id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11854v1
|
Attributions toward Artificial Agents in a modified Moral Turing Test
| 2024-04-03T13:00:47 | 2024-04-03T13:00:47 |
Eyal Aharoni, Sharlene Fernandes, Daniel J. Brady, Caelan Alexander, Michael Criner, Kara Queen, Javier Rando, Eddy Nahmias, Victor Crespo
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Advances in artificial intelligence (AI) raise important questions about
whether people view moral evaluations by AI systems similarly to
human-generated moral evaluations. We conducted a modified Moral Turing Test
(m-MTT), inspired by Allen and colleagues' (2000) proposal, by asking people to
distinguish real human moral evaluations from those made by a popular advanced
AI language model: GPT-4. A representative sample of 299 U.S. adults first
rated the quality of moral evaluations when blinded to their source.
Remarkably, they rated the AI's moral reasoning as superior in quality to
humans' along almost all dimensions, including virtuousness, intelligence, and
trustworthiness, consistent with passing what Allen and colleagues call the
comparative MTT. Next, when tasked with identifying the source of each
evaluation (human or computer), people performed significantly above chance
levels. Although the AI did not pass this test, this was not because of its
inferior moral reasoning but, potentially, its perceived superiority, among
other possible explanations. The emergence of language models capable of
producing moral responses perceived as superior in quality to humans' raises
concerns that people may uncritically accept potentially harmful moral guidance
from AI. This possibility highlights the need for safeguards around generative
language models in matters of morality.
|
[
-0.38595083355903625,
-0.583949625492096,
0.7903378009796143,
-0.09565751254558563,
-0.3289080262184143,
0.062361594289541245,
0.050312746316194534,
-0.7616395354270935,
-0.14325621724128723,
0.20733429491519928,
-0.31239017844200134,
0.11269994080066681,
-0.6099089980125427,
0.46552011370658875,
-0.2560896873474121,
1.007025122642517,
0.2174009531736374,
0.0004945557448081672,
-0.340178519487381,
-0.214641734957695,
-0.08351394534111023,
-0.7956289649009705,
-0.9017130732536316,
-0.7228463292121887,
0.5147833824157715,
-0.00020935569773428142,
1.0648877620697021,
0.5665139555931091,
0.4637943208217621,
0.4633897542953491,
0.27271634340286255,
-0.21908339858055115,
-0.23613515496253967,
-0.30678948760032654,
-0.4250526428222656,
-0.47727590799331665,
-0.5804932713508606,
0.8831729888916016,
0.27708232402801514,
0.20795339345932007,
0.1155303493142128,
0.2889766991138458,
-0.01811998151242733,
0.5162613391876221,
-0.24280625581741333,
0.14079174399375916,
-0.6817783117294312,
0.05396422743797302,
-0.06408989429473877,
-0.39335116744041443,
-0.5746137499809265,
-0.6365472674369812,
0.06620192527770996,
-0.5536426305770874,
0.14637397229671478,
0.060882631689310074,
0.8561530113220215,
0.3651333451271057,
-0.479009211063385,
-0.45176181197166443,
-0.7505316734313965,
1.1459496021270752,
-0.4384973645210266,
0.003301008837297559,
0.8463741540908813,
0.03248393535614014,
0.171888068318367,
-0.5316824913024902,
-0.7817099690437317,
-0.8905373215675354,
-0.007323912810534239,
0.2390899658203125,
-0.30463650822639465,
0.10971102863550186,
0.20759913325309753,
0.1707167625427246,
-0.2525128126144409,
-0.08424418419599533,
-0.5095324516296387,
-0.09851593524217606,
0.7141940593719482,
0.10145600140094757,
0.19298586249351501,
-0.2993691861629486,
-0.34626150131225586,
-0.33986783027648926,
-0.6000685691833496,
0.3620060086250305,
0.6869953274726868,
-0.057217035442590714,
0.07443244755268097,
0.7681806087493896,
0.37598952651023865,
0.2889026403427124,
0.19654327630996704,
0.5707627534866333,
0.25453701615333557,
-0.4128718674182892,
-0.14046388864517212,
-0.07311355322599411,
0.9006249308586121,
0.6146063208580017,
1.1068321466445923,
0.2913583517074585,
-0.3182065784931183,
0.39480867981910706,
0.8809980154037476,
-0.5448978543281555,
-0.15790270268917084,
-0.134820356965065,
-0.6698452830314636,
-0.6837558746337891,
0.3945024609565735,
-0.26033011078834534,
-0.42879870533943176,
-0.36654213070869446,
0.2516811490058899,
-0.4018094539642334,
0.08515095710754395,
-0.1253233104944229,
-0.1501595824956894,
0.382367342710495,
0.374641478061676,
-0.5207743644714355,
0.010356443002820015,
0.7476971745491028,
0.7149527668952942,
0.05044347420334816,
-0.4162486493587494,
-0.5974926948547363,
-0.06010526791214943,
-0.5249367356300354,
0.8367044925689697,
-0.76646488904953,
-0.42033651471138,
-0.48066839575767517,
-0.16305510699748993,
0.11468221247196198,
-0.41231489181518555,
0.5523367524147034,
-0.2956969439983368,
0.3152027130126953,
-0.3324536383152008,
-0.190410777926445,
-0.1948423534631729,
0.3620505630970001,
-0.42293038964271545,
0.36071163415908813,
0.17412036657333374,
-0.5268484950065613,
0.3357292115688324,
-0.9565904140472412,
-0.3933568298816681,
-0.016050994396209717,
-0.45160940289497375,
-0.30111294984817505,
0.10533924400806427,
-0.07656838744878769,
0.17176362872123718,
-0.318440705537796,
0.23397119343280792,
-0.23505191504955292,
-0.527975857257843,
0.8751010894775391,
-1.0890536308288574,
1.056785225868225,
0.14543931186199188,
-0.37139827013015747,
0.1881060004234314,
-0.34191209077835083,
-0.014738480560481548,
0.18177980184555054,
-0.3566017150878906,
-0.396599680185318,
0.22094668447971344,
-0.31348109245300293,
0.12608127295970917,
-0.011771182529628277,
-0.7361536622047424,
-0.1373276710510254,
-0.390619158744812,
0.551185667514801,
1.5226472616195679,
-0.2377903163433075,
0.1300162374973297,
-0.7237500548362732,
0.4792526364326477,
-0.2905324697494507,
0.5827173590660095,
0.49558478593826294,
-0.7568075060844421,
-0.5231910347938538,
-0.0002768704725895077,
-0.13713525235652924,
0.5106611251831055,
-0.6417433023452759,
0.35099685192108154,
-0.03933710232377052,
-0.3414386510848999,
-0.8767948150634766,
-0.3660781681537628,
0.5332903265953064,
0.27112308144569397,
0.3427589535713196,
-0.16442793607711792,
0.01005556434392929,
-1.158344030380249,
-0.6714503169059753,
-0.9134015440940857,
-0.35202986001968384,
0.6106097102165222,
0.640555739402771,
-0.1833149939775467,
0.6943973302841187,
-0.16842812299728394,
0.08874905109405518,
0.12647360563278198,
0.2760576903820038,
-0.07052216678857803,
0.5529744029045105,
0.5839636325836182,
-0.8518700003623962,
-0.3498663604259491,
0.06422388553619385,
-0.8656314015388489,
0.08860373497009277,
-0.006319107487797737,
-0.06968794018030167,
-0.10311494767665863,
0.19361187517642975,
-0.6427187323570251,
0.3580816090106964,
0.33286911249160767,
-0.8049288988113403,
0.9932622313499451,
-0.16732166707515717,
0.6727869510650635,
-0.9307162761688232,
-0.10653769969940186,
-0.39487752318382263,
-0.2706794738769531,
-0.3126092553138733,
-0.03505781292915344,
-0.16436372697353363,
0.29998892545700073,
-0.509284496307373,
0.2686426341533661,
0.07596097141504288,
-0.09032426029443741,
-0.07851556688547134,
-0.03134523332118988,
-0.02981492690742016,
0.2222316414117813,
-0.5111623406410217,
1.127732515335083,
0.42235273122787476,
-0.5091650485992432,
0.7094070911407471,
0.39866018295288086,
0.1700366735458374,
0.9820043444633484,
-0.8700282573699951,
0.4091885983943939,
-0.06119927018880844,
0.06385626643896103,
-0.48866310715675354,
-0.15692873299121857,
0.3707885146141052,
-0.9261429309844971,
-0.2605641186237335,
0.05763537064194679,
-0.2159472405910492,
-0.35280001163482666,
-0.6906594634056091,
0.6003605723381042,
0.6251079440116882,
-0.30844995379447937,
0.6681232452392578,
0.1409057378768921,
-0.1099863201379776,
-0.5055825114250183,
-0.8469209671020508,
0.17903214693069458,
-0.31880316138267517,
-0.6308194994926453,
0.008688393980264664,
-0.1428603231906891,
-0.8514818549156189,
0.07441919296979904,
0.17403919994831085,
0.00960491318255663,
0.1011234000325203,
0.2176142930984497,
0.20563876628875732,
-0.2691493332386017,
0.14960400760173798,
-0.06729795038700104,
-0.3384503722190857,
0.4266379177570343,
0.036872755736112595,
0.24766433238983154,
-0.7817180156707764,
-0.634454607963562,
-0.4868074953556061,
0.4124754071235657,
0.6752572655677795,
-0.3645365238189697,
0.577340304851532,
0.35232192277908325,
-0.20342299342155457,
0.28791344165802,
-0.29093924164772034,
-0.38912132382392883,
-0.5849753618240356,
0.07409591972827911,
-0.16298708319664001,
-0.8843486309051514,
0.2169220894575119,
0.3634102940559387,
0.04801392927765846,
0.6196868419647217,
0.5769850015640259,
-0.303120881319046,
1.0154038667678833,
0.3887924551963806,
0.176246777176857,
0.6363484263420105,
0.045924920588731766,
0.05020753666758537,
-0.6917387247085571,
0.08412954211235046,
-0.5755716562271118,
-0.1351267695426941,
-0.9565292596817017,
-0.3285810053348541,
0.2215678095817566,
-0.3922019302845001,
-0.5630841851234436,
0.11915229260921478,
-0.48957061767578125,
0.7280497550964355,
0.7673020958900452,
0.11981961131095886,
0.3913496136665344,
-0.07857584953308105,
0.11148551106452942,
0.2849668264389038,
-0.09547469764947891,
-1.0233205556869507,
1.1030718088150024,
0.2597695291042328,
0.5365045666694641,
0.2271927148103714,
0.49316418170928955,
0.9647449254989624,
0.5633503198623657,
-0.5765710473060608,
0.5370494723320007,
-0.3889831304550171,
-0.5578078627586365,
-0.2973216772079468,
-0.5916113257408142,
-1.1123278141021729,
0.17264512181282043,
0.0036908129695802927,
-0.6994364857673645,
0.1427924633026123,
0.10819783061742783,
-0.4278179109096527,
0.1826048195362091,
-0.8463391661643982,
0.6126270294189453,
-0.29117336869239807,
-0.17638789117336273,
-0.5873538851737976,
-0.6732019782066345,
0.31370335817337036,
-0.18867366015911102,
0.07788917422294617,
-0.2266741544008255,
0.08665812015533447,
0.6895569562911987,
-0.413944810628891,
0.7401639819145203,
0.008618170395493507,
0.08387172222137451,
0.5104526281356812,
0.1367419958114624,
0.4963948428630829,
0.11172313988208771,
-0.35107529163360596,
0.07931084930896759,
-0.1449301391839981,
-0.39992067217826843,
-0.49472367763519287,
0.5108615756034851,
-0.9857468605041504,
-0.75948566198349,
-0.5885268449783325,
-0.4715137183666229,
0.10111938416957855,
0.0036775858607143164,
0.2563352584838867,
0.46444663405418396,
-0.21435734629631042,
0.276984840631485,
0.13848040997982025,
-0.4398519992828369,
0.21803712844848633,
0.44063422083854675,
0.1945391297340393,
-0.24102772772312164,
0.8769847750663757,
-0.36251100897789,
0.5798941254615784,
-0.2255091518163681,
0.5822169184684753,
-0.3154813349246979,
-0.23419880867004395,
-0.5489586591720581,
0.2576121985912323,
-0.6363566517829895,
-0.1124148890376091,
-0.30405157804489136,
-0.046719565987586975,
0.07233214378356934,
-0.5191633701324463,
-0.5791668891906738,
-0.1685914248228073,
-0.39843782782554626,
-0.2655547857284546,
0.38100311160087585,
1.1868067979812622,
-0.019158974289894104,
0.05113871395587921,
-0.8032856583595276,
0.35694149136543274,
0.4223102629184723,
0.2622964680194855,
-0.2657667398452759,
-0.5223250985145569,
0.2021653652191162,
0.3120472729206085,
-0.4086098074913025,
-0.6942400336265564,
-0.1760403960943222,
0.12102970480918884,
0.40674659609794617,
0.34038469195365906,
0.23953379690647125,
0.4896129071712494,
-0.28535816073417664,
0.9292381405830383,
0.0016725858440622687,
-0.9774613380432129,
0.3329322934150696,
-0.41327789425849915,
-0.0800447016954422,
0.42729663848876953,
0.16220307350158691,
-0.2041323184967041,
-0.8036851286888123,
-0.7495681047439575,
-0.27433884143829346,
0.7253679037094116,
0.7521161437034607,
0.45922407507896423,
-0.15447622537612915,
0.46053752303123474,
0.20568792521953583,
0.13180002570152283,
-0.9471744894981384,
-0.0851857140660286,
-0.3668748736381531,
-0.2463056594133377,
-0.24897052347660065,
0.08491181582212448,
-0.08849325776100159,
-0.14000293612480164,
0.2921083867549896,
-0.07064390927553177,
0.5741327404975891,
0.24851439893245697,
-0.0003969911194872111,
-0.42936277389526367,
0.2940688133239746,
0.6085414290428162,
0.7586639523506165,
0.07934975624084473,
0.2646535336971283,
-0.2183082550764084,
-0.5623915791511536,
0.5075329542160034,
0.08338600397109985,
-0.34431666135787964,
-0.5659385919570923,
0.6205962300300598,
0.45417332649230957,
-0.5655921697616577,
-0.5688496232032776,
0.639987587928772,
-0.2348371297121048,
-0.04158227518200874,
-0.4381483793258667,
0.14232137799263,
-0.2656265199184418,
0.572939932346344,
0.1558593362569809,
0.54853355884552,
0.149942547082901,
-0.8496066927909851,
0.4985937178134918,
0.6908048987388611,
-0.3769298195838928,
-0.5874202847480774,
0.6335763335227966,
0.07627188414335251,
-0.8253864049911499,
0.9589161276817322,
-0.3068106174468994,
-0.6690261960029602,
0.6684445142745972,
0.2362184375524521,
0.9219370484352112,
-0.48539721965789795,
0.5234709978103638,
0.009820002131164074,
0.7437171339988708,
0.15359851717948914,
0.2314557284116745,
0.13157892227172852,
-0.9027645587921143,
-0.3739220201969147,
-0.4161047339439392,
-0.2746376693248749,
-0.22945968806743622,
-0.44950398802757263,
-0.24617142975330353,
-0.42399415373802185,
-0.5375865697860718,
-0.25024229288101196,
-0.2224562168121338,
-0.42084231972694397,
0.03099510632455349,
0.04085754230618477,
0.18843908607959747,
-0.5981869697570801,
0.6225685477256775,
0.6431611180305481,
-0.6625612378120422,
-0.47343310713768005,
0.21281322836875916,
-0.16849032044410706,
-0.9781677722930908,
0.2238345444202423,
0.18581178784370422,
-0.5180614590644836,
-0.010297112166881561,
-0.5992290377616882,
-0.5180240869522095,
0.8340464234352112,
0.5514200329780579,
0.045890506356954575,
0.11021848767995834,
0.26715391874313354,
0.7075102925300598,
-0.3245701789855957,
0.2597469389438629,
0.6450868248939514,
0.7014697790145874,
-0.2979121506214142,
-0.9708573818206787,
0.1690395325422287,
-0.37907376885414124,
-0.25767382979393005,
0.13757680356502533,
-0.5844191312789917,
1.1228208541870117,
-0.47375205159187317,
-0.040001772344112396,
0.008255066350102425,
0.435537725687027,
0.4863832890987396,
0.47031351923942566,
0.6109645962715149,
-0.10891307890415192,
0.6295207738876343,
0.058232057839632034,
1.4536148309707642,
0.24132311344146729,
0.1392732411623001,
0.6396459341049194,
-0.01654566079378128,
0.5765431523323059,
0.5170471668243408,
-0.2513491213321686,
0.4761362075805664,
0.43116626143455505,
-0.12121433019638062,
0.2905016541481018,
0.11003892123699188,
-0.10904784500598907,
-0.1962248980998993,
-0.2963218688964844,
-0.1510389745235443,
0.6257938146591187,
0.21235918998718262,
-0.5285922884941101,
0.1529950499534607,
-0.007502370979636908,
-0.2150510549545288,
0.04070071130990982,
-0.22706599533557892,
0.7355364561080933,
0.23703649640083313,
-0.6268176436424255,
0.5323390960693359,
0.05007713660597801,
0.48181450366973877,
-0.42426636815071106,
-0.1330789029598236,
0.02869565226137638,
0.2753100097179413,
-0.06420502811670303,
-1.0621628761291504,
0.46780285239219666,
0.4818146824836731,
0.06504684686660767,
-0.2937937378883362,
0.4544629454612732,
0.08302760124206543,
-0.5163822174072266,
0.4163331985473633,
0.5607813000679016,
0.43959206342697144,
-0.27438727021217346,
-0.9299726486206055,
-0.29834645986557007,
0.19975879788398743,
-0.3993416428565979,
-0.039269398897886276,
0.2894749641418457,
-0.29234522581100464,
0.93593829870224,
0.894314169883728,
-0.20137229561805725,
0.030079174786806107,
0.052735812962055206,
0.838884711265564,
-0.7906895875930786,
-0.33108803629875183,
-1.204108715057373,
0.4587455987930298,
0.0421920008957386,
-0.2524729073047638,
0.42803484201431274,
0.18032985925674438,
0.6591788530349731,
-0.0431661531329155,
0.8362589478492737,
0.005711774807423353,
0.03919759392738342,
-0.48842787742614746,
0.7664432525634766,
-0.441999226808548,
0.12940561771392822,
-0.3475984036922455,
-0.8869900703430176,
0.11533966660499573,
0.8222363591194153,
-0.19137714803218842,
0.643818199634552,
0.7431682348251343,
0.4802475571632385,
0.09602717310190201,
0.05197443813085556,
0.4665742814540863,
0.3539562523365021,
0.7906897664070129,
0.3079518973827362,
1.3929762840270996,
-0.055699508637189865,
0.5398311018943787,
0.08625500649213791,
-0.39707955718040466,
0.0014582579024136066,
-0.8074772953987122,
-0.7893065810203552,
-0.29080522060394287,
-0.03995926305651665,
-0.08080487698316574,
0.057175420224666595,
1.076515793800354,
0.20057329535484314,
-0.7065277695655823,
-0.12942637503147125,
-0.15300576388835907,
0.05445586144924164,
-0.3203105032444,
-0.23142829537391663,
0.3500843942165375,
0.15696361660957336,
-0.5243848562240601,
0.33029764890670776,
0.1642591804265976,
0.19814902544021606,
-0.26267489790916443,
-0.3325153887271881,
0.10899887979030609,
0.4840899407863617,
0.8201786279678345,
-0.2183188796043396,
-1.0291064977645874,
-0.8972784280776978,
-0.1111968606710434,
-0.04565158113837242,
0.10292909294366837,
0.7862009406089783,
-0.546278715133667,
0.23628069460391998,
0.2607450485229492,
0.2673470675945282,
-0.2529164254665375,
0.5703458786010742,
0.9207760095596313,
-0.23577679693698883,
-0.06433553248643875,
0.5941112637519836,
0.24561338126659393,
0.2516101002693176,
-0.502254843711853,
0.42333856225013733,
0.32994911074638367,
-0.7500473856925964,
-0.5572254061698914,
0.3694596290588379,
-0.645596444606781,
-0.07812964171171188,
0.902213454246521,
-0.18286269903182983,
-0.04522893205285072,
-0.35986822843551636,
-0.25655078887939453,
0.19292880594730377,
-0.6251914501190186,
0.9430147409439087,
0.5843796730041504,
-0.4672602117061615,
0.1101994439959526,
-0.6922233700752258,
0.44476550817489624,
0.2666703462600708,
-0.8508173823356628,
0.21557168662548065,
0.5398029685020447,
-0.030079299584031105,
0.21362829208374023,
0.5609058141708374,
-0.20333226025104523,
0.4880940020084381,
0.06309952586889267,
-0.2175535410642624,
-0.23733016848564148,
-0.1989552080631256,
-0.10657928138971329,
-0.18859896063804626,
0.28185099363327026,
-0.17460830509662628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02699v1
|
Scalable Model Editing via Customized Expert Networks
| 2024-04-03T12:57:19 | 2024-04-03T12:57:19 |
Zihan Yao, Yu He, Tianyu Qi, Ming Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Addressing the issue of hallucinations and outdated knowledge in large
language models is critical for their reliable application. Model Editing
presents a promising avenue for mitigating these challenges in a cost-effective
manner. However, existing methods often suffer from unsatisfactory
generalization and unintended effects on unrelated samples. To overcome these
limitations, we introduce a novel approach: Scalable Model Editing via
Customized Expert Networks (SCEN), which is a two-stage continuous training
paradigm. Specifically, in the first stage, we train lightweight expert
networks individually for each piece of knowledge that needs to be updated.
Subsequently, we train a corresponding neuron for each expert to control the
activation state of that expert. Our experiments on two different sizes of
open-source large language models, the Llama2 7B and 13B, achieve
state-of-the-art results compared to existing mainstream Model Editing methods.
Our code is available at https: //github.com/TAL-auroraX/SCEN
|
[
-0.10702288150787354,
-0.7538756132125854,
0.5293470621109009,
0.29223355650901794,
0.056948527693748474,
-0.02483223006129265,
-0.6190522909164429,
-0.4840013086795807,
0.4300753176212311,
0.6890488862991333,
-0.273144006729126,
-0.32174649834632874,
-0.6056680679321289,
-0.04591446742415428,
-0.29861652851104736,
0.7391473650932312,
-0.012482122518122196,
0.29690107703208923,
-0.2100713849067688,
-0.33580484986305237,
-0.24073944985866547,
-0.29103952646255493,
-1.0773074626922607,
-0.33927324414253235,
0.6775482892990112,
0.3408661484718323,
0.7827188372612,
0.8554356098175049,
0.4538959860801697,
0.3702233135700226,
-0.5428120493888855,
0.32475516200065613,
-0.44700807332992554,
0.25751447677612305,
-0.3654901683330536,
-0.2563687264919281,
-0.8121841549873352,
-0.4759443998336792,
0.5951552391052246,
0.8008336424827576,
-0.291363924741745,
0.1456160545349121,
-0.04120892658829689,
0.5247067809104919,
-0.5466448068618774,
0.11246331036090851,
-1.0173498392105103,
-0.13141287863254547,
-0.03489776700735092,
0.11384623497724533,
-0.4813361167907715,
-0.07000119984149933,
-0.07667223364114761,
-0.6910295486450195,
0.19842617213726044,
-0.3125428855419159,
0.6683254241943359,
0.6396456360816956,
-0.16598178446292877,
-0.053038787096738815,
-0.6017555594444275,
0.30930957198143005,
-1.0083731412887573,
0.07071784138679504,
0.27332863211631775,
0.22965168952941895,
-0.32299041748046875,
-0.8571294546127319,
-0.4945026636123657,
-0.30635395646095276,
0.031651731580495834,
-0.14935091137886047,
-0.3678727149963379,
0.3468741178512573,
0.4764593243598938,
-0.013529199175536633,
-0.22890174388885498,
0.6485461592674255,
-0.35171419382095337,
-0.05562061816453934,
0.7216094732284546,
0.10142594575881958,
0.3042856454849243,
-0.020119205117225647,
0.2801818251609802,
0.08333757519721985,
-0.45143941044807434,
-0.22041265666484833,
0.4351949989795685,
0.268544465303421,
0.3160571753978729,
0.7836706042289734,
-0.4146502912044525,
0.760940432548523,
0.4283560514450073,
0.09807611256837845,
0.19682154059410095,
0.12207093089818954,
-0.37725913524627686,
0.06846954673528671,
0.6957524418830872,
0.374402791261673,
0.2886749804019928,
-0.24103529751300812,
-0.4206944704055786,
-0.21926723420619965,
0.3610992729663849,
-0.6608254909515381,
-0.3905389606952667,
0.22877132892608643,
-0.3878609836101532,
-0.6652272939682007,
-0.5524566173553467,
-0.5554670095443726,
-0.8546956181526184,
-0.40310975909233093,
0.46352338790893555,
-0.12773488461971283,
-0.305422842502594,
0.26400139927864075,
-0.09550558030605316,
-0.476644366979599,
0.5153173804283142,
-1.1134666204452515,
0.15198443830013275,
0.28380462527275085,
0.8744698166847229,
-0.0527331717312336,
-0.41337597370147705,
-0.4398095905780792,
0.24771299958229065,
-0.5036025643348694,
0.6393018364906311,
-0.5873187184333801,
-0.1250956505537033,
-0.21510358154773712,
-0.17154109477996826,
-0.049590155482292175,
-0.49623093008995056,
-0.008767666295170784,
-0.792607307434082,
-0.2620498836040497,
-0.10727664083242416,
-0.4576639235019684,
0.0412106029689312,
0.15228135883808136,
-0.6758812665939331,
1.1923681497573853,
0.06382614374160767,
-0.7237644791603088,
0.043905582278966904,
-0.6817286014556885,
-0.43063971400260925,
-0.10313715040683746,
0.10941345989704132,
-0.2579876780509949,
0.2804824709892273,
0.3547457158565521,
0.5008183121681213,
0.08698952943086624,
0.3496370315551758,
-0.46406543254852295,
-0.11440902948379517,
0.1576242744922638,
0.04294608160853386,
0.4085978865623474,
0.04165685176849365,
-0.269397109746933,
0.7080576419830322,
-1.150331974029541,
-0.08925008028745651,
0.05857938155531883,
-0.2407604157924652,
-0.3517187833786011,
-0.0006713839247822762,
0.03344273939728737,
0.1924847513437271,
0.427087664604187,
-0.4208984971046448,
0.504166841506958,
-0.44503840804100037,
0.7172455787658691,
1.021735429763794,
0.27856963872909546,
0.5804357528686523,
-0.05944693088531494,
0.30787917971611023,
-0.17441348731517792,
0.26423579454421997,
-0.04866093024611473,
-0.21459126472473145,
-1.1973005533218384,
-0.11600141227245331,
0.33690211176872253,
0.5587695837020874,
-0.8249903321266174,
0.2628219425678253,
-0.29581567645072937,
-0.647016704082489,
-0.36420971155166626,
0.2928321957588196,
-0.01730223186314106,
0.48050636053085327,
0.5649381875991821,
-0.10522042959928513,
-0.5577770471572876,
-1.1382479667663574,
-0.4213235080242157,
0.08997051417827606,
-0.2694256901741028,
0.28155097365379333,
0.5371056795120239,
-0.34876736998558044,
0.8820705413818359,
-0.28282803297042847,
-0.12624192237854004,
-0.25153034925460815,
0.046485379338264465,
-0.06316160410642624,
0.6615719795227051,
0.4859624207019806,
-0.4248069226741791,
-0.40535858273506165,
0.3040735423564911,
-0.8391393423080444,
-0.1879580169916153,
-0.5759844183921814,
-0.09081503748893738,
-0.08631934225559235,
0.7122980952262878,
-0.5605193972587585,
0.26823845505714417,
0.46091514825820923,
0.14926576614379883,
0.47750794887542725,
-0.5163968801498413,
0.004729493986815214,
-1.1375433206558228,
-0.173161581158638,
0.07058458775281906,
-0.04131617397069931,
-0.818169355392456,
0.15012231469154358,
0.25448426604270935,
0.05083160474896431,
-0.39878228306770325,
0.4853857457637787,
-0.3437969982624054,
-0.050604358315467834,
-0.3956195116043091,
0.08636641502380371,
-0.34723570942878723,
0.7007399201393127,
-0.009516543708741665,
0.5590769052505493,
0.5420383810997009,
-0.3391936123371124,
0.2052384465932846,
0.2747378349304199,
-0.45916181802749634,
0.20823372900485992,
-1.0631122589111328,
0.4481819272041321,
-0.08682704716920853,
0.1659339815378189,
-0.48900115489959717,
-0.5279840230941772,
0.23503458499908447,
-0.15954650938510895,
0.21337389945983887,
-0.1857498437166214,
-0.6566129326820374,
-0.057170458137989044,
0.16827507317066193,
0.10648523271083832,
0.1598716825246811,
-0.5738374590873718,
0.8516642451286316,
0.29407352209091187,
-0.2297334522008896,
-0.48333778977394104,
-0.868720293045044,
0.6218991875648499,
0.1262931078672409,
-0.6877826452255249,
0.05480346456170082,
-0.09924689680337906,
-0.3285037577152252,
0.016234541311860085,
-0.041622113436460495,
-0.2112218737602234,
0.030399898067116737,
0.26736706495285034,
0.14431002736091614,
0.007477168925106525,
0.28834667801856995,
0.713627278804779,
-0.1525411307811737,
-0.13867944478988647,
-0.3071358799934387,
0.15338774025440216,
0.026614129543304443,
-0.27428939938545227,
-0.6444389820098877,
0.27368372678756714,
0.8077404499053955,
-0.5962957739830017,
0.6791618466377258,
0.3057277500629425,
-0.6270827651023865,
-0.3491474390029907,
-0.7349308729171753,
-0.13628259301185608,
-0.5122765302658081,
0.8132030367851257,
-0.4669467806816101,
-1.195177435874939,
0.474086731672287,
-0.301157683134079,
-0.07243981957435608,
0.4089803397655487,
0.538938581943512,
0.005839705001562834,
1.1565220355987549,
0.8250613212585449,
0.21183602511882782,
0.4985252320766449,
-0.24169038236141205,
0.01804964803159237,
-0.8605785965919495,
-0.15115422010421753,
-0.351522296667099,
-0.4507921040058136,
-0.23500993847846985,
-0.4636135399341583,
0.36086466908454895,
0.15893007814884186,
-0.39448270201683044,
0.38250473141670227,
-0.4893961250782013,
0.6985663175582886,
0.24214960634708405,
0.45160770416259766,
0.15023256838321686,
0.06802432239055634,
-0.029847251251339912,
-0.04269874095916748,
-0.9334732294082642,
-0.4638482630252838,
1.15919029712677,
0.37285202741622925,
0.5603017807006836,
-0.2561012804508209,
0.3207436800003052,
0.4362197816371918,
0.29464107751846313,
-0.639525294303894,
0.6152073740959167,
-0.11607782542705536,
-0.460134893655777,
-0.5320659875869751,
-0.3065466582775116,
-0.38043633103370667,
0.38561055064201355,
-0.3869340717792511,
-0.8342429995536804,
0.5277567505836487,
0.40245604515075684,
-0.27705052495002747,
0.8832072615623474,
-0.41972917318344116,
0.6342730522155762,
-0.17214204370975494,
-0.31610700488090515,
-0.671402633190155,
-0.5648234486579895,
0.3160415589809418,
-0.26387837529182434,
0.06268075853586197,
0.28435060381889343,
-0.0866561084985733,
0.6317639946937561,
-0.4775814414024353,
1.0491372346878052,
0.057642605155706406,
0.15222077071666718,
0.01688111573457718,
0.3181696832180023,
0.9562897682189941,
0.049617890268564224,
-0.385733962059021,
0.37567341327667236,
-0.353122353553772,
-0.5096505284309387,
-0.9245849251747131,
0.6988682746887207,
-0.7476689219474792,
-0.47434768080711365,
-0.14276055991649628,
-0.7745556235313416,
-0.29165783524513245,
0.34888651967048645,
0.18832750618457794,
0.3863954246044159,
-0.060392942279577255,
0.1767820566892624,
0.8411588072776794,
-0.03996317833662033,
0.3584423363208771,
0.28090140223503113,
-0.015087367966771126,
-0.6903479695320129,
0.5832409858703613,
0.28680160641670227,
0.43953755497932434,
0.13595178723335266,
0.09819436073303223,
0.4488818049430847,
-0.9710632562637329,
-0.5440924763679504,
0.16544604301452637,
-0.9208624958992004,
0.12906861305236816,
-1.0879100561141968,
-0.12232380360364914,
-0.2738187313079834,
-0.4275391697883606,
-0.7156204581260681,
-0.65556401014328,
-0.36158037185668945,
-0.19988961517810822,
0.3501032292842865,
1.0698151588439941,
-0.2790449857711792,
0.7602243423461914,
-0.5256057381629944,
0.1208602786064148,
0.4033270478248596,
0.36675572395324707,
0.3163944184780121,
-0.5883334875106812,
-0.6492608785629272,
0.06987078487873077,
0.22365590929985046,
-0.8407654762268066,
0.18610280752182007,
0.16553829610347748,
0.5181803107261658,
0.4087359309196472,
-0.19199138879776,
0.6084567904472351,
-0.5596603155136108,
0.8170609474182129,
0.2211812138557434,
-1.082787036895752,
0.5060351490974426,
-0.3744780421257019,
0.23787346482276917,
0.5256107449531555,
0.17055827379226685,
-0.7403116822242737,
-0.3902999758720398,
-0.4348611533641815,
-0.6694638729095459,
0.5523913502693176,
-0.07200408726930618,
0.2465256005525589,
0.18361897766590118,
0.841648519039154,
0.09132147580385208,
0.3472338914871216,
-0.3904353082180023,
-0.10438000410795212,
-0.35163819789886475,
-0.011413340456783772,
0.010446467436850071,
-0.5307232737541199,
-0.17786328494548798,
-0.40736857056617737,
0.7257758975028992,
-0.14717835187911987,
-0.20362639427185059,
-0.046229392290115356,
-0.3091409206390381,
-0.24971531331539154,
0.172796368598938,
0.7095645070075989,
0.9660244584083557,
-0.037352703511714935,
-0.12433595955371857,
0.7255983352661133,
-0.37868165969848633,
-0.07640589773654938,
-0.3501359224319458,
-0.45479220151901245,
-0.14195489883422852,
0.464122474193573,
1.289515733718872,
0.36016514897346497,
-0.38371536135673523,
0.10108593106269836,
0.06168730929493904,
-0.47222158312797546,
-0.09895920753479004,
0.2855209708213806,
0.13361521065235138,
0.45783671736717224,
0.08880437910556793,
0.7530683279037476,
-0.0774855986237526,
0.15133458375930786,
-0.08805515617132187,
-0.06584912538528442,
-0.4349759519100189,
-0.1714637577533722,
0.8226926326751709,
-0.031556520611047745,
-0.5286278128623962,
0.707152247428894,
0.0009819892002269626,
-0.3913993537425995,
0.45642632246017456,
0.37023502588272095,
0.9206529259681702,
-0.1634962260723114,
0.2628271281719208,
0.5698762536048889,
0.589641273021698,
-0.2753198444843292,
-0.187697634100914,
0.09049693495035172,
-0.7059943675994873,
-0.5638158321380615,
-0.38493281602859497,
-0.5198942422866821,
0.2119429111480713,
-0.5922992825508118,
0.1822240650653839,
-0.7021872401237488,
-0.08839140087366104,
-0.04951876401901245,
-0.5781033635139465,
-0.38678887486457825,
0.2867816984653473,
-0.21045023202896118,
1.0252423286437988,
-0.7322849631309509,
0.9595242738723755,
0.765129804611206,
-0.4186064600944519,
-0.7049270868301392,
-0.30765029788017273,
-0.07228364795446396,
-0.36633121967315674,
0.45621728897094727,
-0.23709259927272797,
-0.005631645210087299,
0.12829679250717163,
-0.8033490180969238,
-0.8602912425994873,
0.9344189167022705,
0.4806491434574127,
-0.8634730577468872,
-0.15439996123313904,
-0.04162302985787392,
0.7126562595367432,
-0.41913166642189026,
0.17914846539497375,
0.5245693325996399,
0.5850654244422913,
0.030168043449521065,
-0.8110819458961487,
-0.12266973406076431,
-0.5396411418914795,
0.2869601845741272,
-0.2438427060842514,
-0.5599754452705383,
0.7999624609947205,
-0.2785501480102539,
0.30242016911506653,
0.1979411542415619,
0.8501763939857483,
-0.05482017621397972,
-0.11023462563753128,
0.8066853284835815,
0.6323520541191101,
0.9874001145362854,
0.22723935544490814,
0.6835611462593079,
-0.4162927567958832,
0.13872221112251282,
1.432342290878296,
-0.19125087559223175,
0.9154244065284729,
0.39646854996681213,
0.1381576657295227,
0.4207458794116974,
0.9119874238967896,
-0.24359500408172607,
0.24317480623722076,
0.21876344084739685,
-0.21358318626880646,
-0.732645571231842,
0.2386428564786911,
-0.2785230875015259,
0.2515444755554199,
0.26510506868362427,
-0.2565547227859497,
-0.0835113450884819,
0.40630537271499634,
0.2652958631515503,
0.12967325747013092,
-0.3177605867385864,
0.5901099443435669,
-0.21648553013801575,
-0.2825870215892792,
0.30071818828582764,
0.1490844190120697,
0.4459081292152405,
-0.7578462958335876,
0.07711336761713028,
-0.1205601766705513,
0.1104269027709961,
-0.35130131244659424,
-0.42986974120140076,
0.08513600379228592,
0.0964575707912445,
-0.24492689967155457,
-0.1325085312128067,
0.7541379332542419,
-0.3770328164100647,
-0.6476043462753296,
0.2779860198497772,
0.20008651912212372,
0.03338690847158432,
-0.25455689430236816,
-0.6234163641929626,
0.11036069691181183,
-0.12233655899763107,
-0.556127667427063,
0.31791773438453674,
0.15194499492645264,
-0.16825948655605316,
0.8848294615745544,
0.7855151295661926,
0.4511087238788605,
0.1070873960852623,
0.19148074090480804,
1.009783387184143,
-0.2863660156726837,
-0.5327584743499756,
-0.455101877450943,
0.7139255404472351,
-0.3287544548511505,
-0.34677985310554504,
0.6029028296470642,
0.27768436074256897,
0.8290889263153076,
-0.26394760608673096,
1.0008130073547363,
0.08012694120407104,
0.08573050796985626,
-0.40131548047065735,
1.1750903129577637,
-0.5926170945167542,
0.2886393666267395,
-0.1261163353919983,
-0.7993444204330444,
-0.5275967121124268,
0.44559183716773987,
-0.4017236530780792,
-0.05914171785116196,
0.5975929498672485,
1.1699143648147583,
0.029506376013159752,
-0.0328444242477417,
0.191316619515419,
0.6644707918167114,
0.31928542256355286,
0.1441294252872467,
0.5215306282043457,
-0.14383789896965027,
0.2889043688774109,
-0.5945478677749634,
-0.3500877916812897,
-0.1792965531349182,
-0.8091049194335938,
-1.1383800506591797,
-0.4272820055484772,
-0.5319207906723022,
-0.28263217210769653,
0.4415495693683624,
1.0478729009628296,
0.6952514052391052,
-0.8428910970687866,
-0.22189728915691376,
-0.08327116072177887,
-0.0037684771232306957,
-0.48816099762916565,
-0.03461315110325813,
0.5488983392715454,
-0.4172859489917755,
-0.6592803597450256,
0.7925539016723633,
0.38372698426246643,
-0.20181092619895935,
-0.3151665925979614,
-0.03201614320278168,
-0.15415836870670319,
0.28161272406578064,
0.5862863063812256,
0.21326172351837158,
-0.6147704124450684,
-0.41245535016059875,
0.06259278953075409,
-0.13015291094779968,
-0.07892825454473495,
0.6831108331680298,
-0.48833340406417847,
0.801598310470581,
0.3552376627922058,
0.7618086338043213,
0.5091528296470642,
-0.36928290128707886,
0.42140164971351624,
-0.30851924419403076,
0.19397053122520447,
0.0241779163479805,
0.368303507566452,
0.3761495053768158,
-0.4699968993663788,
0.40899035334587097,
0.2513662278652191,
-0.658868670463562,
-0.9013465642929077,
0.0934651717543602,
-1.0975472927093506,
-0.2291753590106964,
1.0798156261444092,
-0.020097628235816956,
-0.1856868416070938,
0.2775111198425293,
-0.32549193501472473,
0.3891884684562683,
-0.036956630647182465,
0.8373314738273621,
0.6926676630973816,
-0.05264860764145851,
-0.12018144875764847,
-0.663154661655426,
0.21717332303524017,
0.3267255127429962,
-0.576970636844635,
-0.07603094726800919,
0.5183610916137695,
0.3053463399410248,
-0.2695046067237854,
0.16957984864711761,
0.22489339113235474,
0.4057801365852356,
0.14565162360668182,
0.6544386148452759,
-0.7321252822875977,
-0.4126116931438446,
-0.5404723882675171,
0.15735745429992676,
-0.025688229128718376,
0.10463700443506241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02690v1
|
Attention is Naturally Sparse with Gaussian Distributed Input
| 2024-04-03T12:37:34 | 2024-04-03T12:37:34 |
Yichuan Deng, Zhao Song, Chiwun Yang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The computational intensity of Large Language Models (LLMs) is a critical
bottleneck, primarily due to the $O(n^2)$ complexity of the attention mechanism
in transformer architectures. Addressing this, sparse attention emerges as a
key innovation, aiming to reduce computational load while maintaining model
performance. This study presents a rigorous theoretical analysis of the
sparsity in attention scores within LLMs, particularly under the framework of
Gaussian inputs. By establishing a set of foundational assumptions and
employing a methodical theoretical approach, we unravel the intrinsic
characteristics of attention score sparsity and its implications on
computational efficiency. Our main contribution lies in providing a detailed
theoretical examination of how sparsity manifests in attention mechanisms,
offering insights into the potential trade-offs between computational savings
and model effectiveness. This work not only advances our understanding of
sparse attention but also provides a scaffold for future research in optimizing
the computational frameworks of LLMs, paving the way for more scalable and
efficient AI systems.
|
[
-0.6578752398490906,
-1.102967619895935,
0.7275846004486084,
0.4080196022987366,
0.22819411754608154,
-0.27610912919044495,
-0.42533057928085327,
-0.2525806725025177,
0.0932331383228302,
0.24510788917541504,
-0.6021705269813538,
0.08182202279567719,
-0.9290754795074463,
0.037678662687540054,
-0.5183649063110352,
0.9509539604187012,
0.05200299993157387,
-0.3021892309188843,
-0.33834463357925415,
-0.1823834627866745,
-0.29180118441581726,
-0.4355345070362091,
-0.5455847978591919,
0.01558034960180521,
0.8088443875312805,
0.1718667447566986,
0.9249093532562256,
0.6566529273986816,
0.7456648349761963,
0.3196486234664917,
-0.11909893900156021,
-0.16860967874526978,
-1.1464372873306274,
0.2925757169723511,
-0.010364480316638947,
-0.31143513321876526,
-0.24571828544139862,
-0.09247371554374695,
0.9553207755088806,
0.9963768124580383,
-0.12038921564817429,
0.29445013403892517,
0.6756652593612671,
0.4825548529624939,
-0.5768464803695679,
0.1472264528274536,
-0.5626327991485596,
-0.08204419910907745,
0.014748919755220413,
-0.17754842340946198,
-0.2731679379940033,
0.07016273587942123,
0.12818622589111328,
-0.5118755102157593,
0.6857767105102539,
-0.12345264106988907,
0.9019567966461182,
0.7422273755073547,
0.3347419202327728,
-0.021013006567955017,
-0.8524053692817688,
0.8425819277763367,
-0.24505507946014404,
0.3517496883869171,
0.2290743887424469,
-0.03728458285331726,
-0.0828808844089508,
-0.35799163579940796,
-0.26313358545303345,
-0.24677561223506927,
-0.03643841668963432,
-0.20292584598064423,
-0.6633491516113281,
0.18337973952293396,
0.3443329632282257,
0.4186551570892334,
-0.5292432308197021,
-0.22287778556346893,
-0.20427930355072021,
0.25103136897087097,
0.4381289780139923,
0.47011423110961914,
0.16405613720417023,
0.43052172660827637,
-0.131649911403656,
0.25219184160232544,
-0.5491927266120911,
-0.11734675616025925,
0.01853506825864315,
0.2714061439037323,
-0.32147613167762756,
0.4440709054470062,
0.0037664223928004503,
0.8529168367385864,
0.4096495509147644,
0.16372019052505493,
-0.3272983133792877,
-0.15550602972507477,
-0.3521399199962616,
-0.5544266104698181,
0.6854474544525146,
-0.06398586928844452,
0.4376460313796997,
-0.5182836055755615,
-0.15120232105255127,
-0.07426635175943375,
0.5609158873558044,
-0.5991653800010681,
0.0011462174588814378,
0.12166371941566467,
-0.0987827256321907,
-0.2385498285293579,
-0.2903744876384735,
-0.8553118705749512,
-0.33895227313041687,
-0.3398083448410034,
0.25655820965766907,
-0.10251698642969131,
-0.06928741931915283,
-0.0995367243885994,
0.3073956072330475,
-0.04481256380677223,
0.39856934547424316,
-1.1154829263687134,
0.5799274444580078,
0.7397499680519104,
1.054049015045166,
-0.32651081681251526,
-0.24884115159511566,
-0.5916447043418884,
0.026883414015173912,
-0.29012131690979004,
0.6870157718658447,
-0.6344983577728271,
-0.16525913774967194,
-0.12679989635944366,
-0.2579808831214905,
-0.569861114025116,
-0.33647972345352173,
0.30238664150238037,
-0.6479076147079468,
-0.3693097233772278,
-0.07956009358167648,
-0.2867102026939392,
-0.08583428710699081,
0.07576418668031693,
-0.844876766204834,
1.1367889642715454,
0.40648213028907776,
-0.3738061785697937,
0.010284360498189926,
-0.42165595293045044,
-0.5259406566619873,
0.24823492765426636,
-0.04486846551299095,
-0.22987128794193268,
0.5898364782333374,
-0.09501741826534271,
0.695160448551178,
-0.4953022301197052,
0.3750402331352234,
-0.5027807950973511,
-0.7792190909385681,
0.7371646165847778,
-0.49866336584091187,
0.32534146308898926,
0.22615258395671844,
-0.5102782845497131,
-0.14176592230796814,
-0.806475818157196,
-0.1086021140217781,
0.0757531151175499,
-0.35733768343925476,
-0.09658389538526535,
0.053503960371017456,
0.303291916847229,
0.1208849772810936,
-0.10541075468063354,
-0.09373748302459717,
-0.011330069042742252,
-0.7296578884124756,
0.5870351791381836,
0.6588122844696045,
-0.1206439733505249,
0.5306709408760071,
-0.0027864056173712015,
0.6274207234382629,
-0.5252403616905212,
-0.027300167828798294,
0.16987667977809906,
-0.23778179287910461,
-0.9424115419387817,
-0.6548569798469543,
0.22468341886997223,
0.2730898857116699,
-0.05242765322327614,
0.26587358117103577,
-0.3830261528491974,
0.0009317604708485305,
-0.7449228763580322,
0.1675761491060257,
0.24695280194282532,
0.013027612119913101,
0.13000966608524323,
-0.015436790883541107,
-0.23403818905353546,
-0.7829236388206482,
-0.1748851090669632,
0.4305937886238098,
-0.01692609116435051,
0.5546203255653381,
0.2717238962650299,
-0.13627947866916656,
0.7793275117874146,
-0.2922268807888031,
-0.2259526252746582,
-0.7517918348312378,
-0.18167822062969208,
0.27426058053970337,
0.29793697595596313,
0.49999383091926575,
-0.40961188077926636,
-0.5126580595970154,
-0.0225656870752573,
-0.4229096472263336,
-0.1788579225540161,
-0.15623508393764496,
-0.020206468179821968,
0.20987580716609955,
0.3687601685523987,
-0.8904991745948792,
0.5406344532966614,
0.47676536440849304,
0.07042718678712845,
0.050071828067302704,
-0.0471421554684639,
0.10418272763490677,
-0.47560572624206543,
0.28317251801490784,
0.363369345664978,
0.02673392929136753,
-0.9068892598152161,
0.27223142981529236,
-0.1863839030265808,
-0.36577627062797546,
-0.09150683879852295,
0.47113579511642456,
-0.5595278739929199,
-0.2823401391506195,
-0.40605098009109497,
0.32241252064704895,
-0.044440459460020065,
1.0967999696731567,
-0.19028082489967346,
0.8987265825271606,
0.3051968812942505,
-0.5746826529502869,
0.06411169469356537,
-0.2932162284851074,
-0.10907068848609924,
0.4846804440021515,
-1.1626681089401245,
-0.020024172961711884,
-0.1647835373878479,
-0.32132455706596375,
-1.4769558906555176,
-0.23051875829696655,
0.19785740971565247,
-0.525470495223999,
0.7000924944877625,
-0.019991260021924973,
-0.4682680368423462,
-0.11492114514112473,
-0.15468861162662506,
0.5265346169471741,
0.3139561414718628,
-0.18468709290027618,
0.4658300578594208,
0.5340642333030701,
-0.3888983428478241,
-0.5258358716964722,
-0.6701416373252869,
0.040539491921663284,
-0.058794617652893066,
-0.6738725900650024,
0.0911841168999672,
0.18657690286636353,
-0.34346461296081543,
0.15236108005046844,
0.1988150030374527,
-0.014679771848022938,
0.3838801383972168,
0.24385584890842438,
0.4001378118991852,
-0.23003606498241425,
-0.007325822953134775,
-0.34492185711860657,
-0.1734807789325714,
0.11423354595899582,
0.06480222195386887,
0.5756177306175232,
-0.0071816835552453995,
-0.2944135069847107,
-0.5013753175735474,
0.5850064754486084,
0.7814343571662903,
0.024095075204968452,
0.6519308686256409,
0.33938249945640564,
-0.3004749119281769,
-0.2924403250217438,
-0.8316591382026672,
0.06264142692089081,
-0.4103005826473236,
0.9122223854064941,
-0.2647801637649536,
-1.161256194114685,
0.3927525281906128,
0.4511830806732178,
-0.18356777727603912,
0.5116563439369202,
0.9002195000648499,
0.05385172367095947,
1.3191298246383667,
0.8962026834487915,
-0.47548729181289673,
0.3568442463874817,
-0.056727029383182526,
0.4043577015399933,
-0.8931509256362915,
0.1351703256368637,
-0.6842734813690186,
-0.48444241285324097,
-0.25716859102249146,
-0.6022495031356812,
0.46463742852211,
-0.26397451758384705,
-0.15828552842140198,
-0.22008377313613892,
-0.6571474671363831,
0.5725041031837463,
0.22112822532653809,
-0.2699146866798401,
-0.2890586853027344,
0.18953774869441986,
0.23399050533771515,
-0.14307957887649536,
-1.052550196647644,
-0.27651599049568176,
0.6830321550369263,
0.5865966081619263,
0.880767822265625,
-0.14749306440353394,
0.08003061264753342,
0.22316645085811615,
0.15385736525058746,
-0.8070173859596252,
0.4034966230392456,
0.2512879967689514,
-0.37437936663627625,
-0.44558998942375183,
-0.436252623796463,
-1.010818600654602,
0.3926711976528168,
0.016248146072030067,
-0.8787928223609924,
0.18686677515506744,
0.13512270152568817,
-0.6045824289321899,
-0.05968364700675011,
-0.6657548546791077,
0.9456117749214172,
0.06270227581262589,
-1.014356255531311,
-0.43476763367652893,
-0.5280458331108093,
0.44415393471717834,
0.15394294261932373,
0.2842278778553009,
-0.11146026104688644,
-0.12589915096759796,
0.4299761652946472,
-0.0720674991607666,
1.0453435182571411,
-0.10332504659891129,
0.07176362723112106,
0.12159565836191177,
0.07402317970991135,
0.5705884695053101,
0.15084634721279144,
0.18822576105594635,
0.30107343196868896,
-0.39511486887931824,
-0.32379618287086487,
-0.52508544921875,
0.838039755821228,
-0.940108597278595,
-0.518511950969696,
-0.3548881709575653,
-0.9249403476715088,
-0.36271610856056213,
-0.16364070773124695,
0.028435325250029564,
0.3649764060974121,
-0.2198742777109146,
-0.03415326401591301,
1.2487149238586426,
-0.1408538669347763,
0.1344527304172516,
0.2456212043762207,
0.3429771363735199,
-0.39499661326408386,
0.9524965882301331,
0.4596557021141052,
0.23219330608844757,
0.33696648478507996,
-0.29485055804252625,
-0.03526270017027855,
-0.48980003595352173,
-0.4621059000492096,
0.5335260629653931,
-0.49509677290916443,
-0.06329832226037979,
-0.7789305448532104,
-0.36208081245422363,
-0.4258711636066437,
-0.2809423804283142,
-0.19831416010856628,
-0.2857872247695923,
-0.6203501224517822,
0.114987313747406,
0.13082516193389893,
0.8357923626899719,
0.10610880702733994,
0.21278832852840424,
-0.5489622354507446,
0.33430376648902893,
0.12161415070295334,
0.5800443291664124,
0.6105064749717712,
-0.892744243144989,
-0.6522484421730042,
-0.19397059082984924,
-0.1692737638950348,
-0.3792354166507721,
0.4946734607219696,
0.19946090877056122,
0.9162216782569885,
0.38632267713546753,
-0.37573179602622986,
0.6614601016044617,
-0.5243772864341736,
0.4802733063697815,
-0.061197053641080856,
-0.7788017392158508,
0.11672123521566391,
-0.2357323318719864,
0.3779224157333374,
0.3906435966491699,
0.25310012698173523,
-0.48694655299186707,
-0.6993024349212646,
-0.6128427982330322,
-0.8282515406608582,
1.0497138500213623,
0.10358404368162155,
0.25994592905044556,
0.061395250260829926,
0.39783304929733276,
0.010351498611271381,
0.049633972346782684,
-0.48967865109443665,
-0.19840751588344574,
0.31214550137519836,
-0.2932600677013397,
-0.2268126904964447,
-0.7544775009155273,
-0.0839768797159195,
-0.06183693930506706,
0.5638238787651062,
0.1508045792579651,
0.5161240696907043,
0.07325171679258347,
-0.250057190656662,
-0.25844940543174744,
0.23615984618663788,
0.9054173231124878,
0.23129191994667053,
0.08052629977464676,
0.1509333848953247,
0.12536072731018066,
-0.5957823395729065,
0.0993463471531868,
0.11561476439237595,
-0.2513796389102936,
-0.13218997418880463,
0.26941752433776855,
0.9528387784957886,
0.5599251389503479,
-0.5050973296165466,
0.49839577078819275,
-0.0421045683324337,
-0.23525094985961914,
0.08955257385969162,
0.09348908811807632,
0.03394922614097595,
0.19603514671325684,
0.37819209694862366,
0.1751786172389984,
0.26287075877189636,
-0.03928883746266365,
-0.08350154012441635,
0.6777001023292542,
-0.44088757038116455,
-0.40680763125419617,
0.6271337866783142,
0.12241081893444061,
-0.14206601679325104,
0.26250752806663513,
0.18994061648845673,
-0.38671112060546875,
0.5876436233520508,
0.36064037680625916,
0.9047348499298096,
-0.13415713608264923,
-0.1649164855480194,
0.2181592434644699,
0.480336993932724,
0.01882212981581688,
-0.30223730206489563,
-0.4406171143054962,
-0.37619471549987793,
-0.569857656955719,
-0.709433913230896,
-0.27832406759262085,
0.26312196254730225,
-0.47533953189849854,
0.006289951503276825,
-0.507305383682251,
-0.17821678519248962,
0.1080714613199234,
-0.16640985012054443,
-0.5307510495185852,
0.06149042397737503,
0.36730000376701355,
0.3665303885936737,
-0.653548002243042,
0.3188358247280121,
0.3301103115081787,
-0.15489636361598969,
-0.7449821829795837,
-0.024472614750266075,
-0.26643702387809753,
-1.0520343780517578,
0.4736868739128113,
0.28168851137161255,
-0.4354785978794098,
0.05152641981840134,
-0.574226438999176,
-1.4608304500579834,
0.36291807889938354,
0.5366103649139404,
-0.5716994404792786,
0.10207130759954453,
0.43999868631362915,
0.6216921806335449,
-0.13602927327156067,
0.17253270745277405,
0.7097721695899963,
0.12169888615608215,
-0.005033893510699272,
-0.5597850680351257,
-0.015667028725147247,
-0.4698057174682617,
0.34325554966926575,
0.3423722982406616,
-0.7144296765327454,
0.7337431907653809,
-0.2338913232088089,
-0.43061563372612,
-0.008587135002017021,
0.5747190713882446,
0.05416790395975113,
0.06871598213911057,
-0.031622663140296936,
0.6319087743759155,
0.2814037799835205,
-0.18786627054214478,
1.114886999130249,
-0.5246572494506836,
0.4936000108718872,
0.4525778889656067,
-0.45929083228111267,
0.41505375504493713,
0.6341419219970703,
-0.6466678380966187,
-0.08022193610668182,
0.3496578335762024,
-0.15514960885047913,
0.5562382340431213,
0.4878939986228943,
-0.09599650651216507,
-0.08867520838975906,
-0.0439150370657444,
-0.21200114488601685,
-0.08895370364189148,
0.5694260001182556,
-0.34908196330070496,
-0.06177578121423721,
0.15007279813289642,
-0.12485348433256149,
0.022023752331733704,
-0.45788389444351196,
0.8627039194107056,
-0.08844120055437088,
-0.7609289288520813,
0.9578432440757751,
0.004817009903490543,
0.5140438079833984,
-0.43332797288894653,
0.031816232949495316,
-0.23233503103256226,
0.4742785096168518,
-0.08957073837518692,
-0.4207705855369568,
0.34288692474365234,
0.17933285236358643,
-0.6785538792610168,
0.026000645011663437,
0.698574423789978,
-0.38012537360191345,
-0.5876049995422363,
0.07564055919647217,
0.2199622094631195,
0.1538141518831253,
-0.08635780215263367,
-0.6224378943443298,
0.5254077911376953,
-0.17892229557037354,
-0.5093079209327698,
0.8101006746292114,
0.6786065697669983,
0.13897119462490082,
0.5680314898490906,
0.3675822913646698,
0.1865503489971161,
0.15121260285377502,
0.017587250098586082,
0.9455652832984924,
-0.3034141957759857,
-0.48747092485427856,
-0.9237927198410034,
0.23799999058246613,
0.05690945312380791,
-0.23830059170722961,
0.6584692001342773,
0.27917495369911194,
0.5317639708518982,
-0.11839231848716736,
0.9506452679634094,
0.14523446559906006,
0.661823570728302,
-0.11898312717676163,
0.6877608895301819,
-0.41135329008102417,
0.2599123418331146,
-0.3626970946788788,
-0.7247331142425537,
-0.5424232482910156,
0.7090132832527161,
-0.3705161511898041,
0.1550198495388031,
0.46612346172332764,
0.9257035851478577,
-0.01456774864345789,
-0.1654331386089325,
0.5517972707748413,
0.045507654547691345,
-0.18920840322971344,
0.8138880133628845,
0.9019089341163635,
-0.1694948524236679,
0.47535911202430725,
-0.16054482758045197,
-0.32568663358688354,
-0.5479035377502441,
-0.28322795033454895,
-0.8032891154289246,
-0.3436780273914337,
-0.1986171454191208,
-0.1609322428703308,
0.2396257519721985,
0.6135274171829224,
0.4892922639846802,
-0.7274232506752014,
-0.2474067658185959,
-0.2172422707080841,
0.02054249681532383,
-0.3233688771724701,
-0.29927781224250793,
0.3976191282272339,
-0.7422760725021362,
-0.6472810506820679,
0.11825836449861526,
0.6254945397377014,
-0.05301378667354584,
-0.4208958148956299,
0.04237046092748642,
-0.046559832990169525,
0.3346787095069885,
0.5025428533554077,
0.26248493790626526,
-0.7922351956367493,
-0.008667640388011932,
0.22513844072818756,
-0.6264582872390747,
0.04319686442613602,
0.868158757686615,
-0.493254154920578,
-0.04408011585474014,
0.3240387737751007,
1.0142967700958252,
0.3037627339363098,
-0.06207839772105217,
0.5005340576171875,
-0.6972368359565735,
0.27373120188713074,
0.3107924163341522,
0.23843812942504883,
0.21265462040901184,
-0.7020856142044067,
0.48000460863113403,
0.4531313180923462,
-0.8640982508659363,
-1.0984035730361938,
-0.2052871286869049,
-1.0956966876983643,
-0.07323287427425385,
1.311348795890808,
-0.11134463548660278,
-0.5822985172271729,
-0.23072229325771332,
-0.16181150078773499,
-0.09298992902040482,
-0.42973607778549194,
0.8869156241416931,
0.8238657712936401,
-0.16452307999134064,
-0.31252703070640564,
-0.6515405178070068,
0.40225929021835327,
0.8027549386024475,
-0.3988650143146515,
0.6559357047080994,
0.7012866735458374,
-0.018291691318154335,
0.07389476895332336,
0.5679529905319214,
0.07361496239900589,
0.6092233657836914,
0.1557232290506363,
0.08575648814439774,
0.12968146800994873,
-0.3024488687515259,
-0.7742106318473816,
0.6513015627861023,
0.07179605960845947,
0.11874661594629288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02684v1
|
Cross-Architecture Transfer Learning for Linear-Cost Inference Transformers
| 2024-04-03T12:27:36 | 2024-04-03T12:27:36 |
Sehyun Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recently, multiple architectures has been proposed to improve the efficiency
of the Transformer Language Models through changing the design of the
self-attention block to have a linear-cost inference (LCI). A notable approach
in this realm is the State-Space Machines (SSMs) architecture, which showed
on-par performance on language modeling tasks with the self-attention
transformers. However, such an architectural change requires a full pretraining
of the weights from scratch, which incurs a huge cost to researchers and
practitioners who want to use the new architectures. In the more traditional
linear attention works, it has been proposed to approximate full attention with
linear attention by swap-and-finetune framework. Motivated by this approach, we
propose Cross-Architecture Transfer Learning (XATL), in which the weights of
the shared components between LCI and self-attention-based transformers, such
as layernorms, MLPs, input/output embeddings, are directly transferred to the
new architecture from already pre-trained model parameters. We experimented the
efficacy of the method on varying sizes and alternative attention architectures
and show that \methodabbr significantly reduces the training time up to 2.5x
times and converges to a better minimum with up to 2.6% stronger model on the
LM benchmarks within the same compute budget.
|
[
-0.42058122158050537,
-0.26658758521080017,
0.4896649420261383,
0.21088314056396484,
0.04148794338107109,
-0.06444324553012848,
-0.10818322747945786,
-0.6418936252593994,
0.1686994582414627,
0.346937358379364,
-0.6976544260978699,
0.022740203887224197,
-0.45574310421943665,
-0.47070935368537903,
-0.48112744092941284,
0.5863416194915771,
-0.19914337992668152,
0.030018405988812447,
-0.11043161153793335,
-0.25548607110977173,
-0.29571473598480225,
-0.33849263191223145,
-0.6394403576850891,
-0.2801806628704071,
0.5581988096237183,
0.2296200692653656,
0.6047601103782654,
0.5394203066825867,
0.2807258367538452,
0.26513198018074036,
0.23949293792247772,
-0.11370410770177841,
-0.5386132597923279,
-0.4312414228916168,
-0.5321773886680603,
-0.6678212881088257,
-0.3269438147544861,
0.1285504698753357,
0.5109959244728088,
0.6742532253265381,
0.03838535398244858,
0.5677028894424438,
0.16590212285518646,
0.7995325922966003,
-0.8239911794662476,
0.2016453593969345,
-0.5922502875328064,
0.40168142318725586,
0.11792410910129547,
-0.09344038367271423,
-0.752020537853241,
-0.06627984344959259,
0.3295002579689026,
-0.5388221740722656,
0.1750665009021759,
0.13113458454608917,
0.9057833552360535,
0.6529935598373413,
-0.24260620772838593,
-0.0802767351269722,
-0.8709288835525513,
1.116373062133789,
-0.42257216572761536,
0.7153262495994568,
0.04146086052060127,
0.33980533480644226,
0.4095565974712372,
-0.926796019077301,
-0.20390698313713074,
-0.23469620943069458,
-0.26044395565986633,
0.2740802764892578,
-0.5669445991516113,
-0.13014325499534607,
0.01874709501862526,
0.28384649753570557,
-0.4067695736885071,
0.10350186377763748,
-0.40995052456855774,
-0.09030497074127197,
0.45873862504959106,
-0.0169211458414793,
0.004195997957140207,
0.09164176136255264,
-0.9112756848335266,
-0.3013918101787567,
-0.5853272080421448,
-0.04392090067267418,
-0.045656491070985794,
0.20174479484558105,
-0.14201469719409943,
0.0010754828108474612,
0.1853766292333603,
0.25160273909568787,
0.45865651965141296,
0.4033512771129608,
0.3433745205402374,
-0.5347475409507751,
-0.4697425663471222,
0.19357259571552277,
0.5310916900634766,
-0.0545831061899662,
0.20871123671531677,
-0.3542601764202118,
-0.05829008296132088,
0.07595442235469818,
0.6071458458900452,
-0.6637548804283142,
-0.2143649458885193,
0.14661630988121033,
-0.7623803615570068,
-0.026636607944965363,
-0.2192215770483017,
-0.726466178894043,
0.2429332584142685,
-0.5244385004043579,
0.773723304271698,
-0.3170183002948761,
-0.07267165184020996,
0.24013003706932068,
0.3655780851840973,
0.5662637948989868,
0.23985962569713593,
-0.6254074573516846,
0.4315597414970398,
0.30917423963546753,
0.7352022528648376,
-0.456692099571228,
-0.21160708367824554,
-0.6035616993904114,
0.11470026522874832,
-0.2181933969259262,
0.8193865418434143,
-0.24523626267910004,
-0.21299013495445251,
-0.23947595059871674,
-0.17288535833358765,
-0.3962059020996094,
-0.3830562233924866,
0.6288153529167175,
-0.47292476892471313,
0.2812400460243225,
0.010052008554339409,
-0.5566344857215881,
0.09955953061580658,
-0.1166103184223175,
-0.7767126560211182,
1.0656236410140991,
0.2084452360868454,
-0.5224796533584595,
0.07395251840353012,
-0.5550228953361511,
-0.5867336392402649,
-0.23929913341999054,
-0.11580240726470947,
-0.6481605768203735,
0.15352016687393188,
0.26117590069770813,
0.5043081641197205,
-0.35951855778694153,
-0.0334734208881855,
-0.44501611590385437,
-0.14359843730926514,
0.06193951889872551,
-0.3456428050994873,
0.6337893009185791,
0.4996589124202728,
-0.6938892006874084,
0.21534030139446259,
-0.8813319206237793,
0.09264855086803436,
-0.03157402202486992,
-0.08694402128458023,
-0.28115496039390564,
-0.24240219593048096,
0.12082641571760178,
0.5205854773521423,
0.21660496294498444,
-0.4460742175579071,
-0.059270117431879044,
-0.3243332803249359,
0.21919536590576172,
0.7592811584472656,
-0.5459580421447754,
0.9256839156150818,
-0.28625690937042236,
0.6223493218421936,
0.031308773905038834,
0.21177463233470917,
0.05462586134672165,
-0.03502846136689186,
-0.9590672850608826,
-0.227092444896698,
0.38709813356399536,
0.398356556892395,
-0.6396264433860779,
0.3791772723197937,
-0.3134508430957794,
-0.5033549666404724,
-0.8105148673057556,
-0.03995464742183685,
0.66717129945755,
0.5344209671020508,
0.6577931642532349,
-0.03571626916527748,
-0.5890691876411438,
-0.9759576916694641,
-0.1643504500389099,
0.0702698677778244,
0.006098725367337465,
0.5262680053710938,
0.21247123181819916,
0.00831141509115696,
0.7045868635177612,
-0.44694891571998596,
-0.5797885656356812,
-0.35754913091659546,
0.07074712961912155,
-0.04179832711815834,
0.5065091848373413,
0.7965206503868103,
-0.43022051453590393,
-0.7113924026489258,
0.06817859411239624,
-0.25441181659698486,
-0.20440733432769775,
-0.502662718296051,
-0.2635144293308258,
0.327597439289093,
0.6486372351646423,
-0.7042049765586853,
0.518742024898529,
0.8717382550239563,
-0.20946036279201508,
0.44526100158691406,
-0.22446390986442566,
-0.19203001260757446,
-1.2384132146835327,
0.12614202499389648,
0.12665830552577972,
-0.3279258906841278,
-0.533270537853241,
-0.05841454491019249,
0.20861098170280457,
0.00105260219424963,
-0.6378962993621826,
0.9114887714385986,
-0.7199053764343262,
-0.42948275804519653,
-0.12338395416736603,
0.00819731131196022,
0.03091544099152088,
0.9703463315963745,
0.03235957771539688,
0.8324524760246277,
0.5690156817436218,
-0.4763161242008209,
-0.12263412773609161,
0.08686748892068863,
-0.25178971886634827,
0.42924585938453674,
-0.5685510039329529,
0.11177465319633484,
0.07849416881799698,
0.32670289278030396,
-1.1634507179260254,
0.5989888310432434,
0.31607672572135925,
-0.1915992796421051,
0.346829891204834,
-0.08738505840301514,
0.03808891773223877,
-0.13685566186904907,
-0.2495698481798172,
0.6080431342124939,
0.5622547268867493,
-0.8420301079750061,
1.2081369161605835,
0.13871312141418457,
0.17807897925376892,
-0.5430011749267578,
-0.9233524203300476,
-0.20935310423374176,
0.027207957580685616,
-0.4421692490577698,
0.6200543642044067,
0.04402340203523636,
0.14940224587917328,
0.407505601644516,
-0.41089221835136414,
-0.03892405703663826,
-0.08438760042190552,
0.09909314662218094,
0.2786238491535187,
-0.6888325810432434,
0.0607939176261425,
-0.06713647395372391,
-0.3549431562423706,
0.1399601548910141,
-0.7069326639175415,
0.6032121777534485,
-0.14388401806354523,
-0.5022637844085693,
-0.7188100218772888,
0.16119788587093353,
0.4637811779975891,
-0.5256295800209045,
0.5468711853027344,
0.6942811012268066,
-0.05591781809926033,
-0.4486009180545807,
-0.5295949578285217,
0.007896768860518932,
-0.4301469326019287,
0.5863222479820251,
-0.48288199305534363,
-0.639055609703064,
0.4305969774723053,
-0.039108917117118835,
0.08910375833511353,
0.4346979260444641,
0.564643383026123,
0.08649555593729019,
0.835728645324707,
0.4213375151157379,
-0.5284425020217896,
0.7779188752174377,
-0.3576768934726715,
0.08789152652025223,
-0.6441720724105835,
0.027925867587327957,
-0.5742910504341125,
-0.8676517605781555,
-0.23592214286327362,
-0.8023625612258911,
-0.047275248914957047,
-0.4375567138195038,
-0.1533123403787613,
0.5130541920661926,
-0.22294573485851288,
0.394419401884079,
0.5971682071685791,
0.2038281261920929,
0.12538650631904602,
0.20063985884189606,
0.17079247534275055,
0.16137659549713135,
-0.8887515068054199,
0.04488827660679817,
1.0588825941085815,
0.32654279470443726,
1.0446274280548096,
-0.0194527730345726,
0.5710574984550476,
0.389631986618042,
0.3235243558883667,
-0.6959642171859741,
0.4507060647010803,
-0.3862224817276001,
-0.24124084413051605,
-0.25143957138061523,
-0.776176393032074,
-1.053536295890808,
0.25296318531036377,
0.009429085068404675,
-0.6012656688690186,
0.5563250780105591,
0.3327559232711792,
-0.41524189710617065,
0.5606606006622314,
-0.7999154925346375,
0.6687230467796326,
-0.5132413506507874,
-0.33496809005737305,
-0.6772885918617249,
-0.6742009520530701,
0.21811699867248535,
-0.0268624909222126,
-0.08110249787569046,
0.07828685641288757,
-0.01813087798655033,
0.44907188415527344,
-0.06496261060237885,
0.8851133584976196,
-0.09024820476770401,
-0.1874833106994629,
0.014375421218574047,
0.18037782609462738,
0.449179470539093,
-0.2430243045091629,
-0.0014668244402855635,
0.3796330690383911,
-0.152807354927063,
-0.5728375911712646,
-0.6666551828384399,
0.6070767641067505,
-1.0500991344451904,
-0.4610976576805115,
-0.055369697511196136,
-0.8215639591217041,
-0.2141367495059967,
0.14378422498703003,
-0.04097842797636986,
0.5562744140625,
-0.1274855136871338,
0.13761413097381592,
0.9743412137031555,
-0.09793626517057419,
0.3344646990299225,
0.23778997361660004,
-0.11854914575815201,
-0.17429615557193756,
0.7975293397903442,
-0.06456081569194794,
0.5698261260986328,
0.832786500453949,
0.21510110795497894,
-0.30739933252334595,
-0.2874557375907898,
-0.3309529423713684,
0.16721196472644806,
-0.5694140195846558,
-0.2135297805070877,
-0.7102000713348389,
-0.5150187611579895,
-0.2838270664215088,
-0.16725103557109833,
-0.9241603016853333,
-0.5898457765579224,
-0.34312519431114197,
0.05006249248981476,
-0.06364934146404266,
0.21765537559986115,
-0.06690961867570877,
0.3074136972427368,
-0.83262038230896,
0.4092050790786743,
0.19912785291671753,
0.3674568831920624,
0.38624000549316406,
-0.9034619927406311,
-0.4383467435836792,
-0.10950625687837601,
-0.04737190529704094,
-0.2920950949192047,
0.2496337890625,
0.3996375799179077,
0.8113574981689453,
0.5265438556671143,
0.11523880064487457,
0.7780082821846008,
-0.48956117033958435,
0.2646460235118866,
0.19081886112689972,
-1.0498619079589844,
0.1463901698589325,
0.4736115336418152,
0.3881756067276001,
0.41197142004966736,
0.3946693241596222,
-0.17799222469329834,
-0.07665298134088516,
-0.5924676060676575,
-0.6126241683959961,
1.016132116317749,
0.23093289136886597,
0.09967141598463058,
0.4373170733451843,
0.3063802123069763,
0.004437739960849285,
-0.35789355635643005,
-0.6131041049957275,
-0.5287504196166992,
-0.1459774672985077,
-0.41716188192367554,
0.032353680580854416,
-0.020646492019295692,
0.1744520217180252,
-0.22347840666770935,
0.7939903736114502,
-0.12450923770666122,
0.3967709541320801,
0.3410821557044983,
-0.45095372200012207,
-0.00870735663920641,
0.20497125387191772,
0.5036333203315735,
0.4705670177936554,
-0.02743109129369259,
0.2691737711429596,
0.2914099097251892,
-0.0932793915271759,
0.19848299026489258,
0.25202882289886475,
0.0070357671938836575,
-0.18050020933151245,
0.19457174837589264,
1.19563889503479,
0.6634914875030518,
-0.42718034982681274,
0.42314139008522034,
-0.2894747257232666,
-0.5213316679000854,
-0.07553892582654953,
-0.02360331267118454,
0.11259280145168304,
0.5646081566810608,
0.18053768575191498,
0.3298415243625641,
0.06024015322327614,
-0.22965744137763977,
0.47255855798721313,
0.45489922165870667,
-0.622462809085846,
-0.47066599130630493,
0.719142735004425,
0.24801675975322723,
-0.17245948314666748,
0.3244308829307556,
0.22898352146148682,
-0.3789253830909729,
0.5264868140220642,
0.5418520569801331,
1.120841383934021,
-0.37795233726501465,
0.1920747309923172,
0.10225096344947815,
0.2265661060810089,
0.09572384506464005,
0.0040117776952683926,
-0.3807438313961029,
-0.7811877727508545,
-0.6720319390296936,
-0.5324113965034485,
-0.17863015830516815,
0.031014559790492058,
-0.8084210157394409,
0.20663408935070038,
-0.4612131118774414,
0.14524057507514954,
-0.091569684445858,
-0.11637867987155914,
-0.7863743305206299,
0.06602002680301666,
0.6253064274787903,
1.0579332113265991,
-0.8178113102912903,
1.0322026014328003,
0.5100218057632446,
-0.2725439667701721,
-0.8346428871154785,
-0.07450230419635773,
-0.41121843457221985,
-1.0481187105178833,
0.7601150870323181,
0.02599131502211094,
-0.4659930169582367,
0.23539088666439056,
-0.08294352144002914,
-1.288081407546997,
0.9748373031616211,
0.5621286034584045,
-0.7792366743087769,
-0.3231939971446991,
0.3783680200576782,
0.4295300245285034,
-0.41954484581947327,
0.2116856873035431,
0.45665404200553894,
0.21254552900791168,
0.15728625655174255,
-0.7987464666366577,
0.08246389031410217,
-0.02212372049689293,
-0.015342987142503262,
0.32979556918144226,
-0.764946460723877,
0.8701603412628174,
-0.11383642256259918,
-0.3362277150154114,
0.10314066708087921,
1.091633915901184,
-0.042790770530700684,
0.1364704817533493,
0.8370338678359985,
0.7533908486366272,
0.37124794721603394,
0.346114844083786,
0.9833895564079285,
-0.680798351764679,
0.6644226312637329,
1.338517189025879,
-0.5118707418441772,
0.8161316514015198,
0.6437370181083679,
-0.27782702445983887,
0.4636395275592804,
0.291984498500824,
-0.07904955744743347,
0.5557830333709717,
-0.03009353019297123,
0.18239828944206238,
-0.359904944896698,
0.16416306793689728,
-0.27164000272750854,
0.249074786901474,
0.12141423672437668,
-0.47388139367103577,
-0.43582233786582947,
0.05156312137842178,
-0.1530974805355072,
-0.2613486349582672,
-0.3887322247028351,
0.6628879904747009,
0.19678150117397308,
-0.5365414619445801,
0.4525825083255768,
-0.45039233565330505,
0.5020518898963928,
-0.7160884141921997,
0.08439567685127258,
-0.3160538971424103,
0.7274044752120972,
-0.02707832306623459,
-0.5588349103927612,
0.39535292983055115,
-0.5311158299446106,
-0.27980533242225647,
-0.5419352054595947,
0.7825861573219299,
-0.5716671347618103,
-0.6324287056922913,
0.6672301888465881,
0.4836706817150116,
-0.11246941238641739,
-0.07111190259456635,
-0.9145225882530212,
-0.17659248411655426,
0.15178056061267853,
-0.3537391126155853,
0.5306232571601868,
0.16630198061466217,
-0.09821414202451706,
0.8069074749946594,
0.5892369747161865,
0.09058767557144165,
0.4016381502151489,
0.16235488653182983,
0.8090031147003174,
-0.4707516133785248,
-0.6309677958488464,
-0.6876527070999146,
0.36146530508995056,
0.1074027270078659,
-0.051809489727020264,
0.49436917901039124,
0.5365858674049377,
1.0887213945388794,
-0.20549285411834717,
0.5690534114837646,
0.08835144340991974,
0.2546916902065277,
-0.6132372617721558,
0.6812087893486023,
-0.8388090133666992,
0.14314152300357819,
-0.14748907089233398,
-0.970337450504303,
-0.07761405408382416,
0.40383782982826233,
-0.2316170334815979,
-0.015171091072261333,
0.771124005317688,
0.719357967376709,
-0.5555070042610168,
-0.2238120436668396,
0.4898797869682312,
0.21047021448612213,
0.13423608243465424,
0.833926796913147,
0.6511073708534241,
-0.5252286195755005,
0.9215297102928162,
-0.44317519664764404,
-0.0675385594367981,
-0.15089917182922363,
-0.6378909945487976,
-0.8294277191162109,
-0.3824905753135681,
-0.4377112090587616,
-0.21728909015655518,
-0.025018926709890366,
0.882979154586792,
0.9479658007621765,
-0.912581205368042,
-0.34906667470932007,
0.09287738800048828,
-0.1236511841416359,
-0.4735734760761261,
-0.1931406706571579,
0.7794419527053833,
-0.5969013571739197,
-0.7420527935028076,
0.1380128413438797,
0.3123401701450348,
-0.25965359807014465,
-0.47827979922294617,
-0.03131914138793945,
-0.33538195490837097,
0.2736128866672516,
0.6200806498527527,
0.250900536775589,
-0.7285893559455872,
-0.34931161999702454,
0.04547244682908058,
-0.20584848523139954,
0.4614967405796051,
0.9328537583351135,
-0.9424473643302917,
-0.0286120492964983,
0.40534454584121704,
1.3662385940551758,
0.7712059020996094,
-0.06244100630283356,
0.4595378041267395,
-0.765789270401001,
0.1525084227323532,
-0.10948201268911362,
0.5884161591529846,
-0.0419074222445488,
-0.3895738422870636,
0.4016958475112915,
0.11161673814058304,
-0.5112731456756592,
-0.4085198938846588,
0.1467990130186081,
-1.0485703945159912,
-0.3417833149433136,
0.864264726638794,
-0.17928652465343475,
-0.6907632350921631,
0.07225583493709564,
-0.20606419444084167,
0.27655187249183655,
-0.2382209151983261,
0.839927613735199,
0.12554101645946503,
-0.15385878086090088,
-0.47320348024368286,
-0.0677945613861084,
0.2338402420282364,
0.9879834651947021,
-0.9441898465156555,
0.1691218763589859,
0.1173357293009758,
0.21079134941101074,
0.37479788064956665,
0.16263726353645325,
0.08300851285457611,
0.2502346634864807,
-0.20906326174736023,
0.46803730726242065,
0.147992342710495,
-0.28680238127708435,
-0.2850363254547119,
0.026675883680582047,
-0.4327157139778137,
-0.4265950620174408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02681v1
|
PejorativITy: Disambiguating Pejorative Epithets to Improve Misogyny Detection in Italian Tweets
| 2024-04-03T12:24:48 | 2024-04-03T12:24:48 |
Arianna Muti, Federico Ruggeri, Cagri Toraman, Lorenzo Musetti, Samuel Algherini, Silvia Ronchi, Gianmarco Saretto, Caterina Zapparoli, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Misogyny is often expressed through figurative language. Some neutral words
can assume a negative connotation when functioning as pejorative epithets.
Disambiguating the meaning of such terms might help the detection of misogyny.
In order to address such task, we present PejorativITy, a novel corpus of 1,200
manually annotated Italian tweets for pejorative language at the word level and
misogyny at the sentence level. We evaluate the impact of injecting information
about disambiguated words into a model targeting misogyny detection. In
particular, we explore two different approaches for injection: concatenation of
pejorative information and substitution of ambiguous words with univocal terms.
Our experimental results, both on our corpus and on two popular benchmarks on
Italian tweets, show that both approaches lead to a major classification
improvement, indicating that word sense disambiguation is a promising
preliminary step for misogyny detection. Furthermore, we investigate LLMs'
understanding of pejorative epithets by means of contextual word embeddings
analysis and prompting.
|
[
-0.026164378970861435,
-1.1118940114974976,
0.45846372842788696,
0.22782999277114868,
-0.5950140953063965,
0.1818470060825348,
-0.06980761140584946,
-0.3391326367855072,
0.170762836933136,
0.13798260688781738,
-0.10863009095191956,
-0.4554722011089325,
-0.7910195589065552,
0.24855756759643555,
-0.7923176288604736,
0.9827522039413452,
0.07449512183666229,
0.3266509771347046,
-0.1763879656791687,
0.007311877328902483,
-0.40948161482810974,
-0.3971653878688812,
-0.26347091794013977,
-0.18249353766441345,
0.5385226607322693,
0.06186677888035774,
0.6099891662597656,
0.26147204637527466,
0.29444581270217896,
0.3705504834651947,
-0.2596445083618164,
0.3361978828907013,
-0.49156948924064636,
0.2692742645740509,
-0.5299131870269775,
-0.47247737646102905,
-0.09730110317468643,
0.24869513511657715,
0.35959550738334656,
0.8291099071502686,
-0.10279804468154907,
-0.045887723565101624,
0.07048317044973373,
0.44776374101638794,
-0.7539393901824951,
-0.003513393457978964,
-0.863161563873291,
-0.004898098297417164,
-0.6108010411262512,
-0.2075137495994568,
-0.10855945944786072,
-0.22300098836421967,
-0.12994246184825897,
-0.41523200273513794,
0.05644789710640907,
-0.055886875838041306,
0.5454447865486145,
0.2341836541891098,
-0.3808959424495697,
-0.2997359037399292,
-0.6703619956970215,
0.8657320737838745,
-0.5897823572158813,
0.22381852567195892,
0.3114526867866516,
0.013059332966804504,
-0.222100168466568,
-0.2455153465270996,
-0.37841907143592834,
-0.41767576336860657,
-0.24725846946239471,
-0.16561110317707062,
-0.4351632297039032,
-0.2127629518508911,
0.17927606403827667,
0.20223204791545868,
-0.2287156879901886,
-0.021361328661441803,
-0.18721315264701843,
-0.14623719453811646,
0.6281301379203796,
-0.2667880952358246,
0.3632657825946808,
0.0011672794353216887,
-0.3489179313182831,
0.5261344313621521,
-0.6732468008995056,
-0.4377753436565399,
0.7527891397476196,
0.3170487880706787,
0.2202332466840744,
0.504568338394165,
0.056629765778779984,
0.39328551292419434,
0.2772190570831299,
-0.25194990634918213,
0.3325759768486023,
-0.21278488636016846,
-0.19071616232395172,
0.35098353028297424,
0.6905262470245361,
0.25710171461105347,
0.21220093965530396,
-0.38877594470977783,
0.004236514680087566,
0.34916359186172485,
0.4262050688266754,
-0.5603721737861633,
-0.12480471283197403,
0.01801450364291668,
-0.23306137323379517,
-0.7464998960494995,
0.022601740434765816,
-0.6273733973503113,
-0.6035171151161194,
0.00006848261546110734,
0.37345898151397705,
-0.36857688426971436,
-0.3197994530200958,
-0.16834306716918945,
-0.5781481862068176,
-0.15056541562080383,
0.5773123502731323,
-0.6417836546897888,
-0.02734428644180298,
0.44695091247558594,
0.37543243169784546,
0.05105731263756752,
0.1205533817410469,
-0.36822161078453064,
0.2983192503452301,
-0.3979150056838989,
0.7263132333755493,
-0.8496613502502441,
-0.3561631143093109,
0.06978252530097961,
-0.15531185269355774,
-0.14716310799121857,
-0.6383333206176758,
0.5701244473457336,
0.040167905390262604,
0.43294212222099304,
0.08666206896305084,
-0.5451092720031738,
-0.18035121262073517,
0.38010674715042114,
-0.2264147698879242,
1.1544803380966187,
0.035367872565984726,
-0.8047420978546143,
0.296099990606308,
-0.5080657005310059,
-0.4623875319957733,
0.15305127203464508,
-0.2010495811700821,
-0.34997326135635376,
0.361160010099411,
0.01160610094666481,
0.4509175717830658,
-0.05093877762556076,
0.6657971739768982,
-0.45247212052345276,
-0.46065059304237366,
0.3463308811187744,
-0.2264138162136078,
0.6501450538635254,
-0.03016422502696514,
-0.5691014528274536,
-0.2195039987564087,
-0.3602876663208008,
-0.39248740673065186,
-0.03455834090709686,
0.06029555946588516,
-1.0454219579696655,
0.05393565446138382,
-0.04721812531352043,
-0.26700612902641296,
0.23714007437229156,
-0.48880404233932495,
0.04790567234158516,
-0.3844622075557709,
0.41263967752456665,
0.5515676140785217,
-0.1081959679722786,
0.46434271335601807,
-0.03874412551522255,
0.3421610891819,
0.2775452733039856,
0.2483551800251007,
0.16932347416877747,
-0.46111997961997986,
-0.4969257712364197,
-0.05012671649456024,
0.21294131875038147,
0.4652372896671295,
-0.933258593082428,
0.3797086179256439,
0.11404551565647125,
-0.6147322654724121,
-0.09606538712978363,
0.2014489471912384,
0.6656078696250916,
0.4220835566520691,
0.3795357942581177,
-0.020235510542988777,
-0.4819626808166504,
-1.1342322826385498,
-0.9104958176612854,
-0.4587494432926178,
0.2332647293806076,
0.24583303928375244,
0.6636918187141418,
-0.08175883442163467,
0.5712875723838806,
-0.03123818337917328,
-0.28587397933006287,
-0.0941997841000557,
0.3275769352912903,
0.04734040051698685,
0.43168458342552185,
0.8040091395378113,
-1.1765820980072021,
-0.17105074226856232,
-0.026421574875712395,
-0.472451388835907,
-0.3332177698612213,
0.168172687292099,
-0.4202698767185211,
-0.12355795502662659,
0.4546481668949127,
-0.28713536262512207,
0.5938222408294678,
0.25464046001434326,
-0.4766032099723816,
0.526142954826355,
0.35610833764076233,
0.23586469888687134,
-1.0081355571746826,
-0.024095330387353897,
0.2765946686267853,
-0.2960859537124634,
-0.7114822268486023,
-0.12659099698066711,
-0.2585979104042053,
0.34678399562835693,
-0.7102048397064209,
0.5306077003479004,
-0.3482498526573181,
0.036760903894901276,
0.024456268176436424,
0.18110987544059753,
-0.16370265185832977,
0.07156138122081757,
-0.2420497089624405,
0.7776581645011902,
0.2583767771720886,
-0.5642467141151428,
0.4445367753505707,
0.19145327806472778,
0.094081811606884,
0.5875698924064636,
-0.3349079489707947,
0.08463842421770096,
-0.21154260635375977,
0.16616034507751465,
-1.1434499025344849,
-0.20303741097450256,
0.8549096584320068,
-0.4013742208480835,
0.20120345056056976,
-0.29566723108291626,
-0.691137969493866,
-0.28781020641326904,
-0.40048855543136597,
0.5020051598548889,
-0.0844983458518982,
-0.2574082016944885,
0.3439469635486603,
0.4700642228126526,
0.19105695188045502,
-0.5451087355613708,
-0.7864943146705627,
0.0516529306769371,
-0.525364875793457,
-0.13585485517978668,
0.8388791084289551,
0.03750667721033096,
-0.6126143336296082,
-0.17972849309444427,
-0.07030309736728668,
-0.2995105981826782,
0.20531225204467773,
0.03803641349077225,
0.28440722823143005,
0.3195688724517822,
0.6763831973075867,
0.4740215837955475,
0.35825327038764954,
-0.19709539413452148,
-0.13064691424369812,
0.4310974180698395,
0.11472417414188385,
-0.0006347860908135772,
-0.3335331082344055,
0.4560571312904358,
0.3054250180721283,
0.0823836475610733,
0.7872505187988281,
0.9078407287597656,
-0.5176174640655518,
0.01934547908604145,
-0.5079348087310791,
-0.14625082910060883,
-0.35603204369544983,
0.20224516093730927,
-0.22646036744117737,
-0.7910147905349731,
0.21228919923305511,
-0.26922279596328735,
-0.2802557051181793,
0.3364494740962982,
0.47202399373054504,
-0.2911103665828705,
0.955422580242157,
0.576532781124115,
-0.06575103849172592,
0.6599258184432983,
0.012837561778724194,
0.33652353286743164,
-0.6406286358833313,
-0.14856083691120148,
-0.74278724193573,
-0.4256832003593445,
-0.8760736584663391,
-0.43801265954971313,
0.23470619320869446,
0.32697612047195435,
-0.26583296060562134,
0.31644296646118164,
-0.624722957611084,
0.26952242851257324,
0.11660648882389069,
0.3031434416770935,
0.3960346579551697,
0.032403405755758286,
0.0745629295706749,
-0.2905149459838867,
-0.5387933850288391,
-0.7763097882270813,
0.7654069662094116,
0.10602660477161407,
0.6133224964141846,
0.3424646258354187,
0.7951693534851074,
0.440155565738678,
0.7551348805427551,
-0.7348559498786926,
0.4276411533355713,
-0.48705780506134033,
-0.9119779467582703,
0.09231594949960709,
-0.3821682035923004,
-0.734320878982544,
0.04727314040064812,
-0.1724221408367157,
-1.0047248601913452,
0.3492478132247925,
0.21051545441150665,
-0.02247743122279644,
0.33876702189445496,
-0.5904951095581055,
0.74644535779953,
-0.22947828471660614,
-0.5458077788352966,
-0.0993489995598793,
-0.19540667533874512,
0.40531280636787415,
0.046300437301397324,
0.4488302171230316,
-0.3090514540672302,
-0.5801440477371216,
0.6456239223480225,
-0.28576159477233887,
1.0468244552612305,
-0.2607312500476837,
-0.2666693925857544,
-0.12178423255681992,
0.13604314625263214,
0.1945938766002655,
-0.0653609037399292,
-0.23012596368789673,
0.4214341938495636,
-0.22054438292980194,
-0.27888432145118713,
-0.2851075530052185,
0.6244359016418457,
-0.27302154898643494,
-0.6522340178489685,
-0.3916042447090149,
-0.37464573979377747,
-0.2906627357006073,
0.06397446990013123,
0.28384461998939514,
0.15830357372760773,
-0.24974727630615234,
0.09579875320196152,
0.42844000458717346,
-0.2852201759815216,
0.2729323208332062,
0.07656119018793106,
-0.162736177444458,
-0.03711586818099022,
0.48309001326560974,
0.013371145352721214,
-0.05035287141799927,
0.4449424147605896,
0.14677762985229492,
-0.3989101052284241,
-0.35607799887657166,
-0.5183436274528503,
0.2810596227645874,
-0.07619315385818481,
-0.35124844312667847,
-0.44965723156929016,
0.2940986752510071,
-0.38751155138015747,
-0.11655072122812271,
-0.3820878863334656,
-0.29175665974617004,
-0.45424720644950867,
0.09913171082735062,
0.39780792593955994,
0.4926254451274872,
0.21174931526184082,
0.329186350107193,
-0.49729180335998535,
0.13897615671157837,
-0.02456405758857727,
0.03313222900032997,
-0.38175204396247864,
-0.5884094834327698,
-0.09107623249292374,
0.16983503103256226,
-0.5352634787559509,
-1.3420764207839966,
0.5840306878089905,
0.20171862840652466,
0.5602861046791077,
0.6634735465049744,
0.03252609446644783,
0.837552547454834,
-0.1807480901479721,
0.8093605041503906,
0.5626934170722961,
-1.0694934129714966,
1.0356113910675049,
-0.6250569820404053,
-0.1782665252685547,
0.4328344166278839,
0.4681698977947235,
-0.3406870663166046,
-0.8168411254882812,
-0.645279586315155,
-0.6846861839294434,
0.2969311475753784,
0.3644140362739563,
0.5040984749794006,
-0.3191019296646118,
0.4308134913444519,
0.2902914583683014,
0.7646721005439758,
-0.727575421333313,
-0.3848954141139984,
0.03756863623857498,
-0.02384859323501587,
0.03342640399932861,
-0.3436294496059418,
-0.3678628206253052,
-0.37305235862731934,
0.7571167349815369,
0.02017390914261341,
0.48376190662384033,
0.17216643691062927,
-0.3465827405452728,
0.09053124487400055,
0.36639660596847534,
0.43517211079597473,
0.6859394311904907,
-0.051973067224025726,
0.04142475873231888,
0.021331369876861572,
-0.23844948410987854,
0.11331183463335037,
0.2082493007183075,
-0.2727528512477875,
0.6909328699111938,
0.2776488959789276,
0.6051385998725891,
0.4441579282283783,
-0.5397300720214844,
0.5103622674942017,
0.2655968964099884,
-0.021658597514033318,
-0.4750095009803772,
0.03880992531776428,
-0.04640790820121765,
0.28405749797821045,
0.6387929916381836,
0.0834701657295227,
0.424646258354187,
-1.0593039989471436,
-0.1895170956850052,
0.38598060607910156,
-0.3652779161930084,
-0.032002028077840805,
0.6271079182624817,
0.2765098512172699,
-0.10465778410434723,
0.046520818024873734,
-0.30331820249557495,
-0.9342761635780334,
0.3890068829059601,
0.23890210688114166,
0.6594331860542297,
-0.5404399037361145,
0.4299694001674652,
0.3199579119682312,
0.08122912049293518,
0.15792880952358246,
-0.018978824838995934,
-0.24991539120674133,
-1.060422420501709,
-0.12297414243221283,
-0.5474808216094971,
-0.08807580173015594,
-0.1119060069322586,
-0.45636990666389465,
0.2876860797405243,
-0.3951382339000702,
-0.36403653025627136,
0.24496197700500488,
-0.130794957280159,
-0.32169467210769653,
-0.02167174220085144,
0.31620287895202637,
0.5547952651977539,
-0.9754286408424377,
0.7501698732376099,
1.0429447889328003,
-0.3661561906337738,
-0.6570232510566711,
0.15487709641456604,
0.16949808597564697,
-0.39963075518608093,
0.8341753482818604,
0.3677408695220947,
-0.013045181520283222,
-0.16519658267498016,
-0.6106044054031372,
-0.3004342019557953,
0.9886447191238403,
0.5798985362052917,
-0.7269781827926636,
-0.09540670365095139,
-0.16819804906845093,
0.5093385577201843,
-0.6234068274497986,
0.41946831345558167,
0.607038140296936,
0.74956876039505,
-0.08594119548797607,
-1.0925655364990234,
-0.12889154255390167,
-0.2928878366947174,
0.2514568567276001,
0.301874041557312,
-0.38973721861839294,
0.6894493103027344,
-0.03409261628985405,
-0.2585557699203491,
0.2855534851551056,
0.33194321393966675,
0.08075594156980515,
0.7037596702575684,
0.6372277736663818,
0.532006561756134,
0.6753828525543213,
-0.4668027460575104,
0.9440495371818542,
0.13069947063922882,
0.38443800806999207,
0.9075151681900024,
0.024698711931705475,
0.5543734431266785,
0.9255788326263428,
-0.39131176471710205,
0.6955932974815369,
0.6722837090492249,
0.04545189440250397,
0.23716747760772705,
0.205608069896698,
-0.6032047271728516,
-0.30671653151512146,
-0.689121425151825,
-0.41071170568466187,
0.6580419540405273,
0.48944342136383057,
-0.8162829279899597,
-0.41272425651550293,
0.3821163773536682,
0.5844737887382507,
0.3649705648422241,
-0.419070839881897,
0.5715113282203674,
-0.06163659691810608,
-0.3431578278541565,
0.28397440910339355,
0.035931140184402466,
0.9036063551902771,
-0.14360180497169495,
-0.22183695435523987,
-0.2973998486995697,
0.06449276953935623,
-0.3984443247318268,
-0.43836161494255066,
0.3631424009799957,
0.2741956114768982,
-0.056950632482767105,
-0.25574418902397156,
0.8660922050476074,
-0.6832192540168762,
-0.559087872505188,
0.40892931818962097,
0.7251324653625488,
0.4232601225376129,
-0.34186574816703796,
-0.8726069331169128,
0.015760047361254692,
0.10952191054821014,
0.17873485386371613,
0.2045496553182602,
0.4082064926624298,
-0.011830947361886501,
0.4198809564113617,
0.7292285561561584,
0.04881389066576958,
-0.027075866237282753,
0.21892832219600677,
0.9735075831413269,
-0.2940543591976166,
-0.04203109070658684,
-1.0283737182617188,
0.4439457952976227,
-0.40364569425582886,
-0.3092525005340576,
0.8010947704315186,
0.3992100954055786,
0.8126591444015503,
-0.018078593537211418,
0.46720796823501587,
-0.40294209122657776,
0.660724937915802,
-0.07004346698522568,
0.4291442036628723,
-0.8540668487548828,
0.3709983229637146,
-0.46430665254592896,
-0.8650334477424622,
-0.4616125226020813,
0.7255887985229492,
-0.6983038187026978,
0.10435639321804047,
0.4187399744987488,
0.9119221568107605,
-0.006288446485996246,
-0.10279523581266403,
0.5142175555229187,
0.5435087084770203,
-0.06803533434867859,
0.2267783135175705,
0.863861620426178,
-0.5751534700393677,
0.45612356066703796,
-0.3562021553516388,
-0.20772437751293182,
-0.4924798011779785,
-0.901013970375061,
-0.7402915358543396,
-0.4383544921875,
-0.6375748515129089,
-0.3378663957118988,
0.5635650157928467,
0.6707749962806702,
0.5825958847999573,
-0.5710277557373047,
0.011595814488828182,
-0.29088062047958374,
0.32896482944488525,
-0.11331955343484879,
-0.31839850544929504,
-0.14089921116828918,
-0.17286597192287445,
-1.254522442817688,
0.26975613832473755,
0.1787772923707962,
-0.2755005359649658,
-0.2696308493614197,
0.1554604470729828,
-0.4420280456542969,
-0.05279092490673065,
0.6387473344802856,
-0.22080476582050323,
-0.6886373162269592,
-0.28908243775367737,
-0.46114110946655273,
-0.007045283913612366,
-0.2865496277809143,
0.6669675707817078,
-0.6653622388839722,
0.34032395482063293,
0.335999995470047,
0.1519993543624878,
0.20208293199539185,
0.2259155958890915,
0.5476506352424622,
-0.7359175086021423,
0.32429200410842896,
0.5057786703109741,
0.37298718094825745,
0.43337929248809814,
-0.6074213981628418,
0.5410118103027344,
0.7712114453315735,
0.04485112428665161,
-0.9063031673431396,
0.20537050068378448,
-0.7818909883499146,
-0.44506534934043884,
1.0672529935836792,
-0.20203551650047302,
-0.2916587293148041,
-0.028787055984139442,
-0.17830102145671844,
0.29348376393318176,
-0.6978837847709656,
0.886391818523407,
0.8192429542541504,
-0.1475045382976532,
-0.15757963061332703,
-0.3799527883529663,
0.24415068328380585,
0.3992481529712677,
-0.6457251906394958,
-0.22100766003131866,
0.6268301010131836,
0.1545855551958084,
0.31433311104774475,
0.2141616940498352,
-0.34085729718208313,
0.38054221868515015,
-0.2559751570224762,
-0.05994540452957153,
0.010488731786608696,
-0.11129043251276016,
0.11997657269239426,
-0.13950134813785553,
-0.4827744662761688,
-0.28096646070480347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02677v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02677v2
|
The VoicePrivacy 2024 Challenge Evaluation Plan
| 2024-04-03T12:20:51 | 2024-06-12T14:05:43 |
Natalia Tomashenko, Xiaoxiao Miao, Pierre Champion, Sarina Meyer, Xin Wang, Emmanuel Vincent, Michele Panariello, Nicholas Evans, Junichi Yamagishi, Massimiliano Todisco
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The task of the challenge is to develop a voice anonymization system for
speech data which conceals the speaker's voice identity while protecting
linguistic content and emotional states. The organizers provide development and
evaluation datasets and evaluation scripts, as well as baseline anonymization
systems and a list of training resources formed on the basis of the
participants' requests. Participants apply their developed anonymization
systems, run evaluation scripts and submit evaluation results and anonymized
speech data to the organizers. Results will be presented at a workshop held in
conjunction with Interspeech 2024 to which all participants are invited to
present their challenge systems and to submit additional workshop papers.
|
[
-0.4836888015270233,
-0.21613425016403198,
0.13693813979625702,
0.4973468780517578,
-0.0554581843316555,
0.33283334970474243,
-0.14472611248493195,
-0.6064677834510803,
0.253422349691391,
0.8585116267204285,
-1.3192600011825562,
-0.4618741273880005,
-0.39589735865592957,
0.18816730380058289,
-0.6085283160209656,
0.8952423930168152,
0.27767738699913025,
0.14531230926513672,
-0.22267724573612213,
-0.08504991233348846,
-0.5795560479164124,
-0.762338399887085,
-0.3166363835334778,
-0.2356361746788025,
0.2530297338962555,
0.641357958316803,
0.3196592926979065,
0.7305883765220642,
0.3877405524253845,
0.36994221806526184,
-0.04871492460370064,
-0.25042614340782166,
-0.32094138860702515,
0.15886062383651733,
-0.1636667251586914,
-0.3695511221885681,
-0.28888338804244995,
0.2323535680770874,
0.540088951587677,
0.601600706577301,
-0.5369468331336975,
0.36809712648391724,
-0.2712738811969757,
0.3260330557823181,
-0.7144384384155273,
0.2052902728319168,
-0.5497523546218872,
0.22972193360328674,
-0.6031120419502258,
-0.19258585572242737,
-0.279599666595459,
-0.4157581627368927,
0.06724467128515244,
-0.38113275170326233,
0.22928732633590698,
0.2515181303024292,
0.8675124645233154,
0.27020952105522156,
0.13030855357646942,
-0.5328313708305359,
-0.9212197661399841,
0.7617565989494324,
-0.5721957683563232,
0.2655690908432007,
0.2909072935581207,
0.44212695956230164,
0.014079535380005836,
-0.7553701996803284,
-0.7724032998085022,
0.01597016677260399,
0.31857144832611084,
0.2162502408027649,
-0.526323139667511,
0.19024509191513062,
0.11437837034463882,
0.24180389940738678,
-0.5388676524162292,
0.20424506068229675,
-0.4135594964027405,
-0.28317075967788696,
0.9073812961578369,
0.2924400568008423,
0.4058079421520233,
-0.11751506477594376,
-0.6497266888618469,
-0.026936108246445656,
-0.33363333344459534,
-0.21233625710010529,
1.0502464771270752,
0.4087296724319458,
-0.08219901472330093,
0.56391441822052,
-0.28156381845474243,
0.1659240871667862,
0.06300303339958191,
-0.030494922772049904,
0.7101094722747803,
-0.5935467481613159,
0.07761862128973007,
0.2810767889022827,
0.5586044788360596,
0.10091372579336166,
-0.007538917008787394,
-0.2414160817861557,
-0.13600093126296997,
0.008275292813777924,
0.41170257329940796,
-0.7432210445404053,
-0.11573217064142227,
0.3506132960319519,
-0.5034756660461426,
-0.12485992163419724,
0.07505269348621368,
-1.0367484092712402,
-0.4546107351779938,
-0.4321030080318451,
0.6290088295936584,
-0.19738136231899261,
-0.4139678478240967,
-0.010717946104705334,
-0.3052056133747101,
0.08846712112426758,
0.31939420104026794,
-1.0270590782165527,
0.8994894623756409,
0.716672420501709,
0.4883645176887512,
-0.38687142729759216,
-0.2887510657310486,
-0.47508060932159424,
-0.01045983750373125,
-0.15938149392604828,
0.8408047556877136,
-0.7671331763267517,
-0.47431811690330505,
-0.15861760079860687,
0.37844008207321167,
-0.24501334130764008,
-0.975580632686615,
0.7465831637382507,
0.07545027881860733,
0.13557812571525574,
-0.396190881729126,
-0.6381999254226685,
-0.007317548617720604,
-0.3013708293437958,
-0.5503093004226685,
0.7170075178146362,
-0.18120478093624115,
-0.6643668413162231,
0.23949240148067474,
-0.9569780826568604,
-0.011513273231685162,
0.6269292235374451,
-0.08029238879680634,
-0.5778771042823792,
-0.19620124995708466,
0.17004668712615967,
0.13007843494415283,
0.06714005023241043,
0.08528430759906769,
-0.15801134705543518,
-0.5354679822921753,
0.11017252504825592,
-0.31581270694732666,
1.0860503911972046,
0.23136623203754425,
-0.7163395285606384,
0.49366769194602966,
-0.9249080419540405,
0.0811767503619194,
0.1384284347295761,
-0.036171380430459976,
0.3692709803581238,
-0.10040580481290817,
-0.013810955919325352,
-0.15505702793598175,
0.17680929601192474,
-0.9399558305740356,
-0.05505841597914696,
-0.5344986915588379,
0.37509435415267944,
0.755530059337616,
0.3493429720401764,
0.35427042841911316,
-0.081283338367939,
1.0811117887496948,
-0.27942559123039246,
0.4717387855052948,
-0.13970637321472168,
-0.46763473749160767,
-0.7023613452911377,
-0.2325645536184311,
0.25113946199417114,
0.856073260307312,
-0.37189966440200806,
0.3630087077617645,
0.018656766042113304,
-0.750767171382904,
-0.6141477227210999,
-0.00033666944364085793,
0.3660257160663605,
0.36679592728614807,
0.19049058854579926,
-0.3755587041378021,
-0.8887603282928467,
-1.203712821006775,
-0.3158973753452301,
-0.010855172760784626,
-0.08718324452638626,
0.2589370906352997,
0.5348525047302246,
-0.007565397769212723,
0.5783330202102661,
0.10144062340259552,
-0.5347017049789429,
-0.41473910212516785,
0.32933688163757324,
-0.10321074724197388,
0.7384767532348633,
0.44512754678726196,
-1.0744035243988037,
-0.15037041902542114,
-0.4204111695289612,
-0.2406046837568283,
-0.5132454037666321,
0.21088676154613495,
0.0980185717344284,
-0.20175080001354218,
0.39718854427337646,
-0.26684102416038513,
0.737517774105072,
0.7301278114318848,
-0.39415812492370605,
0.4948633313179016,
0.03913455829024315,
0.30873310565948486,
-0.5403665900230408,
0.09877660125494003,
-0.5492702126502991,
0.04182131588459015,
-0.7538869380950928,
-0.3829360008239746,
-0.3579006493091583,
-0.8672876358032227,
-0.3533957898616791,
0.15678459405899048,
-0.25733575224876404,
-0.3407106399536133,
-0.11373468488454819,
0.08406940847635269,
-0.17635849118232727,
0.19140766561031342,
-0.18633976578712463,
0.824010968208313,
0.3679015040397644,
-0.3816238045692444,
0.7391481399536133,
0.5809213519096375,
-0.32412320375442505,
0.6897377967834473,
-0.47861453890800476,
0.5592751502990723,
-0.13082604110240936,
0.12997114658355713,
-0.9761708974838257,
-0.31576672196388245,
0.08704499900341034,
-0.8931298851966858,
0.03349572420120239,
0.12270841747522354,
-0.30530667304992676,
-0.3397124409675598,
0.05690835043787956,
0.18867434561252594,
0.20731773972511292,
-0.5842733979225159,
0.47283706068992615,
0.8845251798629761,
-0.4782216548919678,
-0.6584786176681519,
-0.5525585412979126,
0.6910862326622009,
-0.5824381113052368,
-0.3616373836994171,
0.6939256191253662,
-0.25164440274238586,
-0.11165868490934372,
0.16485632956027985,
0.26686882972717285,
-0.21091575920581818,
0.07637186348438263,
0.5579829812049866,
-0.14948293566703796,
0.33916324377059937,
-0.008256262168288231,
-0.33551761507987976,
-0.24310670793056488,
0.3355555832386017,
-0.15155944228172302,
0.5257694125175476,
-0.11640124022960663,
-0.2628554403781891,
-0.9712325930595398,
0.8416575193405151,
0.10904306918382645,
-0.43494224548339844,
0.2982355058193207,
0.7104445099830627,
-0.6283342242240906,
-0.2844119668006897,
-0.6440314650535583,
-0.06628137081861496,
-0.47857487201690674,
0.3863356411457062,
-0.21088597178459167,
-0.8154188394546509,
0.6710339784622192,
-0.31002211570739746,
-0.06497646123170853,
0.1767759770154953,
0.7812121510505676,
0.10510065406560898,
1.2171443700790405,
0.837064266204834,
0.2741778790950775,
0.3355884552001953,
0.0767103061079979,
0.29013046622276306,
-0.3544638752937317,
-0.8878480792045593,
-0.9550099968910217,
-0.16139498353004456,
-0.43216896057128906,
-0.39254695177078247,
0.2864728569984436,
-0.3214554190635681,
0.050517767667770386,
0.4152124226093292,
-0.7350311875343323,
0.33734580874443054,
0.708918035030365,
-0.11162686347961426,
-0.15576325356960297,
-0.37486112117767334,
0.27662280201911926,
-0.47069594264030457,
-0.4086073935031891,
-0.4453326165676117,
0.7884550094604492,
0.36516329646110535,
0.1754152923822403,
-0.02946350909769535,
0.9181150794029236,
0.2999410033226013,
-0.11439314484596252,
-0.5739889740943909,
0.7270326018333435,
-0.021607043221592903,
-0.7137675881385803,
-0.4972887635231018,
-0.17129231989383698,
-0.946157693862915,
-0.02251441963016987,
-0.1933024674654007,
-1.2000313997268677,
0.49227049946784973,
-0.0546543188393116,
0.026011915877461433,
0.05777311697602272,
-0.5891920924186707,
0.8888739347457886,
0.077003113925457,
0.042656321078538895,
-0.13029387593269348,
-0.6164873838424683,
0.0994400754570961,
0.07659471780061722,
0.2439451515674591,
-0.36531391739845276,
-0.006481836549937725,
1.2135964632034302,
-0.5550461411476135,
0.6616883277893066,
-0.7326091527938843,
0.4184662699699402,
0.3595831096172333,
-0.4001438617706299,
0.25317609310150146,
-0.1375296413898468,
-0.20429198443889618,
0.03304169327020645,
0.013593676500022411,
-0.35948532819747925,
-0.5685721635818481,
0.44469988346099854,
-0.32109108567237854,
-0.5078484416007996,
-0.1307835876941681,
-0.29865774512290955,
-0.39754340052604675,
0.2597012221813202,
0.41961297392845154,
0.23495365679264069,
-0.29496973752975464,
0.4383987784385681,
0.5532333254814148,
-0.37132006883621216,
0.47298839688301086,
0.3666249215602875,
0.2682659327983856,
-0.661053478717804,
0.7902430295944214,
0.3298611342906952,
-0.04755404219031334,
-0.0766751617193222,
0.22897695004940033,
-0.500291645526886,
-0.6665792465209961,
-0.3175771236419678,
-0.0600053034722805,
-0.7747887372970581,
-0.12585477530956268,
-0.5461552739143372,
-0.20967626571655273,
-0.4947933256626129,
0.32821303606033325,
-0.7381559610366821,
-0.41653943061828613,
-0.041220586746931076,
-0.2644388973712921,
-0.11028362810611725,
1.0663248300552368,
-0.34590062499046326,
0.07710006833076477,
-0.0848303809762001,
0.22512079775333405,
0.1994166523218155,
0.11877879500389099,
-0.4096986949443817,
-0.29796257615089417,
-0.18160587549209595,
-0.39235633611679077,
-0.2623702585697174,
-0.8746486306190491,
0.38262996077537537,
0.2664376199245453,
0.750887393951416,
-0.019696470350027084,
0.2632092237472534,
0.8119853138923645,
-0.5648412108421326,
1.0540868043899536,
0.029273340478539467,
-1.4368504285812378,
0.9645129442214966,
-0.05533338710665703,
0.12054632604122162,
0.7125654220581055,
0.09853833168745041,
-0.1034940630197525,
-0.5607441067695618,
-0.8247249722480774,
-1.0742969512939453,
0.5960894823074341,
0.49557608366012573,
0.3489580750465393,
0.3079650104045868,
0.581308901309967,
-0.12509895861148834,
0.4758744239807129,
-0.5679199695587158,
-0.176170215010643,
-0.3127525746822357,
-0.08110275864601135,
0.30247849225997925,
-0.4018637239933014,
-0.33432161808013916,
-0.21486741304397583,
0.36244168877601624,
0.1569797545671463,
0.44471949338912964,
0.12090078741312027,
0.7322335839271545,
-0.1006397008895874,
0.3274654150009155,
0.7353081703186035,
0.7431506514549255,
-0.021545758470892906,
-0.09781590104103088,
0.32264041900634766,
-0.6638977527618408,
0.2615460455417633,
0.09082253277301788,
0.20914621651172638,
0.17264696955680847,
0.5277484059333801,
1.091951608657837,
0.15997913479804993,
-0.7703800201416016,
0.9088137745857239,
-0.35201287269592285,
-0.6544346213340759,
-0.8446670770645142,
0.04992437735199928,
0.00482369726523757,
0.39659562706947327,
0.5127098560333252,
-0.06308741122484207,
0.5373968482017517,
-0.4815513491630554,
0.33006778359413147,
0.167952761054039,
-0.4656974673271179,
-0.45999929308891296,
0.9611117839813232,
0.04258454591035843,
-0.6104204058647156,
0.07844176143407822,
-0.17891408503055573,
-0.79886794090271,
0.6004056930541992,
0.5561897158622742,
1.0060851573944092,
-0.9197785258293152,
-0.005259442608803511,
0.291833758354187,
0.38232293725013733,
0.3153150677680969,
0.6384996771812439,
0.04045882076025009,
-0.3155898451805115,
-0.18804550170898438,
-0.4596911370754242,
-0.9536108374595642,
0.36036673188209534,
-0.9673611521720886,
0.43872931599617004,
-0.580021321773529,
-0.09396815299987793,
0.16187231242656708,
0.11686111241579056,
-0.5841814875602722,
0.4871571660041809,
0.20866625010967255,
0.6986014246940613,
-0.8584381937980652,
0.5894392728805542,
0.24308300018310547,
0.09253844618797302,
-0.9560896158218384,
-0.16655699908733368,
0.29695841670036316,
-0.6037022471427917,
0.7952919006347656,
0.166910782456398,
-0.2638416588306427,
-0.1507117599248886,
-0.5430614352226257,
-0.839349627494812,
0.9902074337005615,
0.6663089990615845,
-0.42885634303092957,
0.1861879527568817,
0.17739169299602509,
0.37634754180908203,
-0.6588112711906433,
-0.18386584520339966,
0.536844789981842,
0.8145705461502075,
0.06497553735971451,
-1.2696189880371094,
-0.2442878633737564,
-0.4609731435775757,
-0.11523008346557617,
-0.2947133481502533,
-0.5237399935722351,
0.8335331678390503,
-0.10885653644800186,
-0.7621974349021912,
0.30587291717529297,
0.5310582518577576,
0.016199979931116104,
0.28783687949180603,
0.8459485173225403,
0.4211033880710602,
0.9438202977180481,
-0.22178849577903748,
0.684013843536377,
0.013284227810800076,
0.15038973093032837,
1.1493144035339355,
-0.2831647992134094,
0.7492932081222534,
0.289661705493927,
-0.19495642185211182,
0.49032527208328247,
0.3822897672653198,
-0.15015161037445068,
0.5654510259628296,
0.5121973156929016,
-0.4543288052082062,
-0.01341848261654377,
-0.5584567785263062,
-0.19998790323734283,
1.102590799331665,
0.36735793948173523,
0.13061951100826263,
0.09303653985261917,
0.492014080286026,
0.0015666928375139832,
0.45302408933639526,
0.054616715759038925,
1.0642644166946411,
-0.300100177526474,
-0.4847477078437805,
0.5303924083709717,
-0.0930214449763298,
0.09945154190063477,
-0.4936791658401489,
-0.23766905069351196,
0.19464699923992157,
0.23853304982185364,
-0.44282853603363037,
-0.31580647826194763,
0.4776833653450012,
0.15079548954963684,
0.15069366991519928,
-0.24897289276123047,
0.5305938124656677,
-0.4082021117210388,
-0.11226239055395126,
0.4850219488143921,
-0.1454842984676361,
0.20818579196929932,
0.03629213199019432,
-0.8856822848320007,
0.6167887449264526,
-0.019443310797214508,
-0.26312255859375,
0.2028476744890213,
0.30014005303382874,
0.19752365350723267,
0.8218438029289246,
0.31789863109588623,
0.5099424719810486,
0.08988746255636215,
0.37128257751464844,
0.8309023976325989,
-0.4950902462005615,
-0.8931904435157776,
-0.4332055151462555,
0.29368695616722107,
-0.3265267610549927,
-0.2446071207523346,
0.862596869468689,
0.7441034317016602,
0.6193410158157349,
0.28187260031700134,
0.7975004315376282,
0.11273933202028275,
1.2032620906829834,
-0.32496178150177,
0.45622196793556213,
-0.29265037178993225,
0.3111589550971985,
-0.4726330637931824,
-0.828784167766571,
-0.10780727118253708,
0.377653568983078,
-0.023665526881814003,
-0.12447590380907059,
0.382431298494339,
0.6286101341247559,
0.37559470534324646,
0.27541521191596985,
0.2848796546459198,
-0.06262260675430298,
0.4549773931503296,
0.467410147190094,
0.7630465030670166,
-0.3516191840171814,
0.5646584033966064,
-0.7078576683998108,
-0.3987460434436798,
-0.060953184962272644,
-0.8237525820732117,
-0.6364272236824036,
-0.8713210821151733,
-0.2938734292984009,
-0.2537623643875122,
0.24964886903762817,
0.4584815502166748,
0.9652320742607117,
-0.9157277345657349,
-0.46753573417663574,
-0.07684534043073654,
-0.3709902763366699,
-0.1732138693332672,
-0.30155399441719055,
0.04415162652730942,
-0.14801988005638123,
-1.2377021312713623,
0.9058573842048645,
0.6234459280967712,
-0.08568370342254639,
-0.5006203651428223,
0.0927906259894371,
0.07472418993711472,
0.25882747769355774,
-0.05966132879257202,
0.3260640799999237,
-0.8198612332344055,
-0.6544415950775146,
-0.1730547398328781,
0.48945218324661255,
-0.1316278874874115,
0.7595556974411011,
-0.5221876502037048,
0.8338053822517395,
0.10489735007286072,
0.504912793636322,
0.6184769868850708,
0.37660905718803406,
0.6300321221351624,
-0.7384657859802246,
0.7016490697860718,
0.8823055624961853,
-0.04985104501247406,
0.30701568722724915,
-0.47147104144096375,
0.3950774073600769,
0.18108774721622467,
-0.6610475778579712,
-1.2528327703475952,
0.26057198643684387,
-0.8524898290634155,
0.08865159004926682,
0.6843892931938171,
-0.45726731419563293,
-0.1463516503572464,
-0.29561835527420044,
-0.1308606117963791,
0.07784201204776764,
-0.13036896288394928,
0.4072199761867523,
0.7396035194396973,
-0.5831754207611084,
-0.5080432295799255,
-0.8854023814201355,
0.8602300882339478,
0.37945470213890076,
-1.0081753730773926,
0.21565742790699005,
-0.021949199959635735,
0.20919524133205414,
0.2150692492723465,
0.786090612411499,
-0.5395509600639343,
0.295773983001709,
0.28498733043670654,
0.1525300294160843,
0.04201411455869675,
-0.518291175365448,
-0.429089218378067,
0.48484304547309875,
-0.21060524880886078,
-0.4018956124782562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02657v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02657v2
|
Rethinking Kullback-Leibler Divergence in Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T11:40:17 | 2024-06-16T14:32:48 |
Taiqiang Wu, Chaofan Tao, Jiahao Wang, Zhe Zhao, Ngai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Kullback-Leiber divergence has been widely used in Knowledge Distillation
(KD) to compress Large Language Models (LLMs). Contrary to prior assertions
that reverse Kullback-Leibler (RKL) divergence is mode-seeking and thus
preferable over the mean-seeking forward Kullback-Leibler (FKL) divergence,
this study empirically and theoretically demonstrates that neither mode-seeking
nor mean-seeking properties manifest in KD for LLMs. Instead, RKL and FKL are
found to share the same optimization objective and both converge after a
sufficient number of epochs. However, due to practical constraints, LLMs are
seldom trained for such an extensive number of epochs. Meanwhile, we further
find that RKL focuses on the tail part of the distributions, while FKL focuses
on the head part at the beginning epochs. Consequently, we propose a simple yet
effective Adaptive Kullback-Leiber (AKL) divergence method, which adaptively
allocates weights to combine FKL and RKL. Metric-based and GPT-4-based
evaluations demonstrate that the proposed AKL outperforms the baselines across
various tasks and improves the diversity and quality of generated responses.
|
[
-0.40474504232406616,
-0.5945882201194763,
0.7360582947731018,
0.16818562150001526,
-0.4907241463661194,
0.32441797852516174,
-0.5704620480537415,
-0.18411585688591003,
0.17524684965610504,
0.21776331961154938,
-0.43697792291641235,
-0.43137866258621216,
-0.7813407778739929,
0.14853009581565857,
-0.09228602796792984,
1.0664914846420288,
0.1284051090478897,
-0.2430068850517273,
-0.10880664736032486,
-0.3521270751953125,
-0.41979071497917175,
-0.30597415566444397,
-0.5416271686553955,
-0.49138060212135315,
0.6200283169746399,
0.25236204266548157,
0.4848387837409973,
0.31099411845207214,
0.26713261008262634,
0.1966244876384735,
-0.49437645077705383,
0.02153370901942253,
-0.579452395439148,
0.5277848839759827,
0.09567601978778839,
-0.5014733076095581,
-0.20722515881061554,
-0.08819694072008133,
0.7157161831855774,
0.8493914604187012,
-0.4287091791629791,
-0.16720668971538544,
0.3001523017883301,
1.2632908821105957,
-1.0170063972473145,
0.3127024471759796,
-0.516800045967102,
0.10484039783477783,
-0.07041174173355103,
-0.012432032264769077,
-0.4940832555294037,
-0.1510428488254547,
0.41844192147254944,
-0.6227971911430359,
0.07746754586696625,
-0.08607611060142517,
0.40566664934158325,
0.24713413417339325,
-0.3376998007297516,
-0.41349032521247864,
-0.9312422871589661,
1.0226478576660156,
-0.9930263161659241,
0.9784875512123108,
0.32116469740867615,
0.4029310941696167,
-0.041461315006017685,
-0.36271339654922485,
-0.4660477042198181,
-0.3089446425437927,
0.020977705717086792,
0.22830688953399658,
-0.30823513865470886,
-0.09453099220991135,
0.11630526930093765,
0.23520885407924652,
-0.33221936225891113,
0.2730879485607147,
-0.31847280263900757,
-0.07335545867681503,
0.46968692541122437,
0.15509742498397827,
-0.4264911413192749,
0.2875446081161499,
-0.15364880859851837,
-0.2782735526561737,
-0.6718165874481201,
0.21302750706672668,
0.2436012476682663,
0.27671322226524353,
-0.16684065759181976,
0.24827592074871063,
-0.5052868723869324,
0.6660263538360596,
0.2640001177787781,
-0.678232729434967,
0.2374049425125122,
-0.1696518510580063,
-0.16232922673225403,
0.05059079825878143,
0.6012011170387268,
0.40339821577072144,
0.13655152916908264,
-0.20974430441856384,
-0.29351118206977844,
-0.5108931660652161,
0.01951264590024948,
-0.7806519269943237,
-0.28513509035110474,
0.26416143774986267,
-0.47186338901519775,
-0.2926782965660095,
-0.16648396849632263,
-0.8513516783714294,
-0.4086833596229553,
-0.22710829973220825,
0.29405269026756287,
-0.2731195390224457,
-0.5526741743087769,
0.25985246896743774,
-0.25490090250968933,
0.28057995438575745,
0.18444883823394775,
-0.9142426252365112,
0.04940907284617424,
0.7093273997306824,
0.8428396582603455,
-0.25543394684791565,
-0.2697996497154236,
-0.32532334327697754,
-0.04541890695691109,
-0.3840070068836212,
0.7130104303359985,
-0.38523033261299133,
-0.4949333369731903,
-0.07899586856365204,
-0.19249945878982544,
0.02834295853972435,
-0.7477166652679443,
0.3988828659057617,
-0.909607470035553,
0.08470968157052994,
-0.3925905227661133,
-0.6006320118904114,
-0.3197033405303955,
0.35095322132110596,
-0.7795554399490356,
0.5991458892822266,
0.05082818493247032,
-0.7244120836257935,
0.8342742919921875,
-0.5720312595367432,
-0.3446448743343353,
-0.03574112430214882,
-0.17000818252563477,
-0.6887767910957336,
0.28540271520614624,
0.10028139501810074,
0.48162293434143066,
-0.39472874999046326,
0.15154731273651123,
-0.4897947311401367,
-0.14990554749965668,
0.24102187156677246,
-0.32630687952041626,
0.7783385515213013,
0.19145062565803528,
-0.1678641438484192,
-0.3408665955066681,
-0.5141830444335938,
-0.11122673004865646,
0.10185039788484573,
-0.8260491490364075,
-0.6408591270446777,
0.384175568819046,
-0.32650837302207947,
-0.24708382785320282,
-0.03261015936732292,
-0.40445756912231445,
0.29331615567207336,
-0.3546063005924225,
0.27863451838493347,
0.6995432376861572,
-0.03906318172812462,
0.733762800693512,
-0.36032548546791077,
0.43277058005332947,
0.4640255272388458,
0.04358942061662674,
0.025344641879200935,
-0.1911342740058899,
-0.605002760887146,
-0.287485271692276,
0.3530275821685791,
0.2222646027803421,
-0.5448651313781738,
0.4610583484172821,
-0.42110002040863037,
-0.603687047958374,
-0.5376331210136414,
0.1259489804506302,
0.034933727234601974,
0.4875938594341278,
0.3655284643173218,
-0.07875754684209824,
-0.3984754681587219,
-0.7699751853942871,
-0.10539616644382477,
-0.4212181866168976,
0.043564654886722565,
0.3785783052444458,
0.1807296872138977,
0.024985799565911293,
1.0726112127304077,
-0.5857969522476196,
-0.2837532162666321,
-0.17414724826812744,
-0.02146473154425621,
0.4351063370704651,
0.22940149903297424,
0.5437379479408264,
-0.8343873620033264,
-0.8283523917198181,
0.19197465479373932,
-0.6770949363708496,
-0.2825773358345032,
0.05225095525383949,
0.18695750832557678,
0.47564035654067993,
0.3963511288166046,
-0.7436587810516357,
0.15309134125709534,
0.5507292151451111,
-0.13731949031352997,
0.9038199782371521,
-0.1364942342042923,
0.02515328861773014,
-1.04154372215271,
0.12731219828128815,
-0.2460969239473343,
-0.11135151237249374,
-0.6374936103820801,
0.16414345800876617,
0.22895818948745728,
0.34351202845573425,
-0.227806955575943,
0.442607581615448,
-0.6599228382110596,
0.08614417165517807,
-0.4397340416908264,
-0.019924631342291832,
0.00863645039498806,
0.13634784519672394,
0.03768755868077278,
0.41389229893684387,
0.7154473066329956,
-0.7186199426651001,
0.38361960649490356,
-0.2071964144706726,
-0.3368227183818817,
0.6187073588371277,
-0.41498738527297974,
0.1414124220609665,
-0.40791720151901245,
0.42589282989501953,
-0.6514723300933838,
0.222782164812088,
0.1912933737039566,
-0.18202942609786987,
0.4061216115951538,
-0.4683297872543335,
-0.06350463628768921,
-0.19022893905639648,
-0.47955256700515747,
0.4925644099712372,
0.8912124633789062,
-0.5419549345970154,
0.8332728743553162,
0.05683540925383568,
-0.21301645040512085,
-0.7932654619216919,
-0.5054978132247925,
-0.07191397249698639,
-0.7258543968200684,
-0.3853088617324829,
0.17957176268100739,
-0.2569958567619324,
-0.4708884358406067,
0.03722768649458885,
-0.3632509708404541,
0.015328551642596722,
0.17903341352939606,
-0.2012277990579605,
0.1853598803281784,
-0.36105793714523315,
0.0765804648399353,
0.13947972655296326,
-0.008633437566459179,
-0.06061740592122078,
-0.6737005710601807,
0.5427118539810181,
0.3064870238304138,
-0.20043212175369263,
-0.13014021515846252,
0.35515281558036804,
0.7021257281303406,
0.11454803496599197,
0.8383527398109436,
0.5290053486824036,
0.0046368930488824844,
-0.31548476219177246,
-0.7500685453414917,
-0.35288575291633606,
-0.4470269978046417,
0.31689295172691345,
-0.3344738185405731,
-1.120093822479248,
0.6415267586708069,
-0.06343536823987961,
0.222431018948555,
0.20684099197387695,
0.7581019997596741,
-0.08500123023986816,
0.6305961012840271,
0.746816098690033,
-0.39646244049072266,
0.28634655475616455,
-0.24832287430763245,
0.3040759563446045,
-0.8996308445930481,
0.0015578244347125292,
-0.38678961992263794,
-0.3887048661708832,
-0.46027252078056335,
-0.14960260689258575,
0.3822041153907776,
0.5650153756141663,
0.07454248517751694,
0.08108251541852951,
-0.20329704880714417,
0.6240714192390442,
0.46084198355674744,
-0.23769262433052063,
0.5277820825576782,
-0.07337693870067596,
-0.17884080111980438,
-0.055018100887537,
-0.6802928447723389,
-0.014577670954167843,
1.1106330156326294,
0.17486567795276642,
1.2094666957855225,
0.2843431830406189,
0.8634573817253113,
0.2634586989879608,
0.11626670509576797,
-0.9362604022026062,
0.2868099510669708,
-0.1605330854654312,
-0.30468836426734924,
-0.3274696171283722,
-0.4648689925670624,
-0.8935070037841797,
0.3181930482387543,
0.0059789870865643024,
-0.6004739999771118,
0.31229716539382935,
0.19541160762310028,
-0.4089764356613159,
0.2918172776699066,
-0.5262813568115234,
0.433220773935318,
0.0938078835606575,
0.07286293059587479,
-0.28513583540916443,
-0.5003073215484619,
0.1966094672679901,
-0.55092853307724,
0.2309354543685913,
-0.1136707216501236,
-0.05133862420916557,
0.6886656284332275,
-0.18463905155658722,
0.7246478199958801,
-0.5395984649658203,
-0.37843915820121765,
0.2076742947101593,
0.26860401034355164,
0.5413174033164978,
0.0972490981221199,
0.14767000079154968,
0.043708138167858124,
-0.040286291390657425,
-0.270487517118454,
-0.7694063186645508,
0.6894514560699463,
-0.6328055262565613,
-0.8319528698921204,
-0.10791220515966415,
-0.6631033420562744,
-0.06609717756509781,
0.21225664019584656,
0.03813980147242546,
0.23264071345329285,
0.030151421204209328,
0.5389395952224731,
0.5928964018821716,
-0.03490351885557175,
0.5826501250267029,
0.9551893472671509,
-0.2202092558145523,
-0.21974937617778778,
0.661227822303772,
0.23608854413032532,
0.6257352232933044,
0.30422458052635193,
0.5183255076408386,
-0.44363826513290405,
-0.7143595218658447,
-0.283003568649292,
0.17763389647006989,
-0.6197996735572815,
-0.3580906391143799,
-0.6448274254798889,
-0.18786843121051788,
-0.6079498529434204,
-0.1806027591228485,
-0.5137299299240112,
-0.3225080966949463,
-0.0967453196644783,
0.24577675759792328,
0.4587368965148926,
0.40954166650772095,
-0.3629536032676697,
0.16446776688098907,
-0.695382833480835,
-0.05103928595781326,
0.35033974051475525,
0.26562562584877014,
0.2694678008556366,
-0.680116593837738,
-0.3733881413936615,
0.21665310859680176,
-0.16086678206920624,
-0.6410097479820251,
0.2787106931209564,
0.5108712315559387,
0.587723433971405,
0.4502250850200653,
0.3310377895832062,
0.4555274546146393,
-0.46494942903518677,
0.5213340520858765,
0.0651981309056282,
-0.3810567855834961,
0.20133483409881592,
-0.06003652513027191,
0.6126412153244019,
0.3832266926765442,
0.5743630528450012,
-0.7796783447265625,
-0.5242311358451843,
-0.22369594871997833,
-0.7323279976844788,
0.5080490112304688,
-0.07310230284929276,
0.006142972037196159,
0.16589663922786713,
0.22724610567092896,
0.3279031217098236,
0.007529876660555601,
-0.6829193234443665,
-0.1707027405500412,
0.0815226137638092,
-0.09889236837625504,
-0.0855589210987091,
-0.28015458583831787,
-0.04346535727381706,
0.009596283547580242,
0.727345883846283,
-0.22432084381580353,
0.16897110641002655,
0.11685257405042648,
-0.11897644400596619,
-0.03696584701538086,
0.3934042155742645,
0.42043620347976685,
0.4386664628982544,
-0.2561945617198944,
0.2825474143028259,
0.12613613903522491,
-0.6836758255958557,
0.33340439200401306,
0.2030823975801468,
-0.34383681416511536,
-0.09552579373121262,
0.32936805486679077,
0.7968843579292297,
-0.07082793861627579,
-0.5905519723892212,
0.2765730619430542,
-0.0027590268291532993,
-0.325438916683197,
-0.10036804527044296,
-0.0027178307063877583,
0.4583241641521454,
0.6666032075881958,
0.6312258839607239,
-0.28872841596603394,
-0.010578776709735394,
-0.1902027428150177,
-0.0018381787231191993,
0.5178966522216797,
-0.1650327742099762,
-0.20738081634044647,
0.4025084376335144,
-0.1029588058590889,
-0.22581882774829865,
0.6346659064292908,
-0.26211872696876526,
-0.5031298398971558,
0.25296473503112793,
0.5672305226325989,
0.9683625102043152,
-0.18769694864749908,
-0.017246194183826447,
0.12761905789375305,
0.1103949174284935,
0.009223168715834618,
-0.06563618034124374,
-0.37989693880081177,
-0.9477953910827637,
-0.6875653266906738,
-0.8406541347503662,
-0.22585390508174896,
0.14903587102890015,
-0.7011024355888367,
0.12685133516788483,
-0.15108086168766022,
-0.12141149491071701,
0.04067448899149895,
-0.13132180273532867,
-0.3940182030200958,
-0.17418546974658966,
-0.0826195478439331,
0.839118480682373,
-0.8623604774475098,
0.9158889055252075,
0.4682667553424835,
-0.1007249504327774,
-0.6464889645576477,
0.20771285891532898,
0.039258845150470734,
-0.7064750790596008,
0.6738064885139465,
-0.09019920229911804,
0.0809359923005104,
0.22455449402332306,
-0.21512605249881744,
-0.8486751317977905,
1.4244894981384277,
0.11700549721717834,
-0.6824902892112732,
-0.0413949191570282,
0.15856876969337463,
0.38144591450691223,
-0.24789151549339294,
-0.2207818627357483,
0.6686462759971619,
0.23852138221263885,
0.11312086880207062,
-0.9835774302482605,
-0.13974697887897491,
0.10392050445079803,
-0.022515932098031044,
0.5329453349113464,
-0.5721593499183655,
0.713398277759552,
-0.25735658407211304,
-0.2842889428138733,
-0.16443517804145813,
0.4360297918319702,
0.4710867404937744,
0.06761815398931503,
0.9104855060577393,
0.7307243943214417,
0.358090877532959,
0.047699060291051865,
0.6424189805984497,
-0.2015046775341034,
0.6329988241195679,
0.9920657277107239,
-0.3222874701023102,
0.7032573819160461,
0.7312400937080383,
-0.4887574315071106,
0.2843780517578125,
0.315103679895401,
0.25556620955467224,
0.8068490624427795,
-0.0363430418074131,
-0.5040590763092041,
-0.08967205882072449,
0.10112174600362778,
-0.4090236723423004,
0.4246690571308136,
0.0990692600607872,
-0.254055917263031,
-0.4521705210208893,
0.06817422807216644,
0.0987522155046463,
-0.2917613089084625,
-0.10191650688648224,
0.97820645570755,
0.19579803943634033,
-0.7282770276069641,
0.8039780855178833,
-0.13481539487838745,
0.8304736018180847,
-0.5091769695281982,
0.16876593232154846,
-0.5763112902641296,
0.1578003317117691,
0.1737842559814453,
-0.7174484133720398,
0.22870036959648132,
-0.2358534038066864,
-0.2499663382768631,
0.0835796520113945,
0.8964294791221619,
-0.5672122836112976,
-0.37741580605506897,
0.37682220339775085,
0.667669415473938,
-0.031678762286901474,
0.062030717730522156,
-0.596879243850708,
0.20304623246192932,
0.07865770906209946,
-0.4002414643764496,
0.4032883048057556,
0.3365592956542969,
0.21305041015148163,
0.7614642977714539,
0.5772066712379456,
0.2160351723432541,
0.0046027833595871925,
0.10868579149246216,
0.9074568152427673,
-0.379191130399704,
-0.5789160132408142,
-1.031252384185791,
0.38356396555900574,
0.1595655381679535,
0.1829373687505722,
0.5262432098388672,
0.4170443117618561,
0.8657817840576172,
-0.013660192489624023,
0.7066149711608887,
-0.3097701966762543,
0.5410562753677368,
-0.690479576587677,
0.9395855069160461,
-0.5509845614433289,
0.17880600690841675,
-0.19836753606796265,
-1.145463466644287,
-0.22110959887504578,
0.5370343327522278,
-0.11443699896335602,
0.1642746925354004,
0.5887375473976135,
0.7008993625640869,
-0.1516663283109665,
-0.17743246257305145,
0.42603448033332825,
0.37841796875,
0.4473293125629425,
0.5703760385513306,
0.8826481103897095,
-0.01869821920990944,
0.4225108325481415,
-0.3380827009677887,
-0.24366793036460876,
-0.17454589903354645,
-1.0664124488830566,
-0.5588058233261108,
-0.6654279232025146,
-0.17557130753993988,
-0.2665026783943176,
0.19673113524913788,
0.6902398467063904,
0.6341456770896912,
-0.585537850856781,
-0.2661036252975464,
0.09404746443033218,
-0.05132037028670311,
-0.23553501069545746,
-0.23050029575824738,
0.24016073346138,
-0.3704923689365387,
-0.5665673613548279,
0.40863052010536194,
0.33709049224853516,
0.12779061496257782,
-0.5553286671638489,
-0.34908053278923035,
-0.08783037215471268,
-0.2629796266555786,
0.6782756447792053,
0.1898876577615738,
-0.7051075100898743,
-0.2696550786495209,
0.016889717429876328,
0.20597249269485474,
-0.029462626203894615,
0.7646772861480713,
-0.8818679451942444,
0.444032222032547,
0.3446159362792969,
0.6869511604309082,
0.38502275943756104,
-0.2614929676055908,
0.4441671073436737,
-0.5409284234046936,
0.16876237094402313,
0.16006286442279816,
0.19249431788921356,
0.1774282157421112,
-0.05092333257198334,
0.3008307218551636,
0.38361042737960815,
-0.7225252389907837,
-0.8198891282081604,
0.1479358822107315,
-0.8803943991661072,
-0.3580130338668823,
1.0897157192230225,
-0.16568653285503387,
0.038921333849430084,
-0.09239644557237625,
-0.08509591966867447,
-0.0376165434718132,
-0.4552971124649048,
1.0338951349258423,
0.8362663984298706,
-0.08486540615558624,
-0.2090861201286316,
-0.33510369062423706,
0.4788477122783661,
0.41405194997787476,
-0.26039963960647583,
0.4414319694042206,
0.40084248781204224,
0.5168667435646057,
0.10709339380264282,
0.7047061920166016,
-0.00780369620770216,
0.17921793460845947,
-0.10494141280651093,
-0.2784581184387207,
0.1404007375240326,
-0.1732596606016159,
-0.35045722126960754,
-0.11496145278215408,
0.47350311279296875,
0.2798343300819397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02655v1
|
Calibrating the Confidence of Large Language Models by Eliciting Fidelity
| 2024-04-03T11:36:12 | 2024-04-03T11:36:12 |
Mozhi Zhang, Mianqiu Huang, Rundong Shi, Linsen Guo, Chong Peng, Peng Yan, Yaqian Zhou, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models optimized with techniques like RLHF have achieved good
alignment in being helpful and harmless. However, post-alignment, these
language models often exhibit overconfidence, where the expressed confidence
does not accurately calibrate with their correctness rate. In this paper, we
decompose the language model confidence into the \textit{Uncertainty} about the
question and the \textit{Fidelity} to the answer generated by language models.
Then, we propose a plug-and-play method to estimate the confidence of language
models. Our method has shown good calibration performance by conducting
experiments with 6 RLHF-LMs on four MCQA datasets. Moreover, we propose two
novel metrics, IPR and CE, to evaluate the calibration of the model, and we
have conducted a detailed discussion on \textit{Truly Well-Calibrated
Confidence}. Our method could serve as a strong baseline, and we hope that this
work will provide some insights into the model confidence calibration.
|
[
-0.4438794255256653,
-0.7050791382789612,
0.6908661723136902,
-0.21073222160339355,
0.05956359952688217,
0.09840106219053268,
-0.12735040485858917,
-0.4034564793109894,
-0.1094094067811966,
0.37083202600479126,
-0.2346002459526062,
-0.38040000200271606,
-0.5030344724655151,
-0.21090713143348694,
-0.29757070541381836,
0.6646924018859863,
-0.17262303829193115,
0.20149722695350647,
-0.3671148121356964,
-0.09209322184324265,
-0.3560487926006317,
-0.48426148295402527,
-0.14303359389305115,
-0.46297359466552734,
0.5080305933952332,
0.48101410269737244,
0.9528072476387024,
0.4370608329772949,
0.5503634214401245,
0.2298431247472763,
0.012305621057748795,
0.28832560777664185,
-0.5401596426963806,
0.01544805895537138,
-0.23223872482776642,
-0.5850059390068054,
-0.3542666733264923,
0.052797410637140274,
0.7434885501861572,
0.5445109605789185,
-0.4631994068622589,
0.3354420065879822,
0.062263373285532,
0.40318575501441956,
-0.9187517762184143,
0.17593799531459808,
-0.6287097334861755,
-0.2854381501674652,
0.1669258326292038,
-0.11632009595632553,
-0.669072687625885,
-0.6442973613739014,
0.04563001170754433,
-0.47958409786224365,
-0.2495550662279129,
0.22613157331943512,
0.8858111500740051,
0.17940568923950195,
-0.45442256331443787,
-0.07078436017036438,
-0.9190511107444763,
1.0899970531463623,
-0.9631932973861694,
0.4282315671443939,
0.530669629573822,
0.3188422620296478,
-0.2728525400161743,
-0.42103111743927,
-0.650583028793335,
-0.2311248928308487,
-0.011732498183846474,
0.02035951055586338,
0.34207868576049805,
-0.020920170471072197,
0.14379379153251648,
0.5421817302703857,
-0.6651288866996765,
-0.15358377993106842,
-0.07071433961391449,
-0.20362356305122375,
0.596491813659668,
-0.2341366708278656,
0.23569872975349426,
0.20297881960868835,
-0.1593160480260849,
-0.3269149661064148,
-0.7657975554466248,
0.1161576509475708,
0.6344451308250427,
0.2886718213558197,
0.1591104418039322,
0.7856837511062622,
0.11615822464227676,
0.5300585627555847,
0.05977526307106018,
-0.46618860960006714,
0.21294943988323212,
-0.3420884907245636,
-0.15463943779468536,
0.12660445272922516,
0.7837912440299988,
0.34528371691703796,
0.791740357875824,
0.09227220714092255,
-0.30673402547836304,
0.0009992442792281508,
0.33903899788856506,
-0.8085247278213501,
-0.12757384777069092,
0.5394850373268127,
-0.08537457138299942,
-0.20078888535499573,
0.35018858313560486,
-0.28432711958885193,
0.027917440980672836,
-0.12692475318908691,
0.6591816544532776,
-0.25858327746391296,
-0.4963001310825348,
0.08198847621679306,
0.3449382781982422,
0.3906336724758148,
0.20223800837993622,
-0.5422323346138,
0.2252998650074005,
0.8945197463035583,
0.4543784260749817,
-0.0775405615568161,
-0.21637944877147675,
-0.5752235054969788,
-0.06973724067211151,
-0.720454752445221,
0.44025447964668274,
-0.29267916083335876,
-0.5380601286888123,
0.18203003704547882,
0.002129131695255637,
-0.12140797823667526,
-0.26579150557518005,
0.6525388360023499,
-0.6582847833633423,
0.35933899879455566,
-0.4396362602710724,
-0.8767454624176025,
-0.1253471076488495,
0.49880459904670715,
-0.7279564142227173,
1.1777094602584839,
0.07641618698835373,
-0.862348198890686,
0.13624373078346252,
-0.07316914945840836,
-0.092534638941288,
-0.15809598565101624,
-0.16756312549114227,
-0.5225316286087036,
0.07701228559017181,
0.2009372115135193,
0.2143276035785675,
-0.25361868739128113,
0.5955204367637634,
-0.6438665986061096,
-0.4720509946346283,
0.7404453754425049,
-0.4677666127681732,
0.6679500341415405,
0.0892140343785286,
0.1042340099811554,
-0.22378262877464294,
-0.5474886298179626,
0.48659855127334595,
-0.35308584570884705,
-0.15806570649147034,
-0.22752094268798828,
0.002030234318226576,
-0.015626663342118263,
0.2652580142021179,
0.18085813522338867,
-0.6805521845817566,
-0.16032099723815918,
-0.6390480399131775,
0.13100536167621613,
0.30827024579048157,
0.13161258399486542,
0.38222742080688477,
-0.5086044669151306,
0.600322425365448,
-0.2457350194454193,
-0.045217033475637436,
-0.18296153843402863,
-0.45489946007728577,
-0.6632505059242249,
0.06992536038160324,
0.6432605981826782,
0.587211549282074,
-0.38683968782424927,
0.630035400390625,
-0.4522550404071808,
-0.6330458521842957,
-0.6333656907081604,
-0.010282891802489758,
0.5954917073249817,
0.689098596572876,
0.26239073276519775,
-0.2550981938838959,
-0.158080592751503,
-0.712383508682251,
-0.16389226913452148,
-0.6390181183815002,
-0.07478291541337967,
0.37882885336875916,
0.3942452669143677,
0.24516834318637848,
0.9748905301094055,
-0.3761686384677887,
0.13896654546260834,
0.18004681169986725,
0.43956971168518066,
0.09120488911867142,
0.6615526676177979,
0.28987744450569153,
-0.6895408630371094,
-0.6135354042053223,
0.030381103977560997,
-0.3447902500629425,
0.05842028185725212,
0.18718382716178894,
-0.17219527065753937,
0.2805141806602478,
0.5362917184829712,
-0.6990540027618408,
0.2346237450838089,
0.7978668808937073,
0.08528212457895279,
0.5912415981292725,
-0.08609211444854736,
0.6611793637275696,
-1.0753473043441772,
0.4681130647659302,
-0.23709936439990997,
-0.5361124873161316,
-0.42242756485939026,
0.40925729274749756,
0.39544394612312317,
0.32500192523002625,
-0.39373141527175903,
0.4803299009799957,
-0.4573269784450531,
0.06751558184623718,
-0.16194066405296326,
0.21871007978916168,
0.2516680955886841,
0.10498388111591339,
0.13179545104503632,
0.8099406361579895,
0.22201813757419586,
-0.4119305908679962,
0.19791962206363678,
0.09513137489557266,
-0.6392454504966736,
0.5692859888076782,
-0.7971795797348022,
0.1690024733543396,
-0.03235042467713356,
0.18251051008701324,
-1.3933137655258179,
-0.2137449085712433,
-0.12171585112810135,
-0.6276164650917053,
0.47325125336647034,
-0.23330913484096527,
-0.46504566073417664,
-0.308660626411438,
-0.17491166293621063,
0.7395253777503967,
0.4789333641529083,
-0.14036032557487488,
0.529143214225769,
0.5107396841049194,
-0.24704311788082123,
-0.7935824990272522,
-0.8197737336158752,
-0.22885218262672424,
-0.039335813373327255,
-0.5089409947395325,
0.34239453077316284,
-0.3352573812007904,
-0.25164252519607544,
-0.3282569348812103,
0.026009012013673782,
-0.10133124142885208,
-0.12145072966814041,
0.22547560930252075,
0.32249751687049866,
-0.39786458015441895,
0.19382092356681824,
-0.2440299093723297,
-0.17153780162334442,
0.12237997353076935,
-0.007633367087692022,
0.4904734194278717,
-0.04796815663576126,
-0.941494882106781,
-0.2915225028991699,
0.0960979163646698,
0.726028561592102,
-0.39259520173072815,
0.6877913475036621,
0.4047873020172119,
-0.48055341839790344,
0.11836304515600204,
-0.9362682700157166,
-0.2820666432380676,
-0.3994559943675995,
0.30334943532943726,
-0.24471761286258698,
-0.7242425680160522,
0.624204158782959,
0.21712873876094818,
0.1384369134902954,
0.23963366448879242,
0.525633692741394,
0.04804392531514168,
1.1794030666351318,
0.6626797914505005,
-0.03153649717569351,
0.1559077650308609,
0.22978170216083527,
0.30145812034606934,
-0.5183067321777344,
-0.1271762251853943,
-0.7402811050415039,
-0.15775485336780548,
-0.49571987986564636,
-0.609271228313446,
0.05430698022246361,
0.13769559562206268,
-0.44745486974716187,
0.37443414330482483,
-0.02412709780037403,
0.5324785709381104,
0.5124954581260681,
0.019944678992033005,
0.31031760573387146,
-0.311423122882843,
-0.2557092010974884,
-0.23010721802711487,
-0.4128834009170532,
-0.48751121759414673,
0.9642595648765564,
0.7133305072784424,
1.0582574605941772,
0.19858282804489136,
0.43216797709465027,
-0.3179972469806671,
0.3269806504249573,
-0.8913524746894836,
0.08348507434129715,
0.2025667130947113,
-0.7802167534828186,
-0.4520663619041443,
-0.4815782904624939,
-0.280962198972702,
-0.19716617465019226,
-0.1680343896150589,
-0.810806930065155,
0.46402841806411743,
0.4241170585155487,
-0.6126886606216431,
-0.08137726783752441,
-0.48183122277259827,
0.7731366157531738,
0.06870633363723755,
-0.14551328122615814,
0.011981437914073467,
-0.620510995388031,
0.6774778366088867,
-0.30729031562805176,
0.2963015139102936,
-0.10152341425418854,
0.06863649189472198,
0.3328908681869507,
-0.3594955801963806,
0.43265584111213684,
0.1316491812467575,
-0.5354945063591003,
0.4807966947555542,
0.4446141719818115,
0.7074755430221558,
0.11057954281568527,
-0.5113590359687805,
-0.13591818511486053,
0.4534415006637573,
-0.17516398429870605,
-0.6749951243400574,
0.631195604801178,
-0.530491292476654,
-0.19807374477386475,
-0.3459925651550293,
-0.6143640279769897,
-0.4484138786792755,
0.07728862017393112,
0.34698382019996643,
0.3167884349822998,
-0.4724874794483185,
0.4085257947444916,
0.9217331409454346,
-0.13349401950836182,
0.3903527557849884,
0.3750123083591461,
-0.49843671917915344,
-0.46966737508773804,
0.4453999102115631,
0.19579964876174927,
0.9166606664657593,
0.6172219514846802,
0.022624148055911064,
-0.6204569339752197,
-0.040559105575084686,
-0.41924166679382324,
0.07741712033748627,
-0.5028112530708313,
-0.40009239315986633,
-0.3990028202533722,
-0.502407431602478,
-0.4661765694618225,
0.06522771716117859,
-0.7754151225090027,
-0.38324812054634094,
-0.17174620926380157,
-0.08531240373849869,
0.20419907569885254,
0.3106052577495575,
0.22687695920467377,
0.40865129232406616,
-0.8190252780914307,
0.019595863297581673,
0.2095576673746109,
0.40439170598983765,
-0.08878301084041595,
-0.8722609281539917,
-0.2034546583890915,
0.4793826639652252,
0.0479460135102272,
-0.7361623644828796,
0.3037263751029968,
0.4128439426422119,
0.42016568779945374,
0.34936338663101196,
0.26879939436912537,
0.8256508111953735,
-0.5580571293830872,
0.7332973480224609,
0.06807862967252731,
-0.9567543268203735,
0.08744467794895172,
-0.025995366275310516,
0.332825630903244,
0.8790940046310425,
0.37904807925224304,
-0.4292713701725006,
-0.41917821764945984,
-0.47589582204818726,
-0.5059590935707092,
0.2496926486492157,
0.01990785449743271,
0.29782745242118835,
0.1547360122203827,
0.34808340668678284,
-0.24832381308078766,
0.23150674998760223,
-0.6906995177268982,
-0.15777114033699036,
0.04371212050318718,
-0.43438324332237244,
-0.2746948003768921,
-0.46490103006362915,
-0.2350824922323227,
-0.016484102234244347,
0.8282299041748047,
-0.21290454268455505,
-0.03358393535017967,
0.1517508327960968,
-0.1364220827817917,
-0.5992927551269531,
0.21598947048187256,
0.40538033843040466,
0.8966659903526306,
-0.3998798131942749,
0.22297543287277222,
0.11304983496665955,
-0.5135388970375061,
0.20784641802310944,
-0.07585247606039047,
-0.21948251128196716,
-0.041736900806427,
0.37954798340797424,
0.25724124908447266,
0.3567413091659546,
-0.6107526421546936,
0.8735193610191345,
-0.10245408862829208,
-0.14056673645973206,
-0.32359784841537476,
0.07339701801538467,
0.24629440903663635,
-0.03896671533584595,
0.05466723069548607,
-0.3693532943725586,
-0.08877020329236984,
-0.4281326234340668,
0.49264758825302124,
0.7285234332084656,
-0.6209673285484314,
-0.03628452494740486,
0.26355770230293274,
-0.1949763000011444,
-0.24235594272613525,
0.365253210067749,
-0.14646098017692566,
-0.48255282640457153,
0.4306949973106384,
0.626488983631134,
0.6991993188858032,
-0.5960253477096558,
0.08526335656642914,
0.6590856313705444,
0.3864251673221588,
-0.580446720123291,
0.39406439661979675,
0.3737473785877228,
-0.9720042943954468,
-0.8402262330055237,
-0.745498538017273,
-0.5623191595077515,
0.02703111618757248,
-0.8019852638244629,
0.3273695111274719,
-0.09143567085266113,
-0.3010232448577881,
-0.34433427453041077,
0.04926631227135658,
-0.3235097825527191,
0.2800523638725281,
-0.130891814827919,
1.010316252708435,
-0.9143031239509583,
0.9026690125465393,
0.354065865278244,
-0.24016043543815613,
-1.2400792837142944,
0.18254652619361877,
-0.20226290822029114,
-0.681138813495636,
0.11961344629526138,
0.12193243950605392,
-0.3483993113040924,
0.21312396228313446,
-0.6081495881080627,
-1.1430798768997192,
0.8458550572395325,
0.41859132051467896,
-0.5994272232055664,
0.14160674810409546,
0.17086908221244812,
0.37590327858924866,
-0.4275070130825043,
0.5415902733802795,
0.5026393532752991,
0.4966358542442322,
0.32163700461387634,
-1.0517172813415527,
-0.035605594515800476,
-0.13427624106407166,
0.035939980298280716,
0.11082328110933304,
-0.17889751493930817,
0.8688628673553467,
-0.11198796331882477,
-0.1954939067363739,
0.3714175820350647,
0.6851667761802673,
0.3574795126914978,
-0.10862784832715988,
0.45350638031959534,
0.5421865582466125,
0.6433128714561462,
-0.06716527044773102,
0.6462706923484802,
-0.6437310576438904,
0.7225098013877869,
1.2918082475662231,
-0.3634410798549652,
1.3565075397491455,
0.7154044508934021,
-0.2711675465106964,
0.4712541401386261,
0.5435335040092468,
0.25520896911621094,
0.2352539300918579,
0.2563721835613251,
-0.14503931999206543,
-0.5130736827850342,
-0.13907651603221893,
-0.3370985984802246,
0.2786828279495239,
0.32003122568130493,
-0.27656203508377075,
-0.07218271493911743,
-0.3209206461906433,
0.06320087611675262,
0.16323456168174744,
-0.046677280217409134,
0.5587303042411804,
0.3262364864349365,
-1.081152081489563,
0.5758306384086609,
0.0017727200174704194,
0.30375680327415466,
-0.43335774540901184,
-0.09993364661931992,
0.07646697759628296,
0.2228076010942459,
-0.14238378405570984,
-0.9809427261352539,
0.1152142584323883,
-0.29302486777305603,
0.07543054968118668,
0.12384214252233505,
0.4562927782535553,
-0.829619288444519,
-0.7370019555091858,
0.10150421410799026,
0.6036413908004761,
0.09554775804281235,
-0.22537663578987122,
-0.48842760920524597,
0.050798285752534866,
-0.23121152818202972,
-0.219892680644989,
-0.061632800847291946,
0.37508875131607056,
0.3561634123325348,
0.6261124610900879,
0.47867491841316223,
0.019757458940148354,
-0.27886536717414856,
0.02436952106654644,
0.3279903531074524,
-0.19442391395568848,
-0.20036683976650238,
-0.8657411336898804,
0.6880200505256653,
0.11361183226108551,
-0.29349425435066223,
0.5385748147964478,
0.4733443856239319,
0.7650289535522461,
0.13218529522418976,
0.45132508873939514,
0.15651467442512512,
0.6668328642845154,
-0.48111972212791443,
0.7850795984268188,
-0.48894205689430237,
0.20052720606327057,
-0.56657874584198,
-1.0351955890655518,
-0.37394875288009644,
0.8103559017181396,
-0.1773684173822403,
0.24023304879665375,
0.7009745240211487,
1.275073766708374,
-0.3149237334728241,
-0.16022060811519623,
0.46553510427474976,
0.2281973510980606,
0.1271926462650299,
0.4452124834060669,
0.6081751585006714,
-0.5687767267227173,
0.3755303621292114,
-0.3929350674152374,
-0.2911822497844696,
-0.24129728972911835,
-1.4369699954986572,
-0.4996257722377777,
-0.4864692986011505,
-0.36670032143592834,
-0.6328281164169312,
-0.14780806005001068,
0.881489098072052,
0.7711900472640991,
-1.225415587425232,
-0.29057982563972473,
-0.14529715478420258,
-0.006960349623113871,
-0.06791733205318451,
-0.1638880968093872,
0.34056851267814636,
-0.158322274684906,
-0.7137451171875,
-0.028632311150431633,
0.00028964606462977827,
0.28370094299316406,
-0.6554726362228394,
-0.15914286673069,
-0.28166258335113525,
0.44709596037864685,
0.14120188355445862,
0.2943885028362274,
-0.6870079040527344,
-0.6331316232681274,
0.2161213755607605,
-0.5010011792182922,
-0.08247911185026169,
0.34547460079193115,
-0.46704432368278503,
0.4009599983692169,
0.4983914792537689,
0.6824308037757874,
0.25895175337791443,
0.39259010553359985,
0.9952391386032104,
-0.8065722584724426,
-0.2235623151063919,
0.20578515529632568,
0.3606226146221161,
0.3749052584171295,
-0.2801814675331116,
0.1854926198720932,
-0.2545676827430725,
-0.8639805912971497,
-1.1322245597839355,
0.3496483266353607,
-0.7170257568359375,
0.003111758269369602,
1.0323562622070312,
-0.429326593875885,
-0.07182949781417847,
-0.07457223534584045,
-0.09113931655883789,
0.2807130217552185,
-0.15411899983882904,
0.7284743189811707,
1.122435450553894,
0.37534263730049133,
-0.10065935552120209,
-0.6123452186584473,
0.5103416442871094,
0.3396451771259308,
-0.5781564712524414,
0.21985386312007904,
0.30641499161720276,
0.2304418832063675,
0.49699026346206665,
0.3876190781593323,
-0.3692125380039215,
0.34700876474380493,
-0.14665953814983368,
0.17117512226104736,
0.38530606031417847,
-0.3035021424293518,
-0.13870148360729218,
0.08759049326181412,
0.6168668270111084,
0.1311826854944229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02650v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02650v1
|
Towards detecting unanticipated bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T11:25:20 | 2024-04-03T11:25:20 |
Anna Kruspe
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Over the last year, Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have become
widely available and have exhibited fairness issues similar to those in
previous machine learning systems. Current research is primarily focused on
analyzing and quantifying these biases in training data and their impact on the
decisions of these models, alongside developing mitigation strategies. This
research largely targets well-known biases related to gender, race, ethnicity,
and language. However, it is clear that LLMs are also affected by other, less
obvious implicit biases. The complex and often opaque nature of these models
makes detecting such biases challenging, yet this is crucial due to their
potential negative impact in various applications. In this paper, we explore
new avenues for detecting these unanticipated biases in LLMs, focusing
specifically on Uncertainty Quantification and Explainable AI methods. These
approaches aim to assess the certainty of model decisions and to make the
internal decision-making processes of LLMs more transparent, thereby
identifying and understanding biases that are not immediately apparent. Through
this research, we aim to contribute to the development of fairer and more
transparent AI systems.
|
[
-0.38966822624206543,
-0.7548795342445374,
0.7479513883590698,
0.045004766434431076,
0.2447981834411621,
0.12265082448720932,
-0.41011250019073486,
-0.2755010426044464,
-0.2285006195306778,
0.3636607825756073,
-0.6396579146385193,
-0.3707062005996704,
-0.8148160576820374,
-0.3457845151424408,
-0.4486903250217438,
0.8874813914299011,
-0.06941016763448715,
0.2679276168346405,
-0.1564704030752182,
-0.20171773433685303,
-0.6118576526641846,
-0.5470405220985413,
-0.8994891047477722,
-0.5914090275764465,
0.016980215907096863,
0.15348660945892334,
0.6465400457382202,
0.22517378628253937,
0.23486746847629547,
0.28944164514541626,
-0.18206998705863953,
0.035408876836299896,
-0.2976458966732025,
0.0295358095318079,
-0.020052388310432434,
-0.747758686542511,
-0.374871164560318,
-0.05785532668232918,
0.7309011220932007,
0.7847961783409119,
-0.05937863886356354,
0.24000325798988342,
0.3543773293495178,
0.6431406736373901,
-0.840057373046875,
0.42024171352386475,
-0.8045355677604675,
0.354859322309494,
-0.344178169965744,
0.01126173697412014,
-0.48479944467544556,
-0.19955554604530334,
-0.035863105207681656,
-0.2943345010280609,
0.19363632798194885,
-0.01934097893536091,
0.481795072555542,
0.42577826976776123,
-0.4111079275608063,
-0.38507652282714844,
-0.7421643137931824,
0.9496103525161743,
-0.9156816601753235,
0.4210147261619568,
0.28936031460762024,
0.3587225079536438,
-0.4740409255027771,
-0.3930269181728363,
-0.6838611960411072,
-0.19593115150928497,
-0.06712611764669418,
-0.1657000333070755,
-0.39766907691955566,
0.1447460651397705,
0.2656542658805847,
0.1238316223025322,
-0.357383668422699,
0.42891496419906616,
0.07852345705032349,
-0.3643764555454254,
0.5588014125823975,
-0.11165568977594376,
0.26645341515541077,
0.0467941053211689,
0.06537917256355286,
0.21761997044086456,
-0.7109869718551636,
0.014883722178637981,
0.7192786931991577,
0.2477957010269165,
-0.2686377465724945,
0.6743380427360535,
-0.17065247893333435,
0.3897820711135864,
0.044612009078264236,
0.13713766634464264,
0.18831342458724976,
0.021298810839653015,
-0.12550291419029236,
0.09227291494607925,
0.7102901935577393,
0.04497509449720383,
0.6128475069999695,
-0.000238500811974518,
-0.3032647371292114,
0.1248059943318367,
-0.146351620554924,
-0.514543354511261,
-0.08313538134098053,
0.3546801209449768,
-0.48634636402130127,
-0.321982204914093,
-0.3268088400363922,
-0.8004176020622253,
-0.8432419896125793,
-0.19095982611179352,
0.2511807382106781,
-0.26087063550949097,
-0.4625151455402374,
-0.06382469087839127,
0.00995893869549036,
0.30248764157295227,
0.4782414436340332,
-0.844093382358551,
0.007395406253635883,
0.7910512089729309,
0.6013424396514893,
-0.09296655654907227,
-0.017810089513659477,
-0.36649760603904724,
0.05508608743548393,
-0.2924306094646454,
0.5618617534637451,
-0.5872385501861572,
-0.15448027849197388,
0.01040721032768488,
-0.30424875020980835,
0.1682206243276596,
-0.5223102569580078,
0.6433866620063782,
-0.3896799385547638,
0.44553351402282715,
-0.03302827849984169,
-0.6601963043212891,
-0.2429485023021698,
0.4429180920124054,
-0.4456111192703247,
0.8669285178184509,
0.08148025721311569,
-1.1157402992248535,
0.5186156034469604,
-0.8637377619743347,
-0.040558915585279465,
-0.10933897644281387,
-0.5795252919197083,
-0.6352808475494385,
0.13908852636814117,
0.4674290418624878,
0.36279523372650146,
-0.2415289580821991,
0.5655813217163086,
-0.5032542943954468,
-0.2877902388572693,
0.4322960078716278,
-1.0897397994995117,
0.8707064986228943,
0.1551051288843155,
-0.6835111379623413,
0.18732184171676636,
-0.5345169305801392,
0.12137702852487564,
0.026048367843031883,
-0.11277361214160919,
-0.22758346796035767,
0.2135714739561081,
-0.21865835785865784,
0.13379521667957306,
0.21409395337104797,
-0.3213103413581848,
-0.08402658253908157,
-0.2544941306114197,
0.41268911957740784,
1.161335825920105,
-0.2916660010814667,
0.5421457886695862,
-0.02799491211771965,
0.5671828389167786,
0.2742098569869995,
0.30392003059387207,
-0.07040367275476456,
-0.4282701313495636,
-1.1179453134536743,
-0.25918048620224,
0.5056169629096985,
0.4548136293888092,
-0.6829514503479004,
0.27578261494636536,
-0.07967513054609299,
-0.04710518941283226,
-0.8850411772727966,
0.03796263039112091,
0.312391996383667,
0.38767796754837036,
0.04261479154229164,
-0.02493910863995552,
-0.44361045956611633,
-1.0411285161972046,
-0.4873371720314026,
-0.2590427100658417,
-0.3171886205673218,
0.3153504729270935,
0.518589198589325,
-0.31633368134498596,
1.0888444185256958,
-0.24153858423233032,
-0.07118300348520279,
-0.07723958045244217,
0.13456711173057556,
0.1020551323890686,
0.5162293314933777,
0.29000723361968994,
-0.8380034565925598,
-0.2620857059955597,
0.07182139158248901,
-0.8387935757637024,
-0.2190982550382614,
-0.014433887787163258,
0.14840944111347198,
0.38639119267463684,
0.7363731265068054,
-0.511554479598999,
0.5437037348747253,
0.5827704071998596,
-0.21674089133739471,
0.29671981930732727,
-0.10050196945667267,
0.1336435079574585,
-0.683269739151001,
0.011635415256023407,
0.05966929346323013,
-0.25204116106033325,
-0.43947628140449524,
-0.20471927523612976,
0.07568112015724182,
0.21614407002925873,
-0.4525296688079834,
0.6600918173789978,
-0.4753430485725403,
-0.29175299406051636,
-0.20001086592674255,
0.07587586343288422,
-0.20674704015254974,
0.46590742468833923,
-0.017035508528351784,
0.7705816626548767,
0.4792889952659607,
-0.3503435552120209,
-0.012089118361473083,
-0.1127132698893547,
-0.44505271315574646,
0.5323640704154968,
-0.5220873951911926,
0.08953149616718292,
-0.46162179112434387,
0.31025266647338867,
-0.8754270672798157,
-0.015554476529359818,
0.4887344539165497,
-0.8461127281188965,
0.15741144120693207,
-0.5434446334838867,
-0.32989501953125,
-0.2999781370162964,
-0.12586526572704315,
0.5882852077484131,
0.45036065578460693,
-0.4822912812232971,
0.5391013622283936,
0.5302553176879883,
-0.1049986481666565,
-0.9867483973503113,
-0.640015721321106,
-0.21506525576114655,
-0.5063783526420593,
-0.49075549840927124,
-0.09560354053974152,
0.017392314970493317,
-0.6479731202125549,
-0.2759089469909668,
-0.026548121124505997,
-0.17349916696548462,
0.37165048718452454,
0.3504289388656616,
0.27201125025749207,
-0.17020602524280548,
0.080699622631073,
-0.0573880709707737,
-0.016203569248318672,
0.23422181606292725,
-0.42555275559425354,
0.7619630098342896,
-0.22684833407402039,
-0.7658289670944214,
-0.4383940100669861,
0.08364305645227432,
0.40640532970428467,
-0.25246530771255493,
0.7370069026947021,
0.8039215803146362,
-0.5079076886177063,
-0.3913632035255432,
-0.6364931464195251,
-0.19332736730575562,
-0.523123025894165,
0.48616746068000793,
-0.043237242847681046,
-1.073968768119812,
0.7794881463050842,
-0.006346210837364197,
-0.012285693548619747,
0.23313720524311066,
0.8516923189163208,
0.08091580867767334,
1.2811866998672485,
0.655440092086792,
-0.25906404852867126,
0.5089829564094543,
0.10654972493648529,
0.43385404348373413,
-0.6840817928314209,
-0.2651042640209198,
-0.5137916803359985,
-0.10724471509456635,
-1.0341436862945557,
-0.5746544003486633,
0.5107290744781494,
-0.09895599633455276,
-0.3735894560813904,
-0.5457131266593933,
-0.28159448504447937,
0.6895506978034973,
0.6320971250534058,
-0.039623409509658813,
0.2466011494398117,
-0.27725377678871155,
-0.026931894943118095,
0.16131164133548737,
-0.616619348526001,
-0.647106945514679,
1.2529860734939575,
0.6467179656028748,
0.6697220802307129,
0.007669790647923946,
0.3033287525177002,
0.5604355931282043,
0.427761048078537,
-0.6802712678909302,
0.2329990565776825,
0.23803603649139404,
-0.8734880685806274,
-0.43887990713119507,
-0.6297206282615662,
-0.8518361449241638,
0.39018774032592773,
-0.3407371938228607,
-0.856546938419342,
0.08787941187620163,
0.30259689688682556,
-0.13110566139221191,
0.554267942905426,
-0.754248857498169,
0.7838191986083984,
-0.13201773166656494,
-0.31439733505249023,
0.09538964927196503,
-0.41885435581207275,
0.6528752446174622,
-0.30682140588760376,
0.49700599908828735,
-0.33217930793762207,
0.17548316717147827,
0.6108436584472656,
-0.04796922206878662,
0.903175950050354,
-0.2713003158569336,
-0.3527788817882538,
0.11547471582889557,
0.16994787752628326,
0.5228180885314941,
0.1709115207195282,
-0.22477900981903076,
0.4327702820301056,
-0.34351110458374023,
-0.4645785391330719,
-0.49381381273269653,
0.4804534614086151,
-0.662085235118866,
-0.4840850830078125,
-0.42408907413482666,
-0.7080801725387573,
-0.44337770342826843,
0.21475327014923096,
0.14939157664775848,
-0.12122192233800888,
-0.20418521761894226,
-0.25468379259109497,
0.8663708567619324,
-0.604228138923645,
0.4037761390209198,
0.6457753777503967,
-0.11310809850692749,
0.15648776292800903,
0.555859386920929,
-0.07508821040391922,
0.14997723698616028,
0.21254940330982208,
0.10791733115911484,
-0.20711036026477814,
-0.8521180152893066,
-0.23303475975990295,
-0.023650959134101868,
-0.5023953914642334,
-0.08477343618869781,
-0.4241332709789276,
-0.2777460217475891,
-0.5337536931037903,
0.12845398485660553,
-0.5169353485107422,
-0.3241828978061676,
-0.14426946640014648,
0.06784684956073761,
0.1515655368566513,
0.698640763759613,
-0.06356243789196014,
0.6194156408309937,
-0.397463858127594,
0.02846398577094078,
0.14108102023601532,
0.46773576736450195,
0.23583051562309265,
-0.6402564644813538,
0.04947638884186745,
0.37299180030822754,
-0.26179298758506775,
-0.3952263295650482,
0.48570865392684937,
-0.20203731954097748,
0.6749452352523804,
0.6039975881576538,
0.06808674335479736,
0.23320184648036957,
-0.5647429823875427,
0.620701789855957,
-0.023035718128085136,
-1.1643093824386597,
0.5329724550247192,
-0.42849263548851013,
-0.004338153172284365,
0.4050401747226715,
0.4119124114513397,
-0.6618155837059021,
-0.428375780582428,
-0.6145449876785278,
-0.6695995330810547,
0.7208356857299805,
0.36551550030708313,
0.06300751119852066,
0.2045748382806778,
0.24067802727222443,
0.06049336493015289,
0.4795228838920593,
-0.9873265624046326,
-0.3305093050003052,
0.31134939193725586,
-0.2287968248128891,
-0.042520564049482346,
-0.1014852374792099,
-0.00042013052734546363,
0.10020741075277328,
0.7088832855224609,
-0.1717226505279541,
0.20542165637016296,
-0.30246540904045105,
-0.18763452768325806,
0.1530487984418869,
0.5534960627555847,
0.3762628138065338,
0.6278451681137085,
-0.27681204676628113,
0.09631799906492233,
0.19362947344779968,
-0.21951019763946533,
0.07376918196678162,
0.00967647135257721,
-0.38919973373413086,
-0.09762170910835266,
0.5455228090286255,
0.7105765342712402,
-0.21571969985961914,
-0.899776041507721,
0.8541575074195862,
-0.09825020283460617,
0.15798114240169525,
-0.6284525394439697,
0.0403178334236145,
-0.09853086620569229,
0.46205994486808777,
0.0510258711874485,
0.0032439748756587505,
0.1847846806049347,
-0.5451676249504089,
0.07787833362817764,
0.86678147315979,
-0.694363534450531,
-0.04756319522857666,
0.5668870806694031,
0.16969938576221466,
-0.20497724413871765,
0.8129347562789917,
-0.08400757610797882,
-0.6876189112663269,
0.6793778538703918,
0.14423814415931702,
0.6503201127052307,
-0.26789748668670654,
0.21318797767162323,
-0.17161765694618225,
0.5537687540054321,
-0.047090448439121246,
-0.07389824092388153,
0.09220249205827713,
-1.0893281698226929,
-0.33935755491256714,
-0.44321370124816895,
-0.39287543296813965,
0.2517142593860626,
-0.5936694145202637,
0.3217090964317322,
-0.2742653489112854,
-0.11144749075174332,
0.10572931170463562,
-0.24369901418685913,
-0.6452683210372925,
-0.11635269224643707,
0.5249952673912048,
0.6139147877693176,
-1.0134590864181519,
0.7316440939903259,
0.2093750238418579,
-0.1732226312160492,
-0.5686154961585999,
0.13261444866657257,
0.22611452639102936,
-1.3684465885162354,
0.6138372421264648,
0.05085025727748871,
0.10660650581121445,
-0.2644236981868744,
-0.5398873686790466,
-0.5501734614372253,
0.7781509757041931,
0.6021382212638855,
-0.46633657813072205,
-0.07555551826953888,
0.4406339228153229,
0.3557269275188446,
-0.06907423585653305,
0.6598610877990723,
0.8538259863853455,
0.6444664001464844,
-0.15830174088478088,
-1.0262484550476074,
-0.15300916135311127,
0.02023337595164776,
-0.10556028038263321,
0.44433754682540894,
-0.5875333547592163,
0.9490164518356323,
-0.11243076622486115,
-0.05474996939301491,
-0.22294430434703827,
0.46724259853363037,
0.26468467712402344,
0.48853692412376404,
0.48539701104164124,
0.33305788040161133,
1.0544966459274292,
-0.09786351025104523,
0.8497956395149231,
0.035355743020772934,
0.29457104206085205,
1.1967777013778687,
-0.3131351172924042,
0.4996706545352936,
0.5561049580574036,
-0.30136439204216003,
0.16207009553909302,
0.7026844620704651,
0.13679510354995728,
0.13541212677955627,
0.660964846611023,
-0.5693827271461487,
-0.18841049075126648,
-0.3015384376049042,
-0.3473995625972748,
0.5798692107200623,
0.6070894598960876,
-0.3268587291240692,
-0.21852578222751617,
0.03962649777531624,
0.3771573007106781,
-0.07837800681591034,
-0.5068483352661133,
0.5871745347976685,
-0.002310357056558132,
-0.5183226466178894,
0.25552618503570557,
0.1654682755470276,
1.1235405206680298,
-0.5791351199150085,
-0.010588751174509525,
-0.4578096866607666,
0.2952324450016022,
-0.18408557772636414,
-0.8775508999824524,
0.04678712785243988,
-0.010001856833696365,
-0.12822803854942322,
-0.017698194831609726,
0.5871827602386475,
-0.5037099123001099,
-0.4989274740219116,
0.18282102048397064,
0.8247440457344055,
0.011326907202601433,
-0.3509138226509094,
-0.8265356421470642,
0.1826535016298294,
0.29342329502105713,
0.0016763674793764949,
0.32595735788345337,
0.7969860434532166,
-0.4102034568786621,
1.1187357902526855,
0.3872235119342804,
0.08918212354183197,
0.039598748087882996,
-0.05372092127799988,
0.5690982341766357,
-0.34709060192108154,
-0.4137673079967499,
-1.0826064348220825,
0.20412921905517578,
-0.02373647503554821,
-0.017215002328157425,
0.7900316119194031,
0.40733397006988525,
0.9223650097846985,
0.141933873295784,
1.0040881633758545,
0.15973256528377533,
0.418489009141922,
-0.5812369585037231,
0.9180317521095276,
-0.3194042146205902,
0.6811167597770691,
-0.2129785269498825,
-0.6317931413650513,
-0.234786257147789,
0.53279709815979,
-0.40306344628334045,
0.34082868695259094,
0.28323233127593994,
0.8980476260185242,
-0.13654224574565887,
0.07096928358078003,
0.14382849633693695,
0.2296307384967804,
0.5072749257087708,
0.5649744272232056,
1.166512131690979,
-0.18924580514431,
0.4077451527118683,
0.06671253591775894,
-0.2601971924304962,
-0.014672216959297657,
-1.1150386333465576,
-0.9183213114738464,
-0.3485754430294037,
-0.28723961114883423,
-0.2570951581001282,
0.11561884731054306,
0.7556185126304626,
0.7551938891410828,
-1.0314058065414429,
-0.22885148227214813,
-0.12152296304702759,
0.6599483489990234,
0.29465052485466003,
-0.23659659922122955,
0.3835689425468445,
-0.2231171727180481,
-0.8255389928817749,
-0.04490033909678459,
-0.026121076196432114,
0.21263954043388367,
-0.3111218810081482,
-0.08416453748941422,
0.021520718932151794,
0.14247547090053558,
0.5337742567062378,
0.1840859055519104,
-0.5509368181228638,
-0.2797697186470032,
-0.6267145872116089,
0.3371100425720215,
-0.002474400447681546,
0.8055329322814941,
-0.6796058416366577,
0.17644928395748138,
0.2410287708044052,
0.702197253704071,
0.31918877363204956,
-0.34625375270843506,
0.7511389851570129,
-0.8698074817657471,
0.33268100023269653,
0.44406524300575256,
0.300893098115921,
0.39462119340896606,
-0.35492005944252014,
0.6132116317749023,
-0.11301149427890778,
-0.5631186962127686,
-1.0360935926437378,
0.11206725239753723,
-0.619413435459137,
-0.39107659459114075,
1.1359002590179443,
-0.13129758834838867,
0.00020952564955223352,
-0.1259079873561859,
0.008202710188925266,
0.24747702479362488,
-0.33004283905029297,
0.8645449280738831,
0.7534126043319702,
-0.20284123718738556,
-0.01229213085025549,
-0.9130703210830688,
0.5728438496589661,
0.48794466257095337,
-0.9118436574935913,
0.37011876702308655,
0.5753665566444397,
0.28422585129737854,
-0.28731444478034973,
0.6002786159515381,
-0.20539340376853943,
-0.026881495490670204,
-0.23150718212127686,
0.2015460580587387,
0.2964276373386383,
0.02308989129960537,
-0.4867275655269623,
-0.05108843371272087,
0.26337727904319763,
-0.12915468215942383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02625v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02625v1
|
A Differentiable Integer Linear Programming Solver for Explanation-Based Natural Language Inference
| 2024-04-03T10:29:06 | 2024-04-03T10:29:06 |
Mokanarangan Thayaparan, Marco Valentino, André Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Integer Linear Programming (ILP) has been proposed as a formalism for
encoding precise structural and semantic constraints for Natural Language
Inference (NLI). However, traditional ILP frameworks are non-differentiable,
posing critical challenges for the integration of continuous language
representations based on deep learning. In this paper, we introduce a novel
approach, named Diff-Comb Explainer, a neuro-symbolic architecture for
explanation-based NLI based on Differentiable BlackBox Combinatorial Solvers
(DBCS). Differently from existing neuro-symbolic solvers, Diff-Comb Explainer
does not necessitate a continuous relaxation of the semantic constraints,
enabling a direct, more precise, and efficient incorporation of neural
representations into the ILP formulation. Our experiments demonstrate that
Diff-Comb Explainer achieves superior performance when compared to conventional
ILP solvers, neuro-symbolic black-box solvers, and Transformer-based encoders.
Moreover, a deeper analysis reveals that Diff-Comb Explainer can significantly
improve the precision, consistency, and faithfulness of the constructed
explanations, opening new opportunities for research on neuro-symbolic
architectures for explainable and transparent NLI in complex domains.
|
[
-0.5448042154312134,
-0.533069372177124,
0.44533535838127136,
0.4684843122959137,
-0.0482412613928318,
0.1472931206226349,
-0.28748083114624023,
-0.18861781060695648,
-0.07182033360004425,
-0.15263447165489197,
-1.0827924013137817,
-0.06301795691251755,
-0.6726372838020325,
0.2621344029903412,
-0.17366546392440796,
0.7156115770339966,
-0.032947853207588196,
0.20476585626602173,
-0.14464545249938965,
0.0800117552280426,
-0.30170154571533203,
-0.2809438109397888,
-0.639687716960907,
-0.7257516384124756,
0.5715832710266113,
-0.13973692059516907,
0.6515789031982422,
0.32405659556388855,
0.3460593521595001,
0.3548753261566162,
-0.10654749721288681,
0.2607601284980774,
-0.26548588275909424,
-0.3545414209365845,
-0.39757153391838074,
-0.615655779838562,
0.008958795107901096,
-0.3870227336883545,
0.4090784192085266,
1.190168023109436,
-0.36093273758888245,
-0.29466482996940613,
-0.15834349393844604,
0.8293645977973938,
-0.6522150039672852,
0.07591107487678528,
-0.851961612701416,
0.24474386870861053,
0.17076106369495392,
-0.013375974260270596,
-0.5439853072166443,
-0.324434369802475,
0.06753062456846237,
-0.6849269866943359,
0.1721113622188568,
-0.2671165466308594,
0.8105257153511047,
0.7718967199325562,
-0.32560715079307556,
-0.36243364214897156,
-0.9472329616546631,
0.8346974849700928,
-1.293358325958252,
0.3168237805366516,
0.03433794900774956,
0.5380150079727173,
-0.3758084774017334,
-0.567247211933136,
-1.0719473361968994,
0.25887569785118103,
-0.31118667125701904,
-0.013315760530531406,
-0.2672933042049408,
0.21223656833171844,
0.2705480754375458,
0.37035277485847473,
-0.6395395398139954,
0.15830408036708832,
-0.22438471019268036,
0.06153053045272827,
0.6605255603790283,
0.049633804708719254,
0.15808291733264923,
0.11509664356708527,
0.04101241007447243,
0.16970941424369812,
-0.21074070036411285,
0.031578995287418365,
0.20056012272834778,
-0.08108349144458771,
-0.2075236439704895,
0.08144478499889374,
-0.045962024480104446,
0.7987825870513916,
0.25139275193214417,
-0.1481572538614273,
0.26971006393432617,
0.02886219695210457,
-0.3510001599788666,
0.1784399449825287,
0.4393950402736664,
0.12196020781993866,
0.2490665316581726,
-0.3972174823284149,
-0.012873401865363121,
0.4521082639694214,
0.17447485029697418,
-0.8546279668807983,
-0.07482905685901642,
0.2741938531398773,
-0.66426682472229,
-0.20721906423568726,
-0.2745397984981537,
-0.9114298820495605,
-0.12866345047950745,
-0.6869474053382874,
0.1927901655435562,
-0.6229380965232849,
-0.2532959282398224,
0.6335164904594421,
-0.17272451519966125,
0.4280000329017639,
0.34280824661254883,
-0.9917507767677307,
0.6025518774986267,
0.8726226687431335,
0.6484166979789734,
-0.038753099739551544,
-0.059058137238025665,
-0.4448021948337555,
-0.08679760247468948,
-0.2840363383293152,
0.4638034403324127,
-0.9386113286018372,
0.08748283237218857,
-0.037642478942871094,
-0.2616414725780487,
-0.13570235669612885,
-0.4360484778881073,
0.3300877511501312,
-0.3930986821651459,
0.40319180488586426,
-0.06638598442077637,
-0.5291457772254944,
-0.4857299029827118,
-0.09967822581529617,
-0.4292373061180115,
0.633255124092102,
0.05595617741346359,
-0.6123568415641785,
0.17189869284629822,
-0.7786855101585388,
-0.16801989078521729,
0.009131131693720818,
-0.4380580484867096,
-0.3590705990791321,
0.43717315793037415,
0.23793810606002808,
-0.057941973209381104,
-0.25976303219795227,
0.5224003791809082,
-0.5770833492279053,
-0.31046533584594727,
0.3900993764400482,
-0.7738440632820129,
0.9696178436279297,
0.27056604623794556,
-0.5273954272270203,
-0.1982685625553131,
-0.8104202747344971,
0.03883954882621765,
0.06892258673906326,
0.043995440006256104,
-0.11080098897218704,
0.23739683628082275,
-0.5039194226264954,
0.42548519372940063,
0.16714143753051758,
-0.5911481380462646,
0.20612066984176636,
-0.6203595399856567,
0.48438382148742676,
0.6793336272239685,
-0.0857800766825676,
0.5243209600448608,
-0.1839105784893036,
0.38472655415534973,
0.1691436469554901,
0.11887159943580627,
0.24389466643333435,
-0.4169207513332367,
-0.7255178093910217,
-0.04355385899543762,
0.2204829454421997,
0.4661937654018402,
-0.6605230569839478,
0.2490786910057068,
-0.01885927841067314,
-0.12866508960723877,
-0.6049299836158752,
-0.04069576412439346,
0.4058486521244049,
0.6331270933151245,
0.2944340407848358,
0.26468566060066223,
-0.5051887631416321,
-1.1265685558319092,
0.027605324983596802,
0.14166608452796936,
-0.25516951084136963,
0.13095110654830933,
0.5730736255645752,
-0.18306462466716766,
0.8842454552650452,
-0.4234953224658966,
0.21358363330364227,
-0.0680953785777092,
0.4627225399017334,
0.7270692586898804,
0.32376420497894287,
0.6109727621078491,
-0.8989855051040649,
-0.509477972984314,
-0.16607226431369781,
-0.6939902305603027,
-0.17741262912750244,
-0.5468631982803345,
-0.14398488402366638,
-0.1500915288925171,
0.3452574908733368,
-0.5762156248092651,
0.6695306301116943,
0.4987330138683319,
-0.066030353307724,
0.6430402398109436,
-0.34949222207069397,
-0.3604253828525543,
-0.823756217956543,
-0.17619125545024872,
-0.25716692209243774,
0.15813300013542175,
-0.6456868648529053,
-0.11951625347137451,
-0.19488441944122314,
0.004246934782713652,
-0.235647052526474,
0.1166897714138031,
-0.33205294609069824,
0.19774606823921204,
-0.125909686088562,
-0.033802684396505356,
0.2882809638977051,
0.8428398370742798,
0.11103004962205887,
0.5784557461738586,
0.711203932762146,
-0.5709706544876099,
0.016022231429815292,
0.16027602553367615,
0.0687473714351654,
0.4626578688621521,
-0.7949543595314026,
0.2133093625307083,
-0.5360557436943054,
0.31985682249069214,
-0.7207860946655273,
0.060254741460084915,
0.14385062456130981,
-0.35556653141975403,
0.24273276329040527,
-0.3256894648075104,
-0.12378600239753723,
-0.42639103531837463,
-0.27713510394096375,
0.2392915040254593,
0.5311930179595947,
-0.7675462365150452,
0.8795687556266785,
-0.25663402676582336,
0.10595403611660004,
-0.6999428868293762,
-0.8399434089660645,
-0.03755057975649834,
-0.1974441558122635,
-0.5444724559783936,
0.8695656657218933,
-0.4702118933200836,
-0.6934170722961426,
0.0868808701634407,
-0.4929651916027069,
-0.4949386417865753,
0.22509849071502686,
0.11488506197929382,
0.17064975202083588,
-0.6658827662467957,
0.20089076459407806,
0.418520450592041,
-0.2764263153076172,
0.2741391658782959,
-0.4284990131855011,
0.40037623047828674,
-0.3127244710922241,
-0.6906429529190063,
-0.5451803207397461,
0.706757128238678,
0.17160280048847198,
-0.3103298544883728,
0.9448837041854858,
0.48949646949768066,
-0.49706384539604187,
-0.611997663974762,
-0.18689151108264923,
-0.2641291618347168,
-0.5148940682411194,
0.09990331530570984,
-0.4873652458190918,
-0.475861519575119,
0.310742050409317,
-0.3362082839012146,
0.3586125373840332,
0.23919835686683655,
0.46066975593566895,
0.027690930292010307,
1.0053699016571045,
0.2319786548614502,
0.28993672132492065,
0.2258920818567276,
-0.16207048296928406,
0.6803824305534363,
-0.5158308744430542,
-0.08643556386232376,
-0.3645452558994293,
-0.7107492685317993,
-0.2182248830795288,
-0.6000611186027527,
-0.17949144542217255,
0.6242334842681885,
-0.07561183720827103,
0.01690634898841381,
-0.9080479145050049,
0.722727358341217,
0.326299786567688,
-0.2530551552772522,
0.2588830888271332,
-0.054787617176771164,
-0.19322828948497772,
-0.23995500802993774,
-0.4386155903339386,
-0.4003973603248596,
0.5521456003189087,
0.1882227063179016,
0.8504501581192017,
0.40027692914009094,
0.9165517091751099,
0.029325420036911964,
0.0159908514469862,
-0.4549299478530884,
0.2344289869070053,
-0.5811452269554138,
-0.4113612771034241,
-0.08397410809993744,
-0.34286853671073914,
-0.6849455833435059,
0.34317415952682495,
-0.015646720305085182,
-1.210402011871338,
0.7093315124511719,
0.18768641352653503,
-0.3224954605102539,
0.29807049036026,
-0.9166022539138794,
0.674829363822937,
-0.5366710424423218,
-0.17882229387760162,
-0.2528536915779114,
-0.4589092433452606,
0.2299126386642456,
0.1620398312807083,
0.18748988211154938,
-0.1802639663219452,
0.227430060505867,
0.41250380873680115,
-0.5167169570922852,
0.76399165391922,
-0.3859250545501709,
0.056804560124874115,
-0.014393461868166924,
0.2579711973667145,
0.35861650109291077,
0.49250781536102295,
-0.4519856572151184,
0.3053947985172272,
-0.061761438846588135,
-0.23635588586330414,
-1.1851216554641724,
0.6562245488166809,
-0.6245816946029663,
-0.6084628701210022,
-0.13408923149108887,
-0.7791793346405029,
-0.14650660753250122,
-0.0723850354552269,
0.08217322081327438,
0.7564499974250793,
0.37771567702293396,
0.2900548577308655,
0.8443854451179504,
-0.3209981322288513,
0.6563552021980286,
0.5595325827598572,
-0.20477065443992615,
-0.039343416690826416,
1.0663940906524658,
-0.3093010187149048,
0.18049655854701996,
0.8894029259681702,
0.40526801347732544,
-0.3581202030181885,
-0.9906607866287231,
-0.1665787696838379,
0.29066312313079834,
-0.6072673201560974,
0.11718213558197021,
-0.42440763115882874,
-0.39690694212913513,
-0.041388656944036484,
-0.5150146484375,
-0.23276954889297485,
-0.460733562707901,
-0.18733996152877808,
-0.010136593133211136,
0.4077565670013428,
0.5152890086174011,
-0.22726604342460632,
0.37120193243026733,
-0.17357170581817627,
0.7378872036933899,
0.3958410918712616,
0.4949488341808319,
-0.06700551509857178,
-0.2946973741054535,
0.22203905880451202,
0.4431895613670349,
-0.03101692721247673,
-0.8415251970291138,
0.47717124223709106,
0.5224613547325134,
0.6935186386108398,
0.5001723766326904,
0.24303482472896576,
1.012681484222412,
-0.41997718811035156,
0.3854319751262665,
0.1325424611568451,
-0.9928240776062012,
0.1682785302400589,
-0.004248655401170254,
0.3373681306838989,
0.6523022055625916,
0.35122552514076233,
-0.4171064794063568,
-0.16218292713165283,
-0.30567723512649536,
-0.7181015610694885,
0.6428638100624084,
0.4909787178039551,
-0.14639773964881897,
-0.04163530468940735,
0.3586403429508209,
0.3560440242290497,
0.17207731306552887,
-0.8750593066215515,
-0.4724830090999603,
-0.35019299387931824,
-0.4321300685405731,
0.22099840641021729,
-0.08454765379428864,
-0.146659716963768,
-0.16284748911857605,
0.619102418422699,
-0.250377893447876,
0.4565620720386505,
0.19524182379245758,
-0.34948763251304626,
0.3893280029296875,
0.4413480758666992,
0.5926318764686584,
0.9569319486618042,
-0.36298868060112,
0.33395254611968994,
0.17938542366027832,
0.06540476530790329,
-0.20215517282485962,
0.3349490165710449,
-0.15552914142608643,
0.4051852822303772,
0.458707332611084,
0.8715305328369141,
0.07888691872358322,
-0.5450143814086914,
0.2315053939819336,
-0.35863038897514343,
-0.532782256603241,
-0.2495497465133667,
-0.033896900713443756,
0.5718243718147278,
0.09815825521945953,
0.4078289866447449,
0.07492613047361374,
0.27148452401161194,
0.011341288685798645,
0.27418050169944763,
0.3128355145454407,
-0.3410489857196808,
-0.20363926887512207,
0.6044268012046814,
0.08690975606441498,
-0.7361481189727783,
0.6691199541091919,
-0.48161575198173523,
-0.3035247325897217,
0.7097112536430359,
0.5910943746566772,
0.5933161377906799,
0.19003979861736298,
0.4925040006637573,
0.0980457216501236,
0.12442173808813095,
0.5589140057563782,
0.15172222256660461,
-0.2138771414756775,
-0.675273597240448,
-0.7741742730140686,
-0.7045759558677673,
-0.3184996545314789,
0.22347918152809143,
-0.6746220588684082,
-0.1610194891691208,
-0.4393508732318878,
0.40004396438598633,
0.7276667356491089,
-0.34285420179367065,
-0.5841336250305176,
-0.11213105916976929,
0.514504611492157,
0.8614285588264465,
-0.5713663101196289,
0.8083603382110596,
0.3076249361038208,
-0.3981560170650482,
-0.7638580203056335,
-0.10975426435470581,
0.17485007643699646,
-0.6733208298683167,
0.7820432782173157,
0.1968805342912674,
-0.22007165849208832,
-0.29050806164741516,
-0.3351607024669647,
-0.49889668822288513,
0.5695178508758545,
0.8067639470100403,
-0.9008435606956482,
-0.2756814658641815,
0.3504968583583832,
0.5889600515365601,
-0.287449449300766,
0.40700608491897583,
0.372536301612854,
0.4575774073600769,
-0.00862214621156454,
-0.6118302941322327,
-0.06564702838659286,
-0.4317590594291687,
0.16141048073768616,
0.31695082783699036,
-0.01294611394405365,
0.8287754058837891,
-0.04804132506251335,
-0.051028136163949966,
-0.31470316648483276,
0.5183041095733643,
0.12155680358409882,
0.39624395966529846,
0.6325103044509888,
0.5511595606803894,
0.7137287855148315,
0.010085072368383408,
0.9108885526657104,
-0.2609100043773651,
0.21194174885749817,
1.4634666442871094,
-0.15986543893814087,
0.5742418169975281,
0.9541494846343994,
-0.43999233841896057,
1.1172207593917847,
0.41230839490890503,
0.18474513292312622,
0.46448802947998047,
0.45682787895202637,
-0.4931902587413788,
-0.2603861689567566,
0.0847843736410141,
-0.2920374870300293,
0.3331219553947449,
0.3977988064289093,
-0.2540477216243744,
-0.7709293961524963,
-0.17559948563575745,
-0.20115923881530762,
0.40458011627197266,
0.037771791219711304,
0.6555026769638062,
0.16647931933403015,
-0.6254072785377502,
0.802990198135376,
-0.06913206726312637,
0.7973253726959229,
-0.8956180810928345,
-0.5112136006355286,
-0.14479555189609528,
0.5330919027328491,
-0.3913004398345947,
-0.618170440196991,
0.7826209664344788,
-0.3836092948913574,
-0.46409913897514343,
-0.43905264139175415,
0.33428433537483215,
-0.3655228614807129,
-0.5311403870582581,
0.3600408434867859,
0.048005104064941406,
0.06415969878435135,
0.04884995147585869,
-0.9935693740844727,
-0.14188048243522644,
0.24569647014141083,
0.13659150898456573,
0.14975997805595398,
0.635831892490387,
0.04494801536202431,
0.7717890739440918,
0.7906672358512878,
-0.20560094714164734,
0.23540474474430084,
0.3254804313182831,
0.9262312054634094,
-0.32839831709861755,
-0.29802826046943665,
-0.984536349773407,
0.6161209940910339,
-0.22030436992645264,
-0.2759714722633362,
0.25838005542755127,
0.3039741814136505,
0.4752325415611267,
-0.19413134455680847,
0.581875741481781,
-0.4247138798236847,
0.14967596530914307,
-0.39079543948173523,
0.2090432494878769,
-0.39580342173576355,
0.40416982769966125,
0.0769268274307251,
-0.5866956114768982,
-0.17044350504875183,
0.8329184651374817,
-0.4987812042236328,
-0.3272678554058075,
0.9160363078117371,
0.8406616449356079,
-0.23682215809822083,
-0.08067494630813599,
-0.020099174231290817,
0.34230831265449524,
0.49033287167549133,
0.7702332139015198,
0.5295954942703247,
-0.0017791209975257516,
0.6267013549804688,
-0.7495725154876709,
-0.10584081709384918,
-0.00791279599070549,
-1.0549399852752686,
-0.8607571721076965,
-0.47138601541519165,
-0.4411294460296631,
-0.05731368064880371,
0.04629524052143097,
0.7961037158966064,
0.8115545511245728,
-1.0540026426315308,
-0.08267855644226074,
-0.6594487428665161,
0.6492622494697571,
-0.5044907927513123,
-0.33165979385375977,
0.034108493477106094,
-0.44066521525382996,
-0.6565732955932617,
0.4571917653083801,
0.48393070697784424,
-0.44031432271003723,
-0.27139201760292053,
-0.2770494222640991,
-0.40560489892959595,
0.17205004394054413,
0.44969990849494934,
0.3565337061882019,
-0.8772124648094177,
-0.07355282455682755,
-0.15731029212474823,
0.3144240379333496,
0.22977162897586823,
0.7505636215209961,
-0.7717241644859314,
0.5766393542289734,
0.47210192680358887,
0.6980172991752625,
0.547808051109314,
-0.2826429307460785,
0.8630967736244202,
-0.6076251268386841,
0.44189757108688354,
0.4725821018218994,
0.36803603172302246,
0.02942332625389099,
-0.28241729736328125,
0.30963364243507385,
0.009031698107719421,
-0.08511500805616379,
-0.863591194152832,
0.451113760471344,
-1.21682608127594,
-0.5407683253288269,
0.851002037525177,
-0.09757540374994278,
-0.4185490608215332,
-0.37409165501594543,
-0.14170867204666138,
-0.051056619733572006,
-0.4166286587715149,
0.6918249130249023,
0.39279788732528687,
-0.2202007919549942,
-0.2861732542514801,
-0.26811373233795166,
0.3189660906791687,
0.31368884444236755,
-0.9053493738174438,
-0.06058628484606743,
0.22464869916439056,
0.1595393717288971,
0.12965068221092224,
0.20916876196861267,
-0.02470647357404232,
0.17152857780456543,
0.3009619414806366,
0.030679337680339813,
-0.21030348539352417,
0.061347316950559616,
-0.2916991710662842,
-0.023190248757600784,
-0.10701689124107361,
-0.1952732652425766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02622v1
|
Estimating the Causal Effects of Natural Logic Features in Transformer-Based NLI Models
| 2024-04-03T10:22:35 | 2024-04-03T10:22:35 |
Julia Rozanova, Marco Valentino, André Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rigorous evaluation of the causal effects of semantic features on language
model predictions can be hard to achieve for natural language reasoning
problems. However, this is such a desirable form of analysis from both an
interpretability and model evaluation perspective, that it is valuable to
investigate specific patterns of reasoning with enough structure and regularity
to identify and quantify systematic reasoning failures in widely-used models.
In this vein, we pick a portion of the NLI task for which an explicit causal
diagram can be systematically constructed: the case where across two sentences
(the premise and hypothesis), two related words/terms occur in a shared
context. In this work, we apply causal effect estimation strategies to measure
the effect of context interventions (whose effect on the entailment label is
mediated by the semantic monotonicity characteristic) and interventions on the
inserted word-pair (whose effect on the entailment label is mediated by the
relation between these words). Extending related work on causal analysis of NLP
models in different settings, we perform an extensive interventional study on
the NLI task to investigate robustness to irrelevant changes and sensitivity to
impactful changes of Transformers. The results strongly bolster the fact that
similar benchmark accuracy scores may be observed for models that exhibit very
different behaviour. Moreover, our methodology reinforces previously suspected
biases from a causal perspective, including biases in favour of upward-monotone
contexts and ignoring the effects of negation markers.
|
[
-0.44049203395843506,
-1.153192162513733,
0.45183563232421875,
0.4636407494544983,
0.10596484690904617,
-0.6916133165359497,
-0.12020260840654373,
-0.4879494905471802,
0.2647888660430908,
0.6870241761207581,
-0.602039098739624,
-0.11758754402399063,
-0.7910748720169067,
0.3006763458251953,
-0.5756852626800537,
0.9051324129104614,
0.041334640234708786,
-0.23026375472545624,
-0.06873984634876251,
-0.24646340310573578,
-1.0731909275054932,
-0.12193159013986588,
-0.5413123369216919,
-0.4748379588127136,
0.7355682253837585,
-0.05278502404689789,
0.8270357251167297,
0.3355806767940521,
0.46579888463020325,
0.2576959431171417,
-0.2990267872810364,
-0.12932616472244263,
-0.40141212940216064,
0.021023569628596306,
-0.38008230924606323,
-0.4944562613964081,
-0.21093598008155823,
0.17624473571777344,
0.6349861025810242,
0.9669444561004639,
0.024835869669914246,
0.07499571144580841,
0.36451292037963867,
0.466679185628891,
-0.7170050144195557,
0.109854556620121,
-0.7075045704841614,
-0.03522107005119324,
0.042811959981918335,
-0.41911250352859497,
-0.6130558848381042,
-0.08878709375858307,
0.498108446598053,
-0.47454506158828735,
0.19049997627735138,
-0.0020055645145475864,
0.9305157661437988,
0.6907691955566406,
-0.7366608381271362,
-0.28927847743034363,
-0.9488221406936646,
1.0115416049957275,
-0.7313198447227478,
0.188562273979187,
0.19837428629398346,
0.1286434531211853,
-0.41369202733039856,
-0.5937201380729675,
-0.5171552896499634,
-0.0484507754445076,
-0.675373911857605,
0.3343214690685272,
-0.43213996291160583,
-0.039106760174036026,
0.579197883605957,
-0.037092071026563644,
-0.22400450706481934,
-0.05511944741010666,
-0.1851087361574173,
-0.10721291601657867,
0.47150689363479614,
0.2543739378452301,
0.3090621829032898,
-0.4667953848838806,
-0.40871477127075195,
0.11318503320217133,
-0.611403226852417,
0.22040575742721558,
0.15140900015830994,
0.3731379806995392,
-0.28044185042381287,
0.4731251895427704,
-0.08024168759584427,
0.8646345734596252,
-0.02623998187482357,
-0.008506584912538528,
-0.10146058350801468,
-0.6609876751899719,
-0.3842104375362396,
0.06430204957723618,
0.5836315155029297,
0.13407732546329498,
0.18896833062171936,
-0.3689119517803192,
0.10338189452886581,
0.4050522744655609,
0.2951613962650299,
-0.37478160858154297,
0.13104331493377686,
0.09852134436368942,
-0.3141903281211853,
-0.25543534755706787,
0.21471838653087616,
-0.4749795198440552,
-0.3212633430957794,
-0.672234833240509,
0.4681248962879181,
-0.25604140758514404,
-0.2959560751914978,
0.3201388120651245,
-0.36453360319137573,
0.5020186305046082,
-0.04884154349565506,
-0.5116976499557495,
0.33677634596824646,
0.7371898889541626,
0.5267966985702515,
-0.04510848969221115,
-0.38874876499176025,
-0.3599417209625244,
0.24537509679794312,
-0.05449596047401428,
0.7073875665664673,
-0.5085965394973755,
-0.15096934139728546,
0.05380672961473465,
0.19514988362789154,
-0.566100001335144,
-0.3539748191833496,
0.9843995571136475,
-0.3865761458873749,
0.16963206231594086,
-0.19543594121932983,
-0.5887008309364319,
-0.19439120590686798,
0.189627543091774,
-0.8033047318458557,
0.7096034288406372,
-0.1765245497226715,
-1.3093078136444092,
0.6577625274658203,
-0.6827695965766907,
-0.8495033383369446,
-0.41673919558525085,
0.007850058376789093,
-0.4111541509628296,
0.23753978312015533,
0.06144164130091667,
0.21962738037109375,
-0.4111323058605194,
0.8281257748603821,
-0.22580653429031372,
-0.272305965423584,
0.3024059236049652,
-0.7858700156211853,
0.9066755771636963,
-0.4020528495311737,
-0.5406385660171509,
0.35530757904052734,
-0.7955055236816406,
-0.43021199107170105,
0.06644872575998306,
0.12164393812417984,
-0.6427011489868164,
0.3511240482330322,
-0.05428500473499298,
0.26415595412254333,
-0.19441257417201996,
-0.4063999354839325,
-0.08069425821304321,
-0.4527665674686432,
0.03768227621912956,
0.52128005027771,
0.38949066400527954,
0.3965923488140106,
-0.21468956768512726,
0.06529787927865982,
0.04651707410812378,
0.4209432601928711,
0.04382866621017456,
-0.8106637597084045,
-0.7268982529640198,
-0.2932022213935852,
0.0541195347905159,
0.4010176956653595,
-0.550611138343811,
0.4923633337020874,
-0.3072943091392517,
-0.1645302176475525,
-0.16538265347480774,
-0.12182265520095825,
0.32662874460220337,
0.8225939273834229,
0.4171334207057953,
-0.030548173934221268,
-0.49947822093963623,
-1.1683087348937988,
-0.6582168936729431,
-0.028561841696500778,
-0.2552897036075592,
0.12887871265411377,
0.6401298642158508,
-0.29189980030059814,
1.3336714506149292,
-0.5131517052650452,
-0.16268157958984375,
-0.07222277671098709,
0.5639744997024536,
0.5548133850097656,
0.3959358036518097,
0.4004712700843811,
-0.7870731949806213,
-0.10297590494155884,
-0.37330156564712524,
-0.6789917945861816,
-0.2199498414993286,
-0.47404345870018005,
-0.381374716758728,
0.008994354866445065,
0.35992759466171265,
-0.5318439602851868,
0.7966970801353455,
0.2273450642824173,
-0.5262929797172546,
0.5392488241195679,
-0.06567205488681793,
0.08805219829082489,
-0.6454674601554871,
0.21583567559719086,
0.25213584303855896,
0.35486292839050293,
-0.9374174475669861,
-0.175383523106575,
-0.16061793267726898,
0.3634657561779022,
-0.2168256938457489,
0.4454091489315033,
0.0009682087111286819,
0.2302040457725525,
-0.13051737844944,
0.12095057219266891,
0.1098814308643341,
0.5140860080718994,
0.030698265880346298,
0.2288534939289093,
0.3676399886608124,
-0.7187781929969788,
-0.3018377423286438,
0.22458875179290771,
-0.1151021420955658,
0.5706246495246887,
-0.8667197823524475,
-0.23072996735572815,
-0.29584887623786926,
0.202398419380188,
-0.7554352879524231,
-0.12224432080984116,
0.24104498326778412,
-0.1816146820783615,
0.19783887267112732,
0.04729338362812996,
-0.3670896589756012,
-0.046090733259916306,
-0.08778920769691467,
0.18678715825080872,
0.15369467437267303,
-0.46375229954719543,
0.8308605551719666,
0.1873825490474701,
0.3329421281814575,
-0.41524505615234375,
-0.57387775182724,
0.009360086172819138,
-0.5293094515800476,
-0.9679222106933594,
0.18773728609085083,
0.33662015199661255,
-0.43696433305740356,
0.15968279540538788,
-0.25290146470069885,
-0.03686186298727989,
0.46931391954421997,
0.4452272355556488,
0.2931325137615204,
-0.1806936413049698,
0.08625426143407822,
0.25321096181869507,
-0.43425217270851135,
0.4772980511188507,
0.025394201278686523,
0.13096526265144348,
0.004341530613601208,
-0.3434174954891205,
-0.2604680359363556,
0.33131903409957886,
0.49441877007484436,
-0.2569335997104645,
1.0447850227355957,
0.4037957489490509,
-0.43156003952026367,
-0.07776689529418945,
-0.4627566337585449,
-0.3098584711551666,
-0.33795759081840515,
0.03661135584115982,
-0.2055308073759079,
-0.6646822094917297,
0.502855122089386,
0.011372542940080166,
0.008270914666354656,
0.7008137702941895,
0.15415698289871216,
0.10290785133838654,
1.0743108987808228,
0.4792606234550476,
-0.1424611657857895,
0.23917563259601593,
-0.20008531212806702,
0.4985983967781067,
-0.856116771697998,
-0.13901950418949127,
-0.5860817432403564,
-0.2545006573200226,
-0.7305682301521301,
-0.26242679357528687,
0.4969533681869507,
0.16210538148880005,
-0.2735857367515564,
0.4185941517353058,
-0.24843212962150574,
0.081024169921875,
0.48046502470970154,
0.1405518651008606,
0.36952143907546997,
-0.2133503407239914,
0.03503987193107605,
-0.07748720049858093,
-0.7664936780929565,
-0.4789923429489136,
0.7690424919128418,
0.23596487939357758,
0.5410866737365723,
0.11749453097581863,
0.3377583920955658,
-0.003526349551975727,
0.6218978762626648,
-0.619902491569519,
0.2645195722579956,
0.1353796124458313,
-0.6724189519882202,
-0.3624204397201538,
-0.39791515469551086,
-0.8993759751319885,
0.14868830144405365,
-0.4799419641494751,
-0.766059398651123,
0.40503576397895813,
0.05500078573822975,
-0.0019391127862036228,
-0.048217400908470154,
-0.8196699619293213,
1.0910379886627197,
0.08578437566757202,
-0.5539460778236389,
-0.2711024582386017,
-0.6416870951652527,
0.5782015323638916,
-0.1368158608675003,
0.2040630429983139,
0.01577669009566307,
0.33834925293922424,
0.5374044179916382,
-0.23415325582027435,
0.9960488677024841,
-0.17076733708381653,
-0.018804602324962616,
0.1981256604194641,
-0.13026857376098633,
0.4453568160533905,
0.005006673280149698,
-0.17759577929973602,
0.3812871277332306,
-0.11819498986005783,
-0.40538373589515686,
-1.0650237798690796,
0.48909783363342285,
-0.4132045805454254,
-0.7177848219871521,
-0.13098108768463135,
-0.629898726940155,
-0.23344014585018158,
0.10831678658723831,
0.15839260816574097,
0.7199680209159851,
-0.1254681795835495,
0.016645031049847603,
0.43876180052757263,
-0.38572633266448975,
0.29412657022476196,
0.39186328649520874,
0.02456982061266899,
0.17514611780643463,
0.4871353805065155,
0.11097165942192078,
0.42279547452926636,
0.2497084140777588,
0.5695985555648804,
-0.13267439603805542,
-0.2827310860157013,
-0.06696832180023193,
0.281482070684433,
-0.5829383134841919,
0.07073099911212921,
-0.4250255823135376,
-0.13911674916744232,
-0.0432831272482872,
-0.17151665687561035,
-0.11216533929109573,
-0.16066403687000275,
0.13807496428489685,
0.07137966901063919,
0.19103382527828217,
0.5558351278305054,
0.110585056245327,
0.0249972864985466,
-0.44454851746559143,
0.24392765760421753,
0.26559293270111084,
0.30901041626930237,
0.1462269276380539,
-0.5435341000556946,
-0.0930432602763176,
0.04568622633814812,
-0.021695980802178383,
-0.8297504782676697,
0.20943795144557953,
0.01596425101161003,
0.4913138151168823,
0.48866766691207886,
0.20276038348674774,
0.8069931864738464,
-0.5513644218444824,
0.43456780910491943,
0.12239089608192444,
-0.9280531406402588,
0.7551891803741455,
-0.20503269135951996,
0.40862178802490234,
0.3601222336292267,
0.321016788482666,
-0.5643263459205627,
-0.8215577602386475,
-0.49580755829811096,
-0.8827744126319885,
0.4431304335594177,
0.46080076694488525,
0.0010072389850392938,
-0.3684006631374359,
0.22393864393234253,
-0.13490724563598633,
-0.14251510798931122,
-0.5844887495040894,
-0.49159160256385803,
-0.019463609904050827,
-0.001577900955453515,
0.22253403067588806,
-0.17265158891677856,
-0.2553849518299103,
-0.36138638854026794,
0.6784220933914185,
-0.06294973939657211,
0.09375232458114624,
0.36332088708877563,
-0.15196511149406433,
0.1466820389032364,
0.3640083968639374,
0.6037998795509338,
0.5539761185646057,
-0.2366967797279358,
0.21002252399921417,
0.1654077023267746,
-0.10026135295629501,
-0.27111151814460754,
0.17876316606998444,
-0.5663426518440247,
0.0910022035241127,
0.885421872138977,
0.9699284434318542,
0.7114881873130798,
-0.4072323441505432,
0.45862165093421936,
-0.14106543362140656,
0.09820233285427094,
-0.292234867811203,
-0.15674710273742676,
-0.11159750074148178,
0.00342330033890903,
0.08202879875898361,
0.4145599603652954,
0.38212525844573975,
-0.3950815498828888,
0.32002556324005127,
0.5264078378677368,
-0.7256022095680237,
-0.36494362354278564,
0.4838111102581024,
-0.008643724955618382,
-0.10196176171302795,
0.4676462709903717,
-0.022906679660081863,
-0.4166930615901947,
0.7890916466712952,
0.5752042531967163,
0.8819280862808228,
-0.007990695536136627,
0.12947189807891846,
0.5974427461624146,
0.6223161220550537,
0.08049862086772919,
-0.14322178065776825,
0.27084586024284363,
-1.028025507926941,
-0.724358081817627,
-0.4651300311088562,
-0.061114948242902756,
-0.17208079993724823,
-0.8390182852745056,
0.31431394815444946,
-0.03042561747133732,
-0.06321631371974945,
0.2975555658340454,
-0.5296565294265747,
-0.7063004970550537,
-0.015432232990860939,
-0.08400846272706985,
0.7597059607505798,
-1.3476533889770508,
0.5164169669151306,
0.34553489089012146,
-0.5168784260749817,
-1.0074331760406494,
0.21406492590904236,
0.05459362268447876,
-0.3403536081314087,
0.6845130920410156,
0.30445384979248047,
-0.31574225425720215,
-0.25611773133277893,
-0.3945371210575104,
-0.8273724317550659,
0.8473045825958252,
0.18025504052639008,
-0.25084638595581055,
0.09702738374471664,
0.3414776921272278,
0.5431689023971558,
-0.14178074896335602,
0.38681644201278687,
0.9542563557624817,
0.7225903868675232,
-0.06406351923942566,
-0.7729214429855347,
0.3337441384792328,
-0.15590807795524597,
-0.07788601517677307,
0.4395911395549774,
0.03703566640615463,
0.2804200351238251,
0.07507868111133575,
-0.5361078977584839,
-0.20412999391555786,
0.4497565031051636,
0.002825317904353142,
0.35639816522598267,
0.6813606023788452,
0.5240525603294373,
0.4904325306415558,
-0.1522955745458603,
1.4024252891540527,
-0.43695637583732605,
0.34464895725250244,
1.1683036088943481,
-0.0803447812795639,
0.6216505765914917,
0.7891277074813843,
0.011563646607100964,
0.4717032313346863,
-0.061157114803791046,
0.1549254208803177,
0.41742926836013794,
0.21028174459934235,
-0.2293195277452469,
-0.0650959387421608,
-0.49938711524009705,
0.04542772099375725,
0.40945568680763245,
0.2812356948852539,
-0.1400611400604248,
-0.2573489844799042,
-0.11432797461748123,
0.0012133005075156689,
0.09491303563117981,
-0.0690920427441597,
0.5229701995849609,
0.057503506541252136,
-0.7269553542137146,
0.34155622124671936,
-0.0597611665725708,
0.6732299327850342,
-0.5277871489524841,
-0.12217817455530167,
-0.09789649397134781,
0.013399621471762657,
-0.3273928165435791,
-0.3316603899002075,
0.9111788868904114,
-0.16218292713165283,
-0.3053661286830902,
-0.12978456914424896,
0.7502598762512207,
-0.1743338406085968,
-0.6076127290725708,
0.5665474534034729,
0.37814781069755554,
-0.38894122838974,
0.0488322414457798,
-0.3941965103149414,
-0.11425594240427017,
-0.30394619703292847,
-0.26970160007476807,
-0.0024992937687784433,
0.308508038520813,
-0.20033597946166992,
0.3467119634151459,
0.49046555161476135,
-0.15007975697517395,
0.08827179670333862,
0.39700058102607727,
0.646618664264679,
-0.5537061095237732,
-0.07172825932502747,
-0.8051096200942993,
0.8639089465141296,
-0.22723032534122467,
-0.40154722332954407,
0.7909467816352844,
0.2851058840751648,
0.5981086492538452,
-0.0027015116065740585,
0.3819005787372589,
-0.03220721706748009,
0.3406609296798706,
-0.4737016260623932,
0.4800831377506256,
-0.27470770478248596,
0.3362298011779785,
-0.5149955153465271,
-0.7778132557868958,
-0.6447378993034363,
0.3815072476863861,
-0.5684506297111511,
-0.3452256917953491,
0.9427263140678406,
0.8237455487251282,
-0.026489323005080223,
0.34167253971099854,
0.1622365564107895,
0.36486902832984924,
0.19037924706935883,
0.21916116774082184,
0.895822286605835,
-0.5047075748443604,
0.14202111959457397,
-0.23238979279994965,
-0.2934704124927521,
0.24301254749298096,
-0.8991835713386536,
-0.7437242269515991,
-0.4025079905986786,
-0.43295523524284363,
-0.151264950633049,
-0.22617825865745544,
0.5099080204963684,
0.23624823987483978,
-0.7901005744934082,
-0.08753782510757446,
-0.4402702748775482,
0.6005159616470337,
-0.4377567172050476,
-0.30213794112205505,
0.5668864250183105,
-0.4223366677761078,
-0.5343862175941467,
0.2856300473213196,
0.42592495679855347,
-0.5966234803199768,
-0.0999191403388977,
0.14506110548973083,
-0.46045345067977905,
0.3109213411808014,
0.6425304412841797,
0.04675280675292015,
-0.9081224203109741,
-0.7803849577903748,
0.1253892332315445,
0.0929192379117012,
-0.16369561851024628,
0.9576589465141296,
-0.7239811420440674,
0.3990063965320587,
0.3916848301887512,
0.5509144067764282,
0.25962164998054504,
-0.31057965755462646,
0.6961416006088257,
-0.55534827709198,
0.24092884361743927,
-0.0699961930513382,
0.5201658606529236,
0.052998729050159454,
-0.028327642008662224,
0.6290991306304932,
0.34209054708480835,
-0.1896817535161972,
-0.6102226376533508,
0.44360730051994324,
-0.7602458000183105,
-0.16038963198661804,
0.9465163350105286,
-0.04692164063453674,
-0.13214023411273956,
-0.3446178436279297,
0.05363016948103905,
0.3905802071094513,
0.20017407834529877,
0.8252284526824951,
0.5677464008331299,
-0.1471700370311737,
0.2568965554237366,
-0.688923716545105,
0.24628055095672607,
0.5423147082328796,
-0.7084359526634216,
-0.25669363141059875,
0.414750337600708,
0.062115926295518875,
0.4016694128513336,
0.05179813131690025,
-0.04020184651017189,
0.03340906277298927,
0.09295942634344101,
-0.1153496727347374,
0.3207487165927887,
-0.25971710681915283,
-0.4823540151119232,
0.10131163895130157,
-0.2685866057872772,
0.20807315409183502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02619v1
|
Adjusting Interpretable Dimensions in Embedding Space with Human Judgments
| 2024-04-03T10:13:18 | 2024-04-03T10:13:18 |
Katrin Erk, Marianna Apidianaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Embedding spaces contain interpretable dimensions indicating gender,
formality in style, or even object properties. This has been observed multiple
times. Such interpretable dimensions are becoming valuable tools in different
areas of study, from social science to neuroscience. The standard way to
compute these dimensions uses contrasting seed words and computes difference
vectors over them. This is simple but does not always work well. We combine
seed-based vectors with guidance from human ratings of where words fall along a
specific dimension, and evaluate on predicting both object properties like size
and danger, and the stylistic properties of formality and complexity. We obtain
interpretable dimensions with markedly better performance especially in cases
where seed-based dimensions do not work well.
|
[
-0.32032838463783264,
-0.6402909159660339,
0.6225972771644592,
0.5995228886604309,
-0.17986074090003967,
0.23016533255577087,
-0.20600289106369019,
-0.5737791061401367,
0.40077584981918335,
0.05398540571331978,
-0.4346369206905365,
-0.44901007413864136,
-0.9367448687553406,
-0.06256923824548721,
-0.25160229206085205,
0.5564867258071899,
-0.08235461264848709,
0.05637658014893532,
-0.712334930896759,
-0.35231488943099976,
-0.9260887503623962,
-0.3592434823513031,
-0.14526422321796417,
-0.15000829100608826,
0.2525191307067871,
0.3466300368309021,
0.931425154209137,
0.9558414816856384,
0.5866405367851257,
0.36830592155456543,
-0.29002004861831665,
0.16024623811244965,
-0.3135579824447632,
-0.21401210129261017,
-0.3238586187362671,
-0.2964228093624115,
-0.5334818363189697,
0.41932305693626404,
0.5471332669258118,
1.1101963520050049,
-0.07761817425489426,
-0.03831678256392479,
0.20079702138900757,
0.5903662443161011,
-0.5394124984741211,
0.33739110827445984,
-0.18369562923908234,
0.4368959963321686,
0.14064227044582367,
-0.5151052474975586,
-0.18672503530979156,
-0.37283116579055786,
0.29194822907447815,
-0.7382940649986267,
0.4935549199581146,
0.37086978554725647,
0.5651203989982605,
0.12131836265325546,
-0.2702443599700928,
-0.32068073749542236,
-0.8372564315795898,
1.071877360343933,
-0.11718142032623291,
0.763458251953125,
0.5302326679229736,
0.3619171679019928,
-0.24450546503067017,
-0.6530752182006836,
-0.3360964357852936,
-0.12476085126399994,
-0.3176448345184326,
-0.1673029214143753,
-0.12972049415111542,
-0.15558607876300812,
0.5509867668151855,
0.1901341676712036,
-0.4435969591140747,
-0.1050933226943016,
-0.5666836500167847,
-0.27491292357444763,
0.8189889192581177,
0.19108536839485168,
0.5090734958648682,
-0.3681865334510803,
-0.24544064700603485,
-0.246079221367836,
-0.6226412653923035,
0.25750643014907837,
0.411235511302948,
0.31735938787460327,
-0.05414115637540817,
0.26885154843330383,
-0.013080988079309464,
0.5579763650894165,
-0.08975499123334885,
0.025983132421970367,
0.38894811272621155,
-0.1543520838022232,
0.08156604319810867,
-0.03525513783097267,
0.3230614960193634,
0.65042644739151,
-0.042518436908721924,
-0.1966174691915512,
0.12836922705173492,
0.026467880234122276,
0.6784527897834778,
-0.7157210111618042,
-0.2928006052970886,
0.09768571704626083,
-0.7750093340873718,
-0.4628916382789612,
0.3919890224933624,
-0.8535391092300415,
-0.6413230299949646,
-0.24092121422290802,
0.5041199922561646,
-0.6796607375144958,
-0.004688582383096218,
0.36459019780158997,
-0.5403833389282227,
0.2663707137107849,
0.5537186861038208,
-0.7770869135856628,
0.3206825852394104,
0.6848711967468262,
0.9637231826782227,
0.10464651137590408,
-0.1901954561471939,
-0.2060096710920334,
-0.19930529594421387,
-0.5012398958206177,
0.5168262720108032,
-0.9757698178291321,
-0.632095456123352,
-0.1915123462677002,
-0.03943591192364693,
0.21494518220424652,
-0.25839149951934814,
0.7119306921958923,
-0.1810358166694641,
0.16939261555671692,
-0.7018556594848633,
-0.5503317713737488,
-0.3915170729160309,
-0.09660997241735458,
-0.49866387248039246,
0.4375642240047455,
0.16130511462688446,
-0.8520100116729736,
0.8740019202232361,
-0.8824479579925537,
-0.3011540472507477,
0.1012701764702797,
-0.31880250573158264,
-0.2702704071998596,
0.38046541810035706,
0.44156181812286377,
0.5040093660354614,
0.05948256328701973,
-0.17410798370838165,
-0.3472980856895447,
-0.4380040168762207,
0.494321346282959,
-0.1150190532207489,
0.3505791127681732,
0.1745220571756363,
-0.08818312734365463,
0.2601670026779175,
-1.0997737646102905,
0.05376150831580162,
0.2904103696346283,
-0.15076884627342224,
-0.4459897577762604,
0.6226571798324585,
0.03656940534710884,
0.06041997671127319,
0.1792183220386505,
-0.6516828536987305,
0.039018385112285614,
-0.21732814610004425,
0.7200073599815369,
0.683031439781189,
-0.003294324269518256,
0.7861970067024231,
-0.08804977685213089,
0.482565701007843,
0.06267709285020828,
0.05183430388569832,
0.14984045922756195,
-0.5298694968223572,
-0.4728664457798004,
-0.26454517245292664,
0.3577524423599243,
0.19123004376888275,
-0.554896354675293,
0.6911420822143555,
-0.3403109908103943,
-0.4207693636417389,
-0.3477306365966797,
-0.0695498064160347,
0.2628685534000397,
-0.07994691282510757,
0.31216681003570557,
-0.436382919549942,
-0.6551154255867004,
-0.8761991858482361,
-0.48864060640335083,
-0.038889866322278976,
-0.16871534287929535,
0.5322556495666504,
0.538303017616272,
-0.05735493823885918,
0.8405556082725525,
-0.964629054069519,
-0.3418499529361725,
0.08320537954568863,
0.2615945041179657,
-0.0454925075173378,
0.6112716197967529,
0.614703893661499,
-0.7210415601730347,
-0.10647128522396088,
-0.11742755770683289,
-0.6927816271781921,
0.006936009973287582,
-0.05545172840356827,
-0.18489275872707367,
-0.45338165760040283,
0.5962362289428711,
-0.058529920876026154,
0.6464232802391052,
0.5519213676452637,
-0.9375567436218262,
0.3232303559780121,
-0.40594521164894104,
0.040144842118024826,
-0.736812174320221,
-0.2951086163520813,
0.057480353862047195,
-0.25699278712272644,
-0.3997098207473755,
0.1669849306344986,
0.26404377818107605,
-0.027909742668271065,
-0.291098952293396,
0.31530147790908813,
-0.5526211261749268,
-0.44866278767585754,
-0.2136654555797577,
0.11471857130527496,
0.47506919503211975,
0.21068935096263885,
-0.1805773675441742,
0.5499100089073181,
0.1894766241312027,
-0.32746967673301697,
0.14946961402893066,
0.5691595077514648,
-0.6289085745811462,
0.7825619578361511,
-0.6653375029563904,
0.4336870014667511,
-0.3135589063167572,
0.3210402727127075,
-0.9223529100418091,
-0.22192859649658203,
0.007510926574468613,
-0.5393575429916382,
0.4062024652957916,
0.14783185720443726,
-0.17602093517780304,
-0.20976832509040833,
-0.567206859588623,
0.4311244785785675,
0.2510835826396942,
-0.45433011651039124,
0.681723952293396,
0.16000314056873322,
0.07920635491609573,
-0.47424033284187317,
-0.5460521578788757,
-0.02290712110698223,
-0.23130379617214203,
-0.6145756840705872,
0.30450770258903503,
-0.0285508930683136,
-0.33975282311439514,
0.29081666469573975,
0.06855174899101257,
0.24047744274139404,
0.14409267902374268,
0.7406739592552185,
0.01667744107544422,
-0.01165691390633583,
0.1488344371318817,
0.1810780018568039,
-0.10148140788078308,
0.16266603767871857,
-0.3285142481327057,
0.2955509126186371,
-0.16413509845733643,
-0.3340824842453003,
-0.12186740338802338,
0.40971800684928894,
0.5753149390220642,
0.0019482908537611365,
1.0801297426223755,
0.7429432272911072,
-0.49810484051704407,
-0.25558459758758545,
-0.17600485682487488,
-0.15073265135288239,
-0.4596179127693176,
0.3882233798503876,
-0.4966107904911041,
-0.9370191693305969,
0.5294175148010254,
0.11978857219219208,
-0.030116930603981018,
0.5533673763275146,
0.31816530227661133,
-0.30744680762290955,
1.1793205738067627,
0.9988073706626892,
0.30195286870002747,
0.4521799385547638,
-0.3186497092247009,
0.2176838219165802,
-1.204965353012085,
-0.529962420463562,
-0.47070640325546265,
-0.8728892803192139,
-0.7021682262420654,
-0.7965002655982971,
0.29414650797843933,
0.0908006876707077,
-0.13242341578006744,
0.2652054727077484,
-0.4950605034828186,
0.4456392824649811,
0.3353360593318939,
0.23440463840961456,
0.011287457309663296,
0.015622728504240513,
-0.19573235511779785,
-0.5038628578186035,
-0.394102543592453,
-0.5121979117393494,
0.9359244108200073,
0.7494511008262634,
0.6843348741531372,
0.18863007426261902,
0.22043220698833466,
0.3124769926071167,
0.06191576272249222,
-0.8087781071662903,
0.15781597793102264,
-0.4531729817390442,
-0.5380416512489319,
-0.33920398354530334,
-0.3258158564567566,
-0.9192774891853333,
0.43981948494911194,
-0.457498699426651,
-1.0408844947814941,
0.7306402921676636,
-0.09050963073968887,
-0.46057936549186707,
0.3980075418949127,
-0.5951113700866699,
0.4742644727230072,
0.019543617963790894,
0.03156070038676262,
-0.3465879261493683,
-0.3358646333217621,
0.050153110176324844,
-0.06415213644504547,
0.35712289810180664,
-0.08617212623357773,
-0.13591475784778595,
1.0020028352737427,
-0.26244720816612244,
0.8569247722625732,
-0.11165106296539307,
0.0910428985953331,
-0.17098559439182281,
0.2850629389286041,
0.2207510769367218,
0.003755948506295681,
-0.012410723604261875,
0.4147038161754608,
0.1914895623922348,
-0.411579430103302,
-1.0492345094680786,
0.6591002941131592,
-1.2081841230392456,
-0.545842170715332,
-0.3848348557949066,
-0.8204851746559143,
-0.2476128488779068,
-0.21302318572998047,
0.35207146406173706,
0.547214925289154,
-0.6222544312477112,
0.4340326488018036,
0.37584108114242554,
-0.8084908723831177,
0.02412877418100834,
0.2637312114238739,
-0.39414629340171814,
-0.2116759866476059,
0.9189991354942322,
0.3788660764694214,
-0.03779776766896248,
0.512670636177063,
0.539604663848877,
-0.46031317114830017,
-0.31704381108283997,
-0.25259000062942505,
0.03087807260453701,
-0.7956217527389526,
0.13404744863510132,
-0.8792094588279724,
-0.33171921968460083,
-0.20873944461345673,
-0.38733670115470886,
-0.18782469630241394,
-0.7516665458679199,
-0.1941078156232834,
-0.29155904054641724,
0.37769269943237305,
1.0833402872085571,
-0.33988457918167114,
0.16450132429599762,
-0.7420269846916199,
0.1132153868675232,
0.4321272075176239,
0.5486944317817688,
-0.07879005372524261,
-0.850387454032898,
-0.1264728605747223,
-0.15906387567520142,
-0.18713976442813873,
-0.7715243101119995,
0.28667527437210083,
0.21541160345077515,
0.4463571310043335,
0.8037762641906738,
-0.3247441053390503,
0.5321741104125977,
-0.5053096413612366,
0.6789124608039856,
0.17263354361057281,
-1.0655126571655273,
0.6689697504043579,
-0.1713080257177353,
-0.031017009168863297,
0.06943860650062561,
0.29029059410095215,
-0.5910578966140747,
0.0495695024728775,
-0.7856782078742981,
-0.6687151789665222,
0.5425026416778564,
0.45219284296035767,
0.2813938558101654,
0.27810388803482056,
0.45087966322898865,
0.19410113990306854,
0.08393963426351547,
-0.05759737268090248,
-0.19572311639785767,
-0.31699928641319275,
0.24845153093338013,
-0.5300534963607788,
-0.6553483009338379,
-0.27656289935112,
-0.5983280539512634,
0.0888526514172554,
-0.024725288152694702,
0.6028090715408325,
-0.11599873006343842,
-0.07800032198429108,
-0.3146854639053345,
0.17886042594909668,
0.6700118184089661,
0.9538293480873108,
-0.39437904953956604,
0.128402978181839,
0.2427290678024292,
-0.5969119668006897,
0.21881897747516632,
-0.2988068461418152,
0.15273869037628174,
-0.22185108065605164,
0.7640794515609741,
1.0909782648086548,
0.2088487297296524,
-0.06573843210935593,
0.6011174321174622,
-0.3462623953819275,
-0.41725316643714905,
-0.2501082420349121,
0.23326624929904938,
-0.1439620703458786,
0.2740086019039154,
-0.11113304644823074,
0.263351172208786,
0.19244912266731262,
-0.6756966710090637,
0.07785134762525558,
0.1720275729894638,
-0.7629268169403076,
-0.5836790204048157,
0.6947678327560425,
0.2714977264404297,
-0.3523831367492676,
0.667242169380188,
-0.10490009188652039,
-0.5339681506156921,
0.6391457915306091,
0.38353773951530457,
0.953811526298523,
0.03949122130870819,
0.34741127490997314,
0.4424278140068054,
0.4534257650375366,
0.15400956571102142,
0.43307822942733765,
0.1433219313621521,
-1.2047055959701538,
-0.3801642656326294,
-1.0173485279083252,
-0.43577566742897034,
0.032259490340948105,
-0.8358612060546875,
-0.11982187628746033,
-0.9118348956108093,
-0.03828192874789238,
0.38113731145858765,
-0.007841997779905796,
-0.9953799843788147,
0.21907253563404083,
-0.13619592785835266,
0.9685365557670593,
-1.1995956897735596,
0.445406973361969,
1.0801411867141724,
-0.2591264247894287,
-0.8913389444351196,
-0.06441095471382141,
0.3318270146846771,
-0.6928355097770691,
0.7719899415969849,
0.07740677148103714,
0.016929874196648598,
-0.3890174925327301,
-0.6403221487998962,
-0.9622616767883301,
1.0454192161560059,
-0.04109066724777222,
-0.4248976707458496,
0.3680793344974518,
0.01362584624439478,
0.7471345067024231,
-0.4489445388317108,
-0.04349822551012039,
0.7885236740112305,
0.5477712750434875,
0.10204629600048065,
-0.40720292925834656,
0.21820910274982452,
-0.19811582565307617,
0.42009109258651733,
0.15443778038024902,
-0.3609364926815033,
0.7029016017913818,
-0.12730391323566437,
-0.19423997402191162,
-0.0586528480052948,
0.8321896195411682,
0.049762871116399765,
0.1165834441781044,
0.7192999124526978,
0.5608344674110413,
0.8495950102806091,
-0.2649677097797394,
1.2140350341796875,
-0.23840874433517456,
0.16608451306819916,
0.6660743951797485,
0.22111396491527557,
0.8156217336654663,
0.3190648555755615,
-0.6061936616897583,
0.7379004955291748,
0.4613032341003418,
0.062505342066288,
0.2876400351524353,
0.21160133183002472,
0.2633959949016571,
-0.17886081337928772,
-0.03156489133834839,
-0.19970719516277313,
0.952826976776123,
0.7787984013557434,
-0.40692058205604553,
0.19043461978435516,
0.010761748068034649,
-0.36417335271835327,
0.1942729651927948,
-0.0008511574123986065,
0.3960510194301605,
0.369789719581604,
-0.12164560705423355,
-0.18429253995418549,
0.2941235303878784,
0.504684567451477,
-0.1968570351600647,
-0.42089980840682983,
-0.06812036037445068,
0.19362621009349823,
-0.3818085491657257,
-0.9926922917366028,
0.3265456557273865,
-0.3265381455421448,
-0.3652876317501068,
-0.3026312589645386,
0.7798762917518616,
0.024036893621087074,
-0.7255642414093018,
0.3943089246749878,
0.5758782625198364,
0.253727525472641,
-0.00043810749775730073,
-0.5311659574508667,
0.10254344344139099,
-0.2835168242454529,
0.09106231480836868,
0.28392598032951355,
0.673072099685669,
-0.2834082245826721,
0.663924515247345,
0.8322626948356628,
0.2825591266155243,
-0.18820643424987793,
0.17036353051662445,
0.6601427793502808,
-0.8519684076309204,
-0.779752790927887,
-0.6384104490280151,
0.29333868622779846,
-0.030776996165513992,
-0.23085570335388184,
0.645156741142273,
0.007741368841379881,
0.5624978542327881,
-0.05975501984357834,
0.4587264358997345,
-0.20573782920837402,
0.3702642023563385,
-0.49649205803871155,
0.7917641997337341,
-0.5542830228805542,
0.3454044461250305,
-0.4580242931842804,
-1.2097432613372803,
-0.23280705511569977,
0.956084132194519,
-0.4042574465274811,
0.268348753452301,
0.7270678877830505,
0.5207201838493347,
0.010359443724155426,
0.02489851601421833,
0.6562234163284302,
0.3332040011882782,
0.42782601714134216,
0.17215649783611298,
1.124772548675537,
-0.21255794167518616,
-0.07101792097091675,
-0.33837831020355225,
-0.36855772137641907,
-0.30417463183403015,
-1.0081119537353516,
-0.7722106575965881,
-0.6982600092887878,
-0.28502029180526733,
-0.33877331018447876,
-0.22803881764411926,
0.8835145831108093,
0.790861189365387,
-0.7409452795982361,
0.24289695918560028,
0.2965119183063507,
0.18435434997081757,
-0.464291512966156,
-0.2582038640975952,
0.6301662921905518,
0.168375164270401,
-0.5711156725883484,
0.2255878746509552,
0.47214585542678833,
-0.11361372470855713,
-0.6953487992286682,
-0.06474120914936066,
0.3221738636493683,
0.3233834207057953,
0.8055960536003113,
-0.11328182369470596,
-0.5874708294868469,
-1.0686383247375488,
-0.20185263454914093,
0.051268257200717926,
-0.004653542768210173,
0.9044241309165955,
-0.5059544444084167,
0.7150331735610962,
0.8949285745620728,
0.23661953210830688,
0.020250532776117325,
0.02989785559475422,
0.8599513173103333,
-1.1430262327194214,
0.3125164806842804,
-0.08528108149766922,
0.6457711458206177,
0.4834384322166443,
-0.6470564603805542,
0.537083625793457,
0.273618221282959,
-0.3111511766910553,
-0.38361063599586487,
0.07327692955732346,
-0.7736124396324158,
-0.44603273272514343,
0.9886070489883423,
-0.30655160546302795,
-0.24534915387630463,
-0.04485003277659416,
-0.08984913676977158,
0.047165434807538986,
-0.16169407963752747,
0.9055134654045105,
0.860884428024292,
0.011489721946418285,
-0.12310602515935898,
-0.5627606511116028,
0.5238652229309082,
0.07550953328609467,
-0.4532012343406677,
-0.4306909739971161,
0.3344987630844116,
0.3318174183368683,
0.4527895450592041,
0.19079940021038055,
-0.2944246232509613,
0.21868927776813507,
0.2898070216178894,
0.03494030982255936,
-0.13276909291744232,
-0.6526250839233398,
-0.5209452509880066,
0.05328700318932533,
0.2242652177810669,
-0.4373925030231476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02616v1
|
Improving Topic Relevance Model by Mix-structured Summarization and LLM-based Data Augmentation
| 2024-04-03T10:05:47 | 2024-04-03T10:05:47 |
Yizhu Liu, Ran Tao, Shengyu Guo, Yifan Yang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Topic relevance between query and document is a very important part of social
search, which can evaluate the degree of matching between document and user's
requirement. In most social search scenarios such as Dianping, modeling search
relevance always faces two challenges. One is that many documents in social
search are very long and have much redundant information. The other is that the
training data for search relevance model is difficult to get, especially for
multi-classification relevance model. To tackle above two problems, we first
take query concatenated with the query-based summary and the document summary
without query as the input of topic relevance model, which can help model learn
the relevance degree between query and the core topic of document. Then, we
utilize the language understanding and generation abilities of large language
model (LLM) to rewrite and generate query from queries and documents in
existing training data, which can construct new query-document pairs as
training data. Extensive offline experiments and online A/B tests show that the
proposed approaches effectively improve the performance of relevance modeling.
|
[
-0.17787399888038635,
-0.8624820709228516,
0.5793553590774536,
-0.06767763197422028,
-0.5148627758026123,
0.36580073833465576,
-0.06692060828208923,
-0.22257933020591736,
0.7463386654853821,
0.623244047164917,
-0.3793940842151642,
-0.5119875073432922,
-0.7808349132537842,
-0.1171082854270935,
-0.6352018713951111,
0.802408754825592,
0.20510922372341156,
0.0603657104074955,
-0.38437724113464355,
-0.05035244673490524,
-0.261237233877182,
-0.5530940890312195,
-0.4335261583328247,
-0.15781733393669128,
0.34975552558898926,
0.4826960861682892,
0.42690375447273254,
0.30217957496643066,
0.5160459280014038,
0.2777947783470154,
-0.5887662768363953,
0.3896247148513794,
-1.0270440578460693,
0.25815579295158386,
-0.2557464838027954,
-0.4790743589401245,
-0.6088219881057739,
-0.029794475063681602,
0.7802872657775879,
0.922614574432373,
-0.08603601902723312,
-0.1851062923669815,
0.15041741728782654,
0.6482821702957153,
-0.3315455913543701,
-0.054557330906391144,
-0.9960947632789612,
-0.5380653738975525,
-0.17175638675689697,
-0.5731692314147949,
-0.1969616711139679,
-0.29511702060699463,
0.024896427989006042,
-0.4306217432022095,
0.6948997974395752,
-0.11186803877353668,
0.770383894443512,
-0.0879167839884758,
-0.5489422082901001,
-0.20505544543266296,
-0.45642951130867004,
0.4991229474544525,
-0.7429900169372559,
0.27524974942207336,
0.5668894648551941,
0.24096158146858215,
-0.2505575120449066,
-0.7434948682785034,
-0.36673521995544434,
0.01732039824128151,
0.015746435150504112,
0.15791133046150208,
0.5543009042739868,
-0.015682747587561607,
0.09850187599658966,
0.705405592918396,
-0.44534924626350403,
-0.239441379904747,
-0.5615735054016113,
-0.03916366025805473,
0.7534123063087463,
0.25016751885414124,
0.2072836458683014,
-0.3283480405807495,
0.05884547904133797,
-0.04517237842082977,
-0.6114385724067688,
-0.06632499396800995,
0.28807899355888367,
0.4233923852443695,
-0.04923643171787262,
0.8537800908088684,
-0.6841789484024048,
0.6622604727745056,
0.16244946420192719,
-0.2193734049797058,
0.34779393672943115,
-0.7973419427871704,
0.2699768543243408,
-0.08749964833259583,
0.2748558819293976,
0.5529314875602722,
-0.2055772840976715,
-0.24024897813796997,
-0.07217974215745926,
-0.20764659345149994,
0.2515623867511749,
-0.9434730410575867,
0.2735448181629181,
0.3347495198249817,
-0.5371754169464111,
-0.1382899284362793,
0.1773485690355301,
-0.5350319147109985,
-0.21370504796504974,
-0.30762094259262085,
0.204069584608078,
-0.3348076343536377,
-0.18497949838638306,
0.21435026824474335,
-0.19853098690509796,
0.3743108808994293,
0.6564826965332031,
-0.8307137489318848,
-0.0117294667288661,
0.9753162860870361,
1.0059764385223389,
-0.2149607241153717,
-0.17380353808403015,
-0.4166419506072998,
0.25662779808044434,
-0.15507183969020844,
0.7052844762802124,
-0.5453380346298218,
-0.6081275939941406,
-0.046271272003650665,
0.018544821068644524,
-0.07476436346769333,
-0.280839741230011,
0.5111022591590881,
-0.9725668430328369,
0.2693915069103241,
-0.2709093987941742,
-0.8724544644355774,
-0.06097095459699631,
0.36223846673965454,
-0.4858395457267761,
1.1311389207839966,
0.09766141325235367,
-1.0074330568313599,
0.3871002197265625,
-0.40885013341903687,
-0.6194631457328796,
0.19981643557548523,
-0.027640370652079582,
-0.26323020458221436,
0.1697084605693817,
0.3170788288116455,
0.5045903921127319,
-0.280386358499527,
0.6714744567871094,
-0.3911307752132416,
-0.6021677851676941,
-0.09915925562381744,
0.00014891193131916225,
0.30437880754470825,
-0.10946939885616302,
0.12967868149280548,
0.24112939834594727,
-0.6521317958831787,
-0.24890995025634766,
0.11380759626626968,
-0.5514922142028809,
-0.4487899839878082,
0.05899672955274582,
0.005559937097132206,
0.14530524611473083,
0.5067449808120728,
-0.3033725917339325,
0.060574159026145935,
-0.7844099402427673,
0.11619621515274048,
0.37999463081359863,
0.3954842984676361,
0.6722639799118042,
-0.40410590171813965,
0.35136279463768005,
-0.23742052912712097,
-0.18744313716888428,
-0.40542304515838623,
-0.7431138157844543,
-0.5875216126441956,
0.028063399717211723,
0.45924168825149536,
0.44375231862068176,
-0.801117479801178,
0.6415317058563232,
-0.5394593477249146,
-0.602776288986206,
-0.45549288392066956,
0.14997905492782593,
-0.07512880861759186,
0.573932409286499,
0.22235944867134094,
-0.3222450911998749,
-0.39396631717681885,
-0.43947669863700867,
-0.027096891775727272,
-0.021803628653287888,
-0.0918472558259964,
0.5883499383926392,
0.3380509316921234,
-0.31218045949935913,
0.7735722661018372,
-0.7184224128723145,
-0.11572273075580597,
-0.5598557591438293,
0.02557499334216118,
0.601482629776001,
0.13292808830738068,
0.3577654957771301,
-1.1326959133148193,
-0.48097923398017883,
-0.235123410820961,
-0.6359243988990784,
0.03371230512857437,
0.29188239574432373,
-0.1732422411441803,
-0.06694287061691284,
0.47182467579841614,
-0.5026172995567322,
0.5297404527664185,
-0.07191257178783417,
-0.12837879359722137,
0.3403800427913666,
-0.2599416673183441,
0.4394247233867645,
-1.5200562477111816,
0.02956082485616207,
-0.06400594115257263,
-0.20367120206356049,
-0.5464785099029541,
0.2408205270767212,
0.10202810913324356,
-0.5187892913818359,
-0.45760029554367065,
0.6997964978218079,
-0.20788119733333588,
-0.06384420394897461,
-0.7497261762619019,
0.4002278745174408,
0.08245684951543808,
0.1605181246995926,
0.09632819145917892,
0.7400602102279663,
0.7302210330963135,
-0.7346103191375732,
0.2325090765953064,
0.27971354126930237,
-0.006225405260920525,
0.22436809539794922,
-0.805031955242157,
-0.017478374764323235,
-0.2668662667274475,
0.3864426910877228,
-1.1315853595733643,
-0.37517088651657104,
-0.26253458857536316,
-0.528459370136261,
0.35512515902519226,
-0.186252161860466,
-0.739078164100647,
-0.1487564742565155,
-0.7173264026641846,
0.35164427757263184,
0.1967388540506363,
-0.32583099603652954,
0.45840904116630554,
0.5323814749717712,
-0.36363452672958374,
-0.4049626290798187,
-0.16013813018798828,
0.24061957001686096,
-0.20682020485401154,
-0.88578200340271,
0.9649113416671753,
-0.12016110122203827,
0.010736286640167236,
-0.25335776805877686,
-0.1107870563864708,
0.1202121376991272,
0.1361790895462036,
-0.0037607839331030846,
0.08556390553712845,
-0.014700599946081638,
0.23341183364391327,
0.15123048424720764,
-0.051074691116809845,
-0.3667130768299103,
0.2176510989665985,
0.7896488308906555,
0.2902511656284332,
-0.37724626064300537,
0.03213474899530411,
0.5531048774719238,
0.48810508847236633,
-0.2633135914802551,
0.9454727172851562,
0.57106614112854,
-0.4679681062698364,
0.24651333689689636,
-0.620622456073761,
-0.5473349094390869,
-0.41687798500061035,
0.531085193157196,
-0.2850019335746765,
-0.9468823671340942,
0.69507896900177,
-0.20215550065040588,
-0.09912339597940445,
0.444092333316803,
0.6563417911529541,
-0.062583789229393,
0.6295120120048523,
0.556088924407959,
-0.2721165716648102,
0.70848149061203,
-0.30650198459625244,
0.023906804621219635,
-0.891242504119873,
-0.3126278519630432,
-0.485668420791626,
0.059634894132614136,
-0.7489542961120605,
-0.4948345124721527,
0.30948692560195923,
0.2659580707550049,
0.3204110860824585,
0.29179173707962036,
-0.39209991693496704,
0.2328280210494995,
0.39337414503097534,
0.5743610858917236,
0.1894836723804474,
0.2332586795091629,
0.06605947762727737,
-0.045650746673345566,
-0.4819382429122925,
-0.30660340189933777,
1.360897421836853,
0.06781512498855591,
0.813231885433197,
0.17678362131118774,
0.7879258394241333,
0.3937813639640808,
-0.07158999890089035,
-0.5406166315078735,
0.4833891689777374,
-0.22625771164894104,
-0.5353955030441284,
-0.2526305913925171,
-0.44867733120918274,
-0.8591678142547607,
0.49140435457229614,
-0.19978436827659607,
-0.6256836652755737,
0.07770373672246933,
-0.1988871544599533,
0.06257882714271545,
-0.010601176880300045,
-0.422203004360199,
0.4074517488479614,
-0.1055947095155716,
-0.6048155426979065,
-0.38577592372894287,
-0.7519829273223877,
0.2547188997268677,
-0.10898575931787491,
0.0693216472864151,
0.025884943082928658,
0.025191685184836388,
0.6577633619308472,
-0.343628466129303,
0.5980976223945618,
0.13840509951114655,
-0.05563366040587425,
0.11518535017967224,
-0.40423160791397095,
0.4738321304321289,
0.35609757900238037,
-0.48188555240631104,
-0.26676931977272034,
-0.5457108020782471,
-0.42129576206207275,
-0.6561641097068787,
0.6692394018173218,
-0.4691977798938751,
-0.9232579469680786,
-0.14347407221794128,
-0.6015536785125732,
-0.11445203423500061,
0.19224058091640472,
0.23476095497608185,
0.39578792452812195,
-0.2624463140964508,
0.45936182141304016,
0.8203938603401184,
-0.1502120941877365,
0.19637708365917206,
0.5650584101676941,
-0.2360161542892456,
-0.4585592746734619,
0.7187951803207397,
-0.013861337676644325,
0.06558524817228317,
0.7138655185699463,
0.021318534389138222,
-0.5000675916671753,
-0.6094679832458496,
-0.07600833475589752,
0.41510552167892456,
-0.7619696259498596,
-0.15807665884494781,
-1.0968849658966064,
-0.4710005819797516,
-0.8179858922958374,
-0.1597987562417984,
-0.11282326281070709,
-0.34255391359329224,
-0.49642646312713623,
-0.11477050185203552,
0.3183739483356476,
0.3445403575897217,
0.12070679664611816,
0.4191599488258362,
-0.6247524619102478,
0.5933220386505127,
0.10040701925754547,
0.19579075276851654,
-0.02476082183420658,
-0.9882145524024963,
-0.22841641306877136,
0.025329656898975372,
-0.39051100611686707,
-0.9393322467803955,
0.20980480313301086,
0.21153412759304047,
0.7410728931427002,
0.27257871627807617,
-0.02967747673392296,
0.4747624099254608,
-0.2207857370376587,
0.5654646158218384,
-0.19312039017677307,
-0.6320012211799622,
1.036806583404541,
-0.5452287793159485,
-0.0009937239810824394,
0.7292995452880859,
0.36433693766593933,
-0.2297799438238144,
-0.32311511039733887,
-0.6501314640045166,
-1.3554713726043701,
0.6614565253257751,
0.4864468276500702,
0.34939542412757874,
0.2639269530773163,
0.6759518980979919,
-0.10030017793178558,
0.2684374749660492,
-0.580234706401825,
-0.21490561962127686,
-0.13986711204051971,
0.07341086119413376,
-0.17433685064315796,
-0.530644953250885,
0.27228179574012756,
-0.4965948164463043,
0.7752404808998108,
-0.009343849495053291,
0.023058809340000153,
0.040166664868593216,
-0.07956632971763611,
0.18959957361221313,
0.16556331515312195,
0.5820946097373962,
0.8585872650146484,
-0.6970518827438354,
-0.31210896372795105,
0.13258220255374908,
-0.32129910588264465,
0.02232498489320278,
0.34144389629364014,
-0.14747045934200287,
0.10573801398277283,
0.3532472550868988,
0.5304069519042969,
0.24349583685398102,
-0.3641761839389801,
0.5221470594406128,
-0.08499178290367126,
-0.020709780976176262,
0.11260803788900375,
0.3042297065258026,
0.474303662776947,
-0.03724528104066849,
0.6030307412147522,
-0.43981608748435974,
0.44175276160240173,
-0.6045188307762146,
0.490960955619812,
0.40621745586395264,
-0.11767210066318512,
0.03602302446961403,
0.5209155678749084,
0.19885513186454773,
-0.265483558177948,
0.48593735694885254,
-0.1910732537508011,
-0.6296164989471436,
0.6607811450958252,
0.6555071473121643,
0.3185751736164093,
-0.35668280720710754,
0.12483607232570648,
0.4046759009361267,
0.07766970247030258,
-0.1209440678358078,
0.3353923559188843,
-0.18687178194522858,
-0.5863596200942993,
-0.3542625308036804,
-0.6060072183609009,
-0.5047078132629395,
0.10485978424549103,
-0.5255222916603088,
0.5551358461380005,
0.014552694745361805,
-0.06599890440702438,
0.10016798228025436,
0.37407198548316956,
-0.22903697192668915,
0.2435608208179474,
-0.4726852774620056,
0.7127346396446228,
-0.7688378691673279,
0.7005728483200073,
0.887238085269928,
-0.39932283759117126,
-0.34317851066589355,
0.2823944687843323,
-0.43958210945129395,
-0.4452252686023712,
0.4326053857803345,
0.21028539538383484,
0.02037747949361801,
-0.018099481239914894,
-0.34621021151542664,
-0.8333845734596252,
1.2641170024871826,
0.2802969515323639,
-0.17734909057617188,
-0.1380365788936615,
-0.016425007954239845,
0.5260764360427856,
-0.45437195897102356,
0.45281556248664856,
0.136235773563385,
0.1571405827999115,
0.541479229927063,
-0.6451134085655212,
-0.0635802373290062,
-0.3454023003578186,
0.11664816737174988,
0.04667631536722183,
-0.5062689185142517,
0.6941961050033569,
-0.07715116441249847,
-0.07796040922403336,
-0.10959672927856445,
0.6631419658660889,
0.5406718254089355,
0.6730784773826599,
-0.0328838974237442,
0.5636983513832092,
0.6550452709197998,
0.10215536504983902,
0.9757625460624695,
-0.3883529603481293,
0.5018832087516785,
1.1678931713104248,
-0.5203286409378052,
0.8037235140800476,
0.16057449579238892,
-0.10734652727842331,
-0.03967292234301567,
1.0380470752716064,
0.1511407196521759,
0.7620670795440674,
0.057502832263708115,
-0.22080907225608826,
-0.25435736775398254,
-0.22142741084098816,
-0.7838150262832642,
0.4033183455467224,
0.6660267114639282,
-0.437671035528183,
-0.4937061667442322,
-0.21570032835006714,
-0.1745159924030304,
0.16186822950839996,
-0.22259899973869324,
0.9970768094062805,
0.07005956023931503,
-0.4299367368221283,
0.2825460731983185,
0.3605404794216156,
0.7741689085960388,
-0.4553229510784149,
-0.057819318026304245,
-0.5383166074752808,
-0.21397307515144348,
-0.1074819415807724,
-0.570591390132904,
0.34798070788383484,
-0.27849477529525757,
-0.5133695006370544,
0.15678107738494873,
1.1396511793136597,
-0.380482941865921,
-0.75250244140625,
0.33017513155937195,
0.6705948114395142,
0.12418872117996216,
-0.29956212639808655,
-0.6657385230064392,
-0.27016282081604004,
-0.04648091644048691,
-0.012413162738084793,
0.3908388614654541,
0.5065717101097107,
0.046729493886232376,
0.5848807096481323,
0.7478920221328735,
0.060468461364507675,
-0.1458289921283722,
0.18203628063201904,
1.1796841621398926,
-0.7039484977722168,
-0.7608183026313782,
-0.8665478825569153,
0.06974580138921738,
-0.45143452286720276,
0.15316829085350037,
0.6053280830383301,
0.8366064429283142,
0.5254075527191162,
0.27880173921585083,
0.45562735199928284,
0.04754673317074776,
0.6438719034194946,
-0.5715892314910889,
0.8841791749000549,
-0.9197148084640503,
0.49533459544181824,
-0.48409461975097656,
-0.9584338068962097,
-0.08847193419933319,
0.24567189812660217,
-0.3181147873401642,
0.4345676600933075,
0.33373579382896423,
0.9215883612632751,
-0.42819762229919434,
-0.1250840127468109,
0.42645907402038574,
-0.10393425822257996,
0.20062284171581268,
0.209747314453125,
0.6072024703025818,
-0.5296106934547424,
0.2046053111553192,
0.007719954010099173,
-0.22581340372562408,
-0.7045595049858093,
-0.6487290859222412,
-0.9317008256912231,
-0.7965198755264282,
-0.30085745453834534,
-0.33547350764274597,
0.1445828378200531,
0.5071547031402588,
0.8391237854957581,
-0.5181413888931274,
-0.01603546179831028,
0.14092254638671875,
0.5155150890350342,
0.337033212184906,
-0.28287696838378906,
0.7289600372314453,
-0.3048122227191925,
-0.4682057797908783,
0.3996221423149109,
0.2631607949733734,
0.025619860738515854,
-0.0646686777472496,
0.014519508928060532,
-0.6215776205062866,
0.013960447162389755,
0.7290259003639221,
-0.2143019437789917,
-0.5168300867080688,
0.35527801513671875,
0.062471263110637665,
-0.09668858349323273,
0.2624732255935669,
0.7699853181838989,
-0.5521616339683533,
0.3352918326854706,
0.7450799345970154,
0.8015050292015076,
0.8479422926902771,
0.43766340613365173,
0.47413966059684753,
-0.9226028323173523,
0.06843580305576324,
-0.08724180608987808,
0.40429118275642395,
0.6299657225608826,
-0.8014655113220215,
0.6142735481262207,
0.29306092858314514,
-0.34837591648101807,
-0.6279809474945068,
0.1765206754207611,
-0.9672801494598389,
-0.2055070996284485,
1.126423716545105,
-0.014934050850570202,
-0.01334567740559578,
-0.2350427508354187,
-0.173617422580719,
0.4965269863605499,
-0.5773819088935852,
0.8971413373947144,
0.47287827730178833,
0.043180227279663086,
-0.148202583193779,
-0.41099148988723755,
0.011888721026480198,
0.1760791391134262,
-0.8188869953155518,
-0.1313929259777069,
0.16656489670276642,
0.30814263224601746,
0.24161425232887268,
0.7773322463035583,
-0.20144514739513397,
0.24373963475227356,
-0.2928578853607178,
-0.2565896809101105,
0.17996276915073395,
-0.1373174488544464,
-0.04361651837825775,
0.337219774723053,
0.1222706064581871,
-0.1318088322877884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02592v1
|
Leveraging the Interplay Between Syntactic and Acoustic Cues for Optimizing Korean TTS Pause Formation
| 2024-04-03T09:17:38 | 2024-04-03T09:17:38 |
Yejin Jeon, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Contemporary neural speech synthesis models have indeed demonstrated
remarkable proficiency in synthetic speech generation as they have attained a
level of quality comparable to that of human-produced speech. Nevertheless, it
is important to note that these achievements have predominantly been verified
within the context of high-resource languages such as English. Furthermore, the
Tacotron and FastSpeech variants show substantial pausing errors when applied
to the Korean language, which affects speech perception and naturalness. In
order to address the aforementioned issues, we propose a novel framework that
incorporates comprehensive modeling of both syntactic and acoustic cues that
are associated with pausing patterns. Remarkably, our framework possesses the
capability to consistently generate natural speech even for considerably more
extended and intricate out-of-domain (OOD) sentences, despite its training on
short audio clips. Architectural design choices are validated through
comparisons with baseline models and ablation studies using subjective and
objective metrics, thus confirming model performance.
|
[
-0.5785459876060486,
-0.8971694111824036,
0.48262834548950195,
0.42478489875793457,
-0.33309313654899597,
0.4672161340713501,
-0.37952882051467896,
-0.4250771701335907,
0.3408462703227997,
0.29214155673980713,
-0.4995633363723755,
-0.3884007930755615,
-0.21188510954380035,
0.25832170248031616,
-0.08248752355575562,
0.4854607582092285,
0.10819528996944427,
0.11754291504621506,
0.21741768717765808,
-0.01972801424562931,
-0.538078248500824,
-0.22321921586990356,
-0.934266209602356,
-0.27962008118629456,
0.18232059478759766,
0.32635238766670227,
0.7732142210006714,
0.9799531698226929,
-0.3465176820755005,
0.20641441643238068,
-0.48103711009025574,
0.22829987108707428,
0.07896990329027176,
0.5576425194740295,
0.05912860110402107,
-0.11231442540884018,
-0.35206857323646545,
-0.26635855436325073,
0.8204554319381714,
0.6260298490524292,
-0.09354141354560852,
0.02065841481089592,
0.21431845426559448,
0.12576644122600555,
-0.17192396521568298,
0.06941342353820801,
-0.591482400894165,
0.1664578765630722,
-0.20953834056854248,
-0.38050150871276855,
-0.39487379789352417,
-0.4850575625896454,
0.4957956075668335,
-0.5526665449142456,
0.11347848176956177,
-0.2645311951637268,
0.8437399864196777,
0.423310786485672,
-0.2197200208902359,
-0.21535475552082062,
-0.888405442237854,
0.6250041723251343,
-0.9717916250228882,
0.8593682646751404,
0.17061662673950195,
0.17736108601093292,
-0.1804100126028061,
-0.7033869624137878,
-0.3939354717731476,
-0.4063236713409424,
0.1211659163236618,
0.11155997961759567,
0.1202174574136734,
0.4204820990562439,
0.01998283341526985,
-0.12524737417697906,
-0.5731247067451477,
0.44264885783195496,
-0.3664822280406952,
-0.42425423860549927,
0.3769761621952057,
0.15739701688289642,
0.44470053911209106,
-0.5238391757011414,
-0.39567530155181885,
0.12603336572647095,
-0.640081524848938,
0.14046207070350647,
0.5748546123504639,
0.7999292612075806,
-0.13894006609916687,
0.5106335878372192,
-0.18907999992370605,
0.819419801235199,
0.06314957141876221,
-0.2873646914958954,
-0.04830252379179001,
-0.5831647515296936,
-0.011441046372056007,
0.4686605930328369,
0.6642183065414429,
0.30549028515815735,
0.18072248995304108,
-0.22100697457790375,
0.05343909189105034,
0.27622634172439575,
0.22717219591140747,
-0.7333996295928955,
-0.014476483687758446,
0.5325058102607727,
-0.34654414653778076,
-0.19079765677452087,
-0.14751671254634857,
-0.9122360348701477,
0.108866848051548,
-0.6619800925254822,
0.216915100812912,
-0.321699321269989,
-0.44762614369392395,
0.09972219914197922,
-0.1387975662946701,
-0.35496360063552856,
-0.3384703993797302,
-0.6062694191932678,
0.29888612031936646,
0.15269209444522858,
1.1338399648666382,
-0.2312920093536377,
-0.4940909743309021,
-0.5513452887535095,
0.10950087010860443,
-0.5025515556335449,
0.5635913610458374,
-0.32288146018981934,
-0.642000675201416,
-0.16949589550495148,
-0.11559783667325974,
-0.03696008771657944,
-0.6148862242698669,
0.4110543429851532,
-0.302837073802948,
0.22951939702033997,
0.03755855932831764,
-0.5125805139541626,
0.00045227064401842654,
-0.12378716468811035,
-0.8874644041061401,
1.0186522006988525,
0.12977172434329987,
-0.3876113295555115,
0.454685240983963,
-0.90128093957901,
-0.6185678243637085,
-0.0022607084829360247,
-0.10301724076271057,
-0.38319775462150574,
0.16119374334812164,
0.140379399061203,
0.15211550891399384,
-0.17270606756210327,
0.2996160387992859,
0.1007818952202797,
-0.18142342567443848,
0.4200643002986908,
-0.31810250878334045,
0.5655574798583984,
0.3036879003047943,
-0.46504929661750793,
0.15747644007205963,
-0.9031287431716919,
0.5839053988456726,
0.04199633374810219,
-0.475644588470459,
-0.31933578848838806,
-0.20787104964256287,
0.18885664641857147,
0.39661067724227905,
-0.269299179315567,
-0.3702455759048462,
-0.20473594963550568,
-0.5506601929664612,
0.8774498105049133,
0.4618471562862396,
0.5010150671005249,
0.471926212310791,
-0.11177214235067368,
0.895601212978363,
-0.19669237732887268,
-0.06907851994037628,
-0.5345378518104553,
-0.3381894826889038,
-0.3115411102771759,
-0.5340437293052673,
0.6022322177886963,
0.37186136841773987,
-0.9117862582206726,
0.3240874707698822,
0.07543548941612244,
-0.21051713824272156,
-0.7148193120956421,
-0.41527000069618225,
0.6015112996101379,
0.7530516982078552,
0.40015146136283875,
-0.03355647996068001,
-0.9435675144195557,
-0.558199405670166,
-0.2908015549182892,
-0.0671597272157669,
-0.15816912055015564,
0.0914744958281517,
0.07386147230863571,
0.36562711000442505,
1.1542245149612427,
-0.10200302302837372,
0.09309186786413193,
-0.2592814564704895,
0.13399671018123627,
0.18116600811481476,
0.28210100531578064,
0.456341415643692,
-0.6251155734062195,
-0.395523339509964,
-0.17285849153995514,
-0.5135055780410767,
-0.3397687077522278,
-0.2869873344898224,
-0.015477637760341167,
0.48332345485687256,
0.7978174090385437,
-0.8773855566978455,
0.4110930263996124,
0.2073504775762558,
-0.385976642370224,
0.8396804928779602,
0.19933518767356873,
0.23769745230674744,
-1.0731182098388672,
0.13315998017787933,
-0.2736414074897766,
-0.05093485116958618,
-0.9987286925315857,
-0.22079148888587952,
-0.2584898769855499,
-0.27247434854507446,
-0.833178699016571,
0.8134873509407043,
-0.4114566445350647,
-0.1361541897058487,
-0.34781041741371155,
0.31845176219940186,
0.2715733051300049,
0.3739510178565979,
0.16039299964904785,
0.8747984766960144,
0.25845932960510254,
-1.0454246997833252,
-0.1845889836549759,
0.3866735100746155,
-0.3212907910346985,
0.47970932722091675,
-0.9276406764984131,
0.06766130030155182,
0.15605497360229492,
0.1379382312297821,
-0.8764947056770325,
-0.6372923254966736,
0.11858352273702621,
-0.649986207485199,
0.3552626371383667,
-0.5562599301338196,
-0.33702051639556885,
-0.30811309814453125,
-0.018526706844568253,
0.5585196614265442,
0.5841464400291443,
-0.6082627773284912,
0.5139216184616089,
0.5240591168403625,
-0.584635853767395,
-0.15516120195388794,
-0.6223728060722351,
0.04176785796880722,
-0.44513601064682007,
-0.6416011452674866,
0.6007209420204163,
0.18427525460720062,
-0.31211090087890625,
0.03285149112343788,
-0.3239433765411377,
0.05418232083320618,
-0.11363577842712402,
-0.03918341547250748,
0.32471954822540283,
-0.4103204905986786,
0.12302129715681076,
0.32942312955856323,
-0.23289553821086884,
-0.22400422394275665,
-0.6996243596076965,
0.9290452599525452,
0.3281204104423523,
0.01603982225060463,
-0.7012167572975159,
0.30830979347229004,
0.7631067037582397,
-0.237741619348526,
0.37865015864372253,
0.3546726703643799,
-0.4021841883659363,
-0.3004262149333954,
0.02128935605287552,
-0.4059911072254181,
-0.4817880392074585,
0.5539215803146362,
-0.2468850463628769,
-0.7111852765083313,
0.606550395488739,
0.11096829175949097,
-0.16831479966640472,
-0.06614527851343155,
0.5781312584877014,
0.236504927277565,
1.0843186378479004,
0.13730351626873016,
0.2855599820613861,
0.5847930312156677,
-0.06842987984418869,
0.21370083093643188,
-0.7828831076622009,
-0.06318212300539017,
-0.4784015715122223,
-0.03537625074386597,
-0.4135061502456665,
-0.29834631085395813,
0.5533868074417114,
0.06996259838342667,
-0.3455490469932556,
0.3543936014175415,
-0.4844587445259094,
0.6160218715667725,
0.45546218752861023,
-0.16219833493232727,
0.0027797885704785585,
-0.06548123061656952,
-0.3718133866786957,
-0.42995941638946533,
-0.8773342967033386,
-0.5544226169586182,
0.6899952292442322,
0.14555002748966217,
0.448350727558136,
-0.29006218910217285,
0.5543982982635498,
0.17261749505996704,
-0.5613124966621399,
-0.7176763415336609,
0.5541593432426453,
-0.1008300632238388,
-0.4261219799518585,
-0.5127135515213013,
-0.3502439260482788,
-0.9322986602783203,
0.15170438587665558,
0.18556983768939972,
-0.7723137736320496,
-0.15149152278900146,
0.309223473072052,
-0.7455061078071594,
0.17617441713809967,
-0.6651631593704224,
0.8151547908782959,
-0.1491309404373169,
-0.3503604531288147,
0.2638324797153473,
-0.705966591835022,
0.08750181645154953,
0.27355244755744934,
-0.014315362088382244,
-0.09135943651199341,
-0.010109740309417248,
0.4991495907306671,
-0.27231311798095703,
0.6437345147132874,
-0.3683755397796631,
0.1339075118303299,
0.5560770630836487,
0.2726460099220276,
0.23945863544940948,
0.09045103192329407,
0.04654723405838013,
0.07541866600513458,
-0.2433130294084549,
-0.09186061471700668,
-0.4316903352737427,
0.392667293548584,
-0.29497432708740234,
-0.1079583689570427,
0.05564713478088379,
-0.4753747582435608,
-0.4832260012626648,
0.3814844787120819,
0.771353006362915,
0.6710608005523682,
-0.30043622851371765,
-0.2179088443517685,
0.5040957927703857,
-0.45105162262916565,
0.5818025469779968,
0.21104685962200165,
-0.3798028826713562,
-0.8327237963676453,
0.6013256311416626,
0.43195730447769165,
0.7583266496658325,
-0.22596074640750885,
0.13995487987995148,
-0.7293409109115601,
-0.6438023447990417,
-0.592224657535553,
0.13699297606945038,
-0.6006596088409424,
-0.18734495341777802,
-0.4137401580810547,
-0.5656886696815491,
-0.3712739050388336,
-0.09800951182842255,
-0.6306193470954895,
-0.630182147026062,
-0.22401222586631775,
-0.39993467926979065,
0.2624633312225342,
0.5387543439865112,
0.005520664155483246,
0.3875865042209625,
-0.9078149199485779,
0.32559502124786377,
-0.12637017667293549,
0.3433172404766083,
0.28798457980155945,
-0.6629642248153687,
-0.19538633525371552,
0.07553613185882568,
-0.061330679804086685,
-0.6945528388023376,
0.5327524542808533,
0.2078954130411148,
0.5450966358184814,
0.061655692756175995,
0.09756612032651901,
0.7104608416557312,
-0.7696581482887268,
1.0266506671905518,
0.08303342014551163,
-0.9665055274963379,
0.6154146194458008,
-0.49430030584335327,
0.6595720648765564,
0.27804872393608093,
0.1253022849559784,
-0.6658309698104858,
-0.688349187374115,
-0.6060320734977722,
-1.252816915512085,
0.7565901875495911,
0.45436891913414,
-0.23533061146736145,
-0.3025749623775482,
0.11887767910957336,
0.25236913561820984,
0.2615184187889099,
-0.22820138931274414,
0.10813464224338531,
-0.23532581329345703,
-0.09795797616243362,
0.48336392641067505,
-0.002683257684111595,
-0.04812895879149437,
0.29219183325767517,
0.6543789505958557,
-0.10953152924776077,
0.23397748172283173,
0.12241707742214203,
0.04917708784341812,
-0.05850299447774887,
0.1957085132598877,
0.9187557697296143,
0.5811500549316406,
0.14774201810359955,
-0.07294290512800217,
-0.06365862488746643,
-0.5018788576126099,
0.2514834702014923,
0.04074198752641678,
-0.4011293649673462,
0.5965912938117981,
0.1377488225698471,
0.9305196404457092,
0.4307118058204651,
-0.5832868218421936,
-0.2280607521533966,
0.11158367991447449,
0.009392858482897282,
-0.24196550250053406,
-0.28069233894348145,
0.17205609381198883,
0.3152226209640503,
0.11835803091526031,
0.17430193722248077,
-0.027920354157686234,
-0.21440929174423218,
0.5258130431175232,
-0.05828632786870003,
-0.0761987715959549,
-0.6266785264015198,
1.080388069152832,
0.1927414983510971,
-0.58014315366745,
0.48346301913261414,
-0.1107344999909401,
-0.6653969287872314,
0.7815688252449036,
0.5242542028427124,
1.0311946868896484,
-0.48655879497528076,
0.3274230659008026,
0.480545312166214,
-0.0006424314924515784,
-0.22777289152145386,
0.5156551599502563,
-0.05007370933890343,
-0.38335657119750977,
-0.4935336410999298,
-0.5161349773406982,
-0.19287513196468353,
0.05315755680203438,
-0.7453863620758057,
0.4267844259738922,
-0.413515567779541,
-0.6009258031845093,
0.026009326800704002,
-0.435757040977478,
-0.3520151674747467,
0.08010397851467133,
0.18396133184432983,
0.6876316070556641,
-0.5706387162208557,
0.6517149209976196,
0.32146796584129333,
-0.3647363483905792,
-0.8788577914237976,
0.34095579385757446,
0.13198630511760712,
-0.4753768742084503,
0.4448900818824768,
0.267343133687973,
-0.2810385227203369,
-0.05659807100892067,
-0.047845516353845596,
-0.9872521758079529,
0.942550003528595,
0.5110870599746704,
-0.36572912335395813,
-0.31500017642974854,
0.28234800696372986,
0.5307268500328064,
-0.3030886948108673,
-0.2655661404132843,
0.8553335666656494,
0.2781304121017456,
0.07112006843090057,
-1.2359205484390259,
-0.06595312058925629,
-0.04467311128973961,
0.17199084162712097,
0.2981478273868561,
-0.5822049975395203,
0.7072771191596985,
-0.08331537991762161,
-0.4597947597503662,
0.5680370330810547,
0.1812829226255417,
0.6882032752037048,
0.44122427701950073,
0.41067808866500854,
0.364509254693985,
0.6113954782485962,
-0.180948406457901,
0.7279356718063354,
-0.4924035668373108,
-0.18704800307750702,
1.4470617771148682,
-0.27147620916366577,
0.5751874446868896,
0.5306524038314819,
-0.05072403326630592,
-0.08161155134439468,
0.8862646222114563,
0.24796240031719208,
0.7852857112884521,
0.11180367320775986,
-0.16180072724819183,
0.03957333043217659,
-0.5135048627853394,
-0.3773684799671173,
0.6945317983627319,
0.4178229570388794,
-0.3562997281551361,
0.0840928927063942,
0.2322852462530136,
0.22208888828754425,
0.07357829064130783,
-0.25110673904418945,
0.43665170669555664,
0.13681446015834808,
-0.9612935185432434,
0.646218478679657,
-0.38221144676208496,
0.28458166122436523,
-0.7058851718902588,
0.007531656417995691,
-0.18086554110050201,
-0.14796710014343262,
-0.1262393742799759,
-0.5335099101066589,
0.35002052783966064,
-0.029965708032250404,
-0.17617692053318024,
-0.19420284032821655,
0.400278776884079,
-0.6214982867240906,
0.05211654305458069,
0.30762508511543274,
0.41428256034851074,
-0.07277301698923111,
0.2713441550731659,
-0.3275222182273865,
0.26359423995018005,
-0.1412746161222458,
-0.17479075491428375,
0.028948327526450157,
0.35537347197532654,
-0.08389478176832199,
0.24910889565944672,
0.6544029116630554,
0.3540540039539337,
0.33263641595840454,
0.42888143658638,
0.5224616527557373,
-0.7227526903152466,
-1.2026726007461548,
-0.8638526797294617,
0.7923632264137268,
-0.14917701482772827,
-0.5521668195724487,
0.6737406849861145,
0.4655854403972626,
0.8543127775192261,
-0.15523234009742737,
0.9192053079605103,
0.09570688754320145,
0.5742186903953552,
-1.1883397102355957,
0.683239221572876,
-0.2708464562892914,
0.23440077900886536,
-0.3844018280506134,
-0.8958861231803894,
-0.2667910158634186,
0.31139519810676575,
0.2388066202402115,
0.06749521195888519,
0.5378940105438232,
0.7805531620979309,
0.05646517500281334,
0.13701364398002625,
0.4091860055923462,
0.2682219445705414,
0.2506054937839508,
0.07311137020587921,
1.0611411333084106,
-0.09802968800067902,
0.519302248954773,
0.03203202784061432,
0.28891119360923767,
-0.08084090054035187,
-0.7398267388343811,
-0.764260470867157,
-0.6790458559989929,
-0.3109946846961975,
-0.6154443621635437,
0.05862869694828987,
1.1808481216430664,
0.9819827079772949,
-0.6747238636016846,
-0.2843617796897888,
-0.1703958511352539,
-0.05410975590348244,
-0.2571687400341034,
-0.2965346872806549,
0.33959752321243286,
-0.4468960464000702,
-0.7664243578910828,
0.9311419725418091,
0.5752111673355103,
0.5234878659248352,
-0.11035144329071045,
-0.19169822335243225,
0.10359487682580948,
0.36712101101875305,
0.5094576478004456,
0.6895946860313416,
-0.8590776920318604,
-0.2848188281059265,
0.491703599691391,
0.28172701597213745,
0.13611933588981628,
0.9773240685462952,
-0.7295328974723816,
0.6634098887443542,
0.4146605134010315,
0.589690089225769,
0.3136730194091797,
-0.20133186876773834,
0.785198986530304,
-0.934977650642395,
0.4863044023513794,
0.5689988732337952,
0.2344764620065689,
0.36548149585723877,
-0.10292710363864899,
0.5356141924858093,
0.08656027913093567,
-0.5141552090644836,
-1.3480783700942993,
0.5245615243911743,
-0.5890001058578491,
-0.16482113301753998,
0.970164954662323,
0.03293217346072197,
-0.11140341311693192,
-0.4173448979854584,
-0.3101319968700409,
0.5168216824531555,
-0.41496410965919495,
0.8868457078933716,
0.6467658877372742,
-0.3676251769065857,
0.10246150195598602,
-0.6676294803619385,
0.8148491978645325,
0.19342561066150665,
-0.5949118137359619,
0.09111425280570984,
0.32900795340538025,
0.1468614786863327,
0.2866973578929901,
0.4365001916885376,
-0.23134729266166687,
0.665614664554596,
0.3091830313205719,
-0.2611072361469269,
-0.12041729688644409,
-0.7313920259475708,
-0.3745141625404358,
-0.03210577741265297,
-0.12741638720035553,
-0.516097903251648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02589v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02589v1
|
Affective-NLI: Towards Accurate and Interpretable Personality Recognition in Conversation
| 2024-04-03T09:14:24 | 2024-04-03T09:14:24 |
Zhiyuan Wen, Jiannong Cao, Yu Yang, Ruosong Yang, Shuaiqi Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Personality Recognition in Conversation (PRC) aims to identify the
personality traits of speakers through textual dialogue content. It is
essential for providing personalized services in various applications of
Human-Computer Interaction (HCI), such as AI-based mental therapy and companion
robots for the elderly. Most recent studies analyze the dialog content for
personality classification yet overlook two major concerns that hinder their
performance. First, crucial implicit factors contained in conversation, such as
emotions that reflect the speakers' personalities are ignored. Second, only
focusing on the input dialog content disregards the semantic understanding of
personality itself, which reduces the interpretability of the results. In this
paper, we propose Affective Natural Language Inference (Affective-NLI) for
accurate and interpretable PRC. To utilize affectivity within dialog content
for accurate personality recognition, we fine-tuned a pre-trained language
model specifically for emotion recognition in conversations, facilitating
real-time affective annotations for utterances. For interpretability of
recognition results, we formulate personality recognition as an NLI problem by
determining whether the textual description of personality labels is entailed
by the dialog content. Extensive experiments on two daily conversation datasets
suggest that Affective-NLI significantly outperforms (by 6%-7%)
state-of-the-art approaches. Additionally, our Flow experiment demonstrates
that Affective-NLI can accurately recognize the speaker's personality in the
early stages of conversations by surpassing state-of-the-art methods with
22%-34%.
|
[
-0.38285455107688904,
-0.7312191128730774,
0.5676288604736328,
0.5007248520851135,
-0.06652546674013138,
-0.15980099141597748,
-0.47565245628356934,
-0.6439909338951111,
0.4832802712917328,
0.34035763144493103,
-0.8277462124824524,
-0.29541724920272827,
-0.5001463890075684,
0.18231254816055298,
-0.10779306292533875,
0.7934552431106567,
0.11889348179101944,
0.05518323555588722,
-0.05531952902674675,
-0.1280708760023117,
-0.21803869307041168,
-0.5874187350273132,
-0.9893384575843811,
-0.5259902477264404,
0.5397841930389404,
0.26721110939979553,
0.5170320868492126,
0.040500786155462265,
0.2916657328605652,
0.29981133341789246,
-0.39017677307128906,
-0.0332367941737175,
-0.28947123885154724,
0.012079888954758644,
0.013622664846479893,
-0.6063618659973145,
-0.5592952966690063,
-0.019294939935207367,
0.23495188355445862,
0.555443525314331,
-0.0009738992084749043,
-0.29775190353393555,
-0.1389152705669403,
0.9658141732215881,
-0.523557722568512,
0.15644408762454987,
-0.3945641815662384,
0.49993738532066345,
-0.24478045105934143,
-0.24013689160346985,
-0.5977992415428162,
-0.5384365916252136,
0.47155752778053284,
-0.31971824169158936,
-0.24582940340042114,
-0.04610547050833702,
0.723266065120697,
0.46530550718307495,
-0.649878978729248,
-0.4926234781742096,
-0.7208210229873657,
0.918328046798706,
-1.2331651449203491,
0.3949812352657318,
0.6905389428138733,
0.21659930050373077,
0.014837591908872128,
0.03258700668811798,
-0.9691110849380493,
-0.12580503523349762,
-0.18194305896759033,
0.36464670300483704,
-0.32303446531295776,
0.20940709114074707,
0.32743242383003235,
0.4564119577407837,
-0.6619021892547607,
0.16805945336818695,
0.14118066430091858,
0.12639577686786652,
0.6546618938446045,
0.22732974588871002,
0.31329721212387085,
-0.41247302293777466,
0.12480121850967407,
-0.053538236767053604,
-0.27929753065109253,
0.13384021818637848,
0.6682026386260986,
0.14311669766902924,
-0.26377633213996887,
0.5070111155509949,
-0.3580300211906433,
0.5442190170288086,
0.42812487483024597,
0.11031390726566315,
0.38899853825569153,
-0.1738869994878769,
-0.13836239278316498,
-0.030263014137744904,
0.8163284659385681,
0.42698419094085693,
0.6072342991828918,
-0.1484805792570114,
0.2636934518814087,
-0.13876017928123474,
0.5419672727584839,
-0.8580015301704407,
-0.2572862207889557,
0.7943723797798157,
-0.4853573739528656,
-0.3510419726371765,
0.1171158030629158,
-0.9408088326454163,
-0.5123465657234192,
-0.46669819951057434,
0.020072834566235542,
-0.6108170747756958,
-0.356509804725647,
-0.21528276801109314,
0.012041249312460423,
0.5090872645378113,
0.5287765860557556,
-0.98151695728302,
0.08933702111244202,
0.6329233050346375,
0.6086503863334656,
-0.316633403301239,
-0.022806687280535698,
-0.280375212430954,
-0.12270373851060867,
-0.0249888114631176,
0.6230565905570984,
-0.6200896501541138,
-0.2929021716117859,
-0.019242383539676666,
-0.007526630535721779,
-0.004564089234918356,
-0.3469697833061218,
0.6967246532440186,
-0.28902989625930786,
0.3679008185863495,
-0.2183680385351181,
-0.5858007669448853,
-0.05231868848204613,
0.33843061327934265,
-0.5367566347122192,
0.5039885640144348,
0.08930357545614243,
-0.977508544921875,
0.2256365716457367,
-0.8317573070526123,
-0.48516198992729187,
-0.08437015116214752,
0.34305745363235474,
-0.4434136152267456,
0.13928590714931488,
-0.1362067461013794,
0.3952600359916687,
0.18530260026454926,
0.2671370506286621,
-0.5486897826194763,
-0.09295767545700073,
0.7105942964553833,
-0.3947961926460266,
0.5221266746520996,
0.0875682681798935,
-0.6379983425140381,
0.22468335926532745,
-0.7108065485954285,
0.11472459882497787,
-0.2269679754972458,
-0.06090788170695305,
-0.3250718414783478,
0.2684285640716553,
0.0936657190322876,
0.22905901074409485,
0.2917100489139557,
-0.779350757598877,
-0.10778608918190002,
-0.6627050042152405,
0.12457862496376038,
0.5994389653205872,
-0.2529512047767639,
0.5252929925918579,
0.13273967802524567,
0.20673462748527527,
0.09202501177787781,
0.2260240763425827,
0.026440562680363655,
-0.384331613779068,
-0.845719575881958,
-0.10103160887956619,
-0.024670548737049103,
0.8105126619338989,
-0.4333103895187378,
0.9602195024490356,
-0.08789052069187164,
-0.7144083976745605,
-0.4230624735355377,
-0.1182117685675621,
0.4475064277648926,
0.4727700352668762,
0.2623150050640106,
-0.38314390182495117,
-0.6171177625656128,
-0.7987307906150818,
-0.28179001808166504,
-0.49863922595977783,
-0.1940782368183136,
0.8606052994728088,
0.1188441812992096,
-0.553089439868927,
1.149633765220642,
-0.5013982057571411,
0.02178509719669819,
-0.4135892987251282,
0.5417279005050659,
0.21758568286895752,
0.32245901226997375,
0.2956569194793701,
-0.9763737320899963,
-0.565331220626831,
0.015165898948907852,
-0.7596057057380676,
-0.4166407585144043,
-0.1779826283454895,
-0.313262939453125,
0.2522599697113037,
-0.024688974022865295,
-0.4710691571235657,
0.7612124681472778,
0.44568726420402527,
-0.6490415334701538,
0.3864729106426239,
0.04019149765372276,
0.17792536318302155,
-0.6757120490074158,
0.20393222570419312,
0.3314805328845978,
-0.07032027840614319,
-1.039062738418579,
-0.5183324217796326,
-0.16832971572875977,
0.09781006723642349,
-0.28807532787323,
0.7587593793869019,
-0.013834020122885704,
0.112198106944561,
-0.42805159091949463,
0.17264515161514282,
0.09540309011936188,
0.6178874373435974,
0.5068768858909607,
0.3175697922706604,
0.23886020481586456,
-0.5315867066383362,
0.19066272675991058,
0.5911628007888794,
-0.06306200474500656,
1.1560372114181519,
-0.5956936478614807,
0.3278646767139435,
-0.2657683789730072,
0.34747424721717834,
-0.7044883966445923,
-0.25280871987342834,
0.35981297492980957,
-0.30934938788414,
0.24360619485378265,
0.09913745522499084,
0.18254303932189941,
-0.10506384819746017,
-0.18710178136825562,
-0.02849864959716797,
0.30758902430534363,
-0.5585967302322388,
1.1148251295089722,
0.20775961875915527,
-0.32341617345809937,
-0.2838399112224579,
-0.7579415440559387,
0.010982207953929901,
-0.2796649634838104,
-0.4261478781700134,
0.2891578674316406,
-0.488215833902359,
-0.3836863934993744,
-0.2611522376537323,
0.07619509100914001,
-0.4792160391807556,
0.08775211125612259,
0.5851685404777527,
0.16115562617778778,
0.0346950963139534,
-0.04427152872085571,
0.09593082964420319,
0.0030198730528354645,
0.2272455394268036,
0.39407438039779663,
0.42558494210243225,
-0.4705177843570709,
-0.29744118452072144,
-0.7108938694000244,
0.4502732753753662,
0.5941258072853088,
-0.14055734872817993,
0.8820177316665649,
0.9193245768547058,
-0.09865858405828476,
0.1270740032196045,
-0.6152923107147217,
-0.10629705339670181,
-0.4183492362499237,
0.21886411309242249,
-0.30876606702804565,
-0.7265534996986389,
0.4667361080646515,
-0.01860169880092144,
-0.03936146944761276,
0.12486644089221954,
0.34188297390937805,
-0.22667545080184937,
0.9495524764060974,
0.4480785131454468,
-0.06091973930597305,
0.809799313545227,
0.10701069980859756,
0.5029830932617188,
-1.113881230354309,
-0.20318268239498138,
-0.38232362270355225,
-0.35130617022514343,
-0.46533694863319397,
-0.013705896213650703,
-0.1430990993976593,
-0.2390354871749878,
-0.10197541862726212,
0.2850787937641144,
-0.4282412528991699,
0.0805182084441185,
0.29210007190704346,
0.4221927225589752,
-0.06614214926958084,
-0.6045805811882019,
0.6365478038787842,
-0.4466080963611603,
0.17074643075466156,
-0.4862716495990753,
0.6781649589538574,
0.46470269560813904,
0.4732813835144043,
0.4958328604698181,
0.6786973476409912,
0.28043538331985474,
0.7035251259803772,
-1.0705474615097046,
0.49883967638015747,
-0.13894379138946533,
-0.40614989399909973,
-0.3585262894630432,
-0.6520416736602783,
-0.5920237898826599,
-0.017392195761203766,
-0.3740004599094391,
-1.0837353467941284,
0.3299447298049927,
0.2648238241672516,
-0.06029888987541199,
0.09731991589069366,
-1.0429558753967285,
1.0383323431015015,
-0.45191434025764465,
-0.06992675364017487,
-0.20928187668323517,
-0.7961214780807495,
0.20964846014976501,
-0.16167114675045013,
-0.018703630194067955,
-0.3065723478794098,
0.4353776276111603,
0.6576435565948486,
-0.34457558393478394,
0.9563302993774414,
-0.40990081429481506,
0.08112786710262299,
0.009215866215527058,
-0.14955765008926392,
0.35178497433662415,
-0.10878530144691467,
-0.5151506066322327,
0.2961784899234772,
-0.0018896620022132993,
-0.15641610324382782,
-1.0091326236724854,
0.3604274392127991,
-0.7030772566795349,
-0.23612993955612183,
-0.170637845993042,
-0.10434795171022415,
-0.22387827932834625,
0.03135339170694351,
-0.040750231593847275,
0.3671574592590332,
-0.6929702162742615,
-0.07787825167179108,
0.6161803007125854,
-0.4082612693309784,
0.30611637234687805,
0.6191150546073914,
0.019601022824645042,
-0.07831958681344986,
1.151951551437378,
-0.4245140254497528,
0.10768453031778336,
0.5933734774589539,
0.4874654710292816,
-0.16161710023880005,
-0.3537297546863556,
-0.08077050745487213,
0.2889927327632904,
-0.6150609254837036,
0.2142835259437561,
-0.949338972568512,
0.06892426311969757,
-0.2778837978839874,
-0.18149548768997192,
-0.43163830041885376,
-0.16257835924625397,
-0.5650113821029663,
0.17326778173446655,
0.324215292930603,
0.6582974195480347,
0.21415728330612183,
0.3335949182510376,
-0.5449224710464478,
0.2553960382938385,
0.5094007849693298,
0.42361441254615784,
0.1294887661933899,
-0.5487112402915955,
-0.054047223180532455,
0.08948179334402084,
-0.31140798330307007,
-1.2038626670837402,
0.7094008922576904,
0.524390459060669,
0.2811347544193268,
0.8619869351387024,
0.1741519272327423,
0.44229090213775635,
-0.373893141746521,
0.6291051506996155,
0.03779105842113495,
-1.4062029123306274,
0.8059199452400208,
0.030011752620339394,
0.41226911544799805,
0.8694369792938232,
0.4037669599056244,
-0.7585878372192383,
-0.35744014382362366,
-0.5704156160354614,
-0.9630969762802124,
0.6567689180374146,
0.2276715487241745,
0.14553427696228027,
-0.21783079206943512,
0.4562635123729706,
-0.02189108170568943,
0.2963869869709015,
-0.8444598317146301,
-0.20063450932502747,
-0.4535389542579651,
-0.6548269987106323,
0.22957465052604675,
-0.36277133226394653,
0.3052867650985718,
-0.04412279650568962,
0.721910297870636,
-0.4016183912754059,
0.5319011211395264,
0.3311328589916229,
0.023315314203500748,
-0.017590699717402458,
0.5977523326873779,
0.47051846981048584,
0.3281828761100769,
-0.6818838715553284,
0.07716900110244751,
0.24286888539791107,
-0.3594745397567749,
-0.2753753662109375,
-0.027363695204257965,
0.36418282985687256,
0.020011290907859802,
0.14891913533210754,
1.1429667472839355,
0.32070356607437134,
-0.9202832579612732,
0.7310469150543213,
-0.39731666445732117,
0.31726551055908203,
-0.6221830248832703,
-0.02067313715815544,
-0.09832677245140076,
0.25778067111968994,
0.020863309502601624,
-0.07647246867418289,
0.46411168575286865,
-0.4741971492767334,
0.03981474041938782,
0.4076317250728607,
-0.9214691519737244,
-0.5665804147720337,
0.2555161416530609,
0.34132683277130127,
-0.5397032499313354,
0.6997770071029663,
-0.35506507754325867,
-0.7516337037086487,
0.4941868782043457,
0.24764902889728546,
1.1036179065704346,
-0.5197141766548157,
0.3838011920452118,
0.3232666254043579,
-0.14237390458583832,
0.3105591833591461,
0.27301523089408875,
-0.21181604266166687,
-0.9571962952613831,
-0.45170849561691284,
-0.5458987355232239,
-1.3062338829040527,
-0.11966376006603241,
-0.9390406012535095,
0.06278616189956665,
-0.28160786628723145,
-0.0866456925868988,
0.1094324067234993,
-0.23733200132846832,
-0.6163583397865295,
0.40515461564064026,
0.4311739206314087,
0.520247220993042,
-0.8800271153450012,
0.5043618083000183,
0.6503899693489075,
0.05841274559497833,
-0.5562155246734619,
0.06848584860563278,
0.1492234468460083,
-0.19474485516548157,
0.6885279417037964,
0.4331281781196594,
-0.06142881512641907,
-0.17065289616584778,
-0.4306493103504181,
-0.48072385787963867,
0.6789963245391846,
-0.050921957939863205,
-0.25806552171707153,
0.16013100743293762,
-0.13002964854240417,
0.8090611696243286,
-0.30997946858406067,
1.0511794090270996,
0.539739727973938,
0.6654202342033386,
0.12763498723506927,
-0.7235221862792969,
-0.12736107409000397,
-0.7060968279838562,
-0.18233232200145721,
0.13066735863685608,
-0.47831517457962036,
0.2900066673755646,
-0.030781233683228493,
0.05862133577466011,
-0.21925988793373108,
0.9430935382843018,
0.21434158086776733,
0.5881341099739075,
0.9070211052894592,
0.296428918838501,
0.7563899755477905,
-0.2884025573730469,
1.0809277296066284,
-0.37749460339546204,
-0.05401013419032097,
0.9508265852928162,
-0.512033998966217,
1.113716721534729,
0.31950920820236206,
-0.14585259556770325,
0.7679991126060486,
0.42830249667167664,
0.07203226536512375,
0.38795772194862366,
0.006632051896303892,
-0.48055076599121094,
0.09844307601451874,
-0.25802531838417053,
0.21698300540447235,
0.5960351228713989,
0.38611918687820435,
-0.11496428400278091,
0.44709423184394836,
0.1710945963859558,
0.24867701530456543,
-0.17404665052890778,
0.1831921488046646,
0.9406183958053589,
0.029031850397586823,
-0.674746036529541,
-0.010606316849589348,
-0.23704436421394348,
1.0879167318344116,
-0.6328253149986267,
0.0002700628247112036,
-0.0340319387614727,
-0.0007591349422000349,
-0.5341501235961914,
-0.8185476660728455,
0.6535469889640808,
0.20207658410072327,
-0.22497422993183136,
-0.3706783056259155,
0.6251654028892517,
-0.5947756171226501,
0.07666581869125366,
0.3351495563983917,
0.2343677431344986,
0.37330687046051025,
-0.36324915289878845,
-0.5239802002906799,
-0.01443899143487215,
0.13368883728981018,
-0.5129919052124023,
0.1719682216644287,
0.48353177309036255,
0.43654415011405945,
0.6288118958473206,
0.38692060112953186,
-0.042798962444067,
-0.3931690752506256,
0.3206571340560913,
0.6334689259529114,
-0.8923676013946533,
-0.5533635020256042,
-0.7679710388183594,
0.7101011872291565,
-0.3337911367416382,
-0.5024663209915161,
0.4670657515525818,
0.02544695883989334,
0.13913382589817047,
0.06739135086536407,
0.5603403449058533,
-0.2847708463668823,
0.5210773348808289,
-0.2986138164997101,
0.6707589626312256,
-0.2893686592578888,
-0.05486400052905083,
-0.8519076704978943,
-0.7226046919822693,
-0.015651604160666466,
0.8216286897659302,
-0.6239949464797974,
0.16725529730319977,
0.5288222432136536,
0.38284048438072205,
0.35371819138526917,
0.49147674441337585,
0.13776487112045288,
0.34914594888687134,
0.4410657584667206,
0.6034006476402283,
0.6251825094223022,
-0.03429892659187317,
0.0914740338921547,
-0.4299911856651306,
-0.46528661251068115,
-0.1883537769317627,
-1.00550377368927,
-0.9217670559883118,
-0.30900779366493225,
-0.4960680603981018,
-0.3045520782470703,
-0.31231489777565,
0.7655918598175049,
0.5453827977180481,
-0.849950909614563,
0.13058990240097046,
-0.13011999428272247,
0.18901024758815765,
0.01580534316599369,
-0.3691083788871765,
0.18806226551532745,
0.023654133081436157,
-0.9594837427139282,
0.458946168422699,
0.49079829454421997,
-0.01334370207041502,
-0.2299305498600006,
-0.126398965716362,
0.019767578691244125,
0.27805179357528687,
0.6147788763046265,
0.48615801334381104,
-0.7433826327323914,
-0.3980886936187744,
-0.011646809056401253,
0.004053345415741205,
0.24121376872062683,
0.6152406930923462,
-0.4796898066997528,
0.48021912574768066,
0.12119075655937195,
0.5547014474868774,
0.4214130640029907,
0.15853388607501984,
0.4551197290420532,
-0.6267668604850769,
0.10863538086414337,
0.34904560446739197,
0.20779098570346832,
0.5887644290924072,
-0.755774736404419,
0.4053627550601959,
-0.13006828725337982,
-0.6140262484550476,
-0.4950825870037079,
0.4010838270187378,
-1.530727505683899,
0.13015012443065643,
0.9714735150337219,
-0.38738304376602173,
-0.32742568850517273,
-0.2860088050365448,
-0.33783039450645447,
0.17133411765098572,
-0.3985336720943451,
0.7383824586868286,
0.5287602543830872,
-0.5138012170791626,
-0.5580825209617615,
-0.2852242588996887,
0.43932175636291504,
0.7238940596580505,
-1.340004563331604,
0.08536498248577118,
0.22439447045326233,
-0.22205834090709686,
0.3883502185344696,
0.6075754165649414,
0.022089345380663872,
-0.13875114917755127,
-0.3573147654533386,
0.5369706749916077,
0.4128718972206116,
0.1837536096572876,
-0.3769169747829437,
-0.08686564862728119,
-0.08696620166301727,
0.3871289789676666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02588v1
|
Large Language Models for Expansion of Spoken Language Understanding Systems to New Languages
| 2024-04-03T09:13:26 | 2024-04-03T09:13:26 |
Jakub Hoscilowicz, Pawel Pawlowski, Marcin Skorupa, Marcin Sowański, Artur Janicki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Spoken Language Understanding (SLU) models are a core component of voice
assistants (VA), such as Alexa, Bixby, and Google Assistant. In this paper, we
introduce a pipeline designed to extend SLU systems to new languages, utilizing
Large Language Models (LLMs) that we fine-tune for machine translation of
slot-annotated SLU training data. Our approach improved on the MultiATIS++
benchmark, a primary multi-language SLU dataset, in the cloud scenario using an
mBERT model. Specifically, we saw an improvement in the Overall Accuracy
metric: from 53% to 62.18%, compared to the existing state-of-the-art method,
Fine and Coarse-grained Multi-Task Learning Framework (FC-MTLF). In the
on-device scenario (tiny and not pretrained SLU), our method improved the
Overall Accuracy from 5.31% to 22.06% over the baseline Global-Local
Contrastive Learning Framework (GL-CLeF) method. Contrary to both FC-MTLF and
GL-CLeF, our LLM-based machine translation does not require changes in the
production architecture of SLU. Additionally, our pipeline is slot-type
independent: it does not require any slot definitions or examples.
|
[
-0.3433760106563568,
-0.768379271030426,
0.6291378140449524,
-0.09995409101247787,
-0.3323529362678528,
0.14395134150981903,
-0.47962236404418945,
-0.49078601598739624,
0.0416233167052269,
0.6843276619911194,
-0.3331170976161957,
-0.535115122795105,
-0.603209912776947,
-0.11015074700117111,
-0.36735787987709045,
0.7661828994750977,
0.11144862323999405,
0.13192975521087646,
-0.058056093752384186,
-0.18636241555213928,
-0.5266484022140503,
-0.5421503782272339,
-0.6362375617027283,
-0.419131875038147,
0.3649956285953522,
0.483318030834198,
0.7351957559585571,
0.5702752470970154,
0.13944563269615173,
0.32196348905563354,
-0.159306600689888,
0.34185561537742615,
-0.3096986413002014,
0.03191504254937172,
0.114068903028965,
-0.5090500712394714,
-0.5929841995239258,
-0.41702359914779663,
0.8355739116668701,
0.6722740530967712,
-0.2583622634410858,
0.0009136510780081153,
0.12815292179584503,
0.43794041872024536,
-0.4116019010543823,
0.3181457221508026,
-0.937256395816803,
-0.08572347462177277,
0.03871290013194084,
0.04423575848340988,
-0.5827811360359192,
-0.008925364352762699,
0.23028992116451263,
-0.6669391393661499,
0.18999840319156647,
-0.2281830906867981,
0.8525471687316895,
0.323971152305603,
-0.48319846391677856,
-0.09183020144701004,
-0.8342466354370117,
0.9291626214981079,
-0.8776659369468689,
0.8401184678077698,
0.2976277768611908,
0.4194119870662689,
0.07036363333463669,
-0.5752308964729309,
-0.4673357903957367,
-0.2811588644981384,
0.051600147038698196,
-0.11065658181905746,
-0.15520012378692627,
-0.02583412639796734,
0.14003828167915344,
0.257909893989563,
-0.5413739681243896,
0.48305559158325195,
-0.16256259381771088,
-0.04915997013449669,
0.6879554390907288,
0.006548033561557531,
0.10793055593967438,
0.053298987448215485,
-0.34574413299560547,
0.1637035608291626,
-0.8334704041481018,
-0.04092911630868912,
-0.09447630494832993,
0.5393619537353516,
-0.2621424198150635,
0.27107593417167664,
0.0936376303434372,
0.8217724561691284,
-0.1324533224105835,
-0.21095576882362366,
0.4335959851741791,
-0.23957045376300812,
-0.4899163842201233,
-0.08311229944229126,
0.4759729206562042,
0.01922055520117283,
0.11517506092786789,
-0.3384157419204712,
-0.24380439519882202,
-0.1554979830980301,
0.015271404758095741,
-0.539395272731781,
0.0674484446644783,
0.1867697536945343,
-0.16482992470264435,
0.062494054436683655,
-0.22138261795043945,
-0.2664920389652252,
-0.5165069699287415,
-0.7244682312011719,
0.16022996604442596,
-0.44777244329452515,
-0.3750006854534149,
0.11356977373361588,
0.31021103262901306,
0.44486385583877563,
0.7064402103424072,
-0.7039310932159424,
0.21048909425735474,
0.9205794334411621,
0.698371410369873,
-0.2548639178276062,
-0.554491400718689,
-0.8407353162765503,
0.19742096960544586,
-0.1987302005290985,
0.6556041240692139,
-0.36880314350128174,
-0.25219443440437317,
0.1369486004114151,
0.12443980574607849,
-0.18234694004058838,
-0.5668310523033142,
0.678329348564148,
-0.41603535413742065,
-0.044138483703136444,
0.0068682474084198475,
-0.6190013289451599,
-0.2696453630924225,
-0.026677975431084633,
-0.400025874376297,
0.8857241868972778,
-0.02480955235660076,
-0.06540752947330475,
0.15388967096805573,
-0.6303979754447937,
-0.6638021469116211,
0.2793310880661011,
-0.18847577273845673,
-0.2720707952976227,
0.25743967294692993,
0.44341903924942017,
0.6967148184776306,
-0.2837672531604767,
0.5243292450904846,
-0.2826192080974579,
-0.24625664949417114,
0.29105648398399353,
-0.21318061649799347,
0.6069819927215576,
0.21387888491153717,
-0.3126327693462372,
0.25169941782951355,
-0.7531878352165222,
0.020782407373189926,
-0.27297985553741455,
-0.1727106273174286,
-0.26600217819213867,
0.10138639807701111,
0.16500456631183624,
0.12352222204208374,
0.2209303379058838,
-0.5060430765151978,
0.17644864320755005,
-0.18768368661403656,
0.8758490681648254,
0.6987667083740234,
-0.4248514771461487,
0.5768402218818665,
0.022083206102252007,
0.5827253460884094,
-0.04016738757491112,
0.10385973751544952,
-0.3437158167362213,
-0.45396965742111206,
-0.9582430720329285,
-0.3327057361602783,
0.23032750189304352,
0.6552172899246216,
-0.608407735824585,
0.449918270111084,
-0.6694627404212952,
-0.3877609074115753,
-0.8242502212524414,
0.32326751947402954,
0.44406968355178833,
0.3771940767765045,
0.32569751143455505,
-0.09920662641525269,
-0.42351630330085754,
-0.7216846942901611,
0.11531269550323486,
-0.043086566030979156,
-0.10924859344959259,
0.7164174914360046,
0.15739712119102478,
-0.49893733859062195,
0.5435761213302612,
-0.3276313543319702,
-0.24803048372268677,
-0.3149670660495758,
0.06206655874848366,
0.32852470874786377,
0.37330055236816406,
0.19736488163471222,
-0.6154139041900635,
-0.5222235321998596,
0.6748326420783997,
-0.5556197166442871,
0.06531471014022827,
-0.1389867067337036,
0.07168062031269073,
0.21633365750312805,
0.5425384640693665,
-0.737479031085968,
0.06341690570116043,
0.7389839291572571,
-0.11602567136287689,
0.4666474163532257,
-0.08382422477006912,
-0.0794997587800026,
-1.2582646608352661,
-0.030259564518928528,
0.09349408745765686,
-0.47461891174316406,
-0.8571662902832031,
0.3755989968776703,
0.10589776188135147,
-0.442989706993103,
-0.7067280411720276,
0.5867228507995605,
-0.5613071322441101,
-0.38897770643234253,
-0.30309993028640747,
0.5242961645126343,
0.10971444100141525,
0.41382595896720886,
0.13086315989494324,
0.91096031665802,
0.6413577198982239,
-0.7427688241004944,
0.2642751634120941,
0.14305277168750763,
-0.43905454874038696,
0.37308135628700256,
-0.6153963804244995,
0.3688073754310608,
-0.05474627763032913,
0.18710026144981384,
-0.8307496309280396,
0.056425873190164566,
-0.40790146589279175,
-0.5763559937477112,
0.373991459608078,
-0.42565101385116577,
-0.28999221324920654,
0.005362165626138449,
0.2618645131587982,
0.01638561673462391,
0.3406643867492676,
-0.645756185054779,
0.8508914113044739,
0.5069261193275452,
-0.295300155878067,
-0.6426863670349121,
-0.680239200592041,
0.24957656860351562,
-0.20256584882736206,
-0.7316852807998657,
0.2885884940624237,
0.0014413924654945731,
-0.21725477278232574,
-0.27122384309768677,
0.09320123493671417,
-0.38651034235954285,
0.25136667490005493,
0.05114777758717537,
0.23548869788646698,
-0.5651335716247559,
0.23991483449935913,
0.06307379901409149,
-0.09084677696228027,
-0.24617087841033936,
-0.3632112443447113,
0.7473045587539673,
-0.30351021885871887,
-0.23456640541553497,
-0.5640494227409363,
0.39235252141952515,
0.8132994771003723,
-0.552708089351654,
0.6368640661239624,
0.9109834432601929,
-0.37158384919166565,
-0.08285706490278244,
-0.6407124400138855,
-0.009770548902451992,
-0.4263148307800293,
0.46043282747268677,
-0.6223326325416565,
-1.2535290718078613,
0.5767734050750732,
0.05146361514925957,
0.3411158323287964,
0.1846516728401184,
0.502997875213623,
-0.1866988092660904,
1.067791223526001,
0.6026371717453003,
-0.5089499950408936,
0.5976962447166443,
-0.23845767974853516,
0.16687734425067902,
-1.1829606294631958,
0.16113711893558502,
-0.6851065754890442,
-0.08152830600738525,
-0.43128344416618347,
-0.5914816856384277,
0.2640497088432312,
0.2628927230834961,
-0.02710285224020481,
0.5485622882843018,
-0.18467295169830322,
0.23252198100090027,
0.4156864583492279,
0.04555560275912285,
0.3396229147911072,
0.08531933277845383,
0.1414828896522522,
0.04954492300748825,
-0.4312390387058258,
-0.37494295835494995,
1.0566728115081787,
0.5355467200279236,
0.6879681348800659,
0.41962820291519165,
0.5279542207717896,
0.19833143055438995,
0.297724187374115,
-0.8422779440879822,
0.47397565841674805,
-0.39464837312698364,
-0.22574028372764587,
-0.49707096815109253,
-0.33663079142570496,
-1.1201075315475464,
0.5771586894989014,
-0.12867048382759094,
-0.926105797290802,
0.0941714346408844,
0.21750906109809875,
-0.2367522269487381,
0.18559516966342926,
-1.1346632242202759,
0.6762886047363281,
-0.5018030405044556,
-0.3236972391605377,
-0.387773722410202,
-0.24628973007202148,
0.3030558228492737,
-0.03398680314421654,
0.32119444012641907,
-0.07899858057498932,
-0.05604248866438866,
0.3157445192337036,
-0.19576947391033173,
0.7392306923866272,
-0.3268948793411255,
-0.23717263340950012,
0.06022234261035919,
-0.26709282398223877,
0.8012246489524841,
0.02486005239188671,
-0.2951344847679138,
0.23725737631320953,
-0.213172048330307,
-0.43555206060409546,
-0.670928955078125,
0.8630824089050293,
-0.9227297306060791,
-0.4711593687534332,
-0.05609675496816635,
-0.6906717419624329,
-0.22502374649047852,
0.14381591975688934,
-0.07678695023059845,
0.4205523133277893,
-0.05765669420361519,
0.4066331684589386,
0.8084827065467834,
-0.24305446445941925,
0.1540617048740387,
0.9220722913742065,
-0.2277778536081314,
-0.30622610449790955,
0.809668779373169,
-0.1762239634990692,
0.3224090337753296,
0.6247975826263428,
0.15646514296531677,
-0.47968894243240356,
-0.8941330313682556,
-0.8791745901107788,
0.27476564049720764,
-0.4656310975551605,
-0.15349234640598297,
-0.6389987468719482,
-0.09994593262672424,
-0.8734227418899536,
-0.0061536445282399654,
-0.2424793690443039,
-0.20912060141563416,
-0.468201607465744,
-0.1289009004831314,
0.322547048330307,
0.5544683337211609,
0.3199438154697418,
0.7166923880577087,
-0.9719041585922241,
0.09092918038368225,
0.2403254359960556,
0.14647100865840912,
-0.11100828647613525,
-0.9058125019073486,
-0.49289339780807495,
0.044273778796195984,
-0.20072247087955475,
-0.7289835810661316,
0.47130778431892395,
0.5126848220825195,
0.7825987935066223,
0.45189568400382996,
-0.4062480032444,
1.1339811086654663,
-0.6777585744857788,
0.7039567232131958,
0.1386602818965912,
-1.1623162031173706,
0.458567351102829,
-0.5530495047569275,
0.44638457894325256,
0.3479859530925751,
0.05335596948862076,
-0.808627188205719,
-0.20142686367034912,
-0.45239657163619995,
-0.6597380042076111,
0.46624377369880676,
-0.12007349729537964,
0.17246375977993011,
0.2909325361251831,
0.41096606850624084,
0.025489848107099533,
0.1675395667552948,
-0.8222931623458862,
-0.24672271311283112,
0.1636403203010559,
0.0020759697072207928,
-0.6460147500038147,
0.048462774604558945,
0.16831645369529724,
-0.3336937725543976,
0.8394937515258789,
-0.2882266342639923,
0.2287093698978424,
0.004287428222596645,
-0.6301066875457764,
-0.00798792578279972,
0.6433985233306885,
0.6224836707115173,
0.698242723941803,
0.05740068852901459,
-0.06487803906202316,
0.27802613377571106,
-0.3044101893901825,
-0.05599091574549675,
0.461095929145813,
-0.24253059923648834,
0.09070702642202377,
0.230103000998497,
1.2479737997055054,
0.3031213879585266,
-0.7481845021247864,
0.2810230255126953,
-0.03035643696784973,
0.03352886065840721,
-0.42121046781539917,
-0.04570695012807846,
0.17869320511817932,
0.20849652588367462,
0.2182653546333313,
-0.22868254780769348,
0.10007321834564209,
-0.5321534276008606,
0.1396053284406662,
0.6432703733444214,
-0.43155601620674133,
-0.21495038270950317,
0.2915639281272888,
0.46077170968055725,
-0.45092788338661194,
0.42143771052360535,
-0.2859690487384796,
-0.3528958559036255,
0.3871566951274872,
0.677810549736023,
0.8398452401161194,
-0.5617176294326782,
0.11155858635902405,
0.323318213224411,
0.48239386081695557,
0.168404683470726,
0.15894046425819397,
-0.09271150082349777,
-0.7730032205581665,
-0.800402820110321,
-0.6109241247177124,
-0.4371492266654968,
0.6878136396408081,
-0.7164360284805298,
0.37932491302490234,
-0.2660055458545685,
-0.02394133433699608,
0.07258063554763794,
-0.05884861946105957,
-0.7769867181777954,
0.09728726744651794,
0.23134297132492065,
0.7674529552459717,
-0.9301082491874695,
1.411665678024292,
0.8400428891181946,
0.03475390747189522,
-0.7673132419586182,
-0.4458681643009186,
-0.09789863973855972,
-0.9219188094139099,
0.128214031457901,
-0.008985533379018307,
-0.08383938670158386,
0.0725090429186821,
-0.1832599639892578,
-1.057684063911438,
1.0273221731185913,
0.3851402997970581,
-1.0197983980178833,
0.09075210243463516,
0.17397060990333557,
0.5294598340988159,
-0.5321011543273926,
0.2543325126171112,
0.7491549849510193,
0.14491459727287292,
-0.2758632302284241,
-1.0973291397094727,
-0.37138164043426514,
-0.27256321907043457,
0.00078608124749735,
0.4918697774410248,
-0.32807889580726624,
0.8553268313407898,
-0.11272135376930237,
-0.008307382464408875,
0.10130731761455536,
0.6373116970062256,
0.1247699037194252,
0.2591346800327301,
0.651193380355835,
0.6236909627914429,
0.8792006373405457,
-0.05900028720498085,
0.7313917279243469,
-0.22359612584114075,
0.24998480081558228,
1.6391514539718628,
-0.37027058005332947,
1.1842036247253418,
0.3933422267436981,
-0.22541823983192444,
0.5312979221343994,
0.4910593330860138,
0.1412210315465927,
0.11585479229688644,
0.12192536890506744,
-0.331612229347229,
-0.35510167479515076,
-0.1954735517501831,
-0.36805275082588196,
0.4370444118976593,
0.7577294707298279,
-0.35069701075553894,
0.035177502781152725,
0.2672538161277771,
0.05405976250767708,
0.05587681382894516,
-0.2732868194580078,
0.8515233397483826,
0.05852770432829857,
-0.6512705683708191,
0.7722005844116211,
0.008801127783954144,
0.6585433483123779,
-0.5393291115760803,
0.13975703716278076,
-0.1778419017791748,
0.27408939599990845,
-0.09793757647275925,
-0.6047213077545166,
0.021201135590672493,
0.16946955025196075,
-0.00796455703675747,
-0.1102406308054924,
0.7029722929000854,
-0.5279397368431091,
-0.5408301949501038,
0.32198575139045715,
0.6371925473213196,
0.39990460872650146,
-0.07520084828138351,
-0.9064674377441406,
0.23676571249961853,
0.1825142353773117,
0.28776541352272034,
0.2570347785949707,
0.24213522672653198,
0.01310886163264513,
0.7749760150909424,
0.728935182094574,
0.09815080463886261,
0.34891071915626526,
0.4211041033267975,
0.5217103958129883,
-0.37347838282585144,
-0.562530517578125,
-0.47396862506866455,
0.5035269260406494,
-0.06147695705294609,
-0.23418903350830078,
0.6957981586456299,
0.6834476590156555,
0.8330873250961304,
-0.0005372373852878809,
0.9322389364242554,
0.25525474548339844,
0.6488566398620605,
-0.5377483367919922,
0.45523369312286377,
-0.6321402192115784,
0.344001829624176,
-0.3022632598876953,
-0.7808457016944885,
-0.07599624991416931,
0.6250010132789612,
-0.17320497334003448,
-0.2954463064670563,
0.5043089389801025,
0.723389744758606,
-0.1962161660194397,
0.0058297631330788136,
0.4688977599143982,
0.31704989075660706,
0.4726713001728058,
0.6608567833900452,
0.5960484743118286,
-0.47372370958328247,
0.49762678146362305,
-0.16232964396476746,
-0.3082229197025299,
-0.15617381036281586,
-0.7311201691627502,
-0.708594024181366,
-0.6062504053115845,
-0.3469463586807251,
-0.27439987659454346,
0.03290509060025215,
0.6680322885513306,
1.027051329612732,
-0.7825997471809387,
-0.6101951003074646,
-0.08635488152503967,
0.15563802421092987,
-0.3171042203903198,
-0.14475589990615845,
0.2549753785133362,
-0.44723978638648987,
-0.941023051738739,
0.697205662727356,
0.15000517666339874,
-0.05071020498871803,
-0.4671940803527832,
-0.35326048731803894,
-0.1298000067472458,
-0.3243996202945709,
0.9365161657333374,
0.29154932498931885,
-1.047092318534851,
-0.189611554145813,
0.10404399782419205,
0.17681042850017548,
0.2041999101638794,
0.837104856967926,
-0.5798235535621643,
0.3863162398338318,
0.2452433705329895,
0.9382122755050659,
0.6863780617713928,
-0.244980588555336,
0.5539320707321167,
-0.7783092260360718,
0.27158641815185547,
0.0823402926325798,
0.6962277293205261,
0.5082792043685913,
-0.30107396841049194,
0.20184007287025452,
-0.11446276307106018,
-0.5537107586860657,
-0.8898423910140991,
0.45092758536338806,
-1.104244589805603,
-0.11077840626239777,
1.266784906387329,
-0.2561657428741455,
-0.11727669835090637,
-0.2512741684913635,
-0.10090930014848709,
0.25017181038856506,
-0.5270013213157654,
0.4211728870868683,
0.5015691518783569,
0.01399181131273508,
-0.567375659942627,
-0.6316237449645996,
0.18463268876075745,
0.5599591135978699,
-1.0951741933822632,
0.2729808986186981,
0.49678125977516174,
0.16443146765232086,
0.13079430162906647,
0.4996948838233948,
0.07223638892173767,
0.32319605350494385,
-0.5405367612838745,
0.051416587084531784,
0.09109549969434738,
-0.2620612680912018,
-0.6793124079704285,
-0.369276762008667,
0.2853671908378601,
-0.2457166612148285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02581v1
|
Multi-Granularity Guided Fusion-in-Decoder
| 2024-04-03T08:56:00 | 2024-04-03T08:56:00 |
Eunseong Choi, Hyeri Lee, Jongwuk Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In Open-domain Question Answering (ODQA), it is essential to discern relevant
contexts as evidence and avoid spurious ones among retrieved results. The model
architecture that uses concatenated multiple contexts in the decoding phase,
i.e., Fusion-in-Decoder, demonstrates promising performance but generates
incorrect outputs from seemingly plausible contexts. To address this problem,
we propose the Multi-Granularity guided Fusion-in-Decoder (MGFiD), discerning
evidence across multiple levels of granularity. Based on multi-task learning,
MGFiD harmonizes passage re-ranking with sentence classification. It aggregates
evident sentences into an anchor vector that instructs the decoder.
Additionally, it improves decoding efficiency by reusing the results of passage
re-ranking for passage pruning. Through our experiments, MGFiD outperforms
existing models on the Natural Questions (NQ) and TriviaQA (TQA) datasets,
highlighting the benefits of its multi-granularity solution.
|
[
-0.5090715885162354,
-1.2770612239837646,
0.5431492328643799,
0.038181569427251816,
-0.30132368206977844,
-0.15069949626922607,
0.12948830425739288,
-0.1515827625989914,
-0.19293776154518127,
0.4349045753479004,
-0.5665785074234009,
-0.4368072748184204,
-0.5713462829589844,
0.11039649695158005,
-0.3322720229625702,
1.1001800298690796,
-0.0017918036319315434,
0.07714970409870148,
-0.6796203255653381,
-0.15349723398685455,
-0.5461993217468262,
-0.5338574647903442,
-0.44944867491722107,
-0.46463751792907715,
0.32790684700012207,
0.3316124677658081,
0.5869634747505188,
0.32932254672050476,
0.2251802384853363,
0.1840820014476776,
-0.10633248090744019,
0.6577379703521729,
-0.3737497925758362,
-0.1826363056898117,
-0.18745410442352295,
-0.05666472762823105,
-0.44113680720329285,
-0.17806345224380493,
0.6177331209182739,
0.7219162583351135,
-0.16996082663536072,
-0.005854279268532991,
0.19876167178153992,
0.2100607454776764,
-0.7276139259338379,
0.2386886030435562,
-0.472290962934494,
-0.2330009490251541,
-0.04503002390265465,
-0.33154377341270447,
-0.5246934294700623,
-0.1401778906583786,
0.12222816795110703,
-0.60687655210495,
0.11093335598707199,
-0.12318827956914902,
0.87989741563797,
0.3147825598716736,
-0.8219310641288757,
-0.3704726994037628,
-0.3908948004245758,
0.6027179956436157,
-0.527084469795227,
0.27189409732818604,
0.3006086051464081,
0.2580116391181946,
-0.1788358837366104,
-0.5601045489311218,
-0.4965485632419586,
0.22156548500061035,
-0.39093220233917236,
-0.06404376775026321,
0.10891541093587875,
0.12015350908041,
-0.020740609616041183,
0.44101467728614807,
-0.653896689414978,
-0.5355218648910522,
-0.08759139478206635,
-0.5072277188301086,
0.5238655209541321,
0.13513097167015076,
0.20635949075222015,
-0.25370869040489197,
-0.40846171975135803,
-0.18676899373531342,
-0.4893271327018738,
0.15582433342933655,
-0.19369542598724365,
0.33281952142715454,
0.3636223077774048,
0.3724043071269989,
-0.5071564316749573,
1.0298666954040527,
0.3274935781955719,
-0.3883490264415741,
0.3337903320789337,
-0.729972779750824,
-0.3242582082748413,
-0.04036707058548927,
0.44578394293785095,
0.06992761045694351,
-0.28939929604530334,
-0.46755731105804443,
-0.05963292345404625,
-0.1800483912229538,
0.325555682182312,
-0.8444273471832275,
-0.03055630996823311,
0.48275983333587646,
-0.3591829240322113,
0.09813924133777618,
0.3055412769317627,
-0.6482378244400024,
-0.07595905661582947,
-0.06869254261255264,
0.9877691268920898,
-0.7277899384498596,
-0.09129165858030319,
0.4620792865753174,
-0.3447197377681732,
0.28123369812965393,
0.25782904028892517,
-0.5352015495300293,
0.24431850016117096,
0.8750325441360474,
0.6394087076187134,
0.07005799561738968,
-0.5469077825546265,
-0.9555022716522217,
0.11245804280042648,
-0.0525473952293396,
0.972123920917511,
-0.7934998869895935,
-0.39741086959838867,
-0.08498168736696243,
0.00650766771286726,
-0.473659873008728,
-0.5168668627738953,
0.7664564251899719,
-0.6203875541687012,
0.3671534061431885,
-0.42447972297668457,
-0.5237814784049988,
-0.44788938760757446,
0.5645578503608704,
-0.4920927584171295,
0.9231388568878174,
0.30366459488868713,
-0.6682907342910767,
0.5232441425323486,
-0.8496466279029846,
-0.49821627140045166,
-0.016774818301200867,
-0.16071908175945282,
-0.3014146685600281,
0.0678541287779808,
0.6511037945747375,
0.3766021132469177,
0.1015937551856041,
0.6077366471290588,
0.07230254262685776,
-0.4246580898761749,
-0.08080938458442688,
-0.3553463816642761,
0.48019206523895264,
0.21814924478530884,
-0.06037366762757301,
0.1726929396390915,
-0.5058789253234863,
0.028790833428502083,
-0.16227614879608154,
-0.670188844203949,
-0.5180022120475769,
-0.003754502860829234,
-0.22978322207927704,
0.3563581705093384,
0.0018898609559983015,
-0.7370167374610901,
0.24406220018863678,
-0.09778250008821487,
0.27227839827537537,
0.315863698720932,
0.3409450054168701,
0.5223132371902466,
-0.5600436925888062,
0.2722040116786957,
0.40146520733833313,
0.034694261848926544,
-0.29273366928100586,
-0.6767759919166565,
-0.3813522756099701,
-0.22182314097881317,
0.31854936480522156,
0.5613678097724915,
-1.3218660354614258,
0.18491216003894806,
-0.5240045785903931,
-0.2577175199985504,
-0.7126292586326599,
-0.15893886983394623,
0.5985185503959656,
0.6908144354820251,
0.5771586298942566,
-0.019918343052268028,
0.001958188833668828,
-0.7148233652114868,
-0.3172406852245331,
0.14768216013908386,
-0.024336235597729683,
0.6218861937522888,
0.6931009292602539,
-0.23547595739364624,
1.0719444751739502,
-0.6462939977645874,
-0.36397406458854675,
-0.05653922259807587,
0.31944528222084045,
0.12269308418035507,
0.46402010321617126,
0.3337823748588562,
-1.1881986856460571,
-0.16019128262996674,
0.08480200916528702,
-0.6060983538627625,
0.1011451780796051,
-0.16858959197998047,
-0.6009330153465271,
-0.2164413332939148,
0.4806220531463623,
-0.5839638710021973,
0.04351990297436714,
0.2339000552892685,
-0.7839721441268921,
0.25632017850875854,
-0.10245702415704727,
0.5620853304862976,
-1.1444298028945923,
-0.03011433780193329,
-0.296830415725708,
-0.1350690722465515,
-0.8418375849723816,
0.3364836275577545,
0.2887636423110962,
0.12045881897211075,
-0.33806082606315613,
0.3849135935306549,
-0.2159213423728943,
0.12409476935863495,
-0.20433998107910156,
0.1582547277212143,
0.2819637060165405,
0.5223008394241333,
0.13252291083335876,
0.9790857434272766,
0.3933602273464203,
-0.6801175475120544,
-0.04809947311878204,
0.612432599067688,
-0.31334733963012695,
0.6673239469528198,
-0.3893028795719147,
0.15214848518371582,
-0.5537922978401184,
0.4213458299636841,
-0.9493896961212158,
-0.46845144033432007,
0.0757698342204094,
-0.43243512511253357,
0.08486652374267578,
-0.21717607975006104,
-0.26985669136047363,
-0.05361274629831314,
-0.2272004932165146,
0.8484971523284912,
0.1294112652540207,
-0.6083230376243591,
0.9873006939888,
0.37739184498786926,
-0.15585200488567352,
-0.6726273894309998,
-0.5501702427864075,
-0.16411177814006805,
-0.12223784625530243,
-1.0000197887420654,
0.5492181777954102,
-0.08423103392124176,
-0.058028414845466614,
0.03915666416287422,
-0.12166253477334976,
-0.33369970321655273,
0.013281870633363724,
0.13439220190048218,
-0.032954439520835876,
-0.26701048016548157,
0.33504021167755127,
0.21620018780231476,
0.14126209914684296,
0.028908172622323036,
-0.32132384181022644,
0.5651643872261047,
0.014298289082944393,
-0.2818285822868347,
0.07873386889696121,
0.8232148885726929,
0.5070191621780396,
-0.4716252088546753,
0.8452284336090088,
0.785662055015564,
-0.3799865245819092,
-0.18032917380332947,
-0.25210264325141907,
-0.05192365124821663,
-0.43530985713005066,
0.24156297743320465,
-0.6677449941635132,
-1.177100419998169,
0.3613297641277313,
-0.07107473164796829,
0.17586778104305267,
0.5246543288230896,
0.25354939699172974,
0.3296928107738495,
0.8442212343215942,
0.38577041029930115,
0.10121175646781921,
0.26798808574676514,
-0.3017234802246094,
0.21196074783802032,
-1.0500047206878662,
-0.5285383462905884,
-0.4087521731853485,
-0.060339219868183136,
0.028726866468787193,
-0.5313531756401062,
0.7115434408187866,
0.06750240176916122,
0.05949864909052849,
-0.0294998437166214,
-0.3832267224788666,
0.6218973398208618,
0.4629555940628052,
0.3345744013786316,
0.3662590980529785,
-0.14988169074058533,
-0.04513593390583992,
0.47431105375289917,
-0.9330891966819763,
-0.34541574120521545,
0.8842170238494873,
0.03151465579867363,
0.6375438570976257,
0.28255170583724976,
0.6587803959846497,
0.179366335272789,
0.0536101832985878,
-0.6057831645011902,
0.39820823073387146,
-0.07879438996315002,
-0.6559709906578064,
-0.3669354319572449,
-0.5815240144729614,
-0.8664501905441284,
0.8949083089828491,
-0.2893817722797394,
-0.5338186025619507,
0.2626159191131592,
-0.05730853229761124,
-0.6648778319358826,
0.06415208429098129,
-0.7703279852867126,
1.1217902898788452,
0.3085506558418274,
-0.04798363521695137,
0.10681275278329849,
-0.44626760482788086,
0.7123368382453918,
0.032422956079244614,
0.36504876613616943,
0.1988438218832016,
0.09188235551118851,
0.580809473991394,
-0.24037548899650574,
0.4102983772754669,
-0.19179502129554749,
-0.21407343447208405,
0.322478711605072,
-0.09216301143169403,
0.33186960220336914,
0.4293159544467926,
-0.03048587404191494,
-0.06889388710260391,
0.211419478058815,
-0.5301879644393921,
-0.5124242305755615,
0.729250967502594,
-0.45878276228904724,
-0.591107189655304,
-0.27658236026763916,
-0.8813916444778442,
-0.3092077374458313,
0.10062872618436813,
0.3285042643547058,
0.978893518447876,
-0.1805233508348465,
0.20402120053768158,
1.0216386318206787,
0.15076445043087006,
0.5104398727416992,
0.24319708347320557,
0.07248286157846451,
-0.40237244963645935,
0.9065632820129395,
0.01280160527676344,
0.41852617263793945,
0.5402945280075073,
-0.0035043656826019287,
-0.34836769104003906,
-0.7755034565925598,
-0.7482245564460754,
0.046863093972206116,
-0.8936667442321777,
-0.2813088893890381,
-0.9430190920829773,
-0.24400080740451813,
-0.43378975987434387,
0.037894342094659805,
0.23782095313072205,
0.03350149840116501,
-0.10379482060670853,
0.11751946806907654,
0.06965475529432297,
0.4242289066314697,
0.31792837381362915,
0.39180171489715576,
-1.0840510129928589,
0.6660498380661011,
0.5176231861114502,
0.20306390523910522,
-0.17173919081687927,
-0.3384830057621002,
-0.2327866107225418,
0.2859790325164795,
-0.2272903323173523,
-0.6723705530166626,
-0.04183252900838852,
0.4826785922050476,
0.5545027256011963,
0.2593311369419098,
0.31023404002189636,
0.8253388404846191,
-0.3724120855331421,
0.9443776607513428,
-0.4806740880012512,
-0.8964218497276306,
0.3247494399547577,
-0.2970150411128998,
0.775856077671051,
0.6691922545433044,
0.2803226113319397,
-0.44477570056915283,
-0.2674174904823303,
-0.43748345971107483,
-0.6726208329200745,
0.7521125674247742,
0.19556564092636108,
-0.09137991070747375,
-0.27578145265579224,
0.2548677325248718,
0.4505593776702881,
0.25751978158950806,
-0.41780903935432434,
0.018239349126815796,
-0.15502193570137024,
-0.1169387549161911,
-0.10717765241861343,
-0.23012979328632355,
-0.37899893522262573,
-0.11176011711359024,
0.5505707859992981,
-0.5213838815689087,
0.45338377356529236,
0.5855399966239929,
-0.4500553011894226,
0.22678853571414948,
0.5166139006614685,
0.5900900959968567,
0.6753789186477661,
-0.2115573287010193,
0.17195437848567963,
0.2285752147436142,
-0.5541753172874451,
0.01122750248759985,
0.008664848282933235,
-0.3029114007949829,
0.15338696539402008,
0.5029001832008362,
0.47685563564300537,
0.05034990236163139,
-0.6018294095993042,
0.6438635587692261,
-0.1526537388563156,
-0.3778620958328247,
0.2124752402305603,
0.15659630298614502,
-0.11895830929279327,
0.2522609829902649,
0.5189634561538696,
0.13031548261642456,
0.4794946312904358,
-0.8089120984077454,
0.40192192792892456,
0.6431889533996582,
-0.1378600001335144,
0.025362255051732063,
0.2661728262901306,
0.29933252930641174,
0.031770575791597366,
0.4949687719345093,
-0.3298274576663971,
-0.5202017426490784,
0.4036976397037506,
0.3215453028678894,
0.657500684261322,
-0.06680184602737427,
0.4046788215637207,
0.29010817408561707,
0.019782893359661102,
-0.1942489743232727,
0.6560438871383667,
-0.30379539728164673,
-0.6957354545593262,
-0.5979859232902527,
-0.6828912496566772,
-0.1668909192085266,
-0.06323538720607758,
-0.7585837244987488,
-0.286084920167923,
0.06958992779254913,
0.04208902642130852,
0.09946702420711517,
-0.16978906095027924,
-0.17470937967300415,
0.27021101117134094,
-0.07895475625991821,
1.003434181213379,
-0.8348032832145691,
0.8352495431900024,
0.6148576736450195,
-0.23216722905635834,
-0.5020875930786133,
0.27101224660873413,
-0.13393980264663696,
-0.3334786593914032,
0.0027936461847275496,
0.258850634098053,
-0.27160942554473877,
-0.027298491448163986,
-0.36426520347595215,
-0.8175148963928223,
1.286482334136963,
0.08794589340686798,
0.1801859438419342,
-0.05788813903927803,
-0.05340356007218361,
0.012423270381987095,
-0.7748222351074219,
0.14687226712703705,
0.8227131366729736,
0.44768601655960083,
0.3323921263217926,
-0.9915263652801514,
0.0831620916724205,
-0.23331885039806366,
-0.29596537351608276,
0.6104601621627808,
-0.40450093150138855,
1.1773507595062256,
-0.08970240503549576,
-0.35970479249954224,
0.009012186899781227,
0.465476393699646,
0.04975966364145279,
0.566068708896637,
0.49553677439689636,
0.46589669585227966,
0.7725731134414673,
-0.49475333094596863,
1.1312737464904785,
0.002737156581133604,
0.34030210971832275,
0.9564938545227051,
0.1166706383228302,
0.8282732963562012,
0.43176141381263733,
0.1617971658706665,
0.6502795219421387,
0.5472440123558044,
0.34806784987449646,
0.8922229409217834,
-0.1805548220872879,
-0.28938019275665283,
-0.602250337600708,
-0.24930158257484436,
-0.3388092517852783,
0.3846651613712311,
0.3415739834308624,
-0.03040648251771927,
-0.6969157457351685,
0.19277627766132355,
-0.008336503989994526,
0.026510661467909813,
-0.5020470023155212,
0.9505420327186584,
-0.2746512293815613,
-0.9141615033149719,
0.8107268810272217,
-0.07120491564273834,
0.7571181058883667,
-0.7189351320266724,
-0.2013520747423172,
-0.1851457953453064,
0.2078986018896103,
-0.34920886158943176,
-0.8600476980209351,
0.41350746154785156,
-0.42786115407943726,
-0.31493839621543884,
-0.09576775878667831,
0.5832253098487854,
-0.7988452315330505,
-0.23606820404529572,
-0.04479343816637993,
0.7499728202819824,
-0.09475627541542053,
-0.5148656368255615,
-0.36222419142723083,
-0.1882890909910202,
-0.06714429706335068,
0.12071766704320908,
0.48358282446861267,
0.485353022813797,
-0.14509285986423492,
0.5859203934669495,
0.533145546913147,
-0.6324267387390137,
0.03700341656804085,
-0.14803725481033325,
1.1084275245666504,
-0.553307831287384,
-0.5929368138313293,
-0.6584321856498718,
0.6114078760147095,
-0.15707841515541077,
-0.4492007791996002,
0.7618167400360107,
0.4483772814273834,
0.9145458340644836,
-0.11832049489021301,
0.4517399072647095,
-0.19890864193439484,
0.1349169760942459,
-0.7811065912246704,
0.47142326831817627,
-0.6072177290916443,
-0.03727097436785698,
-0.17334702610969543,
-0.6291617751121521,
-0.15441922843456268,
0.2554231882095337,
-0.07314102351665497,
0.05344473198056221,
0.8428567051887512,
0.7808887362480164,
-0.23063600063323975,
0.1787959635257721,
0.23289862275123596,
-0.16464513540267944,
0.2625530958175659,
0.9460328817367554,
0.6455562710762024,
-0.5920051336288452,
0.7416614890098572,
-0.06836365908384323,
-0.20231084525585175,
-0.1978699266910553,
-0.48095545172691345,
-0.8576151132583618,
-0.7279195785522461,
-0.2819158434867859,
-0.25344347953796387,
-0.2167387455701828,
0.6132755875587463,
0.816032886505127,
-0.7309495210647583,
0.08442171663045883,
0.20566317439079285,
0.21060851216316223,
-0.6978036761283875,
-0.2403111606836319,
0.4273809790611267,
-0.3261522352695465,
-0.6112837791442871,
0.5885258913040161,
0.3080366253852844,
-0.15377768874168396,
0.0030999062582850456,
-0.0876057893037796,
-0.6257110834121704,
0.32940012216567993,
0.8533976078033447,
-0.11519071459770203,
-0.6938356757164001,
-0.48192140460014343,
0.009433947503566742,
-0.03470014035701752,
0.09528536349534988,
0.7983996272087097,
-0.9417514204978943,
0.2784308195114136,
0.6077709794044495,
0.8127090930938721,
0.2092992216348648,
0.6191341280937195,
0.4452037513256073,
-0.880327582359314,
-0.1879556030035019,
0.1837589293718338,
0.25950387120246887,
0.12953327596187592,
-0.5755428671836853,
0.40661323070526123,
-0.09093541651964188,
-0.5813871026039124,
-0.6107849478721619,
0.25649648904800415,
-0.9436036944389343,
-0.5419598817825317,
1.2916985750198364,
-0.2489650696516037,
-0.4114631712436676,
-0.4503840506076813,
-0.4542538523674011,
-0.2913760244846344,
-0.4076506197452545,
0.5667982697486877,
0.9692472219467163,
-0.262582391500473,
-0.04977976158261299,
-0.2651161253452301,
0.548907995223999,
0.2716291546821594,
-0.8503656983375549,
0.03395973518490791,
0.7127289175987244,
0.16993579268455505,
0.4241294860839844,
0.5086308121681213,
-0.0015601929044350982,
0.5835575461387634,
0.28412485122680664,
-0.5246083736419678,
-0.4004878103733063,
-0.4989932179450989,
-0.48246562480926514,
0.7678883075714111,
-0.23277468979358673,
-0.42926615476608276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02575v1
|
Language Models as Compilers: Simulating Pseudocode Execution Improves Algorithmic Reasoning in Language Models
| 2024-04-03T08:49:11 | 2024-04-03T08:49:11 |
Hyungjoo Chae, Yeonghyeon Kim, Seungone Kim, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Beong-woo Kwak, Moohyeon Kim, Seonghwan Kim, Taeyoon Kwon, Jiwan Chung, Youngjae Yu, Jinyoung Yeo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Algorithmic reasoning refers to the ability to understand the complex
patterns behind the problem and decompose them into a sequence of reasoning
steps towards the solution. Such nature of algorithmic reasoning makes it a
challenge for large language models (LLMs), even though they have demonstrated
promising performance in other reasoning tasks. Within this context, some
recent studies use programming languages (e.g., Python) to express the
necessary logic for solving a given instance/question (e.g.,
Program-of-Thought) as inspired by their strict and precise syntaxes. However,
it is non-trivial to write an executable code that expresses the correct logic
on the fly within a single inference call. Also, the code generated
specifically for an instance cannot be reused for others, even if they are from
the same task and might require identical logic to solve. This paper presents
Think-and-Execute, a novel framework that decomposes the reasoning process of
language models into two steps. (1) In Think, we discover a task-level logic
that is shared across all instances for solving a given task and then express
the logic with pseudocode; (2) In Execute, we further tailor the generated
pseudocode to each instance and simulate the execution of the code. With
extensive experiments on seven algorithmic reasoning tasks, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of Think-and-Execute. Our approach better improves LMs' reasoning
compared to several strong baselines performing instance-specific reasoning
(e.g., CoT and PoT), suggesting the helpfulness of discovering task-level
logic. Also, we show that compared to natural language, pseudocode can better
guide the reasoning of LMs, even though they are trained to follow natural
language instructions.
|
[
-0.16037555038928986,
-0.8437415957450867,
0.8723980784416199,
-0.07598061859607697,
-0.04756439849734306,
0.01469953078776598,
-0.2677503526210785,
-0.5182897448539734,
-0.010317173786461353,
0.6606230139732361,
-0.43806177377700806,
-0.1754383146762848,
-0.2544277608394623,
-0.11029891669750214,
-0.3721940219402313,
0.834481954574585,
-0.1300557255744934,
-0.013319744728505611,
-0.20614668726921082,
0.059396032243967056,
-0.1217578575015068,
-0.6354975700378418,
-0.3313809335231781,
-0.17799101769924164,
0.010080765001475811,
0.0688084214925766,
0.6939119696617126,
0.6260574460029602,
0.29706892371177673,
0.33827343583106995,
0.04638832062482834,
0.18684247136116028,
-0.49212369322776794,
0.1051022931933403,
-0.2687018811702728,
-0.8048673868179321,
-0.16921845078468323,
-0.11201568692922592,
0.35518574714660645,
0.6626455783843994,
-0.37888333201408386,
0.12886561453342438,
-0.2886861562728882,
0.4804369807243347,
-0.6564053297042847,
0.23881137371063232,
-0.5923119187355042,
-0.10794226080179214,
0.10491223633289337,
-0.16622887551784515,
-0.5019792318344116,
-0.586778998374939,
-0.1179003119468689,
-0.46182936429977417,
-0.0813719853758812,
0.1866573840379715,
0.34086617827415466,
0.21642398834228516,
0.010870758444070816,
-0.5318238139152527,
-0.9506826996803284,
0.8377472758293152,
-1.0052540302276611,
0.3390330672264099,
-0.042700979858636856,
0.1828116476535797,
-0.2654881775379181,
-0.8601419925689697,
-0.7874119281768799,
-0.37330007553100586,
-0.024997461587190628,
-0.20006303489208221,
0.007902399636805058,
0.23896433413028717,
0.6734675765037537,
0.42970579862594604,
-0.6499337553977966,
-0.16809843480587006,
-0.3343850076198578,
-0.018655790016055107,
0.4401259124279022,
0.14011195302009583,
0.5921330451965332,
0.15781916677951813,
-0.04915083944797516,
0.059883859008550644,
-0.8027681708335876,
0.034340426325798035,
0.22287428379058838,
0.2783345580101013,
0.10202456265687943,
0.5598785281181335,
-0.13984814286231995,
0.8473583459854126,
-0.29944244027137756,
0.13876396417617798,
0.16266939043998718,
-0.2139039784669876,
-0.34880495071411133,
0.05697208270430565,
0.7501039505004883,
0.10623516142368317,
0.6793808937072754,
-0.002238939981907606,
-0.21635007858276367,
0.5906099081039429,
0.43474045395851135,
-0.7499514222145081,
-0.33825400471687317,
0.5062734484672546,
-0.5181888341903687,
-0.10092726349830627,
-0.022980038076639175,
-0.3465815782546997,
-0.17270712554454803,
-0.5931403040885925,
0.4085612893104553,
-0.43347370624542236,
-0.3132837116718292,
0.5262525677680969,
-0.05702350661158562,
0.33684784173965454,
0.25967663526535034,
-0.6757771968841553,
0.5077482461929321,
0.9942472577095032,
0.4945051968097687,
0.22083008289337158,
-0.3348674476146698,
-0.5326537489891052,
0.04077552631497383,
-0.7768793702125549,
0.6568068861961365,
-0.6967837810516357,
-0.157194584608078,
0.019462449476122856,
-0.5041537284851074,
-0.10377822816371918,
-0.6184731125831604,
0.32070475816726685,
-0.4951743483543396,
0.22584748268127441,
-0.29757311940193176,
-0.8698011040687561,
-0.05724114179611206,
0.07842714339494705,
-0.5500710606575012,
1.1309611797332764,
-0.08908747136592865,
-0.7446916103363037,
0.1837529093027115,
-0.677281379699707,
-0.4215107560157776,
0.17077113687992096,
-0.4094717502593994,
-0.20720317959785461,
0.3235805928707123,
0.16963715851306915,
0.27958613634109497,
-0.32542282342910767,
0.17612306773662567,
-0.40905624628067017,
-0.6584151387214661,
0.16408798098564148,
0.19147492945194244,
0.7733407616615295,
0.20399242639541626,
-0.64879310131073,
0.2555059492588043,
-0.35941973328590393,
0.5621926784515381,
0.11719697713851929,
-0.021139472723007202,
-0.16062630712985992,
0.4984050989151001,
-0.31931066513061523,
0.43211662769317627,
0.0031327169854193926,
-0.3721328377723694,
0.566505491733551,
-0.6193302273750305,
0.5365591645240784,
0.5192608833312988,
-0.059197358787059784,
0.541520893573761,
-0.35949695110321045,
0.6109123229980469,
-0.17650455236434937,
0.09158258885145187,
-0.29200947284698486,
-0.5619385838508606,
-0.8755332231521606,
-0.293895423412323,
-0.009989073500037193,
0.8750748038291931,
-0.8602451682090759,
0.052943676710128784,
-0.1103593185544014,
-0.4730566143989563,
-0.8279725909233093,
0.28647738695144653,
0.532017707824707,
0.3098762631416321,
0.24246950447559357,
-0.03707200661301613,
-0.7511622905731201,
-0.8765717148780823,
-0.51462322473526,
-0.6220375895500183,
0.35560983419418335,
0.2997761368751526,
0.47206488251686096,
-0.12206105142831802,
0.8318889737129211,
-0.5214353203773499,
0.2638591527938843,
-0.814448356628418,
0.012310564517974854,
0.4404287040233612,
0.35256901383399963,
0.3403449058532715,
-0.784074604511261,
-0.1610996574163437,
-0.0574151985347271,
-0.8677295446395874,
-0.2146080881357193,
-0.21448735892772675,
-0.14671608805656433,
0.11148785054683685,
0.5496062636375427,
-0.5102766156196594,
0.427342027425766,
0.2456548511981964,
-0.07316014915704727,
0.8485872745513916,
-0.3166446387767792,
0.3072100877761841,
-0.7505507469177246,
0.05095015838742256,
-0.33739733695983887,
-0.3783245086669922,
-0.5922529697418213,
0.5832479000091553,
0.09652148932218552,
-0.15846145153045654,
-0.5602409839630127,
0.4259296655654907,
-0.3926239013671875,
-0.23370827734470367,
-0.2678629755973816,
-0.290136456489563,
-0.2542276680469513,
0.3272518217563629,
0.393613338470459,
1.082482933998108,
0.7311766743659973,
-0.63606858253479,
0.24962589144706726,
-0.19036506116390228,
-0.6701425909996033,
0.11647290736436844,
-0.678132176399231,
0.47154322266578674,
-0.01251969113945961,
0.11346762627363205,
-0.5831286311149597,
0.026409875601530075,
0.1519325226545334,
-0.205376997590065,
-0.001588064944371581,
-0.10706374794244766,
-0.8082894086837769,
-0.37710142135620117,
-0.2021348625421524,
0.4463580250740051,
0.7167204022407532,
-0.3211310803890228,
0.6172640919685364,
0.3157249689102173,
0.043405696749687195,
-0.46125805377960205,
-0.6975441575050354,
0.13552165031433105,
0.00499278400093317,
-0.3791157901287079,
0.08247526735067368,
-0.29878392815589905,
-0.6268187761306763,
0.13952647149562836,
0.14276903867721558,
0.06726844608783722,
0.12597058713436127,
0.12243811041116714,
0.15805257856845856,
-0.24863530695438385,
-0.13716334104537964,
-0.038072723895311356,
-0.12425162643194199,
0.09383996576070786,
-0.7232898473739624,
0.5240013599395752,
-0.40408432483673096,
-0.5645843148231506,
-0.46448731422424316,
0.47469186782836914,
0.43800148367881775,
-0.5049087405204773,
0.8469182848930359,
-0.01922890916466713,
-0.408579021692276,
-0.7102962732315063,
-0.5502429604530334,
-0.2115711122751236,
-0.43383678793907166,
0.1862088143825531,
-0.47941333055496216,
-0.8624773025512695,
0.3955237865447998,
-0.3098137378692627,
0.1218215748667717,
0.08168639987707138,
0.9370483160018921,
-0.2521035969257355,
0.986958920955658,
0.6570649147033691,
-0.07449540495872498,
0.25118499994277954,
-0.34195616841316223,
0.6255837082862854,
-0.5598375201225281,
-0.26937583088874817,
-0.40015465021133423,
-0.054078105837106705,
-0.3612392544746399,
-0.8285852670669556,
0.16169027984142303,
0.28724512457847595,
0.030614415183663368,
0.5566582083702087,
-0.5254005789756775,
0.7073833346366882,
0.5704700946807861,
-0.03684181347489357,
0.015614240430295467,
-0.32100921869277954,
-0.491418719291687,
0.05427759885787964,
-0.6554049253463745,
-0.675378143787384,
0.93168705701828,
-0.08640959113836288,
0.7192180156707764,
0.09233452379703522,
1.0440791845321655,
0.4227800667285919,
0.12740257382392883,
-0.7189672589302063,
0.7338641285896301,
0.11794702708721161,
-0.592340350151062,
0.11267798393964767,
-0.5274704098701477,
-0.5118758678436279,
0.12129979580640793,
0.15924425423145294,
-0.9690709114074707,
-0.052542246878147125,
0.40238091349601746,
-0.12299014627933502,
0.45169714093208313,
-0.8846918344497681,
0.9915448427200317,
-0.2781381905078888,
-0.29068028926849365,
-0.4981975555419922,
-0.4681083858013153,
0.25127318501472473,
0.18513064086437225,
0.5969716906547546,
0.32267963886260986,
0.0716199055314064,
0.40946143865585327,
-0.5802117586135864,
0.7124601006507874,
0.021468091756105423,
-0.08687988668680191,
0.6743679642677307,
0.523787260055542,
0.4807862937450409,
-0.2960856258869171,
-0.3404346704483032,
-0.16680178046226501,
0.13230866193771362,
-0.28435346484184265,
-0.9431199431419373,
0.5531371235847473,
-0.30843451619148254,
-0.6378098726272583,
-0.43692490458488464,
-0.38416826725006104,
0.053220588713884354,
0.12375906854867935,
-0.09638718515634537,
0.5294053554534912,
-0.07217589765787125,
-0.2980461120605469,
0.6713499426841736,
-0.07736458629369736,
0.3385568857192993,
0.2789059281349182,
-0.5478112697601318,
-0.02994239702820778,
0.7303931713104248,
-0.13694609701633453,
0.42201727628707886,
0.5575166344642639,
0.08957184106111526,
-0.2746698558330536,
-0.4778522253036499,
-0.44937270879745483,
0.22833774983882904,
-0.8404790759086609,
0.1343473494052887,
-0.6828417778015137,
-0.20247973501682281,
-0.212897390127182,
-0.14209523797035217,
-0.32225772738456726,
-0.513870120048523,
0.08524193614721298,
-0.18400853872299194,
0.024293914437294006,
0.8021796941757202,
-0.0025276262313127518,
-0.08748739957809448,
-0.5468268394470215,
0.3704679012298584,
0.2987864017486572,
0.1224682554602623,
0.03724350780248642,
-0.19687527418136597,
-0.16393262147903442,
-0.023931380361318588,
0.1310838907957077,
-1.0342403650283813,
0.2555844187736511,
0.21202540397644043,
0.6382482647895813,
0.20573006570339203,
-0.004850467666983604,
0.7290973663330078,
-0.6656571626663208,
0.6512203216552734,
-0.23097550868988037,
-1.199104905128479,
0.8346492648124695,
-0.17931541800498962,
0.2207413613796234,
0.4741773009300232,
0.1511743813753128,
-0.3860695958137512,
-0.4869858920574188,
-0.561588704586029,
-0.4236116111278534,
0.8340848088264465,
0.4154343605041504,
0.06391479820013046,
-0.2684575915336609,
0.42903366684913635,
-0.07979656755924225,
0.326232373714447,
-0.6560943722724915,
-0.2442677617073059,
0.06088398024439812,
-0.24435530602931976,
0.11093331128358841,
-0.35403573513031006,
0.09199338406324387,
-0.2901613414287567,
0.5393639802932739,
-0.14320194721221924,
0.4610307514667511,
-0.09067940711975098,
-0.3322867751121521,
0.0016581793315708637,
0.33348944783210754,
0.4807899594306946,
0.8187488317489624,
-0.1776442676782608,
0.3352055251598358,
-0.11964787542819977,
-0.0302992332726717,
0.012117267586290836,
-0.1491587907075882,
-0.14898082613945007,
-0.40773656964302063,
0.6760096549987793,
0.7554839253425598,
0.23012493550777435,
-1.2190957069396973,
0.36135706305503845,
0.020252924412488937,
0.07255739718675613,
-0.09734515845775604,
0.4745229482650757,
0.39333033561706543,
0.288348525762558,
0.04910901188850403,
0.10213115066289902,
0.41197469830513,
-0.9853920340538025,
0.31429076194763184,
0.26756972074508667,
-0.15277111530303955,
-0.28251028060913086,
0.6092878580093384,
-0.0024044334422796965,
-0.5886789560317993,
0.748937726020813,
-0.6051910519599915,
-1.1242835521697998,
0.7672345042228699,
0.7428316473960876,
0.7836759686470032,
-0.018139716237783432,
0.06226290017366409,
0.2544004023075104,
0.45119231939315796,
-0.33197593688964844,
0.875038206577301,
-0.1735532134771347,
-0.7932055592536926,
-0.8211683034896851,
-0.5701636075973511,
-0.3876645863056183,
-0.11210412532091141,
-0.5072001814842224,
0.11275538802146912,
-0.5698058009147644,
0.06495794653892517,
-0.1648978292942047,
-0.06695465743541718,
-0.5759104490280151,
0.20711302757263184,
0.38652095198631287,
0.8851742148399353,
-0.7836160063743591,
0.9599930047988892,
0.909110426902771,
-0.16845223307609558,
-0.94362473487854,
-0.1327192187309265,
0.11553420126438141,
-0.6234021186828613,
0.5834685564041138,
0.4243192970752716,
-0.31222060322761536,
-0.03989021107554436,
-0.4798133671283722,
-0.5882896780967712,
0.42253369092941284,
0.47546282410621643,
-0.681921124458313,
0.11910384148359299,
0.12878848612308502,
0.6694953441619873,
-0.48111197352409363,
0.45718416571617126,
0.6035974025726318,
0.20436982810497284,
-0.03528348729014397,
-1.093401312828064,
-0.018127528950572014,
-0.3233054280281067,
-0.08304710686206818,
0.5069894790649414,
-0.12039259076118469,
0.6765694618225098,
-0.661248505115509,
-0.12088312953710556,
0.07983837276697159,
0.5523556470870972,
0.5475607514381409,
0.1410622000694275,
0.38600480556488037,
0.8053380846977234,
0.6893386244773865,
0.02117288112640381,
1.5589320659637451,
-0.39280423521995544,
0.33591753244400024,
1.1694974899291992,
-0.43749335408210754,
0.9333028197288513,
0.2685980796813965,
-0.38249829411506653,
0.7419790029525757,
0.2664822041988373,
0.3929377794265747,
0.41218459606170654,
0.33287158608436584,
-0.10107146948575974,
-0.7557341456413269,
0.181086003780365,
-0.1555291712284088,
0.37720346450805664,
0.49962151050567627,
-0.32730841636657715,
-0.05771716311573982,
-0.2460518330335617,
-0.009430574253201485,
0.3727804720401764,
-0.23502226173877716,
0.6465787291526794,
0.225511372089386,
-0.7131386995315552,
0.44255882501602173,
0.016495313495397568,
0.28744006156921387,
-0.5112013816833496,
-0.30821073055267334,
0.10556577891111374,
0.4484266936779022,
-0.09057062864303589,
-0.802490234375,
0.4646533131599426,
0.0510319322347641,
-0.2669364809989929,
-0.28085216879844666,
0.609637975692749,
-0.2514040470123291,
-0.670368492603302,
0.5023218393325806,
0.5633425116539001,
0.26533380150794983,
-0.07045852392911911,
-0.9920708537101746,
0.1778474599123001,
0.1447662115097046,
-0.1746845543384552,
0.07307311147451401,
0.39132562279701233,
-0.25793692469596863,
1.0632613897323608,
0.7546864151954651,
0.4177425503730774,
0.25223585963249207,
0.2749456763267517,
0.9061479568481445,
-0.5160595178604126,
-0.5392332077026367,
-1.0770108699798584,
0.3215683698654175,
-0.01065570767968893,
0.08283687382936478,
0.4637806713581085,
0.7828143835067749,
0.8317301869392395,
-0.022671926766633987,
0.8084040284156799,
-0.2717292606830597,
0.47936591506004333,
-0.697874903678894,
0.4620087444782257,
-0.41872966289520264,
0.46270495653152466,
-0.27435293793678284,
-1.029006838798523,
-0.26306551694869995,
0.8525590300559998,
-0.6259710192680359,
0.31277674436569214,
0.6742050051689148,
0.8947814106941223,
-0.09334595501422882,
-0.007907828316092491,
0.1264914870262146,
0.16652871668338776,
0.41481998562812805,
0.7678015828132629,
0.9524660110473633,
-0.046468403190374374,
0.16342346370220184,
-0.3497692346572876,
-0.2741313874721527,
0.01273207925260067,
-0.9411731362342834,
-0.9140199422836304,
-0.4110703766345978,
-0.35960668325424194,
-0.2407560795545578,
0.21683728694915771,
1.1228113174438477,
0.7658010721206665,
-0.9595547318458557,
-0.5206835865974426,
-0.32611915469169617,
0.10720738768577576,
-0.5640091896057129,
-0.21695025265216827,
0.370336651802063,
-0.3797476291656494,
-0.6146141290664673,
0.41100752353668213,
0.4762265980243683,
-0.42639631032943726,
-0.10133515298366547,
-0.13034692406654358,
-0.28001847863197327,
0.35961562395095825,
0.34247785806655884,
0.46360617876052856,
-0.8315930962562561,
-0.04854995012283325,
-0.20653797686100006,
-0.006986607797443867,
-0.15029723942279816,
1.1676712036132812,
-1.241598129272461,
0.7951328754425049,
0.5172939896583557,
0.5752965211868286,
0.3637007474899292,
0.010240699164569378,
0.757006824016571,
-0.2611454427242279,
0.2677626311779022,
0.43367844820022583,
0.46656712889671326,
0.21470314264297485,
-0.20342576503753662,
0.32952335476875305,
0.19219213724136353,
-0.36167725920677185,
-0.8522154688835144,
0.48987632989883423,
-0.6358586549758911,
-0.5400890707969666,
0.9854418635368347,
-0.23287811875343323,
-0.21252503991127014,
-0.05829543620347977,
-0.16704769432544708,
0.11427081376314163,
-0.2139100730419159,
0.6056219339370728,
0.46744340658187866,
-0.3237643539905548,
-0.4649595618247986,
-0.5535513162612915,
0.63399738073349,
0.4929443299770355,
-0.9059380888938904,
0.09199011325836182,
0.2673189043998718,
0.283468633890152,
-0.04612496867775917,
0.7301695942878723,
0.011137361638247967,
0.34227851033210754,
-0.11500154435634613,
0.13447798788547516,
-0.2147568315267563,
-0.32232293486595154,
-0.054646555334329605,
0.014008266851305962,
0.09098716825246811,
0.0723816454410553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07229v1
|
Personality-affected Emotion Generation in Dialog Systems
| 2024-04-03T08:48:50 | 2024-04-03T08:48:50 |
Zhiyuan Wen, Jiannong Cao, Jiaxing Shen, Ruosong Yang, Shuaiqi Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generating appropriate emotions for responses is essential for dialog systems
to provide human-like interaction in various application scenarios. Most
previous dialog systems tried to achieve this goal by learning empathetic
manners from anonymous conversational data. However, emotional responses
generated by those methods may be inconsistent, which will decrease user
engagement and service quality. Psychological findings suggest that the
emotional expressions of humans are rooted in personality traits. Therefore, we
propose a new task, Personality-affected Emotion Generation, to generate
emotion based on the personality given to the dialog system and further
investigate a solution through the personality-affected mood transition.
Specifically, we first construct a daily dialog dataset, Personality
EmotionLines Dataset (PELD), with emotion and personality annotations.
Subsequently, we analyze the challenges in this task, i.e., (1) heterogeneously
integrating personality and emotional factors and (2) extracting
multi-granularity emotional information in the dialog context. Finally, we
propose to model the personality as the transition weight by simulating the
mood transition process in the dialog system and solve the challenges above. We
conduct extensive experiments on PELD for evaluation. Results suggest that by
adopting our method, the emotion generation performance is improved by 13% in
macro-F1 and 5% in weighted-F1 from the BERT-base model.
|
[
-0.5137637257575989,
-0.817314088344574,
0.6366568207740784,
0.4112602472305298,
0.022115347906947136,
-0.018280496820807457,
-0.014917921274900436,
-0.3453620672225952,
0.13632017374038696,
0.4744134843349457,
-0.9866864681243896,
-0.32266777753829956,
-0.18528032302856445,
0.2635587751865387,
0.07879001647233963,
1.2068010568618774,
0.14188189804553986,
0.1311064511537552,
0.061437834054231644,
0.16903014481067657,
-0.5084967613220215,
-0.7127878665924072,
-0.608445405960083,
-0.599179208278656,
0.5665170550346375,
0.42785826325416565,
0.3864912986755371,
-0.1571950763463974,
0.238482266664505,
0.2117600440979004,
-0.09664776176214218,
-0.01293639000505209,
-0.5086296796798706,
0.39565926790237427,
0.1829524040222168,
-0.34319007396698,
-0.8447598814964294,
0.06265687197446823,
0.18353994190692902,
0.3921765983104706,
-0.26013317704200745,
-0.005399005953222513,
0.0228703785687685,
0.6779062747955322,
-0.5329511165618896,
0.2459731549024582,
-0.4625973105430603,
0.4274391233921051,
-0.198787659406662,
-0.36012598872184753,
-0.36179494857788086,
-0.43372637033462524,
0.5839396715164185,
-0.18037493526935577,
0.08756392449140549,
0.05962949991226196,
0.5085991621017456,
0.034458037465810776,
-0.7949032187461853,
-0.43035218119621277,
-0.7226111888885498,
0.5333472490310669,
-0.623634397983551,
0.08430700749158859,
0.08478356152772903,
0.20351329445838928,
-0.01874551549553871,
-0.005172193981707096,
-0.4939877688884735,
-0.08635338395833969,
0.16901394724845886,
0.2907262146472931,
-0.1478971242904663,
0.19161874055862427,
0.2582051157951355,
0.18834204971790314,
-0.2955875098705292,
-0.4187828600406647,
0.015158997848629951,
-0.031201792880892754,
0.682314395904541,
0.5938215255737305,
0.04727601632475853,
-0.5503058433532715,
0.16842889785766602,
-0.1061406210064888,
-0.5937687754631042,
0.14259779453277588,
0.7230326533317566,
0.34865283966064453,
-0.05243502929806709,
0.41944217681884766,
-0.17175428569316864,
0.3127695918083191,
0.6851764917373657,
-0.023130036890506744,
0.35606545209884644,
-0.18727853894233704,
-0.16723012924194336,
0.17633283138275146,
0.45904669165611267,
0.5948870778083801,
0.35439932346343994,
0.25314638018608093,
-0.04750072583556175,
-0.13115447759628296,
0.2722671329975128,
-1.0493710041046143,
-0.2849896252155304,
0.4840538203716278,
-0.40049606561660767,
-0.6791478991508484,
-0.046971824020147324,
-1.0177072286605835,
-0.5242833495140076,
-0.10876332968473434,
0.28079116344451904,
-0.510850191116333,
-0.41474559903144836,
-0.1881006807088852,
0.11559897661209106,
0.06750187277793884,
0.5854046940803528,
-0.8337844014167786,
0.10891785472631454,
0.3027770221233368,
0.5769302845001221,
0.11321470886468887,
0.19549395143985748,
-0.5488860607147217,
-0.1863117516040802,
0.0774756520986557,
0.5511711835861206,
-0.6438705325126648,
-0.6766552925109863,
0.08293947577476501,
-0.06145772710442543,
-0.0888868123292923,
-0.5228188633918762,
0.3092808127403259,
-0.1307275891304016,
0.39198702573776245,
-0.36980539560317993,
-0.5806764364242554,
0.1498405635356903,
0.17246726155281067,
-0.3244464695453644,
0.638218879699707,
0.19878217577934265,
-0.6755664348602295,
-0.012766183353960514,
-0.8536357283592224,
-0.4605828821659088,
-0.04716530814766884,
0.03767015039920807,
-0.3614461123943329,
0.3489264249801636,
0.01850728876888752,
0.5384076833724976,
-0.13172149658203125,
0.18581871688365936,
-0.3834972679615021,
0.07616885751485825,
0.41066601872444153,
0.05791306868195534,
0.5436204075813293,
0.22824746370315552,
-0.39797312021255493,
-0.05526258051395416,
-0.5852011442184448,
0.1768682301044464,
-0.02634318359196186,
-0.2571732997894287,
-0.10438386350870132,
0.15610045194625854,
0.20001427829265594,
0.3685832619667053,
0.3937237560749054,
-0.7952175140380859,
0.056263916194438934,
-0.18555675446987152,
0.07824118435382843,
1.0105401277542114,
0.40287670493125916,
0.2986617088317871,
-0.04019957035779953,
0.5619321465492249,
0.2855049967765808,
0.16781990230083466,
-0.1426592767238617,
-0.5573821663856506,
-0.5244512557983398,
0.15364094078540802,
-0.05087358132004738,
0.6643241047859192,
-0.4340534806251526,
0.7068125009536743,
0.2592090964317322,
-0.3960614502429962,
-0.30271005630493164,
-0.19682395458221436,
0.5074889659881592,
0.7570249438285828,
-0.0796995535492897,
-0.24707111716270447,
-0.36944296956062317,
-0.6332443952560425,
-0.10346992313861847,
-0.38210994005203247,
-0.11175704747438431,
0.907304584980011,
0.08228638023138046,
-0.23147913813591003,
1.0403053760528564,
-0.7991684079170227,
0.18148136138916016,
-0.20001736283302307,
0.584502100944519,
-0.10441974550485611,
0.4054022431373596,
0.3809047341346741,
-0.6073557138442993,
-0.7084304094314575,
-0.06975223869085312,
-0.49450936913490295,
-0.7442594766616821,
-0.1297597438097,
-0.15608453750610352,
0.3843871057033539,
0.029693160206079483,
-0.41249534487724304,
0.34972578287124634,
0.536561131477356,
-0.5936755537986755,
0.8879740238189697,
0.08081895858049393,
0.30248475074768066,
-0.7872615456581116,
0.007105367258191109,
0.12386634945869446,
-0.10305903851985931,
-0.8941268920898438,
-0.5384948253631592,
-0.21598896384239197,
-0.48895570635795593,
-0.32907646894454956,
0.30962541699409485,
0.00788685493171215,
-0.02618882618844509,
-0.10111314803361893,
-0.16672088205814362,
0.10437944531440735,
0.5971527695655823,
0.009138367138803005,
0.5547396540641785,
0.40414565801620483,
-0.22606317698955536,
0.27904975414276123,
0.541742205619812,
-0.009563690051436424,
1.094600796699524,
-0.4328767955303192,
0.3490094542503357,
-0.29517632722854614,
0.4928019344806671,
-0.7649292945861816,
-0.4162951707839966,
0.32860061526298523,
-0.15386441349983215,
0.0889744684100151,
0.12513723969459534,
-0.29407262802124023,
-0.02138848789036274,
-0.10138992220163345,
-0.13065442442893982,
0.6641815304756165,
-0.19262205064296722,
0.8181209564208984,
-0.037798598408699036,
-0.6242629885673523,
0.20433615148067474,
-0.1626298874616623,
0.03703612834215164,
-0.3166826665401459,
-0.8421114683151245,
0.15652568638324738,
-0.44867005944252014,
-0.35833820700645447,
-0.2591634690761566,
-0.09593994170427322,
0.1293458640575409,
-0.06354895979166031,
0.40495651960372925,
0.00028026357176713645,
0.12611918151378632,
0.2252703309059143,
0.23775635659694672,
0.22493720054626465,
0.33174943923950195,
0.4095808267593384,
0.7162269353866577,
-0.5182112455368042,
-0.0639483779668808,
-0.6615820527076721,
0.5999305248260498,
0.6266213059425354,
-0.04567378759384155,
0.6231064796447754,
0.6047157645225525,
-0.01564662531018257,
0.18601635098457336,
-0.3554106056690216,
-0.3706253170967102,
-0.45229947566986084,
0.347129225730896,
-0.5321041345596313,
-0.6395473480224609,
0.5931136608123779,
-0.29777878522872925,
0.07779446244239807,
0.12610170245170593,
0.6414075493812561,
-0.5308841466903687,
1.5785248279571533,
0.47524508833885193,
0.2895103394985199,
0.7900030612945557,
0.2011154592037201,
0.2551555931568146,
-0.8658760786056519,
-0.19057269394397736,
-0.2073536068201065,
-0.41777458786964417,
-0.4880877733230591,
0.04311879724264145,
0.4935426414012909,
-0.22796888649463654,
-0.28173187375068665,
-0.04190646484494209,
-0.2114541083574295,
-0.22709883749485016,
0.14114059507846832,
0.4259469211101532,
0.07779967784881592,
-0.1594943404197693,
0.16422319412231445,
-0.2538362443447113,
-0.31816643476486206,
-0.2927364408969879,
1.044816017150879,
0.28209295868873596,
0.7276768088340759,
0.2647952735424042,
0.9705415964126587,
0.37463638186454773,
0.48009270429611206,
-0.6114919185638428,
0.4930711090564728,
-0.0388936847448349,
-0.5292081832885742,
-0.17483089864253998,
-0.5790016651153564,
-0.6210203766822815,
-0.06469529122114182,
-0.18516921997070312,
-1.1470787525177002,
0.3112529218196869,
0.33051398396492004,
-0.49921590089797974,
-0.2972645163536072,
-1.016713261604309,
0.6201655268669128,
-0.1965644806623459,
-0.17491285502910614,
-0.184633269906044,
-0.8317791819572449,
0.3284607529640198,
-0.28552454710006714,
-0.19533447921276093,
-0.4236513376235962,
0.5334054231643677,
0.4848487079143524,
-0.720622718334198,
0.8951440453529358,
-0.5710440874099731,
-0.23216277360916138,
0.10233846306800842,
0.14578206837177277,
0.6473380923271179,
0.020880939438939095,
-0.18583209812641144,
-0.12914951145648956,
-0.0633920356631279,
-0.13457204401493073,
-0.8316659927368164,
0.3869004547595978,
-0.681265115737915,
-0.473898708820343,
-0.08468959480524063,
-0.597320020198822,
-0.5298648476600647,
-0.27402129769325256,
0.2645629644393921,
0.32752084732055664,
-0.3612099885940552,
-0.025137266144156456,
0.7239187955856323,
-0.27969062328338623,
0.1480850726366043,
0.4070616364479065,
-0.2320115566253662,
-0.18714232742786407,
0.786257266998291,
-0.11365999281406403,
0.43315836787223816,
-0.07486425340175629,
0.2367824763059616,
0.036908820271492004,
0.13497409224510193,
-0.20341555774211884,
-0.1292673796415329,
-0.2863387167453766,
-0.031147249042987823,
-0.6742050647735596,
-0.08187445998191833,
-0.4296025335788727,
-0.1282454878091812,
-0.3484494984149933,
-0.15707270801067352,
-0.4285958707332611,
0.20640625059604645,
0.30869171023368835,
0.7625525593757629,
0.16150975227355957,
0.5404287576675415,
-0.703742265701294,
0.02298499457538128,
0.6091872453689575,
0.13236835598945618,
0.0024941936135292053,
-0.17926135659217834,
-0.06286580115556717,
0.09449049085378647,
-0.7587019205093384,
-1.1985626220703125,
0.4663478136062622,
0.48940157890319824,
0.03464009240269661,
0.6784693598747253,
0.03395727276802063,
0.43072301149368286,
-0.4496786296367645,
0.6409896612167358,
0.1638881266117096,
-1.1056605577468872,
0.6845805048942566,
-0.5461036562919617,
0.3805220425128937,
0.41508838534355164,
-0.18756921589374542,
-0.7647781372070312,
-0.284616619348526,
-0.8277788758277893,
-0.7859575748443604,
0.7226945161819458,
0.5031746625900269,
0.1310061514377594,
-0.07296458631753922,
0.3937770426273346,
0.1116866022348404,
0.5174556970596313,
-0.325219064950943,
-0.150163471698761,
-0.3109453618526459,
-0.35551121830940247,
0.1938963532447815,
-0.15186554193496704,
0.06104936823248863,
-0.05444231256842613,
0.5280318856239319,
-0.20581521093845367,
0.6311603784561157,
0.24738863110542297,
0.09199607372283936,
-0.37302151322364807,
0.3672241270542145,
0.3277367651462555,
0.11192408204078674,
-0.7210162281990051,
-0.2970793843269348,
-0.052701085805892944,
-0.2237340658903122,
0.06146707758307457,
0.03377251699566841,
0.00885221641510725,
-0.1505810171365738,
-0.2519882619380951,
0.8727838397026062,
0.19251856207847595,
-0.7392222881317139,
0.42286044359207153,
-0.09445429593324661,
-0.04167809337377548,
-0.28789007663726807,
0.10071258246898651,
0.0255951676517725,
0.4852186441421509,
0.4268327057361603,
-0.050649240612983704,
0.3925345242023468,
-0.6948568820953369,
0.030111508443951607,
0.3377085328102112,
-0.3670051693916321,
-0.5740892291069031,
0.15082700550556183,
0.7793729901313782,
-0.4734412729740143,
0.7079532742500305,
-0.3387793004512787,
-0.6679200530052185,
0.6523294448852539,
0.5339562296867371,
1.0404685735702515,
-0.5159470438957214,
0.38837930560112,
0.006886213552206755,
-0.2326565533876419,
0.2629823684692383,
0.6022151708602905,
-0.17115500569343567,
-0.8781331181526184,
-0.06038683280348778,
-0.4892977774143219,
-0.8268003463745117,
-0.021324902772903442,
-0.8151551485061646,
0.007530577480792999,
-0.5255777835845947,
-0.47688770294189453,
-0.23293806612491608,
0.059490855783224106,
-0.7116103768348694,
0.2425212264060974,
0.4958004355430603,
0.5660486817359924,
-1.0278279781341553,
0.3076131045818329,
0.7739724516868591,
0.1229461058974266,
-0.5729004740715027,
0.3033582270145416,
0.2808663249015808,
-0.24792741239070892,
0.6739690899848938,
0.3178313970565796,
-0.08287348598241806,
0.2498665153980255,
-0.4783651828765869,
-0.47294336557388306,
0.9276643395423889,
0.07515927404165268,
-0.29494598507881165,
-0.005412463564425707,
-0.05285194516181946,
0.6999877095222473,
-0.8845464587211609,
0.1327735036611557,
0.5821375846862793,
0.5273553133010864,
0.05362802743911743,
-0.7487103343009949,
-0.06665685772895813,
-0.5305538177490234,
0.02991204522550106,
0.14871110022068024,
-0.8771823048591614,
0.8405080437660217,
0.0192432664334774,
-0.05261862277984619,
0.2261519432067871,
0.40814754366874695,
0.39250898361206055,
0.2663702070713043,
0.7630497217178345,
0.381002277135849,
0.6967334747314453,
-0.0882381722331047,
0.715477466583252,
-0.36935216188430786,
0.3635377883911133,
1.0045572519302368,
-0.7900393605232239,
0.5587679147720337,
0.5230727195739746,
0.08217950165271759,
0.8136938214302063,
0.583873987197876,
0.06457728892564774,
0.4090222716331482,
0.1912904679775238,
-0.5552234649658203,
-0.18130911886692047,
-0.3620898127555847,
-0.08506664633750916,
0.5773284435272217,
0.4250316023826599,
-0.313255250453949,
-0.13761143386363983,
0.15739251673221588,
0.06023324280977249,
-0.5134336948394775,
-0.01244320161640644,
0.7111121416091919,
-0.23593705892562866,
-0.4903969168663025,
0.032359495759010315,
-0.2056763768196106,
0.6018156409263611,
-0.4798535704612732,
0.06463676691055298,
-0.2848219871520996,
-0.09871070832014084,
-0.23858582973480225,
-0.5451862812042236,
0.10604214668273926,
0.23645809292793274,
-0.1933206468820572,
-0.5497181415557861,
0.5596756339073181,
-0.40999507904052734,
-0.2281944900751114,
-0.051067713648080826,
0.5748423337936401,
0.31443578004837036,
-0.3989901542663574,
-0.6044888496398926,
-0.07489883899688721,
0.20117723941802979,
-0.7084197402000427,
0.3674435019493103,
0.4404667019844055,
0.20652538537979126,
0.31931811571121216,
0.3289041519165039,
-0.2207185924053192,
-0.11111430078744888,
0.24383585155010223,
0.7312146425247192,
-0.6998515129089355,
-0.45650026202201843,
-0.5164600610733032,
0.8017107248306274,
-0.2474042922258377,
-0.3458336889743805,
0.3586820065975189,
0.11213313788175583,
0.016872379928827286,
-0.12223891168832779,
0.8943172693252563,
-0.5800849795341492,
0.2674168348312378,
-0.18314753472805023,
0.6646724343299866,
-0.440184623003006,
-0.08179072290658951,
-0.7900471687316895,
-0.8850654363632202,
0.24021078646183014,
0.4750697612762451,
-0.24124889075756073,
0.16464339196681976,
0.5956370830535889,
0.5483717322349548,
0.38794654607772827,
0.23220142722129822,
0.12946626543998718,
0.30405500531196594,
0.38197147846221924,
0.8222281336784363,
0.6013213396072388,
-0.0952540934085846,
0.2929933965206146,
-0.2503722012042999,
-0.42066964507102966,
-0.45351442694664,
-0.8973479270935059,
-0.736672043800354,
-0.5530164241790771,
-0.39367783069610596,
-0.3800496757030487,
0.02547430247068405,
0.8361606597900391,
0.448209673166275,
-0.664995014667511,
-0.04953435808420181,
-0.24942411482334137,
-0.12232965975999832,
0.2233262062072754,
-0.39322400093078613,
-0.2352735996246338,
-0.20724627375602722,
-0.8501188158988953,
0.021610643714666367,
0.393746554851532,
0.16495415568351746,
-0.3440479636192322,
-0.14472590386867523,
0.11115261167287827,
0.2707069516181946,
0.6030922532081604,
0.18105478584766388,
-0.4699150323867798,
-0.6260698437690735,
0.0418744720518589,
-0.054417628794908524,
0.18605251610279083,
0.7743099331855774,
-0.5459831953048706,
0.346475213766098,
0.28599199652671814,
0.214394211769104,
0.5071430206298828,
0.29084092378616333,
0.8820515871047974,
-1.0013917684555054,
-0.2112281620502472,
0.1643088161945343,
0.23039492964744568,
0.3554382622241974,
-0.8855509757995605,
0.22487381100654602,
0.1566867083311081,
-0.5959665179252625,
-0.5780395269393921,
0.6550841927528381,
-0.977647066116333,
0.16675733029842377,
0.9618390798568726,
-0.2510060966014862,
-0.05081607773900032,
0.03483014553785324,
-0.4267154633998871,
0.1840246021747589,
-0.9088498950004578,
1.0327004194259644,
0.8277216553688049,
-0.9531881809234619,
-0.29134100675582886,
-0.11714056879281998,
0.2863045930862427,
0.6668332815170288,
-1.0576386451721191,
0.1496114730834961,
0.7806235551834106,
0.14195893704891205,
0.20911943912506104,
0.46455737948417664,
0.09765810519456863,
0.1466904729604721,
-0.24194875359535217,
0.4090564548969269,
0.3023691177368164,
-0.13083234429359436,
-0.27285540103912354,
0.2730127274990082,
-0.3997729420661926,
0.296708345413208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02570v1
|
MaiNLP at SemEval-2024 Task 1: Analyzing Source Language Selection in Cross-Lingual Textual Relatedness
| 2024-04-03T08:44:51 | 2024-04-03T08:44:51 |
Shijia Zhou, Huangyan Shan, Barbara Plank, Robert Litschko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents our system developed for the SemEval-2024 Task 1:
Semantic Textual Relatedness (STR), on Track C: Cross-lingual. The task aims to
detect semantic relatedness of two sentences in a given target language without
access to direct supervision (i.e. zero-shot cross-lingual transfer). To this
end, we focus on different source language selection strategies on two
different pre-trained languages models: XLM-R and Furina. We experiment with 1)
single-source transfer and select source languages based on typological
similarity, 2) augmenting English training data with the two nearest-neighbor
source languages, and 3) multi-source transfer where we compare selecting on
all training languages against languages from the same family. We further study
machine translation-based data augmentation and the impact of script
differences. Our submission achieved the first place in the C8 (Kinyarwanda)
test set.
|
[
-0.3992694020271301,
-0.389739990234375,
0.5013763904571533,
0.26619425415992737,
-0.29323863983154297,
-0.1281110942363739,
-0.3365567922592163,
-0.8293960690498352,
0.2354576736688614,
0.8111242055892944,
-0.732468843460083,
-0.3200973570346832,
-0.46644291281700134,
0.6014637351036072,
-0.28168627619743347,
0.8733527064323425,
-0.26556795835494995,
0.20524613559246063,
-0.38850030303001404,
-0.4616152048110962,
-0.4318239688873291,
-0.6371179223060608,
-0.5812524557113647,
-0.16946452856063843,
0.5917780995368958,
0.4206811487674713,
0.38958707451820374,
0.405329167842865,
0.6473062038421631,
0.2737486958503723,
0.17857688665390015,
-0.14960961043834686,
-0.2776328921318054,
0.24002695083618164,
-0.6558471918106079,
-0.5232828855514526,
-0.22752492129802704,
-0.2906014025211334,
0.5415827035903931,
0.5048109292984009,
0.5868809223175049,
0.24926257133483887,
0.03878101706504822,
0.6122395992279053,
-0.4475395977497101,
0.01046584453433752,
-0.6061513423919678,
0.11128712445497513,
-0.36162033677101135,
-0.342850923538208,
-0.2587032914161682,
0.0017476360080763698,
0.12442662566900253,
-0.47910916805267334,
0.3135196268558502,
0.1545894742012024,
0.9445138573646545,
0.3901301920413971,
-0.4698999226093292,
-0.3725474774837494,
-0.4017077088356018,
0.703338086605072,
-0.47454503178596497,
0.5608200430870056,
0.7052255272865295,
0.03549991920590401,
0.2693186402320862,
-0.5826199650764465,
-0.3569815158843994,
-0.3404351472854614,
-0.1918349266052246,
0.08471546322107315,
-0.04531943053007126,
-0.253412127494812,
0.06465484946966171,
0.014743246138095856,
-0.6845040321350098,
-0.023240812122821808,
-0.45097753405570984,
-0.32903367280960083,
0.6108880043029785,
-0.11166079342365265,
0.5113185048103333,
-0.01959911361336708,
-0.4846190810203552,
-0.15284334123134613,
-0.9024726152420044,
-0.17879505455493927,
0.5277798771858215,
0.32603731751441956,
-0.0356222465634346,
0.5893190503120422,
-0.22661666572093964,
0.5407909154891968,
-0.12199989706277847,
0.3110446333885193,
0.4194071888923645,
-0.9319601655006409,
0.056185416877269745,
0.2695959508419037,
0.668178141117096,
0.14603862166404724,
0.16315852105617523,
-0.12767848372459412,
-0.0037516290321946144,
-0.1672995537519455,
0.061479028314352036,
-0.4555399715900421,
0.06268568336963654,
-0.10275350511074066,
-0.3479098677635193,
-0.49472683668136597,
-0.21882270276546478,
-0.7524034976959229,
0.03923324868083,
-0.44252097606658936,
0.6660849452018738,
-0.42298978567123413,
-0.2242598980665207,
-0.25799083709716797,
0.005812556948512793,
0.2957817614078522,
0.1638650745153427,
-0.7933126091957092,
0.10449063032865524,
0.6592051386833191,
0.559576690196991,
-0.41872960329055786,
-0.7580632567405701,
-0.6222445368766785,
0.19608311355113983,
-0.22946235537528992,
1.0010532140731812,
-0.674787163734436,
-0.1193837895989418,
-0.1119309589266777,
0.44263961911201477,
-0.05905836448073387,
-0.5343579053878784,
0.8221550583839417,
-0.2688462734222412,
0.454786092042923,
-0.34443897008895874,
-0.32059943675994873,
-0.23002901673316956,
0.12757353484630585,
-0.7505457401275635,
1.0677462816238403,
0.14458130300045013,
-0.9318432807922363,
0.3130316734313965,
-0.31965968012809753,
-0.47682949900627136,
-0.09895545244216919,
-0.2031482756137848,
-0.31663331389427185,
-0.1604640781879425,
0.007917564362287521,
0.2927100956439972,
-0.12224195897579193,
0.12397099286317825,
-0.3558405339717865,
-0.34149208664894104,
-0.019101357087492943,
-0.2766663134098053,
0.6248959898948669,
0.3975795805454254,
-0.4139835238456726,
0.12884902954101562,
-0.7204738855361938,
-0.10600269585847855,
-0.00426896708086133,
-0.2341647446155548,
-0.6500986814498901,
-0.29525572061538696,
0.2169451117515564,
0.5079367756843567,
0.4408975839614868,
-0.45341113209724426,
-0.0157379861921072,
-0.46139249205589294,
0.1351524442434311,
0.5001420378684998,
-0.018876656889915466,
0.42121997475624084,
-0.18352922797203064,
0.5077576041221619,
0.17698979377746582,
-0.17668680846691132,
-0.3122507929801941,
-0.30199339985847473,
-0.8042739629745483,
0.21801725029945374,
0.6013795137405396,
0.5948494672775269,
-0.965707540512085,
0.16812030971050262,
-0.28124406933784485,
-0.22872693836688995,
-0.3425646126270294,
0.10803064703941345,
0.5000842809677124,
0.3396085500717163,
0.2792357802391052,
-0.07119716703891754,
-0.8389642834663391,
-1.075147271156311,
-0.2059677094221115,
-0.12004783749580383,
0.08188240975141525,
-0.10521357506513596,
0.41671234369277954,
-0.20056651532649994,
0.4339529871940613,
-0.17030349373817444,
-0.2024109661579132,
-0.1831088662147522,
0.030366575345396996,
-0.1227007731795311,
0.3874419033527374,
0.7646846175193787,
-0.7518116235733032,
-0.5728959441184998,
0.4295157492160797,
-0.7107165455818176,
-0.5270809531211853,
0.20430037379264832,
-0.32542070746421814,
0.642653226852417,
0.7195361256599426,
-0.1079002320766449,
0.42897024750709534,
0.6675853133201599,
-0.6545805931091309,
0.3526395857334137,
-0.14990268647670746,
0.4861167371273041,
-1.330551266670227,
0.16424252092838287,
-0.14296305179595947,
-0.313689649105072,
-0.5869606137275696,
-0.011609830893576145,
0.06401563435792923,
-0.17582698166370392,
-0.4856506288051605,
0.5959433913230896,
-0.27134233713150024,
-0.37487584352493286,
-0.36483827233314514,
0.004395949654281139,
-0.12436790019273758,
0.7056685090065002,
0.3118549585342407,
0.8882666826248169,
0.38726189732551575,
-0.4143684506416321,
0.15299305319786072,
0.2628309726715088,
-0.050166741013526917,
0.6089356541633606,
-0.5077060461044312,
0.16128212213516235,
-0.008787112310528755,
-0.12160498648881912,
-0.7629541158676147,
0.032885339111089706,
0.2343226820230484,
-0.5500665307044983,
0.2919975221157074,
-0.08967966586351395,
-0.2360987514257431,
-0.012430131435394287,
-0.2997581958770752,
0.40722721815109253,
0.16613511741161346,
-0.24467256665229797,
0.21787814795970917,
0.33995339274406433,
-0.6878706812858582,
-0.5431861281394958,
-0.7241806983947754,
0.22235248982906342,
-0.2403154820203781,
-0.7710657715797424,
0.1944168359041214,
0.04889785870909691,
-0.16737309098243713,
0.2945064306259155,
-0.11164241284132004,
-0.20680542290210724,
-0.14245201647281647,
-0.06624077260494232,
0.43755677342414856,
-0.3414336144924164,
0.054220497608184814,
0.14037492871284485,
-0.12211240082979202,
0.04240088164806366,
-0.2993418872356415,
0.2924133241176605,
0.014602558687329292,
-0.3248869776725769,
0.19324110448360443,
0.5100935101509094,
0.27518051862716675,
-0.2576906383037567,
0.38200363516807556,
0.7110410928726196,
-0.28717055916786194,
-0.0451914444565773,
-0.4903630018234253,
0.04618115350604057,
-0.3807336688041687,
0.4225010871887207,
-0.632678747177124,
-1.07807195186615,
0.42649325728416443,
0.2133532464504242,
-0.16185016930103302,
0.5503416657447815,
0.5244778990745544,
0.24561505019664764,
0.7668688297271729,
0.6133469939231873,
-0.03373417630791664,
0.4504072666168213,
0.0804484561085701,
0.02872854471206665,
-0.621735692024231,
-0.17573702335357666,
-0.8773611187934875,
0.044671542942523956,
-0.8335727453231812,
-0.49309104681015015,
0.1088491901755333,
-0.18997733294963837,
-0.05705639347434044,
0.8932768702507019,
-0.1453513354063034,
0.2260715216398239,
0.48728641867637634,
-0.19556932151317596,
0.42030614614486694,
0.2178582400083542,
-0.35143598914146423,
-0.1463732123374939,
-0.4834156930446625,
-0.3396029770374298,
0.9076395034790039,
0.286675363779068,
0.433030366897583,
-0.005465663969516754,
0.5845187902450562,
0.3443857431411743,
-0.19933155179023743,
-0.4448622763156891,
0.5844720005989075,
-0.2373388260602951,
-0.4085031747817993,
-0.415262907743454,
-0.3818909823894501,
-0.9775248765945435,
0.38591885566711426,
-0.16497255861759186,
-0.5136243104934692,
0.22097063064575195,
-0.3424411118030548,
0.21659578382968903,
0.00404578959569335,
-0.5672547817230225,
0.8566130995750427,
-0.3199094533920288,
-0.6317654848098755,
-0.13308821618556976,
-0.8363439440727234,
0.09512683749198914,
-0.3969888985157013,
0.16259145736694336,
-0.17953437566757202,
-0.16419292986392975,
0.6181750893592834,
-0.3420019745826721,
0.2787753939628601,
0.11510378867387772,
-0.3241157829761505,
0.15677565336227417,
-0.029635917395353317,
0.36455586552619934,
-0.1468731164932251,
-0.13094483315944672,
0.3315860331058502,
0.30158182978630066,
-0.38296812772750854,
-0.43523427844047546,
0.7690859436988831,
-0.6441161036491394,
-0.35795968770980835,
-0.5253192782402039,
-0.23470188677310944,
-0.3564828038215637,
0.4366131126880646,
0.4327307343482971,
0.41142573952674866,
-0.31079840660095215,
0.20577433705329895,
0.47163596749305725,
-0.2758268415927887,
0.3528740704059601,
0.6125526428222656,
-0.37334516644477844,
-0.4303087294101715,
0.9272080659866333,
0.026779690757393837,
0.21800291538238525,
0.5725225210189819,
-0.02372775226831436,
-0.4343399703502655,
-0.4313144385814667,
-0.524513304233551,
0.24563385546207428,
-0.6358110308647156,
-0.04699348658323288,
-0.6395847797393799,
-0.4025430679321289,
-0.6195651888847351,
-0.0558905154466629,
-0.2165500819683075,
-0.5280441641807556,
-0.05571385845541954,
-0.02529115043580532,
0.08336177468299866,
0.6366584897041321,
-0.023489616811275482,
-0.46287909150123596,
-0.903489887714386,
0.1095600575208664,
0.20439063012599945,
0.06362110376358032,
-0.5084183812141418,
-0.651678740978241,
-0.2957530915737152,
-0.03305530920624733,
-0.008888979442417622,
-0.6311280727386475,
0.36119985580444336,
0.15121914446353912,
0.6166766285896301,
-0.0040583740919828415,
-0.04569694399833679,
0.40940332412719727,
-0.5938258171081543,
0.5804455280303955,
0.160554900765419,
-0.7186949849128723,
0.8302590250968933,
-0.5135136842727661,
0.27781158685684204,
0.8800928592681885,
0.32932835817337036,
-0.4747125208377838,
-0.5263165235519409,
-0.5450170636177063,
-0.6800326108932495,
0.8354099988937378,
0.4767853021621704,
-0.05702507495880127,
0.22009500861167908,
-0.15444563329219818,
0.22054536640644073,
0.046324655413627625,
-0.5525362491607666,
-0.057446759194135666,
-0.09938531368970871,
-0.21306122839450836,
0.005642247386276722,
-0.09972409904003143,
0.23830989003181458,
-0.07374873757362366,
0.811684787273407,
-0.15213316679000854,
0.16276974976062775,
0.42102450132369995,
-0.10679024457931519,
-0.30123814940452576,
0.5308403372764587,
0.6758196949958801,
0.6773356199264526,
-0.06422342360019684,
0.2002047896385193,
0.5224560499191284,
-0.6418163776397705,
0.15133728086948395,
0.2672339975833893,
-0.26815369725227356,
0.2859095633029938,
0.5192018747329712,
0.9778388738632202,
0.5176407098770142,
-0.6626275181770325,
0.5526739358901978,
0.0019884766079485416,
-0.34081217646598816,
-0.37303027510643005,
-0.13730446994304657,
-0.010608237236738205,
0.1265750527381897,
0.2437232881784439,
0.1181311383843422,
0.23597367107868195,
-0.6816467046737671,
0.484806627035141,
0.12370768189430237,
-0.6569192409515381,
-0.5517153143882751,
0.47315913438796997,
0.2658272087574005,
-0.1532207876443863,
0.07773414254188538,
-0.2486695796251297,
-0.6085473299026489,
0.6419195532798767,
0.6004709601402283,
0.8282504677772522,
-0.2601400911808014,
0.11390673369169235,
0.5810886025428772,
0.26907238364219666,
0.07341459393501282,
0.2559437155723572,
0.009448092430830002,
-0.6227624416351318,
-0.663062334060669,
-0.6501315832138062,
-0.34273940324783325,
0.1988251656293869,
-0.6157425045967102,
0.8198123574256897,
0.2913709282875061,
0.28351297974586487,
-0.11333523690700531,
0.21263127028942108,
-0.5607906579971313,
-0.04984095320105553,
0.3065257668495178,
0.8669180274009705,
-0.8135437369346619,
1.0809320211410522,
0.9754786491394043,
-0.4040064811706543,
-0.8595778346061707,
-0.004634672310203314,
-0.10533978790044785,
-0.6246023774147034,
0.7710431814193726,
-0.03643418475985527,
-0.08732658624649048,
-0.12342607229948044,
-0.2816951870918274,
-0.8346320390701294,
1.129151463508606,
0.3495819568634033,
-0.4954602122306824,
-0.05617416277527809,
0.2594177722930908,
0.5710347890853882,
-0.26454469561576843,
0.07160437107086182,
0.5093533396720886,
0.3900275230407715,
0.3521440923213959,
-1.1902899742126465,
0.01561632938683033,
-0.39473024010658264,
-0.0979100912809372,
0.39448171854019165,
-0.6217589974403381,
0.5971290469169617,
0.13298453390598297,
-0.1774580031633377,
0.03150346875190735,
0.5702824592590332,
0.23920868337154388,
0.6397888660430908,
0.3954299986362457,
0.7049268484115601,
0.3207712769508362,
0.18040181696414948,
0.6131078600883484,
-0.3917403221130371,
0.3235725164413452,
1.2071441411972046,
-0.6265787482261658,
0.9728718400001526,
0.5058817267417908,
-0.3142086863517761,
0.33391183614730835,
0.4697706699371338,
0.1126215010881424,
0.6921178698539734,
-0.10252408683300018,
-0.30271658301353455,
0.004926656372845173,
-0.2630901038646698,
-0.5994025468826294,
0.6013340950012207,
0.1596793234348297,
-0.2774730622768402,
-0.38347020745277405,
0.18652796745300293,
0.08482152968645096,
0.029279343783855438,
-0.32891616225242615,
0.7792505621910095,
0.09792468696832657,
-0.9776259064674377,
0.23019526898860931,
-0.16747716069221497,
0.6646190881729126,
-0.68452388048172,
-0.18545685708522797,
-0.20052972435951233,
-0.09057529270648956,
-0.10954121500253677,
-0.7958890199661255,
0.6986591815948486,
0.11714017391204834,
0.08816927671432495,
-0.14014767110347748,
1.3640273809432983,
-0.8580142855644226,
-0.6233586668968201,
0.4242745339870453,
0.6458828449249268,
0.20837505161762238,
0.0606938935816288,
-0.5407773852348328,
0.08893987536430359,
0.19741150736808777,
0.07867193967103958,
0.5572544932365417,
0.6511326432228088,
-0.2991746664047241,
0.3056069314479828,
0.6127064824104309,
0.25653955340385437,
-0.0021351559553295374,
0.0758858472108841,
0.7444634437561035,
-0.6795955300331116,
-0.5002041459083557,
-0.5535324215888977,
-0.06531348079442978,
-0.019457850605249405,
-0.251383900642395,
0.9320288896560669,
0.6411406993865967,
1.2038075923919678,
-0.16601815819740295,
0.9208382964134216,
-0.1668495535850525,
0.6015824675559998,
-0.6753189563751221,
0.47240591049194336,
-0.4294777512550354,
0.1558663696050644,
-0.2689630389213562,
-1.13717782497406,
0.0795203372836113,
0.4292646050453186,
-0.2751803994178772,
-0.2931046187877655,
1.1257649660110474,
0.8407161831855774,
-0.142839252948761,
0.08276284486055374,
0.6241695880889893,
-0.15133821964263916,
-0.3259943723678589,
0.7501007318496704,
1.006416916847229,
-0.5360541343688965,
0.7781848311424255,
-0.25564369559288025,
0.16645999252796173,
-0.1801229566335678,
-0.7878367900848389,
-0.8279082179069519,
-0.9250449538230896,
-0.27280399203300476,
-0.2525334060192108,
0.12873369455337524,
0.9023194313049316,
0.3863331079483032,
-0.973680853843689,
-0.10626084357500076,
-0.06706791371107101,
0.03901265561580658,
0.18800422549247742,
-0.2191023826599121,
0.2399112731218338,
-0.4752860963344574,
-0.7133196592330933,
0.45041224360466003,
0.4638266861438751,
-0.1107526496052742,
-0.2153620719909668,
-0.1533692181110382,
-0.4305923581123352,
-0.08385074883699417,
0.6093981266021729,
0.1735304445028305,
-0.40714672207832336,
-0.5395642518997192,
0.160464346408844,
-0.2656153738498688,
-0.018398215994238853,
0.8626989126205444,
-0.45515111088752747,
0.23909634351730347,
0.9752341508865356,
0.7675357460975647,
0.4567515552043915,
-0.08692393451929092,
0.5566694140434265,
-0.6061850190162659,
0.35357484221458435,
0.09236371517181396,
0.3760007619857788,
0.26348650455474854,
-0.3528434932231903,
1.0731748342514038,
0.1964670717716217,
-0.7322354912757874,
-0.6100291609764099,
0.1394510269165039,
-0.8733646273612976,
-0.2598404884338379,
1.391471266746521,
-0.2302245944738388,
-0.3650965094566345,
-0.39742061495780945,
-0.3403485119342804,
0.24151001870632172,
0.1094687432050705,
0.1246931329369545,
0.9563173055648804,
0.035548675805330276,
-0.11817983537912369,
-0.7414059042930603,
0.4141061007976532,
0.505986213684082,
-0.8886995315551758,
-0.34623777866363525,
0.4435884654521942,
0.4252421259880066,
0.2243518978357315,
0.7109372019767761,
-0.240891695022583,
0.28020066022872925,
-0.04545590281486511,
-0.09448525309562683,
0.02563452161848545,
-0.18604937195777893,
-0.5706468224525452,
-0.051778487861156464,
0.00365496426820755,
-0.15477034449577332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02540v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02540v2
|
CSEPrompts: A Benchmark of Introductory Computer Science Prompts
| 2024-04-03T07:55:57 | 2024-04-04T04:17:27 |
Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Christian Newman, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in AI, machine learning, and NLP have led to the development
of a new generation of Large Language Models (LLMs) that are trained on massive
amounts of data and often have trillions of parameters. Commercial applications
(e.g., ChatGPT) have made this technology available to the general public, thus
making it possible to use LLMs to produce high-quality texts for academic and
professional purposes. Schools and universities are aware of the increasing use
of AI-generated content by students and they have been researching the impact
of this new technology and its potential misuse. Educational programs in
Computer Science (CS) and related fields are particularly affected because LLMs
are also capable of generating programming code in various programming
languages. To help understand the potential impact of publicly available LLMs
in CS education, we introduce CSEPrompts, a framework with hundreds of
programming exercise prompts and multiple-choice questions retrieved from
introductory CS and programming courses. We also provide experimental results
on CSEPrompts to evaluate the performance of several LLMs with respect to
generating Python code and answering basic computer science and programming
questions.
|
[
-0.40082094073295593,
-0.6462888717651367,
0.5963008403778076,
0.2290593981742859,
0.03847143054008484,
0.335663378238678,
-0.4126945734024048,
-0.24489255249500275,
-0.2251783162355423,
0.315665602684021,
-0.4724918007850647,
-0.5054674744606018,
-0.3930489420890808,
0.18918845057487488,
-0.6927063465118408,
0.8579709529876709,
-0.03407197445631027,
0.21056099236011505,
-0.5372315049171448,
0.21543321013450623,
-0.395074725151062,
-0.6127513647079468,
-0.6377260684967041,
-0.19553875923156738,
0.4514353275299072,
0.7735214233398438,
0.3655972182750702,
0.3809871971607208,
0.40369364619255066,
0.23150059580802917,
0.0415775291621685,
-0.16159075498580933,
-0.34030142426490784,
0.3917286694049835,
-0.058000773191452026,
-0.362842321395874,
0.21870183944702148,
0.057406309992074966,
0.7998332977294922,
1.0180729627609253,
0.09791368991136551,
0.615038275718689,
0.5192736387252808,
0.579862117767334,
-0.7589441537857056,
-0.07415888458490372,
-0.41046321392059326,
-0.170529305934906,
0.02144823595881462,
-0.30988550186157227,
-0.5457346439361572,
-0.6763489246368408,
0.17957298457622528,
-0.44379478693008423,
0.13194862008094788,
-0.07857333868741989,
0.6258832216262817,
0.11476457864046097,
-0.19644039869308472,
-0.5151720643043518,
-0.384359747171402,
0.9707947373390198,
-0.18783104419708252,
0.3785111606121063,
0.24923385679721832,
0.37160688638687134,
-0.30879393219947815,
-0.9026693105697632,
-0.3734763264656067,
-0.44934049248695374,
0.44193002581596375,
-0.011431563645601273,
-0.1879652440547943,
-0.16721606254577637,
0.5653142929077148,
0.2028125822544098,
-0.7466704845428467,
0.2202579528093338,
-0.48828524351119995,
-0.1761193424463272,
0.323537677526474,
0.4667738676071167,
0.36274755001068115,
0.008502914570271969,
-0.19264963269233704,
-0.3906790316104889,
-0.9090303778648376,
0.42145001888275146,
0.38852202892303467,
0.4168297350406647,
-0.01806534454226494,
0.6399134993553162,
-0.1229795441031456,
0.6859638094902039,
-0.051595818251371384,
0.2630041241645813,
-0.14169441163539886,
-0.0909191146492958,
0.005673762410879135,
-0.03721977025270462,
0.5343140959739685,
0.26115602254867554,
0.5635038018226624,
0.06136973574757576,
0.4513130187988281,
0.23494012653827667,
-0.0403088741004467,
-0.819368839263916,
-0.3462829291820526,
0.18384602665901184,
-0.48610344529151917,
-0.3011839985847473,
-0.15469089150428772,
-0.6296918392181396,
-0.6938425898551941,
-0.7112057209014893,
-0.3066873550415039,
-0.5463202595710754,
0.2053545117378235,
-0.20688684284687042,
-0.21935833990573883,
0.5507122874259949,
0.35354506969451904,
-0.641927182674408,
0.42709752917289734,
0.6918149590492249,
0.748783528804779,
-0.43138840794563293,
-0.3856726586818695,
-0.26481130719184875,
-0.32548293471336365,
-0.3025258183479309,
1.0418353080749512,
-0.7370526790618896,
-0.5260050892829895,
0.15020346641540527,
-0.1169416755437851,
0.3156614601612091,
-0.32116422057151794,
0.36016547679901123,
-0.42305904626846313,
0.23618610203266144,
-0.535152792930603,
-0.6780492067337036,
-0.027678396552801132,
0.37771376967430115,
-0.19607064127922058,
1.1938788890838623,
-0.03430232033133507,
-0.45622068643569946,
0.16987331211566925,
-0.30815088748931885,
-0.3646391034126282,
0.20764099061489105,
-0.3442903459072113,
0.13281936943531036,
-0.037197601050138474,
-0.041038431227207184,
0.4236052930355072,
-0.5916813611984253,
-0.07498139142990112,
-0.22717635333538055,
-0.389853835105896,
0.5554505586624146,
-0.373360276222229,
0.8970313668251038,
0.36135539412498474,
-0.07050933688879013,
-0.20923833549022675,
-0.7906604409217834,
0.5868353843688965,
0.00200435658916831,
-0.5452843308448792,
-0.16607320308685303,
0.39945894479751587,
-0.023862380534410477,
0.20129668712615967,
0.3743033707141876,
-0.37321287393569946,
0.11509252339601517,
0.055508922785520554,
0.4188433289527893,
0.9621867537498474,
-0.034998174756765366,
0.06617752462625504,
-0.20613744854927063,
0.6874099373817444,
-0.3774973154067993,
-0.20331256091594696,
-0.5172891616821289,
-0.40834784507751465,
-0.488461971282959,
-0.14840179681777954,
0.03519345074892044,
0.6545119881629944,
-0.3802599012851715,
0.22249922156333923,
0.03131233900785446,
-0.8006249070167542,
0.039310235530138016,
0.14313894510269165,
0.1802072376012802,
0.542830228805542,
0.30259138345718384,
-0.09559598565101624,
-0.5593757033348083,
-0.608862578868866,
-0.5286868810653687,
-0.12372742593288422,
-0.28529539704322815,
0.2733474671840668,
0.2625647783279419,
0.22769373655319214,
0.8736941814422607,
-0.6316743493080139,
0.3796308636665344,
-0.11764118820428848,
0.20118239521980286,
0.15685123205184937,
0.345550537109375,
0.3860112130641937,
-0.11447940021753311,
-0.5892733335494995,
-0.4697292745113373,
-0.6136703491210938,
-0.36947882175445557,
-0.012119841761887074,
0.058906007558107376,
-0.17960494756698608,
0.6738197803497314,
-0.18367204070091248,
0.05384709686040878,
0.6332559585571289,
-0.28535622358322144,
1.0449416637420654,
-0.0681443065404892,
0.30554869771003723,
-0.805075466632843,
0.3130592703819275,
0.0790487602353096,
-0.11522943526506424,
-0.38249143958091736,
0.03508422151207924,
0.0710487812757492,
-0.6869549751281738,
-0.6353410482406616,
0.3511655926704407,
-0.5865283012390137,
-0.15610496699810028,
-0.40283823013305664,
0.37513935565948486,
-0.20798605680465698,
0.15370036661624908,
-0.0748555064201355,
0.9822484254837036,
0.7299938201904297,
-0.7694929838180542,
0.29141294956207275,
0.1499769538640976,
-0.46460989117622375,
0.8003271222114563,
-0.7531497478485107,
0.2038061022758484,
0.021272113546729088,
0.25847893953323364,
-1.0547882318496704,
-0.21866996586322784,
-0.25972437858581543,
-0.5996389389038086,
-0.038692597299814224,
0.10198166221380234,
-0.4031845033168793,
-0.5849735140800476,
-0.4407779276371002,
0.317617267370224,
0.7796299457550049,
-0.7451348900794983,
0.14143437147140503,
0.15410637855529785,
-0.28908681869506836,
-0.6421167254447937,
-0.6292529106140137,
0.3034740090370178,
-0.0017336462624371052,
-0.42686960101127625,
-0.14387646317481995,
-0.30840301513671875,
-0.28143760561943054,
-0.1802806705236435,
0.21723076701164246,
-0.10201211273670197,
0.3361915647983551,
0.4110945165157318,
0.2270755171775818,
-0.2518100142478943,
0.058957453817129135,
-0.04644804447889328,
-0.05119965597987175,
0.29284507036209106,
-0.2554139196872711,
0.8921421766281128,
-0.35993507504463196,
-0.6366360187530518,
-0.3320867717266083,
0.41235819458961487,
0.23248933255672455,
0.09601160138845444,
0.23387457430362701,
-0.01822938397526741,
-0.3161396086215973,
-0.4315725564956665,
-0.37807250022888184,
-0.20032356679439545,
-0.5056942105293274,
0.361734002828598,
-0.012848070822656155,
-0.8082663416862488,
0.42974087595939636,
-0.31709131598472595,
0.09726262092590332,
0.03971973806619644,
0.5866974592208862,
-0.16453084349632263,
1.295670747756958,
0.3571484684944153,
-0.11498678475618362,
0.765623927116394,
0.07114724814891815,
0.07210904359817505,
-0.5962866544723511,
0.09440522640943527,
-0.9609724879264832,
-0.23795661330223083,
-0.5882165431976318,
-0.2815665006637573,
0.10275475680828094,
0.08409620821475983,
-0.7222408652305603,
0.5201564431190491,
-0.8012088537216187,
0.9417783617973328,
0.7712530493736267,
0.042545318603515625,
0.10290687531232834,
0.07608017325401306,
-0.13252130150794983,
-0.09692759811878204,
-0.5014268159866333,
-0.7760893702507019,
1.2372722625732422,
0.026982977986335754,
0.640837550163269,
-0.17300082743167877,
0.5560587644577026,
0.3775285482406616,
0.26137807965278625,
-0.5872371792793274,
0.9006448984146118,
-0.19937986135482788,
-0.3746948838233948,
0.02237975038588047,
-0.21456345915794373,
-1.005491852760315,
-0.13785183429718018,
-0.10754813998937607,
-0.8818488717079163,
-0.019864646717905998,
0.2006843537092209,
-0.13057032227516174,
0.042610008269548416,
-0.5447332262992859,
0.5258154273033142,
-0.38330385088920593,
-0.6419739723205566,
-0.4350161850452423,
-0.5032269954681396,
0.2150615155696869,
0.1276923269033432,
0.019074929878115654,
-0.1855611354112625,
0.10604100674390793,
0.6306296586990356,
-0.18489059805870056,
0.8028903007507324,
-0.08986182510852814,
0.20223210752010345,
0.6826215982437134,
0.3493075668811798,
0.24917227029800415,
-0.06483819335699081,
-0.26269322633743286,
0.14588725566864014,
0.12953868508338928,
-0.3614867329597473,
-0.28180596232414246,
0.9129803776741028,
-0.7920970916748047,
-0.4524526000022888,
-0.5592105984687805,
-0.5203333497047424,
-0.1555136740207672,
0.21101924777030945,
0.16216212511062622,
0.38059601187705994,
-0.4036201536655426,
0.18800589442253113,
0.6357686519622803,
-0.6169497966766357,
0.5192108154296875,
0.5243567824363708,
0.08575940877199173,
-0.35751309990882874,
0.9870674014091492,
0.01923951879143715,
0.26547837257385254,
-0.0017008271533995867,
0.22869352996349335,
-0.07807604968547821,
-0.4158458411693573,
-0.1988387256860733,
-0.09218456596136093,
-1.1528671979904175,
-0.12929531931877136,
-0.12982608377933502,
-0.13399621844291687,
-0.47877272963523865,
-0.6368468999862671,
0.029084976762533188,
-0.4220057725906372,
-0.3903752565383911,
0.1530347764492035,
0.18833695352077484,
0.5987282395362854,
-0.17250362038612366,
0.29265642166137695,
-0.570755660533905,
-0.02925502508878708,
0.27528637647628784,
0.3288881182670593,
-0.11519894003868103,
-0.3504714071750641,
0.006643816363066435,
-0.013896121643483639,
-0.6872658729553223,
-0.7739795446395874,
0.03141513466835022,
-0.002184113720431924,
0.6694911122322083,
0.3710114061832428,
-0.029217727482318878,
0.4310404360294342,
-0.43327590823173523,
1.3441640138626099,
0.3953001797199249,
-1.0329283475875854,
0.4885072112083435,
-0.3869858980178833,
0.3835941553115845,
0.7010432481765747,
0.44129565358161926,
-0.8210272789001465,
-0.3024551570415497,
-0.4925854206085205,
-0.5849390625953674,
0.5657140612602234,
-0.22989030182361603,
0.25428250432014465,
-0.3579102158546448,
0.20678603649139404,
0.15482035279273987,
0.2609570622444153,
-0.5111696124076843,
-0.09589045494794846,
-0.22708508372306824,
-0.4243108034133911,
0.07558964937925339,
-0.1670106202363968,
0.20887474715709686,
-0.15527501702308655,
0.5849419236183167,
-0.1750975251197815,
0.14759927988052368,
-0.01697767898440361,
-0.16578958928585052,
0.1793525367975235,
0.2242787778377533,
0.6872493028640747,
0.575817883014679,
0.16396749019622803,
0.27133679389953613,
0.37309297919273376,
-0.5102660059928894,
0.008515330031514168,
-0.22303660213947296,
0.045250799506902695,
-0.4092696011066437,
0.19613146781921387,
0.12689818441867828,
0.09899932891130447,
-1.0265872478485107,
0.46872764825820923,
0.053742848336696625,
-0.1573590636253357,
-0.5385012626647949,
0.119869664311409,
-0.08759486675262451,
0.0008879235247150064,
0.3378869891166687,
-0.17312803864479065,
0.091966912150383,
-0.5100213885307312,
0.2210131287574768,
0.34575536847114563,
-0.3051901161670685,
-0.11540085077285767,
0.5926117300987244,
0.12610159814357758,
-0.37846192717552185,
0.7774615287780762,
0.25391554832458496,
-0.4655945897102356,
0.7912896871566772,
0.5243979692459106,
0.7806857228279114,
-0.219441220164299,
0.15078003704547882,
0.685221791267395,
0.09224767237901688,
-0.19978682696819305,
0.3931393623352051,
-0.3012479543685913,
-0.37896567583084106,
-0.41202297806739807,
-0.19369763135910034,
-0.8599554896354675,
-0.14108674228191376,
-0.5082796812057495,
0.8388911485671997,
-0.9177073836326599,
-0.06854262948036194,
-0.17517216503620148,
-0.09640494734048843,
-0.8514939546585083,
0.09499028325080872,
0.44837984442710876,
1.012845516204834,
-0.8383311629295349,
0.3672201335430145,
0.7389827966690063,
-0.42982885241508484,
-0.7194037437438965,
-0.21264128386974335,
-0.014683563262224197,
-0.9933766722679138,
0.7402449250221252,
0.12408268451690674,
-0.010087473317980766,
0.06959137320518494,
-1.1649441719055176,
-0.8706557154655457,
0.7545822262763977,
0.3191767632961273,
-0.42465829849243164,
0.08793432265520096,
0.609999418258667,
0.5571181178092957,
-0.1091807410120964,
0.6420892477035522,
0.4525136649608612,
0.4091342091560364,
-0.20352518558502197,
-0.34376201033592224,
0.08919667452573776,
-0.21855467557907104,
-0.25998032093048096,
-0.16218067705631256,
-0.4691007733345032,
0.9921672940254211,
-0.1446533203125,
-0.2131146341562271,
0.1583811342716217,
0.4465823173522949,
0.7144938111305237,
0.23698563873767853,
0.263435035943985,
0.08137602359056473,
0.8509213924407959,
-0.23599053919315338,
1.0318760871887207,
-0.770034670829773,
0.045630402863025665,
0.9834465384483337,
-0.30279555916786194,
0.8109081387519836,
0.4802045226097107,
-0.3353472948074341,
0.7799294590950012,
0.8144910335540771,
-0.3493489921092987,
0.15627522766590118,
0.8255724906921387,
-0.13679973781108856,
-0.42671075463294983,
-0.14346589148044586,
-0.586832582950592,
0.24413910508155823,
0.4941815733909607,
-0.31266000866889954,
-0.3054245710372925,
0.08533095568418503,
0.005541231017559767,
0.4057505130767822,
-0.24572917819023132,
0.4649963676929474,
0.14498886466026306,
-0.8138024210929871,
0.4748847782611847,
-0.20439012348651886,
0.4109481871128082,
-0.5682333707809448,
-0.03306497260928154,
-0.06870638579130173,
0.19092972576618195,
-0.16333474218845367,
-1.0198575258255005,
-0.06658067554235458,
0.3564559817314148,
-0.09071803838014603,
-0.22033345699310303,
0.63448166847229,
-0.1306241750717163,
-0.56510329246521,
0.012192990630865097,
0.3013138175010681,
0.5117495656013489,
0.06006834656000137,
-0.535021960735321,
-0.0529806986451149,
-0.4051789939403534,
-0.28592073917388916,
0.2824937105178833,
0.20289157330989838,
-0.13751426339149475,
0.7138996124267578,
0.8219981789588928,
0.11266878247261047,
0.10418284684419632,
0.033606890588998795,
0.834195077419281,
-0.640498697757721,
-0.5662037134170532,
-0.5894876718521118,
0.346078485250473,
-0.22621160745620728,
-0.5271281003952026,
1.014038324356079,
0.6591261625289917,
0.5550299882888794,
0.17434023320674896,
1.1002073287963867,
-0.10365327447652817,
0.6532379388809204,
-0.15922699868679047,
0.4024205505847931,
-0.1983930468559265,
0.2872452437877655,
-0.4711700677871704,
-0.9767264127731323,
-0.24150897562503815,
0.31688180565834045,
-0.4574282765388489,
-0.08240997046232224,
0.7329654693603516,
0.4770846664905548,
0.32140690088272095,
0.23138512670993805,
0.10531449317932129,
-0.2742595970630646,
0.3296148180961609,
0.6013144254684448,
1.2366782426834106,
-0.1447383463382721,
0.6757357120513916,
-0.12059281021356583,
-0.30635061860084534,
-0.1514717936515808,
-1.0535091161727905,
-1.0402789115905762,
-0.38239336013793945,
-0.3580990135669708,
-0.45795944333076477,
-0.0015755074564367533,
1.0015568733215332,
0.3044947683811188,
-0.9153274297714233,
-0.43358418345451355,
-0.3181372880935669,
0.05672060325741768,
-0.2655283212661743,
-0.229387566447258,
0.34278053045272827,
-0.4956459105014801,
-0.5079773664474487,
0.5140390992164612,
-0.32680246233940125,
0.13226282596588135,
-0.2601202726364136,
0.07128334045410156,
0.07125717401504517,
0.21731264889240265,
0.6486061811447144,
0.6433017253875732,
-0.2707529366016388,
-0.6059719324111938,
0.4674488306045532,
-0.1443738341331482,
-0.06653012335300446,
1.1616958379745483,
-0.8804180026054382,
0.048201754689216614,
0.9328033328056335,
0.5068947076797485,
0.11148891597986221,
0.10984229296445847,
0.4780530035495758,
-0.6849190592765808,
0.0543372668325901,
0.15349486470222473,
0.3618599772453308,
0.31680285930633545,
-0.10426703840494156,
0.24867187440395355,
0.04595004767179489,
-0.8234782218933105,
-1.0804816484451294,
0.043101612478494644,
-0.8095549941062927,
-0.6043084859848022,
1.0842727422714233,
0.01343454048037529,
-0.032155346125364304,
-0.08447756618261337,
-0.2287561595439911,
0.2178504765033722,
-0.27355119585990906,
0.7178218960762024,
0.8042727112770081,
-0.2361135333776474,
-0.04883313551545143,
-0.520929753780365,
0.303605854511261,
0.4599344730377197,
-0.8503813743591309,
0.3595236539840698,
0.5494403839111328,
0.44391143321990967,
0.09049280732870102,
0.3436015248298645,
0.0010781926102936268,
0.3865808844566345,
0.22846798598766327,
0.5114861726760864,
-0.15287572145462036,
-0.14501826465129852,
-0.27107590436935425,
0.3305387794971466,
0.18210797011852264,
-0.08280231058597565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02534v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02534v1
|
ANGOFA: Leveraging OFA Embedding Initialization and Synthetic Data for Angolan Language Model
| 2024-04-03T07:44:38 | 2024-04-03T07:44:38 |
Osvaldo Luamba Quinjica, David Ifeoluwa Adelani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, the development of pre-trained language models (PLMs) has
gained momentum, showcasing their capacity to transcend linguistic barriers and
facilitate knowledge transfer across diverse languages. However, this progress
has predominantly bypassed the inclusion of very-low resource languages,
creating a notable void in the multilingual landscape. This paper addresses
this gap by introducing four tailored PLMs specifically finetuned for Angolan
languages, employing a Multilingual Adaptive Fine-tuning (MAFT) approach. In
this paper, we survey the role of informed embedding initialization and
synthetic data in enhancing the performance of MAFT models in downstream tasks.
We improve baseline over SOTA AfroXLMR-base (developed through MAFT) and OFA
(an effective embedding initialization) by 12.3 and 3.8 points respectively.
|
[
-0.7303922176361084,
-0.9051527380943298,
0.4741692543029785,
0.24466267228126526,
-0.4150799512863159,
0.31179872155189514,
-0.15723444521427155,
-0.5286850929260254,
0.2987857162952423,
0.6466699242591858,
-0.31996557116508484,
-0.19142155349254608,
-0.6947379112243652,
0.062392327934503555,
-0.11453017592430115,
0.8545673489570618,
-0.2971339523792267,
0.008938306011259556,
0.16316375136375427,
-0.42399829626083374,
-0.5940062999725342,
-0.45352452993392944,
-0.6484687328338623,
-0.20325124263763428,
0.45424506068229675,
0.37938252091407776,
0.7568856477737427,
0.9481778144836426,
0.05094371736049652,
0.30085644125938416,
0.06547246128320694,
0.5280995965003967,
-0.5993916988372803,
-0.12957201898097992,
0.0005366626428440213,
-0.33636680245399475,
-0.31679731607437134,
-0.09169657528400421,
0.5948181748390198,
0.8312298655509949,
-0.36842989921569824,
0.03264985978603363,
0.15524865686893463,
0.5116960406303406,
-0.6133719086647034,
0.26599055528640747,
-0.7984962463378906,
-0.13083820044994354,
-0.10651425272226334,
0.0263445395976305,
-0.12090374529361725,
-0.36795398592948914,
0.43073636293411255,
-0.5949621796607971,
-0.1463714838027954,
-0.29572734236717224,
0.8819262981414795,
0.16902470588684082,
-0.4587206244468689,
-0.574535608291626,
-0.7958727478981018,
0.861262321472168,
-0.7030658721923828,
0.42271924018859863,
0.26805049180984497,
0.3013586699962616,
-0.12797003984451294,
-0.5421373248100281,
-0.4809994399547577,
-0.08006175607442856,
0.022248130291700363,
-0.19269202649593353,
-0.046006668359041214,
0.22123487293720245,
-0.17323394119739532,
0.32268643379211426,
0.07157556712627411,
0.07942875474691391,
-0.387629896402359,
-0.2718855142593384,
0.5696676969528198,
-0.3062199652194977,
0.07730714976787567,
0.27750253677368164,
-0.6881081461906433,
-0.03046719916164875,
-0.8844240307807922,
-0.001412137527950108,
0.6576783061027527,
0.6987159848213196,
-0.14118818938732147,
0.3224879503250122,
0.0748804584145546,
0.9487320780754089,
-0.04270674288272858,
-0.3228488862514496,
0.33540090918540955,
-0.29722657799720764,
-0.19420218467712402,
0.16083784401416779,
0.3969394564628601,
-0.1555829793214798,
0.3573978841304779,
-0.02654757723212242,
-0.6203396320343018,
-0.22223086655139923,
0.18944652378559113,
-0.6066930294036865,
0.12337114661931992,
0.15630961954593658,
-0.35463979840278625,
0.13518831133842468,
-0.02600121684372425,
-0.629603385925293,
-0.07833002507686615,
-0.687099814414978,
0.7453818917274475,
-0.6817198991775513,
-0.1707141101360321,
0.06299964338541031,
0.38138940930366516,
0.3124202787876129,
0.19799970090389252,
-0.8519765138626099,
-0.010962746106088161,
0.5850514769554138,
0.9534907937049866,
-0.02543727681040764,
-0.4165339469909668,
-0.577106237411499,
0.0692436471581459,
-0.3049542009830475,
0.7868362069129944,
-0.5852729082107544,
-0.3985958993434906,
0.3044176399707794,
-0.0975065603852272,
-0.09888273477554321,
-0.4942406713962555,
0.4189216196537018,
-0.532000720500946,
-0.2753572165966034,
-0.24040929973125458,
-0.5051871538162231,
-0.41035881638526917,
-0.0643426775932312,
-0.5369703769683838,
0.6412625908851624,
0.3762631118297577,
0.021260088309645653,
0.4318363070487976,
-0.5586820840835571,
-0.47739219665527344,
-0.33172592520713806,
0.022397736087441444,
-0.20117324590682983,
0.09888806194067001,
0.3822917640209198,
0.33668991923332214,
-0.06301075220108032,
0.3011341094970703,
-0.1190483570098877,
-0.16546785831451416,
-0.08213081955909729,
-0.16670918464660645,
0.6600110530853271,
0.5832005143165588,
-0.11286511272192001,
0.17424531280994415,
-0.9571496844291687,
-0.1383969634771347,
-0.22056926786899567,
-0.4562329649925232,
-0.42505455017089844,
-0.3223474621772766,
-0.0874084085226059,
0.40829116106033325,
0.17793823778629303,
-0.46960845589637756,
0.1999378651380539,
-0.7619408369064331,
0.3907238245010376,
0.9142189621925354,
-0.16440030932426453,
0.49399954080581665,
-0.05652062967419624,
0.6404547095298767,
0.13062436878681183,
-0.031133025884628296,
-0.2480214238166809,
-0.4912152588367462,
-0.8763812184333801,
-0.19226770102977753,
0.7089155912399292,
0.5242356061935425,
-1.2001087665557861,
0.20309476554393768,
0.053903914988040924,
-0.5981427431106567,
-0.9118081331253052,
0.5489805936813354,
0.3741501271724701,
0.45125314593315125,
0.3580259382724762,
-0.212264284491539,
-0.6582288146018982,
-1.051512360572815,
-0.021303601562976837,
0.21447822451591492,
-0.07787530869245529,
0.21180805563926697,
0.39069539308547974,
-0.35387369990348816,
0.820237398147583,
-0.38928353786468506,
-0.5475277900695801,
-0.17737525701522827,
0.0859677866101265,
0.2512619197368622,
0.655138373374939,
1.1503350734710693,
-0.5458438992500305,
-0.48392656445503235,
-0.025096124038100243,
-0.43416452407836914,
-0.1684250384569168,
-0.0019226963631808758,
-0.22707898914813995,
0.08958658576011658,
0.4783424735069275,
-0.18612287938594818,
0.07699903100728989,
0.9064930081367493,
-0.33618056774139404,
0.01656814105808735,
-0.5151475667953491,
-0.13193562626838684,
-0.9923598766326904,
-0.11357910931110382,
-0.2903984487056732,
-0.1275395154953003,
-0.949266254901886,
-0.11453768610954285,
-0.19932349026203156,
-0.11509618908166885,
-0.5780595541000366,
0.5621896982192993,
-0.6234571933746338,
0.040678445249795914,
-0.5258409380912781,
0.0447719469666481,
-0.1303003877401352,
0.4586416184902191,
0.02645483985543251,
0.9283483624458313,
0.6698750853538513,
-0.7396005988121033,
-0.03329148143529892,
0.33622023463249207,
-0.3807087242603302,
0.17249305546283722,
-0.6930918097496033,
0.34400901198387146,
-0.2365633100271225,
-0.2943684160709381,
-0.9440631866455078,
-0.0023085949942469597,
0.026992149651050568,
0.005437644198536873,
0.4443618953227997,
-0.20935507118701935,
-0.020513391122221947,
0.12708976864814758,
-0.18472027778625488,
0.27655625343322754,
0.230710968375206,
-0.5913205742835999,
0.9273195266723633,
0.8417825102806091,
-0.47580820322036743,
-0.571429431438446,
-0.6645625829696655,
-0.11241878569126129,
-0.08500859141349792,
-0.6270803213119507,
0.5004644989967346,
0.20752166211605072,
-0.08556844294071198,
-0.448597252368927,
0.2164030373096466,
-0.2422458529472351,
0.10864784568548203,
-0.0018035599496215582,
0.12093906849622726,
-0.41360729932785034,
0.13582873344421387,
0.3307588994503021,
-0.020491117611527443,
-0.10038884729146957,
-0.27663978934288025,
0.6352658867835999,
-0.11248256266117096,
-0.09476946294307709,
0.11540987342596054,
0.28522518277168274,
0.19775055348873138,
-0.5305495858192444,
1.2433992624282837,
0.6749716401100159,
-0.4143008291721344,
-0.06636942923069,
-0.4994930922985077,
-0.16668081283569336,
-0.4682168662548065,
-0.05135380104184151,
-0.3023067116737366,
-0.9101690649986267,
0.8510922193527222,
-0.22518648207187653,
0.061128295958042145,
0.35290831327438354,
0.5406777858734131,
0.22821760177612305,
0.8960670828819275,
1.0234851837158203,
0.09572374075651169,
0.6541061997413635,
-0.3788800835609436,
0.11027293652296066,
-0.6836340427398682,
-0.14840838313102722,
-0.5047434568405151,
-0.33002743124961853,
-0.7989658713340759,
-0.38508203625679016,
0.32195302844047546,
0.29997843503952026,
0.15219144523143768,
0.27093708515167236,
-0.04143000394105911,
0.3008727729320526,
0.5208787322044373,
0.006971673108637333,
-0.012511065229773521,
0.08157432824373245,
-0.3766748309135437,
0.29554641246795654,
-0.8423890471458435,
-0.7638421058654785,
1.19553804397583,
0.2607422173023224,
0.6858469843864441,
0.0666140615940094,
0.6010712385177612,
-0.02910415641963482,
0.4794057309627533,
-0.458398699760437,
0.062323883175849915,
-0.31341883540153503,
-0.3177824020385742,
-0.28273940086364746,
-0.08140132576227188,
-1.183889627456665,
0.20664213597774506,
-0.17971915006637573,
-0.47979268431663513,
0.805320680141449,
0.298015832901001,
-0.82908695936203,
0.08041156828403473,
-0.9518885612487793,
0.6898210644721985,
-0.22654148936271667,
-0.2885214388370514,
0.024080703034996986,
-0.5953686237335205,
0.17184805870056152,
-0.4056508243083954,
0.33006682991981506,
-0.29640814661979675,
-0.19580774009227753,
0.7275781035423279,
-0.6430805325508118,
0.6006563305854797,
-0.5093401074409485,
-0.5716065168380737,
0.6038684844970703,
-0.22244147956371307,
0.45678821206092834,
0.1719122976064682,
-0.2949347496032715,
0.42009496688842773,
-0.259542316198349,
-0.5056067705154419,
-0.23075255751609802,
0.9136022925376892,
-0.8214007019996643,
-0.42844685912132263,
-0.1786750853061676,
-0.529523491859436,
-0.5998120307922363,
0.2737281620502472,
-0.06943591684103012,
0.22999584674835205,
-0.06433471292257309,
0.23013269901275635,
0.5160599946975708,
-0.3022845387458801,
0.4674977660179138,
0.5903623700141907,
-0.3028077483177185,
-0.4334636926651001,
0.8681732416152954,
0.3242785930633545,
0.29567617177963257,
0.1859796941280365,
-0.011756964027881622,
-0.33142635226249695,
-0.8010922074317932,
-0.4825248122215271,
0.10724698007106781,
-0.5955238342285156,
-0.45194363594055176,
-0.5361974239349365,
-0.04081980139017105,
-0.3020630478858948,
-0.12797313928604126,
-0.5296686887741089,
-0.25944387912750244,
-0.373090922832489,
-0.08708597719669342,
0.41987574100494385,
0.7376453876495361,
-0.3450421094894409,
0.6741853356361389,
-0.9933921694755554,
0.2857248783111572,
0.32341811060905457,
0.5433265566825867,
0.053778909146785736,
-0.5524182319641113,
-0.4891391694545746,
0.5112387537956238,
-0.23243844509124756,
-0.7211013436317444,
0.5780360698699951,
0.6898040771484375,
0.7653120756149292,
0.5024135112762451,
-0.35856544971466064,
0.7365186810493469,
-0.4726133942604065,
0.4801499843597412,
-0.40429267287254333,
-1.0354307889938354,
0.7782711386680603,
-0.2325456589460373,
0.21839876472949982,
0.5290948152542114,
0.6349979639053345,
0.12182663381099701,
-0.03859271481633186,
-0.22084662318229675,
-0.7033120393753052,
0.7225194573402405,
0.4013867974281311,
0.2593110203742981,
0.03553249314427376,
0.5296900272369385,
0.49320048093795776,
0.4670110046863556,
-0.25914669036865234,
-0.3527212142944336,
-0.3006290793418884,
0.11910607665777206,
-0.27226483821868896,
-0.31257444620132446,
0.24067501723766327,
-0.30584901571273804,
0.5586525201797485,
-0.32142454385757446,
0.21392008662223816,
0.17261801660060883,
-0.3214310109615326,
-0.018869083374738693,
-0.009197921492159367,
0.8486858606338501,
0.9297100901603699,
-0.18713189661502838,
-0.10099200159311295,
0.2740609645843506,
-0.6416977047920227,
0.2794949412345886,
0.4548688530921936,
-0.22929568588733673,
0.12301899492740631,
0.29524919390678406,
1.0556533336639404,
0.04487127438187599,
-0.7136334180831909,
-0.06915264576673508,
0.2082359790802002,
0.18012790381908417,
0.037231288850307465,
0.10810999572277069,
-0.0075980667024850845,
0.05202733352780342,
0.416220486164093,
0.17430773377418518,
0.011396554298698902,
-0.7162066698074341,
0.1477852165699005,
0.3451131284236908,
-0.5032588839530945,
-0.4061056673526764,
0.48903968930244446,
0.41783198714256287,
0.019641224294900894,
0.31075361371040344,
0.11832060664892197,
-0.30193591117858887,
0.39724037051200867,
0.342626690864563,
0.5039010047912598,
-0.8834879398345947,
0.020349038764834404,
0.1660982370376587,
0.38694629073143005,
0.23624655604362488,
0.8184117078781128,
0.3697744905948639,
-1.0369479656219482,
-0.49602288007736206,
-1.0843870639801025,
-0.04141353443264961,
0.21298407018184662,
-0.5136451721191406,
0.30356115102767944,
-0.33751416206359863,
-0.27596020698547363,
0.19742277264595032,
-0.22209718823432922,
-0.6782413125038147,
0.2177281528711319,
0.04883599653840065,
0.7696211934089661,
-0.6388155817985535,
0.9766238331794739,
0.6643965840339661,
-0.38590219616889954,
-0.6901351809501648,
-0.4181337058544159,
-0.32243454456329346,
-1.028323769569397,
0.3367430567741394,
-0.013701876625418663,
-0.08918224275112152,
0.14226645231246948,
-0.2754960358142853,
-1.0181987285614014,
0.8640005588531494,
0.9810739755630493,
-0.5298202633857727,
0.3057343363761902,
0.41839438676834106,
0.6573697924613953,
-0.7728203535079956,
-0.039834246039390564,
0.8511270880699158,
0.5386096239089966,
-0.04658472537994385,
-0.8723350763320923,
-0.26882535219192505,
0.07784556597471237,
0.2255704253911972,
0.28804364800453186,
-0.5334963798522949,
1.1721347570419312,
-0.21992990374565125,
-0.12059248983860016,
0.003958398010581732,
0.7301899194717407,
0.07381860911846161,
-0.07373934239149094,
0.6233531832695007,
0.15466243028640747,
0.548982560634613,
-0.29247358441352844,
1.0446220636367798,
-0.5858582854270935,
0.08304890245199203,
0.9359620213508606,
-0.28499671816825867,
0.7737190127372742,
0.7670027017593384,
-0.15252886712551117,
0.40428709983825684,
0.5241900086402893,
0.10604491829872131,
0.7011401653289795,
0.004458685405552387,
-0.10342037677764893,
-0.0679628849029541,
-0.42433056235313416,
-0.5026343464851379,
1.037736177444458,
0.5333314538002014,
-0.44702327251434326,
-0.32631418108940125,
0.5230234265327454,
-0.07352179288864136,
0.10189113020896912,
-0.48412904143333435,
0.8025480508804321,
0.14846299588680267,
-0.649013876914978,
0.7159263491630554,
0.16812165081501007,
0.7035121917724609,
-0.8214029669761658,
-0.2887948453426361,
-0.33631932735443115,
0.13943056762218475,
0.12285059690475464,
-0.6852465271949768,
0.511050820350647,
-0.21886900067329407,
0.10747743397951126,
-0.3945867419242859,
0.9602368474006653,
-0.8252958655357361,
-0.4899093210697174,
0.3118728697299957,
0.6746103763580322,
-0.17800043523311615,
-0.18660429120063782,
-0.4863288402557373,
0.04663364216685295,
0.0757586881518364,
-0.09504543244838715,
0.23176507651805878,
0.3915403187274933,
0.08912580460309982,
0.6162325143814087,
0.8419613838195801,
0.12288070470094681,
0.013610394671559334,
0.07280457764863968,
0.8206339478492737,
-0.3703703284263611,
-0.48087334632873535,
-0.768354058265686,
0.17081895470619202,
0.29619666934013367,
-0.4790619909763336,
0.7192781567573547,
0.4762568473815918,
0.9187479019165039,
-0.49877074360847473,
0.44862228631973267,
0.17911137640476227,
0.4270753562450409,
-0.8767951726913452,
0.9895550012588501,
-0.33593592047691345,
0.18057402968406677,
-0.20248498022556305,
-1.0180679559707642,
0.028426518663764,
0.6014150977134705,
-0.06880529224872589,
0.24862243235111237,
0.04844929277896881,
0.6868153810501099,
-0.06786809116601944,
-0.1820899248123169,
0.2895657420158386,
0.3219777047634125,
0.2131030559539795,
0.35621869564056396,
0.6087096333503723,
-0.49824509024620056,
0.3500087261199951,
-0.4757600724697113,
-0.04634184017777443,
-0.21589210629463196,
-0.9890068769454956,
-0.6734784245491028,
-0.5734224915504456,
-0.0555143803358078,
0.0702953115105629,
-0.04880988970398903,
0.8425968289375305,
0.7042596340179443,
-1.349112868309021,
-0.35989078879356384,
0.054893266409635544,
0.11471734195947647,
-0.16700240969657898,
-0.13420505821704865,
0.2817135453224182,
-0.2660309076309204,
-0.7888960242271423,
0.5634509325027466,
0.4054574966430664,
0.5602369904518127,
-0.4222133457660675,
-0.15652018785476685,
-0.9048347473144531,
0.2763669192790985,
0.9035592079162598,
0.17943395674228668,
-0.6072641611099243,
-0.23907282948493958,
-0.16530562937259674,
0.25697019696235657,
0.17453494668006897,
0.6988271474838257,
-1.0427790880203247,
0.5529990196228027,
0.27540498971939087,
0.5638246536254883,
0.06352116912603378,
-0.08521128445863724,
1.0800203084945679,
-1.0499026775360107,
0.5875862240791321,
0.11719752848148346,
0.6514742970466614,
0.37888506054878235,
-0.13187281787395477,
0.582482099533081,
-0.17281921207904816,
-0.1604522317647934,
-0.9057520627975464,
-0.1393233686685562,
-0.5769315958023071,
-0.00952931959182024,
0.7453554272651672,
-0.28533288836479187,
-0.10763488709926605,
-0.20938625931739807,
-0.45481348037719727,
0.38760244846343994,
-0.36955010890960693,
0.7965101599693298,
0.7823846936225891,
-0.000836427672766149,
0.13749222457408905,
-0.4478529691696167,
0.7295575141906738,
0.21982543170452118,
-0.9360586404800415,
-0.27844205498695374,
0.04018786549568176,
-0.003722907742485404,
0.3622208833694458,
0.1963891088962555,
0.24616575241088867,
0.16718360781669617,
-0.11916055530309677,
-0.28545939922332764,
-0.042775411158800125,
-0.28934380412101746,
-0.40506038069725037,
0.05624425783753395,
0.09231772273778915,
-0.043279509991407394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02532v1
|
Learn to Disguise: Avoid Refusal Responses in LLM's Defense via a Multi-agent Attacker-Disguiser Game
| 2024-04-03T07:43:11 | 2024-04-03T07:43:11 |
Qianqiao Xu, Zhiliang Tian, Hongyan Wu, Zhen Huang, Yiping Song, Feng Liu, Dongsheng Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the enhanced performance of large models on natural language processing
tasks, potential moral and ethical issues of large models arise. There exist
malicious attackers who induce large models to jailbreak and generate
information containing illegal, privacy-invasive information through techniques
such as prompt engineering. As a result, large models counter malicious
attackers' attacks using techniques such as safety alignment. However, the
strong defense mechanism of the large model through rejection replies is easily
identified by attackers and used to strengthen attackers' capabilities. In this
paper, we propose a multi-agent attacker-disguiser game approach to achieve a
weak defense mechanism that allows the large model to both safely reply to the
attacker and hide the defense intent. First, we construct a multi-agent
framework to simulate attack and defense scenarios, playing different roles to
be responsible for attack, disguise, safety evaluation, and disguise evaluation
tasks. After that, we design attack and disguise game algorithms to optimize
the game strategies of the attacker and the disguiser and use the curriculum
learning process to strengthen the capabilities of the agents. The experiments
verify that the method in this paper is more effective in strengthening the
model's ability to disguise the defense intent compared with other methods.
Moreover, our approach can adapt any black-box large model to assist the model
in defense and does not suffer from model version iterations.
|
[
-0.34788778424263,
-0.9482226967811584,
0.49946269392967224,
0.10992087423801422,
0.09737355262041092,
0.49111178517341614,
-0.09151923656463623,
-0.309419184923172,
-0.011026924476027489,
0.7464402318000793,
-0.805851936340332,
-0.27992546558380127,
-0.577191174030304,
-0.026110529899597168,
-0.12267918139696121,
0.7968814373016357,
0.14470374584197998,
0.19240836799144745,
0.03560750558972359,
0.10761091858148575,
-0.4216359555721283,
-0.6733902096748352,
-1.0557349920272827,
-0.20037533342838287,
0.5900847315788269,
0.20213016867637634,
0.5275140404701233,
0.46752941608428955,
0.5045869946479797,
0.4566414952278137,
0.06301708519458771,
0.0030261569190770388,
-0.6243287324905396,
0.3746189475059509,
-0.4158417880535126,
-0.5634291172027588,
-0.4867139458656311,
0.06967130303382874,
0.4663417339324951,
0.009943610057234764,
-0.19070056080818176,
0.008396008051931858,
0.06059306487441063,
0.3320477604866028,
-0.8229146599769592,
-0.07846272736787796,
-0.7384040355682373,
0.007398946210741997,
0.00212112907320261,
0.12509478628635406,
-1.0340368747711182,
-0.03381120041012764,
-0.09102407097816467,
-0.46710073947906494,
0.06093950197100639,
0.07610922306776047,
0.7005873322486877,
-0.12643848359584808,
-0.3554023802280426,
-0.13139958679676056,
-0.7059696912765503,
0.7950035929679871,
-0.5515374541282654,
0.033993199467659,
0.14938025176525116,
0.6826937794685364,
-0.2653210461139679,
-0.1888473480939865,
-0.623935341835022,
-0.4725349545478821,
0.057963985949754715,
0.30374228954315186,
-0.35803496837615967,
0.3466775119304657,
0.21553529798984528,
-0.06445492058992386,
-0.5047195553779602,
0.1642531156539917,
-0.17499634623527527,
-0.3807606101036072,
0.6164422035217285,
0.27646493911743164,
0.32693254947662354,
0.27432888746261597,
-0.8784329891204834,
-0.3825489580631256,
-0.7077628374099731,
0.052124906331300735,
0.5997238159179688,
0.33820658922195435,
-0.11077339202165604,
0.700183093547821,
0.03610505908727646,
0.15151797235012054,
0.14546097815036774,
-0.17757216095924377,
-0.1595243215560913,
-0.0004265951574780047,
-0.27274420857429504,
-0.03362059220671654,
0.6194053888320923,
0.08957532793283463,
-0.1793801486492157,
-0.3491203784942627,
-0.5408611297607422,
0.45763614773750305,
0.613990306854248,
-0.7689501643180847,
0.20569758117198944,
0.06358710676431656,
-0.4877285361289978,
-0.5412895083427429,
-0.01534359436482191,
-1.1286036968231201,
-0.6626474857330322,
0.06399936974048615,
0.7947344183921814,
-0.38537660241127014,
-0.03698636591434479,
0.04638197273015976,
-0.2048056721687317,
0.7807362675666809,
0.24925673007965088,
-0.49444982409477234,
0.7033753395080566,
0.5809581875801086,
0.675997257232666,
-0.1345808207988739,
-0.3038986623287201,
-0.7379144430160522,
0.51055908203125,
-0.442680686712265,
0.317802757024765,
-0.27472537755966187,
-0.2710784673690796,
-0.20162433385849,
-0.009510969743132591,
-0.11497554928064346,
-0.4308609366416931,
0.47537514567375183,
-0.7933881282806396,
-0.026970095932483673,
-0.02271360531449318,
-0.31400707364082336,
-0.2622576057910919,
0.7125821709632874,
-0.9086937308311462,
0.14112834632396698,
-0.15706634521484375,
-0.6328737735748291,
-0.1564924418926239,
-0.933905839920044,
-0.43381401896476746,
-0.1565401256084442,
0.18395747244358063,
-0.6981731057167053,
0.008878621272742748,
0.27444764971733093,
0.4486599564552307,
-0.1996309757232666,
-0.14052940905094147,
-0.6232998371124268,
-0.32129859924316406,
0.3160991072654724,
-0.6693512797355652,
0.9215201139450073,
0.20955252647399902,
-0.39254507422447205,
0.22103197872638702,
-0.6441538333892822,
-0.2218644767999649,
0.7193840742111206,
-0.28925439715385437,
-0.25497549772262573,
0.014029355719685555,
-0.3216874897480011,
0.06305410712957382,
0.0993422120809555,
-0.44448426365852356,
0.0391557551920414,
-0.8156843781471252,
0.2135636806488037,
0.9975405335426331,
0.12510566413402557,
0.7796168923377991,
-0.6070244908332825,
0.7287232875823975,
0.03971640020608902,
0.5329738855361938,
-0.11077659577131271,
-0.2353610247373581,
-0.6608498096466064,
-0.4440636932849884,
-0.1749054491519928,
0.6660807132720947,
-1.0764331817626953,
-0.07127998769283295,
0.061249565333127975,
-0.37103742361068726,
-0.7134749889373779,
-0.04003545641899109,
0.620105504989624,
0.14310292899608612,
0.36563992500305176,
-0.18835224211215973,
-0.5962006449699402,
-0.7377081513404846,
-0.1862301081418991,
-0.23293277621269226,
0.010561048053205013,
-0.0034166956320405006,
0.4600459933280945,
-0.20146843791007996,
0.6070635318756104,
-0.22870750725269318,
-0.13161952793598175,
-0.330792099237442,
-0.10716629773378372,
-0.019125329330563545,
0.40494075417518616,
0.7044768333435059,
-0.9802384376525879,
-0.1814802885055542,
-0.24916763603687286,
-0.6424214839935303,
0.4461672008037567,
-0.04563559219241142,
-0.13760410249233246,
0.2530685067176819,
0.30050405859947205,
-0.822292685508728,
0.6394720077514648,
0.25772279500961304,
-0.3367275297641754,
0.5603513717651367,
0.09342154115438461,
0.22245822846889496,
-1.1756750345230103,
-0.25871172547340393,
-0.3809589445590973,
-0.15916357934474945,
-0.9566981792449951,
0.9448559880256653,
-0.036500781774520874,
-0.24302330613136292,
-0.6100770831108093,
0.8629831075668335,
-0.4701671302318573,
0.2709290683269501,
-0.11347615718841553,
-0.1722504049539566,
0.0843341052532196,
0.3996894061565399,
-0.13584131002426147,
0.6691941022872925,
0.7897005081176758,
-0.685806155204773,
0.4119819700717926,
0.04920925572514534,
-0.03568274900317192,
0.7467976212501526,
-0.5149779915809631,
0.4856751561164856,
-0.39163365960121155,
0.08287859708070755,
-1.1051466464996338,
-0.16181649267673492,
0.8689817786216736,
-0.4967769384384155,
0.5822001695632935,
-0.31864896416664124,
-0.2304670661687851,
-0.5304898023605347,
-0.6787456274032593,
0.27381667494773865,
0.38651782274246216,
-0.6021572351455688,
1.1647939682006836,
0.03711336851119995,
0.06751050800085068,
-1.058174729347229,
-0.4750139117240906,
0.3275565207004547,
-0.7082067131996155,
-0.49356809258461,
0.33301740884780884,
-0.7118731141090393,
-0.3419937491416931,
-0.5363649725914001,
0.16062241792678833,
-0.07352107018232346,
0.4115873873233795,
0.42074429988861084,
0.40119051933288574,
-0.28085169196128845,
-0.3556184768676758,
-0.2900630533695221,
0.2396426945924759,
0.41897493600845337,
-0.07295764237642288,
0.4158899784088135,
0.06847213953733444,
-0.6494702696800232,
-0.16036644577980042,
0.580215334892273,
0.5929895043373108,
-0.15024538338184357,
0.9784597158432007,
0.29954344034194946,
-0.2586882412433624,
-0.33348697423934937,
-0.5937861204147339,
-0.4880145192146301,
-0.5637422800064087,
0.39631345868110657,
-0.47962138056755066,
-0.6540123820304871,
0.487186074256897,
0.05756524205207825,
0.4151466488838196,
0.14826491475105286,
0.45339158177375793,
0.2740965187549591,
0.9526822566986084,
0.5620421171188354,
-0.3056943416595459,
0.1371854543685913,
-0.047337353229522705,
0.08678194135427475,
-0.42355582118034363,
-0.3775988221168518,
-0.5072962045669556,
-0.16194571554660797,
-0.17281650006771088,
-0.37616464495658875,
0.10773216933012009,
-0.10390789806842804,
-0.4773676097393036,
0.3141663074493408,
-0.37612712383270264,
0.6464799642562866,
0.29296618700027466,
0.45563802123069763,
-0.06845644861459732,
0.14137734472751617,
-0.07268565148115158,
0.039542973041534424,
-0.4178938865661621,
-0.3407236933708191,
1.1157891750335693,
0.7115923166275024,
0.8898700475692749,
0.864838719367981,
1.0449435710906982,
0.3127595782279968,
0.34016677737236023,
-0.8875224590301514,
0.880946934223175,
0.3779982924461365,
-0.5297952890396118,
-0.24183961749076843,
-0.6513790488243103,
-1.017880916595459,
0.39742958545684814,
-0.2856743335723877,
-0.6521520018577576,
-0.24661029875278473,
-0.1703101396560669,
-0.34861165285110474,
0.46539318561553955,
-0.8165273666381836,
0.5536889433860779,
-0.2509932219982147,
-0.5807194113731384,
-0.11732600629329681,
-0.5260708928108215,
0.5541926026344299,
-0.04101588949561119,
0.5091084241867065,
0.4676400423049927,
0.014910014346241951,
0.610431969165802,
-0.08567196875810623,
1.122496247291565,
-0.21519339084625244,
-0.21961449086666107,
0.3735014498233795,
0.5059995651245117,
0.7476840019226074,
0.1065654531121254,
-0.1861792653799057,
-0.12534762918949127,
-0.31487008929252625,
-0.5087927579879761,
-0.45787733793258667,
0.33655861020088196,
-0.6074872016906738,
-1.18901526927948,
-0.338430255651474,
-0.37540996074676514,
0.008197381161153316,
0.3918001651763916,
0.13322290778160095,
-0.09180319309234619,
-0.5644092559814453,
-0.3024742901325226,
0.9622781872749329,
-0.35722652077674866,
0.8341237306594849,
0.6763665080070496,
0.10931647568941116,
-0.3784894645214081,
0.7869925498962402,
-0.25879818201065063,
0.6390989422798157,
0.4143221080303192,
0.20830798149108887,
-0.27390381693840027,
-0.5139144062995911,
-0.2347201555967331,
0.06557521969079971,
-0.7529841065406799,
-0.4627021849155426,
-0.39812496304512024,
-0.5637639760971069,
-0.4349648356437683,
-0.049668408930301666,
-0.131388857960701,
0.07185184955596924,
-0.07003383338451385,
-0.07485652714967728,
0.009622426703572273,
0.800281822681427,
0.13675285875797272,
0.36104464530944824,
-0.3338569104671478,
0.3403225541114807,
0.4904544949531555,
0.04414576664566994,
0.21287143230438232,
-0.7050516605377197,
0.19535575807094574,
0.17835403978824615,
-0.6221024990081787,
-1.1678962707519531,
0.264206200838089,
-0.17278970777988434,
0.7107117176055908,
0.5785813331604004,
0.3088514506816864,
0.2174474596977234,
-0.47932660579681396,
0.43373775482177734,
0.2837448716163635,
-0.7628005743026733,
0.33378082513809204,
-0.17136816680431366,
-0.02280583418905735,
0.11989066749811172,
0.1422429382801056,
0.20771417021751404,
-0.42359742522239685,
-0.6859182119369507,
-0.6538382172584534,
0.7256609797477722,
0.33411312103271484,
0.41537848114967346,
0.1294967532157898,
0.2589211165904999,
-0.1591440737247467,
0.27269452810287476,
-1.4498635530471802,
-0.3960399329662323,
-0.02093709260225296,
0.09284213185310364,
0.07090316712856293,
-0.3536478281021118,
-0.5923697352409363,
0.23914161324501038,
0.7074638605117798,
-0.06617268174886703,
0.4133681058883667,
-0.09503626823425293,
-0.08443184942007065,
0.2301020622253418,
0.6362581849098206,
0.5935245156288147,
0.21690548956394196,
0.17166492342948914,
0.5048993825912476,
0.2625207304954529,
-0.393383651971817,
0.5963394641876221,
0.10081597417593002,
-0.15491369366645813,
-0.41466858983039856,
0.4211012125015259,
0.38311222195625305,
0.02978760190308094,
-0.5306817293167114,
0.8795977830886841,
-0.11181457340717316,
-0.38759657740592957,
-0.11828970164060593,
0.20722869038581848,
-0.054466523230075836,
0.586124062538147,
0.13177460432052612,
0.17019023001194,
0.1523789018392563,
-0.6450695395469666,
0.14717090129852295,
0.8624595999717712,
-0.14019550383090973,
-0.04625691846013069,
0.6591089963912964,
-0.3793555498123169,
-0.40305572748184204,
0.16313275694847107,
-0.4147309362888336,
-0.7873681783676147,
0.9474150538444519,
0.9146525859832764,
0.6106970310211182,
-0.717091977596283,
0.37666112184524536,
0.11245964467525482,
0.6765047907829285,
-0.29938846826553345,
-0.027329321950674057,
0.2756923735141754,
-0.6066569089889526,
-0.15342213213443756,
-0.392791211605072,
-0.2515399158000946,
0.3770088851451874,
-0.46248114109039307,
0.10040607303380966,
-0.9638330936431885,
-0.04953891783952713,
-0.1047520861029625,
-0.10828068107366562,
-0.5965085625648499,
-0.12753796577453613,
0.20577797293663025,
0.629144549369812,
-0.4745510518550873,
0.4607844352722168,
0.4967498779296875,
-0.3799496591091156,
-0.7803596258163452,
-0.021175310015678406,
0.2870951294898987,
-0.7265599966049194,
0.31209835410118103,
0.22418729960918427,
-0.3444969654083252,
-0.18500617146492004,
-1.0049115419387817,
-0.5747697949409485,
0.8302898406982422,
0.6587156653404236,
-0.4264358580112457,
0.009734374471008778,
-0.07568354159593582,
0.22340503334999084,
-0.43507272005081177,
0.26093432307243347,
0.055943604558706284,
0.4750520884990692,
0.40753352642059326,
-0.31555208563804626,
0.2962115705013275,
0.07448871433734894,
-0.30287620425224304,
-0.1898544877767563,
-0.7421061992645264,
0.9306972026824951,
-0.5181817412376404,
-0.37244126200675964,
0.25022152066230774,
0.6215598583221436,
0.522261917591095,
0.5386436581611633,
0.40925198793411255,
0.2632153034210205,
0.6273025274276733,
0.19354572892189026,
0.6559127569198608,
0.37149322032928467,
0.17150503396987915,
0.9414233565330505,
-0.5595250129699707,
0.68068528175354,
0.3487490117549896,
0.05452762916684151,
0.38553619384765625,
0.19114893674850464,
-0.3977159261703491,
0.5294065475463867,
0.5341786742210388,
-0.35046622157096863,
-0.1715099811553955,
0.19781915843486786,
-0.04815293103456497,
0.38287806510925293,
0.3165155351161957,
-0.1226525604724884,
-0.2423684298992157,
0.20287729799747467,
0.1454928070306778,
0.3750385344028473,
-0.5041229128837585,
0.704939603805542,
0.003851471934467554,
-0.38278231024742126,
0.4909212291240692,
0.45815369486808777,
0.7223668098449707,
-0.7818124294281006,
-0.19053301215171814,
-0.13903909921646118,
0.22110503911972046,
0.14935827255249023,
-0.37419575452804565,
-0.11027319729328156,
-0.2950551509857178,
-0.31177884340286255,
-0.022657183930277824,
0.7493899464607239,
-0.16490480303764343,
-0.3331269919872284,
0.6638421416282654,
0.25644731521606445,
-0.2159266173839569,
-0.039428021758794785,
-0.9514114856719971,
-0.10124290734529495,
-0.30964258313179016,
-0.1739821881055832,
0.664545476436615,
0.20709781348705292,
-0.16832084953784943,
0.9448221325874329,
0.5180062055587769,
-0.09873124212026596,
-0.0838060975074768,
-0.03976266086101532,
0.8651683330535889,
-0.35444167256355286,
-0.5555697083473206,
-1.3427306413650513,
0.09126182645559311,
-0.25221672654151917,
0.6878055334091187,
0.7747318744659424,
0.41053876280784607,
0.564167320728302,
-0.11552927643060684,
0.5283231735229492,
0.25412696599960327,
0.4169425070285797,
-0.6741899847984314,
1.0143202543258667,
-0.2779850959777832,
0.4810131788253784,
-0.4668624699115753,
-0.7522949576377869,
-0.10732228308916092,
0.43558353185653687,
0.08926486223936081,
0.1770356148481369,
0.3589707314968109,
0.9599311351776123,
-0.17008814215660095,
-0.2800610363483429,
0.47616368532180786,
0.22898368537425995,
0.4251314103603363,
1.082081913948059,
1.098076581954956,
-0.4546177387237549,
0.5910488963127136,
0.1913025826215744,
-0.2638159394264221,
0.056106988340616226,
-0.7307501435279846,
-1.5429052114486694,
-0.24095478653907776,
0.1895691156387329,
-0.7860404849052429,
0.2880445420742035,
0.7697295546531677,
0.7614983916282654,
-0.6612624526023865,
-0.13018400967121124,
0.4301832318305969,
0.4699745774269104,
-0.3868333101272583,
-0.26482516527175903,
0.1287018209695816,
0.08923469483852386,
-0.4703361392021179,
0.8697200417518616,
0.019044216722249985,
0.45453017950057983,
-0.2089073657989502,
-0.3831021785736084,
-0.18115559220314026,
0.6008113622665405,
0.4372057616710663,
0.3175239861011505,
-0.8199078440666199,
-0.26833921670913696,
0.03400823473930359,
-0.18639466166496277,
-0.19958074390888214,
0.5255979299545288,
-0.6175743937492371,
0.4028225541114807,
-0.19581939280033112,
0.9815476536750793,
-0.020219536498188972,
-0.12728732824325562,
0.42733216285705566,
-0.7790500521659851,
0.25349676609039307,
0.14198122918605804,
0.0907137393951416,
0.22971726953983307,
-0.8489693403244019,
0.2833527624607086,
0.0560598149895668,
-0.07358935475349426,
-0.832100510597229,
0.4585907459259033,
-0.6825563907623291,
-0.5998061895370483,
0.9439324140548706,
-0.2177923172712326,
-0.43290045857429504,
-0.11647085845470428,
-0.28542011976242065,
0.094471275806427,
-0.41349202394485474,
0.8121318817138672,
0.6725180745124817,
0.46222400665283203,
-0.27389514446258545,
-0.49441203474998474,
0.46636927127838135,
0.331536203622818,
-0.7950250506401062,
0.08979561179876328,
0.29394766688346863,
0.3120189905166626,
0.17463649809360504,
0.34113630652427673,
-0.02243415080010891,
0.27228328585624695,
-0.07417047023773193,
-0.145268514752388,
-0.16657981276512146,
-0.6700105667114258,
-0.4223315417766571,
0.5413020849227905,
0.00989640410989523,
-0.23204635083675385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02529v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02529v1
|
A School Student Essay Corpus for Analyzing Interactions of Argumentative Structure and Quality
| 2024-04-03T07:31:53 | 2024-04-03T07:31:53 |
Maja Stahl, Nadine Michel, Sebastian Kilsbach, Julian Schmidtke, Sara Rezat, Henning Wachsmuth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Learning argumentative writing is challenging. Besides writing fundamentals
such as syntax and grammar, learners must select and arrange argument
components meaningfully to create high-quality essays. To support argumentative
writing computationally, one step is to mine the argumentative structure. When
combined with automatic essay scoring, interactions of the argumentative
structure and quality scores can be exploited for comprehensive writing
support. Although studies have shown the usefulness of using information about
the argumentative structure for essay scoring, no argument mining corpus with
ground-truth essay quality annotations has been published yet. Moreover, none
of the existing corpora contain essays written by school students specifically.
To fill this research gap, we present a German corpus of 1,320 essays from
school students of two age groups. Each essay has been manually annotated for
argumentative structure and quality on multiple levels of granularity. We
propose baseline approaches to argument mining and essay scoring, and we
analyze interactions between both tasks, thereby laying the ground for
quality-oriented argumentative writing support.
|
[
-0.31681033968925476,
-0.8404726982116699,
0.8634276390075684,
-0.15475749969482422,
-0.07548701018095016,
0.13750970363616943,
0.20851854979991913,
-0.09768258780241013,
0.11673925071954727,
0.1206916868686676,
-0.19566571712493896,
-0.7429929971694946,
-0.3896492123603821,
0.061627015471458435,
-0.2299491912126541,
1.0170581340789795,
-0.35830846428871155,
0.06513717770576477,
-0.7955015897750854,
-0.12615090608596802,
-0.1972828507423401,
-0.8410934805870056,
-0.6794273257255554,
-0.08619055896997452,
0.66938316822052,
0.718483030796051,
0.26135823130607605,
0.6517492532730103,
0.30289730429649353,
0.46895164251327515,
0.04193719103932381,
-0.15262754261493683,
-0.16210398077964783,
0.3573912978172302,
-0.5826110243797302,
-0.046805717051029205,
-0.3758423924446106,
0.10305438190698624,
0.6470698714256287,
0.8068684935569763,
0.0980839654803276,
0.2808830142021179,
-0.1450972855091095,
0.14254088699817657,
-0.5042251348495483,
0.0814555287361145,
-0.565447986125946,
-0.017206795513629913,
-0.4773264527320862,
-0.15414798259735107,
-0.3593938648700714,
-0.3929741680622101,
-0.13542614877223969,
-0.3667047619819641,
0.05307049676775932,
-0.25760382413864136,
1.2380307912826538,
0.038731321692466736,
-0.1096661314368248,
-0.42471665143966675,
-0.23418083786964417,
0.6309973001480103,
-0.49598631262779236,
-0.4015202224254608,
0.16331073641777039,
0.14675669372081757,
-0.22968018054962158,
-0.8290255665779114,
-0.3184465765953064,
0.2137259691953659,
-0.32273438572883606,
0.4362561106681824,
-0.36965620517730713,
0.1357421576976776,
0.09292416274547577,
0.36373093724250793,
-0.4124242067337036,
-0.15411946177482605,
-0.587701141834259,
-0.277765154838562,
0.37288495898246765,
0.08844201266765594,
0.27604585886001587,
-0.5775203704833984,
-0.35871827602386475,
-0.22913052141666412,
-0.10184745490550995,
0.6632132530212402,
0.9682114720344543,
0.1423989236354828,
0.39413386583328247,
0.5308904647827148,
0.12172742933034897,
0.5202929973602295,
0.17393657565116882,
0.060876261442899704,
-0.1756020486354828,
-0.11066439002752304,
-0.058187685906887054,
0.32339033484458923,
0.7856409549713135,
0.18970997631549835,
0.09347765147686005,
-0.026836154982447624,
-0.12093807756900787,
0.4523387551307678,
0.617688000202179,
-0.8289123773574829,
-0.21097032725811005,
0.2592730224132538,
-0.6950595378875732,
-0.5252392292022705,
0.29626819491386414,
-0.8795387744903564,
-0.011492461897432804,
-0.09139356017112732,
0.4338303208351135,
-0.4761791229248047,
-0.023221751675009727,
-0.20757274329662323,
-0.47629639506340027,
0.060281042009592056,
-0.10528819262981415,
-0.7409942150115967,
0.5945422649383545,
0.6860395073890686,
0.7084050178527832,
-0.09026683121919632,
-0.2613517642021179,
-0.5927587747573853,
0.02445480041205883,
-0.680195689201355,
1.3912609815597534,
-0.9954021573066711,
-0.34074869751930237,
0.18734952807426453,
-0.1313781440258026,
-0.18200379610061646,
-0.5639693737030029,
1.6137211322784424,
-0.14918991923332214,
0.4742881953716278,
-0.1562207192182541,
-1.0178662538528442,
-0.1343928426504135,
0.013438662514090538,
-0.40955212712287903,
0.993003785610199,
0.3457164466381073,
-0.6372384428977966,
0.1927872896194458,
-0.5777471661567688,
-0.5608015060424805,
0.3065969944000244,
-0.12590080499649048,
-0.4097726345062256,
0.298514723777771,
-0.15838198363780975,
0.6860240697860718,
0.3846363127231598,
0.35847705602645874,
-0.1779802441596985,
-0.4991576075553894,
0.054218143224716187,
0.09000572562217712,
0.5303541421890259,
0.23786130547523499,
-0.10831601917743683,
0.16074059903621674,
-0.9146416783332825,
0.2738587558269501,
-0.09285112470388412,
-0.41301611065864563,
-0.44213125109672546,
0.23830029368400574,
-0.07589738070964813,
0.18934643268585205,
0.23572462797164917,
-0.47959834337234497,
-0.0121941352263093,
-0.29309049248695374,
0.5030533075332642,
0.596141517162323,
0.22814035415649414,
0.12376460433006287,
-0.20948220789432526,
0.21398460865020752,
-0.050604138523340225,
-0.3803795576095581,
-0.33136186003685,
-0.23668216168880463,
-0.6177000999450684,
0.09327591210603714,
0.2930139899253845,
0.3582451045513153,
-0.18033689260482788,
0.4807170033454895,
0.02755691483616829,
-0.38060200214385986,
-0.5713967680931091,
0.1715145707130432,
0.2794022262096405,
0.6686532497406006,
0.3934624493122101,
-0.013115087524056435,
-0.8316227793693542,
-0.9549338817596436,
-0.2582380771636963,
-0.5507237315177917,
0.037664592266082764,
0.07240092754364014,
0.29218754172325134,
0.2252376228570938,
1.0745160579681396,
-0.42529982328414917,
-0.17281357944011688,
-0.29218676686286926,
0.553265392780304,
0.0038991430774331093,
0.4574737548828125,
0.5305951237678528,
-0.329700767993927,
-0.5654444098472595,
-0.12116299569606781,
-0.6767114400863647,
-0.5289722084999084,
-0.2534444332122803,
-0.5542793273925781,
0.038462091237306595,
0.6542863249778748,
-0.12020006775856018,
0.049558937549591064,
0.26363199949264526,
-0.5749106407165527,
0.4825463891029358,
0.08460313081741333,
0.1876431107521057,
-1.0993316173553467,
0.022725870832800865,
0.07853777706623077,
-0.12987162172794342,
-0.5751431584358215,
-0.011418111622333527,
-0.22611349821090698,
-0.10806073993444443,
-0.16780735552310944,
0.3118059039115906,
0.1491478532552719,
0.4965839385986328,
-0.4713432788848877,
0.08425338566303253,
0.23935768008232117,
0.28847241401672363,
0.16714271903038025,
0.7083753347396851,
0.2425282597541809,
-0.025069020688533783,
-0.2061435431241989,
-0.20464788377285004,
-0.018066542223095894,
1.2087328433990479,
-0.7843035459518433,
-0.06453230232000351,
-0.067673459649086,
0.1265895515680313,
-0.9630943536758423,
-0.44652533531188965,
0.017891114577651024,
-0.5981513857841492,
-0.09194185584783554,
-0.34830328822135925,
-0.11120948195457458,
-0.03901352360844612,
-0.38110029697418213,
-0.1358957141637802,
0.11999956518411636,
-0.4524769186973572,
0.686355471611023,
0.42363330721855164,
-0.31116822361946106,
-0.27112647891044617,
0.019281800836324692,
0.3822123408317566,
-0.6106404066085815,
-0.6567628979682922,
0.6099681258201599,
-0.04213535040616989,
-0.6615100502967834,
0.40058663487434387,
-0.16331078112125397,
-0.3381686806678772,
0.033100999891757965,
0.6483020186424255,
0.24410448968410492,
-0.2705002427101135,
0.2666604518890381,
0.3083169460296631,
-0.20995254814624786,
0.35608434677124023,
-0.11753446608781815,
0.2912857234477997,
-0.31892019510269165,
0.06994392722845078,
-0.04809873178601265,
0.923155665397644,
0.3393003046512604,
0.25097164511680603,
0.4682188928127289,
0.48955029249191284,
-0.5508551001548767,
-0.25537535548210144,
-0.5709754228591919,
0.16037783026695251,
-0.44036975502967834,
0.03706264868378639,
-0.6678280830383301,
-0.7576998472213745,
0.324308305978775,
-0.044035084545612335,
0.3178424537181854,
0.7956963181495667,
0.40870898962020874,
-0.4239642322063446,
0.8179183006286621,
0.2525644302368164,
0.1471405327320099,
0.2591054141521454,
0.17187663912773132,
0.28862133622169495,
-0.3638705909252167,
0.050639115273952484,
-0.7481347322463989,
-0.3244214951992035,
0.015728794038295746,
-0.10536650568246841,
-0.05633808672428131,
0.4212974011898041,
-0.3459639549255371,
0.39583534002304077,
-0.6778051853179932,
0.5705434083938599,
0.47814473509788513,
-0.465973436832428,
-0.047940947115421295,
0.15156574547290802,
-0.2812802493572235,
-0.23788166046142578,
-0.5437241196632385,
-1.2065235376358032,
0.6162508726119995,
0.2739926278591156,
0.16602282226085663,
-0.1489725261926651,
0.8272676467895508,
0.3655923306941986,
0.179051011800766,
-0.4809383749961853,
0.707584798336029,
-0.579482913017273,
-0.5931469202041626,
-0.04250457137823105,
-0.44753727316856384,
-0.852575957775116,
0.22801588475704193,
-0.2038882076740265,
-0.6670854687690735,
0.1165153831243515,
-0.2326313853263855,
-0.4555947780609131,
0.17797812819480896,
-0.95005863904953,
1.137520432472229,
0.07130346447229385,
-0.7386952042579651,
-0.06561121344566345,
-0.23430071771144867,
0.03384772688150406,
0.3414416015148163,
0.06287362426519394,
0.059057023376226425,
0.4606735110282898,
1.100459337234497,
-0.4903835356235504,
0.7102513909339905,
-0.06849587708711624,
0.08789093792438507,
0.9245527982711792,
0.0795021653175354,
-0.03120591677725315,
0.07292100042104721,
-0.20171405375003815,
0.04783152416348457,
0.3321476876735687,
-0.4776732325553894,
-0.31057846546173096,
0.9820696711540222,
-0.7890664935112,
-0.6845203638076782,
-0.5372982621192932,
-0.08224211633205414,
-0.08825735747814178,
0.07189454883337021,
0.1572699248790741,
0.15638139843940735,
-0.24460779130458832,
0.2191038876771927,
0.34321141242980957,
0.35377705097198486,
0.7348592877388,
0.06571018695831299,
0.4188353419303894,
-0.513195812702179,
1.1670310497283936,
0.36693504452705383,
-0.2724466621875763,
-0.08008487522602081,
0.6673730611801147,
-0.21528905630111694,
-0.3534570634365082,
-0.6410451531410217,
-0.12939389050006866,
-0.9617689251899719,
-0.22416895627975464,
-0.8414084315299988,
-0.41628298163414,
-0.2728807330131531,
-0.7827709913253784,
-0.154981330037117,
-0.5249892473220825,
-0.21831907331943512,
-0.42157113552093506,
-0.08277247846126556,
0.3951500952243805,
-0.026157643646001816,
0.2096303552389145,
-0.47767865657806396,
0.0019585711415857077,
0.42654120922088623,
0.4322720468044281,
-0.09404424577951431,
-0.09695620089769363,
-0.05858618766069412,
-0.5541219711303711,
-0.4608193635940552,
-0.7606717348098755,
-0.06382177025079727,
0.12328189611434937,
0.6182773113250732,
0.7128086090087891,
0.050765011459589005,
0.8450256586074829,
-0.33898258209228516,
1.0564548969268799,
-0.03932692110538483,
-1.1730754375457764,
0.6059946417808533,
-0.0850805938243866,
-0.11402782797813416,
0.8671042919158936,
0.24968799948692322,
-0.3396463096141815,
-0.3403351306915283,
-0.7778214812278748,
-0.8803590536117554,
0.408410906791687,
0.00034565950045362115,
0.18489918112754822,
-0.1650364100933075,
0.610463559627533,
0.3028634786605835,
0.029353057965636253,
-0.8357491493225098,
0.15392743051052094,
-0.6557216048240662,
-0.5515320897102356,
0.387362539768219,
-0.3486231863498688,
-0.4886877238750458,
-0.25272154808044434,
0.4995993971824646,
-0.20234429836273193,
-0.30757156014442444,
0.20433393120765686,
0.1990494281053543,
-0.3012363910675049,
0.40271371603012085,
0.2758670151233673,
0.3953070044517517,
-0.052860409021377563,
0.5995965003967285,
0.2201252281665802,
-0.41664496064186096,
0.21232973039150238,
-0.01698887348175049,
-0.22256173193454742,
0.25522831082344055,
0.6054362654685974,
0.5117636322975159,
0.18280595541000366,
-0.644074559211731,
0.35677358508110046,
-0.1640908122062683,
-0.6118189096450806,
-0.5101838707923889,
0.5391944050788879,
0.08954289555549622,
0.12251690030097961,
0.14277654886245728,
-0.12856972217559814,
0.09840217232704163,
-0.7898392081260681,
0.18633216619491577,
0.34923145174980164,
-0.4748222827911377,
-0.25977668166160583,
0.3883960545063019,
0.15887781977653503,
-0.3579002916812897,
0.18883372843265533,
-0.17185693979263306,
-0.48023760318756104,
0.33637142181396484,
0.47292301058769226,
0.6750093698501587,
-0.013914525508880615,
0.5085013508796692,
0.7987931370735168,
-0.24409902095794678,
0.15666937828063965,
0.13173457980155945,
0.035606786608695984,
-0.3984890878200531,
-0.3144075274467468,
-0.8437845706939697,
-0.6244537830352783,
0.1930004060268402,
-0.2815455496311188,
0.16003675758838654,
-0.5226383209228516,
-0.030232859775424004,
0.15188953280448914,
0.4044667184352875,
-0.017276549711823463,
0.33111512660980225,
0.0437866672873497,
0.3998620808124542,
-0.8572259545326233,
0.33924850821495056,
1.2853089570999146,
-0.43015626072883606,
-0.5487563610076904,
-0.01758486218750477,
-0.18869265913963318,
0.02166445180773735,
0.4284788966178894,
0.2726413309574127,
-0.36676692962646484,
-0.3878248333930969,
-0.613740861415863,
-0.4892498552799225,
0.5330425500869751,
-0.1068500205874443,
0.002941404702141881,
0.32228389382362366,
0.21022318303585052,
0.9439548254013062,
-0.5976224541664124,
0.2423490583896637,
0.3630226254463196,
0.6184752583503723,
0.15266062319278717,
0.35621002316474915,
0.004223487805575132,
-0.5835286378860474,
-0.32696732878685,
-0.24692752957344055,
-0.5289669036865234,
0.848005473613739,
0.24951240420341492,
-0.5289126634597778,
-0.14171066880226135,
0.7966040968894958,
-0.02233123406767845,
0.5749305486679077,
0.5955055952072144,
0.7562747001647949,
0.677480161190033,
-0.21213982999324799,
0.3887997567653656,
-0.5034015774726868,
-0.12864209711551666,
0.8846420645713806,
-0.2953907549381256,
1.114127516746521,
0.4087423086166382,
0.08507352322340012,
0.956410825252533,
0.6570432782173157,
-0.10422451794147491,
-0.013562241569161415,
0.38243505358695984,
-0.3953827917575836,
-0.5988875031471252,
-0.20682351291179657,
-0.058021921664476395,
0.48548489809036255,
0.31534916162490845,
-0.009232303127646446,
-0.42278751730918884,
-0.5880692005157471,
0.515036940574646,
0.787476122379303,
-0.12307149916887283,
0.8649449944496155,
-0.1785384565591812,
-1.037168264389038,
0.24859675765037537,
0.19827279448509216,
0.21038883924484253,
-0.3192237913608551,
-0.24032466113567352,
-0.204520121216774,
-0.0626545399427414,
-0.5181940793991089,
-0.9545657634735107,
0.5298559665679932,
0.4723376929759979,
-0.2512345016002655,
-0.1771450936794281,
0.9000028371810913,
-0.21469932794570923,
-0.7095275521278381,
0.1274198591709137,
0.4595675766468048,
0.06507066637277603,
0.19765841960906982,
-0.16751010715961456,
0.005060454830527306,
-0.5246854424476624,
-0.258626252412796,
0.5325572490692139,
0.6271058917045593,
-0.15986782312393188,
-0.10445217043161392,
0.8215761184692383,
-0.011944331228733063,
-0.18809689581394196,
-0.05184033140540123,
0.8934343457221985,
-0.5028040409088135,
-0.14159910380840302,
-0.9251781105995178,
0.5745282173156738,
-0.6436845660209656,
-0.570036768913269,
0.5493908524513245,
0.713912308216095,
0.6729860901832581,
0.4206028878688812,
0.8578199148178101,
-0.030729981139302254,
0.6565936207771301,
-0.03621767833828926,
0.5272096991539001,
-0.34292376041412354,
-0.3240514397621155,
-0.37192702293395996,
-0.9186222553253174,
-0.25939223170280457,
1.1095390319824219,
-0.17569319903850555,
-0.5381390452384949,
0.7232179045677185,
0.1972501128911972,
-0.02772294543683529,
0.154935821890831,
0.24489213526248932,
0.010024888440966606,
0.48733165860176086,
0.48904702067375183,
0.6501824855804443,
-0.25385862588882446,
0.8182900547981262,
-0.21233507990837097,
-0.2878322899341583,
-0.05700308457016945,
-0.8602584600448608,
-1.0189359188079834,
-0.6505834460258484,
-0.41195589303970337,
-0.4254463315010071,
0.19977059960365295,
0.62336266040802,
0.4589381814002991,
-0.8628023266792297,
-0.3548916280269623,
-0.0945434719324112,
0.20957346260547638,
-0.2639034688472748,
-0.31240609288215637,
0.5048819184303284,
-0.9351215958595276,
-0.749251663684845,
0.5020429491996765,
0.267861008644104,
-0.40466031432151794,
-0.08365003019571304,
0.1145867183804512,
-0.1094936802983284,
0.7300221920013428,
0.5035516619682312,
0.2808176577091217,
-0.31003251671791077,
-0.5459991693496704,
-0.19550193846225739,
-0.2539357542991638,
0.29173362255096436,
0.8914827704429626,
-0.551065981388092,
0.3014300465583801,
0.5102502703666687,
0.47706422209739685,
-0.10356377810239792,
0.5357620716094971,
0.15564468502998352,
-0.541853129863739,
-0.42674121260643005,
0.2251768410205841,
0.5422778129577637,
0.22482289373874664,
-0.12339538335800171,
0.41422387957572937,
0.18375179171562195,
-0.6215062737464905,
-0.6714707016944885,
-0.18061155080795288,
-0.8872571587562561,
-0.7798950672149658,
0.9319626092910767,
-0.5527055263519287,
-0.16020449995994568,
-0.17257963120937347,
-0.584260106086731,
0.11820715665817261,
-0.4346107542514801,
1.1629445552825928,
1.4483133554458618,
-0.2237439900636673,
0.10011410713195801,
-0.2982134222984314,
0.5438910722732544,
0.48188188672065735,
-1.0578948259353638,
0.07819495350122452,
0.47156983613967896,
-0.06233801320195198,
0.5183070302009583,
0.2145354151725769,
-0.13325363397598267,
0.1623609960079193,
0.40873751044273376,
-0.06705319136381149,
0.012336468324065208,
-0.40695735812187195,
-0.026121126487851143,
1.2865077257156372,
-0.21563716232776642,
0.040094297379255295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02512v1
|
Towards Large Language Model driven Reference-less Translation Evaluation for English and Indian Languages
| 2024-04-03T06:57:45 | 2024-04-03T06:57:45 |
Vandan Mujadia, Pruthwik Mishra, Arafat Ahsan, Dipti Misra Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the primary focus on evaluating the effectiveness of large language
models for automatic reference-less translation assessment, this work presents
our experiments on mimicking human direct assessment to evaluate the quality of
translations in English and Indian languages. We constructed a translation
evaluation task where we performed zero-shot learning, in-context
example-driven learning, and fine-tuning of large language models to provide a
score out of 100, where 100 represents a perfect translation and 1 represents a
poor translation. We compared the performance of our trained systems with
existing methods such as COMET, BERT-Scorer, and LABSE, and found that the
LLM-based evaluator (LLaMA-2-13B) achieves a comparable or higher overall
correlation with human judgments for the considered Indian language pairs.
|
[
0.01709471084177494,
-0.6118597388267517,
0.49449509382247925,
0.35260576009750366,
-0.35442614555358887,
0.12886503338813782,
-0.5209544897079468,
-0.5664432644844055,
0.08883233368396759,
0.07703369110822678,
-0.16352592408657074,
-0.2664845287799835,
-0.5420097708702087,
0.4223698377609253,
-0.5109310150146484,
0.6468481421470642,
-0.27456316351890564,
0.40534037351608276,
-0.2464553266763687,
-0.1734848916530609,
-0.5999349355697632,
-0.20954178273677826,
-0.5938719511032104,
-0.5942826271057129,
0.3177896738052368,
0.30728650093078613,
0.5126691460609436,
0.44411948323249817,
0.6895664930343628,
0.19841688871383667,
0.015881745144724846,
0.10928629338741302,
-0.5126746892929077,
0.0036635398864746094,
-0.5321399569511414,
-0.27482014894485474,
-0.43248215317726135,
0.2344067245721817,
0.6847578883171082,
0.6147909164428711,
-0.02198036201298237,
0.3694402575492859,
0.08855330944061279,
0.47199100255966187,
-0.7514417171478271,
0.24856938421726227,
-0.6806744337081909,
-0.037234608083963394,
0.0281441081315279,
-0.10974583029747009,
-0.630321204662323,
-0.36199167370796204,
-0.19878818094730377,
-0.20534758269786835,
-0.2655189633369446,
0.06461108475923538,
0.7976476550102234,
0.2722366154193878,
-0.5493912100791931,
-0.3168276846408844,
-0.8409312963485718,
1.1493452787399292,
-0.6225053071975708,
0.34985846281051636,
0.43220987915992737,
0.32569175958633423,
0.09748785197734833,
-0.14892664551734924,
-0.5845772624015808,
-0.5368217825889587,
0.032831840217113495,
0.25499075651168823,
-0.024757903069257736,
-0.20676679909229279,
-0.051565442234277725,
0.5203749537467957,
-0.49999505281448364,
0.2583179473876953,
-0.32776790857315063,
-0.0572441965341568,
0.9544001221656799,
0.19338075816631317,
0.12633880972862244,
-0.3222009837627411,
-0.27558186650276184,
-0.06863247603178024,
-0.8097168803215027,
-0.08674744516611099,
0.04763105884194374,
0.3357242941856384,
-0.23315134644508362,
0.4887295365333557,
-0.33671432733535767,
0.8399854302406311,
0.04522872343659401,
-0.28739315271377563,
0.21799539029598236,
-0.46295246481895447,
-0.3079955577850342,
-0.22761207818984985,
0.9190964698791504,
0.40731382369995117,
0.41063839197158813,
-0.30259791016578674,
-0.4951592981815338,
0.30105119943618774,
-0.002323633059859276,
-0.6780607104301453,
0.4388918876647949,
-0.04458710923790932,
-0.3378860056400299,
-0.412261426448822,
-0.31621694564819336,
-0.6079062223434448,
-0.30012333393096924,
-0.5461323261260986,
0.6477201581001282,
-0.283178448677063,
-0.1920851767063141,
0.06738435477018356,
0.2807033360004425,
0.9270212054252625,
0.5151929259300232,
-0.6256850361824036,
0.3441954553127289,
0.4959108233451843,
0.6342580914497375,
-0.4858062267303467,
-0.4560491740703583,
-0.5911275148391724,
-0.08197084069252014,
-0.7322632074356079,
0.7468098402023315,
-0.7143068909645081,
-0.5399888157844543,
0.04994736239314079,
-0.3687119781970978,
0.08902159333229065,
-0.6002769470214844,
0.5339450836181641,
-0.4007303714752197,
0.0102014672011137,
0.0058535062707960606,
-0.43327122926712036,
-0.25155121088027954,
0.4621928632259369,
-0.10395104438066483,
0.8688952326774597,
0.09949486702680588,
-0.1740926206111908,
0.2606320083141327,
-0.6099640727043152,
-0.5413081645965576,
0.07434716820716858,
-0.0886620283126831,
0.0031237651128321886,
0.2695130705833435,
0.21806150674819946,
0.572022557258606,
-0.760015606880188,
0.12577854096889496,
-0.07066735625267029,
-0.7354916334152222,
-0.10200323164463043,
-0.4283117949962616,
0.5673726201057434,
0.30226537585258484,
-0.29849037528038025,
0.13093067705631256,
-0.7858477234840393,
0.16961020231246948,
0.1311357468366623,
-0.31079185009002686,
-0.3594958782196045,
-0.22429637610912323,
0.11816449463367462,
0.23028579354286194,
0.35402175784111023,
-0.6178354620933533,
0.28180044889450073,
-0.4407772421836853,
0.24123597145080566,
0.47463876008987427,
-0.008224647492170334,
0.4792030155658722,
-0.00977976992726326,
0.4700528681278229,
-0.20014871656894684,
0.16941112279891968,
-0.08517216145992279,
-0.4060446321964264,
-0.8314943909645081,
0.005339197814464569,
0.6124931573867798,
0.6531617045402527,
-0.5295353531837463,
0.3649110198020935,
-0.5563478469848633,
-0.6617774963378906,
-0.715293288230896,
0.4893568158149719,
0.7205897569656372,
0.4134204387664795,
0.3419652283191681,
-0.5030236840248108,
-0.18673232197761536,
-0.9475876688957214,
-0.2022114396095276,
-0.2187914252281189,
-0.07130752503871918,
0.024290183559060097,
0.5609161853790283,
-0.3561856746673584,
0.686299741268158,
-0.18822433054447174,
-0.29131096601486206,
-0.267339289188385,
0.08301877975463867,
0.15936915576457977,
0.4628344476222992,
0.355164110660553,
-0.5336085557937622,
-0.7233061790466309,
0.1493472009897232,
-0.7677704095840454,
-0.16957858204841614,
-0.08046335726976395,
0.0006766222650185227,
0.1822073757648468,
0.38313204050064087,
-0.5075057148933411,
0.4585953950881958,
0.5641171932220459,
-0.05564125254750252,
0.5348027944564819,
-0.2134268581867218,
0.4742600917816162,
-1.0000486373901367,
0.27362504601478577,
-0.01386639941483736,
-0.39749640226364136,
-0.4146929681301117,
0.5914087295532227,
0.21028003096580505,
-0.14043301343917847,
-0.6245734691619873,
0.9033941626548767,
-0.3783661127090454,
-0.11119359731674194,
-0.2854689359664917,
0.321338027715683,
-0.10686301440000534,
0.4698832035064697,
0.09570716321468353,
0.8335157632827759,
0.2991178333759308,
-0.38775792717933655,
0.18718154728412628,
0.30776479840278625,
-0.5068942308425903,
0.7539880275726318,
-0.5952204465866089,
0.41599327325820923,
-0.0020526358857750893,
-0.0422745943069458,
-0.9746492505073547,
-0.13261152803897858,
0.014977667480707169,
-0.46580177545547485,
0.5685313940048218,
0.09111239016056061,
-0.5099933743476868,
-0.1589272916316986,
-0.3388485014438629,
0.2935575544834137,
0.7878734469413757,
-0.3740537762641907,
0.33444109559059143,
0.07119984924793243,
-0.015726573765277863,
-0.42502740025520325,
-0.7763011455535889,
0.1495388299226761,
0.14295995235443115,
-0.2981325387954712,
-0.017421765252947807,
-0.16477985680103302,
-0.487196147441864,
-0.19935978949069977,
-0.1502166986465454,
-0.2189563661813736,
0.16062752902507782,
0.30458930134773254,
0.2556508183479309,
0.018355097621679306,
0.020112181082367897,
-0.032867226749658585,
-0.019374905154109,
-0.2578382194042206,
0.18674467504024506,
0.37261584401130676,
-0.2662985026836395,
-0.6320732235908508,
-0.44950777292251587,
0.3185853958129883,
0.6762311458587646,
-0.460938036441803,
0.4146927297115326,
0.37985697388648987,
-0.37451890110969543,
0.016952242702245712,
-0.6746203899383545,
0.09181463718414307,
-0.34473687410354614,
0.36050206422805786,
-0.5622766613960266,
-0.6168522238731384,
0.3069153428077698,
-0.08581078052520752,
0.02231888473033905,
0.6372676491737366,
0.8190116286277771,
0.058419547975063324,
0.9653092622756958,
0.479755163192749,
-0.2340622842311859,
0.1772226095199585,
-0.16822078824043274,
0.29070404171943665,
-0.8318665623664856,
0.036500025540590286,
-0.4391794502735138,
-0.18357209861278534,
-0.2952045500278473,
-0.5210148096084595,
0.24601972103118896,
0.32224100828170776,
-0.0689723864197731,
0.36799922585487366,
-0.3107817769050598,
0.6586667895317078,
0.24605046212673187,
-0.12122422456741333,
0.5853222012519836,
-0.056987885385751724,
-0.21032848954200745,
-0.041455402970314026,
-0.3244393765926361,
-0.6693735718727112,
1.249833345413208,
0.20928752422332764,
0.6211915016174316,
-0.13192297518253326,
0.600264847278595,
0.33927392959594727,
0.7158992290496826,
-1.0559927225112915,
0.47185948491096497,
-0.020868245512247086,
-0.5367788076400757,
-0.22777745127677917,
-0.3441563844680786,
-0.6921973824501038,
0.34218430519104004,
-0.1595415323972702,
-0.3795430660247803,
-0.13079102337360382,
-0.2350742071866989,
-0.24506497383117676,
-0.015282958745956421,
-0.8271039724349976,
0.5401105880737305,
-0.3406185209751129,
-0.4330082833766937,
-0.6818950176239014,
-0.3889511227607727,
0.4466792345046997,
-0.4400143623352051,
0.3328082859516144,
0.0123502928763628,
0.03750382363796234,
0.4595930874347687,
-0.007891812361776829,
0.5952786803245544,
-0.0663786455988884,
-0.11538771539926529,
0.34966644644737244,
0.4241204261779785,
0.3154570162296295,
-0.036755844950675964,
-0.49663111567497253,
0.2857808768749237,
0.05250806733965874,
-0.6442515850067139,
-0.629639744758606,
0.8477928638458252,
-0.766913890838623,
-0.5657033920288086,
-0.3761460781097412,
-0.512153685092926,
-0.4128016233444214,
0.1448507010936737,
-0.14263761043548584,
0.12710382044315338,
-0.2797783315181732,
0.07615546137094498,
0.13286946713924408,
-0.28184813261032104,
0.41590118408203125,
0.9115543365478516,
-0.3372221291065216,
-0.21330490708351135,
0.7648162245750427,
-0.06955036520957947,
0.3417913615703583,
0.5056627988815308,
0.16263526678085327,
-0.22979643940925598,
-0.632643461227417,
-0.678655207157135,
0.34960228204727173,
-0.6484092473983765,
-0.28077858686447144,
-0.059492263942956924,
-0.03253544121980667,
-0.32846900820732117,
-0.1387459635734558,
-0.551795244216919,
-0.2437933385372162,
0.1914311647415161,
0.03708765655755997,
-0.04089325666427612,
1.0238269567489624,
0.037852875888347626,
0.1907191127538681,
-0.8147161602973938,
0.08368313312530518,
0.4501643478870392,
0.4055972695350647,
0.10549268871545792,
-0.7292996644973755,
-0.2727712392807007,
0.20663894712924957,
-0.35628339648246765,
-0.5628315806388855,
0.30486539006233215,
0.1986435204744339,
0.3593989908695221,
0.19950194656848907,
-0.23758114874362946,
0.8195409774780273,
-0.7442612648010254,
0.9111460447311401,
0.18293999135494232,
-1.1614748239517212,
0.5752519965171814,
-0.15491226315498352,
0.3722575306892395,
0.7268850207328796,
0.3959091603755951,
-0.5586380362510681,
-0.14652211964130402,
-0.1486104130744934,
-0.5638506412506104,
0.2969304919242859,
0.11665240675210953,
0.25287967920303345,
0.049320288002491,
0.5921096801757812,
0.0959794670343399,
0.09536740928888321,
-0.6274940371513367,
-0.13024365901947021,
0.27483636140823364,
-0.08186456561088562,
-0.42532992362976074,
-0.21773208677768707,
0.2171594202518463,
-0.46084678173065186,
0.6184475421905518,
0.02748912200331688,
0.03560037538409233,
0.22981543838977814,
-0.4423482418060303,
-0.2675589919090271,
0.4351019859313965,
0.5591389536857605,
0.8171618580818176,
-0.3291160762310028,
-0.18771174550056458,
0.4530852735042572,
-0.2656615674495697,
0.381289005279541,
-0.3226509690284729,
-0.28951287269592285,
-0.048477381467819214,
0.4855312705039978,
0.5901008248329163,
0.3009522259235382,
-0.7840908765792847,
0.7121824026107788,
-0.02656641975045204,
0.0459979772567749,
-0.23733827471733093,
-0.17974044382572174,
-0.04357798397541046,
-0.09122654050588608,
0.29050469398498535,
0.013333018869161606,
0.03854944929480553,
-0.5649625062942505,
0.03997248038649559,
0.388876736164093,
-0.6930446028709412,
-0.5214598774909973,
0.5017560124397278,
0.42478519678115845,
-0.3592108488082886,
0.4420284628868103,
-0.44523683190345764,
-0.32515645027160645,
0.2859135866165161,
0.3940573036670685,
0.8582243919372559,
-0.5873837471008301,
-0.043134987354278564,
0.5009394884109497,
0.3470490872859955,
-0.1341942697763443,
0.0754166841506958,
-0.14366820454597473,
-0.4061986804008484,
-0.9415241479873657,
-0.9639216065406799,
-0.7282471656799316,
0.19651293754577637,
-0.5952600836753845,
0.6073558926582336,
-0.24666652083396912,
0.2886841297149658,
-0.18233594298362732,
0.20180954039096832,
-0.8212194442749023,
0.1868639439344406,
0.22081729769706726,
1.067401647567749,
-1.0211676359176636,
1.0830427408218384,
0.8878752589225769,
-0.6127890348434448,
-0.7881129384040833,
-0.09411990642547607,
-0.28949499130249023,
-0.7746862769126892,
0.9835396409034729,
0.021717680618166924,
-0.22700004279613495,
0.006049341056495905,
-0.3753473460674286,
-0.8135502934455872,
0.8263850808143616,
0.4784936308860779,
-0.6244380474090576,
0.14146336913108826,
0.1363026201725006,
0.8736355900764465,
-0.28527116775512695,
0.587944746017456,
0.5275688171386719,
0.4565567374229431,
-0.04088534787297249,
-1.4345707893371582,
-0.22131389379501343,
-0.324016273021698,
0.04562441632151604,
0.05232759565114975,
-0.7449520826339722,
0.478530615568161,
0.06972381472587585,
-0.06659337133169174,
0.2034056931734085,
0.4331277310848236,
-0.14310576021671295,
0.09449452906847,
0.320798397064209,
0.5531163811683655,
0.33259645104408264,
0.16310448944568634,
1.4484686851501465,
-0.32087162137031555,
0.4208846390247345,
1.1226954460144043,
-0.6525599956512451,
1.3952834606170654,
0.6645509600639343,
-0.41179290413856506,
0.29571250081062317,
0.42382776737213135,
0.22155404090881348,
0.363116592168808,
0.3282482326030731,
0.01971081644296646,
-0.44179627299308777,
-0.23412971198558807,
-0.10282321274280548,
0.7422381043434143,
0.2614195644855499,
-0.10196402668952942,
-0.38325169682502747,
0.011699602007865906,
-0.10950066149234772,
0.43437790870666504,
-0.41528037190437317,
0.5830932259559631,
0.2161998450756073,
-0.6735743880271912,
0.9479573965072632,
0.2397138774394989,
0.8648874163627625,
-0.4575575888156891,
-0.15508754551410675,
-0.4681366980075836,
0.14281179010868073,
-0.08569053560495377,
-0.509604811668396,
0.5435910224914551,
0.29780206084251404,
-0.1331826001405716,
-0.29888811707496643,
0.45655354857444763,
-0.46219056844711304,
-0.5010422468185425,
0.41798126697540283,
0.659027099609375,
0.4252959191799164,
0.011339033022522926,
-0.4394315481185913,
-0.02590157464146614,
-0.06614304333925247,
-0.22442686557769775,
0.46640124917030334,
-0.0976024940609932,
-0.28078770637512207,
0.6544526219367981,
0.39887934923171997,
0.24216093122959137,
-0.14122721552848816,
-0.05727089196443558,
0.21542510390281677,
-0.5970972180366516,
-0.024660896509885788,
-0.7882164716720581,
0.12236589938402176,
0.0803770199418068,
-0.2471228539943695,
0.8100185394287109,
0.628210723400116,
0.9744124412536621,
-0.28802791237831116,
0.6358391642570496,
-0.025436963886022568,
0.7335920333862305,
-0.2052117884159088,
0.7823203802108765,
-0.6257085800170898,
0.09222695231437683,
-0.14594195783138275,
-1.158735990524292,
-0.46113157272338867,
0.6230071187019348,
-0.5575019121170044,
-0.2939131259918213,
0.6508625149726868,
0.6294467449188232,
-0.07757127285003662,
-0.3964273929595947,
0.7122906446456909,
0.24241651594638824,
0.23737257719039917,
0.6966084241867065,
0.8502419590950012,
-0.8587462306022644,
0.5079560875892639,
-0.127323716878891,
-0.22550944983959198,
-0.049230411648750305,
-0.8600000143051147,
-0.7762343287467957,
-0.46878087520599365,
-0.3360055983066559,
-0.014709293842315674,
-0.08923085033893585,
1.078939437866211,
0.5783385634422302,
-0.9804623126983643,
-0.5561895966529846,
0.17615006864070892,
-0.0032201081048697233,
-0.03194143995642662,
-0.1651766449213028,
0.35660815238952637,
-0.45960840582847595,
-1.0885380506515503,
0.6016570329666138,
0.41593223810195923,
-0.2707180678844452,
-0.4539712071418762,
-0.2044619470834732,
-0.2645803987979889,
0.10912209749221802,
0.8451288342475891,
0.0246196947991848,
-0.8147072196006775,
-0.3529722988605499,
-0.10662414878606796,
-0.3278754651546478,
0.073836550116539,
0.44998031854629517,
-0.8369233012199402,
0.5227729678153992,
0.41875430941581726,
0.8358136415481567,
0.4004572033882141,
-0.13675853610038757,
0.6148948073387146,
-0.551793098449707,
0.3326229155063629,
0.1333768665790558,
0.15869328379631042,
0.5514822602272034,
-0.08502029627561569,
0.7633062601089478,
0.09558996558189392,
-0.4798988699913025,
-0.8615074157714844,
0.05486629530787468,
-0.864535927772522,
0.028830837458372116,
1.308236837387085,
-0.29711613059043884,
-0.29204484820365906,
0.29251599311828613,
-0.17244009673595428,
0.1564483791589737,
-0.226999431848526,
0.8130300045013428,
0.7291987538337708,
0.1338881254196167,
0.241945281624794,
-0.6223710775375366,
0.19952116906642914,
0.709541916847229,
-0.6936308741569519,
-0.22119711339473724,
0.3247721195220947,
0.3304412364959717,
0.3734617829322815,
0.36479452252388,
-0.25650477409362793,
0.33780637383461,
-0.21932768821716309,
0.28586167097091675,
0.10063288360834122,
0.005123950075358152,
-0.816493034362793,
-0.1264246255159378,
0.5277084708213806,
-0.036391694098711014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02507v1
|
Lifelong Event Detection with Embedding Space Separation and Compaction
| 2024-04-03T06:51:49 | 2024-04-03T06:51:49 |
Chengwei Qin, Ruirui Chen, Ruochen Zhao, Wenhan Xia, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To mitigate forgetting, existing lifelong event detection methods typically
maintain a memory module and replay the stored memory data during the learning
of a new task. However, the simple combination of memory data and new-task
samples can still result in substantial forgetting of previously acquired
knowledge, which may occur due to the potential overlap between the feature
distribution of new data and the previously learned embedding space. Moreover,
the model suffers from overfitting on the few memory samples rather than
effectively remembering learned patterns. To address the challenges of
forgetting and overfitting, we propose a novel method based on embedding space
separation and compaction. Our method alleviates forgetting of previously
learned tasks by forcing the feature distribution of new data away from the
previous embedding space. It also mitigates overfitting by a memory calibration
mechanism that encourages memory data to be close to its prototype to enhance
intra-class compactness. In addition, the learnable parameters of the new task
are initialized by drawing upon acquired knowledge from the previously learned
task to facilitate forward knowledge transfer. With extensive experiments, we
demonstrate that our method can significantly outperform previous
state-of-the-art approaches.
|
[
-0.24337942898273468,
-0.6115432381629944,
0.7660082578659058,
-0.2888087332248688,
-0.4336656630039215,
0.04351213574409485,
-0.10721336305141449,
-0.40614649653434753,
0.2751612663269043,
0.15858955681324005,
-0.48090091347694397,
-0.42499473690986633,
-0.5039876699447632,
-0.6027305126190186,
-0.09566844999790192,
0.9385500550270081,
-0.30307435989379883,
-0.3710804581642151,
-0.5266302227973938,
-0.28953829407691956,
-0.815900444984436,
-0.488209068775177,
-0.8673958778381348,
-0.47452157735824585,
0.2300829291343689,
0.4798487424850464,
0.10386809706687927,
0.4772067070007324,
0.18559463322162628,
0.14588943123817444,
0.024905648082494736,
0.4738616943359375,
-0.4670967161655426,
0.1479543298482895,
-0.17502065002918243,
-0.5240406394004822,
-0.1859952062368393,
-0.16698937118053436,
0.8558945655822754,
0.508647620677948,
-0.14162933826446533,
-0.07035991549491882,
0.15779593586921692,
0.4710327088832855,
-1.2000401020050049,
0.07819259911775589,
-0.5475364327430725,
0.29800575971603394,
-0.3023667335510254,
-0.5662563443183899,
-0.4621744155883789,
-0.18838824331760406,
-0.08044090121984482,
-0.5472102165222168,
0.25747135281562805,
-0.23939232528209686,
0.5619980692863464,
0.32554081082344055,
-0.3062230944633484,
-0.37012118101119995,
-0.7383794188499451,
0.89640212059021,
-0.3575891852378845,
0.46377578377723694,
0.4156174957752228,
0.3537634015083313,
-0.10691805183887482,
-0.45811617374420166,
-0.692760169506073,
0.03587435930967331,
0.17135760188102722,
0.29251739382743835,
-0.052614934742450714,
-0.4014439880847931,
0.02922474965453148,
-0.008995939046144485,
-0.5970555543899536,
-0.009831806644797325,
-0.19942161440849304,
-0.12984083592891693,
0.40848058462142944,
0.266708642244339,
0.25655597448349,
0.10806059092283249,
-0.5094151496887207,
0.025055207312107086,
-0.7880042791366577,
-0.3101392388343811,
-0.043395522981882095,
-0.25963661074638367,
0.17654240131378174,
0.11109428852796555,
0.08471754938364029,
0.20281833410263062,
0.04160267114639282,
-0.15864230692386627,
0.15982060134410858,
-0.2919762432575226,
-0.2019834965467453,
0.05756860598921776,
0.09604378044605255,
0.2691456973552704,
0.13008169829845428,
-0.3080068528652191,
-0.03451673313975334,
0.06291545927524567,
0.31367626786231995,
-0.569649338722229,
-0.4102556109428406,
0.056974366307258606,
-0.5007559061050415,
0.2518538236618042,
-0.027355102822184563,
-0.5628581047058105,
-0.33355745673179626,
-0.2878867983818054,
0.7211721539497375,
-0.5400378704071045,
-0.07724415510892868,
0.22384829819202423,
-0.2336539328098297,
0.06661361455917358,
0.5350721478462219,
-0.6567918658256531,
0.07527116686105728,
0.5320577621459961,
0.9342197775840759,
-0.38916388154029846,
-0.11726536601781845,
-0.7510485649108887,
0.587235689163208,
0.03123627044260502,
0.9832021594047546,
-0.4260675311088562,
-0.36749911308288574,
-0.09064248204231262,
-0.02341732569038868,
-0.293331116437912,
-0.6931502223014832,
0.18677127361297607,
-0.498854398727417,
-0.00029687071219086647,
-0.11184920370578766,
-1.0393691062927246,
-0.15928761661052704,
0.32544898986816406,
-0.41004836559295654,
0.8463429808616638,
-0.044151823967695236,
-0.43222177028656006,
0.9018914103507996,
-0.1882249265909195,
-0.2794657051563263,
0.1828961819410324,
-0.36961477994918823,
-0.8946685194969177,
-0.11582744866609573,
0.16588923335075378,
0.6359856128692627,
0.4206814765930176,
0.2550814747810364,
-0.614547848701477,
-0.36569666862487793,
-0.1437397450208664,
-0.1474628895521164,
0.2846395671367645,
-0.0478316992521286,
-0.2786788046360016,
-0.15915212035179138,
-0.6973809003829956,
-0.1863395720720291,
0.15539757907390594,
-0.4280494153499603,
-0.537219226360321,
0.259825199842453,
-0.08267811685800552,
0.1928728073835373,
0.2338210940361023,
-0.8566277027130127,
0.2946379780769348,
-0.08230146020650864,
0.2659115791320801,
0.5495365262031555,
0.46403372287750244,
0.5520431399345398,
-0.6949480175971985,
0.2697150707244873,
0.4170474708080292,
0.30856043100357056,
-0.428826242685318,
-0.4301958680152893,
-0.611937940120697,
-0.0817611813545227,
-0.36282461881637573,
0.7134901285171509,
-0.30554890632629395,
0.9373389482498169,
-0.05822836980223656,
-0.1841576248407364,
0.34274378418922424,
0.3197673261165619,
0.03386783227324486,
0.1771545708179474,
0.48798757791519165,
-0.49344122409820557,
-0.8168447613716125,
-0.26087287068367004,
0.149824857711792,
0.005675196181982756,
0.07814023643732071,
0.113039530813694,
0.8527365922927856,
-0.3934652805328369,
0.8375336527824402,
-0.7846297025680542,
-0.7359656691551208,
0.040138211101293564,
-0.04643843322992325,
-0.16627627611160278,
0.9328363537788391,
0.5274344682693481,
-0.8067476749420166,
-0.14844828844070435,
0.13699506223201752,
-0.6806262135505676,
0.4341905117034912,
-0.5736998915672302,
-0.0011032598558813334,
0.323150634765625,
0.8288928270339966,
-0.39037925004959106,
0.8249161839485168,
0.13431571424007416,
-0.4757092595100403,
0.33093857765197754,
-0.4080030620098114,
-0.041843436658382416,
-0.9272975921630859,
0.04257464036345482,
-0.4235117733478546,
-0.4133910834789276,
-0.20837163925170898,
-0.22115975618362427,
0.4175158739089966,
0.17284007370471954,
-0.2505257725715637,
0.7249082326889038,
-0.3313335180282593,
0.04544900357723236,
-0.5451292991638184,
0.3016491234302521,
0.1793043464422226,
0.3500697910785675,
0.1321164071559906,
0.1926826685667038,
0.15925677120685577,
-0.5048041939735413,
0.12628613412380219,
0.5103713274002075,
-0.14271388947963715,
0.6340371370315552,
-0.08127110451459885,
0.006454134359955788,
-0.25503280758857727,
0.6683876514434814,
-1.2163429260253906,
0.14452244341373444,
0.06772985309362411,
-0.5374872088432312,
0.7270498871803284,
-0.25611016154289246,
-0.4978455901145935,
-0.23809845745563507,
-0.22807127237319946,
0.6528977751731873,
0.4997505247592926,
-0.6961858868598938,
0.6915662884712219,
0.30712729692459106,
-0.060895051807165146,
-0.21484151482582092,
-0.6878333687782288,
-0.1565931737422943,
-0.45049166679382324,
-0.5560899376869202,
0.3809904158115387,
-0.18790124356746674,
0.42779871821403503,
0.048191167414188385,
-0.4890289306640625,
-0.32549914717674255,
-0.0017067076405510306,
0.40870290994644165,
0.24733659625053406,
-0.08085867017507553,
0.4157316982746124,
0.13718627393245697,
-0.21713519096374512,
-0.1875390261411667,
-0.8574690222740173,
0.4355420768260956,
0.31957903504371643,
-0.6380331516265869,
-0.3857572674751282,
0.5467545986175537,
0.46662724018096924,
0.006140565499663353,
1.0635474920272827,
0.9262505769729614,
-0.8336051106452942,
-0.13625702261924744,
-0.9240479469299316,
-0.247789204120636,
-0.407493531703949,
0.16325798630714417,
-0.02814095839858055,
-0.8677492141723633,
0.6805513501167297,
-0.379193514585495,
0.2734622657299042,
0.2170100212097168,
0.2242065668106079,
-0.3606399893760681,
0.6187610030174255,
0.703813374042511,
-0.19325633347034454,
0.7382595539093018,
-0.2630142569541931,
0.05980359762907028,
-1.1214115619659424,
-0.36606094241142273,
-0.25534236431121826,
-0.3651682138442993,
0.2637125849723816,
-0.5456811785697937,
0.209201380610466,
0.4696194529533386,
-0.24765489995479584,
0.2418821156024933,
-0.2578919529914856,
0.5116385817527771,
0.2054583579301834,
0.45351171493530273,
0.17024822533130646,
-0.31876078248023987,
-0.06805059313774109,
-0.20116055011749268,
-0.7149110436439514,
-0.09544653445482254,
1.1733695268630981,
0.09719369560480118,
0.5363432168960571,
-0.05451488867402077,
1.1247785091400146,
0.3325388431549072,
0.30461233854293823,
-0.46566876769065857,
0.11201488226652145,
-0.14417700469493866,
-0.3740968406200409,
-0.2535382807254791,
-0.29931220412254333,
-0.9714178442955017,
-0.007321327459067106,
-0.09701146185398102,
-1.1683740615844727,
0.4874926507472992,
0.30046406388282776,
-0.6234990358352661,
0.7179312109947205,
-0.5374451279640198,
0.5248669385910034,
0.23196914792060852,
-0.21768586337566376,
-0.39596372842788696,
-0.34110504388809204,
0.2154516875743866,
-0.37490853667259216,
0.11728618294000626,
0.03866201266646385,
0.015794141218066216,
0.9258481860160828,
0.12129752337932587,
1.058950662612915,
-0.3464777171611786,
0.09423418343067169,
0.22942101955413818,
0.11049263924360275,
0.9088689088821411,
0.3874633014202118,
0.2232159674167633,
-0.3851681351661682,
-0.0854584202170372,
-0.4393443465232849,
-0.565645158290863,
0.5657332539558411,
-0.3666328191757202,
-0.16389842331409454,
0.07537192851305008,
-0.5655855536460876,
0.0690334215760231,
0.07477021217346191,
0.20254671573638916,
0.5236158967018127,
-0.17361634969711304,
0.2544899582862854,
0.9650282859802246,
-0.28199660778045654,
0.4587614834308624,
0.5385821461677551,
0.166612446308136,
-0.3108845353126526,
0.9672689437866211,
0.12639634311199188,
0.2466428428888321,
0.5620579719543457,
0.04513789713382721,
-0.18761636316776276,
-0.6762495040893555,
-0.1455739140510559,
0.17538964748382568,
-0.9034591913223267,
-0.4063883125782013,
-1.0105373859405518,
-0.05184202641248703,
-0.365432471036911,
-0.6991503238677979,
-0.412793904542923,
-0.2520623207092285,
-0.37269023060798645,
0.10480555146932602,
-0.0035371407866477966,
0.3436848521232605,
-0.36670631170272827,
0.28110358119010925,
-1.0898414850234985,
0.2729519307613373,
0.2066613733768463,
0.06981788575649261,
0.017750728875398636,
-0.6557120084762573,
-0.29079458117485046,
-0.41115954518318176,
-0.5955803990364075,
-0.5912483930587769,
0.33801186084747314,
0.44868364930152893,
0.7992715835571289,
0.7283613085746765,
-0.11786913871765137,
0.6132974028587341,
-0.36121970415115356,
0.519787073135376,
0.1707092821598053,
-0.9241340756416321,
0.90011066198349,
-0.0007655823137611151,
0.48009586334228516,
0.388382226228714,
0.32342907786369324,
-0.4516773223876953,
-0.2951892018318176,
-0.8269966244697571,
-0.8688646554946899,
0.2876580059528351,
-0.02506249211728573,
-0.26873505115509033,
-0.07744163274765015,
0.5745144486427307,
0.0397103987634182,
0.026595525443553925,
-0.5244636535644531,
-0.07563770562410355,
0.30775144696235657,
0.11199577152729034,
-0.1559172421693802,
-0.16582058370113373,
0.02661963365972042,
-0.2374567985534668,
0.47798100113868713,
-0.1706698089838028,
0.5010035037994385,
0.2100224643945694,
-0.25756320357322693,
-0.35701701045036316,
-0.07263758033514023,
0.5507493615150452,
0.5781556367874146,
-0.27603986859321594,
-0.045014288276433945,
0.550438642501831,
-0.5940116047859192,
0.20421673357486725,
0.014645623974502087,
-0.02292201854288578,
-0.20091308653354645,
0.4671698212623596,
0.3848893940448761,
0.7137935161590576,
-0.37514087557792664,
0.5561928749084473,
0.1239137202501297,
-0.11557164043188095,
-0.5383195877075195,
0.33603134751319885,
0.062286075204610825,
0.5970199108123779,
0.38430917263031006,
0.3840828835964203,
0.06922277808189392,
-0.5329240560531616,
0.9127370715141296,
0.35067829489707947,
-0.32850512862205505,
-0.058043669909238815,
0.5372263789176941,
-0.10529043525457382,
0.1774357259273529,
0.6391250491142273,
-0.1659536361694336,
-0.5382965803146362,
0.7971441745758057,
0.6950345635414124,
0.5698055028915405,
-0.38148823380470276,
-0.08885745704174042,
0.442520409822464,
0.2394486665725708,
0.015109831467270851,
0.39678654074668884,
-0.5164276957511902,
-0.9337881803512573,
-0.4512988328933716,
-0.5899587869644165,
-0.17508713901042938,
0.15107125043869019,
-0.7831303477287292,
-0.11510951071977615,
-0.4139869511127472,
0.0464768223464489,
-0.15831898152828217,
0.18294477462768555,
-0.6892246603965759,
0.26281365752220154,
0.4298660159111023,
0.8868517875671387,
-1.0262371301651,
0.9554290175437927,
0.4827291667461395,
-0.07682782411575317,
-0.2392609417438507,
-0.03322397917509079,
0.1414453238248825,
-0.6420698165893555,
0.47487932443618774,
0.4579237699508667,
0.31539782881736755,
-0.04531833156943321,
-0.16164769232273102,
-0.9175225496292114,
1.2454769611358643,
0.06306333839893341,
-0.6404576301574707,
-0.07863566279411316,
-0.5142897963523865,
0.009619941003620625,
-0.1933426409959793,
-0.0988752543926239,
0.7194030284881592,
0.5515190958976746,
0.3692174553871155,
-0.5453112125396729,
0.016804449260234833,
0.06884421408176422,
-0.5012152194976807,
0.8638337850570679,
-0.31423065066337585,
0.5134700536727905,
-0.363928884267807,
-0.5003116726875305,
0.15751375257968903,
0.692787766456604,
0.43474483489990234,
0.6797499656677246,
0.557533860206604,
0.7539882063865662,
0.925403892993927,
-0.10903278738260269,
0.6550343036651611,
0.209377259016037,
0.5754228234291077,
1.2735610008239746,
-0.3491082489490509,
0.8239455223083496,
0.4474126100540161,
-0.05801607295870781,
0.36978670954704285,
0.2344813048839569,
0.0064737568609416485,
0.6333665251731873,
0.1175251230597496,
-0.5037872791290283,
-0.510541558265686,
0.38815411925315857,
-0.32033106684684753,
0.254204660654068,
0.8948608040809631,
0.0017822483787313104,
-0.6584311723709106,
0.6813141703605652,
-0.20640844106674194,
-0.22498680651187897,
-0.15888386964797974,
0.6598650813102722,
0.0917695090174675,
-0.42413341999053955,
0.19595739245414734,
-0.4810176193714142,
0.7349979877471924,
-0.6457213163375854,
-0.19762340188026428,
-0.1800895482301712,
0.5671331286430359,
-0.15306679904460907,
-0.8625900745391846,
0.7132508754730225,
-0.616551399230957,
-0.1112016886472702,
-0.006277121603488922,
0.7810123562812805,
-0.4533047378063202,
0.09800343215465546,
0.5289791226387024,
0.24915394186973572,
0.2373259961605072,
-0.20420481264591217,
-0.31342461705207825,
0.10297156870365143,
0.0059860022738575935,
-0.0913059189915657,
0.40530937910079956,
0.38333824276924133,
-0.06715946644544601,
0.6401819586753845,
0.5950424075126648,
0.012840968556702137,
0.22064778208732605,
-0.22970443964004517,
0.8057869672775269,
-0.6287199258804321,
-0.8985339999198914,
-0.57813560962677,
0.44472402334213257,
0.008486473001539707,
-0.22543415427207947,
0.34772172570228577,
0.4359024465084076,
0.9140929579734802,
0.096293143928051,
0.5802823901176453,
-0.022148551419377327,
0.05862068757414818,
-0.6156890392303467,
0.48303380608558655,
-0.5559213161468506,
-0.02532193996012211,
-0.2020498812198639,
-0.5200576186180115,
-0.5517310500144958,
0.5188762545585632,
-0.23207052052021027,
-0.03679464012384415,
0.7730220556259155,
0.3602190613746643,
-0.2837325632572174,
-0.058148495852947235,
0.6826354265213013,
-0.186016246676445,
0.5153069496154785,
1.20148766040802,
0.830597996711731,
-0.4132307767868042,
0.4039120376110077,
-0.003411832032725215,
-0.3462468683719635,
-0.41958844661712646,
-0.8499122262001038,
-0.8366339206695557,
-0.7892869710922241,
-0.5947953462600708,
0.001559967058710754,
0.1253233104944229,
0.429377019405365,
1.104357361793518,
-0.8905144333839417,
0.4978784918785095,
-0.256002277135849,
-0.07596408575773239,
-0.27074432373046875,
-0.2452833354473114,
0.48872458934783936,
-0.3744361400604248,
-0.32481423020362854,
0.5176397562026978,
0.5510197877883911,
0.23636268079280853,
-0.05378052219748497,
0.09941061586141586,
-0.3081417679786682,
-0.1684267669916153,
0.5185319781303406,
0.44271495938301086,
-0.23240061104297638,
-0.5299099087715149,
-0.6521996259689331,
0.20822937786579132,
0.05435451120138168,
0.9522584080696106,
-0.9201593399047852,
0.35866281390190125,
0.32076382637023926,
0.7622660398483276,
0.7954172492027283,
-0.46479088068008423,
0.32443034648895264,
-1.039800763130188,
0.29110032320022583,
0.17005982995033264,
0.6178829669952393,
0.024113371968269348,
-1.0267308950424194,
0.239127516746521,
0.3075777292251587,
-0.7694962620735168,
-0.5312504768371582,
0.17541559040546417,
-0.8913401365280151,
-0.33227914571762085,
0.5768157839775085,
-0.3834599554538727,
-0.06708025932312012,
-0.4983750283718109,
0.03235162794589996,
0.42829298973083496,
-0.14909610152244568,
0.8495389223098755,
0.39781877398490906,
-0.30226975679397583,
-0.22973749041557312,
-0.496185839176178,
0.3087146580219269,
0.32438182830810547,
-0.9228853583335876,
-0.16351360082626343,
0.40868067741394043,
0.46772149205207825,
0.2931700348854065,
0.5378063321113586,
-0.14400121569633484,
0.8200478553771973,
0.10452922433614731,
-0.016418447718024254,
-0.014650339260697365,
-0.8280104398727417,
-0.23155610263347626,
0.26235431432724,
-0.44761964678764343,
-0.39348092675209045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02505v1
|
Dynamic Demonstration Retrieval and Cognitive Understanding for Emotional Support Conversation
| 2024-04-03T06:47:15 | 2024-04-03T06:47:15 |
Zhe Xu, Daoyuan Chen, Jiayi Kuang, Zihao Yi, Yaliang Li, Ying Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Emotional Support Conversation (ESC) systems are pivotal in providing
empathetic interactions, aiding users through negative emotional states by
understanding and addressing their unique experiences. In this paper, we tackle
two key challenges in ESC: enhancing contextually relevant and empathetic
response generation through dynamic demonstration retrieval, and advancing
cognitive understanding to grasp implicit mental states comprehensively. We
introduce Dynamic Demonstration Retrieval and Cognitive-Aspect Situation
Understanding (\ourwork), a novel approach that synergizes these elements to
improve the quality of support provided in ESCs. By leveraging in-context
learning and persona information, we introduce an innovative retrieval
mechanism that selects informative and personalized demonstration pairs. We
also propose a cognitive understanding module that utilizes four cognitive
relationships from the ATOMIC knowledge source to deepen situational awareness
of help-seekers' mental states. Our supportive decoder integrates information
from diverse knowledge sources, underpinning response generation that is both
empathetic and cognitively aware. The effectiveness of \ourwork is demonstrated
through extensive automatic and human evaluations, revealing substantial
improvements over numerous state-of-the-art models, with up to 13.79\%
enhancement in overall performance of ten metrics. Our codes are available for
public access to facilitate further research and development.
|
[
-0.4236147999763489,
-0.9653507471084595,
1.070374846458435,
0.25957077741622925,
-0.014921121299266815,
0.2170378565788269,
-0.15155372023582458,
-0.41085320711135864,
0.29563695192337036,
0.33275845646858215,
-1.0176808834075928,
-0.3937739133834839,
-0.41294893622398376,
0.07305078953504562,
-0.2764764726161957,
0.829036295413971,
-0.09700105339288712,
-0.20428350567817688,
-0.4890076518058777,
-0.18232448399066925,
-0.652563750743866,
-0.3990587294101715,
-0.8379325270652771,
-0.442212849855423,
0.38713890314102173,
0.6690090298652649,
0.20700672268867493,
0.0032860776409506798,
0.2935791313648224,
0.42737725377082825,
-0.1605452597141266,
0.2003401815891266,
-0.1706317663192749,
0.7174255847930908,
-0.025896575301885605,
-0.5441758632659912,
-0.45671698451042175,
-0.3547341227531433,
0.12592187523841858,
0.27845725417137146,
-0.7787669897079468,
-0.07870234549045563,
0.0857400968670845,
0.4580949544906616,
-0.7717305421829224,
0.4113443195819855,
-0.6233469843864441,
0.294499009847641,
0.1977861225605011,
0.11308570206165314,
-0.5624248385429382,
-0.11100973188877106,
0.08882398903369904,
-0.8350955843925476,
-0.25284820795059204,
-0.02627769485116005,
0.5893493890762329,
0.3566763401031494,
-0.7957296371459961,
-0.4764295518398285,
-0.6841464638710022,
0.7159107327461243,
-0.26806309819221497,
0.19010256230831146,
0.5406346321105957,
0.6693124771118164,
0.0664835050702095,
-0.8748595118522644,
-0.49675124883651733,
-0.2283625304698944,
0.06319991499185562,
0.5998600125312805,
-0.5276957750320435,
0.26017501950263977,
0.3332810401916504,
0.2096327543258667,
-0.22845709323883057,
-0.17547522485256195,
0.08431624621152878,
-0.2459016591310501,
0.4989088475704193,
0.4252861738204956,
0.28842610120773315,
-0.30778780579566956,
-0.08309394866228104,
-0.008310914970934391,
-0.09680406749248505,
0.02755787968635559,
-0.03968506306409836,
-0.025413040071725845,
-0.03967606648802757,
0.4305317997932434,
-0.3046075105667114,
0.11460240930318832,
0.3706977367401123,
0.4500267803668976,
0.05704955384135246,
-0.08024570345878601,
-0.22637984156608582,
0.04718354344367981,
0.1128774955868721,
0.17153741419315338,
-0.15021711587905884,
0.07763838022947311,
0.020712923258543015,
0.23956939578056335,
0.556452214717865,
-0.6684837937355042,
0.12028317898511887,
0.2495422065258026,
-0.5947387218475342,
-0.056409891694784164,
0.0005489772884175181,
-0.6497610807418823,
-0.5876520276069641,
-0.5542771220207214,
0.16324228048324585,
-0.5756536722183228,
-0.4514767825603485,
0.0379478745162487,
-0.0930209532380104,
0.17482510209083557,
0.6082722544670105,
-0.4612542688846588,
0.47948068380355835,
0.6944265365600586,
0.7387028932571411,
0.191933274269104,
0.2289334237575531,
-0.44020625948905945,
0.16216352581977844,
0.27617961168289185,
0.7514957189559937,
-0.5439897179603577,
-0.2759644389152527,
0.094277024269104,
0.14997036755084991,
0.12929069995880127,
-0.49951159954071045,
0.7192180752754211,
-0.32399776577949524,
0.07344933599233627,
-0.5239414572715759,
-0.33058181405067444,
-0.13832394778728485,
0.46467122435569763,
-0.3737163543701172,
0.87746262550354,
-0.12554669380187988,
-0.5076886415481567,
0.09749401360750198,
-0.6895684599876404,
-0.40889307856559753,
0.1482246369123459,
-0.3285581171512604,
-0.09563420712947845,
0.251695454120636,
0.08483957499265671,
0.5410694479942322,
-0.020406458526849747,
0.0038367407396435738,
-0.41510826349258423,
-0.23148860037326813,
0.32204878330230713,
-0.2114088088274002,
0.24609406292438507,
0.4672265350818634,
-0.5586158633232117,
-0.03266127035021782,
-0.7687680125236511,
0.019726090133190155,
0.2094525694847107,
-0.016086185351014137,
-0.45174071192741394,
0.1442704051733017,
-0.0767948105931282,
0.4417745769023895,
0.14806906878948212,
-0.6545624136924744,
-0.19365794956684113,
-0.04423447325825691,
0.4306407868862152,
0.7432635426521301,
0.10248584300279617,
0.34040728211402893,
0.059467848390340805,
0.6011731028556824,
-0.01380227506160736,
0.36346495151519775,
-0.3232361078262329,
-0.26462793350219727,
-0.5861630439758301,
-0.21139423549175262,
-0.6685754060745239,
0.5115298628807068,
-1.0941773653030396,
0.3907005786895752,
0.1915798932313919,
-0.3222290873527527,
-0.440710186958313,
-0.2725447416305542,
0.6107017993927002,
0.7461472153663635,
0.5130269527435303,
-0.25261390209198,
-0.5595813393592834,
-1.013797640800476,
-0.27743157744407654,
-0.31435588002204895,
-0.07553644478321075,
0.6039949655532837,
0.23500384390354156,
-0.12063620984554291,
0.5630423426628113,
-0.5944267511367798,
-0.1620805859565735,
-0.2174156755208969,
0.39696791768074036,
-0.1443747878074646,
0.1496894359588623,
0.3361544609069824,
-0.7447534203529358,
-0.4185766279697418,
-0.09019526839256287,
-0.7968761324882507,
-0.22774983942508698,
-0.07464106380939484,
-0.3444669544696808,
0.150201678276062,
0.3258983790874481,
-0.3673843443393707,
0.4900728762149811,
0.368932843208313,
-0.7770631313323975,
0.13288137316703796,
-0.22836342453956604,
0.48102134466171265,
-1.078840732574463,
-0.2911873459815979,
-0.08481860160827637,
-0.2549414336681366,
-0.4342496395111084,
-0.17187254130840302,
0.054318610578775406,
-0.11301617324352264,
-0.4565574526786804,
0.14335553348064423,
-0.5788522362709045,
0.006293925456702709,
-0.24673408269882202,
0.5540221929550171,
-0.0694301575422287,
0.36349722743034363,
0.036507368087768555,
0.28533700108528137,
0.44485902786254883,
-0.3325802683830261,
0.5776652097702026,
0.6036487817764282,
-0.023122744634747505,
1.4045236110687256,
-0.4455625116825104,
0.3466622531414032,
-0.27551233768463135,
0.5534874796867371,
-0.7710656523704529,
0.003063380951061845,
0.12376473098993301,
-0.2076733410358429,
0.20957273244857788,
-0.0843341052532196,
-0.15066877007484436,
-0.47476574778556824,
-0.2093057930469513,
0.10284595191478729,
0.5152754783630371,
-0.4835461974143982,
1.0164092779159546,
0.27418088912963867,
-0.2896919250488281,
-0.45856422185897827,
-0.9215357899665833,
-0.024415887892246246,
-0.036465682089328766,
-0.7579210996627808,
0.4742916226387024,
-0.20796328783035278,
-0.3672703206539154,
-0.02779032103717327,
-0.37159958481788635,
0.04317701980471611,
0.0966290757060051,
0.620593249797821,
-0.10618222504854202,
-0.027003904804587364,
0.39623042941093445,
0.37490352988243103,
-0.1607692986726761,
0.2792776823043823,
0.11900101602077484,
0.4468062222003937,
-0.4818175435066223,
-0.7138400077819824,
-0.6000451445579529,
0.7143956422805786,
0.551261305809021,
-0.16754476726055145,
0.9758205413818359,
0.6940757036209106,
-0.7298958897590637,
0.03170900046825409,
-0.7023302316665649,
-0.5038095116615295,
-0.48915955424308777,
0.6115002036094666,
-0.434687077999115,
-0.6534124612808228,
0.6873210072517395,
-0.18520833551883698,
-0.1755802035331726,
0.008001853711903095,
0.4219818711280823,
-0.2418704628944397,
1.418770432472229,
0.440794438123703,
0.39326879382133484,
0.9121517539024353,
-0.06046612188220024,
0.10878855735063553,
-0.9584050178527832,
-0.6913654208183289,
-0.3033098876476288,
-0.26026079058647156,
-0.05477804318070412,
-0.13662555813789368,
0.28845372796058655,
-0.24916651844978333,
-0.38357993960380554,
0.20758871734142303,
-0.4174492359161377,
-0.016460055485367775,
-0.043093450367450714,
0.7325306534767151,
0.30289769172668457,
-0.13953585922718048,
-0.05317942798137665,
-0.41225171089172363,
-0.16892309486865997,
-0.6781730651855469,
0.5090147852897644,
0.26396170258522034,
0.4346271753311157,
0.4284009039402008,
0.44389989972114563,
0.2957930266857147,
0.3212929666042328,
-0.7732465267181396,
0.7701997756958008,
0.13078512251377106,
-0.35382401943206787,
0.08718626946210861,
-0.3313097357749939,
-0.8382092714309692,
0.1772676259279251,
-0.4167337715625763,
-0.9011276960372925,
-0.07510446012020111,
0.19258271157741547,
-0.33533811569213867,
-0.1451067179441452,
-0.8656653761863708,
0.5559098124504089,
-0.453337699174881,
-0.4395350217819214,
-0.8918822407722473,
-0.5488483905792236,
-0.09864342212677002,
0.16649143397808075,
0.2175675481557846,
-0.13886089622974396,
-0.02081839181482792,
0.6409655809402466,
-0.3278631567955017,
0.722461462020874,
-0.42636069655418396,
0.019468802958726883,
0.30499884486198425,
0.20214396715164185,
0.6537983417510986,
0.10560743510723114,
-0.34987983107566833,
-0.5862292051315308,
-0.016566520556807518,
-0.5102981925010681,
-1.148606538772583,
0.7371754050254822,
-0.49928879737854004,
-0.6601439118385315,
-0.028226589784026146,
-0.25384780764579773,
-0.30269256234169006,
-0.1440407633781433,
-0.27307847142219543,
0.38861361145973206,
-0.4172433316707611,
0.41258811950683594,
0.6113014221191406,
-0.30096110701560974,
0.3608150780200958,
0.8261979818344116,
0.26230835914611816,
-0.010946189053356647,
0.48203036189079285,
-0.11689543724060059,
0.09081897139549255,
0.32490599155426025,
-0.04266618192195892,
-0.20545093715190887,
-0.11275364458560944,
0.12855727970600128,
0.20744037628173828,
-0.930514395236969,
-0.17593401670455933,
-0.9039480686187744,
0.24083860218524933,
-0.20741954445838928,
-0.2490442842245102,
-0.49184074997901917,
-0.3500562310218811,
-0.1439877450466156,
-0.6755934953689575,
0.5233339667320251,
0.8529709577560425,
0.1627035290002823,
0.18881666660308838,
-0.7368002533912659,
-0.07409320026636124,
0.4018591642379761,
-0.009299072436988354,
0.19116143882274628,
-0.23611053824424744,
-0.3178982436656952,
-0.0437714159488678,
-0.7806779742240906,
-1.363039255142212,
0.1943654716014862,
0.011961855925619602,
0.6848021745681763,
0.5111048221588135,
0.3691045939922333,
0.729623019695282,
-0.20228290557861328,
0.9184715747833252,
0.18816488981246948,
-1.2878671884536743,
1.0409389734268188,
-0.12862926721572876,
-0.1115705817937851,
0.5450247526168823,
0.19134271144866943,
-0.6951836943626404,
-0.2734643518924713,
-0.9907193779945374,
-1.1819016933441162,
0.8286224007606506,
0.5582298040390015,
0.17000830173492432,
-0.0603097528219223,
0.5492284297943115,
-0.31557023525238037,
0.23277655243873596,
-0.2438361644744873,
-0.24809987843036652,
-0.06889213621616364,
-0.6706804037094116,
0.42998793721199036,
-0.05097486078739166,
-0.32051002979278564,
0.0013008223613724113,
0.5519380569458008,
-0.24447529017925262,
0.6838884353637695,
0.1597059667110443,
-0.0011069650063291192,
-0.12905935943126678,
0.33471933007240295,
0.28217610716819763,
0.29882940649986267,
0.08488751947879791,
0.09583833813667297,
0.6956984996795654,
-0.3423214852809906,
-0.11339453607797623,
0.12969912588596344,
0.6993732452392578,
-0.4854052662849426,
0.09287875145673752,
0.7881934642791748,
0.29910627007484436,
-0.7180099487304688,
0.5244065523147583,
-0.4318622350692749,
0.2920109033584595,
-0.6136964559555054,
0.06602133065462112,
0.05763241648674011,
0.696326494216919,
0.31788355112075806,
-0.14702938497066498,
0.2750132083892822,
-0.7908749580383301,
0.3645656406879425,
0.33541762828826904,
-0.5232051610946655,
-0.5306269526481628,
0.39473143219947815,
0.3722718060016632,
-0.37851256132125854,
0.800602376461029,
0.001828930457122624,
-0.5372593998908997,
0.9844376444816589,
0.6148064136505127,
0.6150110363960266,
-0.24230840802192688,
0.44705891609191895,
0.11600753664970398,
-0.22403374314308167,
0.04021337628364563,
0.5431446433067322,
-0.49849653244018555,
-0.6716055870056152,
0.046328213065862656,
0.19267220795154572,
-0.60411536693573,
-0.420713871717453,
-1.2903310060501099,
0.17205137014389038,
-0.24514365196228027,
-0.3627088963985443,
-0.4295651316642761,
0.16663813591003418,
-0.7693184018135071,
0.17592671513557434,
0.39715972542762756,
0.7302499413490295,
-0.9708356261253357,
0.39737623929977417,
1.1050007343292236,
-0.5458695292472839,
-0.9274193048477173,
-0.14298909902572632,
0.29948532581329346,
-0.8374733924865723,
0.41948625445365906,
0.030582701787352562,
-0.34415674209594727,
-0.17956911027431488,
-0.3772004246711731,
-0.5015254616737366,
1.7412357330322266,
0.49116477370262146,
-0.3862920105457306,
0.11423170566558838,
-0.48829230666160583,
0.8026711940765381,
-0.5321040749549866,
1.0635617971420288,
0.38526201248168945,
0.6735425591468811,
0.15057747066020966,
-0.5157418847084045,
0.5071704983711243,
-0.37187281250953674,
-0.04582149162888527,
-0.006867825984954834,
-1.0640720129013062,
0.21381285786628723,
-0.026947708800435066,
-0.31903213262557983,
0.13358676433563232,
0.7235174179077148,
0.4516019821166992,
0.7326171398162842,
0.6970386505126953,
0.2185789942741394,
1.0398279428482056,
-0.31100356578826904,
0.9715235829353333,
-0.05956768989562988,
0.3316877782344818,
0.8576276898384094,
-0.32474303245544434,
0.8806503415107727,
0.6848458051681519,
0.04852040857076645,
0.9659480452537537,
0.548101544380188,
0.5360291004180908,
0.3755476176738739,
0.06541341543197632,
-0.6550789475440979,
-0.4718407988548279,
-0.5622921586036682,
-0.12641483545303345,
0.17358794808387756,
0.7013909816741943,
-0.27596208453178406,
0.16779319941997528,
0.2644961476325989,
0.10774850845336914,
0.31675681471824646,
-0.1151740550994873,
0.78354412317276,
0.38163289427757263,
-0.5642447471618652,
0.07418332993984222,
-0.2507303059101105,
0.49377360939979553,
-0.584114134311676,
-0.15321457386016846,
-0.2761327922344208,
0.18135160207748413,
-0.5440739989280701,
-0.8360214829444885,
0.5421317219734192,
0.13252434134483337,
-0.12386458367109299,
-0.48489487171173096,
0.7529589533805847,
-0.2590866982936859,
0.10804729163646698,
0.7402928471565247,
0.47849899530410767,
0.03615665063261986,
-0.30435940623283386,
-0.7950335144996643,
-0.006218741647899151,
-0.15156330168247223,
-0.49164000153541565,
0.2486051321029663,
0.7081055641174316,
0.1610369235277176,
0.7989470362663269,
0.2593691945075989,
-0.2791979908943176,
-0.34636595845222473,
0.24860277771949768,
0.9532232284545898,
-0.5419228672981262,
-0.4806802272796631,
-0.5662000179290771,
0.7989832162857056,
-0.4162873923778534,
0.06114158406853676,
0.4765515625476837,
-0.044857803732156754,
0.4218160808086395,
0.09267264604568481,
0.5184548497200012,
-0.27129411697387695,
0.11771247535943985,
-0.4162081480026245,
0.4238415062427521,
-0.6934833526611328,
0.32111281156539917,
-0.3980903625488281,
-0.5274344086647034,
0.011456295847892761,
0.7330666780471802,
-0.37468451261520386,
0.07959267497062683,
0.8277876377105713,
0.47207775712013245,
0.0824744701385498,
0.45670607686042786,
0.2219727784395218,
0.42335638403892517,
0.5724979043006897,
0.8761698603630066,
1.252299427986145,
-0.17388597130775452,
0.7751865983009338,
-0.20528796315193176,
-0.42205026745796204,
0.006141632795333862,
-0.9334685206413269,
-0.5782512426376343,
-0.6735679507255554,
-0.5105049014091492,
-0.3890426754951477,
0.2508000433444977,
1.180415391921997,
0.932793915271759,
-0.5864768028259277,
0.20587550103664398,
-0.23548999428749084,
-0.052573636174201965,
-0.33075201511383057,
-0.3183917999267578,
-0.05977405980229378,
-0.1102849692106247,
-0.6783987879753113,
0.4822826087474823,
0.19860108196735382,
-0.027195816859602928,
0.040656451135873795,
-0.2390638142824173,
0.09431245177984238,
0.13716699182987213,
0.6807790994644165,
0.23702456057071686,
-0.5561508536338806,
-0.3752501308917999,
0.15777583420276642,
0.09637504070997238,
-0.11109929531812668,
0.9743393659591675,
-0.7889311909675598,
0.27070188522338867,
0.3394966125488281,
0.7290514707565308,
0.6811822652816772,
0.09608090668916702,
0.7429178357124329,
-0.7255412340164185,
0.08191008865833282,
0.3092220425605774,
0.5592849850654602,
0.2951834797859192,
-0.9330703616142273,
0.37504950165748596,
0.1458040326833725,
-0.4814588129520416,
-0.5407296419143677,
0.654895007610321,
-1.0637449026107788,
0.01879062131047249,
0.9027101993560791,
-0.6370717287063599,
0.05889575928449631,
-0.1738615483045578,
-0.5556785464286804,
0.6448049545288086,
-0.8914890885353088,
0.7068431973457336,
0.6587949991226196,
-0.7108948826789856,
-0.42910847067832947,
-0.22096922993659973,
0.08776681125164032,
0.853652834892273,
-1.0243998765945435,
-0.04762367904186249,
0.4167000651359558,
0.042808908969163895,
0.07132800668478012,
0.49291953444480896,
-0.03572003170847893,
-0.037256911396980286,
-0.3436902165412903,
0.0258330088108778,
-0.056096598505973816,
-0.09632599353790283,
-0.3381727933883667,
0.020701497793197632,
-0.14442557096481323,
-0.11842707544565201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02491v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02491v4
|
Measuring Social Norms of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T05:58:57 | 2024-05-22T05:23:45 |
Ye Yuan, Kexin Tang, Jianhao Shen, Ming Zhang, Chenguang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We present a new challenge to examine whether large language models
understand social norms. In contrast to existing datasets, our dataset requires
a fundamental understanding of social norms to solve. Our dataset features the
largest set of social norm skills, consisting of 402 skills and 12,383
questions covering a wide set of social norms ranging from opinions and
arguments to culture and laws. We design our dataset according to the K-12
curriculum. This enables the direct comparison of the social understanding of
large language models to humans, more specifically, elementary students. While
prior work generates nearly random accuracy on our benchmark, recent large
language models such as GPT3.5-Turbo and LLaMA2-Chat are able to improve the
performance significantly, only slightly below human performance. We then
propose a multi-agent framework based on large language models to improve the
models' ability to understand social norms. This method further improves large
language models to be on par with humans. Given the increasing adoption of
large language models in real-world applications, our finding is particularly
important and presents a unique direction for future improvements.
|
[
-0.251133531332016,
-0.8983495831489563,
0.673401415348053,
0.2882864475250244,
-0.030975090339779854,
0.16789495944976807,
-0.5477617979049683,
-0.5572296380996704,
-0.16441915929317474,
0.27425065636634827,
-0.30332085490226746,
-0.4914037883281708,
-0.8354294300079346,
0.07451342046260834,
-0.29693910479545593,
0.5755714774131775,
0.30433380603790283,
0.03791893273591995,
-0.19592176377773285,
-0.03138633444905281,
-0.28272151947021484,
-0.42067331075668335,
-0.7939802408218384,
-0.3417671024799347,
0.4400148391723633,
0.6543487906455994,
0.8772441744804382,
0.6281163692474365,
0.3684082329273224,
0.33775264024734497,
-0.2537558972835541,
0.19486378133296967,
-0.8119176030158997,
-0.0642625093460083,
-0.03701953589916229,
-0.027377288788557053,
-0.6868378520011902,
0.06184562295675278,
0.8666563630104065,
0.7866223454475403,
0.0166335366666317,
0.3407614231109619,
0.14703181385993958,
0.4841105043888092,
-0.2864294946193695,
0.6639865636825562,
-0.5874567627906799,
-0.29962673783302307,
-0.07956937700510025,
0.12325088679790497,
-0.37648072838783264,
-0.39209648966789246,
-0.1120644062757492,
-0.43031370639801025,
0.01804181933403015,
-0.0922081246972084,
0.7712888121604919,
-0.1937337964773178,
-0.8714731931686401,
-0.10725650191307068,
-0.5440611839294434,
0.7389429211616516,
-0.5863462090492249,
0.6054579615592957,
0.5878221392631531,
0.3091786503791809,
-0.2347581833600998,
-0.44377291202545166,
-0.544143557548523,
-0.32035136222839355,
0.2438005954027176,
-0.24766230583190918,
-0.10005208849906921,
-0.035953402519226074,
0.21965712308883667,
0.19767512381076813,
-0.5436913371086121,
0.2725163996219635,
-0.6242259740829468,
-0.023647300899028778,
1.001198649406433,
0.31695887446403503,
-0.021688558161258698,
-0.04284103959798813,
0.07884253561496735,
-0.1957913637161255,
-0.5043938755989075,
0.18193845450878143,
0.5476439595222473,
0.4005710184574127,
-0.18351730704307556,
0.4857933521270752,
-0.1132044866681099,
0.3120453953742981,
-0.11889813840389252,
-0.2292289137840271,
0.293948233127594,
-0.3797680139541626,
-0.01731577329337597,
-0.3480040431022644,
0.5045741200447083,
0.6983655691146851,
1.1388779878616333,
-0.011727207340300083,
-0.06773953139781952,
0.055905554443597794,
-0.08443799614906311,
-0.7432259321212769,
0.11465147137641907,
-0.08580353856086731,
-0.3024926781654358,
-0.2895420491695404,
-0.27281972765922546,
-0.6270840764045715,
-0.7264930605888367,
-0.4583980441093445,
0.20230713486671448,
-0.31361106038093567,
-0.5955033302307129,
0.43787503242492676,
-0.022524097934365273,
0.6089080572128296,
0.48279011249542236,
-0.7491440176963806,
0.5465481281280518,
0.8760290145874023,
0.8489350080490112,
0.08936119079589844,
-0.4629531502723694,
-0.2648310661315918,
-0.08342154324054718,
-0.5546711683273315,
0.577959418296814,
-0.6921368837356567,
-0.37114185094833374,
0.10465919226408005,
0.1672920137643814,
-0.005982046015560627,
-0.3827887177467346,
0.2804138958454132,
-0.4983641803264618,
-0.5020190477371216,
-0.4464556574821472,
-0.6577990055084229,
-0.01795237883925438,
0.32457298040390015,
-0.4961947500705719,
1.003002405166626,
-0.035785410553216934,
-0.19368483126163483,
0.42694103717803955,
-0.6727215647697449,
-0.45798060297966003,
0.10176591575145721,
-0.03970286250114441,
-0.2532149851322174,
-0.051642805337905884,
0.12453096359968185,
0.888129472732544,
-0.36328819394111633,
0.5528979897499084,
-0.6737657189369202,
-0.439787894487381,
0.30870190262794495,
-0.2709888517856598,
0.9901697039604187,
0.1296434998512268,
0.030035551637411118,
0.04357995092868805,
-0.5505250096321106,
-0.15429651737213135,
0.42142894864082336,
-0.21689195930957794,
-0.2300480306148529,
-0.020887238904833794,
0.2364518940448761,
0.09178342670202255,
0.2771342992782593,
-0.42561373114585876,
0.08184883743524551,
0.10953422635793686,
0.5382688641548157,
1.2252929210662842,
-0.1153884008526802,
0.402895987033844,
-0.3981386125087738,
0.2893548905849457,
-0.30255213379859924,
0.2719017565250397,
0.3809186518192291,
-0.6101096868515015,
-0.2929728031158447,
-0.24036633968353271,
-0.062377430498600006,
0.20339283347129822,
-0.06880555301904678,
0.4868263006210327,
-0.364914208650589,
-0.7374997735023499,
-0.275052011013031,
0.35556572675704956,
0.07411102950572968,
-0.016999555751681328,
0.09408631920814514,
-0.23802044987678528,
-0.4901101291179657,
-0.6986682415008545,
-0.19597546756267548,
-0.4087318778038025,
0.1249537318944931,
0.4500846564769745,
0.7468798160552979,
-0.371118426322937,
0.6464717388153076,
-0.338137686252594,
-0.02632802166044712,
-0.45792365074157715,
-0.10095039010047913,
0.007323847152292728,
0.2669447660446167,
0.4897204339504242,
-0.6336110830307007,
-0.5669366717338562,
0.08005742728710175,
-0.5454363822937012,
0.022297117859125137,
0.30225348472595215,
0.006726357154548168,
-0.0419294647872448,
0.6911853551864624,
-0.24909017980098724,
0.2956213355064392,
0.5043296217918396,
-0.593117892742157,
0.6058546900749207,
-0.09668190777301788,
0.26907458901405334,
-1.0169646739959717,
-0.1439950168132782,
0.3566462993621826,
-0.26184624433517456,
-0.6107945442199707,
-0.15753938257694244,
0.15930145978927612,
-0.1076078936457634,
-0.3037724792957306,
0.7134438157081604,
-0.3504232168197632,
-0.25333714485168457,
0.09502658247947693,
0.1614360362291336,
-0.07498698681592941,
0.3601113259792328,
-0.08299089223146439,
0.7580065131187439,
0.575289249420166,
-0.5011152029037476,
0.42640921473503113,
0.07946595549583435,
-0.5356580018997192,
0.7683588266372681,
-0.9502533078193665,
0.27618342638015747,
-0.36401915550231934,
0.248386412858963,
-1.0715898275375366,
-0.5411294102668762,
-0.21078360080718994,
-0.6925352215766907,
-0.09908369183540344,
-0.23138739168643951,
-0.7072505950927734,
-0.179599329829216,
-0.28377988934516907,
0.12759022414684296,
0.5379944443702698,
-0.19879427552223206,
0.44385942816734314,
0.826258659362793,
-0.1585393249988556,
-0.5216678380966187,
-0.1338106244802475,
0.09636353701353073,
-0.16969415545463562,
-0.951052725315094,
-0.33497729897499084,
-0.13539014756679535,
-0.7443702816963196,
-0.17082476615905762,
0.15200215578079224,
-0.340697318315506,
0.37653928995132446,
0.15767887234687805,
0.13360239565372467,
-0.3268229365348816,
0.275989294052124,
-0.05611554533243179,
0.2201077789068222,
0.20711873471736908,
0.025737110525369644,
0.6835322380065918,
-0.5466064214706421,
-0.23649989068508148,
-0.18591760098934174,
0.1791902780532837,
0.9177024960517883,
-0.1607176661491394,
0.891657292842865,
0.5244855284690857,
-0.5090506672859192,
0.05671584606170654,
-0.6861092448234558,
-0.12214463949203491,
-0.5022103786468506,
0.6228888630867004,
-0.4177198112010956,
-1.1521055698394775,
0.7039439678192139,
0.3012169897556305,
0.1538718044757843,
0.22277741134166718,
0.5815346837043762,
0.1797848641872406,
1.1299256086349487,
0.650420606136322,
-0.16737470030784607,
0.3610132932662964,
-0.05531822144985199,
0.22499166429042816,
-0.5341395735740662,
-0.04418144375085831,
-0.6915705800056458,
-0.031021274626255035,
-0.33490678668022156,
-0.3428339660167694,
0.29398107528686523,
-0.32120025157928467,
-0.5653935074806213,
0.23163267970085144,
-0.011554510332643986,
0.6931445598602295,
0.20749953389167786,
-0.022759558632969856,
0.500381350517273,
-0.06931371986865997,
0.2815742790699005,
0.22470608353614807,
-0.2940244674682617,
-0.8040997982025146,
1.1111425161361694,
0.5434733629226685,
0.7319138646125793,
0.22403885424137115,
0.3461395800113678,
0.37592804431915283,
0.2616859972476959,
-0.8514679670333862,
0.6693498492240906,
0.022026149556040764,
-0.8893545866012573,
-0.7098879218101501,
-0.537817120552063,
-0.9292112588882446,
0.1886630654335022,
-0.22338201105594635,
-0.7627485394477844,
0.14086663722991943,
-0.013742650859057903,
-0.10685776174068451,
0.3822220265865326,
-0.8352569937705994,
1.0060222148895264,
0.2775822877883911,
-0.30328696966171265,
-0.3001011312007904,
-0.5943509340286255,
0.251136839389801,
0.038585104048252106,
0.5510283708572388,
-0.5341898202896118,
0.16254247725009918,
0.775658905506134,
-0.09122790396213531,
1.0707727670669556,
-0.07716113328933716,
-0.29223909974098206,
0.24730588495731354,
-0.07293955236673355,
0.5172342658042908,
0.19754385948181152,
-0.2086997628211975,
0.062053486704826355,
0.19535987079143524,
-0.5894456505775452,
-0.22366955876350403,
0.5847591161727905,
-1.074697732925415,
-0.30639320611953735,
-0.26537707448005676,
-0.6001836657524109,
-0.13741406798362732,
-0.08270750194787979,
-0.13957266509532928,
0.38375741243362427,
-0.5287714004516602,
0.5537571907043457,
0.5321752429008484,
0.06665327399969101,
0.080951988697052,
0.6807817816734314,
-0.06907819956541061,
0.04635903239250183,
0.60756915807724,
0.46675416827201843,
0.45085692405700684,
-0.26222679018974304,
0.2223864495754242,
-0.38358423113822937,
-0.2448519915342331,
-0.2450050562620163,
0.4033001959323883,
-0.7193257212638855,
0.10675732791423798,
-0.7663071751594543,
-0.1698087453842163,
-1.0202078819274902,
-0.3490842878818512,
-0.35235464572906494,
0.13057120144367218,
-0.03794079273939133,
-0.07740745693445206,
0.6319159865379333,
0.9353452920913696,
-0.30966615676879883,
0.24504688382148743,
-0.6572394967079163,
0.12172062695026398,
0.5742790699005127,
0.43900546431541443,
0.23181912302970886,
-0.7592723369598389,
-0.1401626318693161,
-0.019134555011987686,
0.06614185869693756,
-0.8161588311195374,
0.09428448230028152,
0.2898225784301758,
0.3437892496585846,
0.3764691948890686,
0.004278583452105522,
0.6199176907539368,
-0.5586762428283691,
0.5234121084213257,
-0.211187943816185,
-1.0636423826217651,
0.2176894098520279,
-0.40209442377090454,
-0.1299305558204651,
0.4210970401763916,
0.3754889965057373,
-0.9978238940238953,
-0.4339718818664551,
-0.7391202449798584,
-0.514308512210846,
0.37745875120162964,
0.07576271891593933,
0.3974197804927826,
-0.15327702462673187,
0.31967803835868835,
-0.09052184224128723,
0.02227797731757164,
-0.675581693649292,
-0.00441059609875083,
0.11500722169876099,
-0.17058472335338593,
-0.5740419626235962,
-0.3424200713634491,
0.21246662735939026,
-0.3996429443359375,
0.6172441840171814,
-0.1913135051727295,
-0.21152068674564362,
-0.23710297048091888,
-0.00977406743913889,
-0.2987380921840668,
0.44472527503967285,
0.39026039838790894,
1.0477478504180908,
-0.13334983587265015,
0.1814105361700058,
0.3751221299171448,
-0.7285652756690979,
0.2810363471508026,
-0.08845183253288269,
0.2509467601776123,
-0.4577938914299011,
0.28435540199279785,
0.32661157846450806,
0.1051134318113327,
-0.6451922655105591,
0.6867018342018127,
-0.2501137852668762,
-0.34821510314941406,
-0.5814359188079834,
-0.009721259586513042,
0.23506489396095276,
0.37175875902175903,
0.24981360137462616,
-0.19492435455322266,
-0.11500026285648346,
-0.6209964752197266,
0.20362168550491333,
0.37960106134414673,
-0.3885840177536011,
-0.45639628171920776,
0.21458925306797028,
0.08584246784448624,
-0.22942610085010529,
0.45675477385520935,
-0.310960978269577,
-0.2684783637523651,
0.8749055862426758,
0.5013943910598755,
0.39031246304512024,
-0.33600035309791565,
0.3682253658771515,
0.40170764923095703,
0.7403052449226379,
-0.33398935198783875,
0.34297677874565125,
0.21399424970149994,
-1.1091153621673584,
-0.7053705453872681,
-0.40177029371261597,
-0.47119274735450745,
0.30342647433280945,
-0.5146888494491577,
0.3080255091190338,
-0.37981292605400085,
-0.0263772364705801,
0.16891679167747498,
0.30968356132507324,
-0.6602710485458374,
-0.024764183908700943,
-0.10308288037776947,
0.6802356839179993,
-1.3945680856704712,
0.85145503282547,
0.7569660544395447,
-0.20919586718082428,
-0.8265184760093689,
-0.23001162707805634,
0.17640990018844604,
-0.9580762386322021,
0.44867458939552307,
0.07241358608007431,
-0.1949523240327835,
0.1403144896030426,
-0.9928973913192749,
-0.6203752160072327,
0.7270439267158508,
0.22027422487735748,
-0.25490567088127136,
0.14343461394309998,
-0.021863089874386787,
0.522780179977417,
-0.3287985622882843,
-0.023398110643029213,
0.6910022497177124,
0.6528810858726501,
-0.005857269279658794,
-0.9428401589393616,
-0.043704986572265625,
-0.39275068044662476,
-0.12189333140850067,
0.0001257467083632946,
-0.5771849751472473,
0.8949398398399353,
-0.1628645956516266,
-0.10581117123365402,
-0.14300480484962463,
0.6862208843231201,
0.1839187741279602,
0.43252313137054443,
0.6941823959350586,
0.15155483782291412,
0.7897552847862244,
0.09499156475067139,
0.6336246132850647,
-0.024327769875526428,
0.4679114520549774,
0.8611445426940918,
-0.5876652002334595,
0.6220361590385437,
0.17799484729766846,
-0.2456783652305603,
-0.062474146485328674,
0.573412299156189,
0.2692740261554718,
-0.20590439438819885,
0.3777230381965637,
-0.16208234429359436,
-0.6500869393348694,
-0.29941314458847046,
-0.29924213886260986,
0.5024417042732239,
0.4841548800468445,
0.035473331809043884,
-0.10796628147363663,
-0.14424164593219757,
0.38346871733665466,
0.2826882600784302,
-0.3739529848098755,
0.6884584426879883,
-0.037089649587869644,
-0.255776047706604,
0.4213251769542694,
-0.022629264742136,
0.4241846203804016,
-0.3247002065181732,
-0.0723608136177063,
-0.2029457539319992,
0.19439512491226196,
0.054452188313007355,
-1.0464729070663452,
0.12924815714359283,
0.09641668945550919,
0.14593812823295593,
-0.00893798004835844,
0.651496171951294,
-0.34723636507987976,
-0.44217783212661743,
0.3640715181827545,
0.6504948735237122,
0.3541664481163025,
-0.06284362077713013,
-0.27121973037719727,
0.21735629439353943,
-0.2962857186794281,
0.008797990158200264,
0.1665482074022293,
0.7852683663368225,
-0.19366440176963806,
0.5587857961654663,
0.5496081709861755,
0.024452878162264824,
0.1261039674282074,
0.10781652480363846,
0.752156138420105,
-0.38862499594688416,
-0.2843863070011139,
-0.8611310124397278,
0.28107017278671265,
-0.37422120571136475,
-0.427129328250885,
0.7099122405052185,
0.36650601029396057,
0.8119233846664429,
0.09980923682451248,
0.6599452495574951,
-0.05781262367963791,
0.4274497330188751,
-0.1135723814368248,
0.6685686111450195,
-0.4878765642642975,
-0.08233797550201416,
-0.4167076647281647,
-0.7101085186004639,
-0.25121942162513733,
0.8483263254165649,
-0.5976005792617798,
0.05444726347923279,
0.30433398485183716,
1.0216668844223022,
-0.14146991074085236,
0.013665969483554363,
0.6447436809539795,
0.2759999632835388,
0.4548294246196747,
0.3872112035751343,
0.9295610785484314,
-0.15080727636814117,
0.33675944805145264,
0.11602848768234253,
-0.5318278074264526,
-0.23947012424468994,
-0.7311943173408508,
-1.2256873846054077,
-0.8391230702400208,
-0.16655895113945007,
-0.437808632850647,
0.26373523473739624,
1.215268850326538,
0.7168839573860168,
-0.4205285906791687,
-0.6364100575447083,
0.32773590087890625,
0.2915150821208954,
-0.21376948058605194,
-0.22257351875305176,
-0.00501996511593461,
-0.43865618109703064,
-0.5759092569351196,
0.2634715437889099,
0.04780593141913414,
-0.03736655414104462,
-0.2914947271347046,
-0.2391531616449356,
-0.32282862067222595,
0.3169822096824646,
0.7557363510131836,
0.1509561687707901,
-0.3282521367073059,
-0.7836635708808899,
0.23306268453598022,
-0.2259267270565033,
0.02752302773296833,
0.6357244253158569,
-0.002685056533664465,
-0.03546585142612457,
0.407517671585083,
0.5098552107810974,
0.2698017954826355,
-0.4075995981693268,
0.34527674317359924,
-0.706387996673584,
0.02530079334974289,
-0.041091691702604294,
0.4694575071334839,
0.30957362055778503,
-0.3005109131336212,
0.49175864458084106,
0.13220767676830292,
-0.7382802367210388,
-0.8166126012802124,
0.34052833914756775,
-0.7709453105926514,
-0.1337234079837799,
1.3012484312057495,
-0.013523466885089874,
-0.27112337946891785,
-0.5953991413116455,
-0.11084891855716705,
0.19547341763973236,
-0.6284391283988953,
0.6912116408348083,
0.8981719017028809,
0.42758509516716003,
-0.24306821823120117,
-0.7791235446929932,
0.33442384004592896,
-0.05983490124344826,
-0.6096410751342773,
0.4328961968421936,
0.6210454106330872,
0.18486490845680237,
-0.022426044568419456,
0.8893650770187378,
-0.2572406530380249,
0.2595728039741516,
-0.28550776839256287,
0.05997254699468613,
0.1380797028541565,
-0.3997487425804138,
-0.1807132214307785,
0.15917660295963287,
0.3189106583595276,
0.28148943185806274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02490v1
|
Enhancing Cross-lingual Sentence Embedding for Low-resource Languages with Word Alignment
| 2024-04-03T05:58:53 | 2024-04-03T05:58:53 |
Zhongtao Miao, Qiyu Wu, Kaiyan Zhao, Zilong Wu, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The field of cross-lingual sentence embeddings has recently experienced
significant advancements, but research concerning low-resource languages has
lagged due to the scarcity of parallel corpora. This paper shows that
cross-lingual word representation in low-resource languages is notably
under-aligned with that in high-resource languages in current models. To
address this, we introduce a novel framework that explicitly aligns words
between English and eight low-resource languages, utilizing off-the-shelf word
alignment models. This framework incorporates three primary training
objectives: aligned word prediction and word translation ranking, along with
the widely used translation ranking. We evaluate our approach through
experiments on the bitext retrieval task, which demonstrate substantial
improvements on sentence embeddings in low-resource languages. In addition, the
competitive performance of the proposed model across a broader range of tasks
in high-resource languages underscores its practicality.
|
[
-0.0034536649473011494,
-0.4625505805015564,
0.5527300834655762,
0.08407291024923325,
-0.3114737570285797,
0.3458401560783386,
-0.31415483355522156,
-0.5040704607963562,
0.5654131770133972,
0.2488085776567459,
-0.27604979276657104,
-0.2701900005340576,
-0.5346717238426208,
0.055489979684352875,
-0.04471362382173538,
0.5809522867202759,
-0.220493882894516,
0.18235109746456146,
-0.2803494930267334,
-0.6060593724250793,
-0.7180489301681519,
-0.10998953133821487,
-0.08682408183813095,
-0.3624459505081177,
0.5431327223777771,
0.41813382506370544,
1.2413889169692993,
0.9371510744094849,
0.4551529884338379,
0.2463335394859314,
0.0724920853972435,
0.12816478312015533,
-0.5241126418113708,
-0.16404090821743011,
-0.4211786687374115,
-0.4433332085609436,
-0.1830957680940628,
-0.24078765511512756,
0.6518420577049255,
0.9858210682868958,
-0.18280594050884247,
-0.1593860536813736,
0.19098061323165894,
0.28896400332450867,
-0.7493820786476135,
-0.16014105081558228,
-0.5039837956428528,
0.112116739153862,
-0.4216352701187134,
-0.02065199241042137,
-0.24757857620716095,
-0.24806596338748932,
0.2490282654762268,
-0.7668036818504333,
-0.3116128444671631,
0.5221371054649353,
0.8196810483932495,
0.13259756565093994,
-0.25791794061660767,
-0.0963943600654602,
-0.23686020076274872,
1.017579436302185,
-0.5278474688529968,
0.7268350720405579,
0.13030309975147247,
-0.0851428359746933,
0.37307795882225037,
-0.3780774474143982,
-0.3198413550853729,
0.04043865576386452,
-0.15869221091270447,
0.0596156120300293,
-0.22413845360279083,
-0.08653558790683746,
-0.12014538794755936,
0.2556547224521637,
-0.7041635513305664,
0.4944324493408203,
-0.09001173824071884,
-0.20733439922332764,
0.4142972528934479,
0.1102178767323494,
0.6130061149597168,
-0.20672079920768738,
-0.7045177221298218,
-0.056517165154218674,
-0.8210457563400269,
-0.07306204736232758,
0.3278842270374298,
0.7258538007736206,
-0.23552176356315613,
0.8693286776542664,
0.20988045632839203,
0.6960195899009705,
-0.09968646615743637,
0.1758488267660141,
0.29591628909111023,
-0.5306735038757324,
-0.021659905090928078,
0.5673053860664368,
0.7205348014831543,
0.45260292291641235,
-0.029632139950990677,
-0.45473480224609375,
-0.34593909978866577,
0.23235377669334412,
0.13902896642684937,
-0.590177595615387,
0.15014414489269257,
-0.07895105332136154,
-0.33262306451797485,
-0.2173725813627243,
-0.20025169849395752,
-0.5904350876808167,
-0.3464181423187256,
-0.08094821125268936,
0.4711398184299469,
-0.5940580368041992,
-0.333912193775177,
0.29157090187072754,
-0.03458359092473984,
0.09498666226863861,
-0.08683593571186066,
-0.9377395510673523,
0.29046353697776794,
0.7556860446929932,
0.9870626330375671,
-0.26714497804641724,
-0.438114732503891,
-0.6825385689735413,
0.2916911244392395,
-0.5292759537696838,
0.5830031633377075,
-0.8745042681694031,
-0.16954998672008514,
0.3465815484523773,
0.04180636256933212,
-0.08898758143186569,
-0.36176368594169617,
0.3971424400806427,
-0.47294238209724426,
0.35418227314949036,
-0.4076548218727112,
-0.6572901606559753,
-0.0008171358495019376,
0.31438663601875305,
-0.5526408553123474,
1.0092440843582153,
0.22745323181152344,
-0.922471284866333,
0.2559255063533783,
-0.4753465950489044,
-0.5017666816711426,
0.20712873339653015,
-0.1939368098974228,
-0.07163688540458679,
0.18526487052440643,
0.23821516335010529,
0.10494748502969742,
-0.48151132464408875,
0.030330276116728783,
-0.2297540158033371,
-0.49923810362815857,
0.03086841106414795,
-0.16315065324306488,
0.8004884719848633,
0.12072305381298065,
-0.25167471170425415,
-0.10888200998306274,
-0.20224972069263458,
0.2767431139945984,
0.10269605368375778,
-0.20232106745243073,
-0.88228440284729,
-0.36399251222610474,
0.2697555422782898,
0.13028712570667267,
0.5600506663322449,
-0.8648973107337952,
0.23334847390651703,
-0.6626331210136414,
0.3505000174045563,
0.36839187145233154,
-0.33960726857185364,
0.884614109992981,
-0.2291286736726761,
0.7570395469665527,
0.1311187893152237,
-0.2307097166776657,
0.07176340371370316,
-0.29935818910598755,
-0.32346153259277344,
-0.029247356578707695,
0.6335484981536865,
0.7587380409240723,
-0.9797644019126892,
0.3920014798641205,
-0.6025062799453735,
-0.20853687822818756,
-1.0374772548675537,
0.44770684838294983,
0.673937976360321,
0.20426024496555328,
0.5490080714225769,
-0.358224481344223,
-0.5375256538391113,
-0.8860620856285095,
-0.29646068811416626,
0.04611746966838837,
0.23623040318489075,
0.1721881628036499,
0.07463391125202179,
-0.2752653658390045,
0.870361328125,
-0.4812413156032562,
-0.2655624747276306,
-0.511907160282135,
0.11103803664445877,
-0.25103309750556946,
0.4613000750541687,
0.47286778688430786,
-0.769505500793457,
-0.48538100719451904,
0.20615628361701965,
-0.4738915264606476,
-0.12704047560691833,
0.16041171550750732,
-0.4141269028186798,
0.306883841753006,
0.5139549970626831,
-0.4282267391681671,
-0.0076654343865811825,
0.8659788370132446,
-0.3882039487361908,
0.0064652832224965096,
-0.16031013429164886,
0.03503938391804695,
-1.3019291162490845,
0.07754381746053696,
0.004341801628470421,
-0.29555413126945496,
-0.21867427229881287,
0.012529193423688412,
0.16660764813423157,
-0.3004220426082611,
-0.5720251202583313,
0.6186162233352661,
-0.640447735786438,
-0.1911451369524002,
-0.26324939727783203,
0.702790379524231,
0.151203453540802,
0.3111978769302368,
0.2452014684677124,
0.6900957822799683,
0.26371827721595764,
-0.012475988827645779,
0.24017581343650818,
0.4620693325996399,
-0.48248860239982605,
0.6231316924095154,
-0.5606071949005127,
-0.21524979174137115,
0.12637408077716827,
-0.1537737101316452,
-0.65444016456604,
0.1784314513206482,
0.009881441481411457,
-0.11213620752096176,
0.34462493658065796,
-0.09373310208320618,
-0.3849680423736572,
-0.0295207928866148,
-0.28310951590538025,
0.7384274005889893,
0.3840247392654419,
-0.4714033901691437,
0.34216248989105225,
0.6832154989242554,
-0.12980329990386963,
-0.8134788870811462,
-0.9366137385368347,
-0.03642010688781738,
-0.14518119394779205,
-0.5764159560203552,
0.7660516500473022,
0.3307279646396637,
-0.22071461379528046,
0.41831278800964355,
-0.004063938278704882,
0.20302791893482208,
-0.18455512821674347,
-0.24458785355091095,
0.3506130874156952,
-0.5177184343338013,
0.23660703003406525,
-0.06444457173347473,
0.055698346346616745,
-0.3859129548072815,
-0.4962572157382965,
0.47467365860939026,
-0.07887157052755356,
-0.3244628608226776,
0.12361371517181396,
0.6189361810684204,
0.1645844578742981,
-0.41371312737464905,
0.6950290203094482,
0.6937727332115173,
-0.5747004151344299,
-0.009120786562561989,
-0.4412805140018463,
0.06905896216630936,
-0.4438062310218811,
0.39317604899406433,
-0.1834927201271057,
-0.918632984161377,
0.254714697599411,
-0.009495844133198261,
-0.0285610631108284,
0.2794024646282196,
0.3188317120075226,
0.12440919131040573,
1.0165897607803345,
1.1294492483139038,
-0.25172924995422363,
0.4895068407058716,
0.08688478171825409,
0.3957099914550781,
-0.8090394139289856,
0.09414076060056686,
-0.26378321647644043,
-0.49619612097740173,
-0.9040665626525879,
-0.5515921115875244,
0.053636372089385986,
0.18112514913082123,
-0.13318626582622528,
0.8284947276115417,
-0.33062613010406494,
0.3686988949775696,
0.46724435687065125,
-0.1985418051481247,
0.023378126323223114,
-0.10363128036260605,
-0.6928255558013916,
-0.2650212347507477,
-0.9730892777442932,
-0.38328248262405396,
0.496112197637558,
0.10574591159820557,
0.8062318563461304,
0.22349980473518372,
0.9191510081291199,
0.13495564460754395,
-0.02947731874883175,
-0.829498291015625,
0.3701605796813965,
-0.4158581495285034,
-0.44012272357940674,
-0.30564379692077637,
-0.35648995637893677,
-1.0321125984191895,
0.2756485939025879,
-0.30290696024894714,
-0.7812594771385193,
0.27230149507522583,
-0.11345533281564713,
-0.5794687271118164,
0.32150033116340637,
-0.8783043622970581,
1.3421120643615723,
-0.49610328674316406,
-0.5839449167251587,
-0.3163129687309265,
-0.41740816831588745,
0.06811100989580154,
0.045701149851083755,
0.27333006262779236,
-0.11040689796209335,
-0.40211182832717896,
0.6187259554862976,
-0.4325944781303406,
0.6952203512191772,
-0.14475572109222412,
-0.19563372433185577,
0.2346252053976059,
0.02140960656106472,
0.41001394391059875,
-0.22380214929580688,
0.04504011198878288,
-0.04047439247369766,
0.16520017385482788,
-0.561465322971344,
-0.46212807297706604,
0.9492633938789368,
-0.5022749304771423,
-0.5119441747665405,
-0.4406316876411438,
-0.7538892030715942,
-0.4383672773838043,
0.30736932158470154,
0.2592218816280365,
0.31282705068588257,
-0.41231682896614075,
0.20145267248153687,
0.40567997097969055,
-0.4229303002357483,
0.46334221959114075,
0.4090655446052551,
-0.19602179527282715,
-0.4986349642276764,
1.0427849292755127,
0.2303062379360199,
0.16730442643165588,
0.78385329246521,
0.25987473130226135,
-0.5448896884918213,
-0.07958268374204636,
-0.5842968225479126,
0.21738311648368835,
-0.4317428767681122,
-0.3208075165748596,
-0.5702077150344849,
0.11355245113372803,
-0.48755279183387756,
-0.49908122420310974,
-0.4762588441371918,
-0.45185282826423645,
0.023999104276299477,
0.03184033930301666,
0.2293819785118103,
0.37244370579719543,
-0.18210163712501526,
0.2190784364938736,
-1.0401556491851807,
0.012662284076213837,
-0.13805153965950012,
0.40189212560653687,
-0.1393916755914688,
-0.3369901776313782,
-0.6605843901634216,
0.03291937708854675,
-0.2395855039358139,
-0.6247893571853638,
0.32474541664123535,
0.12666216492652893,
0.5059593915939331,
0.275340735912323,
0.19124096632003784,
0.8091762065887451,
-0.7324591279029846,
0.6215627789497375,
0.43229401111602783,
-1.041317105293274,
0.3464209735393524,
-0.13707426190376282,
0.47874459624290466,
0.4559310972690582,
0.5625402331352234,
-0.8632807731628418,
-0.26812082529067993,
-0.4350907504558563,
-0.8191429376602173,
0.6108797192573547,
-0.05927570164203644,
0.18188272416591644,
-0.0741143450140953,
-0.25838392972946167,
0.0984678640961647,
0.05157787352800369,
-0.6598962545394897,
0.21918046474456787,
-0.10940995812416077,
-0.6325991749763489,
-0.1158825159072876,
-0.16471320390701294,
-0.16950644552707672,
0.046841397881507874,
0.7068763375282288,
-0.25251469016075134,
0.13202254474163055,
-0.06744695454835892,
-0.47335806488990784,
-0.32285556197166443,
0.3007209002971649,
0.20456254482269287,
0.3971967101097107,
0.010924241505563259,
0.09811587631702423,
0.19675132632255554,
-0.26283136010169983,
0.16037993133068085,
0.43824973702430725,
-0.0653417706489563,
-0.0392443984746933,
0.4355428218841553,
0.6720280647277832,
0.8075191974639893,
-0.7069666385650635,
0.7330820560455322,
0.2513326108455658,
0.2746555805206299,
0.0929637923836708,
-0.36905375123023987,
0.3755249083042145,
0.4393380582332611,
-0.02339901030063629,
-0.09032265096902847,
-0.10800821334123611,
-0.5898211002349854,
0.11370757222175598,
0.5864472985267639,
-0.4648081064224243,
-0.20742428302764893,
0.6796172857284546,
0.30622541904449463,
-0.16528314352035522,
0.4686981737613678,
-0.24295765161514282,
-0.6985476016998291,
0.10691572725772858,
0.6548208594322205,
0.6907880306243896,
-0.0202782079577446,
0.22061334550380707,
0.16375693678855896,
0.36124181747436523,
-0.19637992978096008,
0.45631083846092224,
0.0752706304192543,
-0.9439783096313477,
-0.45643988251686096,
-0.7041274309158325,
-0.4372878074645996,
-0.3596440851688385,
-0.6317849159240723,
0.4297398626804352,
0.08452331274747849,
-0.10640723258256912,
-0.13081562519073486,
0.2424105703830719,
-0.7210996150970459,
-0.07164683192968369,
0.45497840642929077,
0.8546134233474731,
-0.9336084127426147,
0.9057655334472656,
0.8425292372703552,
-0.4453479051589966,
-0.6488045454025269,
0.07607895135879517,
-0.0005018474184907973,
-0.9600037336349487,
0.48079782724380493,
0.194965198636055,
-0.20341332256793976,
0.05017827823758125,
-0.0020121873822063208,
-1.076822280883789,
1.0082324743270874,
0.6479832530021667,
-0.667763888835907,
-0.21420682966709137,
0.3146723210811615,
0.5084869265556335,
-0.4803280532360077,
-0.072248175740242,
0.2469099760055542,
0.2739853262901306,
-0.26338618993759155,
-0.8409764766693115,
0.2033996731042862,
-0.10486466437578201,
0.36668792366981506,
0.3897973299026489,
-0.5298189520835876,
0.36390963196754456,
-0.18348830938339233,
-0.4206761121749878,
0.07368938624858856,
0.725977897644043,
0.05660930275917053,
-0.06894537061452866,
0.5303534865379333,
0.8977229595184326,
0.6085612177848816,
-0.18968795239925385,
0.9245520830154419,
-0.6010175347328186,
0.058636851608753204,
1.0944470167160034,
-0.584669291973114,
1.0552780628204346,
0.5940424799919128,
0.06830092519521713,
0.559386670589447,
0.5993928909301758,
0.09393907338380814,
0.8535690903663635,
-0.03194386884570122,
-0.03812812641263008,
-0.3682883083820343,
-0.5875170826911926,
-0.2596709728240967,
0.574918270111084,
0.18380200862884521,
-0.20832815766334534,
-0.1813945174217224,
0.1607145071029663,
-0.205292746424675,
0.3134891390800476,
-0.3148971498012543,
0.4999181032180786,
0.18262676894664764,
-0.7696160078048706,
0.6142021417617798,
0.06498978286981583,
0.9629660844802856,
-0.3546839654445648,
0.21281257271766663,
-0.1567746102809906,
0.3363909125328064,
-0.11423812806606293,
-0.7347872257232666,
0.2746654748916626,
-0.029313841834664345,
0.044608164578676224,
-0.42643916606903076,
0.5117537975311279,
-1.0121055841445923,
-0.461180716753006,
0.6841017007827759,
0.835568368434906,
-0.11506015807390213,
0.43640586733818054,
-0.6896219253540039,
0.1423483043909073,
-0.2551436722278595,
0.08125082403421402,
0.3891371786594391,
0.6890867352485657,
-0.057313501834869385,
0.19256475567817688,
0.14994187653064728,
0.186525359749794,
-0.08433390408754349,
0.08030873537063599,
0.5758489370346069,
-0.6379615664482117,
-0.747202455997467,
-0.6748251914978027,
0.23972290754318237,
-0.017610866576433182,
-0.34392374753952026,
0.4863867163658142,
0.7918301820755005,
1.1201404333114624,
0.1686733514070511,
0.6444017887115479,
-0.15928761661052704,
0.43027564883232117,
-0.564936101436615,
0.5100098848342896,
-0.9041534662246704,
-0.008091206662356853,
-0.18487131595611572,
-0.9683825373649597,
-0.011623969301581383,
0.3921072483062744,
-0.38240018486976624,
-0.22560489177703857,
0.7778047323226929,
0.6855030655860901,
-0.35877665877342224,
-0.12962090969085693,
0.40846335887908936,
-0.12490881979465485,
-0.21424970030784607,
0.631644070148468,
0.5451271533966064,
-0.4165964722633362,
0.7790235877037048,
-0.41070663928985596,
0.12111107259988785,
-0.1467280238866806,
-0.8957089185714722,
-0.5031570196151733,
-0.5208021998405457,
-0.4095912277698517,
-0.22816626727581024,
0.10931587964296341,
1.1962493658065796,
0.3877663314342499,
-0.6738536357879639,
-0.3040425479412079,
0.1312265247106552,
0.048572130501270294,
-0.4784449338912964,
-0.20282289385795593,
0.245733380317688,
-0.4720500409603119,
-0.8195176720619202,
0.5731788277626038,
0.31072837114334106,
-0.023101642727851868,
-0.23092402517795563,
-0.2144097089767456,
-0.641667902469635,
-0.012783540412783623,
0.43083322048187256,
0.25591912865638733,
-0.6741265058517456,
-0.4113122522830963,
0.2446044236421585,
-0.580928385257721,
0.11864320933818817,
0.7414289116859436,
-0.6514537930488586,
0.34796759486198425,
0.5225926637649536,
1.0564944744110107,
0.042796339839696884,
-0.04091529920697212,
0.9733068346977234,
-1.0490185022354126,
0.18529188632965088,
0.2984102964401245,
0.8091095089912415,
0.7847915291786194,
-0.2629735469818115,
0.4973362684249878,
0.12879343330860138,
-0.25147294998168945,
-0.8594350814819336,
0.1584194004535675,
-0.6511737108230591,
-0.16941234469413757,
1.0797063112258911,
-0.2082490175962448,
-0.21961161494255066,
0.22157424688339233,
0.10583434253931046,
0.3963683247566223,
-0.19277819991111755,
0.5217859745025635,
0.9015479683876038,
0.23206976056098938,
-0.1967533379793167,
-0.2766849994659424,
0.3874050974845886,
0.7154132127761841,
-0.43012580275535583,
0.12851554155349731,
0.3281143009662628,
0.045617226511240005,
0.47826477885246277,
0.30241167545318604,
-0.15119796991348267,
0.16019907593727112,
-0.023453308269381523,
0.062364768236875534,
0.2416660487651825,
0.13397325575351715,
-0.2778894901275635,
-0.07938069850206375,
-0.005309184547513723,
-0.2883793115615845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02489v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02489v1
|
DUQGen: Effective Unsupervised Domain Adaptation of Neural Rankers by Diversifying Synthetic Query Generation
| 2024-04-03T05:50:42 | 2024-04-03T05:50:42 |
Ramraj Chandradevan, Kaustubh D. Dhole, Eugene Agichtein
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
State-of-the-art neural rankers pre-trained on large task-specific training
data such as MS-MARCO, have been shown to exhibit strong performance on various
ranking tasks without domain adaptation, also called zero-shot. However,
zero-shot neural ranking may be sub-optimal, as it does not take advantage of
the target domain information. Unfortunately, acquiring sufficiently large and
high quality target training data to improve a modern neural ranker can be
costly and time-consuming. To address this problem, we propose a new approach
to unsupervised domain adaptation for ranking, DUQGen, which addresses a
critical gap in prior literature, namely how to automatically generate both
effective and diverse synthetic training data to fine tune a modern neural
ranker for a new domain. Specifically, DUQGen produces a more effective
representation of the target domain by identifying clusters of similar
documents; and generates a more diverse training dataset by probabilistic
sampling over the resulting document clusters. Our extensive experiments, over
the standard BEIR collection, demonstrate that DUQGen consistently outperforms
all zero-shot baselines and substantially outperforms the SOTA baselines on 16
out of 18 datasets, for an average of 4% relative improvement across all
datasets. We complement our results with a thorough analysis for more in-depth
understanding of the proposed method's performance and to identify promising
areas for further improvements.
|
[
-0.2756539285182953,
-0.3934439420700073,
0.4033834636211395,
0.012354278936982155,
-0.20036399364471436,
0.4341355860233307,
-0.303416907787323,
0.0020622427109628916,
0.15192924439907074,
0.45475858449935913,
-0.473784476518631,
-0.6683642864227295,
-0.6337248086929321,
-0.03953632339835167,
-0.1900346875190735,
1.0079243183135986,
0.2601027488708496,
0.14534525573253632,
-0.37163716554641724,
-0.2127043604850769,
-0.573808491230011,
-0.4853053092956543,
-0.5743170380592346,
-0.15234917402267456,
0.4817299544811249,
0.4232179820537567,
0.3678823709487915,
0.17862392961978912,
0.4820410907268524,
0.28452715277671814,
0.2771141231060028,
0.4305025637149811,
-1.0325927734375,
0.3219318687915802,
-0.5200429558753967,
-0.46960997581481934,
-0.27848953008651733,
-0.11130638420581818,
0.7564924955368042,
0.8738632202148438,
0.002365338383242488,
-0.04046783968806267,
0.09199526906013489,
1.0314037799835205,
-0.8086576461791992,
-0.2830964922904968,
-1.0519384145736694,
0.033291466534137726,
-0.11548132449388504,
-0.5847119092941284,
-0.402626633644104,
-0.2247484177350998,
-0.043865401297807693,
-0.8483446836471558,
0.4248667061328888,
-0.03984605893492699,
0.44617658853530884,
0.38662824034690857,
-0.6641901731491089,
0.4131389558315277,
-0.7099654674530029,
0.8594136238098145,
-0.3986845016479492,
0.11924787610769272,
-0.0387519896030426,
0.6090008616447449,
-0.3932913839817047,
-0.8529362082481384,
-0.41726958751678467,
0.1647004336118698,
0.11981088668107986,
0.5577628016471863,
-0.26886117458343506,
-0.19131341576576233,
0.13943761587142944,
0.3550828695297241,
-0.8190042972564697,
-0.0006603674846701324,
-0.3714977502822876,
0.06363614648580551,
0.9945166110992432,
0.02891654148697853,
0.1180526539683342,
0.169502392411232,
-0.40049949288368225,
-0.20719315111637115,
-0.6225416660308838,
-0.08052874356508255,
0.19074226915836334,
0.2992197275161743,
0.3650750517845154,
0.2043653279542923,
-0.6272615194320679,
0.6653099060058594,
0.3582843244075775,
0.41094130277633667,
0.3449600338935852,
-0.24929501116275787,
-0.19497619569301605,
0.1299869269132614,
0.5104494094848633,
0.6133634448051453,
0.2888413071632385,
-0.4180661737918854,
-0.014961295761168003,
-0.2798183858394623,
0.5834246873855591,
-0.981214165687561,
-0.43408647179603577,
0.29681938886642456,
-0.33334365487098694,
-0.3399195671081543,
0.0838555097579956,
-0.6662280559539795,
-0.460825115442276,
-0.2264433652162552,
0.7664901614189148,
-0.31794241070747375,
0.004553573206067085,
0.23355282843112946,
-0.413754403591156,
0.18374545872211456,
0.3602520525455475,
-0.848186194896698,
0.14072848856449127,
0.3354301154613495,
0.5786859393119812,
-0.7763471603393555,
-0.35438966751098633,
-0.500615656375885,
0.10548341274261475,
-0.4854607582092285,
0.9866074919700623,
-0.45770737528800964,
-0.4576641023159027,
-0.09082170575857162,
0.15587450563907623,
-0.44382187724113464,
-0.6810829639434814,
0.4118049442768097,
-0.8098835349082947,
0.2527651786804199,
-0.11079324781894684,
-0.47805002331733704,
-0.12519097328186035,
0.16562022268772125,
-0.44151437282562256,
1.0148104429244995,
0.47909051179885864,
-0.40955427289009094,
0.38376882672309875,
-0.7674041390419006,
-0.30269956588745117,
0.12857170403003693,
-0.06291475147008896,
-0.14663231372833252,
0.3660404682159424,
0.32775425910949707,
0.20309986174106598,
-0.2692200541496277,
-0.09368348121643066,
-0.08567123860120773,
-0.4272969961166382,
0.1275106966495514,
-0.09007495641708374,
0.7843708395957947,
0.031047943979501724,
-0.2886088788509369,
0.19173118472099304,
-0.7188320755958557,
0.4506363570690155,
0.35076606273651123,
-0.17678353190422058,
-0.4841371178627014,
-0.18064914643764496,
-0.29232972860336304,
-0.05080847069621086,
-0.03854543715715408,
-0.6234502792358398,
0.6427904963493347,
-0.5381006002426147,
0.13181087374687195,
0.48237767815589905,
0.235152468085289,
0.8235397338867188,
-0.3524205982685089,
0.391417533159256,
-0.029774947091937065,
0.10339079052209854,
0.0947004109621048,
-0.23676376044750214,
-0.7986708879470825,
-0.110559843480587,
0.9811148047447205,
0.4161169230937958,
-0.8422877788543701,
0.4756181240081787,
-0.5578967332839966,
-0.5226121544837952,
-0.3481603264808655,
0.09994511306285858,
0.15349610149860382,
0.28188958764076233,
0.5231552720069885,
-0.588749349117279,
-0.4676339626312256,
-0.6882415413856506,
-0.346279501914978,
0.2845837473869324,
-0.2651910185813904,
0.34354257583618164,
0.36932113766670227,
-0.060332782566547394,
0.6160354614257812,
-0.8476530313491821,
-0.516097366809845,
-0.2649115025997162,
0.3079235851764679,
0.21015389263629913,
0.4951251447200775,
0.7168148159980774,
-0.8005543351173401,
-0.7257584929466248,
-0.1250966489315033,
-0.6712396740913391,
0.021645154803991318,
-0.2834072709083557,
-0.7144002914428711,
0.0897231325507164,
0.4657191336154938,
-0.4282095432281494,
0.32234451174736023,
0.40130704641342163,
-0.10255777835845947,
0.12811671197414398,
-0.2697537839412689,
0.21182285249233246,
-1.0603190660476685,
-0.05392412096261978,
-0.2979612350463867,
-0.07783734798431396,
-0.7434618473052979,
-0.11621411889791489,
0.04072975739836693,
-0.1377180963754654,
-0.3608124554157257,
0.47864386439323425,
-0.41991522908210754,
0.019020436331629753,
-0.40830880403518677,
0.06670570373535156,
0.15986862778663635,
0.675292432308197,
-0.07895275950431824,
0.7724865078926086,
0.552099347114563,
-0.4908788204193115,
0.15714934468269348,
0.5259377956390381,
-0.21263308823108673,
0.5440196990966797,
-0.5738287568092346,
0.13818076252937317,
-0.1226714551448822,
0.2623995244503021,
-1.0452896356582642,
-0.03196408227086067,
-0.030307885259389877,
-0.6831307411193848,
0.42485129833221436,
-0.4092274606227875,
-0.3160775303840637,
-0.05769099295139313,
-0.4041077792644501,
0.48370423913002014,
0.6479793190956116,
-0.7857953310012817,
0.5110462307929993,
0.3366129994392395,
-0.2245408147573471,
-0.4068184494972229,
-0.33426523208618164,
0.11351773887872696,
0.058780014514923096,
-0.6812871098518372,
1.081020712852478,
-0.14700502157211304,
0.191602885723114,
-0.10455886274576187,
-0.3292807936668396,
-0.10435029864311218,
0.09925366938114166,
0.08303622156381607,
0.155961275100708,
-0.3171985447406769,
0.11972623318433762,
0.13544464111328125,
-0.07483810186386108,
-0.1255434900522232,
-0.6669076681137085,
0.31355729699134827,
0.274127334356308,
-0.28221118450164795,
0.02862836793065071,
0.2819697856903076,
0.5028392672538757,
-0.32859379053115845,
0.5757916569709778,
0.4453921318054199,
-0.1369587630033493,
-0.9890704154968262,
-0.15272800624370575,
-0.18957534432411194,
-0.45979997515678406,
0.10862048715353012,
-0.12950482964515686,
-0.779970109462738,
0.08497577905654907,
-0.4648503065109253,
-0.024741649627685547,
0.5982950329780579,
0.481422483921051,
-0.251699298620224,
1.0319812297821045,
0.7248836159706116,
0.12535309791564941,
0.40663230419158936,
-0.5520950555801392,
0.19756606221199036,
-0.7563644051551819,
-0.29344454407691956,
-0.23355507850646973,
-0.742570161819458,
-0.7912865877151489,
-0.5782062411308289,
0.4222884476184845,
0.01466616615653038,
-0.06606496870517731,
0.2761249244213104,
-0.773147463798523,
0.5739583969116211,
0.7540789842605591,
-0.06166712939739227,
0.2718702554702759,
0.3529827892780304,
-0.06653793156147003,
0.03350900113582611,
-0.8057465553283691,
0.11575140058994293,
1.4319640398025513,
-0.2997671663761139,
0.5494489073753357,
0.12612806260585785,
0.6960482597351074,
0.5409757494926453,
0.015150375664234161,
-0.7769495844841003,
0.29386964440345764,
-0.556869626045227,
-0.4700269401073456,
-0.4339028298854828,
-0.4011194705963135,
-1.2070635557174683,
0.6330748200416565,
-0.23916161060333252,
-0.3394608199596405,
0.6231971383094788,
-0.09283727407455444,
-0.6662953495979309,
-0.005114041734486818,
-0.47221609950065613,
0.9923367500305176,
-0.5157995223999023,
-0.3936936855316162,
0.029064184054732323,
-0.4805661141872406,
0.18722578883171082,
-0.41706565022468567,
-0.4100949168205261,
-0.16818541288375854,
0.050138358026742935,
0.6782364249229431,
-0.25782230496406555,
0.4720063805580139,
-0.21709297597408295,
0.3461315929889679,
0.1482933908700943,
-0.054997749626636505,
0.2281116098165512,
-0.04283978417515755,
-0.1836378127336502,
0.27108922600746155,
0.03894982486963272,
-0.6349897384643555,
-0.9629852175712585,
0.8107922077178955,
-0.7294843792915344,
-0.6144940257072449,
-0.4866439700126648,
-0.6587062478065491,
-0.5467577576637268,
0.4219297766685486,
0.29084327816963196,
0.16267111897468567,
-0.37838420271873474,
0.5487268567085266,
0.6532545685768127,
-0.24532826244831085,
0.24650955200195312,
0.6527109146118164,
0.034761060029268265,
-0.4753657579421997,
1.0413696765899658,
0.15303198993206024,
-0.07209625840187073,
0.5235815048217773,
-0.0763576552271843,
-0.37518563866615295,
-1.0340991020202637,
-0.4502767026424408,
0.0033538753632456064,
-0.45451316237449646,
-0.4128199815750122,
-0.6678624749183655,
-0.5389859080314636,
-0.4737798273563385,
-0.20428355038166046,
-0.17811933159828186,
-0.8100284934043884,
-0.07887028157711029,
0.11911850422620773,
0.25325852632522583,
0.21362441778182983,
-0.0019685823936015368,
0.373528391122818,
-0.670529305934906,
0.3960154354572296,
0.40033188462257385,
0.28931841254234314,
-0.3567788898944855,
-0.8435574769973755,
-0.10257218778133392,
-0.13594084978103638,
-0.3947644829750061,
-0.39736562967300415,
0.5894967913627625,
0.5053034424781799,
0.8652273416519165,
0.02900887094438076,
0.49518388509750366,
0.4716779291629791,
-0.5011149048805237,
0.6149040460586548,
-0.02526288852095604,
-0.4937904179096222,
0.627669632434845,
-0.4505501389503479,
0.42981886863708496,
0.9849666953086853,
0.5641507506370544,
-0.19518615305423737,
0.11594568192958832,
-0.5658947825431824,
-0.9289935231208801,
0.7938411235809326,
0.3773886263370514,
0.27178654074668884,
0.2670729160308838,
0.2993667721748352,
0.14765572547912598,
0.20403967797756195,
-0.20374152064323425,
-0.2549020051956177,
-0.4183436632156372,
-0.014739478006958961,
-0.1246408075094223,
0.0007007871172390878,
-0.18565930426120758,
-0.35560342669487,
0.6674819588661194,
-0.38376384973526,
0.20251427590847015,
0.15158632397651672,
-0.32213449478149414,
-0.10324998944997787,
0.11800239980220795,
0.2654038071632385,
0.5929547548294067,
-0.4618155062198639,
-0.06814810633659363,
0.18336865305900574,
-0.23704743385314941,
-0.03435511887073517,
0.3109886944293976,
-0.289923757314682,
0.16235090792179108,
-0.08382447808980942,
0.5826902389526367,
0.21532723307609558,
-0.5244701504707336,
0.738572359085083,
-0.10804002732038498,
-0.5854558944702148,
-0.23254267871379852,
0.29905521869659424,
-0.11716737598180771,
0.19351933896541595,
0.48966631293296814,
0.17718791961669922,
0.28624746203422546,
-0.4715706408023834,
0.3819534480571747,
0.44680067896842957,
-0.2673693895339966,
-0.09328760206699371,
0.5089138150215149,
0.3667566776275635,
0.00516727939248085,
0.5459105372428894,
-0.23166504502296448,
-0.35327211022377014,
0.5598341822624207,
0.4282236397266388,
0.8825798034667969,
-0.2335784137248993,
0.39734795689582825,
0.4265941083431244,
-0.12373089045286179,
-0.11263185739517212,
0.33866432309150696,
-0.0066776457242667675,
-0.7176333665847778,
-0.13333937525749207,
-0.7089203000068665,
-0.2698996067047119,
0.1921139359474182,
-0.4961593747138977,
-0.05883114039897919,
-0.533896803855896,
-0.15600880980491638,
0.40032029151916504,
0.12763644754886627,
-0.4630591571331024,
0.22029606997966766,
-0.02753913775086403,
0.8646984696388245,
-0.41743865609169006,
0.7694881558418274,
0.6178469657897949,
-0.531396210193634,
-0.13141664862632751,
0.2107604295015335,
-0.08679228276014328,
-0.8793056011199951,
0.7399131655693054,
-0.13163064420223236,
-0.08700445294380188,
0.41883790493011475,
-0.3919715881347656,
-0.9697840809822083,
1.2548704147338867,
0.2889326512813568,
-0.3697989881038666,
0.09546000510454178,
0.22614169120788574,
0.730841875076294,
-0.5950695872306824,
-0.008889973163604736,
0.4287557899951935,
0.2321435958147049,
0.22790400683879852,
-0.3269072473049164,
0.13276472687721252,
-0.34675583243370056,
0.09585453569889069,
0.1660424917936325,
-0.6647050380706787,
0.5261752009391785,
-0.0607459619641304,
-0.32286784052848816,
0.187812939286232,
0.36576083302497864,
-0.010954032652080059,
0.38519445061683655,
0.32660356163978577,
0.45295342803001404,
0.6051006317138672,
-0.056733887642621994,
1.0343084335327148,
-0.3920559883117676,
0.0857793390750885,
1.1883751153945923,
-0.45462119579315186,
0.8592531085014343,
0.055911026895046234,
-0.03972441703081131,
0.5527715682983398,
0.4916790723800659,
-0.5498745441436768,
0.819848358631134,
0.32120686769485474,
-0.22575940191745758,
-0.5163621306419373,
-0.19722172617912292,
-0.3529830873012543,
0.732070803642273,
0.08572375774383545,
-0.5099053978919983,
-0.2756786644458771,
-0.33170121908187866,
-0.5024154782295227,
0.03242726996541023,
-0.16583770513534546,
0.8423811197280884,
-0.01932438276708126,
-0.8179209232330322,
1.0340324640274048,
-0.14326319098472595,
0.4948750138282776,
-0.46751198172569275,
-0.025636820122599602,
-0.6186897158622742,
0.2804866135120392,
-0.20882494747638702,
-0.5042672753334045,
0.04781579226255417,
-0.17998729646205902,
-0.2841828465461731,
-0.3291321098804474,
0.9075930714607239,
-0.3066648542881012,
-0.5486330389976501,
0.26766252517700195,
0.9079720973968506,
0.11910887062549591,
-0.4730168879032135,
-0.7436656355857849,
-0.2767115533351898,
0.02580132521688938,
-0.050736911594867706,
0.7151394486427307,
0.47474348545074463,
-0.09297512471675873,
0.22743773460388184,
0.9879997372627258,
-0.025450412184000015,
-0.10349331051111221,
0.3086807429790497,
0.9067835807800293,
-0.7065760493278503,
-0.08517294377088547,
-0.3198324143886566,
0.49744513630867004,
-0.44559401273727417,
-0.3013289272785187,
0.7611256837844849,
0.6634220480918884,
1.1270958185195923,
-0.15274086594581604,
1.006544589996338,
0.3239184319972992,
0.37788987159729004,
-0.40608036518096924,
1.0498251914978027,
-0.9297322034835815,
0.053590018302202225,
0.2656368613243103,
-1.0717177391052246,
-0.4222952425479889,
0.21938204765319824,
-0.29115667939186096,
0.15907810628414154,
0.7724626064300537,
0.923864483833313,
-0.10637037456035614,
-0.3581030070781708,
0.7484514117240906,
0.042962830513715744,
-0.19524239003658295,
0.5239366292953491,
0.8902689814567566,
-0.5978521704673767,
0.7962313890457153,
-0.18151940405368805,
-0.14692436158657074,
-0.43937239050865173,
-0.6454778909683228,
-0.9592709541320801,
-0.32681041955947876,
-0.4835280776023865,
-0.05607076734304428,
0.398140013217926,
0.5409547090530396,
0.8866066336631775,
-1.021304726600647,
0.07394979149103165,
0.10719038546085358,
-0.07092530280351639,
-0.3361307978630066,
-0.16341497004032135,
0.4364641010761261,
-0.5149624943733215,
-0.744254469871521,
0.7079764008522034,
0.31007322669029236,
-0.20982781052589417,
0.18617668747901917,
0.16545769572257996,
0.054527398198843,
0.2777128517627716,
0.7598339319229126,
0.37505388259887695,
-0.2614682912826538,
0.10578061640262604,
0.21433956921100616,
0.013180925510823727,
0.31838178634643555,
0.9060809016227722,
-0.8381474614143372,
0.5288793444633484,
0.719375491142273,
0.9584226608276367,
0.5463861227035522,
0.37490129470825195,
0.5744857788085938,
-0.8213893175125122,
-0.4026119112968445,
0.20858325064182281,
0.17201484739780426,
0.3113175630569458,
-0.4704120457172394,
0.7292338013648987,
0.3533293902873993,
-0.49958792328834534,
-0.5673113465309143,
0.02111867070198059,
-1.2152663469314575,
-0.6251133680343628,
1.1926450729370117,
0.12174965441226959,
-0.2150430679321289,
-0.1423068344593048,
-0.15807271003723145,
0.2067880928516388,
-0.38649407029151917,
1.1517435312271118,
0.05603086203336716,
-0.40041011571884155,
0.04835323244333267,
-0.5581376552581787,
0.5117326378822327,
0.6437158584594727,
-0.7916809320449829,
0.11026964336633682,
0.39095690846443176,
0.39097851514816284,
0.11280756443738937,
0.486246794462204,
-0.1543211191892624,
0.32960259914398193,
0.0375589057803154,
0.03562809154391289,
-0.15802858769893646,
-0.3096042275428772,
-0.4070782959461212,
0.3076742887496948,
0.01653197407722473,
-0.30305078625679016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02474v1
|
uTeBC-NLP at SemEval-2024 Task 9: Can LLMs be Lateral Thinkers?
| 2024-04-03T05:31:59 | 2024-04-03T05:31:59 |
Pouya Sadeghi, Amirhossein Abaskohi, Yadollah Yaghoobzadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Inspired by human cognition, Jiang et al.(2023c) create a benchmark for
assessing LLMs' lateral thinking-thinking outside the box. Building upon this
benchmark, we investigate how different prompting methods enhance LLMs'
performance on this task to reveal their inherent power for outside-the-box
thinking ability. Through participating in SemEval-2024, task 9, Sentence
Puzzle sub-task, we explore prompt engineering methods: chain of thoughts (CoT)
and direct prompting, enhancing with informative descriptions, and employing
contextualizing prompts using a retrieval augmented generation (RAG) pipeline.
Our experiments involve three LLMs including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and
Zephyr-7B-beta. We generate a dataset of thinking paths between riddles and
options using GPT-4, validated by humans for quality. Findings indicate that
compressed informative prompts enhance performance. Dynamic in-context learning
enhances model performance significantly. Furthermore, fine-tuning Zephyr on
our dataset enhances performance across other commonsense datasets,
underscoring the value of innovative thinking.
|
[
-0.662474513053894,
-0.8129739761352539,
0.6168657541275024,
0.22322341799736023,
-0.23531976342201233,
0.3227885365486145,
-0.09709299355745316,
-0.45014166831970215,
0.0572354830801487,
0.3205764591693878,
-0.9998610019683838,
-0.2975102961063385,
-0.0828162282705307,
0.4402940273284912,
0.029345113784074783,
0.5187549591064453,
0.10649842023849487,
0.05799897760152817,
-0.2790524363517761,
-0.0790824294090271,
-0.9823793768882751,
-0.4054015278816223,
-0.5059272050857544,
-0.24095956981182098,
0.4289754331111908,
0.3956066071987152,
0.5513046979904175,
0.19905874133110046,
0.16187427937984467,
0.26290810108184814,
-0.2654143273830414,
0.10956105589866638,
-0.27525606751441956,
0.3028939664363861,
-0.5114063620567322,
-0.5649696588516235,
-0.3256838023662567,
0.04714652895927429,
0.3622538447380066,
0.4684745669364929,
0.08212524652481079,
0.08992332965135574,
0.1650504171848297,
0.7605510950088501,
-0.3034210503101349,
-0.0928405299782753,
-0.694837749004364,
0.2835477590560913,
-0.061756595969200134,
-0.4383637309074402,
-0.3979182541370392,
-0.22230364382266998,
-0.15082624554634094,
-0.30325984954833984,
0.08286403864622116,
0.2570291757583618,
0.3660695254802704,
0.44748759269714355,
-0.3604600727558136,
-0.3390951454639435,
-0.2614375948905945,
0.43053826689720154,
-0.44710585474967957,
0.47676247358322144,
0.0774342268705368,
0.1852962076663971,
-0.288858562707901,
-0.5181604027748108,
-0.17324256896972656,
-0.02038552425801754,
0.2977916896343231,
0.22649095952510834,
-0.09519132971763611,
-0.17917177081108093,
0.641887366771698,
0.0859394520521164,
-0.28871777653694153,
0.31261754035949707,
-0.43576741218566895,
-0.21562840044498444,
0.5050560235977173,
0.3128727376461029,
0.03022446669638157,
-0.0812247171998024,
-0.6746892333030701,
-0.08630655705928802,
-0.9447513818740845,
0.5865253806114197,
0.2740526795387268,
0.07442616671323776,
0.30902066826820374,
0.5843663811683655,
-0.33414411544799805,
0.3251535892486572,
0.0933494120836258,
0.5139452815055847,
0.2103576809167862,
-0.5343946814537048,
-0.08286028355360031,
-0.06839017570018768,
0.4740362763404846,
0.36353111267089844,
-0.16290485858917236,
-0.21379105746746063,
-0.42141151428222656,
0.0322149284183979,
0.4007796049118042,
-0.6287490725517273,
-0.2124776840209961,
0.08929833769798279,
-0.25358977913856506,
-0.14906157553195953,
-0.19502022862434387,
-0.8887472152709961,
-0.6161946654319763,
-0.35980701446533203,
0.44866040349006653,
-0.4068581759929657,
0.06148247420787811,
-0.010228395462036133,
-0.1805887222290039,
0.3415631353855133,
0.17514248192310333,
-0.5914210677146912,
0.12783771753311157,
0.5410400032997131,
0.5568764209747314,
-0.15830187499523163,
-0.13370119035243988,
-0.6391655206680298,
-0.2625181972980499,
-0.35457709431648254,
1.1712126731872559,
-0.48773014545440674,
-0.41325655579566956,
-0.3000040650367737,
-0.06888747215270996,
0.22618339955806732,
-0.48272761702537537,
0.7892007827758789,
-0.5134979486465454,
0.17150817811489105,
-0.8502951264381409,
-0.38579946756362915,
-0.33192819356918335,
0.12895412743091583,
-0.49853023886680603,
1.072054147720337,
-0.15732507407665253,
-0.6753286123275757,
0.3371128439903259,
-0.6751047372817993,
-0.28496846556663513,
0.4662787616252899,
-0.6918368339538574,
0.01338954921811819,
0.25978586077690125,
0.7052803039550781,
0.4631854295730591,
-0.3848848342895508,
0.22901922464370728,
-0.1152084469795227,
-0.19758374989032745,
0.5487547516822815,
-0.39376822113990784,
0.9257877469062805,
-0.12070376425981522,
-0.6454997062683105,
0.33413824439048767,
-0.48838695883750916,
0.33055776357650757,
0.09342914819717407,
0.03966853395104408,
-0.04724385589361191,
-0.3168104588985443,
-0.5326033234596252,
0.6113436222076416,
0.03643188625574112,
-0.16270466148853302,
0.15815508365631104,
-0.4122006297111511,
0.44430044293403625,
0.9894500970840454,
0.21468298137187958,
0.3822507858276367,
-0.5343220233917236,
0.8514845967292786,
-0.03231945261359215,
-0.11362957209348679,
-0.20323532819747925,
-0.8590482473373413,
-0.5906060934066772,
0.1826937049627304,
-0.039491940289735794,
0.6331720948219299,
-0.9369155168533325,
0.36844322085380554,
0.13022610545158386,
-0.41750141978263855,
-0.4908168315887451,
0.32040634751319885,
0.2463224083185196,
0.7393978834152222,
0.5110562443733215,
-0.18929526209831238,
-0.5799363255500793,
-0.6623017191886902,
-0.4554440379142761,
0.1392301619052887,
-0.07018254697322845,
0.26726433634757996,
0.5602372884750366,
-0.1330607682466507,
0.7943768501281738,
-0.18589343130588531,
0.1199415773153305,
-0.2852161228656769,
0.31516537070274353,
0.34865450859069824,
0.20693685114383698,
-0.04492940381169319,
-0.36578699946403503,
-0.008337924256920815,
-0.5295285582542419,
-0.6294623017311096,
-0.4181881248950958,
-0.2851291000843048,
-0.37863707542419434,
0.08641616255044937,
0.6332046389579773,
-0.5644144415855408,
0.3342881202697754,
0.04041344299912453,
-0.6103154420852661,
0.5475407838821411,
-0.2172098606824875,
0.017845451831817627,
-0.7581385970115662,
-0.16338156163692474,
-0.2343188375234604,
0.18312190473079681,
-0.45432549715042114,
-0.17010939121246338,
0.16994036734104156,
-0.02834310568869114,
-0.5566245317459106,
0.5480377078056335,
-0.7479292750358582,
-0.2204829901456833,
-0.12508270144462585,
0.15789680182933807,
-0.011598324403166771,
0.4995095431804657,
-0.050907015800476074,
1.0414155721664429,
0.4116426408290863,
-0.6392499804496765,
0.3266417980194092,
0.3609652519226074,
-0.4253253936767578,
0.324198454618454,
-0.5504911541938782,
0.6082127690315247,
-0.23440685868263245,
0.42065224051475525,
-0.8978694677352905,
0.14413507282733917,
0.061502665281295776,
-0.1435224413871765,
-0.06517139077186584,
0.41114598512649536,
-0.40126296877861023,
-0.5329799652099609,
-0.601209282875061,
0.13484685122966766,
0.6796473264694214,
-0.6491000056266785,
0.5039209127426147,
0.2530880868434906,
-0.36638927459716797,
-0.4477039873600006,
-0.6474835276603699,
0.10728345811367035,
-0.3807031214237213,
-0.6237826347351074,
0.443107545375824,
-0.35689857602119446,
-0.20405487716197968,
-0.245418980717659,
-0.2309368997812271,
0.39426183700561523,
0.18136776983737946,
0.26101213693618774,
0.45529189705848694,
-0.06840261071920395,
0.22812724113464355,
0.03702954575419426,
-0.041674237698316574,
0.5778948664665222,
-0.08665114641189575,
0.31374332308769226,
-0.5381785035133362,
-0.23363427817821503,
-0.08180978149175644,
0.23967505991458893,
0.06403813511133194,
-0.08459659665822983,
0.2657858431339264,
0.519942581653595,
-0.1905813366174698,
-0.5370717644691467,
-0.6755825281143188,
-0.5440154075622559,
-0.4937652051448822,
0.0413111113011837,
-0.6743701100349426,
-0.9126548171043396,
0.6035304069519043,
-0.1676068753004074,
-0.017116235569119453,
0.22514863312244415,
0.5660215020179749,
-0.24431069195270538,
0.7883821725845337,
0.4463714063167572,
0.28523001074790955,
0.1996285319328308,
-0.3423779308795929,
0.12154503166675568,
-1.2474253177642822,
-0.4959906339645386,
-0.1478906273841858,
-0.5822116136550903,
-0.3204036056995392,
-0.744529128074646,
0.4831794798374176,
0.3429192006587982,
-0.05687319114804268,
0.197653666138649,
-0.6866381168365479,
0.5530184507369995,
0.5732536911964417,
0.20009438693523407,
0.2232505977153778,
-0.2745460867881775,
-0.7261282801628113,
-0.03499851003289223,
-0.8417920470237732,
-0.526491105556488,
0.8654311299324036,
0.29512593150138855,
0.6056336760520935,
-0.07497522234916687,
0.5126960873603821,
0.043883632868528366,
0.06791067123413086,
-0.7022110223770142,
1.0523552894592285,
0.6113035082817078,
-0.5209168791770935,
-0.31560418009757996,
-0.18331585824489594,
-0.9530326724052429,
0.3145851790904999,
-0.14696277678012848,
-0.7023641467094421,
0.10667338967323303,
-0.22287873923778534,
-0.7125210165977478,
0.10299181938171387,
-0.47117742896080017,
0.5051295161247253,
-0.6200722455978394,
-0.494663268327713,
-0.15556500852108002,
-0.6946636438369751,
0.16664503514766693,
0.07126238197088242,
0.11558664590120316,
-0.2406630665063858,
-0.5092331171035767,
0.6976975798606873,
0.113011933863163,
0.7355460524559021,
-0.02243048883974552,
-0.053926657885313034,
0.5464953184127808,
-0.005881124641746283,
0.5696336030960083,
0.21890197694301605,
0.033816609531641006,
0.009581899270415306,
-0.39344272017478943,
-0.04996447637677193,
-0.6658620238304138,
0.3906169533729553,
-0.47507256269454956,
-1.0588657855987549,
-0.25447237491607666,
-0.6183370351791382,
-0.6759437918663025,
0.11693164706230164,
0.5120603442192078,
0.4542621076107025,
-0.030033785849809647,
0.3538029193878174,
0.71112459897995,
-0.30247369408607483,
0.6137869358062744,
0.1903565376996994,
-0.030247092247009277,
-0.43162140250205994,
0.19917547702789307,
0.27832838892936707,
-0.10097496956586838,
0.4319821000099182,
0.3619691729545593,
-0.8012382388114929,
-0.4234302341938019,
-0.37339046597480774,
0.041483622044324875,
-0.9490521550178528,
-0.32316169142723083,
-0.792079746723175,
-0.1973000317811966,
-0.3381774127483368,
-0.3789593577384949,
0.064564049243927,
-0.4774770140647888,
-0.1980866938829422,
-0.3736928105354309,
0.20213726162910461,
0.7088014483451843,
0.09121294319629669,
-0.35598260164260864,
-0.6009016036987305,
0.008169837296009064,
0.4450650215148926,
0.005083451513200998,
0.06437714397907257,
-0.4348578155040741,
0.08224280178546906,
-0.08664365857839584,
-0.5348482728004456,
-0.889043390750885,
0.22067618370056152,
-0.42700356245040894,
0.8666384220123291,
-0.046095941215753555,
0.15865562856197357,
0.4906632900238037,
-0.43601125478744507,
0.877191424369812,
0.08872510492801666,
-0.7876047492027283,
0.742279052734375,
-0.19572022557258606,
0.7380485534667969,
0.4453103244304657,
0.38034477829933167,
-0.04964189603924751,
-0.2932298183441162,
-0.6383964419364929,
-0.6932557225227356,
0.5066816210746765,
0.19454093277454376,
-0.2851060926914215,
0.06525125354528427,
-0.006198156625032425,
0.29921770095825195,
0.20487681031227112,
-0.5604883432388306,
0.20848920941352844,
-0.0895286500453949,
0.14900784194469452,
0.07016589492559433,
-0.12938787043094635,
-0.1306993067264557,
-0.31388920545578003,
0.594826877117157,
-0.2510690987110138,
0.4003352224826813,
0.27653706073760986,
0.009609156288206577,
0.028039006516337395,
0.6833214163780212,
0.5672830939292908,
0.696138858795166,
0.06733537465333939,
0.2609372138977051,
0.7519083023071289,
0.011260719038546085,
0.20777569711208344,
-0.10683906823396683,
-0.06653687357902527,
-0.308499813079834,
0.10811369866132736,
0.7426376342773438,
0.28235292434692383,
-0.6819794178009033,
0.19826877117156982,
-0.05413499474525452,
-0.11082573980093002,
-0.07241317629814148,
0.2231660783290863,
0.25793981552124023,
0.534376859664917,
0.35628774762153625,
0.2196415811777115,
0.3117852210998535,
-0.5271114706993103,
-0.01577671244740486,
0.41414961218833923,
-0.23926804959774017,
-0.430984228849411,
0.7585721611976624,
0.40804824233055115,
-0.3716106414794922,
0.46332016587257385,
-0.3571961224079132,
-0.5551652908325195,
0.582778811454773,
0.5564081072807312,
1.1916791200637817,
0.14261750876903534,
0.09562649577856064,
0.20312972366809845,
0.4320312738418579,
0.06632864475250244,
0.5535620450973511,
-0.4080207943916321,
-0.7348254919052124,
-0.4723353385925293,
-0.049917977303266525,
-0.447269082069397,
0.23954713344573975,
-0.30567920207977295,
0.2845666706562042,
-0.3357745110988617,
-0.3900151550769806,
-0.2217492312192917,
0.1529676914215088,
-0.9677983522415161,
-0.11091899871826172,
0.22988107800483704,
1.197487235069275,
-0.42166343331336975,
0.5225578546524048,
0.9166999459266663,
-0.20669002830982208,
-0.9301018714904785,
-0.22182627022266388,
0.17114973068237305,
-0.5381938219070435,
0.6848335266113281,
0.5264695882797241,
-0.3417275846004486,
-0.0878094732761383,
-0.3413696587085724,
-0.591047465801239,
1.3605890274047852,
0.08435971289873123,
-0.45030999183654785,
-0.25768542289733887,
-0.12529152631759644,
0.3768264353275299,
-0.44525662064552307,
0.5218029618263245,
0.3838787078857422,
0.3323424756526947,
0.2039036750793457,
-0.5804827809333801,
0.39613664150238037,
-0.37312817573547363,
0.1843070685863495,
0.08965420722961426,
-0.7140477299690247,
0.6400032639503479,
-0.501722514629364,
-0.34185153245925903,
-0.02962736040353775,
0.7490589618682861,
0.517592191696167,
0.3669929504394531,
0.4356648623943329,
0.4109897017478943,
0.9830836057662964,
0.09694750607013702,
0.5237382054328918,
-0.18720299005508423,
-0.31487593054771423,
1.1479682922363281,
-0.2683679163455963,
0.7097877264022827,
0.5060099959373474,
0.09633754938840866,
0.5048134922981262,
0.3823719024658203,
0.13483448326587677,
0.46805834770202637,
0.16312220692634583,
-0.024109847843647003,
-0.0867403969168663,
-0.025952929630875587,
-0.43054935336112976,
0.13741818070411682,
0.5392462015151978,
-0.05684298649430275,
-0.056463684886693954,
0.026239272207021713,
-0.28391367197036743,
0.07930798083543777,
-0.5243553519248962,
0.5233327150344849,
0.28884124755859375,
-0.9873113036155701,
0.43977299332618713,
-0.37131696939468384,
0.7372058033943176,
-0.10371346771717072,
0.13326045870780945,
-0.16475582122802734,
0.010112263262271881,
0.041687898337841034,
-1.1670761108398438,
0.0847112312912941,
-0.11871055513620377,
0.1876627653837204,
-0.7177371382713318,
0.813305139541626,
-0.06252636015415192,
-0.2460934966802597,
0.1285262107849121,
0.6954958438873291,
-0.013400551863014698,
0.030772365629673004,
-0.8962950110435486,
-0.010287044569849968,
0.035941362380981445,
-0.34402623772621155,
0.0967705026268959,
0.8126425743103027,
-0.1888185739517212,
0.8434271216392517,
0.5473490953445435,
-0.06496042013168335,
0.029350262135267258,
0.15734316408634186,
0.8462232947349548,
-1.0344607830047607,
-0.5931612253189087,
-0.7230297327041626,
0.4920026957988739,
-0.22424788773059845,
-0.5202944874763489,
0.8075823783874512,
0.40593332052230835,
0.80351722240448,
-0.1430431306362152,
0.5085433125495911,
0.186013326048851,
0.3695279359817505,
-0.7184438109397888,
0.0821879655122757,
0.07477967441082001,
0.4344428777694702,
0.046667080372571945,
-0.8095766305923462,
0.17837169766426086,
0.41242143511772156,
-0.588141143321991,
0.07492706924676895,
1.0509843826293945,
0.8185455203056335,
0.38161352276802063,
0.6278780102729797,
0.32881128787994385,
0.0998821035027504,
0.34426555037498474,
0.8169213533401489,
1.3664028644561768,
-0.16843467950820923,
0.37705257534980774,
-0.35257065296173096,
-0.18194855749607086,
-0.061881426721811295,
-0.8919408917427063,
-1.3046379089355469,
-0.5641766786575317,
-0.11366020143032074,
-0.2132091522216797,
-0.24508391320705414,
1.1405515670776367,
0.3480567932128906,
-0.47289541363716125,
-0.03766375035047531,
-0.39084577560424805,
0.016991175711154938,
-0.23972687125205994,
-0.19802145659923553,
0.003682878101244569,
-0.5068247318267822,
-0.14468123018741608,
0.745936393737793,
0.5256496667861938,
0.06002943962812424,
-0.3250596225261688,
0.09719158709049225,
-0.06676972657442093,
0.2376876026391983,
0.5318767428398132,
-0.05858233571052551,
-0.8441364765167236,
-0.09474574029445648,
0.3723294734954834,
0.024435313418507576,
0.07222596555948257,
0.8040119409561157,
-1.1697038412094116,
0.37317049503326416,
0.7107692360877991,
0.8317927718162537,
0.17366893589496613,
0.26338696479797363,
0.4712604880332947,
-0.25320279598236084,
-0.01238824613392353,
0.7775987386703491,
0.2742328345775604,
0.2738160192966461,
-0.6314815878868103,
0.6807838678359985,
0.11049506813287735,
-0.7314838171005249,
-0.46615850925445557,
0.19279339909553528,
-0.6821169853210449,
-0.24434725940227509,
1.1189467906951904,
0.3449007570743561,
-0.25171905755996704,
-0.13818618655204773,
-0.3985551595687866,
-0.16120371222496033,
-0.5490412712097168,
0.601467490196228,
0.8428006172180176,
-0.5847079157829285,
-0.3036966621875763,
-0.5735876560211182,
0.6001954674720764,
0.6986877918243408,
-0.8621692061424255,
-0.23135384917259216,
0.3547951281070709,
-0.042999137192964554,
0.03361467272043228,
0.7781728506088257,
0.015698280185461044,
0.09037971496582031,
0.03686755895614624,
-0.36070820689201355,
-0.15030375123023987,
-0.41520023345947266,
-0.2743777632713318,
0.04141009971499443,
-0.18136674165725708,
0.10065784305334091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02466v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02466v1
|
Prompting for Numerical Sequences: A Case Study on Market Comment Generation
| 2024-04-03T05:10:11 | 2024-04-03T05:10:11 |
Masayuki Kawarada, Tatsuya Ishigaki, Hiroya Takamura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been applied to a wide range of
data-to-text generation tasks, including tables, graphs, and time-series
numerical data-to-text settings. While research on generating prompts for
structured data such as tables and graphs is gaining momentum, in-depth
investigations into prompting for time-series numerical data are lacking.
Therefore, this study explores various input representations, including
sequences of tokens and structured formats such as HTML, LaTeX, and
Python-style codes. In our experiments, we focus on the task of Market Comment
Generation, which involves taking a numerical sequence of stock prices as input
and generating a corresponding market comment. Contrary to our expectations,
the results show that prompts resembling programming languages yield better
outcomes, whereas those similar to natural languages and longer formats, such
as HTML and LaTeX, are less effective. Our findings offer insights into
creating effective prompts for tasks that generate text from numerical
sequences.
|
[
-0.23439568281173706,
-0.6944514513015747,
0.6933510899543762,
0.48436763882637024,
-0.3646427392959595,
-0.004221841227263212,
-0.17578376829624176,
-0.002508686389774084,
0.14965276420116425,
0.1788029819726944,
-0.752984881401062,
-0.595440685749054,
-0.17357061803340912,
0.6377800703048706,
-0.4906982481479645,
1.1355061531066895,
-0.06013893336057663,
-0.10376594215631485,
-0.07542066276073456,
0.3528326749801636,
-0.42267200350761414,
-0.7782070636749268,
-0.5332440137863159,
-0.14330056309700012,
0.8367276191711426,
0.34911060333251953,
0.6061409711837769,
0.5691578984260559,
0.30749034881591797,
0.295625239610672,
0.29573196172714233,
0.31268027424812317,
-0.33407920598983765,
0.5964723825454712,
0.21536986529827118,
-0.2283419668674469,
-0.049013782292604446,
-0.13140523433685303,
0.6801950931549072,
0.7426445484161377,
-0.047972194850444794,
0.4026215374469757,
0.06662936508655548,
0.7379085421562195,
-0.36133378744125366,
0.6072837114334106,
-0.4081348180770874,
0.2692652940750122,
-0.3233540952205658,
-0.7068815231323242,
-0.8948601484298706,
-0.7891693115234375,
0.029428036883473396,
-0.3581092059612274,
-0.08350486308336258,
0.1872335821390152,
0.4861711263656616,
0.20764996111392975,
-0.26405608654022217,
-0.5651487112045288,
-0.7448608875274658,
0.6649028658866882,
-0.9318065643310547,
0.008156118914484978,
0.10375991463661194,
0.11627620458602905,
-0.3855035901069641,
-0.7101340293884277,
-0.4978969693183899,
-0.279594749212265,
0.018990665674209595,
-0.15709981322288513,
-0.24224059283733368,
-0.20714062452316284,
0.873727023601532,
0.007973072119057178,
-0.492586225271225,
-0.027569381520152092,
-0.36487436294555664,
0.2166137993335724,
0.6015421152114868,
0.5807954668998718,
0.10455389320850372,
-0.3997553586959839,
0.12479745596647263,
-0.19739477336406708,
-0.9479405283927917,
0.21297842264175415,
0.4214785397052765,
0.6888043880462646,
-0.19935613870620728,
0.8306511044502258,
-0.2099234014749527,
0.9467425346374512,
-0.10317078977823257,
-0.07711393386125565,
0.0005094861262477934,
-0.2108413428068161,
-0.16487455368041992,
0.11341621726751328,
0.8014547228813171,
0.5033161044120789,
0.6989434957504272,
-0.005708836019039154,
-0.19486719369888306,
0.0374789796769619,
0.17448408901691437,
-0.8630682826042175,
-0.17689335346221924,
-0.04237409308552742,
-0.5086550712585449,
-0.6351209282875061,
0.32680967450141907,
-0.717617392539978,
-0.22947777807712555,
-0.5203221440315247,
-0.051156386733055115,
0.07651734352111816,
0.1899876594543457,
-0.05100246146321297,
-0.2799991965293884,
0.31171169877052307,
0.307901531457901,
-0.9681642055511475,
0.19663004577159882,
0.5798313617706299,
0.7555425763130188,
-0.1363259255886078,
0.19911053776741028,
-0.7425726652145386,
0.1450764536857605,
-0.45655128359794617,
0.6920776963233948,
-0.74718177318573,
-0.794162392616272,
0.1189030334353447,
-0.24618670344352722,
0.14107413589954376,
-0.49100106954574585,
-0.1164655089378357,
-0.7002118229866028,
0.2913495898246765,
-0.5202711224555969,
-0.24812018871307373,
0.07398851960897446,
0.12159790843725204,
-0.6014979481697083,
1.0449351072311401,
-0.25656858086586,
-0.8850494027137756,
0.3871825337409973,
-0.9650915861129761,
-0.6338511109352112,
0.010279753245413303,
-0.642213761806488,
-0.12735900282859802,
-0.02306167222559452,
0.35701271891593933,
0.6911383271217346,
-0.41010740399360657,
0.11608488112688065,
-0.46913352608680725,
-0.138302281498909,
1.1291342973709106,
-0.6630989909172058,
0.10310601443052292,
0.32828211784362793,
-0.4120372533798218,
-0.07178457081317902,
-0.6743502616882324,
-0.03358551487326622,
0.23144593834877014,
-0.37493711709976196,
-0.05267573520541191,
0.10888852179050446,
-0.12796586751937866,
0.06041799113154411,
0.05016636103391647,
-0.2287156879901886,
0.4052446782588959,
-0.3709060251712799,
0.6481804847717285,
1.0568723678588867,
0.3459298014640808,
0.13874885439872742,
-0.38249140977859497,
0.7213302850723267,
0.06799132376909256,
-0.3782553970813751,
-0.8993825912475586,
-0.596484899520874,
-0.2973950207233429,
0.24396716058254242,
0.2761169672012329,
0.6089979410171509,
-0.8757138252258301,
-0.25667572021484375,
-0.07063693553209305,
-0.14014136791229248,
0.1851610541343689,
0.0040230415761470795,
0.11462043225765228,
0.5479418635368347,
-0.2324942648410797,
-0.03595288097858429,
-0.6409170031547546,
-0.6441666483879089,
-0.09787977486848831,
-0.10396178066730499,
-0.0626998096704483,
0.5470910668373108,
0.15005934238433838,
0.18150967359542847,
1.0056668519973755,
-1.0382484197616577,
0.6551029086112976,
-0.06761641055345535,
0.45163312554359436,
0.7068739533424377,
0.08773916959762573,
0.47418537735939026,
-0.4041234850883484,
-0.6425454020500183,
-0.2178925722837448,
-0.6338233947753906,
-0.29225099086761475,
-0.2700367271900177,
0.1176699548959732,
0.34122246503829956,
0.6762169599533081,
-0.4270944595336914,
0.48859602212905884,
0.4712071418762207,
0.011361121200025082,
0.5356248617172241,
0.0853130966424942,
0.15742814540863037,
-1.4468392133712769,
0.4252876341342926,
0.3450154960155487,
-0.2915029525756836,
-0.4896945357322693,
-0.4044973850250244,
-0.35043367743492126,
-0.4467201828956604,
-0.4093632102012634,
0.47325584292411804,
-0.372882604598999,
-0.12980568408966064,
-0.0012601721100509167,
-0.07826660573482513,
-0.17556989192962646,
0.3535304665565491,
0.08133650571107864,
1.2926675081253052,
0.18565788865089417,
-0.8403390049934387,
0.3028486371040344,
0.09860369563102722,
-0.3504562973976135,
0.12412912398576736,
-0.8061747550964355,
0.24923236668109894,
-0.12412942945957184,
0.06937750428915024,
-1.3172495365142822,
-0.38056933879852295,
0.3499006927013397,
-0.4363618493080139,
0.17674125730991364,
-0.036689333617687225,
-0.5598965287208557,
-0.5639551281929016,
-0.4724647104740143,
0.46633002161979675,
0.5234988331794739,
-0.4099600911140442,
-0.09881027787923813,
0.04316551983356476,
-0.828838050365448,
-0.6384792327880859,
-0.6510264277458191,
0.169330894947052,
-0.25078314542770386,
-0.5043632984161377,
-0.09942538291215897,
-0.32828712463378906,
-0.5736910104751587,
-0.44622910022735596,
0.24733537435531616,
0.15538139641284943,
-0.09686414897441864,
0.26733893156051636,
0.5885125994682312,
-0.3586595952510834,
0.00648643309250474,
-0.08051354438066483,
-0.12163751572370529,
0.3658599853515625,
-0.34817659854888916,
0.6408855319023132,
0.14286261796951294,
-0.3296751081943512,
-0.4405421018600464,
0.4847603142261505,
0.44470131397247314,
0.3090415298938751,
0.43071892857551575,
-0.21660809218883514,
-0.13496191799640656,
-0.4560365080833435,
-0.1640481799840927,
-0.3228646218776703,
-0.6253141760826111,
-0.16481509804725647,
-0.18596641719341278,
-0.9834871292114258,
0.44127100706100464,
-0.20794644951820374,
0.22333179414272308,
0.3360997438430786,
0.8634815812110901,
-0.04307419806718826,
1.3086344003677368,
0.217675119638443,
0.10325422883033752,
0.649492621421814,
-0.007548708934336901,
0.46788910031318665,
-0.27266567945480347,
-0.23264151811599731,
-0.6712281107902527,
-0.4047919809818268,
-0.42146846652030945,
-0.2788538932800293,
0.4063977599143982,
-0.5001398921012878,
-0.3376646935939789,
0.08160074055194855,
-0.49827468395233154,
0.4549560844898224,
0.5217472910881042,
-0.11090520024299622,
0.03750050067901611,
0.4056980013847351,
-0.30148184299468994,
-0.38935932517051697,
-0.7081702947616577,
-0.5457493662834167,
1.1107360124588013,
0.2060076892375946,
1.1755067110061646,
-0.09796571731567383,
0.6366462111473083,
0.5751030445098877,
0.36418667435646057,
-0.783939003944397,
0.4818916916847229,
-0.21577656269073486,
0.02677248604595661,
-0.14121544361114502,
-0.5058909058570862,
-1.0201438665390015,
-0.48626604676246643,
0.006668975576758385,
-0.5102521777153015,
0.06279553472995758,
0.18302561342716217,
-0.6939165592193604,
-0.02845897525548935,
-0.43562817573547363,
0.6715314984321594,
-0.02346225641667843,
-0.28264060616493225,
0.1430622637271881,
-0.2733401954174042,
0.22577519714832306,
-0.09930575639009476,
0.2956289052963257,
0.0016974573954939842,
-0.03375113010406494,
0.6308035254478455,
-0.8923840522766113,
1.2633180618286133,
-0.0021031247451901436,
-0.34862202405929565,
0.4261751174926758,
0.12761938571929932,
0.817962646484375,
0.14210180938243866,
-0.18697519600391388,
-0.39461749792099,
-0.40794530510902405,
-0.016966233029961586,
-0.4764947295188904,
0.46288764476776123,
-0.44657260179519653,
-0.6032324433326721,
-0.3207714557647705,
-0.48218828439712524,
-0.11475227773189545,
-0.03392956405878067,
0.2729223370552063,
0.9282724857330322,
0.009100516326725483,
0.08521053194999695,
0.5570000410079956,
-0.19624221324920654,
0.7269052863121033,
0.3269203007221222,
-0.27095240354537964,
-0.6490174531936646,
0.7809934020042419,
0.10520630329847336,
0.04323494806885719,
0.4155639410018921,
0.18774248659610748,
-0.40407854318618774,
-0.21701160073280334,
-0.4833020567893982,
0.19023892283439636,
-0.7660893201828003,
-0.42427751421928406,
-0.3845328390598297,
-0.17683491110801697,
-0.5912278294563293,
-0.3970458507537842,
0.20149891078472137,
-0.6690978407859802,
-0.6094082593917847,
-0.19430342316627502,
0.7814433574676514,
1.3571439981460571,
0.0906953290104866,
0.2597118616104126,
-1.0688514709472656,
0.24630014598369598,
0.5012722611427307,
0.234264075756073,
0.3187486529350281,
-0.3335384726524353,
-0.24411927163600922,
0.0009047956555150449,
-0.18033289909362793,
-1.0386996269226074,
0.6195069551467896,
-0.10113988071680069,
0.21782103180885315,
0.4225292205810547,
0.14565983414649963,
0.6342471241950989,
-0.6260297894477844,
1.0963245630264282,
0.18399973213672638,
-0.87110835313797,
0.6241064667701721,
-0.5649926066398621,
0.4480219781398773,
0.037329599261283875,
0.36515673995018005,
-0.8262110948562622,
-0.3068203628063202,
-0.40917640924453735,
-0.7586863040924072,
0.7423932552337646,
-0.04457380622625351,
0.3867133557796478,
-0.5709195137023926,
0.6153154969215393,
0.28300976753234863,
0.6342120170593262,
-0.6095896363258362,
-0.22323140501976013,
-0.08414726704359055,
-0.27529001235961914,
0.2174636870622635,
-0.2555009424686432,
0.03014204278588295,
0.0775841772556305,
0.2416723519563675,
-0.2881947457790375,
0.16043721139431,
0.18227750062942505,
0.35168734192848206,
-0.09858053922653198,
0.2828871011734009,
0.9234054684638977,
0.5654929280281067,
0.2906828820705414,
-0.03161492198705673,
0.034241318702697754,
-0.11014586687088013,
-0.02787001244723797,
-0.09788528084754944,
-0.2774735987186432,
0.23582123219966888,
0.054488375782966614,
0.7723817825317383,
0.3405381739139557,
-0.6417176127433777,
0.2883443832397461,
-0.03821286931633949,
-0.25838202238082886,
-0.14511068165302277,
-0.09594158828258514,
-0.10124780237674713,
0.01409410871565342,
0.5040906667709351,
-0.10192087292671204,
0.23152269423007965,
-0.5414150357246399,
0.24311870336532593,
0.2645004689693451,
-0.017918070778250694,
-0.39784330129623413,
0.838296115398407,
0.29787522554397583,
-0.25253015756607056,
0.8159582614898682,
-0.13308073580265045,
-0.4459243714809418,
0.7446594834327698,
0.7535994648933411,
0.8974266052246094,
0.0461125485599041,
0.24388952553272247,
0.3906938135623932,
-0.0787816271185875,
-0.18915535509586334,
0.7640910744667053,
-0.23846477270126343,
-0.2857520282268524,
-0.8696503043174744,
-0.4185398817062378,
-0.7336373925209045,
-0.14429491758346558,
-0.41300898790359497,
0.5258224606513977,
-0.8096902966499329,
-0.5913757085800171,
0.2947637438774109,
-0.4357319474220276,
-0.5542821884155273,
-0.07137315720319748,
0.44562190771102905,
0.9104311466217041,
-0.6884564161300659,
0.40106257796287537,
0.773036777973175,
-0.44351890683174133,
-1.0497039556503296,
-0.18254822492599487,
-0.027742717415094376,
-0.9799925088882446,
1.0243985652923584,
0.3179878294467926,
0.11017218977212906,
-0.1908462941646576,
-0.8597104549407959,
-0.671615481376648,
0.5905633568763733,
0.24956512451171875,
-0.5806900858879089,
-0.09817628562450409,
0.7415472269058228,
0.38579851388931274,
-0.48183563351631165,
0.013512908481061459,
0.14776168763637543,
0.5469516515731812,
0.41501012444496155,
-0.6211192011833191,
0.23853124678134918,
-0.6102292537689209,
0.1283075213432312,
0.428574800491333,
-0.5244663953781128,
0.8448761105537415,
-0.3246309459209442,
-0.18514381349086761,
0.22098666429519653,
0.6968621611595154,
0.3663339614868164,
0.5430601835250854,
0.20850412547588348,
0.13385622203350067,
0.6822719573974609,
-0.043127018958330154,
1.0193930864334106,
-0.5457485914230347,
-0.04826036095619202,
0.8582993149757385,
-0.4977736175060272,
0.8885743021965027,
0.423723965883255,
-0.3438739776611328,
0.9014052152633667,
0.8108532428741455,
-0.10683519393205643,
0.1805708110332489,
0.5175396800041199,
-0.25914016366004944,
-0.08054943382740021,
-0.09238136559724808,
-0.38173985481262207,
-0.12577173113822937,
0.614122748374939,
-0.5279819369316101,
-0.08473389595746994,
-0.334809273481369,
0.023480519652366638,
-0.08914200961589813,
-0.200303852558136,
0.9712795615196228,
0.357850044965744,
-0.8479405641555786,
0.16150277853012085,
-0.08238480240106583,
0.4329610764980316,
-0.6512554287910461,
-0.3006380796432495,
-0.2153700292110443,
-0.16314445436000824,
-0.17761412262916565,
-0.9235170483589172,
0.3152097761631012,
0.4264455735683441,
-0.4272843897342682,
-0.43578916788101196,
0.3438819944858551,
-0.2687784731388092,
-0.4990388751029968,
-0.5049947500228882,
0.1027909591794014,
0.21313942968845367,
0.18287138640880585,
-0.4096488356590271,
0.013744112104177475,
0.09878931939601898,
-0.46321481466293335,
-0.03851647302508354,
0.6167234778404236,
-0.15444542467594147,
0.42379599809646606,
1.1271519660949707,
-0.1682036817073822,
0.1203528344631195,
0.2583242356777191,
0.8235662579536438,
-1.082502007484436,
-0.5681016445159912,
-1.0934035778045654,
0.3836486339569092,
0.003543627681210637,
-0.14115113019943237,
0.8252968192100525,
0.5256735682487488,
0.26012033224105835,
-0.3072241246700287,
1.082128643989563,
0.24544589221477509,
0.3023350238800049,
-0.6180117130279541,
0.2814785838127136,
-0.2669960558414459,
0.40271833539009094,
-0.2401910126209259,
-0.8803278207778931,
-0.3477276861667633,
0.20529577136039734,
-0.3509463667869568,
0.0597863607108593,
0.44059276580810547,
0.6685563921928406,
0.37900611758232117,
0.2706459164619446,
0.008557542227208614,
0.24387302994728088,
0.28131768107414246,
0.32367056608200073,
1.0267503261566162,
0.021500278264284134,
0.5875999331474304,
0.10010138899087906,
0.05166316404938698,
-0.25107643008232117,
-1.2708789110183716,
-0.890498161315918,
-0.21410244703292847,
-0.283077210187912,
-0.59613436460495,
-0.14184331893920898,
1.1571035385131836,
0.19891472160816193,
-0.8242829442024231,
-0.4777281880378723,
0.05837024748325348,
-0.12501633167266846,
0.306352436542511,
-0.2489638328552246,
0.21452851593494415,
-0.4645821452140808,
-0.6389760971069336,
0.31407278776168823,
0.4949306547641754,
0.43021827936172485,
-0.37320834398269653,
0.012044001370668411,
0.5940440893173218,
0.42559343576431274,
0.6830687522888184,
0.5493983626365662,
-0.3482358157634735,
-0.007702122442424297,
0.4571045935153961,
-0.13485246896743774,
0.1346174031496048,
1.3767496347427368,
-0.9024343490600586,
0.1886589676141739,
0.7724582552909851,
0.4282662868499756,
0.3183724582195282,
0.1532476395368576,
1.1285961866378784,
-0.8751150965690613,
0.18680375814437866,
-0.0989542081952095,
0.25476163625717163,
0.3030770421028137,
-0.531458854675293,
0.2514354884624481,
0.21278952062129974,
-0.462253212928772,
-0.8760658502578735,
0.013120591640472412,
-0.8639844059944153,
-0.16464613378047943,
1.1514437198638916,
0.255467027425766,
-0.37287095189094543,
0.17812618613243103,
-0.38607242703437805,
-0.10699384659528732,
-0.8848323822021484,
0.7080884575843811,
0.7893351912498474,
-0.08849456161260605,
0.07970020174980164,
-0.2847437858581543,
0.48101338744163513,
0.20414043962955475,
-0.6113781929016113,
0.43061956763267517,
0.4553427994251251,
-0.08554193377494812,
-0.04606262594461441,
0.6652056574821472,
-0.0252555962651968,
0.47931432723999023,
-0.04317356273531914,
-0.40698543190956116,
0.029287435114383698,
-0.08523964881896973,
-0.3741556406021118,
0.268971711397171,
0.4081140458583832,
0.21318651735782623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02456v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02456v2
|
PhonologyBench: Evaluating Phonological Skills of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T04:53:14 | 2024-04-05T04:55:24 |
Ashima Suvarna, Harshita Khandelwal, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Phonology, the study of speech's structure and pronunciation rules, is a
critical yet often overlooked component in Large Language Model (LLM) research.
LLMs are widely used in various downstream applications that leverage phonology
such as educational tools and poetry generation. Moreover, LLMs can potentially
learn imperfect associations between orthographic and phonological forms from
the training data. Thus, it is imperative to benchmark the phonological skills
of LLMs. To this end, we present PhonologyBench, a novel benchmark consisting
of three diagnostic tasks designed to explicitly test the phonological skills
of LLMs in English: grapheme-to-phoneme conversion, syllable counting, and
rhyme word generation. Despite having no access to speech data, LLMs showcased
notable performance on the PhonologyBench tasks. However, we observe a
significant gap of 17% and 45% on Rhyme Word Generation and Syllable counting,
respectively, when compared to humans. Our findings underscore the importance
of studying LLM performance on phonological tasks that inadvertently impact
real-world applications. Furthermore, we encourage researchers to choose LLMs
that perform well on the phonological task that is closely related to the
downstream application since we find that no single model consistently
outperforms the others on all the tasks.
|
[
-0.35458552837371826,
-0.6456078886985779,
0.5596312284469604,
-0.01589217782020569,
-0.3264297544956207,
-0.11838387697935104,
-0.2546585500240326,
-0.3795439600944519,
-0.00031185318948701024,
0.44129490852355957,
-0.37221759557724,
-0.8183894753456116,
-0.330312579870224,
0.05444149300456047,
-0.31267932057380676,
0.4547930359840393,
0.16914062201976776,
0.17995597422122955,
-0.2761510908603668,
-0.03925285115838051,
-0.44402459263801575,
-0.4989751875400543,
-0.6469801664352417,
-0.6594480276107788,
0.4624747037887573,
0.42602142691612244,
0.43140172958374023,
0.7202866673469543,
0.5133878588676453,
0.28111904859542847,
-0.26730579137802124,
-0.0077172452583909035,
-0.44393670558929443,
0.21392491459846497,
-0.09826250374317169,
-0.4785047173500061,
-0.5455532073974609,
0.01230539195239544,
0.8204315900802612,
1.2417573928833008,
-0.31102848052978516,
0.21366733312606812,
0.1145910769701004,
0.5607298016548157,
-0.4718130826950073,
0.19825193285942078,
-0.5024653673171997,
0.08458419889211655,
-0.7381516695022583,
-0.09634443372488022,
-0.4023100435733795,
-0.2879352271556854,
-0.09786883741617203,
-0.3890714943408966,
0.19640101492404938,
0.14571388065814972,
0.4606895446777344,
0.1645359992980957,
-0.2030307948589325,
-0.03671449422836304,
-0.428284615278244,
0.5850518941879272,
-0.7391303777694702,
0.6573392748832703,
0.32349732518196106,
0.17332257330417633,
-0.38856184482574463,
-0.6572685837745667,
-0.6084305047988892,
-0.4988507628440857,
0.1058545857667923,
0.09648668020963669,
-0.08566247671842575,
0.26214274764060974,
0.42405393719673157,
0.5168682336807251,
-0.9300960302352905,
0.31931933760643005,
-0.13929800689220428,
-0.33609405159950256,
0.5141396522521973,
0.2223963886499405,
0.24897892773151398,
-0.22744697332382202,
0.01630990207195282,
-0.39940187335014343,
-0.4294847249984741,
0.09185706079006195,
0.5373249053955078,
0.40651002526283264,
-0.14053218066692352,
0.6545158624649048,
-0.11060462146997452,
0.8008977770805359,
-0.4575060307979584,
-0.49448615312576294,
0.5154804587364197,
0.02743670344352722,
0.005822117440402508,
0.315361350774765,
0.7327895760536194,
0.059613537043333054,
0.31417205929756165,
-0.24208764731884003,
-0.18927417695522308,
0.20818760991096497,
-0.16519738733768463,
-0.6412843465805054,
-0.2119491696357727,
0.10866066068410873,
-0.2650514543056488,
-0.05667754262685776,
-0.06749829649925232,
-0.6924853920936584,
-0.6805710196495056,
-0.08473236858844757,
0.21996241807937622,
-0.5656819343566895,
-0.3706406354904175,
0.06689988076686859,
-0.18556737899780273,
0.12126550823450089,
-0.054812442511320114,
-0.6519629955291748,
0.5064754486083984,
0.9752577543258667,
0.950074315071106,
-0.318867951631546,
-0.7765222787857056,
-0.6939831972122192,
-0.15185312926769257,
-0.49919041991233826,
0.7025417685508728,
-0.39855173230171204,
-0.7301791310310364,
-0.12482992559671402,
-0.025100411847233772,
-0.12855282425880432,
-0.8710184693336487,
0.6806643605232239,
-0.16253796219825745,
-0.268334299325943,
-0.1101590245962143,
-0.8404698967933655,
-0.12841901183128357,
0.10446842014789581,
-0.7026026248931885,
1.0526845455169678,
0.07572651654481888,
-0.55741286277771,
0.2186330109834671,
-0.18484076857566833,
-0.5724703073501587,
0.254721075296402,
-0.18369844555854797,
-0.22692666947841644,
0.25364699959754944,
-0.4106799066066742,
0.44372543692588806,
-0.40509819984436035,
0.15258458256721497,
-0.40077072381973267,
-0.5327561497688293,
0.3402824103832245,
-0.18352855741977692,
0.5611348748207092,
-0.11207141727209091,
-0.2500564157962799,
-0.07377234846353531,
-1.0100353956222534,
0.09973709285259247,
0.06753569841384888,
-0.2832397222518921,
-0.1594235897064209,
-0.12088903039693832,
-0.06580806523561478,
0.07738310098648071,
-0.07107783108949661,
-0.5212456583976746,
-0.06883379071950912,
-0.6241021752357483,
0.3267931044101715,
0.39907142519950867,
0.01803336851298809,
0.14303608238697052,
-0.4644331634044647,
0.5278993248939514,
-0.2572973668575287,
-0.25194790959358215,
-0.12169338017702103,
-0.4886150658130646,
-0.48232704401016235,
-0.27253592014312744,
0.47968292236328125,
0.4614740312099457,
-0.02040916308760643,
0.34446007013320923,
-0.2851825952529907,
-0.7501882314682007,
-0.5295480489730835,
0.22643648087978363,
0.3879014849662781,
0.6042410731315613,
0.18795619904994965,
-0.6570998430252075,
-0.35552191734313965,
-0.7343650460243225,
-0.43671685457229614,
-0.19776669144630432,
-0.10516142845153809,
0.20242422819137573,
0.17913216352462769,
0.10568013042211533,
0.47036314010620117,
-0.22750644385814667,
-0.2096657156944275,
-0.11299578100442886,
0.25596314668655396,
0.20481668412685394,
0.1857546865940094,
0.15658530592918396,
-0.2559642493724823,
-0.0711514875292778,
0.013026837259531021,
-0.45166757702827454,
-0.36615806818008423,
0.44617703557014465,
0.03383118659257889,
0.23466886579990387,
0.7883709669113159,
-0.7155866622924805,
0.13294240832328796,
0.6945044994354248,
-0.20077526569366455,
0.6720011830329895,
-0.0814395621418953,
-0.08691078424453735,
-0.7110124826431274,
0.45564088225364685,
-0.24736370146274567,
-0.24463312327861786,
-0.47880274057388306,
-0.07300809025764465,
0.023023098707199097,
-0.4346682131290436,
-0.1746283620595932,
0.6035872101783752,
-0.46939340233802795,
-0.4784863293170929,
-0.17308129370212555,
0.5122249722480774,
-0.12748119235038757,
0.21655026078224182,
-0.14239604771137238,
0.5748178362846375,
0.4714870750904083,
-0.47138717770576477,
0.48789697885513306,
-0.04840913787484169,
-0.5680508017539978,
0.5680150985717773,
-0.4285401999950409,
0.23760280013084412,
0.024249251931905746,
0.030339315533638,
-1.246003270149231,
-0.18226005136966705,
-0.16176201403141022,
-0.4029417932033539,
0.3305036723613739,
-0.011817870661616325,
-0.523569643497467,
-0.3960230052471161,
-0.07796896994113922,
0.3835127353668213,
0.7188882231712341,
-0.1733688861131668,
0.5772720575332642,
0.50593101978302,
-0.2031976580619812,
-0.15874573588371277,
-0.5908942222595215,
-0.18806444108486176,
-0.31091970205307007,
-0.5660681128501892,
0.21418969333171844,
0.13773754239082336,
-0.474934846162796,
0.014402943663299084,
-0.24779613316059113,
0.1874416172504425,
0.2021052986383438,
0.37957075238227844,
-0.14632000029087067,
-0.30631959438323975,
0.3150929808616638,
-0.5471084713935852,
-0.22777114808559418,
0.1829897165298462,
-0.23274177312850952,
0.8736753463745117,
0.05114741250872612,
-0.39230579137802124,
-0.46861034631729126,
-0.07370783388614655,
0.6691328883171082,
-0.4249560534954071,
0.3533116281032562,
0.43908149003982544,
-0.1749640256166458,
-0.5359043478965759,
-0.6252882480621338,
-0.2089463621377945,
-0.39355024695396423,
0.45434656739234924,
-0.4849618673324585,
-0.6017237901687622,
0.5263033509254456,
-0.3553817570209503,
-0.3231862485408783,
0.2292146235704422,
0.4143126606941223,
0.05708228424191475,
0.7526823282241821,
0.4592582881450653,
-0.21113844215869904,
0.2465600222349167,
-0.06201888993382454,
0.16804875433444977,
-0.6898752450942993,
-0.08922737091779709,
-0.5480493903160095,
-0.23126709461212158,
-0.6423550248146057,
-0.45822811126708984,
0.41335898637771606,
0.011655888520181179,
-0.09340345859527588,
-0.0022765742614865303,
-0.23357036709785461,
0.2679145634174347,
0.43291500210762024,
-0.007530027534812689,
0.36161288619041443,
-0.07976863533258438,
-0.36911246180534363,
-0.06845851987600327,
-0.5020654201507568,
-0.2800351679325104,
0.9560961723327637,
0.11745666712522507,
0.39288416504859924,
0.06845402717590332,
0.720508873462677,
0.1737307906150818,
-0.17989476025104523,
-1.0772258043289185,
0.8192774057388306,
-0.3260648250579834,
-0.13655491173267365,
-0.4237983524799347,
-0.45065850019454956,
-1.1016393899917603,
0.29570215940475464,
0.07476606965065002,
-0.7461449503898621,
-0.07066178321838379,
0.13509097695350647,
-0.19232244789600372,
0.15453432500362396,
-0.454804927110672,
0.9760453104972839,
-0.28989434242248535,
-0.3784412741661072,
-0.384456604719162,
-0.2984204590320587,
0.32329222559928894,
-0.11336137354373932,
0.3483281433582306,
-0.5076121091842651,
-0.03523307666182518,
0.7705639600753784,
-0.3613907992839813,
0.6477845907211304,
-0.2172812521457672,
-0.04484155774116516,
0.09969408065080643,
0.5401797294616699,
0.35307079553604126,
-0.39957132935523987,
-0.33074629306793213,
0.19115176796913147,
0.007799008395522833,
-0.1487436592578888,
-0.3413723409175873,
0.7602949738502502,
-0.6253092885017395,
-0.4361448884010315,
-0.4357856214046478,
-0.5670607686042786,
-0.6803979873657227,
0.3748684525489807,
0.16881254315376282,
0.35316669940948486,
-0.4101058840751648,
0.21863992512226105,
0.4518832862377167,
0.05087081342935562,
0.1891292929649353,
0.6020057797431946,
-0.18554620444774628,
-0.03935159370303154,
1.0042773485183716,
0.2898586094379425,
0.19012753665447235,
0.2092975229024887,
0.4533202052116394,
-0.23668310046195984,
-0.7735068798065186,
-0.05122216045856476,
0.4870452880859375,
-0.6259092688560486,
0.13400329649448395,
-0.35830461978912354,
-0.13819530606269836,
-0.2991201877593994,
0.2610422372817993,
-0.3352562189102173,
-0.24652624130249023,
0.07271892577409744,
-0.07825132459402084,
0.32969042658805847,
0.6947380304336548,
-0.08180029690265656,
0.06744567304849625,
-0.6573845148086548,
0.2566090226173401,
0.31395089626312256,
0.38703659176826477,
0.12527213990688324,
-0.5589373707771301,
-0.044802747666835785,
-0.24389344453811646,
-0.09484699368476868,
-0.7801607847213745,
0.25567832589149475,
0.21727725863456726,
0.6837596893310547,
0.1352611631155014,
-0.2775590121746063,
0.7106585502624512,
-0.6606951355934143,
0.6065713763237,
-0.12113822251558304,
-1.0359368324279785,
0.2225646823644638,
-0.3789600729942322,
0.32534992694854736,
0.521612286567688,
0.2449483722448349,
-0.8061309456825256,
-0.3630048632621765,
-0.6898838877677917,
-1.0557674169540405,
0.5242679715156555,
-0.027360765263438225,
-0.23955315351486206,
0.1905413120985031,
0.2951872646808624,
0.04545515403151512,
0.4071672856807709,
-0.15920744836330414,
0.021812116727232933,
0.11914124339818954,
-0.1205216646194458,
-0.45984145998954773,
-0.2844783365726471,
-0.11139503121376038,
-0.08502960950136185,
0.5814430713653564,
-0.009961297735571861,
-0.25318917632102966,
0.12351944297552109,
-0.19058562815189362,
-0.20634083449840546,
0.17273451387882233,
0.4147297441959381,
0.7471746206283569,
-0.08370295912027359,
0.2865178883075714,
0.24330811202526093,
-0.5214279890060425,
0.051920440047979355,
0.3013213872909546,
0.09673697501420975,
0.04398239031434059,
0.6885351538658142,
0.6759149432182312,
0.42388656735420227,
-0.8793695569038391,
0.37294065952301025,
0.1957724690437317,
-0.15915709733963013,
-0.3109774589538574,
0.14114587008953094,
0.4100433588027954,
0.0737755224108696,
0.11173111945390701,
-0.32197490334510803,
0.2523394823074341,
-0.696726381778717,
0.2842894494533539,
0.26549431681632996,
-0.15451709926128387,
-0.2124580442905426,
0.29913029074668884,
0.071132592856884,
-0.5455313920974731,
0.553639829158783,
-0.25897613167762756,
-0.2653008699417114,
0.6111298203468323,
0.35157790780067444,
0.6226019859313965,
-0.4408731460571289,
-0.10371184349060059,
0.2896004021167755,
0.18829508125782013,
-0.2090327888727188,
0.31207549571990967,
0.083564393222332,
-0.6406224966049194,
-0.21798191964626312,
-0.7091954350471497,
-0.5728346705436707,
0.4229140877723694,
-0.7035118341445923,
0.2874341607093811,
-0.3512021601200104,
-0.18290866911411285,
0.27286943793296814,
0.06977932155132294,
-0.649673342704773,
-0.005187727976590395,
0.4336334764957428,
0.8642018437385559,
-0.6853376626968384,
0.6277664303779602,
0.49525657296180725,
-0.007991797290742397,
-1.1075297594070435,
0.165162593126297,
0.2591770887374878,
-0.9961850643157959,
0.46743854880332947,
0.22953830659389496,
-0.2540060579776764,
0.327640175819397,
0.007722658105194569,
-0.6885923743247986,
0.9906739592552185,
0.5564521551132202,
-0.837039589881897,
0.2263282686471939,
0.2706792652606964,
0.6090149283409119,
-0.0748436450958252,
0.17332138121128082,
0.9508625864982605,
0.5009528994560242,
-0.05647430941462517,
-1.2112151384353638,
-0.09997252374887466,
-0.17422552406787872,
0.006814951077103615,
0.2645716667175293,
-0.7485154867172241,
0.9632955193519592,
0.07797933369874954,
-0.25324589014053345,
0.21456971764564514,
0.24535544216632843,
0.4467723071575165,
0.0908816009759903,
0.5686267614364624,
0.8471534848213196,
1.1857153177261353,
-0.12254612892866135,
1.0744233131408691,
-0.5795730948448181,
0.16883277893066406,
0.9470078349113464,
-0.7071068286895752,
0.9692445993423462,
0.2895028591156006,
-0.26588860154151917,
0.3442413806915283,
0.526533842086792,
-0.012968029826879501,
0.10235650837421417,
0.7303764820098877,
-0.10284963250160217,
-0.3434429466724396,
-0.2639903128147125,
-0.33445459604263306,
0.7975877523422241,
0.3398655652999878,
0.08815125375986099,
-0.14108583331108093,
-0.1413196325302124,
0.14046785235404968,
0.2427321970462799,
-0.34878236055374146,
0.6824315786361694,
0.24746115505695343,
-0.563526451587677,
0.619927167892456,
-0.13342705368995667,
0.3764151632785797,
-0.7901751399040222,
-0.0525025837123394,
-0.24127253890037537,
0.31015151739120483,
-0.20868565142154694,
-0.7149062156677246,
-0.053853780031204224,
-0.19063057005405426,
0.044460684061050415,
0.20150123536586761,
0.48955395817756653,
-0.41151776909828186,
-0.4084200859069824,
0.6509639024734497,
0.6247501373291016,
0.4391901195049286,
0.008740493096411228,
-0.46515709161758423,
0.3643572926521301,
-0.4123886525630951,
-0.2616385221481323,
0.2529580295085907,
0.6283006072044373,
-0.02705586887896061,
0.5102371573448181,
0.5320771336555481,
0.5748946666717529,
0.0068478770554065704,
0.3928965628147125,
0.47823214530944824,
-0.696490466594696,
-0.5291104912757874,
-0.8468759059906006,
0.20148496329784393,
0.02989894151687622,
-0.31188997626304626,
0.8215582370758057,
0.663180410861969,
0.9745110273361206,
0.3158295154571533,
0.7226425409317017,
0.34715941548347473,
0.7577044367790222,
-0.5650125741958618,
0.5574975609779358,
-0.5659878253936768,
0.020344886928796768,
-0.17757312953472137,
-0.8657799363136292,
-0.28453734517097473,
0.5041859149932861,
-0.41608792543411255,
0.15500447154045105,
0.9738842844963074,
0.8255220651626587,
-0.003257748205214739,
-0.06457992643117905,
0.659913182258606,
0.4749811291694641,
-0.07443799078464508,
0.45525801181793213,
0.7487084865570068,
-0.04239092767238617,
0.4897012710571289,
-0.34703442454338074,
-0.08568676561117172,
-0.18035461008548737,
-0.7900377511978149,
-0.7984237670898438,
-0.4459646940231323,
0.0551307313144207,
-0.2684181332588196,
0.13583673536777496,
0.6333492994308472,
0.5459461808204651,
-0.6754238605499268,
-0.8868741393089294,
-0.1443585902452469,
-0.07145677506923676,
-0.28316494822502136,
-0.22457484900951385,
0.3816714286804199,
-0.20995405316352844,
-0.6350173354148865,
0.6772540807723999,
0.1332853138446808,
-0.08070743083953857,
-0.2992151081562042,
0.11425141990184784,
0.12276023626327515,
-0.2795201241970062,
0.27435243129730225,
0.32124489545822144,
-0.5243383049964905,
-0.02752341702580452,
-0.09860502928495407,
-0.10187100619077682,
-0.03222678229212761,
1.051877498626709,
-0.5107312202453613,
0.4354431629180908,
0.6114273071289062,
0.5246555209159851,
0.40738725662231445,
-0.0929005891084671,
0.502526044845581,
-0.6417025923728943,
0.4654233753681183,
0.4487856328487396,
0.4723888039588928,
0.5762186050415039,
-0.09907639026641846,
0.42851823568344116,
0.46355190873146057,
-0.5488669276237488,
-1.0379265546798706,
0.18755996227264404,
-0.8719261884689331,
-0.17840100824832916,
1.0509039163589478,
0.0714351087808609,
-0.3494049906730652,
-0.019495030865073204,
-0.03855285793542862,
0.26224565505981445,
-0.29711517691612244,
0.49251437187194824,
0.8753738403320312,
-0.2096319943666458,
-0.21018266677856445,
-0.707660436630249,
0.4950534701347351,
0.5704874396324158,
-0.35904771089553833,
0.10469209402799606,
0.4031543433666229,
0.2648186981678009,
0.15240183472633362,
0.6945880651473999,
-0.052567195147275925,
0.3389383852481842,
0.1648009866476059,
0.4237141013145447,
-0.1935819685459137,
-0.2429352104663849,
-0.5174386501312256,
0.32577863335609436,
0.5451772212982178,
-0.07823891192674637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02452v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02452v1
|
Adaptive Cross-lingual Text Classification through In-Context One-Shot Demonstrations
| 2024-04-03T04:40:57 | 2024-04-03T04:40:57 |
Emilio Villa-Cueva, A. Pastor López-Monroy, Fernando Sánchez-Vega, Thamar Solorio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Zero-Shot Cross-lingual Transfer (ZS-XLT) utilizes a model trained in a
source language to make predictions in another language, often with a
performance loss. To alleviate this, additional improvements can be achieved
through subsequent adaptation using examples in the target language. In this
paper, we exploit In-Context Tuning (ICT) for One-Shot Cross-lingual transfer
in the classification task by introducing In-Context Cross-lingual Transfer
(IC-XLT). The novel concept involves training a model to learn from context
examples and subsequently adapting it during inference to a target language by
prepending a One-Shot context demonstration in that language. Our results show
that IC-XLT successfully leverages target-language examples to improve the
cross-lingual capabilities of the evaluated mT5 model, outperforming
prompt-based models in the Zero and Few-shot scenarios adapted through
fine-tuning. Moreover, we show that when source-language data is limited, the
fine-tuning framework employed for IC-XLT performs comparably to prompt-based
fine-tuning with significantly more training data in the source language.
|
[
-0.20881837606430054,
-0.5863502025604248,
0.313847154378891,
0.1022961437702179,
-0.46693888306617737,
-0.14131830632686615,
-0.19920110702514648,
-0.4693434536457062,
-0.35367369651794434,
0.3374424874782562,
-0.5938426852226257,
-0.36560025811195374,
-0.450603187084198,
0.20417821407318115,
-0.36433887481689453,
1.1589699983596802,
-0.26913508772850037,
0.04993052780628204,
0.17657919228076935,
-0.1077272817492485,
-0.7514284253120422,
-0.3894695043563843,
-0.8809892535209656,
-0.12194973975419998,
0.3663784861564636,
0.9612636566162109,
0.21428392827510834,
0.495536744594574,
0.06384911388158798,
0.16834579408168793,
0.3633538484573364,
-0.10357169806957245,
-0.43328583240509033,
-0.2151021510362625,
-0.6693007349967957,
-0.5178298950195312,
-0.0795988067984581,
-0.2017369270324707,
0.8324118256568909,
0.5690802931785583,
0.25602084398269653,
-0.051104284822940826,
0.2074051946401596,
0.37216606736183167,
-0.5683751702308655,
0.01757253333926201,
-0.7616046667098999,
0.2227993905544281,
-0.12866832315921783,
-0.5382022261619568,
-0.7583395838737488,
0.1153312399983406,
0.2491483986377716,
-0.8346841931343079,
-0.03529663756489754,
0.2741597294807434,
0.7973347306251526,
0.08948049694299698,
-0.5160664916038513,
-0.16349627077579498,
-0.5240189433097839,
0.857192873954773,
-0.6573056578636169,
0.3504609167575836,
0.41019266843795776,
0.3992704153060913,
0.24909727275371552,
-0.5662104487419128,
-0.4824812710285187,
0.016034988686442375,
-0.13864535093307495,
0.2270340770483017,
-0.256283164024353,
-0.10530908405780792,
0.09913035482168198,
-0.12987178564071655,
-0.5726102590560913,
0.38809454441070557,
-0.23256142437458038,
-0.136178120970726,
0.27477118372917175,
-0.0071220132522284985,
0.5362768769264221,
0.016773318871855736,
-0.6840819120407104,
-0.10251198709011078,
-0.6483561396598816,
0.2016785442829132,
-0.04680965840816498,
0.7330678701400757,
-0.21453307569026947,
0.2010764479637146,
-0.1908653825521469,
0.8010202050209045,
0.41277173161506653,
-0.037205591797828674,
0.04401751235127449,
-0.549970805644989,
-0.40828800201416016,
0.7414567470550537,
0.5414260625839233,
0.32719406485557556,
0.1883956491947174,
-0.22786270081996918,
0.0367925651371479,
-0.2096615731716156,
0.04018760845065117,
-1.0365290641784668,
0.27710965275764465,
-0.3128003776073456,
-0.27019086480140686,
-0.042793504893779755,
-0.06741973012685776,
-0.44352537393569946,
0.0769856795668602,
-0.2882186472415924,
0.8449781537055969,
-0.6649181246757507,
-0.05995187535881996,
0.3064468502998352,
-0.1392735242843628,
0.15078914165496826,
0.4416159689426422,
-0.9613216519355774,
0.33820149302482605,
0.4165836572647095,
0.8875165581703186,
-0.32532283663749695,
-0.6191715002059937,
-0.9248063564300537,
0.33096635341644287,
-0.4731849133968353,
1.077876329421997,
-0.36655372381210327,
-0.022747093811631203,
0.06892174482345581,
0.19837871193885803,
-0.39213764667510986,
-0.2591691315174103,
0.5030367374420166,
-0.21768084168434143,
0.5262665748596191,
-0.20138490200042725,
-0.5116079449653625,
-0.3522644340991974,
0.40251049399375916,
-0.1919858753681183,
0.8505212664604187,
0.47063320875167847,
-0.7625133395195007,
0.6882761120796204,
-0.8113230466842651,
-0.6368461847305298,
0.1970919370651245,
0.18683084845542908,
-0.24137797951698303,
-0.2008219063282013,
0.17720822989940643,
0.5752398371696472,
-0.15789347887039185,
-0.2163638472557068,
-0.13187189400196075,
-0.6839540004730225,
-0.09947726875543594,
-0.3288858234882355,
0.8860620260238647,
0.05178682133555412,
-0.5105237364768982,
0.013505198992788792,
-0.8738500475883484,
0.024103732779622078,
-0.37577319145202637,
-0.23234644532203674,
-0.6567736268043518,
-0.3282572627067566,
0.31453150510787964,
0.41394296288490295,
-0.18164850771427155,
-0.6009772419929504,
0.242613285779953,
-0.4266788363456726,
0.17732688784599304,
0.45546260476112366,
-0.12195365130901337,
0.6587843298912048,
-0.4118403196334839,
0.5928075313568115,
0.20788754522800446,
-0.11863943189382553,
-0.5627987384796143,
-0.08170337975025177,
-0.6546317338943481,
-0.2985996603965759,
0.6299272775650024,
0.9042368531227112,
-1.3365885019302368,
0.19593697786331177,
-0.5441889762878418,
-0.3250623643398285,
-0.3743211627006531,
0.04261632263660431,
0.4848096966743469,
0.8534491658210754,
0.4115492105484009,
-0.28497883677482605,
-0.31309574842453003,
-0.730536699295044,
-0.20526161789894104,
-0.1474093645811081,
-0.10191211104393005,
0.19636820256710052,
0.13327628374099731,
0.06243355572223663,
0.7610761523246765,
0.11529619246721268,
-0.46956437826156616,
-0.4811209440231323,
0.4248092770576477,
-0.09369910508394241,
0.4888519048690796,
1.0034818649291992,
-0.612352192401886,
-1.1800371408462524,
0.6602820754051208,
-0.5203846096992493,
-0.4022774398326874,
-0.38059866428375244,
-0.10428886115550995,
0.4611750841140747,
0.642276406288147,
0.006523774471133947,
0.39838913083076477,
0.48631343245506287,
-0.6281700730323792,
0.35880550742149353,
-0.18827424943447113,
0.4442119002342224,
-1.1628406047821045,
-0.23660808801651,
-0.04685313627123833,
-0.5191055536270142,
-0.725849449634552,
-0.2605746388435364,
0.3368789851665497,
0.17655982077121735,
-0.8574297428131104,
0.7687116861343384,
-0.2988707423210144,
-0.010147065855562687,
-0.4342540502548218,
0.10057029873132706,
-0.09065061062574387,
0.5210275053977966,
0.2274872213602066,
0.6995822787284851,
0.995381236076355,
-0.6838465332984924,
-0.03839889168739319,
0.21619971096515656,
-0.5188795328140259,
1.049176812171936,
-0.19098545610904694,
0.01983887143433094,
0.05807974562048912,
0.14734472334384918,
-0.9459918737411499,
0.2084082067012787,
0.3227063715457916,
-0.2698124349117279,
0.5092005133628845,
-0.32411959767341614,
-0.4359380006790161,
0.3154633045196533,
-0.09652183949947357,
0.43847253918647766,
0.3391425907611847,
-0.7348249554634094,
0.49789491295814514,
-0.24606360495090485,
-0.39594000577926636,
-0.5005778670310974,
-0.8734638690948486,
0.11060014367103577,
-0.25834140181541443,
-0.3661138117313385,
0.6092857718467712,
-0.13589335978031158,
0.1752658486366272,
0.028763212263584137,
0.0426875576376915,
-0.08741482347249985,
0.04152848944067955,
-0.13439808785915375,
0.1683928221464157,
-0.3729957640171051,
0.15157005190849304,
0.6174978613853455,
-0.00582880899310112,
-0.31234535574913025,
-0.4507385492324829,
0.22015205025672913,
0.21199776232242584,
-0.2509710192680359,
-0.4998018741607666,
0.3501955568790436,
0.5372366309165955,
0.18785400688648224,
0.4429243206977844,
0.7229645252227783,
-0.22586961090564728,
-0.556857168674469,
0.02056218311190605,
-0.02698673866689205,
-0.39413443207740784,
0.477068692445755,
-0.6565128564834595,
-0.8228409290313721,
0.351152628660202,
-0.11296150833368301,
0.06545168161392212,
0.21082818508148193,
0.2722581624984741,
0.22728176414966583,
1.0026482343673706,
1.0161452293395996,
-0.26475924253463745,
0.9508191347122192,
0.12660327553749084,
-0.007672400213778019,
-0.610295832157135,
0.3121803104877472,
-0.5817104578018188,
-0.16979196667671204,
-0.47571587562561035,
-0.04713115096092224,
0.30664947628974915,
0.08369375765323639,
-0.356331467628479,
0.7628296613693237,
-0.1633765995502472,
0.4701632261276245,
0.4707488715648651,
0.1936667114496231,
0.27070730924606323,
0.26232218742370605,
-0.4171026051044464,
-0.12877294421195984,
-1.2096203565597534,
-0.1522642821073532,
0.5832988023757935,
0.1583772450685501,
0.5566551089286804,
-0.01602991484105587,
0.28386998176574707,
0.18131029605865479,
0.5486128926277161,
-0.7052255868911743,
0.32548588514328003,
-0.5259208083152771,
-0.3430820405483246,
-0.37979310750961304,
-0.34004703164100647,
-0.7066988348960876,
0.270302951335907,
-0.19456368684768677,
-0.82935631275177,
0.24766457080841064,
-0.01593877002596855,
-0.3600437343120575,
0.2884722054004669,
-0.7101345658302307,
1.0303891897201538,
-0.30175670981407166,
-0.5291487574577332,
-0.10201278328895569,
-0.5947626233100891,
0.0871591567993164,
-0.26653867959976196,
0.2493959665298462,
0.16001899540424347,
0.07122191041707993,
0.5150338411331177,
0.019344141706824303,
0.9971321225166321,
-0.04659480229020119,
-0.2247014045715332,
0.10127262771129608,
0.29569539427757263,
0.3322109282016754,
-0.2332114726305008,
-0.2817896902561188,
0.0997655838727951,
0.14996536076068878,
-0.41875889897346497,
-0.7322957515716553,
0.513404369354248,
-0.5954017043113708,
-0.23201368749141693,
-0.2918170392513275,
-0.6847025752067566,
-0.24255315959453583,
0.34382694959640503,
0.49417898058891296,
0.5673224329948425,
-0.1500278115272522,
0.25370848178863525,
0.34999457001686096,
-0.4194231629371643,
0.48849305510520935,
0.9440187215805054,
-0.18805941939353943,
-0.09666917473077774,
0.8645760416984558,
0.1927701085805893,
0.5820454955101013,
0.8667876720428467,
0.22182588279247284,
-0.13440759479999542,
-0.6200853586196899,
-1.015926480293274,
-0.20283475518226624,
-0.8180445432662964,
-0.3351636528968811,
-0.34510067105293274,
-0.12083420157432556,
-0.4827570617198944,
-0.5538257360458374,
-0.1363600343465805,
-0.35691753029823303,
-0.33894574642181396,
0.01108572818338871,
0.20766659080982208,
0.3360428512096405,
0.017043301835656166,
0.5795632004737854,
-0.8967824578285217,
0.09585673362016678,
0.23978562653064728,
0.4816308617591858,
-0.3682437837123871,
-1.1802209615707397,
-0.5579572916030884,
-0.06921955198049545,
-0.16853484511375427,
-0.6583775877952576,
0.4885742664337158,
0.5240557789802551,
0.4952594041824341,
0.3567955493927002,
0.20347799360752106,
0.8004665970802307,
-0.5749757289886475,
0.6788402795791626,
0.10346274077892303,
-1.265624761581421,
0.3711468577384949,
-0.24833817780017853,
0.6007713675498962,
0.5789662003517151,
0.5725163221359253,
-0.8098379373550415,
-0.17927029728889465,
-0.1702459156513214,
-0.5186745524406433,
1.294486403465271,
-0.13902752101421356,
0.026575064286589622,
0.10525200515985489,
0.24072735011577606,
0.37317565083503723,
-0.2479967623949051,
-0.8350710272789001,
0.024325504899024963,
-0.3883972465991974,
-0.33339744806289673,
-0.07540283352136612,
0.1550920158624649,
0.29962509870529175,
-0.3551102578639984,
0.8127214908599854,
-0.7294120192527771,
-0.14678871631622314,
0.26553359627723694,
-0.479714959859848,
-0.41468924283981323,
0.4115196466445923,
0.6469001173973083,
0.4520408511161804,
-0.08044301718473434,
0.0642579048871994,
0.5708304643630981,
-0.23609252274036407,
0.09427165985107422,
0.23762810230255127,
-0.4106169044971466,
0.11266040802001953,
0.3577796220779419,
1.1380573511123657,
0.8180682063102722,
-0.5405821204185486,
0.4513736963272095,
-0.1384187936782837,
-0.4327794313430786,
0.2130061686038971,
-0.0382542684674263,
-0.3898569345474243,
0.1796836107969284,
0.36650678515434265,
-0.061685074120759964,
0.2505074739456177,
-0.7046026587486267,
0.22396427392959595,
0.2961548864841461,
-0.706439197063446,
-0.33624890446662903,
0.3441252112388611,
-0.07951722294092178,
-0.2601716220378876,
0.3518097400665283,
-0.12498906999826431,
-0.6518930196762085,
0.5336453914642334,
0.9967882633209229,
0.9207613468170166,
-0.3148394823074341,
0.30235555768013,
0.4718225300312042,
0.2065693885087967,
0.013055292889475822,
-0.0721556693315506,
-0.3751896023750305,
-0.8754971027374268,
-0.513755738735199,
-0.38072413206100464,
-0.5555084943771362,
-0.17932482063770294,
-0.5632637739181519,
0.5901005268096924,
-0.025736410170793533,
0.408886581659317,
0.16917413473129272,
-0.09242279082536697,
-0.4141548275947571,
0.17260782420635223,
0.16794516146183014,
1.2112928628921509,
-0.9100765585899353,
1.1187325716018677,
0.8135923147201538,
-0.09788793325424194,
-0.6087979078292847,
-0.034906741231679916,
-0.2577132284641266,
-0.4653989374637604,
0.7899773716926575,
0.09633217006921768,
-0.1697072833776474,
0.17833799123764038,
-0.47630465030670166,
-0.6751770973205566,
1.0743709802627563,
0.5297390222549438,
-0.5428164601325989,
0.21648778021335602,
0.30126479268074036,
0.5511702299118042,
-0.6128333806991577,
0.2928483784198761,
0.33366215229034424,
0.5518298149108887,
0.04442886635661125,
-1.4062691926956177,
0.037702955305576324,
-0.057060591876506805,
-0.1318897008895874,
-0.012031235732138157,
-0.5114914774894714,
0.734085202217102,
-0.05770963057875633,
-0.42873427271842957,
-0.018752548843622208,
0.41338998079299927,
-0.07510896027088165,
0.4874792695045471,
0.7208800911903381,
0.2834407687187195,
0.1295425295829773,
0.15233495831489563,
1.0636743307113647,
-0.30091631412506104,
0.10692865401506424,
1.0798661708831787,
-0.5249592661857605,
0.8706396818161011,
0.3664405941963196,
0.21669070422649384,
0.5624414086341858,
0.5486425757408142,
0.28628265857696533,
0.7672460675239563,
-0.239207923412323,
-0.3132946491241455,
-0.17152485251426697,
-0.13311350345611572,
-0.09896950423717499,
0.5838963389396667,
0.3106066584587097,
-0.29312190413475037,
-0.5174499750137329,
0.5296814441680908,
-0.13141116499900818,
-0.010751948691904545,
-0.6617178320884705,
0.9804331064224243,
-0.0626310259103775,
-0.8922536373138428,
0.7012282013893127,
0.061805468052625656,
0.8275593519210815,
-0.6550218462944031,
-0.14897316694259644,
-0.1759057641029358,
0.3312063217163086,
0.04094168543815613,
-0.6470528841018677,
0.18000514805316925,
-0.05550675094127655,
-0.11196859180927277,
-0.5421343445777893,
0.8403144478797913,
-0.7924471497535706,
-0.5275285840034485,
0.3927749991416931,
0.3467338979244232,
0.16296891868114471,
-0.04189791530370712,
-0.5249292254447937,
-0.3551701307296753,
0.047890108078718185,
-0.013645247556269169,
0.7509368062019348,
0.9279607534408569,
-0.3503752648830414,
0.47729966044425964,
0.3939046859741211,
-0.046912871301174164,
0.034632522612810135,
0.023369403555989265,
0.6487258076667786,
-0.5862140655517578,
-0.6612858772277832,
-0.6578553318977356,
0.24014583230018616,
0.2587963342666626,
-0.4013344645500183,
0.7802466750144958,
0.44508475065231323,
1.3038402795791626,
-0.19606547057628632,
0.9415829181671143,
0.002816207008436322,
0.5485089421272278,
-0.5880769491195679,
0.6802082657814026,
-0.7350314259529114,
-0.04963406175374985,
-0.3410831689834595,
-0.4608675241470337,
-0.3765746057033539,
0.46845728158950806,
-0.13764964044094086,
-0.16941504180431366,
0.745254635810852,
0.6115351915359497,
-0.39129242300987244,
-0.17590416967868805,
0.8501858115196228,
0.08655410259962082,
-0.020485255867242813,
0.6597483158111572,
0.4905182719230652,
-0.7607762217521667,
0.6067531704902649,
-0.4260048270225525,
-0.22707384824752808,
-0.2472001016139984,
-1.1666290760040283,
-0.8710859417915344,
-0.6336871385574341,
-0.3471849858760834,
-0.010169059969484806,
0.25199028849601746,
0.8930271863937378,
0.9026379585266113,
-0.8857918381690979,
-0.2043379545211792,
0.044020846486091614,
0.040767330676317215,
-0.5759334564208984,
-0.25256240367889404,
0.29417744278907776,
-0.6173830628395081,
-0.9006083607673645,
0.412479430437088,
0.39590826630592346,
0.1098385751247406,
0.13261088728904724,
0.03150508180260658,
-0.13587334752082825,
0.021669985726475716,
1.0037873983383179,
0.36992380023002625,
-0.18126049637794495,
-0.5285359025001526,
0.09759196639060974,
-0.0099619897082448,
0.1351165920495987,
0.7413304448127747,
-0.8731093406677246,
0.3911455273628235,
0.45475804805755615,
0.7645891904830933,
0.5128371715545654,
-0.05913543701171875,
0.5984441637992859,
-0.8512392640113831,
0.1962794065475464,
-0.042085595428943634,
0.3335767090320587,
0.3328447639942169,
-0.4062854051589966,
0.2969215214252472,
-0.006908929441124201,
-0.31242257356643677,
-0.740388035774231,
-0.0266487505286932,
-1.1234315633773804,
-0.551129937171936,
1.096392035484314,
-0.29121026396751404,
-0.20424741506576538,
-0.320890337228775,
-0.5358903408050537,
0.36033275723457336,
-0.16447460651397705,
0.8009449243545532,
0.708949625492096,
0.022013382986187935,
-0.5617071390151978,
-0.36744076013565063,
0.2986898124217987,
0.4994813799858093,
-1.0526182651519775,
0.001211280352436006,
0.1106264740228653,
0.43335068225860596,
0.07235440611839294,
0.48625844717025757,
0.054245978593826294,
0.6314452290534973,
-0.14799576997756958,
-0.05923156440258026,
0.03482404723763466,
-0.34671157598495483,
-0.5468858480453491,
0.040039755403995514,
-0.16788437962532043,
-0.1324623078107834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02936v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02936v3
|
Min-K%++: Improved Baseline for Detecting Pre-Training Data from Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T04:25:01 | 2024-05-23T23:06:49 |
Jingyang Zhang, Jingwei Sun, Eric Yeats, Yang Ouyang, Martin Kuo, Jianyi Zhang, Hao Frank Yang, Hai Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The problem of pre-training data detection for large language models (LLMs)
has received growing attention due to its implications in critical issues like
copyright violation and test data contamination. Despite improved performance,
existing methods (including the state-of-the-art, Min-K%) are mostly developed
upon simple heuristics and lack solid, reasonable foundations. In this work, we
propose a novel and theoretically motivated methodology for pre-training data
detection, named Min-K%++. Specifically, we present a key insight that training
samples tend to be local maxima of the modeled distribution along each input
dimension through maximum likelihood training, which in turn allow us to
insightfully translate the problem into identification of local maxima. Then,
we design our method accordingly that works under the discrete distribution
modeled by LLMs, whose core idea is to determine whether the input forms a mode
or has relatively high probability under the conditional categorical
distribution. Empirically, the proposed method achieves new SOTA performance
across multiple settings. On the WikiMIA benchmark, Min-K%++ outperforms the
runner-up by 6.2% to 10.5% in detection AUROC averaged over five models. On the
more challenging MIMIR benchmark, it consistently improves upon reference-free
methods while performing on par with reference-based method that requires an
extra reference model.
|
[
-0.711198091506958,
-0.7052508592605591,
0.5938493013381958,
-0.03449233993887901,
-0.3018776774406433,
-0.07468187063932419,
-0.2866460382938385,
-0.26603519916534424,
0.2601965367794037,
0.5005478858947754,
-0.5385933518409729,
-0.613875150680542,
-0.6789044141769409,
0.08106034249067307,
-0.35821548104286194,
0.6767460703849792,
0.12035490572452545,
0.1489105373620987,
-0.2656378746032715,
-0.18338385224342346,
-0.24452181160449982,
-0.6726208329200745,
-0.6228876709938049,
-0.31195780634880066,
0.44402220845222473,
0.5773276686668396,
0.4937874376773834,
0.6431166529655457,
0.3866814076900482,
0.20885522663593292,
-0.016260897740721703,
-0.10506045818328857,
-0.5080339312553406,
-0.20849986374378204,
0.4457624554634094,
-0.6749512553215027,
-0.4663199484348297,
-0.007623798213899136,
0.7933084964752197,
0.545711874961853,
-0.07469917088747025,
0.26818710565567017,
-0.11817920953035355,
0.6581956744194031,
-1.0504034757614136,
-0.01671023666858673,
-0.5484259128570557,
0.03504684939980507,
-0.44305485486984253,
-0.3316440284252167,
-0.5129108428955078,
-0.2898382544517517,
-0.27741357684135437,
-0.6350646018981934,
0.15034650266170502,
-0.3528294265270233,
0.8507397174835205,
0.1977100819349289,
-0.5281786322593689,
-0.2281372994184494,
-0.6053210496902466,
0.7050564289093018,
-0.7229577898979187,
0.7032559514045715,
0.7720944285392761,
0.4438420832157135,
-0.21741218864917755,
-0.4858804941177368,
-0.9018594026565552,
-0.5362516641616821,
-0.04480426758527756,
-0.1644103080034256,
-0.17924316227436066,
-0.2259645164012909,
0.46726641058921814,
0.3126274049282074,
-0.4807094931602478,
0.23380334675312042,
0.01975019834935665,
-0.3925093412399292,
0.33715930581092834,
-0.020845897495746613,
0.12472233921289444,
0.023271985352039337,
-0.17005757987499237,
-0.20895183086395264,
-1.1291307210922241,
0.1696932464838028,
0.49532559514045715,
0.26224830746650696,
-0.13424330949783325,
0.40881338715553284,
-0.5206114053726196,
0.6507547497749329,
0.05652257055044174,
-0.2163192182779312,
0.4630492925643921,
-0.508739709854126,
-0.07564087957143784,
-0.1451362818479538,
0.7353980541229248,
-0.08313979208469391,
0.4017443358898163,
0.29932376742362976,
-0.2709721028804779,
0.24253612756729126,
-0.3087945580482483,
-0.9781956672668457,
-0.5126557946205139,
-0.2551426589488983,
-0.3161454200744629,
-0.6017132997512817,
-0.43582579493522644,
-0.35751503705978394,
-0.48913371562957764,
-0.5719022750854492,
0.5270753502845764,
-0.2384052276611328,
-0.36122584342956543,
0.07233127951622009,
0.42582201957702637,
0.22954949736595154,
0.16312234103679657,
-0.7208126783370972,
0.10969482362270355,
0.6521957516670227,
0.5275241136550903,
-0.058014415204524994,
-0.018407095223665237,
-0.7292875647544861,
-0.23808617889881134,
-0.541379988193512,
1.0641604661941528,
-0.5938565731048584,
0.006612885743379593,
-0.15358653664588928,
-0.09427818655967712,
0.3008716404438019,
-0.670471727848053,
0.6088897585868835,
-0.6502856612205505,
0.14922207593917847,
-0.36103540658950806,
-0.7359155416488647,
0.48599517345428467,
0.41523972153663635,
-0.7818538546562195,
1.162219524383545,
0.04945024102926254,
-0.928069531917572,
0.8003453612327576,
-0.46544939279556274,
-0.46762773394584656,
0.08810004591941833,
-0.2934424877166748,
-0.49592769145965576,
-0.031696297228336334,
0.4198366105556488,
0.45485612750053406,
-0.1381036639213562,
0.3061050474643707,
-0.4801982343196869,
-0.3486505448818207,
0.32981693744659424,
-0.49775075912475586,
0.7962896823883057,
0.17704300582408905,
-0.008535902015864849,
0.08607343584299088,
-0.9034391641616821,
0.016648821532726288,
0.06063366308808327,
-0.36403125524520874,
-0.5614057779312134,
-0.2568736672401428,
-0.24833419919013977,
0.24217690527439117,
0.22630639374256134,
-0.4966864585876465,
0.15214407444000244,
-0.16332392394542694,
0.024974117055535316,
0.8076527714729309,
-0.16606861352920532,
0.6050081253051758,
-0.14470040798187256,
0.6562440395355225,
-0.07910164445638657,
0.25974294543266296,
-0.11742051690816879,
-0.23411212861537933,
-0.797605574131012,
-0.6191801428794861,
0.6555077433586121,
0.41223645210266113,
-0.9294611811637878,
0.7584502100944519,
-0.42030295729637146,
-0.397340327501297,
-0.4558453857898712,
0.18013343214988708,
0.21184782683849335,
0.6034846901893616,
0.1659117341041565,
-0.1530107706785202,
-0.6423845887184143,
-0.9642122983932495,
-0.05259687826037407,
-0.006687917746603489,
-0.290263295173645,
-0.00557277537882328,
0.4968184530735016,
-0.2152140885591507,
1.0315964221954346,
-0.534315824508667,
-0.23818080127239227,
-0.328464150428772,
-0.1173015758395195,
0.4475553333759308,
0.5091860890388489,
0.3864019513130188,
-0.7620402574539185,
-0.8799240589141846,
-0.2238735854625702,
-0.5353134274482727,
-0.29024478793144226,
0.13265156745910645,
-0.3047199845314026,
-0.1359555721282959,
0.5419237017631531,
-0.6580858826637268,
0.3351222574710846,
0.482334166765213,
-0.23537784814834595,
0.6606571078300476,
-0.03654438629746437,
0.04411355406045914,
-1.0707319974899292,
0.19088900089263916,
0.00020372867584228516,
-0.4486980736255646,
-0.8233808875083923,
0.010478206910192966,
0.2773304581642151,
0.058746762573719025,
-0.3199428915977478,
0.5120894908905029,
-0.18731927871704102,
0.04576576128602028,
-0.4189942479133606,
-0.09829563647508621,
-0.21031032502651215,
0.32134267687797546,
0.06767623871564865,
0.7774571776390076,
0.557645857334137,
-0.7004355788230896,
0.21122318506240845,
-0.022102409973740578,
-0.6109726428985596,
0.5643647909164429,
-0.32040277123451233,
0.16002380847930908,
-0.09991190582513809,
0.4776245355606079,
-0.8424253463745117,
-0.11078115552663803,
0.12197295576334,
-0.624845027923584,
0.2127748727798462,
-0.2887111306190491,
-0.7662150859832764,
-0.0214352086186409,
-0.4499351382255554,
0.4710192382335663,
0.47129034996032715,
-0.5333437323570251,
0.43987134099006653,
0.6165012717247009,
-0.09807902574539185,
-0.652145266532898,
-0.35208630561828613,
-0.13619542121887207,
-0.19297295808792114,
-0.6136776804924011,
0.017448363825678825,
-0.20568521320819855,
-0.009212768636643887,
-0.25452765822410583,
-0.3279419541358948,
-0.36670225858688354,
0.29457056522369385,
-0.18483272194862366,
0.30874699354171753,
-0.3854258060455322,
-0.03449311852455139,
-0.12509344518184662,
-0.46130552887916565,
-0.223188579082489,
-0.11076252162456512,
0.8102996945381165,
-0.015494326129555702,
-0.282021164894104,
-0.5993526577949524,
0.08342079818248749,
0.41524356603622437,
-0.0969301238656044,
0.7473779320716858,
0.7174298167228699,
-0.5001073479652405,
-0.04427507892251015,
-0.5886260271072388,
-0.36057794094085693,
-0.5079110264778137,
0.4557286202907562,
-0.5126556158065796,
-0.7255842089653015,
0.4021468162536621,
-0.036092016845941544,
-0.17379917204380035,
0.1497609168291092,
0.5580624938011169,
-0.29573798179626465,
1.0798943042755127,
0.8729078769683838,
-0.5469549894332886,
0.8041812181472778,
-0.3079453408718109,
0.27889564633369446,
-0.4711754322052002,
0.0770922303199768,
-0.5479857325553894,
-0.26374900341033936,
-0.34659647941589355,
-0.3737405836582184,
0.29754069447517395,
0.4277692437171936,
-0.06688188016414642,
0.4254978597164154,
-0.009695839136838913,
0.8862747550010681,
0.4271574914455414,
-0.0543486513197422,
0.5021982789039612,
0.08318490535020828,
-0.011569996364414692,
-0.08089341968297958,
-0.672196626663208,
-0.27796095609664917,
1.320891261100769,
0.31991907954216003,
0.6245256066322327,
-0.1372869461774826,
0.7281576991081238,
0.3709254860877991,
0.8052281737327576,
-0.6842510104179382,
0.5808238387107849,
-0.17185096442699432,
-0.6255760788917542,
-0.31923308968544006,
-0.7297796010971069,
-0.8476918935775757,
0.31467005610466003,
-0.2639303505420685,
-0.47774022817611694,
0.2038823813199997,
0.3164384365081787,
-0.25944840908050537,
0.09758077561855316,
-0.6236612796783447,
0.9909903407096863,
-0.044145721942186356,
0.06662130355834961,
0.017827339470386505,
-0.3186971843242645,
0.5455494523048401,
-0.36448949575424194,
0.46960967779159546,
-0.3907158076763153,
-0.03576537221670151,
0.6261246800422668,
-0.4170098900794983,
0.4936590790748596,
-0.44572949409484863,
-0.2856678068637848,
0.05624021962285042,
0.030073976144194603,
0.9223269820213318,
-0.05247018113732338,
0.27929529547691345,
-0.09319909662008286,
0.018006889149546623,
-0.597003698348999,
-0.45211827754974365,
0.4064677655696869,
-0.47156432271003723,
-0.03519012778997421,
-0.10424654185771942,
-0.5332144498825073,
-0.3684104084968567,
0.2701394855976105,
0.5460784435272217,
0.4027822017669678,
0.10631868988275528,
0.5630961656570435,
0.6917675733566284,
-0.045100778341293335,
-0.07385063171386719,
0.842275083065033,
-0.25051724910736084,
-0.26130566000938416,
0.9632827043533325,
-0.12005163729190826,
0.2894764244556427,
0.5239583849906921,
0.4065091907978058,
-0.36789700388908386,
-0.7420507073402405,
-0.2869816720485687,
0.2556783854961395,
-0.8695133328437805,
-0.2357204109430313,
-0.5333930850028992,
0.07915018498897552,
-0.3337622582912445,
0.08210987597703934,
-0.5823081135749817,
-0.16512252390384674,
0.017250951379537582,
-0.07307472079992294,
0.06484224647283554,
0.11996360868215561,
-0.009393816813826561,
0.5846896171569824,
-0.5741006135940552,
0.4788188338279724,
0.15605591237545013,
0.13907110691070557,
-0.21203364431858063,
-0.7087702751159668,
-0.30141517519950867,
0.040539246052503586,
0.1057489886879921,
-0.5426555871963501,
0.2707638144493103,
0.2768801748752594,
0.4897319972515106,
0.5512953996658325,
0.09526757895946503,
0.6198509931564331,
-0.33165156841278076,
0.24572601914405823,
0.15841038525104523,
-0.7614907026290894,
0.34414902329444885,
-0.21258032321929932,
0.3498844802379608,
0.8741365075111389,
0.5599831342697144,
-0.4830802381038666,
-0.48891374468803406,
-0.44881415367126465,
-0.6177319884300232,
0.5491283535957336,
0.329227089881897,
0.16337132453918457,
0.3039807379245758,
0.15340232849121094,
0.04265223816037178,
0.09832966327667236,
-0.9826251268386841,
-0.2482208013534546,
0.38076260685920715,
-0.41083094477653503,
-0.2731142044067383,
-0.21296966075897217,
0.08023256808519363,
-0.3659970760345459,
0.6191483736038208,
-0.151866152882576,
0.07886926084756851,
-0.2889830470085144,
-0.4523216187953949,
0.15859836339950562,
0.20058952271938324,
0.4540211260318756,
0.6887269020080566,
-0.13657747209072113,
0.251132607460022,
0.2883233428001404,
-0.7076826095581055,
0.35652488470077515,
-0.0554361566901207,
-0.488413006067276,
0.0034702038392424583,
0.6315712928771973,
0.5334162712097168,
0.03298294171690941,
-0.6979343295097351,
0.7853500843048096,
-0.22915136814117432,
0.012793105095624924,
-0.3095780313014984,
-0.024169735610485077,
0.09657219052314758,
0.09162004292011261,
0.4549175202846527,
0.10106327384710312,
0.011204695329070091,
-0.5058691501617432,
0.5113489627838135,
0.4064589738845825,
-0.13850584626197815,
-0.5073608756065369,
0.10587062686681747,
-0.08777093887329102,
-0.07073624432086945,
0.22975054383277893,
-0.38534340262413025,
-0.6438011527061462,
0.6689504981040955,
0.34630900621414185,
0.6142742037773132,
-0.23000024259090424,
0.042065735906362534,
0.29906144738197327,
0.3314485251903534,
-0.08556992560625076,
0.3961045444011688,
-0.3727458417415619,
-1.1804832220077515,
-0.7021762132644653,
-0.72330242395401,
0.016798561438918114,
0.648753821849823,
-0.6773839592933655,
0.4051160216331482,
-0.2691200375556946,
-0.22821465134620667,
0.10767482221126556,
0.06434217840433121,
-0.7542524337768555,
0.0748009979724884,
0.3636856973171234,
0.9631096124649048,
-1.2374770641326904,
1.315096139907837,
0.23419539630413055,
-0.023939810693264008,
-0.7601691484451294,
0.0833074152469635,
-0.14081881940364838,
-0.7120789289474487,
0.6702383160591125,
0.17753349244594574,
-0.08578619360923767,
0.03488153591752052,
-0.5115766525268555,
-0.9111841320991516,
0.7628716826438904,
0.7186248898506165,
-0.5927132368087769,
0.27101656794548035,
-0.023214980959892273,
0.4908643960952759,
-0.3892573118209839,
0.00711115961894393,
0.9939834475517273,
0.3743819296360016,
-0.023894648998975754,
-0.659466028213501,
-0.08697093278169632,
-0.24390920996665955,
-0.3698689937591553,
0.505657434463501,
-0.03712345287203789,
0.7436916828155518,
0.16775034368038177,
-0.3024878203868866,
0.009792153723537922,
0.433768093585968,
0.5857588052749634,
0.3805354833602905,
0.9536251425743103,
0.6473615169525146,
0.7982560992240906,
0.10253951698541641,
1.0754358768463135,
-0.17235438525676727,
0.3896107077598572,
1.1104869842529297,
-0.1797720342874527,
1.0597749948501587,
0.2278192788362503,
-0.5324249863624573,
0.19847933948040009,
0.6485483050346375,
0.21007297933101654,
0.787861704826355,
0.1567177176475525,
-0.4557872712612152,
-0.5031319856643677,
-0.10286185890436172,
-0.48461923003196716,
0.29820260405540466,
0.18671005964279175,
0.0026090280152857304,
-0.19221752882003784,
0.16979466378688812,
0.10015504062175751,
-0.10592611879110336,
-0.306171715259552,
0.573235809803009,
-0.03193112462759018,
-0.36829909682273865,
0.7903372645378113,
-0.09209945052862167,
0.9910016655921936,
-0.7588202953338623,
0.2473319172859192,
-0.5552076101303101,
0.323408305644989,
-0.20093168318271637,
-0.31655868887901306,
-0.004400288220494986,
0.2980712652206421,
-0.09552250057458878,
-0.020642587915062904,
0.8520699143409729,
-0.46826988458633423,
-0.6696957945823669,
0.12886904180049896,
0.2512083053588867,
0.179795041680336,
-0.2911323308944702,
-0.45561715960502625,
0.01422977726906538,
-0.029106685891747475,
-0.10827215760946274,
0.5642610788345337,
0.3576296269893646,
-0.13275575637817383,
0.7192512154579163,
0.9932653307914734,
0.23952920734882355,
0.2522478699684143,
0.19272245466709137,
0.862884521484375,
-0.34788891673088074,
-0.7316740155220032,
-0.8993274569511414,
0.1905151605606079,
-0.11177189648151398,
-0.050679732114076614,
0.7198432683944702,
0.6760133504867554,
1.1422455310821533,
-0.10707183182239532,
0.5423781871795654,
0.07575498521327972,
0.39130815863609314,
-0.5832226276397705,
0.6982271671295166,
-0.47498905658721924,
0.31064897775650024,
-0.1641210913658142,
-1.0218414068222046,
-0.23306860029697418,
0.6656360626220703,
-0.41482704877853394,
-0.13317903876304626,
0.574569821357727,
0.8969343304634094,
-0.30034512281417847,
-0.19378264248371124,
0.3589746356010437,
-0.04426192119717598,
0.3759925365447998,
0.5346232652664185,
1.1821635961532593,
-0.2382468283176422,
0.6652166843414307,
-0.4473515450954437,
-0.31764546036720276,
-0.13958650827407837,
-0.8458526730537415,
-0.6947857141494751,
-0.2900303900241852,
-0.23005087673664093,
-0.19542542099952698,
-0.42298030853271484,
0.7734047770500183,
0.9695556163787842,
-1.1014535427093506,
-0.11975707113742828,
-0.056644003838300705,
0.04798242077231407,
0.06370542198419571,
-0.16783715784549713,
0.3546123802661896,
-0.1651279479265213,
-0.3774377107620239,
0.6333971619606018,
-0.06435049325227737,
-0.09140511602163315,
-0.29075342416763306,
-0.32439887523651123,
-0.1517779529094696,
-0.04258269816637039,
0.5958707332611084,
0.2233380526304245,
-0.3569663166999817,
-0.13490352034568787,
-0.11395388841629028,
-0.31862837076187134,
0.09982988238334656,
1.0510581731796265,
-0.8322575688362122,
0.35401105880737305,
0.7499628663063049,
0.6955870985984802,
0.7056913375854492,
-0.041595712304115295,
0.40651121735572815,
-1.0398787260055542,
0.459512859582901,
0.42263415455818176,
0.30075961351394653,
0.2755276560783386,
-0.1959310621023178,
0.344873309135437,
0.2921709716320038,
-0.24768327176570892,
-1.2639269828796387,
0.3715111017227173,
-0.49159854650497437,
-0.030152229592204094,
0.7470052242279053,
-0.2352801412343979,
0.03167163208127022,
-0.015198440290987492,
0.11665559560060501,
0.0785103291273117,
-0.27618008852005005,
0.5903891921043396,
0.6883227825164795,
0.1034880205988884,
-0.019141651690006256,
-0.8452827334403992,
0.6056126952171326,
0.4340790808200836,
-0.9945459961891174,
-0.032133523374795914,
0.46665897965431213,
0.5399347543716431,
-0.004896043334156275,
1.1229850053787231,
0.04561752453446388,
0.23161680996418,
-0.07816498726606369,
-0.07280623912811279,
-0.09231981635093689,
-0.5239182710647583,
-0.3985174894332886,
0.1694221943616867,
0.09040679782629013,
-0.23141790926456451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02444v1
|
The Promises and Pitfalls of Using Language Models to Measure Instruction Quality in Education
| 2024-04-03T04:15:29 | 2024-04-03T04:15:29 |
Paiheng Xu, Jing Liu, Nathan Jones, Julie Cohen, Wei Ai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Assessing instruction quality is a fundamental component of any improvement
efforts in the education system. However, traditional manual assessments are
expensive, subjective, and heavily dependent on observers' expertise and
idiosyncratic factors, preventing teachers from getting timely and frequent
feedback. Different from prior research that mostly focuses on low-inference
instructional practices on a singular basis, this paper presents the first
study that leverages Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques to assess
multiple high-inference instructional practices in two distinct educational
settings: in-person K-12 classrooms and simulated performance tasks for
pre-service teachers. This is also the first study that applies NLP to measure
a teaching practice that is widely acknowledged to be particularly effective
for students with special needs. We confront two challenges inherent in
NLP-based instructional analysis, including noisy and long input data and
highly skewed distributions of human ratings. Our results suggest that
pretrained Language Models (PLMs) demonstrate performances comparable to the
agreement level of human raters for variables that are more discrete and
require lower inference, but their efficacy diminishes with more complex
teaching practices. Interestingly, using only teachers' utterances as input
yields strong results for student-centered variables, alleviating common
concerns over the difficulty of collecting and transcribing high-quality
student speech data in in-person teaching settings. Our findings highlight both
the potential and the limitations of current NLP techniques in the education
domain, opening avenues for further exploration.
|
[
-0.3435526490211487,
-0.8391788005828857,
0.22351792454719543,
0.2965936064720154,
0.011008559726178646,
0.10156480967998505,
-0.28076210618019104,
-0.3224470019340515,
-0.10979953408241272,
0.45001649856567383,
-0.24082037806510925,
-0.5566784739494324,
-0.7492594122886658,
0.00605982868000865,
-0.5666693449020386,
0.6897605657577515,
0.05009029433131218,
0.513279378414154,
-0.26910310983657837,
-0.09646955132484436,
-0.5044715404510498,
-0.7738940119743347,
-0.4597473740577698,
-0.24733832478523254,
0.19096530973911285,
0.474580854177475,
0.8038546442985535,
0.25378039479255676,
0.5966346859931946,
0.22156192362308502,
0.16802529990673065,
0.2678084969520569,
-0.11176270991563797,
-0.288394570350647,
-0.07859667390584946,
-0.2774900496006012,
-0.45542433857917786,
0.4451793134212494,
0.996496856212616,
1.3162403106689453,
-0.3969467878341675,
0.23925212025642395,
0.4724331498146057,
0.29424357414245605,
-0.770237386226654,
-0.19948166608810425,
-0.020911134779453278,
0.3169008195400238,
-0.0423164963722229,
-0.013890826143324375,
-0.6025540828704834,
-0.5759228467941284,
0.404630184173584,
-0.3649727404117584,
0.16266927123069763,
-0.24339927732944489,
0.7858794927597046,
0.2192584127187729,
-0.3307703137397766,
-0.49857109785079956,
-0.8513574004173279,
1.051801085472107,
-1.1325769424438477,
0.4236402213573456,
0.6427435278892517,
0.26058655977249146,
-0.07072541862726212,
-0.6263248324394226,
-0.5077642798423767,
-0.3583507239818573,
-0.2038055658340454,
0.1621628850698471,
0.1626640409231186,
0.06180356815457344,
0.29961833357810974,
0.26392874121665955,
-0.46822044253349304,
0.382398396730423,
-0.2701152265071869,
0.020002638921141624,
0.4520851671695709,
0.0509839691221714,
0.23729820549488068,
-0.3378545343875885,
-0.40088629722595215,
-0.3099434971809387,
-0.30985260009765625,
0.44507896900177,
0.4007987380027771,
0.36689361929893494,
0.007219721097499132,
0.48325279355049133,
0.0222322940826416,
0.8533464074134827,
-0.4864517152309418,
-0.20851436257362366,
-0.04688713327050209,
-0.21252796053886414,
-0.24396279454231262,
-0.32287395000457764,
0.7112265229225159,
0.22237464785575867,
0.16657882928848267,
-0.1954735666513443,
-0.1922660768032074,
0.37242910265922546,
0.2032524049282074,
-0.5073741674423218,
-0.14087258279323578,
-0.17381258308887482,
-0.2531847357749939,
0.034506406635046005,
0.1291932761669159,
-1.0220179557800293,
-0.14498503506183624,
-0.5429680347442627,
0.4079214930534363,
-0.308628648519516,
-0.10389572381973267,
0.24307262897491455,
0.2117897868156433,
0.23100349307060242,
0.32705435156822205,
-0.848720371723175,
0.7631942629814148,
0.6364657282829285,
0.6331944465637207,
-0.3865815997123718,
-0.46063971519470215,
-0.49273040890693665,
-0.28386572003364563,
-0.3918561637401581,
0.7450424432754517,
-0.6936848759651184,
-0.4428507089614868,
0.10234199464321136,
-0.2497909963130951,
-0.23203174769878387,
-0.5982164144515991,
0.5460489392280579,
-0.14952240884304047,
0.38837340474128723,
0.0378861278295517,
-0.9877141118049622,
0.0008894006605260074,
0.13293971121311188,
-0.46422553062438965,
1.1649938821792603,
0.20441246032714844,
-0.2970714569091797,
0.3179478645324707,
-0.5414841175079346,
-0.5076401829719543,
-0.09082993865013123,
-0.049802184104919434,
-0.2292984426021576,
0.25124773383140564,
0.21132098138332367,
0.43540075421333313,
-0.1762571930885315,
0.2790715992450714,
-0.0037498045712709427,
-0.5147770643234253,
0.29017332196235657,
-0.7607183456420898,
0.5600590109825134,
-0.1395118236541748,
-0.27133193612098694,
-0.1231686919927597,
-0.780432403087616,
0.3786320686340332,
-0.09983231127262115,
-0.4563184976577759,
-0.42542749643325806,
0.1101778969168663,
-0.15722592175006866,
0.017508845776319504,
-0.09996592998504639,
-0.1380215883255005,
0.06859670579433441,
-0.5975227355957031,
0.060379717499017715,
0.5423387885093689,
-0.13138450682163239,
0.5618874430656433,
-0.2559982240200043,
0.6682068109512329,
-0.48450401425361633,
0.36001941561698914,
-0.1858375072479248,
-0.31842097640037537,
-0.7292242050170898,
0.0029888765420764685,
0.5072476267814636,
0.2705574035644531,
-0.5888041853904724,
0.1707514375448227,
-0.03983606398105621,
-0.38696447014808655,
-0.7553210854530334,
0.15266108512878418,
0.5758317708969116,
0.5004302263259888,
0.46393781900405884,
-0.6662032008171082,
-0.1855534017086029,
-0.47589415311813354,
-0.4928329288959503,
0.059282101690769196,
-0.14781272411346436,
0.0838669165968895,
0.3227599561214447,
0.21043850481510162,
0.8470057249069214,
-0.2707268297672272,
-0.07556875050067902,
-0.08315186947584152,
0.3594178855419159,
0.18100960552692413,
0.6280586123466492,
0.4294896721839905,
-0.39849984645843506,
-0.4972456991672516,
-0.5098505020141602,
-0.623960554599762,
0.006329365074634552,
-0.09028811007738113,
-0.22252726554870605,
0.03296623378992081,
-0.024012506008148193,
-0.35276204347610474,
0.4868004620075226,
0.5744927525520325,
-0.29250454902648926,
0.6194838285446167,
-0.15154969692230225,
0.22190304100513458,
-0.3972829282283783,
-0.25828519463539124,
0.03225988149642944,
-0.007509173359721899,
-0.7797640562057495,
0.04495435580611229,
-0.06692711263895035,
-0.12221591919660568,
-0.4283718168735504,
0.3689860701560974,
-0.3407056927680969,
-0.22388873994350433,
-0.16411063075065613,
0.1266208291053772,
0.2354741245508194,
0.5026017427444458,
0.16778507828712463,
0.6837361454963684,
0.3532162308692932,
-0.5399025678634644,
0.021751565858721733,
0.05329592525959015,
-0.6415891051292419,
0.7089416980743408,
-0.6766538619995117,
0.350788950920105,
0.09270894527435303,
0.04290737956762314,
-0.6063715815544128,
-0.10901191830635071,
0.18109910190105438,
-0.39176374673843384,
0.37068596482276917,
0.009860733523964882,
-0.4826066792011261,
-0.26736900210380554,
-0.16664941608905792,
-0.15090106427669525,
0.5834917426109314,
-0.47133299708366394,
0.4474101960659027,
0.17032529413700104,
-0.0548604317009449,
-0.6853748559951782,
-0.5716729760169983,
0.03754346817731857,
0.008611517027020454,
-0.3688318431377411,
0.042173974215984344,
0.009242693893611431,
-0.16918818652629852,
-0.08881301432847977,
-0.43923330307006836,
-0.48407554626464844,
0.3619372546672821,
0.00629253126680851,
0.46921706199645996,
-0.4342222809791565,
0.07797138392925262,
0.06423944979906082,
-0.029742833226919174,
0.23407085239887238,
-0.04559297487139702,
0.4397723972797394,
-0.06256291270256042,
-0.7102421522140503,
-0.8277108669281006,
0.4651793837547302,
0.3217107951641083,
-0.22705790400505066,
0.6949406862258911,
0.46612557768821716,
-0.3104844391345978,
-0.469633549451828,
-0.5597097873687744,
-0.526087760925293,
-0.39272865653038025,
0.36232858896255493,
-0.04980172589421272,
-0.5208060145378113,
-0.08411558717489243,
-0.03583107143640518,
0.24798721075057983,
-0.08570238947868347,
-0.13387824594974518,
-0.4702698290348053,
0.9603105187416077,
0.521664023399353,
0.2729436159133911,
0.4276394844055176,
-0.3751203715801239,
0.44876664876937866,
-0.6570032835006714,
-0.031578179448843,
-0.6243835091590881,
-0.08550615608692169,
-0.20502814650535583,
-0.4449099004268646,
0.12318295985460281,
0.543014407157898,
-0.013207701966166496,
0.10157625377178192,
-0.5868163108825684,
0.39338526129722595,
0.7236436605453491,
0.046986859291791916,
0.34914740920066833,
-0.07809674739837646,
0.2650877833366394,
-0.34241193532943726,
-0.5779666304588318,
-1.0657905340194702,
1.0018048286437988,
0.35226067900657654,
0.6406126618385315,
0.11022317409515381,
0.5931388735771179,
0.12426599115133286,
0.7298334240913391,
-0.7353612780570984,
0.41774505376815796,
-0.28735268115997314,
-0.47411757707595825,
-0.6660459041595459,
-0.4375476837158203,
-0.7035455703735352,
0.47018301486968994,
-0.30473843216896057,
-0.390522301197052,
-0.06564803421497345,
0.20069006085395813,
-0.4980196952819824,
0.19458134472370148,
-1.0963261127471924,
0.9495736956596375,
-0.35949575901031494,
-0.23149490356445312,
0.04105198010802269,
-0.41775962710380554,
0.189689502120018,
0.018687518313527107,
0.26166731119155884,
-0.3344934284687042,
0.18413357436656952,
0.9101799130439758,
-0.37126389145851135,
0.7773493528366089,
-0.4608573317527771,
-0.009876263327896595,
0.49042218923568726,
-0.05910327658057213,
0.2528665363788605,
-0.06293556094169617,
-0.1644064038991928,
0.07168824225664139,
0.19053873419761658,
-0.5775451064109802,
-0.9550427198410034,
0.34266388416290283,
-0.7631757855415344,
-0.5906770825386047,
-0.37796664237976074,
-0.36966437101364136,
-0.5167197585105896,
-0.025304876267910004,
0.06022656336426735,
0.4396763741970062,
-0.06644552201032639,
0.15160802006721497,
0.48164719343185425,
-0.22979262471199036,
0.47905752062797546,
0.6915483474731445,
0.07948697358369827,
-0.009768634103238583,
1.1049487590789795,
0.5410246253013611,
0.554241418838501,
0.1074226051568985,
0.3602713644504547,
-0.3038625717163086,
-0.6054307222366333,
-0.11412245035171509,
0.05464990437030792,
-0.7747828364372253,
-0.008782331831753254,
-0.2624489367008209,
-0.10991363227367401,
-0.5494314432144165,
-0.22646048665046692,
-0.4900754392147064,
-0.19704009592533112,
-0.481139600276947,
-0.09562364965677261,
-0.2675078511238098,
0.6742216944694519,
0.159201979637146,
0.49350327253341675,
-0.6387938261032104,
0.23682239651679993,
0.49412664771080017,
0.21081151068210602,
0.18374359607696533,
-0.6491278409957886,
-0.10147099941968918,
0.09745904058218002,
-0.2979290783405304,
-0.7150020003318787,
0.5024856925010681,
0.43546736240386963,
0.5242337584495544,
0.13033121824264526,
0.19372525811195374,
0.6711972951889038,
-0.3921155333518982,
0.9475679397583008,
0.21665099263191223,
-0.9725069999694824,
0.47194525599479675,
0.2869079113006592,
0.1359967738389969,
0.48861128091812134,
0.3734622299671173,
-0.3004152476787567,
-0.5012821555137634,
-0.38276517391204834,
-0.7129994630813599,
0.8919683694839478,
-0.03375382348895073,
0.35434746742248535,
0.12404821068048477,
0.15304800868034363,
0.14527365565299988,
0.22389549016952515,
-0.5063536167144775,
-0.34309133887290955,
-0.4326438307762146,
-0.3365965485572815,
-0.0671117752790451,
-0.3054035007953644,
-0.02811395563185215,
-0.29690757393836975,
0.3975870609283447,
-0.056901413947343826,
0.009104938246309757,
0.19331154227256775,
-0.16671955585479736,
0.3098437190055847,
0.5912614464759827,
0.47632691264152527,
0.9550687074661255,
-0.010643485002219677,
0.21395866572856903,
0.3103927969932556,
-0.46393799781799316,
0.1597549319267273,
-0.0060402629896998405,
-0.0026326775550842285,
0.21467998623847961,
0.7382979989051819,
0.6754541993141174,
0.6795483827590942,
-0.4973112642765045,
0.6487247943878174,
-0.014878303743898869,
0.1000436395406723,
-0.34093666076660156,
0.2344924658536911,
-0.20097239315509796,
-0.1191539391875267,
0.3048076033592224,
0.12097549438476562,
0.028102068230509758,
-0.3651898205280304,
0.06592048704624176,
0.0685008093714714,
-0.4601467251777649,
-0.5030378103256226,
0.17801807820796967,
0.19963888823986053,
-0.6177074909210205,
0.7230319976806641,
-0.0478021502494812,
0.020233774557709694,
0.6315680146217346,
0.4581643044948578,
0.4668433368206024,
-0.5260607004165649,
0.5043859481811523,
0.2782515287399292,
0.36351826786994934,
-0.2881576120853424,
0.11969278752803802,
-0.2112179547548294,
-0.6723469495773315,
-0.639950692653656,
-0.5315526127815247,
-0.6196388602256775,
-0.0007177006918936968,
-1.126313328742981,
0.17112474143505096,
-0.5277585983276367,
-0.3156823515892029,
0.23754490911960602,
0.011560563929378986,
-0.7133249044418335,
0.13565076887607574,
0.07874379307031631,
0.6550725102424622,
-0.9371780753135681,
0.7750768065452576,
0.666779637336731,
-0.342918336391449,
-0.8438130021095276,
-0.1829679310321808,
-0.12457150965929031,
-0.4612572491168976,
0.4410766065120697,
0.05838398262858391,
-0.11852199584245682,
0.05803403630852699,
-0.4343227446079254,
-0.5963212847709656,
0.4426644742488861,
0.4836791157722473,
-0.5546354651451111,
-0.39775732159614563,
0.1449131965637207,
0.6250009536743164,
-0.14140282571315765,
0.37819036841392517,
0.9026179909706116,
0.5335885286331177,
-0.3151688575744629,
-0.7751370072364807,
-0.4626239836215973,
0.0978442057967186,
-0.11773531138896942,
-0.05606262385845184,
-0.22463101148605347,
0.573223888874054,
0.004838672932237387,
-0.39441609382629395,
-0.1283031553030014,
0.684977650642395,
0.11491348594427109,
0.5930747389793396,
0.3158266246318817,
0.4470779597759247,
0.7859197854995728,
-0.2865939140319824,
1.0223101377487183,
0.03585026040673256,
0.4086036682128906,
1.2964859008789062,
-0.22137829661369324,
0.9211459159851074,
0.5852188467979431,
-0.6621045470237732,
0.3252989649772644,
0.4226497709751129,
0.06371747702360153,
0.20682469010353088,
0.21319453418254852,
-0.25275999307632446,
-0.13964755833148956,
-0.33630773425102234,
-0.1087668389081955,
0.44161421060562134,
0.4770912230014801,
0.08475571125745773,
-0.054404985159635544,
0.2515608072280884,
-0.13925056159496307,
0.5729096531867981,
-0.17839264869689941,
0.5333471894264221,
0.1995616853237152,
-0.7510991096496582,
0.47422975301742554,
-0.25385236740112305,
0.7600039839744568,
-0.4467197358608246,
-0.2793649137020111,
-0.18161365389823914,
-0.1663752794265747,
-0.2064555436372757,
-0.6796802878379822,
0.31163299083709717,
0.10874578356742859,
-0.040560901165008545,
-0.4033428728580475,
0.22128109633922577,
-0.39658960700035095,
-0.37361836433410645,
0.2330077439546585,
0.43534234166145325,
0.13669219613075256,
0.35891416668891907,
-0.42829009890556335,
-0.04699224233627319,
-0.2613356411457062,
-0.4274599254131317,
0.2386004626750946,
0.06537648290395737,
0.20904956758022308,
0.33952710032463074,
0.5988732576370239,
0.27530404925346375,
0.36299195885658264,
0.49200066924095154,
0.2777269184589386,
-0.4488440155982971,
-0.03996596485376358,
-0.5362957715988159,
0.5069978833198547,
-0.04474274441599846,
-0.721303403377533,
0.7769240736961365,
0.09791036695241928,
1.2109944820404053,
0.12403295934200287,
0.521492600440979,
0.32556936144828796,
0.6945710778236389,
-0.5198788642883301,
0.3004630506038666,
-0.14898476004600525,
0.2375490516424179,
-0.23726604878902435,
-0.7358692288398743,
-0.3319268822669983,
0.8103984594345093,
-0.4512171149253845,
-0.03856221213936806,
0.7620795965194702,
0.4259191155433655,
0.09849771857261658,
0.2491084784269333,
0.5419481992721558,
-0.1893358826637268,
0.24940060079097748,
0.26164281368255615,
1.1529788970947266,
-0.4720093607902527,
0.1683901995420456,
-0.6013291478157043,
-0.24159835278987885,
-0.04135671630501747,
-0.4055854082107544,
-0.8486935496330261,
-0.34517499804496765,
-0.354055255651474,
0.06098511815071106,
-0.07151581346988678,
0.8965281844139099,
0.748889684677124,
-0.7032275795936584,
-0.37789857387542725,
0.08834258466959,
0.24122874438762665,
-0.37578123807907104,
-0.2956879436969757,
0.5122036337852478,
-0.5482399463653564,
-1.0124351978302002,
0.6381973624229431,
-0.073809415102005,
0.13263970613479614,
-0.33855414390563965,
-0.011248416267335415,
-0.06289010494947433,
0.06064477935433388,
0.5883433222770691,
0.2540706694126129,
-0.7698833346366882,
-0.21382960677146912,
0.028855638578534126,
-0.21418145298957825,
-0.00267056399025023,
0.780645489692688,
-0.40501946210861206,
0.6546242833137512,
0.24830010533332825,
0.7830943465232849,
0.20982901751995087,
0.06373043358325958,
0.3982398808002472,
-0.7549834251403809,
0.017139015719294548,
0.7067700028419495,
0.03352335840463638,
0.3728533089160919,
0.010513327084481716,
0.3450048565864563,
0.031650640070438385,
-0.4578074812889099,
-1.1755270957946777,
-0.09774577617645264,
-0.43887826800346375,
-0.18887931108474731,
0.5942527651786804,
-0.5734854340553284,
-0.04092266783118248,
-0.16146793961524963,
0.119414784014225,
0.16424597799777985,
-0.11728958040475845,
0.6966933608055115,
0.9308192133903503,
-0.2869705259799957,
-0.16283096373081207,
-1.059544324874878,
0.2944498658180237,
0.6138177514076233,
-0.671928882598877,
-0.3065322935581207,
0.20835274457931519,
-0.03393735736608505,
0.2510804831981659,
0.45618927478790283,
-0.025124650448560715,
0.17466136813163757,
-0.0172895435243845,
0.15911807119846344,
0.1446705162525177,
-0.5034905672073364,
-0.40634363889694214,
0.3837738037109375,
-0.0011144051095470786,
-0.22947734594345093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02438v1
|
From Narratives to Numbers: Valid Inference Using Language Model Predictions from Verbal Autopsy Narratives
| 2024-04-03T03:53:37 | 2024-04-03T03:53:37 |
Shuxian Fan, Adam Visokay, Kentaro Hoffman, Stephen Salerno, Li Liu, Jeffrey T. Leek, Tyler H. McCormick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
In settings where most deaths occur outside the healthcare system, verbal
autopsies (VAs) are a common tool to monitor trends in causes of death (COD).
VAs are interviews with a surviving caregiver or relative that are used to
predict the decedent's COD. Turning VAs into actionable insights for
researchers and policymakers requires two steps (i) predicting likely COD using
the VA interview and (ii) performing inference with predicted CODs (e.g.
modeling the breakdown of causes by demographic factors using a sample of
deaths). In this paper, we develop a method for valid inference using outcomes
(in our case COD) predicted from free-form text using state-of-the-art NLP
techniques. This method, which we call multiPPI++, extends recent work in
"prediction-powered inference" to multinomial classification. We leverage a
suite of NLP techniques for COD prediction and, through empirical analysis of
VA data, demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in handling
transportability issues. multiPPI++ recovers ground truth estimates, regardless
of which NLP model produced predictions and regardless of whether they were
produced by a more accurate predictor like GPT-4-32k or a less accurate
predictor like KNN. Our findings demonstrate the practical importance of
inference correction for public health decision-making and suggests that if
inference tasks are the end goal, having a small amount of contextually
relevant, high quality labeled data is essential regardless of the NLP
algorithm.
|
[
-0.10706690698862076,
-0.5282830595970154,
1.030681848526001,
0.3076038658618927,
0.09303583949804306,
-0.05155414342880249,
0.07976473867893219,
-0.48972612619400024,
0.2806229889392853,
0.48722007870674133,
-0.27825239300727844,
-0.24690693616867065,
-0.7032948732376099,
0.0931059941649437,
-0.2899898886680603,
0.6612744927406311,
0.319227397441864,
0.23042836785316467,
-0.29652681946754456,
0.052329402416944504,
-0.3049467206001282,
-0.7531120777130127,
-0.7350661754608154,
-0.03739192709326744,
0.5998856425285339,
0.18839184939861298,
0.81544429063797,
0.6807762384414673,
0.09535208344459534,
0.26347771286964417,
0.08190248906612396,
0.28898611664772034,
-0.03382761776447296,
-0.010922434739768505,
0.16441909968852997,
-0.5100457668304443,
-0.4694399833679199,
0.1639508157968521,
0.291675865650177,
1.026330590248108,
-0.27699369192123413,
-0.09843256324529648,
-0.21133483946323395,
0.4995196759700775,
-0.6872983574867249,
0.028267066925764084,
-0.3438512086868286,
0.09419644623994827,
-0.1036696806550026,
-0.2551356852054596,
-1.0367343425750732,
-0.5536690354347229,
0.17268893122673035,
-0.6236673593521118,
0.15580816566944122,
-0.1961752027273178,
0.6393082141876221,
0.2495209127664566,
-0.7251988649368286,
-0.20852293074131012,
-0.7536675930023193,
0.843225359916687,
-0.9572417140007019,
0.24434557557106018,
0.792422890663147,
0.3155531883239746,
-0.28946810960769653,
-0.7285259366035461,
-0.4094250500202179,
-0.1880253404378891,
-0.1792825162410736,
0.26337239146232605,
-0.22916826605796814,
0.2424754798412323,
0.38019463419914246,
-0.0006980314501561224,
-0.5004163384437561,
-0.0539686381816864,
-0.39327049255371094,
-0.2798338234424591,
0.797703742980957,
-0.03375353664159775,
0.5645568370819092,
-0.2692597508430481,
-0.28368592262268066,
0.06889855861663818,
-0.5776376724243164,
-0.215929314494133,
0.27062752842903137,
0.23188382387161255,
-0.3162038028240204,
0.5559853315353394,
-0.1846877932548523,
0.8011854887008667,
-0.3495846390724182,
-0.4037940204143524,
0.5269396901130676,
-0.4810405373573303,
0.01626262068748474,
0.2382107973098755,
0.5212312340736389,
0.5973661541938782,
0.5474410653114319,
-0.19942313432693481,
0.2993030250072479,
0.31460100412368774,
0.405368447303772,
-0.4640716016292572,
-0.11892574280500412,
0.4330420196056366,
-0.6608151793479919,
-0.16846968233585358,
0.03092968836426735,
-0.8968121409416199,
-0.3872067928314209,
-0.3676700294017792,
0.07657420635223389,
-0.609177827835083,
-0.25404438376426697,
0.3397212326526642,
-0.4293766915798187,
0.03325440362095833,
0.6573163866996765,
-0.619368314743042,
0.36766499280929565,
0.5860949158668518,
0.9079146981239319,
0.023673612624406815,
-0.2308150976896286,
-0.6487156748771667,
0.2984599173069,
-0.4886094033718109,
1.106237530708313,
-0.2784701883792877,
-0.2750470042228699,
-0.0015322115505114198,
-0.17168551683425903,
-0.22197026014328003,
-0.3039907217025757,
0.48423832654953003,
-0.0062583438120782375,
0.17464882135391235,
-0.04858658090233803,
-0.6771987080574036,
-0.2689666450023651,
-0.09494057297706604,
-0.6511326432228088,
0.5528832674026489,
-0.17626021802425385,
-0.6492442488670349,
0.4028003513813019,
-0.3470892906188965,
-0.4761583209037781,
-0.07460280507802963,
-0.15619869530200958,
-0.33563166856765747,
0.34658658504486084,
0.029744122177362442,
0.3251558542251587,
-0.08720467984676361,
0.6970139741897583,
-0.5924488306045532,
0.13844844698905945,
0.006134797818958759,
-0.7954731583595276,
0.8783911466598511,
0.12123356759548187,
-0.14284338057041168,
-0.05561047047376633,
-0.7701291441917419,
0.0020139282569289207,
-0.03761979937553406,
-0.10828050971031189,
-0.36300522089004517,
0.5977891087532043,
-0.14592082798480988,
0.3119495213031769,
-0.32102155685424805,
-0.5510365962982178,
0.15535473823547363,
-0.5037677884101868,
0.18038064241409302,
0.3445632755756378,
0.14117376506328583,
0.4062795042991638,
-0.6680228114128113,
0.5906156897544861,
-0.37918612360954285,
0.393431693315506,
-0.15905340015888214,
-1.1670104265213013,
-0.2560882866382599,
-0.010650512762367725,
0.3809303939342499,
0.6076987981796265,
-0.7389435768127441,
0.28429311513900757,
-0.258935809135437,
-0.5234173536300659,
-0.41422903537750244,
-0.6785874366760254,
0.04889168217778206,
0.729454517364502,
0.5410370826721191,
-0.0838327556848526,
-0.7218450307846069,
-0.7047665119171143,
-0.08397883176803589,
-0.5348725914955139,
-0.25189730525016785,
-0.08435998857021332,
0.286955863237381,
-0.0036424449644982815,
0.7972949743270874,
-0.5146902203559875,
0.043980009853839874,
-0.2489272803068161,
0.5006381869316101,
0.00798962265253067,
0.3641792833805084,
0.5704084038734436,
-0.8185552954673767,
-0.05587586387991905,
-0.42379793524742126,
-0.7563462257385254,
-0.3447349965572357,
-0.43685102462768555,
0.050710853189229965,
-0.03273991122841835,
0.33992868661880493,
-0.6090142726898193,
0.8958444595336914,
0.7060483694076538,
-0.463332861661911,
0.7045632600784302,
-0.307352215051651,
0.13534483313560486,
-0.7050661444664001,
-0.22526027262210846,
0.1281396746635437,
-0.16035553812980652,
-0.7702872157096863,
-0.24269741773605347,
-0.1646985560655594,
-0.04593472182750702,
-0.3323574960231781,
0.6712518930435181,
-0.2918880879878998,
-0.10076405107975006,
-0.1297333687543869,
-0.18804329633712769,
0.2132638543844223,
-0.03371400013566017,
0.43065154552459717,
0.5211097002029419,
0.3437381088733673,
-0.3976549208164215,
0.03670119121670723,
0.27468082308769226,
-0.10864473879337311,
0.1569536328315735,
-0.3924054503440857,
-0.2523975372314453,
-0.2955893874168396,
0.6321605443954468,
-1.005419135093689,
-0.10652665048837662,
0.024160562083125114,
-0.7031527757644653,
-0.08723967522382736,
-0.21179480850696564,
-0.5126873850822449,
-0.2158575803041458,
-0.33670496940612793,
0.14180682599544525,
0.2576649785041809,
-0.011013125069439411,
0.9695132970809937,
0.7352234721183777,
-0.4614798426628113,
-0.3564707040786743,
-0.8676401376724243,
0.37095484137535095,
-0.017352741211652756,
-0.5217593908309937,
-0.005237216129899025,
-0.12271654605865479,
-0.5911454558372498,
-0.3037046194076538,
0.08972851932048798,
-0.402799129486084,
0.18633174896240234,
0.3291632831096649,
0.2770250141620636,
-0.15307651460170746,
0.37549158930778503,
0.2564120590686798,
-0.49176862835884094,
0.18873460590839386,
0.20714029669761658,
0.34606868028640747,
0.17907825112342834,
-0.40613263845443726,
-0.25492894649505615,
0.76650470495224,
0.6655409336090088,
-0.2614021599292755,
0.6216275691986084,
0.3228178322315216,
-0.5121747255325317,
0.20046167075634003,
-0.6538258790969849,
-0.10257179290056229,
-0.2545097768306732,
-0.117156982421875,
-0.2554606795310974,
-0.13502466678619385,
0.3356727957725525,
-0.3175051510334015,
0.041517943143844604,
0.48180413246154785,
0.2242017537355423,
0.02349393256008625,
1.3560125827789307,
0.18907193839550018,
0.20137864351272583,
0.030935991555452347,
-0.013679007068276405,
0.08936821669340134,
-0.5304614305496216,
-0.0966007336974144,
-0.6415428519248962,
0.16543491184711456,
-0.5898144245147705,
-0.611509382724762,
0.44990065693855286,
-0.10278983414173126,
0.08377493172883987,
0.02211245894432068,
-0.4038882255554199,
0.18354906141757965,
0.4321279227733612,
0.20927806198596954,
0.510818362236023,
-0.23417937755584717,
0.2189343422651291,
0.013094105757772923,
-0.91083824634552,
-0.6004807949066162,
1.0071805715560913,
0.2950465977191925,
0.4916118383407593,
0.22299443185329437,
0.6750093102455139,
0.22559858858585358,
0.511622428894043,
-0.6250784397125244,
0.34182626008987427,
-0.283963143825531,
-0.6102465987205505,
-0.3190251886844635,
-0.43062376976013184,
-1.1428546905517578,
0.21870650351047516,
-0.4487183690071106,
-0.5997940897941589,
0.41350463032722473,
-0.04855293780565262,
-0.6553263068199158,
0.16304674744606018,
-1.0032949447631836,
0.6374053955078125,
-0.49622228741645813,
0.21005526185035706,
-0.351688414812088,
-1.0846331119537354,
0.1965680718421936,
-0.0408385805785656,
0.7153981924057007,
-0.41716742515563965,
-0.2886652946472168,
0.6275966763496399,
-0.6063628792762756,
0.9447569251060486,
-0.16388890147209167,
0.04907773807644844,
0.3338494598865509,
-0.12428382784128189,
0.19871914386749268,
0.09754719585180283,
-0.5707160234451294,
0.4182196855545044,
0.193267360329628,
-0.4827052354812622,
-0.5984247326850891,
0.2941265106201172,
-0.5108202695846558,
-0.2183983325958252,
-0.5307111740112305,
-0.3557299077510834,
-0.21684497594833374,
0.12022022157907486,
0.25175848603248596,
0.7621259689331055,
0.06357532739639282,
-0.15685482323169708,
0.39083945751190186,
-0.5114262104034424,
0.4149354100227356,
0.4708477556705475,
-0.08027162402868271,
-0.4826386272907257,
0.5725404620170593,
0.39202675223350525,
0.25547006726264954,
0.4843176305294037,
0.660006582736969,
-0.3388926684856415,
-0.5906505584716797,
-0.568195641040802,
0.31526488065719604,
-0.539401650428772,
-0.2563079297542572,
-0.7098575234413147,
-0.0420263409614563,
-0.5739973187446594,
-0.17762786149978638,
-0.23719662427902222,
-0.4207708239555359,
-0.10409817844629288,
-0.46281376481056213,
0.3458455204963684,
0.6536843180656433,
-0.33427199721336365,
-0.08248797059059143,
-0.9586871266365051,
0.7035753130912781,
0.12446146458387375,
0.032845597714185715,
-0.025599433109164238,
-0.22500810027122498,
0.15037909150123596,
0.0637834444642067,
0.07944457232952118,
-1.2991855144500732,
0.36938926577568054,
0.24308909475803375,
0.45038092136383057,
0.1857454478740692,
0.2595776915550232,
0.8023477792739868,
-0.7325442433357239,
0.5012817978858948,
0.17989498376846313,
-0.7891550660133362,
0.7609800696372986,
-0.4146510660648346,
0.25236719846725464,
0.7083145976066589,
0.6156911849975586,
-0.5503715872764587,
-0.4093841314315796,
-1.007894515991211,
-0.8497309684753418,
0.13062784075737,
0.014566727913916111,
-0.0694793239235878,
-0.4718191623687744,
0.20798394083976746,
0.1952807456254959,
0.12787605822086334,
-0.4388591945171356,
-0.2735960781574249,
0.011089703999459743,
-0.2909257411956787,
-0.057971127331256866,
-0.36290234327316284,
0.038158200681209564,
-0.39128410816192627,
0.4906507730484009,
-0.29895567893981934,
0.3206113576889038,
0.25769102573394775,
0.21730755269527435,
0.025349797680974007,
-0.002690030261874199,
0.63633793592453,
1.136231780052185,
-0.13780395686626434,
0.23404203355312347,
0.19378791749477386,
-0.3987193703651428,
0.26935410499572754,
0.19640229642391205,
-0.10787543654441833,
0.40734708309173584,
0.80516117811203,
0.3971133232116699,
0.20393279194831848,
-0.8107832074165344,
0.9533898234367371,
-0.2035301774740219,
0.08641582727432251,
-0.573511004447937,
-0.2901093661785126,
0.0785386711359024,
-0.12454621493816376,
0.3658708333969116,
0.2918103039264679,
0.4519121050834656,
-0.48453289270401,
0.5845840573310852,
0.03977443650364876,
-0.10470983386039734,
-0.11189394444227219,
0.5754014253616333,
0.22024686634540558,
-0.17620089650154114,
0.3830667734146118,
-0.07303066551685333,
0.03816136345267296,
0.7471337914466858,
0.2285865694284439,
0.603308916091919,
-0.45360732078552246,
0.4752098619937897,
0.43159109354019165,
0.2523575723171234,
-0.41990354657173157,
0.24158063530921936,
0.4609941244125366,
-0.8324935436248779,
-1.1795544624328613,
-0.42827674746513367,
-0.48975953459739685,
0.09336055815219879,
-0.7792602777481079,
0.18414932489395142,
-0.15676762163639069,
-0.16877228021621704,
0.42964187264442444,
-0.43388035893440247,
-0.20016302168369293,
0.47890761494636536,
0.6150371432304382,
1.0331593751907349,
-1.2435016632080078,
0.7387902140617371,
0.3016105592250824,
-0.45002222061157227,
-0.8237751126289368,
-0.04411220923066139,
0.2198357880115509,
-0.7315274477005005,
0.2925559878349304,
0.18312466144561768,
0.03526819497346878,
-0.15622013807296753,
-0.41929197311401367,
-0.9030300378799438,
0.5302321314811707,
0.5170524716377258,
-0.47697848081588745,
-0.30271878838539124,
-0.2101769745349884,
0.4192151427268982,
-0.13313814997673035,
0.5391223430633545,
0.228252574801445,
0.6927048563957214,
-0.15183986723423004,
-0.9394760131835938,
-0.0764823853969574,
0.0902944803237915,
-0.12317216396331787,
0.25744205713272095,
-0.2348155528306961,
0.5545661449432373,
-0.44062066078186035,
0.010932119563221931,
0.07692917436361313,
0.6362448930740356,
0.4276284873485565,
0.6028382182121277,
0.6480668187141418,
0.6697180867195129,
0.9275050163269043,
-0.06677699834108353,
1.548479437828064,
-0.03626978397369385,
0.18070904910564423,
1.1092771291732788,
-0.2077764868736267,
0.8406983613967896,
0.3885696828365326,
-0.32743126153945923,
0.7252073287963867,
0.5459131598472595,
0.13815763592720032,
0.4043784737586975,
0.1269577294588089,
-0.3421383798122406,
-0.3126433193683624,
-0.18243619799613953,
-0.13243916630744934,
0.6606967449188232,
0.4807075262069702,
-0.2231767475605011,
-0.325519323348999,
0.14819656312465668,
0.12472113966941833,
0.04952504113316536,
-0.07839841395616531,
0.8077682852745056,
0.041444081813097,
-0.6756809949874878,
0.1585671305656433,
-0.16893449425697327,
0.27532973885536194,
-0.655486524105072,
-0.5606142282485962,
0.23296485841274261,
-0.17368879914283752,
-0.21071960031986237,
-0.7909431457519531,
0.641506552696228,
-0.3433069884777069,
-0.2771911919116974,
-0.3204544484615326,
0.9141407608985901,
-0.3839142620563507,
-0.6733983159065247,
0.4167059361934662,
0.7553421854972839,
0.41389167308807373,
-0.27074187994003296,
-0.6839151382446289,
-0.05641894042491913,
-0.03408002108335495,
-0.09686484187841415,
0.21908050775527954,
0.37021404504776,
-0.15199680626392365,
0.7459652423858643,
0.6087812781333923,
0.6155035495758057,
-0.059721991419792175,
0.360196977853775,
0.27272748947143555,
-0.4508984684944153,
-0.5681816339492798,
-0.8670110702514648,
0.6035515666007996,
-0.1130959615111351,
-0.2245464324951172,
0.585534930229187,
0.549201488494873,
0.4198123514652252,
0.00640367716550827,
0.9303632378578186,
0.08785375952720642,
0.7204172015190125,
-0.5927091240882874,
0.34514090418815613,
-0.2148880660533905,
-0.24406196177005768,
-0.153631791472435,
-0.29066896438598633,
-0.36008280515670776,
0.7047340869903564,
-0.4820778965950012,
-0.050282593816518784,
0.7417305707931519,
0.26486316323280334,
0.277110755443573,
0.01149683352559805,
0.2483258992433548,
0.1122315302491188,
0.10814797878265381,
0.3879478871822357,
0.6219679117202759,
-0.4255734384059906,
0.2065799981355667,
-0.23587706685066223,
-0.43367841839790344,
-0.057015273720026016,
-1.0419824123382568,
-0.10196737200021744,
-0.4450390636920929,
-0.4288622736930847,
-0.28392714262008667,
0.037714190781116486,
0.6135085225105286,
0.8586861491203308,
-0.5953525304794312,
-0.07738769054412842,
-0.01088462769985199,
0.22659118473529816,
-0.4079349935054779,
-0.21761451661586761,
0.33581364154815674,
-0.1093442291021347,
-0.4043474495410919,
0.5951740741729736,
0.48688241839408875,
0.1220245510339737,
0.17847870290279388,
0.1466386616230011,
-0.416351318359375,
0.07809265702962875,
0.8048049211502075,
0.13524632155895233,
-0.8174493312835693,
-0.3216126263141632,
-0.4807240962982178,
0.0373026579618454,
0.13816247880458832,
0.7950985431671143,
-0.9381359219551086,
0.516097903251648,
0.5819372534751892,
0.5726862549781799,
0.24283920228481293,
0.24226030707359314,
0.9215631484985352,
-0.6372687816619873,
0.08865484595298767,
0.41319745779037476,
0.5531560182571411,
0.19459830224514008,
-0.38534820079803467,
0.7883375883102417,
0.2687704265117645,
-0.47403261065483093,
-0.6346123218536377,
0.2654719352722168,
-0.9582144618034363,
-0.6223143339157104,
1.1965596675872803,
-0.004876112099736929,
-0.11213693022727966,
-0.6911717653274536,
-0.14361384510993958,
0.2608289420604706,
-0.3252229392528534,
0.6202229857444763,
0.509593665599823,
-0.48039165139198303,
-0.20072583854198456,
-1.069175124168396,
0.4992026686668396,
0.2798115909099579,
-1.0990045070648193,
0.08426450192928314,
0.5705733299255371,
-0.025831662118434906,
0.3844698965549469,
0.926478385925293,
0.03268450126051903,
0.33945637941360474,
0.0410948321223259,
0.19197453558444977,
0.33312639594078064,
-0.40301433205604553,
-0.1877485066652298,
0.1700325608253479,
-0.04052186757326126,
-0.021848920732736588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02431v1
|
On the Multilingual Ability of Decoder-based Pre-trained Language Models: Finding and Controlling Language-Specific Neurons
| 2024-04-03T03:37:22 | 2024-04-03T03:37:22 |
Takeshi Kojima, Itsuki Okimura, Yusuke Iwasawa, Hitomi Yanaka, Yutaka Matsuo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current decoder-based pre-trained language models (PLMs) successfully
demonstrate multilingual capabilities. However, it is unclear how these models
handle multilingualism. We analyze the neuron-level internal behavior of
multilingual decoder-based PLMs, Specifically examining the existence of
neurons that fire ``uniquely for each language'' within decoder-only
multilingual PLMs. We analyze six languages: English, German, French, Spanish,
Chinese, and Japanese, and show that language-specific neurons are unique, with
a slight overlap (< 5%) between languages. These neurons are mainly distributed
in the models' first and last few layers. This trend remains consistent across
languages and models. Additionally, we tamper with less than 1% of the total
neurons in each model during inference and demonstrate that tampering with a
few language-specific neurons drastically changes the probability of target
language occurrence in text generation.
|
[
-0.314826637506485,
-0.5009640455245972,
0.3314593732357025,
0.562964141368866,
-0.03533341735601425,
0.09645746648311615,
-0.3778975307941437,
-0.21008917689323425,
0.11827269941568375,
0.3245188891887665,
-0.3707984983921051,
-0.3145955502986908,
-0.5714384317398071,
0.298629492521286,
-0.20310425758361816,
0.9479561448097229,
0.019019844010472298,
0.27454957365989685,
-0.039601996541023254,
-0.13066793978214264,
-0.17405417561531067,
-0.9737858176231384,
-0.3690040111541748,
-0.48722049593925476,
0.711004376411438,
0.01624094881117344,
0.556169867515564,
0.20388004183769226,
0.2703869938850403,
0.3596065640449524,
-0.20215246081352234,
0.051743075251579285,
-0.22081772983074188,
-0.2013077735900879,
-0.2152561992406845,
-0.5983361601829529,
-0.337131142616272,
-0.3058324158191681,
0.6281338930130005,
0.6745491623878479,
-0.21672017872333527,
-0.29802215099334717,
0.11603628098964691,
0.13180238008499146,
-0.46137967705726624,
-0.1146397665143013,
-0.8111092448234558,
0.14300161600112915,
-0.16245527565479279,
-0.3054268956184387,
-0.6816180348396301,
0.0434100404381752,
-0.11666462570428848,
-0.4650968909263611,
0.3624075949192047,
-0.6260635852813721,
0.633171021938324,
-0.19040052592754364,
-0.5046640634536743,
-0.140033558011055,
-0.5593580007553101,
0.6293882131576538,
-0.7158334851264954,
0.20260347425937653,
0.4882911443710327,
-0.19634439051151276,
-0.03061685711145401,
-0.5201356410980225,
-0.4209643006324768,
-0.21202322840690613,
-0.29873597621917725,
-0.11108691990375519,
-0.010665573179721832,
0.042844679206609726,
0.3468623757362366,
0.0032023400999605656,
-0.6353299617767334,
0.1485341191291809,
-0.10809888690710068,
-0.283633828163147,
0.42348620295524597,
-0.011199431493878365,
0.761285126209259,
0.032269030809402466,
-0.2549629807472229,
0.005814134608954191,
-0.4838098883628845,
0.14024747908115387,
0.6726304888725281,
0.36767247319221497,
-0.15121765434741974,
0.3438061773777008,
0.1466795802116394,
0.6639569401741028,
-0.37252047657966614,
-0.11577244102954865,
0.4419383704662323,
-0.53695148229599,
-0.04656579717993736,
0.12416427582502365,
0.9873298406600952,
-0.11474420130252838,
0.684286892414093,
-0.2142159789800644,
-0.3609171509742737,
0.036146119236946106,
0.2891072630882263,
-0.5655600428581238,
-0.2708100378513336,
-0.08744368702173233,
-0.39588892459869385,
-0.04168577492237091,
-0.2720377445220947,
-0.26176878809928894,
-0.2006819099187851,
0.06607206165790558,
0.48404639959335327,
-0.36703044176101685,
-0.8446805477142334,
0.3353198766708374,
-0.16244298219680786,
0.07870233803987503,
-0.2797488272190094,
-1.1030563116073608,
0.19319653511047363,
0.2261018306016922,
0.7325708270072937,
-0.23089788854122162,
-1.05207097530365,
-0.11627377569675446,
0.1331995278596878,
-0.5920069813728333,
0.6782039403915405,
-0.6432080268859863,
-0.29970458149909973,
0.1918010115623474,
0.3210325539112091,
-0.3048875033855438,
-0.5098469257354736,
0.11134318262338638,
-0.6664882898330688,
-0.14866209030151367,
-0.37237533926963806,
-0.06921540200710297,
-0.04878527671098709,
0.23844341933727264,
-0.6369083523750305,
0.4147478938102722,
-0.32640138268470764,
-0.8323174118995667,
0.24613700807094574,
-0.4126601219177246,
-0.7647931575775146,
-0.06646362692117691,
-0.22190003097057343,
-0.16609887778759003,
0.43944594264030457,
0.0064078387804329395,
0.2778894901275635,
0.06730451434850693,
0.24276763200759888,
-0.024456270039081573,
-0.34502938389778137,
0.3767622411251068,
-0.7053817510604858,
0.7988321185112,
-0.009077438153326511,
-0.15915043652057648,
0.34928861260414124,
-0.7128586769104004,
0.25472527742385864,
0.3238445520401001,
-0.3709631860256195,
-0.3129575550556183,
0.024843474850058556,
-0.04083292558789253,
0.4964715242385864,
0.23276355862617493,
-0.43550464510917664,
0.1139015182852745,
-0.32181623578071594,
0.485840380191803,
0.5506231188774109,
-0.15902160108089447,
0.5679705739021301,
-0.2057540863752365,
0.4833947420120239,
0.3099055886268616,
-0.1182132288813591,
-0.7142593264579773,
-0.47664687037467957,
-0.5290647149085999,
-0.07628464698791504,
0.06861753761768341,
0.5661147832870483,
-0.6338871121406555,
0.10603747516870499,
-0.03830598667263985,
-0.16185422241687775,
-0.49229151010513306,
0.10354579985141754,
0.5475696921348572,
-0.004662775434553623,
0.22880248725414276,
-0.22064629197120667,
-0.057173557579517365,
-1.016237497329712,
-0.5015349388122559,
0.2980479896068573,
0.1828509271144867,
-0.1424148678779602,
0.3747619688510895,
-0.016076330095529556,
0.37131884694099426,
0.12345120310783386,
0.01908930577337742,
-0.5031812191009521,
0.10478688776493073,
0.16013085842132568,
0.5157778859138489,
0.5544278621673584,
-0.8638265132904053,
-0.6610608696937561,
0.3633536994457245,
-0.8659011721611023,
0.0002994663664139807,
-0.5484061241149902,
0.13356764614582062,
0.31940463185310364,
0.3970484435558319,
-0.549146294593811,
0.44269683957099915,
0.5390663146972656,
-0.157858744263649,
0.5179960131645203,
-0.850701093673706,
0.09909427911043167,
-0.8493710160255432,
-0.0362950935959816,
-0.1517673283815384,
0.15717533230781555,
-0.9895420074462891,
0.05632639676332474,
0.38287606835365295,
0.08241589367389679,
-0.4803391695022583,
0.4056074321269989,
-0.6745224595069885,
-0.2986848056316376,
-0.5504131317138672,
-0.16385610401630402,
-0.06500271707773209,
0.6821798086166382,
0.48278501629829407,
0.6350868344306946,
0.7596258521080017,
-0.6945734620094299,
0.04148702323436737,
0.05869182571768761,
-0.6874832510948181,
0.06579231470823288,
-0.6218461394309998,
0.08571116626262665,
-0.30222856998443604,
-0.16928933560848236,
-0.7937328219413757,
-0.06894233077764511,
-0.2166946977376938,
-0.30633410811424255,
0.4581899344921112,
-0.19002613425254822,
-0.5432095527648926,
-0.02834903448820114,
0.15778222680091858,
0.46279725432395935,
0.20106640458106995,
-0.5355132222175598,
0.6153838634490967,
0.2050059586763382,
-0.2274816781282425,
-0.8208940029144287,
-1.0479745864868164,
0.1319727748632431,
0.1107005700469017,
-0.531441867351532,
0.24099332094192505,
-0.3501780033111572,
-0.16208294034004211,
-0.2503950893878937,
0.0465635322034359,
-0.13052277266979218,
0.09855078160762787,
0.04714209586381912,
-0.19749726355075836,
-0.13900870084762573,
0.053479742258787155,
0.18154309689998627,
-0.06500273942947388,
0.09798587113618851,
-0.1044415682554245,
1.0055537223815918,
-0.11291815340518951,
-0.5534888505935669,
-0.44408324360847473,
0.6169038414955139,
0.5894358158111572,
-0.7786901593208313,
0.8436920642852783,
0.41334205865859985,
-0.2675642669200897,
-0.29123958945274353,
-0.19249022006988525,
-0.20932258665561676,
-0.5058581233024597,
0.6948069334030151,
-1.1111750602722168,
-0.5209674835205078,
0.9565280675888062,
0.27733635902404785,
-0.07993443310260773,
0.15728075802326202,
0.6349844932556152,
0.32253551483154297,
1.3481906652450562,
0.6723010540008545,
0.1202213242650032,
0.4495435655117035,
-0.1825006902217865,
0.27760112285614014,
-0.5067874193191528,
-0.3851507604122162,
-0.3057515323162079,
-0.17510771751403809,
-0.6505627036094666,
0.03594588860869408,
-0.0283418707549572,
0.28544893860816956,
-0.3143414258956909,
0.30407142639160156,
-0.39758849143981934,
0.763903021812439,
0.5359146595001221,
-0.3116944134235382,
0.1870821714401245,
0.27475038170814514,
-0.62542325258255,
-0.01317594200372696,
-0.968925952911377,
-0.31469494104385376,
0.7491421103477478,
0.1684727817773819,
0.6070342063903809,
0.04132566601037979,
0.5177913308143616,
-0.17743337154388428,
0.1620100885629654,
-0.25126343965530396,
0.3958030045032501,
-0.28100091218948364,
-0.7227350473403931,
0.07619093358516693,
-0.47750914096832275,
-0.8504320383071899,
0.6826578974723816,
0.001973511418327689,
-0.6710108518600464,
0.2461615651845932,
-0.02417818456888199,
-0.1380242556333542,
0.7564404010772705,
-0.8901507258415222,
1.1255993843078613,
-0.7608218789100647,
-0.3312986493110657,
-0.1555870920419693,
-0.4173687696456909,
0.16380517184734344,
-0.30098649859428406,
0.26624616980552673,
-0.025864768773317337,
0.02707102708518505,
0.20852826535701752,
0.13208924233913422,
0.7756598591804504,
0.012556117959320545,
-0.37351205945014954,
0.1587677001953125,
0.4063056707382202,
0.15566015243530273,
0.0216786228120327,
-0.05353310704231262,
0.5090497732162476,
0.08244141191244125,
-0.5311130285263062,
-0.22616946697235107,
1.0377180576324463,
-0.8336499929428101,
-0.5221165418624878,
-0.544921338558197,
-0.6594458818435669,
0.0065154265612363815,
0.4344173073768616,
0.6802670359611511,
0.385990172624588,
-0.22979119420051575,
-0.135409876704216,
0.5640439391136169,
-0.7082716226577759,
0.9778956174850464,
0.8105739951133728,
-0.35943517088890076,
-0.149722158908844,
1.027288556098938,
0.11752315610647202,
0.36235511302948,
0.4119817912578583,
0.07464966922998428,
-0.019440049305558205,
-0.5994290113449097,
-0.3478820323944092,
0.24594661593437195,
-0.6560892462730408,
0.21405203640460968,
-0.6964302062988281,
-0.24801383912563324,
-0.29304900765419006,
-0.08219828456640244,
-0.3637142479419708,
0.12305285781621933,
-0.2924996018409729,
-0.15739893913269043,
-0.19646142423152924,
0.8710863590240479,
-0.13880762457847595,
0.4632263779640198,
-0.8587630391120911,
0.37374451756477356,
0.17689867317676544,
0.5929933190345764,
0.046045128256082535,
-0.5143792629241943,
-0.17988426983356476,
0.1675439327955246,
0.18214792013168335,
-1.0377306938171387,
0.6075512170791626,
0.3002135753631592,
0.7424135208129883,
0.3852825462818146,
-0.3433573246002197,
0.19141201674938202,
-0.6013133525848389,
0.7418972849845886,
0.27395549416542053,
-0.8116849660873413,
0.15045484900474548,
-0.3743426203727722,
0.7572829723358154,
0.020727645605802536,
0.6238666772842407,
-0.4947015643119812,
-0.26215094327926636,
-0.3412717878818512,
-0.4403493404388428,
1.1257047653198242,
0.049680911004543304,
0.670349657535553,
-0.4021074175834656,
0.09120893478393555,
0.1062130257487297,
0.1312863677740097,
-1.1289860010147095,
-0.26005709171295166,
-0.38917088508605957,
0.0806126818060875,
-0.24752898514270782,
-0.31385403871536255,
-0.03697829693555832,
-0.08885753899812698,
0.2368019074201584,
-0.09168963879346848,
0.07090646773576736,
0.0016582465032115579,
-0.35583168268203735,
0.160441592335701,
0.35319972038269043,
0.8948582410812378,
0.7497657537460327,
0.08504016697406769,
0.42077991366386414,
0.1089121624827385,
-0.32402878999710083,
0.21166788041591644,
-0.21459870040416718,
-0.08392138034105301,
0.20009423792362213,
0.3532765805721283,
0.9855778217315674,
0.0008083092980086803,
-0.5320944786071777,
0.4485654830932617,
-0.213393896818161,
-0.20194531977176666,
-0.315044641494751,
-0.09414126724004745,
0.3034568130970001,
0.07820343971252441,
0.18349839746952057,
0.32772189378738403,
-0.41246113181114197,
-0.4600462317466736,
0.11691836267709732,
0.47334712743759155,
-0.13509610295295715,
-0.774016261100769,
0.49374860525131226,
-0.05820661038160324,
-0.5128214955329895,
0.5148268938064575,
-0.3490932881832123,
-0.7082753777503967,
0.841241717338562,
0.965816080570221,
0.5983622074127197,
-0.562332808971405,
0.19381198287010193,
0.39357128739356995,
0.6566135883331299,
-0.2570366859436035,
0.4543628394603729,
0.08813737332820892,
-1.196655511856079,
-0.5309894680976868,
-0.47729629278182983,
0.3520272970199585,
0.2876860201358795,
-0.5153312087059021,
-0.10883088409900665,
-0.3110962212085724,
-0.2964288592338562,
0.029341664165258408,
-0.4467875361442566,
-0.49256354570388794,
0.061933767050504684,
0.25803592801094055,
0.8125735521316528,
-0.6990418434143066,
1.287846326828003,
0.6728527545928955,
-0.36524274945259094,
-0.4108177423477173,
-0.25828853249549866,
-0.40324661135673523,
-0.5589455366134644,
0.7801176309585571,
0.13413041830062866,
-0.19768786430358887,
-0.02908312901854515,
-0.26110005378723145,
-0.6982376575469971,
0.21298666298389435,
0.675011932849884,
-0.3251909613609314,
-0.1862393319606781,
0.4520220160484314,
0.6314758658409119,
-0.28286856412887573,
0.35744500160217285,
0.400247186422348,
0.30446550250053406,
-0.5084749460220337,
-1.0213960409164429,
-0.5263609290122986,
-0.6060957908630371,
-0.020883092656731606,
0.3324003219604492,
-0.3874289095401764,
1.0410634279251099,
-0.4054984450340271,
-0.20351555943489075,
-0.09750474989414215,
0.36668282747268677,
-0.0054555051028728485,
-0.049599532037973404,
0.11180047690868378,
0.4994678795337677,
0.4355243146419525,
0.009096214547753334,
1.230089545249939,
-0.5013097524642944,
-0.0429484061896801,
1.21719229221344,
-0.30061373114585876,
0.7612941861152649,
0.31636670231819153,
0.2250899225473404,
0.48866572976112366,
0.33328214287757874,
0.0930691808462143,
0.6361632347106934,
0.11295870691537857,
-0.4267277121543884,
-0.475938618183136,
0.027638277038931847,
-0.28872716426849365,
0.42680197954177856,
0.2894939184188843,
-0.28578636050224304,
-0.03589826822280884,
0.3749566376209259,
0.0027950319927185774,
0.18839332461357117,
-0.32070550322532654,
0.7579973340034485,
0.07743918150663376,
-0.8077279925346375,
0.6796322464942932,
0.16867318749427795,
0.9426906108856201,
-1.0326775312423706,
0.19726493954658508,
-0.44602110981941223,
0.22999736666679382,
-0.2507436275482178,
-0.672491192817688,
0.18491648137569427,
-0.0025404312182217836,
-0.33890223503112793,
-0.4302474558353424,
0.5153605341911316,
-0.7552995681762695,
-0.22922636568546295,
0.8015199899673462,
0.4512426555156708,
0.08818116039037704,
-0.2864614427089691,
-0.3791540563106537,
0.07799682766199112,
0.1638231724500656,
-0.3162202537059784,
0.6334524750709534,
0.32351136207580566,
-0.005203270353376865,
0.5367557406425476,
0.6093645691871643,
0.2983200252056122,
0.6278718113899231,
0.3226993978023529,
0.3708621859550476,
-0.6111323833465576,
-0.47801339626312256,
-0.7285371422767639,
0.3475239872932434,
0.08711348474025726,
-0.4095131754875183,
0.7848230600357056,
0.3684913218021393,
1.2925515174865723,
-0.32257571816444397,
0.8011302351951599,
0.2253151535987854,
0.02619999088346958,
-0.26012927293777466,
0.9938633441925049,
-0.6585606336593628,
0.06374864280223846,
0.1285446584224701,
-0.858825147151947,
-0.24468213319778442,
0.6798498630523682,
-0.20184274017810822,
0.28022870421409607,
0.7822901010513306,
0.9252647161483765,
-0.0497940331697464,
-0.09299425035715103,
0.6635746955871582,
0.020680269226431847,
0.19376854598522186,
0.5311815738677979,
0.8788337707519531,
-0.08135863393545151,
0.58261638879776,
-0.39312252402305603,
0.1083141416311264,
0.5318314433097839,
-0.7518078088760376,
-0.8187630772590637,
-0.5636959075927734,
-0.13938379287719727,
0.07646146416664124,
-0.2075701206922531,
0.4526974856853485,
0.6226024627685547,
-0.8925928473472595,
-0.5049326419830322,
-0.1744508296251297,
0.12374652177095413,
-0.19074049592018127,
-0.12579280138015747,
0.13257651031017303,
-0.7450417280197144,
-0.709502637386322,
0.6901718974113464,
0.18804147839546204,
0.0355808325111866,
-0.17361389100551605,
-0.08569469302892685,
-0.42023706436157227,
0.05814223736524582,
0.4748222827911377,
0.4022729992866516,
-0.672130823135376,
0.24324962496757507,
0.22537992894649506,
-0.3953886926174164,
0.10266793519258499,
1.0849568843841553,
-0.43236279487609863,
0.6893931031227112,
0.6524837017059326,
0.438018262386322,
0.2846640348434448,
-0.4698091447353363,
0.6539464592933655,
-0.913155734539032,
0.47660040855407715,
0.12814149260520935,
0.5134263634681702,
0.4019756615161896,
0.0890113040804863,
-0.049196869134902954,
0.07370240986347198,
-0.3493077754974365,
-0.6693729758262634,
0.3006282448768616,
-0.5037074685096741,
-0.741624653339386,
1.1713355779647827,
-0.355151891708374,
-0.10229447484016418,
0.036259040236473083,
0.07026602327823639,
0.08843616396188736,
0.17272600531578064,
0.357621967792511,
0.8072006106376648,
0.17297734320163727,
-0.29687896370887756,
-0.4083545207977295,
0.5493457317352295,
0.6475362181663513,
-0.5533820390701294,
-0.04537786915898323,
0.10408730804920197,
0.26039236783981323,
0.34650635719299316,
0.6220899820327759,
-0.07172637432813644,
0.15501175820827484,
0.05664365738630295,
0.4391498565673828,
0.017996644601225853,
-0.780695915222168,
-0.7789139747619629,
0.336359441280365,
0.03366104140877724,
0.0233570896089077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02422v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02422v1
|
Enhancing Low-Resource LLMs Classification with PEFT and Synthetic Data
| 2024-04-03T03:24:19 | 2024-04-03T03:24:19 |
Parth Patwa, Simone Filice, Zhiyu Chen, Giuseppe Castellucci, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) operating in 0-shot or few-shot settings achieve
competitive results in Text Classification tasks. In-Context Learning (ICL)
typically achieves better accuracy than the 0-shot setting, but it pays in
terms of efficiency, due to the longer input prompt. In this paper, we propose
a strategy to make LLMs as efficient as 0-shot text classifiers, while getting
comparable or better accuracy than ICL. Our solution targets the low resource
setting, i.e., when only 4 examples per class are available. Using a single LLM
and few-shot real data we perform a sequence of generation, filtering and
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning steps to create a robust and efficient
classifier. Experimental results show that our approach leads to competitive
results on multiple text classification datasets.
|
[
-0.20861978828907013,
-0.6306820511817932,
0.6093882918357849,
-0.025543618947267532,
-0.29784083366394043,
0.5518449544906616,
-0.571056604385376,
-0.5259494781494141,
-0.2741728723049164,
0.43336039781570435,
-0.3074048161506653,
-0.4599877595901489,
-0.4615016579627991,
0.551507294178009,
-0.21112214028835297,
0.942523717880249,
-0.16852572560310364,
-0.2769182622432709,
-0.003991819452494383,
-0.2815015912055969,
-0.19232787191867828,
-0.6627971529960632,
-0.7598840594291687,
-0.5838050842285156,
0.5378542542457581,
0.7777126431465149,
0.21216106414794922,
0.7269512414932251,
0.2898496389389038,
0.30397337675094604,
-0.15771101415157318,
0.4593387246131897,
-0.42798128724098206,
0.10102332383394241,
-0.028147803619503975,
-0.47028258442878723,
-0.2726767957210541,
0.16241483390331268,
0.8722671270370483,
0.47311103343963623,
0.019426977261900902,
0.18351426720619202,
0.41247349977493286,
0.298570841550827,
-0.6401746869087219,
0.05000441148877144,
-0.8508993983268738,
0.1570844203233719,
-0.4066386818885803,
-0.36295056343078613,
-0.637387752532959,
-0.18292640149593353,
0.15941014885902405,
-0.39119473099708557,
0.19063764810562134,
0.1124921664595604,
0.6635603904724121,
0.11605758219957352,
-0.34993189573287964,
-0.030788546428084373,
-0.55709308385849,
1.1588650941848755,
-0.614707887172699,
0.2781941294670105,
0.18292267620563507,
0.2690192759037018,
-0.04742017015814781,
-0.6392235159873962,
-0.6461153626441956,
-0.0013119785580784082,
-0.23137235641479492,
-0.06777671724557877,
0.12666301429271698,
0.043662045150995255,
0.19238290190696716,
0.08554757386445999,
-0.2665864825248718,
0.37576407194137573,
-0.14036141335964203,
-0.09872791916131973,
0.5136117339134216,
0.16494572162628174,
-0.08691266179084778,
-0.016963887959718704,
-0.33319881558418274,
-0.10724642872810364,
-0.6987618207931519,
0.0637701153755188,
0.07707983255386353,
0.7825022339820862,
-0.04578235000371933,
0.43459954857826233,
-0.1523480862379074,
0.8529029488563538,
0.2780379056930542,
-0.8224608302116394,
0.17522765696048737,
-0.40246155858039856,
-0.2500917911529541,
0.3686318099498749,
0.6808546781539917,
0.019681284204125404,
-0.12360527366399765,
0.001986634684726596,
-0.3809368312358856,
-0.11210910230875015,
0.030586164444684982,
-1.0226255655288696,
0.07807107269763947,
-0.13751959800720215,
-0.36760902404785156,
-0.5920346975326538,
-0.27624082565307617,
-0.665753185749054,
-0.25355249643325806,
-0.34127485752105713,
0.3980960547924042,
-0.34024789929389954,
0.3119352459907532,
-0.10592882335186005,
0.07426180690526962,
0.31829801201820374,
0.4950424134731293,
-0.8051910996437073,
0.3957740068435669,
0.3553420901298523,
1.1462225914001465,
-0.35426393151283264,
-0.08641704171895981,
-0.6770464181900024,
0.23159025609493256,
-0.2892620861530304,
1.0087997913360596,
-0.5003057718276978,
-0.36171838641166687,
-0.15421220660209656,
-0.14302992820739746,
0.16015756130218506,
-0.590155839920044,
0.5154971480369568,
-0.31551143527030945,
0.41455480456352234,
-0.04314572736620903,
-0.6432026028633118,
-0.03596259281039238,
0.4769429862499237,
-0.31010159850120544,
1.1365344524383545,
0.3201303780078888,
-0.403180330991745,
0.5168139338493347,
-0.7500761151313782,
-0.47681957483291626,
0.4267812669277191,
-0.3633655905723572,
-0.4045284390449524,
0.027150850743055344,
0.06385378539562225,
0.7560800313949585,
-0.30804142355918884,
-0.0228952094912529,
-0.18083719909191132,
-0.6694984436035156,
0.17381292581558228,
-0.6335029602050781,
0.4510497748851776,
0.30477333068847656,
-0.3538137972354889,
-0.21696341037750244,
-0.7731155753135681,
0.1448684185743332,
0.00396306486800313,
-1.0311267375946045,
-0.3155836760997772,
-0.15455548465251923,
0.27164170145988464,
0.18930917978286743,
0.09139276295900345,
-0.5938730239868164,
0.26473331451416016,
-0.6643506288528442,
0.31764984130859375,
0.7446202635765076,
-0.09492435306310654,
0.8642359375953674,
-0.5244940519332886,
0.3668173551559448,
-0.22788143157958984,
-0.18097522854804993,
-0.21843788027763367,
-0.14844277501106262,
-0.6658183932304382,
-0.6395726203918457,
0.3967229723930359,
0.4915468394756317,
-0.9487312436103821,
0.42404046654701233,
-0.1395665407180786,
-0.4048006534576416,
-0.2140815556049347,
0.4541020691394806,
0.3434148132801056,
0.7758359313011169,
0.2743362486362457,
0.1371224820613861,
-0.34080252051353455,
-0.6330116391181946,
-0.23817914724349976,
-0.0569845475256443,
-0.12811174988746643,
0.5416242480278015,
0.15845289826393127,
-0.08014138787984848,
0.8451170921325684,
-0.27861902117729187,
-0.33048000931739807,
-0.5424615740776062,
0.06489300727844238,
0.4106626808643341,
0.29727688431739807,
0.7161000370979309,
-0.5697007179260254,
-0.988679826259613,
0.04299964755773544,
-0.6062325835227966,
-0.3100137412548065,
-0.16047097742557526,
0.008315120823681355,
0.459072083234787,
0.5166898369789124,
-0.028089575469493866,
-0.0013712991494685411,
0.2811052203178406,
-0.22155258059501648,
0.019617045298218727,
-0.03218793123960495,
-0.0022293732035905123,
-0.953890323638916,
-0.28466957807540894,
0.2826929986476898,
-0.5093189477920532,
-0.6055050492286682,
-0.22774040699005127,
0.14857318997383118,
-0.17514583468437195,
-0.7957448363304138,
0.7367159128189087,
-0.22339604794979095,
0.3422464430332184,
-0.47233179211616516,
0.1828693300485611,
-0.10539612919092178,
0.4686989486217499,
0.23120254278182983,
0.7934644818305969,
0.35861173272132874,
-0.6412105560302734,
0.19792784750461578,
0.011626370251178741,
-0.38414573669433594,
0.5770367980003357,
-0.25930342078208923,
0.08718887716531754,
-0.15132775902748108,
0.42248186469078064,
-0.5571532249450684,
-0.31729984283447266,
0.041542649269104004,
-0.01604531519114971,
0.4822250306606293,
-0.07351326942443848,
-0.6947201490402222,
0.0661991760134697,
-0.531684935092926,
0.3607581555843353,
0.6920598149299622,
-0.9847856760025024,
0.4083937704563141,
0.24102362990379333,
0.009713313542306423,
-0.3930776119232178,
-0.5906340479850769,
-0.03237438574433327,
-0.490233451128006,
-0.07578545808792114,
0.72987300157547,
0.06546305119991302,
-0.062073588371276855,
-0.12837673723697662,
-0.03510168567299843,
-0.16023950278759003,
0.2688395380973816,
-0.10898809880018234,
0.2186945676803589,
-0.029382502660155296,
0.46882471442222595,
0.07931069284677505,
0.005779406521469355,
-0.5008805990219116,
-0.266461044549942,
0.40917736291885376,
-0.1269885003566742,
0.017162198200821877,
-0.5299201011657715,
0.19265985488891602,
0.502305805683136,
0.24314741790294647,
0.6886102557182312,
0.4286418557167053,
-0.48831889033317566,
-0.7970095276832581,
-0.3284052014350891,
-0.163183331489563,
-0.544736921787262,
0.19253920018672943,
-0.28431278467178345,
-1.0737583637237549,
-0.011902895756065845,
-0.3984011709690094,
0.10789787024259567,
0.23324738442897797,
0.5233684182167053,
-0.2860349714756012,
0.7839330434799194,
0.8614741563796997,
-0.058235540986061096,
0.772101879119873,
-0.3254527151584625,
0.209100142121315,
-0.557918906211853,
-0.1994033008813858,
-0.4766565263271332,
-0.4771070182323456,
-0.691758930683136,
-0.3373468518257141,
0.5801013112068176,
0.19048964977264404,
-0.35774654150009155,
0.40120062232017517,
-0.5987609624862671,
0.8922473788261414,
0.5443755388259888,
0.33917179703712463,
0.2516998052597046,
0.18617026507854462,
-0.0396907739341259,
-0.04944893717765808,
-1.0489680767059326,
-0.772207498550415,
1.15837824344635,
0.28362926840782166,
0.7355159521102905,
0.06416207551956177,
0.9391834139823914,
0.17862923443317413,
0.5454031229019165,
-0.9548210501670837,
0.511154294013977,
-0.383886456489563,
-0.41099292039871216,
-0.30891546607017517,
-0.4398654103279114,
-0.4625869691371918,
0.19121482968330383,
-0.4691302180290222,
-0.4398004412651062,
0.10304046422243118,
0.22871141135692596,
-0.6168878674507141,
0.38853007555007935,
-0.6634525656700134,
0.6280211210250854,
-0.46400871872901917,
-0.5090802311897278,
-0.07280643284320831,
-0.24508561193943024,
0.28205910325050354,
-0.6745195984840393,
0.08376205712556839,
-0.1758638322353363,
-0.35451218485832214,
0.5440521240234375,
-0.46434858441352844,
0.8978973031044006,
-0.07424135506153107,
0.15621879696846008,
0.4807710349559784,
-0.21143782138824463,
0.5784323811531067,
-0.0473213829100132,
-0.3492826521396637,
0.13325665891170502,
-0.11949114501476288,
-0.4210917353630066,
-0.4984472393989563,
0.6830700039863586,
-0.5972667932510376,
-0.21761374175548553,
-0.6508080959320068,
-0.3200957477092743,
-0.3731619417667389,
-0.052970729768276215,
0.4284040629863739,
0.27180564403533936,
0.017633816227316856,
0.4755023121833801,
0.5904847979545593,
-0.3336831033229828,
0.842648983001709,
0.6449646949768066,
0.19690512120723724,
-0.2001945674419403,
0.723332941532135,
0.297712504863739,
0.10752234607934952,
0.4676625728607178,
0.1924068182706833,
-0.42574986815452576,
-0.600005567073822,
-0.27550074458122253,
0.07313106209039688,
-0.5395408272743225,
-0.698032021522522,
-0.41426530480384827,
-0.365079790353775,
-0.14678479731082916,
-0.5128956437110901,
-0.22924666106700897,
-0.15470345318317413,
-0.5016335844993591,
0.09322671592235565,
0.37522780895233154,
0.293811559677124,
0.1293186992406845,
0.7172011733055115,
-0.852739691734314,
-0.022350823506712914,
0.30868861079216003,
0.5684826970100403,
-0.19013187289237976,
-0.8109798431396484,
-0.36908167600631714,
-0.3211595416069031,
-0.45808640122413635,
-0.5269770622253418,
0.4242152273654938,
0.6447932720184326,
0.5368180274963379,
0.19447365403175354,
0.11984752863645554,
0.6324699521064758,
-0.6880945563316345,
0.5444720983505249,
0.24805964529514313,
-0.9851516485214233,
0.5913809537887573,
-0.032110296189785004,
0.3053107261657715,
0.7447177171707153,
0.350396066904068,
-0.3085121810436249,
-0.14246028661727905,
-0.4557499289512634,
-0.5201483964920044,
1.026728630065918,
0.14946284890174866,
0.23372693359851837,
-0.004930132534354925,
0.6406192183494568,
0.0868675634264946,
0.03236472234129906,
-0.8347371220588684,
0.04333958402276039,
0.20016923546791077,
-0.5031031966209412,
-0.06944210827350616,
-0.25580117106437683,
0.12488849461078644,
-0.38081541657447815,
0.7522428631782532,
-0.4445329010486603,
-0.039333391934633255,
0.07568420469760895,
-0.12335514277219772,
-0.14037524163722992,
0.35719889402389526,
0.2786882519721985,
0.2560075521469116,
-0.15907005965709686,
0.35705292224884033,
0.7208610773086548,
-0.19114066660404205,
0.5316977500915527,
-0.2472679764032364,
-0.2131270319223404,
0.03488433361053467,
0.47166845202445984,
0.5180913209915161,
0.3453730046749115,
-0.9367567300796509,
0.4548044502735138,
0.08578912913799286,
-0.1684369593858719,
-0.11304842680692673,
0.24222718179225922,
-0.3863353729248047,
0.4989638924598694,
0.20971082150936127,
0.005350567866116762,
-0.06732844561338425,
-0.6243562698364258,
0.15633727610111237,
0.3552400767803192,
0.007604542188346386,
-0.14266625046730042,
0.26111695170402527,
0.3866288661956787,
-0.35235852003097534,
0.4020213782787323,
-0.42173004150390625,
-0.4903537631034851,
0.2757101356983185,
0.7450419068336487,
0.7320147752761841,
-0.08063290268182755,
0.1988799273967743,
0.2572915554046631,
0.07595512270927429,
-0.3295974135398865,
0.03222876414656639,
-0.2801756262779236,
-0.9461926221847534,
-0.42288386821746826,
-0.973301112651825,
-0.6262366771697998,
0.34910330176353455,
-0.10046539455652237,
0.6378519535064697,
-0.6953029036521912,
-0.1405750811100006,
0.07538054138422012,
0.23210026323795319,
-0.5776931643486023,
-0.066012442111969,
0.28603094816207886,
0.7547193765640259,
-0.7604429125785828,
1.1882835626602173,
0.7101711630821228,
-0.011894069612026215,
-0.5251254439353943,
0.04551747441291809,
-0.040101874619722366,
-0.3298945128917694,
0.8008608818054199,
0.243160679936409,
-0.1327914446592331,
-0.03657575324177742,
-0.7141674160957336,
-0.7684524655342102,
1.104048252105713,
0.47057652473449707,
-0.7528508305549622,
0.055831603705883026,
-0.010628846473991871,
0.5496701598167419,
-0.49502500891685486,
-0.24498514831066132,
0.5552514791488647,
0.2624537944793701,
0.02514723129570484,
-0.9231089949607849,
-0.22695860266685486,
0.1416182518005371,
0.0955284982919693,
0.1576024293899536,
-0.6048561334609985,
0.6763364672660828,
0.08043717592954636,
-0.38176873326301575,
-0.22534623742103577,
0.31866568326950073,
0.41846707463264465,
0.45298704504966736,
0.5734062790870667,
0.33023276925086975,
0.7124730944633484,
-0.09620599448680878,
0.9377124905586243,
-0.1930255889892578,
0.31008246541023254,
1.1507251262664795,
-0.523015022277832,
0.9653218984603882,
0.31404417753219604,
-0.28873854875564575,
0.3791852593421936,
0.7740484476089478,
-0.0629531592130661,
0.6948564648628235,
0.07128042727708817,
-0.7636928558349609,
-0.46277663111686707,
-0.2983977794647217,
0.3203100562095642,
0.686251699924469,
0.2851113975048065,
-0.3569853901863098,
-0.3884274363517761,
0.2999233305454254,
-0.033550214022397995,
0.28324002027511597,
-0.3186974823474884,
0.8917098641395569,
0.12577301263809204,
-0.24229870736598969,
0.5505563020706177,
0.3728766143321991,
1.106032133102417,
-0.30203503370285034,
-0.13180820643901825,
-0.1414497047662735,
0.3417046070098877,
-0.11297447979450226,
-0.5783985257148743,
0.2517032325267792,
0.47613421082496643,
-0.33413636684417725,
-0.5374162793159485,
0.9377903938293457,
-0.5172505378723145,
-0.5837443470954895,
0.06736093759536743,
0.42651960253715515,
0.11704497039318085,
0.02992246486246586,
-0.5567799210548401,
-0.06949988752603531,
-0.24819396436214447,
0.00016842337208800018,
0.5124075412750244,
0.5240379571914673,
-0.12744495272636414,
0.38338515162467957,
0.5284830331802368,
0.13106998801231384,
-0.25040653347969055,
-0.36491551995277405,
0.6741596460342407,
-0.6026541590690613,
-0.3272189199924469,
-1.1533206701278687,
0.043194178491830826,
-0.20386148989200592,
-0.10001610964536667,
0.5476562976837158,
0.6010286211967468,
1.1109287738800049,
0.11504946649074554,
0.8408514261245728,
0.11013086885213852,
0.5671405792236328,
-0.4332616627216339,
0.577452540397644,
-0.5090771317481995,
0.45791998505592346,
0.045381058007478714,
-0.8705549836158752,
-0.4470727741718292,
0.7319068312644958,
0.007518180646002293,
-0.13179270923137665,
0.5459392666816711,
0.5510521531105042,
-0.12514619529247284,
-0.3034803569316864,
0.5003209114074707,
-0.09188660234212875,
0.26900458335876465,
0.6525903940200806,
0.6790603995323181,
-0.3659757971763611,
0.546072781085968,
-0.5487320423126221,
-0.36133235692977905,
-0.2026452124118805,
-1.058986783027649,
-0.9947614073753357,
-0.34621331095695496,
-0.2613181173801422,
-0.09544634819030762,
-0.20793528854846954,
1.4002002477645874,
0.8359280228614807,
-0.7502641081809998,
-0.2890721261501312,
0.08510967344045639,
0.16251154243946075,
0.06588093936443329,
-0.2521001696586609,
0.2044220119714737,
-0.6613557934761047,
-0.9817267060279846,
0.6993145942687988,
0.4961291253566742,
0.3177304267883301,
0.07952054589986801,
-0.10289780050516129,
-0.012500506825745106,
0.17997804284095764,
1.0276691913604736,
0.10727028548717499,
-0.5295710563659668,
-0.36176207661628723,
-0.07527218759059906,
-0.1219860166311264,
0.03409769386053085,
0.6902853846549988,
-1.1327183246612549,
0.21099518239498138,
0.4616239070892334,
0.7858006954193115,
0.47149986028671265,
-0.06577213853597641,
0.3096567392349243,
-1.0726091861724854,
0.18040287494659424,
0.3869442641735077,
0.3076017200946808,
0.2889884114265442,
-0.4599447250366211,
0.5717664361000061,
0.37437522411346436,
-0.5105042457580566,
-0.9958885908126831,
-0.06253770738840103,
-0.8112694025039673,
-0.4736190140247345,
1.1005141735076904,
-0.019572068005800247,
-0.10005592554807663,
0.08660893887281418,
-0.18720456957817078,
0.18486784398555756,
-0.5392591953277588,
0.8241877555847168,
0.6157255172729492,
-0.4686804711818695,
-0.14237456023693085,
-0.2678315043449402,
0.6191258430480957,
-0.011965056881308556,
-1.0130393505096436,
-0.13934341073036194,
0.4009997248649597,
0.30841773748397827,
0.04864040017127991,
0.6014940142631531,
-0.045969270169734955,
-0.12320370227098465,
-0.3042026460170746,
-0.30847033858299255,
0.07577837258577347,
-0.41972586512565613,
-0.5345375537872314,
0.30373862385749817,
0.07440613955259323,
-0.04411650821566582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04281v1
|
Similar Data Points Identification with LLM: A Human-in-the-loop Strategy Using Summarization and Hidden State Insights
| 2024-04-03T03:17:28 | 2024-04-03T03:17:28 |
Xianlong Zeng, Fanghao Song, Ang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study introduces a simple yet effective method for identifying similar
data points across non-free text domains, such as tabular and image data, using
Large Language Models (LLMs). Our two-step approach involves data point
summarization and hidden state extraction. Initially, data is condensed via
summarization using an LLM, reducing complexity and highlighting essential
information in sentences. Subsequently, the summarization sentences are fed
through another LLM to extract hidden states, serving as compact, feature-rich
representations. This approach leverages the advanced comprehension and
generative capabilities of LLMs, offering a scalable and efficient strategy for
similarity identification across diverse datasets. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method in identifying similar data points on multiple
datasets. Additionally, our approach enables non-technical domain experts, such
as fraud investigators or marketing operators, to quickly identify similar data
points tailored to specific scenarios, demonstrating its utility in practical
applications. In general, our results open new avenues for leveraging LLMs in
data analysis across various domains.
|
[
-0.29148051142692566,
-0.7579448223114014,
0.693209707736969,
-0.3189334273338318,
-0.33970820903778076,
0.3297940790653229,
-0.16751901805400848,
-0.4214318096637726,
0.387113094329834,
0.6912868022918701,
-0.6494352221488953,
-0.8512080311775208,
-0.3252450227737427,
0.0745580717921257,
-0.6007097959518433,
0.8625670075416565,
-0.05642245337367058,
-0.10921316593885422,
-0.3951401710510254,
-0.22842101752758026,
-0.28518450260162354,
-0.7172335982322693,
-0.3942963182926178,
-0.4120168685913086,
0.635964572429657,
0.5588827133178711,
0.3074145019054413,
0.6291453242301941,
0.5961992740631104,
0.20506000518798828,
0.0694018304347992,
0.3078332245349884,
-0.8307275772094727,
0.08310588449239731,
-0.0904153510928154,
-0.6018312573432922,
-0.2334357500076294,
-0.08539873361587524,
0.612148642539978,
0.7494227290153503,
0.04337421432137489,
0.3579657971858978,
0.35117417573928833,
0.6834385991096497,
-0.4972687065601349,
0.21728378534317017,
-0.7723073363304138,
0.028393780812621117,
-0.37482643127441406,
-0.3889085650444031,
-0.2312595546245575,
-0.7549353837966919,
0.15809917449951172,
-0.6017407774925232,
0.5478694438934326,
0.11343957483768463,
0.9824571013450623,
0.01489521749317646,
-0.3767728805541992,
-0.43762582540512085,
-0.6544426679611206,
0.8177520036697388,
-0.5393948554992676,
0.08711238950490952,
0.029323508962988853,
0.3760175108909607,
-0.1390027403831482,
-0.4369913935661316,
-0.8169625997543335,
0.027874447405338287,
-0.24922360479831696,
-0.0804203674197197,
-0.2671887278556824,
-0.28104066848754883,
0.24687615036964417,
0.2992486357688904,
-0.7811533212661743,
0.18632441759109497,
-0.33987289667129517,
-0.2793356478214264,
0.5637476444244385,
0.3987637758255005,
0.04731898009777069,
0.046294569969177246,
-0.3595229983329773,
0.0009788722964003682,
-1.0071371793746948,
-0.0014487056760117412,
0.2680399417877197,
0.4681437015533447,
-0.23786546289920807,
0.685452401638031,
-0.4463544189929962,
0.4970589280128479,
-0.16552813351154327,
-0.3027302026748657,
0.3796118199825287,
-0.16185930371284485,
-0.22087745368480682,
-0.19443379342556,
0.7486854195594788,
0.5407096147537231,
0.4850839674472809,
-0.14698049426078796,
-0.2849612236022949,
-0.18018101155757904,
-0.021603409200906754,
-0.4876447916030884,
-0.19146952033042908,
-0.08047047257423401,
-0.7764102220535278,
-0.27600473165512085,
0.35941579937934875,
-0.9519074559211731,
-0.6858618259429932,
-0.37442028522491455,
0.253759503364563,
-0.09206784516572952,
-0.09441675990819931,
-0.4718671143054962,
-0.08347178250551224,
0.598560631275177,
0.23807869851589203,
-0.7578925490379333,
0.5701115131378174,
1.0458509922027588,
0.9594542384147644,
-0.5794264674186707,
-0.24462881684303284,
-0.23905596137046814,
0.27149009704589844,
-0.4862429201602936,
0.8876999020576477,
-0.7452455163002014,
-0.37152788043022156,
0.008318658918142319,
0.0926368311047554,
0.16270512342453003,
-1.0452224016189575,
0.03244205191731453,
-0.8295475244522095,
-0.17547506093978882,
-0.44168198108673096,
-0.6731038093566895,
-0.3066183626651764,
0.4369093179702759,
-0.925945520401001,
1.1370877027511597,
0.034347839653491974,
-0.816641092300415,
0.5001733303070068,
-0.635504961013794,
-0.237789124250412,
0.09835121780633926,
-0.3992002010345459,
-0.6925815343856812,
0.42333608865737915,
0.18958963453769684,
0.6949477791786194,
-0.2555163502693176,
-0.08523155748844147,
-0.47331809997558594,
-0.3829875588417053,
0.4716852009296417,
-0.25889822840690613,
0.38918641209602356,
0.18765254318714142,
0.23868408799171448,
0.16917447745800018,
-0.8003591895103455,
-0.18814703822135925,
0.33879512548446655,
-0.1671219766139984,
-0.4808063209056854,
-0.11556292325258255,
-0.11602477729320526,
-0.01730876974761486,
0.4014732539653778,
-0.45953065156936646,
0.34330305457115173,
-0.13740992546081543,
0.0644262358546257,
0.6324256658554077,
0.3415156602859497,
0.38152986764907837,
-0.4068375527858734,
0.659514844417572,
0.08614256978034973,
-0.20392856001853943,
-0.25978365540504456,
-0.5692468881607056,
-0.4161718189716339,
-0.2767830193042755,
0.3081613779067993,
0.71511310338974,
-0.6522585153579712,
0.183523491024971,
-0.6400691866874695,
-0.3820708692073822,
-0.37231406569480896,
0.28609925508499146,
0.31490516662597656,
0.8359797596931458,
0.20137906074523926,
-0.24367061257362366,
-0.29579052329063416,
-0.9676916599273682,
-0.5086513757705688,
0.14952974021434784,
-0.3610120117664337,
0.3148193955421448,
0.47943562269210815,
-0.0661737397313118,
1.1807712316513062,
-0.9458299875259399,
-0.24949410557746887,
-0.501982569694519,
0.13376682996749878,
0.4153612554073334,
0.11798453330993652,
0.4831601679325104,
-0.7006503939628601,
-0.6471660733222961,
0.10076549649238586,
-0.9480488300323486,
-0.04186302796006203,
-0.08813682943582535,
0.21205559372901917,
0.020670749247074127,
0.6227484345436096,
-0.2062273770570755,
0.5688273906707764,
0.2696533501148224,
-0.11289811879396439,
0.26118192076683044,
-0.17762266099452972,
0.26956406235694885,
-1.0955816507339478,
0.31012386083602905,
0.08611766248941422,
-0.21043695509433746,
-0.7706317901611328,
-0.11974871158599854,
0.22741787135601044,
-0.42943301796913147,
-0.24599860608577728,
0.5120330452919006,
-0.5596697330474854,
-0.30088961124420166,
-0.3606187403202057,
0.13086958229541779,
-0.1645110845565796,
0.603617250919342,
-0.0035567807499319315,
0.7524154782295227,
0.6002565622329712,
-0.48926714062690735,
0.4160199463367462,
0.19992905855178833,
-0.5850029587745667,
0.6488532423973083,
-0.5340220928192139,
0.20224767923355103,
-0.3219718337059021,
0.14835156500339508,
-0.9702936410903931,
-0.2611033618450165,
0.17663776874542236,
-0.4341486096382141,
0.11982645094394684,
-0.19628797471523285,
-0.5492573380470276,
-0.32950806617736816,
-0.4494589865207672,
0.40936002135276794,
0.4543062448501587,
-0.48775339126586914,
0.48393526673316956,
0.512097179889679,
-0.5622648596763611,
-0.6153794527053833,
-0.5220730304718018,
0.04934828355908394,
-0.6202818751335144,
-0.3409455120563507,
0.26852789521217346,
0.05489936098456383,
-0.24093440175056458,
-0.013619058765470982,
0.02065197378396988,
-0.21613192558288574,
0.18416887521743774,
0.37509700655937195,
0.30828267335891724,
-0.14233651757240295,
0.22127175331115723,
0.016801917925477028,
-0.33922040462493896,
-0.09245780855417252,
-0.10245805978775024,
0.4691126346588135,
0.10560160130262375,
-0.2828124165534973,
-0.6161616444587708,
0.7417922616004944,
0.3325713276863098,
-0.0455952025949955,
0.5715599656105042,
0.328928142786026,
-0.5824823975563049,
-0.23172152042388916,
-0.3641015589237213,
-0.09329979866743088,
-0.46893295645713806,
0.2705841064453125,
-0.7165093421936035,
-0.7284471392631531,
0.7872192859649658,
-0.3229049742221832,
-0.0432400107383728,
0.32414528727531433,
0.5407453179359436,
-0.3298766613006592,
0.5791836977005005,
0.9381197690963745,
-0.45422133803367615,
0.3947906196117401,
-0.2899390161037445,
0.2966148853302002,
-0.5026077032089233,
-0.4137338697910309,
-0.4630364179611206,
-0.4219096899032593,
-0.3762087821960449,
-0.4368264973163605,
0.3262500464916229,
0.1864861398935318,
0.16345864534378052,
0.2050100713968277,
-0.09465043991804123,
0.8485292196273804,
0.5584788918495178,
0.16413044929504395,
0.40129050612449646,
0.16192129254341125,
0.02382098324596882,
0.001982306595891714,
-0.2683052122592926,
-0.5745996832847595,
1.4169063568115234,
0.23401819169521332,
0.96637362241745,
-0.0023939383681863546,
0.8247142434120178,
0.4592747390270233,
0.39386194944381714,
-0.9501773118972778,
0.5677751898765564,
-0.01490713655948639,
-0.154625803232193,
-0.32737743854522705,
-0.49552130699157715,
-1.0062365531921387,
0.013846632093191147,
-0.3165263831615448,
-0.7380821108818054,
0.026925047859549522,
0.09266123175621033,
-0.3463580012321472,
0.2430952787399292,
-0.5951251983642578,
0.5641579031944275,
0.1873713880777359,
0.11223634332418442,
-0.24107202887535095,
-0.51389479637146,
0.09538087993860245,
-0.3366904854774475,
0.13266831636428833,
-0.20570281147956848,
-0.1693933606147766,
0.9632135629653931,
-0.46299678087234497,
0.8126842379570007,
-0.1667407602071762,
-0.21723072230815887,
0.34185150265693665,
-0.03659998998045921,
0.614033043384552,
-0.14169296622276306,
-0.04745645821094513,
0.4069671034812927,
-0.26824572682380676,
-0.3742200434207916,
-0.8815934658050537,
0.9426147937774658,
-0.4395357072353363,
-0.3123495280742645,
-0.09853456169366837,
-0.5453600883483887,
-0.24326542019844055,
0.33960238099098206,
0.061407241970300674,
0.4843696653842926,
-0.18025708198547363,
0.021403158083558083,
0.6010382175445557,
-0.1306910663843155,
0.5139528512954712,
0.6092269420623779,
0.11312607675790787,
-0.3174249827861786,
1.0058833360671997,
-0.1194475069642067,
-0.03222592920064926,
0.7034608125686646,
0.11362890154123306,
-0.48138973116874695,
-0.6395761966705322,
-0.2148292362689972,
0.5018783211708069,
-0.7378154397010803,
-0.3239709138870239,
-0.38970908522605896,
0.0417451448738575,
-0.2294125258922577,
-0.19978977739810944,
-0.12520533800125122,
-0.189982607960701,
-0.4370831549167633,
-0.1452331393957138,
0.3331581652164459,
1.0763710737228394,
0.10309772938489914,
0.2832208573818207,
-0.6924389004707336,
0.6864004731178284,
0.39251789450645447,
0.3976682424545288,
0.043756820261478424,
-0.24355648458003998,
-0.21749626100063324,
-0.08011568337678909,
-0.2616654932498932,
-1.0056028366088867,
0.5281794667243958,
0.2955376207828522,
0.6856843829154968,
0.6330419778823853,
-0.05429937317967415,
0.747157871723175,
-0.37377235293388367,
0.7117043733596802,
0.1687241941690445,
-0.9431577324867249,
0.550774335861206,
-0.14311076700687408,
0.09146934002637863,
0.5555260181427002,
0.7437092661857605,
-0.5146422982215881,
-0.19712643325328827,
-0.33025678992271423,
-0.525486171245575,
0.44211143255233765,
-0.13567452132701874,
-0.07520080357789993,
0.2923404276371002,
0.4382794201374054,
0.3174068331718445,
0.20690341293811798,
-0.7276595234870911,
-0.4759046137332916,
0.2472832053899765,
-0.5809024572372437,
-0.08007825165987015,
-0.14930090308189392,
-0.17427833378314972,
0.07509970664978027,
0.26617488265037537,
-0.3820491135120392,
0.1621018350124359,
0.01577725261449814,
-0.33345893025398254,
0.0896051898598671,
0.3120161294937134,
0.4917306900024414,
0.9049422144889832,
-0.035064488649368286,
0.23209542036056519,
0.2721858322620392,
-0.49913012981414795,
0.059469036757946014,
-0.19097456336021423,
-0.16750280559062958,
0.07354354858398438,
0.5664891004562378,
0.3059960901737213,
0.0576256699860096,
-0.7470002174377441,
0.7396232485771179,
-0.04190552234649658,
-0.17084583640098572,
-0.17674672603607178,
-0.07862439751625061,
-0.12015312910079956,
0.4487365186214447,
0.6180092692375183,
-0.24819105863571167,
0.07692062854766846,
-0.672906219959259,
0.3484095335006714,
0.4977957308292389,
-0.5112819671630859,
-0.38817813992500305,
0.3134576380252838,
0.023054368793964386,
-0.26610276103019714,
0.5504562258720398,
-0.1457522213459015,
-0.3093906044960022,
0.6089051365852356,
0.4412952661514282,
0.7103224396705627,
-0.023235468193888664,
0.11420619487762451,
0.14314545691013336,
-0.031315289437770844,
0.03170720487833023,
0.5860702991485596,
-0.07712644338607788,
-0.7445962429046631,
-0.19822511076927185,
-0.3619304895401001,
-0.2974119782447815,
0.23948630690574646,
-1.0188119411468506,
0.31178075075149536,
-0.29144248366355896,
0.17812082171440125,
0.043228719383478165,
0.08046538382768631,
-0.7816057205200195,
-0.024850593879818916,
0.24603679776191711,
0.6552993059158325,
-1.180283546447754,
0.9705725312232971,
0.40277570486068726,
-0.02942875772714615,
-0.6738021373748779,
0.1583632230758667,
0.3347938060760498,
-0.9618142247200012,
0.41171592473983765,
0.16153091192245483,
-0.01380554772913456,
-0.22866281867027283,
-0.5922966003417969,
-0.7234922647476196,
1.4248968362808228,
0.17971466481685638,
-0.7521094679832458,
0.11872297525405884,
0.26799526810646057,
0.5003075003623962,
-0.5622491836547852,
0.041578736156225204,
0.7928676009178162,
0.10520312935113907,
0.21752050518989563,
-0.7585240006446838,
0.14666509628295898,
-0.12412549555301666,
-0.09544462710618973,
0.37083351612091064,
-0.2817608714103699,
0.7538823485374451,
-0.5296013951301575,
-0.48041364550590515,
-0.0024761317763477564,
0.7008336782455444,
0.2945689558982849,
0.5618606805801392,
0.429798424243927,
0.49095064401626587,
1.1655819416046143,
0.1551443189382553,
0.5783885717391968,
-0.11136461049318314,
0.6227492094039917,
1.1936147212982178,
-0.3344384729862213,
0.9530553817749023,
0.26593923568725586,
-0.11992748081684113,
0.6149153113365173,
0.4352738559246063,
-0.3111637830734253,
0.6906251311302185,
0.41196274757385254,
-0.06789958477020264,
0.01301650982350111,
0.05360998958349228,
-0.20927342772483826,
0.3850991725921631,
0.5343371629714966,
-0.3434378206729889,
-0.3346973657608032,
-0.01910894736647606,
-0.02874087542295456,
0.04336268827319145,
-0.47028258442878723,
1.1398261785507202,
-0.028402205556631088,
-0.14988628029823303,
0.5545278191566467,
-0.23662561178207397,
0.6187672019004822,
-0.49530836939811707,
-0.21478696167469025,
-0.36268091201782227,
-0.15331289172172546,
-0.1591307520866394,
-0.8400487303733826,
0.4191397428512573,
0.25586628913879395,
-0.28880563378334045,
-0.13807344436645508,
0.5716990828514099,
-0.36986303329467773,
-0.4507385194301605,
0.054337240755558014,
0.4291571378707886,
0.405465304851532,
-0.32044973969459534,
-0.5418468713760376,
-0.12373059242963791,
0.07170939445495605,
0.08917563408613205,
0.14664196968078613,
0.4563140571117401,
-0.3231227993965149,
0.8489047288894653,
0.41972479224205017,
0.1759478747844696,
-0.04892551898956299,
0.23437736928462982,
0.9270409345626831,
-1.2489006519317627,
-0.6038336157798767,
-0.8523864150047302,
0.1508399248123169,
-0.2996011972427368,
-0.19160403311252594,
0.7468094825744629,
0.8025999665260315,
0.853931188583374,
-0.131379634141922,
0.8404514193534851,
0.3188830018043518,
1.0213851928710938,
-0.5252182483673096,
0.7086209058761597,
-0.4738253355026245,
0.43894779682159424,
-0.35707661509513855,
-0.9818739891052246,
-0.2837671935558319,
0.10261493176221848,
-0.2334642857313156,
-0.310795396566391,
0.7246233820915222,
1.1763784885406494,
-0.18901658058166504,
-0.18953807651996613,
0.3709852993488312,
0.06981415301561356,
0.24956919252872467,
0.5711787939071655,
0.9690629243850708,
-0.2070522904396057,
0.6437210440635681,
-0.015440826304256916,
-0.4128991365432739,
-0.23282790184020996,
-0.77578204870224,
-0.9716019034385681,
-0.6967524886131287,
-0.31204989552497864,
0.05363941192626953,
-0.3530727028846741,
0.6618163585662842,
0.6469755172729492,
-1.0277721881866455,
-0.14243194460868835,
0.24713034927845,
0.2587220370769501,
-0.21168269217014313,
-0.26268672943115234,
0.4952729344367981,
0.2711538076400757,
-0.5982387065887451,
0.44488176703453064,
0.4543684720993042,
0.19658824801445007,
-0.1273684799671173,
0.21372656524181366,
0.2752547264099121,
0.15230995416641235,
0.420724093914032,
0.3712383806705475,
-0.7825756072998047,
-0.3226628005504608,
-0.13428954780101776,
0.026548633351922035,
0.07812079787254333,
1.3456108570098877,
-0.8297187089920044,
0.23907284438610077,
0.5463892221450806,
0.5170689225196838,
0.47257742285728455,
0.43103936314582825,
0.3959923982620239,
-0.8833731412887573,
0.06259437650442123,
0.11739502847194672,
0.21949109435081482,
0.2312110960483551,
-0.380347341299057,
0.24648010730743408,
0.07137016952037811,
-0.31251251697540283,
-0.6554125547409058,
0.27593347430229187,
-1.2273842096328735,
-0.2798452377319336,
0.9537311792373657,
-0.3693245053291321,
-0.07706218957901001,
-0.40598416328430176,
0.12663842737674713,
-0.028959205374121666,
-0.427097886800766,
0.8809677958488464,
0.2763318121433258,
-0.2928469181060791,
-0.10030323266983032,
-0.1338682472705841,
0.47594621777534485,
-0.20062917470932007,
-1.1202033758163452,
0.09765934944152832,
0.24310214817523956,
0.5887587666511536,
-0.040463484823703766,
0.5443248748779297,
-0.013341630809009075,
-0.3153077960014343,
-0.08336735516786575,
-0.18648748099803925,
0.046806175261735916,
-0.39803048968315125,
-0.5815160274505615,
0.4464605748653412,
-0.21950840950012207,
-0.22429108619689941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02421v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02421v2
|
Revisiting subword tokenization: A case study on affixal negation in large language models
| 2024-04-03T03:14:27 | 2024-04-04T04:52:37 |
Thinh Hung Truong, Yulia Otmakhova, Karin Verspoor, Trevor Cohn, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we measure the impact of affixal negation on modern English
large language models (LLMs). In affixal negation, the negated meaning is
expressed through a negative morpheme, which is potentially challenging for
LLMs as their tokenizers are often not morphologically plausible. We conduct
extensive experiments using LLMs with different subword tokenization methods,
which lead to several insights on the interaction between tokenization
performance and negation sensitivity. Despite some interesting mismatches
between tokenization accuracy and negation detection performance, we show that
models can, on the whole, reliably recognize the meaning of affixal negation.
|
[
-0.5082528591156006,
-1.136448621749878,
0.35155782103538513,
-0.13947151601314545,
-0.39125627279281616,
-0.16892941296100616,
-0.043167196214199066,
-0.6603769659996033,
0.4276616871356964,
0.33454787731170654,
-0.29412713646888733,
-0.36415228247642517,
-0.9280531406402588,
0.3730959892272949,
-0.9321410059928894,
0.6564182043075562,
0.15868215262889862,
0.10655109584331512,
-0.3915731608867645,
-0.2932094633579254,
-0.612304151058197,
-0.9540501832962036,
-0.9325121641159058,
-0.6866877675056458,
0.5366652011871338,
0.07400745898485184,
1.0824552774429321,
0.4815914034843445,
0.3469522297382355,
0.2816062271595001,
-0.47178491950035095,
-0.4776991307735443,
-0.47284388542175293,
0.09517619013786316,
-0.3339790105819702,
-0.7087835073471069,
-0.41729408502578735,
-0.008714132010936737,
0.621161937713623,
0.8390862345695496,
-0.014420855790376663,
-0.1217963919043541,
-0.35932284593582153,
0.34126096963882446,
-0.5981934070587158,
-0.20143525302410126,
-0.9681288003921509,
-0.0044740550220012665,
-0.30615416169166565,
0.28103598952293396,
-0.43458202481269836,
-0.019538868218660355,
-0.11003893613815308,
-0.3089219927787781,
0.2119893729686737,
0.12328636646270752,
0.7643731832504272,
0.09826003760099411,
-0.8651217818260193,
-0.3195756673812866,
-0.4269829988479614,
0.9532895684242249,
-1.1824512481689453,
0.8076475262641907,
0.20222437381744385,
0.061964333057403564,
-0.25715258717536926,
-0.7980345487594604,
-0.8764407634735107,
-0.3884319067001343,
-0.4409688413143158,
-0.327109694480896,
-0.4440311789512634,
0.2613481879234314,
0.20467504858970642,
0.4417596757411957,
-0.15168514847755432,
0.34393468499183655,
-0.17898830771446228,
-0.5224618911743164,
0.5247976779937744,
0.2906915843486786,
0.10743366181850433,
0.023631790652871132,
-0.30760613083839417,
0.33467087149620056,
-0.8734655976295471,
-0.1085246279835701,
0.22127148509025574,
0.2924783527851105,
0.12708283960819244,
0.6359040141105652,
0.029323363676667213,
0.46912097930908203,
0.14839598536491394,
-0.0454496368765831,
0.38296839594841003,
-0.45670056343078613,
-0.19255176186561584,
-0.06083143129944801,
0.23462630808353424,
0.1335609257221222,
0.35082897543907166,
-0.1675482541322708,
-0.5678043961524963,
0.1754603534936905,
0.07541187852621078,
-0.6751285791397095,
0.1730089783668518,
0.04336376115679741,
-0.6717309951782227,
-0.20019370317459106,
-0.15018336474895477,
-0.3550206124782562,
-0.5784224271774292,
-0.38435840606689453,
0.6030598282814026,
-0.4286684989929199,
-0.2932385504245758,
0.21027149260044098,
-0.1235041692852974,
0.5974061489105225,
0.4273797273635864,
-0.6296389698982239,
0.42134717106819153,
0.9809635877609253,
0.6028290390968323,
-0.16796502470970154,
-0.360159695148468,
-0.6558966040611267,
-0.1943940371274948,
-0.4390791058540344,
0.5198548436164856,
-0.9457371234893799,
-0.5550070405006409,
-0.016244912520051003,
0.12070496380329132,
-0.1029624491930008,
-0.483512282371521,
0.32064011693000793,
-0.5678941011428833,
-0.0412772037088871,
0.1657235473394394,
-0.7324575185775757,
-0.2504855990409851,
0.45929381251335144,
-0.43402913212776184,
0.5166164636611938,
-0.19364875555038452,
-0.5069810152053833,
0.31874197721481323,
-0.3255007266998291,
-0.8739461302757263,
-0.04067624360322952,
-0.0477079339325428,
-0.3274253308773041,
0.7173113822937012,
-0.0614943653345108,
0.2725762128829956,
-0.10682965070009232,
0.15539957582950592,
-0.15626110136508942,
-0.475577175617218,
0.33596259355545044,
-0.5761765241622925,
0.47213712334632874,
-0.23585145175457,
-0.26703953742980957,
0.006956286262720823,
-0.5280263423919678,
-0.30077654123306274,
-0.015828121453523636,
-0.19749552011489868,
-0.5737249255180359,
-0.04498028755187988,
0.03148683160543442,
0.106875941157341,
0.1901162564754486,
-0.7684269547462463,
0.10575176030397415,
-0.6330313086509705,
0.583754301071167,
0.744620680809021,
-0.1500478982925415,
0.19742031395435333,
-0.026835625991225243,
0.7077848315238953,
0.0970320850610733,
0.0653899759054184,
-0.24848060309886932,
-0.5373287796974182,
-1.0196384191513062,
-0.14251644909381866,
0.7739015221595764,
0.13601048290729523,
-0.5302311182022095,
-0.07525540888309479,
-0.10077402740716934,
-0.4082528352737427,
-0.23262430727481842,
-0.23125199973583221,
0.44228583574295044,
0.4321528673171997,
0.4275643825531006,
-0.2726794481277466,
-0.46427983045578003,
-1.1580524444580078,
-0.42781779170036316,
-0.2569044828414917,
0.29575371742248535,
0.41671720147132874,
0.9326066970825195,
-0.5744823217391968,
0.5273301005363464,
-0.4637095034122467,
-0.14777939021587372,
-0.18425655364990234,
0.32693225145339966,
0.3203820288181305,
0.29904431104660034,
0.6186262369155884,
-0.8571657538414001,
-0.14661017060279846,
-0.1034005656838417,
0.0615558847784996,
-0.3014008700847626,
0.03630753234028816,
0.14894649386405945,
0.3284606337547302,
1.1276782751083374,
-0.6390581130981445,
0.7670935392379761,
0.529639482498169,
-0.6234056949615479,
0.6925694346427917,
0.08406534045934677,
-0.022822724655270576,
-0.7793587446212769,
0.11653035134077072,
-0.393951416015625,
-0.20152778923511505,
-0.6982043385505676,
0.21520383656024933,
-0.014532876200973988,
0.2476886510848999,
-0.7002806663513184,
0.9603405594825745,
-0.2973056733608246,
0.02983398362994194,
-0.46706146001815796,
-0.05149785801768303,
-0.01896481215953827,
0.0582854263484478,
-0.002458416623994708,
0.6984384655952454,
0.1736489087343216,
-0.6191748976707458,
0.3286483585834503,
0.24680763483047485,
0.14543506503105164,
0.5648514628410339,
-0.6516534686088562,
-0.013520372100174427,
-0.43973615765571594,
0.3119080066680908,
-1.316968560218811,
0.037038687616586685,
-0.11897695809602737,
-0.6078539490699768,
0.323585569858551,
-0.15134935081005096,
-0.3689206838607788,
-0.10465123504400253,
-0.06916552782058716,
0.7317190766334534,
0.3069959878921509,
-0.32852843403816223,
0.6969683766365051,
0.4657357335090637,
0.10457918792963028,
-0.40081483125686646,
-0.8213859796524048,
0.39357659220695496,
-0.23747631907463074,
-0.30130279064178467,
0.41524744033813477,
0.17891736328601837,
-0.46354857087135315,
-0.07646501809358597,
-0.02955777570605278,
0.05369285121560097,
0.4031085669994354,
0.1967504769563675,
-0.027161981910467148,
-0.1965886503458023,
0.48390814661979675,
-0.19886624813079834,
-0.22142302989959717,
-0.0002341423969483003,
0.09776876866817474,
0.824933648109436,
0.11723093688488007,
-0.4953400194644928,
-0.09673341363668442,
0.4089386463165283,
0.8138111233711243,
-0.24032394587993622,
0.9294916391372681,
0.38015952706336975,
-0.7554613947868347,
0.049060843884944916,
-0.6043272614479065,
-0.31141045689582825,
-0.4146658778190613,
0.3249186873435974,
-0.3860584795475006,
-1.0401426553726196,
0.6911221146583557,
0.19340665638446808,
0.1173243597149849,
0.7097023129463196,
0.422132283449173,
0.21019072830677032,
1.1083275079727173,
0.591311514377594,
0.020105862990021706,
0.37548506259918213,
0.11439897119998932,
0.3798878788948059,
-0.6312153935432434,
-0.04234715923666954,
-0.656862199306488,
-0.5384519100189209,
-0.5974253416061401,
-0.1884521096944809,
0.12866203486919403,
-0.04348527267575264,
-0.06356194615364075,
0.3163149952888489,
0.10957275331020355,
0.4199581444263458,
0.21538934111595154,
-0.38489648699760437,
0.24664326012134552,
-0.25773102045059204,
-0.2335609495639801,
-0.13452480733394623,
-0.3999204933643341,
-0.3420788049697876,
0.7455074787139893,
0.4627809226512909,
0.8074047565460205,
0.2705880105495453,
0.5123438239097595,
0.3046107888221741,
0.4215899109840393,
-1.0244027376174927,
0.5985991954803467,
-0.5049694776535034,
-0.6629319787025452,
-0.04304775968194008,
-0.13564248383045197,
-0.9957196116447449,
0.36281853914260864,
-0.42822420597076416,
-0.45475098490715027,
0.29311585426330566,
0.2036336362361908,
-0.2025393396615982,
0.21211549639701843,
-0.7357239723205566,
0.7207342386245728,
-0.1230299323797226,
-0.07787904888391495,
-0.3064796030521393,
-0.2966592609882355,
0.2107231765985489,
-0.22751037776470184,
0.39487504959106445,
0.10470501333475113,
-0.40757307410240173,
0.5861742496490479,
-0.4160894453525543,
0.9527341723442078,
-0.017574140802025795,
-0.30243438482284546,
0.07794079184532166,
0.23707163333892822,
0.5670787692070007,
-0.07090284675359726,
-0.3130165636539459,
0.5124263763427734,
-0.0017472516046836972,
-0.4562329351902008,
-0.49212923645973206,
0.7892739772796631,
-0.30506911873817444,
-0.8468222618103027,
-0.4657966196537018,
-0.34923243522644043,
-0.24244055151939392,
0.3801068365573883,
0.027134181931614876,
0.5409298539161682,
-0.15241305530071259,
0.3901945948600769,
0.370423823595047,
-0.36471015214920044,
0.31647932529449463,
0.6498743295669556,
-0.45612263679504395,
-0.2103738784790039,
0.6014824509620667,
0.4763236343860626,
0.400945782661438,
0.40671300888061523,
0.19908753037452698,
-0.28793537616729736,
-0.9486685991287231,
-0.017352532595396042,
0.25229090452194214,
-0.5893640518188477,
-0.23419296741485596,
-0.612276554107666,
-0.30838441848754883,
-0.5436127185821533,
-0.27042675018310547,
-0.18441736698150635,
-0.6638091206550598,
-0.24353298544883728,
-0.26067253947257996,
0.22170761227607727,
0.9036438465118408,
0.020733414217829704,
0.26523441076278687,
-0.5877826809883118,
0.056884028017520905,
0.3432677686214447,
0.20351706445217133,
0.15023499727249146,
-0.6237218976020813,
-0.11843593418598175,
0.09523540735244751,
0.007871895097196102,
-0.7190054655075073,
0.28667259216308594,
0.19658756256103516,
0.6433871388435364,
0.2295464128255844,
-0.18211844563484192,
0.6916230320930481,
-0.5655271410942078,
1.0016206502914429,
0.14166855812072754,
-1.2153476476669312,
0.2979958653450012,
-0.2005576640367508,
0.4752955138683319,
0.32586240768432617,
0.09429487586021423,
-0.8604288101196289,
-0.3772942125797272,
-0.5798037052154541,
-1.1975536346435547,
0.1575566530227661,
0.0897880271077156,
0.5970209240913391,
-0.4934149980545044,
0.6120327115058899,
0.3810393214225769,
0.4901338815689087,
-0.5564499497413635,
-0.2802123427391052,
0.03738481551408768,
0.11101538687944412,
-0.3291642963886261,
-0.5850948691368103,
0.21312618255615234,
-0.14640338718891144,
0.7483514547348022,
-0.01825610175728798,
0.14067381620407104,
0.035629648715257645,
-0.27801334857940674,
0.12111452221870422,
0.3356260359287262,
0.7008463144302368,
0.5192941427230835,
0.26508891582489014,
0.4907498061656952,
0.5298989415168762,
-0.5228720903396606,
0.04612916707992554,
-0.21254664659500122,
-0.18515214323997498,
0.11879196763038635,
0.9562950730323792,
0.45779359340667725,
0.23021024465560913,
-0.616907000541687,
0.6379778385162354,
-0.04028858616948128,
-0.20924384891986847,
-0.27301856875419617,
-0.07827255874872208,
0.05492844060063362,
-0.03802427276968956,
0.31163671612739563,
-0.14735586941242218,
0.04858817532658577,
-0.61784827709198,
0.34194374084472656,
0.946912407875061,
-0.46643367409706116,
-0.32848161458969116,
0.45634278655052185,
0.23895464837551117,
-0.36022573709487915,
0.4585783779621124,
-0.033808909356594086,
-0.894142210483551,
0.7570880055427551,
0.756334662437439,
0.7199667096138,
-0.1813134104013443,
-0.20071282982826233,
0.18276408314704895,
0.48663049936294556,
0.5248585939407349,
0.0936083272099495,
0.17300744354724884,
-0.8445941209793091,
-0.42253270745277405,
-0.6411734819412231,
-0.3491005599498749,
0.2920895516872406,
-0.306663453578949,
0.26006144285202026,
-0.45368778705596924,
-0.33457842469215393,
0.18753212690353394,
-0.2152288258075714,
-0.4621052145957947,
0.42003998160362244,
0.3909498453140259,
1.1869125366210938,
-0.8204596638679504,
0.5762583613395691,
1.0012235641479492,
-0.017566772177815437,
-0.5516462922096252,
0.1774858981370926,
-0.03607975319027901,
-0.9449592232704163,
0.7529768943786621,
0.29306507110595703,
-0.250396728515625,
-0.007510373834520578,
-0.5614367723464966,
-0.905635416507721,
1.0032767057418823,
0.21514679491519928,
-0.5454527139663696,
0.20285853743553162,
0.24022288620471954,
0.8154452443122864,
-0.38748839497566223,
0.21575824916362762,
0.521633505821228,
0.4300162196159363,
0.16096782684326172,
-1.0523200035095215,
0.0135155925527215,
-0.10279400646686554,
-0.07360920310020447,
0.6232895851135254,
-0.7273985147476196,
1.1591612100601196,
0.0003931414394173771,
-0.3446234166622162,
-0.010830488987267017,
0.5630877017974854,
-0.2424650639295578,
0.2578781843185425,
0.7408634424209595,
0.6545072197914124,
0.3549175262451172,
-0.045996565371751785,
0.9015554189682007,
-0.13758602738380432,
0.15246964991092682,
0.8034917712211609,
-0.20079773664474487,
0.8287919163703918,
0.9492807984352112,
-0.08127597719430923,
0.3338649868965149,
0.33767765760421753,
0.40647241473197937,
0.12182241678237915,
0.43651121854782104,
-0.2032218873500824,
-0.5646040439605713,
-0.4769285321235657,
-0.366495281457901,
0.6281713247299194,
0.4609532356262207,
-0.5206925868988037,
-0.29367008805274963,
0.1508549004793167,
0.22006794810295105,
0.14269722998142242,
-0.7061936259269714,
0.5443437695503235,
0.2315215766429901,
-0.4445553719997406,
0.5929323434829712,
0.27898260951042175,
0.9874842166900635,
-0.49307891726493835,
-0.25028496980667114,
-0.4203350841999054,
0.23507165908813477,
-0.3644943833351135,
-0.6843636631965637,
0.611075758934021,
-0.23868589103221893,
0.04736039787530899,
-0.10719635337591171,
0.8548147082328796,
-0.23967216908931732,
-0.47086283564567566,
0.4261407256126404,
0.39331191778182983,
-0.06796345859766006,
0.265491783618927,
-0.4012131989002228,
0.05821729451417923,
-0.05223776400089264,
-0.1720249056816101,
0.3534260392189026,
0.1498757302761078,
-0.2893453538417816,
0.6934224367141724,
0.6233298182487488,
-0.08018910139799118,
0.0690683126449585,
-0.07865514606237411,
0.7188891172409058,
-0.687575101852417,
-0.3153080344200134,
-0.9490355253219604,
0.2714817225933075,
0.2529885470867157,
-0.34342870116233826,
0.7020745277404785,
0.5390960574150085,
0.9793171286582947,
0.24527573585510254,
0.5552520155906677,
-0.06915667653083801,
0.35865992307662964,
-0.4285634458065033,
0.5087173581123352,
-0.6898854970932007,
0.23079082369804382,
-0.1669601947069168,
-0.5550185441970825,
-0.5229673385620117,
0.5344843864440918,
-0.5822246074676514,
-0.15971197187900543,
0.4399327337741852,
0.8668680787086487,
-0.07777298241853714,
0.010730311274528503,
0.6502060890197754,
0.6908193826675415,
0.2873070240020752,
0.3224666714668274,
0.8896647095680237,
-0.46114012598991394,
0.37035804986953735,
-0.031905002892017365,
0.06518331170082092,
-0.22823219001293182,
-1.012584924697876,
-0.8336363434791565,
-0.5451149940490723,
-0.3536585569381714,
-0.38747575879096985,
0.21964214742183685,
0.7902204990386963,
0.2317294329404831,
-1.0103873014450073,
0.022599710151553154,
-0.11547839641571045,
0.4719271659851074,
0.0326647125184536,
-0.27839991450309753,
0.05314389988780022,
0.046622540801763535,
-0.6993177533149719,
0.21895360946655273,
0.10671313852071762,
0.2316460907459259,
-0.376416951417923,
0.05357782170176506,
-0.5100302696228027,
0.6123359799385071,
0.7490029335021973,
-0.04477747902274132,
-0.6430756449699402,
-0.7090309262275696,
-0.06542082875967026,
-0.10814891755580902,
-0.2902655005455017,
0.7340518236160278,
-0.9633526802062988,
0.05904119461774826,
0.6095715761184692,
0.5063692927360535,
0.16182652115821838,
-0.0520947240293026,
0.6231431365013123,
-0.548904299736023,
0.08538118004798889,
0.18872524797916412,
0.514587938785553,
0.25808826088905334,
-0.19290243089199066,
0.4436740577220917,
0.4431469142436981,
-0.16800890862941742,
-0.9879053831100464,
0.6576663851737976,
-0.17640818655490875,
-0.3065566122531891,
1.3116706609725952,
0.07875239104032516,
-0.10253638029098511,
-0.15715155005455017,
-0.29720833897590637,
-0.19267043471336365,
-0.20072431862354279,
0.3217170834541321,
0.9994605779647827,
-0.1795339584350586,
-0.06496509909629822,
-0.25354117155075073,
0.15461622178554535,
0.606880784034729,
-0.15858131647109985,
0.025671184062957764,
0.6116613149642944,
0.2886051535606384,
0.23591391742229462,
0.4118193984031677,
-0.0859711766242981,
0.23322193324565887,
-0.09978925436735153,
-0.18877477943897247,
-0.1527935117483139,
0.009517843835055828,
-0.5955003499984741,
0.2697458863258362,
0.2223317176103592,
0.007171888370066881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02418v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02418v1
|
Auxiliary task demands mask the capabilities of smaller language models
| 2024-04-03T02:56:52 | 2024-04-03T02:56:52 |
Jennifer Hu, Michael C. Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Developmental psychologists have argued about when cognitive capacities such
as language understanding or theory of mind emerge. These debates often hinge
on the concept of "task demands" -- the auxiliary challenges associated with
performing a particular evaluation -- that may mask the child's underlying
ability. The same issues arise when measuring the capacities of language models
(LMs): performance on a task is a function of the model's underlying
competence, combined with the model's ability to interpret and perform the task
given its available resources. Here, we show that for analogical reasoning,
reflective reasoning, word prediction, and grammaticality judgments, evaluation
methods with greater task demands yield lower performance than evaluations with
reduced demands. This "demand gap" is most pronounced for models with fewer
parameters and less training data. Our results illustrate that LM performance
should not be interpreted as a direct indication of intelligence (or lack
thereof), but as a reflection of capacities seen through the lens of
researchers' design choices.
|
[
-0.6412419080734253,
-0.29745346307754517,
0.7109912037849426,
0.17299199104309082,
0.03637033328413963,
-0.03511642664670944,
-0.360085666179657,
-0.7345742583274841,
0.08925897628068924,
0.4332464337348938,
-0.8367078304290771,
0.2696917653083801,
-0.8235427141189575,
0.055377427488565445,
-0.15675492584705353,
0.5699431896209717,
-0.03913960978388786,
-0.14272667467594147,
-0.8601515293121338,
-0.20598594844341278,
-0.7812235355377197,
-0.14849425852298737,
-0.3930719792842865,
-0.5255541205406189,
0.4164390563964844,
0.5244390368461609,
0.8036200404167175,
0.5955682396888733,
0.4202529489994049,
0.22117692232131958,
0.2040301114320755,
0.11803669482469559,
-0.16107609868049622,
0.15136633813381195,
-0.010980061255395412,
-0.36486518383026123,
-0.42066070437431335,
0.4319109320640564,
0.4822436273097992,
1.0753138065338135,
0.25867438316345215,
0.338981956243515,
0.3422410786151886,
0.7648196220397949,
-0.8261714577674866,
0.4461406171321869,
-0.5279451608657837,
-0.19944125413894653,
0.10090771317481995,
0.124809630215168,
-0.3293437659740448,
0.058285389095544815,
0.2754763960838318,
-0.4805266857147217,
0.21944911777973175,
-0.056759774684906006,
0.8640050292015076,
0.18955180048942566,
-0.18471699953079224,
-0.323879599571228,
-0.8146312832832336,
0.8822720050811768,
-0.33404824137687683,
0.4883776009082794,
0.8966233730316162,
-0.030285784974694252,
0.17145875096321106,
-0.49867022037506104,
-0.5189813375473022,
-0.6068946719169617,
-0.32548394799232483,
0.05683453381061554,
-0.17143166065216064,
0.1779777854681015,
0.6524484753608704,
0.30208179354667664,
-0.40982088446617126,
0.18895824253559113,
-0.8424103260040283,
0.12444768846035004,
0.5536832213401794,
0.20192286372184753,
0.26437845826148987,
-0.07078799605369568,
-0.11161108314990997,
-0.007955863140523434,
-0.7256119251251221,
0.3093321919441223,
0.05527988076210022,
0.340675950050354,
-0.10026884824037552,
0.706390380859375,
-0.34768742322921753,
0.5212396383285522,
0.043787650763988495,
0.10911768674850464,
-0.07887795567512512,
0.08800538629293442,
-0.18470969796180725,
-0.4782087504863739,
0.44201013445854187,
0.20578281581401825,
0.2719168961048126,
-0.06795898824930191,
-0.38693198561668396,
0.3576327860355377,
0.5109463930130005,
-0.5306423306465149,
-0.10297132283449173,
0.0016658930107951164,
-0.38092172145843506,
0.2789614796638489,
-0.056562863290309906,
-0.4827796518802643,
-0.41950011253356934,
-0.4327111840248108,
0.5135971307754517,
-0.3178711235523224,
-0.09356564283370972,
-0.25259658694267273,
-0.1702011525630951,
-0.14774276316165924,
0.13368253409862518,
-1.007375955581665,
0.8836998343467712,
0.5233014225959778,
0.7868273258209229,
-0.1520392745733261,
-0.19751770794391632,
-0.3904542028903961,
-0.2185714691877365,
-0.37975576519966125,
0.7700075507164001,
-0.6758930087089539,
-0.6624652147293091,
-0.18714620172977448,
-0.10863257944583893,
-0.4625808596611023,
-0.5763615369796753,
0.6242104768753052,
-0.39491406083106995,
-0.050352949649095535,
-0.6509182453155518,
-0.4260227680206299,
-0.3485046625137329,
0.036114733666181564,
-0.798418402671814,
1.002167820930481,
0.3584844172000885,
-0.10620301216840744,
0.6803238391876221,
-0.46680504083633423,
-0.5574092268943787,
0.4374252259731293,
-0.43276697397232056,
0.33694976568222046,
0.6017199158668518,
0.12439557164907455,
0.3024704158306122,
-0.5217087268829346,
-0.284511536359787,
-0.25145024061203003,
-0.4733639657497406,
0.45930013060569763,
-0.2980166971683502,
0.45956483483314514,
0.09658606350421906,
-0.30962038040161133,
-0.14307436347007751,
-0.702791690826416,
0.23415692150592804,
0.005814098287373781,
-0.45519599318504333,
-0.44131508469581604,
0.41205498576164246,
-0.4011929929256439,
0.3408986032009125,
0.2459874153137207,
-0.4516581892967224,
-0.2858375012874603,
-0.6294190287590027,
0.37044939398765564,
0.5977557301521301,
-0.4838479459285736,
0.525901198387146,
-0.8687198162078857,
0.7180735468864441,
-0.5436926484107971,
0.06609174609184265,
0.1984427571296692,
-0.5717885494232178,
-1.0643811225891113,
-0.22552290558815002,
0.14912693202495575,
0.2893793284893036,
-0.4019809067249298,
0.14292266964912415,
-0.43610653281211853,
-0.34514114260673523,
-0.5643719434738159,
0.3442918658256531,
0.33810850977897644,
0.27675750851631165,
0.12382853031158447,
-0.4957934021949768,
-0.6238892078399658,
-1.072408676147461,
-0.23076996207237244,
-0.37225744128227234,
0.0012831261847168207,
0.404386043548584,
0.4346036911010742,
0.2168426811695099,
0.6521053314208984,
-0.17932067811489105,
-0.3017209470272064,
-0.485941618680954,
0.06401899456977844,
0.24059751629829407,
0.4968383312225342,
0.5163319110870361,
-0.6188268065452576,
-0.31229129433631897,
-0.11079080402851105,
-0.4260142743587494,
-0.23841308057308197,
-0.09286224842071533,
0.2067517191171646,
0.04187062010169029,
0.3441593647003174,
-1.073245644569397,
0.22860725224018097,
0.47203508019447327,
-0.1999611109495163,
0.5769381523132324,
-0.360076904296875,
-0.06489568203687668,
-0.05143069475889206,
-0.012498793192207813,
0.11077763140201569,
-0.0660509467124939,
-0.7166665196418762,
0.41466838121414185,
0.13421206176280975,
-0.05003916472196579,
-0.10793519765138626,
0.5934972763061523,
-0.7360281348228455,
-0.017911072820425034,
-0.5122637748718262,
0.17529988288879395,
0.3015460968017578,
0.22573402523994446,
-0.1014079675078392,
0.8032847046852112,
0.26942434906959534,
-0.8837160468101501,
0.06935373693704605,
-0.23065219819545746,
-0.49827635288238525,
0.40328744053840637,
-0.6245542168617249,
0.3038204610347748,
0.03801741451025009,
-0.33413630723953247,
-0.9109466075897217,
-0.31364360451698303,
-0.019429581239819527,
-0.285783976316452,
0.2837660312652588,
0.13938835263252258,
-0.4638538062572479,
-0.6814659237861633,
-0.248481884598732,
0.40862876176834106,
0.8830951452255249,
-0.03209717944264412,
0.521074116230011,
0.41922545433044434,
-0.20645292103290558,
-0.32571178674697876,
-0.8570934534072876,
-0.13534381985664368,
-0.015512321144342422,
-0.2999180853366852,
0.56755131483078,
0.10047611594200134,
-0.5136721134185791,
0.31108686327934265,
-0.3047841489315033,
-0.17852260172367096,
0.1989317089319229,
0.39861565828323364,
0.4409499168395996,
-0.34169742465019226,
0.2740436792373657,
-0.08065542578697205,
0.18495483696460724,
0.5168263912200928,
0.11764820665121078,
0.2962179481983185,
0.10743128508329391,
-0.5774570107460022,
0.08365361392498016,
0.4628748297691345,
0.5681098103523254,
-0.029451578855514526,
0.613943338394165,
0.09146790951490402,
-0.5984053015708923,
-0.2795076072216034,
-0.700796365737915,
-0.11799539625644684,
-0.4415409564971924,
0.2949336767196655,
-0.4809187054634094,
-0.725602388381958,
0.2755146622657776,
0.5853243470191956,
-0.07608816772699356,
0.5972675085067749,
0.2846822142601013,
-0.30364662408828735,
1.123116135597229,
0.33944135904312134,
0.45894214510917664,
0.18585088849067688,
-0.1563275158405304,
0.1018248051404953,
-1.1301957368850708,
-0.14145705103874207,
-0.4041973352432251,
-0.36904874444007874,
-0.35986629128456116,
-0.5245020389556885,
0.19048352539539337,
-0.04350482299923897,
-0.13281823694705963,
0.2841447591781616,
-0.4627365469932556,
0.40907207131385803,
0.6460090279579163,
0.16627202928066254,
0.21575631201267242,
-0.21638712286949158,
0.12702003121376038,
-0.3143558204174042,
-0.6641815304756165,
-0.6824585199356079,
0.9513887763023376,
0.19255147874355316,
0.44022002816200256,
0.04098150506615639,
0.10975004732608795,
0.31639668345451355,
0.36088240146636963,
-1.0817489624023438,
0.7842639088630676,
-0.24231204390525818,
-0.9144144058227539,
-0.08165246248245239,
-0.15698552131652832,
-0.8534367680549622,
0.684698760509491,
-0.2964445650577545,
-1.0031282901763916,
0.42650488018989563,
0.038214992731809616,
-0.4270744323730469,
-0.10100986063480377,
-0.9662266373634338,
0.513456404209137,
-0.1228923350572586,
-0.13120923936367035,
-0.6501445174217224,
0.04784858226776123,
0.40523916482925415,
0.15389810502529144,
0.3105519711971283,
-0.377603143453598,
-0.2337552011013031,
0.9262396097183228,
-0.5523338913917542,
0.9087304472923279,
-0.21921223402023315,
0.31652945280075073,
0.5083706974983215,
0.2275455892086029,
0.4586060643196106,
-0.21258392930030823,
-0.08122575283050537,
-0.5050176978111267,
0.10597464442253113,
-0.4826238751411438,
-0.6522488594055176,
0.740908682346344,
-0.4959658682346344,
-1.3596800565719604,
-0.3580836057662964,
-0.7885228991508484,
-0.6244689226150513,
0.09110799431800842,
0.12095163762569427,
0.2958330810070038,
-0.16308829188346863,
0.14108067750930786,
0.37539583444595337,
0.0977146327495575,
0.3815977871417999,
0.11137999594211578,
0.10126204788684845,
0.19736231863498688,
0.831923246383667,
0.7064832448959351,
0.6247342228889465,
-0.15152543783187866,
0.0012976104626432061,
-0.25359266996383667,
-0.6667920351028442,
-0.3236852288246155,
0.13737772405147552,
-0.8794480562210083,
0.10992268472909927,
-0.559421956539154,
-0.21049469709396362,
-0.2874763011932373,
0.02652391977608204,
-0.3001858592033386,
-0.5223239064216614,
-0.29450294375419617,
-0.11447098106145859,
0.1402309089899063,
0.8248676061630249,
0.07164596021175385,
0.0349280945956707,
-0.628212034702301,
0.21246923506259918,
0.5709051489830017,
0.1809917390346527,
0.37810271978378296,
-0.5831444263458252,
-0.40061700344085693,
0.0237625353038311,
-0.6222289204597473,
-0.7087129354476929,
0.09807652235031128,
0.27562403678894043,
0.7543364763259888,
0.22763411700725555,
0.19836780428886414,
0.7977597117424011,
-0.2699873447418213,
0.7237768769264221,
0.12367608398199081,
-1.0580615997314453,
0.3615768849849701,
-0.21475104987621307,
0.26731976866722107,
0.40995121002197266,
0.19567334651947021,
-0.17630723118782043,
-0.3557843565940857,
-0.5787320733070374,
-0.6795082688331604,
0.7864254117012024,
0.27512073516845703,
0.5544107556343079,
0.010424463078379631,
0.06881634145975113,
0.16592895984649658,
0.213142991065979,
-0.7720730900764465,
0.17313925921916962,
0.16086728870868683,
-0.053446121513843536,
0.08964966237545013,
-0.37494945526123047,
-0.06003442034125328,
-0.419680118560791,
0.3407966196537018,
0.17641374468803406,
0.45011308789253235,
0.21136483550071716,
-0.282214879989624,
-0.2641403377056122,
0.28175225853919983,
0.5568575263023376,
0.8067496418952942,
0.03772301971912384,
0.068901427090168,
0.5059747099876404,
-0.325681209564209,
0.03589737415313721,
0.09088537842035294,
0.04067159444093704,
-0.1402166485786438,
0.7851419448852539,
0.8927359580993652,
0.24741049110889435,
-0.8380717039108276,
0.35900789499282837,
0.36379358172416687,
-0.35044029355049133,
-0.39480429887771606,
0.4578093886375427,
0.07280857115983963,
0.2268485128879547,
0.44997456669807434,
0.20425739884376526,
0.05911516770720482,
-0.7730388641357422,
-0.16529449820518494,
0.4242820739746094,
-0.7625585794448853,
-0.4742307662963867,
0.44370412826538086,
-0.06549961119890213,
-0.27011024951934814,
0.35298267006874084,
-0.15204930305480957,
-0.18715104460716248,
0.8890567421913147,
0.4333333373069763,
0.7077971696853638,
0.008316111750900745,
0.14656680822372437,
0.01872585527598858,
0.6899304986000061,
-0.10635500401258469,
0.4472108781337738,
-0.0419444665312767,
-0.7616901993751526,
-0.5616699457168579,
-0.2348622828722,
-0.16434141993522644,
0.4105556607246399,
-0.7379670143127441,
-0.07149544358253479,
-0.6030960083007812,
-0.34750932455062866,
-0.0770280659198761,
-0.10062819719314575,
-1.0274595022201538,
0.4911241829395294,
-0.013033074326813221,
0.8077430129051208,
-0.5987534523010254,
0.5634216666221619,
0.705433189868927,
-0.4045368432998657,
-0.6812928915023804,
-0.04914642870426178,
-0.3177037239074707,
-0.9438369870185852,
1.0256493091583252,
0.2962171137332916,
-0.16245293617248535,
-0.3951507806777954,
0.12632609903812408,
-0.8890246152877808,
0.5599677562713623,
0.5001329183578491,
-0.164413720369339,
-0.2855232357978821,
-0.01806752197444439,
0.666567325592041,
-0.7588126063346863,
0.14063148200511932,
0.4895353317260742,
0.5101402401924133,
-0.3225799798965454,
-0.9322828650474548,
0.3575734496116638,
-0.22864431142807007,
0.11772619187831879,
-0.0716339498758316,
-0.4239088296890259,
0.9780890345573425,
-0.35451623797416687,
-0.681858479976654,
0.15604697167873383,
0.4211008846759796,
0.11854154616594315,
0.13119637966156006,
0.6245439052581787,
0.24237105250358582,
0.4983341693878174,
-0.2492055743932724,
1.2576457262039185,
0.20876866579055786,
-0.08758243918418884,
0.9546973705291748,
-0.18508115410804749,
0.7912077307701111,
0.6086575388908386,
-0.4421905279159546,
0.37757521867752075,
0.6008206605911255,
0.19650232791900635,
0.5547927021980286,
0.2327602356672287,
-0.026322016492486,
-0.3575844466686249,
-0.3015567660331726,
-0.18272894620895386,
0.3808716833591461,
0.7775488495826721,
-0.37046054005622864,
0.2748192250728607,
-0.03766646236181259,
-0.47278645634651184,
0.3664145767688751,
-0.3872182071208954,
0.4733111560344696,
0.42726948857307434,
-0.9433994293212891,
0.7656687498092651,
-0.1577088087797165,
0.1342894434928894,
-0.17036022245883942,
0.050433214753866196,
0.20563872158527374,
-0.03356649726629257,
-0.09454142302274704,
-0.7100769281387329,
0.4691617786884308,
-0.05257939547300339,
-0.3728439211845398,
-0.10545032471418381,
0.6227287650108337,
0.14596977829933167,
-0.644572377204895,
0.6011094450950623,
0.8373708128929138,
-0.1968029886484146,
0.058936432003974915,
-0.4737369120121002,
-0.05253750830888748,
-0.4255504310131073,
-0.2884102463722229,
0.33589205145835876,
0.2799326777458191,
0.0033922933507710695,
0.7342032790184021,
0.272116094827652,
0.47498589754104614,
0.08953841030597687,
0.017749866470694542,
0.7144708633422852,
-0.3621842563152313,
-0.27892211079597473,
-0.8658992052078247,
0.37166449427604675,
-0.11635059118270874,
-0.4890936315059662,
0.4178241789340973,
0.22533650696277618,
0.8164922595024109,
-0.19651153683662415,
0.8523921966552734,
-0.31708022952079773,
0.4019659459590912,
-0.5800116658210754,
0.44635409116744995,
-0.7567226886749268,
0.42528098821640015,
-0.05980479717254639,
-0.6672549843788147,
0.02230699174106121,
0.5670674443244934,
-0.5736504793167114,
0.3963906764984131,
0.8681255578994751,
0.4789915680885315,
-0.23437310755252838,
0.14433668553829193,
0.5394421815872192,
-0.18870317935943604,
-0.119828000664711,
0.79742431640625,
1.0897679328918457,
-0.28838756680488586,
0.3396936357021332,
-0.31411322951316833,
-0.1362200528383255,
-0.11889955401420593,
-0.24098606407642365,
-1.2357689142227173,
-0.7686659097671509,
-0.06355670839548111,
-0.15022829174995422,
-0.10077633708715439,
0.9339689016342163,
0.9073967337608337,
-0.6905686855316162,
-0.4410772919654846,
-0.18136630952358246,
0.05059223622083664,
-0.5581696033477783,
-0.13491685688495636,
0.1356232762336731,
-0.4825975000858307,
-0.732010543346405,
0.5767717361450195,
-0.07324683666229248,
-0.21485015749931335,
-0.3673325777053833,
0.02012810856103897,
-0.06973866373300552,
0.31573957204818726,
0.43468138575553894,
0.3048047125339508,
-1.0223350524902344,
-0.5367653369903564,
-0.012503399513661861,
0.009035116992890835,
0.08594419062137604,
0.8773601055145264,
-0.6621909141540527,
0.30355846881866455,
0.4870263934135437,
0.5862404108047485,
0.4826534390449524,
-0.398813396692276,
0.7313308119773865,
-0.6960468292236328,
0.20958952605724335,
0.2796832025051117,
0.5216800570487976,
0.16546835005283356,
-0.45600777864456177,
0.2566912770271301,
0.2740917503833771,
-0.11326835304498672,
-0.8321366310119629,
0.5671650171279907,
-0.5336531400680542,
-0.33368003368377686,
0.7888173460960388,
-0.15058010816574097,
-0.0076074376702308655,
-0.2066410928964615,
-0.05059928074479103,
0.006649111397564411,
-0.3027878701686859,
0.749984622001648,
1.140556812286377,
-0.3365093469619751,
-0.43283119797706604,
-1.0874556303024292,
0.4618692398071289,
0.7996566891670227,
-0.23621678352355957,
-0.025123530998826027,
0.3700690269470215,
-0.10639682412147522,
0.24089661240577698,
0.5894879102706909,
0.052862249314785004,
0.42214712500572205,
0.17623960971832275,
-0.5667380094528198,
0.12121863663196564,
-0.18327632546424866,
0.09686855971813202,
0.39096760749816895,
0.5873635411262512,
-0.15948395431041718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02935v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02935v1
|
KnowHalu: Hallucination Detection via Multi-Form Knowledge Based Factual Checking
| 2024-04-03T02:52:07 | 2024-04-03T02:52:07 |
Jiawei Zhang, Chejian Xu, Yu Gai, Freddy Lecue, Dawn Song, Bo Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces KnowHalu, a novel approach for detecting hallucinations
in text generated by large language models (LLMs), utilizing step-wise
reasoning, multi-formulation query, multi-form knowledge for factual checking,
and fusion-based detection mechanism. As LLMs are increasingly applied across
various domains, ensuring that their outputs are not hallucinated is critical.
Recognizing the limitations of existing approaches that either rely on the
self-consistency check of LLMs or perform post-hoc fact-checking without
considering the complexity of queries or the form of knowledge, KnowHalu
proposes a two-phase process for hallucination detection. In the first phase,
it identifies non-fabrication hallucinations--responses that, while factually
correct, are irrelevant or non-specific to the query. The second phase,
multi-form based factual checking, contains five key steps: reasoning and query
decomposition, knowledge retrieval, knowledge optimization, judgment
generation, and judgment aggregation. Our extensive evaluations demonstrate
that KnowHalu significantly outperforms SOTA baselines in detecting
hallucinations across diverse tasks, e.g., improving by 15.65% in QA tasks and
5.50% in summarization tasks, highlighting its effectiveness and versatility in
detecting hallucinations in LLM-generated content.
|
[
-0.36578041315078735,
-1.3594372272491455,
0.8778538107872009,
0.4203757643699646,
-0.14112545549869537,
-0.13188977539539337,
-0.25967028737068176,
-0.6658327579498291,
0.46513479948043823,
0.6940373778343201,
-0.635623037815094,
-0.7535590529441833,
-0.457139253616333,
0.3505058288574219,
-0.44452863931655884,
0.7885212302207947,
0.024274053052067757,
0.05802216753363609,
-0.3159475326538086,
-0.11189302057027817,
-0.5924375057220459,
-0.34877413511276245,
-0.4476454257965088,
-0.18571795523166656,
0.33686742186546326,
0.36270806193351746,
0.6134653687477112,
0.045330148190259933,
0.2915724515914917,
0.2946566343307495,
0.05389004573225975,
0.6107895970344543,
-0.5472900867462158,
0.3997143805027008,
0.27716347575187683,
-0.5165291428565979,
-0.3844360411167145,
-0.33666786551475525,
0.5106034874916077,
0.23390349745750427,
-0.25682738423347473,
-0.13927559554576874,
-0.16057410836219788,
0.6041630506515503,
-0.6621448397636414,
0.15938208997249603,
-0.5549300312995911,
0.1873062551021576,
-0.14118346571922302,
-0.39611199498176575,
-0.6727460622787476,
-0.7404961585998535,
-0.2223188728094101,
-0.510966956615448,
0.23971274495124817,
0.20532812178134918,
0.5688210129737854,
0.6460624933242798,
-0.4243444502353668,
-0.4978870153427124,
-0.7079671025276184,
0.5995132327079773,
-0.695566713809967,
0.7867913842201233,
0.6073518395423889,
0.4891130328178406,
-0.30120500922203064,
-0.4845808148384094,
-1.137452483177185,
-0.3145372271537781,
-0.2382233440876007,
0.03196379169821739,
0.05499303713440895,
0.013245775364339352,
0.3774815499782562,
0.39403775334358215,
-0.8991020321846008,
-0.10265029221773148,
-0.2148522287607193,
-0.5877381563186646,
0.47013571858406067,
-0.1802823543548584,
0.5830980539321899,
-0.43713828921318054,
-0.5454135537147522,
0.10932685434818268,
-0.6102167367935181,
-0.40634527802467346,
0.33334115147590637,
-0.11733739823102951,
0.04630577191710472,
0.5837711691856384,
-0.3339991569519043,
0.7496112585067749,
-0.10274124145507812,
-0.5230416059494019,
0.15936073660850525,
-0.3524704873561859,
-0.2377651333808899,
0.49609845876693726,
0.6048442125320435,
0.0788227766752243,
-0.058359306305646896,
-0.2908971309661865,
-0.18301403522491455,
0.263439804315567,
0.30638399720191956,
-0.5768258571624756,
-0.4147343337535858,
0.3485003411769867,
-0.48549285531044006,
-0.28077033162117004,
-0.14099952578544617,
-0.8934856057167053,
-0.8214040398597717,
-0.40580207109451294,
0.7838619351387024,
-0.8178358674049377,
-0.5026217103004456,
0.2500556707382202,
0.18284708261489868,
0.3877301812171936,
0.3967662453651428,
-0.5870226621627808,
0.17538116872310638,
0.488561749458313,
0.6923534870147705,
-0.4712967574596405,
-0.4305560290813446,
-0.7324301600456238,
0.1260814666748047,
-0.32235556840896606,
1.2885956764221191,
-0.27571508288383484,
-0.09401138126850128,
0.03128387778997421,
-0.18532830476760864,
0.08482446521520615,
-0.5946699976921082,
0.6635594367980957,
-0.4749812185764313,
0.29551368951797485,
-0.4343767762184143,
-0.46413081884384155,
-0.6848688721656799,
0.42276278138160706,
-0.8198204040527344,
1.0817729234695435,
-0.03375014662742615,
-0.7955830097198486,
0.5555879473686218,
-0.32063165307044983,
-0.7283087968826294,
0.26137256622314453,
-0.3043537735939026,
-0.43845564126968384,
-0.05531733110547066,
0.26115310192108154,
0.4613740146160126,
0.07020387798547745,
0.6422974467277527,
-0.19181549549102783,
-0.332243949174881,
0.0827716588973999,
-0.1560826450586319,
0.5938297510147095,
0.14721794426441193,
-0.6380077004432678,
0.6020621061325073,
-1.0363774299621582,
-0.25574323534965515,
-0.059138670563697815,
-0.15108589828014374,
-0.2515107989311218,
0.03283173590898514,
-0.01594546064734459,
-0.0517248697578907,
0.14879032969474792,
-0.3938567638397217,
0.06296650320291519,
-0.2207307517528534,
-0.07944907248020172,
0.44781848788261414,
0.12974706292152405,
-0.03965606540441513,
-0.42879176139831543,
0.3323623836040497,
0.15401913225650787,
0.21838386356830597,
-0.033571746200323105,
-0.47141605615615845,
-1.1154654026031494,
-0.23302100598812103,
-0.17979265749454498,
0.6067659854888916,
-0.9799519777297974,
0.7790912389755249,
0.24574309587478638,
-0.5384554862976074,
-0.290115624666214,
0.08893589675426483,
0.13548192381858826,
0.6426262855529785,
0.5644665956497192,
0.3408888578414917,
-0.8304163813591003,
-0.713176965713501,
-0.16099131107330322,
-0.24339717626571655,
0.40808171033859253,
-0.06773250550031662,
0.5937655568122864,
-0.5043016672134399,
0.5467112064361572,
-0.6046127676963806,
-0.8315480351448059,
-0.2853112518787384,
0.2121652066707611,
0.009814145974814892,
0.14651256799697876,
0.21634280681610107,
-0.8403865098953247,
-0.07312692701816559,
-0.05568312108516693,
-1.4842461347579956,
-0.060208987444639206,
-0.3474702835083008,
-0.053996115922927856,
0.6390523314476013,
0.6434630155563354,
-0.6206263899803162,
0.3824492394924164,
0.4752553403377533,
-0.43838587403297424,
0.8556138277053833,
-0.23823533952236176,
0.4340733587741852,
-1.0299499034881592,
-0.010557715781033039,
-0.23979157209396362,
-0.22827944159507751,
-0.5638759732246399,
0.15762072801589966,
-0.04155101627111435,
0.2274172604084015,
-0.17263484001159668,
0.04537304863333702,
-0.41160014271736145,
0.10213727504014969,
-0.3012251555919647,
0.2599661946296692,
-0.15114234387874603,
0.5476027131080627,
0.19024336338043213,
0.5578470826148987,
0.6377950310707092,
-0.7260150909423828,
0.4991452991962433,
0.21178722381591797,
-0.5339616537094116,
0.617444634437561,
-0.3444400131702423,
0.13673634827136993,
-0.1930672824382782,
0.15715675055980682,
-1.1160651445388794,
-0.38458818197250366,
0.41733962297439575,
-0.27267003059387207,
0.11734940111637115,
0.4131450355052948,
-0.7420944571495056,
-0.15190571546554565,
-0.3327891528606415,
0.37815818190574646,
0.12199539691209793,
-0.6596798896789551,
1.060776710510254,
0.3693298101425171,
0.07547508180141449,
-0.5207843780517578,
-0.4795204997062683,
0.10002882778644562,
-0.0587313249707222,
-0.7922428846359253,
0.09906988590955734,
-0.3744637072086334,
-0.23028211295604706,
-0.21599504351615906,
-0.18006446957588196,
-0.045875538140535355,
-0.060418084263801575,
0.285467267036438,
0.1694076806306839,
-0.20974114537239075,
0.13690190017223358,
0.4174625873565674,
0.02108154259622097,
0.21150362491607666,
-0.17607520520687103,
0.6786178350448608,
-0.06919324398040771,
-0.5265090465545654,
-0.6156874299049377,
0.20318163931369781,
0.5230023264884949,
0.055899251252412796,
0.5779932141304016,
0.9445434808731079,
-0.8438932299613953,
-0.44655197858810425,
-1.1554359197616577,
-0.4899551272392273,
-0.3900456726551056,
0.19971215724945068,
-0.5275055170059204,
-0.7553519010543823,
0.5401764512062073,
0.04381518438458443,
-0.244997039437294,
0.4161614179611206,
0.7894237041473389,
0.25213873386383057,
0.7681834101676941,
0.4930461049079895,
0.17793244123458862,
-0.1613093912601471,
-0.07316877692937851,
0.6332250833511353,
-0.4332391619682312,
-0.8569292426109314,
-0.2513783574104309,
-0.027929475530982018,
-0.3719951808452606,
-0.37596452236175537,
0.49854254722595215,
0.03758905827999115,
0.32797396183013916,
0.17542441189289093,
-0.5332777500152588,
0.377328485250473,
0.35291197896003723,
0.2766047418117523,
0.7857736945152283,
-0.14959996938705444,
0.030019856989383698,
-0.12363819032907486,
-0.3701517581939697,
-0.40129247307777405,
0.7599008083343506,
0.012689612805843353,
0.6307670474052429,
0.23342560231685638,
0.7859350442886353,
0.6720925569534302,
0.10907461494207382,
-0.9610956311225891,
0.7536083459854126,
0.49677735567092896,
-0.48851242661476135,
-0.45601844787597656,
-0.2849135398864746,
-0.6631366014480591,
0.22275479137897491,
-0.43273860216140747,
-0.43708521127700806,
-0.0015193052822723985,
-0.03514399752020836,
-0.3451978862285614,
0.4585362374782562,
-0.58660489320755,
0.6131520867347717,
-0.1951521784067154,
-0.10356561839580536,
-0.43887585401535034,
-0.47554582357406616,
0.8982328176498413,
-0.28109613060951233,
0.3563786745071411,
-0.038795508444309235,
0.323297917842865,
0.8183125853538513,
-0.17904146015644073,
0.7538691759109497,
-0.08937963843345642,
-0.4828122854232788,
0.34599658846855164,
0.422270804643631,
0.3668440878391266,
0.34944623708724976,
0.17265623807907104,
0.24389681220054626,
0.08462441712617874,
-0.07027487456798553,
-0.49882185459136963,
0.867786705493927,
-0.5175348520278931,
-0.5846757292747498,
-0.5986678600311279,
-0.5623729228973389,
-0.06591654568910599,
0.4554674029350281,
0.515286386013031,
0.19210973381996155,
-0.27961254119873047,
-0.01571699045598507,
1.0718411207199097,
-0.2984173595905304,
0.018145276233553886,
0.36025470495224,
-0.6812035441398621,
-0.3388950824737549,
1.11587393283844,
-0.07252700626850128,
-0.31766918301582336,
0.41204655170440674,
0.236366406083107,
-0.4474668502807617,
-0.6348592042922974,
-0.3372589647769928,
0.5779510140419006,
-0.8311970233917236,
-0.24906675517559052,
-0.9841849207878113,
-0.18769825994968414,
-0.7950705885887146,
0.2426951378583908,
-0.22996285557746887,
-0.0031329598277807236,
-0.13721783459186554,
-0.090362548828125,
0.30435702204704285,
0.9706423282623291,
-0.0965924859046936,
-0.00464799115434289,
-0.45701903104782104,
1.0086106061935425,
0.4351005256175995,
0.1552404910326004,
-0.05283433198928833,
-0.23385871946811676,
0.1313016265630722,
-0.2661524713039398,
-0.24310992658138275,
-1.0713192224502563,
0.3524073362350464,
-0.05742678791284561,
0.5602607727050781,
0.7844151258468628,
0.2769315838813782,
0.45950794219970703,
-0.12314343452453613,
0.6916906237602234,
0.10657411068677902,
-0.9860305786132812,
0.7833337783813477,
-0.022728927433490753,
-0.12835116684436798,
0.4578514099121094,
0.5952997803688049,
-0.41037818789482117,
-0.5172690153121948,
-0.22519996762275696,
-0.39631643891334534,
0.6066325902938843,
0.26698771119117737,
-0.3038754165172577,
0.08761513233184814,
0.1136094480752945,
0.5042105317115784,
0.10635419189929962,
-0.8441067934036255,
-0.3028597831726074,
-0.1804952770471573,
-0.07237180322408676,
0.2523007392883301,
-0.5401777625083923,
-0.16531328856945038,
-0.25377270579338074,
0.7072498798370361,
-0.10469388216733932,
0.14023549854755402,
0.46122822165489197,
-0.5770769715309143,
-0.08160127699375153,
0.08652251213788986,
0.8593893647193909,
0.8175044655799866,
-0.2936912178993225,
0.4273125231266022,
0.2999597191810608,
-0.5828288197517395,
-0.014346250332891941,
-0.04081746190786362,
-0.21023589372634888,
0.1879900097846985,
0.4582051634788513,
0.7768729329109192,
0.22039681673049927,
-0.652953565120697,
0.4194221496582031,
-0.12550842761993408,
-0.4373541474342346,
-0.5375869274139404,
0.1018885150551796,
-0.12469673901796341,
0.31420668959617615,
0.378220796585083,
0.051454223692417145,
0.4387982487678528,
-0.48757949471473694,
0.3039902448654175,
0.2378794401884079,
-0.2702006697654724,
-0.40329602360725403,
0.7260388731956482,
-0.17872917652130127,
-0.3087143003940582,
0.536213755607605,
-0.4790968596935272,
-0.5957944989204407,
0.1665954440832138,
0.6700422167778015,
0.6919175386428833,
-0.42611733078956604,
0.3716818690299988,
0.30031073093414307,
0.41750937700271606,
-0.1924205720424652,
0.7534087300300598,
-0.1935078203678131,
-0.87434321641922,
-0.3500610589981079,
-0.7334412336349487,
-0.31107354164123535,
0.5173700451850891,
-0.5293483138084412,
0.5186458230018616,
-0.31139522790908813,
-0.025097696110606194,
-0.2066623866558075,
-0.16257640719413757,
-0.33375388383865356,
0.12622477114200592,
0.31825506687164307,
0.5116348266601562,
-0.8743388652801514,
0.7067325115203857,
0.44724804162979126,
-0.3635818064212799,
-0.5076711773872375,
0.1434449404478073,
0.1939723938703537,
-0.7556661367416382,
0.3516077697277069,
0.43107476830482483,
-0.43535566329956055,
-0.02254161797463894,
-0.4344455599784851,
-0.548502504825592,
0.8818801045417786,
0.3108810782432556,
-0.3764048218727112,
-0.1132809966802597,
-0.1567106544971466,
0.3971327245235443,
0.07427652180194855,
-0.1036311462521553,
0.6764001846313477,
0.8390842080116272,
0.18938764929771423,
-0.49650901556015015,
0.40562841296195984,
-0.05085897445678711,
-0.4902544915676117,
0.07371404767036438,
-0.3912474513053894,
0.43077510595321655,
-0.48308202624320984,
-0.3617057502269745,
-0.10871279984712601,
1.1065491437911987,
0.6052293181419373,
0.7587161660194397,
0.5813893675804138,
0.7352476119995117,
1.192546010017395,
0.0773177444934845,
0.7513466477394104,
-0.4244629442691803,
0.07297517359256744,
0.8633397221565247,
-0.4120548665523529,
0.5823141932487488,
0.4815690517425537,
0.07536228001117706,
0.7915908098220825,
0.3159378468990326,
-0.15232494473457336,
0.2549412250518799,
-0.008926929906010628,
-0.3723807632923126,
-0.5066861510276794,
-0.15383121371269226,
-0.5160102248191833,
0.42365509271621704,
0.3942268192768097,
0.2707374691963196,
-0.12836305797100067,
0.3835192918777466,
0.06464041024446487,
0.22561971843242645,
0.20593616366386414,
0.8894087672233582,
-0.019980283454060555,
-0.9416038990020752,
0.7323279976844788,
-0.1882399022579193,
0.7824300527572632,
-0.5096027851104736,
-0.2173783928155899,
-0.26423510909080505,
0.07254257798194885,
-0.47542279958724976,
-0.4943508207798004,
0.4521365463733673,
-0.16791503131389618,
-0.07976464927196503,
0.16347093880176544,
0.9730767607688904,
-0.4900476336479187,
-0.4749338924884796,
0.48169779777526855,
0.5963104367256165,
0.4309893548488617,
-0.4976116120815277,
-0.20636644959449768,
0.26935771107673645,
-0.05526783689856529,
-0.07079703360795975,
-0.09174544364213943,
0.5961780548095703,
-0.03182215243577957,
0.5945060849189758,
0.6885296702384949,
0.17153730988502502,
0.05219579488039017,
0.3859332799911499,
0.5958387851715088,
-0.6257357001304626,
-0.34513652324676514,
-0.8523419499397278,
-0.03864845260977745,
0.003436419880017638,
-0.08520149439573288,
0.9377784132957458,
0.6886210441589355,
0.7246266007423401,
-0.17951887845993042,
0.6732794642448425,
0.024478135630488396,
0.2444772571325302,
-0.8040035963058472,
1.0146559476852417,
-0.5016078352928162,
0.03598707169294357,
-0.10817815363407135,
-1.0451446771621704,
-0.6011245250701904,
0.7439563870429993,
-0.03613822162151337,
-0.030702149495482445,
1.171043872833252,
1.0409342050552368,
0.17044904828071594,
0.30834105610847473,
0.5689898133277893,
0.4684026837348938,
0.1542460322380066,
0.3965280055999756,
1.0452386140823364,
-0.4727119207382202,
0.4592496156692505,
-0.2176273614168167,
-0.18066386878490448,
-0.3625107705593109,
-0.6635439395904541,
-1.0354783535003662,
-0.8020233511924744,
-0.5252751111984253,
-0.5190206170082092,
-0.2655507028102875,
0.5151801109313965,
0.6010463237762451,
-1.1099655628204346,
-0.10989691317081451,
-0.0023195550311356783,
0.5584139227867126,
-0.25688520073890686,
-0.25916141271591187,
0.5339750647544861,
-0.5596145987510681,
-0.4329179525375366,
0.6267611980438232,
0.5415717363357544,
-0.18991661071777344,
-0.550911545753479,
-0.17526771128177643,
-0.3870100677013397,
-0.01399656105786562,
0.9101299047470093,
-0.13961175084114075,
-0.9558121562004089,
-0.14681294560432434,
0.1513511687517166,
-0.06781768053770065,
0.09587382525205612,
0.8315222263336182,
-0.9344933032989502,
0.5693663954734802,
0.7524317502975464,
0.3236854374408722,
0.4466586709022522,
-0.3332805931568146,
0.04258929193019867,
-0.496064692735672,
-0.012450726702809334,
0.07134724408388138,
0.40212392807006836,
0.3422461450099945,
-0.7222092747688293,
0.332658976316452,
0.5600680112838745,
-0.4689827859401703,
-0.9665905237197876,
0.14264823496341705,
-1.334054946899414,
-0.4315448999404907,
1.1479994058609009,
0.33263400197029114,
-0.30650004744529724,
-0.3906361162662506,
-0.4710187315940857,
0.6103365421295166,
-0.153204545378685,
1.3248928785324097,
0.6110090017318726,
-0.19937588274478912,
0.03591535985469818,
-0.39331915974617004,
0.7598569393157959,
0.32055145502090454,
-1.169204831123352,
-0.024305032566189766,
0.590609610080719,
0.03273438662290573,
0.37553295493125916,
0.5796763300895691,
-0.02650177665054798,
0.24008138477802277,
-0.09402302652597427,
0.1441522091627121,
-0.040564652532339096,
-0.6852614283561707,
-0.1022324189543724,
0.40820956230163574,
-0.09198083728551865,
0.07975083589553833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02408v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02408v1
|
CMULAB: An Open-Source Framework for Training and Deployment of Natural Language Processing Models
| 2024-04-03T02:21:46 | 2024-04-03T02:21:46 |
Zaid Sheikh, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Shruti Rijhwani, Lindia Tjuatja, Robbie Jimerson, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effectively using Natural Language Processing (NLP) tools in under-resourced
languages requires a thorough understanding of the language itself, familiarity
with the latest models and training methodologies, and technical expertise to
deploy these models. This could present a significant obstacle for language
community members and linguists to use NLP tools. This paper introduces the CMU
Linguistic Annotation Backend, an open-source framework that simplifies model
deployment and continuous human-in-the-loop fine-tuning of NLP models. CMULAB
enables users to leverage the power of multilingual models to quickly adapt and
extend existing tools for speech recognition, OCR, translation, and syntactic
analysis to new languages, even with limited training data. We describe various
tools and APIs that are currently available and how developers can easily add
new models/functionality to the framework. Code is available at
https://github.com/neulab/cmulab along with a live demo at https://cmulab.dev
|
[
-0.7062185406684875,
-0.7663013339042664,
0.3689507842063904,
0.34178921580314636,
-0.2737506628036499,
0.18243807554244995,
-0.5372387766838074,
-0.4140595495700836,
0.18123093247413635,
0.6652358174324036,
-0.5551872253417969,
-0.7077333331108093,
-0.29487714171409607,
0.0010417777812108397,
-0.32116222381591797,
0.9941348433494568,
0.22986619174480438,
0.21255932748317719,
-0.09279785305261612,
-0.5293976068496704,
-0.5417133569717407,
-0.7746416330337524,
-0.5153871178627014,
-0.2868751883506775,
0.7099384665489197,
0.3719886243343353,
0.8644621968269348,
0.5320842862129211,
0.5491456389427185,
0.2056063562631607,
-0.010075079277157784,
-0.05992912873625755,
-0.017620710656046867,
-0.11790494620800018,
-0.5506030321121216,
-0.5631268620491028,
-0.5265560746192932,
-0.14530576765537262,
0.5712024569511414,
1.0620464086532593,
-0.1633167564868927,
0.5475975871086121,
0.0058516510762274265,
0.4359944462776184,
-0.8074376583099365,
-0.1475628763437271,
-0.5368515253067017,
-0.19077105820178986,
-0.34782877564430237,
-0.12625724077224731,
-0.35428425669670105,
-0.4868989884853363,
-0.05757394805550575,
-0.5945786237716675,
-0.07734036445617676,
-0.1901542693376541,
0.4823912978172302,
0.2749263048171997,
-0.3414943814277649,
-0.1890917271375656,
-0.46972590684890747,
0.803997278213501,
-0.8514087796211243,
0.6079983115196228,
0.4510130286216736,
0.5104143619537354,
-0.31729862093925476,
-0.4565925598144531,
-0.5492774844169617,
-0.26788678765296936,
-0.12999171018600464,
-0.3676054775714874,
0.12532752752304077,
0.05496304854750633,
0.018239883705973625,
0.3303128480911255,
-0.5311360359191895,
0.444950133562088,
-0.1979219615459442,
-0.07774125784635544,
0.32635700702667236,
0.04087795317173004,
0.34142088890075684,
-0.04626839607954025,
-0.09678011387586594,
0.18724294006824493,
-0.41173669695854187,
-0.2649118900299072,
0.5364170074462891,
0.77001953125,
-0.4733807444572449,
0.6465944647789001,
-0.1404515951871872,
0.6799384355545044,
-0.34256717562675476,
0.2429462969303131,
0.3851016163825989,
-0.11620324850082397,
-0.3607665002346039,
-0.14974723756313324,
0.6793799996376038,
0.06693495810031891,
0.05720129981637001,
-0.06685993820428848,
-0.1034742221236229,
0.33950984477996826,
0.30456387996673584,
-0.4671427309513092,
-0.19521263241767883,
0.376941978931427,
-0.3079611659049988,
-0.37172746658325195,
-0.27500271797180176,
-0.8104249238967896,
-0.3293795585632324,
-0.5921210050582886,
0.11378028243780136,
-0.45152491331100464,
-0.5408086776733398,
-0.243444561958313,
-0.05518155172467232,
0.19039300084114075,
0.20446918904781342,
-1.0994718074798584,
0.36967089772224426,
0.8785275816917419,
0.9539593458175659,
0.018424486741423607,
-0.2724286913871765,
-0.7179352045059204,
-0.2784518003463745,
-0.23787812888622284,
0.8329770565032959,
-0.4982997477054596,
-0.21803700923919678,
0.15634313225746155,
0.21785980463027954,
-0.2159595787525177,
-0.3059823215007782,
0.5947957634925842,
-0.3050960898399353,
0.029732653871178627,
-0.10283639281988144,
-0.3175027072429657,
-0.3086118996143341,
0.4446457326412201,
-0.6498405933380127,
0.9693652987480164,
0.30541542172431946,
-0.6576621532440186,
0.09023778140544891,
-1.083883285522461,
-0.3292917311191559,
0.2558318078517914,
-0.09995418041944504,
-0.20316055417060852,
0.14233824610710144,
0.2665903866291046,
0.4482373297214508,
-0.23701204359531403,
0.24875229597091675,
-0.4441298246383667,
-0.14311398565769196,
0.23154978454113007,
-0.1303621232509613,
1.2146409749984741,
0.4801495671272278,
-0.07458615303039551,
0.370254248380661,
-1.0534378290176392,
0.12343009561300278,
-0.07269842177629471,
-0.6911386847496033,
-0.23335088789463043,
-0.12297544628381729,
0.622840404510498,
0.24804790318012238,
0.0018077176064252853,
-0.5840163230895996,
0.22663775086402893,
-0.5910223722457886,
0.4598521292209625,
0.34844639897346497,
-0.31337159872055054,
0.6271880865097046,
0.07391279935836792,
0.7502768039703369,
-0.13270464539527893,
0.18980853259563446,
-0.38214704394340515,
-0.4747384488582611,
-0.701999306678772,
-0.11776912212371826,
0.5476827621459961,
0.6087762117385864,
-0.5732393264770508,
0.4408892095088959,
0.00714894849807024,
-0.849833607673645,
-0.9859587550163269,
0.41267743706703186,
0.29719287157058716,
0.4055314064025879,
0.5514823198318481,
-0.15785574913024902,
-0.7538754940032959,
-0.9128177762031555,
-0.06373949348926544,
-0.01438627764582634,
-0.1645469069480896,
-0.15142275393009186,
0.5208830833435059,
-0.474282830953598,
0.843316376209259,
0.0072031100280582905,
-0.577642023563385,
-0.5334290862083435,
0.041902851313352585,
0.0942263975739479,
0.7230504155158997,
0.6363972425460815,
-0.7558788657188416,
-0.06793247908353806,
0.33101174235343933,
-0.6701127290725708,
-0.34707486629486084,
0.11863935738801956,
-0.1244744211435318,
0.6692582368850708,
0.5651997923851013,
-0.42348796129226685,
0.376640260219574,
1.1645667552947998,
-0.12451119720935822,
0.5316798686981201,
-0.12790653109550476,
-0.17255322635173798,
-1.160831093788147,
0.6371267437934875,
-0.2945827543735504,
-0.29288774728775024,
-0.5153436660766602,
0.4440128803253174,
0.2142380326986313,
-0.24695539474487305,
-0.5431385040283203,
0.5409516096115112,
-0.30679458379745483,
-0.07114236801862717,
-0.3703560531139374,
0.41549983620643616,
-0.06927240639925003,
0.40032902359962463,
0.005061673931777477,
0.30792757868766785,
0.3083564043045044,
-0.602777898311615,
0.30613645911216736,
0.2772001624107361,
-0.1545821577310562,
0.7958765625953674,
-0.3630400598049164,
0.17099444568157196,
0.11794847249984741,
0.019638709723949432,
-0.571991503238678,
-0.26294657588005066,
0.2523941099643707,
-0.4768075942993164,
0.012991133145987988,
-0.6151025891304016,
-0.5185868144035339,
-0.29569894075393677,
-0.01645282842218876,
0.14888833463191986,
0.15245410799980164,
-0.6329699158668518,
0.8769241571426392,
0.6190253496170044,
-0.008600570261478424,
-0.5521037578582764,
-1.0544425249099731,
0.17494599521160126,
-0.005157941952347755,
-0.4657532870769501,
-0.015651682391762733,
-0.18517571687698364,
-0.10836274176836014,
-0.05934280902147293,
0.41032227873802185,
-0.2249487042427063,
0.5163222551345825,
0.44692811369895935,
0.12031291425228119,
-0.5301477909088135,
0.32047006487846375,
0.04282796382904053,
-0.2847706377506256,
-0.012008384801447392,
-0.32798847556114197,
0.6177225112915039,
-0.08580400794744492,
-0.40297731757164,
-0.5191693305969238,
0.29923856258392334,
0.22159668803215027,
-0.6663729548454285,
0.6663067936897278,
0.9655794501304626,
-0.3878205120563507,
-0.19901984930038452,
-0.618818461894989,
0.04312063381075859,
-0.4240376353263855,
0.24359697103500366,
-0.214363232254982,
-0.5181497931480408,
0.4123744070529938,
-0.11725802719593048,
0.4987831711769104,
0.2948085069656372,
0.7047389149665833,
-0.039626121520996094,
0.5811777114868164,
1.151222825050354,
-0.13981257379055023,
0.5159042477607727,
-0.18284370005130768,
-0.09852275997400284,
-0.806878387928009,
-0.11187304556369781,
-0.7487239241600037,
-0.24486501514911652,
-0.4274202883243561,
-0.3555062413215637,
-0.2622065842151642,
-0.03408785164356232,
0.23629170656204224,
0.5726552605628967,
-0.5147049427032471,
0.3987163007259369,
0.7204007506370544,
-0.3055191934108734,
0.15489768981933594,
-0.3381866216659546,
-0.38859668374061584,
0.15330170094966888,
-0.6687365770339966,
-0.7163519263267517,
1.0802369117736816,
0.37743085622787476,
0.5384485721588135,
0.15374214947223663,
0.5845577120780945,
-0.03269749879837036,
0.43168073892593384,
-0.7272719740867615,
0.4071609079837799,
0.04657544568181038,
-0.870341956615448,
-0.04279641807079315,
-0.10027041286230087,
-0.753058671951294,
0.17085324227809906,
-0.5838159322738647,
-0.8091593980789185,
0.24814024567604065,
0.45144709944725037,
-0.4752783477306366,
0.44911372661590576,
-0.8464750647544861,
1.1721051931381226,
-0.2080548107624054,
-0.1856463998556137,
-0.2771100401878357,
-0.6143117547035217,
0.12599259614944458,
-0.20462742447853088,
0.5937462449073792,
-0.3012716770172119,
0.06981918215751648,
0.4657897353172302,
-0.506011962890625,
0.8103111386299133,
-0.41106387972831726,
-0.062354832887649536,
0.231881245970726,
0.13918669521808624,
0.09611700475215912,
0.012326939962804317,
-0.23869848251342773,
0.40834054350852966,
0.2379607856273651,
-0.311527281999588,
-0.3848375976085663,
0.7094266414642334,
-0.390578955411911,
-0.09784632921218872,
-0.20135000348091125,
-0.5422728657722473,
0.0780576765537262,
0.21598473191261292,
-0.04040875658392906,
0.37011852860450745,
-0.42826855182647705,
0.1937146782875061,
0.09681053459644318,
-0.5128158926963806,
0.5379696488380432,
0.2977486252784729,
-0.6529022455215454,
-0.5032210946083069,
0.47527968883514404,
0.008366734720766544,
0.28705137968063354,
0.3180878460407257,
0.024485915899276733,
-0.014813516288995743,
-0.7354512214660645,
-0.5242259502410889,
0.03887617588043213,
-0.7471963167190552,
-0.15866884589195251,
-0.7630648016929626,
-0.020207110792398453,
-0.409208208322525,
-0.31880295276641846,
-0.5935372114181519,
-0.5852087140083313,
-0.2011898010969162,
-0.03294645622372627,
0.2882288694381714,
0.5293213725090027,
-0.18864068388938904,
0.7966091632843018,
-0.5609217882156372,
0.2247900515794754,
-0.21387839317321777,
0.4568180441856384,
-0.32650405168533325,
-0.34300655126571655,
-0.6722683310508728,
0.21531209349632263,
-0.37089529633522034,
-0.47969987988471985,
0.4258141815662384,
0.07915560901165009,
0.46263203024864197,
0.06896401941776276,
-0.04573855921626091,
0.4793221056461334,
-0.28790125250816345,
0.6488801836967468,
-0.007258289493620396,
-0.8372712135314941,
0.6836995482444763,
-0.43597784638404846,
0.6633272767066956,
0.6913672685623169,
0.34356802701950073,
-0.5916845798492432,
-0.49766576290130615,
-0.24141748249530792,
-0.7668623328208923,
0.5808793306350708,
0.07878174632787704,
0.14558733999729156,
0.0030571683309972286,
0.023918980732560158,
0.11016365885734558,
0.14124034345149994,
-0.5545229911804199,
0.08639797568321228,
-0.22791053354740143,
-0.4021202623844147,
-0.2776767909526825,
-0.12039422243833542,
-0.0144623052328825,
-0.11134844273328781,
0.770775556564331,
-0.48526912927627563,
-0.006152032874524593,
0.09777762740850449,
-0.6202054023742676,
-0.09771762788295746,
0.4751534163951874,
0.36407148838043213,
0.7039918303489685,
-0.49182623624801636,
-0.061896517872810364,
0.24015063047409058,
-0.4281439781188965,
-0.22338052093982697,
0.35068488121032715,
0.028786983340978622,
0.2070077657699585,
0.12118859589099884,
0.48685386776924133,
0.5665265321731567,
-0.7243497967720032,
0.3878563642501831,
-0.11883392184972763,
-0.13373537361621857,
-0.6483834385871887,
-0.05428402125835419,
0.520279049873352,
0.27921798825263977,
0.15276595950126648,
0.22468124330043793,
-0.03775307163596153,
-0.47166645526885986,
-0.060000624507665634,
0.33080148696899414,
-0.3673798739910126,
-0.413982629776001,
0.7548349499702454,
0.3047221601009369,
-0.6367534399032593,
0.5260812044143677,
-0.00300044659525156,
-0.3339560925960541,
0.24339745938777924,
0.3060545325279236,
0.7248255014419556,
-0.2641304135322571,
0.15061232447624207,
0.3592943847179413,
0.5014107823371887,
0.21796220541000366,
0.3856131136417389,
0.0005937475361861289,
-0.5018312335014343,
-0.41213274002075195,
-0.87189781665802,
-0.6178305745124817,
0.0032951037865132093,
-0.5896479487419128,
0.794904351234436,
-0.8091033101081848,
-0.5344231724739075,
0.5180507302284241,
-0.19611172378063202,
-0.7762340903282166,
0.03813261538743973,
0.359759122133255,
1.0530576705932617,
-0.470435231924057,
1.1817686557769775,
0.756209671497345,
-0.47812333703041077,
-0.4435933530330658,
-0.6329805254936218,
0.3373091518878937,
-0.32668352127075195,
0.4573740065097809,
0.32249394059181213,
0.056680526584386826,
0.0869693011045456,
-0.35075971484184265,
-0.5664427876472473,
0.7700066566467285,
0.6832197904586792,
-0.6138558387756348,
-0.004382159095257521,
0.20248042047023773,
0.5665619969367981,
-0.41949862241744995,
0.15818439424037933,
0.5031536221504211,
0.3953847885131836,
-0.39419203996658325,
-1.178322672843933,
-0.15568849444389343,
-0.09009014815092087,
-0.16953487694263458,
0.25458279252052307,
-0.1416703313589096,
0.6465139389038086,
-0.3930639922618866,
-0.13408716022968292,
0.3061002790927887,
0.4060133993625641,
0.06758701801300049,
0.25582951307296753,
0.35184985399246216,
0.5153610110282898,
0.6716113090515137,
-0.06435240060091019,
0.8826622366905212,
-0.14666356146335602,
0.15089046955108643,
1.5443984270095825,
-0.03909336403012276,
1.2507312297821045,
0.6098411083221436,
0.16365990042686462,
0.621023416519165,
0.19677430391311646,
-0.21762442588806152,
0.054738178849220276,
0.001842510886490345,
-0.03553644195199013,
-0.09050117433071136,
-0.22328777611255646,
-0.13874290883541107,
0.4318409860134125,
0.44455474615097046,
-0.4893819987773895,
-0.26435035467147827,
0.31594762206077576,
0.10909330099821091,
0.4080432057380676,
-0.20871911942958832,
0.6956659555435181,
0.3151547610759735,
-0.40408873558044434,
0.7261101603507996,
0.1646110713481903,
0.720360279083252,
-0.6682717204093933,
0.13585442304611206,
-0.034400422126054764,
0.409148633480072,
-0.5020348429679871,
-0.5211138129234314,
0.6968426704406738,
-0.013099795207381248,
0.090671107172966,
0.05969654396176338,
0.48982295393943787,
-0.2986767292022705,
-0.44972920417785645,
0.640008270740509,
0.332191526889801,
0.13867342472076416,
-0.2595776319503784,
-0.635985255241394,
0.3055418133735657,
-0.2012551724910736,
-0.0998278260231018,
0.18286782503128052,
0.22202889621257782,
-0.02796306647360325,
0.8056733012199402,
1.010803461074829,
0.12442543357610703,
0.24283640086650848,
0.32094550132751465,
0.8008140325546265,
-0.6765782237052917,
-0.4607464373111725,
-0.9528637528419495,
0.7399387955665588,
0.0581846609711647,
-0.3027673065662384,
0.6145088076591492,
0.5523861050605774,
1.0009698867797852,
0.00442578736692667,
0.7290289998054504,
-0.20516279339790344,
0.5639335513114929,
-0.31426289677619934,
0.9567705988883972,
-0.3108581602573395,
0.15507856011390686,
-0.38319987058639526,
-0.927778959274292,
-0.729619026184082,
0.4231385588645935,
-0.2181364744901657,
-0.3361104130744934,
0.5676775574684143,
0.7764968276023865,
-0.2779052257537842,
0.11770324409008026,
0.3944198191165924,
0.08635888993740082,
0.3562087416648865,
0.22854505479335785,
0.5831154584884644,
-0.3016569912433624,
0.5624170899391174,
-0.4890177547931671,
-0.07320769876241684,
-0.37842419743537903,
-0.9401921629905701,
-1.2100245952606201,
-0.4976269006729126,
-0.22786982357501984,
-0.04311124607920647,
0.13105401396751404,
1.4109463691711426,
0.982146680355072,
-0.8974544405937195,
-0.39587464928627014,
-0.026872655376791954,
-0.033843833953142166,
-0.09707897156476974,
-0.1995498389005661,
-0.006241511087864637,
-0.6399773359298706,
-0.5320231318473816,
0.5329734086990356,
0.10905736684799194,
0.08529451489448547,
-0.43072476983070374,
0.12007414549589157,
-0.827713668346405,
-0.18066643178462982,
0.6012758612632751,
0.4924968481063843,
-0.6446437835693359,
-0.01281803660094738,
-0.41335031390190125,
0.07360105216503143,
0.05257948860526085,
0.6451516151428223,
-0.9212494492530823,
0.3569593131542206,
0.18050368130207062,
0.8441588878631592,
0.042666610330343246,
-0.2417253851890564,
0.7760187983512878,
-0.7895902991294861,
0.6247602105140686,
0.10419515520334244,
0.41976726055145264,
0.707374632358551,
-0.11354535818099976,
0.6523208022117615,
0.06441010534763336,
-0.48686933517456055,
-1.112284541130066,
0.038336705416440964,
-0.9994086027145386,
-0.16289202868938446,
0.8861746788024902,
-0.12574656307697296,
-0.41786807775497437,
-0.3327528238296509,
-0.40655049681663513,
0.34306809306144714,
-0.29542940855026245,
0.32402336597442627,
0.3987358510494232,
0.5665281414985657,
-0.1285807341337204,
-0.9737822413444519,
0.2872813045978546,
0.09064871817827225,
-0.8350889682769775,
0.4695671498775482,
0.302857369184494,
0.4731535017490387,
0.36058172583580017,
0.4717523753643036,
-0.06452913582324982,
0.2641447186470032,
-0.06581120938062668,
0.49167731404304504,
-0.2315617799758911,
-0.09690937399864197,
-0.6534268856048584,
0.06370840221643448,
0.17823654413223267,
-0.14126838743686676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02406v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02406v1
|
Exploring Backdoor Vulnerabilities of Chat Models
| 2024-04-03T02:16:53 | 2024-04-03T02:16:53 |
Yunzhuo Hao, Wenkai Yang, Yankai Lin
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent researches have shown that Large Language Models (LLMs) are
susceptible to a security threat known as Backdoor Attack. The backdoored model
will behave well in normal cases but exhibit malicious behaviours on inputs
inserted with a specific backdoor trigger. Current backdoor studies on LLMs
predominantly focus on instruction-tuned LLMs, while neglecting another
realistic scenario where LLMs are fine-tuned on multi-turn conversational data
to be chat models. Chat models are extensively adopted across various
real-world scenarios, thus the security of chat models deserves increasing
attention. Unfortunately, we point out that the flexible multi-turn interaction
format instead increases the flexibility of trigger designs and amplifies the
vulnerability of chat models to backdoor attacks. In this work, we reveal and
achieve a novel backdoor attacking method on chat models by distributing
multiple trigger scenarios across user inputs in different rounds, and making
the backdoor be triggered only when all trigger scenarios have appeared in the
historical conversations. Experimental results demonstrate that our method can
achieve high attack success rates (e.g., over 90% ASR on Vicuna-7B) while
successfully maintaining the normal capabilities of chat models on providing
helpful responses to benign user requests. Also, the backdoor can not be easily
removed by the downstream re-alignment, highlighting the importance of
continued research and attention to the security concerns of chat models.
Warning: This paper may contain toxic content.
|
[
-0.036578960716724396,
-0.9482805132865906,
0.4044409990310669,
0.19460171461105347,
-0.08274800330400467,
-0.043633487075567245,
-0.09684403985738754,
-0.37192705273628235,
-0.06846338510513306,
0.8460463881492615,
-0.7879658341407776,
-0.6997153759002686,
-0.5464780926704407,
-0.30366623401641846,
-0.5958335995674133,
0.7671979069709778,
0.38239243626594543,
-0.14605054259300232,
0.21324948966503143,
-0.18574029207229614,
-0.6940324902534485,
-0.898980438709259,
-0.41326332092285156,
-0.020007280632853508,
0.7041732668876648,
0.19931215047836304,
0.8341560363769531,
-0.02322390303015709,
0.45716050267219543,
0.3303695321083069,
0.02637048438191414,
-0.2337574064731598,
-0.7943618893623352,
0.49101191759109497,
0.0022423076443374157,
-0.5995619297027588,
-0.5685372948646545,
-0.10761135816574097,
0.5086014270782471,
0.06718625128269196,
-0.30982691049575806,
0.13461068272590637,
0.0019980662036687136,
0.35128557682037354,
-0.7724032998085022,
-0.17547471821308136,
-1.0157324075698853,
-0.11442706733942032,
-0.24687334895133972,
-0.15835021436214447,
-0.8054001927375793,
-0.11911378055810928,
-0.3526619076728821,
-0.05597490817308426,
-0.06599895656108856,
-0.09221914410591125,
0.5622149705886841,
-0.07650000602006912,
-0.29397428035736084,
-0.24789288640022278,
-0.6815100312232971,
0.5166985988616943,
-1.044427752494812,
0.5910976529121399,
0.03281569480895996,
0.6542934775352478,
-0.5963836312294006,
-0.34327375888824463,
-0.7445465922355652,
-0.3090446889400482,
-0.12832142412662506,
-0.1537659615278244,
-0.3427388370037079,
-0.20149919390678406,
0.1474669873714447,
0.13548344373703003,
-0.595772922039032,
0.481000155210495,
-0.2213364690542221,
-0.18900667130947113,
0.7309527397155762,
0.43582674860954285,
0.4030894637107849,
-0.07056590914726257,
-0.36110296845436096,
-0.21054938435554504,
-0.8952383995056152,
0.11034586280584335,
0.757061243057251,
0.6567157506942749,
-0.35419732332229614,
0.7014147043228149,
-0.015351812355220318,
0.5118715763092041,
-0.0467219278216362,
-0.032648712396621704,
0.02968786284327507,
-0.24529261887073517,
0.013754172250628471,
-0.24465903639793396,
1.0683789253234863,
0.2775198221206665,
-0.0642537772655487,
0.06185232102870941,
-0.1834164410829544,
-0.1846400499343872,
0.45416373014450073,
-0.7865433692932129,
0.08243508636951447,
0.541972279548645,
-0.3929884433746338,
-0.6368365287780762,
-0.1555725783109665,
-0.9818125367164612,
-0.39398065209388733,
0.6868604421615601,
0.5284359455108643,
-0.4161360561847687,
-0.28850799798965454,
-0.031244978308677673,
0.12591692805290222,
0.5930742621421814,
0.23844359815120697,
-0.8428136110305786,
0.18003642559051514,
0.868962824344635,
0.8305968046188354,
0.04033239185810089,
-0.2942190170288086,
-0.5916827321052551,
0.26756051182746887,
-0.1453913003206253,
0.5642415285110474,
-0.6853232979774475,
-0.5831271409988403,
0.13349583745002747,
-0.1503869593143463,
0.030334001407027245,
-0.1309308409690857,
0.09791829437017441,
-0.8853286504745483,
0.40759921073913574,
0.2846718728542328,
-0.27267131209373474,
-0.22662204504013062,
0.6147077679634094,
-0.59792560338974,
0.7618734836578369,
-0.43607375025749207,
-0.6781999468803406,
-0.13281604647636414,
-0.5214347243309021,
-0.4179511070251465,
-0.19237081706523895,
-0.2592374384403229,
-0.6355600357055664,
0.08122772723436356,
0.2377404123544693,
0.4533899426460266,
0.05143504962325096,
-0.057935930788517,
-0.6884247064590454,
-0.11018571257591248,
0.7385706305503845,
-0.7584654688835144,
0.7766638398170471,
-0.03457450866699219,
-0.13807964324951172,
0.40527066588401794,
-0.6362891793251038,
-0.1153777688741684,
0.1731143742799759,
-0.11525758355855942,
-0.22327448427677155,
-0.1660253405570984,
-0.1914113312959671,
0.3489864766597748,
0.14167222380638123,
-0.656591534614563,
0.46183785796165466,
-0.5424558520317078,
0.10797379910945892,
0.6484659910202026,
0.1824420988559723,
0.21946321427822113,
-0.28384697437286377,
0.5490880012512207,
0.05449064075946808,
0.42079395055770874,
-0.40963584184646606,
-0.7221782803535461,
-0.24252578616142273,
-0.38087108731269836,
0.14399825036525726,
0.6639224290847778,
-0.49029526114463806,
0.3735203444957733,
0.1447388082742691,
-0.7879324555397034,
-0.39867690205574036,
-0.08219294995069504,
0.5147411823272705,
0.1450430154800415,
-0.00009450676589040086,
-0.23969343304634094,
-0.10903039574623108,
-0.7083788514137268,
-0.4705196022987366,
-0.12805920839309692,
-0.2987755537033081,
0.4268306791782379,
0.4247334599494934,
-0.4013035297393799,
0.7100620865821838,
-0.656267523765564,
-0.18973404169082642,
-0.11652044951915741,
-0.10172496736049652,
0.12411761283874512,
0.5080066919326782,
0.5849615931510925,
-0.614277720451355,
-0.2025630623102188,
-0.2096019983291626,
-0.5354303121566772,
0.02106521837413311,
-0.23033897578716278,
-0.24245263636112213,
0.22624439001083374,
0.38982468843460083,
-0.6340399980545044,
0.8864617347717285,
0.8879588842391968,
-0.24972866475582123,
0.46729356050491333,
-0.009509453549981117,
0.035266708582639694,
-1.1251397132873535,
-0.19376713037490845,
-0.22996556758880615,
-0.07078356295824051,
-0.8541409373283386,
0.2618965804576874,
0.20386096835136414,
-0.526866614818573,
-0.674091100692749,
0.6093908548355103,
-0.30758875608444214,
-0.10270242393016815,
-0.1756187379360199,
-0.0539524145424366,
-0.24876928329467773,
0.7548568844795227,
-0.30903783440589905,
0.40965861082077026,
0.4191637635231018,
-0.34791648387908936,
0.5321377515792847,
0.3552776277065277,
0.17776180803775787,
0.24678325653076172,
-0.5760628581047058,
0.5782541036605835,
0.2832316756248474,
0.550931453704834,
-1.3549935817718506,
-0.10661900788545609,
0.6772989630699158,
-0.8010551929473877,
0.48069512844085693,
-0.19446110725402832,
-0.38182175159454346,
0.03433782979846001,
-0.5312976837158203,
0.19240844249725342,
0.21060509979724884,
-0.4715428650379181,
1.0437430143356323,
0.2866901159286499,
-0.12703092396259308,
-0.437676340341568,
-0.4830353558063507,
0.18504299223423004,
-0.37830767035484314,
-1.0144460201263428,
0.022737855091691017,
-0.05684184283018112,
-0.06327603757381439,
-0.4715927541255951,
-0.038812726736068726,
-0.012685324065387249,
0.21965272724628448,
0.5004872679710388,
0.23323865234851837,
-0.20476984977722168,
-0.17209012806415558,
-0.1077725812792778,
-0.019561031833291054,
-0.038441482931375504,
0.05949554219841957,
0.8004418015480042,
0.009277216158807278,
-0.7287304997444153,
-0.6640975475311279,
0.7787967324256897,
0.7197854518890381,
-0.18547536432743073,
1.0980911254882812,
0.3180640637874603,
-0.34882017970085144,
-0.026823632419109344,
-0.7127703428268433,
-0.6128480434417725,
-0.553679347038269,
0.42469093203544617,
-0.5672246217727661,
-0.7725407481193542,
0.8528404235839844,
0.26048049330711365,
0.5773226618766785,
0.04821110516786575,
0.8878039717674255,
0.10456421971321106,
1.073086142539978,
0.7417542934417725,
0.005005622282624245,
0.510596513748169,
0.06664437800645828,
0.28949645161628723,
-0.6396040916442871,
-0.3438899517059326,
-0.5304738283157349,
-0.14990374445915222,
-0.7601022720336914,
-0.10341325402259827,
0.2146887481212616,
-0.23146285116672516,
0.09357341378927231,
0.30103135108947754,
0.004031687043607235,
0.14119338989257812,
0.2676844596862793,
0.2855737805366516,
0.41910335421562195,
-0.42265668511390686,
-0.02651369571685791,
0.20060701668262482,
-0.6947035193443298,
-0.46596696972846985,
1.1263641119003296,
0.6668797135353088,
1.2218502759933472,
0.6329291462898254,
0.7502762079238892,
-0.03612712025642395,
0.35107922554016113,
-0.5647088885307312,
0.5445562601089478,
0.14070278406143188,
-0.8519341945648193,
-0.5027547478675842,
-0.26663172245025635,
-0.9406560063362122,
0.4291222393512726,
-0.31405940651893616,
-0.9607300162315369,
0.09643499553203583,
0.1351015716791153,
-0.592373251914978,
0.38134121894836426,
-0.810265064239502,
0.8350881934165955,
-0.28517669439315796,
-0.24230040609836578,
-0.16463175415992737,
-0.7768279314041138,
0.6408930420875549,
-0.20319417119026184,
0.39410120248794556,
-0.13088999688625336,
0.16414710879325867,
0.3722611367702484,
-0.4528869390487671,
1.2540289163589478,
-0.002861184999346733,
-0.47530636191368103,
-0.1763310730457306,
0.4541245996952057,
0.636350154876709,
0.3438046872615814,
0.1581725776195526,
0.44373565912246704,
-0.13873718678951263,
-0.34886860847473145,
-0.7753363847732544,
0.5920423865318298,
-0.5946676731109619,
-1.1147496700286865,
-0.38066408038139343,
-0.5298296213150024,
-0.3284982740879059,
0.07290474325418472,
0.20390020310878754,
0.4423842430114746,
0.011278976686298847,
0.1677129566669464,
0.33879145979881287,
-0.6093322038650513,
0.3590888977050781,
0.7181395888328552,
-0.2867790162563324,
-0.058590587228536606,
0.5299996137619019,
-0.25800612568855286,
0.6433764696121216,
0.2574833035469055,
0.26984795928001404,
-0.011520911008119583,
-0.4943409860134125,
-0.2912004590034485,
0.1453147679567337,
-0.44000449776649475,
-0.32612472772598267,
-0.6661148071289062,
-0.46191227436065674,
-0.6678431034088135,
0.014256613329052925,
-0.7035222053527832,
-0.14154547452926636,
-0.03996001556515694,
0.12627167999744415,
0.4984945058822632,
0.43673956394195557,
-0.0018850305350497365,
0.55766761302948,
-1.1377828121185303,
0.33158519864082336,
0.5014950633049011,
0.38079795241355896,
0.10583300143480301,
-0.5662279725074768,
0.04942711070179939,
0.10071934759616852,
-0.33811864256858826,
-1.2668342590332031,
0.5494428277015686,
-0.0535971000790596,
0.6214932799339294,
0.27058330178260803,
0.0925174206495285,
0.35299837589263916,
-0.6699249744415283,
0.6526226997375488,
0.1516091376543045,
-0.5952854752540588,
0.4548770487308502,
-0.4442122280597687,
0.22303557395935059,
0.1870533972978592,
0.276710569858551,
-0.6645894050598145,
-0.7597541213035583,
-0.6734625697135925,
-0.8657692670822144,
0.52961266040802,
0.2912302613258362,
0.5046061277389526,
0.3946562111377716,
0.10192795097827911,
0.31984448432922363,
0.17987459897994995,
-0.5497883558273315,
-0.21328243613243103,
-0.1500057429075241,
0.028889713808894157,
0.27596515417099,
-0.34721681475639343,
-0.14323265850543976,
0.29084986448287964,
0.5473292469978333,
0.22533933818340302,
0.11385942250490189,
-0.2777644395828247,
-0.11651024967432022,
0.10078783333301544,
0.5216753482818604,
0.7023215293884277,
0.3186117112636566,
-0.1574748307466507,
-0.1556316614151001,
0.27628007531166077,
-0.5777202844619751,
-0.051990147680044174,
-0.058981236070394516,
0.08519279211759567,
-0.21392840147018433,
0.3626651465892792,
0.5612777471542358,
0.43497416377067566,
-0.3503955006599426,
0.5690980553627014,
-0.46926090121269226,
0.20188064873218536,
-0.31834137439727783,
0.06477821618318558,
0.06017831340432167,
0.533301830291748,
0.4413648843765259,
-0.16065797209739685,
-0.18939544260501862,
-0.8361640572547913,
0.24363437294960022,
0.587989330291748,
-0.2595292031764984,
-0.4203340709209442,
0.24554939568042755,
0.3970196843147278,
-0.8171274662017822,
0.6114142537117004,
0.2559988796710968,
-0.886306643486023,
0.1348903775215149,
0.5599668025970459,
0.8399431705474854,
-0.503604531288147,
-0.30575692653656006,
-0.08802115172147751,
0.37908124923706055,
0.3385339081287384,
0.11774874478578568,
0.16126041114330292,
-1.0198132991790771,
-0.08278294652700424,
-0.3262331783771515,
-0.6578254699707031,
0.30451029539108276,
-0.47524112462997437,
0.4330708980560303,
-0.46026474237442017,
-0.09800072014331818,
-0.06444137543439865,
-0.4463488757610321,
-0.3162616491317749,
-0.2714514136314392,
0.3305951952934265,
0.7206956744194031,
-0.8523857593536377,
0.7330954074859619,
0.09542223066091537,
-0.12945418059825897,
-0.7510594129562378,
0.16172224283218384,
0.39277929067611694,
-0.8272384405136108,
0.45424923300743103,
0.07090125977993011,
-0.20704227685928345,
-0.2680380940437317,
-0.6216810345649719,
-0.6437113285064697,
0.5893250703811646,
0.11327055096626282,
-0.6273881196975708,
-0.19759199023246765,
-0.1076284795999527,
0.2736929953098297,
-0.3126956820487976,
0.11063582450151443,
0.4309064745903015,
0.20511645078659058,
0.43958616256713867,
-0.9421358108520508,
0.1268385946750641,
-0.3200056254863739,
-0.1356918215751648,
0.14153596758842468,
-0.7789102792739868,
0.7701016664505005,
-0.17582054436206818,
-0.21688556671142578,
-0.00695750443264842,
0.7221810817718506,
0.8184136748313904,
0.30027464032173157,
0.42588403820991516,
0.24908143281936646,
0.2994553744792938,
0.1528509557247162,
0.7458958625793457,
-0.12780693173408508,
0.10913683474063873,
1.1730424165725708,
-0.5059837102890015,
1.0102488994598389,
0.4503193795681,
0.03313026204705238,
0.4094407260417938,
0.36039477586746216,
-0.026741748675704002,
0.3657108247280121,
0.22459201514720917,
-0.07664713263511658,
-0.03613336384296417,
0.5351623296737671,
-0.4672591984272003,
0.7848673462867737,
0.6185254454612732,
0.07201467454433441,
-0.13786423206329346,
0.2752074599266052,
0.3417448401451111,
0.002471794141456485,
-0.08184857666492462,
0.8109418749809265,
0.07006443291902542,
-0.23566611111164093,
0.2937621474266052,
0.06031760945916176,
0.9758477807044983,
-0.687494695186615,
0.024856416508555412,
-0.22779889404773712,
0.2748780846595764,
-0.1631697714328766,
-0.6917691230773926,
0.3778333067893982,
0.04150547459721565,
0.30041512846946716,
0.03313141688704491,
0.6835484504699707,
-0.29648080468177795,
-0.4512993097305298,
0.25936099886894226,
0.23644396662712097,
-0.02960282936692238,
-0.25134792923927307,
-0.4396481513977051,
0.43835771083831787,
-0.1125994324684143,
-0.5549600124359131,
0.3859143853187561,
0.47501879930496216,
-0.14445218443870544,
0.8087306618690491,
0.8194306492805481,
0.022627050057053566,
0.2071264684200287,
0.06349330395460129,
1.0810678005218506,
-0.7733935117721558,
-0.713172435760498,
-1.1236732006072998,
0.54157555103302,
-0.09578631073236465,
-0.12169677764177322,
1.0583664178848267,
0.40267565846443176,
0.5799999237060547,
0.23889636993408203,
0.4861810803413391,
0.3314541280269623,
0.4338413178920746,
-0.5317187905311584,
1.028052568435669,
-0.21019913256168365,
0.6851245164871216,
-0.3738139569759369,
-0.346293568611145,
-0.374812513589859,
0.0741853192448616,
-0.33781126141548157,
0.11190465837717056,
0.38918831944465637,
1.109113097190857,
0.14749804139137268,
0.1311526745557785,
0.51902174949646,
0.37713101506233215,
0.7206880450248718,
0.47954076528549194,
1.0713794231414795,
-0.28921982645988464,
0.8159646391868591,
-0.046556372195482254,
-0.28348347544670105,
-0.5383758544921875,
-0.7557204961776733,
-1.2448786497116089,
-0.3931608200073242,
-0.12494170665740967,
-0.5416211485862732,
0.2590090036392212,
0.5031499862670898,
0.5237406492233276,
-0.8484224677085876,
-0.21444763243198395,
0.6566047668457031,
0.15875114500522614,
0.019856378436088562,
-0.17587865889072418,
0.08376709371805191,
0.0016372131649404764,
-0.29831311106681824,
0.33919283747673035,
0.3192920684814453,
0.0026775470469146967,
-0.49402061104774475,
0.2855342924594879,
-0.42721113562583923,
0.11947629600763321,
0.3445139527320862,
0.38446566462516785,
-0.6607985496520996,
-0.5364776253700256,
0.043874066323041916,
-0.2734966278076172,
-0.007974805310368538,
0.6965855360031128,
-0.604002833366394,
0.15913912653923035,
0.48224425315856934,
0.452126681804657,
0.621264636516571,
-0.1380525827407837,
0.9709314703941345,
-0.9949544668197632,
0.47888126969337463,
0.2617111802101135,
0.15416602790355682,
0.2245485633611679,
-0.6734176874160767,
-0.069553904235363,
-0.05024559050798416,
-0.17375154793262482,
-0.9365228414535522,
0.43493887782096863,
-0.7976962924003601,
-0.43468981981277466,
1.214453935623169,
-0.07951346039772034,
-0.39008986949920654,
-0.08678212761878967,
-0.1902119368314743,
0.2647981345653534,
-0.5956336259841919,
0.9987121224403381,
0.5403233766555786,
0.02560027502477169,
-0.13157837092876434,
-0.49697205424308777,
0.1958259493112564,
-0.0352044403553009,
-0.6680113077163696,
0.3096064031124115,
0.2913161814212799,
0.281430184841156,
0.1721663922071457,
0.23592768609523773,
-0.3923695683479309,
0.24144873023033142,
0.046598274260759354,
-0.07180427759885788,
-0.11631157994270325,
-0.26890167593955994,
-0.6097214221954346,
0.36364856362342834,
-0.16989780962467194,
-0.366004079580307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02934v1
|
GreedLlama: Performance of Financial Value-Aligned Large Language Models in Moral Reasoning
| 2024-04-03T02:16:37 | 2024-04-03T02:16:37 |
Jeffy Yu, Maximilian Huber, Kevin Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This paper investigates the ethical implications of aligning Large Language
Models (LLMs) with financial optimization, through the case study of
GreedLlama, a model fine-tuned to prioritize economically beneficial outcomes.
By comparing GreedLlama's performance in moral reasoning tasks to a base Llama2
model, our results highlight a concerning trend: GreedLlama demonstrates a
marked preference for profit over ethical considerations, making morally
appropriate decisions at significantly lower rates than the base model in
scenarios of both low and high moral ambiguity. In low ambiguity situations,
GreedLlama's ethical decisions decreased to 54.4%, compared to the base model's
86.9%, while in high ambiguity contexts, the rate was 47.4% against the base
model's 65.1%. These findings emphasize the risks of single-dimensional value
alignment in LLMs, underscoring the need for integrating broader ethical values
into AI development to ensure decisions are not solely driven by financial
incentives. The study calls for a balanced approach to LLM deployment,
advocating for the incorporation of ethical considerations in models intended
for business applications, particularly in light of the absence of regulatory
oversight.
|
[
0.2025519758462906,
-0.42487552762031555,
0.7919178009033203,
0.3276790678501129,
-0.31371501088142395,
-0.054326992481946945,
-0.23341405391693115,
-0.7258598804473877,
0.029934721067547798,
0.8658396601676941,
-0.2874276638031006,
-0.2756800055503845,
-0.6185256838798523,
-0.3462899625301361,
-0.05396623909473419,
0.9813769459724426,
0.22289422154426575,
0.3701372444629669,
-0.35494476556777954,
-0.2813131511211395,
-0.3157675266265869,
-0.44640153646469116,
-1.1617944240570068,
-0.47407835721969604,
0.3628162741661072,
0.28780075907707214,
1.1391663551330566,
0.9838002920150757,
0.6736000180244446,
0.33468300104141235,
-0.18567484617233276,
-0.11336742341518402,
-0.9026354551315308,
0.05780695006251335,
-0.40415704250335693,
-0.3965393006801605,
-0.6683761477470398,
0.3639775514602661,
0.18014344573020935,
0.3446720838546753,
-0.46726521849632263,
0.5648795962333679,
-0.0792553499341011,
0.7500477433204651,
-0.8624312877655029,
-0.09493409097194672,
-0.566856861114502,
-0.15311846137046814,
-0.014571473002433777,
-0.397846519947052,
-0.47484642267227173,
-0.8512528538703918,
0.3295922875404358,
-0.5894027352333069,
-0.7709702253341675,
0.15792697668075562,
0.8548928499221802,
0.749534010887146,
-0.33854949474334717,
-0.6635693311691284,
-0.43800070881843567,
1.391973614692688,
-0.7073463201522827,
0.024051858112215996,
0.44344958662986755,
0.07559563964605331,
0.03773241117596626,
-0.38378527760505676,
-0.3143382668495178,
-0.10158959776163101,
0.2087496668100357,
0.20889155566692352,
-0.22726427018642426,
0.1235233023762703,
0.0672580897808075,
0.37112751603126526,
-0.09352307766675949,
0.7097223997116089,
-0.5147093534469604,
-0.13551774621009827,
0.9189081788063049,
0.39370349049568176,
0.120660200715065,
-0.01626182533800602,
-0.6120164394378662,
-0.23701126873493195,
-0.7798953056335449,
0.4352061152458191,
0.9274476170539856,
0.36836427450180054,
-0.2472086101770401,
0.6354755759239197,
0.4949405789375305,
0.6120200753211975,
-0.1274515986442566,
-0.518551766872406,
0.06978979706764221,
-0.17603808641433716,
-0.5426820516586304,
0.512018620967865,
0.4254530668258667,
0.7743777632713318,
0.5979592800140381,
0.46061375737190247,
-0.0996020957827568,
0.12960129976272583,
0.60232013463974,
-0.6598682403564453,
0.33915868401527405,
0.3858117461204529,
-0.8860482573509216,
-0.8026524186134338,
-0.2186245322227478,
-0.8443194031715393,
-0.6963879466056824,
-0.4037538468837738,
0.21948087215423584,
-0.05743642523884773,
0.07854821532964706,
0.6519008278846741,
0.09627625346183777,
0.5284673571586609,
0.45204687118530273,
-0.8343759179115295,
0.046144649386405945,
0.9025566577911377,
0.48180484771728516,
0.21602270007133484,
-0.04337969049811363,
-0.7057097554206848,
0.38784947991371155,
-0.5576396584510803,
0.36505261063575745,
-0.6150240898132324,
-0.30052146315574646,
-0.06017182022333145,
-0.5523252487182617,
0.10833172500133514,
-0.5841086506843567,
0.8859796524047852,
-0.4796346127986908,
0.015250288881361485,
-0.49631357192993164,
-0.5140437483787537,
-0.577802836894989,
-0.010181338526308537,
-0.5008339881896973,
0.3714291453361511,
-0.009595413692295551,
-0.4874219298362732,
0.5410558581352234,
-0.7675735950469971,
-0.26702532172203064,
0.05768566578626633,
-0.1919749528169632,
-0.42290428280830383,
-0.022249426692724228,
-0.4277939796447754,
0.3166806101799011,
-0.8444949388504028,
0.5400665998458862,
-0.5354313850402832,
-0.4076036214828491,
0.26618093252182007,
-0.45603424310684204,
1.0942939519882202,
0.31080693006515503,
-0.602940022945404,
0.030268214643001556,
-0.4206988215446472,
0.24312497675418854,
0.3330105245113373,
-0.29033783078193665,
-0.6594468355178833,
0.3763061761856079,
0.07105277478694916,
0.2671735882759094,
0.5901510715484619,
-0.035205841064453125,
0.09728165715932846,
-0.44491109251976013,
0.35811564326286316,
1.3332548141479492,
-0.3852877914905548,
0.3394274413585663,
-0.4906617999076843,
0.7122902274131775,
-0.33409383893013,
0.5488678812980652,
0.4468074440956116,
-0.4299241900444031,
-0.8468909859657288,
-0.3089529275894165,
-0.13465379178524017,
0.6676928400993347,
0.44113510847091675,
0.23156028985977173,
0.0233928170055151,
-0.27196741104125977,
-0.7622160315513611,
0.16757382452487946,
0.30445992946624756,
0.44992655515670776,
0.26611000299453735,
0.014694711193442345,
-0.4485412538051605,
-1.3194533586502075,
-0.35734447836875916,
-0.5042862892150879,
0.5512612462043762,
0.6120168566703796,
0.2135043442249298,
-0.3949509263038635,
0.5983313918113708,
-0.34454545378685,
-0.26917925477027893,
-0.008764212019741535,
-0.14357972145080566,
0.46573054790496826,
0.5080294013023376,
0.6870330572128296,
-0.8669933080673218,
-0.07804357260465622,
0.0463540218770504,
-0.5604304671287537,
-0.1991201788187027,
-0.2342911809682846,
-0.2072170376777649,
0.33009886741638184,
0.19971856474876404,
-0.2711774408817291,
0.4307836890220642,
0.6345964670181274,
-0.31350111961364746,
0.2675085663795471,
-0.044494446367025375,
0.1041300818324089,
-1.083896517753601,
0.21789228916168213,
-0.045342594385147095,
0.010416368022561073,
-0.27681317925453186,
0.09914824366569519,
-0.14929091930389404,
0.23590245842933655,
-0.3734532296657562,
0.45732569694519043,
-0.048063501715660095,
-0.4013466238975525,
-0.2693639099597931,
0.30492645502090454,
-0.13487565517425537,
-0.03133255988359451,
-0.208670973777771,
1.1274991035461426,
0.5678131580352783,
-0.5223383903503418,
0.4203762710094452,
0.18653789162635803,
-0.2824806869029999,
0.583149790763855,
-0.7237119674682617,
-0.21314972639083862,
0.09079219400882721,
-0.10240312665700912,
-0.38441455364227295,
0.03454763814806938,
0.13478510081768036,
-0.12403368204832077,
-0.12609827518463135,
-0.023819440975785255,
-0.3376784324645996,
-0.10001339763402939,
-0.45267507433891296,
0.5838012099266052,
0.6706282496452332,
-0.4676133096218109,
0.5650305151939392,
0.6384678483009338,
-0.051758263260126114,
-0.9963279962539673,
-0.5893215537071228,
0.004741176962852478,
-0.8356159329414368,
-0.9786657691001892,
-0.016339944675564766,
0.04741422459483147,
-0.7271390557289124,
-0.13059477508068085,
-0.0534127801656723,
0.3251502513885498,
0.44910717010498047,
0.2153889238834381,
0.44244620203971863,
-0.3231141269207001,
-0.04074522480368614,
-0.0637274906039238,
-0.23256047070026398,
0.2273244708776474,
-0.5264101028442383,
0.4688394367694855,
-0.5016767978668213,
-0.14137552678585052,
-0.2887192964553833,
0.07191994786262512,
0.7356866002082825,
-0.2880454361438751,
0.8067085146903992,
0.02683718502521515,
-0.286479651927948,
-0.02397843822836876,
-0.6945057511329651,
0.3505270183086395,
-0.5938073396682739,
-0.08860062807798386,
0.2389838695526123,
-1.0129808187484741,
0.6225563883781433,
0.05682140216231346,
0.06618855148553848,
0.694146454334259,
0.7239223122596741,
-0.1093912422657013,
0.9304398894309998,
0.8166574835777283,
-0.20363393425941467,
0.06928054988384247,
-0.26726534962654114,
0.6456025242805481,
-0.7097678184509277,
-0.35255345702171326,
-0.47833511233329773,
-0.3681199848651886,
-0.8211232423782349,
-0.44369885325431824,
0.3010726273059845,
0.16981704533100128,
-0.5399392247200012,
0.05929561331868172,
-0.40251973271369934,
0.6321288347244263,
0.4786399304866791,
-0.29422664642333984,
0.3716665804386139,
-0.20076468586921692,
-0.017107099294662476,
0.015499308705329895,
-0.44557127356529236,
-1.0404878854751587,
1.039428472518921,
0.42789673805236816,
1.0066936016082764,
0.4587254524230957,
0.5315437912940979,
0.1274416446685791,
0.18457801640033722,
-0.8973180055618286,
0.5194178223609924,
-0.3340526819229126,
-0.4520680010318756,
-0.25628596544265747,
-0.45290717482566833,
-0.9008089900016785,
-0.05882686749100685,
0.08533427864313126,
-0.9858555197715759,
0.2794530689716339,
0.052488189190626144,
-0.7407370805740356,
0.19281107187271118,
-0.5997605323791504,
0.8652576804161072,
-0.7580995559692383,
-0.629379391670227,
-0.7383695244789124,
-0.533375084400177,
0.49761101603507996,
-0.2503579556941986,
0.06712498515844345,
-0.20857232809066772,
-0.2472267746925354,
0.6332293748855591,
-0.30783846974372864,
0.7651486396789551,
0.18982602655887604,
-0.5653815865516663,
0.2561826705932617,
0.041467953473329544,
0.49724188446998596,
0.2961655557155609,
-0.3426413834095001,
0.07296433299779892,
-0.05233101174235344,
-0.385067343711853,
-0.17763681709766388,
0.9243839979171753,
-0.7077163457870483,
-0.9591857194900513,
-0.7532227635383606,
-0.7092751264572144,
-0.14046646654605865,
0.1560688614845276,
-0.0004961820668540895,
-0.057053569704294205,
-0.01489028800278902,
0.2729129195213318,
0.6303501725196838,
-0.6447170972824097,
0.20902743935585022,
0.3063661456108093,
-0.05868266150355339,
-0.19944578409194946,
0.7287874221801758,
-0.2943435311317444,
0.43741026520729065,
-0.15451239049434662,
0.48151057958602905,
-0.36272284388542175,
-0.29999375343322754,
-0.20279209315776825,
0.3015492856502533,
-0.6664586663246155,
-0.2714638411998749,
-0.34295186400413513,
-0.05563349649310112,
-0.19597221910953522,
-0.8718713521957397,
-0.6290768384933472,
-0.10047131031751633,
-0.5829631090164185,
-0.03338638320565224,
0.37094900012016296,
0.5679285526275635,
-0.06758755445480347,
-0.05149130895733833,
-0.5154315233230591,
-0.12645046412944794,
0.11824051290750504,
0.5263856053352356,
0.05571708828210831,
-0.4517979919910431,
-0.11942796409130096,
0.14069831371307373,
-0.1520024538040161,
-0.3821549713611603,
0.01039794273674488,
-0.21501541137695312,
0.527495801448822,
0.8789716362953186,
-0.11201262474060059,
0.9721489548683167,
-0.06137752905488014,
0.49370336532592773,
0.23599494993686676,
-1.1232094764709473,
0.40876510739326477,
-0.5082613229751587,
-0.049594346433877945,
0.7264841794967651,
0.36449354887008667,
-0.3703133165836334,
-0.28418827056884766,
-0.5431625247001648,
-0.7481244802474976,
0.7763580679893494,
0.11569485068321228,
0.266934871673584,
0.2880293130874634,
0.3319534361362457,
0.060645055025815964,
0.32556048035621643,
-0.7490631341934204,
-0.10987502336502075,
0.10122749954462051,
-0.17094290256500244,
-0.05370739847421646,
-0.43121469020843506,
-0.37663182616233826,
-0.11104696244001389,
0.7481855750083923,
0.0010305364849045873,
-0.20247189700603485,
-0.1733563244342804,
0.1557907611131668,
-0.3406773805618286,
0.07197251170873642,
1.0302435159683228,
0.9874908924102783,
-0.09685570746660233,
-0.15420681238174438,
-0.1005634218454361,
-0.3205472528934479,
0.17015178501605988,
-0.03482304513454437,
-0.018608149141073227,
-0.8664166927337646,
0.24377340078353882,
0.5034630298614502,
0.15285362303256989,
-1.0995454788208008,
0.6508603692054749,
0.22188685834407806,
-0.04627149552106857,
-0.47018617391586304,
0.06871266663074493,
0.23320192098617554,
0.6402180790901184,
0.1492704302072525,
0.03992319479584694,
0.27853623032569885,
-0.6102232933044434,
-0.18008698523044586,
0.6818175911903381,
0.11790572106838226,
0.18529845774173737,
0.855636715888977,
0.17698600888252258,
-0.06659694015979767,
0.7930030226707458,
0.08791086822748184,
-0.5920082926750183,
0.9972586631774902,
0.49186816811561584,
0.8630958795547485,
-0.264712393283844,
0.21488074958324432,
0.1157507598400116,
0.7113890647888184,
-0.17050831019878387,
0.36988401412963867,
0.17485502362251282,
-0.7360635995864868,
-0.46008431911468506,
-0.7359287738800049,
-0.44133955240249634,
0.1861484944820404,
-0.7263420224189758,
0.35704222321510315,
-0.5635619163513184,
-0.16845399141311646,
-0.1794901043176651,
-0.07654955983161926,
-0.17135347425937653,
0.18281525373458862,
0.1209782138466835,
0.5195764899253845,
-0.40315595269203186,
0.44356220960617065,
0.4283924996852875,
-0.2896434962749481,
-0.8337502479553223,
-0.04430437833070755,
0.16220037639141083,
-1.1395537853240967,
0.7469093203544617,
0.21838076412677765,
-0.6816419959068298,
-0.24269041419029236,
-0.5234978199005127,
-1.1453559398651123,
1.0385726690292358,
0.7925605773925781,
-0.32544997334480286,
0.07811243832111359,
0.12702709436416626,
0.4742027819156647,
-0.42217421531677246,
-0.2263583391904831,
0.40694770216941833,
0.8224221467971802,
0.1382727324962616,
-0.8021551966667175,
-0.1282963752746582,
-0.04870949313044548,
0.026560798287391663,
0.5098739862442017,
-1.1394922733306885,
0.7087371945381165,
-0.7127338647842407,
-0.031886763870716095,
0.14637048542499542,
0.18438372015953064,
0.44795531034469604,
0.4407460391521454,
0.4041498303413391,
0.6831066012382507,
0.8177030086517334,
0.07185939699411392,
1.1155967712402344,
-0.31568416953086853,
0.43314167857170105,
0.7370843887329102,
-0.5555378198623657,
0.356757253408432,
0.6841228008270264,
0.054849643260240555,
0.16362401843070984,
0.7248780727386475,
-0.24647247791290283,
0.2715873420238495,
0.41625964641571045,
0.006171226501464844,
-0.4789181649684906,
-0.33911609649658203,
-0.3438454866409302,
0.8385745286941528,
0.33825603127479553,
-0.47981226444244385,
0.10920221358537674,
-0.5016452670097351,
0.3122517764568329,
0.09636102616786957,
-0.4109307825565338,
0.45331019163131714,
0.2581745386123657,
-0.5323652029037476,
0.40659070014953613,
0.30870458483695984,
0.49606090784072876,
-0.5159324407577515,
0.17157922685146332,
-0.0002545806346461177,
0.22054588794708252,
-0.22374357283115387,
-0.5886450409889221,
0.46381810307502747,
0.17653296887874603,
-0.006396039389073849,
-0.4669286608695984,
0.4467374384403229,
-0.0990227684378624,
-0.43202126026153564,
0.6450743675231934,
0.021836435422301292,
-0.015124516561627388,
0.4248218238353729,
-0.7421683669090271,
0.14002563059329987,
-0.04790780693292618,
-0.11887196451425552,
0.14727212488651276,
-0.015181128866970539,
-0.14400875568389893,
0.8637691140174866,
0.671358048915863,
0.014844454824924469,
-0.11269184201955795,
-0.018920866772532463,
0.583524763584137,
-0.7270721197128296,
-0.7116581201553345,
-1.130355715751648,
0.23439517617225647,
-0.02182852290570736,
-0.49542078375816345,
0.6236415505409241,
0.7586721777915955,
0.7500749230384827,
0.258453369140625,
0.3485623598098755,
0.2545500099658966,
-0.20968706905841827,
-0.9387234449386597,
0.9259071946144104,
-0.8797618746757507,
0.45016980171203613,
-0.4742377698421478,
-0.8588133454322815,
-0.04335993155837059,
0.9349703788757324,
-0.4239077866077423,
0.3571969270706177,
0.4960412383079529,
0.4568804204463959,
0.1141248270869255,
0.2181100994348526,
0.36270871758461,
0.20092420279979706,
-0.037216488271951675,
0.6039251089096069,
0.978265106678009,
-0.07213526964187622,
0.25198909640312195,
-0.006597045809030533,
-0.09677308797836304,
-0.4391714334487915,
-1.152064323425293,
-0.48277196288108826,
-0.39301350712776184,
-0.19176997244358063,
-0.2692519426345825,
-0.016185523942112923,
0.8876984715461731,
0.44819262623786926,
-0.4840391278266907,
-0.7103546261787415,
0.16428977251052856,
0.2411927878856659,
-0.1998082399368286,
-0.183553546667099,
0.18473215401172638,
-0.2305104285478592,
-0.6902469396591187,
0.3119714856147766,
0.8565700650215149,
-0.04058052971959114,
-0.21404094994068146,
-0.23865829408168793,
-0.21725721657276154,
0.6770349144935608,
0.4794048070907593,
-0.08488137274980545,
-0.8829836249351501,
-0.2649562954902649,
-0.10133197903633118,
-0.27787724137306213,
-0.02250845357775688,
0.8944472670555115,
-0.21018756926059723,
0.16993744671344757,
0.08840572834014893,
0.8515586256980896,
0.00245055858977139,
0.20587240159511566,
0.7023783922195435,
0.30992361903190613,
0.21094755828380585,
0.5655433535575867,
0.3001834452152252,
0.0015325626591220498,
-0.7924948930740356,
0.49543946981430054,
-0.194832444190979,
-0.7631803750991821,
-0.8263742327690125,
0.327593594789505,
-1.1898736953735352,
-0.07820221036672592,
1.1794544458389282,
0.266122967004776,
-0.07022371888160706,
0.2399469017982483,
-0.07110399007797241,
-0.12211600691080093,
-0.42323872447013855,
0.8271939158439636,
0.747646152973175,
0.08463846892118454,
0.13539022207260132,
-0.5978749990463257,
0.40601930022239685,
0.85550457239151,
-0.7656782865524292,
0.13682931661605835,
0.7182431817054749,
-0.062485016882419586,
0.04904257133603096,
0.47597530484199524,
-0.2624853253364563,
0.5238838791847229,
-0.6100835800170898,
-0.1089954748749733,
0.045271262526512146,
-0.1493423581123352,
-0.45018357038497925,
-0.0515923798084259,
0.16217944025993347,
0.20159421861171722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02403v1
|
Benchmarking Large Language Models for Persian: A Preliminary Study Focusing on ChatGPT
| 2024-04-03T02:12:29 | 2024-04-03T02:12:29 |
Amirhossein Abaskohi, Sara Baruni, Mostafa Masoudi, Nesa Abbasi, Mohammad Hadi Babalou, Ali Edalat, Sepehr Kamahi, Samin Mahdizadeh Sani, Nikoo Naghavian, Danial Namazifard, Pouya Sadeghi, Yadollah Yaghoobzadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper explores the efficacy of large language models (LLMs) for Persian.
While ChatGPT and consequent LLMs have shown remarkable performance in English,
their efficiency for more low-resource languages remains an open question. We
present the first comprehensive benchmarking study of LLMs across diverse
Persian language tasks. Our primary focus is on GPT-3.5-turbo, but we also
include GPT-4 and OpenChat-3.5 to provide a more holistic evaluation. Our
assessment encompasses a diverse set of tasks categorized into classic,
reasoning, and knowledge-based domains. To enable a thorough comparison, we
evaluate LLMs against existing task-specific fine-tuned models. Given the
limited availability of Persian datasets for reasoning tasks, we introduce two
new benchmarks: one based on elementary school math questions and another
derived from the entrance exams for 7th and 10th grades. Our findings reveal
that while LLMs, especially GPT-4, excel in tasks requiring reasoning abilities
and a broad understanding of general knowledge, they often lag behind smaller
pre-trained models fine-tuned specifically for particular tasks. Additionally,
we observe improved performance when test sets are translated to English before
inputting them into GPT-3.5. These results highlight the significant potential
for enhancing LLM performance in the Persian language. This is particularly
noteworthy due to the unique attributes of Persian, including its distinct
alphabet and writing styles.
|
[
-0.24792714416980743,
-0.7965031266212463,
0.7395574450492859,
0.10928048193454742,
-0.19277718663215637,
0.32281044125556946,
-0.7942039966583252,
-0.2667594850063324,
-0.1461154818534851,
0.24635529518127441,
-0.3043515086174011,
-0.3925953209400177,
-0.47104188799858093,
0.07378493249416351,
-0.2548185884952545,
0.7148697376251221,
-0.1997997909784317,
0.272087037563324,
-0.14883220195770264,
0.08250311017036438,
-0.4342525005340576,
-0.674937903881073,
-0.9229661226272583,
-0.3521076738834381,
0.39997798204421997,
0.5687925815582275,
0.7199738621711731,
0.27348148822784424,
0.6221110820770264,
0.2683287560939789,
-0.16757571697235107,
0.0036645582877099514,
-0.5380699634552002,
0.20455975830554962,
-0.3268045485019684,
-0.3697004020214081,
-0.2899254858493805,
0.08277355134487152,
0.922954261302948,
0.6370856761932373,
-0.3158721327781677,
0.26673468947410583,
0.08467862755060196,
0.7038374543190002,
-0.4926697611808777,
0.20916029810905457,
-0.5414096713066101,
-0.092115618288517,
-0.5898237824440002,
0.18240582942962646,
-0.24823930859565735,
-0.4870125353336334,
-0.0753822848200798,
-0.37971609830856323,
-0.2040843516588211,
0.18759094178676605,
0.7630015015602112,
0.14413709938526154,
-0.41266173124313354,
0.04907595366239548,
-0.9496551752090454,
0.8761798143386841,
-0.6748737096786499,
0.45021793246269226,
0.1670897752046585,
0.5900627970695496,
-0.28240343928337097,
-0.6132988929748535,
-0.4888911545276642,
-0.6085944771766663,
0.17572762072086334,
0.16789686679840088,
-0.3998582363128662,
-0.18180663883686066,
0.4515749216079712,
0.6541403532028198,
-0.792292594909668,
0.030484072864055634,
-0.2693210244178772,
0.09686600416898727,
0.484825998544693,
0.18557758629322052,
0.3651881814002991,
0.19435951113700867,
-0.10946854948997498,
-0.18532298505306244,
-0.9084995985031128,
-0.0510263554751873,
0.22047187387943268,
0.2214810699224472,
-0.06553914397954941,
0.679227352142334,
-0.5273639559745789,
0.4161003530025482,
-0.1342851221561432,
-0.0415031760931015,
0.10021816939115524,
-0.4263242483139038,
-0.03394259512424469,
-0.25502943992614746,
0.8352991938591003,
0.04207833483815193,
0.6177560091018677,
-0.08579898625612259,
-0.033772990107536316,
0.07314082980155945,
0.005551764275878668,
-0.7644332051277161,
-0.23727819323539734,
-0.12689152359962463,
-0.14935198426246643,
0.13945037126541138,
-0.3448898494243622,
-0.45090532302856445,
-0.3624119460582733,
-0.25615379214286804,
0.3050163686275482,
-0.5852797627449036,
-0.3416394889354706,
0.26123425364494324,
0.2539824843406677,
0.4209264814853668,
0.50248122215271,
-0.7060813307762146,
0.7335695624351501,
0.7774636745452881,
0.8266698122024536,
-0.4023084342479706,
-0.1837647259235382,
-0.29041701555252075,
-0.03186868876218796,
-0.495822548866272,
0.8788952827453613,
-0.6083455085754395,
-0.16811472177505493,
-0.27220144867897034,
-0.28112927079200745,
-0.3332197964191437,
-0.5189135670661926,
0.8058139085769653,
-0.39849549531936646,
0.30885398387908936,
-0.042463455349206924,
-0.6426266431808472,
-0.29102277755737305,
0.4717724621295929,
-0.4914405643939972,
1.255653977394104,
0.12688694894313812,
-0.680793046951294,
-0.16116321086883545,
-0.48020482063293457,
-0.30217522382736206,
0.18092602491378784,
-0.23384350538253784,
-0.24405282735824585,
0.19039100408554077,
0.17299488186836243,
0.44289737939834595,
-0.8719866871833801,
0.08325058966875076,
-0.13456681370735168,
-0.5153561234474182,
0.17718105018138885,
-0.3875046968460083,
0.377141535282135,
0.258680522441864,
-0.2975150942802429,
-0.003958460409194231,
-0.4301351308822632,
0.4805658459663391,
0.3094855844974518,
-0.220489501953125,
-0.23092256486415863,
0.1680355817079544,
-0.08381490409374237,
0.1648159772157669,
0.31566131114959717,
-0.48840340971946716,
0.01741037517786026,
-0.372460275888443,
0.23726247251033783,
0.5347334742546082,
-0.11993799358606339,
0.06559781730175018,
-0.41719263792037964,
0.704858660697937,
-0.2220342755317688,
-0.06514175981283188,
0.10197372734546661,
-0.42855677008628845,
-0.7362040877342224,
-0.11586540192365646,
0.4333314299583435,
0.647936999797821,
-0.48818910121917725,
-0.055481165647506714,
-0.4039917588233948,
-0.9426648616790771,
0.11634963750839233,
-0.013214212842285633,
0.506885826587677,
0.033717185258865356,
0.13973507285118103,
-0.5121890902519226,
-0.19750802218914032,
-1.094964861869812,
-0.6548581123352051,
-0.18730902671813965,
0.11306130886077881,
0.4287183880805969,
0.498698890209198,
0.2351599931716919,
0.4004212021827698,
-0.37229233980178833,
-0.06901071220636368,
-0.6424108147621155,
-0.21533316373825073,
0.5430604815483093,
0.43540632724761963,
0.34587427973747253,
-0.46312394738197327,
-0.9574005007743835,
0.34773650765419006,
-0.26917675137519836,
-0.122523732483387,
0.11004777252674103,
-0.21849408745765686,
0.007421760354191065,
0.5098102688789368,
-0.6602200865745544,
0.1707383692264557,
0.6783896684646606,
-0.3582676649093628,
0.787921130657196,
0.04334389418363571,
0.27350741624832153,
-1.0388580560684204,
0.014538419432938099,
0.09926863014698029,
-0.31913241744041443,
-0.7412979602813721,
0.07740302383899689,
0.21134978532791138,
-0.13522277772426605,
-0.4649234116077423,
0.6979501247406006,
-0.4961931109428406,
-0.1257733553647995,
-0.11977093666791916,
0.09858261793851852,
-0.372822105884552,
0.5199342966079712,
0.08939199894666672,
1.160848617553711,
0.46082445979118347,
-0.286406010389328,
0.21776866912841797,
0.045906614512205124,
-0.599595844745636,
0.46759265661239624,
-0.694652795791626,
0.05379396677017212,
0.3056025505065918,
0.12273938953876495,
-0.777271032333374,
-0.13634449243545532,
0.13605687022209167,
-0.36678269505500793,
0.17013439536094666,
-0.15650570392608643,
-0.7530245184898376,
-0.2492324858903885,
-0.05704517289996147,
0.3619309663772583,
0.8423682451248169,
-0.2580017149448395,
0.4793197512626648,
0.21046867966651917,
-0.5330528616905212,
-0.06985323131084442,
-0.04416044056415558,
0.093304343521595,
-0.34720537066459656,
-0.5102985501289368,
0.09316049516201019,
-0.006541332229971886,
-0.49680662155151367,
-0.22853177785873413,
-0.2648557126522064,
-0.24532747268676758,
0.3329418897628784,
0.07118187844753265,
0.07467152923345566,
-0.4958317279815674,
0.16766159236431122,
-0.2462652325630188,
0.021012406796216965,
0.030495207756757736,
-0.206612691283226,
0.6708682775497437,
-0.4284500181674957,
-0.4890587627887726,
-0.1594846397638321,
0.20831118524074554,
0.33634206652641296,
-0.40069541335105896,
0.6042708158493042,
0.3631146252155304,
-0.2577613592147827,
-0.10597117990255356,
-0.7434834241867065,
0.06517261266708374,
-0.4464948773384094,
0.4575176537036896,
-0.5529326796531677,
-0.9597800970077515,
0.3372655212879181,
-0.37317708134651184,
0.0034737992100417614,
0.45445868372917175,
0.8051747679710388,
0.11914188414812088,
1.0131654739379883,
0.47691038250923157,
-0.2963903248310089,
0.4545094072818756,
0.22284765541553497,
0.1994195580482483,
-0.744002640247345,
0.3088569641113281,
-0.7207579612731934,
-0.02364526130259037,
-0.6055945754051208,
-0.721057116985321,
0.46274787187576294,
0.18240879476070404,
-0.541566014289856,
0.07863719761371613,
-0.03362800553441048,
0.9423478245735168,
0.5639042854309082,
0.023582007735967636,
0.45847100019454956,
-0.0098746158182621,
-0.16425439715385437,
-0.04713653400540352,
-0.6619549989700317,
-0.6980491280555725,
1.2548750638961792,
0.152446910738945,
0.7338465452194214,
0.4175342321395874,
0.5418772101402283,
-0.02362285926938057,
0.11824512481689453,
-0.5169212818145752,
0.6520053148269653,
-0.17620447278022766,
-0.510575532913208,
-0.2550045847892761,
-0.451382040977478,
-0.7440564036369324,
0.529015064239502,
-0.021154122427105904,
-0.7963626980781555,
-0.4362013638019562,
-0.04214247688651085,
-0.18770335614681244,
0.28783178329467773,
-0.6968400478363037,
0.918420672416687,
-0.3364117443561554,
-0.6254757642745972,
-0.5063366889953613,
-0.25525063276290894,
0.5738049149513245,
-0.16663037240505219,
0.13192647695541382,
-0.5296635031700134,
0.02995959483087063,
0.6364966034889221,
-0.2372242957353592,
0.5255388617515564,
0.17268946766853333,
0.08141377568244934,
0.11105804890394211,
0.16888932883739471,
0.4308623671531677,
0.09893971681594849,
-0.0627959817647934,
0.13024184107780457,
0.10554412752389908,
-0.5664287805557251,
-0.4191841781139374,
0.7243933081626892,
-0.8135433197021484,
-0.9221299886703491,
-0.7212963104248047,
-0.39154133200645447,
-0.6424720287322998,
0.28359076380729675,
-0.24577884376049042,
0.31748726963996887,
-0.5782056450843811,
0.09753450006246567,
0.7515792846679688,
-0.19906465709209442,
0.18380579352378845,
0.7361313700675964,
-0.1498946100473404,
-0.06586553901433945,
0.7903437614440918,
-0.2697681784629822,
0.46940505504608154,
0.2486288845539093,
0.2802339792251587,
-0.11220360547304153,
-0.6950101256370544,
-0.5602388978004456,
0.4031227231025696,
-0.49393442273139954,
0.0762561783194542,
-0.3316596746444702,
-0.3372907340526581,
-0.20374146103858948,
0.23726725578308105,
-0.5956814289093018,
-0.6292266249656677,
0.18196530640125275,
0.4099818766117096,
0.30926865339279175,
0.9063705801963806,
0.021853001788258553,
0.16297629475593567,
-0.6534490585327148,
0.11452575773000717,
0.2181040644645691,
0.45856282114982605,
-0.040114399045705795,
-0.5720328092575073,
-0.41609832644462585,
-0.14603616297245026,
-0.5165026783943176,
-0.6511070728302002,
0.2492464929819107,
0.2972547709941864,
0.6434536576271057,
0.01119010616093874,
-0.20084311068058014,
0.5064483284950256,
-0.9718344211578369,
0.9023918509483337,
-0.07799828797578812,
-0.8787393569946289,
0.4111822545528412,
-0.6928209066390991,
0.39498966932296753,
0.4642207622528076,
0.41685751080513,
-0.8609716892242432,
-0.46901753544807434,
-0.46125710010528564,
-0.5478753447532654,
0.6978320479393005,
0.3885924220085144,
0.06951404362916946,
0.060659173876047134,
0.22056764364242554,
-0.04412493482232094,
0.07400205731391907,
-0.6206767559051514,
-0.16976895928382874,
0.26038098335266113,
-0.17805621027946472,
-0.47641441226005554,
-0.18725304305553436,
0.04917580634355545,
-0.24819768965244293,
0.7814870476722717,
-0.04943927004933357,
0.13621185719966888,
-0.14394734799861908,
-0.16180828213691711,
0.05524606257677078,
0.626500129699707,
0.6099560260772705,
0.6379778981208801,
0.08341997861862183,
-0.06000775471329689,
0.4466370940208435,
-0.6443871259689331,
0.14690347015857697,
0.2649236023426056,
0.11247467994689941,
-0.21298889815807343,
0.1867479681968689,
0.47960713505744934,
0.3480342924594879,
-0.8788301944732666,
0.48265039920806885,
-0.33796367049217224,
-0.14123719930648804,
-0.5748966336250305,
0.22305361926555634,
0.22458404302597046,
0.4457244277000427,
0.12596094608306885,
-0.27279865741729736,
-0.005623022094368935,
-0.4382990002632141,
-0.20306406915187836,
0.5222622752189636,
-0.06697669625282288,
-0.31367596983909607,
0.5688400268554688,
0.023939548060297966,
0.06431959569454193,
0.40188249945640564,
-0.1118297427892685,
-0.7597204446792603,
0.5010579824447632,
0.45610788464546204,
0.7282217741012573,
-0.25852957367897034,
-0.03990108519792557,
0.5418959259986877,
0.24550913274288177,
-0.43287193775177,
0.4476422071456909,
-0.0569346658885479,
-0.671226441860199,
-0.5966470837593079,
-0.5253430008888245,
-0.972373366355896,
0.003536591539159417,
-0.38930201530456543,
0.09570449590682983,
-0.37373796105384827,
0.0906093418598175,
-0.19311878085136414,
0.46163225173950195,
-0.7196642160415649,
0.04579291492700577,
0.38495153188705444,
0.8593844771385193,
-0.6971773505210876,
0.8967604041099548,
0.9125903248786926,
-0.09625659137964249,
-1.0854153633117676,
-0.051228117197752,
0.06239774450659752,
-0.7743993401527405,
0.6244165897369385,
-0.0955885723233223,
-0.020437389612197876,
0.17215962707996368,
-0.24877667427062988,
-1.2888177633285522,
0.8419098854064941,
0.0863446444272995,
-0.6247844099998474,
0.2205442637205124,
0.27219659090042114,
0.5415072441101074,
-0.0717335194349289,
0.5862922072410583,
0.7712281346321106,
0.38187167048454285,
-0.10563208162784576,
-1.3174725770950317,
-0.03848550096154213,
-0.42282241582870483,
0.11837578564882278,
0.3707255721092224,
-0.828784167766571,
1.1224931478500366,
0.01480951625853777,
-0.3573034703731537,
0.45317837595939636,
0.4765540063381195,
0.2647717297077179,
-0.20767903327941895,
0.33986014127731323,
0.6062348484992981,
0.6591621041297913,
-0.287923663854599,
1.203521490097046,
-0.4355911314487457,
0.06910483539104462,
1.230360507965088,
-0.49114668369293213,
1.0491318702697754,
0.26451820135116577,
-0.5279027223587036,
0.4422551989555359,
0.5573622584342957,
0.187888041138649,
0.23778373003005981,
0.5059494376182556,
-0.3214927017688751,
-0.46434909105300903,
-0.068861223757267,
-0.49874523282051086,
0.43280231952667236,
0.2971799969673157,
0.07197625935077667,
-0.2744491696357727,
-0.3569844961166382,
0.2008703351020813,
0.13988249003887177,
-0.44024693965911865,
0.7197824120521545,
0.07923626899719238,
-0.7498131394386292,
0.5596392750740051,
0.12058160454034805,
0.3746372163295746,
-0.596731424331665,
0.1181541383266449,
-0.4292043447494507,
0.41466182470321655,
0.2032405138015747,
-0.71750408411026,
-0.03531510382890701,
0.2504282295703888,
0.07478325068950653,
-0.17858104407787323,
0.6863768696784973,
-0.40704208612442017,
-0.6075224876403809,
-0.08897155523300171,
0.9831123352050781,
0.41398581862449646,
-0.3064814805984497,
-0.5459489226341248,
0.008279417641460896,
-0.021092230454087257,
-0.4463634788990021,
0.46894294023513794,
0.5248379707336426,
-0.36696264147758484,
0.607631266117096,
0.5828638672828674,
0.3445216715335846,
-0.06584332883358002,
0.025470368564128876,
0.9677329659461975,
-0.8640335202217102,
-0.28091296553611755,
-0.8240146636962891,
0.03592907264828682,
-0.1221991628408432,
-0.3914913833141327,
1.0975286960601807,
0.7597392797470093,
0.8893447518348694,
0.022430146113038063,
0.7903764843940735,
0.11697958409786224,
1.1138428449630737,
-0.49496063590049744,
0.6323675513267517,
-0.5046281218528748,
0.2148982733488083,
-0.18649236857891083,
-1.0271035432815552,
-0.12351340055465698,
0.536864161491394,
-0.60029536485672,
0.06635599583387375,
1.0109285116195679,
0.5871460437774658,
-0.036147475242614746,
0.19057421386241913,
0.4105323255062103,
0.18469370901584625,
0.18752382695674896,
0.9941592216491699,
1.2276464700698853,
-0.2542797327041626,
0.4843190014362335,
-0.25570541620254517,
-0.16640552878379822,
0.06814119964838028,
-0.6502787470817566,
-1.2025569677352905,
-0.2832752764225006,
-0.17777349054813385,
0.015051190741360188,
0.2900533378124237,
0.7483112215995789,
0.4082854688167572,
-0.7076908946037292,
-0.49478110671043396,
0.16073566675186157,
0.08633692562580109,
-0.15515220165252686,
-0.1209854781627655,
0.21206443011760712,
-0.34874361753463745,
-0.6942078471183777,
0.4087372422218323,
0.06586155295372009,
0.00921888928860426,
-0.062152497470378876,
0.007878904230892658,
0.039710186421871185,
-0.0014009507140144706,
0.4428379237651825,
0.33839306235313416,
-0.6115446090698242,
-0.21294695138931274,
0.02729249931871891,
-0.26576152443885803,
0.07079723477363586,
0.7633798122406006,
-0.7917516231536865,
-0.177628755569458,
0.2542756497859955,
0.49602702260017395,
0.5740792751312256,
-0.04501255229115486,
0.6933503746986389,
-0.33984655141830444,
-0.033961791545152664,
0.25115564465522766,
0.38993513584136963,
0.338052362203598,
0.07145950943231583,
0.8559685945510864,
-0.029673412442207336,
-0.7057486176490784,
-0.617346465587616,
0.11800465732812881,
-0.7064656615257263,
-0.14659243822097778,
1.2751258611679077,
-0.20735037326812744,
-0.09564851224422455,
-0.04033361002802849,
-0.25078684091567993,
-0.13538537919521332,
-0.2693045735359192,
0.44873443245887756,
0.8706902265548706,
-0.07025022804737091,
-0.25996536016464233,
-0.9190841913223267,
0.4938249886035919,
0.7343708276748657,
-0.9518292546272278,
0.20659296214580536,
0.5564280152320862,
0.3183978796005249,
-0.26349952816963196,
0.7585254311561584,
-0.13696499168872833,
0.47740256786346436,
-0.11257798969745636,
-0.028125373646616936,
0.1980733722448349,
0.023418130353093147,
-0.2690788805484772,
-0.1370103806257248,
0.512346625328064,
0.24349358677864075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02402v1
|
Token Trails: Navigating Contextual Depths in Conversational AI with ChatLLM
| 2024-04-03T02:11:39 | 2024-04-03T02:11:39 |
Md. Kowsher, Ritesh Panditi, Nusrat Jahan Prottasha, Prakash Bhat, Anupam Kumar Bairagi, Mohammad Shamsul Arefin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Conversational modeling using Large Language Models (LLMs) requires a nuanced
understanding of context to generate coherent and contextually relevant
responses. In this paper, we present Token Trails, a novel approach that
leverages token-type embeddings to navigate the intricate contextual nuances
within conversations. Our framework utilizes token-type embeddings to
distinguish between user utterances and bot responses, facilitating the
generation of context-aware replies. Through comprehensive experimentation and
evaluation, we demonstrate the effectiveness of Token Trails in improving
conversational understanding and response generation, achieving
state-of-the-art performance. Our results highlight the significance of
contextual modeling in conversational AI and underscore the promising potential
of Token Trails to advance the field, paving the way for more sophisticated and
contextually aware chatbot interactions.
|
[
-0.029296133667230606,
-1.09928297996521,
0.43617820739746094,
0.03995668888092041,
-0.33249345421791077,
0.6051847338676453,
-0.040076300501823425,
-0.19732724130153656,
0.21738040447235107,
0.5526542067527771,
-0.5203039050102234,
-0.7548412680625916,
-0.4303206205368042,
-0.4874509871006012,
-0.7480173707008362,
0.9257610440254211,
0.38428404927253723,
-0.024490222334861755,
-0.6064121127128601,
-0.1764681041240692,
-0.980796217918396,
-0.8789318203926086,
-0.7375877499580383,
-0.2007523775100708,
0.6499040722846985,
0.16242873668670654,
0.4938317537307739,
0.4056991636753082,
0.34017491340637207,
0.24723561108112335,
-0.22367478907108307,
0.20062929391860962,
-0.6851249933242798,
0.7818318009376526,
0.1791318953037262,
-0.7184509038925171,
-0.11079414933919907,
-0.41235342621803284,
0.30458420515060425,
0.522522509098053,
-0.1605658382177353,
-0.016947712749242783,
-0.28101134300231934,
0.030938822776079178,
-0.5532086491584778,
0.061342187225818634,
-0.9395497441291809,
0.042322542518377304,
-0.07819388061761856,
-0.365283340215683,
-0.5517938137054443,
0.06820883601903915,
0.21681027114391327,
-0.5786137580871582,
0.11650750786066055,
0.3720076084136963,
0.30631646513938904,
0.14955781400203705,
-0.635921061038971,
-0.4625110924243927,
-0.5733516812324524,
0.5050748586654663,
-0.7122218012809753,
0.20329850912094116,
0.18208006024360657,
0.4635200798511505,
-0.20780760049819946,
-1.1134859323501587,
-0.3540821373462677,
-0.2498040795326233,
0.0001909881830215454,
0.0019526779651641846,
0.00433694152161479,
-0.1102798730134964,
-0.017437191680073738,
0.16766270995140076,
-0.12108251452445984,
0.12980709969997406,
-0.06665389239788055,
-0.2581848204135895,
0.39819684624671936,
0.6780191659927368,
0.4490590989589691,
-0.2413744479417801,
-0.42212697863578796,
-0.03133843094110489,
-0.7681899070739746,
0.31000882387161255,
-0.09732445329427719,
0.6848716139793396,
-0.35432377457618713,
0.47866714000701904,
0.08011826872825623,
0.6930566430091858,
-0.17052985727787018,
0.01977410912513733,
0.004527019336819649,
-0.4773523509502411,
-0.11408530175685883,
0.10500194877386093,
0.5947378277778625,
0.448253870010376,
0.05311625823378563,
-0.42259007692337036,
-0.20216231048107147,
-0.24167266488075256,
0.154420405626297,
-0.7771894335746765,
-0.20140953361988068,
0.3241543471813202,
-0.20165596902370453,
-0.35293230414390564,
-0.13839279115200043,
-0.5941227078437805,
-0.8352773189544678,
-0.0882803425192833,
0.2120608389377594,
-0.4443836510181427,
-0.37712714076042175,
-0.02681572362780571,
-0.4359583258628845,
0.5036811828613281,
0.5583459734916687,
-0.8384565114974976,
0.2167038768529892,
1.0570253133773804,
1.0927612781524658,
-0.02522582933306694,
0.10036295652389526,
-0.8575106859207153,
0.2634606957435608,
-0.41066834330558777,
0.43716633319854736,
-0.8186264634132385,
-0.8547263145446777,
0.38020050525665283,
-0.3647685945034027,
0.01644180715084076,
-0.27177855372428894,
0.14658915996551514,
-0.5854032039642334,
0.16588792204856873,
0.030841050669550896,
-0.5668136477470398,
-0.30771294236183167,
0.6432579159736633,
-0.20788288116455078,
1.0459928512573242,
-0.12243522703647614,
-0.632960855960846,
0.25006869435310364,
-0.8520732522010803,
-0.6908522248268127,
0.269773930311203,
-0.2283538579940796,
0.08593835681676865,
0.19863569736480713,
0.20615726709365845,
0.35888954997062683,
-0.10220999270677567,
0.4569540023803711,
-0.163918599486351,
-0.3738069236278534,
0.23784811794757843,
-0.4806647002696991,
0.6580260396003723,
0.02588147670030594,
-0.4401180148124695,
0.5117441415786743,
-0.4457166790962219,
-0.21303872764110565,
0.09626977145671844,
-0.1610729694366455,
-0.39726531505584717,
0.30495455861091614,
0.3994814455509186,
0.04238629713654518,
0.27131420373916626,
-0.33530306816101074,
0.015567189082503319,
-0.5274306535720825,
0.7114263772964478,
1.0346237421035767,
-0.04169044271111488,
0.4854710102081299,
-0.03919457271695137,
0.4849213659763336,
0.22111305594444275,
0.12952588498592377,
-1.0077564716339111,
-0.6655718088150024,
-0.8760558366775513,
-0.2409975826740265,
0.14146599173545837,
0.3216873109340668,
-0.38914451003074646,
0.48034974932670593,
-0.47675925493240356,
-0.41705310344696045,
-0.41495630145072937,
-0.08328613638877869,
0.28009355068206787,
0.7237457036972046,
0.14599590003490448,
-0.23989428579807281,
-0.37380295991897583,
-0.5298349261283875,
-0.3193272054195404,
-0.24610397219657898,
0.05053997412323952,
0.8354422450065613,
0.4267488420009613,
-0.43217435479164124,
1.4053336381912231,
-0.38042473793029785,
-0.04561053588986397,
-0.0722377598285675,
0.06123669072985649,
-0.12121202796697617,
0.5034831166267395,
0.3387102782726288,
-0.9397150278091431,
-0.33257579803466797,
-0.04880145192146301,
-0.3094569146633148,
0.26964300870895386,
-0.151786208152771,
-0.16585709154605865,
0.009683939628303051,
0.7476332187652588,
-0.6657471656799316,
0.6248809099197388,
0.19131745398044586,
-0.6150745153427124,
-0.2002643495798111,
-0.09442362934350967,
0.07942210137844086,
-1.1102120876312256,
0.30669984221458435,
-0.4559668302536011,
-0.714479386806488,
-0.6530168056488037,
-0.016867822036147118,
-0.3455171287059784,
-0.22180882096290588,
-0.6316774487495422,
0.9281551241874695,
0.012262453325092793,
-0.23946447670459747,
-0.032708216458559036,
0.589565634727478,
0.08653274178504944,
0.4441535472869873,
-0.22536250948905945,
0.6309381723403931,
0.574820876121521,
-0.4610160291194916,
0.30381840467453003,
0.4558550715446472,
-0.08492761105298996,
0.4811108112335205,
-0.5830110907554626,
0.4915764331817627,
-0.08205985277891159,
0.6167851090431213,
-1.442838430404663,
-0.15160921216011047,
0.22516430914402008,
-0.5902667045593262,
0.11890408396720886,
-0.31346842646598816,
-0.6743108630180359,
-0.02984743006527424,
-0.2149580717086792,
0.4427752196788788,
0.577711284160614,
-0.40613627433776855,
0.9574835300445557,
0.38608434796333313,
0.029508166015148163,
-0.10328366607427597,
-0.6514651775360107,
0.45575928688049316,
-0.38776713609695435,
-0.4971641004085541,
0.13894948363304138,
-0.1823941171169281,
-0.15102618932724,
-0.42466065287590027,
0.1618376523256302,
0.23641474545001984,
0.5335033535957336,
0.5945506691932678,
0.1430482715368271,
-0.16109322011470795,
0.2497384399175644,
-0.3049258887767792,
0.12997037172317505,
0.1759859025478363,
-0.09587796777486801,
1.0951435565948486,
0.04410530626773834,
-0.6002770662307739,
-0.3325812816619873,
0.32409316301345825,
0.6967377662658691,
-0.26927393674850464,
0.49917641282081604,
0.7892395257949829,
-0.32923656702041626,
0.2104155272245407,
-0.37523001432418823,
-0.4176093339920044,
-0.4973016679286957,
0.2735802233219147,
-0.2756761312484741,
-1.2233976125717163,
0.7593695521354675,
-0.2427634596824646,
0.1847662776708603,
0.14915233850479126,
0.6530219316482544,
-0.10411429405212402,
1.4508167505264282,
0.428004652261734,
-0.10049951821565628,
0.7176860570907593,
-0.12501786649227142,
0.5424703359603882,
-0.9111279249191284,
-0.7419738173484802,
-0.4331814646720886,
-0.23550945520401,
-0.5032132267951965,
-0.6280187368392944,
0.18945185840129852,
-0.09064488112926483,
-0.5431020259857178,
-0.18882593512535095,
-0.25250443816185,
0.22204747796058655,
0.7239801287651062,
-0.08117131143808365,
0.026178346946835518,
-0.25569844245910645,
-0.033227890729904175,
0.22618436813354492,
-0.817781388759613,
-0.49652281403541565,
0.9974714517593384,
0.24031031131744385,
0.48608851432800293,
0.08756907284259796,
0.41946443915367126,
0.5562552809715271,
0.3729362487792969,
-0.8197487592697144,
0.5281192064285278,
0.2048998475074768,
-0.7305384278297424,
-0.18947410583496094,
0.03265536203980446,
-0.9449871778488159,
0.1430462896823883,
-0.21204496920108795,
-1.0697516202926636,
-0.43476760387420654,
0.06741610169410706,
-0.3386315703392029,
0.23078405857086182,
-0.6661587953567505,
0.805279016494751,
-0.4479460120201111,
-0.21209627389907837,
-0.2922014594078064,
-0.8322780728340149,
0.076177217066288,
0.3228956460952759,
0.2758491039276123,
-0.18142366409301758,
-0.1659054011106491,
0.6692180037498474,
-0.25392940640449524,
1.2871630191802979,
-0.333874374628067,
0.021646877750754356,
0.48930302262306213,
0.35160699486732483,
0.4956764876842499,
0.20112018287181854,
0.2706906795501709,
0.06470644474029541,
-0.23973456025123596,
-0.2866292893886566,
-0.5717324614524841,
0.9108524322509766,
-0.6077175736427307,
-0.8538023233413696,
-0.05133257806301117,
-0.4457608163356781,
-0.24420319497585297,
0.21053002774715424,
-0.2252408266067505,
0.7228173017501831,
-0.3037671744823456,
0.35042494535446167,
0.26670363545417786,
-0.28272125124931335,
0.5768163800239563,
0.24496717751026154,
-0.433228462934494,
-0.3833787739276886,
0.5552378296852112,
-0.4445107877254486,
-0.07448036968708038,
0.44043201208114624,
0.0979822650551796,
-0.5685129761695862,
-0.5886428356170654,
-0.4863033592700958,
-0.17068280279636383,
-0.9090868830680847,
-0.26691770553588867,
-0.6457778811454773,
-0.08296073228120804,
-0.584745466709137,
-0.2755303382873535,
-0.16438888013362885,
-0.3063231408596039,
-0.5677523612976074,
-0.2042858898639679,
0.7270833849906921,
0.9525966048240662,
0.31161338090896606,
0.5439201593399048,
-0.5337945222854614,
-0.06714250892400742,
0.3027971386909485,
0.1696784943342209,
0.3457253575325012,
-0.5307123064994812,
-0.21868595480918884,
0.22837050259113312,
-0.3670865297317505,
-0.5110273957252502,
0.18805494904518127,
-0.035676393657922745,
0.457939475774765,
0.37379854917526245,
-0.09235435724258423,
0.9325527548789978,
-0.5104390978813171,
1.284606695175171,
0.4147527813911438,
-1.0962493419647217,
0.8437873721122742,
-0.515916109085083,
0.17988482117652893,
0.3491361141204834,
-0.19325822591781616,
-0.8967776298522949,
-0.285722941160202,
-0.6594099402427673,
-1.288886308670044,
0.5497938990592957,
0.19616957008838654,
0.7841852307319641,
-0.21107833087444305,
0.3375529944896698,
-0.03536301478743553,
0.4374265670776367,
-0.47085314989089966,
-0.13336986303329468,
-0.37741324305534363,
-0.2675849497318268,
-0.3188360333442688,
-0.047558147460222244,
-0.3707439601421356,
0.02184629626572132,
0.11523191630840302,
-0.26606741547584534,
0.11576532572507858,
0.15029063820838928,
-0.12666776776313782,
0.307371586561203,
-0.28763672709465027,
0.6817276477813721,
0.6366238594055176,
-0.1385050266981125,
0.19085074961185455,
0.010395705699920654,
0.03149401769042015,
-0.2005006968975067,
-0.4062272906303406,
0.10136730968952179,
-0.122867152094841,
0.4216195344924927,
0.905348002910614,
0.3884486258029938,
-0.9164478182792664,
0.740018367767334,
-0.08192085474729538,
0.3041984438896179,
-0.2266840785741806,
0.21574845910072327,
0.39913302659988403,
0.1922888159751892,
0.45933640003204346,
0.0013088078703731298,
0.18121036887168884,
-0.4664197862148285,
0.042896710336208344,
0.646547794342041,
-0.7390809059143066,
-0.23833756148815155,
0.7062060236930847,
0.6911807060241699,
-0.9978895783424377,
0.6741378307342529,
0.550195574760437,
-0.6044829487800598,
0.6340748071670532,
0.632740318775177,
0.8725335597991943,
0.3018939197063446,
0.03241484984755516,
0.09969377517700195,
-0.2112928330898285,
0.4804840087890625,
-0.39983317255973816,
-0.5414246320724487,
-0.3843911290168762,
-0.045421257615089417,
-0.17964252829551697,
-0.45713838934898376,
-0.2334277331829071,
-0.3897605240345001,
0.14734424650669098,
-0.5169041752815247,
-0.4148254692554474,
-0.31115132570266724,
-0.4349539875984192,
-0.8442693948745728,
0.07883939892053604,
0.30991458892822266,
1.0062514543533325,
-0.46889081597328186,
0.23982973396778107,
0.4846552014350891,
-0.2931005358695984,
-0.2866966128349304,
-0.02834344655275345,
-0.2914654016494751,
-1.0008010864257812,
0.5898032188415527,
0.4627037048339844,
-0.37416425347328186,
0.05184181407094002,
-0.7305312752723694,
-0.7011192440986633,
1.3205839395523071,
-0.009609858505427837,
-0.22308160364627838,
0.1655031144618988,
0.15022332966327667,
0.5799792408943176,
-0.7560802698135376,
0.5836275219917297,
0.41164305806159973,
0.18691053986549377,
0.2400810569524765,
-0.5543872117996216,
0.07385066151618958,
-0.07624825090169907,
0.3270821273326874,
-0.07184727489948273,
-0.8578656911849976,
0.49714452028274536,
0.0467505156993866,
-0.2855290472507477,
0.2584715485572815,
0.3188149631023407,
0.2900864779949188,
0.6447564959526062,
0.43148157000541687,
0.1985575258731842,
0.6879855394363403,
-0.09951914846897125,
0.9629440903663635,
-0.5310680270195007,
0.006692591123282909,
1.011880874633789,
-0.23924829065799713,
1.014701008796692,
0.7507187128067017,
0.1727626770734787,
0.8750514388084412,
0.8332034945487976,
0.46508273482322693,
0.6247177720069885,
0.5947372317314148,
-0.3953397274017334,
-0.3646128177642822,
-0.4775550365447998,
-0.1939898580312729,
0.48691385984420776,
0.5559905767440796,
-0.15217044949531555,
0.044920414686203,
-0.03088180162012577,
0.14887581765651703,
0.027899498119950294,
-0.20559437572956085,
0.9281206727027893,
-0.07014308869838715,
-0.7445314526557922,
0.4057749807834625,
-0.02257297933101654,
0.6367691159248352,
-0.43222376704216003,
-0.17491844296455383,
-0.5835917592048645,
-0.14869794249534607,
0.1169971451163292,
-0.6283694505691528,
-0.032662179321050644,
0.08129683136940002,
0.10674338787794113,
-0.3061811923980713,
0.574443519115448,
-0.17346441745758057,
-0.2363838106393814,
0.3277093768119812,
0.517074465751648,
-0.07226910442113876,
0.10886254161596298,
-0.7464279532432556,
0.11583743989467621,
-0.10968733578920364,
-0.2563786208629608,
0.008726665750145912,
0.497834712266922,
-0.002553485566750169,
0.9384668469429016,
0.9139805436134338,
-0.4917161464691162,
0.15382073819637299,
0.25253552198410034,
1.0319089889526367,
-0.8284212946891785,
-0.681800365447998,
-1.0225427150726318,
0.8143672943115234,
-0.21101173758506775,
-0.4108501970767975,
0.593462347984314,
0.7923571467399597,
0.3460092842578888,
0.19220292568206787,
0.6526511311531067,
0.07283560931682587,
0.19452126324176788,
-0.40385276079177856,
0.5190699696540833,
-0.46922311186790466,
0.27534666657447815,
0.11379670351743698,
-0.3721823990345001,
-0.43911996483802795,
0.4157458245754242,
-0.08175697922706604,
0.07527374476194382,
0.18751515448093414,
0.6546949744224548,
-0.0006789558683522046,
-0.20946989953517914,
0.23882293701171875,
0.1466771513223648,
0.7567735910415649,
0.4881032407283783,
1.1448934078216553,
-0.33903589844703674,
0.5619840025901794,
0.4764215350151062,
0.15059271454811096,
-0.4947783350944519,
-0.8250314593315125,
-1.0538265705108643,
-0.6053060293197632,
-0.04744499549269676,
-0.16306430101394653,
0.12765178084373474,
0.6335244178771973,
1.10100257396698,
-0.5962891578674316,
-0.1936134397983551,
-0.4449869692325592,
0.34381550550460815,
0.4730447232723236,
-0.28217312693595886,
0.23269180953502655,
-0.48588013648986816,
-0.7303053736686707,
0.34374335408210754,
0.5224676728248596,
0.31483569741249084,
-0.5955268740653992,
-0.21357235312461853,
-0.15825368463993073,
0.3327658772468567,
0.504589855670929,
-0.05475594848394394,
-1.0462051630020142,
-0.4844435751438141,
0.05953483656048775,
-0.10735450685024261,
0.24932079017162323,
0.9814719557762146,
-1.0992430448532104,
0.6135919094085693,
0.38325268030166626,
0.7144908905029297,
0.7608125805854797,
0.09799718111753464,
0.6735787391662598,
-0.8020445704460144,
0.31843891739845276,
0.4075433611869812,
0.18983079493045807,
0.7417882084846497,
-0.15777845680713654,
0.3825084865093231,
0.11339174956083298,
-0.17678460478782654,
-1.0036982297897339,
0.14487388730049133,
-0.8517274260520935,
-0.23612837493419647,
1.1050983667373657,
-0.16658836603164673,
-0.19671662151813507,
-0.008918752893805504,
-0.39218011498451233,
0.14657236635684967,
-0.3881867825984955,
0.7217437028884888,
0.6037863492965698,
0.014249715022742748,
-0.010066233575344086,
-0.27643290162086487,
0.33416396379470825,
0.4348202645778656,
-0.6484002470970154,
0.28598544001579285,
0.40415340662002563,
0.07285825163125992,
0.21893125772476196,
0.8656405806541443,
0.14582397043704987,
-0.03829507902264595,
0.058149971067905426,
-0.4275347590446472,
0.08219864964485168,
-0.20881588757038116,
-0.06937853991985321,
0.016492635011672974,
0.11070609092712402,
-0.40502068400382996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02393v1
|
Backdoor Attack on Multilingual Machine Translation
| 2024-04-03T01:32:31 | 2024-04-03T01:32:31 |
Jun Wang, Qiongkai Xu, Xuanli He, Benjamin I. P. Rubinstein, Trevor Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While multilingual machine translation (MNMT) systems hold substantial
promise, they also have security vulnerabilities. Our research highlights that
MNMT systems can be susceptible to a particularly devious style of backdoor
attack, whereby an attacker injects poisoned data into a low-resource language
pair to cause malicious translations in other languages, including
high-resource languages. Our experimental results reveal that injecting less
than 0.01% poisoned data into a low-resource language pair can achieve an
average 20% attack success rate in attacking high-resource language pairs. This
type of attack is of particular concern, given the larger attack surface of
languages inherent to low-resource settings. Our aim is to bring attention to
these vulnerabilities within MNMT systems with the hope of encouraging the
community to address security concerns in machine translation, especially in
the context of low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.04181644693017006,
-0.7003759145736694,
0.42776280641555786,
0.30528417229652405,
-0.2777980864048004,
0.24171997606754303,
-0.008946450427174568,
-0.38854068517684937,
0.22285611927509308,
0.9451111555099487,
-0.3612332046031952,
-0.5608980059623718,
-0.7236512303352356,
0.19276198744773865,
-0.31947049498558044,
1.2503286600112915,
0.04639614373445511,
0.22894622385501862,
0.36594390869140625,
-0.32045304775238037,
-0.8467991352081299,
-1.1351369619369507,
-0.713278591632843,
-0.14631757140159607,
0.7961907386779785,
0.4425685703754425,
1.0546225309371948,
0.20987693965435028,
0.8724934458732605,
0.2602650821208954,
0.3033241331577301,
-0.37793582677841187,
-0.38260942697525024,
0.4355219900608063,
-0.26803719997406006,
-0.7116838097572327,
-0.4708053171634674,
-0.16783715784549713,
0.5116901397705078,
0.3123379945755005,
0.002705007093027234,
0.13307201862335205,
-0.10813604295253754,
0.8003953695297241,
-0.5212500095367432,
-0.4330222010612488,
-0.9519150853157043,
0.3469933867454529,
-0.605567991733551,
-0.38183122873306274,
-0.7028783559799194,
-0.059875573962926865,
-0.4452631175518036,
-0.11133027076721191,
0.0036244052462279797,
0.13662131130695343,
0.30425795912742615,
0.19507507979869843,
-0.6032172441482544,
-0.08883186429738998,
-0.4166709780693054,
0.6847956776618958,
-0.5490561127662659,
0.5460062623023987,
0.4640488922595978,
0.4383695125579834,
-0.33178645372390747,
-0.45231905579566956,
-0.4320012629032135,
-0.2162950485944748,
-0.2609301209449768,
-0.061035074293613434,
-0.4379813075065613,
-0.24328215420246124,
0.21818524599075317,
0.36597132682800293,
-0.9205167889595032,
0.2593706250190735,
-0.39202478528022766,
-0.36664238572120667,
0.5095301270484924,
0.4414656460285187,
0.7048261761665344,
-0.47906461358070374,
-0.5507949590682983,
-0.11187220364809036,
-0.8761924505233765,
-0.406089186668396,
0.6827840805053711,
0.565657377243042,
-0.3907599151134491,
0.6293296217918396,
0.22943411767482758,
0.40875494480133057,
-0.43062883615493774,
0.06844575703144073,
0.22749294340610504,
-0.7517790794372559,
-0.2031470090150833,
0.25986844301223755,
0.9857662916183472,
0.4116348922252655,
-0.12648332118988037,
-0.3096458613872528,
-0.4889211654663086,
-0.24311095476150513,
0.3369992971420288,
-0.9262404441833496,
-0.12330736964941025,
0.4859112799167633,
-0.47906506061553955,
-0.37269356846809387,
-0.07707563787698746,
-1.0612292289733887,
-0.4956734776496887,
0.5955536961555481,
0.6422925591468811,
-0.5780740976333618,
-0.4388653337955475,
-0.19015556573867798,
-0.25542891025543213,
0.09826593846082687,
-0.196703240275383,
-0.5626874566078186,
0.15588796138763428,
0.6232063174247742,
1.1641842126846313,
-0.13743285834789276,
-0.6295744180679321,
-0.7192325592041016,
0.3074224293231964,
-0.22813259065151215,
0.26495620608329773,
-0.2977980673313141,
-0.7419830560684204,
-0.15501900017261505,
0.16791550815105438,
-0.08065293729305267,
-0.5304033160209656,
0.31008660793304443,
-0.7869617938995361,
0.19114330410957336,
-0.0874268114566803,
0.3800581991672516,
0.01103820838034153,
0.4065735936164856,
-0.688210666179657,
0.678393542766571,
-0.08802680671215057,
-0.9197093844413757,
-0.03033214807510376,
-0.6147618889808655,
-0.7715341448783875,
-0.29003357887268066,
0.22039708495140076,
-0.30438753962516785,
0.27581509947776794,
-0.01597513072192669,
0.3320140242576599,
0.011196964420378208,
-0.20751284062862396,
-0.15368276834487915,
-0.14990359544754028,
0.8581336736679077,
-0.918532133102417,
0.99878990650177,
0.6278530955314636,
-0.2253556251525879,
-0.11168430000543594,
-0.6779111623764038,
-0.0884062647819519,
0.21488894522190094,
-0.3279023766517639,
-0.537611722946167,
-0.3412545323371887,
0.2153184860944748,
0.6401416063308716,
0.3379972279071808,
-0.6099992394447327,
0.2826670706272125,
-0.7521019577980042,
0.2909637987613678,
0.6552110910415649,
0.3428831398487091,
0.16232134401798248,
-0.0711064264178276,
0.6862675547599792,
0.43919336795806885,
0.37226617336273193,
-0.31474366784095764,
-0.5647600889205933,
-0.3273714780807495,
-0.11811426281929016,
0.16666056215763092,
0.9187818169593811,
-1.1028441190719604,
-0.12073522806167603,
-0.1244271919131279,
-0.41235798597335815,
-0.5842961072921753,
0.2928800880908966,
0.9355818629264832,
0.17331847548484802,
0.5103103518486023,
-0.17812670767307281,
-0.3250257074832916,
-1.0972992181777954,
-0.4859532117843628,
0.05837208032608032,
0.0033141158055514097,
-0.010403499938547611,
0.636484682559967,
-0.41554510593414307,
0.3007379174232483,
-0.3975551426410675,
-0.3161051571369171,
0.002473133383318782,
-0.15831443667411804,
0.5111308097839355,
0.7644268870353699,
0.7154732346534729,
-0.8560804724693298,
-0.7436433434486389,
0.3226171135902405,
-0.710313081741333,
0.12077299505472183,
0.006174026522785425,
-0.31785669922828674,
0.33432281017303467,
0.4268847107887268,
-0.3921200931072235,
0.2780330181121826,
1.072807788848877,
-0.25710415840148926,
0.25963398814201355,
-0.2892869710922241,
0.3893502950668335,
-1.7192302942276,
0.11912300437688828,
-0.444143146276474,
-0.060724884271621704,
-0.8615865707397461,
0.6294063329696655,
0.19351056218147278,
-0.5904183387756348,
-0.8792501091957092,
0.40224337577819824,
-0.37192878127098083,
-0.09692714363336563,
-0.0069879707880318165,
-0.016725104302167892,
-0.14302180707454681,
0.46956244111061096,
-0.6453517079353333,
1.0738381147384644,
0.3166472911834717,
-0.3506343960762024,
0.6216304302215576,
-0.05221171677112579,
0.08214739710092545,
0.7392516136169434,
-0.3836649954319,
0.3250619173049927,
0.3753281533718109,
0.10758509486913681,
-1.0796170234680176,
-0.37270388007164,
0.6780429482460022,
-0.8112286925315857,
0.7166337370872498,
-0.31582292914390564,
-0.8230988383293152,
-0.00858394242823124,
-0.34410324692726135,
0.4715959131717682,
0.17930440604686737,
-0.36734282970428467,
0.42113423347473145,
0.26767686009407043,
-0.25130200386047363,
-0.7928383350372314,
-1.3096039295196533,
0.7458909153938293,
-0.25588691234588623,
-0.6542447805404663,
0.06821837276220322,
0.26603561639785767,
-0.349824458360672,
-0.15656839311122894,
0.11924127489328384,
-0.337348610162735,
0.436122328042984,
0.2338036745786667,
-0.035310134291648865,
-0.1645888239145279,
-0.06491254270076752,
0.07132474333047867,
-0.36641615629196167,
0.14078833162784576,
-0.37099331617355347,
0.7533004879951477,
0.020343584939837456,
-0.6585233211517334,
-0.6207879185676575,
0.9392255544662476,
0.9503809213638306,
-0.39408865571022034,
1.1986846923828125,
0.46286603808403015,
-0.3464149832725525,
0.31812092661857605,
-0.2474053055047989,
-0.28051239252090454,
-0.4438994526863098,
0.58760666847229,
-0.8064276576042175,
-0.283696711063385,
0.7387746572494507,
0.4818143844604492,
0.057270266115665436,
0.5354750156402588,
0.5047322511672974,
-0.04755653440952301,
1.3735958337783813,
0.6091193556785583,
-0.21448853611946106,
0.26966720819473267,
-0.008940482512116432,
0.08544991910457611,
-0.6425874829292297,
-0.21484330296516418,
-0.8051803708076477,
-0.3517797291278839,
-0.8692866563796997,
-0.1269083321094513,
0.49057310819625854,
-0.15984012186527252,
0.014269791543483734,
0.4430950880050659,
-0.2702213227748871,
0.3206224739551544,
0.4312423765659332,
0.10559983551502228,
0.4255792200565338,
0.020337199792265892,
-0.4317587614059448,
-0.13274060189723969,
-0.6526520848274231,
-0.38723328709602356,
1.1261354684829712,
0.3022647500038147,
0.8010249137878418,
0.7412028312683105,
0.8366405367851257,
0.2501688003540039,
0.3212754428386688,
-0.4796150326728821,
0.22194647789001465,
-0.2351755052804947,
-1.06998610496521,
-0.25951552391052246,
-0.5050277709960938,
-1.0863873958587646,
0.293765664100647,
0.04239034652709961,
-0.6040167808532715,
-0.17749418318271637,
0.1888616532087326,
-0.1729423552751541,
0.6101588606834412,
-1.0235884189605713,
0.9561342000961304,
-0.5293285846710205,
-0.10237329453229904,
-0.4567216634750366,
-0.9350024461746216,
0.5920485854148865,
-0.7058641910552979,
0.39310336112976074,
0.1550276279449463,
-0.05318542197346687,
0.5101999044418335,
-0.4127418100833893,
0.8836092352867126,
-0.1306404322385788,
-0.4406101405620575,
-0.34226641058921814,
0.45620715618133545,
0.5247300863265991,
0.12954387068748474,
-0.26719722151756287,
0.6012151837348938,
0.09139716625213623,
-0.654679536819458,
-0.6036407947540283,
0.675391435623169,
-0.5481885075569153,
-0.9023529887199402,
-0.5615670680999756,
-0.31541183590888977,
-0.0758761465549469,
0.21088086068630219,
0.6173816919326782,
0.27582234144210815,
0.0999416783452034,
0.1905117779970169,
0.5023874640464783,
-0.6029855012893677,
0.4823237657546997,
0.5481922030448914,
-0.3579413890838623,
-0.810746431350708,
1.1980164051055908,
0.21357375383377075,
0.6356651186943054,
0.639166533946991,
0.09761680662631989,
0.06750690191984177,
-0.47648608684539795,
-0.9143688678741455,
0.18909384310245514,
-0.5483126044273376,
-0.4344252049922943,
-0.7673420906066895,
-0.20087622106075287,
-0.4164125919342041,
-0.00912642851471901,
-0.5140548944473267,
-0.4438043236732483,
0.14865873754024506,
0.2022237479686737,
0.4250107705593109,
0.4745382070541382,
0.0400870256125927,
0.6038889288902283,
-1.460697054862976,
0.16489645838737488,
0.006002997048199177,
0.20753219723701477,
-0.27488821744918823,
-0.5581957101821899,
-0.6523825526237488,
0.11545823514461517,
-0.40486180782318115,
-1.4196102619171143,
0.3925180435180664,
-0.17081840336322784,
0.49192702770233154,
0.19436994194984436,
-0.03485127538442612,
0.3438820242881775,
-0.7086223363876343,
0.9310758709907532,
0.3716092109680176,
-0.7278463840484619,
0.6259390711784363,
-0.26159340143203735,
0.3080044686794281,
0.4576352834701538,
0.39279547333717346,
-1.1535686254501343,
-0.8187444806098938,
-0.45760273933410645,
-0.6579130291938782,
0.6315341591835022,
0.2436021864414215,
0.5698651075363159,
0.22912250459194183,
-0.07459700852632523,
0.30264711380004883,
0.343583881855011,
-0.550483763217926,
-0.4147169888019562,
-0.32313787937164307,
0.08310899883508682,
-0.22995121777057648,
-0.25768589973449707,
-0.07287941128015518,
0.25436022877693176,
0.619464099407196,
0.22630776464939117,
0.08245154470205307,
-0.10953331738710403,
-0.2647154629230499,
-0.057524461299180984,
0.652551531791687,
0.8263570070266724,
0.29303231835365295,
-0.03406739979982376,
0.44528788328170776,
0.45035308599472046,
-0.8440672755241394,
0.23835472762584686,
-0.0716070756316185,
0.012943156994879246,
0.07608012855052948,
0.31717267632484436,
0.36220958828926086,
0.23999646306037903,
-0.20320647954940796,
0.46646857261657715,
-0.10914944112300873,
0.28302091360092163,
0.05810994282364845,
-0.22174446284770966,
-0.13920150697231293,
0.17639358341693878,
0.3949452340602875,
0.23637253046035767,
-0.10125314444303513,
-0.7450156211853027,
0.094082772731781,
0.4149415194988251,
-0.4017632007598877,
-0.6451007127761841,
0.35945120453834534,
0.349448025226593,
-0.5647292137145996,
0.6075185537338257,
0.17986755073070526,
-1.002471923828125,
0.299364298582077,
0.7932711243629456,
1.118579387664795,
-0.7436773180961609,
-0.30453842878341675,
-0.14147312939167023,
0.9224175810813904,
0.519911527633667,
0.29873546957969666,
0.13117511570453644,
-0.4810837507247925,
-0.13520987331867218,
-0.5158354640007019,
-0.32532423734664917,
0.11575385928153992,
-0.32150381803512573,
0.10499769449234009,
-0.19793260097503662,
-0.2990683615207672,
-0.3994655907154083,
-0.21318864822387695,
-0.28050199151039124,
-0.049520667642354965,
-0.17207689583301544,
0.7656910419464111,
-0.8765778541564941,
0.8556106686592102,
0.5198774933815002,
-0.45294517278671265,
-0.30749818682670593,
0.121005117893219,
-0.0026786301750689745,
-0.7853124737739563,
0.916740357875824,
-0.013335640542209148,
-0.2845255732536316,
-0.04748223349452019,
-0.13756337761878967,
-0.7519648671150208,
0.503071129322052,
0.4918947219848633,
-0.15276479721069336,
0.16189351677894592,
0.3562213182449341,
0.27093029022216797,
0.23919320106506348,
-0.5193670392036438,
0.3554126024246216,
0.6075304746627808,
-0.4026962220668793,
-0.997327446937561,
0.12775598466396332,
-0.2253812849521637,
-0.18657591938972473,
0.6372423768043518,
-0.6995355486869812,
0.9040704965591431,
-0.03501293808221817,
-0.45391717553138733,
-0.26297810673713684,
0.34957897663116455,
-0.011201959103345871,
0.4872415363788605,
0.16743305325508118,
0.5542725920677185,
0.3987332880496979,
0.10667803138494492,
1.0160661935806274,
-0.42516225576400757,
-0.2048296332359314,
1.0194182395935059,
-0.1996975690126419,
0.9929307699203491,
0.8886952996253967,
0.01586814969778061,
0.16793763637542725,
0.47101762890815735,
0.027688821777701378,
0.4908134937286377,
-0.0909620001912117,
-0.25815925002098083,
0.2254355251789093,
0.051222771406173706,
-0.7748040556907654,
0.4469199776649475,
0.4233650267124176,
-0.5062505006790161,
-0.08755472302436829,
0.3963886499404907,
0.452676385641098,
-0.09247860312461853,
-0.19943808019161224,
0.58006751537323,
0.2707996666431427,
-0.45563575625419617,
0.5418648719787598,
0.4327830374240875,
0.5685189366340637,
-0.49186286330223083,
0.1432017832994461,
-0.3529528081417084,
0.13220074772834778,
-0.4302528500556946,
-0.9398142099380493,
0.688900887966156,
0.27159884572029114,
-0.16936597228050232,
-0.29746267199516296,
0.4294652044773102,
-0.2010549008846283,
-0.19000104069709778,
0.29581788182258606,
0.5004398226737976,
0.37218427658081055,
-0.2813340723514557,
-0.5570623874664307,
0.05989452823996544,
-0.05959002301096916,
-0.16520607471466064,
0.46222928166389465,
0.5429362058639526,
-0.12060287594795227,
0.5086493492126465,
0.9743714928627014,
0.28653067350387573,
0.299395889043808,
-0.18818646669387817,
0.6587579846382141,
-0.7761776447296143,
-0.5037643313407898,
-1.3274005651474,
0.34636759757995605,
-0.11229772120714188,
-0.18203164637088776,
1.3158938884735107,
0.8235149383544922,
0.8912537693977356,
-0.0038194837979972363,
0.7100381851196289,
0.3548041880130768,
0.02828243374824524,
-0.7832954525947571,
1.1851435899734497,
-0.7050943374633789,
0.17498786747455597,
-0.2856699526309967,
-0.7284324765205383,
-0.4052436947822571,
-0.2033368945121765,
-0.1615857630968094,
-0.22294498980045319,
1.0962409973144531,
0.91913241147995,
-0.005383970681577921,
-0.18584975600242615,
0.6224141716957092,
0.3086460828781128,
0.3184492290019989,
0.5766654014587402,
0.8659577965736389,
-0.46113336086273193,
0.9788076877593994,
-0.15210144221782684,
0.0316026397049427,
-0.44166961312294006,
-0.6517676711082458,
-0.8958665728569031,
-0.3907281160354614,
0.18359874188899994,
-0.638026773929596,
0.19011710584163666,
0.7051509618759155,
0.3737051784992218,
-0.7948547601699829,
-0.18920576572418213,
0.5794864892959595,
0.5078307390213013,
-0.12979494035243988,
-0.1446963995695114,
0.1086551770567894,
-0.16421009600162506,
-0.4813482165336609,
0.5445936918258667,
0.5555768609046936,
0.07708001881837845,
-0.6226499676704407,
0.01659724861383438,
-0.12049353867769241,
-0.09441068768501282,
0.4171355068683624,
0.19638101756572723,
-0.5918023586273193,
-0.17511777579784393,
0.05942988023161888,
-0.7771929502487183,
0.03471635654568672,
0.8481990694999695,
-0.2737373411655426,
0.35794541239738464,
0.5980851650238037,
0.8700003623962402,
0.1682746559381485,
-0.5005011558532715,
0.6411715745925903,
-1.210034966468811,
0.37108898162841797,
0.16148996353149414,
0.15987472236156464,
0.34377846121788025,
-0.616629421710968,
0.2528727352619171,
0.4497549831867218,
-0.23299279808998108,
-1.1900253295898438,
0.5788183212280273,
-0.4625433385372162,
-0.3611605167388916,
0.8762000799179077,
-0.03147868439555168,
-0.4345568120479584,
-0.23918534815311432,
-0.1606028974056244,
0.3545258343219757,
-0.21097098290920258,
0.595546543598175,
0.7345302104949951,
0.3219410479068756,
0.2709176540374756,
-0.9099173545837402,
0.16449521481990814,
0.29440027475357056,
-0.7039471864700317,
0.009196383878588676,
0.13466313481330872,
0.1639576107263565,
0.44834572076797485,
0.2509741187095642,
-0.3412179946899414,
0.28091883659362793,
0.1606825441122055,
-0.1640181988477707,
0.017342584207654,
-0.41048741340637207,
-0.5561853647232056,
0.4184528887271881,
-0.1466463804244995,
-0.4235268533229828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02392v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02392v1
|
Low-resource neural machine translation with morphological modeling
| 2024-04-03T01:31:41 | 2024-04-03T01:31:41 |
Antoine Nzeyimana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2
|
Morphological modeling in neural machine translation (NMT) is a promising
approach to achieving open-vocabulary machine translation for
morphologically-rich languages. However, existing methods such as sub-word
tokenization and character-based models are limited to the surface forms of the
words. In this work, we propose a framework-solution for modeling complex
morphology in low-resource settings. A two-tier transformer architecture is
chosen to encode morphological information at the inputs. At the target-side
output, a multi-task multi-label training scheme coupled with a beam
search-based decoder are found to improve machine translation performance. An
attention augmentation scheme to the transformer model is proposed in a generic
form to allow integration of pre-trained language models and also facilitate
modeling of word order relationships between the source and target languages.
Several data augmentation techniques are evaluated and shown to increase
translation performance in low-resource settings. We evaluate our proposed
solution on Kinyarwanda - English translation using public-domain parallel
text. Our final models achieve competitive performance in relation to large
multi-lingual models. We hope that our results will motivate more use of
explicit morphological information and the proposed model and data
augmentations in low-resource NMT.
|
[
-0.25272831320762634,
-0.5962215065956116,
0.25830161571502686,
0.16828793287277222,
-0.5349596738815308,
-0.1519002914428711,
-0.30064907670021057,
-0.3946404457092285,
0.3309299945831299,
0.4861891269683838,
-0.44380295276641846,
-0.2647722065448761,
-0.7051064372062683,
0.21377557516098022,
-0.1283637285232544,
0.5060022473335266,
-0.17545725405216217,
0.4065302014350891,
0.07428096234798431,
-0.17841662466526031,
-0.49339842796325684,
-0.472314715385437,
-0.4608227610588074,
-0.4508070945739746,
0.4670912027359009,
0.12391145527362823,
0.8405606150627136,
1.1179896593093872,
0.6490494012832642,
0.3262020945549011,
-0.44817137718200684,
0.2966887354850769,
-0.15891849994659424,
-0.04965925216674805,
-0.23063045740127563,
-0.5261711478233337,
-0.7108241319656372,
-0.2467665821313858,
0.5931391716003418,
0.9230914115905762,
0.08403915911912918,
0.12813685834407806,
0.10546944290399551,
0.2676187753677368,
-0.3552843928337097,
0.31317198276519775,
-0.6110154390335083,
0.16183705627918243,
-0.29808610677719116,
-0.09302296489477158,
-0.24427610635757446,
0.07978043705224991,
-0.04122833535075188,
-0.4043543338775635,
0.12711453437805176,
-0.012527725659310818,
0.5552888512611389,
0.5641677379608154,
-0.13391120731830597,
0.06306269764900208,
-0.6156363487243652,
0.6220114231109619,
-0.7206969857215881,
0.46200329065322876,
0.31841933727264404,
0.16845844686031342,
0.2404368817806244,
-0.5293242931365967,
-0.2650950253009796,
-0.23958513140678406,
-0.3270433247089386,
0.18837513029575348,
-0.31942853331565857,
0.2284730076789856,
0.14607737958431244,
0.4086749851703644,
-0.5006877779960632,
0.3529621958732605,
-0.3604887127876282,
-0.16338376700878143,
0.11423991620540619,
0.3650680184364319,
0.3182912766933441,
-0.4778093695640564,
-0.3488130569458008,
-0.028963591903448105,
-0.5123937726020813,
-0.1689574122428894,
0.08269411325454712,
0.701884925365448,
-0.1763748675584793,
1.0686317682266235,
-0.18600940704345703,
0.5248578786849976,
-0.02961675077676773,
0.12658636271953583,
0.10162843018770218,
-0.44170647859573364,
-0.16913621127605438,
0.1564112901687622,
0.7110020518302917,
0.07813262939453125,
-0.17394009232521057,
-0.3213641047477722,
-0.6040394902229309,
0.0758896917104721,
0.17491799592971802,
-0.9098694920539856,
0.15154191851615906,
-0.030580859631299973,
-0.7065746188163757,
-0.2488427460193634,
-0.5757043361663818,
-0.8671121597290039,
-0.4848625361919403,
-0.4397996962070465,
0.34982162714004517,
-0.5965285897254944,
-0.35983192920684814,
0.18453983962535858,
0.30124497413635254,
-0.0962175577878952,
0.11266119033098221,
-0.7495598196983337,
0.3264836370944977,
0.39841920137405396,
1.2896517515182495,
-0.3507397174835205,
-0.19247160851955414,
-0.38016852736473083,
0.053754791617393494,
-0.2566896975040436,
0.48318278789520264,
-0.4428405463695526,
-0.1739058941602707,
-0.06817843019962311,
-0.045932430773973465,
-0.23303507268428802,
-0.5172502994537354,
0.4434985816478729,
-0.34742945432662964,
-0.04698929190635681,
0.3590337634086609,
-0.1683502346277237,
-0.07781972736120224,
0.2520856559276581,
-0.8187929391860962,
0.8136100769042969,
0.28817644715309143,
-0.5677617788314819,
-0.2590042054653168,
-1.1412853002548218,
-0.5978707075119019,
0.2642490863800049,
0.16742567718029022,
-0.18400968611240387,
0.43581312894821167,
0.15925855934619904,
0.3158946931362152,
-0.5051064491271973,
0.2717113792896271,
0.028542546555399895,
-0.10957092046737671,
0.09540001302957535,
-0.7114267945289612,
0.5007563233375549,
0.3361225724220276,
-0.23180118203163147,
0.2144940197467804,
-0.5265840888023376,
-0.08736097067594528,
0.1749664843082428,
-0.5280988812446594,
-0.27785345911979675,
-0.27122241258621216,
0.40497779846191406,
0.3686142563819885,
0.43111589550971985,
-0.5394168496131897,
0.2416088730096817,
-0.7407570481300354,
0.676959216594696,
0.29047420620918274,
-0.26605913043022156,
0.8379974961280823,
-0.061237357556819916,
0.4652327299118042,
0.4754568934440613,
0.13624964654445648,
-0.09474658966064453,
-0.5848495960235596,
-0.8060672879219055,
-0.19473981857299805,
0.49076998233795166,
0.44531095027923584,
-1.1334589719772339,
0.0745881050825119,
-0.6821317672729492,
-0.3669295608997345,
-1.0028458833694458,
-0.1114630177617073,
0.5566455125808716,
0.5033746957778931,
0.7120895981788635,
-0.2623002231121063,
-0.3356248438358307,
-1.1264199018478394,
0.06134985387325287,
0.17479801177978516,
-0.1472546011209488,
0.28667137026786804,
0.31169837713241577,
-0.3997269868850708,
0.6164572834968567,
-0.36137640476226807,
-0.3222582936286926,
-0.34673842787742615,
0.24548639357089996,
0.3045671582221985,
0.5720203518867493,
0.3824845254421234,
-0.7640073299407959,
-0.19883573055267334,
0.5042077898979187,
-0.2998826205730438,
0.008537465706467628,
0.2555878162384033,
-0.08406825363636017,
0.16364753246307373,
0.22957642376422882,
-0.8414016366004944,
0.293466717004776,
0.566746175289154,
0.06751890480518341,
0.20170673727989197,
-0.29271095991134644,
0.03184696286916733,
-1.3077582120895386,
0.2375338226556778,
0.07401683181524277,
-0.05079314857721329,
-0.7998123168945312,
0.22797077894210815,
0.2180878072977066,
-0.5436620116233826,
-0.7866455316543579,
0.5397611260414124,
-0.12246223539113998,
-0.08726808428764343,
-0.3656870126724243,
-0.09893668442964554,
-0.10625030100345612,
0.6818506717681885,
0.17413544654846191,
0.8787213563919067,
0.24783340096473694,
-0.4296741485595703,
0.20995767414569855,
0.20264789462089539,
-0.10979641228914261,
0.3159983456134796,
-0.6227673888206482,
-0.0010962790111079812,
-0.07352276891469955,
-0.15386807918548584,
-0.6108217239379883,
-0.4524565041065216,
0.40512675046920776,
-0.31676334142684937,
0.3470689654350281,
-0.4571867883205414,
-0.6088906526565552,
-0.09696216881275177,
0.08618725836277008,
0.5659721493721008,
0.469399094581604,
-0.2685689330101013,
0.6472225785255432,
0.3390558660030365,
-0.3040759563446045,
-0.15947571396827698,
-0.9325178265571594,
0.1948775351047516,
-0.053258128464221954,
-0.6205252408981323,
0.7641194462776184,
0.19502800703048706,
0.11310016363859177,
0.1371890753507614,
0.011145543307065964,
-0.5437489151954651,
-0.0018338299123570323,
-0.05456218495965004,
0.18285033106803894,
-0.6245460510253906,
0.06423310935497284,
0.1711767613887787,
-0.11284641176462173,
-0.21464164555072784,
-0.6438373327255249,
0.8469850420951843,
-0.052894555032253265,
-0.2607390582561493,
-0.3121209442615509,
0.4537489712238312,
0.7929020524024963,
-0.5215304493904114,
0.6864746809005737,
0.7486340999603271,
-0.8698053359985352,
0.1431339681148529,
-0.2677241563796997,
-0.23156212270259857,
-0.368147611618042,
0.7221108078956604,
-0.5527350902557373,
-0.5679371356964111,
0.4258027672767639,
-0.18147669732570648,
-0.2501656413078308,
0.4417518973350525,
0.6809088587760925,
-0.014707510359585285,
1.1476771831512451,
0.697716474533081,
0.11394523829221725,
0.5077360272407532,
-0.28754091262817383,
0.18601611256599426,
-0.9365639686584473,
-0.22236819565296173,
-0.34247052669525146,
-0.5040884017944336,
-0.5703929662704468,
-0.6437486410140991,
0.29755669832229614,
0.14124378561973572,
0.10423304885625839,
0.7033213973045349,
-0.5737614035606384,
0.2505674660205841,
0.45654618740081787,
0.2625217139720917,
0.14881673455238342,
0.11526517570018768,
-0.20884446799755096,
-0.2144213169813156,
-0.9416744709014893,
-0.512241780757904,
0.4709736406803131,
0.3465365469455719,
0.5603968501091003,
0.053137049078941345,
0.30872297286987305,
0.052858561277389526,
0.1897680014371872,
-0.9275170564651489,
0.3598623275756836,
-0.5453876256942749,
-0.3186327815055847,
-0.3614044785499573,
-0.5916564464569092,
-0.8323114514350891,
0.5010680556297302,
-0.09123077988624573,
-0.28900063037872314,
0.17468349635601044,
-0.019721243530511856,
-0.29327642917633057,
0.3938979506492615,
-0.6927023530006409,
0.8784541487693787,
-0.3303726613521576,
-0.20687317848205566,
-0.18221861124038696,
-0.471671462059021,
0.2661576271057129,
-0.18444928526878357,
0.06572367250919342,
0.08232898265123367,
-0.30539655685424805,
0.4229861795902252,
-0.3538617789745331,
0.8531495928764343,
-0.10653603076934814,
0.00019329448696225882,
0.0362682044506073,
0.14545801281929016,
0.4619179666042328,
-0.16141408681869507,
-0.14423489570617676,
0.367616206407547,
-0.30654972791671753,
-0.2996369004249573,
-0.38953515887260437,
0.45187053084373474,
-0.7259365916252136,
-0.3387615382671356,
0.006012703292071819,
-0.8031690120697021,
-0.05849530175328255,
0.3721310496330261,
0.362400621175766,
0.17910905182361603,
0.07092712074518204,
0.28480249643325806,
0.4989974796772003,
-0.0994187444448471,
0.3900270164012909,
0.2686605453491211,
0.11757972091436386,
-0.5131259560585022,
0.9317227602005005,
0.310258686542511,
0.1431961953639984,
0.4701975882053375,
0.1820434033870697,
-0.2758200764656067,
-0.6766083240509033,
-0.8502646684646606,
0.16826581954956055,
-0.44951415061950684,
-0.5179337859153748,
-0.758094072341919,
-0.3127705752849579,
-0.26506567001342773,
0.24206385016441345,
-0.6620420813560486,
-0.45699137449264526,
-0.32402321696281433,
0.23860636353492737,
0.24818840622901917,
0.6334334015846252,
0.24195539951324463,
0.6086688041687012,
-0.8592333793640137,
0.3731600344181061,
-0.08318907022476196,
0.40655404329299927,
0.025413639843463898,
-0.6312291622161865,
-0.519159197807312,
0.31461644172668457,
-0.24444904923439026,
-0.7037688493728638,
0.6457633376121521,
-0.06635531038045883,
0.35986873507499695,
-0.12646959722042084,
-0.1306781768798828,
0.5899600386619568,
-0.719601035118103,
0.40943124890327454,
0.2840704917907715,
-0.8234723210334778,
0.4514960050582886,
-0.2973102033138275,
0.44478270411491394,
0.11935928463935852,
0.1614195555448532,
-0.5063168406486511,
-0.1818791925907135,
-0.15192005038261414,
-0.7732214331626892,
0.9274030327796936,
0.39024806022644043,
0.2492717206478119,
0.08518026769161224,
0.17499230802059174,
0.017140518873929977,
0.06784364581108093,
-0.6068358421325684,
0.02175133116543293,
-0.2978203296661377,
-0.42017269134521484,
0.19638846814632416,
-0.09015211462974548,
0.12316462397575378,
-0.04210364818572998,
0.421480655670166,
-0.19520384073257446,
0.1212376281619072,
-0.06630139797925949,
-0.3778398334980011,
-0.15833133459091187,
0.3179682493209839,
0.7235523462295532,
0.08177529275417328,
0.048884984105825424,
0.18225999176502228,
0.3826477527618408,
-0.5151852369308472,
0.21097002923488617,
0.21962347626686096,
-0.31416571140289307,
0.20855830609798431,
0.1770707368850708,
0.914506733417511,
0.43284738063812256,
-0.25425851345062256,
0.396688312292099,
0.144293874502182,
-0.06980793178081512,
0.4358604848384857,
-0.2728969156742096,
0.3504446744918823,
0.2569575905799866,
0.13418486714363098,
0.6233416199684143,
0.036124441772699356,
-0.07543005794286728,
0.005317844450473785,
0.058130789548158646,
-0.49537789821624756,
-0.4810631573200226,
0.6667435765266418,
0.29664313793182373,
-0.4739435017108917,
0.47985178232192993,
-0.04310925677418709,
-0.4866046905517578,
0.5397474765777588,
0.6115404367446899,
0.8061046004295349,
-0.3022162616252899,
0.011332024820148945,
0.1884671449661255,
0.493747740983963,
-0.12109263986349106,
0.002686948049813509,
0.09728439897298813,
-0.33037951588630676,
-0.6305670738220215,
-0.8588094115257263,
-0.16307814419269562,
0.3411634862422943,
-0.44328439235687256,
0.3282355070114136,
-0.031085392460227013,
-0.2988646626472473,
-0.12518419325351715,
-0.2972519099712372,
-0.7287123203277588,
-0.04239324852824211,
0.1559380441904068,
0.8515778183937073,
-0.6361792683601379,
0.9205859899520874,
0.8110257983207703,
-0.6001815795898438,
-0.3808232247829437,
-0.22158314287662506,
-0.4523470997810364,
-0.6027166843414307,
0.7045972347259521,
0.13567276298999786,
-0.25129780173301697,
0.17958196997642517,
-0.018179738894104958,
-0.9119691848754883,
0.9838874340057373,
0.7573148608207703,
-0.4749319851398468,
-0.3260573148727417,
0.5502038598060608,
0.603553831577301,
-0.3142409026622772,
0.010815056040883064,
0.22243064641952515,
0.4007868468761444,
-0.138739675283432,
-0.8972418904304504,
-0.09479506313800812,
-0.277947336435318,
0.4110545217990875,
0.16327981650829315,
-0.28723815083503723,
0.9812607169151306,
0.17184530198574066,
-0.3255605697631836,
0.16531431674957275,
0.4782129228115082,
-0.09692038595676422,
-0.1263124644756317,
0.2632485330104828,
0.42432090640068054,
0.37897464632987976,
-0.05440220609307289,
0.9759030938148499,
-0.5888814330101013,
0.3086031973361969,
0.8252614140510559,
-0.054567378014326096,
0.7341156005859375,
0.5229541659355164,
0.12411434203386307,
-0.27944767475128174,
0.6196631789207458,
0.10046128928661346,
0.7527167797088623,
0.14609484374523163,
-0.06847197562456131,
-0.20646825432777405,
-0.7188445925712585,
-0.34956392645835876,
0.47368568181991577,
0.2638278305530548,
-0.4740898311138153,
-0.3655232787132263,
0.2583082318305969,
-0.19451454281806946,
0.012884147465229034,
-0.5767590403556824,
0.7097970843315125,
0.10977374762296677,
-0.4433947205543518,
0.6199756860733032,
0.51656174659729,
0.7578944563865662,
-0.26397913694381714,
-0.0896301120519638,
-0.3718312680721283,
0.20922964811325073,
-0.04039895907044411,
-0.5671716332435608,
0.4739703834056854,
0.23600417375564575,
-0.44461938738822937,
-0.39955827593803406,
0.6374509334564209,
-0.7047340273857117,
-0.5970045328140259,
0.37905868887901306,
0.7876451015472412,
0.08874877542257309,
-0.08241872489452362,
-0.5275431871414185,
-0.0017520845867693424,
-0.35757043957710266,
-0.09863850474357605,
0.3840714693069458,
0.6196131110191345,
-0.22408781945705414,
0.3308146297931671,
0.5091292858123779,
0.19977019727230072,
0.3297118842601776,
0.15578098595142365,
0.8692120313644409,
-0.30169805884361267,
-0.4063847064971924,
-0.89523845911026,
0.42537233233451843,
0.03482804074883461,
-0.14546000957489014,
0.24479591846466064,
0.665119469165802,
0.7304875254631042,
-0.3834156394004822,
0.5213087797164917,
0.2281830608844757,
0.08497613668441772,
-0.5120877027511597,
0.9442229270935059,
-0.5080824494361877,
-0.16805925965309143,
0.22275933623313904,
-1.0634009838104248,
-0.34766441583633423,
0.38830268383026123,
-0.13402700424194336,
-0.2511156499385834,
0.5584656596183777,
0.7750393748283386,
-0.54118412733078,
-0.29018619656562805,
0.6203221082687378,
0.11970289796590805,
-0.03339080885052681,
0.4213597774505615,
0.6021817922592163,
-0.43665897846221924,
0.8792890310287476,
-0.3408060073852539,
0.010770249180495739,
-0.3442692756652832,
-0.4512562155723572,
-0.6274287700653076,
-0.4823574125766754,
-0.050995610654354095,
-0.1292113959789276,
-0.056648701429367065,
0.9183596968650818,
0.6544936299324036,
-0.6832350492477417,
-0.13541561365127563,
-0.054365336894989014,
-0.1323758214712143,
-0.11765606701374054,
-0.13372990489006042,
0.2742193043231964,
-0.5529524087905884,
-0.9182301759719849,
0.61606764793396,
0.41472285985946655,
0.16350425779819489,
-0.2667330205440521,
-0.04859286546707153,
-0.013032103888690472,
-0.06317611783742905,
0.6749014854431152,
-0.24861951172351837,
-0.9026738405227661,
0.018240781500935555,
0.36722618341445923,
-0.608128547668457,
0.3533830940723419,
0.6660347580909729,
-0.32545381784439087,
0.2630839943885803,
0.4272352159023285,
1.0472323894500732,
0.51643967628479,
-0.22314001619815826,
0.42307960987091064,
-0.8819076418876648,
0.162290558218956,
0.44744452834129333,
0.5580520629882812,
0.3945537209510803,
-0.33840805292129517,
0.4799330532550812,
0.16408377885818481,
0.10657469183206558,
-0.7592012286186218,
0.3819827139377594,
-0.5858832597732544,
-0.12490347772836685,
0.8859136700630188,
-0.09344159066677094,
-0.48642826080322266,
0.03604355454444885,
-0.18098202347755432,
0.5728418827056885,
-0.18801434338092804,
0.5035413503646851,
0.6019056439399719,
0.1876337081193924,
-0.1703268438577652,
-0.583053708076477,
0.08820413798093796,
0.3053493797779083,
-0.6760013103485107,
0.15508651733398438,
0.1849290430545807,
-0.11159554868936539,
0.513798177242279,
0.1869945377111435,
-0.2349860966205597,
0.11445251107215881,
0.006521138828247786,
0.12117341160774231,
-0.3017725646495819,
-0.2530692219734192,
-0.541757345199585,
0.11730165779590607,
-0.20055320858955383,
-0.37127038836479187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02389v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02389v1
|
On Linearizing Structured Data in Encoder-Decoder Language Models: Insights from Text-to-SQL
| 2024-04-03T01:16:20 | 2024-04-03T01:16:20 |
Yutong Shao, Ndapa Nakashole
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Structured data, prevalent in tables, databases, and knowledge graphs, poses
a significant challenge in its representation. With the advent of large
language models (LLMs), there has been a shift towards linearization-based
methods, which process structured data as sequential token streams, diverging
from approaches that explicitly model structure, often as a graph. Crucially,
there remains a gap in our understanding of how these linearization-based
methods handle structured data, which is inherently non-linear. This work
investigates the linear handling of structured data in encoder-decoder language
models, specifically T5. Our findings reveal the model's ability to mimic
human-designed processes such as schema linking and syntax prediction,
indicating a deep, meaningful learning of structure beyond simple token
sequencing. We also uncover insights into the model's internal mechanisms,
including the ego-centric nature of structure node encodings and the potential
for model compression due to modality fusion redundancy. Overall, this work
sheds light on the inner workings of linearization-based methods and could
potentially provide guidance for future research.
|
[
0.1751880794763565,
-0.8849998712539673,
0.6334933638572693,
-0.10478667169809341,
-0.1926402598619461,
0.08624114096164703,
-0.04714622348546982,
-0.5259859561920166,
0.2333715856075287,
0.42769262194633484,
-0.48324739933013916,
-0.6425997018814087,
-0.35396116971969604,
0.25777289271354675,
-0.7543941736221313,
1.0022135972976685,
-0.016043860465288162,
0.23043489456176758,
-0.31987419724464417,
0.06498365849256516,
-0.34718945622444153,
-0.8541550040245056,
-0.3068973422050476,
-0.5206910371780396,
0.657092273235321,
0.009953908622264862,
0.6869613528251648,
1.1684119701385498,
0.35558220744132996,
0.15610343217849731,
-0.06810507923364639,
0.0008640381856821477,
-0.8135272264480591,
0.18791453540325165,
0.05156654864549637,
-0.6028980612754822,
-0.5590329170227051,
-0.1989993005990982,
0.7075105905532837,
1.4049692153930664,
-0.11009275913238525,
0.12731458246707916,
0.10533229261636734,
0.5350450873374939,
-0.20463193953037262,
0.37517473101615906,
-0.6799136400222778,
0.13959135115146637,
-0.3789827525615692,
-0.15876592695713043,
-0.6886582970619202,
-0.3554072380065918,
-0.32627636194229126,
-0.4399018883705139,
0.1609688699245453,
0.15070892870426178,
0.7901375889778137,
0.34089112281799316,
-0.6110787987709045,
-0.4352140426635742,
-1.0399609804153442,
0.5061426162719727,
-0.666961133480072,
0.6222870349884033,
0.3615242838859558,
0.07333871722221375,
-0.30756354331970215,
-0.9657984972000122,
-0.41357287764549255,
-0.04508659616112709,
-0.26015129685401917,
-0.42496389150619507,
0.21446222066879272,
0.34660691022872925,
0.39509317278862,
0.32699811458587646,
-0.4411688446998596,
0.08023037016391754,
-0.5986674427986145,
0.02842647209763527,
0.48138245940208435,
0.1523492932319641,
0.1571325957775116,
-0.2603038251399994,
-0.3893287777900696,
0.30607733130455017,
-0.706005871295929,
0.06024866923689842,
0.2229061871767044,
0.4509238004684448,
0.1643853634595871,
0.7947705388069153,
0.0620337538421154,
0.8015660643577576,
0.02419549599289894,
-0.005587036721408367,
0.2894192039966583,
-0.5980548858642578,
-0.38801807165145874,
-0.045403510332107544,
0.5934123396873474,
0.04286720231175423,
0.3558383882045746,
-0.5770930647850037,
-0.5773304104804993,
0.13780063390731812,
0.3714801073074341,
-0.7938185930252075,
-0.3662961721420288,
0.509977400302887,
-0.7048841714859009,
-0.44415032863616943,
-0.17239265143871307,
-0.4590984880924225,
-0.20850014686584473,
-0.28114086389541626,
0.21627239882946014,
-0.4027133882045746,
0.11339274793863297,
0.2046828716993332,
-0.03781205788254738,
0.3807072043418884,
0.12801963090896606,
-1.0508314371109009,
0.7147446870803833,
0.7327819466590881,
0.6866225600242615,
-0.022854797542095184,
0.2436228096485138,
-0.45378127694129944,
0.19821670651435852,
-0.5016374588012695,
0.5858927965164185,
-0.9152935743331909,
-0.2509938180446625,
-0.07438643276691437,
-0.22221188247203827,
-0.07416609674692154,
-0.28455936908721924,
0.6125984787940979,
-0.5219182372093201,
0.2345249056816101,
-0.4770430624485016,
-0.8408492803573608,
0.09930669516324997,
0.1075754389166832,
-0.6175561547279358,
1.0201369524002075,
-0.1800859123468399,
-0.6336775422096252,
0.45523884892463684,
-0.6007566452026367,
-0.2889162003993988,
-0.010071451775729656,
-0.42693892121315,
-0.5474512577056885,
0.28240787982940674,
0.17122754454612732,
0.4479149878025055,
-0.15209639072418213,
0.3348581790924072,
-0.5524394512176514,
-0.4839715361595154,
0.24228093028068542,
-0.03997500240802765,
0.33255311846733093,
0.060625992715358734,
0.14384977519512177,
0.18953837454319,
-0.9193039536476135,
0.06809109449386597,
0.25761178135871887,
-0.48087674379348755,
-0.2709020972251892,
0.6095736622810364,
-0.0012311609461903572,
0.374356746673584,
0.23406989872455597,
-0.6256418228149414,
0.49029192328453064,
-0.5543124079704285,
0.6662390232086182,
0.7210841178894043,
-0.05602436140179634,
0.6449677348136902,
-0.04394667595624924,
0.1862783432006836,
0.21798360347747803,
-0.03402644395828247,
-0.3610599935054779,
-0.19016379117965698,
-0.7538369297981262,
0.017470628023147583,
0.2706070840358734,
0.33743780851364136,
-0.5893625020980835,
0.2261478155851364,
-0.5594686269760132,
-0.015315396711230278,
-0.4943145215511322,
0.07021094113588333,
0.3079628348350525,
0.6931018829345703,
0.3883134424686432,
-0.2057819813489914,
-0.5960536599159241,
-0.7945587038993835,
-0.23417173326015472,
0.08784476667642593,
-0.1185283288359642,
0.30578771233558655,
0.5847848653793335,
-0.2552090585231781,
1.0573253631591797,
-0.3688628077507019,
-0.20280590653419495,
-0.3328584134578705,
-0.08250109851360321,
0.39739397168159485,
0.3684717118740082,
0.4120159447193146,
-0.4810793995857239,
-0.1486969143152237,
-0.15540675818920135,
-0.9264571666717529,
-0.15940193831920624,
-0.15612971782684326,
0.2235115021467209,
0.26708194613456726,
0.7576828598976135,
-0.4777108132839203,
0.4164718985557556,
0.3096579611301422,
-0.49877333641052246,
0.10914287716150284,
-0.09715341031551361,
-0.40603989362716675,
-1.2557272911071777,
0.1562773734331131,
-0.2927863299846649,
-0.4821912944316864,
-0.9947715401649475,
-0.23593869805335999,
0.09666301310062408,
-0.20173178613185883,
0.13380855321884155,
-0.01451969426125288,
-0.6059306263923645,
-0.5704408884048462,
0.022889120504260063,
0.04520007222890854,
0.07915341854095459,
0.5887423157691956,
-0.09305049479007721,
0.5707838535308838,
0.1082335114479065,
-0.3621353507041931,
0.1461736410856247,
0.3064185082912445,
-0.004176596645265818,
0.26896828413009644,
-0.9901361465454102,
0.5943337678909302,
-0.5343480706214905,
0.3642688989639282,
-0.8933895230293274,
-0.0892973467707634,
0.13157132267951965,
-0.41577696800231934,
0.28202754259109497,
-0.38281965255737305,
-0.672638475894928,
-0.0024750162847340107,
-0.27637699246406555,
0.36076056957244873,
0.3412626087665558,
-0.2647574841976166,
0.6527811884880066,
0.38559454679489136,
0.20257504284381866,
-0.6113836765289307,
-0.7869372963905334,
0.17169231176376343,
-0.10403325408697128,
-0.7270213961601257,
0.4367111027240753,
0.0734647735953331,
-0.2158614546060562,
0.11788003891706467,
-0.2864496409893036,
-0.1190224140882492,
0.07174348831176758,
0.18244744837284088,
0.26096203923225403,
-0.22909310460090637,
0.324147492647171,
-0.13558132946491241,
0.0685739815235138,
0.21868017315864563,
-0.872645914554596,
0.7495668530464172,
-0.022629551589488983,
-0.16611677408218384,
-0.3514145016670227,
0.24192427098751068,
0.341257780790329,
-0.28571099042892456,
1.193149447441101,
0.28952735662460327,
-0.5531008243560791,
-0.391755074262619,
-0.10007118433713913,
-0.2341051697731018,
-0.4302772879600525,
0.36606115102767944,
-0.5654336214065552,
-0.6535985469818115,
0.7712329626083374,
-0.07499329000711441,
0.13408508896827698,
0.19698062539100647,
0.29156896471977234,
-0.44952332973480225,
0.8157718777656555,
0.5646400451660156,
0.026209885254502296,
0.4618653953075409,
-0.23236890137195587,
0.4716564118862152,
-0.5718748569488525,
-0.603661835193634,
-0.5461212992668152,
-0.4988636374473572,
-0.34909147024154663,
-0.4397040009498596,
0.27830180525779724,
0.10104461759328842,
-0.07192616164684296,
0.17041459679603577,
-0.23503929376602173,
0.4314039349555969,
-0.022036563605070114,
0.03332856297492981,
0.43600890040397644,
0.07843940705060959,
-0.1913875788450241,
-0.023476039990782738,
-0.6789137125015259,
-0.3240388035774231,
1.0728613138198853,
0.6172626614570618,
0.9830804467201233,
-0.002192975953221321,
0.6391286849975586,
0.1581876277923584,
-0.24158869683742523,
-0.8364271521568298,
0.40377452969551086,
-0.14414536952972412,
-0.1783473938703537,
-0.20110714435577393,
-0.4670194089412689,
-1.0651012659072876,
0.16294315457344055,
-0.2544229030609131,
-0.4807698726654053,
0.5334030389785767,
0.11833075433969498,
0.12313564121723175,
0.32033824920654297,
-0.6975045204162598,
0.6112973093986511,
0.0009048715000972152,
-0.3587688207626343,
0.042771678417921066,
-0.6106423735618591,
0.12468705326318741,
-0.05292598530650139,
0.3411199748516083,
0.1377449929714203,
-0.20725803077220917,
0.442970871925354,
-0.6555288434028625,
0.8592037558555603,
-0.18530401587486267,
-0.20981335639953613,
-0.2975306808948517,
0.20355378091335297,
0.7806945443153381,
-0.1315150260925293,
-0.04976911097764969,
0.23490898311138153,
-0.06066766008734703,
-0.6674526929855347,
-0.6673783659934998,
0.3944315016269684,
-0.7928183078765869,
-0.28789669275283813,
-0.2786380350589752,
-0.6854076981544495,
-0.13965357840061188,
0.15612179040908813,
-0.03535023331642151,
0.8195686936378479,
-0.08136576414108276,
0.400892972946167,
0.7513007521629333,
-0.09012413024902344,
0.42842063307762146,
0.10640671104192734,
-0.39699292182922363,
-0.12196458131074905,
0.5702621340751648,
0.3579849600791931,
0.5400341749191284,
0.555341362953186,
-0.10856495797634125,
-0.2908000946044922,
-0.8214933276176453,
-0.200253427028656,
0.2587648332118988,
-0.7796298265457153,
-0.03802647069096565,
-0.6281257271766663,
-0.3467101752758026,
-0.27555444836616516,
-0.08542467653751373,
-0.3839079439640045,
-0.6577262282371521,
-0.2987980246543884,
-0.371757835149765,
0.09433853626251221,
1.178799033164978,
0.6058838963508606,
-0.11067557334899902,
-0.4723666310310364,
0.12236441671848297,
-0.12472563982009888,
0.4524032175540924,
-0.26640889048576355,
-0.37955063581466675,
-0.26085203886032104,
-0.06649721413850784,
0.224289670586586,
-0.8713376522064209,
0.4844287037849426,
0.4168055057525635,
0.2816859781742096,
0.21788646280765533,
-0.11400827020406723,
0.7282079458236694,
-0.5578064322471619,
0.6216280460357666,
-0.39425745606422424,
-0.8929941654205322,
0.3995756506919861,
-0.6571887135505676,
0.08418238908052444,
0.10144728422164917,
0.1534201204776764,
-0.6600390672683716,
-0.061286427080631256,
-0.20694895088672638,
-0.9117746353149414,
0.7362620830535889,
0.4225989282131195,
0.13508240878582,
0.1930931657552719,
0.6619383096694946,
-0.11285453289747238,
0.2826274037361145,
-1.1174646615982056,
-0.13693274557590485,
-0.3835337460041046,
-0.3546880781650543,
0.16192738711833954,
-0.35741662979125977,
0.07979853451251984,
-0.04996119439601898,
-0.018299486488103867,
-0.266288161277771,
0.5225721597671509,
0.19885088503360748,
-0.3963175117969513,
0.06690889596939087,
0.3578930199146271,
0.45875662565231323,
0.5734569430351257,
-0.2771918773651123,
0.15833452343940735,
0.031916163861751556,
-0.24595794081687927,
-0.26838216185569763,
-0.07504890114068985,
-0.287475049495697,
-0.14242029190063477,
0.43774470686912537,
1.001583218574524,
0.32630211114883423,
-0.32049059867858887,
0.2583659589290619,
-0.008688364177942276,
-0.1881849318742752,
-0.44370800256729126,
-0.19111841917037964,
0.047655291855335236,
0.018399633467197418,
0.40322136878967285,
0.04213150963187218,
0.09186705201864243,
-0.6233963966369629,
0.06389342993497849,
0.38947829604148865,
-0.2531491816043854,
-0.6224056482315063,
0.8587244153022766,
0.20014455914497375,
-0.3184256851673126,
0.8804173469543457,
0.1508353352546692,
-0.19095227122306824,
0.2739981710910797,
0.6838924884796143,
0.5944691300392151,
0.04757216200232506,
-0.12771616876125336,
0.2533918619155884,
0.30445170402526855,
0.23775947093963623,
0.4928243160247803,
-0.1256716102361679,
-0.840027928352356,
-0.32485759258270264,
-0.6882807612419128,
-0.0020647544879466295,
-0.18978530168533325,
-0.6048296093940735,
0.23634155094623566,
-0.6719497442245483,
0.0788164958357811,
0.06913374364376068,
-0.18055924773216248,
-0.41124996542930603,
-0.14365656673908234,
0.30332449078559875,
0.9193951487541199,
-0.7248467206954956,
1.3742756843566895,
0.29659944772720337,
-0.5740927457809448,
-0.7618164420127869,
0.01111641712486744,
-0.0706111416220665,
-0.6437514424324036,
0.7074723243713379,
-0.004583672620356083,
-0.08138663321733475,
0.014947595074772835,
-0.6171392202377319,
-0.9909707307815552,
1.1736356019973755,
0.484407514333725,
-0.44525590538978577,
-0.6726949214935303,
0.5428600907325745,
0.7574278712272644,
-0.5316790342330933,
-0.002032672520726919,
0.5292460322380066,
0.1192333996295929,
0.2192228138446808,
-0.8038924336433411,
0.04678291827440262,
-0.3812911808490753,
0.3095020353794098,
0.37389108538627625,
-0.3680577576160431,
1.0288777351379395,
-0.05473236367106438,
-0.3779584467411041,
-0.28259238600730896,
0.6026819348335266,
-0.16526998579502106,
-0.04341261833906174,
0.3011862337589264,
0.3710646331310272,
0.9315879344940186,
-0.1261918544769287,
1.2366060018539429,
-0.3941205143928528,
0.30545881390571594,
0.8911144137382507,
-0.3818091154098511,
0.8958308100700378,
0.5124077796936035,
-0.06941331177949905,
0.8299095034599304,
0.39937686920166016,
0.006806152407079935,
0.2276434749364853,
0.00687778415158391,
0.02902976982295513,
-0.10720876604318619,
-0.13001099228858948,
-0.049730826169252396,
0.38057681918144226,
0.725982129573822,
-0.5883150100708008,
-0.1815471053123474,
-0.32205596566200256,
0.05751447379589081,
0.11209031939506531,
-0.37453049421310425,
0.9018346667289734,
0.12511640787124634,
-0.2863506078720093,
0.5856380462646484,
0.14632268249988556,
0.43020275235176086,
-0.5606350302696228,
0.03902541473507881,
-0.1471034288406372,
0.24886776506900787,
-0.48439010977745056,
-0.6854802966117859,
0.692628800868988,
-0.15905746817588806,
-0.30257344245910645,
-0.723676860332489,
0.7774933576583862,
-0.6903098225593567,
-0.39598721265792847,
0.3285991847515106,
0.2836339771747589,
-0.011186491698026657,
0.34746691584587097,
-0.3672432005405426,
0.1747506707906723,
-0.10907495021820068,
-0.003511357121169567,
0.290934681892395,
0.26054343581199646,
-0.31036466360092163,
0.668316125869751,
0.7367732524871826,
0.005741573870182037,
0.2483152598142624,
0.19403591752052307,
1.0770896673202515,
-0.8584964275360107,
-0.3131312131881714,
-0.8671883940696716,
0.5073956251144409,
-0.017499124631285667,
0.23423384130001068,
0.6497713923454285,
0.7706170678138733,
0.8084424138069153,
-0.006750365253537893,
0.3924749791622162,
0.11673440784215927,
0.3195101320743561,
-0.7111584544181824,
0.5408542156219482,
-0.2758364677429199,
0.6624875664710999,
-0.06161211058497429,
-0.6136845350265503,
-0.2520763576030731,
0.44329142570495605,
-0.27787116169929504,
0.07112426310777664,
0.7691361308097839,
0.7878567576408386,
0.07827597111463547,
-0.14278139173984528,
0.2213839441537857,
0.6879414319992065,
0.4694906175136566,
0.5395449995994568,
0.43295416235923767,
-0.44216203689575195,
0.5662353038787842,
0.19961410760879517,
0.31583279371261597,
0.028162742033600807,
-0.5751920938491821,
-1.03950834274292,
-0.7188215851783752,
0.22270308434963226,
-0.486014187335968,
0.09393598139286041,
1.0787456035614014,
0.5539857745170593,
-0.6768184900283813,
-0.3101281225681305,
-0.2960558831691742,
0.03695150837302208,
0.17459896206855774,
-0.14020226895809174,
0.261301726102829,
-0.5344669222831726,
-0.6683659553527832,
0.4490233361721039,
0.42991575598716736,
-0.03858968988060951,
-0.25118327140808105,
0.13548344373703003,
-0.03210623934864998,
0.32775723934173584,
0.6454116702079773,
0.034566573798656464,
-0.5429405570030212,
-0.33367758989334106,
0.23331211507320404,
-0.21104823052883148,
0.38907378911972046,
0.9607799649238586,
-1.0909264087677002,
0.3781426250934601,
0.6959863901138306,
0.5104407072067261,
0.6637027859687805,
0.17110951244831085,
1.040154218673706,
-1.1283226013183594,
0.13339827954769135,
0.23341141641139984,
0.4503772556781769,
0.29332324862480164,
-0.4674202799797058,
0.4102357029914856,
0.41110536456108093,
-0.3809461295604706,
-0.9426866173744202,
0.3531549572944641,
-0.8210036158561707,
-0.15688902139663696,
1.0669246912002563,
0.0652402937412262,
-0.37831950187683105,
-0.4349236488342285,
0.18435177206993103,
-0.05124755576252937,
-0.23419451713562012,
0.5778762102127075,
0.5579237341880798,
-0.12670980393886566,
-0.34586450457572937,
-0.39141273498535156,
0.5726836323738098,
0.012021319009363651,
-0.8229143619537354,
0.1061733216047287,
0.5878618359565735,
0.4399990141391754,
-0.29687848687171936,
0.6350100636482239,
-0.28306514024734497,
-0.19926904141902924,
-0.03236328065395355,
-0.0425412692129612,
-0.29071903228759766,
-0.2142021656036377,
-0.7024966478347778,
0.4823682904243469,
-0.043201103806495667,
0.08606080710887909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02933v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02933v2
|
NL2KQL: From Natural Language to Kusto Query
| 2024-04-03T01:09:41 | 2024-04-15T22:10:17 |
Amir H. Abdi, Xinye Tang, Jeremias Eichelbaum, Mahan Das, Alex Klein, Nihal Irmak Pakis, William Blum, Daniel L Mace, Tanvi Raja, Namrata Padmanabhan, Ye Xing
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Data is growing rapidly in volume and complexity. Proficiency in database
query languages is pivotal for crafting effective queries. As coding assistants
become more prevalent, there is significant opportunity to enhance database
query languages. The Kusto Query Language (KQL) is a widely used query language
for large semi-structured data such as logs, telemetries, and time-series for
big data analytics platforms. This paper introduces NL2KQL an innovative
framework that uses large language models (LLMs) to convert natural language
queries (NLQs) to KQL queries. The proposed NL2KQL framework includes several
key components: Schema Refiner which narrows down the schema to its most
pertinent elements; the Few-shot Selector which dynamically selects relevant
examples from a few-shot dataset; and the Query Refiner which repairs syntactic
and semantic errors in KQL queries. Additionally, this study outlines a method
for generating large datasets of synthetic NLQ-KQL pairs which are valid within
a specific database contexts. To validate NL2KQL's performance, we utilize an
array of online (based on query execution) and offline (based on query parsing)
metrics. Through ablation studies, the significance of each framework component
is examined, and the datasets used for benchmarking are made publicly
available. This work is the first of its kind and is compared with available
baselines to demonstrate its effectiveness.
|
[
-0.22878322005271912,
-0.9980777502059937,
0.4306705892086029,
0.1682424545288086,
-0.334104061126709,
0.37041887640953064,
-0.2447684407234192,
-0.5287900567054749,
-0.027540862560272217,
1.0310255289077759,
-0.3667449355125427,
-0.6458781957626343,
-0.12346551567316055,
0.2589375078678131,
-0.3582959473133087,
0.6866158246994019,
0.21889296174049377,
0.10105660557746887,
-0.19527286291122437,
-0.41964322328567505,
-0.49838024377822876,
-0.5023055076599121,
-0.6049454808235168,
-0.21261508762836456,
0.21307292580604553,
0.3488587439060211,
0.6027354001998901,
0.3414562940597534,
0.40918925404548645,
0.2098543643951416,
0.04317468777298927,
0.37389567494392395,
-0.6956062912940979,
0.7687180042266846,
-0.02418634481728077,
-0.8843164443969727,
0.06681088358163834,
-0.6497609615325928,
0.679384171962738,
0.7539718151092529,
-0.43794792890548706,
0.0572492815554142,
-0.20777732133865356,
1.1452568769454956,
-0.6063681244850159,
0.29964035749435425,
-0.7646485567092896,
0.15536338090896606,
-0.17756900191307068,
0.10282213240861893,
-0.5382646918296814,
-0.7189692854881287,
-0.24315962195396423,
-0.5260637998580933,
-0.14814576506614685,
0.2797376811504364,
0.48428186774253845,
0.4680596590042114,
-0.7855191826820374,
-0.561445415019989,
-0.9627915620803833,
0.635776162147522,
-0.9346029162406921,
0.9429784417152405,
0.5763129591941833,
0.9879682064056396,
-0.384942889213562,
-0.9711445569992065,
-0.6602315306663513,
-0.28454121947288513,
-0.4407140910625458,
-0.038839470595121384,
0.03478137403726578,
-0.21325287222862244,
0.2761934697628021,
0.05806867778301239,
-0.6104457378387451,
0.1904575377702713,
-0.3396337330341339,
0.03032829612493515,
0.7180318832397461,
0.5502651929855347,
-0.024984892457723618,
-0.20913247764110565,
0.09964040666818619,
0.0400807186961174,
-0.7322036623954773,
0.07474234700202942,
0.12325220555067062,
0.4108659625053406,
0.09822751581668854,
0.811477541923523,
-0.7447997331619263,
0.784585177898407,
-0.05220814421772957,
-0.20243743062019348,
-0.0928034782409668,
-0.5267693996429443,
-0.20402215421199799,
0.07489831745624542,
0.7697449922561646,
0.674446165561676,
-0.05799686163663864,
-0.4427337646484375,
0.10184258967638016,
0.05021938309073448,
0.16277676820755005,
-0.7860931754112244,
-0.2411929965019226,
0.4410327672958374,
-0.2556314766407013,
-0.3424147963523865,
-0.3340717554092407,
-0.9218118786811829,
-0.5779557824134827,
-0.373941034078598,
-0.10934103280305862,
-0.4471755921840668,
-0.3348795473575592,
-0.07293860614299774,
0.29176947474479675,
0.42833465337753296,
0.014532553032040596,
-0.6750645041465759,
0.3527839779853821,
0.8286747932434082,
0.4719012975692749,
0.01581193134188652,
0.27982407808303833,
-0.45700526237487793,
0.1455821394920349,
-0.744442880153656,
0.5837644338607788,
-0.41205570101737976,
-0.3953935503959656,
0.005675133317708969,
0.08366043120622635,
0.3773517608642578,
-0.5962620377540588,
0.5483226180076599,
-1.1354433298110962,
0.01711180806159973,
-0.2658519148826599,
-0.7719766497612,
-0.08684206008911133,
0.37216272950172424,
-0.7380111813545227,
1.5440666675567627,
0.31140008568763733,
-0.32112282514572144,
0.5252361297607422,
-0.5727734565734863,
-0.35243991017341614,
0.46099376678466797,
-0.06204447150230408,
-0.4919416606426239,
-0.09614776819944382,
0.03124772384762764,
0.11193623393774033,
-0.5649062991142273,
0.3563773036003113,
-0.15586069226264954,
-0.18987493216991425,
0.08039872348308563,
0.2979904115200043,
0.803426206111908,
0.2622542679309845,
0.005291834939271212,
-0.31162846088409424,
-0.8603939414024353,
0.5113292336463928,
0.06904332339763641,
-0.41956087946891785,
-0.5258103609085083,
0.07026169449090958,
-0.02617936208844185,
0.17428499460220337,
-0.08469642698764801,
-0.4950861930847168,
0.32741236686706543,
-0.7556979656219482,
0.554183840751648,
0.07844456285238266,
0.0685330480337143,
0.4295252561569214,
0.43244317173957825,
0.43491533398628235,
-0.4024074971675873,
0.12159694731235504,
0.06755156815052032,
-0.31218084692955017,
-0.6399322152137756,
-0.033924490213394165,
0.4315456449985504,
0.5117267966270447,
-1.0577083826065063,
0.40087002515792847,
-0.2744225263595581,
-0.8149341940879822,
-0.7501702904701233,
0.14630553126335144,
0.1425265222787857,
0.6037441492080688,
0.16579528152942657,
0.327723890542984,
-0.7975354790687561,
-0.8690071702003479,
-0.21781302988529205,
-0.1611553430557251,
-0.10161855816841125,
0.48404809832572937,
0.3183954060077667,
-0.04397900402545929,
1.1087565422058105,
-0.509394109249115,
-0.13336431980133057,
-0.10444619506597519,
-0.05475294589996338,
0.5346764326095581,
0.1499934196472168,
0.3677058219909668,
-0.6346612572669983,
-1.0090525150299072,
0.38499686121940613,
-0.9466773271560669,
-0.18283362686634064,
0.3434801697731018,
-0.41408655047416687,
0.5217872858047485,
0.7933320999145508,
-0.7773407101631165,
0.20151416957378387,
0.1583912968635559,
-0.5262027382850647,
0.7643594145774841,
0.06299019604921341,
0.07018576562404633,
-0.9205663800239563,
0.28275519609451294,
-0.6494444012641907,
-0.2572391927242279,
-0.6861006021499634,
0.5137691497802734,
0.1821046620607376,
-0.2015465497970581,
-0.25823161005973816,
0.5454903244972229,
-0.09719190746545792,
-0.2721790075302124,
-0.16535823047161102,
-0.19101551175117493,
0.20945747196674347,
0.22793272137641907,
-0.21600916981697083,
0.42205604910850525,
0.3030424416065216,
-0.5165433287620544,
0.9931011199951172,
0.3819662034511566,
-0.5334932208061218,
0.7807438373565674,
-0.5841591358184814,
0.29951730370521545,
-0.15478789806365967,
0.3288433849811554,
-0.8867275714874268,
-0.3086848258972168,
0.11376787722110748,
-0.42713990807533264,
0.011035497300326824,
-0.46256548166275024,
-0.8411779403686523,
-0.4314626157283783,
-0.06657733768224716,
-0.05392549932003021,
0.5093287825584412,
-0.5109564661979675,
0.8074204921722412,
0.11093496531248093,
-0.08319087326526642,
-0.39847713708877563,
-0.5672085881233215,
0.2425302267074585,
-0.23126035928726196,
-0.5995737314224243,
0.16348175704479218,
0.08748859912157059,
-0.29339396953582764,
0.27863749861717224,
0.09617876261472702,
-0.21550606191158295,
0.03242722526192665,
-0.042617347091436386,
0.3466525077819824,
-0.3343190848827362,
0.24646419286727905,
0.10800562053918839,
0.0073067257180809975,
0.052213579416275024,
-0.22746916115283966,
0.72463458776474,
0.14775614440441132,
-0.15424934029579163,
-0.3004150986671448,
0.3608890771865845,
0.6580107808113098,
-0.22760428488254547,
0.7968021035194397,
0.6221240758895874,
-0.2250649482011795,
-0.19436895847320557,
-0.6487247347831726,
-0.30146709084510803,
-0.4197956323623657,
0.512692391872406,
-0.23205481469631195,
-0.9848054051399231,
0.3088058829307556,
0.036253657191991806,
0.049096643924713135,
0.16094756126403809,
0.7275301218032837,
-0.1598587930202484,
1.025496006011963,
0.30626508593559265,
0.03180406242609024,
-0.19580316543579102,
-0.0778525173664093,
0.4972018003463745,
-0.5722940564155579,
-0.5104848742485046,
-0.7067963480949402,
-0.01930205523967743,
-0.7137143015861511,
-0.26786133646965027,
0.3983287513256073,
0.4326716959476471,
-0.32735297083854675,
0.14018185436725616,
-0.26996326446533203,
0.6978855133056641,
0.4111226499080658,
-0.32815131545066833,
0.5092225074768066,
0.11992652714252472,
-0.1610557585954666,
-0.2514735162258148,
-0.36849844455718994,
-0.15210771560668945,
1.2670042514801025,
-0.14989887177944183,
0.4981394112110138,
0.38333258032798767,
0.20485273003578186,
0.4136664867401123,
-0.015786366537213326,
-0.9630484580993652,
0.5423723459243774,
-0.029387932270765305,
-0.7568212151527405,
-0.44756728410720825,
-0.4361971914768219,
-0.8429338335990906,
0.27339157462120056,
-0.4160539507865906,
-0.5204858779907227,
-0.10054714977741241,
-0.026081295683979988,
-0.2869361937046051,
0.04432014748454094,
-0.6344955563545227,
0.6792205572128296,
-0.22276560962200165,
-0.5308796763420105,
-0.0482536144554615,
-0.6123688817024231,
0.3434934616088867,
-0.26322075724601746,
0.04122614115476608,
-0.19297371804714203,
-0.01697966270148754,
0.20581960678100586,
-0.5546420812606812,
0.41032442450523376,
-0.3770815432071686,
0.06756816059350967,
0.1470070779323578,
0.34035536646842957,
0.8409483432769775,
0.1403079330921173,
-0.38315168023109436,
-0.02505791373550892,
0.1934276670217514,
-0.20475009083747864,
-0.9827497601509094,
0.49399131536483765,
-0.26568058133125305,
-0.09524628520011902,
0.003299719886854291,
-0.33565327525138855,
-0.5299808382987976,
0.42990952730178833,
-0.08048927038908005,
0.21021786332130432,
0.06240487098693848,
0.7374071478843689,
0.08579441905021667,
-0.1658894270658493,
-0.020158089697360992,
1.0293043851852417,
-0.6171200275421143,
-0.26617908477783203,
0.5935036540031433,
0.09540702402591705,
0.14317739009857178,
0.24161505699157715,
0.1311170905828476,
-0.8528838157653809,
-0.5898504257202148,
-0.33281210064888,
0.1962900161743164,
-0.5490450263023376,
-0.48664432764053345,
-0.6128778457641602,
-0.09711156785488129,
-0.5406250357627869,
-0.021299069747328758,
-0.3684674799442291,
-0.5269516706466675,
0.4645717442035675,
-0.03497031703591347,
0.5892274379730225,
0.3128452003002167,
0.3390345573425293,
0.1807071715593338,
-0.6376495957374573,
0.2555052936077118,
0.23696395754814148,
0.59138423204422,
0.06610472500324249,
-0.05278580263257027,
-0.23534433543682098,
-0.18756572902202606,
0.0240239966660738,
-0.5100955963134766,
0.6797118782997131,
0.18409664928913116,
0.3616028428077698,
0.007054643705487251,
0.3870297372341156,
0.43945401906967163,
-0.5049975514411926,
0.6045910716056824,
-0.11264287680387497,
-0.2710748016834259,
0.5669885277748108,
-0.31098440289497375,
0.2721886932849884,
0.7564899921417236,
0.40836259722709656,
-0.8985717296600342,
-0.36116307973861694,
-0.27955880761146545,
-0.9863102436065674,
0.7390829920768738,
0.3967060148715973,
-0.2095097303390503,
0.07528045028448105,
0.3796722888946533,
0.11965028196573257,
0.2650938332080841,
-0.33932989835739136,
-0.3210386037826538,
-0.13348791003227234,
-0.13598117232322693,
0.2441619485616684,
-0.36255285143852234,
0.04038650542497635,
-0.21892240643501282,
0.6892176866531372,
-0.19275668263435364,
0.059416577219963074,
-0.19236640632152557,
-0.001859639654867351,
0.1025080680847168,
0.28989508748054504,
0.03499990701675415,
0.4940674304962158,
-0.3827260732650757,
-0.3135811388492584,
0.15551237761974335,
-0.3744402527809143,
-0.08913487941026688,
0.19526006281375885,
-0.4762219488620758,
0.05236855521798134,
0.12518972158432007,
0.6262425184249878,
0.06074434891343117,
-0.9207073450088501,
-0.07117070257663727,
-0.10581012070178986,
-0.020441120490431786,
-0.39215967059135437,
-0.259583055973053,
0.4641345143318176,
0.2755585312843323,
0.4014633595943451,
-0.6187538504600525,
0.3700682818889618,
-0.37514427304267883,
0.021020270884037018,
0.3883303105831146,
-0.07388820499181747,
-0.08710812777280807,
0.6128485798835754,
0.13844306766986847,
-0.22415556013584137,
0.9903756380081177,
-0.30715319514274597,
-0.30902722477912903,
0.5092678070068359,
0.4906960427761078,
0.27549222111701965,
-0.2487500160932541,
0.012658313848078251,
0.7674123048782349,
0.12569288909435272,
0.23495632410049438,
0.3262512981891632,
-0.06242990493774414,
-0.7674687504768372,
-0.6422135233879089,
-0.886314332485199,
-0.35118967294692993,
0.23013637959957123,
-0.6714431047439575,
0.4198395907878876,
-0.3618904650211334,
-0.06152302026748657,
0.18661805987358093,
0.05700093135237694,
-0.4440789520740509,
-0.06196708232164383,
-0.19937610626220703,
0.6279221773147583,
-0.5897698402404785,
0.7665674090385437,
0.5611993074417114,
-0.12894600629806519,
-0.7446925044059753,
-0.7061015367507935,
0.037315186113119125,
-0.7587743997573853,
0.7621418237686157,
-0.20756295323371887,
0.3900735080242157,
0.07410649210214615,
-0.3426229655742645,
-0.669033408164978,
1.1227675676345825,
0.20652562379837036,
-0.6378705501556396,
-0.16616207361221313,
0.7381647229194641,
0.6215034127235413,
-0.17327652871608734,
0.02289511449635029,
1.012515664100647,
0.41417577862739563,
0.18624310195446014,
-0.7631291151046753,
-0.01905364915728569,
-0.05917798727750778,
0.031528376042842865,
0.7704238295555115,
-0.38499054312705994,
0.21810078620910645,
0.23047026991844177,
0.0284561850130558,
0.11344106495380402,
0.3288702666759491,
0.33651286363601685,
0.3578988015651703,
0.2962031066417694,
0.6837001442909241,
0.6600773334503174,
-0.1927158236503601,
0.9763485789299011,
-0.3424353301525116,
0.37679168581962585,
1.2176803350448608,
-0.77364581823349,
0.9477452635765076,
0.40832534432411194,
-0.5586931705474854,
0.2570054829120636,
0.12071391940116882,
-0.21068280935287476,
0.6044750213623047,
-0.06031220406293869,
-0.3347725570201874,
-0.1683751940727234,
-0.38263803720474243,
-0.3942306935787201,
0.6917970180511475,
0.5569048523902893,
-0.16742973029613495,
-0.3239130675792694,
-0.12072667479515076,
0.024698756635189056,
0.12960852682590485,
-0.05645677074790001,
0.8724981546401978,
-0.05039294809103012,
-0.6080023050308228,
0.6556376814842224,
0.06592036038637161,
0.25863781571388245,
-0.7152191400527954,
-0.02800145000219345,
-0.4868427813053131,
-0.008624558337032795,
-0.24353483319282532,
-0.7137809991836548,
0.6099229454994202,
-0.10981215536594391,
0.05038897320628166,
0.2331576943397522,
0.8817170262336731,
-0.2973947525024414,
-0.603221595287323,
0.11369183659553528,
0.28612464666366577,
0.07064741104841232,
0.021863659843802452,
-0.5950274467468262,
-0.08584018051624298,
-0.015799982473254204,
0.09106110781431198,
0.17799553275108337,
0.521620512008667,
-0.07286855578422546,
0.685808002948761,
0.9794859886169434,
0.09846974164247513,
0.0836242139339447,
0.11606060713529587,
0.7505151033401489,
-0.6819859147071838,
-0.5912227034568787,
-0.6508879661560059,
0.3619154989719391,
-0.3598211109638214,
0.22347335517406464,
0.8029887080192566,
0.9075801968574524,
0.4843306839466095,
-0.0389438159763813,
0.5892242193222046,
-0.24984484910964966,
0.9112678170204163,
-0.7138844132423401,
0.8275127410888672,
-0.24290414154529572,
0.07918579131364822,
0.11583805084228516,
-0.9151903986930847,
-0.266000896692276,
0.20694252848625183,
-0.05590290203690529,
-0.37060436606407166,
0.37594786286354065,
1.0514585971832275,
0.3310597836971283,
0.06487557291984558,
0.40741318464279175,
0.479328989982605,
0.3641412854194641,
0.26551496982574463,
0.7621369361877441,
-0.2826302647590637,
0.7539856433868408,
-0.28524842858314514,
0.3343886733055115,
-0.4682879149913788,
-0.7229801416397095,
-0.48182037472724915,
-0.29264888167381287,
-0.12293768674135208,
-0.5764778852462769,
0.1494089812040329,
0.6489052772521973,
0.5179677605628967,
-0.71024090051651,
-0.1515597105026245,
-0.04975337162613869,
-0.08500287681818008,
0.02719265967607498,
-0.3426869511604309,
0.452312707901001,
-0.2315216362476349,
-0.43097540736198425,
0.4894813597202301,
0.1993318647146225,
-0.43230679631233215,
-0.15001016855239868,
-0.10349299758672714,
-0.07264691591262817,
-0.3294440507888794,
1.0803450345993042,
0.3788067698478699,
-0.5912927985191345,
0.16304093599319458,
0.171712726354599,
0.016867054626345634,
-0.034707024693489075,
0.5572713613510132,
-0.9209018349647522,
0.6513532400131226,
0.43881216645240784,
0.7360479235649109,
0.7293084859848022,
-0.18478351831436157,
0.32343026995658875,
-0.8243622183799744,
0.033556897193193436,
0.5707119107246399,
-0.05709598958492279,
0.3126719892024994,
-0.39244168996810913,
0.9404228329658508,
0.07012639939785004,
-0.5416688323020935,
-1.1396158933639526,
0.20307567715644836,
-0.814185619354248,
-0.08750613778829575,
1.054945468902588,
0.3875430226325989,
-0.11584163457155228,
-0.5715429782867432,
-0.1119847372174263,
-0.07166032493114471,
-0.3194930851459503,
0.6372461915016174,
0.7892733812332153,
-0.20149214565753937,
-0.07409210503101349,
-0.9794266819953918,
0.4955035150051117,
0.1997482031583786,
-0.7290146946907043,
0.23238064348697662,
0.6913360953330994,
0.2824448347091675,
-0.053266458213329315,
0.6536742448806763,
-0.4449964761734009,
0.22132642567157745,
-0.09940028190612793,
-0.016626501455903053,
-0.09996434301137924,
0.2932080328464508,
0.09374368190765381,
0.09320773184299469,
0.19250337779521942,
0.37429845333099365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02375v1
|
Optical Text Recognition in Nepali and Bengali: A Transformer-based Approach
| 2024-04-03T00:21:14 | 2024-04-03T00:21:14 |
S M Rakib Hasan, Aakar Dhakal, Md Humaion Kabir Mehedi, Annajiat Alim Rasel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Efforts on the research and development of OCR systems for Low-Resource
Languages are relatively new. Low-resource languages have little training data
available for training Machine Translation systems or other systems. Even
though a vast amount of text has been digitized and made available on the
internet the text is still in PDF and Image format, which are not instantly
accessible. This paper discusses text recognition for two scripts: Bengali and
Nepali; there are about 300 and 40 million Bengali and Nepali speakers
respectively. In this study, using encoder-decoder transformers, a model was
developed, and its efficacy was assessed using a collection of optical text
images, both handwritten and printed. The results signify that the suggested
technique corresponds with current approaches and achieves high precision in
recognizing text in Bengali and Nepali. This study can pave the way for the
advanced and accessible study of linguistics in South East Asia.
|
[
-0.03802398964762688,
-0.29403144121170044,
0.1781761795282364,
0.08624296635389328,
-0.37165674567222595,
0.14920783042907715,
-0.0913112461566925,
-0.6798849105834961,
0.1641753613948822,
0.6500678658485413,
0.1442611962556839,
-0.006854547653347254,
-0.7648099660873413,
0.8156725168228149,
-0.6282663345336914,
0.5061299800872803,
-0.26362448930740356,
0.1460576206445694,
0.35776185989379883,
-0.2798340916633606,
-0.11962580680847168,
-0.1835831105709076,
-0.46550020575523376,
-0.13460980355739594,
0.10193756967782974,
0.20259448885917664,
0.4006226360797882,
0.6056759357452393,
0.9155001044273376,
0.3931431770324707,
-0.2034531831741333,
0.21944426000118256,
0.07743838429450989,
-0.01603732630610466,
0.09434331953525543,
-0.6588055491447449,
-0.055158160626888275,
-0.18467900156974792,
0.9037787318229675,
0.5244902968406677,
-0.13194164633750916,
-0.08834094554185867,
0.0832107812166214,
0.7337495684623718,
-0.6369075775146484,
0.08443698287010193,
-0.4921287000179291,
0.19773174822330475,
-0.2428562045097351,
-0.2207377701997757,
-0.5552830696105957,
-0.4321078062057495,
-0.0460980087518692,
-0.49380335211753845,
0.3671308159828186,
0.17356093227863312,
0.7075343728065491,
0.21472294628620148,
-0.49764740467071533,
-0.5950208306312561,
-1.0443857908248901,
0.7690244913101196,
-0.4288904368877411,
0.43814927339553833,
0.698777973651886,
0.5795789361000061,
0.3857250213623047,
-0.3110652565956116,
-0.7000311613082886,
0.041963979601860046,
-0.39526280760765076,
0.23397962749004364,
-0.15546216070652008,
-0.3685985803604126,
0.16835272312164307,
0.5256303548812866,
-0.6373789310455322,
0.13859453797340393,
-0.6183322072029114,
-0.16522975265979767,
0.2459721565246582,
0.11864066123962402,
0.24597451090812683,
-0.4482777416706085,
-0.1920134723186493,
0.0370132178068161,
-0.5681230425834656,
-0.36296090483665466,
0.3481717109680176,
0.23218578100204468,
-0.18574325740337372,
0.9390856027603149,
0.04023735225200653,
0.9557600617408752,
0.1669987589120865,
-0.29994627833366394,
0.014111482538282871,
-0.5033325552940369,
-0.11803402006626129,
0.395464688539505,
0.6780352592468262,
0.03065129555761814,
0.3541095554828644,
-0.006728033069521189,
-0.2374850958585739,
0.11186043173074722,
0.11513495445251465,
-0.5310390591621399,
0.2937028110027313,
-0.21279911696910858,
-0.839005172252655,
0.03963685780763626,
-0.05586771294474602,
-0.998108983039856,
-0.9052873849868774,
-0.19265013933181763,
0.0496349036693573,
-0.3780667781829834,
-0.5120563507080078,
0.0979834496974945,
-0.3353651762008667,
0.48666366934776306,
0.44102001190185547,
-1.0841596126556396,
0.19831730425357819,
0.2182113379240036,
0.8837567567825317,
-0.05448776111006737,
-0.22253836691379547,
-0.20091183483600616,
0.2985742390155792,
-0.3876904547214508,
0.9811382293701172,
-0.5289608836174011,
-0.26673048734664917,
0.335196852684021,
-0.17611561715602875,
0.032365161925554276,
-0.776477575302124,
0.19239051640033722,
-0.595970630645752,
0.1309407651424408,
0.38121509552001953,
-0.007216418161988258,
-0.0931597650051117,
0.18189109861850739,
-0.975172758102417,
1.0292922258377075,
0.3458576798439026,
-0.7642614841461182,
0.3341127932071686,
-0.3266408145427704,
-0.6608643531799316,
0.2840067446231842,
-0.1388932168483734,
-0.22495824098587036,
0.20315305888652802,
0.14641085267066956,
0.24590390920639038,
-0.7016964554786682,
-0.21044503152370453,
0.3018941879272461,
-0.46493616700172424,
0.20820146799087524,
-0.749945878982544,
0.7489215731620789,
0.15998902916908264,
-0.3582797646522522,
-0.24332745373249054,
-1.3361899852752686,
-0.3383197486400604,
0.13195309042930603,
-0.6935779452323914,
-0.3945796489715576,
-0.005449545569717884,
0.6123714447021484,
-0.07977473735809326,
0.29439297318458557,
-0.7289960980415344,
0.2641088366508484,
-0.5936223268508911,
0.8392326831817627,
0.3554907441139221,
-0.35823655128479004,
0.672387957572937,
0.13147619366645813,
0.35975706577301025,
-0.015835873782634735,
0.061431411653757095,
-0.28726354241371155,
-0.3929019570350647,
-0.8208772540092468,
-0.11105940490961075,
0.4127119481563568,
0.745173990726471,
-0.9753333330154419,
0.4404800832271576,
-0.24888034164905548,
-0.6233788728713989,
-0.7126175165176392,
-0.13848315179347992,
0.2290414720773697,
0.2572118043899536,
0.33129891753196716,
-0.3204748034477234,
-0.5423699021339417,
-0.7729426622390747,
-0.257689505815506,
-0.2770968973636627,
-0.10203642398118973,
0.17345313727855682,
0.3790091574192047,
-0.1109050065279007,
0.8923516869544983,
-0.5447241067886353,
-0.6524218320846558,
-0.30186447501182556,
0.15480224788188934,
0.19372150301933289,
0.4812242090702057,
0.34592974185943604,
-1.3020117282867432,
-0.9636725187301636,
0.3857913017272949,
-0.7560186386108398,
0.06469675898551941,
0.09926602244377136,
0.2831789553165436,
0.7737603783607483,
0.551557183265686,
-0.20170386135578156,
0.7662737965583801,
0.5266907811164856,
0.038464151322841644,
0.5356229543685913,
-0.3037043511867523,
0.32810646295547485,
-0.8497281074523926,
0.11534541845321655,
-0.030008908361196518,
-0.1406787633895874,
-0.5996960401535034,
-0.31615352630615234,
0.19614224135875702,
-0.4481262266635895,
-0.41157177090644836,
0.5980505347251892,
-0.6665011048316956,
-0.0976778045296669,
-0.35234543681144714,
0.035807643085718155,
-0.28918057680130005,
0.35918566584587097,
0.5504687428474426,
0.8142059445381165,
0.2844555675983429,
-0.18266615271568298,
0.15338431298732758,
0.29997745156288147,
-0.7355772852897644,
0.9484397172927856,
-0.5592409372329712,
0.12478262931108475,
-0.05860920622944832,
-0.0027462614234536886,
-1.0087294578552246,
-0.12934480607509613,
0.3805979788303375,
-0.3198893666267395,
0.44902241230010986,
-0.11203005909919739,
-0.67955082654953,
-0.14618335664272308,
0.13285769522190094,
0.7636889219284058,
0.6735411286354065,
-0.48493069410324097,
1.0362203121185303,
0.412526398897171,
-0.11681584268808365,
-0.46335309743881226,
-0.9333495497703552,
0.09173805266618729,
-0.0719400942325592,
-0.14536017179489136,
0.12710066139698029,
0.2740151584148407,
0.051473528146743774,
0.015603246167302132,
0.11613981425762177,
-0.6131575107574463,
-0.38463151454925537,
0.09561948478221893,
0.04483755677938461,
-0.09940506517887115,
-0.11520770937204361,
-0.19587136805057526,
-0.3492381274700165,
-0.5818729996681213,
-0.2544531226158142,
0.6895166635513306,
-0.05145770311355591,
-0.2883211374282837,
-0.5991954803466797,
0.6723699569702148,
0.5991171002388,
-0.45882412791252136,
0.6801509261131287,
0.6962304711341858,
-0.5624001622200012,
0.20821726322174072,
-0.6884893178939819,
0.031584687530994415,
-0.44718196988105774,
0.24683278799057007,
-0.10395358502864838,
-0.5839684009552002,
0.3772101402282715,
-0.2817184329032898,
-0.6204347014427185,
0.4747791290283203,
0.538364052772522,
0.03674294427037239,
1.036025881767273,
0.9376113414764404,
0.03264664486050606,
0.6168140769004822,
-0.0747864842414856,
0.5281352996826172,
-0.9612550139427185,
-0.22607965767383575,
-0.9959619045257568,
-0.0004936683108098805,
-0.5788366794586182,
-0.016920756548643112,
0.2716500163078308,
-0.00403247307986021,
-0.1272779256105423,
0.7161204218864441,
-0.9447667002677917,
0.43089935183525085,
0.5432856678962708,
-0.023789022117853165,
0.4484715461730957,
0.028726903721690178,
0.14418965578079224,
-0.14226390421390533,
-0.6138424873352051,
-0.6071678996086121,
0.7225794196128845,
-0.1872486174106598,
0.6325032711029053,
-0.150162935256958,
0.4019275903701782,
0.26373720169067383,
0.09518636018037796,
-0.7570202946662903,
0.4045513868331909,
-0.3170166313648224,
-0.5885588526725769,
-0.3257375955581665,
-0.2389562875032425,
-0.98468017578125,
0.01531174499541521,
-0.15489214658737183,
-0.3767896890640259,
0.6549686789512634,
-0.061563629657030106,
0.15382546186447144,
0.34964749217033386,
-0.6985312700271606,
0.44352757930755615,
-0.19629035890102386,
0.18315447866916656,
-0.18522727489471436,
-0.7805008888244629,
-0.1862553060054779,
-0.2596001625061035,
0.3126700520515442,
0.32503387331962585,
-0.038820862770080566,
0.799414873123169,
-0.08311863243579865,
0.9631759524345398,
0.004438033327460289,
-0.15085852146148682,
0.3500925302505493,
-0.10954985022544861,
0.18272875249385834,
-0.630476176738739,
-0.25486132502555847,
0.4458044171333313,
-0.1136355772614479,
-0.29523470997810364,
-0.5315364599227905,
0.02755650505423546,
-0.5210292935371399,
-0.007848290726542473,
-0.7343274354934692,
-0.2692936360836029,
0.330671489238739,
0.7865256071090698,
0.3991846740245819,
0.5064286589622498,
0.06704922765493393,
0.16636647284030914,
0.17813800275325775,
-0.33629679679870605,
0.4564915597438812,
0.6408395171165466,
-0.013881453312933445,
-0.8481910824775696,
0.9622719287872314,
0.3944637179374695,
0.22482629120349884,
0.6212526559829712,
0.18355385959148407,
-0.11420444399118423,
-0.5801174640655518,
-0.5476162433624268,
0.25565916299819946,
-0.7324721217155457,
-0.338768869638443,
-0.12750355899333954,
-0.23709070682525635,
-0.2561362385749817,
-0.3676699101924896,
-0.1478266566991806,
-0.31691181659698486,
-0.3040802478790283,
0.4581763744354248,
0.2256021797657013,
1.0374162197113037,
-0.01033816672861576,
0.46146807074546814,
-0.8655611276626587,
0.3048410415649414,
0.0727018192410469,
0.4088214337825775,
0.15199148654937744,
-0.09194084256887436,
-0.5156461000442505,
-0.1420316845178604,
-0.14442524313926697,
-0.9289956092834473,
0.5333831906318665,
0.22919043898582458,
0.1656460165977478,
0.39563003182411194,
0.034242238849401474,
0.2951764166355133,
-0.9003946185112,
0.6799742579460144,
0.39373916387557983,
-1.0190523862838745,
0.6143831610679626,
-0.1362987458705902,
0.04012467339634895,
0.3776349127292633,
0.47118762135505676,
-0.5838335752487183,
-0.10412623733282089,
-0.17552174627780914,
-0.4672505259513855,
0.7263878583908081,
0.09257791191339493,
-0.18324600160121918,
0.14691433310508728,
0.2687670886516571,
0.27484384179115295,
0.2705414295196533,
-0.4928956925868988,
-0.0008891994948498905,
-0.34392833709716797,
-0.4604106545448303,
-0.1777433305978775,
0.015329993329942226,
0.14372298121452332,
-0.23190419375896454,
0.12311094999313354,
-0.1902865469455719,
0.42021238803863525,
0.27825039625167847,
-0.2896507978439331,
-0.07212138921022415,
0.14455033838748932,
0.49378201365470886,
0.13590551912784576,
0.0986136719584465,
0.2757951319217682,
-0.039154257625341415,
-1.0234739780426025,
0.38092517852783203,
-0.2080555409193039,
-0.38362669944763184,
-0.11454225331544876,
0.512550413608551,
0.6880496144294739,
0.19343723356723785,
-0.6301209330558777,
0.3808991014957428,
0.08405260741710663,
0.08717731386423111,
-0.37570104002952576,
-0.3953604996204376,
-0.2867094874382019,
0.14109119772911072,
0.6278054714202881,
0.5593562126159668,
0.08959247916936874,
-0.5002007484436035,
-0.3905419707298279,
0.18417951464653015,
-0.5875056982040405,
-0.25799453258514404,
0.41508743166923523,
0.14039826393127441,
-0.9669712781906128,
0.812049150466919,
-0.06420277804136276,
-0.9115869998931885,
0.6253621578216553,
0.9476966857910156,
0.6923119425773621,
-0.21937161684036255,
0.18421036005020142,
0.23140165209770203,
0.4575578272342682,
-0.1512686014175415,
0.2562706768512726,
-0.26927006244659424,
-0.6832329630851746,
-0.10394226759672165,
-0.715376615524292,
-0.6156565546989441,
-0.3438650667667389,
-0.6775210499763489,
0.4673902094364166,
-0.08612126111984253,
0.09099956601858139,
-0.09928324073553085,
-0.11169687658548355,
-0.499208927154541,
0.10044552385807037,
-0.3644537031650543,
0.7531042695045471,
-0.8963595628738403,
0.6045379042625427,
0.5674601793289185,
-0.6368083953857422,
-0.39871498942375183,
-0.06113819405436516,
-0.16479834914207458,
-1.0154086351394653,
0.989055871963501,
0.272059828042984,
-0.15912598371505737,
0.22133193910121918,
-0.14843407273292542,
-0.7056675553321838,
0.7335353493690491,
0.22510191798210144,
-0.33295682072639465,
0.02473287284374237,
0.5084688067436218,
0.8511621952056885,
0.0026251175440847874,
0.46709156036376953,
0.3652964234352112,
0.834954023361206,
-0.1747923642396927,
-1.1389579772949219,
-0.2636299729347229,
-0.3974306583404541,
-0.0716276541352272,
0.540682852268219,
-0.5245935916900635,
0.6292581558227539,
0.2249060869216919,
-0.4319140315055847,
0.2523990869522095,
0.41845887899398804,
-0.16828754544258118,
0.22495968639850616,
0.3304114043712616,
0.21848280727863312,
0.23785462975502014,
-0.03980434685945511,
0.9503359794616699,
-0.02223467454314232,
0.15690582990646362,
0.2166445255279541,
-0.4691583514213562,
1.263451337814331,
0.441318154335022,
-0.5000128746032715,
0.4716022312641144,
0.31489139795303345,
-0.2204694151878357,
0.5838527083396912,
0.06129959225654602,
-0.08971216529607773,
0.06650962680578232,
-0.339196115732193,
-0.1906740665435791,
0.6811757683753967,
0.2700132429599762,
-0.15292249619960785,
-0.11124416440725327,
0.44113337993621826,
-0.46028509736061096,
0.24236558377742767,
-0.33649393916130066,
0.978121817111969,
0.0073798829689621925,
-0.4254786968231201,
0.6941429972648621,
-0.21558447182178497,
0.9743301272392273,
-0.5944391489028931,
-0.2968372106552124,
0.2788531482219696,
0.37268853187561035,
-0.31300196051597595,
-0.6851748824119568,
0.6104748249053955,
0.10821554064750671,
-0.4217904806137085,
-0.19141319394111633,
0.9709147810935974,
-0.5081770420074463,
-0.6429916024208069,
0.30375123023986816,
0.0527103953063488,
0.4044918417930603,
0.09341662377119064,
-0.09891172498464584,
0.09455975145101547,
-0.21884067356586456,
0.32393595576286316,
0.3000515103340149,
0.2586289644241333,
0.04455177113413811,
0.27351152896881104,
0.31262117624282837,
0.525351345539093,
0.15500646829605103,
-0.17263300716876984,
0.26119881868362427,
-0.43959012627601624,
-0.4197649359703064,
-0.5025147199630737,
0.18272775411605835,
-0.03653178736567497,
-0.36425885558128357,
0.8577930927276611,
0.6340830326080322,
0.742279589176178,
-0.39313235878944397,
0.7977219820022583,
0.02835015021264553,
0.5679423809051514,
-0.3814285397529602,
0.999163806438446,
-0.7036035656929016,
-0.2554684579372406,
-0.25503844022750854,
-1.139567255973816,
-0.604759693145752,
1.0325825214385986,
-0.22463837265968323,
-0.07265934348106384,
0.8363237380981445,
0.5525385737419128,
-0.0010965759865939617,
0.21598829329013824,
-0.040590398013591766,
-0.07258524000644684,
0.1713804453611374,
0.2737346887588501,
0.7899255752563477,
-0.7304893136024475,
0.643011748790741,
-0.09631657600402832,
-0.4321155548095703,
-0.2890421748161316,
-0.8284422159194946,
-0.6504190564155579,
-1.0743257999420166,
-0.027698908001184464,
-0.16763629019260406,
-0.18881256878376007,
0.3631249964237213,
0.4010331630706787,
-0.6499118804931641,
-0.32750481367111206,
-0.17889192700386047,
-0.017551051452755928,
-0.4052335321903229,
-0.14631089568138123,
0.7475042939186096,
0.2587357759475708,
-0.9435585737228394,
0.2474464476108551,
0.46466654539108276,
0.19581224024295807,
-0.4155485928058624,
0.11714445054531097,
-0.21424341201782227,
-0.03406699374318123,
0.49660027027130127,
0.4930221438407898,
-0.4584006369113922,
-0.09736834466457367,
0.113365039229393,
-0.1582784354686737,
0.32515960931777954,
0.8431380987167358,
-0.6812722086906433,
0.44844669103622437,
0.8678709268569946,
0.5591319799423218,
0.4096904695034027,
-0.22616633772850037,
0.22969380021095276,
-0.23687519133090973,
0.28669583797454834,
0.36532726883888245,
0.24235069751739502,
0.5877813100814819,
-0.24187418818473816,
0.5491726398468018,
0.3060963749885559,
-0.6451927423477173,
-1.0675938129425049,
0.31930819153785706,
-1.0021620988845825,
0.04611598700284958,
0.978702962398529,
0.05506784841418266,
-0.3300713896751404,
-0.4443609416484833,
-0.6103096008300781,
0.2964004576206207,
-0.06946524232625961,
0.5808162689208984,
0.6119958758354187,
0.04702145978808403,
-0.09643804281949997,
-0.10728848725557327,
0.19496965408325195,
0.1285558044910431,
-0.6674371361732483,
0.041446566581726074,
0.1286344826221466,
-0.14349010586738586,
0.8734988570213318,
0.6024428009986877,
-0.2608979344367981,
0.06818418204784393,
0.4450925886631012,
-0.03965028375387192,
0.14688946306705475,
-0.50715571641922,
-0.6738058924674988,
0.23886604607105255,
-0.2476801574230194,
0.09219442307949066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02372v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02372v1
|
Obfuscated Malware Detection: Investigating Real-world Scenarios through Memory Analysis
| 2024-04-03T00:13:23 | 2024-04-03T00:13:23 |
S M Rakib Hasan, Aakar Dhakal
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the era of the internet and smart devices, the detection of malware has
become crucial for system security. Malware authors increasingly employ
obfuscation techniques to evade advanced security solutions, making it
challenging to detect and eliminate threats. Obfuscated malware, adept at
hiding itself, poses a significant risk to various platforms, including
computers, mobile devices, and IoT devices. Conventional methods like
heuristic-based or signature-based systems struggle against this type of
malware, as it leaves no discernible traces on the system. In this research, we
propose a simple and cost-effective obfuscated malware detection system through
memory dump analysis, utilizing diverse machine-learning algorithms. The study
focuses on the CIC-MalMem-2022 dataset, designed to simulate real-world
scenarios and assess memory-based obfuscated malware detection. We evaluate the
effectiveness of machine learning algorithms, such as decision trees, ensemble
methods, and neural networks, in detecting obfuscated malware within memory
dumps. Our analysis spans multiple malware categories, providing insights into
algorithmic strengths and limitations. By offering a comprehensive assessment
of machine learning algorithms for obfuscated malware detection through memory
analysis, this paper contributes to ongoing efforts to enhance cybersecurity
and fortify digital ecosystems against evolving and sophisticated malware
threats. The source code is made open-access for reproducibility and future
research endeavours. It can be accessed at https://bit.ly/MalMemCode.
|
[
-0.27463528513908386,
-1.0334532260894775,
0.29653993248939514,
-0.09215762466192245,
-0.23055613040924072,
0.07963986694812775,
0.03998672589659691,
-0.49124574661254883,
-0.004915147554129362,
0.8523414134979248,
-0.2990887761116028,
-0.4740960896015167,
-0.45793968439102173,
-0.39976319670677185,
-0.48580026626586914,
0.6679309010505676,
0.19325482845306396,
-0.2943006157875061,
-0.36584046483039856,
-0.02657134458422661,
-0.9404846429824829,
-0.42902982234954834,
-0.5359747409820557,
0.17327484488487244,
-0.026842446997761726,
0.5909507870674133,
0.08676724880933762,
0.6144553422927856,
0.44071415066719055,
0.2936842441558838,
0.37541621923446655,
0.26079702377319336,
-0.40036875009536743,
0.17186596989631653,
0.21855828166007996,
-0.21566952764987946,
-0.2795628011226654,
-0.03437535837292671,
-0.19320739805698395,
0.22908490896224976,
-0.26856377720832825,
0.2877942621707916,
-0.08472742140293121,
0.5622641444206238,
-1.2551435232162476,
-0.24846455454826355,
-0.9344383478164673,
0.1579831838607788,
-0.2084541916847229,
-0.537672758102417,
-0.5123388767242432,
-0.10463250428438187,
-0.04128989204764366,
-0.12348906695842743,
0.15395857393741608,
0.381026953458786,
0.5258322358131409,
0.36472058296203613,
0.16093945503234863,
-0.2721213102340698,
-0.7890825867652893,
0.8261040449142456,
-0.49962183833122253,
-0.0083778603002429,
0.5043745040893555,
0.6297666430473328,
0.0135575532913208,
-0.6913118958473206,
0.032196562737226486,
-0.0785946324467659,
0.20030950009822845,
-0.012830407358705997,
-0.5083550810813904,
-0.5304555892944336,
0.06356559693813324,
0.2599067687988281,
-0.7272431254386902,
0.06377241015434265,
-0.7166826725006104,
-0.1844930797815323,
0.14257840812206268,
0.24512028694152832,
0.2948072552680969,
0.19058315455913544,
-0.730319082736969,
0.1426127701997757,
-0.4983895719051361,
-0.2682688236236572,
0.6995293498039246,
-0.11391516774892807,
0.059416674077510834,
0.029371535405516624,
-0.23704031109809875,
0.5390003323554993,
-0.04822704941034317,
0.010687544010579586,
0.033443350344896317,
0.10835465788841248,
-0.6082472205162048,
0.4293868839740753,
0.5261863470077515,
0.2462766468524933,
0.0008207432110793889,
-0.2563324272632599,
-0.227894589304924,
-0.3045995831489563,
0.783344030380249,
-1.125877857208252,
-0.6448926329612732,
0.31774622201919556,
-0.8519763946533203,
-0.5005515813827515,
0.5286248326301575,
-0.9444485902786255,
-0.5928772687911987,
0.3962906301021576,
0.37706342339515686,
-0.5093621611595154,
-0.02872060239315033,
0.4563414752483368,
-0.2030458301305771,
0.0038727878127247095,
0.14392951130867004,
-0.39458706974983215,
0.47539588809013367,
0.48304277658462524,
0.6251085996627808,
-0.28617584705352783,
0.1787807047367096,
-0.7830939292907715,
0.14566899836063385,
0.39743247628211975,
0.64788818359375,
-0.15451256930828094,
-0.37811434268951416,
-0.05659002438187599,
-0.1871655136346817,
-0.016227154061198235,
-1.0734632015228271,
0.4049595892429352,
-0.3451634347438812,
0.007566274143755436,
0.3395606577396393,
-0.18673822283744812,
-0.509575605392456,
0.4721277356147766,
-0.7205315232276917,
0.8495039939880371,
-0.15090075135231018,
-0.5406991243362427,
0.2424635887145996,
-0.47096675634384155,
-0.26401224732398987,
0.26307833194732666,
0.1740555465221405,
-0.7821534276008606,
0.20294761657714844,
0.3040573000907898,
0.6805562973022461,
0.074325792491436,
0.11248324066400528,
-0.6199889779090881,
-0.5695750117301941,
0.4785539209842682,
-0.4870193898677826,
0.9678346514701843,
0.5072591304779053,
-0.3837644159793854,
-0.24202574789524078,
-0.7291619777679443,
0.1217997595667839,
0.4433755576610565,
-0.05705244466662407,
-0.5561429858207703,
-0.0784149020910263,
-0.0059183393605053425,
-0.13006357848644257,
0.19701117277145386,
-0.7057944536209106,
0.34119704365730286,
-0.10003336519002914,
0.4278440773487091,
0.4069046676158905,
0.2204645574092865,
-0.006830190774053335,
-0.02513967826962471,
0.33996209502220154,
0.313692182302475,
0.552873432636261,
-0.6443846225738525,
-0.4200456738471985,
-0.4721469581127167,
-0.4046233296394348,
0.07697106152772903,
0.9291083216667175,
-0.10211963206529617,
0.3938300907611847,
-0.044146038591861725,
-0.36133623123168945,
-0.3866662085056305,
0.08840116113424301,
0.4555671513080597,
0.5894955992698669,
0.4269196391105652,
-0.09980452060699463,
-0.8166782855987549,
-0.8214266896247864,
-0.4762611389160156,
-0.04408489912748337,
0.06497567147016525,
0.23936378955841064,
0.6378674507141113,
-0.18228721618652344,
0.6478739976882935,
-0.9297556281089783,
-0.229640394449234,
0.14151465892791748,
0.09303645044565201,
-0.11141277104616165,
0.5361946225166321,
0.6402906775474548,
-0.6165904402732849,
-0.14029251039028168,
0.04366954788565636,
-0.4872884452342987,
-0.20226287841796875,
0.003481208812445402,
0.43554219603538513,
0.16076190769672394,
0.890729546546936,
-0.22209174931049347,
0.6978065371513367,
0.25651103258132935,
-0.22594475746154785,
0.6715567708015442,
-0.2923101484775543,
0.08986881375312805,
-0.48917287588119507,
0.46594303846359253,
-0.6493148803710938,
-0.25990623235702515,
-0.37254467606544495,
0.06953123211860657,
0.2985340654850006,
-0.16432470083236694,
-0.7458253502845764,
0.5807371139526367,
-0.32328012585639954,
0.06592770665884018,
-0.17500898241996765,
-0.09290868788957596,
-0.08947040885686874,
0.3320992887020111,
-0.47993460297584534,
0.27505454421043396,
0.2767253518104553,
-0.48772796988487244,
0.1139841079711914,
-0.4826628565788269,
-0.16996844112873077,
0.4416520297527313,
-0.23942208290100098,
0.2399476319551468,
-0.0637088194489479,
-0.19630254805088043,
-1.049315094947815,
-0.04511190578341484,
0.8467298746109009,
-0.45254287123680115,
0.3765990436077118,
-0.521793007850647,
-0.4334601163864136,
-0.21864628791809082,
-0.531624436378479,
0.3840678632259369,
0.6375269293785095,
-0.4942432940006256,
0.35284996032714844,
0.3218817412853241,
0.42820143699645996,
-0.6100466847419739,
-0.6234259009361267,
-0.14140188694000244,
-0.36459770798683167,
-0.2302619367837906,
0.20140640437602997,
-0.17262308299541473,
-0.4474755525588989,
0.33462977409362793,
-0.3400883972644806,
-0.2831059396266937,
0.5430521965026855,
0.7243102192878723,
0.30117523670196533,
-0.37001970410346985,
-0.3338170349597931,
0.009018728509545326,
-0.17863240838050842,
-0.027362719178199768,
-0.6809117794036865,
0.576560378074646,
-0.27094733715057373,
-0.7105281352996826,
-0.30395182967185974,
0.023038242012262344,
0.653693437576294,
-0.1447875052690506,
0.6450258493423462,
0.815770149230957,
-0.6354060173034668,
-0.42216604948043823,
-0.4800357222557068,
0.016870778053998947,
-0.4440876841545105,
0.17642048001289368,
-0.03217862918972969,
-0.45693713426589966,
0.4742797017097473,
-0.24606281518936157,
0.041411109268665314,
0.2849145233631134,
0.25705695152282715,
-0.13579967617988586,
0.643022894859314,
0.2706232964992523,
-0.31708386540412903,
0.2756296694278717,
-0.5085631608963013,
0.22675664722919464,
-0.5078082084655762,
-0.4379812479019165,
-0.47444382309913635,
-0.3792653977870941,
-0.1592435985803604,
-0.28788289427757263,
0.03263994678854942,
0.22716739773750305,
-0.14180350303649902,
0.3164513111114502,
-0.5083388090133667,
0.5215283632278442,
0.3881281614303589,
0.10784577578306198,
0.23484207689762115,
0.053789686411619186,
-0.13165311515331268,
0.28465592861175537,
-0.49067896604537964,
-0.5362964868545532,
1.119667887687683,
0.25349369645118713,
0.523193359375,
-0.19335351884365082,
0.6785935163497925,
0.5671124458312988,
0.1307021677494049,
-0.7350932955741882,
0.38251227140426636,
-0.10981674492359161,
-0.5846579074859619,
0.04552531614899635,
0.04092635214328766,
-1.0590935945510864,
0.06333573162555695,
0.12863542139530182,
-0.9400776624679565,
-0.019331511110067368,
0.10574712604284286,
-0.469890296459198,
0.8891711831092834,
-0.5740470290184021,
0.7338732481002808,
-0.2057022899389267,
-0.11324424296617508,
-0.13759207725524902,
-0.387749582529068,
0.6316174864768982,
-0.02492452599108219,
-0.020055439323186874,
-0.002629379276186228,
-0.2091246247291565,
0.5528842806816101,
-0.2264302521944046,
0.6279050707817078,
-0.41672155261039734,
0.2522676885128021,
0.6469470262527466,
0.4036114811897278,
0.2682255804538727,
0.16097070276737213,
0.11828236281871796,
0.3974972367286682,
-0.014091040007770061,
-0.4422035217285156,
-0.37758535146713257,
0.7731305360794067,
-0.25241586565971375,
-0.2365845888853073,
-0.15285080671310425,
-0.3522799015045166,
0.16512978076934814,
0.3736966550350189,
0.1370214819908142,
0.28267142176628113,
-0.20106518268585205,
0.4534233510494232,
1.1454074382781982,
-0.4297316372394562,
0.5418998599052429,
0.3338627815246582,
-0.3947466313838959,
-0.3219747841358185,
0.9866199493408203,
0.0019612619653344154,
-0.008207084611058235,
0.4711636006832123,
0.41489049792289734,
0.2749345898628235,
-0.77888023853302,
-0.6201828718185425,
-0.03264027088880539,
-0.1687549501657486,
-0.669242262840271,
-0.8193973302841187,
-0.19689355790615082,
-0.058513786643743515,
-0.09806405752897263,
-0.19188712537288666,
-0.11656555533409119,
-0.22578565776348114,
0.2027643918991089,
0.3160208463668823,
0.20668424665927887,
0.13027171790599823,
0.4683977961540222,
-1.003453016281128,
0.2541520893573761,
0.006029860582202673,
0.2748228907585144,
0.3605720102787018,
-0.19697150588035583,
-0.28505274653434753,
-0.031037380918860435,
-0.5486968159675598,
-0.9694381952285767,
0.574323832988739,
-0.3905261754989624,
0.5360071659088135,
1.1226035356521606,
0.16576562821865082,
0.7193158268928528,
0.016421785578131676,
0.5423035025596619,
-0.18267862498760223,
-0.48393455147743225,
0.4609752893447876,
-0.3184318542480469,
0.006479636766016483,
0.7247931957244873,
0.005985703319311142,
-0.19240276515483856,
-0.009548285976052284,
-0.6395189166069031,
-0.7617394924163818,
0.8517306447029114,
0.17886918783187866,
-0.1695181280374527,
0.260804682970047,
0.09815026819705963,
0.338673859834671,
0.41183412075042725,
-0.2109697461128235,
-0.3848811686038971,
-0.14877988398075104,
0.08297549933195114,
0.49545395374298096,
-0.029789987951517105,
0.12435536086559296,
0.060342203825712204,
0.5777392983436584,
0.4538523852825165,
0.44913047552108765,
-0.20838536322116852,
-0.2980516254901886,
0.2550545036792755,
0.08087702095508575,
0.5466015338897705,
0.0927160233259201,
-0.4941105842590332,
0.31689679622650146,
0.003984333947300911,
-0.9993700385093689,
-0.18336905539035797,
-0.17006315290927887,
-0.15805664658546448,
-0.19659386575222015,
0.03958044573664665,
0.23820710182189941,
0.014001911506056786,
-1.1354174613952637,
0.42627251148223877,
0.06854595988988876,
0.12145457416772842,
-0.4880305826663971,
0.2965201735496521,
-0.05832689628005028,
0.007100218906998634,
0.4795994162559509,
0.4516388177871704,
0.37560129165649414,
-0.4676456153392792,
0.0943685844540596,
0.47031494975090027,
-0.6419621109962463,
-0.14176248013973236,
0.20868171751499176,
-0.13846972584724426,
-0.2836936116218567,
0.9881927967071533,
-0.31820669770240784,
-0.40195420384407043,
0.9317471981048584,
0.6232061982154846,
1.1755518913269043,
-0.2956588566303253,
-0.28673219680786133,
0.09065445512533188,
0.7142153978347778,
0.1923970878124237,
0.13920460641384125,
-0.22099927067756653,
-0.36358320713043213,
0.3052983582019806,
-0.4268205761909485,
0.03393395617604256,
0.7555446624755859,
-0.5464062094688416,
0.32818546891212463,
-0.5660154223442078,
0.10654577612876892,
-0.36243876814842224,
-0.2672290802001953,
-0.6544220447540283,
-0.0920143723487854,
0.01966959983110428,
0.6627573370933533,
-0.6214705109596252,
0.5063410997390747,
0.4387165904045105,
-0.07273315638303757,
-0.07103560864925385,
0.13587503135204315,
0.1458471417427063,
-0.8506060838699341,
0.26083454489707947,
0.616149365901947,
-0.004141880664974451,
-0.19918183982372284,
-0.5696675777435303,
-0.49546724557876587,
0.8720678687095642,
0.11254484951496124,
-0.160310760140419,
0.4392147362232208,
-0.13834327459335327,
0.1053864136338234,
-0.16448821127414703,
0.03184620290994644,
0.22672660648822784,
0.6479113698005676,
-0.2947112023830414,
-0.1665765643119812,
0.006940733641386032,
-0.24838529527187347,
-0.4420706331729889,
0.6655388474464417,
-0.12121085077524185,
0.7845050096511841,
-0.2523818910121918,
-0.2157214730978012,
0.16755910217761993,
0.3216722011566162,
0.2710738182067871,
0.8819030523300171,
0.34291312098503113,
0.7702504396438599,
0.41183602809906006,
0.234996497631073,
0.5451475977897644,
-0.11858871579170227,
0.04447302222251892,
0.8232500553131104,
-0.0014995959354564548,
0.8199736475944519,
0.5489817261695862,
-0.11987211555242538,
0.37296852469444275,
0.3446808457374573,
-0.4668616056442261,
0.5102240443229675,
0.4581935405731201,
-0.24677318334579468,
-0.15939950942993164,
0.22567671537399292,
0.033254459500312805,
0.3736305832862854,
0.6925667524337769,
-0.37860703468322754,
-0.27628809213638306,
0.3377954661846161,
0.17497654259204865,
-0.17260900139808655,
-0.3979540765285492,
0.3513966202735901,
-0.11435449868440628,
-0.25939512252807617,
0.3444931209087372,
0.2832362651824951,
0.5894283652305603,
-0.2881803810596466,
-0.11004956811666489,
0.186239093542099,
0.3172295093536377,
-0.37893494963645935,
-0.44297322630882263,
0.5384775400161743,
-0.10184410959482193,
-0.12270469218492508,
-0.10055220127105713,
1.2574107646942139,
0.04870748519897461,
-0.06960075348615646,
0.15977951884269714,
0.3827019929885864,
0.5859384536743164,
-0.6175163984298706,
-0.47002217173576355,
0.2017797827720642,
-0.11035577207803726,
-0.06581380218267441,
0.4512767791748047,
0.057234905660152435,
-0.23428505659103394,
0.791978657245636,
0.8748247623443604,
-0.267701655626297,
0.1245056763291359,
-0.6630421280860901,
0.5659644603729248,
-0.23046256601810455,
-0.39281049370765686,
-1.1318461894989014,
0.5273387432098389,
-0.19044923782348633,
0.08610387146472931,
0.5906085968017578,
1.05818772315979,
0.7483326196670532,
-0.5243532061576843,
0.5274163484573364,
-0.22996129095554352,
0.07875402271747589,
-0.24247662723064423,
0.8726450800895691,
-0.4201979339122772,
0.47762390971183777,
0.18618714809417725,
-0.4604138433933258,
-0.2266436666250229,
0.13087911903858185,
-0.16956014931201935,
-0.07866887003183365,
0.5937778353691101,
0.6650473475456238,
-0.5797080993652344,
-0.0573137030005455,
0.45355263352394104,
-0.03755628690123558,
-0.08818358182907104,
0.3891630172729492,
0.7375965118408203,
-0.64152592420578,
0.7267711758613586,
-0.14686702191829681,
-0.0859665796160698,
-0.7556994557380676,
-0.9272340536117554,
-0.8119975328445435,
-0.4199331998825073,
-0.25806906819343567,
-0.14477530121803284,
0.1315975934267044,
0.22367851436138153,
0.6979594826698303,
-0.7681202292442322,
0.009041424840688705,
0.10927911847829819,
0.10380018502473831,
-0.5210204124450684,
-0.23077861964702606,
0.20576728880405426,
0.14105793833732605,
-0.35560503602027893,
0.25243431329727173,
0.6229272484779358,
-0.1788470447063446,
-0.4215855896472931,
0.2807580232620239,
0.037733037024736404,
0.031054062768816948,
0.5860409736633301,
0.49234530329704285,
-0.5792244076728821,
0.019710062071681023,
0.13628964126110077,
-0.07679357379674911,
-0.19394128024578094,
0.7762322425842285,
-1.2345844507217407,
0.32568150758743286,
0.6173930764198303,
0.7033015489578247,
0.471847265958786,
-0.16964317858219147,
-0.21648554503917694,
-0.6873061060905457,
0.09480144828557968,
0.14087072014808655,
0.25006550550460815,
-0.199808269739151,
-0.32054129242897034,
0.24454881250858307,
0.40393635630607605,
-0.021765420213341713,
-0.9738785624504089,
-0.04463323950767517,
-0.9760145545005798,
-0.8105374574661255,
0.6451780796051025,
-0.25830620527267456,
-0.42342767119407654,
-0.5753266215324402,
-0.3456457853317261,
0.06909286975860596,
-0.4321340024471283,
0.838656485080719,
0.11210966855287552,
-0.23101550340652466,
0.2376650720834732,
-0.8331171870231628,
0.017063701525330544,
-0.04988645389676094,
-0.9135391116142273,
0.0799521803855896,
0.2393404245376587,
0.255342036485672,
0.013658266514539719,
0.23734831809997559,
-0.3970610499382019,
0.2068539559841156,
0.06322906166315079,
-0.07218120247125626,
-0.5845076441764832,
-0.3911623954772949,
-0.2694774568080902,
0.5874248147010803,
-0.6231021881103516,
-0.9288316965103149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02370v1
|
Enhancing Human-Computer Interaction in Chest X-ray Analysis using Vision and Language Model with Eye Gaze Patterns
| 2024-04-03T00:09:05 | 2024-04-03T00:09:05 |
Yunsoo Kim, Jinge Wu, Yusuf Abdulle, Yue Gao, Honghan Wu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in Computer Assisted Diagnosis have shown promising
performance in medical imaging tasks, particularly in chest X-ray analysis.
However, the interaction between these models and radiologists has been
primarily limited to input images. This work proposes a novel approach to
enhance human-computer interaction in chest X-ray analysis using
Vision-Language Models (VLMs) enhanced with radiologists' attention by
incorporating eye gaze data alongside textual prompts. Our approach leverages
heatmaps generated from eye gaze data, overlaying them onto medical images to
highlight areas of intense radiologist's focus during chest X-ray evaluation.
We evaluate this methodology in tasks such as visual question answering, chest
X-ray report automation, error detection, and differential diagnosis. Our
results demonstrate the inclusion of eye gaze information significantly
enhances the accuracy of chest X-ray analysis. Also, the impact of eye gaze on
fine-tuning was confirmed as it outperformed other medical VLMs in all tasks
except visual question answering. This work marks the potential of leveraging
both the VLM's capabilities and the radiologist's domain knowledge to improve
the capabilities of AI models in medical imaging, paving a novel way for
Computer Assisted Diagnosis with a human-centred AI.
|
[
-0.4700048565864563,
-0.6365005373954773,
0.8345987796783447,
-0.2051762193441391,
-0.44502854347229004,
-0.2617245316505432,
-0.021216727793216705,
-0.7927854657173157,
0.1874719262123108,
0.9855682253837585,
-0.5791900157928467,
-0.5457869172096252,
-0.5507451295852661,
-0.11862948536872864,
-0.5608690977096558,
0.3347342908382416,
0.017808260396122932,
0.0035275050904601812,
-0.5812105536460876,
0.0239701047539711,
-0.33300402760505676,
-0.40035897493362427,
-0.7058582901954651,
-0.2851044833660126,
0.21131348609924316,
-0.10401863604784012,
1.0254758596420288,
0.4483172297477722,
0.9136846661567688,
0.2756190299987793,
0.379828542470932,
0.24756474792957306,
-0.2567357122898102,
-0.10884400457143784,
0.13815703988075256,
-0.268410861492157,
-0.4337056577205658,
-0.2572453022003174,
0.15245121717453003,
0.4270552694797516,
0.0770326554775238,
0.12740719318389893,
-0.24830225110054016,
1.1385983228683472,
-0.624546468257904,
0.3106396496295929,
-0.10816022753715515,
0.2574041485786438,
-0.17288891971111298,
-0.645326554775238,
-0.35759103298187256,
0.0028168342541903257,
0.6797401905059814,
-0.6139872074127197,
0.19369933009147644,
0.20786181092262268,
0.7352340817451477,
0.7179713249206543,
0.020706312730908394,
0.10683370381593704,
-0.3987210988998413,
0.5571635365486145,
-0.3298706114292145,
0.4953130781650543,
0.4134509265422821,
0.42223334312438965,
0.35609036684036255,
-0.453407883644104,
0.0238302331417799,
-0.215272456407547,
-0.42884114384651184,
0.19278281927108765,
-0.4758630096912384,
-0.06145846098661423,
0.22207370400428772,
0.21238628029823303,
-0.8794727325439453,
-0.25028297305107117,
-0.272124320268631,
0.1529492437839508,
0.6079959869384766,
0.29558780789375305,
0.4542475640773773,
-0.19533494114875793,
-0.41015952825546265,
-0.10267847031354904,
-0.19950160384178162,
-0.15577024221420288,
-0.6468616724014282,
-0.05281113460659981,
-0.08059059083461761,
0.4792864918708801,
-0.5934877991676331,
1.1041393280029297,
0.25831761956214905,
0.1129627451300621,
0.31086885929107666,
0.018184073269367218,
-0.7005425095558167,
0.04028506949543953,
0.47852087020874023,
0.5572008490562439,
0.022824646905064583,
0.07347804307937622,
0.20010842382907867,
0.4175730347633362,
0.6188611388206482,
-0.2310131937265396,
-0.3462514877319336,
0.3443770706653595,
-0.7979234457015991,
-0.6919349431991577,
-0.17730477452278137,
-0.7705211639404297,
-0.5426614880561829,
-0.5066563487052917,
0.3230135440826416,
-0.3134864866733551,
-0.07212971895933151,
0.6343310475349426,
-0.08039215952157974,
0.07344669848680496,
0.31890228390693665,
-0.2445513755083084,
0.2836001515388489,
0.10510655492544174,
0.5431856513023376,
0.03337453678250313,
0.08394710719585419,
-0.7117212414741516,
0.13063262403011322,
0.10668109357357025,
0.8896093368530273,
-0.745915949344635,
-0.39724433422088623,
0.01934042014181614,
-0.1494913250207901,
-0.008207674138247967,
-0.7073686122894287,
0.10042060911655426,
-0.4990643560886383,
0.15884658694267273,
-0.18078617751598358,
-0.028127646073698997,
-0.30973199009895325,
0.4275539517402649,
-0.4927012622356415,
0.9897734522819519,
0.25834184885025024,
-0.5225169062614441,
0.14435778558254242,
-0.6662765145301819,
-0.24861933290958405,
0.5084341168403625,
-0.4245116710662842,
-0.4533742368221283,
0.20844295620918274,
0.5150639414787292,
0.6811909675598145,
-0.5299940705299377,
0.002690959721803665,
0.009542115963995457,
0.040867388248443604,
0.4499569833278656,
0.10687311738729477,
0.8724039793014526,
-0.16578207910060883,
-0.7003839015960693,
0.08574437350034714,
-0.7647308111190796,
0.5126290917396545,
0.13453714549541473,
0.07325587421655655,
-0.28119978308677673,
0.02923707291483879,
-0.025500748306512833,
0.08310920745134354,
0.10384747385978699,
-0.2651882469654083,
0.17987482249736786,
-0.010744215920567513,
-0.2049596905708313,
0.1466945856809616,
-0.13009873032569885,
-0.2919708788394928,
-0.3269580900669098,
0.6309065818786621,
-0.07550211250782013,
0.5600278973579407,
0.0841662660241127,
-0.6065806746482849,
-0.8614580631256104,
-0.28032347559928894,
-0.2443564534187317,
0.6999605894088745,
-1.007411241531372,
-0.0017212441889569163,
0.13147693872451782,
-0.38579392433166504,
-0.5594316124916077,
0.2039424180984497,
0.8441929817199707,
0.6719616651535034,
0.466307669878006,
-0.7529261112213135,
-0.6558529138565063,
-0.7136728763580322,
-0.04591282457113266,
-0.02827073261141777,
0.09678912907838821,
0.7276325821876526,
-0.27971893548965454,
-0.3785676062107086,
0.42969661951065063,
-0.9552686214447021,
-0.7109434604644775,
-0.30959030985832214,
0.23048925399780273,
-0.025588259100914,
0.10554779320955276,
0.8117265701293945,
-0.9405491948127747,
-0.7897631525993347,
0.3138333857059479,
-1.3099819421768188,
-0.3378473222255707,
0.0950036272406578,
-0.2506226599216461,
0.018602386116981506,
0.7902876138687134,
-0.15094172954559326,
0.8794066309928894,
0.3249577283859253,
-0.2041618674993515,
0.3745027780532837,
-0.1883058398962021,
0.5190933346748352,
-0.2493916004896164,
-0.034787606447935104,
0.5632083415985107,
-0.46182137727737427,
-0.8222166895866394,
0.3889126479625702,
0.04398248344659805,
-0.40670081973075867,
-0.4026976227760315,
0.27351289987564087,
-0.8269789814949036,
-0.0032897561322897673,
-0.3132076859474182,
0.37334075570106506,
-0.02484653890132904,
0.3442167043685913,
0.5633676648139954,
0.1476210504770279,
1.0345783233642578,
-0.30221056938171387,
0.40918320417404175,
0.3555409610271454,
-0.3488735556602478,
0.7613375186920166,
-0.6445299983024597,
0.24811433255672455,
-0.00017312508134637028,
-0.43675288558006287,
-0.6278448104858398,
-0.19464068114757538,
0.20290744304656982,
-0.3678639829158783,
0.5762717127799988,
-0.03137122839689255,
-0.1668815314769745,
-0.5635967254638672,
-0.26185885071754456,
0.4576719403266907,
0.5499985218048096,
-0.3361092209815979,
0.6752728223800659,
0.34156131744384766,
-0.12718059122562408,
-0.28357622027397156,
-0.560531735420227,
0.2966678738594055,
0.15001259744167328,
-0.7363024950027466,
0.2161409854888916,
-0.07905401289463043,
-0.506304144859314,
0.22449414432048798,
0.392910897731781,
-0.2325543910264969,
-0.09640727937221527,
0.38966214656829834,
0.8118358850479126,
-0.2727993130683899,
-0.3064316511154175,
-0.5371170043945312,
-0.3660762906074524,
0.14088848233222961,
-0.4208487570285797,
0.40625014901161194,
-0.1468193233013153,
-0.2856377363204956,
-0.6317811608314514,
0.4078531563282013,
0.6557024121284485,
-0.3254014849662781,
0.17891648411750793,
0.531866192817688,
-0.32566624879837036,
0.3590686321258545,
-0.8328967094421387,
0.12378285825252533,
-0.42660269141197205,
0.31623491644859314,
-0.0743476077914238,
-0.6577672362327576,
-0.20506054162979126,
0.1449752002954483,
-0.32882848381996155,
0.09462686628103256,
0.6585734486579895,
-0.2065538465976715,
1.1734373569488525,
1.0467325448989868,
-0.15336787700653076,
0.4145807921886444,
-0.15792791545391083,
0.08379780501127243,
-1.1684597730636597,
-0.2589254677295685,
-0.3288588225841522,
-0.11475866287946701,
0.03244592994451523,
-0.507952868938446,
0.8610574007034302,
-0.6965727210044861,
0.6471385955810547,
0.062402766197919846,
-0.9022760987281799,
0.4241199195384979,
0.35780295729637146,
0.7906723618507385,
0.04877263680100441,
0.17772427201271057,
0.2876609265804291,
-0.11319104582071304,
-0.6524357795715332,
-0.041134487837553024,
1.046477198600769,
-0.19816532731056213,
0.5341587066650391,
-0.2135028839111328,
0.5662158131599426,
0.43441182374954224,
0.10602866113185883,
-0.5038778185844421,
0.5238152146339417,
-0.4311407506465912,
-0.5662752389907837,
-0.26662904024124146,
-0.04363679513335228,
-0.726542055606842,
0.14075882732868195,
-0.3217858672142029,
-0.8602558970451355,
0.3296424448490143,
0.38433024287223816,
-0.6038709282875061,
-0.038306642323732376,
-0.5165848135948181,
0.7994191646575928,
-0.516917884349823,
-0.6180605888366699,
-0.34780409932136536,
-0.5952527523040771,
0.28035831451416016,
0.050012681633234024,
0.13658931851387024,
0.14487788081169128,
0.14285050332546234,
0.41864457726478577,
-0.39273935556411743,
1.051760196685791,
-0.14215624332427979,
0.1670105755329132,
0.11056719720363617,
-0.034703947603702545,
0.19544477760791779,
-0.23931153118610382,
-0.030079957097768784,
0.013170521706342697,
-0.178279846906662,
-0.4062286913394928,
-0.46065545082092285,
0.5912014842033386,
-0.6463368535041809,
-0.7387070655822754,
-0.36305874586105347,
-0.649462878704071,
-0.44082674384117126,
0.1665589064359665,
0.20250961184501648,
0.7221673130989075,
0.01773199439048767,
-0.00999515876173973,
0.8024451732635498,
-0.1153130903840065,
-0.20709459483623505,
0.527292013168335,
-0.23754939436912537,
-0.07632181793451309,
0.8232353925704956,
0.031194742769002914,
0.16798678040504456,
0.47253692150115967,
0.13925842940807343,
0.15844972431659698,
-0.404194176197052,
-0.32425981760025024,
0.373972088098526,
-0.6540738940238953,
-0.09125781059265137,
-0.6825771927833557,
-0.08698578178882599,
-0.2873553931713104,
-0.7789742350578308,
0.11345493048429489,
0.16531594097614288,
-0.24705541133880615,
0.39794179797172546,
0.3489839732646942,
0.3935096859931946,
0.11451074481010437,
0.13763101398944855,
-0.8691728711128235,
0.5535997748374939,
0.3537841737270355,
0.06263844668865204,
-0.05668734386563301,
-0.19720126688480377,
-0.5219753980636597,
-0.5027371644973755,
0.060535822063684464,
-0.6804957985877991,
0.5391145944595337,
-0.07916616648435593,
0.4001026451587677,
0.45721185207366943,
-0.0018429843476042151,
0.7370821237564087,
-0.07105334848165512,
0.5904176235198975,
0.4448317885398865,
-0.8290325999259949,
0.748214602470398,
-0.06644129008054733,
0.706372857093811,
0.46638575196266174,
0.2652907371520996,
-0.1775473654270172,
-0.46175768971443176,
-0.5191595554351807,
-0.6002734303474426,
0.7665428519248962,
0.07775241136550903,
-0.5457830429077148,
0.18425653874874115,
0.3455612063407898,
-0.2636086642742157,
0.14081186056137085,
-0.26512953639030457,
-0.20846793055534363,
-0.011338689364492893,
-0.238038569688797,
0.028964193537831306,
-0.18183034658432007,
-0.12022830545902252,
-0.2362893968820572,
0.7318953275680542,
-0.2922332286834717,
0.13129036128520966,
0.45029571652412415,
-0.30500635504722595,
-0.4485279321670532,
-0.18578137457370758,
0.2910425364971161,
0.5531202554702759,
-0.19830819964408875,
0.18166399002075195,
-0.10504937171936035,
-0.6136667132377625,
-0.2838347852230072,
-0.04591083154082298,
-0.12736505270004272,
0.0100629897788167,
0.0637064278125763,
0.6072443723678589,
0.4732982814311981,
-0.79070645570755,
0.18922653794288635,
-0.3710114061832428,
-0.1282549500465393,
-0.12169607728719711,
0.2022572010755539,
-0.033594243228435516,
0.5436753034591675,
0.1777966171503067,
0.41783949732780457,
0.37741389870643616,
-0.4332495927810669,
0.18357446789741516,
0.4018363952636719,
-0.79741370677948,
0.09298352152109146,
0.6616603136062622,
0.13394923508167267,
-0.06520792841911316,
0.6049104332923889,
0.25647446513175964,
-0.5279703736305237,
0.7371624112129211,
0.038302432745695114,
0.9823397994041443,
-0.1893499493598938,
0.20996829867362976,
0.1006590723991394,
0.40430063009262085,
0.1752258986234665,
0.6429786086082458,
-0.16357354819774628,
-0.36873185634613037,
-0.055777840316295624,
0.02192103862762451,
-0.5073418617248535,
-0.06561925262212753,
-1.1396210193634033,
0.39610475301742554,
-0.3899295926094055,
-0.16597113013267517,
0.29697349667549133,
-0.006910616531968117,
-0.7522177696228027,
0.7868139147758484,
0.524360716342926,
0.5875865817070007,
-0.4515732228755951,
0.7847311496734619,
0.6795580387115479,
-0.23869846761226654,
-0.3057226240634918,
-0.1070580780506134,
0.4910440444946289,
-1.2633795738220215,
0.4824741780757904,
0.1434992402791977,
-0.2685607671737671,
-0.006277020089328289,
-0.4408806264400482,
-0.7979969382286072,
0.9715176820755005,
-0.04017737880349159,
-0.675449013710022,
0.3351937234401703,
-0.12037912756204605,
0.5562583208084106,
-0.40485769510269165,
0.03204401955008507,
0.612080991268158,
0.442935049533844,
-0.09325909614562988,
-0.683769702911377,
0.20091380178928375,
-0.5780417323112488,
-0.22119033336639404,
0.332750529050827,
-0.5783453583717346,
0.3627498149871826,
-0.4362151026725769,
0.05022691190242767,
-0.13296084105968475,
0.3130488693714142,
-0.11831942945718765,
0.4680638015270233,
0.5491518974304199,
0.6131253838539124,
0.5783253312110901,
0.020229194313287735,
1.4208101034164429,
-0.4127737581729889,
-0.03408733010292053,
0.7205672860145569,
-0.581821620464325,
0.7582727670669556,
0.4140503704547882,
-0.058948371559381485,
0.40617090463638306,
0.14056475460529327,
-0.16988994181156158,
0.37813273072242737,
-0.26233145594596863,
-0.18462444841861725,
-0.45400094985961914,
-0.16293290257453918,
-0.3180185854434967,
0.18498733639717102,
0.4582298994064331,
-0.3307570517063141,
0.10054323822259903,
0.3403145670890808,
-0.24601072072982788,
-0.28981393575668335,
-0.455926775932312,
0.7888044714927673,
-0.15486016869544983,
-0.3561551570892334,
0.9215987920761108,
-0.5515215992927551,
0.3363834023475647,
-0.5461779832839966,
0.24115893244743347,
0.19961026310920715,
0.27041947841644287,
-0.5249758362770081,
-0.5447563529014587,
0.2350640743970871,
0.22646155953407288,
-0.4543421268463135,
0.03316904604434967,
0.7320157289505005,
-0.2707405984401703,
-0.6662013530731201,
0.3457264006137848,
0.33369123935699463,
0.29411566257476807,
-0.2639181911945343,
-0.7168384194374084,
0.5022899508476257,
0.3483401834964752,
-0.15270152688026428,
0.5427994728088379,
0.05015246942639351,
-0.0067726196721196175,
0.6360403299331665,
0.3744320273399353,
0.061010830104351044,
-0.09002910554409027,
0.22537654638290405,
0.94454026222229,
-0.47719258069992065,
-0.1841706931591034,
-0.4314393103122711,
0.5991092920303345,
-0.21084819734096527,
-0.14938077330589294,
0.3780939280986786,
0.21203355491161346,
0.6545755863189697,
-0.24336153268814087,
1.008571982383728,
-0.019955666735768318,
0.32245707511901855,
-0.6366174221038818,
0.44725844264030457,
-1.0647873878479004,
-0.010044005699455738,
-0.47897210717201233,
-0.2670150101184845,
-0.638498842716217,
0.5639892816543579,
-0.3348786234855652,
-0.21145795285701752,
0.9175697565078735,
0.7139328122138977,
-0.01773344725370407,
-0.28495660424232483,
0.8678308129310608,
0.3528118133544922,
-0.09325217455625534,
0.5228537321090698,
0.2815990746021271,
-0.3731831908226013,
0.415947288274765,
-0.5880598425865173,
-0.7259809970855713,
-0.8112562298774719,
-0.3981747627258301,
-0.898668646812439,
-0.47940319776535034,
-1.042373538017273,
-0.06654729694128036,
0.09229908138513565,
0.4802042543888092,
0.9175586104393005,
-0.3719017207622528,
-0.22992056608200073,
0.5270166993141174,
-0.46836739778518677,
-0.5071327090263367,
-0.1474248617887497,
0.46450096368789673,
-0.17232152819633484,
-0.5497822165489197,
0.37179991602897644,
0.9870116114616394,
-0.1666090339422226,
-0.43871983885765076,
0.16654853522777557,
0.15151932835578918,
0.08994977921247482,
0.8532771468162537,
0.36701008677482605,
-0.7042487263679504,
-0.0835549384355545,
0.3038051724433899,
-0.020351814106106758,
0.23141397535800934,
0.8095424175262451,
-1.0508445501327515,
1.0296088457107544,
0.2095005214214325,
0.44316333532333374,
0.5324378609657288,
-0.09107621759176254,
0.2913568913936615,
-0.3320182263851166,
0.21234031021595,
-0.05892663449048996,
0.5567431449890137,
0.40016740560531616,
-0.9520031213760376,
0.4030054211616516,
0.10726112872362137,
-0.3316328525543213,
-0.617925763130188,
0.053015418350696564,
-1.34983491897583,
-0.19644670188426971,
0.6237038373947144,
0.0034757822286337614,
-0.6195878982543945,
-0.30925875902175903,
-0.6243811249732971,
-0.2433125078678131,
0.0105447294190526,
1.1054850816726685,
0.23281414806842804,
-0.6362985372543335,
-0.5577657222747803,
-0.4570896625518799,
0.32876917719841003,
0.5389253497123718,
-1.0216600894927979,
-0.0013675051741302013,
0.4108677804470062,
-0.03051023557782173,
0.31990766525268555,
0.5518264770507812,
-0.3415251076221466,
0.9332162737846375,
-0.26409053802490234,
0.07034673541784286,
-0.0820237472653389,
-0.1004585325717926,
-0.08281300961971283,
0.21142566204071045,
-0.03184732794761658,
-0.19698314368724823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02356v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02356v1
|
Two Heads are Better than One: Nested PoE for Robust Defense Against Multi-Backdoors
| 2024-04-02T22:58:38 | 2024-04-02T22:58:38 |
Victoria Graf, Qin Liu, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data poisoning backdoor attacks can cause undesirable behaviors in large
language models (LLMs), and defending against them is of increasing importance.
Existing defense mechanisms often assume that only one type of trigger is
adopted by the attacker, while defending against multiple simultaneous and
independent trigger types necessitates general defense frameworks and is
relatively unexplored. In this paper, we propose Nested Product of
Experts(NPoE) defense framework, which involves a mixture of experts (MoE) as a
trigger-only ensemble within the PoE defense framework to simultaneously defend
against multiple trigger types. During NPoE training, the main model is trained
in an ensemble with a mixture of smaller expert models that learn the features
of backdoor triggers. At inference time, only the main model is used.
Experimental results on sentiment analysis, hate speech detection, and question
classification tasks demonstrate that NPoE effectively defends against a
variety of triggers both separately and in trigger mixtures. Due to the
versatility of the MoE structure in NPoE, this framework can be further
expanded to defend against other attack settings
|
[
-0.07983050495386124,
-0.8353264927864075,
0.10092999786138535,
0.18517951667308807,
0.11604917049407959,
0.5130511522293091,
-0.0015571137191727757,
-0.4810263514518738,
0.0359094999730587,
0.4959416687488556,
-0.18579187989234924,
-0.5828922390937805,
-0.578205943107605,
-0.04873005673289299,
-0.45151326060295105,
1.1352307796478271,
0.45566025376319885,
-0.48416465520858765,
0.1487177163362503,
0.019506728276610374,
-0.3957453966140747,
-0.5542377829551697,
-0.6606271862983704,
-0.09302579611539841,
0.631607174873352,
0.4982201159000397,
0.49148327112197876,
0.0942700058221817,
0.4252535104751587,
0.2445748746395111,
0.276826947927475,
-0.034100115299224854,
-0.3071807622909546,
0.47779616713523865,
-0.25070369243621826,
-0.8059812188148499,
-0.6939665079116821,
-0.270874947309494,
0.16478756070137024,
-0.07089518010616302,
-0.2205323576927185,
-0.24003846943378448,
-0.06803152710199356,
0.41502776741981506,
-0.8600069880485535,
-0.442643940448761,
-1.3234665393829346,
0.16646257042884827,
-0.015821469947695732,
-0.0567510724067688,
-0.6423347592353821,
0.18727394938468933,
-0.0823805034160614,
-0.5171715617179871,
0.09509499371051788,
0.32738205790519714,
0.5106668472290039,
0.14204730093479156,
-0.35146504640579224,
0.2612420618534088,
-0.2643432915210724,
0.884054958820343,
-0.8969762921333313,
0.2760859727859497,
-0.018863797187805176,
0.08481770008802414,
-0.30110448598861694,
-0.18077093362808228,
-0.6149596571922302,
-0.003828903194516897,
0.07719845324754715,
0.38511183857917786,
-0.5574132204055786,
0.2483823001384735,
-0.02658965438604355,
0.20651400089263916,
-0.7553118467330933,
0.6193360090255737,
-0.16991688311100006,
-0.18082469701766968,
0.8531320691108704,
0.045876409858465195,
0.39171868562698364,
-0.18882891535758972,
-0.9088413119316101,
-0.10708482563495636,
-0.7537003755569458,
-0.16499081254005432,
0.7009603381156921,
0.3561718761920929,
-0.015734931454062462,
0.2753793001174927,
-0.03692755848169327,
0.5170518159866333,
0.33322152495384216,
-0.6112838387489319,
0.10692926496267319,
0.055988628417253494,
-0.24669864773750305,
0.06086898222565651,
1.0002025365829468,
0.514870285987854,
0.11982231587171555,
-0.5744982361793518,
-0.35218220949172974,
0.14253954589366913,
0.6013562679290771,
-0.4993059039115906,
-0.2625815272331238,
0.6754972338676453,
-0.2859403192996979,
-0.831249475479126,
0.029940197244286537,
-1.2528440952301025,
-0.2890472710132599,
0.3845018446445465,
0.5376337766647339,
-0.1454520970582962,
-0.7166350483894348,
-0.00046914193080738187,
-0.4248849153518677,
-0.060220424085855484,
-0.12258750945329666,
-0.8345544934272766,
0.6866060495376587,
1.0372169017791748,
0.7616466283798218,
-0.531424343585968,
-0.508215606212616,
-0.8271048665046692,
0.36599698662757874,
-0.4984767735004425,
0.7666729688644409,
-0.47943392395973206,
-0.5084257125854492,
-0.08808145672082901,
-0.445054292678833,
-0.13901366293430328,
-0.6024514436721802,
0.456404447555542,
-0.8246235251426697,
0.2046269029378891,
0.1480034440755844,
-0.27361318469047546,
-0.19783060252666473,
0.626491904258728,
-0.5802522301673889,
1.0488128662109375,
-0.20818637311458588,
-1.0014077425003052,
0.3360501229763031,
-0.4242907464504242,
-0.6645461916923523,
0.12976403534412384,
-0.5098484754562378,
-0.44924962520599365,
0.016955295577645302,
0.3833628296852112,
0.5333752632141113,
0.14382769167423248,
0.11092056334018707,
-0.6648730635643005,
0.2537460923194885,
-0.17852357029914856,
-0.12349073588848114,
0.6542278528213501,
-0.030498791486024857,
-0.3910813629627228,
0.38371169567108154,
-0.9881191253662109,
-0.22722043097019196,
0.09171105176210403,
-0.2801920175552368,
-0.47221043705940247,
0.05519350618124008,
-0.40718674659729004,
0.257757306098938,
0.06404329836368561,
-0.9566088914871216,
0.1700754165649414,
-0.5071811676025391,
0.18338939547538757,
0.9072364568710327,
0.4249226450920105,
0.47368669509887695,
-0.40760672092437744,
0.5762105584144592,
0.3789600729942322,
0.16484108567237854,
-0.1314098984003067,
-0.8455819487571716,
-0.25928279757499695,
-0.5572132468223572,
-0.237360417842865,
0.8396235108375549,
-0.7799167633056641,
0.6066794395446777,
0.045890774577856064,
-0.48706743121147156,
-0.2083824723958969,
0.22577622532844543,
0.39944693446159363,
0.8218280076980591,
0.3033263385295868,
-0.12313415110111237,
-0.47049638628959656,
-0.8787161111831665,
-0.3363872766494751,
-0.3231382668018341,
-0.15679582953453064,
0.06963504105806351,
0.5889391303062439,
-0.006537980400025845,
0.9420599937438965,
-0.2631056010723114,
-0.14221780002117157,
-0.07080410420894623,
0.05365011841058731,
0.3056921660900116,
0.36989423632621765,
0.720250129699707,
-0.5350868105888367,
-0.397288978099823,
0.08648041635751724,
-0.7457137107849121,
-0.17131061851978302,
0.05103373900055885,
-0.13550131022930145,
0.042872097343206406,
0.0761851891875267,
-0.6592073440551758,
0.17465181648731232,
0.4892195165157318,
0.15036536753177643,
0.6859749555587769,
0.3406027853488922,
-0.033253706991672516,
-1.199558138847351,
-0.2759471833705902,
-0.03691604733467102,
-0.12293151766061783,
-0.7579497694969177,
0.559585452079773,
-0.2782561182975769,
-0.300056517124176,
-0.44557851552963257,
0.415282279253006,
0.043883711099624634,
-0.0699857547879219,
-0.14281532168388367,
-0.17172129452228546,
0.22999773919582367,
0.5669695734977722,
0.012339162640273571,
0.6662816405296326,
0.9632018804550171,
-0.5534152984619141,
0.5418985486030579,
0.1281140297651291,
-0.08114633709192276,
0.779130220413208,
-0.9689064025878906,
0.4398724436759949,
0.20616625249385834,
0.3850061595439911,
-0.9803285002708435,
-0.2544483244419098,
0.443369597196579,
-0.4130886495113373,
0.4076545834541321,
-0.298596054315567,
-0.561759889125824,
-0.3843860924243927,
-0.7061688899993896,
0.09245023876428604,
0.33074694871902466,
-0.653190553188324,
0.8570592999458313,
0.3212290406227112,
-0.22719107568264008,
-1.010465383529663,
-0.9966059327125549,
0.2382374256849289,
-0.5323910713195801,
-1.0952259302139282,
0.2882998585700989,
-0.11650286614894867,
-0.46860596537590027,
-0.2305137813091278,
-0.11634387820959091,
-0.11158212274312973,
0.17930789291858673,
0.22438441216945648,
0.06768449395895004,
-0.4750712215900421,
0.27392613887786865,
0.011119278147816658,
-0.18620172142982483,
0.08308862149715424,
-0.5309170484542847,
0.202730193734169,
0.09301269054412842,
-0.5290338397026062,
-0.3149411082267761,
0.9806585311889648,
0.686501145362854,
-0.26266828179359436,
0.6733355522155762,
0.3938283920288086,
-0.3133557438850403,
-0.41083917021751404,
-0.68976891040802,
-0.5215246081352234,
-0.4514583349227905,
0.3392064571380615,
-0.4006529152393341,
-0.581617534160614,
0.7087794542312622,
0.4086574614048004,
0.4125329852104187,
0.4289451241493225,
0.5635076761245728,
0.2536630630493164,
0.7531773447990417,
0.39714765548706055,
-0.5111274719238281,
0.1700679361820221,
-0.11417833715677261,
0.573756217956543,
-0.6645781993865967,
-0.18534564971923828,
-0.19253277778625488,
-0.1922818124294281,
-0.31268712878227234,
0.13336825370788574,
0.5193327069282532,
-0.017224224284291267,
-0.18844719231128693,
0.3031395971775055,
-0.7102271318435669,
0.31937992572784424,
0.4802621901035309,
0.23783357441425323,
0.3149707019329071,
0.1850818693637848,
0.13059233129024506,
0.3312782645225525,
-0.9745229482650757,
-0.37957334518432617,
1.2990105152130127,
0.6812816262245178,
1.065009593963623,
0.13712333142757416,
0.8798908591270447,
0.24066810309886932,
-0.08348578214645386,
-0.6278784275054932,
0.4222422242164612,
-0.009844308719038963,
-0.9586632251739502,
-0.023594198748469353,
-0.18795660138130188,
-0.6808434128761292,
0.5469258427619934,
-0.13437852263450623,
-1.107767105102539,
0.47025957703590393,
0.20326554775238037,
-0.9407206773757935,
0.7084976434707642,
-0.8541548252105713,
0.6662041544914246,
-0.38669857382774353,
-0.53516685962677,
-0.09981656819581985,
-0.6216935515403748,
0.6595412492752075,
-0.13413578271865845,
0.16815343499183655,
0.11369108408689499,
-0.12010735273361206,
0.8718801736831665,
-0.292208194732666,
1.021494746208191,
0.024205967783927917,
-0.2979130148887634,
0.24358920753002167,
0.0796872228384018,
0.377745658159256,
0.2704450488090515,
-0.20056219398975372,
0.20651938021183014,
-0.3709551692008972,
-0.37998872995376587,
-0.3827486038208008,
0.574415385723114,
-0.6333197951316833,
-0.8752244710922241,
-0.17827551066875458,
-0.3744342029094696,
-0.11023444682359695,
0.27542799711227417,
0.6749045252799988,
0.384297639131546,
0.1282682865858078,
0.1568787395954132,
0.9546030163764954,
-0.1795412302017212,
0.5481704473495483,
0.4930914342403412,
0.05711950734257698,
-0.3920702338218689,
0.7059134244918823,
0.0005014431662857533,
0.45253515243530273,
0.671624481678009,
0.4311537444591522,
-0.02516644261777401,
-0.5888016819953918,
-0.1811043620109558,
-0.41156548261642456,
-0.5409319400787354,
-0.6306039690971375,
-1.0832617282867432,
0.035650383681058884,
-0.7471224665641785,
-0.026616284623742104,
-0.4559861421585083,
-0.007368796970695257,
0.13907355070114136,
-0.25156405568122864,
0.6041600108146667,
0.7162985801696777,
-0.28292712569236755,
0.4260149896144867,
-0.5750796794891357,
0.5738202333450317,
0.9584575295448303,
0.03720463812351227,
0.21808616816997528,
-0.20333118736743927,
0.2376231700181961,
-0.10069872438907623,
-0.4448778033256531,
-1.2537972927093506,
0.27312836050987244,
0.11294178664684296,
0.6895294189453125,
0.4292795956134796,
0.3306136429309845,
-0.025939051061868668,
-0.37812352180480957,
0.8953343629837036,
0.19028469920158386,
-0.6001337766647339,
0.4375231862068176,
-0.5929549336433411,
-0.1542867124080658,
0.2199842929840088,
0.15966947376728058,
-0.07920125871896744,
-0.46180662512779236,
-0.6699842214584351,
-0.9238191843032837,
0.314649760723114,
-0.0402444526553154,
-0.005010543391108513,
0.01876220852136612,
-0.3853946626186371,
0.38355085253715515,
0.5507020950317383,
-0.7378671765327454,
0.1677848845720291,
-0.1583327203989029,
-0.04615681618452072,
0.4821542501449585,
-0.10833132266998291,
-0.5477062463760376,
0.0812808945775032,
0.6681115031242371,
0.08125631511211395,
0.2579696476459503,
0.09121337532997131,
-0.07488584518432617,
-0.13806986808776855,
0.4489707052707672,
0.34432750940322876,
0.2842327654361725,
-0.1268160045146942,
0.19236207008361816,
0.15825702250003815,
-0.185281902551651,
0.03602093458175659,
-0.1473834365606308,
0.07326448708772659,
-0.2207673192024231,
0.8057244420051575,
0.6596030592918396,
0.31563806533813477,
-0.2595578730106354,
0.704804539680481,
0.3444271981716156,
-0.042050234973430634,
-0.013523503206670284,
0.27818775177001953,
-0.35481998324394226,
0.14143836498260498,
0.568899929523468,
0.23488664627075195,
0.10587237030267715,
-0.6321231722831726,
0.4568744897842407,
0.2246556282043457,
0.2879457175731659,
-0.2570763826370239,
0.30642199516296387,
0.36205029487609863,
-0.41767439246177673,
0.30085140466690063,
0.0741325095295906,
-1.1490833759307861,
0.6631975173950195,
0.47800853848457336,
0.943978488445282,
-0.4154248833656311,
-0.1493358463048935,
-0.05016395077109337,
0.5607566833496094,
0.19749291241168976,
0.0999709740281105,
-0.04898153990507126,
-1.0203826427459717,
0.00409171637147665,
-0.2509136199951172,
-0.34728413820266724,
0.2691933512687683,
-0.5099394917488098,
-0.07375524193048477,
-0.7015509605407715,
0.10719253867864609,
-0.023798808455467224,
-0.2867439389228821,
-0.3247411251068115,
0.09884027391672134,
-0.03357521817088127,
0.8861424922943115,
-0.9619158506393433,
0.3390653729438782,
0.38421881198883057,
-0.33732354640960693,
-0.5210874676704407,
0.1048571988940239,
0.2924717664718628,
-0.7578467726707458,
0.45985135436058044,
0.044718850404024124,
-0.3762666881084442,
-0.29863548278808594,
-0.6023047566413879,
-0.28075912594795227,
0.39937546849250793,
0.0608440525829792,
-0.6619105935096741,
0.034051261842250824,
-0.2360253483057022,
0.48146137595176697,
-0.5780048370361328,
0.10533564537763596,
0.31734296679496765,
0.20415891706943512,
-0.27373331785202026,
-0.5890113115310669,
-0.2910700738430023,
-0.4304203391075134,
-0.4891938269138336,
-0.05728287249803543,
-0.63503497838974,
1.010421633720398,
-0.02014719881117344,
-0.059103723615407944,
-0.18009595572948456,
0.493995726108551,
0.4882541298866272,
0.43055349588394165,
0.612013041973114,
0.9939625263214111,
0.40968555212020874,
0.23592671751976013,
1.0328433513641357,
-0.4456731975078583,
-0.06934640556573868,
1.2595137357711792,
-0.30639591813087463,
1.1642191410064697,
0.13846978545188904,
-0.08404788374900818,
0.7915791273117065,
0.4501245319843292,
-0.10378430038690567,
0.5241915583610535,
-0.03669869527220726,
-0.2532180845737457,
-0.20600473880767822,
0.2201453298330307,
-0.6539829969406128,
0.39887458086013794,
0.3085622489452362,
-0.14510852098464966,
-0.1095956414937973,
-0.0032012052834033966,
0.12628111243247986,
0.12649740278720856,
-0.1725984662771225,
1.0012086629867554,
0.05287695676088333,
-0.5738837122917175,
0.19520388543605804,
-0.29891589283943176,
0.93169105052948,
-0.6165671944618225,
0.3537636697292328,
0.024542158469557762,
0.18821629881858826,
-0.6643356680870056,
-0.9862620234489441,
0.13703633844852448,
0.05629382282495499,
-0.2406638264656067,
0.07098551839590073,
0.9204702377319336,
-0.4252795875072479,
-0.13001000881195068,
0.5357485413551331,
0.045472826808691025,
-0.24068717658519745,
-0.4015842378139496,
-0.5871067047119141,
0.05708819627761841,
-0.5008111000061035,
-0.19326302409172058,
0.04107816144824028,
0.14470063149929047,
0.17826879024505615,
0.4416600167751312,
0.5722035765647888,
-0.050496190786361694,
0.5911930203437805,
0.02274007722735405,
0.9318385720252991,
0.03518809378147125,
-0.9360736012458801,
-0.8851330280303955,
0.6593392491340637,
-0.6243734359741211,
-0.25871485471725464,
0.909122884273529,
0.5124331116676331,
0.6942841410636902,
0.0047913515008986,
0.9308084845542908,
0.23988035321235657,
0.5291063189506531,
-0.2709035575389862,
0.5067151188850403,
-0.3652265965938568,
0.1029268205165863,
-0.4386729896068573,
-0.8489205241203308,
-0.12256726622581482,
0.40957945585250854,
-0.24523474276065826,
-0.01627868041396141,
0.5246700644493103,
0.9030085206031799,
-0.10378564149141312,
0.08384883403778076,
0.3017420768737793,
0.39919909834861755,
0.5859588384628296,
0.7899808287620544,
0.8434840440750122,
-0.404803603887558,
0.31145286560058594,
-0.35476967692375183,
-0.45539039373397827,
-0.11024188250303268,
-0.9303410053253174,
-1.1407098770141602,
-0.11736463755369186,
-0.3093917965888977,
-0.1829860508441925,
0.21993373334407806,
0.7098205089569092,
1.1571577787399292,
-1.015923261642456,
0.11326766014099121,
0.0012345114955678582,
0.4424665570259094,
-0.23034736514091492,
-0.24182136356830597,
-0.13023391366004944,
-0.2943163216114044,
-0.19009913504123688,
0.75189608335495,
0.6890646815299988,
-0.4041174054145813,
-0.3762841820716858,
0.24071189761161804,
-0.21859923005104065,
0.15612171590328217,
0.5917510986328125,
0.3560474216938019,
-0.9121402502059937,
-0.41502928733825684,
-0.12539136409759521,
-0.10724984854459763,
0.08898048102855682,
0.5442575216293335,
-0.5261893272399902,
0.5459825992584229,
0.9646745920181274,
0.8292174935340881,
-0.24929925799369812,
-0.08211355656385422,
0.7506781816482544,
-1.0743993520736694,
0.37097886204719543,
0.43471893668174744,
0.33809176087379456,
0.26197129487991333,
-0.801199197769165,
0.2902931272983551,
0.4044509530067444,
-0.3270752429962158,
-0.8218886256217957,
0.5223909020423889,
-1.0112860202789307,
-0.257256418466568,
1.1786304712295532,
-0.2838965058326721,
-0.333618700504303,
-0.1563943475484848,
-0.07514522969722748,
-0.06865577399730682,
-0.7728998064994812,
0.9342526197433472,
0.6295123100280762,
0.23317129909992218,
-0.19703039526939392,
-0.09781498461961746,
0.05247341841459274,
0.3499602675437927,
-0.8865963220596313,
-0.08630292117595673,
0.0009850023780018091,
0.18548960983753204,
0.5349981188774109,
0.11311118304729462,
0.02455800585448742,
0.2083768993616104,
0.3652263283729553,
-0.15525995194911957,
-0.10617424547672272,
-0.742414653301239,
-0.2212209701538086,
0.5339038968086243,
-0.21232184767723083,
-0.5750933289527893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02342v1
|
A Computational Analysis of Lyric Similarity Perception
| 2024-04-02T22:31:38 | 2024-04-02T22:31:38 |
Haven Kim, Taketo Akama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In musical compositions that include vocals, lyrics significantly contribute
to artistic expression. Consequently, previous studies have introduced the
concept of a recommendation system that suggests lyrics similar to a user's
favorites or personalized preferences, aiding in the discovery of lyrics among
millions of tracks. However, many of these systems do not fully consider human
perceptions of lyric similarity, primarily due to limited research in this
area. To bridge this gap, we conducted a comparative analysis of computational
methods for modeling lyric similarity with human perception. Results indicated
that computational models based on similarities between embeddings from
pre-trained BERT-based models, the audio from which the lyrics are derived, and
phonetic components are indicative of perceptual lyric similarity. This finding
underscores the importance of semantic, stylistic, and phonetic similarities in
human perception about lyric similarity. We anticipate that our findings will
enhance the development of similarity-based lyric recommendation systems by
offering pseudo-labels for neural network development and introducing objective
evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.6315106749534607,
-0.033133089542388916,
0.631479024887085,
0.42712879180908203,
-0.036014046519994736,
0.125252366065979,
-0.1967652589082718,
-0.7812926173210144,
0.5759186148643494,
0.40179717540740967,
-0.8151069283485413,
-0.4594304859638214,
-0.13522428274154663,
0.10210657864809036,
-0.4626968502998352,
0.8562376499176025,
0.26979705691337585,
0.080481618642807,
-0.3794304132461548,
0.19744691252708435,
-0.27519699931144714,
-0.4606960415840149,
-0.3193332254886627,
-0.3196173310279846,
0.8667535185813904,
-0.06016317754983902,
0.3071529269218445,
0.18830272555351257,
0.6587254405021667,
0.35309678316116333,
-0.029032530263066292,
-0.37765032052993774,
-0.4173038899898529,
0.07310853898525238,
-0.07538150250911713,
-0.5622207522392273,
-0.06406303495168686,
0.30554479360580444,
0.31136181950569153,
0.7520864009857178,
0.1318492293357849,
0.37338125705718994,
0.13818401098251343,
0.692886233329773,
-0.21418149769306183,
-0.08155007660388947,
-0.8467164635658264,
0.3813979923725128,
-0.2570929527282715,
-0.1608731746673584,
0.14288398623466492,
-0.580555260181427,
0.9849653840065002,
-0.871924638748169,
0.4270888864994049,
0.36868661642074585,
0.7804917097091675,
0.07639820873737335,
0.20417597889900208,
-0.6528575420379639,
-0.5125163793563843,
0.582850992679596,
-0.45197823643684387,
0.2529675364494324,
0.1391046941280365,
0.3183179199695587,
-0.04469529911875725,
-0.5675055384635925,
-0.6439254283905029,
-0.5616121888160706,
-0.09065531939268112,
0.3116680681705475,
-0.21195466816425323,
0.008672144263982773,
0.24039258062839508,
0.2762443721294403,
-0.8168116211891174,
-0.19451794028282166,
-0.28304940462112427,
-0.39418265223503113,
0.2831498980522156,
-0.11446663737297058,
0.5582200288772583,
-0.46868646144866943,
-0.7151505351066589,
-0.10611705482006073,
-0.5130214691162109,
0.1055767610669136,
0.6951808333396912,
0.41235271096229553,
-0.13076716661453247,
0.2801904082298279,
-0.06978504359722137,
0.7714433073997498,
-0.05588304623961449,
-0.11124105751514435,
0.5687687397003174,
-0.10585678368806839,
-0.2594239413738251,
0.24608667194843292,
0.92435222864151,
0.4068133533000946,
0.5897384881973267,
-0.5889434218406677,
-0.18553327023983002,
0.39932265877723694,
0.5033379197120667,
-0.12742389738559723,
-0.591240644454956,
-0.44629162549972534,
-0.8407726287841797,
-0.37825316190719604,
0.1814420521259308,
-0.42407357692718506,
-0.44004499912261963,
-1.005553126335144,
0.8119322657585144,
-0.5146438479423523,
-0.04020065441727638,
-0.16883467137813568,
-0.42791521549224854,
-0.1839442402124405,
-0.1266431212425232,
-0.6744489073753357,
0.22612836956977844,
0.8181358575820923,
0.987654447555542,
-0.06438222527503967,
-0.3489857017993927,
0.20184588432312012,
-0.2492435723543167,
-0.3679628372192383,
0.9573062658309937,
-0.4006504714488983,
-0.30101221799850464,
-0.4224865734577179,
-0.29928165674209595,
-0.16381175816059113,
-0.9194070100784302,
0.6066097617149353,
-0.26258033514022827,
-0.2282194048166275,
-0.8332687020301819,
-0.6662509441375732,
-0.1568470299243927,
-0.07494358718395233,
-0.6822171807289124,
0.483093798160553,
0.1293230652809143,
-0.8275886178016663,
0.4926895797252655,
-0.5866956114768982,
-0.15096768736839294,
-0.17086322605609894,
-0.22814248502254486,
-0.11898437142372131,
0.5386925935745239,
-0.25022566318511963,
0.24167285859584808,
-0.19054923951625824,
-0.22047534584999084,
-0.5572338700294495,
-0.7970862984657288,
0.6993657350540161,
0.13156355917453766,
0.5118881464004517,
0.5657104253768921,
-0.12504664063453674,
0.2332160323858261,
-0.6972483992576599,
0.06888945400714874,
-0.11490551382303238,
-0.056455571204423904,
-0.6949646472930908,
0.0011487046722322702,
0.4444553256034851,
0.015404939651489258,
0.2316570281982422,
-0.6072536706924438,
-0.09712626039981842,
-0.7374798655509949,
0.4656594693660736,
0.7896292805671692,
-0.1804201304912567,
0.3946615755558014,
-0.8531294465065002,
0.40465229749679565,
-0.3577618896961212,
-0.09230569750070572,
0.2815353274345398,
-0.3287349343299866,
-0.3625068962574005,
-0.012422079220414162,
0.6111993193626404,
0.25760748982429504,
-0.1115938276052475,
0.5126239061355591,
-0.3626168370246887,
-0.46736830472946167,
-0.5812540054321289,
0.14930418133735657,
0.3595944941043854,
0.5040134787559509,
0.18681123852729797,
-0.390085905790329,
-0.9673208594322205,
-1.1559078693389893,
-0.38840430974960327,
-0.25967884063720703,
-0.29923537373542786,
0.46342557668685913,
0.03215988725423813,
0.030534327030181885,
1.0695648193359375,
-0.41461214423179626,
-0.5053592324256897,
0.14178182184696198,
-0.01239074394106865,
0.3340176045894623,
0.3702094852924347,
1.2214057445526123,
-0.5811973810195923,
-0.6753726601600647,
-0.09137440472841263,
-0.5849488973617554,
-0.5239661931991577,
-0.008762865327298641,
-0.2988089919090271,
-0.5352354049682617,
0.34623032808303833,
0.0044204858131706715,
0.012930510565638542,
0.5110298991203308,
-0.19821478426456451,
0.5019071102142334,
0.15810319781303406,
0.21966753900051117,
-0.7451023459434509,
-0.0328986831009388,
0.06776510924100876,
0.1807953417301178,
-0.34141647815704346,
-0.17068785429000854,
-0.28216710686683655,
-0.060547105967998505,
0.021840505301952362,
0.022405998781323433,
-0.07742661982774734,
-0.766261100769043,
-0.2722810208797455,
0.1617107391357422,
-0.06425303965806961,
0.40778955817222595,
-0.11022783815860748,
0.8718315958976746,
0.7723121643066406,
-0.2588050961494446,
0.6135594248771667,
0.09434107691049576,
-1.0368911027908325,
0.8365780115127563,
-0.7971111536026001,
0.1039721667766571,
-0.10733483731746674,
0.04154616966843605,
-1.2071763277053833,
0.16946785151958466,
-0.005083519499748945,
-0.7114258408546448,
0.08149150013923645,
-0.2574840188026428,
-0.307585209608078,
-0.30453991889953613,
-0.114464670419693,
0.456083744764328,
0.5336554646492004,
-0.45638033747673035,
0.30524274706840515,
0.0717177465558052,
-0.2553994953632355,
-0.14584559202194214,
-0.5436667203903198,
0.1748659759759903,
-0.5818577408790588,
-0.5399161577224731,
0.7428252696990967,
-0.04163162037730217,
-0.4238264858722687,
0.1076848953962326,
-0.03749209642410278,
0.22311751544475555,
0.2587900757789612,
0.525497317314148,
0.15350903570652008,
-0.347234845161438,
0.5544849634170532,
-0.14636830985546112,
0.01489153690636158,
0.23607295751571655,
-0.9035612344741821,
0.395229309797287,
-0.025929437950253487,
-0.06761420518159866,
-0.4251039922237396,
0.3328913450241089,
0.562138020992279,
-0.09512174874544144,
0.17607225477695465,
0.5850520730018616,
-0.012847726233303547,
0.09056438505649567,
-0.3641658425331116,
0.006136629264801741,
-0.3805888891220093,
0.13642984628677368,
-0.6532130837440491,
-0.5143269896507263,
0.5266053676605225,
-0.13060279190540314,
-0.42922350764274597,
0.43193817138671875,
0.30296987295150757,
-1.037827730178833,
0.44677308201789856,
0.4885101914405823,
-0.34872204065322876,
0.7614392042160034,
-0.38478291034698486,
-0.22586315870285034,
-1.0453026294708252,
-0.0898687019944191,
-0.7451422810554504,
-0.9004924297332764,
-0.4823778569698334,
-0.010535246692597866,
0.37993955612182617,
0.08030949532985687,
-0.33557605743408203,
0.4049534201622009,
-0.5009523630142212,
0.31030213832855225,
0.7633391618728638,
-0.07078872621059418,
-0.2720164656639099,
0.17349646985530853,
-0.9176900386810303,
-0.06539220362901688,
-0.29718440771102905,
-0.32469651103019714,
1.0950076580047607,
0.07175453752279282,
0.38228651881217957,
0.3031420409679413,
0.7117920517921448,
0.5865908861160278,
-0.04447109252214432,
-0.6975548267364502,
0.24174195528030396,
-0.4631313681602478,
-0.3630501329898834,
-0.10175132751464844,
-0.43818867206573486,
-0.6255795955657959,
-0.09103620797395706,
-0.7219473719596863,
-0.9975569248199463,
0.17654511332511902,
-0.07397527992725372,
-0.4304475486278534,
0.11164938658475876,
-0.7117241621017456,
0.5240711569786072,
-0.16165630519390106,
0.2243323028087616,
0.018245290964841843,
-0.47550317645072937,
-0.06396429985761642,
-0.3114068806171417,
0.10384027659893036,
-0.2755492925643921,
0.27373161911964417,
1.1309481859207153,
-0.43348196148872375,
0.6049565672874451,
-0.12129615992307663,
-0.06066514551639557,
0.2642826735973358,
-0.04167839139699936,
-0.02092336304485798,
-0.4815289080142975,
-0.16342037916183472,
0.0964493453502655,
-0.016465090215206146,
-0.20129458606243134,
-0.7746274471282959,
1.3131682872772217,
-0.9818458557128906,
0.018679464235901833,
-0.031173059716820717,
-0.22508016228675842,
-0.3170660138130188,
-0.04593460261821747,
0.584502637386322,
0.5526681542396545,
0.014377126470208168,
0.06159830465912819,
0.2652277648448944,
-0.22291138768196106,
0.30218860507011414,
0.01858777552843094,
-0.3666873574256897,
-0.5301152467727661,
0.7985814213752747,
0.12298126518726349,
0.042150769382715225,
0.44694697856903076,
0.455827534198761,
-0.6904560327529907,
-0.5286241769790649,
-0.3660193085670471,
0.2649608850479126,
-0.4594070017337799,
-0.08266281336545944,
-0.3136904835700989,
0.21623724699020386,
-0.3326677083969116,
-0.11709676682949066,
-0.13196136057376862,
-0.40001413226127625,
-0.2298913300037384,
-0.09828776866197586,
0.7495741248130798,
0.8873980641365051,
0.0094141261652112,
0.45538073778152466,
-0.5536512732505798,
0.3570428192615509,
0.4020771384239197,
0.8178545832633972,
0.35498344898223877,
-0.48423609137535095,
-0.3587447702884674,
-0.07030543684959412,
-0.16322067379951477,
-0.9146290421485901,
0.048677004873752594,
0.28879669308662415,
0.5560656785964966,
0.5332810282707214,
-0.06616826355457306,
0.8255150318145752,
-0.5171539187431335,
0.6023417711257935,
0.3560619056224823,
-1.0374486446380615,
0.4190056025981903,
-0.4792391359806061,
-0.2134585678577423,
0.818480908870697,
0.3327246308326721,
-0.35827064514160156,
0.03572971001267433,
-0.23642438650131226,
-0.37520742416381836,
0.290852427482605,
0.4890068471431732,
0.02572629600763321,
0.2525712251663208,
0.6901598572731018,
0.07678646594285965,
0.18579921126365662,
-0.32182425260543823,
-0.49924036860466003,
-0.3939584493637085,
-0.3373947739601135,
-0.5055050253868103,
0.17881551384925842,
0.25022390484809875,
-0.21048018336296082,
0.09788984805345535,
0.12625837326049805,
0.6556524634361267,
0.21875789761543274,
0.260220468044281,
-0.1810028851032257,
0.13372431695461273,
0.450540691614151,
0.45593956112861633,
-0.34161990880966187,
-0.07335842400789261,
0.018701281398534775,
-0.5916681885719299,
0.03206557035446167,
-0.11180626600980759,
-0.18300575017929077,
-0.16905571520328522,
0.5337251424789429,
0.925276517868042,
0.20638664066791534,
-0.4412600100040436,
0.24116383492946625,
0.019214607775211334,
-0.13635939359664917,
-0.4571962058544159,
0.11270833760499954,
0.2764246165752411,
0.18564020097255707,
0.3028108477592468,
0.5437670350074768,
0.482928603887558,
-0.865118682384491,
0.19949404895305634,
0.30691638588905334,
-0.9385928511619568,
-0.32781198620796204,
0.24773618578910828,
-0.11547812074422836,
-0.38069474697113037,
0.2969453036785126,
0.3443615138530731,
-0.9289495944976807,
0.6646374464035034,
0.31548118591308594,
0.9291822910308838,
0.18318277597427368,
-0.28359562158584595,
0.23637226223945618,
-0.21628275513648987,
0.33463048934936523,
0.19804364442825317,
-0.2759740352630615,
-0.5443366765975952,
-0.24696312844753265,
-1.015745997428894,
0.09988845884799957,
-0.15516775846481323,
-0.6660562753677368,
0.0740831270813942,
-0.3835132420063019,
-0.42593637108802795,
0.5110208988189697,
-0.012868870981037617,
-0.6682310104370117,
0.4829539954662323,
0.2716802954673767,
0.41638872027397156,
-0.8342272043228149,
0.5970973968505859,
0.8926064372062683,
-0.2302464097738266,
-1.1015616655349731,
0.15464523434638977,
0.010400415398180485,
-0.2695614993572235,
0.8215529322624207,
-0.006458833813667297,
-0.2641269266605377,
-0.13871318101882935,
-0.18176975846290588,
-0.7018679976463318,
0.852049708366394,
0.08559000492095947,
-0.7513788938522339,
-0.04628830775618553,
-0.13330420851707458,
0.9233334064483643,
-0.6663821935653687,
0.2812148630619049,
0.47526147961616516,
0.4104933440685272,
0.3938281834125519,
-1.1546542644500732,
-0.5188438296318054,
-0.3728329539299011,
0.11736109852790833,
0.13787463307380676,
-0.2055622637271881,
1.1239663362503052,
-0.00958330649882555,
-0.0025869791861623526,
0.46637216210365295,
0.38182228803634644,
0.14156243205070496,
0.3555522561073303,
0.650120735168457,
0.6283889412879944,
0.5714796781539917,
-0.1078181117773056,
0.9343827962875366,
-0.04976498708128929,
0.324629008769989,
1.0385338068008423,
-0.3560979664325714,
0.7453787922859192,
0.15888158977031708,
-0.608509361743927,
0.758267343044281,
0.6501295566558838,
-0.18945428729057312,
0.6958533525466919,
0.8330013751983643,
0.019780514761805534,
-0.20324420928955078,
-0.19916534423828125,
-0.5902134776115417,
0.742642343044281,
0.017348386347293854,
-0.8563495874404907,
0.23161357641220093,
0.024261474609375,
-0.7018366456031799,
0.46728163957595825,
-0.33850911259651184,
1.126159429550171,
0.12851852178573608,
-0.4465363621711731,
0.5019592642784119,
-0.34652820229530334,
0.8409621119499207,
-0.24703648686408997,
0.029292404651641846,
0.21083703637123108,
-0.16932104527950287,
-0.2305469810962677,
-0.5701398253440857,
0.2506293058395386,
-0.009459635242819786,
-0.5665484666824341,
0.13416410982608795,
0.6223355531692505,
0.004405326675623655,
-0.3928392827510834,
0.6245783567428589,
0.07966694235801697,
0.1440582275390625,
-0.2170363962650299,
-0.6256499886512756,
0.03806549683213234,
0.1317797750234604,
0.6314730048179626,
0.18674713373184204,
0.34775951504707336,
0.15400855243206024,
0.5321303606033325,
0.7554061412811279,
0.6796401143074036,
0.27649611234664917,
0.4373936057090759,
0.6343783140182495,
-0.6758519411087036,
-0.7205241918563843,
-0.45355093479156494,
-0.2855849266052246,
0.10655104368925095,
0.002572139957919717,
0.48431694507598877,
0.5678495764732361,
0.8762314319610596,
-0.49311864376068115,
0.971337616443634,
0.28474071621894836,
1.1467244625091553,
-0.5742374658584595,
1.1611659526824951,
-0.6211466193199158,
0.5219427347183228,
-1.1947251558303833,
-1.4682568311691284,
-0.06138976290822029,
0.8111338019371033,
-0.41721680760383606,
0.1582559496164322,
0.28039735555648804,
0.581210196018219,
-0.27128922939300537,
0.1559685617685318,
0.2813436985015869,
0.07181228697299957,
-0.2516269087791443,
0.6876060962677002,
1.3759583234786987,
-0.13383464515209198,
0.4068554639816284,
-0.17607995867729187,
0.15288406610488892,
-0.1572118103504181,
-0.682768702507019,
-0.6750084161758423,
-0.8266525268554688,
-0.0194547176361084,
0.0819023847579956,
-0.041425373405218124,
1.2696375846862793,
0.7195714712142944,
-0.7511858344078064,
-0.23757478594779968,
0.01979260891675949,
-0.1397840678691864,
-0.09257443249225616,
-0.19115856289863586,
0.45337438583374023,
-0.010701066814363003,
-0.34649813175201416,
0.14294429123401642,
0.09311890602111816,
0.4286896288394928,
-0.16574661433696747,
-0.04200087487697601,
0.20737324655056,
0.14584609866142273,
0.36204373836517334,
-0.08275457471609116,
-1.1739434003829956,
-0.3294571340084076,
0.06381203234195709,
0.06761226058006287,
-0.057388026267290115,
1.0246280431747437,
-1.0550404787063599,
0.5123595595359802,
0.8154910802841187,
0.12634120881557465,
0.07008929550647736,
0.17219457030296326,
0.32478487491607666,
-0.439283549785614,
-0.26015180349349976,
0.06003618985414505,
0.422574520111084,
0.2954980134963989,
-0.062057480216026306,
0.20196911692619324,
0.28404197096824646,
-0.2295377552509308,
-0.3768709897994995,
0.27609044313430786,
-1.2992287874221802,
0.03254662826657295,
0.7352244853973389,
-0.46358075737953186,
0.12235674262046814,
-0.10339979827404022,
-0.4566180408000946,
0.021094011142849922,
-0.40205180644989014,
0.700461745262146,
0.4588397145271301,
-0.16438627243041992,
0.3111829161643982,
-0.11089252680540085,
0.6677917838096619,
0.12101320922374725,
-0.10012035071849823,
-0.34442952275276184,
0.32112917304039,
0.48027312755584717,
0.5627683997154236,
0.05480487644672394,
0.10638415068387985,
0.20223280787467957,
-0.20572321116924286,
0.02738499455153942,
0.03421953693032265,
-0.5542238354682922,
-0.15840864181518555,
0.30747073888778687,
0.1612311750650406,
-0.24380192160606384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02340v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02340v2
|
Corpus Considerations for Annotator Modeling and Scaling
| 2024-04-02T22:27:24 | 2024-04-17T14:02:03 |
Olufunke O. Sarumi, Béla Neuendorf, Joan Plepi, Lucie Flek, Jörg Schlötterer, Charles Welch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, F.2.2; I.2.7
|
Recent trends in natural language processing research and annotation tasks
affirm a paradigm shift from the traditional reliance on a single ground truth
to a focus on individual perspectives, particularly in subjective tasks. In
scenarios where annotation tasks are meant to encompass diversity, models that
solely rely on the majority class labels may inadvertently disregard valuable
minority perspectives. This oversight could result in the omission of crucial
information and, in a broader context, risk disrupting the balance within
larger ecosystems. As the landscape of annotator modeling unfolds with diverse
representation techniques, it becomes imperative to investigate their
effectiveness with the fine-grained features of the datasets in view. This
study systematically explores various annotator modeling techniques and
compares their performance across seven corpora.
From our findings, we show that the commonly used user token model
consistently outperforms more complex models. We introduce a composite
embedding approach and show distinct differences in which model performs best
as a function of the agreement with a given dataset. Our findings shed light on
the relationship between corpus statistics and annotator modeling performance,
which informs future work on corpus construction and perspectivist NLP.
|
[
-0.7713000178337097,
-0.6472598910331726,
0.21905621886253357,
0.3027012348175049,
-0.12238768488168716,
-0.023079028353095055,
-0.5081920027732849,
-0.7194320559501648,
0.09422897547483444,
0.5392495393753052,
0.21520866453647614,
-0.559320330619812,
-0.9733544588088989,
0.28904008865356445,
-0.542174220085144,
1.0927225351333618,
0.12744620442390442,
-0.07706242054700851,
-0.2814849317073822,
-0.36231398582458496,
-0.39159268140792847,
-0.9331042766571045,
-0.40339046716690063,
-0.2421153336763382,
0.5014446377754211,
0.24864545464515686,
1.0800191164016724,
0.8310930728912354,
0.689544141292572,
0.24416913092136383,
-0.38631269335746765,
-0.04005321115255356,
-0.08623956143856049,
0.14653527736663818,
-0.1517515331506729,
-0.4968162178993225,
-0.3596397340297699,
0.0477302186191082,
0.6105119585990906,
1.232638955116272,
0.22487112879753113,
0.37053558230400085,
-0.05314871296286583,
0.07701443880796432,
-0.8930190801620483,
0.12414883077144623,
-0.4626641571521759,
0.11247006803750992,
-0.40581241250038147,
0.10464073717594147,
-0.47984185814857483,
-0.12903468310832977,
0.25867870450019836,
-0.5876826643943787,
0.3350502848625183,
0.20247331261634827,
0.47077709436416626,
0.27780091762542725,
-0.4533878564834595,
-0.3762347400188446,
-0.907679557800293,
0.651308000087738,
-0.5911549925804138,
0.26221391558647156,
0.3725427985191345,
0.22630657255649567,
0.4187350571155548,
-0.5874068737030029,
-0.2295495718717575,
-0.11395857483148575,
-0.325505793094635,
-0.25574013590812683,
-0.36971160769462585,
0.05370483547449112,
0.47310101985931396,
0.49560603499412537,
-0.015231105498969555,
0.5008301734924316,
-0.4105769097805023,
-0.17674538493156433,
0.33488738536834717,
0.18222416937351227,
0.11658088117837906,
-0.42837002873420715,
-0.38049575686454773,
-0.16024671494960785,
-0.3646521270275116,
0.04370962455868721,
0.540047824382782,
0.6481034755706787,
-0.06837388873100281,
0.6867030262947083,
0.03593648225069046,
0.7863819599151611,
0.053602930158376694,
0.04420290142297745,
0.1817190945148468,
-0.31744739413261414,
-0.20349782705307007,
0.02497706189751625,
0.5361931324005127,
0.5079945921897888,
0.19051116704940796,
-0.14052769541740417,
-0.2959343492984772,
0.24277211725711823,
0.4674617350101471,
-0.6827120184898376,
-0.1914190649986267,
0.16855432093143463,
-0.43115103244781494,
-0.21410442888736725,
-0.021069422364234924,
-0.7421500086784363,
-0.47555240988731384,
-0.5689885020256042,
0.24892573058605194,
-0.41455841064453125,
-0.4738897979259491,
-0.17425291240215302,
-0.16245689988136292,
-0.14559133350849152,
0.3940999209880829,
-1.1661503314971924,
0.6434767246246338,
0.8596368432044983,
0.8687424659729004,
-0.20039880275726318,
-0.02485593594610691,
-0.2845833897590637,
-0.2539580464363098,
-0.3460056483745575,
0.6718897223472595,
-0.7645388245582581,
-0.46365585923194885,
0.3597618341445923,
-0.36900219321250916,
-0.061014238744974136,
-0.5624587535858154,
0.8392928838729858,
-0.4843085706233978,
-0.1763274073600769,
-0.5836763381958008,
-0.7990208864212036,
-0.23312652111053467,
0.14189641177654266,
-0.8868803381919861,
0.8945451974868774,
0.16695287823677063,
-1.1523934602737427,
0.7625100016593933,
-0.8965550661087036,
-0.1870918869972229,
0.09117845445871353,
-0.0063803293742239475,
-0.10552410781383514,
0.2733403742313385,
0.2419971525669098,
0.49740463495254517,
-0.21260550618171692,
0.044212643057107925,
-0.18436282873153687,
-0.37069228291511536,
0.3079797923564911,
-0.2643975615501404,
0.6141232252120972,
0.40285438299179077,
0.11540672183036804,
0.24461963772773743,
-0.7023038864135742,
-0.43929389119148254,
-0.23082850873470306,
-0.1547173261642456,
-0.630117654800415,
-0.02437659725546837,
0.7817944288253784,
0.005956162698566914,
0.058826643973588943,
-0.5780591368675232,
0.12248136103153229,
-0.1820078194141388,
0.5025984048843384,
0.3652474582195282,
-0.06249723583459854,
0.7968822717666626,
-0.22829920053482056,
0.5194515585899353,
0.08194649964570999,
0.05819832533597946,
-0.31822872161865234,
-0.3260166645050049,
-0.5076208710670471,
-0.5418888926506042,
0.7723933458328247,
0.2532144784927368,
-0.04159879311919212,
0.356770396232605,
-0.2226443737745285,
-0.5323333740234375,
-0.726171612739563,
-0.02156243845820427,
-0.03480960428714752,
0.2711309790611267,
0.5476824045181274,
-0.37742242217063904,
-0.6372373104095459,
-0.9710900187492371,
-0.3173917829990387,
-0.2150803953409195,
-0.16469891369342804,
-0.11891670525074005,
0.49376267194747925,
-0.08526746183633804,
1.265720248222351,
-0.1949663907289505,
-0.17134816944599152,
-0.2802020311355591,
0.4451825022697449,
-0.11170067638158798,
0.5444109439849854,
0.7827655673027039,
-1.098935604095459,
-0.048159562051296234,
-0.2120448648929596,
-0.6110699772834778,
-0.17140625417232513,
-0.1075550839304924,
0.16363216936588287,
0.23695462942123413,
0.3785802125930786,
-0.40735873579978943,
0.46494293212890625,
0.6447328925132751,
-0.21108128130435944,
0.30888062715530396,
-0.15479622781276703,
0.04173727706074715,
-0.8340150713920593,
0.17013444006443024,
0.18257811665534973,
-0.1935688555240631,
-0.7523404955863953,
0.14658834040164948,
0.11389116197824478,
0.1554604023694992,
-0.3035646378993988,
0.3475702702999115,
-0.28853368759155273,
-0.21644821763038635,
-0.21847699582576752,
0.0937492698431015,
-0.1812954992055893,
-0.061063237488269806,
0.01799498125910759,
0.7050196528434753,
0.21468202769756317,
-0.5211043357849121,
-0.2409808188676834,
0.20513318479061127,
-0.14791004359722137,
0.4547739028930664,
-0.6484063267707825,
-0.06571593135595322,
-0.2125118523836136,
0.14628058671951294,
-1.1758232116699219,
-0.2088654637336731,
-0.0791347473859787,
-0.37205013632774353,
0.41026487946510315,
-0.24402278661727905,
-0.8842816948890686,
-0.13312575221061707,
-0.29319578409194946,
0.4138730764389038,
0.20357827842235565,
-0.4210374057292938,
0.6922174692153931,
0.5246672630310059,
0.06322208791971207,
-0.4463648200035095,
-0.8031629323959351,
0.1382475644350052,
-0.47916126251220703,
-0.6303688883781433,
0.4632265865802765,
0.13381892442703247,
-0.6612359285354614,
-0.0855250284075737,
0.04045293107628822,
0.05887400358915329,
0.30409926176071167,
0.5990781784057617,
0.16517792642116547,
-0.1782042682170868,
0.3163474202156067,
-0.036755479872226715,
-0.139046311378479,
-0.031158441677689552,
-0.09936516731977463,
0.5505852103233337,
-0.17458955943584442,
-0.24923276901245117,
-0.03282012417912483,
0.3969186544418335,
0.4972986578941345,
-0.4825952351093292,
0.9401336312294006,
0.8126201033592224,
-0.4840461015701294,
0.3617267906665802,
-0.7691382765769958,
-0.13656747341156006,
-0.3253636062145233,
0.2837150990962982,
-0.32832133769989014,
-1.0051329135894775,
0.8384806513786316,
0.02513396367430687,
0.3324930965900421,
0.6029645800590515,
0.7294559478759766,
0.11648731678724289,
0.6344168782234192,
0.8446230292320251,
0.03267951309680939,
0.5958773493766785,
-0.08577489107847214,
0.10787447541952133,
-1.0150697231292725,
0.07624271512031555,
-0.7087855935096741,
-0.2206568419933319,
-0.8518040776252747,
-0.4783983528614044,
0.1753690093755722,
0.08126211911439896,
-0.20711737871170044,
0.3773396909236908,
-0.5490068197250366,
0.09012682735919952,
0.5479323267936707,
-0.45063817501068115,
0.3266868591308594,
-0.04129820689558983,
-0.026823658496141434,
-0.2036776840686798,
-0.495747834444046,
-1.1161137819290161,
1.231215000152588,
0.538801372051239,
0.4084116816520691,
0.033373817801475525,
0.7001989483833313,
0.27168744802474976,
0.617835521697998,
-0.49147260189056396,
0.16227088868618011,
-0.23222053050994873,
-1.0766069889068604,
-0.36674177646636963,
-0.07147581875324249,
-0.7636018395423889,
0.7625170946121216,
-0.39468055963516235,
-0.7969210147857666,
0.23218794167041779,
-0.019794922322034836,
-0.48587775230407715,
0.3543570339679718,
-0.7962366342544556,
0.8959956765174866,
0.3897079825401306,
-0.16406965255737305,
0.04532060772180557,
-0.7556557059288025,
0.13477729260921478,
-0.15435922145843506,
0.40146052837371826,
-0.2853224575519562,
-0.3234444558620453,
0.8173664212226868,
-0.30748921632766724,
0.9614133834838867,
-0.2216331660747528,
0.18823271989822388,
0.3345612585544586,
0.02643508091568947,
0.05330078676342964,
0.06941913813352585,
-0.27684685587882996,
0.39038291573524475,
0.2213200479745865,
-0.3397032916545868,
-0.24221760034561157,
0.374915212392807,
-0.849814236164093,
-0.47271397709846497,
-0.18404348194599152,
-0.6019319295883179,
-0.0629684254527092,
-0.13767530024051666,
0.35078442096710205,
0.2102547287940979,
-0.1931082010269165,
0.3099784851074219,
0.2931827902793884,
0.060898106545209885,
0.526918888092041,
0.10627328604459763,
-0.20707863569259644,
-0.3021136522293091,
0.27743983268737793,
0.5430349707603455,
0.3846637010574341,
0.4535161852836609,
0.02563614957034588,
-0.08785659819841385,
-0.5022366046905518,
-0.4360514283180237,
-0.05687111243605614,
-0.9084655046463013,
-0.15518918633460999,
-0.9555904865264893,
0.0818159356713295,
-0.33725860714912415,
-0.17063604295253754,
-0.4367263615131378,
-0.609410285949707,
-0.2919483482837677,
-0.38333848118782043,
0.4852614104747772,
0.4797718822956085,
-0.03377635031938553,
0.26712390780448914,
-0.37541645765304565,
-0.16224925220012665,
-0.006050091702491045,
0.009044833481311798,
0.03563793748617172,
-0.36710599064826965,
-0.12607334554195404,
-0.27657485008239746,
-0.08100015670061111,
-0.6920175552368164,
0.2437649369239807,
-0.3487611413002014,
0.4371422827243805,
0.14888083934783936,
0.10747040808200836,
0.4161040186882019,
-0.2999776303768158,
0.8048178553581238,
-0.026633156463503838,
-0.8624349236488342,
0.22120526432991028,
-0.34143945574760437,
0.3008030354976654,
0.7789931893348694,
0.4851618707180023,
-0.6323325037956238,
-0.45971354842185974,
-0.4590972363948822,
-0.9508634209632874,
0.2769549787044525,
0.36125490069389343,
0.23532643914222717,
-0.014744261279702187,
0.27709347009658813,
0.36281728744506836,
0.12052389234304428,
-0.4256266951560974,
-0.16844269633293152,
-0.2127942591905594,
-0.2752603590488434,
-0.0727313682436943,
-0.2974533140659332,
0.11179918050765991,
-0.16805879771709442,
-0.03326190263032913,
-0.17995525896549225,
0.16073498129844666,
0.17273421585559845,
-0.1819853037595749,
-0.0862988829612732,
0.4214416444301605,
0.4815060496330261,
0.6806066632270813,
-0.26558947563171387,
0.4667758643627167,
0.329003244638443,
-0.46224600076675415,
-0.21097387373447418,
0.29416537284851074,
-0.21654322743415833,
0.10369528084993362,
0.5323287844657898,
0.6235401630401611,
0.49232012033462524,
-0.38667938113212585,
0.35743793845176697,
-0.015702247619628906,
0.14108461141586304,
-0.36469346284866333,
-0.2100120484828949,
0.16719123721122742,
0.04478210583329201,
0.447916716337204,
0.39440083503723145,
0.27216339111328125,
-0.36357250809669495,
-0.06337001919746399,
0.017276132479310036,
-0.3383055329322815,
-0.4000069499015808,
0.7383915185928345,
0.0043001603335142136,
-0.18808139860630035,
0.42331209778785706,
0.17304390668869019,
-0.3768315613269806,
0.5302355885505676,
0.4158875048160553,
0.4895904064178467,
-0.07701151072978973,
-0.1260305494070053,
0.3876960873603821,
0.37655696272850037,
-0.036789268255233765,
-0.3061869740486145,
-0.14585357904434204,
-0.6256502270698547,
-0.41659772396087646,
-0.6750710606575012,
-0.607795000076294,
-0.4126972556114197,
-0.787449061870575,
0.25727716088294983,
-0.4940705895423889,
-0.6006655693054199,
0.5958433151245117,
0.0005397069617174566,
-0.9802375435829163,
0.13662777841091156,
0.4430924355983734,
0.9156052470207214,
-0.9668252468109131,
0.498656302690506,
0.9081279635429382,
-0.820626974105835,
-0.4694102108478546,
-0.0786730945110321,
0.16465671360492706,
-0.22433850169181824,
0.6762952208518982,
0.10397730767726898,
0.26799917221069336,
-0.39833152294158936,
-0.31124159693717957,
-0.8199058175086975,
0.8165541887283325,
0.23182526230812073,
-0.4061499834060669,
-0.02892102114856243,
0.21242575347423553,
0.8800731301307678,
-0.6995986700057983,
0.4845259189605713,
0.5230375528335571,
0.3987637758255005,
-0.044475119560956955,
-1.0164527893066406,
0.08084617555141449,
0.15703260898590088,
0.33931732177734375,
0.109125517308712,
-0.4558866322040558,
1.1861051321029663,
0.025760944932699203,
-0.00625750795006752,
-0.05505046248435974,
0.6335213780403137,
0.11896771937608719,
0.17204399406909943,
0.59931480884552,
0.24273249506950378,
0.7371695041656494,
0.1654687225818634,
1.2724751234054565,
-0.26825129985809326,
0.23353756964206696,
0.9465296864509583,
-0.1735951006412506,
0.9989824891090393,
0.4736219048500061,
-0.21734444797039032,
0.2971465289592743,
0.7011432647705078,
-0.023716477677226067,
-0.02470450848340988,
0.13553892076015472,
-0.0857200175523758,
-0.2978115677833557,
-0.28891631960868835,
-0.17898783087730408,
0.6156786680221558,
0.3535051643848419,
-0.6109269261360168,
-0.16217996180057526,
0.026314305141568184,
0.16293376684188843,
0.30275118350982666,
-0.21130016446113586,
0.5573269128799438,
-0.0700685903429985,
-0.4139293432235718,
0.09591981023550034,
0.22053265571594238,
0.8047052621841431,
-0.19133201241493225,
0.1794450581073761,
-0.1105828508734703,
0.05599004775285721,
-0.31903043389320374,
-0.5909576416015625,
0.507719099521637,
0.20411692559719086,
-0.3315623998641968,
-0.16032594442367554,
0.7088308334350586,
-0.08365093171596527,
-0.5675095319747925,
0.23264683783054352,
0.3300398588180542,
0.07323940098285675,
-0.09404529631137848,
-0.06839624047279358,
0.48801755905151367,
-0.40618979930877686,
-0.05384720489382744,
0.27052372694015503,
0.43680667877197266,
-0.325155109167099,
0.2035476118326187,
0.42162448167800903,
-0.0684560239315033,
0.0949099063873291,
0.1825527846813202,
0.792391300201416,
-0.5653337836265564,
-0.16181853413581848,
-0.90225750207901,
0.4401439428329468,
-0.28360068798065186,
-0.5862056016921997,
0.9019972085952759,
0.6556731462478638,
0.8890216946601868,
0.05161966383457184,
0.674514889717102,
0.058888837695121765,
0.6035078167915344,
-0.16490130126476288,
0.535118043422699,
-0.11616501957178116,
0.1481441706418991,
-0.43904680013656616,
-0.9682993292808533,
-0.701263964176178,
0.6665270328521729,
-0.5770957469940186,
0.09760777652263641,
0.3301749527454376,
0.2797875702381134,
0.07545043528079987,
0.5336679816246033,
0.3380371928215027,
-0.022922269999980927,
0.4419393241405487,
0.041815921664237976,
0.7473635673522949,
-0.37989622354507446,
0.18621370196342468,
-0.2033928781747818,
-0.07859168201684952,
-0.4407963454723358,
-0.7291269302368164,
-0.9361047744750977,
-0.6936482787132263,
-0.4404839277267456,
0.09005044400691986,
-0.32541531324386597,
1.2128846645355225,
0.9357507824897766,
-0.7083871364593506,
-0.128438338637352,
0.1945648193359375,
-0.14771153032779694,
-0.1051744893193245,
-0.18823204934597015,
0.17648197710514069,
-0.48582062125205994,
-0.7845996618270874,
-0.30899176001548767,
0.1712716668844223,
-0.08453308045864105,
-0.6045979857444763,
0.36767321825027466,
-0.025144068524241447,
0.13724122941493988,
0.6511847972869873,
0.006784163881093264,
-0.8815938830375671,
-0.41350263357162476,
-0.20133990049362183,
-0.23098190128803253,
0.20700521767139435,
0.8348109126091003,
-0.7016826868057251,
0.4539257884025574,
0.29339292645454407,
0.6350855827331543,
0.6933857798576355,
0.0343455895781517,
0.30579283833503723,
-0.6641151905059814,
0.120478056371212,
0.3598296344280243,
0.30556973814964294,
0.8109807372093201,
-0.12686777114868164,
0.6653399467468262,
-0.06730066239833832,
-0.41740602254867554,
-0.7867199182510376,
-0.13255035877227783,
-0.9426776170730591,
-0.15412934124469757,
1.1198862791061401,
-0.04136477783322334,
-0.13988350331783295,
-0.1800660490989685,
-0.3208152949810028,
0.1147763803601265,
-0.44932907819747925,
0.44287511706352234,
1.0118333101272583,
-0.11507322639226913,
-0.039426300674676895,
-0.717922568321228,
0.29556575417518616,
0.290377140045166,
-0.36229854822158813,
0.29777762293815613,
0.36106786131858826,
0.28936633467674255,
0.7286600470542908,
0.38294440507888794,
-0.21526847779750824,
-0.11280247569084167,
0.3794194459915161,
0.15739350020885468,
0.0664568692445755,
-0.05204296484589577,
-0.3134223520755768,
0.7052590847015381,
0.4118969440460205,
0.0221395306289196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02335v1
|
Multi-BERT: Leveraging Adapters and Prompt Tuning for Low-Resource Multi-Domain Adaptation
| 2024-04-02T22:15:48 | 2024-04-02T22:15:48 |
Parham Abed Azad, Hamid Beigy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid expansion of texts' volume and diversity presents formidable
challenges in multi-domain settings. These challenges are also visible in the
Persian name entity recognition (NER) settings. Traditional approaches, either
employing a unified model for multiple domains or individual models for each
domain, frequently pose significant limitations. Single models often struggle
to capture the nuances of diverse domains, while utilizing multiple large
models can lead to resource constraints, rendering the training of a model for
each domain virtually impractical. Therefore, this paper introduces a novel
approach composed of one core model with multiple sets of domain-specific
parameters. We utilize techniques such as prompt tuning and adapters, combined
with the incorporation of additional layers, to add parameters that we can
train for the specific domains. This enables the model to perform comparably to
individual models for each domain. Experimental results on different formal and
informal datasets show that by employing these added parameters, the proposed
model significantly surpasses existing practical models in performance.
Remarkably, the proposed model requires only one instance for training and
storage, yet achieves outstanding results across all domains, even surpassing
the state-of-the-art in some. Moreover, we analyze each adaptation strategy,
delineating its strengths, weaknesses, and optimal hyper-parameters for the
Persian NER settings. Finally, we introduce a document-based domain detection
pipeline tailored for scenarios with unknown text domains, enhancing the
adaptability and practicality of this paper in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.7743253707885742,
-0.6206092238426208,
0.5011730790138245,
0.08084989339113235,
-0.22626757621765137,
0.04616205394268036,
-0.6161947846412659,
-0.316940039396286,
-0.06757524609565735,
0.3862318694591522,
-0.734318733215332,
-0.34068143367767334,
-0.7181838154792786,
0.3504798114299774,
-0.05725492909550667,
1.3705543279647827,
0.0823221504688263,
-0.05246821418404579,
0.3027220666408539,
-0.3326837122440338,
-0.7020722031593323,
-0.6083242893218994,
-0.6608749032020569,
0.1040569394826889,
0.5291863679885864,
0.6962836980819702,
0.47987672686576843,
0.28931447863578796,
0.3120739459991455,
0.2591821253299713,
0.08669836074113846,
0.6432555913925171,
-0.28806012868881226,
0.23996765911579132,
-0.29885968565940857,
0.11075881868600845,
-0.2456454634666443,
-0.33033910393714905,
0.893434464931488,
0.3167370557785034,
-0.106728695333004,
0.013026085682213306,
0.09848236292600632,
0.6673225164413452,
-0.5295236110687256,
-0.3332442045211792,
-0.951414942741394,
-0.3564789295196533,
-0.23771722614765167,
-0.10404162108898163,
-0.5856179594993591,
-0.25154832005500793,
0.46345221996307373,
-0.9476439952850342,
0.49512937664985657,
0.30099695920944214,
1.1003985404968262,
0.019110074266791344,
-0.40459775924682617,
-0.32220256328582764,
-0.8615922927856445,
1.0630078315734863,
-0.5768522620201111,
0.4142710268497467,
0.1939256489276886,
0.4457175135612488,
-0.21893168985843658,
-0.4002855122089386,
-0.7159128785133362,
0.22527989745140076,
0.04890402406454086,
-0.09136717766523361,
-0.06913280487060547,
-0.2619636654853821,
0.16629259288311005,
0.015600282698869705,
-0.5191994905471802,
0.0804191529750824,
-0.04791465029120445,
-0.07354485988616943,
0.2721115052700043,
-0.13579080998897552,
0.4365786015987396,
0.06156788393855095,
-0.5747000575065613,
-0.20055513083934784,
-0.3538074791431427,
-0.04528161883354187,
0.28206852078437805,
0.8682825565338135,
0.024303559213876724,
-0.010954651981592178,
0.007692829705774784,
0.6197680830955505,
0.4744178354740143,
-0.21056325733661652,
0.07664275914430618,
-0.22564168274402618,
-0.05040806904435158,
0.1331978291273117,
0.43727782368659973,
-0.2292601317167282,
0.2184133380651474,
-0.10229889303445816,
-0.1905302107334137,
-0.40594911575317383,
0.3928645849227905,
-0.8079737424850464,
-0.30875441431999207,
-0.06485237926244736,
-0.568907618522644,
0.1603086143732071,
-0.2150726020336151,
-0.9705073237419128,
-0.5870547890663147,
-0.39537516236305237,
0.6067290902137756,
-0.8881393074989319,
-0.17262662947177887,
-0.03280479460954666,
-0.12546144425868988,
0.3537466526031494,
0.7091429829597473,
-1.0260483026504517,
0.5524606704711914,
0.2453678697347641,
0.7075894474983215,
-0.23438997566699982,
-0.29318878054618835,
-0.4706588387489319,
0.11280930787324905,
-0.019052788615226746,
1.0652234554290771,
-0.7147834300994873,
-0.36327865719795227,
-0.17179349064826965,
0.10491761565208435,
-0.4349499046802521,
-0.23885998129844666,
0.9140836000442505,
-0.8359956741333008,
0.20112241804599762,
-0.3009948134422302,
-0.5173777341842651,
-0.46229133009910583,
0.18929040431976318,
-0.7921290993690491,
0.9479548335075378,
0.18635787069797516,
-0.6339517831802368,
0.340044766664505,
-0.710834801197052,
-0.4547536373138428,
0.13613292574882507,
0.1316576600074768,
-0.6653991341590881,
0.21192684769630432,
0.6285861730575562,
0.42080172896385193,
-0.4986555278301239,
0.0978773757815361,
-0.13040314614772797,
-0.06833692640066147,
0.15728771686553955,
-0.4489043354988098,
0.6234654784202576,
0.04813022539019585,
-0.026255812495946884,
-0.05730687826871872,
-0.9512491822242737,
0.18617458641529083,
-0.01000013668090105,
-0.43704357743263245,
-0.715114951133728,
0.2364119291305542,
0.4089410901069641,
0.17349842190742493,
0.06879366934299469,
-0.3928947448730469,
0.3038347065448761,
-0.2454819232225418,
0.21730363368988037,
0.6848350763320923,
0.23207519948482513,
0.5198677778244019,
-0.42965367436408997,
0.3161938190460205,
0.12780342996120453,
0.07855449616909027,
-0.23796045780181885,
-0.45687904953956604,
-0.724685788154602,
-0.585360050201416,
0.7641077041625977,
0.4634692668914795,
-0.7950548529624939,
0.2717863619327545,
-0.33044612407684326,
-0.7017719149589539,
-0.547625720500946,
0.09555494040250778,
0.2799924910068512,
0.4599836468696594,
0.6481917500495911,
-0.3017561733722687,
-0.3702453672885895,
-0.7698724269866943,
-0.33801963925361633,
0.079073965549469,
0.2856210470199585,
0.7392487525939941,
0.5595459342002869,
-0.025530053302645683,
0.7084444165229797,
-0.2870546579360962,
-0.5620818734169006,
-0.3413170278072357,
0.1850326657295227,
0.5408037304878235,
0.5463200807571411,
0.7174206972122192,
-0.9605112075805664,
-0.7793370485305786,
0.19207999110221863,
-0.32225245237350464,
0.18251913785934448,
-0.5126957297325134,
-0.36382097005844116,
0.03908136114478111,
-0.1216234415769577,
-0.205253005027771,
0.1042984202504158,
0.518287718296051,
-0.23366093635559082,
0.6636072397232056,
-0.3507769703865051,
0.15759935975074768,
-1.1680999994277954,
-0.08824639767408371,
0.2800658941268921,
-0.08515018969774246,
-0.975435197353363,
-0.022267986088991165,
0.3868969976902008,
-0.10412361472845078,
-0.29364895820617676,
0.7498116493225098,
-0.770718514919281,
0.26536092162132263,
-0.29777559638023376,
0.04398340359330177,
0.1401321291923523,
0.6582107543945312,
0.24094390869140625,
1.0413540601730347,
0.6510128378868103,
-1.0730488300323486,
0.035991325974464417,
0.5721133947372437,
-0.3351004421710968,
0.770973801612854,
-0.3936780095100403,
0.08643627911806107,
-0.15145975351333618,
0.12820446491241455,
-0.6084485650062561,
-0.11561860889196396,
0.13171520829200745,
-0.4298820495605469,
0.3739347755908966,
-0.3609563112258911,
-0.5231640934944153,
-0.049314577132463455,
-0.21705061197280884,
0.4612933099269867,
0.4272911548614502,
-0.8875811100006104,
1.1460493803024292,
0.2571762204170227,
-0.4030420482158661,
-0.4936608076095581,
-0.12390276044607162,
0.10223010927438736,
-0.31929028034210205,
-0.4947311580181122,
0.7025949954986572,
-0.21709175407886505,
0.2548705041408539,
-0.07512512803077698,
-0.07974909991025925,
-0.5971458554267883,
0.22452157735824585,
0.07115726172924042,
0.3518875539302826,
-0.49066418409347534,
0.3712484538555145,
0.3767024874687195,
0.09421803802251816,
-0.4628742039203644,
-0.5145753026008606,
0.17164400219917297,
-0.04709916189312935,
-0.04839776083827019,
-0.38268962502479553,
0.566152811050415,
0.4475012421607971,
-0.4246080219745636,
0.9730720520019531,
0.6628016233444214,
-0.5574319362640381,
-0.6859666705131531,
-0.42329075932502747,
-0.0398346446454525,
-0.46183791756629944,
0.19109712541103363,
-0.6706905364990234,
-0.5689857006072998,
0.403643935918808,
-0.6389357447624207,
-0.0008903896086849272,
0.47505828738212585,
0.7011507749557495,
0.052154846489429474,
0.6865130662918091,
0.935431182384491,
-0.07292069494724274,
0.49186474084854126,
0.16094914078712463,
0.3914123773574829,
-1.189782977104187,
0.05716047063469887,
-0.8027151823043823,
-0.3127169907093048,
-0.4963452219963074,
-0.27789583802223206,
0.5243550539016724,
0.037506554275751114,
-0.16397522389888763,
0.503918468952179,
-0.6490848064422607,
0.6593464016914368,
0.686796247959137,
0.19229544699192047,
0.18965062499046326,
0.015061757527291775,
-0.11091546714305878,
-0.2296866476535797,
-0.6950780749320984,
-0.4698123335838318,
0.969253420829773,
0.0007604545098729432,
0.7290016412734985,
0.5078427791595459,
0.5965068340301514,
0.49991047382354736,
0.10237511247396469,
-0.7399356365203857,
0.14498770236968994,
-0.4446904957294464,
-0.7339596748352051,
-0.38871943950653076,
-0.02178855799138546,
-0.8137673735618591,
0.4954318106174469,
-0.4853861629962921,
-0.5121759176254272,
0.7405433058738708,
-0.012163824401795864,
-0.5939162373542786,
0.3850979804992676,
-0.7007164359092712,
0.751573920249939,
-0.3661952614784241,
-0.17933626472949982,
0.07623054832220078,
-0.5290845632553101,
0.15742981433868408,
-0.6236296892166138,
0.34868374466896057,
-0.2695678174495697,
-0.03306550905108452,
0.6068625450134277,
-0.06210775300860405,
0.708379328250885,
-0.23464305698871613,
0.07741138339042664,
0.16889414191246033,
-0.0777338519692421,
0.5714744925498962,
0.161283940076828,
-0.22697190940380096,
0.02071719989180565,
-0.007076953072100878,
-0.45461001992225647,
-0.36271941661834717,
0.7172984480857849,
-1.1568797826766968,
-0.3288037180900574,
-0.5667994022369385,
-0.6007071137428284,
-0.4467173218727112,
0.5461658835411072,
-0.01161189004778862,
0.5452238321304321,
-0.4658583402633667,
-0.10564170777797699,
1.0424927473068237,
-0.55557781457901,
0.5569222569465637,
0.8055906295776367,
0.27312660217285156,
-0.3332632780075073,
1.1247477531433105,
-0.322712242603302,
-0.018824025988578796,
0.39535191655158997,
0.006195393390953541,
-0.09428130090236664,
-0.5688332319259644,
-0.8029531836509705,
0.20204052329063416,
-0.5779817700386047,
-0.47153306007385254,
-0.6199519634246826,
-0.2658878266811371,
-0.235506072640419,
-0.04821879789233208,
-0.10905209928750992,
-0.3271159827709198,
-0.6229925751686096,
0.5534761548042297,
0.5133370757102966,
0.36864912509918213,
0.18982431292533875,
0.543887734413147,
-1.1047652959823608,
0.49149253964424133,
0.20416788756847382,
0.37031587958335876,
0.028753362596035004,
-0.8590181469917297,
-0.48075443506240845,
-0.2642006278038025,
-0.27035006880760193,
-1.02659273147583,
0.6076086759567261,
1.066457986831665,
0.5377163290977478,
0.23403429985046387,
0.3330681622028351,
0.583703339099884,
-0.9811390042304993,
0.4875938892364502,
-0.21649333834648132,
-1.0444117784500122,
0.6730620861053467,
-0.3431397080421448,
0.10884936898946762,
0.5770667791366577,
0.6261800527572632,
-0.47272783517837524,
0.1165785938501358,
-0.3473218083381653,
-0.7710944414138794,
0.9758662581443787,
0.030855106189846992,
0.36201196908950806,
0.26551273465156555,
0.43126776814460754,
0.4488149881362915,
-0.12444142997264862,
-0.4970667064189911,
-0.2384355664253235,
-0.08584553748369217,
-0.18332253396511078,
0.2650146484375,
-0.20287376642227173,
-0.0010788944782689214,
-0.11098984628915787,
1.090809941291809,
-0.3232477009296417,
0.2729145884513855,
0.1999737173318863,
-0.4465557336807251,
0.07868881523609161,
0.6453912258148193,
0.5401830673217773,
0.3250826895236969,
-0.1205911934375763,
-0.21338105201721191,
0.2888646125793457,
-0.44079604744911194,
0.14170747995376587,
0.29680564999580383,
-0.08035165071487427,
0.3873765468597412,
0.07203305512666702,
0.8606351017951965,
0.22270219027996063,
-0.5331246852874756,
0.3795677125453949,
-0.28676554560661316,
-0.10545837879180908,
-0.22612802684307098,
0.07352011650800705,
-0.30536913871765137,
0.2681104838848114,
0.4766099750995636,
0.4012475311756134,
0.14223189651966095,
-0.21929842233657837,
0.12924781441688538,
0.2966989576816559,
-0.16336050629615784,
-0.3451802730560303,
0.5247019529342651,
0.2269117683172226,
-0.12031899392604828,
0.4668616056442261,
-0.1934598684310913,
-0.5260780453681946,
0.5305421948432922,
0.6531181335449219,
0.81192547082901,
-0.29886195063591003,
0.19036602973937988,
0.42729687690734863,
0.2042369246482849,
-0.04353910684585571,
0.24574092030525208,
-0.07766149938106537,
-1.0805907249450684,
-0.2199111431837082,
-0.6277472376823425,
-0.6346507668495178,
-0.06372322142124176,
-0.7996935844421387,
0.3895650804042816,
-0.5731238126754761,
-0.314799964427948,
0.3856874406337738,
0.057180989533662796,
-0.7536876201629639,
0.2635623812675476,
0.23880070447921753,
0.9396077394485474,
-0.7130023837089539,
1.14509916305542,
0.896272599697113,
-0.1928723156452179,
-0.5230714082717896,
0.10766877979040146,
-0.037500571459531784,
-0.7047317624092102,
0.48071056604385376,
-0.10970357060432434,
-0.029332419857382774,
0.1981145143508911,
-0.21344444155693054,
-1.1573803424835205,
0.8488394021987915,
-0.07547270506620407,
-0.6798558235168457,
-0.04298611730337143,
-0.4654811918735504,
0.41918787360191345,
-0.4385997951030731,
0.08934693783521652,
0.38977786898612976,
0.5420997738838196,
-0.3135882019996643,
-0.8629710674285889,
0.08592390269041061,
-0.16411057114601135,
0.3093957006931305,
0.36886125802993774,
-0.5475336909294128,
0.9670530557632446,
-0.3265140950679779,
-0.38682347536087036,
0.27349838614463806,
0.5758850574493408,
0.10080482810735703,
-0.005523248575627804,
0.49087953567504883,
0.20173239707946777,
0.8866183161735535,
-0.033423371613025665,
0.828733503818512,
-0.5238177180290222,
0.2911836504936218,
1.2460129261016846,
-0.5250959396362305,
0.806821882724762,
0.23274563252925873,
-0.07036363333463669,
0.7508255839347839,
0.5448707938194275,
-0.3085658550262451,
0.8370084166526794,
-0.0003506693465169519,
-0.46490031480789185,
-0.3257828950881958,
-0.3391120433807373,
-0.3197697699069977,
0.20938001573085785,
0.6310948729515076,
-0.2240101397037506,
-0.24143660068511963,
0.13318102061748505,
-0.11405545473098755,
0.052478231489658356,
-0.2780633568763733,
0.8877369165420532,
-0.13649146258831024,
-0.48370078206062317,
0.3356226086616516,
0.406660795211792,
0.6553677320480347,
-0.6069275736808777,
0.006708481349050999,
0.016324812546372414,
0.28569141030311584,
0.08592347800731659,
-0.2686192989349365,
-0.06477263569831848,
0.12642259895801544,
-0.6178908348083496,
-0.18178154528141022,
1.0931123495101929,
-0.2636461853981018,
-0.5246111154556274,
0.2280910313129425,
0.8035716414451599,
-0.13177958130836487,
-0.11915286630392075,
-0.6927337050437927,
-0.11436520516872406,
-0.15424908697605133,
-0.06359689682722092,
0.4523351192474365,
0.8983474969863892,
-0.051521655172109604,
0.3700633645057678,
0.7536702156066895,
0.09564170241355896,
0.15200075507164001,
0.14427901804447174,
0.9810184240341187,
-0.6708095073699951,
-0.3511628806591034,
-0.6008759140968323,
0.2711944580078125,
0.03815081715583801,
-0.539776086807251,
0.6175245642662048,
0.32379332184791565,
0.6591872572898865,
-0.15019948780536652,
0.9767072796821594,
0.09004494547843933,
0.7481340765953064,
-0.36671924591064453,
0.6462896466255188,
-0.5778064727783203,
0.1628461480140686,
-0.1666763573884964,
-0.8323120474815369,
-0.22130557894706726,
0.4664863646030426,
0.12228802591562271,
-0.02801915816962719,
0.6680870652198792,
0.47825098037719727,
-0.11160575598478317,
-0.012898162007331848,
0.17642171680927277,
0.066928431391716,
0.028678452596068382,
0.7358996272087097,
0.6869043707847595,
-0.5858396887779236,
0.5177400708198547,
0.06923826038837433,
-0.18026693165302277,
-0.20161475241184235,
-0.8172754645347595,
-0.9770917892456055,
-0.6446843147277832,
-0.2863035202026367,
-0.11553955078125,
0.29665982723236084,
0.8396642804145813,
0.8697224855422974,
-1.1948186159133911,
0.13633319735527039,
0.4910612404346466,
0.17090503871440887,
-0.40682655572891235,
-0.17938460409641266,
0.5136570930480957,
-0.5279331207275391,
-0.7480736970901489,
0.40616750717163086,
0.1501365602016449,
-0.004884224850684404,
0.21977628767490387,
0.0115163279697299,
-0.3598262071609497,
0.39909592270851135,
0.5008377432823181,
0.3941640555858612,
-0.7157490849494934,
-0.11886025965213776,
0.006687104236334562,
-0.09193047136068344,
0.051155317574739456,
0.6797375679016113,
-0.9604048132896423,
0.4388250708580017,
0.13138413429260254,
1.0672794580459595,
0.1490861475467682,
-0.001966918585821986,
0.4463558793067932,
-0.937290608882904,
-0.27443158626556396,
0.12801747024059296,
0.281165212392807,
0.27006345987319946,
-0.40646785497665405,
0.15820644795894623,
0.06470929831266403,
-0.549126923084259,
-0.6052027940750122,
0.0664597675204277,
-1.0748398303985596,
-0.35905537009239197,
0.7683382034301758,
-0.06144179031252861,
0.10360968112945557,
-0.3243686556816101,
-0.31125667691230774,
0.07183872163295746,
-0.7746405005455017,
0.7418919801712036,
0.831924557685852,
-0.08509305864572525,
-0.16257630288600922,
-0.5122681856155396,
0.4256766438484192,
0.36139756441116333,
-0.8308538794517517,
-0.21735966205596924,
0.3501793146133423,
0.26816779375076294,
0.03194441646337509,
0.44772323966026306,
0.2047276794910431,
0.36282429099082947,
-0.21919748187065125,
-0.029674192890524864,
0.1659792810678482,
-0.5311381816864014,
-0.5089748501777649,
-0.04975125193595886,
0.13667121529579163,
-0.1827719360589981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02330v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02330v1
|
Comparative Study of Domain Driven Terms Extraction Using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-02T22:04:51 | 2024-04-02T22:04:51 |
Sandeep Chataut, Tuyen Do, Bichar Dip Shrestha Gurung, Shiva Aryal, Anup Khanal, Carol Lushbough, Etienne Gnimpieba
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Keywords play a crucial role in bridging the gap between human understanding
and machine processing of textual data. They are essential to data enrichment
because they form the basis for detailed annotations that provide a more
insightful and in-depth view of the underlying data. Keyword/domain driven term
extraction is a pivotal task in natural language processing, facilitating
information retrieval, document summarization, and content categorization. This
review focuses on keyword extraction methods, emphasizing the use of three
major Large Language Models(LLMs): Llama2-7B, GPT-3.5, and Falcon-7B. We
employed a custom Python package to interface with these LLMs, simplifying
keyword extraction. Our study, utilizing the Inspec and PubMed datasets,
evaluates the performance of these models. The Jaccard similarity index was
used for assessment, yielding scores of 0.64 (Inspec) and 0.21 (PubMed) for
GPT-3.5, 0.40 and 0.17 for Llama2-7B, and 0.23 and 0.12 for Falcon-7B. This
paper underlines the role of prompt engineering in LLMs for better keyword
extraction and discusses the impact of hallucination in LLMs on result
evaluation. It also sheds light on the challenges in using LLMs for keyword
extraction, including model complexity, resource demands, and optimization
techniques.
|
[
-0.32482361793518066,
-0.8855702877044678,
0.7709825038909912,
0.13371698558330536,
-0.5173290967941284,
0.3786267638206482,
-0.3588714599609375,
-0.4847559332847595,
-0.1884169727563858,
0.6883925795555115,
-0.22369833290576935,
-0.5526973605155945,
-0.8998907804489136,
0.48611322045326233,
-0.31284961104393005,
0.5381836891174316,
-0.038580816239118576,
0.0002727872633840889,
0.025320541113615036,
0.2195477932691574,
-0.6283990144729614,
-0.6518042087554932,
-0.416865736246109,
-0.4196731150150299,
0.24079850316047668,
0.0721525177359581,
0.6866936087608337,
0.6538186073303223,
0.9137564301490784,
0.23516786098480225,
-0.36641761660575867,
0.1179666668176651,
-0.23867236077785492,
0.35680997371673584,
-0.08234594762325287,
-0.2235322743654251,
-0.2489824891090393,
0.16294720768928528,
0.41619783639907837,
0.6465641856193542,
0.05309493839740753,
-0.04327933490276337,
0.08665397763252258,
0.5811783671379089,
-0.5599491596221924,
0.44532090425491333,
-0.8571494817733765,
-0.10885202139616013,
-0.3328503370285034,
-0.15543434023857117,
-0.16875261068344116,
-0.36379557847976685,
0.31366458535194397,
-0.5027832984924316,
0.04305814579129219,
0.09253000468015671,
0.9709548950195312,
0.22735591232776642,
-0.15951448678970337,
-0.7693825960159302,
-0.23953311145305634,
0.7695297002792358,
-0.9214035272598267,
0.562420129776001,
0.3382684588432312,
0.11731691658496857,
-0.3558158874511719,
-0.82041996717453,
-0.5348281860351562,
-0.49386096000671387,
0.0872378721833229,
0.04768269136548042,
-0.007671653758734465,
0.29917025566101074,
0.36002135276794434,
0.4739825427532196,
-0.6383563876152039,
0.4399314522743225,
-0.3546246588230133,
-0.05571215599775314,
0.6142847537994385,
0.1147303655743599,
0.18707185983657837,
-0.5459097027778625,
-0.23013801872730255,
0.038608238101005554,
-1.0467350482940674,
-0.12587592005729675,
0.11123757809400558,
0.6111026406288147,
0.35600152611732483,
0.6338151097297668,
-0.3050413727760315,
0.592153787612915,
-0.21928340196609497,
-0.28130534291267395,
0.1177619993686676,
-0.12982845306396484,
-0.26802369952201843,
-0.07579539716243744,
0.7572031021118164,
0.13517634570598602,
0.32162532210350037,
-0.6614798307418823,
-0.3647937476634979,
0.0689762681722641,
0.0655628964304924,
-0.8499616384506226,
0.027716001495718956,
0.21633057296276093,
-0.7216690182685852,
-0.31788280606269836,
0.13052336871623993,
-0.9094122648239136,
-0.5859686732292175,
-0.2941133379936218,
0.34057146310806274,
-0.1856069266796112,
-0.17892764508724213,
0.10793960839509964,
-0.15149015188217163,
0.5205118060112,
0.26043424010276794,
-0.5389835834503174,
0.3737524449825287,
1.1393811702728271,
1.112999677658081,
-0.9107351303100586,
0.18089762330055237,
-0.44010332226753235,
-0.18560482561588287,
-0.30686014890670776,
0.6341057419776917,
-0.8031872510910034,
-0.7435760498046875,
0.13751161098480225,
0.08597253262996674,
-0.09526659548282623,
-0.9892130494117737,
0.49415498971939087,
-0.9085457921028137,
0.09666378796100616,
-0.21748557686805725,
-0.776742160320282,
-0.47560596466064453,
0.010020175017416477,
-0.7031910419464111,
0.8628063201904297,
0.013639252632856369,
-0.42525312304496765,
0.23328904807567596,
-0.6656098365783691,
-0.47283145785331726,
0.4621405303478241,
-0.24096792936325073,
-0.14238567650318146,
0.3200027644634247,
0.22715964913368225,
0.752341628074646,
-0.698192834854126,
0.33309558033943176,
-0.31100988388061523,
-0.39367544651031494,
0.40546438097953796,
-0.15531234443187714,
0.49837392568588257,
0.4293072521686554,
-0.42345765233039856,
-0.2523288428783417,
-0.5709095001220703,
-0.12108306586742401,
0.12322056293487549,
-0.3092041611671448,
-0.39158275723457336,
0.15376797318458557,
-0.04596395418047905,
0.250073105096817,
0.15802033245563507,
-0.4137222468852997,
0.31753304600715637,
-0.4423827528953552,
0.6094838976860046,
0.5500802397727966,
0.1432058960199356,
0.1934937685728073,
0.03487503528594971,
0.6081811785697937,
-0.11681971698999405,
-0.23320917785167694,
-0.03186668083071709,
-0.4678099453449249,
-0.3467065691947937,
-0.4302944540977478,
0.6027852296829224,
0.42324867844581604,
-0.6170534491539001,
0.26118823885917664,
-0.3389314115047455,
-0.3906462490558624,
-0.5098602175712585,
0.16638609766960144,
0.1656908541917801,
0.2249199002981186,
0.19508732855319977,
-0.21133938431739807,
-0.21179437637329102,
-0.6683389544487,
-0.27769553661346436,
0.03389688581228256,
0.08491457998752594,
0.2563735246658325,
0.4068629741668701,
-0.24342599511146545,
0.8612426519393921,
-0.6331037878990173,
-0.1795702427625656,
-0.38776344060897827,
0.13191796839237213,
0.4580196738243103,
0.14975984394550323,
0.11384513974189758,
-0.9473046660423279,
-0.34797605872154236,
0.14392121136188507,
-0.7094011902809143,
-0.3419651389122009,
-0.018961668014526367,
0.2948848009109497,
0.11220267415046692,
0.49205639958381653,
-0.9801133275032043,
0.3616991639137268,
0.16345544159412384,
0.12562023103237152,
0.39123594760894775,
0.25748685002326965,
0.10018260776996613,
-0.9385280609130859,
0.21920786798000336,
0.09688615798950195,
-0.17485646903514862,
-0.623696506023407,
0.4259425103664398,
0.06611811369657516,
-0.027818353846669197,
-0.3759075701236725,
0.5643808841705322,
-0.7495156526565552,
-0.2575368285179138,
-0.6911856532096863,
0.45053890347480774,
-0.09480906277894974,
0.14169371128082275,
0.25730326771736145,
1.0946807861328125,
0.2836363613605499,
-0.583724856376648,
0.3142160177230835,
0.26893123984336853,
-0.41008931398391724,
-0.2564105689525604,
-0.7498522996902466,
0.30329087376594543,
0.11342229694128036,
-0.12162566184997559,
-0.929572582244873,
-0.04878250136971474,
0.1576990932226181,
-0.2742200791835785,
0.4074203372001648,
0.1437835395336151,
-0.796715497970581,
-0.2598157227039337,
-0.2204708307981491,
-0.10644464939832687,
0.6449899077415466,
-0.5020611882209778,
0.1734606772661209,
0.5960147976875305,
-0.5183306336402893,
-0.3343503773212433,
-0.16889910399913788,
0.2596063017845154,
-0.5279144048690796,
-0.14289560914039612,
0.3313835859298706,
0.18239125609397888,
-0.557837963104248,
-0.311889111995697,
-0.21661369502544403,
0.082028828561306,
0.31106847524642944,
0.33251363039016724,
0.3178322911262512,
-0.08082195371389389,
0.3357921838760376,
-0.03299368545413017,
-0.012470648624002934,
0.12153086811304092,
0.04723222553730011,
0.6394110321998596,
-0.06624729931354523,
0.06839538365602493,
-0.11267562955617905,
0.3597739338874817,
0.5798963308334351,
-0.3269325792789459,
0.36682602763175964,
0.26292911171913147,
-0.4782865047454834,
0.10560602694749832,
-0.7526342272758484,
-0.32957255840301514,
-0.4300227463245392,
0.43437284231185913,
-0.5444343090057373,
-0.9853600263595581,
0.37540218234062195,
-0.39163899421691895,
0.03447867929935455,
0.554617166519165,
0.6138244867324829,
0.08206596970558167,
0.9499158263206482,
0.6252720952033997,
-0.053508635610342026,
0.26637914776802063,
-0.12926478683948517,
0.26173850893974304,
-0.9322623610496521,
-0.11303701251745224,
-0.7243016958236694,
0.089711032807827,
-0.6219772100448608,
-0.13728800415992737,
0.18362317979335785,
0.20717819035053253,
0.27745240926742554,
0.3787896931171417,
-0.42517179250717163,
0.15467238426208496,
0.12447880953550339,
-0.17310713231563568,
0.36401715874671936,
0.11144120246171951,
0.025609171018004417,
-0.11217925697565079,
-0.39943745732307434,
-0.7534095644950867,
1.1802442073822021,
0.43113648891448975,
0.6777724027633667,
-0.10439693927764893,
0.6318596601486206,
0.271873414516449,
0.26098889112472534,
-0.9945130944252014,
0.6235313415527344,
-0.18927070498466492,
-0.3572808504104614,
-0.017756249755620956,
-0.23437857627868652,
-1.0306793451309204,
0.43001052737236023,
-0.03129100054502487,
-0.8696296811103821,
0.1501896232366562,
-0.5449550747871399,
-0.3896538019180298,
0.012706396169960499,
-0.3748105764389038,
0.5570361614227295,
-0.18501043319702148,
-0.28097209334373474,
-0.1740339994430542,
-0.7255439758300781,
0.28250569105148315,
-0.5968629121780396,
0.20094923675060272,
-0.20986789464950562,
-0.2661952078342438,
0.9335598945617676,
-0.24768920242786407,
0.4376256465911865,
0.07048473507165909,
-0.1391267031431198,
0.25432220101356506,
0.05098608508706093,
0.5586310625076294,
-0.07544445991516113,
-0.11201629042625427,
0.48499417304992676,
0.09886625409126282,
0.20463401079177856,
-0.45505741238594055,
0.6852685213088989,
-0.5772911310195923,
-0.8107097744941711,
-0.4820355474948883,
-0.48822325468063354,
-0.27361151576042175,
0.10748997330665588,
0.2043205052614212,
0.3041020333766937,
0.09887880831956863,
0.2635610103607178,
0.746403694152832,
-0.3415592908859253,
0.7683042883872986,
0.4581525921821594,
-0.26641589403152466,
-0.37191057205200195,
0.8345546722412109,
0.14904433488845825,
0.10864580422639847,
0.44289904832839966,
0.26161330938339233,
-0.5240892767906189,
-0.7381840348243713,
-0.05843029543757439,
0.4724081754684448,
-0.5568073391914368,
-0.43356573581695557,
-0.9534696340560913,
-0.286933958530426,
-0.5954890847206116,
-0.017967671155929565,
-0.029623785987496376,
-0.4033108055591583,
-0.47238659858703613,
-0.022561632096767426,
0.32525262236595154,
0.6944073438644409,
0.1512463390827179,
0.6593779921531677,
-0.9060769081115723,
0.33812215924263,
0.02648937702178955,
-0.15222381055355072,
-0.09591428935527802,
-0.4098498821258545,
-0.14001582562923431,
-0.39807066321372986,
-0.2821606695652008,
-1.2610771656036377,
0.6211109757423401,
0.09888242185115814,
0.6010982394218445,
0.40147876739501953,
-0.25562381744384766,
0.6109859347343445,
-0.25502994656562805,
1.049554705619812,
-0.02437507174909115,
-0.9026286005973816,
0.44142240285873413,
-0.06461989879608154,
0.10828788578510284,
0.5723175406455994,
0.6410285830497742,
-0.49319639801979065,
-0.1397874504327774,
-0.6157700419425964,
-0.8573145270347595,
0.3502346873283386,
0.07125744968652725,
-0.2257491946220398,
-0.16008895635604858,
0.6617143154144287,
0.5279290080070496,
0.6075729131698608,
-0.5161153674125671,
0.1591184139251709,
0.3480271100997925,
-0.061400145292282104,
-0.11129062622785568,
-0.22940438985824585,
0.26721182465553284,
0.0922665148973465,
0.6191508173942566,
-0.044327281415462494,
0.04746699705719948,
0.1461198627948761,
-0.5014344453811646,
0.10396161675453186,
0.3013005256652832,
0.43055981397628784,
0.5947799682617188,
-0.24846680462360382,
-0.011225368827581406,
-0.017043156549334526,
-0.6900943517684937,
-0.11106227338314056,
0.1738445907831192,
-0.019519710913300514,
0.19611874222755432,
0.4486018121242523,
0.4294354021549225,
-0.053355712443590164,
-0.7591204643249512,
0.47435733675956726,
0.09535913169384003,
0.005714877974241972,
0.10522566735744476,
-0.08139394223690033,
-0.20726749300956726,
0.314602255821228,
0.4271080195903778,
-0.567966639995575,
0.5621544718742371,
-0.31874915957450867,
0.09206927567720413,
0.7435513734817505,
-0.14470751583576202,
-0.19018273055553436,
0.5076603293418884,
-0.026839161291718483,
-0.22894644737243652,
0.6971420645713806,
0.028218980878591537,
-0.5718201994895935,
0.5068167448043823,
0.5463915467262268,
1.189788818359375,
0.13876713812351227,
-0.027822773903608322,
0.1676468551158905,
0.3310014307498932,
-0.14394451677799225,
0.23063750565052032,
-0.17708063125610352,
-0.47169411182403564,
-0.5517024397850037,
-0.7326467037200928,
-0.2836233675479889,
0.41116228699684143,
-0.4746634066104889,
0.12304692715406418,
-0.26401054859161377,
-0.39921608567237854,
-0.03356461971998215,
0.6084890365600586,
-0.697704017162323,
0.0034947532694786787,
0.2314765602350235,
0.9866454601287842,
-0.6243162751197815,
0.7816263437271118,
0.6862157583236694,
-0.41483569145202637,
-0.7410570979118347,
0.009072592481970787,
-0.09007840603590012,
-0.6692078709602356,
0.8968238830566406,
0.26786279678344727,
0.11342068016529083,
-0.02507849782705307,
-0.49761834740638733,
-0.7042778730392456,
0.9770975708961487,
-0.28189924359321594,
-0.7498149275779724,
-0.2085866630077362,
0.13677871227264404,
0.3750650882720947,
-0.4814155697822571,
0.2347324788570404,
0.8797311782836914,
0.41147753596305847,
-0.08729277551174164,
-0.8442666530609131,
0.1898280680179596,
0.10669413954019547,
0.30778273940086365,
0.07614954560995102,
-0.33266595005989075,
0.7817859649658203,
0.01210032682865858,
-0.3476542532444,
0.23766088485717773,
0.6758673787117004,
0.34412312507629395,
0.05004750192165375,
0.26754406094551086,
0.18304838240146637,
0.6072902083396912,
-0.10560262948274612,
0.7594166994094849,
-0.31163203716278076,
0.35479089617729187,
0.6711422801017761,
-0.6059889793395996,
0.8994289636611938,
0.689900279045105,
-0.20532388985157013,
0.1015663668513298,
1.0531563758850098,
0.12222718447446823,
0.690884530544281,
0.2297341674566269,
-0.015214258804917336,
-0.15503619611263275,
0.04043549671769142,
-0.46797460317611694,
0.5409529209136963,
0.6946418285369873,
-0.38259389996528625,
-0.25751692056655884,
0.08963213115930557,
0.14642533659934998,
-0.3153647780418396,
-0.22645367681980133,
1.0588080883026123,
0.4692702293395996,
-0.6371943950653076,
0.4310223162174225,
0.01686537079513073,
0.5753818154335022,
-0.48089599609375,
-0.13386595249176025,
-0.3684271275997162,
-0.07445283234119415,
0.00307073094882071,
-0.5693617463111877,
-0.03494615480303764,
0.016185659915208817,
0.08234811574220657,
0.0346522256731987,
0.9326921701431274,
-0.17845678329467773,
-0.1524238884449005,
0.12838342785835266,
0.6580880284309387,
0.35767775774002075,
-0.3389044404029846,
-0.7295777797698975,
0.39134886860847473,
-0.23273596167564392,
-0.38788214325904846,
0.15860895812511444,
0.13926734030246735,
-0.029722152277827263,
0.5424147844314575,
0.5196090936660767,
0.5679352879524231,
0.02460191585123539,
-0.14963215589523315,
0.8427694439888,
-0.6976211667060852,
-0.19189012050628662,
-1.0081030130386353,
0.023517699912190437,
-0.06569626927375793,
-0.22592827677726746,
0.7083937525749207,
0.5306059122085571,
0.3832235038280487,
-0.1123698428273201,
0.9028524160385132,
0.020442422479391098,
0.5438975691795349,
-0.6472944021224976,
0.5246539115905762,
-0.49091359972953796,
0.2525542378425598,
-0.4530280530452728,
-1.2778408527374268,
-0.39934518933296204,
0.4439201354980469,
-0.39858606457710266,
-0.21547004580497742,
0.7503089308738708,
0.8842912912368774,
0.22289273142814636,
0.13580112159252167,
0.2786780893802643,
0.1222638413310051,
0.5237622857093811,
0.31310296058654785,
1.0394887924194336,
-0.43010950088500977,
-0.006840371526777744,
0.030942481011152267,
-0.2561679482460022,
-0.34659343957901,
-0.7691091299057007,
-0.8412756323814392,
-0.5756000280380249,
-0.3597574532032013,
-0.3108048439025879,
0.1986120194196701,
0.9852253794670105,
0.3004778325557709,
-0.725071132183075,
-0.34149619936943054,
0.12912742793560028,
0.2766416370868683,
-0.14446747303009033,
-0.26505687832832336,
0.5468384027481079,
-0.6347584128379822,
-0.6242209672927856,
0.4573659598827362,
0.3935336470603943,
-0.044494517147541046,
-0.18485432863235474,
0.028179187327623367,
-0.06728459894657135,
-0.01866944506764412,
0.729668915271759,
0.13036131858825684,
-0.9406681656837463,
-0.11389123648405075,
0.19747138023376465,
-0.21799692511558533,
0.018398471176624298,
0.7895252108573914,
-0.812764048576355,
0.1761023998260498,
0.5895001292228699,
0.8565360903739929,
0.22056829929351807,
0.06738082319498062,
0.44935503602027893,
-0.08308771997690201,
-0.1210145577788353,
0.13259856402873993,
0.20760945975780487,
0.2967391312122345,
-0.3985697627067566,
0.6589394807815552,
0.39530497789382935,
-0.6305640339851379,
-0.9081984162330627,
-0.05702296644449234,
-0.9670586585998535,
-0.4673366844654083,
1.5858060121536255,
0.1335165947675705,
-0.1663472205400467,
-0.05098966136574745,
-0.2153608798980713,
0.173464834690094,
-0.1414918303489685,
0.7657433152198792,
0.7155005931854248,
0.04136481508612633,
-0.15514640510082245,
-0.7453501224517822,
0.6334221959114075,
0.0991617813706398,
-0.7148692607879639,
0.02417990006506443,
0.35658958554267883,
0.19268089532852173,
0.018617291003465652,
0.3587503135204315,
-0.38221055269241333,
-0.08785030990839005,
-0.4382133483886719,
0.07442060112953186,
0.08231177181005478,
-0.2261463701725006,
-0.6574299931526184,
0.4395434856414795,
0.10193824023008347,
-0.18516190350055695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02323v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02323v2
|
Toward Informal Language Processing: Knowledge of Slang in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-02T21:50:18 | 2024-04-13T02:17:01 |
Zhewei Sun, Qian Hu, Rahul Gupta, Richard Zemel, Yang Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancement in large language models (LLMs) has offered a strong
potential for natural language systems to process informal language. A
representative form of informal language is slang, used commonly in daily
conversations and online social media. To date, slang has not been
comprehensively evaluated in LLMs due partly to the absence of a carefully
designed and publicly accessible benchmark. Using movie subtitles, we construct
a dataset that supports evaluation on a diverse set of tasks pertaining to
automatic processing of slang. For both evaluation and finetuning, we show the
effectiveness of our dataset on two core applications: 1) slang detection, and
2) identification of regional and historical sources of slang from natural
sentences. We also show how our dataset can be used to probe the output
distributions of LLMs for interpretive insights. We find that while LLMs such
as GPT-4 achieve good performance in a zero-shot setting, smaller BERT-like
models finetuned on our dataset achieve comparable performance. Furthermore, we
show that our dataset enables finetuning of LLMs such as GPT-3.5 that achieve
substantially better performance than strong zero-shot baselines. Our work
offers a comprehensive evaluation and a high-quality benchmark on English slang
based on the OpenSubtitles corpus, serving both as a publicly accessible
resource and a platform for applying tools for informal language processing.
|
[
-0.13238835334777832,
-1.0526466369628906,
0.5927298665046692,
-0.024444494396448135,
-0.29676181077957153,
0.16076458990573883,
-0.42358121275901794,
-0.7634685039520264,
0.27074769139289856,
0.20171299576759338,
-0.3737781345844269,
-0.6807540059089661,
-0.6757199168205261,
0.21873009204864502,
-0.8053475022315979,
0.9197035431861877,
0.32687050104141235,
0.037292394787073135,
-0.18914876878261566,
0.32309070229530334,
-0.24171225726604462,
-0.47317609190940857,
-0.6740419268608093,
-0.13726451992988586,
0.2740733027458191,
0.5918012261390686,
0.6584814190864563,
0.7245784997940063,
0.3952305018901825,
0.29729026556015015,
0.16925621032714844,
0.2387125939130783,
-0.7782865166664124,
0.25734642148017883,
0.13585342466831207,
-0.23238299787044525,
-0.3775131404399872,
-0.05024172365665436,
0.5094773173332214,
0.5111916661262512,
0.014578407630324364,
0.2079363912343979,
-0.21299989521503448,
0.3306191861629486,
-0.41690459847450256,
0.20839396119117737,
-0.8748968839645386,
-0.012364635244011879,
-0.7881114482879639,
-0.1777597963809967,
0.15416520833969116,
-0.207384392619133,
-0.20331333577632904,
-0.24278570711612701,
0.39413365721702576,
-0.13455787301063538,
1.0222233533859253,
0.12216892093420029,
-0.04093608632683754,
-0.29839834570884705,
-0.7223988175392151,
0.33095988631248474,
-0.8341721296310425,
0.5650358200073242,
0.5640020370483398,
0.40522798895835876,
0.04133857041597366,
-0.9197864532470703,
-0.46653392910957336,
-0.5145304203033447,
-0.13085190951824188,
-0.10572121292352676,
-0.2961466610431671,
0.10202612727880478,
-0.02306174486875534,
0.6550893783569336,
-0.4663633704185486,
0.3261556029319763,
-0.7397335767745972,
-0.16819337010383606,
0.5028411746025085,
0.11094830185174942,
-0.05496842786669731,
-0.31158411502838135,
-0.2084776908159256,
0.46600374579429626,
-0.4713425934314728,
0.026131469756364822,
0.5381888747215271,
0.4783393144607544,
-0.21890509128570557,
0.6782413721084595,
-0.40092119574546814,
0.5660905838012695,
-0.03588842228055,
-0.12563446164131165,
0.3102242350578308,
-0.3254091441631317,
-0.24816270172595978,
-0.3469793200492859,
0.6669716238975525,
0.3576919734477997,
0.6664151549339294,
-0.38787660002708435,
-0.4950600266456604,
-0.05053628608584404,
0.12510015070438385,
-0.2906588315963745,
-0.2338993102312088,
0.05095408111810684,
-0.1236276924610138,
-0.13075804710388184,
0.02301594614982605,
-0.719569981098175,
-0.36951252818107605,
-0.4426012337207794,
0.14307618141174316,
-0.35287219285964966,
0.20080123841762543,
-0.02306373231112957,
-0.2459450364112854,
0.10655397176742554,
0.10901389271020889,
-0.8448847532272339,
0.6788056492805481,
0.6522519588470459,
1.311815857887268,
-0.10375037789344788,
0.012215684168040752,
-0.5581578016281128,
0.08582992106676102,
-0.24103328585624695,
0.9033960700035095,
-0.5542972087860107,
-0.05789358168840408,
0.042367905378341675,
-0.17012228071689606,
0.21925665438175201,
-0.394018292427063,
0.566040575504303,
-0.4629882276058197,
-0.12330228835344315,
0.3820670545101166,
-0.3848839998245239,
0.18511265516281128,
0.33896127343177795,
-0.5295091867446899,
1.2231405973434448,
0.20397672057151794,
-0.33205822110176086,
0.34627076983451843,
-0.6730266213417053,
-0.44701698422431946,
0.27925124764442444,
-0.15951457619667053,
0.1229381412267685,
0.23136502504348755,
0.299182653427124,
0.5651769638061523,
-0.1222149059176445,
0.30639058351516724,
-0.30767926573753357,
-0.6649615168571472,
0.198685422539711,
-0.5609641075134277,
0.12047845870256424,
0.49888041615486145,
-0.14902383089065552,
0.09669122099876404,
-0.6783092617988586,
-0.23491543531417847,
0.06131938472390175,
-0.1188422441482544,
-0.3237113952636719,
-0.1618644744157791,
0.08290023356676102,
-0.04823058098554611,
0.4061211347579956,
-0.3527142405509949,
0.12371102720499039,
-0.4735533893108368,
0.47687938809394836,
0.8363324999809265,
-0.1951920986175537,
0.2757410407066345,
0.0673505961894989,
0.4699153006076813,
-0.21023796498775482,
0.02118319272994995,
-0.005481865257024765,
-0.29734474420547485,
-0.7789096832275391,
-0.25733593106269836,
0.29827871918678284,
0.32837143540382385,
-0.6225940585136414,
0.163572758436203,
-0.32936951518058777,
-0.48033732175827026,
-0.4534550607204437,
0.2735278308391571,
0.2006155401468277,
0.28555363416671753,
0.24094349145889282,
-0.3902058005332947,
-0.7585320472717285,
-1.1176480054855347,
-0.2517260015010834,
0.008510318584740162,
-0.37476956844329834,
0.37410709261894226,
0.17040391266345978,
0.005776715464890003,
0.9241458177566528,
-0.5749126672744751,
-0.4603758454322815,
-0.3634794056415558,
0.3077361285686493,
0.47722432017326355,
-0.053225211799144745,
0.6248416304588318,
-0.4328661262989044,
-0.22208315134048462,
-0.224089115858078,
-0.36499348282814026,
-0.5334146022796631,
0.3239250183105469,
0.12357177585363388,
0.26807063817977905,
0.8035672307014465,
-0.4114419221878052,
0.22660647332668304,
0.5217511653900146,
-0.22795669734477997,
0.6525798439979553,
-0.034914787858724594,
0.1494050770998001,
-0.5400252938270569,
0.07375909388065338,
0.21616163849830627,
-0.5944663882255554,
-0.5581052899360657,
0.05686595290899277,
-0.5179116725921631,
0.014923477545380592,
-0.394612193107605,
0.6558590531349182,
-0.37360304594039917,
-0.39403268694877625,
-0.21791967749595642,
0.3264547288417816,
-0.2396165281534195,
0.14780399203300476,
0.10098768770694733,
0.6950452327728271,
0.5657379031181335,
-0.6632538437843323,
0.4327734410762787,
-0.15725691616535187,
-0.5602611303329468,
0.0663585215806961,
-0.7109569311141968,
0.4977346360683441,
-0.35556840896606445,
0.03135884180665016,
-1.1564522981643677,
-0.6034522652626038,
0.3884035050868988,
-0.34010785818099976,
0.2118455171585083,
-0.4669412672519684,
-0.5008875131607056,
-0.20497694611549377,
-0.23098209500312805,
-0.0353798009455204,
0.37455564737319946,
-0.11793700605630875,
0.1851528137922287,
0.691047191619873,
-0.3472331762313843,
-0.5250664353370667,
-0.5993080139160156,
0.31589654088020325,
-0.28314295411109924,
-0.4500758647918701,
0.21202506124973297,
0.2096729278564453,
-0.5104465484619141,
-0.09854692965745926,
-0.07703030854463577,
-0.3363078236579895,
-0.02737267129123211,
0.02674216963350773,
0.19913382828235626,
-0.16607360541820526,
0.24986523389816284,
-0.3839121460914612,
0.15411368012428284,
-0.14778809249401093,
-0.09566216915845871,
0.7961163520812988,
-0.132162943482399,
0.11174967885017395,
0.191300630569458,
0.15335746109485626,
0.2813224196434021,
0.21025998890399933,
0.3850349485874176,
0.8831856846809387,
-0.3750796914100647,
-0.0011865821434184909,
-0.5183209776878357,
-0.10818521678447723,
-0.4610539376735687,
0.37011608481407166,
-0.32329481840133667,
-0.8505653738975525,
0.3420102298259735,
0.4836746156215668,
0.018786383792757988,
0.22291623055934906,
0.4334917962551117,
-0.1654156595468521,
0.5241561532020569,
0.5475226044654846,
-0.1410199999809265,
0.543817937374115,
0.011949118226766586,
0.20601890981197357,
-0.23124414682388306,
-0.07024361193180084,
-0.5780875086784363,
-0.43636542558670044,
-0.5427318215370178,
-0.588074803352356,
0.39709675312042236,
-0.11574847251176834,
-0.04914449527859688,
0.1771182417869568,
0.16694192588329315,
0.7330452799797058,
0.5450602769851685,
0.028981439769268036,
0.6104538440704346,
0.07634574919939041,
0.11257076263427734,
0.12590762972831726,
-0.6407811641693115,
-0.7280309200286865,
0.8724513053894043,
0.5383085608482361,
0.8286305069923401,
0.07357928156852722,
0.331088662147522,
0.7399839758872986,
0.19892442226409912,
-1.0973248481750488,
0.6590732336044312,
-0.6533722281455994,
-0.6251831650733948,
-0.29635313153266907,
-0.38229894638061523,
-0.7800662517547607,
-0.19478271901607513,
-0.053380295634269714,
-0.9155191779136658,
-0.2472730427980423,
0.1679598093032837,
-0.29353761672973633,
0.025063324719667435,
-0.7974398136138916,
0.5215752720832825,
-0.1569572538137436,
-0.5329564809799194,
0.021906256675720215,
-0.6390062570571899,
0.6443183422088623,
0.1334664523601532,
0.594795823097229,
-0.3505516052246094,
-0.07641720771789551,
0.550528347492218,
-0.11445032060146332,
0.9784381985664368,
0.027092009782791138,
-0.1761392205953598,
0.1904008984565735,
0.07346049696207047,
0.14144766330718994,
0.2676660418510437,
-0.039818085730075836,
0.7297766804695129,
-0.05252354219555855,
-0.0765804797410965,
-0.3793865442276001,
0.8459583520889282,
-0.5432568788528442,
-0.5151169896125793,
-0.43290576338768005,
-0.5755390524864197,
-0.33949217200279236,
0.0750955119729042,
0.250601202249527,
0.5578200221061707,
-0.19518066942691803,
0.15307895839214325,
0.042060736566782,
0.2515393793582916,
0.35857507586479187,
0.49377837777137756,
-0.3358641564846039,
-0.028782371431589127,
0.38177454471588135,
0.27966055274009705,
0.13320083916187286,
0.19653110206127167,
0.20726002752780914,
-0.6792530417442322,
-0.7087081074714661,
-0.3162864148616791,
0.06685148179531097,
-0.8659839630126953,
-0.24084046483039856,
-0.5365257859230042,
-0.277224063873291,
-0.8940027356147766,
0.09217388927936554,
-0.22058233618736267,
-0.39651110768318176,
-0.027599859982728958,
-0.21357829868793488,
0.5815194249153137,
0.9410131573677063,
-0.24415086209774017,
0.1823560893535614,
-0.80375736951828,
0.5847163200378418,
0.05251698940992355,
0.5987566113471985,
-0.33285409212112427,
-0.6365060806274414,
-0.3197533190250397,
0.009221377782523632,
-0.043568696826696396,
-0.7413179874420166,
0.3847612738609314,
0.6010522246360779,
0.46092191338539124,
0.3899596333503723,
-0.1932276040315628,
0.8133964538574219,
-0.47329404950141907,
1.0022597312927246,
-0.26584070920944214,
-0.9596589207649231,
0.3289034068584442,
-0.5483617782592773,
0.27799591422080994,
0.5599600672721863,
0.44590723514556885,
-0.7316479682922363,
-0.4578951597213745,
-0.4159466326236725,
-1.1069281101226807,
0.6120455265045166,
0.22380253672599792,
0.4043276906013489,
-0.3840314447879791,
0.2816300690174103,
0.3437318801879883,
0.31827235221862793,
-0.8319246768951416,
-0.21406523883342743,
-0.005631566978991032,
-0.059308163821697235,
-0.356829971075058,
-0.13625945150852203,
0.09382902085781097,
-0.1501745581626892,
0.592273473739624,
-0.08953001350164413,
0.3624996542930603,
0.00020268600201234221,
-0.1281006634235382,
-0.0928436890244484,
0.4512656331062317,
0.3656717836856842,
0.5098607540130615,
-0.3563375174999237,
0.3068004250526428,
-0.008371710777282715,
-0.5937390327453613,
-0.23009644448757172,
0.053882092237472534,
-0.22250713407993317,
0.26727208495140076,
0.27713432908058167,
0.6133156418800354,
0.42202335596084595,
-0.8133973479270935,
0.1645597517490387,
0.13287873566150665,
0.00014821960940025747,
-0.5164255499839783,
0.18475890159606934,
-0.22939984500408173,
0.10703440755605698,
0.3665198087692261,
-0.07574160397052765,
0.5409329533576965,
-0.9474261403083801,
0.23271051049232483,
0.38762786984443665,
-0.35236650705337524,
-0.22595146298408508,
0.27029961347579956,
0.05441248044371605,
-0.24406783282756805,
0.4177335202693939,
-0.2989446520805359,
-0.25187185406684875,
0.3329088091850281,
0.514748752117157,
0.6816861033439636,
0.1371525228023529,
0.07444414496421814,
0.34026482701301575,
0.23759682476520538,
0.17561250925064087,
0.13003262877464294,
-0.008578787557780743,
-0.6848485469818115,
-0.5256800055503845,
-0.8738678693771362,
-0.19280724227428436,
0.7803946733474731,
-0.2899463176727295,
0.6504461765289307,
-0.3246783912181854,
-0.1363329440355301,
-0.1488669216632843,
-0.33231547474861145,
-0.8402867317199707,
0.06183803081512451,
0.5240650177001953,
0.8119145035743713,
-0.8296216726303101,
0.5725767612457275,
0.6479189991950989,
-0.20948246121406555,
-0.5332738161087036,
0.1546572595834732,
0.12290659546852112,
-0.7405382394790649,
0.623852014541626,
0.11683124303817749,
-0.34265586733818054,
0.014371638186275959,
-0.6263386607170105,
-0.9748567342758179,
0.6885585784912109,
0.2202443927526474,
-0.593384861946106,
-0.2279309630393982,
0.15808391571044922,
0.7004026770591736,
-0.2337208092212677,
0.46618130803108215,
1.1095316410064697,
0.5214124917984009,
0.21037335693836212,
-1.1054006814956665,
-0.3198089599609375,
-0.25554150342941284,
-0.3078116476535797,
0.12076223641633987,
-0.3329102098941803,
0.6644831895828247,
-0.018737731501460075,
-0.449310839176178,
0.22659634053707123,
0.5910722017288208,
0.1185668557882309,
0.49810561537742615,
0.36197370290756226,
0.19745756685733795,
0.5313905477523804,
-0.28050291538238525,
0.8527498245239258,
0.03468981012701988,
0.08510841429233551,
1.3133774995803833,
-0.10577463358640671,
0.8236662745475769,
0.484053373336792,
-0.2234727293252945,
0.4305948317050934,
0.5789538621902466,
0.08731824904680252,
0.36797258257865906,
0.43691179156303406,
-0.05333836376667023,
-0.05074610933661461,
-0.30356642603874207,
-0.10848485678434372,
1.116502046585083,
0.4658712148666382,
-0.33533594012260437,
-0.4795421361923218,
-0.15890944004058838,
-0.058055564761161804,
0.11560852825641632,
-0.6547137498855591,
0.8041982650756836,
0.03525037690997124,
-0.44525623321533203,
0.31676629185676575,
0.0759606659412384,
0.9310409426689148,
-0.8809397220611572,
-0.1087249144911766,
-0.2523793876171112,
-0.15055838227272034,
-0.28177738189697266,
-0.7890991568565369,
0.4957317113876343,
0.5642723441123962,
0.05441666394472122,
-0.0012162270722910762,
0.9965294599533081,
-0.39759060740470886,
-0.4026647210121155,
-0.034313399344682693,
0.6040433049201965,
0.6711717247962952,
0.21366100013256073,
-0.3212907314300537,
0.02184552699327469,
-0.5458278656005859,
-0.021437993273139,
0.05263670161366463,
0.4376355707645416,
-0.06321212649345398,
0.46823230385780334,
0.5885963439941406,
0.30988097190856934,
0.11197130382061005,
0.4672621488571167,
0.6855716705322266,
-0.40338215231895447,
-0.49613717198371887,
-0.8196857571601868,
0.28291210532188416,
-0.043785370886325836,
-0.37595653533935547,
0.876099705696106,
0.5206543803215027,
0.9081230759620667,
-0.300535649061203,
0.8514824509620667,
-0.41523662209510803,
0.42248377203941345,
-1.0362391471862793,
0.41919106245040894,
-0.2778691351413727,
0.470807284116745,
-0.29700034856796265,
-0.7740428447723389,
-0.22904933989048004,
0.6040367484092712,
-0.6027510166168213,
0.3195836544036865,
0.40437746047973633,
0.7113891243934631,
-0.3366706371307373,
-0.18700017035007477,
0.5616539716720581,
0.3730696141719818,
0.16580608487129211,
0.0319148413836956,
0.8386475443840027,
-0.16411328315734863,
0.4342113137245178,
-0.18342436850070953,
-0.06417691707611084,
-0.3041076362133026,
-1.1218304634094238,
-0.7273563146591187,
-0.47816118597984314,
-0.01886908710002899,
-0.13947640359401703,
0.30954626202583313,
1.1493371725082397,
0.8024386167526245,
-0.5272433161735535,
-0.3943628966808319,
0.005211411044001579,
-0.18986406922340393,
-0.19813309609889984,
-0.3783843219280243,
-0.11334296315908432,
-0.5663225650787354,
-1.098855972290039,
0.7808674573898315,
0.22734315693378448,
-0.008854898624122143,
-0.33529406785964966,
0.1528674066066742,
-0.2596634328365326,
0.08816061168909073,
0.633191704750061,
0.07295724749565125,
-0.579666793346405,
-0.43930914998054504,
0.11504771560430527,
0.12297888845205307,
0.12934228777885437,
0.8364567756652832,
-0.8735392093658447,
0.19204983115196228,
0.3744784891605377,
0.13238373398780823,
0.37655165791511536,
0.17401568591594696,
0.6212285757064819,
-1.309720516204834,
0.0777384489774704,
0.36396554112434387,
0.4130418002605438,
0.4400568902492523,
-0.451005756855011,
0.6768801212310791,
0.19172219932079315,
-0.35518112778663635,
-0.5976614952087402,
0.20050644874572754,
-0.818227231502533,
-0.10688189417123795,
1.4929252862930298,
-0.013597465120255947,
-0.17253437638282776,
-0.6667135953903198,
-0.16586685180664062,
0.24466213583946228,
-0.6250396370887756,
0.9438050389289856,
0.8545734882354736,
-0.10920754820108414,
-0.17253641784191132,
-0.7207435965538025,
0.44374412298202515,
-0.21150407195091248,
-0.7046825885772705,
0.11886074393987656,
0.7925354242324829,
0.3812938630580902,
-0.06513068825006485,
0.8281896114349365,
-0.11154954880475998,
0.05815020576119423,
-0.18792785704135895,
-0.29781824350357056,
-0.3626920282840729,
-0.480386346578598,
-0.34897878766059875,
0.18324775993824005,
0.06601159274578094,
0.07185148447751999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02319v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02319v2
|
Symbolic Prompt Program Search: A Structure-Aware Approach to Efficient Compile-Time Prompt Optimization
| 2024-04-02T21:35:54 | 2024-06-27T23:22:14 |
Tobias Schnabel, Jennifer Neville
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In many modern LLM applications, such as retrieval augmented generation,
prompts have become programs themselves. In these settings, prompt programs are
repeatedly called with different user queries or data instances. A big
practical challenge is optimizing such prompt programs. Recent work has mostly
focused on either simple prompt programs or assumed that the general structure
of a prompt program is fixed.
We introduce SAMMO, a framework to perform symbolic prompt program search for
compile-time optimizations of prompt programs. SAMMO represents prompt programs
on a symbolic level which allows for a rich set of transformations that can be
searched over during optimization. We show that SAMMO generalizes previous
methods and improves the performance of complex prompts on (1) instruction
tuning, (2) RAG pipeline tuning, and (3) prompt compression, across several
different LLMs. We make all code available open-source at
https://github.com/microsoft/sammo .
|
[
-0.09058451652526855,
-0.4808177351951599,
0.8177957534790039,
0.30259376764297485,
-0.30481451749801636,
0.1820780485868454,
0.09861499816179276,
-0.1643380969762802,
0.17435871064662933,
0.12266993522644043,
-1.131430983543396,
-0.6345852017402649,
-0.5569460391998291,
0.4903794825077057,
0.1335681527853012,
0.4670449495315552,
0.04933014139533043,
0.27218690514564514,
-0.22319063544273376,
-0.020159883424639702,
-0.5778472423553467,
-0.2808232009410858,
-0.7878978252410889,
0.07456345856189728,
0.5097649097442627,
0.21557027101516724,
0.36068692803382874,
0.9007796049118042,
0.374741792678833,
0.2872174084186554,
-0.35243669152259827,
0.5297045707702637,
-0.27608874440193176,
1.0322906970977783,
0.01684664376080036,
-0.5721944570541382,
-0.08434177935123444,
-0.22346021234989166,
0.6819039583206177,
0.2566867172718048,
0.13454516232013702,
0.33621978759765625,
-0.22776567935943604,
0.6790792942047119,
-0.8804014921188354,
0.24174940586090088,
-0.5140159726142883,
0.10388679802417755,
-0.17740221321582794,
-0.8075950741767883,
-0.45970165729522705,
-0.6407963037490845,
-0.5676275491714478,
-0.544370710849762,
0.21143297851085663,
0.45579683780670166,
0.4404379427433014,
0.7095645070075989,
-0.571159839630127,
-0.43035662174224854,
-0.31286394596099854,
0.9702558517456055,
-0.31841203570365906,
0.2776065766811371,
0.0842701867222786,
0.47527316212654114,
-0.719092845916748,
-0.4317333698272705,
-0.01308934111148119,
-0.271499902009964,
-0.07778677344322205,
-0.041637249290943146,
-0.3662295639514923,
0.5947489738464355,
0.5310018658638,
0.19426864385604858,
-0.7047779560089111,
-0.2941485643386841,
-0.2663414180278778,
-0.28673744201660156,
0.5132107138633728,
0.44420620799064636,
0.5236227512359619,
-0.31720247864723206,
-0.4576624631881714,
-0.08116254955530167,
-0.9171801209449768,
0.12255050987005234,
0.3520354926586151,
0.3739377558231354,
0.24473309516906738,
0.527177631855011,
-0.19514065980911255,
0.7124122381210327,
-0.09612436592578888,
-0.25668153166770935,
-0.12266351282596588,
-0.2763218879699707,
0.07543520629405975,
0.28829699754714966,
0.26777413487434387,
0.14617498219013214,
-0.04125772789120674,
0.24990741908550262,
-0.49990877509117126,
0.3542144298553467,
0.18701250851154327,
-0.8325082659721375,
-0.1576186865568161,
0.17919787764549255,
-0.5015953779220581,
-0.15329574048519135,
0.0715695396065712,
-0.07399063557386398,
-0.3918902575969696,
-0.29937049746513367,
0.30186086893081665,
-0.11356091499328613,
0.4548226594924927,
-0.07261109352111816,
-0.3947816789150238,
-0.11250698566436768,
0.407278448343277,
-0.47535550594329834,
-0.029493547976017,
0.826684296131134,
0.8712298274040222,
0.13095338642597198,
0.20445466041564941,
-1.455479621887207,
0.4101542830467224,
-0.37696704268455505,
0.7234711050987244,
-0.8677909970283508,
-0.6696910262107849,
-0.36844974756240845,
-0.004474295303225517,
-0.009458940476179123,
-0.4679168164730072,
0.47982460260391235,
-0.32920190691947937,
0.1574418693780899,
-0.3584981858730316,
-0.3379990756511688,
0.08059021830558777,
0.16302043199539185,
-0.6578284502029419,
1.275978446006775,
0.1367756426334381,
-0.4569844901561737,
0.09741561114788055,
-0.7854763865470886,
-0.4824969172477722,
0.07111397385597229,
-0.4024386703968048,
-0.14783623814582825,
0.716059684753418,
0.3434379994869232,
0.3121258318424225,
-0.5687546730041504,
0.12207479029893875,
-0.06280224025249481,
-0.8875982761383057,
-0.06850866228342056,
0.01635400764644146,
1.1383945941925049,
0.4923136830329895,
-0.3721436858177185,
0.5155150890350342,
-0.5795271992683411,
0.12514381110668182,
0.06309789419174194,
-0.312793105840683,
-0.5766015648841858,
0.01208496280014515,
-0.7239114046096802,
0.014129693619906902,
0.4194715917110443,
-0.4667224884033203,
0.6321077942848206,
-0.18679580092430115,
0.24591584503650665,
1.0211623907089233,
0.16499952971935272,
0.14812999963760376,
-0.12216166406869888,
1.0336155891418457,
0.01742682047188282,
0.5721496939659119,
-0.5922060608863831,
-0.40532493591308594,
-0.5159112811088562,
-0.7210566997528076,
-0.21250009536743164,
0.49947115778923035,
-0.7548535466194153,
0.17357854545116425,
0.15738505125045776,
-0.2995469570159912,
-0.5979935526847839,
0.05061187967658043,
0.45897629857063293,
0.32558637857437134,
0.10308735072612762,
0.2327038198709488,
-0.5921958684921265,
-0.8434621691703796,
-0.5191188454627991,
-0.4988899827003479,
-0.013908905908465385,
0.4042781591415405,
0.06075216084718704,
-0.15349005162715912,
0.5447699427604675,
-0.8068405985832214,
0.13442477583885193,
-0.06473300606012344,
-0.06383109092712402,
0.5017350316047668,
0.2562483549118042,
0.4576273262500763,
-0.5311140418052673,
-0.4493285119533539,
-0.05520341917872429,
-0.4116058945655823,
-0.7514474987983704,
-0.17045952379703522,
-0.16913966834545135,
0.12786883115768433,
0.49704062938690186,
-0.6942286491394043,
0.08168882876634598,
0.49803265929222107,
-0.4245830774307251,
0.5552456974983215,
-0.11942438036203384,
0.18496808409690857,
-1.1581346988677979,
0.1766233593225479,
-0.3573596179485321,
-0.22701209783554077,
-0.13002657890319824,
0.5237739682197571,
0.20496688783168793,
-0.43528392910957336,
-0.2899837791919708,
0.8316016793251038,
-0.8589823246002197,
-0.3039422333240509,
-0.031470440328121185,
0.06339108198881149,
-0.04696347564458847,
0.1991845965385437,
-0.5832003355026245,
1.2548949718475342,
0.593634307384491,
-0.4887367784976959,
0.36126041412353516,
-0.03162529319524765,
-0.1400233954191208,
0.6615382432937622,
-0.819214940071106,
0.28097063302993774,
-0.34285983443260193,
0.20147672295570374,
-1.0804885625839233,
-0.11304118484258652,
0.428955614566803,
-0.2875347137451172,
0.13598665595054626,
-0.30925053358078003,
-0.6038422584533691,
-0.1354016363620758,
-0.6162529587745667,
0.31059762835502625,
0.32861950993537903,
-0.638173520565033,
0.6347991228103638,
0.046165503561496735,
-0.2098889946937561,
-0.4762851893901825,
-0.08402141183614731,
-0.20761317014694214,
-0.21232688426971436,
-0.6829614043235779,
0.2009219527244568,
-0.2715413272380829,
-0.18409353494644165,
-0.18621090054512024,
-0.5711036324501038,
0.24357211589813232,
0.34219223260879517,
0.507002055644989,
0.24573568999767303,
-0.017013447359204292,
0.22567085921764374,
0.6168757677078247,
-0.314564049243927,
0.021091504022479057,
-0.19663164019584656,
0.5525302290916443,
-0.01663638837635517,
-0.2574689984321594,
-0.35401394963264465,
0.5388650894165039,
0.3661143481731415,
-0.05612647533416748,
0.24548667669296265,
0.24170835316181183,
-0.15576161444187164,
-0.4860828220844269,
-0.24261923134326935,
-0.2659781277179718,
-0.5592784881591797,
0.035410575568675995,
-0.6265314221382141,
-1.0355271100997925,
0.3773821294307709,
-0.43283969163894653,
0.09865468740463257,
0.17507478594779968,
0.3779497444629669,
-0.038158949464559555,
1.5287445783615112,
0.5361632704734802,
0.2350311577320099,
0.6094138622283936,
0.13726921379566193,
0.03897687792778015,
-0.4193931221961975,
-0.36774590611457825,
-0.9133046269416809,
-0.6695718765258789,
-0.46294939517974854,
-0.4016481637954712,
0.7544416189193726,
0.1178772822022438,
-0.24619214236736298,
0.4759996235370636,
-0.7610629200935364,
0.7585825324058533,
0.5975232124328613,
0.038430146872997284,
0.41387367248535156,
0.1153569146990776,
-0.16880135238170624,
0.0025266169104725122,
-0.7942959666252136,
-0.400355726480484,
0.44104328751564026,
0.04854172095656395,
0.8535811305046082,
-0.11611905694007874,
0.9982536435127258,
0.3540082573890686,
-0.03797849640250206,
-0.8107542991638184,
0.9089366793632507,
-0.1153116449713707,
-0.5272079706192017,
-0.07673361152410507,
-0.7916381359100342,
-0.9803835153579712,
-0.17938074469566345,
0.27242738008499146,
-0.334450900554657,
0.22943629324436188,
0.1702527403831482,
-0.2841856777667999,
-0.0989486575126648,
-0.688148558139801,
0.5501740574836731,
-0.31983673572540283,
0.16035325825214386,
-0.4409215450286865,
-0.8558592796325684,
0.01623360998928547,
0.17092226445674896,
-0.3288537263870239,
-0.2938746213912964,
-0.4905255138874054,
0.20578961074352264,
-0.4629160165786743,
0.5508860349655151,
-0.29230719804763794,
0.0011117630638182163,
0.11898982524871826,
0.39243483543395996,
0.8168509006500244,
0.05300706624984741,
-0.20069560408592224,
-0.11892355233430862,
0.344410240650177,
-0.49617213010787964,
-1.0105563402175903,
0.6769448518753052,
-0.4255952835083008,
-0.7375994324684143,
-0.4297351539134979,
-0.5956113338470459,
0.1303490251302719,
0.12336405366659164,
0.09579098969697952,
0.3992151916027069,
0.1908341944217682,
0.15105462074279785,
0.5205104947090149,
-0.07944422215223312,
0.2884850800037384,
0.0901549756526947,
-0.09542792290449142,
-0.2630147933959961,
0.5987545847892761,
-0.13287445902824402,
-0.09898918122053146,
0.5346512198448181,
0.3039452135562897,
-0.15702208876609802,
-0.1346224993467331,
-0.4806012809276581,
0.19561299681663513,
-0.6949610710144043,
-0.5893469452857971,
-0.24208201467990875,
0.12059136480093002,
-0.04409559443593025,
-0.3381776213645935,
-0.07268750667572021,
-0.7258304953575134,
-0.2752630114555359,
0.12801909446716309,
0.37755751609802246,
0.39846062660217285,
0.17644526064395905,
0.45020824670791626,
-0.8066348433494568,
0.12594595551490784,
0.11808627098798752,
0.08710960298776627,
-0.47526001930236816,
0.1069485992193222,
0.01721801981329918,
-0.1601938009262085,
-0.26090940833091736,
-0.9320902824401855,
0.054669931530952454,
0.23230645060539246,
0.5899872183799744,
0.4324130415916443,
0.40991243720054626,
0.7194937467575073,
-0.1264399290084839,
0.6000635623931885,
0.1848306506872177,
-0.8906249403953552,
0.919367790222168,
-0.14722976088523865,
0.5116572380065918,
0.5021450519561768,
0.49840450286865234,
-0.31795766949653625,
-0.10077819228172302,
-0.2446359395980835,
-0.5005683898925781,
0.7285705804824829,
0.1489115208387375,
0.07515652477741241,
-0.2880513370037079,
0.27075743675231934,
0.1620538830757141,
0.3869354724884033,
-0.038171153515577316,
-0.22931309044361115,
0.3577005863189697,
-0.17631664872169495,
0.3223152458667755,
-0.39233869314193726,
-0.4278682470321655,
-0.07072296738624573,
0.45517435669898987,
-0.2501000463962555,
0.41010555624961853,
-0.002353548537939787,
-0.07357089221477509,
-0.14539605379104614,
0.11694677919149399,
0.5917372703552246,
0.393512099981308,
-0.0866541936993599,
0.3702543079853058,
-0.14554090797901154,
-0.3489561676979065,
0.244699627161026,
-0.041526541113853455,
-0.3245754539966583,
0.32971614599227905,
0.016196195036172867,
0.9053930640220642,
0.11374123394489288,
-0.7656100988388062,
0.16292433440685272,
-0.024066632613539696,
0.2707771062850952,
0.16539204120635986,
0.6325535774230957,
-0.3868758976459503,
0.6988728642463684,
0.4346292018890381,
-0.09026987850666046,
0.3511611521244049,
-0.6135131120681763,
-0.08132759481668472,
0.5644873976707458,
0.02227143943309784,
-0.10185419768095016,
0.6555935740470886,
0.27333053946495056,
-0.4733867943286896,
0.5757347941398621,
-0.27231428027153015,
-0.41838639974594116,
0.4523094594478607,
0.70942223072052,
1.2926380634307861,
-0.36241403222084045,
0.23862846195697784,
0.2768661677837372,
0.22542428970336914,
0.1304444968700409,
0.8218140006065369,
-0.5220884680747986,
-0.021407444030046463,
-0.3821585774421692,
-0.39005520939826965,
-0.380805641412735,
-0.4707299470901489,
-0.21465446054935455,
0.6817314624786377,
-0.8694279193878174,
-0.4531481862068176,
-0.6001241207122803,
0.21874293684959412,
-0.20546306669712067,
-0.011596467345952988,
-0.30636540055274963,
1.0176818370819092,
-0.4284070134162903,
0.3692115247249603,
1.0536659955978394,
0.06237583979964256,
-0.5534332990646362,
-0.05567741394042969,
0.25626108050346375,
-0.6726198792457581,
0.7227484583854675,
0.28075242042541504,
-0.5190029144287109,
0.16209888458251953,
-0.6047921776771545,
-0.6448631882667542,
1.1843584775924683,
0.9974202513694763,
-0.417429655790329,
-0.29886993765830994,
-0.30461516976356506,
0.12872740626335144,
-0.3517293930053711,
0.12074606120586395,
0.13798712193965912,
0.5093486905097961,
0.2438690960407257,
-0.45521530508995056,
0.316723495721817,
-0.37788259983062744,
0.37736135721206665,
0.6026104688644409,
-0.6037713289260864,
0.5121864080429077,
-0.15293331444263458,
-0.5433513522148132,
0.21656949818134308,
0.42572465538978577,
0.9246606230735779,
0.5878527760505676,
0.40168774127960205,
0.11670848727226257,
0.9408299326896667,
-0.24128586053848267,
0.9341238141059875,
-0.7619754672050476,
0.04890982806682587,
0.5585942268371582,
0.0387222021818161,
0.27211374044418335,
0.6660165190696716,
0.016519298776984215,
0.2422807812690735,
0.8823201060295105,
0.11537916213274002,
0.43054744601249695,
0.08554555475711823,
-0.5452693700790405,
-0.4582119584083557,
-0.3165184557437897,
-0.34687143564224243,
0.01766713336110115,
0.11107127368450165,
-0.37261709570884705,
-0.28308770060539246,
-0.4826597571372986,
0.08678524196147919,
-0.09955064207315445,
-0.3481295704841614,
0.27102649211883545,
0.20662327110767365,
-0.44232800602912903,
0.5183649063110352,
0.05881544575095177,
0.30821603536605835,
-0.7146862149238586,
-0.16633543372154236,
-0.5875394344329834,
-0.14158593118190765,
-0.20257338881492615,
-0.3323496878147125,
0.29318687319755554,
-0.12343470007181168,
-0.2750111520290375,
-0.23880183696746826,
0.9901632070541382,
-0.06134863942861557,
-0.24776679277420044,
-0.09524383395910263,
0.39632174372673035,
0.366840124130249,
-0.19032302498817444,
-0.6633636355400085,
0.5045937895774841,
-0.012383970431983471,
-0.2392992079257965,
0.10216272622346878,
0.5052455067634583,
-0.4231860637664795,
1.0319277048110962,
0.7091053128242493,
0.12126566469669342,
0.10210420191287994,
-0.28874075412750244,
0.9238159656524658,
-0.6184566617012024,
-0.6178064346313477,
-0.79929119348526,
0.30952832102775574,
-0.009545035660266876,
-0.3068860173225403,
0.7087713479995728,
0.7504839897155762,
0.5276551246643066,
-0.31152626872062683,
0.24102935194969177,
0.08276139199733734,
0.06769654899835587,
-0.7208510637283325,
0.39775562286376953,
-0.7058359980583191,
0.4389359652996063,
-0.3621118664741516,
-1.4964035749435425,
-0.4427569806575775,
0.6324997544288635,
-0.028752431273460388,
0.010654580779373646,
0.5590996742248535,
1.1324005126953125,
0.056615110486745834,
-0.1731896996498108,
0.22979727387428284,
-0.23107481002807617,
0.1035986989736557,
0.4479738473892212,
0.8764241933822632,
-0.02589348517358303,
0.3765868544578552,
0.0677901953458786,
-0.02941146492958069,
-0.4019092321395874,
-1.0564966201782227,
-0.7451315522193909,
-0.6532717943191528,
-0.21074193716049194,
-0.07072508335113525,
0.5490351915359497,
1.3260564804077148,
0.5853601694107056,
-0.41728585958480835,
-0.20768773555755615,
0.013001075945794582,
0.3015301823616028,
-0.1778354048728943,
-0.15116503834724426,
0.2780389189720154,
-0.5033636689186096,
-0.7880429625511169,
0.807314395904541,
0.6449819803237915,
-0.1093968003988266,
-0.12141875922679901,
-0.2643503248691559,
0.1953156441450119,
0.2293199896812439,
0.7271470427513123,
0.22895283997058868,
-0.3445630669593811,
-0.11903707683086395,
0.41250401735305786,
-0.19341550767421722,
-0.10360196232795715,
1.1441435813903809,
-0.7484728097915649,
0.538399875164032,
1.0037211179733276,
0.6896083950996399,
0.1756998896598816,
0.27056118845939636,
0.5927217602729797,
-1.1345683336257935,
0.01616903766989708,
0.15801848471164703,
0.1451701819896698,
0.058839693665504456,
-0.5901089906692505,
0.8350951671600342,
0.3433055281639099,
-0.4328306019306183,
-1.026003360748291,
0.4002683460712433,
-0.9507340788841248,
-0.4293633699417114,
0.9206868410110474,
0.06380650401115417,
-0.23097245395183563,
0.30435237288475037,
-0.6257309913635254,
0.23992155492305756,
-0.6331722140312195,
0.8585907220840454,
0.32841047644615173,
-0.4667168855667114,
-0.29503709077835083,
-0.3333078622817993,
0.40347716212272644,
0.41623207926750183,
-0.6494378447532654,
-0.1467496007680893,
0.8862334489822388,
-0.11263110488653183,
-0.05995415896177292,
0.41306033730506897,
-0.15442819893360138,
0.31955447793006897,
-0.2552582323551178,
-0.19775667786598206,
-0.523628830909729,
-0.7302604913711548,
-0.3577033579349518,
0.04362151399254799,
-0.03996429964900017,
-0.3298572301864624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02305v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02305v1
|
Collapse of Self-trained Language Models
| 2024-04-02T21:03:37 | 2024-04-02T21:03:37 |
David Herel, Tomas Mikolov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In various fields of knowledge creation, including science, new ideas often
build on pre-existing information. In this work, we explore this concept within
the context of language models. Specifically, we explore the potential of
self-training models on their own outputs, akin to how humans learn and build
on their previous thoughts and actions. While this approach is intuitively
appealing, our research reveals its practical limitations. We find that
extended self-training of the GPT-2 model leads to a significant degradation in
performance, resulting in repetitive and collapsed token output.
|
[
-0.3070499300956726,
-0.4896029531955719,
0.7202696204185486,
-0.3080541491508484,
-0.03249895200133324,
0.11215081810951233,
-0.08284725248813629,
-0.44281256198883057,
-0.05966886505484581,
0.6797547936439514,
-0.4073081910610199,
0.07810000330209732,
-0.7613610029220581,
-0.16934143006801605,
-0.7919571399688721,
1.3764903545379639,
-0.06999307125806808,
-0.029231715947389603,
-0.2744372487068176,
-0.04588387534022331,
-0.6510373950004578,
-0.8946388363838196,
-0.6952952742576599,
-0.6158493161201477,
0.24894772469997406,
0.15025165677070618,
0.48856136202812195,
0.6313456892967224,
0.2591805160045624,
0.3568625748157501,
0.24453145265579224,
-0.49247410893440247,
-0.6990150213241577,
0.06728056818246841,
-0.2303248941898346,
-0.6148437261581421,
-0.15096284449100494,
0.4200335741043091,
0.8164728283882141,
0.7224057912826538,
-0.04756208136677742,
0.0882236510515213,
0.32296812534332275,
0.5427277684211731,
-0.3069840371608734,
0.3075203001499176,
-0.5011688470840454,
0.05699826776981354,
0.07689987868070602,
0.01489220093935728,
-0.29221105575561523,
-0.05851190164685249,
0.28533586859703064,
-0.23080138862133026,
0.5100376605987549,
-0.5655421018600464,
0.577086865901947,
0.18379919230937958,
-0.3391694128513336,
-0.38646596670150757,
-1.0203702449798584,
0.5147072076797485,
-0.6922933459281921,
0.379326730966568,
0.2956087291240692,
0.3537159562110901,
-0.020014075562357903,
-0.9745750427246094,
-0.5843603610992432,
-0.38912737369537354,
-0.3617898225784302,
0.22244682908058167,
0.12860052287578583,
-0.007749841082841158,
0.22483143210411072,
0.3651629686355591,
-0.39796891808509827,
0.09169507026672363,
-0.8550447225570679,
0.01440237183123827,
0.2839691936969757,
0.07929245382547379,
0.4634576439857483,
-0.23831705749034882,
-0.1681583672761917,
-0.0038106879219412804,
-0.8147388696670532,
-0.08973219990730286,
0.49274539947509766,
0.14552266895771027,
0.07815543562173843,
0.4782392382621765,
-0.1157294511795044,
0.3935125470161438,
-0.01909230463206768,
0.008130141533911228,
0.018287433311343193,
-0.2461254745721817,
-0.16092562675476074,
-0.25080636143684387,
0.7456741333007812,
-0.04879111796617508,
0.03336121886968613,
-0.4240235984325409,
-0.172699972987175,
-0.034813735634088516,
0.23974178731441498,
-0.723448634147644,
-0.5247669816017151,
0.15785160660743713,
-0.3415922224521637,
-0.35088711977005005,
-0.12231145054101944,
-0.002646162174642086,
-0.04087783396244049,
-0.3409310579299927,
0.6850829720497131,
-0.43082064390182495,
-0.7176662087440491,
0.006428098771721125,
-0.24820218980312347,
-0.22221344709396362,
0.1087617427110672,
-1.1103384494781494,
0.35870081186294556,
0.598051130771637,
0.8485424518585205,
0.09649983048439026,
-0.7875126004219055,
-0.14601768553256989,
0.07941038906574249,
-0.34626293182373047,
0.6610545516014099,
-0.3137713074684143,
-0.6666606664657593,
-0.12992550432682037,
-0.03489260748028755,
-0.036726463586091995,
-0.3859964609146118,
0.14818932116031647,
-0.3354422152042389,
0.6743118166923523,
-0.321137011051178,
-0.611495852470398,
-0.06062786281108856,
-0.017636628821492195,
-0.635263979434967,
0.8671624660491943,
0.16760219633579254,
-0.8444756269454956,
0.5486786365509033,
-0.7021369934082031,
-0.41690781712532043,
0.1676453948020935,
-0.5157680511474609,
-0.26573866605758667,
0.32655203342437744,
-0.3265567123889923,
0.5072205066680908,
-0.2900449335575104,
0.3941749632358551,
-0.3281109035015106,
-0.14146462082862854,
0.07899213582277298,
-0.27345141768455505,
0.6455604434013367,
0.2623351514339447,
-0.4319525957107544,
-0.20122326910495758,
-0.6379166841506958,
-0.011080385185778141,
0.2697319984436035,
-0.44500625133514404,
-0.40816542506217957,
0.06322420388460159,
-0.34524697065353394,
0.5861741900444031,
0.10624199360609055,
-0.4347139596939087,
0.44860318303108215,
-0.5502665638923645,
0.7327378988265991,
0.5985710024833679,
-0.16822001338005066,
0.5187605619430542,
-0.24831697344779968,
0.40404626727104187,
-0.022921089082956314,
-0.01833297684788704,
-0.34011709690093994,
-0.3112305998802185,
-0.8793306350708008,
0.10150472819805145,
0.21561886370182037,
0.04423188418149948,
-0.51188725233078,
0.14372612535953522,
-0.3407813310623169,
-0.5327587723731995,
-0.2969071567058563,
0.2648638188838959,
0.4029737412929535,
0.6207164525985718,
0.24077342450618744,
-0.3974739611148834,
-0.6146364212036133,
-0.8681897521018982,
-0.5095854997634888,
-0.3771333694458008,
-0.04833896830677986,
-0.1613197773694992,
0.8706332445144653,
-0.205882266163826,
1.054845929145813,
-0.33357372879981995,
-0.12800069153308868,
-0.45748910307884216,
0.6446405053138733,
-0.051201511174440384,
0.6804656982421875,
0.4015282690525055,
-0.37840449810028076,
-0.1775846779346466,
-0.08209189027547836,
-0.8145380616188049,
0.3926222622394562,
-0.3312631845474243,
0.2588393986225128,
0.05584605410695076,
0.45653149485588074,
-0.6896716952323914,
0.5004765391349792,
0.45111361145973206,
-0.2550557851791382,
0.8792662024497986,
-0.28480520844459534,
0.05968441814184189,
-1.061493158340454,
-0.06186923012137413,
-0.45690345764160156,
0.037521712481975555,
-0.6815834045410156,
-0.20237822830677032,
-0.11734235286712646,
-0.31819361448287964,
-0.27909624576568604,
0.7380871176719666,
-0.7116191983222961,
-0.21780484914779663,
-0.7307107448577881,
-0.04127951338887215,
-0.19326117634773254,
0.31661003828048706,
0.2850305736064911,
0.7587672472000122,
0.398335337638855,
-0.5630386471748352,
0.043070849031209946,
0.13565173745155334,
-0.24429720640182495,
-0.12262730300426483,
-0.7995232343673706,
0.3031615912914276,
-0.22488780319690704,
0.15514475107192993,
-1.0051190853118896,
-0.5135714411735535,
0.05012790486216545,
-0.557424008846283,
0.6116131544113159,
-0.48164573311805725,
-0.3300052881240845,
-0.603306233882904,
-0.10199012607336044,
0.4949227273464203,
0.6539345383644104,
-0.6266892552375793,
0.335029274225235,
0.3554912507534027,
-0.21303687989711761,
-0.45771804451942444,
-1.0082226991653442,
0.09559701383113861,
-0.07487205415964127,
-0.5221048593521118,
0.04697339981794357,
0.1707613170146942,
-0.014435993507504463,
0.23325420916080475,
0.027957582846283913,
-0.09272774308919907,
-0.008786008693277836,
0.4046793580055237,
-0.12739767134189606,
-0.21834106743335724,
0.5156892538070679,
-0.027475858107209206,
0.10040673613548279,
0.35101422667503357,
-0.433143675327301,
0.7782729864120483,
-0.28936371207237244,
-0.5164154767990112,
-0.37448757886886597,
0.3539384603500366,
0.6685513257980347,
-0.23224349319934845,
0.9713178277015686,
0.3739018142223358,
-0.2108694463968277,
-0.033833540976047516,
-0.5233628153800964,
-0.4183923304080963,
-0.5213637948036194,
0.6913940906524658,
-0.3875105679035187,
-0.9273422956466675,
0.4087711572647095,
-0.1647096574306488,
-0.13597282767295837,
0.6733537316322327,
0.6720539331436157,
-0.1822264939546585,
0.8609685301780701,
1.0527892112731934,
0.2536540627479553,
0.6200059056282043,
-0.6248964667320251,
0.232284277677536,
-0.813738226890564,
-0.23254765570163727,
-0.11854176223278046,
0.11475273221731186,
-0.45218196511268616,
-0.3134216070175171,
0.005068182945251465,
0.24558806419372559,
-0.2517097294330597,
0.42457008361816406,
-0.5529182553291321,
0.4751806855201721,
0.6822742223739624,
-0.025560248643159866,
0.14658580720424652,
-0.17034295201301575,
0.011807450093328953,
0.12196218967437744,
-1.075874924659729,
-0.4719138741493225,
1.4231511354446411,
0.5706663131713867,
0.8406223654747009,
-0.1907390058040619,
0.9547520279884338,
0.2822679579257965,
0.6818110942840576,
-0.5042664408683777,
0.12307339161634445,
0.10266172140836716,
-0.8006998896598816,
-0.5346439480781555,
-0.37357842922210693,
-0.9718522429466248,
-0.11219926178455353,
0.20424620807170868,
-0.6069385409355164,
0.03377733752131462,
0.4996720850467682,
-0.22273923456668854,
0.4075530171394348,
-0.9910810589790344,
0.9306684732437134,
-0.5858010053634644,
-0.27573728561401367,
-0.23134109377861023,
-0.454537570476532,
0.657036542892456,
-0.24230130016803741,
0.2551211714744568,
0.06207088753581047,
0.3863019645214081,
1.0942388772964478,
-0.6197582483291626,
1.0707436800003052,
-0.19713521003723145,
-0.13613396883010864,
0.5783122181892395,
0.10678461194038391,
0.39276453852653503,
-0.059624094516038895,
0.41456693410873413,
0.1505832076072693,
-0.0790845975279808,
-0.43400540947914124,
-0.7805832028388977,
0.5365172624588013,
-0.9739827513694763,
-0.7928716540336609,
-0.3845416009426117,
-0.32384416460990906,
-0.07412396371364594,
0.3054081201553345,
0.5718773007392883,
0.5881353616714478,
-0.28024816513061523,
-0.19140011072158813,
0.06806913018226624,
0.005941061303019524,
0.39634397625923157,
0.4793120324611664,
-0.4630814492702484,
-0.4362622797489166,
0.7953916788101196,
0.5931350588798523,
0.6050508618354797,
-0.19907782971858978,
0.12829694151878357,
-0.5199030041694641,
-0.521674633026123,
0.00817856378853321,
0.4111515283584595,
-0.9560911059379578,
0.13728688657283783,
-0.5693537592887878,
-0.36070674657821655,
-0.7480893731117249,
0.18662314116954803,
-0.6473627686500549,
-0.8112943768501282,
-0.1518639624118805,
-0.29341766238212585,
-0.015069758519530296,
1.5186102390289307,
-0.36812788248062134,
0.4966185390949249,
-0.6646484732627869,
-0.12731178104877472,
0.5907488465309143,
0.47881296277046204,
0.11978498846292496,
-0.7264877557754517,
-0.5922704339027405,
0.09833802282810211,
-0.3474023640155792,
-0.8863736987113953,
0.24062411487102509,
0.24500535428524017,
0.6553419828414917,
0.46602869033813477,
-0.38250526785850525,
0.3551022708415985,
-0.6107538938522339,
0.7253906726837158,
0.7165858745574951,
-0.8879109025001526,
0.7447142004966736,
-0.4156509041786194,
0.33468469977378845,
0.3536660075187683,
0.47026190161705017,
-0.5627456903457642,
-0.42030778527259827,
-0.782024621963501,
-0.5899210572242737,
0.5040237903594971,
0.2760651409626007,
0.35195276141166687,
-0.26892581582069397,
0.5564380288124084,
0.2361987680196762,
0.09042257815599442,
-0.9513021111488342,
-0.2591037154197693,
-0.6750966310501099,
0.19926103949546814,
-0.1442330777645111,
-0.677642822265625,
-0.10327021032571793,
-0.4962988495826721,
0.46145790815353394,
-0.1388695240020752,
0.491886705160141,
0.13231024146080017,
-0.23557943105697632,
0.044262636452913284,
0.15017525851726532,
0.39736583828926086,
0.6187509894371033,
0.13230617344379425,
0.21309712529182434,
0.1484490931034088,
-0.3210641145706177,
0.3968786299228668,
-0.3212960958480835,
-0.019212329760193825,
-0.264511376619339,
0.4615945518016815,
0.8193244338035583,
0.24092477560043335,
-0.4101424813270569,
0.360721230506897,
-0.12251166999340057,
-0.3543902635574341,
-0.40352994203567505,
0.14989517629146576,
0.19716767966747284,
-0.019372550770640373,
0.3164983093738556,
0.3144461512565613,
0.18658821284770966,
-1.15841805934906,
0.5542370676994324,
0.3456217646598816,
-0.25442296266555786,
-0.7168771028518677,
0.8085358142852783,
0.10565941780805588,
-0.26328036189079285,
0.4863471984863281,
-0.14736008644104004,
-0.8059048056602478,
0.34473052620887756,
0.8229448795318604,
0.9972894191741943,
-0.2559877336025238,
0.3037062883377075,
0.4652356207370758,
0.41104215383529663,
-0.3572860360145569,
0.013916541822254658,
-0.20788058638572693,
-0.646176278591156,
-0.7320643067359924,
-0.44903916120529175,
-0.13239996135234833,
0.38416650891304016,
-0.5571721792221069,
0.21597272157669067,
-0.5803266763687134,
-0.3937508463859558,
-0.31693798303604126,
-0.25606825947761536,
-0.8007842302322388,
0.34946364164352417,
0.10196222364902496,
0.4351561963558197,
-0.9675594568252563,
0.9872138500213623,
0.5252744555473328,
-0.8386180996894836,
-0.7124812006950378,
-0.00406719371676445,
-0.3901241421699524,
-0.7963353395462036,
1.1011395454406738,
0.24215152859687805,
-0.2037600874900818,
-0.0024066080804914236,
-0.5208714008331299,
-1.304307222366333,
0.8747491240501404,
0.5182182192802429,
-0.3459499478340149,
-0.4385169744491577,
0.39409950375556946,
0.704014003276825,
-0.24622784554958344,
0.20035049319267273,
0.6400377750396729,
0.09333663433790207,
-0.05925219878554344,
-1.0310297012329102,
0.014952135272324085,
-0.26232293248176575,
-0.1886191964149475,
0.08813681453466415,
-0.7947643399238586,
1.1195663213729858,
-0.32764366269111633,
-0.5007299780845642,
0.0035089512821286917,
0.7041738629341125,
-0.38265854120254517,
-0.1777314692735672,
0.22303146123886108,
0.695399284362793,
0.5765975713729858,
0.11123558133840561,
1.0566799640655518,
-0.33935612440109253,
0.6937514543533325,
1.584326148033142,
0.2925061881542206,
0.6374004483222961,
0.1895202249288559,
-0.21361075341701508,
0.5195334553718567,
0.4557360112667084,
-0.09418029338121414,
0.5034058094024658,
0.10016707330942154,
-0.027807094156742096,
-0.237433522939682,
0.33991435170173645,
-0.5543912649154663,
0.6040544509887695,
0.2907290458679199,
-0.44775718450546265,
-0.19620172679424286,
0.1654372364282608,
-0.11809536814689636,
-0.23487766087055206,
-0.04110104963183403,
0.5827512741088867,
0.13963741064071655,
-0.7230866551399231,
0.7132959365844727,
-0.3767615854740143,
0.2627062201499939,
-0.41372790932655334,
0.006051233503967524,
-0.1513022780418396,
0.08713345974683762,
-0.11652939021587372,
-0.566798746585846,
0.5279879570007324,
-0.15514828264713287,
-0.10371395945549011,
-0.26877444982528687,
0.7920304536819458,
-0.4786248207092285,
-0.3765329122543335,
0.38143378496170044,
0.7358886003494263,
0.41174083948135376,
-0.1132327988743782,
-0.5817821621894836,
-0.20175836980342865,
-0.07064154744148254,
-0.31046733260154724,
0.45130500197410583,
0.3780680298805237,
0.35624223947525024,
0.8180872797966003,
0.4804299771785736,
0.0002180655865231529,
0.38498592376708984,
-0.16609029471874237,
0.9763270020484924,
-0.6845990419387817,
-0.3615870475769043,
-0.8839462995529175,
0.4148741066455841,
-0.07218288630247116,
-0.35242271423339844,
0.8020302653312683,
0.7112155556678772,
1.0115045309066772,
-0.07926557958126068,
1.272207498550415,
0.02417297102510929,
0.5885969996452332,
-0.4996478259563446,
1.0702487230300903,
-0.6061723828315735,
0.2793903648853302,
-0.12899497151374817,
-0.4119916260242462,
0.08051326870918274,
0.392391175031662,
-0.5319637656211853,
0.3393939733505249,
0.8684388995170593,
0.1738409847021103,
0.06227659806609154,
-0.350771963596344,
0.5762569904327393,
0.359049528837204,
0.4120768904685974,
0.301018625497818,
1.1037371158599854,
-0.26282721757888794,
0.6879062652587891,
-0.3569585680961609,
-0.1336662769317627,
0.018874382600188255,
-0.5121851563453674,
-1.2625236511230469,
-0.9419996738433838,
-0.24365568161010742,
-0.22378461062908173,
0.025608284398913383,
0.48561856150627136,
0.8280922770500183,
-0.6350535750389099,
-0.1769205629825592,
-0.3961697816848755,
-0.15017302334308624,
0.2473485767841339,
-0.12572528421878815,
0.37437185645103455,
-0.8223205804824829,
-0.3527783155441284,
0.43090376257896423,
0.21709051728248596,
0.5140253901481628,
-0.5715681910514832,
-0.09567589312791824,
0.15912356972694397,
-0.08388306200504303,
0.5463985800743103,
0.6390613317489624,
-0.6652104258537292,
-0.34865671396255493,
-0.23722690343856812,
0.16158385574817657,
0.12796619534492493,
1.138471007347107,
-1.013526439666748,
0.569920003414154,
0.17074914276599884,
0.4195369780063629,
0.6872226595878601,
-0.19333186745643616,
0.9760153293609619,
-0.6523324251174927,
0.16761179268360138,
0.20932944118976593,
0.40829965472221375,
0.3143059015274048,
-0.2471272349357605,
0.4353683292865753,
0.4629097580909729,
-0.5838369727134705,
-0.8862470984458923,
0.48817864060401917,
-0.2241995483636856,
-0.4230336546897888,
0.8910990357398987,
-0.1472429484128952,
-0.24563999474048615,
-0.11739522963762283,
-0.08660852909088135,
0.45530280470848083,
0.007406554650515318,
1.0762981176376343,
0.8125342130661011,
-0.43661874532699585,
-0.01232073176652193,
-0.5351094603538513,
0.7875005006790161,
0.4856732487678528,
-0.6496044397354126,
0.2985493242740631,
0.206786647439003,
0.7087844610214233,
0.19744126498699188,
0.9074944853782654,
-0.04478013142943382,
0.2609518766403198,
0.3833298683166504,
0.25640207529067993,
-0.05409933999180794,
-0.5486368536949158,
-0.32357773184776306,
0.21831563115119934,
0.3508314788341522,
0.03919338807463646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05741v1
|
Enhancing Inference Efficiency of Large Language Models: Investigating Optimization Strategies and Architectural Innovations
| 2024-04-02T19:53:54 | 2024-04-02T19:53:54 |
Georgy Tyukin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PF
|
Large Language Models are growing in size, and we expect them to continue to
do so, as larger models train quicker. However, this increase in size will
severely impact inference costs. Therefore model compression is important, to
retain the performance of larger models, but with a reduced cost of running
them. In this thesis we explore the methods of model compression, and we
empirically demonstrate that the simple method of skipping latter attention
sublayers in Transformer LLMs is an effective method of model compression, as
these layers prove to be redundant, whilst also being incredibly
computationally expensive. We observed a 21% speed increase in one-token
generation for Llama 2 7B, whilst surprisingly and unexpectedly improving
performance over several common benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5283840298652649,
-0.6193431615829468,
0.5203882455825806,
0.31773215532302856,
-0.16021853685379028,
-0.07990483939647675,
-0.13282904028892517,
-0.5878640413284302,
-0.0770818367600441,
0.5981062650680542,
-0.40971893072128296,
-0.06886604428291321,
-0.5764091610908508,
-0.03550472483038902,
-0.38424715399742126,
0.2633824050426483,
0.2746398448944092,
-0.054113540798425674,
-0.21215496957302094,
0.16259752213954926,
-0.2302863448858261,
-0.5067130923271179,
-0.977867066860199,
-0.3256751000881195,
0.3955475389957428,
0.3384990990161896,
0.6734819412231445,
1.0216768980026245,
0.6012140512466431,
0.3706322908401489,
-0.5466236472129822,
0.3051231801509857,
-0.577755868434906,
0.16933302581310272,
0.003910701721906662,
-0.5621965527534485,
-0.411618709564209,
-0.3366122841835022,
0.789658784866333,
0.8079124689102173,
-0.020572835579514503,
0.3103404939174652,
0.02573799155652523,
0.7656819820404053,
-0.7979147434234619,
0.175403892993927,
-0.5267375111579895,
0.022779298946261406,
-0.18306870758533478,
-0.2279524952173233,
-0.6254850625991821,
-0.1287657916545868,
0.01969779282808304,
-0.4943609833717346,
0.1904190629720688,
0.2748390734195709,
0.6234479546546936,
0.629424512386322,
-0.04695857688784599,
-0.0712670087814331,
-0.6183692216873169,
0.9568824768066406,
-0.8505101203918457,
0.5040836334228516,
0.2553698718547821,
-0.012121879495680332,
-0.20419812202453613,
-0.9889681935310364,
-0.3954090476036072,
-0.15584544837474823,
-0.03597226366400719,
-0.042080070823431015,
-0.49045121669769287,
0.26189276576042175,
0.5187274217605591,
0.21634571254253387,
-0.24178145825862885,
0.5706800818443298,
-0.34704792499542236,
-0.13626191020011902,
0.6134155988693237,
0.10002020746469498,
0.023855503648519516,
-0.17613227665424347,
-0.1437579095363617,
-0.25297093391418457,
-0.994968056678772,
-0.2610696256160736,
0.7623264789581299,
0.04432788863778114,
0.24383968114852905,
0.5352928042411804,
-0.1504823863506317,
0.6642793416976929,
-0.11517613381147385,
-0.20932912826538086,
0.08599711209535599,
-0.25978344678878784,
-0.3145217299461365,
0.03473735228180885,
0.34416481852531433,
0.08267537504434586,
0.26375532150268555,
-0.14536811411380768,
-0.2038634568452835,
0.27233096957206726,
0.3245616853237152,
-0.8421599268913269,
-0.1979171633720398,
0.39771613478660583,
-0.699441134929657,
-0.262073814868927,
-0.24390263855457306,
-0.7323188781738281,
-0.19664408266544342,
-0.2948894202709198,
0.2460257112979889,
-0.2558004558086395,
-0.2922194004058838,
0.3715835511684418,
-0.31104353070259094,
0.34050828218460083,
0.25348806381225586,
-0.9677463173866272,
0.3387576937675476,
0.8043789267539978,
0.7288991808891296,
0.05745162442326546,
-0.1319361925125122,
-0.5579088926315308,
0.04078805446624756,
-0.4822474718093872,
0.9142528176307678,
-0.4713541865348816,
-0.5085805654525757,
-0.22901390492916107,
-0.24090301990509033,
0.11536070704460144,
-0.7780126929283142,
0.785233199596405,
-0.5261720418930054,
-0.10935459285974503,
-0.05508925020694733,
-0.5891618728637695,
-0.17615075409412384,
-0.06217646598815918,
-0.850007951259613,
1.2228423357009888,
0.1865575760602951,
-0.660219132900238,
-0.023687520995736122,
-0.7366028428077698,
-0.5689474940299988,
-0.14376835525035858,
0.2118668109178543,
-0.4230806827545166,
0.6679403781890869,
0.5197861790657043,
0.41700509190559387,
-0.7871492505073547,
0.009069978259503841,
-0.020829586312174797,
-0.5130032300949097,
0.0006529231905005872,
-0.4418654143810272,
0.6223035454750061,
0.4134516716003418,
-0.35515642166137695,
-0.11438030749559402,
-0.9329091906547546,
-0.17369979619979858,
0.320361852645874,
-0.4694747030735016,
-0.3314588963985443,
0.1658649742603302,
-0.12676893174648285,
-0.031216250732541084,
0.10481887310743332,
-0.25559210777282715,
0.32607266306877136,
-0.3867003619670868,
0.5428902506828308,
0.8237691521644592,
-0.003560431068763137,
0.5025943517684937,
-0.09814027696847916,
0.5904040336608887,
0.05282013118267059,
0.3810522258281708,
-0.370533287525177,
-0.3897407352924347,
-1.1833795309066772,
-0.3490927219390869,
0.5366311073303223,
0.32997921109199524,
-0.5797106623649597,
0.1451381891965866,
-0.24135684967041016,
-0.41840338706970215,
-0.6688137650489807,
0.14977484941482544,
0.3321293890476227,
0.2627067565917969,
0.31343767046928406,
-0.21869514882564545,
-0.6148450374603271,
-1.0643045902252197,
-0.3469264805316925,
-0.19881005585193634,
0.011857714504003525,
0.22670426964759827,
0.29494068026542664,
-0.13276603817939758,
0.6823959946632385,
-0.4866916239261627,
0.3694237172603607,
-0.48342758417129517,
0.026274127885699272,
0.24949173629283905,
0.6397466063499451,
0.4989009499549866,
-0.6642326712608337,
-0.1712377518415451,
-0.08464530110359192,
-0.3928275406360626,
-0.4070683717727661,
-0.07865646481513977,
-0.1389961987733841,
0.2646259367465973,
0.5538159608840942,
-0.7318548560142517,
0.32085174322128296,
0.6330573558807373,
0.10139703750610352,
0.5127820372581482,
-0.08354434370994568,
-0.14029990136623383,
-0.7503405809402466,
-0.07850531488656998,
-0.058778248727321625,
-0.13333146274089813,
-0.8142489790916443,
0.15858282148838043,
0.06124189868569374,
0.17176471650600433,
-0.5253168344497681,
0.5810595750808716,
-0.970583975315094,
-0.20893466472625732,
-0.339079886674881,
0.05321343615651131,
-0.0678647980093956,
0.5422549843788147,
-0.18021419644355774,
0.9184945821762085,
0.6541053056716919,
-0.6849103569984436,
0.01318550668656826,
0.016671348363161087,
-0.5756500959396362,
-0.027590541169047356,
-0.7210052609443665,
0.406198650598526,
-0.4100719392299652,
0.009404321201145649,
-1.0601327419281006,
-0.1449270248413086,
0.019876470789313316,
-0.0714232325553894,
0.5486648082733154,
-0.11141487956047058,
-0.6366350650787354,
-0.39815810322761536,
-0.31049343943595886,
0.43628382682800293,
0.7348511219024658,
-0.8596267104148865,
0.8352499008178711,
0.4277823567390442,
0.03419533371925354,
-0.7028339505195618,
-0.8602851033210754,
0.10480418801307678,
-0.47557106614112854,
-0.5506653785705566,
0.20904913544654846,
0.0037705085705965757,
-0.4011327922344208,
-0.04961969330906868,
-0.19674722850322723,
0.3235398530960083,
0.26753392815589905,
-0.015123811550438404,
0.045507002621889114,
-0.283973753452301,
0.07103493064641953,
0.1777932196855545,
-0.12961189448833466,
0.0024168873205780983,
-0.5753489136695862,
0.849856436252594,
0.1774357259273529,
-0.371168851852417,
-0.6382912397384644,
0.30551403760910034,
0.5052257180213928,
-0.10731246322393417,
0.7918287515640259,
0.21559669077396393,
-0.2349841147661209,
-0.37010490894317627,
-0.9190980792045593,
-0.08310066163539886,
-0.5221253633499146,
0.47047555446624756,
-0.4560960531234741,
-0.8422573804855347,
0.5772769451141357,
-0.37846413254737854,
0.14094918966293335,
0.5048521757125854,
0.4658222794532776,
0.42953088879585266,
1.0993517637252808,
0.4818545877933502,
-0.1298481971025467,
0.6902644634246826,
-0.3035472333431244,
0.23243385553359985,
-0.8810723423957825,
0.00933191366493702,
-0.7810914516448975,
-0.3747802972793579,
-0.5420480966567993,
-0.7085000276565552,
0.23247574269771576,
0.3174574077129364,
-0.13798369467258453,
0.2986714541912079,
-0.4457976520061493,
0.6537344455718994,
0.7479216456413269,
0.03379226103425026,
0.24745653569698334,
0.1991180032491684,
0.16700497269630432,
0.2658533453941345,
-1.098388433456421,
-0.413063108921051,
0.9619089365005493,
0.573955237865448,
0.9579536318778992,
0.28736138343811035,
0.5179297924041748,
0.05449444055557251,
0.31520476937294006,
-0.7865287661552429,
0.6306340098381042,
-0.06974084675312042,
-0.3068937361240387,
-0.12231968343257904,
-0.5712836980819702,
-0.8969488143920898,
0.392553448677063,
0.047524962574243546,
-0.8680026531219482,
0.311583548784256,
0.2575218677520752,
-0.15340274572372437,
0.3176705837249756,
-0.9256155490875244,
0.5125748515129089,
-0.06583087146282196,
-0.3963731527328491,
-0.3399167060852051,
-0.5776255130767822,
0.32852113246917725,
-0.1252976506948471,
0.03946416452527046,
0.1222485601902008,
-0.1668914556503296,
0.6338873505592346,
-0.2329089343547821,
0.8138055205345154,
-0.009790444746613503,
-0.11861717700958252,
0.3299878239631653,
-0.024226615205407143,
0.7413350343704224,
-0.30086749792099,
-0.2737724781036377,
0.2780383825302124,
-0.3857942223548889,
-0.5755540132522583,
-0.6751789450645447,
0.4244382977485657,
-0.5723668336868286,
-0.9027889966964722,
0.187201127409935,
-0.7274615168571472,
-0.17155039310455322,
-0.01404336653649807,
0.16999469697475433,
0.5824893712997437,
0.14249306917190552,
0.2355934977531433,
0.7317672967910767,
-0.3754371106624603,
0.5409239530563354,
0.05826305225491524,
0.04583550989627838,
-0.23093077540397644,
0.5665205717086792,
0.12272361665964127,
0.549529492855072,
0.46721190214157104,
0.4086551368236542,
-0.3259112238883972,
-0.8247942924499512,
-0.20250287652015686,
0.3450605869293213,
-0.8176524043083191,
-0.274379700422287,
-0.8499149084091187,
-0.19338388741016388,
-0.7199640274047852,
0.11472586542367935,
-0.5007659792900085,
-0.867150068283081,
-0.27191874384880066,
-0.13186605274677277,
0.09981027990579605,
0.7308914661407471,
-0.1045149490237236,
0.8115079998970032,
-0.6742238998413086,
-0.01775837317109108,
0.07340236753225327,
0.044253166764974594,
0.5224885940551758,
-0.60783451795578,
-0.3232777714729309,
-0.5012500882148743,
-0.27518317103385925,
-0.6203314661979675,
0.2728801667690277,
0.12640579044818878,
0.7482306957244873,
0.6476573944091797,
-0.10854095965623856,
0.7835212349891663,
-0.49809446930885315,
0.8065677285194397,
-0.020428571850061417,
-1.0595505237579346,
0.3424045443534851,
0.05563671141862869,
0.46880438923835754,
0.03634573891758919,
0.2054174393415451,
-0.27798697352409363,
-0.20823907852172852,
-0.7698992490768433,
-0.977341890335083,
0.6508432626724243,
0.0719107910990715,
0.2391255795955658,
-0.11097800731658936,
0.6451447606086731,
-0.08671189844608307,
0.06498700380325317,
-0.4483610689640045,
-0.41151928901672363,
0.24307791888713837,
-0.17313902080059052,
0.014655377715826035,
-0.6847904324531555,
0.0620606504380703,
-0.15912681818008423,
0.8063028454780579,
-0.13093650341033936,
0.3432410657405853,
0.13610219955444336,
-0.1343909353017807,
0.15173713862895966,
0.09473526477813721,
0.7085726857185364,
0.6468005776405334,
0.20344966650009155,
0.20904435217380524,
0.36661961674690247,
-0.309863805770874,
-0.044941287487745285,
-0.08984006196260452,
-0.00969136506319046,
-0.11038237065076828,
0.5099685788154602,
1.1196234226226807,
0.21186040341854095,
-0.6432496309280396,
0.050412435084581375,
0.07640726119279861,
-0.22252924740314484,
0.06277284771203995,
0.2386535257101059,
0.3005984127521515,
0.6359000205993652,
0.3459455668926239,
-0.2311142235994339,
0.19608555734157562,
-0.355612576007843,
-0.07860603928565979,
0.42284145951271057,
0.1393807828426361,
-0.033241644501686096,
0.6085013747215271,
-0.1359599381685257,
-0.3658634126186371,
0.5586965084075928,
0.3216591477394104,
-0.6302444338798523,
0.6620129942893982,
0.7152471542358398,
0.8801320195198059,
-0.31292304396629333,
-0.23160536587238312,
0.3998837172985077,
0.5247378945350647,
-0.5308763980865479,
-0.030431978404521942,
-0.25880321860313416,
-0.6484496593475342,
-0.7003963589668274,
-0.7212270498275757,
-0.44078701734542847,
-0.03130650147795677,
-0.4755929708480835,
0.14545650780200958,
-0.2693510353565216,
-0.22629833221435547,
0.025699693709611893,
-0.07783636450767517,
-0.5651216506958008,
0.035665955394506454,
0.14178383350372314,
1.1813609600067139,
-0.5931774973869324,
0.697918713092804,
0.3759979009628296,
-0.05607471987605095,
-0.9851261377334595,
-0.15240637958049774,
-0.15256823599338531,
-0.7961124181747437,
0.7459881901741028,
0.09889703243970871,
-0.19525566697120667,
0.23103660345077515,
-0.6038363575935364,
-1.0276004076004028,
0.7830157279968262,
0.5903407335281372,
-0.7053878307342529,
-0.12987878918647766,
0.1038709282875061,
0.502149760723114,
-0.2827203571796417,
0.15497085452079773,
0.9184774160385132,
0.46940454840660095,
0.12469691038131714,
-0.5346692204475403,
-0.015050962567329407,
-0.10118285566568375,
0.30053475499153137,
0.4848596155643463,
-0.7657977342605591,
0.7568506598472595,
-0.09816247969865799,
-0.3430628776550293,
0.3148576021194458,
0.7940184473991394,
0.08187086880207062,
-0.07377519458532333,
0.7224493026733398,
0.6878571510314941,
0.7160050868988037,
-0.023986751213669777,
1.27083158493042,
-0.4811267852783203,
0.5210661888122559,
0.8616413474082947,
-0.14157453179359436,
0.7345291376113892,
0.7367268800735474,
-0.14826740324497223,
0.24099239706993103,
0.6642887592315674,
0.08688682317733765,
0.29026713967323303,
0.44559821486473083,
-0.2122933566570282,
-0.29978105425834656,
-0.13782086968421936,
-0.11402103304862976,
0.4358316957950592,
0.2595701515674591,
-0.4322942793369293,
0.019718479365110397,
-0.19904015958309174,
0.07389989495277405,
-0.331646203994751,
-0.23979860544204712,
0.7440550923347473,
0.014791393652558327,
-0.788188636302948,
0.4930654466152191,
-0.08060576766729355,
0.40890806913375854,
-0.5245674848556519,
0.09272249042987823,
-0.4322362244129181,
0.2701662480831146,
0.01611807383596897,
-0.35124149918556213,
0.12666936218738556,
-0.007038394920527935,
-0.037110403180122375,
-0.1982051432132721,
0.6880413889884949,
-0.2054097205400467,
-0.5119880437850952,
0.35246849060058594,
0.49036023020744324,
0.3582402467727661,
0.14299629628658295,
-0.43260619044303894,
0.2984917163848877,
-0.09143926948308945,
-0.766899824142456,
0.11592552810907364,
0.18298238515853882,
0.012826609425246716,
0.652313768863678,
0.8496608734130859,
0.3010523319244385,
0.250266969203949,
0.3139883279800415,
1.0230616331100464,
-0.5129678845405579,
-0.3340757191181183,
-1.0275295972824097,
0.39427807927131653,
-0.14717313647270203,
-0.11748725920915604,
0.7005585432052612,
0.5354077219963074,
0.7838167548179626,
0.022064384073019028,
0.4763338565826416,
0.07723777741193771,
0.2275654822587967,
-0.8552237749099731,
0.2784184515476227,
-0.74086594581604,
0.4562820792198181,
-0.2285115271806717,
-1.1685832738876343,
-0.422702431678772,
0.5537667870521545,
-0.0684199333190918,
-0.005205735098570585,
0.673040509223938,
0.9570959210395813,
-0.13279306888580322,
0.04458286240696907,
0.3181363344192505,
0.3667026460170746,
0.43187639117240906,
0.38883426785469055,
0.87632817029953,
-0.4542234539985657,
0.30691632628440857,
-0.2583119869232178,
-0.08463563024997711,
0.03705081716179848,
-0.9923083782196045,
-0.7926951050758362,
-0.22485026717185974,
-0.26943299174308777,
-0.3465460240840912,
-0.08308452367782593,
0.8083258271217346,
0.7992343306541443,
-0.5408470034599304,
-0.22247155010700226,
-0.08928392827510834,
0.09679070860147476,
-0.28167402744293213,
-0.19658923149108887,
0.4967316687107086,
-0.39266809821128845,
-1.1917189359664917,
0.45171764492988586,
0.40268126130104065,
-0.006323869805783033,
-0.4533747434616089,
0.19252437353134155,
-0.2057509422302246,
0.3963472843170166,
0.6718270182609558,
0.12743641436100006,
-0.7283200025558472,
-0.19776608049869537,
-0.1351080685853958,
0.12305759638547897,
0.1125093325972557,
1.0602288246154785,
-0.632196307182312,
0.026918955147266388,
0.588191568851471,
1.0908929109573364,
0.7392804026603699,
0.17372801899909973,
0.4198067784309387,
-0.6637923121452332,
0.5175639390945435,
-0.05594687536358833,
0.5248304605484009,
0.40763968229293823,
-0.44752174615859985,
0.7976371645927429,
0.21164368093013763,
-0.6815314888954163,
-1.0426040887832642,
0.19354422390460968,
-0.8442344665527344,
-0.4180090129375458,
1.169480562210083,
0.022901207208633423,
-0.5938369035720825,
0.1823624074459076,
-0.2717176079750061,
0.2553882598876953,
-0.1510366052389145,
0.6553574800491333,
0.6595972180366516,
-0.3324163556098938,
-0.42146381735801697,
-0.6403318047523499,
0.23897849023342133,
0.7709920406341553,
-0.873201310634613,
0.17876768112182617,
0.4023555517196655,
0.0071811252273619175,
0.3016107976436615,
0.29801979660987854,
0.11023776233196259,
0.015576285310089588,
0.30116596817970276,
-0.08105725049972534,
-0.06633657962083817,
-0.48018407821655273,
-0.4465318024158478,
0.25689634680747986,
-0.05064151808619499,
0.06223573908209801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02269v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02269v1
|
Extracting Norms from Contracts Via ChatGPT: Opportunities and Challenges
| 2024-04-02T19:49:34 | 2024-04-02T19:49:34 |
Amanul Haque, Munindar P. Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate the effectiveness of ChatGPT in extracting norms from
contracts. Norms provide a natural way to engineer multiagent systems by
capturing how to govern the interactions between two or more autonomous
parties. We extract norms of commitment, prohibition, authorization, and power,
along with associated norm elements (the parties involved, antecedents, and
consequents) from contracts. Our investigation reveals ChatGPT's effectiveness
and limitations in norm extraction from contracts. ChatGPT demonstrates
promising performance in norm extraction without requiring training or
fine-tuning, thus obviating the need for annotated data, which is not generally
available in this domain. However, we found some limitations of ChatGPT in
extracting these norms that lead to incorrect norm extractions. The limitations
include oversight of crucial details, hallucination, incorrect parsing of
conjunctions, and empty norm elements. Enhanced norm extraction from contracts
can foster the development of more transparent and trustworthy formal agent
interaction specifications, thereby contributing to the improvement of
multiagent systems.
|
[
-0.3824232518672943,
-0.6434423327445984,
0.3742503821849823,
0.17597165703773499,
-0.22264590859413147,
-0.0918785110116005,
-0.09048769623041153,
-0.804841160774231,
-0.13585646450519562,
0.5954234004020691,
-0.2565705180168152,
-0.2036755084991455,
-0.8995742201805115,
-0.15049679577350616,
0.03785828500986099,
1.1939926147460938,
0.1919310837984085,
-0.35284918546676636,
-0.0009166082018055022,
0.1084229126572609,
-0.6166731715202332,
-0.5267226099967957,
-0.4904603660106659,
-0.3458263576030731,
0.042943451553583145,
0.4647153317928314,
0.785287618637085,
0.5662866830825806,
0.5494334101676941,
0.26612141728401184,
0.1639697551727295,
0.3663827180862427,
-0.29936376214027405,
0.07926606386899948,
0.3539898097515106,
0.07512577623128891,
-0.788565993309021,
0.7641901969909668,
0.6784884929656982,
0.09027104824781418,
-0.2834782302379608,
-0.06463853269815445,
0.15515293180942535,
0.485750287771225,
-0.503944456577301,
0.8929499387741089,
-0.7660589814186096,
-0.058258332312107086,
-0.1092095747590065,
-0.2748948335647583,
-0.402517169713974,
-0.3133985698223114,
0.209748312830925,
-0.7537000179290771,
-0.12522786855697632,
-0.0782260075211525,
1.3848788738250732,
0.2367536574602127,
-0.5839957594871521,
-0.6404247283935547,
-0.5492163300514221,
0.40957602858543396,
-0.5476352572441101,
0.6800436973571777,
0.33477455377578735,
0.40490326285362244,
-0.09316464513540268,
-0.9238060712814331,
-0.2504512071609497,
-0.6089833378791809,
-0.22414541244506836,
0.5158807039260864,
-0.27345579862594604,
0.31302690505981445,
0.37283650040626526,
0.20935460925102234,
-0.23670797049999237,
-0.17414988577365875,
-0.5940946936607361,
-0.3737015128135681,
0.7992506623268127,
-0.10925004631280899,
0.0918552428483963,
-0.37416964769363403,
-0.5857021808624268,
0.18864808976650238,
-0.4810636043548584,
0.3671596348285675,
0.7417232394218445,
0.3560121953487396,
-0.0725536122918129,
0.6755966544151306,
0.16391237080097198,
0.13700850307941437,
-0.0959944799542427,
0.04784345254302025,
0.2888354957103729,
-0.3558133840560913,
-0.1344563066959381,
-0.3503125011920929,
0.7331424355506897,
0.3334173560142517,
0.47689318656921387,
-0.46539437770843506,
-0.28398653864860535,
-0.31174564361572266,
0.2237759530544281,
-0.552202582359314,
-0.3907814919948578,
0.13709861040115356,
-0.4018426835536957,
-0.2921285331249237,
0.4790399968624115,
-0.9016166925430298,
-0.3362452983856201,
-0.5222412943840027,
0.3261032700538635,
-0.6357844471931458,
-0.5102636814117432,
0.01532203983515501,
-0.6051124930381775,
0.984008252620697,
0.2191706895828247,
-0.6109374165534973,
0.5662901401519775,
0.8934333920478821,
0.8951842784881592,
0.060929976403713226,
-0.0343402661383152,
-0.660709023475647,
-0.24303635954856873,
-0.003414014121517539,
0.5552902221679688,
-0.537378191947937,
-0.45115986466407776,
-0.2129453420639038,
-0.11277136206626892,
-0.29677915573120117,
-0.24803723394870758,
0.19579626619815826,
-0.5590546727180481,
-0.4265274107456207,
0.14326871931552887,
-0.6113486289978027,
0.4123227894306183,
0.5293349623680115,
-0.6501427292823792,
0.7866266369819641,
-0.07877042144536972,
-0.3174038827419281,
0.49942997097969055,
-1.0223591327667236,
-0.07515045255422592,
0.2491023987531662,
-0.42328834533691406,
-0.6393206715583801,
-0.20582962036132812,
0.03629615902900696,
0.3279935121536255,
-0.009487943723797798,
-0.04147316515445709,
-0.046942126005887985,
-0.05292897671461105,
0.6420891880989075,
-0.43671220541000366,
1.0456393957138062,
0.598737359046936,
-0.030359821394085884,
-0.032153163105249405,
-0.5861545205116272,
-0.12234410643577576,
0.0756552517414093,
-0.4033028781414032,
0.09502363204956055,
0.049993425607681274,
0.07609342783689499,
0.28654944896698,
0.32864680886268616,
-0.6999534964561462,
0.24513943493366241,
-0.05697130039334297,
0.504086971282959,
1.0101858377456665,
0.3922725319862366,
0.4474763870239258,
-0.40353530645370483,
0.5283706188201904,
-0.27276846766471863,
0.40619751811027527,
0.3748929798603058,
-0.4595972001552582,
-0.1529078185558319,
-0.797175943851471,
0.3224666118621826,
0.4707357883453369,
-0.35105594992637634,
0.11187513917684555,
-0.07206398993730545,
-0.6520241498947144,
-0.4435981214046478,
0.028058065101504326,
0.18053141236305237,
-0.03883619233965874,
0.006158188916742802,
-0.35873308777809143,
-0.5662904381752014,
-0.6962664723396301,
-0.22189848124980927,
-0.33166706562042236,
0.31605997681617737,
0.4156505763530731,
0.3551434278488159,
0.060366034507751465,
1.1810396909713745,
-0.4429301917552948,
-0.4229848086833954,
-0.053739648312330246,
0.0336303673684597,
0.026083165779709816,
0.7196388244628906,
0.29183706641197205,
-1.0470761060714722,
-0.4372473955154419,
0.292510986328125,
-0.5037339925765991,
0.15468043088912964,
-0.2552836537361145,
0.055841319262981415,
-0.27244916558265686,
0.9270841479301453,
-0.5071557760238647,
0.34812983870506287,
0.25710952281951904,
-0.48285624384880066,
1.0819525718688965,
-0.22851206362247467,
0.10819193720817566,
-0.6575847864151001,
0.0015356754884123802,
-0.2017282396554947,
-0.6018059849739075,
-0.5434170961380005,
0.08204531669616699,
0.15914767980575562,
-0.17668627202510834,
-0.27750110626220703,
0.07371117174625397,
-0.6458606719970703,
0.010832891799509525,
0.04302963614463806,
0.129354327917099,
-0.056286849081516266,
0.33069998025894165,
-0.09148695319890976,
0.9213535785675049,
0.46152248978614807,
-0.6053647398948669,
0.32708755135536194,
0.41586458683013916,
0.10325183719396591,
0.773849368095398,
-0.7164681553840637,
0.31150856614112854,
-0.03455700725317001,
-0.23268398642539978,
-0.6533435583114624,
0.04991902783513069,
0.45594796538352966,
-0.5792913436889648,
0.20631790161132812,
-0.8522962331771851,
-0.21837688982486725,
0.3587203919887543,
-0.23822659254074097,
0.006890831049531698,
0.7008238434791565,
-0.040337592363357544,
0.4202839732170105,
0.838714599609375,
0.21859753131866455,
-0.7430088520050049,
-0.14686793088912964,
0.18175026774406433,
-0.29534977674484253,
-0.18415586650371552,
-0.25283440947532654,
0.20149795711040497,
-0.4590720534324646,
-0.0016413842095062137,
-0.23020599782466888,
-0.3764447569847107,
0.3839969336986542,
0.6233417987823486,
0.10905464738607407,
0.06847237795591354,
0.06222419813275337,
-0.3047502636909485,
-0.3512008786201477,
0.20492777228355408,
-0.2453305572271347,
0.30619099736213684,
-0.5407143235206604,
-0.3668813407421112,
-0.16532741487026215,
0.41554415225982666,
0.6336730718612671,
-0.5707769393920898,
0.3767622411251068,
0.8488864302635193,
-0.28103509545326233,
0.15230010449886322,
-0.422074556350708,
-0.06822080910205841,
-0.40665552020072937,
0.1740662008523941,
-0.7248349785804749,
-0.8488609194755554,
0.5089523196220398,
-0.31012651324272156,
0.48761969804763794,
0.5173873901367188,
0.2710442543029785,
0.03862624987959862,
0.5866694450378418,
0.7993660569190979,
0.33423227071762085,
0.7421912550926208,
-0.1078786551952362,
-0.0567627027630806,
-0.8393524885177612,
-0.3795754015445709,
-0.7011325359344482,
0.3860968351364136,
-0.7978533506393433,
-0.00017824153474066406,
0.6086980104446411,
-0.20836199820041656,
0.20804883539676666,
0.5545979738235474,
-0.30120450258255005,
0.42090141773223877,
0.5176169276237488,
0.33360838890075684,
0.4853460490703583,
-0.29046541452407837,
0.16766242682933807,
0.1850220113992691,
-0.4062764346599579,
-0.6216097474098206,
0.8623774647712708,
0.40714511275291443,
0.4161163568496704,
0.3884134888648987,
0.8313474059104919,
0.5001016855239868,
-0.01676337420940399,
-1.0793720483779907,
0.33523958921432495,
0.34488940238952637,
-0.7137465476989746,
-0.6698364019393921,
-0.5460563898086548,
-1.4281195402145386,
0.25077134370803833,
-0.2657228112220764,
-1.031265377998352,
0.4640617072582245,
-0.17476074397563934,
-0.2658501863479614,
-0.023045942187309265,
-0.8128083348274231,
0.8936744332313538,
0.5209845900535583,
-0.03080238774418831,
0.025302693247795105,
-0.812464714050293,
0.11431488394737244,
0.06652147322893143,
0.2861078679561615,
-0.444000780582428,
0.06244182586669922,
0.75790935754776,
-0.476025253534317,
0.8883339166641235,
-0.14827652275562286,
-0.22009100019931793,
0.5347740054130554,
0.18615153431892395,
0.6270837187767029,
0.5829405188560486,
-0.15119414031505585,
0.07794996351003647,
0.40252283215522766,
-0.44252485036849976,
-0.25117799639701843,
0.14070148766040802,
-0.9944210648536682,
-0.20443548262119293,
-0.5233123302459717,
-0.8741873502731323,
-0.24684451520442963,
0.18301254510879517,
0.08238232135772705,
0.4262121915817261,
-0.4203556776046753,
-0.03846871107816696,
0.20366038382053375,
0.4701772630214691,
0.52547687292099,
0.25504258275032043,
0.22382168471813202,
-0.10792829841375351,
0.9202423095703125,
0.35152506828308105,
0.4350622892379761,
-0.28488847613334656,
0.05672246590256691,
-0.3008870780467987,
-0.5719302296638489,
-0.0589611642062664,
-0.08806005865335464,
-0.5917927622795105,
-0.13722582161426544,
-0.5868383646011353,
-0.44258707761764526,
-0.8073406219482422,
0.0519673228263855,
-0.6203923225402832,
-0.39849257469177246,
0.12644457817077637,
0.07799101620912552,
0.30139225721359253,
0.7015813589096069,
-0.7772261500358582,
0.10074373334646225,
-0.8775309324264526,
0.09302058070898056,
0.6386691331863403,
0.2836865484714508,
-0.6760660409927368,
-0.041065577417612076,
-0.1779221147298813,
-0.22326450049877167,
-0.19980506598949432,
-1.0952914953231812,
0.24191749095916748,
0.25232353806495667,
0.6403092741966248,
0.23833723366260529,
0.24956060945987701,
0.6221067309379578,
-0.3724368214607239,
0.6504530906677246,
-0.06275114417076111,
-1.1459797620773315,
0.1860121637582779,
-0.3648192286491394,
-0.13191883265972137,
0.33778998255729675,
-0.0737900510430336,
-0.6723311543464661,
-0.5756381154060364,
-1.1381100416183472,
-0.7130540013313293,
0.5816757678985596,
0.8163213729858398,
-0.09702973812818527,
0.09506045281887054,
0.577755331993103,
0.13837654888629913,
0.13252541422843933,
-0.6891767978668213,
0.016773110255599022,
-0.11240625381469727,
0.3081827461719513,
0.06181919202208519,
-0.215076744556427,
-0.29995742440223694,
0.3358854055404663,
0.6921538710594177,
-0.013353269547224045,
0.49245619773864746,
0.4823797643184662,
-0.3188041150569916,
0.23600052297115326,
0.5762743353843689,
0.2849084138870239,
0.8128941059112549,
-0.21908631920814514,
0.34193041920661926,
0.15860100090503693,
-0.7490084767341614,
0.06769537180662155,
0.4676647484302521,
0.06742250174283981,
-0.19294743239879608,
0.2982313930988312,
0.24934521317481995,
-0.34158939123153687,
-0.3812602460384369,
0.65264892578125,
-0.1738896667957306,
-0.34071439504623413,
-0.5296708345413208,
-0.20216743648052216,
-0.5313728451728821,
0.7749682068824768,
0.12346170842647552,
0.15033107995986938,
0.23546119034290314,
-0.100216343998909,
0.6506392955780029,
0.6917952299118042,
-0.8964595794677734,
-0.1773413121700287,
0.25628232955932617,
-0.13930697739124298,
-0.042376305907964706,
0.47372159361839294,
-0.4020592272281647,
-0.16764843463897705,
0.7701000571250916,
0.3842940032482147,
0.5974428057670593,
0.15686744451522827,
0.4448995590209961,
0.07885295152664185,
0.7717846035957336,
0.2985515296459198,
-0.013757397420704365,
-0.06727607548236847,
-0.9480956196784973,
-0.5567952990531921,
0.007901369594037533,
-0.5589262843132019,
-0.20727339386940002,
-0.6728674173355103,
0.09862112998962402,
-0.3405064344406128,
-0.21528996527194977,
0.09781130403280258,
0.22759635746479034,
-0.7842802405357361,
-0.4378413259983063,
-0.0176564808934927,
0.46017301082611084,
-0.8033703565597534,
0.6942968368530273,
0.6545342803001404,
-0.6526541709899902,
-0.9750956892967224,
-0.27454641461372375,
0.18893006443977356,
-0.8616719841957092,
0.16054512560367584,
-0.19420352578163147,
-0.0651060938835144,
0.21111246943473816,
-0.7201533913612366,
-0.33391958475112915,
0.9646844267845154,
0.4583972096443176,
-0.020631173625588417,
0.109084852039814,
0.048409946262836456,
0.013957519084215164,
0.056423529982566833,
0.21112893521785736,
0.8158602118492126,
0.6757919788360596,
-0.060992222279310226,
-1.1657629013061523,
0.2524569034576416,
-0.2255062758922577,
-0.5768396258354187,
0.23010657727718353,
-0.589440107345581,
0.7779268622398376,
0.1334117352962494,
-0.3434416651725769,
-0.2274388074874878,
0.5109840035438538,
-0.026991434395313263,
0.0963275134563446,
0.7423999905586243,
-0.0513385571539402,
0.7809090614318848,
0.06479974836111069,
0.657609224319458,
0.19877056777477264,
0.7744048237800598,
0.5257109999656677,
-0.11227717995643616,
0.2493758648633957,
0.7989979386329651,
-0.010512864217162132,
0.013004432432353497,
0.4755421578884125,
0.07582873106002808,
0.12859021127223969,
0.028447337448596954,
-0.07105494290590286,
-0.4888715147972107,
-0.23619869351387024,
-0.33347344398498535,
0.7337466478347778,
0.358449786901474,
0.36058974266052246,
-0.40426111221313477,
-0.30345600843429565,
0.26384127140045166,
-0.21144819259643555,
0.003350765211507678,
1.2622679471969604,
0.2051118165254593,
-0.24058878421783447,
-0.0722336396574974,
-0.2086065262556076,
0.1055217906832695,
-0.5540236234664917,
-0.45523521304130554,
0.21910376846790314,
0.053225334733724594,
-0.21858932077884674,
-0.6134918928146362,
0.415735125541687,
-0.1720046103000641,
0.377547949552536,
-0.43743693828582764,
0.9973689913749695,
-0.2811964154243469,
0.09006348997354507,
-0.15333718061447144,
0.9069064855575562,
0.46045514941215515,
-0.25349876284599304,
-0.7465654611587524,
-0.10040764510631561,
-0.28600966930389404,
-0.24022337794303894,
0.11888109892606735,
0.8367739915847778,
0.18546351790428162,
0.19897912442684174,
0.6629551649093628,
0.2809188663959503,
0.07037054747343063,
-0.4621872901916504,
0.7910813689231873,
-0.28918737173080444,
-0.42844241857528687,
-0.9613763689994812,
0.6182796359062195,
-0.45108869671821594,
-0.2435676008462906,
0.6923823356628418,
0.4105166494846344,
0.3397323191165924,
0.022555500268936157,
0.7681542038917542,
-0.455279678106308,
-0.28016653656959534,
-0.7028684616088867,
0.6542328000068665,
-0.07464637607336044,
0.11681640148162842,
-0.2430979311466217,
-0.6630789041519165,
-0.42299923300743103,
0.44906774163246155,
-0.18777959048748016,
-0.3225596845149994,
0.5872916579246521,
0.7115871906280518,
-0.22191645205020905,
-0.1734636276960373,
0.4338930547237396,
-0.12527960538864136,
0.9136331677436829,
0.3176138699054718,
0.7872235178947449,
-0.4920855164527893,
0.9816374182701111,
0.042532939463853836,
-0.5041764974594116,
-0.06347795575857162,
-0.8677231073379517,
-0.7664650082588196,
-0.7713095545768738,
-0.4029024541378021,
-0.5265259742736816,
0.09272661060094833,
1.248679518699646,
0.9248353242874146,
-0.45396000146865845,
-0.411847323179245,
-0.008502024225890636,
0.32552167773246765,
-0.713871955871582,
-0.2502502202987671,
0.28922736644744873,
-0.9550338387489319,
-0.6116393208503723,
0.3647279143333435,
0.11147721856832504,
0.10259673744440079,
0.2691461741924286,
-0.34381023049354553,
-0.24180032312870026,
0.1410902440547943,
0.3444642424583435,
0.5053139925003052,
-0.11304203420877457,
-0.8046813011169434,
-0.16623757779598236,
-0.30207040905952454,
0.19707797467708588,
1.0190308094024658,
-0.11129021644592285,
0.34667032957077026,
0.27474695444107056,
0.5157861709594727,
0.6718969941139221,
-0.1291274130344391,
0.644241988658905,
-1.080582857131958,
0.31582745909690857,
0.22743017971515656,
0.26141035556793213,
-0.31459420919418335,
-0.4162343144416809,
0.6667408347129822,
0.22258591651916504,
-0.7212973237037659,
-0.44717496633529663,
0.49454227089881897,
-1.2224408388137817,
0.019651811569929123,
1.1583768129348755,
-0.34460005164146423,
0.13443079590797424,
-0.8447437882423401,
-0.5241498351097107,
0.5902541875839233,
-0.4915006756782532,
0.47011446952819824,
0.6597315073013306,
-0.19720758497714996,
-0.33017948269844055,
-0.8843941688537598,
0.8553599119186401,
0.022161446511745453,
-0.7787163853645325,
0.16251417994499207,
0.5671436786651611,
-0.005675426218658686,
0.12018493562936783,
0.9111215472221375,
-0.5974132418632507,
0.26033148169517517,
0.2899915874004364,
0.12918289005756378,
-0.44462624192237854,
-0.14620716869831085,
-0.15450388193130493,
0.5196529030799866,
0.3988165557384491,
-0.5983880758285522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06650v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06650v1
|
Large Language Models as Planning Domain Generators
| 2024-04-02T19:39:23 | 2024-04-02T19:39:23 |
James Oswald, Kavitha Srinivas, Harsha Kokel, Junkyu Lee, Michael Katz, Shirin Sohrabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Developing domain models is one of the few remaining places that require
manual human labor in AI planning. Thus, in order to make planning more
accessible, it is desirable to automate the process of domain model generation.
To this end, we investigate if large language models (LLMs) can be used to
generate planning domain models from simple textual descriptions. Specifically,
we introduce a framework for automated evaluation of LLM-generated domains by
comparing the sets of plans for domain instances. Finally, we perform an
empirical analysis of 7 large language models, including coding and chat models
across 9 different planning domains, and under three classes of natural
language domain descriptions. Our results indicate that LLMs, particularly
those with high parameter counts, exhibit a moderate level of proficiency in
generating correct planning domains from natural language descriptions. Our
code is available at https://github.com/IBM/NL2PDDL.
|
[
-0.4266638159751892,
-0.8376546502113342,
0.7950209975242615,
0.3825184106826782,
0.008164787665009499,
-0.17922180891036987,
-0.5366743206977844,
-0.47662147879600525,
0.06347116827964783,
0.9187321066856384,
-0.5691013932228088,
-0.2920532822608948,
-0.40672892332077026,
0.18411879241466522,
-0.46661999821662903,
0.6418208479881287,
-0.20101258158683777,
-0.039514120668172836,
-0.41357406973838806,
0.31734487414360046,
-0.5695257782936096,
-0.510168194770813,
-0.7474907040596008,
-0.49474114179611206,
0.17987723648548126,
0.2605918049812317,
0.7145593762397766,
0.5694475769996643,
0.44468241930007935,
0.3123645484447479,
0.24433915317058563,
0.3689918518066406,
-0.3432515561580658,
0.1603938490152359,
-0.023367149755358696,
-0.10078660398721695,
-0.738987147808075,
-0.1033429428935051,
0.7054698467254639,
0.9877350926399231,
-0.10811101645231247,
0.15678337216377258,
-0.10883999615907669,
0.4816565215587616,
-0.42052438855171204,
0.47063344717025757,
-0.9353669881820679,
-0.10937110334634781,
0.08697126060724258,
-0.32053816318511963,
-0.5174362659454346,
-0.11257763206958771,
0.37483295798301697,
-0.3183012008666992,
0.09003708511590958,
0.1573624461889267,
0.6770990490913391,
0.07212812453508377,
-0.3349320590496063,
-0.5179240107536316,
-1.0710408687591553,
0.914238452911377,
-0.9378324747085571,
0.14960268139839172,
0.5931060910224915,
0.47822073101997375,
-0.41483283042907715,
-0.6575528383255005,
-0.7744734883308411,
-0.4492443799972534,
-0.17409926652908325,
-0.20220011472702026,
-0.19111673533916473,
0.028821751475334167,
0.47724220156669617,
0.047484949231147766,
-0.6229943633079529,
0.3526323139667511,
-0.40279364585876465,
-0.026663238182663918,
1.09804368019104,
0.48327022790908813,
0.3998439908027649,
-0.18489712476730347,
-0.18576443195343018,
0.26496341824531555,
-0.8999525904655457,
-0.31137892603874207,
0.39533329010009766,
0.40923774242401123,
-0.02455919235944748,
0.836097240447998,
-0.2645847201347351,
0.748683512210846,
-0.4547666907310486,
-0.2276960015296936,
-0.3769969344139099,
-0.29871150851249695,
-0.5792427659034729,
-0.24346253275871277,
0.6553385257720947,
0.46246153116226196,
0.7210991978645325,
-0.1917686015367508,
-0.4760074019432068,
-0.01646655797958374,
0.4658656120300293,
-0.8469028472900391,
-0.26577839255332947,
0.28252753615379333,
-0.42503058910369873,
-0.18429268896579742,
-0.3575581908226013,
-0.530778169631958,
-0.18785685300827026,
-0.5191423892974854,
0.0108480928465724,
-0.35853826999664307,
-0.2197023332118988,
0.32348549365997314,
0.11497443169355392,
0.36465984582901,
0.3724362552165985,
-0.8153237700462341,
0.5343686938285828,
0.8190399408340454,
0.38728341460227966,
-0.256123423576355,
-0.5681085586547852,
-0.33960941433906555,
0.22271840274333954,
-0.6435563564300537,
0.8663027286529541,
-0.3587179481983185,
-0.6118580102920532,
0.5852063894271851,
-0.30678749084472656,
0.07646068930625916,
-0.6971220970153809,
0.3505900800228119,
-0.6665411591529846,
0.023441771045327187,
0.1996266394853592,
-0.7642436623573303,
0.01876641809940338,
0.2732641398906708,
-0.765935480594635,
0.6966552734375,
-0.04627816006541252,
-0.15555666387081146,
0.44125792384147644,
-0.6638128757476807,
-0.6616583466529846,
0.3301011323928833,
-0.2499183714389801,
-0.34180718660354614,
-0.12692326307296753,
0.052574485540390015,
0.7497132420539856,
-0.6730687022209167,
0.5436124801635742,
-0.02006307616829872,
0.14235226809978485,
0.4947763979434967,
-0.19931353628635406,
0.6753829717636108,
0.1931856870651245,
-0.29300588369369507,
0.11482511460781097,
-0.6136277318000793,
0.43068626523017883,
0.28642189502716064,
-0.4688703119754791,
-0.012252310290932655,
0.3494444191455841,
0.11337587237358093,
0.12385870516300201,
0.27666500210762024,
-0.0024297861382365227,
0.4321262836456299,
-0.34020349383354187,
0.3233722746372223,
0.4923863410949707,
0.0845554769039154,
0.575043261051178,
-0.2801421582698822,
0.6033126711845398,
-0.5273976922035217,
-0.17763474583625793,
-0.20863454043865204,
-0.5726748108863831,
-0.7701610922813416,
-0.1449325531721115,
0.2413291186094284,
0.19264979660511017,
-0.7384570240974426,
0.5208536982536316,
-0.42905521392822266,
-0.416086345911026,
0.030636858195066452,
0.05479668080806732,
0.36395063996315,
0.024874873459339142,
0.040216561406850815,
-0.16897433996200562,
-0.5635233521461487,
-0.8353947401046753,
-0.09139297902584076,
-0.2764919400215149,
-0.07362007349729538,
0.3211539089679718,
0.5525762438774109,
-0.3237566351890564,
1.038150668144226,
-0.5866614580154419,
-0.16665810346603394,
-0.7131699919700623,
0.06858798861503601,
-0.135645791888237,
0.04936846345663071,
0.6569356322288513,
-0.669442355632782,
-0.5680202841758728,
-0.0727066844701767,
-0.6529379487037659,
-0.10940910130739212,
-0.32715457677841187,
-0.19148676097393036,
0.30936747789382935,
0.180197611451149,
-0.9127964377403259,
0.45288124680519104,
0.28226161003112793,
-0.14929480850696564,
0.7551358938217163,
-0.14688614010810852,
-0.26214152574539185,
-0.9179007411003113,
0.05662759020924568,
0.0640350729227066,
-0.20892959833145142,
-0.829997718334198,
0.2314823418855667,
-0.14895972609519958,
-0.3376857042312622,
-0.29029062390327454,
0.8393129110336304,
-0.6646666526794434,
-0.4365714490413666,
-0.6283261179924011,
0.12535449862480164,
-0.10081945359706879,
0.4862731993198395,
0.2887386679649353,
0.6965545415878296,
0.5150224566459656,
-0.8629571199417114,
0.21199196577072144,
0.38708069920539856,
-0.5674245953559875,
0.14136329293251038,
-0.48023054003715515,
0.11025560647249222,
0.22506749629974365,
0.3737872838973999,
-0.5765241384506226,
-0.642207145690918,
-0.23135891556739807,
-0.25824376940727234,
0.23628661036491394,
-0.29477158188819885,
-0.602756679058075,
-0.5891548991203308,
-0.01572120189666748,
0.04269789159297943,
0.5990384817123413,
-0.3679836094379425,
0.5161216259002686,
0.694908082485199,
-0.483908474445343,
-0.12636393308639526,
-0.5536807179450989,
0.21724459528923035,
-0.014522873796522617,
-0.6722064018249512,
0.24593421816825867,
-0.0396367609500885,
-0.5145847797393799,
-0.15064233541488647,
0.30148619413375854,
-0.33341261744499207,
0.05409581959247589,
0.26708313822746277,
0.384743332862854,
-0.21177026629447937,
0.009705021977424622,
-0.19958950579166412,
-0.0374012291431427,
0.3286588191986084,
-0.4000651240348816,
0.8568000197410583,
0.23118872940540314,
-0.29609057307243347,
-0.3215535879135132,
0.4477866291999817,
0.49276962876319885,
-0.4110855758190155,
0.4620773196220398,
-0.023563791066408157,
-0.7135529518127441,
-0.5534507036209106,
-0.2921511232852936,
0.16530047357082367,
-0.44492584466934204,
0.3710411489009857,
-0.38984811305999756,
-0.5887933969497681,
0.3459591865539551,
-0.24990981817245483,
0.3055609464645386,
0.6400765776634216,
0.8662098050117493,
0.2003876268863678,
1.1231070756912231,
0.986270546913147,
0.09693221002817154,
-0.016086868941783905,
-0.35784754157066345,
0.2920082211494446,
-0.5019060373306274,
0.03648799657821655,
-0.6272507309913635,
-0.09691594541072845,
-0.3566710948944092,
-0.5350127220153809,
0.026540284976363182,
-0.056469522416591644,
-0.11137834191322327,
0.33853843808174133,
-0.2551867365837097,
0.57138592004776,
0.288565456867218,
-0.6915154457092285,
0.17386454343795776,
0.20296621322631836,
0.1225023940205574,
0.07703419029712677,
-0.5284469723701477,
-1.1689984798431396,
1.1662170886993408,
0.31343796849250793,
0.718166172504425,
-0.032354697585105896,
0.5410074591636658,
0.38163667917251587,
0.3138783276081085,
-0.9022672772407532,
0.8293789625167847,
-0.15908464789390564,
-0.5302855968475342,
-0.5444233417510986,
-0.35573524236679077,
-0.9840922355651855,
-0.13165521621704102,
-0.32658112049102783,
-0.4887217879295349,
-0.02221045270562172,
-0.048662155866622925,
-0.37755998969078064,
0.2544436454772949,
-0.5680163502693176,
0.6237471699714661,
-0.46894729137420654,
0.13812124729156494,
-0.3253253698348999,
-0.16474492847919464,
0.36593329906463623,
-0.4599357545375824,
0.0763586163520813,
-0.31430357694625854,
0.15610115230083466,
0.7366911768913269,
-0.47700682282447815,
0.7646864056587219,
-0.12718872725963593,
-0.28681981563568115,
0.5360910892486572,
0.29950758814811707,
0.56266850233078,
-0.15867607295513153,
-0.34757575392723083,
0.06426098197698593,
-0.3437338173389435,
-0.29872944951057434,
-0.3125450015068054,
0.6722598075866699,
-0.7661464214324951,
-0.37040960788726807,
0.015916183590888977,
-0.5606063604354858,
-0.31065890192985535,
0.37980592250823975,
0.02918804995715618,
0.4649122655391693,
-0.6266717314720154,
-0.2194243222475052,
0.21668457984924316,
-0.5449513792991638,
0.4448966085910797,
0.4686073660850525,
-0.6532881259918213,
-0.055711664259433746,
0.7106117606163025,
0.06732620298862457,
0.4248603880405426,
0.16285286843776703,
-0.11476533859968185,
-0.11175825446844101,
-0.7749704718589783,
-0.5128194689750671,
0.21218588948249817,
-0.5626106858253479,
-0.31225427985191345,
-0.6199213266372681,
-0.4927697479724884,
-0.5004525780677795,
-0.30510184168815613,
-0.28939127922058105,
-0.47641104459762573,
0.16582432389259338,
-0.02729691006243229,
0.050595611333847046,
1.1865859031677246,
0.3617280125617981,
0.5100387334823608,
-0.5632821917533875,
0.34592071175575256,
0.36877456307411194,
0.153016597032547,
0.008920285850763321,
-0.10134731233119965,
-0.3306000232696533,
0.19856394827365875,
-0.3088885247707367,
-0.5330109596252441,
0.8800697922706604,
0.23251667618751526,
0.49953094124794006,
0.18552808463573456,
-0.0017582717118784785,
0.5789464116096497,
-0.9283530712127686,
0.9229063987731934,
-0.021998295560479164,
-0.6687521934509277,
0.5408270359039307,
-0.24952124059200287,
0.11818678677082062,
0.1538543999195099,
0.5476019382476807,
-0.22860018908977509,
-0.39834463596343994,
-0.6496811509132385,
-0.7982751727104187,
0.6394613981246948,
0.22678549587726593,
0.40590909123420715,
-0.14881202578544617,
0.29625454545021057,
0.21963340044021606,
0.1836729496717453,
-0.6264225244522095,
-0.1797499805688858,
0.3410983979701996,
0.13077811896800995,
0.0473516620695591,
-0.5668029189109802,
-0.22608770430088043,
0.22447749972343445,
0.6238795518875122,
-0.19809763133525848,
0.6889380216598511,
-0.2825031876564026,
-0.1526515781879425,
-0.46188098192214966,
0.17225851118564606,
0.6891453862190247,
1.0581483840942383,
0.0738762840628624,
0.09898896515369415,
0.13594888150691986,
-0.1747671365737915,
-0.20164282619953156,
0.06198553740978241,
-0.048669010400772095,
-0.025612303987145424,
0.6111996173858643,
0.705897867679596,
0.025662627071142197,
-0.8687857985496521,
0.4238937795162201,
-0.20190493762493134,
-0.4366174340248108,
-0.6275639533996582,
0.03679807484149933,
0.13722962141036987,
0.15012988448143005,
0.36975353956222534,
-0.14651380479335785,
-0.06370359659194946,
-0.6121441721916199,
0.16971813142299652,
0.4379312992095947,
0.12311970442533493,
-0.3098447322845459,
0.5268890261650085,
0.28853753209114075,
-0.62223219871521,
0.8479514718055725,
-0.19146069884300232,
-0.5717000961303711,
0.7247775197029114,
0.678528904914856,
1.0038392543792725,
0.12224339693784714,
0.06612898409366608,
0.16309699416160583,
0.21930329501628876,
0.1506519615650177,
0.23062404990196228,
0.24646291136741638,
-0.7300482392311096,
-0.7568901181221008,
-0.8311249613761902,
-0.5287162661552429,
0.11419524997472763,
-0.23452430963516235,
0.473137229681015,
-0.41656947135925293,
-0.14550602436065674,
0.23996521532535553,
0.07609295845031738,
-0.8168489336967468,
0.1567840278148651,
0.34257012605667114,
0.890388011932373,
-0.5134255886077881,
0.9362152218818665,
0.7699919939041138,
-0.2658160626888275,
-0.8226946592330933,
0.26803961396217346,
-0.2292618453502655,
-0.8273075222969055,
0.9415586590766907,
0.07679228484630585,
-0.10062205791473389,
-0.16556496918201447,
-0.6266546249389648,
-0.6119073033332825,
1.0691261291503906,
0.06089043989777565,
-0.4882606863975525,
-0.2629120349884033,
0.6045100092887878,
0.6825905442237854,
-0.7215383648872375,
-0.06925080716609955,
0.33310645818710327,
0.4295855164527893,
-0.10111987590789795,
-1.1377979516983032,
-0.17313027381896973,
-0.05953224003314972,
-0.05239434912800789,
0.19211196899414062,
-0.2432650327682495,
0.8332837820053101,
-0.21598434448242188,
-0.41718927025794983,
0.3697828948497772,
0.6053349375724792,
0.19060824811458588,
0.09298136085271835,
0.3869657516479492,
0.12048441916704178,
0.6005115509033203,
0.07035677134990692,
1.30307137966156,
-0.4762108623981476,
0.179033562541008,
1.1098281145095825,
-0.7744264006614685,
1.0027896165847778,
0.0249027106910944,
-0.21837978065013885,
0.2582181990146637,
0.3605297803878784,
0.18525898456573486,
0.26280656456947327,
0.20323511958122253,
-0.02956700511276722,
-0.3204866647720337,
0.18683822453022003,
-0.06787312030792236,
0.4924205243587494,
0.49050673842430115,
-0.2712863087654114,
-0.18658605217933655,
-0.13738448917865753,
-0.0452294759452343,
0.0734773799777031,
-0.23731258511543274,
0.7862825989723206,
0.16698046028614044,
-0.9109031558036804,
0.5880937576293945,
0.38080886006355286,
0.3144336938858032,
-0.5191077589988708,
-0.0072465622797608376,
-0.06445211917161942,
0.12116388231515884,
0.05323190242052078,
-0.9318783283233643,
0.469681978225708,
0.3376152813434601,
-0.07326768338680267,
-0.575106680393219,
1.0013724565505981,
-0.37565359473228455,
-0.35914406180381775,
0.2438097894191742,
0.7037564516067505,
0.2281084954738617,
0.022965706884860992,
-0.5423065423965454,
-0.1028972789645195,
-0.06941431015729904,
-0.2241867631673813,
0.24160976707935333,
0.5586226582527161,
-0.3310830891132355,
0.7266019582748413,
0.6905824542045593,
0.1974516659975052,
0.19724087417125702,
0.03358511999249458,
0.73078453540802,
-0.6901752948760986,
-0.2888762652873993,
-0.733089804649353,
0.37315261363983154,
-0.08434818685054779,
-0.11575735360383987,
0.5429134964942932,
0.6687458753585815,
0.792503833770752,
-0.31243622303009033,
0.9627308249473572,
-0.10001971572637558,
0.46037349104881287,
-0.6103471517562866,
0.7195075750350952,
-0.37185630202293396,
0.4581778347492218,
0.23399320244789124,
-1.1433912515640259,
-0.2998529374599457,
0.5152615308761597,
-0.4841926693916321,
-0.0302902739495039,
0.443509966135025,
0.6431976556777954,
0.03442290052771568,
-0.22948746383190155,
0.5656260848045349,
0.11993797868490219,
0.5290574431419373,
0.3672085106372833,
1.1110981702804565,
0.0054715415462851524,
0.3720800578594208,
-0.021177932620048523,
-0.1004895493388176,
-0.27421966195106506,
-0.8022261261940002,
-1.0348410606384277,
-0.5603167414665222,
-0.2525533437728882,
-0.06820216029882431,
-0.09968353807926178,
0.8669865131378174,
0.6718622446060181,
-0.5011062026023865,
-0.7127496600151062,
0.08811607211828232,
-0.008467281237244606,
0.22468771040439606,
-0.21394817531108856,
0.19178302586078644,
-0.5002095699310303,
-0.7715632319450378,
0.40501439571380615,
0.29911863803863525,
0.07386117428541183,
-0.7009566426277161,
-0.3743675947189331,
-0.13582436740398407,
0.3620787262916565,
0.8690859079360962,
0.18532532453536987,
-0.7202171087265015,
-0.1044505387544632,
-0.052287422120571136,
-0.4302331507205963,
-0.3287229537963867,
0.9950385689735413,
-0.5393421649932861,
0.06949413567781448,
0.2817268669605255,
0.5629919171333313,
0.43577539920806885,
-0.3674534857273102,
0.9551393389701843,
-0.7622867822647095,
-0.03615912050008774,
0.13382507860660553,
0.5641130208969116,
0.2734062671661377,
-0.1392034888267517,
0.6585087180137634,
-0.3287566304206848,
-0.825421929359436,
-0.7493175268173218,
0.44240906834602356,
-0.8876042366027832,
-0.20901697874069214,
1.4747084379196167,
0.09472456574440002,
-0.27248847484588623,
0.04874035716056824,
-0.32143205404281616,
-0.018860366195440292,
0.016968859359622,
0.7137069702148438,
0.5777757167816162,
-0.16362838447093964,
0.37533509731292725,
-0.8097060918807983,
0.689929187297821,
-0.04198940098285675,
-1.0329622030258179,
0.5169277191162109,
0.7176229357719421,
0.043668877333402634,
0.2101040929555893,
0.9919683933258057,
0.11533496528863907,
0.13053104281425476,
-0.2004396915435791,
0.36688679456710815,
0.20561370253562927,
-0.3817325532436371,
0.10482487082481384,
-0.06965593248605728,
0.5398067831993103,
0.38078150153160095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02261v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02261v2
|
LLMs in the Loop: Leveraging Large Language Model Annotations for Active Learning in Low-Resource Languages
| 2024-04-02T19:34:22 | 2024-06-23T18:21:01 |
Nataliia Kholodna, Sahib Julka, Mohammad Khodadadi, Muhammed Nurullah Gumus, Michael Granitzer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.6
|
Low-resource languages face significant barriers in AI development due to
limited linguistic resources and expertise for data labeling, rendering them
rare and costly. The scarcity of data and the absence of preexisting tools
exacerbate these challenges, especially since these languages may not be
adequately represented in various NLP datasets. To address this gap, we propose
leveraging the potential of LLMs in the active learning loop for data
annotation. Initially, we conduct evaluations to assess inter-annotator
agreement and consistency, facilitating the selection of a suitable LLM
annotator. The chosen annotator is then integrated into a training loop for a
classifier using an active learning paradigm, minimizing the amount of queried
data required. Empirical evaluations, notably employing GPT-4-Turbo,
demonstrate near-state-of-the-art performance with significantly reduced data
requirements, as indicated by estimated potential cost savings of at least
42.45 times compared to human annotation. Our proposed solution shows promising
potential to substantially reduce both the monetary and computational costs
associated with automation in low-resource settings. By bridging the gap
between low-resource languages and AI, this approach fosters broader inclusion
and shows the potential to enable automation across diverse linguistic
landscapes.
|
[
-0.27075597643852234,
-0.705003023147583,
0.44485458731651306,
-0.016945496201515198,
-0.2618444263935089,
0.24464884400367737,
-0.6328771710395813,
-0.5224728584289551,
0.09720154851675034,
0.47059109807014465,
-0.24184444546699524,
-0.38105157017707825,
-0.25086963176727295,
0.2429983913898468,
-0.1250062882900238,
0.7640663981437683,
-0.3179667294025421,
-0.02646685764193535,
-0.28173279762268066,
-0.22306932508945465,
-0.34031835198402405,
-0.5203308463096619,
-0.589884340763092,
-0.43297305703163147,
0.7304399609565735,
0.5058092474937439,
0.713968813419342,
0.9399011135101318,
0.4632783830165863,
0.2650226056575775,
-0.028388667851686478,
0.3753674328327179,
-0.15749171376228333,
0.3977765142917633,
0.1608688086271286,
-0.6414511203765869,
-0.5143725872039795,
0.25323644280433655,
0.8270504474639893,
0.8026343584060669,
0.03158481419086456,
0.2303692251443863,
-0.06673046201467514,
0.4688941538333893,
-0.6269028186798096,
0.3030793070793152,
-0.7238935828208923,
0.061186958104372025,
-0.4267289340496063,
0.09893530607223511,
0.0033498029224574566,
-0.321695476770401,
-0.15984158217906952,
-0.4587550163269043,
-0.1560581922531128,
0.034410521388053894,
0.697625994682312,
0.6321364641189575,
0.02469353936612606,
-0.33928173780441284,
-0.8189948797225952,
0.7191780209541321,
-0.6137403249740601,
0.30162161588668823,
0.6506443023681641,
0.26021742820739746,
0.17701421678066254,
-0.6914510726928711,
-0.6686227321624756,
-0.44781866669654846,
0.08978424966335297,
0.006994163617491722,
-0.16676786541938782,
-0.04269339516758919,
0.4529404938220978,
0.4360959827899933,
-0.26350852847099304,
0.40553945302963257,
-0.3770850896835327,
-0.2233816385269165,
0.5892879962921143,
-0.06134111061692238,
0.09888218343257904,
0.13920383155345917,
-0.16802479326725006,
0.2095373272895813,
-0.7971546649932861,
-0.2183547466993332,
0.45003607869148254,
0.7103573679924011,
-0.15601998567581177,
0.7350636720657349,
0.054949402809143066,
0.6691749095916748,
-0.3408204913139343,
-0.10884659737348557,
0.342957466840744,
-0.22883546352386475,
-0.17476530373096466,
-0.07442586869001389,
0.780525267124176,
-0.1816106140613556,
0.3287421464920044,
-0.2636376917362213,
-0.6256740093231201,
0.1610489934682846,
0.09233669191598892,
-0.44288375973701477,
-0.13185502588748932,
0.01377907395362854,
-0.08267055451869965,
-0.15399804711341858,
-0.22275188565254211,
-0.5882898569107056,
-0.3785136640071869,
-0.36181530356407166,
0.1756119430065155,
-0.11714067310094833,
-0.08691640943288803,
-0.1730649620294571,
0.4105347990989685,
0.05739697068929672,
0.40052804350852966,
-0.7132154703140259,
0.12814632058143616,
0.3932483196258545,
1.1270722150802612,
-0.19392129778862,
-0.25600335001945496,
-0.6018733978271484,
0.2821395993232727,
-0.322162926197052,
0.6978083252906799,
-0.7089467644691467,
-0.21588146686553955,
0.07636331021785736,
-0.008064432069659233,
0.02896413579583168,
-0.6936860084533691,
0.38414809107780457,
-0.4367940425872803,
-0.16471651196479797,
0.08217129856348038,
-0.3820820152759552,
-0.1655241698026657,
0.33591461181640625,
-0.9660872220993042,
1.3541613817214966,
0.10851483792066574,
-0.48268455266952515,
0.21976721286773682,
-0.9116472005844116,
-0.4726886451244354,
0.28801247477531433,
-0.2176724225282669,
-0.5827893614768982,
-0.002853487618267536,
0.04943849518895149,
0.4956437349319458,
-0.2941901981830597,
0.022664334625005722,
-0.4429205358028412,
-0.361605703830719,
0.3086594045162201,
-0.5410722494125366,
0.5077721476554871,
0.317148894071579,
-0.44399312138557434,
0.17203998565673828,
-0.6585838198661804,
-0.24493421614170074,
0.13839802145957947,
-0.6999415755271912,
-0.3124437630176544,
-0.09802289307117462,
-0.021873649209737778,
0.22057336568832397,
0.28174957633018494,
-0.28914159536361694,
0.5414935350418091,
-0.20859353244304657,
0.3164563775062561,
0.8232362866401672,
-0.28027603030204773,
0.620392382144928,
-0.07372830808162689,
0.8378370404243469,
-0.15151093900203705,
-0.03290048614144325,
-0.21474839746952057,
-0.4092700183391571,
-1.018696665763855,
-0.4314281642436981,
0.551038920879364,
0.6700528264045715,
-0.8043979406356812,
0.3202821910381317,
0.03661581873893738,
-0.2998145818710327,
-0.9514839053153992,
0.6148867011070251,
0.23950761556625366,
0.2463218867778778,
0.4154360890388489,
-0.14409993588924408,
-0.43125632405281067,
-0.7704843282699585,
0.16741633415222168,
-0.3721049726009369,
-0.04198961704969406,
0.3438521921634674,
0.42407241463661194,
-0.4877326190471649,
0.923462450504303,
-0.1432970017194748,
-0.303175151348114,
-0.4625522494316101,
0.00810174085199833,
0.18033075332641602,
0.4086587429046631,
0.342946320772171,
-0.6158717274665833,
-0.2677132487297058,
0.13576233386993408,
-0.7607621550559998,
-0.352376788854599,
-0.13149631023406982,
0.05217067897319794,
0.3443455100059509,
0.4914360046386719,
-0.356630802154541,
0.24370494484901428,
0.5491852760314941,
0.019547751173377037,
0.1718187928199768,
-0.17788086831569672,
-0.30009928345680237,
-0.7479528784751892,
0.32165130972862244,
0.038493502885103226,
-0.2114669233560562,
-0.46930158138275146,
-0.22842971980571747,
0.04080897197127342,
-0.25683659315109253,
-0.4375133216381073,
0.6289422512054443,
-0.6263890862464905,
-0.21880298852920532,
-0.3752274811267853,
0.23970942199230194,
-0.3576521575450897,
0.32297801971435547,
0.05686242878437042,
0.8924484252929688,
0.5931330323219299,
-0.5396466851234436,
0.5409764051437378,
0.012388451024889946,
-0.26824066042900085,
0.027477290481328964,
-0.22453546524047852,
0.21760007739067078,
0.052235670387744904,
0.2068951576948166,
-0.6068031191825867,
-0.1712583303451538,
0.43436264991760254,
-0.1849966198205948,
0.3396552503108978,
-0.3621216416358948,
-0.7638888359069824,
-0.2618314325809479,
-0.13147124648094177,
0.42976224422454834,
0.478887140750885,
-0.45831412076950073,
0.4679408669471741,
0.6774926781654358,
-0.1122831255197525,
-0.43794167041778564,
-0.7558653354644775,
0.21851152181625366,
-0.22542405128479004,
-0.26445382833480835,
-0.00018943531904369593,
0.13225847482681274,
-0.4458753168582916,
0.03995469585061073,
-0.007167200092226267,
0.14300133287906647,
0.4881071150302887,
0.19177459180355072,
0.1691235452890396,
-0.13957111537456512,
0.31572720408439636,
-0.21665146946907043,
-0.43483614921569824,
-0.1645043045282364,
-0.3725137412548065,
0.45018264651298523,
-0.24939830601215363,
-0.731431782245636,
-0.42660146951675415,
0.14137928187847137,
0.4845771789550781,
-0.45265263319015503,
0.5560852289199829,
0.6110243797302246,
-0.5932618975639343,
-0.38094455003738403,
-0.4371679425239563,
-0.030887462198734283,
-0.4067102372646332,
0.1812686026096344,
-0.11639941483736038,
-0.994649350643158,
0.5152400135993958,
-0.38540926575660706,
0.19039364159107208,
0.24293510615825653,
0.8273804187774658,
-0.19568899273872375,
0.7825896739959717,
0.5862544775009155,
-0.32487985491752625,
0.7069920301437378,
-0.4310818612575531,
0.29983624815940857,
-0.7515373826026917,
-0.05918365716934204,
-0.4214632213115692,
-0.43057873845100403,
-0.577941358089447,
-0.8875995874404907,
0.1674407571554184,
0.37705865502357483,
-0.136142298579216,
-0.03298511728644371,
-0.24186505377292633,
0.46126243472099304,
0.6484746932983398,
-0.1250724196434021,
0.18596778810024261,
-0.18098261952400208,
-0.038017842918634415,
0.2178470939397812,
-0.8954352140426636,
-0.9025548100471497,
0.8986308574676514,
0.4654599130153656,
0.919026255607605,
-0.06924030929803848,
0.562815248966217,
0.39483407139778137,
0.5395923256874084,
-1.0098849534988403,
0.6010981798171997,
0.08783669769763947,
-0.43507975339889526,
-0.3270951211452484,
-0.38722389936447144,
-0.7768701910972595,
0.013149580918252468,
-0.21170666813850403,
-0.3528026342391968,
-0.15287287533283234,
0.39043328166007996,
-0.28730762004852295,
0.5367094278335571,
-0.5417994260787964,
0.72856205701828,
-0.6137036681175232,
-0.6062439680099487,
0.0948018729686737,
-0.5379279851913452,
0.19403865933418274,
-0.4002106189727783,
0.3645935356616974,
-0.38962337374687195,
-0.3410055935382843,
0.7407019138336182,
-0.25432443618774414,
1.1905218362808228,
-0.2988824248313904,
-0.1369602084159851,
0.5018263459205627,
-0.15409323573112488,
0.6662686467170715,
0.1085246205329895,
-0.18728573620319366,
0.30064067244529724,
-0.6728280186653137,
-0.3891630470752716,
-0.26398128271102905,
0.5628086924552917,
-0.6151360273361206,
-0.3954446315765381,
-0.537620484828949,
-0.3995000123977661,
-0.2120499163866043,
0.1272120624780655,
-0.40857765078544617,
-0.01805037073791027,
0.2269381880760193,
-0.08775965124368668,
0.4396631717681885,
-0.21581265330314636,
0.5210658311843872,
0.4402866065502167,
-0.018643232062458992,
-0.3295498490333557,
0.968001663684845,
0.20383679866790771,
0.11898449063301086,
0.07001260668039322,
0.15328337252140045,
-0.2473841905593872,
-0.8921138048171997,
-0.5554514527320862,
0.39377620816230774,
-0.7240663170814514,
-0.5148164629936218,
-0.4676237404346466,
-0.04725513234734535,
-0.14667870104312897,
-0.31660810112953186,
-0.38986724615097046,
-0.4728865325450897,
-0.28421473503112793,
-0.18676097691059113,
0.5363333225250244,
0.6156689524650574,
-0.21905459463596344,
0.3452168107032776,
-0.634397566318512,
0.14926299452781677,
0.2732146382331848,
0.5358967781066895,
-0.040664996951818466,
-0.2585827112197876,
-0.7182633876800537,
0.01614960841834545,
-0.23967522382736206,
-0.5517664551734924,
0.2354946732521057,
0.3418533205986023,
0.813344419002533,
0.3649923801422119,
0.09101005643606186,
0.7285430431365967,
-0.4067527651786804,
0.8187049627304077,
-0.05271352082490921,
-0.9314311146736145,
0.7198085188865662,
-0.19117245078086853,
0.22779661417007446,
0.5477474927902222,
0.24506287276744843,
-0.6148709654808044,
-0.7044385671615601,
-0.3477827310562134,
-1.2121835947036743,
0.7613808512687683,
0.16622965037822723,
-0.0008606218034401536,
-0.12235034257173538,
0.4968254268169403,
0.11756428331136703,
0.0777350515127182,
-0.9432935118675232,
-0.2680894732475281,
0.02606619894504547,
-0.18651935458183289,
-0.05419337749481201,
-0.030492352321743965,
-0.08866526186466217,
-0.0975450798869133,
0.8565157651901245,
-0.46670129895210266,
0.20927636325359344,
-0.26095741987228394,
-0.42043536901474,
-0.20258457958698273,
0.005387509241700172,
0.34368792176246643,
0.4836674630641937,
-0.05175153166055679,
0.34539079666137695,
0.3994523584842682,
-0.4180731475353241,
0.0338352769613266,
0.14206832647323608,
-0.18941332399845123,
-0.06523913890123367,
0.6757981181144714,
0.908189594745636,
0.21525107324123383,
-0.8243700265884399,
0.303627610206604,
0.0952553004026413,
0.15391905605793,
-0.4349982440471649,
0.11440879106521606,
0.07005050778388977,
0.5036125779151917,
0.30013757944107056,
-0.1749039739370346,
-0.2572982907295227,
-0.40265756845474243,
0.3010683059692383,
0.40193435549736023,
-0.44321733713150024,
-0.4325864613056183,
0.6858340501785278,
0.45685556530952454,
-0.3148256838321686,
0.7009094953536987,
-0.08806795626878738,
-0.5812403559684753,
0.44773605465888977,
0.4150453209877014,
0.8939633965492249,
-0.2386033833026886,
-0.19013711810112,
0.2530510425567627,
0.39931395649909973,
-0.19338750839233398,
0.2977747321128845,
-0.21143123507499695,
-0.6377793550491333,
-0.6193171143531799,
-0.8553672432899475,
-0.7063588500022888,
0.09395184367895126,
-0.44136571884155273,
0.5082152485847473,
-0.34420862793922424,
-0.041165828704833984,
-0.22416330873966217,
0.12115801125764847,
-0.6090296506881714,
0.06819197535514832,
0.6595682501792908,
0.7676118016242981,
-1.060381293296814,
1.188008427619934,
1.010616660118103,
-0.6058316826820374,
-0.42849382758140564,
-0.05969138815999031,
-0.005685527343302965,
-1.0273680686950684,
0.6049752831459045,
0.25940564274787903,
-0.08908640593290329,
-0.035918157547712326,
-0.46661177277565,
-0.6611996293067932,
1.1574918031692505,
0.4503299295902252,
-0.602064311504364,
0.27054086327552795,
0.07825765013694763,
0.4635717272758484,
-0.39737504720687866,
0.08280418068170547,
0.5114635229110718,
0.6000565886497498,
0.07700364291667938,
-0.8510206341743469,
-0.1466829478740692,
-0.21418075263500214,
-0.15238147974014282,
0.37478023767471313,
-0.5260613560676575,
0.6438493728637695,
-0.25895950198173523,
-0.2871207296848297,
-0.21081645786762238,
0.7717632055282593,
0.23518240451812744,
0.2828100919723511,
0.6109987497329712,
0.4456486105918884,
0.9484254121780396,
-0.11207965016365051,
0.8040505647659302,
-0.3542599678039551,
0.32499995827674866,
0.7762892246246338,
-0.5009996891021729,
0.7918132543563843,
0.574346125125885,
-0.30465438961982727,
0.035072989761829376,
0.7975074648857117,
-0.054803334176540375,
0.35865047574043274,
0.48350492119789124,
-0.5358018279075623,
-0.35007578134536743,
-0.18970920145511627,
-0.008433728478848934,
0.511986494064331,
0.49148786067962646,
-0.22193212807178497,
-0.11418160051107407,
0.1270756721496582,
0.18868498504161835,
-0.054523568600416183,
-0.4485149383544922,
0.8672891855239868,
0.057277385145425797,
-0.2746029794216156,
0.6070011854171753,
-0.0753597542643547,
0.7620673179626465,
-0.6218021512031555,
-0.11041494458913803,
-0.291334867477417,
0.0839281752705574,
-0.1620965152978897,
-0.6042088270187378,
0.26322880387306213,
0.4366580545902252,
0.0038339553866535425,
-0.5296165943145752,
0.566167950630188,
-0.6689628958702087,
-0.5896148681640625,
0.4072583019733429,
0.6809278130531311,
0.23536716401576996,
0.2519828975200653,
-0.756031334400177,
0.2622734606266022,
-0.13175392150878906,
-0.2491069883108139,
0.21706794202327728,
0.5479553937911987,
-0.31790557503700256,
0.7478966116905212,
0.7241309881210327,
0.43251344561576843,
-0.01397677045315504,
0.15036337077617645,
1.1313836574554443,
-0.7837454676628113,
-0.28289252519607544,
-0.8689385652542114,
0.40723294019699097,
0.10677050799131393,
-0.16125310957431793,
0.5891163945198059,
0.7698072195053101,
0.9448887705802917,
0.2888351380825043,
1.2279974222183228,
-0.09147801250219345,
0.43466436862945557,
-0.6300397515296936,
0.6931561827659607,
-0.5874958038330078,
0.6117917895317078,
0.0027601702604442835,
-1.071744441986084,
-0.6652382016181946,
0.8751956820487976,
-0.25983908772468567,
-0.08795197308063507,
0.3999898135662079,
0.5944029688835144,
-0.1071440726518631,
-0.29274654388427734,
0.3184228241443634,
0.12076199054718018,
0.38148269057273865,
0.30013713240623474,
0.9086658358573914,
0.018171565607190132,
0.36640962958335876,
-0.36410465836524963,
-0.3340432643890381,
-0.3115617334842682,
-0.8704198002815247,
-0.9449620842933655,
-0.5160877108573914,
-0.3832298219203949,
-0.19382722675800323,
0.035657547414302826,
1.2141577005386353,
0.4328884482383728,
-0.7354853749275208,
-0.3930356204509735,
0.15705923736095428,
0.28364303708076477,
-0.21717603504657745,
-0.10190040618181229,
0.37051019072532654,
-0.6595892906188965,
-0.8647196292877197,
0.546690046787262,
0.41977307200431824,
0.1838613897562027,
-0.5620952844619751,
-0.14330404996871948,
-0.31714215874671936,
-0.18184825778007507,
0.46310198307037354,
0.4222206473350525,
-0.7272118926048279,
-0.24044683575630188,
-0.2562777101993561,
-0.000111316294351127,
0.04280297830700874,
0.9592580795288086,
-0.9143185615539551,
0.40599700808525085,
0.16560615599155426,
0.9168015718460083,
0.5198177695274353,
-0.2589682340621948,
0.51600581407547,
-0.7264533042907715,
0.3304939568042755,
0.6181308031082153,
0.3388327360153198,
0.4586184322834015,
0.017668498679995537,
0.7761749029159546,
0.28294622898101807,
-0.38739490509033203,
-1.2167375087738037,
0.19081701338291168,
-0.8649060130119324,
0.09085986018180847,
1.3615370988845825,
-0.30097854137420654,
-0.22076062858104706,
-0.296232134103775,
0.039518650621175766,
0.4060337543487549,
-0.3976724147796631,
0.7239766120910645,
0.5228071212768555,
-0.2716641426086426,
-0.24096907675266266,
-0.8215464949607849,
0.4165210425853729,
0.035793595016002655,
-0.8562624454498291,
0.4403614401817322,
0.3804796636104584,
-0.13960538804531097,
0.08753883093595505,
0.40151870250701904,
0.048154234886169434,
-0.03914415463805199,
-0.2453315407037735,
0.42150068283081055,
-0.20198805630207062,
-0.2200196087360382,
-0.6234477758407593,
-0.07821618020534515,
0.35172420740127563,
-0.2123710811138153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02258v1
|
Mixture-of-Depths: Dynamically allocating compute in transformer-based language models
| 2024-04-02T19:28:11 | 2024-04-02T19:28:11 |
David Raposo, Sam Ritter, Blake Richards, Timothy Lillicrap, Peter Conway Humphreys, Adam Santoro
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Transformer-based language models spread FLOPs uniformly across input
sequences. In this work we demonstrate that transformers can instead learn to
dynamically allocate FLOPs (or compute) to specific positions in a sequence,
optimising the allocation along the sequence for different layers across the
model depth. Our method enforces a total compute budget by capping the number
of tokens ($k$) that can participate in the self-attention and MLP computations
at a given layer. The tokens to be processed are determined by the network
using a top-$k$ routing mechanism. Since $k$ is defined a priori, this simple
procedure uses a static computation graph with known tensor sizes, unlike other
conditional computation techniques. Nevertheless, since the identities of the
$k$ tokens are fluid, this method can expend FLOPs non-uniformly across the
time and model depth dimensions. Thus, compute expenditure is entirely
predictable in sum total, but dynamic and context-sensitive at the token-level.
Not only do models trained in this way learn to dynamically allocate compute,
they do so efficiently. These models match baseline performance for equivalent
FLOPS and wall-clock times to train, but require a fraction of the FLOPs per
forward pass, and can be upwards of 50\% faster to step during post-training
sampling.
|
[
-0.33135709166526794,
-0.6198253035545349,
0.535174548625946,
0.4711223840713501,
0.03905374929308891,
0.6147370338439941,
-0.17303290963172913,
-0.3277520537376404,
0.187604621052742,
0.7792472243309021,
-0.49308475852012634,
0.06313115358352661,
-0.5864632725715637,
-0.3690742552280426,
-0.7328675389289856,
0.8799790143966675,
0.09554053843021393,
-0.3432348072528839,
-0.19149498641490936,
0.08499979972839355,
-0.5076310634613037,
-0.16627691686153412,
-0.4268045425415039,
-0.37898463010787964,
0.504429280757904,
0.5528352856636047,
0.7563433051109314,
0.6707073450088501,
0.3905494213104248,
0.4641231596469879,
0.0463455505669117,
-0.10951019823551178,
-0.563260555267334,
0.36265042424201965,
-0.17840759456157684,
-0.514103353023529,
-0.16063082218170166,
-0.23313599824905396,
0.8270224928855896,
0.8949213624000549,
-0.6064035296440125,
-0.1697462797164917,
-0.2028527855873108,
0.6404150724411011,
-0.957466185092926,
-0.2299722135066986,
-0.8905982971191406,
0.3199480473995209,
-0.09493564069271088,
-0.11124233156442642,
-0.6342665553092957,
0.20750612020492554,
0.17435801029205322,
-0.3990357220172882,
0.25601518154144287,
-0.31388285756111145,
0.572096049785614,
0.46329331398010254,
-0.26196181774139404,
-0.12241040170192719,
-1.200123906135559,
0.7478368878364563,
-0.3331262469291687,
0.5927035212516785,
0.11427522450685501,
0.4416557848453522,
0.3460782766342163,
-0.9975045323371887,
-0.5250865817070007,
-0.019597649574279785,
-0.14400550723075867,
0.32230305671691895,
-0.03076491691172123,
0.017051994800567627,
0.11645092815160751,
0.7675668597221375,
-0.26477864384651184,
0.24921302497386932,
-0.25848257541656494,
-0.033878445625305176,
0.4771979749202728,
0.2622144818305969,
0.0053652385249733925,
-0.00481293722987175,
-0.5154184699058533,
-0.4474191963672638,
-0.4966122806072235,
0.18725812435150146,
0.20974686741828918,
0.1463712602853775,
-0.6064195036888123,
0.5072869658470154,
-0.0742875337600708,
0.5925122499465942,
0.43132859468460083,
-0.2643163204193115,
0.22579997777938843,
-0.3526074290275574,
-0.2884419858455658,
-0.06099715083837509,
0.773974597454071,
-0.3983129858970642,
0.2207067310810089,
-0.48556944727897644,
-0.5622780323028564,
-0.09743916988372803,
0.7737260460853577,
-0.7050542235374451,
-0.34629982709884644,
0.2571932077407837,
0.020397134125232697,
-0.5509321689605713,
0.013854091987013817,
-0.6406476497650146,
-0.29288622736930847,
-0.28263425827026367,
0.4955073893070221,
-0.22254064679145813,
-0.28548872470855713,
0.3965552747249603,
-0.08137926459312439,
0.26127326488494873,
-0.0484151765704155,
-1.0544767379760742,
0.7035895586013794,
0.5377891063690186,
0.671989917755127,
-0.3038721978664398,
-0.3406185209751129,
-0.3534506857395172,
0.16010305285453796,
-0.26149165630340576,
0.5774690508842468,
-0.6640841960906982,
-0.5271927714347839,
-0.03576723113656044,
-0.3820432424545288,
-0.2734679579734802,
-0.6289317011833191,
0.2412641942501068,
-0.5040205121040344,
0.21743927896022797,
0.022154197096824646,
-0.3376426100730896,
0.19093938171863556,
-0.09486100822687149,
-0.6541138887405396,
1.0802572965621948,
0.43902236223220825,
-0.7392796874046326,
0.059430286288261414,
-0.5466206669807434,
-0.8171708583831787,
-0.08594775199890137,
-0.20559988915920258,
-0.4498295783996582,
0.2026267647743225,
0.2058783918619156,
0.3700835406780243,
-0.2570475935935974,
0.4287693202495575,
0.1460883915424347,
-0.34033164381980896,
0.31718721985816956,
-0.49631956219673157,
0.5924733877182007,
0.29187965393066406,
-0.6665773391723633,
0.2896922826766968,
-0.7108488082885742,
-0.34525996446609497,
0.21167586743831635,
-0.10701990127563477,
0.2228563278913498,
0.022101888433098793,
-0.07177019119262695,
0.12587881088256836,
0.12263529002666473,
-0.34267351031303406,
0.22388754785060883,
-0.5019514560699463,
0.45185816287994385,
0.761881947517395,
-0.21602755784988403,
1.078555703163147,
-0.21832013130187988,
0.6991420388221741,
0.3145528733730316,
0.25316327810287476,
-0.6239683032035828,
-0.2534385621547699,
-0.9481021761894226,
-0.48795557022094727,
0.40152508020401,
0.7495026588439941,
-0.7369961738586426,
0.4280249774456024,
-0.3760768473148346,
-0.6434102058410645,
-0.35415515303611755,
-0.29179611802101135,
0.15093989670276642,
0.7843259572982788,
0.31674787402153015,
-0.2748025059700012,
-0.3291584849357605,
-1.0477045774459839,
0.2632218897342682,
0.07188931107521057,
0.0027960112784057856,
0.7073988914489746,
0.19359047710895538,
0.03340163081884384,
0.8455201387405396,
-0.6346257925033569,
-0.025436997413635254,
-0.28845900297164917,
0.10641144961118698,
0.3637981414794922,
0.5951291918754578,
0.5155687928199768,
-0.7411901354789734,
-0.5577714443206787,
-0.0933423563838005,
-0.41441231966018677,
-0.0930553451180458,
-0.495739221572876,
-0.3567180037498474,
-0.11079289764165878,
0.375959575176239,
-0.789005696773529,
0.14103427529335022,
0.5941710472106934,
-0.20029515027999878,
0.46033450961112976,
-0.2537589967250824,
-0.2456091344356537,
-0.7980429530143738,
-0.08040741831064224,
-0.449424684047699,
-0.2485947608947754,
-0.499386727809906,
0.29433611035346985,
0.08456142991781235,
-0.10730759799480438,
-0.42611727118492126,
0.4721822440624237,
-0.33439192175865173,
-0.22805897891521454,
-0.19942954182624817,
-0.034683022648096085,
0.16913603246212006,
0.525459885597229,
-0.03863348439335823,
0.772153377532959,
0.9827079772949219,
-0.7471874952316284,
0.14571590721607208,
-0.046378009021282196,
-0.2910548746585846,
0.4197152554988861,
-0.7059321999549866,
0.12873393297195435,
0.07514376193284988,
0.5218125581741333,
-1.1149613857269287,
0.02627982199192047,
0.018757550045847893,
-0.32184651494026184,
0.5550571084022522,
-0.04077737033367157,
-0.35171398520469666,
-0.34023725986480713,
-0.0645294338464737,
0.7514423131942749,
0.7096641659736633,
-0.3754775822162628,
1.0553297996520996,
0.7073287963867188,
0.16320331394672394,
-0.871803879737854,
-0.8526125550270081,
-0.05150383338332176,
0.00004662948413169943,
-0.6665980815887451,
1.004149317741394,
0.05970390513539314,
0.13452085852622986,
-0.04343068599700928,
0.03304066136479378,
-0.12493637949228287,
0.2747300863265991,
0.22084668278694153,
0.20246736705303192,
-0.2612570822238922,
-0.3382214605808258,
0.06150783970952034,
-0.06321989744901657,
-0.062359608709812164,
-0.6001207828521729,
1.0267866849899292,
-0.040316250175237656,
-0.631538450717926,
0.007624999154359102,
0.15077105164527893,
0.6303014159202576,
-0.4246848523616791,
0.7500178813934326,
0.8005249500274658,
-0.32973048090934753,
-0.23812338709831238,
-0.8075971603393555,
-0.3311307430267334,
-0.5920578837394714,
0.3298289179801941,
-0.4907950460910797,
-0.8565085530281067,
0.9931008219718933,
0.2535468339920044,
0.11043421179056168,
0.5468997359275818,
0.7288820743560791,
-0.010700962506234646,
0.5867884755134583,
0.6402368545532227,
-0.23859892785549164,
0.4380768835544586,
-0.7249782085418701,
0.4009036123752594,
-0.6935611367225647,
-0.1993333399295807,
-0.4248654842376709,
-0.7258028984069824,
-0.808703601360321,
-0.5994678735733032,
0.4017009735107422,
-0.13295073807239532,
-0.36104437708854675,
0.1366148144006729,
-0.5076904892921448,
0.6557371020317078,
0.4558819532394409,
-0.045565806329250336,
-0.16469410061836243,
0.036314018070697784,
-0.35573500394821167,
0.21665573120117188,
-0.8858730792999268,
0.29079669713974,
0.714096188545227,
0.43360209465026855,
0.6300830245018005,
-0.07859255373477936,
0.6670880913734436,
0.06706303358078003,
0.03932109475135803,
-0.6339097619056702,
0.3260364532470703,
-0.21447259187698364,
-0.43886348605155945,
-0.43854719400405884,
-0.49166303873062134,
-1.0146218538284302,
0.2555742561817169,
-0.08680243045091629,
-0.6528587937355042,
0.18941250443458557,
-0.013561263680458069,
-0.45742326974868774,
0.7363659143447876,
-0.48756057024002075,
0.5207096934318542,
-0.2357172816991806,
-0.47617506980895996,
-0.47252458333969116,
-0.6216609477996826,
0.2922385036945343,
-0.023885097354650497,
0.17687882483005524,
0.24875622987747192,
-0.03584745153784752,
0.3351120948791504,
-0.11624381691217422,
0.8316949605941772,
-0.23436197638511658,
-0.09390755742788315,
0.3827652633190155,
0.44778141379356384,
0.4621318280696869,
-0.08662150800228119,
0.058056943118572235,
0.085069440305233,
-0.45858821272850037,
-0.4317105710506439,
-0.556692898273468,
0.6309331059455872,
-0.9818586707115173,
-0.3447171449661255,
-0.20405921339988708,
-0.786505401134491,
-0.24896134436130524,
0.15922942757606506,
0.09378675371408463,
0.43987715244293213,
0.04896511510014534,
0.28198352456092834,
0.6555725932121277,
-0.4469209909439087,
0.596494197845459,
0.400206059217453,
-0.1628563553094864,
-0.2858618199825287,
0.9002957344055176,
0.01662449911236763,
0.3535122275352478,
0.6839617490768433,
0.4849208891391754,
-0.5210026502609253,
-0.3635946214199066,
-0.6076234579086304,
0.12244056910276413,
-0.608153223991394,
-0.20752272009849548,
-0.9096220135688782,
-0.7322871685028076,
-0.2584545314311981,
-0.5020548701286316,
-0.8863952159881592,
-0.5679287314414978,
0.15718667209148407,
-0.1346433013677597,
0.15583132207393646,
0.6688371896743774,
-0.0604434497654438,
0.6365811228752136,
-0.5513797402381897,
0.37687402963638306,
0.20210577547550201,
0.6542592644691467,
0.40352413058280945,
-0.8269774913787842,
-0.21715600788593292,
-0.07336024940013885,
-0.5016309022903442,
-0.5260160565376282,
0.19936659932136536,
0.1179434210062027,
0.5588856935501099,
0.30428481101989746,
-0.1092672049999237,
0.584022581577301,
-0.7013285756111145,
0.7510279417037964,
0.09381049126386642,
-0.9974249005317688,
0.013472342863678932,
-0.4059874713420868,
0.47161751985549927,
0.4912312924861908,
0.12046653032302856,
-0.46321380138397217,
-0.43216049671173096,
-0.9106656312942505,
-1.109614372253418,
0.7922155857086182,
0.29890576004981995,
0.6137638092041016,
0.13459470868110657,
0.27666717767715454,
0.12652690708637238,
0.2463809698820114,
-0.612622082233429,
-0.38855165243148804,
-0.12572968006134033,
-0.030567185953259468,
0.1967656910419464,
-0.2258085459470749,
0.11111307144165039,
-0.42624786496162415,
0.36571264266967773,
0.0847439244389534,
0.4574408531188965,
-0.17482687532901764,
-0.054368194192647934,
-0.03390364348888397,
-0.07609284669160843,
0.7117835879325867,
0.8651955723762512,
0.067023865878582,
0.3427734971046448,
0.19484394788742065,
-0.4515341520309448,
0.18958799540996552,
-0.19021190702915192,
-0.37607499957084656,
-0.2589612305164337,
0.13479100167751312,
1.1549259424209595,
0.7008537650108337,
-0.5046652555465698,
0.635556161403656,
0.13020119071006775,
-0.1922069638967514,
-0.3716142475605011,
0.12028947472572327,
0.29046425223350525,
0.16837868094444275,
0.18554723262786865,
0.19610626995563507,
0.062249522656202316,
-0.18679192662239075,
0.49809056520462036,
0.2731075882911682,
-0.27622196078300476,
-0.2797611951828003,
0.5119351744651794,
0.107560895383358,
-0.34083613753318787,
0.9600194692611694,
0.06614481657743454,
-0.6502367854118347,
0.636367678642273,
0.6875861883163452,
0.9487295150756836,
-0.2881481349468231,
0.3329831659793854,
0.25468015670776367,
0.04401853308081627,
0.03656291961669922,
0.10168149322271347,
-0.26870033144950867,
-0.9802086353302002,
-0.6741355061531067,
-0.7262324690818787,
-0.4109203517436981,
0.0801200196146965,
-0.41664087772369385,
0.31995975971221924,
-0.6865164041519165,
0.07961467653512955,
0.055591873824596405,
-0.4971742033958435,
-0.825589656829834,
0.3131219744682312,
0.4683299660682678,
0.6888380646705627,
-0.7549731135368347,
0.7320185303688049,
0.21767185628414154,
-0.12434987723827362,
-0.6311113238334656,
-0.2040519267320633,
-0.4544123411178589,
-1.0369900465011597,
0.3207254707813263,
-0.020681899040937424,
-0.3047696650028229,
-0.013937515206634998,
-0.22458718717098236,
-1.0759201049804688,
0.8696797490119934,
0.4373933970928192,
-0.5474933981895447,
-0.08873207867145538,
0.49722135066986084,
0.38963577151298523,
-0.4203638732433319,
0.6732414960861206,
0.40102627873420715,
0.3700641393661499,
0.31065988540649414,
-0.9410519599914551,
-0.23424242436885834,
-0.03823670372366905,
-0.2928846776485443,
0.27496981620788574,
-0.6259937882423401,
1.1074559688568115,
-0.2335568070411682,
-0.13914290070533752,
-0.4915112257003784,
0.6669057011604309,
0.28117865324020386,
-0.16064870357513428,
0.9686251282691956,
0.7230621576309204,
0.7023717164993286,
0.008755862712860107,
1.3399759531021118,
-0.6163440346717834,
0.13084015250205994,
0.8778255581855774,
-0.12830804288387299,
0.7292271852493286,
0.3222389221191406,
-0.3734094798564911,
0.6620542407035828,
0.3859843611717224,
0.0641845166683197,
0.6554085612297058,
0.4448559284210205,
0.020312529057264328,
-0.22061805427074432,
-0.05124891921877861,
-0.15533709526062012,
0.5244351625442505,
0.1941061019897461,
-0.15590843558311462,
-0.005187748931348324,
-0.12973053753376007,
-0.18861542642116547,
-0.08874576538801193,
0.04391992837190628,
0.6255435943603516,
0.06984344869852066,
-0.8266674876213074,
0.6442190408706665,
0.19227655231952667,
0.77596116065979,
-0.5933176875114441,
0.3722098171710968,
-0.2576857805252075,
0.23021329939365387,
-0.10684539377689362,
-0.9701524376869202,
0.4324258267879486,
-0.22339770197868347,
-0.2809387147426605,
-0.40169575810432434,
0.48592424392700195,
-0.3454412519931793,
-0.7678142786026001,
0.2583600580692291,
0.5113528370857239,
-0.17203298211097717,
-0.19391044974327087,
-0.5805978775024414,
-0.04686439409852028,
-0.16895636916160583,
-0.27559879422187805,
0.32577750086784363,
0.4125325083732605,
0.015953371301293373,
0.7448941469192505,
0.5200603604316711,
0.05647721514105797,
0.41628214716911316,
0.5069496035575867,
0.9989454746246338,
-0.3621536195278168,
-0.7936587929725647,
-0.9414531588554382,
0.9125900864601135,
0.16365894675254822,
-0.04832645505666733,
0.04533429443836212,
0.6100000143051147,
0.9337009787559509,
-0.008303478360176086,
0.5568180084228516,
0.12033218890428543,
0.027427423745393753,
-0.4128112494945526,
0.5559790730476379,
-0.6348027586936951,
0.2790423631668091,
-0.06470230221748352,
-0.9733672142028809,
0.06447780877351761,
0.6005200147628784,
-0.12041298300027847,
0.15648311376571655,
0.525138258934021,
0.4815763235092163,
-0.6158902645111084,
-0.045597247779369354,
0.15347817540168762,
0.04781387746334076,
0.3944181501865387,
0.41777506470680237,
0.7512257099151611,
-0.3408213257789612,
0.1887420117855072,
-0.8632370233535767,
-0.08795279264450073,
0.05551251396536827,
-0.8053893446922302,
-0.3795790672302246,
-0.675972044467926,
-0.1496916562318802,
-0.14646048843860626,
-0.39248329401016235,
0.40481096506118774,
0.852956235408783,
-0.7701562643051147,
-0.5305150151252747,
-0.1322057992219925,
0.06825722008943558,
-0.13404668867588043,
-0.26298823952674866,
0.23817527294158936,
-0.5117632746696472,
-0.5927808880805969,
0.4178140461444855,
0.3951350748538971,
-0.17379646003246307,
-0.6345400214195251,
0.04554832726716995,
-0.039555054157972336,
0.3211950659751892,
0.6385210752487183,
-0.15764744579792023,
-0.5684166550636292,
-0.0055997674353420734,
0.5039690732955933,
-0.21109427511692047,
0.342138409614563,
1.0853285789489746,
-0.910987913608551,
0.18215663731098175,
0.632288932800293,
1.0525109767913818,
1.046423316001892,
-0.21178297698497772,
0.5473233461380005,
-0.931521475315094,
0.5168085098266602,
0.4529784321784973,
0.3100111186504364,
0.4546230137348175,
-0.4595341980457306,
0.2558654546737671,
0.18254885077476501,
-0.39548400044441223,
-0.8471025228500366,
0.31210920214653015,
-1.095711588859558,
-0.24462135136127472,
0.8520190119743347,
0.21929126977920532,
-0.09404385834932327,
0.3011207580566406,
0.0895138829946518,
0.12020278722047806,
-0.19377072155475616,
0.8903601765632629,
0.5302289724349976,
-0.05888386815786362,
-0.24231012165546417,
-0.31977081298828125,
0.1496422439813614,
0.6806748509407043,
-0.3935542702674866,
-0.026355376467108727,
-0.03215273097157478,
0.05181223899126053,
0.23939794301986694,
0.7786421179771423,
-0.1870950609445572,
-0.14542996883392334,
0.09654102474451065,
-0.03984550014138222,
0.06469132006168365,
-0.6988772749900818,
0.10176119953393936,
0.17034000158309937,
-0.21795906126499176,
-0.11835033446550369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02255v1
|
$\texttt{LM}^\texttt{2}$: A Simple Society of Language Models Solves Complex Reasoning
| 2024-04-02T19:23:10 | 2024-04-02T19:23:10 |
Gurusha Juneja, Subhabrata Dutta, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite demonstrating emergent reasoning abilities, Large Language Models
(LLMS) often lose track of complex, multi-step reasoning. Existing studies show
that providing guidance via decomposing the original question into multiple
subproblems elicits more robustness in LLM reasoning -- a decomposer generates
the subproblems, and a solver solves each of these subproblems. However, these
techniques fail to accommodate coordination between the decomposer and the
solver modules (either in a single model or different specialized ones) -- the
decomposer does not keep track of the ability of the solver to follow the
decomposed reasoning. In this paper, we propose LM2 to address these
challenges. LM2 modularizes the decomposition, solution, and verification into
three different language models. The decomposer module identifies the key
concepts necessary to solve the problem and generates step-by-step subquestions
according to the reasoning requirement. The solver model generates the solution
to the subproblems that are then checked by the verifier module; depending upon
the feedback from the verifier, the reasoning context is constructed using the
subproblems and the solutions. These models are trained to coordinate using
policy learning. Exhaustive experimentation suggests the superiority of LM2
over existing methods on in- and out-domain reasoning problems, outperforming
the best baselines by $8.1\%$ on MATH, $7.71\%$ on JEEBench, and $9.7\%$ on
MedQA problems (code available at
https://github.com/LCS2-IIITD/Language_Model_Multiplex).
|
[
-0.08922053128480911,
-0.9011825323104858,
0.7137895226478577,
0.026495639234781265,
-0.011717850342392921,
0.10964811593294144,
-0.2259412407875061,
-0.2316298633813858,
-0.6520026326179504,
0.5224036574363708,
-0.391525000333786,
-0.10024451464414597,
-0.4573732316493988,
-0.07912494242191315,
0.10116061568260193,
0.6224194765090942,
-0.12241464853286743,
0.21725250780582428,
-0.5354893803596497,
0.04749395325779915,
-0.23147018253803253,
-0.5164928436279297,
-0.9032846093177795,
-1.0052050352096558,
0.2825278043746948,
0.4466797411441803,
0.6515274047851562,
0.5043365359306335,
0.24756649136543274,
0.25562554597854614,
-0.6348996162414551,
0.6513904929161072,
-0.49065831303596497,
0.1746765822172165,
-0.42584335803985596,
-0.7593817114830017,
-0.3890954852104187,
-0.3848807215690613,
0.42836993932724,
0.44953420758247375,
-0.24956122040748596,
0.05106997862458229,
0.1412014216184616,
0.617331862449646,
-0.32742178440093994,
0.4043991267681122,
-0.5597136616706848,
-0.24992331862449646,
0.17765921354293823,
-0.024126503616571426,
-0.5938851833343506,
-0.21523186564445496,
-0.08597525209188461,
-0.19871459901332855,
-0.0733097493648529,
-0.03186933696269989,
0.6366270184516907,
0.3741501271724701,
-0.5719555616378784,
-0.2623634338378906,
-0.9346618056297302,
0.8153799772262573,
-0.5486708283424377,
0.2342483401298523,
0.34329915046691895,
0.4481908082962036,
-0.41553470492362976,
-0.538444459438324,
-0.5553848743438721,
0.09344272315502167,
-0.11648757010698318,
0.14530350267887115,
-0.20181627571582794,
-0.07476218789815903,
0.12158651649951935,
0.01822429895401001,
-0.5511177778244019,
0.30472561717033386,
-0.4509132206439972,
-0.36769574880599976,
0.4568931758403778,
0.2933292090892792,
0.210346519947052,
-0.06756783276796341,
-0.5410131216049194,
0.11496297270059586,
-0.8480265140533447,
0.26288551092147827,
0.026790358126163483,
0.15248361229896545,
-0.0008639823645353317,
0.4481971561908722,
-0.04761424660682678,
0.36658522486686707,
-0.2981419861316681,
-0.5742654204368591,
0.042406581342220306,
-0.353062242269516,
0.0016018492169678211,
-0.3224756717681885,
0.412187784910202,
0.3662298917770386,
0.2918870747089386,
0.13735975325107574,
-0.4773358702659607,
0.00038487990968860686,
-0.08645657449960709,
-0.6031631231307983,
-0.18598052859306335,
0.5235755443572998,
-0.3944660425186157,
0.07829604297876358,
-0.22666285932064056,
-0.3663557171821594,
-0.1407257318496704,
-0.5835410952568054,
0.378574013710022,
-0.41953781247138977,
-0.4611791670322418,
0.27524587512016296,
0.09912899881601334,
0.42015016078948975,
0.5300756096839905,
-0.6828605532646179,
0.4018218517303467,
1.1014013290405273,
0.7978739738464355,
-0.19481658935546875,
-0.09863106906414032,
-0.29218631982803345,
0.12533526122570038,
-0.3425890803337097,
0.7616767883300781,
-0.2668732702732086,
-0.09872511774301529,
0.15841080248355865,
0.07774624228477478,
0.014484085142612457,
-0.829816460609436,
0.32836493849754333,
-0.5151439905166626,
0.051550257951021194,
-0.229225292801857,
-0.6218040585517883,
-0.19354435801506042,
0.5727459788322449,
-0.5597521662712097,
1.1616722345352173,
0.05268625542521477,
-0.4502924382686615,
-0.1397363394498825,
-0.5582409501075745,
-0.19200499355793,
-0.06277024745941162,
-0.16362358629703522,
-0.464549720287323,
-0.04614175111055374,
-0.013546752743422985,
0.20942896604537964,
-0.32491210103034973,
0.4778192639350891,
-0.1837242990732193,
-0.21398493647575378,
0.19895145297050476,
-0.22887097299098969,
0.7961246967315674,
0.2386084645986557,
-0.13432076573371887,
0.05170769244432449,
-0.5331702828407288,
0.15335096418857574,
0.25477537512779236,
-0.8631712794303894,
-0.17642436921596527,
0.3189205527305603,
-0.1278802901506424,
0.3811541497707367,
0.19351302087306976,
-0.21460723876953125,
0.1619855761528015,
-0.42892763018608093,
0.6091071963310242,
0.6633497476577759,
-0.06189458444714546,
0.6030145287513733,
-0.3727376163005829,
0.27011147141456604,
0.19658039510250092,
0.022326834499835968,
-0.24533721804618835,
-0.46834778785705566,
-0.9922658205032349,
-0.03745773434638977,
-0.019817866384983063,
0.9438015222549438,
-0.6690129637718201,
0.14223933219909668,
-0.059361640363931656,
-0.2279229313135147,
-0.14340905845165253,
0.18526135385036469,
0.7524213790893555,
0.1623246818780899,
0.5307049751281738,
0.22484785318374634,
-0.4912325441837311,
-0.9959556460380554,
-0.17467640340328217,
-0.2561018764972687,
-0.06731647998094559,
0.039066217839717865,
0.7144946455955505,
-0.29725679755210876,
0.8711229562759399,
-0.26507943868637085,
-0.02924301102757454,
-0.6886863708496094,
-0.015637697651982307,
0.009024286642670631,
0.6159547567367554,
0.19147293269634247,
-0.5952440500259399,
-0.1331472396850586,
-0.0172259658575058,
-0.699043333530426,
-0.07142692059278488,
0.06452632695436478,
-0.048444170504808426,
0.35336044430732727,
0.44776830077171326,
-0.7550895810127258,
0.12260828167200089,
0.15127579867839813,
-0.1739981472492218,
0.5995103716850281,
-0.33585262298583984,
-0.44248464703559875,
-1.0937764644622803,
-0.10990235954523087,
-0.27332329750061035,
-0.43814513087272644,
-0.6781665086746216,
0.45203036069869995,
0.0058511425741016865,
0.06699499487876892,
-0.3202451765537262,
0.6803480386734009,
-0.5488492250442505,
0.0179519634693861,
-0.2508560121059418,
0.26249662041664124,
0.017851032316684723,
0.37266042828559875,
0.08651822805404663,
0.6331916451454163,
0.5275837182998657,
-0.6440771818161011,
0.3913456201553345,
0.15495212376117706,
-0.43644964694976807,
0.30775219202041626,
-0.7793005108833313,
0.3049173653125763,
-0.3950933516025543,
0.3500998616218567,
-1.0277878046035767,
-0.24300582706928253,
0.21394385397434235,
-0.2887708246707916,
0.3225081264972687,
-0.1116177961230278,
-0.7049716114997864,
-0.3017560541629791,
-0.07848085463047028,
0.2942269742488861,
0.6705545783042908,
-0.47342759370803833,
0.7314420938491821,
0.22952227294445038,
-0.10417193919420242,
-0.4830772280693054,
-0.785847008228302,
-0.11162598431110382,
0.046783287078142166,
-0.655157208442688,
0.03869837149977684,
-0.28075721859931946,
-0.6485925912857056,
-0.06726884096860886,
-0.3216925859451294,
-0.09979838132858276,
0.06538555026054382,
0.007029611151665449,
0.18015797436237335,
-0.33078017830848694,
0.2114565670490265,
0.2515902817249298,
-0.4768584072589874,
0.3488757908344269,
-0.2764991521835327,
0.47692447900772095,
-0.1300775706768036,
-0.3665412664413452,
-0.23552682995796204,
0.556060791015625,
0.6157544851303101,
-0.28106072545051575,
0.6616670489311218,
0.31437593698501587,
-0.47351112961769104,
-0.5615666508674622,
-0.526665985584259,
-0.20991355180740356,
-0.4259633421897888,
0.4835064709186554,
-0.6656755208969116,
-1.115788221359253,
0.5168986916542053,
-0.4226752519607544,
0.08802950382232666,
0.17622318863868713,
0.8970524668693542,
0.012120305560529232,
1.141103982925415,
0.2894760072231293,
0.3459842801094055,
-0.09981773048639297,
-0.27563774585723877,
0.25420263409614563,
-0.7550001740455627,
-0.8412514925003052,
-0.4502619504928589,
-0.14645366370677948,
-0.2185453176498413,
-0.8099539279937744,
0.4049527943134308,
0.4285909831523895,
-0.3661330044269562,
0.194040447473526,
-0.25216546654701233,
0.7661155462265015,
0.5074341893196106,
0.26260310411453247,
0.32711490988731384,
0.05552907660603523,
-0.3195616900920868,
0.18259882926940918,
-0.8219490051269531,
-0.81385737657547,
0.6630415320396423,
0.6177849769592285,
0.6822159886360168,
0.6591153740882874,
0.538204550743103,
-0.01908734254539013,
0.017846066504716873,
-1.0179648399353027,
0.7343745231628418,
-0.0800824761390686,
-0.6753795742988586,
-0.1942773014307022,
-0.34465768933296204,
-0.636351466178894,
0.5139307379722595,
0.08359004557132721,
-0.8040319681167603,
-0.005319651681929827,
0.27477869391441345,
-0.19211217761039734,
0.2544817328453064,
-0.3946912884712219,
0.5962749719619751,
-0.1107608750462532,
-0.47213637828826904,
-0.3203659653663635,
-0.844656765460968,
0.5450718402862549,
0.06406266987323761,
0.49717530608177185,
-0.17399397492408752,
0.00477749016135931,
0.3710840344429016,
-0.608078122138977,
0.9059170484542847,
-0.14617648720741272,
-0.3701384365558624,
0.49511492252349854,
0.43902474641799927,
0.7659154534339905,
0.1116175502538681,
-0.05480668321251869,
-0.15477602183818817,
0.10696513205766678,
-0.365744024515152,
-0.6518275141716003,
0.5212987661361694,
-0.7135391235351562,
-0.7460548877716064,
-0.21466770768165588,
-0.43373292684555054,
-0.05211329460144043,
0.12183259427547455,
0.027339709922671318,
0.5280398726463318,
0.1329357773065567,
0.15420900285243988,
1.0216784477233887,
0.004907602909952402,
0.3092113733291626,
0.6233066320419312,
-0.392604798078537,
-0.30054494738578796,
0.5711416006088257,
-0.030871888622641563,
0.6399939656257629,
0.5742686986923218,
0.3899991810321808,
-0.4642663598060608,
-0.41471055150032043,
-0.26302453875541687,
0.1450057178735733,
-1.1827924251556396,
-0.25757595896720886,
-0.5047454237937927,
-0.3300941586494446,
-0.02900068275630474,
0.14218996465206146,
-0.32015249133110046,
-0.37631484866142273,
-0.07917938381433487,
-0.09439647197723389,
-0.08358585834503174,
0.6542760729789734,
-0.1455284208059311,
0.05944285914301872,
-0.6132770776748657,
0.3136116564273834,
0.5192236304283142,
0.029744165018200874,
-0.032782092690467834,
-0.49012330174446106,
-0.06983380764722824,
0.010288955643773079,
-0.08586085587739944,
-0.6596605777740479,
-0.1881503015756607,
0.03416483476758003,
0.648186445236206,
0.34727051854133606,
-0.1087958887219429,
0.32958367466926575,
-0.5234150886535645,
0.7565096020698547,
0.03099854849278927,
-0.8063406944274902,
0.6734075546264648,
-0.11265288293361664,
0.4090515077114105,
0.23200823366641998,
0.1299065798521042,
-0.09243432432413101,
-0.3782718777656555,
-0.17962093651294708,
-0.7432278990745544,
0.6934194564819336,
0.19761599600315094,
0.04952390491962433,
0.03583964332938194,
0.47034916281700134,
-0.04978102445602417,
-0.31362390518188477,
-0.7555138468742371,
-0.27707740664482117,
0.030056333169341087,
0.043098222464323044,
0.17246758937835693,
-0.7599882483482361,
-0.18723338842391968,
-0.3141953647136688,
0.7356863021850586,
-0.18801546096801758,
0.11741603165864944,
0.13864648342132568,
-0.10641489923000336,
-0.03449239954352379,
0.5586751103401184,
0.8249189853668213,
0.6693869829177856,
0.029075894504785538,
0.6840682029724121,
0.13740947842597961,
-0.02102654241025448,
0.38931533694267273,
-0.24103987216949463,
-0.4553816020488739,
-0.07158882170915604,
0.48233214020729065,
0.6418495178222656,
0.12500961124897003,
-0.7299911975860596,
0.3172844350337982,
0.3106982409954071,
-0.36195313930511475,
-0.4173602759838104,
0.2044040709733963,
0.4202745854854584,
0.648960530757904,
0.23404966294765472,
0.1837630420923233,
-0.08610642701387405,
-0.5837647318840027,
0.13343186676502228,
0.35192760825157166,
-0.1591285616159439,
-0.36319661140441895,
0.6673822999000549,
0.08689665794372559,
-0.5465410351753235,
0.4035610854625702,
-0.42550423741340637,
-0.8827968239784241,
0.704555332660675,
1.0525075197219849,
0.5335397720336914,
-0.3140908181667328,
0.058267053216695786,
0.6262689232826233,
0.5507698655128479,
-0.6243354678153992,
0.49033647775650024,
0.059702061116695404,
-0.8681018352508545,
-0.5174340605735779,
-0.5436157584190369,
-0.36201852560043335,
0.2796204388141632,
-0.4090215265750885,
0.09633221477270126,
-0.3581371307373047,
0.10137443244457245,
-0.25846391916275024,
-0.30523741245269775,
-0.34201574325561523,
0.07655676454305649,
0.15494661033153534,
0.9531317353248596,
-0.6943601965904236,
0.7919440269470215,
0.7961033582687378,
-0.31726518273353577,
-1.0203168392181396,
-0.11101007461547852,
0.38743793964385986,
-0.7706177830696106,
0.6354706883430481,
0.21853303909301758,
-0.4986754357814789,
-0.08951199054718018,
-0.6327108144760132,
-0.7682781219482422,
1.071668267250061,
0.3380279541015625,
-0.6467478275299072,
0.1159207820892334,
0.13278287649154663,
0.33547836542129517,
-0.30567270517349243,
0.14864663779735565,
0.6239256858825684,
0.5585078001022339,
0.2768529951572418,
-0.9169732928276062,
0.1821693480014801,
-0.21846474707126617,
0.03024766594171524,
0.12867388129234314,
-0.6801595687866211,
0.9861135482788086,
-0.5693594217300415,
-0.20441599190235138,
0.25677600502967834,
0.32589688897132874,
0.5373590588569641,
0.3606356382369995,
0.39040470123291016,
0.5366882681846619,
0.6291807293891907,
-0.19068199396133423,
0.7891331315040588,
-0.045727554708719254,
0.5758312344551086,
1.2361125946044922,
-0.2513945400714874,
0.9464786648750305,
0.41658541560173035,
-0.338850200176239,
0.5833306312561035,
0.4240432679653168,
0.2132353037595749,
0.41435369849205017,
0.29894906282424927,
-0.35495737195014954,
-0.765953779220581,
0.04570460319519043,
-0.19150517880916595,
0.45073333382606506,
0.3965319097042084,
-0.08512735366821289,
-0.4002858102321625,
-0.2675537168979645,
0.36593613028526306,
0.1948983520269394,
-0.14388640224933624,
0.8530839681625366,
0.26786157488822937,
-0.8599585890769958,
0.591159999370575,
0.2666168212890625,
0.1702772080898285,
-0.5982832908630371,
-0.04434528201818466,
-0.47556808590888977,
0.6004435420036316,
-0.21184371411800385,
-0.8010170459747314,
0.3886782228946686,
-0.1668282449245453,
-0.29633939266204834,
-0.171152263879776,
0.9035120606422424,
-0.617896556854248,
-0.3478747010231018,
0.4499812722206116,
0.778792142868042,
0.19535070657730103,
0.24839361011981964,
-0.6148573756217957,
0.06736639887094498,
-0.1461394876241684,
-0.33275341987609863,
0.20575551688671112,
0.3917604386806488,
-0.18746131658554077,
0.9988690614700317,
0.529292643070221,
-0.23751717805862427,
-0.15109466016292572,
0.23696152865886688,
0.8646870255470276,
-0.270569384098053,
-0.31635746359825134,
-1.0631352663040161,
0.6383739113807678,
0.011328959837555885,
0.06362222880125046,
0.5802901983261108,
0.7085238695144653,
0.7180031538009644,
-0.07561099529266357,
0.7484890818595886,
0.07370340824127197,
0.5580784678459167,
-0.7837238311767578,
0.3988010287284851,
-0.6207114458084106,
0.526782214641571,
0.30545109510421753,
-0.9040579199790955,
-0.4399241507053375,
0.6344171166419983,
0.045370183885097504,
-0.08003812283277512,
0.6825286149978638,
1.0564419031143188,
-0.13347654044628143,
-0.47379305958747864,
0.16092444956302643,
0.28092893958091736,
0.3550556004047394,
0.8343654274940491,
1.0414618253707886,
-0.1519603580236435,
0.5062527060508728,
0.04614586383104324,
-0.20903293788433075,
-0.26090091466903687,
-0.673538327217102,
-1.1280345916748047,
-0.25764933228492737,
-0.27253589034080505,
-0.5200907588005066,
0.015384914353489876,
0.9787156581878662,
0.5223920941352844,
-0.8466578125953674,
-0.2509383261203766,
-0.17266994714736938,
0.38910865783691406,
-0.3402582108974457,
-0.24128668010234833,
0.24057482182979584,
-0.4095398485660553,
-0.43650954961776733,
0.5505644679069519,
0.41969895362854004,
-0.13716867566108704,
-0.49859628081321716,
-0.4623560607433319,
-0.05742020532488823,
0.3965509533882141,
0.8677818179130554,
0.08131270855665207,
-1.2308443784713745,
-0.34808632731437683,
-0.09255372732877731,
-0.15433575212955475,
-0.0003016641712747514,
0.8239837884902954,
-0.4879383444786072,
0.4327832758426666,
0.6478581428527832,
0.42363685369491577,
0.4258403182029724,
-0.008283371105790138,
0.2324720025062561,
-0.48265841603279114,
-0.08231174945831299,
0.023399800062179565,
0.4521387219429016,
0.13273628056049347,
-0.0415773019194603,
0.49432483315467834,
0.23193444311618805,
-0.6041871905326843,
-0.7635553479194641,
0.7775187492370605,
-0.9032855033874512,
-0.5274640321731567,
1.4584136009216309,
-0.2199523001909256,
-0.14111091196537018,
-0.41248127818107605,
-0.2811874449253082,
0.13798880577087402,
-0.1964661329984665,
0.4551948606967926,
0.4677966237068176,
-0.16946958005428314,
-0.4444473683834076,
-0.4335731863975525,
0.31285637617111206,
0.3555426597595215,
-0.7873815298080444,
0.05221647769212723,
0.44116148352622986,
0.5901556015014648,
0.29487842321395874,
0.6982271075248718,
-0.08064380288124084,
0.055234771221876144,
-0.009188247844576836,
-0.27384454011917114,
-0.3239458203315735,
-0.43151503801345825,
-0.24213340878486633,
0.30644091963768005,
0.16477730870246887,
0.03614449128508568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02204v1
|
Emergent Abilities in Reduced-Scale Generative Language Models
| 2024-04-02T18:00:28 | 2024-04-02T18:00:28 |
Sherin Muckatira, Vijeta Deshpande, Vladislav Lialin, Anna Rumshisky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models can solve new tasks without task-specific fine-tuning.
This ability, also known as in-context learning (ICL), is considered an
emergent ability and is primarily seen in large language models with billions
of parameters. This study investigates if such emergent properties are strictly
tied to model size or can be demonstrated by smaller models trained on
reduced-scale data. To explore this, we simplify pre-training data and
pre-train 36 causal language models with parameters varying from 1 million to
165 million parameters. We show that models trained on this simplified
pre-training data demonstrate enhanced zero-shot capabilities across various
tasks in simplified language, achieving performance comparable to that of
pre-trained models six times larger on unrestricted language. This suggests
that downscaling the language allows zero-shot learning capabilities to emerge
in models with limited size. Additionally, we find that these smaller models
pre-trained on simplified data demonstrate a power law relationship between the
evaluation loss and the three scaling factors: compute, dataset size, and model
size.
|
[
-0.33779048919677734,
-0.6351435780525208,
0.6598895788192749,
0.03652911260724068,
-0.2265564203262329,
-0.18702754378318787,
-0.5203152298927307,
-0.44710615277290344,
-0.2711610794067383,
0.23300613462924957,
-0.3578137755393982,
0.032276690006256104,
-0.6887757182121277,
0.13038165867328644,
-0.3791787326335907,
1.1265931129455566,
0.20468316972255707,
-0.07035242766141891,
-0.22356319427490234,
0.06538498401641846,
-0.36792561411857605,
-0.2651398479938507,
-0.7648840546607971,
-0.35570603609085083,
0.5060920715332031,
0.5656142234802246,
0.497176855802536,
0.6774081587791443,
0.40242382884025574,
0.18394231796264648,
-0.13513019680976868,
-0.3373875319957733,
-0.6124897599220276,
-0.011004907079041004,
-0.0038271299563348293,
-0.5597975254058838,
-0.24311693012714386,
0.06659814715385437,
1.0940780639648438,
1.066129446029663,
0.08945440500974655,
0.3589226305484772,
0.26823484897613525,
0.4895697236061096,
-0.6021998524665833,
0.25217753648757935,
-0.7727543711662292,
-0.010167596861720085,
-0.06918908655643463,
-0.0726342722773552,
-0.6803313493728638,
0.2202661633491516,
0.22681038081645966,
-0.45550310611724854,
0.4747767150402069,
-0.20732291042804718,
0.7880926132202148,
0.29745057225227356,
-0.5289531350135803,
-0.04974135756492615,
-1.0238041877746582,
0.7832475900650024,
-0.8213793039321899,
0.15683554112911224,
0.12855631113052368,
0.17133048176765442,
0.11395419389009476,
-0.6195662617683411,
-0.49384549260139465,
-0.4533560276031494,
-0.298654705286026,
-0.23148047924041748,
-0.2695534825325012,
0.23914533853530884,
0.6786197423934937,
0.19814445078372955,
-0.2775037884712219,
0.4235590696334839,
-0.43231216073036194,
0.25015851855278015,
0.550708532333374,
0.17163841426372528,
0.3243553638458252,
-0.21327953040599823,
-0.09340547025203705,
-0.05180737376213074,
-1.0298751592636108,
-0.04747052863240242,
-0.04696289822459221,
0.7251775860786438,
-0.29404494166374207,
0.3896521329879761,
-0.012898383662104607,
0.6972382068634033,
0.2355487048625946,
-0.2602335214614868,
-0.13045039772987366,
-0.28968843817710876,
-0.42001399397850037,
-0.036296237260103226,
0.5256273150444031,
-0.2563653588294983,
0.04848499968647957,
-0.20687228441238403,
-0.016785135492682457,
-0.4162013530731201,
0.12788517773151398,
-0.9678134322166443,
-0.08776118606328964,
-0.16006970405578613,
-0.40756285190582275,
-0.13374939560890198,
-0.18813346326351166,
-0.2657046914100647,
-0.3282298147678375,
-0.16787183284759521,
0.7591779828071594,
-0.3698391616344452,
-0.4177664816379547,
-0.17747388780117035,
-0.1364344358444214,
0.4748023748397827,
0.3345582187175751,
-0.9159830808639526,
0.29883137345314026,
0.25155624747276306,
0.8925538659095764,
0.34122878313064575,
-0.24616916477680206,
-0.42818036675453186,
-0.06858917325735092,
-0.6654943823814392,
0.3245996832847595,
-0.5106095671653748,
-0.21656417846679688,
-0.2722983658313751,
-0.05865562707185745,
-0.416443407535553,
-0.5584954619407654,
0.17650574445724487,
-0.6059560775756836,
-0.2530210614204407,
-0.16334187984466553,
-0.4900677800178528,
-0.18391191959381104,
-0.12451596558094025,
-0.5639520287513733,
0.49903854727745056,
0.24133241176605225,
-0.7328581809997559,
0.8450442552566528,
-0.6156386137008667,
-0.6366526484489441,
0.3967026174068451,
-0.2899927496910095,
-0.520513117313385,
0.5164200663566589,
-0.07941866666078568,
0.7160509824752808,
-0.49678462743759155,
0.14842164516448975,
-0.38226959109306335,
-0.22121579945087433,
0.006864647846668959,
-0.6684401631355286,
0.9127921462059021,
0.10215030610561371,
-0.5201006531715393,
-0.05023815110325813,
-0.8817537426948547,
0.006024716887623072,
0.20242522656917572,
-0.4442903697490692,
-0.2884761691093445,
-0.0564548522233963,
-0.13519731163978577,
0.4036722183227539,
0.13187536597251892,
-0.538373589515686,
0.1033516600728035,
-0.3890973925590515,
0.4376436769962311,
0.30600833892822266,
0.22348524630069733,
0.5762681365013123,
-0.16419413685798645,
0.5661468505859375,
0.025078866630792618,
0.027718035504221916,
-0.30575430393218994,
-0.31738680601119995,
-0.9506112337112427,
-0.38979849219322205,
0.12440839409828186,
0.18901272118091583,
-0.6423509120941162,
0.19662687182426453,
-0.4253746569156647,
-0.6724756360054016,
-0.3209855258464813,
0.1912550926208496,
0.4614017605781555,
0.4837837517261505,
0.19587251543998718,
0.06489088386297226,
-0.45613735914230347,
-0.9572368860244751,
0.049918413162231445,
-0.06856486201286316,
-0.4376298785209656,
0.4094715714454651,
0.5933296084403992,
0.10267189890146255,
0.837307333946228,
-0.31769752502441406,
-0.23499856889247894,
-0.6041422486305237,
0.34512123465538025,
0.12600493431091309,
0.5052857995033264,
0.6332186460494995,
-0.5992496609687805,
-0.5951457619667053,
0.15744751691818237,
-0.7376495599746704,
0.071470245718956,
-0.21472978591918945,
0.5741353631019592,
0.06548451632261276,
0.7671740651130676,
-0.5280542373657227,
0.5217617750167847,
0.3425341546535492,
-0.17858988046646118,
0.49657922983169556,
-0.6882690191268921,
-0.11713699996471405,
-0.9970178008079529,
-0.013312575407326221,
-0.035971567034721375,
0.0915675088763237,
-0.9911084771156311,
0.15384623408317566,
0.2652265131473541,
-0.29692474007606506,
-0.5545616745948792,
0.479292631149292,
-0.6895096302032471,
-0.20178534090518951,
-0.2764207124710083,
-0.04388776049017906,
-0.12536083161830902,
0.414773166179657,
0.24788428843021393,
0.6800904870033264,
0.7807605266571045,
-0.8316622376441956,
-0.294698566198349,
-0.17959795892238617,
-0.4384952485561371,
0.23502637445926666,
-0.7251942753791809,
-0.12627580761909485,
-0.27194783091545105,
0.0506637878715992,
-0.8602035641670227,
-0.4463168680667877,
-0.45566850900650024,
-0.14240281283855438,
0.5497345328330994,
-0.2671341598033905,
-0.6266553401947021,
-0.21159309148788452,
-0.08143258839845657,
0.5533813238143921,
0.5744760632514954,
-0.48362573981285095,
0.28736934065818787,
0.034448135644197464,
-0.06733265519142151,
-0.11008725315332413,
-0.7168872952461243,
-0.20811080932617188,
-0.40917521715164185,
-0.31347426772117615,
0.24249118566513062,
-0.17067116498947144,
-0.18153856694698334,
-0.07256847620010376,
0.39040592312812805,
-0.19090186059474945,
0.23959384858608246,
0.20033879578113556,
0.009682965464890003,
-0.36798095703125,
0.5114568471908569,
0.16202077269554138,
0.21040533483028412,
-0.05937523767352104,
-0.12225668877363205,
0.3704976737499237,
-0.38329780101776123,
-0.22217026352882385,
-0.15848077833652496,
0.17785868048667908,
0.8095747232437134,
-0.1371150016784668,
1.1946704387664795,
0.20563314855098724,
-0.30574697256088257,
-0.20323589444160461,
-0.09338819235563278,
-0.22352571785449982,
-0.37468597292900085,
0.3895089626312256,
-0.30348318815231323,
-0.8737428188323975,
0.6376585364341736,
0.12958550453186035,
-0.02790207788348198,
0.7660550475120544,
0.4228748679161072,
0.24346086382865906,
1.069122314453125,
0.9392091631889343,
0.29552462697029114,
0.6455621719360352,
-0.3583047688007355,
0.2854463458061218,
-1.0061935186386108,
-0.11143678426742554,
-0.4022623300552368,
-0.07937468588352203,
-0.6200118064880371,
-0.3110998272895813,
0.5034082531929016,
0.35714957118034363,
-0.6288487911224365,
0.35044199228286743,
-0.12521816790103912,
0.48954448103904724,
0.3775814473628998,
0.11826331168413162,
0.23922540247440338,
-0.22452183067798615,
0.05570881813764572,
0.1436651200056076,
-1.065824031829834,
-0.12316728383302689,
1.3221336603164673,
0.3320949077606201,
0.6930055618286133,
0.08809202909469604,
0.5134940147399902,
-0.013123181648552418,
0.43434885144233704,
-0.9221835732460022,
0.3982406258583069,
-0.0761609673500061,
-0.7863281965255737,
-0.7175184488296509,
-0.5678892731666565,
-0.9552745819091797,
0.2762730121612549,
-0.35217559337615967,
-0.7300371527671814,
0.2943542003631592,
0.06808873265981674,
-0.6500169038772583,
0.45527535676956177,
-0.9566778540611267,
0.6900432705879211,
-0.04162663221359253,
-0.2412736713886261,
-0.23695901036262512,
-0.5567482113838196,
0.36194875836372375,
-0.33243870735168457,
0.08636990189552307,
-0.04292754828929901,
0.09477825462818146,
0.6904967427253723,
-0.4671659469604492,
0.9878091812133789,
-0.10876575857400894,
-0.027898697182536125,
0.31942251324653625,
0.10199938714504242,
0.3275418281555176,
0.06724849343299866,
0.13799218833446503,
0.1400478035211563,
-0.17495521903038025,
-0.4327520728111267,
-0.6274389624595642,
0.5278198719024658,
-0.7145898342132568,
-0.6167780756950378,
-0.03876907750964165,
-0.4395045340061188,
-0.13769949972629547,
0.42863333225250244,
0.6060343980789185,
0.6119682192802429,
-0.09133773297071457,
0.6992945671081543,
0.6925760507583618,
-0.028934253379702568,
0.8664679527282715,
0.7848595976829529,
-0.05205276980996132,
0.1680082529783249,
0.5814552307128906,
0.6742159128189087,
0.6254776120185852,
0.3985719680786133,
0.21317936480045319,
0.030088912695646286,
-0.6320317983627319,
-0.280572772026062,
0.15199019014835358,
-0.5423177480697632,
-0.2040642499923706,
-0.4065391719341278,
-0.645695149898529,
-0.2976360321044922,
-0.30926039814949036,
-0.3953460156917572,
-0.2013077288866043,
-0.3480921685695648,
-0.20895226299762726,
0.21504691243171692,
0.7291648387908936,
-0.1965227723121643,
0.4385327100753784,
-0.5953221321105957,
-0.07782835513353348,
0.48047658801078796,
0.29539400339126587,
0.49115675687789917,
-0.9048166275024414,
-0.5600938200950623,
-0.1730714589357376,
-0.023401619866490364,
-0.6501656174659729,
0.45594722032546997,
0.5515143275260925,
0.34957918524742126,
0.8198583722114563,
-0.026745038107037544,
0.5438976287841797,
-0.628939688205719,
0.5977641940116882,
0.21779827773571014,
-0.8393648266792297,
0.6178271770477295,
-0.5223167538642883,
0.727039098739624,
0.313833624124527,
0.4453047811985016,
-0.07732515782117844,
-0.27714958786964417,
-0.984834611415863,
-0.6173173785209656,
0.7504289150238037,
0.1572844237089157,
0.35212188959121704,
-0.11837343126535416,
0.4794660806655884,
0.030781488865613937,
0.14785262942314148,
-0.8961840271949768,
-0.10653384774923325,
0.20358744263648987,
0.31607311964035034,
-0.3970542252063751,
-0.26579275727272034,
0.0590621642768383,
-0.5749679803848267,
0.36475133895874023,
-0.13865917921066284,
0.03029754012823105,
-0.025654805824160576,
-0.14393217861652374,
-0.16205839812755585,
0.4656746983528137,
0.5498622059822083,
0.5368606448173523,
-0.22589188814163208,
0.14689314365386963,
0.3166131377220154,
-0.3956652879714966,
0.28059959411621094,
-0.004022897221148014,
-0.37523794174194336,
-0.40344691276550293,
0.773524284362793,
0.9598115086555481,
0.6528542041778564,
-0.6953310370445251,
0.5129404664039612,
0.01651613786816597,
-0.1484219878911972,
-0.29730066657066345,
0.12575845420360565,
-0.1990319937467575,
0.07354094088077545,
0.5215122699737549,
0.11984234303236008,
0.0026446213014423847,
-0.47202691435813904,
0.12629562616348267,
0.4383527636528015,
-0.6528936624526978,
-0.5580766797065735,
0.4896816313266754,
-0.07481305301189423,
-0.04353293776512146,
0.6703845858573914,
-0.29243502020835876,
0.07682061940431595,
0.7745651006698608,
0.8257495164871216,
0.8327356576919556,
-0.21550551056861877,
0.39401325583457947,
0.3989129960536957,
0.5350456833839417,
0.0842515379190445,
-0.436111718416214,
-0.19630977511405945,
-0.8288294076919556,
-0.4103652238845825,
-0.6152178049087524,
-0.010765152983367443,
0.6906933188438416,
-0.6895415782928467,
0.10516726970672607,
-0.6124182939529419,
0.03485272079706192,
0.1192481592297554,
0.06984180212020874,
-0.9076329469680786,
0.2644852101802826,
-0.1461048424243927,
0.6375581622123718,
-1.0650641918182373,
0.842848539352417,
0.43590325117111206,
-0.7003898024559021,
-1.1406888961791992,
0.12307076901197433,
-0.10479273647069931,
-0.42402997612953186,
0.9631917476654053,
0.18604014813899994,
-0.019612887874245644,
0.2361176609992981,
-0.4812999367713928,
-1.1160924434661865,
1.0576403141021729,
0.7630575895309448,
-0.24667134881019592,
-0.06845100224018097,
-0.131087064743042,
0.7524587512016296,
-0.6739345788955688,
0.23809608817100525,
0.5605173110961914,
0.004661897197365761,
0.17977502942085266,
-1.030526876449585,
0.035798121243715286,
0.05878971889615059,
0.13007311522960663,
0.26505398750305176,
-0.4944656789302826,
1.2102946043014526,
-0.5924319624900818,
-0.5615859031677246,
-0.191711887717247,
0.37054717540740967,
-0.17359809577465057,
-0.05093248188495636,
0.311292439699173,
0.49640533328056335,
0.5067732334136963,
0.26154327392578125,
1.1490448713302612,
-0.15418702363967896,
0.45067667961120605,
1.127657175064087,
-0.199441596865654,
1.1369470357894897,
0.28779336810112,
-0.03213389590382576,
0.5002609491348267,
0.4958574175834656,
0.32199621200561523,
0.4309154450893402,
0.06558898091316223,
-0.4227007031440735,
-0.3355698585510254,
-0.09191402047872543,
-0.07645532488822937,
0.5544653534889221,
0.3171386122703552,
-0.5686970949172974,
-0.426539808511734,
0.31752926111221313,
0.13024002313613892,
-0.12162952870130539,
-0.6525964140892029,
0.7903339862823486,
0.05715432018041611,
-0.4376824200153351,
0.6200234889984131,
-0.22216860949993134,
0.27591440081596375,
-0.5746299624443054,
-0.046931616961956024,
-0.1268533319234848,
0.09347659349441528,
-0.004785834811627865,
-0.5070587396621704,
0.20100361108779907,
-0.15017729997634888,
-0.4225430190563202,
0.09838362038135529,
0.6376730799674988,
-0.28535887598991394,
-0.582059919834137,
0.3703254163265228,
0.34518155455589294,
0.02981915883719921,
-0.029191553592681885,
-0.22944284975528717,
-0.3817281723022461,
-0.2558101713657379,
-0.19412106275558472,
0.5625351071357727,
0.39565739035606384,
-0.11080241948366165,
0.7490434050559998,
0.3329811692237854,
0.2539992332458496,
0.11139923334121704,
0.07372725009918213,
0.7719917893409729,
-0.35705894231796265,
-0.2724810540676117,
-0.7914232611656189,
0.40360602736473083,
-0.03907302767038345,
-0.08027168363332748,
0.8929585218429565,
0.33411499857902527,
0.9112253189086914,
-0.31298625469207764,
0.7855554819107056,
-0.24102194607257843,
0.26960474252700806,
-0.41027605533599854,
0.7615857124328613,
-0.5948461294174194,
0.13342997431755066,
-0.10993275791406631,
-0.6775199174880981,
-0.3243674337863922,
0.2769617438316345,
-0.6535735130310059,
0.30347245931625366,
0.6030945777893066,
0.5542984008789062,
-0.02529893070459366,
-0.5893877744674683,
0.8846273422241211,
0.2954390347003937,
0.22340074181556702,
0.5327810049057007,
0.30734944343566895,
-0.2736499011516571,
0.3348299562931061,
0.011389708146452904,
-0.5633150339126587,
-0.304818719625473,
-0.7962406873703003,
-1.0024137496948242,
-0.8371533751487732,
-0.1343594491481781,
0.058456119149923325,
-0.43535125255584717,
0.6229475140571594,
0.8986362814903259,
-0.5714033246040344,
-0.10341440141201019,
-0.4134208858013153,
0.03211185708642006,
-0.28852853178977966,
-0.24451811611652374,
0.34788113832473755,
-0.539703905582428,
-0.3956875205039978,
0.4044463634490967,
0.4607582688331604,
0.20908114314079285,
-0.4316948652267456,
0.10161609947681427,
-0.14522826671600342,
0.36579185724258423,
0.8209480047225952,
0.6223514080047607,
-0.4225924015045166,
-0.4313041865825653,
-0.380068302154541,
0.12580929696559906,
-0.10275951772928238,
0.9281428456306458,
-0.6713865399360657,
0.6086978316307068,
0.23669756948947906,
0.3547389507293701,
0.5171683430671692,
-0.387778639793396,
0.472964346408844,
-1.048710584640503,
0.46964484453201294,
0.042239367961883545,
0.31486883759498596,
0.18857800960540771,
-0.4270212948322296,
0.12788474559783936,
-0.01938617043197155,
-0.3800605535507202,
-0.6211846470832825,
0.45502012968063354,
-0.349099338054657,
-0.32526320219039917,
0.9797383546829224,
-0.23521843552589417,
-0.06374938786029816,
0.009817228652536869,
0.1818302571773529,
0.16902224719524384,
0.07002861797809601,
0.620011031627655,
0.5393288731575012,
-0.38794633746147156,
-0.38289427757263184,
-0.5707499384880066,
0.8291088938713074,
0.10012473165988922,
-0.7041296362876892,
0.24825140833854675,
0.3094055950641632,
0.213898703455925,
0.2676580250263214,
0.6403396725654602,
0.006616674363613129,
0.17104770243167877,
0.38942742347717285,
-0.18581435084342957,
0.24670369923114777,
-0.605212390422821,
-0.6590054035186768,
0.4095403850078583,
0.4947059750556946,
0.19546376168727875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02138v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02138v2
|
Topic-based Watermarks for LLM-Generated Text
| 2024-04-02T17:49:40 | 2024-04-16T07:28:05 |
Alexander Nemecek, Yuzhou Jiang, Erman Ayday
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements of large language models (LLMs) have resulted in
indistinguishable text outputs comparable to human-generated text. Watermarking
algorithms are potential tools that offer a way to differentiate between LLM-
and human-generated text by embedding detectable signatures within
LLM-generated output. However, current watermarking schemes lack robustness
against known attacks against watermarking algorithms. In addition, they are
impractical considering an LLM generates tens of thousands of text outputs per
day and the watermarking algorithm needs to memorize each output it generates
for the detection to work. In this work, focusing on the limitations of current
watermarking schemes, we propose the concept of a "topic-based watermarking
algorithm" for LLMs. The proposed algorithm determines how to generate tokens
for the watermarked LLM output based on extracted topics of an input prompt or
the output of a non-watermarked LLM. Inspired from previous work, we propose
using a pair of lists (that are generated based on the specified extracted
topic(s)) that specify certain tokens to be included or excluded while
generating the watermarked output of the LLM. Using the proposed watermarking
algorithm, we show the practicality of a watermark detection algorithm.
Furthermore, we discuss a wide range of attacks that can emerge against
watermarking algorithms for LLMs and the benefit of the proposed watermarking
scheme for the feasibility of modeling a potential attacker considering its
benefit vs. loss.
|
[
-0.36304745078086853,
-0.8902485370635986,
0.48660701513290405,
-0.015263398177921772,
-0.7042312622070312,
0.24136371910572052,
0.005069558974355459,
-0.3197931945323944,
0.5569040179252625,
0.916546642780304,
-0.5625808238983154,
-0.459731787443161,
-0.7964925765991211,
-0.03162829205393791,
-0.6406072378158569,
0.8947243690490723,
-0.0494738444685936,
-0.3624591827392578,
-0.31340599060058594,
-0.010674317367374897,
-0.5700496435165405,
-0.8167843222618103,
-0.48914214968681335,
-0.20380987226963043,
0.47051313519477844,
0.31102344393730164,
0.12449084222316742,
0.7708063125610352,
0.5428685545921326,
0.20775453746318817,
-0.37175479531288147,
0.032187145203351974,
-0.44529658555984497,
0.4896289110183716,
-0.11889049410820007,
-0.28252461552619934,
-0.0213139820843935,
0.0607430599629879,
0.6483656167984009,
0.19418096542358398,
0.2990056276321411,
0.03445233777165413,
0.05581623315811157,
0.6047252416610718,
-0.6149603724479675,
-0.12040351331233978,
-0.9784203767776489,
0.21237105131149292,
-0.6307055354118347,
-0.49703752994537354,
-0.37401944398880005,
-0.05041182413697243,
-0.13191163539886475,
-0.19207358360290527,
0.09439908713102341,
0.09943140298128128,
0.9030435085296631,
0.0933099165558815,
0.006906980182975531,
-0.4445309042930603,
-0.623488187789917,
0.6812329888343811,
-0.8522419929504395,
0.12651872634887695,
0.47128424048423767,
0.09192768484354019,
-0.19392162561416626,
-0.739281415939331,
-0.5991476774215698,
-0.05145585536956787,
0.24881158769130707,
0.09093490242958069,
-0.25568631291389465,
-0.35122770071029663,
0.33785632252693176,
0.31872183084487915,
-0.39288467168807983,
-0.03652685135602951,
0.18868331611156464,
-0.21419334411621094,
0.4758971333503723,
0.2930300533771515,
0.44104087352752686,
-0.06862721592187881,
-0.4297955334186554,
0.03574606403708458,
-1.0177751779556274,
-0.11320530623197556,
0.48114222288131714,
0.3278178572654724,
0.030836038291454315,
0.6540407538414001,
-0.06621237099170685,
0.4184706509113312,
-0.07696820795536041,
-0.29554465413093567,
-0.35148897767066956,
-0.07024576514959335,
0.12003803253173828,
0.12782971560955048,
0.641899585723877,
0.2922021746635437,
0.23544897139072418,
-0.3201836347579956,
-0.39067432284355164,
-0.09257965534925461,
0.05020003765821457,
-0.9389614462852478,
-0.05981653556227684,
0.11717122793197632,
-0.47557520866394043,
-0.38603532314300537,
0.2431933581829071,
-0.8267815709114075,
-0.7825586795806885,
-0.007231853436678648,
0.49674564599990845,
-0.04643324017524719,
-0.10521693527698517,
-0.21698611974716187,
-0.23320430517196655,
-0.0705844908952713,
0.1981470137834549,
-0.7884212136268616,
0.3429592251777649,
0.8138333559036255,
0.8822053670883179,
-0.6222541928291321,
-0.012797700241208076,
-0.7516762018203735,
0.5984303951263428,
-0.1395648866891861,
1.0236985683441162,
-0.6741490960121155,
-0.6001565456390381,
-0.06559950113296509,
-0.12688003480434418,
0.3196764290332794,
-0.5474467277526855,
-0.0057811131700873375,
-0.7964270114898682,
0.24618549644947052,
-0.28905582427978516,
-1.0161255598068237,
0.25070348381996155,
0.301283061504364,
-0.8462159037590027,
0.9004077911376953,
-0.429577499628067,
-1.1985247135162354,
0.23460185527801514,
-0.6425641179084778,
-0.3617636263370514,
0.2610648274421692,
-0.2365466207265854,
-0.6316388845443726,
-0.10313145816326141,
0.026962686330080032,
0.44134992361068726,
-0.3997822403907776,
0.4035322964191437,
-0.24181564152240753,
-0.4025358557701111,
0.6654780507087708,
-0.7214919328689575,
0.4016381800174713,
-0.05393753945827484,
-0.5087947249412537,
0.205738827586174,
-0.5412983894348145,
-0.19448266923427582,
0.3928528130054474,
-0.44999557733535767,
-0.3040756583213806,
0.22693346440792084,
0.01961509883403778,
-0.21309597790241241,
0.6677120327949524,
-0.5452077388763428,
-0.05279148370027542,
-0.1937793642282486,
0.4651506543159485,
0.8841109275817871,
0.49939873814582825,
0.1255781203508377,
-0.4434031844139099,
0.6175418496131897,
-0.06099875271320343,
-0.15276804566383362,
-0.47228768467903137,
-0.7638084292411804,
-0.6540167331695557,
-0.5017451047897339,
0.5386682152748108,
0.5737498998641968,
-0.7206430435180664,
0.4161439538002014,
-0.016616929322481155,
-0.5044777989387512,
0.140371173620224,
0.21479350328445435,
0.26914867758750916,
0.47004279494285583,
0.22244785726070404,
-0.37731504440307617,
-0.22684431076049805,
-0.7188007235527039,
-0.42784184217453003,
-0.1701904833316803,
0.08813098818063736,
0.4472029507160187,
0.49662870168685913,
0.08288231492042542,
1.1237850189208984,
-0.7446327209472656,
-0.1217355951666832,
-0.22931712865829468,
0.2081446647644043,
0.026126282289624214,
0.5325936079025269,
0.4446301758289337,
-0.7525738477706909,
-0.4481552541255951,
-0.3403392434120178,
-0.36860889196395874,
-0.5019823312759399,
-0.0907672569155693,
-0.08107960969209671,
-0.06901130825281143,
0.7003639936447144,
-0.4868559241294861,
0.6354421973228455,
0.32943636178970337,
-0.5354602336883545,
0.5001084208488464,
-0.07104919850826263,
-0.17012502253055573,
-1.1145219802856445,
0.047987423837184906,
-0.05366532504558563,
-0.2159847468137741,
-0.4880372881889343,
-0.02440168522298336,
-0.14023981988430023,
-0.537713348865509,
-0.27404850721359253,
0.9718021154403687,
-0.18003304302692413,
-0.008984697051346302,
-0.7328912019729614,
-0.20688451826572418,
0.09061945974826813,
0.26625677943229675,
0.14398039877414703,
0.8452564477920532,
0.43941986560821533,
-0.3291754722595215,
0.13327676057815552,
-0.20742303133010864,
0.08278132230043411,
0.3872341513633728,
-0.6885630488395691,
0.4224702715873718,
-0.023716239258646965,
0.12987762689590454,
-1.010088324546814,
0.18628689646720886,
0.5786384344100952,
-0.25174686312675476,
0.48227977752685547,
-0.368429571390152,
-0.6010387539863586,
0.15905746817588806,
-0.5001402497291565,
0.1653527319431305,
0.340484082698822,
-0.4705708920955658,
0.3864038586616516,
0.38743162155151367,
-0.4425959587097168,
-0.4124978184700012,
-0.5163939595222473,
0.5084506869316101,
-0.6762293577194214,
-0.2502373158931732,
0.726530909538269,
-0.19322516024112701,
-0.1158735379576683,
0.09579955041408539,
-0.1253829151391983,
-0.2498958557844162,
0.43958961963653564,
0.5017461776733398,
0.1344621330499649,
-0.13945095241069794,
-0.06132308393716812,
-0.017932875081896782,
-0.3971897065639496,
-0.07296402752399445,
-0.3058255612850189,
0.6540293097496033,
0.2344268262386322,
-0.7533097267150879,
-0.4935961067676544,
0.7553447484970093,
0.5292009711265564,
-0.4350256621837616,
0.5468977093696594,
0.4402545392513275,
-0.7358472943305969,
-0.2475564032793045,
-0.524200975894928,
-0.3700270354747772,
-0.5017728209495544,
0.12103135883808136,
-0.0654793307185173,
-0.8311284184455872,
0.5334983468055725,
-0.22943809628486633,
0.11376947164535522,
0.3644067943096161,
0.43350210785865784,
-0.23461195826530457,
0.28595051169395447,
0.5284508466720581,
-0.2684480547904968,
0.784116268157959,
-0.05835568532347679,
0.1604849100112915,
-0.6131706237792969,
-0.09156908839941025,
-0.5701984763145447,
-0.16684986650943756,
-0.41387200355529785,
-0.5106673836708069,
-0.24400410056114197,
0.15835651755332947,
-0.10748804360628128,
0.25832775235176086,
-0.3968521058559418,
0.5609031319618225,
0.8074200749397278,
-0.059601590037345886,
0.22606322169303894,
0.37025952339172363,
-0.11185555160045624,
-0.3169240951538086,
-0.4392167925834656,
-0.9291269779205322,
1.041246771812439,
0.2276698499917984,
0.49750858545303345,
-0.09620943665504456,
1.1567469835281372,
0.7946998476982117,
0.4677700400352478,
-0.41586652398109436,
0.6805998086929321,
-0.1478760987520218,
-0.42463523149490356,
-0.4085052013397217,
-0.29431483149528503,
-1.0453941822052002,
0.0698603019118309,
-0.2306651622056961,
-0.7942339777946472,
-0.14883865416049957,
-0.19674131274223328,
0.09919959306716919,
0.5770640969276428,
-0.2761927843093872,
0.674915075302124,
-0.31293997168540955,
-0.5774645209312439,
-0.07171667367219925,
-0.111357182264328,
-0.24879248440265656,
-0.33228734135627747,
0.1336362361907959,
-0.3399546444416046,
-0.1980522722005844,
1.0542691946029663,
-0.32276907563209534,
0.9672338962554932,
-0.4067053198814392,
-0.3628580570220947,
0.4281957149505615,
0.08623918145895004,
0.4880983233451843,
0.33779653906822205,
0.02201089821755886,
0.24946565926074982,
-0.3137233257293701,
-0.24518504738807678,
-0.37987232208251953,
0.5064523816108704,
-0.34659066796302795,
-0.9021481871604919,
-0.4385887384414673,
-0.3894596993923187,
-0.06579959392547607,
0.3695865869522095,
0.0462079718708992,
0.5547225475311279,
-0.15896908938884735,
-0.029293673112988472,
0.6000840663909912,
-0.40629926323890686,
0.8129839301109314,
0.5332539677619934,
-0.10377490520477295,
-0.6413503289222717,
1.401282787322998,
0.093760184943676,
-0.16287243366241455,
0.587559700012207,
0.25653380155563354,
-0.1660671979188919,
-0.9481346011161804,
-0.3683508038520813,
0.1249428391456604,
-0.759161114692688,
-0.44581273198127747,
-0.30547213554382324,
-0.21571099758148193,
0.20641720294952393,
-0.1566382348537445,
-0.1823825091123581,
-0.32462117075920105,
-0.6325249075889587,
0.3541030287742615,
0.4765714406967163,
0.613457441329956,
0.19332264363765717,
0.1407124102115631,
-0.5929664969444275,
0.5336931347846985,
0.6961500644683838,
0.23003923892974854,
0.003134390339255333,
-0.5376597046852112,
0.10334639251232147,
-0.032751649618148804,
-0.5486730337142944,
-0.9332616329193115,
0.23836258053779602,
0.044059641659259796,
0.49693217873573303,
0.5418571829795837,
0.1034926325082779,
0.42416489124298096,
-0.6357206106185913,
0.8538678884506226,
0.24410678446292877,
-1.1109610795974731,
0.6457240581512451,
-0.22013993561267853,
-0.019482633098959923,
0.2073858231306076,
-0.16104917228221893,
-0.4865630269050598,
-0.6291550397872925,
-0.5285266637802124,
-0.9579631686210632,
0.46373310685157776,
0.4034169912338257,
0.4736224114894867,
-0.12664073705673218,
0.5456703305244446,
0.22646616399288177,
0.25812363624572754,
-0.7699481248855591,
-0.2630891799926758,
-0.22801463305950165,
-0.12144843488931656,
0.1913907676935196,
-0.4764881432056427,
-0.027809711173176765,
0.1391991227865219,
0.5993369817733765,
-0.014541441574692726,
0.46422404050827026,
0.07409780472517014,
-0.0062486291863024235,
0.1260804533958435,
0.318587064743042,
0.6593390703201294,
0.28716975450515747,
-0.09252627938985825,
0.3861711919307709,
0.0036760582588613033,
-0.35538530349731445,
0.324284166097641,
0.01334184966981411,
-0.40275686979293823,
0.10552094131708145,
0.638410210609436,
0.5908846259117126,
-0.048825737088918686,
-0.8129803538322449,
0.49647367000579834,
-0.07940828800201416,
0.002620187820866704,
-0.16405917704105377,
0.021986519917845726,
0.5270336270332336,
0.277071088552475,
0.5560624003410339,
-0.3125978708267212,
-0.23546697199344635,
-0.26858681440353394,
0.30595797300338745,
0.558648407459259,
-0.30526578426361084,
-0.15093985199928284,
0.6414217352867126,
0.20291349291801453,
-0.5649099946022034,
0.16992346942424774,
-0.09381218999624252,
-0.7408611178398132,
0.8550496101379395,
0.6865079402923584,
0.8973069190979004,
0.08588668704032898,
-0.03620615601539612,
-0.022702984511852264,
0.2481047511100769,
0.10322674363851547,
0.39928972721099854,
-0.12632299959659576,
-0.7801274061203003,
-0.02043674699962139,
-0.4909175932407379,
-0.7847520709037781,
0.39568018913269043,
-0.3913719058036804,
0.08204080909490585,
-0.6868947148323059,
-0.308340847492218,
-0.08438333123922348,
-0.0011497058439999819,
-0.15779221057891846,
0.17224889993667603,
0.5407060980796814,
0.5707259178161621,
-0.6122637987136841,
0.7746309041976929,
0.7896751165390015,
0.0349806547164917,
-0.16820015013217926,
0.4877226650714874,
-0.30302202701568604,
-0.5838017463684082,
0.5780382752418518,
0.30306944251060486,
-0.102922722697258,
-0.17363573610782623,
-0.4010336995124817,
-0.8837002515792847,
0.9933851957321167,
0.5036588311195374,
-0.4348383843898773,
0.4764181077480316,
0.42590779066085815,
0.2722384035587311,
-0.37800896167755127,
-0.2788688838481903,
0.014218972064554691,
0.4161546528339386,
-0.2619665563106537,
-0.28536903858184814,
0.3308972418308258,
-0.41763782501220703,
0.10228948295116425,
0.08288231492042542,
-0.4883742034435272,
0.7328125834465027,
0.2517363131046295,
-0.21059945225715637,
0.05106809362769127,
0.6578332185745239,
0.5713357329368591,
0.47093600034713745,
0.3554682433605194,
0.4335269331932068,
0.7366772890090942,
-0.06192765384912491,
0.7546490430831909,
-0.4251468777656555,
0.33262717723846436,
0.9067088961601257,
-0.4945492148399353,
0.8598830699920654,
0.7408010959625244,
-0.14845743775367737,
0.2487623691558838,
0.5124956965446472,
-0.3913513720035553,
0.804510235786438,
0.7233011722564697,
-0.31687238812446594,
-0.1736958920955658,
-0.4115593433380127,
-0.46243375539779663,
0.15410734713077545,
0.372211754322052,
-0.35522404313087463,
-0.004235598724335432,
-0.1917320191860199,
-0.012097951956093311,
0.10383821278810501,
-0.07238798588514328,
0.8245018124580383,
0.14873459935188293,
-0.24130496382713318,
0.3133983314037323,
0.45426809787750244,
0.8892322778701782,
-0.47457942366600037,
-0.06086896359920502,
-0.3913991451263428,
-0.2317187637090683,
0.0723123773932457,
-0.612438440322876,
0.13726086914539337,
0.380379319190979,
-0.23268572986125946,
-0.4305640459060669,
1.1641066074371338,
-0.40033894777297974,
-0.3537764251232147,
0.1526394933462143,
0.5918270945549011,
0.08454560488462448,
-0.17910321056842804,
-0.6172882318496704,
0.12916287779808044,
-0.0330081470310688,
-0.348969042301178,
0.4214070737361908,
0.4186277389526367,
-0.08557084202766418,
0.7100287675857544,
0.6952869892120361,
0.24650901556015015,
-0.06523636728525162,
0.005008656531572342,
0.7485518455505371,
-0.76580810546875,
-0.67947918176651,
-1.2716071605682373,
-0.038603391498327255,
-0.09773655980825424,
-0.15333357453346252,
0.5296347737312317,
0.43530362844467163,
0.2660036087036133,
0.016902191564440727,
0.9350199103355408,
0.28745949268341064,
0.15520872175693512,
-0.6760966181755066,
0.8123842477798462,
-0.5559806227684021,
0.5944424271583557,
-0.5289243459701538,
-0.9932921528816223,
-0.26032575964927673,
0.35346272587776184,
-0.028387119993567467,
-0.12762616574764252,
0.5304146409034729,
0.6073131561279297,
0.08489242941141129,
0.122433602809906,
0.25992175936698914,
-0.5123708248138428,
0.5334439873695374,
0.32230910658836365,
1.0507160425186157,
-0.13257332146167755,
0.4721735119819641,
-0.28483283519744873,
0.08450496196746826,
-0.1944429725408554,
-1.2503750324249268,
-1.1305066347122192,
-0.4968051612377167,
-0.6824409365653992,
-0.056214962154626846,
0.04745108634233475,
0.5976727604866028,
0.5161418914794922,
-0.9933720231056213,
-0.1023983284831047,
-0.16235452890396118,
0.3101634979248047,
0.08557761460542679,
-0.21319876611232758,
0.6464434266090393,
0.18443801999092102,
-0.41104793548583984,
0.336241751909256,
0.4376043975353241,
0.5358366966247559,
-0.1963540017604828,
-0.043082498013973236,
0.12661021947860718,
0.36523085832595825,
0.24863065779209137,
0.16068290174007416,
-0.7105370759963989,
-0.2811596095561981,
-0.2394525557756424,
-0.03295954316854477,
-0.038581717759370804,
1.001919150352478,
-0.5184080600738525,
0.12247350811958313,
0.33477717638015747,
0.8514425754547119,
0.5195139646530151,
-0.07117930054664612,
0.2591720521450043,
-0.8412706255912781,
0.1730576902627945,
0.1957605630159378,
0.4842970669269562,
0.5274789929389954,
-0.2753438651561737,
0.17795273661613464,
0.6259843707084656,
0.08300210535526276,
-0.9862284064292908,
0.10611264407634735,
-0.5797163248062134,
-0.4741431474685669,
1.1053400039672852,
-0.4687718451023102,
0.1291159987449646,
-0.22609977424144745,
-0.2726162374019623,
0.12150734663009644,
-0.5350253582000732,
0.797512412071228,
0.8414154052734375,
0.2959447205066681,
0.15698465704917908,
-0.27598604559898376,
0.26204144954681396,
0.4583916962146759,
-1.04703950881958,
0.3017677068710327,
-0.003398762783035636,
0.40814584493637085,
0.12604251503944397,
0.48410141468048096,
-0.152342289686203,
0.16591192781925201,
-0.07585272192955017,
0.10854167491197586,
-0.20078089833259583,
-0.16526204347610474,
-0.18940357863903046,
0.4268239438533783,
0.1695457249879837,
-0.22481894493103027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02127v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02127v1
|
FLawN-T5: An Empirical Examination of Effective Instruction-Tuning Data Mixtures for Legal Reasoning
| 2024-04-02T17:33:34 | 2024-04-02T17:33:34 |
Joel Niklaus, Lucia Zheng, Arya D. McCarthy, Christopher Hahn, Brian M. Rosen, Peter Henderson, Daniel E. Ho, Garrett Honke, Percy Liang, Christopher Manning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2
|
Instruction tuning is an important step in making language models useful for
direct user interaction. However, many legal tasks remain out of reach for most
open LLMs and there do not yet exist any large scale instruction datasets for
the domain. This critically limits research in this application area. In this
work, we curate LawInstruct, a large legal instruction dataset, covering 17
jurisdictions, 24 languages and a total of 12M examples. We present evidence
that domain-specific pretraining and instruction tuning improve performance on
LegalBench, including improving Flan-T5 XL by 8 points or 16\% over the
baseline. However, the effect does not generalize across all tasks, training
regimes, model sizes, and other factors. LawInstruct is a resource for
accelerating the development of models with stronger information processing and
decision making capabilities in the legal domain.
|
[
-0.2353234589099884,
-0.5508594512939453,
0.46172311902046204,
-0.09041645377874374,
-0.17251737415790558,
-0.16481754183769226,
-0.20322158932685852,
-0.18874816596508026,
-0.24142692983150482,
0.7831907272338867,
-0.46597737073898315,
-0.9524432420730591,
-0.3207114338874817,
-0.29595038294792175,
-0.5660586953163147,
0.8863521218299866,
0.12215093523263931,
0.3566324710845947,
-0.2961727976799011,
-0.2398754060268402,
-0.7697190046310425,
-0.3885899484157562,
-0.33930256962776184,
-0.10771220177412033,
0.2899397611618042,
0.609005331993103,
0.34928640723228455,
0.8048443794250488,
0.47737085819244385,
0.27603715658187866,
0.2993251085281372,
-0.12652276456356049,
-0.6926407217979431,
-0.016966495662927628,
-0.45617514848709106,
-0.9204190969467163,
-0.5217185616493225,
0.10008081048727036,
0.30696865916252136,
0.6675428152084351,
-0.6065219044685364,
0.0038198025431483984,
-0.29861271381378174,
0.592289388179779,
-1.0048539638519287,
-0.14781111478805542,
-0.532981812953949,
0.20225220918655396,
-0.4853406548500061,
-0.1831904649734497,
-0.6197566986083984,
-0.457752525806427,
-0.10448100417852402,
-0.7103972434997559,
0.555447518825531,
0.46702685952186584,
0.820345401763916,
0.5460337996482849,
-0.5318310856819153,
-0.29301902651786804,
-0.5672593712806702,
0.8021007180213928,
-0.9416239261627197,
0.6469990611076355,
0.4094773530960083,
0.3435058295726776,
-0.3746224343776703,
-0.8328874707221985,
-0.352581650018692,
-0.05995124205946922,
0.2917158603668213,
0.31004369258880615,
0.1395372897386551,
0.5146670341491699,
0.6034133434295654,
0.3772840201854706,
-0.4670310914516449,
0.44670259952545166,
-0.39427071809768677,
-0.25571098923683167,
0.6770559549331665,
0.3441280722618103,
0.37201762199401855,
0.279959499835968,
0.04220154508948326,
-0.3075392544269562,
-0.9681504964828491,
0.03320220857858658,
0.7303851246833801,
0.12208716571331024,
0.03432189300656319,
0.5739725232124329,
0.1338586062192917,
0.8547618389129639,
0.32133862376213074,
-0.2392328977584839,
0.11004894971847534,
-0.2939983010292053,
-0.46291643381118774,
0.35959091782569885,
0.5406573414802551,
0.2033507525920868,
0.125255286693573,
-0.15370775759220123,
-0.4748079478740692,
-0.31742560863494873,
0.5555904507637024,
-0.9245452284812927,
-0.2849904000759125,
0.3155129551887512,
-0.3187935948371887,
-0.13688424229621887,
0.47412043809890747,
-0.6012105345726013,
-0.5636274218559265,
-0.5780614614486694,
0.24116866290569305,
-0.6088826060295105,
-0.04327360913157463,
0.45455971360206604,
-0.19500142335891724,
0.4208992123603821,
0.371151864528656,
-0.924976646900177,
0.3441479802131653,
0.8594165444374084,
0.28469812870025635,
-0.001205660286359489,
-0.0882958173751831,
-0.8499748110771179,
0.08215401321649551,
-0.5748971700668335,
0.6300066709518433,
-0.9271402955055237,
-0.37758126854896545,
0.04467550665140152,
0.03917448967695236,
-0.2255024015903473,
-1.0639753341674805,
0.8365410566329956,
-0.612952709197998,
0.09084848314523697,
-0.35719072818756104,
-1.055149793624878,
-0.16627171635627747,
-0.10888867825269699,
-0.7469072937965393,
0.765949010848999,
0.2561049163341522,
-0.4727887213230133,
0.9631791114807129,
-0.7798307538032532,
-0.7750114798545837,
-0.027836155146360397,
-0.379845529794693,
-0.6704085469245911,
0.2615843117237091,
0.10480712354183197,
0.3898434042930603,
-0.19686265289783478,
0.3148968815803528,
-0.44158631563186646,
-0.6057667136192322,
0.02717902697622776,
-0.07495429366827011,
0.9026597738265991,
0.3081026077270508,
-0.7664685845375061,
0.08317308872938156,
-0.7097399234771729,
-0.08556003868579865,
-0.12606729567050934,
-0.26139479875564575,
-0.3541555106639862,
0.05865158513188362,
-0.44260281324386597,
0.07754766196012497,
-0.1103968620300293,
-0.45331165194511414,
0.09138315916061401,
-0.4358665347099304,
0.07318871468305588,
0.7507147789001465,
-0.048022061586380005,
0.3920125365257263,
-0.22142867743968964,
0.8262064456939697,
0.44211313128471375,
-0.045563019812107086,
-0.006560677196830511,
-0.08950715512037277,
-0.9720735549926758,
-0.14206582307815552,
0.7042698264122009,
0.6275579333305359,
-0.7427907586097717,
0.3821922540664673,
-0.23614396154880524,
-0.04037446528673172,
-0.7964668273925781,
0.17595216631889343,
0.3885318636894226,
0.2969438135623932,
0.28654223680496216,
-0.1774413287639618,
-0.5072147250175476,
-0.8552249073982239,
-0.51661217212677,
0.39920517802238464,
0.14040668308734894,
0.4003658592700958,
0.49550288915634155,
0.1768028289079666,
0.6126761436462402,
-0.19438444077968597,
-0.1169184073805809,
-0.22249016165733337,
0.06817079335451126,
0.18316365778446198,
0.33281171321868896,
0.7084234356880188,
-0.3897225856781006,
-0.4823410212993622,
0.05495716631412506,
-0.7067070603370667,
-0.2169346958398819,
-0.11247037351131439,
-0.1614367812871933,
0.11195389181375504,
0.4874608814716339,
-0.2062220275402069,
0.5744065642356873,
-0.07244610041379929,
-0.3930658996105194,
0.45418983697891235,
-0.2982482612133026,
0.38792410492897034,
-0.9195426106452942,
-0.22956116497516632,
-0.08326049894094467,
-0.206649512052536,
-0.49903714656829834,
0.13732047379016876,
0.22478128969669342,
-0.0458262637257576,
-0.5924402475357056,
0.2251836210489273,
-0.49023669958114624,
-0.2710437774658203,
-0.2110590785741806,
-0.019739076495170593,
-0.1918260157108307,
0.21070405840873718,
-0.3494398891925812,
1.240671157836914,
0.5339588522911072,
-0.6508071422576904,
0.25674140453338623,
-0.056050464510917664,
-0.6524841785430908,
0.7308436036109924,
-0.45825791358947754,
0.1310417652130127,
-0.0665581077337265,
-0.045423056930303574,
-0.3893379271030426,
-0.587813675403595,
0.05375353991985321,
0.2036452442407608,
0.5459674000740051,
-0.24640142917633057,
-0.5926291942596436,
-0.19416357576847076,
-0.25097644329071045,
0.2228185087442398,
0.4696778357028961,
-0.4990006983280182,
0.5648288130760193,
0.33834555745124817,
0.2938554584980011,
-0.7254520058631897,
-0.6424717307090759,
-0.04600587114691734,
-0.5375592112541199,
-0.6117548942565918,
0.3420821726322174,
0.14942820370197296,
-0.4517129361629486,
0.06419268250465393,
-0.23877857625484467,
-0.19622738659381866,
0.06805640459060669,
0.1454439014196396,
-0.12472353875637054,
-0.5963637828826904,
-0.001171135576441884,
0.3726904094219208,
0.23582956194877625,
0.30206918716430664,
-0.4192616939544678,
0.28904619812965393,
0.07716194540262222,
-0.5743288993835449,
-0.4474595785140991,
0.039777662605047226,
0.2618595361709595,
-0.16281066834926605,
0.6661814451217651,
0.3557370603084564,
0.05238206684589386,
-0.7136978507041931,
-0.5598814487457275,
-0.19338753819465637,
-0.5430520176887512,
0.3587534725666046,
-0.49623385071754456,
-0.9213371872901917,
0.2849366068840027,
-0.15315750241279602,
0.3632577657699585,
0.3091360926628113,
0.41525042057037354,
-0.23935233056545258,
0.5906915664672852,
0.34931662678718567,
0.08564458787441254,
0.5817081332206726,
-0.06581798940896988,
0.25928062200546265,
-0.3121821880340576,
-0.15129435062408447,
-0.4025011956691742,
-0.3123532235622406,
-0.5654330253601074,
-0.34792229533195496,
0.33157530426979065,
-0.16863295435905457,
-0.3447812795639038,
0.2186814844608307,
-0.033753104507923126,
0.9346883893013,
0.6935831904411316,
0.3896445035934448,
-0.023860875517129898,
0.14795947074890137,
-0.21878421306610107,
-0.07803421467542648,
-0.9604532718658447,
-0.1882549524307251,
1.4109363555908203,
-0.02170724794268608,
0.7591426372528076,
0.1724737286567688,
0.9494668841362,
0.27137282490730286,
0.028714995831251144,
-0.7015254497528076,
0.6147192120552063,
-0.726104736328125,
-0.7302326560020447,
-0.14496026933193207,
-0.49597811698913574,
-1.014457106590271,
-0.04345478489995003,
-0.10390377044677734,
-0.41558584570884705,
0.008776180446147919,
0.26452046632766724,
-0.39620649814605713,
0.29383331537246704,
-0.8512148857116699,
0.9556090831756592,
-0.5013700127601624,
-0.7242962718009949,
-0.4803362488746643,
-0.5602011680603027,
0.5053431987762451,
-0.11077045649290085,
0.1513274610042572,
-0.01149589940905571,
0.19503606855869293,
0.6995130181312561,
-0.8830767273902893,
0.8006924986839294,
-0.4746125340461731,
-0.26971787214279175,
0.40774035453796387,
0.030248405411839485,
0.44003015756607056,
-0.3595646917819977,
-0.12370916455984116,
-0.2692318558692932,
-0.023720519617199898,
-0.37474730610847473,
-0.9574869275093079,
0.5779238939285278,
-0.6052952408790588,
-0.7895915508270264,
-0.11768796294927597,
-0.5419898629188538,
-0.31286078691482544,
0.28884121775627136,
0.12668940424919128,
0.5616713762283325,
-0.05010887607932091,
0.44735094904899597,
1.1071453094482422,
-0.2815752923488617,
0.20135867595672607,
0.4397796392440796,
0.14494910836219788,
-0.1535201221704483,
1.162179708480835,
0.1332859992980957,
0.01178846787661314,
0.26178932189941406,
0.06555993854999542,
-0.259169340133667,
-0.6098247170448303,
-0.2637692987918854,
0.09076334536075592,
-0.9169705510139465,
-0.04288021847605705,
-0.1404798924922943,
-0.04255246743559837,
-0.2587413787841797,
-0.0002899851242545992,
-0.4429769217967987,
-0.2767146825790405,
-0.17582955956459045,
-0.15733502805233002,
0.11723797023296356,
0.8238179087638855,
0.252707839012146,
0.1772606521844864,
-0.5431934595108032,
0.0875210240483284,
0.02838711068034172,
0.5500860214233398,
-0.3180525004863739,
-0.7470601201057434,
-0.3243849277496338,
0.047263022512197495,
-0.1702648401260376,
-0.516307532787323,
-0.12585072219371796,
0.28861764073371887,
0.8545562028884888,
0.6598179340362549,
0.11165637522935867,
0.8800783157348633,
-0.4982154369354248,
0.6607756614685059,
-0.05536101758480072,
-0.9140732288360596,
0.5941693186759949,
-0.2622578740119934,
0.07627948373556137,
0.6944643259048462,
0.19624702632427216,
0.14565108716487885,
-0.31951388716697693,
-0.6895339488983154,
-0.6546643972396851,
1.0037227869033813,
0.15330539643764496,
0.04390784725546837,
0.4799618721008301,
0.5205744504928589,
0.32555335760116577,
0.16911210119724274,
-0.3304379880428314,
-0.1324310153722763,
-0.3047453761100769,
-0.5423890948295593,
0.2886461615562439,
0.0516795739531517,
-0.12716853618621826,
-0.3946431875228882,
0.6401973366737366,
0.18491008877754211,
0.13718707859516144,
-0.45298346877098083,
-0.21429602801799774,
0.2194623500108719,
0.2717476189136505,
1.0205304622650146,
0.6379667520523071,
0.03831419721245766,
0.18987856805324554,
0.2197454273700714,
-0.5953506827354431,
0.28129497170448303,
-0.10755828022956848,
0.016195286065340042,
-0.29238229990005493,
0.5447512865066528,
1.022779107093811,
0.21018144488334656,
-0.7129250168800354,
0.5581235885620117,
0.10999373346567154,
-0.5700246691703796,
-0.08983348309993744,
0.9164505004882812,
-0.1423889696598053,
0.21371346712112427,
-0.14976508915424347,
-0.15445899963378906,
0.22277987003326416,
-0.3940558135509491,
0.2631608545780182,
0.020270366221666336,
-0.22045040130615234,
-0.1939222812652588,
0.7752446532249451,
0.11311852931976318,
-0.0044484492391347885,
0.7155425548553467,
-0.10382028669118881,
-0.09496369957923889,
0.7652826905250549,
0.4479123055934906,
0.6781639456748962,
-0.11891378462314606,
-0.026026200503110886,
0.31855377554893494,
0.2854861617088318,
-0.16816362738609314,
0.3442470133304596,
-0.10632749646902084,
-0.6047222018241882,
-0.44899898767471313,
-0.19802060723304749,
-0.24909134209156036,
0.27356383204460144,
-0.6138530373573303,
0.3429149389266968,
-0.6028507947921753,
0.0017624397296458483,
-0.12628883123397827,
-0.2631092369556427,
-0.6710792183876038,
0.3926349878311157,
-0.283683717250824,
0.7455400228500366,
-0.6066506505012512,
0.8348795771598816,
0.686671793460846,
-0.4572545289993286,
-0.8580479025840759,
0.16550223529338837,
0.18641434609889984,
-0.6209474205970764,
0.7112905383110046,
-0.03575461357831955,
-0.06964319199323654,
-0.054206445813179016,
-0.88646399974823,
-0.3738726079463959,
1.0338494777679443,
0.7504368424415588,
-0.7567759156227112,
0.23630352318286896,
0.6082296371459961,
0.37226954102516174,
-0.25529909133911133,
0.09866402298212051,
0.8657829165458679,
0.4529980719089508,
0.07006527483463287,
-0.5626405477523804,
-0.06963711231946945,
-0.07526910305023193,
-0.29344499111175537,
0.31159424781799316,
-0.4346848428249359,
0.4353320598602295,
-0.08009406179189682,
-0.15622162818908691,
-0.38058722019195557,
0.5994580984115601,
0.24554964900016785,
0.23741957545280457,
0.4290400445461273,
0.8397849202156067,
1.0308455228805542,
-0.21620364487171173,
1.0546635389328003,
-0.47303611040115356,
0.05984913185238838,
1.3197021484375,
-0.38880297541618347,
0.43783748149871826,
0.30746811628341675,
-0.14711228013038635,
0.4269610345363617,
0.7113339304924011,
-0.1449321061372757,
0.4254671335220337,
0.2636880576610565,
-0.29083484411239624,
-0.4737851023674011,
-0.02623762935400009,
-0.22526493668556213,
0.393766313791275,
0.4096318781375885,
-0.36669108271598816,
-0.06148490309715271,
-0.1215493306517601,
0.07632041722536087,
-0.03655827417969704,
-0.24806658923625946,
0.7556332945823669,
0.000618847378063947,
-0.6706733107566833,
0.36821305751800537,
0.10320253670215607,
0.26426100730895996,
-0.35419008135795593,
-0.13741406798362732,
-0.5446306467056274,
0.16757969558238983,
-0.36644652485847473,
-0.715796709060669,
0.1118197962641716,
0.04433080181479454,
0.12299907207489014,
-0.14175982773303986,
0.6710021495819092,
-0.40743789076805115,
-0.20507273077964783,
-0.05102251470088959,
0.2667832374572754,
0.30077725648880005,
0.2509581744670868,
-0.6172480583190918,
-0.10153970867395401,
0.04455183818936348,
-0.13628169894218445,
0.260827898979187,
0.8284074664115906,
-0.19639287889003754,
0.5493867993354797,
0.35391828417778015,
-0.03536998853087425,
0.3291698098182678,
0.42522165179252625,
0.8094498515129089,
-0.7100637555122375,
-0.3852212429046631,
-0.5862888693809509,
0.5811787247657776,
-0.23394806683063507,
-0.32645174860954285,
0.7101308107376099,
0.7962323427200317,
1.0053629875183105,
-0.15989603102207184,
0.7971916198730469,
-0.012333337217569351,
0.2193990796804428,
-1.1593035459518433,
0.50472491979599,
-0.6375885605812073,
0.4716617166996002,
0.015004043467342854,
-0.8056870102882385,
-0.2711116671562195,
0.47900351881980896,
-0.5205347537994385,
0.344653844833374,
0.7955835461616516,
0.900270938873291,
-0.7086219191551208,
0.06560068577528,
0.5497010946273804,
0.08958877623081207,
0.27760565280914307,
0.3310586214065552,
0.6604942083358765,
-0.29720279574394226,
0.27985063195228577,
-0.1966465413570404,
0.16433024406433105,
-0.26248642802238464,
-0.6068442463874817,
-1.1697732210159302,
-0.13985539972782135,
-0.2739519476890564,
-0.24037139117717743,
0.2815159857273102,
0.8701393604278564,
0.7118876576423645,
-1.1611077785491943,
-0.4098389148712158,
-0.36134350299835205,
-0.12270834296941757,
0.04100880026817322,
-0.23461520671844482,
0.26625025272369385,
-0.759637176990509,
-0.5427238345146179,
0.6531590223312378,
0.1906360685825348,
-0.06747084856033325,
0.0893651619553566,
-0.1544060856103897,
-0.005559515208005905,
0.15475474298000336,
0.3503428101539612,
0.08911518007516861,
-0.6639117002487183,
-0.24057120084762573,
-0.05606309324502945,
-0.08199933171272278,
0.19663284718990326,
1.2575045824050903,
-0.0864662379026413,
0.6150551438331604,
0.3040967285633087,
0.9620010852813721,
0.6141912341117859,
0.1443699598312378,
0.8503807783126831,
-0.8019849061965942,
0.27294954657554626,
0.1529734879732132,
0.40065547823905945,
-0.040111955255270004,
-0.2521756589412689,
0.6663660407066345,
0.25797605514526367,
-0.38875651359558105,
-0.46823111176490784,
0.03409845754504204,
-0.5740891098976135,
-0.34341612458229065,
0.9647208452224731,
-0.28321340680122375,
-0.2732309103012085,
-0.2099711298942566,
-0.0531858466565609,
0.14529526233673096,
-0.422087699174881,
0.6815213561058044,
0.9497057795524597,
-0.13348686695098877,
-0.35352134704589844,
-1.0003361701965332,
0.4695153832435608,
0.7119289040565491,
-1.0791394710540771,
-0.2106981724500656,
0.7024611830711365,
0.37555035948753357,
-0.49067723751068115,
0.1921771913766861,
0.0582180954515934,
0.47412893176078796,
0.3020193576812744,
0.10109708458185196,
-0.21861593425273895,
-0.35141777992248535,
-0.16482053697109222,
0.2149491012096405,
-0.07351166754961014,
0.0013459428446367383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02126v1
|
Rematch: Robust and Efficient Matching of Local Knowledge Graphs to Improve Structural and Semantic Similarity
| 2024-04-02T17:33:00 | 2024-04-02T17:33:00 |
Zoher Kachwala, Jisun An, Haewoon Kwak, Filippo Menczer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Knowledge graphs play a pivotal role in various applications, such as
question-answering and fact-checking. Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR)
represents text as knowledge graphs. Evaluating the quality of these graphs
involves matching them structurally to each other and semantically to the
source text. Existing AMR metrics are inefficient and struggle to capture
semantic similarity. We also lack a systematic evaluation benchmark for
assessing structural similarity between AMR graphs. To overcome these
limitations, we introduce a novel AMR similarity metric, rematch, alongside a
new evaluation for structural similarity called RARE. Among state-of-the-art
metrics, rematch ranks second in structural similarity; and first in semantic
similarity by 1--5 percentage points on the STS-B and SICK-R benchmarks.
Rematch is also five times faster than the next most efficient metric.
|
[
-0.259891539812088,
-0.5048781633377075,
0.5467115640640259,
-0.0338769257068634,
-0.3854670822620392,
0.37546584010124207,
0.05746116489171982,
-0.48768219351768494,
0.7762861847877502,
0.28086188435554504,
-0.1893732249736786,
-0.4493274688720703,
-0.5189377069473267,
0.2818663716316223,
-0.31979265809059143,
0.6181666851043701,
-0.47404593229293823,
0.19071683287620544,
-0.6799864768981934,
-0.8405823707580566,
-0.1689639687538147,
-0.5110974311828613,
-0.5386783480644226,
-0.6176965832710266,
0.5988416075706482,
-0.04844578728079796,
0.8782166838645935,
0.7881253361701965,
0.6331185102462769,
0.43561744689941406,
-0.04512032866477966,
-0.0842505544424057,
-0.5474382638931274,
0.3027189075946808,
-0.259537011384964,
-0.17230820655822754,
-0.33218687772750854,
-0.2766682505607605,
0.9821993112564087,
1.0526878833770752,
0.10800948739051819,
-0.010533532127737999,
0.04837295413017273,
0.961901843547821,
-0.49073219299316406,
0.15872250497341156,
-0.9079402685165405,
0.07690016180276871,
-0.5008158087730408,
-0.2875312864780426,
-0.026638543233275414,
-0.7161210775375366,
0.03343928977847099,
-0.6231987476348877,
0.15202882885932922,
0.44187861680984497,
1.2686548233032227,
0.13075251877307892,
-0.5865874290466309,
0.13480094075202942,
-0.22847263514995575,
0.34426620602607727,
-0.43592962622642517,
0.5331763029098511,
-0.07279299944639206,
0.5790761113166809,
-0.407809317111969,
-0.9936215877532959,
-0.75001460313797,
-0.05560057610273361,
-0.27249786257743835,
0.14732903242111206,
-0.7350673675537109,
0.0557597391307354,
-0.047452960163354874,
0.5527524948120117,
-0.534936785697937,
-0.16101497411727905,
-0.35804635286331177,
-0.5656852722167969,
0.22622491419315338,
0.3861476480960846,
0.19332778453826904,
-0.3008623719215393,
-0.6292256116867065,
-0.29948312044143677,
-0.5998245477676392,
-0.24774077534675598,
0.44689932465553284,
0.31156614422798157,
0.24457423388957977,
0.6052218079566956,
-0.6101329326629639,
0.9617841839790344,
-0.26057112216949463,
0.04983774945139885,
0.5335908532142639,
-0.651901125907898,
0.0685228556394577,
0.16504602134227753,
0.9049819707870483,
0.6539705395698547,
0.0297207310795784,
-0.5412688851356506,
-0.03975655511021614,
0.29798778891563416,
0.1427847295999527,
-0.6890557408332825,
-0.2901778817176819,
-0.17361608147621155,
-0.6063138842582703,
-0.04663843661546707,
0.06205148994922638,
-0.47532162070274353,
-0.3084787428379059,
-0.20555433630943298,
0.606224000453949,
-0.43169450759887695,
-0.009543846361339092,
0.11400506645441055,
-0.5704001188278198,
0.25413641333580017,
0.12415499240159988,
-0.4812910258769989,
0.4321410059928894,
0.7315954566001892,
1.0381108522415161,
-0.3719901442527771,
-0.03554278612136841,
-0.4304690957069397,
0.14992962777614594,
-0.1793259084224701,
1.059407114982605,
-0.6202763319015503,
0.03803270682692528,
-0.2931455373764038,
-0.16755712032318115,
-0.1482435166835785,
-0.7369293570518494,
0.43317654728889465,
-0.7303526401519775,
-0.13224950432777405,
-0.37253615260124207,
-0.8184556365013123,
-0.184000626206398,
0.5849972367286682,
-0.9356684684753418,
0.9965585470199585,
0.3149355947971344,
-1.190567135810852,
0.5192188620567322,
-0.23888640105724335,
-0.4576166868209839,
0.0981517806649208,
-0.16463856399059296,
-0.4345640540122986,
-0.19209054112434387,
-0.24525728821754456,
0.1995813548564911,
-0.14618802070617676,
-0.2208145409822464,
-0.948223352432251,
-0.37846988439559937,
0.09484206140041351,
0.018888939172029495,
0.16631464660167694,
0.15928864479064941,
-0.053253911435604095,
0.15245071053504944,
-0.8305575847625732,
0.23729272186756134,
0.0019557829946279526,
-0.24752134084701538,
-0.9078150391578674,
0.0773097351193428,
-0.3459905683994293,
0.06726976484060287,
0.5359042286872864,
-0.717042863368988,
0.15975697338581085,
-0.6922935247421265,
0.3449026942253113,
0.5684362649917603,
0.06784330308437347,
0.38545355200767517,
-0.5402626395225525,
0.3362513482570648,
0.012110699899494648,
-0.28423187136650085,
0.21375159919261932,
-0.4408358931541443,
-0.40224775671958923,
-0.21617069840431213,
0.5523828864097595,
0.3022770285606384,
-0.5934893488883972,
0.19690920412540436,
-0.7214797139167786,
-0.653523325920105,
-0.7898402810096741,
-0.06429227441549301,
0.4463047981262207,
0.5937753319740295,
0.31102654337882996,
-0.7528624534606934,
-0.7044246792793274,
-0.9088196158409119,
-0.7029760479927063,
-0.166685089468956,
0.06957880407571793,
0.40554967522621155,
0.6022686958312988,
0.08517920970916748,
1.1661136150360107,
-0.5871475338935852,
-0.47522401809692383,
-0.05863669142127037,
0.06262721866369247,
0.15778137743473053,
0.1418178826570511,
0.6822310090065002,
-0.7530198693275452,
-0.6790050268173218,
0.18074190616607666,
-0.7177984714508057,
0.17128968238830566,
0.3398657441139221,
-0.2987074851989746,
0.01538573857396841,
0.5384366512298584,
-0.2975851893424988,
0.37404531240463257,
0.31895142793655396,
-0.7259467244148254,
0.5072410702705383,
-0.00483331922441721,
0.6502200365066528,
-1.1382369995117188,
0.24597641825675964,
-0.5535575151443481,
-0.3627530038356781,
-0.051740776747465134,
0.04903188720345497,
-0.0437019020318985,
-0.1300116777420044,
-0.2654218375682831,
1.0379589796066284,
-0.2694099545478821,
-0.19010955095291138,
-0.031676098704338074,
0.7612821459770203,
0.009696375578641891,
0.2096358984708786,
-0.07436553388834,
0.6709122657775879,
0.33198902010917664,
-0.1869010329246521,
0.686364471912384,
0.38068675994873047,
-0.4910227358341217,
0.8617866039276123,
-0.856633722782135,
0.03205261379480362,
0.0048232912085950375,
0.2468368262052536,
-0.9847307205200195,
-0.1397247165441513,
0.1411505937576294,
-0.6109398007392883,
-0.03306062892079353,
-0.18129387497901917,
-0.6957429051399231,
-0.43110063672065735,
-0.5402463674545288,
0.49825572967529297,
0.2317112684249878,
-0.43783122301101685,
0.5067406892776489,
0.24393349885940552,
0.018643207848072052,
-0.6219555735588074,
-0.3042333424091339,
-0.018292702734470367,
-0.20411139726638794,
-0.6796693205833435,
0.5700236558914185,
0.29196667671203613,
-0.247984379529953,
0.6945739388465881,
-0.4256305992603302,
0.005721536464989185,
-0.08511173725128174,
0.14647012948989868,
-0.20812052488327026,
-0.36114048957824707,
0.003962595947086811,
0.17294351756572723,
-0.33805766701698303,
-0.11995827406644821,
-0.41784122586250305,
0.3620321750640869,
-0.09638512879610062,
-0.5550168752670288,
0.02928103879094124,
0.3932676911354065,
0.5969687104225159,
-0.14680112898349762,
0.9701032638549805,
0.39082077145576477,
-0.43748554587364197,
0.323194682598114,
-0.4464186429977417,
-0.0867110937833786,
-0.452005535364151,
0.48286980390548706,
-0.5295907258987427,
-0.9972108006477356,
0.7030555605888367,
-0.2103370577096939,
-0.3182297945022583,
0.3325650691986084,
0.2767457365989685,
-0.00033748213900253177,
0.9774040579795837,
0.3569973409175873,
-0.21704205870628357,
0.40009036660194397,
0.18748463690280914,
0.08062022924423218,
-0.7458707094192505,
-0.4565659463405609,
-0.8439648151397705,
-0.49196457862854004,
-0.39880186319351196,
-0.3344070613384247,
0.45643851161003113,
0.08604789525270462,
-0.3032393455505371,
0.5910308957099915,
-0.39663663506507874,
0.4058869481086731,
0.5661885142326355,
0.05425795912742615,
0.45542415976524353,
0.32887864112854004,
-0.7220966815948486,
-0.4797656238079071,
-0.6762191653251648,
-0.4406759738922119,
0.8661474585533142,
-0.1605452299118042,
0.727643609046936,
0.16370151937007904,
0.9254946708679199,
0.24927197396755219,
0.1191914901137352,
-0.6453755497932434,
0.5986150503158569,
-0.0526973195374012,
-0.3945637345314026,
0.03892846405506134,
-0.8906974792480469,
-1.3394430875778198,
0.295987069606781,
-0.4503530263900757,
-0.7685695290565491,
-0.22192950546741486,
0.14548280835151672,
0.046611983329057693,
0.5967955589294434,
-0.538580060005188,
1.2287323474884033,
0.2858164608478546,
-0.10438261926174164,
-0.3336757719516754,
-0.6707296371459961,
-0.02572415955364704,
0.15077327191829681,
0.04536076635122299,
0.04980233684182167,
0.08589654415845871,
1.1029562950134277,
-0.5202351212501526,
0.3704303503036499,
-0.025926247239112854,
0.34575846791267395,
0.09595027565956116,
0.04726337641477585,
0.4816140830516815,
-0.3090094327926636,
-0.36067119240760803,
-0.09234254062175751,
0.26421090960502625,
-0.4549383819103241,
-0.9918476343154907,
0.7578047513961792,
-0.5033420324325562,
-0.3238069415092468,
-0.5588684678077698,
-0.17770686745643616,
-0.07440994679927826,
0.5154544711112976,
0.11976820975542068,
0.6380245685577393,
-0.4238065779209137,
0.31527331471443176,
0.40441298484802246,
0.1518351435661316,
-0.023693321272730827,
0.5377012491226196,
0.06520630419254303,
-0.76072758436203,
0.8682624697685242,
-0.0008233514381572604,
0.2440129816532135,
0.8002282381057739,
0.06313640624284744,
-0.5514763593673706,
-0.4012255370616913,
-0.21036165952682495,
0.24870148301124573,
-0.980513870716095,
-0.640692949295044,
-0.7710034251213074,
-0.07170671969652176,
-0.16026607155799866,
-0.27643388509750366,
-0.3489771783351898,
-0.6155595779418945,
0.18677474558353424,
-0.020935192704200745,
0.6244453191757202,
0.7902383208274841,
-0.05101797357201576,
-0.12479285895824432,
-0.645528256893158,
0.1809612661600113,
0.24266688525676727,
0.6289440989494324,
0.059697993099689484,
-0.30936872959136963,
-0.1170857772231102,
-0.2136271595954895,
-0.2822507321834564,
-1.1258201599121094,
-0.08007729053497314,
0.18813711404800415,
0.7393495440483093,
0.21842585504055023,
0.49059155583381653,
0.7740333080291748,
-0.4853411614894867,
0.502977192401886,
0.27464625239372253,
-0.7780925035476685,
0.45919743180274963,
-0.021103020757436752,
0.10319314152002335,
0.9877002239227295,
0.35085567831993103,
-0.41202056407928467,
-0.7774801254272461,
-0.6528178453445435,
-1.0780677795410156,
0.2897171676158905,
0.23457489907741547,
0.083042211830616,
-0.27777594327926636,
0.38776570558547974,
-0.19482962787151337,
0.1499529480934143,
-0.733256995677948,
-0.6081711649894714,
-0.2770984470844269,
-0.4585610330104828,
0.5081802010536194,
0.09447638690471649,
-0.24598802626132965,
-0.2334894984960556,
0.4035733640193939,
-0.19800731539726257,
0.5058915019035339,
0.2552950978279114,
0.09932972490787506,
0.029420427978038788,
0.2133857011795044,
0.012779816053807735,
0.22028537094593048,
-0.07856105268001556,
0.5746228098869324,
0.3441261053085327,
-0.41384342312812805,
0.15131376683712006,
0.33680471777915955,
-0.10584107786417007,
0.12801481783390045,
0.5139937400817871,
0.642520010471344,
0.7264548540115356,
-0.4649156332015991,
0.5705417990684509,
-0.07273712009191513,
0.027565812692046165,
0.12562821805477142,
-0.04905184358358383,
0.13513082265853882,
0.22601750493049622,
0.17945367097854614,
0.3377576470375061,
0.2675519585609436,
-0.4874565601348877,
0.6068800687789917,
0.6757974624633789,
-0.7184830904006958,
-0.13360750675201416,
0.6902992129325867,
0.053380098193883896,
-0.13042518496513367,
0.4014720916748047,
-0.7328299283981323,
-0.9206953644752502,
0.38926681876182556,
0.5116931796073914,
0.304763525724411,
0.23983022570610046,
0.023650260642170906,
0.7064912915229797,
-0.07079444080591202,
0.17713984847068787,
0.23548205196857452,
-0.18690773844718933,
-0.6777313351631165,
-0.1131361871957779,
-0.7680336236953735,
-0.4097795784473419,
-0.5166535377502441,
-0.802019476890564,
0.2897631824016571,
-0.16650648415088654,
-0.04899907112121582,
-0.1074230745434761,
0.42039787769317627,
-0.5174532532691956,
-0.06292445957660675,
-0.39083802700042725,
0.9740914106369019,
-0.6764633655548096,
0.687037467956543,
1.0219849348068237,
-0.3095747232437134,
-1.004289150238037,
-0.28619688749313354,
-0.007564019877463579,
-0.6079019904136658,
0.3401866555213928,
0.026929456740617752,
-0.11982753127813339,
-0.06129441410303116,
-0.05659831687808037,
-0.7932702898979187,
1.3069782257080078,
0.6211344003677368,
-0.3159051835536957,
0.1927560418844223,
-0.13244721293449402,
0.5173196196556091,
-0.17556649446487427,
0.2862241566181183,
0.37464961409568787,
0.5313149094581604,
0.3284587264060974,
-0.8680177927017212,
0.4988845884799957,
-0.39790448546409607,
-0.26009342074394226,
0.5435703992843628,
-0.6513532996177673,
0.2679107189178467,
-0.1429545134305954,
-0.44204938411712646,
0.24822159111499786,
0.9347037076950073,
0.46137943863868713,
0.38960251212120056,
0.3424796462059021,
0.8539300560951233,
0.8436165452003479,
-0.3229857385158539,
0.8720102310180664,
-0.32842427492141724,
0.4910634458065033,
0.9593597054481506,
-0.23856936395168304,
1.010853886604309,
0.3403782844543457,
-0.3313416838645935,
0.8654108643531799,
0.45302852988243103,
-0.00875062495470047,
0.6335921287536621,
0.24171082675457,
-0.2501135468482971,
-0.3056354522705078,
-0.08305748552083969,
-0.6128936409950256,
0.24986499547958374,
-0.03698552027344704,
0.01345639768987894,
-0.5977534055709839,
-0.3028664290904999,
0.31620973348617554,
0.5208765268325806,
0.029115187004208565,
0.8226683139801025,
0.059855472296476364,
-0.5696009993553162,
0.4846939444541931,
-0.12129037827253342,
0.5210205316543579,
-0.9026341438293457,
-0.08063871413469315,
-0.3037867546081543,
0.20433790981769562,
-0.11311447620391846,
-0.788634717464447,
0.5401490926742554,
-0.4033218026161194,
-0.19983640313148499,
0.052048057317733765,
0.7064087986946106,
-0.407061368227005,
-0.005107763689011335,
0.7769434452056885,
0.21747007966041565,
-0.010494367219507694,
0.0844338908791542,
-0.7543967366218567,
0.1126212477684021,
-0.3626919388771057,
0.011953192763030529,
0.37218084931373596,
0.6588490605354309,
0.07216891646385193,
0.6888533234596252,
0.25798481702804565,
0.16499891877174377,
0.04663126915693283,
0.036743324249982834,
1.0661307573318481,
-0.7135025858879089,
-0.4202089309692383,
-0.7643530964851379,
0.0544307641685009,
-0.2955806255340576,
-0.29279714822769165,
0.9397846460342407,
0.8005338907241821,
0.7406424880027771,
0.3020262122154236,
0.4913010001182556,
-0.3612123429775238,
0.3572450578212738,
-0.4671891927719116,
0.9360929727554321,
-0.8013913631439209,
-0.07704507559537888,
-0.6431499719619751,
-0.988251805305481,
-0.3530993163585663,
0.5386891961097717,
-0.08599301427602768,
-0.05994991958141327,
0.9103147983551025,
0.7072337865829468,
-0.3410499095916748,
-0.20028221607208252,
0.16951869428157806,
0.2703762650489807,
-0.013732660561800003,
0.7102447748184204,
0.6696439981460571,
-0.6728886365890503,
0.8968268632888794,
0.22533126175403595,
-0.21222998201847076,
0.013865439221262932,
-0.8722209334373474,
-0.7154415845870972,
-0.8815667629241943,
-0.3529149293899536,
-0.6670511960983276,
0.1498653143644333,
0.6410428285598755,
0.6458719372749329,
-0.6588684320449829,
0.19893567264080048,
0.1378479152917862,
0.6520177721977234,
-0.32763707637786865,
-0.22604961693286896,
0.5851238965988159,
-0.23440925776958466,
-0.22575105726718903,
0.3277136981487274,
0.2676660716533661,
0.0757550299167633,
0.16897878050804138,
-0.23032385110855103,
0.010503223165869713,
-0.00035479964572004974,
0.39324894547462463,
0.40344691276550293,
-0.5751449465751648,
-0.6999570727348328,
0.00040368616464547813,
-0.07505916804075241,
0.05028871074318886,
0.8331659436225891,
-1.1597833633422852,
0.619733989238739,
0.7312557697296143,
0.6927060484886169,
0.5247308015823364,
-0.016566874459385872,
0.6117970943450928,
-0.8165925145149231,
0.006219511851668358,
0.053524959832429886,
0.5966309905052185,
0.5208321213722229,
0.13547343015670776,
0.5536518096923828,
0.5369914770126343,
-0.33352914452552795,
-0.8832306861877441,
0.36586815118789673,
-1.1720939874649048,
0.07262276113033295,
0.8805503845214844,
-0.453789085149765,
-0.24792206287384033,
-0.32961520552635193,
0.008667861111462116,
0.334269642829895,
-0.27404630184173584,
0.633882462978363,
0.5808748602867126,
0.028225500136613846,
0.36530789732933044,
0.02133077196776867,
0.42480823397636414,
0.38928449153900146,
-0.6326472163200378,
-0.10774317383766174,
0.08789817243814468,
0.5062048435211182,
0.1932017207145691,
0.8773635625839233,
-0.5017316937446594,
0.15961024165153503,
0.21820151805877686,
-0.270572692155838,
0.02523566037416458,
-0.05712918937206268,
0.06778240948915482,
0.35281985998153687,
0.08840794861316681,
-0.06378190219402313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02124v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02124v3
|
Exploring Automated Distractor Generation for Math Multiple-choice Questions via Large Language Models
| 2024-04-02T17:31:58 | 2024-04-18T17:12:19 |
Wanyong Feng, Jaewook Lee, Hunter McNichols, Alexander Scarlatos, Digory Smith, Simon Woodhead, Nancy Otero Ornelas, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple-choice questions (MCQs) are ubiquitous in almost all levels of
education since they are easy to administer, grade, and are a reliable format
in assessments and practices. One of the most important aspects of MCQs is the
distractors, i.e., incorrect options that are designed to target common errors
or misconceptions among real students. To date, the task of crafting
high-quality distractors largely remains a labor and time-intensive process for
teachers and learning content designers, which has limited scalability. In this
work, we study the task of automated distractor generation in the domain of
math MCQs and explore a wide variety of large language model (LLM)-based
approaches, from in-context learning to fine-tuning. We conduct extensive
experiments using a real-world math MCQ dataset and find that although LLMs can
generate some mathematically valid distractors, they are less adept at
anticipating common errors or misconceptions among real students.
|
[
-0.7304804921150208,
-1.1586374044418335,
0.6363787055015564,
0.0006946028443053365,
-0.13658836483955383,
-0.023728586733341217,
-0.15504349768161774,
-0.3215092718601227,
-0.13748085498809814,
0.5874223113059998,
-0.5832479000091553,
-0.10520996898412704,
-0.4979095757007599,
0.20327028632164001,
-0.11026158928871155,
0.9044377207756042,
-0.3473965525627136,
-0.010408816859126091,
-0.4881328046321869,
0.05541626363992691,
-0.5833169221878052,
-0.6074997782707214,
-0.7346417903900146,
0.03295755013823509,
0.6357700824737549,
0.6443776488304138,
0.7571887373924255,
0.4852086901664734,
0.5256972312927246,
0.22943781316280365,
0.08365242928266525,
0.4109403192996979,
-0.32877999544143677,
0.2909196615219116,
-0.1080297902226448,
-0.2810842990875244,
0.01939956471323967,
-0.1541493982076645,
0.6613399982452393,
0.8222201466560364,
-0.01649704948067665,
0.3379446566104889,
0.0842774510383606,
0.3171024024486542,
-0.9953612089157104,
0.032023146748542786,
-0.7333465218544006,
0.033454712480306625,
-0.12683559954166412,
0.004965486936271191,
-0.39130863547325134,
-0.39507368206977844,
0.048763155937194824,
-0.47390756011009216,
0.11680158227682114,
-0.11870323121547699,
0.7123188972473145,
0.6276254057884216,
-0.6255932450294495,
-0.7619959712028503,
-0.8175742626190186,
1.146912932395935,
-0.3038555383682251,
0.2651178240776062,
0.5188512206077576,
0.49633029103279114,
-0.08875226229429245,
-0.2708132565021515,
-0.4047545790672302,
-0.271772563457489,
-0.0012890378711745143,
0.2657525837421417,
0.07280636578798294,
-0.2886006534099579,
0.6112544536590576,
-0.05715854465961456,
-0.20120738446712494,
0.051890838891267776,
-0.25720536708831787,
-0.12315055727958679,
0.6842355132102966,
0.48526591062545776,
0.2713148295879364,
-0.27064454555511475,
-0.07981860637664795,
0.04460519179701805,
-0.6203250288963318,
0.035194773226976395,
0.2761123478412628,
0.026845289394259453,
0.22903646528720856,
0.7647736668586731,
0.09526880085468292,
0.975583016872406,
0.16230933368206024,
-0.19900813698768616,
-0.253416508436203,
-0.34490230679512024,
0.11063511669635773,
-0.2672179341316223,
0.6080390810966492,
0.0014844690449535847,
0.5212008953094482,
0.23575341701507568,
-0.27971887588500977,
0.14157985150814056,
0.29073402285575867,
-0.7362939715385437,
-0.29133105278015137,
0.2354891300201416,
0.1686527580022812,
-0.33240923285484314,
-0.2619478106498718,
-0.6456031799316406,
-0.01685420796275139,
-0.5402386784553528,
0.4178807735443115,
-0.2752397656440735,
0.2397509217262268,
0.02917025424540043,
0.14005161821842194,
-0.09512398391962051,
0.45990538597106934,
-0.7431339621543884,
0.1818941831588745,
0.3289072513580322,
0.3868081867694855,
-0.39423418045043945,
-0.4072449207305908,
-0.9166023135185242,
-0.013917029835283756,
-0.4105618894100189,
0.8428680300712585,
-0.6659788489341736,
-0.4162091016769409,
-0.04468974843621254,
-0.4959612488746643,
-0.361356258392334,
-0.7600378394126892,
0.5260021090507507,
-0.6058071851730347,
0.4885740280151367,
-0.15063409507274628,
-0.5751997828483582,
-0.05408148467540741,
0.4716174304485321,
-0.7186588048934937,
1.1112229824066162,
0.18390405178070068,
-0.4997289180755615,
0.31033018231391907,
-0.7435283660888672,
-0.27685627341270447,
-0.0364491306245327,
-0.2915065586566925,
-0.5990538001060486,
0.12870611250400543,
0.45491400361061096,
0.40715450048446655,
-0.2672882378101349,
0.43396809697151184,
-0.1084895208477974,
-0.24236272275447845,
0.9262171387672424,
-0.6984654068946838,
0.6773110032081604,
0.23370161652565002,
-0.19780460000038147,
-0.021328778937458992,
-0.7371337413787842,
-0.08171425759792328,
0.16101936995983124,
-0.3858336806297302,
-0.3670794367790222,
0.11224833130836487,
-0.014618519693613052,
0.8765808343887329,
0.03259960934519768,
-0.34508711099624634,
-0.20646828413009644,
0.19524209201335907,
-0.0436728410422802,
0.7560116648674011,
0.2648273706436157,
0.15351593494415283,
-0.7478442788124084,
0.69118732213974,
0.20610947906970978,
0.04010510817170143,
-0.07981202751398087,
-0.3327390253543854,
-0.7771445512771606,
-0.5865164995193481,
0.19798435270786285,
0.49886322021484375,
-0.7033207416534424,
0.2055899202823639,
0.017414607107639313,
-0.32016798853874207,
-0.11150207370519638,
0.20134460926055908,
0.32725369930267334,
0.6253311634063721,
0.306566447019577,
0.20941507816314697,
-0.3093625605106354,
-0.6287506818771362,
-0.3880632519721985,
0.42827728390693665,
-0.1061706468462944,
0.6962841749191284,
0.6985084414482117,
-0.1454618126153946,
1.1970770359039307,
-0.914065420627594,
-0.13152532279491425,
-0.05208193510770798,
-0.10820236802101135,
-0.1679014265537262,
0.46922385692596436,
0.39751842617988586,
-0.9073159694671631,
-0.7137914299964905,
-0.49582162499427795,
-0.5658829212188721,
-0.33136898279190063,
-0.4161117374897003,
-0.3668680787086487,
0.15066592395305634,
0.4993445873260498,
-0.4256177544593811,
0.17783693969249725,
0.14046497642993927,
-0.10947083681821823,
1.029694676399231,
0.14271080493927002,
-0.14124704897403717,
-1.170015811920166,
0.02980445884168148,
-0.015941156074404716,
-0.01408082339912653,
-0.5820620656013489,
0.0937059223651886,
0.15778101980686188,
-0.14507417380809784,
-0.7173528075218201,
0.8945814967155457,
-0.3930717706680298,
0.2790445387363434,
-0.025198418647050858,
0.2514585852622986,
-0.11696890741586685,
0.3910823166370392,
-0.02215118706226349,
0.7552481293678284,
0.3820241093635559,
-0.888016939163208,
-0.0063359737396240234,
0.17373470962047577,
-0.18399527668952942,
0.6957963109016418,
-0.5435382723808289,
-0.12096517533063889,
-0.23895087838172913,
0.1800183355808258,
-1.1344540119171143,
-0.5832141637802124,
0.16255700588226318,
-0.29622524976730347,
-0.10020038485527039,
-0.027718205004930496,
-0.6136158108711243,
-0.48153090476989746,
-0.03454563394188881,
0.6709758639335632,
0.45456287264823914,
-0.6118366122245789,
0.5784915685653687,
0.38457754254341125,
-0.2978818714618683,
-0.7258003354072571,
-0.5269460082054138,
-0.311610609292984,
-0.29199811816215515,
-0.24376000463962555,
-0.05698901787400246,
-0.6316877007484436,
-0.5588957667350769,
-0.28262442350387573,
-0.17210598289966583,
-0.29724302887916565,
0.35526084899902344,
0.23654308915138245,
0.6461964845657349,
0.07095318287611008,
0.2406216412782669,
0.13641944527626038,
-0.02268674597144127,
0.2876931130886078,
-0.08850233256816864,
0.5633367896080017,
0.256161093711853,
-0.7493386268615723,
-0.01347836758941412,
0.3092380166053772,
0.5894048810005188,
-0.27244386076927185,
0.47403016686439514,
0.3419085144996643,
-0.5777957439422607,
-0.3683185577392578,
-0.799363911151886,
-0.17134587466716766,
-0.46446970105171204,
0.3599991202354431,
-0.4840543568134308,
-1.0140392780303955,
0.6598781943321228,
-0.04957760125398636,
0.39981943368911743,
0.3772478699684143,
0.6199114322662354,
0.08641490340232849,
1.4507502317428589,
0.039952993392944336,
0.3963453471660614,
0.691970944404602,
-0.07622027397155762,
-0.2237270176410675,
-0.7935429215431213,
0.02933879755437374,
-0.37497299909591675,
-0.19064247608184814,
-0.18183448910713196,
-0.5966708660125732,
0.34839627146720886,
0.028165003284811974,
-0.2687924802303314,
0.006360670551657677,
-0.26876264810562134,
0.8736037611961365,
0.5675166845321655,
-0.2622714936733246,
0.11474387347698212,
0.0727119967341423,
-0.4598301947116852,
-0.1997867226600647,
-0.5505415797233582,
-0.4235711693763733,
1.1839927434921265,
-0.019062098115682602,
0.6829633712768555,
0.1396438181400299,
0.8913832306861877,
-0.26705652475357056,
0.5236233472824097,
-0.8915271759033203,
0.5017406940460205,
0.06181992217898369,
-0.8512726426124573,
-0.42374762892723083,
-0.7208185195922852,
-1.0230368375778198,
0.48415496945381165,
-0.23478510975837708,
-0.4769597351551056,
-0.006663898471742868,
0.16729743778705597,
-0.5489530563354492,
0.14942267537117004,
-0.4843639135360718,
0.7393512725830078,
-0.31994518637657166,
-0.612013041973114,
0.2043088674545288,
-0.3154565393924713,
0.5175987482070923,
-0.6125143766403198,
0.3691398799419403,
-0.03496436029672623,
0.032150376588106155,
0.4981400966644287,
-0.212754026055336,
0.6807855367660522,
0.19049954414367676,
-0.3548838496208191,
0.6268893480300903,
0.4826969802379608,
0.38591423630714417,
0.2760246992111206,
-0.16887184977531433,
-0.20485413074493408,
-0.2559138238430023,
-0.44124704599380493,
-0.4663842022418976,
0.5330632925033569,
-0.690305769443512,
-0.39476290345191956,
-0.2871221601963043,
-1.0566259622573853,
-0.25684109330177307,
0.1630953848361969,
0.1870424747467041,
0.7276117205619812,
-0.09282074123620987,
-0.11415993422269821,
0.7567910552024841,
-0.11796066910028458,
0.6079885959625244,
0.4667840600013733,
-0.09756970405578613,
-0.5134401917457581,
1.0921052694320679,
0.4997766315937042,
0.5156722068786621,
0.24893179535865784,
0.2360355108976364,
-0.4485117793083191,
-0.12912234663963318,
-0.4726860821247101,
0.3062207102775574,
-0.7224652767181396,
-0.14622171223163605,
-0.740474283695221,
-0.3890359401702881,
-0.11951214075088501,
-0.5430595874786377,
-0.21101459860801697,
-0.4330359697341919,
-0.6405460834503174,
0.07498343288898468,
-0.17122474312782288,
0.5909769535064697,
0.07627634704113007,
0.14828746020793915,
-0.7488040328025818,
0.23843036592006683,
0.7716178297996521,
0.1325172781944275,
-0.07669775187969208,
-0.41957464814186096,
-0.2621843218803406,
0.11646188050508499,
-0.5678180456161499,
-0.4751400053501129,
0.3747290074825287,
-0.06487258523702621,
0.4766640365123749,
0.31703925132751465,
0.24380113184452057,
0.7167202234268188,
-0.5672641396522522,
0.696607232093811,
0.030712062492966652,
-0.859259307384491,
0.2681204676628113,
-0.3075314462184906,
0.610387921333313,
0.46310940384864807,
0.3609415590763092,
-0.4262233376502991,
-0.5422288775444031,
-0.6591225266456604,
-0.46132317185401917,
0.5970505475997925,
0.21342961490154266,
0.06117720901966095,
-0.30917292833328247,
0.17043082416057587,
0.15159273147583008,
0.16535772383213043,
-0.720514714717865,
-0.14949561655521393,
0.04638509079813957,
-0.45694661140441895,
-0.14721602201461792,
-0.29739290475845337,
-0.19994226098060608,
0.07415089011192322,
0.33148184418678284,
-0.2784872353076935,
-0.03432779014110565,
-0.11468632519245148,
-0.4856046736240387,
-0.3057030141353607,
0.47764143347740173,
0.9952457547187805,
0.8250777721405029,
-0.05038575828075409,
0.28768840432167053,
0.4556023180484772,
-0.5355943441390991,
0.1491978019475937,
0.24102236330509186,
-0.3823516368865967,
-0.08789144456386566,
-0.0019091109279543161,
0.5301162600517273,
0.29728496074676514,
-1.0544825792312622,
0.2651021182537079,
-0.03166652098298073,
-0.36392468214035034,
-0.5886005163192749,
0.23512454330921173,
-0.06324811279773712,
-0.06581642478704453,
0.38205164670944214,
0.20197534561157227,
-0.07066420465707779,
-0.22408097982406616,
0.2472314089536667,
0.6648572087287903,
-0.2533778250217438,
-0.12223363667726517,
0.6472105979919434,
0.043228961527347565,
-0.33417582511901855,
0.44623905420303345,
-0.15103480219841003,
-0.6199527978897095,
0.8039974570274353,
0.8320708870887756,
0.6314851641654968,
-0.22106944024562836,
0.202215313911438,
0.4772876799106598,
0.039929669350385666,
-0.07255896180868149,
0.22522318363189697,
-0.04947412759065628,
-0.7442592978477478,
-0.4172265827655792,
-0.3901199698448181,
-0.5503682494163513,
0.10188625007867813,
-0.4756644070148468,
0.28030067682266235,
-0.3714989721775055,
-0.21942393481731415,
-0.12011436372995377,
-0.029194384813308716,
-0.7064930200576782,
0.3178117871284485,
0.27190035581588745,
0.4613661468029022,
-0.5663175582885742,
0.33095136284828186,
0.9381755590438843,
-0.3105338513851166,
-0.8051828742027283,
0.16612689197063446,
-0.018326491117477417,
-0.4876476526260376,
0.7719195485115051,
0.14506883919239044,
-0.00742752943187952,
0.11508553475141525,
-0.627578854560852,
-1.2205482721328735,
0.8250719308853149,
0.13663645088672638,
-0.43819117546081543,
-0.10189951956272125,
0.5432021021842957,
0.3838893473148346,
-0.3138297200202942,
0.550000011920929,
0.20214131474494934,
0.14576296508312225,
0.31179195642471313,
-0.6317561268806458,
0.0228340532630682,
-0.0022878905292600393,
-0.07248827815055847,
0.462200403213501,
-0.5894796252250671,
1.159101128578186,
-0.32797759771347046,
-0.06079019978642464,
-0.2884555459022522,
0.31285831332206726,
0.7702007293701172,
0.19235122203826904,
0.5544947385787964,
0.40132927894592285,
0.7085421681404114,
0.09349759668111801,
0.833179235458374,
-0.24068301916122437,
0.3662128448486328,
1.2793071269989014,
-0.3276117146015167,
0.847771167755127,
0.49333620071411133,
0.1633109599351883,
0.25988829135894775,
0.6006510257720947,
-0.030449608340859413,
-0.032905254513025284,
0.555792510509491,
-0.25372451543807983,
-0.7150118947029114,
0.0791090801358223,
-0.05511639267206192,
0.4283904731273651,
0.5861518979072571,
-0.18213655054569244,
-0.1742127239704132,
0.1150541678071022,
0.1441313475370407,
-0.036977771669626236,
-0.28028950095176697,
0.5739424228668213,
-0.020860519260168076,
-1.085573673248291,
0.6122414469718933,
-0.25484997034072876,
0.6290841102600098,
-0.47137174010276794,
0.0148730194196105,
-0.25259438157081604,
0.3110892176628113,
0.18589313328266144,
-0.7730620503425598,
0.14806365966796875,
0.11779448390007019,
-0.06782955676317215,
-0.06195861101150513,
0.5772143006324768,
-0.5483946204185486,
-0.7839630842208862,
-0.18970313668251038,
0.7662956118583679,
-0.012581564486026764,
-0.09289833903312683,
-0.7981205582618713,
-0.22513975203037262,
-0.2289510816335678,
-0.16969268023967743,
0.3707423508167267,
0.3149983882904053,
-0.22992739081382751,
0.9110391139984131,
0.8357431292533875,
-0.23075947165489197,
0.26687169075012207,
0.019948484376072884,
0.5746995806694031,
-0.49360722303390503,
-0.32745039463043213,
-0.8952266573905945,
0.6101735830307007,
0.0519094243645668,
-0.5880725383758545,
0.9491962194442749,
0.6322517395019531,
0.9345563054084778,
-0.28176751732826233,
0.7435678243637085,
0.3297298550605774,
0.5977843999862671,
-0.2871078550815582,
0.4507153630256653,
-0.5673147439956665,
0.18294550478458405,
-0.5535473823547363,
-0.907335102558136,
-0.552942156791687,
0.45218366384506226,
-0.44145166873931885,
0.10183273255825043,
0.7191102504730225,
0.4339428246021271,
-0.12739898264408112,
-0.24195381999015808,
0.45774683356285095,
-0.24869279563426971,
0.42387089133262634,
0.6404736638069153,
1.2533485889434814,
-0.29928824305534363,
0.8953720927238464,
-0.32297295331954956,
0.01679176092147827,
-0.3572235107421875,
-0.4869177043437958,
-1.2710280418395996,
-0.4089832305908203,
-0.5004092454910278,
-0.20258435606956482,
-0.40935271978378296,
1.1279287338256836,
0.3455825448036194,
-0.8370823264122009,
-0.29649099707603455,
-0.04089463874697685,
0.3750714063644409,
-0.10230014473199844,
-0.2829238176345825,
0.3215067684650421,
-0.5036541819572449,
-0.978523850440979,
-0.1587599366903305,
-0.1267278492450714,
0.39662301540374756,
-0.040537115186452866,
0.17789718508720398,
-0.22380663454532623,
0.5245763659477234,
0.6655434966087341,
0.07940816879272461,
-0.581891655921936,
-0.34017521142959595,
0.4016471207141876,
-0.38451889157295227,
-0.09604525566101074,
0.7219761610031128,
-0.7276520133018494,
0.3150705099105835,
0.3136088252067566,
0.6132769584655762,
0.11896944791078568,
0.16178491711616516,
0.23235879838466644,
-0.6898617744445801,
-0.2936045229434967,
0.3752674162387848,
0.1982017308473587,
0.1256861388683319,
-0.30587056279182434,
0.3147805631160736,
0.21326519548892975,
-0.6752386093139648,
-1.0265980958938599,
0.41757482290267944,
-0.5299732685089111,
-0.3037828505039215,
1.3101518154144287,
0.2589782774448395,
-0.07355877012014389,
-0.22434890270233154,
-0.47416725754737854,
0.13656668365001678,
-0.15786439180374146,
0.9164392948150635,
0.9368114471435547,
-0.22471025586128235,
-0.07885807007551193,
-0.6294334530830383,
0.5240297913551331,
0.6777239441871643,
-0.9706165194511414,
0.017128895968198776,
0.865557074546814,
0.4586610198020935,
0.4615890085697174,
0.2549588978290558,
0.18072208762168884,
0.49537521600723267,
0.043146681040525436,
-0.13867540657520294,
-0.014134861528873444,
-0.3481122553348541,
-0.1512344628572464,
0.24455256760120392,
-0.16751570999622345,
-0.15105417370796204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02115v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02115v1
|
GINopic: Topic Modeling with Graph Isomorphism Network
| 2024-04-02T17:18:48 | 2024-04-02T17:18:48 |
Suman Adhya, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Topic modeling is a widely used approach for analyzing and exploring large
document collections. Recent research efforts have incorporated pre-trained
contextualized language models, such as BERT embeddings, into topic modeling.
However, they often neglect the intrinsic informational value conveyed by
mutual dependencies between words. In this study, we introduce GINopic, a topic
modeling framework based on graph isomorphism networks to capture the
correlation between words. By conducting intrinsic (quantitative as well as
qualitative) and extrinsic evaluations on diverse benchmark datasets, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of GINopic compared to existing topic models and
highlight its potential for advancing topic modeling.
|
[
-0.5521801710128784,
-1.0981125831604004,
0.2382051795721054,
-0.2153182029724121,
-0.3067527115345001,
-0.07124365866184235,
-0.12477117031812668,
-0.39026808738708496,
0.6777684092521667,
0.22908219695091248,
-0.26232802867889404,
-0.4991379678249359,
-0.7156528234481812,
-0.49514976143836975,
-0.5762476921081543,
0.8597912788391113,
0.018673721700906754,
0.09752007573843002,
-0.39850154519081116,
-0.0172420721501112,
-0.20348374545574188,
-0.5659933686256409,
-0.37029147148132324,
-0.3642377257347107,
0.4281276762485504,
0.2597366273403168,
0.604961097240448,
0.5885878801345825,
0.6614189147949219,
0.24967432022094727,
-0.3043702244758606,
-0.238441601395607,
-0.6182931661605835,
0.22403022646903992,
-0.26953840255737305,
-0.34915825724601746,
-0.1902512013912201,
0.32633042335510254,
0.5736396312713623,
1.0951565504074097,
-0.21908220648765564,
0.02188434824347496,
0.06574223190546036,
0.38450339436531067,
-0.4949902594089508,
0.42795100808143616,
-0.7408284544944763,
0.18650002777576447,
-0.2853538990020752,
-0.1846315860748291,
-0.061882492154836655,
-0.3580942153930664,
0.5296441316604614,
-0.5477822422981262,
0.42822036147117615,
0.10783231258392334,
1.1735347509384155,
-0.15680190920829773,
-0.1910620629787445,
-0.5193637013435364,
-0.37818217277526855,
0.1757356822490692,
-0.648123025894165,
0.1631874293088913,
0.4387753903865814,
0.07224518060684204,
0.07335644960403442,
-0.9740254282951355,
-0.4833388924598694,
-0.11658328026533127,
0.10179195553064346,
0.23374928534030914,
-0.3669623136520386,
0.03123290091753006,
-0.18080130219459534,
0.3480831980705261,
-0.41850125789642334,
0.1248675212264061,
-0.017314719036221504,
0.18451344966888428,
0.22818297147750854,
0.10978967696428299,
0.47084978222846985,
-0.38039156794548035,
-0.360950767993927,
-0.01951528526842594,
-0.5712783336639404,
0.00014335436571855098,
0.4137948155403137,
0.6213616728782654,
0.11877506971359253,
0.7482524514198303,
-0.1232045590877533,
0.8803398609161377,
-0.0890737920999527,
0.10691393911838531,
-0.07704073190689087,
-0.25790539383888245,
0.029067836701869965,
0.0065122065134346485,
0.5146398544311523,
0.29626479744911194,
0.08874359726905823,
-0.3358728885650635,
0.24396461248397827,
0.06061067059636116,
0.1958806961774826,
-0.9407217502593994,
-0.34149760007858276,
0.14616113901138306,
-0.5204030871391296,
-0.17588089406490326,
0.2884802222251892,
-0.6793984174728394,
-0.24731655418872833,
-0.24913926422595978,
0.16834019124507904,
-0.6184262037277222,
-0.24537263810634613,
-0.06470978260040283,
-0.38879504799842834,
-0.15112553536891937,
0.45122677087783813,
-0.7749287486076355,
0.15519891679286957,
1.0149133205413818,
1.1851751804351807,
-0.09676476567983627,
-0.3876701593399048,
-0.008823669515550137,
0.3011265993118286,
-0.45566052198410034,
0.8876025080680847,
-0.8012813329696655,
-0.492851197719574,
0.13530343770980835,
-0.3331218957901001,
0.057156480848789215,
-0.2105076164007187,
0.2847503423690796,
-0.6680724620819092,
0.28947144746780396,
-0.2993848919868469,
-1.0456299781799316,
-0.20432192087173462,
0.45859092473983765,
-0.7116504907608032,
0.7639487385749817,
0.05425794795155525,
-1.3856046199798584,
0.5382224917411804,
-0.5817611217498779,
-0.1740589439868927,
0.18378449976444244,
-0.1347295194864273,
-0.09505196660757065,
0.018444852903485298,
-0.08434980362653732,
0.4918679893016815,
-0.6291602253913879,
0.7880434989929199,
-0.7153493165969849,
-0.211784228682518,
0.11230778694152832,
-0.15934041142463684,
0.6113492846488953,
0.06507076323032379,
0.04860394448041916,
0.3449215590953827,
-0.3890376091003418,
-0.34778472781181335,
0.051338374614715576,
0.2929491102695465,
-0.8578475117683411,
0.2855691909790039,
-0.004004277754575014,
0.1644746959209442,
0.28627464175224304,
-0.29684117436408997,
0.3417132794857025,
-0.15814180672168732,
0.4929012954235077,
0.698640763759613,
0.245785653591156,
0.4392302334308624,
-0.27086320519447327,
0.3098335266113281,
-0.024921439588069916,
-0.14993804693222046,
0.07298053056001663,
-0.7541143298149109,
-0.5723391771316528,
-0.2677536904811859,
0.3532335162162781,
0.4321136474609375,
-0.6231995820999146,
0.6988109946250916,
-0.5032328963279724,
-0.82338947057724,
0.07816919684410095,
-0.3311300277709961,
0.016180003061890602,
0.7085880637168884,
-0.04054826870560646,
-0.7334026098251343,
-0.060474224388599396,
-0.7626128792762756,
0.27451902627944946,
-0.6086287498474121,
0.04493391513824463,
0.5506605505943298,
0.36957740783691406,
-0.08740345388650894,
1.3799315690994263,
-0.7642279267311096,
-0.3492339849472046,
-0.03377065807580948,
0.7672771215438843,
0.2939750552177429,
0.2070511132478714,
0.48778635263442993,
-0.6284257769584656,
-0.3849182426929474,
-0.11761533468961716,
-0.807596743106842,
-0.12862831354141235,
0.26546770334243774,
-0.29290205240249634,
-0.6207080483436584,
0.42263486981391907,
-0.44069933891296387,
0.21004335582256317,
0.39758971333503723,
-0.33340221643447876,
0.5874305963516235,
-0.07297880947589874,
-0.0852660983800888,
-1.3660269975662231,
0.3337475061416626,
0.1340285986661911,
-0.1179317906498909,
-0.42493337392807007,
0.14913052320480347,
-0.3826276659965515,
-0.8024587035179138,
-0.05522889271378517,
0.5136771202087402,
-0.47677549719810486,
-0.20062047243118286,
-0.36491659283638,
0.3514973819255829,
0.03328466787934303,
0.12258175015449524,
0.19010388851165771,
0.8708912134170532,
0.7906366586685181,
-0.37633606791496277,
0.38417792320251465,
0.44765228033065796,
-0.29159966111183167,
0.6008383631706238,
-0.7093561887741089,
-0.08147593587636948,
-0.2391841858625412,
0.25439074635505676,
-0.976775586605072,
-0.11985115706920624,
0.08188960701227188,
-0.24776668846607208,
0.36461320519447327,
-0.4008632302284241,
-0.47555604577064514,
-0.2268272042274475,
-0.4106582701206207,
-0.03262476250529289,
-0.051754530519247055,
-0.2316717654466629,
0.2746537923812866,
0.8429962396621704,
-0.6971572041511536,
-0.4363064467906952,
-0.2888420522212982,
0.19041220843791962,
-0.30969393253326416,
-0.6013450026512146,
0.5730730891227722,
0.18043363094329834,
-0.1785968393087387,
0.5096912384033203,
0.263140469789505,
-0.4031216502189636,
0.12150988727807999,
0.2927073836326599,
0.15108366310596466,
-0.09015748649835587,
0.45865416526794434,
-0.195187509059906,
-0.10893083363771439,
-0.1920473575592041,
-0.3229481875896454,
0.8918893337249756,
-0.23520611226558685,
-0.2785183787345886,
-0.03903007507324219,
0.5533856749534607,
0.34059059619903564,
-0.39546558260917664,
0.8065533638000488,
0.4602336585521698,
-0.5299550294876099,
0.12927411496639252,
-0.1610228717327118,
-0.26049330830574036,
-0.3570325970649719,
0.5514553785324097,
-0.3614344298839569,
-1.0479358434677124,
0.6296624541282654,
-0.33492177724838257,
-0.2372293472290039,
0.24878785014152527,
0.371104896068573,
-0.14814592897891998,
0.35856473445892334,
0.6840353608131409,
-0.39642834663391113,
1.0093852281570435,
-0.3914405405521393,
0.13830189406871796,
-0.8136318922042847,
0.05260004103183746,
-0.5342280268669128,
-0.027446318417787552,
-0.5133423805236816,
-0.5437496900558472,
0.25628170371055603,
0.6721851825714111,
-0.107742078602314,
0.3355603814125061,
-0.44327059388160706,
0.06741521507501602,
0.540497362613678,
0.0334291085600853,
0.09486038237810135,
0.1512635052204132,
-0.12886086106300354,
0.05483609437942505,
-0.7879364490509033,
-0.6196959018707275,
0.9811580777168274,
0.1938270926475525,
0.7915621399879456,
0.057965509593486786,
0.4227761924266815,
0.2965144217014313,
0.5975963473320007,
-0.78731369972229,
0.5408089756965637,
-0.505768358707428,
-0.7126026153564453,
-0.5323328375816345,
-0.35286420583724976,
-0.9885643124580383,
0.22092305123806,
-0.20649723708629608,
-1.1943153142929077,
0.5231307148933411,
-0.012861617840826511,
0.22133800387382507,
0.372613787651062,
-0.47032201290130615,
0.8617373704910278,
-0.054894980043172836,
-0.32545629143714905,
-0.2422947734594345,
-0.4983612596988678,
0.08158496022224426,
0.06691921502351761,
-0.22627608478069305,
-0.49005046486854553,
0.058918096125125885,
0.7743917107582092,
-0.3794897794723511,
0.7934157848358154,
-0.10829691588878632,
0.14068979024887085,
0.3618711829185486,
-0.030546914786100388,
0.2362501174211502,
0.19549345970153809,
-0.29398876428604126,
0.3494046628475189,
-0.2912429869174957,
-0.19634047150611877,
-0.6317132711410522,
0.5967490673065186,
-0.8833925127983093,
-0.6902071833610535,
-0.327079176902771,
-0.39000359177589417,
-0.2687157094478607,
0.3899132311344147,
0.28648921847343445,
0.48797357082366943,
-0.7300578355789185,
0.12821076810359955,
0.32586586475372314,
0.12463685125112534,
0.393013596534729,
0.18353430926799774,
-0.48855745792388916,
-0.3644949495792389,
0.9159042239189148,
0.31751352548599243,
-0.01478997990489006,
0.6435999274253845,
0.3353227972984314,
-0.21850040555000305,
-0.5045634508132935,
-0.0734875351190567,
0.14939261972904205,
-0.6653918027877808,
-0.06594683974981308,
-0.7718042731285095,
-0.2898108661174774,
-0.40420812368392944,
-0.29086601734161377,
-0.4486285150051117,
-0.3412429392337799,
-0.4389077425003052,
-0.13124452531337738,
0.416554719209671,
0.4067781865596771,
-0.2120620161294937,
0.4724031984806061,
-0.45351651310920715,
0.2624342143535614,
0.505547046661377,
0.29852643609046936,
0.05877666920423508,
-0.11063101887702942,
-0.07737671583890915,
-0.10495764017105103,
-0.1497061401605606,
-1.1740354299545288,
0.34807124733924866,
0.36321890354156494,
0.6985917091369629,
0.7305721044540405,
-0.018806537613272667,
0.5999159812927246,
-0.4906291961669922,
0.6330897212028503,
0.2401132732629776,
-1.1797726154327393,
0.7097676992416382,
-0.5452574491500854,
-0.23463743925094604,
0.7132272720336914,
0.6418094635009766,
-0.6964625716209412,
-0.11129885166883469,
-0.6538101434707642,
-1.1044130325317383,
0.4263296127319336,
0.21174278855323792,
0.019342901185154915,
-0.06533434987068176,
0.1859920620918274,
0.005270562134683132,
0.4074290096759796,
-0.5758110880851746,
-0.03511597961187363,
-0.4984103739261627,
0.10966112464666367,
-0.1868976503610611,
-0.41294097900390625,
-0.3390226364135742,
-0.1191602349281311,
0.5606403946876526,
-0.23987722396850586,
0.6983850598335266,
0.05636274814605713,
-0.13348111510276794,
0.23833487927913666,
0.04212597757577896,
0.10993587225675583,
0.7077536582946777,
-0.706977367401123,
0.27382901310920715,
-0.3645222783088684,
-0.2203923612833023,
0.17800556123256683,
0.6546511650085449,
-0.25839608907699585,
0.1298346221446991,
0.42563724517822266,
0.859539270401001,
-0.17080429196357727,
-0.2535349726676941,
0.5551261901855469,
0.01867692731320858,
0.3434593081474304,
-0.004866276867687702,
-0.2515488862991333,
0.3742617666721344,
-0.17503632605075836,
0.1883784383535385,
-0.27369388937950134,
0.3436066806316376,
-0.6908337473869324,
0.44697079062461853,
0.41847893595695496,
-0.8772479295730591,
-0.17928053438663483,
0.4623667001724243,
0.2633662521839142,
-0.10103718191385269,
0.7550044059753418,
-0.18098264932632446,
-0.6976178288459778,
0.6733378171920776,
0.6235829591751099,
0.8111892938613892,
-0.04087565466761589,
0.5397821068763733,
0.24693505465984344,
0.11001712083816528,
0.25331977009773254,
-0.09739670902490616,
-0.06964372843503952,
-1.0481457710266113,
0.013199551030993462,
-0.27887001633644104,
-0.7139089703559875,
-0.3218148350715637,
-0.8489506244659424,
0.0891161784529686,
-0.35200488567352295,
-0.4808224141597748,
0.2317247837781906,
-0.10790817439556122,
-0.23118463158607483,
0.18578022718429565,
-0.20607507228851318,
0.7855250835418701,
-1.0162959098815918,
0.8928656578063965,
0.8556349873542786,
-0.4706975519657135,
-0.4823035001754761,
0.3553398549556732,
-0.20511522889137268,
-0.5678371787071228,
0.6375887989997864,
0.18395544588565826,
0.010598503984510899,
-0.014814724214375019,
-0.33869871497154236,
-0.9262381792068481,
1.075330138206482,
0.2007812112569809,
-0.2441415786743164,
-0.051098067313432693,
0.04584547504782677,
0.6808595657348633,
-0.44086605310440063,
0.4070153534412384,
-0.15834204852581024,
0.05508996918797493,
0.17722724378108978,
-0.3849411904811859,
-0.17934834957122803,
-0.5154667496681213,
0.3072621524333954,
0.0843653753399849,
-0.6707594394683838,
1.0890227556228638,
0.3233519494533539,
-0.2570582926273346,
-0.18036101758480072,
0.7033727169036865,
0.2643963098526001,
0.15189123153686523,
0.46253731846809387,
0.6357870697975159,
0.9229423999786377,
-0.10436370223760605,
1.0209134817123413,
-0.7779472470283508,
0.6918061971664429,
1.2709523439407349,
-0.5841286778450012,
0.8508638143539429,
0.26250559091567993,
-0.11167284101247787,
0.38572070002555847,
0.9087569713592529,
0.13605262339115143,
0.5812479853630066,
0.3418694734573364,
-0.14515340328216553,
0.05660788714885712,
-0.5461840033531189,
-0.7038067579269409,
0.47718310356140137,
0.6634132862091064,
-0.17532721161842346,
-0.34873443841934204,
-0.11192350089550018,
0.0923059955239296,
-0.13529717922210693,
0.05207130312919617,
0.6322982907295227,
-0.05621422454714775,
-0.30349332094192505,
-0.11268136650323868,
0.07461825758218765,
0.5579357147216797,
-0.9101969003677368,
0.03057451732456684,
-0.3453460931777954,
-0.24999426305294037,
0.3382336497306824,
-0.8467586636543274,
0.30305665731430054,
-0.1670714020729065,
-0.3529243767261505,
-0.10100705176591873,
1.0084071159362793,
-0.29459381103515625,
-0.4567433297634125,
0.5253978371620178,
0.5069451332092285,
-0.13834993541240692,
-0.07810436189174652,
-0.7356747388839722,
-0.36208367347717285,
-0.3872983157634735,
-0.06449774652719498,
-0.016472909599542618,
0.5497388243675232,
-0.1736777126789093,
0.7658967971801758,
0.5503615736961365,
0.18433792889118195,
-0.19250577688217163,
0.054016292095184326,
0.9500337243080139,
-0.5738706588745117,
-0.8237790465354919,
-0.48451319336891174,
0.07811089605093002,
-0.329446017742157,
-0.46550965309143066,
0.7153300642967224,
0.6555830836296082,
0.4834859073162079,
0.04461177438497543,
0.67658531665802,
-0.19759872555732727,
0.3526003956794739,
-0.3866543769836426,
0.8605761528015137,
-0.4823366701602936,
0.09233345836400986,
-0.707587718963623,
-1.0754858255386353,
-0.17326860129833221,
0.7895589470863342,
-0.3501394987106323,
-0.15703201293945312,
0.5647143125534058,
0.6327232122421265,
-0.04089963436126709,
0.20879408717155457,
0.12775200605392456,
0.01591332256793976,
0.45738518238067627,
0.32392385601997375,
1.010755181312561,
0.07354243844747543,
-0.04841882735490799,
-0.3250022232532501,
-0.470803439617157,
-0.3380793035030365,
-0.9132466316223145,
-0.6965697407722473,
-0.8838256001472473,
-0.3528195321559906,
-0.18423402309417725,
0.23727527260780334,
0.5324497222900391,
1.0049623250961304,
-0.6482748985290527,
-0.35355472564697266,
-0.4462762475013733,
0.24199765920639038,
-0.011257486417889595,
-0.2760874927043915,
0.7243024110794067,
0.0232971403747797,
-0.4501109719276428,
-0.045633092522621155,
0.4012105464935303,
0.15812084078788757,
-0.39153170585632324,
0.4518635869026184,
-0.49851641058921814,
0.14903472363948822,
0.3903850018978119,
0.14644396305084229,
-0.4250223934650421,
-0.3125337064266205,
-0.2832379937171936,
-0.24986758828163147,
0.19960270822048187,
1.019754409790039,
-0.32137641310691833,
0.6781750917434692,
0.7359755635261536,
0.5319274663925171,
0.8259444832801819,
0.19638903439044952,
0.6074042320251465,
-0.5937460064888,
0.42494893074035645,
0.11429926007986069,
0.5511288642883301,
0.3708913326263428,
-0.15449866652488708,
0.6816892027854919,
0.5273558497428894,
-0.2049778699874878,
-0.44015681743621826,
0.2490631490945816,
-1.1127454042434692,
-0.5502871870994568,
0.9290382266044617,
-0.4730677902698517,
0.0836273580789566,
-0.0565551221370697,
-0.007204207591712475,
0.36147406697273254,
-0.1768723726272583,
0.8189622759819031,
0.9375510215759277,
-0.2091861516237259,
-0.04108496010303497,
0.0679582729935646,
-0.15039505064487457,
0.14467784762382507,
-1.160449743270874,
-0.1557764858007431,
0.4957837164402008,
0.06763193756341934,
0.45323479175567627,
0.7320238947868347,
0.05661441385746002,
-0.2718398869037628,
0.4581376016139984,
0.20414577424526215,
-0.010214434005320072,
-0.3930497467517853,
0.11202086508274078,
0.4716084599494934,
0.1149047389626503,
-0.14506717026233673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02103v1
|
CLAPNQ: Cohesive Long-form Answers from Passages in Natural Questions for RAG systems
| 2024-04-02T17:00:11 | 2024-04-02T17:00:11 |
Sara Rosenthal, Avirup Sil, Radu Florian, Salim Roukos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has become a popular application for
large language models. It is preferable that successful RAG systems provide
accurate answers that are supported by being grounded in a passage without any
hallucinations. While considerable work is required for building a full RAG
pipeline, being able to benchmark performance is also necessary. We present
ClapNQ, a benchmark Long-form Question Answering dataset for the full RAG
pipeline. ClapNQ includes long answers with grounded gold passages from Natural
Questions (NQ) and a corpus to perform either retrieval, generation, or the
full RAG pipeline. The ClapNQ answers are concise, 3x smaller than the full
passage, and cohesive, with multiple pieces of the passage that are not
contiguous. RAG models must adapt to these properties to be successful at
ClapNQ. We present baseline experiments and analysis for ClapNQ that highlight
areas where there is still significant room for improvement in grounded RAG.
CLAPNQ is publicly available at https://github.com/primeqa/clapnq
|
[
-0.4262060225009918,
-0.7986787557601929,
0.496340811252594,
0.3451782763004303,
-0.41114428639411926,
0.23418892920017242,
-0.009978222660720348,
-0.44505414366722107,
0.28655049204826355,
0.9171623587608337,
-0.29773977398872375,
-0.240895077586174,
-0.31369468569755554,
0.14263786375522614,
-0.5384173393249512,
1.116733193397522,
0.15328210592269897,
-0.4615943133831024,
-0.3848636746406555,
-0.4121379852294922,
-0.256572961807251,
-0.5518280267715454,
-0.6431745290756226,
-0.30629971623420715,
0.5104783773422241,
0.374722421169281,
0.7837638258934021,
0.48002320528030396,
0.38889265060424805,
0.1326524019241333,
-0.3113129734992981,
0.2314785122871399,
-0.4785577058792114,
0.6253844499588013,
-0.312787801027298,
-0.38559794425964355,
-0.7468612790107727,
-0.1473642885684967,
0.6648904085159302,
0.9011905789375305,
-0.061751589179039,
0.6254665851593018,
-0.022227508947253227,
0.9019944667816162,
-0.6111947298049927,
-0.09072963893413544,
-0.5007303357124329,
-0.07102910429239273,
-0.3970282971858978,
-0.18105381727218628,
-0.37145498394966125,
-0.4520402252674103,
-0.005224422551691532,
-0.3909083604812622,
0.5579051375389099,
0.30123788118362427,
0.7896039485931396,
0.3522379398345947,
-0.7719312310218811,
-0.22009891271591187,
-0.4693959355354309,
0.7499138116836548,
-0.6431859731674194,
0.33314284682273865,
0.4909433126449585,
0.5586894154548645,
-0.4990575909614563,
-0.8142088651657104,
-0.497011661529541,
-0.27387115359306335,
0.13363298773765564,
0.5800264477729797,
0.42127662897109985,
-0.04645108804106712,
0.19383582472801208,
0.7006710171699524,
-0.7872558236122131,
-0.21408042311668396,
-0.30392026901245117,
-0.04660322144627571,
0.7011644840240479,
0.10341250151395798,
0.038461893796920776,
-0.5797300338745117,
-0.5885621309280396,
-0.28862833976745605,
-0.6650939583778381,
0.2724197804927826,
0.1925291121006012,
0.3000377118587494,
-0.08849696069955826,
0.6913079023361206,
-0.17192843556404114,
0.8669434785842896,
0.103794626891613,
-0.06815831363201141,
-0.05469060689210892,
0.10637199133634567,
-0.032371047884225845,
-0.1424996256828308,
0.55909663438797,
0.30605822801589966,
-0.09963002800941467,
-0.3302927315235138,
-0.3941432237625122,
-0.06599511951208115,
0.2750222980976105,
-0.6572738885879517,
-0.12949621677398682,
0.49997472763061523,
-0.22285331785678864,
-0.09325964003801346,
0.0475374311208725,
-0.8140426278114319,
-0.6653841137886047,
-0.4526223838329315,
0.346101313829422,
-0.07681798934936523,
-0.4870848059654236,
-0.017491860315203667,
-0.5729196071624756,
0.538964033126831,
0.15963676571846008,
-0.44885119795799255,
0.7560221552848816,
1.3047268390655518,
0.6549434065818787,
-0.17168201506137848,
-0.003663037670776248,
-1.145330548286438,
-0.034013304859399796,
-0.5461214184761047,
0.7139915823936462,
-0.11758017539978027,
-0.03216763585805893,
-0.23740296065807343,
0.012998288497328758,
-0.08610954880714417,
-0.8501254916191101,
0.8553881049156189,
-0.9892624020576477,
0.21714504063129425,
-0.046841803938150406,
-0.6338244080543518,
-0.09649346768856049,
0.503795862197876,
-0.7010536789894104,
1.2534314393997192,
0.3629828989505768,
-0.8477418422698975,
0.01663728430867195,
-0.4517873525619507,
-0.21084706485271454,
0.021625913679599762,
0.05343024805188179,
-0.28880831599235535,
0.4051240086555481,
0.1118260845541954,
0.2415398508310318,
-0.570182740688324,
0.5500799417495728,
-0.3618054986000061,
-0.31420689821243286,
0.4025420844554901,
-0.3146996796131134,
0.8227715492248535,
0.2769356369972229,
-0.39908337593078613,
-0.03232891112565994,
-0.8706833720207214,
0.19734376668930054,
-0.09426933526992798,
-0.08069302141666412,
-0.25676238536834717,
-0.2019503116607666,
-0.09765537083148956,
0.11138615012168884,
0.014971895143389702,
-0.5051827430725098,
-0.10222398489713669,
-0.5331517457962036,
0.14049425721168518,
0.5614171028137207,
0.18661436438560486,
0.3695699870586395,
-0.6407164931297302,
0.7176218628883362,
-0.058924634009599686,
-0.020578579977154732,
-0.10726874321699142,
-0.5226274728775024,
-0.8138580918312073,
-0.25889450311660767,
0.5120465159416199,
0.43238723278045654,
-0.7867661118507385,
0.08883991092443466,
-0.34175607562065125,
-0.45537248253822327,
-0.43375611305236816,
0.03782900422811508,
0.3591148853302002,
0.8547319769859314,
0.33082693815231323,
-0.3011693060398102,
-0.6350223422050476,
-0.728077232837677,
-0.30471038818359375,
-0.20419251918792725,
-0.11661060899496078,
0.5579189658164978,
0.36010080575942993,
0.053708408027887344,
1.0835243463516235,
-0.28302615880966187,
0.25742319226264954,
0.20242291688919067,
0.42190122604370117,
0.8165954351425171,
0.1477002203464508,
0.2574157118797302,
-0.9571701884269714,
-0.688555121421814,
0.03167358413338661,
-0.7094991207122803,
-0.15561319887638092,
0.08924826234579086,
-0.37965524196624756,
0.15085925161838531,
0.3519544303417206,
-0.7029622197151184,
0.24562124907970428,
0.7819731831550598,
-0.4673765003681183,
0.7460360527038574,
0.055098794400691986,
0.10296040773391724,
-1.1012747287750244,
0.47185131907463074,
-0.5401981472969055,
-0.66295325756073,
-0.4859192669391632,
0.4033099412918091,
0.22922967374324799,
-0.34844616055488586,
-0.31503570079803467,
0.8948899507522583,
-0.40331733226776123,
-0.23412494361400604,
-0.3435390591621399,
0.3965214192867279,
0.2916649878025055,
0.25637683272361755,
-0.03945796936750412,
0.8402979969978333,
0.41500625014305115,
-0.7972666025161743,
0.3720995783805847,
0.1807800680398941,
0.02145330421626568,
0.44186994433403015,
-0.9437785148620605,
0.5638217329978943,
-0.3760402202606201,
0.4733532667160034,
-0.8580977320671082,
-0.5761890411376953,
-0.035872671753168106,
-0.49505048990249634,
0.17150460183620453,
-0.561564028263092,
-0.36779290437698364,
-0.42145973443984985,
-0.21506433188915253,
0.4840548634529114,
0.7139983773231506,
-0.6290649175643921,
0.39910197257995605,
0.444180965423584,
-0.2600957155227661,
-0.667191207408905,
-0.09578435868024826,
0.21105045080184937,
-0.36394476890563965,
-0.9200710654258728,
0.2101905643939972,
0.10279759019613266,
-0.2377835512161255,
-0.23605334758758545,
-0.2067345380783081,
-0.21215227246284485,
0.12277426570653915,
0.32885169982910156,
0.05640717223286629,
-0.4970998167991638,
0.176044762134552,
-0.248649001121521,
-0.1590292751789093,
0.009611375629901886,
-0.17941151559352875,
0.5465433597564697,
-0.2659411132335663,
-0.1523401290178299,
0.25177159905433655,
0.4912690222263336,
0.7888774275779724,
-0.39021214842796326,
0.5133616924285889,
0.4592083692550659,
-0.08641606569290161,
-0.3378341794013977,
-0.4390493631362915,
-0.03954293951392174,
-0.42867764830589294,
-0.1587890088558197,
-0.2992938756942749,
-0.9815104603767395,
0.6376686096191406,
-0.11601158231496811,
0.1778317093849182,
0.4344404637813568,
0.20709843933582306,
-0.35119378566741943,
0.7877944707870483,
0.27699005603790283,
0.37412694096565247,
-0.12443441152572632,
-0.0029433751478791237,
-0.12301509827375412,
-1.076450228691101,
0.2992604076862335,
-0.510671854019165,
-0.24369116127490997,
-0.42765557765960693,
-0.9735885262489319,
0.5353039503097534,
0.5222079753875732,
-0.4800742268562317,
0.10186021029949188,
-0.3169206380844116,
0.2233095020055771,
0.5800040364265442,
-0.05594228208065033,
0.26760709285736084,
-0.4041258990764618,
-0.007735578343272209,
0.0848950520157814,
-0.5963805317878723,
-0.570880651473999,
0.955482006072998,
0.38053596019744873,
0.5628905892372131,
0.3568660020828247,
0.8310940861701965,
0.018046485260128975,
0.5253233313560486,
-0.5239014625549316,
0.5430118441581726,
-0.15728580951690674,
-0.8925289511680603,
-0.28643500804901123,
-0.5050516128540039,
-1.1300489902496338,
0.20857641100883484,
0.016283312812447548,
-0.3056958019733429,
-0.08736177533864975,
0.16803976893424988,
-0.4050504267215729,
0.0023622873704880476,
-0.5298935174942017,
0.7031576037406921,
-0.2424563616514206,
-0.5005872845649719,
0.3184976875782013,
-0.7649368643760681,
0.6057601571083069,
-0.020681986585259438,
0.03586573153734207,
-0.14102423191070557,
-0.04079165682196617,
0.6950134038925171,
-0.3822726309299469,
0.5011270642280579,
-0.24113324284553528,
-0.056089747697114944,
0.7271953225135803,
-0.1069820448756218,
0.6171528697013855,
0.2155584841966629,
-0.3285387456417084,
-0.3343879282474518,
0.1679893434047699,
-0.5365074276924133,
-0.890491247177124,
0.4013601839542389,
-0.46890202164649963,
-0.6870405673980713,
-0.46239352226257324,
-0.29573020339012146,
-0.4902578890323639,
0.05621951073408127,
0.0070815011858940125,
0.659747302532196,
-0.06413310766220093,
0.578592836856842,
0.6874133348464966,
-0.20172135531902313,
0.31586673855781555,
0.21337170898914337,
-0.7212991714477539,
-0.6357647180557251,
0.5933704972267151,
0.03663838282227516,
0.20863795280456543,
0.15738153457641602,
0.4532870054244995,
-0.5742394924163818,
-0.3018096685409546,
-0.6081228852272034,
0.24462120234966278,
-0.37833788990974426,
-0.401908814907074,
-0.5927366018295288,
-0.3016664683818817,
-0.5256105661392212,
0.18072642385959625,
-0.4113277494907379,
-0.6230049133300781,
0.11240842938423157,
0.2355680614709854,
0.4685775637626648,
0.38771000504493713,
0.05415315181016922,
-0.11472311615943909,
-1.2096068859100342,
0.9761746525764465,
0.5149424076080322,
0.6471002101898193,
-0.07724004983901978,
-0.6179239749908447,
-0.09020175784826279,
0.24822257459163666,
-0.2795305550098419,
-0.7361587882041931,
0.18858718872070312,
0.3398309051990509,
0.39539435505867004,
0.03964995965361595,
0.7894965410232544,
1.009617567062378,
-0.6125452518463135,
0.8536610007286072,
0.025588924065232277,
-0.5661238431930542,
0.3795260787010193,
-0.8190931677818298,
0.42264410853385925,
0.5956167578697205,
0.26549458503723145,
-0.7294214367866516,
-0.48018449544906616,
-0.7551525235176086,
-0.8977276086807251,
0.12872745096683502,
0.1635119765996933,
0.03463287279009819,
-0.2372172623872757,
0.3271372318267822,
0.2688758373260498,
0.18630579113960266,
-0.30613723397254944,
0.026699313893914223,
-0.200333371758461,
-0.038587119430303574,
-0.10669136792421341,
-0.18859916925430298,
-0.37703201174736023,
-0.05546382814645767,
0.436041921377182,
-0.3141690790653229,
0.19511087238788605,
0.32008007168769836,
-0.14652884006500244,
-0.032019153237342834,
0.40711891651153564,
0.3105100691318512,
0.7234674096107483,
-0.37007880210876465,
0.26482856273651123,
-0.06028025224804878,
-0.5168332457542419,
0.07143401354551315,
-0.043314553797245026,
-0.1484873741865158,
0.09598571807146072,
0.09175313264131546,
0.6607548594474792,
0.11197024583816528,
-0.695918619632721,
0.4683739244937897,
-0.09141525626182556,
-0.19155067205429077,
-0.6286114454269409,
0.09048742800951004,
0.1667189598083496,
0.18084441125392914,
0.5509008169174194,
0.012440718710422516,
0.1325622946023941,
-0.6446326971054077,
0.39982011914253235,
0.28165584802627563,
-0.32725000381469727,
-0.2124669849872589,
0.5486555099487305,
0.16713154315948486,
-0.45815372467041016,
0.6945582628250122,
-0.20297308266162872,
-0.6311260461807251,
0.5397436022758484,
0.6592742204666138,
0.7986606955528259,
0.31650081276893616,
0.39822593331336975,
0.5219963788986206,
-0.14894679188728333,
-0.10865113884210587,
0.40325406193733215,
-0.14535075426101685,
-0.19163569808006287,
-0.7272038459777832,
-0.8164917230606079,
-0.7754703164100647,
0.06177833303809166,
-0.9328019618988037,
0.1799844354391098,
-0.43666207790374756,
-0.36497771739959717,
-0.40067628026008606,
-0.03662167862057686,
-0.5146225690841675,
0.31724318861961365,
0.1675848811864853,
0.9338568449020386,
-0.5641814470291138,
0.2640855312347412,
0.7588319778442383,
-0.025068731978535652,
-0.9125343561172485,
-0.014381838031113148,
-0.3264017403125763,
-0.11572365462779999,
0.5166903138160706,
0.2526443898677826,
-0.0006882728193886578,
-0.10436341166496277,
-0.6473064422607422,
-0.9901643991470337,
0.9677383899688721,
0.3924630582332611,
0.0011898827506229281,
0.23427410423755646,
0.24345465004444122,
0.7547156810760498,
0.03272855654358864,
0.1937524825334549,
0.32569292187690735,
0.2049866020679474,
0.27766168117523193,
-1.0351020097732544,
-0.18484021723270416,
-0.3558615744113922,
-0.3002849221229553,
0.37951889634132385,
-0.7680785655975342,
0.9289582371711731,
0.28965312242507935,
-0.3325519561767578,
0.29115644097328186,
0.7994512915611267,
0.8169597387313843,
0.6853857636451721,
0.4649852216243744,
0.7752987742424011,
1.0337674617767334,
-0.07799632847309113,
1.0022200345993042,
-0.08458228409290314,
0.20358088612556458,
1.5237878561019897,
-0.32366928458213806,
1.2595347166061401,
0.5597023367881775,
-0.1645086407661438,
0.5373490452766418,
0.358011931180954,
0.5001686811447144,
0.025840971618890762,
0.4473007917404175,
-0.37113380432128906,
-0.3090048134326935,
-0.12023833394050598,
-0.4659460186958313,
0.5397477746009827,
0.020329860970377922,
0.14234165847301483,
-0.3155357837677002,
-0.08832713961601257,
-0.28938159346580505,
0.2702389061450958,
-0.28723326325416565,
0.6470131874084473,
0.3385646641254425,
-1.2977293729782104,
0.8523895144462585,
-0.30764561891555786,
0.3812953233718872,
-0.30283692479133606,
-0.1956767737865448,
-0.5084957480430603,
0.12528511881828308,
-0.09038762748241425,
-0.8277947902679443,
0.39186081290245056,
0.19601953029632568,
-0.23302584886550903,
-0.3004109859466553,
0.7837129235267639,
-0.1717088222503662,
-0.3414952754974365,
-0.10118504613637924,
0.5886374711990356,
0.3142924904823303,
-0.16680650413036346,
-0.4369877576828003,
-0.30608201026916504,
-0.5135020017623901,
-0.11823876202106476,
0.356198251247406,
0.7195229530334473,
-0.15949171781539917,
0.5803860425949097,
0.7397804856300354,
0.019408201798796654,
0.5161008834838867,
-0.01946420781314373,
0.6117766499519348,
-0.7993805408477783,
-0.5823829174041748,
-0.21141204237937927,
0.9116082191467285,
-0.46735474467277527,
-0.41237732768058777,
0.9556244015693665,
0.6043288707733154,
0.27250343561172485,
-0.047249142080545425,
0.31898853182792664,
-0.14258520305156708,
1.3052635192871094,
-0.27451494336128235,
0.7111648321151733,
-0.5211678147315979,
-0.035035282373428345,
-0.16043324768543243,
-1.0617575645446777,
-0.24083974957466125,
0.22345954179763794,
0.008579598739743233,
-0.3697493076324463,
0.41660964488983154,
0.7626582384109497,
-0.17998962104320526,
0.11150015145540237,
0.3063126504421234,
-0.03182225674390793,
0.27728623151779175,
0.3281944990158081,
1.1957850456237793,
-0.849973201751709,
0.337040513753891,
-0.24454917013645172,
-0.07499342411756516,
-0.10681828111410141,
-1.0918831825256348,
-0.7107093930244446,
-0.5062814950942993,
-0.31070834398269653,
-0.5370360016822815,
0.01650109514594078,
0.7492988705635071,
0.5840956568717957,
-0.833200216293335,
-0.3405728042125702,
-0.10213672369718552,
0.07088437676429749,
-0.2118348628282547,
-0.2512612044811249,
0.46849775314331055,
-0.5045653581619263,
-0.44845712184906006,
0.42453014850616455,
0.13930252194404602,
-0.13591940701007843,
0.03843105956912041,
-0.13083165884017944,
-0.18373295664787292,
-0.010922897607088089,
0.6413823962211609,
0.6388179063796997,
-0.4181016981601715,
-0.4570818245410919,
0.5182382464408875,
-0.047192659229040146,
-0.009507134556770325,
0.682952344417572,
-0.963912308216095,
0.4560147225856781,
0.6208420395851135,
0.9915387034416199,
0.6152665019035339,
0.4513748586177826,
0.6621716022491455,
-0.9117276668548584,
0.08631721884012222,
0.8434414863586426,
-0.08772492408752441,
0.31674447655677795,
0.09067345410585403,
0.672664999961853,
-0.10794445127248764,
-0.8969236612319946,
-1.0068392753601074,
0.11300365626811981,
-1.1549121141433716,
0.19895188510417938,
1.310051441192627,
-0.19041357934474945,
-0.49007001519203186,
-0.5126028656959534,
-0.13101550936698914,
0.1972363442182541,
0.03261323273181915,
0.5677056908607483,
0.5558566451072693,
-0.05383376404643059,
-0.36263084411621094,
-0.750815212726593,
0.4057300090789795,
0.5544265508651733,
-0.518585205078125,
0.20527507364749908,
0.5981143116950989,
-0.07200616598129272,
0.2892802059650421,
0.6427722573280334,
-0.22611373662948608,
0.5049605965614319,
0.045755933970212936,
-0.4282434284687042,
0.2296900600194931,
-0.27157580852508545,
-0.1001524031162262,
0.520603358745575,
0.24166645109653473,
0.026771366596221924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02931v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02931v1
|
READ: Improving Relation Extraction from an ADversarial Perspective
| 2024-04-02T16:42:44 | 2024-04-02T16:42:44 |
Dawei Li, William Hogan, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent works in relation extraction (RE) have achieved promising benchmark
accuracy; however, our adversarial attack experiments show that these works
excessively rely on entities, making their generalization capability
questionable. To address this issue, we propose an adversarial training method
specifically designed for RE. Our approach introduces both sequence- and
token-level perturbations to the sample and uses a separate perturbation
vocabulary to improve the search for entity and context perturbations.
Furthermore, we introduce a probabilistic strategy for leaving clean tokens in
the context during adversarial training. This strategy enables a larger attack
budget for entities and coaxes the model to leverage relational patterns
embedded in the context. Extensive experiments show that compared to various
adversarial training methods, our method significantly improves both the
accuracy and robustness of the model. Additionally, experiments on different
data availability settings highlight the effectiveness of our method in
low-resource scenarios. We also perform in-depth analyses of our proposed
method and provide further hints. We will release our code at
https://github.com/David-Li0406/READ.
|
[
-0.4003540575504303,
-0.9886431097984314,
0.22973839938640594,
-0.18145696818828583,
-0.4079190194606781,
-0.14907149970531464,
-0.1567269265651703,
-0.2643861770629883,
0.14397922158241272,
0.6206845641136169,
-0.4526076018810272,
-0.39913612604141235,
-0.6623209118843079,
-0.03187984228134155,
-0.43076616525650024,
0.9991297125816345,
0.20680630207061768,
0.11787256598472595,
-0.0813746228814125,
-0.22272977232933044,
-0.28178802132606506,
-0.7615097165107727,
-0.8819341659545898,
-0.1994868814945221,
0.6597563028335571,
0.09442359209060669,
0.9106485843658447,
0.7865825295448303,
0.6097360849380493,
0.20588763058185577,
-0.298117458820343,
0.30436310172080994,
-0.6682677865028381,
0.3665188252925873,
-0.319821834564209,
-0.4938923120498657,
-0.23852713406085968,
0.1637100726366043,
0.333706796169281,
0.5855749845504761,
-0.3032914400100708,
0.15900418162345886,
-0.22645382583141327,
0.40111446380615234,
-0.9554115533828735,
0.20008622109889984,
-0.9951883554458618,
0.1150117740035057,
-0.30092868208885193,
-0.2612919509410858,
-0.6188950538635254,
0.15603318810462952,
0.12273039668798447,
-0.7200947999954224,
0.4170653223991394,
0.01889815367758274,
1.3462040424346924,
0.31819990277290344,
-0.2925187349319458,
0.12755487859249115,
-0.6316609382629395,
0.5621381998062134,
-0.4647052586078644,
0.41156667470932007,
0.22574546933174133,
0.11158942431211472,
-0.4691731333732605,
-0.8567624688148499,
-0.2691221535205841,
0.0019727458711713552,
-0.175840362906456,
-0.132671058177948,
-0.12093671411275864,
-0.09356410801410675,
0.4281361997127533,
0.23327785730361938,
-0.1165173351764679,
-0.1696597784757614,
0.07327117770910263,
-0.032843153923749924,
0.4158879220485687,
0.03963513672351837,
0.3087349832057953,
-0.1613149493932724,
-0.5501585006713867,
-0.2362777143716812,
-0.9629271030426025,
0.04257168248295784,
0.42910057306289673,
0.2899826169013977,
0.2696699798107147,
0.3605506122112274,
0.27456143498420715,
0.4481772184371948,
0.15082506835460663,
0.29377269744873047,
0.013379503041505814,
-0.30499503016471863,
-0.13067349791526794,
-0.20541857182979584,
0.9637539386749268,
-0.10557418316602707,
0.16099347174167633,
-0.681914746761322,
-0.29725390672683716,
-0.09570246934890747,
0.5489704012870789,
-0.8011676073074341,
-0.7617911100387573,
-0.10367303341627121,
-0.2716359794139862,
-0.4895549714565277,
0.21584388613700867,
-0.9275455474853516,
-0.5368599891662598,
-0.1511772722005844,
0.04705208167433739,
-0.7147420644760132,
-0.28515517711639404,
-0.32589495182037354,
-0.19291432201862335,
-0.11484462022781372,
0.11220087856054306,
-0.9582112431526184,
0.38432738184928894,
0.6850130558013916,
0.5087399482727051,
-0.01969534531235695,
-0.13879849016666412,
-0.9832823276519775,
0.1202632412314415,
-0.23222489655017853,
0.4880402386188507,
-0.5476123094558716,
-0.4112134873867035,
-0.10896798968315125,
-0.14480791985988617,
-0.01819177158176899,
-0.7283521294593811,
0.4219302237033844,
-1.1263642311096191,
-0.012051704339683056,
-0.24093514680862427,
-0.24366992712020874,
0.021850936114788055,
0.3235176205635071,
-0.9836181998252869,
0.5562496781349182,
0.1462661772966385,
-1.0557671785354614,
0.26913490891456604,
-0.37073469161987305,
-0.47475042939186096,
-0.3291296064853668,
-0.4072299897670746,
-0.7701555490493774,
0.031188903376460075,
0.7234116196632385,
0.2655579149723053,
-0.2263779491186142,
0.10866262018680573,
-0.6271753907203674,
-0.3562408685684204,
0.27648916840553284,
-0.375629186630249,
0.9778013229370117,
0.18237245082855225,
-0.30658307671546936,
0.04408872500061989,
-0.7571586966514587,
-0.25729987025260925,
0.4058610796928406,
-0.28771182894706726,
-0.7241793870925903,
0.02952919714152813,
-0.17975136637687683,
-0.06326378136873245,
0.010051828809082508,
-0.4415521025657654,
0.30934685468673706,
-0.8910010457038879,
0.21445421874523163,
0.6734236478805542,
0.5365175008773804,
0.6070205569267273,
0.08385234326124191,
0.5486034750938416,
0.3995841145515442,
0.020542776212096214,
-0.13467800617218018,
-0.03988064080476761,
-0.48109933733940125,
-0.37656861543655396,
0.6701028943061829,
0.5417418479919434,
-1.1449720859527588,
0.29699450731277466,
-0.3778896927833557,
-0.22742332518100739,
-0.3454345166683197,
0.329468697309494,
0.7128844857215881,
0.6351150870323181,
0.5718762874603271,
-0.386766642332077,
-0.7663766145706177,
-0.6389843821525574,
-0.5480632185935974,
-0.11165803670883179,
-0.03828204423189163,
0.18937891721725464,
0.4088778793811798,
-0.046083830296993256,
1.0089689493179321,
-0.6577613949775696,
-0.1611768752336502,
0.04711548984050751,
-0.04178045690059662,
0.09269159287214279,
0.42423972487449646,
0.5484333634376526,
-1.3120399713516235,
-0.05513700097799301,
-0.29319658875465393,
-1.0065515041351318,
0.4152286648750305,
-0.062389351427555084,
-0.24755653738975525,
-0.1140504702925682,
0.389787495136261,
-0.7638459205627441,
0.5107539296150208,
-0.019341545179486275,
-0.2615472674369812,
0.17928828299045563,
0.17982584238052368,
-0.18500426411628723,
-1.0771567821502686,
0.10478552430868149,
0.1118670105934143,
-0.23680227994918823,
-0.5527927279472351,
0.4014859199523926,
0.07954206317663193,
-0.30027517676353455,
-0.4425562620162964,
0.3065488934516907,
-0.5749237537384033,
0.13258518278598785,
0.06282708048820496,
0.11404723674058914,
0.04259217903017998,
0.3734074532985687,
-0.16846375167369843,
0.7494068741798401,
0.15666717290878296,
-0.5554869174957275,
0.4868135452270508,
0.5736055970191956,
0.19814737141132355,
0.3765825033187866,
-0.21946769952774048,
0.351602166891098,
-0.05906490609049797,
0.30701372027397156,
-0.6659177541732788,
0.05155074968934059,
0.6434034705162048,
-0.6534872055053711,
0.8961838483810425,
-0.27696526050567627,
-0.27813977003097534,
0.1531749665737152,
-0.3754870593547821,
0.24258971214294434,
0.10640906542539597,
-0.7285913825035095,
0.7577350735664368,
0.5407736897468567,
0.22373878955841064,
-1.187225341796875,
-0.4396767318248749,
0.2776090204715729,
-0.530695378780365,
-0.4286547899246216,
0.43118351697921753,
0.4520342946052551,
-0.2696589529514313,
0.3338586091995239,
-0.35828325152397156,
-0.17518985271453857,
0.4872971475124359,
0.2753657400608063,
0.3242628872394562,
-0.0769689753651619,
0.042468540370464325,
-0.5558399558067322,
-0.28795310854911804,
0.4367639422416687,
-0.22555269300937653,
0.4450145363807678,
0.14746695756912231,
0.06145969405770302,
-0.3716636896133423,
0.13884906470775604,
0.3304744362831116,
-0.3904426395893097,
0.9212237000465393,
0.7547279596328735,
-0.44614022970199585,
-0.08373655378818512,
-0.2652507424354553,
-0.34194648265838623,
-0.41285744309425354,
0.6372799277305603,
-0.6080896854400635,
-0.19408416748046875,
0.5541579723358154,
-0.21206417679786682,
0.14644841849803925,
0.30078125,
-0.013158388435840607,
0.21168597042560577,
0.6857039928436279,
0.5230980515480042,
-0.5704225301742554,
0.7649275660514832,
-0.5793087482452393,
0.21719110012054443,
-1.094746708869934,
-0.13188281655311584,
-0.3331809341907501,
-0.03817826136946678,
-0.3547796607017517,
0.04548295959830284,
0.08247599005699158,
0.31576013565063477,
-0.26413771510124207,
0.6480664610862732,
-0.28945791721343994,
0.12113775312900543,
0.34863805770874023,
0.4981954097747803,
0.1295313984155655,
0.2531149685382843,
0.08522766083478928,
-0.23117893934249878,
-0.6484020948410034,
-0.27691736817359924,
1.3378217220306396,
0.2455514520406723,
0.6424557566642761,
0.2752295136451721,
0.9176482558250427,
0.04894987493753433,
0.6656491756439209,
-0.5203250646591187,
0.3392471373081207,
-0.27633437514305115,
-0.5628324747085571,
-0.422105997800827,
-0.8796409368515015,
-1.129838228225708,
0.33711013197898865,
-0.22350479662418365,
-0.7296699285507202,
0.2294926941394806,
0.11295957863330841,
-0.33390307426452637,
0.47226810455322266,
-0.45950236916542053,
0.8651398420333862,
0.0567636638879776,
-0.43047845363616943,
0.14928685128688812,
-0.7298522591590881,
0.39039406180381775,
-0.06508778780698776,
0.16169025003910065,
0.3105527460575104,
-0.21075506508350372,
0.558526873588562,
-0.4316479563713074,
0.5422707796096802,
-0.4298887550830841,
0.03422827646136284,
0.21700869500637054,
0.0663568377494812,
0.940640389919281,
0.4030400514602661,
-0.2677614688873291,
-0.022674251347780228,
-0.35173603892326355,
-0.3818611204624176,
-1.0224924087524414,
0.5828630924224854,
-0.8626273274421692,
-0.7276210188865662,
-0.16607359051704407,
-0.33801156282424927,
-0.3485051691532135,
0.11287333816289902,
0.3564601540565491,
0.45276013016700745,
-0.2828638553619385,
0.3055860698223114,
0.8233538269996643,
-0.023310089483857155,
0.2704624831676483,
0.10969076305627823,
0.23028412461280823,
-0.7397934794425964,
0.8225333094596863,
-0.034890204668045044,
0.09947714954614639,
0.5718961954116821,
-0.05328324809670448,
-0.3186964690685272,
-0.4728141725063324,
-0.4562389850616455,
0.027811553329229355,
-0.7817156314849854,
-0.43454718589782715,
-0.5963762998580933,
-0.09449618309736252,
-0.5243414640426636,
0.45467236638069153,
-0.3368903696537018,
-0.2108822613954544,
-0.5614567995071411,
0.042700834572315216,
-0.03352266177535057,
0.2476607859134674,
0.33505985140800476,
0.1433694064617157,
-0.6981351375579834,
0.3942316770553589,
0.08393009006977081,
-0.08771031349897385,
-0.08283232152462006,
-0.5085554122924805,
-0.08828955143690109,
-0.056023821234703064,
-0.4534061849117279,
-0.9667940139770508,
0.2838182747364044,
0.18396256864070892,
0.3870467245578766,
0.4074757993221283,
0.34453651309013367,
0.8594689965248108,
-0.44034382700920105,
0.5752240419387817,
0.21865108609199524,
-0.6794117093086243,
0.5759520530700684,
-0.24982495605945587,
-0.18047739565372467,
0.6539492011070251,
0.32237717509269714,
-0.023606501519680023,
-0.16887305676937103,
-1.2286511659622192,
-1.138611078262329,
0.6551758646965027,
0.3617953062057495,
-0.08349128812551498,
0.07635090500116348,
0.9404603838920593,
-0.5600346922874451,
0.3389526605606079,
-0.5316676497459412,
-0.5646973252296448,
-0.08255492895841599,
-0.1543101817369461,
0.07506659626960754,
-0.1781764030456543,
-0.3564879894256592,
0.07754063606262207,
0.7994548678398132,
0.2802917957305908,
0.0017829869175329804,
0.3326190114021301,
-0.10257400572299957,
-0.13229408860206604,
-0.03443712741136551,
-0.054411910474300385,
0.6790644526481628,
-0.1092337965965271,
0.31186509132385254,
0.28906169533729553,
-0.48455584049224854,
0.2624605596065521,
0.4533618092536926,
-0.16920769214630127,
0.12920130789279938,
0.45126447081565857,
0.3025340437889099,
0.2229832410812378,
-0.3493509590625763,
0.6821606159210205,
-0.4118431508541107,
0.06696444004774094,
-0.5068734288215637,
0.03999665752053261,
-0.13053955137729645,
0.25147122144699097,
0.16043446958065033,
0.2344539910554886,
0.09866806119680405,
-0.5973716974258423,
0.6358527541160583,
0.5413947105407715,
-0.4422360062599182,
-0.19021715223789215,
0.9538737535476685,
0.04228873550891876,
-0.35267025232315063,
0.7915624380111694,
-0.36081168055534363,
-0.5063340663909912,
0.48914647102355957,
0.488429456949234,
0.7064954042434692,
-0.13688386976718903,
-0.3393888473510742,
0.12242120504379272,
0.15983475744724274,
-0.010268871672451496,
-0.2509216070175171,
0.08849528431892395,
-0.7718535661697388,
-0.25687459111213684,
-0.31283512711524963,
-0.25068819522857666,
0.4906803369522095,
-0.8699309825897217,
0.21896326541900635,
-0.666499674320221,
-0.31028875708580017,
0.17051710188388824,
0.22408489882946014,
-0.5042688846588135,
0.2992631196975708,
-0.13315439224243164,
0.6079261898994446,
-0.44415920972824097,
0.9005106091499329,
0.9278193116188049,
-0.6226352453231812,
-0.910157322883606,
0.1606931835412979,
0.04997769370675087,
-0.4219190776348114,
0.809354305267334,
-0.11979535222053528,
-0.00818625744432211,
-0.10940328240394592,
-0.3188304603099823,
-0.7011542320251465,
0.8561321496963501,
0.6502991914749146,
-0.4248477816581726,
-0.22181424498558044,
-0.4554804563522339,
0.3787314295768738,
-0.27454379200935364,
-0.04652278125286102,
0.6041490435600281,
0.03802269697189331,
0.009159937500953674,
-0.16584670543670654,
0.37838509678840637,
-0.3371984362602234,
0.17530491948127747,
0.47897103428840637,
-0.3649103343486786,
0.6795834302902222,
0.027252789586782455,
-0.5229521989822388,
0.13815492391586304,
0.9195152521133423,
0.05848828703165054,
0.14254207909107208,
0.8048760294914246,
0.6365395188331604,
0.6814849972724915,
-0.0018407815368846059,
1.0348182916641235,
-0.3142942786216736,
0.42894917726516724,
1.47340989112854,
-0.04182569682598114,
0.6645923256874084,
0.6123923063278198,
-0.09957918524742126,
0.3819570243358612,
0.6319032311439514,
-0.07554465532302856,
0.5664169788360596,
0.3120500147342682,
-0.25458794832229614,
-0.09798641502857208,
0.03910939395427704,
-0.17228831350803375,
0.27890512347221375,
0.30521678924560547,
-0.5723313093185425,
0.02112557366490364,
-0.24470487236976624,
0.34262198209762573,
0.31383106112480164,
0.14061003923416138,
0.7189278602600098,
0.176286980509758,
-0.5777216553688049,
0.4709664583206177,
-0.12114333361387253,
0.2898944616317749,
-0.43031787872314453,
-0.0705602616071701,
-0.007727392017841339,
0.5837966799736023,
-0.18853360414505005,
-0.07132057100534439,
0.2539043426513672,
-0.1161884292960167,
-0.15025682747364044,
0.15566693246364594,
0.6515593528747559,
-0.30381160974502563,
-0.026119591668248177,
0.39418354630470276,
0.26335591077804565,
-0.20725707709789276,
-0.2678292393684387,
-0.6870263814926147,
-0.2964659333229065,
0.07527986168861389,
-0.5787881016731262,
0.4438132345676422,
0.6608279347419739,
0.13906516134738922,
0.35281258821487427,
0.7727792859077454,
0.4748392403125763,
-0.4165460467338562,
0.03395143151283264,
1.12343430519104,
-0.5692673921585083,
-0.20195052027702332,
-1.1450788974761963,
0.1653091013431549,
-0.5742406249046326,
-0.3849185109138489,
0.7090884447097778,
0.4845183491706848,
0.8516598343849182,
0.20420682430267334,
0.40896886587142944,
0.15625400841236115,
0.2512722611427307,
-0.3842189610004425,
0.5135619044303894,
-0.2469833344221115,
0.7263147234916687,
-0.26282012462615967,
-0.7330585718154907,
-0.46866658329963684,
0.4503193199634552,
-0.31876224279403687,
-0.2376214861869812,
0.6994741559028625,
0.7162761092185974,
-0.09996740520000458,
-0.035993486642837524,
0.052290625870227814,
-0.015486535616219044,
0.7760114073753357,
0.45195913314819336,
0.7454221248626709,
-0.8393520712852478,
1.0098018646240234,
-0.32251644134521484,
-0.1585170030593872,
0.10707098990678787,
-0.5307355523109436,
-0.9677121639251709,
-0.21148478984832764,
-0.24068404734134674,
-0.735698938369751,
0.3810727298259735,
0.6686191558837891,
0.6144248843193054,
-0.60164475440979,
0.29503223299980164,
-0.10108305513858795,
0.12774978578090668,
-0.21069952845573425,
-0.26334822177886963,
0.5262781381607056,
-0.49411219358444214,
-0.4027951657772064,
0.4201452136039734,
-0.06798105686903,
-0.21605999767780304,
-0.1592118740081787,
0.11380092054605484,
-0.3532693386077881,
-0.33723852038383484,
0.09035033732652664,
0.17031915485858917,
-0.5457834005355835,
-0.34955164790153503,
-0.28612586855888367,
-0.04188236966729164,
0.13420206308364868,
0.8618357181549072,
-0.7438912987709045,
0.37605875730514526,
0.21057383716106415,
0.9762572050094604,
0.39324086904525757,
0.5213245749473572,
0.7857518792152405,
-1.0576127767562866,
0.2712714970111847,
0.2762516736984253,
0.4753870368003845,
0.3746664226055145,
-0.8210059404373169,
0.8848139643669128,
0.5092317461967468,
-0.3014092445373535,
-0.8396368622779846,
0.33558189868927,
-0.4137524962425232,
-0.35828739404678345,
0.956220805644989,
-0.7604529857635498,
-0.3466348350048065,
-0.12482830882072449,
0.026236189529299736,
0.6792802810668945,
-0.48371583223342896,
0.8408313989639282,
0.4477114677429199,
0.05012664943933487,
0.05016190558671951,
-0.28895917534828186,
0.5735726952552795,
0.3424477279186249,
-0.6085122227668762,
0.1438412070274353,
0.1322549432516098,
0.3148573040962219,
0.4327235221862793,
0.2463148981332779,
-0.31939518451690674,
0.1846928596496582,
0.22025130689144135,
-0.3232949376106262,
-0.33372384309768677,
-0.3170098066329956,
-0.48144474625587463,
0.44757550954818726,
-0.02378149703145027,
-0.35418999195098877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02088v1
|
LastResort at SemEval-2024 Task 3: Exploring Multimodal Emotion Cause Pair Extraction as Sequence Labelling Task
| 2024-04-02T16:32:49 | 2024-04-02T16:32:49 |
Suyash Vardhan Mathur, Akshett Rai Jindal, Hardik Mittal, Manish Shrivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Conversation is the most natural form of human communication, where each
utterance can range over a variety of possible emotions. While significant work
has been done towards the detection of emotions in text, relatively little work
has been done towards finding the cause of the said emotions, especially in
multimodal settings. SemEval 2024 introduces the task of Multimodal Emotion
Cause Analysis in Conversations, which aims to extract emotions reflected in
individual utterances in a conversation involving multiple modalities (textual,
audio, and visual modalities) along with the corresponding utterances that were
the cause for the emotion. In this paper, we propose models that tackle this
task as an utterance labeling and a sequence labeling problem and perform a
comparative study of these models, involving baselines using different
encoders, using BiLSTM for adding contextual information of the conversation,
and finally adding a CRF layer to try to model the inter-dependencies between
adjacent utterances more effectively. In the official leaderboard for the task,
our architecture was ranked 8th, achieving an F1-score of 0.1759 on the
leaderboard.
|
[
-0.5460287928581238,
-0.8582139611244202,
0.3451917767524719,
0.36941537261009216,
-0.17104502022266388,
-0.1449403613805771,
0.023895500227808952,
-0.7825222015380859,
0.024928933009505272,
0.2851698696613312,
-0.5681021213531494,
-0.3485928773880005,
-0.6001551151275635,
0.24523530900478363,
-0.22913052141666412,
0.8227123022079468,
0.0868796557188034,
0.2200937718153,
-0.4103344976902008,
-0.5052351355552673,
-0.6798377633094788,
-0.7791687250137329,
-0.596491277217865,
-0.15756745636463165,
0.600365400314331,
0.5976154208183289,
0.31867581605911255,
-0.013617197051644325,
0.5628881454467773,
0.4097348153591156,
-0.16790197789669037,
0.08355659991502762,
-0.4374731481075287,
0.4680100381374359,
-0.07859131693840027,
-0.16830343008041382,
-0.6284485459327698,
-0.1683780401945114,
0.20091374218463898,
0.24570462107658386,
0.005982690490782261,
0.0004768343351315707,
0.052726421505212784,
0.6829469799995422,
-0.3830086290836334,
0.16729550063610077,
-0.25515952706336975,
0.16612282395362854,
-0.2767315208911896,
-0.5489949584007263,
-0.3638717234134674,
0.051832057535648346,
0.3522001802921295,
-0.12140100449323654,
0.044013723731040955,
0.29724550247192383,
0.882320761680603,
0.16664648056030273,
-0.8179662227630615,
-0.5356876850128174,
-0.42558106780052185,
0.6206877827644348,
-0.7502105236053467,
0.6419693231582642,
0.08912128210067749,
-0.1313253790140152,
0.14209774136543274,
-0.45015037059783936,
-0.44993776082992554,
0.2634919285774231,
0.0856250524520874,
0.333587110042572,
-0.19383814930915833,
0.13312996923923492,
0.18010050058364868,
0.3157256543636322,
-0.8633366823196411,
-0.020555663853883743,
-0.3819907605648041,
-0.23960664868354797,
0.5417332649230957,
0.34108102321624756,
0.5635227560997009,
-0.3253527879714966,
-0.6181290149688721,
-0.1074175164103508,
-0.6108428835868835,
0.06079250946640968,
0.3489439785480499,
0.022083893418312073,
-0.2731068730354309,
0.42206889390945435,
-0.04707393795251846,
0.6090148687362671,
-0.14162728190422058,
-0.027191154658794403,
0.5474833250045776,
-0.6751485466957092,
-0.1907641738653183,
0.27883264422416687,
0.8502885699272156,
0.5308070778846741,
0.20188528299331665,
0.1642277091741562,
-0.0626545175909996,
0.05994776263833046,
0.13037247955799103,
-0.8983361721038818,
-0.07858295738697052,
0.32879838347435,
-0.5199231505393982,
-0.29582980275154114,
-0.249855175614357,
-1.1730002164840698,
-0.35353341698646545,
-0.3756619989871979,
0.6400724649429321,
-0.3818219304084778,
-0.284049391746521,
-0.13202063739299774,
-0.10405245423316956,
0.3460176885128021,
0.28866034746170044,
-0.7179073691368103,
-0.025527138262987137,
0.3056733012199402,
0.6437533497810364,
-0.11259448528289795,
-0.05530057102441788,
-0.3178028166294098,
-0.2194235622882843,
-0.013130278326570988,
0.9239262938499451,
-0.6532009243965149,
-0.6418392658233643,
-0.23071062564849854,
0.1251315474510193,
-0.04812666401267052,
-0.37214499711990356,
0.8535136580467224,
-0.3542245328426361,
0.4626462459564209,
-0.4032897651195526,
-0.3894486427307129,
-0.31705790758132935,
0.32488778233528137,
-0.5076435804367065,
0.9236884713172913,
-0.15157371759414673,
-0.7287993431091309,
-0.08524975925683975,
-0.6379151344299316,
-0.5164521932601929,
0.1366109848022461,
-0.21835128962993622,
-0.2869967520236969,
0.032777752727270126,
-0.0006172666326165199,
0.4337952136993408,
-0.5179586410522461,
0.3173695206642151,
-0.2148723006248474,
-0.07898691296577454,
0.30056649446487427,
-0.39520931243896484,
0.38742607831954956,
0.22075773775577545,
-0.5279943943023682,
0.27042868733406067,
-0.7309893369674683,
-0.1483333557844162,
0.011732598766684532,
-0.31438323855400085,
-0.4206658601760864,
0.1366126835346222,
0.05894369259476662,
0.6264872550964355,
-0.02559669315814972,
-0.5990479588508606,
-0.3672507703304291,
-0.3182394802570343,
0.32371875643730164,
0.8726864457130432,
0.4136678874492645,
0.3030388653278351,
-0.16587947309017181,
0.49315014481544495,
0.4911043047904968,
0.041790883988142014,
-0.5915608406066895,
-0.8146085143089294,
-0.7622895240783691,
-0.0944158062338829,
0.1069541946053505,
0.6391839385032654,
-0.5010911226272583,
-0.1342329978942871,
0.10012948513031006,
-0.3356987237930298,
-0.4155224561691284,
-0.09375704824924469,
0.6477314829826355,
0.8157497048377991,
0.2090310901403427,
-0.27636703848838806,
-0.7824416756629944,
-0.9284425973892212,
-0.21472686529159546,
-0.06556371599435806,
0.44016507267951965,
0.5333212614059448,
0.375402569770813,
-0.3118264377117157,
0.6346710920333862,
-0.22260139882564545,
-0.04986988753080368,
-0.018098285421729088,
0.4235357642173767,
-0.16794995963573456,
0.47373443841934204,
0.40839090943336487,
-0.9765881896018982,
-0.3138505518436432,
-0.08713770657777786,
-0.8666454553604126,
-0.33492323756217957,
-0.057352323085069656,
-0.2007409781217575,
0.510809063911438,
0.31400954723358154,
-0.33956021070480347,
0.48068541288375854,
0.6504530310630798,
-0.29923975467681885,
0.4236460030078888,
0.06568962335586548,
0.7061204314231873,
-1.0489617586135864,
-0.09345940500497818,
0.26124972105026245,
-0.0026730981189757586,
-0.7521131038665771,
-0.4271896481513977,
-0.03670129552483559,
-0.42127954959869385,
-0.5158279538154602,
0.3414042592048645,
-0.38372933864593506,
-0.053140152245759964,
0.1083708181977272,
0.2137117087841034,
0.3344380855560303,
0.7532561421394348,
0.07492581009864807,
0.5163066983222961,
0.4255245625972748,
-0.48181360960006714,
0.4600740075111389,
0.4989311695098877,
-0.2508067488670349,
0.6830707788467407,
-0.5746874213218689,
0.2553673982620239,
-0.168879434466362,
-0.06181060150265694,
-1.5316838026046753,
-0.2898732125759125,
0.38440775871276855,
-0.5473278164863586,
0.14010675251483917,
0.13924875855445862,
-0.22383423149585724,
-0.2327812910079956,
-0.04949124902486801,
0.5311616659164429,
0.32350414991378784,
-0.4106628894805908,
0.5720990300178528,
0.4297981858253479,
-0.6406476497650146,
-0.11835693567991257,
-0.6652255654335022,
0.12977413833141327,
-0.34576109051704407,
-1.0590035915374756,
0.340962678194046,
-0.36876627802848816,
-0.2422615885734558,
-0.2280583679676056,
-0.11326046288013458,
0.051242440938949585,
-0.004124921280890703,
0.6224064230918884,
0.14809055626392365,
-0.28491485118865967,
0.15448178350925446,
-0.11477412283420563,
-0.14206360280513763,
0.22419215738773346,
0.47252634167671204,
0.4329507350921631,
-0.42745286226272583,
-0.3874490261077881,
-0.45822611451148987,
0.7041829824447632,
0.7048466205596924,
-0.45396772027015686,
0.5205208659172058,
0.6499610543251038,
-0.3025802969932556,
0.10448945313692093,
-0.5792227983474731,
-0.07184219360351562,
-0.4427820146083832,
0.4225368797779083,
-0.32535669207572937,
-0.9225342273712158,
0.4725053608417511,
-0.21686230599880219,
-0.2792297601699829,
0.24548375606536865,
0.7934961318969727,
-0.267587810754776,
1.40583074092865,
0.27068161964416504,
0.020922046154737473,
0.5063261985778809,
0.14833670854568481,
0.41573235392570496,
-0.6292698383331299,
-0.6381880044937134,
-0.5523439645767212,
-0.3147464990615845,
-0.3919709324836731,
-0.22222785651683807,
0.552340567111969,
-0.16135001182556152,
0.12468010932207108,
0.20187227427959442,
-0.3313554525375366,
0.09729693830013275,
0.4304899573326111,
0.027555303648114204,
0.003998629283159971,
-0.12286248803138733,
0.04442029073834419,
-0.06439151614904404,
-0.5874228477478027,
-0.29040810465812683,
0.5686332583427429,
0.22924096882343292,
0.3928033411502838,
0.34155282378196716,
0.6466674208641052,
0.33798283338546753,
0.06240005046129227,
-0.6820252537727356,
0.6089527010917664,
0.3005058169364929,
-0.6711975932121277,
-0.07929038256406784,
-0.31818822026252747,
-0.8468013405799866,
0.36631184816360474,
-0.22876301407814026,
-0.8884053826332092,
0.3752208948135376,
0.1363983303308487,
-0.16193489730358124,
-0.23777848482131958,
-0.8364718556404114,
1.2745872735977173,
-0.46922731399536133,
-0.37544476985931396,
-0.11780214309692383,
-0.9334188103675842,
0.5761668086051941,
-0.028426602482795715,
0.5790578126907349,
-0.2060202807188034,
0.491323858499527,
0.810249924659729,
-0.3959941267967224,
0.8431479334831238,
-0.08442532271146774,
-0.07648299634456635,
0.45167970657348633,
-0.017538556829094887,
0.420425683259964,
-0.19963102042675018,
-0.14845888316631317,
-0.00021820244728587568,
0.17162062227725983,
-0.0650348886847496,
-0.3294605016708374,
0.6273438334465027,
-0.5188791155815125,
-0.3557710349559784,
-0.2852557599544525,
-0.2765977084636688,
-0.15588197112083435,
-0.1605377495288849,
0.3788754642009735,
1.087924838066101,
-0.19034017622470856,
0.20648840069770813,
0.8261843919754028,
-0.4882640540599823,
0.7808433175086975,
0.2944469451904297,
0.03547780588269234,
-0.4842350482940674,
1.0434317588806152,
-0.16763456165790558,
0.1064375713467598,
0.24455000460147858,
0.22813883423805237,
-0.31229260563850403,
-0.2193429172039032,
-0.34211266040802,
-0.1269001066684723,
-0.7771251797676086,
-0.43806421756744385,
-0.6985774040222168,
0.028680309653282166,
-0.5723075270652771,
-0.03429795801639557,
-0.17954027652740479,
-0.14608623087406158,
-0.3945903480052948,
0.016164585947990417,
0.18218109011650085,
0.5526282787322998,
-0.046942636370658875,
0.19048814475536346,
-1.2232117652893066,
0.20220068097114563,
0.22664016485214233,
-0.022144436836242676,
-0.11409056186676025,
-0.4241996705532074,
-0.18066053092479706,
-0.049486901611089706,
-0.570379912853241,
-1.3279825448989868,
0.6344285607337952,
0.3348041772842407,
0.44921600818634033,
0.4319523274898529,
0.08819323033094406,
0.9005040526390076,
-0.18588022887706757,
0.8375417590141296,
0.33947357535362244,
-1.0573008060455322,
0.6116952896118164,
-0.36479490995407104,
0.3540714383125305,
0.16453950107097626,
0.33402347564697266,
-0.8616704940795898,
-0.09854815155267715,
-0.6481969952583313,
-0.9023563265800476,
0.7912073135375977,
0.2505108416080475,
-0.06635134667158127,
-0.24225124716758728,
-0.008430383168160915,
-0.0912724956870079,
-0.006192133761942387,
-0.43892502784729004,
-0.07151784002780914,
-0.07754313200712204,
-0.524880588054657,
0.0359550341963768,
-0.7168663740158081,
0.10325944423675537,
0.2084997296333313,
0.6993290185928345,
0.1696513593196869,
0.568486750125885,
0.33337685465812683,
-0.37497299909591675,
-0.24511221051216125,
0.45211803913116455,
0.9163232445716858,
0.2569231688976288,
-0.15308824181556702,
0.25867682695388794,
0.1452333629131317,
0.11335266381502151,
-0.025296615436673164,
0.008754825219511986,
0.37176957726478577,
0.010263601318001747,
0.4934791922569275,
1.082610845565796,
0.6431334018707275,
-0.8580384850502014,
0.7739403247833252,
0.08187680691480637,
-0.016906706616282463,
-0.054465387016534805,
-0.25672295689582825,
0.20501257479190826,
0.5360719561576843,
0.17780011892318726,
0.18473097681999207,
0.6271934509277344,
-0.5923470854759216,
0.36138275265693665,
0.10926319658756256,
-0.560360312461853,
-0.610165536403656,
0.5283063054084778,
0.6213189959526062,
-0.4853847920894623,
0.336311012506485,
-0.15331842005252838,
-0.9347333312034607,
0.6499971151351929,
0.5052528381347656,
0.6170071959495544,
-0.4371970295906067,
0.03882160782814026,
0.36957624554634094,
-0.12975305318832397,
0.2196294218301773,
0.4435339868068695,
-0.22661520540714264,
-0.7874981760978699,
-0.33839231729507446,
-0.3854360282421112,
-0.4714524745941162,
-0.23777809739112854,
-0.6540887951850891,
0.18703530728816986,
-0.032402098178863525,
-0.2449166476726532,
-0.06943271309137344,
-0.42108824849128723,
-0.7041786909103394,
0.34535518288612366,
0.6098873019218445,
0.4363999664783478,
-0.8542488813400269,
0.34504297375679016,
0.7886589765548706,
-0.34370461106300354,
-0.6197136044502258,
-0.5236225724220276,
0.5701414346694946,
-0.536184549331665,
0.9253247380256653,
0.3669709265232086,
-0.19545161724090576,
0.0507938489317894,
-0.48539039492607117,
-0.6179272532463074,
0.9557365775108337,
-0.10567009449005127,
-0.5932409167289734,
0.10594435036182404,
0.09578707814216614,
0.4429457485675812,
-0.29769620299339294,
0.39267680048942566,
0.26092737913131714,
0.3920026123523712,
0.3301645517349243,
-0.6805182695388794,
-0.10479874163866043,
-0.5073226690292358,
-0.1845550239086151,
0.31061115860939026,
-0.7277639508247375,
0.5540562868118286,
0.02275930903851986,
-0.184927299618721,
-0.1267032027244568,
0.523417055606842,
0.25493595004081726,
0.6510911583900452,
0.3886110782623291,
0.48088815808296204,
0.531118631362915,
-0.14832961559295654,
0.7146057486534119,
-0.251297265291214,
0.2263147532939911,
1.2120411396026611,
-0.41200023889541626,
0.644649088382721,
0.43044689297676086,
0.09975360333919525,
0.3922317922115326,
0.8915359973907471,
0.38668492436408997,
0.47776609659194946,
0.04885823652148247,
-0.3813944458961487,
-0.30952882766723633,
-0.15431109070777893,
-0.43557968735694885,
0.6734998822212219,
0.5189414024353027,
-0.33781999349594116,
-0.15443454682826996,
0.3969368040561676,
-0.00756331579759717,
-0.4018111526966095,
-0.10989861190319061,
0.8398920297622681,
0.09912066906690598,
-0.5713655352592468,
0.1278124451637268,
-0.06511200964450836,
0.3810182213783264,
-0.2766800820827484,
-0.13001079857349396,
-0.41316673159599304,
0.07085175812244415,
-0.21517032384872437,
-0.4938318431377411,
0.1963874101638794,
-0.06099812686443329,
-0.01103683840483427,
-0.4690267741680145,
0.8728965520858765,
-0.6629575490951538,
-0.14943677186965942,
0.267474889755249,
0.44116759300231934,
0.3136683702468872,
-0.15928365290164948,
-0.6548048853874207,
0.5259739756584167,
0.058215558528900146,
-0.553656280040741,
0.2546665668487549,
0.7198595404624939,
-0.10364808142185211,
0.33047419786453247,
0.41893914341926575,
-0.596784770488739,
0.18649563193321228,
0.16047321259975433,
0.6871465444564819,
-0.7178553938865662,
-0.23020456731319427,
-0.949076771736145,
0.8786929845809937,
-0.05408203974366188,
-0.46246054768562317,
0.48463770747184753,
0.4801763594150543,
0.35137873888015747,
-0.10426563769578934,
0.56861412525177,
-0.2636686861515045,
0.16103608906269073,
-0.34781429171562195,
0.2759072184562683,
-0.7100859880447388,
0.06951519101858139,
-0.6927487850189209,
-0.8065893650054932,
-0.15761417150497437,
0.4801875054836273,
-0.08386651426553726,
-0.3003157079219818,
0.7287752628326416,
0.9615187644958496,
0.3374410569667816,
0.5888627767562866,
0.4712151885032654,
0.19879451394081116,
0.25812429189682007,
0.7823581695556641,
1.12997305393219,
-0.4545821249485016,
0.5630638599395752,
-0.1110273003578186,
-0.17230908572673798,
-0.4389016628265381,
-0.8858242034912109,
-0.7344410419464111,
-1.0157890319824219,
-0.5701301097869873,
-0.29204344749450684,
-0.01696835830807686,
0.8744775652885437,
0.555216908454895,
-0.7715798020362854,
0.1097763404250145,
0.06777011603116989,
0.07201376557350159,
0.26729559898376465,
-0.23680084943771362,
-0.03251488506793976,
-0.3323252201080322,
-0.5956736207008362,
0.5295766592025757,
0.5549455285072327,
0.08458433300256729,
0.24980472028255463,
-0.22874639928340912,
-0.3652855455875397,
0.10929515212774277,
0.7719776630401611,
0.20920278131961823,
-0.647884726524353,
-0.6605983972549438,
-0.12142836302518845,
-0.11577659845352173,
0.1745741367340088,
0.7178037762641907,
-0.4591050148010254,
0.5979980826377869,
0.8744508028030396,
0.5907005667686462,
0.6113199591636658,
0.09298214316368103,
0.5905107855796814,
-0.6487532258033752,
-0.04551282897591591,
0.04008825495839119,
0.514480471611023,
0.3271619975566864,
-0.28854936361312866,
0.5544877052307129,
0.5378273725509644,
-0.8348912000656128,
-0.7669370174407959,
0.21486864984035492,
-1.2994606494903564,
-0.003402640111744404,
1.0386168956756592,
-0.19469048082828522,
-0.16176848113536835,
0.06978201121091843,
-0.6400246024131775,
0.4499923288822174,
-0.3563400208950043,
0.39588671922683716,
0.9730806946754456,
-0.46070292592048645,
-0.48481056094169617,
-0.3423379957675934,
0.17309367656707764,
0.7380006313323975,
-0.8822365403175354,
-0.3322243094444275,
0.7445444464683533,
-0.013150441460311413,
0.04821976646780968,
0.5539367198944092,
-0.17731687426567078,
0.04580210521817207,
-0.12740252912044525,
0.28919798135757446,
0.052565500140190125,
-0.3800896108150482,
-0.22571466863155365,
0.2792820632457733,
-0.3114129304885864,
-0.19581788778305054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02078v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02078v1
|
Advancing LLM Reasoning Generalists with Preference Trees
| 2024-04-02T16:25:30 | 2024-04-02T16:25:30 |
Lifan Yuan, Ganqu Cui, Hanbin Wang, Ning Ding, Xingyao Wang, Jia Deng, Boji Shan, Huimin Chen, Ruobing Xie, Yankai Lin, Zhenghao Liu, Bowen Zhou, Hao Peng, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce Eurus, a suite of large language models (LLMs) optimized for
reasoning. Finetuned from Mistral-7B and CodeLlama-70B, Eurus models achieve
state-of-the-art results among open-source models on a diverse set of
benchmarks covering mathematics, code generation, and logical reasoning
problems. Notably, Eurus-70B beats GPT-3.5 Turbo in reasoning through a
comprehensive benchmarking across 12 tests covering five tasks, and achieves a
33.3% pass@1 accuracy on LeetCode and 32.6% on TheoremQA, two challenging
benchmarks, substantially outperforming existing open-source models by margins
more than 13.3%. The strong performance of Eurus can be primarily attributed to
UltraInteract, our newly-curated large-scale, high-quality alignment dataset
specifically designed for complex reasoning tasks. UltraInteract can be used in
both supervised fine-tuning and preference learning. For each instruction, it
includes a preference tree consisting of (1) reasoning chains with diverse
planning strategies in a unified format, (2) multi-turn interaction
trajectories with the environment and the critique, and (3) pairwise data to
facilitate preference learning. UltraInteract allows us to conduct an in-depth
exploration of preference learning for reasoning tasks. Our investigation
reveals that some well-established preference learning algorithms may be less
suitable for reasoning tasks compared to their effectiveness in general
conversations. Inspired by this, we derive a novel reward modeling objective
which, together with UltraInteract, leads to a strong reward model.
|
[
-0.24231283366680145,
-0.5418699383735657,
0.8171009421348572,
-0.30620816349983215,
-0.06999582797288895,
0.03523965924978256,
-0.3422578275203705,
-0.2771761119365692,
-0.09495147317647934,
0.4863708019256592,
-0.5360277891159058,
-0.5578164458274841,
-0.2949657440185547,
-0.09734170138835907,
-0.18201300501823425,
0.900858461856842,
-0.00928588304668665,
-0.14937487244606018,
-0.3323081135749817,
-0.2072586566209793,
-0.21523338556289673,
-0.8646968007087708,
-0.5554279685020447,
-0.5652331709861755,
0.3558575510978699,
0.6528177261352539,
0.8634673357009888,
0.511650025844574,
0.23240284621715546,
0.24142758548259735,
-0.4430403411388397,
0.43156132102012634,
-0.6146293878555298,
0.2983470857143402,
-0.30839622020721436,
-0.5607187151908875,
-0.3608553111553192,
-0.21403361856937408,
0.19202612340450287,
0.7128334045410156,
-0.45250800251960754,
0.12641538679599762,
-0.09972083568572998,
0.7927484512329102,
-0.49878713488578796,
0.10342603176832199,
-0.7812508940696716,
-0.007255970500409603,
-0.16013973951339722,
-0.4576141834259033,
-0.660478949546814,
-0.3266339898109436,
0.14947037398815155,
-0.7855637669563293,
-0.17063914239406586,
0.07398959249258041,
0.7905545830726624,
0.41418391466140747,
-0.22672218084335327,
-0.1780732423067093,
-0.6708731055259705,
0.948884904384613,
-0.5127267837524414,
0.26473498344421387,
0.09156075119972229,
0.2521471083164215,
-0.3619472086429596,
-0.6117147207260132,
-0.038993172347545624,
-0.2214551717042923,
0.16639970242977142,
0.09167911112308502,
-0.5843382477760315,
0.1867021769285202,
0.28082337975502014,
0.47539371252059937,
-0.4971886873245239,
0.1464913934469223,
-0.13960738480091095,
-0.0657132938504219,
0.5475475192070007,
0.44538402557373047,
-0.02616908587515354,
0.0750352069735527,
-0.09759331494569778,
-0.10111388564109802,
-1.0136083364486694,
0.5545440912246704,
0.3023403584957123,
0.10283350199460983,
0.22480958700180054,
0.5578169822692871,
-0.49978989362716675,
0.8544831871986389,
0.1144760325551033,
-0.040081143379211426,
-0.16741257905960083,
0.1896616369485855,
-0.4575028121471405,
-0.019860215485095978,
0.4950907230377197,
0.29897570610046387,
0.5359299778938293,
-0.096845343708992,
-0.04287071153521538,
0.4996149241924286,
-0.043729640543460846,
-0.659871518611908,
-0.5046286582946777,
0.2374090552330017,
-0.30286043882369995,
-0.3225989043712616,
-0.13027836382389069,
-0.2566169202327728,
-0.3176013231277466,
-0.7374539971351624,
-0.011920124292373657,
-0.21248935163021088,
-0.13928169012069702,
0.6746248602867126,
0.1344841569662094,
0.02799413353204727,
0.5136107802391052,
-1.065036654472351,
0.21902406215667725,
0.7670645117759705,
0.3124273419380188,
-0.33142098784446716,
-0.06127365306019783,
-0.4083343744277954,
0.27682575583457947,
-0.36078375577926636,
1.0259768962860107,
-0.9473602771759033,
-0.4009622037410736,
-0.260355681180954,
-0.0950891375541687,
0.28406357765197754,
-0.5731908082962036,
0.9073022603988647,
-0.3532772660255432,
0.24342268705368042,
-0.2435186356306076,
-0.694465696811676,
-0.4319286346435547,
0.2072787880897522,
-0.2822361886501312,
1.2679797410964966,
0.16731257736682892,
-0.7104629874229431,
0.30553463101387024,
-0.7886884212493896,
-0.18905243277549744,
0.08224480599164963,
-0.28394249081611633,
-0.022001801058650017,
0.22490714490413666,
0.2629798352718353,
0.7347342371940613,
-0.5519945621490479,
0.6333560347557068,
-0.4628587067127228,
-0.38133880496025085,
0.1003638505935669,
-0.4472896158695221,
0.8596647381782532,
0.4052414298057556,
-0.35913005471229553,
0.43977469205856323,
-0.29324379563331604,
0.05704265832901001,
0.25288599729537964,
-0.2933831512928009,
-0.4811052083969116,
0.2545264959335327,
-0.3145934045314789,
-0.07263866811990738,
0.10469266027212143,
-0.4818513095378876,
0.36370527744293213,
-0.2604021430015564,
0.440400630235672,
1.1529955863952637,
-0.34274551272392273,
0.32605376839637756,
-0.1777201145887375,
0.3907666504383087,
-0.05875883996486664,
0.3073590099811554,
0.053422894328832626,
-0.502839207649231,
-0.899409830570221,
-0.03937966004014015,
0.15805235505104065,
0.4512116014957428,
-0.22245921194553375,
0.38134437799453735,
-0.2991132140159607,
-0.38086506724357605,
-0.37818896770477295,
0.1479928344488144,
0.21103663742542267,
0.3257524371147156,
0.3846598267555237,
-0.018947871401906013,
-0.5048072934150696,
-0.839664876461029,
-0.1240210309624672,
-0.22590301930904388,
0.11065594106912613,
0.5295727849006653,
0.2540227770805359,
-0.22264255583286285,
0.895487904548645,
-0.6114773154258728,
0.1790844053030014,
-0.5079295039176941,
-0.2914845943450928,
0.3473312258720398,
0.1603095829486847,
0.22615280747413635,
-0.5964534282684326,
-0.4002724885940552,
0.28053855895996094,
-0.8046308159828186,
0.0015837001847103238,
0.06411021202802658,
-0.2625374495983124,
0.4332734942436218,
0.48566970229148865,
-0.38886070251464844,
0.18919946253299713,
0.5961448550224304,
-0.5484767556190491,
0.3490990400314331,
-0.06140455976128578,
-0.2404737025499344,
-1.1422637701034546,
-0.0248929001390934,
0.09178482741117477,
-0.3135685920715332,
-0.27117350697517395,
0.09705033153295517,
-0.18224959075450897,
0.27047768235206604,
-0.5340923070907593,
0.5614010095596313,
-0.3569948375225067,
-0.07710383087396622,
-0.011843714863061905,
-0.16227410733699799,
-0.12516477704048157,
0.4925152659416199,
0.1519695371389389,
0.6833584904670715,
0.6206862330436707,
-0.6210988163948059,
0.5923833847045898,
0.030946174636483192,
-0.18215058743953705,
0.47771018743515015,
-0.5972159504890442,
0.08669210225343704,
0.145936980843544,
0.30360400676727295,
-0.614261269569397,
-0.17239154875278473,
-0.05874205008149147,
-0.4006032645702362,
0.10946545004844666,
-0.18199174106121063,
-0.22291003167629242,
-0.40540724992752075,
-0.22950735688209534,
0.06522116810083389,
0.40008625388145447,
-0.9210083484649658,
0.5354540944099426,
0.4890088140964508,
-0.03094421699643135,
-0.7547088861465454,
-0.3573574125766754,
-0.16083142161369324,
-0.38153398036956787,
-0.5142399072647095,
0.14618486166000366,
-0.1939457505941391,
-0.4686126410961151,
0.05256843566894531,
-0.27034756541252136,
0.37574702501296997,
0.2866210639476776,
0.344635933637619,
0.4666670560836792,
-0.09924302995204926,
-0.01812625117599964,
0.11093617975711823,
-0.5149604678153992,
0.005265328101813793,
-0.4637298583984375,
0.3745949864387512,
-0.6689543724060059,
-0.5141276717185974,
-0.21153883635997772,
0.2203318476676941,
0.5322465300559998,
-0.15442125499248505,
0.17089490592479706,
0.14919322729110718,
-0.20239238440990448,
-0.25706714391708374,
-0.5373682975769043,
-0.09101182222366333,
-0.4586901366710663,
0.20914754271507263,
-0.6078148484230042,
-1.4119770526885986,
0.13675034046173096,
-0.3119204044342041,
0.41202619671821594,
0.5178720355033875,
0.7174606919288635,
0.0010747482301667333,
1.3304411172866821,
0.5663299560546875,
-0.3468392789363861,
0.19410228729248047,
-0.32042422890663147,
0.05701923742890358,
-0.7709694504737854,
-0.23173262178897858,
-0.41048648953437805,
-0.1196703165769577,
-0.43141186237335205,
-0.2981036603450775,
0.21762186288833618,
0.0703720673918724,
-0.46822991967201233,
0.05273896083235741,
-1.0404022932052612,
0.9190504550933838,
0.6200476288795471,
-0.2490347921848297,
0.5216603875160217,
0.3029831349849701,
-0.48053762316703796,
0.08531324565410614,
-0.7002788186073303,
-0.7127493619918823,
1.436713457107544,
0.17160353064537048,
1.0069507360458374,
-0.0361352376639843,
0.5782567262649536,
0.24937543272972107,
0.5371690392494202,
-0.8058463931083679,
0.6769431829452515,
-0.25063198804855347,
-0.5826064944267273,
-0.32785776257514954,
-0.46666935086250305,
-1.0259395837783813,
0.2695106565952301,
0.060852088034152985,
-0.8291479349136353,
-0.2034902423620224,
0.072453074157238,
-0.5625011324882507,
0.7302680015563965,
-0.6186872124671936,
0.7869008779525757,
-0.34714996814727783,
-0.3937307894229889,
-0.3272993862628937,
-0.5069185495376587,
0.36659368872642517,
0.568414568901062,
-0.095924511551857,
-0.34119707345962524,
0.23602014780044556,
0.6054633855819702,
0.11876866221427917,
0.5829731225967407,
-0.032711777836084366,
0.13337357342243195,
0.36617526412010193,
0.46359968185424805,
0.3228314518928528,
0.1306433230638504,
-0.07087132334709167,
-0.057525694370269775,
0.06352683901786804,
-0.30273810029029846,
-0.2898508310317993,
0.9328410625457764,
-0.8441364765167236,
-0.6847398281097412,
-0.6119787693023682,
-0.7232254147529602,
-0.3009081184864044,
-0.16658571362495422,
-0.04567611590027809,
0.41328731179237366,
-0.30561161041259766,
0.2559625506401062,
0.930419921875,
0.03415023535490036,
0.35874027013778687,
0.46883171796798706,
-0.3309614360332489,
-0.3064515292644501,
0.8371710777282715,
-0.3606829345226288,
0.2366439253091812,
0.43112626671791077,
0.2964235842227936,
-0.4189559817314148,
-0.4458368420600891,
-0.5573503971099854,
0.06573822349309921,
-0.8285002112388611,
-0.286881685256958,
-0.5368795394897461,
0.0038618186954408884,
0.0888230949640274,
-0.35002225637435913,
-0.3000646233558655,
-0.6755229830741882,
-0.19684815406799316,
-0.3151680529117584,
0.5606651306152344,
1.055527925491333,
-0.1136823445558548,
-0.0036148501094430685,
-0.391541063785553,
0.03908304125070572,
0.5462453365325928,
0.14360900223255157,
-0.29366880655288696,
-0.6024001240730286,
0.053541019558906555,
-0.1085423156619072,
-0.6292619705200195,
-0.5285018086433411,
0.1732487827539444,
-0.22866062819957733,
0.6826135516166687,
0.5921119451522827,
-0.17040273547172546,
0.4917411208152771,
-0.09807208180427551,
0.5682395696640015,
0.02503959648311138,
-0.8109707832336426,
0.5121918320655823,
-0.43650028109550476,
0.04989546909928322,
0.6131414175033569,
0.2886696457862854,
-0.5253733396530151,
-0.10452872514724731,
-0.9349246025085449,
-0.5394296646118164,
0.60578453540802,
-0.057112060487270355,
-0.08311820775270462,
0.17467471957206726,
0.40145444869995117,
0.04768085479736328,
-0.1104385256767273,
-0.7184018492698669,
-0.28002220392227173,
0.10595887154340744,
-0.2335309088230133,
-0.16190828382968903,
-0.247224360704422,
-0.2998894453048706,
-0.6788829565048218,
0.8206855654716492,
-0.48449593782424927,
0.01676071062684059,
0.02066190168261528,
0.11335129290819168,
-0.21207229793071747,
0.6055624485015869,
0.3977877199649811,
0.563988447189331,
-0.32103270292282104,
0.17410039901733398,
0.2223803550004959,
0.004830873105674982,
0.24830341339111328,
0.14687921106815338,
-0.19687312841415405,
-0.2153603434562683,
-0.23437896370887756,
0.6650674343109131,
0.02737109735608101,
-0.6221656799316406,
0.2774890065193176,
-0.1153094694018364,
-0.2852059006690979,
-0.10479641705751419,
0.06523194164037704,
0.5295442938804626,
0.09959772229194641,
0.0911826342344284,
0.10295315831899643,
0.23489436507225037,
-0.4306223392486572,
-0.14398916065692902,
0.6262837052345276,
-0.47163936495780945,
-0.272217333316803,
0.6109250783920288,
0.3191230297088623,
0.15745843946933746,
0.5104933977127075,
-0.21261624991893768,
-0.5235055088996887,
0.3959755301475525,
0.43623387813568115,
0.7951011061668396,
-0.31435340642929077,
0.24304112792015076,
0.21967259049415588,
0.23278437554836273,
-0.2662234902381897,
0.455335408449173,
-0.18724317848682404,
-0.706447422504425,
-0.47487467527389526,
-0.647083044052124,
-0.9204983711242676,
0.07236350327730179,
-0.4244987666606903,
0.03931398689746857,
-0.31150510907173157,
0.08109750598669052,
-0.13675570487976074,
0.0036012837663292885,
-0.41371455788612366,
0.13677765429019928,
0.3135293424129486,
0.8250933289527893,
-0.7907485365867615,
0.7921831607818604,
1.043455958366394,
-0.07220122963190079,
-1.0775210857391357,
-0.5231185555458069,
0.19043877720832825,
-0.7014213800430298,
0.2961854934692383,
0.2876725494861603,
-0.16330698132514954,
-0.04361264035105705,
-0.6733457446098328,
-0.7174962162971497,
1.1225374937057495,
0.6967064142227173,
-0.5335709452629089,
0.026631997898221016,
0.009525862522423267,
0.2896566092967987,
-0.5669542551040649,
0.5129689574241638,
0.8662627935409546,
0.3779759407043457,
0.18278509378433228,
-0.684625506401062,
-0.04383770003914833,
-0.25487709045410156,
-0.23110629618167877,
0.3864835500717163,
-0.622933030128479,
0.8204306960105896,
-0.38142094016075134,
0.020995361730456352,
-0.066386379301548,
0.5779619812965393,
0.5953668355941772,
0.02470342256128788,
0.5116413831710815,
1.0202666521072388,
0.943549633026123,
-0.3075900971889496,
1.0996097326278687,
-0.26295796036720276,
0.3421286344528198,
1.0563911199569702,
-0.22387787699699402,
0.8964930772781372,
0.5243680477142334,
-0.30286094546318054,
0.6972672343254089,
1.004024863243103,
0.3575631082057953,
0.1921924352645874,
0.3164539337158203,
-0.30551397800445557,
-0.9449208974838257,
-0.3506966829299927,
-0.4571816325187683,
0.20702867209911346,
0.5117103457450867,
-0.09846554696559906,
-0.166587695479393,
-0.5751147270202637,
0.20543542504310608,
0.05323902890086174,
-0.2980181872844696,
0.6230323910713196,
0.11770898103713989,
-0.9164753556251526,
0.6121301651000977,
-0.058946359902620316,
0.683144211769104,
-0.5136693716049194,
0.03451623395085335,
-0.34383127093315125,
0.5420867204666138,
-0.32761073112487793,
-1.0143400430679321,
0.05321446433663368,
0.08622520416975021,
0.10928831249475479,
-0.3030259907245636,
0.5954899191856384,
-0.10927319526672363,
-0.47310876846313477,
0.420907199382782,
0.5704113841056824,
0.17756560444831848,
-0.1807972639799118,
-0.8276749849319458,
-0.11698956787586212,
0.3658793568611145,
-0.44186490774154663,
0.2788492441177368,
0.5186874270439148,
-0.19022142887115479,
0.8026466965675354,
0.9412108659744263,
-0.06218797713518143,
-0.22707758843898773,
0.18546612560749054,
1.136704444885254,
-0.6459599137306213,
-0.40064966678619385,
-0.8858203291893005,
0.41374850273132324,
-0.08539862185716629,
-0.4500349164009094,
0.5690904855728149,
0.8587304949760437,
0.9785401225090027,
0.31053784489631653,
0.7959793210029602,
0.1552869975566864,
0.5099113583564758,
-0.49069055914878845,
0.09608608484268188,
-0.5950126051902771,
0.2400018274784088,
-0.023032402619719505,
-0.9848126769065857,
-0.36221325397491455,
0.491033136844635,
-0.25186726450920105,
-0.21755817532539368,
0.7506290674209595,
0.7809855937957764,
-0.31743550300598145,
0.31382909417152405,
0.370204895734787,
-0.0880681648850441,
0.3252195715904236,
1.2417759895324707,
1.1424709558486938,
0.19649694859981537,
0.6593998670578003,
-0.2422533482313156,
-0.32547727227211,
-0.08090230077505112,
-0.7220509052276611,
-0.9986807703971863,
-0.2529669404029846,
0.0027352427132427692,
-0.17801018059253693,
0.1322014182806015,
1.145552396774292,
0.721680760383606,
-0.8696825504302979,
-0.5530165433883667,
-0.2953513562679291,
0.06469758599996567,
0.021678142249584198,
-0.18239529430866241,
0.29955166578292847,
-0.19710314273834229,
-0.4554523527622223,
0.5232997536659241,
0.5359758734703064,
-0.07027147710323334,
-0.28454723954200745,
-0.4691014289855957,
0.05070281773805618,
0.10482662171125412,
0.5521517395973206,
0.4277375638484955,
-1.1522912979125977,
-0.11534707248210907,
0.206246480345726,
-0.05022159218788147,
0.1745045781135559,
0.7943510413169861,
-0.8345333337783813,
0.4532325267791748,
0.211479052901268,
0.6437742114067078,
0.49764299392700195,
-0.022740956395864487,
0.4200853705406189,
-0.06570852547883987,
0.03679250553250313,
0.23275835812091827,
0.7055166363716125,
0.4951929450035095,
-0.13536512851715088,
0.9117283225059509,
0.16059666872024536,
-0.7491384744644165,
-0.7463106513023376,
0.2877173125743866,
-1.0559114217758179,
-0.28450557589530945,
1.3716038465499878,
0.023641349747776985,
-0.048001423478126526,
-0.03607859089970589,
-0.43756037950515747,
-0.03719199076294899,
-0.6717373132705688,
0.5224764943122864,
0.6694980263710022,
-0.46933749318122864,
0.19191209971904755,
-0.4322170317173004,
0.5742474794387817,
0.9248808026313782,
-1.0567601919174194,
0.24432578682899475,
0.6166973114013672,
0.2532607614994049,
-0.024764053523540497,
0.5481927394866943,
-0.15038932859897614,
0.359623521566391,
-0.48075562715530396,
0.15340107679367065,
-0.148042693734169,
-0.4623773694038391,
-0.37269511818885803,
0.05816607549786568,
0.4227423667907715,
0.1932845562696457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02068v1
|
Using Interpretation Methods for Model Enhancement
| 2024-04-02T16:10:29 | 2024-04-02T16:10:29 |
Zhuo Chen, Chengyue Jiang, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the age of neural natural language processing, there are plenty of works
trying to derive interpretations of neural models. Intuitively, when gold
rationales exist during training, one can additionally train the model to match
its interpretation with the rationales. However, this intuitive idea has not
been fully explored. In this paper, we propose a framework of utilizing
interpretation methods and gold rationales to enhance models. Our framework is
very general in the sense that it can incorporate various interpretation
methods. Previously proposed gradient-based methods can be shown as an instance
of our framework. We also propose two novel instances utilizing two other types
of interpretation methods, erasure/replace-based and extractor-based methods,
for model enhancement. We conduct comprehensive experiments on a variety of
tasks. Experimental results show that our framework is effective especially in
low-resource settings in enhancing models with various interpretation methods,
and our two newly-proposed methods outperform gradient-based methods in most
settings. Code is available at https://github.com/Chord-Chen-30/UIMER.
|
[
-0.08475644886493683,
-0.6488975882530212,
0.40146827697753906,
0.26452451944351196,
-0.27135249972343445,
-0.21701054275035858,
-0.2095358818769455,
-0.5162443518638611,
0.05503693222999573,
0.6808926463127136,
-0.4738321602344513,
-0.2570241093635559,
-0.2864868640899658,
0.18761120736598969,
-0.3079151213169098,
1.0301722288131714,
0.037014421075582504,
0.34855079650878906,
0.04103928059339523,
-0.181929811835289,
-0.5710396766662598,
-0.5218493342399597,
-0.5056712031364441,
-0.6696184873580933,
0.2541680634021759,
0.08763798326253891,
0.7809830904006958,
0.9962441325187683,
0.6222472190856934,
0.2719842791557312,
-0.45134714245796204,
0.20134124159812927,
-0.25551265478134155,
-0.08083119243383408,
-0.2542415261268616,
-0.6523246169090271,
-0.43660327792167664,
0.007799190003424883,
0.5069426894187927,
0.8539889454841614,
-0.16382315754890442,
-0.0945984274148941,
0.2921275794506073,
0.4198867976665497,
-0.7907410860061646,
0.16496463119983673,
-0.6143872141838074,
0.07832961529493332,
0.08960771560668945,
-0.6345296502113342,
-0.3812325596809387,
-0.02902715839445591,
0.41488879919052124,
-0.6685755848884583,
0.18513882160186768,
-0.18692398071289062,
0.7393590807914734,
0.1486094743013382,
-0.42920586466789246,
-0.16937892138957977,
-0.7696941494941711,
0.8960533142089844,
-1.1360985040664673,
0.15410767495632172,
0.46318867802619934,
0.4343758225440979,
0.059805918484926224,
-0.8921336531639099,
-0.5451508164405823,
-0.519114077091217,
-0.5444206595420837,
0.024579282850027084,
-0.16883325576782227,
0.3512929379940033,
0.4581015706062317,
0.7017009854316711,
-0.1231074333190918,
-0.021123692393302917,
-0.17388252913951874,
-0.20020130276679993,
0.36315760016441345,
0.13997112214565277,
0.5345833897590637,
-0.513889491558075,
-0.4844975769519806,
0.15994834899902344,
-0.3708780109882355,
0.06563378125429153,
0.28607919812202454,
0.44056764245033264,
-0.043391186743974686,
0.5885173082351685,
-0.33926478028297424,
0.919082760810852,
-0.09852733463048935,
0.27698925137519836,
0.2604733407497406,
-0.37076589465141296,
-0.5843892693519592,
-0.21114124357700348,
0.32991960644721985,
0.28446945548057556,
0.12515175342559814,
-0.29616281390190125,
-0.28932657837867737,
0.26690828800201416,
0.1730584055185318,
-0.8148984909057617,
-0.37667176127433777,
-0.0566340871155262,
-0.9044107794761658,
-0.5759309530258179,
-0.12731899321079254,
-0.7925606369972229,
-0.6171121001243591,
-0.8003811240196228,
0.37571772933006287,
-0.44544726610183716,
-0.6140360832214355,
0.3183693587779999,
-0.35412168502807617,
0.15206411480903625,
0.2586299479007721,
-1.3325719833374023,
0.37859469652175903,
0.711569607257843,
0.6732762455940247,
0.15863165259361267,
-0.03491633012890816,
-0.804236114025116,
-0.025048330426216125,
-0.20535559952259064,
0.9358426928520203,
-0.8464685082435608,
-0.18128179013729095,
-0.20027489960193634,
-0.30945760011672974,
-0.16573618352413177,
-0.46431347727775574,
1.0670076608657837,
-0.5268372297286987,
0.17075960338115692,
-0.3002777695655823,
-0.5664994716644287,
-0.4816187024116516,
0.12813155353069305,
-0.7518965005874634,
0.8250575065612793,
0.255148321390152,
-0.5831306576728821,
0.19177401065826416,
-1.1288920640945435,
-0.2788298428058624,
0.1346435248851776,
-0.09293387830257416,
0.22478917241096497,
0.4719432294368744,
0.6175380349159241,
0.047379471361637115,
-0.25005659461021423,
0.0380004420876503,
-0.24909982085227966,
-0.3511984944343567,
0.49637728929519653,
-0.7751536965370178,
1.0135741233825684,
0.33970004320144653,
-0.4154698848724365,
0.13790713250637054,
-0.7668216824531555,
0.21408692002296448,
-0.23138359189033508,
-0.2584550678730011,
-0.40563467144966125,
-0.039918702095746994,
0.15288393199443817,
0.11775318533182144,
0.04649290069937706,
-0.24183981120586395,
-0.17679594457149506,
-0.8699554800987244,
0.5284051299095154,
0.7055543661117554,
0.15159273147583008,
0.8355210423469543,
-0.24591530859470367,
0.7747922539710999,
-0.14894311130046844,
0.02122499607503414,
-0.38715243339538574,
-0.010339506901800632,
-0.6681577563285828,
-0.44792434573173523,
0.616490364074707,
0.5428224802017212,
-0.5440448522567749,
0.3444124162197113,
-0.3551245629787445,
-0.12371362745761871,
-0.7813693881034851,
0.2875385284423828,
0.07437082380056381,
0.7922314405441284,
0.5386068820953369,
-0.1556161791086197,
-0.6773539781570435,
-0.9610695838928223,
-0.7884307503700256,
0.020514100790023804,
-0.19976088404655457,
0.2573193609714508,
0.11892731487751007,
-0.13721005618572235,
1.0896633863449097,
-0.1597139835357666,
-0.08906487375497818,
-0.23337163031101227,
0.16089566051959991,
0.24863968789577484,
0.6697993874549866,
0.6850719451904297,
-1.0240861177444458,
-0.44684457778930664,
0.20137889683246613,
-0.9105826616287231,
-0.2740224003791809,
-0.3794935643672943,
-0.40177685022354126,
-0.14339402318000793,
0.3514103293418884,
-0.39697813987731934,
0.4549609124660492,
0.470573365688324,
-0.3683268427848816,
0.3568393290042877,
-0.0007905534585006535,
0.17556129395961761,
-0.7192054390907288,
0.2212352454662323,
0.3665156066417694,
-0.2653912901878357,
-1.1119863986968994,
0.3214360773563385,
-0.08738841861486435,
0.14968810975551605,
-0.12835243344306946,
0.6492595672607422,
-0.5112372636795044,
0.0234205462038517,
-0.6178845167160034,
0.2363068014383316,
0.3604621887207031,
0.33367082476615906,
-0.018402041867375374,
0.3455297648906708,
0.5789199471473694,
-0.3650541305541992,
0.12114729732275009,
0.24012963473796844,
-0.38375037908554077,
0.6916084885597229,
-0.6970519423484802,
0.033089667558670044,
-0.3407227396965027,
0.02019607461988926,
-0.7785731554031372,
-0.10147763788700104,
0.5332046747207642,
-0.417898952960968,
0.2579040229320526,
-0.3568548560142517,
-0.5369418859481812,
0.11572568863630295,
-0.22210092842578888,
0.10538914054632187,
0.500328004360199,
-0.9777151346206665,
0.9253034591674805,
-0.03266913443803787,
-0.1903611123561859,
-0.6361587643623352,
-0.7979159951210022,
0.1568327397108078,
-0.6776114702224731,
-0.5065873265266418,
0.2746206521987915,
-0.19060635566711426,
-0.6046140789985657,
0.17750580608844757,
-0.2155606895685196,
-0.13612325489521027,
0.5129523873329163,
-0.19748787581920624,
0.5947840809822083,
-0.29648736119270325,
0.11933104693889618,
0.3016238212585449,
-0.2773759961128235,
0.025652294978499413,
-0.2591789662837982,
0.15366403758525848,
-0.07727958261966705,
-0.21248768270015717,
-0.837831437587738,
0.2763527035713196,
0.247419074177742,
-0.462388277053833,
0.6244115233421326,
0.5157352685928345,
-0.49426499009132385,
-0.1239018365740776,
-0.41827359795570374,
-0.39881592988967896,
-0.5151169896125793,
0.3237228989601135,
-0.3088891804218292,
-0.5449371933937073,
0.4483223259449005,
-0.23241457343101501,
0.14536572992801666,
0.4006344974040985,
0.2713742256164551,
-0.13546645641326904,
1.6018399000167847,
0.4245627224445343,
-0.02242211624979973,
0.9054924249649048,
-0.18144668638706207,
0.10582611709833145,
-1.155849814414978,
0.16407379508018494,
-0.44828692078590393,
-0.1952674835920334,
-0.21681912243366241,
-0.06776519119739532,
-0.06380907446146011,
0.778078556060791,
0.10558806359767914,
0.08006643503904343,
-0.595008373260498,
0.5254531502723694,
0.20292115211486816,
0.0793302059173584,
0.5249022245407104,
0.43285253643989563,
0.14802886545658112,
-0.33487483859062195,
-0.6523340940475464,
-0.8342270255088806,
1.0219148397445679,
0.4961361289024353,
0.4227476716041565,
-0.07457485049962997,
0.20308063924312592,
0.2629002034664154,
0.8226651549339294,
-0.715354859828949,
0.22594891488552094,
0.03530391305685043,
-0.7365814447402954,
-0.07543367892503738,
-0.6462034583091736,
-0.6786935925483704,
0.8793042302131653,
-0.45543724298477173,
-0.9402944445610046,
0.3554403781890869,
0.3697473406791687,
-0.333413302898407,
0.08212076872587204,
-0.7395731210708618,
0.930313766002655,
-0.4427475929260254,
-0.17514120042324066,
-0.30985593795776367,
-0.4092935025691986,
0.3721928596496582,
0.21200241148471832,
0.18373914062976837,
0.08200392872095108,
0.12138328701257706,
0.4461754858493805,
-0.27353477478027344,
0.7895547151565552,
-0.41660961508750916,
-0.008106442168354988,
0.2763758599758148,
-0.047027379274368286,
0.6137782335281372,
0.12403484433889389,
-0.6007788777351379,
0.06830696761608124,
-0.03226010873913765,
-0.27909156680107117,
-1.212804913520813,
0.5128662586212158,
-0.285596638917923,
-0.41237592697143555,
-0.1643674224615097,
-0.8343380093574524,
-0.06623866409063339,
0.26855364441871643,
0.007443562150001526,
0.7538641095161438,
0.17743155360221863,
0.08105023950338364,
0.1632741391658783,
0.11397776752710342,
0.1539786159992218,
0.23378010094165802,
-0.15141955018043518,
-0.36080485582351685,
0.7355567216873169,
-0.16630209982395172,
0.44023504853248596,
0.14567048847675323,
0.31720447540283203,
-0.4220234453678131,
-0.9733278155326843,
-0.3108963370323181,
0.11118125915527344,
-1.0454617738723755,
-0.05203958973288536,
-0.591343343257904,
0.03779106214642525,
-0.20071209967136383,
0.07907335460186005,
0.27937132120132446,
-0.5818342566490173,
-0.6061658263206482,
-0.29051870107650757,
0.3139444887638092,
0.2666708528995514,
-0.3181686997413635,
0.6690903306007385,
-0.7309557199478149,
0.3450171947479248,
0.08282472938299179,
0.32765910029411316,
0.16323266923427582,
-0.5985914468765259,
-0.35836249589920044,
0.5900448560714722,
-0.08010970056056976,
-0.6497578620910645,
0.5861234664916992,
0.1299974024295807,
0.978138267993927,
0.448312908411026,
-0.1000465676188469,
0.8004216551780701,
-0.1734313815832138,
0.4806777834892273,
-0.020175699144601822,
-1.084589958190918,
0.5229300856590271,
-0.3684808611869812,
-0.14159145951271057,
0.7736572027206421,
-0.04505477473139763,
-0.3854731619358063,
-0.19398371875286102,
-0.6543545722961426,
-0.6357012987136841,
0.7314743995666504,
0.38464123010635376,
0.35270634293556213,
0.24936698377132416,
0.8535550832748413,
0.08388465642929077,
0.20884466171264648,
-0.9583355784416199,
-0.2763712704181671,
-0.2946372330188751,
-0.37969931960105896,
-0.007115119136869907,
-0.1149870976805687,
-0.2665087580680847,
-0.1280968338251114,
0.5892664790153503,
-0.3120439350605011,
0.10424745082855225,
0.06049429252743721,
-0.36536237597465515,
-0.10763233155012131,
0.400501012802124,
0.31260305643081665,
0.8584087491035461,
-0.1224454715847969,
-0.024019623175263405,
0.15807589888572693,
-0.027589211240410805,
-0.46687522530555725,
0.38766029477119446,
-0.26286014914512634,
-0.016672002151608467,
0.42738649249076843,
1.1265279054641724,
0.17193375527858734,
-0.6456025838851929,
0.11978074163198471,
-0.06770642846822739,
0.1821422278881073,
-0.03005233220756054,
0.1487308293581009,
-0.061975929886102676,
0.4797403812408447,
0.2546563446521759,
0.45726871490478516,
0.5521150827407837,
-0.5253667235374451,
-0.1461765617132187,
0.5488015413284302,
-0.5530751943588257,
-0.2869274318218231,
0.5292004942893982,
-0.014540652744472027,
-0.3494992256164551,
0.5843309760093689,
-0.16526535153388977,
-0.4732513129711151,
0.4450696110725403,
0.578079342842102,
0.7322720289230347,
0.09311509132385254,
0.11802621185779572,
0.11202730983495712,
0.13821490108966827,
-0.21625664830207825,
0.28258877992630005,
-0.23809711635112762,
-0.7529998421669006,
-0.8040387034416199,
-0.469346821308136,
-0.15427377820014954,
0.07747261971235275,
-0.9328798055648804,
0.25727716088294983,
-0.006351527292281389,
-0.11674821376800537,
0.18503202497959137,
-0.1388913094997406,
-0.38059887290000916,
0.11333540827035904,
0.13505420088768005,
0.9402488470077515,
-0.698793888092041,
0.5573133826255798,
0.6404667496681213,
-0.36287203431129456,
-0.7908056378364563,
0.0161603931337595,
-0.010845058597624302,
-0.39938896894454956,
0.63573157787323,
0.13384480774402618,
0.021896550431847572,
0.2164134830236435,
-0.5118752121925354,
-0.7063707709312439,
0.9378856420516968,
0.6440900564193726,
-0.0861063003540039,
-0.053121984004974365,
-0.13803529739379883,
0.9061709046363831,
-0.5636254549026489,
0.2640235424041748,
0.8689259886741638,
0.565708339214325,
-0.14433468878269196,
-0.5920817255973816,
-0.0874764695763588,
-0.47536054253578186,
0.15548256039619446,
-0.05745536461472511,
0.17784912884235382,
0.727480411529541,
0.05444157123565674,
-0.45098692178726196,
0.5758589506149292,
0.6998974084854126,
0.3312450349330902,
0.10420297831296921,
0.7484925389289856,
0.26109224557876587,
0.8439117670059204,
0.25156643986701965,
1.2465285062789917,
-0.24698686599731445,
0.47292613983154297,
1.0382344722747803,
-0.14440380036830902,
0.5083360075950623,
0.3813716471195221,
0.1448245495557785,
0.6849836707115173,
0.5009243488311768,
-0.06245763972401619,
0.6795647740364075,
0.15946824848651886,
-0.3677716851234436,
-0.38717788457870483,
-0.27519604563713074,
-0.17416301369667053,
0.3930605947971344,
0.4798712730407715,
-0.5990330576896667,
-0.25953173637390137,
0.07904636859893799,
-0.18102984130382538,
0.268434077501297,
-0.4279120862483978,
0.47528761625289917,
0.1850983053445816,
-0.5352528691291809,
0.3334220051765442,
0.057171136140823364,
0.6105178594589233,
-0.4220729172229767,
-0.388338565826416,
-0.048953551799058914,
0.28693339228630066,
-0.3405015766620636,
-0.2990691661834717,
0.1406535506248474,
-0.04718153551220894,
-0.0455288402736187,
-0.30566051602363586,
0.8980565667152405,
-0.25466856360435486,
-0.5852071642875671,
0.29962608218193054,
0.4746270179748535,
-0.12696906924247742,
-0.10258972644805908,
-0.7702547311782837,
-0.2719097435474396,
0.04517953470349312,
-0.23263238370418549,
0.14468620717525482,
0.284970223903656,
0.05408395081758499,
0.40102097392082214,
0.8128555417060852,
0.4047093093395233,
-0.11740458011627197,
0.26494112610816956,
0.7514848709106445,
-0.4104589819908142,
-0.5368190407752991,
-1.0592893362045288,
0.763940155506134,
-0.3796982169151306,
-0.02801729366183281,
0.7631693482398987,
0.22976382076740265,
0.5192589163780212,
0.21299445629119873,
0.9711713194847107,
0.1446930468082428,
0.5698086619377136,
-0.6723032593727112,
0.4877845346927643,
-0.4940202534198761,
0.5831395983695984,
-0.3838486969470978,
-1.0179221630096436,
-0.3693581223487854,
1.071759819984436,
-0.48766282200813293,
0.14311562478542328,
0.5440583825111389,
0.6831374764442444,
-0.18450026214122772,
0.5381034016609192,
-0.039488524198532104,
0.03779548406600952,
0.3679506778717041,
-0.03351936489343643,
1.267266035079956,
-0.31430235505104065,
0.40698546171188354,
-0.342887818813324,
-0.4039943516254425,
-0.04290393367409706,
-0.8641230463981628,
-0.8130539059638977,
-0.10428279638290405,
-0.1696029007434845,
-0.3199062943458557,
-0.15170086920261383,
0.9367106556892395,
0.5419195294380188,
-0.5764094591140747,
-0.1408248245716095,
-0.2829149663448334,
-0.050785403698682785,
-0.6077703237533569,
-0.24342815577983856,
0.31250032782554626,
-0.4899179935455322,
-0.7929280400276184,
0.7079299092292786,
0.07808846235275269,
-0.008600371889770031,
-0.21018385887145996,
-0.09120244532823563,
0.010191725566983223,
-0.0024549385998398066,
0.5523830652236938,
0.26421475410461426,
-0.5055484175682068,
-0.3559185862541199,
0.13103322684764862,
0.16804584860801697,
0.2645696997642517,
1.0436007976531982,
-0.873240053653717,
0.6498878598213196,
0.5180882811546326,
0.5663520693778992,
0.382872074842453,
0.4013342559337616,
0.7915379405021667,
-0.4473372995853424,
-0.010765769518911839,
0.37550729513168335,
0.5492675304412842,
0.45914119482040405,
-0.4099416732788086,
0.6003753542900085,
-0.01674000360071659,
-0.18989188969135284,
-1.1525050401687622,
0.26167455315589905,
-0.8366020321846008,
-0.12480109930038452,
1.090799331665039,
-0.1324131339788437,
0.13882680237293243,
-0.0545869879424572,
-0.2523016035556793,
0.2562147080898285,
-0.10645274817943573,
0.7321414351463318,
0.536397397518158,
-0.36852335929870605,
-0.07565195858478546,
-0.8791028261184692,
0.4034610688686371,
0.6696110963821411,
-0.9754553437232971,
0.22165334224700928,
0.5654921531677246,
0.10553077608346939,
0.24721015989780426,
0.43420371413230896,
-0.2513003647327423,
0.3613327443599701,
-0.157371386885643,
-0.2108048051595688,
-0.15110881626605988,
0.005514894146472216,
-1.026472806930542,
-0.21009185910224915,
0.15921887755393982,
0.08903764933347702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02060v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02060v3
|
Long-context LLMs Struggle with Long In-context Learning
| 2024-04-02T15:59:11 | 2024-06-12T02:46:16 |
Tianle Li, Ge Zhang, Quy Duc Do, Xiang Yue, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant strides in handling long
sequences. Some models like Gemini could even to be capable of dealing with
millions of tokens. However, their performance evaluation has largely been
confined to metrics like perplexity and synthetic tasks, which may not fully
capture their true abilities in more challenging, real-world scenarios. We
introduce a benchmark (LongICLBench) for long in-context learning in
extreme-label classification using six datasets with 28 to 174 classes and
input lengths from 2K to 50K tokens. Our benchmark requires LLMs to comprehend
the entire input to recognize the massive label spaces to make correct
predictions. We evaluate on 15 long-context LLMs and find that they perform
well on less challenging classification tasks with smaller label space and
shorter demonstrations. However, they struggle with more challenging task like
Discovery with 174 labels, suggesting a gap in their ability to process long,
context-rich sequences. Further analysis reveals a bias towards labels
presented later in the sequence and a need for improved reasoning over multiple
pieces of information. Our study reveals that long context understanding and
reasoning is still a challenging task for the existing LLMs. We believe
LongICLBench could serve as a more realistic evaluation for the future
long-context LLMs.
|
[
-0.46563345193862915,
-0.5817955136299133,
0.6539885997772217,
0.1778150349855423,
-0.3198896050453186,
0.04126875475049019,
-0.6004814505577087,
-0.8870285153388977,
-0.23954400420188904,
0.3213599920272827,
-0.48747318983078003,
-0.6355812549591064,
-0.6161022186279297,
0.3338826894760132,
-0.35629260540008545,
1.0612850189208984,
-0.17644861340522766,
-0.23042920231819153,
-0.18757662177085876,
-0.376407653093338,
-0.2595727741718292,
-0.6426255106925964,
-0.5161701440811157,
-0.47018787264823914,
0.6342708468437195,
0.3296438157558441,
0.4387182891368866,
0.4131564199924469,
0.09462673962116241,
0.2109357863664627,
-0.47808974981307983,
0.2416246086359024,
-0.6559937000274658,
0.26039600372314453,
-0.35084542632102966,
-0.08803214132785797,
-0.2563369572162628,
-0.1683538258075714,
0.8658331632614136,
0.847995400428772,
0.15528838336467743,
0.1002652570605278,
0.0978412851691246,
0.5752041339874268,
-0.46190524101257324,
0.2211030274629593,
-0.3235160708427429,
0.1478702872991562,
-0.31359902024269104,
0.16146810352802277,
-0.5283940434455872,
0.11388883739709854,
0.2368701696395874,
-0.35002684593200684,
-0.24481502175331116,
0.3087772727012634,
0.5292245745658875,
0.13645420968532562,
-0.7438186407089233,
-0.4915924668312073,
-0.5818645358085632,
0.6368706226348877,
-0.5705380439758301,
0.5339064002037048,
0.23056641221046448,
0.4090617597103119,
-0.4331957697868347,
-0.7084065675735474,
-0.4597416818141937,
-0.27421703934669495,
0.26629316806793213,
0.0026624652091413736,
0.0741400346159935,
0.08782804012298584,
0.6050359606742859,
-0.04545776918530464,
-0.36544138193130493,
0.7222817540168762,
-0.2222910374403,
-0.11001799255609512,
0.39677008986473083,
0.14538536965847015,
-0.36453911662101746,
-0.1449059396982193,
-0.7044559121131897,
-0.08918514847755432,
-0.7283229827880859,
0.3421867787837982,
0.0640677958726883,
0.19136692583560944,
-0.07069718837738037,
0.2321384847164154,
-0.002083000959828496,
0.7272821068763733,
-0.3064383268356323,
-0.2435520589351654,
0.3576696813106537,
0.2937721908092499,
-0.2236427217721939,
0.0857408344745636,
0.5972645282745361,
0.2979363799095154,
-0.0446612648665905,
-0.2644026577472687,
-0.5611652731895447,
-0.22326961159706116,
-0.268292635679245,
-0.9036767482757568,
0.2557152807712555,
0.18434496223926544,
-0.150650754570961,
0.3260454535484314,
-0.09332884103059769,
-0.4702806770801544,
-0.47957345843315125,
-0.47342294454574585,
0.39752396941185,
-0.30329978466033936,
0.20523135364055634,
0.08260270953178406,
-0.08028604835271835,
0.27235010266304016,
0.29772335290908813,
-0.47506392002105713,
0.31831812858581543,
0.8606706857681274,
0.6954796314239502,
-0.43975648283958435,
-0.30681854486465454,
-0.451907217502594,
0.2006288319826126,
-0.26009997725486755,
0.6653236746788025,
-0.43383997678756714,
-0.4238106906414032,
-0.051432158797979355,
0.09252149611711502,
0.17538894712924957,
-0.7428166270256042,
0.6116787195205688,
-0.6585854887962341,
-0.1024102196097374,
-0.1555566042661667,
-0.9406747221946716,
-0.00263597653247416,
0.31335538625717163,
-0.35704976320266724,
1.0671534538269043,
0.23492994904518127,
-0.48062077164649963,
0.5402956604957581,
-0.5371777415275574,
-0.4957161545753479,
0.33815863728523254,
-0.27299433946609497,
-0.2439584881067276,
0.12426720559597015,
-0.05673817917704582,
0.8667017221450806,
-0.36050179600715637,
0.5519552230834961,
-0.4234962463378906,
-0.6720799803733826,
0.5067570209503174,
-0.4520130455493927,
0.3847929835319519,
0.0675881877541542,
-0.5266073942184448,
0.025426629930734634,
-0.8178011775016785,
-0.04623094201087952,
-0.1587466299533844,
-0.5939866304397583,
-0.3453476130962372,
-0.07125379145145416,
0.14323647320270538,
0.3880762457847595,
0.029478469863533974,
-0.6017372608184814,
0.2506205439567566,
-0.25473183393478394,
0.6171932816505432,
1.0421266555786133,
-0.5645648241043091,
0.2673196494579315,
0.02531951665878296,
0.14329546689987183,
0.000968136650044471,
0.03432174399495125,
-0.06194859743118286,
-0.17093534767627716,
-0.6205255389213562,
-0.3306930959224701,
0.2882484495639801,
0.25002190470695496,
-0.7523764967918396,
0.588439404964447,
-0.5365245938301086,
-0.2243720144033432,
-0.005345263984054327,
0.35158413648605347,
0.5869408845901489,
0.581052303314209,
0.4561575949192047,
-0.34403449296951294,
-0.2611595392227173,
-0.8530821800231934,
-0.008470501750707626,
0.27028489112854004,
-0.2339150756597519,
0.6079967617988586,
0.840135395526886,
-0.6824600696563721,
0.8446792960166931,
-0.2364983707666397,
-0.1698015332221985,
-0.1331784576177597,
0.06139294430613518,
0.5434547662734985,
0.054083988070487976,
0.13600210845470428,
-0.5768741369247437,
-0.30942171812057495,
-0.10532549768686295,
-0.7357776165008545,
-0.07433082163333893,
0.1526249498128891,
0.10966495424509048,
0.49097099900245667,
0.7099783420562744,
-0.3952374756336212,
0.12610261142253876,
0.4985389709472656,
-0.23817014694213867,
0.5161411762237549,
-0.13821212947368622,
-0.35286328196525574,
-0.7293176651000977,
0.019336983561515808,
0.07857289165258408,
-0.3667513132095337,
-0.3765355944633484,
0.05789130553603172,
0.5512561798095703,
-0.05064428597688675,
-0.7508533596992493,
0.8867846131324768,
-0.3289569318294525,
-0.14990659058094025,
-0.39099255204200745,
0.18036054074764252,
-0.26858407258987427,
0.42715296149253845,
0.13628479838371277,
0.52939373254776,
0.5515666007995605,
-0.6227481365203857,
0.4797811508178711,
-0.19252057373523712,
-0.8189281821250916,
0.5051169395446777,
-0.34019458293914795,
0.3117205500602722,
-0.2896948456764221,
1.0295946598052979,
-0.9044820070266724,
-0.30146533250808716,
-0.017038622871041298,
-0.07401405274868011,
0.6412562727928162,
0.09090737253427505,
-0.7464534640312195,
-0.6065608859062195,
-0.11387713253498077,
0.6091642379760742,
0.5270806550979614,
-0.9694190621376038,
0.3722900152206421,
-0.004155932925641537,
0.16735661029815674,
-0.7056704759597778,
-0.4161165952682495,
0.31912124156951904,
-0.42753714323043823,
-0.3428494930267334,
0.43931248784065247,
-0.07515845447778702,
-0.027469677850604057,
-0.3690434694290161,
-0.3204406201839447,
0.4128219187259674,
0.009506529197096825,
0.4832797348499298,
-0.0630105510354042,
0.016420910134911537,
0.45504170656204224,
-0.08170533925294876,
-0.19332411885261536,
0.12883634865283966,
-0.31879448890686035,
0.2733169198036194,
-0.3258148431777954,
-0.1294826716184616,
-0.01957091875374317,
0.2146388590335846,
0.5950148105621338,
0.29708442091941833,
0.7051288485527039,
0.5368912220001221,
-0.32885950803756714,
-0.64609295129776,
-0.6187704801559448,
0.11104961484670639,
-0.46983271837234497,
0.6585938930511475,
-0.4479604661464691,
-1.0449403524398804,
0.4632743299007416,
-0.40918660163879395,
0.03196755796670914,
0.343743234872818,
0.29041385650634766,
-0.2824883460998535,
0.6849286556243896,
0.49799251556396484,
-0.21667301654815674,
0.15646901726722717,
-0.3031919002532959,
0.025003595277667046,
-1.0561974048614502,
-0.45067843794822693,
-0.21189628541469574,
-0.44563189148902893,
-0.2341471165418625,
-0.6092960238456726,
0.5294516086578369,
0.04976771026849747,
-0.5617146492004395,
0.21029628813266754,
-0.22589893639087677,
0.6409779787063599,
0.23253706097602844,
0.3414958119392395,
-0.005532547831535339,
-0.2037990689277649,
-0.16522611677646637,
0.19458529353141785,
-0.5727863311767578,
-0.3729683756828308,
0.9004870653152466,
0.620822548866272,
0.7520965933799744,
0.02601521648466587,
0.6261019706726074,
0.05743302032351494,
0.6809093356132507,
-0.8553521633148193,
0.6372809410095215,
-0.17565102875232697,
-0.5878766775131226,
-0.35993731021881104,
-0.37804701924324036,
-0.9060570597648621,
0.24120424687862396,
-0.004468776285648346,
-0.6404591202735901,
-0.2038724273443222,
-0.16294734179973602,
-0.12713371217250824,
0.2327229380607605,
-0.27359622716903687,
0.6267316937446594,
-0.5391503572463989,
-0.498990923166275,
0.08211206644773483,
-1.1086914539337158,
0.22475497424602509,
-0.29855841398239136,
0.6202764511108398,
-0.15443211793899536,
-0.21957635879516602,
0.9994915127754211,
-0.1478949934244156,
0.9817155599594116,
-0.09408779442310333,
-0.24477887153625488,
0.10786768049001694,
-0.158777117729187,
0.4486848711967468,
0.06968259066343307,
-0.07373309135437012,
0.06329111754894257,
-0.18833184242248535,
-0.4148513078689575,
-0.3770727217197418,
0.8323532342910767,
-0.7646980881690979,
-0.5049018859863281,
-0.43135663866996765,
-0.36933809518814087,
-0.46495094895362854,
0.03539663553237915,
0.32954204082489014,
0.5201635360717773,
-0.0490112379193306,
0.42174920439720154,
0.8597466349601746,
-0.2735786736011505,
0.4668191969394684,
0.36751842498779297,
-0.17481476068496704,
-0.3003568649291992,
0.6884176135063171,
0.13123637437820435,
0.17411087453365326,
0.48117420077323914,
0.22135110199451447,
-0.5239949226379395,
-0.5846340656280518,
-0.42472144961357117,
0.13043943047523499,
-1.223541498184204,
-0.2341620922088623,
-0.5049614310264587,
-0.0415397584438324,
-0.10506599396467209,
-0.1982026845216751,
-0.21626709401607513,
-0.0666012167930603,
-0.22024941444396973,
-0.10555402934551239,
0.04809008911252022,
0.7369526028633118,
0.1379794478416443,
0.20575952529907227,
-0.7416249513626099,
0.1517467498779297,
0.27209916710853577,
0.5145873427391052,
0.16186000406742096,
-0.7831307649612427,
-0.36256352066993713,
-0.2526213526725769,
-0.34220099449157715,
-0.614818274974823,
0.05946645885705948,
0.26026657223701477,
0.5000866055488586,
0.43524596095085144,
0.05543775483965874,
0.7575460076332092,
-0.5250579118728638,
0.6962782740592957,
0.2384173423051834,
-0.8927173614501953,
0.05790821090340614,
-0.07526412606239319,
0.48595601320266724,
0.3595106899738312,
0.6732656955718994,
-0.5839264392852783,
-0.06093767285346985,
-0.3283172845840454,
-1.2012535333633423,
0.4406021535396576,
-0.14176161587238312,
0.20001789927482605,
-0.2341158539056778,
0.49974608421325684,
0.4421934187412262,
0.011976712383329868,
-0.9168480038642883,
-0.11034087836742401,
0.14796553552150726,
0.07456987351179123,
-0.619805097579956,
-0.2900252640247345,
-0.13010379672050476,
-0.4098729193210602,
0.4069245457649231,
-0.2851526141166687,
-0.05441158637404442,
0.07553735375404358,
-0.26095715165138245,
0.1499430537223816,
0.4548201858997345,
0.6963045597076416,
0.857222855091095,
-0.22101545333862305,
0.2829189598560333,
0.6597809791564941,
0.08496707677841187,
0.08191486448049545,
0.09184566885232925,
0.47335103154182434,
-0.20198504626750946,
0.5663980841636658,
0.9289969801902771,
0.5414010882377625,
-1.0176036357879639,
0.5413690805435181,
0.060778893530368805,
-0.20703572034835815,
-0.4636766314506531,
-0.06671950221061707,
0.2165362387895584,
0.3150188624858856,
0.5878903865814209,
-0.32951194047927856,
0.012085629627108574,
-0.6697998642921448,
-0.05815235152840614,
0.3381357789039612,
-0.4653182029724121,
-0.08950220793485641,
0.38039177656173706,
0.22186101973056793,
-0.17843984067440033,
0.8850982189178467,
-0.05432288721203804,
-0.68951815366745,
0.7385505437850952,
0.6774579286575317,
0.5314940810203552,
0.12562738358974457,
-0.3673612177371979,
0.055011164397001266,
-0.18890252709388733,
-0.24031099677085876,
-0.26457247138023376,
-0.4714961349964142,
-0.39779001474380493,
-0.4892970621585846,
-0.7167133092880249,
-0.6010441184043884,
0.34160491824150085,
-0.44274207949638367,
0.3358498513698578,
-0.38715660572052,
-0.17241761088371277,
-0.10436946898698807,
-0.15293803811073303,
-0.6871525049209595,
0.24872544407844543,
0.6150078177452087,
1.1284593343734741,
-0.7346081733703613,
0.7946489453315735,
0.5604403018951416,
0.5054111480712891,
-0.46193501353263855,
-0.43314534425735474,
-0.1690843403339386,
-0.5909605622291565,
1.0293325185775757,
0.8707736730575562,
-0.10804173350334167,
-0.4621899127960205,
-0.6887357831001282,
-0.6083850264549255,
1.0727821588516235,
-0.03576737642288208,
-0.9092062711715698,
-0.16386251151561737,
0.057442378252744675,
0.7356124520301819,
-0.3187001049518585,
0.2555292546749115,
0.49342694878578186,
0.38983452320098877,
0.2295105755329132,
-1.0051006078720093,
0.03377124294638634,
0.03752896934747696,
-0.14628709852695465,
0.3696048855781555,
-0.5985352993011475,
0.49680405855178833,
-0.10040920972824097,
-0.1189015731215477,
-0.016746141016483307,
0.6807926297187805,
0.29528284072875977,
0.6115136742591858,
0.4937697649002075,
0.5100889205932617,
0.5634906888008118,
-0.0017796737374737859,
0.9054272174835205,
0.04124767333269119,
0.3703518807888031,
1.1475392580032349,
-0.42890170216560364,
0.9722867012023926,
0.47844818234443665,
-0.22233794629573822,
0.4080582559108734,
0.8842710256576538,
0.21196149289608002,
0.3232823312282562,
0.7406107187271118,
-0.27585822343826294,
-0.3319694995880127,
0.11113614588975906,
-0.4062459170818329,
0.27114027738571167,
0.8253350853919983,
-0.26611319184303284,
-0.1968415230512619,
0.440415620803833,
-0.06132086366415024,
-0.1987263709306717,
-0.42506739497184753,
0.6364866495132446,
0.4865318536758423,
-0.7512123584747314,
0.9689752459526062,
-0.0028351182118058205,
1.0506843328475952,
-0.4543217122554779,
0.21969091892242432,
-0.10288099944591522,
0.3703557848930359,
-0.12032647430896759,
-0.9432819485664368,
-0.1880972534418106,
-0.22144955396652222,
0.03319244086742401,
-0.31323015689849854,
0.3117251396179199,
-0.19517283141613007,
-0.13790501654148102,
0.6381262540817261,
0.04060062766075134,
0.3139757513999939,
0.04164654389023781,
-0.5196408033370972,
0.12079402059316635,
-0.3939923346042633,
-0.5076419711112976,
0.6796525120735168,
0.3778940439224243,
-0.22083714604377747,
0.845093309879303,
0.36101871728897095,
-0.2892957627773285,
-0.06727897375822067,
-0.06825091689825058,
0.88136887550354,
-0.8713718056678772,
-0.3344523012638092,
-0.9592521786689758,
0.055726662278175354,
0.04401899129152298,
-0.45261362195014954,
0.42022398114204407,
0.64348965883255,
1.0788359642028809,
0.061086058616638184,
0.42164748907089233,
0.1532132625579834,
0.3133208453655243,
-0.5023354887962341,
0.2704426348209381,
-0.6381008625030518,
0.2644594609737396,
-0.10126379877328873,
-1.0102516412734985,
-0.36072322726249695,
0.19259759783744812,
-0.2917928993701935,
-0.06499820947647095,
0.6384938359260559,
0.3532264828681946,
-0.1115233451128006,
-0.05229313671588898,
0.425676554441452,
0.24786476790905,
0.47693032026290894,
1.124493956565857,
1.1597882509231567,
-0.1400763839483261,
0.3538118600845337,
-0.21458473801612854,
-0.42601966857910156,
-0.27927207946777344,
-1.1215496063232422,
-1.1150554418563843,
-0.5252022743225098,
-0.029652724042534828,
-0.3137491047382355,
0.2959306538105011,
1.200682282447815,
0.5689687728881836,
-0.45811206102371216,
-0.339828759431839,
0.29834309220314026,
-0.05560009554028511,
0.0005641303141601384,
-0.16030411422252655,
0.5418914556503296,
-0.1079559326171875,
-0.662865400314331,
0.48633912205696106,
0.2864241600036621,
0.018541162833571434,
-0.0073948027566075325,
-0.2293025106191635,
0.3156018853187561,
-0.19635511934757233,
0.988949179649353,
0.4130449593067169,
-0.8450419306755066,
-0.4142104983329773,
-0.24517816305160522,
-0.13423609733581543,
-0.022940313443541527,
0.5435379147529602,
-0.9429311156272888,
0.38164401054382324,
0.23124243319034576,
0.608300507068634,
0.7122706174850464,
-0.11691546440124512,
0.11641361564397812,
-0.5800071358680725,
-0.06785791367292404,
0.4172552227973938,
0.422236829996109,
0.30376771092414856,
-0.07781343907117844,
0.32032325863838196,
-0.11192535609006882,
-0.8518379330635071,
-0.9455785155296326,
0.14835254848003387,
-0.973134458065033,
-0.5752224326133728,
1.4247870445251465,
-0.2525510787963867,
-0.29185348749160767,
-0.10186967253684998,
-0.08622709661722183,
0.09914442151784897,
-0.33568522334098816,
0.6538826823234558,
0.8112888932228088,
-0.3297782838344574,
0.06706439703702927,
-0.49808502197265625,
0.24910791218280792,
0.42746907472610474,
-0.4320104420185089,
0.10426392406225204,
0.3574625253677368,
0.42695894837379456,
-0.02738773450255394,
0.2761218845844269,
0.060771409422159195,
0.12512892484664917,
-0.5180386304855347,
-0.2797119617462158,
-0.14370092749595642,
-0.5545006394386292,
-0.34525957703590393,
0.1907118707895279,
0.08293737471103668,
0.3289623558521271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02054v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02054v2
|
Deconstructing In-Context Learning: Understanding Prompts via Corruption
| 2024-04-02T15:50:55 | 2024-05-29T16:12:37 |
Namrata Shivagunde, Vladislav Lialin, Sherin Muckatira, Anna Rumshisky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ability of large language models (LLMs) to $``$learn in context$"$ based
on the provided prompt has led to an explosive growth in their use, culminating
in the proliferation of AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Bard. These
AI assistants are known to be robust to minor prompt modifications, mostly due
to alignment techniques that use human feedback. In contrast, the underlying
pre-trained LLMs they use as a backbone are known to be brittle in this
respect. Building high-quality backbone models remains a core challenge, and a
common approach to assessing their quality is to conduct few-shot evaluation.
Such evaluation is notorious for being highly sensitive to minor prompt
modifications, as well as the choice of specific in-context examples. Prior
work has examined how modifying different elements of the prompt can affect
model performance. However, these earlier studies tended to concentrate on a
limited number of specific prompt attributes and often produced contradictory
results. Additionally, previous research either focused on models with fewer
than 15 billion parameters or exclusively examined black-box models like GPT-3
or PaLM, making replication challenging. In the present study, we decompose the
entire prompt into four components: task description, demonstration inputs,
labels, and inline instructions provided for each demonstration. We investigate
the effects of structural and semantic corruptions of these elements on model
performance. We study models ranging from 1.5B to 70B in size, using ten
datasets covering classification and generation tasks. We find that repeating
text within the prompt boosts model performance, and bigger models ($\geq$30B)
are more sensitive to the semantics of the prompt. Finally, we observe that
adding task and inline instructions to the demonstrations enhances model
performance even when the instructions are semantically corrupted.
|
[
-0.09507844597101212,
-0.8934853672981262,
0.565657377243042,
0.05139511451125145,
-0.1967766135931015,
-0.26245805621147156,
-0.014532827772200108,
-0.39742735028266907,
-0.4135657250881195,
0.39767956733703613,
-0.6434498429298401,
-0.15191295742988586,
-0.48166516423225403,
0.403949111700058,
-0.3410837948322296,
1.2749370336532593,
0.22978375852108002,
0.24219506978988647,
-0.3742556869983673,
-0.11799793690443039,
-0.8597568869590759,
-0.315889447927475,
-0.7366330027580261,
-0.35796722769737244,
0.4531515836715698,
0.4520390033721924,
0.5610566139221191,
0.656766951084137,
0.15466587245464325,
0.3476007282733917,
-0.3914162814617157,
0.022828081622719765,
-0.8165550231933594,
0.21338534355163574,
-0.2375309318304062,
-0.5273141264915466,
-0.20898935198783875,
0.13785791397094727,
0.7464507222175598,
0.7305243611335754,
0.37004101276397705,
0.07933516055345535,
0.7085740566253662,
0.35652145743370056,
-0.49484413862228394,
0.2625986337661743,
-0.6949597001075745,
-0.3561374545097351,
-0.08093132078647614,
-0.21667909622192383,
-0.6731903553009033,
-0.11187266558408737,
0.31573721766471863,
-0.6325656175613403,
0.19088506698608398,
0.02215179242193699,
0.8672772645950317,
0.3221692442893982,
-0.40677130222320557,
-0.40182793140411377,
-0.4727151095867157,
0.6700624227523804,
-0.48417797684669495,
-0.06693664193153381,
0.3402405083179474,
0.26722434163093567,
-0.40905705094337463,
-0.6995061039924622,
-0.3599841296672821,
-0.3202635943889618,
-0.2474619746208191,
-0.016460029408335686,
-0.2212837040424347,
0.1697498857975006,
0.5080984830856323,
0.16377206146717072,
-0.3804631233215332,
0.25510719418525696,
-0.4330960810184479,
-0.3739602267742157,
0.34147801995277405,
0.4510096609592438,
0.47280243039131165,
-0.5380662083625793,
-0.3800838887691498,
-0.24868394434452057,
-1.026635766029358,
0.3261021077632904,
0.48349055647850037,
0.6123371124267578,
-0.12516027688980103,
0.5474889278411865,
-0.062431175261735916,
0.7894002795219421,
0.16782858967781067,
-0.3109189569950104,
-0.1695834845304489,
-0.6163639426231384,
-0.3344706594944,
-0.05229895934462547,
0.5350679159164429,
0.11415788531303406,
0.040512584149837494,
0.0663052499294281,
-0.3001691997051239,
-0.03814529627561569,
0.28839606046676636,
-0.9167801141738892,
-0.191012442111969,
0.08082087337970734,
-0.5222910046577454,
-0.2209215611219406,
-0.21668927371501923,
-0.33296599984169006,
-0.6343656778335571,
-0.428766131401062,
0.6475109457969666,
-0.6913313865661621,
0.27414950728416443,
-0.2003195732831955,
-0.23800347745418549,
0.23892608284950256,
0.6518053412437439,
-0.6087692975997925,
-0.03986406326293945,
0.6740292906761169,
0.7587904334068298,
-0.056370727717876434,
-0.4008171558380127,
-0.6698402166366577,
-0.2890284061431885,
-0.30588337779045105,
0.7962729334831238,
-0.5689685940742493,
-0.5150719285011292,
-0.1307433545589447,
0.11648209393024445,
-0.11641430109739304,
-0.539286732673645,
0.5132260918617249,
-0.3108751177787781,
0.3465745449066162,
-0.5765224099159241,
-0.5142396688461304,
-0.20030467212200165,
0.18642544746398926,
-0.7010543942451477,
0.801116943359375,
0.20256738364696503,
-0.6460310220718384,
0.49106839299201965,
-0.495342880487442,
-0.2624015510082245,
0.08157340437173843,
-0.06925657391548157,
-0.19545744359493256,
0.11496853828430176,
0.1868249475955963,
0.5315907001495361,
-0.29628080129623413,
0.19576574862003326,
-0.0858856737613678,
-0.697950541973114,
0.25978952646255493,
-0.6942679286003113,
0.957829475402832,
-0.02622082270681858,
-0.27478522062301636,
0.24763670563697815,
-0.8491771817207336,
-0.39336568117141724,
-0.07114935666322708,
-0.3383813202381134,
-0.4151421785354614,
-0.12263984233140945,
-0.2508161664009094,
0.17727795243263245,
-0.154806986451149,
-0.2701058089733124,
0.3316405117511749,
-0.5274284482002258,
0.31260445713996887,
0.8610642552375793,
0.16561894118785858,
0.5533169507980347,
-0.47236961126327515,
0.5720223188400269,
0.11519541591405869,
-0.00408641854301095,
-0.9021642208099365,
-0.5035114884376526,
-0.5941402316093445,
-0.3568263351917267,
0.11488186568021774,
0.3626517951488495,
-0.8271271586418152,
-0.16246604919433594,
-0.24872922897338867,
-0.3621496856212616,
-0.6494137644767761,
0.2301270216703415,
0.513198733329773,
0.9981420636177063,
0.4409453570842743,
-0.0036913680378347635,
-0.20144325494766235,
-0.8413339853286743,
-0.440796822309494,
-0.28758299350738525,
-0.10406208783388138,
0.4398135542869568,
0.7118593454360962,
-0.01734619215130806,
0.9515893459320068,
-0.002460057381540537,
-0.12491503357887268,
-0.39408713579177856,
0.18867549300193787,
0.1710033416748047,
0.506359338760376,
0.5623753666877747,
-0.32958680391311646,
-0.32919806241989136,
-0.3803297281265259,
-0.4951590299606323,
-0.13099095225334167,
-0.34537771344184875,
0.15738210082054138,
0.14998145401477814,
0.4120706021785736,
-0.4316923916339874,
0.509281575679779,
0.2305280715227127,
-0.5339846611022949,
0.8761435747146606,
0.014189201407134533,
0.12782929837703705,
-0.8585619330406189,
-0.06236729398369789,
-0.16567634046077728,
-0.14923611283302307,
-0.48989859223365784,
0.05137459561228752,
0.0926986038684845,
-0.18511557579040527,
-0.6659948825836182,
0.780968189239502,
-0.4134693145751953,
-0.04034041240811348,
-0.37354227900505066,
0.2801702618598938,
0.05167527124285698,
0.3739750385284424,
-0.31818845868110657,
1.070660948753357,
0.4397611618041992,
-0.7429897785186768,
0.057864412665367126,
0.2317751795053482,
-0.5402215719223022,
0.7433987855911255,
-0.9790493249893188,
0.09085264056921005,
-0.27098071575164795,
0.3667714595794678,
-1.2245769500732422,
-0.40204232931137085,
0.03360212966799736,
-0.27444353699684143,
0.4137551486492157,
-0.3630770146846771,
-0.4591938555240631,
0.1992732733488083,
-0.34456712007522583,
0.4617862403392792,
0.4067002236843109,
-0.6768721342086792,
0.4459405243396759,
-0.1452402025461197,
-0.05201081559062004,
-0.6995621919631958,
-0.5024184584617615,
-0.0574512779712677,
-0.3453275263309479,
-0.7775625586509705,
0.39258572459220886,
-0.050407517701387405,
-0.32419538497924805,
-0.1180415153503418,
-0.042405981570482254,
0.30143848061561584,
0.5021952390670776,
0.40331295132637024,
0.29696670174598694,
-0.1497819572687149,
0.1788901835680008,
0.13129650056362152,
0.08209718763828278,
0.04289709031581879,
-0.07347878068685532,
0.3569282591342926,
-0.09440340846776962,
-0.27239659428596497,
-0.6406536102294922,
0.12748675048351288,
0.5540595054626465,
-0.015622955746948719,
0.8269902467727661,
0.25127923488616943,
-0.22274722158908844,
-0.35146746039390564,
-0.21918565034866333,
-0.4017477333545685,
-0.48303043842315674,
0.27020543813705444,
-0.42460793256759644,
-0.8493764996528625,
0.6528502702713013,
-0.05928719416260719,
0.000012405354937072843,
0.34533408284187317,
0.408212810754776,
-0.02568819746375084,
0.7757653594017029,
0.517402708530426,
0.047150567173957825,
0.5664955377578735,
-0.2898816168308258,
-0.12953780591487885,
-0.888389527797699,
-0.2041093409061432,
-0.6212714910507202,
-0.2334349900484085,
-0.44806164503097534,
-0.3153412640094757,
0.5124801397323608,
0.30776748061180115,
-0.3653935194015503,
0.27317914366722107,
-0.21589678525924683,
0.5984402298927307,
0.40231630206108093,
0.24313759803771973,
0.18450090289115906,
-0.30786463618278503,
-0.2788214087486267,
0.2312479019165039,
-0.8371703624725342,
-0.8781861066818237,
0.9825224280357361,
0.41199544072151184,
0.6512510776519775,
0.06440628319978714,
0.47466903924942017,
0.11154574155807495,
0.12126746773719788,
-0.817600667476654,
0.4758699834346771,
0.24535156786441803,
-0.45012515783309937,
-0.2670648992061615,
-0.19506965577602386,
-1.1558672189712524,
0.3353859484195709,
-0.1450786292552948,
-0.8483838438987732,
0.2311054915189743,
0.25492414832115173,
-0.5948874354362488,
-0.03464016318321228,
-0.7648695111274719,
0.9970446228981018,
0.13035431504249573,
-0.6059674620628357,
-0.06437762081623077,
-0.5401354432106018,
0.5184964537620544,
0.11652714014053345,
-0.02460690215229988,
0.09304241091012955,
0.08835460245609283,
0.574851393699646,
-0.43847620487213135,
1.168698787689209,
-0.0712045282125473,
-0.15559203922748566,
0.3174663782119751,
0.3732236325740814,
0.8016501665115356,
0.0956534594297409,
-0.11126454174518585,
-0.09554798901081085,
-0.011121266521513462,
-0.521725058555603,
-0.7305953502655029,
0.5646175146102905,
-0.699684202671051,
-0.7847918272018433,
-0.16099366545677185,
-0.558744490146637,
-0.08663701266050339,
-0.12507523596286774,
0.4229482114315033,
0.853471577167511,
-0.17412352561950684,
0.2536764144897461,
0.6030371189117432,
-0.47654324769973755,
0.6183481216430664,
0.18277300894260406,
0.20307350158691406,
0.052682653069496155,
0.6032914519309998,
0.1281738430261612,
0.451513409614563,
0.059556663036346436,
0.19175133109092712,
-0.1622891128063202,
-0.5212306976318359,
-0.40090706944465637,
0.10982459038496017,
-0.9816500544548035,
-0.23862949013710022,
-0.43301868438720703,
0.09053382277488708,
-0.3045250475406647,
-0.1461237519979477,
-0.16267018020153046,
-0.3373188376426697,
-0.7271891832351685,
-0.14536911249160767,
0.1310683935880661,
0.8455476760864258,
0.28279992938041687,
0.6007016897201538,
-0.6335687041282654,
-0.056087665259838104,
0.27280688285827637,
0.05994828790426254,
0.24762481451034546,
-0.7919092774391174,
-0.14496412873268127,
0.03897067904472351,
-0.3452933728694916,
-1.1459749937057495,
0.17039833962917328,
0.135881245136261,
0.5373745560646057,
0.4547329545021057,
0.02929645963013172,
0.8645505309104919,
-0.43961092829704285,
1.2354533672332764,
-0.3343748152256012,
-1.0535410642623901,
0.6010429859161377,
-0.3828209936618805,
0.4202854037284851,
0.4728597104549408,
0.30637243390083313,
-0.2919432520866394,
-0.34937864542007446,
-0.46988391876220703,
-0.6807625889778137,
0.9640860557556152,
0.03964884951710701,
0.34631383419036865,
-0.07957518845796585,
0.4608379304409027,
0.26363322138786316,
-0.06889103353023529,
-0.7105281352996826,
-0.1561264991760254,
-0.22957921028137207,
0.04524005949497223,
0.018576372414827347,
-0.49394482374191284,
-0.0950295627117157,
-0.15584121644496918,
0.5339877605438232,
-0.2231493890285492,
0.09031876921653748,
0.16772514581680298,
-0.46326425671577454,
0.28661784529685974,
0.4204053282737732,
0.7796118259429932,
0.6535145044326782,
0.15762072801589966,
-0.003900176379829645,
0.21121220290660858,
-0.14963431656360626,
0.11394904553890228,
-0.28353172540664673,
-0.3069709241390228,
-0.10437006503343582,
0.8715556263923645,
1.1206713914871216,
0.475202739238739,
-0.584237813949585,
0.5393050909042358,
0.10748320072889328,
0.2552914023399353,
-0.03930636867880821,
0.3136274516582489,
-0.36327940225601196,
0.2961824834346771,
0.3711458146572113,
0.06360772252082825,
0.16044023633003235,
-0.9309466481208801,
0.1465468555688858,
0.4047788679599762,
-0.30312955379486084,
-0.4974476099014282,
0.5194296836853027,
0.1655329018831253,
-0.3207664489746094,
0.8136847615242004,
-0.32394590973854065,
-0.534195065498352,
0.5271078944206238,
0.7281944155693054,
0.795350968837738,
-0.179881289601326,
0.20887112617492676,
0.49735623598098755,
0.4063279926776886,
-0.11008119583129883,
-0.05606802925467491,
-0.24730655550956726,
-0.5821544528007507,
-0.4145476520061493,
-0.36665040254592896,
-0.20817798376083374,
0.16262418031692505,
-0.48153501749038696,
0.4021213948726654,
-0.3102916479110718,
-0.04364246502518654,
-0.29125893115997314,
-0.0889246016740799,
-0.7705069780349731,
-0.006029665470123291,
-0.21162588894367218,
0.7870038151741028,
-0.9408445358276367,
0.5675446391105652,
0.5306392908096313,
-0.5943304300308228,
-0.8549155592918396,
0.02828621305525303,
0.23345360159873962,
-0.5646538138389587,
0.8008506894111633,
0.2670847773551941,
0.11416700482368469,
-0.154926598072052,
-0.6839141249656677,
-0.7965767979621887,
1.0731089115142822,
0.5123957395553589,
-0.2584626078605652,
-0.21297498047351837,
-0.12426096946001053,
0.5246961712837219,
-0.38582843542099,
0.6651515364646912,
0.6116009950637817,
0.32426121830940247,
-0.027943773195147514,
-1.0546220541000366,
0.1745789796113968,
-0.003651277394965291,
-0.021765630692243576,
-0.22466735541820526,
-0.492737740278244,
1.0009105205535889,
-0.30610042810440063,
-0.46810856461524963,
0.21874824166297913,
0.4553796052932739,
0.4859738051891327,
0.16308870911598206,
0.27861303091049194,
0.09037857502698898,
0.8756822347640991,
-0.20929327607154846,
1.3899236917495728,
-0.12909908592700958,
0.03955846652388573,
1.1777957677841187,
-0.08157846331596375,
0.6080474257469177,
0.4661926329135895,
0.1706731915473938,
0.7099136114120483,
0.6961285471916199,
0.07319372147321701,
0.36093807220458984,
0.13264375925064087,
0.03140205517411232,
-0.15682198107242584,
-0.14031048119068146,
-0.050182171165943146,
0.5999019145965576,
0.29436230659484863,
-0.3465893566608429,
-0.36743447184562683,
0.3060355484485626,
0.15063920617103577,
0.03660101816058159,
-0.4474729299545288,
0.7731454372406006,
-0.05528227984905243,
-0.8754655122756958,
0.5982319712638855,
-0.020863140001893044,
0.5238632559776306,
-0.4198005795478821,
-0.18750770390033722,
-0.2842605710029602,
-0.060108624398708344,
-0.13047073781490326,
-0.5350163578987122,
0.1571653038263321,
0.03692378103733063,
-0.1200215294957161,
-0.197515070438385,
0.6508910059928894,
-0.23657174408435822,
-0.11168507486581802,
0.09810839593410492,
0.3382697105407715,
0.22374780476093292,
-0.12175396829843521,
-0.5963404774665833,
0.16845257580280304,
-0.13075092434883118,
-0.34325507283210754,
0.41478168964385986,
0.45843684673309326,
-0.20157651603221893,
0.7643346786499023,
0.5284791588783264,
-0.15383708477020264,
-0.05035906657576561,
-0.15140126645565033,
0.7852751612663269,
-0.4874028265476227,
-0.3428340554237366,
-0.9777093529701233,
0.8928358554840088,
0.07514443248510361,
-0.47244420647621155,
0.9688683748245239,
0.4063962996006012,
0.9719545841217041,
-0.01438829954713583,
0.47568121552467346,
0.29048511385917664,
0.16122658550739288,
-0.674691379070282,
0.6243451833724976,
-0.49898073077201843,
0.6391834616661072,
-0.47191306948661804,
-0.6981592178344727,
0.03824787586927414,
0.40065377950668335,
-0.21731534600257874,
0.18913519382476807,
0.6110612154006958,
0.8633816242218018,
0.08534227311611176,
-0.013844515196979046,
0.3952626585960388,
0.28184059262275696,
0.3792780041694641,
0.32990366220474243,
0.9931719303131104,
-0.4927319586277008,
0.45760059356689453,
-0.1443670690059662,
-0.10604996979236603,
-0.19454115629196167,
-0.9268127679824829,
-1.0789172649383545,
-0.7393447756767273,
-0.2576861083507538,
-0.410297155380249,
0.014327622018754482,
0.954064667224884,
0.5444144606590271,
-0.5275692939758301,
-0.0680411085486412,
0.12093735486268997,
0.39437663555145264,
-0.26558399200439453,
-0.2674219608306885,
0.4790935516357422,
-0.6570928692817688,
-0.7611009478569031,
0.801545262336731,
0.13533931970596313,
0.2416336089372635,
-0.20493245124816895,
0.044304195791482925,
0.15181225538253784,
0.2649074196815491,
0.7979012727737427,
0.0573858767747879,
-0.8789026737213135,
-0.4063650965690613,
-0.011639832518994808,
-0.09356575459241867,
-0.15323349833488464,
0.776772677898407,
-1.1949982643127441,
0.49804064631462097,
0.6766796708106995,
0.6559053063392639,
0.14361372590065002,
0.23957529664039612,
0.6185272932052612,
-0.9682088494300842,
0.053155168890953064,
0.17828978598117828,
0.48413556814193726,
0.3677235543727875,
-0.4559847414493561,
0.2355869561433792,
0.2625422179698944,
-0.5412781238555908,
-1.0400407314300537,
0.22752946615219116,
-0.7464786767959595,
-0.6065754890441895,
1.2037315368652344,
-0.23289497196674347,
-0.3093871772289276,
-0.11846883594989777,
-0.3873263895511627,
0.2026219516992569,
-0.3296862542629242,
0.7535234689712524,
0.8743801116943359,
-0.24662785232067108,
-0.17615774273872375,
-0.30830061435699463,
0.6768052577972412,
0.3618184030056,
-0.48053601384162903,
0.1234474927186966,
0.7455142140388489,
0.3419836163520813,
-0.001770651899278164,
0.36529338359832764,
-0.12879280745983124,
0.4223397970199585,
0.04984920471906662,
-0.40257659554481506,
-0.29327481985092163,
-0.5139419436454773,
-0.868864893913269,
0.28337132930755615,
0.0019985877443104982,
0.07884003967046738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02053v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02053v2
|
BERTopic-Driven Stock Market Predictions: Unraveling Sentiment Insights
| 2024-04-02T15:50:10 | 2024-04-04T08:05:37 |
Enmin Zhu, Jerome Yen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, q-fin.ST
|
This paper explores the intersection of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and
financial analysis, focusing on the impact of sentiment analysis in stock price
prediction. We employ BERTopic, an advanced NLP technique, to analyze the
sentiment of topics derived from stock market comments. Our methodology
integrates this sentiment analysis with various deep learning models, renowned
for their effectiveness in time series and stock prediction tasks. Through
comprehensive experiments, we demonstrate that incorporating topic sentiment
notably enhances the performance of these models. The results indicate that
topics in stock market comments provide implicit, valuable insights into stock
market volatility and price trends. This study contributes to the field by
showcasing the potential of NLP in enriching financial analysis and opens up
avenues for further research into real-time sentiment analysis and the
exploration of emotional and contextual aspects of market sentiment. The
integration of advanced NLP techniques like BERTopic with traditional financial
analysis methods marks a step forward in developing more sophisticated tools
for understanding and predicting market behaviors.
|
[
-0.3466097116470337,
-0.5797098278999329,
-0.06635478883981705,
0.3942645490169525,
-0.3615908622741699,
0.491222083568573,
-0.25813156366348267,
-0.5924795269966125,
0.38798776268959045,
0.2859439253807068,
-0.8578715920448303,
-0.4498310089111328,
-0.45353251695632935,
-0.3040347397327423,
-0.33416643738746643,
1.2283380031585693,
0.4576275944709778,
0.3638087809085846,
0.020137930288910866,
0.3093109130859375,
-0.10740052163600922,
-0.8077221512794495,
-0.6241878867149353,
-0.056416504085063934,
0.35846826434135437,
-0.1298234760761261,
0.969072699546814,
0.04054754972457886,
0.635086178779602,
0.24309273064136505,
-0.10110881924629211,
-0.01881389692425728,
-0.009449983015656471,
0.3615192770957947,
0.18988291919231415,
-0.17102696001529694,
-0.5219423770904541,
0.14819121360778809,
0.2281142622232437,
0.8442326188087463,
-0.24797268211841583,
-0.06714428961277008,
0.22043165564537048,
0.6888834238052368,
-0.3121297061443329,
0.4709973633289337,
-0.5888291001319885,
0.462290495634079,
-0.27155616879463196,
-0.4182330071926117,
-0.48887670040130615,
-0.24245832860469818,
0.7392879128456116,
-0.3423461318016052,
0.10985668748617172,
0.09633729606866837,
0.8769545555114746,
0.14705796539783478,
0.048935625702142715,
-0.41441163420677185,
-0.6905328631401062,
1.041853666305542,
-0.9412025213241577,
0.15631161630153656,
0.13822445273399353,
0.2959333658218384,
-0.10254258662462234,
-0.5079601407051086,
-0.2160596251487732,
-0.024582017213106155,
0.14446796476840973,
0.2706109583377838,
-0.28995659947395325,
0.0095824571326375,
-0.09633851796388626,
0.37290307879447937,
-0.23737522959709167,
0.03757602721452713,
-0.5387477278709412,
0.19790275394916534,
0.7885733842849731,
-0.13164374232292175,
0.027551570907235146,
-0.4286755919456482,
-0.35726189613342285,
-0.07739473134279251,
-0.16223396360874176,
0.09638671576976776,
0.3859899938106537,
0.8244245052337646,
0.17780368030071259,
0.2656920254230499,
0.03837187960743904,
0.4666798710823059,
-0.11687012761831284,
0.14650575816631317,
0.4136539399623871,
0.23160485923290253,
-0.3486139476299286,
0.3211442828178406,
0.5660905838012695,
0.42703092098236084,
0.4905157685279846,
-0.10417065024375916,
-0.013655837625265121,
-0.32973146438598633,
0.5069090723991394,
-0.4829040467739105,
-0.24586819112300873,
0.3809606432914734,
-0.7959758639335632,
-0.6109428405761719,
0.40854567289352417,
-1.2621979713439941,
-0.387357234954834,
-0.42220497131347656,
0.03918299451470375,
-0.3563697636127472,
-0.05432254076004028,
0.18388469517230988,
-0.47079455852508545,
0.5160605907440186,
0.3362196087837219,
-0.8607988953590393,
0.31879326701164246,
1.121781826019287,
0.6603907346725464,
-0.043410543352365494,
0.002343880943953991,
-0.37558501958847046,
0.04842493683099747,
-0.32053300738334656,
0.8146220445632935,
-0.6127637028694153,
-0.49364957213401794,
0.22551974654197693,
-0.38578465580940247,
0.28413209319114685,
-0.2582411766052246,
0.37469977140426636,
-0.4933580160140991,
0.45303088426589966,
-0.4334171712398529,
-0.4934689402580261,
-0.5745054483413696,
0.15286271274089813,
-0.5528945922851562,
0.9109886884689331,
-0.3578595817089081,
-1.029709815979004,
0.7671698927879333,
-1.1120188236236572,
-0.5142971873283386,
0.07439567148685455,
-0.05535750463604927,
-0.1743210405111313,
0.14423999190330505,
0.5363449454307556,
0.7489217519760132,
-0.18985718488693237,
0.17121632397174835,
-0.7334913611412048,
-0.01815713383257389,
0.7720180749893188,
-0.4315454959869385,
0.3222019076347351,
0.20440931618213654,
-0.4273347854614258,
-0.13573473691940308,
-0.5080365538597107,
-0.1344628930091858,
-0.03266971558332443,
0.3096316456794739,
-0.431233286857605,
0.6041128039360046,
0.24745261669158936,
0.13938607275485992,
0.44883543252944946,
-0.43388721346855164,
0.3162871301174164,
-0.8411386013031006,
0.39398902654647827,
1.2037055492401123,
0.07672309130430222,
0.43370354175567627,
0.1612144112586975,
0.5124644637107849,
-0.09395986050367355,
0.4696907103061676,
0.24026599526405334,
-0.632646381855011,
-0.3811658024787903,
-0.09649928659200668,
0.31858763098716736,
0.7155985236167908,
0.03153855353593826,
0.3724985420703888,
0.165218323469162,
-0.44315576553344727,
-0.5231813192367554,
-0.13469359278678894,
-0.35390546917915344,
0.30211448669433594,
0.29890406131744385,
-0.2217293381690979,
-0.7486199140548706,
-0.948940098285675,
-0.38366377353668213,
0.010990695096552372,
-0.007172095589339733,
0.11523019522428513,
0.044935014098882675,
-0.26940247416496277,
1.0207945108413696,
-0.868843138217926,
-0.10923328250646591,
-0.25278374552726746,
0.7539107799530029,
0.7139149308204651,
0.06480352580547333,
0.560656726360321,
-0.6657325625419617,
-0.42598190903663635,
0.23750382661819458,
-0.5421625375747681,
0.21391935646533966,
-0.19073699414730072,
0.11377370357513428,
0.30387192964553833,
0.4868791401386261,
-0.3226848244667053,
0.410948783159256,
0.39748743176460266,
-0.27250203490257263,
0.1911146491765976,
-0.04324663430452347,
-0.3632192313671112,
-1.0865060091018677,
-0.07293128222227097,
0.39346131682395935,
0.08696626126766205,
-0.4394863247871399,
-0.33041656017303467,
-0.7460343241691589,
-0.13973262906074524,
0.011677371338009834,
0.3290911316871643,
-0.010093867778778076,
-0.49507832527160645,
-0.5138553977012634,
0.006420999299734831,
-0.24858297407627106,
0.26986029744148254,
0.15387924015522003,
0.7607422471046448,
0.7812951803207397,
-0.18248987197875977,
0.29172483086586,
0.04692131280899048,
-0.2655612826347351,
-0.031108487397432327,
-0.682919979095459,
-0.1921743005514145,
-0.11543738842010498,
-0.04019772261381149,
-1.3150396347045898,
-0.012499374337494373,
0.27249154448509216,
-0.7341222167015076,
0.10558439791202545,
0.3889898657798767,
-0.41111183166503906,
-0.21595560014247894,
-0.6629139184951782,
-0.3661839962005615,
0.33461061120033264,
-0.24758291244506836,
0.5797131657600403,
0.2797389626502991,
-0.8402981162071228,
-1.0411783456802368,
-0.8338225483894348,
0.13288620114326477,
-0.00612859008833766,
-0.41535237431526184,
0.15713079273700714,
0.07808049023151398,
-0.6361086964607239,
-0.14719630777835846,
0.07508508861064911,
-0.1096918061375618,
0.1781834065914154,
0.31350424885749817,
0.7633975744247437,
0.02855110913515091,
0.3226243257522583,
0.06801702082157135,
-0.2764546275138855,
0.35686588287353516,
-0.2740270793437958,
0.48710906505584717,
-0.3599399924278259,
0.19046533107757568,
-0.28560376167297363,
0.4119971990585327,
0.5230250954627991,
0.051201727241277695,
0.6100363731384277,
0.35962021350860596,
-0.0925392135977745,
-0.3006919324398041,
-0.324846088886261,
-0.19176509976387024,
-0.547274112701416,
0.23381611704826355,
0.212579607963562,
-0.7391433119773865,
0.5127597451210022,
0.09675315022468567,
0.28628769516944885,
0.7097390294075012,
0.5786756873130798,
-0.5163758993148804,
1.1181648969650269,
0.7080274820327759,
-0.39509305357933044,
0.5678697228431702,
-0.0735199972987175,
0.7804000973701477,
-0.19983868300914764,
-0.12232332676649094,
-0.22093388438224792,
-0.7283327579498291,
-0.830100953578949,
-0.27705758810043335,
0.11292325705289841,
-0.36336374282836914,
0.09245111048221588,
0.012994380667805672,
-0.6882736682891846,
0.05074077099561691,
0.7466134428977966,
-0.17147919535636902,
-0.04453336074948311,
0.05474778264760971,
-0.11534170806407928,
-0.4007909595966339,
-0.3261227607727051,
-0.4449458420276642,
1.2697628736495972,
0.6615964770317078,
0.49831658601760864,
-0.44932758808135986,
0.4573374092578888,
0.8034271001815796,
0.2332262098789215,
-0.8948878049850464,
0.4981442391872406,
-0.538098931312561,
-0.5135912299156189,
-0.21552520990371704,
-0.10378476232290268,
-0.42014074325561523,
0.0037481095641851425,
-0.2944747507572174,
-0.40013450384140015,
0.476788192987442,
-0.23522356152534485,
-0.7058150768280029,
0.0867592990398407,
-0.41220834851264954,
0.6110333204269409,
-0.3593934178352356,
0.026228919625282288,
-0.38784530758857727,
-0.5404701828956604,
-0.005432839039713144,
0.026148710399866104,
0.32177120447158813,
-0.3403668999671936,
-0.057937171310186386,
0.7971697449684143,
-0.33392322063446045,
1.0552875995635986,
-0.25650012493133545,
-0.28011012077331543,
-0.051569320261478424,
-0.3729502856731415,
0.22546085715293884,
0.30915307998657227,
-0.2930012047290802,
0.13301871716976166,
-0.16292113065719604,
-0.41182398796081543,
-0.4378131330013275,
0.5077677369117737,
-0.8719425201416016,
-0.06897038966417313,
-0.7988759875297546,
-0.47584930062294006,
-0.41867440938949585,
-0.3727128803730011,
0.14884015917778015,
-0.10617288947105408,
-0.24471020698547363,
0.00888040754944086,
0.4026089906692505,
-0.06966692209243774,
0.8248836994171143,
0.02098488062620163,
-0.24062824249267578,
-0.7099083662033081,
0.8117284178733826,
0.1695186197757721,
-0.2650090157985687,
0.47006410360336304,
0.1681375950574875,
-0.2209756076335907,
-0.38941124081611633,
0.33455029129981995,
-0.06196489930152893,
-0.6073530316352844,
-0.035178959369659424,
-0.44215136766433716,
-0.06384241580963135,
-0.5931013226509094,
-0.6106780171394348,
-0.5425109267234802,
-0.45967811346054077,
-0.5077707767486572,
-0.5577970743179321,
0.5600298643112183,
0.6560757756233215,
-0.2754572629928589,
0.1453188806772232,
-0.8518304824829102,
0.16817894577980042,
0.7205431461334229,
0.27472180128097534,
0.14378711581230164,
-0.09977906942367554,
-0.2119835615158081,
-0.033830076456069946,
-0.23043189942836761,
-0.6747846603393555,
0.9050062298774719,
0.02489708736538887,
0.2902768552303314,
0.7845887541770935,
0.012236355803906918,
0.39120081067085266,
0.06966285407543182,
0.833206832408905,
0.13898096978664398,
-0.9912553429603577,
0.8762111067771912,
-0.373079389333725,
-0.05708771571516991,
0.43764883279800415,
0.37388166785240173,
-0.5519700646400452,
-0.5174897909164429,
-0.5779432058334351,
-1.143930435180664,
0.4524376392364502,
-0.050945181399583817,
0.1691632866859436,
-0.04144590348005295,
0.4200350046157837,
0.400160551071167,
0.6317070722579956,
-0.7667121887207031,
-0.05413811281323433,
-0.3763572573661804,
-0.1423962265253067,
0.02835184335708618,
-0.5018652081489563,
0.0814780592918396,
-0.5085362195968628,
0.5507181882858276,
-0.13132688403129578,
0.3488297164440155,
0.031572211533784866,
0.529583752155304,
-0.11923450231552124,
0.10856243222951889,
0.33746445178985596,
0.5637679100036621,
-0.7527310848236084,
-0.45318731665611267,
0.06655977666378021,
-0.07360566407442093,
-0.630643904209137,
0.4216291606426239,
0.026181019842624664,
0.24075132608413696,
0.360391229391098,
0.5773196816444397,
0.4155668020248413,
-0.9744300246238708,
0.5212040543556213,
-0.04278792440891266,
-0.2373303472995758,
-0.7793009281158447,
-0.23707711696624756,
-0.24909943342208862,
0.5082984566688538,
0.8740290403366089,
0.19431038200855255,
0.505081832408905,
-0.7745492458343506,
0.31520819664001465,
0.44033122062683105,
-0.6574282646179199,
-0.4464462697505951,
0.5260804891586304,
0.2231859564781189,
0.4783238470554352,
0.630399763584137,
0.2622220814228058,
-0.5958870053291321,
0.52299565076828,
-0.1516599804162979,
1.5108107328414917,
-0.05025702714920044,
0.3810971677303314,
-0.011370868422091007,
0.16564929485321045,
0.11552444100379944,
0.715897262096405,
0.0650099664926529,
-0.764614462852478,
-0.9261173009872437,
-0.6998094916343689,
-0.8334450125694275,
-0.222109854221344,
-0.8036007285118103,
0.2275688499212265,
-0.8007394671440125,
-0.37728267908096313,
0.5995461344718933,
0.114073745906353,
-0.08222686499357224,
0.5005635023117065,
0.588038444519043,
0.6944084167480469,
-0.6520867347717285,
0.5590260028839111,
0.6837592124938965,
-0.30033496022224426,
-0.11946645379066467,
0.2859179973602295,
-0.1962457001209259,
-0.7138277292251587,
0.9665549993515015,
0.23302997648715973,
0.03820693492889404,
-0.7024321556091309,
-0.7934569716453552,
-0.49567997455596924,
0.48990947008132935,
-0.051711320877075195,
-0.43781474232673645,
-0.0759674683213234,
0.10299167037010193,
0.6822327971458435,
-0.46937090158462524,
-0.13758066296577454,
0.4400458335876465,
0.5961968898773193,
0.3143538236618042,
-0.404096394777298,
-0.5468339920043945,
-0.40946200489997864,
-0.14514866471290588,
0.32056668400764465,
-0.43459993600845337,
0.9387527704238892,
0.017140889540314674,
0.243009552359581,
-0.16164357960224152,
1.000584602355957,
-0.15385578572750092,
0.4491739571094513,
0.22210478782653809,
0.3610117435455322,
0.6334620714187622,
-0.05209241434931755,
0.8972114324569702,
-0.6064667701721191,
0.5014268159866333,
0.729311466217041,
-0.37637415528297424,
1.3602848052978516,
0.5566344261169434,
-0.30830851197242737,
0.6584956645965576,
0.5962249040603638,
-0.3659001886844635,
0.5878632068634033,
0.15640583634376526,
-0.19582432508468628,
-0.28347206115722656,
0.05931361764669418,
-0.31405124068260193,
0.7333876490592957,
0.42082834243774414,
-0.5009174942970276,
0.015237661078572273,
0.02748628705739975,
0.009902031160891056,
0.01160475704818964,
-0.3239179849624634,
0.7118499875068665,
0.048656314611434937,
-0.09007888287305832,
-0.3213527202606201,
-0.0058608888648450375,
0.9968345761299133,
-0.6318299770355225,
0.21316714584827423,
-0.06834249943494797,
0.24385176599025726,
0.13223017752170563,
-0.8067577481269836,
0.7528289556503296,
-0.11437395960092545,
-0.20861250162124634,
-0.6046900749206543,
0.7801226377487183,
0.07940241694450378,
-0.6643583178520203,
0.47864121198654175,
0.2181854099035263,
-0.38384389877319336,
-0.3754670023918152,
-0.7343772649765015,
-0.40868812799453735,
0.231327086687088,
-0.5477141737937927,
0.3061971962451935,
0.5400111675262451,
0.7355175018310547,
0.7211301326751709,
0.8793633580207825,
-0.10363911837339401,
-0.21082250773906708,
-0.1926622986793518,
0.8858691453933716,
-1.1522051095962524,
-0.6688123941421509,
-0.7983828783035278,
0.35432565212249756,
-0.36745208501815796,
-0.35454678535461426,
0.6145697832107544,
0.4255520701408386,
0.2647015154361725,
-0.27477994561195374,
1.0612080097198486,
0.3465474545955658,
0.9032284021377563,
-0.30802467465400696,
0.7056102156639099,
-0.33473795652389526,
0.24860049784183502,
-0.46053850650787354,
-0.6968845129013062,
-0.42879295349121094,
0.6455479264259338,
-0.742915153503418,
-0.19462037086486816,
0.2594943344593048,
0.21870212256908417,
0.34963566064834595,
0.5654911994934082,
-0.010857904329895973,
0.23228169977664948,
-0.06771835684776306,
-0.08973973989486694,
0.7625717520713806,
-0.2612476050853729,
0.29624778032302856,
-0.6954956650733948,
0.09120713919401169,
-0.6397902369499207,
-0.9839544296264648,
-0.712008535861969,
-0.23181554675102234,
-0.47513076663017273,
-0.02647247537970543,
-0.04493673890829086,
0.9842473864555359,
0.19897571206092834,
-0.9916107654571533,
-0.4684762954711914,
0.02711135894060135,
-0.11529703438282013,
-0.3542267978191376,
-0.42649853229522705,
0.41480308771133423,
-0.7384304404258728,
-0.7122210264205933,
0.2735607326030731,
0.8092063069343567,
0.04443200305104256,
-0.5270859599113464,
0.2627672553062439,
0.05648035556077957,
0.5917667746543884,
0.8454549312591553,
0.20343080163002014,
-0.47467276453971863,
0.04634309932589531,
0.09744756668806076,
0.12441647797822952,
-0.11800413578748703,
0.7016867995262146,
-0.5012599229812622,
0.2843427360057831,
0.59561687707901,
0.40262141823768616,
0.11931530386209488,
-0.011564372107386589,
1.0469344854354858,
-0.7546476721763611,
0.41145411133766174,
0.6057277321815491,
0.29870840907096863,
-0.11876803636550903,
-0.44282829761505127,
0.3060351610183716,
0.1061689704656601,
-0.32384809851646423,
-0.5632345080375671,
-0.32564857602119446,
-1.2100249528884888,
-0.7847774028778076,
0.7175318598747253,
0.3071329891681671,
-0.20274388790130615,
0.29216790199279785,
-0.2127692699432373,
-0.25150153040885925,
-0.8463592529296875,
0.9760469198226929,
0.7636697292327881,
-0.151981920003891,
-0.18169543147087097,
-0.7557432651519775,
0.44620341062545776,
0.5157495141029358,
-0.5514583587646484,
0.31708261370658875,
0.14858411252498627,
-0.46867722272872925,
0.006026636343449354,
0.1780751496553421,
0.11121521890163422,
0.2688179612159729,
-0.1609625220298767,
0.2548708915710449,
0.4151025414466858,
-0.15322557091712952,
-0.2226029932498932,
0.6773794293403625,
0.05778959393501282,
-0.40954387187957764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02043v1
|
Ukrainian Texts Classification: Exploration of Cross-lingual Knowledge Transfer Approaches
| 2024-04-02T15:37:09 | 2024-04-02T15:37:09 |
Daryna Dementieva, Valeriia Khylenko, Georg Groh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the extensive amount of labeled datasets in the NLP text
classification field, the persistent imbalance in data availability across
various languages remains evident. Ukrainian, in particular, stands as a
language that still can benefit from the continued refinement of cross-lingual
methodologies. Due to our knowledge, there is a tremendous lack of Ukrainian
corpora for typical text classification tasks. In this work, we leverage the
state-of-the-art advances in NLP, exploring cross-lingual knowledge transfer
methods avoiding manual data curation: large multilingual encoders and
translation systems, LLMs, and language adapters. We test the approaches on
three text classification tasks -- toxicity classification, formality
classification, and natural language inference -- providing the "recipe" for
the optimal setups.
|
[
0.060965750366449356,
-0.325809508562088,
0.39808234572410583,
0.2246163934469223,
-0.12154518812894821,
0.4130461812019348,
0.05969249829649925,
-0.773704469203949,
0.031057240441441536,
0.5446901321411133,
-0.32188406586647034,
-0.7930281758308411,
-0.5125036835670471,
0.27415162324905396,
-0.24764257669448853,
0.9632250666618347,
-0.22319883108139038,
0.45717117190361023,
-0.07039234787225723,
-0.2258128672838211,
-0.45463985204696655,
-0.771767258644104,
-0.4083402454853058,
-0.3477979004383087,
0.33648449182510376,
0.7122650146484375,
0.19108350574970245,
0.24779415130615234,
0.40920621156692505,
0.31153786182403564,
0.09363727271556854,
-0.035471998155117035,
-0.03823864459991455,
0.14138303697109222,
-0.5332047939300537,
-0.8829165697097778,
0.11281638592481613,
-0.15762832760810852,
0.420790433883667,
0.682316243648529,
-0.06963101774454117,
0.06347180902957916,
-0.15931418538093567,
0.639748215675354,
-0.6722732186317444,
-0.07214609533548355,
-0.6140481233596802,
0.621850311756134,
-0.24937447905540466,
-0.2545439898967743,
-0.6232433319091797,
-0.3387916386127472,
0.17280042171478271,
-0.7002406120300293,
-0.045033227652311325,
0.17275716364383698,
0.5023159980773926,
-0.11321655660867691,
-0.6107375621795654,
-0.6820623874664307,
-0.6900051832199097,
0.9130445122718811,
-0.4647519886493683,
0.44504889845848083,
0.3777354657649994,
0.19250255823135376,
0.12152092158794403,
-0.7514982223510742,
-0.07065623998641968,
0.08219818770885468,
-0.046080026775598526,
0.4029267728328705,
-0.312347948551178,
-0.23534433543682098,
-0.0699913427233696,
0.15227444469928741,
-0.390424519777298,
0.4528268277645111,
-0.55220627784729,
-0.6143196821212769,
0.38831597566604614,
0.10960129648447037,
0.5673298835754395,
-0.264451265335083,
-0.5453115701675415,
0.20201918482780457,
-0.5338047742843628,
0.002973073162138462,
0.4155183434486389,
0.0901472419500351,
0.05847391486167908,
0.6932021975517273,
-0.2746596336364746,
0.4926885962486267,
0.025198088958859444,
-0.10184250771999359,
0.25073307752609253,
-0.8889763951301575,
-0.2593350410461426,
0.32038256525993347,
0.7027921676635742,
0.47653791308403015,
-0.03235231339931488,
-0.3964008390903473,
0.25885728001594543,
0.07174142450094223,
0.3017754554748535,
-0.6146877408027649,
0.021539103239774704,
-0.008249343372881413,
-0.4539547264575958,
-0.4602707326412201,
-0.22951480746269226,
-1.1673860549926758,
-0.2732103765010834,
-0.11807476729154587,
0.27889952063560486,
-0.24165666103363037,
-0.018873900175094604,
0.3900691270828247,
-0.08608246594667435,
0.06428497284650803,
0.2583877742290497,
-1.1214007139205933,
0.4125770926475525,
0.39702677726745605,
0.9378989934921265,
-0.2829892337322235,
-0.06252574175596237,
-0.5287882685661316,
0.0656295195221901,
-0.4209865927696228,
0.8257378339767456,
-0.33689025044441223,
-0.24040722846984863,
0.2949680685997009,
0.1929778903722763,
0.03065178357064724,
-0.619966447353363,
0.7653610110282898,
-0.34157735109329224,
0.4930422902107239,
-0.3480222225189209,
-0.4059116840362549,
-0.23514829576015472,
0.269159197807312,
-0.3977964222431183,
1.1574182510375977,
0.16424356400966644,
-1.090707778930664,
0.4619641900062561,
-0.3896885812282562,
-0.4718369245529175,
0.04150424152612686,
0.2907436490058899,
-0.037357646971940994,
-0.08958938717842102,
-0.21100546419620514,
0.6718364953994751,
-0.2718014717102051,
0.18829523026943207,
-0.2211940735578537,
0.009841961786150932,
0.22851869463920593,
-0.01863461546599865,
0.8546627759933472,
0.2640068531036377,
-0.29942774772644043,
0.0785183236002922,
-0.7542436122894287,
-0.12570951879024506,
-0.41891542077064514,
-0.5639543533325195,
-0.748945951461792,
-0.2160923182964325,
0.3827027976512909,
0.6037076115608215,
0.15265263617038727,
-0.718803346157074,
0.1929876059293747,
-0.3968254029750824,
0.2851974368095398,
0.31928789615631104,
-0.1743346005678177,
1.0147022008895874,
-0.4939485192298889,
0.7296827435493469,
0.15564163029193878,
0.160890594124794,
0.23913590610027313,
-0.5170665979385376,
-0.7010617852210999,
0.20161181688308716,
0.3946168124675751,
1.0931435823440552,
-1.1031972169876099,
0.4773293435573578,
-0.18778790533542633,
-0.8446606397628784,
-0.5148460268974304,
0.15143758058547974,
0.33415454626083374,
0.5494741201400757,
0.45887672901153564,
-0.11799275130033493,
-0.7027551531791687,
-0.968777060508728,
-0.06745130568742752,
-0.29557907581329346,
0.13623981177806854,
0.1311209499835968,
0.45209801197052,
-0.19224098324775696,
0.34169721603393555,
-0.10433915257453918,
-0.32945510745048523,
-0.33787021040916443,
0.21261312067508698,
-0.2389950156211853,
0.39455902576446533,
0.7313184142112732,
-0.5546234846115112,
-0.7349281907081604,
0.5552315711975098,
-0.6576546430587769,
-0.5479731559753418,
-0.020053593441843987,
-0.35428687930107117,
0.5479980707168579,
0.8140403628349304,
-0.3127058446407318,
0.1160430833697319,
0.735115647315979,
-0.3714165687561035,
0.6867879033088684,
0.05769367888569832,
0.07422134280204773,
-1.253122329711914,
0.18739202618598938,
-0.012950649484992027,
-0.2451259195804596,
-0.8637898564338684,
-0.37228330969810486,
0.07193252444267273,
0.32378360629081726,
-0.4033361077308655,
0.7510972023010254,
-0.33595263957977295,
-0.09342486411333084,
0.021393513306975365,
0.07900124043226242,
-0.06143123656511307,
0.06828690320253372,
0.29603514075279236,
0.403729110956192,
0.6760278344154358,
-0.40625935792922974,
0.39362746477127075,
0.2415374517440796,
-0.3391674757003784,
0.8290865421295166,
0.055448997765779495,
-0.28884878754615784,
0.16733308136463165,
0.10713477432727814,
-0.786206841468811,
0.09138079732656479,
0.6701719760894775,
-0.34339243173599243,
0.27951905131340027,
-0.47687041759490967,
-0.605104923248291,
0.02159254439175129,
-0.17995983362197876,
0.2019871175289154,
0.3515552282333374,
-0.3763987720012665,
0.5809807777404785,
0.3673044443130493,
-0.5019246339797974,
-0.8815011978149414,
-0.91544508934021,
0.18260006606578827,
-0.5501968860626221,
-0.2897436022758484,
0.38327983021736145,
-0.15994073450565338,
-0.3627482056617737,
-0.00719556026160717,
-0.056892987340688705,
-0.3957095742225647,
0.03402822092175484,
-0.08640789240598679,
0.1694338470697403,
-0.11228571832180023,
0.43762627243995667,
0.24754537642002106,
0.0935162678360939,
0.2523498833179474,
-0.28376707434654236,
0.2983531951904297,
0.03365076333284378,
-0.02053990587592125,
-0.25206810235977173,
0.3891165554523468,
0.7207756042480469,
-0.01144576445221901,
0.6023753881454468,
0.7510498762130737,
-0.3294684588909149,
-0.2163858413696289,
-0.3838197886943817,
0.1810804307460785,
-0.40118107199668884,
0.25077587366104126,
-0.2308933436870575,
-0.5682773590087891,
0.7726282477378845,
-0.19304978847503662,
0.0409725047647953,
0.43157094717025757,
0.38570404052734375,
0.15875424444675446,
0.6378816962242126,
0.5614462494850159,
-0.2545011341571808,
0.37519562244415283,
0.0023384783416986465,
-0.17770439386367798,
-0.5548158288002014,
-0.466367244720459,
-0.8967859148979187,
-0.11109154671430588,
-0.5811551213264465,
-0.36547473073005676,
-0.14226922392845154,
-0.13177169859409332,
0.11480758339166641,
0.17854616045951843,
-0.277635395526886,
0.3124402165412903,
0.40966707468032837,
-0.00012094709381926805,
0.6092652082443237,
0.04672832041978836,
-0.4638776481151581,
-0.268398255109787,
-0.9678077697753906,
-0.44410377740859985,
0.9928879737854004,
0.20039263367652893,
0.6380258202552795,
0.05380900204181671,
0.575566828250885,
-0.023551763966679573,
0.5984450578689575,
-0.97479647397995,
0.3343561291694641,
-0.2757319509983063,
-0.6528732776641846,
-0.09553927183151245,
-0.47147902846336365,
-0.9375216364860535,
0.18503858149051666,
-0.45497193932533264,
-0.6591386795043945,
0.11281449347734451,
-0.2910822629928589,
0.14020971953868866,
0.4706275463104248,
-0.7217237949371338,
0.815830647945404,
-0.42029398679733276,
-0.23543477058410645,
0.031933970749378204,
-0.5662422180175781,
0.44593268632888794,
-0.4905572533607483,
0.6330863237380981,
0.17395806312561035,
-0.3768354654312134,
0.8712111711502075,
-0.1512538194656372,
0.7836131453514099,
-0.06863594800233841,
-0.22497549653053284,
-0.05242979899048805,
0.0792006105184555,
0.11550886183977127,
-0.012106373906135559,
0.03515372425317764,
0.036245644092559814,
0.19482482969760895,
-0.3092275857925415,
-0.39119651913642883,
0.5365866422653198,
-0.5079115033149719,
0.02292952500283718,
-0.46708133816719055,
-0.3939593434333801,
-0.25154799222946167,
0.359183669090271,
0.7121266722679138,
0.16437964141368866,
-0.19200144708156586,
0.29789039492607117,
0.5491371750831604,
-0.4990614056587219,
0.13588519394397736,
0.70742267370224,
-0.6066395044326782,
-0.31273138523101807,
0.6117221117019653,
0.3007625341415405,
0.4216417968273163,
0.62086021900177,
0.15900816023349762,
-0.30306774377822876,
-0.8510844707489014,
-0.4687047302722931,
0.01284842099994421,
-0.9853538274765015,
-0.3285094201564789,
-0.6215305924415588,
-0.1837022751569748,
-0.21951068937778473,
-0.375741183757782,
-0.34033095836639404,
-0.2984228730201721,
-0.4917747974395752,
-0.2268965244293213,
0.2615295946598053,
0.7599678635597229,
-0.19926810264587402,
0.1699933111667633,
-0.9741201400756836,
0.11623501032590866,
0.07849431037902832,
0.39934226870536804,
-0.26704418659210205,
-0.4542173743247986,
-0.38184595108032227,
-0.17458787560462952,
-0.13532499969005585,
-1.1665923595428467,
0.5210320949554443,
-0.020267317071557045,
0.7040238976478577,
0.02216155454516411,
0.13959285616874695,
0.10830184817314148,
-0.3239130973815918,
0.42721498012542725,
0.3076695203781128,
-0.8942230939865112,
0.3141702711582184,
-0.31303030252456665,
0.28318020701408386,
0.6032446622848511,
0.7311512231826782,
-0.893288254737854,
-0.37920087575912476,
-0.5245514512062073,
-0.6693968176841736,
0.5861501097679138,
0.13070105016231537,
-0.04559839516878128,
0.3356838822364807,
0.14798599481582642,
0.3222339451313019,
-0.11712507903575897,
-0.7630013227462769,
-0.12424881011247635,
-0.10917118191719055,
-0.48481035232543945,
0.02587769366800785,
0.06964809447526932,
0.061073288321495056,
-0.24349474906921387,
0.6392261385917664,
-0.14564728736877441,
-0.03369789943099022,
0.34909361600875854,
-0.45415082573890686,
-0.17010900378227234,
0.521457314491272,
0.5470996499061584,
0.4362674355506897,
-0.014973164536058903,
0.22342802584171295,
0.4942181408405304,
-0.7429397702217102,
0.4090307950973511,
0.0607612282037735,
-0.373991996049881,
0.21222271025180817,
0.216438427567482,
0.42538705468177795,
0.608636736869812,
-0.6605954766273499,
0.2096603810787201,
-0.23065988719463348,
-0.5582863092422485,
-0.07711315900087357,
-0.17208725214004517,
0.27854272723197937,
0.18807435035705566,
0.333047091960907,
0.0781526044011116,
0.34423908591270447,
-0.6525693535804749,
0.09975913166999817,
0.21995851397514343,
-0.4047536253929138,
-0.3467904329299927,
0.09928552806377411,
0.22762876749038696,
-0.06330349296331406,
0.23806129395961761,
-0.047939665615558624,
-0.7532644271850586,
0.45461714267730713,
0.5116119980812073,
0.649229884147644,
-0.3032619059085846,
0.5732868313789368,
0.45569342374801636,
0.3881355822086334,
-0.1719987839460373,
0.26404038071632385,
0.21951419115066528,
-0.8792201280593872,
-0.46921220421791077,
-0.6502687931060791,
-0.5696513056755066,
0.3095288574695587,
-0.6833223700523376,
0.2499636560678482,
-0.37896475195884705,
-0.028505025431513786,
0.226532444357872,
0.2013690173625946,
-0.45502349734306335,
-0.05369463935494423,
-0.06554508954286575,
0.9861212968826294,
-1.1824790239334106,
0.6890342235565186,
0.8409781455993652,
0.003685120027512312,
-0.15673890709877014,
-0.3821509778499603,
-0.040916621685028076,
-0.39250344038009644,
0.803601861000061,
0.16985906660556793,
-0.019726654514670372,
0.05234752595424652,
-0.24688860774040222,
-0.7408856749534607,
0.7318665981292725,
0.1225128099322319,
-0.46554163098335266,
0.030028613284230232,
0.04086427763104439,
0.729921817779541,
-0.22142860293388367,
-0.2304142862558365,
0.3273293673992157,
0.7324995398521423,
-0.17557141184806824,
-1.1192141771316528,
-0.005826791748404503,
-0.44038915634155273,
-0.5198817849159241,
0.15420857071876526,
-0.21116624772548676,
0.2908307909965515,
0.10636253654956818,
-0.1753247082233429,
0.10462956875562668,
0.24541719257831573,
-0.08243245631456375,
0.520918607711792,
0.2929069399833679,
0.4941810667514801,
0.6910301446914673,
0.03861266374588013,
0.587774395942688,
0.13575483858585358,
0.01579192653298378,
0.8512177467346191,
-0.2647958993911743,
0.8121148943901062,
0.3098202347755432,
-0.1952008306980133,
0.5996052622795105,
0.7314255833625793,
-0.11338205635547638,
0.4646751880645752,
0.21581223607063293,
-0.23700708150863647,
-0.005745658650994301,
-0.2986666262149811,
-0.16034550964832306,
0.610666036605835,
0.5003408193588257,
-0.31129565834999084,
-0.288947731256485,
0.3260422945022583,
0.08806012570858002,
0.031689468771219254,
-0.4387684166431427,
0.8868438601493835,
-0.06698650121688843,
-0.7447529435157776,
0.17492996156215668,
0.1022089421749115,
0.9306068420410156,
-0.49751725792884827,
0.16128955781459808,
-0.12805673480033875,
0.13908053934574127,
-0.23606431484222412,
-0.8271725177764893,
0.5854995846748352,
-0.03068186528980732,
-0.11853886395692825,
-0.39457058906555176,
1.1906583309173584,
-0.6149361729621887,
-0.5133805871009827,
0.6136773824691772,
0.567826509475708,
0.1758449822664261,
0.213704451918602,
-0.6786519289016724,
-0.3411675691604614,
-0.12108825147151947,
0.08717669546604156,
0.4660610556602478,
0.6815732717514038,
-0.13129305839538574,
0.6690138578414917,
0.6799590587615967,
0.4095848500728607,
0.36284881830215454,
-0.20157457888126373,
0.5195558667182922,
-0.6139698624610901,
-0.4256957471370697,
-0.6473776698112488,
0.29712820053100586,
0.052908532321453094,
-0.31857770681381226,
0.871242344379425,
0.7172693014144897,
0.9564229249954224,
-0.16370511054992676,
0.9684444069862366,
0.2071031779050827,
0.4206206798553467,
-0.9063295125961304,
0.66093510389328,
-0.411896288394928,
-0.13902580738067627,
-0.19934172928333282,
-0.5537664890289307,
-0.4382440447807312,
0.4440045952796936,
-0.034197770059108734,
-0.17834827303886414,
0.9016790390014648,
0.28128963708877563,
0.005930136423557997,
-0.13572955131530762,
0.16348721086978912,
0.13864096999168396,
-0.08415771275758743,
0.5653448700904846,
0.9425368309020996,
-0.3708972930908203,
0.711199164390564,
-0.45570340752601624,
-0.030942996963858604,
-0.31852996349334717,
-0.7595469355583191,
-0.8362671732902527,
-0.8177636861801147,
-0.1426263451576233,
-0.3187789022922516,
-0.054738134145736694,
0.5010721683502197,
0.6063537001609802,
-0.6511460542678833,
-0.1559746414422989,
-0.17370478808879852,
0.2102043628692627,
0.007411826401948929,
-0.2348097711801529,
0.006169105414301157,
-0.3951287567615509,
-0.621396541595459,
0.17033573985099792,
0.16879069805145264,
0.4373547434806824,
-0.27796512842178345,
0.04107527807354927,
-0.4189473092556,
-0.15408708155155182,
0.6629169583320618,
0.2361823171377182,
-0.5021591186523438,
-0.02859729714691639,
0.452725350856781,
-0.2015657275915146,
0.05463176965713501,
0.7559097409248352,
-0.5722341537475586,
0.45538002252578735,
0.7653260231018066,
0.6408533453941345,
0.48096367716789246,
-0.25340861082077026,
0.5694168210029602,
-0.6732397079467773,
-0.08998198062181473,
0.3086092174053192,
0.3470287322998047,
0.5277078151702881,
-0.2838514447212219,
0.45159175992012024,
0.2667320966720581,
-0.49728426337242126,
-0.7651337385177612,
0.11206154525279999,
-0.9742740392684937,
-0.5941169261932373,
1.172192096710205,
-0.11030061542987823,
-0.018379786983132362,
-0.830528199672699,
-0.38075798749923706,
0.32942187786102295,
-0.043846964836120605,
0.7785450220108032,
1.209523320198059,
0.291440486907959,
-0.21111157536506653,
-0.9195626974105835,
0.6300029754638672,
0.32725170254707336,
-1.497780203819275,
0.05737309902906418,
0.4702678620815277,
0.40989401936531067,
0.47335875034332275,
0.5663065314292908,
-0.19821065664291382,
0.14447352290153503,
-0.20848655700683594,
0.08790291845798492,
0.4734058380126953,
-0.45937517285346985,
-0.2906543016433716,
-0.053093262016773224,
-0.13953951001167297,
0.20967021584510803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02037v1
|
MultiParaDetox: Extending Text Detoxification with Parallel Data to New Languages
| 2024-04-02T15:32:32 | 2024-04-02T15:32:32 |
Daryna Dementieva, Nikolay Babakov, Alexander Panchenko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text detoxification is a textual style transfer (TST) task where a text is
paraphrased from a toxic surface form, e.g. featuring rude words, to the
neutral register. Recently, text detoxification methods found their
applications in various task such as detoxification of Large Language Models
(LLMs) (Leong et al., 2023; He et al., 2024; Tang et al., 2023) and toxic
speech combating in social networks (Deng et al., 2023; Mun et al., 2023;
Agarwal et al., 2023). All these applications are extremely important to ensure
safe communication in modern digital worlds. However, the previous approaches
for parallel text detoxification corpora collection -- ParaDetox (Logacheva et
al., 2022) and APPADIA (Atwell et al., 2022) -- were explored only in
monolingual setup. In this work, we aim to extend ParaDetox pipeline to
multiple languages presenting MultiParaDetox to automate parallel
detoxification corpus collection for potentially any language. Then, we
experiment with different text detoxification models -- from unsupervised
baselines to LLMs and fine-tuned models on the presented parallel corpora --
showing the great benefit of parallel corpus presence to obtain
state-of-the-art text detoxification models for any language.
|
[
-0.27466490864753723,
-0.6935453414916992,
0.7142203450202942,
0.34156468510627747,
-0.33661192655563354,
0.2645486295223236,
-0.20754128694534302,
-0.15973331034183502,
0.08468446135520935,
0.789654552936554,
-0.30255407094955444,
-1.0562607049942017,
-0.6469202637672424,
0.3727371394634247,
-0.6468184590339661,
1.2392140626907349,
-0.055839139968156815,
-0.26655998826026917,
0.11406978219747543,
-0.39750146865844727,
-0.16427581012248993,
-0.6142148375511169,
-0.8616666793823242,
-0.0474705696105957,
0.6474751234054565,
0.45978665351867676,
0.6562891602516174,
0.42341771721839905,
0.22885796427726746,
0.3384834825992584,
-0.009564664214849472,
-0.12229199707508087,
-0.43810322880744934,
0.34794196486473083,
-0.44158849120140076,
-0.17000144720077515,
-0.009675173088908195,
-0.26558858156204224,
0.6161133050918579,
0.5788822770118713,
-0.13168758153915405,
-0.2135736644268036,
0.16097618639469147,
0.6325313448905945,
-0.780401349067688,
-0.04081167280673981,
-0.5115235447883606,
-0.06918389350175858,
-0.3356285095214844,
-0.0818425640463829,
-0.28734320402145386,
-0.5940937399864197,
-0.2306869924068451,
-0.40986087918281555,
-0.10557706654071808,
-0.2613792419433594,
0.6503909230232239,
0.2623090147972107,
-0.6633344292640686,
-0.21704092621803284,
-0.672730028629303,
0.9497545957565308,
-0.6897992491722107,
0.5465186834335327,
0.043257784098386765,
0.20571906864643097,
0.19610553979873657,
-0.867192804813385,
-0.26998642086982727,
0.08120694011449814,
0.09806323051452637,
0.3431495726108551,
0.005606997292488813,
-0.061283618211746216,
-0.11539525538682938,
0.2789219319820404,
-0.6278635263442993,
0.04603632539510727,
-0.28246113657951355,
-0.17982976138591766,
0.4167533814907074,
0.4004833698272705,
0.4882608950138092,
-0.2202582061290741,
-0.8699832558631897,
-0.03945419564843178,
-0.5405222177505493,
-0.20242328941822052,
0.3569464087486267,
0.3297906517982483,
-0.21749646961688995,
0.18957394361495972,
-0.294351726770401,
0.05061168223619461,
-0.39353498816490173,
-0.01930053159594536,
0.5625321269035339,
-0.8115308284759521,
0.014701193198561668,
-0.05426438897848129,
1.0711520910263062,
0.17922505736351013,
0.14867538213729858,
-0.1743994951248169,
-0.07975634932518005,
-0.09133736789226532,
0.4159160256385803,
-1.0520689487457275,
-0.27692025899887085,
0.4681118130683899,
-0.6700534820556641,
-0.4583924114704132,
-0.3429219126701355,
-1.3926628828048706,
-0.49603623151779175,
-0.3385866582393646,
0.318645715713501,
-0.6669642925262451,
-0.6475327610969543,
0.3895290195941925,
-0.4419342279434204,
-0.18536017835140228,
0.36750420928001404,
-0.5127842426300049,
0.3650100529193878,
0.5518618226051331,
0.819800078868866,
-0.50946444272995,
-0.4883387088775635,
-0.5221084356307983,
0.23777419328689575,
0.025872040539979935,
0.8712592124938965,
-0.6551641225814819,
-0.18050895631313324,
0.18682406842708588,
-0.04577050730586052,
-0.22605273127555847,
-0.664775550365448,
0.9006195664405823,
-0.1872958540916443,
-0.039247702807188034,
-0.17207761108875275,
-0.15010403096675873,
-0.16068968176841736,
0.228550523519516,
-0.632810652256012,
0.8872542977333069,
-0.2787353992462158,
-0.9251095652580261,
-0.0559857115149498,
-0.242567241191864,
-0.5010101795196533,
-0.10694240033626556,
-0.04478606954216957,
-0.4886801540851593,
0.05877973884344101,
0.16624006628990173,
0.31176862120628357,
-0.3995192348957062,
0.1475272923707962,
-0.5654377937316895,
-0.0783439427614212,
-0.232948899269104,
-0.6361565589904785,
1.0001230239868164,
0.4958125054836273,
-0.28056660294532776,
0.34237733483314514,
-0.7536686658859253,
-0.21272188425064087,
-0.16715535521507263,
-0.2964629530906677,
-0.8503720164299011,
-0.12419921159744263,
0.7539348602294922,
0.47952309250831604,
0.16106994450092316,
-0.6396315097808838,
-0.3266478478908539,
-0.11857005953788757,
0.24971282482147217,
0.5652677416801453,
0.33798083662986755,
0.09861307591199875,
-0.271200567483902,
0.5183033347129822,
0.33863377571105957,
0.2716543972492218,
-0.3088475167751312,
-0.6220875382423401,
-0.399946391582489,
-0.43344900012016296,
-0.14893107116222382,
0.8117446899414062,
-0.9932692050933838,
0.10043206065893173,
-0.24985581636428833,
-0.4928574860095978,
-0.06840862333774567,
0.09671838581562042,
0.46686097979545593,
0.3016698658466339,
0.47379282116889954,
-0.2990787625312805,
-0.3178773522377014,
-0.9614143967628479,
-0.30153724551200867,
-0.048769161105155945,
0.09570107609033585,
-0.16885876655578613,
0.32414117455482483,
-0.24521882832050323,
0.5432441234588623,
-0.33911600708961487,
-0.07712046056985855,
-0.2269597053527832,
0.348088800907135,
-0.007126185577362776,
0.35577869415283203,
0.751852810382843,
-0.7321470379829407,
-0.5630598664283752,
0.04689699783921242,
-0.867841362953186,
-0.30570048093795776,
-0.23232673108577728,
-0.29453185200691223,
-0.3770195543766022,
0.5565550327301025,
-0.4419863820075989,
0.2593056559562683,
0.41671791672706604,
-0.026145339012145996,
0.9901213645935059,
-0.18486088514328003,
0.2938695549964905,
-1.3468846082687378,
-0.01107813324779272,
0.2127368301153183,
-0.18513770401477814,
-1.025706171989441,
0.15357694029808044,
0.2532970905303955,
-0.3069645166397095,
-0.8716531991958618,
0.8088107705116272,
-0.25152143836021423,
0.5838934183120728,
-0.4045557379722595,
0.06947271525859833,
0.08558504283428192,
0.415571928024292,
0.3960564434528351,
0.7959989905357361,
0.7129037976264954,
-0.6109957695007324,
0.02952321246266365,
0.34834805130958557,
0.15766793489456177,
0.640373945236206,
-0.3282851576805115,
-0.18279649317264557,
-0.18223360180854797,
0.11403432488441467,
-1.047278642654419,
0.1938399076461792,
0.21006368100643158,
0.03958945721387863,
0.014774652197957039,
-0.03467867150902748,
-0.6996908783912659,
-0.1790519654750824,
-0.5277982950210571,
0.5481663942337036,
0.2518634498119354,
-0.596320390701294,
0.19796408712863922,
0.513922393321991,
-0.459018349647522,
-0.5211521983146667,
-0.3654078543186188,
0.368294358253479,
-0.7731262445449829,
-0.3011842370033264,
0.22306698560714722,
-0.10719205439090729,
-0.3730340600013733,
-0.4138190448284149,
-0.007124811876565218,
-0.4011021554470062,
0.005918615031987429,
-0.13487306237220764,
-0.010947657749056816,
0.10530700534582138,
0.18034008145332336,
0.619235634803772,
-0.23805928230285645,
-0.009257182478904724,
-0.05943082273006439,
0.5176114439964294,
0.018188167363405228,
-0.13360048830509186,
-0.49996283650398254,
0.8847487568855286,
0.7606329917907715,
-0.36792588233947754,
0.8136401176452637,
0.9050014019012451,
-0.3543708324432373,
0.006286631803959608,
-0.4446772038936615,
-0.09606968611478806,
-0.46382516622543335,
0.3035088777542114,
-0.5061754584312439,
-0.6626144051551819,
0.6818228960037231,
-0.3653402328491211,
0.024715539067983627,
0.34672799706459045,
0.7195364236831665,
0.40507131814956665,
0.8129029870033264,
0.5132113099098206,
-0.022838357836008072,
0.32304003834724426,
0.2686934173107147,
0.04623553529381752,
-0.5701495409011841,
0.16970194876194,
-0.8519042730331421,
0.12930969893932343,
-0.6477310657501221,
-0.3286193609237671,
0.4413813650608063,
0.03697105497121811,
-0.3718661665916443,
0.5925569534301758,
-0.23453059792518616,
0.3399401605129242,
0.5453923344612122,
0.18325285613536835,
0.49100255966186523,
0.13212282955646515,
-0.3685629665851593,
0.017155980691313744,
-0.29144367575645447,
-0.5680265426635742,
1.076766014099121,
0.31244027614593506,
0.6905476450920105,
0.06995831429958344,
1.2471455335617065,
-0.012842523865401745,
0.307790070772171,
-0.3861057460308075,
0.4771765470504761,
-0.7529300451278687,
-0.5240595936775208,
-0.043106306344270706,
-0.44010087847709656,
-0.8280096650123596,
0.338715136051178,
0.2194080501794815,
-0.8238130807876587,
0.4241202175617218,
-0.3747466802597046,
-0.29977282881736755,
0.5198761820793152,
-0.7396113276481628,
1.0057168006896973,
-0.02039489895105362,
-0.5864134430885315,
-0.2891704738140106,
-0.5410209894180298,
0.5806218385696411,
-0.48626020550727844,
0.5986507534980774,
-0.2853727340698242,
-0.27210479974746704,
0.6685558557510376,
-0.396284282207489,
0.8577146530151367,
-0.058495670557022095,
-0.506437361240387,
0.16639110445976257,
0.04070853441953659,
0.48357197642326355,
0.2970620095729828,
-0.41610389947891235,
0.5791163444519043,
0.21363940834999084,
-0.3324461579322815,
-0.20017366111278534,
0.7308170795440674,
-0.4234357178211212,
-0.39615073800086975,
-0.12136568874120712,
-0.5872220993041992,
-0.27026301622390747,
0.4355495572090149,
0.12688542902469635,
0.4364687502384186,
-0.08665581792593002,
-0.04115145653486252,
0.5086528658866882,
-0.8483323454856873,
0.46995192766189575,
0.1822783648967743,
-0.2657376527786255,
-0.5776176452636719,
1.0409108400344849,
-0.3857748210430145,
0.30219200253486633,
0.5281735062599182,
0.3373834490776062,
-0.5014281868934631,
-0.7716655731201172,
-0.4524606466293335,
0.2250317633152008,
-0.6879070997238159,
-0.07088158279657364,
-0.9064971208572388,
-0.171756774187088,
-0.43532755970954895,
0.19195647537708282,
-0.4448687434196472,
-0.4487099051475525,
-0.16460928320884705,
0.052342671900987625,
0.4168156385421753,
0.5074462890625,
-0.2763144373893738,
0.22938352823257446,
-1.2201085090637207,
0.4807354807853699,
-0.040894992649555206,
0.15677055716514587,
-0.26240772008895874,
-0.21503272652626038,
-0.10044577717781067,
-0.14630761742591858,
-0.3290761709213257,
-1.2407233715057373,
0.6060868501663208,
0.03506355360150337,
0.6956990361213684,
0.5066066980361938,
0.3239767849445343,
0.492689847946167,
-0.7795671820640564,
0.5584027767181396,
0.37231501936912537,
-0.738670289516449,
0.463392436504364,
-0.6956951022148132,
0.34991011023521423,
0.8623796105384827,
0.6277494430541992,
-0.9438262581825256,
-1.0481514930725098,
-0.2721627950668335,
-1.0588451623916626,
0.5317112803459167,
0.4759877324104309,
0.33243468403816223,
-0.476589560508728,
0.12680606544017792,
0.6576709747314453,
0.3697163164615631,
-0.45501193404197693,
-0.40919941663742065,
-0.1773315668106079,
-0.47199854254722595,
-0.07946521043777466,
-0.2565291225910187,
0.03631825000047684,
-0.04427717998623848,
0.5986039042472839,
0.23094215989112854,
0.17413479089736938,
-0.19516561925411224,
-0.05902402848005295,
0.37761440873146057,
0.5888645648956299,
0.3443030118942261,
0.31468871235847473,
-0.12360171228647232,
0.5423024296760559,
-0.020316526293754578,
-0.7173216938972473,
0.3413470685482025,
0.30083945393562317,
-0.15087920427322388,
0.048793498426675797,
-0.03018815442919731,
0.5856969952583313,
0.21176956593990326,
-0.7029378414154053,
0.25126296281814575,
-0.06986244767904282,
-0.10020443052053452,
0.029463890939950943,
-0.2693628668785095,
-0.01486304122954607,
0.12203240394592285,
0.19089221954345703,
0.12426568567752838,
0.46009811758995056,
-0.3475203514099121,
0.6339385509490967,
0.19872424006462097,
-0.37270697951316833,
-0.18936719000339508,
1.0787686109542847,
0.30746638774871826,
0.05425361543893814,
0.38555726408958435,
-0.2177591621875763,
-0.40817996859550476,
0.46644482016563416,
0.39372989535331726,
1.2057380676269531,
-0.424796998500824,
0.43613407015800476,
0.6358417272567749,
0.30753257870674133,
0.0587003193795681,
0.034516360610723495,
-0.048276208341121674,
-0.6807759404182434,
-0.26981598138809204,
-0.875454306602478,
-0.0889703631401062,
0.3132251501083374,
-0.4788496196269989,
0.0909995287656784,
-0.2639927566051483,
0.11160887032747269,
-0.0170780960470438,
-0.35091862082481384,
-0.40566486120224,
-0.041069336235523224,
0.35110849142074585,
0.7802442908287048,
-1.241640329360962,
0.927303671836853,
0.5995715856552124,
-0.6439875364303589,
-0.2638658285140991,
0.3811887204647064,
0.3570634722709656,
-0.4472556710243225,
0.4462786316871643,
0.3883456289768219,
-0.02733045257627964,
0.11309636384248734,
0.22609882056713104,
-0.759339451789856,
0.46613579988479614,
0.33939090371131897,
-0.4475539028644562,
0.15309178829193115,
0.4667898118495941,
0.5681195855140686,
0.2288532257080078,
0.48785829544067383,
0.482944518327713,
0.5062154531478882,
-0.07036727666854858,
-0.971500039100647,
0.3023396134376526,
-0.4149709939956665,
0.16126322746276855,
0.21026626229286194,
-0.6182733178138733,
0.8187428116798401,
0.23291590809822083,
-0.18391089141368866,
0.2105761021375656,
0.2990969121456146,
0.3454771935939789,
0.2519613802433014,
0.4513915181159973,
0.8783479928970337,
0.5086991190910339,
0.23604528605937958,
0.9652841687202454,
-0.24923734366893768,
0.24194367229938507,
1.0713618993759155,
-0.4951709508895874,
0.7031926512718201,
0.33955714106559753,
-0.13150537014007568,
0.5001152157783508,
0.6379856467247009,
0.5190051198005676,
0.6649845838546753,
-0.13462595641613007,
-0.7521201968193054,
-0.26968640089035034,
-0.06456519663333893,
-0.3564639687538147,
0.07090353220701218,
0.41931822896003723,
-0.3052613139152527,
-0.9521558284759521,
0.5855823755264282,
0.12474310398101807,
0.2540149390697479,
-0.16421790421009064,
0.6097533702850342,
0.0601719468832016,
-0.409084290266037,
0.6291235089302063,
0.1152862161397934,
0.6392150521278381,
-0.3660907745361328,
0.20490801334381104,
-0.41160404682159424,
0.38099873065948486,
0.12721595168113708,
-0.852240800857544,
0.6770853400230408,
-0.09409962594509125,
-0.002316712634637952,
-0.5754697918891907,
0.8176099061965942,
-0.4884894788265228,
-0.45780786871910095,
0.6582705974578857,
0.7491746544837952,
0.5039324164390564,
-0.49608731269836426,
-1.0030102729797363,
0.17641372978687286,
-0.09258907288312912,
-0.07271446287631989,
0.5091253519058228,
0.5818307399749756,
-0.2640085518360138,
0.5049399733543396,
0.4772803783416748,
-0.08325904607772827,
0.318606972694397,
0.5039019584655762,
0.6673792600631714,
-0.5150445103645325,
-0.3481331169605255,
-0.7299329042434692,
0.510155200958252,
-0.008570564910769463,
-0.12363378703594208,
1.0104873180389404,
1.0674312114715576,
0.4863821864128113,
-0.12494589388370514,
0.9729673266410828,
0.20090769231319427,
0.5418835878372192,
-0.4046792984008789,
0.8672153949737549,
-0.6857469081878662,
0.03350888565182686,
-0.5516632795333862,
-0.7883481979370117,
-0.3794766366481781,
0.007919498719274998,
-0.21287114918231964,
-0.10041853785514832,
1.1480813026428223,
0.7837690711021423,
-0.2316415160894394,
0.13456523418426514,
0.32483571767807007,
0.1252119243144989,
0.2502395808696747,
0.49537408351898193,
0.659736156463623,
-0.3697769343852997,
0.8377628922462463,
-0.6500712037086487,
-0.26462996006011963,
0.23920899629592896,
-0.6627408266067505,
-0.8102085590362549,
-0.7648458480834961,
-0.5970072746276855,
-0.1910003423690796,
0.2691538333892822,
0.3855440020561218,
0.434661328792572,
-0.8966658711433411,
-0.312224417924881,
-0.3715347349643707,
0.2492530345916748,
-0.5583982467651367,
-0.2250637263059616,
0.32350873947143555,
-0.6803211569786072,
-1.0955588817596436,
0.4701288640499115,
0.3700897991657257,
-0.2634376883506775,
0.005820142105221748,
0.18870215117931366,
-0.4226312041282654,
-0.032208152115345,
0.7777479887008667,
0.17124487459659576,
-0.4029730558395386,
-0.22083841264247894,
-0.5189713835716248,
-0.05609869211912155,
0.2037387490272522,
0.6759629845619202,
-0.6793732047080994,
0.206854447722435,
0.6430866718292236,
0.6407106518745422,
0.4343045949935913,
0.05802839994430542,
0.26265984773635864,
-0.8832818269729614,
0.3149079978466034,
-0.016256183385849,
0.14018189907073975,
0.10901749134063721,
-0.14985129237174988,
0.20774312317371368,
0.4425729513168335,
-0.2255639135837555,
-0.6653065085411072,
0.25163230299949646,
-0.9377022385597229,
-0.5637885928153992,
1.3777973651885986,
-0.03892970457673073,
-0.22225119173526764,
-0.6950228214263916,
-0.19549770653247833,
0.2768375277519226,
-0.47358953952789307,
0.6732897162437439,
0.4834878742694855,
0.20874114334583282,
-0.4372522532939911,
-0.7970793843269348,
0.3472948372364044,
0.3376923203468323,
-1.3922090530395508,
0.37860631942749023,
0.3774542510509491,
0.4300662875175476,
0.1085968166589737,
0.7512092590332031,
-0.3977900743484497,
0.07468095421791077,
0.0095170047134161,
0.14879760146141052,
0.26530030369758606,
-0.384400337934494,
-0.2722475230693817,
0.3631714880466461,
-0.5452171564102173,
-0.22801858186721802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02022v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02022v2
|
Improving Retrieval Augmented Open-Domain Question-Answering with Vectorized Contexts
| 2024-04-02T15:10:11 | 2024-07-01T10:38:59 |
Zhuo Chen, Xinyu Wang, Yong Jiang, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the era of large language models, applying techniques such as Retrieval
Augmented Generation can better address Open-Domain Question-Answering
problems. Due to constraints including model sizes and computing resources, the
length of context is often limited, and it becomes challenging to empower the
model to cover overlong contexts while answering questions from open domains.
This paper proposes a general and convenient method to covering longer contexts
in Open-Domain Question-Answering tasks. It leverages a small encoder language
model that effectively encodes contexts, and the encoding applies
cross-attention with origin inputs. With our method, the origin language models
can cover several times longer contexts while keeping the computing
requirements close to the baseline. Our experiments demonstrate that after
fine-tuning, there is improved performance across two held-in datasets, four
held-out datasets, and also in two In Context Learning settings.
|
[
-0.7550694346427917,
-0.7639924883842468,
0.3908683955669403,
-0.022884421050548553,
-0.2747577726840973,
-0.16173842549324036,
-0.5078880190849304,
-0.4472794234752655,
-0.003680851310491562,
0.44605305790901184,
-0.4635133743286133,
-0.14586769044399261,
-0.357045978307724,
0.3119068145751953,
-0.06858926266431808,
0.7241224646568298,
-0.41374531388282776,
-0.14354164898395538,
-0.69376540184021,
-0.3487739861011505,
-0.6286720633506775,
-0.4978058338165283,
-0.532941997051239,
0.0915365219116211,
0.45109716057777405,
0.4126082956790924,
0.5753561854362488,
0.44772258400917053,
0.31394901871681213,
0.09301728755235672,
-0.21645669639110565,
0.5810680389404297,
-0.7348816990852356,
0.15327702462673187,
-0.31111350655555725,
-0.28864970803260803,
-0.13532154262065887,
-0.28185954689979553,
0.7294343113899231,
0.7956588268280029,
0.22591368854045868,
0.28729143738746643,
0.1807764321565628,
0.36309316754341125,
-0.8607938885688782,
-0.29393383860588074,
-0.4526894986629486,
0.027000704780220985,
0.062459129840135574,
-0.503677487373352,
-0.45343491435050964,
-0.10519725829362869,
0.3314453959465027,
-0.7733103632926941,
0.18899868428707123,
0.16593217849731445,
0.6073305606842041,
0.11043485254049301,
-0.4104178845882416,
-0.01629542000591755,
-0.8795208930969238,
1.0180546045303345,
-0.2583301365375519,
0.6181943416595459,
0.5480200052261353,
0.47752901911735535,
-0.003392997896298766,
-0.6998898983001709,
-0.44380977749824524,
0.2749110758304596,
-0.2356201410293579,
-0.173176571726799,
-0.1172582134604454,
-0.17998458445072174,
0.3296947777271271,
0.1394662857055664,
-0.3105214536190033,
-0.40587130188941956,
-0.6324681639671326,
-0.07724732160568237,
0.26389554142951965,
0.06494807451963425,
0.2657744288444519,
0.04340521618723869,
-0.47081926465034485,
-0.013243530876934528,
-1.0072530508041382,
0.3519212007522583,
-0.12732331454753876,
0.46280595660209656,
0.25473281741142273,
0.8491550087928772,
-0.35428082942962646,
0.9990537166595459,
0.08729016035795212,
0.32304924726486206,
-0.09429798275232315,
-0.4455808103084564,
-0.3819551467895508,
-0.14425450563430786,
-0.05982459709048271,
0.3741612136363983,
0.19698841869831085,
-0.45371222496032715,
-0.07338952273130417,
-0.44773709774017334,
0.34172436594963074,
-1.0459562540054321,
0.3986499309539795,
0.4050808250904083,
-0.2455495148897171,
0.497598260641098,
0.044657934457063675,
-0.602921724319458,
0.17681561410427094,
-0.5316980481147766,
0.5491787791252136,
-0.49964770674705505,
0.10610765218734741,
0.17345769703388214,
-0.15141667425632477,
0.4710977375507355,
0.2552511990070343,
-0.6276430487632751,
0.4454549252986908,
0.6297363638877869,
0.7023767828941345,
-0.1988592892885208,
-0.09384115785360336,
-1.1004430055618286,
0.21354012191295624,
-0.2746567130088806,
0.39948391914367676,
-0.8380933403968811,
-0.32294076681137085,
0.23812808096408844,
0.06016897037625313,
-0.02807154506444931,
-0.4347589910030365,
0.2712654173374176,
-1.0462156534194946,
0.2794576585292816,
-0.575019896030426,
-0.5583333373069763,
0.004241063725203276,
0.3286926746368408,
-0.41961753368377686,
1.1846951246261597,
0.38864386081695557,
-0.730377733707428,
0.3392934799194336,
-0.4727695882320404,
-0.41207003593444824,
0.011000864207744598,
-0.13641804456710815,
-0.06076829507946968,
0.16444961726665497,
0.7520089149475098,
0.4374960660934448,
-0.27675291895866394,
-0.15441246330738068,
0.11913583427667618,
-0.5351020693778992,
-0.0007751062512397766,
0.09002673625946045,
0.5822760462760925,
0.09699409455060959,
-0.1236182227730751,
0.04634500667452812,
-0.42877626419067383,
0.2221360206604004,
0.07999544590711594,
-0.32225528359413147,
-0.9186829924583435,
-0.14932863414287567,
-0.12173426896333694,
0.06689810007810593,
0.2867240905761719,
-0.9328694343566895,
0.07916774600744247,
-0.478522926568985,
0.3769828975200653,
0.23776459693908691,
0.2556384801864624,
0.7504729628562927,
-0.1837662011384964,
0.6575367450714111,
0.14592070877552032,
-0.07215652614831924,
-0.19852568209171295,
-0.18754220008850098,
-0.566347062587738,
-0.12056401371955872,
0.3947988748550415,
0.28838294744491577,
-1.3339990377426147,
0.05822756886482239,
-0.5031053423881531,
0.06823737174272537,
-0.5581080317497253,
-0.028257427737116814,
0.45264625549316406,
0.6245144009590149,
0.8799527287483215,
-0.31870728731155396,
-0.5523674488067627,
-0.6823816299438477,
-0.27020958065986633,
0.3855093717575073,
-0.3162047564983368,
0.9773409962654114,
0.5812569260597229,
-0.24877946078777313,
1.4570941925048828,
-0.6897059082984924,
-0.11424819380044937,
-0.13488276302814484,
-0.25323784351348877,
-0.13456673920154572,
0.36317503452301025,
0.5800911784172058,
-0.9481048583984375,
-0.6121044158935547,
0.0036206580698490143,
-0.3966052532196045,
0.2730865180492401,
0.28194108605384827,
-0.5686853528022766,
0.11716818064451218,
0.5542073249816895,
-0.5374293923377991,
0.4453813135623932,
0.08437711000442505,
-0.2741686999797821,
0.08246021717786789,
-0.1101408377289772,
0.33886098861694336,
-0.8870618343353271,
0.009946808218955994,
-0.22595034539699554,
-0.35249075293540955,
-0.7871800065040588,
0.2815220057964325,
0.389657586812973,
-0.2885075509548187,
-0.6691316962242126,
0.9251113533973694,
-0.6003516316413879,
-0.0774102732539177,
-0.17336125671863556,
0.2770961821079254,
0.18558233976364136,
0.511137068271637,
0.2742486596107483,
1.141671061515808,
0.4916780889034271,
-0.7684175968170166,
0.004388191271573305,
0.5017215609550476,
-0.32262593507766724,
0.37700894474983215,
-0.7130255699157715,
0.3341589868068695,
-0.4617784023284912,
0.2446286827325821,
-0.7935869693756104,
-0.27349624037742615,
-0.000040097394958138466,
-0.5067102909088135,
0.28449445962905884,
-0.388685017824173,
-0.18938417732715607,
-0.32505738735198975,
-0.15619851648807526,
0.9622233510017395,
0.542906641960144,
-1.0496692657470703,
0.6286664605140686,
0.213880717754364,
-0.12227565050125122,
-0.8073995113372803,
-0.4023160934448242,
-0.2556128203868866,
-0.1466008871793747,
-0.590254008769989,
0.5442589521408081,
0.059827011078596115,
0.013260439969599247,
0.11682379245758057,
-0.24726766347885132,
-0.1504920870065689,
-0.2026376873254776,
-0.23181021213531494,
-0.1946924924850464,
-0.48613882064819336,
0.30458158254623413,
0.25803741812705994,
0.34971341490745544,
-0.05370238795876503,
-0.36415767669677734,
0.4914352595806122,
0.1395147442817688,
-0.036071039736270905,
0.39788246154785156,
0.8128129839897156,
0.25839313864707947,
-0.7325327396392822,
0.9237794280052185,
0.2095669060945511,
-0.7507588863372803,
-0.5089424252510071,
-0.0868104100227356,
-0.2935786545276642,
-0.43034568428993225,
0.15486669540405273,
-0.6548090577125549,
-1.3274339437484741,
0.5249879956245422,
0.14295461773872375,
0.028688892722129822,
0.28445181250572205,
0.40101781487464905,
0.10859206318855286,
0.859346866607666,
0.7391945719718933,
0.034835800528526306,
0.4484608471393585,
-0.16042651236057281,
0.025471901521086693,
-1.239704966545105,
-0.0362376905977726,
-0.3237663805484772,
-0.08453369140625,
-0.12055611610412598,
-0.901925265789032,
0.49063825607299805,
0.2548636496067047,
-0.25756797194480896,
0.3935631215572357,
-0.564076840877533,
0.6141664385795593,
0.526698887348175,
0.2328745722770691,
-0.05804025009274483,
0.12890200316905975,
-0.05654038116335869,
0.06020142510533333,
-0.8701009154319763,
-0.1578008383512497,
1.083988070487976,
0.2535703778266907,
0.6103163361549377,
0.3409065008163452,
0.48976930975914,
-0.08345294743776321,
0.1740003079175949,
-0.36487534642219543,
0.28329214453697205,
0.023410780355334282,
-0.6002746224403381,
-0.5839972496032715,
-0.36538323760032654,
-1.021483302116394,
0.36520707607269287,
0.03600172698497772,
-0.5220165848731995,
0.46867725253105164,
0.136814147233963,
-0.754611074924469,
0.0980733335018158,
-0.3696326017379761,
0.7124183177947998,
0.1161625012755394,
-0.5263566374778748,
0.12520669400691986,
-0.6431159973144531,
0.2042086124420166,
0.19378070533275604,
-0.21905279159545898,
0.30059564113616943,
-0.07632254809141159,
0.560065746307373,
-0.3894568681716919,
0.6381366848945618,
-0.3393506109714508,
-0.07602586597204208,
0.6283274292945862,
-0.17831824719905853,
0.4011388123035431,
0.19945555925369263,
0.15590934455394745,
-0.2299441546201706,
0.13553257286548615,
-0.5712347626686096,
-0.8675940036773682,
0.6067479252815247,
-0.5607444047927856,
-0.5063315629959106,
-0.09420660883188248,
-0.4727359116077423,
-0.5048285126686096,
0.07053311914205551,
0.3407185971736908,
0.7664932608604431,
-0.2973421812057495,
0.49456655979156494,
1.0380100011825562,
-0.377253919839859,
0.17748905718326569,
0.2865740954875946,
-0.09516412019729614,
-0.31042081117630005,
0.5261058807373047,
0.07069068402051926,
0.2789894640445709,
0.6101251840591431,
-0.037739530205726624,
-0.4070078134536743,
-0.25393685698509216,
-0.7708652019500732,
0.036337632685899734,
-0.7139593958854675,
-0.39967653155326843,
-0.7932300567626953,
-0.20982366800308228,
-0.5794852375984192,
-0.10337972640991211,
-0.1353992521762848,
-0.3635372817516327,
-0.3422989845275879,
0.12951524555683136,
0.6761314868927002,
0.08183097839355469,
0.27441850304603577,
0.21020002663135529,
-0.6421322226524353,
0.5727071166038513,
0.44224658608436584,
0.5833795666694641,
0.08944934606552124,
-0.5780350565910339,
-0.3771620988845825,
0.2105228155851364,
0.2433953732252121,
-0.6448814272880554,
0.2141137570142746,
0.36943042278289795,
0.41386178135871887,
-0.14783824980258942,
0.33839836716651917,
0.7079934477806091,
-0.9669008255004883,
0.6700496077537537,
-0.3507925271987915,
-0.6074373126029968,
0.6051724553108215,
-0.2461233139038086,
0.5927900671958923,
0.5266219973564148,
0.7056446075439453,
-0.5028373599052429,
0.04380689933896065,
-0.047199446707963943,
-1.0096219778060913,
0.6682971119880676,
0.3095860779285431,
0.26060816645622253,
-0.3769597113132477,
0.6629813313484192,
0.10375849157571793,
0.026410436257719994,
-0.17470861971378326,
-0.05934778228402138,
-0.12012698501348495,
-0.04510815441608429,
-0.24938948452472687,
-0.33277592062950134,
-0.4405604898929596,
-0.4595414400100708,
0.6365179419517517,
-0.46764814853668213,
0.6027059555053711,
0.6411649584770203,
-0.39867091178894043,
-0.2514343559741974,
0.3345887362957001,
0.7598738074302673,
0.8584497570991516,
-0.2609007954597473,
0.04550278186798096,
0.3366590440273285,
-0.2591867446899414,
-0.04789101704955101,
0.21509647369384766,
-0.21496371924877167,
-0.10634059458971024,
-0.06839368492364883,
0.8227348327636719,
-0.009929034858942032,
-0.7420768737792969,
0.5386956334114075,
-0.2277403622865677,
0.09308105707168579,
-0.38561442494392395,
-0.01403331384062767,
-0.11899751424789429,
0.2881723940372467,
0.47605225443840027,
-0.24115817248821259,
0.14844848215579987,
-0.42112699151039124,
0.31965890526771545,
0.46312132477760315,
-0.48952624201774597,
0.03933383896946907,
0.8040185570716858,
0.11450859904289246,
-0.20401029288768768,
0.4154520332813263,
0.1470056027173996,
-0.5136982798576355,
0.6774703860282898,
0.6631196141242981,
0.5956685543060303,
0.007705093827098608,
-0.1700238138437271,
0.3392700254917145,
0.13688208162784576,
0.003574119182303548,
0.5318126678466797,
-0.427270770072937,
-0.6659381985664368,
-0.5476778149604797,
-0.5690639615058899,
-0.5262956619262695,
-0.09888554364442825,
-0.8969460129737854,
-0.06997448951005936,
-0.10155922174453735,
-0.017777739092707634,
-0.20352530479431152,
-0.12773539125919342,
-0.878169596195221,
0.48691675066947937,
-0.21040505170822144,
1.1566821336746216,
-0.36432090401649475,
0.6578153967857361,
0.7640928626060486,
-0.28783127665519714,
-0.29366376996040344,
0.014723126776516438,
-0.683533251285553,
-0.3122035562992096,
0.6307024955749512,
0.18957948684692383,
-0.26535090804100037,
0.17017002403736115,
-0.5064553022384644,
-1.0413352251052856,
0.970583438873291,
-0.08003712445497513,
-0.2489410638809204,
0.0518011711537838,
0.09327832609415054,
0.6259334087371826,
-0.6778414249420166,
0.0055944547057151794,
0.609218418598175,
0.020869456231594086,
-0.20871882140636444,
-0.6336033940315247,
0.09486057609319687,
-0.11921271681785583,
0.09415615350008011,
0.32654044032096863,
-0.34524857997894287,
0.7092650532722473,
-0.15446224808692932,
-0.2810981273651123,
0.16841888427734375,
1.1387630701065063,
0.1508907526731491,
0.20810313522815704,
0.35585662722587585,
0.20637989044189453,
0.5172949433326721,
-0.036133404821157455,
1.2847530841827393,
-0.23494206368923187,
0.28700944781303406,
1.1586155891418457,
-0.2388659566640854,
1.0136680603027344,
0.5192396640777588,
0.1588573455810547,
0.1349540501832962,
0.5732399225234985,
0.5183881521224976,
0.6777611374855042,
0.1404041200876236,
-0.307035893201828,
-0.15756355226039886,
-0.06594712287187576,
-0.4107297956943512,
0.12229564785957336,
0.2605336606502533,
-0.3179348409175873,
-0.1818801909685135,
0.580290675163269,
-0.2667647898197174,
0.23629218339920044,
-0.5868794918060303,
0.47583603858947754,
-0.027891123667359352,
-0.9492230415344238,
0.828873336315155,
0.22301852703094482,
0.5599454045295715,
-0.23935990035533905,
-0.02638963796198368,
-0.2950635552406311,
0.06920791417360306,
0.2428523451089859,
-0.7099023461341858,
0.2433619499206543,
0.123572438955307,
-0.43704697489738464,
-0.2773565351963043,
0.7799040675163269,
-0.7938241362571716,
-0.19920645654201508,
0.24971012771129608,
0.4949873387813568,
-0.13343675434589386,
-0.06955765187740326,
-0.017384624108672142,
-0.15149252116680145,
-0.34975671768188477,
-0.3082173466682434,
0.3348903954029083,
0.5544252395629883,
-0.38875100016593933,
0.2986317574977875,
0.29333022236824036,
-0.3684610426425934,
0.28797125816345215,
-0.11075452715158463,
1.0039916038513184,
-0.6364724040031433,
-0.4322507381439209,
-0.4458034336566925,
0.2322276383638382,
-0.09640835970640182,
-0.3023912012577057,
0.7034924626350403,
0.7304622530937195,
1.1072028875350952,
-0.22037462890148163,
0.5938189029693604,
-0.16929519176483154,
0.8890174031257629,
-0.46036335825920105,
0.4198264181613922,
-0.7296164631843567,
-0.07241746038198471,
0.11388736963272095,
-0.8781308531761169,
-0.28294637799263,
0.44033631682395935,
-0.4380551278591156,
0.15227092802524567,
0.26003941893577576,
0.4994160234928131,
-0.4874323308467865,
-0.2040872722864151,
0.2847020924091339,
-0.08718547224998474,
-0.0030732078012079,
0.7377777695655823,
0.6822850704193115,
-0.4883633553981781,
0.3030647337436676,
-0.26042887568473816,
-0.09537476301193237,
-0.22290928661823273,
-0.5467244982719421,
-1.1370795965194702,
-0.555415689945221,
-0.05842548608779907,
-0.4317014217376709,
0.13160307705402374,
0.8493892550468445,
0.6153069138526917,
-0.8323772549629211,
0.17629317939281464,
0.3698892891407013,
-0.11743754893541336,
-0.34575724601745605,
-0.20509158074855804,
0.5437303185462952,
-0.26982325315475464,
-0.8792221546173096,
0.5433513522148132,
0.04226158931851387,
-0.13030557334423065,
0.03056979365646839,
-0.01467223186045885,
-0.2718302309513092,
0.46554362773895264,
1.0138492584228516,
0.5896112322807312,
-0.5505004525184631,
-0.8865923285484314,
0.4399315118789673,
0.027012059465050697,
0.25142958760261536,
0.9188592433929443,
-0.9456581473350525,
0.4948672354221344,
0.6656056642532349,
1.2397700548171997,
0.6352014541625977,
0.5351609587669373,
0.659808337688446,
-1.3624614477157593,
-0.05789746716618538,
0.3273757994174957,
0.17411251366138458,
0.2700445353984833,
-0.6182589530944824,
0.5238903164863586,
-0.26807504892349243,
-0.3521026074886322,
-0.7649922370910645,
0.20937782526016235,
-0.8108075261116028,
-0.48557916283607483,
1.1979442834854126,
-0.07428918033838272,
-0.3882807493209839,
-0.17220906913280487,
-0.2007044404745102,
0.14480328559875488,
-0.0945601835846901,
0.24837009608745575,
0.5269983410835266,
-0.1366942971944809,
-0.1483728140592575,
-0.6217126846313477,
0.6427586674690247,
0.5104946494102478,
-0.5623244643211365,
0.14375554025173187,
0.45950615406036377,
0.3371070921421051,
0.008965765126049519,
0.6715080738067627,
-0.10613515228033066,
0.49145665764808655,
-0.35609444975852966,
-0.08298826962709427,
0.003625904442742467,
-0.6541059613227844,
-0.27219685912132263,
0.3504209518432617,
-0.2889440059661865,
-0.34920862317085266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11852v1
|
Risks from Language Models for Automated Mental Healthcare: Ethics and Structure for Implementation
| 2024-04-02T15:05:06 | 2024-04-02T15:05:06 |
Declan Grabb, Max Lamparth, Nina Vasan
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Amidst the growing interest in developing task-autonomous AI for automated
mental health care, this paper addresses the ethical and practical challenges
associated with the issue and proposes a structured framework that delineates
levels of autonomy, outlines ethical requirements, and defines beneficial
default behaviors for AI agents in the context of mental health support. We
also evaluate ten state-of-the-art language models using 16 mental
health-related questions designed to reflect various mental health conditions,
such as psychosis, mania, depression, suicidal thoughts, and homicidal
tendencies. The question design and response evaluations were conducted by
mental health clinicians (M.D.s). We find that existing language models are
insufficient to match the standard provided by human professionals who can
navigate nuances and appreciate context. This is due to a range of issues,
including overly cautious or sycophantic responses and the absence of necessary
safeguards. Alarmingly, we find that most of the tested models could cause harm
if accessed in mental health emergencies, failing to protect users and
potentially exacerbating existing symptoms. We explore solutions to enhance the
safety of current models. Before the release of increasingly task-autonomous AI
systems in mental health, it is crucial to ensure that these models can
reliably detect and manage symptoms of common psychiatric disorders to prevent
harm to users. This involves aligning with the ethical framework and default
behaviors outlined in our study. We contend that model developers are
responsible for refining their systems per these guidelines to safeguard
against the risks posed by current AI technologies to user mental health and
safety.
Trigger warning: Contains and discusses examples of sensitive mental health
topics, including suicide and self-harm.
|
[
-0.10062192380428314,
-0.7013298273086548,
0.9138504266738892,
-0.002334342570975423,
0.291493684053421,
-0.28082746267318726,
0.15307825803756714,
-0.7053329348564148,
-0.46054190397262573,
0.6913849115371704,
-0.6067508459091187,
-0.13602587580680847,
-0.6808382868766785,
0.10252530872821808,
-0.3823155462741852,
1.0385428667068481,
-0.05030578747391701,
-0.022920403629541397,
-0.11181361973285675,
0.11261384934186935,
-0.368030846118927,
-0.5940229296684265,
-0.7993633151054382,
0.06253747642040253,
0.42457088828086853,
0.04767977073788643,
1.0558651685714722,
0.604418158531189,
0.6088985800743103,
0.31325051188468933,
0.28659123182296753,
-0.2672439217567444,
-0.004601266235113144,
0.17048169672489166,
-0.011891954578459263,
-0.18123501539230347,
-0.8852332234382629,
0.1389230191707611,
0.04924074560403824,
0.49606192111968994,
-0.40137162804603577,
0.2308623343706131,
-0.06506510823965073,
0.359566330909729,
-0.49045413732528687,
0.23339103162288666,
-0.2243374139070511,
0.14890331029891968,
0.06774727255105972,
0.05218684673309326,
-0.440677672624588,
-0.18343046307563782,
0.04285650700330734,
-0.47037968039512634,
-0.3066675364971161,
0.06908644735813141,
0.48784399032592773,
0.8312622308731079,
-0.5141344666481018,
-0.32623717188835144,
-0.9964454174041748,
0.44360753893852234,
-0.7979453206062317,
-0.02259611338376999,
0.7006428837776184,
0.26486971974372864,
-0.10078465193510056,
-0.49629655480384827,
-0.573788046836853,
-0.24740299582481384,
-0.11674255132675171,
-0.12295370548963547,
-0.5920920968055725,
0.4812304675579071,
0.4347354471683502,
0.19154170155525208,
-0.4917079508304596,
0.20344513654708862,
-0.28044894337654114,
-0.022712495177984238,
0.9819610714912415,
0.6084239482879639,
0.7007157802581787,
-0.18388178944587708,
0.052536655217409134,
0.07406919449567795,
-0.2582869231700897,
0.18866132199764252,
0.4759242534637451,
-0.02154914289712906,
-0.1820889264345169,
0.641933023929596,
0.17816650867462158,
0.40228575468063354,
0.025323260575532913,
-0.05677429214119911,
-0.019682738929986954,
-0.054488297551870346,
-0.3153276741504669,
-0.050881996750831604,
0.8308047652244568,
0.5348680019378662,
0.3889234662055969,
-0.1063709557056427,
-0.2733325958251953,
0.07926986366510391,
0.940190851688385,
-0.33544018864631653,
-0.22760988771915436,
0.801331102848053,
-0.6148959398269653,
-0.2304561734199524,
-0.10331510007381439,
-0.2347833663225174,
-0.4582214653491974,
-0.3897058069705963,
0.43527597188949585,
-0.49315255880355835,
-0.4062475562095642,
0.1423218697309494,
0.19590862095355988,
0.18569155037403107,
0.10119256377220154,
-0.6169074177742004,
0.47274544835090637,
0.5880553126335144,
0.3094269633293152,
-0.061297476291656494,
-0.15143108367919922,
-0.10724260658025742,
0.10421326756477356,
-0.3563181757926941,
0.4544621407985687,
-0.2266932725906372,
-0.5966666340827942,
-0.0939791351556778,
0.031161118298768997,
-0.13730037212371826,
-0.2077411264181137,
0.44194701313972473,
0.02746117115020752,
0.19412894546985626,
-0.18018144369125366,
-0.3946473002433777,
-0.13566793501377106,
-0.029855763539671898,
-0.418057918548584,
0.48292577266693115,
0.16467544436454773,
-0.8230997920036316,
0.03825237229466438,
-0.9458156228065491,
-0.5013039112091064,
0.21666975319385529,
-0.23874081671237946,
-0.09073489904403687,
0.0122087262570858,
-0.03764216974377632,
0.5251704454421997,
-0.15854404866695404,
0.36358389258384705,
-0.39241158962249756,
-0.12285509705543518,
0.15787635743618011,
-0.4901915490627289,
1.37353515625,
0.2251555472612381,
-0.5188660621643066,
0.47981780767440796,
-0.5300551056861877,
0.16644906997680664,
0.19231997430324554,
0.2017148733139038,
-0.506560206413269,
0.24613957107067108,
0.2185547947883606,
0.3655661344528198,
0.10720174759626389,
-0.22889360785484314,
-0.3717429041862488,
-0.3138946294784546,
0.30533334612846375,
0.7968778610229492,
0.2075309157371521,
0.35652610659599304,
-0.7209166884422302,
0.7451609373092651,
-0.23855161666870117,
0.8998243808746338,
0.02027985453605652,
-0.5343255400657654,
-0.1174594983458519,
-0.45607033371925354,
-0.37386587262153625,
0.9730927348136902,
-0.17534226179122925,
0.9253478050231934,
0.19344325363636017,
-0.49072444438934326,
-0.7858396768569946,
-0.3339689373970032,
0.25166162848472595,
0.6257195472717285,
0.2679668664932251,
0.019038284197449684,
-0.25673946738243103,
-1.0306932926177979,
-0.15752239525318146,
-0.4496738910675049,
-0.03528102487325668,
0.3718401789665222,
0.5027890205383301,
-0.681955873966217,
0.900721549987793,
-0.2631058096885681,
0.030505096539855003,
-0.004476307425647974,
0.16323110461235046,
-0.3866964280605316,
0.7457420229911804,
0.3507501184940338,
-0.6656651496887207,
-0.16775727272033691,
-0.15053698420524597,
-1.0864158868789673,
-0.19981445372104645,
0.044378019869327545,
-0.004771432839334011,
0.1870228350162506,
0.23415623605251312,
-0.7341939210891724,
0.618868350982666,
0.3427872061729431,
-0.22829720377922058,
0.5246753096580505,
-0.28797948360443115,
0.06408607214689255,
-1.1103159189224243,
0.3588271141052246,
-0.18133296072483063,
-0.0585557296872139,
-0.835108757019043,
0.27508434653282166,
-0.2592947483062744,
-0.12416450679302216,
-0.3843492865562439,
0.5081745982170105,
0.007767363917082548,
0.2644651532173157,
-0.5306451320648193,
-0.4029861092567444,
-0.185524120926857,
0.10077136754989624,
-0.22799791395664215,
0.4954809546470642,
0.4474382996559143,
-0.4758327305316925,
0.2767760157585144,
0.07321839779615402,
0.10112219303846359,
0.7784380912780762,
-0.717583417892456,
0.17045535147190094,
-0.16592521965503693,
0.13564349710941315,
-0.33990857005119324,
-0.3215450942516327,
0.6251786351203918,
-0.37099477648735046,
0.03610909730195999,
0.3736806809902191,
-0.5159329771995544,
-0.2392057627439499,
-0.00799356959760189,
0.5162607431411743,
0.5442560315132141,
0.3640541434288025,
0.2612079381942749,
0.9784811735153198,
-0.4318550229072571,
-0.5864917635917664,
-0.4802044630050659,
0.15687088668346405,
-0.4619576632976532,
-0.18600985407829285,
0.16925513744354248,
-0.20609165728092194,
-0.7863408327102661,
0.10619907081127167,
0.07639537006616592,
-0.04845665022730827,
0.6733275651931763,
0.6021685600280762,
0.11564113199710846,
0.14357741177082062,
0.17926153540611267,
0.17430543899536133,
-0.3091828525066376,
0.5979796648025513,
-0.13013549149036407,
0.07347047328948975,
-0.3030625283718109,
-0.3812066614627838,
-0.6285492777824402,
0.981328547000885,
0.6197392344474792,
-0.2421932816505432,
0.5158776044845581,
0.382220059633255,
-0.9800985455513,
0.26234784722328186,
-0.39093074202537537,
-0.28640010952949524,
-0.34638968110084534,
0.2600170075893402,
0.17142805457115173,
-0.7817004323005676,
0.417148619890213,
0.43230071663856506,
0.2924639582633972,
0.4457647204399109,
0.5842098593711853,
-0.5083673596382141,
1.5036314725875854,
0.9281855821609497,
-0.16840560734272003,
0.07449426501989365,
0.09547066688537598,
0.5098642110824585,
-0.39494580030441284,
-0.05571448802947998,
-0.49730542302131653,
0.1121634915471077,
-0.8248277902603149,
-0.19475381076335907,
0.5132929086685181,
-0.3749184012413025,
-0.5453280806541443,
0.20361144840717316,
-0.5873269438743591,
-0.07604195922613144,
0.3602679967880249,
0.043004121631383896,
0.2904394865036011,
-0.543967604637146,
0.014823680743575096,
-0.00376718258485198,
-0.44235777854919434,
-0.9025298953056335,
0.7272216081619263,
0.5860294699668884,
1.0097867250442505,
-0.08468025177717209,
0.6783583164215088,
0.5326584577560425,
0.1461963653564453,
-0.6110684871673584,
0.38748854398727417,
0.25201180577278137,
-0.9736998677253723,
-0.46720075607299805,
-0.17715276777744293,
-0.758050262928009,
-0.25851646065711975,
0.10515417903661728,
-0.947221577167511,
0.1987433135509491,
0.13903920352458954,
-0.6902649402618408,
0.025928732007741928,
-0.4863380789756775,
0.837706446647644,
-0.5718788504600525,
0.12731871008872986,
-0.18894849717617035,
-1.155301570892334,
0.35876622796058655,
-0.09425391256809235,
0.22641809284687042,
-0.34747567772865295,
0.016900861635804176,
0.5841334462165833,
-0.22579319775104523,
0.8455840945243835,
0.12747281789779663,
-0.22965829074382782,
0.24810607731342316,
-0.014675669372081757,
0.14513464272022247,
0.10478710383176804,
0.045841991901397705,
-0.06903864443302155,
0.433358758687973,
-0.2523998022079468,
-0.47985437512397766,
0.3325404226779938,
-0.813160240650177,
-1.0214507579803467,
-0.44164320826530457,
-0.8183346390724182,
-0.20695029199123383,
0.41416844725608826,
0.16813288629055023,
0.23404675722122192,
-0.15881569683551788,
-0.24108296632766724,
0.5667362809181213,
-0.28969690203666687,
0.225563183426857,
0.4180032014846802,
0.025416668504476547,
-0.17100615799427032,
0.561067521572113,
-0.12797653675079346,
0.14819256961345673,
-0.09865565598011017,
0.10379908978939056,
-0.1370917558670044,
-0.3769403398036957,
-0.22107556462287903,
0.10688313096761703,
-0.6492560505867004,
-0.06254739314317703,
-0.8086945414543152,
-0.4809114336967468,
-0.6214233636856079,
-0.17516954243183136,
-0.3351556658744812,
-0.058757614344358444,
-0.39198756217956543,
-0.2409084588289261,
0.3166045844554901,
0.9052166938781738,
0.032124318182468414,
0.0982404574751854,
-0.7742519974708557,
0.12063422054052353,
0.09646608680486679,
0.09380471706390381,
-0.21772386133670807,
0.07000722736120224,
-0.040624089539051056,
0.0904233306646347,
-0.16307806968688965,
-0.9928272366523743,
0.3138323128223419,
-0.3044351637363434,
0.8663998246192932,
0.4925483465194702,
0.5851541757583618,
0.5288280844688416,
-0.630916953086853,
0.4967529773712158,
-0.10602892190217972,
-0.9405442476272583,
0.7229005098342896,
-0.4513295292854309,
0.04901404678821564,
0.6902090311050415,
0.7735610604286194,
-0.624876856803894,
-0.6772982478141785,
-0.8886138200759888,
-0.7196576595306396,
0.43924951553344727,
0.279354453086853,
0.1858081966638565,
-0.32660502195358276,
0.4461243152618408,
0.04023211821913719,
0.2347991019487381,
-0.7145094871520996,
-0.2625861167907715,
-0.008800310082733631,
-0.532630205154419,
0.03597794100642204,
-0.003535199910402298,
-0.5933802723884583,
-0.08208595216274261,
0.45587819814682007,
-0.1427001804113388,
0.5756515264511108,
0.2666237950325012,
-0.029020657762885094,
-0.38544416427612305,
0.23390579223632812,
0.46160653233528137,
0.4465806484222412,
-0.12594634294509888,
0.002233050996437669,
-0.2222139835357666,
-0.18443751335144043,
0.33223897218704224,
0.4398442804813385,
-0.0389525406062603,
-0.5253991484642029,
0.18938188254833221,
0.4854181408882141,
-0.030116388574242592,
-0.8518388867378235,
0.334940642118454,
0.02324611321091652,
0.1711096614599228,
-0.44259607791900635,
0.1463600993156433,
-0.24106131494045258,
0.25474846363067627,
0.13091573119163513,
0.10540564358234406,
0.4671962559223175,
-0.5734608173370361,
0.4157258868217468,
0.599273681640625,
-0.36140644550323486,
-0.39432886242866516,
0.686454713344574,
0.017424587160348892,
-0.7055945992469788,
0.43031808733940125,
-0.02428361028432846,
-0.233253613114357,
0.7351402044296265,
0.33109214901924133,
1.0063676834106445,
-0.5253943800926208,
0.2544685900211334,
-0.17643295228481293,
0.6351373791694641,
-0.10337194055318832,
0.3735058605670929,
0.17138038575649261,
-0.542809009552002,
0.054265353828668594,
0.05569387227296829,
-0.5854913592338562,
0.1480436474084854,
-0.8068753480911255,
-0.04083891585469246,
-0.5577390193939209,
-0.5992627143859863,
-0.266762912273407,
-0.03377725929021835,
-0.275628000497818,
0.28944286704063416,
0.44463226199150085,
0.5613186359405518,
-0.7121647596359253,
0.618955671787262,
0.7530596256256104,
-0.22202754020690918,
-0.7333349585533142,
0.2930757403373718,
0.22213207185268402,
-0.49469509720802307,
-0.14493761956691742,
0.18684051930904388,
-0.2324073314666748,
-0.10845016688108444,
-0.43302223086357117,
-0.6669982075691223,
1.0206804275512695,
0.454004168510437,
0.016906777396798134,
-0.4888257384300232,
0.12859895825386047,
0.6463726758956909,
-0.5403468608856201,
0.16012383997440338,
0.32338112592697144,
0.47901907563209534,
-0.38172316551208496,
-0.9817512631416321,
0.22860443592071533,
-0.38111719489097595,
-0.0007843807688914239,
-0.171122208237648,
-0.18349838256835938,
0.7683431506156921,
-0.40494367480278015,
-0.227430522441864,
0.11815974861383438,
0.30083808302879333,
0.1723533570766449,
0.33627790212631226,
0.43039610981941223,
0.39399659633636475,
0.9140750765800476,
0.39614319801330566,
1.1359249353408813,
-0.4040829837322235,
0.04580944776535034,
0.8647853136062622,
-0.5792633295059204,
0.42479684948921204,
0.22976019978523254,
0.041531436145305634,
0.15645335614681244,
0.6184647083282471,
0.16302335262298584,
0.2196696698665619,
0.02711094357073307,
-0.27671030163764954,
-0.13239778578281403,
-0.2609700560569763,
-0.34546613693237305,
0.3790375292301178,
0.579988420009613,
-0.4243605136871338,
-0.02957018092274666,
0.29429590702056885,
0.19607485830783844,
0.022321853786706924,
-0.021381452679634094,
0.5778140425682068,
0.30719026923179626,
-0.5401546955108643,
-0.004985698964446783,
0.1847127377986908,
0.2384772151708603,
-0.3792537450790405,
0.19050484895706177,
0.16038008034229279,
0.10946528613567352,
0.017748722806572914,
-0.5033932328224182,
0.7074292898178101,
0.1503227949142456,
-0.21487396955490112,
-0.3778746724128723,
0.6824921369552612,
0.0679457038640976,
-0.6817330718040466,
0.3063141405582428,
0.687267005443573,
-0.06369536370038986,
-0.053258344531059265,
-1.183359146118164,
-0.2793141305446625,
-0.5187296867370605,
-0.07703819870948792,
0.2394997477531433,
0.1255125105381012,
-0.37092921137809753,
0.8707787990570068,
0.3978525996208191,
0.02209150232374668,
-0.04681174084544182,
-0.3650721311569214,
0.394855260848999,
-0.5792776346206665,
-0.44340524077415466,
-0.8230876922607422,
0.5103075504302979,
0.2729779779911041,
-0.20544490218162537,
0.3396635353565216,
-0.101958267390728,
0.3902941048145294,
0.010552541352808475,
0.8427649736404419,
-0.22171124815940857,
0.15643182396888733,
-0.1111169308423996,
1.2484130859375,
-0.6408898234367371,
-0.03797747567296028,
-0.24293580651283264,
-0.20968641340732574,
-0.4235335886478424,
0.7222009897232056,
-0.43517595529556274,
0.3565385639667511,
0.6174114346504211,
0.5635509490966797,
0.552675724029541,
0.01824237033724785,
0.3244588375091553,
0.17450648546218872,
0.4497654438018799,
0.4006554186344147,
0.7350855469703674,
-0.3254387676715851,
0.06813536584377289,
-0.47127842903137207,
-0.14784136414527893,
0.08088760077953339,
-0.7819441556930542,
-0.5604143142700195,
-0.7467892169952393,
-0.44756072759628296,
-0.06026593968272209,
0.2571621239185333,
1.1453888416290283,
0.6415755152702332,
-0.7097309231758118,
-0.29894182085990906,
0.00020437035709619522,
0.14968989789485931,
-0.44243094325065613,
-0.21622423827648163,
-0.014102580025792122,
-0.15414462983608246,
-0.5404323935508728,
0.2012561708688736,
0.45425018668174744,
0.2016603946685791,
-0.37727975845336914,
0.15152479708194733,
-0.12016215920448303,
0.11383385956287384,
0.28441479802131653,
0.39213070273399353,
-0.9639214277267456,
-0.39214447140693665,
0.011686128564178944,
-0.6162248253822327,
-0.18055285513401031,
0.6021944880485535,
-0.35494521260261536,
0.12653326988220215,
0.09526915103197098,
0.6462303400039673,
-0.6163899898529053,
-0.05745464935898781,
0.8807927370071411,
-0.057401083409786224,
-0.13616129755973816,
0.7853689193725586,
0.3592792749404907,
0.061956170946359634,
-1.0279266834259033,
0.22467492520809174,
-0.002015608362853527,
-0.5622424483299255,
-0.8374675512313843,
0.23181387782096863,
-0.8704586625099182,
-0.0962006077170372,
0.8844199776649475,
-0.26788777112960815,
-0.15129759907722473,
-0.39513903856277466,
-0.20127014815807343,
0.3234550952911377,
-0.1814671754837036,
0.9366066455841064,
0.4059610068798065,
-0.38697710633277893,
-0.34678733348846436,
-0.9324713945388794,
0.6700074076652527,
0.1640675663948059,
-0.9418789148330688,
0.14605052769184113,
0.3141561448574066,
0.15639561414718628,
-0.17859084904193878,
0.8051380515098572,
-0.28723350167274475,
0.542029082775116,
-0.2924114465713501,
0.23322056233882904,
-0.06838847696781158,
-0.23441512882709503,
-0.38832542300224304,
-0.14082464575767517,
0.0360034815967083,
0.023092128336429596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02013v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02013v2
|
Breaking the Silence Detecting and Mitigating Gendered Abuse in Hindi, Tamil, and Indian English Online Spaces
| 2024-04-02T14:55:47 | 2024-04-03T09:14:01 |
Advaitha Vetagiri, Gyandeep Kalita, Eisha Halder, Chetna Taparia, Partha Pakray, Riyanka Manna
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Online gender-based harassment is a widespread issue limiting the free
expression and participation of women and marginalized genders in digital
spaces. Detecting such abusive content can enable platforms to curb this
menace. We participated in the Gendered Abuse Detection in Indic Languages
shared task at ICON2023 that provided datasets of annotated Twitter posts in
English, Hindi and Tamil for building classifiers to identify gendered abuse.
Our team CNLP-NITS-PP developed an ensemble approach combining CNN and BiLSTM
networks that can effectively model semantic and sequential patterns in textual
data. The CNN captures localized features indicative of abusive language
through its convolution filters applied on embedded input text. To determine
context-based offensiveness, the BiLSTM analyzes this sequence for dependencies
among words and phrases. Multiple variations were trained using FastText and
GloVe word embeddings for each language dataset comprising over 7,600
crowdsourced annotations across labels for explicit abuse, targeted minority
attacks and general offences. The validation scores showed strong performance
across f1-measures, especially for English 0.84. Our experiments reveal how
customizing embeddings and model hyperparameters can improve detection
capability. The proposed architecture ranked 1st in the competition, proving
its ability to handle real-world noisy text with code-switching. This technique
has a promising scope as platforms aim to combat cyber harassment facing Indic
language internet users. Our Code is at
https://github.com/advaithavetagiri/CNLP-NITS-PP
|
[
-0.23798660933971405,
-0.8578377962112427,
-0.14450021088123322,
0.7391915321350098,
-0.12670664489269257,
0.5584424138069153,
-0.0700668916106224,
-0.7606273293495178,
-0.20655390620231628,
0.330976665019989,
-0.22819359600543976,
-0.39615750312805176,
-0.9021811485290527,
0.35077130794525146,
-0.8836084604263306,
0.855335533618927,
0.00987306423485279,
0.2541649341583252,
0.11326142400503159,
-0.2977520823478699,
-0.8007387518882751,
-0.30596673488616943,
-0.6364245414733887,
0.008243433199822903,
0.3396037817001343,
0.04688504338264465,
0.2216821014881134,
0.24513190984725952,
0.6404951810836792,
0.387270987033844,
-0.22728848457336426,
0.43180420994758606,
-0.3841542899608612,
0.3398723304271698,
-0.1482638418674469,
-0.17278112471103668,
-0.16156500577926636,
-0.18863119184970856,
0.2887430787086487,
0.3444744646549225,
-0.1866419017314911,
0.1509741246700287,
0.4468039572238922,
0.28505638241767883,
-0.8016761541366577,
0.12207053601741791,
-0.4709225594997406,
0.1468035876750946,
-0.36479854583740234,
0.00037096525193192065,
-0.31884661316871643,
-0.23985812067985535,
-0.21497663855552673,
-0.22750170528888702,
0.008231615647673607,
0.006514652166515589,
0.8169548511505127,
0.14141163229942322,
-0.011706175282597542,
-0.515646755695343,
-0.7849732637405396,
0.9072678685188293,
-0.45479488372802734,
0.6866012215614319,
0.6413029432296753,
0.07251836359500885,
0.1952361762523651,
-0.5562590956687927,
-0.3161379396915436,
-0.022204505279660225,
-0.1440601795911789,
0.08289221674203873,
-0.5556848049163818,
-0.26026850938796997,
0.17317675054073334,
0.32785025238990784,
-0.40941357612609863,
0.17881624400615692,
-0.570420503616333,
-0.13446888327598572,
0.38433438539505005,
-0.06411010026931763,
0.8090303540229797,
-0.11287821829319,
-0.4603981673717499,
0.3953874409198761,
-0.5209283828735352,
-0.1382962167263031,
0.6434637904167175,
0.6975328326225281,
-0.43979552388191223,
0.22445327043533325,
0.009185650385916233,
0.2606991231441498,
0.149644136428833,
-0.15474741160869598,
-0.010055260732769966,
-0.28263652324676514,
-0.047264352440834045,
0.13789965212345123,
0.8266381621360779,
0.3097692131996155,
0.2209177315235138,
-0.19558750092983246,
-0.25823792815208435,
0.25503531098365784,
0.19731405377388,
-0.6297277212142944,
0.021518167108297348,
0.02749025635421276,
-0.4500080645084381,
-0.46215853095054626,
-0.27538928389549255,
-1.0472745895385742,
-0.8128095865249634,
-0.20771877467632294,
0.17813722789287567,
-0.44307202100753784,
-0.8869350552558899,
-0.11127080023288727,
-0.2706788182258606,
0.495310515165329,
0.11147842556238174,
-0.8061827421188354,
0.5505604147911072,
0.6742868423461914,
1.0517815351486206,
-0.14814406633377075,
0.005366151686757803,
-0.4149167239665985,
-0.09886297583580017,
-0.29268553853034973,
0.4541732966899872,
-0.7049450874328613,
-0.26733601093292236,
0.2735985517501831,
-0.22303949296474457,
-0.11315758526325226,
-0.8601289987564087,
0.5832801461219788,
-0.24806080758571625,
0.2484886795282364,
-0.07152832299470901,
-0.13255326449871063,
0.07072185724973679,
0.4621579349040985,
-0.500029981136322,
1.0767916440963745,
-0.038311704993247986,
-0.9607408046722412,
0.4583297669887543,
-0.9636094570159912,
-0.47971111536026,
0.26058119535446167,
-0.06443507969379425,
-0.4941198229789734,
-0.17164571583271027,
0.3221836984157562,
0.14786958694458008,
-0.2547054886817932,
0.21314115822315216,
-0.038730937987565994,
-0.40192559361457825,
-0.016090407967567444,
-0.3389178216457367,
1.1978894472122192,
0.34260353446006775,
-0.5211958289146423,
0.23436622321605682,
-0.3285364806652069,
-0.3986892104148865,
0.1354692429304123,
-0.03885751962661743,
-0.3559809625148773,
-0.025962332263588905,
0.3524930775165558,
0.15478384494781494,
-0.23563362658023834,
-0.8883445262908936,
-0.4365653991699219,
-0.24693237245082855,
0.40373143553733826,
0.6360130310058594,
-0.07678496837615967,
0.10075029730796814,
-0.22009876370429993,
0.517437219619751,
0.11916814744472504,
0.31193307042121887,
0.1303318440914154,
-0.3998069763183594,
-0.38010507822036743,
-0.5544971823692322,
0.12921634316444397,
0.5634663105010986,
-0.7223888039588928,
0.08031852543354034,
-0.09877683967351913,
-0.20146502554416656,
-0.6907230019569397,
0.2832722067832947,
0.691223680973053,
0.48443230986595154,
0.3905094563961029,
-0.22524172067642212,
-0.7971374988555908,
-0.9244345426559448,
-0.5357027053833008,
-0.1743345856666565,
0.18725921213626862,
-0.18887872993946075,
0.23674730956554413,
-0.003264359664171934,
0.777398407459259,
0.11380047351121902,
-0.43221157789230347,
-0.45958420634269714,
0.5395999550819397,
-0.3497188687324524,
0.33832043409347534,
0.46073347330093384,
-1.130063772201538,
-0.6737631559371948,
-0.15240029990673065,
-0.9088304042816162,
-0.6099738478660583,
0.2236475944519043,
0.10510635375976562,
0.18194453418254852,
0.744011640548706,
-0.2026374340057373,
0.6568198800086975,
0.23406130075454712,
-0.3043438196182251,
0.3863299787044525,
0.5258365869522095,
0.3006995618343353,
-1.0055030584335327,
-0.08257252722978592,
0.06214512139558792,
-0.4019163250923157,
-0.6838027834892273,
0.10577919334173203,
-0.4448762536048889,
-0.0856030210852623,
-0.6021001935005188,
0.3752562403678894,
-0.5313304662704468,
0.16512587666511536,
-0.28556448221206665,
-0.060159098356962204,
-0.32706889510154724,
0.3302871584892273,
-0.17184339463710785,
0.6772448420524597,
0.29251059889793396,
-0.4195539951324463,
0.008500696159899235,
0.3653876483440399,
-0.035388216376304626,
0.8330585956573486,
-0.37567415833473206,
0.20632779598236084,
-0.19280017912387848,
-0.18114271759986877,
-0.8165836930274963,
-0.06711961328983307,
0.5627051591873169,
-0.6401214003562927,
0.23255762457847595,
-0.39101019501686096,
-0.6404997110366821,
-0.053579218685626984,
-0.5764883160591125,
0.367514431476593,
0.10903559625148773,
-0.5954718589782715,
0.4438079595565796,
0.6376501321792603,
-0.12475070357322693,
-0.6945947408676147,
-0.8044747710227966,
0.41191771626472473,
-0.21584120392799377,
-0.25350308418273926,
-0.10643000900745392,
-0.12184079736471176,
-0.6548265218734741,
-0.18788592517375946,
0.13293017446994781,
-0.2068096101284027,
0.12459041178226471,
0.5406114459037781,
0.19596312940120697,
0.08196582645177841,
-0.010483111254870892,
0.07289686053991318,
0.15630370378494263,
0.12622511386871338,
0.10486926883459091,
0.9605575799942017,
-0.4575602114200592,
-0.24170657992362976,
-0.3465508222579956,
0.7260394096374512,
0.6081374883651733,
-0.2824421525001526,
0.5774241089820862,
1.065486192703247,
-0.748981773853302,
-0.0032663752790540457,
-0.28629785776138306,
-0.056562382727861404,
-0.4477666914463043,
0.2772282063961029,
-0.12329614907503128,
-0.9053730964660645,
0.3691190779209137,
-0.0282170120626688,
0.13706547021865845,
0.32371121644973755,
0.6160740852355957,
-0.041552357375621796,
0.9740728139877319,
0.8676126003265381,
-0.3085319399833679,
0.4238511621952057,
0.07364142686128616,
0.5235985517501831,
-0.6212497353553772,
-0.14195331931114197,
-0.4383823573589325,
-0.19828571379184723,
-0.8498613238334656,
-0.09601826220750809,
0.14214469492435455,
0.12065276503562927,
-0.2083858996629715,
0.38493773341178894,
-0.8384639024734497,
0.3768460750579834,
0.11644323170185089,
0.1394822746515274,
0.29900339245796204,
0.1835285723209381,
0.01702115684747696,
-0.38969147205352783,
-0.4019741714000702,
-0.4256557524204254,
0.6052444577217102,
0.4073621928691864,
0.4054293632507324,
0.4044676125049591,
0.2659015357494354,
0.6789063811302185,
0.626509428024292,
-0.5954700708389282,
0.5315613150596619,
-0.13551636040210724,
-0.7950090169906616,
-0.061648063361644745,
-0.24417312443256378,
-0.9535617232322693,
0.1735067516565323,
0.011286456137895584,
-0.9754354357719421,
0.2821049392223358,
-0.2430231273174286,
-0.02809254452586174,
0.8259199857711792,
-0.5610730051994324,
0.3111288845539093,
-0.07700132578611374,
-0.6271045207977295,
-0.17406783998012543,
-0.4127654433250427,
0.6166481971740723,
0.00942586362361908,
0.416704386472702,
-0.15352970361709595,
0.018123729154467583,
0.7011387348175049,
-0.5012838840484619,
1.307212233543396,
-0.18730665743350983,
0.10585370659828186,
0.23503290116786957,
0.12233257293701172,
-0.057811420410871506,
-0.2589516341686249,
-0.02214251644909382,
0.5337793827056885,
-0.30509090423583984,
-0.3437650799751282,
0.0914313867688179,
0.578078031539917,
-0.4984298348426819,
-0.11986231058835983,
-0.5513245463371277,
-0.4894917905330658,
-0.16540363430976868,
0.2622240483760834,
0.453450471162796,
0.4656597077846527,
0.09720953553915024,
0.20264901220798492,
0.5719740390777588,
-0.25613126158714294,
0.7796214818954468,
0.28887173533439636,
-0.4157732427120209,
-0.20865918695926666,
1.0005196332931519,
0.08663256466388702,
-0.1476360410451889,
0.26496046781539917,
0.2248973399400711,
-0.2769167721271515,
-0.4569470286369324,
-0.5265102386474609,
-0.20230399072170258,
-0.44998177886009216,
-0.41567057371139526,
-0.7554038763046265,
-0.4735594093799591,
-0.44191911816596985,
-0.0036488494370132685,
-0.28309693932533264,
0.16933917999267578,
0.2572046220302582,
-0.11004341393709183,
0.44766560196876526,
0.944749653339386,
-0.3896181881427765,
0.27735161781311035,
-0.5981155633926392,
0.36326903104782104,
0.22314020991325378,
0.5682382583618164,
-0.16857250034809113,
-0.6084724068641663,
0.05222444236278534,
-0.33600515127182007,
-0.1540476381778717,
-0.9036669731140137,
0.5282840132713318,
0.0428110770881176,
0.08692309260368347,
0.18306423723697662,
0.2481575310230255,
0.6026318669319153,
0.03897027671337128,
0.5119171738624573,
0.1565832495689392,
-0.8056104183197021,
0.4841296076774597,
-0.5449570417404175,
0.1816699504852295,
0.5069575309753418,
0.4516836106777191,
-0.6303327083587646,
-0.7240490913391113,
-0.42475426197052,
-1.007215142250061,
0.6033341288566589,
0.5414183139801025,
0.3129647970199585,
-0.1985301971435547,
0.06074369698762894,
0.04010920226573944,
0.4298275411128998,
-0.7983747720718384,
-0.28626880049705505,
-0.04496738314628601,
-0.2916490137577057,
0.8383922576904297,
-0.2589144706726074,
-0.18741583824157715,
-0.4281822443008423,
0.5674924850463867,
0.30023959279060364,
0.46086961030960083,
0.03922749310731888,
-0.4024105966091156,
-0.10340471565723419,
0.11749666929244995,
0.47319841384887695,
0.5969479084014893,
-0.12795324623584747,
-0.009547675959765911,
0.20081497728824615,
-0.9294578433036804,
-0.11264695227146149,
0.06660276651382446,
-0.2847081422805786,
0.1837976723909378,
0.48663046956062317,
0.6147335767745972,
0.2416292428970337,
-0.6509288549423218,
0.6552999019622803,
-0.2795785665512085,
0.0010551969753578305,
-0.45432037115097046,
-0.3066522479057312,
-0.19070817530155182,
0.06558036804199219,
0.38316601514816284,
0.05840817466378212,
0.20983190834522247,
-0.4622096121311188,
0.2608219087123871,
0.045394666492938995,
-0.7990002632141113,
-0.3021576702594757,
0.5567021369934082,
0.13213956356048584,
-0.5870597958564758,
0.44586092233657837,
-0.4164864420890808,
-0.7934804558753967,
0.28852951526641846,
0.6195496320724487,
0.9944210648536682,
-0.2753927707672119,
0.14804552495479584,
0.48670387268066406,
0.59061598777771,
0.2831007242202759,
0.37044402956962585,
0.07723715156316757,
-0.6719783544540405,
-0.2548307478427887,
-0.6182442903518677,
-0.306282103061676,
0.3217487931251526,
-0.6528103947639465,
0.23899832367897034,
-1.126499056816101,
0.20315808057785034,
-0.06686833500862122,
-0.14222337305545807,
-0.40551111102104187,
-0.007831400260329247,
0.3166212737560272,
0.6319257020950317,
-0.9332404136657715,
0.3055833876132965,
0.3778800070285797,
-0.551749050617218,
-0.6766858100891113,
-0.029741276055574417,
0.4018637537956238,
-0.6971401572227478,
0.4849449694156647,
0.3124099373817444,
-0.3367570638656616,
-0.22414875030517578,
-0.9244559407234192,
-0.3325408101081848,
0.5397744178771973,
0.3619630038738251,
-0.5034275054931641,
0.7115662097930908,
0.28880977630615234,
0.5892800092697144,
-0.15021705627441406,
0.3564324378967285,
0.5349239706993103,
0.40265023708343506,
-0.23009558022022247,
-0.9474716186523438,
0.00908837839961052,
-0.5250357985496521,
-0.39285916090011597,
0.5314178466796875,
-0.6697276830673218,
0.6474176645278931,
0.30542558431625366,
-0.32927340269088745,
-0.09911849349737167,
0.3357885777950287,
0.11785709857940674,
0.3898109793663025,
0.7706614136695862,
0.5445045232772827,
0.584357500076294,
-0.14969080686569214,
0.9555606245994568,
-0.05588337406516075,
-0.12005006521940231,
1.129819393157959,
-0.15477874875068665,
0.7688820958137512,
0.15056945383548737,
-0.18279793858528137,
0.532797634601593,
0.38054513931274414,
0.002296959748491645,
0.07807862758636475,
0.25148528814315796,
-0.5816870927810669,
-0.007734028622508049,
-0.9250274300575256,
-0.165577232837677,
0.731926679611206,
0.509428858757019,
0.0026754180435091257,
-0.4039222002029419,
0.44786256551742554,
0.5578451752662659,
0.4081922471523285,
-0.2864103615283966,
0.7904075384140015,
0.013958324678242207,
-0.04987812414765358,
0.2243122160434723,
0.14190007746219635,
0.9444185495376587,
-0.5112298727035522,
-0.1081245020031929,
-0.3461257517337799,
0.08333469182252884,
-0.3573269546031952,
-0.5870020389556885,
0.5263421535491943,
0.5181591510772705,
-0.15433458983898163,
-0.43613746762275696,
1.1437938213348389,
-0.43461450934410095,
-0.48877114057540894,
0.6767624020576477,
0.468833327293396,
0.26626214385032654,
-0.3054333031177521,
-0.7713629603385925,
0.2932153344154358,
-0.21163314580917358,
0.3847796320915222,
0.537202000617981,
0.10797367990016937,
-0.4996813237667084,
0.5432400703430176,
0.7541659474372864,
-0.04213598743081093,
0.2746497094631195,
0.25145256519317627,
0.7783469557762146,
-0.3417631983757019,
-0.29145869612693787,
-0.8211094737052917,
0.2129981517791748,
-0.4797247648239136,
-0.45417407155036926,
0.5665552616119385,
0.656080424785614,
0.7342296838760376,
0.26561325788497925,
0.6160280108451843,
-0.36278045177459717,
0.8029659986495972,
0.13132618367671967,
0.8362155556678772,
-0.16043543815612793,
0.2250923216342926,
-0.34881117939949036,
-0.5469783544540405,
-0.48833760619163513,
0.2163044512271881,
-0.08339094370603561,
-0.10321854799985886,
0.25969719886779785,
0.8519610166549683,
-0.039553120732307434,
0.04667229950428009,
0.37508025765419006,
0.42328622937202454,
0.3148491680622101,
-0.048602133989334106,
0.9194632768630981,
-0.6247611045837402,
0.7744897603988647,
-0.1797151416540146,
-0.013721903786063194,
0.0325436033308506,
-0.657672107219696,
-0.7483028173446655,
-0.3457716703414917,
-0.4817524254322052,
-0.33423230051994324,
0.2836955785751343,
0.9509603381156921,
0.7336353063583374,
-0.8737586736679077,
-0.24129663407802582,
-0.01264734473079443,
0.277024507522583,
-0.23388640582561493,
-0.3105296492576599,
0.1762481927871704,
-0.15716777741909027,
-0.9423291683197021,
0.3773689568042755,
0.5146541595458984,
-0.4792484641075134,
-0.1537962406873703,
0.0859789103269577,
-0.8301615715026855,
-0.09417006373405457,
0.8275073766708374,
0.42377689480781555,
-0.42294928431510925,
-0.2561926245689392,
-0.0435856357216835,
-0.13089248538017273,
0.08362407982349396,
0.7161906361579895,
-0.4254397451877594,
0.5988592505455017,
0.5029698610305786,
0.7528944611549377,
0.06514973938465118,
-0.1699286699295044,
0.41263115406036377,
-1.1069622039794922,
0.23531924188137054,
0.28579896688461304,
0.2961968183517456,
0.7464287281036377,
-0.3815096616744995,
0.6311701536178589,
0.4501139223575592,
-0.04904080182313919,
-1.1919424533843994,
0.029093047603964806,
-0.6152909994125366,
-0.3061962425708771,
0.8400707244873047,
0.0017228815704584122,
-0.13511328399181366,
-0.8078309893608093,
-0.2266053557395935,
0.4524344503879547,
-0.41471049189567566,
0.8797092437744141,
0.627938985824585,
0.17970728874206543,
-0.45703938603401184,
-0.7449005246162415,
0.47805795073509216,
0.4256075620651245,
-0.651856541633606,
0.12462034076452255,
0.02590274251997471,
0.18647484481334686,
0.30436426401138306,
0.48070019483566284,
-0.4966987073421478,
0.19201691448688507,
-0.08292827010154724,
0.21763664484024048,
-0.007895056158304214,
-0.2688741385936737,
-0.39168763160705566,
0.22933541238307953,
-0.31173160672187805,
-0.5296070575714111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02009v1
|
Preuve de concept d'un bot vocal dialoguant en wolof
| 2024-04-02T14:53:41 | 2024-04-02T14:53:41 |
Elodie Gauthier, Papa-Séga Wade, Thierry Moudenc, Patrice Collen, Emilie De Neef, Oumar Ba, Ndeye Khoyane Cama, Cheikh Ahmadou Bamba Kebe, Ndeye Aissatou Gningue, Thomas Mendo'o Aristide
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
This paper presents the proof-of-concept of the first automatic voice
assistant ever built in Wolof language, the main vehicular language spoken in
Senegal. This voicebot is the result of a collaborative research project
between Orange Innovation in France, Orange Senegal (aka Sonatel) and ADNCorp,
a small IT company based in Dakar, Senegal. The purpose of the voicebot is to
provide information to Orange customers about the Sargal loyalty program of
Orange Senegal by using the most natural mean to communicate: speech. The
voicebot receives in input the customer's oral request that is then processed
by a SLU system to reply to the customer's request using audio recordings. The
first results of this proof-of-concept are encouraging as we achieved 22\% of
WER for the ASR task and 78\% of F1-score on the NLU task.
|
[
-0.7120164632797241,
-0.7865946888923645,
0.3088811933994293,
0.4321107864379883,
-0.06442411243915558,
0.15052619576454163,
0.013987093232572079,
-0.6810968518257141,
0.24862883985042572,
0.5861308574676514,
-0.41020962595939636,
-0.25307318568229675,
-0.44395434856414795,
0.09345649927854538,
-0.5075904726982117,
0.6098731756210327,
0.35972580313682556,
-0.16549214720726013,
0.15890054404735565,
-0.29483234882354736,
-0.32967254519462585,
-0.5622959136962891,
-0.8107770681381226,
0.01624666154384613,
0.4908195734024048,
0.5877097249031067,
0.540566623210907,
-0.07826882600784302,
0.15835359692573547,
0.4509477913379669,
-0.014759301207959652,
0.2278829962015152,
-0.21090728044509888,
-0.1858372539281845,
0.06752071529626846,
-0.4683725833892822,
-0.6391304135322571,
-0.11155662685632706,
0.217972069978714,
0.4646376669406891,
-0.5541326403617859,
0.010171834379434586,
0.06827699393033981,
0.8839293122291565,
-0.4548899829387665,
0.14074262976646423,
-0.556938111782074,
-0.21325595676898956,
0.04757501557469368,
0.09428680688142776,
-0.030205460265278816,
-0.3584292531013489,
0.2691183388233185,
-0.5547966361045837,
0.061385951936244965,
-0.09442177414894104,
0.9654707908630371,
0.5524937510490417,
-0.2602270841598511,
-0.5534684658050537,
-0.883375346660614,
0.4590725600719452,
-0.7026647329330444,
0.31177958846092224,
0.35340502858161926,
0.5559017062187195,
-0.365123987197876,
-0.5747889876365662,
-1.2498317956924438,
-0.10843829065561295,
0.1136082261800766,
0.08484259247779846,
-0.296078622341156,
0.0881149098277092,
-0.04376770183444023,
0.3377145528793335,
-0.5090891122817993,
-0.13170211017131805,
-0.4603668451309204,
-0.49085670709609985,
0.8449086546897888,
-0.44112148880958557,
0.3010775148868561,
0.011233609169721603,
-0.296835333108902,
-0.02650991454720497,
-0.285617470741272,
0.1075328066945076,
0.45877400040626526,
0.3233276307582855,
-0.11086210608482361,
0.5806301236152649,
-0.2638043761253357,
0.8819176554679871,
-0.18762534856796265,
-0.33432385325431824,
0.5002673864364624,
-0.1477849930524826,
-0.3810978829860687,
0.643235445022583,
1.1174986362457275,
-0.08050458878278732,
0.4320049285888672,
0.07261109352111816,
-0.3810011148452759,
-0.016329847276210785,
0.021033110097050667,
-0.380493700504303,
0.0515611506998539,
0.14254476130008698,
-0.3202890157699585,
-0.19223660230636597,
0.30763593316078186,
-0.36646315455436707,
0.02881103754043579,
-0.044710561633110046,
0.7577325701713562,
0.047287315130233765,
-0.6421182751655579,
0.06254463642835617,
-0.10047052055597305,
0.1780061572790146,
0.33270034193992615,
-0.3272484540939331,
0.23094424605369568,
0.2680080533027649,
0.6686890125274658,
0.06577412039041519,
-0.1765642762184143,
-0.34571918845176697,
0.002541002118960023,
-0.0005420789238996804,
0.9144288897514343,
-0.23035646975040436,
-0.8365126252174377,
0.058688655495643616,
0.24894393980503082,
0.12025118619203568,
-0.6091100573539734,
0.7351349592208862,
-0.30574434995651245,
0.28522324562072754,
0.252883642911911,
-0.20775271952152252,
-0.22419846057891846,
-0.03236716613173485,
-0.6399581432342529,
0.9809309244155884,
0.4040111303329468,
-0.3886681795120239,
0.24842703342437744,
-1.0824813842773438,
-0.7945298552513123,
0.15686069428920746,
-0.1162545457482338,
-0.2808859944343567,
-0.19487176835536957,
0.08124658465385437,
0.17735998332500458,
-0.3363497853279114,
0.08391338586807251,
0.2691830098628998,
-0.15017038583755493,
0.22528952360153198,
-0.3544277846813202,
1.1163911819458008,
0.4116613268852234,
-0.569374680519104,
-0.11473257839679718,
-0.9215021729469299,
0.10293236374855042,
0.2806113064289093,
-0.26721084117889404,
0.02271718718111515,
-0.4287647604942322,
0.3099091649055481,
0.2217828631401062,
0.3792305290699005,
-0.8921170234680176,
0.06890067458152771,
-0.5888393521308899,
0.4768418073654175,
0.28775471448898315,
-0.13744276762008667,
0.09638666361570358,
-0.1701958030462265,
0.6661994457244873,
-0.47656533122062683,
0.10985390841960907,
-0.07305332273244858,
-0.9621807336807251,
-0.6702527403831482,
-0.17015258967876434,
0.2585299611091614,
0.7923163771629333,
-0.5290114283561707,
0.6136811971664429,
0.29543763399124146,
-0.5539111495018005,
-0.4848640561103821,
0.17872637510299683,
0.28437840938568115,
0.65467369556427,
0.06375101953744888,
0.016856104135513306,
-0.47516536712646484,
-1.1320972442626953,
0.06620475649833679,
-0.5663865804672241,
0.04936620593070984,
0.43659505248069763,
0.2924957871437073,
-0.4217027723789215,
0.978089451789856,
-0.3068881630897522,
-0.7126568555831909,
-0.5049779415130615,
0.4326278567314148,
0.40885651111602783,
0.5552976727485657,
0.7719219923019409,
-1.1207575798034668,
-0.6297305226325989,
0.11316819489002228,
-0.427062064409256,
-0.3305598795413971,
0.4828277826309204,
-0.08620046824216843,
0.3192346394062042,
0.3551856577396393,
-0.45660293102264404,
0.7937968969345093,
0.8138635158538818,
-0.12278161942958832,
0.19149628281593323,
-0.47148597240448,
0.2930644750595093,
-0.8995176553726196,
-0.05471687391400337,
-0.37005215883255005,
-0.45288845896720886,
-0.3942551016807556,
-0.7494807243347168,
-0.36527344584465027,
-0.4391997456550598,
-0.7755084037780762,
0.522573709487915,
-0.19108590483665466,
-0.017459342256188393,
-0.6687621474266052,
0.07751526683568954,
-0.15423628687858582,
0.5068085789680481,
0.12691424787044525,
0.9379562139511108,
0.5417345762252808,
-1.1161284446716309,
0.4956040680408478,
0.6427128314971924,
-0.06393636018037796,
0.7061816453933716,
-1.1200413703918457,
0.20650309324264526,
0.26167193055152893,
-0.09507881850004196,
-1.159039855003357,
-0.04296194016933441,
-0.008816951885819435,
-0.7874783277511597,
-0.03935797140002251,
0.055619873106479645,
-0.4231823980808258,
-0.7397918105125427,
0.7140979766845703,
0.03845614567399025,
0.7751196026802063,
-0.47441962361335754,
0.42573466897010803,
1.1530262231826782,
-0.259684681892395,
-0.16142266988754272,
-0.6159688830375671,
0.10911276936531067,
-0.018332181498408318,
-0.8669202923774719,
0.19986814260482788,
0.2113638073205948,
-0.15087874233722687,
-0.3450697064399719,
0.015397140756249428,
-0.4421660602092743,
0.08957729488611221,
0.08297207951545715,
-0.03544048219919205,
-0.07008019089698792,
0.024262987077236176,
-0.1973111778497696,
-0.16491317749023438,
-0.11856679618358612,
-0.4118993282318115,
0.6448657512664795,
-0.4141343832015991,
-0.18565070629119873,
-0.7870669364929199,
0.3228462338447571,
0.6108818054199219,
-0.2665727734565735,
0.6146807670593262,
0.566901683807373,
-0.36375194787979126,
-0.07622427493333817,
-0.5176259875297546,
0.14851146936416626,
-0.5519101619720459,
0.11107156425714493,
-0.1214735209941864,
-0.4579867124557495,
0.1847948282957077,
-0.22641924023628235,
-0.04152669012546539,
0.473533034324646,
0.4214550256729126,
-0.6135223507881165,
1.0827239751815796,
1.0414124727249146,
0.09707663208246231,
0.5698255300521851,
-0.49749934673309326,
0.10507988929748535,
-0.4653148949146271,
-0.36167487502098083,
-0.7132492065429688,
-0.2324020266532898,
-0.8191443681716919,
-0.14643575251102448,
0.5653997659683228,
0.03858677297830582,
-0.054897721856832504,
0.5496382117271423,
-0.5543185472488403,
-0.055340491235256195,
0.6174329519271851,
-0.04676831141114235,
0.15321384370326996,
-0.3302600383758545,
-0.0009668671991676092,
0.2732333242893219,
-0.9000923037528992,
-0.7055380344390869,
0.692582905292511,
-0.028193484991788864,
0.6019721031188965,
-0.03973327577114105,
0.6587173342704773,
0.5942091345787048,
0.09312666952610016,
-0.7865117788314819,
0.5094249248504639,
-0.06727641820907593,
-0.32583755254745483,
-0.7813611030578613,
-0.043817952275276184,
-1.1150070428848267,
-0.05424321070313454,
0.23654773831367493,
-0.682370126247406,
0.3080310821533203,
0.7338319420814514,
0.022472994402050972,
-0.10608777403831482,
-0.8481153249740601,
0.9924506545066833,
-0.7652912735939026,
-0.11181402951478958,
0.038616035133600235,
-0.5854027271270752,
-0.07300026714801788,
0.2558552920818329,
0.36320480704307556,
-0.14520396292209625,
0.27348053455352783,
0.9657914042472839,
-0.8138892650604248,
0.2825620472431183,
-0.6292997598648071,
-0.5292057394981384,
0.7072837352752686,
-0.23860305547714233,
0.6459258794784546,
-0.005124576855450869,
-0.034137021750211716,
0.059399593621492386,
-0.24987107515335083,
-0.2518208622932434,
-0.469882607460022,
0.47488853335380554,
-0.539662778377533,
-0.5362244248390198,
-0.3614589273929596,
-0.24366769194602966,
-0.4244033098220825,
0.42174553871154785,
0.25717076659202576,
0.188673198223114,
-0.5390068292617798,
0.1710779368877411,
0.49414217472076416,
-0.48024260997772217,
0.4870057702064514,
0.6248210072517395,
-0.26604267954826355,
-0.26064664125442505,
0.983634352684021,
-0.30922722816467285,
0.4355242848396301,
0.4646994471549988,
0.41110894083976746,
-0.49547457695007324,
-0.22888068854808807,
-0.5164818167686462,
0.14291271567344666,
-0.34623727202415466,
0.03126555681228638,
-0.857168436050415,
-0.14579500257968903,
-0.3594251871109009,
0.005353021435439587,
-0.7468889355659485,
-0.44602474570274353,
0.17939241230487823,
0.22980815172195435,
0.4265132248401642,
0.8347374200820923,
-0.15871618688106537,
0.4506767988204956,
-0.5928724408149719,
0.6323263645172119,
0.6367909908294678,
-0.22442197799682617,
-0.4782414138317108,
-0.23462995886802673,
-0.1778562217950821,
0.5102895498275757,
-0.1919199526309967,
-0.5388891100883484,
0.46740657091140747,
0.39444801211357117,
0.8528829216957092,
0.2634377181529999,
0.0883338525891304,
0.5062728524208069,
-0.3274425268173218,
0.7146960496902466,
0.21197746694087982,
-0.9160186052322388,
0.964759886264801,
-0.1967017501592636,
0.4410528838634491,
0.48783573508262634,
0.044433511793613434,
-0.4888639450073242,
-0.5201604962348938,
-0.7369202375411987,
-0.6816641092300415,
0.5650490522384644,
0.5430454015731812,
-0.15325069427490234,
0.09664303064346313,
-0.046572551131248474,
0.07496144622564316,
0.6319265961647034,
-0.3670397996902466,
-0.5032429695129395,
-0.40073180198669434,
-0.1967284232378006,
-0.035409633070230484,
0.1237405315041542,
0.09600339084863663,
-0.2149430811405182,
0.6968266367912292,
-0.24693983793258667,
0.6458059549331665,
0.6234923005104065,
-0.3039739727973938,
0.16761821508407593,
0.3596203625202179,
0.818265438079834,
0.746991753578186,
0.07801100611686707,
-0.28876566886901855,
-0.07157395780086517,
-0.5407460927963257,
0.29167604446411133,
-0.0794859230518341,
0.04466228559613228,
0.29923710227012634,
0.058293864130973816,
0.7269346117973328,
-0.09139192849397659,
-0.9185340404510498,
0.6251594424247742,
-0.10730361193418503,
-0.2653607726097107,
-0.7472596168518066,
0.347619891166687,
0.08165404945611954,
0.03477688878774643,
0.4750727713108063,
0.0037963443901389837,
0.22974252700805664,
-0.6200032234191895,
0.1881944090127945,
0.6062495708465576,
-0.6359236240386963,
-0.20879966020584106,
0.7695130705833435,
0.6548711657524109,
-0.8381134271621704,
0.19576330482959747,
-0.3814444839954376,
-1.0427939891815186,
0.8325570821762085,
0.5763064026832581,
0.8325483798980713,
-0.27944499254226685,
0.40344828367233276,
0.3085971772670746,
0.14314575493335724,
-0.0069302404299378395,
0.6753137707710266,
-0.3156364858150482,
-0.6367391347885132,
0.11876346915960312,
-0.5725478529930115,
-0.37006667256355286,
-0.008850396610796452,
-0.6522516012191772,
0.3394361138343811,
-0.12266425043344498,
-0.09522945433855057,
-0.16098491847515106,
-0.35930752754211426,
-0.960721492767334,
0.47733211517333984,
0.03923637792468071,
0.7134182453155518,
-0.5174500942230225,
0.8629295825958252,
0.6697396636009216,
-0.31456127762794495,
-0.5124524235725403,
-0.05120231583714485,
-0.2884936034679413,
-1.1517789363861084,
1.1781429052352905,
-0.027990641072392464,
-0.7785417437553406,
0.23323605954647064,
-0.4813890755176544,
-0.5618126392364502,
0.7296997904777527,
0.3146826922893524,
-1.029140591621399,
0.3684048056602478,
0.22100627422332764,
0.4222984313964844,
-0.3915787935256958,
0.06743693351745605,
0.4965273141860962,
0.6967604160308838,
0.1758928745985031,
-1.607078194618225,
-0.5360379219055176,
-0.3085334300994873,
-0.16818289458751678,
0.034127913415431976,
-0.8054003715515137,
0.5859680771827698,
-0.48197558522224426,
-0.17717421054840088,
0.19323496520519257,
0.666312038898468,
-0.22926877439022064,
0.21474185585975647,
0.9356861114501953,
0.359884649515152,
0.9068633317947388,
-0.005976238753646612,
0.9014990329742432,
-0.2613343596458435,
-0.041444145143032074,
0.9988601803779602,
-0.319095641374588,
0.5510752201080322,
0.5129379630088806,
-0.29198217391967773,
0.5263259410858154,
0.13394759595394135,
0.43536967039108276,
0.5959731340408325,
0.2573060393333435,
-0.168882355093956,
0.07647508382797241,
-0.302740216255188,
-0.39816102385520935,
0.8779340386390686,
0.4782605767250061,
0.06311852484941483,
0.30609333515167236,
0.7061770558357239,
-0.29566308856010437,
0.169186070561409,
-0.22741955518722534,
1.0318008661270142,
-0.08298574388027191,
-0.5003135204315186,
0.7016005516052246,
-0.47153788805007935,
0.656423807144165,
-0.5723001956939697,
-0.223602756857872,
0.19157598912715912,
0.23977306485176086,
-0.06834516674280167,
-0.799773633480072,
0.2367718517780304,
-0.014307528734207153,
0.10395684838294983,
-0.2294933944940567,
0.45126864314079285,
-0.5462308526039124,
-0.5738215446472168,
0.2640882730484009,
0.5254766345024109,
0.18979118764400482,
-0.18039482831954956,
-0.8410214781761169,
-0.0772884339094162,
0.023493748158216476,
0.0981128141283989,
-0.3903603255748749,
0.5359416604042053,
0.18063591420650482,
0.6318474411964417,
0.5718930959701538,
0.2848072052001953,
-0.0029289228841662407,
0.3125738203525543,
0.46516185998916626,
-0.6063251495361328,
-0.8956888318061829,
-0.4251972436904907,
0.503125011920929,
-0.09884953498840332,
-0.4581158459186554,
0.6318372488021851,
0.5279332399368286,
0.9260799884796143,
0.054286446422338486,
1.2429653406143188,
-0.48705390095710754,
0.7298603057861328,
-0.31660377979278564,
0.7966226935386658,
-0.8024591207504272,
-0.02166166342794895,
-0.49441638588905334,
-0.8916624188423157,
0.32280299067497253,
1.0987554788589478,
0.20111212134361267,
-0.15234529972076416,
0.6295111179351807,
0.745469331741333,
0.2624477744102478,
0.07257512211799622,
0.48547518253326416,
0.18473447859287262,
0.42645347118377686,
0.1504986584186554,
0.910515546798706,
-0.6847897171974182,
0.8194059133529663,
-0.3350239098072052,
-0.2973622977733612,
-0.12259697169065475,
-0.6692790389060974,
-0.8550365567207336,
-0.6235920190811157,
-0.258676141500473,
-0.18743079900741577,
-0.02486312948167324,
0.776873767375946,
0.7423092722892761,
-0.935038149356842,
-0.4432111382484436,
-0.4450630843639374,
0.1764165759086609,
-0.27388766407966614,
-0.2384861707687378,
0.06412435322999954,
0.12677808105945587,
-1.0069068670272827,
0.4495694041252136,
0.33920782804489136,
0.383230060338974,
-0.4854801595211029,
-0.43720555305480957,
-0.3333052098751068,
-0.2440803498029709,
0.40528225898742676,
0.7033476233482361,
-0.6686323285102844,
-0.1695338785648346,
0.15483622252941132,
0.11013835668563843,
0.22413116693496704,
0.8935367465019226,
-0.7937471270561218,
0.6012967824935913,
0.35297054052352905,
0.38465604186058044,
0.3492724597454071,
-0.08229831606149673,
1.0502405166625977,
-0.5654881000518799,
0.8535773754119873,
0.45187482237815857,
0.44610610604286194,
0.2940666675567627,
-0.46913108229637146,
0.3310560882091522,
0.18731689453125,
-0.543383002281189,
-0.5522328019142151,
0.15433938801288605,
-1.0272226333618164,
0.13156947493553162,
0.7979544997215271,
0.20052753388881683,
-0.3265276849269867,
-0.5051486492156982,
-0.8902094960212708,
0.31729018688201904,
-0.7870559692382812,
0.44104713201522827,
0.41328251361846924,
-0.41600170731544495,
-0.046782903373241425,
-0.5105050206184387,
0.44985008239746094,
0.055438075214624405,
-0.9949591755867004,
-0.38413482904434204,
-0.08865249902009964,
-0.16921497881412506,
0.35702311992645264,
0.769234299659729,
-0.022031350061297417,
0.6190517544746399,
-0.08359567821025848,
0.19265522062778473,
-0.13796301186084747,
-0.3199784755706787,
0.36875125765800476,
-0.0702122375369072,
-0.07144898921251297,
-0.6156337261199951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02000v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02000v3
|
Africa-Centric Self-Supervised Pre-Training for Multilingual Speech Representation in a Sub-Saharan Context
| 2024-04-02T14:43:36 | 2024-04-22T09:18:44 |
Antoine Caubrière, Elodie Gauthier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We present the first self-supervised multilingual speech model trained
exclusively on African speech. The model learned from nearly 60 000 hours of
unlabeled speech segments in 21 languages and dialects spoken in sub-Saharan
Africa. On the SSA subset of the FLEURS-102 dataset, our approach based on a
HuBERT$_{base}$ (0.09B) architecture shows competitive results, for ASR
downstream task, compared to the w2v-bert-51 (0.6B) pre-trained model proposed
in the FLEURS benchmark, while being more efficient by using 7x less data and
6x less parameters. Furthermore, in the context of a LID downstream task, our
approach outperforms FLEURS baselines accuracy by over 22\%.
|
[
-0.7051353454589844,
-0.3613002598285675,
0.14300571382045746,
0.5195335149765015,
-0.2389722317457199,
-0.22672218084335327,
-0.3927636742591858,
-0.5028836727142334,
0.6430743336677551,
0.5349680185317993,
-0.7569113969802856,
-0.27808254957199097,
-0.5828651189804077,
0.11462058871984482,
-0.39392828941345215,
0.7041183114051819,
0.20746052265167236,
0.23018065094947815,
-0.02968820556998253,
-0.18699869513511658,
-0.03386678174138069,
-1.0565330982208252,
-0.4323398768901825,
-0.16245043277740479,
0.6240631341934204,
0.44756102561950684,
0.19067128002643585,
0.27585411071777344,
-0.07235527038574219,
0.3157554566860199,
0.10619258135557175,
0.18395529687404633,
-0.36799556016921997,
-0.16272972524166107,
-0.0689629539847374,
0.037449050694704056,
-0.3800683915615082,
-0.004174124915152788,
0.07754894345998764,
0.6733739376068115,
-0.2841170132160187,
0.28703629970550537,
-0.004993070848286152,
0.5313711762428284,
-0.5661782622337341,
0.12417405843734741,
-0.5254245400428772,
-0.20750205218791962,
-0.7000155448913574,
-0.007235234137624502,
-0.3892776370048523,
0.320634126663208,
0.21239688992500305,
-0.44117555022239685,
0.287433385848999,
-0.527574896812439,
0.6347761750221252,
0.11665381491184235,
-0.4798496961593628,
-0.2167108803987503,
-0.6142515540122986,
0.5893197059631348,
-0.4672289192676544,
0.6254956722259521,
0.4188251495361328,
0.39284080266952515,
0.20323622226715088,
-0.9399710893630981,
-0.18866989016532898,
0.04546339064836502,
0.14902348816394806,
0.12822094559669495,
-0.0008995027747005224,
-0.19375573098659515,
-0.07197217643260956,
0.06560679525136948,
-0.4177539348602295,
0.18533527851104736,
-0.652878999710083,
-0.47404715418815613,
1.0059902667999268,
-0.5402842164039612,
-0.11173425614833832,
-0.006498268805444241,
-0.4049387276172638,
0.09859517216682434,
-0.49416807293891907,
0.04486113041639328,
0.3810654878616333,
0.7414307594299316,
-0.2829718291759491,
0.1958172619342804,
-0.3224254548549652,
0.6702939867973328,
-0.18566147983074188,
-0.08689658343791962,
0.46439141035079956,
-0.02425627037882805,
0.023124748840928078,
0.2697373926639557,
0.8892917633056641,
-0.20980499684810638,
0.7784942388534546,
-0.0898064523935318,
-0.44323521852493286,
-0.036002811044454575,
0.4686320722103119,
-0.6711046695709229,
-0.5230739712715149,
-0.145142063498497,
-0.3567380905151367,
0.12738724052906036,
-0.15812009572982788,
-0.5134296417236328,
-0.04379323124885559,
-0.5265618562698364,
0.6044771671295166,
-0.34441712498664856,
-0.16435691714286804,
-0.3778592050075531,
0.5077508687973022,
-0.04626789689064026,
0.10775352269411087,
-1.0134267807006836,
0.059539586305618286,
0.3219683766365051,
0.7617535591125488,
-0.023829560726881027,
-0.43034881353378296,
-0.3420378267765045,
0.09015779942274094,
-0.2690947651863098,
0.6973349452018738,
-0.16431500017642975,
-0.4766748547554016,
0.026202989742159843,
-0.005194738041609526,
0.06361076980829239,
-0.23354671895503998,
0.598553478717804,
-0.4003722667694092,
-0.09859313815832138,
-0.40035852789878845,
-0.49595069885253906,
-0.2921777367591858,
-0.3011218011379242,
-0.4757736921310425,
0.8500112295150757,
0.20959489047527313,
-0.38523635268211365,
0.465082049369812,
-0.5154709219932556,
-0.7118024230003357,
0.07892124354839325,
-0.43176132440567017,
-0.30871039628982544,
0.06109199300408363,
0.8086408376693726,
0.24895288050174713,
0.0265035480260849,
0.1414734572172165,
-0.09900981187820435,
-0.09679098427295685,
-0.20147332549095154,
-0.4994734525680542,
0.9455634355545044,
0.2638283371925354,
-0.41639378666877747,
0.18913498520851135,
-0.7860075235366821,
0.046592868864536285,
0.1522899866104126,
0.12161184102296829,
-0.174759179353714,
-0.23201465606689453,
0.20859336853027344,
0.3925621509552002,
0.31557488441467285,
-0.9080039262771606,
-0.11072850972414017,
-0.3578822910785675,
0.4075213670730591,
0.7020817399024963,
-0.17840053141117096,
0.2058655023574829,
0.13932009041309357,
0.38889268040657043,
0.08127296715974808,
0.18610085546970367,
-0.10647408664226532,
-0.3733934462070465,
-0.8407391905784607,
-0.5401060581207275,
0.7326424717903137,
0.4172256290912628,
-0.5533121824264526,
0.24606412649154663,
-0.20495112240314484,
-0.611471951007843,
-0.7424736022949219,
0.4528353214263916,
0.18197058141231537,
0.4540562331676483,
0.7164241671562195,
-0.1966087967157364,
-0.6975067853927612,
-1.159490942955017,
0.08517125248908997,
0.24231746792793274,
0.1593482941389084,
0.13298185169696808,
0.4651470482349396,
-0.40710964798927307,
0.9389078617095947,
-0.11383122205734253,
-0.7958125472068787,
-0.43133997917175293,
0.27761897444725037,
0.13455885648727417,
0.5502278804779053,
1.0658133029937744,
-0.803921103477478,
-0.5458975434303284,
-0.2626141607761383,
-0.6277632117271423,
-0.25101786851882935,
0.2615055739879608,
0.04643518477678299,
0.5326094627380371,
0.6911139488220215,
-0.25004103779792786,
0.4826570153236389,
0.8476772308349609,
0.228036031126976,
0.15123318135738373,
-0.370687872171402,
-0.17539654672145844,
-0.8669528961181641,
-0.13260644674301147,
-0.16174998879432678,
-0.32343950867652893,
-0.8542001843452454,
-0.447920024394989,
0.14535079896450043,
-0.4111916422843933,
-0.42599785327911377,
0.3381879925727844,
-0.6215340495109558,
-0.1594659835100174,
-0.3469923138618469,
0.1127614676952362,
-0.2836247384548187,
0.629004716873169,
0.5358455181121826,
0.9330742955207825,
0.6705114245414734,
-0.6939110159873962,
0.11504549533128738,
0.3192218840122223,
-0.3433942496776581,
0.364557683467865,
-0.6849209070205688,
0.3356153964996338,
-0.2150251716375351,
0.23814719915390015,
-0.8444663286209106,
-0.03853652998805046,
-0.30473795533180237,
-0.4815672039985657,
0.3837905526161194,
-0.17478491365909576,
-0.024558933451771736,
-0.335933119058609,
0.406541109085083,
0.4430033564567566,
0.24330328404903412,
-0.6870158910751343,
0.7250904440879822,
0.7323650121688843,
-0.4451563358306885,
-0.6284562945365906,
-1.1194097995758057,
-0.14055389165878296,
0.081163190305233,
-0.6466044783592224,
0.21560420095920563,
0.3019755184650421,
0.19450774788856506,
-0.4438769221305847,
-0.21731173992156982,
-0.09166858345270157,
-0.10425449162721634,
0.3076700270175934,
-0.23190851509571075,
-0.2021118849515915,
0.06834380328655243,
-0.11102547496557236,
-0.13227568566799164,
-0.00741844717413187,
-0.3782617747783661,
0.7214637994766235,
0.03710906580090523,
-0.40883857011795044,
-0.4396428167819977,
0.5620894432067871,
0.020635444670915604,
-0.7337339520454407,
0.9168592691421509,
0.6263951659202576,
-0.23388002812862396,
-0.17406165599822998,
-0.5236924886703491,
-0.16229470074176788,
-0.46320641040802,
0.1585012525320053,
-0.7257953882217407,
-0.7303570508956909,
0.5289465188980103,
0.24804314970970154,
0.06719648092985153,
0.5033832788467407,
0.46463215351104736,
-0.2626209259033203,
0.811810314655304,
0.632036566734314,
-0.2291935831308365,
0.5186184048652649,
-0.5694717168807983,
0.26630091667175293,
-0.49857762455940247,
-0.31251147389411926,
-0.4384068250656128,
-0.1905660182237625,
-0.606050968170166,
-0.32114672660827637,
0.41112521290779114,
0.11886169761419296,
-0.13861258327960968,
0.325812429189682,
-0.18978601694107056,
0.0002746756945271045,
0.7387949824333191,
0.07720990478992462,
-0.28317803144454956,
0.08532159775495529,
-0.1909605711698532,
-0.08143851906061172,
-0.850485622882843,
-0.3891661763191223,
1.0521591901779175,
0.15246684849262238,
0.6566398739814758,
0.11627605557441711,
1.0838840007781982,
0.43690499663352966,
0.6287145018577576,
-0.4754039943218231,
0.26515331864356995,
-0.45201343297958374,
-0.7841401100158691,
-0.4479386806488037,
-0.37656888365745544,
-0.8959835171699524,
0.5359000563621521,
-0.028164541348814964,
-0.6474922895431519,
0.30039191246032715,
0.32045722007751465,
-0.31001660227775574,
0.1397409290075302,
-0.6289700865745544,
1.043463110923767,
-0.559604287147522,
0.02669444866478443,
-0.0064411526545882225,
-0.8020719289779663,
0.10231734067201614,
-0.32824796438217163,
0.5475209355354309,
-0.1834608018398285,
0.27437856793403625,
0.7604541182518005,
-0.5967569947242737,
0.5143908858299255,
-0.6240795850753784,
-0.171128511428833,
0.39114075899124146,
-0.03515464439988136,
0.04750325530767441,
-0.10482382029294968,
-0.10645659267902374,
0.7562711238861084,
-0.1082478016614914,
-0.6118931770324707,
-0.15373769402503967,
0.6158803701400757,
-0.9647325277328491,
-0.4008375108242035,
-0.48777133226394653,
-0.35235393047332764,
-0.5601444840431213,
0.31750816106796265,
0.577965497970581,
0.9240714907646179,
-0.18875820934772491,
0.33052071928977966,
0.3002969026565552,
-0.025344207882881165,
0.4707989990711212,
0.6145756244659424,
-0.25382742285728455,
-0.5345517992973328,
0.8040152192115784,
0.3842286169528961,
0.24429388344287872,
0.3411328196525574,
-0.056874990463256836,
-0.6926377415657043,
-0.5160653591156006,
-0.6006349325180054,
0.31435471773147583,
-0.7996354103088379,
-0.21832610666751862,
-0.8610329627990723,
-0.4023899435997009,
-0.8506131172180176,
0.04391924664378166,
-0.636106014251709,
-0.32252001762390137,
-0.3594367504119873,
-0.18910099565982819,
0.17268410325050354,
0.6313675045967102,
-0.60051429271698,
0.7405748963356018,
-0.7189628481864929,
0.36655500531196594,
0.4427333474159241,
-0.00761177996173501,
-0.17419402301311493,
-0.8226523995399475,
-0.2987954914569855,
0.4443456828594208,
0.0780477225780487,
-0.7379592657089233,
0.6307140588760376,
0.6328846216201782,
0.7618492841720581,
0.2885148525238037,
0.0658159852027893,
0.814176619052887,
-0.5631352066993713,
0.8032446503639221,
-0.015220214612782001,
-1.1727802753448486,
0.6711272597312927,
-0.07293026149272919,
0.2210085093975067,
0.7098375558853149,
0.6131306886672974,
-0.1816951036453247,
0.004240585491061211,
-0.48362794518470764,
-0.8638296723365784,
0.780234158039093,
0.22700335085391998,
0.05819755047559738,
-0.012154270894825459,
0.17635558545589447,
0.0929470807313919,
0.2493768334388733,
-0.6271833181381226,
-0.4984847903251648,
-0.5975950360298157,
-0.08838751167058945,
-0.7402767539024353,
-0.2823064923286438,
-0.05004396662116051,
-0.2060650736093521,
0.9137899279594421,
-0.20993785560131073,
0.19483375549316406,
0.47209832072257996,
-0.6078947186470032,
0.11749553680419922,
0.12025590240955353,
0.7235620021820068,
0.949414849281311,
-0.048518408089876175,
-0.0353558287024498,
0.08006563037633896,
-0.1804855763912201,
0.2750323414802551,
0.40513893961906433,
-0.12387622147798538,
0.0684828832745552,
0.5078199505805969,
0.8943670392036438,
0.03228342905640602,
-0.378436803817749,
0.5758193135261536,
-0.03750402852892876,
-0.17069052159786224,
-0.6379383206367493,
-0.4700827896595001,
0.1543901562690735,
-0.006098917219787836,
0.4399307370185852,
-0.05565345287322998,
0.062131237238645554,
-0.4202028214931488,
0.46228495240211487,
0.2781515121459961,
-0.657298743724823,
-0.17879655957221985,
0.7315483689308167,
0.48590731620788574,
-0.11337679624557495,
0.5002203583717346,
0.0044703297317028046,
-0.6054580211639404,
0.28232550621032715,
0.4038824141025543,
0.4689013361930847,
-0.6514958739280701,
0.24263307452201843,
0.19168701767921448,
0.45017388463020325,
0.28368502855300903,
0.5574116110801697,
-0.18148793280124664,
-0.7111721038818359,
-0.41487690806388855,
-0.8893583416938782,
-0.005877509713172913,
0.09779985249042511,
-0.8802562355995178,
0.028853001073002815,
-0.0807543396949768,
-0.21757614612579346,
0.29206857085227966,
-0.20347556471824646,
-0.5821506977081299,
0.5242974758148193,
0.4306603670120239,
0.9879835247993469,
-0.9785317182540894,
1.0649926662445068,
0.6874450445175171,
-0.35865190625190735,
-0.7555313110351562,
-0.2682068943977356,
-0.10642329603433609,
-0.6691134572029114,
0.7041019797325134,
0.3137844502925873,
-0.42911824584007263,
0.04668731242418289,
-0.25505104660987854,
-0.9657871127128601,
0.5888239741325378,
0.5205024480819702,
-0.7711137533187866,
0.4529821574687958,
0.20333179831504822,
0.5142144560813904,
-0.5742799639701843,
-0.03491482883691788,
0.46296679973602295,
0.16456735134124756,
0.06563246995210648,
-1.1205288171768188,
-0.644314169883728,
0.02107025310397148,
0.054118331521749496,
0.16295748949050903,
-0.7041051983833313,
0.9293621182441711,
-0.13149109482765198,
-0.04109109565615654,
0.06981877237558365,
1.2829442024230957,
-0.05246599391102791,
0.07732335478067398,
0.6908336281776428,
0.4167831242084503,
0.6064361333847046,
-0.22795410454273224,
0.9683324694633484,
-0.5193460583686829,
0.19691599905490875,
1.2934660911560059,
-0.27426210045814514,
0.7094565629959106,
0.2052818238735199,
0.03660537675023079,
0.5253092050552368,
0.7931399345397949,
0.5921230912208557,
0.7300383448600769,
-0.01466913428157568,
-0.09474129974842072,
-0.5646337866783142,
-0.2162495255470276,
-0.5681821703910828,
0.9765737056732178,
0.37689685821533203,
-0.1392786204814911,
-0.0682099461555481,
0.23204123973846436,
-0.20914718508720398,
0.15566641092300415,
-0.5783792734146118,
0.6697219610214233,
0.2453259974718094,
-0.4365277588367462,
0.5805819034576416,
-0.20326711237430573,
0.5824387669563293,
-0.9886048436164856,
0.4601824879646301,
-0.1680338978767395,
0.2940446436405182,
-0.1651078760623932,
-0.414580762386322,
0.1519724577665329,
-0.08162271976470947,
0.04728609696030617,
-0.3633917570114136,
0.4640522301197052,
-0.8014089465141296,
-0.6049908399581909,
0.5867582559585571,
0.5152587890625,
0.13463635742664337,
-0.33236342668533325,
-0.5193161368370056,
0.03432544693350792,
0.05225193127989769,
-0.11256906390190125,
0.04420554265379906,
0.37825635075569153,
-0.1294410079717636,
0.5925789475440979,
0.4080784022808075,
0.19450287520885468,
0.2526373267173767,
0.5897597670555115,
0.6616544723510742,
-0.3610078692436218,
-0.8619883060455322,
-0.4762263000011444,
0.24322642385959625,
-0.003492680611088872,
-0.29471832513809204,
0.7571286559104919,
0.6062865257263184,
1.0659990310668945,
-0.1602402925491333,
0.8516799807548523,
-0.020985422655940056,
0.7311424016952515,
-0.35375115275382996,
0.5382729172706604,
-0.7200717926025391,
-0.39742258191108704,
-0.1642395555973053,
-0.8317283391952515,
0.24032877385616302,
0.811977207660675,
-0.24698835611343384,
0.25601404905319214,
0.20048058032989502,
0.5757282376289368,
-0.17654947936534882,
0.11624156683683395,
0.3309028744697571,
-0.04426782578229904,
0.3101000189781189,
0.08222542703151703,
0.5744754672050476,
-0.30399808287620544,
0.3582872450351715,
-0.7521055340766907,
-0.14719197154045105,
-0.006171543151140213,
-0.6655276417732239,
-0.8053001761436462,
-0.6193479895591736,
-0.0831565409898758,
0.007168690674006939,
-0.08955249935388565,
1.0577802658081055,
1.2107093334197998,
-1.3383498191833496,
-0.46164584159851074,
0.3336602747440338,
-0.5362095832824707,
-0.32952097058296204,
-0.10821777582168579,
0.21456529200077057,
-0.2626546621322632,
-0.4864269196987152,
0.9394643306732178,
0.15372131764888763,
0.18536539375782013,
-0.5771603584289551,
-0.010047194547951221,
-0.601101815700531,
0.022039731964468956,
0.5972800254821777,
0.29169243574142456,
-0.5689252018928528,
-0.08779514580965042,
-0.30408260226249695,
0.0792027935385704,
0.08716268092393875,
0.8135551810264587,
-0.6286092400550842,
0.6047255396842957,
0.10521991550922394,
0.48815444111824036,
0.9744789004325867,
0.2854406237602234,
0.6841246485710144,
-1.1659536361694336,
0.718052089214325,
0.30740538239479065,
0.5592030882835388,
0.6426677107810974,
-0.034078966826200485,
0.528374195098877,
0.1176837608218193,
-0.47641852498054504,
-0.5655065178871155,
0.2488413006067276,
-0.8546700477600098,
-0.0020011586602777243,
0.8567385673522949,
-0.4277031123638153,
-0.11737228184938431,
-0.08154596388339996,
-0.02630675956606865,
0.3272915780544281,
-0.4189116954803467,
0.2899974584579468,
0.4870290756225586,
-0.2265966236591339,
-0.22982220351696014,
-0.41119641065597534,
0.509204626083374,
0.31153199076652527,
-0.7130107879638672,
-0.19159440696239471,
0.33073386549949646,
0.22603002190589905,
0.36872977018356323,
0.841972827911377,
0.12988589704036713,
-0.01644544117152691,
-0.07664848119020462,
0.24533526599407196,
-0.1050766259431839,
-0.702172577381134,
-0.3344322443008423,
0.1405409276485443,
-0.21361397206783295,
-0.31402653455734253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01994v1
|
DELAN: Dual-Level Alignment for Vision-and-Language Navigation by Cross-Modal Contrastive Learning
| 2024-04-02T14:40:04 | 2024-04-02T14:40:04 |
Mengfei Du, Binhao Wu, Jiwen Zhang, Zhihao Fan, Zejun Li, Ruipu Luo, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision-and-Language navigation (VLN) requires an agent to navigate in unseen
environment by following natural language instruction. For task completion, the
agent needs to align and integrate various navigation modalities, including
instruction, observation and navigation history. Existing works primarily
concentrate on cross-modal attention at the fusion stage to achieve this
objective. Nevertheless, modality features generated by disparate uni-encoders
reside in their own spaces, leading to a decline in the quality of cross-modal
fusion and decision. To address this problem, we propose a Dual-levEL AligNment
(DELAN) framework by cross-modal contrastive learning. This framework is
designed to align various navigation-related modalities before fusion, thereby
enhancing cross-modal interaction and action decision-making. Specifically, we
divide the pre-fusion alignment into dual levels: instruction-history level and
landmark-observation level according to their semantic correlations. We also
reconstruct a dual-level instruction for adaptation to the dual-level
alignment. As the training signals for pre-fusion alignment are extremely
limited, self-supervised contrastive learning strategies are employed to
enforce the matching between different modalities. Our approach seamlessly
integrates with the majority of existing models, resulting in improved
navigation performance on various VLN benchmarks, including R2R, R4R, RxR and
CVDN.
|
[
-0.29984691739082336,
-0.25102922320365906,
0.3702673614025116,
-0.1342647671699524,
-0.20078103244304657,
0.15537039935588837,
-0.11464483290910721,
-0.41012296080589294,
0.21331709623336792,
0.4566655457019806,
-0.6519562602043152,
-0.6328939199447632,
-0.24209201335906982,
-0.26768648624420166,
0.061494845896959305,
0.7182136178016663,
-0.0563981793820858,
0.12261182814836502,
-0.02852657251060009,
-0.21149949729442596,
-0.6353906393051147,
-0.17332550883293152,
-0.6192821860313416,
-0.17373250424861908,
0.6620444059371948,
0.31147435307502747,
0.7803151607513428,
0.6155745387077332,
0.6188227534294128,
0.27501386404037476,
0.058033671230077744,
0.45299842953681946,
-0.49280062317848206,
0.12194403260946274,
-0.6495920419692993,
-0.25803545117378235,
-0.3973739743232727,
-0.26724427938461304,
0.601832389831543,
0.5653012990951538,
0.1499190777540207,
-0.28802627325057983,
0.18963319063186646,
0.6823861002922058,
-0.8347846865653992,
0.23207104206085205,
-0.18163509666919708,
0.25936993956565857,
-0.05837661027908325,
-0.17597931623458862,
-0.04227609559893608,
-0.06938227266073227,
0.3903040885925293,
-1.078948736190796,
-0.03184780105948448,
-0.03409073129296303,
0.7566353678703308,
0.7934157848358154,
-0.8556642532348633,
-0.024349872022867203,
-0.7014236450195312,
0.8447410464286804,
-0.3856046497821808,
0.6317561864852905,
0.16789507865905762,
0.47405827045440674,
0.05271294713020325,
-0.4469049274921417,
-0.5540709495544434,
-0.1488264501094818,
-0.3623560070991516,
0.5654408931732178,
0.063321053981781,
0.24966517090797424,
-0.07879579067230225,
0.45085570216178894,
-0.8400285243988037,
0.34269219636917114,
-0.333858460187912,
-0.21879903972148895,
0.3953871428966522,
0.3702690303325653,
0.3210641145706177,
-0.06927435100078583,
-0.870885968208313,
-0.39616429805755615,
-0.47550860047340393,
0.04389631748199463,
0.07547083497047424,
0.5894816517829895,
-0.29660889506340027,
0.3673996925354004,
-0.2763640582561493,
0.8628306984901428,
0.4110155403614044,
-0.13894571363925934,
0.5031622648239136,
-0.8965780138969421,
-0.2551923096179962,
0.0670015811920166,
0.6569351553916931,
0.5045445561408997,
-0.06259613484144211,
0.09968321025371552,
-0.26660022139549255,
0.21498370170593262,
0.4710157811641693,
-0.3608858287334442,
-0.23667290806770325,
-0.08931587636470795,
-0.29728925228118896,
-0.15346777439117432,
-0.07712964713573456,
-0.7842841744422913,
-0.4862525761127472,
-0.5909323692321777,
0.778550386428833,
-0.26578637957572937,
-0.3541468381881714,
0.2436099797487259,
0.15615375339984894,
0.5467691421508789,
0.5621570944786072,
-0.7871142029762268,
0.147774800658226,
0.548303484916687,
0.46664002537727356,
-0.26798686385154724,
-0.4508632719516754,
-0.45316413044929504,
0.4085860550403595,
-0.2838168442249298,
0.2880120575428009,
-0.9008041024208069,
-0.3751065135002136,
0.1241377666592598,
-0.018141968175768852,
-0.3645712733268738,
-0.4124872386455536,
0.3046087324619293,
-0.41002291440963745,
0.6270827054977417,
-0.2924284338951111,
-0.03408518806099892,
-0.45437246561050415,
0.5416635870933533,
-0.7123948335647583,
0.9106134176254272,
0.15894457697868347,
-0.5140690207481384,
0.36326608061790466,
-0.5941353440284729,
-0.7019026875495911,
-0.0066075678914785385,
-0.5490750074386597,
-0.07333475351333618,
-0.07236651331186295,
0.36753877997398376,
0.13572366535663605,
-0.25844836235046387,
-0.08332499116659164,
0.22955752909183502,
-0.3127540349960327,
-0.24962115287780762,
-0.2398715764284134,
0.6117168068885803,
-0.03830912336707115,
-0.6651764512062073,
0.2658894658088684,
-0.6681009531021118,
-0.21413159370422363,
-0.15210440754890442,
-0.2883542478084564,
-0.675328254699707,
-0.19518181681632996,
-0.2113199084997177,
0.5815962553024292,
0.6240967512130737,
-0.29887861013412476,
0.09467646479606628,
-0.5179229378700256,
-0.3151945471763611,
0.5468875169754028,
-0.2292264997959137,
0.8530634045600891,
-0.16050967574119568,
0.5997097492218018,
0.46457260847091675,
0.338534951210022,
-0.15917976200580597,
-0.08701438456773758,
-1.1099656820297241,
-0.09258677065372467,
-0.04814981669187546,
0.7623975276947021,
-0.9164479970932007,
0.5134207606315613,
-0.3269087076187134,
-0.20962856709957123,
-0.43426820635795593,
0.06684161722660065,
0.9503120183944702,
0.7286551594734192,
0.7098087072372437,
-0.407825231552124,
-0.3394915461540222,
-0.9461634159088135,
0.15073716640472412,
-0.09445485472679138,
0.10708007216453552,
0.3016364276409149,
0.17705978453159332,
-0.37190693616867065,
0.4443333148956299,
-0.225222647190094,
-0.7127437591552734,
-0.10782323777675629,
-0.03151283785700798,
-0.1560625284910202,
0.671494722366333,
0.43904179334640503,
-1.0878709554672241,
-0.4473804533481598,
0.5718192458152771,
-0.729438304901123,
0.013658521696925163,
-0.3652878403663635,
-0.5159738659858704,
0.2564428448677063,
0.5186290740966797,
-0.09750927239656448,
0.6178805828094482,
0.5285496115684509,
-0.4082314074039459,
-0.15971311926841736,
-0.2485480159521103,
0.4046967625617981,
-1.2559832334518433,
0.022020995616912842,
0.06461949646472931,
-0.05542711913585663,
-0.6054771542549133,
-0.045124299824237823,
0.14247269928455353,
0.10214827954769135,
-0.3169715106487274,
0.5498096346855164,
-0.5892353057861328,
-0.07195921242237091,
-0.23566342890262604,
0.41713571548461914,
0.1922864317893982,
0.6751352548599243,
0.3265616297721863,
0.48786306381225586,
0.6244016885757446,
-0.3811229169368744,
0.30292046070098877,
0.29871666431427,
-0.10974354296922684,
0.8743244409561157,
-0.2647472620010376,
-0.26143160462379456,
-0.13727283477783203,
0.1354382485151291,
-1.103822946548462,
0.21737675368785858,
0.5741491913795471,
-0.027235034853219986,
0.6596431732177734,
-0.09521661698818207,
0.171547070145607,
-0.09828919172286987,
-0.20252156257629395,
0.7283118963241577,
0.3107835352420807,
-0.6691333651542664,
0.9957573413848877,
0.15589585900306702,
0.1064518392086029,
-1.0421761274337769,
-0.6905331611633301,
-0.05443758890032768,
0.06666192412376404,
-0.569900631904602,
0.45012739300727844,
-0.08710960298776627,
-0.02776314690709114,
-0.025902889668941498,
-0.45426633954048157,
0.11346190422773361,
-0.22471420466899872,
0.3949255645275116,
0.5835484266281128,
-0.32496318221092224,
-0.1613045036792755,
0.25147783756256104,
-0.3092934191226959,
-0.22207240760326385,
-0.38407719135284424,
0.4140373766422272,
-0.023290041834115982,
-0.46504974365234375,
-0.5907777547836304,
0.35007336735725403,
0.5931104421615601,
-0.5550392270088196,
0.5631887316703796,
0.450136661529541,
-0.17211198806762695,
-0.04483132064342499,
-0.48670950531959534,
-0.06404424458742142,
-0.4517430365085602,
0.40647146105766296,
-0.4892847537994385,
-0.8303371667861938,
0.4494173228740692,
0.03249276801943779,
0.1507824808359146,
0.2896154820919037,
0.41018617153167725,
0.0419805571436882,
0.7601449489593506,
0.6881803274154663,
0.10623569041490555,
0.6561073064804077,
-0.23759537935256958,
0.3161182999610901,
-0.8632819652557373,
-0.8105552196502686,
-0.0574524849653244,
-0.7425588369369507,
-0.3686577379703522,
-0.7647577524185181,
0.361704558134079,
-0.26471763849258423,
-0.3029795289039612,
0.21110284328460693,
-0.3582157492637634,
0.5546817183494568,
0.6306965351104736,
0.13260610401630402,
0.26128482818603516,
-0.13709989190101624,
-0.07831060886383057,
-0.09225736558437347,
-0.5864157676696777,
-0.05515288561582565,
0.6461977362632751,
-0.00836393516510725,
1.0232943296432495,
0.20188623666763306,
0.8723838925361633,
0.06842462718486786,
-0.20956110954284668,
-0.5708661675453186,
0.5944334864616394,
-0.30548107624053955,
-0.43089210987091064,
-0.3726201355457306,
-0.3809969425201416,
-0.9174696803092957,
0.5342966914176941,
-0.17723101377487183,
-0.3773043751716614,
0.6257256269454956,
0.20122994482517242,
-0.5169652700424194,
0.04801851883530617,
-0.3001558780670166,
1.2957494258880615,
-0.5544052720069885,
-0.3241099715232849,
-0.33111292123794556,
-1.2564119100570679,
0.29011476039886475,
-0.03239762783050537,
-0.10762946307659149,
0.247740238904953,
-0.41739168763160706,
0.3212971091270447,
-0.12692126631736755,
1.0307291746139526,
-0.07073349505662918,
-0.34945517778396606,
-0.13079753518104553,
0.2345505803823471,
0.15209946036338806,
-0.26589784026145935,
0.40501150488853455,
0.07649928331375122,
-0.2266301065683365,
-0.1715514212846756,
-0.6634941697120667,
0.8755468130111694,
-0.7384936809539795,
-0.593891978263855,
-0.39196768403053284,
-0.5849640369415283,
-0.11365333199501038,
0.18620815873146057,
0.025725943967700005,
0.6327466368675232,
-0.30758923292160034,
-0.17655503749847412,
0.7816650867462158,
-0.20764324069023132,
0.34038251638412476,
0.716487467288971,
-0.17077703773975372,
-0.4262833595275879,
1.0567656755447388,
-0.13131144642829895,
0.46398067474365234,
0.9909060597419739,
-0.012764671817421913,
-0.32544708251953125,
-0.5470083951950073,
-0.45854267477989197,
0.19907885789871216,
-0.5960316061973572,
-0.2290746569633484,
-0.28302568197250366,
-0.2730877697467804,
-0.23981958627700806,
-0.5564612746238708,
-0.5143239498138428,
-0.44427821040153503,
-0.310616135597229,
0.16937986016273499,
-0.3694324493408203,
0.6088311076164246,
-0.48403728008270264,
0.035523686558008194,
-0.6273583173751831,
0.5337615609169006,
0.37190285325050354,
0.07686543464660645,
-0.26658329367637634,
-0.695737361907959,
-0.29019245505332947,
0.016737831756472588,
0.11528555303812027,
-0.4134456217288971,
0.10667397081851959,
0.03276913985610008,
0.6409193873405457,
0.435824453830719,
0.07225367426872253,
0.6774728298187256,
-0.20989546179771423,
0.6195119023323059,
0.4941008985042572,
-0.7288644313812256,
0.7629789710044861,
-0.1560487151145935,
0.5873640179634094,
0.781387209892273,
0.40122324228286743,
-0.4656538665294647,
-0.26129400730133057,
-0.07628384977579117,
-0.722842276096344,
0.7102032899856567,
-0.17979876697063446,
-0.26098430156707764,
0.2204686999320984,
0.04598185420036316,
0.17041252553462982,
-0.04656795784831047,
-0.6082143187522888,
-0.2472524493932724,
-0.4048493206501007,
-0.5331465005874634,
-0.04895416647195816,
-0.022968607023358345,
-0.40316036343574524,
-0.033530302345752716,
0.5903795957565308,
-0.11827567964792252,
-0.41313764452934265,
0.061455607414245605,
-0.23878419399261475,
-0.060500022023916245,
-0.023668814450502396,
0.6018160581588745,
0.6241490840911865,
0.07977788895368576,
0.1013057753443718,
-0.04927892982959747,
-0.46782124042510986,
0.12345928698778152,
0.36122262477874756,
-0.192439004778862,
-0.38999462127685547,
0.1227831169962883,
0.7159896492958069,
0.5633596181869507,
-0.5662618279457092,
0.7383872270584106,
-0.15304957330226898,
0.04359595477581024,
-0.12356558442115784,
0.22096791863441467,
-0.31439879536628723,
0.7234201431274414,
-0.014079248532652855,
0.10869604349136353,
0.05512259900569916,
-0.36999523639678955,
-0.08177989721298218,
0.4069374203681946,
-0.5965414643287659,
-0.2055111974477768,
0.6753742694854736,
0.5623896718025208,
-0.03225927799940109,
0.4855807423591614,
0.1253322809934616,
-0.449632853269577,
0.2871750295162201,
0.274150550365448,
0.8418959379196167,
-0.5062536001205444,
0.16161328554153442,
0.4282512366771698,
0.34436070919036865,
0.12052792310714722,
0.3280627131462097,
-0.328649640083313,
-0.6523391604423523,
-0.35817986726760864,
-0.5438947081565857,
-0.1882002204656601,
-0.3214614689350128,
-0.7845349311828613,
0.021204330027103424,
-0.2811046838760376,
0.2744719982147217,
-0.4278865158557892,
-0.04147390276193619,
-0.7107884883880615,
0.44750767946243286,
0.6386464834213257,
0.6309689879417419,
-0.7491884827613831,
0.6779621243476868,
0.7405595779418945,
-0.6643916368484497,
-0.4764711856842041,
0.12834474444389343,
0.28173449635505676,
-0.8314248323440552,
0.7531794309616089,
0.07297919690608978,
-0.7058634757995605,
-0.20614071190357208,
0.07405988872051239,
-0.9752936363220215,
1.2331160306930542,
0.06885945051908493,
-0.7919636368751526,
-0.22329606115818024,
0.22088156640529633,
0.36141663789749146,
-0.35547935962677,
-0.13991743326187134,
0.40317219495773315,
0.41976404190063477,
0.3213401436805725,
-1.0514787435531616,
0.1995621770620346,
-0.17592161893844604,
0.049922771751880646,
0.49674898386001587,
-0.852942705154419,
0.5189276933670044,
-0.15060974657535553,
-0.23238451778888702,
0.09954897314310074,
0.8073524832725525,
-0.14633233845233917,
0.2648417353630066,
0.5918003916740417,
0.7551814317703247,
0.5385515689849854,
-0.005694056395441294,
0.6216514110565186,
-0.3312465250492096,
-0.07709497958421707,
1.3182170391082764,
-0.3426362872123718,
0.6490575671195984,
0.5123019218444824,
0.3881244957447052,
0.6463547945022583,
0.3117676079273224,
0.23020778596401215,
0.8601356744766235,
-0.093742236495018,
-0.43397822976112366,
-0.5440730452537537,
-0.14983628690242767,
-0.5454877614974976,
0.7194991707801819,
0.31343746185302734,
-0.31066837906837463,
-0.2601258158683777,
0.05438981577754021,
-0.2540372610092163,
0.17488504946231842,
-0.47250285744667053,
0.808379054069519,
-0.17214292287826538,
-0.5719582438468933,
0.4106224477291107,
-0.5053037405014038,
0.5496205687522888,
-0.7491906881332397,
-0.0996793881058693,
-0.4091249406337738,
0.2779560387134552,
-0.12376882135868073,
-0.8126863241195679,
-0.08370120823383331,
-0.5243680477142334,
-0.1689298152923584,
-0.10443362593650818,
0.44518542289733887,
-0.8712786436080933,
-0.18875397741794586,
0.48442280292510986,
0.6434999704360962,
-0.1598491668701172,
0.3330516815185547,
-0.529708743095398,
0.20071767270565033,
0.1692841798067093,
-0.19071662425994873,
0.4161510765552521,
0.4030477702617645,
0.19116228818893433,
0.3531099855899811,
0.19580353796482086,
-0.39467012882232666,
0.09327256679534912,
0.32458266615867615,
1.0160726308822632,
-0.7625798583030701,
-0.4537588357925415,
-0.529922604560852,
0.6996983289718628,
-0.15396177768707275,
-0.4195214807987213,
0.6076833605766296,
0.7250476479530334,
1.2570099830627441,
0.2013850063085556,
0.5667802095413208,
0.138144388794899,
0.155428946018219,
-0.7518225312232971,
0.28512147068977356,
-0.9724212288856506,
0.12213108688592911,
0.008255565539002419,
-1.0016686916351318,
-0.48208141326904297,
0.6745555400848389,
-0.2805618643760681,
0.012664576061069965,
0.7453275322914124,
1.1025322675704956,
-0.415641188621521,
-0.2542802095413208,
0.5505197644233704,
0.005009764805436134,
0.12658877670764923,
1.0517551898956299,
0.979992151260376,
-0.24600942432880402,
0.7806183099746704,
-0.24873951077461243,
-0.29430365562438965,
-0.26338285207748413,
-0.48239874839782715,
-0.9679892659187317,
-0.6598941683769226,
-0.4601626694202423,
-0.1930227428674698,
0.12883208692073822,
0.5930585861206055,
0.5817553997039795,
-0.5401999354362488,
-0.11435551196336746,
0.20678752660751343,
-0.10089868307113647,
-0.1573312133550644,
-0.14742900431156158,
0.3231470286846161,
-0.28337547183036804,
-0.8527571558952332,
0.9404358267784119,
0.7566201090812683,
0.11942650377750397,
-0.43050846457481384,
-0.3169253468513489,
-0.17110508680343628,
-0.15524227917194366,
0.2778587341308594,
0.6531288623809814,
-0.8573521971702576,
-0.30791038274765015,
-0.1576378494501114,
-0.4316898584365845,
0.18289844691753387,
0.7766225337982178,
-0.9628900289535522,
0.7585938572883606,
0.46876347064971924,
0.825939416885376,
0.4305199086666107,
-0.00764843076467514,
0.6901518106460571,
-0.29267528653144836,
0.01056117843836546,
0.23859797418117523,
0.247674822807312,
0.33424222469329834,
-0.16736680269241333,
0.5508847832679749,
-0.05824236571788788,
-0.4568048417568207,
-0.2849160432815552,
0.4217618405818939,
-1.4158713817596436,
-0.15817657113075256,
0.8467487692832947,
0.04389466717839241,
-0.13338498771190643,
-0.03372744098305702,
-0.521872878074646,
0.2639792263507843,
-0.11219321936368942,
0.4933061897754669,
0.04569815471768379,
-0.0785072073340416,
-0.03435423970222473,
0.026400169357657433,
0.31596633791923523,
0.6553261280059814,
-0.6340175271034241,
-0.052220214158296585,
0.8672636151313782,
-0.14459381997585297,
0.28440791368484497,
0.2315812110900879,
-0.04196285083889961,
0.44895854592323303,
0.14756639301776886,
-0.02155386283993721,
-0.12596391141414642,
-0.6722366809844971,
-0.5142316222190857,
-0.06322207301855087,
-0.3712684214115143,
-0.5567381978034973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01992v1
|
Dissecting Paraphrases: The Impact of Prompt Syntax and supplementary Information on Knowledge Retrieval from Pretrained Language Models
| 2024-04-02T14:35:08 | 2024-04-02T14:35:08 |
Stephan Linzbach, Dimitar Dimitrov, Laura Kallmeyer, Kilian Evang, Hajira Jabeen, Stefan Dietze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) are known to contain various kinds of
knowledge. One method to infer relational knowledge is through the use of
cloze-style prompts, where a model is tasked to predict missing subjects or
objects. Typically, designing these prompts is a tedious task because small
differences in syntax or semantics can have a substantial impact on knowledge
retrieval performance. Simultaneously, evaluating the impact of either prompt
syntax or information is challenging due to their interdependence. We designed
CONPARE-LAMA - a dedicated probe, consisting of 34 million distinct prompts
that facilitate comparison across minimal paraphrases. These paraphrases follow
a unified meta-template enabling the controlled variation of syntax and
semantics across arbitrary relations. CONPARE-LAMA enables insights into the
independent impact of either syntactical form or semantic information of
paraphrases on the knowledge retrieval performance of PLMs. Extensive knowledge
retrieval experiments using our probe reveal that prompts following clausal
syntax have several desirable properties in comparison to appositive syntax: i)
they are more useful when querying PLMs with a combination of supplementary
information, ii) knowledge is more consistently recalled across different
combinations of supplementary information, and iii) they decrease response
uncertainty when retrieving known facts. In addition, range information can
boost knowledge retrieval performance more than domain information, even though
domain information is more reliably helpful across syntactic forms.
|
[
-0.39584723114967346,
-0.5957962274551392,
0.7533316016197205,
0.2059190273284912,
-0.4399915337562561,
-0.16243866086006165,
0.00016336231783498079,
-0.09698814153671265,
0.07997976988554001,
0.3540700674057007,
-0.38377049565315247,
-0.31718510389328003,
-0.5275117754936218,
0.2884158790111542,
-0.27801263332366943,
0.9039733409881592,
0.27624770998954773,
0.0727834403514862,
-0.6600175499916077,
-0.1200379729270935,
-0.4468885064125061,
-0.6922944188117981,
-0.25574013590812683,
-0.01074061170220375,
0.6243765950202942,
0.29186955094337463,
0.7254529595375061,
0.603642463684082,
0.48146483302116394,
0.31128841638565063,
-0.24467425048351288,
-0.0889749601483345,
-0.1864680051803589,
0.2176538109779358,
-0.3273453414440155,
-0.5063551068305969,
0.1021084189414978,
0.09347674250602722,
0.5256128907203674,
1.028829574584961,
-0.19502167403697968,
0.005709821358323097,
0.3474658131599426,
0.6159451603889465,
-0.7221469283103943,
0.23205748200416565,
-0.4993348717689514,
-0.3463013172149658,
-0.3280164301395416,
-0.40065720677375793,
-0.34065118432044983,
-0.6102041602134705,
0.6691949963569641,
-0.7883842587471008,
0.1874992549419403,
0.027186140418052673,
0.5925490260124207,
0.2358809858560562,
-0.2624569237232208,
-0.7046518325805664,
-0.20740260183811188,
0.5621612071990967,
-0.5510706305503845,
0.4050579071044922,
0.19914618134498596,
0.2360600233078003,
-0.0999004915356636,
-1.0771288871765137,
-0.5804588794708252,
-0.4891048073768616,
-0.6077643036842346,
-0.2626167833805084,
-0.09188824892044067,
0.11912544816732407,
0.3492131531238556,
0.2532636225223541,
-0.5401416420936584,
-0.352450966835022,
-0.29737749695777893,
-0.22671331465244293,
0.17564909160137177,
0.12702834606170654,
0.35954606533050537,
-0.32983657717704773,
-0.5316513776779175,
-0.28703776001930237,
-0.9394937753677368,
0.30633702874183655,
0.19233690202236176,
0.14052070677280426,
0.3041873574256897,
0.3418983817100525,
-0.3553963303565979,
0.9701231718063354,
-0.08789198100566864,
-0.21268561482429504,
0.058763742446899414,
-0.5687096118927002,
0.15518136322498322,
-0.14341920614242554,
0.8836105465888977,
0.2661909759044647,
0.1899571716785431,
-0.2801586389541626,
-0.03185778111219406,
-0.18733447790145874,
-0.16156527400016785,
-0.6934345960617065,
-0.4322240948677063,
-0.32401031255722046,
-0.22850759327411652,
0.24832916259765625,
0.28956177830696106,
-0.9406920075416565,
-0.5299289226531982,
-0.5656121969223022,
0.3943069875240326,
-0.6155483722686768,
0.024763161316514015,
0.14937447011470795,
-0.5794618129730225,
0.15296022593975067,
0.4071239233016968,
-0.6042110919952393,
0.19131146371364594,
0.5539749264717102,
0.6402679681777954,
-0.10723854601383209,
-0.5829359292984009,
-0.6226333379745483,
-0.04853992164134979,
-0.08267559856176376,
0.7444233894348145,
-0.8727998733520508,
-0.4989998936653137,
-0.1298331618309021,
0.014323820360004902,
-0.3647401034832001,
-0.7501692175865173,
0.4904114902019501,
-0.6121388077735901,
0.4013664126396179,
-0.8136134743690491,
-0.7140016555786133,
-0.18632104992866516,
-0.05764200538396835,
-0.6064669489860535,
0.6701777577400208,
0.08643017709255219,
-0.8778530359268188,
0.17229849100112915,
-0.19039969146251678,
-0.5011478066444397,
0.034007132053375244,
-0.2340821921825409,
0.16428020596504211,
-0.0376589260995388,
0.15293239057064056,
0.351197212934494,
-0.5431262254714966,
0.4768891930580139,
-0.21482150256633759,
-0.21715335547924042,
0.2953025698661804,
-0.19594287872314453,
0.6619598269462585,
0.1465650051832199,
-0.1899951994419098,
-0.1018928810954094,
-0.7018197774887085,
-0.26609542965888977,
0.006333999801427126,
-0.18335872888565063,
-0.6836057305335999,
-0.1799248903989792,
-0.6275362372398376,
0.26795223355293274,
0.3647782504558563,
-0.29100555181503296,
-0.03848100081086159,
-0.14167235791683197,
0.282145231962204,
0.42717596888542175,
0.32302892208099365,
0.5668944120407104,
-0.41960832476615906,
0.7183613777160645,
0.05696363002061844,
0.13449349999427795,
-0.4067806601524353,
-0.4067061245441437,
-0.3847816586494446,
-0.008595600724220276,
0.2256098985671997,
0.4352576732635498,
-0.9410268664360046,
0.16875281929969788,
-0.09003466367721558,
-0.4533623456954956,
-0.568383514881134,
0.2168692648410797,
0.4622327387332916,
0.8971787095069885,
0.5614157915115356,
0.14264638721942902,
-0.5264140963554382,
-0.6710950136184692,
-0.4951684772968292,
-0.16185393929481506,
-0.08003424108028412,
0.19020962715148926,
0.3107817471027374,
0.33382511138916016,
1.0280447006225586,
-0.5770041942596436,
0.09464702755212784,
-0.3379625082015991,
-0.15780533850193024,
0.15359191596508026,
0.30443212389945984,
0.7167211174964905,
-0.6984397172927856,
-0.5041775703430176,
-0.3867039382457733,
-0.7017313241958618,
-0.28196853399276733,
-0.0010088225826621056,
-0.20566938817501068,
-0.5645512938499451,
0.5362135171890259,
-1.039237141609192,
0.06992606073617935,
0.12183810770511627,
-0.2776730954647064,
0.702347993850708,
0.0464978963136673,
0.12541751563549042,
-0.725924015045166,
0.2885829210281372,
-0.32124432921409607,
0.0935850739479065,
-0.5834516882896423,
-0.004259088542312384,
0.1131853461265564,
-0.10729845613241196,
-0.5263447761535645,
0.5982810854911804,
-0.44554415345191956,
0.1639471799135208,
-0.03883571922779083,
0.36685511469841003,
0.44624343514442444,
0.33663827180862427,
0.14278218150138855,
1.0778154134750366,
0.551625669002533,
-0.8856020569801331,
0.32386094331741333,
0.37987273931503296,
-0.3843415379524231,
0.43280860781669617,
-0.7893996238708496,
0.059486448764801025,
-0.25786229968070984,
0.1751704216003418,
-0.8388423919677734,
-0.03647543117403984,
0.18217508494853973,
-0.3207744359970093,
0.1726040542125702,
0.2006215751171112,
-0.5750816464424133,
-0.030348272994160652,
-0.5891073346138,
0.40718400478363037,
0.4591596722602844,
-0.5898255109786987,
0.12104412168264389,
0.2535270154476166,
-0.4736720323562622,
-0.5592271685600281,
0.014825426042079926,
-0.04151109233498573,
-0.4074711203575134,
-0.3811558187007904,
0.058529868721961975,
-0.17628125846385956,
-0.3659153878688812,
-0.13531213998794556,
-0.13309569656848907,
0.16609981656074524,
0.27229323983192444,
-0.18854562938213348,
0.15121454000473022,
-0.21848390996456146,
0.23194655776023865,
0.10116676241159439,
0.07659028470516205,
0.2121228575706482,
-0.2178857922554016,
0.7037183046340942,
-0.121407151222229,
-0.18382586538791656,
-0.35371771454811096,
0.30698904395103455,
0.5110822319984436,
-0.4338214695453644,
0.8753635287284851,
0.14075534045696259,
-0.06862285733222961,
-0.002082090824842453,
-0.42739298939704895,
-0.4661557078361511,
-0.4567466974258423,
-0.10447169095277786,
-0.3759615123271942,
-0.6500632166862488,
0.4307582378387451,
-0.09039174765348434,
-0.3689049482345581,
0.38866809010505676,
0.09733816981315613,
-0.11034776270389557,
0.5728299617767334,
0.27941861748695374,
0.16858625411987305,
0.5901734232902527,
-0.026265589520335197,
-0.12728430330753326,
-0.7072272300720215,
-0.5594131350517273,
-0.5557552576065063,
0.012108264490962029,
-0.20637066662311554,
-0.16661259531974792,
0.4389781057834625,
0.5132459998130798,
0.013670546002686024,
0.2968103289604187,
-0.20506496727466583,
0.4025283753871918,
0.8552337884902954,
0.17452660202980042,
0.3880802094936371,
-0.3314000368118286,
-0.16679136455059052,
-0.038181450217962265,
-0.8345487117767334,
-0.5614219903945923,
0.8443573117256165,
0.0013394722482189536,
0.6663307547569275,
0.050359953194856644,
0.40062883496284485,
-0.017978964373469353,
-0.08774834871292114,
-0.48552146553993225,
0.6898841857910156,
0.03575035557150841,
-0.3619847297668457,
-0.08757689595222473,
-0.37992382049560547,
-0.9696329832077026,
0.2800811231136322,
0.16872723400592804,
-0.42270326614379883,
0.3943846523761749,
0.060066211968660355,
-0.5693869590759277,
-0.21843881905078888,
-0.8579080700874329,
0.8814420104026794,
-0.047209348529577255,
-0.06104900315403938,
0.16618594527244568,
-1.1012718677520752,
0.1303606480360031,
-0.04438752308487892,
0.05686334893107414,
-0.012587505392730236,
-0.10590710490942001,
0.907957911491394,
-0.6122655868530273,
0.7495501637458801,
-0.28148648142814636,
0.12821170687675476,
0.5452678203582764,
0.09179326146841049,
0.4716763496398926,
0.1927589476108551,
-0.117669478058815,
-0.1872391402721405,
0.23489700257778168,
-0.29060661792755127,
-0.8541808128356934,
0.5012761950492859,
-0.4352622330188751,
-0.9706370234489441,
-0.24847003817558289,
-0.5883468389511108,
-0.3186078667640686,
0.17254768311977386,
0.4082028865814209,
0.5199235081672668,
0.1001046895980835,
0.3380185663700104,
0.6675503253936768,
-0.2749420702457428,
0.3521521985530853,
0.6635442972183228,
0.033063534647226334,
-0.31347715854644775,
0.6954838633537292,
0.050254564732313156,
0.41381892561912537,
0.6884016990661621,
0.2828432619571686,
-0.5682907104492188,
-0.4001792371273041,
-0.23721136152744293,
0.4638492166996002,
-0.9377003312110901,
-0.3055255711078644,
-0.7298614978790283,
0.08668652176856995,
-0.5113136172294617,
0.13685277104377747,
0.12152083963155746,
-0.4610808491706848,
-0.49097001552581787,
-0.13010825216770172,
0.4473857283592224,
0.566497266292572,
0.10447795689105988,
0.4862460494041443,
-0.9243875741958618,
0.008926629088819027,
0.4048769474029541,
-0.119280144572258,
-0.15896464884281158,
-0.39476439356803894,
0.05692261457443237,
-0.054034218192100525,
-0.16080836951732635,
-1.2471730709075928,
0.059047214686870575,
0.3515152335166931,
0.7600510120391846,
0.31462153792381287,
0.4139614701271057,
0.6145131587982178,
-0.446725070476532,
0.7813522815704346,
0.057615727186203,
-0.9065585136413574,
0.7851704359054565,
-0.3091222047805786,
0.21391379833221436,
0.7391476035118103,
0.6171771883964539,
-0.33669617772102356,
-0.46995702385902405,
-0.6657307744026184,
-0.49938175082206726,
0.6168847680091858,
0.08493953198194504,
0.02352655865252018,
-0.46480926871299744,
0.5059986114501953,
0.4432533383369446,
0.6899232268333435,
-0.2703670263290405,
-0.25022271275520325,
-0.03691631928086281,
-0.0777093693614006,
-0.0837511494755745,
-0.3523314297199249,
-0.058165691792964935,
-0.32572540640830994,
0.158824622631073,
0.12091859430074692,
-0.013145668432116508,
0.3186448812484741,
-0.30445247888565063,
0.40047788619995117,
0.3140205144882202,
0.5353923439979553,
0.8744886517524719,
0.0008444531704299152,
0.514385461807251,
0.19085575640201569,
-0.25564220547676086,
-0.011323484592139721,
0.30105987191200256,
-0.037074606865644455,
0.4568394720554352,
0.6087943315505981,
0.766663670539856,
0.16017106175422668,
-0.8140926361083984,
0.6482077240943909,
0.10035986453294754,
0.17356881499290466,
0.16229389607906342,
0.01142457127571106,
0.0017240637680515647,
0.1690208613872528,
0.33121082186698914,
0.05178895965218544,
0.3883154094219208,
-0.5923346877098083,
0.4659601151943207,
0.3337492346763611,
0.07910040020942688,
-0.6039466261863708,
0.5890038013458252,
0.04823979362845421,
-0.034519266337156296,
0.4254890978336334,
-0.1831953525543213,
-0.502995491027832,
0.4129350781440735,
0.44238707423210144,
0.2836633622646332,
-0.45084401965141296,
0.2862412929534912,
0.16287188231945038,
0.015088281594216824,
-0.2223288118839264,
0.21813519299030304,
-0.3158789277076721,
-0.30482345819473267,
-0.21159492433071136,
-0.6711647510528564,
-0.261650025844574,
0.08075986057519913,
-0.7305821180343628,
0.27266672253608704,
-0.42257159948349,
0.021429581567645073,
-0.24159903824329376,
-0.15795378386974335,
-0.7419138550758362,
0.0894431620836258,
-0.26066353917121887,
0.9619894623756409,
-0.6524817943572998,
0.709985613822937,
0.796225905418396,
-0.6061604619026184,
-0.8798407316207886,
0.0727037712931633,
-0.4225023686885834,
-0.7407400012016296,
0.5677222609519958,
0.15323872864246368,
0.031389813870191574,
0.16965150833129883,
-0.20532634854316711,
-0.8569598197937012,
1.053299903869629,
0.8333235383033752,
-0.4615399241447449,
-0.23905853927135468,
0.16647660732269287,
0.5270217657089233,
-0.16819873452186584,
0.27903100848197937,
0.8051081299781799,
0.233328714966774,
0.24034731090068817,
-1.091286301612854,
0.25874659419059753,
-0.06944037973880768,
-0.12417636066675186,
0.22809244692325592,
-0.3169844150543213,
1.0485514402389526,
-0.15362870693206787,
-0.3509882092475891,
-0.007242980878800154,
0.4539805054664612,
0.37565740942955017,
0.4138563871383667,
0.3735530376434326,
0.3424382209777832,
0.945766270160675,
0.12507741153240204,
1.1029900312423706,
-0.5727782845497131,
0.17177900671958923,
1.0069870948791504,
-0.09692727029323578,
0.6612545847892761,
0.6417747735977173,
-0.20259900391101837,
0.5036647915840149,
0.6160662174224854,
0.449174165725708,
0.9413050413131714,
-0.020743630826473236,
-0.3346257209777832,
-0.059214845299720764,
-0.4392780065536499,
-0.6734005212783813,
0.04534774273633957,
0.4105781316757202,
-0.4304966330528259,
-0.5016875267028809,
0.206154927611351,
0.15744972229003906,
0.09754321724176407,
-0.06186681240797043,
0.9180992245674133,
0.31086215376853943,
-1.053360939025879,
0.6437559723854065,
-0.49324527382850647,
0.31792503595352173,
-0.5885757803916931,
-0.051476411521434784,
-0.37691426277160645,
-0.010830528102815151,
-0.06222507730126381,
-0.8450939059257507,
0.25882548093795776,
-0.30666467547416687,
0.021157797425985336,
-0.22261929512023926,
0.6774527430534363,
-0.608953058719635,
0.019906168803572655,
0.24017295241355896,
0.826239824295044,
0.11959206312894821,
-0.42582520842552185,
-0.5137957334518433,
-0.11919263005256653,
-0.10571882128715515,
-0.19811215996742249,
0.35468390583992004,
0.8912742137908936,
0.082516148686409,
0.594744086265564,
0.583305835723877,
-0.10924790799617767,
0.282626748085022,
-0.044618718326091766,
1.210805058479309,
-0.5245994329452515,
-0.521815299987793,
-1.1148011684417725,
0.3092826306819916,
0.04595157876610756,
-0.30113521218299866,
0.9866229891777039,
0.46210941672325134,
0.6319445371627808,
-0.2927922010421753,
0.6387528777122498,
0.07704076915979385,
0.5591021776199341,
-0.655738353729248,
0.30499333143234253,
-0.2904331386089325,
0.5173433423042297,
-0.13941161334514618,
-0.7520775198936462,
-0.05908704176545143,
0.3080101013183594,
-0.5260391235351562,
-0.11262231320142746,
0.9197772145271301,
0.6575214266777039,
0.17569008469581604,
0.06114668399095535,
0.050853580236434937,
-0.2174118012189865,
0.19121098518371582,
0.4349037706851959,
1.2370285987854004,
-0.1070752888917923,
0.7482267022132874,
-0.26535728573799133,
-0.09866712987422943,
0.031039385125041008,
-0.5572407245635986,
-0.933413028717041,
-0.746796727180481,
-0.03739636391401291,
-0.0984828770160675,
0.08363516628742218,
0.7397955060005188,
0.30511975288391113,
-0.60239177942276,
-0.027095958590507507,
-0.2466447353363037,
0.2940889596939087,
0.0657292902469635,
-0.23415766656398773,
0.437227338552475,
-0.7356997728347778,
-0.5269317030906677,
0.5838512778282166,
-0.059643086045980453,
0.04825727641582489,
0.1694478690624237,
-0.052428554743528366,
-0.1918455809354782,
-0.1311047375202179,
0.448769211769104,
0.1005789265036583,
-0.6232404708862305,
-0.128280371427536,
0.3582255244255066,
-0.07603747397661209,
-0.07275749742984772,
1.0121370553970337,
-0.9826062917709351,
0.2395220696926117,
0.7480995655059814,
0.5663207173347473,
-0.10536570847034454,
0.2805159389972687,
0.7900328040122986,
-0.9616737365722656,
0.19841249287128448,
0.31097108125686646,
0.40391549468040466,
0.366167277097702,
-0.29050490260124207,
0.20309452712535858,
0.584736704826355,
-0.3966050446033478,
-0.7114017605781555,
0.18024207651615143,
-0.7093933820724487,
-0.407123327255249,
1.319259524345398,
-0.43915292620658875,
-0.006751260720193386,
-0.11378781497478485,
-0.320658802986145,
0.0922631099820137,
-0.4124376177787781,
0.39602312445640564,
0.8079055547714233,
-0.07915084809064865,
-0.2501322031021118,
-0.43524274230003357,
0.8569545149803162,
0.574231743812561,
-0.619347095489502,
-0.061613962054252625,
0.4138438105583191,
0.31597939133644104,
0.19687139987945557,
0.5416634678840637,
0.09786572307348251,
0.2936285734176636,
-0.13815779983997345,
-0.4182482361793518,
-0.07378652691841125,
-0.3579166531562805,
-0.22363562881946564,
0.3537939190864563,
0.15826620161533356,
-0.32896557450294495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01991v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01991v1
|
Kallaama: A Transcribed Speech Dataset about Agriculture in the Three Most Widely Spoken Languages in Senegal
| 2024-04-02T14:31:14 | 2024-04-02T14:31:14 |
Elodie Gauthier, Aminata Ndiaye, Abdoulaye Guissé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work is part of the Kallaama project, whose objective is to produce and
disseminate national languages corpora for speech technologies developments, in
the field of agriculture. Except for Wolof, which benefits from some language
data for natural language processing, national languages of Senegal are largely
ignored by language technology providers. However, such technologies are keys
to the protection, promotion and teaching of these languages. Kallaama focuses
on the 3 main spoken languages by Senegalese people: Wolof, Pulaar and Sereer.
These languages are widely spoken by the population, with around 10 million of
native Senegalese speakers, not to mention those outside the country. However,
they remain under-resourced in terms of machine-readable data that can be used
for automatic processing and language technologies, all the more so in the
agricultural sector. We release a transcribed speech dataset containing 125
hours of recordings, about agriculture, in each of the above-mentioned
languages. These resources are specifically designed for Automatic Speech
Recognition purpose, including traditional approaches. To build such
technologies, we provide textual corpora in Wolof and Pulaar, and a
pronunciation lexicon containing 49,132 entries from the Wolof dataset.
|
[
-0.26334670186042786,
-0.7866420149803162,
0.4290519952774048,
0.5051318407058716,
0.01607605442404747,
0.06088816374540329,
-0.43757835030555725,
-0.7361287474632263,
0.3221534192562103,
0.7741098999977112,
-0.022037815302610397,
-0.5087961554527283,
-1.0654067993164062,
0.26828306913375854,
-0.5776062607765198,
0.9325929284095764,
0.025673342868685722,
-0.32040533423423767,
0.19757038354873657,
-0.5328711271286011,
-0.5097638964653015,
-0.5238299369812012,
-0.38703447580337524,
-0.0757562592625618,
0.5193636417388916,
0.6640931963920593,
0.5914650559425354,
0.24519653618335724,
0.02946285344660282,
0.3480638861656189,
-0.2561630308628082,
0.41730302572250366,
-0.31670448184013367,
0.1461515873670578,
0.060382433235645294,
-0.255188912153244,
-0.23815271258354187,
-0.08196569979190826,
0.4170575737953186,
0.6602463722229004,
-0.36948665976524353,
0.35970112681388855,
0.0845528244972229,
0.7007948160171509,
-0.754623293876648,
0.6354690790176392,
-0.4328560531139374,
-0.03883346542716026,
-0.4604366421699524,
0.018226413056254387,
-0.28216034173965454,
-0.8105228543281555,
0.28275641798973083,
-0.6527827978134155,
0.005475034937262535,
-0.5487638711929321,
0.8549557328224182,
0.07611498236656189,
-0.4522378742694855,
-0.6267787218093872,
-0.75274658203125,
0.6643901467323303,
-0.42811745405197144,
-0.04456847533583641,
1.0797758102416992,
0.5983331799507141,
-0.44955265522003174,
-0.3496667146682739,
-0.7005319595336914,
-0.012028595432639122,
-0.021086759865283966,
0.12832504510879517,
-0.14967665076255798,
-0.22780698537826538,
-0.31024545431137085,
0.39543700218200684,
-0.2983390688896179,
-0.002285003662109375,
-0.47732865810394287,
-0.3929797112941742,
0.5116026401519775,
-0.1735810935497284,
0.07402683049440384,
0.17506767809391022,
0.19038432836532593,
-0.4174453318119049,
-0.40438732504844666,
0.08381130546331406,
0.6229614019393921,
0.5313282012939453,
-0.137473925948143,
0.44804760813713074,
-0.25162991881370544,
0.9011176824569702,
-0.3452039659023285,
-0.6194735169410706,
0.5850275158882141,
-0.05595063790678978,
-0.2798749506473541,
0.2317887246608734,
0.787631094455719,
-0.009845081716775894,
0.06682492047548294,
0.19717852771282196,
0.051859717816114426,
0.26864492893218994,
-0.04283859208226204,
-0.006381313782185316,
-0.1768123209476471,
0.13537800312042236,
-0.32837995886802673,
-0.3819717466831207,
0.006780112162232399,
-1.223021149635315,
-0.40548065304756165,
0.2605080008506775,
0.4588285982608795,
-0.11466033011674881,
-0.045093026012182236,
0.11166923493146896,
0.07525235414505005,
0.3035968840122223,
0.13408689200878143,
-0.8786327838897705,
0.4242747724056244,
0.48929861187934875,
0.8225558996200562,
0.3293992578983307,
-0.1822787970304489,
-0.6582022309303284,
0.10057270526885986,
-0.2698507010936737,
0.6495065093040466,
-0.8542976379394531,
-0.9878605604171753,
0.06765439361333847,
0.4174495339393616,
-0.09732665121555328,
-0.6178821921348572,
0.9279811978340149,
-0.3197266161441803,
0.10827828198671341,
-0.26396477222442627,
-0.31500115990638733,
-0.7379913330078125,
-0.2583831250667572,
-0.8055741786956787,
0.8581792712211609,
0.11085208505392075,
-0.14923135936260223,
0.389467716217041,
-0.7763601541519165,
-0.8528682589530945,
0.051166992634534836,
-0.25628581643104553,
-0.41914287209510803,
-0.2909945547580719,
0.19405043125152588,
0.4252927005290985,
-0.41890856623649597,
0.15610761940479279,
0.408493310213089,
0.23438385128974915,
0.2000800222158432,
-0.4626402258872986,
0.6236813068389893,
0.509711742401123,
-0.48214638233184814,
-0.41256770491600037,
-1.0493131875991821,
-0.38719552755355835,
0.12799614667892456,
-0.4890795052051544,
0.06376966834068298,
0.21259236335754395,
0.6185157299041748,
-0.13474927842617035,
0.28147608041763306,
-0.8255935907363892,
-0.022043777629733086,
-0.40349987149238586,
0.34060707688331604,
0.5521331429481506,
-0.15345337986946106,
0.3332173526287079,
-0.2907879948616028,
0.5779001712799072,
0.027929022908210754,
0.14907625317573547,
0.028090015053749084,
-0.8552654981613159,
-0.6867341995239258,
-0.16587580740451813,
0.4339635670185089,
0.577639639377594,
-0.14706063270568848,
0.22338636219501495,
0.21560975909233093,
-0.6900250911712646,
-0.7647480368614197,
0.1228981614112854,
0.2428983598947525,
0.7390310168266296,
0.2716291546821594,
-0.10975120961666107,
-0.6362762451171875,
-1.1712956428527832,
0.3560140132904053,
0.11324344575405121,
0.4388834536075592,
0.12968237698078156,
0.1920391023159027,
-0.36643674969673157,
0.7249495983123779,
-0.5666264295578003,
-0.68316650390625,
-0.15590831637382507,
0.3352423310279846,
0.596125066280365,
0.398422509431839,
0.562946617603302,
-0.8945032358169556,
-0.5449992418289185,
0.47710633277893066,
-0.36332830786705017,
-0.21620340645313263,
0.3457251191139221,
0.09924579411745071,
0.46547773480415344,
-0.26260533928871155,
-0.3162301480770111,
0.47112709283828735,
0.9557647705078125,
-0.031670309603214264,
0.12498557567596436,
-0.21874050796031952,
0.10626951605081558,
-0.873927891254425,
0.08299970626831055,
-0.1777578890323639,
-0.057024601846933365,
-0.3743213713169098,
-0.2716200351715088,
-0.3171936273574829,
-0.18336811661720276,
-0.4475046694278717,
0.4091032147407532,
-0.41506627202033997,
-0.01181576494127512,
-0.4812111258506775,
-0.031118106096982956,
-0.11148760467767715,
0.14845725893974304,
0.12161529064178467,
1.098612904548645,
0.7630549669265747,
-0.695782482624054,
0.288285493850708,
0.4680896997451782,
-0.4995887577533722,
0.39932429790496826,
-0.5274101495742798,
-0.030982214957475662,
0.03747428581118584,
0.3423488438129425,
-0.4005287289619446,
-0.5368351340293884,
0.48609521985054016,
-0.3450498878955841,
-0.07750938087701797,
0.31840118765830994,
-0.3733494281768799,
-0.1822146475315094,
0.09729663282632828,
0.1339685618877411,
0.7051730751991272,
-0.49478375911712646,
0.4706938862800598,
1.1572688817977905,
-0.18576686084270477,
-0.5314440727233887,
-0.5780394673347473,
0.24720902740955353,
-0.22193941473960876,
-0.30453845858573914,
-0.23629964888095856,
0.35401010513305664,
-0.05466170608997345,
-0.268533319234848,
0.0762067586183548,
-0.31109732389450073,
0.048865146934986115,
0.6086626052856445,
-0.19395244121551514,
0.015756167471408844,
0.087145134806633,
-0.17032869160175323,
-0.025904491543769836,
-0.22861993312835693,
-0.3012247085571289,
0.40337979793548584,
-0.11828197538852692,
0.17644476890563965,
-0.5727798938751221,
0.5647399425506592,
0.3966946303844452,
-0.13259148597717285,
0.9556192755699158,
0.5257286429405212,
-0.383172869682312,
0.02547195553779602,
-0.5630657076835632,
0.45801833271980286,
-0.425956666469574,
-0.031092431396245956,
-0.16190752387046814,
-0.6224910020828247,
0.3106951415538788,
-0.051648467779159546,
-0.042268574237823486,
0.7011900544166565,
0.4410935044288635,
-0.21476413309574127,
0.5879282355308533,
0.6312751173973083,
-0.6404827833175659,
-0.13522674143314362,
-0.48207172751426697,
0.07880370318889618,
-0.5466395020484924,
-0.6172628998756409,
-0.9627841711044312,
-0.07347636669874191,
-0.7110936641693115,
-0.43685048818588257,
0.3221970200538635,
-0.5048381686210632,
0.45944535732269287,
0.7074620127677917,
-0.35538798570632935,
0.46871697902679443,
0.6497865915298462,
-0.20021745562553406,
0.19673492014408112,
-0.016112660989165306,
0.08852969110012054,
0.36228516697883606,
-0.5004622340202332,
-1.0820214748382568,
0.8995856642723083,
0.03542497381567955,
0.6398736238479614,
0.02290247566998005,
0.49420347809791565,
0.6358678936958313,
-0.13610310852527618,
-0.8452708721160889,
0.34203365445137024,
-0.45417943596839905,
-0.1447146236896515,
-0.17177212238311768,
-0.16086359322071075,
-1.444182276725769,
-0.1628546416759491,
0.15623101592063904,
-0.8001735210418701,
0.49072712659835815,
0.18922241032123566,
-0.20163221657276154,
0.11626037955284119,
-0.6758190989494324,
0.47988423705101013,
0.10286876559257507,
0.146364226937294,
-0.3612981140613556,
-0.6753107309341431,
0.03353356197476387,
-0.25081947445869446,
0.5915237665176392,
-0.27530792355537415,
0.24215956032276154,
0.9999018907546997,
-0.8397127389907837,
0.9265726804733276,
-0.14202049374580383,
-0.6756454110145569,
0.6408252120018005,
-0.17244818806648254,
0.38188859820365906,
-0.0803598091006279,
-0.29251405596733093,
0.24250635504722595,
0.04348398745059967,
-0.44381076097488403,
-0.05194861814379692,
0.7545052170753479,
-0.9402027726173401,
-0.3202182948589325,
-0.7941762208938599,
-0.5283955335617065,
-0.2933809757232666,
-0.24543775618076324,
0.08001590520143509,
0.5411228537559509,
-0.3255607485771179,
0.3034396171569824,
0.15205751359462738,
-0.2707686424255371,
0.21056224405765533,
0.14932386577129364,
0.05207214877009392,
-0.30430084466934204,
1.0975207090377808,
0.2848699390888214,
-0.06659428775310516,
0.2796138525009155,
0.12277527153491974,
-0.2596037685871124,
-0.12983570992946625,
-0.07127954810857773,
0.024709373712539673,
-0.7300199270248413,
-0.18135473132133484,
-0.8383990526199341,
-0.24568656086921692,
-0.21396414935588837,
-0.1392827033996582,
-0.14532674849033356,
-0.6567274928092957,
-0.4481573700904846,
-0.13609854876995087,
0.6744968295097351,
1.1604875326156616,
-0.22090746462345123,
0.6625511050224304,
-0.8085131049156189,
0.5201078057289124,
0.43102115392684937,
-0.16595153510570526,
-0.03032400645315647,
-0.22363491356372833,
-0.23003427684307098,
0.3143935203552246,
-0.4635069668292999,
-0.9886419177055359,
0.569954514503479,
0.7292042970657349,
0.5174017548561096,
0.1466246247291565,
-0.30331581830978394,
0.47100552916526794,
-0.3173936605453491,
0.7732540369033813,
-0.010587243363261223,
-0.8584684729576111,
1.0475612878799438,
-0.15803177654743195,
0.3740067481994629,
0.4498816132545471,
0.4637211859226227,
-0.5597031712532043,
-0.5757365226745605,
-0.43876105546951294,
-0.7237842082977295,
0.6521809101104736,
0.40692493319511414,
0.06677810847759247,
-0.38582947850227356,
-0.4428749978542328,
0.8626920580863953,
-0.026602767407894135,
-0.21568813920021057,
-0.05302870646119118,
-0.2497439682483673,
-0.2431836724281311,
-0.14760930836200714,
-0.1905604600906372,
-0.2561095654964447,
-0.05026858672499657,
0.9327964186668396,
0.15951374173164368,
-0.09531991183757782,
0.2542780339717865,
-0.2021588534116745,
-0.09046860784292221,
0.4198845326900482,
0.42371055483818054,
0.7386719584465027,
-0.10460123419761658,
0.013676255010068417,
-0.022946106269955635,
-1.128560185432434,
0.5372072458267212,
0.11383101344108582,
-0.35409680008888245,
0.1838148683309555,
0.023015731945633888,
0.7640666961669922,
0.0856349766254425,
-0.793375551700592,
0.08816255629062653,
0.2516951262950897,
-0.24898724257946014,
-0.42371249198913574,
0.22555994987487793,
-0.06793392449617386,
0.26054659485816956,
0.6883103251457214,
0.052521515637636185,
0.22978973388671875,
-0.479763001203537,
-0.031137565150856972,
-0.06423316150903702,
-0.028027839958667755,
-0.29542621970176697,
0.5091170072555542,
0.48116353154182434,
-0.21317152678966522,
0.26368600130081177,
0.16792580485343933,
-0.2852086126804352,
0.9677990674972534,
0.5343095660209656,
0.508338212966919,
-0.08051389455795288,
0.7879986763000488,
0.5133547186851501,
0.05133066698908806,
0.07478604465723038,
0.6230753660202026,
-0.232521191239357,
-0.4461105763912201,
0.08057979494333267,
-0.962334394454956,
-0.41893061995506287,
0.2899003326892853,
-0.7233255505561829,
-0.09540940076112747,
-0.2215479612350464,
-0.5421590209007263,
0.09675803035497665,
-0.027545860037207603,
-0.5559183359146118,
0.21528121829032898,
-0.053991928696632385,
0.7183493971824646,
-0.8695992231369019,
1.026991605758667,
0.5526354908943176,
-0.222712904214859,
-0.4737052023410797,
-0.29800641536712646,
0.0016840484458953142,
-0.7011190056800842,
0.8616475462913513,
-0.0533980131149292,
-0.4666319787502289,
0.04914233088493347,
-0.26631709933280945,
-0.6496132016181946,
0.9030274748802185,
0.07147587090730667,
-0.7442697882652283,
0.7439652681350708,
0.24066713452339172,
0.26440519094467163,
-0.2195463925600052,
-0.3039911389350891,
0.8131755590438843,
0.7925911545753479,
-0.02725313976407051,
-1.2177658081054688,
-0.4485946297645569,
-0.049730025231838226,
-0.11423755437135696,
0.24987906217575073,
-0.7624224424362183,
0.42657580971717834,
0.06526581943035126,
-0.31192535161972046,
0.3798169195652008,
0.6356943845748901,
0.11621689051389694,
0.1358390897512436,
0.47090569138526917,
0.3413846492767334,
0.9856126308441162,
-0.038491033017635345,
0.6647765636444092,
0.031224742531776428,
0.04272943362593651,
1.22450852394104,
-0.6536110043525696,
0.7692503929138184,
0.5585021376609802,
-0.43282705545425415,
0.284103125333786,
0.5439116954803467,
0.13600069284439087,
0.7717159986495972,
-0.09580548852682114,
-0.6691275835037231,
0.24184533953666687,
-0.6957947611808777,
-0.7473785877227783,
1.0922436714172363,
0.6315438151359558,
-0.2626494765281677,
-0.2504403293132782,
0.28360286355018616,
0.1302899420261383,
0.5061832666397095,
-0.20025946199893951,
0.5204275846481323,
0.012263552285730839,
-0.28279730677604675,
0.2776122987270355,
-0.0971648320555687,
0.4689348638057709,
-0.7680918574333191,
-0.25303322076797485,
-0.08587988466024399,
-0.1721171885728836,
-0.11308912187814713,
-0.7969738841056824,
0.37783339619636536,
0.22780568897724152,
-0.11351218819618225,
0.10456940531730652,
0.43465423583984375,
-0.4405903220176697,
-0.5734468698501587,
0.2954632639884949,
0.02059944160282612,
0.32149720191955566,
0.5017313957214355,
-0.0686548724770546,
0.2215808928012848,
-0.30470147728919983,
0.2782977521419525,
-0.08587763458490372,
0.03179042786359787,
-0.06714795529842377,
0.4407140612602234,
0.48614248633384705,
0.5264266133308411,
0.17636632919311523,
0.28181129693984985,
0.49977999925613403,
-0.439495325088501,
-0.4276490807533264,
-0.5175259113311768,
-0.1421934962272644,
0.05082317814230919,
-0.4878515601158142,
0.7864229679107666,
0.48301833868026733,
0.7521880865097046,
-0.36023378372192383,
0.8433260917663574,
-0.3484855890274048,
0.24259443581104279,
-0.5046805739402771,
0.7775770425796509,
-0.22189582884311676,
-0.35682031512260437,
-0.3128334879875183,
-0.9094340205192566,
0.11566268652677536,
0.7844132781028748,
-0.07496348023414612,
-0.31427085399627686,
0.34938478469848633,
0.7354811429977417,
0.1748727262020111,
0.46961942315101624,
0.37004029750823975,
0.4373369514942169,
0.04778970777988434,
0.5469183325767517,
0.6430816650390625,
-0.5620279908180237,
0.3763725161552429,
-0.3689991533756256,
-0.19986878335475922,
-0.13788701593875885,
-0.8236359357833862,
-0.14673210680484772,
-1.0919599533081055,
-0.12819033861160278,
0.13562464714050293,
0.3012574315071106,
0.7896087765693665,
0.685455858707428,
-1.1701104640960693,
-0.6831434965133667,
0.09109080582857132,
-0.16003093123435974,
-0.14972108602523804,
-0.20282678306102753,
0.3968765437602997,
-0.03489449992775917,
-0.801171600818634,
0.7733184695243835,
0.3887697458267212,
0.022286497056484222,
-0.08742678165435791,
-0.18901339173316956,
-0.7749229073524475,
-0.120551697909832,
0.7883610725402832,
0.8140846490859985,
-0.6596521735191345,
-0.23483076691627502,
-0.39918336272239685,
0.12693333625793457,
0.11105456948280334,
0.24083311855793,
-0.7792176604270935,
0.6132652759552002,
0.23153436183929443,
0.6438405513763428,
0.24711567163467407,
-0.19224591553211212,
0.7139926552772522,
-0.5346239805221558,
0.6450316905975342,
0.11053244769573212,
0.42727354168891907,
0.26963523030281067,
-0.48397526144981384,
0.6665619015693665,
-0.05784519761800766,
-0.6068981289863586,
-0.4308452904224396,
-0.040484435856342316,
-0.9943697452545166,
0.24800166487693787,
0.7600104212760925,
-0.04226319491863251,
-0.44622567296028137,
-0.3661670684814453,
-0.6045427918434143,
0.46659228205680847,
-0.6154594421386719,
0.6946768164634705,
0.8587961196899414,
0.2615119516849518,
0.16556057333946228,
-0.764186441898346,
0.36658719182014465,
0.2791576385498047,
-0.8023850321769714,
-0.40945929288864136,
0.5867336988449097,
-0.09779050201177597,
0.21350720524787903,
0.7930170893669128,
-0.17810623347759247,
0.42017388343811035,
-0.14932014048099518,
-0.2559506297111511,
0.39699414372444153,
-0.4598875939846039,
-0.1550973504781723,
0.17419631779193878,
0.12465213984251022,
-0.697904646396637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01961v1
|
Team UTSA-NLP at SemEval 2024 Task 5: Prompt Ensembling for Argument Reasoning in Civil Procedures with GPT4
| 2024-04-02T13:55:05 | 2024-04-02T13:55:05 |
Dan Schumacher, Anthony Rios
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present our system for the SemEval Task 5, The Legal
Argument Reasoning Task in Civil Procedure Challenge. Legal argument reasoning
is an essential skill that all law students must master. Moreover, it is
important to develop natural language processing solutions that can reason
about a question given terse domain-specific contextual information. Our system
explores a prompt-based solution using GPT4 to reason over legal arguments. We
also evaluate an ensemble of prompting strategies, including chain-of-thought
reasoning and in-context learning. Overall, our system results in a Macro F1 of
.8095 on the validation dataset and .7315 (5th out of 21 teams) on the final
test set. Code for this project is available at
https://github.com/danschumac1/CivilPromptReasoningGPT4.
|
[
-0.37133148312568665,
-0.5854344964027405,
0.8504013419151306,
0.3208928406238556,
-0.6068435311317444,
-0.20074835419654846,
0.12680649757385254,
-0.14186756312847137,
-0.12186913192272186,
0.5025086402893066,
-0.3959686756134033,
-0.44849520921707153,
-0.32052135467529297,
0.6261163353919983,
-0.07291795313358307,
0.9160431027412415,
-0.07835683226585388,
0.29529282450675964,
-0.31835299730300903,
-0.3725999891757965,
-0.9348680973052979,
-0.6885846853256226,
-1.071694016456604,
-0.18219007551670074,
0.28954198956489563,
0.6947258114814758,
0.0752302035689354,
0.15598198771476746,
0.0995660275220871,
0.2924198508262634,
-0.19464011490345,
-0.14717279374599457,
0.20643755793571472,
0.6157740950584412,
-0.6030621528625488,
-0.19880659878253937,
-0.2360559105873108,
-0.293846994638443,
0.17028358578681946,
0.3135528266429901,
-0.2790631651878357,
0.08207683265209198,
0.04296298325061798,
0.365285187959671,
-0.2878856658935547,
0.007151799276471138,
-0.5793517231941223,
0.2065235823392868,
-0.22134332358837128,
-0.45604875683784485,
-0.31018349528312683,
-0.2078658938407898,
0.05344772711396217,
-0.36030295491218567,
0.2099061906337738,
-0.06405869871377945,
0.802450954914093,
0.5516638159751892,
-0.4649679660797119,
-0.24413250386714935,
-0.25027206540107727,
0.3136596977710724,
-0.8562887907028198,
0.13899008929729462,
0.214967742562294,
0.5103000998497009,
-0.21178965270519257,
-0.803353488445282,
-0.4086642861366272,
-0.0017497033113613725,
0.3251931369304657,
0.34710875153541565,
0.1277356892824173,
0.10634585469961166,
0.44457247853279114,
-0.17726726830005646,
-0.7659700512886047,
-0.09345100075006485,
-0.3977178931236267,
-0.33235031366348267,
0.5427974462509155,
0.1366274356842041,
0.2219434380531311,
-0.1292528510093689,
-0.3776431679725647,
0.37438222765922546,
-0.8363813161849976,
0.19484561681747437,
0.24354827404022217,
0.2046431452035904,
0.09751284122467041,
0.5046337246894836,
-0.16661210358142853,
0.526648759841919,
0.007738746702671051,
0.41699889302253723,
0.0593063049018383,
-0.30420055985450745,
-0.5289848446846008,
0.25770729780197144,
0.5627377033233643,
0.0513291098177433,
-0.07759501785039902,
0.2052708864212036,
-0.26802340149879456,
-0.048971209675073624,
0.26235231757164,
-0.49916326999664307,
-0.04496808722615242,
0.2317957729101181,
-0.2673279345035553,
-0.2460792064666748,
-0.13976971805095673,
-0.9579481482505798,
-0.5426768064498901,
-0.3258955478668213,
0.47058990597724915,
-0.3412827253341675,
0.19260236620903015,
0.2989453375339508,
-0.32384294271469116,
0.39716780185699463,
0.6878588199615479,
-0.7663694620132446,
0.21155868470668793,
0.47182697057724,
0.4450152814388275,
0.08666033297777176,
0.011225518770515919,
-0.8988224864006042,
0.21782207489013672,
-0.052334610372781754,
1.0952008962631226,
-0.7466825842857361,
-0.4135858714580536,
-0.22172735631465912,
0.15792597830295563,
0.05686380714178085,
-0.420149028301239,
1.368563175201416,
-0.3463614881038666,
0.24397681653499603,
-0.6833344101905823,
-0.4521336555480957,
-0.16786402463912964,
0.22567343711853027,
-0.37775886058807373,
0.9247348308563232,
-0.08787278831005096,
-0.47208619117736816,
0.6266077756881714,
-1.224344253540039,
-0.5481070280075073,
0.6401935815811157,
-0.5073603987693787,
-0.1417519450187683,
-0.056062422692775726,
0.6444109678268433,
0.4303514361381531,
-0.14642830193042755,
0.43623292446136475,
-0.05780475214123726,
-0.22227618098258972,
-0.2891467213630676,
-0.20143957436084747,
1.0333046913146973,
0.4591296911239624,
-0.6771580576896667,
0.2225947231054306,
-0.364585816860199,
-0.2290859818458557,
0.3056993782520294,
-0.5162732601165771,
-0.1288011074066162,
-0.12405162304639816,
-0.4013824760913849,
0.3390335738658905,
0.11847612261772156,
-0.41339200735092163,
0.3602631092071533,
-0.33863481879234314,
0.4345775842666626,
0.892562747001648,
0.41523048281669617,
0.1816176325082779,
0.19147169589996338,
0.849934458732605,
-0.10153120011091232,
0.05506299063563347,
-0.12729904055595398,
-0.8861780762672424,
-0.5887008905410767,
0.2433623969554901,
0.336380273103714,
0.6263473629951477,
-0.7964996695518494,
0.13377049565315247,
0.39915186166763306,
0.03990044817328453,
-0.10292521864175797,
-0.29555392265319824,
0.02256636507809162,
0.6952176094055176,
0.5419134497642517,
0.2177145779132843,
-0.918687105178833,
-0.7672098278999329,
-0.33192476630210876,
-0.19465409219264984,
-0.08002369850873947,
0.2594919204711914,
0.807507336139679,
-0.1661161333322525,
0.811656653881073,
-0.12550340592861176,
-0.19302213191986084,
-0.34758707880973816,
0.4108852446079254,
0.37082627415657043,
0.24485185742378235,
0.3252982497215271,
-0.6379709839820862,
-0.16832298040390015,
-0.02191975526511669,
-0.8744688034057617,
-0.7050784230232239,
-0.20078159868717194,
0.05115590989589691,
0.5210704803466797,
0.7197321057319641,
-0.20433223247528076,
0.37080302834510803,
0.1048651710152626,
-0.8181260228157043,
0.74306720495224,
-0.18713301420211792,
0.21313774585723877,
-1.099005103111267,
-0.015281779691576958,
0.033113837242126465,
-0.33131393790245056,
-0.2683168649673462,
0.14813534915447235,
-0.3025341331958771,
-0.32680708169937134,
-0.46777579188346863,
0.35060855746269226,
-0.48899704217910767,
0.019774727523326874,
-0.0756218358874321,
-0.05842088535428047,
0.016086069867014885,
0.31601405143737793,
0.08522515743970871,
0.8988977074623108,
0.4881245791912079,
-0.5207924246788025,
0.41456568241119385,
0.25297144055366516,
0.1333809792995453,
0.844426155090332,
-0.7831940650939941,
0.26064905524253845,
0.19534309208393097,
0.2935599088668823,
-0.6622653603553772,
-0.317445307970047,
0.18827112019062042,
-0.44901901483535767,
0.09525120258331299,
-0.42930227518081665,
-0.41054269671440125,
-0.5721287131309509,
0.005568179301917553,
0.09085036814212799,
0.18469949066638947,
-0.42177101969718933,
0.5870140790939331,
0.6045388579368591,
-0.529090940952301,
-0.55915766954422,
-0.27255547046661377,
0.5672590136528015,
-0.5865445137023926,
-0.6020330786705017,
0.17655955255031586,
0.12078350782394409,
-0.03986483812332153,
-0.0006829943740740418,
-0.23209887742996216,
-0.12337162345647812,
-0.005530615337193012,
0.1437307447195053,
0.09784422069787979,
-0.11744829267263412,
0.1857180893421173,
0.3517375588417053,
-0.14171652495861053,
0.49190080165863037,
-0.24293021857738495,
0.529821515083313,
-0.6487076878547668,
-0.32678115367889404,
-0.1590789556503296,
0.5058547854423523,
0.2654491364955902,
-0.05478108301758766,
0.19865572452545166,
0.2107110619544983,
-0.5757225751876831,
-0.043632298707962036,
-0.53235924243927,
-0.09960831701755524,
-0.4592851400375366,
-0.046600423753261566,
-0.7137508392333984,
-1.1150556802749634,
0.5899789333343506,
-0.1879916787147522,
0.33354613184928894,
0.6215967535972595,
0.5949106812477112,
-0.24480508267879486,
1.1201001405715942,
0.15565605461597443,
0.12692946195602417,
-0.10491504520177841,
0.017106015235185623,
0.08949463069438934,
-0.6204038858413696,
-0.2840750217437744,
-0.8460512161254883,
0.05077539384365082,
-0.02654707245528698,
-0.3468492925167084,
0.43395185470581055,
0.018171481788158417,
-0.4480481445789337,
0.49444350600242615,
-0.6758609414100647,
0.5917781591415405,
0.44643133878707886,
-0.2655767798423767,
0.15245887637138367,
-0.21946468949317932,
-0.8473614454269409,
0.007324101869016886,
-0.5855492949485779,
-0.7037007808685303,
0.6168983578681946,
0.3830718398094177,
0.49179020524024963,
0.2080070823431015,
1.0181875228881836,
0.351681113243103,
-0.08411858975887299,
-0.5442529320716858,
1.0000182390213013,
0.2480315864086151,
-0.4674256145954132,
-0.6155583262443542,
-0.2901584506034851,
-1.0882781744003296,
0.29338857531547546,
-0.003934704698622227,
-0.7431442141532898,
0.029235370457172394,
-0.09708525240421295,
-0.6641066074371338,
-0.048897240310907364,
-0.3896455764770508,
0.9748432636260986,
0.038257814943790436,
-0.29912880063056946,
-0.025383783504366875,
-0.812886118888855,
0.19656582176685333,
0.12603388726711273,
0.05937044322490692,
-0.017587868496775627,
0.026885049417614937,
0.788170337677002,
-0.6256811022758484,
0.5803760290145874,
-0.5137118101119995,
-0.12740567326545715,
0.4768340289592743,
-0.1793918013572693,
0.41451296210289,
0.42893996834754944,
0.005943561438471079,
-0.23526543378829956,
0.14440567791461945,
-0.07222530245780945,
-0.4545832872390747,
0.46254175901412964,
-0.13146360218524933,
-0.808091402053833,
-0.7054073810577393,
-0.2733534276485443,
-0.18765439093112946,
0.09830734133720398,
0.2511066794395447,
0.44784778356552124,
-0.0016873128479346633,
0.12471943348646164,
0.5015776753425598,
-0.15017752349376678,
0.652702808380127,
0.3547532558441162,
0.1396462321281433,
-0.3922548294067383,
0.7053107619285583,
0.029966898262500763,
-0.45005902647972107,
-0.0218338780105114,
0.4355999529361725,
-0.8566187620162964,
-0.5668823719024658,
-0.8609651327133179,
0.10004069656133652,
-0.9003093838691711,
-0.31294527649879456,
-0.7208893895149231,
-0.13974086940288544,
-0.6293026804924011,
-0.346413791179657,
0.10779774188995361,
-0.5003814697265625,
-0.11171586066484451,
-0.08636434376239777,
-0.11160893738269806,
0.7673941850662231,
0.05656163766980171,
-0.2775413691997528,
-0.8697096705436707,
-0.09427545219659805,
0.42261284589767456,
0.0922330692410469,
-0.6945434212684631,
-0.7434788346290588,
0.08047551661729813,
-0.43832477927207947,
-0.4321826696395874,
-1.2459862232208252,
0.14624637365341187,
-0.156828835606575,
0.8504253029823303,
0.3688491880893707,
0.05541277304291725,
0.6049728989601135,
-0.5867337584495544,
1.028504729270935,
-0.11459271609783173,
-1.0813223123550415,
1.110274076461792,
-0.6547020673751831,
0.4383789300918579,
0.8021636009216309,
0.12176770716905594,
-0.47200724482536316,
-0.4990749955177307,
-0.7959070801734924,
-0.7594243288040161,
0.39785856008529663,
0.19573646783828735,
-0.22794277966022491,
-0.11574389785528183,
0.2264733463525772,
-0.09130837023258209,
-0.0017601476283743978,
-0.7596970200538635,
0.34417200088500977,
-0.13097964227199554,
-0.06176897883415222,
0.636548638343811,
-0.21479476988315582,
-0.38383278250694275,
-0.43588438630104065,
0.731453001499176,
-0.42220786213874817,
0.32006433606147766,
0.3088986575603485,
-0.032219208776950836,
0.17468759417533875,
0.8004387021064758,
1.0476832389831543,
0.63336580991745,
0.051514290273189545,
0.049159541726112366,
0.6455486416816711,
-0.3803369700908661,
0.3803175687789917,
0.2849915325641632,
0.042173147201538086,
0.13585469126701355,
0.038264837116003036,
0.5446081757545471,
0.09492890536785126,
-0.44285884499549866,
0.5954011678695679,
-0.3004603981971741,
-0.6912474632263184,
-0.48671478033065796,
-0.0840127244591713,
0.09449046850204468,
0.45434898138046265,
0.3299610912799835,
0.07569079101085663,
0.5323851704597473,
-0.2790408730506897,
0.2675738036632538,
0.1661861389875412,
-0.3508673906326294,
-0.2488100528717041,
0.9443458318710327,
0.5574867129325867,
-0.0002883748966269195,
0.11626212298870087,
-0.5456562042236328,
-0.6159026026725769,
0.6895195245742798,
0.6593489050865173,
0.9323275685310364,
-0.378610759973526,
0.301371306180954,
0.46077659726142883,
0.1751774549484253,
-0.18283946812152863,
0.7519392371177673,
-0.064947210252285,
-0.5009847283363342,
-0.661541759967804,
-0.3947615623474121,
-0.5095791220664978,
0.37571388483047485,
-0.273045152425766,
0.5358115434646606,
-0.3346898555755615,
-0.04684148356318474,
-0.2753799855709076,
-0.16104969382286072,
-0.349306583404541,
0.20370203256607056,
0.06519711762666702,
1.0258454084396362,
-0.8802767992019653,
0.5741984248161316,
1.1897039413452148,
-0.4846959412097931,
-0.9892715215682983,
-0.16184668242931366,
0.33469876646995544,
-0.19309167563915253,
0.679669976234436,
0.4007839560508728,
-0.1048935130238533,
-0.0337677076458931,
-0.6419419646263123,
-0.30423685908317566,
0.9355894327163696,
0.3651946485042572,
-0.2898100018501282,
0.050573356449604034,
-0.08779018372297287,
0.3266957700252533,
-0.29860568046569824,
0.0004929234855808318,
0.6018168330192566,
0.5974608063697815,
0.3409934937953949,
-0.6973246932029724,
0.3009362816810608,
-0.3400801420211792,
-0.32024553418159485,
0.08422097563743591,
-0.088922880589962,
0.44013145565986633,
-0.3505387604236603,
-0.4349915087223053,
-0.27680033445358276,
0.7730991244316101,
0.5422716736793518,
0.4079599678516388,
0.7390196919441223,
0.9123644828796387,
0.8416221141815186,
-0.1665600836277008,
0.6555883884429932,
0.20398566126823425,
0.1779809445142746,
1.2365303039550781,
-0.5485267639160156,
0.5138536691665649,
0.6217735409736633,
-0.05456939712166786,
0.4110988676548004,
0.7771875262260437,
0.11459629982709885,
0.22956067323684692,
0.07663725316524506,
-0.6240323781967163,
-0.38330718874931335,
-0.15774329006671906,
-0.46552321314811707,
0.47650307416915894,
0.4189967215061188,
-0.0888754352927208,
-0.4528043568134308,
0.005243626888841391,
-0.014856782741844654,
-0.09717661887407303,
-0.22935304045677185,
0.7939820289611816,
0.14535591006278992,
-0.9293355345726013,
0.15491421520709991,
-0.1056930348277092,
0.1880650520324707,
-0.1911948025226593,
-0.39218762516975403,
-0.17562313377857208,
-0.18830417096614838,
-0.11667663604021072,
-1.2377326488494873,
0.48057711124420166,
0.22648479044437408,
0.33702635765075684,
-0.23744282126426697,
0.8776050806045532,
-0.11844512820243835,
-0.03267306089401245,
-0.017267871648073196,
0.3578125536441803,
0.4011990427970886,
-0.04822312295436859,
-0.8600705862045288,
-0.3463578224182129,
-0.020135940983891487,
-0.37927278876304626,
0.024716876447200775,
0.7251068949699402,
-0.48923200368881226,
0.397538423538208,
0.5748271942138672,
0.0037673739716410637,
-0.10328934341669083,
0.7106443643569946,
0.9036176800727844,
-0.6011284589767456,
-0.587023913860321,
-0.9301097393035889,
0.6544447541236877,
-0.49194884300231934,
-0.454691618680954,
0.5148617625236511,
0.5758472681045532,
0.3684149980545044,
0.016575133427977562,
0.7855376601219177,
-0.19746874272823334,
0.3312062919139862,
-0.6203403472900391,
0.3508596122264862,
-0.3118046820163727,
0.13153418898582458,
-0.3847634196281433,
-0.7254480123519897,
-0.3767876625061035,
0.7332018613815308,
-0.10132959485054016,
-0.21411429345607758,
1.0188825130462646,
0.4680244028568268,
0.1923598349094391,
0.49806931614875793,
0.4083099663257599,
-0.23448610305786133,
0.5938319563865662,
0.5857667922973633,
0.8162228465080261,
-0.062358610332012177,
0.5459941625595093,
0.333555668592453,
-0.1591125875711441,
-0.16011109948158264,
-1.075535535812378,
-0.8188206553459167,
-0.6098253130912781,
-0.04447586089372635,
-0.3821006715297699,
0.1538352072238922,
1.0242364406585693,
0.2812541127204895,
-0.8586330413818359,
0.11605194211006165,
-0.4217377305030823,
-0.14235888421535492,
-0.06018488109111786,
-0.25926473736763,
0.053915925323963165,
-0.7000749111175537,
-0.4028666913509369,
0.740044116973877,
0.5521543025970459,
-0.009197589010000229,
0.17028184235095978,
-0.13937826454639435,
-0.4495999217033386,
0.13566088676452637,
0.6310621500015259,
0.448917418718338,
-0.665222704410553,
-0.5618216395378113,
-0.15747669339179993,
0.04663221538066864,
-0.0004919715574942529,
0.8472682237625122,
-0.6322790384292603,
0.37193363904953003,
0.7100415825843811,
0.982157826423645,
0.34083274006843567,
0.18426381051540375,
0.8382882475852966,
-0.7094579339027405,
0.07629498839378357,
0.6164048314094543,
0.9360893368721008,
0.06314300000667572,
-0.3814086616039276,
1.145227074623108,
0.4357803165912628,
-1.0870521068572998,
-0.6415868997573853,
0.12409576773643494,
-0.8783750534057617,
-0.14526690542697906,
1.0713945627212524,
-0.14249250292778015,
0.016419030725955963,
-0.7312986850738525,
-0.6292210817337036,
0.2138434499502182,
-0.65496426820755,
0.4221000373363495,
0.9474266767501831,
-0.35621100664138794,
-0.4216806888580322,
-0.8905209302902222,
0.5538438558578491,
0.7544219493865967,
-1.2609245777130127,
-0.3836430013179779,
0.507890522480011,
0.08217161148786545,
-0.06597930938005447,
0.966916024684906,
-0.2206694781780243,
0.5225858688354492,
-0.22149643301963806,
-0.018222341313958168,
-0.011298266239464283,
-0.4892337918281555,
-0.6500147581100464,
0.21060311794281006,
-0.30834344029426575,
-0.08880984783172607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01954v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01954v2
|
HyperCLOVA X Technical Report
| 2024-04-02T13:48:49 | 2024-04-13T15:06:19 |
Kang Min Yoo, Jaegeun Han, Sookyo In, Heewon Jeon, Jisu Jeong, Jaewook Kang, Hyunwook Kim, Kyung-Min Kim, Munhyong Kim, Sungju Kim, Donghyun Kwak, Hanock Kwak, Se Jung Kwon, Bado Lee, Dongsoo Lee, Gichang Lee, Jooho Lee, Baeseong Park, Seongjin Shin, Joonsang Yu, Seolki Baek, Sumin Byeon, Eungsup Cho, Dooseok Choe, Jeesung Han, Youngkyun Jin, Hyein Jun, Jaeseung Jung, Chanwoong Kim, Jinhong Kim, Jinuk Kim, Dokyeong Lee, Dongwook Park, Jeong Min Sohn, Sujung Han, Jiae Heo, Sungju Hong, Mina Jeon, Hyunhoon Jung, Jungeun Jung, Wangkyo Jung, Chungjoon Kim, Hyeri Kim, Jonghyun Kim, Min Young Kim, Soeun Lee, Joonhee Park, Jieun Shin, Sojin Yang, Jungsoon Yoon, Hwaran Lee, Sanghwan Bae, Jeehwan Cha, Karl Gylleus, Donghoon Ham, Mihak Hong, Youngki Hong, Yunki Hong, Dahyun Jang, Hyojun Jeon, Yujin Jeon, Yeji Jeong, Myunggeun Ji, Yeguk Jin, Chansong Jo, Shinyoung Joo, Seunghwan Jung, Adrian Jungmyung Kim, Byoung Hoon Kim, Hyomin Kim, Jungwhan Kim, Minkyoung Kim, Minseung Kim, Sungdong Kim, Yonghee Kim, Youngjun Kim, Youngkwan Kim, Donghyeon Ko, Dughyun Lee, Ha Young Lee, Jaehong Lee, Jieun Lee, Jonghyun Lee, Jongjin Lee, Min Young Lee, Yehbin Lee, Taehong Min, Yuri Min, Kiyoon Moon, Hyangnam Oh, Jaesun Park, Kyuyon Park, Younghun Park, Hanbae Seo, Seunghyun Seo, Mihyun Sim, Gyubin Son, Matt Yeo, Kyung Hoon Yeom, Wonjoon Yoo, Myungin You, Doheon Ahn, Homin Ahn, Joohee Ahn, Seongmin Ahn, Chanwoo An, Hyeryun An, Junho An, Sang-Min An, Boram Byun, Eunbin Byun, Jongho Cha, Minji Chang, Seunggyu Chang, Haesong Cho, Youngdo Cho, Dalnim Choi, Daseul Choi, Hyoseok Choi, Minseong Choi, Sangho Choi, Seongjae Choi, Wooyong Choi, Sewhan Chun, Dong Young Go, Chiheon Ham, Danbi Han, Jaemin Han, Moonyoung Hong, Sung Bum Hong, Dong-Hyun Hwang, Seongchan Hwang, Jinbae Im, Hyuk Jin Jang, Jaehyung Jang, Jaeni Jang, Sihyeon Jang, Sungwon Jang, Joonha Jeon, Daun Jeong, Joonhyun Jeong, Kyeongseok Jeong, Mini Jeong, Sol Jin, Hanbyeol Jo, Hanju Jo, Minjung Jo, Chaeyoon Jung, Hyungsik Jung, Jaeuk Jung, Ju Hwan Jung, Kwangsun Jung, Seungjae Jung, Soonwon Ka, Donghan Kang, Soyoung Kang, Taeho Kil, Areum Kim, Beomyoung Kim, Byeongwook Kim, Daehee Kim, Dong-Gyun Kim, Donggook Kim, Donghyun Kim, Euna Kim, Eunchul Kim, Geewook Kim, Gyu Ri Kim, Hanbyul Kim, Heesu Kim, Isaac Kim, Jeonghoon Kim, Jihye Kim, Joonghoon Kim, Minjae Kim, Minsub Kim, Pil Hwan Kim, Sammy Kim, Seokhun Kim, Seonghyeon Kim, Soojin Kim, Soong Kim, Soyoon Kim, Sunyoung Kim, Taeho Kim, Wonho Kim, Yoonsik Kim, You Jin Kim, Yuri Kim, Beomseok Kwon, Ohsung Kwon, Yoo-Hwan Kwon, Anna Lee, Byungwook Lee, Changho Lee, Daun Lee, Dongjae Lee, Ha-Ram Lee, Hodong Lee, Hwiyeong Lee, Hyunmi Lee, Injae Lee, Jaeung Lee, Jeongsang Lee, Jisoo Lee, Jongsoo Lee, Joongjae Lee, Juhan Lee, Jung Hyun Lee, Junghoon Lee, Junwoo Lee, Se Yun Lee, Sujin Lee, Sungjae Lee, Sungwoo Lee, Wonjae Lee, Zoo Hyun Lee, Jong Kun Lim, Kun Lim, Taemin Lim, Nuri Na, Jeongyeon Nam, Kyeong-Min Nam, Yeonseog Noh, Biro Oh, Jung-Sik Oh, Solgil Oh, Yeontaek Oh, Boyoun Park, Cheonbok Park, Dongju Park, Hyeonjin Park, Hyun Tae Park, Hyunjung Park, Jihye Park, Jooseok Park, Junghwan Park, Jungsoo Park, Miru Park, Sang Hee Park, Seunghyun Park, Soyoung Park, Taerim Park, Wonkyeong Park, Hyunjoon Ryu, Jeonghun Ryu, Nahyeon Ryu, Soonshin Seo, Suk Min Seo, Yoonjeong Shim, Kyuyong Shin, Wonkwang Shin, Hyun Sim, Woongseob Sim, Hyejin Soh, Bokyong Son, Hyunjun Son, Seulah Son, Chi-Yun Song, Chiyoung Song, Ka Yeon Song, Minchul Song, Seungmin Song, Jisung Wang, Yonggoo Yeo, Myeong Yeon Yi, Moon Bin Yim, Taehwan Yoo, Youngjoon Yoo, Sungmin Yoon, Young Jin Yoon, Hangyeol Yu, Ui Seon Yu, Xingdong Zuo, Jeongin Bae, Joungeun Bae, Hyunsoo Cho, Seonghyun Cho, Yongjin Cho, Taekyoon Choi, Yera Choi, Jiwan Chung, Zhenghui Han, Byeongho Heo, Euisuk Hong, Taebaek Hwang, Seonyeol Im, Sumin Jegal, Sumin Jeon, Yelim Jeong, Yonghyun Jeong, Can Jiang, Juyong Jiang, Jiho Jin, Ara Jo, Younghyun Jo, Hoyoun Jung, Juyoung Jung, Seunghyeong Kang, Dae Hee Kim, Ginam Kim, Hangyeol Kim, Heeseung Kim, Hyojin Kim, Hyojun Kim, Hyun-Ah Kim, Jeehye Kim, Jin-Hwa Kim, Jiseon Kim, Jonghak Kim, Jung Yoon Kim, Rak Yeong Kim, Seongjin Kim, Seoyoon Kim, Sewon Kim, Sooyoung Kim, Sukyoung Kim, Taeyong Kim, Naeun Ko, Bonseung Koo, Heeyoung Kwak, Haena Kwon, Youngjin Kwon, Boram Lee, Bruce W. Lee, Dagyeong Lee, Erin Lee, Euijin Lee, Ha Gyeong Lee, Hyojin Lee, Hyunjeong Lee, Jeeyoon Lee, Jeonghyun Lee, Jongheok Lee, Joonhyung Lee, Junhyuk Lee, Mingu Lee, Nayeon Lee, Sangkyu Lee, Se Young Lee, Seulgi Lee, Seung Jin Lee, Suhyeon Lee, Yeonjae Lee, Yesol Lee, Youngbeom Lee, Yujin Lee, Shaodong Li, Tianyu Liu, Seong-Eun Moon, Taehong Moon, Max-Lasse Nihlenramstroem, Wonseok Oh, Yuri Oh, Hongbeen Park, Hyekyung Park, Jaeho Park, Nohil Park, Sangjin Park, Jiwon Ryu, Miru Ryu, Simo Ryu, Ahreum Seo, Hee Seo, Kangdeok Seo, Jamin Shin, Seungyoun Shin, Heetae Sin, Jiangping Wang, Lei Wang, Ning Xiang, Longxiang Xiao, Jing Xu, Seonyeong Yi, Haanju Yoo, Haneul Yoo, Hwanhee Yoo, Liang Yu, Youngjae Yu, Weijie Yuan, Bo Zeng, Qian Zhou, Kyunghyun Cho, Jung-Woo Ha, Joonsuk Park, Jihyun Hwang, Hyoung Jo Kwon, Soonyong Kwon, Jungyeon Lee, Seungho Lee, Seonghyeon Lim, Hyunkyung Noh, Seungho Choi, Sang-Woo Lee, Jung Hwa Lim, Nako Sung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce HyperCLOVA X, a family of large language models (LLMs) tailored
to the Korean language and culture, along with competitive capabilities in
English, math, and coding. HyperCLOVA X was trained on a balanced mix of
Korean, English, and code data, followed by instruction-tuning with
high-quality human-annotated datasets while abiding by strict safety guidelines
reflecting our commitment to responsible AI. The model is evaluated across
various benchmarks, including comprehensive reasoning, knowledge, commonsense,
factuality, coding, math, chatting, instruction-following, and harmlessness, in
both Korean and English. HyperCLOVA X exhibits strong reasoning capabilities in
Korean backed by a deep understanding of the language and cultural nuances.
Further analysis of the inherent bilingual nature and its extension to
multilingualism highlights the model's cross-lingual proficiency and strong
generalization ability to untargeted languages, including machine translation
between several language pairs and cross-lingual inference tasks. We believe
that HyperCLOVA X can provide helpful guidance for regions or countries in
developing their sovereign LLMs.
|
[
-0.1989900767803192,
-0.3497315049171448,
0.6439394950866699,
0.45123642683029175,
0.024629803374409676,
0.4342171549797058,
-0.5248955488204956,
-0.39541810750961304,
0.18380765616893768,
0.7185097932815552,
-0.3430047929286957,
-0.7256036996841431,
-0.3440428376197815,
0.201687291264534,
-0.38448965549468994,
1.0984703302383423,
-0.14025698602199554,
0.3416341245174408,
-0.295708030462265,
-0.2302243858575821,
-0.39755114912986755,
-0.8910881280899048,
-0.058432143181562424,
-0.4352056384086609,
0.42016711831092834,
0.57914137840271,
0.9659331440925598,
0.9431741833686829,
0.4113461673259735,
0.35316020250320435,
-0.2937942445278168,
-0.05992250517010689,
-0.6586502194404602,
0.09988744556903839,
-0.20746783912181854,
-0.8659695386886597,
-0.7394675016403198,
0.044654473662376404,
0.6079823970794678,
0.6354398131370544,
0.05434449017047882,
0.6283935308456421,
-0.28688955307006836,
0.6505401730537415,
-0.3255176842212677,
0.33720821142196655,
-0.5211002230644226,
0.03860485926270485,
-0.2151961326599121,
0.06393203139305115,
-0.3585842251777649,
-0.21887598931789398,
0.33445310592651367,
-0.9484639763832092,
-0.16454912722110748,
0.37790751457214355,
0.8616243600845337,
0.03792104497551918,
-0.3692997097969055,
-0.28003332018852234,
-0.9496751427650452,
0.9596779942512512,
-0.16839367151260376,
0.7488113641738892,
0.47166624665260315,
0.28077757358551025,
0.035844434052705765,
-0.6019071340560913,
-0.6253337860107422,
-0.3415951728820801,
0.23504042625427246,
0.016417961567640305,
-0.3356902301311493,
-0.12936940789222717,
0.06245340406894684,
0.17758513987064362,
-0.973343014717102,
0.11835277080535889,
-0.4273990988731384,
-0.10623794049024582,
0.770358681678772,
0.42148640751838684,
0.3820042014122009,
-0.24841514229774475,
-0.3021354079246521,
0.044366504997015,
-0.8477252721786499,
0.0812436193227768,
0.342553049325943,
0.1523086577653885,
-0.2762283980846405,
0.6816673278808594,
-0.5078205466270447,
0.39637261629104614,
-0.34047582745552063,
-0.38292446732521057,
0.5598921775817871,
-0.6517415642738342,
-0.295428067445755,
0.22382038831710815,
0.47463956475257874,
0.4100603461265564,
0.5076431632041931,
-0.09257054328918457,
0.0062331752851605415,
0.07213730365037918,
-0.0996379479765892,
-0.5175386667251587,
-0.18582677841186523,
0.24620027840137482,
-0.5799567103385925,
-0.32008129358291626,
-0.23294733464717865,
-0.8489642143249512,
-0.14762045443058014,
-0.5563230514526367,
0.04116117209196091,
0.18689948320388794,
-0.46038252115249634,
0.5118809342384338,
0.08954725414514542,
-0.14429831504821777,
-0.13309970498085022,
-0.615544319152832,
0.4541318118572235,
0.6680986881256104,
0.5870427489280701,
-0.44704148173332214,
-0.4206542372703552,
-0.07167604565620422,
0.0024116302374750376,
-0.48050472140312195,
0.49265801906585693,
-0.5843491554260254,
-0.5081474184989929,
0.10748057067394257,
0.11241693794727325,
0.16591084003448486,
-0.7002298831939697,
0.7299673557281494,
-0.5927569270133972,
0.16968652606010437,
-0.23882970213890076,
-0.3294551372528076,
-0.3323993384838104,
0.40663620829582214,
-0.750095784664154,
0.8414182066917419,
0.009283021092414856,
-0.5350379347801208,
0.30861684679985046,
-0.5064020156860352,
-0.1495925635099411,
0.34406420588493347,
-0.03347506374120712,
-0.4261239469051361,
-0.016617340967059135,
-0.06623917073011398,
0.25479641556739807,
-0.5702048540115356,
0.13540159165859222,
-0.34821534156799316,
-0.23390871286392212,
0.21208512783050537,
-0.1140228733420372,
0.8071141839027405,
-0.03183884173631668,
-0.34281644225120544,
0.4961642622947693,
-1.1277368068695068,
0.32094335556030273,
0.28671711683273315,
-0.4545134902000427,
-0.6787479519844055,
-0.36150336265563965,
0.3976759612560272,
0.705096423625946,
0.2725282311439514,
-0.7862034440040588,
-0.0010185003047809005,
-0.1671205759048462,
0.18282027542591095,
0.5531860589981079,
-0.34720051288604736,
0.36409080028533936,
-0.014990045689046383,
0.9246029853820801,
-0.37849271297454834,
0.15063199400901794,
-0.11361338198184967,
-0.47936248779296875,
-0.5435829758644104,
-0.5641393661499023,
0.40102633833885193,
1.0212602615356445,
-0.8274049162864685,
0.24325977265834808,
-0.42270171642303467,
-0.47371557354927063,
-0.5096184015274048,
0.663799524307251,
0.8483189344406128,
0.28302499651908875,
0.02762593701481819,
0.42949193716049194,
-1.0022355318069458,
-0.7278928160667419,
0.22995200753211975,
-0.24774755537509918,
0.45104601979255676,
0.20639866590499878,
0.6650239825248718,
-0.39480072259902954,
0.5502108335494995,
-0.4280957579612732,
-0.06297871470451355,
-0.7705662250518799,
-0.10720792412757874,
0.05736852437257767,
0.11323809623718262,
0.2760865092277527,
-0.9745369553565979,
-0.7508414387702942,
0.6780408024787903,
-0.9803274869918823,
-0.048629067838191986,
0.10607516020536423,
-0.3159986734390259,
0.22194871306419373,
0.6559332013130188,
-0.6477916836738586,
0.2675505578517914,
0.9750935435295105,
-0.46776726841926575,
0.9107963442802429,
-0.1415412724018097,
0.06612647324800491,
-0.9622400403022766,
0.000554956030100584,
0.12388717383146286,
-0.23178909718990326,
-0.7048644423484802,
0.060184601694345474,
0.21061235666275024,
-0.22139936685562134,
-0.6358286142349243,
0.693260669708252,
-0.19151781499385834,
-0.025384703651070595,
-0.5265371799468994,
0.07767500728368759,
-0.13588181138038635,
0.28137707710266113,
0.17523205280303955,
1.0281802415847778,
0.4617170989513397,
-0.5212593078613281,
0.5927726030349731,
0.3734714686870575,
-0.6137481331825256,
0.3798253536224365,
-1.0631574392318726,
-0.18947598338127136,
0.16540727019309998,
0.020830752328038216,
-0.688660204410553,
-0.21990405023097992,
-0.33505499362945557,
-0.42387545108795166,
-0.255945086479187,
-0.05168507620692253,
-0.6032381057739258,
-0.6920843124389648,
-0.07838936150074005,
0.5577266812324524,
0.5623912215232849,
-0.42659324407577515,
0.2768373191356659,
0.506811797618866,
-0.4383324086666107,
-0.3764626383781433,
-0.2958787977695465,
0.055706851184368134,
-0.22989585995674133,
-0.7789304256439209,
0.12179075181484222,
-0.04731433838605881,
-0.4852469265460968,
0.12867581844329834,
0.23926429450511932,
-0.3186221122741699,
-0.032542504370212555,
0.28952330350875854,
0.6910552978515625,
-0.48255521059036255,
0.026420217007398605,
0.06216452270746231,
-0.3704177737236023,
0.1879601627588272,
-0.2092590630054474,
0.6105331778526306,
-0.11671549826860428,
-0.05672219768166542,
-0.6151957511901855,
0.3685120642185211,
1.226575255393982,
-0.4823288321495056,
0.3497413396835327,
0.35836341977119446,
-0.36233532428741455,
0.05408128350973129,
-0.31015822291374207,
0.39889174699783325,
-0.4051746129989624,
0.831200897693634,
-0.592660129070282,
-0.940568745136261,
0.6524052023887634,
-0.049087345600128174,
-0.17200082540512085,
0.008425697684288025,
1.0231484174728394,
0.12469783425331116,
1.6448071002960205,
0.9586514234542847,
-0.2500314712524414,
0.15347415208816528,
-0.10968205332756042,
0.13081324100494385,
-0.7604038119316101,
-0.41697898507118225,
-0.5742906332015991,
0.02055717073380947,
-0.6679086685180664,
-0.2510873079299927,
0.5230306386947632,
-0.4730599522590637,
-0.3282139003276825,
0.18356570601463318,
0.10032996535301208,
0.767937183380127,
0.5110654234886169,
-0.29919999837875366,
0.4604862630367279,
-0.07233604788780212,
-0.20178888738155365,
-0.3406718075275421,
-0.7952300906181335,
-0.5844654440879822,
1.35659921169281,
0.4379030168056488,
0.9005882740020752,
0.0303858183324337,
0.522441565990448,
0.16521191596984863,
-0.050973858684301376,
-0.6307748556137085,
0.5196974873542786,
-0.17287714779376984,
-0.8476402759552002,
-0.20399686694145203,
-0.2668958604335785,
-0.9406055808067322,
0.26495078206062317,
-0.3318794071674347,
-0.40611669421195984,
-0.017928563058376312,
0.03740039840340614,
-0.4811549484729767,
0.17400573194026947,
-0.5078158378601074,
0.8095874786376953,
-0.3990015983581543,
-0.2657640874385834,
-0.31434959173202515,
-0.4102214276790619,
0.6753580570220947,
-0.3231551945209503,
0.16643108427524567,
-0.014924082905054092,
0.02031916007399559,
0.660663902759552,
0.09474405646324158,
0.7068476676940918,
0.22061830759048462,
0.0755251944065094,
0.03186767175793648,
0.09847418963909149,
0.2799026072025299,
0.15968379378318787,
-0.01140984520316124,
0.13017775118350983,
-0.21268346905708313,
-0.5326638221740723,
-0.7629687190055847,
0.8528899550437927,
-0.9695655107498169,
-0.5883398652076721,
-0.22681528329849243,
-1.0125882625579834,
-0.06673511117696762,
0.3231266438961029,
-0.01947549544274807,
0.038488443940877914,
-0.3267177939414978,
0.22987863421440125,
1.0176489353179932,
-0.2078021764755249,
-0.11282374709844589,
0.4863351583480835,
-0.8345491290092468,
-0.6646993160247803,
1.2713415622711182,
0.1503259241580963,
0.3992280066013336,
-0.03955734148621559,
0.09413979947566986,
-0.3181796669960022,
-0.3043932318687439,
-0.6570440530776978,
0.5284059047698975,
-0.6086595058441162,
0.08183924853801727,
-0.6057239174842834,
-0.07022310793399811,
-0.1722361147403717,
-0.16631679236888885,
-0.7228617072105408,
-0.4166103005409241,
0.20146049559116364,
-0.3119382858276367,
-0.1559160202741623,
1.0731191635131836,
0.3035721778869629,
0.12604987621307373,
-0.7792317867279053,
0.24526703357696533,
0.06703491508960724,
0.1532140076160431,
-0.341058611869812,
-0.36609259247779846,
-0.5923352837562561,
-0.3590446710586548,
0.04980447515845299,
-0.23879443109035492,
0.4206097722053528,
-0.29926955699920654,
0.7176465392112732,
0.11775913834571838,
-0.21229276061058044,
0.5510377883911133,
-0.6649357676506042,
0.7007673978805542,
0.13753469288349152,
-1.0845675468444824,
0.23427116870880127,
-0.1302737444639206,
0.31417316198349,
0.33178985118865967,
0.7995112538337708,
-0.5756462812423706,
-0.1757020354270935,
-0.3437862992286682,
-0.5453391671180725,
0.2244933694601059,
0.08460123091936111,
0.37268462777137756,
0.0601864717900753,
0.1891428381204605,
0.21679756045341492,
0.2581610679626465,
-0.7170716524124146,
-0.3110465407371521,
0.008656976744532585,
-0.17613427340984344,
0.06900482624769211,
-0.3208480477333069,
-0.26260533928871155,
-0.5264204144477844,
0.6865896582603455,
0.0572192445397377,
-0.1898593306541443,
0.09095151722431183,
-0.15980751812458038,
-0.07258856296539307,
0.15751996636390686,
1.0087292194366455,
0.8884419798851013,
0.16245165467262268,
-0.0357188917696476,
0.11161844432353973,
-0.564337432384491,
0.6549811363220215,
-0.17795301973819733,
-0.06289924681186676,
-0.04761332646012306,
0.2768867015838623,
0.7543153166770935,
0.12576541304588318,
-1.075836181640625,
0.3317517042160034,
-0.04548975080251694,
-0.36761757731437683,
-0.1842256486415863,
-0.24611984193325043,
-0.17744064331054688,
0.35916635394096375,
0.06706392765045166,
-0.3283202350139618,
-0.052394382655620575,
-0.4921964704990387,
0.1943856030702591,
0.15851660072803497,
-0.40649789571762085,
-0.6241028904914856,
0.5442397594451904,
0.46819785237312317,
-0.03688507899641991,
0.5117679238319397,
-0.48845964670181274,
-0.948862612247467,
0.494546502828598,
1.004923939704895,
0.6362317800521851,
-0.20849746465682983,
0.36700794100761414,
0.17019475996494293,
0.3430452048778534,
-0.17993871867656708,
0.5723123550415039,
0.4500456154346466,
-0.5320740938186646,
-0.6389073133468628,
-0.14055633544921875,
-0.42385345697402954,
-0.08621832728385925,
-0.728641152381897,
0.3673776388168335,
-0.33668407797813416,
-0.20091679692268372,
-0.21645574271678925,
0.05143388360738754,
-0.5348719954490662,
0.03142571076750755,
0.45976755023002625,
1.1241408586502075,
-1.2076454162597656,
0.990369439125061,
0.9931812286376953,
-0.27523934841156006,
-0.4367833435535431,
-0.13811999559402466,
0.1485472023487091,
-0.7825295329093933,
1.1728041172027588,
-0.25300872325897217,
-0.22026443481445312,
-0.1886424869298935,
-0.49495330452919006,
-1.3166167736053467,
1.130837321281433,
0.18827594816684723,
-0.42655444145202637,
-0.0569571927189827,
0.13448847830295563,
0.6504875421524048,
-0.6461929082870483,
-0.3350467383861542,
0.68666011095047,
0.2870000898838043,
-0.39523181319236755,
-1.2366678714752197,
-0.07750512659549713,
-0.42333316802978516,
0.12140213698148727,
-0.011415471322834492,
-0.665779709815979,
0.8057880997657776,
-0.3604537546634674,
0.18027226626873016,
0.36865147948265076,
0.92516028881073,
0.505680501461029,
0.5097484588623047,
0.2418353259563446,
0.49041733145713806,
0.9324853420257568,
0.24876585602760315,
1.2547403573989868,
-0.5582117438316345,
0.13357622921466827,
1.1376633644104004,
-0.896543562412262,
0.6723396182060242,
0.24824409186840057,
0.0701577216386795,
0.7113587260246277,
0.15992076694965363,
0.15777987241744995,
0.3716406524181366,
0.24360743165016174,
-0.1542811542749405,
-0.33885782957077026,
-0.3710300922393799,
-0.16646647453308105,
0.7283589243888855,
0.35071736574172974,
-0.32881802320480347,
0.15351971983909607,
0.5636301040649414,
0.5643624067306519,
0.2167312651872635,
-0.46080946922302246,
0.38802453875541687,
-0.33200928568840027,
-0.5443286299705505,
0.5819053649902344,
0.006580640096217394,
0.4002169370651245,
-0.4263847768306732,
0.017304321750998497,
0.04272281751036644,
0.22403429448604584,
-0.22357334196567535,
-0.9731274247169495,
0.026957668364048004,
0.16742432117462158,
-0.5259883403778076,
0.15171107649803162,
0.39791303873062134,
-0.41541847586631775,
-0.6790342926979065,
0.3904246687889099,
0.7058605551719666,
0.018223363906145096,
0.10872448980808258,
-0.774268627166748,
0.5853880047798157,
0.029607469215989113,
-0.16573761403560638,
0.24356888234615326,
0.5053719282150269,
-0.6846083402633667,
1.0352799892425537,
0.7247939705848694,
0.30750399827957153,
0.34908756613731384,
0.06111239269375801,
0.9091759324073792,
-0.7241217494010925,
-0.42881521582603455,
-0.5796527862548828,
0.415526419878006,
-0.12274099886417389,
-0.6382424831390381,
0.9744657278060913,
0.6821540594100952,
1.1444274187088013,
0.00009129656245931983,
1.076209306716919,
0.38279756903648376,
0.3974042236804962,
-0.4206831455230713,
0.6341415643692017,
-0.21176153421401978,
-0.13798534870147705,
0.032985132187604904,
-0.668470025062561,
-0.5775262117385864,
0.260368674993515,
-0.38472282886505127,
-0.1487133800983429,
0.7619338035583496,
0.6019970178604126,
-0.007579191587865353,
-0.13549098372459412,
0.7611573338508606,
0.22508926689624786,
0.2863965332508087,
0.301846981048584,
0.6409282684326172,
-0.18443891406059265,
0.7860108017921448,
-0.2608848810195923,
-0.39378872513771057,
-0.08568479865789413,
-0.294178307056427,
-1.1084190607070923,
-0.39743438363075256,
-0.3484187722206116,
-0.4029165804386139,
0.1624675989151001,
1.3980114459991455,
0.9602701663970947,
-0.5496819615364075,
-0.7048580050468445,
0.3461128771305084,
0.25863566994667053,
-0.08465102314949036,
-0.14951692521572113,
0.0997435599565506,
-0.30660149455070496,
-0.9214333891868591,
0.4218703508377075,
0.5074236392974854,
0.04809127748012543,
-0.7262074947357178,
-0.43872830271720886,
-0.011875679716467857,
0.2502632141113281,
0.9335935115814209,
0.4138282835483551,
-0.6223413944244385,
0.15356793999671936,
0.5975644588470459,
-0.29853785037994385,
-0.12412909418344498,
0.969140350818634,
-0.5214799642562866,
0.5138267278671265,
0.5105628967285156,
0.724652886390686,
0.08153596520423889,
-0.11896567791700363,
0.8202595710754395,
-0.1427612006664276,
0.2236347794532776,
-0.030304457992315292,
0.3576667904853821,
0.14089924097061157,
-0.30349379777908325,
0.3142660856246948,
0.20781274139881134,
-0.8142595887184143,
-1.096619725227356,
0.24276544153690338,
-0.8076144456863403,
-0.0133008798584342,
1.3924024105072021,
-0.42919662594795227,
-0.5004414319992065,
-0.4956796169281006,
-0.313611775636673,
-0.16014470160007477,
-0.12901635468006134,
0.5977441668510437,
0.9693082571029663,
-0.12906210124492645,
0.049058686941862106,
-1.0093607902526855,
0.3356853127479553,
0.5747725963592529,
-0.8159637451171875,
0.20706674456596375,
0.08639168739318848,
0.2810572385787964,
0.3010903596878052,
0.21297824382781982,
-0.3842640221118927,
0.8305097818374634,
-0.2412579208612442,
0.32654646039009094,
0.10205084830522537,
-0.8023759126663208,
-0.5249837636947632,
0.0004441147029865533,
0.1359100490808487,
-0.2035895586013794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01953v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01953v1
|
Classifying Graphemes in English Words Through the Application of a Fuzzy Inference System
| 2024-04-02T13:47:52 | 2024-04-02T13:47:52 |
Samuel Rose, Chandrasekhar Kambhampati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LO
|
In Linguistics, a grapheme is a written unit of a writing system
corresponding to a phonological sound. In Natural Language Processing tasks,
written language is analysed through two different mediums, word analysis, and
character analysis. This paper focuses on a third approach, the analysis of
graphemes. Graphemes have advantages over word and character analysis by being
self-contained representations of phonetic sounds. Due to the nature of
splitting a word into graphemes being based on complex, non-binary rules, the
application of fuzzy logic would provide a suitable medium upon which to
predict the number of graphemes in a word. This paper proposes the application
of a Fuzzy Inference System to split words into their graphemes. This Fuzzy
Inference System results in a correct prediction of the number of graphemes in
a word 50.18% of the time, with 93.51% being within a margin of +- 1 from the
correct classification. Given the variety in language, graphemes are tied with
pronunciation and therefore can change depending on a regional accent/dialect,
the +- 1 accuracy represents the impreciseness of grapheme classification when
regional variances are accounted for. To give a baseline of comparison, a
second method involving a recursive IPA mapping exercise using a pronunciation
dictionary was developed to allow for comparisons to be made.
|
[
-0.5257095694541931,
-0.7585700154304504,
0.5187637209892273,
-0.12365758419036865,
-0.324651300907135,
0.2013038992881775,
-0.333816796541214,
-0.5217257142066956,
0.32733312249183655,
0.5310633778572083,
-0.3093179166316986,
-0.5164874196052551,
-0.5687898397445679,
0.5623092651367188,
-0.2546616196632385,
0.47645363211631775,
0.16573196649551392,
0.24430102109909058,
0.09129080176353455,
-0.16783525049686432,
-0.763184666633606,
-0.6153663992881775,
-0.8395578861236572,
-0.3813626170158386,
0.44510549306869507,
0.49596235156059265,
0.7906703948974609,
0.6013033986091614,
0.23892222344875336,
0.4956763684749603,
-0.30423158407211304,
0.3832033574581146,
-0.2932818531990051,
-0.2614994943141937,
0.11012960225343704,
-0.5691052079200745,
-0.12120162695646286,
0.33958005905151367,
0.4391290843486786,
0.838550865650177,
-0.3498256802558899,
-0.27204960584640503,
-0.17811432480812073,
0.4630245566368103,
-0.27475234866142273,
0.22518795728683472,
-0.48037388920783997,
-0.010813303291797638,
-0.24335986375808716,
0.15819066762924194,
-0.35958540439605713,
-0.313193142414093,
-0.2471815049648285,
-0.6177605986595154,
0.38707271218299866,
0.36672961711883545,
0.9406452178955078,
-0.18753746151924133,
-0.10469809919595718,
-0.3920315206050873,
-0.4717140793800354,
0.6233302354812622,
-1.0335241556167603,
0.9710730314254761,
0.34501516819000244,
0.13906975090503693,
-0.24341349303722382,
-0.5718227028846741,
-0.9535952210426331,
-0.2500162422657013,
-0.25118178129196167,
-0.03945406526327133,
-0.011353863403201103,
0.3320455253124237,
-0.08520582318305969,
0.15586140751838684,
-0.36477336287498474,
0.2612621784210205,
-0.37594616413116455,
-0.2766055762767792,
0.9581130146980286,
-0.13524885475635529,
0.6350657939910889,
-0.32149165868759155,
-0.1087346225976944,
0.0068084318190813065,
-0.3644288182258606,
-0.3663918972015381,
0.5882902145385742,
0.7454541325569153,
-0.020579075440764427,
0.397941917181015,
-0.07947645336389542,
0.7107369899749756,
0.1481381505727768,
-0.6089239716529846,
0.5200780630111694,
-0.24539422988891602,
-0.13172481954097748,
0.30103814601898193,
0.8343552947044373,
0.22826629877090454,
0.5543198585510254,
-0.20425032079219818,
-0.26980337500572205,
0.12215425074100494,
0.1395462602376938,
-0.3425235152244568,
-0.12997089326381683,
0.21892645955085754,
-0.1944621205329895,
-0.24906855821609497,
0.12787099182605743,
-0.7164977192878723,
-0.10210613161325455,
-0.20938144624233246,
0.2553988993167877,
-0.9032418727874756,
-0.21931950747966766,
0.20432378351688385,
-0.6304468512535095,
-0.09679504483938217,
0.17605237662792206,
-0.8938255906105042,
0.7627760767936707,
0.9608230590820312,
0.7943323254585266,
-0.031585365533828735,
-0.5869663953781128,
0.05648830533027649,
0.0220070481300354,
-0.4679540693759918,
1.0933092832565308,
-0.5445823669433594,
-0.6307536363601685,
-0.09525904059410095,
0.0944119319319725,
-0.46331602334976196,
-0.6418520212173462,
0.33742085099220276,
-0.3750990331172943,
0.420278400182724,
0.2700674831867218,
-0.737824022769928,
-0.7032084465026855,
-0.0803709328174591,
-0.7326418161392212,
1.074839472770691,
0.404777854681015,
-0.469599187374115,
0.60715651512146,
-0.40461596846580505,
-0.7859486937522888,
0.44877031445503235,
0.011286606080830097,
-0.12714551389217377,
0.10288529843091965,
-0.14317451417446136,
0.13458508253097534,
-0.14149825274944305,
-0.1200994923710823,
-0.13118679821491241,
-0.6089386343955994,
0.19509010016918182,
-0.15390025079250336,
0.5868565440177917,
0.2601393163204193,
-0.2609141767024994,
-0.31864067912101746,
-0.47419318556785583,
0.3550960421562195,
0.06722402572631836,
-0.2442738115787506,
-0.3433760702610016,
0.2695492208003998,
-0.10369554162025452,
-0.1492428332567215,
-0.10708548128604889,
-0.7770566940307617,
-0.07565931975841522,
-0.6378967761993408,
0.5112015604972839,
0.3717658817768097,
0.07832828909158707,
0.1307610273361206,
-0.16057422757148743,
0.3140944242477417,
-0.13210880756378174,
-0.12415464222431183,
0.5675603151321411,
-0.6169970631599426,
-0.5957617163658142,
-0.5900083780288696,
0.8300157785415649,
0.8090190887451172,
-0.41812863945961,
0.6183379292488098,
-0.27500319480895996,
-0.6137368679046631,
-0.5022872686386108,
0.15050899982452393,
0.16366364061832428,
0.3016316294670105,
0.06949345767498016,
-0.35665163397789,
-0.08509210497140884,
-0.7319374680519104,
-0.15945234894752502,
-0.4572347104549408,
-0.01135540846735239,
0.343906044960022,
0.16983279585838318,
-0.03319516032934189,
0.5040891170501709,
-0.7589797377586365,
-0.17010000348091125,
-0.43924281001091003,
0.19665399193763733,
0.39751410484313965,
0.13410311937332153,
0.6077951192855835,
-0.7878621816635132,
-0.43384218215942383,
0.2596489489078522,
-0.2943631410598755,
-0.3382341265678406,
0.12997081875801086,
-0.02833898551762104,
0.21310833096504211,
0.32430800795555115,
-0.47498753666877747,
0.2806605398654938,
0.29891878366470337,
-0.4911622703075409,
0.6064311265945435,
-0.127345472574234,
0.33367815613746643,
-0.6587227582931519,
-0.21393835544586182,
-0.07849719375371933,
-0.26457762718200684,
-0.7026594281196594,
0.06779836863279343,
-0.4679723381996155,
-0.17828184366226196,
-0.25228312611579895,
0.3997453451156616,
-0.4559025168418884,
0.11782082170248032,
-0.17167451977729797,
0.46322280168533325,
0.09981948137283325,
0.32113873958587646,
0.05614796653389931,
0.8105415105819702,
0.2703651487827301,
-0.42803576588630676,
0.4720519781112671,
0.2634304463863373,
-0.23506230115890503,
0.6244485378265381,
-0.3107401132583618,
0.20205289125442505,
0.05857401341199875,
-0.24463698267936707,
-1.3224843740463257,
0.09808902442455292,
0.31645268201828003,
-0.6378881335258484,
0.5345563888549805,
0.18512283265590668,
-0.5622674226760864,
-0.3311557173728943,
-0.03461720421910286,
0.024739645421504974,
0.457504540681839,
-0.1779966652393341,
0.5024353265762329,
0.5908226370811462,
-0.4101390540599823,
-0.1316770613193512,
-0.6468801498413086,
-0.0003171038697473705,
-0.39722687005996704,
-0.5360963344573975,
0.0015522721223533154,
0.21451710164546967,
-0.51833176612854,
0.18680118024349213,
0.02863960713148117,
-0.3653011620044708,
0.1833110749721527,
0.0744713842868805,
0.19837260246276855,
-0.15304973721504211,
0.301474004983902,
-0.1581362634897232,
-0.14634287357330322,
-0.05345632880926132,
-0.45842111110687256,
0.5950264930725098,
-0.023167118430137634,
-0.06371467560529709,
-0.33385226130485535,
0.6900984048843384,
0.4219237267971039,
-0.15891003608703613,
0.5280195474624634,
0.2143896371126175,
-0.4315614700317383,
-0.3797703981399536,
-0.536548912525177,
0.20178937911987305,
-0.44971951842308044,
0.26998254656791687,
-0.31901949644088745,
-0.37376460433006287,
0.3279470205307007,
-0.06404862552881241,
-0.46338099241256714,
0.7152755260467529,
0.23259779810905457,
-0.17776864767074585,
0.9567884802818298,
0.49197593331336975,
-0.22646963596343994,
0.47907957434654236,
-0.1622840315103531,
0.4984229505062103,
-0.4095475971698761,
-0.019983943551778793,
-0.7017590999603271,
-0.04578094929456711,
-0.7917966842651367,
-0.05264635011553764,
0.06872731447219849,
0.09320086985826492,
-0.08214051276445389,
0.4003734290599823,
-0.519205629825592,
0.3432157039642334,
0.6049877405166626,
0.2222108542919159,
0.09027151763439178,
0.25376230478286743,
-0.3261093497276306,
0.24312056601047516,
-0.734229326248169,
-0.36405816674232483,
0.4388260543346405,
0.035074371844530106,
0.5266826152801514,
0.024867691099643707,
0.861439049243927,
0.6172219514846802,
0.16099365055561066,
-1.2110503911972046,
0.581440269947052,
-0.4726143479347229,
-0.371748685836792,
-0.6369069218635559,
-0.30643293261528015,
-0.797924816608429,
0.12293259054422379,
-0.31031104922294617,
-0.8763946294784546,
0.20373152196407318,
-0.1790848970413208,
-0.040977802127599716,
0.33005890250205994,
-0.9873995780944824,
0.5010054111480713,
-0.3514616787433624,
0.00248865969479084,
-0.23807045817375183,
-0.30423492193222046,
-0.15380974113941193,
-0.281877726316452,
0.5147016048431396,
-0.2340070903301239,
0.2796366512775421,
0.9301643371582031,
-0.8951262831687927,
0.7016028165817261,
-0.07017959654331207,
-0.07515271753072739,
0.7700638175010681,
0.18958227336406708,
0.0708857923746109,
-0.5461245179176331,
-0.34419119358062744,
0.8367803692817688,
0.39612019062042236,
-0.05754200741648674,
-0.7092658281326294,
0.31352123618125916,
-0.6334674954414368,
-0.528598964214325,
-0.5057113766670227,
-0.3073120415210724,
-0.28263917565345764,
0.6579671502113342,
0.34973594546318054,
0.4433082640171051,
-0.06602706015110016,
-0.5191103219985962,
-0.03656022995710373,
0.2908749580383301,
0.025595229119062424,
0.3185913860797882,
-0.01309073157608509,
-0.6862846612930298,
1.102530837059021,
0.6317071318626404,
0.2199186235666275,
0.1907508820295334,
0.5545200705528259,
-0.4469611942768097,
-0.8891354203224182,
-0.12197341024875641,
0.5562495589256287,
-0.6971468925476074,
-0.07927194237709045,
-0.015809684991836548,
-0.0436784066259861,
-0.7280935645103455,
-0.3945709466934204,
0.24039527773857117,
-0.3364115059375763,
-0.08996333181858063,
-0.19034123420715332,
0.464184433221817,
1.0319087505340576,
-0.19675619900226593,
0.534980058670044,
-0.7208831906318665,
0.15010443329811096,
0.16142165660858154,
0.5204193592071533,
-0.26890894770622253,
-0.2566777169704437,
-0.06698283553123474,
0.011464927345514297,
0.06146533787250519,
-1.2743420600891113,
0.45543333888053894,
0.513474702835083,
0.6671416163444519,
0.4500415623188019,
-0.24764804542064667,
0.6673259139060974,
-0.7781810164451599,
0.8083915710449219,
0.15688924491405487,
-1.0841617584228516,
0.04369054362177849,
-0.13491705060005188,
-0.33992382884025574,
0.6778717041015625,
0.1965532898902893,
-1.0006475448608398,
-0.5322552919387817,
-0.9434516429901123,
-0.6935272812843323,
0.3090779185295105,
-0.037906065583229065,
-0.0885808914899826,
-0.5551366806030273,
0.513458788394928,
0.11532817035913467,
0.18064171075820923,
0.03361097350716591,
-0.014392885379493237,
-0.020812587812542915,
-0.43388545513153076,
-0.415957510471344,
-0.18339964747428894,
-0.15793462097644806,
-0.132283553481102,
0.7247844338417053,
-0.15383069217205048,
0.4416695833206177,
0.08288807421922684,
0.057804565876722336,
0.2631061375141144,
0.2777463495731354,
0.23346355557441711,
0.525959312915802,
-0.014729288406670094,
0.2071157991886139,
0.577986478805542,
-0.8774611353874207,
0.1438976675271988,
0.0885055810213089,
-0.09430364519357681,
0.20440573990345,
0.7077593207359314,
0.5049447417259216,
0.02853022888302803,
-0.4461720287799835,
0.313802033662796,
0.27194347977638245,
-0.16368554532527924,
-0.19566214084625244,
0.22337424755096436,
0.039419014006853104,
-0.10038052499294281,
-0.05044134333729744,
-0.32250961661338806,
0.4444272220134735,
-0.5161976218223572,
0.2850401699542999,
0.4081186056137085,
-0.31089675426483154,
-0.10413803160190582,
0.18080376088619232,
0.19227781891822815,
-0.8074268698692322,
0.7886622548103333,
-0.38743773102760315,
-0.8847616314888,
0.7409626841545105,
0.932828426361084,
0.8642181754112244,
-0.28818419575691223,
0.1643056571483612,
0.20685331523418427,
0.17147211730480194,
0.2289379984140396,
0.6096556186676025,
0.09465585649013519,
-1.0703189373016357,
0.05552847683429718,
-0.5287363529205322,
-0.39066216349601746,
-0.19966740906238556,
-0.5480908155441284,
0.344766229391098,
-0.4260435700416565,
-0.27485594153404236,
0.3636685609817505,
0.07003225386142731,
-0.46445131301879883,
0.6257573962211609,
0.49121811985969543,
1.0451714992523193,
-0.9565693140029907,
0.2175953984260559,
0.6109187006950378,
-0.03682946041226387,
-1.0712792873382568,
-0.1369198113679886,
0.12772385776042938,
-0.9782982468605042,
0.5286319255828857,
0.15004630386829376,
-0.6159158945083618,
-0.02922622114419937,
-0.5731980204582214,
-0.68064945936203,
0.6417135000228882,
0.09723223000764847,
-0.30187878012657166,
0.2440856397151947,
0.23820771276950836,
0.6511229276657104,
-0.29960349202156067,
0.18220289051532745,
0.7415593266487122,
0.5958144664764404,
0.10281015187501907,
-0.8280279040336609,
-0.03742734342813492,
-0.16416679322719574,
-0.13293689489364624,
0.5926095247268677,
-0.6335172653198242,
0.70146244764328,
-0.29705891013145447,
-0.7755443453788757,
-0.09106923639774323,
0.4040064811706543,
-0.15416991710662842,
0.06311483681201935,
0.8423747420310974,
0.5248499512672424,
1.240716576576233,
-0.19837410748004913,
0.9393833875656128,
-0.43091386556625366,
0.5760570168495178,
0.671596348285675,
-0.3483269512653351,
0.9872973561286926,
0.274275004863739,
-0.5626032948493958,
0.7679800987243652,
0.8592802286148071,
-0.1390017718076706,
0.31824228167533875,
0.26486530900001526,
-0.36651235818862915,
-0.1673562377691269,
-0.08097632229328156,
-0.012833683751523495,
1.002467393875122,
0.647955596446991,
-0.03896434232592583,
-0.08133823424577713,
-0.41823941469192505,
0.4275009334087372,
-0.031136926263570786,
-0.36624789237976074,
0.9632170796394348,
-0.12171204388141632,
-0.4832104444503784,
0.4842427670955658,
0.01110299862921238,
0.22254177927970886,
-0.778669536113739,
-0.40355926752090454,
0.006204323377460241,
-0.04537195339798927,
-0.33292219042778015,
-0.9588817954063416,
0.07380381226539612,
-0.3642960786819458,
0.22689294815063477,
0.4691001772880554,
0.8706380128860474,
-0.4456227123737335,
-0.7973197102546692,
0.3204813599586487,
0.27469953894615173,
0.34335437417030334,
0.2931702435016632,
-0.3797851502895355,
-0.40428829193115234,
-0.19420483708381653,
0.15649761259555817,
-0.36918240785598755,
0.3947405219078064,
0.06141490861773491,
0.42950451374053955,
0.4510114789009094,
0.5572631359100342,
-0.057052597403526306,
-0.13169898092746735,
0.421267032623291,
-0.6823670864105225,
-0.9454018473625183,
-0.5539339184761047,
-0.028833480551838875,
-0.07409664988517761,
-0.2497328370809555,
0.78758305311203,
0.4400252103805542,
0.7280722260475159,
0.23005814850330353,
0.9614239931106567,
-0.0469982847571373,
0.471295028924942,
-0.6418237090110779,
0.6650484204292297,
-0.37816983461380005,
-0.23902520537376404,
-0.23312325775623322,
-0.41660866141319275,
-0.3288039267063141,
0.6591855883598328,
-0.2333221137523651,
-0.02498609945178032,
0.8622888922691345,
0.5589728355407715,
0.1671045571565628,
0.23585078120231628,
0.1947489082813263,
0.17119862139225006,
-0.121392160654068,
0.09120839089155197,
0.3445757329463959,
-0.10933242738246918,
-0.05752087011933327,
-0.28438490629196167,
-0.18724481761455536,
-0.014241510070860386,
-0.5872360467910767,
-0.35435208678245544,
-0.4157600998878479,
-0.07466518133878708,
-0.5346234440803528,
0.1521359533071518,
0.7447455525398254,
0.5535265207290649,
-0.9634422659873962,
-0.49584341049194336,
0.37289634346961975,
0.4175545275211334,
-0.7576872110366821,
-0.20409013330936432,
0.37647491693496704,
-0.3055900037288666,
-0.779072105884552,
0.31218448281288147,
0.04690563678741455,
-0.04001857712864876,
0.10204508155584335,
0.16916301846504211,
-0.38342106342315674,
0.3135048747062683,
0.6040586829185486,
0.28218668699264526,
-0.4323389530181885,
-0.9381143450737,
-0.15141375362873077,
0.09523428231477737,
0.4938431680202484,
0.5729528069496155,
-0.5721462368965149,
0.5175669193267822,
0.6928940415382385,
0.24737690389156342,
0.13611485064029694,
0.18843814730644226,
0.520557165145874,
-0.5112884044647217,
0.06017543375492096,
-0.08012156933546066,
0.5747654438018799,
0.32197481393814087,
-0.6759621500968933,
0.5422305464744568,
0.6210309267044067,
-0.24335652589797974,
-0.48620447516441345,
0.07687423378229141,
-0.8084318041801453,
-0.37218186259269714,
1.2103877067565918,
0.0964391753077507,
-0.47048819065093994,
-0.23154376447200775,
-0.30172714591026306,
0.31318771839141846,
-0.33986467123031616,
0.3685527443885803,
0.9892473220825195,
-0.5122693777084351,
0.17622603476047516,
-0.29361826181411743,
0.18830135464668274,
-0.10494594275951385,
-0.6380911469459534,
-0.19342651963233948,
0.5361557006835938,
0.7261990308761597,
0.6144376397132874,
0.4390295743942261,
0.08304096758365631,
-0.06442369520664215,
0.4260199964046478,
0.2089127153158188,
-0.014348714612424374,
-0.2866080105304718,
-0.47407516837120056,
0.19804416596889496,
0.12458039820194244,
-0.353618860244751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02183v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02183v1
|
Self-Organized Agents: A LLM Multi-Agent Framework toward Ultra Large-Scale Code Generation and Optimization
| 2024-04-02T13:37:28 | 2024-04-02T13:37:28 |
Yoichi Ishibashi, Yoshimasa Nishimura
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
Recent advancements in automatic code generation using large language model
(LLM) agent have brought us closer to the future of automated software
development. However, existing single-agent approaches face limitations in
generating and improving large-scale, complex codebases due to constraints in
context length. To tackle this challenge, we propose Self-Organized multi-Agent
framework (SoA), a novel multi-agent framework that enables the scalable and
efficient generation and optimization of large-scale code. In SoA,
self-organized agents operate independently to generate and modify code
components while seamlessly collaborating to construct the overall codebase. A
key feature of our framework is the automatic multiplication of agents based on
problem complexity, allowing for dynamic scalability. This enables the overall
code volume to be increased indefinitely according to the number of agents,
while the amount of code managed by each agent remains constant. We evaluate
SoA on the HumanEval benchmark and demonstrate that, compared to a single-agent
system, each agent in SoA handles significantly less code, yet the overall
generated code is substantially greater. Moreover, SoA surpasses the powerful
single-agent baseline by 5% in terms of Pass@1 accuracy.
|
[
-0.453200101852417,
-0.48633715510368347,
0.44992244243621826,
0.6333991885185242,
0.07886862009763718,
0.2331896424293518,
0.01551556121557951,
-0.3747948408126831,
0.356566458940506,
0.5518637895584106,
-0.5632910132408142,
-0.445355087518692,
-0.09099899977445602,
0.332253634929657,
-0.18144188821315765,
0.7660998106002808,
0.24504457414150238,
0.01321115717291832,
-0.305379182100296,
-0.3832307755947113,
-0.10720203816890717,
-0.7536036372184753,
-0.37282460927963257,
-0.25109827518463135,
0.33857858180999756,
0.5871075391769409,
0.7059385776519775,
1.2354754209518433,
0.6135950088500977,
0.46917855739593506,
0.4749392569065094,
0.1375054121017456,
-0.4743943214416504,
0.2913151979446411,
0.12140995264053345,
-0.15569111704826355,
-0.8352532386779785,
-0.3412639796733856,
0.6750476360321045,
0.08348293602466583,
-0.2678964138031006,
0.49750131368637085,
-0.24158883094787598,
0.6589383482933044,
-0.5383819341659546,
0.16233253479003906,
-0.3095099627971649,
-0.032153256237506866,
-0.018031619489192963,
-0.44342952966690063,
-0.10746117681264877,
-0.024805424734950066,
-0.41293585300445557,
-0.5227767825126648,
-0.1441381275653839,
-0.22775046527385712,
0.2389480471611023,
0.6199128031730652,
-0.3671456277370453,
-0.26245829463005066,
-0.6984764337539673,
0.5585684776306152,
-0.6588488817214966,
-0.03606663644313812,
-0.29678183794021606,
0.21971209347248077,
-0.3405736982822418,
-0.765775740146637,
-0.5459742546081543,
-0.19845515489578247,
0.38675054907798767,
0.05978858470916748,
-0.11891696602106094,
0.03927333652973175,
-0.037739455699920654,
0.10506047308444977,
-0.758871853351593,
0.3261149823665619,
-0.0856744647026062,
-0.07932403683662415,
0.7833942770957947,
0.36078789830207825,
0.5259693264961243,
0.15496212244033813,
-0.6249036192893982,
0.07836036384105682,
-0.6397596001625061,
-0.18089932203292847,
0.229550302028656,
0.31300729513168335,
0.1840425729751587,
0.308958500623703,
-0.20601336658000946,
0.20849381387233734,
0.0642765611410141,
-0.18281041085720062,
0.32180866599082947,
-0.3842546343803406,
-0.30775681138038635,
-0.09408093988895416,
0.8193842768669128,
0.23552706837654114,
-0.04933333396911621,
-0.055774930864572525,
-0.41635772585868835,
0.2122173309326172,
0.4574083387851715,
-1.01894211769104,
0.03962024301290512,
0.4397793710231781,
-0.5147247910499573,
-0.5479130148887634,
-0.16926084458827972,
-0.6697940826416016,
-0.24508534371852875,
-0.006039100233465433,
0.26928937435150146,
0.22332797944545746,
-0.27308058738708496,
0.1480495184659958,
0.23895849287509918,
0.28228506445884705,
0.18919521570205688,
-0.5630539655685425,
0.08775074034929276,
0.42172250151634216,
0.5310401320457458,
-0.16547510027885437,
-0.7675558924674988,
-0.6899543404579163,
0.3745975196361542,
-0.6617502570152283,
0.7171052098274231,
-0.43766748905181885,
-0.21856506168842316,
-0.1597507894039154,
-0.3708156943321228,
0.38193947076797485,
-0.4615219831466675,
-0.06492363661527634,
-0.6355754137039185,
-0.36029911041259766,
0.1505025327205658,
-0.2930314838886261,
0.28196731209754944,
0.14595535397529602,
-0.5915460586547852,
0.9542281627655029,
0.24895180761814117,
-0.281005322933197,
0.05637873709201813,
-0.7603545784950256,
-0.2605542540550232,
0.25639578700065613,
-0.5047394037246704,
-0.5298840999603271,
0.08568257093429565,
-0.06653806567192078,
0.48672109842300415,
-0.4640648365020752,
0.2827468514442444,
-0.3379559814929962,
-0.32079029083251953,
-0.0032191118225455284,
-0.07320669293403625,
0.5140842795372009,
0.5036817789077759,
-0.563277006149292,
0.473779559135437,
-0.824206531047821,
0.2612568736076355,
0.14506973326206207,
-0.607724666595459,
0.043551791459321976,
-0.13663046061992645,
-0.14539454877376556,
0.5520836114883423,
0.5893324017524719,
-0.24111723899841309,
0.6808059811592102,
-0.13525773584842682,
0.18243274092674255,
0.8946217894554138,
-0.024906132370233536,
0.7013258934020996,
-0.12423449754714966,
0.7435178756713867,
-0.311871737241745,
0.48365622758865356,
-0.2313845008611679,
-0.06577601283788681,
-0.44418588280677795,
-0.5057595372200012,
-0.12427201122045517,
0.2303784340620041,
-0.6854546666145325,
0.4505641758441925,
-0.09677278995513916,
-0.5424059629440308,
-0.04990196228027344,
0.4525775909423828,
0.5431906580924988,
-0.11366570740938187,
0.21584093570709229,
-0.25069835782051086,
-0.3868432343006134,
-0.7138581275939941,
0.10939747095108032,
-0.06412026286125183,
0.19274823367595673,
0.07717742770910263,
0.6596252918243408,
-0.8039620518684387,
0.7829346656799316,
-0.31559616327285767,
-0.37121614813804626,
-0.25885578989982605,
0.08886938542127609,
-0.026823827996850014,
0.7672744989395142,
0.5861952304840088,
-0.629095733165741,
-0.47104063630104065,
0.11974278837442398,
-0.7478168606758118,
-0.2446097582578659,
-0.39047491550445557,
-0.2456541210412979,
0.39926877617836,
0.6078330874443054,
-0.512925922870636,
0.29636064171791077,
0.5723870396614075,
-0.36640438437461853,
0.7651737928390503,
-0.7377659678459167,
-0.2055196464061737,
-1.0103399753570557,
-0.15777400135993958,
-0.5112414360046387,
-0.1790992170572281,
-0.6179245114326477,
0.7523226141929626,
0.042079512029886246,
-0.044167254120111465,
-0.2501990497112274,
0.29101675748825073,
-0.6902798414230347,
-0.33828914165496826,
-0.5215110182762146,
-0.1107376217842102,
-0.1342965066432953,
0.7748850584030151,
-0.3568311333656311,
1.077303171157837,
0.7597590684890747,
-0.6872054934501648,
0.4789085388183594,
-0.13005614280700684,
0.03105398267507553,
0.2838263213634491,
-0.6237786412239075,
0.3156281113624573,
-0.10376088321208954,
0.381136417388916,
-0.5389235615730286,
-0.3005901277065277,
-0.1709291636943817,
-0.25922295451164246,
0.18773259222507477,
0.13780829310417175,
-0.7755191922187805,
-0.3049982786178589,
-0.43887174129486084,
0.4891642928123474,
0.26376262307167053,
-0.5569296479225159,
0.7648546099662781,
0.4354236423969269,
0.1512783169746399,
-0.639430582523346,
-0.5390914082527161,
0.1167207658290863,
0.029453903436660767,
-0.6359364986419678,
0.025084227323532104,
-0.5163702964782715,
-0.1909182220697403,
-0.13342271745204926,
-0.4931182861328125,
-0.056619204580783844,
0.17511019110679626,
0.35300207138061523,
-0.014475850388407707,
-0.3825172185897827,
0.4972267150878906,
0.0893685594201088,
-0.2714003622531891,
0.024148888885974884,
-0.7084840536117554,
0.5597217679023743,
-0.4770304262638092,
-0.3377586901187897,
-0.11835983395576477,
0.4562527537345886,
0.8647704720497131,
-0.5979018807411194,
0.7082646489143372,
0.2296764850616455,
-0.09509088844060898,
-0.6797882914543152,
-0.3974924683570862,
0.13947589695453644,
-0.5000948309898376,
0.34445399045944214,
-0.7723617553710938,
-0.8795344233512878,
0.7772817611694336,
-0.3276343047618866,
0.20460867881774902,
0.43715399503707886,
0.7146397233009338,
0.14498476684093475,
1.1104762554168701,
0.8573712706565857,
-0.049275826662778854,
0.42097747325897217,
-0.4209720194339752,
-0.15812097489833832,
-0.23436926305294037,
0.07878877222537994,
-0.6328092217445374,
0.0033332447055727243,
-0.762102484703064,
-0.8198517560958862,
0.5575920939445496,
0.09468881785869598,
-0.48031169176101685,
0.24867242574691772,
-0.8216465711593628,
0.7382147312164307,
0.39791756868362427,
-0.3491179347038269,
0.4243311285972595,
-0.1875333935022354,
0.10070643573999405,
0.7358341217041016,
-0.8764926195144653,
-0.5731197595596313,
1.1375298500061035,
0.34745267033576965,
0.8184683322906494,
0.22583870589733124,
1.2210438251495361,
0.4039500057697296,
0.2506861090660095,
-0.3688961863517761,
0.6389192938804626,
0.18906979262828827,
-0.6200844049453735,
-0.732874870300293,
-0.6047678589820862,
-1.0305986404418945,
0.5097257494926453,
0.05005035921931267,
-0.3970378637313843,
0.23578409850597382,
-0.057734161615371704,
-0.4733227491378784,
0.029419641941785812,
-0.7019995450973511,
0.9827284216880798,
-0.3408208191394806,
-0.33805155754089355,
-0.32749658823013306,
-0.6310634613037109,
-0.10364768654108047,
-0.5121183395385742,
0.301920086145401,
-0.05231805518269539,
-0.3076680600643158,
0.3362676799297333,
-0.8236770629882812,
0.40916019678115845,
-0.017235586419701576,
-0.47499769926071167,
0.5776264071464539,
0.2264009565114975,
0.6724774837493896,
0.20868094265460968,
-0.27481988072395325,
0.032781220972537994,
0.02246318943798542,
-0.6041542887687683,
-0.7473748326301575,
0.7393258810043335,
-0.8666715025901794,
-0.34700655937194824,
-0.3331774175167084,
-0.582667887210846,
0.31146907806396484,
0.6405476331710815,
0.01474060956388712,
0.7925125360488892,
-0.1419261246919632,
0.16134847700595856,
0.2722848951816559,
-0.16847768425941467,
0.6637026071548462,
0.7600676417350769,
-0.25824594497680664,
-0.25703540444374084,
0.9264570474624634,
0.12567684054374695,
0.21472980082035065,
0.21724911034107208,
0.05333178490400314,
-0.17120221257209778,
-0.6052480340003967,
-0.6547890901565552,
0.03199619799852371,
-0.5951222777366638,
-0.49438631534576416,
-0.504660427570343,
0.03262852132320404,
-0.5037205219268799,
-0.47203749418258667,
-0.6726557612419128,
-0.11393969506025314,
-0.0626414492726326,
0.17463678121566772,
-0.08013574779033661,
1.1319763660430908,
-0.2719046175479889,
0.3341773748397827,
-0.8265507817268372,
0.4647318124771118,
0.3741680681705475,
0.5478187203407288,
-0.11627122759819031,
0.0375426821410656,
-0.5925549268722534,
-0.24740701913833618,
-0.11829400062561035,
-0.8088651895523071,
0.3860139846801758,
-0.15073202550411224,
0.4969959259033203,
0.29240161180496216,
0.3253176212310791,
0.5511012673377991,
-0.4313904643058777,
0.3604213297367096,
0.22834154963493347,
-0.9376078844070435,
0.3241615295410156,
-0.43313342332839966,
0.5123701095581055,
0.3832692503929138,
-0.20760460197925568,
0.052026595920324326,
-0.668400228023529,
-0.7145830392837524,
-0.6794820427894592,
0.8637933731079102,
0.4392874836921692,
0.125663623213768,
0.23913341760635376,
0.3396187722682953,
-0.07463841885328293,
0.300361692905426,
-0.9018352031707764,
-0.46912041306495667,
-0.10306554287672043,
-0.036001648753881454,
-0.10678883641958237,
-0.3208463788032532,
-0.18871912360191345,
0.21370147168636322,
0.512836217880249,
-0.6096957921981812,
0.30499106645584106,
0.16557322442531586,
-0.03982065990567207,
-0.41803547739982605,
0.3662087321281433,
0.6388112306594849,
0.8570972084999084,
0.0016094468301162124,
0.20417843759059906,
0.027109533548355103,
-0.2993181049823761,
0.43556511402130127,
-0.004214541520923376,
-0.006580573506653309,
-0.5643802285194397,
0.36330080032348633,
0.2788516879081726,
-0.2590752840042114,
-0.7009962201118469,
0.4489617943763733,
-0.03949394077062607,
-0.11865364015102386,
-0.28636634349823,
0.11939644813537598,
-0.028823446482419968,
0.6800665855407715,
0.5369260907173157,
0.10242075473070145,
0.23486876487731934,
-0.583626925945282,
0.28232941031455994,
0.3477745056152344,
0.27354705333709717,
-0.02538640797138214,
0.4225417673587799,
0.4795578718185425,
-0.34139278531074524,
0.11345014721155167,
-0.6272415518760681,
-0.3797145485877991,
1.1466575860977173,
0.6702347993850708,
0.9941474199295044,
-0.28672751784324646,
0.18071357905864716,
-0.013765709474682808,
0.3985947370529175,
-0.0754355862736702,
0.3475207984447479,
-0.29412275552749634,
-0.5577075481414795,
-0.4565408527851105,
-0.7354291081428528,
-0.09811326116323471,
-0.17402052879333496,
-0.2516254186630249,
-0.06224457919597626,
-0.5296350121498108,
0.06686404347419739,
-0.1738964319229126,
0.345874547958374,
-0.22965240478515625,
0.1340772807598114,
-0.004100307356566191,
0.6513268351554871,
-0.36405885219573975,
0.951353907585144,
0.9171807765960693,
-0.5137429237365723,
-1.06971275806427,
0.14261314272880554,
-0.13558080792427063,
-0.49515363574028015,
0.3447321653366089,
0.3221163749694824,
-0.6282862424850464,
0.16995687782764435,
-0.6305896043777466,
-1.0042153596878052,
1.0468237400054932,
0.49357306957244873,
-0.39713913202285767,
0.09521463513374329,
0.04804270714521408,
0.9349208474159241,
-0.7466673254966736,
0.20114363729953766,
0.26420146226882935,
0.41948404908180237,
0.14953728020191193,
-0.7565018534660339,
0.09913453459739685,
-0.4247698485851288,
0.16019651293754578,
0.18280969560146332,
-0.9747816324234009,
0.7400801777839661,
-0.40227916836738586,
-0.2156987488269806,
0.08097502589225769,
0.7047043442726135,
0.28368115425109863,
0.41320496797561646,
0.4030821621417999,
0.12778030335903168,
0.5279040336608887,
0.4256066381931305,
0.8223821520805359,
-0.7262176871299744,
0.5169427990913391,
0.9789451956748962,
-0.3648482859134674,
0.3485722839832306,
0.1315724402666092,
-0.025145642459392548,
0.4239252805709839,
0.27466028928756714,
0.1435791254043579,
-0.0650520920753479,
0.30125692486763,
-0.07757183909416199,
-0.4389658272266388,
0.12645220756530762,
-0.47652944922447205,
0.6977142095565796,
-0.11373467743396759,
0.07547193765640259,
-0.11663664877414703,
-0.11497844010591507,
-0.16484282910823822,
0.14797018468379974,
-0.4053005278110504,
0.8251816034317017,
-0.1913992166519165,
-0.5014495253562927,
0.5842883586883545,
0.05329465866088867,
0.3609655499458313,
-0.5533174872398376,
0.037483055144548416,
-0.4219514727592468,
0.33152052760124207,
-0.29952457547187805,
-0.26701584458351135,
0.23027403652668,
-0.01337449811398983,
-0.2240261286497116,
-0.5846377015113831,
0.8480255007743835,
-0.2294308990240097,
-0.1830931156873703,
0.47268977761268616,
0.7650588750839233,
0.2064725160598755,
-0.15221679210662842,
-0.6011298298835754,
0.03807219862937927,
-0.1922413855791092,
-0.5531285405158997,
0.4373568296432495,
0.8202380537986755,
-0.016468271613121033,
0.9970526695251465,
0.5921204686164856,
-0.07109541445970535,
0.16594740748405457,
-0.0016265383455902338,
1.147632122039795,
-0.6012747883796692,
-0.837215006351471,
-0.7463791966438293,
0.13871753215789795,
0.10945107787847519,
-0.11016616970300674,
0.8085440993309021,
0.6033140420913696,
0.5993790030479431,
-0.130026176571846,
0.43407362699508667,
-0.14189346134662628,
-0.09272897988557816,
-0.10612349957227707,
0.7244459390640259,
-0.9464436173439026,
0.38125959038734436,
-0.36648374795913696,
-0.9441723227500916,
-0.32315194606781006,
0.4130929708480835,
0.3423066735267639,
0.17925599217414856,
0.49544620513916016,
0.975736677646637,
0.3210042715072632,
-0.32640552520751953,
0.5258303880691528,
0.16453778743743896,
0.37480777502059937,
0.40872901678085327,
0.7201494574546814,
-0.06857731938362122,
0.809884786605835,
-0.006760819349437952,
-0.4166226089000702,
-0.22156421840190887,
-0.5793831944465637,
-0.6995981335639954,
-0.42522192001342773,
-0.177530899643898,
-0.12348867207765579,
-0.21277326345443726,
1.2167474031448364,
0.8327125906944275,
-0.5362885594367981,
-0.5811474323272705,
-0.4448417127132416,
0.27682146430015564,
-0.40415123105049133,
-0.11938585340976715,
0.11750384420156479,
-0.6996519565582275,
-0.6899585127830505,
0.5969073176383972,
0.8379592895507812,
-0.10179217159748077,
-0.7149885296821594,
-0.530929684638977,
-0.033669792115688324,
0.3124862313270569,
0.6222606301307678,
0.3197433054447174,
-0.23512668907642365,
0.06996316462755203,
0.02961023524403572,
-0.7847790122032166,
0.018542524427175522,
0.8315970301628113,
-0.6314433217048645,
0.6391744613647461,
0.3629612326622009,
0.6391961574554443,
0.20979374647140503,
0.023399215191602707,
0.5919530987739563,
-0.6186215877532959,
-0.047625359147787094,
0.12166929244995117,
-0.07698240876197815,
-0.4527425169944763,
-0.5664498209953308,
0.6889466047286987,
0.015984052792191505,
-0.9027609825134277,
-0.8489425182342529,
0.25109240412712097,
-0.848766028881073,
-0.42314577102661133,
1.012022614479065,
-0.12720359861850739,
-0.21076230704784393,
-0.09157822281122208,
-0.08487387001514435,
0.31316354870796204,
-0.5884286761283875,
0.6493915915489197,
0.13889944553375244,
-0.4454462230205536,
0.037538137286901474,
-0.0626504123210907,
0.4502655267715454,
0.4226539731025696,
-1.227911114692688,
0.038263820111751556,
0.738264799118042,
-0.07953855395317078,
0.5473802089691162,
1.234857201576233,
0.05403916910290718,
0.447194904088974,
0.26481926441192627,
0.570703387260437,
-0.36093801259994507,
-0.797183096408844,
-0.4653686285018921,
0.4990006983280182,
0.04662742465734482,
-0.19025515019893646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01940v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01940v1
|
Towards Better Understanding of Cybercrime: The Role of Fine-Tuned LLMs in Translation
| 2024-04-02T13:33:23 | 2024-04-02T13:33:23 |
Veronica Valeros, Anna Širokova, Carlos Catania, Sebastian Garcia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding cybercrime communications is paramount for cybersecurity
defence. This often involves translating communications into English for
processing, interpreting, and generating timely intelligence. The problem is
that translation is hard. Human translation is slow, expensive, and scarce.
Machine translation is inaccurate and biased. We propose using fine-tuned Large
Language Models (LLM) to generate translations that can accurately capture the
nuances of cybercrime language. We apply our technique to public chats from the
NoName057(16) Russian-speaking hacktivist group. Our results show that our
fine-tuned LLM model is better, faster, more accurate, and able to capture
nuances of the language. Our method shows it is possible to achieve
high-fidelity translations and significantly reduce costs by a factor ranging
from 430 to 23,000 compared to a human translator.
|
[
-0.03307958319783211,
-0.7999625205993652,
0.4181572198867798,
0.09297940135002136,
-0.5992235541343689,
0.4050096273422241,
-0.2897970676422119,
-0.779763400554657,
0.15656214952468872,
0.7741634249687195,
-0.42751196026802063,
-0.2863225042819977,
-0.8477048277854919,
0.2202526479959488,
-0.5278567671775818,
1.154162049293518,
0.16954387724399567,
0.2855124771595001,
-0.0003628308477345854,
0.3190155327320099,
-0.3533613979816437,
-0.5505028963088989,
-0.7103126645088196,
-0.4206238090991974,
0.1470756083726883,
0.31643614172935486,
0.6380299925804138,
0.6547238826751709,
0.9016656875610352,
0.41290533542633057,
-0.163692906498909,
0.30658599734306335,
-0.9207919239997864,
-0.24541956186294556,
-0.3079565167427063,
-0.8494317531585693,
-0.498561829328537,
-0.024746811017394066,
0.07179625332355499,
0.38077330589294434,
0.0020583041477948427,
0.2358006089925766,
0.14878299832344055,
0.4367554187774658,
-0.28219321370124817,
-0.045905206352472305,
-0.8790042996406555,
-0.12583675980567932,
-0.19792519509792328,
-0.47311511635780334,
-0.5701614022254944,
-0.155512273311615,
-0.035617273300886154,
-0.5756002068519592,
0.19291430711746216,
-0.0004691129142884165,
0.6861684918403625,
0.1177990511059761,
-0.29087531566619873,
0.01056161243468523,
-0.9465946555137634,
0.809661328792572,
-0.7963050007820129,
0.08731875568628311,
0.6106517910957336,
0.3064127564430237,
-0.31192710995674133,
-0.6759953498840332,
-0.2511318027973175,
0.06964070349931717,
0.1313573271036148,
-0.11607857793569565,
-0.48568010330200195,
0.08344798535108566,
-0.0273740291595459,
0.15958167612552643,
-0.3733346462249756,
0.22014115750789642,
-0.8319041132926941,
-0.4800870418548584,
0.9516125321388245,
0.48680511116981506,
0.1531612128019333,
0.05273250862956047,
-0.15186738967895508,
0.1474902480840683,
-0.5396692156791687,
-0.24760015308856964,
0.5116320252418518,
0.4366520941257477,
-0.43645811080932617,
0.357622891664505,
-0.2536177635192871,
0.637882649898529,
0.10040313005447388,
-0.6417880058288574,
-0.07232016324996948,
-0.5881393551826477,
-0.31284964084625244,
-0.09911834448575974,
0.5700838565826416,
0.525146484375,
0.6710631251335144,
-0.2857791781425476,
-0.16709794104099274,
0.06221078708767891,
0.6330541968345642,
-0.9414313435554504,
-0.2781328856945038,
0.26488178968429565,
-0.47912994027137756,
-0.7368786931037903,
0.017368681728839874,
-0.5771270394325256,
-0.29255983233451843,
-0.5092588067054749,
0.18747468292713165,
-0.28272199630737305,
0.007066936697810888,
0.47090455889701843,
-0.043013036251068115,
0.07023262977600098,
0.5947087407112122,
-0.4068836271762848,
0.2961917817592621,
0.7168516516685486,
0.7408814430236816,
0.014024821110069752,
-0.0751119926571846,
-0.5070996880531311,
0.14057286083698273,
-0.49552488327026367,
0.6691873669624329,
-0.297412246465683,
-0.020365562289953232,
-0.1251123547554016,
-0.19419802725315094,
0.34241315722465515,
-0.33384037017822266,
0.16770415008068085,
-0.7119941115379333,
0.10804038494825363,
0.4316767156124115,
-0.17466329038143158,
-0.06301809102296829,
0.366515189409256,
-0.147536963224411,
0.21480481326580048,
-0.12425699830055237,
-0.449417382478714,
0.013045030646026134,
-0.21181397140026093,
-0.64783775806427,
0.44328176975250244,
0.3395783007144928,
-0.1712825447320938,
0.27373799681663513,
0.21262972056865692,
0.6076948046684265,
-0.6294061541557312,
0.5188136100769043,
-0.3974936306476593,
-0.33819344639778137,
0.5998308658599854,
-0.46696674823760986,
0.6322148442268372,
0.43725457787513733,
-0.19434428215026855,
-0.03686593100428581,
-0.26131901144981384,
0.020160706713795662,
0.022511223331093788,
-0.35898205637931824,
-0.03787707909941673,
0.11404156684875488,
0.2226184606552124,
0.1958005577325821,
0.5716226696968079,
-0.43274161219596863,
-0.06679317355155945,
-0.7355098724365234,
0.8085288405418396,
0.7054443359375,
-0.05152715742588043,
0.2765556275844574,
-0.3283774256706238,
0.5703584551811218,
-0.08244089037179947,
0.3731860816478729,
-0.07042548060417175,
-0.3864552080631256,
-0.49600347876548767,
-0.3778310716152191,
0.19969630241394043,
0.8605740070343018,
-0.511307418346405,
0.28802672028541565,
-0.48335883021354675,
-0.5879034399986267,
-0.8081030249595642,
0.28442081809043884,
0.465261846780777,
0.023087939247488976,
0.4347623884677887,
-0.24944128096103668,
-0.4368261396884918,
-0.8796778321266174,
-0.4413388669490814,
-0.08606302738189697,
0.01696597971022129,
0.3326825499534607,
0.41863930225372314,
-0.26444703340530396,
0.30866876244544983,
-0.41516995429992676,
-0.3085962235927582,
-0.40720656514167786,
0.1715986132621765,
0.1628328412771225,
0.1952771693468094,
0.10611382871866226,
-0.7270306944847107,
-0.5665746331214905,
0.26505208015441895,
-0.4249018430709839,
-0.086374431848526,
-0.2319066971540451,
0.23092836141586304,
0.032932307571172714,
0.8425598740577698,
-0.4722038209438324,
0.46896064281463623,
0.4285511076450348,
-0.42367324233055115,
0.2789852023124695,
-0.2348811775445938,
0.20354868471622467,
-1.463936448097229,
0.21755504608154297,
-0.1440519392490387,
-0.7849252820014954,
-0.8679099678993225,
0.4053424298763275,
-0.032808300107717514,
-0.3677372634410858,
-0.9322220683097839,
0.284449964761734,
-0.39961040019989014,
0.2299121767282486,
-0.4511295258998871,
0.5728699564933777,
-0.25213515758514404,
0.1606566160917282,
-0.3367663323879242,
0.8612796664237976,
0.3017871081829071,
-0.6639542579650879,
0.585003137588501,
0.14821678400039673,
-0.5220471024513245,
0.7340566515922546,
-0.8095307946205139,
0.18246936798095703,
0.057043034583330154,
0.11899096518754959,
-0.6940330862998962,
-0.40181490778923035,
0.11025998741388321,
-0.7265077233314514,
0.5023317337036133,
-0.23079293966293335,
-0.547387421131134,
-0.1037503182888031,
-0.11579980701208115,
0.4089409112930298,
0.444744348526001,
-0.07460211962461472,
0.20271249115467072,
0.840587854385376,
-0.10831299424171448,
-0.4797404706478119,
-0.8688637614250183,
0.5052309632301331,
-0.328066349029541,
-0.6829057335853577,
0.40637585520744324,
0.018168313428759575,
-0.38874009251594543,
-0.4051405191421509,
0.05978066101670265,
-0.1190379187464714,
0.4486929178237915,
-0.07492969930171967,
0.116617351770401,
-0.13405321538448334,
-0.2616909444332123,
-0.36504578590393066,
-0.05721086263656616,
0.16632623970508575,
-0.43511176109313965,
0.7464702129364014,
0.07397051155567169,
-0.15166552364826202,
-0.681579053401947,
0.32342204451560974,
0.6920960545539856,
-0.1281842440366745,
0.5925610065460205,
0.40599846839904785,
-0.28327128291130066,
-0.056192949414253235,
-0.5988330245018005,
-0.45388850569725037,
-0.49137982726097107,
0.5480362772941589,
-0.2077292948961258,
-1.067590355873108,
0.471098393201828,
-0.04208802804350853,
-0.22853754460811615,
0.28529784083366394,
0.5851406455039978,
-0.09137158840894699,
1.0963735580444336,
0.715404212474823,
-0.6361755728721619,
0.2693805694580078,
0.07377218455076218,
0.32643693685531616,
-0.42686545848846436,
-0.058008939027786255,
-0.5771275162696838,
-0.4557090103626251,
-0.589844286441803,
-0.3760165274143219,
0.22236847877502441,
-0.017401758581399918,
0.06654620915651321,
0.6674399971961975,
-0.3070187270641327,
0.6795871257781982,
0.11737950891256332,
0.2128090113401413,
0.22455757856369019,
0.15950727462768555,
0.3502691984176636,
-0.17338275909423828,
-0.5454131960868835,
-0.7325100898742676,
0.9178858399391174,
0.37374481558799744,
0.7656798362731934,
0.43587541580200195,
0.554531991481781,
0.26038458943367004,
-0.07989546656608582,
-0.7872161865234375,
0.5659060478210449,
-0.3185120224952698,
-0.6752253174781799,
-0.07461577653884888,
-0.4466703236103058,
-1.186286449432373,
-0.09207567572593689,
-0.4093873202800751,
-1.0479708909988403,
-0.07367469370365143,
0.13645172119140625,
-0.24790209531784058,
0.2788490355014801,
-0.13485591113567352,
0.6472755074501038,
-0.19387118518352509,
-0.3379027545452118,
-0.8387885093688965,
-0.5981476306915283,
0.3590334951877594,
-0.30354490876197815,
0.34853073954582214,
-0.1065112054347992,
-0.0013105323305353522,
0.480044960975647,
-0.1414366215467453,
1.2560356855392456,
0.3187355697154999,
-0.1309657245874405,
0.12076425552368164,
0.4106363356113434,
0.57680344581604,
0.20312826335430145,
0.26559796929359436,
0.39499738812446594,
-0.01584949530661106,
-0.45415690541267395,
-0.16556905210018158,
0.4409308433532715,
-0.9034900665283203,
-0.7567169070243835,
-0.16565613448619843,
-0.664885938167572,
0.26776567101478577,
0.2744801938533783,
0.3095968961715698,
0.34104570746421814,
-0.38711825013160706,
0.4769571125507355,
0.7637816071510315,
-0.054003212600946426,
0.0024920429568737745,
0.8296740055084229,
0.021614378318190575,
-0.4724811613559723,
0.8806837201118469,
-0.14920726418495178,
0.40011969208717346,
0.6485578417778015,
-0.0033875976223498583,
0.08739563822746277,
-0.756431519985199,
-0.2292613536119461,
0.39778149127960205,
-0.44400274753570557,
-0.6894006133079529,
-0.6137272119522095,
-0.16081097722053528,
-0.6926941275596619,
-0.3300592005252838,
-0.27617529034614563,
-0.4037703275680542,
-0.5625120401382446,
0.18210315704345703,
0.4273736774921417,
0.6978365778923035,
-0.03491082787513733,
0.5430192947387695,
-0.9105502963066101,
0.4347822368144989,
0.068609319627285,
-0.08067838102579117,
-0.3989424407482147,
-1.2399948835372925,
-0.4795171916484833,
0.23103374242782593,
-0.4181769788265228,
-0.969801127910614,
0.6516361832618713,
0.06452096998691559,
0.256680428981781,
0.36294862627983093,
-0.07334528118371964,
0.989418089389801,
-0.36192598938941956,
0.7646946907043457,
-0.08101076632738113,
-1.0684516429901123,
0.47399118542671204,
-0.5018019676208496,
0.2669288218021393,
0.5698066353797913,
0.21661432087421417,
-0.6975577473640442,
-0.5692051649093628,
-0.5792616009712219,
-0.6769024729728699,
0.8127124905586243,
0.05368100479245186,
0.5272884964942932,
0.07114679366350174,
0.28326570987701416,
-0.3471793830394745,
0.19903911650180817,
-0.5585324168205261,
0.11371763795614243,
0.26038411259651184,
-0.17803655564785004,
-0.2997775375843048,
-0.22302018105983734,
-0.21159763634204865,
0.0479397177696228,
0.7741985321044922,
-0.11746853590011597,
0.2119472175836563,
-0.12754707038402557,
-0.19296616315841675,
-0.2725784480571747,
0.21628648042678833,
0.8996238112449646,
0.6017807722091675,
0.2349691390991211,
-0.017442049458622932,
0.4844409227371216,
-0.6563705801963806,
-0.004141955636441708,
-0.3290511667728424,
-0.12751822173595428,
-0.19954103231430054,
0.508955180644989,
0.6244179606437683,
0.1376064568758011,
-0.6977202296257019,
0.8319275975227356,
0.05652560666203499,
-0.36342546343803406,
-0.23147638142108917,
0.10861705988645554,
0.1223650649189949,
0.38557660579681396,
0.032780785113573074,
0.07754302769899368,
0.016334375366568565,
-0.41191044449806213,
0.1747119277715683,
0.6220616698265076,
-0.24151074886322021,
-0.3794081509113312,
0.5423636436462402,
0.3626270294189453,
-0.8475784659385681,
0.6415696144104004,
0.06664338707923889,
-0.5881514549255371,
0.438938707113266,
0.8322969079017639,
0.890488862991333,
-0.28888654708862305,
0.18181365728378296,
0.14187000691890717,
0.7929297089576721,
-0.2326696366071701,
0.2815472483634949,
0.18285882472991943,
-0.5614498853683472,
-0.7670159339904785,
-0.3971851170063019,
-0.3114202916622162,
0.469445139169693,
-0.5277665853500366,
0.5871055722236633,
-0.46001186966896057,
-0.17621076107025146,
-0.11194860190153122,
-0.13759413361549377,
-0.7264614701271057,
0.08899814635515213,
0.09856443852186203,
0.8950274586677551,
-0.7982818484306335,
0.663414478302002,
0.5241969227790833,
0.020977512001991272,
-0.4743814170360565,
-0.22095398604869843,
0.020159436389803886,
-0.7462658882141113,
0.5317887663841248,
0.02764594554901123,
-0.13408808410167694,
0.04047108441591263,
-0.8893778920173645,
-0.9526001811027527,
0.8175143599510193,
0.5016171336174011,
-0.6237971186637878,
0.18749357759952545,
0.6090648770332336,
0.7100360989570618,
-0.3272329866886139,
-0.06598223745822906,
0.4027203619480133,
0.3519097864627838,
-0.40319564938545227,
-1.0965296030044556,
-0.09844621270895004,
-0.27539166808128357,
-0.10416067391633987,
0.6047802567481995,
-0.6425045132637024,
0.6209845542907715,
-0.06494362652301788,
-0.26121488213539124,
-0.062325168401002884,
0.477965384721756,
-0.2638668119907379,
0.21123777329921722,
-0.10842844098806381,
0.35446929931640625,
0.4859171211719513,
0.1614806354045868,
0.843604564666748,
-0.43653157353401184,
-0.045734141021966934,
0.9742371439933777,
0.2649381756782532,
0.7055091857910156,
0.5870285630226135,
-0.17252898216247559,
0.015548634342849255,
0.3812226951122284,
-0.12149184942245483,
0.34104374051094055,
0.3309193551540375,
-0.08433528989553452,
-0.4560719430446625,
-0.08039112389087677,
0.18658286333084106,
0.7127387523651123,
0.504392683506012,
-0.44962990283966064,
0.002028962830081582,
-0.17663908004760742,
0.3484658896923065,
0.35959282517433167,
-0.32076236605644226,
1.139943242073059,
0.32063397765159607,
-0.4346074163913727,
0.7227305769920349,
0.5826793909072876,
0.610759973526001,
-0.3674791157245636,
0.33759379386901855,
-0.058589961379766464,
0.35166969895362854,
-0.08645559102296829,
-0.5309585928916931,
0.5081666707992554,
0.23287832736968994,
0.0627349466085434,
-0.09369795769453049,
0.7133753895759583,
-0.39209070801734924,
-0.3899048864841461,
0.108857162296772,
0.2992260754108429,
0.7366702556610107,
-0.15177564322948456,
-0.7738363742828369,
-0.11467423290014267,
0.14707431197166443,
0.1438923478126526,
0.3299790918827057,
0.4414423406124115,
-0.08885432034730911,
0.6551315188407898,
0.8307834267616272,
0.4643512964248657,
-0.253129243850708,
-0.49991992115974426,
0.6666072010993958,
-0.4225265085697174,
-0.4002187252044678,
-1.215877652168274,
0.385252445936203,
-0.18060851097106934,
-0.6379556655883789,
0.6189365983009338,
0.3443996012210846,
0.9937658905982971,
-0.10730969160795212,
0.5612617135047913,
0.3254665434360504,
0.19678790867328644,
-0.4821990728378296,
0.7931811809539795,
-0.3655811548233032,
0.17534013092517853,
-0.04859842360019684,
-0.7015547752380371,
-0.3454280197620392,
0.6282147765159607,
-0.16798384487628937,
-0.48241838812828064,
0.29113516211509705,
0.8246965408325195,
-0.33031460642814636,
-0.2502667307853699,
0.49840256571769714,
0.20958904922008514,
0.3941865861415863,
0.4666156470775604,
0.4401301443576813,
-0.6148421168327332,
0.8424925804138184,
-0.06390232592821121,
0.09675096720457077,
-0.4750354588031769,
-0.9787541031837463,
-1.240845799446106,
-0.10954523831605911,
-0.2678096890449524,
-0.36200571060180664,
0.11597931385040283,
0.7952806353569031,
0.7365983128547668,
-0.7148577570915222,
-0.36737242341041565,
0.07118066400289536,
-0.13785932958126068,
-0.005720069631934166,
-0.14184264838695526,
-0.3819160759449005,
-0.32419395446777344,
-0.631380021572113,
0.5978372693061829,
0.22784538567066193,
0.13709299266338348,
-0.3821333646774292,
0.10038652271032333,
0.08580383658409119,
0.5135887861251831,
0.5672081112861633,
0.0009766769362613559,
-0.7798821330070496,
-0.19720208644866943,
0.1128382608294487,
-0.2951407730579376,
-0.1352001130580902,
0.7112097144126892,
-0.43317410349845886,
0.2827320992946625,
0.6860129833221436,
0.8183645606040955,
0.5136969685554504,
-0.07560136914253235,
0.8283843398094177,
-0.5985061526298523,
0.3079156279563904,
0.2566508948802948,
0.15550024807453156,
0.41522204875946045,
-0.6187914609909058,
0.30357643961906433,
0.14266280829906464,
-0.6230072379112244,
-0.8648393750190735,
0.3929724395275116,
-0.40447545051574707,
-0.5459504723548889,
1.042799949645996,
-0.04849577322602272,
-0.2777338922023773,
-0.4248703420162201,
-0.15780945122241974,
0.34967276453971863,
-0.35226917266845703,
0.9795002341270447,
0.5207363963127136,
0.6503027677536011,
0.023595549166202545,
-0.5612643361091614,
0.4255470335483551,
0.27360105514526367,
-0.7987110614776611,
0.20923562347888947,
0.25949397683143616,
0.11577995866537094,
0.2937047779560089,
0.37727227807044983,
-0.11223337054252625,
0.27121445536613464,
-0.3624194860458374,
-0.07743945717811584,
0.026177531108260155,
-0.5153979659080505,
-0.3352847993373871,
-0.11787372827529907,
-0.04151979461312294,
0.2041054368019104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01923v1
|
SGSH: Stimulate Large Language Models with Skeleton Heuristics for Knowledge Base Question Generation
| 2024-04-02T13:17:36 | 2024-04-02T13:17:36 |
Shasha Guo, Lizi Liao, Jing Zhang, Yanling Wang, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge base question generation (KBQG) aims to generate natural language
questions from a set of triplet facts extracted from KB. Existing methods have
significantly boosted the performance of KBQG via pre-trained language models
(PLMs) thanks to the richly endowed semantic knowledge. With the advance of
pre-training techniques, large language models (LLMs) (e.g., GPT-3.5)
undoubtedly possess much more semantic knowledge. Therefore, how to effectively
organize and exploit the abundant knowledge for KBQG becomes the focus of our
study. In this work, we propose SGSH--a simple and effective framework to
Stimulate GPT-3.5 with Skeleton Heuristics to enhance KBQG. The framework
incorporates "skeleton heuristics", which provides more fine-grained guidance
associated with each input to stimulate LLMs to generate optimal questions,
encompassing essential elements like the question phrase and the auxiliary
verb.More specifically, we devise an automatic data construction strategy
leveraging ChatGPT to construct a skeleton training dataset, based on which we
employ a soft prompting approach to train a BART model dedicated to generating
the skeleton associated with each input. Subsequently, skeleton heuristics are
encoded into the prompt to incentivize GPT-3.5 to generate desired questions.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that SGSH derives the new state-of-the-art
performance on the KBQG tasks.
|
[
-0.4221808612346649,
-0.8809259533882141,
0.6756662726402283,
-0.13549530506134033,
-0.5095618963241577,
-0.07116935402154922,
-0.09860999882221222,
-0.11857892572879791,
0.08287657052278519,
0.6937922835350037,
-0.4842246472835541,
-0.6574556231498718,
-0.2409585863351822,
0.025418762117624283,
-0.0897919163107872,
0.899029016494751,
-0.03431423753499985,
0.03678572177886963,
-0.15469537675380707,
0.1911371499300003,
-0.2840576469898224,
-0.489382266998291,
-0.4546530842781067,
-0.09521077573299408,
0.32028713822364807,
0.6813721656799316,
0.6830654144287109,
0.7069095969200134,
0.24253928661346436,
0.20033490657806396,
0.08435450494289398,
0.1666490137577057,
-0.3770976662635803,
0.5275909900665283,
-0.008607552386820316,
-0.4295330047607422,
-0.27950894832611084,
-0.26847174763679504,
0.4943697154521942,
0.8696765899658203,
-0.17917656898498535,
0.2821185290813446,
-0.16016729176044464,
0.633713960647583,
-0.4034632742404938,
0.5214336514472961,
-0.8681531548500061,
-0.1905098557472229,
-0.15917737782001495,
-0.3465788662433624,
-0.1307019293308258,
-0.518414318561554,
0.1868070363998413,
-0.4491368532180786,
0.28666064143180847,
0.06788909435272217,
0.7316818237304688,
0.17210505902767181,
-0.49742403626441956,
-0.2574599087238312,
-0.19332852959632874,
0.14813877642154694,
-0.7496598958969116,
0.5273736119270325,
0.41006597876548767,
0.34106072783470154,
-0.3603953421115875,
-0.6450150609016418,
-0.6077759861946106,
-0.5526678562164307,
0.0610574334859848,
0.01336605940014124,
0.31592851877212524,
0.1519065648317337,
0.35332179069519043,
0.19503098726272583,
-0.6912562847137451,
-0.259196937084198,
-0.41405412554740906,
-0.13619984686374664,
0.5576087832450867,
0.27828797698020935,
0.2783806622028351,
-0.7620022296905518,
-0.12021245807409286,
-0.06993061304092407,
-0.9030529856681824,
0.0023868915159255266,
0.5849958658218384,
0.5498237013816833,
0.3021327555179596,
0.7013911604881287,
-0.47002676129341125,
0.6463504433631897,
0.3149852752685547,
-0.12938925623893738,
0.07133637368679047,
-0.4349451959133148,
0.04552663490176201,
0.09142260998487473,
0.6105372309684753,
0.4824102818965912,
0.24262785911560059,
-0.2915627062320709,
-0.08556610345840454,
0.005393252708017826,
0.3239424228668213,
-0.9438904523849487,
-0.39684736728668213,
0.2076156884431839,
-0.20956847071647644,
-0.3616660237312317,
-0.15069803595542908,
-0.4623259902000427,
-0.3390272557735443,
-0.24179087579250336,
0.5280117392539978,
-0.5656718611717224,
-0.6157447099685669,
0.29552653431892395,
-0.21030652523040771,
0.21091526746749878,
0.12453410774469376,
-1.0622165203094482,
0.1100444495677948,
0.37182649970054626,
0.20628449320793152,
-0.09582448750734329,
-0.039603911340236664,
-0.4277527630329132,
0.6374107599258423,
-0.3664124310016632,
0.6151351928710938,
-0.25862744450569153,
-0.3869800865650177,
-0.11121524125337601,
0.008634806610643864,
0.1571093052625656,
-0.5650292634963989,
0.174808070063591,
-0.6011428833007812,
0.408072292804718,
-0.5336577892303467,
-0.5766171813011169,
-0.09702309966087341,
0.4400770366191864,
-0.5088890194892883,
1.0236631631851196,
0.4465053677558899,
-0.7252285480499268,
0.5193930268287659,
-0.538244366645813,
-0.5191854238510132,
0.41841134428977966,
-0.3558887243270874,
-0.08156236261129379,
-0.19231712818145752,
0.3659484088420868,
0.8243599534034729,
-0.5023044943809509,
0.4937007427215576,
-0.22072067856788635,
0.06680471450090408,
-0.29793184995651245,
-0.021199986338615417,
0.5609472990036011,
-0.08194142580032349,
-0.446965754032135,
0.10288551449775696,
-0.5238275527954102,
0.416159987449646,
0.2616192102432251,
-0.4161902368068695,
-0.22534562647342682,
-0.1560467779636383,
-0.500995397567749,
0.04802946001291275,
0.012926461175084114,
-0.2046593874692917,
0.3497276306152344,
-0.5771068334579468,
0.14213135838508606,
0.5983708500862122,
0.29725736379623413,
0.46946829557418823,
-0.14440591633319855,
0.7433181405067444,
-0.0715523511171341,
-0.10511856526136398,
-0.14627058804035187,
-0.45083388686180115,
-0.3123863637447357,
0.08573389798402786,
0.38944441080093384,
0.5590106844902039,
-1.0656521320343018,
0.32215553522109985,
-0.22192002832889557,
-0.5320239663124084,
-0.34542137384414673,
0.19225482642650604,
0.021424468606710434,
0.7271715402603149,
0.343289852142334,
-0.08507005870342255,
-0.5288596749305725,
-0.8491648435592651,
0.012412935495376587,
-0.6334545612335205,
-0.01610175147652626,
0.5562611818313599,
0.352984219789505,
0.1408246010541916,
0.9858202338218689,
-0.6816775798797607,
0.3898157477378845,
-0.48119693994522095,
0.25264856219291687,
0.10433951765298843,
0.4510871469974518,
0.41976699233055115,
-0.7375968098640442,
-0.5017401576042175,
-0.17634893953800201,
-0.7256717085838318,
-0.21364766359329224,
0.07768843322992325,
-0.2902868092060089,
0.005652096122503281,
0.5116474628448486,
-1.1313567161560059,
0.08149081468582153,
-0.02912595123052597,
-0.14139942824840546,
0.9522638916969299,
0.17959384620189667,
0.2610671818256378,
-1.3677226305007935,
0.12006056308746338,
-0.4236031770706177,
-0.03677205368876457,
-0.581343412399292,
0.3119388520717621,
0.12749083340168,
-0.13946382701396942,
-0.23600833117961884,
0.7232528328895569,
-0.4058471918106079,
0.10661691427230835,
-0.04995908960700035,
0.23418089747428894,
-0.19050657749176025,
0.6592867970466614,
-0.020733799785375595,
0.47886428236961365,
0.3990246057510376,
-0.7929055690765381,
0.5738641619682312,
0.2816931903362274,
-0.28067338466644287,
0.49603724479675293,
-0.5382357239723206,
0.16542571783065796,
-0.29491785168647766,
0.3356584310531616,
-0.9434312582015991,
-0.6701404452323914,
0.35041067004203796,
-0.5251094102859497,
0.37629541754722595,
-0.4715343713760376,
-0.6177297234535217,
-0.7952049970626831,
-0.32366743683815,
0.19437257945537567,
0.5514857769012451,
-0.34233778715133667,
0.5814571976661682,
0.37575411796569824,
-0.5782824754714966,
-0.5553629398345947,
-0.3472999036312103,
-0.04891158640384674,
-0.15409840643405914,
-0.9842112064361572,
0.2390190064907074,
-0.16300633549690247,
-0.12759548425674438,
0.1007622480392456,
-0.4526149332523346,
0.040971796959638596,
0.011494573205709457,
-0.02109656110405922,
0.28428587317466736,
-0.5711705088615417,
0.17271925508975983,
0.24802221357822418,
0.034929439425468445,
0.30876150727272034,
-0.6223989129066467,
0.6891939640045166,
0.04738142341375351,
-0.46844273805618286,
0.015542767941951752,
0.33833131194114685,
0.3324423134326935,
0.018220437690615654,
0.35153913497924805,
0.5363342761993408,
-0.18158818781375885,
-0.1505708396434784,
-0.6815706491470337,
-0.4949812591075897,
-0.4515921473503113,
0.48959511518478394,
-0.41651371121406555,
-1.0457576513290405,
0.38918203115463257,
-0.16247765719890594,
0.006769268773496151,
0.33802586793899536,
0.7427928447723389,
0.0663469061255455,
1.3651015758514404,
0.3035167455673218,
-0.008619893342256546,
0.103317990899086,
-0.03673018887639046,
-0.04098312556743622,
-0.3987307548522949,
-0.1251230239868164,
-0.33856281638145447,
0.0252976194024086,
-0.3216454088687897,
-0.49290621280670166,
0.3759368360042572,
0.5372007489204407,
-0.31587696075439453,
0.33389073610305786,
-0.2635391652584076,
0.502685010433197,
0.42271536588668823,
0.06353786587715149,
0.06695172935724258,
-0.1195274069905281,
-0.4948609471321106,
0.38117682933807373,
-1.0076462030410767,
-0.4232867956161499,
1.2390286922454834,
0.04628121480345726,
0.636970579624176,
0.037088487297296524,
0.7616487741470337,
-0.1183561384677887,
0.27144137024879456,
-0.7127578258514404,
0.8237878680229187,
0.23827852308750153,
-0.7928654551506042,
-0.44063833355903625,
-0.6661426424980164,
-0.8064807653427124,
-0.040748827159404755,
0.028105638921260834,
-0.5672435164451599,
-0.2830130457878113,
0.43908223509788513,
-0.679638683795929,
0.11577825248241425,
-0.8880113959312439,
0.7587613463401794,
-0.19038568437099457,
-0.26150205731391907,
0.06823213398456573,
-0.8518290519714355,
0.519200325012207,
0.14039766788482666,
-0.17572808265686035,
-0.1206773966550827,
0.1275920271873474,
0.550598680973053,
-0.33226051926612854,
0.6127545237541199,
-0.6421957015991211,
-0.1620226502418518,
0.42476198077201843,
0.08813189715147018,
0.7540538907051086,
0.3489506244659424,
0.0650925412774086,
-0.42117196321487427,
-0.06126745045185089,
-0.3492191433906555,
-0.5335574746131897,
0.34894707798957825,
-0.4286843240261078,
-1.0158843994140625,
0.23242701590061188,
-0.4950951635837555,
-0.7945598363876343,
0.3389914035797119,
0.13708294928073883,
0.3001709282398224,
0.0030755032785236835,
0.24615247547626495,
0.7881562113761902,
-0.25808897614479065,
-0.08351561427116394,
0.5002714991569519,
-0.4034484922885895,
-0.38634824752807617,
0.7205694317817688,
-0.010907506570219994,
0.5305311679840088,
0.20968182384967804,
0.2434796392917633,
-0.4324754774570465,
-0.5334351658821106,
-0.878932774066925,
0.07138128578662872,
-0.6650068759918213,
-0.5603780746459961,
-0.8668524622917175,
-0.33296048641204834,
-0.7257372140884399,
0.018182769417762756,
0.08302577584981918,
-0.5222067832946777,
0.026951180770993233,
-0.2405807375907898,
0.4740827679634094,
0.5986474752426147,
0.002038768259808421,
0.4243326783180237,
-0.8071829080581665,
0.5459557175636292,
0.7108602523803711,
0.414612352848053,
-0.08559711277484894,
-0.18970857560634613,
-0.14016574621200562,
0.05082325264811516,
-0.029349984601140022,
-0.9942024350166321,
0.029161155223846436,
-0.30935171246528625,
0.8270490169525146,
0.08836691826581955,
-0.013083424419164658,
0.5640507340431213,
-0.5255381464958191,
0.8422644734382629,
0.07059752196073532,
-0.6094939708709717,
0.5048364996910095,
-0.9025917053222656,
0.36387258768081665,
0.724461019039154,
0.4685631990432739,
-0.47668156027793884,
-0.3919171988964081,
-0.7819583415985107,
-1.067893147468567,
0.8897538185119629,
-0.045293595641851425,
0.15901771187782288,
-0.2790900468826294,
0.5123039484024048,
0.31172674894332886,
0.5048777461051941,
-0.4683627188205719,
0.09637783467769623,
-0.18544866144657135,
-0.4228458106517792,
0.6216738224029541,
-0.1370752602815628,
0.051229946315288544,
-0.20731529593467712,
0.731909453868866,
-0.5579797029495239,
0.07903263717889786,
-0.17683178186416626,
-0.23261994123458862,
-0.25210127234458923,
0.13430579006671906,
0.08663304150104523,
0.4085735082626343,
-0.20359627902507782,
-0.0474427193403244,
0.2845771014690399,
-0.5042233467102051,
-0.0017525791190564632,
0.22193537652492523,
-0.273691326379776,
-0.2537499666213989,
0.13158611953258514,
0.7684391140937805,
0.1096734032034874,
-0.5511126518249512,
0.4282844662666321,
0.013830620795488358,
-0.5909741520881653,
0.03902306780219078,
0.3825886845588684,
0.4506015479564667,
0.27408480644226074,
0.2957078814506531,
-0.30847516655921936,
-0.22681592404842377,
-0.34632331132888794,
0.29169362783432007,
0.5525836944580078,
0.060780998319387436,
-0.0341372936964035,
0.5835998058319092,
0.11637398600578308,
0.06547460705041885,
0.4686753749847412,
-0.4268728196620941,
-0.8460213541984558,
0.46765390038490295,
0.5052289366722107,
0.5331208109855652,
-0.29750362038612366,
0.2609507441520691,
0.4540272057056427,
0.292985200881958,
-0.332965612411499,
0.7674152255058289,
-0.3243652880191803,
-0.7128974199295044,
-0.5797716975212097,
-0.5498718023300171,
-0.22718596458435059,
0.39845216274261475,
-0.2861105799674988,
0.3551468253135681,
-0.4387010633945465,
0.07078670710325241,
-0.18491455912590027,
0.03557028993964195,
-0.6613271236419678,
0.15151748061180115,
0.16976337134838104,
0.978001594543457,
-0.4811323285102844,
0.5557745695114136,
0.5364343523979187,
-0.5193988680839539,
-1.2954185009002686,
0.240494504570961,
-0.14293654263019562,
-0.8595144152641296,
0.691561758518219,
0.042645689100027084,
0.1179078072309494,
0.3209155201911926,
-0.8659338355064392,
-0.9045013189315796,
1.0824087858200073,
0.5005190968513489,
-0.0844016969203949,
-0.39839649200439453,
0.319789856672287,
0.15737417340278625,
-0.15958307683467865,
0.03088226541876793,
0.4612294137477875,
0.6501302719116211,
0.27346983551979065,
-0.7217673659324646,
0.23322418332099915,
-0.3134356737136841,
-0.38233813643455505,
0.3978087306022644,
-0.33421120047569275,
0.6257938742637634,
-0.31083357334136963,
-0.21354874968528748,
0.15300558507442474,
0.6286205053329468,
0.53618985414505,
-0.18254952132701874,
0.8218963742256165,
0.33438172936439514,
0.8737092018127441,
0.0835130512714386,
0.7295963168144226,
-0.49210768938064575,
-0.12773717939853668,
0.9766983985900879,
-0.4381253719329834,
0.4647709131240845,
0.3163732588291168,
0.03512254357337952,
0.32334330677986145,
0.6398967504501343,
0.036420974880456924,
0.45578256249427795,
0.5452048182487488,
-0.21760782599449158,
-0.47470930218696594,
0.10770879685878754,
-0.6319054365158081,
0.35994523763656616,
0.41897884011268616,
-0.1536022275686264,
-0.31245240569114685,
-0.041429199278354645,
0.05120173096656799,
-0.35197460651397705,
-0.2230021059513092,
0.8759015798568726,
-0.15660767257213593,
-0.8809248805046082,
0.4486967921257019,
-0.14552852511405945,
0.3066837191581726,
-1.0189661979675293,
-0.030505655333399773,
-0.1864931285381317,
-0.28976452350616455,
0.029905783012509346,
-0.674406111240387,
-0.045513253659009933,
0.03490408509969711,
-0.2518751621246338,
-0.2248772382736206,
1.0236599445343018,
-0.572464644908905,
-0.26151055097579956,
-0.1454591453075409,
0.8767527341842651,
0.06906166672706604,
-0.20694805681705475,
-0.4866555333137512,
-0.5282166004180908,
0.016488315537571907,
-0.46276554465293884,
0.24572381377220154,
0.7817323803901672,
-0.18972015380859375,
0.4447189271450043,
0.8303288817405701,
0.12535935640335083,
-0.15336787700653076,
0.0816354751586914,
1.0666142702102661,
-0.7703621983528137,
-0.6446496844291687,
-0.6580663323402405,
0.45773807168006897,
-0.18705064058303833,
-0.15037524700164795,
0.6039543747901917,
0.4137527346611023,
0.5328574180603027,
0.0348440483212471,
1.0111584663391113,
-0.32335829734802246,
0.5895358920097351,
-0.5609584450721741,
0.7411131262779236,
-0.3910314738750458,
0.20494584739208221,
-0.42018869519233704,
-0.6722659468650818,
-0.014412074349820614,
0.36374667286872864,
-0.1825076937675476,
0.19335408508777618,
0.6459876298904419,
1.0156776905059814,
0.06943464279174805,
0.40682080388069153,
0.006657618097960949,
0.2419382631778717,
0.1496809720993042,
0.43164604902267456,
0.7901141047477722,
0.03552193567156792,
0.7406493425369263,
-0.010077843442559242,
-0.12199927121400833,
-0.024784788489341736,
-0.8604210615158081,
-0.9398806691169739,
-0.6102799773216248,
0.03924218937754631,
-0.4867892563343048,
0.08765161037445068,
1.280109167098999,
0.7877683639526367,
-0.6658948659896851,
0.021958129480481148,
-0.08263622969388962,
0.061669882386922836,
0.22334009408950806,
-0.23192639648914337,
0.49345633387565613,
-0.37007471919059753,
-0.04267275333404541,
0.45957785844802856,
0.0850994810461998,
0.0523068867623806,
-0.3768137991428375,
0.01473874133080244,
-0.11180262267589569,
-0.1707087606191635,
0.6368048191070557,
0.02836139127612114,
-0.43384265899658203,
-0.3728303611278534,
0.24398070573806763,
-0.22127825021743774,
-0.2756015956401825,
0.8603938817977905,
-1.0726643800735474,
-0.04275331273674965,
0.6095569133758545,
1.0109659433364868,
0.5365232825279236,
0.04663398489356041,
0.8511426448822021,
-0.9748737812042236,
-0.35102471709251404,
0.38981619477272034,
0.1498359739780426,
0.32541128993034363,
-0.4667629897594452,
0.6166191101074219,
0.39509856700897217,
-0.32745176553726196,
-0.8032976984977722,
0.24156954884529114,
-0.5799540877342224,
-0.3022611737251282,
1.402700424194336,
0.26074713468551636,
-0.22945694625377655,
-0.26218077540397644,
-0.4300529360771179,
0.3384436368942261,
-0.2789752185344696,
0.7729032039642334,
0.8265329003334045,
-0.17164954543113708,
0.04153337702155113,
-0.8772236704826355,
0.7858569622039795,
0.45796963572502136,
-1.0303878784179688,
0.4327525198459625,
0.6188687682151794,
0.26281073689460754,
-0.032449379563331604,
0.7729138731956482,
-0.01809348724782467,
0.43237388134002686,
0.038798559457063675,
-0.08879084885120392,
-0.14012767374515533,
-0.08423472940921783,
0.3864785134792328,
0.5337703824043274,
-0.0765209048986435,
0.3305789828300476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01921v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01921v2
|
A Rationale-centric Counterfactual Data Augmentation Method for Cross-Document Event Coreference Resolution
| 2024-04-02T13:15:07 | 2024-05-08T04:07:35 |
Bowen Ding, Qingkai Min, Shengkun Ma, Yingjie Li, Linyi Yang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Based on Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), event coreference resolution
(ECR) systems have demonstrated outstanding performance in clustering
coreferential events across documents. However, the existing system exhibits an
excessive reliance on the `triggers lexical matching' spurious pattern in the
input mention pair text. We formalize the decision-making process of the
baseline ECR system using a Structural Causal Model (SCM), aiming to identify
spurious and causal associations (i.e., rationales) within the ECR task.
Leveraging the debiasing capability of counterfactual data augmentation, we
develop a rationale-centric counterfactual data augmentation method with
LLM-in-the-loop. This method is specialized for pairwise input in the ECR
system, where we conduct direct interventions on triggers and context to
mitigate the spurious association while emphasizing the causation. Our approach
achieves state-of-the-art performance on three popular cross-document ECR
benchmarks and demonstrates robustness in out-of-domain scenarios.
|
[
-0.6048588156700134,
-1.0645793676376343,
0.6940889954566956,
-0.23670940101146698,
-0.5345773100852966,
-0.13100266456604004,
-0.26258015632629395,
-0.48057880997657776,
0.25575894117355347,
0.4984336495399475,
-0.5776374936103821,
-0.3322468101978302,
-0.5878416895866394,
0.10805168747901917,
-0.4636515974998474,
0.8571361899375916,
-0.17918230593204498,
0.1597651094198227,
-0.5599144101142883,
-0.30317431688308716,
-0.48368775844573975,
-1.0698474645614624,
-0.4628681540489197,
-0.6603579521179199,
0.32591256499290466,
0.555924117565155,
0.27994677424430847,
0.484154611825943,
0.38597556948661804,
0.2008785754442215,
0.09951722621917725,
0.23741401731967926,
-0.3183611333370209,
0.13131821155548096,
-0.6560678482055664,
-0.2746847867965698,
-0.5013375282287598,
0.010285631753504276,
0.16850420832633972,
0.39969611167907715,
0.12751173973083496,
-0.010269117541611195,
0.07892697304487228,
0.28725719451904297,
-0.49801376461982727,
-0.1165841668844223,
-0.7845194935798645,
-0.3538190722465515,
-0.2286262810230255,
-0.565009593963623,
-0.45056092739105225,
-0.013797971419990063,
0.22048814594745636,
-0.6129658818244934,
0.474128782749176,
0.1889158934354782,
0.6187809109687805,
0.23812371492385864,
-0.1700850874185562,
-0.3700089752674103,
-0.7159336805343628,
0.6182624697685242,
-0.6016569137573242,
0.11266051232814789,
0.2715168595314026,
-0.2527018189430237,
-0.039845794439315796,
-0.4381802976131439,
-0.80568927526474,
0.06158106029033661,
-0.3597097098827362,
0.007856355980038643,
-0.3718104064464569,
-0.013478200882673264,
0.5426065325737,
0.0486631914973259,
-0.7337782979011536,
0.09547261148691177,
-0.09900932759046555,
-0.12970399856567383,
0.42078933119773865,
0.13724063336849213,
0.31765463948249817,
0.13250188529491425,
-0.31331387162208557,
0.21433378756046295,
-0.9102575182914734,
-0.16080470383167267,
0.014094089157879353,
0.23748034238815308,
0.017004109919071198,
0.7144720554351807,
-0.11621727794408798,
0.4424310624599457,
0.9796829223632812,
0.12124571204185486,
-0.01848725974559784,
-0.48255813121795654,
-0.15878920257091522,
0.6718142032623291,
0.3801705837249756,
0.6483578085899353,
0.22935868799686432,
-0.22710749506950378,
0.14513641595840454,
0.7216571569442749,
0.1729375720024109,
-0.674375593662262,
0.3198103606700897,
0.39926114678382874,
0.04232075437903404,
-0.04760061576962471,
-0.20108629763126373,
-0.4231666624546051,
-0.263248085975647,
-0.6542157530784607,
0.3316141664981842,
-0.5335537195205688,
0.023640692234039307,
-0.2596778869628906,
-0.14404326677322388,
0.23853610455989838,
0.15299606323242188,
-0.2891671061515808,
0.00903697032481432,
0.6191115975379944,
0.5872216820716858,
-0.028943292796611786,
-0.1655285507440567,
-0.5393138527870178,
0.4432941973209381,
-0.30346372723579407,
1.0699948072433472,
-0.8012660145759583,
-0.766273021697998,
-0.1392713189125061,
0.10657493025064468,
-0.1264926642179489,
-0.49676549434661865,
0.8841057419776917,
-0.4488110840320587,
0.06383786350488663,
-0.5291253924369812,
-0.6845645904541016,
-0.1342545747756958,
0.40223580598831177,
-0.3113850951194763,
1.1689924001693726,
-0.24419239163398743,
-0.8481648564338684,
0.6587962508201599,
-0.2767215073108673,
-0.3963842988014221,
0.18180686235427856,
-0.33185115456581116,
-0.2061963975429535,
-0.15013407170772552,
0.33687663078308105,
0.18618248403072357,
-0.2960246205329895,
0.7883238196372986,
-0.5742477178573608,
-0.20830713212490082,
0.14420771598815918,
-0.13520649075508118,
0.23333747684955597,
-0.26498883962631226,
-0.4656248390674591,
0.45446401834487915,
-0.8394269943237305,
-0.520340085029602,
-0.19339874386787415,
0.17406512796878815,
-0.9051800966262817,
-0.04404246807098389,
-0.19905248284339905,
0.6239191293716431,
0.1283436119556427,
-0.6036928296089172,
0.02846779301762581,
-0.23690097033977509,
0.12620234489440918,
0.37615200877189636,
0.22162650525569916,
0.5671579837799072,
-0.4091583788394928,
0.17455004155635834,
0.42452678084373474,
0.13050667941570282,
-0.36509814858436584,
-0.2472253143787384,
-0.8682425022125244,
-0.1366722136735916,
-0.222035750746727,
0.6290081143379211,
-0.696153461933136,
0.7787193655967712,
-0.2379636913537979,
-0.35308101773262024,
-0.052325066179037094,
0.05272882059216499,
0.4294409155845642,
1.1693412065505981,
0.5710708498954773,
-0.1001620665192604,
-1.0418013334274292,
-0.9070650339126587,
-0.3051229417324066,
-0.11724594235420227,
0.14283417165279388,
0.23371663689613342,
0.4902353286743164,
-0.2632777988910675,
1.2056281566619873,
0.028329499065876007,
-0.29746687412261963,
-0.3283807337284088,
0.4059940576553345,
0.21075502038002014,
0.658741295337677,
0.5217416286468506,
-0.6521826386451721,
-0.24778413772583008,
-0.10915153473615646,
-0.6245412230491638,
-0.4695921242237091,
-0.2685765326023102,
-0.1509048193693161,
0.5077685117721558,
0.6398249268531799,
-0.4812775254249573,
0.6974087953567505,
0.12063993513584137,
-0.4522368907928467,
0.5729432702064514,
-0.09710332751274109,
0.27851834893226624,
-0.775323748588562,
0.2709663212299347,
0.168474942445755,
0.010574628598988056,
-0.6058955788612366,
-0.2592078447341919,
0.05449240282177925,
0.2096136510372162,
-0.2194090187549591,
0.49418407678604126,
-0.18068869411945343,
0.23667632043361664,
-0.4153653085231781,
0.4452876150608063,
0.10064800083637238,
0.46525928378105164,
0.3377896845340729,
0.6420456767082214,
0.3796290159225464,
-0.6584328413009644,
0.1705436408519745,
0.23979510366916656,
0.025286972522735596,
1.1382513046264648,
-0.622267484664917,
0.024988573044538498,
-0.18874292075634003,
0.4556070566177368,
-0.7833141684532166,
0.148191899061203,
0.2650012671947479,
-0.22223316133022308,
0.10854963213205338,
-0.19815997779369354,
-0.2692647874355316,
-0.12507693469524384,
-0.2427760511636734,
0.4904101490974426,
0.07107352465391159,
-0.7233856320381165,
0.9036813378334045,
0.2538057267665863,
-0.27072328329086304,
-0.4779896140098572,
-0.5241433382034302,
0.15204133093357086,
-0.305279016494751,
-0.5095517635345459,
0.6169016361236572,
-0.16290932893753052,
-0.36739665269851685,
-0.048844870179891586,
-0.3131236732006073,
0.2610473334789276,
-0.39208289980888367,
0.45972639322280884,
0.6733209490776062,
0.023203440010547638,
-0.05961240828037262,
0.06903889775276184,
-0.28250089287757874,
0.14002563059329987,
-0.1785728633403778,
0.4063648581504822,
0.058356065303087234,
-0.37218424677848816,
0.027847835794091225,
0.5680387020111084,
0.4763394892215729,
0.09087926894426346,
0.604712724685669,
0.2954767346382141,
-0.38668113946914673,
-0.11739735305309296,
-0.9547145366668701,
-0.28888505697250366,
-0.3452053368091583,
0.07867240160703659,
-0.3895871639251709,
-0.7254025936126709,
0.7464777827262878,
-0.023651087656617165,
-0.1538771241903305,
0.48562929034233093,
0.6506809592247009,
0.14306838810443878,
0.7654961347579956,
0.2054421305656433,
-0.11155420541763306,
0.43587610125541687,
-0.04896848276257515,
0.26949042081832886,
-1.0025548934936523,
-0.1814713031053543,
-0.5348972678184509,
0.05489571765065193,
-0.1125202625989914,
-0.6521031260490417,
0.3923584222793579,
0.27730077505111694,
-0.13399221003055573,
0.3491976261138916,
-0.27465492486953735,
0.2834009528160095,
0.38393643498420715,
0.144280806183815,
0.4917592704296112,
-0.3063291013240814,
-0.4034561812877655,
-0.12180858105421066,
-0.7573975324630737,
-0.5056633353233337,
0.7054997682571411,
-0.1925232708454132,
0.48146939277648926,
-0.27180835604667664,
0.2461801916360855,
0.2422136813402176,
0.6055341958999634,
-0.5382530093193054,
0.4573307931423187,
0.0372200645506382,
-0.6440082788467407,
-0.04365576058626175,
0.006891733966767788,
-0.46783867478370667,
0.15799842774868011,
-0.26171639561653137,
-0.7582323551177979,
0.7476861476898193,
0.15161950886249542,
-0.19779105484485626,
0.16662324965000153,
-0.40769681334495544,
0.5344663262367249,
-0.05556320771574974,
-0.6049680113792419,
-0.5168130397796631,
-0.4594828188419342,
0.325818806886673,
-0.12531103193759918,
0.42092445492744446,
0.08106137067079544,
0.14037930965423584,
0.6520317196846008,
-0.45110589265823364,
0.9846293926239014,
0.08856144547462463,
-0.02139146625995636,
0.37051504850387573,
0.05177583917975426,
0.889372706413269,
0.056623026728630066,
-0.13528084754943848,
0.3135201930999756,
-0.1915879249572754,
-0.15305723249912262,
-0.46950915455818176,
0.9318697452545166,
-0.3745359480381012,
-0.6983124613761902,
-0.3177151679992676,
-0.4342445433139801,
-0.26068684458732605,
0.05343875288963318,
0.3927404582500458,
0.7124145030975342,
-0.6024932265281677,
0.09105341881513596,
0.529893696308136,
0.0939270555973053,
0.6542443037033081,
0.907389223575592,
0.17119315266609192,
-0.45341262221336365,
0.4415813088417053,
0.2528423070907593,
-0.055815666913986206,
0.3409299850463867,
0.09799360483884811,
-0.3981553316116333,
-0.4021667242050171,
-0.42567452788352966,
0.1513301432132721,
-0.744099497795105,
-0.16537991166114807,
-0.8111897110939026,
0.09301523864269257,
-0.5415932536125183,
-0.5747066140174866,
0.05058962106704712,
-0.21731489896774292,
-0.3634772002696991,
-0.272175133228302,
0.3614397943019867,
0.09643619507551193,
-0.1923370659351349,
0.3694116175174713,
-0.8221405744552612,
0.14592574536800385,
-0.09067068248987198,
0.0924355760216713,
-0.23285022377967834,
-0.7611809372901917,
-0.2519681453704834,
-0.26522576808929443,
-0.10308967530727386,
-0.7945197820663452,
0.3703027665615082,
0.007059188559651375,
0.7694461941719055,
0.49194955825805664,
0.337266743183136,
0.8335287570953369,
-0.29067355394363403,
0.6003727912902832,
0.19555552303791046,
-1.0625337362289429,
0.7090100049972534,
-0.37989774346351624,
0.07632160931825638,
0.5114148855209351,
0.3591266870498657,
-0.49857255816459656,
-0.41112640500068665,
-0.8906057476997375,
-0.9608224630355835,
0.6946898698806763,
-0.12553060054779053,
-0.47962018847465515,
-0.15291962027549744,
0.3523917496204376,
0.03778718411922455,
0.02259281650185585,
-0.3523450195789337,
-0.198505237698555,
-0.11466848105192184,
-0.04181184247136116,
-0.10415905714035034,
-0.29089492559432983,
-0.3281731903553009,
-0.05758504197001457,
1.0252143144607544,
-0.319690465927124,
-0.47989317774772644,
0.8252778649330139,
-0.5235295295715332,
-0.5187802910804749,
0.5144076347351074,
0.6346758008003235,
0.7371456623077393,
-0.16476230323314667,
0.20080815255641937,
0.3240954577922821,
-0.1969415843486786,
-0.041306622326374054,
0.1991313397884369,
-0.4040808081626892,
0.07787803560495377,
0.4579578638076782,
0.547264039516449,
0.4964049458503723,
-0.6019142866134644,
0.3012975752353668,
0.2835127115249634,
-0.036450501531362534,
-0.14283709228038788,
-0.17824684083461761,
-0.17504268884658813,
0.1473013013601303,
0.5438016653060913,
0.0019354147370904684,
0.1174655333161354,
-0.441336065530777,
0.5028859972953796,
0.43930312991142273,
-0.3794091045856476,
-0.3447224497795105,
0.21319271624088287,
0.4055422246456146,
0.12652088701725006,
-0.01772356405854225,
0.05336882919073105,
-0.7115070223808289,
0.5792730450630188,
0.6317727565765381,
0.7678127288818359,
-0.21952226758003235,
-0.0740213692188263,
0.716354250907898,
0.4614267647266388,
0.07192524522542953,
0.2206641435623169,
-0.03211075812578201,
-0.9632577896118164,
-0.6020464897155762,
-0.3342335522174835,
-0.5189640522003174,
0.20298247039318085,
-0.6123103499412537,
0.36951544880867004,
-0.26617398858070374,
-0.21210457384586334,
-0.045291509479284286,
-0.05076491832733154,
-0.4635648727416992,
0.20437437295913696,
0.11661276966333389,
0.896884560585022,
-0.8590542674064636,
0.8824995756149292,
0.702021598815918,
-0.4276614487171173,
-0.48021405935287476,
-0.3045814335346222,
0.16009610891342163,
-0.5140018463134766,
0.5877608060836792,
-0.14674116671085358,
-0.1693931519985199,
-0.2162199765443802,
-0.34440603852272034,
-0.5891858339309692,
0.8091104626655579,
0.03765925019979477,
-1.016321063041687,
0.1169431135058403,
0.1078118234872818,
0.40061718225479126,
-0.7220406532287598,
0.40326419472694397,
0.7734307646751404,
0.6705971360206604,
0.1816791296005249,
-0.7550418972969055,
0.520929753780365,
-0.07454285025596619,
-0.26777905225753784,
0.11799019575119019,
-0.3577745258808136,
0.34678351879119873,
-0.0534498356282711,
-0.2194107323884964,
-0.26054930686950684,
0.3853120803833008,
0.4864893853664398,
0.6916418075561523,
0.6311182975769043,
0.7194114923477173,
0.3435991704463959,
-0.03901221230626106,
0.6566495299339294,
-0.6489030122756958,
0.1279461830854416,
1.3902387619018555,
-0.6764853000640869,
0.49019792675971985,
0.8731703758239746,
-0.0026223291642963886,
0.5337358117103577,
0.40170928835868835,
0.17489394545555115,
0.25434252619743347,
-0.24657565355300903,
-0.24936379492282867,
-0.6026222705841064,
-0.6009688973426819,
-0.2110612988471985,
0.04738139361143112,
0.7756935358047485,
-0.3358640968799591,
-0.4778306782245636,
-0.1765214502811432,
-0.004138842690736055,
0.10499659180641174,
-0.42101460695266724,
0.803309977054596,
0.10692653059959412,
-0.6476514339447021,
0.12575054168701172,
-0.19651907682418823,
0.8249125480651855,
-0.42265838384628296,
0.0753050222992897,
-0.13072694838047028,
0.21266135573387146,
-0.25686967372894287,
-0.35222911834716797,
0.600596010684967,
0.05950336530804634,
-0.6030373573303223,
0.01754121482372284,
1.0301014184951782,
-0.507704496383667,
-0.44099342823028564,
0.5453104972839355,
0.576265811920166,
-0.358041912317276,
-0.11038344353437424,
-0.445218563079834,
0.023450642824172974,
-0.41998693346977234,
-0.15836219489574432,
0.2548719048500061,
0.4011467397212982,
-0.41223326325416565,
0.17588883638381958,
0.8913074135780334,
0.037759631872177124,
-0.28894543647766113,
0.3195449113845825,
1.0222853422164917,
-0.6887254118919373,
-0.6430206298828125,
-0.9248756766319275,
0.2630523145198822,
-0.2387343794107437,
-0.33332279324531555,
0.6153419613838196,
0.5344447493553162,
0.7010441422462463,
0.2513054311275482,
0.837639331817627,
-0.04522988945245743,
0.5913832187652588,
-0.20987318456172943,
0.059954363852739334,
-0.14078521728515625,
0.3420097529888153,
-0.34733593463897705,
-0.4948097765445709,
-0.22703932225704193,
0.16089242696762085,
-0.716738224029541,
-0.25838854908943176,
0.7150720953941345,
1.045202374458313,
0.11782476305961609,
0.1954520344734192,
0.39979591965675354,
0.3456996977329254,
0.12665560841560364,
0.4462665021419525,
0.785851240158081,
-0.18637968599796295,
0.4958072304725647,
-0.1851499080657959,
-0.39560467004776,
-0.4769637882709503,
-1.0503169298171997,
-0.9063680768013,
-0.5503380298614502,
-0.5144284963607788,
-0.39607343077659607,
0.14563065767288208,
1.117856502532959,
0.5280592441558838,
-0.9567396640777588,
0.22346919775009155,
-0.18833699822425842,
0.24339795112609863,
-0.16952374577522278,
-0.2535184919834137,
0.24090853333473206,
-0.23429445922374725,
-0.5529224276542664,
0.4608824849128723,
0.5259613394737244,
-0.16751714050769806,
0.03898249566555023,
0.026174208149313927,
-0.35785406827926636,
0.4918521046638489,
0.6596008539199829,
0.190407857298851,
-0.7563865184783936,
-0.31560012698173523,
-0.1263096034526825,
-0.13130447268486023,
-0.008219528943300247,
1.4738516807556152,
-0.9309754371643066,
0.09719837456941605,
0.5608087778091431,
0.2762962579727173,
0.3561241030693054,
0.15703846514225006,
0.6325008273124695,
-0.6828916072845459,
0.18051530420780182,
0.0522087961435318,
0.5847381949424744,
0.17299439013004303,
-0.7088776230812073,
0.3989673852920532,
0.5581255555152893,
-0.3249534070491791,
-0.6772608757019043,
0.10572672635316849,
-1.2381993532180786,
-0.33019885420799255,
0.9346249103546143,
-0.07609353214502335,
-0.08175473660230637,
-0.6612785458564758,
-0.221283957362175,
0.41160061955451965,
-0.47537484765052795,
0.6518980264663696,
0.7680773138999939,
-0.4338078200817108,
-0.13534687459468842,
0.3171437978744507,
0.20363293588161469,
0.46916666626930237,
-0.675471305847168,
0.21875758469104767,
0.6981474161148071,
0.21575909852981567,
0.35910311341285706,
0.5247019529342651,
-0.2068556696176529,
0.2404119372367859,
0.060596950352191925,
0.17048755288124084,
-0.08653166145086288,
-0.16522216796875,
-0.3143872022628784,
0.10471215099096298,
-0.3739238977432251,
0.3219301104545593
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.