915558,
0.4437071681022644,
0.16204221546649933,
0.37534481287002563,
0.11087587475776672,
-0.3685046434402466,
-0.3960169851779938,
0.4485452175140381,
0.7134300470352173,
-0.849395751953125,
-0.48908910155296326,
0.3481387794017792,
-0.5497887134552002,
-0.6049347519874573,
-0.2847634255886078,
-0.9443607926368713,
-0.7396503686904907,
-0.7044328451156616,
1.0951728820800781,
-0.4308275878429413,
-0.1333766132593155,
0.3565616309642792,
-0.14387625455856323,
0.1928880512714386,
0.4043990969657898,
-0.7077181935310364,
0.2877225875854492,
0.533832311630249,
0.7221214771270752,
-0.39802199602127075,
-0.3039149045944214,
-0.7002519965171814,
-0.14809225499629974,
-0.23727630078792572,
0.8584526181221008,
-0.3947678506374359,
-0.26050347089767456,
-0.3641810715198517,
0.04954196512699127,
-0.4691423177719116,
-0.7668551802635193,
0.8625880479812622,
-0.15747514367103577,
0.23491668701171875,
-0.37060314416885376,
-0.6649662852287292,
-0.3927117586135864,
-0.024319248273968697,
-0.667351245880127,
0.9269157648086548,
-0.005435737315565348,
-0.5192142128944397,
0.46674180030822754,
-0.7810279130935669,
-0.3958210349082947,
0.24111366271972656,
-0.28972843289375305,
-0.5044100284576416,
0.3571139872074127,
0.24646294116973877,
0.5136279463768005,
0.08025546371936798,
0.6119698882102966,
-0.11341667175292969,
-0.7870556712150574,
-0.028328293934464455,
-0.44049617648124695,
0.6388089656829834,
0.31969210505485535,
-0.8670291900634766,
0.4249582290649414,
-1.1276402473449707,
0.020728718489408493,
-0.004744579084217548,
0.14259465038776398,
-0.22493626177310944,
0.03631194680929184,
-0.05661206319928169,
0.2063530683517456,
0.10254530608654022,
-0.41173985600471497,
0.041275911033153534,
-0.3254762589931488,
0.49601131677627563,
0.8136001825332642,
0.09218021482229233,
0.15059298276901245,
-0.38827940821647644,
0.33833903074264526,
-0.038014814257621765,
0.41596630215644836,
0.10302325338125229,
-0.5695433020591736,
-0.8204326629638672,
0.23474544286727905,
0.17575225234031677,
0.33524906635284424,
-0.6009061336517334,
0.6754866242408752,
0.059650544077157974,
-0.4448387622833252,
-0.49110931158065796,
-0.26595157384872437,
0.007345688529312611,
0.6083317399024963,
0.6438133716583252,
-0.13285945355892181,
-0.9707756638526917,
-0.8673357367515564,
0.00938862282782793,
0.12914931774139404,
0.30745044350624084,
0.1703692227602005,
0.7774200439453125,
-0.7144086956977844,
0.4024357199668884,
-0.3006531894207001,
-0.6311801671981812,
0.0894671380519867,
0.4826696813106537,
-0.045324306935071945,
0.6024646162986755,
0.5452350974082947,
-0.7355848550796509,
-0.0008251219987869263,
-0.1189400926232338,
-0.9453142285346985,
-0.37377306818962097,
-0.06617671251296997,
-0.18978774547576904,
0.7931072115898132,
0.9690564870834351,
-0.12137846648693085,
0.6464382410049438,
0.4348689019680023,
-0.6032774448394775,
0.5894689559936523,
-0.1803746074438095,
0.408532977104187,
-0.9303503632545471,
-0.02094980701804161,
-0.31818172335624695,
-0.06446675956249237,
-0.8374528288841248,
-0.012615732848644257,
0.017304807901382446,
0.1524011343717575,
-0.0841323733329773,
0.2861117422580719,
-0.372099369764328,
-0.16840440034866333,
-0.4908445477485657,
-0.34995895624160767,
-0.193905770778656,
0.6514145135879517,
0.2659696638584137,
0.5531130433082581,
0.5241291522979736,
-0.6189762949943542,
-0.14781664311885834,
0.05177991837263107,
-0.2759329080581665,
0.24670764803886414,
-0.5857124924659729,
0.36874303221702576,
-0.0401507131755352,
-0.14089182019233704,
-0.7682743072509766,
-0.4499341547489166,
0.13432440161705017,
-0.5041560530662537,
0.0823671817779541,
0.315829873085022,
-0.37857964634895325,
-0.12558101117610931,
-0.20260536670684814,
0.43826156854629517,
0.2543734610080719,
-0.5349695086479187,
0.9600644707679749,
0.41074737906455994,
0.32635611295700073,
-0.37876179814338684,
-0.5805359482765198,
-0.04400847107172012,
-0.32631075382232666,
-0.6233169436454773,
0.43595248460769653,
-0.1300508826971054,
-0.16987067461013794,
-0.018282517790794373,
-0.22400808334350586,
-0.022712359204888344,
0.2860414385795593,
0.579094648361206,
0.06639043241739273,
-0.24508816003799438,
0.0584840402007103,
-0.02013765275478363,
-0.1298842579126358,
0.14159724116325378,
-0.04823465645313263,
0.8940482139587402,
-0.29484233260154724,
-0.3151668608188629,
-0.4111453890800476,
0.21271201968193054,
0.48399266600608826,
0.05398964881896973,
0.7427870035171509,
0.7498472332954407,
-0.9122647643089294,
-0.25336113572120667,
-0.8342891931533813,
-0.4940926730632782,
-0.5039941072463989,
0.2857506275177002,
-0.30750855803489685,
-0.8013674020767212,
0.6667221784591675,
0.3227568566799164,
0.09165584295988083,
0.5345395803451538,
0.4483276307582855,
0.11183912307024002,
1.2920331954956055,
0.4120796322822571,
0.13644813001155853,
0.14498452842235565,
-0.19902978837490082,
0.253700852394104,
-0.4689587354660034,
-0.3191090226173401,
-0.7233787775039673,
-0.38622409105300903,
-0.44503360986709595,
-0.5801954865455627,
0.36745646595954895,
-0.310477614402771,
-0.09364243596792221,
0.3709940016269684,
-0.710547685623169,
0.42141592502593994,
0.6252660751342773,
0.10932998359203339,
0.29968783259391785,
-0.08229198306798935,
0.3620842397212982,
-0.1855543851852417,
-0.59185791015625,
-0.12774044275283813,
0.7790022492408752,
0.24303549528121948,
0.5741293430328369,
-0.10570885986089706,
0.8228114247322083,
0.4968346655368805,
-0.30451256036758423,
-0.6024729013442993,
0.6134436726570129,
-0.03285510838031769,
-0.5601693987846375,
-0.6793854236602783,
-0.34111297130584717,
-0.8033439517021179,
0.33733612298965454,
-0.1669982671737671,
-0.8435366749763489,
0.6957106590270996,
0.1794908195734024,
-0.45364853739738464,
0.10657165199518204,
-0.6430187821388245,
0.9080034494400024,
-0.1430007517337799,
-0.14210695028305054,
-0.49551868438720703,
-0.5597334504127502,
0.45767390727996826,
-0.4120270609855652,
0.12099650502204895,
-0.0550985150039196,
0.38033023476600647,
0.7565794587135315,
-0.26886722445487976,
0.8022001385688782,
-0.320466548204422,
0.13484662771224976,
0.02302522584795952,
-0.049007028341293335,
0.4500235617160797,
-0.15900276601314545,
-0.32961955666542053,
0.2714313566684723,
0.1390281468629837,
-0.12206573784351349,
-0.5500421524047852,
0.5543653964996338,
-0.7607923150062561,
-0.34832045435905457,
-0.6299469470977783,
-0.37334609031677246,
-0.19959987699985504,
0.023935435339808464,
0.677897572517395,
0.6838954091072083,
0.005741835106164217,
0.47344231605529785,
0.8637118339538574,
-0.3090352714061737,
0.24217341840267181,
0.20025013387203217,
-0.1692887544631958,
-0.0827171728014946,
1.0869158506393433,
0.14733292162418365,
-0.0769132599234581,
-0.025758914649486542,
0.16204951703548431,
-0.30218297243118286,
-0.7603887915611267,
-0.11362368613481522,
0.19164468348026276,
-0.6996026635169983,
-0.2616862654685974,
-1.0446678400039673,
-0.581081211566925,
-0.8029648065567017,
-0.12628649175167084,
-0.39693209528923035,
-0.46521836519241333,
-0.4616627097129822,
-0.1702040284872055,
0.031496211886405945,
0.5560398697853088,
-0.20520713925361633,
0.0030183899216353893,
-0.6158739924430847,
0.40057486295700073,
0.15122126042842865,
0.10657034069299698,
-0.03182914853096008,
-0.8198988437652588,
-0.11317747086286545,
-0.1830037236213684,
-0.06774517893791199,
-0.7698912024497986,
0.6209744811058044,
0.30811309814453125,
0.7886584401130676,
0.2332056760787964,
0.19888097047805786,
0.9632601141929626,
-0.11375433951616287,
0.5696722865104675,
-0.25363296270370483,
-0.8373174071311951,
0.8074492812156677,
-0.009569076821208,
0.28996971249580383,
0.9989511370658875,
0.2210736870765686,
-0.2874451279640198,
-0.4243007004261017,
-0.6307466626167297,
-0.931662380695343,
0.958754301071167,
0.4844800531864166,
-0.25569936633110046,
0.3011588454246521,
0.24431677162647247,
0.2778736650943756,
0.20750732719898224,
-0.7089399695396423,
0.13577647507190704,
-0.24740397930145264,
0.004566130228340626,
0.02838323637843132,
-0.3360122740268707,
0.08646395057439804,
-0.5853578448295593,
1.0756152868270874,
-0.2459508776664734,
0.3794343173503876,
0.07934153825044632,
-0.32750043272972107,
-0.350230872631073,
0.02348986454308033,
0.9557099938392639,
0.7981274127960205,
-0.45311883091926575,
0.03576599061489105,
0.39406833052635193,
-0.39743489027023315,
-0.2755507528781891,
0.14398694038391113,
-0.1978510320186615,
0.054721392691135406,
0.33680620789527893,
1.1749508380889893,
0.09972313791513443,
-0.6876465678215027,
0.27530694007873535,
-0.44832566380500793,
-0.5601164698600769,
-0.6435819268226624,
0.29711195826530457,
-0.2567625343799591,
0.289315789937973,
0.3734893500804901,
0.3832208514213562,
0.701154351234436,
-0.5377389788627625,
0.4794839024543762,
0.12887169420719147,
-0.4893665313720703,
-0.3453238010406494,
0.8690882325172424,
0.005469871684908867,
-0.2965690493583679,
0.7636792659759521,
-0.49391642212867737,
-0.6800327897071838,
0.6584340929985046,
0.3644174635410309,
1.0922244787216187,
-0.33153095841407776,
0.09707310050725937,
0.6944515705108643,
0.34600353240966797,
-0.22043883800506592,
0.5811005234718323,
-0.0926215648651123,
-0.8595458269119263,
-0.264965295791626,
-0.8767597079277039,
-0.11527535319328308,
0.4593822956085205,
-0.8086003065109253,
0.49869468808174133,
0.026958808302879333,
-0.021648650988936424,
0.13225990533828735,
-0.16045726835727692,
-0.4522791802883148,
0.21991918981075287,
0.16717256605625153,
0.7146818041801453,
-1.0642353296279907,
0.7793325185775757,
0.4248267710208893,
0.027080347761511803,
-0.7625645399093628,
-0.08889640122652054,
0.08507521450519562,
-0.6158223748207092,
0.32634422183036804,
0.42867201566696167,
0.010804100893437862,
0.1597415953874588,
-0.5019246935844421,
-0.6686570048332214,
1.1070141792297363,
-0.013441408053040504,
-0.6543111205101013,
-0.3035350739955902,
-0.07427291572093964,
0.6633691191673279,
-0.09525878727436066,
-0.0061981528997421265,
0.9335290789604187,
0.5414797067642212,
0.38973212242126465,
-0.8797087669372559,
-0.09723386913537979,
-0.3852553963661194,
-0.2695673108100891,
0.30919942259788513,
-0.3348006308078766,
0.4641142189502716,
-0.07503610104322433,
-0.038155484944581985,
0.07421046495437622,
0.6787478923797607,
0.49638476967811584,
0.7044958472251892,
0.9032224416732788,
0.5771738886833191,
0.9124232530593872,
-0.17069518566131592,
0.5466361045837402,
-0.36613956093788147,
0.03268188238143921,
1.3519648313522339,
-0.28770190477371216,
0.6127264499664307,
0.3812960684299469,
0.2771283686161041,
-0.06692086905241013,
0.7172227501869202,
-0.2387174814939499,
0.6440993547439575,
-0.012958729639649391,
0.047345951199531555,
-0.45356491208076477,
-0.10456505417823792,
-0.4722157418727875,
0.5404551029205322,
0.5949466824531555,
-0.2330341339111328,
-0.05898053199052811,
0.34051331877708435,
-0.47239798307418823,
-0.10521673411130905,
-0.18193475902080536,
0.8001832365989685,
0.04020487889647484,
-0.8580273389816284,
0.43464744091033936,
-0.25037941336631775,
0.8381879329681396,
-0.16416019201278687,
-0.18301132321357727,
-0.21153560280799866,
0.19443663954734802,
-0.40389037132263184,
-0.35667896270751953,
0.6929343938827515,
-0.27333301305770874,
0.17750050127506256,
-0.14906975626945496,
1.0162771940231323,
-0.22055809199810028,
-0.5431928038597107,
0.3097287118434906,
0.2067345827817917,
0.3417759835720062,
-0.41731467843055725,
-0.43478119373321533,
0.24217559397220612,
0.22277966141700745,
-0.013882415369153023,
0.07155606150627136,
0.4114200174808502,
-0.40647464990615845,
0.47422295808792114,
0.14983278512954712,
-0.07965628057718277,
0.3753725290298462,
0.5198315382003784,
0.4099487066268921,
-0.752454936504364,
-0.48948100209236145,
-0.679278552532196,
0.23121501505374908,
-0.18639299273490906,
-0.3758231997489929,
0.5318120121955872,
0.6360309720039368,
0.7948591709136963,
-0.19499756395816803,
0.4744904041290283,
-0.040913764387369156,
0.37437915802001953,
-0.5918623805046082,
0.5555989742279053,
-0.7432406544685364,
0.1272132843732834,
-0.16335554420948029,
-0.941809892654419,
-0.15694057941436768,
0.8196147680282593,
0.00237450934946537,
0.019227750599384308,
0.6785751581192017,
1.0843381881713867,
0.1276666820049286,
0.6450055837631226,
0.6197040677070618,
0.29413196444511414,
0.14699958264827728,
0.47053641080856323,
0.92299485206604,
-0.5267003774642944,
0.1402364820241928,
-0.6016727685928345,
0.07849396765232086,
-0.4360431432723999,
-0.6840435266494751,
-0.8026208281517029,
-1.0258774757385254,
-0.6375038623809814,
-0.18365193903446198,
0.20015278458595276,
0.9772596955299377,
0.6327269077301025,
-1.2947514057159424,
-0.059944745153188705,
-0.2798289954662323,
-0.36356058716773987,
-0.26361364126205444,
-0.26056408882141113,
0.2332579493522644,
-0.4258674383163452,
-0.6879451870918274,
0.48933732509613037,
0.1855391263961792,
-0.00010596632637316361,
-0.13813190162181854,
0.01526168454438448,
-0.09104517847299576,
-0.05452844500541687,
0.6348544955253601,
-0.19027704000473022,
-0.6348428130149841,
-0.45140960812568665,
0.19716773927211761,
0.11000440269708633,
0.051773712038993835,
0.5619556903839111,
-0.6223782300949097,
0.3944096863269806,
0.7075152397155762,
0.5839942097663879,
0.5274308323860168,
0.16551949083805084,
0.5462820529937744,
-0.48406559228897095,
-0.014101631939411163,
0.5459973216056824,
0.37104037404060364,
0.0955805853009224,
-0.7368530035018921,
1.1370391845703125,
0.20971249043941498,
-0.9853708744049072,
-1.2238749265670776,
-0.37244755029678345,
-1.049311637878418,
-0.5760056972503662,
1.0305699110031128,
0.6075048446655273,
-0.16289269924163818,
-0.33949509263038635,
-0.2239859700202942,
0.26521962881088257,
-0.2262815684080124,
1.1869721412658691,
0.7046754360198975,
-0.4327491521835327,
-0.07267995178699493,
-0.7698560953140259,
0.7914390563964844,
0.6454402208328247,
-0.9596037268638611,
-0.11553638428449631,
0.6975398063659668,
-0.1765526533126831,
0.31002068519592285,
0.6042602062225342,
-0.05746249854564667,
0.5628238320350647,
-0.08224191516637802,
0.04260186105966568,
0.005094684194773436,
-0.6907579898834229,
-0.6479638814926147,
0.09619441628456116,
-0.10406383872032166,
-0.18764303624629974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01204v1
|
The Fine Line: Navigating Large Language Model Pretraining with Down-streaming Capability Analysis
| 2024-04-01T16:00:01 | 2024-04-01T16:00:01 |
Chen Yang, Junzhuo Li, Xinyao Niu, Xinrun Du, Songyang Gao, Haoran Zhang, Zhaoliang Chen, Xingwei Qu, Ruibin Yuan, Yizhi Li, Jiaheng Liu, Stephen W. Huang, Shawn Yue, Wenhu Chen, Jie Fu, Ge Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Uncovering early-stage metrics that reflect final model performance is one
core principle for large-scale pretraining. The existing scaling law
demonstrates the power-law correlation between pretraining loss and training
flops, which serves as an important indicator of the current training state for
large language models. However, this principle only focuses on the model's
compression properties on the training data, resulting in an inconsistency with
the ability improvements on the downstream tasks. Some follow-up works
attempted to extend the scaling-law to more complex metrics (such as
hyperparameters), but still lacked a comprehensive analysis of the dynamic
differences among various capabilities during pretraining. To address the
aforementioned limitations, this paper undertakes a comprehensive comparison of
model capabilities at various pretraining intermediate checkpoints. Through
this analysis, we confirm that specific downstream metrics exhibit similar
training dynamics across models of different sizes, up to 67 billion
parameters. In addition to our core findings, we've reproduced Amber and
OpenLLaMA, releasing their intermediate checkpoints. This initiative offers
valuable resources to the research community and facilitates the verification
and exploration of LLM pretraining by open-source researchers. Besides, we
provide empirical summaries, including performance comparisons of different
models and capabilities, and tuition of key metrics for different training
phases. Based on these findings, we provide a more user-friendly strategy for
evaluating the optimization state, offering guidance for establishing a stable
pretraining process.
|
[
-0.611579179763794,
-0.5760809183120728,
0.6903619766235352,
-0.045214518904685974,
-0.3261425793170929,
0.06243002787232399,
-0.5720328688621521,
-0.2652091085910797,
-0.1115674078464508,
0.735495388507843,
-0.6308362483978271,
-0.25503766536712646,
-0.7687703967094421,
-0.1936776489019394,
-0.43976694345474243,
0.9233869910240173,
-0.1986677050590515,
0.2591152489185333,
0.009227773174643517,
0.019430477172136307,
-0.4565146267414093,
-0.5983996391296387,
-0.6960951685905457,
-0.25723931193351746,
0.34584954380989075,
0.21782635152339935,
0.39009615778923035,
0.5497376918792725,
0.5373539328575134,
0.2694512903690338,
-0.23033510148525238,
-0.24952290952205658,
-0.8489522337913513,
-0.15017792582511902,
-0.10543123632669449,
-0.4451809227466583,
-0.631267249584198,
0.07478265464305878,
0.9761143326759338,
0.7349035143852234,
-0.06498239189386368,
0.29622024297714233,
0.45237091183662415,
0.7571393847465515,
-0.7103177309036255,
0.07229147106409073,
-0.651485800743103,
-0.11619748175144196,
-0.5741972923278809,
-0.14028312265872955,
-0.3732810616493225,
-0.24035309255123138,
0.2658708393573761,
-0.5216901898384094,
0.10228824615478516,
-0.11418141424655914,
1.081648349761963,
0.39562541246414185,
-0.2763756513595581,
-0.1745503544807434,
-0.8545489311218262,
0.8413950800895691,
-0.8861730694770813,
0.48856183886528015,
0.22828379273414612,
0.4260740578174591,
0.11818407475948334,
-0.7253463268280029,
-0.4898475706577301,
-0.4044485092163086,
0.08564992249011993,
-0.19852003455162048,
-0.17442522943019867,
0.23117771744728088,
0.2871769964694977,
0.497729629278183,
-0.3876401484012604,
0.5919655561447144,
-0.49567243456840515,
-0.24431630969047546,
0.48329970240592957,
-0.056898389011621475,
0.1041443943977356,
0.4088924825191498,
-0.05731017142534256,
-0.3456075191497803,
-0.8551462888717651,
0.1563495248556137,
0.301614373922348,
0.5112086534500122,
-0.42222556471824646,
0.2647812068462372,
-0.2171766608953476,
0.5927960872650146,
-0.0661587193608284,
-0.1604398488998413,
0.27922528982162476,
-0.4685570001602173,
-0.09185905009508133,
0.043908968567848206,
0.6579232215881348,
-0.054718613624572754,
0.38438963890075684,
-0.09553445875644684,
-0.20818601548671722,
-0.4975201487541199,
0.35987600684165955,
-0.9595755338668823,
-0.035623230040073395,
0.008227814920246601,
-0.44793668389320374,
0.07866323739290237,
-0.08952881395816803,
-0.49731022119522095,
-0.3256826102733612,
-0.5796093344688416,
0.5201486349105835,
-0.2533838748931885,
-0.4013013541698456,
0.12436883896589279,
0.2597689926624298,
0.45681649446487427,
0.15161991119384766,
-0.9407328963279724,
0.2603774666786194,
0.7938121557235718,
1.0009465217590332,
0.06601279228925705,
-0.2745489180088043,
-0.5380899310112,
-0.22004380822181702,
-0.19667455554008484,
0.3306543827056885,
-0.22404572367668152,
0.021764900535345078,
0.08164237439632416,
-0.03882080316543579,
-0.12496451288461685,
-0.5528823137283325,
0.4160979688167572,
-0.6818377375602722,
-0.33756938576698303,
-0.24965235590934753,
-0.44385606050491333,
-0.2514289319515228,
0.16514435410499573,
-0.6557953357696533,
0.6203351616859436,
-0.0024924338795244694,
-0.5201476812362671,
0.5174447298049927,
-0.3610897362232208,
-0.18194514513015747,
-0.003364612115547061,
-0.21452730894088745,
-0.32888171076774597,
0.15943953394889832,
-0.18901294469833374,
0.6901158690452576,
-0.5794283747673035,
0.13630211353302002,
-0.5319570899009705,
-0.22521166503429413,
-0.10829813778400421,
-0.231802299618721,
0.6803363561630249,
0.27186018228530884,
-0.3627804219722748,
0.042713675647974014,
-0.9253909587860107,
0.12014592438936234,
-0.06661009043455124,
-0.441013902425766,
-0.0898139700293541,
-0.004434830509126186,
-0.1911313831806183,
0.10935728251934052,
0.3736884295940399,
-0.2694951593875885,
0.09193012863397598,
-0.15905314683914185,
0.5023204684257507,
0.5324763059616089,
-0.31877395510673523,
0.45433253049850464,
-0.0632752850651741,
0.5607742071151733,
-0.25211063027381897,
0.15568943321704865,
-0.2046639323234558,
-0.026966040953993797,
-0.8146632313728333,
-0.16132646799087524,
0.29728996753692627,
0.44311657547950745,
-0.2643294632434845,
0.6000538468360901,
-0.4160442054271698,
-0.7357244491577148,
-0.5063722133636475,
0.5005393028259277,
0.5678845047950745,
0.3734824061393738,
0.5517939329147339,
-0.43218907713890076,
-0.5384629964828491,
-0.7922366261482239,
-0.042032428085803986,
-0.20727777481079102,
-0.03692324459552765,
-0.10423789918422699,
0.37392446398735046,
-0.02231644093990326,
0.7125648856163025,
-0.2799285352230072,
-0.3551257252693176,
-0.5036920309066772,
0.1759250909090042,
0.2831000089645386,
0.6344232559204102,
0.5136184692382812,
-0.4949018657207489,
-0.2587480843067169,
0.09340697526931763,
-0.46396106481552124,
-0.15266627073287964,
-0.03860535845160484,
-0.08673737198114395,
-0.04839830473065376,
0.8399055600166321,
-0.213394895195961,
0.10575626790523529,
0.774282693862915,
-0.093864805996418,
0.6530002355575562,
-0.36479800939559937,
-0.020107977092266083,
-0.6878839135169983,
0.18966391682624817,
-0.10775653272867203,
0.12146623432636261,
-0.7295233011245728,
0.1874472051858902,
0.017779069021344185,
-0.017062388360500336,
-0.43514949083328247,
0.2826327085494995,
-0.4158457815647125,
-0.10723832994699478,
-0.16100327670574188,
-0.049482785165309906,
-0.2060876488685608,
0.33510124683380127,
-0.0025900041218847036,
0.7347763776779175,
0.5946498513221741,
-0.6746578216552734,
0.05714017152786255,
-0.08981016278266907,
-0.48591598868370056,
0.01869257166981697,
-0.6466403007507324,
0.14660541713237762,
0.0943572074174881,
0.10559944808483124,
-0.9364500641822815,
-0.03963368013501167,
-0.3315676152706146,
-0.12427934259176254,
0.5903563499450684,
-0.2944260835647583,
-0.4584687054157257,
-0.14073975384235382,
0.007488806266337633,
0.5732278227806091,
0.6882824301719666,
-0.09170497953891754,
0.5489954948425293,
0.3522353768348694,
-0.2783794701099396,
-0.4147084951400757,
-0.5864476561546326,
-0.14625589549541473,
-0.3903724253177643,
-0.6420844197273254,
0.2383114993572235,
0.09192084521055222,
-0.13781628012657166,
-0.5149053931236267,
0.10154359042644501,
-0.2541296184062958,
0.3261232376098633,
0.01859186217188835,
0.10924282670021057,
-0.49671968817710876,
-0.11101232469081879,
-0.16426904499530792,
-0.11972872167825699,
0.2190900593996048,
-0.33166250586509705,
0.8753545880317688,
-0.4452154338359833,
-0.22890129685401917,
-0.46316275000572205,
-0.16541630029678345,
0.6151836514472961,
-0.46414753794670105,
0.8366170525550842,
0.6610897779464722,
-0.08578260987997055,
0.07804084569215775,
-0.6548107266426086,
-0.10600372403860092,
-0.4575096368789673,
0.4488812983036041,
-0.11368285119533539,
-0.7937515377998352,
0.6362740993499756,
-0.17314957082271576,
0.09480064362287521,
0.24980483949184418,
0.48832425475120544,
0.2101333886384964,
0.866087794303894,
0.9405626058578491,
0.10524284094572067,
0.5956081748008728,
-0.47270986437797546,
0.2208329439163208,
-0.6898660063743591,
-0.14148901402950287,
-0.6723969578742981,
-0.21793504059314728,
-0.5619325041770935,
-0.3383365869522095,
0.231042742729187,
0.5814112424850464,
-0.6798878312110901,
0.29666373133659363,
0.050431057810783386,
0.47183308005332947,
0.42495113611221313,
-0.10371778160333633,
0.304319828748703,
-0.2280174046754837,
-0.08140691369771957,
-0.06434887647628784,
-0.5790902376174927,
-0.6801272034645081,
1.1899210214614868,
0.5526794791221619,
0.6751294732093811,
0.007917594164609909,
0.63161700963974,
-0.1066354513168335,
0.1868416666984558,
-0.7337651252746582,
0.6118577122688293,
-0.4037802517414093,
-0.6308794617652893,
-0.46612581610679626,
-0.5132604837417603,
-0.7379747629165649,
0.048373766243457794,
-0.4121696352958679,
-0.6955628991127014,
-0.043703593313694,
0.3241577446460724,
-0.6443482041358948,
0.4626874625682831,
-0.8311406373977661,
1.0776091814041138,
-0.5079385042190552,
-0.2177104353904724,
-0.3796491324901581,
-0.6271375417709351,
0.255021333694458,
-0.5383345484733582,
0.16957210004329681,
-0.10139153152704239,
0.08633746206760406,
0.9372764229774475,
-0.5862839818000793,
0.6654638648033142,
-0.2644549310207367,
-0.29637688398361206,
0.14751988649368286,
-0.06926274299621582,
0.20519763231277466,
-0.43569961190223694,
0.13997426629066467,
0.384769469499588,
0.050063356757164,
-0.46213656663894653,
-0.47007641196250916,
0.35528916120529175,
-0.8574911952018738,
-0.4183231294155121,
0.16074000298976898,
-0.19962655007839203,
-0.3570932149887085,
0.5824123620986938,
0.38780829310417175,
0.47595447301864624,
-0.022589659318327904,
0.5000121593475342,
0.7268957495689392,
-0.15686379373073578,
0.41506966948509216,
0.46315115690231323,
-0.27041396498680115,
-0.05501265078783035,
0.7783325910568237,
0.4377136826515198,
0.5849335193634033,
0.3530425727367401,
0.1954626888036728,
-0.3017803430557251,
-1.1933586597442627,
-0.1065237820148468,
0.24998752772808075,
-0.5946316123008728,
0.19500263035297394,
-0.30083325505256653,
-0.2520327568054199,
-0.37291449308395386,
-0.13895975053310394,
-0.7619931101799011,
0.05617719143629074,
-0.09255058318376541,
0.1647786945104599,
-0.0909217968583107,
0.5419099926948547,
0.04131702706217766,
0.7409632802009583,
-0.8662368059158325,
-0.10594442486763,
0.21549448370933533,
0.2572847604751587,
0.3584764003753662,
-0.7184557318687439,
-0.582984447479248,
0.007936281152069569,
-0.4726417064666748,
-0.5233317613601685,
0.1206691786646843,
0.24065834283828735,
0.5809794068336487,
0.8028488159179688,
-0.08171100914478302,
0.7599397897720337,
-0.4415694773197174,
0.6564539074897766,
0.3944476246833801,
-1.0000190734863281,
0.5303000807762146,
-0.2488890290260315,
0.09011660516262054,
0.8156551122665405,
0.5440311431884766,
-0.035654108971357346,
-0.3225535452365875,
-0.5201441645622253,
-0.9065821766853333,
0.5344120860099792,
0.015343612991273403,
0.17717893421649933,
0.4931259751319885,
0.40678563714027405,
0.06449049711227417,
0.1718447506427765,
-0.676626443862915,
0.05754054710268974,
0.003136545652523637,
0.10071635246276855,
-0.4010395407676697,
0.008051947690546513,
-0.04280844330787659,
-0.331170916557312,
0.5369511246681213,
-0.10007556527853012,
-0.2104053646326065,
-0.16900959610939026,
-0.18679171800613403,
0.1725005805492401,
0.2423998862504959,
0.43221133947372437,
0.9537431597709656,
-0.3644523620605469,
-0.02160602994263172,
0.28927454352378845,
-0.7493083477020264,
0.17734619975090027,
0.07687198370695114,
0.02934839203953743,
-0.4071202874183655,
0.7272518277168274,
0.9475104212760925,
0.2368180900812149,
-0.7704671025276184,
0.5426239371299744,
0.05885682627558708,
-0.11010384559631348,
-0.2664714753627777,
0.25752755999565125,
-0.1977822482585907,
0.3219565749168396,
0.4491112232208252,
-0.1711748093366623,
-0.208413764834404,
-0.6256766319274902,
0.022837873548269272,
0.3074232339859009,
-0.4367811679840088,
-0.4249414801597595,
0.4992760419845581,
0.25248295068740845,
0.012203006073832512,
0.7499138712882996,
-0.07026407867670059,
-0.30771321058273315,
0.3999401330947876,
0.12455254793167114,
0.8037251830101013,
-0.06704836338758469,
-0.09758985042572021,
0.3174038827419281,
0.36925771832466125,
-0.280791699886322,
-0.12843577563762665,
-0.07489220052957535,
-0.6898493766784668,
-0.9085856080055237,
-0.7195795178413391,
-0.11407199501991272,
0.5834447145462036,
-0.9616702795028687,
0.4733459949493408,
-0.5321310758590698,
-0.2654876708984375,
-0.005015646573156118,
0.2550182342529297,
-0.8749223351478577,
0.16773435473442078,
0.40867337584495544,
0.9685389399528503,
-0.7504166960716248,
0.8421059250831604,
0.4705616533756256,
-0.42789608240127563,
-1.0329012870788574,
0.1731262356042862,
0.01841757260262966,
-0.9843617677688599,
0.7531265020370483,
0.234427809715271,
-0.1855705827474594,
0.21535156667232513,
-0.4148557782173157,
-0.8886117935180664,
1.2677342891693115,
0.6680026054382324,
-0.7947470545768738,
-0.41127821803092957,
0.051491882652044296,
0.44405505061149597,
-0.4201350212097168,
0.37466245889663696,
0.8680188655853271,
0.26896393299102783,
0.12624408304691315,
-1.3128321170806885,
0.09865175932645798,
0.19974586367607117,
-0.03759678453207016,
0.22435149550437927,
-0.5829804539680481,
1.0040667057037354,
-0.25632309913635254,
-0.3353029787540436,
0.04328643158078194,
0.5319888591766357,
0.19222663342952728,
0.11319516599178314,
0.5955861210823059,
0.6872209310531616,
0.6609564423561096,
-0.08383332937955856,
0.9131482839584351,
-0.42580145597457886,
0.4397578835487366,
1.0028444528579712,
-0.12070369720458984,
1.146459698677063,
0.5002980828285217,
-0.3247442841529846,
0.4375738799571991,
0.612588107585907,
0.15058332681655884,
0.5272776484489441,
0.3787766993045807,
-0.02677599899470806,
-0.39333376288414,
0.028265712782740593,
-0.5099813938140869,
0.42392536997795105,
0.13139818608760834,
-0.2046469748020172,
-0.3952769935131073,
-0.024551881477236748,
0.2361995428800583,
-0.23082569241523743,
-0.6914085149765015,
0.6222279667854309,
0.10854331403970718,
-0.6301566362380981,
0.9707592129707336,
-0.31248006224632263,
0.585631251335144,
-0.9362899661064148,
0.2483758181333542,
-0.11053362488746643,
0.3429673910140991,
-0.004137550015002489,
-0.6848089694976807,
0.10127471387386322,
0.058753300458192825,
0.01583727076649666,
-0.3574705719947815,
0.3204968273639679,
-0.09562689065933228,
-0.012821529991924763,
0.49636563658714294,
0.4686424136161804,
0.31871554255485535,
-0.09278737008571625,
-0.5540049076080322,
0.3150325119495392,
-0.12238847464323044,
-0.18913675844669342,
0.4433246850967407,
0.3540199398994446,
0.207594096660614,
0.7035157084465027,
0.5923177003860474,
0.5020993947982788,
0.20491020381450653,
0.1610809713602066,
0.7904601097106934,
-0.40139564871788025,
-0.5986084342002869,
-0.8918228149414062,
0.511955201625824,
0.04216946288943291,
-0.4888891875743866,
0.6131553053855896,
0.41121941804885864,
1.208743929862976,
0.20543350279331207,
0.5454169511795044,
0.06719617545604706,
0.26375070214271545,
-0.9447203278541565,
0.8422920107841492,
-0.5616043210029602,
0.35734838247299194,
-0.01633680798113346,
-1.0268564224243164,
0.04172967001795769,
0.4148486852645874,
-0.5460779666900635,
0.14875441789627075,
0.6001464128494263,
0.7706750631332397,
-0.15690366923809052,
-0.2374417781829834,
0.25314393639564514,
0.4195491373538971,
0.3679029643535614,
0.4951735734939575,
0.8235306143760681,
-0.11846562474966049,
0.6362526416778564,
0.035137902945280075,
-0.41459721326828003,
-0.18644317984580994,
-1.0202484130859375,
-0.765942394733429,
-0.661798894405365,
-0.21697691082954407,
-0.3470117151737213,
-0.27465078234672546,
0.670997679233551,
1.1122127771377563,
-0.6272854208946228,
-0.4736335277557373,
-0.27201661467552185,
-0.42921605706214905,
-0.06534390896558762,
-0.14032383263111115,
0.1498839110136032,
-0.568282961845398,
-0.3175254762172699,
0.14065109193325043,
0.025343850255012512,
0.2756788432598114,
-0.6958463191986084,
-0.3922775685787201,
-0.016450513154268265,
0.03232930228114128,
0.3239210844039917,
0.4976145327091217,
-0.46064305305480957,
-0.04809968173503876,
-0.46170565485954285,
0.1400875449180603,
-0.15219391882419586,
1.1394363641738892,
-0.4712231457233429,
0.2831488251686096,
0.4319436550140381,
0.835338830947876,
0.623896062374115,
-0.39808735251426697,
0.5550527572631836,
-0.6545737385749817,
0.16214333474636078,
0.13274866342544556,
0.29172468185424805,
0.19037052989006042,
0.1262558251619339,
0.27747291326522827,
-0.037684425711631775,
-0.6753502488136292,
-0.9275710582733154,
0.1747613549232483,
-0.9289248585700989,
-0.11075203120708466,
1.0439622402191162,
-0.3851286768913269,
0.023672355338931084,
0.010537682101130486,
0.05966801568865776,
0.3022623062133789,
-0.0008001475944183767,
0.6184994578361511,
1.0120166540145874,
0.016329895704984665,
-0.0193033367395401,
-0.8922324776649475,
0.5284643173217773,
0.4686863124370575,
-0.677031397819519,
0.1789986789226532,
0.16615767776966095,
0.1671278476715088,
0.3284578025341034,
0.6263555884361267,
0.032992321997880936,
-0.09940691292285919,
-0.16140779852867126,
-0.17104417085647583,
0.03118770755827427,
-0.44216758012771606,
-0.5578993558883667,
0.023858632892370224,
0.2885890007019043,
0.013168847188353539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01196v1
|
Estimating Lexical Complexity from Document-Level Distributions
| 2024-04-01T15:55:18 | 2024-04-01T15:55:18 |
Sondre Wold, Petter Mæhlum, Oddbjørn Hove
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing methods for complexity estimation are typically developed for entire
documents. This limitation in scope makes them inapplicable for shorter pieces
of text, such as health assessment tools. These typically consist of lists of
independent sentences, all of which are too short for existing methods to
apply. The choice of wording in these assessment tools is crucial, as both the
cognitive capacity and the linguistic competency of the intended patient groups
could vary substantially. As a first step towards creating better tools for
supporting health practitioners, we develop a two-step approach for estimating
lexical complexity that does not rely on any pre-annotated data. We implement
our approach for the Norwegian language and verify its effectiveness using
statistical testing and a qualitative evaluation of samples from real
assessment tools. We also investigate the relationship between our complexity
measure and certain features typically associated with complexity in the
literature, such as word length, frequency, and the number of syllables.
|
[
-0.18408338725566864,
-0.605520486831665,
0.8010174632072449,
0.2682429552078247,
-0.41745397448539734,
-0.1649613380432129,
-0.2592209279537201,
-0.6084694266319275,
0.2326618731021881,
0.13096098601818085,
-0.24737468361854553,
-0.30688753724098206,
-1.0062912702560425,
0.3376685678958893,
-0.16794085502624512,
0.8500325083732605,
-0.17542409896850586,
0.23209916055202484,
-0.45994260907173157,
-0.12915457785129547,
-0.3981057107448578,
-0.04122021794319153,
-0.38378435373306274,
-0.3071749210357666,
0.6009953618049622,
0.2818365693092346,
0.7211905717849731,
0.2254936695098877,
0.6391502022743225,
0.23455531895160675,
-0.536779522895813,
0.11379797756671906,
-0.3204995095729828,
0.12201699614524841,
-0.14822064340114594,
-0.45349785685539246,
-0.3963537812232971,
-0.32386404275894165,
0.5605811476707458,
0.9944375157356262,
0.021898576989769936,
0.15082277357578278,
-0.008087830618023872,
0.8721340298652649,
-0.6278197765350342,
0.22322873771190643,
-0.2829901874065399,
0.16893863677978516,
-0.35849612951278687,
0.05521702393889427,
-0.01597907580435276,
-0.20160596072673798,
0.5896767377853394,
-0.6530756950378418,
0.07564937323331833,
-0.08770468086004257,
0.4259086847305298,
0.20736265182495117,
-0.34254926443099976,
-0.8265351057052612,
-0.8069411516189575,
0.7290409207344055,
-0.6344560384750366,
0.347660094499588,
0.771762490272522,
-0.12306247651576996,
-0.1886485069990158,
-0.568595290184021,
-0.3826152980327606,
-0.41887760162353516,
-0.11170932650566101,
0.16359207034111023,
-0.216427743434906,
0.21454498171806335,
0.30585232377052307,
0.46318522095680237,
-0.7586460113525391,
0.07938134670257568,
-0.6108265519142151,
-0.21469764411449432,
0.5698130130767822,
0.06413313746452332,
0.3953096866607666,
-0.6669439673423767,
-0.07830244302749634,
-0.03153814747929573,
-0.07014837861061096,
-0.055839065462350845,
0.2938957214355469,
0.04571367800235748,
-0.03426872193813324,
0.7975942492485046,
-0.14356330037117004,
0.2600806653499603,
-0.39525100588798523,
-0.5260993242263794,
0.4078303575515747,
-0.4866132438182831,
-0.18788743019104004,
0.06905607879161835,
0.789243757724762,
-0.07756546884775162,
-0.05741360783576965,
-0.08179287612438202,
-0.22182337939739227,
-0.3122122883796692,
0.41098663210868835,
-0.39668357372283936,
-0.2805130183696747,
0.5350878834724426,
-0.2042296677827835,
0.006253606639802456,
-0.10553533583879471,
-0.8744921684265137,
-0.3956888020038605,
0.1588473618030548,
0.6243828535079956,
-0.6435677409172058,
-0.39863502979278564,
0.20751063525676727,
-0.3286990821361542,
-0.20317451655864716,
0.10109129548072815,
-0.5252755880355835,
0.33591973781585693,
0.5982697010040283,
1.0586128234863281,
-0.2635789215564728,
-0.01980544999241829,
-0.02093333564698696,
-0.3581385314464569,
-0.5141861438751221,
0.6796696186065674,
-0.08735692501068115,
-0.44299840927124023,
-0.056272104382514954,
-0.16003774106502533,
0.0664411410689354,
-0.3117213547229767,
0.8532308340072632,
-0.25355151295661926,
0.18411503732204437,
-0.13463428616523743,
-0.7228233814239502,
0.1095016673207283,
0.1368064284324646,
-0.8605296015739441,
1.2199457883834839,
0.6633925437927246,
-1.1920866966247559,
0.4801962077617645,
-0.5788261890411377,
-0.6779016852378845,
0.29912877082824707,
-0.08118101954460144,
-0.45445770025253296,
0.5384370684623718,
0.0881829559803009,
0.19353371858596802,
-0.5000367760658264,
-0.03798148036003113,
-0.05262601375579834,
-0.0008543693693354726,
0.07489576190710068,
-0.378507137298584,
0.6848087310791016,
0.1887338012456894,
-0.24667806923389435,
-0.0512334369122982,
-0.7277776002883911,
0.12507571280002594,
-0.05633210390806198,
-0.4586072862148285,
-0.6315038204193115,
0.17639194428920746,
0.05665765702724457,
-0.14641357958316803,
0.35851752758026123,
-0.4565741717815399,
-0.15950319170951843,
-0.7732452154159546,
0.12616416811943054,
0.21856756508350372,
0.06080791726708412,
0.5345496535301208,
-0.39265602827072144,
0.8329751491546631,
-0.22488310933113098,
0.2713855803012848,
0.2667199373245239,
-0.5846613049507141,
-0.2995212972164154,
-0.25917187333106995,
0.6360943913459778,
0.612997829914093,
-0.856902003288269,
0.5850164294242859,
-0.55229252576828,
-0.9341009855270386,
-0.33751633763313293,
0.2695510685443878,
0.581338107585907,
0.23411104083061218,
0.2790609300136566,
-0.7107684016227722,
-0.3286888897418976,
-0.6965262293815613,
-0.06997630000114441,
-0.5015462040901184,
-0.27106666564941406,
0.10468603670597076,
0.626872718334198,
-0.1272139996290207,
0.5640793442726135,
-0.5054123997688293,
-0.17759551107883453,
-0.31417134404182434,
0.2806752026081085,
0.23596131801605225,
0.36084774136543274,
0.322398841381073,
-0.7130216956138611,
-0.2556474804878235,
0.07141049206256866,
-0.5799151659011841,
-0.19487710297107697,
0.23742179572582245,
0.22836382687091827,
0.16253213584423065,
0.3659542500972748,
-0.3953346312046051,
0.5296028256416321,
0.640031099319458,
-0.10782106965780258,
0.6425777673721313,
-0.6948086619377136,
-0.1973082423210144,
-0.6356512308120728,
0.05030890181660652,
-0.16408024728298187,
0.05112222954630852,
-0.8416086435317993,
-0.011589973233640194,
-0.031049199402332306,
0.197694331407547,
-0.38832342624664307,
0.5407355427742004,
-0.5721083879470825,
0.016413791105151176,
-0.031682223081588745,
-0.01911885291337967,
-0.025207487866282463,
0.12456288933753967,
-0.06498830765485764,
0.5777087807655334,
0.19863997399806976,
-0.39765796065330505,
0.015401780605316162,
0.03760484606027603,
-0.8034034371376038,
0.7415610551834106,
-0.7925265431404114,
-0.2584269940853119,
-0.20074093341827393,
0.05403393134474754,
-1.1686547994613647,
-0.36291787028312683,
-0.020285876467823982,
-0.29865238070487976,
0.1484164297580719,
0.16054211556911469,
-0.5861685276031494,
-0.4496532380580902,
-0.2859180271625519,
0.611745297908783,
0.34617698192596436,
0.34926098585128784,
0.6050711870193481,
0.6473912596702576,
-0.28422340750694275,
-0.3419126868247986,
-0.772710382938385,
-0.034568171948194504,
-0.15051335096359253,
-0.6456902027130127,
0.12199214845895767,
-0.14726592600345612,
-0.24849484860897064,
-0.16732774674892426,
-0.3361561894416809,
-0.3352757394313812,
0.09709784388542175,
0.4107445478439331,
-0.22999128699302673,
-0.16160915791988373,
0.6052704453468323,
0.30308589339256287,
0.2377963662147522,
0.056741323322057724,
-0.23293188214302063,
0.4742976129055023,
0.09087391942739487,
-0.4483688473701477,
-0.10500703006982803,
0.4941767156124115,
0.6619352698326111,
-0.07530341297388077,
0.4093111753463745,
0.5326413512229919,
-0.504324734210968,
0.030220799148082733,
-0.4676586389541626,
0.3431629538536072,
-0.3668367266654968,
0.6169610619544983,
-0.3335304856300354,
-0.7263534665107727,
0.5898865461349487,
0.16531051695346832,
-0.137429878115654,
0.7133045196533203,
0.5632457137107849,
0.009162361733615398,
0.5915239453315735,
0.3232226073741913,
0.25305989384651184,
0.17530527710914612,
-0.008473873138427734,
-0.05673477426171303,
-0.625904381275177,
-0.33320698142051697,
-0.6157753467559814,
-0.061416007578372955,
-0.6901993751525879,
-0.6285454630851746,
0.8801262378692627,
0.15419410169124603,
-0.08304362744092941,
0.266498327255249,
-0.36029303073883057,
0.18472348153591156,
0.39674392342567444,
0.3366515338420868,
0.17454376816749573,
-0.008578076958656311,
-0.43380171060562134,
0.004569252487272024,
-0.6749233603477478,
-0.2082546502351761,
0.9816491007804871,
0.5546489357948303,
0.612328052520752,
0.29985445737838745,
0.8587455749511719,
0.33760860562324524,
0.064476877450943,
-1.0407319068908691,
0.15575236082077026,
-0.30259907245635986,
-0.615667998790741,
-0.9605492353439331,
-0.45966196060180664,
-1.280521035194397,
0.04595602676272392,
-0.2563275396823883,
-0.5167797207832336,
0.19757992029190063,
-0.35032737255096436,
-0.34114566445350647,
-0.05889783799648285,
-0.6550432443618774,
0.4266148507595062,
-0.16366985440254211,
0.1813565492630005,
0.1669035255908966,
-0.6245543360710144,
0.014109281823039055,
-0.4856627583503723,
0.565240740776062,
-0.06594450026750565,
-0.2664377689361572,
1.1924729347229004,
-0.6037876605987549,
0.616393506526947,
0.09853319078683853,
-0.37777358293533325,
0.21064986288547516,
0.06295911222696304,
0.14209595322608948,
0.06542795896530151,
-0.30817997455596924,
0.11804181337356567,
0.6237426400184631,
-0.5406505465507507,
-0.4672406315803528,
0.341731995344162,
-0.7101156711578369,
-0.4083910882472992,
-0.6032640337944031,
-0.6266683340072632,
-0.353945791721344,
0.5500853061676025,
0.4765147566795349,
0.2666186988353729,
-0.356768399477005,
0.12004223465919495,
0.4639921188354492,
-0.2530948221683502,
0.2713918685913086,
0.17311978340148926,
0.10703899711370468,
-0.6352725625038147,
0.5717903971672058,
0.6335391998291016,
0.40649744868278503,
0.4324711859226227,
0.665132462978363,
-0.4202578067779541,
-0.8891429901123047,
-0.07422643899917603,
0.12346632033586502,
-0.6990721225738525,
0.12991750240325928,
-0.5727387070655823,
-0.19046200811862946,
-0.5369852185249329,
-0.01422018464654684,
-0.14238138496875763,
-0.4702965319156647,
-0.2644979655742645,
-0.043672021478414536,
0.41110068559646606,
1.108643651008606,
-0.28586795926094055,
0.15657608211040497,
-0.8003798723220825,
0.32251498103141785,
0.4021429419517517,
0.30868393182754517,
-0.02322394959628582,
-0.47478726506233215,
-0.20163601636886597,
-0.19063441455364227,
-0.019947471097111702,
-1.1426180601119995,
0.33491969108581543,
0.3307596445083618,
0.4196930229663849,
0.2265927493572235,
0.2582094669342041,
0.42236974835395813,
-0.5348286628723145,
0.886102557182312,
0.3075205683708191,
-0.9920307993888855,
0.49045559763908386,
-0.22434446215629578,
0.5360329151153564,
0.8013232946395874,
0.4847928583621979,
-0.29658910632133484,
-0.43539121747016907,
-0.8025142550468445,
-1.0143839120864868,
0.22010287642478943,
0.3126310706138611,
0.1400979459285736,
-0.187369704246521,
0.4595862627029419,
-0.21107123792171478,
-0.08682980388402939,
-0.3441179394721985,
0.05185670405626297,
0.15317589044570923,
-0.404659241437912,
-0.30968156456947327,
-0.460545152425766,
-0.24954001605510712,
-0.17496263980865479,
0.2800008952617645,
-0.08890316635370255,
0.11229664832353592,
0.6233375072479248,
-0.13741351664066315,
-0.18723466992378235,
0.3905872404575348,
0.7057408690452576,
1.0656044483184814,
-0.1919110119342804,
0.449004203081131,
0.4835154414176941,
-0.9595349431037903,
0.18244019150733948,
-0.02446124702692032,
0.07405704259872437,
0.2544735372066498,
0.9083012938499451,
0.4065619707107544,
0.3151170313358307,
-0.8073394894599915,
0.7112370133399963,
0.027297863736748695,
-0.40004128217697144,
-0.4867897927761078,
-0.01767844334244728,
0.2144020050764084,
0.11054584383964539,
0.2095472812652588,
-0.34113821387290955,
0.22097817063331604,
-0.25175246596336365,
0.2869596481323242,
0.14251649379730225,
-0.7187232375144958,
-0.07128196209669113,
0.14777685701847076,
-0.1305244415998459,
-0.37139052152633667,
0.2864273190498352,
-0.2779688835144043,
-0.2895174026489258,
0.6500672101974487,
0.3034193217754364,
0.6872606873512268,
-0.09683236479759216,
0.34250369668006897,
0.33014440536499023,
0.57975172996521,
-0.46780556440353394,
0.5099367499351501,
0.30258575081825256,
-0.36190277338027954,
-0.41501206159591675,
-1.0256588459014893,
-0.30179363489151,
0.01031265314668417,
-0.8589051365852356,
0.11127880960702896,
-0.24698437750339508,
-0.24106265604496002,
0.259645938873291,
0.2360105812549591,
-0.7159668207168579,
0.31994807720184326,
-0.09245534986257553,
0.9904259443283081,
-0.81119704246521,
0.4917210340499878,
0.4635081887245178,
-0.34423717856407166,
-0.68906569480896,
-0.004912694916129112,
-0.034321267157793045,
-0.6954128742218018,
0.4632396996021271,
-0.18064868450164795,
0.12025589495897293,
-0.31312790513038635,
-0.2003602236509323,
-0.7381939888000488,
0.9190971851348877,
0.13191711902618408,
-0.42071545124053955,
-0.2946198284626007,
0.28327858448028564,
0.9429949522018433,
-0.10356041043996811,
0.3399161398410797,
0.5203087329864502,
0.5650677680969238,
0.172285795211792,
-1.3798136711120605,
0.060637589544057846,
-0.08374027907848358,
0.28806763887405396,
0.18510328233242035,
0.12303630262613297,
0.8402579426765442,
-0.03742046281695366,
-0.28871849179267883,
0.12395229935646057,
0.6062345504760742,
-0.14315830171108246,
0.3569543659687042,
0.8499574661254883,
0.6223894953727722,
1.017594337463379,
0.25310835242271423,
1.0756951570510864,
-0.025135736912488937,
0.502884566783905,
1.0991023778915405,
0.02088751830160618,
0.905463695526123,
0.36689260601997375,
-0.6019595861434937,
0.5081921815872192,
0.5104815363883972,
0.2624209523200989,
0.22148509323596954,
0.6944571733474731,
-0.34367573261260986,
0.04937824234366417,
-0.1561574637889862,
-0.1607481837272644,
0.5483947992324829,
0.6174715757369995,
-0.3982193171977997,
-0.22378578782081604,
0.09726443886756897,
0.108216792345047,
-0.024810772389173508,
-0.15087319910526276,
0.9379263520240784,
0.19613973796367645,
-0.707967221736908,
0.711428701877594,
-0.16007006168365479,
0.36005106568336487,
-0.6717620491981506,
0.19322465360164642,
0.11630666255950928,
-0.2507063150405884,
-0.172622412443161,
-1.0226354598999023,
0.4174065887928009,
-0.16636832058429718,
-0.17508575320243835,
0.3520828187465668,
0.5779565572738647,
-0.3557783365249634,
-0.7735272645950317,
0.2458011358976364,
0.8359999060630798,
0.4241698384284973,
0.006033044774085283,
-0.41433510184288025,
-0.2056170105934143,
-0.3653712868690491,
-0.1945863664150238,
0.18329159915447235,
0.6730045080184937,
-0.07090555131435394,
0.36407381296157837,
0.42553070187568665,
0.45122241973876953,
-0.012645515613257885,
-0.07321824133396149,
0.5493283271789551,
-0.23349060118198395,
-0.48904234170913696,
-0.635089635848999,
0.2620612382888794,
0.011101270094513893,
-0.6012768149375916,
0.5324476361274719,
0.2519043982028961,
0.5672696828842163,
0.0013533124001696706,
0.8043217658996582,
-0.3589783012866974,
0.48990508913993835,
-0.47074270248413086,
0.6464699506759644,
-0.7672103643417358,
0.08838393539190292,
-0.42158281803131104,
-0.41290679574012756,
-0.5693265795707703,
0.4031939208507538,
-0.30088332295417786,
-0.18336234986782074,
0.9950979948043823,
0.6730881333351135,
0.06278754770755768,
-0.14363963901996613,
0.48881757259368896,
0.13813836872577667,
0.16501736640930176,
0.4618287682533264,
0.3094247281551361,
-0.23004591464996338,
0.3908059597015381,
-0.3160270154476166,
-0.5075401067733765,
0.028198441490530968,
-0.9519103765487671,
-0.7287465929985046,
-0.7411689162254333,
-0.15013818442821503,
-0.5982487201690674,
-0.10387127101421356,
0.8254431486129761,
0.4184376001358032,
-0.6527603268623352,
-0.15779773890972137,
-0.022303231060504913,
0.2808496356010437,
-0.40449047088623047,
-0.1291613131761551,
0.8371381163597107,
-0.3009997308254242,
-0.444460391998291,
-0.07792684435844421,
0.2163340300321579,
-0.0688350573182106,
-0.48484116792678833,
0.15157097578048706,
-0.17758023738861084,
0.35727301239967346,
0.6651659607887268,
0.270548015832901,
-0.7946380376815796,
-0.4187929630279541,
-0.0899495929479599,
-0.14253532886505127,
-0.059419382363557816,
0.573521077632904,
-0.14006361365318298,
0.8540846705436707,
0.9984856247901917,
0.5200835466384888,
0.11629520356655121,
-0.4153854548931122,
0.2144944667816162,
-0.7331966161727905,
-0.11187049001455307,
0.4059622585773468,
0.2632439434528351,
0.07586471736431122,
-0.27442315220832825,
0.5499988198280334,
0.12291161715984344,
-0.4648928940296173,
-0.716708242893219,
0.185639888048172,
-1.0811513662338257,
-0.32519105076789856,
1.1584528684616089,
-0.2766490578651428,
-0.37258070707321167,
-0.5397665500640869,
-0.1375260055065155,
0.13018755614757538,
-0.10198117792606354,
0.6710041165351868,
0.9096275568008423,
-0.1301218867301941,
0.02519102394580841,
-0.6871196031570435,
0.6809060573577881,
0.20491865277290344,
-0.7890073657035828,
-0.20753945410251617,
0.1324717402458191,
0.35258007049560547,
0.8221489787101746,
0.9622209072113037,
-0.3628067076206207,
0.15113511681556702,
-0.008679598569869995,
-0.16364428400993347,
0.5281503200531006,
-0.19842194020748138,
-0.4132429361343384,
0.3738505244255066,
0.3676212728023529,
0.43234169483184814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01189v1
|
Generating Faithful and Complete Hospital-Course Summaries from the Electronic Health Record
| 2024-04-01T15:47:21 | 2024-04-01T15:47:21 |
Griffin Adams
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid adoption of Electronic Health Records (EHRs) has been instrumental
in streamlining administrative tasks, increasing transparency, and enabling
continuity of care across providers. An unintended consequence of the increased
documentation burden, however, has been reduced face-time with patients and,
concomitantly, a dramatic rise in clinician burnout. In this thesis, we
pinpoint a particularly time-intensive, yet critical, documentation task:
generating a summary of a patient's hospital admissions, and propose and
evaluate automated solutions. In Chapter 2, we construct a dataset based on
109,000 hospitalizations (2M source notes) and perform exploratory analyses to
motivate future work on modeling and evaluation [NAACL 2021]. In Chapter 3, we
address faithfulness from a modeling perspective by revising noisy references
[EMNLP 2022] and, to reduce the reliance on references, directly calibrating
model outputs to metrics [ACL 2023]. These works relied heavily on automatic
metrics as human annotations were limited. To fill this gap, in Chapter 4, we
conduct a fine-grained expert annotation of system errors in order to
meta-evaluate existing metrics and better understand task-specific issues of
domain adaptation and source-summary alignments. To learn a metric less
correlated to extractiveness (copy-and-paste), we derive noisy faithfulness
labels from an ensemble of existing metrics and train a faithfulness classifier
on these pseudo labels [MLHC 2023]. Finally, in Chapter 5, we demonstrate that
fine-tuned LLMs (Mistral and Zephyr) are highly prone to entity hallucinations
and cover fewer salient entities. We improve both coverage and faithfulness by
performing sentence-level entity planning based on a set of pre-computed
salient entities from the source text, which extends our work on entity-guided
news summarization [ACL, 2023], [EMNLP, 2023].
|
[
-0.13691268861293793,
-0.5810199975967407,
0.9712736010551453,
-0.11706887930631638,
0.06889358162879944,
-0.1679239571094513,
-0.04197198152542114,
-0.5295256972312927,
0.2650515139102936,
0.8156957626342773,
-0.3287164866924286,
-0.5538893938064575,
-0.44838351011276245,
0.043732259422540665,
-0.5176188945770264,
1.4715818166732788,
-0.44308149814605713,
-0.10573837906122208,
-0.30306121706962585,
-0.13931909203529358,
-0.1575806885957718,
-0.46990516781806946,
-0.32923853397369385,
-0.4369354844093323,
0.4347047805786133,
0.3916735053062439,
0.6745260953903198,
0.7533100843429565,
0.8338231444358826,
0.19331598281860352,
0.3704473078250885,
0.30704110860824585,
-0.5091841816902161,
0.2367701679468155,
0.02548443339765072,
-0.28385376930236816,
-0.709579586982727,
-0.321766197681427,
0.6113255620002747,
0.8806093335151672,
-0.1619640439748764,
0.4393013119697571,
0.058459218591451645,
0.7859209179878235,
-0.6873978972434998,
0.1198548898100853,
-0.36951324343681335,
-0.003403955604881048,
-0.04666021838784218,
-0.2953498661518097,
-0.40129485726356506,
-0.31932398676872253,
0.1944289654493332,
-0.8961713314056396,
0.5082957744598389,
-0.1233367770910263,
1.0660152435302734,
0.5876917839050293,
-0.17336708307266235,
-0.33881843090057373,
-0.8804464340209961,
0.8012109398841858,
-0.5808082222938538,
0.3808773458003998,
0.5124875903129578,
0.20264697074890137,
0.004560007248073816,
-0.8741811513900757,
-0.11519218981266022,
-0.19443850219249725,
-0.1955818235874176,
0.36891239881515503,
-0.047600556164979935,
0.2103632688522339,
0.41646745800971985,
0.45310258865356445,
-0.3572195768356323,
-0.2677019536495209,
-0.4463537335395813,
-0.1652069240808487,
0.7827206254005432,
0.40795207023620605,
0.11719425767660141,
0.06094851344823837,
0.07390132546424866,
0.047196220606565475,
-0.4469212293624878,
-0.38684865832328796,
0.21422694623470306,
-0.0778752788901329,
0.0030448504257947206,
0.6677190661430359,
-0.2852731943130493,
0.53354412317276,
-0.022389153018593788,
-0.3526337444782257,
0.2159172147512436,
-0.3572656810283661,
-0.24907363951206207,
0.09362857043743134,
0.5272586941719055,
0.6026428937911987,
0.13083037734031677,
-0.3035120666027069,
-0.3590264320373535,
0.04436501860618591,
0.6798441410064697,
-0.44978439807891846,
-0.45733457803726196,
0.5403550863265991,
-0.6044471859931946,
-0.3002389073371887,
0.1431327611207962,
-0.7023828029632568,
0.021089784801006317,
-0.6517199873924255,
0.28635525703430176,
-0.5291978120803833,
0.15100271999835968,
-0.006953063420951366,
-0.02152545005083084,
-0.0769432783126831,
0.5977370142936707,
-0.569412887096405,
0.526237428188324,
0.666395366191864,
0.9311758875846863,
-0.12122722715139389,
-0.241292342543602,
-0.503504753112793,
0.4633455276489258,
-0.17794197797775269,
0.5763404965400696,
-0.03563019633293152,
-0.42351028323173523,
0.20013490319252014,
-0.005232418887317181,
0.14781644940376282,
-0.5530399680137634,
0.6895008087158203,
-0.2723942995071411,
0.125545471906662,
-0.0729498565196991,
-0.6282617449760437,
0.0037820495199412107,
0.1586616039276123,
-0.7464740872383118,
0.7200908064842224,
0.46955883502960205,
-0.6291627883911133,
0.12049056589603424,
-0.4946587085723877,
-0.3164495527744293,
-0.22039611637592316,
0.063118577003479,
-0.6940604448318481,
0.3165360689163208,
0.08203516900539398,
0.3421843945980072,
0.15695099532604218,
0.13510392606258392,
-0.0027712706942111254,
-0.33436959981918335,
-0.061675816774368286,
0.002396815223619342,
0.6755126714706421,
0.25361138582229614,
-0.11184827238321304,
-0.05022740736603737,
-0.7896108031272888,
-0.09462464600801468,
-0.010007682256400585,
-0.4277443289756775,
-0.44276949763298035,
0.060400161892175674,
0.11854038387537003,
-0.0672328919172287,
0.11520706862211227,
-0.03743701055645943,
0.06299435347318649,
-0.18027925491333008,
-0.01662667840719223,
0.41995304822921753,
0.2343418151140213,
0.30448201298713684,
-0.8092731237411499,
0.4012121260166168,
0.1022985428571701,
0.3745814561843872,
-0.5970029830932617,
-0.20522859692573547,
-0.7671127319335938,
-0.039438772946596146,
0.22323565185070038,
0.4575638771057129,
-0.6488716006278992,
0.2300610989332199,
-0.45124202966690063,
-0.41127705574035645,
-0.6946548819541931,
0.04771498590707779,
0.5009779930114746,
0.7295867800712585,
0.5935352444648743,
-0.5009490251541138,
-0.5469650030136108,
-0.8638961911201477,
-0.3046680688858032,
-0.386249303817749,
-0.1940690577030182,
0.13529613614082336,
0.3971329927444458,
-0.36943694949150085,
0.5053292512893677,
-0.6132591366767883,
-0.5541398525238037,
0.05008271336555481,
0.20072010159492493,
-0.03346366435289383,
0.407282292842865,
0.3438413441181183,
-0.44991132616996765,
-0.23512251675128937,
-0.1974010169506073,
-0.9249830842018127,
-0.33956485986709595,
-0.5186582803726196,
-0.06507287174463272,
0.022365601733326912,
0.33042412996292114,
-0.4362785816192627,
0.2684447467327118,
0.17618833482265472,
-0.14643126726150513,
0.6854028701782227,
-0.3616477847099304,
0.1304197907447815,
-0.9381513595581055,
0.0479261614382267,
0.22655072808265686,
-0.4096376597881317,
-0.5760113000869751,
0.13055101037025452,
-0.05188848078250885,
0.16625438630580902,
-0.03357643634080887,
0.32518261671066284,
-0.6607316732406616,
0.18062599003314972,
-0.06755967438220978,
0.12412212789058685,
0.22966228425502777,
0.300147145986557,
-0.17137648165225983,
0.3201546370983124,
0.21652042865753174,
-0.5368523001670837,
0.21616245806217194,
0.40810689330101013,
0.17988979816436768,
0.6341685652732849,
-0.43031424283981323,
-0.07194937020540237,
-0.34028360247612,
0.20512336492538452,
-0.410290002822876,
-0.631626307964325,
0.09152377396821976,
-0.2528671622276306,
0.3700726330280304,
0.016666563227772713,
-0.38833603262901306,
-0.05312778800725937,
-0.4076653718948364,
0.10809206962585449,
0.5704919099807739,
-0.03863229602575302,
0.6229218244552612,
0.47206151485443115,
-0.22599196434020996,
-0.2984738051891327,
-0.6934141516685486,
0.15430353581905365,
0.09769712388515472,
-0.1945270597934723,
0.4723464250564575,
0.1539415717124939,
-0.705767035484314,
0.18928074836730957,
-0.03621629625558853,
-0.21886152029037476,
0.049274418503046036,
0.3949454724788666,
0.28345340490341187,
-0.2803686261177063,
0.15964554250240326,
0.051174554973840714,
-0.00261573470197618,
0.45517274737358093,
-0.3809598982334137,
-0.009540058672428131,
-0.1417476236820221,
-0.6098817586898804,
-0.6124303936958313,
0.7070593237876892,
0.6317890882492065,
0.1984838843345642,
0.4472205340862274,
0.29298779368400574,
-0.6460011601448059,
0.03931782767176628,
-0.7525866627693176,
-0.24955032765865326,
-0.27851903438568115,
0.3776192367076874,
-0.03549099713563919,
-0.281269371509552,
0.49935752153396606,
-0.031215667724609375,
0.6312801241874695,
0.6405785083770752,
0.4026106297969818,
-0.07827849686145782,
0.7295997142791748,
0.7372982501983643,
0.05914977937936783,
0.3410482108592987,
-0.23286673426628113,
-0.1358472853899002,
-0.7494845390319824,
-0.3448118269443512,
-0.4574141204357147,
0.050385408103466034,
-0.5973942279815674,
-0.29395169019699097,
0.40551242232322693,
0.025080092251300812,
0.037042275071144104,
0.043891631066799164,
-0.4161835312843323,
0.29136306047439575,
0.39877477288246155,
0.377989798784256,
0.580794632434845,
-0.016761718317866325,
0.2949458360671997,
-0.10439691692590714,
-0.4271073639392853,
-0.8885142803192139,
1.1465705633163452,
0.5418846607208252,
0.7073411345481873,
0.004767596255987883,
0.9797261953353882,
0.3244132697582245,
0.5587074160575867,
-0.4728226065635681,
0.11830562353134155,
-0.07941985875368118,
-0.3917806148529053,
-0.23839817941188812,
-0.3128387928009033,
-0.4476659297943115,
-0.1343371719121933,
-0.10621987283229828,
-0.41393840312957764,
0.11916466057300568,
0.47510385513305664,
-0.5952683687210083,
0.2280503809452057,
-0.6228861808776855,
0.542275071144104,
-0.33490225672721863,
-0.3709532916545868,
-0.01459357887506485,
-0.8991698026657104,
0.43894338607788086,
-0.34821903705596924,
0.15316273272037506,
0.11997576057910919,
-0.18954329192638397,
0.5733415484428406,
-0.5255650877952576,
0.5067477822303772,
0.09305369853973389,
-0.00579488929361105,
0.18062035739421844,
0.0988740473985672,
0.4863163232803345,
0.018000157549977303,
-0.003934352193027735,
0.21550798416137695,
0.15399403870105743,
-0.4138423204421997,
-0.6062544584274292,
0.395114928483963,
-0.6386182308197021,
-0.3959384858608246,
-0.2179957628250122,
-0.5153082609176636,
-0.24273502826690674,
0.18868206441402435,
0.321990966796875,
0.4577074348926544,
-0.3535095155239105,
-0.24588531255722046,
0.9971350431442261,
-0.11395835876464844,
0.016377145424485207,
0.3288424015045166,
-0.12422118335962296,
-0.41427886486053467,
0.7582210898399353,
0.20195485651493073,
0.21788926422595978,
0.34903740882873535,
-0.13001033663749695,
-0.02621469460427761,
-0.4510975480079651,
-0.563685953617096,
0.2896985113620758,
-0.6827461123466492,
-0.19498677551746368,
-1.0087512731552124,
-0.41058769822120667,
-0.33016470074653625,
-0.41502827405929565,
-0.19432969391345978,
-0.5602105259895325,
-0.7378635406494141,
-0.06671027094125748,
0.018022524192929268,
0.9869555830955505,
-0.03666810318827629,
0.2756733000278473,
-0.831080436706543,
0.5147083401679993,
-0.0660487487912178,
0.21058520674705505,
-0.022215232253074646,
-0.5352749824523926,
-0.42080363631248474,
-0.003862278535962105,
-0.5010260343551636,
-1.095544457435608,
0.3207699656486511,
0.22523941099643707,
0.5929157137870789,
0.589255690574646,
0.09758607298135757,
0.6932688355445862,
-0.6055298447608948,
0.8184402585029602,
0.20135295391082764,
-0.7001820206642151,
0.7386711835861206,
-0.3947727084159851,
0.14609570801258087,
1.0241694450378418,
0.3623119592666626,
-0.3746035695075989,
-0.7465559840202332,
-0.9326766729354858,
-1.042012095451355,
0.415771484375,
0.15473946928977966,
-0.06652994453907013,
0.10256166756153107,
0.5939162969589233,
0.10053154826164246,
0.015723727643489838,
-0.383602112531662,
-0.4482645094394684,
-0.28378498554229736,
-0.6258522868156433,
-0.011953171342611313,
-0.4018339216709137,
-0.2798754870891571,
0.02796083316206932,
0.8401110172271729,
-0.086823970079422,
0.16747410595417023,
0.5763744711875916,
-0.23360860347747803,
-0.3088838756084442,
0.18445856869220734,
0.7558550238609314,
0.9836755990982056,
-0.17288069427013397,
0.3238348662853241,
0.2739139497280121,
-0.6586466431617737,
-0.0316682830452919,
0.18549421429634094,
-0.4047701060771942,
0.6741270422935486,
0.6124379634857178,
0.4365023970603943,
0.09070626646280289,
-0.4484122097492218,
0.46377474069595337,
0.04771685227751732,
-0.14522872865200043,
-0.5035364627838135,
0.002460210118442774,
-0.1600164920091629,
-0.10563959181308746,
0.2659545838832855,
-0.0847180113196373,
0.4564875662326813,
-0.4051348865032196,
0.5334495902061462,
0.0743069276213646,
-0.6512212753295898,
-0.36567604541778564,
0.7562295198440552,
0.058565523475408554,
-0.16108918190002441,
0.44008344411849976,
0.17811284959316254,
-0.2485181987285614,
0.4514259397983551,
0.338984876871109,
0.9842203259468079,
-0.2826104462146759,
0.08196630328893661,
0.36633366346359253,
0.2923617959022522,
-0.447483092546463,
0.06649021804332733,
0.04081426560878754,
-0.1413259506225586,
-0.38233181834220886,
-0.5153484344482422,
-0.5285080075263977,
0.051736019551754,
-0.9796695113182068,
0.2411087602376938,
-0.3620709180831909,
-0.16329489648342133,
-0.07283573597669601,
-0.0555395670235157,
-0.6182530522346497,
0.1879907250404358,
0.018091607838869095,
0.7917469143867493,
-0.9483487010002136,
0.20256438851356506,
0.8137978315353394,
-0.5763243436813354,
-0.7831597924232483,
0.13980503380298615,
0.11135058850049973,
-0.48911046981811523,
0.15571145713329315,
-0.14555242657661438,
0.14183670282363892,
-0.1355789601802826,
-0.3986337184906006,
-0.3692551255226135,
1.0524119138717651,
0.3265528678894043,
-0.7491232752799988,
-0.30789145827293396,
0.057299256324768066,
0.6283450722694397,
-0.23599831759929657,
0.40394261479377747,
0.45701321959495544,
0.22796393930912018,
-0.32266804575920105,
-0.9135861992835999,
0.13025790452957153,
-0.027126168832182884,
-0.2406020164489746,
0.12883397936820984,
-0.6421998143196106,
0.5591568350791931,
-0.41697898507118225,
0.04323912039399147,
-0.15804806351661682,
0.4972059726715088,
0.10879503935575485,
0.46775582432746887,
0.16603969037532806,
0.8032560348510742,
0.8886058330535889,
-0.202091246843338,
1.1125378608703613,
-0.1574181467294693,
0.27933070063591003,
1.30668306350708,
-0.13788023591041565,
0.5203580260276794,
0.6330009698867798,
-0.10797186940908432,
0.5255783200263977,
0.5954622626304626,
-0.05899081379175186,
0.3643459677696228,
0.09023009240627289,
-0.3804253339767456,
-0.07860269397497177,
-0.33165818452835083,
-0.34417158365249634,
0.04060794413089752,
0.14217491447925568,
-0.8267614841461182,
-0.3563993275165558,
-0.16226515173912048,
0.11975307017564774,
-0.0708533450961113,
-0.31542909145355225,
1.0802150964736938,
0.41400760412216187,
-0.8014711737632751,
0.05415963754057884,
-0.11018207669258118,
-0.03629537299275398,
-0.3858659267425537,
-0.34517526626586914,
-0.20771360397338867,
0.13699571788311005,
-0.45860999822616577,
-0.5062829852104187,
0.4956686496734619,
0.10684945434331894,
-0.5174829959869385,
-0.46149590611457825,
0.5943831205368042,
-0.29950249195098877,
-0.531499981880188,
-0.13192227482795715,
0.5645060539245605,
0.35387468338012695,
0.08985098451375961,
-0.5633331537246704,
-0.011750045232474804,
-0.04819768667221069,
-0.16002248227596283,
0.06845922023057938,
0.6276952624320984,
-0.11843086034059525,
0.39365464448928833,
0.4806447923183441,
0.5923976898193359,
-0.11192193627357483,
0.2555782198905945,
0.7925885915756226,
-0.4906817376613617,
-0.3041132390499115,
-0.8472909927368164,
0.5394240617752075,
-0.12539313733577728,
-0.29980579018592834,
0.4719076156616211,
0.7030936479568481,
0.7846806645393372,
-0.03208006173372269,
0.9224561452865601,
0.2367475926876068,
0.6550403237342834,
-0.5672356486320496,
0.6926252245903015,
-0.49696168303489685,
0.29353880882263184,
-0.3714980483055115,
-0.7267594337463379,
-0.36617913842201233,
0.4216921329498291,
-0.005664941389113665,
-0.11760032176971436,
0.5887160897254944,
0.3482665717601776,
0.013232380151748657,
-0.23150189220905304,
0.2925495505332947,
0.031817466020584106,
0.25052157044410706,
0.5848506093025208,
0.7433577179908752,
-0.6890573501586914,
0.306310772895813,
-0.3986699879169464,
-0.1990281641483307,
-0.4591101109981537,
-0.7026938796043396,
-0.5006582736968994,
-0.49623531103134155,
-0.7194108963012695,
-0.6626186370849609,
0.26134493947029114,
0.6712022423744202,
0.6597878932952881,
-1.0070722103118896,
0.09612229466438293,
0.028754403814673424,
0.0601077675819397,
-0.09851063787937164,
-0.201147198677063,
0.3779922425746918,
-0.3908344805240631,
-0.4157850444316864,
-0.2961910367012024,
0.28860723972320557,
0.3110028803348541,
-0.2662568986415863,
0.0739443451166153,
0.257656455039978,
-0.14485840499401093,
0.24343444406986237,
0.20606540143489838,
-0.7302194833755493,
-0.09110623598098755,
-0.05517050623893738,
-0.34513425827026367,
0.01932619884610176,
0.8610920906066895,
-0.527379035949707,
0.3535488545894623,
0.14523935317993164,
0.6026695966720581,
0.3457176387310028,
0.3626387119293213,
0.49372246861457825,
-0.5768973231315613,
-0.4542839229106903,
0.4724213182926178,
0.39190152287483215,
0.4318263828754425,
-0.7408378720283508,
0.4414106011390686,
0.2136116772890091,
-0.7126896381378174,
-0.8408882021903992,
-0.058401260524988174,
-0.8685770630836487,
-0.035523056983947754,
0.9490103125572205,
-0.1860092431306839,
-0.2743734121322632,
-0.4955432116985321,
0.0084009300917387,
0.4583619236946106,
-0.18001258373260498,
1.0802448987960815,
0.70721036195755,
-0.36045315861701965,
0.11039166897535324,
-0.9374456405639648,
0.6768295168876648,
0.21970157325267792,
-1.03681480884552,
0.07903172820806503,
0.8722903728485107,
0.34708818793296814,
0.4646274447441101,
0.8614804148674011,
-0.22234578430652618,
0.3175959587097168,
0.03632504865527153,
0.1116466373205185,
-0.11416547000408173,
-0.40545761585235596,
-0.32584473490715027,
0.13381817936897278,
0.0869673639535904,
0.025067713111639023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01182v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01182v1
|
A Neuro-Symbolic Approach to Monitoring Salt Content in Food
| 2024-04-01T15:34:24 | 2024-04-01T15:34:24 |
Anuja Tayal, Barbara Di Eugenio, Devika Salunke, Andrew D. Boyd, Carolyn A Dickens, Eulalia P Abril, Olga Garcia-Bedoya, Paula G Allen-Meares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SC
|
We propose a dialogue system that enables heart failure patients to inquire
about salt content in foods and help them monitor and reduce salt intake.
Addressing the lack of specific datasets for food-based salt content inquiries,
we develop a template-based conversational dataset. The dataset is structured
to ask clarification questions to identify food items and their salt content.
Our findings indicate that while fine-tuning transformer-based models on the
dataset yields limited performance, the integration of Neuro-Symbolic Rules
significantly enhances the system's performance. Our experiments show that by
integrating neuro-symbolic rules, our system achieves an improvement in joint
goal accuracy of over 20% across different data sizes compared to naively
fine-tuning transformer-based models.
|
[
-0.33020418882369995,
-0.3972366154193878,
0.6783552765846252,
0.1060553565621376,
-0.17278531193733215,
-0.1853468418121338,
-0.17899009585380554,
-0.31354576349258423,
0.38303545117378235,
0.2535821199417114,
-0.6832627654075623,
-0.4568980634212494,
-0.7742491364479065,
0.2146664261817932,
-0.4802651107311249,
1.0653367042541504,
-0.045362383127212524,
0.44919291138648987,
-0.018100740388035774,
0.2066996544599533,
-1.1025996208190918,
0.058666836470365524,
-0.9860369563102722,
-0.8408352136611938,
0.40099161863327026,
0.6885976791381836,
0.9617570042610168,
0.7838696241378784,
0.7611480355262756,
0.21409210562705994,
0.13596190512180328,
0.1701100915670395,
-0.3189235329627991,
0.4808688759803772,
-0.29343539476394653,
-0.7827809453010559,
-0.4803920090198517,
-0.2836924195289612,
0.12030301243066788,
0.45598581433296204,
0.08130589127540588,
0.2670952379703522,
0.1736745983362198,
0.635478138923645,
-0.5572580695152283,
0.6490343809127808,
-0.15613341331481934,
0.2665482461452484,
0.33655285835266113,
-0.396112859249115,
-0.1276627629995346,
-0.22596494853496552,
0.3201479911804199,
-0.5758663415908813,
0.0652424693107605,
0.15562033653259277,
0.9588925838470459,
0.5214585065841675,
-0.3214026391506195,
-0.4873548746109009,
-0.8360185027122498,
0.6673057675361633,
-0.47059351205825806,
0.5823968052864075,
0.7361827492713928,
0.2950088381767273,
-0.06489906460046768,
-0.4150201380252838,
-0.47933104634284973,
-0.14174239337444305,
-0.570161759853363,
0.11273466795682907,
-0.41067978739738464,
0.17703209817409515,
0.14182287454605103,
0.4069891571998596,
-0.4445383548736572,
-0.5274374485015869,
-0.29580000042915344,
-0.21223998069763184,
0.44684454798698425,
0.32043248414993286,
0.3958699107170105,
-0.47808003425598145,
-0.13030627369880676,
-0.05843851715326309,
-0.07724040001630783,
-0.32940608263015747,
-0.197104811668396,
0.40832385420799255,
-0.4057091176509857,
0.33477380871772766,
-0.15252000093460083,
0.714134931564331,
0.23264025151729584,
-0.17165565490722656,
0.027318019419908524,
-0.2905977666378021,
-0.3268277943134308,
0.39363208413124084,
0.32233092188835144,
0.7976131439208984,
0.5355935096740723,
-0.08416774868965149,
-0.6482413411140442,
0.3227021396160126,
0.3848055601119995,
-0.4205126464366913,
-0.678093433380127,
0.31999334692955017,
-0.366722971200943,
-0.14787527918815613,
0.12039399892091751,
-0.3864836096763611,
-0.5257700681686401,
-0.495281457901001,
0.47817492485046387,
-0.6259815692901611,
-0.10886628180742264,
0.15084367990493774,
-0.48414844274520874,
-0.20874078571796417,
0.1476651430130005,
-0.9543535709381104,
1.0602298974990845,
0.6720647215843201,
1.0737885236740112,
-0.0813199058175087,
0.15196868777275085,
-0.5657927393913269,
0.34422123432159424,
-0.15934649109840393,
0.7323839664459229,
-0.44297268986701965,
-0.3706246316432953,
-0.2820703685283661,
0.04157484695315361,
0.16688932478427887,
-0.6892504096031189,
0.453931987285614,
-0.2159755378961563,
-0.3863143026828766,
-0.575843334197998,
-0.2887808084487915,
-0.27899250388145447,
0.6861112117767334,
-0.7073153853416443,
1.02254056930542,
0.2083663046360016,
-0.35062575340270996,
0.44891518354415894,
-0.6616125702857971,
-0.7345275282859802,
-0.09390261769294739,
-0.17546698451042175,
0.1234683021903038,
0.3656230866909027,
0.18980689346790314,
0.5024514198303223,
-0.7285080552101135,
0.5367867350578308,
-0.0020922680851072073,
-0.42981600761413574,
0.24065417051315308,
-0.38011860847473145,
-0.3207723796367645,
0.2435769885778427,
-0.3307364881038666,
0.23204205930233002,
-0.6412753462791443,
0.04501829296350479,
-0.028126908466219902,
-0.07498888671398163,
-0.48775094747543335,
0.1985243856906891,
0.06087227910757065,
0.16935186088085175,
0.04093928635120392,
-0.43676337599754333,
-0.017081262543797493,
-0.46362993121147156,
0.48812276124954224,
0.743744432926178,
0.24148012697696686,
0.3646405041217804,
-0.7832655906677246,
0.001515278359875083,
0.38793137669563293,
0.5025072693824768,
0.24877724051475525,
-0.17503389716148376,
-1.0453603267669678,
0.0890478640794754,
0.16738319396972656,
0.5207328796386719,
-0.3125697672367096,
0.6067793965339661,
-0.4148130714893341,
-0.36579883098602295,
-0.5138292908668518,
-0.09127230197191238,
0.08885882049798965,
0.8133746385574341,
0.5811624526977539,
-0.4432142376899719,
-0.3871164619922638,
-1.2252427339553833,
0.17754106223583221,
-0.18925394117832184,
0.09107553213834763,
0.34648439288139343,
0.5429156422615051,
0.36313730478286743,
0.6599145531654358,
-0.9212797284126282,
-0.26766595244407654,
-0.33968910574913025,
-0.18247681856155396,
0.6083931922912598,
0.8511424660682678,
0.017330976203083992,
-0.7324550151824951,
-0.4143649935722351,
0.14641505479812622,
-0.7979070544242859,
-0.01946934126317501,
-0.11238836497068405,
-0.24216973781585693,
-0.3561912178993225,
0.31363263726234436,
-0.5593639016151428,
0.49346923828125,
0.3653661608695984,
-0.5078266263008118,
0.20324011147022247,
-0.08824831247329712,
0.26442819833755493,
-1.1315234899520874,
0.028784191235899925,
0.24028415977954865,
-0.05402565002441406,
-0.9197996258735657,
-0.5572567582130432,
0.010408309288322926,
0.10491956770420074,
-0.26597851514816284,
0.40262550115585327,
-0.26646819710731506,
0.01731586456298828,
-0.4576389193534851,
-0.21404460072517395,
-0.08162374049425125,
0.425795316696167,
0.10479411482810974,
0.1398734748363495,
0.8485237956047058,
-0.83269202709198,
0.5985369086265564,
0.09160652756690979,
0.15382637083530426,
1.3054192066192627,
-1.0171492099761963,
-0.4710678160190582,
-0.38171523809432983,
0.15977931022644043,
-0.9641186594963074,
-0.23368503153324127,
0.8106723427772522,
-0.24397076666355133,
0.1764579862356186,
0.045257922261953354,
-0.7079946994781494,
-0.21446385979652405,
0.08312898129224777,
0.330241322517395,
0.349484920501709,
-0.22240810096263885,
0.8061853647232056,
0.04175754636526108,
0.1282154619693756,
0.07760212570428848,
-0.8203330039978027,
-0.4117373526096344,
0.07806077599525452,
-0.3907220959663391,
0.05478193983435631,
0.04253704100847244,
-0.1657232940196991,
0.1748931109905243,
-0.7430499196052551,
-0.024189241230487823,
0.06221678480505943,
0.8295180797576904,
0.34096381068229675,
-0.10890745371580124,
0.7282876372337341,
0.170254185795784,
-0.26492488384246826,
0.28089961409568787,
-0.6354355812072754,
1.1193723678588867,
-0.2635091245174408,
-0.3898100256919861,
-1.0722814798355103,
0.4271688759326935,
0.7222121953964233,
0.05701969563961029,
0.43374085426330566,
0.32917407155036926,
-0.7694326639175415,
-0.06710559129714966,
-0.4518725872039795,
-0.8540287017822266,
-0.45579037070274353,
0.10052597522735596,
-0.3104392886161804,
-0.271396666765213,
0.21554306149482727,
-0.12573082745075226,
-0.10469125211238861,
0.4267123341560364,
0.09957733750343323,
-0.2876805365085602,
1.1157816648483276,
0.35699981451034546,
-0.22032062709331512,
0.13128121197223663,
-0.2532498240470886,
0.006498828995972872,
-0.6881352066993713,
-0.5017181634902954,
-0.2602035701274872,
-1.3006998300552368,
-0.0540396049618721,
-0.17677956819534302,
0.6809270977973938,
-0.2914893925189972,
-0.7189351320266724,
0.011859932914376259,
-0.7539073824882507,
0.34935876727104187,
0.44710588455200195,
0.6415829658508301,
0.3772192597389221,
-0.16062501072883606,
-0.00003402135553187691,
-0.11341741681098938,
-0.6602256894111633,
-0.26057901978492737,
0.6321081519126892,
0.21164022386074066,
0.9066817164421082,
-0.184923455119133,
0.4575842618942261,
0.42217233777046204,
0.44903746247291565,
-0.9066526889801025,
0.34757280349731445,
0.16608303785324097,
-0.6011388897895813,
-0.10852255672216415,
-0.31284424662590027,
-0.6171695590019226,
-0.0813734158873558,
-0.40423664450645447,
-0.6471036076545715,
-0.004648449830710888,
0.3407936692237854,
-0.5040188431739807,
0.31416553258895874,
-0.8445314764976501,
0.7850189805030823,
-0.5525227785110474,
0.024928517639636993,
0.06359469890594482,
-0.608390748500824,
0.067359559237957,
0.0661369189620018,
-0.06687036901712418,
-0.23344416916370392,
-0.03631570562720299,
0.6414396166801453,
-0.5971171259880066,
1.0552029609680176,
0.037349849939346313,
0.23339548707008362,
-0.16250747442245483,
0.35108062624931335,
0.5765339732170105,
0.2982988953590393,
-0.02647441253066063,
0.10883037000894547,
0.10242679715156555,
-0.33793482184410095,
-1.0857864618301392,
0.9089507460594177,
-0.6901809573173523,
-0.353272408246994,
-0.7658273577690125,
-0.9209831357002258,
-0.41803887486457825,
0.18653397262096405,
-0.13660091161727905,
0.07021180540323257,
0.2673342823982239,
-0.0015755477361381054,
0.4297802150249481,
0.23351198434829712,
0.15866564214229584,
0.46704721450805664,
0.27979692816734314,
-0.3897990584373474,
0.7706438302993774,
-0.08208416402339935,
0.3439551293849945,
0.37895268201828003,
0.3258480131626129,
-0.007339948788285255,
-0.24982020258903503,
-0.15336154401302338,
0.39550673961639404,
-0.6823471784591675,
-0.38309165835380554,
-0.4917489290237427,
-0.09923484176397324,
-0.08731244504451752,
-0.21316131949424744,
-0.4317850172519684,
0.09031642973423004,
-0.3853680491447449,
-0.08600961416959763,
0.6595721244812012,
0.9424920082092285,
-0.07439227402210236,
0.43500179052352905,
-0.8396608829498291,
0.171786829829216,
-0.14995014667510986,
0.7451627254486084,
0.3698643445968628,
-0.13946561515331268,
-0.05271356552839279,
0.13225865364074707,
-0.22005952894687653,
-1.3270971775054932,
0.5005609393119812,
0.014730952680110931,
0.22108446061611176,
0.19847801327705383,
-0.13696539402008057,
0.8740355968475342,
-0.06345648318529129,
0.5954745411872864,
0.5341415405273438,
-1.270679235458374,
1.044467568397522,
0.02879326231777668,
0.5184823870658875,
0.6146973371505737,
0.7352855801582336,
-1.1258116960525513,
-0.2057693898677826,
-0.5209996700286865,
-0.6022893190383911,
0.6340765953063965,
0.08783672004938126,
-0.04437620937824249,
-0.14128419756889343,
0.3452662527561188,
-0.006985408719629049,
0.24641665816307068,
-0.24904528260231018,
-0.6090234518051147,
-0.1863923966884613,
-0.5009539127349854,
-0.09239888191223145,
0.31435325741767883,
-0.26197031140327454,
-0.7247961163520813,
0.80766761302948,
-0.22957731783390045,
-0.22083400189876556,
0.552034318447113,
0.22290214896202087,
-0.21223385632038116,
0.07165446132421494,
0.2776010036468506,
0.2983284890651703,
0.02921975776553154,
0.532772421836853,
0.5124692320823669,
-0.5658018589019775,
0.13233919441699982,
-0.2585679292678833,
-0.37534672021865845,
0.1165914461016655,
-0.049095526337623596,
0.6870723962783813,
0.5656086206436157,
-0.7092616558074951,
0.19981111586093903,
-0.11155477911233902,
-0.21015512943267822,
-0.0993712916970253,
0.13178931176662445,
0.1920485496520996,
0.28349629044532776,
0.011867721565067768,
0.4178933799266815,
0.0505683533847332,
-0.3379766345024109,
0.5245162844657898,
0.06713423132896423,
-1.0067999362945557,
-0.36641478538513184,
0.23983483016490936,
0.04556987062096596,
-0.13323335349559784,
0.9851643443107605,
0.20218096673488617,
-0.256626158952713,
0.4518672525882721,
0.7336364388465881,
0.4453153908252716,
-0.09386787563562393,
0.5150076746940613,
0.30545464158058167,
0.5294184684753418,
-0.43502485752105713,
0.8403982520103455,
-0.06026345491409302,
-0.5573074221611023,
0.18728569149971008,
-0.7284539937973022,
-0.10941285640001297,
0.1117134615778923,
-0.7954968214035034,
0.2071421593427658,
-0.7038561105728149,
-0.3500131666660309,
0.06750839948654175,
-0.2688043713569641,
-0.8715441226959229,
0.47953858971595764,
-0.019472092390060425,
0.892720103263855,
-1.0289816856384277,
0.29350051283836365,
0.731660008430481,
-0.5100230574607849,
-1.1172668933868408,
-0.21606791019439697,
0.1443616896867752,
-0.6209993362426758,
0.9145028591156006,
-0.18377915024757385,
0.30608421564102173,
-0.20030593872070312,
-0.42869406938552856,
-1.318128228187561,
0.9929108023643494,
0.2643420100212097,
-0.2699407935142517,
0.00038741834578104317,
0.3030644357204437,
0.6175611019134521,
-0.22400087118148804,
0.3746247887611389,
0.8753952383995056,
0.9768811464309692,
0.23021896183490753,
-1.0208628177642822,
0.43856191635131836,
-0.49586018919944763,
-0.2013351321220398,
0.6155998706817627,
-0.6479595899581909,
0.8751955032348633,
0.14158238470554352,
-0.2896212637424469,
-0.4419022798538208,
0.7528224587440491,
-0.1528451293706894,
0.23857681453227997,
0.6999573111534119,
0.40906423330307007,
0.8830459117889404,
-0.5762330889701843,
1.1299667358398438,
-0.5510388016700745,
0.06123604625463486,
0.9108912348747253,
-0.1391627937555313,
0.5056596994400024,
0.8679454326629639,
0.46248579025268555,
0.26533713936805725,
0.4623493254184723,
-0.4217177629470825,
0.3396996259689331,
0.7836191058158875,
-0.21557891368865967,
-0.39760592579841614,
-0.6607608199119568,
-0.15545165538787842,
0.3740079402923584,
0.6219091415405273,
-0.8492932915687561,
-0.45778200030326843,
-0.16192921996116638,
0.0414867103099823,
-0.15213756263256073,
-0.3756578266620636,
0.6759334206581116,
0.09211299568414688,
-1.0205129384994507,
0.7427161335945129,
-0.17231519520282745,
0.4123378098011017,
-0.6145918369293213,
-0.28349044919013977,
-0.054756928235292435,
0.197549968957901,
-0.5023995041847229,
-0.6371994018554688,
0.36727312207221985,
-0.24665474891662598,
-0.46721911430358887,
-0.022775936871767044,
0.6393424868583679,
-0.37414780259132385,
-0.44918152689933777,
-0.06723092496395111,
0.8203821778297424,
0.17792391777038574,
-0.12043162435293198,
-0.5717216730117798,
0.45944419503211975,
-0.3539096713066101,
0.2732216715812683,
0.055765409022569656,
-0.11819394677877426,
0.04717900604009628,
0.7574815154075623,
0.520719587802887,
0.5585503578186035,
-0.333126038312912,
-0.05948401987552643,
0.8697989583015442,
-0.7287575602531433,
-0.533161997795105,
-0.7879515290260315,
0.12648706138134003,
-0.10797839611768723,
-0.5207797884941101,
0.4498182237148285,
0.3929070234298706,
0.8493565917015076,
-0.11842911690473557,
0.8985942602157593,
-0.0638623908162117,
-0.1573135107755661,
-0.2970172166824341,
0.8349702954292297,
-0.723854124546051,
0.16853512823581696,
0.08247146010398865,
-0.5327059626579285,
-0.34598419070243835,
0.5066513419151306,
-0.4624927341938019,
-0.09272906929254532,
0.9383088946342468,
1.0090723037719727,
-0.33435097336769104,
0.6652724742889404,
0.21409457921981812,
0.04343336075544357,
0.2588667571544647,
0.9651869535446167,
0.6238226294517517,
-0.619422435760498,
0.25537803769111633,
-0.4094528257846832,
-0.0896027460694313,
-0.00031379787833429873,
-0.46052831411361694,
-0.5867044925689697,
-0.7073819637298584,
-0.17632508277893066,
-0.3545786142349243,
0.46381962299346924,
1.263079047203064,
0.9781349301338196,
-0.9118613004684448,
-0.3687845766544342,
-0.0283943023532629,
0.1340510994195938,
-0.6465269327163696,
-0.2253255397081375,
0.15758350491523743,
-0.2816280722618103,
-0.5008488893508911,
0.236543670296669,
0.47711727023124695,
0.10181673616170883,
-0.1122925654053688,
-0.15938307344913483,
-0.18297451734542847,
0.024394281208515167,
0.23446395993232727,
0.0917757973074913,
-0.5954569578170776,
-0.424850732088089,
-0.0075886729173362255,
-0.2186121791601181,
0.08015944063663483,
0.8880789279937744,
-0.5317831635475159,
0.2862338125705719,
0.44279229640960693,
0.3334197700023651,
0.13149391114711761,
-0.0217428021132946,
0.5896154642105103,
-0.747653603553772,
-0.44080650806427,
0.3556496202945709,
0.3404149115085602,
0.26176443696022034,
-0.49935969710350037,
0.22527344524860382,
0.38359472155570984,
-0.11279476433992386,
-0.5434136390686035,
0.08423200994729996,
-1.1043167114257812,
0.04818318039178848,
1.0487867593765259,
0.30309364199638367,
-0.5413252711296082,
-0.22860130667686462,
-0.2806372344493866,
0.39071762561798096,
-0.7761361002922058,
0.703091561794281,
0.7143843173980713,
-0.3981187045574188,
0.15753310918807983,
-0.5934709906578064,
0.5236304998397827,
0.7193567156791687,
-1.0687071084976196,
-0.2637426555156708,
0.4753369390964508,
0.4055320918560028,
0.40634945034980774,
0.34161269664764404,
0.12025061249732971,
0.3968181908130646,
-0.14730198681354523,
-0.07438351958990097,
0.004922743421047926,
-0.4014829099178314,
-0.10148444026708603,
0.47710520029067993,
-0.39995744824409485,
-0.18474556505680084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15363v1
|
Exploring LLM Multi-Agents for ICD Coding
| 2024-04-01T15:17:39 | 2024-04-01T15:17:39 |
Rumeng Li, Xun Wang, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive and diverse
abilities that can benefit various domains, such as zero and few-shot
information extraction from clinical text without domain-specific training.
However, for the ICD coding task, they often hallucinate key details and
produce high recall but low precision results due to the high-dimensional and
skewed distribution of the ICD codes. Existing LLM-based methods fail to
account for the complex and dynamic interactions among the human agents
involved in coding, such as patients, physicians, and coders, and they lack
interpretability and reliability. In this paper, we present a novel multi-agent
method for ICD coding, which mimics the real-world coding process with five
agents: a patient agent, a physician agent, a coder agent, a reviewer agent,
and an adjuster agent. Each agent has a specific function and uses a LLM-based
model to perform it. We evaluate our method on the MIMIC-III dataset and show
that our proposed multi-agent coding framework substantially improves
performance on both common and rare codes compared to Zero-shot Chain of
Thought (CoT) prompting and self-consistency with CoT. The ablation study
confirms the proposed agent roles' efficacy. Our method also matches the
state-of-the-art ICD coding methods that require pre-training or fine-tuning,
in terms of coding accuracy, rare code accuracy, and explainability.
|
[
-0.3754796087741852,
-0.24694296717643738,
0.6894672513008118,
0.023396708071231842,
-0.35950812697410583,
0.3912135064601898,
-0.13400396704673767,
-0.6080676317214966,
0.3313938081264496,
0.4214003086090088,
-0.3389376699924469,
-0.808402419090271,
-0.42220526933670044,
0.3909876048564911,
-0.052265118807554245,
0.7803394198417664,
-0.19140823185443878,
0.3872669041156769,
0.17619596421718597,
-0.10132342576980591,
-0.1831689476966858,
-0.9103432893753052,
-0.2983340919017792,
-0.4371880888938904,
0.573127269744873,
0.4631774425506592,
0.5161357522010803,
0.5868735313415527,
0.5261994004249573,
0.2192578762769699,
0.30727553367614746,
0.449379026889801,
0.0549367219209671,
-0.04150863364338875,
0.11604587733745575,
-0.30002614855766296,
-1.0294264554977417,
-0.11553094536066055,
0.475892573595047,
0.2814785838127136,
-0.387586772441864,
-0.004786492791026831,
-0.22099189460277557,
0.075730100274086,
-0.394717276096344,
0.18722057342529297,
-0.40094563364982605,
-0.014037737622857094,
0.28766652941703796,
-0.5646150708198547,
-0.5500167608261108,
-0.19546754658222198,
-0.2770138680934906,
-0.32674914598464966,
0.18769630789756775,
-0.19887085258960724,
0.40551987290382385,
0.12575580179691315,
-0.5285850167274475,
-0.4183424711227417,
-0.8130242824554443,
0.2888685464859009,
-0.5830633044242859,
0.31222039461135864,
0.25072869658470154,
0.18603649735450745,
0.1306457221508026,
-0.5726240277290344,
-0.7857220768928528,
-0.23397694528102875,
0.13725510239601135,
0.12685780227184296,
0.03581172600388527,
0.22753925621509552,
0.13929128646850586,
0.07958102226257324,
-0.3463650345802307,
0.1798461675643921,
-0.18665273487567902,
-0.12261158227920532,
0.46176865696907043,
0.16832782328128815,
0.3954411447048187,
0.30378687381744385,
-0.3558191657066345,
-0.05030158907175064,
-0.5646722912788391,
-0.2351963073015213,
-0.07086728513240814,
0.260891854763031,
-0.6330039501190186,
0.46212437748908997,
0.03886006772518158,
0.18218174576759338,
0.006748825311660767,
-0.6343340873718262,
0.5035741925239563,
-0.09277116507291794,
-0.1172294095158577,
0.18383485078811646,
0.40336182713508606,
0.5071375370025635,
0.19424863159656525,
-0.2697196304798126,
-0.19474555552005768,
0.11301065981388092,
0.4896618723869324,
-0.6296181082725525,
0.057142846286296844,
0.2256404459476471,
-0.7063669562339783,
-0.2443845421075821,
-0.12261252850294113,
-0.6288083791732788,
-0.3381425738334656,
-0.2610417902469635,
0.22416360676288605,
-0.25651416182518005,
-0.14739270508289337,
0.25564008951187134,
0.20266397297382355,
0.2839405834674835,
0.37142953276634216,
-0.59595787525177,
0.5345780849456787,
0.3309735655784607,
0.6879978179931641,
0.059056609869003296,
-0.7536490559577942,
-0.7075836062431335,
0.27829936146736145,
-0.37470003962516785,
0.8656497597694397,
-0.49858349561691284,
-0.2451665997505188,
0.0009041240555234253,
-0.19719550013542175,
0.11785666644573212,
-0.3820001184940338,
0.3461054265499115,
-0.4870654046535492,
-0.6020700335502625,
0.10671447217464447,
-0.24305787682533264,
-0.001750337891280651,
0.4208417534828186,
-0.7280105948448181,
0.28913283348083496,
0.13711926341056824,
-0.27205950021743774,
0.2770775556564331,
-0.41424360871315,
-0.37373870611190796,
0.024617331102490425,
-0.47066041827201843,
-0.5089760422706604,
0.02146211825311184,
0.4282015264034271,
0.7930096983909607,
-0.4656502604484558,
-0.0343075729906559,
-0.05987149849534035,
-0.35951876640319824,
0.2884981632232666,
-0.44056299328804016,
0.221049502491951,
0.22337396442890167,
-0.1607435643672943,
0.21165330708026886,
-0.788990318775177,
-0.12285993993282318,
0.00950394943356514,
-0.3567557632923126,
0.12892727553844452,
-0.36174672842025757,
-0.0036383913829922676,
0.4329621195793152,
-0.11335983127355576,
-0.5022680759429932,
0.7048274278640747,
-0.08302184194326401,
0.024088438600301743,
0.6418334245681763,
0.2946978509426117,
0.1846415400505066,
-0.8417108654975891,
0.7807357907295227,
0.11297895014286041,
0.08049988746643066,
-0.2034144401550293,
-0.3344740569591522,
-0.19713926315307617,
-0.529045581817627,
0.033425915986299515,
0.38767674565315247,
-0.9821361899375916,
0.07496289163827896,
-0.3795492649078369,
-0.4982825219631195,
-0.6731261014938354,
0.11752501130104065,
0.5661819577217102,
0.252373069524765,
0.4001656472682953,
-0.47410303354263306,
-0.03699793666601181,
-0.4623405933380127,
0.21865679323673248,
-0.2479262351989746,
0.22906911373138428,
0.36048072576522827,
0.39655765891075134,
-0.611193835735321,
0.5638055205345154,
-0.40693962574005127,
-0.5019428133964539,
-0.6253225207328796,
0.12074824422597885,
0.10519362986087799,
0.4528611898422241,
0.42659735679626465,
-0.3462771475315094,
-0.4574314057826996,
0.3253166675567627,
-0.4893880784511566,
-0.05370935797691345,
-0.5454328656196594,
0.26088517904281616,
0.28352320194244385,
0.19637280702590942,
-0.5415379405021667,
0.5718910098075867,
0.34895825386047363,
-0.08593198657035828,
0.6099803447723389,
-0.8799886107444763,
0.4273955821990967,
-0.8807045817375183,
0.05115581676363945,
-0.048564039170742035,
-0.13870328664779663,
-0.8707115650177002,
0.22014574706554413,
0.3810930848121643,
0.10856852680444717,
-0.613461971282959,
0.6588041186332703,
-0.6768178939819336,
-0.06337852030992508,
-0.2987876534461975,
-0.08778807520866394,
-0.11140049248933792,
0.7040699124336243,
0.07429071515798569,
0.6210122108459473,
0.6195920705795288,
-0.6764703989028931,
0.5280230641365051,
0.11954114586114883,
0.10086768865585327,
0.5717182159423828,
-0.31552764773368835,
0.46653708815574646,
-0.32301434874534607,
0.33264806866645813,
-0.3186517059803009,
-0.09031730890274048,
0.3911760747432709,
-0.31010252237319946,
0.24232089519500732,
-0.23180973529815674,
-0.8706926107406616,
-0.30901914834976196,
-0.350180983543396,
0.9652326703071594,
0.567862868309021,
-0.588202714920044,
0.8040679097175598,
0.20806744694709778,
0.1311066597700119,
-0.4080449938774109,
-0.5716120600700378,
0.19814670085906982,
-0.11074159294366837,
-0.19737915694713593,
0.4276443421840668,
-0.3383117616176605,
-0.10116912424564362,
-0.21887467801570892,
-0.15686258673667908,
-0.16185882687568665,
-0.01175290159881115,
0.2227940857410431,
0.23310069739818573,
-0.027666473761200905,
0.171865314245224,
-0.011042695492506027,
-0.26434531807899475,
-0.19539040327072144,
-0.09559005498886108,
0.7046725749969482,
0.10995262861251831,
-0.8292859792709351,
-0.6839454770088196,
0.3660446107387543,
0.8105530738830566,
-0.4384337365627289,
0.5499858856201172,
0.46579432487487793,
-0.6435461640357971,
-0.5008124709129333,
-0.6189290285110474,
-0.20431147515773773,
-0.3322334289550781,
0.24874566495418549,
-0.615655243396759,
-0.4784698486328125,
0.7164334654808044,
-0.11769232898950577,
-0.1579819768667221,
0.031458623707294464,
0.8033488988876343,
0.4295538365840912,
1.064436912536621,
0.5447569489479065,
-0.14332644641399384,
-0.072535440325737,
-0.3540359139442444,
0.1367630660533905,
-0.9198275208473206,
-0.49370771646499634,
-0.6107801795005798,
0.14424766600131989,
-0.21739423274993896,
-0.7173027992248535,
0.567406415939331,
-0.11768078804016113,
-0.014604330062866211,
-0.027218185365200043,
-0.48652583360671997,
0.39894014596939087,
0.3215649425983429,
0.16998519003391266,
0.4988820552825928,
0.08127527683973312,
-0.34343472123146057,
0.42450881004333496,
-0.5942360162734985,
-0.4655042886734009,
1.2119417190551758,
0.40292391180992126,
1.2180131673812866,
0.14662452042102814,
0.7502986192703247,
0.4103231430053711,
0.4035426080226898,
-0.5510503649711609,
0.3740793466567993,
-0.055536553263664246,
-0.10038045793771744,
0.025962956249713898,
-0.09535384923219681,
-0.9797596335411072,
0.26160725951194763,
-0.15634936094284058,
-0.6159716844558716,
0.23246699571609497,
0.0512361153960228,
-0.6413272023200989,
0.410469651222229,
-0.48123419284820557,
0.45496344566345215,
-0.2873830497264862,
-0.0603867843747139,
-0.36114516854286194,
-0.6362848877906799,
-0.023236647248268127,
-0.27612680196762085,
0.2828439176082611,
-0.022678421810269356,
-0.12653230130672455,
0.26619982719421387,
-0.49797749519348145,
0.8826572895050049,
0.08201787620782852,
-0.36174121499061584,
0.16190168261528015,
-0.029325297102332115,
0.6177108287811279,
0.20489738881587982,
-0.15804210305213928,
0.19446386396884918,
-0.03169143572449684,
-0.33016037940979004,
-0.5107499957084656,
0.5687648057937622,
-0.9572342038154602,
-0.0690753161907196,
-0.560939610004425,
-0.35134801268577576,
-0.11869897693395615,
0.1530749499797821,
0.02406386286020279,
0.7999597191810608,
-0.0638175830245018,
-0.3577433228492737,
0.3048912286758423,
-0.3332970142364502,
0.272803395986557,
0.7062973380088806,
0.09712817519903183,
-0.522636890411377,
0.8601794242858887,
-0.02398151159286499,
0.309532105922699,
0.4123965799808502,
-0.2543017864227295,
0.0933067798614502,
-0.7228631377220154,
-0.501584529876709,
0.6245570182800293,
-0.8184946775436401,
-0.40969425439834595,
-0.6370644569396973,
-0.3272326588630676,
-0.6245149374008179,
-0.41865503787994385,
-0.20766258239746094,
0.29140377044677734,
-0.3454021215438843,
0.03736439719796181,
0.05354947969317436,
1.0109254121780396,
-0.11735135316848755,
0.37687408924102783,
-0.9966681599617004,
0.7108080387115479,
0.11358180642127991,
0.618971586227417,
0.21012715995311737,
0.09566497057676315,
-0.553745687007904,
0.057210326194763184,
-0.03367577865719795,
-1.138737678527832,
0.5709652900695801,
-0.14092661440372467,
0.9110053181648254,
0.2868606150150299,
0.13407447934150696,
0.7377902865409851,
-0.5548228025436401,
0.5308138132095337,
0.2911125123500824,
-0.9242465496063232,
0.2022922784090042,
0.11295181512832642,
0.3194679319858551,
0.17449021339416504,
0.04235738888382912,
-0.6581055521965027,
-0.3543849289417267,
-0.440214604139328,
-0.5375889539718628,
1.0637565851211548,
0.17878775298595428,
-0.05699201673269272,
-0.316671758890152,
0.6537978053092957,
0.13873493671417236,
0.1887322962284088,
-0.5745978951454163,
-0.4994165897369385,
0.1497873067855835,
-0.3837394118309021,
-0.09729135036468506,
-0.30474773049354553,
-0.12604251503944397,
0.1760106086730957,
0.2994285225868225,
-0.3768669366836548,
0.6569066047668457,
0.6494132280349731,
-0.18634960055351257,
-0.4390033781528473,
0.3518234193325043,
0.9022060036659241,
0.6425418853759766,
-0.05834777280688286,
0.4014047086238861,
0.16629911959171295,
-0.62432461977005,
0.42715510725975037,
0.1311880350112915,
0.3449278771877289,
-0.3060218095779419,
0.6307125091552734,
0.45313000679016113,
-0.2668186128139496,
-0.8353002667427063,
0.6204696297645569,
-0.3801775872707367,
-0.25772950053215027,
-0.19568127393722534,
-0.022814497351646423,
-0.24006642401218414,
0.5096235871315002,
0.42090529203414917,
0.30265435576438904,
-0.04085062816739082,
-0.5141734480857849,
0.30728885531425476,
0.3726057708263397,
-0.2087012529373169,
-0.5054757595062256,
0.4562436044216156,
0.2094077318906784,
-0.600582480430603,
0.3759980797767639,
-0.40128159523010254,
-0.4436773359775543,
1.051700472831726,
0.7638300657272339,
0.8069729208946228,
-0.2515498995780945,
0.26360100507736206,
-0.154072567820549,
0.40303778648376465,
-0.14054128527641296,
0.4205631613731384,
0.03563149645924568,
-0.9021974802017212,
-0.4365067183971405,
-0.1213902160525322,
-0.2950437068939209,
0.18815454840660095,
-0.6297327280044556,
0.40567904710769653,
-0.483173131942749,
0.02859790436923504,
-0.25089240074157715,
0.005349700339138508,
-0.767532467842102,
0.07484390586614609,
0.26851630210876465,
0.7455480694770813,
-0.37881290912628174,
0.9895787239074707,
0.8702943921089172,
-0.36962032318115234,
-0.9853829741477966,
0.365380197763443,
0.0362570658326149,
-0.8569220304489136,
0.15922605991363525,
0.16757822036743164,
-0.4203091561794281,
0.026287617161870003,
-0.1957361251115799,
-0.5982881784439087,
1.2068334817886353,
0.4687577188014984,
-0.3787154257297516,
-0.09337086975574493,
-0.03466153144836426,
0.7405494451522827,
-0.8673698306083679,
0.33345723152160645,
0.2842843532562256,
-0.06964582949876785,
0.20042648911476135,
-1.2722910642623901,
0.2080204337835312,
-0.4224024713039398,
-0.34868550300598145,
-0.05001873895525932,
-0.7426684498786926,
0.6410911083221436,
-0.5551016926765442,
0.018183721229434013,
0.08669653534889221,
0.09757482260465622,
0.42332372069358826,
0.5173884630203247,
0.21335875988006592,
0.08429981023073196,
0.7595883011817932,
0.6412025094032288,
0.9043963551521301,
-0.8351902961730957,
0.3514944016933441,
0.885349452495575,
-0.6829385757446289,
0.37498408555984497,
0.06830231845378876,
0.04598713666200638,
0.2337719053030014,
0.1458330601453781,
0.04675479233264923,
0.3632778227329254,
0.07315266877412796,
-0.39773133397102356,
-0.23185734450817108,
-0.1152268573641777,
-0.4205164909362793,
0.26571208238601685,
0.06676832586526871,
-0.2354522943496704,
-0.10669834911823273,
0.2546640634536743,
-0.001051783561706543,
-0.08391904085874557,
-0.38140669465065,
0.905539870262146,
0.03996014595031738,
-0.49500054121017456,
0.4935392439365387,
0.32397082448005676,
0.38141560554504395,
-0.3241320550441742,
-0.46195346117019653,
-0.08597652614116669,
0.2135939598083496,
0.035998065024614334,
-0.3184288442134857,
-0.16518434882164001,
-0.07663152366876602,
0.003679142100736499,
-0.3772319555282593,
0.5040456652641296,
-0.4490257501602173,
-0.2385086715221405,
0.36229032278060913,
0.6377512216567993,
0.1969469040632248,
0.20665022730827332,
-0.4634053111076355,
0.12669286131858826,
-0.15750250220298767,
0.22879540920257568,
0.262907475233078,
0.49569717049598694,
0.08709349483251572,
0.8190879225730896,
0.4562915563583374,
0.6119427680969238,
-0.09945549815893173,
0.4808458387851715,
0.9199556112289429,
-0.7833778262138367,
-0.6347753405570984,
-0.8022310137748718,
0.37653225660324097,
0.24435269832611084,
-0.20185017585754395,
0.3423251211643219,
0.46687984466552734,
0.562811553478241,
-0.01468580774962902,
0.6838151812553406,
0.4618009328842163,
0.3119748830795288,
-0.4731006622314453,
0.5852029919624329,
-0.41002753376960754,
0.6440023183822632,
-0.3676750063896179,
-0.5396386981010437,
-0.7271511554718018,
0.4958221912384033,
0.16744594275951385,
0.16882988810539246,
0.804527759552002,
0.7089909315109253,
0.13075697422027588,
-0.5011569857597351,
0.4957108199596405,
0.23937809467315674,
0.5459373593330383,
0.43183034658432007,
0.6774096488952637,
-0.07732026278972626,
0.47680720686912537,
-0.34488704800605774,
-0.15678946673870087,
-0.4078042507171631,
-0.5932068824768066,
-1.0577648878097534,
-0.4195217490196228,
-0.3602944016456604,
-0.25521454215049744,
0.08017474412918091,
1.5210716724395752,
0.8536849617958069,
-0.37267500162124634,
-0.18151730298995972,
0.19960623979568481,
0.27509215474128723,
-0.492394357919693,
0.0012157161254435778,
0.4546602666378021,
-0.2001516968011856,
-0.54524165391922,
0.17291352152824402,
0.4325416386127472,
0.31988468766212463,
-0.08788640052080154,
-0.5341694355010986,
0.11072631925344467,
0.025103848427534103,
0.39178991317749023,
-0.002845961833372712,
-0.717054545879364,
-0.1488010436296463,
0.06955268234014511,
-0.3010658323764801,
0.29152825474739075,
0.9008597135543823,
-0.7754636406898499,
0.4020010232925415,
-0.13810987770557404,
0.3960183262825012,
0.2841581702232361,
0.26468732953071594,
0.2216036468744278,
-0.529466450214386,
0.031018270179629326,
0.23880258202552795,
0.1030285581946373,
-0.14317002892494202,
-0.5177628397941589,
0.14079023897647858,
0.11041311174631119,
-0.598999559879303,
-0.901435136795044,
0.16677747666835785,
-1.0447667837142944,
-0.29487520456314087,
1.1368818283081055,
-0.1518683135509491,
0.058893196284770966,
-0.4699181914329529,
-0.43568170070648193,
0.22083532810211182,
-0.6299475431442261,
0.8015792369842529,
0.28615331649780273,
-0.5133740305900574,
-0.4326847493648529,
-0.15174265205860138,
0.4282553791999817,
-0.11801721155643463,
-0.9245707988739014,
-0.27013203501701355,
0.5937092304229736,
0.0971740260720253,
0.1541576385498047,
1.1717740297317505,
0.025201642885804176,
0.4906134307384491,
0.055021315813064575,
0.5850266218185425,
-0.13286192715168,
-0.6632642149925232,
-0.758105993270874,
0.3168231248855591,
0.4859123229980469,
-0.036435406655073166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01165v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01165v1
|
LITE: Modeling Environmental Ecosystems with Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-04-01T15:14:07 | 2024-04-01T15:14:07 |
Haoran Li, Junqi Liu, Zexian Wang, Shiyuan Luo, Xiaowei Jia, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The modeling of environmental ecosystems plays a pivotal role in the
sustainable management of our planet. Accurate prediction of key environmental
variables over space and time can aid in informed policy and decision-making,
thus improving people's livelihood. Recently, deep learning-based methods have
shown promise in modeling the spatial-temporal relationships for predicting
environmental variables. However, these approaches often fall short in handling
incomplete features and distribution shifts, which are commonly observed in
environmental data due to the substantial cost of data collection and
malfunctions in measuring instruments. To address these issues, we propose LITE
-- a multimodal large language model for environmental ecosystems modeling.
Specifically, LITE unifies different environmental variables by transforming
them into natural language descriptions and line graph images. Then, LITE
utilizes unified encoders to capture spatial-temporal dynamics and correlations
in different modalities. During this step, the incomplete features are imputed
by a sparse Mixture-of-Experts framework, and the distribution shift is handled
by incorporating multi-granularity information from past observations. Finally,
guided by domain instructions, a language model is employed to fuse the
multimodal representations for the prediction. Our experiments demonstrate that
LITE significantly enhances performance in environmental spatial-temporal
prediction across different domains compared to the best baseline, with a
41.25% reduction in prediction error. This justifies its effectiveness. Our
data and code are available at https://github.com/hrlics/LITE.
|
[
-0.39915862679481506,
-0.8376110196113586,
0.8221840262413025,
0.19853869080543518,
-0.04067717492580414,
-0.0029615273233503103,
-0.47568148374557495,
-0.639103353023529,
0.20743981003761292,
0.533624529838562,
-0.5626717805862427,
-0.43127307295799255,
-0.2796137034893036,
-0.27235740423202515,
-0.19796305894851685,
0.6564578413963318,
0.1904221773147583,
-0.11214336007833481,
0.2127789556980133,
-0.2706732451915741,
-0.6174376010894775,
0.04119503125548363,
-0.4051135182380676,
-0.3069571256637573,
0.8055122494697571,
0.036538586020469666,
0.7673701047897339,
0.1543029546737671,
0.33219826221466064,
0.37137290835380554,
-0.18214966356754303,
0.22937388718128204,
-0.3385280966758728,
0.19357576966285706,
-0.21360471844673157,
0.004343715030699968,
-0.14842703938484192,
-0.11202148348093033,
0.6120052337646484,
0.9122264981269836,
-0.08485311269760132,
0.24474062025547028,
-0.017368240281939507,
0.3057193458080292,
-0.707129180431366,
0.6016263365745544,
-0.6756698489189148,
0.09651640057563782,
0.18089008331298828,
-0.37624165415763855,
-0.4662364423274994,
0.17479483783245087,
0.2042694389820099,
-0.7060337066650391,
-0.013079579919576645,
0.10871122777462006,
0.41940635442733765,
0.31215161085128784,
-0.6723276376724243,
-0.11275960505008698,
-1.017127275466919,
0.8500126600265503,
-0.6984312534332275,
0.42620450258255005,
0.036583997309207916,
0.30292123556137085,
0.06966732442378998,
-0.6017954349517822,
-0.6131210327148438,
0.0220378115773201,
0.115994393825531,
0.4221266806125641,
0.25874367356300354,
0.04335624352097511,
-0.017251884564757347,
0.006746490485966206,
-0.3468036949634552,
0.024789292365312576,
-0.23362256586551666,
0.026916703209280968,
0.5469609498977661,
0.14012745022773743,
0.22243943810462952,
-0.34005674719810486,
-0.7367147207260132,
-0.19742929935455322,
-0.46626096963882446,
0.2791886031627655,
0.2394273281097412,
0.6274363994598389,
-0.09871039539575577,
0.5421121120452881,
0.16427190601825714,
0.11934670060873032,
-0.4119900166988373,
-0.01843271590769291,
0.24249905347824097,
-0.4084276258945465,
-0.19484741985797882,
-0.19849510490894318,
0.5469608306884766,
0.43357419967651367,
-0.35476091504096985,
-0.07051009684801102,
-0.46282896399497986,
0.057471372187137604,
-0.029877545312047005,
-0.7567059397697449,
-0.2675793468952179,
0.21748079359531403,
-0.4617571234703064,
-0.20562180876731873,
-0.007379154674708843,
-1.3367875814437866,
-0.46837925910949707,
-0.6351401209831238,
0.43923336267471313,
-0.33256250619888306,
-0.41577547788619995,
0.32273465394973755,
0.08115251362323761,
-0.1498597264289856,
0.4980657696723938,
-0.49621331691741943,
0.12139127403497696,
0.4032662808895111,
0.8115323185920715,
0.23050405085086823,
-0.3709934949874878,
-0.3980490267276764,
0.22630558907985687,
-0.16537389159202576,
0.539020299911499,
-0.8777937293052673,
-0.25499427318573,
0.0905633196234703,
0.13834738731384277,
-0.2745458781719208,
-0.10379141569137573,
0.19613097608089447,
-0.6842594742774963,
0.1476442664861679,
-0.02652483992278576,
-0.5812147259712219,
-0.25161030888557434,
-0.13881373405456543,
-0.9008879661560059,
0.8519914746284485,
-0.06080644950270653,
-0.7737882733345032,
0.5245519876480103,
-1.0345056056976318,
-0.05169990286231041,
0.33468666672706604,
0.10330924391746521,
-0.4068785607814789,
-0.09481961280107498,
0.4111882448196411,
0.2115975171327591,
0.00656525231897831,
0.5471108555793762,
-0.7206949591636658,
-0.15882305800914764,
0.20919013023376465,
-0.5009143948554993,
0.7753599286079407,
0.413648396730423,
-0.1994556337594986,
0.19558651745319366,
-0.4081684947013855,
0.17796781659126282,
-0.14845846593379974,
-0.3079356551170349,
-0.11251204460859299,
0.33118367195129395,
0.9313198924064636,
0.11828486621379852,
0.19311584532260895,
-0.5540910363197327,
0.16282518208026886,
-0.006032134871929884,
0.6357336640357971,
0.8142099380493164,
0.18875998258590698,
0.6758344769477844,
-0.11398151516914368,
0.37751471996307373,
0.05464508384466171,
0.27306073904037476,
-0.6751000881195068,
-0.35290899872779846,
-0.37049975991249084,
-0.3570309579372406,
0.13512220978736877,
0.6286569237709045,
-0.7791087627410889,
0.5686273574829102,
-0.679702639579773,
-0.3338795006275177,
0.04181002452969551,
0.1305013746023178,
-0.11647149920463562,
0.1294725388288498,
0.5248846411705017,
0.10128628462553024,
-0.5545810461044312,
-0.4825453460216522,
0.11332472413778305,
-0.026374375447630882,
0.0025988167617470026,
0.5766651630401611,
0.8735631704330444,
-0.8612060546875,
1.0959434509277344,
-0.5386991500854492,
-0.137642040848732,
0.014397098682820797,
0.19332313537597656,
-0.0022777908015996218,
0.3419255018234253,
0.6589277386665344,
-1.0097618103027344,
-0.15625140070915222,
-0.036616381257772446,
-0.6365500092506409,
0.09867784380912781,
-0.13984619081020355,
0.21456056833267212,
-0.017172634601593018,
0.4460148513317108,
-0.5138437151908875,
0.20934267342090607,
0.7411184906959534,
-0.5594821572303772,
0.1930985003709793,
-0.2896861433982849,
0.23411980271339417,
-0.991856038570404,
0.11650651693344116,
0.17015552520751953,
-0.09203050285577774,
-0.3010896146297455,
0.2608116865158081,
0.11361947655677795,
-0.6175717115402222,
-0.3856809139251709,
0.7446231245994568,
-0.27727460861206055,
-0.15107552707195282,
0.1269269585609436,
-0.19172020256519318,
0.06688857078552246,
0.4198314845561981,
0.16366219520568848,
0.5241146087646484,
0.580009400844574,
-0.45656996965408325,
0.349079966545105,
-0.014335637912154198,
-0.4874563217163086,
0.0877988412976265,
-0.3945849537849426,
0.00014226157509256154,
-0.28690314292907715,
0.44143053889274597,
-0.7200354933738708,
-0.2596359848976135,
-0.49620890617370605,
0.037897951900959015,
0.21048285067081451,
-0.2076309323310852,
-0.6386053562164307,
-0.20054517686367035,
-0.2404884397983551,
0.4788707196712494,
0.34441691637039185,
-0.5739359259605408,
0.8160529732704163,
0.29422837495803833,
-0.2620469033718109,
-0.11865551024675369,
-0.6359046697616577,
0.23254957795143127,
-0.41021761298179626,
-0.615103542804718,
0.13505510985851288,
-0.2743324935436249,
-0.09201151132583618,
0.168318971991539,
-0.006942344829440117,
-0.28520292043685913,
0.1319105625152588,
0.3143922686576843,
0.19576385617256165,
-0.2210787981748581,
0.2846657335758209,
-0.3759051561355591,
-0.05036618188023567,
0.11896077543497086,
-0.4916236102581024,
0.41912755370140076,
-0.2461111843585968,
-0.29039496183395386,
-0.0022347017657011747,
0.340192586183548,
0.9346973896026611,
-0.26874151825904846,
0.7010529637336731,
0.6320109963417053,
-0.6006924510002136,
-0.28640076518058777,
-0.31742537021636963,
-0.15754587948322296,
-0.47809290885925293,
0.6259637475013733,
0.12129071354866028,
-0.7164598107337952,
0.4799099564552307,
-0.3471771478652954,
-0.05835068225860596,
0.12719528377056122,
-0.04143628105521202,
-0.4465533494949341,
0.8020285367965698,
0.8920373320579529,
0.008699038065969944,
0.7558897137641907,
-0.44759681820869446,
0.4839242398738861,
-0.7587044835090637,
-0.2973161041736603,
-0.155404731631279,
-0.26642516255378723,
-0.5092878341674805,
-0.659081220626831,
0.4935932755470276,
-0.0286924559623003,
-0.5561144351959229,
0.08721639961004257,
0.005586207844316959,
0.31980687379837036,
0.09248509258031845,
0.27293744683265686,
-0.11117968708276749,
0.3233345150947571,
0.1098175048828125,
-0.2782372236251831,
-0.5004297494888306,
-0.5930261015892029,
0.6026586890220642,
0.4712257981300354,
0.904000461101532,
0.07680448144674301,
0.5513836145401001,
0.4760596454143524,
-0.019273309037089348,
-0.4154266119003296,
0.5003865957260132,
-0.1380040943622589,
-0.35180991888046265,
-0.45566752552986145,
-0.5935052633285522,
-1.0069770812988281,
0.3265218734741211,
-0.4713843762874603,
-0.5835020542144775,
0.2396739274263382,
-0.08148490637540817,
-0.36464452743530273,
0.5409569144248962,
-0.8586366176605225,
0.8099161386489868,
-0.4618564546108246,
-0.42079925537109375,
-0.3556860089302063,
-0.4288278818130493,
0.017274968326091766,
-0.10189910233020782,
0.7885425686836243,
-0.24624329805374146,
-0.3645874857902527,
0.23193196952342987,
-0.11685844510793686,
1.0700730085372925,
-0.44167473912239075,
-0.06663620471954346,
0.1964273452758789,
0.12316814810037613,
0.41811665892601013,
0.5128963589668274,
0.04509114474058151,
0.05231831967830658,
-0.11502740532159805,
-0.4893161952495575,
-0.499311238527298,
0.8259657025337219,
-0.8414223790168762,
0.017244484275579453,
-0.23535388708114624,
-0.6711828112602234,
-0.27687662839889526,
0.22397032380104065,
0.08197774738073349,
0.46303489804267883,
-0.20545029640197754,
0.38706183433532715,
0.7444230318069458,
-0.5870769023895264,
0.6365658044815063,
0.4190531373023987,
-0.570582926273346,
-0.5497608184814453,
0.8150064945220947,
0.1870030015707016,
0.06503453850746155,
0.47137659788131714,
0.24709327518939972,
-0.3714267909526825,
-0.2737827003002167,
0.06175414100289345,
-0.13993369042873383,
-0.7497161030769348,
-0.3605494797229767,
-0.8881697654724121,
-0.1132361888885498,
-0.06781298667192459,
-0.4435386657714844,
-0.2869711220264435,
0.06431009620428085,
-0.007137938402593136,
-0.21386496722698212,
0.3860437273979187,
0.7346110343933105,
0.23825757205486298,
0.1851334571838379,
-0.7798958420753479,
0.2113046944141388,
0.3395358622074127,
0.4135907292366028,
-0.22340606153011322,
-0.09386240690946579,
-0.24009199440479279,
0.4664832353591919,
0.06330574303865433,
-0.7093194723129272,
0.7779375910758972,
0.30741018056869507,
0.342395156621933,
0.10562389343976974,
-0.23840437829494476,
0.7395486235618591,
-0.30257248878479004,
0.8250361680984497,
0.2189009040594101,
-1.0160064697265625,
0.62897127866745,
-0.5705034732818604,
0.3688080608844757,
0.21268059313297272,
-0.11452314257621765,
-0.640483021736145,
-0.21560963988304138,
-0.4349561333656311,
-1.3108229637145996,
0.44323092699050903,
0.18721561133861542,
0.21010617911815643,
0.04557798057794571,
-0.04246979206800461,
0.1520741730928421,
0.19087788462638855,
-1.022467851638794,
0.09660159796476364,
-0.35569196939468384,
-0.1367252916097641,
-0.3505820333957672,
-0.25566565990448,
0.08639909327030182,
-0.17020979523658752,
0.5445395112037659,
-0.2906050980091095,
0.1948140561580658,
-0.055343084037303925,
-0.30161991715431213,
-0.14230579137802124,
0.40428462624549866,
0.3950107991695404,
0.4408577084541321,
-0.25678083300590515,
0.41663891077041626,
0.3362973630428314,
-0.28731465339660645,
-0.016180789098143578,
0.024684512987732887,
-0.2244076132774353,
-0.06789454072713852,
0.6602811217308044,
0.7909460067749023,
0.6905691027641296,
-0.7269124388694763,
0.5548701286315918,
0.11382252722978592,
0.04690781608223915,
-0.33504077792167664,
-0.21371611952781677,
0.3390374183654785,
0.3739403188228607,
0.3906615674495697,
0.5585711002349854,
0.1922190636396408,
-0.5525721311569214,
0.041648492217063904,
0.19160102307796478,
-0.19158008694648743,
-0.33917611837387085,
0.7622064352035522,
0.45532092452049255,
0.3257277309894562,
0.7559558153152466,
-0.14737723767757416,
-0.41328299045562744,
1.0240230560302734,
0.27392223477363586,
0.7120978832244873,
0.11268027871847153,
0.11265618354082108,
0.590286910533905,
0.3296278715133667,
0.011133819818496704,
0.24724216759204865,
0.18840080499649048,
-0.6828336119651794,
-0.604742705821991,
-0.6441368460655212,
-0.06219041347503662,
0.25986868143081665,
-0.3363570272922516,
0.18589524924755096,
-0.4859313368797302,
-0.0730285719037056,
-0.048214349895715714,
0.0851127952337265,
-0.9848806858062744,
0.06907569617033005,
0.5414706468582153,
0.8554202914237976,
-1.2775403261184692,
0.5199268460273743,
0.7016540169715881,
-0.44133153557777405,
-0.6219907402992249,
-0.2975601851940155,
-0.1295243799686432,
-0.398988276720047,
0.6857932209968567,
0.40689361095428467,
-0.19887197017669678,
-0.22407753765583038,
-0.7430216073989868,
-1.141473650932312,
1.3189105987548828,
0.4319533705711365,
-0.766057014465332,
0.3712545335292816,
-0.06483049690723419,
0.5282371640205383,
-0.6067225337028503,
0.3477935791015625,
-0.16921690106391907,
0.7663100957870483,
-0.27612292766571045,
-0.6748608946800232,
-0.15224182605743408,
-0.23826389014720917,
0.4702235758304596,
0.22030456364154816,
-0.5983784198760986,
0.972591757774353,
-0.338657945394516,
-0.43329092860221863,
-0.2135448455810547,
0.4481867551803589,
-0.12465108931064606,
0.34166571497917175,
0.7367393970489502,
0.41634857654571533,
0.7936681509017944,
-0.04449111968278885,
0.9426515102386475,
-0.3884003162384033,
0.783631443977356,
0.9910469651222229,
-0.8101090788841248,
0.9078059196472168,
0.3336561322212219,
-0.15951021015644073,
0.4833453297615051,
0.5318623781204224,
-0.17116940021514893,
0.7426807284355164,
-0.5155094265937805,
-0.4877534806728363,
-0.30827972292900085,
-0.10369456559419632,
-0.21268339455127716,
0.12707337737083435,
0.4485991299152374,
-0.14903084933757782,
-0.3723446726799011,
0.2570270299911499,
-0.4677462875843048,
0.1043056771159172,
-0.44028884172439575,
0.54747074842453,
-0.1303187757730484,
-0.3937014043331146,
-0.07541768997907639,
-0.1480550467967987,
0.7711065411567688,
-0.5354235768318176,
-0.2865690290927887,
-0.14227154850959778,
0.20000199973583221,
-0.33740660548210144,
-0.9831754565238953,
0.07252848148345947,
-0.3884686827659607,
-0.2581319808959961,
-0.6797775030136108,
0.5877168774604797,
-0.7301625609397888,
-0.5877490043640137,
0.732597291469574,
0.4210948348045349,
-0.33333224058151245,
0.1777009516954422,
-0.6487457752227783,
-0.09986190497875214,
0.007131519261747599,
-0.3010091781616211,
0.03364267572760582,
0.5871155261993408,
-0.06475435942411423,
0.811757504940033,
0.8181955814361572,
-0.036138102412223816,
0.3680133521556854,
0.19279998540878296,
0.7182881832122803,
-0.723138153553009,
-0.5365960597991943,
-0.5187240839004517,
0.48454520106315613,
0.01443550270050764,
0.10083840787410736,
0.43369075655937195,
0.7909572124481201,
0.5694720149040222,
-0.3617886006832123,
0.9266890287399292,
-0.032097551971673965,
0.14493680000305176,
-0.6454114317893982,
0.35832664370536804,
-0.2961609363555908,
0.3744654357433319,
0.07739961892366409,
-1.14748215675354,
0.09569593518972397,
0.3838607966899872,
-0.10681035369634628,
0.42383772134780884,
0.7787651419639587,
0.6352006196975708,
-0.31055328249931335,
-0.06393888592720032,
0.2591315507888794,
0.19868826866149902,
0.5334894061088562,
0.5700827240943909,
0.8985248804092407,
-0.022052058950066566,
0.35831519961357117,
-0.4334489703178406,
0.2684919238090515,
-0.12827636301517487,
-1.027152180671692,
-0.4747636914253235,
-0.5322182774543762,
-0.3903457224369049,
0.05252989009022713,
-0.15367558598518372,
0.9128080010414124,
0.8668342232704163,
-0.569090723991394,
-0.02360798977315426,
-0.1717602163553238,
-0.1418963521718979,
-0.27944114804267883,
-0.26425760984420776,
0.17182393372058868,
-0.39346960186958313,
-0.5900728106498718,
0.46191373467445374,
0.49212679266929626,
0.05336395278573036,
-0.40108034014701843,
-0.09697172045707703,
-0.07032641768455505,
0.09987150132656097,
0.6355265378952026,
-0.00017534404469188303,
-0.7951300144195557,
-0.519849956035614,
-0.02869424596428871,
-0.10494658350944519,
-0.1215522363781929,
0.6514021754264832,
-0.7130908370018005,
0.4270326495170593,
0.3574865758419037,
0.442700058221817,
0.6181867122650146,
-0.3972127437591553,
0.2554662227630615,
-0.8592067956924438,
0.26143553853034973,
0.3164329528808594,
0.9871807098388672,
0.49186113476753235,
-0.36551815271377563,
0.5400246977806091,
0.046784430742263794,
-0.5622130632400513,
-0.5094956755638123,
0.17596685886383057,
-1.0657460689544678,
-0.49865829944610596,
1.1406469345092773,
-0.08876433223485947,
-0.28902116417884827,
0.026490211486816406,
-0.21310065686702728,
-0.20596091449260712,
-0.5899627208709717,
0.5821990966796875,
0.644996166229248,
0.2239735722541809,
-0.3831031918525696,
-0.7457141876220703,
-0.12769313156604767,
0.13569276034832,
-0.8101445436477661,
0.22774812579154968,
0.9508355855941772,
0.47208693623542786,
0.32465600967407227,
0.2023613303899765,
0.2662598192691803,
0.11966140568256378,
0.14421352744102478,
0.25488272309303284,
-0.03980803117156029,
-0.3849239945411682,
-0.28257492184638977,
0.23869062960147858,
-0.07356057316064835,
0.1662812978029251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01158v1
|
Dialogue with Robots: Proposals for Broadening Participation and Research in the SLIVAR Community
| 2024-04-01T15:03:27 | 2024-04-01T15:03:27 |
Casey Kennington, Malihe Alikhani, Heather Pon-Barry, Katherine Atwell, Yonatan Bisk, Daniel Fried, Felix Gervits, Zhao Han, Mert Inan, Michael Johnston, Raj Korpan, Diane Litman, Matthew Marge, Cynthia Matuszek, Ross Mead, Shiwali Mohan, Raymond Mooney, Natalie Parde, Jivko Sinapov, Angela Stewart, Matthew Stone, Stefanie Tellex, Tom Williams
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.RO
|
The ability to interact with machines using natural human language is
becoming not just commonplace, but expected. The next step is not just text
interfaces, but speech interfaces and not just with computers, but with all
machines including robots. In this paper, we chronicle the recent history of
this growing field of spoken dialogue with robots and offer the community three
proposals, the first focused on education, the second on benchmarks, and the
third on the modeling of language when it comes to spoken interaction with
robots. The three proposals should act as white papers for any researcher to
take and build upon.
|
[
-0.4885536730289459,
-0.5416401624679565,
0.8875344395637512,
-0.25630372762680054,
0.290667325258255,
0.4761735498905182,
-0.0737459659576416,
-0.8595287203788757,
0.6278756856918335,
0.8144868016242981,
-0.5445353984832764,
-0.2072841227054596,
-0.5981636643409729,
-0.055687349289655685,
-0.5124786496162415,
0.6337057948112488,
0.06672009080648422,
-0.07504361122846603,
-0.3144473433494568,
-0.2750965654850006,
-0.3501431941986084,
-0.6911388635635376,
-0.43821388483047485,
-0.3561839759349823,
0.8052878975868225,
0.47051551938056946,
0.8563403487205505,
0.2029992640018463,
0.37309226393699646,
0.47395816445350647,
-0.22117237746715546,
0.1928100287914276,
0.023938218131661415,
0.4846634268760681,
-0.12556929886341095,
-0.6306344866752625,
-0.30407676100730896,
0.03642242029309273,
0.5378754138946533,
1.059128761291504,
0.13360178470611572,
0.14583347737789154,
0.04710140824317932,
0.9021896123886108,
-0.448657751083374,
-0.07103776186704636,
-0.22949975728988647,
0.2652018964290619,
-0.049680184572935104,
-0.06262726336717606,
-0.19401679933071136,
-0.4963924288749695,
0.13043312728405,
-0.38724592328071594,
0.07199003547430038,
-0.2790597975254059,
0.5961235165596008,
0.18932490050792694,
-0.1835746020078659,
-0.3983359932899475,
-1.057171106338501,
0.7753416895866394,
-0.6551846861839294,
0.33253636956214905,
0.6214234232902527,
0.2769565284252167,
-0.3688497841358185,
-0.8104044198989868,
-0.546173095703125,
-0.21821309626102448,
-0.0363486148416996,
0.08882896602153778,
-0.5916318893432617,
0.32923218607902527,
0.22558005154132843,
-0.013917297124862671,
-0.4687696397304535,
-0.05114428699016571,
-0.9269708395004272,
-0.20977896451950073,
0.48274198174476624,
0.26614364981651306,
0.1316491812467575,
0.13447684049606323,
-0.067294180393219,
0.015454716049134731,
-0.4136248826980591,
-0.06954796612262726,
0.7843888998031616,
0.5278913974761963,
0.12425335496664047,
0.5869922637939453,
-0.28015807271003723,
1.05859375,
-0.3432486951351166,
-0.02049189619719982,
0.27603745460510254,
-0.6842415928840637,
-0.10366668552160263,
-0.38227546215057373,
0.7623174786567688,
0.2530912756919861,
0.02353649027645588,
0.1371035873889923,
0.05487567558884621,
0.2841462194919586,
0.5653548240661621,
-0.39140498638153076,
-0.06836747378110886,
0.06269560754299164,
-0.4924958646297455,
-0.1081058531999588,
0.06650310009717941,
-0.887664794921875,
-0.46217286586761475,
-0.381857693195343,
0.20720641314983368,
0.008021974004805088,
-0.39509955048561096,
0.25069165229797363,
-0.3117985427379608,
-0.12768197059631348,
0.4464840590953827,
-0.9116899967193604,
0.6781284809112549,
0.9422838091850281,
0.877236008644104,
0.09727156162261963,
-0.1405315101146698,
-0.35134151577949524,
0.19814682006835938,
-0.3186878561973572,
0.72640460729599,
-0.8410705924034119,
-0.7030827403068542,
0.2396472841501236,
0.003400783985853195,
0.08868809044361115,
-0.3911372423171997,
0.3986733853816986,
0.015026338398456573,
0.5660566687583923,
0.015520229004323483,
-0.22409416735172272,
-0.14282619953155518,
0.11884641647338867,
-0.6555128693580627,
0.8946882486343384,
0.21410280466079712,
-0.49894121289253235,
-0.01880398578941822,
-1.3264774084091187,
-0.624966025352478,
0.30121052265167236,
-0.4172278642654419,
-0.03348778188228607,
-0.1227492019534111,
-0.31959816813468933,
0.06887736916542053,
-0.057248733937740326,
0.3351925313472748,
-0.22366930544376373,
-0.201630100607872,
0.2818358242511749,
-0.2041865885257721,
0.6071113348007202,
0.3389444053173065,
-0.20161545276641846,
0.4583483040332794,
-0.3657325804233551,
-0.06958954781293869,
-0.38121506571769714,
0.12093809992074966,
-0.1364038735628128,
0.18044216930866241,
-0.122268907725811,
-0.1214602142572403,
0.391925573348999,
-0.439835786819458,
0.158829003572464,
-0.7088145613670349,
0.8341649770736694,
0.5663458108901978,
-0.19667263329029083,
0.7446111440658569,
-0.45985013246536255,
0.9984249472618103,
-0.3162819445133209,
0.41342437267303467,
-0.2663235366344452,
-0.8121259808540344,
-0.8800781965255737,
0.1014990508556366,
0.06412209570407867,
0.18546366691589355,
-0.6879517436027527,
0.08236412703990936,
0.4353564381599426,
-0.4875238835811615,
-0.7132584452629089,
-0.15432585775852203,
0.03939623758196831,
0.3779539167881012,
0.11608687788248062,
-0.38613125681877136,
-1.0689514875411987,
-1.0601935386657715,
0.004605014342814684,
-0.5612125992774963,
-0.1573120355606079,
0.5805934071540833,
0.3465418815612793,
-0.34899061918258667,
1.1083016395568848,
-0.5895532369613647,
-0.16892686486244202,
-0.43457698822021484,
0.3766734302043915,
0.2073032110929489,
0.37036335468292236,
0.5533086061477661,
-0.8396275043487549,
-0.5904542207717896,
0.04229600727558136,
-0.3564527928829193,
0.26135915517807007,
0.5142988562583923,
-0.05350620299577713,
0.02055438980460167,
0.4849759638309479,
-0.7248194813728333,
0.4170810282230377,
0.6899282336235046,
0.1596379429101944,
0.1606765240430832,
0.03641978278756142,
0.26800909638404846,
-1.0819370746612549,
-0.013128465972840786,
-0.22043631970882416,
-0.20493638515472412,
-1.2008984088897705,
-0.22941114008426666,
-0.7153766751289368,
-0.3845038414001465,
-0.6203650236129761,
0.636126697063446,
-0.14434155821800232,
-0.2815474271774292,
-0.6627045273780823,
0.6379698514938354,
-0.14775735139846802,
0.007265663705766201,
0.05221832916140556,
0.975568413734436,
0.4945555031299591,
-0.6369382739067078,
0.25175267457962036,
0.3333190083503723,
-0.33088719844818115,
0.1840558499097824,
-0.9063935875892639,
0.3146660625934601,
0.018921582028269768,
0.48747360706329346,
-0.69029301404953,
-0.36473655700683594,
0.5882849097251892,
-0.796710729598999,
-0.43232226371765137,
0.09687575697898865,
-0.47278156876564026,
-0.6567118167877197,
-0.24949514865875244,
0.2944585382938385,
0.35704317688941956,
0.044363733381032944,
0.7171169519424438,
1.1431879997253418,
-0.2842603027820587,
-0.4356449246406555,
-0.2846974730491638,
0.3204576373100281,
-0.05012195557355881,
-0.6652130484580994,
-0.023065119981765747,
-0.3562830686569214,
-0.5564886927604675,
-0.1472577005624771,
0.2693995237350464,
-0.5363715291023254,
0.2682212293148041,
0.36806756258010864,
0.0668116882443428,
-0.13017792999744415,
0.058633655309677124,
0.028637001290917397,
-0.2296663522720337,
-0.0379335917532444,
0.06009296327829361,
0.8490331172943115,
-0.12701424956321716,
-0.23302532732486725,
-0.5409243106842041,
0.5224184393882751,
0.4465472102165222,
-0.050279345363378525,
0.29262566566467285,
0.4005486071109772,
-0.3722365200519562,
0.3494109809398651,
-0.1364297866821289,
-0.40466904640197754,
-0.5966544151306152,
0.24033230543136597,
0.095276840031147,
-1.4162064790725708,
-0.15068745613098145,
-0.4252779185771942,
0.1502217799425125,
0.021154969930648804,
0.4496568441390991,
-0.5149758458137512,
1.0912728309631348,
1.111678957939148,
-0.06547842919826508,
0.6063204407691956,
0.11129063367843628,
0.25981393456459045,
-0.7252263426780701,
-0.07654556632041931,
-0.9877218008041382,
-0.22768792510032654,
-0.5983222126960754,
-0.6276350617408752,
0.15658524632453918,
-0.45690950751304626,
-0.023559492081403732,
0.8658154606819153,
-0.5737580060958862,
0.3130011260509491,
0.6668463945388794,
-0.1322602927684784,
0.004732128698378801,
-0.4537453353404999,
0.25881922245025635,
-0.1550280749797821,
-0.6221018433570862,
-0.9832248687744141,
0.5688657164573669,
0.2628225088119507,
0.28398361802101135,
-0.046471577137708664,
0.722856342792511,
0.5691035389900208,
0.08535625040531158,
-0.6514482498168945,
0.8695924282073975,
-0.022589176893234253,
-0.6877162456512451,
-0.3633849620819092,
-0.008704965934157372,
-1.2620582580566406,
0.158256396651268,
0.06451575458049774,
-0.8513165712356567,
-0.016901016235351562,
-0.07262281328439713,
-0.20656916499137878,
0.23127047717571259,
-0.14033342897891998,
0.5503939986228943,
0.09453480690717697,
0.02831965498626232,
-0.49341490864753723,
-0.9123290777206421,
0.07952900975942612,
0.27930229902267456,
0.5403531789779663,
-0.427944153547287,
0.06221542879939079,
0.8180556297302246,
0.009837358258664608,
1.2004987001419067,
-0.19812969863414764,
-0.14341624081134796,
0.6370342969894409,
-0.30874690413475037,
-0.0720466896891594,
-0.28200361132621765,
-0.18679223954677582,
-0.09401381015777588,
-0.20872431993484497,
-0.17495107650756836,
-0.40197205543518066,
0.24432708323001862,
-0.838064968585968,
-0.6661016941070557,
-0.4226265251636505,
-0.6158896088600159,
-0.2692694365978241,
0.19525039196014404,
-0.4170747995376587,
0.030422473326325417,
-0.4220714867115021,
0.2502334713935852,
0.6085182428359985,
-0.16094942390918732,
0.3004041016101837,
0.37679246068000793,
-0.5092755556106567,
-0.44986847043037415,
0.7726825475692749,
-0.33300817012786865,
0.44237056374549866,
0.15298838913440704,
0.19890393316745758,
-0.003012843895703554,
0.02926350198686123,
-0.24938686192035675,
0.02862474136054516,
-0.44124576449394226,
-0.2618710994720459,
-0.8110294342041016,
-0.2993091344833374,
-0.4489549398422241,
-0.37215304374694824,
-0.28265807032585144,
-0.6727743148803711,
-0.47953540086746216,
-0.11116717010736465,
0.30108642578125,
1.201798677444458,
-0.3795015513896942,
0.6453840136528015,
-0.7597115635871887,
0.30420953035354614,
0.1657617837190628,
-0.03247642144560814,
-0.058588121086359024,
-0.31323951482772827,
-0.30132293701171875,
0.3838108777999878,
-0.4976351261138916,
-0.580859899520874,
0.14215198159217834,
0.0175702515989542,
0.5830656886100769,
0.29441770911216736,
-0.0005676906439475715,
0.5997039079666138,
-0.5813031792640686,
1.0595868825912476,
0.42742055654525757,
-0.843436062335968,
0.9220532178878784,
-0.29611676931381226,
0.14209413528442383,
0.6594877243041992,
0.5430479645729065,
-0.882545530796051,
-0.9182369112968445,
-0.5950327515602112,
-0.6745495200157166,
0.676560640335083,
0.011908161453902721,
0.6385253667831421,
0.1273694783449173,
-0.12067542970180511,
0.3125256896018982,
0.5253225564956665,
-0.6325830817222595,
-0.12880811095237732,
0.11793363094329834,
0.039533767849206924,
0.15772713720798492,
0.020337138324975967,
-0.5372402667999268,
-0.2029678225517273,
0.20465850830078125,
0.01932951621711254,
0.18800608813762665,
-0.17549245059490204,
0.36531174182891846,
-0.24156208336353302,
0.29197898507118225,
0.8140360713005066,
0.8752859830856323,
0.32658645510673523,
0.09509476274251938,
-0.19558607041835785,
-0.34486547112464905,
0.04091264307498932,
-0.3481433391571045,
-0.5061512589454651,
0.3738604187965393,
0.03219230845570564,
0.7698147296905518,
0.15016715228557587,
-0.770232617855072,
0.24073173105716705,
-0.044047761708498,
-0.5565019845962524,
-0.25868770480155945,
0.48394718766212463,
0.18054363131523132,
0.44780027866363525,
0.2863962948322296,
0.3550925850868225,
0.30851152539253235,
-0.8387150168418884,
0.22387351095676422,
0.28484442830085754,
-0.868060290813446,
-0.29647010564804077,
0.505439043045044,
0.4210227429866791,
-0.9767297506332397,
0.19099313020706177,
0.2094702422618866,
-0.9035012125968933,
0.4492800831794739,
0.20022264122962952,
0.7859610319137573,
-0.05165232717990875,
0.7394378185272217,
0.4475659430027008,
0.3524545729160309,
-0.08962252736091614,
0.31107330322265625,
-0.15818485617637634,
-0.6293981671333313,
-0.15005998313426971,
-0.36945733428001404,
-1.1478508710861206,
-0.20890329778194427,
-0.5463873744010925,
0.23534199595451355,
-0.25039616227149963,
-0.6183697581291199,
0.06919306516647339,
0.022086886689066887,
-0.1708695888519287,
-0.19248192012310028,
0.10140188783407211,
0.4660029411315918,
-0.8014233708381653,
0.7972941994667053,
0.69862300157547,
-0.41373252868652344,
-0.15834477543830872,
-0.02595970779657364,
-0.3306056261062622,
-0.4608129858970642,
0.5411041378974915,
0.181325301527977,
-0.6009294390678406,
-0.3878886103630066,
-1.1555219888687134,
-0.7365157604217529,
0.8618518710136414,
0.13877557218074799,
-0.3574654757976532,
0.21701306104660034,
0.3815511167049408,
0.5084118247032166,
-0.21318787336349487,
0.08404485136270523,
0.3351183235645294,
0.7449674606323242,
-0.06723912060260773,
-1.0901670455932617,
-0.48394548892974854,
-0.2258646935224533,
-0.09753816574811935,
0.2895955443382263,
-0.9135464429855347,
0.711444616317749,
0.1041557788848877,
-0.19613753259181976,
0.654782235622406,
1.1216007471084595,
0.15938788652420044,
0.5666092038154602,
0.37041762471199036,
-0.07527174055576324,
0.8251112103462219,
0.0035246512852609158,
0.41549524664878845,
-0.26044562458992004,
-0.0271912869066,
1.0006643533706665,
-0.5789941549301147,
0.7698552012443542,
0.42689764499664307,
-0.5746784210205078,
0.5138638019561768,
0.365634560585022,
-0.05853912979364395,
0.47107651829719543,
0.19402433931827545,
-0.7703073620796204,
0.1026860848069191,
-0.6207000613212585,
-0.3479658365249634,
0.4868222177028656,
0.5889740586280823,
0.11692732572555542,
0.1854713410139084,
0.3420042097568512,
-0.06232208386063576,
0.5166851878166199,
-0.010859908536076546,
0.7023743987083435,
0.07418951392173767,
-0.6113715767860413,
-0.3162412643432617,
-0.19200947880744934,
0.6313391923904419,
-0.6291308999061584,
-0.22316621243953705,
0.009199677966535091,
-0.14808978140354156,
-0.011448264122009277,
-0.87661212682724,
0.3758668303489685,
-0.07509472221136093,
-0.24123439192771912,
-0.359279602766037,
0.9553439021110535,
-0.377854585647583,
-0.31903785467147827,
0.30705899000167847,
0.4091022312641144,
0.5578954815864563,
0.5428045988082886,
-0.7707780599594116,
0.5087586641311646,
-0.07062624394893646,
0.326516717672348,
0.3795110285282135,
0.2749284505844116,
0.15874440968036652,
0.8249378204345703,
0.5675079822540283,
-0.022707827389240265,
-0.1209266260266304,
0.24537955224514008,
1.0997352600097656,
-0.5826619863510132,
-0.1373997926712036,
-0.45008012652397156,
0.44241175055503845,
-0.2611708641052246,
-0.22820666432380676,
0.5851264595985413,
0.6750583648681641,
0.7044712901115417,
0.17514151334762573,
1.0135788917541504,
-0.2463521510362625,
0.8100038170814514,
0.030695540830492973,
0.6124922633171082,
-0.3623824119567871,
-0.20592106878757477,
-0.4150698781013489,
-0.6283960938453674,
-0.14447276294231415,
0.8856849670410156,
0.1105610579252243,
0.049935463815927505,
0.3909222185611725,
0.5443230271339417,
0.29464203119277954,
0.33686378598213196,
0.49987924098968506,
-0.05641962215304375,
0.353685200214386,
0.04601399973034859,
1.1562440395355225,
-0.2755129039287567,
0.43473020195961,
-0.12950855493545532,
-0.08616939187049866,
-0.36087679862976074,
-0.47918662428855896,
-0.7703861594200134,
-0.8245323300361633,
-0.1377146691083908,
-0.19569818675518036,
0.3761714994907379,
0.7456345558166504,
0.5737218260765076,
-0.4772641062736511,
-0.8311909437179565,
0.03717871755361557,
0.3012084364891052,
0.04567131772637367,
-0.13892067968845367,
-0.14824846386909485,
-0.2897516191005707,
-1.1062698364257812,
0.7752025127410889,
0.5411505699157715,
-0.11040351539850235,
-0.6754480004310608,
-0.1299404352903366,
-0.22390609979629517,
0.06566059589385986,
0.7456766366958618,
0.7702831625938416,
-0.6479771733283997,
-0.3251924514770508,
0.21725831925868988,
0.026426546275615692,
0.18002378940582275,
1.0319161415100098,
-0.7964516878128052,
0.38186168670654297,
0.27567917108535767,
0.5163567662239075,
0.5126829743385315,
-0.1367739886045456,
0.902837336063385,
-0.208045095205307,
0.5497925877571106,
0.7332761883735657,
-0.013594748452305794,
0.2908042371273041,
0.23416642844676971,
0.8023397922515869,
-0.05381910502910614,
-0.7215666174888611,
-1.181044340133667,
0.5695701241493225,
-0.855042576789856,
-0.15661711990833282,
0.6812490820884705,
0.12018822878599167,
-0.11844177544116974,
-0.5691826343536377,
-0.4196411073207855,
0.17724981904029846,
-0.3348412811756134,
0.4688207805156708,
0.5052981972694397,
-0.4900301992893219,
-0.1235511526465416,
-1.0778725147247314,
0.4241401255130768,
0.18965227901935577,
-0.8316478729248047,
0.044014472514390945,
0.39741384983062744,
-0.4432055652141571,
0.374035507440567,
1.0352420806884766,
0.09304604679346085,
0.34855929017066956,
-0.06509409099817276,
0.030680015683174133,
0.5533491969108582,
-0.5854678153991699,
0.2064565271139145,
-0.08189725130796432,
0.28485918045043945,
-0.05365715175867081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01157v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01157v1
|
Green AI: Exploring Carbon Footprints, Mitigation Strategies, and Trade Offs in Large Language Model Training
| 2024-04-01T15:01:45 | 2024-04-01T15:01:45 |
Vivian Liu, Yiqiao Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PF
|
Prominent works in the field of Natural Language Processing have long
attempted to create new innovative models by improving upon previous model
training approaches, altering model architecture, and developing more in-depth
datasets to better their performance. However, with the quickly advancing field
of NLP comes increased greenhouse gas emissions, posing concerns over the
environmental damage caused by training LLMs. Gaining a comprehensive
understanding of the various costs, particularly those pertaining to
environmental aspects, that are associated with artificial intelligence serves
as the foundational basis for ensuring safe AI models. Currently,
investigations into the CO2 emissions of AI models remain an emerging area of
research, and as such, in this paper, we evaluate the CO2 emissions of
well-known large language models, which have an especially high carbon
footprint due to their significant amount of model parameters. We argue for the
training of LLMs in a way that is responsible and sustainable by suggesting
measures for reducing carbon emissions. Furthermore, we discuss how the choice
of hardware affects CO2 emissions by contrasting the CO2 emissions during model
training for two widely used GPUs. Based on our results, we present the
benefits and drawbacks of our proposed solutions and make the argument for the
possibility of training more environmentally safe AI models without sacrificing
their robustness and performance.
|
[
-0.4095722734928131,
-0.7120342254638672,
0.5697935819625854,
-0.4162750542163849,
0.017092008143663406,
0.07395724207162857,
-0.2910897135734558,
-0.7078001499176025,
-0.32759979367256165,
0.47035419940948486,
-0.37608984112739563,
-0.3600480258464813,
-0.5347079038619995,
-0.1567840874195099,
-0.2134188413619995,
0.8054438829421997,
0.20855599641799927,
0.05838341265916824,
-0.3034655451774597,
-0.007396513596177101,
-0.5074899196624756,
-0.45057180523872375,
-1.3270645141601562,
-0.22499333322048187,
0.4064221680164337,
0.21179436147212982,
0.7012311816215515,
0.22000284492969513,
0.48495718836784363,
0.3268294930458069,
-0.21613895893096924,
-0.12553243339061737,
-0.3854151666164398,
-0.2103719711303711,
0.028618302196264267,
-0.18496593832969666,
-0.1091386005282402,
0.22579817473888397,
0.6351145505905151,
0.5611192584037781,
0.0010588188888505101,
0.1571069061756134,
0.08899370580911636,
0.4009190797805786,
-0.4981708526611328,
0.2668416500091553,
-0.8663702607154846,
0.1525377780199051,
0.15053804218769073,
-0.03748983517289162,
-0.32959678769111633,
0.14415553212165833,
-0.3577464520931244,
-0.6042746305465698,
0.08912238478660583,
0.22604037821292877,
0.8745378851890564,
0.7343961596488953,
-0.04304960370063782,
-0.3685546815395355,
-0.8283404111862183,
1.0277307033538818,
-0.9959039688110352,
0.45223426818847656,
0.06792333722114563,
0.0775509625673294,
-0.031479571014642715,
-0.18196971714496613,
-0.9009772539138794,
-0.3969573974609375,
-0.16700643301010132,
0.436113178730011,
-0.3928128778934479,
0.16671708226203918,
0.07118193805217743,
0.2785811722278595,
-0.4810972809791565,
0.7030044198036194,
-0.2852916717529297,
-0.37226757407188416,
0.8632597923278809,
0.08623595535755157,
0.5190162062644958,
0.10257593542337418,
-0.29376497864723206,
-0.08801929652690887,
-0.7174755930900574,
-0.05732330307364464,
0.8131001591682434,
0.48685404658317566,
-0.2410610169172287,
0.5220775008201599,
0.1357368528842926,
0.3876055181026459,
-0.3882763683795929,
0.047603584825992584,
-0.4091890752315521,
-0.5730510950088501,
-0.13041365146636963,
0.12844933569431305,
0.6251840591430664,
0.34892013669013977,
0.11904027312994003,
-0.36540645360946655,
0.04142316058278084,
0.28387996554374695,
0.11049598455429077,
-0.8145604729652405,
-0.40551289916038513,
0.35495874285697937,
-0.13401301205158234,
-0.18237702548503876,
-0.22619123756885529,
-0.883863627910614,
-0.06650529056787491,
-0.565085768699646,
-0.10127778351306915,
0.029574040323495865,
-0.24779647588729858,
0.20886990427970886,
-0.2516811192035675,
0.13163936138153076,
0.4830082356929779,
-0.973890483379364,
0.36347195506095886,
0.8074363470077515,
0.8515824675559998,
-0.2785598039627075,
0.05220634117722511,
-0.5025722980499268,
0.1226082369685173,
-0.2273179590702057,
0.6461490988731384,
-0.5620669722557068,
-0.609679102897644,
-0.3288428783416748,
-0.28394627571105957,
0.09084676206111908,
-0.3685356676578522,
0.30287835001945496,
-0.39072659611701965,
0.32649219036102295,
-0.17805936932563782,
-0.42985305190086365,
-0.35519060492515564,
0.32343757152557373,
-0.643006443977356,
0.9848606586456299,
-0.32859373092651367,
-0.8215238451957703,
0.1977381855249405,
-0.8575385808944702,
-0.3472728431224823,
0.2974552810192108,
-0.04158470779657364,
-0.5066221952438354,
-0.2139645516872406,
-0.092037633061409,
0.37455806136131287,
-0.20579420030117035,
0.21393050253391266,
-0.4523181617259979,
-0.22409461438655853,
-0.5065999627113342,
-0.6091949939727783,
1.094207525253296,
0.20503783226013184,
-0.4528457522392273,
0.295002281665802,
-0.648556113243103,
0.08640743792057037,
0.049764931201934814,
-0.5152084231376648,
-0.36471986770629883,
0.061557836830616,
0.07154937088489532,
0.06697890907526016,
0.044023700058460236,
-0.47352859377861023,
-0.28852593898773193,
-0.3037533164024353,
0.6206295490264893,
0.9018961191177368,
0.0961417481303215,
0.3750523626804352,
-0.08742985129356384,
0.5574637055397034,
-0.43410930037498474,
-0.02969537302851677,
0.220663920044899,
-0.5045021176338196,
-0.6643065214157104,
-0.4097763001918793,
-0.20265275239944458,
0.5996976494789124,
-0.04850543290376663,
0.7539551258087158,
-0.12087489664554596,
-0.6944786906242371,
-0.10073196887969971,
0.2175120711326599,
0.07208745926618576,
0.3293854296207428,
0.1541619449853897,
-0.043297819793224335,
-0.17461422085762024,
-0.6015965938568115,
-0.46107351779937744,
-0.18677759170532227,
0.28350070118904114,
0.700493335723877,
0.9076254963874817,
-0.39360472559928894,
0.9318186640739441,
-0.42169350385665894,
0.11485611647367477,
-0.039541780948638916,
-0.15010428428649902,
-0.1736111342906952,
0.7389254570007324,
0.5249748229980469,
-0.8633408546447754,
-0.3087053596973419,
0.09137316048145294,
-0.32250577211380005,
0.3349796533584595,
-0.4410054087638855,
0.02645951509475708,
0.19941486418247223,
0.8013690710067749,
-0.9009689092636108,
0.2502417266368866,
0.8420760035514832,
-0.2435474544763565,
0.5542078018188477,
-0.4096846282482147,
-0.04223528504371643,
-0.7359594106674194,
0.4615081250667572,
0.058982864022254944,
-0.10706069320440292,
-0.38033878803253174,
0.18167637288570404,
-0.6735318899154663,
-0.5642136335372925,
-0.3755216598510742,
0.9276953935623169,
-0.30064159631729126,
-0.300396591424942,
-0.26256701350212097,
0.03199226036667824,
0.106615349650383,
0.3491697311401367,
0.19276925921440125,
0.9460539221763611,
0.2587623596191406,
-0.6370458006858826,
0.14988119900226593,
0.16905929148197174,
-0.051668353378772736,
0.07311949878931046,
-0.5358293056488037,
0.60878986120224,
0.027190571650862694,
0.2005959451198578,
-1.0152183771133423,
0.11676698923110962,
0.3670197129249573,
-0.28891047835350037,
0.36166635155677795,
0.14473788440227509,
-0.6930891275405884,
-0.1416308879852295,
-0.07588101178407669,
0.13987183570861816,
0.45412477850914,
-0.7818674445152283,
0.32055503129959106,
0.49942484498023987,
-0.27724021673202515,
-0.12884582579135895,
-0.687892496585846,
0.36656641960144043,
-0.6422452926635742,
-0.4786772131919861,
0.2608499825000763,
-0.3536146581172943,
-0.5492501258850098,
0.01414552703499794,
-0.2968934178352356,
0.21313679218292236,
0.890470564365387,
0.03014541231095791,
0.11993978917598724,
-0.019769085571169853,
0.1257125735282898,
-0.2630482316017151,
-0.3175659775733948,
0.4526188373565674,
-0.2787342965602875,
0.5457767248153687,
-0.17669817805290222,
-0.15135517716407776,
-0.6270903944969177,
0.3866109848022461,
0.479343444108963,
-0.23176956176757812,
0.746316134929657,
0.4358082115650177,
-0.6653378009796143,
-0.015519427135586739,
-0.09108857065439224,
-0.018563969060778618,
-0.5250191688537598,
0.6876109838485718,
0.24914471805095673,
-0.9243398904800415,
0.17060652375221252,
-0.3532981276512146,
0.34616008400917053,
0.6408399939537048,
0.498718798160553,
-0.20120950043201447,
0.7264784574508667,
0.6429094672203064,
-0.12541167438030243,
0.5771130323410034,
-0.32434141635894775,
0.5810160040855408,
-0.7279582023620605,
-0.11078977584838867,
-0.8664596080780029,
0.07552292943000793,
-0.7273257970809937,
-0.4863549768924713,
0.07890861481428146,
0.053704701364040375,
-0.7555551528930664,
0.016284510493278503,
-0.5095376968383789,
0.46721386909484863,
0.4859640598297119,
-0.12560346722602844,
0.16550107300281525,
0.03615257516503334,
0.29571741819381714,
0.17901423573493958,
-0.7721178531646729,
-0.8245513439178467,
0.5362189412117004,
0.32627156376838684,
0.44642573595046997,
-0.038735952228307724,
0.520514726638794,
0.40284815430641174,
0.1681239902973175,
-0.7808754444122314,
0.5769143104553223,
-0.21528463065624237,
-0.660211980342865,
-0.4410266578197479,
-0.5482208132743835,
-0.7481939792633057,
-0.09299128502607346,
-0.2925271987915039,
-0.6373308300971985,
-0.34910809993743896,
0.2880117893218994,
-0.2467138171195984,
0.6788135766983032,
-0.5224374532699585,
1.075538992881775,
-0.8937588930130005,
-0.5891240239143372,
-0.689552366733551,
-0.3581049144268036,
0.13980352878570557,
0.018328530713915825,
0.24377276003360748,
-0.005459344480186701,
-0.0488908477127552,
0.7895557880401611,
-0.06832806766033173,
0.976302444934845,
-0.2806463837623596,
-0.27721723914146423,
0.3246215879917145,
-0.3409576714038849,
0.6975921392440796,
-0.10361258685588837,
0.010607191361486912,
0.6947765350341797,
-0.3880068361759186,
-0.4273715019226074,
-0.056661780923604965,
0.6387625932693481,
-0.793493390083313,
-0.7781447768211365,
-0.5109241604804993,
-0.5862097144126892,
-0.27268335223197937,
0.3829857110977173,
0.11373764276504517,
-0.2990324795246124,
-0.30491477251052856,
-0.1117713451385498,
0.49964460730552673,
-0.6972015500068665,
0.4478752613067627,
0.05751834437251091,
0.13194315135478973,
-0.2489987313747406,
0.8167845010757446,
-0.0037115770392119884,
0.48074254393577576,
0.1974593549966812,
0.6161051392555237,
-0.15251299738883972,
-1.059295892715454,
-0.2602076232433319,
-0.01804589480161667,
-0.6692659258842468,
0.05233842879533768,
-0.5300495028495789,
-0.16697806119918823,
-0.1723029464483261,
-0.31756362318992615,
-0.3370975852012634,
-0.08291874080896378,
-0.62647944688797,
-0.39371949434280396,
0.4201822280883789,
0.6887046694755554,
0.11322321742773056,
0.19182902574539185,
-0.6895079016685486,
0.008275178261101246,
0.13669054210186005,
0.25298917293548584,
0.0533888041973114,
-0.0264291875064373,
-0.3792479336261749,
0.2050146758556366,
-0.1678789108991623,
-0.3454199731349945,
0.3174349367618561,
0.11652710288763046,
0.719582200050354,
0.22719940543174744,
-0.175971120595932,
0.578615665435791,
-0.41683730483055115,
0.9711392521858215,
0.45758941769599915,
-0.9286527633666992,
0.3441627621650696,
-0.4095197916030884,
0.12715937197208405,
0.45429372787475586,
0.3467581868171692,
-0.4326767921447754,
-0.3557106554508209,
-0.7330915331840515,
-0.8509271740913391,
0.3226904273033142,
0.09181780368089676,
0.2630348205566406,
-0.023884635418653488,
0.41468167304992676,
0.22924646735191345,
0.1358194351196289,
-0.6513614654541016,
0.10390602052211761,
-0.08648880571126938,
-0.0454442985355854,
-0.347063809633255,
0.21206513047218323,
-0.029603762552142143,
-0.15965679287910461,
1.003186583518982,
-0.24693377315998077,
0.24399954080581665,
-0.21118615567684174,
0.2413332611322403,
0.16135820746421814,
0.247938334941864,
0.4787824749946594,
0.022216560319066048,
-0.05479380488395691,
-0.013817507773637772,
0.34182819724082947,
-0.4532119631767273,
-0.0048563736490905285,
-0.2163664549589157,
-0.29176953434944153,
-0.2153763324022293,
0.2005210518836975,
0.7122727036476135,
-0.1405198872089386,
-0.7388485670089722,
-0.11335358768701553,
0.034556735306978226,
-0.07917703688144684,
-0.42791759967803955,
0.3914874792098999,
0.558502197265625,
0.05634813383221626,
-0.3078746795654297,
0.6954857707023621,
0.10811797529459,
-0.6785848140716553,
-0.11948112398386002,
1.0382078886032104,
-0.22993417084217072,
-0.17438672482967377,
0.9097954034805298,
0.501555323600769,
-0.3957168757915497,
0.9252517223358154,
-0.10557107627391815,
-0.6605058908462524,
0.9103230237960815,
0.41882243752479553,
0.8156271576881409,
0.49702244997024536,
-0.19684378802776337,
0.6932549476623535,
0.4351966977119446,
0.12203271687030792,
-0.12706300616264343,
-0.06735547631978989,
-0.774603545665741,
-0.25221624970436096,
-0.4165117144584656,
-0.5651857852935791,
0.29664146900177,
-0.42263534665107727,
0.18143893778324127,
-0.8111296892166138,
0.014896378852427006,
-0.26120325922966003,
0.4284279942512512,
-0.7206542491912842,
0.30475538969039917,
0.6814630627632141,
0.7509692907333374,
-0.8998816013336182,
0.4588417410850525,
0.4841483235359192,
-0.043852146714925766,
-0.5496141314506531,
0.2077586054801941,
-0.007417419925332069,
-0.5907933712005615,
0.6023674011230469,
0.36420056223869324,
-0.6516076326370239,
0.12065448611974716,
-0.5824129581451416,
-0.846307635307312,
1.0717353820800781,
0.7011401653289795,
-0.98579341173172,
-0.02160167694091797,
0.07799723744392395,
0.47021016478538513,
-0.06535381078720093,
-0.1696212887763977,
0.459288626909256,
0.725627064704895,
-0.2396155446767807,
-0.3847956657409668,
0.032619837671518326,
-0.20469030737876892,
-0.11800216883420944,
0.07898543775081635,
-1.0640565156936646,
0.42969247698783875,
-0.5027138590812683,
-0.6888192296028137,
0.10002868622541428,
0.4930517077445984,
0.16045226156711578,
0.3083532452583313,
0.5542530417442322,
0.738792359828949,
1.1384490728378296,
0.09415041655302048,
1.2590316534042358,
-0.3115125894546509,
0.4585188031196594,
0.9131119847297668,
-0.4231513440608978,
0.8437250256538391,
0.442059725522995,
-0.4370907247066498,
0.03955496475100517,
0.7929731011390686,
-0.21852557361125946,
0.37186843156814575,
0.6020420789718628,
-0.3156696557998657,
-0.2772146761417389,
-0.20857441425323486,
0.009451966732740402,
0.5016173720359802,
0.2824757695198059,
0.18471291661262512,
-0.1473793089389801,
-0.1303325891494751,
0.3003878593444824,
0.1362224817276001,
-0.3534431457519531,
0.7235736846923828,
-0.08682401478290558,
-0.616156280040741,
0.028670525178313255,
0.0003350432962179184,
0.908345103263855,
-0.4180910587310791,
-0.17916755378246307,
-0.013007665053009987,
0.16738323867321014,
-0.23075468838214874,
-0.4497932493686676,
0.5863151550292969,
0.1763152778148651,
-0.0043020728044211864,
-0.4975146949291229,
0.5046972036361694,
-0.23688501119613647,
-0.5567629337310791,
0.4767182171344757,
0.13107401132583618,
0.12264306843280792,
0.06426942348480225,
-0.9585015773773193,
-0.005644185934215784,
0.10374441742897034,
0.08976823836565018,
0.24914012849330902,
-0.20250752568244934,
0.1753958761692047,
0.3646736145019531,
0.9584709405899048,
0.21709930896759033,
-0.052165884524583817,
-0.2549861669540405,
0.5127264857292175,
-0.558424711227417,
-0.6825213432312012,
-0.842260479927063,
0.23196600377559662,
0.07454556226730347,
-0.22615841031074524,
0.760262668132782,
0.7530112266540527,
0.8855347037315369,
0.3246200680732727,
1.1279370784759521,
0.1917143613100052,
-0.026811350136995316,
-0.8102942705154419,
0.8172069787979126,
-0.4885175824165344,
0.5859346389770508,
0.05254242569208145,
-0.8391023874282837,
-0.10272786766290665,
0.5934750437736511,
-0.31954675912857056,
0.37655556201934814,
0.38782548904418945,
0.617222249507904,
0.18470825254917145,
0.14540883898735046,
0.07891552895307541,
0.16921165585517883,
0.8033829927444458,
0.287418007850647,
0.6693270206451416,
-0.08968080580234528,
0.21511881053447723,
-0.07105356454849243,
0.17437341809272766,
0.03828936442732811,
-1.0781038999557495,
-0.717505931854248,
-0.15217064321041107,
-0.8024489879608154,
-0.15891534090042114,
0.0960058867931366,
0.49692273139953613,
0.5932294726371765,
-0.8591957092285156,
0.039424050599336624,
-0.694277286529541,
0.05558190867304802,
-0.3664965033531189,
-0.20578505098819733,
0.6349872350692749,
-0.17807678878307343,
-0.8416739702224731,
0.2703443765640259,
0.26916104555130005,
0.11877899616956711,
-0.39142462611198425,
-0.35505568981170654,
-0.17403282225131989,
0.22914738953113556,
0.36784619092941284,
0.23228298127651215,
-0.5741804242134094,
-0.8343188762664795,
-0.026541024446487427,
-0.005078491289168596,
0.17382438480854034,
0.44533151388168335,
-0.6024181246757507,
0.1942863017320633,
0.3184766471385956,
0.9890502095222473,
0.29371967911720276,
-0.40346166491508484,
0.3829098343849182,
-0.3756133019924164,
0.06279455870389938,
0.4642348885536194,
0.4329962134361267,
0.6476801633834839,
-0.7351172566413879,
0.513267993927002,
0.21107883751392365,
-0.5375217199325562,
-0.7614102959632874,
0.16466374695301056,
-1.0010114908218384,
-0.46310535073280334,
1.4057183265686035,
-0.11578641086816788,
-0.023239657282829285,
-0.025000594556331635,
-0.1602807641029358,
0.1716822385787964,
-0.0352427177131176,
0.7194831967353821,
0.8621649742126465,
-0.2565213441848755,
0.035092879086732864,
-0.6744343042373657,
0.20871442556381226,
0.4640795886516571,
-1.2637553215026855,
0.3534497022628784,
0.516850471496582,
0.47181937098503113,
0.3798796236515045,
0.2510577440261841,
0.2692652940750122,
0.1412099152803421,
0.47084370255470276,
0.05483930557966232,
-0.06031259894371033,
-0.1885118931531906,
-0.37571725249290466,
-0.2415786236524582,
-0.024962913244962692,
-0.023271935060620308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01147v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01147v1
|
Do LLMs Find Human Answers To Fact-Driven Questions Perplexing? A Case Study on Reddit
| 2024-04-01T14:46:20 | 2024-04-01T14:46:20 |
Parker Seegmiller, Joseph Gatto, Omar Sharif, Madhusudan Basak, Sarah Masud Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been shown to be proficient in correctly
answering questions in the context of online discourse. However, the study of
using LLMs to model human-like answers to fact-driven social media questions is
still under-explored. In this work, we investigate how LLMs model the wide
variety of human answers to fact-driven questions posed on several
topic-specific Reddit communities, or subreddits. We collect and release a
dataset of 409 fact-driven questions and 7,534 diverse, human-rated answers
from 15 r/Ask{Topic} communities across 3 categories: profession, social
identity, and geographic location. We find that LLMs are considerably better at
modeling highly-rated human answers to such questions, as opposed to
poorly-rated human answers. We present several directions for future research
based on our initial findings.
|
[
-0.6289337873458862,
-1.110600233078003,
1.0961604118347168,
0.10864178836345673,
-0.4686569273471832,
0.23764079809188843,
-0.2821353077888489,
-0.3920729160308838,
0.15244145691394806,
0.3941573202610016,
-0.8303088545799255,
-0.4664174020290375,
-0.6631700992584229,
0.44516780972480774,
-0.5376101732254028,
0.6463125348091125,
0.1405472606420517,
0.05277353897690773,
-0.5479627847671509,
-0.10557374358177185,
-0.01645192876458168,
-0.8563550710678101,
-0.18823693692684174,
-0.33793362975120544,
1.1083921194076538,
0.6861363053321838,
0.5662187933921814,
0.5755636692047119,
0.7969256639480591,
0.19567494094371796,
-0.1963951140642166,
0.34995007514953613,
-0.7491586208343506,
0.0004740727017633617,
-0.35242053866386414,
-0.7042208909988403,
-0.12416012585163116,
0.12014638632535934,
0.27845481038093567,
0.9228335618972778,
-0.11250586807727814,
0.5940680503845215,
-0.22839947044849396,
0.39525657892227173,
-0.33089905977249146,
-0.24291454255580902,
-0.6520023345947266,
-0.01764686405658722,
0.0029384351801127195,
-0.41060420870780945,
-0.10538139939308167,
-0.48150917887687683,
0.2659160792827606,
-0.398147314786911,
0.5622509121894836,
-0.033407557755708694,
0.8138071298599243,
0.12209978699684143,
-0.6496573686599731,
-0.39785557985305786,
-0.8505023717880249,
0.8264902234077454,
-0.40178215503692627,
0.0117866862565279,
0.220366969704628,
0.12907378375530243,
-0.06557710468769073,
-0.36742866039276123,
-0.5860108733177185,
0.1793719232082367,
-0.41886264085769653,
-0.15282230079174042,
-0.18934306502342224,
-0.316156268119812,
0.42143934965133667,
0.06100131943821907,
-0.5529320240020752,
0.0831812173128128,
-0.2108319252729416,
0.00950869545340538,
0.9261219501495361,
0.5315868258476257,
0.18697425723075867,
-0.3874927759170532,
-0.22005845606327057,
0.24972490966320038,
-0.6936333179473877,
0.04221154376864433,
0.36521124839782715,
0.158635213971138,
-0.05364396050572395,
0.680492103099823,
-0.1878339797258377,
0.6200866103172302,
-0.07245694845914841,
-0.218343123793602,
-0.1986178159713745,
-0.3465016186237335,
0.10476851463317871,
-0.2992396652698517,
0.5228505730628967,
0.5782666802406311,
0.5690297484397888,
0.07156448811292648,
-0.20784485340118408,
-0.07296408712863922,
0.35190659761428833,
-0.6620870232582092,
-0.009161164984107018,
0.3306063115596771,
-0.2846386730670929,
-0.28692686557769775,
0.17226503789424896,
-0.48889172077178955,
-0.6912563443183899,
-0.1755618304014206,
0.1372489035129547,
0.205912783741951,
-0.4154183268547058,
0.13884058594703674,
0.05192774906754494,
0.33772286772727966,
0.5638936758041382,
-0.5269695520401001,
0.20658622682094574,
0.8041189312934875,
0.6304914951324463,
-0.403194785118103,
0.008867503143846989,
-0.17844246327877045,
-0.12878113985061646,
-0.29990309476852417,
1.092673897743225,
-0.5439449548721313,
-0.38067641854286194,
0.10222523659467697,
0.05996426194906235,
0.20561140775680542,
-0.7233242988586426,
0.404509574174881,
-1.021348476409912,
-0.08912782371044159,
-0.9139314889907837,
-0.5238273739814758,
-0.16104662418365479,
0.5705710053443909,
-0.4701014459133148,
0.5049535036087036,
-0.32917940616607666,
-0.960604190826416,
0.10988697409629822,
-0.7068841457366943,
-0.42844894528388977,
-0.05066126212477684,
-0.17829453945159912,
-0.040451616048812866,
0.12201899290084839,
0.10372014343738556,
0.6684243083000183,
-0.6319257020950317,
0.34512338042259216,
-0.26857373118400574,
-0.278496116399765,
1.0690854787826538,
-0.3756774663925171,
0.4742637872695923,
0.2577705681324005,
-0.009611319750547409,
-0.03876253217458725,
-0.5555417537689209,
-0.29329535365104675,
0.3316545784473419,
-0.5557747483253479,
-0.27179959416389465,
-0.011483014561235905,
-0.3821466565132141,
0.2819957435131073,
0.33510762453079224,
-0.7183061838150024,
-0.06823651492595673,
0.09188816696405411,
0.6240030527114868,
0.6150216460227966,
0.1844959259033203,
0.08225148916244507,
-0.621394157409668,
0.5734072923660278,
0.1284933090209961,
-0.16432814300060272,
0.1414572298526764,
-0.5670086145401001,
-0.6655159592628479,
-0.005068537779152393,
0.044766850769519806,
0.507909893989563,
-0.43528151512145996,
0.10669601708650589,
-0.16029731929302216,
-0.7168189287185669,
-0.5096175074577332,
0.22640734910964966,
0.1561317890882492,
0.6787194609642029,
0.08648493885993958,
0.03581393137574196,
-0.32559260725975037,
-0.9594441056251526,
-0.5159834623336792,
-0.12279166281223297,
-0.1638687252998352,
0.6062479615211487,
0.5693657398223877,
-0.28578653931617737,
1.0658036470413208,
-0.8240808844566345,
0.37675219774246216,
-0.2010466754436493,
0.30302315950393677,
0.23505796492099762,
-0.3277401030063629,
0.21652767062187195,
-1.0871492624282837,
-0.3331485390663147,
-0.3293779790401459,
-0.9030709266662598,
-0.21072719991207123,
0.0772114098072052,
0.05436845123767853,
0.06401407718658447,
0.31186485290527344,
-0.8769388794898987,
0.05001834034919739,
0.35762664675712585,
-0.11910054087638855,
0.6741529107093811,
-0.01818179152905941,
0.165204718708992,
-0.9334375262260437,
0.05439727008342743,
0.1771034300327301,
-0.3204834759235382,
-0.6338342428207397,
0.11748544871807098,
-0.19392749667167664,
0.05948343873023987,
-0.7350578904151917,
0.32920145988464355,
-0.3771422505378723,
-0.3616970181465149,
-0.1768757700920105,
0.3049471378326416,
-0.26302823424339294,
0.316738098859787,
0.10372905433177948,
0.7545285820960999,
0.3660219609737396,
-0.7550690174102783,
0.5756776928901672,
0.1034528985619545,
-0.46893933415412903,
0.26987767219543457,
-0.8232658505439758,
0.3754575848579407,
-0.34259429574012756,
0.13599064946174622,
-1.1955056190490723,
-0.748583197593689,
-0.07824710011482239,
-0.34831702709198,
-0.2984811067581177,
-0.13741987943649292,
-0.7285449504852295,
-0.426850825548172,
-0.22832299768924713,
0.4107150733470917,
0.38927775621414185,
-0.34086087346076965,
0.48608553409576416,
0.7420845031738281,
-0.41763627529144287,
-0.2886412441730499,
-0.6304036378860474,
0.05339624360203743,
-0.2085321992635727,
-0.6225112676620483,
-0.043674856424331665,
-0.17650054395198822,
-0.7328861951828003,
0.2197899967432022,
-0.05607311800122261,
-0.015288923867046833,
0.3325548470020294,
0.05734843760728836,
0.058330461382865906,
-0.22684268653392792,
0.22916458547115326,
-0.4013446569442749,
0.1824577897787094,
0.3375823497772217,
0.34120938181877136,
0.8189942836761475,
-0.11009178310632706,
-0.6004160046577454,
-0.23602552711963654,
0.3735806345939636,
0.7456448078155518,
-0.08170297741889954,
0.6201270222663879,
0.17189979553222656,
-0.2968217134475708,
0.011417558416724205,
-0.5669159889221191,
-0.5091187357902527,
-0.44346702098846436,
0.4828591048717499,
-0.07825686037540436,
-1.4721194505691528,
0.7811154723167419,
0.042387887835502625,
0.28459587693214417,
0.2016061544418335,
0.868180513381958,
-0.6153867244720459,
0.9068624973297119,
0.3203420341014862,
0.40268266201019287,
-0.08295879513025284,
0.15948186814785004,
0.2413141429424286,
-0.28158700466156006,
-0.20611579716205597,
-0.3594610095024109,
-0.46870818734169006,
-0.6399480700492859,
-0.5212171673774719,
0.5463322997093201,
-0.31390678882598877,
-0.06349314004182816,
0.05638454109430313,
-0.1623329371213913,
0.44364869594573975,
0.3911740183830261,
0.027972538024187088,
0.4134644567966461,
0.0406460240483284,
0.34314289689064026,
-0.022420840337872505,
-0.8901026248931885,
-0.7831671237945557,
1.155737280845642,
0.4244302809238434,
1.0947617292404175,
0.26151272654533386,
0.5642914175987244,
0.3019914925098419,
0.576691746711731,
-0.5769104957580566,
0.8037022352218628,
-0.16843558847904205,
-0.8947280645370483,
-0.4434613883495331,
-0.5763528347015381,
-0.716970682144165,
0.16935259103775024,
-0.5098802447319031,
-0.2315538078546524,
-0.20136487483978271,
0.2368023842573166,
-0.4476308524608612,
0.38499656319618225,
-0.4273320734500885,
0.38084766268730164,
-0.5620182156562805,
-0.24438033998012543,
-0.29208454489707947,
-0.8124390244483948,
0.47416937351226807,
-0.24837428331375122,
0.3323827087879181,
-0.26733118295669556,
-0.06095599755644798,
0.7466992735862732,
-0.14364565908908844,
0.9537495374679565,
0.13206081092357635,
-0.3731604516506195,
0.5579469799995422,
-0.07540152221918106,
0.25869089365005493,
0.23350395262241364,
0.022663399577140808,
0.04805946350097656,
-0.2626103162765503,
-0.4160017669200897,
-0.7262223958969116,
0.6932111978530884,
-1.0126734972000122,
-1.1216455698013306,
-0.29078495502471924,
-0.5461524724960327,
-0.24123609066009521,
-0.05716172233223915,
0.0025230266619473696,
0.369407057762146,
-0.13423630595207214,
0.08742665499448776,
1.0381057262420654,
-0.3355276882648468,
0.16114702820777893,
1.0072308778762817,
-0.0960894376039505,
0.012965159490704536,
0.6808853149414062,
0.34608620405197144,
0.2058759182691574,
0.43877509236335754,
0.2267603874206543,
-0.47063884139060974,
-0.18729168176651,
-0.2955707013607025,
0.7115104794502258,
-0.7399142980575562,
-0.008384461514651775,
-0.9189763069152832,
-0.23035556077957153,
-0.2377646565437317,
0.020682018250226974,
-0.18056081235408783,
-0.3493959903717041,
-0.5728008151054382,
-0.2471390664577484,
0.40780124068260193,
1.0219169855117798,
0.25744110345840454,
-0.08586311340332031,
-0.8754060864448547,
0.5399668216705322,
0.8861223459243774,
0.22041456401348114,
-0.16384419798851013,
-0.6787216663360596,
0.06381918489933014,
0.04969760403037071,
0.031079506501555443,
-0.9123271703720093,
-0.10466576367616653,
-0.17506438493728638,
0.3998972177505493,
0.380230188369751,
0.38471975922584534,
0.48859280347824097,
-0.2698439061641693,
0.7173864245414734,
-0.10527446866035461,
-0.14226537942886353,
0.37599968910217285,
-0.4941375255584717,
0.2014511078596115,
0.48401588201522827,
0.8692269325256348,
-0.6757049560546875,
-0.39991819858551025,
-0.3720102310180664,
-0.6788272261619568,
0.45351359248161316,
-0.08703630417585373,
0.6307787299156189,
-0.09119728952646255,
0.7053869366645813,
0.02295059710741043,
0.4053073823451996,
-0.6894778609275818,
-0.41291293501853943,
0.11437759548425674,
0.14272701740264893,
0.03210458531975746,
-0.7238081097602844,
-0.3939705193042755,
-0.09698262065649033,
0.4453221559524536,
0.1004067212343216,
0.18083545565605164,
0.26559191942214966,
-0.013259950093925,
-0.5059148669242859,
0.4292268455028534,
0.9887182712554932,
0.8686650991439819,
-0.17927272617816925,
0.4620704650878906,
0.17112720012664795,
-0.1998969316482544,
0.3009173572063446,
-0.21295933425426483,
-0.18780465424060822,
-0.20336505770683289,
0.4960792660713196,
0.4250287711620331,
0.0616750493645668,
-0.9347988367080688,
0.43095988035202026,
-0.2509983777999878,
-0.46799466013908386,
-0.28096508979797363,
0.18494735658168793,
0.7940570712089539,
0.164526104927063,
0.5427636504173279,
-0.18187808990478516,
-0.31450825929641724,
-0.8393949270248413,
-0.0020485783461481333,
0.407497763633728,
-0.24503925442695618,
-0.43766364455223083,
0.43923577666282654,
0.6038566827774048,
-0.6455000042915344,
0.45973339676856995,
-0.055325936526060104,
-0.6783397197723389,
0.5280085206031799,
0.33900755643844604,
0.559431254863739,
0.2890743017196655,
0.21720585227012634,
0.21617278456687927,
0.2475389689207077,
-0.040178488940000534,
0.38810908794403076,
0.15312203764915466,
-0.9930088520050049,
-0.36701130867004395,
-0.7235214114189148,
-0.6741776466369629,
0.15717698633670807,
-0.3277309536933899,
0.1945800632238388,
-0.47655388712882996,
-0.37129849195480347,
-0.03213316947221756,
-0.062310971319675446,
-0.4917970895767212,
0.2388596534729004,
0.012066539376974106,
0.9485273957252502,
-1.004900336265564,
0.45467209815979004,
1.265478253364563,
-0.2753365933895111,
-0.7027575969696045,
0.3437495529651642,
-0.047174692153930664,
-0.5011652112007141,
0.5774438381195068,
-0.07690827548503876,
-0.5301141142845154,
-0.054405804723501205,
-0.9130309224128723,
-0.6928016543388367,
1.0331319570541382,
0.5597735047340393,
-0.5911598801612854,
0.0860573947429657,
0.5279333591461182,
0.6572921872138977,
-0.3359615206718445,
0.054173365235328674,
0.46590331196784973,
0.36856064200401306,
-0.0021825432777404785,
-0.5897430181503296,
0.08274121582508087,
-0.07163181155920029,
-0.3495893180370331,
-0.299917608499527,
-0.8932148218154907,
0.8480472564697266,
-0.5301255583763123,
-0.31740155816078186,
-0.25792357325553894,
0.6255901455879211,
0.5087071061134338,
0.29593318700790405,
0.5915275812149048,
0.24832689762115479,
0.7601079344749451,
0.17528365552425385,
0.9939368367195129,
-0.27279701828956604,
0.36618614196777344,
0.7825873494148254,
-0.4062547981739044,
0.6500056385993958,
0.38723891973495483,
-0.22223065793514252,
0.498129278421402,
0.8148698210716248,
0.20961163938045502,
0.20396097004413605,
0.2989948093891144,
-0.3133491277694702,
-0.9418315291404724,
-0.2657409608364105,
0.06095244362950325,
0.4108661711215973,
0.1180855929851532,
-0.12071441859006882,
-0.2567482888698578,
-0.4381718039512634,
0.020410412922501564,
0.3218063414096832,
-0.14566287398338318,
0.7640049457550049,
0.1598505973815918,
-0.862643837928772,
0.4068300127983093,
0.25600898265838623,
0.6983778476715088,
-0.41359806060791016,
0.09291569888591766,
-0.4773283302783966,
-0.3536653518676758,
-0.22105543315410614,
-1.2733999490737915,
0.1941131204366684,
0.4915260374546051,
-0.47900283336639404,
-0.12497882544994354,
0.8521767258644104,
-0.32181689143180847,
-0.4619006812572479,
0.032095178961753845,
0.728127121925354,
0.21293191611766815,
0.02578912489116192,
-0.4836864173412323,
-0.1309262216091156,
-0.09059305489063263,
-0.27462130784988403,
0.3218323588371277,
0.5162582993507385,
-0.16497430205345154,
1.1755895614624023,
0.6281089782714844,
-0.26176226139068604,
0.02887166291475296,
-0.043079737573862076,
0.9190566539764404,
-0.6008487939834595,
-0.32898494601249695,
-1.0121158361434937,
0.2581981420516968,
-0.09521115571260452,
-0.39440199732780457,
0.8342519402503967,
0.33541369438171387,
0.6240894794464111,
-0.12471328675746918,
0.8643518090248108,
0.1667652726173401,
1.0200790166854858,
-0.1637931764125824,
0.7727957963943481,
-0.6876470446586609,
0.5068269371986389,
-0.30261895060539246,
-0.6023002862930298,
-0.29524749517440796,
0.3596838712692261,
-0.49731576442718506,
-0.14652280509471893,
0.2552194893360138,
1.0733215808868408,
0.09284669905900955,
0.06886553764343262,
0.31313756108283997,
0.23045559227466583,
0.17325468361377716,
0.22026565670967102,
1.3262525796890259,
0.32762351632118225,
0.5802720785140991,
-0.0418114960193634,
0.027948517352342606,
-0.45806884765625,
-0.6663960218429565,
-0.8561887145042419,
-0.28672903776168823,
-0.3009842038154602,
0.010795108042657375,
-0.09654120355844498,
1.0221434831619263,
0.532512903213501,
-0.6628828644752502,
-0.2941506505012512,
0.13667775690555573,
0.45097941160202026,
0.3869727849960327,
-0.2214515507221222,
0.030265381559729576,
0.04847211018204689,
-0.2859525680541992,
-0.03346475213766098,
0.10640673339366913,
-0.07298785448074341,
-0.4674103856086731,
0.05995873361825943,
-0.4174407124519348,
0.3894992172718048,
0.5900771617889404,
0.007083444390445948,
-0.7988603115081787,
-0.5374377369880676,
0.49087509512901306,
-0.26372799277305603,
-0.03970403969287872,
1.0382181406021118,
-0.3786983788013458,
-0.00812601950019598,
0.47642093896865845,
0.6486489772796631,
0.2324257791042328,
0.7025337219238281,
0.32083699107170105,
-0.6700986623764038,
-0.39206168055534363,
0.20381635427474976,
-0.004955745302140713,
0.6356592774391174,
-0.27475506067276,
0.2933580279350281,
0.5687729120254517,
-0.6168175339698792,
-0.621600866317749,
0.46241405606269836,
-0.7060478329658508,
-0.4330711364746094,
1.4060167074203491,
0.11937130242586136,
-0.16938698291778564,
-0.2974616289138794,
0.06498957425355911,
-0.07322318851947784,
-0.24892109632492065,
0.9425650835037231,
0.8827239274978638,
-0.476230263710022,
-0.3061130940914154,
-0.40950843691825867,
0.2347092479467392,
0.16858749091625214,
-0.7940878868103027,
0.3243350684642792,
0.359404593706131,
0.7233966588973999,
0.2698279321193695,
0.7180116772651672,
0.1414901614189148,
0.3955942988395691,
-0.5498778820037842,
-0.3301964998245239,
0.24046814441680908,
-0.23367930948734283,
-0.15271489322185516,
0.4745006263256073,
0.4656917154788971,
0.23816068470478058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01140v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01140v2
|
KoCoNovel: Annotated Dataset of Character Coreference in Korean Novels
| 2024-04-01T14:36:35 | 2024-04-11T14:57:10 |
Kyuhee Kim, Surin Lee, Sangah Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present KoCoNovel, a novel character coreference dataset
derived from Korean literary texts, complete with detailed annotation
guidelines. Comprising 178K tokens from 50 modern and contemporary novels,
KoCoNovel stands as one of the largest public coreference resolution corpora in
Korean, and the first to be based on literary texts. KoCoNovel offers four
distinct versions to accommodate a wide range of literary coreference analysis
needs. These versions are designed to support perspectives of the omniscient
author or readers, and to manage multiple entities as either separate or
overlapping, thereby broadening its applicability. One of KoCoNovel's
distinctive features is that 24% of all character mentions are single common
nouns, lacking possessive markers or articles. This feature is particularly
influenced by the nuances of Korean address term culture, which favors the use
of terms denoting social relationships and kinship over personal names. In
experiments with a BERT-based coreference model, we observe notable performance
enhancements with KoCoNovel in character coreference tasks within literary
texts, compared to a larger non-literary coreference dataset. Such findings
underscore KoCoNovel's potential to significantly enhance coreference
resolution models through the integration of Korean cultural and linguistic
dynamics.
|
[
-0.19350594282150269,
-0.49847134947776794,
0.3718409538269043,
0.022790145128965378,
-0.30838531255722046,
0.0715678408741951,
-0.5173866152763367,
-0.6577328443527222,
0.18680457770824432,
0.9665420651435852,
-0.46282920241355896,
-0.7913868427276611,
-0.24380271136760712,
0.5482237339019775,
0.5513389706611633,
0.8466582894325256,
0.1001095175743103,
-0.11639011651277542,
-0.30376213788986206,
-0.33750176429748535,
-0.47660359740257263,
-0.8538388013839722,
-0.032754652202129364,
-0.4538581967353821,
0.7354723215103149,
0.46428611874580383,
0.9365407228469849,
0.5786912441253662,
0.4458119869232178,
0.22419330477714539,
-0.21368584036827087,
0.1287425458431244,
-0.3458006978034973,
0.342753142118454,
-0.47486525774002075,
-0.5598641037940979,
-0.21720606088638306,
-0.14942900836467743,
0.36442455649375916,
0.8301599025726318,
0.6123760342597961,
-0.07236188650131226,
0.09717407822608948,
0.7353758811950684,
-0.7434139251708984,
0.31537774205207825,
-0.2696053087711334,
0.05738437548279762,
-0.2712746262550354,
0.18377146124839783,
-0.4137231111526489,
-0.7290660738945007,
0.3310181200504303,
-0.6703482270240784,
0.24768978357315063,
0.10606925934553146,
0.8272122740745544,
-0.20874077081680298,
-0.6057572364807129,
-0.7891700267791748,
-0.5213977098464966,
0.8182195425033569,
-0.4581553041934967,
0.10512537509202957,
0.36105307936668396,
0.08405175805091858,
0.1611274629831314,
-0.3227701485157013,
-0.2404307872056961,
-0.5697599053382874,
-0.4583410620689392,
-0.08487392216920853,
0.1397181749343872,
0.43478095531463623,
0.269641637802124,
0.30017441511154175,
-0.34157058596611023,
-0.026757286861538887,
-0.28029516339302063,
-0.34728363156318665,
0.6524598002433777,
0.08438980579376221,
0.3911654055118561,
-0.5347437262535095,
-0.3242407739162445,
0.08714763820171356,
-0.6864343285560608,
0.1787441223859787,
0.34808430075645447,
0.4247398376464844,
0.2945714592933655,
0.477701872587204,
-0.1953631341457367,
0.1422942578792572,
0.48282545804977417,
-0.19661492109298706,
0.39493000507354736,
-0.45508918166160583,
0.2128424346446991,
0.6634130477905273,
0.6175574660301208,
0.8766175508499146,
0.651231586933136,
-0.37685704231262207,
0.27508679032325745,
0.2868053913116455,
0.1073671504855156,
-0.825329065322876,
-0.5641373991966248,
0.21551017463207245,
-0.38133323192596436,
-0.37801891565322876,
-0.06260479241609573,
-0.7457188367843628,
-0.9159427285194397,
-0.43268173933029175,
-0.10991634428501129,
-0.5897457003593445,
-0.385648638010025,
-0.13224035501480103,
-0.21946598589420319,
-0.023322343826293945,
0.12509679794311523,
-0.666486918926239,
-0.031337156891822815,
0.4994139075279236,
0.59903484582901,
-0.25705376267433167,
-0.1329827755689621,
0.06218665838241577,
-0.02308930642902851,
-0.6737985014915466,
0.6696766018867493,
-0.4916089177131653,
-0.6655279994010925,
0.22618159651756287,
0.27589330077171326,
-0.14311076700687408,
-0.5741152763366699,
1.069720983505249,
-0.19988654553890228,
-0.6025516390800476,
-0.6309067010879517,
-0.6754766702651978,
-0.06830082088708878,
0.2763291895389557,
-0.9240753054618835,
0.8383178114891052,
-0.036653343588113785,
-0.7327069044113159,
0.09559116512537003,
-0.3401302993297577,
-0.4291435182094574,
0.36594685912132263,
-0.14148291945457458,
0.03376994654536247,
0.0101520586758852,
0.12662844359874725,
0.5824185013771057,
-0.06559459865093231,
0.19150035083293915,
-0.3937961459159851,
0.01748727820813656,
0.47160691022872925,
0.2687322199344635,
0.7210611701011658,
0.305399090051651,
0.2407200187444687,
-0.12533459067344666,
-0.7177977561950684,
0.0005253073759377003,
-0.1282017081975937,
0.03701600432395935,
-1.132733941078186,
-0.4647522568702698,
0.06536513566970825,
-0.11335241049528122,
0.7361379861831665,
-0.8723729252815247,
0.2432217001914978,
-0.055199604481458664,
0.08819175511598587,
0.341645747423172,
0.2523697018623352,
0.6721428632736206,
-0.3159573972225189,
0.6136835813522339,
-0.023905480280518532,
0.019345015287399292,
-0.6448267102241516,
-0.17467710375785828,
-0.2982810139656067,
-0.5312637686729431,
0.4676613509654999,
0.6207479238510132,
-0.7723034024238586,
0.5723292827606201,
-0.24628563225269318,
-0.9780439734458923,
-0.563493013381958,
-0.11411848664283752,
0.7711811661720276,
0.430248498916626,
-0.04328368231654167,
0.2798333764076233,
-0.7041158080101013,
-0.9823206663131714,
-0.4575200080871582,
-0.2607060372829437,
0.06730392575263977,
0.3913670480251312,
0.4367678761482239,
0.1918988972902298,
1.0261352062225342,
-0.5549144148826599,
-0.30659541487693787,
-0.3559422492980957,
0.06922250986099243,
0.3435468375682831,
0.47953176498413086,
0.5551431179046631,
-0.7906752824783325,
-0.6022067666053772,
0.3452392518520355,
-0.8914046883583069,
-0.2973858118057251,
-0.09274234622716904,
-0.42665326595306396,
0.00032021396327763796,
0.5290216207504272,
-0.48908355832099915,
0.21711696684360504,
0.3172702193260193,
-0.7096517086029053,
1.2433313131332397,
0.07383796572685242,
0.44028452038764954,
-1.1720399856567383,
0.20443779230117798,
-0.1596745103597641,
-0.05250516161322594,
-0.6601079702377319,
0.24687449634075165,
0.34087905287742615,
0.09770072251558304,
-0.17902061343193054,
0.6389407515525818,
-0.3798878490924835,
0.44517552852630615,
0.007493358571082354,
0.2973949909210205,
0.26885098218917847,
0.46435314416885376,
0.233061745762825,
0.4357829689979553,
0.16197840869426727,
-0.5955430865287781,
0.4718090295791626,
0.36667248606681824,
-0.4074620008468628,
1.1969126462936401,
-0.4465257227420807,
0.04955202713608742,
-0.035256527364254,
0.09549295157194138,
-0.9862247109413147,
-0.1568656712770462,
0.2069232016801834,
-0.2777840197086334,
0.01704929769039154,
-0.4903624653816223,
-0.46812689304351807,
0.04637528955936432,
-0.06766074895858765,
0.3434746265411377,
0.15977783501148224,
-0.5008875727653503,
0.6241351962089539,
0.220749169588089,
-0.40612176060676575,
-0.3465871214866638,
-0.5313156247138977,
-0.0887681171298027,
-0.19803769886493683,
-0.5449655652046204,
0.46315866708755493,
-0.3675118088722229,
-0.2980521619319916,
0.22174079716205597,
0.01887347549200058,
-0.2654905617237091,
-0.18474848568439484,
0.37038809061050415,
0.5287474989891052,
-0.08186827600002289,
0.40634578466415405,
0.12710538506507874,
-0.0018809894099831581,
-0.2415189892053604,
0.11068714410066605,
0.2244686782360077,
-0.22303041815757751,
0.14295557141304016,
-0.20367704331874847,
0.48655587434768677,
0.5333939790725708,
-0.037385132163763046,
0.3793503940105438,
0.1090158075094223,
-0.21722112596035004,
0.2143671065568924,
-0.4330436587333679,
0.22584211826324463,
-0.3838927745819092,
0.4871717095375061,
-0.7149080634117126,
-0.8716228008270264,
0.7806495428085327,
-0.3131188154220581,
0.11701939254999161,
0.48976048827171326,
0.30666038393974304,
-0.036726608872413635,
0.30642715096473694,
0.340828537940979,
-0.027586640790104866,
0.3483569622039795,
0.18388047814369202,
0.004218566231429577,
-1.034105896949768,
-0.18086357414722443,
-0.7402938604354858,
-0.368651807308197,
-0.5488829612731934,
-0.2700415253639221,
0.05009717121720314,
0.5093527436256409,
-0.1324242353439331,
0.6810014843940735,
-0.39943867921829224,
0.8746817111968994,
0.34053441882133484,
0.0009394201333634555,
0.6470202207565308,
-0.3470362722873688,
-0.38673776388168335,
-0.48556920886039734,
-0.25266972184181213,
-0.7127788662910461,
0.9160985946655273,
0.11547859758138657,
0.7228822708129883,
-0.028532391414046288,
0.601529061794281,
0.6614317297935486,
-0.05618763715028763,
-0.6069203019142151,
0.44545498490333557,
-0.2299475073814392,
-0.8370956778526306,
-0.0703221783041954,
-0.1760551482439041,
-0.9432892203330994,
0.18629677593708038,
0.10085846483707428,
-0.923527181148529,
0.6050035953521729,
-0.04924416542053223,
-0.4563705027103424,
0.0949038714170456,
-0.5963238477706909,
0.9416436553001404,
-0.057851940393447876,
0.00695532001554966,
0.12963135540485382,
-0.46239733695983887,
0.2748017907142639,
0.1328931301832199,
-0.09167081117630005,
-0.2717033624649048,
-0.044759172946214676,
0.5928935408592224,
-0.06496908515691757,
0.9524652361869812,
-0.01909462921321392,
-0.04225071147084236,
0.357619971036911,
0.3735944628715515,
0.49742788076400757,
0.006192448083311319,
-0.3382832407951355,
0.46057069301605225,
0.6483534574508667,
-0.35975825786590576,
-0.4009176790714264,
0.8615750670433044,
-0.647020697593689,
0.20394860208034515,
-0.45340609550476074,
-0.7483287453651428,
-0.06961550563573837,
0.30101311206817627,
0.5745474100112915,
0.4953736960887909,
-0.5863099098205566,
0.40663498640060425,
0.6340857148170471,
-0.04336172714829445,
0.12463938444852829,
0.281940758228302,
-0.3962996304035187,
-0.7856447696685791,
0.5881751179695129,
0.392926424741745,
0.3505089581012726,
0.12427694350481033,
0.08671218156814575,
-0.4343683421611786,
0.05343984439969063,
-0.20677706599235535,
0.3449319899082184,
-0.8581932187080383,
-0.04124809429049492,
-0.6571962833404541,
-0.19581878185272217,
-0.39635059237480164,
-0.680883526802063,
-0.444366455078125,
-0.43794968724250793,
-0.13358229398727417,
-0.10804291069507599,
0.40161409974098206,
0.38261255621910095,
0.31335708498954773,
0.3185766637325287,
-0.6286768317222595,
0.14416605234146118,
-0.291498064994812,
0.1755480021238327,
-0.21870170533657074,
-0.18212881684303284,
-0.5180287957191467,
-0.19041606783866882,
-0.12020472437143326,
-0.8093671798706055,
0.22622793912887573,
0.22133806347846985,
0.3110879063606262,
0.541254997253418,
0.8972776532173157,
0.47389063239097595,
-0.32602304220199585,
1.0105003118515015,
0.19261421263217926,
-0.6254957914352417,
0.20740436017513275,
-0.42778873443603516,
0.6546317934989929,
0.7408072352409363,
0.3741542398929596,
-1.021567702293396,
-0.36943063139915466,
-0.6542693972587585,
-0.5529108047485352,
0.27643248438835144,
0.28465962409973145,
-0.017572926357388496,
-0.060758765786886215,
0.38719338178634644,
0.42855191230773926,
0.3019453287124634,
-0.2494673877954483,
-0.1510927528142929,
0.07075763493776321,
-0.3809143006801605,
-0.1593395173549652,
-0.4239945709705353,
0.031175101175904274,
-0.03195401281118393,
0.5216628909111023,
-0.1610565185546875,
0.03934922441840172,
0.5568652749061584,
-0.368268758058548,
0.19685639441013336,
0.30397120118141174,
0.243261456489563,
0.47851985692977905,
-0.07296019792556763,
0.061469461768865585,
-0.1354721486568451,
-0.6801082491874695,
-0.1458565890789032,
-0.08560620993375778,
-0.3246544301509857,
0.47710588574409485,
0.5140435099601746,
0.47739821672439575,
0.49556946754455566,
-0.726654052734375,
0.05079096928238869,
0.2677137553691864,
-0.16781067848205566,
-0.5877417325973511,
-0.154409721493721,
-0.07319755852222443,
0.6268784999847412,
0.32682695984840393,
0.000911724113393575,
0.005259630735963583,
-0.3125484585762024,
0.2074091136455536,
-0.0825786218047142,
-0.4681713581085205,
-0.4277823865413666,
0.06954508274793625,
0.3419070541858673,
-0.04549902305006981,
0.4113130271434784,
-0.3139980137348175,
-0.6413369178771973,
0.5724575519561768,
0.37086746096611023,
0.9357063174247742,
-0.3059503734111786,
0.33368900418281555,
0.7687896490097046,
0.30887898802757263,
0.22062362730503082,
0.03666367381811142,
0.16153624653816223,
-0.8712586164474487,
-0.1002197191119194,
-0.666824996471405,
-0.4219502806663513,
-0.1652011275291443,
-0.6729542016983032,
0.22294534742832184,
-0.5166817307472229,
-0.19071464240550995,
-0.16296246647834778,
0.3470909595489502,
-0.4471437931060791,
-0.2710838317871094,
0.053005944937467575,
0.6369653940200806,
-0.7964750528335571,
0.6501890420913696,
0.7219566106796265,
-0.2804001271724701,
-0.31999683380126953,
-0.21683958172798157,
0.10426827520132065,
-0.04470124468207359,
0.42254316806793213,
0.25940895080566406,
0.2074572592973709,
0.03299557417631149,
-0.29049962759017944,
-0.6045644879341125,
1.0480866432189941,
0.2930225729942322,
-0.4800933003425598,
-0.17365986108779907,
0.24377530813217163,
0.465565025806427,
-0.7651201486587524,
0.010024245828390121,
0.7475150227546692,
0.3812951147556305,
0.06806095689535141,
-0.7957759499549866,
0.03590269014239311,
-0.39296454191207886,
0.1671351194381714,
0.13622190058231354,
-0.5807588696479797,
0.5976067781448364,
0.04415549337863922,
-0.09051024913787842,
0.5572772026062012,
0.7073303461074829,
0.505187451839447,
0.38979780673980713,
0.5104507803916931,
0.2850938141345978,
1.014693260192871,
-0.13872626423835754,
0.7597135305404663,
-0.2722742557525635,
0.2703322172164917,
1.4766947031021118,
-0.2768566310405731,
0.4436068534851074,
0.31806421279907227,
-0.05514521524310112,
0.4951564073562622,
0.6201415657997131,
-0.1696009635925293,
0.49643996357917786,
-0.18153338134288788,
-0.4195524752140045,
-0.2927224636077881,
-0.7538595199584961,
-0.2547677159309387,
-0.05968187376856804,
0.25557875633239746,
-0.516635537147522,
-0.13411256670951843,
0.41974708437919617,
0.5108321309089661,
0.5039834380149841,
-0.4415505826473236,
0.5541678667068481,
0.002952718175947666,
-0.667637050151825,
0.1742609739303589,
-0.33262065052986145,
0.551975429058075,
-0.7096279859542847,
0.059144891798496246,
-0.08981362730264664,
0.4605320692062378,
-0.07726746052503586,
-0.798025906085968,
0.03416438773274422,
-0.0475078709423542,
-0.5152521729469299,
0.23776863515377045,
1.0164443254470825,
-0.6638413071632385,
-0.6471978425979614,
0.07114261388778687,
-0.052692122757434845,
0.3312067687511444,
-0.41674208641052246,
-0.3613327741622925,
0.0600869245827198,
-0.13714897632598877,
0.12483981251716614,
0.1434205323457718,
0.8258094787597656,
-0.0732482373714447,
0.2893141508102417,
0.3435955345630646,
0.09002310037612915,
0.22249184548854828,
-0.29676899313926697,
0.4749627113342285,
-0.6598749160766602,
-0.6710059642791748,
-0.4595196843147278,
0.563544511795044,
-0.27873772382736206,
-0.674080491065979,
0.8500838279724121,
0.35626864433288574,
0.6567922830581665,
-0.37471723556518555,
1.0098849534988403,
-0.4432757794857025,
0.5154334306716919,
-0.279131144285202,
0.7169458270072937,
0.10508202016353607,
-0.1830114871263504,
-0.4751337170600891,
-0.7116740942001343,
-0.11772086471319199,
0.3077445924282074,
-0.3372799754142761,
-0.190572127699852,
0.7247207164764404,
0.7046807408332825,
0.36191147565841675,
0.3768632411956787,
0.7364605665206909,
0.19691850244998932,
0.05152451992034912,
0.4180019795894623,
0.5362846851348877,
-0.36036416888237,
0.5049331784248352,
-0.6402937769889832,
-0.13777390122413635,
-0.4672982394695282,
-0.7850735187530518,
-1.1763330698013306,
-0.8441481590270996,
-0.5546331405639648,
-0.41708698868751526,
0.15004892647266388,
1.0768717527389526,
0.29905611276626587,
-0.7059077024459839,
-0.1646755039691925,
0.35484579205513,
0.014538288116455078,
-0.6187185049057007,
-0.23645250499248505,
0.4705863893032074,
-0.39518553018569946,
-0.8621450066566467,
0.030742108821868896,
-0.06965414434671402,
-0.5628634691238403,
-0.1481136977672577,
-0.25705137848854065,
-0.18742454051971436,
0.2014586478471756,
0.5825361609458923,
0.1950494796037674,
-0.7091970443725586,
-0.3027268350124359,
-0.06013628467917442,
-0.17082570493221283,
0.004740272182971239,
0.9744327664375305,
-0.48036637902259827,
0.8699880838394165,
0.500295877456665,
0.3823778033256531,
-0.07376886904239655,
0.1694284826517105,
0.43104907870292664,
-0.8132092952728271,
0.07931029796600342,
0.35545364022254944,
0.12959183752536774,
0.14276327192783356,
-0.7601713538169861,
0.4790869951248169,
0.43932241201400757,
-0.7531567215919495,
-0.44869425892829895,
0.4391511380672455,
-1.1196770668029785,
-0.2481212168931961,
1.2157390117645264,
-0.5156346559524536,
-0.44120001792907715,
-0.41122379899024963,
-0.782077968120575,
0.13286827504634857,
-0.7028997540473938,
0.2507612109184265,
1.2096073627471924,
0.017601173371076584,
-0.25604093074798584,
-0.5016804337501526,
0.3325040638446808,
0.010906122624874115,
-0.3405505418777466,
0.6008434295654297,
0.6628718376159668,
0.13751250505447388,
0.583512008190155,
0.16208605468273163,
-0.38301315903663635,
0.1831057369709015,
0.042772624641656876,
0.5344571471214294,
-0.125305637717247,
-0.214864119887352,
-0.005759434308856726,
0.32550182938575745,
-0.1707279235124588,
-0.13890618085861206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01129v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01129v2
|
Structured Information Matters: Incorporating Abstract Meaning Representation into LLMs for Improved Open-Domain Dialogue Evaluation
| 2024-04-01T14:11:45 | 2024-04-06T16:44:37 |
Bohao Yang, Kun Zhao, Chen Tang, Liang Zhan, Chenghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic open-domain dialogue evaluation has attracted increasing attention.
Trainable evaluation metrics are commonly trained with true positive and
randomly selected negative responses, resulting in a tendency for them to
assign a higher score to the responses that share higher content similarity
with a given context. However, adversarial negative responses possess high
content similarity with the contexts whilst being semantically different.
Therefore, existing evaluation metrics are not robust enough to evaluate such
responses, resulting in low correlations with human judgments. While recent
studies have shown some efficacy in utilizing Large Language Models (LLMs) for
open-domain dialogue evaluation, they still encounter challenges in effectively
handling adversarial negative examples. In this paper, we propose a simple yet
effective framework for open-domain dialogue evaluation, which combines
domain-specific language models (SLMs) with LLMs. The SLMs can explicitly
incorporate Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) graph information of the
dialogue through a gating mechanism for enhanced semantic representation
learning. The evaluation result of SLMs and AMR graph information are plugged
into the prompt of LLM, for the enhanced in-context learning performance.
Experimental results on open-domain dialogue evaluation tasks demonstrate the
superiority of our method compared to a wide range of state-of-the-art
baselines, especially in discriminating adversarial negative responses. Our
code is available at https://github.com/Bernard-Yang/SIMAMR.
|
[
-0.42420390248298645,
-0.7524522542953491,
0.6041046977043152,
0.019691672176122665,
-0.31489020586013794,
0.09076198190450668,
-0.4598749279975891,
-0.23742224276065826,
0.135487362742424,
0.23731428384780884,
-0.34172117710113525,
-0.7741252779960632,
-0.7744712233543396,
-0.012191698886454105,
-0.15158168971538544,
1.153050422668457,
-0.1256168931722641,
0.33949461579322815,
-0.34938398003578186,
-0.22612585127353668,
-0.2503288686275482,
-0.651685357093811,
-0.7507234215736389,
-0.62177973985672,
0.2486104816198349,
-0.25939106941223145,
0.8676234483718872,
0.2904823124408722,
0.2198464572429657,
0.2650986313819885,
-0.05387761443853378,
0.2660176157951355,
-0.6012486219406128,
0.12624028325080872,
-0.2561795711517334,
-0.10321284830570221,
-0.5600572228431702,
0.13371220231056213,
0.5229277610778809,
0.71107017993927,
-0.050192493945360184,
-0.08452445268630981,
0.09670443087816238,
0.20014609396457672,
-0.5937235951423645,
0.5431705713272095,
-0.6696315407752991,
0.28900158405303955,
0.24608224630355835,
-0.5448662042617798,
-0.6330128908157349,
-0.3242453336715698,
0.29707685112953186,
-0.7445749044418335,
-0.15379127860069275,
-0.047386832535266876,
0.9455371499061584,
-0.011383689939975739,
-0.37814682722091675,
-0.47614723443984985,
-0.6182138323783875,
0.7709282040596008,
-0.8501315116882324,
0.09007169306278229,
0.09105396270751953,
0.38544002175331116,
-0.2835286855697632,
-0.46719154715538025,
-0.43007126450538635,
-0.2499738186597824,
-0.13018551468849182,
0.19858165085315704,
-0.3287109136581421,
0.3573586344718933,
0.12752054631710052,
0.41740599274635315,
-0.22485987842082977,
-0.11456795781850815,
-0.14389298856258392,
-0.26504018902778625,
0.4206891655921936,
0.4213368892669678,
0.28145632147789,
0.014792745932936668,
-0.41943636536598206,
-0.09321467578411102,
-0.7465848326683044,
-0.10830128937959671,
0.41857290267944336,
0.43192487955093384,
-0.147781103849411,
0.6171419620513916,
-0.007226638495922089,
0.7595619559288025,
0.09884312003850937,
0.011461492627859116,
0.2135315239429474,
-0.2750103771686554,
-0.30887311697006226,
-0.11465626209974289,
0.7723283171653748,
0.40390580892562866,
0.3094595968723297,
-0.26937994360923767,
-0.28600046038627625,
0.3001993000507355,
0.37831053137779236,
-1.0168299674987793,
-0.10274484753608704,
-0.046586014330387115,
-0.40664514899253845,
-0.07828592509031296,
0.10197500884532928,
-0.48175176978111267,
-0.5164686441421509,
-0.4451090097427368,
0.49327749013900757,
-0.42593422532081604,
0.053056344389915466,
0.32314950227737427,
-0.08207056671380997,
0.15546545386314392,
0.7231631875038147,
-0.5821255445480347,
0.623733639717102,
0.6609777808189392,
0.7314167618751526,
-0.08731693029403687,
0.2153574824333191,
-0.77024906873703,
-0.04829181730747223,
-0.2800941467285156,
0.5066971182823181,
-0.7996110320091248,
-0.255522221326828,
0.13275422155857086,
-0.1533157229423523,
-0.2411641925573349,
-0.5107449889183044,
0.5060335993766785,
-0.7732890844345093,
0.3180893361568451,
0.23764042556285858,
-0.5202308893203735,
-0.25222519040107727,
0.5020314455032349,
-0.4902932643890381,
0.5320771932601929,
0.2795517146587372,
-0.7325537204742432,
0.08151363581418991,
-0.7324850559234619,
-0.3303298056125641,
0.13878287374973297,
-0.46400871872901917,
-0.38158950209617615,
0.009142573922872543,
0.2357393205165863,
0.39257553219795227,
-0.19413185119628906,
0.1046932116150856,
-0.47711873054504395,
-0.5101967453956604,
0.3868902623653412,
-0.43432295322418213,
0.5034961104393005,
0.07378675043582916,
-0.24665479362010956,
0.37341752648353577,
-0.5964230298995972,
0.3038232922554016,
0.0569993332028389,
-0.3616333603858948,
-0.5189770460128784,
0.0014071098994463682,
-0.34408581256866455,
0.3041991889476776,
0.03442780300974846,
-0.6890968680381775,
0.06352677941322327,
-0.7453652620315552,
0.3300139307975769,
0.7964794635772705,
0.11580531299114227,
0.5045961737632751,
-0.07662779837846756,
0.6078112721443176,
0.14182426035404205,
-0.1287708729505539,
-0.20900319516658783,
-0.4036422669887543,
-0.6185390949249268,
-0.21770542860031128,
0.3012235462665558,
0.43241000175476074,
-0.7008547782897949,
0.393435001373291,
-0.30038580298423767,
0.011505027301609516,
-0.6146566271781921,
-0.06407570838928223,
0.6549071073532104,
0.47881320118904114,
0.32724684476852417,
-0.5846133232116699,
-0.590437114238739,
-0.6420742273330688,
-0.10775584727525711,
-0.33448049426078796,
-0.2204461395740509,
0.6424496173858643,
0.5429983139038086,
-0.18782742321491241,
0.9075101017951965,
-0.643347978591919,
-0.26689422130584717,
-0.19738639891147614,
0.17559471726417542,
0.10233853757381439,
0.012637441046535969,
0.23569902777671814,
-0.6230162382125854,
-0.3523236811161041,
0.05263606458902359,
-0.8120056986808777,
-0.03376862034201622,
0.13315559923648834,
-0.22769242525100708,
0.0869460329413414,
0.1684408038854599,
-0.7333151698112488,
0.6396539211273193,
0.3773573040962219,
-0.3390634059906006,
0.5982880592346191,
0.06972137838602066,
0.35635337233543396,
-0.8609669804573059,
-0.12803903222084045,
0.02258307673037052,
-0.26423972845077515,
-0.533654510974884,
0.09304051846265793,
-0.2378145158290863,
-0.31500616669654846,
-0.5984378457069397,
0.7315196394920349,
-0.25423797965049744,
-0.13745632767677307,
-0.1778743863105774,
0.6415156722068787,
0.23647893965244293,
0.7815970182418823,
0.06335998326539993,
0.7996804714202881,
0.22723178565502167,
-0.5324599742889404,
0.24750855565071106,
0.533848226070404,
-0.5897568464279175,
0.44708016514778137,
-0.7019168734550476,
0.2906942367553711,
-0.09561537206172943,
0.6088383793830872,
-0.8040072321891785,
-0.086602121591568,
0.528062105178833,
-0.5044658780097961,
0.34434911608695984,
-0.312895268201828,
-0.38961726427078247,
0.007605444639921188,
-0.37230920791625977,
0.4648262560367584,
0.33884140849113464,
-0.5950306057929993,
0.45931440591812134,
0.4357755482196808,
-0.1091672033071518,
-0.612095832824707,
-0.35023239254951477,
0.19300666451454163,
-0.2008548229932785,
-0.9272054433822632,
0.5289533138275146,
0.03735797107219696,
-0.3380652070045471,
0.046397142112255096,
-0.15746049582958221,
0.17027360200881958,
0.05735434964299202,
0.11892972886562347,
0.12275166809558868,
-0.3437648117542267,
0.0950055718421936,
-0.24252872169017792,
-0.25161802768707275,
0.14511822164058685,
-0.4582825303077698,
0.5422186255455017,
-0.43799495697021484,
-0.5491291880607605,
-0.039909981191158295,
0.33889660239219666,
0.24023032188415527,
-0.10439051687717438,
0.7775745391845703,
0.4185219705104828,
-0.3440135419368744,
-0.3672649562358856,
0.10148097574710846,
-0.16659721732139587,
-0.3871056139469147,
0.37164321541786194,
-0.31511521339416504,
-1.088958740234375,
0.39870190620422363,
-0.21010923385620117,
0.0024210105184465647,
0.12276431918144226,
0.6158350706100464,
0.02151712216436863,
1.3655346632003784,
0.24017119407653809,
0.13008776307106018,
0.3160451352596283,
-0.33390092849731445,
0.5871524214744568,
-1.011600136756897,
-0.2123674899339676,
-0.3171631693840027,
-0.07297825068235397,
-0.1197756677865982,
-0.6108716130256653,
0.5907778143882751,
0.02542145550251007,
-0.25438177585601807,
0.17680300772190094,
-0.2238980382680893,
0.2718352675437927,
0.012985552661120892,
0.07551927864551544,
0.30920931696891785,
0.10387583076953888,
-0.24392051994800568,
-0.0347047857940197,
-0.4546475112438202,
-0.8683845400810242,
0.8386251926422119,
0.5318741202354431,
1.0723899602890015,
0.17795541882514954,
0.5160507559776306,
0.4046161472797394,
0.29646581411361694,
-1.0905758142471313,
0.7813448309898376,
-0.11540289223194122,
-0.0597524419426918,
-0.1207335814833641,
-0.5639057755470276,
-0.8300166726112366,
0.5981862545013428,
0.0010939222993329167,
-0.783376157283783,
-0.1793566793203354,
-0.085710309445858,
-0.2830054461956024,
0.25466620922088623,
-0.5484366416931152,
0.7832570672035217,
0.10504144430160522,
-0.010444724932312965,
-0.08337082713842392,
-0.5850445628166199,
0.21159406006336212,
0.26689577102661133,
0.06383734196424484,
-0.07882390916347504,
0.15454432368278503,
0.6032008528709412,
-0.611801266670227,
0.9756477475166321,
-0.39500299096107483,
-0.31038039922714233,
0.3964643180370331,
-0.021398348733782768,
0.5615161061286926,
0.07736271619796753,
-0.12035492807626724,
0.20320206880569458,
-0.28684544563293457,
-0.15360240638256073,
-1.2502505779266357,
0.5899134874343872,
-0.8062961101531982,
-0.7533126473426819,
-0.264514684677124,
-0.4136987328529358,
-0.314309686422348,
-0.13138069212436676,
-0.09664123505353928,
0.7893304228782654,
-0.46987077593803406,
0.07631942629814148,
0.7629097700119019,
-0.3458896577358246,
-0.06932956725358963,
0.4798746705055237,
-0.20123742520809174,
-0.45150503516197205,
0.7642461061477661,
-0.25653359293937683,
0.4570941925048828,
0.43823808431625366,
0.06189821660518646,
-0.26931411027908325,
-0.5566992163658142,
-0.6210641860961914,
-0.049994438886642456,
-1.1257920265197754,
-0.43604686856269836,
-0.6306508779525757,
-0.4558905065059662,
-0.19555780291557312,
0.0998186320066452,
0.09986289590597153,
-0.6302134394645691,
-0.18256515264511108,
-0.27573132514953613,
0.06388478726148605,
0.5797315835952759,
0.3958478569984436,
0.22586213052272797,
-0.5371378660202026,
0.19927623867988586,
-0.0038693195674568415,
0.2718104422092438,
0.02472129836678505,
-0.5353537797927856,
-0.5308400392532349,
0.24714604020118713,
-0.5198659896850586,
-0.6109240055084229,
0.22123238444328308,
0.33570757508277893,
0.5297712683677673,
0.37042418122291565,
0.16411326825618744,
0.7257237434387207,
-0.5768722891807556,
0.7539883852005005,
0.08100791275501251,
-0.896867036819458,
0.43177688121795654,
-0.27522966265678406,
0.3346182405948639,
0.45577189326286316,
0.178563192486763,
-0.3975682556629181,
-0.607214093208313,
-0.2858749330043793,
-0.7706682085990906,
0.8527532815933228,
0.32789346575737,
0.360745370388031,
-0.2849573791027069,
-0.011778886429965496,
-0.010823088698089123,
0.2387414276599884,
-0.8505954146385193,
-0.21690070629119873,
-0.2579461634159088,
-0.2284829318523407,
0.07654422521591187,
0.02776886336505413,
-0.49247902631759644,
-0.01763244904577732,
0.7890914678573608,
-0.38163885474205017,
0.6042007803916931,
0.130504310131073,
-0.2519092559814453,
-0.1309298872947693,
0.6101758480072021,
0.41879886388778687,
0.4698657989501953,
-0.24176643788814545,
0.13922518491744995,
0.05946957692503929,
-0.15879903733730316,
0.17923317849636078,
0.13208115100860596,
0.016064707189798355,
0.03969530016183853,
0.3392604887485504,
1.0391520261764526,
0.3433271050453186,
-0.6998950242996216,
0.9277797937393188,
-0.2934287190437317,
-0.0760624036192894,
-0.2041732370853424,
-0.015275861136615276,
-0.12790529429912567,
0.09209500998258591,
0.20501255989074707,
0.26408088207244873,
0.22613920271396637,
-0.5690239071846008,
0.18238793313503265,
0.6489362120628357,
-0.5400878190994263,
-0.32327505946159363,
0.23517179489135742,
0.21853181719779968,
-0.2017955780029297,
0.45552384853363037,
-0.37943825125694275,
-0.7870131134986877,
0.3594844937324524,
0.6843461394309998,
0.9197363257408142,
-0.1250704675912857,
0.274024099111557,
0.1865982562303543,
-0.08659666031599045,
0.4686508774757385,
0.017123354598879814,
-0.32579338550567627,
-0.7283411622047424,
-0.4807792901992798,
-0.7667803168296814,
-0.514293909072876,
0.24919788539409637,
-0.5427772402763367,
0.27930912375450134,
-0.5245994329452515,
-0.1986646205186844,
-0.16769076883792877,
0.02964787371456623,
-0.4733469486236572,
0.23074033856391907,
0.24939076602458954,
0.8465297222137451,
-0.5714142918586731,
0.5736338496208191,
0.6879245042800903,
-0.24812258780002594,
-0.5361363887786865,
0.025101838633418083,
-0.00672818161547184,
-0.658949077129364,
0.6910737156867981,
0.31198593974113464,
-0.5498009920120239,
-0.44096896052360535,
-0.33791568875312805,
-0.5384253263473511,
0.9066050052642822,
0.4960479736328125,
-0.14471277594566345,
-0.03857484087347984,
0.04066808521747589,
0.7447702884674072,
-0.9233145713806152,
0.6124085783958435,
0.22110383212566376,
0.21266792714595795,
0.30959248542785645,
-0.669694185256958,
0.24871569871902466,
-0.5367558002471924,
-0.002227708464488387,
0.37609902024269104,
-0.23068566620349884,
0.6275144815444946,
-0.14056849479675293,
-0.7353672385215759,
0.16771192848682404,
0.6375166177749634,
0.29225313663482666,
0.3790130913257599,
0.4236309230327606,
0.4326622188091278,
0.5429121255874634,
-0.07356800138950348,
1.079400897026062,
-0.2739145755767822,
0.18890994787216187,
1.252008080482483,
-0.28409889340400696,
0.5982872843742371,
0.22385422885417938,
-0.10666327178478241,
0.8090130090713501,
0.5582326054573059,
0.19807614386081696,
0.619765043258667,
0.5966115593910217,
-0.6387616991996765,
-0.14195455610752106,
-0.11119171977043152,
-0.23626591265201569,
0.2673574686050415,
0.6794605255126953,
-0.46986642479896545,
-0.5855913162231445,
-0.10417595505714417,
0.07688798010349274,
0.23891668021678925,
-0.18360508978366852,
1.028433918952942,
0.35185542702674866,
-0.6959647536277771,
0.7870761752128601,
0.37198540568351746,
0.46421125531196594,
-0.8222004175186157,
-0.41722145676612854,
0.2548794746398926,
0.18096713721752167,
-0.3845052421092987,
-0.7330201268196106,
0.3127562999725342,
0.004641234874725342,
-0.1121044009923935,
-0.25754478573799133,
0.8392680287361145,
-0.5324866771697998,
0.00792115367949009,
0.7229846119880676,
0.24689076840877533,
0.18038006126880646,
0.1359403133392334,
-0.645553708076477,
0.12066890299320221,
-0.18970264494419098,
-0.13238030672073364,
0.4731043577194214,
0.32310983538627625,
-0.2037895768880844,
0.4657248556613922,
0.3793490529060364,
-0.1497834175825119,
-0.25650838017463684,
0.5623703002929688,
1.0848692655563354,
-0.36058199405670166,
-0.40564781427383423,
-0.8583939671516418,
0.3976566791534424,
-0.193020761013031,
-0.06856414675712585,
0.7980037331581116,
0.5060896277427673,
0.8546320199966431,
0.08801791071891785,
0.9940118193626404,
0.09609740227460861,
0.24024485051631927,
-0.6381683945655823,
0.4202619194984436,
-0.14561183750629425,
0.566311776638031,
-0.40840932726860046,
-0.8932648301124573,
-0.19991175830364227,
0.7220352292060852,
-0.5504582524299622,
0.17724022269248962,
0.5939295887947083,
0.7368574738502502,
-0.21416351199150085,
0.24952901899814606,
0.44746798276901245,
0.30914968252182007,
0.4382064938545227,
0.6993899345397949,
1.2027618885040283,
-0.498199462890625,
0.5619929432868958,
0.33883073925971985,
-0.38899338245391846,
-0.018802214413881302,
-0.8178191781044006,
-1.0327221155166626,
-0.46064314246177673,
-0.3989616334438324,
-0.6224273443222046,
0.19501307606697083,
1.0566160678863525,
0.6967132091522217,
-0.7266117334365845,
-0.22448673844337463,
0.19757676124572754,
0.16889268159866333,
-0.018319392576813698,
-0.2948310673236847,
0.25930464267730713,
-0.5423060655593872,
-0.6057324409484863,
0.6373060941696167,
0.49679771065711975,
-0.09115321189165115,
-0.2818874716758728,
-0.5203816890716553,
0.14632706344127655,
0.44540122151374817,
0.8767617344856262,
-0.05834386870265007,
-0.7644612789154053,
-0.4691130518913269,
-0.40467122197151184,
-0.10345500707626343,
0.27549800276756287,
0.9085127711296082,
-0.9284382462501526,
0.5387820601463318,
0.2381843775510788,
0.7163015007972717,
0.5389536619186401,
0.26534324884414673,
0.9507066011428833,
-0.8684858083724976,
-0.1941789984703064,
0.4057982861995697,
0.3657539486885071,
0.5583999752998352,
-0.27743497490882874,
0.44939643144607544,
-0.04179598018527031,
-0.2926173210144043,
-0.6616742014884949,
0.4503166377544403,
-0.780196487903595,
-0.14600831270217896,
1.1378496885299683,
-0.7621930837631226,
-0.1358899623155594,
-0.26954856514930725,
-0.2711339592933655,
-0.016760947182774544,
-0.5668914914131165,
0.5829814672470093,
0.8452065587043762,
-0.15688163042068481,
0.33456945419311523,
-0.2397049516439438,
0.38584384322166443,
0.15463125705718994,
-0.7194005846977234,
0.01768922060728073,
0.5510806441307068,
0.08487015962600708,
0.2372254878282547,
0.7863140106201172,
-0.3985443115234375,
0.14837348461151123,
-0.25550732016563416,
-0.23719875514507294,
-0.12293906509876251,
-0.3809331953525543,
-0.5623347163200378,
0.22352463006973267,
-0.11651584506034851,
-0.051676638424396515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01104v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01104v1
|
SentiCSE: A Sentiment-aware Contrastive Sentence Embedding Framework with Sentiment-guided Textual Similarity
| 2024-04-01T13:24:20 | 2024-04-01T13:24:20 |
Jaemin Kim, Yohan Na, Kangmin Kim, Sang Rak Lee, Dong-Kyu Chae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recently, sentiment-aware pre-trained language models (PLMs) demonstrate
impressive results in downstream sentiment analysis tasks. However, they
neglect to evaluate the quality of their constructed sentiment representations;
they just focus on improving the fine-tuning performance, which overshadows the
representation quality. We argue that without guaranteeing the representation
quality, their downstream performance can be highly dependent on the
supervision of the fine-tuning data rather than representation quality. This
problem would make them difficult to foray into other sentiment-related
domains, especially where labeled data is scarce. We first propose
Sentiment-guided Textual Similarity (SgTS), a novel metric for evaluating the
quality of sentiment representations, which is designed based on the degree of
equivalence in sentiment polarity between two sentences. We then propose
SentiCSE, a novel Sentiment-aware Contrastive Sentence Embedding framework for
constructing sentiment representations via combined word-level and
sentence-level objectives, whose quality is guaranteed by SgTS. Qualitative and
quantitative comparison with the previous sentiment-aware PLMs shows the
superiority of our work. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/nayohan/SentiCSE
|
[
-0.3160580098628998,
-0.127557635307312,
0.5570165514945984,
0.4542957842350006,
-0.5574119687080383,
0.13344021141529083,
-0.41345110535621643,
-0.02154327556490898,
0.48742178082466125,
0.6614383459091187,
-0.6678043603897095,
-0.7963228225708008,
-0.7349817752838135,
0.20410998165607452,
-0.10539311915636063,
1.0384994745254517,
0.004472175147384405,
0.18710720539093018,
-0.43741634488105774,
-0.5816055536270142,
-0.2441919893026352,
-0.3714210093021393,
-0.44426771998405457,
-0.15050646662712097,
0.43283259868621826,
0.16701391339302063,
0.7043041586875916,
0.2883022129535675,
0.7038193345069885,
0.27560484409332275,
-0.14166554808616638,
0.07026251405477524,
-0.30463874340057373,
0.33491218090057373,
-0.2569804787635803,
-0.608938455581665,
-0.4396210014820099,
0.39902374148368835,
0.3551103472709656,
0.5927757024765015,
0.012556809931993484,
-0.17340946197509766,
0.44436416029930115,
0.8462154865264893,
-0.5582728385925293,
0.10255466401576996,
-0.43028274178504944,
0.1308993101119995,
0.04929791018366814,
-0.14309574663639069,
-0.3790924549102783,
-0.6493601202964783,
0.18658708035945892,
-0.5691778063774109,
-0.1216796264052391,
0.042594414204359055,
0.756625235080719,
0.5766647458076477,
-0.365833580493927,
-0.4986039102077484,
-0.14678242802619934,
0.924412190914154,
-0.9051027894020081,
0.29076263308525085,
0.12129616737365723,
-0.06307867914438248,
0.1276714950799942,
-0.7047234773635864,
-0.3127100467681885,
-0.14097529649734497,
-0.16334012150764465,
0.756931722164154,
-0.012755653820931911,
0.1528843492269516,
0.06542112678289413,
0.5819687843322754,
-0.6489644050598145,
-0.15084004402160645,
0.26944786310195923,
0.022190287709236145,
0.16599734127521515,
0.024483030661940575,
0.13163097202777863,
-0.3608417510986328,
-0.5063928365707397,
-0.0992664024233818,
-0.6662134528160095,
0.03620219975709915,
0.43629616498947144,
0.4671187698841095,
-0.30269891023635864,
0.39521121978759766,
-0.006179539021104574,
0.31453409790992737,
0.04941042140126228,
0.37438514828681946,
0.5605946779251099,
-0.15053994953632355,
-0.20774787664413452,
-0.2764579653739929,
0.8684952259063721,
0.5859610438346863,
0.5112581849098206,
-0.21352888643741608,
-0.34189847111701965,
0.3747550845146179,
0.305859237909317,
-0.9587560892105103,
-0.2183474749326706,
0.2712201476097107,
-0.6301010251045227,
-0.4943910837173462,
0.31322723627090454,
-0.713407576084137,
-0.38495969772338867,
-0.3103289008140564,
0.17185793817043304,
-0.31711792945861816,
-0.223544180393219,
0.0866369679570198,
-0.13302859663963318,
0.09963233768939972,
-0.0773039385676384,
-0.5889291763305664,
0.2404545545578003,
0.8545556664466858,
0.8134099245071411,
0.04951629787683487,
-0.14439645409584045,
-0.6814672350883484,
-0.17045708000659943,
-0.475909024477005,
0.8167269229888916,
-0.8703262209892273,
-0.36208927631378174,
0.0757349506020546,
-0.22321252524852753,
0.043770838528871536,
-0.6766071319580078,
0.629153311252594,
-0.4263787567615509,
0.5529317259788513,
-0.48996543884277344,
-0.8518213033676147,
-0.05780862644314766,
0.3792608976364136,
-0.5186089277267456,
0.8654714822769165,
0.16335906088352203,
-1.055938720703125,
0.4053657352924347,
-0.40861454606056213,
-0.34084352850914,
-0.08631046116352081,
-0.24586623907089233,
-0.4678521454334259,
0.18699084222316742,
0.3781278133392334,
0.6351351737976074,
-0.08694157749414444,
0.12954916059970856,
-0.444945365190506,
-0.4923422634601593,
0.19907766580581665,
-0.21862004697322845,
0.5901080965995789,
0.14477179944515228,
-0.055026695132255554,
0.3179475665092468,
-0.4808734655380249,
-0.03492583706974983,
-0.4113515317440033,
-0.18296074867248535,
-0.5495092272758484,
0.06027549132704735,
-0.06785935908555984,
0.18882524967193604,
0.3204679787158966,
-0.7355671525001526,
-0.10974299162626266,
-0.9320834279060364,
0.45860588550567627,
0.7439162731170654,
-0.12156850099563599,
0.7632954120635986,
-0.20104065537452698,
0.5185964703559875,
0.43673962354660034,
0.16075417399406433,
-0.1601451188325882,
-0.1394314467906952,
-0.40570738911628723,
-0.4202392101287842,
0.30348384380340576,
0.6318327188491821,
-0.7624390721321106,
0.5816311836242676,
-0.30794742703437805,
-0.18490195274353027,
-0.7152717113494873,
0.16304992139339447,
0.28075459599494934,
0.17996659874916077,
0.39439865946769714,
-0.36476802825927734,
-0.5276196599006653,
-0.8990060091018677,
-0.5599786639213562,
-0.11990375071763992,
-0.01167957205325365,
0.31358855962753296,
0.18950407207012177,
-0.3105681836605072,
0.855057954788208,
-0.4960242509841919,
-0.29824063181877136,
-0.25480714440345764,
0.05318356305360794,
0.18099290132522583,
0.472627192735672,
0.668668806552887,
-0.5715493559837341,
-0.4999440610408783,
-0.1594248265028,
-0.9142060875892639,
-0.2715827226638794,
0.06751720607280731,
-0.2114579677581787,
-0.1476401388645172,
0.854607343673706,
-0.5358241200447083,
-0.11231837421655655,
0.7173792719841003,
-0.3873659670352936,
0.24656732380390167,
-0.05279058590531349,
0.40807589888572693,
-1.500866174697876,
-0.1189054325222969,
0.12794721126556396,
-0.45088034868240356,
-0.11584090441465378,
0.006606903858482838,
0.004886401817202568,
-0.3318125009536743,
-0.18994897603988647,
0.1490401178598404,
-0.3103145956993103,
0.0071161589585244656,
-0.2661454975605011,
0.3669043481349945,
0.19301266968250275,
0.5320283770561218,
-0.18924714624881744,
0.8105318546295166,
0.6475552916526794,
-0.08863426744937897,
0.16448578238487244,
0.17926552891731262,
-0.1332586109638214,
1.0330543518066406,
-0.7656272053718567,
-0.12812432646751404,
-0.19331203401088715,
0.16562607884407043,
-0.6242743134498596,
0.1253185123205185,
0.43683022260665894,
-0.41537171602249146,
0.2553682327270508,
-0.0700017437338829,
-0.32908615469932556,
-0.2647090554237366,
-0.8436450958251953,
0.23896601796150208,
0.4492547810077667,
-0.4962311387062073,
0.5794849991798401,
0.034935642033815384,
-0.3956244885921478,
-0.7509575486183167,
-0.8759915232658386,
-0.01581588014960289,
-0.37119680643081665,
-0.38554197549819946,
0.3581480383872986,
-0.07181035727262497,
-0.08760898560285568,
0.28822624683380127,
-0.0750349834561348,
0.11424721032381058,
-0.03655261546373367,
0.3284800052642822,
-0.10200148820877075,
-0.39530929923057556,
0.23268567025661469,
0.38033440709114075,
-0.2857820987701416,
0.21002493798732758,
-0.4122184216976166,
0.2655410170555115,
-0.21858817338943481,
-0.300690621137619,
-0.2509830892086029,
0.4509553611278534,
0.5493769645690918,
-0.34475019574165344,
0.7347617745399475,
0.53816157579422,
-0.25436878204345703,
-0.27688562870025635,
-0.2803204357624054,
-0.18135903775691986,
-0.5036837458610535,
0.18398432433605194,
-0.34701600670814514,
-1.1206917762756348,
0.4985664486885071,
-0.24982671439647675,
-0.11042914539575577,
0.20933282375335693,
0.11492636054754257,
-0.45666930079460144,
0.7524529099464417,
0.6400869488716125,
-0.16547149419784546,
0.5565612316131592,
0.009090336039662361,
0.3299638032913208,
-0.7511497139930725,
-0.00016270697233267128,
-0.4757716953754425,
-0.14910055696964264,
-0.8467596769332886,
-0.3613549470901489,
0.09985902905464172,
0.09912445396184921,
-0.3687969148159027,
0.19259828329086304,
-0.4283551275730133,
0.4554850459098816,
0.36712905764579773,
0.3151656985282898,
-0.017074625939130783,
-0.07971211522817612,
-0.017357438802719116,
-0.4265846908092499,
-0.6422594785690308,
-0.6977313160896301,
0.8233160376548767,
0.2237023264169693,
0.5849666595458984,
-0.2138095498085022,
0.8696279525756836,
0.4522315263748169,
0.2968321442604065,
-0.6068741083145142,
0.6146108508110046,
-0.7953096628189087,
0.08257192373275757,
0.29349616169929504,
-0.5428457260131836,
-0.690191388130188,
0.22955194115638733,
-0.13487635552883148,
-0.1828230619430542,
0.2561069428920746,
-0.012891153804957867,
-0.19181951880455017,
0.12007100880146027,
-0.614084005355835,
0.9211954474449158,
0.2154885083436966,
-0.2494412362575531,
-0.5093018412590027,
-0.6240631341934204,
-0.10447974503040314,
0.331311970949173,
-0.024356530979275703,
-0.04151076823472977,
-0.14794152975082397,
0.83125901222229,
-0.41066235303878784,
0.8554586172103882,
-0.27872252464294434,
0.07620823383331299,
0.30355820059776306,
-0.015112551860511303,
0.21229183673858643,
0.13053229451179504,
-0.17017336189746857,
-0.145385280251503,
-0.2157265990972519,
-0.6404553651809692,
-0.8030610680580139,
1.214900016784668,
-0.524411678314209,
-0.400802344083786,
-0.25563016533851624,
-0.3082047998905182,
-0.32580575346946716,
0.015130056999623775,
0.15913069248199463,
0.5383590459823608,
-0.34041813015937805,
0.142525315284729,
0.5767706632614136,
-0.3247159421443939,
0.5123339891433716,
0.06671624630689621,
0.08124131709337234,
-0.643743097782135,
1.0026800632476807,
-0.18885841965675354,
-0.15311752259731293,
0.3967823386192322,
0.03554597496986389,
-0.29918181896209717,
-0.3216697573661804,
-0.27303585410118103,
0.30157214403152466,
-0.7986719608306885,
-0.3480185866355896,
-0.42847657203674316,
0.18072554469108582,
-0.1729276329278946,
-0.5597081184387207,
-0.6185736656188965,
-0.06231136992573738,
-0.5312982797622681,
-0.11565133184194565,
0.37596744298934937,
0.7945262789726257,
-0.04214613884687424,
0.28765571117401123,
-0.7470170855522156,
0.10912133753299713,
0.08286961913108826,
0.7628671526908875,
-0.2932092845439911,
-0.24168068170547485,
-0.2089320719242096,
-0.019159281626343727,
-0.12109384685754776,
-0.804719090461731,
0.19322583079338074,
0.01596887782216072,
0.305417001247406,
0.4299500286579132,
0.04026658833026886,
0.10136453807353973,
-0.10876718163490295,
0.8736332654953003,
0.12747327983379364,
-1.1321446895599365,
0.6853547692298889,
-0.29864007234573364,
0.1829921305179596,
0.8654441237449646,
0.2245340496301651,
-0.2063732147216797,
-0.6259077787399292,
-0.5051479339599609,
-0.7095279693603516,
0.32834580540657043,
0.25122496485710144,
0.3501492440700531,
-0.2587345540523529,
0.45536065101623535,
0.18058709800243378,
0.4323674440383911,
-0.858667254447937,
-0.0297690499573946,
-0.5023032426834106,
-0.7696764469146729,
-0.0908351019024849,
-0.2746577262878418,
0.4282018840312958,
0.23500894010066986,
0.6146916151046753,
-0.07300375401973724,
0.2131890207529068,
0.28851112723350525,
-0.23716770112514496,
0.12783314287662506,
0.4472085237503052,
0.05410037934780121,
-0.061595939099788666,
-0.12835976481437683,
0.12375546991825104,
-0.05344018340110779,
-0.2627204358577728,
-0.06929585337638855,
0.12255226820707321,
-0.16013379395008087,
-0.07695931196212769,
0.42619025707244873,
0.641101062297821,
0.2888030707836151,
-0.5035421848297119,
0.8416385650634766,
0.17184790968894958,
0.0663047805428505,
0.18311993777751923,
-0.12572108209133148,
0.21017198264598846,
0.4068934917449951,
-0.11364027857780457,
0.3205436170101166,
0.19794511795043945,
-0.4387797713279724,
0.15516826510429382,
0.43074947595596313,
-0.7624495625495911,
-0.2623973488807678,
0.5347006320953369,
0.664871871471405,
-0.14434099197387695,
0.5225091576576233,
-0.33235594630241394,
-0.6929915547370911,
0.46534204483032227,
0.059666652232408524,
0.8491426110267639,
-0.17987923324108124,
0.2849481403827667,
0.3202207684516907,
0.24914918839931488,
-0.021286223083734512,
0.47799211740493774,
0.0435432568192482,
-0.6189295649528503,
-0.47645100951194763,
-0.34450897574424744,
-0.31063809990882874,
-0.41290783882141113,
-0.8381512761116028,
0.06162097677588463,
-0.3977382481098175,
-0.1554046869277954,
-0.4531475007534027,
-0.03320753946900368,
-0.4715842306613922,
0.4726821780204773,
0.04564785212278366,
0.7372219562530518,
-1.0101914405822754,
0.2843332290649414,
0.8015059232711792,
-0.37953981757164,
-0.43492183089256287,
0.2438553124666214,
-0.5241329669952393,
-0.25035470724105835,
0.17047752439975739,
0.404023677110672,
-0.48907533288002014,
0.06013382971286774,
-0.4351150393486023,
-0.20668601989746094,
0.8717227578163147,
0.4599822461605072,
-0.5542174577713013,
0.429768830537796,
0.11389392614364624,
0.8458684682846069,
-0.5742658972740173,
0.25918111205101013,
0.33157792687416077,
0.1586112380027771,
-0.49897637963294983,
-0.24061939120292664,
0.14690570533275604,
-0.3907637298107147,
-0.08992773294448853,
0.07061752676963806,
-0.7043902277946472,
0.43434789776802063,
-0.10437659919261932,
-0.17935030162334442,
-0.060721516609191895,
0.875650942325592,
-0.12772643566131592,
0.40700533986091614,
0.3107616901397705,
0.7901538014411926,
0.6376451253890991,
-0.20313005149364471,
0.9587823748588562,
-0.3453981876373291,
0.31796905398368835,
1.0182914733886719,
-0.3369680941104889,
1.0141665935516357,
0.35859209299087524,
0.03733430057764053,
0.9463022947311401,
0.4373489320278168,
0.1778516322374344,
0.7949420213699341,
0.0859101414680481,
-0.28326067328453064,
-0.2622828781604767,
-0.1014193668961525,
-0.3121124505996704,
0.23861011862754822,
0.31971651315689087,
-0.6214172840118408,
-0.04886166378855705,
0.19481602311134338,
-0.3359632194042206,
0.7434694170951843,
-0.2543877065181732,
0.816898763179779,
0.35754692554473877,
-0.5087655186653137,
0.09334542602300644,
-0.21972669661045074,
1.0250205993652344,
-0.2837250232696533,
0.26810842752456665,
-0.5955483317375183,
0.01588556356728077,
-0.22391203045845032,
-1.0555416345596313,
0.5087341070175171,
0.04726141691207886,
-0.2387809455394745,
-0.39827486872673035,
0.7339928150177002,
-0.4638527035713196,
-0.15827389061450958,
0.6007015109062195,
0.8156824707984924,
-0.11145849525928497,
-0.14001396298408508,
-0.7639248967170715,
0.005942749325186014,
-0.04680269584059715,
-0.5105020403862,
0.1502581685781479,
0.5840038657188416,
0.3347780108451843,
0.6697787642478943,
0.1764562875032425,
0.004886356182396412,
-0.3974832594394684,
0.6612111330032349,
0.8944478631019592,
-0.7743948101997375,
-0.7902894020080566,
-0.8704543709754944,
0.2856277525424957,
-0.17112810909748077,
-0.2919537127017975,
0.47486403584480286,
0.5639245510101318,
0.5609504580497742,
-0.11358951777219772,
0.5985831022262573,
0.5031824707984924,
0.5324145555496216,
-0.46009930968284607,
0.6158332824707031,
-0.5224743485450745,
0.2971477806568146,
-0.34345489740371704,
-1.0560359954833984,
-0.42042502760887146,
0.7512127757072449,
-0.3293149471282959,
0.05151386186480522,
0.7585872411727905,
0.9691268801689148,
-0.24302616715431213,
0.14113183319568634,
0.10514399409294128,
0.2724706530570984,
-0.029246019199490547,
0.5761404633522034,
0.8100007772445679,
-0.461640864610672,
0.49331361055374146,
0.061363380402326584,
0.03908100351691246,
0.18304508924484253,
-0.8320972323417664,
-0.9843019247055054,
-0.42088592052459717,
-0.7068619132041931,
-0.30679214000701904,
0.34145495295524597,
0.9376698732376099,
0.37623536586761475,
-0.7723219394683838,
0.20175530016422272,
-0.48463889956474304,
-0.08440933376550674,
-0.005879456177353859,
-0.20512771606445312,
0.32179298996925354,
-0.3218362033367157,
-0.5754043459892273,
0.23933045566082,
0.5432291030883789,
-0.01145205833017826,
0.05144651606678963,
-0.13659460842609406,
0.2637619972229004,
0.34223002195358276,
0.6064507365226746,
-0.3019779324531555,
-0.625803530216217,
-0.29410600662231445,
-0.12154287099838257,
-0.5657086372375488,
0.13644996285438538,
1.0480799674987793,
-0.8650373220443726,
0.1193188950419426,
0.5333763360977173,
0.6583683490753174,
0.08853739500045776,
0.07612194120883942,
0.48672714829444885,
-0.8731006383895874,
0.08908873051404953,
0.45966336131095886,
0.5086983442306519,
0.7715557813644409,
-0.15155991911888123,
0.2681300640106201,
0.14944560825824738,
-0.3893680274486542,
-0.4192766547203064,
0.28144344687461853,
-1.3410985469818115,
-0.3910667300224304,
1.0124539136886597,
-0.509063720703125,
0.20288942754268646,
0.2038855254650116,
-0.28657597303390503,
0.35802680253982544,
-0.40732282400131226,
0.5074031949043274,
0.5936945676803589,
0.29928162693977356,
-0.20941081643104553,
0.12617142498493195,
0.49254125356674194,
0.9020783305168152,
-0.8880437016487122,
0.1520797610282898,
0.4371735155582428,
0.18895691633224487,
-0.10904254764318466,
0.4835275411605835,
-0.10252109169960022,
0.08618882298469543,
0.21300527453422546,
-0.12655261158943176,
0.15017089247703552,
0.06681820005178452,
-0.39973652362823486,
0.4401272237300873,
0.039402928203344345,
-0.2161746472120285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01361v1
|
LLM Attributor: Interactive Visual Attribution for LLM Generation
| 2024-04-01T13:16:34 | 2024-04-01T13:16:34 |
Seongmin Lee, Zijie J. Wang, Aishwarya Chakravarthy, Alec Helbling, ShengYun Peng, Mansi Phute, Duen Horng Chau, Minsuk Kahng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
While large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capability to
generate convincing text across diverse domains, concerns around its potential
risks have highlighted the importance of understanding the rationale behind
text generation. We present LLM Attributor, a Python library that provides
interactive visualizations for training data attribution of an LLM's text
generation. Our library offers a new way to quickly attribute an LLM's text
generation to training data points to inspect model behaviors, enhance its
trustworthiness, and compare model-generated text with user-provided text. We
describe the visual and interactive design of our tool and highlight usage
scenarios for LLaMA2 models fine-tuned with two different datasets: online
articles about recent disasters and finance-related question-answer pairs.
Thanks to LLM Attributor's broad support for computational notebooks, users can
easily integrate it into their workflow to interactively visualize attributions
of their models. For easier access and extensibility, we open-source LLM
Attributor at https://github.com/poloclub/ LLM-Attribution. The video demo is
available at https://youtu.be/mIG2MDQKQxM.
|
[
0.16359882056713104,
-0.7919980883598328,
0.6369518637657166,
0.4165298640727997,
-0.2816106379032135,
0.14791613817214966,
-0.07826250046491623,
-0.3180738687515259,
0.024986667558550835,
0.48320236802101135,
-0.3974170386791229,
-0.3834741711616516,
-0.4099445343017578,
-0.10931583493947983,
-0.7188003063201904,
1.0823229551315308,
-0.19328348338603973,
-0.306940495967865,
-0.8124233484268188,
0.3626839220523834,
-0.030490312725305557,
-0.511708676815033,
-0.9291405081748962,
-0.7505572438240051,
0.7896291613578796,
0.3327483832836151,
0.594049334526062,
0.7102617621421814,
0.4933195114135742,
0.3442175090312958,
-0.015858305618166924,
-0.21475881338119507,
-0.5737848877906799,
0.30647942423820496,
-0.08833236992359161,
-0.5934247970581055,
-0.4810684025287628,
-0.1141984686255455,
0.5486534833908081,
0.23452302813529968,
-0.17728379368782043,
0.580843448638916,
0.08546116203069687,
0.26629823446273804,
-0.5367685556411743,
0.24971537292003632,
-0.7421186566352844,
-0.20928670465946198,
-0.37606510519981384,
-0.5049044489860535,
-0.3885141909122467,
-0.7980993986129761,
0.04671356827020645,
-0.6106938719749451,
-0.05529548600316048,
0.19057908654212952,
0.5708677172660828,
0.5141851305961609,
-0.7125164270401001,
-0.48023438453674316,
-0.36918750405311584,
0.6879276037216187,
-0.42396894097328186,
-0.12910860776901245,
0.23010419309139252,
0.38181179761886597,
-0.057437896728515625,
-0.984826385974884,
-0.42222023010253906,
-0.19973503053188324,
0.015984676778316498,
0.05079444870352745,
-0.4117904007434845,
-0.28097063302993774,
0.1433912068605423,
0.21772527694702148,
-0.37099945545196533,
0.23046287894248962,
-0.26609814167022705,
-0.25569358468055725,
0.6049210429191589,
0.38898494839668274,
0.22660906612873077,
-0.2389218509197235,
-0.43085506558418274,
-0.26060473918914795,
-1.0041539669036865,
-0.07272084802389145,
0.825457751750946,
-0.09584076702594757,
-0.3478221297264099,
0.826235830783844,
0.2664465308189392,
0.5701055526733398,
-0.43282514810562134,
-0.1706314980983734,
0.10438545793294907,
-0.18226490914821625,
0.12268108874559402,
0.4330843389034271,
0.9452998638153076,
0.6461579203605652,
0.5508030652999878,
0.30042800307273865,
-0.3207195997238159,
-0.07276039570569992,
0.2678813338279724,
-0.9801328182220459,
-0.5964211821556091,
0.07482487708330154,
-0.41144677996635437,
-1.0017757415771484,
-0.182741180062294,
-0.6153203248977661,
-0.7908848524093628,
-0.0028816894628107548,
0.19189463555812836,
-0.1532622128725052,
-0.18697908520698547,
-0.201730877161026,
-0.27414652705192566,
0.06906743347644806,
0.4765138030052185,
-0.7194607853889465,
0.12001247704029083,
0.4178749620914459,
0.902584433555603,
-0.3147581219673157,
-0.22266936302185059,
-0.6767492890357971,
0.6193073987960815,
-0.11645667254924774,
0.9440475702285767,
-0.4301709830760956,
-0.2758003771305084,
0.16204072535037994,
-0.32662683725357056,
0.2766963541507721,
-0.5296432375907898,
0.1477532684803009,
-0.29992783069610596,
-0.035528600215911865,
0.0005028672167100012,
-0.4381764829158783,
-0.05708089843392372,
0.28612297773361206,
-0.7611024975776672,
1.029927372932434,
-0.041386157274246216,
-0.9618277549743652,
0.32329922914505005,
-0.6785739660263062,
-0.29177436232566833,
0.11010375618934631,
-0.3728552758693695,
-0.7305536270141602,
-0.056221358478069305,
0.03985429182648659,
0.43482035398483276,
-0.28239622712135315,
0.3050522804260254,
-0.4613994359970093,
-0.1286049336194992,
0.844373881816864,
-0.7030597925186157,
0.8499984741210938,
0.20105040073394775,
0.10767219215631485,
0.41887786984443665,
-0.9808928966522217,
-0.2138848751783371,
0.45550188422203064,
-0.6053850650787354,
-0.25328704714775085,
0.24630890786647797,
0.48957791924476624,
-0.17604628205299377,
0.4607420563697815,
-0.2581755220890045,
0.3088858127593994,
-0.0440901480615139,
0.6029042601585388,
0.7824257612228394,
0.12151887267827988,
0.14363574981689453,
-0.29663580656051636,
0.7784377336502075,
-0.047309357672929764,
-0.12257567793130875,
-0.2173316925764084,
-0.5107528567314148,
-0.7263562083244324,
-0.23554950952529907,
-0.002144240541383624,
0.6867269277572632,
-0.7112734913825989,
0.006010903045535088,
-0.10479145497083664,
-0.43606075644493103,
-0.2726723849773407,
0.19958312809467316,
0.20649711787700653,
0.5147140026092529,
0.010458070784807205,
-0.014392540790140629,
-0.5956354737281799,
-0.8376351594924927,
-0.27341750264167786,
-0.5388479828834534,
-0.27015987038612366,
0.22166478633880615,
0.7162405848503113,
-0.2305094450712204,
0.9917961359024048,
-0.7121999859809875,
0.028691982850432396,
-0.4513551592826843,
0.4222927987575531,
-0.04804495349526405,
0.36559009552001953,
0.7813343405723572,
-0.43344375491142273,
-0.4787994921207428,
0.027540521696209908,
-0.7446174025535583,
-0.48480767011642456,
-0.30662626028060913,
0.013683609664440155,
0.049669671803712845,
0.5570356249809265,
-0.44917047023773193,
0.37782561779022217,
0.46686848998069763,
-0.2714412212371826,
0.5728694200515747,
-0.15319964289665222,
-0.0730900764465332,
-1.2413665056228638,
0.22671212255954742,
-0.09991557896137238,
-0.4411262273788452,
-0.525639533996582,
-0.23523668944835663,
0.005228283815085888,
-0.2592662572860718,
-0.5927689075469971,
0.7567835450172424,
-0.23907360434532166,
-0.025937777012586594,
-0.21427994966506958,
0.20792442560195923,
-0.10443713515996933,
-0.02091137133538723,
-0.05103791877627373,
0.8172580599784851,
0.6282085180282593,
-0.2066194862127304,
0.9634828567504883,
0.42628219723701477,
-0.5601459741592407,
0.27813729643821716,
-0.7253396511077881,
-0.012354064732789993,
0.19080772995948792,
0.23638612031936646,
-0.9197614789009094,
-0.4776228666305542,
0.4001363217830658,
-0.36724457144737244,
0.07885068655014038,
-0.18124055862426758,
-0.6545091867446899,
-0.19612079858779907,
-0.5892255306243896,
0.505472719669342,
0.2719750702381134,
-0.6950292587280273,
0.5234959125518799,
0.07922974228858948,
-0.42279937863349915,
-0.3720014691352844,
-0.9612374901771545,
0.18899616599082947,
-0.759451150894165,
-0.6536340117454529,
0.09048530459403992,
0.021563738584518433,
-0.5200181007385254,
-0.03755520284175873,
0.29432904720306396,
0.01330967154353857,
0.30347031354904175,
0.450307160615921,
0.39754003286361694,
0.02181101217865944,
-0.010705258697271347,
-0.06016038358211517,
-0.30935558676719666,
0.48509925603866577,
0.07721063494682312,
0.42208144068717957,
-0.10446509718894958,
-0.3864973187446594,
-0.1610374003648758,
0.17619018256664276,
0.14281244575977325,
-0.05430019274353981,
0.8029770851135254,
0.5007349848747253,
-0.2587728798389435,
-0.08412183076143265,
-0.35604730248451233,
-0.022576842457056046,
-0.5517760515213013,
0.3345097303390503,
-0.07385629415512085,
-0.6719304323196411,
0.7099133133888245,
-0.08815368264913559,
-0.12018691003322601,
0.3121564984321594,
1.0759937763214111,
-0.05574170500040054,
0.7717827558517456,
0.7605533003807068,
-0.058375611901283264,
0.7376669049263,
-0.05346370115876198,
0.05818952992558479,
-0.4820915162563324,
-0.41999176144599915,
-0.3129453659057617,
-0.08934037387371063,
-0.24652047455310822,
-0.2260269820690155,
0.3098878264427185,
0.05509636923670769,
-0.20183753967285156,
0.05684356391429901,
-0.1925773173570633,
0.6919460892677307,
0.5313712954521179,
-0.20675605535507202,
0.4620197117328644,
0.15398351848125458,
0.23109641671180725,
-0.009634966030716896,
-0.4879016876220703,
-0.8307909369468689,
1.193884015083313,
0.4227113723754883,
1.4311997890472412,
0.1277313083410263,
0.780206561088562,
0.3783668279647827,
0.6108797192573547,
-0.7652088403701782,
0.47446557879447937,
0.27209410071372986,
-0.32168251276016235,
-0.0798635333776474,
-0.516594409942627,
-0.7934556007385254,
-0.17570386826992035,
-0.2740814685821533,
-0.9237292408943176,
-0.3080148696899414,
0.631049394607544,
-0.37526363134384155,
0.25785568356513977,
-0.6085842251777649,
0.9644737243652344,
-0.38532647490501404,
-0.42965710163116455,
-0.059347495436668396,
-0.33071640133857727,
0.5290788412094116,
-0.32809576392173767,
-0.017472820356488228,
0.12509751319885254,
-0.2455061823129654,
0.668372631072998,
-0.4242117404937744,
1.0087023973464966,
0.14784149825572968,
-0.5631643533706665,
0.46849575638771057,
0.129013329744339,
0.7679030895233154,
0.21493332087993622,
-0.12371190637350082,
-0.18927913904190063,
-0.25242480635643005,
0.07540927082300186,
-0.44173067808151245,
0.8245567679405212,
-0.6383330821990967,
-0.4048559367656708,
-0.3772985339164734,
-0.6712778210639954,
0.34514567255973816,
0.17579393088817596,
0.24359042942523956,
0.34061160683631897,
-0.16830649971961975,
0.24401773512363434,
0.3367311656475067,
-0.45744889974594116,
0.27930694818496704,
0.231612890958786,
-0.47183671593666077,
-0.4642440974712372,
1.2982196807861328,
-0.3150799572467804,
0.24980232119560242,
0.19875827431678772,
0.18974317610263824,
-0.3736998736858368,
-0.5203998684883118,
-0.3578544855117798,
0.13237133622169495,
-1.0619378089904785,
-0.34032145142555237,
-0.31222063302993774,
-0.1485278159379959,
-0.21394479274749756,
-0.5059987306594849,
-0.2675704061985016,
-0.5714074969291687,
-0.6605582237243652,
-0.20569172501564026,
0.8423978090286255,
0.8748677968978882,
0.07411405444145203,
0.6354408264160156,
-0.4605002701282501,
0.1093168556690216,
0.22589454054832458,
0.1178249940276146,
-0.13434813916683197,
-0.3355409502983093,
-0.2557806074619293,
-0.39823055267333984,
-0.7472641468048096,
-0.8863661289215088,
0.34162962436676025,
0.2337888777256012,
0.45347288250923157,
0.6106627583503723,
-0.02692450024187565,
0.5305740833282471,
-0.41655033826828003,
0.7858393788337708,
0.4132522940635681,
-0.8294690847396851,
0.6884380578994751,
-0.25351670384407043,
-0.03313346207141876,
0.23266804218292236,
0.38317713141441345,
-0.2815408706665039,
-0.7153130173683167,
-0.417353093624115,
-1.0050582885742188,
0.5288733839988708,
0.43731367588043213,
-0.047397784888744354,
0.11722025275230408,
0.20596930384635925,
-0.02594015933573246,
0.25439608097076416,
-1.0765395164489746,
-0.23487403988838196,
-0.4457820951938629,
-0.5329169034957886,
-0.09827592223882675,
-0.28141698241233826,
-0.23843634128570557,
-0.0011823278618976474,
0.6088669300079346,
-0.22975151240825653,
0.0833684504032135,
-0.29929518699645996,
-0.23587961494922638,
-0.15764161944389343,
0.1370871663093567,
0.5018284916877747,
0.6028029322624207,
-0.30196377635002136,
0.34661585092544556,
0.1748732030391693,
-0.27870047092437744,
0.10512876510620117,
0.2006312906742096,
-0.16459421813488007,
-0.3174014091491699,
0.7205470204353333,
0.7457394003868103,
0.07033726572990417,
-0.8622995615005493,
0.7373098731040955,
0.03449958562850952,
-0.3007117211818695,
-0.5749618411064148,
0.10544668138027191,
0.377076655626297,
0.5830588936805725,
0.19273366034030914,
-0.33343541622161865,
0.2668863832950592,
-0.5232831835746765,
0.06672649830579758,
0.3761112093925476,
-0.04243423789739609,
-0.13713568449020386,
1.1811503171920776,
0.29984861612319946,
-0.22621136903762817,
0.6975427865982056,
0.17719127237796783,
-0.5359335541725159,
0.5491929054260254,
0.7692689895629883,
0.8290027379989624,
0.0036507288459688425,
0.036992352455854416,
0.10555195808410645,
0.20435693860054016,
0.14028599858283997,
0.24111546576023102,
0.051042042672634125,
-0.4203038513660431,
-0.33067402243614197,
-0.5198826193809509,
-0.5740465521812439,
0.15073181688785553,
-0.5795872807502747,
0.3796226680278778,
-0.16716007888317108,
-0.3030622601509094,
-0.20423820614814758,
-0.30608636140823364,
-0.25037193298339844,
-0.16189813613891602,
0.4659585654735565,
0.6811028718948364,
-0.9117453098297119,
0.9050143361091614,
0.8160932660102844,
-0.3574081063270569,
-0.347110778093338,
-0.16350030899047852,
0.2878836393356323,
-0.8817306160926819,
0.7039881348609924,
0.3128840923309326,
-0.1393231898546219,
0.08869015425443649,
-0.8004549741744995,
-0.6492325067520142,
1.3051377534866333,
0.6714953184127808,
-0.36638665199279785,
0.07880973070859909,
0.43677279353141785,
0.27035269141197205,
-0.3752641975879669,
0.36020126938819885,
0.4205942749977112,
0.4505428373813629,
0.06495203822851181,
-0.4867057502269745,
0.1049937754869461,
-0.29087725281715393,
0.04222943261265755,
-0.003349458100274205,
-0.3966810703277588,
0.7010247111320496,
-0.34319472312927246,
0.05242230370640755,
0.15786179900169373,
0.7471950054168701,
0.6063055396080017,
0.27324387431144714,
0.4299870729446411,
0.2171616405248642,
0.5641281604766846,
-0.10289391875267029,
1.0714819431304932,
-0.14288853108882904,
0.32720044255256653,
1.1883442401885986,
-0.08973945677280426,
0.7636194229125977,
0.8389832973480225,
-0.051033150404691696,
0.49800363183021545,
0.6947564482688904,
-0.3806656301021576,
0.4455491304397583,
0.6758691668510437,
-0.23047462105751038,
-0.26071697473526,
-0.23454998433589935,
-0.1243627518415451,
0.023806951940059662,
0.21939706802368164,
-0.48627203702926636,
-0.22110410034656525,
-0.02793230675160885,
-0.01900942623615265,
-0.06088855117559433,
-0.13574331998825073,
0.6262260675430298,
0.24555189907550812,
-0.055614303797483444,
0.4195418655872345,
-0.1741362363100052,
0.4981270730495453,
-0.7905845642089844,
-0.10391958057880402,
-0.11541126668453217,
0.3024604022502899,
-0.36437085270881653,
-1.0672169923782349,
0.21946251392364502,
0.39858055114746094,
-0.040110375732183456,
-0.44762399792671204,
0.8554142117500305,
-0.5909379124641418,
-0.6113973259925842,
0.176662415266037,
0.26169899106025696,
0.46733009815216064,
-0.08463305979967117,
-0.5435040593147278,
0.4309149980545044,
0.052836451679468155,
-0.8312933444976807,
0.14859914779663086,
0.4297264814376831,
-0.1748393326997757,
1.2662640810012817,
0.5901178121566772,
0.1002216562628746,
0.11196336895227432,
0.28359031677246094,
0.9948521852493286,
-0.5678117871284485,
-0.22541919350624084,
-1.097704529762268,
0.6364181041717529,
-0.09749884903430939,
-0.26169711351394653,
0.7830517888069153,
0.7831568121910095,
0.6339735388755798,
-0.24939900636672974,
0.8772078156471252,
0.014406461268663406,
0.07501697540283203,
-0.5319041013717651,
0.9288301467895508,
-0.8736699819564819,
0.40139809250831604,
-0.23800571262836456,
-0.9482890367507935,
-0.29005518555641174,
0.7611809968948364,
-0.10571493208408356,
-0.33812835812568665,
0.452924519777298,
0.7020255923271179,
-0.11378595978021622,
-0.3808268904685974,
-0.14224106073379517,
0.13409678637981415,
0.6348819136619568,
0.348208487033844,
1.2003892660140991,
-0.05240507423877716,
1.09626042842865,
-0.1239270567893982,
-0.130679652094841,
-0.39754509925842285,
-1.4812426567077637,
-1.2007893323898315,
-0.2483673095703125,
-0.5637804865837097,
-0.06512904167175293,
-0.2553062438964844,
0.8752314448356628,
0.08974368870258331,
-0.5305944681167603,
-0.45536234974861145,
0.00210900092497468,
0.02438051998615265,
0.16007016599178314,
-0.2154167890548706,
0.16335996985435486,
-0.01878475956618786,
-0.5259166359901428,
0.3280065953731537,
-0.0012176500167697668,
0.46791526675224304,
-0.4434282183647156,
-0.11682402342557907,
0.22552749514579773,
0.04678074270486832,
0.5471277236938477,
-0.04254258796572685,
-0.5626572370529175,
-0.17966347932815552,
-0.6330618262290955,
-0.14294251799583435,
-0.13640272617340088,
0.907869815826416,
-0.49459925293922424,
0.10663849115371704,
0.46248573064804077,
0.44566676020622253,
0.6229084730148315,
0.11288014054298401,
0.7088577747344971,
-0.6770608425140381,
0.19148029386997223,
-0.10032226890325546,
0.3302960693836212,
0.43206915259361267,
-0.41242387890815735,
0.4375958740711212,
0.07412217557430267,
-0.579592227935791,
-1.0770432949066162,
0.1465807557106018,
-1.0125294923782349,
0.01379395741969347,
1.1124054193496704,
-0.13686244189739227,
-0.2185119241476059,
0.15434367954730988,
-0.349109411239624,
0.25827756524086,
-0.6966806650161743,
0.6138595342636108,
0.6367351412773132,
-0.06192935258150101,
-0.17945165932178497,
-0.7732186913490295,
0.5115184783935547,
0.11710882931947708,
-1.0496246814727783,
0.48533135652542114,
0.44192254543304443,
0.32153671979904175,
0.014452347531914711,
0.5357789397239685,
0.22389660775661469,
-0.02278970554471016,
0.13716384768486023,
0.28618666529655457,
-0.39993762969970703,
-0.32555970549583435,
-0.1473332941532135,
-0.1651325672864914,
0.23328784108161926,
0.17658668756484985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01099v1
|
What's in Your "Safe" Data?: Identifying Benign Data that Breaks Safety
| 2024-04-01T13:12:30 | 2024-04-01T13:12:30 |
Luxi He, Mengzhou Xia, Peter Henderson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Current Large Language Models (LLMs), even those tuned for safety and
alignment, are susceptible to jailbreaking. Some have found that just further
fine-tuning an aligned model with benign data (i.e., data without harmful
content) surprisingly leads to substantial degradation in safety. We delve into
the data-centric aspects of why benign fine-tuning inadvertently contributes to
jailbreaking. First, we represent fine-tuning data through two lenses:
representation and gradient spaces. Furthermore, we propose a bi-directional
anchoring method that prioritizes data points that are close to harmful
examples and distant from benign ones. By doing so, our approach effectively
identifies subsets of benign data that are more likely to degrade the model's
safety after fine-tuning. Training on just 100 of these seemingly benign
datapoints can lead to the fine-tuned model affirmatively responding to > 70%
of tested harmful requests, compared to < 20% after fine-tuning on randomly
selected data. We further find that selected data are often in the form of
lists and bullet points, or math questions.
|
[
-0.3251064121723175,
-0.9844298362731934,
0.5367710590362549,
-0.1694772094488144,
-0.28454044461250305,
0.09360067546367645,
0.011043453589081764,
-0.5554297566413879,
-0.20398253202438354,
0.6703133583068848,
-0.480174720287323,
-0.6316412687301636,
-0.6307539939880371,
-0.3429522216320038,
-0.5664465427398682,
1.4612213373184204,
0.3198431432247162,
-0.11848881840705872,
0.06255726516246796,
-0.1550074815750122,
-0.7788805365562439,
-0.5450218319892883,
-0.6110655665397644,
0.01814454048871994,
0.5762064456939697,
0.6392970085144043,
1.0002939701080322,
1.4477041959762573,
0.44919320940971375,
0.19433631002902985,
-0.1652912199497223,
-0.14592255651950836,
-0.8851032257080078,
0.16057637333869934,
-0.2984342873096466,
-0.6385549902915955,
-0.36595821380615234,
0.11244700103998184,
0.22052372992038727,
0.7696346044540405,
0.012077479623258114,
0.09964368492364883,
0.06498553603887558,
0.9063655138015747,
-0.5750006437301636,
0.010891116224229336,
-0.9667137265205383,
-0.06619434803724289,
-0.5099170804023743,
-0.08729204535484314,
-0.21729186177253723,
-0.69107985496521,
-0.20911119878292084,
-0.2374560385942459,
0.12521745264530182,
0.17436160147190094,
0.706101655960083,
0.4545707702636719,
-0.5185734033584595,
-0.13839499652385712,
-0.5592050552368164,
0.7837357521057129,
-0.4152268171310425,
0.2508096694946289,
0.712007999420166,
0.029044579714536667,
-0.3699064552783966,
-0.09529690444469452,
-0.19402922689914703,
-0.18851633369922638,
0.3385395407676697,
-0.46353358030319214,
-0.17090359330177307,
0.04648590087890625,
0.49143341183662415,
0.20593808591365814,
-0.4977460205554962,
0.5018645524978638,
-0.4444655478000641,
-0.2193341702222824,
0.848112940788269,
0.3261711597442627,
0.5027079582214355,
0.11051885783672333,
-0.17384493350982666,
-0.012594936415553093,
-1.3244023323059082,
0.0039449031464755535,
0.8124583959579468,
0.6334282159805298,
-0.0931764766573906,
0.8056412935256958,
0.10468443483114243,
0.5913374423980713,
0.22572125494480133,
-0.07304537296295166,
0.14953146874904633,
-0.27345791459083557,
-0.028587471693754196,
0.21558062732219696,
0.5692840814590454,
0.8124234080314636,
0.7755356431007385,
-0.39620479941368103,
-0.20816807448863983,
0.12388798594474792,
0.4573054015636444,
-0.5882450938224792,
-0.29151514172554016,
0.2602415382862091,
-0.30141228437423706,
-0.6311036348342896,
-0.07498645782470703,
-0.5528291463851929,
-0.9734494090080261,
-0.31939852237701416,
0.11269374936819077,
-0.5565348863601685,
0.12306055426597595,
0.20847263932228088,
0.1988839954137802,
-0.05545167252421379,
-0.09782541543245316,
-1.1312497854232788,
0.125083789229393,
0.9821502566337585,
0.5933657288551331,
0.0933808982372284,
-0.09306830912828445,
-0.7180063724517822,
0.27634602785110474,
-0.5652058720588684,
0.5974174737930298,
-0.4358093738555908,
-0.4579784572124481,
0.055246900767087936,
0.3209242820739746,
0.06690320372581482,
-0.7415522933006287,
0.7330034971237183,
-0.3733179271221161,
-0.4231642782688141,
-0.3348287343978882,
-0.5879889726638794,
-0.08859741687774658,
0.046384669840335846,
-0.8045052289962769,
0.7013096809387207,
-0.11197099089622498,
-0.9098761081695557,
0.6219768524169922,
-0.13456043601036072,
-0.5267710089683533,
-0.38541966676712036,
-0.06752463430166245,
-0.6132175922393799,
0.0064653996378183365,
-0.13633489608764648,
0.507725715637207,
0.02289428934454918,
0.5959693789482117,
-0.9033065438270569,
-0.2967303991317749,
0.49006426334381104,
-0.3657858669757843,
0.6197909712791443,
0.3448861539363861,
-0.19437164068222046,
0.03203244134783745,
-0.9972130060195923,
-0.3722769618034363,
0.0772293284535408,
-0.376706063747406,
-0.6837924718856812,
0.38853922486305237,
0.10080858319997787,
0.30858248472213745,
0.2645961046218872,
-0.7391249537467957,
0.15180759131908417,
-0.29564905166625977,
0.2793794870376587,
1.1059173345565796,
-0.04303102195262909,
0.5434808135032654,
-0.6118850708007812,
0.24499838054180145,
0.3094795048236847,
0.23349729180335999,
0.16026385128498077,
-0.44752922654151917,
-0.3940621316432953,
0.05207736790180206,
0.11704283207654953,
0.6836877465248108,
-0.1752048134803772,
0.577796995639801,
-0.16618503630161285,
-0.49682578444480896,
-0.4100717306137085,
0.4293619394302368,
0.4150657653808594,
0.8592914342880249,
0.30971482396125793,
-0.11303381621837616,
-0.3311547636985779,
-1.1779038906097412,
-0.5132400393486023,
-0.11963272094726562,
0.14948616921901703,
0.10668089240789413,
0.27984246611595154,
-0.41880616545677185,
0.6851155161857605,
-0.437281996011734,
-0.04382849484682083,
-0.17946524918079376,
-0.16812267899513245,
0.16404883563518524,
0.8506513833999634,
0.6858928799629211,
-0.6154277324676514,
-0.28986334800720215,
-0.19981279969215393,
-0.4989279508590698,
-0.12635008990764618,
-0.10652719438076019,
-0.046206433326005936,
0.06549029797315598,
0.5404576659202576,
-0.41885480284690857,
0.4665999114513397,
0.23737913370132446,
-0.6110483407974243,
0.3016812801361084,
-0.05009754002094269,
-0.3245372176170349,
-0.8203743696212769,
-0.025198902934789658,
0.3047015368938446,
-0.2630501389503479,
-0.7942150235176086,
0.018393028527498245,
0.22336934506893158,
-0.008172557689249516,
-0.310881108045578,
0.1309184581041336,
0.05869229510426521,
0.47504058480262756,
-0.09509023278951645,
-0.026518860831856728,
-0.35061559081077576,
0.04433679208159447,
-0.3931952714920044,
0.6680638790130615,
0.6757699847221375,
-0.43130651116371155,
0.03670331463217735,
0.21116989850997925,
-0.4924495816230774,
0.28475284576416016,
-0.5835312604904175,
0.23318558931350708,
-0.24700064957141876,
-0.417277455329895,
-0.7908166646957397,
-0.30230534076690674,
0.21885806322097778,
-0.0902717188000679,
0.5141682624816895,
-0.4204975366592407,
-0.5689534544944763,
-0.061860714107751846,
-0.6319376826286316,
0.3984234631061554,
0.3058501183986664,
-0.4601961672306061,
-0.1697174310684204,
0.9669473171234131,
-0.4105895459651947,
-0.654834508895874,
-0.8221722841262817,
-0.16235296428203583,
-0.6442317366600037,
-0.5725629329681396,
0.05000513419508934,
0.07746483385562897,
-0.3693225383758545,
-0.019616398960351944,
-0.2963067889213562,
-0.2229241579771042,
0.6497333645820618,
0.5381099581718445,
0.36314883828163147,
0.09309154748916626,
-0.01573909819126129,
0.2792155146598816,
-0.3062135875225067,
0.25521570444107056,
0.08210854232311249,
0.3311476409435272,
-0.20568636059761047,
-0.1857815831899643,
-0.29374873638153076,
0.35401010513305664,
0.6339550614356995,
0.031444646418094635,
0.8936237692832947,
0.07335516810417175,
-0.43142977356910706,
-0.12959925830364227,
-0.27423951029777527,
-0.020394328981637955,
-0.538866400718689,
0.3190673589706421,
0.046198662370443344,
-0.9879888892173767,
0.5238927602767944,
0.0716933086514473,
0.14748062193393707,
0.016646118834614754,
0.33814743161201477,
-0.2533644437789917,
1.266698956489563,
1.041729211807251,
-0.6811766624450684,
0.42267125844955444,
0.19616392254829407,
0.6789669990539551,
-0.3035258948802948,
-0.30450043082237244,
-0.6618685126304626,
-0.2937753200531006,
-0.8981661200523376,
-0.04628870263695717,
0.17637746036052704,
0.27658939361572266,
-0.5162777304649353,
0.3542996644973755,
-0.2505033314228058,
0.6315656900405884,
0.3320186138153076,
0.13392193615436554,
0.346355676651001,
-0.18280881643295288,
0.09431377053260803,
-0.06494668126106262,
-0.37523218989372253,
-0.7750551700592041,
1.251810073852539,
0.6756781935691833,
1.3477015495300293,
0.1055196076631546,
0.6165957450866699,
0.057803548872470856,
0.233499214053154,
-0.6917906999588013,
0.4375249445438385,
-0.35709866881370544,
-0.9887759685516357,
-0.043162908405065536,
-0.34937188029289246,
-0.9793053269386292,
-0.3783649802207947,
-0.2666850686073303,
-1.1951619386672974,
0.16250640153884888,
0.2655273973941803,
-0.5207774043083191,
0.38259145617485046,
-0.700024425983429,
0.794368326663971,
-0.39205411076545715,
-0.5293675065040588,
-0.16823002696037292,
-0.9033820629119873,
0.6013102531433105,
-0.3860684633255005,
0.4536275267601013,
-0.39340731501579285,
0.2118409425020218,
0.6756823062896729,
-0.3163366913795471,
0.8301324248313904,
-0.2890453040599823,
-0.16180680692195892,
0.03824242576956749,
0.36098378896713257,
0.43648600578308105,
0.2363530397415161,
-0.03400430455803871,
-0.08246038854122162,
0.24571961164474487,
-0.2758632004261017,
-0.32783043384552,
0.889333188533783,
-0.6618400812149048,
-0.5836640000343323,
-0.32034507393836975,
-0.7687094211578369,
-0.5231389999389648,
0.20612727105617523,
-0.05082601681351662,
0.28687626123428345,
0.08699671924114227,
0.39513954520225525,
0.8953823447227478,
-0.44285354018211365,
0.27781742811203003,
0.410701185464859,
-0.15723659098148346,
0.1729268878698349,
1.0240942239761353,
0.17287717759609222,
0.049401238560676575,
-0.0019095262978225946,
0.03770777955651283,
-0.414609432220459,
-0.9736942648887634,
-0.28896331787109375,
0.23534637689590454,
-0.6516982913017273,
-0.3002585470676422,
-0.4173303544521332,
-0.08449698984622955,
-0.14520680904388428,
-0.1727256327867508,
-0.5150389075279236,
-0.45776525139808655,
-0.3929760158061981,
-0.5832483768463135,
0.4587990343570709,
0.779684841632843,
-0.18527591228485107,
0.16284358501434326,
-0.9596058130264282,
0.24050772190093994,
-0.042496100068092346,
0.7106351256370544,
-0.3900962769985199,
-0.255504846572876,
-0.3610696792602539,
-0.006096942815929651,
-0.2726599872112274,
-0.6571630239486694,
0.3003353476524353,
0.04967288672924042,
0.4278384745121002,
0.8154395222663879,
-0.033679794520139694,
0.6175329685211182,
-0.6449782252311707,
0.4757458567619324,
-0.12614542245864868,
-0.5962970852851868,
0.5887579917907715,
-0.78670334815979,
-0.3810780942440033,
1.150356411933899,
0.5790448784828186,
-0.38781118392944336,
-0.6137367486953735,
-0.3491459786891937,
-0.9171609282493591,
0.33371615409851074,
-0.3045102655887604,
0.4147702157497406,
-0.1993340253829956,
0.5735113024711609,
0.292385458946228,
0.20313288271427155,
-0.7218255996704102,
-0.28240007162094116,
0.10081158578395844,
-0.33029603958129883,
-0.15325137972831726,
-0.27769696712493896,
-0.368272989988327,
-0.4074046313762665,
0.27589526772499084,
-0.026858581230044365,
-0.10306847840547562,
-0.4910338222980499,
-0.0450688898563385,
-0.26548317074775696,
0.3010183870792389,
0.2338164895772934,
0.29005399346351624,
-0.41919711232185364,
0.11459499597549438,
-0.21633145213127136,
-0.7181288003921509,
0.23532451689243317,
0.1564180701971054,
-0.237417072057724,
-0.45614275336265564,
0.09872861951589584,
0.3879735469818115,
0.1451304405927658,
-0.7899132966995239,
0.5093782544136047,
-0.10867318511009216,
0.21532441675662994,
-0.03142557293176651,
0.5947854518890381,
-0.06152356043457985,
-0.06954075396060944,
0.033364925533533096,
0.17897199094295502,
0.033930469304323196,
-0.7153448462486267,
0.3828110694885254,
0.6135905981063843,
-0.4138586223125458,
-0.36502304673194885,
0.8801854848861694,
0.06536686420440674,
-0.004691442474722862,
0.687908411026001,
0.07124347984790802,
-0.15396854281425476,
0.5402523875236511,
0.5364041328430176,
0.6802300810813904,
-0.05665511637926102,
-0.07639937102794647,
0.1891908198595047,
0.6051493287086487,
0.06414037942886353,
0.5747084617614746,
0.3155682384967804,
-0.7944225668907166,
-0.05433293431997299,
-0.5612019300460815,
-0.04292617365717888,
0.34339872002601624,
-0.8524786829948425,
0.2507723569869995,
-0.7434185147285461,
-0.1522492617368698,
-0.17288851737976074,
-0.20491072535514832,
-0.41713792085647583,
0.22109465301036835,
0.24449479579925537,
1.0159423351287842,
-1.0772151947021484,
0.9730255007743835,
0.44942793250083923,
-0.14788462221622467,
-0.8049966096878052,
0.0029084838461130857,
0.3769957721233368,
-0.6550371646881104,
0.2473279982805252,
0.2010614573955536,
0.019826050847768784,
-0.19608572125434875,
-0.7266367673873901,
-0.9052094221115112,
0.7244436740875244,
0.6315394639968872,
-0.9771997928619385,
0.02548051066696644,
0.4515572488307953,
0.34714415669441223,
0.04512136057019234,
-0.4359285533428192,
0.9622947573661804,
0.38017040491104126,
-0.573584794998169,
-0.623555600643158,
0.24671682715415955,
-0.2799941301345825,
-0.12466444820165634,
0.39063823223114014,
-0.4608944356441498,
0.7527059316635132,
-0.3202969431877136,
-0.24077805876731873,
0.2157905250787735,
-0.054620787501335144,
0.29830440878868103,
0.3826228678226471,
0.4423518180847168,
0.8329259157180786,
0.9424046277999878,
-0.25578558444976807,
1.136916160583496,
-0.4752262234687805,
0.1841968595981598,
0.9966410994529724,
-0.23401279747486115,
0.5803035497665405,
0.6261271238327026,
0.12321431934833527,
0.1779605895280838,
0.8207520842552185,
-0.06739380955696106,
0.9639781713485718,
0.1646188497543335,
-0.08986476808786392,
-0.08637718111276627,
-0.03720898926258087,
-0.2898639738559723,
0.347482830286026,
0.5490899682044983,
-0.3740899860858917,
-0.2511579990386963,
-0.03515761345624924,
0.27133163809776306,
-0.0852498710155487,
-0.35997939109802246,
0.6792393922805786,
0.18716783821582794,
-0.3887128531932831,
0.3877412974834442,
0.15936964750289917,
0.41063615679740906,
-0.22824910283088684,
0.26094695925712585,
-0.20156584680080414,
0.20080973207950592,
-0.3744812607765198,
-1.0579631328582764,
0.5762789845466614,
0.27355846762657166,
-0.1342855840921402,
-0.1272011697292328,
0.7639935612678528,
-0.20263473689556122,
-0.2107694447040558,
0.29456740617752075,
0.4293256103992462,
-0.05175440013408661,
0.07095184177160263,
-0.6130850911140442,
0.0845131129026413,
-0.08139632642269135,
-0.19103655219078064,
0.6992279291152954,
0.3551684319972992,
-0.30316945910453796,
0.8854577541351318,
0.6278474926948547,
-0.11033797264099121,
0.20741021633148193,
0.07244692742824554,
1.1841760873794556,
-0.833943784236908,
-0.3658568561077118,
-0.9395938515663147,
0.7371086478233337,
0.19522036612033844,
-0.3673290014266968,
0.8079169988632202,
0.6261376738548279,
0.782511293888092,
0.1090841144323349,
0.7818333506584167,
0.10409718006849289,
0.49415209889411926,
-0.5509181618690491,
1.1197563409805298,
-0.3635184168815613,
0.5809080600738525,
-0.28635114431381226,
-0.6825493574142456,
-0.49966126680374146,
0.6102563738822937,
-0.5842323899269104,
-0.28558021783828735,
0.3219691812992096,
1.045882225036621,
-0.17207998037338257,
0.1267816424369812,
0.13796314597129822,
0.4116520285606384,
0.3242199122905731,
0.531854510307312,
1.0876469612121582,
-0.1402842253446579,
0.26124852895736694,
-0.5375045537948608,
-0.11568381637334824,
-0.056303445249795914,
-0.7995508313179016,
-0.9189843535423279,
-0.3698183596134186,
-0.2969990372657776,
-0.4177655577659607,
0.06275542080402374,
0.7089852690696716,
0.5591169595718384,
-0.8925998210906982,
0.05627373978495598,
-0.34053635597229004,
0.2268364429473877,
0.2963554263114929,
-0.15912507474422455,
-0.11838318407535553,
-0.24993525445461273,
-0.4046284556388855,
0.5447163581848145,
0.2866249084472656,
0.13900643587112427,
0.08822956681251526,
0.2479792982339859,
0.11078961193561554,
-0.054029300808906555,
0.33403342962265015,
0.35758376121520996,
-0.19619296491146088,
-0.5688518285751343,
-0.17888270318508148,
-0.23642076551914215,
0.07180466502904892,
0.6358053088188171,
-0.42239323258399963,
0.33656641840934753,
0.12338811904191971,
0.7853134274482727,
0.1138405054807663,
0.14737409353256226,
0.5302778482437134,
-0.6017958521842957,
0.33981072902679443,
0.32112792134284973,
0.40910497307777405,
0.20774750411510468,
-0.6433575749397278,
0.331838995218277,
-0.019695023074746132,
-0.7188238501548767,
-1.032214879989624,
0.2374972403049469,
-0.8902086615562439,
-0.18388518691062927,
0.9706323146820068,
-0.04946645349264145,
-0.2798829972743988,
-0.5300662517547607,
-0.10356045514345169,
0.12870031595230103,
-0.3808063566684723,
1.1745940446853638,
0.5206444263458252,
-0.1358974426984787,
0.1445699781179428,
-0.7313541769981384,
0.7073470950126648,
0.2960255742073059,
-0.6585226058959961,
0.20517146587371826,
0.65207839012146,
0.7322617173194885,
-0.1508464813232422,
0.13752855360507965,
-0.42330580949783325,
0.20495927333831787,
-0.203715980052948,
-0.7389562726020813,
0.051838696002960205,
-0.5168284773826599,
-0.7636322379112244,
0.07780838757753372,
0.35646072030067444,
-0.1255452185869217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01084v1
|
AILS-NTUA at SemEval-2024 Task 9: Cracking Brain Teasers: Transformer Models for Lateral Thinking Puzzles
| 2024-04-01T12:27:55 | 2024-04-01T12:27:55 |
Ioannis Panagiotopoulos, Giorgos Filandrianos, Maria Lymperaiou, Giorgos Stamou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we outline our submission for the SemEval-2024 Task 9
competition: 'BRAINTEASER: A Novel Task Defying Common Sense'. We engage in
both sub-tasks: Sub-task A-Sentence Puzzle and Sub-task B-Word Puzzle. We
evaluate a plethora of pre-trained transformer-based language models of
different sizes through fine-tuning. Subsequently, we undertake an analysis of
their scores and responses to aid future researchers in understanding and
utilizing these models effectively. Our top-performing approaches secured
competitive positions on the competition leaderboard across both sub-tasks. In
the evaluation phase, our best submission attained an average accuracy score of
81.7% in the Sentence Puzzle, and 85.4% in the Word Puzzle, significantly
outperforming the best neural baseline (ChatGPT) by more than 20% and 30%
respectively.
|
[
-0.2657340466976166,
-0.7796770334243774,
0.3947359323501587,
0.2938174307346344,
-0.32582905888557434,
0.12608586251735687,
-0.07630499452352524,
-0.4073205292224884,
0.15865837037563324,
0.3037930428981781,
-0.7473281025886536,
-0.16523388028144836,
-0.7610469460487366,
0.3681669235229492,
-0.504364550113678,
0.5316179990768433,
0.20075134932994843,
0.005977995693683624,
-0.26465904712677,
-0.38889002799987793,
-0.9820319414138794,
-0.3604765832424164,
-0.8353484869003296,
-0.5646635890007019,
0.18062515556812286,
0.23454736173152924,
0.40086063742637634,
0.2964510917663574,
0.5385773181915283,
0.3535510301589966,
-0.29611432552337646,
-0.09484218806028366,
-0.1756199598312378,
0.03421957045793533,
-0.5388023853302002,
-0.6255651712417603,
-0.5022298693656921,
0.023122206330299377,
0.2619403004646301,
0.5710712671279907,
-0.07776310294866562,
0.18598079681396484,
0.11341425031423569,
0.6908780336380005,
-0.23150479793548584,
0.05252935737371445,
-0.7883779406547546,
0.1478431075811386,
-0.19321800768375397,
-0.22160443663597107,
-0.47517842054367065,
-0.3122796416282654,
0.0156993567943573,
-0.47625795006752014,
0.06643502414226532,
0.004147089086472988,
0.9441688656806946,
0.7481927275657654,
-0.5576018691062927,
-0.16718105971813202,
-0.3927910625934601,
0.7918334007263184,
-0.5706084370613098,
0.43948259949684143,
0.1450621336698532,
0.5028091669082642,
0.15762576460838318,
-0.739861249923706,
-0.4392082393169403,
-0.09578763693571091,
0.2312535047531128,
0.1716444045305252,
-0.5618545413017273,
-0.3647427558898926,
0.2136322259902954,
-0.018548782914876938,
-0.6382161378860474,
0.08413451164960861,
-0.6026763916015625,
-0.17852751910686493,
0.8283877968788147,
0.5016807913780212,
0.2625422477722168,
0.04978874698281288,
-0.2663784325122833,
0.024841636419296265,
-0.6394391059875488,
0.22886665165424347,
0.12420129030942917,
-0.015892433002591133,
0.08459579199552536,
0.5258044004440308,
-0.2492588311433792,
0.4487757682800293,
0.4075376093387604,
0.3803463876247406,
0.44011664390563965,
-0.37071335315704346,
-0.007873640395700932,
-0.1883144974708557,
0.7044889330863953,
0.3989829123020172,
0.2185675948858261,
-0.21012113988399506,
-0.3667955696582794,
0.38601431250572205,
0.4398341178894043,
-0.5593613982200623,
-0.4173275828361511,
0.06018504872918129,
-0.36627790331840515,
-0.42605605721473694,
-0.5413433313369751,
-0.5369046926498413,
-0.22552990913391113,
-0.3151269853115082,
0.8866861462593079,
-0.6250281929969788,
-0.15293455123901367,
0.1814843714237213,
-0.20098985731601715,
0.3151480555534363,
0.4112180471420288,
-0.5652819871902466,
0.29994437098503113,
0.5646917223930359,
0.5109403133392334,
-0.4617801308631897,
-0.5140410661697388,
-0.3054056465625763,
-0.34838712215423584,
-0.14742852747440338,
0.9948299527168274,
-0.5447431206703186,
-0.1637914776802063,
-0.605055570602417,
0.05064976215362549,
-0.3425769805908203,
-0.5655428171157837,
0.6979718804359436,
-0.5862724184989929,
0.33370089530944824,
-0.462768018245697,
-0.3780500590801239,
-0.3990746736526489,
0.5715312957763672,
-0.642573356628418,
0.9453619718551636,
-0.14836008846759796,
-0.5284104943275452,
0.14950281381607056,
-1.013930320739746,
-0.5164983868598938,
0.3671862781047821,
-0.35462307929992676,
-0.17757759988307953,
0.0973103791475296,
0.41061916947364807,
0.13115248084068298,
-0.4228252172470093,
0.43734127283096313,
0.22219567000865936,
-0.41824838519096375,
0.3456657826900482,
-0.5177149772644043,
1.1854755878448486,
0.021416986361145973,
-0.6515605449676514,
0.17801088094711304,
-0.5241553783416748,
0.006525452248752117,
0.4465857446193695,
-0.05966705083847046,
0.01403025072067976,
-0.32910701632499695,
-0.028361745178699493,
0.48679548501968384,
0.2936227321624756,
-0.6627414226531982,
0.0899403765797615,
-0.5778300762176514,
0.7944733500480652,
0.6166346669197083,
0.01090775616466999,
0.3833253085613251,
-0.15772219002246857,
0.7287154793739319,
0.36581867933273315,
0.27672961354255676,
0.08569282293319702,
-0.7985693216323853,
-0.7104709148406982,
0.2859543263912201,
0.4952102303504944,
0.7577887177467346,
-0.839336097240448,
0.4541221261024475,
-0.24784860014915466,
-0.8039218187332153,
-0.5190593004226685,
-0.31532320380210876,
0.05010566487908363,
0.6537929773330688,
0.5382636785507202,
-0.27691224217414856,
-0.36960214376449585,
-1.188500165939331,
-0.6256162524223328,
0.2075492888689041,
0.17429156601428986,
0.1296607404947281,
0.8634225130081177,
-0.18938392400741577,
0.7110462784767151,
-0.3611207604408264,
-0.38609886169433594,
-0.3445879817008972,
0.39415350556373596,
0.2843639552593231,
0.4348096549510956,
0.33434149622917175,
-0.877763569355011,
-0.2984239161014557,
-0.28043898940086365,
-0.7445265650749207,
-0.1318991333246231,
0.08815427869558334,
0.312893271446228,
0.23302412033081055,
0.6266889572143555,
-0.5221866965293884,
0.5354063510894775,
0.3436201214790344,
-0.6146463751792908,
0.42262032628059387,
0.11677459627389908,
0.16671930253505707,
-0.9166398644447327,
0.15524353086948395,
-0.18193623423576355,
0.01803094707429409,
-0.6700931191444397,
0.1448378562927246,
0.17398768663406372,
-0.1310817450284958,
-0.5513851046562195,
0.5486346483230591,
-0.36525678634643555,
0.3171256184577942,
-0.4333270490169525,
0.010230441577732563,
-0.13171923160552979,
0.5423555374145508,
-0.05388332158327103,
0.812679648399353,
0.37834659218788147,
-0.4059160053730011,
0.029292216524481773,
0.2504865527153015,
-0.4076876640319824,
0.33062779903411865,
-0.8964803814888,
0.36941075325012207,
-0.1749534010887146,
0.07822646200656891,
-0.8421012759208679,
0.13436023890972137,
-0.0513702854514122,
-0.6042523384094238,
-0.08815059065818787,
0.37742626667022705,
-0.13032282888889313,
-0.5384673476219177,
0.12057159841060638,
0.5951399207115173,
0.496227502822876,
-0.28208693861961365,
0.9253560900688171,
0.6230681538581848,
0.008446418680250645,
-0.7896059155464172,
-0.9104601740837097,
0.22936047613620758,
-0.4586232304573059,
-0.6399700045585632,
0.3250138759613037,
-0.29196664690971375,
-0.016911374405026436,
0.04805010184645653,
-0.1591494232416153,
0.04230663925409317,
0.3847469687461853,
0.16013503074645996,
0.06257326900959015,
-0.19571878015995026,
-0.3142137825489044,
0.050954993814229965,
-0.2594176232814789,
0.38236793875694275,
0.0641990602016449,
0.5132431387901306,
-0.5203143358230591,
-0.3631139397621155,
-0.19528673589229584,
0.15998032689094543,
0.2629643976688385,
-0.4204272925853729,
0.3026501536369324,
0.5490149259567261,
-0.4874531626701355,
-0.1833924800157547,
-0.6959570646286011,
-0.4094248116016388,
-0.5170038938522339,
0.47045740485191345,
-0.6989597082138062,
-1.122895359992981,
0.5503942966461182,
-0.09987204521894455,
-0.13165511190891266,
0.5584677457809448,
0.6834195256233215,
0.1359051764011383,
1.1304110288619995,
0.6276542544364929,
0.01593451015651226,
-0.08720014989376068,
-0.20598290860652924,
0.49293965101242065,
-0.7167298197746277,
-0.3587767481803894,
-0.35020530223846436,
-0.7097283005714417,
-0.26914864778518677,
-0.4148901402950287,
0.6396651864051819,
-0.04510686546564102,
-0.049408961087465286,
0.6974827647209167,
-0.768212080001831,
0.7514361143112183,
0.591211199760437,
-0.04948212951421738,
0.12687209248542786,
-0.4008775055408478,
-0.4229414463043213,
-0.2366919368505478,
-0.6564568281173706,
-0.20858460664749146,
0.988513171672821,
0.27478957176208496,
0.4206710457801819,
0.11580170691013336,
0.5968291759490967,
0.10179830342531204,
-0.1479165107011795,
-0.8198319673538208,
0.9799648523330688,
0.13235895335674286,
-0.7362170219421387,
-0.3929421305656433,
-0.048507194966077805,
-1.1385853290557861,
0.3417154848575592,
0.07570294290781021,
-0.8437594175338745,
0.19092491269111633,
-0.21581588685512543,
-0.46801838278770447,
-0.03429356962442398,
-0.37777942419052124,
0.9148719906806946,
-0.1443447321653366,
-0.16857336461544037,
-0.32584476470947266,
-0.7325214743614197,
0.29828691482543945,
-0.05513998493552208,
0.0758938193321228,
-0.0925360843539238,
-0.08720667660236359,
0.8888387680053711,
0.0964144691824913,
0.5387396216392517,
-0.14283601939678192,
0.22103779017925262,
0.3193475306034088,
0.17102791368961334,
0.2125997543334961,
0.053595032542943954,
-0.12081412225961685,
0.271610826253891,
-0.038849685341119766,
-0.20121817290782928,
-0.61026531457901,
0.33291321992874146,
-0.6848713755607605,
-0.8925475478172302,
-0.5768983960151672,
-0.6243743896484375,
-0.2158408910036087,
0.3922838270664215,
0.5582759380340576,
0.520652174949646,
-0.30493298172950745,
0.3246042728424072,
0.556732714176178,
-0.051046937704086304,
0.5751261115074158,
0.43835124373435974,
0.11884774267673492,
-0.43346500396728516,
0.6472816467285156,
0.2148057073354721,
-0.22524337470531464,
0.35374292731285095,
0.2153828740119934,
-0.35810279846191406,
-0.7803596258163452,
-0.24423551559448242,
0.08692169189453125,
-0.6882426142692566,
-0.3088976740837097,
-0.8687924742698669,
-0.6336879730224609,
-0.4122202694416046,
-0.025608506053686142,
-0.4164053797721863,
-0.6673877835273743,
0.14226149022579193,
0.03952159732580185,
-0.25068554282188416,
0.7976546287536621,
-0.10872850567102432,
-0.03624667599797249,
-0.6007565259933472,
0.03715083375573158,
0.31783801317214966,
-0.1074962317943573,
-0.08747297525405884,
-0.7461212873458862,
-0.22129328548908234,
-0.1488201767206192,
-0.46615687012672424,
-0.8673186302185059,
0.5336102843284607,
-0.325129896402359,
0.6082891225814819,
-0.17126363515853882,
-0.1600113809108734,
0.46171432733535767,
-0.6292637586593628,
1.0191818475723267,
0.03215247765183449,
-1.0094178915023804,
0.8190717101097107,
-0.2470947504043579,
0.8414021134376526,
0.7864698767662048,
0.31955111026763916,
-0.32551756501197815,
-0.4342595636844635,
-0.7777917385101318,
-0.7255919575691223,
0.617745578289032,
0.3383364975452423,
-0.015510041266679764,
0.0466553159058094,
-0.00989803671836853,
0.08846977353096008,
0.12973371148109436,
-0.9527899622917175,
-0.22928252816200256,
-0.13024862110614777,
-0.20526611804962158,
0.11504404991865158,
-0.012890497222542763,
-0.12848776578903198,
-0.5006893277168274,
0.8033396005630493,
-0.28721460700035095,
0.47727882862091064,
0.023287639021873474,
-0.34596875309944153,
0.015432728454470634,
0.40465614199638367,
0.6597113013267517,
0.6919722557067871,
0.14001065492630005,
-0.03803753852844238,
0.5569067001342773,
-0.6282259821891785,
0.13247069716453552,
0.2059839814901352,
-0.3795706331729889,
-0.22902916371822357,
0.2738312780857086,
0.8782938718795776,
0.15155822038650513,
-0.5905137062072754,
0.6860559582710266,
-0.2801911532878876,
-0.42930740118026733,
-0.4806280732154846,
0.024498524144291878,
0.32909974455833435,
0.5087153911590576,
0.48161736130714417,
0.5334738492965698,
0.5326241254806519,
-0.2729912996292114,
0.09429198503494263,
0.38214758038520813,
-0.36397844552993774,
-0.7178347706794739,
0.8842113614082336,
0.15239477157592773,
-0.4432281255722046,
0.3996032178401947,
-0.4715511202812195,
-0.9883626103401184,
0.6817173361778259,
0.7013862729072571,
0.928571343421936,
-0.42765626311302185,
-0.10188941657543182,
0.4640774726867676,
0.5401750802993774,
0.052405163645744324,
0.6450527310371399,
0.1668929010629654,
-0.9417256116867065,
-0.3751528859138489,
-0.29338568449020386,
-0.2805247902870178,
0.4826844334602356,
-0.4313505291938782,
0.4943547248840332,
-0.04009628668427467,
-0.2502744197845459,
0.060172468423843384,
0.0751379057765007,
-0.9282735586166382,
0.28729549050331116,
0.24273861944675446,
1.206954836845398,
-0.7586076259613037,
0.9352070093154907,
1.0135250091552734,
-0.3605242073535919,
-0.9092172384262085,
-0.14436571300029755,
0.1552862673997879,
-0.6387344002723694,
0.8080649971961975,
0.22938761115074158,
0.022428154945373535,
0.19576534628868103,
-0.3173258900642395,
-0.9675737023353577,
1.2030242681503296,
0.1689770668745041,
-0.33844876289367676,
-0.48897919058799744,
0.3609660863876343,
0.34606149792671204,
-0.19718492031097412,
0.5841397047042847,
0.6907023191452026,
0.5375602841377258,
0.01877610944211483,
-1.0954025983810425,
0.11697341501712799,
-0.6305246353149414,
-0.29703494906425476,
0.09363486617803574,
-0.9042679667472839,
0.829966127872467,
0.0032692421227693558,
-0.19694074988365173,
-0.03752274066209793,
0.8944797515869141,
0.44085025787353516,
0.42510777711868286,
0.6749909520149231,
0.8005067110061646,
0.5196829438209534,
-0.0838017463684082,
0.4078962504863739,
-0.315493106842041,
-0.002172834472730756,
1.2230864763259888,
-0.32337647676467896,
0.9266259670257568,
0.4059933125972748,
0.11137733608484268,
0.46350064873695374,
0.07886092364788055,
-0.11922608315944672,
0.5327594876289368,
-0.011111785657703876,
0.1903785914182663,
-0.35092705488204956,
0.01989804022014141,
-0.21058471500873566,
0.9135829210281372,
0.4455030858516693,
0.11646296083927155,
-0.3521437346935272,
0.22024236619472504,
-0.33126845955848694,
0.33004438877105713,
-0.10524628311395645,
0.6010962128639221,
0.3960750699043274,
-0.9823825359344482,
0.44491782784461975,
0.01698652096092701,
0.8931371569633484,
-0.22111934423446655,
0.21013912558555603,
-0.1696736365556717,
0.3873491585254669,
0.11716935783624649,
-0.8862861394882202,
0.5236839056015015,
-0.17465367913246155,
0.2819037139415741,
-0.24115301668643951,
1.0996804237365723,
-0.24600499868392944,
-0.3566248118877411,
0.1819850206375122,
0.7532703876495361,
0.03170495480298996,
-0.17096124589443207,
-1.112898349761963,
0.13509657979011536,
-0.05258636549115181,
-0.38569995760917664,
0.1673332154750824,
0.5708307027816772,
-0.1833992302417755,
0.6611472964286804,
0.040083013474941254,
-0.3416437804698944,
0.04443277418613434,
0.05540943890810013,
0.6445309519767761,
-0.9581142663955688,
-0.647807240486145,
-0.8171288967132568,
0.44636470079421997,
-0.1375560164451599,
-0.5608768463134766,
0.8742665648460388,
0.8072856664657593,
0.6363582015037537,
-0.18065856397151947,
0.48761695623397827,
0.12436296045780182,
0.4293172061443329,
-0.23822486400604248,
0.821522057056427,
-0.46445560455322266,
-0.10353115200996399,
0.09492509812116623,
-0.7928398251533508,
-0.08706799894571304,
0.4631366729736328,
-0.5253442525863647,
-0.14864492416381836,
1.0737475156784058,
0.7397751212120056,
-0.1577063649892807,
0.6188245415687561,
0.30051088333129883,
0.22472627460956573,
0.12568004429340363,
1.0922306776046753,
0.9875667691230774,
-0.9084799289703369,
0.38522589206695557,
-0.2911565601825714,
0.026170069351792336,
-0.03008575364947319,
-0.7793527245521545,
-1.1635665893554688,
-0.9232932925224304,
-0.4167723059654236,
-0.14215844869613647,
-0.07631383091211319,
0.8566848039627075,
0.4830038547515869,
-0.8117550611495972,
-0.3527231216430664,
-0.16796326637268066,
-0.3153737783432007,
-0.3195851147174835,
-0.26578909158706665,
0.10117220878601074,
-0.14556945860385895,
-0.7260915637016296,
0.934154212474823,
0.2708893120288849,
-0.21568681299686432,
0.005893472116440535,
0.2547687590122223,
-0.48809102177619934,
0.3027574419975281,
0.6855552196502686,
-0.08144816756248474,
-0.8670445084571838,
-0.3154333531856537,
0.37293562293052673,
-0.0008617046405561268,
0.018828770145773888,
0.5331592559814453,
-1.2462624311447144,
-0.1968272179365158,
0.6435282826423645,
0.9007611870765686,
0.5924355983734131,
-0.1326814591884613,
0.5058813691139221,
-0.23824989795684814,
0.11091969907283783,
0.6706182360649109,
0.3539887070655823,
0.22067947685718536,
-0.4510475695133209,
1.0054322481155396,
0.25346794724464417,
-0.6825657486915588,
-0.824966311454773,
0.1039486899971962,
-0.974787712097168,
-0.3278365731239319,
0.8520768284797668,
0.3644046485424042,
-0.6392263174057007,
-0.008689972572028637,
0.08136393874883652,
0.1389751136302948,
-0.1543518751859665,
0.6846885681152344,
0.7188869714736938,
-0.21561315655708313,
-0.20701958239078522,
-0.41082608699798584,
0.4053964912891388,
1.0568100214004517,
-0.7151913046836853,
-0.40511196851730347,
0.08352335542440414,
0.26805204153060913,
0.3949274718761444,
0.761256992816925,
-0.2418215274810791,
0.4859488010406494,
0.06106763705611229,
-0.13496093451976776,
-0.22619715332984924,
-0.42252081632614136,
-0.5764358043670654,
0.39532357454299927,
-0.12826523184776306,
0.06480076164007187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01582v1
|
BERT-Enhanced Retrieval Tool for Homework Plagiarism Detection System
| 2024-04-01T12:20:34 | 2024-04-01T12:20:34 |
Jiarong Xian, Jibao Yuan, Peiwei Zheng, Dexian Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Text plagiarism detection task is a common natural language processing task
that aims to detect whether a given text contains plagiarism or copying from
other texts. In existing research, detection of high level plagiarism is still
a challenge due to the lack of high quality datasets. In this paper, we propose
a plagiarized text data generation method based on GPT-3.5, which produces
32,927 pairs of text plagiarism detection datasets covering a wide range of
plagiarism methods, bridging the gap in this part of research. Meanwhile, we
propose a plagiarism identification method based on Faiss with BERT with high
efficiency and high accuracy. Our experiments show that the performance of this
model outperforms other models in several metrics, including 98.86\%, 98.90%,
98.86%, and 0.9888 for Accuracy, Precision, Recall, and F1 Score, respectively.
At the end, we also provide a user-friendly demo platform that allows users to
upload a text library and intuitively participate in the plagiarism analysis.
|
[
-0.17610351741313934,
-0.9740931391716003,
0.5694581270217896,
0.3975430727005005,
-0.41813749074935913,
-0.12986795604228973,
0.0759001150727272,
-0.1819746494293213,
-0.1910906881093979,
0.3870147168636322,
-0.2980389893054962,
-0.5048801898956299,
-0.6983006596565247,
0.21745742857456207,
-0.9580592513084412,
1.2651441097259521,
-0.02350773476064205,
-0.204515278339386,
-0.2626761198043823,
0.31973782181739807,
-0.1415557712316513,
-0.3905087113380432,
-0.28105199337005615,
-0.07712449133396149,
0.3706056475639343,
0.3882790207862854,
0.5499531626701355,
0.3584878742694855,
0.5914419293403625,
0.315324991941452,
-0.21223841607570648,
0.011593681760132313,
-0.5901500582695007,
0.224069282412529,
-0.01963111385703087,
-0.23433327674865723,
-0.4653353691101074,
-0.15310005843639374,
0.6870635747909546,
-0.0026561229024082422,
0.12096944451332092,
0.12285642325878143,
0.3426283001899719,
0.6546618938446045,
-0.5109572410583496,
0.11302512139081955,
-0.6540135741233826,
-0.09253954142332077,
-0.6846812963485718,
0.13555142283439636,
-0.28144776821136475,
-0.6740926504135132,
0.3672686517238617,
-0.48348167538642883,
0.572092592716217,
-0.23206770420074463,
0.862975001335144,
-0.09626026451587677,
-0.2669218182563782,
-0.6965003609657288,
-0.043473273515701294,
0.7995719909667969,
-0.6395416259765625,
0.14603601396083832,
0.33728015422821045,
0.077688068151474,
-0.11282642930746078,
-0.9405022263526917,
-0.7168394327163696,
-0.07860267907381058,
-0.0023969828616827726,
0.2336472123861313,
0.1351950466632843,
-0.12129015475511551,
0.09607432037591934,
0.753719687461853,
-0.6330406069755554,
-0.4708331525325775,
-0.15769195556640625,
-0.3720535337924957,
0.4190596044063568,
-0.19938161969184875,
0.23546217381954193,
-0.5559962391853333,
-0.5814222693443298,
-0.05182567238807678,
-0.3254411816596985,
-0.20440714061260223,
0.5973010063171387,
0.10267628729343414,
0.3048968017101288,
0.4139239490032196,
0.11200788617134094,
0.3935684561729431,
-0.3305128812789917,
-0.03252308443188667,
0.5846286416053772,
-0.19498571753501892,
-0.192837193608284,
-0.22683455049991608,
0.6240858435630798,
-0.1289244145154953,
0.09023074805736542,
-0.14427810907363892,
-0.36390221118927,
-0.2865428924560547,
0.15190818905830383,
-0.6892971992492676,
-0.5602154731750488,
-0.09876281023025513,
-0.5437151789665222,
-0.3701992928981781,
0.4282390773296356,
-0.7043001651763916,
-0.17506694793701172,
-0.3443213403224945,
0.9008487462997437,
-0.9384573101997375,
-0.1459936797618866,
-0.14986804127693176,
-0.12628105282783508,
0.1223093792796135,
0.3987254202365875,
-0.49447494745254517,
0.06747505813837051,
0.7843567728996277,
1.0026171207427979,
-0.46369579434394836,
-0.2878483235836029,
-0.4673748016357422,
0.3171480894088745,
0.0776834487915039,
0.4617389440536499,
-0.26215070486068726,
-0.4567185938358307,
0.06050023436546326,
0.12037300318479538,
-0.0320659801363945,
-0.42710965871810913,
1.0712400674819946,
-0.5513860583305359,
0.48301535844802856,
-0.5444149374961853,
-0.6893150806427002,
-0.3705763816833496,
0.046233441680669785,
-0.8492533564567566,
1.6758936643600464,
0.04170432314276695,
-1.0044621229171753,
0.1630987972021103,
-0.8508265018463135,
-0.5228930115699768,
0.2697230279445648,
0.2899340093135834,
-0.8583836555480957,
-0.16638901829719543,
0.2535722851753235,
0.5905069708824158,
0.06379148364067078,
0.33398059010505676,
0.09819038957357407,
-0.8071860671043396,
-0.06429355591535568,
-0.40926751494407654,
1.0853182077407837,
0.2004527449607849,
-0.3000444173812866,
0.12868492305278778,
-0.2725486159324646,
-0.26019489765167236,
0.22754941880702972,
-0.6313679814338684,
-0.49964651465415955,
-0.1964675635099411,
0.3713909983634949,
0.014818266965448856,
0.6139431595802307,
-0.7555837631225586,
-0.25025641918182373,
-0.2326890230178833,
-0.01944904215633869,
0.8245972990989685,
0.05143318697810173,
0.00413029920309782,
-0.7165416479110718,
0.16971313953399658,
-0.348441481590271,
0.09399271756410599,
-0.0030174506828188896,
-0.7387183308601379,
-0.5069952607154846,
-0.7870282530784607,
0.47397366166114807,
0.6274609565734863,
-0.7676249146461487,
0.5617479681968689,
-0.29121771454811096,
-0.3991027772426605,
-0.3496250808238983,
0.37599650025367737,
0.4621738791465759,
0.4808219075202942,
0.5955207347869873,
-0.007892272435128689,
-0.22029292583465576,
-0.7826017737388611,
-0.4109319746494293,
0.0813894271850586,
-0.4273221492767334,
0.07779469341039658,
0.9318685531616211,
0.20538191497325897,
1.1213524341583252,
-0.4297751486301422,
-0.6349220871925354,
-0.1924251765012741,
0.6474598050117493,
0.19455330073833466,
0.5860180854797363,
0.867762565612793,
-1.0733160972595215,
-0.8586056232452393,
-0.2929134964942932,
-0.6850405335426331,
-0.3923456072807312,
0.09144922345876694,
-0.2755848169326782,
0.24598757922649384,
0.17465028166770935,
-0.08821724355220795,
0.3223324716091156,
0.13310104608535767,
-0.25324782729148865,
0.6273519396781921,
-0.20519480109214783,
0.1268339455127716,
-0.999060332775116,
0.5343367457389832,
-0.1156088188290596,
-0.23590581119060516,
-0.32564860582351685,
-0.006982689723372459,
0.2410181164741516,
-0.01943526603281498,
-0.220802903175354,
0.1308896243572235,
-0.18466898798942566,
-0.007075101602822542,
-0.15608300268650055,
0.18807730078697205,
-0.24828486144542694,
0.30082762241363525,
-0.1779317706823349,
1.0433601140975952,
0.10439514368772507,
-0.3487757444381714,
0.3956725299358368,
0.505614161491394,
-0.40850943326950073,
0.3808820843696594,
-0.497295081615448,
0.3671150505542755,
-0.14205461740493774,
0.1795947104692459,
-1.1293587684631348,
-0.18489576876163483,
0.22491715848445892,
-0.5432368516921997,
-0.13271364569664001,
0.030120108276605606,
-0.987678050994873,
-0.3721558153629303,
-0.7904588580131531,
-0.1541687548160553,
0.41543641686439514,
-0.8710324764251709,
0.4347720444202423,
-0.02047797664999962,
-0.657107412815094,
-0.6083846092224121,
-0.4174695312976837,
-0.038323014974594116,
0.014015342108905315,
-0.5204098224639893,
0.5754941701889038,
-0.17520616948604584,
0.0622551329433918,
0.004004957154393196,
-0.11592968553304672,
-0.48780497908592224,
0.13638249039649963,
0.015205230563879013,
0.5141690969467163,
0.23043017089366913,
0.3222372233867645,
0.3630242645740509,
0.17240603268146515,
0.04837237298488617,
0.17122486233711243,
0.3619637191295624,
-0.027524735778570175,
-0.11607412993907928,
-0.27764490246772766,
0.6325756311416626,
0.5355656147003174,
-0.051300738006830215,
0.3865305483341217,
0.976952850818634,
-0.5864577889442444,
0.0010946431430056691,
-0.642007052898407,
-0.10768488049507141,
-0.47870293259620667,
0.1302320510149002,
-0.2694036662578583,
-0.6082004904747009,
0.18420293927192688,
0.09841366857290268,
0.26964902877807617,
0.18276546895503998,
0.4216894805431366,
-0.1105094850063324,
0.5165402293205261,
0.2304459661245346,
-0.3201412558555603,
0.7959380745887756,
-0.03289470821619034,
0.05115671455860138,
-0.5020543336868286,
-0.14774514734745026,
-0.5664981603622437,
-0.3469390273094177,
-0.027693547308444977,
-0.16100354492664337,
0.2520202696323395,
-0.002023115521296859,
-0.2697546184062958,
0.24470874667167664,
-0.7740314602851868,
0.31353646516799927,
1.1275272369384766,
0.3023914396762848,
0.5049856305122375,
0.09118098020553589,
-0.3010005056858063,
-0.2546761929988861,
0.009672984480857849,
-0.678796648979187,
1.0509538650512695,
0.05811528116464615,
0.1343536376953125,
0.24232131242752075,
0.9693744778633118,
0.6544257998466492,
0.6242278814315796,
-0.3384375274181366,
0.6903142929077148,
-0.37599313259124756,
-1.0040651559829712,
-0.34915080666542053,
-0.4552059471607208,
-0.6433759331703186,
0.3216395676136017,
-0.19094090163707733,
-0.520003616809845,
-0.1401911973953247,
-0.09718704968690872,
-0.032341133803129196,
0.2121632844209671,
-0.8519087433815002,
0.6679632663726807,
-0.05207659676671028,
-0.649470865726471,
0.09412531554698944,
-0.49983668327331543,
0.4354987144470215,
-0.30329564213752747,
0.12045362591743469,
-0.04359347000718117,
0.14117778837680817,
1.0388104915618896,
-0.46079421043395996,
0.5511470437049866,
-0.5402060151100159,
-0.18235239386558533,
0.42587482929229736,
0.06569085270166397,
0.5963436961174011,
0.15431590378284454,
-0.17974364757537842,
-0.113251693546772,
0.005292594898492098,
-0.32898011803627014,
-0.020033355802297592,
0.835904598236084,
-0.4653104543685913,
-0.2810041010379791,
-0.4394049048423767,
-0.8221855163574219,
0.06700512766838074,
0.5526114702224731,
0.2553612291812897,
-0.10179418325424194,
0.05762852355837822,
0.33056923747062683,
0.6173103451728821,
-0.13376738131046295,
0.5916087031364441,
0.3666137754917145,
-0.0713106170296669,
-0.28263404965400696,
1.1956369876861572,
-0.0032743087504059076,
-0.2088732272386551,
0.36056822538375854,
0.008216672576963902,
-0.3784753978252411,
-0.49765169620513916,
-0.247653067111969,
0.21627797186374664,
-0.4803938567638397,
-0.38185688853263855,
-0.36499160528182983,
0.08876584470272064,
-0.4852205514907837,
-0.22671829164028168,
0.11931174248456955,
-0.09137819707393646,
-0.4682563543319702,
0.16617771983146667,
0.5722718834877014,
0.623945951461792,
-0.06508714705705643,
0.27859216928482056,
-0.8200411200523376,
0.4913443326950073,
0.40155985951423645,
0.40777787566185,
-0.007245663553476334,
-0.26335030794143677,
0.1630447655916214,
-0.16092953085899353,
-0.5386666059494019,
-0.938438355922699,
0.5636377930641174,
0.08755753189325333,
0.43385934829711914,
0.0711522027850151,
0.03574803099036217,
0.2331220805644989,
-0.06770669668912888,
0.8414080142974854,
-0.22281810641288757,
-1.4438602924346924,
0.3419426679611206,
-0.5571995377540588,
-0.030060088261961937,
0.44003915786743164,
0.25761449337005615,
0.029925456270575523,
-0.5074734687805176,
-0.5334872007369995,
-0.8990845680236816,
0.6037483811378479,
0.6212105751037598,
-0.08331427723169327,
0.12576927244663239,
0.4309096336364746,
0.40724918246269226,
0.24995459616184235,
-0.986571729183197,
-0.0021125266794115305,
-0.35846808552742004,
-0.7368401288986206,
0.4479072690010071,
-0.3364099860191345,
0.14890047907829285,
-0.2417861521244049,
1.022565484046936,
0.09390175342559814,
0.5138115882873535,
0.42526504397392273,
-0.2632341980934143,
0.26175805926322937,
0.2653990685939789,
0.1544889509677887,
0.2985461354255676,
-0.6004582643508911,
-0.335300087928772,
0.23895767331123352,
-0.9715287685394287,
-0.1432160884141922,
0.4827282130718231,
-0.141201451420784,
0.4950009882450104,
0.2233576476573944,
-0.11786160618066788,
-0.04248730093240738,
-0.5213829874992371,
0.9348943829536438,
0.09747465699911118,
-0.5332431197166443,
-0.40491628646850586,
0.016760997474193573,
-0.06848596036434174,
0.10390248894691467,
0.827338695526123,
-0.25545820593833923,
0.37221816182136536,
-0.015029417350888252,
0.3172610402107239,
0.42596930265426636,
-0.017512567341327667,
-0.14648067951202393,
0.5673608183860779,
0.261221706867218,
-0.11387503892183304,
0.5810468792915344,
-0.3066607713699341,
-0.8010691404342651,
0.3198479413986206,
0.5186050534248352,
0.5968453288078308,
-0.1383216381072998,
0.08186043053865433,
0.018675774335861206,
0.10565676540136337,
-0.2258027195930481,
0.7386196255683899,
-0.3277210295200348,
-0.5661887526512146,
-0.2439098060131073,
-0.5187773704528809,
-0.2641364634037018,
0.3775288760662079,
-0.7383311986923218,
0.15418897569179535,
-0.21622249484062195,
0.07868752628564835,
-0.20049598813056946,
0.12294448167085648,
-0.40834760665893555,
0.13094545900821686,
-0.0018283459357917309,
0.7584377527236938,
-0.7333120703697205,
1.0520036220550537,
0.7785384654998779,
-0.25942766666412354,
-0.2594657242298126,
0.34933990240097046,
-0.12929479777812958,
-0.47476622462272644,
0.6708134412765503,
0.19889171421527863,
-0.08168598264455795,
0.33626896142959595,
-0.5616677403450012,
-0.3774298131465912,
1.2538063526153564,
0.3972756266593933,
-0.4390835165977478,
-0.18721313774585724,
-0.1538330614566803,
0.3432363271713257,
0.3020695447921753,
-0.10722219944000244,
0.5369162559509277,
0.49006274342536926,
-0.13697120547294617,
-0.7795540690422058,
-0.005731856916099787,
-0.20395047962665558,
-0.11889844387769699,
0.3880613148212433,
-0.22357605397701263,
1.1221734285354614,
0.20485273003578186,
-0.21523137390613556,
0.46694517135620117,
0.4239063262939453,
0.14267326891422272,
0.20405538380146027,
0.43650108575820923,
0.5722958445549011,
0.7719059586524963,
-0.2682904303073883,
0.6704809069633484,
-0.04888397082686424,
0.6935263872146606,
0.9180259108543396,
-0.032348308712244034,
0.7655069828033447,
0.48867255449295044,
-0.17970457673072815,
0.5063763856887817,
0.08978209644556046,
-0.23488356173038483,
0.6839196085929871,
0.06547949463129044,
-0.6609904170036316,
-0.15552014112472534,
0.18479059636592865,
-0.42458635568618774,
0.03043023683130741,
0.48760995268821716,
-0.7285266518592834,
-0.3232247531414032,
0.06355968117713928,
0.178430438041687,
0.20568494498729706,
-0.020295513793826103,
0.6640971302986145,
-0.42779675126075745,
-0.38188478350639343,
0.2842652201652527,
0.024569926783442497,
0.927509605884552,
-0.4723748564720154,
-0.2159019112586975,
-0.019821563735604286,
0.5163717865943909,
-0.14814382791519165,
-0.8342188000679016,
0.05057937279343605,
0.2224077731370926,
-0.05699813738465309,
-0.24114756286144257,
1.0215365886688232,
-0.2074083536863327,
-0.28262844681739807,
0.15855954587459564,
0.515903890132904,
0.11356708407402039,
-0.17900940775871277,
-0.609720766544342,
0.0583864226937294,
0.20527632534503937,
-0.11216815561056137,
0.2373892068862915,
0.4719512164592743,
0.32408326864242554,
0.21817854046821594,
0.895354688167572,
-0.17225366830825806,
0.03970707952976227,
-0.17686498165130615,
0.7037616968154907,
-0.38104361295700073,
-0.5177536010742188,
-0.7275447249412537,
0.09817178547382355,
-0.5064805746078491,
-0.3933650553226471,
0.7744172215461731,
0.7698974609375,
0.7958168387413025,
-0.2369932383298874,
1.1153775453567505,
-0.1192609891295433,
1.1309576034545898,
-0.26980504393577576,
0.7309427261352539,
-0.26346108317375183,
0.2185971438884735,
-0.7174211144447327,
-0.8111571669578552,
-0.3495512902736664,
1.0153392553329468,
-0.4666700065135956,
-0.07117810100317001,
0.5789989829063416,
0.5148904919624329,
-0.04379904642701149,
0.5989091396331787,
-0.19857743382453918,
-0.08336060494184494,
0.4829835295677185,
0.3816918134689331,
0.57793128490448,
-0.5772735476493835,
0.872691810131073,
-0.27181094884872437,
-0.22104477882385254,
-0.36348041892051697,
-0.7808182239532471,
-0.7750594019889832,
-0.4853588938713074,
-0.0750722661614418,
-0.16068509221076965,
0.24236784875392914,
0.57562655210495,
0.22665013372898102,
-0.9158071875572205,
0.15906429290771484,
-0.36823680996894836,
0.08423608541488647,
-0.19849757850170135,
-0.39299482107162476,
0.5691782832145691,
-0.39599609375,
-0.9580316543579102,
0.23372876644134521,
-0.17049014568328857,
0.1724860668182373,
0.013802935369312763,
0.24288418889045715,
-0.5429562926292419,
-0.050599608570337296,
0.5144254565238953,
-0.22960226237773895,
-0.4269339442253113,
-0.3623954653739929,
-0.18549945950508118,
-0.2338837832212448,
-0.255989670753479,
0.7588405013084412,
-0.8166027665138245,
0.2284521609544754,
0.6477570533752441,
0.6035717129707336,
0.5606699585914612,
0.27746036648750305,
0.3074883222579956,
-1.1455600261688232,
-0.22900396585464478,
0.31029778718948364,
0.2868010699748993,
0.40631183981895447,
-0.27787846326828003,
0.3140215277671814,
0.516828715801239,
-0.7271963953971863,
-0.8607808351516724,
-0.3747562766075134,
-0.5590333342552185,
-0.3814994990825653,
0.7588385343551636,
-0.5159793496131897,
0.06251399219036102,
-0.5125266313552856,
-0.6840236783027649,
0.33353391289711,
-0.8400340676307678,
1.1146527528762817,
1.0157350301742554,
0.09080154448747635,
0.43905359506607056,
-0.6497300863265991,
0.48273617029190063,
0.5617698431015015,
-0.6428090333938599,
0.07187657058238983,
0.3066555857658386,
0.3806491196155548,
0.19359835982322693,
0.22044718265533447,
-0.23297949135303497,
0.40529581904411316,
-0.37491682171821594,
0.025233326479792595,
-0.28783878684043884,
-0.012936657294631004,
0.05623358488082886,
0.5656914710998535,
-0.35650646686553955,
-0.45822808146476746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01077v1
|
Efficient Prompting Methods for Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-04-01T12:19:08 | 2024-04-01T12:19:08 |
Kaiyan Chang, Songcheng Xu, Chenglong Wang, Yingfeng Luo, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompting has become a mainstream paradigm for adapting large language models
(LLMs) to specific natural language processing tasks. While this approach opens
the door to in-context learning of LLMs, it brings the additional computational
burden of model inference and human effort of manual-designed prompts,
particularly when using lengthy and complex prompts to guide and control the
behavior of LLMs. As a result, the LLM field has seen a remarkable surge in
efficient prompting methods. In this paper, we present a comprehensive overview
of these methods. At a high level, efficient prompting methods can broadly be
categorized into two approaches: prompting with efficient computation and
prompting with efficient design. The former involves various ways of
compressing prompts, and the latter employs techniques for automatic prompt
optimization. We present the basic concepts of prompting, review the advances
for efficient prompting, and highlight future research directions.
|
[
-0.3769799470901489,
-1.2210688591003418,
0.7086979150772095,
0.47559234499931335,
-0.09700025618076324,
-0.16293850541114807,
-0.6243330240249634,
-0.07073626667261124,
-0.16674023866653442,
0.28774988651275635,
-0.9025300741195679,
-0.22202911972999573,
-0.16064301133155823,
0.31408751010894775,
-0.2509321868419647,
0.5478575825691223,
0.021186186000704765,
0.1852509081363678,
-0.3357942998409271,
0.17232823371887207,
-0.6984431147575378,
-0.4239194393157959,
-0.9480912685394287,
-0.3468094766139984,
0.5544083118438721,
0.4982181191444397,
0.2870500087738037,
0.5262296199798584,
-0.05973765626549721,
0.3033069372177124,
-0.36865270137786865,
0.2665635049343109,
-0.3434910178184509,
0.575610876083374,
-0.06319934129714966,
-0.35735219717025757,
-0.11288715898990631,
-0.17354081571102142,
0.7655410170555115,
0.93190997838974,
-0.06003805994987488,
0.23133321106433868,
0.35210099816322327,
0.6909038424491882,
-0.6770485043525696,
0.07661688327789307,
-0.47433722019195557,
-0.09050383418798447,
-0.10084042698144913,
-0.45932358503341675,
-0.8545489311218262,
-0.4763101637363434,
0.03469545394182205,
-0.4888077676296234,
0.04287812113761902,
0.17887519299983978,
0.1756598800420761,
0.20198264718055725,
-0.2786712050437927,
-0.5643096566200256,
-0.5831403136253357,
0.9770938754081726,
-0.4568104147911072,
0.411475270986557,
0.3730435073375702,
0.24842295050621033,
-0.42548295855522156,
-0.5801280736923218,
-0.3516969680786133,
-0.5099247694015503,
0.13145674765110016,
-0.15073364973068237,
-0.36223408579826355,
0.24967345595359802,
0.570244312286377,
0.039386410266160965,
-0.4835873544216156,
0.5385457277297974,
-0.05389384180307388,
-0.0021269191056489944,
0.37176215648651123,
0.2831926941871643,
0.34067586064338684,
-0.05546128749847412,
-0.2708302438259125,
-0.1662268340587616,
-1.048644781112671,
0.23998309671878815,
0.26661810278892517,
0.36558884382247925,
0.004118949640542269,
0.3360450267791748,
-0.30549654364585876,
1.3224878311157227,
0.1241874098777771,
-0.04170119762420654,
-0.3060573637485504,
-0.32728224992752075,
-0.18314583599567413,
-0.1930907517671585,
0.6850160360336304,
0.24354062974452972,
0.48900559544563293,
0.19109582901000977,
-0.3871917426586151,
-0.27951106429100037,
0.09571649879217148,
-0.49228960275650024,
-0.03772811219096184,
0.14747656881809235,
-0.4757244288921356,
-0.1015022024512291,
-0.3508164882659912,
-0.9770368933677673,
-0.5098811984062195,
-0.471841424703598,
0.4750736951828003,
-0.17645905911922455,
0.12977151572704315,
-0.055691178888082504,
-0.04537337273359299,
0.38436052203178406,
0.6069386601448059,
-1.1908594369888306,
0.19939984381198883,
0.7383421063423157,
0.8767445683479309,
-0.02634701505303383,
-0.11193113774061203,
-1.0088168382644653,
0.13133904337882996,
-0.39864426851272583,
0.8113405704498291,
-0.6113308072090149,
-0.48879414796829224,
0.2834983468055725,
-0.22621046006679535,
-0.00036106506013311446,
-0.476313054561615,
0.6313270926475525,
-0.6098337769508362,
0.17203165590763092,
-0.6059329509735107,
-0.6305415034294128,
-0.34266164898872375,
0.30847689509391785,
-0.6804212927818298,
0.9986817836761475,
-0.01653379201889038,
-0.39105844497680664,
-0.007437011227011681,
-0.8536757826805115,
-0.3318788707256317,
0.09120044857263565,
0.11409793049097061,
0.1738753765821457,
0.3291345536708832,
0.6262922883033752,
0.7097923755645752,
-0.5574992895126343,
0.3559460937976837,
-0.06293448805809021,
-0.18265125155448914,
0.13815753161907196,
-0.5250749588012695,
0.8676301836967468,
0.34480229020118713,
-0.08246009796857834,
0.33973345160484314,
-0.37993088364601135,
-0.006901843473315239,
0.15405195951461792,
-0.3834654688835144,
-0.25877490639686584,
-0.08107230067253113,
-0.1142868772149086,
-0.11408081650733948,
0.19019170105457306,
-0.04032905399799347,
0.5478281378746033,
-0.35362759232521057,
0.5348780155181885,
0.9466670751571655,
0.08286812901496887,
0.6270581483840942,
-0.2090805172920227,
0.7228106260299683,
-0.5477548837661743,
0.04939446225762367,
-0.6792072057723999,
-0.33928558230400085,
-0.5712014436721802,
-0.19626905024051666,
0.18363234400749207,
0.48501521348953247,
-0.6234073042869568,
0.3356228768825531,
0.11001987010240555,
-0.2908531129360199,
-0.21506723761558533,
0.19047389924526215,
0.28252285718917847,
0.45702463388442993,
0.11867096275091171,
0.259844034910202,
-0.4579697847366333,
-0.5747995972633362,
-0.41247135400772095,
-0.12279012054204941,
-0.07293497025966644,
0.12939253449440002,
0.0788487046957016,
0.13323262333869934,
0.8536425232887268,
-0.45019716024398804,
0.2754458785057068,
-0.5043069124221802,
0.045177020132541656,
0.419118732213974,
0.3977346420288086,
0.5022821426391602,
-0.5525251030921936,
-0.7847054600715637,
-0.39600881934165955,
-0.5063045024871826,
-0.486910879611969,
-0.23320110142230988,
0.06263758987188339,
0.11546116322278976,
0.9094061851501465,
-0.5754801630973816,
0.03866683691740036,
0.5412083268165588,
0.03138640522956848,
0.7539620399475098,
-0.1077231839299202,
0.12360920757055283,
-0.7513594031333923,
0.0032111220061779022,
-0.06891091912984848,
-0.2792847752571106,
-1.0686225891113281,
0.14275427162647247,
0.0531967431306839,
-0.016180574893951416,
-0.41227903962135315,
0.9439505338668823,
-1.0064946413040161,
0.1696128100156784,
-0.45541948080062866,
-0.02334229089319706,
-0.12484019249677658,
0.24267959594726562,
-0.016554925590753555,
0.81293785572052,
0.7987290024757385,
-0.902623176574707,
0.6169906258583069,
0.06963036954402924,
-0.3155171573162079,
0.42710933089256287,
-0.7214303016662598,
0.3542601764202118,
-0.3159635066986084,
0.4410562813282013,
-1.088329553604126,
-0.37813419103622437,
0.3431326746940613,
-0.1707075983285904,
0.3938838243484497,
-0.17105616629123688,
-0.6690162420272827,
-0.43882161378860474,
-0.4461667835712433,
0.37559735774993896,
0.6325174570083618,
-0.9468734264373779,
0.41774803400039673,
0.008079689927399158,
-0.44086894392967224,
-0.422349214553833,
-0.35907846689224243,
0.20602412521839142,
-0.36840787529945374,
-0.44746387004852295,
0.11728311330080032,
-0.40200772881507874,
-0.4101572036743164,
-0.32112762331962585,
0.38229063153266907,
0.0781579464673996,
0.15096795558929443,
0.015875069424510002,
0.2872389853000641,
-0.06843197345733643,
0.13882945477962494,
0.16048775613307953,
-0.09148265421390533,
0.11397762596607208,
-0.1723916083574295,
0.8699116706848145,
0.18362684547901154,
-0.34288468956947327,
-0.753656804561615,
0.6080066561698914,
0.19159375131130219,
-0.003216442186385393,
0.5637634992599487,
0.28715434670448303,
-0.49804577231407166,
-0.2715504467487335,
-0.7862993478775024,
-0.516573429107666,
-0.5254168510437012,
0.10896404087543488,
-0.3638652563095093,
-0.9916697144508362,
0.2986014187335968,
-0.30296847224235535,
0.24579358100891113,
0.07237205654382706,
0.8442090749740601,
0.1483592838048935,
1.3408020734786987,
0.5750859379768372,
-0.1374097317457199,
0.7547875046730042,
0.01679418608546257,
0.0838550254702568,
-0.7466315627098083,
0.0041376743465662,
-0.8309821486473083,
-0.04280472919344902,
-0.11801403760910034,
-0.42341670393943787,
0.36545994877815247,
0.2360711693763733,
-0.07784561812877655,
-0.044936180114746094,
-0.4634874761104584,
0.7047846913337708,
0.5281423926353455,
-0.23889611661434174,
0.18858173489570618,
0.08080931752920151,
-0.03716837614774704,
0.08206757158041,
-0.8841988444328308,
-0.5622351765632629,
0.6398090720176697,
0.272316575050354,
0.8580459356307983,
-0.036977920681238174,
0.5719732642173767,
0.08430325239896774,
0.21967265009880066,
-1.1339149475097656,
0.6460931897163391,
0.33902618288993835,
-0.4628441035747528,
-0.35316550731658936,
-0.33196887373924255,
-1.1831245422363281,
-0.0814552903175354,
-0.153340682387352,
-0.9523600339889526,
0.08710015565156937,
0.47342449426651,
-0.6412359476089478,
0.051113780587911606,
-0.7556139230728149,
0.45279377698898315,
-0.046985723078250885,
-0.13954204320907593,
-0.22531355917453766,
-0.5069557428359985,
0.3342188596725464,
0.04192352294921875,
0.29408109188079834,
0.02025763876736164,
-0.23391498625278473,
0.5504571795463562,
-0.15306280553340912,
0.9919882416725159,
-0.37663477659225464,
-0.22882653772830963,
0.35776007175445557,
0.1959402710199356,
0.9305232167243958,
-0.09643029421567917,
-0.39027249813079834,
-0.41405123472213745,
-0.20907506346702576,
-0.22781065106391907,
-0.771375834941864,
0.6220143437385559,
-0.2264096885919571,
-0.6481592059135437,
-0.14777523279190063,
-0.5601893067359924,
-0.42545682191848755,
0.09705598652362823,
0.39364004135131836,
0.5694778561592102,
-0.17964357137680054,
-0.013228281401097775,
0.883278489112854,
-0.419827938079834,
0.6670759320259094,
0.2649218440055847,
-0.11236625909805298,
-0.31812775135040283,
0.6092072129249573,
0.013306715525686741,
0.31146207451820374,
0.34015142917633057,
0.5475283265113831,
-0.6114768981933594,
-0.5645644068717957,
-0.6006892323493958,
0.2570711076259613,
-0.8573979735374451,
-0.26161375641822815,
-0.743553876876831,
0.10690630972385406,
-0.6757550239562988,
-0.5494155883789062,
0.03056195005774498,
-0.21858428418636322,
-0.37406015396118164,
0.04224887117743492,
0.4935821294784546,
0.8832063674926758,
0.03527652099728584,
0.41030415892601013,
-1.0081641674041748,
0.154798224568367,
0.4455625116825104,
0.033517662435770035,
0.5104033946990967,
-0.43103358149528503,
-0.004626708570867777,
-0.19195033609867096,
-0.02996506541967392,
-0.9364702701568604,
0.2741224765777588,
0.28825587034225464,
0.7811203598976135,
0.475158154964447,
0.19598880410194397,
0.5291502475738525,
-0.6277636289596558,
1.0235477685928345,
0.2668023705482483,
-0.9636520743370056,
0.6188803315162659,
-0.33492380380630493,
0.4878433048725128,
0.39773523807525635,
0.5230763554573059,
-0.8450090885162354,
0.008465021848678589,
-0.2559395730495453,
-0.8135238885879517,
0.648868203163147,
-0.41485944390296936,
0.47412440180778503,
-0.10304077714681625,
0.4972760081291199,
0.3241282105445862,
-0.05028361827135086,
-0.4805121123790741,
-0.07285755127668381,
0.35714492201805115,
-0.27121588587760925,
0.021398013457655907,
-0.43389514088630676,
-0.09862981736660004,
-0.2167413830757141,
0.5583933591842651,
-0.412884920835495,
0.27598634362220764,
0.09092316776514053,
-0.30162280797958374,
-0.06069076806306839,
0.377275288105011,
0.6859480142593384,
0.5916818380355835,
0.40543249249458313,
0.15405996143817902,
0.5840898156166077,
0.07712328433990479,
0.3020375072956085,
-0.22308747470378876,
-0.23432961106300354,
-0.16205690801143646,
0.31896093487739563,
0.8619264364242554,
0.11310675740242004,
-0.6370235681533813,
0.30793341994285583,
-0.05410945415496826,
-0.13896895945072174,
-0.057501401752233505,
0.21833306550979614,
0.23855668306350708,
0.1684177964925766,
0.33179694414138794,
-0.5337090492248535,
0.2015499472618103,
-0.4666118025779724,
-0.273202121257782,
0.5090410709381104,
-0.31716927886009216,
-0.1613389551639557,
0.5356457233428955,
0.1772160679101944,
-0.5026393532752991,
0.5679453611373901,
-0.14211609959602356,
-0.467059463262558,
0.15964147448539734,
0.7287724018096924,
0.8715835809707642,
-0.42102521657943726,
0.015967395156621933,
0.5990086793899536,
-0.046242211014032364,
-0.44946300983428955,
0.1734326332807541,
-0.4633694589138031,
-0.36990615725517273,
-0.8246338367462158,
-0.5056764483451843,
-0.6396958827972412,
0.0168752558529377,
-0.5120823979377747,
0.358812153339386,
-0.5037582516670227,
0.06051793694496155,
-0.05042552947998047,
-0.09673313796520233,
-0.39641791582107544,
-0.10501496493816376,
0.22119925916194916,
1.2996151447296143,
-0.6479377150535583,
0.49566006660461426,
0.7805834412574768,
0.1589110940694809,
-0.9476867914199829,
-0.13448075950145721,
0.36574727296829224,
-0.8124740123748779,
0.45424142479896545,
0.22725611925125122,
-0.1226869523525238,
0.2928583323955536,
-0.9139488935470581,
-0.557722806930542,
0.5052364468574524,
0.3996550440788269,
-0.5995252728462219,
0.0616820752620697,
-0.2724502682685852,
0.2848118543624878,
-0.18289679288864136,
0.2771419584751129,
0.4409012198448181,
0.739990234375,
0.08797215670347214,
-0.6457135677337646,
0.33914873003959656,
-0.0826815664768219,
0.18123848736286163,
0.14085985720157623,
-0.5697282552719116,
0.49541953206062317,
-0.10727269947528839,
-0.18550485372543335,
0.3203642666339874,
0.6631560921669006,
0.4674968421459198,
0.16216745972633362,
0.8567214608192444,
-0.04885558784008026,
0.9609344005584717,
-0.018809858709573746,
0.9366541504859924,
-0.14338448643684387,
0.06815393269062042,
0.5543251633644104,
-0.3156924843788147,
0.5805200338363647,
0.5137013792991638,
-0.05140029266476631,
0.3111651539802551,
0.9021413922309875,
0.12805375456809998,
0.1446112096309662,
0.29639846086502075,
-0.5606982707977295,
-0.3320823311805725,
-0.2732236981391907,
-0.21100017428398132,
0.2071874886751175,
0.517960786819458,
-0.03947112709283829,
-0.21961289644241333,
0.2366865575313568,
0.11498309671878815,
-0.08020628243684769,
-0.3666679263114929,
1.014951467514038,
0.3121398985385895,
-1.1564773321151733,
0.6458825469017029,
-0.09458082169294357,
0.7108481526374817,
-0.5558885931968689,
0.005078759975731373,
0.0008463324629701674,
-0.39422059059143066,
0.011971239000558853,
-0.6906009912490845,
0.03910379111766815,
0.2508613169193268,
-0.2847699224948883,
-0.6494507789611816,
0.8182294368743896,
-0.35553282499313354,
-0.027723634615540504,
0.10790247470140457,
0.502284824848175,
0.2264583706855774,
-0.15748600661754608,
-0.6790028214454651,
0.13876603543758392,
-0.12752114236354828,
-0.6645525693893433,
0.1866074502468109,
0.32687926292419434,
-0.3275066018104553,
0.7829480767250061,
0.8976877927780151,
0.19827668368816376,
0.005393106956034899,
0.39336755871772766,
0.7669466137886047,
-0.8989279866218567,
-0.4630737006664276,
-1.0817277431488037,
0.3245854675769806,
0.052808597683906555,
0.055668458342552185,
0.7177227139472961,
0.13229431211948395,
0.350362092256546,
-0.1188717633485794,
0.6762210130691528,
0.05290762707591057,
0.48907536268234253,
-0.9148348569869995,
0.39020422101020813,
-0.37788480520248413,
0.13931548595428467,
-0.13622230291366577,
-1.0031864643096924,
-0.48790574073791504,
0.45702680945396423,
-0.21127113699913025,
0.11920986324548721,
0.4314168691635132,
0.9028636813163757,
0.21310114860534668,
0.14332540333271027,
0.1738356649875641,
-0.023786257952451706,
0.30438241362571716,
0.3746339678764343,
1.2829035520553589,
0.3432084918022156,
0.2507319152355194,
-0.03882376477122307,
-0.48591285943984985,
-0.5739356875419617,
-1.052822232246399,
-0.8188060522079468,
-0.5021800994873047,
-0.10936098545789719,
-0.1310848742723465,
-0.01794670894742012,
1.4614096879959106,
0.7539827823638916,
-0.6661577820777893,
-0.29291707277297974,
-0.08438348025083542,
0.2730044722557068,
-0.27285507321357727,
-0.15733690559864044,
0.2532867193222046,
-0.676188051700592,
-1.1187034845352173,
0.7754106521606445,
0.22957146167755127,
0.06856435537338257,
-0.34113526344299316,
-0.10084512084722519,
-0.023472139611840248,
0.13134635984897614,
0.6876217126846313,
0.4321579933166504,
-0.5622642040252686,
-0.07495515793561935,
0.21342559158802032,
-0.030006131157279015,
-0.057540420442819595,
1.1102420091629028,
-0.7047627568244934,
0.4759836196899414,
0.9253044724464417,
0.6183239221572876,
0.15718615055084229,
0.09693635255098343,
0.8393835425376892,
-0.6869118213653564,
-0.008630075491964817,
0.2497113198041916,
0.25791093707084656,
0.48014190793037415,
-0.41542497277259827,
0.249243825674057,
-0.08404397964477539,
-0.6500130891799927,
-1.0437941551208496,
0.3783157467842102,
-0.8173187375068665,
-0.3042546212673187,
1.2737698554992676,
0.0896710753440857,
-0.43088576197624207,
-0.15012960135936737,
-0.5400533080101013,
0.1402076929807663,
-0.41071557998657227,
0.41054826974868774,
0.7568811178207397,
-0.365800142288208,
-0.3276709020137787,
-0.6867190003395081,
0.5783907771110535,
0.5734263062477112,
-0.7152100205421448,
0.44106534123420715,
0.5142216682434082,
0.04570118710398674,
-0.21179448068141937,
0.733690083026886,
0.156646266579628,
0.33289214968681335,
-0.25496554374694824,
-0.1815023273229599,
0.07617183029651642,
-0.2974848747253418,
-0.8845108151435852,
0.07687488943338394,
0.4120689034461975,
0.3001595735549927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01070v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01070v1
|
Advancing AI with Integrity: Ethical Challenges and Solutions in Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-04-01T12:03:35 | 2024-04-01T12:03:35 |
Richard Kimera, Yun-Seon Kim, Heeyoul Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper addresses the ethical challenges of Artificial Intelligence in
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) systems, emphasizing the imperative for
developers to ensure fairness and cultural sensitivity. We investigate the
ethical competence of AI models in NMT, examining the Ethical considerations at
each stage of NMT development, including data handling, privacy, data
ownership, and consent. We identify and address ethical issues through
empirical studies. These include employing Transformer models for
Luganda-English translations and enhancing efficiency with sentence
mini-batching. And complementary studies that refine data labeling techniques
and fine-tune BERT and Longformer models for analyzing Luganda and English
social media content. Our second approach is a literature review from databases
such as Google Scholar and platforms like GitHub. Additionally, the paper
probes the distribution of responsibility between AI systems and humans,
underscoring the essential role of human oversight in upholding NMT ethical
standards. Incorporating a biblical perspective, we discuss the societal impact
of NMT and the broader ethical responsibilities of developers, positing them as
stewards accountable for the societal repercussions of their creations.
|
[
0.27201661467552185,
-0.38739490509033203,
0.4795442819595337,
0.07684203237295151,
0.1056097149848938,
0.18725702166557312,
-0.12095135450363159,
-0.6333413124084473,
-0.24323512613773346,
0.6059731245040894,
-0.39697226881980896,
-0.008050983771681786,
-0.7254027128219604,
0.16468316316604614,
-0.297963947057724,
1.169614553451538,
-0.10784897208213806,
0.44835516810417175,
-0.13855285942554474,
-0.2377619594335556,
-0.4818921983242035,
-0.41273921728134155,
-0.8264946937561035,
-0.2620072662830353,
0.4314262270927429,
0.01891344040632248,
1.114145040512085,
1.0810930728912354,
0.7445060610771179,
0.3546898066997528,
-0.16940994560718536,
-0.058077361434698105,
-0.3283722996711731,
0.20080427825450897,
-0.27642008662223816,
-0.2591935396194458,
-0.6246563196182251,
0.2356732040643692,
0.08489447832107544,
0.45740029215812683,
-0.01721620000898838,
0.5802031755447388,
0.06334754079580307,
0.5603224039077759,
-0.227976456284523,
-0.016835110262036324,
-0.519298255443573,
0.13373775780200958,
-0.012227212078869343,
-0.07229019701480865,
-0.2963051497936249,
-0.733004629611969,
0.05141327157616615,
-0.6139776706695557,
-0.17526085674762726,
-0.00976179726421833,
0.6611921787261963,
0.7817311882972717,
-0.35209643840789795,
-0.46913766860961914,
-0.6665397882461548,
1.100174069404602,
-0.6708561778068542,
0.16688762605190277,
0.5257039666175842,
0.16981396079063416,
0.16641353070735931,
-0.6913865208625793,
-0.4362923204898834,
-0.1825210154056549,
0.18971189856529236,
-0.024374056607484818,
0.02109675481915474,
-0.07997915148735046,
0.18204984068870544,
0.22512489557266235,
-0.45073431730270386,
0.15687516331672668,
-0.6746376752853394,
-0.19959388673305511,
0.7019677758216858,
0.021897271275520325,
0.5495866537094116,
-0.10362602770328522,
-0.30914270877838135,
0.08067251741886139,
-0.7089465260505676,
0.09406464546918869,
0.7334403991699219,
0.04961778223514557,
0.02974686399102211,
0.5455737709999084,
0.2885189354419708,
0.2541162073612213,
-0.32080408930778503,
0.3651479184627533,
0.16002631187438965,
-0.5163817405700684,
-0.14590251445770264,
0.18704354763031006,
0.6541221737861633,
0.6626937389373779,
0.6658959984779358,
-0.2715184986591339,
-0.35622116923332214,
-0.09909390658140182,
0.9256836771965027,
-0.5994252562522888,
0.11897183954715729,
0.3531060516834259,
-0.8648838400840759,
-0.6129249930381775,
0.07007241994142532,
-0.39534249901771545,
-0.5005720853805542,
-0.5793241858482361,
0.38308611512184143,
-0.46433401107788086,
-0.23624256253242493,
-0.05298953503370285,
-0.062498364597558975,
0.438694566488266,
0.19663521647453308,
-0.8203360438346863,
-0.05514370650053024,
0.9443422555923462,
0.4795696437358856,
0.15205852687358856,
-0.37366998195648193,
-0.26588645577430725,
0.21471577882766724,
-0.39703378081321716,
-0.08153752237558365,
-0.30640313029289246,
-0.1981550008058548,
-0.34890225529670715,
-0.20900338888168335,
0.07734156399965286,
-0.2693522572517395,
0.6981590986251831,
-0.5027866959571838,
0.014677212573587894,
-0.37700578570365906,
-0.2798479497432709,
-0.1787668615579605,
0.22578227519989014,
-0.3434602916240692,
0.4295131266117096,
0.20208586752414703,
-0.38202622532844543,
0.1517440676689148,
-1.15090012550354,
-0.5137814879417419,
0.21374820172786713,
-0.3523099720478058,
-0.23079806566238403,
0.3541108965873718,
0.026145093142986298,
0.3094215989112854,
-0.2863002419471741,
0.6978960633277893,
0.15514111518859863,
-0.45802298188209534,
0.33599475026130676,
-0.8032888770103455,
1.5420550107955933,
0.32962170243263245,
-0.818220853805542,
0.1136970967054367,
-0.42217469215393066,
0.10822618752717972,
0.17912891507148743,
-0.10403290390968323,
-0.29336339235305786,
0.20605765283107758,
0.17293031513690948,
0.21320585906505585,
0.23653985559940338,
-0.4957066476345062,
0.018341025337576866,
-0.16235940158367157,
0.8481982946395874,
1.2662938833236694,
-0.4089176654815674,
0.6582277417182922,
-0.19681262969970703,
0.518278181552887,
-0.20250722765922546,
0.6030566692352295,
0.10367119312286377,
-0.6573784947395325,
-0.5033984184265137,
0.43872693181037903,
0.46743032336235046,
0.7969093918800354,
-0.7524070739746094,
0.5772675275802612,
-0.6440455317497253,
-0.15707415342330933,
-1.3225785493850708,
0.03475705161690712,
0.3049120306968689,
0.5549883246421814,
0.42036065459251404,
-0.04101661592721939,
-0.11556285619735718,
-1.2181575298309326,
-0.3728454113006592,
-0.21337832510471344,
-0.0829872190952301,
0.400780588388443,
0.6109899878501892,
-0.2502458691596985,
0.7430503964424133,
0.21734143793582916,
-0.11097471415996552,
0.2264716625213623,
0.08577346801757812,
0.009795211255550385,
1.0726525783538818,
0.441984623670578,
-1.1495540142059326,
-0.35608208179473877,
0.3566853702068329,
-1.2364641427993774,
0.12866905331611633,
-0.32163187861442566,
-0.12463819235563278,
0.08193857222795486,
0.3910110890865326,
-0.3992006182670593,
0.7283082008361816,
0.38887789845466614,
-0.44488582015037537,
0.012403973378241062,
0.07579556852579117,
0.48141396045684814,
-1.2364869117736816,
0.25998175144195557,
-0.536135733127594,
-0.19316460192203522,
-0.5740043520927429,
0.3571692407131195,
0.0015669777058064938,
0.1336168795824051,
-0.5209049582481384,
0.15436425805091858,
-0.13320229947566986,
-0.09139036387205124,
-0.1981445699930191,
-0.20942135155200958,
-0.04329412430524826,
-0.059525858610868454,
-0.32497891783714294,
0.9426342844963074,
0.19234134256839752,
-0.3697158098220825,
0.328694224357605,
0.3860182464122772,
0.057289015501737595,
0.7375417947769165,
-0.8533527851104736,
0.35425159335136414,
-0.055295880883932114,
-0.11308757215738297,
-0.07187320291996002,
0.11745182424783707,
0.516030490398407,
-1.0573616027832031,
-0.0039477236568927765,
-0.14414483308792114,
-0.5894428491592407,
0.03352907672524452,
-0.16969405114650726,
0.505163311958313,
0.529546320438385,
-0.013977915048599243,
0.5430817604064941,
0.2951430380344391,
-0.1906944066286087,
-1.0453754663467407,
-1.2798271179199219,
0.403534859418869,
-0.30225738883018494,
-0.7892940044403076,
0.3396422863006592,
0.058783192187547684,
-0.5295279622077942,
0.31445634365081787,
0.1332307606935501,
-0.002491244813427329,
0.5949278473854065,
0.035659559071063995,
0.005109420046210289,
-0.38190963864326477,
-0.20326103270053864,
0.14557696878910065,
-0.35019993782043457,
0.532943844795227,
-0.4291241466999054,
0.2571781575679779,
-0.32103675603866577,
-0.1027606874704361,
-0.423865407705307,
0.7263835668563843,
0.5057417154312134,
-0.32136908173561096,
0.7338796854019165,
0.8321442604064941,
-0.6203323006629944,
0.267333060503006,
-0.29190781712532043,
-0.22384938597679138,
-0.44824081659317017,
0.2517225444316864,
0.08101829886436462,
-0.7616087198257446,
0.5398958325386047,
0.38534626364707947,
0.39190664887428284,
0.4439008831977844,
0.4444076120853424,
-0.41772738099098206,
0.7876524925231934,
0.6808721423149109,
-0.07752594351768494,
0.16728262603282928,
-0.11027683317661285,
0.29818153381347656,
-0.8929478526115417,
-0.1261659562587738,
-0.4796716868877411,
-0.7504076361656189,
-0.7407764196395874,
-0.24573233723640442,
0.18234378099441528,
-0.053459182381629944,
-0.348034143447876,
0.3968247175216675,
-0.9164397716522217,
0.8034523725509644,
0.7267248034477234,
-0.12403611093759537,
0.45279815793037415,
-0.3480983376502991,
0.19905388355255127,
-0.25415724515914917,
-0.2897901237010956,
-0.9498528242111206,
0.8908495306968689,
0.507843554019928,
0.43134090304374695,
0.3320361077785492,
0.6425289511680603,
0.48839837312698364,
0.34785687923431396,
-0.5750759840011597,
0.29670849442481995,
-0.13276219367980957,
-0.9579927921295166,
-0.1193092092871666,
-0.5650209188461304,
-0.8869465589523315,
-0.15370097756385803,
0.29524847865104675,
-0.578931987285614,
0.22824861109256744,
-0.1698378473520279,
-0.3405681252479553,
0.3576233983039856,
-0.6321544647216797,
0.8549491763114929,
-0.6257715225219727,
-0.3132217824459076,
-0.24705097079277039,
-1.2733076810836792,
0.16639424860477448,
0.0890829861164093,
0.010209129191935062,
-0.024570133537054062,
-0.20538517832756042,
0.5043811798095703,
-0.12289079278707504,
0.6731702089309692,
-0.04536055028438568,
-0.0287389624863863,
0.014722097665071487,
0.16159771382808685,
0.12366367131471634,
0.3218978941440582,
-0.31585291028022766,
0.24652789533138275,
-0.09813957661390305,
-0.4421607255935669,
-0.22986549139022827,
0.5804219245910645,
-0.7802637815475464,
-0.4685962200164795,
-0.5982335209846497,
-0.8298425674438477,
0.10724816471338272,
0.5413953065872192,
0.2397192418575287,
-0.21685491502285004,
0.04848605766892433,
0.5602045655250549,
0.8072946667671204,
-0.34427398443222046,
0.4690325856208801,
0.06358147412538528,
-0.01991148851811886,
-0.34431731700897217,
0.9069781303405762,
0.06676071137189865,
0.2483871579170227,
-0.12316961586475372,
0.10740461945533752,
0.07855288684368134,
-0.7354646325111389,
-1.0240435600280762,
-0.2579089105129242,
-0.6646901369094849,
-0.2915463447570801,
-0.5951244235038757,
-0.4301711320877075,
-0.37816664576530457,
-0.43325164914131165,
-0.4509490132331848,
-0.34124577045440674,
-0.5002697110176086,
-0.07445663958787918,
0.4185252785682678,
0.8994284272193909,
0.1174323633313179,
0.31754493713378906,
-0.744521975517273,
0.18615633249282837,
-0.22880209982395172,
0.21722543239593506,
-0.2609802186489105,
-0.34261226654052734,
0.06605016440153122,
0.3883484899997711,
-0.4326668977737427,
-0.4377608001232147,
0.0826680138707161,
-0.25858134031295776,
0.4098225235939026,
-0.0640493705868721,
-0.11889127641916275,
0.4686514139175415,
-0.5307128429412842,
0.8133048415184021,
-0.22345706820487976,
-1.1148242950439453,
0.500329315662384,
-0.5610347986221313,
-0.04247496277093887,
0.8394593596458435,
0.4464590847492218,
-0.6576364636421204,
-0.3279579281806946,
-0.7507070899009705,
-0.8822152018547058,
0.6032477617263794,
0.7850450873374939,
0.5681250691413879,
0.275692343711853,
0.4579256772994995,
0.10974393784999847,
0.3783714175224304,
-0.8642436265945435,
-0.12089990079402924,
-0.24302083253860474,
-0.40374866127967834,
0.2572430968284607,
0.5351627469062805,
-0.10905658453702927,
-0.2584974467754364,
0.4800155460834503,
0.0004180136020295322,
0.15229234099388123,
0.06692960113286972,
-0.3280686140060425,
0.11726933717727661,
0.1567457616329193,
0.682756245136261,
0.6992887258529663,
0.1870698481798172,
-0.30415797233581543,
-0.19583632051944733,
-0.5117886066436768,
0.1628856211900711,
0.10838575661182404,
-0.7267442941665649,
-0.3278768062591553,
0.058808036148548126,
0.365815132856369,
-0.3330079913139343,
-0.26271459460258484,
0.500151515007019,
-0.17213524878025055,
-0.03185950219631195,
-0.4461231231689453,
-0.2867621183395386,
0.20124897360801697,
0.2130780965089798,
0.3399375379085541,
0.637089192867279,
0.26953572034835815,
-0.3242592215538025,
0.22088178992271423,
0.24260608851909637,
-0.4295055568218231,
-0.18890278041362762,
0.9787071347236633,
0.230168879032135,
-0.6129732728004456,
0.9914470314979553,
-0.18469783663749695,
-0.556513786315918,
0.9148640036582947,
0.2382272183895111,
0.9343531131744385,
-0.3762267231941223,
0.1484803706407547,
-0.31809431314468384,
1.0519765615463257,
-0.13070042431354523,
0.31940874457359314,
0.1293787658214569,
-0.5298585891723633,
-0.5156340599060059,
-0.320079505443573,
-0.3897840678691864,
-0.11495301127433777,
-0.6321441531181335,
-0.1635282039642334,
-0.39885812997817993,
-0.33460700511932373,
-0.20563456416130066,
-0.2920776307582855,
-0.5039679408073425,
-0.09427644312381744,
0.09521510452032089,
0.36242297291755676,
-0.3760172426700592,
0.7529359459877014,
0.5294800400733948,
-0.6127212047576904,
-0.2817252278327942,
-0.02649769000709057,
0.06577710062265396,
-0.838445246219635,
0.36588719487190247,
0.27317318320274353,
-0.16324664652347565,
0.10796765238046646,
-0.5896066427230835,
-0.5577252507209778,
1.246266484260559,
0.6658461689949036,
0.022492541000247,
-0.15010063350200653,
0.420958012342453,
0.4914250671863556,
-0.13840609788894653,
-0.08864445239305496,
0.4098934233188629,
0.698723316192627,
-0.6174121499061584,
-0.7821480631828308,
-0.09162845462560654,
-0.3170120120048523,
0.04290035739541054,
0.13171830773353577,
-0.5434147715568542,
0.7302936315536499,
-0.04513225704431534,
0.13625293970108032,
0.08941792696714401,
0.44145363569259644,
-0.09155037999153137,
0.19492055475711823,
0.1960306167602539,
0.19303645193576813,
0.6058073043823242,
-0.0864676907658577,
1.0442302227020264,
-0.10004693269729614,
0.031881384551525116,
0.7386445999145508,
-0.14182329177856445,
0.2966989576816559,
0.7347989082336426,
0.22189776599407196,
-0.11020173877477646,
0.574790894985199,
-0.2171429693698883,
0.013866974040865898,
0.35921812057495117,
0.1267939805984497,
0.31427448987960815,
-0.5466020703315735,
-0.37223339080810547,
0.5000808835029602,
0.3105520009994507,
-0.7567459940910339,
0.27710622549057007,
-0.09402267634868622,
0.10901794582605362,
0.2774145007133484,
-0.25656405091285706,
0.557826578617096,
0.37143662571907043,
-0.4412400722503662,
0.1714804768562317,
0.16228963434696198,
0.9048505425453186,
-0.11986006796360016,
0.06399217247962952,
-0.03544912114739418,
0.16924360394477844,
-0.17757129669189453,
-0.6689431071281433,
0.8821951746940613,
0.24993927776813507,
-0.13301922380924225,
-0.875720739364624,
0.31993719935417175,
-0.09965384751558304,
-0.5726791620254517,
0.2505623996257782,
0.6014455556869507,
-0.013398238457739353,
0.04279695078730583,
-1.1117573976516724,
0.044293928891420364,
0.06474367529153824,
-0.22840313613414764,
0.12186769396066666,
0.2633255124092102,
-0.17575722932815552,
0.6357392072677612,
0.6957575082778931,
-0.02589552104473114,
0.13798311352729797,
-0.21302609145641327,
0.4190148711204529,
-0.6729873418807983,
-0.15117435157299042,
-1.156777024269104,
0.6123074889183044,
-0.1875096559524536,
-0.5459818840026855,
0.4244348406791687,
0.40941691398620605,
0.8889210224151611,
0.003979770932346582,
0.6384072303771973,
-0.37184059619903564,
-0.1482885777950287,
-0.49100878834724426,
1.508852481842041,
-0.3894062638282776,
0.14617054164409637,
0.06932968646287918,
-0.8943244814872742,
-0.28880277276039124,
0.6335856318473816,
0.004308066330850124,
0.32957059144973755,
0.47958388924598694,
0.4170703887939453,
-0.06464873254299164,
0.167390838265419,
0.1448415368795395,
-0.00715032359585166,
0.41318097710609436,
0.39916178584098816,
0.8517109751701355,
-0.8045305609703064,
0.4816976487636566,
-0.3807626962661743,
0.19215832650661469,
0.26643943786621094,
-0.9821397662162781,
-0.3870658278465271,
-0.3919883966445923,
-0.12225180119276047,
-0.37073928117752075,
0.09722492843866348,
1.1033309698104858,
0.5301457643508911,
-0.7599436640739441,
-0.22257652878761292,
-0.02397077903151512,
0.28880342841148376,
-0.4179609417915344,
-0.2360716462135315,
0.126329705119133,
-0.01702919974923134,
-0.8919787406921387,
0.36398106813430786,
0.11193584650754929,
0.07897032052278519,
-0.30415746569633484,
-0.0858873501420021,
-0.09572775661945343,
-0.11630921065807343,
0.43568626046180725,
-0.08468455821275711,
-0.8266106247901917,
-0.39050209522247314,
0.23553960025310516,
-0.3420202434062958,
0.16202056407928467,
0.6952816247940063,
-0.27982741594314575,
0.09237056225538254,
0.3593929409980774,
1.4431208372116089,
-0.32858899235725403,
0.008001676760613918,
0.9547620415687561,
-0.4825276732444763,
-0.11748524010181427,
1.0635817050933838,
0.11134645342826843,
0.33978796005249023,
-0.7762011885643005,
0.8708329200744629,
-0.05194608122110367,
-0.9150746464729309,
-0.9435874819755554,
0.18084360659122467,
-0.7547945976257324,
0.056784406304359436,
0.804480791091919,
-0.08172554522752762,
-0.24101927876472473,
-0.3544369339942932,
0.015056184493005276,
0.24754713475704193,
-0.349457710981369,
0.6254278421401978,
0.5972594022750854,
0.2088017463684082,
-0.015003497712314129,
-1.2118326425552368,
0.39539676904678345,
0.5993147492408752,
-0.7867738008499146,
0.1235860213637352,
0.21821315586566925,
0.11311295628547668,
0.1831362545490265,
0.36398446559906006,
-0.5087029933929443,
0.3624976873397827,
-0.23013396561145782,
0.06524430960416794,
-0.13361622393131256,
-0.1300557255744934,
-0.4193161129951477,
-0.325031578540802,
-0.2206176072359085,
-0.046760838478803635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01067v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01067v1
|
Exploring the Mystery of Influential Data for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-04-01T12:01:06 | 2024-04-01T12:01:06 |
Xinzhe Ni, Yeyun Gong, Zhibin Gou, Yelong Shen, Yujiu Yang, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Selecting influential data for fine-tuning on downstream tasks is a key
factor for both performance and computation efficiency. Recent works have shown
that training with only limited data can show a superior performance on general
tasks. However, the feasibility on mathematical reasoning tasks has not been
validated. To go further, there exist two open questions for mathematical
reasoning: how to select influential data and what is an influential data
composition. For the former one, we propose a Quality-aware Diverse Selection
(QaDS) strategy adaptable for mathematical reasoning. A comparison with other
selection strategies validates the superiority of QaDS. For the latter one, we
first enlarge our setting and explore the influential data composition. We
conduct a series of experiments and highlight: scaling up reasoning data, and
training with general data selected by QaDS is helpful. Then, we define our
optimal mixture as OpenMathMix, an influential data mixture with open-source
data selected by QaDS. With OpenMathMix, we achieve a state-of-the-art 48.8%
accuracy on MATH with 7B base model. Additionally, we showcase the use of QaDS
in creating efficient fine-tuning mixtures with various selection ratios, and
analyze the quality of a wide range of open-source datasets, which can perform
as a reference for future works on mathematical reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.5797218084335327,
-0.628963053226471,
0.7079094052314758,
0.26493701338768005,
-0.4128762483596802,
-0.029279522597789764,
-0.15121813118457794,
-0.2447955459356308,
0.08829988539218903,
0.37108278274536133,
-0.42019978165626526,
-0.46052810549736023,
-0.7547169327735901,
-0.2555284798145294,
-0.1671418696641922,
0.9294989109039307,
-0.07686067372560501,
0.3383394777774811,
-0.43725907802581787,
-0.6301055550575256,
-0.5543291568756104,
-0.19836314022541046,
-0.41077831387519836,
-0.1491190493106842,
0.3202914595603943,
0.35868632793426514,
1.1500253677368164,
0.5305605530738831,
0.5790290236473083,
0.21941062808036804,
-0.03088357299566269,
0.5427053570747375,
-0.9001347422599792,
0.340011864900589,
-0.7253015041351318,
-0.8986191749572754,
-0.08047057688236237,
-0.21903374791145325,
0.4973627030849457,
0.7362460494041443,
-0.23440557718276978,
0.22760958969593048,
-0.14399531483650208,
0.6397181749343872,
-0.9087989330291748,
-0.09620454162359238,
-0.6289728879928589,
0.0547613687813282,
-0.3447751998901367,
0.05861473083496094,
-0.17387673258781433,
-0.7947008013725281,
-0.09898756444454193,
-0.7956056594848633,
-0.09907102584838867,
-0.05824131518602371,
0.3587764799594879,
0.49895113706588745,
-0.40590083599090576,
-0.2575754225254059,
-1.0370935201644897,
1.2686185836791992,
-0.3396143913269043,
0.3544609546661377,
0.5516908168792725,
0.6027376055717468,
-0.13221125304698944,
-0.5382196307182312,
-0.24726465344429016,
0.3208586275577545,
0.1623053252696991,
0.03381648287177086,
-0.4788706302642822,
-0.3031487762928009,
0.42701002955436707,
0.34776121377944946,
-0.3932442367076874,
-0.2575231194496155,
-0.3249087929725647,
-0.12832976877689362,
0.696746826171875,
0.3237978518009186,
0.23460738360881805,
0.3356148302555084,
0.12992466986179352,
-0.13364070653915405,
-0.5633648633956909,
0.23138678073883057,
0.2922731339931488,
-0.06368464231491089,
0.12755365669727325,
0.6218379735946655,
-0.38363316655158997,
0.6104105710983276,
-0.018712839111685753,
-0.00762338750064373,
0.031104300171136856,
-0.26718881726264954,
-0.06084832549095154,
-0.17788657546043396,
0.47346988320350647,
-0.054337259382009506,
0.44197896122932434,
-0.010462464764714241,
-0.1458870768547058,
0.20528075098991394,
0.17574431002140045,
-0.9744502305984497,
-0.615849494934082,
0.08300946652889252,
-0.3023478388786316,
0.001026577316224575,
0.2785665988922119,
-0.6943857669830322,
-0.22862237691879272,
-0.6706087589263916,
0.6341243386268616,
-0.44076046347618103,
-0.28301796317100525,
0.3016599118709564,
-0.14397253096103668,
-0.42440420389175415,
0.5625313520431519,
-0.8691851496696472,
0.19613830745220184,
0.8490597009658813,
0.5609021782875061,
0.14788931608200073,
0.1534382849931717,
-0.7506073117256165,
-0.106625996530056,
-0.6688010692596436,
0.7345404028892517,
-0.8662457466125488,
-0.4591508209705353,
-0.453051894903183,
-0.5943211317062378,
0.07332852482795715,
-0.8222219944000244,
0.8804731369018555,
-0.6384894251823425,
0.18047481775283813,
-0.44664913415908813,
-0.5616428256034851,
-0.3349185585975647,
-0.21663247048854828,
-0.6710518598556519,
1.029305338859558,
0.48291322588920593,
-0.37589746713638306,
0.5456770658493042,
-0.3514843285083771,
-0.30945584177970886,
-0.11255612224340439,
-0.4319452941417694,
-0.6914247274398804,
0.41766250133514404,
0.376906156539917,
0.011370684020221233,
-0.2743814289569855,
0.07760993391275406,
-0.7647256255149841,
-0.1624932438135147,
0.4981526732444763,
-0.2618747651576996,
0.9917684197425842,
0.3735980689525604,
-0.2472895234823227,
-0.011886042542755604,
-0.8784046173095703,
0.5146404504776001,
-0.04169946163892746,
0.14037026464939117,
-0.7424863576889038,
-0.024616409093141556,
-0.5855033993721008,
0.04920632764697075,
-0.2528006434440613,
-0.3224768340587616,
0.0850263461470604,
0.04316432401537895,
0.2611863315105438,
0.7611499428749084,
0.3623260259628296,
0.5324961543083191,
-0.5426796674728394,
0.661291241645813,
-0.08641508221626282,
0.2119133174419403,
0.21538403630256653,
-0.7317638397216797,
-0.21537147462368011,
-0.4133455753326416,
0.6109501123428345,
0.32632964849472046,
-0.605141818523407,
0.2944463789463043,
-0.053583912551403046,
-0.7993414998054504,
-0.6015088558197021,
0.41480425000190735,
0.18565775454044342,
0.4052780866622925,
0.43754562735557556,
-0.05339588224887848,
-0.3388805389404297,
-0.7716328501701355,
-0.4638687074184418,
0.2787238657474518,
-0.05160348489880562,
0.38058555126190186,
0.22525404393672943,
-0.057073235511779785,
0.9704932570457458,
-1.0102096796035767,
-0.056151583790779114,
0.1816362589597702,
-0.16080762445926666,
0.30272936820983887,
0.5184450149536133,
0.9083938002586365,
-0.6205701231956482,
-0.4496563971042633,
-0.24070993065834045,
-0.7321104407310486,
-0.12603215873241425,
-0.023654570803046227,
-0.917502224445343,
-0.665528416633606,
0.12540729343891144,
-0.5112056136131287,
0.3555152714252472,
0.5132144689559937,
-0.4685974717140198,
0.39494648575782776,
-0.03900759667158127,
0.052115362137556076,
-0.6548969149589539,
-0.24286139011383057,
0.25006744265556335,
0.20540687441825867,
-0.4331322908401489,
-0.09455741941928864,
0.14418479800224304,
0.018173707649111748,
0.0072204358875751495,
0.4964436888694763,
-0.13809335231781006,
0.18063011765480042,
0.06751444190740585,
-0.29260900616645813,
0.02150927111506462,
0.17133143544197083,
-0.42087051272392273,
0.6244613528251648,
0.8354876041412354,
-0.6738393306732178,
0.20476482808589935,
0.2488359659910202,
-0.6169670820236206,
0.6479789614677429,
-0.6576501131057739,
-0.1705794632434845,
0.02391265146434307,
-0.0565665028989315,
-0.9315546751022339,
-0.007522155065089464,
0.22595661878585815,
-0.43937358260154724,
-0.14625196158885956,
-0.1361268311738968,
-0.40598225593566895,
0.05393684655427933,
-0.019490178674459457,
0.6775612235069275,
0.653775691986084,
-0.6411475539207458,
0.7147762179374695,
0.30977383255958557,
-0.16094793379306793,
-0.2164994329214096,
-0.43864646553993225,
-0.4731176197528839,
-0.28162339329719543,
-0.8749920725822449,
0.12413375079631805,
-0.11548630893230438,
-0.7444986701011658,
0.15066486597061157,
-0.3730556070804596,
-0.19930432736873627,
0.2278188169002533,
0.30740201473236084,
0.09644854813814163,
-0.36937886476516724,
0.19594737887382507,
0.6680712699890137,
-0.16415604948997498,
0.3661866784095764,
-0.25448182225227356,
0.06943748891353607,
0.10348153859376907,
-0.6134844422340393,
-0.29006168246269226,
0.1881566345691681,
0.4861133098602295,
-0.4497590959072113,
0.5014066100120544,
0.45829567313194275,
-0.3505801558494568,
-0.6927131414413452,
-0.149998277425766,
-0.4477657675743103,
-0.45608481764793396,
0.15496952831745148,
-0.365352988243103,
-0.575005829334259,
0.37817877531051636,
-0.19804413616657257,
0.23547185957431793,
0.6944785714149475,
0.3742225468158722,
0.05318311229348183,
1.444987416267395,
0.05929971858859062,
0.08344008028507233,
0.5489106178283691,
-0.42159438133239746,
0.1622355431318283,
-0.4986670911312103,
-0.10054369270801544,
-0.5630322098731995,
-0.6330565810203552,
-0.31690123677253723,
-0.4543992877006531,
0.5919051170349121,
0.3245774805545807,
-0.1762200891971588,
-0.1631615161895752,
-0.4709867238998413,
0.5781171917915344,
0.8329069018363953,
0.45638710260391235,
0.24216821789741516,
0.27395275235176086,
0.16620707511901855,
-0.1563873142004013,
-0.5388635396957397,
-0.12350833415985107,
1.3700188398361206,
0.02131064049899578,
1.0035028457641602,
0.410679429769516,
0.4680273234844208,
0.08617652207612991,
0.13804209232330322,
-0.5237241387367249,
0.3347744941711426,
-0.21350844204425812,
-0.5533291101455688,
-0.37312236428260803,
-0.8450857400894165,
-1.0177170038223267,
0.28248366713523865,
-0.38554471731185913,
-0.17689833045005798,
0.34096813201904297,
0.09854293614625931,
-0.7784837484359741,
0.262728214263916,
-0.715537428855896,
0.47918960452079773,
-0.39943426847457886,
-0.5702603459358215,
-0.6342793107032776,
-0.20905448496341705,
0.3290652632713318,
-0.08979948610067368,
0.2854773700237274,
-0.1627396196126938,
0.04796372354030609,
0.6140278577804565,
-0.6153552532196045,
0.4590737223625183,
-0.20246189832687378,
0.05572636425495148,
0.7129296660423279,
0.4605565071105957,
0.23070202767848969,
0.4547922611236572,
-0.2889903485774994,
0.3783717453479767,
-0.08057843893766403,
-0.657015323638916,
-1.1559264659881592,
0.6798670291900635,
-0.9934168457984924,
-0.3750486373901367,
-0.0984465554356575,
-0.4784979522228241,
-0.4295197129249573,
0.11796791106462479,
0.010407318361103535,
0.611468493938446,
0.19258251786231995,
0.47691038250923157,
0.8615772724151611,
0.5233057141304016,
-0.028884224593639374,
0.008637701161205769,
-0.03387131169438362,
-0.8346567153930664,
1.1714317798614502,
0.3214842677116394,
0.27180156111717224,
0.19790145754814148,
0.5779420733451843,
-0.1451772153377533,
-0.5142927765846252,
-0.6759417653083801,
0.1612018197774887,
-0.5579028725624084,
-0.19549846649169922,
-0.327669233083725,
-0.039621882140636444,
-0.09288293868303299,
-0.11196237057447433,
-0.2754119038581848,
-0.8075262308120728,
-0.409688264131546,
0.07201562076807022,
0.4258839786052704,
0.6104149222373962,
-0.1372653990983963,
0.1258741170167923,
-0.6717963218688965,
0.4405305087566376,
0.6887865662574768,
0.5545393824577332,
0.017012370750308037,
-0.3529011905193329,
-0.26657038927078247,
0.24696186184883118,
-0.4561978280544281,
-0.654812216758728,
0.025787681341171265,
0.1059737354516983,
1.0242335796356201,
0.9157724380493164,
0.09357935190200806,
0.3320496678352356,
0.20106889307498932,
0.3706590533256531,
0.07428326457738876,
-0.736842691898346,
0.46781933307647705,
-0.29671671986579895,
0.14347486197948456,
0.6166754364967346,
0.43507957458496094,
0.1967555284500122,
-0.15085537731647491,
-0.7485491633415222,
-0.17669682204723358,
0.5262863039970398,
0.4686700403690338,
-0.14951203763484955,
0.39975154399871826,
0.39300087094306946,
0.38508135080337524,
0.2852495312690735,
0.06310523301362991,
-0.08225913345813751,
-0.1495392620563507,
-0.3554028570652008,
-0.0034149494022130966,
0.13736647367477417,
-0.33915215730667114,
-0.5967268943786621,
0.5359438061714172,
-0.024853935465216637,
-0.23852835595607758,
-0.06333030760288239,
0.18384163081645966,
-0.3174160420894623,
-0.08929714560508728,
0.6208880543708801,
1.0743424892425537,
0.007486260961741209,
0.1572418212890625,
-0.04441290721297264,
-0.7495425343513489,
-0.05459997430443764,
0.10110325366258621,
-0.3890734910964966,
0.16008105874061584,
0.12202940136194229,
0.7136507630348206,
0.16480222344398499,
-0.5972821712493896,
0.08324358612298965,
0.012247375212609768,
-0.4024144411087036,
0.17172609269618988,
0.6394028663635254,
-0.14189733564853668,
0.3071930408477783,
0.3161091208457947,
0.5351197719573975,
0.034085944294929504,
-0.4743068516254425,
0.002501286333426833,
0.539682149887085,
-0.20085887610912323,
-0.3023454248905182,
0.6510921716690063,
0.09330464899539948,
0.005435532424598932,
0.6295115351676941,
-0.3241058588027954,
-0.40790146589279175,
0.7810857892036438,
0.04308333247900009,
0.5267078876495361,
-0.31582707166671753,
0.050537172704935074,
0.5375543832778931,
0.057023461908102036,
-0.29330599308013916,
0.5605213642120361,
-0.16515454649925232,
-0.6243447661399841,
-0.21162164211273193,
-0.2430746704339981,
-0.6347877383232117,
-0.3124690055847168,
-0.6334555149078369,
0.3085493743419647,
-0.6718472838401794,
-0.2968154549598694,
0.09523002058267593,
-0.040395669639110565,
-0.521033525466919,
0.4455971121788025,
-0.26667729020118713,
0.5210562348365784,
-0.7589561343193054,
0.30183684825897217,
0.5927829742431641,
-0.10582821071147919,
-0.7961327433586121,
-0.2365911304950714,
-0.06412279605865479,
-0.8652076125144958,
0.3359166383743286,
-0.443136602640152,
0.1261669546365738,
-0.050527796149253845,
-0.5574813485145569,
-1.1480106115341187,
0.8497001528739929,
0.42121416330337524,
-0.42869335412979126,
0.4860771894454956,
-0.07091233879327774,
0.46991387009620667,
-0.18742632865905762,
0.5116402506828308,
0.360364705324173,
0.34491264820098877,
0.47190558910369873,
-0.45657622814178467,
-0.017118696123361588,
-0.17385165393352509,
-0.25265809893608093,
0.7150659561157227,
-0.6694000959396362,
1.0781066417694092,
-0.5960894823074341,
0.04878104478120804,
-0.14018209278583527,
0.7865359783172607,
0.5360734462738037,
0.7817314267158508,
0.534000039100647,
0.8974241614341736,
1.0433330535888672,
-0.04692116752266884,
0.7834427356719971,
-0.16465499997138977,
0.13156229257583618,
1.062623381614685,
0.04453859478235245,
0.6903825998306274,
0.1841972917318344,
-0.49028679728507996,
0.6565468907356262,
0.6374000310897827,
-0.18803586065769196,
0.6355706453323364,
0.3301599323749542,
-0.3193393349647522,
-0.6273986101150513,
0.1741107702255249,
-0.6531822681427002,
0.246194526553154,
0.5058358311653137,
-0.3486485481262207,
-0.4499266743659973,
-0.12636084854602814,
-0.15860624611377716,
0.14564381539821625,
-0.5348724722862244,
0.5549452304840088,
0.07436467707157135,
-0.6891934871673584,
0.288303017616272,
-0.1951143592596054,
0.0239102765917778,
-0.6333463788032532,
-0.2246907353401184,
-0.08581193536520004,
0.2865254580974579,
-0.3909089267253876,
-1.0034445524215698,
0.21976691484451294,
-0.3976552486419678,
-0.28084442019462585,
-0.003335299901664257,
0.5827268958091736,
-0.2139521688222885,
-0.5120029449462891,
-0.2861306071281433,
0.7442630529403687,
-0.035679034888744354,
-0.6092807650566101,
-0.36726412177085876,
-0.03764841705560684,
0.21483199298381805,
0.11599712818861008,
0.4360966086387634,
0.8897478580474854,
-0.35426050424575806,
0.4773730933666229,
1.0600123405456543,
0.2354653775691986,
0.10068777948617935,
0.1447473168373108,
1.02367103099823,
-0.5389299988746643,
-0.665632426738739,
-0.6899880170822144,
0.3678198456764221,
-0.21443581581115723,
-0.7620795965194702,
0.9371647238731384,
0.7530452013015747,
0.8080272078514099,
0.14263786375522614,
0.8544641733169556,
0.43288254737854004,
0.47966268658638,
-0.42740294337272644,
0.4389774203300476,
-0.3007480204105377,
0.06011492386460304,
-0.03464788198471069,
-0.9871614575386047,
-0.2321806252002716,
0.47090235352516174,
-0.5580559968948364,
0.19772768020629883,
0.4578430950641632,
0.45289552211761475,
-0.3492186665534973,
0.5748475193977356,
0.040322694927453995,
0.02771926485002041,
0.3961889147758484,
0.5459985733032227,
0.687662661075592,
-0.15519319474697113,
0.7102659940719604,
-0.6315745711326599,
-0.5660305619239807,
-0.28746455907821655,
-0.48160281777381897,
-0.8190125226974487,
-0.1734030693769455,
-0.43238717317581177,
-0.5446314811706543,
-0.2563436031341553,
0.7890660166740417,
0.7593575716018677,
-0.939843475818634,
0.09729290008544922,
-0.28096672892570496,
0.44008421897888184,
-0.47267037630081177,
-0.20913010835647583,
0.24038812518119812,
-0.10275951772928238,
-0.5100421905517578,
0.0899692252278328,
0.10059388726949692,
0.02734413370490074,
-0.20344381034374237,
0.008533511310815811,
0.48674216866493225,
0.2364954650402069,
0.5299212336540222,
0.23494617640972137,
-0.31298401951789856,
0.11534515023231506,
0.12984363734722137,
-0.030732858926057816,
-0.004810922313481569,
0.9489784836769104,
-0.611521303653717,
0.6432175636291504,
0.7420504689216614,
0.8268765211105347,
0.2367904782295227,
0.42198053002357483,
0.4201379120349884,
-0.027026688680052757,
-0.36817532777786255,
0.5467214584350586,
0.2008609026670456,
-0.14475072920322418,
-0.33354538679122925,
0.5880922079086304,
0.5200660824775696,
-0.671246349811554,
-0.6433587670326233,
0.042304687201976776,
-0.9947201609611511,
-0.3512400686740875,
1.197025179862976,
0.3408738672733307,
-0.04067609831690788,
0.0661884993314743,
-0.49974367022514343,
-0.3345533311367035,
-0.7832005620002747,
0.8996831774711609,
0.6087875366210938,
-0.5555196404457092,
0.13478298485279083,
-0.6207607984542847,
0.4136984944343567,
0.7291250824928284,
-0.820870578289032,
-0.4430747330188751,
0.547944962978363,
0.19902464747428894,
0.12883789837360382,
0.021398507058620453,
0.045465756207704544,
0.36962565779685974,
0.2813999056816101,
-0.6362780332565308,
0.0020048171281814575,
-0.19081665575504303,
-0.050201158970594406,
0.4694444239139557,
-0.058627717196941376,
-0.18487758934497833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01054v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01054v3
|
Regularized Best-of-N Sampling to Mitigate Reward Hacking for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-04-01T11:26:50 | 2024-06-24T02:31:06 |
Yuu Jinnai, Tetsuro Morimura, Kaito Ariu, Kenshi Abe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Best-of-N (BoN) sampling with a reward model has been shown to be an
effective strategy for aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) to human
preferences at the time of decoding. BoN sampling is susceptible to a problem
known as reward hacking. Because the reward model is an imperfect proxy for the
true objective, over-optimizing its value can compromise its performance on the
true objective. A common solution to prevent reward hacking in preference
learning techniques is to optimize a reward using proximity regularization
(e.g., KL regularization), which ensures that the language model remains close
to the reference model. In this research, we propose Regularized Best-of-N
(RBoN), a variant of BoN that aims to mitigate reward hacking by incorporating
a proximity term in response selection, similar to preference learning
techniques. We evaluate RBoN on the AlpacaFarm and Anthropic's hh-rlhf datasets
and find that it outperforms BoN. As an application of RBoN, we use RBoN to
generate a pairwise preference learning dataset. Experimental results show that
a DPO model trained on a dataset generated with RBoN outperforms a DPO model
generated with vanilla BoN. Our code is available at
https://github.com/CyberAgentAILab/regularized-bon
|
[
-0.3239201307296753,
-0.5178487300872803,
0.16031809151172638,
0.0745394229888916,
-0.2633674442768097,
0.11105414479970932,
-0.3350147008895874,
-0.517475962638855,
0.5009521245956421,
0.4432651102542877,
-0.531937837600708,
-0.4303987920284271,
-0.6372801661491394,
0.27970826625823975,
-0.05305176600813866,
1.1540944576263428,
0.1897757351398468,
-0.19673024117946625,
-0.27921560406684875,
-0.18452568352222443,
-0.6480386853218079,
-0.6537084579467773,
-0.6316229104995728,
-0.33822983503341675,
0.5566221475601196,
0.4080229699611664,
0.5626642107963562,
0.7668033242225647,
0.7129756212234497,
0.1859676092863083,
0.016047367826104164,
0.16950702667236328,
-0.6753745675086975,
-0.021965019404888153,
0.019361963495612144,
-0.5224161744117737,
-0.5924449563026428,
-0.08850544691085815,
0.3938555121421814,
0.3610784113407135,
-0.1482142210006714,
-0.012471877038478851,
-0.048301905393600464,
0.8762827515602112,
-0.7825837731361389,
-0.07863812148571014,
-0.6754488945007324,
-0.26381736993789673,
-0.10230809450149536,
-0.33374252915382385,
-0.483176589012146,
-0.7836700677871704,
0.09523527324199677,
-0.4984874129295349,
0.28109830617904663,
0.14956024289131165,
1.2005683183670044,
0.46313896775245667,
-0.08816251158714294,
0.14194616675376892,
-0.6578105092048645,
1.1309534311294556,
-0.7900403738021851,
0.3792243003845215,
0.9038869142532349,
0.3750624358654022,
-0.41615381836891174,
-0.04455730691552162,
-0.4562617838382721,
-0.2791726887226105,
-0.08352203667163849,
0.04946132004261017,
-0.0619439072906971,
0.006379156373441219,
0.019073201343417168,
0.1831272840499878,
-0.7783182263374329,
0.2745361626148224,
-0.13236898183822632,
-0.20144148170948029,
0.7309907674789429,
-0.03144507110118866,
0.07665886729955673,
-0.18444214761257172,
-0.5460464954376221,
-0.3450709283351898,
-0.8253164887428284,
0.01692395843565464,
0.6783105731010437,
0.39289605617523193,
0.02936415560543537,
0.2222379595041275,
-0.3344642221927643,
1.0393307209014893,
0.07035503536462784,
-0.3201771378517151,
0.1513250321149826,
-0.4401872456073761,
-0.18337294459342957,
0.12350640445947647,
0.8077557682991028,
0.5264363288879395,
0.39722976088523865,
-0.10190308094024658,
-0.4782446324825287,
0.06573745608329773,
0.13538336753845215,
-0.6488003730773926,
-0.4828585684299469,
0.3195006549358368,
-0.5023480653762817,
-0.7039352059364319,
-0.04438963159918785,
-0.8504385948181152,
-0.04913247749209404,
-0.07454076409339905,
0.07446646690368652,
-0.20636656880378723,
-0.11374769359827042,
0.2021203637123108,
0.04277971386909485,
-0.09116628021001816,
-0.031050747260451317,
-1.2289665937423706,
0.5600834488868713,
0.47808051109313965,
0.838821291923523,
-0.317654550075531,
-0.2655625641345978,
-0.6911411881446838,
0.18140916526317596,
-0.16023977100849152,
0.7787162065505981,
-0.49525341391563416,
-0.3389624357223511,
-0.28320667147636414,
-0.3428744673728943,
0.020683297887444496,
-0.6015429496765137,
0.5772260427474976,
-0.8704633116722107,
0.3254239559173584,
-0.20718200504779816,
-0.5758686661720276,
0.14105592668056488,
0.3816746473312378,
-0.6831318140029907,
0.9362333416938782,
-0.010321247391402721,
-0.8229712247848511,
0.35472428798675537,
-0.4844677150249481,
-0.1941627413034439,
-0.0772126168012619,
-0.17584268748760223,
-0.40550684928894043,
-0.08483900874853134,
0.396284818649292,
0.2763226330280304,
-0.08964654058218002,
0.31395307183265686,
-0.2682870328426361,
-0.39242443442344666,
0.4029945135116577,
-0.24359171092510223,
0.7052883505821228,
0.11209382861852646,
-0.35723239183425903,
0.24104073643684387,
-0.4600414037704468,
-0.23352737724781036,
0.37978237867355347,
-0.29152828454971313,
-0.6647274494171143,
-0.1020367220044136,
0.027096295729279518,
0.08679641038179398,
0.22778962552547455,
-0.6595718860626221,
0.437496542930603,
-0.5834199786186218,
0.2955244481563568,
1.1891558170318604,
-0.004206877201795578,
0.39357510209083557,
-0.5697885751724243,
0.5574190616607666,
-0.42185378074645996,
0.3225614130496979,
0.09810219705104828,
-0.4842418432235718,
-0.23914150893688202,
-0.5792546272277832,
0.9822914004325867,
0.5061975717544556,
-0.2818756699562073,
0.7819600105285645,
-0.5269928574562073,
-0.0792008712887764,
-0.3924824893474579,
0.02362946979701519,
0.27105578780174255,
0.5059415102005005,
0.32259637117385864,
-0.35886073112487793,
-0.2802463471889496,
-0.9562000632286072,
-0.12025707960128784,
-0.03475894033908844,
-0.08435042202472687,
0.4538796544075012,
0.1056952252984047,
-0.09841286391019821,
1.1301645040512085,
-0.6484405994415283,
-0.34022945165634155,
-0.13188552856445312,
-0.07479240745306015,
0.17946599423885345,
0.6070016622543335,
0.669390857219696,
-0.8781317472457886,
-0.44230058789253235,
-0.1813257783651352,
-0.15276730060577393,
-0.0903615728020668,
-0.09833461046218872,
-0.41585153341293335,
0.17464397847652435,
0.04936613515019417,
-0.2369515299797058,
0.483828604221344,
0.6748309135437012,
-0.0537799671292305,
0.3142729103565216,
0.017008474096655846,
0.2618703842163086,
-1.1099857091903687,
0.39439669251441956,
-0.1562594771385193,
-0.37394824624061584,
-0.647040069103241,
-0.05109268054366112,
0.19296476244926453,
0.10927420854568481,
-0.11499062180519104,
0.7417178750038147,
-0.16747979819774628,
0.0824919044971466,
-0.5354372262954712,
0.1791641116142273,
0.12853732705116272,
0.4886327087879181,
0.27251294255256653,
0.5974372029304504,
0.203172504901886,
-0.7257916927337646,
0.2949422299861908,
0.42154231667518616,
-0.09002579003572464,
0.1384439915418625,
-0.5995757579803467,
0.49982237815856934,
-0.0032426088582724333,
0.4383390247821808,
-0.9525096416473389,
-0.4017622470855713,
0.2932972013950348,
-0.755298376083374,
0.4486646056175232,
-0.29673218727111816,
-0.4026760756969452,
0.01768144778907299,
-0.4969662129878998,
0.9556660056114197,
0.5022925138473511,
-0.6931619048118591,
0.06888961046934128,
0.36683139204978943,
-0.12096571922302246,
-0.9352434873580933,
-0.5665819048881531,
-0.13015833497047424,
-0.22791601717472076,
-0.37807291746139526,
0.5037209987640381,
-0.1736431121826172,
-0.015943128615617752,
-0.13400663435459137,
-0.10808954387903214,
0.08890422433614731,
0.1392669379711151,
-0.07774568349123001,
0.6535971164703369,
0.3902708888053894,
-0.2242942601442337,
-0.2047804296016693,
-0.3069303333759308,
-0.2096436470746994,
-0.3053642213344574,
0.7886864542961121,
0.3086591362953186,
-0.2136400192975998,
-0.39599695801734924,
0.25745925307273865,
0.3429681956768036,
-0.4339851438999176,
0.6349037885665894,
0.10122819989919662,
-0.6014881134033203,
0.05973908677697182,
-0.5548446774482727,
-0.6995548009872437,
-0.45689135789871216,
0.10936874151229858,
-0.12801161408424377,
-0.7865080833435059,
0.3803185522556305,
0.18164677917957306,
0.19290997087955475,
-0.06509843468666077,
0.44058316946029663,
0.1855187714099884,
0.9745761752128601,
0.7763097882270813,
-0.7597295641899109,
0.6774176359176636,
-0.025750329717993736,
0.41258710622787476,
-0.7383639812469482,
-0.16627436876296997,
-0.5902805328369141,
-0.5258259177207947,
-0.41696715354919434,
-0.1356298327445984,
0.25633203983306885,
0.13655401766300201,
0.22033020853996277,
0.3933144509792328,
-0.5064163208007812,
0.706407904624939,
0.6950181722640991,
0.18259015679359436,
0.11981882899999619,
0.3058018982410431,
-0.14235837757587433,
-0.004725283477455378,
-0.847154438495636,
-0.3399028182029724,
1.2437233924865723,
0.3238849937915802,
0.7019796371459961,
0.16649189591407776,
1.1741665601730347,
0.08101263642311096,
0.1330932229757309,
-0.807234525680542,
0.3269999623298645,
0.16903477907180786,
-0.48365476727485657,
-0.3174382746219635,
-0.6992923617362976,
-1.1093659400939941,
-0.2258627861738205,
-0.09950623661279678,
-0.8474805951118469,
0.36474302411079407,
0.34804657101631165,
-0.6128522753715515,
0.17961367964744568,
-0.3302132189273834,
0.7207993268966675,
-0.18206439912319183,
-0.46331587433815,
-0.1996067464351654,
-0.7039511203765869,
0.39524415135383606,
0.043106559664011,
0.23248668015003204,
-0.07746736705303192,
0.2270384281873703,
0.6964290738105774,
-0.119719959795475,
0.5472027659416199,
-0.03901844099164009,
0.10360193252563477,
-0.11479844897985458,
0.40931618213653564,
0.7352975606918335,
0.08403558284044266,
-0.02467436157166958,
0.1517951935529709,
-0.12413376569747925,
-0.7410719990730286,
-0.6758038401603699,
0.9319262504577637,
-0.5776903033256531,
-0.3081821799278259,
-0.4662311375141144,
-0.5398092269897461,
-0.3099057674407959,
0.06167251244187355,
0.2927882671356201,
0.4520342946052551,
-0.017780620604753494,
-0.11050906032323837,
0.6976128220558167,
-0.18937906622886658,
0.28773945569992065,
0.10689903795719147,
-0.17011432349681854,
-0.597521185874939,
1.0904090404510498,
-0.29510727524757385,
0.5325483679771423,
0.5197201371192932,
0.47121500968933105,
-0.4268437325954437,
-0.43974795937538147,
-0.5512388348579407,
0.2525184154510498,
-0.37520718574523926,
-0.4099026322364807,
-0.35314881801605225,
0.13548481464385986,
-0.5904864072799683,
-0.22991907596588135,
-0.37297025322914124,
-0.38111475110054016,
0.07471039891242981,
-0.07139969617128372,
0.4424786865711212,
0.5253742933273315,
-0.1488998681306839,
-0.09786654263734818,
-0.8369810581207275,
0.32749640941619873,
0.09149927645921707,
0.544140100479126,
-0.09103155136108398,
-0.5882891416549683,
-0.21990256011486053,
-0.03920130059123039,
0.04976312816143036,
-0.9211074709892273,
0.4657242000102997,
-0.1839282065629959,
0.51131272315979,
0.4131886065006256,
0.20774176716804504,
0.48467913269996643,
-0.29008612036705017,
0.6219287514686584,
0.1432540863752365,
-0.6051380038261414,
0.5981221199035645,
-0.43852394819259644,
0.23375985026359558,
0.8375744223594666,
0.4655380845069885,
-0.5699043273925781,
-0.22837179899215698,
-0.6408546566963196,
-0.8583424091339111,
0.7167404890060425,
0.33149775862693787,
-0.10518576204776764,
-0.041780225932598114,
0.4690563380718231,
0.11462332308292389,
0.1889517903327942,
-0.9020811319351196,
-0.28540530800819397,
-0.08123791217803955,
-0.3805955648422241,
-0.02261161431670189,
-0.2644602358341217,
-0.3607347011566162,
-0.02303999476134777,
0.7785358428955078,
-0.16203685104846954,
0.3784416615962982,
0.14495831727981567,
0.1602587103843689,
-0.22200213372707367,
0.04575807973742485,
0.8440777659416199,
0.48747706413269043,
-0.5840042233467102,
-0.02148907445371151,
-0.07000680267810822,
-0.4392222464084625,
0.03088236227631569,
-0.12806235253810883,
-0.32285234332084656,
-0.15981942415237427,
0.18556660413742065,
0.5434324145317078,
-0.09855526685714722,
-0.6998921632766724,
0.565762996673584,
-0.33700650930404663,
-0.20210795104503632,
0.1635838747024536,
-0.04551313817501068,
-0.19464749097824097,
-0.22031332552433014,
0.07384907454252243,
0.12367996573448181,
0.18856734037399292,
-0.26321324706077576,
0.2760993242263794,
0.4713561534881592,
-0.08513252437114716,
-0.1417972594499588,
0.47486284375190735,
0.10877621918916702,
-0.425591379404068,
0.5093045234680176,
-0.20077867805957794,
-0.6939567923545837,
0.5310782194137573,
0.6884670257568359,
0.8109290599822998,
-0.3551514446735382,
-0.10620597749948502,
0.6112033724784851,
0.392737478017807,
-0.10738261044025421,
0.131349578499794,
-0.19066090881824493,
-0.7567915916442871,
-0.3317851424217224,
-0.4894188940525055,
-0.42022648453712463,
0.24571745097637177,
-0.7991002798080444,
0.25322064757347107,
-0.6025357842445374,
-0.0767078623175621,
-0.5462400317192078,
-0.14979641139507294,
-0.44212156534194946,
0.12797868251800537,
0.06626005470752716,
0.6541879773139954,
-0.8933247923851013,
0.9831924438476562,
0.6297960877418518,
-0.0534466989338398,
-0.8560354113578796,
0.3698815703392029,
-0.02443765103816986,
-0.41820335388183594,
0.5964967608451843,
0.05001811310648918,
-0.22266952693462372,
-0.14313828945159912,
-0.45849478244781494,
-1.0268126726150513,
0.8542124032974243,
0.2559370994567871,
-0.7047809362411499,
0.2958053648471832,
-0.1766759753227234,
0.22805199027061462,
-0.17900238931179047,
0.23354193568229675,
0.5513215661048889,
0.3864622414112091,
-0.20554788410663605,
-0.9266756772994995,
0.0353587307035923,
-0.10317211598157883,
-0.084373839199543,
0.48054268956184387,
-0.8736961483955383,
0.345601886510849,
0.10681719332933426,
0.002825989620760083,
-0.11977041512727737,
0.4088631570339203,
0.6381938457489014,
0.10377915948629379,
0.6811115741729736,
0.5515474081039429,
0.8089700937271118,
0.1473229080438614,
1.0058199167251587,
-0.40269991755485535,
0.39676952362060547,
1.085018277168274,
-0.22058537602424622,
0.8407482504844666,
0.6368820667266846,
-0.0051012542098760605,
0.27145975828170776,
0.829846203327179,
0.19331198930740356,
0.8841256499290466,
0.2662021517753601,
-0.2312452346086502,
-0.07222690433263779,
-0.056737497448921204,
-0.24469611048698425,
0.3216768205165863,
-0.031192339956760406,
0.013157546520233154,
0.015944957733154297,
-0.18066275119781494,
-0.32005658745765686,
0.28517773747444153,
-0.02063535526394844,
0.7471442818641663,
-0.22220392525196075,
-0.5997704267501831,
0.9005621671676636,
0.2835262417793274,
0.838854968547821,
-0.5693863034248352,
-0.03547012433409691,
-0.5622413754463196,
-0.056921713054180145,
-0.33492353558540344,
-0.15687334537506104,
0.1380370855331421,
-0.00525697460398078,
-0.2584264874458313,
-0.11351671069860458,
0.6221039295196533,
-0.4180743098258972,
-0.17870543897151947,
0.34835439920425415,
-0.06679394096136093,
0.13266626000404358,
0.12687060236930847,
-0.6421754360198975,
0.15089423954486847,
0.15315969288349152,
-0.22477036714553833,
0.6865495443344116,
-0.13959848880767822,
-0.1649276316165924,
0.64975506067276,
0.7621305584907532,
0.16761068999767303,
0.0691557303071022,
0.0015926627675071359,
0.7407549619674683,
-0.44851741194725037,
-0.7006316184997559,
-1.0644683837890625,
0.08595523983240128,
-0.07762494683265686,
-0.1926434189081192,
0.6876781582832336,
0.6965219378471375,
1.0402992963790894,
-0.017016449943184853,
0.6688705682754517,
0.17920410633087158,
0.4222438633441925,
-0.579210102558136,
0.5107558369636536,
-0.5526511669158936,
0.2344123125076294,
-0.3079356849193573,
-1.0381425619125366,
-0.42901667952537537,
0.8730166554450989,
-0.27258482575416565,
-0.013254002667963505,
0.6406563520431519,
0.988391101360321,
-0.2054993063211441,
-0.048205237835645676,
0.294359415769577,
-0.41258227825164795,
0.3359406590461731,
0.6651235818862915,
0.5736648440361023,
-0.37511029839515686,
0.25777667760849,
-0.5876001119613647,
-0.562544584274292,
-0.39450007677078247,
-0.9870657920837402,
-0.8450835347175598,
-0.3744342029094696,
-0.1549505591392517,
-0.4873969852924347,
-0.010076564736664295,
1.3235340118408203,
0.9004173278808594,
-0.9915001392364502,
-0.32099658250808716,
-0.14885495603084564,
0.1525561362504959,
-0.32261332869529724,
-0.23942430317401886,
0.42661917209625244,
-0.14801964163780212,
-0.8483059406280518,
0.6648916006088257,
0.29562661051750183,
-0.02293449267745018,
-0.07801859825849533,
-0.18205797672271729,
-0.32199859619140625,
0.06680615246295929,
0.01083650067448616,
0.310045063495636,
-0.5287909507751465,
-0.4114599823951721,
0.2617342174053192,
-0.06638644635677338,
0.221249058842659,
0.9358968138694763,
-0.7193399667739868,
0.45419031381607056,
0.46257275342941284,
1.061112642288208,
0.22725887596607208,
0.32538947463035583,
0.6489863991737366,
-0.8883548378944397,
0.15024496614933014,
0.4254319965839386,
0.20453320443630219,
0.32368233799934387,
-0.7020448446273804,
0.30714845657348633,
0.14857831597328186,
-0.8506512641906738,
-1.0267677307128906,
0.5405141115188599,
-0.9450516700744629,
-0.1467227339744568,
1.1728639602661133,
-0.0070164077915251255,
-0.3223986327648163,
0.03729066625237465,
-0.16325941681861877,
0.07978445291519165,
-0.613545835018158,
1.2450437545776367,
0.7123668789863586,
-0.20362555980682373,
0.13082604110240936,
-0.4451538324356079,
0.7187412977218628,
0.9209258556365967,
-0.5955256223678589,
0.1798526644706726,
0.4313703775405884,
0.37367478013038635,
0.02735552377998829,
0.7421116232872009,
-0.060739368200302124,
0.28394415974617004,
-0.4265199601650238,
0.2699905335903168,
-0.17396357655525208,
-0.5299392342567444,
-0.6855282187461853,
-0.08654479682445526,
0.31733158230781555,
-0.4615035951137543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01037v1
|
ARAGOG: Advanced RAG Output Grading
| 2024-04-01T10:43:52 | 2024-04-01T10:43:52 |
Matouš Eibich, Shivay Nagpal, Alexander Fred-Ojala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is essential for integrating external
knowledge into Large Language Model (LLM) outputs. While the literature on RAG
is growing, it primarily focuses on systematic reviews and comparisons of new
state-of-the-art (SoTA) techniques against their predecessors, with a gap in
extensive experimental comparisons. This study begins to address this gap by
assessing various RAG methods' impacts on retrieval precision and answer
similarity. We found that Hypothetical Document Embedding (HyDE) and LLM
reranking significantly enhance retrieval precision. However, Maximal Marginal
Relevance (MMR) and Cohere rerank did not exhibit notable advantages over a
baseline Naive RAG system, and Multi-query approaches underperformed. Sentence
Window Retrieval emerged as the most effective for retrieval precision, despite
its variable performance on answer similarity. The study confirms the potential
of the Document Summary Index as a competent retrieval approach. All resources
related to this research are publicly accessible for further investigation
through our GitHub repository ARAGOG (https://github.com/predlico/ARAGOG). We
welcome the community to further this exploratory study in RAG systems.
|
[
-0.46623101830482483,
-0.8594292998313904,
0.5134630799293518,
-0.22988077998161316,
-0.07399612665176392,
0.2902469038963318,
-0.23411045968532562,
-0.3994961380958557,
0.3538219630718231,
0.44861334562301636,
0.3137452304363251,
-0.5115659236907959,
-1.0100568532943726,
0.10290657728910446,
-0.5175301432609558,
1.3107963800430298,
0.09733180701732635,
0.03843722119927406,
-0.1348269134759903,
-0.33556100726127625,
-0.1544615477323532,
-0.39874520897865295,
-0.8157311677932739,
-0.35717788338661194,
0.5168460607528687,
0.491422563791275,
0.5935963988304138,
0.8229424953460693,
0.802358090877533,
0.2792801260948181,
-0.3267694115638733,
0.4217855632305145,
-0.4985126256942749,
0.18779858946800232,
-0.029889019206166267,
-0.5032230615615845,
-0.8565572500228882,
0.2943141460418701,
0.8462275266647339,
0.45293140411376953,
-0.4239911437034607,
0.4018433094024658,
0.327085942029953,
0.9227735996246338,
-0.7970983386039734,
-0.1046319380402565,
-0.5263035297393799,
-0.2985563278198242,
-0.47615984082221985,
-0.28418171405792236,
-0.42118436098098755,
-0.48039913177490234,
-0.09519186615943909,
-0.7852523326873779,
0.41900187730789185,
0.18438926339149475,
1.1479308605194092,
0.32838353514671326,
-0.46944424510002136,
-0.6835429668426514,
-0.5328512787818909,
0.601276159286499,
-0.5648120641708374,
0.2342156022787094,
0.48461592197418213,
0.38424357771873474,
-0.08595684915781021,
-0.7764478921890259,
-0.31024888157844543,
-0.29807159304618835,
-0.08464410901069641,
0.4194135069847107,
-0.017640290781855583,
0.08452920615673065,
0.26701024174690247,
0.7373747229576111,
-0.4718787968158722,
-0.1803971827030182,
-0.4402244985103607,
0.2491893619298935,
0.48643478751182556,
-0.16059719026088715,
-0.11522472649812698,
-0.3075212240219116,
-0.19219103455543518,
-0.32503023743629456,
-0.6389096975326538,
-0.10376784205436707,
0.6435474753379822,
0.1501259207725525,
0.33895066380500793,
0.6087602972984314,
-0.10323551297187805,
0.8333242535591125,
0.20552979409694672,
-0.174024760723114,
0.22554723918437958,
-0.11259040236473083,
0.04898495227098465,
-0.2776704430580139,
0.5679054260253906,
0.42487290501594543,
0.05696319043636322,
-0.10058631747961044,
-0.297405481338501,
-0.20124001801013947,
0.6068968176841736,
-0.31185269355773926,
0.07795531302690506,
-0.28167468309402466,
-0.2941260039806366,
-0.32381030917167664,
0.25486043095588684,
-0.7476853728294373,
-0.43434932827949524,
-0.12048298120498657,
0.5484954714775085,
-0.24254533648490906,
-0.055361613631248474,
-0.23197177052497864,
-0.3472098410129547,
0.2485794723033905,
0.3769400119781494,
-0.591545581817627,
0.41121259331703186,
1.0029149055480957,
0.7458073496818542,
-0.43692097067832947,
-0.14133025705814362,
-0.7166021466255188,
0.26336055994033813,
-0.6621860861778259,
1.0236433744430542,
-0.5309079885482788,
-0.34252747893333435,
-0.14084650576114655,
-0.4149217903614044,
0.1493181735277176,
-0.9094787240028381,
0.9291927814483643,
-0.8302125334739685,
0.18870742619037628,
-0.07201721519231796,
-0.6113694906234741,
-0.24311891198158264,
0.3416910171508789,
-0.5506614446640015,
1.2930004596710205,
0.08840256184339523,
-0.7948431372642517,
0.3548043370246887,
-0.24575625360012054,
-0.2164420783519745,
0.046150486916303635,
-0.2862285077571869,
-0.317709356546402,
0.23885184526443481,
-0.08405182510614395,
0.24872922897338867,
-0.5060573816299438,
0.23975691199302673,
-0.045526809990406036,
-0.5083935260772705,
-0.16121624410152435,
-0.26445576548576355,
0.09920763969421387,
0.3289901912212372,
-0.14869435131549835,
-0.14179882407188416,
-0.7823599576950073,
0.05209416523575783,
-0.06704527884721756,
-0.5819074511528015,
-0.6630016565322876,
-0.2538585066795349,
-0.23582834005355835,
-0.3337610065937042,
0.4566452205181122,
-0.31849947571754456,
0.1407696157693863,
-0.17514465749263763,
-0.18263711035251617,
0.7327499389648438,
-0.2137688398361206,
0.6644206047058105,
-0.484925240278244,
0.808626115322113,
-0.6510985493659973,
-0.14538465440273285,
-0.06823735684156418,
-0.5270047783851624,
-0.717877984046936,
0.02348347380757332,
0.7765777111053467,
0.5889405608177185,
-0.5226552486419678,
0.18468883633613586,
-0.36504679918289185,
-0.5732548832893372,
-0.7077480554580688,
-0.012170444242656231,
0.8455160856246948,
0.6045396327972412,
0.1916736364364624,
-0.35398420691490173,
-0.3904182016849518,
-0.9299549460411072,
-0.4162276089191437,
-0.20138674974441528,
-0.05647781491279602,
0.6468785405158997,
0.06334716826677322,
0.020000038668513298,
0.5345435738563538,
-0.7564813494682312,
-0.3297516405582428,
0.004994471091777086,
0.27333271503448486,
0.45729485154151917,
0.1376313418149948,
0.29401421546936035,
-0.7858061194419861,
-0.7231854200363159,
0.23030434548854828,
-0.648672878742218,
-0.3020685613155365,
0.4824996292591095,
-0.1654077023267746,
0.5708138942718506,
0.6890072822570801,
-0.28842249512672424,
0.4349340498447418,
0.759452223777771,
0.00728135509416461,
0.5753816366195679,
-0.4529813528060913,
0.6481738686561584,
-0.9327598214149475,
0.4071487486362457,
-0.20580445230007172,
-0.3067467510700226,
-0.42523565888404846,
0.6231021285057068,
0.0697360411286354,
0.11806582659482956,
0.03387871012091637,
0.5801472663879395,
-0.4180944263935089,
-0.335093230009079,
-0.5621001124382019,
0.3817749321460724,
0.2560604214668274,
0.006849528290331364,
-0.3778245151042938,
1.3313757181167603,
0.044873692095279694,
-0.6415180563926697,
-0.024515803903341293,
-0.02954409271478653,
-0.032257694751024246,
0.3094344735145569,
-0.6021928191184998,
0.3801896572113037,
-0.045351143926382065,
0.2644183337688446,
-0.9857295155525208,
-0.13915754854679108,
-0.0047570522874593735,
-0.9210918545722961,
0.7453821897506714,
-0.3950023949146271,
-0.3462851643562317,
0.09321778267621994,
-0.48731574416160583,
0.2099730223417282,
0.6276140809059143,
-0.26003193855285645,
0.5161063075065613,
0.6954849362373352,
-0.2712448537349701,
-0.892993688583374,
-0.2765690088272095,
0.08358227461576462,
-0.37478798627853394,
-0.4271847605705261,
0.3593400716781616,
0.2478632777929306,
-0.3698992133140564,
-0.05212390050292015,
-0.3041056990623474,
0.20051048696041107,
-0.09375908225774765,
-0.13499194383621216,
-0.020965393632650375,
-0.12897031009197235,
0.25812453031539917,
-0.09137250483036041,
-0.4177950322628021,
-0.2111349105834961,
0.07520275563001633,
0.6119665503501892,
-0.31696444749832153,
-0.09890162199735641,
0.5932533740997314,
0.383053719997406,
0.15708747506141663,
-0.30536654591560364,
0.5761189460754395,
0.6519385576248169,
-0.1526775360107422,
0.0028786754701286554,
-0.684339702129364,
0.09349799156188965,
-0.46778297424316406,
0.19022400677204132,
-0.39432698488235474,
-0.8848491311073303,
0.6194015741348267,
-0.12134166806936264,
0.039033759385347366,
0.5926095247268677,
0.3433149456977844,
-0.2945244014263153,
0.8200677633285522,
0.5516859292984009,
0.3816661536693573,
0.33329179883003235,
-0.4644453525543213,
-0.00839162152260542,
-1.370766282081604,
0.03559163585305214,
-0.8215420842170715,
-0.21488821506500244,
-0.937126874923706,
-0.692090630531311,
0.6086506843566895,
0.7183091044425964,
-0.02445698156952858,
0.08864752948284149,
-0.583186686038971,
0.4098629355430603,
0.653571605682373,
-0.11705058068037033,
0.4573741853237152,
0.010511540807783604,
-0.06703387200832367,
0.0004249153716955334,
-0.6082854270935059,
-0.882283627986908,
1.364195466041565,
-0.007618346251547337,
0.7779227495193481,
0.22439484298229218,
0.9026262760162354,
0.4358213543891907,
0.48153793811798096,
-0.6653809547424316,
0.5532881021499634,
-0.7565100193023682,
-0.5113872289657593,
-0.3736657202243805,
-0.40760383009910583,
-1.3424344062805176,
0.21354082226753235,
-0.08833657205104828,
-0.41238152980804443,
-0.21414397656917572,
0.2129344940185547,
-0.11347965896129608,
0.06760025024414062,
-0.7288125157356262,
0.27164146304130554,
0.11745774000883102,
-0.3683707118034363,
-0.33993643522262573,
-0.41268372535705566,
0.1609915941953659,
-0.10072483867406845,
0.3444094955921173,
0.0017657785210758448,
-0.32704225182533264,
0.8862193822860718,
-0.07096055895090103,
0.13983957469463348,
0.029859578236937523,
-0.23279303312301636,
0.2804396450519562,
0.11987974494695663,
0.480648398399353,
-0.02534359320998192,
-0.3868195414543152,
0.037919070571660995,
-0.3459562361240387,
-0.2680794298648834,
-0.76163649559021,
0.9396379590034485,
-0.6591089963912964,
-1.0150147676467896,
-0.6765665411949158,
-0.5570242404937744,
0.008606931194663048,
0.354704886674881,
0.2697204053401947,
0.37489834427833557,
0.0943480134010315,
0.22880561649799347,
0.8090071082115173,
-0.2834111452102661,
0.08548911660909653,
0.564082682132721,
-0.5796001553535461,
-0.6232718825340271,
0.8433302640914917,
0.5387962460517883,
0.305705726146698,
0.42271268367767334,
0.30052095651626587,
-0.26917892694473267,
-0.6112252473831177,
-0.5318354368209839,
0.2214716374874115,
-0.7768634557723999,
-0.4537341892719269,
-0.6761863231658936,
-0.15078957378864288,
-0.6215811967849731,
-0.07401175796985626,
-0.2613605260848999,
-0.6201805472373962,
-0.09107181429862976,
-0.042065925896167755,
0.6092873811721802,
1.0451682806015015,
-0.22837772965431213,
0.15319447219371796,
-0.7575876712799072,
0.5384643077850342,
0.06102962791919708,
0.49976134300231934,
-0.010483774356544018,
-0.7989856600761414,
-0.33021479845046997,
-0.3001420497894287,
-0.41872313618659973,
-0.8390865921974182,
0.16820622980594635,
0.20576128363609314,
0.6650760173797607,
0.03624362498521805,
0.025291357189416885,
0.6538781523704529,
-0.696488082408905,
0.5042776465415955,
-0.32306262850761414,
-0.5203821659088135,
0.5004343390464783,
-0.6319495439529419,
0.13272280991077423,
0.6975527405738831,
0.240926131606102,
-0.4294666647911072,
-0.5422173142433167,
-0.7707441449165344,
-1.1454986333847046,
0.5796249508857727,
-0.016405301168560982,
-0.20727355778217316,
-0.12302865087985992,
0.6375677585601807,
0.13744336366653442,
0.044210582971572876,
-0.13481192290782928,
-0.42017441987991333,
0.3904733657836914,
0.07519454509019852,
-0.3051271140575409,
-0.14693781733512878,
-0.02484685182571411,
0.12102819979190826,
0.7567452192306519,
-0.061478391289711,
0.09754874557256699,
0.23100592195987701,
0.016020517796278,
0.020064016804099083,
0.3194406032562256,
0.4220508337020874,
0.6341944932937622,
-0.3066667914390564,
0.16429592669010162,
0.35441842675209045,
-0.6152215003967285,
0.17550204694271088,
0.11855214089155197,
-0.3927440941333771,
-0.0072434102185070515,
0.2920604646205902,
0.38673216104507446,
-0.07684876769781113,
-0.3960285186767578,
0.2465902715921402,
0.0031584270764142275,
0.11639416962862015,
-0.3511994779109955,
0.03502735123038292,
-0.0959911048412323,
0.05453629046678543,
0.7353092432022095,
0.07887845486402512,
0.6965309977531433,
-0.38135403394699097,
0.33701127767562866,
0.32124224305152893,
-0.0970325842499733,
0.1560606211423874,
0.3491625189781189,
-0.05508633702993393,
-0.6684862971305847,
0.23245055973529816,
-0.3264703154563904,
-0.39643293619155884,
0.6298326849937439,
0.4325663149356842,
0.5883345007896423,
-0.13780897855758667,
0.081290103495121,
0.39861124753952026,
0.2165185809135437,
-0.10716971009969711,
0.11141064018011093,
0.00012957521539647132,
-0.3671673536300659,
-0.568472146987915,
-0.7409285306930542,
-0.5539276599884033,
-0.1139426976442337,
-1.076395869255066,
0.24810543656349182,
-0.2669016122817993,
-0.35568079352378845,
-0.26827743649482727,
0.3675256371498108,
-0.2790670096874237,
0.16356141865253448,
-0.12384822964668274,
0.712867259979248,
-0.4915536046028137,
0.514803946018219,
1.2891896963119507,
-0.25594305992126465,
-0.8474498987197876,
0.16260813176631927,
-0.21702295541763306,
-0.693305492401123,
0.2905544638633728,
0.06369408220052719,
-0.48731163144111633,
0.12519080936908722,
-0.14757977426052094,
-1.0583384037017822,
1.0956361293792725,
0.32674434781074524,
-0.2141062319278717,
-0.006973242852836847,
-0.27102744579315186,
0.7986845970153809,
-0.025846632197499275,
0.6919460892677307,
0.5987768769264221,
0.353910356760025,
-0.027238622307777405,
-1.102012038230896,
-0.26643526554107666,
-0.36000895500183105,
0.09253580123186111,
0.6478070020675659,
-0.8959773778915405,
0.6443862915039062,
-0.007339485455304384,
-0.18079572916030884,
-0.038126301020383835,
0.5297282934188843,
0.8032383918762207,
0.4164644479751587,
0.2755111753940582,
1.098966121673584,
0.5699856877326965,
-0.11496564000844955,
1.3041337728500366,
-0.12540726363658905,
0.25881487131118774,
1.081786870956421,
-0.10539881139993668,
1.094053864479065,
0.4502006769180298,
-0.26651713252067566,
0.39081302285194397,
0.34018439054489136,
0.36781471967697144,
0.35242608189582825,
0.3065921664237976,
-0.04964854568243027,
0.11651375889778137,
-0.3580459952354431,
-0.5040818452835083,
0.34850743412971497,
0.40737396478652954,
-0.2543709874153137,
-0.2912331223487854,
-0.18652832508087158,
0.1051119938492775,
0.5771707892417908,
-0.24417589604854584,
1.021899938583374,
0.06979893147945404,
-0.9458923935890198,
0.6214473843574524,
0.15520338714122772,
0.9039215445518494,
-0.5161105990409851,
-0.4466480612754822,
-0.5317090749740601,
0.2880038917064667,
-0.1799386888742447,
-0.884663999080658,
0.4886496067047119,
0.18144991993904114,
-0.30382803082466125,
-0.26958033442497253,
0.7729516625404358,
-0.19224080443382263,
-0.2901611626148224,
0.4894534647464752,
0.4623258709907532,
0.4492172300815582,
0.2254800945520401,
-0.4703048765659332,
0.11819274723529816,
-0.12830375134944916,
-0.3623575270175934,
0.470959335565567,
0.6080710887908936,
-0.1383979767560959,
0.4809941053390503,
0.4198664724826813,
0.2274099886417389,
0.3033908009529114,
0.055630072951316833,
0.6473225355148315,
-0.3688592314720154,
-0.29868239164352417,
-0.4653719365596771,
0.09011152386665344,
-0.026502035558223724,
-0.2988223433494568,
0.9892075061798096,
0.771538496017456,
0.9436424970626831,
0.2686394155025482,
0.48103219270706177,
-0.29391106963157654,
1.0172154903411865,
-0.36055171489715576,
0.7435378432273865,
-0.7498016357421875,
0.3498423993587494,
-0.339560329914093,
-1.0608989000320435,
-0.13768929243087769,
0.5622861385345459,
-0.2241044044494629,
0.19164913892745972,
0.5985159873962402,
0.7674776911735535,
0.06523419171571732,
-0.5262110829353333,
0.34829217195510864,
-0.07561834901571274,
0.3196113705635071,
0.13131847977638245,
0.6666548252105713,
-0.7895874381065369,
0.7856083512306213,
0.04165733605623245,
-0.4988734722137451,
-0.06468867510557175,
-0.6733927726745605,
-0.3559408485889435,
-0.6020122170448303,
-0.06841423362493515,
-0.46887704730033875,
0.48205551505088806,
0.39948201179504395,
0.35642895102500916,
-0.5474573373794556,
-0.30502378940582275,
0.1005222350358963,
0.009859810583293438,
-0.016514770686626434,
-0.23231568932533264,
0.5926710963249207,
-0.4237566888332367,
-0.7794963717460632,
0.22551418840885162,
0.1269157975912094,
-0.28480446338653564,
-0.004735816735774279,
-0.2615407109260559,
-0.5289968848228455,
-0.1005488857626915,
0.3529617488384247,
0.041727662086486816,
-0.7278740406036377,
-0.18580521643161774,
0.2284315675497055,
-0.22643157839775085,
0.16344860196113586,
0.5270560383796692,
-0.770550012588501,
0.3322314918041229,
0.8377156853675842,
0.6658243536949158,
0.5561997294425964,
0.4815303385257721,
0.5743566155433655,
-0.7879273891448975,
-0.2505536675453186,
0.2968486249446869,
-0.007723855786025524,
0.39698487520217896,
-0.31392499804496765,
0.8130964040756226,
-0.21977606415748596,
-0.9663752913475037,
-0.879998505115509,
0.1340789496898651,
-0.6009819507598877,
0.055590249598026276,
1.284197449684143,
-0.34337496757507324,
-0.03680336847901344,
0.06349057704210281,
-0.3584897220134735,
0.49813225865364075,
-0.5347521901130676,
0.8296828269958496,
0.8257738947868347,
-0.06749039143323898,
-0.21963606774806976,
-0.5858153700828552,
0.3676498830318451,
0.4489825963973999,
-0.670406699180603,
-0.07940982282161713,
0.2634102404117584,
0.03368060290813446,
0.6315662264823914,
0.6956784725189209,
-0.3546980321407318,
0.27636146545410156,
-0.08484773337841034,
0.15098562836647034,
0.07551010698080063,
-0.34483104944229126,
-0.5339908599853516,
0.14196330308914185,
0.3507879972457886,
0.007152548059821129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01029v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01029v1
|
Verifying Claims About Metaphors with Large-Scale Automatic Metaphor Identification
| 2024-04-01T10:17:45 | 2024-04-01T10:17:45 |
Kotaro Aono, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There are several linguistic claims about situations where words are more
likely to be used as metaphors. However, few studies have sought to verify such
claims with large corpora. This study entails a large-scale, corpus-based
analysis of certain existing claims about verb metaphors, by applying metaphor
detection to sentences extracted from Common Crawl and using the statistics
obtained from the results. The verification results indicate that the direct
objects of verbs used as metaphors tend to have lower degrees of concreteness,
imageability, and familiarity, and that metaphors are more likely to be used in
emotional and subjective sentences.
|
[
-0.5429582595825195,
-0.8391672968864441,
0.7448341846466064,
0.21648108959197998,
-0.31549039483070374,
-0.13770611584186554,
-0.3673670291900635,
-0.6911668181419373,
0.3897218704223633,
0.1146712526679039,
-0.17730486392974854,
-0.17187735438346863,
-0.8774972558021545,
0.5462213158607483,
-0.7781199812889099,
0.37631887197494507,
0.0032450389117002487,
-0.1747414916753769,
-0.32458850741386414,
-0.10097174346446991,
-0.8524727821350098,
-0.6016011238098145,
-0.72217857837677,
-0.015879392623901367,
0.6948856115341187,
0.038070905953645706,
0.9093238711357117,
0.5367481708526611,
0.7992767095565796,
0.4151673913002014,
-0.03970450535416603,
0.030680084601044655,
-0.006879627704620361,
0.14195440709590912,
-0.34195849299430847,
-0.7005909085273743,
0.014264378696680069,
0.18944630026817322,
0.6564258933067322,
0.5070957541465759,
0.03621553257107735,
0.07050248235464096,
-0.41146379709243774,
0.4187438488006592,
-0.9093355536460876,
0.07542402297258377,
-0.9854683876037598,
0.26295071840286255,
-0.19312241673469543,
-0.4179462790489197,
-0.39056146144866943,
-0.12100392580032349,
0.22713778913021088,
-0.3495100736618042,
0.24052664637565613,
0.46569615602493286,
1.1367385387420654,
0.10233491659164429,
-0.6805049777030945,
-0.6729533076286316,
-0.43591639399528503,
0.7883290648460388,
-0.4002380967140198,
0.32015442848205566,
0.46079105138778687,
0.6177299618721008,
-0.19324512779712677,
-0.7987644672393799,
-0.8087262511253357,
-0.7206465601921082,
-0.3876589834690094,
0.004624037072062492,
-0.43545180559158325,
0.0622437410056591,
0.49203407764434814,
0.2976987957954407,
-0.47863438725471497,
0.13016119599342346,
-0.3437183201313019,
-0.3964478671550751,
0.39421558380126953,
0.10464103519916534,
0.7731614112854004,
-0.419880211353302,
-0.5255116820335388,
-0.35693371295928955,
-0.7369908094406128,
-0.058735769242048264,
0.27431216835975647,
0.11005468666553497,
0.011175036430358887,
0.8684627413749695,
-0.011326148174703121,
0.6946549415588379,
-0.1969449669122696,
-0.28574633598327637,
0.3914254605770111,
-0.0365133211016655,
-0.3329136371612549,
0.38966432213783264,
0.44362562894821167,
0.6895108222961426,
0.6205287575721741,
-0.24784943461418152,
-0.30431437492370605,
0.5562706589698792,
0.3569788634777069,
-0.4577392041683197,
0.27564671635627747,
0.2602359652519226,
-0.471037358045578,
-0.067393459379673,
0.27252936363220215,
-0.7427312135696411,
-0.5235455632209778,
-0.3448147773742676,
0.3500160276889801,
-0.5202517509460449,
-0.22621972858905792,
0.1681680977344513,
-0.7387833595275879,
0.45751896500587463,
0.2606803774833679,
-0.3869841694831848,
0.3413422405719757,
0.8475298881530762,
0.9313950538635254,
-0.2366078943014145,
-0.4075700640678406,
-0.5982254147529602,
0.13061657547950745,
-0.5598415732383728,
0.9785139560699463,
-0.5333480834960938,
-0.06911205500364304,
0.31577038764953613,
0.2632477283477783,
-0.11437314748764038,
-0.7645012140274048,
0.5985279679298401,
-0.6727920770645142,
0.14054462313652039,
-0.24560852348804474,
-0.7051606774330139,
-0.37323811650276184,
0.6397911310195923,
-0.8033032417297363,
0.8031491637229919,
0.11812470853328705,
-0.9098377823829651,
0.410064160823822,
-0.3773641884326935,
-0.3290753662586212,
-0.2757084369659424,
-0.46859005093574524,
0.09854907542467117,
0.49257683753967285,
-0.21655155718326569,
0.5772093534469604,
-0.6451111435890198,
0.27304208278656006,
-0.14006850123405457,
-0.32061973214149475,
0.8439354300498962,
-0.13802023231983185,
0.689275860786438,
0.4180881977081299,
-0.5243631601333618,
-0.03668805584311485,
-0.3334982395172119,
-0.3373628258705139,
0.3578914701938629,
0.1829928606748581,
-0.7644269466400146,
-0.05567888915538788,
0.18485994637012482,
0.07036110013723373,
0.013726889155805111,
-0.7581261992454529,
0.1985187977552414,
-0.25014621019363403,
0.21068279445171356,
0.3896995782852173,
-0.05484601855278015,
0.09534101188182831,
-0.6041917204856873,
0.5931415557861328,
0.1432403177022934,
-0.3888589143753052,
-0.050764091312885284,
-0.4099859893321991,
-0.5482848286628723,
-0.6886891722679138,
0.5111327171325684,
0.3406045138835907,
-0.43103212118148804,
0.3673797845840454,
-0.6019394397735596,
-0.39407435059547424,
-0.05227232724428177,
-0.22302323579788208,
0.11488262563943863,
0.49315160512924194,
0.2540481686592102,
-0.2746562957763672,
-0.5470618009567261,
-1.0717792510986328,
-0.31008175015449524,
-0.28918275237083435,
-0.34521690011024475,
0.32225149869918823,
0.659091591835022,
-0.22563862800598145,
1.1381839513778687,
-0.6357834339141846,
-0.3151737451553345,
0.04937215521931648,
0.276465505361557,
0.010159360244870186,
0.17972196638584137,
1.0695466995239258,
-1.1683368682861328,
-0.28475281596183777,
-0.3806335926055908,
-0.6768865585327148,
-0.035878099501132965,
-0.18727825582027435,
-0.01731904409825802,
0.2228546440601349,
0.7765054106712341,
-0.7793726921081543,
0.25128909945487976,
0.34770429134368896,
-0.5912995338439941,
0.5074870586395264,
-0.19966605305671692,
0.16532061994075775,
-0.7176146507263184,
0.0030982638709247112,
0.22600270807743073,
-0.2493954598903656,
-0.02372664213180542,
0.28780925273895264,
-0.07227197289466858,
0.3093104064464569,
-0.44849810004234314,
0.6232119798660278,
-0.48595529794692993,
-0.06619882583618164,
-0.302578330039978,
0.40202972292900085,
-0.23257289826869965,
-0.19025884568691254,
0.3007389008998871,
0.6352483630180359,
0.8275124430656433,
-0.6960110664367676,
0.7001356482505798,
-0.08573174476623535,
-0.35142162442207336,
0.6114211082458496,
-0.6715534925460815,
-0.11616522073745728,
-0.45209425687789917,
0.4454076290130615,
-1.2521770000457764,
-0.4249226748943329,
-0.09962150454521179,
-0.2566605806350708,
-0.08751967549324036,
0.21068783104419708,
-0.934830904006958,
-0.3265792429447174,
-0.2952651381492615,
0.26716282963752747,
0.6625422835350037,
-0.6273839473724365,
0.6635398864746094,
0.4105970859527588,
0.17847348749637604,
-0.35636383295059204,
-0.5364828705787659,
0.2727624475955963,
-0.7627797722816467,
-0.32456251978874207,
0.3064218759536743,
0.19870509207248688,
-0.799933135509491,
-0.15360836684703827,
-0.016784226521849632,
-0.19802096486091614,
0.18213368952274323,
0.4332139492034912,
0.37476927042007446,
-0.045338936150074005,
0.24113963544368744,
-0.19388845562934875,
0.01802530698478222,
0.38605576753616333,
0.11342109739780426,
0.7285857200622559,
-0.1759098768234253,
-0.2533720135688782,
-0.1166137084364891,
0.3112260103225708,
0.8426064252853394,
0.014617756940424442,
0.6929280161857605,
0.6808133721351624,
-0.6050798296928406,
0.12344629317522049,
-0.7349684238433838,
-0.07593432068824768,
-0.4002312421798706,
-0.01025581918656826,
-0.33843016624450684,
-0.5646805763244629,
0.44597819447517395,
-0.21477840840816498,
-0.2749577760696411,
0.6724132895469666,
0.3354450762271881,
-0.1790834665298462,
0.45535123348236084,
0.12734296917915344,
-0.2592150568962097,
0.052448078989982605,
0.057029180228710175,
0.10929319262504578,
-0.6397296190261841,
-0.06606713682413101,
-0.9553186893463135,
-0.40988826751708984,
-0.9511545896530151,
-0.5050179362297058,
0.060745857656002045,
-0.3230310082435608,
-0.28882935643196106,
0.43322062492370605,
-0.3170984387397766,
0.2387111335992813,
0.46686872839927673,
-0.2752457559108734,
0.4382026791572571,
0.09229069203138351,
-0.17559540271759033,
0.13287772238254547,
-0.17015302181243896,
-0.6931782960891724,
0.6208803653717041,
0.3104158043861389,
0.2589767575263977,
0.21488717198371887,
0.4724154770374298,
0.4494803249835968,
0.373636394739151,
-1.1203511953353882,
0.7948191165924072,
0.01098680216819048,
-0.9843609929084778,
-0.04479246586561203,
-0.2667026221752167,
-1.4109750986099243,
0.12721854448318481,
-0.3468491733074188,
-1.0192478895187378,
-0.14583991467952728,
-0.032291214913129807,
-0.004634515382349491,
0.018475156277418137,
-0.5248976349830627,
0.4926731586456299,
-0.16347981989383698,
0.31846916675567627,
-0.38700804114341736,
-0.6159428954124451,
0.15183724462985992,
-0.16598224639892578,
0.30625393986701965,
-0.15375441312789917,
-0.27412793040275574,
0.7010491490364075,
-0.1698724627494812,
0.7158799171447754,
-0.040096767246723175,
-0.28277045488357544,
0.7355518937110901,
0.24528725445270538,
0.4627034068107605,
-0.24478991329669952,
0.026426248252391815,
0.02363588474690914,
0.26151537895202637,
-0.2699028551578522,
-0.6213488578796387,
0.45941105484962463,
-0.43230846524238586,
-0.4694177210330963,
-0.7149279713630676,
-0.34093809127807617,
-0.24263757467269897,
-0.07786756753921509,
0.3610675036907196,
0.2015385925769806,
-0.15472733974456787,
0.44534993171691895,
0.1860329508781433,
-0.3294961452484131,
0.3515104651451111,
0.2643897831439972,
-0.23316890001296997,
-0.08622854202985764,
0.5389876365661621,
0.018840283155441284,
-0.09491509199142456,
0.30745628476142883,
0.38215371966362,
-0.33100247383117676,
-0.22669050097465515,
-0.0034037847071886063,
0.21036222577095032,
-0.517019510269165,
-0.27436092495918274,
-0.5224900841712952,
0.04074466601014137,
-0.2428334504365921,
-0.31086334586143494,
-0.2950833737850189,
-0.24527566134929657,
0.38974666595458984,
-0.154424786567688,
0.7984862327575684,
0.2673150300979614,
0.1467837691307068,
0.27265551686286926,
-0.723016619682312,
0.5699179768562317,
0.09164118766784668,
-0.008254075422883034,
-0.045043617486953735,
-0.38575178384780884,
0.30469682812690735,
-0.10662580281496048,
0.17907515168190002,
-1.0400141477584839,
0.3868864178657532,
0.024943562224507332,
0.3041183650493622,
0.5392930507659912,
0.09671895951032639,
0.5322595238685608,
-0.6456050276756287,
0.8997593522071838,
0.41370606422424316,
-0.8306831121444702,
0.451892614364624,
-0.49163177609443665,
-0.28014931082725525,
0.3147988021373749,
0.6201328039169312,
-0.6505838632583618,
-0.4033620357513428,
-0.9031549096107483,
-0.8707782030105591,
-0.14605729281902313,
0.17813658714294434,
0.5343644618988037,
-0.45524826645851135,
0.4277903735637665,
0.025242719799280167,
0.18641917407512665,
-0.42977848649024963,
-0.35422757267951965,
0.22980032861232758,
-0.29308509826660156,
-0.1904650777578354,
-0.2012593299150467,
-0.11550360918045044,
0.019764786586165428,
0.1950368583202362,
0.013852882198989391,
0.5134097337722778,
0.3035258948802948,
-0.16522422432899475,
0.14421571791172028,
0.16339600086212158,
0.286584734916687,
0.45056086778640747,
-0.03986499458551407,
0.7210202813148499,
0.1641228199005127,
-0.514017641544342,
0.23555850982666016,
-0.31586411595344543,
0.04815901815891266,
0.47942307591438293,
0.45763546228408813,
0.31598904728889465,
0.1399320662021637,
-1.085078477859497,
0.655834972858429,
0.10625264048576355,
0.10369764268398285,
-0.8255170583724976,
0.06869708001613617,
0.049223821610212326,
0.22955620288848877,
0.24512256681919098,
-0.28526514768600464,
0.3968328535556793,
-0.8313521146774292,
0.0358659103512764,
0.5322216749191284,
-0.07149454951286316,
-0.11378204077482224,
0.3644656240940094,
-0.27776193618774414,
-0.18908344209194183,
0.8217427134513855,
-0.1401703953742981,
-0.4306618869304657,
0.9596131443977356,
0.7324347496032715,
0.7969866394996643,
0.19117020070552826,
0.11173813045024872,
0.41800984740257263,
0.11615131795406342,
-0.3553595542907715,
0.010707944631576538,
0.38163521885871887,
-0.8303661942481995,
-0.24879178404808044,
-0.5046215653419495,
-0.28029248118400574,
0.281277596950531,
-0.657652735710144,
0.32399457693099976,
-0.07404433935880661,
-0.40765243768692017,
0.22995257377624512,
-0.3232472240924835,
-0.7843529582023621,
0.5201720595359802,
0.30460989475250244,
1.1143298149108887,
-1.1046816110610962,
0.5217777490615845,
1.083851933479309,
-0.5502713918685913,
-0.8912062048912048,
0.24828630685806274,
0.10172275453805923,
-0.5519502758979797,
1.2001256942749023,
0.3396227955818176,
-0.3115595579147339,
-0.2766963541507721,
-0.7295467853546143,
-0.6737863421440125,
0.9902230501174927,
0.5115416049957275,
-0.13383741676807404,
-0.08906932175159454,
0.0910056009888649,
0.6861757040023804,
-0.44126302003860474,
0.2585272192955017,
0.24022941291332245,
0.637566089630127,
0.23799489438533783,
-1.0873662233352661,
0.4837486743927002,
0.1123611256480217,
0.08301480114459991,
-0.044954221695661545,
-0.4661825895309448,
0.8745636940002441,
0.1437404602766037,
-0.2062569260597229,
-0.0006010374636389315,
0.8966754674911499,
0.3591729998588562,
0.45455795526504517,
0.9008013010025024,
0.2624138593673706,
0.8176143169403076,
0.10247621685266495,
1.1464529037475586,
-0.23234888911247253,
0.36929887533187866,
1.012979507446289,
-0.23720945417881012,
0.8579403758049011,
0.6077216267585754,
-0.06432336568832397,
0.5035498738288879,
0.6616929769515991,
-0.21393613517284393,
0.23438209295272827,
0.5766597390174866,
-0.21043138206005096,
-0.021080221980810165,
-0.3164348304271698,
-0.21537642180919647,
0.870617151260376,
0.3891320824623108,
-0.517810583114624,
-0.21671071648597717,
0.050509143620729446,
0.2710621953010559,
-0.010372019372880459,
-0.3069995045661926,
0.4649100601673126,
0.03657781705260277,
-0.9011164307594299,
0.5229093432426453,
-0.023323047906160355,
0.6320548057556152,
-0.22591523826122284,
-0.0464044027030468,
0.12880085408687592,
0.06067950651049614,
-0.018520433455705643,
-0.47117042541503906,
0.41024351119995117,
0.18141870200634003,
0.38139188289642334,
0.1495000272989273,
0.9480141997337341,
-0.024123378098011017,
-0.1196642592549324,
0.35437676310539246,
0.7168383598327637,
0.47149232029914856,
-0.32485997676849365,
-0.06908942013978958,
-0.13508711755275726,
-0.4506613612174988,
-0.1307906061410904,
0.3161022365093231,
0.7009102702140808,
-0.16174514591693878,
0.6104741096496582,
0.20804506540298462,
0.20413967967033386,
-0.034572385251522064,
-0.17888829112052917,
0.5129504203796387,
-0.7635052800178528,
-0.22535450756549835,
-0.8625854849815369,
0.1744488775730133,
-0.30860254168510437,
-0.05693691968917847,
0.9973978996276855,
0.4783709943294525,
0.6570631861686707,
-0.4086062014102936,
0.594481885433197,
-0.32522228360176086,
0.19643399119377136,
-0.5589207410812378,
0.46586188673973083,
-0.4646400809288025,
-0.1541300266981125,
-0.5140472650527954,
-0.9294063448905945,
-0.3944842219352722,
1.1245567798614502,
-0.2424773871898651,
-0.09867823868989944,
1.0088850259780884,
0.49032244086265564,
-0.18745529651641846,
-0.1486150473356247,
0.19512425363063812,
0.056876543909311295,
-0.008354167453944683,
-0.0174703449010849,
1.04468834400177,
-0.19316771626472473,
-0.04501486197113991,
0.053221385926008224,
-0.009805972687900066,
-0.3339444696903229,
-1.2539021968841553,
-0.7724581956863403,
-0.8107405304908752,
-0.7013017535209656,
-0.6903804540634155,
-0.12232845276594162,
1.114025592803955,
0.2859152555465698,
-0.4809809923171997,
-0.17759066820144653,
-0.13419653475284576,
-0.11625975370407104,
-0.14786440134048462,
-0.23748576641082764,
0.45680660009384155,
-0.44951438903808594,
-0.8740273714065552,
0.00034348820918239653,
-0.1064750924706459,
0.0752623975276947,
-0.01641993597149849,
0.34490394592285156,
-0.20251327753067017,
0.49419334530830383,
0.7163065075874329,
0.10393279790878296,
-0.6888061761856079,
-0.6758306622505188,
-0.01711506024003029,
-0.3424767255783081,
0.1457383930683136,
0.8148157000541687,
-0.8203052878379822,
-0.013021127320826054,
0.458388090133667,
0.5455112457275391,
0.11704548448324203,
-0.03966960683465004,
0.3091433346271515,
-0.5703526735305786,
0.2285163253545761,
-0.020726501941680908,
0.6687197685241699,
0.2043520212173462,
-0.2641526460647583,
0.685798704624176,
0.2792709767818451,
-0.09722787886857986,
-0.8299310803413391,
0.2630913555622101,
-1.3538086414337158,
-0.27770644426345825,
1.594621181488037,
-0.23157042264938354,
-0.41980376839637756,
0.11596962809562683,
-0.3633883595466614,
0.3739088773727417,
-0.18323452770709991,
1.040650486946106,
1.0899816751480103,
-0.013812514953315258,
0.3940684199333191,
-0.6965600848197937,
0.32042622566223145,
0.23778396844863892,
-0.7168295383453369,
0.010596386156976223,
0.7157515287399292,
0.43239790201187134,
0.6449421048164368,
0.2415112555027008,
-0.14825084805488586,
-0.0372031033039093,
0.007389585953205824,
-0.2615416944026947,
0.3830460011959076,
-0.2744837999343872,
-0.07379887253046036,
0.4188331663608551,
0.25874581933021545,
-0.2804679572582245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01358v1
|
Utilizing AI and Social Media Analytics to Discover Adverse Side Effects of GLP-1 Receptor Agonists
| 2024-04-01T09:48:14 | 2024-04-01T09:48:14 |
Alon Bartal, Kathleen M. Jagodnik, Nava Pliskin, Abraham Seidmann
|
q-bio.QM
|
q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SI, 62
|
Adverse side effects (ASEs) of drugs, revealed after FDA approval, pose a
threat to patient safety. To promptly detect overlooked ASEs, we developed a
digital health methodology capable of analyzing massive public data from social
media, published clinical research, manufacturers' reports, and ChatGPT. We
uncovered ASEs associated with the glucagon-like peptide 1 receptor agonists
(GLP-1 RA), a market expected to grow exponentially to $133.5 billion USD by
2030. Using a Named Entity Recognition (NER) model, our method successfully
detected 21 potential ASEs overlooked upon FDA approval, including irritability
and numbness. Our data-analytic approach revolutionizes the detection of
unreported ASEs associated with newly deployed drugs, leveraging cutting-edge
AI-driven social media analytics. It can increase the safety of new drugs in
the marketplace by unlocking the power of social media to support regulators
and manufacturers in the rapid discovery of hidden ASE risks.
|
[
-0.45873916149139404,
-0.4808710217475891,
0.5476505160331726,
-0.09364128112792969,
-0.18466788530349731,
-0.004130505956709385,
0.2083047777414322,
-0.7661989331245422,
0.7172555327415466,
0.654634416103363,
-0.7192042469978333,
-0.6908673048019409,
-0.9513617157936096,
-0.12052275240421295,
-0.3418183922767639,
1.1767985820770264,
0.1338246911764145,
0.14601199328899384,
0.16352730989456177,
-0.22542981803417206,
-0.19251669943332672,
-0.3469341993331909,
-0.8130243420600891,
-0.154170960187912,
0.9063324928283691,
0.18180133402347565,
0.5768296122550964,
-0.036654066294431686,
0.9081334471702576,
0.2094103842973709,
0.10704391449689865,
-0.2249254584312439,
-0.22225452959537506,
-0.19452138245105743,
-0.0994870588183403,
0.01701285131275654,
-0.8733717799186707,
-0.07705119997262955,
0.4232761561870575,
0.3726227879524231,
-0.07860228419303894,
0.3383145034313202,
0.0057515730150043964,
0.8272904753684998,
-0.6827621459960938,
-0.20893561840057373,
-0.3753439784049988,
0.23306097090244293,
-0.23461107909679413,
-0.37984180450439453,
-0.11426832526922226,
-0.7243260145187378,
0.2767168879508972,
-0.7262009978294373,
0.04952923208475113,
0.036790475249290466,
1.0106078386306763,
0.4031468629837036,
-0.13747474551200867,
-0.7444673776626587,
-0.6062663197517395,
0.18004865944385529,
-0.6912459135055542,
0.28795531392097473,
0.3285677433013916,
0.7661248445510864,
-0.49719756841659546,
-0.7012063264846802,
-0.45547839999198914,
0.016953153535723686,
-0.36684054136276245,
-0.2982705235481262,
-0.5268754959106445,
0.14343640208244324,
-0.03219449892640114,
0.22235704958438873,
-0.6062020063400269,
0.20832929015159607,
-0.7954534292221069,
-0.25346237421035767,
0.5575836300849915,
0.04296686500310898,
0.6537010669708252,
0.019010093063116074,
-0.32985925674438477,
0.3811797797679901,
-0.593612015247345,
-0.12586906552314758,
0.11551836878061295,
0.41996610164642334,
-0.2831152081489563,
0.5632538199424744,
0.14875566959381104,
0.2908981442451477,
0.14961737394332886,
0.41648778319358826,
0.2905716300010681,
-0.4658922553062439,
-0.2271067500114441,
0.2983579933643341,
1.0071518421173096,
0.5889090299606323,
-0.05255963280797005,
-0.002885908354073763,
0.14031821489334106,
0.05687069520354271,
0.31481653451919556,
-0.707004189491272,
-0.42270025610923767,
0.610819399356842,
-0.557277262210846,
-0.23138992488384247,
-0.008175176568329334,
-1.0960572957992554,
-0.9011450409889221,
-0.0018408799078315496,
0.7129109501838684,
-0.38091766834259033,
-0.24948745965957642,
0.1892540156841278,
-0.32459408044815063,
0.3900921940803528,
0.11742962151765823,
-0.8046607375144958,
0.6697876453399658,
0.7267391681671143,
0.7671565413475037,
-0.007225230801850557,
-0.047528479248285294,
-0.4853069484233856,
-0.16717171669006348,
-0.4049541652202606,
1.2157137393951416,
-0.10221786051988602,
-0.3692871928215027,
-0.02642194926738739,
-0.054319024085998535,
-0.09352990239858627,
-0.6706686615943909,
0.41272974014282227,
-0.4577806890010834,
0.13246455788612366,
-0.5993544459342957,
-0.5993615388870239,
-0.10387550294399261,
0.15064455568790436,
-0.7353296279907227,
0.122871533036232,
-0.22335146367549896,
-0.7806347012519836,
0.6710283160209656,
-0.8500677347183228,
-0.31411659717559814,
0.2991167902946472,
-0.35797229409217834,
-0.635899543762207,
0.4099023938179016,
0.34892332553863525,
0.21418222784996033,
-0.09524093568325043,
0.01186048798263073,
-0.057674407958984375,
-0.3619709610939026,
0.1421322375535965,
-0.016978276893496513,
0.7665687203407288,
0.32528960704803467,
-0.13391120731830597,
0.43514785170555115,
-0.4639614522457123,
0.0321170836687088,
-0.05269833281636238,
-0.331254243850708,
-0.1108742281794548,
-0.044939927756786346,
0.07310588657855988,
0.2655957341194153,
-0.09037160128355026,
-0.5732472538948059,
-0.12192852050065994,
-0.03518946096301079,
0.07674948126077652,
0.6845377087593079,
0.6140766143798828,
0.25339704751968384,
-0.3913687765598297,
0.5350518822669983,
-0.23976849019527435,
0.4951225817203522,
0.30163735151290894,
-0.6533326506614685,
-0.2809208333492279,
-0.20085157454013824,
0.12347163259983063,
0.4198962450027466,
-0.3043493628501892,
0.5224212408065796,
-0.12497181445360184,
-0.3111608028411865,
-0.7236796617507935,
-0.11088006943464279,
0.1415390819311142,
0.3832322955131531,
0.2791074514389038,
-0.1921914517879486,
-0.21843791007995605,
-0.6520313620567322,
-0.4996561110019684,
-0.0024594601709395647,
-0.32329386472702026,
0.028728527948260307,
0.2195338010787964,
-0.7615395784378052,
0.5922519564628601,
-0.4526999890804291,
-0.7209691405296326,
0.015872083604335785,
0.13273802399635315,
0.0296205822378397,
0.42436933517456055,
0.4337581992149353,
-0.619895875453949,
-0.5266591310501099,
0.02505423128604889,
-0.796956479549408,
-0.0047957273200154305,
-0.04714635759592056,
0.12399016320705414,
-0.04180275276303291,
0.4657878279685974,
-0.41121628880500793,
0.38623344898223877,
0.39412713050842285,
-0.19085220992565155,
0.3501167595386505,
-0.16680149734020233,
0.322428435087204,
-0.5092822313308716,
0.3763369917869568,
0.5045405030250549,
0.37025749683380127,
-0.9015920162200928,
-0.15245315432548523,
-0.13765066862106323,
-0.3804584741592407,
-0.4339240491390228,
0.5522908568382263,
-0.2544552981853485,
0.005339990369975567,
-0.0757237896323204,
-0.2547813057899475,
-0.10337820649147034,
0.10557929426431656,
-0.2582835555076599,
0.46896302700042725,
0.6398137807846069,
-0.5021494030952454,
-0.024991635233163834,
0.16524571180343628,
-0.4393537640571594,
0.22171786427497864,
-0.4261198341846466,
-0.0947771817445755,
-0.49102216958999634,
0.22540587186813354,
-1.0491416454315186,
-0.515156090259552,
0.9460393190383911,
-0.7811447978019714,
0.30952703952789307,
-0.19185738265514374,
-0.08810614794492722,
-0.7574303150177002,
-0.47631362080574036,
-0.023127999156713486,
0.21234223246574402,
-0.24243685603141785,
0.8942684531211853,
0.7198293209075928,
-0.5436200499534607,
-0.44645097851753235,
-0.48893964290618896,
0.09983578324317932,
-0.3041125237941742,
-0.034241143614053726,
-0.09503861516714096,
0.12681807577610016,
-0.4310976266860962,
0.2218007892370224,
-0.2030012309551239,
-0.21916727721691132,
-0.20209011435508728,
0.20682170987129211,
0.024915343150496483,
0.055401623249053955,
0.2656095623970032,
0.14855051040649414,
-0.3753591775894165,
0.4749346375465393,
0.29692769050598145,
0.36504191160202026,
-0.20353050529956818,
-0.13447897136211395,
-0.7700098156929016,
0.4334193766117096,
0.8943660259246826,
-0.10121149569749832,
0.12341435998678207,
0.41732996702194214,
-0.8666752576828003,
0.10900948196649551,
-0.48434826731681824,
-0.31459280848503113,
-0.5179930329322815,
0.14346113801002502,
0.35047343373298645,
-0.13294173777103424,
0.6961020827293396,
0.14257113635540009,
-0.06387261301279068,
0.41971683502197266,
0.07850857824087143,
0.2192821204662323,
0.8596832156181335,
0.23072302341461182,
-0.3266432285308838,
0.3005973994731903,
-0.19565577805042267,
0.44546735286712646,
-0.5038133263587952,
-0.4917847216129303,
-0.27310413122177124,
-0.4358348548412323,
-0.8221288323402405,
-0.25968137383461,
0.7163287401199341,
-0.4555908739566803,
-0.2525103986263275,
0.04846588149666786,
-0.6257951855659485,
0.466962605714798,
0.5419651865959167,
0.39087650179862976,
0.18611806631088257,
0.05855974555015564,
0.4549766480922699,
-0.02462024800479412,
-0.21711722016334534,
-0.25353768467903137,
1.2341357469558716,
0.5593118667602539,
0.6690170764923096,
-0.19616268575191498,
0.5946386456489563,
0.42401909828186035,
0.5992282032966614,
-0.8674677610397339,
0.5265406966209412,
-0.33213213086128235,
-0.8641500473022461,
0.00017293839482590556,
-0.28357282280921936,
-0.6231875419616699,
-0.18093881011009216,
-0.5882501006126404,
-1.004062294960022,
0.25003889203071594,
0.3064006268978119,
-0.9706078767776489,
0.22786371409893036,
-0.9004497528076172,
0.8973787426948547,
-0.5891371965408325,
-0.23493307828903198,
-0.2945409417152405,
-0.777712881565094,
0.019065475091338158,
-0.2315053641796112,
0.2892880141735077,
-0.1814350038766861,
0.29124915599823,
0.5603666305541992,
-0.4128938615322113,
0.42690885066986084,
-0.43819424510002136,
0.13833779096603394,
0.38275963068008423,
-0.2082809954881668,
0.3387983739376068,
0.06834709644317627,
0.06317636370658875,
0.293259859085083,
-0.48194342851638794,
-0.44036608934402466,
-0.4764576256275177,
0.9565068483352661,
-0.3377940058708191,
-0.12121512740850449,
-0.546249270439148,
-0.11543700098991394,
-0.04716936871409416,
0.1317863166332245,
0.5460216403007507,
0.10194309055805206,
-0.25433215498924255,
-0.5888124704360962,
0.1960105001926422,
-0.5905275344848633,
0.10157214850187302,
0.6765031218528748,
-0.08333626389503479,
-0.5454562306404114,
0.8844721913337708,
0.37985265254974365,
-0.11141268163919449,
0.16323116421699524,
0.30531439185142517,
-0.3635009825229645,
-0.6659221649169922,
-0.15655381977558136,
0.184774249792099,
-0.42654433846473694,
0.10662441700696945,
-0.5466374158859253,
-0.1265895515680313,
-0.45903804898262024,
-0.3146098256111145,
-0.35027527809143066,
0.16413943469524384,
-0.2441786825656891,
-0.3114112317562103,
0.38607218861579895,
1.2518442869186401,
-0.2213514894247055,
0.5941371917724609,
-0.6343327760696411,
0.24696223437786102,
0.25934088230133057,
0.9002829790115356,
-0.12114519625902176,
0.21211141347885132,
0.21279223263263702,
0.12178593873977661,
-0.27766525745391846,
-0.624083399772644,
0.3860509991645813,
0.055121734738349915,
0.4161777198314667,
0.7614464163780212,
-0.1955416053533554,
0.4528495669364929,
-0.29801398515701294,
0.3444293439388275,
0.4123881757259369,
-0.6690734028816223,
0.6485112905502319,
-0.5054677724838257,
0.19423840939998627,
0.7433292865753174,
0.9302929639816284,
-0.6328524947166443,
-0.21523824334144592,
-0.3010975122451782,
-1.1281028985977173,
0.34009984135627747,
0.06450900435447693,
-0.17596393823623657,
-0.26474282145500183,
0.24713833630084991,
0.2196854054927826,
0.2624050974845886,
-0.4845219850540161,
-0.24251128733158112,
0.12306305021047592,
0.19564059376716614,
0.13485969603061676,
0.03396454080939293,
0.22537611424922943,
-0.24775280058383942,
0.5627297163009644,
0.07561265677213669,
0.5471950769424438,
0.11771596968173981,
0.1474573016166687,
-0.5203948020935059,
0.45265674591064453,
0.37382081151008606,
0.7309581637382507,
-0.805173397064209,
0.02215043269097805,
-0.2713896930217743,
-0.5645825862884521,
-0.36665186285972595,
0.7502603530883789,
-0.06307019293308258,
-0.01443487498909235,
0.10939133912324905,
0.39023950695991516,
-0.0532388761639595,
-0.6043330430984497,
0.2399190068244934,
-0.14933006465435028,
-0.10154056549072266,
-0.5726454854011536,
-0.2568828761577606,
-0.2745596170425415,
0.14760006964206696,
0.9569895267486572,
0.1800977885723114,
0.6022587418556213,
-0.552241861820221,
0.78094482421875,
0.5058803558349609,
-0.8344979286193848,
-0.5656375288963318,
0.7239730954170227,
0.15377354621887207,
-0.359925240278244,
0.39218682050704956,
-0.03321453183889389,
-0.37481898069381714,
0.7759529948234558,
0.03962324187159538,
0.7932395339012146,
-0.3728434443473816,
0.40753573179244995,
0.34955573081970215,
0.19406326115131378,
0.01758752018213272,
0.24801602959632874,
0.6938460469245911,
-0.3923563063144684,
0.0518195703625679,
-0.18379567563533783,
-0.34952419996261597,
0.4528801143169403,
-0.5631148219108582,
0.5077679753303528,
-0.8528333902359009,
-0.4529564082622528,
0.8635480999946594,
0.08676246553659439,
-0.5200255513191223,
0.06497479230165482,
0.2881772816181183,
0.4527035653591156,
-1.181930661201477,
0.18981671333312988,
0.6772392988204956,
-0.3895658850669861,
-0.5876783728599548,
0.1213420182466507,
0.44456225633621216,
-0.687903881072998,
0.1371614933013916,
0.5031108856201172,
-0.03843402862548828,
-0.018831556662917137,
-0.41117310523986816,
-0.5040724277496338,
0.9569851160049438,
-0.0006944136111997068,
-0.6082010269165039,
-0.17737708985805511,
0.24547244608402252,
0.7831831574440002,
-0.3058710992336273,
0.14957642555236816,
0.5330259799957275,
0.2571141719818115,
0.20042595267295837,
-0.7853885293006897,
0.1348821371793747,
-0.35793808102607727,
-0.5954825282096863,
0.4985176622867584,
-0.2036076784133911,
0.698040783405304,
-0.5768651366233826,
-0.6743611693382263,
-0.3294598460197449,
-0.18621987104415894,
-0.015863152220845222,
0.8580321669578552,
0.07734626531600952,
0.5971669554710388,
0.7270203232765198,
0.20728737115859985,
0.9620766639709473,
-0.08882729709148407,
0.3260971009731293,
1.0719066858291626,
-0.4612601399421692,
0.6548033356666565,
0.4651045799255371,
-0.009473943151533604,
0.41416797041893005,
0.2666870951652527,
-0.032954420894384384,
0.7772156000137329,
0.2624114453792572,
-0.5335236191749573,
0.04840543121099472,
-0.2990070581436157,
-0.422552227973938,
0.05394409969449043,
0.8281199932098389,
-0.3333105444908142,
-0.596045970916748,
0.27627331018447876,
-0.0239703468978405,
-0.1477808803319931,
-0.5650689005851746,
0.8169035315513611,
-0.005735849961638451,
-0.4236821234226227,
0.39801493287086487,
-0.6027959585189819,
0.5024505257606506,
-0.7314286231994629,
0.06156179681420326,
-0.1492352932691574,
0.607104480266571,
-0.28787800669670105,
-0.5504773259162903,
0.5702856183052063,
-0.27286839485168457,
0.2123134732246399,
0.2562408149242401,
0.8813281059265137,
-0.29083675146102905,
-0.41705983877182007,
0.641526997089386,
0.3612048327922821,
-0.08002614229917526,
-0.23767046630382538,
-0.6109781265258789,
0.2410544902086258,
-0.15963521599769592,
-0.0564836785197258,
0.3469240963459015,
0.07927922159433365,
0.00979998242110014,
0.7687938213348389,
0.27707043290138245,
0.24000325798988342,
-0.20789718627929688,
-0.20724526047706604,
1.1396032571792603,
-0.4825439155101776,
-0.1330375224351883,
-0.6244014501571655,
0.6462244987487793,
-0.14954443275928497,
-0.3661375939846039,
0.487047404050827,
0.5011948347091675,
0.21224521100521088,
-0.021603595465421677,
0.6884536147117615,
-0.1318783462047577,
0.5972269773483276,
-0.09018201380968094,
1.337403416633606,
-0.5249130725860596,
0.41879594326019287,
-0.1405889391899109,
-0.44146057963371277,
-0.8333942294120789,
0.24965429306030273,
-0.6646398305892944,
-0.42040786147117615,
0.39393556118011475,
0.833278477191925,
0.12729239463806152,
0.04000992327928543,
-0.28073763847351074,
0.22002029418945312,
0.3678148686885834,
0.444002240896225,
0.3151707053184509,
-0.7554930448532104,
0.3591567575931549,
0.12440706044435501,
-0.2677702307701111,
-0.16424380242824554,
-0.5458589792251587,
-0.7310027480125427,
-0.14165464043617249,
-0.4118322432041168,
-0.4022260308265686,
0.5716977119445801,
1.2783918380737305,
0.2515717148780823,
-1.1342403888702393,
0.19371362030506134,
-0.1754235327243805,
0.14828228950500488,
-0.22041936218738556,
-0.2090751826763153,
0.3521418273448944,
0.17241939902305603,
-0.2477513700723648,
0.18235071003437042,
0.16348321735858917,
0.3586454391479492,
0.3249855041503906,
-0.041704341769218445,
-0.4561050236225128,
-0.10911814868450165,
0.22713318467140198,
0.6497122645378113,
-0.43599778413772583,
-0.17627860605716705,
-0.048161279410123825,
-0.12223947793245316,
-0.09776221960783005,
0.6728368997573853,
-0.40491783618927,
0.5707890391349792,
0.4142800271511078,
0.3836880028247833,
0.2233939915895462,
0.25148510932922363,
0.6834107041358948,
-0.26765045523643494,
-0.3159729242324829,
0.5374628305435181,
0.147327721118927,
0.09345708042383194,
-0.4318954348564148,
0.2886362373828888,
-0.14223073422908783,
-0.5431079268455505,
-0.4492974281311035,
-0.17439790070056915,
-0.8070780038833618,
-0.43301624059677124,
0.889542818069458,
0.035988692194223404,
-0.11392783373594284,
-0.1967611461877823,
0.00008467498992104083,
-0.060885950922966,
-0.7091959118843079,
1.1944971084594727,
0.3040066659450531,
-0.09245377779006958,
0.12456810474395752,
-0.7816672921180725,
0.7282681465148926,
-0.08971960842609406,
-0.7973626852035522,
0.1772599071264267,
0.6685577630996704,
0.22247314453125,
0.3461959958076477,
1.1298273801803589,
-0.1583259254693985,
0.3774638772010803,
0.02694336511194706,
-0.02382337488234043,
0.1352604776620865,
-0.24357908964157104,
-0.42836257815361023,
-0.00595594709739089,
-0.15760932862758636,
-0.5071507096290588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01019v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01019v2
|
Source-Aware Training Enables Knowledge Attribution in Language Models
| 2024-04-01T09:39:38 | 2024-04-11T16:32:26 |
Muhammad Khalifa, David Wadden, Emma Strubell, Honglak Lee, Lu Wang, Iz Beltagy, Hao Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) learn a vast amount of knowledge during
pretraining, but they are often oblivious to the source(s) of such knowledge.
We investigate the problem of intrinsic source citation, where LLMs are
required to cite the pretraining source supporting a generated response.
Intrinsic source citation can enhance LLM transparency, interpretability, and
verifiability. To give LLMs such ability, we explore source-aware training -- a
post pretraining recipe that involves (i) training the LLM to associate unique
source document identifiers with the knowledge in each document, followed by
(ii) an instruction-tuning to teach the LLM to cite a supporting pretraining
source when prompted. Source-aware training can easily be applied to pretrained
LLMs off the shelf, and diverges minimally from existing
pretraining/fine-tuning frameworks. Through experiments on carefully curated
data, we demonstrate that our training recipe can enable faithful attribution
to the pretraining data without a substantial impact on the model's quality
compared to standard pretraining. Our results also highlight the importance of
data augmentation in achieving attribution. Code and data available here:
\url{https://github.com/mukhal/intrinsic-source-citation}
|
[
0.06884267181158066,
-0.3334594964981079,
0.849334180355072,
0.034159835427999496,
-0.21373073756694794,
0.13756678998470306,
-0.31204718351364136,
-0.45731502771377563,
-0.029756102710962296,
0.36926448345184326,
-0.47017791867256165,
-0.11562252789735794,
-0.6782005429267883,
-0.09979737550020218,
-0.5307501554489136,
0.8185523152351379,
-0.2051316350698471,
0.23134319484233856,
-0.47421500086784363,
-0.12900537252426147,
-0.07409544289112091,
-0.8242224454879761,
-0.4795360863208771,
-0.38262516260147095,
0.9105285406112671,
0.25586846470832825,
0.27307406067848206,
0.8689009547233582,
0.2124680131673813,
0.19640272855758667,
0.17737112939357758,
0.0770118311047554,
-0.5258265733718872,
0.17647717893123627,
-0.535538375377655,
-0.6842060089111328,
-0.1775677353143692,
0.1790430098772049,
0.8766443729400635,
0.4596676528453827,
0.0571243055164814,
0.27977409958839417,
0.1475575715303421,
0.5900037884712219,
-0.8779681921005249,
-0.03229890391230583,
-1.1972250938415527,
-0.2907915711402893,
-0.3730294406414032,
-0.3935125470161438,
-0.41960230469703674,
-0.5724070072174072,
0.010101242922246456,
-0.7776983976364136,
0.13255178928375244,
-0.057068806141614914,
0.8913968801498413,
0.3842184841632843,
-0.21530893445014954,
-0.2666759490966797,
-0.6093339323997498,
0.5054678320884705,
-0.5715888142585754,
0.5024020075798035,
0.6123608350753784,
-0.0051337056793272495,
0.1506795883178711,
-0.6479365229606628,
-0.6053318977355957,
-0.0423833467066288,
-0.11623688042163849,
-0.1491222083568573,
0.2341381460428238,
-0.4847416281700134,
0.1593114584684372,
0.32426917552948,
-0.1335112303495407,
0.01698669046163559,
-0.04996349290013313,
-0.16208527982234955,
0.28765398263931274,
-0.36002489924430847,
0.03377136215567589,
0.09964814782142639,
-0.2062591165304184,
0.07330834120512009,
-1.229315161705017,
-0.18541398644447327,
0.405967652797699,
0.3608257472515106,
0.06547944247722626,
0.5606488585472107,
0.026838649064302444,
0.6218767762184143,
0.05353033170104027,
0.0772722065448761,
0.40727323293685913,
-0.40449273586273193,
0.139467254281044,
0.3772359788417816,
0.5481342077255249,
-0.3171413838863373,
0.6941766142845154,
-0.3492670953273773,
-0.23395927250385284,
-0.25009459257125854,
0.4172993302345276,
-0.7147213816642761,
-0.1987200677394867,
-0.18576541543006897,
0.2135884165763855,
-0.34222307801246643,
0.051726240664720535,
0.26317939162254333,
-0.3774546980857849,
-0.7175157070159912,
0.5862997770309448,
-0.5519762635231018,
-0.33835846185684204,
-0.30111441016197205,
-0.08865213394165039,
0.3264540433883667,
0.3119942843914032,
-0.9176442623138428,
-0.2736964225769043,
0.6837248802185059,
0.8339261412620544,
0.18036599457263947,
-0.4070456922054291,
-0.6603552103042603,
0.8295047283172607,
-0.3892650604248047,
1.0283007621765137,
-0.726678192615509,
-0.17057538032531738,
0.012168055400252342,
0.026252079755067825,
0.0497615709900856,
-0.5574043393135071,
0.5034865736961365,
-0.6928834319114685,
-0.021028952673077583,
-0.7064467668533325,
-0.716422975063324,
0.20041999220848083,
0.17829211056232452,
-0.4437253177165985,
0.7347907423973083,
0.24310728907585144,
-0.7612157464027405,
0.6519260406494141,
-0.4182518422603607,
-0.5035492181777954,
0.004080932587385178,
-0.3438698351383209,
-0.3152754008769989,
0.34905534982681274,
0.19789853692054749,
0.27592116594314575,
-0.041195038706064224,
0.37071549892425537,
-0.35256990790367126,
-0.16746921837329865,
0.3406675159931183,
-0.33030080795288086,
0.7237607836723328,
0.10681085288524628,
0.007788437884300947,
0.2086605727672577,
-0.893677294254303,
-0.08235186338424683,
0.2968578040599823,
-0.4952538311481476,
-0.5787317156791687,
-0.05805739015340805,
-0.3648131489753723,
0.010825264267623425,
0.21233560144901276,
-0.44639167189598083,
0.11279978603124619,
-0.3325319290161133,
0.3381406366825104,
1.090221881866455,
-0.1549086719751358,
0.5959521532058716,
-0.12057863175868988,
0.2565748989582062,
-0.07607103884220123,
-0.12235450744628906,
-0.25997334718704224,
0.13286827504634857,
-0.7738380432128906,
-0.32940471172332764,
0.362526535987854,
0.2917734980583191,
-0.7876746654510498,
0.4614093005657196,
-0.5894991755485535,
-0.41130831837654114,
-0.5957655310630798,
0.4298565983772278,
0.3299202620983124,
0.8254676461219788,
0.3759952485561371,
-0.01974036730825901,
-0.6183729767799377,
-0.7168347239494324,
-0.440563827753067,
-0.1358969658613205,
-0.31632861495018005,
0.2361789047718048,
0.3239741921424866,
-0.023239128291606903,
1.0036810636520386,
-0.326214075088501,
-0.20491887629032135,
-0.1541328877210617,
0.09524711966514587,
-0.09998531639575958,
0.6732892394065857,
0.42528417706489563,
-0.3658412992954254,
-0.7164643406867981,
-0.12274575233459473,
-0.8472110629081726,
-0.25208526849746704,
0.004146079067140818,
-0.46779415011405945,
-0.05293472483754158,
0.7059953808784485,
-0.472339004278183,
-0.04038754105567932,
0.29434680938720703,
-0.13864949345588684,
0.6491647362709045,
-0.1347355842590332,
-0.05759824812412262,
-0.9430458545684814,
0.2394416183233261,
-0.20329488813877106,
-0.4184289574623108,
-0.31730201840400696,
0.032955292612314224,
0.33115649223327637,
-0.16805097460746765,
-0.44400960206985474,
0.6205813884735107,
-0.6415047645568848,
0.012001954950392246,
-0.32853320240974426,
-0.12848114967346191,
0.2017749547958374,
0.2952140271663666,
0.35963377356529236,
0.8583483695983887,
0.7411009669303894,
-0.4669569730758667,
0.1698550283908844,
0.19995346665382385,
-0.5503759980201721,
0.6406705379486084,
-0.664879560470581,
0.33507996797561646,
0.012888286262750626,
0.23634304106235504,
-0.3673945665359497,
-0.07879571616649628,
0.2973328232765198,
-0.42223629355430603,
0.5141103267669678,
-0.3284109830856323,
-0.5303089022636414,
0.11411789804697037,
-0.18744760751724243,
0.38575437664985657,
0.132457435131073,
-0.7396211624145508,
0.730377733707428,
0.04102347418665886,
-0.2243015319108963,
-0.44219306111335754,
-0.5938963294029236,
-0.15098515152931213,
-0.14958059787750244,
-0.3456536531448364,
0.23344096541404724,
-0.09086398780345917,
0.099344402551651,
0.05452357977628708,
-0.2706213593482971,
-0.13718673586845398,
0.2789204716682434,
0.03486645594239235,
0.19381800293922424,
-0.24744844436645508,
0.28569215536117554,
-0.0804174616932869,
-0.33185407519340515,
0.2282678335905075,
-0.5354031920433044,
0.373096764087677,
0.08956677466630936,
-0.689043402671814,
-0.27016401290893555,
0.26334190368652344,
0.2624225616455078,
-0.47231948375701904,
1.031175971031189,
0.5958777070045471,
-0.1810680478811264,
-0.11036260426044464,
-0.5725231170654297,
-0.3064086437225342,
-0.5008793473243713,
0.18938761949539185,
-0.2721329629421234,
-0.7214997410774231,
0.3227893114089966,
-0.022801391780376434,
-0.04176202043890953,
0.21714678406715393,
0.4389680325984955,
-0.22235485911369324,
0.5941129922866821,
0.5330572128295898,
-0.15712948143482208,
0.9426678419113159,
0.07263686507940292,
0.01346991490572691,
-0.9227893352508545,
-0.2366420030593872,
-0.7080853581428528,
-0.1138807013630867,
0.04775254428386688,
-0.3801935315132141,
0.11969134211540222,
0.2873334586620331,
-0.5945141315460205,
-0.015476707369089127,
-0.25766509771347046,
0.7882001996040344,
0.748343825340271,
0.273702472448349,
0.4513235092163086,
0.22111479938030243,
0.094746433198452,
0.09637606889009476,
-0.6082035899162292,
-0.3743458390235901,
1.3405001163482666,
0.25236111879348755,
0.9394969940185547,
0.04849531874060631,
0.5028094053268433,
0.0824226588010788,
0.5573527812957764,
-0.47377142310142517,
0.2785155177116394,
0.2077908217906952,
-0.678197979927063,
-0.2570723295211792,
-0.5490772724151611,
-0.6146430373191833,
-0.0963282436132431,
-0.30023613572120667,
-0.5556154847145081,
0.11032585054636002,
0.4290963411331177,
-0.18388967216014862,
0.03940599039196968,
-0.8690885901451111,
0.7449491620063782,
-0.44596388936042786,
-0.6525781154632568,
-0.12699057161808014,
-0.454741895198822,
0.16487500071525574,
-0.43611714243888855,
0.11984486132860184,
0.011024325154721737,
0.18056799471378326,
0.6525708436965942,
-0.4947463274002075,
0.6755757331848145,
-0.2696874141693115,
-0.21100696921348572,
0.18403294682502747,
-0.030917938798666,
0.9895480275154114,
0.19629718363285065,
-0.005113921593874693,
0.041412387043237686,
-0.5123235583305359,
-0.5077093243598938,
-0.7165545225143433,
0.8358162641525269,
-0.8815014958381653,
-0.7919415235519409,
-0.3888000547885895,
-0.309903621673584,
-0.5166125893592834,
0.2742370069026947,
0.17849832773208618,
0.4081091582775116,
0.19600801169872284,
0.4517458975315094,
0.9751514196395874,
0.04279325529932976,
0.06687569618225098,
0.9670447707176208,
-0.0271761491894722,
-0.11829908192157745,
1.203048586845398,
0.011315264739096165,
0.36738502979278564,
0.4429822266101837,
0.2301655411720276,
-0.3832007646560669,
-0.8018755316734314,
-0.265608549118042,
0.3515852689743042,
-0.8171728253364563,
-0.1571115255355835,
-0.5695398449897766,
-0.3333764970302582,
-0.39083242416381836,
-0.3069564402103424,
-0.6506811380386353,
-0.17248985171318054,
-0.516620934009552,
-0.3842262327671051,
0.35538867115974426,
0.2912902235984802,
-0.0735134482383728,
0.43248552083969116,
-0.7046468257904053,
0.029786262661218643,
0.48647671937942505,
0.5376386046409607,
0.1172461062669754,
-0.8334137201309204,
-0.654804527759552,
0.10859772562980652,
-0.060090772807598114,
-0.4284801781177521,
0.005152352154254913,
0.3921818435192108,
0.8367701172828674,
0.4484289288520813,
-0.10442692786455154,
0.6578356623649597,
-0.6096128821372986,
0.5203854441642761,
0.18592716753482819,
-0.9867640137672424,
0.7690889835357666,
-0.3105083405971527,
0.37776827812194824,
0.800771951675415,
0.6446643471717834,
-0.016897492110729218,
-0.5227071046829224,
-0.5320689678192139,
-0.9779910445213318,
0.7161216735839844,
-0.04446528106927872,
0.17802108824253082,
0.09120465070009232,
0.4319499731063843,
0.06750176846981049,
0.2675235867500305,
-0.9959897994995117,
-0.025028426200151443,
-0.39125508069992065,
-0.022468596696853638,
-0.22505488991737366,
-0.3667668402194977,
-0.20861968398094177,
-0.4549676775932312,
0.8711796402931213,
-0.09477055817842484,
0.05993521586060524,
0.03590811789035797,
-0.6459111571311951,
-0.1856120377779007,
0.039053648710250854,
0.42176690697669983,
0.9639837145805359,
-0.22952435910701752,
0.4224657118320465,
-0.14080475270748138,
-0.2545635402202606,
0.20995649695396423,
-0.0028993766754865646,
-0.11601164191961288,
-0.10835439711809158,
0.6941404342651367,
0.7994362115859985,
0.2105041742324829,
-0.5388218760490417,
0.49314096570014954,
0.11152932792901993,
-0.08933506906032562,
-0.40200531482696533,
0.17626740038394928,
0.3513261079788208,
0.19575048983097076,
0.5582687258720398,
0.09727703034877777,
-0.4175932705402374,
-0.4882380962371826,
0.16565461456775665,
0.3614773154258728,
-0.38859546184539795,
-0.3896755278110504,
0.5723791122436523,
0.23327143490314484,
0.07262516021728516,
0.5556458234786987,
0.025078309699892998,
-0.43334707617759705,
-0.10488499701023102,
0.4598708748817444,
0.6082174777984619,
-0.35921207070350647,
-0.04554234817624092,
0.3533541262149811,
0.18183070421218872,
-0.05506529659032822,
-0.17818744480609894,
-0.21962110698223114,
-0.9593214392662048,
-0.5685943961143494,
-0.6843966245651245,
-0.21540674567222595,
0.06152208521962166,
-0.4737856090068817,
0.23377248644828796,
-0.4147834777832031,
0.2365453988313675,
-0.023104261606931686,
-0.34393930435180664,
-0.6584934592247009,
0.024754207581281662,
0.31295135617256165,
0.805848240852356,
-0.8555799126625061,
1.1731585264205933,
0.653515636920929,
-0.5414877533912659,
-0.9600812196731567,
-0.12071820348501205,
-0.23466673493385315,
-1.0885668992996216,
0.7429356575012207,
-0.17952251434326172,
0.01329860370606184,
0.22976729273796082,
-0.7289215922355652,
-0.9788439273834229,
0.9693872332572937,
1.0278432369232178,
-0.5226045846939087,
0.03813372179865837,
0.06557325273752213,
0.20400887727737427,
-0.391014039516449,
0.2606599032878876,
0.3631473779678345,
0.42338183522224426,
0.33737754821777344,
-0.5943840146064758,
0.13056020438671112,
-0.11268384009599686,
-0.2414436936378479,
-0.13075238466262817,
-0.2340213507413864,
0.5272195339202881,
-0.08421087265014648,
-0.1806473433971405,
-0.5784363746643066,
0.7199898958206177,
0.44417494535446167,
-0.03970303386449814,
0.36924782395362854,
0.5974924564361572,
0.8342335224151611,
-0.028161155059933662,
1.0025615692138672,
-0.2613656222820282,
-0.03572594001889229,
1.6648738384246826,
-0.25394201278686523,
0.861138641834259,
0.6520737409591675,
-0.060497403144836426,
0.5509658455848694,
0.4400498867034912,
0.25556647777557373,
0.8601218461990356,
0.08047457039356232,
-0.35237985849380493,
-0.4069804549217224,
-0.427304744720459,
-0.6591570377349854,
0.03150305524468422,
0.10716704279184341,
-0.6684648394584656,
-0.20973800122737885,
-0.05782913789153099,
0.10451854765415192,
-0.00751041853800416,
-0.3713313937187195,
0.9555596709251404,
0.1713091880083084,
-0.29718634486198425,
0.7044384479522705,
-0.46804457902908325,
0.4933099150657654,
-1.1372582912445068,
0.23801054060459137,
-0.1955941915512085,
0.05211465433239937,
-0.2987525165081024,
-0.652499794960022,
0.4024610221385956,
0.09731883555650711,
-0.47180506587028503,
-0.556276261806488,
0.7082201838493347,
-0.4850928485393524,
-0.45812124013900757,
0.03530723601579666,
0.6193068623542786,
-0.07699348777532578,
-0.5513898134231567,
-0.3573255240917206,
0.18537195026874542,
0.025756176561117172,
-0.5560972690582275,
0.6269083023071289,
0.7510939836502075,
0.21964651346206665,
0.7801522612571716,
0.8846492767333984,
0.3546171486377716,
-0.040851663798093796,
0.3259822726249695,
1.220732569694519,
-0.4258849322795868,
-0.5053669214248657,
-0.9070533514022827,
0.488787978887558,
-0.0587671734392643,
0.0140690291300416,
0.7255916595458984,
0.5178301930427551,
0.9595959186553955,
-0.14383070170879364,
0.9577891826629639,
0.1470811367034912,
0.5269300937652588,
-0.5850421190261841,
0.7594961524009705,
-0.516058087348938,
0.5110556483268738,
-0.0667242482304573,
-1.1066452264785767,
-0.01799355261027813,
0.6083794236183167,
-0.4246523082256317,
-0.14244379103183746,
0.612112283706665,
0.7259624600410461,
-0.17460696399211884,
-0.2316538691520691,
-0.010005279444158077,
0.15150293707847595,
0.5008249878883362,
0.3559352159500122,
0.9245874285697937,
0.07625143229961395,
0.5277516841888428,
0.028758808970451355,
-0.12127611041069031,
0.023565348237752914,
-1.2642532587051392,
-0.6644098162651062,
-0.4810822010040283,
-0.3270496428012848,
-0.14467576146125793,
0.11118099838495255,
0.9243828654289246,
0.675936222076416,
-0.6876581907272339,
0.20698580145835876,
-0.283125102519989,
0.12744085490703583,
0.03544292226433754,
-0.14821860194206238,
0.20810365676879883,
-0.48754310607910156,
-0.3826563358306885,
0.41218316555023193,
0.006093560717999935,
0.21847228705883026,
-0.25441524386405945,
-0.12632539868354797,
-0.4125661551952362,
-0.09553699940443039,
0.5255592465400696,
0.25808000564575195,
-0.3482724130153656,
-0.5476778745651245,
-0.3100709617137909,
-0.06204763054847717,
0.10300366580486298,
1.095448613166809,
-0.8319821953773499,
0.2601465582847595,
0.2872255742549896,
0.7948035597801208,
0.4538557231426239,
0.13437201082706451,
0.8787358403205872,
-1.0494346618652344,
0.20852647721767426,
0.18750573694705963,
0.25027066469192505,
0.581221878528595,
-0.3359145224094391,
0.37980642914772034,
0.37252238392829895,
-0.4589585065841675,
-0.8396017551422119,
0.05558587238192558,
-0.7664676904678345,
-0.22454676032066345,
1.1341190338134766,
-0.4811283349990845,
-0.138930082321167,
-0.08770927786827087,
0.1547151505947113,
0.2523949146270752,
-0.4270671308040619,
0.6594188213348389,
0.8148577213287354,
0.3820745646953583,
-0.2561667859554291,
-0.17893299460411072,
0.536791205406189,
0.2520323097705841,
-0.7018384337425232,
0.4259854555130005,
0.35415077209472656,
0.38944557309150696,
0.06887972354888916,
0.6781510710716248,
-0.035245560109615326,
-0.11842077970504761,
-0.005520510487258434,
0.031222255900502205,
-0.5442519187927246,
-0.3961299955844879,
-0.029399732127785683,
-0.13990116119384766,
0.6012616753578186,
0.1337607353925705
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.