id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03865v1
|
FFN-SkipLLM: A Hidden Gem for Autoregressive Decoding with Adaptive Feed Forward Skipping
| 2024-04-05T02:35:43 | 2024-04-05T02:35:43 |
Ajay Jaiswal, Bodun Hu, Lu Yin, Yeonju Ro, Shiwei Liu, Tianlong Chen, Aditya Akella
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Autoregressive Large Language Models (e.g., LLaMa, GPTs) are omnipresent
achieving remarkable success in language understanding and generation. However,
such impressive capability typically comes with a substantial model size, which
presents significant challenges for autoregressive token-by-token generation.
To mitigate computation overload incurred during generation, several early-exit
and layer-dropping strategies have been proposed. Despite some promising
success due to the redundancy across LLMs layers on metrics like Rough-L/BLUE,
our careful knowledge-intensive evaluation unveils issues such as generation
collapse, hallucination of wrong facts, and noticeable performance drop even at
the trivial exit ratio of 10-15% of layers. We attribute these errors primarily
to ineffective handling of the KV cache through state copying during
early-exit. In this work, we observed the saturation of computationally
expensive feed-forward blocks of LLM layers and proposed FFN-SkipLLM, which is
a novel fine-grained skip strategy of autoregressive LLMs. More specifically,
FFN-SkipLLM is an input-adaptive feed-forward skipping strategy that can skip
25-30% of FFN blocks of LLMs with marginal change in performance on
knowledge-intensive generation tasks without any requirement to handle KV
cache. Our extensive experiments and ablation across benchmarks like MT-Bench,
Factoid-QA, and variable-length text summarization illustrate how our simple
and ease-at-use method can facilitate faster autoregressive decoding.
|
[
-0.41290050745010376,
-0.7386184930801392,
0.31692448258399963,
0.6067631840705872,
-0.2176811844110489,
0.46589988470077515,
0.08509604632854462,
-0.2364792674779892,
-0.2882451117038727,
0.24369142949581146,
-0.6662938594818115,
-0.2449425905942917,
-0.7110041975975037,
-0.04638654366135597,
-0.6405598521232605,
0.7024654746055603,
-0.22517763078212738,
-0.08446439355611801,
0.010378421284258366,
0.18961907923221588,
-0.493191123008728,
-0.20320063829421997,
-0.9281965494155884,
-0.46345755457878113,
0.3356010913848877,
0.22254277765750885,
0.5992347598075867,
1.222136378288269,
0.21031254529953003,
0.17650768160820007,
-0.2560352087020874,
0.3084510862827301,
-0.49332374334335327,
0.05421542003750801,
0.027754386886954308,
-0.18100835382938385,
-0.5976448059082031,
-0.21172289550304413,
0.7443933486938477,
0.5823073983192444,
-0.2868060767650604,
-0.14119119942188263,
0.23958787322044373,
0.8779473304748535,
-0.8582178950309753,
0.2959401309490204,
-0.6016238331794739,
0.322658509016037,
-0.26948055624961853,
-0.3604949116706848,
-0.4316219389438629,
-0.19918417930603027,
-0.22657635807991028,
-0.4326205253601074,
0.0406586118042469,
-0.060976702719926834,
0.49897924065589905,
0.47282296419143677,
-0.2455466240644455,
-0.37158241868019104,
-0.8906247615814209,
0.6994463801383972,
-0.6459140777587891,
0.5904198884963989,
0.3609689176082611,
-0.036054473370313644,
-0.27906695008277893,
-0.3879730701446533,
-0.40223413705825806,
0.14944666624069214,
0.06677252799272537,
0.1352299451828003,
-0.29298490285873413,
-0.08744167536497116,
0.033006854355335236,
0.5444340109825134,
-0.6405530571937561,
0.20859797298908234,
-0.14303503930568695,
-0.4352911114692688,
0.3795437812805176,
0.32754749059677124,
-0.06128057837486267,
-0.20945124328136444,
-0.4111015200614929,
-0.007706713397055864,
-0.8727202415466309,
-0.13652709126472473,
0.3683285713195801,
0.20668861269950867,
0.1139177531003952,
0.18213017284870148,
-0.31692200899124146,
0.6573621034622192,
0.16884221136569977,
0.24930162727832794,
0.11367250978946686,
-0.5598371028900146,
-0.40363630652427673,
0.042228732258081436,
0.8322128057479858,
-0.05944577604532242,
0.05152974650263786,
-0.20614083111286163,
-0.2734714448451996,
-0.3564416766166687,
-0.06802871823310852,
-0.8156848549842834,
-0.5791251063346863,
0.19400814175605774,
-0.40905502438545227,
-0.3816206157207489,
-0.4762592613697052,
-0.4571627974510193,
-0.1428036093711853,
0.2447364628314972,
0.3526957333087921,
-0.7108995318412781,
-0.23425287008285522,
0.10269299894571304,
0.19639676809310913,
0.4753379821777344,
0.49108561873435974,
-0.7712497711181641,
0.29918041825294495,
0.6853145956993103,
0.9219157695770264,
-0.2725810408592224,
-0.43760058283805847,
-0.8839709162712097,
-0.06859840452671051,
-0.527296245098114,
0.45580437779426575,
-0.22388803958892822,
-0.7157358527183533,
-0.3640035092830658,
-0.14728131890296936,
-0.15829458832740784,
-0.4334898889064789,
0.2974143326282501,
-0.6795669794082642,
-0.0054341210052371025,
-0.32020068168640137,
-0.3909454047679901,
-0.1644027680158615,
0.09718664735555649,
-0.5638418793678284,
0.8480569124221802,
-0.0412118174135685,
-0.5343562364578247,
0.38745370507240295,
-0.38265079259872437,
-0.6559433341026306,
-0.04015953466296196,
0.04483494162559509,
-0.13516324758529663,
0.2566611170768738,
0.4893490672111511,
0.5447867512702942,
-0.3101383149623871,
0.12341724336147308,
-0.004811832215636969,
-0.37713295221328735,
0.1501801311969757,
-0.7933154702186584,
0.6561324000358582,
0.504652202129364,
-0.2916056215763092,
-0.27430763840675354,
-0.8416348099708557,
-0.1658344864845276,
0.321402370929718,
-0.532963216304779,
-0.24748149514198303,
0.06979946047067642,
-0.15554454922676086,
0.36676380038261414,
0.18072445690631866,
-0.2803012728691101,
-0.011958467774093151,
-0.3166133761405945,
0.29048869013786316,
0.9281995892524719,
-0.050267674028873444,
0.5211472511291504,
-0.3215796947479248,
0.41540685296058655,
0.22712549567222595,
0.19437506794929504,
-0.8207483291625977,
-0.20930816233158112,
-0.896806538105011,
-0.21260355412960052,
0.3593101501464844,
0.5931805968284607,
-0.7012080550193787,
0.27064162492752075,
0.030258767306804657,
-0.18270187079906464,
-0.577673614025116,
0.4181402325630188,
0.585060715675354,
0.6944248676300049,
0.489766001701355,
-0.3522469401359558,
-0.22024354338645935,
-0.7161950469017029,
-0.2800784111022949,
-0.2765118479728699,
0.29404300451278687,
0.21063324809074402,
0.2133917510509491,
-0.18801264464855194,
0.9477795362472534,
-0.4402901232242584,
-0.22032524645328522,
0.014396070502698421,
0.2520602345466614,
0.08677470684051514,
0.7152596712112427,
0.23510529100894928,
-0.42045050859451294,
-0.22462739050388336,
0.029041975736618042,
-0.5321833491325378,
-0.07908739149570465,
-0.2937721312046051,
-0.16516579687595367,
0.5148035883903503,
0.42524784803390503,
-0.453217089176178,
0.2572946548461914,
0.26568594574928284,
-0.21976527571678162,
0.4923516511917114,
-0.16525013744831085,
0.06883744150400162,
-0.7266741394996643,
0.13122498989105225,
-0.28664129972457886,
-0.3264981508255005,
-0.4610568583011627,
-0.07291845977306366,
0.22337442636489868,
0.32686862349510193,
-0.5183171629905701,
0.6330389380455017,
-0.5761725306510925,
-0.11185111850500107,
-0.39529937505722046,
-0.2891894280910492,
0.10315336287021637,
0.489715039730072,
-0.0061540985479950905,
0.7955694794654846,
0.3761686086654663,
-0.6176888942718506,
0.16515949368476868,
0.04202037677168846,
0.17595206201076508,
0.059771861881017685,
-0.2652187645435333,
0.19800813496112823,
-0.15664519369602203,
0.14343225955963135,
-0.8256778120994568,
0.01860763505101204,
0.350006639957428,
-0.4650101065635681,
0.6396093368530273,
-0.32794731855392456,
-0.4504959285259247,
-0.2676589787006378,
-0.276957243680954,
0.5268986225128174,
0.635711669921875,
-0.6223375201225281,
0.5751457214355469,
0.01188911683857441,
-0.20951758325099945,
-0.9193875789642334,
-0.9863365292549133,
0.12895341217517853,
0.01932382583618164,
-0.44135212898254395,
-0.08376841247081757,
-0.23383383452892303,
0.10684024542570114,
0.10266336053609848,
-0.27139022946357727,
0.07856003940105438,
0.25196847319602966,
-0.01631254516541958,
0.06459071487188339,
-0.3878882825374603,
-0.28870248794555664,
0.36556732654571533,
-0.16742029786109924,
0.28063565492630005,
-0.5880990624427795,
0.7309199571609497,
-0.32056349515914917,
-0.3713877499103546,
-0.14228323101997375,
0.2361447513103485,
0.3606488108634949,
-0.03303145989775658,
0.5764569044113159,
0.6691421270370483,
-0.334636390209198,
-0.3836827278137207,
-0.48927536606788635,
0.08033847063779831,
-0.4908074140548706,
0.3865755498409271,
-0.1378423571586609,
-0.725189745426178,
0.7849353551864624,
-0.03650433570146561,
0.2652595341205597,
0.45574110746383667,
0.5196076035499573,
-0.005426020361483097,
0.6080160737037659,
0.3008563220500946,
-0.06701021641492844,
0.20058177411556244,
-0.29911181330680847,
-0.1685405969619751,
-0.7736676335334778,
-0.24886323511600494,
-0.1873343288898468,
-0.09067503362894058,
-0.06121106073260307,
-0.7412527799606323,
-0.21977423131465912,
0.41176825761795044,
-0.1376982033252716,
0.048105597496032715,
-0.25836554169654846,
0.46269989013671875,
0.14936715364456177,
-0.28458312153816223,
0.556729257106781,
-0.0956081748008728,
-0.28823935985565186,
0.10496846586465836,
-1.0275250673294067,
0.03909018263220787,
0.9099093079566956,
0.5071835517883301,
0.9850797057151794,
-0.21805371344089508,
0.8365179300308228,
0.6570859551429749,
0.18887799978256226,
-0.7265111207962036,
0.49483534693717957,
-0.3110852539539337,
-0.14472292363643646,
-0.21626406908035278,
-0.6170195937156677,
-0.5813507437705994,
0.22943449020385742,
0.11104442179203033,
-0.31140610575675964,
0.465124249458313,
0.5285248756408691,
-0.4737023413181305,
0.42955082654953003,
-0.41226133704185486,
0.6251040697097778,
-0.10451530665159225,
-0.3594316244125366,
0.015157932415604591,
-0.4380030930042267,
0.7026644945144653,
-0.3912229537963867,
0.21620586514472961,
0.008887793868780136,
-0.07226352393627167,
0.591672420501709,
-0.5860521197319031,
0.46579331159591675,
-0.25544503331184387,
-0.3374983072280884,
0.1683051735162735,
0.49809229373931885,
0.7456954717636108,
0.050548192113637924,
0.09281360357999802,
0.1922229528427124,
-0.5432953238487244,
-0.35378775000572205,
-0.40655526518821716,
0.9433640837669373,
-0.6369377374649048,
-0.2950341999530792,
-0.40202850103378296,
-0.45770981907844543,
-0.21457026898860931,
0.22769182920455933,
0.35817059874534607,
0.5196442604064941,
-0.23941649496555328,
-0.1059575155377388,
0.9558960199356079,
-0.2608136236667633,
0.8486441373825073,
0.5882452726364136,
-0.3254855275154114,
-0.4310224652290344,
1.1700737476348877,
0.12310124188661575,
0.25845617055892944,
0.34605154395103455,
0.05678841844201088,
-0.315100759267807,
-1.0103235244750977,
-0.6438688039779663,
0.1220521479845047,
-0.7908663749694824,
-0.4477195739746094,
-1.0039769411087036,
-0.6324445009231567,
-0.13491268455982208,
-0.30641964077949524,
-0.7006280422210693,
-0.43553346395492554,
-0.47287097573280334,
-0.0053620776161551476,
0.38558411598205566,
0.6501805186271667,
-0.35528266429901123,
0.4215543568134308,
-0.9323391914367676,
0.12147359549999237,
0.2029728889465332,
0.3584814965724945,
0.6219750046730042,
-0.47250136733055115,
-0.4170728623867035,
-0.2881051301956177,
-0.10547830909490585,
-0.5871008634567261,
0.4712277948856354,
0.14131268858909607,
0.495678573846817,
0.3814750611782074,
-0.016771811991930008,
0.7261937260627747,
-0.3964186906814575,
0.5478755235671997,
0.10166028887033463,
-1.0787369012832642,
0.38954758644104004,
-0.4898923635482788,
0.5451407432556152,
0.3199862837791443,
0.18443581461906433,
-0.4031476378440857,
-0.5105253458023071,
-0.27962958812713623,
-1.2806270122528076,
1.0953280925750732,
0.3263256847858429,
-0.19881653785705566,
-0.1557784229516983,
0.3169330656528473,
0.24763675034046173,
0.08905596286058426,
-0.4442022144794464,
-0.34938177466392517,
-0.3689138889312744,
0.048600584268569946,
0.08295155316591263,
-0.24395379424095154,
0.199501633644104,
0.13593095541000366,
0.7751280665397644,
-0.08884546905755997,
0.33823421597480774,
0.23152011632919312,
-0.5170855522155762,
-0.1879725158214569,
0.21500760316848755,
0.5851752758026123,
0.3688916265964508,
-0.2067781388759613,
-0.07115477323532104,
0.3131832778453827,
-0.6874139904975891,
0.1502992957830429,
0.1863592267036438,
-0.3456677496433258,
-0.20231062173843384,
0.327337384223938,
0.8844120502471924,
0.1334444284439087,
-0.2978416681289673,
0.21521620452404022,
-0.2894333004951477,
-0.40581631660461426,
-0.16803179681301117,
0.19309447705745697,
0.1496330052614212,
0.1734665185213089,
0.8867443799972534,
0.24691073596477509,
0.12817542254924774,
-0.15326716005802155,
0.3247770071029663,
0.27768808603286743,
-0.2961568832397461,
-0.2507399320602417,
0.6701963543891907,
0.26592451333999634,
-0.16224156320095062,
0.589581310749054,
-0.24653205275535583,
-0.24967853724956512,
0.49437564611434937,
0.4856334626674652,
1.1278386116027832,
-0.2477649748325348,
0.05561307817697525,
-0.025913739576935768,
0.5388518571853638,
-0.27991431951522827,
0.1580815613269806,
-0.32790499925613403,
-0.598236083984375,
-0.6754100322723389,
-0.9629696607589722,
-0.10219531506299973,
0.30926430225372314,
-0.6413341164588928,
-0.02626284770667553,
-0.604357123374939,
0.23223327100276947,
-0.43961527943611145,
-0.08506544679403305,
-0.6181212663650513,
0.23492668569087982,
0.27379918098449707,
1.1489201784133911,
-0.6746357679367065,
0.844917356967926,
0.22239802777767181,
0.10357281565666199,
-0.7075841426849365,
0.24612444639205933,
0.07087596505880356,
-0.8096628189086914,
0.6566897630691528,
-0.25625771284103394,
-0.33495640754699707,
0.10644228756427765,
-0.09215223044157028,
-0.8991232514381409,
1.1215415000915527,
0.14448262751102448,
-0.5140124559402466,
-0.22640018165111542,
-0.10043832659721375,
0.08483274281024933,
-0.4400922358036041,
0.11400402337312698,
0.7349247336387634,
0.4324585497379303,
0.41249141097068787,
-0.7405064702033997,
0.32291948795318604,
-0.2004609853029251,
0.06013140082359314,
0.3846781551837921,
-0.8071592450141907,
0.9202257990837097,
-0.09684642404317856,
-0.14596663415431976,
0.10884783416986465,
0.804267942905426,
0.0588991604745388,
0.2223520427942276,
0.5119985938072205,
0.27301302552223206,
0.48494160175323486,
-0.06301603466272354,
0.7339984178543091,
-0.251102477312088,
0.21077653765678406,
0.9809072017669678,
-0.10977260768413544,
0.6133177876472473,
0.2871437966823578,
-0.0016006957739591599,
-0.03702354058623314,
0.5743107199668884,
0.19919605553150177,
0.6210061311721802,
0.08439187705516815,
-0.06394476443529129,
-0.26641857624053955,
0.3956637382507324,
-0.3624621629714966,
0.46975094079971313,
0.5694416761398315,
-0.40322569012641907,
-0.45477500557899475,
0.05869119614362717,
0.13426537811756134,
-0.2918643653392792,
-0.48601093888282776,
0.718100368976593,
0.1538313925266266,
-0.3941337466239929,
0.7100472450256348,
-0.0007929596467874944,
0.8865363597869873,
-0.6641809344291687,
0.14350689947605133,
-0.5693473815917969,
0.040530651807785034,
-0.1847202330827713,
-0.6497543454170227,
0.54805588722229,
0.028186319395899773,
-0.3334757387638092,
-0.4637269079685211,
0.8661813139915466,
-0.34123000502586365,
-0.33553192019462585,
0.44587329030036926,
0.6990997195243835,
-0.028722163289785385,
0.2540956139564514,
-0.6755993962287903,
0.26612451672554016,
0.015316617675125599,
-0.4391637444496155,
0.39712607860565186,
0.36274030804634094,
0.0549265593290329,
0.6343064308166504,
0.8155685663223267,
0.23774969577789307,
0.25882160663604736,
-0.2382163554430008,
0.9462243318557739,
-0.8511723279953003,
-0.6486710906028748,
-1.0334892272949219,
0.22417132556438446,
0.28886425495147705,
-0.046204984188079834,
0.7574687600135803,
0.6707440614700317,
0.7215153574943542,
0.18148060142993927,
0.7276173233985901,
0.18133635818958282,
0.08979400992393494,
-0.8682349324226379,
0.9696581363677979,
-0.5632517337799072,
0.5435289144515991,
-0.3890269100666046,
-0.7879318594932556,
-0.12406182289123535,
0.315754234790802,
0.15533758699893951,
0.07341568917036057,
0.4393429756164551,
0.48031169176101685,
-0.049532450735569,
-0.04566637799143791,
0.28282251954078674,
0.5334535837173462,
0.2501290738582611,
0.6823317408561707,
0.9427235722541809,
-0.4296867549419403,
0.6328033804893494,
-0.05047871544957161,
-0.1478240042924881,
-0.2909089922904968,
-0.9909788966178894,
-0.5381196141242981,
-0.30723342299461365,
-0.431854248046875,
-0.3960610330104828,
0.21342283487319946,
0.6514341831207275,
0.6515806913375854,
-0.5235661268234253,
-0.13732554018497467,
-0.23350125551223755,
0.23924510180950165,
-0.15364111959934235,
-0.2317008078098297,
0.23910140991210938,
-0.35389280319213867,
-0.49219268560409546,
0.6753564476966858,
0.5989150404930115,
0.16157923638820648,
-0.5130792260169983,
-0.3351229429244995,
-0.07602699100971222,
0.29995742440223694,
0.4620041251182556,
0.6411705613136292,
-0.5704822540283203,
0.26462700963020325,
0.1663488745689392,
-0.04968002066016197,
0.07856138050556183,
0.8560528755187988,
-1.0588185787200928,
0.1990160048007965,
0.5710413455963135,
0.7524487972259521,
0.6159113645553589,
-0.16376803815364838,
0.7210627794265747,
-0.654589831829071,
-0.01854344829916954,
0.187238872051239,
0.28508642315864563,
0.3674747943878174,
-0.5924742221832275,
0.1587040275335312,
0.2526318430900574,
-0.41735512018203735,
-0.901661217212677,
0.11800428479909897,
-0.7849954962730408,
-0.27240851521492004,
0.9916279315948486,
-0.11775277554988861,
-0.44775110483169556,
-0.27234092354774475,
0.21657408773899078,
0.00811376515775919,
-0.6284408569335938,
0.456749826669693,
0.7923065423965454,
-0.1768174022436142,
-0.3275018334388733,
-0.3114498555660248,
0.7130032777786255,
0.4112369120121002,
-0.41046711802482605,
0.5059501528739929,
0.44506844878196716,
0.20250605046749115,
-0.019318347796797752,
1.007279872894287,
-0.22892481088638306,
0.5025026798248291,
0.002736620604991913,
-0.24256432056427002,
-0.7113353610038757,
-0.4380852282047272,
-0.758405864238739,
0.1297168880701065,
0.10100571811199188,
-0.22353488206863403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03862v1
|
Verifiable by Design: Aligning Language Models to Quote from Pre-Training Data
| 2024-04-05T02:27:09 | 2024-04-05T02:27:09 |
Jingyu Zhang, Marc Marone, Tianjian Li, Benjamin Van Durme, Daniel Khashabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For humans to trust the fluent generations of large language models (LLMs),
they must be able to verify their correctness against trusted, external
sources. Recent efforts aim to increase verifiability through citations of
retrieved documents or post-hoc provenance. However, such citations are prone
to mistakes that further complicate their verifiability. To address these
limitations, we tackle the verifiability goal with a different philosophy: we
trivialize the verification process by developing models that quote verbatim
statements from trusted sources in pre-training data. We propose Quote-Tuning,
which demonstrates the feasibility of aligning LLMs to leverage memorized
information and quote from pre-training data. Quote-Tuning quantifies quoting
against large corpora with efficient membership inference tools, and uses the
amount of quotes as an implicit reward signal to construct a synthetic
preference dataset for quoting, without any human annotation. Next, the target
model is aligned to quote using preference optimization algorithms.
Experimental results show that Quote-Tuning significantly increases the
percentage of LLM generation quoted verbatim from high-quality pre-training
documents by 55% to 130% relative to untuned models while maintaining response
quality. Further experiments demonstrate that Quote-Tuning generalizes quoting
to out-of-domain data, is applicable in different tasks, and provides
additional benefits to truthfulness. Quote-Tuning not only serves as a
hassle-free method to increase quoting but also opens up avenues for improving
LLM trustworthiness through better verifiability.
|
[
-0.13319183886051178,
-0.44011935591697693,
0.6652061939239502,
-0.06282345950603485,
-0.41589805483818054,
0.24715973436832428,
-0.4579000771045685,
-0.4293559789657593,
0.04800955206155777,
0.690421462059021,
-0.6256029009819031,
-0.3547337055206299,
-0.41579097509384155,
-0.005367835517972708,
-0.20649531483650208,
1.0290333032608032,
-0.004189094994217157,
0.10799054056406021,
-0.3229953348636627,
-0.027538727968931198,
-0.38024240732192993,
-0.7195279002189636,
-0.5044752359390259,
-0.328255832195282,
0.4505838453769684,
0.2827145755290985,
0.9112313389778137,
0.873328685760498,
0.5733786821365356,
0.2540970742702484,
0.11741507053375244,
0.3264729082584381,
-0.5024399161338806,
0.30807745456695557,
-0.32320436835289,
-0.730488121509552,
-0.26570984721183777,
0.2089472860097885,
0.5525717735290527,
0.23899297416210175,
-0.15285858511924744,
0.09056925028562546,
-0.007095552980899811,
0.6615585088729858,
-0.601447343826294,
-0.028295427560806274,
-1.1777325868606567,
-0.13564082980155945,
-0.35020434856414795,
-0.2528257369995117,
-0.47458404302597046,
-0.7385001182556152,
0.006341391243040562,
-0.5863848924636841,
0.15233835577964783,
0.36338892579078674,
1.2501178979873657,
0.49084195494651794,
-0.24910396337509155,
-0.41993221640586853,
-0.6417249441146851,
0.8694344758987427,
-0.705507218837738,
0.29175838828086853,
0.6440402865409851,
0.36600327491760254,
-0.05982688441872597,
-0.5958696007728577,
-0.5266216397285461,
-0.3415510356426239,
-0.2635583281517029,
-0.04131033271551132,
0.00599559536203742,
-0.19687128067016602,
0.2597169876098633,
0.4894832968711853,
-0.5020064115524292,
0.14074228703975677,
-0.026430170983076096,
-0.4056234657764435,
0.5568140149116516,
-0.16853514313697815,
0.11482618749141693,
0.04091633856296539,
-0.44695860147476196,
-0.16051211953163147,
-1.013715386390686,
-0.2149617075920105,
0.4813195765018463,
0.40595245361328125,
0.03383500501513481,
0.7015103101730347,
-0.12620432674884796,
0.5248133540153503,
-0.018426835536956787,
0.2408730834722519,
0.17089740931987762,
-0.5806072354316711,
-0.2598809003829956,
0.11920977383852005,
0.6646458506584167,
0.26890313625335693,
0.5913581252098083,
-0.2783793807029724,
-0.16904671490192413,
0.2286006212234497,
0.6051204800605774,
-0.486406534910202,
-0.12422459572553635,
0.04929245635867119,
0.00885971449315548,
-0.5013713836669922,
-0.05069088190793991,
-0.3892565369606018,
-0.3514656722545624,
-0.523148238658905,
0.5351050496101379,
-0.39963656663894653,
-0.056598737835884094,
0.13839156925678253,
-0.01198103092610836,
0.18720422685146332,
0.2908608913421631,
-0.9136658906936646,
-0.14580179750919342,
0.7775744795799255,
0.7440769076347351,
0.026770025491714478,
-0.1837804764509201,
-0.44309133291244507,
0.4128653407096863,
-0.48311030864715576,
0.8681257963180542,
-0.5013961791992188,
-0.2243698537349701,
0.33488404750823975,
-0.12844891846179962,
0.11006058752536774,
-0.28362053632736206,
1.11726713180542,
-0.6319419145584106,
0.16785134375095367,
-0.5824156999588013,
-0.6912572979927063,
0.35688260197639465,
0.35487690567970276,
-0.5365538001060486,
1.0686454772949219,
-0.06918367743492126,
-0.739351749420166,
0.6608868837356567,
-0.3386571705341339,
-0.40873923897743225,
-0.06219227984547615,
-0.3861675560474396,
-0.5085508823394775,
0.23407723009586334,
0.18014182150363922,
0.22799572348594666,
-0.482284814119339,
0.24982485175132751,
-0.3940788209438324,
-0.17934556305408478,
0.5047922730445862,
-0.3503973186016083,
0.5816014409065247,
0.4747360050678253,
-0.06592161953449249,
0.14792878925800323,
-0.6296516060829163,
0.24117140471935272,
0.09717989712953568,
-0.35985809564590454,
-0.46714577078819275,
-0.09507566690444946,
-0.11313790082931519,
0.0853915736079216,
0.4431877136230469,
-0.5174475908279419,
0.13821662962436676,
-0.6073113679885864,
0.4517190754413605,
1.0302748680114746,
-0.2898080050945282,
0.3585560917854309,
-0.6383622288703918,
0.2628023028373718,
-0.09253055602312088,
0.1591298133134842,
0.006876208819448948,
0.060001201927661896,
-0.71468186378479,
-0.42200174927711487,
0.18934985995292664,
0.2932635247707367,
-0.5548990368843079,
0.7319762110710144,
-0.5827955603599548,
-0.4317956864833832,
-0.5693965554237366,
0.39761778712272644,
0.43543076515197754,
0.8042067289352417,
0.3924766480922699,
-0.14292800426483154,
-0.7858269214630127,
-0.9037920236587524,
-0.5136866569519043,
-0.4470140337944031,
-0.19146943092346191,
0.23819534480571747,
0.2023402750492096,
0.05384969711303711,
1.0585964918136597,
-0.5550098419189453,
-0.04973996430635452,
-0.016969723626971245,
0.060725074261426926,
0.028743039816617966,
0.618783175945282,
0.38981136679649353,
-0.5920525193214417,
-0.49359580874443054,
-0.002302497159689665,
-0.7941427826881409,
-0.11909671127796173,
0.004656669683754444,
-0.5840891003608704,
0.15240487456321716,
0.5305849313735962,
-0.6138318777084351,
0.10924912989139557,
0.24358639121055603,
-0.11573418974876404,
0.3718826472759247,
-0.37534695863723755,
0.1727409064769745,
-1.2765476703643799,
-0.09888384491205215,
-0.05433335527777672,
-0.5000535249710083,
-0.19210827350616455,
-0.099094457924366,
0.16592364013195038,
0.12251704931259155,
-0.12397409975528717,
0.3393501043319702,
-0.35885563492774963,
0.2350902557373047,
-0.3290611803531647,
0.053536541759967804,
0.21236000955104828,
0.13320642709732056,
0.024404630064964294,
0.9610697031021118,
0.4683687686920166,
-0.4589356482028961,
0.06039346009492874,
0.395529180765152,
-0.7334344983100891,
0.8740671873092651,
-0.7825890183448792,
0.3312292993068695,
0.02547168731689453,
0.06537769734859467,
-0.9106685519218445,
-0.1387345939874649,
0.029033305123448372,
-0.2857624590396881,
0.3140128254890442,
-0.23599833250045776,
-0.5485239624977112,
-0.00999466236680746,
-0.24369853734970093,
0.08531762659549713,
0.534517765045166,
-0.7021962404251099,
0.45939815044403076,
0.35101407766342163,
-0.064178965985775,
-0.6695784330368042,
-0.6483597159385681,
0.10321911424398422,
-0.24351565539836884,
-0.6377823948860168,
0.507046639919281,
-0.20920948684215546,
0.049165163189172745,
-0.13854336738586426,
-0.35078707337379456,
-0.07221419364213943,
0.20540757477283478,
0.22206078469753265,
0.5038971304893494,
-0.24425111711025238,
0.32181012630462646,
0.07239651679992676,
-0.12554508447647095,
-0.04173591732978821,
-0.4025025963783264,
0.2726088762283325,
-0.08992215245962143,
-0.43803611397743225,
-0.28125330805778503,
0.23528988659381866,
0.46182265877723694,
-0.28023314476013184,
0.7427527904510498,
0.2692963480949402,
-0.19752520322799683,
-0.17895610630512238,
-0.772905170917511,
-0.15376926958560944,
-0.527379035949707,
0.05818997323513031,
-0.29143309593200684,
-1.0375277996063232,
0.18832160532474518,
-0.1853148639202118,
0.16052216291427612,
0.139797642827034,
0.5270987749099731,
-0.4084359109401703,
0.639564037322998,
0.6981231570243835,
-0.16817998886108398,
0.5851945281028748,
0.3686208724975586,
0.06505212187767029,
-0.5188838839530945,
0.015104081481695175,
-0.8635686039924622,
0.04471934586763382,
-0.4016682207584381,
-0.2681260406970978,
0.09786877036094666,
0.10896819829940796,
-0.43202149868011475,
0.48037540912628174,
-0.3372814655303955,
0.6310328245162964,
0.4491578936576843,
0.12523025274276733,
0.375547856092453,
0.1484881043434143,
-0.14794079959392548,
-0.08508565276861191,
-0.24362026154994965,
-0.945704460144043,
1.1801564693450928,
0.19749201834201813,
0.8997448086738586,
0.3074742257595062,
0.53201824426651,
0.3976303040981293,
0.3174329400062561,
-0.5680690407752991,
0.3214474022388458,
0.07087396085262299,
-0.892806351184845,
-0.2818306088447571,
-0.2417767494916916,
-0.612022340297699,
-0.02144205942749977,
-0.31844520568847656,
-0.6841306090354919,
-0.010690439492464066,
0.4541962742805481,
-0.16559231281280518,
-0.14773359894752502,
-0.6786749958992004,
0.8262782096862793,
-0.3104218542575836,
-0.41917410492897034,
-0.329666405916214,
-0.7260995507240295,
0.2711362838745117,
-0.24286550283432007,
-0.0023999414406716824,
-0.24173271656036377,
0.17645832896232605,
0.49421507120132446,
-0.6181211471557617,
0.7575222849845886,
0.034347161650657654,
-0.1898493617773056,
-0.046391405165195465,
-0.13072572648525238,
0.7913077473640442,
0.12910263240337372,
-0.3682290017604828,
-0.019867373630404472,
0.02563103660941124,
-0.4252929091453552,
-0.7804734706878662,
0.7266466021537781,
-0.8234074711799622,
-0.8683599233627319,
-0.31628239154815674,
-0.35201358795166016,
-0.5840632319450378,
0.24175766110420227,
0.33377519249916077,
-0.023943688720464706,
-0.27895596623420715,
0.3406832218170166,
0.7307601571083069,
0.20401184260845184,
0.2240733802318573,
0.5265148282051086,
0.013998221606016159,
-0.5042294263839722,
0.7395578622817993,
-0.0707549899816513,
0.3853251039981842,
0.5202944874763489,
0.08261531591415405,
-0.5095211863517761,
-0.5502898097038269,
-0.29971516132354736,
0.31428685784339905,
-0.8430812954902649,
-0.2519460916519165,
-0.2962104380130768,
-0.13049308955669403,
-0.3708855211734772,
-0.20951126515865326,
-0.6783247590065002,
-0.21914491057395935,
-0.1662343442440033,
-0.3497729003429413,
0.3745412826538086,
0.3406628668308258,
0.0960858017206192,
0.43794548511505127,
-0.5533718466758728,
-0.08422849327325821,
0.24884092807769775,
0.3586067259311676,
-0.4778370261192322,
-0.7433081269264221,
-0.5620313286781311,
0.07141260802745819,
-0.13627074658870697,
-0.46338698267936707,
0.0755031555891037,
0.2596360445022583,
0.6624534130096436,
0.2139747142791748,
0.22805777192115784,
0.6411952972412109,
-0.6188052296638489,
0.6068370342254639,
0.13228197395801544,
-1.1639072895050049,
0.6692073941230774,
-0.07385946810245514,
-0.24527065455913544,
0.9542721509933472,
0.3543316423892975,
-0.22293253242969513,
-0.2675047814846039,
-0.3981620669364929,
-0.6390939950942993,
0.5053926706314087,
0.32133960723876953,
0.37302833795547485,
0.12059110403060913,
0.499981164932251,
0.188995361328125,
0.31215929985046387,
-0.6007266044616699,
-0.1379161924123764,
-0.5577853322029114,
-0.40546560287475586,
-0.33578065037727356,
-0.419007807970047,
-0.4622913599014282,
0.004567996598780155,
0.7286267280578613,
-0.30599313974380493,
0.09689608961343765,
0.0548420175909996,
-0.27569305896759033,
-0.09399262070655823,
0.34832829236984253,
0.7305696606636047,
0.703912615776062,
-0.24576081335544586,
0.3734102249145508,
-0.16112251579761505,
-0.19734209775924683,
0.33471816778182983,
-0.1253204643726349,
-0.08179004490375519,
-0.07208946347236633,
0.21530841290950775,
0.9027783274650574,
0.17148014903068542,
-0.3285297155380249,
0.4368756413459778,
-0.19031743705272675,
-0.02343880757689476,
-0.39937978982925415,
0.24168480932712555,
0.20577828586101532,
0.19713127613067627,
0.2712344527244568,
0.09119583666324615,
-0.4661656618118286,
-0.2660592198371887,
0.2866363525390625,
0.7094511985778809,
-0.3171535134315491,
-0.31777629256248474,
0.6927427053451538,
0.01720886304974556,
-0.20619997382164001,
0.5591323375701904,
0.29009273648262024,
-0.10229508578777313,
0.18452633917331696,
0.5284141898155212,
0.9423909187316895,
-0.06111154332756996,
0.2028508484363556,
0.27977147698402405,
0.37894150614738464,
-0.1977064311504364,
0.0662430077791214,
-0.18438294529914856,
-1.0902457237243652,
-0.37721046805381775,
-0.78304523229599,
-0.610797643661499,
0.016602586954832077,
-0.7546370029449463,
0.31034040451049805,
-0.5148053169250488,
-0.33991488814353943,
0.09916801750659943,
-0.17914533615112305,
-0.5586047172546387,
0.2942822575569153,
0.04944503679871559,
0.8455022573471069,
-0.9463926553726196,
1.2923349142074585,
0.4566826820373535,
-0.6793091297149658,
-0.7981911897659302,
0.21173223853111267,
-0.1754736304283142,
-1.0610623359680176,
0.6968611478805542,
-0.11359062790870667,
-0.2280620038509369,
0.12969627976417542,
-0.8558282256126404,
-0.893860399723053,
0.9506734013557434,
1.1265933513641357,
-0.3995407819747925,
0.08450020849704742,
0.10715766996145248,
0.4198245406150818,
-0.31313833594322205,
0.18913163244724274,
0.3029332756996155,
0.35079795122146606,
0.378519743680954,
-0.6920804977416992,
0.21558302640914917,
-0.16693554818630219,
0.09801216423511505,
-0.14203386008739471,
-0.5107298493385315,
0.5034903287887573,
0.15943291783332825,
-0.2260463684797287,
-0.05139823257923126,
0.8403811454772949,
0.2975929379463196,
-0.15294073522090912,
0.38221266865730286,
0.4344971776008606,
1.1862637996673584,
-0.04857638478279114,
0.9914252161979675,
-0.42039716243743896,
0.27467718720436096,
1.4569495916366577,
-0.5051529407501221,
0.8044118285179138,
0.7374184727668762,
-0.25058892369270325,
0.5277786254882812,
0.49673014879226685,
0.12141532450914383,
0.6510895490646362,
0.13533177971839905,
-0.34986409544944763,
-0.6098957061767578,
-0.17738474905490875,
-0.5080999135971069,
0.24497269093990326,
0.08595237880945206,
-0.5331913232803345,
-0.10733411461114883,
-0.39999714493751526,
0.05622784048318863,
0.3425394594669342,
0.12362933158874512,
0.6603454947471619,
0.0988108366727829,
-0.7258539795875549,
0.6314401030540466,
-0.16164317727088928,
0.5609461665153503,
-0.8223602771759033,
0.272836834192276,
-0.20338134467601776,
0.13768255710601807,
-0.07312888652086258,
-0.46400949358940125,
0.37176600098609924,
0.10248542577028275,
-0.45256125926971436,
-0.44007688760757446,
0.5454928278923035,
-0.34702545404434204,
-0.47683942317962646,
-0.19077050685882568,
0.37373802065849304,
0.0005092979990877211,
0.056583140045404434,
-0.5450645685195923,
0.24348826706409454,
-0.015607613138854504,
-0.2117493897676468,
0.4631785750389099,
0.3860466778278351,
0.10401160269975662,
0.63174968957901,
0.804202139377594,
0.11929313093423843,
-0.08996502310037613,
0.14414282143115997,
0.816722571849823,
-0.5648366808891296,
-0.4540242552757263,
-1.118323802947998,
0.4097703993320465,
-0.40374791622161865,
-0.16288474202156067,
0.9173919558525085,
0.5444286465644836,
0.932051420211792,
-0.21138063073158264,
1.0025910139083862,
0.32267454266548157,
0.5202356576919556,
-0.7817625403404236,
0.8117724657058716,
-0.39189115166664124,
0.3624897599220276,
-0.27438005805015564,
-0.6290724873542786,
-0.2998863458633423,
0.7616642117500305,
-0.32624149322509766,
0.054629091173410416,
0.5944326519966125,
1.1474779844284058,
0.06197814643383026,
0.008041993714869022,
0.366062194108963,
-0.0572969950735569,
0.5829482674598694,
0.33975932002067566,
0.8356084227561951,
-0.20757730305194855,
0.4452284276485443,
-0.04025847092270851,
0.033660631626844406,
-0.13439318537712097,
-1.3082587718963623,
-0.8489718437194824,
-0.4760937988758087,
-0.5614185333251953,
-0.3795565366744995,
0.042062338441610336,
1.0441547632217407,
0.7720494866371155,
-0.7797573804855347,
-0.08452615141868591,
-0.29147905111312866,
0.21698401868343353,
-0.10141565650701523,
-0.11485214531421661,
0.27383679151535034,
-0.7340238690376282,
-0.6700895428657532,
0.5400971174240112,
0.13779707252979279,
0.22350718080997467,
-0.17536279559135437,
-0.12816055119037628,
-0.14531268179416656,
0.42337876558303833,
0.18522119522094727,
0.39930200576782227,
-0.6501165628433228,
-0.5925812125205994,
-0.17243723571300507,
-0.5087117552757263,
0.2304431051015854,
0.8720418810844421,
-0.5806429982185364,
0.31693899631500244,
0.32521283626556396,
0.8082828521728516,
0.4072608947753906,
0.18810893595218658,
0.8841530680656433,
-0.8820482492446899,
-0.14435580372810364,
-0.02804485894739628,
0.4431486427783966,
0.48234227299690247,
-0.42346444725990295,
0.45019200444221497,
0.13238386809825897,
-0.6648417711257935,
-1.0972570180892944,
0.37768587470054626,
-0.9442801475524902,
0.04682561755180359,
0.7272078990936279,
-0.45269179344177246,
-0.17085334658622742,
-0.06059643253684044,
-0.22092373669147491,
0.3397674560546875,
-0.2090306133031845,
0.7806594371795654,
0.9556593298912048,
0.14317244291305542,
0.030694717541337013,
-0.1603122502565384,
0.8312429189682007,
0.7020160555839539,
-0.7712763547897339,
0.44986656308174133,
0.41996848583221436,
0.3637131154537201,
0.09249608963727951,
0.5226266980171204,
-0.016657935455441475,
-0.059028200805187225,
-0.2499018758535385,
-0.03786966949701309,
-0.1708703488111496,
-0.02066783979535103,
-0.1372126340866089,
0.1485261768102646,
0.6747140288352966,
-0.17271435260772705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03854v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03854v2
|
Align as Ideal: Cross-Modal Alignment Binding for Federated Medical Vision-Language Pre-training
| 2024-04-05T01:17:25 | 2024-05-24T15:08:38 |
Zitao Shuai, Liyue Shen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Vision-language pre-training (VLP) has arised as an efficient scheme for
multimodal representation learning, but it requires large-scale multimodal data
for pre-training, making it an obstacle especially for medical applications. To
overcome the data limitation, federated learning (FL) can be a promising
strategy to scale up the dataset for medical VLP while protecting data privacy.
However, client data are often heterogeneous in real-world scenarios, and we
observe that local training on heterogeneous client data would distort the
multimodal representation learning and lead to biased cross-modal alignment. To
address this challenge, we propose a Federated Align as IDeal (FedAID)
framework for federated VLP with robustness to data heterogeneity, to bind
local clients with an ideal crossmodal alignment. Specifically, to reduce
distortions on global-aggregated features while learning diverse semantics from
client datasets during local training, we propose to bind the cross-model
aligned representation space learned by local models with an unbiased one via
guidance-based regularization. Moreover, we employ a distribution-based min-max
optimization to learn the unbiased cross-modal alignment at each communication
turn of federated pre-training. The experiments on real-world datasets
demonstrate our method successfully promotes efficient federated multimodal
learning for medical VLP with data heterogeneity.
|
[
-0.07150106877088547,
-0.3215840756893158,
0.3161277770996094,
0.02070731110870838,
-0.308840274810791,
-0.13938342034816742,
-0.2329755276441574,
-0.41220879554748535,
0.3805813491344452,
0.3247217833995819,
-0.6641960740089417,
-0.45235246419906616,
-0.34051620960235596,
-0.07452353090047836,
0.19763046503067017,
0.7577530145645142,
-0.19145214557647705,
0.5851126909255981,
-0.5412692427635193,
-0.5488426089286804,
-0.26175251603126526,
-0.2018018215894699,
0.018656745553016663,
-0.24796853959560394,
0.245522603392601,
0.3086444139480591,
0.9180566668510437,
0.8250018358230591,
0.6729555726051331,
0.31065595149993896,
0.7043207287788391,
0.1279238760471344,
-0.5353981852531433,
0.010401512496173382,
-0.3827817440032959,
-0.538424015045166,
-0.6725062727928162,
0.2116219401359558,
0.7247452735900879,
0.8326817154884338,
-0.2622099220752716,
0.08423025161027908,
-0.35146564245224,
0.464917927980423,
-0.6625437140464783,
0.2401685118675232,
-0.4241119623184204,
0.447792112827301,
-0.31021368503570557,
-0.2399137020111084,
-0.2831045389175415,
-0.2191648632287979,
0.32794344425201416,
-0.9227189421653748,
-0.011316759511828423,
0.1945478469133377,
1.240837574005127,
0.5281040668487549,
-0.25809594988822937,
0.2240813672542572,
-0.350125789642334,
0.7631711363792419,
-0.2697558104991913,
0.9143158793449402,
0.33815255761146545,
0.6935790777206421,
0.20874740183353424,
-0.7685061693191528,
-0.44747501611709595,
0.31591981649398804,
-0.23812516033649445,
0.20352675020694733,
-0.2516092360019684,
0.24140329658985138,
-0.10773251950740814,
0.3207133412361145,
-0.5478662252426147,
0.1614353507757187,
-0.08139707148075104,
-0.34183862805366516,
0.6125363707542419,
0.11784675717353821,
0.23049399256706238,
0.20404952764511108,
-0.7869815230369568,
-0.13414140045642853,
-0.6551434993743896,
-0.040597960352897644,
0.011111842468380928,
0.4736699163913727,
-0.4122805893421173,
0.5887467265129089,
-0.20947937667369843,
0.8634634017944336,
0.6342043876647949,
-0.4481359124183655,
0.7045690417289734,
-0.6758165955543518,
-0.5818425416946411,
0.05118746683001518,
0.8071321845054626,
0.3780440390110016,
0.05179348215460777,
-0.21929137408733368,
-0.26177334785461426,
0.020872941240668297,
0.3614353835582733,
-0.56458580493927,
0.22449472546577454,
0.08951349556446075,
-0.4974673390388489,
-0.27012571692466736,
0.12823235988616943,
-0.5874907970428467,
0.05217267945408821,
-0.57701176404953,
0.5275494456291199,
-0.23654820024967194,
-0.040605951100587845,
0.15805256366729736,
0.5357440710067749,
0.2903410494327545,
0.34821921586990356,
-0.8932278156280518,
0.0470290407538414,
0.5321375727653503,
0.5472611784934998,
0.06258926540613174,
-0.48208585381507874,
-0.888853907585144,
0.27983978390693665,
0.026472022756934166,
0.3483513593673706,
-0.7464620471000671,
0.03967775031924248,
0.25071704387664795,
0.17035247385501862,
-0.2853919565677643,
-0.20337101817131042,
0.2150999754667282,
-0.3248778283596039,
0.6612499952316284,
-0.054869394749403,
-0.4851972460746765,
0.05781571939587593,
0.26578256487846375,
-0.3548365533351898,
0.011192464269697666,
0.20294208824634552,
-0.7547599077224731,
0.6610172986984253,
-0.33004453778266907,
-0.3935312330722809,
-0.060275208204984665,
-0.7528062462806702,
-0.7293593287467957,
0.1261904537677765,
0.5023060441017151,
0.5151723027229309,
-0.2901800870895386,
0.23023490607738495,
-0.38056424260139465,
-0.10559573769569397,
-0.20974645018577576,
-0.19245553016662598,
0.695911705493927,
0.14927054941654205,
-0.3206280767917633,
0.30137932300567627,
-0.5764418840408325,
0.0422566719353199,
-0.1207897961139679,
0.009936838410794735,
-0.36412617564201355,
-0.3021947741508484,
0.04872766509652138,
0.2230057567358017,
0.19512750208377838,
-0.698783814907074,
0.32972291111946106,
-0.3564346730709076,
-0.10275883972644806,
0.7429870367050171,
-0.4037330150604248,
0.721507728099823,
-0.32688385248184204,
0.7562744617462158,
0.13221599161624908,
0.5495590567588806,
0.1738564521074295,
-0.23582789301872253,
-0.24590915441513062,
-0.675662636756897,
0.1477249711751938,
0.2124621719121933,
-1.016906499862671,
0.1374264508485794,
-0.615527868270874,
-0.2780802249908447,
-0.9025853276252747,
0.09760541468858719,
0.823212742805481,
0.7959379553794861,
0.290301114320755,
-0.5256916284561157,
-0.42883700132369995,
-0.9567753076553345,
-0.013763627037405968,
0.09727300703525543,
0.1702369600534439,
0.4363710880279541,
-0.09708244353532791,
-0.838991641998291,
1.0055224895477295,
-0.3635191321372986,
-0.9778851866722107,
0.1174241453409195,
-0.048008229583501816,
-0.05649059638381004,
0.5955120325088501,
0.7375019192695618,
-1.1012911796569824,
-0.5373741984367371,
0.3379964232444763,
-0.519555926322937,
-0.171229287981987,
-0.09620162844657898,
-0.1726222187280655,
0.31263384222984314,
0.10277307778596878,
-0.32077160477638245,
0.2833629548549652,
0.8922801613807678,
-0.594586968421936,
0.2254556566476822,
-0.34781160950660706,
0.13239537179470062,
-1.1185497045516968,
0.04180096834897995,
-0.08391837030649185,
-0.5261332392692566,
-0.4465939998626709,
-0.05030680075287819,
0.060225870460271835,
-0.2144809514284134,
-0.25353580713272095,
0.2866520583629608,
-0.63258957862854,
-0.22942331433296204,
0.14214856922626495,
-0.16495424509048462,
-0.02712838724255562,
0.23676525056362152,
0.4151984751224518,
0.5294314026832581,
0.7556309700012207,
0.17265893518924713,
0.20942345261573792,
0.5682633519172668,
-0.07860500365495682,
0.9168183207511902,
-0.24515262246131897,
-0.25451692938804626,
-0.12404628098011017,
0.27522751688957214,
-0.4248688817024231,
-0.4363716244697571,
0.14373794198036194,
-0.36135172843933105,
0.4151633381843567,
0.05037910118699074,
-0.1363338679075241,
0.15699295699596405,
-0.02590801753103733,
0.6630396842956543,
0.21213224530220032,
-0.6345773935317993,
0.8538640141487122,
0.5278717875480652,
0.4031386375427246,
-1.0678801536560059,
-0.6615213751792908,
-0.5376626253128052,
0.21372251212596893,
-0.6773105263710022,
0.4686970114707947,
0.25701335072517395,
0.11122216284275055,
0.07458725571632385,
-0.2628392279148102,
-0.22442039847373962,
-0.32779282331466675,
0.6253990530967712,
0.3836517333984375,
-0.5005600452423096,
0.028721962124109268,
0.04980447143316269,
-0.29518836736679077,
-0.2429661750793457,
-0.32666218280792236,
0.4988000690937042,
-0.2778779864311218,
-0.8203738331794739,
-0.5414038896560669,
0.41549888253211975,
0.6519840359687805,
-0.497837096452713,
0.6148249506950378,
0.7453926801681519,
-0.39913687109947205,
0.18150459229946136,
-0.48924705386161804,
-0.02637225203216076,
-0.46523621678352356,
0.2260085940361023,
-0.24270190298557281,
-0.9058977961540222,
0.3043448030948639,
0.13690492510795593,
0.05554613098502159,
-0.026930689811706543,
0.6515067219734192,
-0.12864665687084198,
0.8149292469024658,
0.9794613122940063,
-0.12833979725837708,
0.5858553051948547,
0.015440335497260094,
0.1456199735403061,
-0.22721709311008453,
-0.39110177755355835,
0.005663746036589146,
-0.3722955584526062,
-0.25246256589889526,
-0.6246774792671204,
0.20906512439250946,
-0.14949123561382294,
-0.020684709772467613,
0.07116764038801193,
-0.3416796326637268,
0.45009857416152954,
0.2750411629676819,
0.10247234255075455,
0.10161381959915161,
0.2645658552646637,
-0.2878548800945282,
-0.28523632884025574,
-0.5848246812820435,
0.1479533314704895,
1.021225094795227,
0.33651039004325867,
1.0551499128341675,
-0.008181218057870865,
0.8028622269630432,
-0.11786327511072159,
0.3295379877090454,
-0.3851935565471649,
0.13719162344932556,
-0.22883208096027374,
-0.36147329211235046,
-0.0026512551121413708,
-0.4586530029773712,
-0.7618390321731567,
0.2352163940668106,
-0.5518385767936707,
-0.5355566740036011,
0.7315919399261475,
0.44480109214782715,
-0.4318661093711853,
0.1745072454214096,
-0.6417407989501953,
1.0573502779006958,
-0.3254244327545166,
-0.38922765851020813,
-0.04162699729204178,
-1.1633527278900146,
0.1932392418384552,
-0.11523500084877014,
-0.005054577253758907,
0.21926501393318176,
-0.02303808182477951,
0.1714365929365158,
-0.5431391000747681,
0.9209127426147461,
-0.3270888030529022,
0.02909761108458042,
-0.4415632486343384,
-0.3803078830242157,
0.2499057799577713,
0.08046478033065796,
0.4114023745059967,
0.1419065296649933,
-0.11324561387300491,
-0.4057057797908783,
-0.4155932366847992,
0.5812264680862427,
-0.8519439697265625,
-0.3695267140865326,
-0.4219928979873657,
-0.7304937243461609,
-0.5065319538116455,
0.20576541125774384,
0.4359757900238037,
0.5484517216682434,
-0.006198310758918524,
0.1898670792579651,
0.6051762700080872,
0.09264157712459564,
0.026601340621709824,
0.6235913634300232,
-0.4218396246433258,
-0.5979667901992798,
0.9740002751350403,
0.020377276465296745,
0.6180270314216614,
0.7296670079231262,
0.01323356106877327,
-0.18579664826393127,
-0.3479084372520447,
-0.44681087136268616,
0.3582570552825928,
-0.5390468835830688,
-0.37679794430732727,
-0.4134274423122406,
0.02312985435128212,
-0.5754249691963196,
-0.7346501350402832,
-0.6931880116462708,
-0.09231126308441162,
-0.2787734568119049,
0.14400270581245422,
-0.06303945183753967,
-0.049580808728933334,
-0.39283716678619385,
0.3253146708011627,
-0.7400892972946167,
0.25383463501930237,
0.18742096424102783,
0.5510789752006531,
-0.5505197048187256,
-0.017639625817537308,
-0.25063812732696533,
0.16226907074451447,
0.22431260347366333,
-0.48387300968170166,
0.2925759553909302,
0.44658544659614563,
0.620296835899353,
1.0736711025238037,
0.026674708351492882,
1.0062087774276733,
-0.5591275691986084,
0.2831360697746277,
0.6339821219444275,
-0.7427701354026794,
0.34670329093933105,
-0.09362545609474182,
0.3143611550331116,
0.8563814163208008,
0.5515217185020447,
-0.3223492503166199,
-0.21523268520832062,
-0.5047824382781982,
-0.3991077244281769,
0.600515604019165,
-0.11846569925546646,
-0.12210238724946976,
0.3994769752025604,
0.03377247974276543,
0.2732844352722168,
0.20789974927902222,
-0.6361914873123169,
-0.33004170656204224,
-0.5428104996681213,
-0.5301000475883484,
-0.016005948185920715,
0.2282007336616516,
-0.5220143795013428,
-0.4115617275238037,
0.4196077883243561,
-0.39370232820510864,
0.26928824186325073,
0.31903737783432007,
-0.20668740570545197,
-0.3892771899700165,
-0.1806216984987259,
0.6978462934494019,
0.531525194644928,
-0.19591298699378967,
0.03909279778599739,
-0.4378451406955719,
-0.7430276870727539,
0.1460190862417221,
0.4929507374763489,
-0.018296990543603897,
0.07014500349760056,
0.5083165168762207,
0.8423271179199219,
0.12371037155389786,
-0.7605427503585815,
1.021060824394226,
-0.2572711110115051,
-0.16142691671848297,
0.09099714457988739,
-0.18887370824813843,
-0.22315093874931335,
0.4390425682067871,
0.024349549785256386,
0.3326343894004822,
-0.25305673480033875,
-0.39847156405448914,
0.5640052556991577,
0.667205810546875,
-0.7690673470497131,
-0.44674554467201233,
0.798384964466095,
0.18471567332744598,
0.08625521510839462,
0.2650397717952728,
0.17781205475330353,
-0.49992629885673523,
-0.04303811118006706,
0.5322670936584473,
0.5744824409484863,
-0.40546914935112,
0.4085984230041504,
-0.10983703285455704,
0.14286774396896362,
0.14743317663669586,
0.2240900993347168,
-0.32630547881126404,
-0.8896443843841553,
-0.25987544655799866,
-0.650123655796051,
-0.12700220942497253,
-0.4495907127857208,
-0.6982229948043823,
0.1638423204421997,
-0.4572543203830719,
-0.05416420102119446,
-0.0429178886115551,
-0.06948874890804291,
-0.7818063497543335,
0.34186995029449463,
0.078684002161026,
0.5231940746307373,
-0.9703153371810913,
1.1771631240844727,
0.9302151203155518,
-0.6468718647956848,
-0.9452276825904846,
-0.009186246432363987,
0.2704172432422638,
-1.0846097469329834,
0.6723099946975708,
0.056646279990673065,
-0.009380768984556198,
-0.2759433686733246,
-0.3128950893878937,
-0.7691354155540466,
1.2015266418457031,
0.5553786158561707,
-0.713577389717102,
-0.19905291497707367,
0.38982871174812317,
0.3999609351158142,
-0.8765744566917419,
-0.11798591166734695,
0.07740262895822525,
0.15883897244930267,
0.09811034798622131,
-1.210585594177246,
0.08537118881940842,
-0.17968572676181793,
-0.20848578214645386,
0.1889600157737732,
-0.5530070662498474,
0.7217029333114624,
-0.25020578503608704,
-0.2601413428783417,
-0.4269435703754425,
0.6093234419822693,
-0.18805770576000214,
0.2557608187198639,
0.5522404313087463,
0.7572304010391235,
0.5766927599906921,
0.027841178700327873,
0.859268069267273,
-0.10241581499576569,
0.3871449828147888,
1.2604687213897705,
-0.43733200430870056,
0.46014663577079773,
0.8697050213813782,
0.2503907382488251,
0.05168231204152107,
0.2965651750564575,
0.12311465293169022,
0.8521652817726135,
-0.39632195234298706,
-0.17858262360095978,
-0.4141262173652649,
-0.19205529987812042,
-0.5707077980041504,
0.6929898262023926,
0.0689723789691925,
-0.6441554427146912,
-0.46173691749572754,
0.4010549485683441,
-0.21027091145515442,
0.15448926389217377,
-0.19972577691078186,
0.6175070405006409,
-0.17194019258022308,
-0.21446146070957184,
0.5946412086486816,
-0.4632379710674286,
0.6261285543441772,
-0.7413484454154968,
0.15738032758235931,
-0.12470827996730804,
0.3188076317310333,
-0.3163180649280548,
-0.21548186242580414,
0.2551862597465515,
-0.4584677815437317,
-0.2613339126110077,
-0.3584786057472229,
0.5284823775291443,
-0.6855268478393555,
-0.24584591388702393,
0.13127951323986053,
0.49196889996528625,
-0.32490894198417664,
0.4813178777694702,
-0.54175865650177,
0.0860317051410675,
0.2780320644378662,
-0.052758798003196716,
0.5320366024971008,
0.37084686756134033,
0.10270106792449951,
0.6209010481834412,
0.5216509699821472,
0.249084934592247,
-0.029104700312018394,
-0.055418822914361954,
0.8762351274490356,
-0.04995788633823395,
-0.4237138628959656,
-0.378484845161438,
0.3984748423099518,
-0.12613894045352936,
-0.4038887619972229,
0.5976535677909851,
0.38756120204925537,
1.1286325454711914,
0.010460943914949894,
0.2137826383113861,
-0.1410236954689026,
0.0734395682811737,
-0.4724106192588806,
0.9107517004013062,
-0.8576045036315918,
-0.07755275815725327,
-0.19511236250400543,
-0.6996415853500366,
-0.6126469969749451,
0.7647116780281067,
-0.321190744638443,
-0.4891773462295532,
0.35137343406677246,
0.684644877910614,
-0.471479207277298,
-0.050143901258707047,
0.5573421716690063,
-0.04598874971270561,
0.18517397344112396,
0.4807875156402588,
0.15408451855182648,
-0.19215507805347443,
0.0547669492661953,
-0.52723228931427,
-0.2634415924549103,
-0.36750948429107666,
-0.6878848075866699,
-0.6321651935577393,
-0.7615751624107361,
-0.3714645802974701,
-0.08034848421812057,
0.060900188982486725,
1.2725707292556763,
0.8885155320167542,
-0.5747678875923157,
0.10148585587739944,
0.26423195004463196,
-0.07074253261089325,
-0.32517769932746887,
-0.129654198884964,
0.349799782037735,
-0.3844373822212219,
-0.6154476404190063,
0.2729589641094208,
0.42451712489128113,
0.18293188512325287,
-0.30598631501197815,
-0.3038681745529175,
-0.31362172961235046,
-0.31798166036605835,
0.27006813883781433,
0.41533103585243225,
-0.6868992447853088,
-0.44997262954711914,
-0.12747424840927124,
-0.37114331126213074,
0.3389401435852051,
0.7286917567253113,
-0.7960981726646423,
0.9012752771377563,
0.31874069571495056,
1.076656699180603,
0.048167839646339417,
0.12774449586868286,
0.9982881546020508,
-0.8685752153396606,
0.5248289108276367,
0.42415955662727356,
0.5426331758499146,
0.06962946802377701,
-0.35081467032432556,
0.37342262268066406,
0.1595424860715866,
-0.3969751298427582,
-0.9440039992332458,
0.2995818853378296,
-1.1293092966079712,
0.0017616103868931532,
0.6438426375389099,
-0.431602418422699,
-0.26910606026649475,
0.17665745317935944,
0.05708332359790802,
0.19199922680854797,
-0.14435738325119019,
0.33617207407951355,
0.1389191448688507,
-0.09811998903751373,
-0.035293277353048325,
-0.007215437013655901,
0.6226526498794556,
0.6709967255592346,
-0.706747829914093,
-0.10793280601501465,
0.8744756579399109,
0.13899487257003784,
0.32204654812812805,
0.6382007002830505,
-0.18447503447532654,
0.37923920154571533,
-0.14753825962543488,
0.051561638712882996,
-0.21094071865081787,
-0.3905152976512909,
-0.32170426845550537,
0.20147280395030975,
-0.40037086606025696,
-0.5040847063064575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03823v1
|
An Investigation into Misuse of Java Security APIs by Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T22:52:41 | 2024-04-04T22:52:41 |
Zahra Mousavi, Chadni Islam, Kristen Moore, Alsharif Abuadbba, Muhammad Ali Babar
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The increasing trend of using Large Language Models (LLMs) for code
generation raises the question of their capability to generate trustworthy
code. While many researchers are exploring the utility of code generation for
uncovering software vulnerabilities, one crucial but often overlooked aspect is
the security Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). APIs play an integral
role in upholding software security, yet effectively integrating security APIs
presents substantial challenges. This leads to inadvertent misuse by
developers, thereby exposing software to vulnerabilities. To overcome these
challenges, developers may seek assistance from LLMs. In this paper, we
systematically assess ChatGPT's trustworthiness in code generation for security
API use cases in Java. To conduct a thorough evaluation, we compile an
extensive collection of 48 programming tasks for 5 widely used security APIs.
We employ both automated and manual approaches to effectively detect security
API misuse in the code generated by ChatGPT for these tasks. Our findings are
concerning: around 70% of the code instances across 30 attempts per task
contain security API misuse, with 20 distinct misuse types identified.
Moreover, for roughly half of the tasks, this rate reaches 100%, indicating
that there is a long way to go before developers can rely on ChatGPT to
securely implement security API code.
|
[
-0.24872711300849915,
-0.5216571688652039,
0.3476419150829315,
0.036124613136053085,
-0.09641187638044357,
0.14560361206531525,
0.1893317699432373,
-0.47514981031417847,
-0.45184674859046936,
0.7157052755355835,
-0.23446771502494812,
-0.47775426506996155,
-0.8889636397361755,
-0.07830154150724411,
-0.4903108775615692,
0.967838704586029,
0.1272529810667038,
-0.16793136298656464,
0.07966111600399017,
0.20761074125766754,
-0.5672239661216736,
-0.6086578965187073,
-0.7645794749259949,
-0.12909889221191406,
0.060710616409778595,
0.2546830475330353,
0.689328670501709,
0.13356125354766846,
0.6908426284790039,
0.32893210649490356,
0.04983167722821236,
0.09204266220331192,
-0.3815556764602661,
0.18821658194065094,
-0.08367136865854263,
-0.5862761735916138,
-0.3669283986091614,
-0.08712466061115265,
0.04089811071753502,
0.17829038202762604,
-0.08210868388414383,
0.49357572197914124,
0.19039733707904816,
0.32248255610466003,
-0.53758704662323,
0.4140123426914215,
-1.0127393007278442,
-0.13955120742321014,
-0.4635842442512512,
-0.5198358297348022,
-0.5798065662384033,
-0.2963390350341797,
0.1814301759004593,
-0.17786391079425812,
-0.3134182095527649,
0.29340091347694397,
0.3211471438407898,
0.051748938858509064,
-0.22845220565795898,
-0.7564993500709534,
-0.5284112691879272,
0.7565213441848755,
-0.8005309700965881,
0.12171103805303574,
0.4324149787425995,
0.1634802520275116,
-0.7496987581253052,
-0.5490039587020874,
-0.46334826946258545,
-0.5899918675422668,
0.03771066293120384,
-0.14932872354984283,
-0.3795139789581299,
-0.08631392568349838,
0.48987600207328796,
0.18205960094928741,
-0.807843029499054,
-0.06379030644893646,
-0.31444814801216125,
-0.3376411497592926,
0.540334939956665,
0.001415443723089993,
0.8771382570266724,
-0.2984349727630615,
-0.15837234258651733,
-0.02555040270090103,
-0.8856133222579956,
0.1583968549966812,
0.8547892570495605,
0.3817863464355469,
-0.12491237372159958,
0.7202761769294739,
0.24927350878715515,
0.5270828604698181,
-0.6055156588554382,
-0.3466825485229492,
0.02573140524327755,
-0.09086812287569046,
-0.3809076249599457,
-0.1612056940793991,
0.6609876751899719,
0.2635868191719055,
0.5929680466651917,
-0.1482909619808197,
-0.060659028589725494,
0.22024638950824738,
0.6546810865402222,
-0.6226738691329956,
-0.3773926794528961,
0.4897525906562805,
-0.4566751718521118,
-0.5183061361312866,
-0.12735290825366974,
-0.41287851333618164,
-0.519892692565918,
0.05325201153755188,
-0.0748753547668457,
-0.6829396486282349,
-0.3721301853656769,
-0.1128869578242302,
-0.18978659808635712,
0.41088730096817017,
-0.1001627966761589,
-0.2702799439430237,
-0.19330257177352905,
0.967848539352417,
0.5761576294898987,
0.1361290067434311,
-0.291274756193161,
-0.35338032245635986,
0.07104472815990448,
-0.2804597318172455,
0.3184705376625061,
-0.5662900805473328,
-0.6854479908943176,
0.26478853821754456,
-0.3070092499256134,
0.22048644721508026,
-0.34676843881607056,
0.6385748386383057,
-0.6493232250213623,
-0.11531327664852142,
0.05856344848871231,
-0.5047070384025574,
0.20379503071308136,
0.32393062114715576,
-0.31562966108322144,
0.8533214330673218,
-0.055115073919296265,
-0.7603806257247925,
0.4318237900733948,
-0.6239981651306152,
-0.16417494416236877,
0.21769694983959198,
-0.2084847241640091,
-0.4589269757270813,
-0.01888618804514408,
0.09370457381010056,
0.41980451345443726,
0.08377106487751007,
-0.19141365587711334,
-0.5342013239860535,
-0.38859036564826965,
0.8311805129051208,
-0.4146435558795929,
0.9327647089958191,
0.5201413631439209,
-0.18760409951210022,
-0.37784749269485474,
-0.5886386036872864,
0.07875941693782806,
0.2533406615257263,
-0.20369070768356323,
-0.6750975847244263,
-0.12541036307811737,
-0.30341383814811707,
-0.01932537369430065,
0.2526933252811432,
-0.5618438720703125,
-0.041668009012937546,
-0.313615083694458,
0.3645327389240265,
0.876693606376648,
0.27930834889411926,
0.24544773995876312,
-0.06806865334510803,
0.46800681948661804,
-0.17525909841060638,
0.5388145446777344,
-0.26698461174964905,
-0.6209238767623901,
-0.24915051460266113,
-0.20715397596359253,
0.04963719844818115,
0.6232803463935852,
-0.6830018758773804,
0.30013909935951233,
0.006902250926941633,
-0.740960419178009,
-0.12209837883710861,
0.4136963188648224,
0.742078423500061,
0.16448834538459778,
-0.031778719276189804,
-0.28357675671577454,
-0.4447084367275238,
-0.7200868129730225,
-0.49053165316581726,
-0.4610321819782257,
-0.10153055191040039,
0.39392712712287903,
0.45401671528816223,
-0.31755733489990234,
0.7831078767776489,
-0.22300298511981964,
0.3479040563106537,
0.02102736011147499,
0.08981331437826157,
-0.01356301549822092,
0.5667635202407837,
0.7232686281204224,
-0.4812825918197632,
-0.26727598905563354,
-0.17914657294750214,
-0.7892701029777527,
-0.11303748935461044,
-0.07029393315315247,
-0.3592279255390167,
0.22508172690868378,
0.49293211102485657,
-0.6329101324081421,
0.39073410630226135,
0.8552623987197876,
-0.29592642188072205,
0.50246262550354,
-0.03907887637615204,
0.05322854965925217,
-1.0814839601516724,
0.16018414497375488,
-0.09263719618320465,
-0.23132386803627014,
-0.44741132855415344,
0.6809015870094299,
0.15467676520347595,
-0.6005945205688477,
-0.47971975803375244,
0.010648230090737343,
-0.37064263224601746,
-0.2884107232093811,
-0.2725868821144104,
0.1463697999715805,
-0.3999325931072235,
0.2547975778579712,
-0.6499052047729492,
1.0295052528381348,
0.5574278831481934,
-0.49104946851730347,
0.399598091840744,
0.11519652605056763,
-0.45189541578292847,
0.4287438690662384,
-0.46306443214416504,
0.19245390594005585,
0.21166324615478516,
0.2906443476676941,
-1.1515973806381226,
-0.30357661843299866,
0.5309273600578308,
-0.6767815351486206,
0.15755799412727356,
-0.5721619129180908,
-0.5582389831542969,
-0.554720401763916,
-0.27126190066337585,
0.14380694925785065,
0.7354070544242859,
-0.45058682560920715,
0.379451721906662,
0.4892072081565857,
-0.28483763337135315,
-0.8101896643638611,
-0.9007161259651184,
0.07976316660642624,
-0.20743641257286072,
-0.7712428569793701,
-0.37251952290534973,
0.20751433074474335,
-0.36178410053253174,
-0.06501834839582443,
-0.3359672725200653,
0.126682311296463,
0.2981624901294708,
0.6051396727561951,
0.4394626021385193,
-0.00593774626031518,
-0.15504637360572815,
-0.0914086252450943,
-0.12103704363107681,
0.332253098487854,
-0.18180428445339203,
0.7224603891372681,
-0.10345175117254257,
-0.923879861831665,
-0.3908444046974182,
0.22401019930839539,
0.6089794635772705,
-0.25296705961227417,
0.5579859018325806,
0.3354801833629608,
0.00032908780849538743,
-0.19998934864997864,
-0.4224885404109955,
0.07938689738512039,
-0.5290241241455078,
0.3185989260673523,
-0.3832587003707886,
-0.8146147727966309,
0.6994343996047974,
-0.2556320130825043,
0.5110948085784912,
0.06874359399080276,
0.40129899978637695,
0.11176034063100815,
0.5746800899505615,
0.40181201696395874,
-0.26338398456573486,
0.4443958103656769,
0.06715643405914307,
0.6355369091033936,
-0.47004061937332153,
-0.07939561456441879,
-0.568482518196106,
0.13845989108085632,
-0.8482012748718262,
-0.24934665858745575,
0.15764445066452026,
-0.03600364550948143,
-0.2630458176136017,
0.5674812197685242,
-0.5358713865280151,
0.5642850399017334,
0.5023249387741089,
-0.01778414472937584,
0.2726677358150482,
-0.03831088915467262,
0.24123942852020264,
0.37907570600509644,
-0.26663461327552795,
-0.7540773749351501,
1.5312998294830322,
0.514731228351593,
0.8663179874420166,
0.453988641500473,
0.9395768046379089,
0.490553617477417,
0.16215673089027405,
-0.36270660161972046,
0.692615270614624,
-0.02630181983113289,
-0.5413668751716614,
-0.19318938255310059,
-0.39052245020866394,
-1.0134315490722656,
-0.09883599728345871,
0.0165666826069355,
-0.8772561550140381,
-0.22376558184623718,
0.2845339775085449,
-0.35741451382637024,
0.061448369175195694,
-1.222224235534668,
0.6194848418235779,
0.12280983477830887,
0.0016595666529610753,
-0.1658584177494049,
-0.23619996011257172,
0.7792421579360962,
-0.17721419036388397,
0.1558806151151657,
-0.11137597262859344,
0.20145243406295776,
0.3429669439792633,
-0.5775221586227417,
0.9496927261352539,
-0.34969550371170044,
-0.4756544828414917,
0.6450181007385254,
0.42507508397102356,
0.8456406593322754,
0.37567511200904846,
0.15649570524692535,
0.24543602764606476,
-0.006417324300855398,
-0.4357164204120636,
-0.39377501606941223,
0.8185040950775146,
-0.6250163912773132,
-0.5507389307022095,
-0.4644278585910797,
-0.36780473589897156,
-0.4062720835208893,
0.012358893640339375,
0.17203983664512634,
0.49470439553260803,
0.10655301064252853,
-0.029105260968208313,
0.5987287759780884,
-0.65776127576828,
0.47988951206207275,
0.15443019568920135,
-0.47886472940444946,
0.20254449546337128,
0.7543731331825256,
-0.17259454727172852,
0.2707773745059967,
-0.21126043796539307,
-0.19697749614715576,
-0.01608581654727459,
-0.7256645560264587,
-0.4747120141983032,
-0.18124382197856903,
-0.36542487144470215,
-0.3789786398410797,
-0.2568979263305664,
-0.5250494480133057,
-0.4188816547393799,
-0.09786052256822586,
-0.45264944434165955,
-0.04719049111008644,
0.4130324423313141,
0.020252136513590813,
0.46315041184425354,
0.2551300823688507,
0.2571464478969574,
0.4882553219795227,
-0.951398491859436,
0.043075401335954666,
0.2996670603752136,
0.32995712757110596,
-0.05349798873066902,
-0.31630977988243103,
0.06554245948791504,
-0.23182664811611176,
-0.02094128727912903,
-0.6373995542526245,
0.18808595836162567,
-0.5064142942428589,
0.6209503412246704,
0.15520629286766052,
-0.06316998600959778,
0.4530269503593445,
-0.22949235141277313,
1.1489707231521606,
0.04780641943216324,
-0.8447681069374084,
0.5379312634468079,
-0.5806377530097961,
0.1848127394914627,
0.2402704656124115,
0.21931535005569458,
-0.2714550793170929,
-1.0536184310913086,
-0.6975372433662415,
-0.8912909030914307,
0.5577008128166199,
0.6263008117675781,
0.5529460310935974,
0.18296776711940765,
0.35538288950920105,
0.10237634927034378,
0.05791902914643288,
-0.7161984443664551,
-0.31797918677330017,
0.027977894991636276,
0.153129443526268,
0.48346617817878723,
-0.5617579817771912,
-0.31813907623291016,
0.6043474674224854,
0.6769260764122009,
0.21728481352329254,
0.4606623947620392,
-0.28798601031303406,
-0.022070297971367836,
0.2040269374847412,
0.5282933115959167,
0.4542842209339142,
0.6623156666755676,
-0.08175067603588104,
0.05959608778357506,
-0.015824932605028152,
-0.7391273975372314,
-0.3038100004196167,
0.00020301088807173073,
-0.0683244839310646,
-0.24447223544120789,
0.46281540393829346,
0.3879561424255371,
-0.20203876495361328,
-0.9083696603775024,
0.6548980474472046,
-0.21407200396060944,
-0.07035849988460541,
-0.8286442160606384,
0.4968923032283783,
-0.11251571774482727,
0.41821345686912537,
0.38083431124687195,
0.3500147759914398,
0.07126401364803314,
-0.5823079347610474,
0.23243415355682373,
0.5958020687103271,
0.1598324477672577,
0.03923098370432854,
0.07362361997365952,
0.27669572830200195,
-0.1943351775407791,
0.5445524454116821,
-0.3810025155544281,
-0.2911777198314667,
0.42339298129081726,
0.4961796700954437,
0.7995825409889221,
-0.22888678312301636,
0.0030867017339915037,
0.18948893249034882,
0.5873029828071594,
0.09897921234369278,
0.24550709128379822,
0.15957783162593842,
-0.6647723317146301,
-0.6547319293022156,
-0.524011492729187,
-0.5776433348655701,
0.3281186819076538,
-0.3241686224937439,
0.025928610935807228,
-0.6168872714042664,
-0.2761887013912201,
-0.30608952045440674,
-0.29262787103652954,
-0.539251983165741,
-0.21219027042388916,
0.3749209940433502,
0.7904325723648071,
-0.789241373538971,
0.5882366895675659,
0.3580991327762604,
-0.27859947085380554,
-1.1152160167694092,
0.23370955884456635,
0.167297825217247,
-1.1005977392196655,
0.5037473440170288,
-0.14319978654384613,
0.05062001943588257,
-0.48606255650520325,
-0.5792509317398071,
-0.7565005421638489,
0.8730691075325012,
0.3178180754184723,
-0.38744333386421204,
0.17063342034816742,
0.5508865118026733,
0.31278830766677856,
-0.007406944874674082,
0.2343917191028595,
0.5552084445953369,
0.3301813006401062,
-0.105220727622509,
-0.8876170516014099,
0.12048818916082382,
-0.2131936252117157,
0.2798707187175751,
0.14783848822116852,
-0.5587107539176941,
0.6315405368804932,
0.24560725688934326,
-0.1260780394077301,
0.1846795529127121,
0.29312700033187866,
0.6375465989112854,
0.2021518498659134,
0.329924613237381,
0.2882471978664398,
0.7316784262657166,
0.060973260551691055,
1.121816635131836,
-0.5243448615074158,
0.07907525449991226,
0.9215447306632996,
-0.1368122398853302,
0.6759373545646667,
0.48973169922828674,
-0.29566690325737,
0.22503052651882172,
0.32878321409225464,
-0.07545439153909683,
0.18129871785640717,
0.2527400553226471,
-0.266728937625885,
-0.11486096680164337,
0.19307394325733185,
-0.5752120614051819,
0.7543579339981079,
0.2896851897239685,
-0.5035831332206726,
-0.26600557565689087,
-0.07859813421964645,
0.3470247685909271,
-0.21602989733219147,
-0.30598902702331543,
0.46788761019706726,
0.29167625308036804,
-0.5522048473358154,
0.14550599455833435,
0.05859711766242981,
0.565139651298523,
-0.6560204029083252,
0.15765981376171112,
-0.16904497146606445,
0.12905564904212952,
-0.23270058631896973,
-0.8779505491256714,
0.5012611746788025,
0.583156943321228,
0.2728005647659302,
-0.11453106254339218,
0.9773910045623779,
0.1646973043680191,
-0.07191082835197449,
0.022033093497157097,
0.5103996992111206,
0.19947679340839386,
-0.0976860299706459,
-0.5825977921485901,
0.30474135279655457,
0.2313353419303894,
-0.3508971929550171,
0.5545295476913452,
0.5418415665626526,
0.09509279578924179,
0.7135222554206848,
1.0122568607330322,
0.08715873211622238,
0.30597737431526184,
-0.05821767821907997,
0.7021000385284424,
-0.26173409819602966,
-0.3924615979194641,
-1.145228385925293,
0.37494561076164246,
-0.4120350182056427,
-0.25909873843193054,
1.0903329849243164,
0.5648335218429565,
0.8460822105407715,
-0.233084037899971,
1.127647042274475,
-0.12363233417272568,
0.5202344655990601,
-0.5366137623786926,
0.6332318782806396,
-0.02028687298297882,
0.6039999127388,
-0.5005092024803162,
-0.9909634590148926,
-0.26457762718200684,
0.3010930120944977,
-0.46737009286880493,
-0.03755301237106323,
0.5053155422210693,
1.0793144702911377,
-0.09014712274074554,
0.2831435799598694,
0.275372177362442,
-0.029450180009007454,
0.6605156660079956,
0.4198765754699707,
0.978386402130127,
-0.39457863569259644,
1.0680636167526245,
0.021700553596019745,
-0.35810211300849915,
-0.13090083003044128,
-0.8138498067855835,
-0.8927117586135864,
-0.12848852574825287,
-0.22376884520053864,
-0.6189156174659729,
0.03499878570437431,
0.77524733543396,
0.3393791615962982,
-0.7172245383262634,
0.06778059899806976,
-0.23959164321422577,
-0.16043496131896973,
0.0781007632613182,
-0.20365460216999054,
0.017212199047207832,
-0.5064921379089355,
-0.6826958060264587,
0.1732052117586136,
0.21628795564174652,
0.030023345723748207,
-0.3532055914402008,
0.04430357366800308,
0.4341740310192108,
0.2822553515434265,
0.5150580406188965,
0.5823241472244263,
-0.5694255828857422,
-0.5223067402839661,
-0.26288825273513794,
-0.5188686847686768,
-0.4886763095855713,
0.7937889099121094,
-0.18533247709274292,
0.1065199077129364,
0.46868735551834106,
0.9912106394767761,
0.15289990603923798,
-0.12203450500965118,
0.43188440799713135,
-0.9216035604476929,
0.15643036365509033,
-0.14898179471492767,
0.4471985697746277,
0.03798772767186165,
-0.37079325318336487,
0.5708755254745483,
-0.025091854855418205,
-0.8243734836578369,
-0.8974664211273193,
0.3585716485977173,
-1.0552411079406738,
-0.21893425285816193,
1.234320044517517,
-0.4693705141544342,
-0.337959349155426,
-0.24837104976177216,
-0.3557582199573517,
0.0551835298538208,
-0.5476036071777344,
0.9066633582115173,
0.7537835240364075,
-0.20145662128925323,
-0.047462787479162216,
-0.5796342492103577,
0.5335220694541931,
0.1752977967262268,
-0.7393863201141357,
0.34714701771736145,
0.4028952121734619,
0.29810845851898193,
0.336808443069458,
0.5776855945587158,
-0.4186784625053406,
0.16371551156044006,
0.48238274455070496,
0.09109402447938919,
-0.18307527899742126,
0.1475805640220642,
0.15191121399402618,
0.2883571684360504,
0.4573424756526947,
-0.2649325132369995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03820v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03820v2
|
CantTalkAboutThis: Aligning Language Models to Stay on Topic in Dialogues
| 2024-04-04T22:31:58 | 2024-06-21T13:57:11 |
Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Traian Rebedea, Shaona Ghosh, Jiaqi Zeng, Christopher Parisien
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in instruction-tuning datasets have predominantly focused
on specific tasks like mathematical or logical reasoning. There has been a
notable gap in data designed for aligning language models to maintain topic
relevance in conversations - a critical aspect for deploying chatbots to
production. We introduce the CantTalkAboutThis dataset to help language models
remain focused on the subject at hand during task-oriented interactions. It
consists of synthetic dialogues on a wide range of conversation topics from
different domains. These dialogues are interspersed with distractor turns that
intentionally divert the chatbot from the predefined topic. Fine-tuning
language models on this dataset helps make them resilient to deviating from the
role assigned and improves their ability to maintain topical coherence compared
to general-purpose instruction-tuned LLMs like GPT-4-turbo and
Mixtral-Instruct. Additionally, preliminary observations suggest that training
models on this dataset also enhance their performance on fine-grained
instruction following tasks, including safety alignment.
|
[
-0.012043174356222153,
-0.8755171895027161,
0.3141234219074249,
0.046949904412031174,
-0.14332398772239685,
0.14347033202648163,
-0.3709036409854889,
0.011718081310391426,
-0.11817905306816101,
0.7593821287155151,
-0.7398740649223328,
-0.4542723298072815,
-0.5426908731460571,
-0.42846816778182983,
-0.4335692822933197,
1.1926262378692627,
0.2020464390516281,
0.11198388040065765,
-0.6061199903488159,
-0.028056683018803596,
-0.9913642406463623,
-0.3738754689693451,
-0.6475439071655273,
-0.3926609456539154,
0.31683698296546936,
0.7698190808296204,
0.7741187810897827,
0.6558369398117065,
0.6684725880622864,
0.3433809280395508,
-0.05250624567270279,
0.13089320063591003,
-0.7315390706062317,
0.6559375524520874,
-0.3601561188697815,
-0.4839569628238678,
-0.39889490604400635,
-0.32311519980430603,
0.5017472505569458,
0.7476280331611633,
-0.43818578124046326,
-0.09579106420278549,
0.2481529265642166,
0.4221048355102539,
-0.3837067484855652,
0.2698824107646942,
-0.8336142897605896,
-0.20194192230701447,
-0.08471696823835373,
0.0050040194764733315,
-0.4173992872238159,
-0.3299442529678345,
0.16523562371730804,
-0.6099567413330078,
0.2840157151222229,
-0.034598950296640396,
1.083518624305725,
0.5418625473976135,
-0.2127278745174408,
-0.16849665343761444,
-0.7542482018470764,
1.0134683847427368,
-0.6353412866592407,
0.19253522157669067,
0.6822214722633362,
0.3469249904155731,
-0.4339045286178589,
-0.3342784345149994,
-0.199119433760643,
-0.06196388974785805,
-0.11233829706907272,
0.13178850710391998,
0.0313885360956192,
0.07395473122596741,
0.16096505522727966,
0.2721409201622009,
-0.4172392785549164,
0.13662004470825195,
-0.2493133842945099,
-0.34156355261802673,
0.5722170472145081,
0.41846963763237,
0.3299131989479065,
-0.04575031250715256,
0.06844860315322876,
0.01550618652254343,
-0.6347751617431641,
-0.05513162538409233,
0.3064371645450592,
0.5846878886222839,
-0.18385396897792816,
0.6069545745849609,
-0.4422351121902466,
0.7294297814369202,
0.30827683210372925,
-0.11070536822080612,
-0.14578869938850403,
-0.5946935415267944,
0.03020312450826168,
0.08180689811706543,
0.4593602418899536,
0.37246331572532654,
0.4016207456588745,
-0.12333876639604568,
0.10401599854230881,
0.14781586825847626,
0.6603618264198303,
-0.767353355884552,
-0.4583881199359894,
0.10569613426923752,
-0.023561090230941772,
-0.2462240606546402,
-0.2492161989212036,
-0.5458502173423767,
-0.13485029339790344,
-0.584234356880188,
0.2437562197446823,
-0.3209518492221832,
-0.17946380376815796,
-0.008149298839271069,
0.21149682998657227,
0.2549334764480591,
0.3974083960056305,
-1.2259352207183838,
0.5088748931884766,
0.9707757830619812,
0.7097157835960388,
-0.20480960607528687,
0.12556414306163788,
-0.6854091286659241,
0.21405720710754395,
-0.37526893615722656,
0.7805168628692627,
-0.7950703501701355,
-0.2044043391942978,
-0.013857766054570675,
0.16772302985191345,
-0.15231582522392273,
-0.5549154281616211,
0.35756945610046387,
-0.19793224334716797,
0.40535059571266174,
-0.08475199341773987,
-0.6029684543609619,
0.016980335116386414,
0.3806358277797699,
-0.3094993531703949,
0.938462495803833,
-0.13471604883670807,
-0.5005326271057129,
0.20035837590694427,
-0.4967259168624878,
-0.33908921480178833,
-0.11285757273435593,
-0.3725602626800537,
-0.7011280059814453,
0.10645675659179688,
0.20364747941493988,
0.4313792884349823,
-0.2792506515979767,
0.6253350377082825,
-0.27043551206588745,
-0.15926121175289154,
0.22882024943828583,
-0.1644843965768814,
0.5101144313812256,
0.11725904792547226,
-0.008498609997332096,
0.37425392866134644,
-0.4673885405063629,
-0.01074992585927248,
-0.11077358573675156,
-0.015801899135112762,
-0.21266674995422363,
0.31083521246910095,
-0.17835865914821625,
0.02488260716199875,
-0.0012879741843789816,
-0.4449951946735382,
0.1759643703699112,
-0.31741079688072205,
0.4353117048740387,
0.5361217856407166,
0.028045736253261566,
0.44044727087020874,
-0.39673227071762085,
0.5108517408370972,
0.01953609474003315,
-0.030600551515817642,
0.04498661682009697,
-0.6162551641464233,
-1.0567378997802734,
-0.2177172750234604,
0.4833998680114746,
0.6978328227996826,
-0.46310296654701233,
0.47666263580322266,
-0.40162569284439087,
-0.49650779366493225,
-0.49261194467544556,
0.13354913890361786,
0.2733929753303528,
0.6743344068527222,
0.05032133683562279,
-0.33813318610191345,
-0.2748362123966217,
-1.0175023078918457,
0.05909255892038345,
0.10784284770488739,
-0.061835650354623795,
0.18598517775535583,
0.14347855746746063,
-0.0006813480285927653,
1.0712863206863403,
-0.43861305713653564,
0.006261706817895174,
-0.2781836688518524,
0.08621161431074142,
0.23363371193408966,
0.9070097208023071,
0.18592475354671478,
-0.7337288856506348,
-0.6091289520263672,
-0.04440745711326599,
-0.6893555521965027,
-0.17314839363098145,
-0.05178980156779289,
-0.5487499833106995,
-0.010707085952162743,
0.550915002822876,
-0.7143803834915161,
0.41711917519569397,
0.37905049324035645,
-0.08082889020442963,
0.1316184550523758,
0.0009880635188892484,
0.09912630170583725,
-1.2466444969177246,
-0.06223487854003906,
-0.1214037537574768,
-0.41491201519966125,
-0.9216685891151428,
-0.2628352642059326,
-0.0571066178381443,
-0.5238282084465027,
-0.30155149102211,
0.35741886496543884,
-0.15161077678203583,
0.026850225403904915,
-0.4604334235191345,
0.29575780034065247,
-0.05794932693243027,
0.47308894991874695,
0.2996622622013092,
0.8399795293807983,
0.7080562114715576,
-0.6308866739273071,
0.09760962426662445,
0.6860011219978333,
-0.5233656167984009,
0.6099413633346558,
-0.6760844588279724,
0.2910858690738678,
0.061601750552654266,
0.08462285250425339,
-1.0751965045928955,
-0.4625031054019928,
0.30218830704689026,
-0.17017550766468048,
0.5568645596504211,
-0.22226732969284058,
-0.3596785366535187,
0.0833778977394104,
0.11180207133293152,
0.20730805397033691,
0.4006926417350769,
-0.005837935488671064,
0.5541694760322571,
0.5666014552116394,
-0.6772565245628357,
-0.514468789100647,
-0.4707052707672119,
-0.19496868550777435,
-0.3099057078361511,
-0.6669949293136597,
0.41473913192749023,
-0.15238410234451294,
-0.19281047582626343,
-0.11996038258075714,
-0.2886209785938263,
-0.1068747490644455,
0.2886836528778076,
0.36758187413215637,
0.42107126116752625,
-0.243047297000885,
0.37496182322502136,
0.2777276933193207,
-0.28644946217536926,
-0.2989741265773773,
-0.07270898669958115,
0.5643816590309143,
0.09271424263715744,
-0.33650118112564087,
-0.5388085246086121,
0.34877920150756836,
0.2527924180030823,
0.08070168644189835,
0.8272840976715088,
0.259432315826416,
-0.32358241081237793,
0.1822555810213089,
-0.5178559422492981,
-0.38303884863853455,
-0.503638505935669,
0.5119740962982178,
-0.1812717467546463,
-0.9505100846290588,
0.4863950312137604,
-0.0341339074075222,
0.16905656456947327,
0.3008769452571869,
0.6829314827919006,
-0.21298588812351227,
0.8749749660491943,
0.8258891701698303,
-0.12553216516971588,
0.679059624671936,
0.04558516666293144,
0.4734669029712677,
-0.5940204858779907,
-0.1354488581418991,
-0.452571839094162,
-0.27156099677085876,
-0.6116167902946472,
-0.2596704065799713,
-0.003407596843317151,
0.08937939256429672,
-0.25862252712249756,
0.4475977420806885,
-0.4575761556625366,
0.7053810358047485,
0.3165222108364105,
0.14371106028556824,
-0.012456508353352547,
0.06168551743030548,
0.22663679718971252,
-0.02917836792767048,
-0.9093584418296814,
-0.686996579170227,
0.9838245511054993,
0.1982659101486206,
0.7354171872138977,
0.02887880429625511,
0.39929062128067017,
0.16086773574352264,
0.24662618339061737,
-0.5797855854034424,
0.7125540971755981,
-0.21007069945335388,
-0.8390920758247375,
-0.3129391074180603,
-0.28953710198402405,
-0.924815833568573,
-0.02792961522936821,
-0.028572145849466324,
-0.9990429878234863,
-0.1843033879995346,
0.3130258321762085,
-0.3352409601211548,
-0.13173140585422516,
-0.7949551939964294,
1.17368745803833,
-0.23575963079929352,
-0.5833638310432434,
-0.4918719530105591,
-0.687585175037384,
0.06437189131975174,
0.0677795335650444,
-0.0376906618475914,
-0.5701971054077148,
0.18751512467861176,
0.5785650014877319,
-0.4581506848335266,
1.106454849243164,
0.08974330127239227,
-0.13883061707019806,
0.31433969736099243,
-0.03338543325662613,
0.23804719746112823,
-0.033061303198337555,
-0.008112144656479359,
0.014164735563099384,
-0.1697857826948166,
-0.6275710463523865,
-0.5815066695213318,
0.7776421904563904,
-0.7634963393211365,
-1.058859944343567,
-0.0775563046336174,
-0.9102240204811096,
-0.3240223824977875,
-0.048279233276844025,
0.07634276896715164,
0.3989162743091583,
-0.1428292840719223,
0.3934521973133087,
0.7504168748855591,
-0.057460855692625046,
0.046322450041770935,
0.3095533847808838,
-0.12288952618837357,
-0.18776747584342957,
1.1111096143722534,
-0.010731952264904976,
0.6241346001625061,
0.5262852907180786,
0.0947081670165062,
-0.07058577239513397,
-0.42052143812179565,
-0.18644870817661285,
-0.014055630192160606,
-0.797508180141449,
-0.3917377293109894,
-0.4981502592563629,
-0.44872280955314636,
-0.33685141801834106,
-0.08305179327726364,
-0.42105284333229065,
-0.6816785335540771,
-0.30377456545829773,
-0.07060428708791733,
0.5603194832801819,
0.4810369312763214,
0.1833365559577942,
0.5912832617759705,
-0.526491641998291,
0.18659161031246185,
0.35496786236763,
0.25223588943481445,
-0.3401511013507843,
-0.842856764793396,
-0.3429161310195923,
0.15060167014598846,
-0.6341665387153625,
-0.5999698638916016,
0.21542315185070038,
0.44573599100112915,
0.6270171999931335,
0.10199844837188721,
-0.14667704701423645,
0.6435104012489319,
-0.39643558859825134,
0.6658120155334473,
0.005921186413615942,
-0.8945013880729675,
0.8609523177146912,
-0.5956556797027588,
0.6243705749511719,
0.6478716731071472,
0.4171459972858429,
-0.634536862373352,
-0.6281996369361877,
-0.3245140314102173,
-0.7496670484542847,
1.0223472118377686,
0.5159255862236023,
0.3216463029384613,
0.134784996509552,
0.261933833360672,
0.2825336456298828,
0.3609088659286499,
-0.5755062699317932,
-0.016818568110466003,
-0.38826051354408264,
-0.7095757722854614,
-0.05614412575960159,
-0.048197805881500244,
-0.23505055904388428,
-0.28022265434265137,
0.6601322293281555,
-0.14543798565864563,
0.44835588335990906,
-0.4508548080921173,
-0.057205162942409515,
-0.12395778298377991,
0.22487972676753998,
0.8033173084259033,
0.5932291150093079,
-0.12681607902050018,
-0.13019129633903503,
0.10013055801391602,
-0.3875429034233093,
0.11259931325912476,
0.026563851162791252,
-0.042457837611436844,
-0.311987042427063,
0.13972723484039307,
0.9860398769378662,
0.3284766972064972,
-0.6813997626304626,
0.0960223376750946,
-0.037697773426771164,
-0.05641023442149162,
-0.10631337761878967,
0.548291027545929,
0.272582471370697,
0.32100528478622437,
-0.07542816549539566,
0.08108750730752945,
-0.32543131709098816,
-0.6601476669311523,
0.19157175719738007,
0.33800208568573,
-0.36367928981781006,
-0.1839836835861206,
0.45867449045181274,
0.37924879789352417,
-0.7059279084205627,
0.9849259853363037,
0.2546996474266052,
-0.5107066631317139,
0.6476835012435913,
0.3703126907348633,
0.8095578551292419,
-0.15389227867126465,
0.01799270696938038,
0.29150620102882385,
-0.0437965914607048,
-0.042363543063402176,
0.12575778365135193,
-0.13599610328674316,
-0.9441685080528259,
-0.4561251103878021,
-0.31791988015174866,
-0.7164024114608765,
0.14054307341575623,
-0.5647407174110413,
0.39788922667503357,
-0.35935482382774353,
-0.3435385823249817,
-0.029506074264645576,
-0.20249336957931519,
-0.5772324204444885,
0.04255014285445213,
0.12826994061470032,
0.3475083112716675,
-0.8629898428916931,
1.0261317491531372,
0.3477640151977539,
-0.18460051715373993,
-0.42053520679473877,
0.08687499165534973,
-0.0023233552929013968,
-0.5743052363395691,
0.6373671293258667,
0.3170247972011566,
0.04512364789843559,
-0.15804478526115417,
-0.6715407371520996,
-1.031794786453247,
0.9396299719810486,
0.5180078744888306,
-0.8946645259857178,
0.17316082119941711,
0.3092111349105835,
0.5324645638465881,
-0.564495861530304,
0.09009711444377899,
0.4941645562648773,
0.06572937965393066,
-0.013543040491640568,
-0.890906035900116,
-0.22037212550640106,
-0.3871097266674042,
-0.23347662389278412,
0.30115264654159546,
-0.7848027348518372,
0.33952468633651733,
0.18439339101314545,
-0.07287343591451645,
0.21135598421096802,
0.6127561330795288,
0.2418127804994583,
0.09771452099084854,
0.3626037538051605,
0.41511616110801697,
0.7766532301902771,
-0.4484429955482483,
0.8283327221870422,
-0.31495341658592224,
0.06576535850763321,
1.323870301246643,
-0.3507826626300812,
0.7566480040550232,
0.40594542026519775,
0.14605002105236053,
0.5486720204353333,
0.7191828489303589,
0.07326330244541168,
0.8156151175498962,
0.1628502905368805,
0.017457740381360054,
-0.6922900080680847,
-0.2563219666481018,
-0.10777585208415985,
0.5064540505409241,
0.7242459654808044,
0.11922461539506912,
0.09031004458665848,
0.060336191207170486,
-0.21543118357658386,
0.1414455771446228,
-0.0837693139910698,
0.8731241822242737,
0.012964469380676746,
-0.969117283821106,
0.45627787709236145,
-0.3969970941543579,
0.24507708847522736,
-0.716117799282074,
-0.010286439210176468,
-0.34061288833618164,
0.32218146324157715,
0.05218621715903282,
-0.6753992438316345,
0.507878839969635,
0.03234168887138367,
-0.2461332380771637,
-0.263759046792984,
0.8776819109916687,
-0.8257536888122559,
-0.5444986820220947,
-0.06423261016607285,
0.21137934923171997,
0.10223843157291412,
0.3073734939098358,
-0.7879432439804077,
0.25507259368896484,
0.0019148533465340734,
0.016283178701996803,
0.42409878969192505,
0.44438549876213074,
-0.16758698225021362,
0.8755159378051758,
0.16800189018249512,
-0.30199331045150757,
-0.10035553574562073,
0.17637288570404053,
0.8600724935531616,
-0.5189784169197083,
-0.3156587481498718,
-0.5642883777618408,
0.7412646412849426,
-0.23449566960334778,
-0.26615405082702637,
0.6607946753501892,
0.47882625460624695,
0.7798109650611877,
-0.003169504925608635,
0.4912165403366089,
0.11241760104894638,
0.5756602883338928,
-0.6231441497802734,
0.5435136556625366,
-0.5171118974685669,
0.2655833959579468,
-0.06678355485200882,
-0.8772950768470764,
-0.09524627774953842,
0.7009441256523132,
-0.6084500551223755,
0.026231935247778893,
0.40467503666877747,
1.0302784442901611,
-0.335758239030838,
0.04794449359178543,
0.368902325630188,
-0.055957596749067307,
0.2357134222984314,
0.1744557023048401,
0.9493584036827087,
-0.35725846886634827,
0.4886213541030884,
-0.27713343501091003,
0.176103875041008,
-0.3425103425979614,
-0.8711585402488708,
-1.0311766862869263,
-0.4347401559352875,
-0.837944507598877,
-0.0017408636631444097,
0.2825728952884674,
0.8836041688919067,
0.9261173605918884,
-1.1643693447113037,
-0.5227342844009399,
-0.41225486993789673,
0.012897697277367115,
-0.08018972724676132,
-0.19327563047409058,
0.04479050636291504,
-0.6955464482307434,
-0.6729040145874023,
0.3171270787715912,
0.27573877573013306,
0.01363382674753666,
0.015877967700362206,
0.05854511633515358,
-0.3830830454826355,
0.21369031071662903,
0.2409943789243698,
0.039673347026109695,
-0.7436881065368652,
-0.41713979840278625,
0.10665345191955566,
-0.10130421072244644,
0.3302946090698242,
0.9126700758934021,
-0.35960519313812256,
0.4710995554924011,
0.38293689489364624,
0.7599550485610962,
0.5809551477432251,
0.0573347732424736,
1.0124574899673462,
-0.919167160987854,
0.3707538843154907,
0.25392237305641174,
0.14508464932441711,
0.6460623741149902,
-0.23371621966362,
0.5021259784698486,
0.09720999002456665,
-0.7810550928115845,
-0.7291149497032166,
0.21662142872810364,
-0.977508008480072,
-0.162855863571167,
0.8097541332244873,
-0.062412332743406296,
-0.05815338343381882,
-0.230533629655838,
-0.22185420989990234,
0.4433630704879761,
-0.4834051728248596,
0.8716866970062256,
1.0287953615188599,
-0.048090144991874695,
-0.2544941306114197,
-0.6368655562400818,
0.4804682731628418,
1.0070462226867676,
-0.8961971402168274,
0.29033535718917847,
0.2971572279930115,
0.16167761385440826,
0.11422105133533478,
0.33071932196617126,
0.31169557571411133,
0.2064266949892044,
-0.040692027658224106,
-0.18753989040851593,
0.43236732482910156,
-0.3889697194099426,
-0.13920168578624725,
-0.22202026844024658,
0.049726516008377075,
-0.28964897990226746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03818v1
|
PRobELM: Plausibility Ranking Evaluation for Language Models
| 2024-04-04T21:57:11 | 2024-04-04T21:57:11 |
Zhangdie Yuan, Chenxi Whitehouse, Eric Chamoun, Rami Aly, Andreas Vlachos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces PRobELM (Plausibility Ranking Evaluation for Language
Models), a benchmark designed to assess language models' ability to discern
more plausible from less plausible scenarios through their parametric
knowledge. While benchmarks such as TruthfulQA emphasise factual accuracy or
truthfulness, and others such as COPA explore plausible scenarios without
explicitly incorporating world knowledge, PRobELM seeks to bridge this gap by
evaluating models' capabilities to prioritise plausible scenarios that leverage
world knowledge over less plausible alternatives. This design allows us to
assess the potential of language models for downstream use cases such as
literature-based discovery where the focus is on identifying information that
is likely but not yet known. Our benchmark is constructed from a dataset
curated from Wikidata edit histories, tailored to align the temporal bounds of
the training data for the evaluated models. PRobELM facilitates the evaluation
of language models across multiple prompting types, including statement, text
completion, and question-answering. Experiments with 10 models of various sizes
and architectures on the relationship between model scales, training recency,
and plausibility performance, reveal that factual accuracy does not directly
correlate with plausibility performance and that up-to-date training data
enhances plausibility assessment across different model architectures.
|
[
-0.24122634530067444,
-0.46549466252326965,
0.7496948838233948,
0.07481005787849426,
0.04628894478082657,
0.10026276856660843,
-0.25314223766326904,
-0.05039253085851669,
-0.4689359962940216,
0.18691451847553253,
-0.23103611171245575,
-0.5029283761978149,
-0.432758629322052,
-0.11263848841190338,
-0.6146660447120667,
0.8526275157928467,
0.17776256799697876,
-0.11747422069311142,
-0.6710896492004395,
-0.3295488953590393,
-0.19543179869651794,
-0.4175132215023041,
-0.3804701268672943,
-0.10635816305875778,
0.42414742708206177,
0.2288983166217804,
0.6526743173599243,
0.41050395369529724,
0.44098609685897827,
0.18503908812999725,
-0.17630992829799652,
0.10926530510187149,
-0.6679015159606934,
0.23685045540332794,
-0.18614400923252106,
-0.4825984835624695,
-0.5156879425048828,
0.2793543338775635,
0.9378406405448914,
0.9109874963760376,
-0.14371585845947266,
0.31371328234672546,
0.06279071420431137,
0.48186835646629333,
-0.5624294281005859,
-0.008443200960755348,
-0.7575880289077759,
-0.34331342577934265,
-0.17465785145759583,
-0.10642852634191513,
-0.6320067048072815,
-0.6801331639289856,
0.4322037696838379,
-0.4442371428012848,
0.5475389957427979,
0.40599408745765686,
0.726888120174408,
-0.034516435116529465,
-0.45387837290763855,
-0.08844727277755737,
-0.4905024766921997,
0.7502953410148621,
-0.9072306156158447,
0.5683376789093018,
0.44384312629699707,
0.5983266234397888,
-0.08183809369802475,
-1.1050165891647339,
-0.5136826634407043,
-0.6865596771240234,
-0.17427290976047516,
0.09069156646728516,
-0.06851863861083984,
-0.07656668871641159,
0.5869591236114502,
0.526068925857544,
-0.782027542591095,
-0.11182481050491333,
-0.33982741832733154,
-0.4238320589065552,
0.6060011982917786,
0.3192070722579956,
0.1550511121749878,
0.17108100652694702,
-0.33538222312927246,
-0.0467989444732666,
-0.7533565163612366,
0.32696616649627686,
0.4338262379169464,
0.4415939450263977,
-0.21728408336639404,
0.3910020589828491,
-0.3953203558921814,
0.774007260799408,
-0.329840749502182,
-0.17501859366893768,
0.2764643728733063,
-0.28592124581336975,
-0.10763037204742432,
-0.28517982363700867,
0.49643051624298096,
0.4076937139034271,
-0.2150713950395584,
-0.3619143068790436,
-0.21935978531837463,
0.03078433685004711,
0.24093709886074066,
-0.744940459728241,
-0.36749711632728577,
0.21282924711704254,
-0.5925915241241455,
-0.27415525913238525,
0.2062952071428299,
-0.8243734240531921,
-0.6410539746284485,
-0.012467333115637302,
0.4937679171562195,
-0.253352552652359,
-0.5869446396827698,
-0.019337506964802742,
-0.23044872283935547,
0.22889594733715057,
0.2779230773448944,
-0.2878030836582184,
0.31709080934524536,
0.6871912479400635,
0.7661960124969482,
-0.31038668751716614,
-0.6028302311897278,
-0.7012631297111511,
-0.1357482224702835,
-0.47096818685531616,
0.7937156558036804,
-0.6895961761474609,
-0.46861910820007324,
0.05922764539718628,
0.04505635425448418,
-0.2706662118434906,
-0.549153208732605,
1.14382004737854,
-0.6419535875320435,
0.37048041820526123,
-0.46734723448753357,
-1.0093724727630615,
-0.41627055406570435,
0.23120951652526855,
-0.8427641987800598,
1.084644079208374,
0.26326388120651245,
-0.9233740568161011,
0.5252280235290527,
-0.6284565329551697,
-0.38863977789878845,
0.20396539568901062,
0.17063573002815247,
-0.28295108675956726,
0.06117239221930504,
-0.15852102637290955,
0.19930648803710938,
-0.66560298204422,
0.6665140390396118,
-0.37138453125953674,
-0.3662014901638031,
0.3314310312271118,
-0.641989529132843,
0.8026555180549622,
0.18847371637821198,
-0.1488277167081833,
0.23275627195835114,
-0.6886813044548035,
-0.00963865127414465,
0.1240784227848053,
-0.4699152708053589,
-0.26736485958099365,
-0.02351102977991104,
-0.05735515430569649,
0.20992666482925415,
0.3319116532802582,
-0.40729624032974243,
0.033791642636060715,
-0.5958399176597595,
0.2519077956676483,
0.37349414825439453,
-0.070761539041996,
0.38935813307762146,
-0.7196496725082397,
0.6578910946846008,
-0.2200060784816742,
0.2681460976600647,
-0.10210219770669937,
-0.590807318687439,
-0.8890961408615112,
-0.1786039024591446,
0.4330105483531952,
0.34070539474487305,
-0.5040444731712341,
0.007837158627808094,
-0.2230158895254135,
-0.8413203358650208,
-0.549847424030304,
0.009652199223637581,
0.5225546360015869,
0.978118896484375,
0.22523219883441925,
0.017664382234215736,
-0.6864316463470459,
-1.0229014158248901,
-0.5837481021881104,
-0.5035179257392883,
-0.019499098882079124,
0.22075676918029785,
0.3429023325443268,
0.10357226431369781,
0.998857855796814,
-0.25383907556533813,
0.19538041949272156,
-0.22408336400985718,
0.26896607875823975,
0.2836531698703766,
0.18858321011066437,
0.4769459366798401,
-0.9682239294052124,
-0.27170076966285706,
-0.19740164279937744,
-0.6330025792121887,
-0.09529946744441986,
0.26419103145599365,
0.19531524181365967,
0.185048907995224,
0.31584057211875916,
-0.40832704305648804,
0.48512110114097595,
0.4290015995502472,
-0.30142542719841003,
0.8145067095756531,
-0.2902834415435791,
0.22968150675296783,
-0.5523648858070374,
0.4961010813713074,
-0.3048838675022125,
-0.23918035626411438,
-0.8684197068214417,
0.08975400030612946,
0.3106134235858917,
-0.04174051433801651,
-0.540789783000946,
1.0465164184570312,
-0.3674625754356384,
-0.1830318570137024,
-0.009892848320305347,
0.14469027519226074,
0.29369401931762695,
0.07280823588371277,
-0.004168915096670389,
0.9328813552856445,
0.629179835319519,
-0.746021032333374,
0.0471121110022068,
0.10594446212053299,
-0.7279700636863708,
0.30583035945892334,
-0.5560826659202576,
0.09403280168771744,
0.22172509133815765,
0.010479587130248547,
-1.108682632446289,
-0.0463518463075161,
-0.20089933276176453,
-0.5144104361534119,
-0.004586984869092703,
-0.054105695337057114,
-0.3400510549545288,
-0.3582417368888855,
-0.26348260045051575,
0.30089452862739563,
0.5144423842430115,
-0.41826164722442627,
0.5626432299613953,
0.25697773694992065,
-0.08482160419225693,
-0.40100282430648804,
-0.25659963488578796,
-0.09688880294561386,
-0.48812147974967957,
-0.44580158591270447,
0.21603171527385712,
-0.35289132595062256,
-0.4237135052680969,
-0.1968132108449936,
-0.007870842702686787,
-0.05510544776916504,
0.3790934979915619,
0.269096314907074,
0.37605607509613037,
-0.2850429117679596,
0.07289465516805649,
-0.16677814722061157,
-0.010193854570388794,
0.1591644585132599,
0.07870741933584213,
0.39586687088012695,
-0.39480116963386536,
-0.3705465793609619,
-0.04658015817403793,
0.11602805554866791,
0.6070730686187744,
-0.27022963762283325,
0.7034796476364136,
0.45732808113098145,
-0.35053378343582153,
-0.026076622307300568,
-0.6704843044281006,
-0.22512322664260864,
-0.4262746572494507,
0.14422507584095,
-0.4312070310115814,
-0.6962049603462219,
0.6698805689811707,
-0.10526466369628906,
0.22450734674930573,
0.46937093138694763,
0.5832749605178833,
0.09510418772697449,
0.9301373362541199,
0.4239225685596466,
0.2255704402923584,
0.04582437872886658,
-0.049047935754060745,
0.22340844571590424,
-0.8197050094604492,
-0.2974478006362915,
-0.5565192103385925,
0.11908676475286484,
-0.40246665477752686,
-0.5089271664619446,
0.17028780281543732,
0.07134656608104706,
-0.18719738721847534,
0.15932117402553558,
-0.14805974066257477,
0.09913679212331772,
0.6984788775444031,
-0.30628976225852966,
0.45925235748291016,
-0.28444573283195496,
-0.5687386989593506,
0.04326311871409416,
-0.8415186405181885,
-0.7532047629356384,
1.2142565250396729,
0.27589845657348633,
0.30265048146247864,
0.23463517427444458,
0.13302914798259735,
0.4483584463596344,
0.5822058320045471,
-0.5788894295692444,
0.5790501236915588,
0.18610507249832153,
-0.908003032207489,
-0.37638962268829346,
-0.1920502483844757,
-0.8681814670562744,
0.18598516285419464,
-0.2323218733072281,
-0.573628842830658,
0.14595572650432587,
-0.07192836701869965,
-0.3111080229282379,
0.039637934416532516,
-0.6795836687088013,
0.8464609980583191,
-0.10392467677593231,
-0.39007890224456787,
-0.04780121147632599,
-0.6483644843101501,
0.5257079005241394,
0.018704822286963463,
0.34621116518974304,
-0.16081947088241577,
-0.08913096785545349,
0.8602612614631653,
-0.20489256083965302,
0.6628143191337585,
-0.2533265948295593,
0.11308835446834564,
0.13383892178535461,
0.3384186029434204,
0.3980656862258911,
0.09344343841075897,
-0.49935075640678406,
0.042387835681438446,
0.2622457444667816,
-0.35805460810661316,
-0.5686677098274231,
0.5587143301963806,
-0.5307290554046631,
-0.7710587382316589,
-0.3392200469970703,
-0.5901854038238525,
-0.6720529198646545,
0.31725677847862244,
0.3180433511734009,
0.5695087313652039,
-0.41244789958000183,
0.23098786175251007,
0.4242360293865204,
-0.31205689907073975,
0.2965752184391022,
0.8853650093078613,
-0.40294232964515686,
-0.24807338416576385,
0.9759201407432556,
0.04414941743016243,
0.12200813740491867,
0.3932201564311981,
0.34216004610061646,
-0.7632530331611633,
-0.8091694712638855,
-0.11377900093793869,
0.1739892214536667,
-0.7626691460609436,
-0.02479584515094757,
-0.5310210585594177,
-0.3787233829498291,
-0.4728866219520569,
0.13636243343353271,
-0.17032039165496826,
-0.26094457507133484,
0.012793859466910362,
-0.22346067428588867,
0.21575108170509338,
0.4648522734642029,
0.24974723160266876,
0.03295399621129036,
-0.5233518481254578,
0.07027722895145416,
0.2607056200504303,
0.344988077878952,
0.0884581059217453,
-0.9171358346939087,
-0.04938063398003578,
-0.0819297656416893,
0.0962766706943512,
-0.7560832500457764,
0.41034501791000366,
0.2613125443458557,
1.0836743116378784,
0.21929098665714264,
0.5179120898246765,
0.3550977110862732,
-0.3411652147769928,
0.7141261100769043,
-0.180755615234375,
-0.8766800165176392,
0.49540066719055176,
-0.43785029649734497,
0.13479594886302948,
0.606979489326477,
0.3980882465839386,
-0.28224289417266846,
-0.4628542959690094,
-0.8176098465919495,
-0.6487142443656921,
0.493827760219574,
0.1610688865184784,
-0.16395194828510284,
0.168112650513649,
0.11374932527542114,
0.45746076107025146,
0.3708966374397278,
-0.4308796226978302,
-0.24407239258289337,
-0.09730294346809387,
-0.11986818164587021,
-0.2016274631023407,
-0.5001258850097656,
-0.2168699949979782,
-0.2670708894729614,
0.6062193512916565,
-0.051796793937683105,
0.07890874147415161,
0.08476898819208145,
-0.26774242520332336,
0.31015753746032715,
0.2564108669757843,
0.7145618200302124,
1.21998929977417,
-0.39285027980804443,
0.1909029483795166,
0.3094421923160553,
-0.3883345127105713,
-0.05065629258751869,
0.23409175872802734,
-0.23665733635425568,
-0.008164873346686363,
0.6269872784614563,
0.9790175557136536,
0.12043816596269608,
-0.8960689902305603,
0.6213001012802124,
-0.34069404006004333,
-0.17043566703796387,
-0.18201318383216858,
0.1579718142747879,
0.167436882853508,
0.23599927127361298,
0.5089304447174072,
-0.18620163202285767,
0.4221975803375244,
-0.2769274413585663,
0.23871739208698273,
0.3640957176685333,
-0.24290572106838226,
-0.3889256417751312,
0.6073495745658875,
0.15696527063846588,
-0.37209638953208923,
0.4342009723186493,
-0.16930191218852997,
-0.5087273716926575,
0.5610978603363037,
0.329789400100708,
0.5362253189086914,
-0.32094523310661316,
0.360239177942276,
0.4796428978443146,
0.329079270362854,
-0.0011554030934348702,
0.15095217525959015,
0.06299138069152832,
-0.6783275604248047,
-0.11252237856388092,
-0.6614015102386475,
-0.6178478598594666,
0.4235086739063263,
-0.7676090002059937,
0.3953113257884979,
-0.3153200149536133,
-0.06912755966186523,
-0.017266809940338135,
0.30020710825920105,
-0.7275360822677612,
0.29656100273132324,
-0.18820638954639435,
1.2932884693145752,
-1.0010457038879395,
0.9825878739356995,
0.7537146210670471,
-0.08675137907266617,
-0.8023700714111328,
0.10529434680938721,
-0.005228310823440552,
-0.6023861169815063,
0.43999800086021423,
0.17293307185173035,
-0.007800305727869272,
0.012012242339551449,
-0.181361123919487,
-0.789028525352478,
1.1789910793304443,
0.6716200709342957,
-0.3725775480270386,
0.23002974689006805,
-0.18823190033435822,
0.577636182308197,
-0.3718899190425873,
0.45623260736465454,
0.7443113327026367,
0.5397628545761108,
0.1394127458333969,
-0.9207965135574341,
0.20082108676433563,
-0.4298900365829468,
-0.0016103636007755995,
-0.29823076725006104,
-0.43590959906578064,
0.7560561895370483,
-0.21165412664413452,
-0.38390064239501953,
0.1537618637084961,
0.5268398523330688,
0.5657631754875183,
0.6814310550689697,
0.6095367670059204,
0.2513415217399597,
1.1508930921554565,
-0.04723960906267166,
1.1122373342514038,
-0.2506757974624634,
0.3917810916900635,
1.2416032552719116,
-0.5431102514266968,
0.9318350553512573,
0.2501620948314667,
-0.49357330799102783,
0.3797968327999115,
0.7779698371887207,
0.12180501967668533,
0.7140893340110779,
-0.10437416285276413,
-0.09924337267875671,
-0.3420051038265228,
-0.1347133219242096,
-0.5304355621337891,
0.3659108877182007,
0.28326845169067383,
-0.17144915461540222,
-0.25226882100105286,
0.026892920956015587,
-0.18277238309383392,
0.0917929857969284,
-0.014967801049351692,
0.5066093802452087,
-0.18342363834381104,
-0.8116308450698853,
0.7415956258773804,
-0.15248769521713257,
0.28852856159210205,
-0.42451012134552,
0.06785836070775986,
-0.53407883644104,
-0.13165733218193054,
-0.0829971432685852,
-0.793971836566925,
0.30584582686424255,
-0.024951810017228127,
-0.27527081966400146,
0.08324915915727615,
0.8665302991867065,
-0.24072496592998505,
-0.4469331204891205,
0.2673495411872864,
0.705207884311676,
0.242048978805542,
-0.03476390987634659,
-0.7076491713523865,
0.1619301736354828,
-0.12704749405384064,
-0.37540680170059204,
0.31630465388298035,
0.2519236207008362,
-0.0890389233827591,
0.9324182271957397,
0.7328459620475769,
0.06678877025842667,
-0.011683952063322067,
0.22259049117565155,
0.8215233683586121,
-0.42367494106292725,
-0.4816550016403198,
-0.7037991881370544,
0.4806840717792511,
-0.19058343768119812,
-0.2456623762845993,
1.0242738723754883,
0.8282579779624939,
0.43000364303588867,
0.0840996652841568,
0.8614804148674011,
-0.02683507278561592,
1.0406460762023926,
-0.37952062487602234,
0.8510386943817139,
-0.5294084548950195,
0.4903613328933716,
0.011253141798079014,
-0.719562828540802,
-0.16941288113594055,
0.36429649591445923,
-0.7259457111358643,
0.09947120398283005,
0.7463183999061584,
0.8722766041755676,
0.03386254608631134,
0.16249319911003113,
0.7186318039894104,
0.36929044127464294,
0.08587386459112167,
0.295227587223053,
1.1794183254241943,
-0.15277762711048126,
0.46652427315711975,
-0.12281417846679688,
-0.23427900671958923,
-0.4201282262802124,
-1.0778770446777344,
-1.0330848693847656,
-0.9435663819313049,
-0.2552567422389984,
-0.20591653883457184,
0.0011494264472275972,
0.3331335484981537,
0.6883823871612549,
-0.927903950214386,
-0.08016315847635269,
-0.006689397152513266,
0.23734138906002045,
-0.320506751537323,
-0.2732888162136078,
0.459800124168396,
-0.2299337238073349,
-0.6159353256225586,
0.6300421953201294,
0.21189402043819427,
-0.16595646739006042,
-0.3023524582386017,
-0.23547594249248505,
-0.2854735255241394,
0.06220272555947304,
0.39195239543914795,
0.34598442912101746,
-0.9672966599464417,
-0.19464480876922607,
0.07306133210659027,
-0.03792848810553551,
-0.10947630554437637,
0.7083110809326172,
-1.0324286222457886,
0.5002787113189697,
0.5685552358627319,
0.495911568403244,
0.34292080998420715,
-0.0536683164536953,
0.648027241230011,
-0.6003682613372803,
0.13659822940826416,
0.37497350573539734,
0.34375399351119995,
0.5978534817695618,
-0.11097800731658936,
0.5226891040802002,
0.09343964606523514,
-0.5274155139923096,
-1.3113137483596802,
0.07304798066616058,
-0.7997960448265076,
-0.19680729508399963,
1.0920203924179077,
-0.5237535834312439,
0.018527580425143242,
-0.3688173294067383,
-0.0567798838019371,
0.13124048709869385,
-0.16288922727108002,
0.5888750553131104,
0.8111452460289001,
0.04349226877093315,
-0.2536427974700928,
-0.9700531363487244,
0.667220413684845,
0.35852840542793274,
-0.6903224587440491,
0.3332947790622711,
0.3078266382217407,
0.44492653012275696,
-0.02763177454471588,
0.4195069968700409,
0.0402340367436409,
0.2824365794658661,
-0.020325956866145134,
-0.4113428592681885,
-0.14728493988513947,
-0.26351213455200195,
-0.3163130283355713,
0.3151368796825409,
0.5595665574073792,
0.1724132001399994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04302v1
|
CBR-RAG: Case-Based Reasoning for Retrieval Augmented Generation in LLMs for Legal Question Answering
| 2024-04-04T21:47:43 | 2024-04-04T21:47:43 |
Nirmalie Wiratunga, Ramitha Abeyratne, Lasal Jayawardena, Kyle Martin, Stewart Massie, Ikechukwu Nkisi-Orji, Ruvan Weerasinghe, Anne Liret, Bruno Fleisch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) enhances Large Language Model (LLM)
output by providing prior knowledge as context to input. This is beneficial for
knowledge-intensive and expert reliant tasks, including legal
question-answering, which require evidence to validate generated text outputs.
We highlight that Case-Based Reasoning (CBR) presents key opportunities to
structure retrieval as part of the RAG process in an LLM. We introduce CBR-RAG,
where CBR cycle's initial retrieval stage, its indexing vocabulary, and
similarity knowledge containers are used to enhance LLM queries with
contextually relevant cases. This integration augments the original LLM query,
providing a richer prompt. We present an evaluation of CBR-RAG, and examine
different representations (i.e. general and domain-specific embeddings) and
methods of comparison (i.e. inter, intra and hybrid similarity) on the task of
legal question-answering. Our results indicate that the context provided by
CBR's case reuse enforces similarity between relevant components of the
questions and the evidence base leading to significant improvements in the
quality of generated answers.
|
[
-0.3800409734249115,
-0.9267849326133728,
0.871921718120575,
-0.2519803047180176,
-0.5466731190681458,
0.28709375858306885,
0.09841320663690567,
-0.20020681619644165,
0.2513788342475891,
0.9776108860969543,
-0.14905807375907898,
-0.40930917859077454,
-0.21081113815307617,
-0.03745846077799797,
-0.4943635165691376,
1.031124234199524,
0.005822955630719662,
0.22353871166706085,
-0.7128429412841797,
-0.39983657002449036,
-0.7282893061637878,
-0.8783604502677917,
-0.7080528736114502,
-0.18123193085193634,
0.5741060376167297,
0.17790666222572327,
0.2926085293292999,
0.4477841854095459,
0.5126894116401672,
0.22127866744995117,
-0.41777318716049194,
0.26931482553482056,
-0.32881996035575867,
0.5902673602104187,
-0.381136953830719,
-0.5999997854232788,
-0.3293631672859192,
-0.3643522262573242,
0.27707433700561523,
0.488551527261734,
-0.4935271143913269,
0.25728651881217957,
-0.3042371869087219,
0.7925180792808533,
-0.6687052249908447,
-0.29517021775245667,
-0.9984354972839355,
-0.06901824474334717,
-0.2506547272205353,
-0.5708464980125427,
-0.4658719599246979,
-0.20492886006832123,
-0.3124772608280182,
-0.5308718085289001,
0.5581696629524231,
0.4698444604873657,
0.6558678150177002,
0.46608397364616394,
-0.5639443397521973,
-0.6856082677841187,
-0.5297415256500244,
0.37841135263442993,
-0.620746910572052,
0.3415636122226715,
0.20546625554561615,
0.623020589351654,
-0.3360687494277954,
-0.922526478767395,
-0.8167350888252258,
-0.2660427391529083,
-0.13294614851474762,
0.43162640929222107,
0.12850487232208252,
-0.08387536555528641,
0.3891127407550812,
0.28552767634391785,
-0.5769258141517639,
-0.40662679076194763,
-0.3892996907234192,
-0.1601586788892746,
0.5316523313522339,
0.22525343298912048,
0.208934023976326,
-0.3167504370212555,
-0.08767643570899963,
-0.022947905585169792,
-0.8732461333274841,
0.12208113819360733,
0.31517982482910156,
0.24320654571056366,
0.3485293388366699,
0.8238527774810791,
-0.10884616523981094,
0.8428356647491455,
0.26458996534347534,
-0.23370398581027985,
0.0099616888910532,
-0.22871868312358856,
-0.14256680011749268,
0.23862765729427338,
0.2419937700033188,
0.2261665016412735,
-0.07799197733402252,
-0.015438330359756947,
-0.1920202672481537,
-0.32467636466026306,
0.47402963042259216,
-0.6947667598724365,
0.4290983974933624,
0.3546263873577118,
-0.5145875811576843,
-0.02112787775695324,
0.20374225080013275,
-0.4147363305091858,
-0.46319663524627686,
-0.47249481081962585,
0.08257827907800674,
-0.10539796203374863,
-0.1687239706516266,
0.1165611669421196,
-0.3801236152648926,
0.7818641066551208,
0.25147610902786255,
-0.2636960446834564,
0.3196755051612854,
1.0398107767105103,
0.2316937893629074,
-0.02127448096871376,
0.548679769039154,
-0.9565807580947876,
0.36137691140174866,
-0.5261582136154175,
1.0092321634292603,
-0.6152657866477966,
-0.511039674282074,
0.05073479190468788,
-0.04704985395073891,
0.15865430235862732,
-0.9476005434989929,
0.7259337306022644,
-1.032667636871338,
0.2314673513174057,
-0.5501465797424316,
-0.5683029890060425,
-0.022440413013100624,
0.4600527286529541,
-0.40986162424087524,
1.0069125890731812,
-0.09975846111774445,
-0.7519815564155579,
0.699790358543396,
-0.40864425897598267,
-0.69144207239151,
0.35010072588920593,
-0.3890257775783539,
-0.542582094669342,
0.19052869081497192,
0.2159157395362854,
0.21556484699249268,
-0.2809443175792694,
0.3247013986110687,
-0.22632411122322083,
-0.22178217768669128,
0.21304015815258026,
-0.018875448033213615,
0.765141487121582,
0.49818679690361023,
-0.13244183361530304,
-0.06326078623533249,
-0.6010444164276123,
-0.07206235826015472,
0.12365103513002396,
-0.5381121635437012,
-0.5942489504814148,
0.08421500772237778,
-0.4125113785266876,
-0.005344265140593052,
0.13278314471244812,
-0.6766065955162048,
-0.013127163983881474,
-0.37905725836753845,
0.023959405720233917,
0.24918542802333832,
0.43404147028923035,
0.22696314752101898,
-0.527229905128479,
0.6402620077133179,
0.020351480692625046,
-0.19511689245700836,
-0.14269626140594482,
-0.5041033625602722,
-0.6185563802719116,
-0.1754283607006073,
0.39437299966812134,
0.6167728304862976,
-0.8901264667510986,
-0.1013794094324112,
-0.14949865639209747,
-0.09065810590982437,
-0.5550859570503235,
-0.03486724942922592,
0.5013848543167114,
0.6070941686630249,
0.455799400806427,
-0.23611809313297272,
-0.6502231955528259,
-0.8095085024833679,
-0.44368717074394226,
-0.10892300307750702,
0.15538319945335388,
0.7148057222366333,
0.25562357902526855,
0.003850894747301936,
1.078958511352539,
-0.2526412904262543,
-0.05482933297753334,
-0.42786604166030884,
0.1717342734336853,
0.34540441632270813,
0.03371641784906387,
0.3920270800590515,
-1.039121389389038,
-0.5885485410690308,
0.1898769736289978,
-0.5326126217842102,
-0.3181392550468445,
-0.165081188082695,
-0.21017414331436157,
0.452312171459198,
0.7818636298179626,
-0.5232807397842407,
0.5478410124778748,
-0.01717330887913704,
-0.4658386707305908,
0.611428439617157,
-0.3055233955383301,
0.4582940936088562,
-1.3367741107940674,
0.041471198201179504,
-0.5592647194862366,
-0.5723438858985901,
-0.39117082953453064,
0.3937884271144867,
-0.03647376596927643,
-0.03273581340909004,
-0.4276692867279053,
0.6866776943206787,
-0.5283851027488708,
-0.4944491684436798,
-0.5883904099464417,
0.3426761329174042,
0.16971318423748016,
0.10156051069498062,
-0.19763459265232086,
1.071893572807312,
0.10967718064785004,
-0.47141939401626587,
0.31035467982292175,
0.2919616103172302,
-0.24982154369354248,
0.8071527481079102,
-0.5626621246337891,
0.4066111445426941,
-0.48124298453330994,
0.10805895924568176,
-0.6776828169822693,
-0.07434411346912384,
0.08878299593925476,
-0.47213488817214966,
0.6305157542228699,
-0.4650041460990906,
-0.5202439427375793,
-0.40171754360198975,
-0.013494495302438736,
0.4016661047935486,
0.5303224325180054,
-0.35629692673683167,
1.0072145462036133,
0.3864237368106842,
-0.31655895709991455,
-0.8066275119781494,
-0.5058479309082031,
0.05308964103460312,
-0.3652102053165436,
-0.25928473472595215,
0.4869460165500641,
-0.06287819147109985,
-0.6150190234184265,
0.3855603337287903,
-0.3155384361743927,
-0.2466324269771576,
-0.062180206179618835,
0.12949712574481964,
-0.011266352608799934,
-0.2893545925617218,
0.08251141011714935,
0.4984716475009918,
0.18700391054153442,
0.20622743666172028,
0.14707644283771515,
0.44411978125572205,
0.033794961869716644,
-0.5060416460037231,
0.37603843212127686,
0.49379876255989075,
0.25138914585113525,
-0.4336824119091034,
0.5274736285209656,
0.18291142582893372,
-0.05545530095696449,
-0.2317385971546173,
-0.9304973483085632,
0.09025201201438904,
-0.4067358672618866,
0.12843243777751923,
-0.6756400465965271,
-1.225001335144043,
0.5531327724456787,
0.019160695374011993,
-0.03463374823331833,
0.3790896534919739,
0.8092929720878601,
-0.3272399306297302,
0.6263152360916138,
0.28654351830482483,
0.2795957922935486,
0.2673361599445343,
0.0766240805387497,
0.1655949205160141,
-0.9560154676437378,
-0.2689768075942993,
-0.4931555986404419,
0.2580714225769043,
-0.3516664505004883,
-0.7394368052482605,
0.4714643657207489,
0.2325330376625061,
-0.17777785658836365,
0.1639203578233719,
-0.4999321699142456,
0.5866169333457947,
0.5611451864242554,
0.05594765022397041,
0.35786569118499756,
-0.07398398220539093,
-0.5493398308753967,
0.3550257682800293,
-0.7665697932243347,
-0.44584622979164124,
1.0974316596984863,
-0.20026300847530365,
0.24908187985420227,
0.22749480605125427,
0.9164791107177734,
0.33168143033981323,
0.4880847632884979,
-0.6909753084182739,
0.7259465456008911,
-0.14145256578922272,
-0.9629863500595093,
-0.029051590710878372,
-0.4218868911266327,
-1.158034324645996,
0.2604025602340698,
-0.29372817277908325,
-0.22428399324417114,
0.037117112427949905,
-0.004280979745090008,
-0.4147636592388153,
0.05181988328695297,
-0.26392844319343567,
0.5397412776947021,
-0.2401101440191269,
-0.46926963329315186,
-0.34898117184638977,
-0.5932916402816772,
0.263773649930954,
-0.13709087669849396,
0.33173123002052307,
0.1202569231390953,
0.09972026199102402,
0.6291514039039612,
-0.5977017879486084,
0.3113127052783966,
-0.22422632575035095,
0.1708771288394928,
0.956782341003418,
0.09909405559301376,
0.37847012281417847,
0.032932791858911514,
-0.012514065951108932,
-0.42672616243362427,
0.3228180408477783,
-0.05351261422038078,
-0.944318413734436,
0.40542131662368774,
-0.10164587199687958,
-1.24124276638031,
-0.37659186124801636,
-0.655796229839325,
-0.04757550358772278,
0.2045406848192215,
-0.19330279529094696,
0.5528688430786133,
0.06069609150290489,
0.4985031187534332,
0.6397251486778259,
-0.44578203558921814,
0.08027640730142593,
0.6749584078788757,
-0.3491586744785309,
-0.4038252532482147,
0.6279089450836182,
-0.06664041429758072,
-0.13296076655387878,
0.6677939295768738,
0.20740006864070892,
-0.4764637351036072,
-0.6105093359947205,
-0.31792786717414856,
0.36679765582084656,
-0.8070355653762817,
-0.5160060524940491,
-0.6514190435409546,
-0.15876898169517517,
-0.4112154543399811,
-0.08751974999904633,
-0.022530056536197662,
-0.5133829116821289,
0.09016182273626328,
-0.11126308143138885,
0.43124109506607056,
0.5663132071495056,
0.1311882883310318,
-0.13661809265613556,
-0.5731580853462219,
0.5999675393104553,
0.39751461148262024,
0.21062341332435608,
-0.47622498869895935,
-0.6659088134765625,
-0.07917289435863495,
-0.2162393480539322,
-0.29186856746673584,
-0.816031277179718,
0.17752619087696075,
-0.21561099588871002,
0.7892818450927734,
-0.04210641235113144,
0.1961691826581955,
0.7891841530799866,
-0.8520246744155884,
0.618435263633728,
-0.18873600661754608,
-0.5853114724159241,
0.5283042788505554,
-0.3265612721443176,
-0.12012553215026855,
0.6464017033576965,
0.10210666060447693,
-0.13384349644184113,
-0.5849570035934448,
-0.5632838606834412,
-0.8595979809761047,
0.2683787941932678,
0.10174089670181274,
0.16696113348007202,
-0.17295575141906738,
0.9080954194068909,
-0.04748424515128136,
0.26562386751174927,
-0.46729227900505066,
-0.19991876184940338,
-0.17510627210140228,
-0.146965891122818,
0.4570466876029968,
-0.43024304509162903,
-0.1514061838388443,
-0.30175119638442993,
0.5366902947425842,
-0.08144810050725937,
0.27984482049942017,
0.5385106801986694,
-0.05121263116598129,
0.22355055809020996,
0.506515622138977,
0.4990694224834442,
0.5809231996536255,
-0.1916053742170334,
-0.05283207446336746,
0.4905734658241272,
-0.2105589359998703,
0.11164457350969315,
0.12062540650367737,
-0.1745741218328476,
0.04988350346684456,
0.19164618849754333,
0.4360753297805786,
-0.2138618379831314,
-0.864558219909668,
0.4655776917934418,
-0.13077376782894135,
-0.439704030752182,
-0.4819217920303345,
-0.04310697689652443,
0.054819997400045395,
0.5100023746490479,
0.5387855768203735,
-0.39067888259887695,
0.4282473027706146,
-0.7166725397109985,
0.44911715388298035,
0.7530044913291931,
-0.09361352771520615,
0.4202451705932617,
0.7848984003067017,
-0.18247473239898682,
-0.28503233194351196,
0.17000459134578705,
-0.4221857488155365,
-0.561539351940155,
0.7119829058647156,
0.42918455600738525,
0.5725592374801636,
0.1685907393693924,
-0.09301111847162247,
0.39252111315727234,
0.07057496905326843,
0.04609993100166321,
0.5053665041923523,
-0.30943819880485535,
-0.6451419591903687,
-0.7921585440635681,
-0.6185432076454163,
-0.5503195524215698,
-0.1364186555147171,
-0.7808936834335327,
0.14309783279895782,
-0.35847148299217224,
-0.09546420723199844,
-0.4694831371307373,
-0.05837464705109596,
-0.4828565716743469,
0.27884581685066223,
-0.0655459612607956,
0.7476048469543457,
-0.18853677809238434,
0.6930090188980103,
0.880357027053833,
-0.5981682538986206,
-0.93161541223526,
0.042965203523635864,
-0.22058728337287903,
-0.5632286071777344,
0.8590303659439087,
-0.04646829143166542,
-0.15770086646080017,
-0.213545560836792,
-0.36470603942871094,
-0.6252573132514954,
1.1911638975143433,
0.1871880143880844,
-0.464349627494812,
0.1349364072084427,
0.2914953827857971,
0.7344712615013123,
-0.3960946500301361,
0.19205160439014435,
0.484910786151886,
0.22405870258808136,
0.5286855101585388,
-0.5007755756378174,
0.22595690190792084,
-0.21782295405864716,
0.018819913268089294,
0.147345170378685,
-0.20710593461990356,
0.41130268573760986,
-0.13493281602859497,
-0.3093991279602051,
0.12298791110515594,
0.6760869026184082,
0.8246285319328308,
0.5760345458984375,
0.3925393521785736,
0.6949087977409363,
0.6456348299980164,
-0.1621570736169815,
1.3437814712524414,
-0.45947501063346863,
0.09313957393169403,
1.2888379096984863,
-0.349944531917572,
0.9108037948608398,
0.5832040905952454,
0.02513340674340725,
0.7680890560150146,
0.24411730468273163,
0.17891797423362732,
0.4814864695072174,
0.378675639629364,
-0.2351892739534378,
-0.36148205399513245,
-0.14507514238357544,
-0.265412837266922,
0.22696217894554138,
0.25610101222991943,
-0.21040430665016174,
-0.016185853630304337,
-0.15906591713428497,
-0.1636536866426468,
0.4234278202056885,
-0.3490876257419586,
1.0967849493026733,
0.15496686100959778,
-0.7692804932594299,
0.2544628381729126,
-0.06759876757860184,
0.29484787583351135,
-0.24054469168186188,
-0.22308091819286346,
-0.6179017424583435,
-0.17045263946056366,
0.00037484263884834945,
-0.8839426636695862,
0.7433869242668152,
0.3271270990371704,
-0.2850019931793213,
-0.20232369005680084,
0.9366243481636047,
-0.22709442675113678,
-0.5325239896774292,
0.22605273127555847,
0.6532763242721558,
0.24507977068424225,
-0.03492467477917671,
-0.7220340371131897,
-0.28939276933670044,
-0.33694788813591003,
-0.32061904668807983,
0.15283489227294922,
0.8530569672584534,
-0.19871053099632263,
0.6509105563163757,
0.7580339908599854,
0.11456696689128876,
0.22075021266937256,
0.3590303063392639,
1.0234531164169312,
-0.7304919958114624,
-0.14284999668598175,
-0.39886710047721863,
0.5065041780471802,
-0.23646411299705505,
0.2155272364616394,
0.5680590867996216,
0.8468844890594482,
0.6902329325675964,
0.17603649199008942,
0.5479357838630676,
-0.2558061182498932,
1.0639559030532837,
-0.6794111728668213,
0.5724954009056091,
-0.7628320455551147,
0.32822203636169434,
-0.17116715013980865,
-0.9273079037666321,
-0.29604196548461914,
0.3811502456665039,
-0.39967110753059387,
0.09983965009450912,
0.7617392539978027,
0.969414234161377,
-0.06884325295686722,
-0.5618632435798645,
0.5221742391586304,
0.011918986216187477,
0.3007073700428009,
0.22944903373718262,
0.8263994455337524,
-0.26169583201408386,
0.8720664978027344,
0.18290409445762634,
0.13248392939567566,
-0.09438303112983704,
-0.8128208518028259,
-0.8592544198036194,
-0.3945223391056061,
-0.12585294246673584,
-0.44188830256462097,
0.25667136907577515,
0.628272533416748,
0.3278201222419739,
-0.8269609212875366,
-0.08975141495466232,
-0.25248754024505615,
0.14790630340576172,
-0.0225962046533823,
-0.28151533007621765,
0.1628854125738144,
-0.5852614641189575,
-0.35599836707115173,
0.4117397964000702,
0.10784048587083817,
-0.24932022392749786,
0.29311469197273254,
0.002203046577051282,
-0.17216822504997253,
0.3288051187992096,
0.7626093626022339,
0.2838236391544342,
-0.8427076935768127,
-0.30621659755706787,
-0.04230010136961937,
-0.029353067278862,
0.12023605406284332,
1.1329268217086792,
-0.830574095249176,
0.40060222148895264,
0.5042896270751953,
1.1008390188217163,
0.9180722832679749,
0.3513471484184265,
0.48780542612075806,
-0.7046597003936768,
0.03989025205373764,
0.2834315896034241,
0.6908197402954102,
0.2628292143344879,
-0.22059334814548492,
0.5383590459823608,
0.16345350444316864,
-0.6250746250152588,
-0.6942092180252075,
0.3109789490699768,
-1.0976219177246094,
-0.5493195652961731,
1.2065273523330688,
0.01665540598332882,
-0.1663849949836731,
-0.4487067461013794,
-0.42664557695388794,
0.3790189325809479,
-0.17060774564743042,
0.5394196510314941,
0.5547782182693481,
-0.0178788211196661,
-0.3704212009906769,
-0.6267783641815186,
0.3020174503326416,
0.5275442004203796,
-0.8390477895736694,
-0.09909393638372421,
0.5891547799110413,
0.4623422622680664,
0.20249463617801666,
0.6379132270812988,
-0.4299688935279846,
0.2836258113384247,
-0.15570610761642456,
0.04295041039586067,
-0.2582858204841614,
-0.15569372475147247,
0.03131036460399628,
0.3796229064464569,
0.026443442329764366,
0.2524305582046509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04298v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04298v1
|
SELF-[IN]CORRECT: LLMs Struggle with Refining Self-Generated Responses
| 2024-04-04T20:27:37 | 2024-04-04T20:27:37 |
Dongwei Jiang, Jingyu Zhang, Orion Weller, Nathaniel Weir, Benjamin Van Durme, Daniel Khashabi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Can LLMs continually improve their previous outputs for better results? An
affirmative answer would require LLMs to be better at discriminating among
previously-generated alternatives, than generating initial responses. We
explore the validity of this hypothesis in practice. We first introduce a
unified framework that allows us to compare the generative and discriminative
capability of any model on any task. Then, in our resulting experimental
analysis of several LLMs, we do not observe the performance of those models on
discrimination to be reliably better than generation. We hope these findings
inform the growing literature on self-improvement AI systems.
|
[
-0.13358129560947418,
-0.6347821354866028,
0.8042424917221069,
-0.01998736523091793,
0.11467400938272476,
0.3953251838684082,
-0.06013672798871994,
-0.5240650177001953,
-0.03435257822275162,
0.288085013628006,
-0.6221849918365479,
-0.009899402037262917,
-0.5938970446586609,
0.8445881605148315,
-0.5434859991073608,
0.6399154663085938,
0.0619349330663681,
0.37669581174850464,
-0.634020984172821,
-0.2060975730419159,
-0.7955783009529114,
-0.38539838790893555,
-0.7745263576507568,
-0.528332531452179,
0.35223814845085144,
0.5989544987678528,
0.33516162633895874,
0.4149746596813202,
0.6443687081336975,
0.4059678912162781,
0.26080819964408875,
0.2655479907989502,
-0.5669675469398499,
0.5725398659706116,
-0.1742381751537323,
-0.6382365822792053,
-0.23427854478359222,
0.1972571313381195,
0.5103406310081482,
0.44098949432373047,
-0.1564714014530182,
0.3106474280357361,
0.3949020206928253,
0.6591667532920837,
-0.41892552375793457,
-0.38116440176963806,
-0.8854105472564697,
0.06323666870594025,
-0.2168041169643402,
-0.10317730903625488,
-0.39135363698005676,
-0.3755691945552826,
-0.22045165300369263,
-0.37559011578559875,
0.6255722641944885,
0.005980544723570347,
0.7560607194900513,
0.6777512431144714,
-0.27487170696258545,
-0.37575772404670715,
-0.9048669934272766,
0.45360732078552246,
-0.8285512328147888,
0.25038427114486694,
0.0819774717092514,
0.2721204161643982,
-0.24065455794334412,
-0.8201524019241333,
-0.47821760177612305,
-0.5333982706069946,
0.03547276183962822,
0.30602848529815674,
-0.05155891925096512,
-0.07194789499044418,
0.44789960980415344,
0.6608607769012451,
-0.46839064359664917,
0.43771040439605713,
-0.384507954120636,
-0.15412591397762299,
0.8605552315711975,
0.4518842101097107,
0.08249231427907944,
-0.020147696137428284,
-0.36877503991127014,
0.15448594093322754,
-0.9450075626373291,
-0.06507059186697006,
0.15308351814746857,
0.200046569108963,
0.32219213247299194,
0.7291349172592163,
-0.2031446248292923,
0.3524862229824066,
0.5791805982589722,
-0.1549355387687683,
0.23113596439361572,
-0.2619561553001404,
-0.354107141494751,
-0.09647964686155319,
0.49132972955703735,
0.21150004863739014,
-0.11246012151241302,
-0.3373839855194092,
-0.5546675324440002,
0.2543375492095947,
0.6621353626251221,
-0.4727165699005127,
-0.11378421634435654,
0.28340208530426025,
-0.6329243183135986,
-0.04413650929927826,
-0.16084438562393188,
-0.3617689311504364,
-0.3546172082424164,
-0.4103619158267975,
0.498070627450943,
-0.08865319192409515,
-0.25936126708984375,
-0.06877198815345764,
-0.24332234263420105,
0.1997818499803543,
0.2064601629972458,
-0.7112686038017273,
0.2647286653518677,
0.5369229912757874,
0.718981921672821,
-0.4630252420902252,
-0.19353847205638885,
-0.46775949001312256,
-0.07087057828903198,
-0.5041733384132385,
1.0254958868026733,
-0.25429996848106384,
-0.7679089307785034,
-0.08993000537157059,
-0.15644994378089905,
-0.07135485112667084,
-1.2181283235549927,
0.3949672281742096,
-0.44131532311439514,
0.09830420464277267,
-0.6226617693901062,
-0.9080604910850525,
0.29792121052742004,
0.24091753363609314,
-0.23180721700191498,
0.9716358780860901,
0.35671132802963257,
-0.3794175684452057,
0.6481735706329346,
-0.8175673484802246,
-0.21082980930805206,
0.2114344984292984,
-0.3498245179653168,
-0.541621208190918,
0.44529271125793457,
-0.037481606006622314,
0.33383968472480774,
-0.09127818048000336,
0.23613771796226501,
-0.7770372033119202,
-0.37084344029426575,
0.4416254758834839,
-0.2814640998840332,
0.6391301155090332,
0.5121366381645203,
-0.49217525124549866,
0.08612243086099625,
-0.806163489818573,
-0.003965590614825487,
0.2927112579345703,
-0.4363509714603424,
0.09086432307958603,
0.1589370220899582,
-0.7494273781776428,
0.11280238628387451,
0.230690598487854,
-0.8448662757873535,
0.3450748026371002,
-0.24736012518405914,
0.21971756219863892,
1.1401132345199585,
-0.17863886058330536,
0.43657055497169495,
-0.587739109992981,
0.5875768661499023,
-0.18689313530921936,
0.05102796480059624,
-0.07448703050613403,
-0.1780620813369751,
-1.2365244626998901,
-0.204625204205513,
0.18573816120624542,
0.29048508405685425,
-0.6800451278686523,
0.25874245166778564,
-0.02483505941927433,
-0.17048081755638123,
-0.41155025362968445,
0.42919817566871643,
0.4220331311225891,
0.6415936350822449,
0.2542456388473511,
-0.5701315999031067,
-0.6397503614425659,
-0.6891672015190125,
-0.2604174315929413,
-0.3477674126625061,
-0.09692657738924026,
0.10973672568798065,
0.4783279299736023,
-0.29678431153297424,
0.6607837080955505,
-0.1032404825091362,
0.11307036876678467,
-0.01369345560669899,
0.1409967988729477,
0.028810596093535423,
0.2910444736480713,
0.37817510962486267,
-0.2636965811252594,
-0.42227619886398315,
-0.3144747018814087,
-1.1203027963638306,
-0.27853885293006897,
-0.07515877485275269,
-0.028617987409234047,
0.20678140223026276,
0.5473570823669434,
-0.3353533148765564,
0.559567391872406,
0.061225440353155136,
-0.21352189779281616,
0.6608132719993591,
-0.22838693857192993,
0.20824825763702393,
-0.6307435631752014,
-0.2929528057575226,
-0.15266796946525574,
-0.20313382148742676,
-0.42727670073509216,
-0.08761535584926605,
-0.042490046471357346,
0.147769495844841,
-0.1352943629026413,
0.41712191700935364,
-0.48542502522468567,
-0.3026689887046814,
-0.6949602961540222,
0.05753473564982414,
-0.32056695222854614,
0.1163586750626564,
-0.37321752309799194,
0.9794312715530396,
0.5998972058296204,
-1.0386435985565186,
0.5415775179862976,
0.15392199158668518,
-0.3239283263683319,
0.7899754047393799,
-0.777576208114624,
0.3481956720352173,
-0.3822534680366516,
-0.0013085633981972933,
-1.3754172325134277,
-0.40969833731651306,
0.34696656465530396,
-0.38154494762420654,
0.3305005431175232,
0.3746725022792816,
-0.3232117295265198,
-0.737671434879303,
-0.06467032432556152,
0.23403368890285492,
0.6360349655151367,
-0.8800011873245239,
0.40073588490486145,
-0.0765814483165741,
-0.1032574474811554,
-0.3186148405075073,
-0.5885010957717896,
0.05739680677652359,
-0.32122939825057983,
-0.38234689831733704,
0.29072874784469604,
-0.3910380005836487,
-0.5052068829536438,
-0.11328327655792236,
-0.15659764409065247,
0.2804368734359741,
0.3818493187427521,
0.15582865476608276,
-0.04919685795903206,
-0.21005839109420776,
0.3038708567619324,
-0.16705071926116943,
-0.08193076401948929,
0.2971671223640442,
0.166184201836586,
0.26707637310028076,
0.11424179375171661,
-0.8110057711601257,
-0.40639200806617737,
0.1680375188589096,
0.1858033537864685,
-0.16652759909629822,
0.0300959050655365,
0.2891068160533905,
-0.005642344243824482,
-0.09578326344490051,
-0.6956597566604614,
-0.23567239940166473,
-0.49578601121902466,
0.17285175621509552,
-0.6132708191871643,
-1.1248807907104492,
0.4430130422115326,
0.015232211910188198,
0.27010858058929443,
0.7422100901603699,
0.5380910634994507,
-0.5411316156387329,
1.1733547449111938,
0.7261413931846619,
0.2127341479063034,
0.19302023947238922,
-0.28546643257141113,
-0.09224165976047516,
-0.9038667678833008,
-0.3771207928657532,
-0.7044991850852966,
-0.35081973671913147,
-0.6251945495605469,
0.28232574462890625,
0.28910064697265625,
0.08499377965927124,
-0.4083099663257599,
0.030319973826408386,
-0.7398913502693176,
0.22689056396484375,
0.7283777594566345,
0.13822151720523834,
0.20450390875339508,
-0.17224203050136566,
0.07097920030355453,
-0.11962439864873886,
-0.858173668384552,
-0.5052487254142761,
1.1012903451919556,
0.4414025843143463,
0.8219645619392395,
0.26867538690567017,
1.0530242919921875,
0.46517547965049744,
1.1040812730789185,
-0.41431576013565063,
0.3856434226036072,
0.09029736369848251,
-0.6979129314422607,
-0.2160596251487732,
-0.34410470724105835,
-1.1705281734466553,
0.15760158002376556,
-0.15895454585552216,
-0.5256364345550537,
0.24632538855075836,
0.4016731083393097,
-0.5056765675544739,
0.2611551284790039,
-0.420273095369339,
0.6467370390892029,
-0.7914565801620483,
-0.2336505949497223,
-0.18235479295253754,
-0.3744024932384491,
0.4018365144729614,
-0.1939777135848999,
-0.23919549584388733,
-0.3905639350414276,
0.04206719249486923,
0.5859149098396301,
-0.5260394215583801,
0.7708228826522827,
-0.15278761088848114,
-0.29679521918296814,
0.4996282160282135,
0.07698764652013779,
0.17300058901309967,
-0.06872578710317612,
-0.16613198816776276,
-0.15896089375019073,
-0.2807968556880951,
-0.5913311839103699,
-0.8957593441009521,
0.352967768907547,
-0.621966540813446,
-1.1753636598587036,
-0.4179389476776123,
-0.07235053181648254,
-0.16066807508468628,
0.13562877476215363,
0.4938749074935913,
0.390651136636734,
-0.35133785009384155,
-0.004164030775427818,
0.47614648938179016,
0.0826025977730751,
0.5911658406257629,
0.6209206581115723,
-0.3447674512863159,
-0.326803058385849,
0.6024847030639648,
0.22797173261642456,
0.320220947265625,
-0.03097796067595482,
0.05403066426515579,
-0.6135522723197937,
-0.6765494346618652,
-0.4890865981578827,
0.05163475498557091,
-0.6115254759788513,
-0.4827931523323059,
-0.17387211322784424,
-0.013783270493149757,
-0.5978316068649292,
0.0607704296708107,
-0.1446560025215149,
-0.050245095044374466,
-0.33770161867141724,
-0.1703016608953476,
-0.029900526627898216,
1.3922679424285889,
-0.4862644076347351,
0.1480027139186859,
-0.4422248601913452,
0.32672804594039917,
0.7195944786071777,
0.2161889225244522,
-0.042539775371551514,
-0.9231320023536682,
-0.15249234437942505,
0.22423256933689117,
-0.787168025970459,
-0.6853439807891846,
0.0853474959731102,
0.13427945971488953,
0.8026548027992249,
0.37700173258781433,
-0.06808798760175705,
0.7368384599685669,
-0.2690494656562805,
0.9951609969139099,
0.19567473232746124,
-0.632632315158844,
0.5695570707321167,
0.056703146547079086,
0.39207348227500916,
0.49035197496414185,
0.2545527219772339,
-0.09283599257469177,
-0.5369645953178406,
-0.7743965983390808,
-0.2793218791484833,
0.3423174321651459,
0.21089164912700653,
0.2485879361629486,
-0.37103772163391113,
0.860319197177887,
0.23320777714252472,
0.2431713044643402,
-0.7655655741691589,
-0.3641950488090515,
-0.2935352623462677,
0.048723820596933365,
-0.09844066202640533,
-0.48831722140312195,
0.09613646566867828,
-0.24663250148296356,
0.7217711806297302,
0.01706792414188385,
0.4404068887233734,
0.4529891014099121,
0.0760338306427002,
-0.312186598777771,
0.052898284047842026,
0.44606906175613403,
0.8653894662857056,
-0.021713119000196457,
0.13592787086963654,
0.5011703372001648,
0.1597284972667694,
0.6022586822509766,
-0.228058859705925,
-0.1500965803861618,
0.011445592157542706,
0.38049501180648804,
0.43862542510032654,
-0.31021448969841003,
-0.37155136466026306,
0.33165067434310913,
-0.20900271832942963,
-0.2746010720729828,
-0.3596501648426056,
0.5773106217384338,
-0.4136693775653839,
0.3940514922142029,
0.4677870571613312,
0.14605624973773956,
0.2820281386375427,
-0.7286378741264343,
0.3634943962097168,
0.7172755599021912,
-0.22070510685443878,
-0.0016121452208608389,
0.8506733775138855,
0.3991749882698059,
-0.7872455716133118,
0.8681141138076782,
-0.36965814232826233,
-0.35756397247314453,
0.7183639407157898,
0.7228479385375977,
1.0278692245483398,
-0.3394818603992462,
0.17766627669334412,
0.4620312750339508,
0.02815772220492363,
-0.05232973396778107,
0.04890408366918564,
-0.23422393202781677,
-0.9614987969398499,
-0.4116702377796173,
-0.29627352952957153,
-0.30309295654296875,
0.1920972317457199,
-0.6571060419082642,
-0.2173062413930893,
-0.43331608176231384,
-0.4645514488220215,
-0.10712562501430511,
-0.03892790153622627,
-0.6744645833969116,
0.42349371314048767,
-0.045182663947343826,
0.5972604155540466,
-0.4905776381492615,
0.47485437989234924,
0.4895937740802765,
-0.5379273295402527,
-0.5723705291748047,
-0.10475107282400131,
-0.23326103389263153,
-0.8328186869621277,
0.8167148232460022,
0.2716154158115387,
-0.2175280749797821,
-0.2873051166534424,
-0.9927638173103333,
-1.0356146097183228,
1.081775188446045,
0.4194360375404358,
-0.4908023178577423,
0.12319348007440567,
0.12082167714834213,
0.6684059500694275,
-0.4563279151916504,
0.2547559142112732,
0.47084012627601624,
0.29180267453193665,
-0.1495184302330017,
-0.8508885502815247,
-0.17056450247764587,
-0.21055029332637787,
0.2186630666255951,
-0.06629793345928192,
-0.7723207473754883,
0.7433663606643677,
-0.4574592113494873,
-0.4903142750263214,
0.5760986804962158,
1.2119371891021729,
0.11742519587278366,
0.5186952352523804,
0.5034796595573425,
0.8097347021102905,
0.8374143242835999,
-0.2454521656036377,
0.978032112121582,
-0.18717136979103088,
0.27077794075012207,
1.2567130327224731,
-0.24757042527198792,
0.40854132175445557,
0.09681481122970581,
-0.42469942569732666,
0.5256472826004028,
0.9301899671554565,
-0.15749947726726532,
0.4406560957431793,
0.35968834161758423,
-0.3157781958580017,
-0.4609564244747162,
0.0897437036037445,
-0.408048540353775,
0.44360798597335815,
-0.08184509724378586,
-0.29941892623901367,
-0.08577802032232285,
-0.04465780779719353,
-0.281868040561676,
0.31319108605384827,
-0.39445173740386963,
0.8571472764015198,
-0.008264350704848766,
-0.8879375457763672,
0.7190756797790527,
-0.09634795784950256,
0.8254762887954712,
-0.2703630328178406,
-0.12985675036907196,
-0.6160470843315125,
0.11357053369283676,
-0.3198937177658081,
-0.6276543736457825,
0.2916630208492279,
-0.026575565338134766,
-0.2677581310272217,
-0.1579281985759735,
0.8829831480979919,
-0.24445730447769165,
-0.3877652883529663,
0.1705172061920166,
0.7272964715957642,
0.23165932297706604,
0.37203505635261536,
-0.8488470315933228,
-0.030988693237304688,
0.026884088292717934,
0.15245367586612701,
0.0601213313639164,
0.21744784712791443,
0.37129130959510803,
0.994279146194458,
0.28354501724243164,
-0.08553868532180786,
0.228472039103508,
0.19114191830158234,
0.46580299735069275,
-0.5565219521522522,
0.027363842353224754,
-0.9151933789253235,
0.3951241672039032,
-0.25582343339920044,
-0.48580026626586914,
1.060562252998352,
0.6076070666313171,
1.2507370710372925,
0.07667071372270584,
0.8108707666397095,
0.020279476419091225,
0.7522843480110168,
-0.5899198651313782,
-0.011714094318449497,
-0.7992700338363647,
0.17070168256759644,
-0.05773485079407692,
-0.7534633874893188,
0.0969376191496849,
0.7378638982772827,
-0.12459173053503036,
0.37187668681144714,
0.4704648554325104,
0.9326556324958801,
0.19833675026893616,
-0.17203488945960999,
0.4015812873840332,
0.27326175570487976,
0.32499340176582336,
0.129744291305542,
1.3993854522705078,
-0.17395873367786407,
0.11242713779211044,
-0.1298184096813202,
-0.010597484186291695,
0.044380005449056625,
-0.4978642463684082,
-0.6785745024681091,
-0.44122540950775146,
-0.4107803702354431,
-0.5846148133277893,
0.17120130360126495,
0.7649834156036377,
0.4368514120578766,
-0.6350592374801636,
-0.350784033536911,
-0.14221994578838348,
0.11892751604318619,
-0.04302487149834633,
-0.1433478742837906,
-0.07986022531986237,
-0.9559986591339111,
-0.5202269554138184,
0.49424317479133606,
0.2269810438156128,
0.22367633879184723,
-0.5316260457038879,
-0.38523703813552856,
0.2670600116252899,
0.10041119903326035,
0.6181298494338989,
0.4215611219406128,
-0.8137966394424438,
-0.6625577807426453,
-0.02266007475554943,
-0.20767362415790558,
0.4321446716785431,
0.7541946172714233,
-0.6327840685844421,
0.5364285707473755,
0.06141500547528267,
0.7671061754226685,
0.3311392068862915,
0.13790296018123627,
0.5215821266174316,
-0.36122024059295654,
-0.5536710023880005,
0.13877467811107635,
0.5621382594108582,
0.5683751702308655,
-0.32208195328712463,
0.7395785450935364,
0.3395593762397766,
-0.9249884486198425,
-0.6995267868041992,
0.5190935134887695,
-0.2826622426509857,
-0.2133176177740097,
1.0201486349105835,
-0.01502173114567995,
-0.04907270893454552,
-0.12071844935417175,
-0.1990550309419632,
0.21083058416843414,
-0.14744259417057037,
1.1772955656051636,
0.4512498676776886,
-0.8779528737068176,
-0.017975443974137306,
0.043559782207012177,
0.4763801097869873,
0.6370000839233398,
-0.7140894532203674,
-0.2400987297296524,
0.6163468360900879,
0.485887736082077,
0.1615571528673172,
1.1295877695083618,
0.055863600224256516,
0.36580005288124084,
-0.10786277055740356,
-0.12595117092132568,
0.18064634501934052,
-0.41100913286209106,
-0.46070465445518494,
-0.10085563361644745,
0.5672546029090881,
-0.24561730027198792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03746v1
|
GenQREnsemble: Zero-Shot LLM Ensemble Prompting for Generative Query Reformulation
| 2024-04-04T18:35:25 | 2024-04-04T18:35:25 |
Kaustubh Dhole, Eugene Agichtein
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Query Reformulation(QR) is a set of techniques used to transform a user's
original search query to a text that better aligns with the user's intent and
improves their search experience. Recently, zero-shot QR has been shown to be a
promising approach due to its ability to exploit knowledge inherent in large
language models. By taking inspiration from the success of ensemble prompting
strategies which have benefited many tasks, we investigate if they can help
improve query reformulation. In this context, we propose an ensemble based
prompting technique, GenQREnsemble which leverages paraphrases of a zero-shot
instruction to generate multiple sets of keywords ultimately improving
retrieval performance. We further introduce its post-retrieval variant,
GenQREnsembleRF to incorporate pseudo relevant feedback. On evaluations over
four IR benchmarks, we find that GenQREnsemble generates better reformulations
with relative nDCG@10 improvements up to 18% and MAP improvements upto 24% over
the previous zero-shot state-of-art. On the MSMarco Passage Ranking task,
GenQREnsembleRF shows relative gains of 5% MRR using pseudo-relevance feedback,
and 9% nDCG@10 using relevant feedback documents.
|
[
-0.29392632842063904,
-0.6690319180488586,
0.5494585037231445,
-0.24134644865989685,
-0.40172338485717773,
0.16620808839797974,
-0.1965663880109787,
0.20025430619716644,
0.358451247215271,
0.6015727519989014,
-0.5539426207542419,
-0.5301869511604309,
-0.02537347376346588,
0.2385515719652176,
-0.5921436548233032,
1.0024340152740479,
0.22389601171016693,
0.03532375767827034,
-0.3285834491252899,
0.0026008905842900276,
-0.37845054268836975,
-0.40975943207740784,
-0.6777001023292542,
-0.11168153584003448,
0.5624056458473206,
0.5430667996406555,
0.31337466835975647,
0.2783275246620178,
0.3079130947589874,
0.26179683208465576,
-0.14498966932296753,
0.0627555400133133,
-0.7465269565582275,
0.9392325282096863,
-0.11916034668684006,
-0.7358272671699524,
0.013341972604393959,
-0.25136256217956543,
0.6902206540107727,
0.15603050589561462,
-0.5954931974411011,
0.11826516687870026,
0.29048997163772583,
0.5913841128349304,
-0.84941565990448,
-0.17194896936416626,
-0.8885071873664856,
0.05881989002227783,
-0.29240402579307556,
-0.7914990782737732,
-0.36222636699676514,
-0.41173064708709717,
-0.4133804738521576,
-0.6707954406738281,
0.5858997106552124,
0.15698428452014923,
0.4910411536693573,
0.19138826429843903,
-0.149766206741333,
0.05456732213497162,
-0.7197299599647522,
0.6783120036125183,
-0.6458239555358887,
0.2804241180419922,
0.19601505994796753,
0.7107251286506653,
-0.35086631774902344,
-0.9235550165176392,
-0.6262298226356506,
0.04657403752207756,
0.12793584167957306,
0.30285483598709106,
-0.24848277866840363,
0.18983185291290283,
0.10425037890672684,
0.435909628868103,
-0.6586201190948486,
-0.3468678295612335,
-0.62369704246521,
-0.1564159244298935,
0.729439914226532,
0.30194979906082153,
0.25180357694625854,
-0.1294471025466919,
-0.3381419777870178,
-0.6090625524520874,
-0.7364524006843567,
0.03157936781644821,
0.1356441229581833,
0.24284815788269043,
0.5429319143295288,
0.5498263835906982,
-0.7930628657341003,
0.7801656126976013,
0.5177404880523682,
0.1554393172264099,
0.026726005598902702,
-0.567030131816864,
-0.2557448148727417,
0.35351482033729553,
0.8680160045623779,
0.5032199025154114,
-0.08229625970125198,
-0.28841185569763184,
-0.49230828881263733,
-0.3244442641735077,
0.29868924617767334,
-0.8228733539581299,
-0.43218645453453064,
0.2543468177318573,
-0.371914267539978,
-0.35079482197761536,
0.06728006154298782,
-0.9421024322509766,
-0.09595856070518494,
-0.08051009476184845,
0.7149753570556641,
-0.7771748900413513,
0.16790173947811127,
0.06246335431933403,
-0.5827761292457581,
0.782829761505127,
0.4904108941555023,
-0.7397693395614624,
-0.02296515740454197,
0.7034776210784912,
0.6676284074783325,
0.3034745752811432,
-0.15372438728809357,
-0.8600075244903564,
0.032516609877347946,
-0.35531631112098694,
1.1225793361663818,
-0.8371462225914001,
-0.81755530834198,
-0.2394426316022873,
-0.09182004630565643,
-0.4145128130912781,
-0.6050419211387634,
0.651513397693634,
-0.8451806306838989,
0.6321631669998169,
-0.3458545207977295,
-0.698245644569397,
-0.10869060456752777,
0.5471111536026001,
-0.3417736291885376,
1.092267632484436,
-0.036981724202632904,
-0.40782925486564636,
0.30685698986053467,
-0.5186344981193542,
-0.20772086083889008,
0.6599763035774231,
-0.3019356429576874,
-0.18025954067707062,
0.13076405227184296,
0.5163965225219727,
0.13632500171661377,
-0.04062417149543762,
-0.08672597259283066,
-0.08931069821119308,
-0.6964312791824341,
-0.003177558071911335,
-0.31910648941993713,
0.5476602911949158,
0.2343284785747528,
-0.1528777778148651,
0.27774930000305176,
-0.40523746609687805,
0.5235550999641418,
0.041303396224975586,
-0.17682169377803802,
-0.3410276770591736,
-0.23740606009960175,
-0.2610589861869812,
-0.04861391335725784,
0.06289821863174438,
-0.3358258008956909,
0.4916391372680664,
-0.2798144221305847,
0.5362353324890137,
0.3254694938659668,
0.6060218811035156,
0.6218836307525635,
-0.6055466532707214,
1.1689027547836304,
-0.2922325134277344,
0.10450264066457748,
-0.5276180505752563,
-0.551652193069458,
-0.26474982500076294,
-0.20695860683918,
0.5229995250701904,
0.6083982586860657,
-1.3851497173309326,
0.018363988026976585,
-0.22738564014434814,
-0.33566275238990784,
-0.9414804577827454,
0.11667870730161667,
0.4136052131652832,
0.6022338271141052,
0.5374813675880432,
-0.005551982671022415,
-0.455929160118103,
-0.5023255944252014,
-0.3317010998725891,
-0.12667332589626312,
-0.18571941554546356,
0.12762261927127838,
0.20948931574821472,
0.2727992534637451,
0.7207406163215637,
-0.48236703872680664,
-0.22173845767974854,
-0.3271850645542145,
0.2477734535932541,
0.09694895893335342,
0.3552112877368927,
0.3804498016834259,
-0.6311289668083191,
-0.3465592563152313,
-0.37144607305526733,
-0.3724226653575897,
0.017184928059577942,
-0.11990436911582947,
-0.37077954411506653,
-0.10155563056468964,
0.8767753839492798,
-0.6539825797080994,
0.1672390103340149,
0.026160746812820435,
-0.04529274255037308,
0.7249813675880432,
-0.21719348430633545,
0.7220840454101562,
-1.1229584217071533,
-0.013778641819953918,
-0.3397004008293152,
-0.011072253808379173,
-0.4574376940727234,
0.4970676004886627,
0.17615418136119843,
-0.12326852977275848,
-0.5576791167259216,
0.48343631625175476,
-0.5240229964256287,
0.29738032817840576,
-0.13591298460960388,
0.08316149562597275,
0.16891391575336456,
0.06203612685203552,
-0.35546067357063293,
1.2876967191696167,
0.401249498128891,
-0.7301071286201477,
0.3842954635620117,
0.366816908121109,
-0.18743057548999786,
0.6787596940994263,
-0.7114911675453186,
0.3176559805870056,
-0.38216954469680786,
0.3067612051963806,
-1.3196043968200684,
-0.3995569944381714,
0.1596183329820633,
-0.7040874361991882,
0.35296621918678284,
-0.36781659722328186,
-0.4048336446285248,
-0.39025482535362244,
-0.8895664215087891,
0.47397005558013916,
0.6388604044914246,
-0.4544263482093811,
0.2796398103237152,
-0.24572718143463135,
-0.09423919022083282,
-0.39981117844581604,
-0.5014591813087463,
0.26601338386535645,
-0.3233736753463745,
-0.572270393371582,
0.5519781708717346,
0.0739782527089119,
-0.06022576242685318,
0.058279458433389664,
0.04439803212881088,
0.17494189739227295,
-0.08972107619047165,
-0.20233219861984253,
0.18576236069202423,
-0.4373416006565094,
0.22057998180389404,
0.34342241287231445,
0.25252437591552734,
-0.2501829266548157,
-0.3423669934272766,
0.7494381070137024,
0.16254529356956482,
-0.3688611388206482,
-0.3926590085029602,
0.18171536922454834,
0.34342750906944275,
-0.5637441873550415,
0.5188868641853333,
0.4590814411640167,
0.15923815965652466,
-0.18804052472114563,
-0.4769269526004791,
-0.7139180898666382,
-0.4646514058113098,
-0.24836492538452148,
-0.4303106367588043,
-1.1511011123657227,
0.3412007987499237,
0.10788360983133316,
-0.17775091528892517,
0.43517398834228516,
0.2985862195491791,
-0.30825546383857727,
1.0204812288284302,
0.13273249566555023,
0.17854882776737213,
0.5454521179199219,
-0.24814476072788239,
0.15626034140586853,
-1.1144202947616577,
-0.39641356468200684,
-0.6392704248428345,
-0.5112857818603516,
-0.6144391894340515,
-0.6064388155937195,
0.5406398177146912,
0.5741928815841675,
0.029933828860521317,
0.30424708127975464,
-0.7832928895950317,
0.5987987518310547,
0.823757529258728,
0.14881977438926697,
0.14255498349666595,
0.2208966314792633,
-0.26678234338760376,
0.16386628150939941,
-0.8880352973937988,
-0.2612309455871582,
1.3098721504211426,
-0.6358371376991272,
0.6455081701278687,
0.11682102829217911,
1.3607245683670044,
0.07704143971204758,
-0.00001377644730382599,
-0.9360235333442688,
0.7086957693099976,
0.18842309713363647,
-0.43275895714759827,
-0.5427218079566956,
-0.49705854058265686,
-1.2918037176132202,
0.373705118894577,
-0.23280848562717438,
-0.6016315221786499,
0.2457026094198227,
0.21781645715236664,
-0.8252003788948059,
0.06247974559664726,
-0.4234076142311096,
0.5886660218238831,
-0.010351534932851791,
-0.18890516459941864,
0.0511276051402092,
-0.612430989742279,
0.39647749066352844,
0.27011317014694214,
-0.1850242167711258,
0.13264112174510956,
-0.013897663913667202,
0.4825631380081177,
-0.41990047693252563,
0.22577384114265442,
-0.15240046381950378,
0.23995907604694366,
0.43629151582717896,
0.1904457062482834,
0.4847448170185089,
-0.11973655968904495,
-0.3910518288612366,
-0.3351772725582123,
0.3014412820339203,
-0.3777334690093994,
-0.9613537788391113,
0.5777851343154907,
-0.15966473519802094,
-1.0349315404891968,
-0.08148416131734848,
-0.26221898198127747,
-0.09879956394433975,
0.13599500060081482,
0.6127383708953857,
0.33920934796333313,
-0.2034010887145996,
0.4715031683444977,
0.8236057162284851,
-0.11590918153524399,
0.5161362290382385,
0.3466416299343109,
-0.3242452144622803,
-0.5836820006370544,
0.707701563835144,
0.004476099740713835,
0.11864341795444489,
0.5904099345207214,
-0.002388045424595475,
-0.6269670128822327,
-0.5371519327163696,
-0.7580426931381226,
-0.06347516924142838,
-0.2959810495376587,
-0.5401694774627686,
-0.5025157332420349,
-0.07922440767288208,
-0.8050132393836975,
-0.0021067666821181774,
0.26720330119132996,
-0.5861403346061707,
-0.13145361840724945,
0.06550087779760361,
0.5947521924972534,
0.04791400954127312,
-0.009684952907264233,
0.2798738181591034,
-1.087699294090271,
0.06797675043344498,
0.3863891363143921,
-0.09163402765989304,
-0.04779158905148506,
-0.7746878266334534,
0.18158741295337677,
0.022322088479995728,
-0.38879039883613586,
-1.0340825319290161,
0.4180747866630554,
0.4633193612098694,
0.6761209964752197,
0.45900580286979675,
0.39880645275115967,
0.7132617235183716,
-0.5625677108764648,
0.9654998779296875,
0.048761770129203796,
-0.6260541081428528,
0.8744707703590393,
-0.4233686923980713,
0.5174294710159302,
1.0085837841033936,
0.1522090584039688,
-0.4710274934768677,
-0.41599637269973755,
-0.6183363199234009,
-0.8894039988517761,
0.4415702819824219,
0.19208410382270813,
0.36116066575050354,
-0.3051687777042389,
0.6106541752815247,
-0.35127392411231995,
0.4810577630996704,
0.19770672917366028,
-0.10258445888757706,
-0.21426109969615936,
-0.12273846566677094,
0.058972109109163284,
-0.17487142980098724,
-0.19027568399906158,
-0.19422884285449982,
0.5059911608695984,
-0.17301738262176514,
0.2692207396030426,
0.4569595754146576,
0.03970750793814659,
0.024739611893892288,
0.7319173812866211,
0.5252218842506409,
0.25914350152015686,
-0.2872543931007385,
0.08863320201635361,
-0.000307882612105459,
-0.2695179879665375,
0.3019905984401703,
0.281550794839859,
-0.5893664360046387,
-0.03543602302670479,
0.1443018615245819,
0.6339767575263977,
0.2611832320690155,
-0.5789960026741028,
0.47553473711013794,
-0.08678774535655975,
-0.44096484780311584,
0.2187543511390686,
0.4760759770870209,
-0.1670757383108139,
0.31503933668136597,
0.6634775996208191,
-0.22510051727294922,
0.7402786612510681,
-0.602620005607605,
0.43570929765701294,
0.6076245903968811,
-0.3576744794845581,
-0.03300425782799721,
0.8478909134864807,
-0.14670829474925995,
-0.25546494126319885,
0.7988177537918091,
-0.6597042679786682,
-0.5542815923690796,
0.44761770963668823,
0.4277768135070801,
0.8972896933555603,
-0.6693750023841858,
0.5346498489379883,
0.42281079292297363,
0.15329395234584808,
-0.35941970348358154,
0.560918390750885,
-0.5430343151092529,
-0.6061493158340454,
-0.46621981263160706,
-0.6303768754005432,
-0.27635782957077026,
-0.009581893682479858,
-0.9320986270904541,
0.15770019590854645,
-0.3598894774913788,
0.01828068308532238,
-0.13673092424869537,
-0.2551858425140381,
-0.2370062619447708,
0.029325315728783607,
-0.09524741023778915,
0.8175736665725708,
-0.22322069108486176,
0.7270593047142029,
1.0342069864273071,
-0.6656463146209717,
-0.9354404807090759,
0.3958356976509094,
0.14811201393604279,
-0.8423792719841003,
0.3880157470703125,
-0.04979846626520157,
-0.09598950296640396,
0.2962442636489868,
-0.6365079879760742,
-0.6302372217178345,
1.3409942388534546,
0.2778683602809906,
-0.6947497129440308,
0.062331490218639374,
-0.3193376064300537,
0.5309305191040039,
-0.09442587941884995,
0.4291660785675049,
0.390899121761322,
0.27172401547431946,
0.6539750099182129,
-0.5718215703964233,
0.20053139328956604,
-0.24855610728263855,
0.30176857113838196,
0.6915302276611328,
-0.5459470152854919,
0.7710645794868469,
-0.2659590542316437,
-0.5157189965248108,
0.2594940960407257,
0.4863744080066681,
0.5860497355461121,
0.49574223160743713,
0.24442023038864136,
0.7212822437286377,
0.8366777896881104,
-0.05062488093972206,
1.2583280801773071,
-0.6721681356430054,
0.24323095381259918,
1.0502305030822754,
-0.2300834357738495,
1.2152936458587646,
0.5549715161323547,
-0.13032567501068115,
0.39580482244491577,
0.5500113368034363,
0.021598465740680695,
0.755728542804718,
0.20883721113204956,
-0.5975313186645508,
-0.27186399698257446,
0.12122850865125656,
-0.4267856776714325,
0.4129987359046936,
0.24825137853622437,
-0.261055588722229,
-0.47470298409461975,
-0.05423317477107048,
-0.007350186351686716,
-0.05763876438140869,
-0.4892672002315521,
0.9345788359642029,
0.012378298677504063,
-0.8072742223739624,
0.758212685585022,
-0.15630339086055756,
0.6185213327407837,
-0.25543805956840515,
-0.2243957221508026,
-0.5759827494621277,
-0.1279696375131607,
-0.2721916437149048,
-0.837539792060852,
0.1981019824743271,
-0.3373967111110687,
-0.13500995934009552,
-0.22240358591079712,
0.8279536962509155,
-0.6789601445198059,
-0.4451262354850769,
-0.021656109020113945,
0.6236650347709656,
0.2747838795185089,
-0.49195343255996704,
-0.803759753704071,
-0.3018459379673004,
0.24250514805316925,
-0.16899985074996948,
0.35370731353759766,
0.590290904045105,
-0.07455538213253021,
0.3519382178783417,
0.7318218946456909,
-0.1295841783285141,
0.09536628425121307,
0.23174798488616943,
0.7430521249771118,
-0.7708765268325806,
-0.19368278980255127,
-0.6711210608482361,
0.21753007173538208,
-0.113290935754776,
-0.11160608381032944,
0.9467456936836243,
0.5529084801673889,
0.7929386496543884,
0.14496919512748718,
0.5440434217453003,
0.16629871726036072,
0.41292861104011536,
-0.6734968423843384,
0.7738715410232544,
-0.6419760584831238,
0.37279024720191956,
0.11290466040372849,
-1.0144314765930176,
-0.24579648673534393,
0.2517959475517273,
-0.40646326541900635,
0.09155591577291489,
0.34123244881629944,
1.181650161743164,
0.03260605037212372,
-0.02148504927754402,
0.47993093729019165,
0.0129810506477952,
-0.032060712575912476,
0.2496529519557953,
0.8941947817802429,
-0.49593669176101685,
0.7673553824424744,
0.0704803541302681,
0.007551026530563831,
-0.5716243982315063,
-0.3826102018356323,
-0.3154892027378082,
-0.40055111050605774,
-0.3103694021701813,
-0.38480058312416077,
0.346642404794693,
0.6946636438369751,
0.42243289947509766,
-0.7944388389587402,
0.08007824420928955,
-0.06431000679731369,
-0.026554729789495468,
-0.23468980193138123,
-0.3260410726070404,
0.06763018667697906,
-0.7820596098899841,
-0.40757909417152405,
0.8137493133544922,
0.42568066716194153,
-0.10978969931602478,
0.017368314787745476,
0.1232452392578125,
-0.13184022903442383,
0.2442350536584854,
0.5427564382553101,
0.36633923649787903,
-0.43092620372772217,
-0.008881080895662308,
0.3812706172466278,
0.05053136870265007,
0.17133162915706635,
0.7972458004951477,
-1.0984158515930176,
0.48893415927886963,
0.7940029501914978,
0.5242949724197388,
0.718806803226471,
0.3369598388671875,
0.5519472360610962,
-0.6593372225761414,
-0.21854378283023834,
0.4213174283504486,
0.11557582765817642,
0.3898547887802124,
-0.5128341913223267,
0.3687860369682312,
0.04327898472547531,
-0.48569732904434204,
-0.7059065103530884,
0.017913296818733215,
-0.740020751953125,
-0.320815771818161,
1.0915223360061646,
0.13564161956310272,
-0.3357931673526764,
0.18059757351875305,
-0.21459905803203583,
0.015942472964525223,
-0.8406932353973389,
0.7189089059829712,
0.3030988872051239,
-0.39528003334999084,
-0.703010618686676,
-0.33767133951187134,
0.43341389298439026,
0.5924291014671326,
-0.45065364241600037,
-0.6143240332603455,
0.4695890545845032,
0.3621755540370941,
-0.014679787680506706,
0.7058062553405762,
-0.36251577734947205,
0.4072464406490326,
-0.07716785371303558,
0.07225285470485687,
0.16519032418727875,
0.06085626780986786,
-0.5829566717147827,
0.4161086678504944,
-0.07456949353218079,
-0.4622573256492615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03745v1
|
Fakes of Varying Shades: How Warning Affects Human Perception and Engagement Regarding LLM Hallucinations
| 2024-04-04T18:34:32 | 2024-04-04T18:34:32 |
Mahjabin Nahar, Haeseung Seo, Eun-Ju Lee, Aiping Xiong, Dongwon Lee
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The widespread adoption and transformative effects of large language models
(LLMs) have sparked concerns regarding their capacity to produce inaccurate and
fictitious content, referred to as `hallucinations'. Given the potential risks
associated with hallucinations, humans should be able to identify them. This
research aims to understand the human perception of LLM hallucinations by
systematically varying the degree of hallucination (genuine, minor
hallucination, major hallucination) and examining its interaction with warning
(i.e., a warning of potential inaccuracies: absent vs. present). Participants
(N=419) from Prolific rated the perceived accuracy and engaged with content
(e.g., like, dislike, share) in a Q/A format. Results indicate that humans rank
content as truthful in the order genuine > minor hallucination > major
hallucination and user engagement behaviors mirror this pattern. More
importantly, we observed that warning improves hallucination detection without
significantly affecting the perceived truthfulness of genuine content. We
conclude by offering insights for future tools to aid human detection of
hallucinations.
|
[
-0.413119375705719,
-0.737433910369873,
0.8030849695205688,
0.5111410021781921,
-0.20824633538722992,
0.04671972617506981,
-0.06539972871541977,
-1.022910475730896,
0.5791663527488708,
0.41804179549217224,
-0.4587288796901703,
-0.46771225333213806,
-0.6321433782577515,
0.41757333278656006,
-0.5919650197029114,
0.6859729290008545,
-0.05620667338371277,
0.12490998208522797,
-0.1578037589788437,
-0.04107246920466423,
-0.6018099188804626,
-0.5833396315574646,
-0.2911638915538788,
-0.29517099261283875,
1.0253205299377441,
0.05200153589248657,
1.024476170539856,
0.17310719192028046,
0.26691949367523193,
0.23595497012138367,
0.038891684263944626,
0.14652949571609497,
-0.6419010162353516,
0.1360343098640442,
-0.1503530591726303,
-0.7459837198257446,
-0.0888860821723938,
0.3551657497882843,
0.2409769743680954,
0.6137699484825134,
-0.17757625877857208,
-0.133091539144516,
0.14521466195583344,
0.7045153379440308,
-0.45303383469581604,
-0.061170902103185654,
-0.6789082288742065,
0.5225117206573486,
0.039350274950265884,
-0.4961802661418915,
-0.6110277771949768,
-0.2046673744916916,
0.17215774953365326,
-0.5588325262069702,
0.37686336040496826,
0.29091623425483704,
0.7428564429283142,
0.34513238072395325,
-0.4804746210575104,
-0.6471672654151917,
-0.9664360284805298,
0.7010356783866882,
-0.38598012924194336,
0.5047767162322998,
0.5029701590538025,
0.3544566035270691,
-0.13030238449573517,
-0.3010503649711609,
-0.8771563768386841,
-0.373795747756958,
-0.21452222764492035,
0.1611270308494568,
-0.19139522314071655,
0.05144060403108597,
0.4672999680042267,
0.32958894968032837,
-0.5066936016082764,
0.07431161403656006,
-0.4236315190792084,
-0.6239175200462341,
0.6571531891822815,
0.30867838859558105,
0.35431814193725586,
-0.18385572731494904,
-0.2270071804523468,
0.01125048752874136,
-0.6921499967575073,
-0.22632011771202087,
0.7823401093482971,
-0.02463916689157486,
-0.21252287924289703,
0.6796077489852905,
-0.06759462505578995,
0.4270579516887665,
0.059681933373212814,
-0.013789410702884197,
0.28633400797843933,
-0.02030307799577713,
-0.27202528715133667,
0.21770380437374115,
0.5428379774093628,
0.690884530544281,
0.16797174513339996,
-0.21057523787021637,
-0.24473510682582855,
0.5529606342315674,
0.7443290948867798,
-0.5466539263725281,
-0.27734848856925964,
0.22357359528541565,
-0.49360519647598267,
-0.46445417404174805,
0.2936622202396393,
-0.8755035996437073,
-1.1402430534362793,
-0.36907482147216797,
0.7451459765434265,
-0.3872811496257782,
-0.252225399017334,
0.35359713435173035,
-0.035226598381996155,
0.14389485120773315,
0.5759618282318115,
-0.5858519673347473,
0.25569137930870056,
0.23886047303676605,
0.7133197784423828,
-0.6130256056785583,
-0.20450711250305176,
-0.0842713862657547,
-0.14498664438724518,
-0.5260812640190125,
0.6527306437492371,
-0.20860229432582855,
-0.48772531747817993,
0.103437140583992,
0.14364413917064667,
0.1186424121260643,
-0.700078010559082,
0.6642565131187439,
-0.23502859473228455,
0.27847304940223694,
-0.5678698420524597,
-0.21878910064697266,
-0.4085117280483246,
0.18790557980537415,
-0.7293438911437988,
0.8385306000709534,
0.22170518338680267,
-0.6965621709823608,
0.44697341322898865,
-0.004139987286180258,
-0.312723308801651,
-0.04324382171034813,
-0.3962826430797577,
-0.2795981764793396,
0.24248318374156952,
-0.13154669106006622,
0.2255934327840805,
0.1909511685371399,
0.012968722730875015,
-0.08526676148176193,
-0.8017734885215759,
0.7696865797042847,
-0.6653266549110413,
0.4403875768184662,
0.1511596292257309,
-0.8337652087211609,
0.20434218645095825,
-0.34386640787124634,
-0.5874311923980713,
0.13554885983467102,
-0.027204107493162155,
-0.16089041531085968,
-0.010404519736766815,
-0.06936155259609222,
0.1831117421388626,
0.030934134498238564,
-0.36511123180389404,
-0.2562621235847473,
-0.3279259502887726,
-0.08112768083810806,
0.8799659609794617,
0.26446282863616943,
0.26342150568962097,
-0.8839676380157471,
0.639215350151062,
0.5499992370605469,
0.5007187724113464,
0.16784928739070892,
-0.6882269978523254,
-0.9374476075172424,
0.11786100268363953,
-0.17149801552295685,
0.438136488199234,
-0.4828338325023651,
0.4305415153503418,
-0.027218708768486977,
-0.44949236512184143,
-0.4477906823158264,
-0.005613034591078758,
0.32611531019210815,
0.36909082531929016,
0.24873602390289307,
-0.08641264587640762,
-0.7825291156768799,
-0.8625682592391968,
-0.23303619027137756,
-0.26760223507881165,
0.06451236456632614,
0.5407029986381531,
0.48025795817375183,
-0.5393809080123901,
0.5945447683334351,
-0.4651168882846832,
-0.45431846380233765,
-0.02455674484372139,
0.16924884915351868,
-0.20084337890148163,
0.003111288184300065,
0.46643081307411194,
-0.9909294247627258,
-0.571984589099884,
-0.09658395498991013,
-0.8191364407539368,
0.00781642459332943,
-0.4982357919216156,
0.07469327002763748,
0.5232234001159668,
0.3001129627227783,
-0.37950801849365234,
0.6122937202453613,
0.7020365595817566,
-0.3020472526550293,
0.9318515062332153,
0.03259148821234703,
0.4366317689418793,
-0.6058717966079712,
-0.3808707892894745,
-0.015230566263198853,
0.05315973609685898,
-0.4252144992351532,
-0.44982287287712097,
-0.133712038397789,
0.28376567363739014,
-0.4432494044303894,
0.47254371643066406,
-0.536213755607605,
-0.09600822627544403,
0.012034634128212929,
0.17187879979610443,
0.13526153564453125,
0.16039356589317322,
0.031700510531663895,
0.7866345047950745,
0.5960565805435181,
-0.4439084529876709,
0.2501413822174072,
-0.11018097400665283,
-0.6045629382133484,
0.2833254039287567,
-0.28468167781829834,
0.10375752300024033,
-0.22987867891788483,
0.013123071752488613,
-1.0864800214767456,
-0.497346967458725,
0.44224607944488525,
-0.39629724621772766,
-0.0692848339676857,
0.2546154260635376,
-0.6027593612670898,
-0.30523067712783813,
-0.43108686804771423,
0.23636086285114288,
0.5987582206726074,
-0.369479238986969,
0.7293510437011719,
0.21452215313911438,
0.17871257662773132,
-0.40622493624687195,
-0.9012759327888489,
0.13185304403305054,
-0.42556408047676086,
-0.3171077072620392,
0.2168068140745163,
-0.3354077935218811,
-0.5599272847175598,
-0.28263160586357117,
-0.4661872982978821,
0.31151413917541504,
0.017685092985630035,
0.8413692116737366,
0.26977819204330444,
0.1772388368844986,
-0.0005586760235019028,
-0.030265074223279953,
0.2359389215707779,
0.370974063873291,
0.29546454548835754,
0.5727468132972717,
0.02890346385538578,
-0.6192179322242737,
-0.6256822347640991,
0.15430878102779388,
0.44162270426750183,
0.5858820676803589,
0.7144535779953003,
0.5086115002632141,
-0.627605140209198,
-0.19631341099739075,
-0.8651653528213501,
-0.5331329107284546,
-0.518061101436615,
-0.010480538941919804,
-0.17992143332958221,
-0.6685246229171753,
0.7670353651046753,
0.2159288376569748,
-0.5815374851226807,
0.20021992921829224,
0.5390720963478088,
-0.22918801009655,
1.1989812850952148,
0.5854735970497131,
0.062107715755701065,
0.47809281945228577,
0.14802706241607666,
0.286924809217453,
-0.5317086577415466,
-0.4920899271965027,
-0.3183540403842926,
-0.21907250583171844,
-0.7397287487983704,
-0.5061454176902771,
0.35800600051879883,
-0.10011444240808487,
0.13780932128429413,
-0.012637356296181679,
-0.6709535717964172,
0.5601539611816406,
0.020268386229872704,
0.4454071521759033,
0.35335269570350647,
0.15136054158210754,
0.08473759889602661,
-0.5241272449493408,
-0.27677297592163086,
-0.6508108377456665,
0.9244463443756104,
0.3121882379055023,
0.7562873959541321,
0.1820596158504486,
0.5531259775161743,
0.7228049039840698,
0.43769586086273193,
-0.7973082661628723,
0.5172128081321716,
0.41588327288627625,
-0.5250493884086609,
-0.1660124659538269,
-0.36464717984199524,
-0.6920739412307739,
0.08341620117425919,
-0.408817321062088,
-0.7655048370361328,
0.26624828577041626,
0.026166819036006927,
-0.3248080313205719,
0.22863192856311798,
-0.5308550000190735,
0.31029030680656433,
-0.28064438700675964,
-0.2485823929309845,
-0.24523471295833588,
-0.5292636156082153,
0.49270835518836975,
-0.10609731823205948,
0.4320894181728363,
-0.2182064801454544,
0.1066419780254364,
0.704753577709198,
0.30739691853523254,
1.3426504135131836,
0.036142513155937195,
-0.2562517523765564,
0.21686382591724396,
0.49149662256240845,
0.5624642372131348,
0.01618473045527935,
-0.08839590847492218,
0.22564762830734253,
-0.3676833212375641,
-0.17445102334022522,
-0.4614850878715515,
0.6486496329307556,
-0.7566776275634766,
-0.8271363973617554,
-0.6656628847122192,
-0.5540780425071716,
-0.20669592916965485,
-0.03869178891181946,
0.42722079157829285,
-0.01762104593217373,
-0.31049391627311707,
-0.09863082319498062,
1.0039414167404175,
-0.3385806083679199,
-0.01956859603524208,
0.13843725621700287,
-0.5330162048339844,
-0.25664976239204407,
0.6900936365127563,
-0.0017238013679161668,
0.38515472412109375,
0.04985542967915535,
0.2687832713127136,
-0.3268358111381531,
-0.6506538391113281,
-0.0006359593826346099,
0.44278448820114136,
-0.8485545516014099,
0.08890268951654434,
-0.7127068042755127,
-0.19295814633369446,
-0.6265888214111328,
-0.28984886407852173,
-0.03995031118392944,
0.017826195806264877,
-0.5794479846954346,
-0.39270731806755066,
0.31383857131004333,
0.9007520079612732,
-0.07259801030158997,
0.2066282331943512,
-0.3254272937774658,
0.3384600579738617,
0.32222723960876465,
0.29196545481681824,
-0.10992705821990967,
-0.5967903137207031,
-0.043901462107896805,
0.1570105254650116,
-0.24602802097797394,
-1.0744982957839966,
0.41767701506614685,
-0.24807962775230408,
0.6887938976287842,
0.9243316650390625,
0.277139276266098,
0.5491605997085571,
-0.0020632108207792044,
0.9670476317405701,
0.3272210955619812,
-0.7560908794403076,
0.22540245950222015,
-0.27829936146736145,
-0.19559624791145325,
0.4305713176727295,
0.6851575374603271,
-0.8228998780250549,
-0.6294834613800049,
-0.431644082069397,
-0.48291856050491333,
0.39711233973503113,
0.07076024264097214,
0.36198222637176514,
-0.05808220058679581,
0.06672728806734085,
0.5701491832733154,
0.2904830574989319,
-1.1582237482070923,
-0.36770638823509216,
-0.3104541003704071,
0.12103502452373505,
-0.05380501598119736,
-0.7268794178962708,
-0.40553978085517883,
-0.17397761344909668,
0.34176987409591675,
0.08912727981805801,
0.33451977372169495,
0.3549516499042511,
-0.1255013346672058,
-0.4775077998638153,
0.01744816266000271,
0.9094894528388977,
0.7578068375587463,
-0.3922370970249176,
0.498914897441864,
0.0328747034072876,
-0.6444895267486572,
-0.1066795289516449,
-0.5399510264396667,
-0.08601968735456467,
0.19240295886993408,
0.364996999502182,
0.8660429120063782,
0.10746984928846359,
-0.7050718069076538,
0.5321042537689209,
0.051233116537332535,
-0.3039184808731079,
-0.5108889937400818,
0.0424683578312397,
-0.07954995334148407,
0.06165507063269615,
0.488288938999176,
0.0879800021648407,
0.2505132555961609,
-0.8409858345985413,
0.09475545585155487,
0.214146226644516,
-0.6803916692733765,
-0.42370906472206116,
0.5458967685699463,
-0.11951808631420135,
-0.3736601769924164,
0.4149107038974762,
-0.2728710174560547,
-0.6960380673408508,
0.3071475625038147,
0.50898277759552,
0.7885076999664307,
-0.09644792228937149,
0.45655009150505066,
0.11567400395870209,
0.5927743315696716,
-0.0449153333902359,
0.35555198788642883,
0.16878816485404968,
-1.151440978050232,
-0.054133445024490356,
-0.6966397166252136,
-0.5416849851608276,
0.20601558685302734,
-0.6484367847442627,
0.23250818252563477,
-0.3702668249607086,
-0.23208916187286377,
-0.12584170699119568,
-0.2623256742954254,
-0.3985471725463867,
0.16678091883659363,
0.2614245116710663,
0.6503266096115112,
-1.140113115310669,
0.4438856542110443,
0.27308389544487,
-0.4656513035297394,
-0.5723052620887756,
0.4818665683269501,
0.3070184588432312,
-0.4556664526462555,
0.35557347536087036,
0.496271014213562,
-0.24157920479774475,
-0.4220260977745056,
-0.5448863506317139,
-0.4365527629852295,
0.8156698346138,
0.1788140833377838,
-0.3560313880443573,
0.007551586255431175,
0.5509709119796753,
0.6921316385269165,
-0.38305413722991943,
-0.011616685427725315,
0.5610554218292236,
0.6755000352859497,
0.33986321091651917,
-0.6180622577667236,
0.2167850285768509,
0.1335439383983612,
-0.0752231553196907,
-0.20798487961292267,
-0.3166082501411438,
0.7155125141143799,
-0.30155980587005615,
-0.5497240424156189,
-0.18362148106098175,
0.36483731865882874,
0.2733578383922577,
0.5744468569755554,
0.6444697380065918,
0.17802222073078156,
0.7405350804328918,
-0.14583197236061096,
0.9742463231086731,
0.08617645502090454,
-0.10627977550029755,
0.8758382201194763,
-0.4584920108318329,
0.5465953350067139,
0.7712059617042542,
-0.09281039237976074,
0.7273513078689575,
0.701276421546936,
0.05685122311115265,
0.4603993594646454,
0.3115418553352356,
-0.5036762952804565,
-0.18347349762916565,
-0.12528280913829803,
-0.3660709857940674,
0.14513139426708221,
0.5322585701942444,
-0.2581712305545807,
0.19154669344425201,
0.24953748285770416,
-0.08156482130289078,
0.31016460061073303,
-0.0569550059735775,
0.6848766803741455,
0.09202495962381363,
-0.38716650009155273,
0.5032474398612976,
-0.29443734884262085,
0.9499050378799438,
-0.2599742114543915,
-0.17449533939361572,
-0.2913472354412079,
-0.20825430750846863,
-0.5138231515884399,
-0.6920357942581177,
0.5182386040687561,
-0.3365756869316101,
-0.18970738351345062,
-0.22890080511569977,
0.7063001394271851,
-0.10809304565191269,
-0.3205813765525818,
0.5997651815414429,
0.34040457010269165,
0.5164234638214111,
-0.41802895069122314,
-0.46800315380096436,
0.3779121935367584,
0.21524782478809357,
-0.12337120622396469,
0.32292941212654114,
0.4548484981060028,
-0.1532379686832428,
0.7145126461982727,
0.695684015750885,
0.31222856044769287,
0.3439866602420807,
0.08381161093711853,
0.6003537178039551,
-0.6372340321540833,
-0.3364151418209076,
-0.583478569984436,
0.3508071005344391,
-0.009388797916471958,
-0.16364271938800812,
0.773811936378479,
0.4487449824810028,
0.8510583639144897,
-0.28590983152389526,
0.5952202677726746,
0.12227808684110641,
0.25635313987731934,
-0.37585046887397766,
0.860974907875061,
-0.5048564076423645,
0.39448118209838867,
-0.16280236840248108,
-0.888280987739563,
-0.21560713648796082,
0.5800154805183411,
-0.4100513756275177,
0.043215248733758926,
0.815699577331543,
0.9604713916778564,
0.2517160475254059,
0.1916908472776413,
0.6843546628952026,
0.5074155926704407,
-0.0666518360376358,
0.05345528945326805,
1.1303095817565918,
-0.08982137590646744,
0.33536794781684875,
-0.5323678851127625,
-0.02322891540825367,
-0.521349310874939,
-0.8061127662658691,
-0.8401585221290588,
-0.6789833903312683,
-0.2646489143371582,
-0.6188386082649231,
-0.08533435314893723,
0.5375269651412964,
0.3462662100791931,
-0.9172914624214172,
-0.18170666694641113,
-0.06414128839969635,
0.19989871978759766,
-0.18321633338928223,
-0.3378046154975891,
0.09912258386611938,
0.02293381467461586,
-0.661138117313385,
0.19173133373260498,
0.3833273947238922,
0.5235148072242737,
-0.6690754294395447,
-0.2650021016597748,
0.19985999166965485,
0.2558514475822449,
0.4618000090122223,
0.005668982397764921,
-1.048416256904602,
-0.5835745930671692,
0.06853648275136948,
-0.4201478064060211,
0.22159646451473236,
0.6860825419425964,
-0.7287161946296692,
0.3332313299179077,
0.24792832136154175,
0.060339994728565216,
0.4347963333129883,
-0.10981754958629608,
0.31736913323402405,
-0.5201607346534729,
0.2051747739315033,
0.29960742592811584,
0.23765189945697784,
0.5077875256538391,
-0.8657127022743225,
0.36777517199516296,
0.4344812035560608,
-0.23664551973342896,
-1.0852570533752441,
0.3115256726741791,
-1.2690409421920776,
-0.16460154950618744,
1.2642980813980103,
0.1635511964559555,
-0.09278277307748795,
-0.3260941803455353,
-0.4309053122997284,
0.21344828605651855,
-0.22460825741291046,
1.4561597108840942,
0.7758581042289734,
-0.2814759314060211,
0.0878494530916214,
-0.6509490609169006,
0.7450083494186401,
0.36406195163726807,
-0.8079924583435059,
0.12138114124536514,
0.6386154294013977,
0.18326859176158905,
0.43248456716537476,
0.23186524212360382,
-0.2013770490884781,
0.24417056143283844,
0.1542488932609558,
0.06498022377490997,
0.12429478764533997,
-0.4913879334926605,
-0.34780439734458923,
-0.026101715862751007,
-0.027949564158916473,
0.19266118109226227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03732v1
|
SHROOM-INDElab at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Zero- and Few-Shot LLM-Based Classification for Hallucination Detection
| 2024-04-04T18:01:21 | 2024-04-04T18:01:21 |
Bradley P. Allen, Fina Polat, Paul Groth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We describe the University of Amsterdam Intelligent Data Engineering Lab
team's entry for the SemEval-2024 Task 6 competition. The SHROOM-INDElab system
builds on previous work on using prompt programming and in-context learning
with large language models (LLMs) to build classifiers for hallucination
detection, and extends that work through the incorporation of context-specific
definition of task, role, and target concept, and automated generation of
examples for use in a few-shot prompting approach. The resulting system
achieved fourth-best and sixth-best performance in the model-agnostic track and
model-aware tracks for Task 6, respectively, and evaluation using the
validation sets showed that the system's classification decisions were
consistent with those of the crowd-sourced human labellers. We further found
that a zero-shot approach provided better accuracy than a few-shot approach
using automatically generated examples. Code for the system described in this
paper is available on Github.
|
[
-0.31937938928604126,
-0.6472914814949036,
0.8146977424621582,
0.22354060411453247,
-0.2042209357023239,
-0.36897584795951843,
-0.09687890857458115,
-0.5786506533622742,
0.19725441932678223,
0.39555856585502625,
-0.5601264238357544,
-0.7219242453575134,
-0.5973363518714905,
0.5104008913040161,
-0.5411748290061951,
0.3134640157222748,
0.026364626362919807,
0.29131627082824707,
-0.4143396317958832,
-0.20379623770713806,
-0.8553894758224487,
-0.6202731728553772,
-0.0313817523419857,
-0.4890970289707184,
0.51585453748703,
0.736952543258667,
-0.05808645486831665,
0.324967622756958,
0.45423099398612976,
0.2202925980091095,
0.18372562527656555,
0.019172310829162598,
-0.120272696018219,
0.4814557433128357,
-0.11475511640310287,
-0.26522988080978394,
-0.1448257863521576,
-0.246650829911232,
0.04871802031993866,
0.3993023633956909,
-0.13278383016586304,
0.1598455160856247,
0.029589524492621422,
0.2467564344406128,
-0.6141239404678345,
0.1549047976732254,
-0.5939576029777527,
0.28284770250320435,
-0.2975480854511261,
-0.5165915489196777,
-0.6267574429512024,
-0.09970395267009735,
-0.28227007389068604,
-0.03565184772014618,
0.19128099083900452,
-0.14455294609069824,
0.42869290709495544,
0.7218834161758423,
-0.1557970941066742,
-0.3854652941226959,
-0.34219440817832947,
0.6165593266487122,
-0.69825279712677,
0.4460187256336212,
0.40047553181648254,
0.3529796004295349,
-0.30153608322143555,
-0.5784227252006531,
-0.4343383014202118,
0.03573887422680855,
0.17902545630931854,
-0.005630080122500658,
0.1384897530078888,
0.07151001691818237,
0.39762333035469055,
-0.02347721718251705,
-0.714425265789032,
0.3364771604537964,
-0.5313558578491211,
-0.3237038254737854,
0.5061506032943726,
0.19732055068016052,
0.04591304808855057,
-0.24749569594860077,
-0.23253527283668518,
0.34314510226249695,
-0.48527607321739197,
-0.31185293197631836,
-0.1272934526205063,
0.48046764731407166,
0.13701194524765015,
0.6251843571662903,
-0.42907291650772095,
0.526397168636322,
-0.00510029261931777,
0.09022186696529388,
0.4330836832523346,
0.03374537080526352,
-0.17661860585212708,
0.5161023736000061,
0.45470181107521057,
0.032934680581092834,
-0.22239209711551666,
-0.08277266472578049,
-0.40646445751190186,
0.4307982623577118,
0.20521198213100433,
-0.7998393774032593,
-0.27103736996650696,
0.3065701127052307,
-0.4180334210395813,
-0.47672051191329956,
-0.234597310423851,
-0.6115335822105408,
-0.7022066116333008,
-0.5200147032737732,
0.9946607351303101,
-0.2768196761608124,
0.14763067662715912,
0.1819615513086319,
0.024852508679032326,
0.58326256275177,
0.5304076671600342,
-0.6369230151176453,
0.05070609226822853,
0.5952104330062866,
0.7879661321640015,
-0.6640844941139221,
-0.40186309814453125,
-0.744029700756073,
-0.06311360746622086,
-0.19044210016727448,
1.078536868095398,
-0.5356823801994324,
-0.2852042317390442,
-0.05809643492102623,
-0.016661446541547775,
0.10889874398708344,
-0.6628974080085754,
0.7743399739265442,
-0.09666084498167038,
0.36092063784599304,
-0.2730463743209839,
-0.762120246887207,
-0.3026120364665985,
0.22542846202850342,
-0.24908004701137543,
0.8986708521842957,
0.16701382398605347,
-0.4357224106788635,
0.4468262195587158,
-0.5951225161552429,
-0.38141170144081116,
0.7515645623207092,
-0.6041349768638611,
-0.2699182629585266,
0.22797057032585144,
0.06360329687595367,
0.7390097379684448,
0.04114720597863197,
0.3397929072380066,
-0.35683685541152954,
-0.827307939529419,
-0.02115751802921295,
-0.27768248319625854,
0.7273775935173035,
0.14444254338741302,
-0.7299609184265137,
0.25543659925460815,
-0.782597541809082,
-0.20070475339889526,
-0.015329530462622643,
-0.2239116132259369,
-0.008657793514430523,
-0.3400883078575134,
0.03649964556097984,
0.4070330262184143,
0.07010497152805328,
-0.4587610363960266,
0.3156243562698364,
-0.10901828110218048,
0.2921786308288574,
0.8830640316009521,
0.20080792903900146,
0.32617536187171936,
-0.08085105568170547,
0.49031999707221985,
-0.03147643432021141,
0.22499661147594452,
-0.3074248433113098,
-0.42603039741516113,
-0.8381229639053345,
-0.3745418190956116,
0.21231918036937714,
0.5187135934829712,
-0.586581289768219,
0.7557679414749146,
0.17785444855690002,
-0.31302526593208313,
-0.1697458177804947,
0.026003016158938408,
-0.041078757494688034,
0.5921210646629333,
0.428570032119751,
-0.24360992014408112,
-0.6687963604927063,
-0.9345934987068176,
0.20662438869476318,
0.039491768926382065,
-0.014005004428327084,
0.19123518466949463,
0.9260067343711853,
-0.6375768184661865,
0.4213126003742218,
-0.325412392616272,
-0.8004841208457947,
-0.16340695321559906,
0.16860738396644592,
0.37772083282470703,
0.3998028039932251,
0.33637991547584534,
-0.3066217303276062,
-0.20604802668094635,
-0.09233621507883072,
-1.1715352535247803,
-0.5491918921470642,
0.07903637737035751,
-0.14611771702766418,
0.4889809489250183,
0.5943726897239685,
-0.359747052192688,
0.5791784524917603,
0.12623776495456696,
-0.3089018762111664,
0.4994312822818756,
0.21778665482997894,
0.21532879769802094,
-0.858507513999939,
-0.21134749054908752,
-0.31559574604034424,
-0.1597883105278015,
-0.7539776563644409,
-0.2632197141647339,
0.05657494440674782,
-0.0672837495803833,
-0.6607697010040283,
0.3909740746021271,
-0.11599263548851013,
-0.15596474707126617,
-0.4989602863788605,
-0.2850561738014221,
-0.252622127532959,
0.7881647944450378,
0.2760452330112457,
0.39223477244377136,
0.5434724688529968,
-0.6248410940170288,
0.2401757836341858,
0.3211539387702942,
-0.4163302481174469,
0.6010631918907166,
-0.28339603543281555,
0.3147309720516205,
0.04005591571331024,
0.12677901983261108,
-0.8380575180053711,
-0.6369779109954834,
0.3898523151874542,
-0.6318907737731934,
0.14309602975845337,
0.13397473096847534,
-0.45642220973968506,
-0.2714206278324127,
-0.26340368390083313,
0.24465836584568024,
0.4653579294681549,
-0.6829271912574768,
0.5940226316452026,
0.3729356825351715,
0.05732257291674614,
-0.352321058511734,
-0.7043050527572632,
0.1186176985502243,
-0.36626169085502625,
-0.3775775730609894,
0.2637433409690857,
-0.044946733862161636,
0.05898335948586464,
-0.24026308953762054,
-0.3775646388530731,
-0.0766417533159256,
0.09209892153739929,
0.519494891166687,
0.22654032707214355,
0.10967246443033218,
0.15772493183612823,
-0.08986169844865799,
-0.11539021134376526,
0.21854303777217865,
-0.2753617465496063,
0.5693001747131348,
-0.17168758809566498,
-0.6002709865570068,
-0.6129038333892822,
0.2302764505147934,
0.4239005446434021,
0.3638122081756592,
0.28489336371421814,
0.5458424091339111,
-0.8252538442611694,
-0.6067482829093933,
-0.6599907279014587,
-0.5704471468925476,
-0.46700650453567505,
0.1449303925037384,
-0.45121315121650696,
-0.9089857935905457,
0.4136459231376648,
0.19296078383922577,
-0.0038336473517119884,
0.25032371282577515,
0.7711804509162903,
-0.22796234488487244,
0.9906933307647705,
0.5795817971229553,
0.15118946135044098,
0.2743246555328369,
-0.15223781764507294,
0.19880449771881104,
-0.45116254687309265,
-0.43121668696403503,
-0.593717098236084,
-0.5309993624687195,
-0.10000459849834442,
-0.4919351041316986,
0.3954086899757385,
-0.15140722692012787,
-0.23504763841629028,
0.48201215267181396,
-0.9132844805717468,
0.4391356110572815,
0.5063445568084717,
0.08254965394735336,
0.2444729059934616,
0.011378907598555088,
-0.021855341270565987,
-0.24475069344043732,
-0.7058907151222229,
-0.37436994910240173,
0.8274980783462524,
0.26657581329345703,
0.8220970034599304,
-0.21576081216335297,
1.168305516242981,
0.679627001285553,
0.21805937588214874,
-1.0742045640945435,
0.7628605365753174,
0.24382509291172028,
-0.33710506558418274,
-0.4303921163082123,
-0.008269243873655796,
-0.5583901405334473,
0.349176287651062,
0.07141991704702377,
-0.7122499346733093,
0.5177164077758789,
-0.17808111011981964,
-0.36943507194519043,
-0.038140684366226196,
-0.4075155556201935,
0.8007121086120605,
-0.3565501868724823,
-0.29889118671417236,
0.003942893352359533,
-0.4919467568397522,
0.4277249276638031,
-0.20180770754814148,
-0.006758774630725384,
-0.23834533989429474,
0.13293345272541046,
0.7035168409347534,
-0.23044805228710175,
0.7800788283348083,
-0.4716772437095642,
-0.018782244995236397,
0.2062489241361618,
0.17231592535972595,
0.4279976487159729,
-0.10806170850992203,
0.015426033176481724,
0.230141744017601,
-0.07971502840518951,
-0.08695369213819504,
-0.44048503041267395,
0.5969820618629456,
-0.35149168968200684,
-0.4016324579715729,
-0.6793009638786316,
-0.30749937891960144,
-0.18606409430503845,
0.1613166481256485,
0.6253927946090698,
0.42609843611717224,
0.07750117033720016,
0.5574336051940918,
0.8151981234550476,
-0.28246042132377625,
0.21355924010276794,
0.2779015302658081,
-0.2981133759021759,
-0.25152745842933655,
0.8348404765129089,
0.09687554091215134,
-0.2917947769165039,
0.24056978523731232,
0.07122345268726349,
-0.41722628474235535,
-0.7377699613571167,
-0.16073179244995117,
0.215336874127388,
-1.0448687076568604,
-0.5458714365959167,
-0.7775039076805115,
-0.3400655686855316,
-0.6270471811294556,
-0.36546438932418823,
-0.19278879463672638,
-0.3091064989566803,
-0.34211277961730957,
-0.1512436866760254,
-0.007747961673885584,
0.5706169009208679,
-0.160663902759552,
0.007590772118419409,
-0.5839999914169312,
0.18966419994831085,
0.32958635687828064,
0.08877692371606827,
-0.3999028205871582,
-0.9193122386932373,
-0.15955902636051178,
-0.5187564492225647,
-0.3003433048725128,
-0.8710789084434509,
0.5232436656951904,
-0.0507342666387558,
0.7800984978675842,
0.3901054859161377,
0.17829842865467072,
0.6172217130661011,
-0.24237415194511414,
0.6935799717903137,
0.1072879508137703,
-0.8901389837265015,
0.822064220905304,
-0.15245851874351501,
0.2943180501461029,
0.8723803758621216,
0.21027058362960815,
-0.5189949870109558,
-0.4069025218486786,
-0.37961727380752563,
-0.7342270612716675,
0.8269033432006836,
0.23999783396720886,
-0.19945436716079712,
0.07266362756490707,
0.17235277593135834,
0.47808003425598145,
0.1822577863931656,
-0.8048745393753052,
0.1491025984287262,
0.013026141561567783,
-0.2927184998989105,
0.3609045743942261,
-0.28695932030677795,
0.05987489968538284,
-0.37118566036224365,
0.9095903038978577,
-0.27808448672294617,
0.34337228536605835,
0.2803741991519928,
-0.5311707854270935,
0.03352585434913635,
0.26103824377059937,
0.6499462127685547,
0.5031895637512207,
-0.2845747172832489,
0.125877246260643,
0.5077404379844666,
-0.32571515440940857,
0.20309260487556458,
-0.24230104684829712,
-0.43476560711860657,
0.14550043642520905,
0.351325660943985,
0.6219496130943298,
0.2320098578929901,
-0.7298592329025269,
0.5017411112785339,
-0.018332498148083687,
-0.6521278619766235,
-0.5724482536315918,
0.1138807088136673,
-0.3239019215106964,
0.4754694104194641,
0.30600109696388245,
-0.03459581732749939,
0.6114153265953064,
-0.18515582382678986,
0.45374390482902527,
0.10692472010850906,
-0.606144905090332,
-0.4230045676231384,
0.8071337938308716,
0.21643300354480743,
-0.3770117461681366,
0.46755748987197876,
-0.4949013292789459,
-0.6192102432250977,
0.5256190896034241,
0.37967798113822937,
1.225561261177063,
-0.2706550061702728,
0.14535702764987946,
0.43077966570854187,
0.14563371241092682,
-0.2701210677623749,
0.5564463138580322,
-0.29822680354118347,
-0.6568623781204224,
-0.09749013185501099,
-0.7305369973182678,
-0.38073086738586426,
0.5016679763793945,
-0.4062950313091278,
0.8056157827377319,
-0.2513870894908905,
0.10894162207841873,
-0.055268142372369766,
-0.2050868570804596,
-0.5925844311714172,
-0.25075268745422363,
0.5683190226554871,
0.7999582290649414,
-0.9394181370735168,
0.8332794308662415,
0.47623926401138306,
-0.21283382177352905,
-0.42989736795425415,
-0.2364809513092041,
0.3896973133087158,
-0.30239081382751465,
0.664003849029541,
0.7146345376968384,
-0.11741989850997925,
-0.10014086961746216,
-0.7942198514938354,
-0.41226083040237427,
1.2002472877502441,
0.11039071530103683,
-0.505681037902832,
-0.019845815375447273,
-0.12769180536270142,
0.3609163165092468,
-0.4120098948478699,
-0.11310765147209167,
0.6306376457214355,
0.43006959557533264,
0.4326474964618683,
-0.6127923130989075,
-0.20153501629829407,
-0.15777133405208588,
-0.21828553080558777,
-0.03512514382600784,
-0.22607465088367462,
0.44242244958877563,
0.02137412503361702,
-0.21776215732097626,
0.05846855789422989,
0.7893615365028381,
0.6131436824798584,
0.6412431001663208,
0.438599556684494,
0.5949054956436157,
0.6721429824829102,
-0.17062106728553772,
0.5005320906639099,
-0.09596310555934906,
0.1652967780828476,
1.3817245960235596,
-0.8011988401412964,
0.7399776577949524,
0.5242133140563965,
-0.023731080815196037,
0.22893834114074707,
0.7711038589477539,
-0.24720899760723114,
0.6179301142692566,
0.12417654693126678,
-0.30973124504089355,
-0.41331735253334045,
-0.22238832712173462,
-0.29723870754241943,
0.6225913166999817,
0.6014668941497803,
-0.025953613221645355,
-0.18009798228740692,
0.4969954788684845,
-0.5863001942634583,
-0.13346664607524872,
-0.08113380521535873,
0.6751924157142639,
0.25669342279434204,
-0.5439338684082031,
0.39496034383773804,
-0.2617153525352478,
0.9856644868850708,
-0.25854361057281494,
-0.20687569677829742,
-0.251236230134964,
0.25607553124427795,
-0.4170100688934326,
-0.5629785060882568,
0.21610882878303528,
-0.017204314470291138,
0.1586514115333557,
-0.2085525393486023,
1.007214903831482,
-0.3578554093837738,
-0.26395779848098755,
0.25881022214889526,
0.36974531412124634,
0.5292800068855286,
-0.1727440506219864,
-0.446431964635849,
0.13515470921993256,
-0.06390394270420074,
-0.15770108997821808,
0.12972094118595123,
0.45746591687202454,
-0.2019801288843155,
0.5296650528907776,
0.20693320035934448,
-0.20324984192848206,
0.10091927647590637,
0.5155208110809326,
0.40998727083206177,
-0.8352551460266113,
-0.3575166165828705,
-0.7314391732215881,
0.2114643007516861,
0.0600348524749279,
-0.04236709699034691,
0.7193744778633118,
0.7516900300979614,
0.823997974395752,
-0.2990569472312927,
0.7895965576171875,
-0.08047796040773392,
0.36958742141723633,
-0.29273226857185364,
0.29763302206993103,
-0.47197526693344116,
0.29492971301078796,
-0.1533813178539276,
-1.034395456314087,
-0.4893683195114136,
0.7710202932357788,
0.02317182347178459,
-0.22386828064918518,
0.836005449295044,
1.0271469354629517,
0.16110391914844513,
0.07609428465366364,
0.6150781512260437,
0.11294329166412354,
0.22847922146320343,
0.7391147613525391,
1.155037522315979,
-0.35433077812194824,
0.34775108098983765,
-0.4467897415161133,
-0.07013329118490219,
-0.5478852987289429,
-0.6220282316207886,
-0.8416667580604553,
-0.8113928437232971,
-0.49191632866859436,
-0.24127541482448578,
-0.15759959816932678,
1.195749282836914,
0.49751317501068115,
-1.1172021627426147,
-0.18579715490341187,
-0.09136518836021423,
-0.005370547063648701,
-0.024048149585723877,
-0.2491462230682373,
0.10146758705377579,
-0.5508669018745422,
-0.6834397912025452,
0.6634458899497986,
0.7640278935432434,
0.020518269389867783,
-0.1795613169670105,
-0.1776936948299408,
-0.16876570880413055,
-0.15159212052822113,
0.859038770198822,
0.07532858103513718,
-0.7593393325805664,
-0.3765638470649719,
0.1854894757270813,
-0.2115778625011444,
0.07988283783197403,
0.5937070846557617,
-0.8165026307106018,
0.3496485650539398,
1.0335421562194824,
0.6696483492851257,
0.42493805289268494,
-0.08782144635915756,
0.17967481911182404,
-0.4924277663230896,
0.20210494101047516,
0.6859166026115417,
0.4162755012512207,
0.061936259269714355,
-0.4720994234085083,
0.9678836464881897,
0.3722265958786011,
-0.8448866009712219,
-1.1803282499313354,
-0.15383751690387726,
-1.0093470811843872,
-0.4717157185077667,
1.1164592504501343,
0.4828474223613739,
-0.3159327507019043,
-0.35635629296302795,
-0.163174569606781,
0.021437237039208412,
-0.3145977854728699,
1.0428836345672607,
0.8465439677238464,
-0.5331646800041199,
-0.175380676984787,
-0.7705866694450378,
0.40836936235427856,
0.26261433959007263,
-1.1243494749069214,
-0.23010683059692383,
0.7978412508964539,
0.005425270181149244,
0.07267262786626816,
0.8784971237182617,
-0.26891037821769714,
0.5692243576049805,
-0.2086547166109085,
0.3817138373851776,
0.012437116354703903,
-0.6893274784088135,
-0.7965419292449951,
0.21804890036582947,
-0.15090051293373108,
-0.3409680128097534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03653v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03653v2
|
CoMat: Aligning Text-to-Image Diffusion Model with Image-to-Text Concept Matching
| 2024-04-04T17:59:46 | 2024-06-03T06:02:34 |
Dongzhi Jiang, Guanglu Song, Xiaoshi Wu, Renrui Zhang, Dazhong Shen, Zhuofan Zong, Yu Liu, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Diffusion models have demonstrated great success in the field of
text-to-image generation. However, alleviating the misalignment between the
text prompts and images is still challenging. The root reason behind the
misalignment has not been extensively investigated. We observe that the
misalignment is caused by inadequate token attention activation. We further
attribute this phenomenon to the diffusion model's insufficient condition
utilization, which is caused by its training paradigm. To address the issue, we
propose CoMat, an end-to-end diffusion model fine-tuning strategy with an
image-to-text concept matching mechanism. We leverage an image captioning model
to measure image-to-text alignment and guide the diffusion model to revisit
ignored tokens. A novel attribute concentration module is also proposed to
address the attribute binding problem. Without any image or human preference
data, we use only 20K text prompts to fine-tune SDXL to obtain CoMat-SDXL.
Extensive experiments show that CoMat-SDXL significantly outperforms the
baseline model SDXL in two text-to-image alignment benchmarks and achieves
start-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.34088587760925293,
-0.5768997669219971,
0.6470195651054382,
0.1651230901479721,
-0.5782973170280457,
0.007134915329515934,
-0.07949662953615189,
-0.29533880949020386,
-0.06992562115192413,
0.31365740299224854,
-0.589528501033783,
-0.47709667682647705,
-0.7240162491798401,
0.040534451603889465,
-0.3592042624950409,
0.8886054754257202,
-0.12439369410276413,
-0.05805034935474396,
-0.5090781450271606,
-0.16705743968486786,
-0.8365108966827393,
0.12945368885993958,
-1.1721417903900146,
-0.08842483162879944,
0.44805678725242615,
0.39673346281051636,
0.6465081572532654,
0.8133307695388794,
0.6545131802558899,
0.17335578799247742,
-0.061506256461143494,
0.26273348927497864,
-0.30725571513175964,
-0.032335035502910614,
-0.38711249828338623,
-0.3218004107475281,
-0.094825379550457,
-0.1551177203655243,
0.48300573229789734,
0.42307794094085693,
-0.040724288672208786,
-0.16595308482646942,
0.006697905715554953,
0.8402764797210693,
-0.7674293518066406,
-0.21124175190925598,
-0.6129348278045654,
0.1268332451581955,
0.03137049078941345,
-0.14654597640037537,
-0.5909668207168579,
-0.07419867813587189,
0.2679421901702881,
-0.7372174263000488,
0.518903374671936,
0.3673469126224518,
1.0876045227050781,
0.8894864916801453,
-0.41826221346855164,
-0.06861042976379395,
-0.4211069345474243,
0.7083888649940491,
-0.5541181564331055,
0.3240453004837036,
0.0538393035531044,
0.014615384861826897,
0.13052071630954742,
-0.5865054726600647,
-0.6734621524810791,
0.020965885370969772,
-0.12131402641534805,
0.4058290421962738,
-0.24702109396457672,
-0.024490151554346085,
-0.07821494340896606,
-0.02674105204641819,
-0.5434930324554443,
0.2284240424633026,
-0.06961831450462341,
-0.0087024150416255,
0.3405976891517639,
0.07224425673484802,
0.2236989587545395,
0.0886712521314621,
-0.8964671492576599,
0.060537099838256836,
-0.5258209109306335,
-0.1298413872718811,
0.015116224065423012,
0.15989726781845093,
-0.19073250889778137,
0.6171688437461853,
0.05484551191329956,
0.7208621501922607,
0.612281858921051,
0.36717337369918823,
-0.027179870754480362,
-0.3693183958530426,
-0.34864407777786255,
0.28694766759872437,
0.779382586479187,
0.7156853675842285,
-0.023377977311611176,
-0.22460010647773743,
-0.22445622086524963,
0.14860090613365173,
0.24108000099658966,
-0.9606332182884216,
-0.10501855611801147,
0.21461951732635498,
-0.3285439908504486,
-0.4731092154979706,
-0.1550120860338211,
-0.6177896857261658,
-0.4071813225746155,
-0.2812579870223999,
0.5911291837692261,
-0.31968867778778076,
-0.09257035702466965,
0.19450633227825165,
-0.27946966886520386,
0.2846318185329437,
0.44817855954170227,
-0.7130914330482483,
0.07067312300205231,
0.3827146589756012,
1.2694871425628662,
-0.8250939846038818,
0.07141448557376862,
-0.2820819914340973,
0.23267963528633118,
-0.5508769750595093,
1.1738618612289429,
-0.45946410298347473,
-0.16434326767921448,
-0.09877564758062363,
-0.05822789669036865,
-0.2073308676481247,
-0.40211760997772217,
0.6516775488853455,
-0.6239485740661621,
0.2925046980381012,
-0.1418066769838333,
-0.7248511910438538,
0.2792412042617798,
0.262497216463089,
-0.6034866571426392,
0.8177588582038879,
0.07011877000331879,
-0.8831090927124023,
0.25586020946502686,
-0.9986892342567444,
-0.3563183844089508,
0.03125187009572983,
-0.018257446587085724,
-0.6586201786994934,
0.018281344324350357,
0.12756596505641937,
0.533761203289032,
-0.40093785524368286,
0.1738419383764267,
-0.005892554763704538,
-0.26902762055397034,
0.38060876727104187,
-0.3522427976131439,
0.530258297920227,
0.26280638575553894,
-0.10023067146539688,
0.157321959733963,
-0.4617016017436981,
-0.25706687569618225,
0.07843656837940216,
0.03480901941657066,
-0.36621999740600586,
0.03938441351056099,
0.24470046162605286,
0.2964063584804535,
0.37798166275024414,
-0.4964219331741333,
-0.032131265848875046,
-0.24142412841320038,
0.5559710264205933,
0.7773414850234985,
0.20934714376926422,
0.7891332507133484,
-0.179147869348526,
0.26241937279701233,
0.5181804299354553,
0.07761026918888092,
-0.3776390850543976,
-0.41359949111938477,
-0.7931069731712341,
-0.29242977499961853,
0.423677533864975,
0.4516891837120056,
-0.562876284122467,
0.4519982635974884,
-0.28338244557380676,
-0.29617685079574585,
-0.6894221305847168,
-0.17064706981182098,
0.24916976690292358,
0.9411553144454956,
0.40992122888565063,
-0.6115237474441528,
-0.04407181590795517,
-1.067299723625183,
0.17483967542648315,
0.31328219175338745,
0.09124423563480377,
0.16868381202220917,
0.34416812658309937,
-0.22380663454532623,
1.1210585832595825,
-0.7520360946655273,
-0.6235485672950745,
0.2799801826477051,
0.1270434558391571,
-0.28879526257514954,
0.6787801384925842,
0.5000378489494324,
-0.8850414156913757,
-0.5836656093597412,
0.2125186175107956,
-0.3823133111000061,
-0.045159727334976196,
-0.3500704765319824,
-0.4618969261646271,
0.44377440214157104,
0.753861665725708,
-0.7124682068824768,
0.3693702518939972,
0.2502746284008026,
-0.5687667727470398,
0.30223363637924194,
-0.22203104197978973,
0.2393133044242859,
-1.3661410808563232,
0.2311408370733261,
0.541793942451477,
-0.2601812779903412,
-0.4228566884994507,
0.11814339458942413,
0.3931374251842499,
-0.17041946947574615,
-0.49625271558761597,
0.5517857670783997,
-0.328191876411438,
0.3202781677246094,
-0.4375995695590973,
0.3738205134868622,
0.2287197858095169,
0.42649000883102417,
0.414262592792511,
0.8584901094436646,
0.6538427472114563,
-0.5758044719696045,
0.0411590114235878,
0.4067242741584778,
-0.09300444275140762,
1.3404630422592163,
-0.6975212097167969,
0.05836673080921173,
-0.25703051686286926,
0.18709620833396912,
-1.4164116382598877,
-0.0849495455622673,
0.3561253547668457,
-0.392464280128479,
0.4723903238773346,
0.060935717076063156,
-0.36637744307518005,
0.045448027551174164,
-0.20149612426757812,
0.6616805195808411,
0.48001596331596375,
-0.43205469846725464,
0.32806938886642456,
-0.09581838548183441,
0.029113734140992165,
-0.6933109760284424,
-0.5115516781806946,
0.30923911929130554,
-0.3952156901359558,
-0.5700941681861877,
0.7832906246185303,
-0.1857088953256607,
0.3820965886116028,
0.15511631965637207,
-0.1842237263917923,
-0.24716347455978394,
-0.17657694220542908,
-0.07376807183027267,
0.24665439128875732,
-0.20400470495224,
0.17231878638267517,
0.2770732045173645,
-0.33103370666503906,
-0.15336772799491882,
-0.4474823772907257,
0.3646080791950226,
0.4455593228340149,
-0.1966892033815384,
-0.7710655331611633,
0.39407989382743835,
0.5625850558280945,
-0.32334327697753906,
0.7112852334976196,
0.676258385181427,
-0.3584996163845062,
0.09163691103458405,
-0.47867491841316223,
0.01086682453751564,
-0.44277188181877136,
0.43089649081230164,
-0.052485957741737366,
-0.5590387582778931,
0.3774819076061249,
-0.2595739960670471,
0.08450432866811752,
0.3799116611480713,
0.393637090921402,
-0.4176046550273895,
1.0262421369552612,
0.801496148109436,
0.1783159226179123,
0.6268662214279175,
-0.10688737034797668,
0.22480641305446625,
-1.0716862678527832,
-0.12401442974805832,
-0.4376783072948456,
-0.5825697779655457,
-0.0015781347174197435,
-0.47937652468681335,
0.13413318991661072,
-0.1299585998058319,
-0.3019246757030487,
0.40870583057403564,
-0.843903124332428,
0.7330625057220459,
0.26815569400787354,
0.2886047959327698,
0.3048255145549774,
-0.020270133391022682,
0.08346491307020187,
-0.20906959474086761,
-0.5168336033821106,
-0.27448540925979614,
0.7084882259368896,
0.02159353531897068,
0.7278414964675903,
0.04566596448421478,
0.4946366548538208,
0.33144962787628174,
0.27733904123306274,
-0.688522219657898,
0.4768592417240143,
-0.2968440353870392,
-0.2252088487148285,
-0.2151159942150116,
-0.09397822618484497,
-1.0053743124008179,
-0.11965281516313553,
-0.008934595622122288,
-0.45632439851760864,
0.3744090497493744,
0.17696800827980042,
-0.4128418266773224,
-0.16442164778709412,
-0.9148270487785339,
1.112268328666687,
0.017080333083868027,
-0.5387874841690063,
-0.09632270038127899,
-0.8183116912841797,
0.2692505121231079,
-0.2858731746673584,
-0.07945120334625244,
0.05655369162559509,
-0.47571125626564026,
0.5465079545974731,
-0.37243664264678955,
0.9678101539611816,
-0.04153398051857948,
-0.42623740434646606,
-0.034042127430438995,
-0.09298240393400192,
0.4056365191936493,
-0.21517543494701385,
0.20470379292964935,
-0.1463385820388794,
-0.1295919418334961,
-0.5330561399459839,
-0.6757953763008118,
0.6938599348068237,
-0.6720537543296814,
-0.44514816999435425,
-0.1466248482465744,
-0.5471035242080688,
-0.02583693154156208,
0.11558296531438828,
0.8252099752426147,
0.028079284355044365,
-0.19567787647247314,
-0.04783325642347336,
1.0356565713882446,
0.036104656755924225,
0.5886738896369934,
0.3073466122150421,
0.3086473345756531,
-0.31623008847236633,
0.9822964668273926,
-0.18301358819007874,
0.6520213484764099,
0.5903074145317078,
0.03130492568016052,
-0.5644069314002991,
-0.3454969823360443,
-0.6871892213821411,
0.07310949265956879,
-0.6693239808082581,
-0.6040733456611633,
-0.49563685059547424,
-0.12917350232601166,
-0.17630831897258759,
-0.629976212978363,
-0.3618199825286865,
-0.3376540541648865,
-0.8242439031600952,
0.32730621099472046,
0.3422524034976959,
0.17999252676963806,
0.24415795505046844,
0.7265924215316772,
-0.34767696261405945,
0.26341933012008667,
0.013610058464109898,
0.4137645661830902,
0.17526431381702423,
-0.708324670791626,
-0.23096676170825958,
-0.037077050656080246,
-0.6118138432502747,
-0.8749182820320129,
0.05915122851729393,
0.3434205651283264,
0.09958714246749878,
0.6710959076881409,
0.08701906353235245,
0.8396462798118591,
-0.5295472741127014,
0.7534148097038269,
0.6272657513618469,
-0.9344069361686707,
0.6549657583236694,
-0.09931207448244095,
0.3040134012699127,
0.2750881314277649,
0.17395228147506714,
-0.6768121719360352,
-0.4823805093765259,
-0.6069204211235046,
-0.8924012184143066,
0.5427762269973755,
0.2857368290424347,
0.22541695833206177,
-0.055277206003665924,
0.4631100296974182,
-0.05115782096982002,
0.029134245589375496,
-0.706769585609436,
-0.012722436338663101,
-0.15062816441059113,
-0.6327989101409912,
0.24095024168491364,
0.18960338830947876,
-0.0918518602848053,
-0.14749771356582642,
0.6772720217704773,
-0.21073445677757263,
0.26536187529563904,
0.3646923005580902,
-0.17958274483680725,
-0.3473988473415375,
0.0030492355581372976,
0.7194932699203491,
0.10248780995607376,
0.2392989844083786,
-0.045178841799497604,
-0.13874487578868866,
-0.35333648324012756,
0.364414781332016,
0.13012342154979706,
-0.4569331407546997,
-0.13286185264587402,
-0.09226223081350327,
0.7364602088928223,
0.2324340045452118,
-0.47603070735931396,
0.6999018788337708,
-0.11214321851730347,
-0.30849990248680115,
0.07688569277524948,
0.1452394425868988,
0.20171312987804413,
0.1782880276441574,
0.32571306824684143,
0.6008592247962952,
0.045110560953617096,
0.052058134227991104,
0.19587859511375427,
0.8297527432441711,
-0.61965012550354,
0.12520155310630798,
1.0923655033111572,
0.30732235312461853,
-0.25637850165367126,
0.4101250469684601,
-0.17298585176467896,
-0.16001348197460175,
0.8299286365509033,
0.6771010160446167,
0.9357815980911255,
-0.0028214589692652225,
0.4248104691505432,
0.22883695363998413,
0.2180868536233902,
-0.2342798411846161,
-0.16441985964775085,
-0.1834142655134201,
-0.7237407565116882,
-0.40895330905914307,
-0.26113468408584595,
-0.1495923399925232,
-0.19994103908538818,
-0.51109379529953,
0.5269051194190979,
-0.22456413507461548,
-0.24129901826381683,
0.15859366953372955,
-0.17758074402809143,
-0.5716823935508728,
0.3198763430118561,
-0.14376211166381836,
0.8598335385322571,
-0.972478449344635,
0.5159161686897278,
0.594436764717102,
-0.5063416361808777,
-0.3712921440601349,
0.07285037636756897,
-0.4138341546058655,
-0.6747355461120605,
0.34374797344207764,
0.18699607253074646,
0.07094895839691162,
0.6072432398796082,
-0.9576478004455566,
-0.70485919713974,
1.25960111618042,
0.331272691488266,
-0.5966957211494446,
0.12586814165115356,
0.08868497610092163,
0.45631009340286255,
-0.5540502071380615,
-0.13365525007247925,
0.4861219525337219,
0.3220066726207733,
0.46648532152175903,
-0.3777744472026825,
0.2632002532482147,
-0.06506121158599854,
0.15457682311534882,
0.25656354427337646,
-0.8848263621330261,
0.3732222318649292,
-0.47992801666259766,
-0.42562732100486755,
0.3552643060684204,
0.6382238268852234,
0.09264472126960754,
0.3698391020298004,
0.4407396912574768,
0.9502571225166321,
0.5146359205245972,
-0.09758191555738449,
0.5629783868789673,
-0.15672311186790466,
0.33774232864379883,
0.851711630821228,
-0.34347620606422424,
0.7211311459541321,
0.6881468892097473,
0.191939115524292,
0.20413699746131897,
1.0127089023590088,
-0.15377408266067505,
0.9605974555015564,
-0.16624855995178223,
-0.3559345602989197,
-0.23420622944831848,
-0.25406691431999207,
-0.19488126039505005,
-0.17443570494651794,
0.3083682656288147,
-0.5547844171524048,
-0.34693580865859985,
0.06916866451501846,
-0.3832150101661682,
0.07316344231367111,
-0.1983659863471985,
0.8868902921676636,
-0.1254330277442932,
-0.7240105867385864,
0.4921920895576477,
0.002839724300429225,
0.8214450478553772,
-0.2184622585773468,
0.14856353402137756,
-0.29347729682922363,
-0.04468478262424469,
-0.20744653046131134,
-0.8720481991767883,
0.13610735535621643,
-0.11311250180006027,
-0.4131326377391815,
-0.026339799165725708,
0.5674223303794861,
-0.6460483074188232,
-0.37520208954811096,
-0.19783180952072144,
0.3100547790527344,
-0.08800633996725082,
-0.033309079706668854,
-0.6816473603248596,
-0.1150030642747879,
-0.04182456061244011,
0.02491399273276329,
0.2761401832103729,
0.6321560740470886,
-0.14231327176094055,
0.4683772921562195,
0.4597225785255432,
-0.263667494058609,
-0.14056247472763062,
-0.0028579197824001312,
0.4927825331687927,
-0.315346360206604,
-0.4838239550590515,
-1.0766031742095947,
0.6906394958496094,
-0.2011135220527649,
-0.472726970911026,
0.05681195482611656,
0.6660600900650024,
0.5172522068023682,
-0.25567948818206787,
0.6776325702667236,
-0.02649649605154991,
-0.2375294715166092,
-0.5909999012947083,
0.8075461983680725,
-0.7668932676315308,
-0.009526790119707584,
-0.3378574550151825,
-0.9929901361465454,
-0.3819815516471863,
0.5667132139205933,
0.19210797548294067,
-0.2678067684173584,
0.8117263913154602,
0.9172029495239258,
-0.2615208327770233,
-0.14895373582839966,
0.30031195282936096,
-0.13743729889392853,
0.2709980905056,
0.6313168406486511,
0.5605410933494568,
-0.5781344175338745,
0.5087062120437622,
0.08857748657464981,
-0.2622447609901428,
-0.08603086322546005,
-1.1486709117889404,
-0.6164409518241882,
-1.0606935024261475,
-0.88619464635849,
-0.19415099918842316,
-0.10834721475839615,
0.6161860227584839,
0.7582016587257385,
-0.3995203375816345,
0.2835421562194824,
-0.3956499993801117,
0.06960800290107727,
-0.3006327450275421,
-0.21646937727928162,
0.6376888751983643,
-0.5047711133956909,
-0.757947564125061,
-0.3221985697746277,
0.4634746015071869,
0.5432911515235901,
-0.04067210853099823,
-0.04457896575331688,
-0.07893470674753189,
0.22317436337471008,
0.5665541887283325,
0.047395993024110794,
-0.6764666438102722,
-0.13494452834129333,
0.20320622622966766,
-0.25452470779418945,
0.42340925335884094,
0.6151810884475708,
-0.6225262880325317,
0.17715732753276825,
0.012985303066670895,
0.7519866824150085,
0.27356910705566406,
0.19331492483615875,
0.3557923436164856,
-1.2975022792816162,
0.008465110324323177,
-0.00845148041844368,
0.18926924467086792,
0.520311176776886,
-0.5773696303367615,
0.4291125535964966,
0.23075972497463226,
-0.5383760333061218,
-0.7312215566635132,
0.25736045837402344,
-1.3964289426803589,
-0.27445417642593384,
0.8985673785209656,
0.2676570415496826,
-0.23273541033267975,
0.0813164934515953,
-0.7366798520088196,
0.4003746509552002,
-0.5217865705490112,
1.0175594091415405,
0.8741946816444397,
-0.0051428815349936485,
-0.5240197777748108,
-0.24957811832427979,
0.3791399598121643,
0.5523694753646851,
-0.8087548017501831,
0.05412083491683006,
0.44646185636520386,
0.2608903646469116,
0.25550612807273865,
0.543728768825531,
0.05603177472949028,
0.5206531882286072,
-0.4060456454753876,
0.02043294720351696,
0.24874760210514069,
0.005363562144339085,
-0.1490539163351059,
-0.24245008826255798,
-0.03839707374572754,
-0.5194618105888367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03648v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03648v1
|
AutoWebGLM: Bootstrap And Reinforce A Large Language Model-based Web Navigating Agent
| 2024-04-04T17:58:40 | 2024-04-04T17:58:40 |
Hanyu Lai, Xiao Liu, Iat Long Iong, Shuntian Yao, Yuxuan Chen, Pengbo Shen, Hao Yu, Hanchen Zhang, Xiaohan Zhang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have fueled many intelligent agent tasks, such
as web navigation -- but most existing agents perform far from satisfying in
real-world webpages due to three factors: (1) the versatility of actions on
webpages, (2) HTML text exceeding model processing capacity, and (3) the
complexity of decision-making due to the open-domain nature of web. In light of
the challenge, we develop AutoWebGLM, a GPT-4-outperforming automated web
navigation agent built upon ChatGLM3-6B. Inspired by human browsing patterns,
we design an HTML simplification algorithm to represent webpages, preserving
vital information succinctly. We employ a hybrid human-AI method to build web
browsing data for curriculum training. Then, we bootstrap the model by
reinforcement learning and rejection sampling to further facilitate webpage
comprehension, browser operations, and efficient task decomposition by itself.
For testing, we establish a bilingual benchmark -- AutoWebBench -- for
real-world web browsing tasks. We evaluate AutoWebGLM across diverse web
navigation benchmarks, revealing its improvements but also underlying
challenges to tackle real environments. Related code, model, and data will be
released at \url{https://github.com/THUDM/AutoWebGLM}.
|
[
-0.5798105597496033,
-0.80302894115448,
0.2195984125137329,
0.3851882219314575,
0.04388429597020149,
0.34325045347213745,
-0.3016516864299774,
-0.528317391872406,
-0.11149236559867859,
0.06638601422309875,
-0.3773651421070099,
-0.48791012167930603,
-0.2478247880935669,
-0.10539715737104416,
-0.48203182220458984,
0.6651643514633179,
0.027168402448296547,
0.11999668926000595,
-0.401292622089386,
0.14251187443733215,
-0.050172191113233566,
-0.4224652349948883,
-0.6647185683250427,
-0.425091028213501,
0.43508028984069824,
0.39309102296829224,
0.9119607210159302,
0.5959078073501587,
0.2980439364910126,
0.39919254183769226,
0.2701042592525482,
0.08793693780899048,
-0.4253968894481659,
-0.0034811014775186777,
-0.3286512494087219,
-0.4311802089214325,
-0.6815841794013977,
0.11106838285923004,
0.41173338890075684,
0.7244024276733398,
-0.4591276943683624,
-0.046441834419965744,
0.0992986410856247,
0.510125458240509,
-0.6608557105064392,
0.35994160175323486,
-0.3155720829963684,
-0.1369556486606598,
0.14024433493614197,
-0.05210530012845993,
-0.4588339328765869,
-0.3241764008998871,
0.11320222169160843,
-0.8403624296188354,
0.1759549081325531,
0.352186381816864,
0.7732074856758118,
0.28541719913482666,
-0.6060003638267517,
-0.12715888023376465,
-0.6250688433647156,
0.6228381395339966,
-0.43237781524658203,
0.5808639526367188,
0.5307069420814514,
0.28784310817718506,
-0.3971705734729767,
-0.6332532167434692,
-0.4734346866607666,
-0.33045732975006104,
0.20567362010478973,
0.23244856297969818,
-0.24246743321418762,
0.0026905667036771774,
-0.050714123994112015,
0.21682025492191315,
-1.0135631561279297,
0.3877831697463989,
-0.2802695333957672,
-0.42468586564064026,
0.5290859341621399,
0.15962263941764832,
0.6006099581718445,
0.3554111123085022,
-0.37531062960624695,
-0.40424466133117676,
-0.6720346808433533,
-0.16180473566055298,
0.33799415826797485,
0.08487165719270706,
-0.007092129439115524,
0.1350383162498474,
-0.37816867232322693,
0.7933392524719238,
0.019016820937395096,
-0.050264306366443634,
0.2971244752407074,
0.11004207283258438,
-0.13464005291461945,
-0.20537133514881134,
0.5906112790107727,
0.5749819278717041,
0.408576101064682,
-0.36905133724212646,
-0.3157632648944855,
-0.025509241968393326,
0.5492645502090454,
-0.7536531090736389,
-0.3845613896846771,
0.12904062867164612,
-0.39219143986701965,
-0.03637976199388504,
0.06650199741125107,
-0.5814418792724609,
-0.19944901764392853,
-0.19110597670078278,
0.34795206785202026,
-0.46476686000823975,
-0.18605506420135498,
0.09982294589281082,
0.0111513277515769,
0.6285060048103333,
0.5622457265853882,
-0.7090083360671997,
0.4876636266708374,
0.42070499062538147,
0.6976681351661682,
-0.5549337863922119,
-0.5589249134063721,
-0.49120235443115234,
0.23067307472229004,
-0.2630237638950348,
0.6200782060623169,
-0.5414674282073975,
-0.2918839454650879,
0.2671371400356293,
-0.02720211260020733,
0.07960491627454758,
-0.5109891295433044,
0.02849210798740387,
-0.7774264812469482,
0.16314075887203217,
0.04202038794755936,
-0.5323401093482971,
-0.41418880224227905,
0.39690983295440674,
-0.5986831784248352,
0.6980777382850647,
-0.04878121614456177,
-0.03136826306581497,
0.13978268206119537,
-0.4604097306728363,
-0.6403091549873352,
0.2577902376651764,
0.10571131110191345,
-0.06384024769067764,
-0.1493835151195526,
0.12809206545352936,
0.2251717895269394,
-0.4951951503753662,
-0.03371342271566391,
-0.187257781624794,
-0.34684354066848755,
-0.08363413065671921,
-0.3883712887763977,
0.7305988669395447,
0.13107773661613464,
-0.37683627009391785,
-0.04139569029211998,
-0.7167329788208008,
0.16679196059703827,
0.28398871421813965,
-0.6140522956848145,
-0.16075068712234497,
0.14238472282886505,
0.33670884370803833,
0.29834410548210144,
0.35212716460227966,
-0.18501827120780945,
0.4515626132488251,
-0.13718882203102112,
0.05453988164663315,
0.6640033721923828,
-0.23581205308437347,
0.514402449131012,
-0.3641967475414276,
0.818943977355957,
-0.17395710945129395,
0.23946338891983032,
-0.03879684582352638,
-0.5403474569320679,
-1.0748282670974731,
-0.004804740194231272,
0.2995598316192627,
0.5959853529930115,
-0.8325072526931763,
0.3645585775375366,
-0.14452558755874634,
-0.5978474617004395,
-0.18098077178001404,
0.23443284630775452,
0.44089314341545105,
0.18512770533561707,
0.6712181568145752,
-0.4380110502243042,
-0.04662699997425079,
-0.7595837116241455,
-0.15741953253746033,
-0.3955167233943939,
-0.05718028172850609,
-0.09647536277770996,
0.482281357049942,
-0.5626152157783508,
0.8660401701927185,
-0.5329316258430481,
-0.27117958664894104,
-0.31504136323928833,
0.32290884852409363,
-0.38296815752983093,
0.5332814455032349,
0.36190953850746155,
-0.8802530169487,
-0.59425288438797,
-0.1962086707353592,
-0.6186864376068115,
-0.321978360414505,
-0.06556786596775055,
-0.04666193202137947,
0.14004530012607574,
0.5594245195388794,
-0.5964260101318359,
0.37784692645072937,
0.3041430413722992,
-0.1312231421470642,
0.5064576268196106,
-0.33212101459503174,
-0.10962564498186111,
-0.5779778361320496,
-0.19393318891525269,
0.3309907615184784,
-0.48445311188697815,
-0.49766805768013,
0.3837904930114746,
0.21148450672626495,
0.09801334142684937,
-0.27769893407821655,
0.7735490202903748,
-0.8648335337638855,
-0.04106825962662697,
-0.517665684223175,
0.24926738440990448,
-0.16098552942276,
0.6376942992210388,
-0.1592969447374344,
0.7262076735496521,
0.5539190769195557,
-0.7696779370307922,
0.60222989320755,
0.1449664682149887,
0.07341112941503525,
0.3840178847312927,
-0.33377933502197266,
0.044494789093732834,
0.11546313762664795,
0.5271609425544739,
-0.9242463707923889,
-0.27603429555892944,
0.02536630444228649,
-0.24258080124855042,
0.35301631689071655,
-0.1881306916475296,
-0.771331787109375,
-0.3946821987628937,
-0.20954670011997223,
0.30920422077178955,
0.6871117353439331,
-0.5521851778030396,
0.6149380207061768,
0.5768868923187256,
-0.21313229203224182,
-0.19903671741485596,
-0.3518778681755066,
0.3282204270362854,
0.08588536083698273,
-0.5059905052185059,
0.4248037040233612,
-0.39998573064804077,
-0.23172874748706818,
-0.21774877607822418,
-0.13865797221660614,
-0.10171517729759216,
0.21820855140686035,
0.17422311007976532,
0.25747179985046387,
-0.010155174881219864,
0.03446852043271065,
-0.18428567051887512,
-0.11751110851764679,
0.1982320100069046,
-0.45745205879211426,
0.6232943534851074,
-0.5784479379653931,
-0.6048048138618469,
-0.198618546128273,
0.03305576369166374,
0.40657639503479004,
-0.20774473249912262,
0.20869080722332,
0.7621251940727234,
-0.1853894591331482,
-0.30582430958747864,
-0.6442084908485413,
0.003903188044205308,
-0.5671641826629639,
0.18662205338478088,
-0.10103310644626617,
-0.6468920111656189,
0.48230624198913574,
-0.33262336254119873,
-0.021154209971427917,
0.19364695250988007,
0.5600546598434448,
-0.2243880033493042,
1.0031732320785522,
0.6393582224845886,
-0.2865840494632721,
0.36151909828186035,
-0.19901703298091888,
-0.16155372560024261,
-0.3761846423149109,
-0.29584893584251404,
-0.13770338892936707,
-0.4093032777309418,
-0.7562119364738464,
-0.4648124575614929,
0.2693173885345459,
-0.11219584196805954,
-0.1418800801038742,
0.1864025890827179,
-0.2292996346950531,
0.3571357727050781,
0.752981960773468,
-0.10512582212686539,
0.35502955317497253,
-0.06429554522037506,
-0.3240996301174164,
0.43025875091552734,
-0.9143146872520447,
-0.42181017994880676,
0.9035383462905884,
0.16797785460948944,
1.1197879314422607,
0.3000195324420929,
0.44592922925949097,
0.48040771484375,
0.25281208753585815,
-0.6465750336647034,
0.9332948327064514,
0.30884191393852234,
-0.5010596513748169,
-0.2728063762187958,
-0.23346124589443207,
-1.0189911127090454,
0.3878498077392578,
-0.11559223383665085,
-0.6090770363807678,
-0.03507433086633682,
0.31141334772109985,
-0.07007233798503876,
0.13375478982925415,
-0.6000955700874329,
0.7548196315765381,
-0.4594639241695404,
-0.7452613115310669,
-0.38150888681411743,
-0.7600842714309692,
0.024210136383771896,
0.08511579036712646,
0.2552649676799774,
0.1512526422739029,
-0.333416610956192,
0.27767565846443176,
-0.5098453760147095,
0.9212082028388977,
-0.14055511355400085,
-0.23931244015693665,
0.2047455757856369,
0.30213648080825806,
0.5860635042190552,
-0.25635412335395813,
0.38157615065574646,
0.08769790083169937,
-0.49229857325553894,
-0.5223551392555237,
-0.4389858841896057,
0.665621817111969,
-0.6027085781097412,
-0.861721396446228,
-0.6566025018692017,
-0.24804596602916718,
-0.602706789970398,
0.20280367136001587,
0.05678160861134529,
0.4192602038383484,
-0.4746021032333374,
0.12966008484363556,
0.5402052998542786,
-0.3075718879699707,
0.6849141716957092,
0.798154354095459,
-0.5998744368553162,
-0.028486309573054314,
1.159777283668518,
-0.13769042491912842,
0.2337241768836975,
0.3350578546524048,
-0.03383864462375641,
-0.3362993597984314,
-0.7055017352104187,
-0.6914865970611572,
0.011988182552158833,
-0.6555193662643433,
-0.10845872759819031,
-0.29275497794151306,
-0.30550912022590637,
-0.16192086040973663,
-0.2095700204372406,
-0.1852456033229828,
-0.19547730684280396,
-0.14697496592998505,
0.1202375516295433,
-0.03558381274342537,
0.8106973171234131,
-0.20404095947742462,
0.3783220946788788,
-0.6250678300857544,
0.32157427072525024,
0.5441944003105164,
0.2531237304210663,
0.20097029209136963,
-0.23928551375865936,
-0.4957614839076996,
-0.1127525120973587,
-0.35727807879447937,
-0.6366409659385681,
0.39552468061447144,
0.03568069636821747,
0.726391077041626,
0.4395536482334137,
-0.1076047345995903,
0.5878773331642151,
-0.5769574046134949,
0.6479142904281616,
0.14039450883865356,
-0.591158390045166,
0.1364792436361313,
-0.5900589227676392,
0.6775979995727539,
0.39360371232032776,
0.4801405668258667,
-0.3646985590457916,
-0.4976826310157776,
-0.39956966042518616,
-0.9238528609275818,
0.46533113718032837,
0.2551093101501465,
-0.15221138298511505,
0.0512969009578228,
0.17360034584999084,
-0.0469827726483345,
0.1666257679462433,
-0.6781038045883179,
-0.34058260917663574,
-0.30057767033576965,
-0.028514675796031952,
-0.016505295410752296,
0.04081696644425392,
0.22924663126468658,
-0.23782865703105927,
0.9932773113250732,
-0.3576945662498474,
0.031299151480197906,
-0.13754884898662567,
-0.8731281161308289,
0.028486888855695724,
0.09476400166749954,
0.46470218896865845,
0.7445769906044006,
-0.09841123968362808,
0.14010928571224213,
0.12944872677326202,
-0.6473858952522278,
0.4120836555957794,
0.2742657959461212,
-0.29722851514816284,
-0.29291388392448425,
0.32654979825019836,
0.3335946202278137,
0.1443595290184021,
-0.8176642060279846,
0.48000451922416687,
-0.13353879749774933,
0.16233785450458527,
-0.3815324902534485,
0.4770747125148773,
0.12322436273097992,
0.24614232778549194,
0.7350432276725769,
-0.34116145968437195,
0.3435666263103485,
-0.5467481017112732,
0.05101710185408592,
0.5084949731826782,
-0.23139943182468414,
-0.26617100834846497,
0.7101109623908997,
0.5484783053398132,
-0.40960320830345154,
0.6182760000228882,
-0.5070725083351135,
-0.6096016764640808,
0.6079795360565186,
0.6491484045982361,
0.7944712042808533,
-0.37547406554222107,
0.16955521702766418,
0.1021580845117569,
0.4443086087703705,
-0.23897139728069305,
0.03999820724129677,
0.0047318339347839355,
-0.4461495280265808,
-0.16217182576656342,
-0.5482643842697144,
-0.5017752051353455,
0.07978931814432144,
-0.5090945363044739,
-0.11562640219926834,
-0.364399254322052,
-0.050601761788129807,
-0.3216423988342285,
-0.1832338571548462,
-0.6933103799819946,
0.5870798826217651,
0.2752073407173157,
0.8989666104316711,
-0.31737345457077026,
0.8124514222145081,
0.7448472380638123,
-0.49878352880477905,
-0.20367608964443207,
0.48064547777175903,
0.3650430738925934,
-0.7376282215118408,
0.5268674492835999,
0.11594827473163605,
-0.637679398059845,
0.192832350730896,
-0.5531877875328064,
-0.83074551820755,
1.0159775018692017,
0.08117903769016266,
-0.6526874899864197,
-0.27337273955345154,
0.17018212378025055,
0.4562164545059204,
-0.1968531310558319,
0.30604287981987,
0.09496059268712997,
0.5749832391738892,
-0.3041810095310211,
-0.9433830380439758,
0.07191041857004166,
-0.3673253357410431,
0.00476317061111331,
0.00988311879336834,
-1.1224250793457031,
0.5816280245780945,
0.032953716814517975,
-0.09253520518541336,
0.04034703969955444,
0.7052237391471863,
-0.11826032400131226,
-0.03361442685127258,
0.774351179599762,
0.4602372646331787,
0.646550714969635,
0.06432826817035675,
0.8794906735420227,
-0.4224131405353546,
0.16763794422149658,
1.130070686340332,
-0.37803494930267334,
0.6946472525596619,
0.11798886954784393,
-0.01201665960252285,
0.640001118183136,
0.6107937097549438,
-0.07922744750976562,
0.3341556191444397,
0.27809977531433105,
-0.19444219768047333,
-0.4978041648864746,
0.22084000706672668,
-0.1859942227602005,
0.7618581652641296,
0.3423572778701782,
0.07331777364015579,
-0.41445666551589966,
0.09320265799760818,
-0.17758502066135406,
-0.04308236762881279,
-0.3612385392189026,
0.6869698166847229,
0.0832308828830719,
-0.8099575638771057,
0.5335379838943481,
0.26792046427726746,
0.41619956493377686,
-0.7278304100036621,
-0.009976545348763466,
-0.3049179017543793,
0.05767887458205223,
0.04234921559691429,
-0.47766348719596863,
-0.28827837109565735,
0.03398703783750534,
0.07552491873502731,
-0.4446692168712616,
0.7716416716575623,
-0.34520503878593445,
-0.1826130598783493,
0.5204263925552368,
0.8381946086883545,
0.10162604600191116,
-0.021484022960066795,
-0.7289383411407471,
-0.020917143672704697,
-0.0629807710647583,
-0.36140671372413635,
0.6813607811927795,
0.19194276630878448,
-0.09544892609119415,
1.1452293395996094,
0.6006386280059814,
-0.12260833382606506,
0.13122178614139557,
-0.010600301437079906,
0.7800325155258179,
-0.8092858195304871,
-0.5625228881835938,
-0.7917376160621643,
0.1453038603067398,
-0.08035963773727417,
-0.06768833845853806,
0.8362487554550171,
1.0090010166168213,
0.8530990481376648,
0.1679198145866394,
0.9038555026054382,
0.1743248701095581,
0.005129634402692318,
-0.575271487236023,
0.8458507061004639,
-0.6834530234336853,
0.038633424788713455,
0.04194646701216698,
-1.0019996166229248,
-0.08796822279691696,
0.6928499937057495,
0.021412959322333336,
0.36381691694259644,
0.5732734203338623,
0.7382002472877502,
-0.3491467237472534,
-0.2164660394191742,
0.40743735432624817,
0.2588020861148834,
0.23575489223003387,
0.45636090636253357,
0.8275194764137268,
-0.08372946828603745,
0.7483319640159607,
0.07303697615861893,
-0.21934323012828827,
-0.6529846787452698,
-0.8416650891304016,
-0.8413612842559814,
-0.5852152109146118,
-0.2937171459197998,
-0.3390255868434906,
0.1702367067337036,
0.9739753007888794,
0.8280776143074036,
-0.4864685833454132,
-0.5003107786178589,
-0.1300220489501953,
0.011798344552516937,
-0.13407829403877258,
-0.15844319760799408,
0.028034361079335213,
-0.4736176133155823,
-0.7757509350776672,
0.68645840883255,
0.40080007910728455,
0.21951203048229218,
-0.6692671179771423,
-0.21025767922401428,
-0.36802899837493896,
0.10186013579368591,
0.49324727058410645,
0.4632399082183838,
-0.6292267441749573,
-0.11379359662532806,
-0.15145252645015717,
-0.3543950915336609,
0.25649866461753845,
0.4812718331813812,
-0.8503325581550598,
0.4863235652446747,
0.11376087367534637,
0.6680834293365479,
0.7671179175376892,
0.10368739813566208,
0.7449612021446228,
-0.40988150238990784,
0.011654808185994625,
0.14937886595726013,
0.4651890695095062,
0.37256067991256714,
0.000201930568437092,
0.6370441317558289,
0.12981432676315308,
-0.4196581542491913,
-0.34515541791915894,
0.23059584200382233,
-0.9467346668243408,
-0.5954477190971375,
1.3811582326889038,
-0.029593590646982193,
-0.18957996368408203,
-0.31471455097198486,
0.06113123521208763,
0.117886483669281,
-0.46654364466667175,
0.7862949371337891,
0.6868731379508972,
-0.11807478219270706,
0.12956269085407257,
-0.5988371968269348,
0.4850832223892212,
0.22104515135288239,
-0.9549430012702942,
-0.15899625420570374,
0.830642819404602,
0.2797497808933258,
0.08887628465890884,
0.4501746594905853,
0.4561634659767151,
0.4486306607723236,
-0.17038650810718536,
0.29652705788612366,
-0.19534127414226532,
-0.5084146857261658,
-0.24950578808784485,
0.21441085636615753,
-0.033796556293964386,
-0.010573698207736015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03646v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03646v1
|
Locating and Editing Factual Associations in Mamba
| 2024-04-04T17:58:31 | 2024-04-04T17:58:31 |
Arnab Sen Sharma, David Atkinson, David Bau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate the mechanisms of factual recall in the Mamba state space
model. Our work is inspired by previous findings in autoregressive transformer
language models suggesting that their knowledge recall is localized to
particular modules at specific token locations; we therefore ask whether
factual recall in Mamba can be similarly localized. To investigate this, we
conduct four lines of experiments on Mamba. First, we apply causal tracing or
interchange interventions to localize key components inside Mamba that are
responsible for recalling facts, revealing that specific components within
middle layers show strong causal effects at the last token of the subject,
while the causal effect of intervening on later layers is most pronounced at
the last token of the prompt, matching previous findings on autoregressive
transformers. Second, we show that rank-one model editing methods can
successfully insert facts at specific locations, again resembling findings on
transformer models. Third, we examine the linearity of Mamba's representations
of factual relations. Finally we adapt attention-knockout techniques to Mamba
to dissect information flow during factual recall. We compare Mamba directly to
a similar-sized transformer and conclude that despite significant differences
in architectural approach, when it comes to factual recall, the two
architectures share many similarities.
|
[
-0.42364567518234253,
-1.0230849981307983,
0.8362879157066345,
-0.04165511205792427,
0.11967108398675919,
-0.03232702240347862,
0.14173489809036255,
-0.26269280910491943,
0.48999109864234924,
0.4987436830997467,
-0.20221038162708282,
-0.2968168258666992,
-0.5512771606445312,
0.026176197454333305,
-0.34376928210258484,
0.7140899896621704,
-0.12262550741434097,
-0.3584986627101898,
-0.26666051149368286,
-0.4970583915710449,
-0.8585286140441895,
-0.9589254856109619,
-0.5132099986076355,
-0.14594672620296478,
0.6729142069816589,
0.4121628999710083,
0.8383694887161255,
0.8499326705932617,
0.2912573516368866,
0.3052011728286743,
-0.37820300459861755,
0.03746931627392769,
-0.5132694244384766,
-0.19480682909488678,
-0.46743977069854736,
-0.7782182097434998,
-0.34560686349868774,
-0.020504554733633995,
0.8017032742500305,
0.7287566065788269,
-0.23878958821296692,
0.2761453092098236,
-0.28778642416000366,
0.6337352395057678,
-0.9082643985748291,
0.3022218346595764,
-0.5575675368309021,
0.17830272018909454,
-0.09670526534318924,
-0.10387198626995087,
-0.6711181998252869,
-0.653100848197937,
0.060913603752851486,
-0.4570108652114868,
0.4872458875179291,
0.33725279569625854,
1.0240957736968994,
0.39570489525794983,
-0.7925864458084106,
-0.3747568428516388,
-0.9052879214286804,
0.2505452334880829,
-0.5146751403808594,
0.22639624774456024,
0.52606201171875,
0.29126980900764465,
-0.10300543159246445,
-0.4785913825035095,
-0.7938348650932312,
-0.06436681747436523,
-0.607657790184021,
0.23990067839622498,
-0.3546479344367981,
-0.13748589158058167,
0.5777621269226074,
0.250051885843277,
-0.18614338338375092,
-0.12114059925079346,
-0.6400933265686035,
-0.6395454406738281,
0.3185562491416931,
0.23104269802570343,
0.10813889652490616,
-0.5608458518981934,
-0.2186732292175293,
0.05861536040902138,
-0.8872347474098206,
0.1734398752450943,
0.22171343863010406,
0.12837067246437073,
0.19969500601291656,
0.8992296457290649,
-0.08633296936750412,
0.7008331418037415,
0.2738441526889801,
-0.22782285511493683,
0.13597606122493744,
-0.40156829357147217,
-0.18092867732048035,
0.47830432653427124,
0.5195722579956055,
0.17768551409244537,
-0.2788187563419342,
-0.12041071802377701,
0.06102711707353592,
-0.15880772471427917,
0.6305418610572815,
-0.3781414330005646,
-0.3564952611923218,
-0.25814589858055115,
-0.6182519793510437,
-0.11377950012683868,
0.009091373533010483,
-0.5639448761940002,
-0.5667642951011658,
-0.36861997842788696,
0.8455807566642761,
-0.4341772198677063,
-0.1341264396905899,
-0.015593890100717545,
0.07380124181509018,
0.18768373131752014,
-0.014583787880837917,
-0.8642932772636414,
0.2553084194660187,
0.36247628927230835,
0.7226341366767883,
0.23088711500167847,
-0.1998378187417984,
-0.3030582070350647,
0.4412609934806824,
-0.5492349863052368,
0.7576095461845398,
-0.6814663410186768,
-0.5375468134880066,
-0.000870184856466949,
0.15017251670360565,
-0.2572900354862213,
-0.5806320309638977,
0.5967132449150085,
-0.6396109461784363,
0.2402532547712326,
-1.0649421215057373,
-0.6932154893875122,
-0.7338417768478394,
0.10547973960638046,
-0.8572097420692444,
1.0157352685928345,
-0.2207547277212143,
-0.6671181321144104,
0.41528090834617615,
-0.5652347207069397,
-0.7597036361694336,
-0.8694632649421692,
0.22655203938484192,
-0.5822950601577759,
0.10104800015687943,
0.16434422135353088,
0.39175698161125183,
0.09608548879623413,
0.36343875527381897,
-0.11323094367980957,
-0.34285029768943787,
0.41712287068367004,
-0.14192774891853333,
0.5399502515792847,
-0.07711920142173767,
-0.288735568523407,
-0.030844414606690407,
-1.1707649230957031,
-0.9593064188957214,
0.24246403574943542,
-0.31891849637031555,
-0.5342268347740173,
0.13977976143360138,
-0.8059636950492859,
0.23035365343093872,
0.09744379669427872,
-0.6653997302055359,
0.335479199886322,
0.04530298709869385,
-0.11800013482570648,
0.5644673109054565,
0.6637344360351562,
0.616226077079773,
-0.13776956498622894,
0.23699575662612915,
0.397993266582489,
0.06191738322377205,
-0.3990531861782074,
-0.3152697682380676,
-1.2193976640701294,
-0.17525215446949005,
0.237453892827034,
0.511765718460083,
-0.5872086882591248,
0.3015923500061035,
0.047804489731788635,
-0.39137184619903564,
-0.5008904337882996,
-0.32884058356285095,
0.19733229279518127,
1.0445096492767334,
0.4999166429042816,
-0.11833809316158295,
-0.4685881435871124,
-1.2581267356872559,
0.0038579916581511497,
-0.11650273203849792,
0.24848560988903046,
0.38177862763404846,
0.30116236209869385,
0.052356231957674026,
1.2716538906097412,
-0.843055248260498,
-0.2432425171136856,
0.18469640612602234,
0.374283105134964,
0.15444082021713257,
0.2017384171485901,
1.0016955137252808,
-0.6726747751235962,
0.02077959105372429,
-0.2525998651981354,
-0.9774397611618042,
-0.020517846569418907,
-0.3868941068649292,
-0.26026952266693115,
0.2560199201107025,
0.5348721146583557,
-0.7541324496269226,
0.7177879214286804,
-0.06785858422517776,
-0.3552594780921936,
0.3059707581996918,
-0.2498677521944046,
0.45637550950050354,
-0.940385103225708,
0.2340729683637619,
-0.42512649297714233,
0.008920500986278057,
-0.5415871143341064,
-0.4141777455806732,
0.21819142997264862,
-0.1038917601108551,
-0.08926084637641907,
0.312615305185318,
-0.484313040971756,
-0.4421769380569458,
-0.28136321902275085,
0.4398179352283478,
0.15156419575214386,
0.7122423052787781,
-0.1431933343410492,
0.7416216731071472,
0.46795451641082764,
-0.9528126120567322,
0.046667952090501785,
0.509151816368103,
-0.3522697389125824,
0.2685951292514801,
-0.4162614643573761,
0.06172715127468109,
-0.3778160810470581,
0.29490625858306885,
-1.2971292734146118,
-0.047836728394031525,
0.42905402183532715,
-0.11772767454385757,
0.39605817198753357,
-0.2239977866411209,
-0.6796427369117737,
-0.2884325087070465,
0.19114206731319427,
0.1303452104330063,
0.481320858001709,
-0.5772035121917725,
0.9150872230529785,
0.6553492546081543,
-0.3463546931743622,
-0.6399782299995422,
-0.4800559878349304,
-0.03753592073917389,
-0.21646568179130554,
-0.03753932937979698,
-0.1957794427871704,
0.28847596049308777,
-0.07762201875448227,
0.10185927152633667,
-0.25563210248947144,
0.04499182105064392,
0.20576687157154083,
0.46315237879753113,
0.4776778221130371,
-0.3333989083766937,
0.2740647494792938,
0.27822861075401306,
-0.11897461116313934,
0.36604756116867065,
0.09036949276924133,
0.06882495433092117,
0.14197708666324615,
-0.35636430978775024,
-0.2110813409090042,
0.01652170903980732,
0.5612366199493408,
-0.33238452672958374,
1.0211765766143799,
0.24687939882278442,
-0.35125210881233215,
0.44106370210647583,
-0.8005214333534241,
0.09503425657749176,
-0.3940509557723999,
0.16014151275157928,
-0.6212349534034729,
-0.6478846669197083,
0.904201328754425,
-0.21065382659435272,
0.027524949982762337,
0.5295904278755188,
0.5081026554107666,
-0.018964536488056183,
0.7439839243888855,
0.7288151979446411,
-0.13876725733280182,
0.24579191207885742,
-0.11514059454202652,
0.36382028460502625,
-0.8877489566802979,
-0.4208071231842041,
-0.5194520950317383,
-0.31950828433036804,
-0.06605716049671173,
-0.3073331415653229,
0.4741615951061249,
0.08826220780611038,
-0.006638080347329378,
0.47293832898139954,
-0.04176885262131691,
0.5899651050567627,
0.27502956986427307,
0.005076103378087282,
0.2818949222564697,
-0.400206595659256,
-0.46796226501464844,
-0.13002586364746094,
-1.1218879222869873,
-0.35032886266708374,
0.8222861886024475,
0.1506233811378479,
0.4045315682888031,
0.277885764837265,
0.38872426748275757,
0.053326331079006195,
0.43916991353034973,
-0.5276063680648804,
0.5286072492599487,
0.19389744102954865,
-0.7300786972045898,
-0.006062858272343874,
-0.08453217148780823,
-0.8136019110679626,
0.14758136868476868,
-0.41208451986312866,
-0.6692094206809998,
0.5490232706069946,
0.29334717988967896,
-0.5085067749023438,
0.5464773178100586,
-0.7290725708007812,
0.6319504380226135,
0.4089789390563965,
-0.20824725925922394,
-0.4301812946796417,
-0.9361391067504883,
0.6138942241668701,
-0.09953148663043976,
0.3278467059135437,
0.13660722970962524,
0.3461534380912781,
0.5768066644668579,
-0.11345996707677841,
1.0503134727478027,
-0.3347141444683075,
-0.1816655844449997,
0.4647050201892853,
0.46897804737091064,
0.4246519207954407,
-0.11092941462993622,
-0.12289665639400482,
-0.009599445387721062,
-0.3733517527580261,
-0.34439167380332947,
-0.8974156975746155,
0.4413613975048065,
-0.6240833401679993,
-0.6482503414154053,
-0.3113273084163666,
-0.5739970207214355,
-0.15724341571331024,
0.0993468165397644,
-0.0009197871549986303,
0.7813448309898376,
-0.34983330965042114,
0.11474140733480453,
0.7711192965507507,
-0.3662111163139343,
0.3861057162284851,
0.8553544282913208,
-0.36158379912376404,
0.09645684063434601,
0.9478686451911926,
0.43871572613716125,
0.13985523581504822,
0.6787444353103638,
0.10733355581760406,
-0.24870683252811432,
-0.09967371821403503,
-0.2755461037158966,
0.2881625294685364,
-1.0826473236083984,
-0.24914614856243134,
-0.9332343935966492,
-0.015330466441810131,
-0.057992350310087204,
-0.21198144555091858,
-0.5251597166061401,
-0.8635373115539551,
-0.05877244472503662,
-0.46903786063194275,
0.3547477722167969,
0.9591153860092163,
-0.3675636351108551,
0.08923407644033432,
-0.772282600402832,
0.6402154564857483,
0.16227364540100098,
0.06611912697553635,
0.28017035126686096,
-0.574213981628418,
-0.3641479015350342,
-0.14254529774188995,
-0.14011645317077637,
-0.8502916097640991,
-0.2111901491880417,
-0.24356727302074432,
0.6896216869354248,
0.2593570053577423,
-0.04708557203412056,
0.7973371148109436,
-0.7586544156074524,
0.8509230613708496,
-0.09921212494373322,
-0.9621545672416687,
0.6849988698959351,
0.018812064081430435,
0.26913729310035706,
0.38343530893325806,
0.5833171010017395,
-0.31518229842185974,
-0.5392733216285706,
-0.6037566661834717,
-0.4068954288959503,
0.6210463643074036,
0.13165657222270966,
-0.03651616349816322,
-0.21612641215324402,
0.7502948641777039,
0.22449201345443726,
0.07819557934999466,
-0.49859297275543213,
-0.6465352177619934,
-0.47251519560813904,
0.11029499769210815,
0.13609202206134796,
-0.5216110348701477,
-0.295514851808548,
-0.1722012609243393,
0.5671406388282776,
0.20768997073173523,
0.2917823791503906,
0.4629330039024353,
-0.2882697582244873,
0.030763687565922737,
0.10282004624605179,
0.7057510018348694,
0.8431691527366638,
-0.04578611999750137,
0.1962185949087143,
0.39576736092567444,
-0.2441985160112381,
0.16497914493083954,
-0.21540775895118713,
-0.47957223653793335,
0.2419533133506775,
0.32108473777770996,
1.0120246410369873,
0.8012639284133911,
-0.06558375060558319,
0.24307061731815338,
0.01944895088672638,
0.036650706082582474,
-0.012659873813390732,
0.1906813681125641,
0.07988598197698593,
0.30540579557418823,
0.26545220613479614,
0.526897132396698,
0.36126819252967834,
-0.8626526594161987,
0.09723423421382904,
-0.08002004772424698,
-0.16283725202083588,
-0.42233577370643616,
0.8088928461074829,
-0.11493481695652008,
-0.09835271537303925,
0.5171054005622864,
-0.14227606356143951,
-0.589859664440155,
0.5708038210868835,
0.5312469005584717,
0.4904085099697113,
-0.2996287941932678,
0.19553294777870178,
0.8538813591003418,
0.30089500546455383,
0.131757453083992,
-0.1944112479686737,
-0.15158136188983917,
-0.7034045457839966,
-0.32951590418815613,
-0.2729591131210327,
-0.4024108648300171,
-0.41499218344688416,
-0.9750908017158508,
0.08082018792629242,
-0.39889779686927795,
-0.19966481626033783,
0.012985343113541603,
-0.28970006108283997,
-0.32377853989601135,
0.25919920206069946,
0.20056864619255066,
0.7305830717086792,
-0.8835526704788208,
0.8269606828689575,
0.47596555948257446,
-0.5190203785896301,
-0.9532884359359741,
0.014937948435544968,
0.29107052087783813,
-0.5568816065788269,
0.5755772590637207,
-0.24155093729496002,
-0.34784987568855286,
-0.21384891867637634,
-0.49554169178009033,
-1.1744006872177124,
1.2970653772354126,
0.12592029571533203,
-0.3802774250507355,
0.21112173795700073,
-0.20016521215438843,
0.37032291293144226,
-0.06026982143521309,
-0.16634273529052734,
0.7690417766571045,
0.4546051621437073,
0.22141355276107788,
-0.7027292847633362,
0.2468615472316742,
0.1578962504863739,
-0.29609066247940063,
0.3075309991836548,
-1.0098886489868164,
0.6260802149772644,
-0.4209253787994385,
-0.32154226303100586,
0.03144742175936699,
0.9364770650863647,
0.17363902926445007,
0.13622574508190155,
0.44186505675315857,
0.3885899782180786,
1.1258076429367065,
0.034310564398765564,
1.194297432899475,
-0.10342065244913101,
0.40014058351516724,
1.1845098733901978,
-0.5659664273262024,
0.5840766429901123,
0.17752717435359955,
-0.06194999814033508,
0.7304632663726807,
0.3630107641220093,
-0.0478789247572422,
0.6521676182746887,
-0.36126697063446045,
-0.122551329433918,
0.07512739300727844,
-0.05386432632803917,
-0.1247551441192627,
0.41835394501686096,
0.299712210893631,
-0.0069353110156953335,
-0.012037734501063824,
0.1427428424358368,
0.5395482778549194,
0.007235818542540073,
-0.26394686102867126,
0.7335507273674011,
-0.19041340053081512,
-0.6643412709236145,
0.2728423774242401,
-0.09675495326519012,
-0.19026507437229156,
-0.6801288723945618,
-0.07607857137918472,
-0.49440500140190125,
-0.013154782354831696,
0.07518992573022842,
-0.7002316117286682,
0.6385747194290161,
-0.22172902524471283,
-0.4879235029220581,
0.15431684255599976,
0.7887272238731384,
-0.38501158356666565,
-0.3768356144428253,
0.09514676034450531,
0.1329239159822464,
-0.03749533370137215,
0.4703403413295746,
-0.32937484979629517,
0.0305639561265707,
-0.030147040262818336,
-0.36898311972618103,
0.16601112484931946,
0.7267184853553772,
0.011479875072836876,
0.5807927846908569,
0.48557916283607483,
-0.30491355061531067,
0.336991548538208,
0.1379377841949463,
0.6809189319610596,
-0.9728237390518188,
-0.49655693769454956,
-0.7036035656929016,
0.35476723313331604,
-0.07250814139842987,
-0.13988752663135529,
0.9288398623466492,
0.7116983532905579,
0.4851752817630768,
-0.19957083463668823,
0.5273967385292053,
-0.145746111869812,
0.5971823334693909,
-0.9175918698310852,
0.6495637893676758,
-0.26617807149887085,
0.012369660660624504,
-0.2640816867351532,
-0.9573540687561035,
-0.2697093188762665,
0.5415398478507996,
-0.1915140599012375,
-0.4094584584236145,
0.927691638469696,
0.7649474143981934,
-0.24476587772369385,
0.10760439932346344,
0.22460678219795227,
1.0822800397872925,
0.14574715495109558,
0.23876670002937317,
0.7676958441734314,
-0.5899469256401062,
0.42312297224998474,
-0.2736316919326782,
0.003961409442126751,
-0.2505802810192108,
-0.69906085729599,
-0.7941854596138,
-0.7216267585754395,
-0.3781704902648926,
-0.16234034299850464,
-0.24199318885803223,
0.4620656967163086,
0.3771127164363861,
-0.6729010939598083,
0.08353142440319061,
0.5232599377632141,
0.42270445823669434,
-0.09624972939491272,
-0.24793869256973267,
0.5392614603042603,
-0.015724660828709602,
-0.26837584376335144,
0.571905255317688,
0.5626068115234375,
0.06500177085399628,
0.04896330460906029,
0.2950546443462372,
-0.6555224061012268,
0.30531278252601624,
0.7674816846847534,
0.4423360526561737,
-0.7081482410430908,
-0.8425588011741638,
-0.01596987247467041,
-0.021517818793654442,
0.2330431342124939,
1.06671142578125,
-0.9765416383743286,
0.5537551641464233,
0.30482593178749084,
0.6522421836853027,
0.6762464642524719,
0.18330375850200653,
0.5463980436325073,
-0.8097832202911377,
0.37004634737968445,
-0.3245103359222412,
0.7322300672531128,
0.36528274416923523,
-0.3495798408985138,
0.5125640034675598,
0.36765149235725403,
-0.5535964965820312,
-0.520655632019043,
0.05329379066824913,
-1.004066824913025,
-0.24880513548851013,
0.8184639811515808,
-0.13599544763565063,
-0.1589607447385788,
-0.236282080411911,
-0.6488006114959717,
0.5601857304573059,
0.15805453062057495,
0.9990801215171814,
1.05619478225708,
-0.17235946655273438,
0.09413274377584457,
-0.527651846408844,
0.11829733848571777,
0.2520536482334137,
-0.4142976999282837,
0.01395425759255886,
0.7215587496757507,
0.3176349699497223,
0.6118600368499756,
0.5134437084197998,
-0.04035675898194313,
0.3043479919433594,
0.23134632408618927,
0.01755109801888466,
-0.03343160077929497,
-0.480425089597702,
-0.19154371321201324,
0.12941645085811615,
-0.39890623092651367,
-0.1182699203491211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04125v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04125v2
|
No "Zero-Shot" Without Exponential Data: Pretraining Concept Frequency Determines Multimodal Model Performance
| 2024-04-04T17:58:02 | 2024-04-08T21:14:43 |
Vishaal Udandarao, Ameya Prabhu, Adhiraj Ghosh, Yash Sharma, Philip H. S. Torr, Adel Bibi, Samuel Albanie, Matthias Bethge
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Web-crawled pretraining datasets underlie the impressive "zero-shot"
evaluation performance of multimodal models, such as CLIP for
classification/retrieval and Stable-Diffusion for image generation. However, it
is unclear how meaningful the notion of "zero-shot" generalization is for such
multimodal models, as it is not known to what extent their pretraining datasets
encompass the downstream concepts targeted for during "zero-shot" evaluation.
In this work, we ask: How is the performance of multimodal models on downstream
concepts influenced by the frequency of these concepts in their pretraining
datasets? We comprehensively investigate this question across 34 models and
five standard pretraining datasets (CC-3M, CC-12M, YFCC-15M, LAION-400M,
LAION-Aesthetics), generating over 300GB of data artifacts. We consistently
find that, far from exhibiting "zero-shot" generalization, multimodal models
require exponentially more data to achieve linear improvements in downstream
"zero-shot" performance, following a sample inefficient log-linear scaling
trend. This trend persists even when controlling for sample-level similarity
between pretraining and downstream datasets, and testing on purely synthetic
data distributions. Furthermore, upon benchmarking models on long-tailed data
sampled based on our analysis, we demonstrate that multimodal models across the
board perform poorly. We contribute this long-tail test set as the "Let it
Wag!" benchmark to further research in this direction. Taken together, our
study reveals an exponential need for training data which implies that the key
to "zero-shot" generalization capabilities under large-scale training paradigms
remains to be found.
|
[
-0.501336395740509,
-0.6803652048110962,
0.5934817790985107,
0.09854280948638916,
-0.3411107361316681,
-0.04341363534331322,
-0.11346636712551117,
-0.5571590065956116,
0.1641925871372223,
0.062303025275468826,
-0.8293423652648926,
-0.323232501745224,
-0.5856607556343079,
0.022033415734767914,
-0.5577499866485596,
0.8653682470321655,
0.10332578420639038,
-0.026549864560365677,
-0.261440634727478,
-0.24943779408931732,
-0.4001356065273285,
-0.45938512682914734,
-0.29509270191192627,
-0.16655370593070984,
0.989513635635376,
0.09892787784337997,
0.43652379512786865,
0.719322681427002,
0.4100610613822937,
0.14754700660705566,
0.3995189070701599,
-0.2902514338493347,
-0.5438384413719177,
0.08736096322536469,
0.04325318709015846,
-0.5792456269264221,
-0.3662731945514679,
-0.02291501872241497,
0.7940192222595215,
0.7633190751075745,
0.04621150344610214,
0.35185983777046204,
-0.346817284822464,
0.5184490084648132,
-1.0393214225769043,
-0.022846903651952744,
-0.5935798287391663,
0.08595997095108032,
-0.4281153380870819,
-0.4449651837348938,
-0.419149786233902,
0.07067878544330597,
-0.02034827321767807,
-0.9799717664718628,
0.502790629863739,
-0.1148628294467926,
0.9685134291648865,
0.12573648989200592,
-0.9812068343162537,
0.023237889632582664,
-1.0097806453704834,
0.7788068652153015,
-0.4014599323272705,
0.6344242691993713,
0.1605883687734604,
0.11549639701843262,
0.1326211839914322,
-0.7087716460227966,
-0.8288501501083374,
-0.2620641887187958,
0.4648454189300537,
0.26524341106414795,
-0.25415077805519104,
0.24621789157390594,
0.6601515412330627,
0.055105164647102356,
-0.7054203748703003,
0.021013742312788963,
-0.2967611849308014,
0.062170930206775665,
0.6043931245803833,
0.18522992730140686,
-0.03190771862864494,
0.11079149693250656,
-0.5530832409858704,
-0.5135490298271179,
-0.6585738062858582,
0.2571258842945099,
0.3731743097305298,
0.11488771438598633,
-0.05090979486703873,
0.46058738231658936,
-0.5042970776557922,
0.6150489449501038,
-0.07106681913137436,
-0.14119550585746765,
0.5155166387557983,
-0.48432716727256775,
-0.17381919920444489,
-0.11569222062826157,
0.6510722637176514,
0.520116925239563,
0.3521484136581421,
-0.08785222470760345,
-0.21419945359230042,
0.28373026847839355,
0.4096711277961731,
-0.9381518363952637,
0.08657040446996689,
0.1394226998090744,
-0.15061934292316437,
-0.1290392279624939,
0.025987708941102028,
-0.5234965085983276,
0.1693444401025772,
-0.45137134194374084,
0.8995202779769897,
-0.3157632648944855,
-0.46967795491218567,
0.08288465440273285,
-0.5092339515686035,
0.1363910287618637,
0.20378853380680084,
-0.791473925113678,
-0.05103891342878342,
0.41170787811279297,
0.950228750705719,
0.0575719028711319,
-0.18502098321914673,
-0.03408464044332504,
0.29974377155303955,
-0.6597058176994324,
0.8559827208518982,
-0.6283212304115295,
-0.40467238426208496,
-0.00797951128333807,
0.07170651108026505,
-0.35891324281692505,
-0.125494584441185,
0.3175201117992401,
-0.6406928300857544,
-0.2286888211965561,
-0.11299920082092285,
-0.5011442303657532,
-0.1865847110748291,
0.08169364184141159,
-0.6259090900421143,
0.708751380443573,
-0.13858526945114136,
-0.3913594186306,
1.0590920448303223,
-0.669488787651062,
-0.44365882873535156,
0.1095551997423172,
-0.18835534155368805,
-0.2639363706111908,
0.4202215373516083,
-0.04953354224562645,
0.3892774283885956,
-0.0456228144466877,
0.13317306339740753,
-0.8351719379425049,
-0.508024275302887,
0.03201312571763992,
-0.6754593849182129,
0.3172813355922699,
0.186915323138237,
-0.2990770936012268,
0.06538356095552444,
-1.08261239528656,
0.24883650243282318,
0.0348619781434536,
0.13662804663181305,
-0.3093090355396271,
-0.037414077669382095,
0.10637614876031876,
0.46187257766723633,
-0.24487823247909546,
-0.6854472160339355,
0.0820794552564621,
0.1082160696387291,
0.1791650950908661,
0.77799391746521,
-0.08993610739707947,
0.290731817483902,
-0.5110670924186707,
0.6938726305961609,
0.030194906517863274,
0.1718454658985138,
-0.8764147758483887,
-0.30107951164245605,
-0.7219827175140381,
-0.3094785213470459,
0.34504762291908264,
-0.027758512645959854,
-0.79170823097229,
0.026907317340373993,
-0.5993855595588684,
-0.6618021726608276,
-0.16625815629959106,
-0.1958048790693283,
0.15995915234088898,
0.4184322953224182,
0.37138596177101135,
-0.610492467880249,
-0.29114991426467896,
-0.8450930118560791,
0.1534334272146225,
0.12187444418668747,
-0.20413649082183838,
0.1484203189611435,
0.5812007188796997,
0.05496077984571457,
0.9955090880393982,
-0.39393407106399536,
-0.12703752517700195,
0.07453791052103043,
0.6370914578437805,
-0.08030075579881668,
0.48240578174591064,
0.7737075686454773,
-0.7122156620025635,
-0.3062620162963867,
-0.3426244854927063,
-0.8600649237632751,
0.16571897268295288,
-0.24061815440654755,
0.09943743050098419,
0.05343643203377724,
0.23343700170516968,
-0.8362239003181458,
0.4654078185558319,
0.46498653292655945,
0.00565337622538209,
0.5684801340103149,
-0.13445569574832916,
0.15155023336410522,
-0.5491015315055847,
0.2260611653327942,
0.25825363397598267,
-0.038996826857328415,
-0.7618889808654785,
0.16558349132537842,
0.32606834173202515,
-0.22934527695178986,
-0.4596363306045532,
0.4247966408729553,
-0.30351120233535767,
-0.06130366399884224,
-0.12877912819385529,
-0.22555828094482422,
0.15191207826137543,
0.6167790293693542,
0.23491497337818146,
0.6686537265777588,
0.673783004283905,
-0.8914209604263306,
0.08127406984567642,
-0.21645613014698029,
-0.24107545614242554,
0.6681423187255859,
-0.8225246667861938,
0.15875115990638733,
-0.3369070589542389,
0.5571060180664062,
-0.8819697499275208,
-0.37667587399482727,
-0.2553752064704895,
-0.495051771402359,
0.33520445227622986,
-0.12497936934232712,
-0.3398526608943939,
-0.3387308418750763,
-0.5134749412536621,
0.6079321503639221,
0.3800501525402069,
0.006636178586632013,
0.3015570342540741,
-0.041096460074186325,
0.04071874916553497,
-0.7850432991981506,
-0.47444188594818115,
-0.1740468144416809,
-0.151402547955513,
-0.6447069644927979,
0.2939745783805847,
-0.14411874115467072,
0.2297472357749939,
-0.194398432970047,
-0.2981831133365631,
-0.12673456966876984,
0.010394671000540257,
0.5140334367752075,
0.3481708765029907,
-0.3068874776363373,
0.6156721711158752,
-0.06453362107276917,
0.0028646995779126883,
0.030065437778830528,
-0.2879043221473694,
0.5398789048194885,
0.27274641394615173,
-0.6348169445991516,
-0.5203090906143188,
0.18107447028160095,
0.6020748615264893,
-0.10457395017147064,
0.6937832832336426,
0.9287822246551514,
-0.034951046109199524,
0.019784878939390182,
-0.5610315799713135,
-0.18296673893928528,
-0.3934500515460968,
0.42812857031822205,
-0.44601866602897644,
-0.6711900234222412,
0.18913555145263672,
0.006835897918790579,
-0.1081715002655983,
0.5719312429428101,
0.3705942630767822,
-0.2772285044193268,
1.1676682233810425,
0.8993206024169922,
0.46308910846710205,
0.6018269658088684,
-0.38001254200935364,
-0.12328530102968216,
-0.5508672595024109,
-0.2760649025440216,
-0.3124847710132599,
-0.3891506493091583,
-0.7054337859153748,
-0.2154722362756729,
0.504764199256897,
0.056247878819704056,
-0.3886662423610687,
0.06134771555662155,
0.004935414995998144,
0.2728942036628723,
0.3508985638618469,
0.027934480458498,
0.24975886940956116,
0.21084338426589966,
0.04948153346776962,
0.16774626076221466,
-0.6157543063163757,
-0.09824784100055695,
1.64262855052948,
0.28290390968322754,
0.8354784846305847,
-0.1130298376083374,
0.323601096868515,
0.33290979266166687,
0.16105785965919495,
-0.794298529624939,
0.23680609464645386,
-0.0021801560651510954,
-0.843789279460907,
-0.18073707818984985,
-0.4478089511394501,
-1.1567790508270264,
0.24826674163341522,
-0.320245623588562,
-0.3502209782600403,
0.45081424713134766,
0.2534595727920532,
-0.49337098002433777,
0.08052753657102585,
-0.7797406911849976,
0.8223156929016113,
-0.2974913716316223,
-0.4583185911178589,
-0.4081208109855652,
-0.6098628044128418,
0.3543282449245453,
-0.5223004221916199,
0.2715376019477844,
-0.4693059027194977,
-0.0270721185952425,
0.6733739376068115,
-0.2059994488954544,
0.5417611598968506,
-0.2967090606689453,
0.10940176993608475,
0.1605990082025528,
-0.14236457645893097,
0.010569663718342781,
-0.2086396962404251,
0.2721385657787323,
0.5915706157684326,
0.24386848509311676,
-0.6112501621246338,
-0.526518702507019,
0.32770872116088867,
-0.7604342699050903,
-0.2847466766834259,
-0.41255173087120056,
-0.5642685294151306,
-0.4390334486961365,
0.27510866522789,
0.4092754125595093,
0.8009827136993408,
-0.027722302824258804,
0.7394192814826965,
0.46833884716033936,
0.1212606132030487,
0.7268599271774292,
0.5203108787536621,
-0.17107243835926056,
0.04161563143134117,
0.9380988478660583,
0.5284222960472107,
0.6268239617347717,
0.17318718135356903,
-0.2881662845611572,
-0.4404296875,
-0.39478686451911926,
-0.5549180507659912,
-0.07357003539800644,
-0.46534305810928345,
-0.17034949362277985,
-0.6376721858978271,
0.00903558824211359,
-0.370074599981308,
0.04323439300060272,
-0.3075050115585327,
-0.5349199175834656,
0.0003572803980205208,
-0.04435194283723831,
0.08093325793743134,
0.6484146118164062,
-0.12308520823717117,
0.5441617369651794,
-0.8111481666564941,
0.3542247414588928,
0.32395219802856445,
0.34672266244888306,
0.26513901352882385,
-0.5405470132827759,
-0.3139711022377014,
0.4051741063594818,
-0.5168063640594482,
-0.49309617280960083,
0.24806518852710724,
0.5189982056617737,
0.5286605954170227,
0.5391660928726196,
-0.1455325186252594,
1.0394283533096313,
-0.5770665407180786,
0.785121500492096,
0.6373066902160645,
-0.7782884836196899,
0.3924959599971771,
-0.5051416754722595,
0.4107385575771332,
0.28549033403396606,
0.9768967032432556,
-0.4449039101600647,
0.02182992547750473,
-0.6093042492866516,
-0.9473759531974792,
0.6753941178321838,
0.017377151176333427,
0.5970829725265503,
-0.10177158564329147,
0.06238657608628273,
0.05622990056872368,
0.5902619361877441,
-0.7402504682540894,
-0.05130090191960335,
-0.5531803369522095,
0.09044132381677628,
-0.2171453982591629,
-0.13169553875923157,
0.026540298014879227,
-0.21661530435085297,
0.12266761064529419,
-0.2810971736907959,
0.22487767040729523,
0.0032095478381961584,
-0.3465522825717926,
-0.3903373181819916,
0.18184849619865417,
0.6171974539756775,
0.8547163009643555,
-0.4908258318901062,
0.0034410860389471054,
-0.1623985767364502,
-0.45636096596717834,
0.35790157318115234,
-0.21117311716079712,
-0.19932691752910614,
0.028446640819311142,
0.6154885292053223,
0.9921860694885254,
0.20557716488838196,
-0.6956286430358887,
0.7430809736251831,
0.1002463772892952,
-0.1184869185090065,
-0.4376480281352997,
0.23479300737380981,
-0.41515177488327026,
-0.0188139658421278,
0.9002476334571838,
0.24448803067207336,
-0.11686675250530243,
-0.6989055275917053,
0.2200244814157486,
0.5127101540565491,
-0.3168826103210449,
-0.7541182041168213,
0.6699938774108887,
0.05003553256392479,
0.28948450088500977,
0.6933000683784485,
-0.04580717533826828,
0.13537254929542542,
0.7319380640983582,
0.43054431676864624,
0.6395698189735413,
-0.14325034618377686,
0.16766948997974396,
0.4304281175136566,
0.07882224023342133,
0.015013194642961025,
-0.015369957312941551,
-0.28235360980033875,
-0.8005189895629883,
-0.6527830362319946,
-0.7720028758049011,
-0.045679837465286255,
0.17643773555755615,
-0.8628528714179993,
0.3159627318382263,
-0.538558304309845,
-0.6045790910720825,
0.3399939239025116,
-0.4557918310165405,
-0.9891840815544128,
0.44879481196403503,
0.376607745885849,
0.695049524307251,
-0.7431426048278809,
0.8338443040847778,
0.3205662667751312,
-0.7937623858451843,
-0.6507072448730469,
-0.05039649456739426,
0.08227836340665817,
-0.793921172618866,
1.0734821557998657,
0.40006592869758606,
-0.09930442273616791,
0.19175678491592407,
-0.6471526026725769,
-0.9603366255760193,
1.2094335556030273,
0.3837735950946808,
-0.7124431133270264,
-0.2460027039051056,
0.3016713559627533,
0.5535756349563599,
-0.3774716556072235,
0.8248520493507385,
0.10289709270000458,
0.28630948066711426,
0.49967196583747864,
-1.1374608278274536,
-0.43603822588920593,
-0.15154694020748138,
0.1345820277929306,
0.04200905188918114,
-0.7271947860717773,
1.2383804321289062,
-0.17002971470355988,
-0.3550284802913666,
-0.27409493923187256,
0.15861834585666656,
-0.13113105297088623,
0.48818662762641907,
0.4801231920719147,
0.8507376313209534,
0.21551629900932312,
-0.06561440229415894,
1.271230936050415,
-0.32457274198532104,
0.43762850761413574,
0.7947268486022949,
-0.5301340818405151,
1.0263416767120361,
0.25502628087997437,
-0.27260422706604004,
0.4265657067298889,
0.5036700963973999,
-0.06650038808584213,
0.4797429144382477,
-0.17329970002174377,
-0.27557945251464844,
-0.4109945297241211,
-0.43654346466064453,
-0.5493756532669067,
0.6903702020645142,
0.2530798614025116,
-0.12924359738826752,
-0.3720565438270569,
0.19312608242034912,
-0.15116383135318756,
-0.5120518207550049,
-0.4061616361141205,
0.6000027060508728,
-0.10078591108322144,
-0.3215186893939972,
0.798213541507721,
-0.18857744336128235,
0.7952330708503723,
-1.1476045846939087,
0.04573790356516838,
-0.12294193357229233,
-0.07417283207178116,
-0.23275898396968842,
-0.46763554215431213,
0.11078115552663803,
-0.15460343658924103,
-0.17663075029850006,
-0.19598427414894104,
0.4734252095222473,
-0.21368853747844696,
-0.4312303364276886,
0.30154097080230713,
0.5109880566596985,
-0.05533304065465927,
-0.32578304409980774,
-0.3546968996524811,
0.1104862317442894,
-0.2970753312110901,
-0.27036938071250916,
0.5654598474502563,
0.27530673146247864,
-0.0975608304142952,
0.6601542234420776,
1.0720691680908203,
-0.05729053169488907,
0.36780115962028503,
0.1569870114326477,
0.8158357739448547,
-0.5663464665412903,
-0.18910418450832367,
-0.678314745426178,
0.6060544848442078,
0.09458053857088089,
-0.28012973070144653,
0.6862966418266296,
0.41158589720726013,
1.2449160814285278,
-0.20192602276802063,
0.605293333530426,
-0.07865366339683533,
0.10932354629039764,
-0.4811093807220459,
0.5639988780021667,
-0.8384190201759338,
-0.26353174448013306,
-0.15719370543956757,
-1.0473650693893433,
-0.04035792127251625,
0.34914761781692505,
-0.33724841475486755,
0.37621787190437317,
0.5914580225944519,
0.6616426110267639,
-0.15767252445220947,
-0.1413528025150299,
0.7034421563148499,
-0.03403465822339058,
0.2656768560409546,
0.42006102204322815,
0.7786858677864075,
-0.3936769962310791,
0.41862356662750244,
-0.2503146231174469,
-0.15642842650413513,
-0.06642118096351624,
-0.8310678005218506,
-0.42104044556617737,
-0.5665736198425293,
-0.1321575790643692,
0.28123757243156433,
0.00910084880888462,
0.7718005180358887,
1.1256976127624512,
-0.5104128122329712,
-0.2035297155380249,
0.17450767755508423,
-0.46202731132507324,
-0.04550033062696457,
-0.21375831961631775,
-0.003206021385267377,
-0.5660505294799805,
-0.5107420682907104,
0.2715974450111389,
0.3303208351135254,
0.10203000158071518,
-0.15742695331573486,
0.3243298828601837,
-0.32535380125045776,
0.1388164460659027,
0.8602731823921204,
0.31921592354774475,
-0.4297398626804352,
-0.32734420895576477,
0.06980665028095245,
0.21711383759975433,
0.0534110926091671,
0.9634397625923157,
-0.8834423422813416,
0.7593376040458679,
0.04784432426095009,
0.3030327260494232,
0.8447885513305664,
0.07501444220542908,
0.3759661018848419,
-1.0727537870407104,
0.6239933967590332,
0.07932494580745697,
0.15098465979099274,
-0.06195640563964844,
0.12254723161458969,
0.3645676374435425,
0.7197297215461731,
-0.3430446684360504,
-0.8423081636428833,
0.1698538213968277,
-0.8335902690887451,
-0.18379847705364227,
0.8499069809913635,
-0.2500144839286804,
-0.1522599309682846,
-0.041809722781181335,
0.35072165727615356,
0.21417883038520813,
-0.3484998643398285,
0.5189146995544434,
0.751595139503479,
-0.23058409988880157,
-0.2241072803735733,
-0.9141266942024231,
0.22831781208515167,
0.33316946029663086,
-0.4265611469745636,
-0.2749107778072357,
0.6797093152999878,
0.45980456471443176,
0.3419157862663269,
0.5802258253097534,
0.04228696972131729,
0.2996709942817688,
0.40276792645454407,
0.2611999809741974,
-0.2453199028968811,
-0.4543973207473755,
-0.430862694978714,
0.4320703148841858,
-0.08125106245279312,
-0.12569206953048706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03715v1
|
Direct Nash Optimization: Teaching Language Models to Self-Improve with General Preferences
| 2024-04-04T17:56:41 | 2024-04-04T17:56:41 |
Corby Rosset, Ching-An Cheng, Arindam Mitra, Michael Santacroce, Ahmed Awadallah, Tengyang Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper studies post-training large language models (LLMs) using
preference feedback from a powerful oracle to help a model iteratively improve
over itself. The typical approach for post-training LLMs involves Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), which traditionally separates reward
learning and subsequent policy optimization. However, such a reward
maximization approach is limited by the nature of "point-wise" rewards (such as
Bradley-Terry model), which fails to express complex intransitive or cyclic
preference relations. While advances on RLHF show reward learning and policy
optimization can be merged into a single contrastive objective for stability,
they yet still remain tethered to the reward maximization framework. Recently,
a new wave of research sidesteps the reward maximization presumptions in favor
of directly optimizing over "pair-wise" or general preferences. In this paper,
we introduce Direct Nash Optimization (DNO), a provable and scalable algorithm
that marries the simplicity and stability of contrastive learning with
theoretical generality from optimizing general preferences. Because DNO is a
batched on-policy algorithm using a regression-based objective, its
implementation is straightforward and efficient. Moreover, DNO enjoys monotonic
improvement across iterations that help it improve even over a strong teacher
(such as GPT-4). In our experiments, a resulting 7B parameter Orca-2.5 model
aligned by DNO achieves the state-of-the-art win-rate against GPT-4-Turbo of
33% on AlpacaEval 2.0 (even after controlling for response length), an absolute
gain of 26% (7% to 33%) over the initializing model. It outperforms models with
far more parameters, including Mistral Large, Self-Rewarding LM (70B
parameters), and older versions of GPT-4.
|
[
-0.22584758698940277,
-0.6373745203018188,
0.5473324656486511,
0.12528328597545624,
-0.1816195249557495,
0.02368343062698841,
-0.5610432624816895,
-0.011770515702664852,
0.0970296561717987,
0.48502427339553833,
-0.5515387654304504,
-0.4119146466255188,
-0.6218308210372925,
-0.031238364055752754,
-0.006004708353430033,
1.2317187786102295,
-0.014034158550202847,
0.24006788432598114,
0.04614090919494629,
0.05104188621044159,
-0.36785799264907837,
-0.550648033618927,
-1.1145356893539429,
-0.42630305886268616,
0.6177187561988831,
0.40425506234169006,
0.6955147981643677,
0.7028065323829651,
0.30259642004966736,
0.28480032086372375,
0.02729557454586029,
0.13502369821071625,
-0.7075262665748596,
0.26645538210868835,
-0.028388289734721184,
-0.4522349536418915,
-0.3870706260204315,
0.08311160653829575,
0.7042726874351501,
0.4687650799751282,
-0.5109868049621582,
-0.33241957426071167,
0.18227115273475647,
0.8629679679870605,
-0.5743556022644043,
0.16401968896389008,
-0.773126482963562,
0.019157884642481804,
0.010862310416996479,
-0.2736148238182068,
-0.40990689396858215,
-0.6221096515655518,
0.20339086651802063,
-0.6526277661323547,
-0.10754833370447159,
-0.25489911437034607,
0.7967484593391418,
0.4159865379333496,
-0.29607972502708435,
-0.3492808938026428,
-0.7628812193870544,
0.9534742832183838,
-0.6383113861083984,
0.08618409931659698,
0.38915911316871643,
0.32560569047927856,
-0.20461268723011017,
-0.32427647709846497,
-0.22492051124572754,
-0.6844619512557983,
0.15250645577907562,
0.2567388713359833,
0.1649514138698578,
0.27015167474746704,
-0.035301387310028076,
0.3531700372695923,
-0.4109819233417511,
0.3217546343803406,
0.025406520813703537,
0.06650504469871521,
0.6011884808540344,
0.1497814953327179,
0.054840076714754105,
0.19014042615890503,
-0.3682771325111389,
-0.3075481355190277,
-0.9127474427223206,
0.2726680636405945,
0.46064144372940063,
0.4093506336212158,
0.1289530247449875,
0.21930231153964996,
-0.09293206036090851,
0.6695990562438965,
0.28021106123924255,
-0.26514509320259094,
-0.04466104134917259,
-0.0880243182182312,
0.010707433335483074,
-0.14210304617881775,
0.5653305053710938,
0.13574106991291046,
0.2743087708950043,
-0.10840579867362976,
-0.4633336663246155,
0.16102932393550873,
0.17033059895038605,
-0.6545537114143372,
-0.1822439283132553,
-0.0329844169318676,
-0.2150341272354126,
-0.47888243198394775,
-0.2885994017124176,
-0.5865566730499268,
-0.32778915762901306,
-0.5969544053077698,
0.6226690411567688,
-0.1151103526353836,
-0.2920835614204407,
0.23262490332126617,
0.369874507188797,
0.3136231005191803,
0.4465015232563019,
-1.2028344869613647,
0.6025129556655884,
0.8308802843093872,
0.6444045305252075,
-0.2716955244541168,
-0.38488245010375977,
-0.7252323031425476,
0.01222309097647667,
-0.48401764035224915,
0.5570918917655945,
-0.512333333492279,
-0.5726450085639954,
0.10742038488388062,
-0.29555901885032654,
-0.037451986223459244,
-0.6260516047477722,
0.4521433413028717,
-0.5117738842964172,
0.2915906608104706,
-0.3873526453971863,
-0.4468578100204468,
0.15313410758972168,
0.3123605251312256,
-0.4389977753162384,
0.9574032425880432,
-0.12044194340705872,
-0.542655348777771,
0.3962806761264801,
-0.6410953402519226,
-0.17013777792453766,
-0.1861373633146286,
-0.33335626125335693,
-0.3917442560195923,
0.010292315855622292,
-0.0024665521923452616,
0.18594442307949066,
-0.3924557566642761,
0.5453330874443054,
-0.19801416993141174,
-0.38455212116241455,
-0.19229446351528168,
-0.06205715611577034,
0.380327969789505,
-0.004138993564993143,
-0.6041321158409119,
0.5055195093154907,
-0.45663508772850037,
-0.0437232106924057,
0.35492512583732605,
-0.5718910694122314,
-0.4261113107204437,
0.06120062246918678,
-0.47240325808525085,
0.054040197283029556,
0.20159834623336792,
-0.3587230443954468,
0.5039815902709961,
-0.6204394102096558,
0.14798571169376373,
1.0827951431274414,
-0.312328040599823,
0.6567829847335815,
-0.1478402465581894,
0.5735034942626953,
-0.2674300968647003,
0.4387340545654297,
0.21411995589733124,
-0.154134139418602,
-0.8970911502838135,
-0.047644566744565964,
0.2220405787229538,
0.22338815033435822,
-0.6989585161209106,
0.19657383859157562,
-0.18807633221149445,
-0.24829640984535217,
-0.4711352586746216,
0.21299968659877777,
0.5295904278755188,
0.48687365651130676,
0.2920955419540405,
-0.38417357206344604,
-0.3245779573917389,
-0.9003307819366455,
-0.07193785905838013,
-0.1265009343624115,
0.2815576493740082,
0.46363335847854614,
0.19539721310138702,
-0.11282356828451157,
0.787730872631073,
-0.6013734936714172,
-0.17776258289813995,
-0.27814817428588867,
0.03831569477915764,
0.42418572306632996,
0.32830801606178284,
0.4423936903476715,
-0.5518094897270203,
-0.8032418489456177,
0.04579748958349228,
-0.38979360461235046,
0.1328020542860031,
0.1983385980129242,
-0.1140131875872612,
0.4128000736236572,
0.07051433622837067,
-0.27965036034584045,
0.15217120945453644,
0.5001479387283325,
-0.16474789381027222,
0.6722520589828491,
-0.4865165948867798,
-0.030988097190856934,
-0.5611807703971863,
-0.08262325078248978,
-0.12786270678043365,
-0.08745032548904419,
-0.5706638097763062,
-0.15871867537498474,
-0.23168210685253143,
-0.0030623890925198793,
-0.22088348865509033,
0.5514506697654724,
-0.44750550389289856,
-0.1748148649930954,
-0.6131172776222229,
0.02639022096991539,
-0.31780916452407837,
0.6922300457954407,
0.3203873336315155,
0.7081159949302673,
0.6811641454696655,
-0.6270015835762024,
0.4137106239795685,
-0.027200810611248016,
-0.03472282737493515,
0.2604145109653473,
-0.7210718989372253,
0.26793181896209717,
-0.25480416417121887,
0.1972082257270813,
-0.7494260668754578,
-0.02825709991157055,
0.2947651147842407,
-0.2490784376859665,
0.5572636127471924,
-0.09915481507778168,
0.00992604810744524,
-0.3267839550971985,
-0.531606137752533,
0.1629866063594818,
0.48081082105636597,
-0.7709474563598633,
0.32037219405174255,
0.15160584449768066,
-0.1250489056110382,
-1.0245797634124756,
-0.1273612380027771,
-0.13314886391162872,
-0.05046255886554718,
-0.3049459755420685,
0.26381736993789673,
-0.20191673934459686,
-0.2136419117450714,
0.03257469832897186,
-0.19685809314250946,
-0.034689199179410934,
0.16167926788330078,
-0.05414570868015289,
0.3100699782371521,
0.024961290881037712,
0.1917196363210678,
-0.03836865723133087,
-0.4000367522239685,
0.007971104234457016,
-0.4168940782546997,
0.6608397364616394,
-0.3890339732170105,
-0.10104628652334213,
-0.07400581240653992,
0.1577700823545456,
0.10976439714431763,
-0.11612723022699356,
0.5917814373970032,
0.4043009877204895,
0.08541499078273773,
-0.43962419033050537,
-0.4320111870765686,
-0.47735974192619324,
-0.47628143429756165,
0.48263072967529297,
-0.520092248916626,
-0.9213424921035767,
0.08030658215284348,
0.01644243486225605,
0.10989750921726227,
0.39687496423721313,
0.5147948265075684,
0.25150540471076965,
1.0001304149627686,
0.5986941456794739,
-0.2861808240413666,
0.46073541045188904,
-0.4677712023258209,
-0.1818852573633194,
-0.5293900966644287,
-0.1739852875471115,
-0.4119672477245331,
-0.07613860070705414,
-0.46673741936683655,
-0.06825165450572968,
0.21045297384262085,
-0.09419102221727371,
-0.6073896288871765,
0.03792809695005417,
-0.6773042678833008,
0.7143581509590149,
0.7615365386009216,
0.22181332111358643,
0.1628151535987854,
-0.15758642554283142,
-0.1993696093559265,
-0.15978924930095673,
-0.6220220327377319,
-0.15192292630672455,
1.231727123260498,
0.30082249641418457,
0.9671322107315063,
0.0020370904821902514,
1.0021404027938843,
0.27595680952072144,
0.4137490391731262,
-0.7454808354377747,
0.44184473156929016,
-0.33228379487991333,
-0.3477397859096527,
-0.5090154409408569,
-0.5352097749710083,
-1.0758999586105347,
0.25571805238723755,
-0.09022379666566849,
-0.3285726308822632,
0.12219119817018509,
0.3793269693851471,
-0.22630314528942108,
0.2878059446811676,
-0.41611170768737793,
0.8971170783042908,
-0.6001377701759338,
-0.6011799573898315,
-0.41394978761672974,
-0.6884453892707825,
0.38611358404159546,
0.14184291660785675,
0.0705978274345398,
-0.04945031926035881,
-0.13886785507202148,
0.6405442357063293,
-0.4586225152015686,
0.6603348851203918,
-0.505737841129303,
-0.25324711203575134,
0.1194172129034996,
0.19211791455745697,
0.6452592015266418,
-0.22140556573867798,
-0.022396957501769066,
-0.3809887170791626,
-0.24081255495548248,
-0.4838278591632843,
-0.7947317361831665,
0.9370495080947876,
-1.1515406370162964,
-0.9748747944831848,
-0.448833703994751,
-0.30600935220718384,
-0.37968412041664124,
-0.02858099527657032,
-0.10045403242111206,
0.5146468281745911,
-0.10617723315954208,
0.06009998917579651,
0.5894390940666199,
-0.1592462658882141,
0.3375198543071747,
0.543634295463562,
-0.35785773396492004,
-0.5717795491218567,
0.8985124826431274,
-0.1287737637758255,
0.5207018852233887,
0.4193218946456909,
0.5188712477684021,
-0.5863152742385864,
-0.566073477268219,
-0.21426492929458618,
0.49442970752716064,
-0.7745409607887268,
-0.08422040939331055,
-0.22519776225090027,
-0.09382946789264679,
-0.2023186832666397,
-0.17524869740009308,
-0.5426637530326843,
-0.17613519728183746,
-0.15726029872894287,
-0.05975759029388428,
0.11597996205091476,
1.027158260345459,
-0.29162850975990295,
0.2515897750854492,
-0.20081275701522827,
-0.13584931194782257,
0.6903002858161926,
0.4406803846359253,
0.11412966996431351,
-0.54215008020401,
-0.2204449325799942,
-0.026655105873942375,
-0.2749008536338806,
-0.6202220916748047,
0.4199044704437256,
0.18869557976722717,
0.547421395778656,
0.34954628348350525,
-0.11042530834674835,
0.2989988923072815,
-0.29064568877220154,
0.5204100608825684,
0.3404390215873718,
-0.8096423745155334,
0.6731273531913757,
-0.5195378065109253,
0.019024506211280823,
0.6574341654777527,
0.5468576550483704,
-0.41199880838394165,
0.10863768309354782,
-0.46265143156051636,
-0.7478472590446472,
0.9090576767921448,
-0.2474260777235031,
0.1031595766544342,
-0.020872406661510468,
0.6952896118164062,
0.1307777613401413,
0.2274099886417389,
-0.9793617129325867,
-0.4453270733356476,
-0.2598631680011749,
-0.03472627326846123,
-0.2585426867008209,
-0.5031638741493225,
-0.20153284072875977,
-0.16960109770298004,
0.9293568134307861,
-0.24378111958503723,
0.04606699198484421,
0.05805037543177605,
0.136636883020401,
0.038001831620931625,
0.3000538647174835,
0.6543950438499451,
0.5072314739227295,
-0.37658578157424927,
0.14422202110290527,
0.10517624765634537,
-0.2346247136592865,
0.5618024468421936,
-0.1391642838716507,
-0.1544458419084549,
-0.2625288963317871,
-0.061456046998500824,
0.981050968170166,
0.3459825813770294,
-0.34114378690719604,
0.6359894275665283,
-0.10108717530965805,
-0.24866904318332672,
-0.09620573371648788,
0.19594551622867584,
-0.10878978669643402,
0.0032642537262290716,
0.21510577201843262,
-0.1887659728527069,
0.10788629204034805,
-0.5355517268180847,
0.037159815430641174,
0.5625099539756775,
-0.4276774227619171,
-0.3021300137042999,
0.5141881704330444,
0.3758280873298645,
-0.17334763705730438,
0.16360028088092804,
-0.2057276964187622,
-0.5276710391044617,
0.5604875683784485,
0.6940324902534485,
0.9017583727836609,
-0.5228719711303711,
0.42493340373039246,
0.48255422711372375,
0.0029482480604201555,
-0.31157201528549194,
-0.029452143236994743,
-0.23813584446907043,
-0.7434309720993042,
-0.3423786461353302,
-0.5043854117393494,
-0.7407224774360657,
-0.019180288538336754,
-0.6133890748023987,
0.16359345614910126,
-0.7349095940589905,
-0.111150361597538,
-0.2746959328651428,
0.4118327796459198,
-0.5190713405609131,
0.2595963478088379,
0.002685002749785781,
0.4038231372833252,
-0.5670207142829895,
1.0526505708694458,
0.6147509217262268,
-0.43013083934783936,
-0.8792203664779663,
-0.19468136131763458,
-0.046824995428323746,
-1.0523161888122559,
0.9545378088951111,
-0.055587418377399445,
-0.16131801903247833,
0.13698437809944153,
-0.4342038631439209,
-1.0032291412353516,
0.9586983323097229,
0.4763537049293518,
-0.6363298296928406,
-0.03169801086187363,
-0.08312571048736572,
0.4493211507797241,
-0.41483280062675476,
0.5037251114845276,
0.5796259045600891,
0.4483886957168579,
0.336675763130188,
-0.838408350944519,
-0.06284758448600769,
0.024646317586302757,
0.13306744396686554,
0.30217841267585754,
-0.7893726229667664,
0.7862005829811096,
-0.22555430233478546,
0.03269464895129204,
-0.11329377442598343,
0.4541396200656891,
0.15438340604305267,
-0.0419267974793911,
0.7014274001121521,
0.6318542957305908,
0.6259354948997498,
-0.09293223172426224,
1.2264955043792725,
-0.1499979943037033,
0.4453345537185669,
1.197182059288025,
-0.2737213671207428,
0.740466833114624,
0.23428869247436523,
-0.39479586482048035,
0.4804198145866394,
0.6650555729866028,
0.28173720836639404,
0.8045556545257568,
0.5083433389663696,
-0.3591027557849884,
-0.31379038095474243,
-0.13548706471920013,
-0.44621849060058594,
0.27454835176467896,
-0.017096098512411118,
-0.10884623229503632,
-0.2596549391746521,
-0.2119387686252594,
0.23699703812599182,
0.295017808675766,
-0.4080783426761627,
0.906714141368866,
-0.04556828364729881,
-0.9322437047958374,
0.7935999631881714,
-0.046698760241270065,
0.8324404358863831,
-0.8800243735313416,
0.19048628211021423,
-0.48447051644325256,
0.4018149673938751,
0.009687564335763454,
-0.49951937794685364,
0.14469486474990845,
-0.2361532747745514,
-0.05062026530504227,
-0.13942764699459076,
0.693370521068573,
-0.6957567930221558,
0.024050578474998474,
0.6062057614326477,
0.20570561289787292,
-0.003080138470977545,
0.11691359430551529,
-0.7621123790740967,
0.16840241849422455,
0.1180700734257698,
-0.29027682542800903,
0.4857829213142395,
-0.0354098379611969,
0.3525557816028595,
0.7324138283729553,
0.4970158636569977,
0.27569401264190674,
-0.245446115732193,
0.208649680018425,
0.9030658006668091,
-0.5939947366714478,
-0.4037620425224304,
-0.9094270467758179,
0.16590435802936554,
0.07590034604072571,
-0.2795056998729706,
0.5844194293022156,
0.33767834305763245,
0.7375260591506958,
-0.07887498289346695,
0.5658539533615112,
0.3708646297454834,
0.40321120619773865,
-0.4566088914871216,
0.3545950651168823,
-0.6109501123428345,
0.19082745909690857,
-0.04878607019782066,
-1.0622756481170654,
-0.2641064524650574,
0.49519452452659607,
-0.6398347020149231,
0.12568382918834686,
0.5399886965751648,
0.6829085946083069,
0.40518054366111755,
-0.22929565608501434,
0.4094962477684021,
0.2115994244813919,
0.36362332105636597,
0.7710115909576416,
0.863491952419281,
-0.008686252869665623,
0.47050386667251587,
-0.2919667661190033,
-0.4013077914714813,
-0.0933578610420227,
-0.6276530623435974,
-0.710028886795044,
-0.40110355615615845,
-0.2708604633808136,
-0.25390031933784485,
0.5123828053474426,
1.0796619653701782,
0.719959020614624,
-0.6833513379096985,
-0.551245927810669,
-0.21706174314022064,
0.1687765270471573,
0.07952563464641571,
-0.1876440942287445,
0.4936375021934509,
-0.8440679907798767,
-0.7219615578651428,
0.3951793909072876,
0.31421002745628357,
0.027900414541363716,
-0.36809155344963074,
-0.6428713202476501,
-0.0637749508023262,
0.04687905311584473,
0.4334692060947418,
0.4821518361568451,
-0.7273338437080383,
-0.18329381942749023,
-0.06267773360013962,
-0.14206615090370178,
0.07265999913215637,
0.6894562244415283,
-0.6079601645469666,
0.5676794052124023,
0.0021673901937901974,
0.7977020740509033,
0.7823286652565002,
0.03449222072958946,
0.6114487648010254,
-0.464740514755249,
0.06939580291509628,
0.3028102517127991,
0.2443709373474121,
0.2854636311531067,
-0.11303232610225677,
0.5958544611930847,
0.33131787180900574,
-0.8690327405929565,
-0.6086207628250122,
0.2245456576347351,
-0.7504047751426697,
-0.16268305480480194,
1.1978025436401367,
-0.1624019891023636,
-0.2325049787759781,
0.3313136100769043,
-0.44440513849258423,
-0.0647796168923378,
-0.5604690909385681,
0.8297243118286133,
0.4270991384983063,
-0.06594409793615341,
-0.09445972740650177,
-0.06631715595722198,
0.9396704435348511,
0.7484390139579773,
-0.7996492385864258,
-0.024026399478316307,
0.4839574992656708,
0.29442933201789856,
-0.32170364260673523,
0.9366942644119263,
0.09360849857330322,
0.25386813282966614,
-0.0905754417181015,
0.21994754672050476,
-0.16177023947238922,
-0.5204904079437256,
-0.5856027007102966,
-0.03747368976473808,
0.5671103596687317,
-0.190010204911232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03635v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03635v4
|
WorDepth: Variational Language Prior for Monocular Depth Estimation
| 2024-04-04T17:54:33 | 2024-06-02T04:56:32 |
Ziyao Zeng, Daniel Wang, Fengyu Yang, Hyoungseob Park, Yangchao Wu, Stefano Soatto, Byung-Woo Hong, Dong Lao, Alex Wong
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction from a single image is an ill-posed
problem with inherent ambiguities, i.e. scale. Predicting a 3D scene from text
description(s) is similarly ill-posed, i.e. spatial arrangements of objects
described. We investigate the question of whether two inherently ambiguous
modalities can be used in conjunction to produce metric-scaled reconstructions.
To test this, we focus on monocular depth estimation, the problem of predicting
a dense depth map from a single image, but with an additional text caption
describing the scene. To this end, we begin by encoding the text caption as a
mean and standard deviation; using a variational framework, we learn the
distribution of the plausible metric reconstructions of 3D scenes corresponding
to the text captions as a prior. To "select" a specific reconstruction or depth
map, we encode the given image through a conditional sampler that samples from
the latent space of the variational text encoder, which is then decoded to the
output depth map. Our approach is trained alternatingly between the text and
image branches: in one optimization step, we predict the mean and standard
deviation from the text description and sample from a standard Gaussian, and in
the other, we sample using a (image) conditional sampler. Once trained, we
directly predict depth from the encoded text using the conditional sampler. We
demonstrate our approach on indoor (NYUv2) and outdoor (KITTI) scenarios, where
we show that language can consistently improve performance in both.
|
[
-0.4384114742279053,
-0.6802340745925903,
0.579136312007904,
0.10995768010616302,
-0.5835064053535461,
-0.1901295930147171,
-0.16704870760440826,
-0.4527578353881836,
0.21247223019599915,
0.6464998126029968,
-0.5035468339920044,
-0.32326242327690125,
-0.36948615312576294,
0.1157020777463913,
-0.1682722419500351,
0.758586585521698,
-0.08791404217481613,
0.1915917694568634,
-0.3036808371543884,
-0.16618093848228455,
-0.30498310923576355,
-0.18510937690734863,
-0.39901506900787354,
-0.058638766407966614,
0.2444761097431183,
0.5197663903236389,
0.9970274567604065,
0.48770537972450256,
0.728867769241333,
0.3454977869987488,
0.03396574407815933,
0.09504334628582001,
-0.2519718110561371,
-0.1629464477300644,
0.15459565818309784,
-0.5029709339141846,
-0.0158579982817173,
-0.15357854962348938,
0.8731514811515808,
0.9589240550994873,
-0.14383313059806824,
-0.37563356757164,
-0.12398172914981842,
0.8351613283157349,
-0.6721547842025757,
-0.2812213897705078,
-0.4089925289154053,
0.41353192925453186,
0.1285170018672943,
-0.30252954363822937,
0.10461694747209549,
-0.04759804904460907,
0.5708651542663574,
-0.9118056893348694,
0.5120571255683899,
0.0630892962217331,
0.8640059232711792,
0.4559759199619293,
-0.31545814871788025,
-0.18582288920879364,
-0.8453131318092346,
0.6203871965408325,
-0.8441206216812134,
0.3173181712627411,
0.39154723286628723,
0.579525351524353,
0.19756647944450378,
-0.4566011130809784,
-0.7251845002174377,
-0.19158218801021576,
-0.3848559856414795,
0.5629469156265259,
0.176254540681839,
0.22688022255897522,
0.18072104454040527,
0.9958955645561218,
-0.7585051655769348,
-0.011742232367396355,
-0.6292629241943359,
-0.20870055258274078,
0.49949121475219727,
0.1733141988515854,
0.12465621531009674,
-0.2708422839641571,
-0.708181619644165,
-0.35498395562171936,
-0.4397621750831604,
0.11133494973182678,
0.3004797101020813,
0.20875109732151031,
-0.4761109948158264,
0.6560078859329224,
-0.12869766354560852,
0.9012144804000854,
-0.2150307595729828,
-0.19153150916099548,
0.24778738617897034,
-0.4420531988143921,
-0.41792094707489014,
-0.2005215883255005,
0.8638176918029785,
0.3765117824077606,
0.14285071194171906,
-0.019286436960101128,
-0.11699458211660385,
0.009439055807888508,
0.19834068417549133,
-0.6035330295562744,
-0.12895172834396362,
0.11498256027698517,
-0.11402446031570435,
-0.025038352236151695,
0.36438265442848206,
-1.0799206495285034,
-0.6583386063575745,
-0.19568608701229095,
0.38297247886657715,
-0.3934156596660614,
-0.23819538950920105,
0.7316944599151611,
-0.10271187126636505,
0.10260175168514252,
0.2919827699661255,
-0.7558323740959167,
0.4946652948856354,
0.05408327281475067,
0.8304046392440796,
0.00497547397390008,
-0.47422000765800476,
0.0005816149641759694,
0.1004188284277916,
-0.5468271970748901,
0.5414106249809265,
-0.1502254605293274,
-0.5475334525108337,
0.07848954200744629,
-0.20107723772525787,
0.2804965376853943,
-0.46675848960876465,
0.23278576135635376,
-0.23556174337863922,
0.45531728863716125,
0.13095645606517792,
-0.3513565957546234,
-0.26880747079849243,
0.41807451844215393,
-0.9680050611495972,
0.501087486743927,
0.33792954683303833,
-1.050156593322754,
0.38692066073417664,
-0.3023557662963867,
-0.4574951231479645,
-0.1669592559337616,
-0.4037461280822754,
-0.4249054193496704,
0.25620803236961365,
0.5963619351387024,
0.2655429244041443,
-0.33306485414505005,
-0.1369553506374359,
-0.06853677332401276,
-0.20238889753818512,
0.06137567386031151,
-0.3862687945365906,
0.2524813115596771,
-0.010092008858919144,
-0.10419468581676483,
-0.08573325723409653,
-0.7202549576759338,
-0.28550955653190613,
0.027883607894182205,
-0.3709349036216736,
-0.2947942018508911,
0.13723406195640564,
-0.04350779950618744,
-0.13863566517829895,
0.278726726770401,
-0.562819242477417,
-0.09649654477834702,
-0.9451112151145935,
-0.1531042903661728,
0.5810604691505432,
0.15882690250873566,
0.8941900134086609,
-0.18627610802650452,
0.8217837810516357,
0.26641926169395447,
-0.17469143867492676,
-0.46454426646232605,
-0.16032350063323975,
-0.613283634185791,
-0.41220933198928833,
0.08988311141729355,
0.5226898193359375,
-0.8962329626083374,
0.0572722963988781,
-0.4783797562122345,
-0.2905169427394867,
-0.21059666574001312,
-0.2284470498561859,
0.27515578269958496,
0.3774140179157257,
0.32379114627838135,
-0.23196063935756683,
-0.716891884803772,
-1.0031635761260986,
-0.014044075272977352,
-0.37435266375541687,
-0.2651842534542084,
0.40066543221473694,
0.1508917212486267,
0.15276184678077698,
0.8493674397468567,
-0.8379873037338257,
-0.41680100560188293,
-0.11370326578617096,
0.17023803293704987,
0.33358126878738403,
0.5074172019958496,
0.5829249620437622,
-1.100432276725769,
-0.4116935729980469,
0.29880955815315247,
-0.7518471479415894,
0.3604104816913605,
-0.22308684885501862,
0.12058766186237335,
-0.016287866979837418,
0.4697681665420532,
-0.309536337852478,
0.6187441349029541,
0.7475928068161011,
-0.12056577205657959,
0.4452754557132721,
-0.5352615714073181,
0.23654428124427795,
-1.0692771673202515,
-0.4030901789665222,
0.17443428933620453,
-0.2564464807510376,
-0.5832905173301697,
0.031362779438495636,
-0.08653802424669266,
-0.03892805054783821,
-0.14599405229091644,
0.4839671850204468,
-0.724862277507782,
0.004093247931450605,
-0.030197488144040108,
0.12317787110805511,
-0.11882894486188889,
0.4407503008842468,
0.40294814109802246,
0.7202718257904053,
0.8243407011032104,
-0.4872734844684601,
-0.0392342172563076,
-0.046799421310424805,
-0.6030522584915161,
0.5186387896537781,
-0.6453859210014343,
0.03974781930446625,
-0.24495981633663177,
0.03452187404036522,
-1.2128862142562866,
-0.426328182220459,
0.1361681967973709,
-0.4309164881706238,
0.30676794052124023,
0.23356235027313232,
-0.3872675597667694,
-0.47182998061180115,
-0.11119517683982849,
0.604839026927948,
0.19918064773082733,
-0.3160475194454193,
0.6007081866264343,
0.4121933877468109,
0.022339964285492897,
-0.4489611089229584,
-1.1142246723175049,
-0.16687089204788208,
-0.11093557626008987,
-0.4419911503791809,
0.1909060925245285,
-0.10705193877220154,
-0.0756981372833252,
-0.03507450222969055,
-0.34045764803886414,
-0.39128631353378296,
-0.2569183111190796,
0.18404769897460938,
0.3342995345592499,
-0.44862210750579834,
-0.08653637021780014,
-0.012432940304279327,
0.17430472373962402,
-0.12201148271560669,
-0.15258435904979706,
0.15906992554664612,
-0.19104085862636566,
-0.3369491398334503,
-0.08675013482570648,
0.3669664263725281,
0.42689141631126404,
0.03167756646871567,
0.29441729187965393,
0.2670592665672302,
-0.5917876958847046,
0.10552171617746353,
-0.39132755994796753,
-0.1513456106185913,
-0.43399447202682495,
0.48914864659309387,
-0.5786120891571045,
-0.8860687613487244,
0.40172189474105835,
0.2433004230260849,
-0.25873732566833496,
0.14232344925403595,
0.1528235375881195,
-0.0867161676287651,
0.8636889457702637,
0.8763134479522705,
-0.05802019685506821,
0.3328809440135956,
-0.42207521200180054,
0.04667738825082779,
-0.6754930019378662,
-0.06029727682471275,
-0.2726660668849945,
-0.24401159584522247,
-0.5124323964118958,
-0.642200231552124,
0.6163011789321899,
0.07558437436819077,
0.07380273938179016,
0.24403555691242218,
-0.29656416177749634,
0.6448784470558167,
0.39850690960884094,
0.360223650932312,
0.23485857248306274,
0.2375119924545288,
-0.17636409401893616,
-0.27401113510131836,
-0.6737592816352844,
-0.3827655613422394,
0.8872461915016174,
0.1979844719171524,
0.7836754322052002,
0.026677194982767105,
0.6024895906448364,
-0.20594879984855652,
0.20590651035308838,
-0.8683639168739319,
0.4621625244617462,
-0.15763051807880402,
-0.7980006337165833,
-0.5376721024513245,
-0.5230345129966736,
-0.9248465895652771,
0.5916682481765747,
0.008577379398047924,
-0.7600823044776917,
0.4334036707878113,
0.12881867587566376,
-0.4871358871459961,
0.3316236436367035,
-0.567043662071228,
0.6593790650367737,
0.010059974156320095,
-0.12617260217666626,
-0.030369793996214867,
-0.9341967701911926,
0.480741024017334,
-0.11526786535978317,
0.48191580176353455,
0.12128734588623047,
-0.41955381631851196,
0.24373796582221985,
-0.1353677660226822,
0.7450015544891357,
-0.05836210027337074,
-0.1032584086060524,
0.16067206859588623,
0.4581470191478729,
0.03089742176234722,
0.4213748574256897,
0.13583305478096008,
0.05264691263437271,
0.14284276962280273,
-0.27917757630348206,
-0.7514214515686035,
0.26339757442474365,
-0.8252190947532654,
-0.6780614852905273,
-0.2862713932991028,
-0.7750740647315979,
-0.3006100356578827,
0.19873535633087158,
0.5774483680725098,
0.46652570366859436,
-0.4783889949321747,
0.14570054411888123,
0.3680514097213745,
-0.26768752932548523,
0.3489251434803009,
0.42296433448791504,
-0.34222543239593506,
-0.5901354551315308,
0.6535229682922363,
-0.17175675928592682,
0.3864233195781708,
0.961166262626648,
0.3387373387813568,
-0.15201203525066376,
-0.6132211089134216,
-0.32526570558547974,
0.10624966770410538,
-0.6128567457199097,
-0.288700133562088,
-0.19139201939105988,
-0.14863307774066925,
-0.23525585234165192,
-0.3948360085487366,
-0.3337899148464203,
-0.4239194095134735,
-0.3455163836479187,
-0.08527558296918869,
-0.2571360766887665,
0.631685733795166,
-0.38305041193962097,
0.3927871882915497,
-0.4833548665046692,
0.46894294023513794,
0.29832956194877625,
0.054796237498521805,
-0.507681667804718,
-0.45505738258361816,
-0.31866613030433655,
0.2824939489364624,
0.06343872845172882,
-0.8724402785301208,
0.3546069860458374,
0.12620794773101807,
0.25738802552223206,
0.5049452185630798,
-0.20528632402420044,
0.7004072070121765,
-0.5556811094284058,
0.8186436891555786,
0.49568551778793335,
-0.5920270681381226,
0.5992437601089478,
-0.28818947076797485,
0.8291526436805725,
0.4941394329071045,
0.2984062135219574,
-0.35671523213386536,
-0.5909526944160461,
-0.5335460901260376,
-0.7884596586227417,
0.7724356651306152,
0.2653615176677704,
0.2612610459327698,
0.08274240791797638,
0.14634351432323456,
0.2967459559440613,
0.15942244231700897,
-0.9249541759490967,
-0.16983342170715332,
-0.5441797375679016,
-0.10162834823131561,
-0.46687087416648865,
-0.17133134603500366,
-0.13660068809986115,
-0.3073261082172394,
0.24009424448013306,
-0.0685325339436531,
0.19797654449939728,
0.5553985834121704,
-0.013742508366703987,
-0.17190131545066833,
0.00626416364684701,
0.6546233296394348,
0.770441472530365,
-0.40212658047676086,
0.49344924092292786,
0.17347635328769684,
-0.4371672570705414,
0.05236518383026123,
0.24192199110984802,
-0.03351229429244995,
0.2833888530731201,
0.38992878794670105,
0.7777237296104431,
0.3096276521682739,
-0.5144404768943787,
0.7427594065666199,
0.06288494169712067,
-0.3963625729084015,
-0.18920758366584778,
-0.4464558959007263,
-0.17618200182914734,
0.049117427319288254,
0.3148060441017151,
0.25009822845458984,
0.3184216320514679,
-0.09835831820964813,
0.056834667921066284,
0.21751315891742706,
-0.44113796949386597,
-0.35927706956863403,
0.35752829909324646,
-0.2495741993188858,
-0.08024141192436218,
0.1583082377910614,
-0.07627981156110764,
-0.39732956886291504,
0.7264891266822815,
0.4483385980129242,
0.6853508949279785,
-0.26199594140052795,
0.4007081687450409,
0.804766833782196,
0.504541277885437,
0.043074581772089005,
0.15051104128360748,
-0.053137894719839096,
-1.0314747095108032,
-0.16621242463588715,
-0.49802306294441223,
-0.20624415576457977,
0.1286335587501526,
-0.58352130651474,
0.12818388640880585,
-0.4703165590763092,
0.26546281576156616,
-0.04188463091850281,
-0.38152289390563965,
-0.7163450121879578,
0.49454912543296814,
0.12913580238819122,
0.6888980865478516,
-0.5502602458000183,
0.43334776163101196,
0.9083353281021118,
-0.6225191354751587,
-0.7029932737350464,
0.2970603406429291,
-0.032492607831954956,
-0.5792558789253235,
0.11939942836761475,
0.05603254958987236,
-0.45082348585128784,
-0.14432473480701447,
-0.6539895534515381,
-0.7174904942512512,
0.8287312984466553,
0.4197190999984741,
-0.4336412847042084,
-0.08729781210422516,
0.3537682592868805,
0.5934504270553589,
-0.36235788464546204,
-0.050933837890625,
0.20993070304393768,
0.22776556015014648,
0.22772173583507538,
-0.6396796703338623,
-0.01960492879152298,
0.09815805405378342,
0.40694764256477356,
0.0785052627325058,
-0.1652730405330658,
0.7171142101287842,
-0.2873304486274719,
-0.5142871141433716,
0.5182902812957764,
0.8666385412216187,
0.060518961399793625,
-0.0690418928861618,
0.8380174040794373,
0.5323712825775146,
0.32953816652297974,
0.043945781886577606,
1.337571620941162,
-0.01914241537451744,
0.27438369393348694,
1.2512623071670532,
0.21486082673072815,
0.6434415578842163,
0.7359890341758728,
-0.22879336774349213,
0.453924298286438,
0.67198246717453,
0.3000306785106659,
0.855466365814209,
0.21311768889427185,
-0.18494442105293274,
-0.10772249102592468,
0.33219102025032043,
-0.46912121772766113,
0.4757404625415802,
0.30051708221435547,
-0.13037346303462982,
-0.3435654044151306,
0.14437903463840485,
-0.32227054238319397,
0.3242019712924957,
-0.0183271411806345,
0.7279477119445801,
-0.03588074445724487,
-0.6462457180023193,
0.5381546020507812,
-0.0819513276219368,
0.48127442598342896,
-0.5807135701179504,
0.11548398435115814,
-0.5557990670204163,
0.07441967725753784,
0.11835755407810211,
-0.7698915004730225,
0.2239462435245514,
-0.5650330185890198,
-0.10484390705823898,
0.043797899037599564,
0.3610522150993347,
-0.6385608315467834,
-0.6739317774772644,
-0.023373281583189964,
0.4344128668308258,
0.17678944766521454,
-0.10713007301092148,
-0.3546345829963684,
-0.33754974603652954,
-0.07667753845453262,
-0.13124746084213257,
-0.24619124829769135,
0.7866668701171875,
0.4516283869743347,
0.32756805419921875,
0.2767263650894165,
0.2497655153274536,
0.14982323348522186,
0.047477465122938156,
0.9369603395462036,
-0.24050971865653992,
-0.6041461229324341,
-0.5619158744812012,
0.6904571056365967,
-0.08927436172962189,
-0.36454930901527405,
0.42611271142959595,
0.7366751432418823,
1.0671039819717407,
-0.3405093550682068,
0.6575932502746582,
0.051986757665872574,
0.36772748827934265,
-0.7452325224876404,
0.1332038789987564,
-1.0154967308044434,
0.20935922861099243,
-0.31885579228401184,
-0.9570882320404053,
-0.5340432524681091,
0.7703433036804199,
-0.271533727645874,
-0.20149260759353638,
1.0205574035644531,
1.0772192478179932,
-0.34245815873146057,
0.029448674991726875,
0.49666357040405273,
0.02026480995118618,
-0.10576523095369339,
0.40671393275260925,
0.9897897839546204,
-0.3826611042022705,
0.5710803866386414,
-0.4583158493041992,
-0.2501997947692871,
0.23809675872325897,
-0.6114557981491089,
-0.6392216086387634,
-0.8098065257072449,
-0.12940092384815216,
-0.0433182418346405,
-0.12680064141750336,
0.2640799880027771,
0.7756056189537048,
-0.6234899163246155,
-0.46342724561691284,
-0.40996506810188293,
0.1638372838497162,
-0.06935645639896393,
-0.23242098093032837,
0.05959288030862808,
-0.16352540254592896,
-0.855150043964386,
0.28861361742019653,
0.4446539878845215,
0.5448296666145325,
-0.4975162744522095,
-0.053993143141269684,
-0.25320905447006226,
0.03640352189540863,
0.22983568906784058,
0.17884312570095062,
-0.8647925853729248,
-0.3515952527523041,
-0.16442838311195374,
-0.19068048894405365,
0.3128198981285095,
0.9961315989494324,
-0.5394487380981445,
0.9550849199295044,
0.4996441900730133,
0.5352908968925476,
0.8495410680770874,
-0.19722111523151398,
0.7452867031097412,
-1.0198380947113037,
0.5576649308204651,
0.32471999526023865,
0.3712252974510193,
0.6476935744285583,
-0.2786839008331299,
0.6255990862846375,
-0.0034886347129940987,
-0.129017174243927,
-0.5735778212547302,
0.49066585302352905,
-1.0139840841293335,
-0.4918223023414612,
1.1434884071350098,
-0.18816141784191132,
-0.11481973528862,
0.1942726969718933,
-0.37616485357284546,
-0.0017320908373221755,
0.12514470517635345,
0.588166356086731,
0.7881593704223633,
0.4001559019088745,
-0.489289253950119,
-0.47086232900619507,
0.3370632827281952,
0.3316055238246918,
-0.6506027579307556,
-0.33616459369659424,
0.6686072945594788,
-0.01669296622276306,
0.39953377842903137,
0.7871090769767761,
-0.095721535384655,
0.21297429502010345,
0.3131413161754608,
-0.04852589592337608,
0.34470927715301514,
-0.40909621119499207,
-0.3466891944408417,
0.05477549135684967,
-0.27370181679725647,
-0.413190633058548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03626v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03626v1
|
Training LLMs over Neurally Compressed Text
| 2024-04-04T17:48:28 | 2024-04-04T17:48:28 |
Brian Lester, Jaehoon Lee, Alex Alemi, Jeffrey Pennington, Adam Roberts, Jascha Sohl-Dickstein, Noah Constant
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we explore the idea of training large language models (LLMs)
over highly compressed text. While standard subword tokenizers compress text by
a small factor, neural text compressors can achieve much higher rates of
compression. If it were possible to train LLMs directly over neurally
compressed text, this would confer advantages in training and serving
efficiency, as well as easier handling of long text spans. The main obstacle to
this goal is that strong compression tends to produce opaque outputs that are
not well-suited for learning. In particular, we find that text na\"ively
compressed via Arithmetic Coding is not readily learnable by LLMs. To overcome
this, we propose Equal-Info Windows, a novel compression technique whereby text
is segmented into blocks that each compress to the same bit length. Using this
method, we demonstrate effective learning over neurally compressed text that
improves with scale, and outperforms byte-level baselines by a wide margin on
perplexity and inference speed benchmarks. While our method delivers worse
perplexity than subword tokenizers for models trained with the same parameter
count, it has the benefit of shorter sequence lengths. Shorter sequence lengths
require fewer autoregressive generation steps, and reduce latency. Finally, we
provide extensive analysis of the properties that contribute to learnability,
and offer concrete suggestions for how to further improve the performance of
high-compression tokenizers.
|
[
-0.031122302636504173,
-0.5695180892944336,
0.44816580414772034,
0.10030562430620193,
-0.3695375323295593,
0.04047694429755211,
-0.5213276147842407,
-0.48815467953681946,
0.30082985758781433,
0.14049406349658966,
-0.3304586112499237,
-0.27145329117774963,
-0.942874550819397,
0.2437623143196106,
-0.31280115246772766,
0.9260684251785278,
0.11605402827262878,
0.1994718462228775,
-0.1826080083847046,
0.11832089722156525,
-0.13885799050331116,
-0.8699701428413391,
-0.7870544791221619,
-0.06416299194097519,
0.4941577911376953,
0.14443108439445496,
0.556182324886322,
0.9556175470352173,
0.422707200050354,
0.3981398344039917,
-0.23858918249607086,
0.24402879178524017,
-0.6573902368545532,
0.12099612504243851,
0.2846447825431824,
-0.6621057391166687,
-0.3093073070049286,
0.01173398643732071,
0.8532590270042419,
0.7464694380760193,
-0.12661831080913544,
0.03531710430979729,
0.2058679610490799,
0.7076787352561951,
-0.5770127773284912,
0.24475784599781036,
-0.9224157333374023,
0.38757213950157166,
-0.10594651103019714,
-0.3632669150829315,
-0.5267254114151001,
-0.24685704708099365,
-0.3506923019886017,
-0.5739319324493408,
0.20004940032958984,
0.28529104590415955,
0.7989656329154968,
0.3991001844406128,
-0.3113442361354828,
-0.1335822343826294,
-0.46523168683052063,
0.6725531816482544,
-0.7938865423202515,
0.32448917627334595,
0.20498552918434143,
0.1873941719532013,
-0.16972461342811584,
-0.6754671335220337,
-0.45069587230682373,
0.09313362836837769,
0.042550284415483475,
0.0007322513265535235,
-0.39446717500686646,
0.3549744486808777,
0.46670714020729065,
0.45076656341552734,
-0.46239006519317627,
0.30054575204849243,
-0.46086323261260986,
-0.33183079957962036,
0.3764907717704773,
0.18588395416736603,
0.2197938859462738,
0.05161547660827637,
-0.4704662561416626,
-0.05736793577671051,
-0.8857817053794861,
0.07640483975410461,
0.679888904094696,
0.36520829796791077,
0.1414792239665985,
0.5340321660041809,
-0.1477753072977066,
0.8547566533088684,
-0.1550167351961136,
-0.0774526298046112,
0.16513849794864655,
-0.07237324863672256,
-0.26935818791389465,
0.11610953509807587,
0.7144644856452942,
0.12060752511024475,
0.248721644282341,
-0.45938539505004883,
-0.5051276683807373,
-0.0885782316327095,
0.1664026975631714,
-1.1715633869171143,
0.026019737124443054,
-0.06454776972532272,
-0.5870532393455505,
-0.1447438895702362,
0.053795017302036285,
-0.5152167677879333,
-0.4046689569950104,
-0.533511221408844,
0.47168731689453125,
-0.35151875019073486,
0.04333138093352318,
0.24843579530715942,
-0.2045382559299469,
-0.1480572372674942,
0.32580623030662537,
-1.0914236307144165,
0.4179636538028717,
0.6828700304031372,
0.7958731651306152,
-0.12712082266807556,
-0.22718749940395355,
-0.6645054817199707,
-0.1269637793302536,
-0.23630549013614655,
0.5254655480384827,
-0.48372524976730347,
0.1359996646642685,
0.03994297608733177,
-0.33027341961860657,
0.00783584639430046,
-0.6527835130691528,
0.42628195881843567,
-0.6506026983261108,
0.034462712705135345,
0.04931608960032463,
-0.8283496499061584,
0.0996372178196907,
0.2978852093219757,
-0.6198599934577942,
0.7975881099700928,
0.06339855492115021,
-0.8887267708778381,
0.06708692759275436,
-0.206765279173851,
-0.35700076818466187,
-0.11927247047424316,
-0.37344467639923096,
-0.31651315093040466,
0.48081040382385254,
0.17826813459396362,
0.5699376463890076,
-0.32576417922973633,
0.13067737221717834,
-0.00523378374055028,
-0.5031763315200806,
0.23798134922981262,
-0.8402378559112549,
0.5450936555862427,
0.10258492827415466,
-0.14111506938934326,
-0.013799847103655338,
-0.8251433968544006,
0.13556542992591858,
0.05244399979710579,
-1.005682349205017,
-0.2660645842552185,
-0.2240699827671051,
-0.004891188815236092,
0.06876927614212036,
0.3860883414745331,
-0.689743161201477,
0.4138643741607666,
-0.564640998840332,
0.5086050033569336,
0.9102360010147095,
-0.4848591387271881,
0.3662010133266449,
-0.1856548935174942,
0.4541155695915222,
0.11320793628692627,
0.04948563873767853,
-0.24025291204452515,
-0.15867070853710175,
-0.939845085144043,
-0.326244592666626,
0.6228393912315369,
0.33530086278915405,
-0.815956711769104,
0.6548767685890198,
-0.48841604590415955,
-0.10653853416442871,
-0.579269289970398,
0.18929985165596008,
0.4309940040111542,
0.3901398181915283,
0.2334645688533783,
-0.3342141807079315,
-0.6705127954483032,
-0.789440393447876,
-0.4790235459804535,
0.00867779552936554,
0.022950343787670135,
0.1311374306678772,
0.13131067156791687,
0.07186194509267807,
0.7355368137359619,
-0.47623908519744873,
-0.05868833512067795,
-0.17402221262454987,
0.20180611312389374,
0.2885245382785797,
0.4515928030014038,
0.14991547167301178,
-0.7867214679718018,
-0.39248526096343994,
-0.3874276876449585,
-0.5552058219909668,
-0.09376596659421921,
-0.03926549479365349,
0.13478733599185944,
0.14826565980911255,
0.9065421223640442,
-0.6908837556838989,
0.460909903049469,
0.6146115660667419,
-0.4186895191669464,
0.30151963233947754,
-0.41606074571609497,
-0.13634935021400452,
-1.0854405164718628,
-0.2974841892719269,
-0.09084367007017136,
-0.3969682455062866,
-0.6989673376083374,
-0.07707998901605606,
0.24635420739650726,
-0.1117224246263504,
-0.41123902797698975,
0.2542073428630829,
-0.7098479866981506,
-0.10511675477027893,
-0.4730933606624603,
-0.0012451134389266372,
-0.08184956014156342,
0.6482965350151062,
-0.1009821742773056,
0.9129132628440857,
0.37947142124176025,
-0.4314703643321991,
0.2272595465183258,
-0.1407080888748169,
-0.5441763401031494,
0.20471429824829102,
-0.510168194770813,
0.19511640071868896,
-0.552492618560791,
0.18571409583091736,
-0.862118124961853,
0.11566269397735596,
-0.14967064559459686,
-0.6151548027992249,
0.7198121547698975,
-0.05424632877111435,
-0.6221285462379456,
0.08693213760852814,
-0.2428276389837265,
0.4686508774757385,
0.619151771068573,
-0.8488336801528931,
0.48058798909187317,
0.3194347321987152,
-0.07998032867908478,
-0.7900172472000122,
-0.6893458366394043,
0.28218528628349304,
-0.11084583401679993,
-0.5585558414459229,
0.45258599519729614,
-0.13873068988323212,
-0.028776029124855995,
-0.07589160650968552,
-0.17573997378349304,
-0.146727055311203,
0.1149861142039299,
0.2961970865726471,
0.16404443979263306,
-0.30755576491355896,
0.5336470603942871,
0.009037106297910213,
-0.13946639001369476,
-0.09877019375562668,
-0.6027467846870422,
0.652496874332428,
-0.18032896518707275,
-0.15421266853809357,
-0.20921531319618225,
0.2689010202884674,
0.30992603302001953,
0.1252051144838333,
0.9243935346603394,
0.4378833472728729,
-0.47592607140541077,
-0.21414649486541748,
-0.5174016952514648,
-0.22219237685203552,
-0.4881247580051422,
0.5494694709777832,
-0.31508415937423706,
-1.0984787940979004,
0.1892763376235962,
-0.1474764049053192,
-0.03432236611843109,
0.34010955691337585,
0.2404165416955948,
-0.002271519508212805,
0.8698702454566956,
0.826911449432373,
-0.26791447401046753,
0.4670427739620209,
-0.20819911360740662,
0.20713366568088531,
-0.6954116821289062,
-0.15576574206352234,
-0.5569107532501221,
-0.42741090059280396,
-0.22144745290279388,
-0.5141422748565674,
0.29403388500213623,
0.3564744293689728,
-0.2196042686700821,
0.17791816592216492,
-0.46805399656295776,
0.7816260457038879,
0.3834526538848877,
0.26366209983825684,
0.2660265862941742,
0.31749171018600464,
0.07024327665567398,
-0.2518559396266937,
-0.9793845415115356,
-0.3404633104801178,
0.8331173062324524,
0.4703906178474426,
0.9205938577651978,
0.08965229243040085,
0.6240379810333252,
0.11543747782707214,
0.18010222911834717,
-0.9126148223876953,
0.3886027932167053,
-0.4141841530799866,
-0.2525324821472168,
-0.33723461627960205,
-0.9730024337768555,
-1.0852919816970825,
0.23737087845802307,
-0.3214324414730072,
-0.5620461702346802,
-0.02477666735649109,
0.022865813225507736,
-0.2510600686073303,
0.6141586899757385,
-0.7406681180000305,
0.5179169774055481,
-0.24083499610424042,
-0.034675247967243195,
-0.041167497634887695,
-0.5744099617004395,
0.03319026529788971,
-0.05253744125366211,
0.17727632820606232,
0.06444978713989258,
-0.4459115266799927,
0.8585735559463501,
-0.7294629812240601,
0.966130256652832,
-0.026715947315096855,
0.04978444427251816,
-0.08931165188550949,
-0.16679437458515167,
0.5324945449829102,
-0.26421481370925903,
0.01640479452908039,
0.30531153082847595,
-0.46304377913475037,
-0.48911887407302856,
-0.8483908176422119,
0.5106654763221741,
-0.8776994943618774,
-0.5717050433158875,
-0.2640901505947113,
-0.6871400475502014,
-0.14536459743976593,
0.08538567274808884,
0.4827241599559784,
0.7885149121284485,
0.15302692353725433,
0.24804076552391052,
0.823550820350647,
-0.06178732588887215,
0.5669934153556824,
0.4032283425331116,
0.04971417039632797,
-0.40021565556526184,
0.7847506403923035,
0.2514130473136902,
0.3243020474910736,
0.7353577017784119,
0.23663848638534546,
-0.23292425274848938,
-0.7869304418563843,
-0.417987197637558,
-0.08249076455831528,
-0.8710049390792847,
-0.45730599761009216,
-0.6286042332649231,
-0.548626184463501,
-0.4263608753681183,
0.0768682211637497,
-0.3606950640678406,
-0.7042606472969055,
-0.3696087896823883,
-0.12687239050865173,
0.25435671210289,
0.7576639652252197,
-0.11383461207151413,
0.4528389275074005,
-0.8354389071464539,
0.12208805978298187,
0.29898297786712646,
0.33541572093963623,
0.14521591365337372,
-0.8323917984962463,
-0.4699598252773285,
-0.1618398129940033,
-0.02409343793988228,
-0.5820774435997009,
0.3906884789466858,
0.2623850405216217,
0.409397691488266,
0.33099064230918884,
0.010766875930130482,
0.5017675161361694,
-0.6657001376152039,
0.5462097525596619,
0.5716785788536072,
-0.8859525918960571,
0.07657941430807114,
0.10001182556152344,
0.29846712946891785,
0.6200305819511414,
0.5336040258407593,
-0.41442227363586426,
-0.17845728993415833,
-0.47007328271865845,
-0.9525613188743591,
0.5479260087013245,
0.1985282450914383,
0.4681696593761444,
0.05345846712589264,
0.5194574594497681,
0.16975705325603485,
0.31654301285743713,
-0.8644306063652039,
-0.3474886417388916,
0.0791497603058815,
-0.6062618494033813,
-0.11802079528570175,
-0.3862161636352539,
0.02610195055603981,
-0.25110146403312683,
0.6157187223434448,
-0.1722298413515091,
0.3249991834163666,
0.21257586777210236,
-0.19024011492729187,
0.19866149127483368,
0.3750514090061188,
0.25888586044311523,
0.44251003861427307,
0.022381873801350594,
0.6178415417671204,
0.15834872424602509,
-0.6714754104614258,
0.24334363639354706,
0.1456114798784256,
-0.10348303616046906,
0.017963197082281113,
0.3743405342102051,
1.1243886947631836,
0.05734854191541672,
-0.6302833557128906,
0.8161143064498901,
-0.41987067461013794,
-0.08273938298225403,
-0.12209836393594742,
-0.018058082088828087,
-0.015315333381295204,
0.25954899191856384,
0.2892666757106781,
0.1531461626291275,
-0.010616933926939964,
-0.65689617395401,
-0.0968211367726326,
0.3534063398838043,
-0.6186686158180237,
-0.06762097030878067,
0.39515554904937744,
0.15647365152835846,
-0.531613290309906,
0.7766624689102173,
-0.10420031100511551,
-0.6768014430999756,
0.6023757457733154,
0.7300622463226318,
0.6566740870475769,
0.0722559466958046,
-0.37334302067756653,
0.20098881423473358,
0.45317432284355164,
-0.14219464361667633,
0.13929150998592377,
-0.2336166650056839,
-0.6472059488296509,
-0.5671281814575195,
-0.6438685059547424,
-0.1842668503522873,
0.12966777384281158,
-0.39493006467819214,
0.04359838366508484,
-0.48046597838401794,
-0.0877426490187645,
-0.11631913483142853,
-0.1164841428399086,
-0.47806838154792786,
0.17869524657726288,
0.16169902682304382,
1.3136568069458008,
-0.651871383190155,
0.7827316522598267,
0.4290310740470886,
-0.22348937392234802,
-0.9110204577445984,
-0.05795987695455551,
-0.25387123227119446,
-0.7849102020263672,
0.8351736068725586,
0.4917515516281128,
0.08028674870729446,
-0.04372382536530495,
-0.6506511569023132,
-0.7749350070953369,
0.7931596636772156,
0.618911862373352,
-0.8061025738716125,
-0.181696355342865,
0.24141094088554382,
0.5184640884399414,
-0.3816930651664734,
0.34815922379493713,
0.38115373253822327,
0.16689832508563995,
-0.12675261497497559,
-0.666172444820404,
0.13019968569278717,
-0.4663798213005066,
-0.05767374485731125,
0.3274839520454407,
-0.5542053580284119,
0.9136208891868591,
0.03120790608227253,
-0.23761789500713348,
0.14468152821063995,
0.7910026907920837,
-0.07969270646572113,
0.07303038239479065,
0.5481887459754944,
0.7918232083320618,
0.9021555185317993,
-0.05394498631358147,
1.003920316696167,
-0.3709891736507416,
0.17806293070316315,
1.0951958894729614,
0.2879685163497925,
0.899020791053772,
0.5924336910247803,
-0.12984740734100342,
0.2798191010951996,
0.44102999567985535,
0.2485305517911911,
0.3400857746601105,
0.6510897874832153,
-0.3497731685638428,
-0.3891833424568176,
-0.009601105004549026,
-0.18885405361652374,
0.23607347905635834,
0.23788174986839294,
-0.4282307028770447,
-0.10740531235933304,
-0.07925335317850113,
0.009159411303699017,
0.22745902836322784,
-0.3757376968860626,
0.6853446960449219,
0.24632690846920013,
-0.476036012172699,
0.7079657912254333,
0.19794732332229614,
1.1351312398910522,
-0.6558581590652466,
0.11525548249483109,
-0.12913180887699127,
0.0816459208726883,
-0.18427756428718567,
-0.47974541783332825,
0.11341500282287598,
0.12350115180015564,
-0.33778563141822815,
-0.25906017422676086,
0.8398463726043701,
-0.6225070953369141,
-0.30761417746543884,
0.0342884436249733,
0.29164397716522217,
0.5036042928695679,
-0.2475275993347168,
-0.4500778317451477,
0.005991073790937662,
-0.0815223678946495,
-0.21601130068302155,
0.5465856790542603,
0.5476289391517639,
0.3768957257270813,
0.39748236536979675,
0.5211787819862366,
0.4101366102695465,
0.3880372941493988,
0.09195580333471298,
0.8907357454299927,
-0.6449413299560547,
-0.4108502268791199,
-1.0120075941085815,
0.16541288793087006,
-0.32447874546051025,
-0.2587321400642395,
0.6744405031204224,
0.823418140411377,
0.7952952980995178,
0.06853964924812317,
0.7129622101783752,
0.2187153846025467,
0.2862086594104767,
-0.9024604558944702,
0.6517131924629211,
-0.548275351524353,
0.37432679533958435,
0.3325822055339813,
-0.9080861806869507,
-0.2549718916416168,
0.47974950075149536,
-0.03754407912492752,
0.005747034214437008,
0.5827438235282898,
0.6922731995582581,
-0.10493623465299606,
0.060080673545598984,
0.4909425973892212,
0.25198379158973694,
0.09354068338871002,
0.9092947840690613,
1.0539692640304565,
-0.609136164188385,
0.8129854798316956,
-0.04073628783226013,
-0.20493540167808533,
-0.03627847135066986,
-0.8602207899093628,
-1.0753761529922485,
-0.40497472882270813,
-0.1329669952392578,
-0.4612908363342285,
0.10785072296857834,
1.1151072978973389,
0.8432047367095947,
-0.38034623861312866,
-0.06565407663583755,
-0.2257315069437027,
0.15329143404960632,
0.23636536300182343,
-0.1544882208108902,
0.34210532903671265,
-0.48353540897369385,
-0.7825051546096802,
0.4664529860019684,
0.3124859631061554,
0.2852311432361603,
-0.2586759626865387,
-0.03373546898365021,
0.19478917121887207,
0.27055349946022034,
0.5388236045837402,
0.14969699084758759,
-0.19614160060882568,
-0.08853806555271149,
-0.2167062610387802,
-0.3891771733760834,
0.3548622727394104,
0.9900209307670593,
-0.7582439184188843,
0.2940700650215149,
0.7209551334381104,
0.967566967010498,
0.5146190524101257,
-0.1492774784564972,
0.36760789155960083,
-1.0663923025131226,
0.2979764938354492,
0.17374978959560394,
0.570565402507782,
0.5035768151283264,
-0.5232465863227844,
0.40240007638931274,
0.1225467175245285,
-0.5062494874000549,
-0.7330541610717773,
0.11899557709693909,
-0.6977959871292114,
-0.5501860976219177,
1.353778600692749,
-0.33406126499176025,
-0.324375182390213,
0.029976945370435715,
-0.23922185599803925,
0.3140501081943512,
-0.3882099390029907,
0.829011857509613,
0.5346011519432068,
0.09689296036958694,
0.09347552061080933,
-0.24535933136940002,
0.5032830834388733,
0.5011156797409058,
-0.8625835180282593,
0.07445774972438812,
0.2804914116859436,
0.11527570337057114,
0.1685585379600525,
0.6220008134841919,
-0.11125611513853073,
-0.010754676535725594,
0.19260476529598236,
0.08369862288236618,
-0.33960777521133423,
-0.49458444118499756,
-0.8331220746040344,
0.32877424359321594,
0.0645897313952446,
-0.022024212405085564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03623v1
|
Unveiling LLMs: The Evolution of Latent Representations in a Temporal Knowledge Graph
| 2024-04-04T17:45:59 | 2024-04-04T17:45:59 |
Marco Bronzini, Carlo Nicolini, Bruno Lepri, Jacopo Staiano, Andrea Passerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate an impressive capacity to recall a
vast range of common factual knowledge information. However, unravelling the
underlying reasoning of LLMs and explaining their internal mechanisms of
exploiting this factual knowledge remain active areas of investigation. Our
work analyzes the factual knowledge encoded in the latent representation of
LLMs when prompted to assess the truthfulness of factual claims. We propose an
end-to-end framework that jointly decodes the factual knowledge embedded in the
latent space of LLMs from a vector space to a set of ground predicates and
represents its evolution across the layers using a temporal knowledge graph.
Our framework relies on the technique of activation patching which intervenes
in the inference computation of a model by dynamically altering its latent
representations. Consequently, we neither rely on external models nor training
processes. We showcase our framework with local and global interpretability
analyses using two claim verification datasets: FEVER and CLIMATE-FEVER. The
local interpretability analysis exposes different latent errors from
representation to multi-hop reasoning errors. On the other hand, the global
analysis uncovered patterns in the underlying evolution of the model's factual
knowledge (e.g., store-and-seek factual information). By enabling graph-based
analyses of the latent representations, this work represents a step towards the
mechanistic interpretability of LLMs.
|
[
0.11916510760784149,
-0.8875154852867126,
0.8085097074508667,
0.0179253201931715,
-0.1679532378911972,
0.5880908966064453,
-0.22865141928195953,
-0.33535903692245483,
0.04505367949604988,
0.5002381205558777,
-0.5165666341781616,
-0.4670163094997406,
-0.6449664235115051,
0.009579380974173546,
-0.19287660717964172,
0.8724735975265503,
-0.19425059854984283,
-0.41246023774147034,
-0.4551740884780884,
-0.043381329625844955,
-0.008492383174598217,
-0.5877970457077026,
-0.2421114146709442,
-0.661819577217102,
0.47100815176963806,
0.13898298144340515,
0.5437836050987244,
0.5108891129493713,
0.1315571367740631,
0.22626934945583344,
-0.33980101346969604,
0.33745434880256653,
-0.7038791179656982,
0.08522166311740875,
-0.24713553488254547,
-0.5802624821662903,
-0.4460046887397766,
0.1867915838956833,
0.7943156361579895,
0.8225231766700745,
-0.025494739413261414,
0.235544353723526,
0.014035193249583244,
0.23029327392578125,
-0.512076199054718,
0.4271649718284607,
-0.8283477425575256,
-0.039837852120399475,
-0.2300092577934265,
-0.4694365859031677,
-0.5309519171714783,
-0.08563928306102753,
0.06184634566307068,
-0.33125385642051697,
0.15969766676425934,
-0.0001900470961118117,
0.7247317433357239,
0.24166902899742126,
-0.6422898769378662,
-0.16930371522903442,
-0.6628335118293762,
0.5559303760528564,
-0.639540433883667,
0.273910790681839,
0.06414695084095001,
0.3505482077598572,
-0.5497784614562988,
-0.9350031018257141,
-0.6617327332496643,
-0.15964633226394653,
-0.21936148405075073,
0.034512851387262344,
-0.4022103250026703,
-0.18944036960601807,
0.187421515583992,
0.37550851702690125,
-0.49934932589530945,
-0.005741406232118607,
-0.20646624267101288,
-0.4808908998966217,
0.3651598393917084,
-0.03812601789832115,
0.4568230211734772,
-0.24703504145145416,
-0.4395500123500824,
0.46620574593544006,
-0.9886990189552307,
0.12806808948516846,
0.1761372834444046,
0.27739712595939636,
-0.3881777226924896,
0.6131498217582703,
-0.05759386345744133,
0.556056559085846,
-0.26998233795166016,
-0.19243930280208588,
0.2503507137298584,
-0.20724554359912872,
-0.27287226915359497,
0.06202966719865799,
0.5431719422340393,
0.26812976598739624,
-0.1996876448392868,
-0.4349573254585266,
-0.12336239963769913,
0.03272957354784012,
-0.0826677605509758,
-0.6274479031562805,
-0.009648429229855537,
0.17548827826976776,
-0.3865029811859131,
-0.41867297887802124,
-0.12851358950138092,
-0.6112459301948547,
-0.3902440071105957,
-0.27095797657966614,
0.24903972446918488,
-0.21389420330524445,
-0.41057056188583374,
0.1113836020231247,
0.0009079381125047803,
0.1513713002204895,
0.19738441705703735,
-0.4959361255168915,
0.16687777638435364,
0.5998668670654297,
0.8306251764297485,
0.0578271709382534,
-0.04027928411960602,
-0.3487064838409424,
0.48503631353378296,
-0.36295202374458313,
0.7779597640037537,
-0.6898397207260132,
-0.15054425597190857,
-0.048828594386577606,
0.2861611545085907,
-0.21185742318630219,
-0.40502914786338806,
0.32253631949424744,
-0.9710813760757446,
0.08215796947479248,
-0.37504616379737854,
-0.5103652477264404,
-0.3640013039112091,
0.4202219545841217,
-0.5326778292655945,
0.9090328812599182,
0.18495604395866394,
-0.8343625068664551,
0.175687775015831,
-0.6313437223434448,
-0.02701602876186371,
-0.12599918246269226,
-0.2537875175476074,
-0.36633044481277466,
0.12121204286813736,
0.29260462522506714,
0.4471430480480194,
-0.3977348208427429,
0.4506147503852844,
-0.40394771099090576,
-0.06900367140769958,
0.5648568868637085,
-0.5590858459472656,
0.8908254504203796,
0.09964186698198318,
-0.28566598892211914,
-0.15946318209171295,
-0.8700336217880249,
-0.34112516045570374,
0.386398583650589,
-0.35038453340530396,
0.054511941969394684,
0.16752640902996063,
-0.6133100986480713,
0.08115154504776001,
0.4427991807460785,
-0.5722463130950928,
0.36701884865760803,
-0.32041943073272705,
0.5770507454872131,
0.6909788250923157,
0.4461359679698944,
0.24091775715351105,
-0.26575878262519836,
0.3448259234428406,
0.35909950733184814,
0.11254080384969711,
-0.4728573262691498,
-0.38812413811683655,
-0.5099509954452515,
-0.12906761467456818,
0.15603916347026825,
0.4743289649486542,
-0.6863625049591064,
0.1916883885860443,
-0.5095697641372681,
-0.24992547929286957,
-0.007426850497722626,
0.0909571424126625,
0.28101521730422974,
0.6592322587966919,
0.2567325830459595,
0.07325580716133118,
-0.4188685715198517,
-0.721519410610199,
-0.13063637912273407,
-0.3656838536262512,
0.1748364418745041,
0.1629898101091385,
0.5159267783164978,
-0.43048280477523804,
1.1357393264770508,
-0.49050039052963257,
0.14222154021263123,
-0.17818617820739746,
0.33726391196250916,
0.4099763035774231,
0.24321839213371277,
0.6496812701225281,
-0.6316317915916443,
-0.020372556522488594,
0.05051402375102043,
-0.9693776965141296,
-0.3341408967971802,
-0.11027399450540543,
0.07301724702119827,
0.19962912797927856,
0.6998593211174011,
-0.2935868501663208,
0.47316354513168335,
0.6576513648033142,
-0.49850401282310486,
0.6735899448394775,
-0.28055769205093384,
0.12362974137067795,
-0.7723888754844666,
0.018074436113238335,
-0.39962494373321533,
-0.37212780117988586,
-0.4055721163749695,
-0.0055281901732087135,
-0.15768513083457947,
0.054027095437049866,
-0.1601799875497818,
0.6082475781440735,
-0.6494731307029724,
-0.22050301730632782,
-0.12400013953447342,
0.09235206246376038,
0.19682176411151886,
0.4278642237186432,
-0.3023410141468048,
0.5834825038909912,
0.5749636292457581,
-0.4781700670719147,
0.36991316080093384,
-0.11277098208665848,
-0.27715229988098145,
0.12213078141212463,
-0.39755943417549133,
0.1443946361541748,
-0.3127749264240265,
0.30701911449432373,
-1.0343952178955078,
-0.1859871745109558,
0.4341176748275757,
-0.4828318953514099,
0.4462396800518036,
-0.5708638429641724,
-0.7431616187095642,
-0.16025622189044952,
0.07998920232057571,
0.38497307896614075,
0.5314081311225891,
-0.648410439491272,
0.9710352420806885,
0.27240583300590515,
-0.202010840177536,
-0.5049959421157837,
-0.44287407398223877,
0.11249923706054688,
-0.1767696589231491,
-0.733633279800415,
0.2842719852924347,
0.08483777195215225,
-0.5744834542274475,
0.3195863366127014,
-0.21140991151332855,
0.10674189776182175,
0.10773307085037231,
0.1764160394668579,
0.21919088065624237,
-0.3724380433559418,
0.07780110836029053,
0.0371767021715641,
-0.2829275131225586,
0.33253827691078186,
-0.510071337223053,
0.46407848596572876,
-0.024139275774359703,
-0.5501866936683655,
0.007991928607225418,
-0.07279637455940247,
0.6395849585533142,
-0.17356735467910767,
0.9949250221252441,
0.41575565934181213,
-0.5017228126525879,
-0.1050531193614006,
-0.48755890130996704,
0.11367963254451752,
-0.40951332449913025,
0.14512205123901367,
-0.3987296521663666,
-0.7975354790687561,
0.8838123083114624,
-0.5620734095573425,
0.10179312527179718,
0.6215033531188965,
0.5356625914573669,
-0.010791068896651268,
0.6024340391159058,
0.6381081938743591,
0.2303127646446228,
0.11995811015367508,
-0.2648921012878418,
0.1535577028989792,
-0.9195200204849243,
-0.6824600696563721,
-0.21075387299060822,
0.011172843165695667,
-0.271027147769928,
-1.0365760326385498,
0.4897056221961975,
0.3452627956867218,
-0.1398564726114273,
-0.3525390326976776,
-0.01757931150496006,
0.5499986410140991,
-0.08063412457704544,
0.2554619312286377,
0.3673734962940216,
0.15501205623149872,
-0.5181833505630493,
-0.03398674726486206,
-0.5188960433006287,
-0.6619692444801331,
1.1793564558029175,
0.5033050179481506,
0.513874888420105,
0.39770591259002686,
0.3779180645942688,
0.48582571744918823,
0.3492305278778076,
-0.38841164112091064,
0.3417927026748657,
-0.016602659597992897,
-0.4969461262226105,
-0.14277710020542145,
-0.48193925619125366,
-0.8137412071228027,
0.1555682271718979,
-0.26850876212120056,
-1.0362492799758911,
0.09769739955663681,
0.15481242537498474,
-0.17297403514385223,
0.6181872487068176,
-0.5026333928108215,
0.7063367366790771,
-0.3052451014518738,
-0.4765405058860779,
-0.3319378197193146,
-0.7223344445228577,
0.47007253766059875,
-0.14028745889663696,
0.5717265605926514,
-0.3360019624233246,
0.05545559152960777,
0.729049026966095,
-0.33968043327331543,
1.2747553586959839,
-0.23908133804798126,
-0.3092370331287384,
0.4660756587982178,
0.17063148319721222,
0.5637023448944092,
0.200699582695961,
-0.11337511241436005,
0.17076480388641357,
-0.020647108554840088,
-0.5945343971252441,
-0.8312633037567139,
0.2998903691768646,
-0.7705150842666626,
-0.6313355565071106,
-0.43517306447029114,
-0.38820451498031616,
-0.28957173228263855,
0.13680541515350342,
-0.0580630749464035,
0.8412445783615112,
-0.40756919980049133,
-0.07899101823568344,
0.8665902018547058,
-0.41193458437919617,
0.09157241135835648,
0.6007851958274841,
-0.6566265821456909,
-0.022103838622570038,
0.9605851769447327,
0.06613261997699738,
0.253202885389328,
0.5393916964530945,
0.42563751339912415,
-0.3852657079696655,
-0.7286622524261475,
-0.18574102222919464,
0.5288072824478149,
-0.9890668988227844,
-0.0014116426464170218,
-0.6695333123207092,
-0.2518242299556732,
-0.4873707592487335,
0.008237486705183983,
-0.09971064329147339,
-0.297108918428421,
-0.2987208664417267,
-0.17159685492515564,
0.37722575664520264,
1.0316110849380493,
-0.3250134587287903,
0.38455840945243835,
-0.7739347219467163,
0.307462602853775,
0.2275277078151703,
0.20531132817268372,
-0.1240013837814331,
-0.6422841548919678,
-0.21246224641799927,
0.039166223257780075,
-0.08854597806930542,
-1.0497883558273315,
0.1753077358007431,
-0.006523722317069769,
0.8430872559547424,
0.5427910685539246,
0.05170348659157753,
0.42516642808914185,
-0.3868972957134247,
0.8844001293182373,
0.04108639433979988,
-0.8837409615516663,
0.44801366329193115,
-0.3597635328769684,
0.005628878250718117,
-0.08341751247644424,
0.2773340940475464,
-0.4220063090324402,
-0.3326476514339447,
-0.8364128470420837,
-0.8535335063934326,
0.4806414246559143,
0.059791333973407745,
-0.022032862529158592,
0.17907357215881348,
0.6055738925933838,
0.143350288271904,
-0.026842279359698296,
-0.6574309468269348,
-0.25984740257263184,
-0.14936786890029907,
0.10373318195343018,
-0.1163104772567749,
-0.6685699224472046,
-0.4624260663986206,
-0.10153672099113464,
0.6057341694831848,
-0.26866140961647034,
0.3255823254585266,
0.0782889574766159,
-0.39609241485595703,
0.052340611815452576,
0.38260695338249207,
0.44026467204093933,
0.8713563680648804,
-0.2384645640850067,
0.5251153111457825,
0.10679168254137039,
-0.29586946964263916,
-0.05591244250535965,
0.1638348251581192,
-0.018196308985352516,
-0.035372309386730194,
0.8698646426200867,
0.7455194592475891,
0.3175235986709595,
-0.47803041338920593,
0.474118173122406,
0.05394122004508972,
0.2023296356201172,
-0.2763386368751526,
-0.14771300554275513,
0.20295049250125885,
0.4638136923313141,
0.4474349617958069,
-0.03592929616570473,
-0.11670880019664764,
-0.7845353484153748,
0.3059346675872803,
0.22028905153274536,
-0.20570267736911774,
-0.671599805355072,
0.4398745596408844,
-0.06785324215888977,
0.24935638904571533,
0.48349297046661377,
-0.31936413049697876,
-0.7523260116577148,
0.4611203074455261,
0.6258329153060913,
0.41794919967651367,
-0.05109889432787895,
0.3654716908931732,
0.2630929946899414,
0.4536619782447815,
0.4490448534488678,
0.1851721704006195,
0.049291450530290604,
-0.8614673018455505,
-0.6774325966835022,
-0.6908544898033142,
-0.2759183347225189,
0.13377350568771362,
-0.4139823913574219,
0.027808992192149162,
-0.2421475350856781,
0.07897990942001343,
-0.10101869702339172,
-0.11618095636367798,
-0.470080703496933,
0.09804077446460724,
0.24684160947799683,
0.8147584795951843,
-1.0939387083053589,
0.5937970876693726,
0.5619668364524841,
-0.33860424160957336,
-0.6576383709907532,
0.14177381992340088,
0.3341704308986664,
-1.2949212789535522,
0.8927589654922485,
-0.0852106437087059,
-0.15053251385688782,
-0.12087920308113098,
-0.7332208156585693,
-0.8917132616043091,
1.0925877094268799,
0.572827160358429,
-0.38779035210609436,
-0.047500401735305786,
0.19428181648254395,
0.28720468282699585,
-0.5393199920654297,
0.1639764904975891,
0.6063132882118225,
0.43779659271240234,
0.5502581596374512,
-0.5047698020935059,
0.21595129370689392,
-0.07979021221399307,
-0.3565567433834076,
-0.12239755690097809,
-0.40898624062538147,
0.7953675389289856,
-0.5159307718276978,
-0.39076951146125793,
-0.415682852268219,
0.8368669748306274,
0.2164342850446701,
0.31645119190216064,
0.40178579092025757,
0.40672767162323,
1.0845884084701538,
-0.2242419272661209,
0.9988579154014587,
-0.39154547452926636,
0.2704807221889496,
1.003046989440918,
-0.15334370732307434,
0.5285606980323792,
0.33535391092300415,
-0.27363961935043335,
0.764744222164154,
0.6989389061927795,
0.133967325091362,
0.35655802488327026,
0.36295875906944275,
-0.4148904085159302,
-0.36625707149505615,
-0.28992849588394165,
-0.2835240364074707,
0.36161166429519653,
0.7537717223167419,
-0.25232627987861633,
-0.5454310774803162,
-0.19447633624076843,
0.3737563192844391,
-0.14468301832675934,
-0.2430281788110733,
0.6446686387062073,
0.058951880782842636,
-0.33779945969581604,
0.42703625559806824,
-0.046225689351558685,
0.13447843492031097,
-0.5169991254806519,
-0.2251817137002945,
-0.1476375162601471,
-0.07597023248672485,
-0.3149489164352417,
-0.8686532974243164,
0.315091073513031,
0.04767244681715965,
-0.3290095031261444,
-0.151285320520401,
0.6741241812705994,
-0.31491515040397644,
-0.45751890540122986,
0.3087339699268341,
0.7272818088531494,
0.29491740465164185,
0.14191406965255737,
-0.5191168189048767,
0.30289581418037415,
0.015603650361299515,
-0.27261367440223694,
0.03254855051636696,
0.9590268135070801,
-0.16303592920303345,
0.6680012941360474,
0.7586511969566345,
0.2863253057003021,
0.14254675805568695,
0.1634940654039383,
1.0851479768753052,
-0.4957513213157654,
-0.3893252909183502,
-0.9870852828025818,
0.6013278961181641,
-0.028750037774443626,
0.35724663734436035,
0.5388211607933044,
0.540972888469696,
0.2774110436439514,
0.438469260931015,
0.877510130405426,
-0.017308060079813004,
0.4823506772518158,
-1.0157665014266968,
0.6333628296852112,
-0.4176376461982727,
0.6417019963264465,
0.1406298130750656,
-0.5793658494949341,
-0.12754516303539276,
0.21410922706127167,
-0.47748902440071106,
-0.187513068318367,
0.7407656908035278,
0.5616064667701721,
0.04117930680513382,
-0.08344388008117676,
0.19923840463161469,
0.8061543703079224,
0.4830349087715149,
0.3944224417209625,
1.0502268075942993,
-0.017203232273459435,
0.3883117735385895,
0.12146759033203125,
-0.5349166989326477,
-0.10359551757574081,
-1.268175482749939,
-0.890393078327179,
-0.5591315627098083,
-0.4210621118545532,
-0.6809081435203552,
0.07790245115756989,
0.7546828389167786,
0.26239562034606934,
-0.5531120300292969,
0.1698007434606552,
0.33376428484916687,
0.34625834226608276,
0.05291470140218735,
-0.20244982838630676,
0.6105482578277588,
-0.37351420521736145,
-0.23795467615127563,
0.4516238272190094,
0.4263512194156647,
0.19981364905834198,
-0.34213435649871826,
-0.05491773784160614,
0.004498529713600874,
0.11274410039186478,
0.6607866287231445,
0.31599387526512146,
-0.6992624402046204,
-0.2894573211669922,
-0.1379242241382599,
0.20684808492660522,
0.12765178084373474,
1.0421082973480225,
-0.9275954365730286,
0.5232478976249695,
0.27955490350723267,
0.5669713616371155,
0.49135154485702515,
-0.33886614441871643,
0.6442530751228333,
-0.8027148246765137,
0.02479519508779049,
-0.027521686628460884,
0.6600632667541504,
0.4101760685443878,
-0.17231662571430206,
0.41329875588417053,
0.6767758727073669,
-0.33684512972831726,
-0.9886904358863831,
0.39636364579200745,
-0.9351440668106079,
-0.4387655556201935,
1.1619116067886353,
-0.42829132080078125,
-0.4458451271057129,
-0.4332719147205353,
0.21604980528354645,
0.48780715465545654,
-0.12980963289737701,
0.6910642981529236,
0.6883775591850281,
-0.16689108312129974,
-0.14227913320064545,
-0.47724077105522156,
0.3705942928791046,
-0.19650012254714966,
-0.7455675005912781,
0.3335936963558197,
0.4336875081062317,
0.5521011352539062,
0.31946855783462524,
0.7499752640724182,
-0.36116424202919006,
-0.12224915623664856,
0.06365585327148438,
-0.29543745517730713,
-0.2075130194425583,
-0.31615203619003296,
-0.17391927540302277,
0.18908900022506714,
0.09376241266727448,
0.22999873757362366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03622v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03622v2
|
Mind's Eye of LLMs: Visualization-of-Thought Elicits Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T17:45:08 | 2024-05-24T04:07:44 |
Wenshan Wu, Shaoguang Mao, Yadong Zhang, Yan Xia, Li Dong, Lei Cui, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive performance in
language comprehension and various reasoning tasks. However, their abilities in
spatial reasoning, a crucial aspect of human cognition, remain relatively
unexplored. Human possess a remarkable ability to create mental images of
unseen objects and actions through a process known as the Mind's Eye, enabling
the imagination of the unseen world. Inspired by this cognitive capacity, we
propose Visualization-of-Thought (VoT) prompting. VoT aims to elicit spatial
reasoning of LLMs by visualizing their reasoning traces, thereby guiding
subsequent reasoning steps. We employed VoT for multi-hop spatial reasoning
tasks, including natural language navigation, visual navigation, and visual
tiling in 2D grid worlds. Experimental results demonstrated that VoT
significantly enhances the spatial reasoning abilities of LLMs. Notably, VoT
outperformed existing multimodal large language models (MLLMs) in these tasks.
While VoT works surprisingly well on LLMs, the ability to generate mental
images to facilitate spatial reasoning resembles the mind's eye process,
suggesting its potential viability in MLLMs.
|
[
-0.6024096012115479,
-0.8994846343994141,
1.2251015901565552,
0.1563713103532791,
-0.37192514538764954,
-0.1889047920703888,
-0.013653295114636421,
-0.21901008486747742,
0.15273992717266083,
0.5396639704704285,
-0.6818597912788391,
-0.5442356467247009,
-0.23656107485294342,
0.06259787827730179,
-0.1548478603363037,
0.40746182203292847,
0.004240396898239851,
-0.03606826812028885,
-0.28687193989753723,
0.27831506729125977,
-0.8278839588165283,
-0.2946532964706421,
-0.5802605152130127,
-0.2933787703514099,
0.7910417914390564,
0.2017475664615631,
0.5191815495491028,
0.4952070116996765,
0.4820241332054138,
0.32711267471313477,
0.06706809252500534,
0.4629628360271454,
-0.3517823815345764,
0.12259450554847717,
-0.279295414686203,
-0.7052127122879028,
-0.4449978470802307,
-0.15740130841732025,
0.5092716813087463,
0.5389998555183411,
-0.052723757922649384,
-0.13298402726650238,
0.0009450333309359848,
1.0389806032180786,
-0.39092493057250977,
0.2298373430967331,
-0.6927416324615479,
0.16331225633621216,
0.03727760165929794,
-0.48407354950904846,
-0.31226664781570435,
-0.34654897451400757,
0.46424660086631775,
-0.8255475163459778,
-0.15792381763458252,
0.42098185420036316,
0.4613443613052368,
0.5599064230918884,
-0.34443938732147217,
0.055241603404283524,
-0.5569392442703247,
0.494132399559021,
-0.1914672553539276,
0.6064593195915222,
0.32181501388549805,
0.5009057521820068,
-0.19689875841140747,
-0.38144105672836304,
-0.6795568466186523,
-0.14341004192829132,
0.1766120046377182,
0.4611813426017761,
-0.28794756531715393,
-0.035608552396297455,
0.6233157515525818,
-0.1298997700214386,
-0.659354567527771,
-0.41335272789001465,
-0.36466124653816223,
0.11111924052238464,
0.2797125577926636,
0.20819994807243347,
0.5489951372146606,
-0.12387489527463913,
-0.7739711403846741,
-0.08958550542593002,
-0.8204543590545654,
-0.04999195784330368,
-0.2118169516324997,
0.05764550715684891,
0.023298164829611778,
0.7250745892524719,
-0.10974279791116714,
0.8552849888801575,
-0.1913243681192398,
0.1168021559715271,
-0.23542998731136322,
-0.16238120198249817,
-0.3366672098636627,
-0.12107885628938675,
0.41073712706565857,
0.776584267616272,
0.6082156896591187,
-0.09013840556144714,
-0.16850784420967102,
0.3154641389846802,
0.40372464060783386,
-0.3460400700569153,
-0.40482261776924133,
0.22558872401714325,
-0.2866930663585663,
0.07320240139961243,
-0.013465880416333675,
-0.7728686332702637,
-0.6262941956520081,
-0.44814592599868774,
0.3023916780948639,
-0.6936147809028625,
-0.34784168004989624,
0.4697316884994507,
-0.44802069664001465,
0.15990175306797028,
0.7641764879226685,
-0.6584871411323547,
-0.16254983842372894,
0.526513934135437,
0.6772723197937012,
-0.07956431061029434,
-0.7243831753730774,
-0.15563927590847015,
0.43193376064300537,
-0.601847767829895,
1.3865221738815308,
-0.5865159034729004,
-0.3987996280193329,
-0.15117700397968292,
-0.3073952794075012,
-0.03088769130408764,
-0.48182547092437744,
0.25975844264030457,
-0.4895629286766052,
-0.07821578532457352,
-1.001896619796753,
-0.34885168075561523,
-0.2705715298652649,
0.6179388165473938,
-0.4521227777004242,
0.9079784750938416,
-0.16317005455493927,
-0.6894113421440125,
0.6641944050788879,
-0.8639246225357056,
-0.014547205530107021,
0.5085023045539856,
-0.5236814022064209,
0.07684580236673355,
0.11517034471035004,
0.6182432174682617,
0.38431137800216675,
0.05277401953935623,
-0.09212690591812134,
-0.23830820620059967,
-0.4551974833011627,
0.41792818903923035,
-0.2644486129283905,
0.6742914915084839,
0.09496230632066727,
-0.28268560767173767,
0.20200368762016296,
-0.2705993056297302,
0.18378406763076782,
0.4052366316318512,
-0.197799414396286,
-0.5100327134132385,
0.1050587147474289,
-0.3700380325317383,
0.07787692546844482,
0.12849318981170654,
-0.3640645444393158,
0.5135135054588318,
-0.3395976126194,
0.30769047141075134,
0.7117858529090881,
0.02598433941602707,
0.506464421749115,
-0.12313245236873627,
0.5034688711166382,
0.1597617119550705,
0.07544072717428207,
-0.20549488067626953,
-0.806177020072937,
-0.8726024627685547,
-0.37875625491142273,
-0.3788965046405792,
0.7480248212814331,
-1.3250293731689453,
0.15320557355880737,
-0.3888208568096161,
-0.3985767662525177,
-0.23494690656661987,
-0.19571086764335632,
0.16082367300987244,
0.337047815322876,
0.2243291437625885,
0.24549709260463715,
-0.5808692574501038,
-0.7611865401268005,
-0.3384292423725128,
-0.12385597825050354,
0.0707307681441307,
0.4667363464832306,
0.6629106998443604,
-0.4766351580619812,
0.8251268863677979,
-0.6691725850105286,
-0.16773469746112823,
-0.38603147864341736,
-0.08835028111934662,
0.03837225213646889,
0.014695079997181892,
0.3870542645454407,
-0.5651913285255432,
-0.312466025352478,
0.33095037937164307,
-0.9039771556854248,
-0.12341534346342087,
-0.13477998971939087,
-0.6034418940544128,
-0.08582080900669098,
0.6195169687271118,
-0.8663947582244873,
0.8254802823066711,
0.11606847494840622,
-0.5744199156761169,
0.5905866026878357,
-0.4172336161136627,
0.224999338388443,
-0.6034113764762878,
-0.19146589934825897,
-0.1183626726269722,
-0.019253525882959366,
-0.4331618845462799,
-0.060405079275369644,
0.0661076158285141,
-0.26447904109954834,
-0.3646315038204193,
0.7736690044403076,
-0.6208385825157166,
-0.25824299454689026,
-0.2968483865261078,
0.549235463142395,
0.10850944370031357,
0.5572605133056641,
0.32617098093032837,
0.8430088758468628,
0.8516638875007629,
-0.5683502554893494,
0.4662283658981323,
0.224381223320961,
-0.531830906867981,
0.6432265639305115,
-0.3990892469882965,
0.17068155109882355,
-0.3277214765548706,
0.2705920338630676,
-1.018795371055603,
-0.0017553524812683463,
0.16789527237415314,
-0.1415102779865265,
-0.18938696384429932,
0.05003054812550545,
-0.40460941195487976,
-0.5986778736114502,
-0.1640414446592331,
0.3942328691482544,
0.2046453356742859,
-0.8082767128944397,
0.7353399395942688,
0.20975430309772491,
0.04193092882633209,
-0.35007816553115845,
-0.7480928897857666,
0.28429776430130005,
-0.25309017300605774,
-0.5098497867584229,
-0.10446273535490036,
0.011069810949265957,
-0.4175814390182495,
-0.06895530968904495,
0.14847424626350403,
0.2343125343322754,
-0.2635258436203003,
0.22938503324985504,
0.5965649485588074,
-0.07062720507383347,
0.05817565694451332,
-0.21227632462978363,
-0.18759888410568237,
0.25909897685050964,
-0.607661783695221,
0.2868223488330841,
-0.4072396755218506,
-0.7595852017402649,
-0.37395432591438293,
0.3974526822566986,
0.6728178858757019,
-0.2605758309364319,
0.1536613255739212,
0.2979889214038849,
-0.32604822516441345,
-0.4527650773525238,
-0.6318799257278442,
-0.2218114286661148,
-0.4450022280216217,
0.4053446352481842,
-0.5749348402023315,
-0.755402684211731,
0.3515806496143341,
-0.2904154360294342,
-0.17014075815677643,
-0.17984478175640106,
0.5763829946517944,
-0.525242805480957,
1.004273533821106,
0.42674997448921204,
0.13940644264221191,
0.5338780283927917,
-0.39068856835365295,
0.4846317172050476,
-1.0341482162475586,
-0.3245765268802643,
-0.001597047783434391,
-0.3577483892440796,
-0.1888296753168106,
-0.9790394902229309,
0.7206427454948425,
-0.09510095417499542,
-0.03490597754716873,
0.01776210404932499,
-0.6913403868675232,
0.8917902708053589,
0.6237232089042664,
0.307597815990448,
0.09573743492364883,
0.1977134644985199,
-0.5710654258728027,
-0.23111101984977722,
-0.8634521961212158,
-0.5063005685806274,
0.738497793674469,
0.11595823615789413,
0.6068671941757202,
-0.06524216383695602,
0.5607914924621582,
0.06031014770269394,
0.13623295724391937,
-0.7656779289245605,
1.043810248374939,
0.1453876942396164,
-0.2833946645259857,
-0.5019611120223999,
-0.08643940091133118,
-0.9850028157234192,
0.5994425415992737,
-0.2215932011604309,
-0.9183802008628845,
0.07135508954524994,
0.2728692889213562,
-0.41052183508872986,
0.5397976040840149,
-0.802094042301178,
0.6011473536491394,
-0.48131754994392395,
-0.34705790877342224,
-0.3674548864364624,
-0.06440393626689911,
0.24928618967533112,
0.3246880769729614,
0.009131336584687233,
0.23506446182727814,
-0.052679501473903656,
0.29462045431137085,
-0.04228818416595459,
0.7975596785545349,
-0.3031984567642212,
-0.15318544209003448,
0.42861318588256836,
0.2781997323036194,
0.5992122292518616,
-0.09671103209257126,
0.512143075466156,
0.16103626787662506,
-0.405112624168396,
-0.18846987187862396,
-0.8363032937049866,
0.6738712191581726,
-0.32360967993736267,
-0.8569652438163757,
-0.28729215264320374,
-0.7164168953895569,
-0.3267744481563568,
0.2534007430076599,
0.19977952539920807,
0.10923503339290619,
-0.0958147719502449,
-0.15172834694385529,
0.8475085496902466,
-0.3147524893283844,
0.15552188456058502,
0.05033817142248154,
-0.8547040820121765,
-0.32802632451057434,
0.9360600709915161,
-0.008796106092631817,
-0.02928178198635578,
0.447836309671402,
0.16005675494670868,
-0.504520058631897,
-0.49212172627449036,
-0.4440687298774719,
0.4007715880870819,
-0.7844973206520081,
0.05734596028923988,
-0.5322073101997375,
-0.07749917358160019,
0.13063615560531616,
-0.44949230551719666,
-0.0828476995229721,
-0.10020624101161957,
0.1268191784620285,
-0.2330588400363922,
0.23550665378570557,
0.9755005836486816,
0.21088175475597382,
-0.10111641138792038,
-0.5134791135787964,
0.4341600835323334,
0.842562735080719,
0.3434980809688568,
0.30754581093788147,
-0.04285268113017082,
-0.14823220670223236,
0.16995611786842346,
-0.11091417819261551,
-0.7395740747451782,
0.24876786768436432,
-0.43243998289108276,
0.525973379611969,
0.5044649243354797,
-0.5443397164344788,
0.957470715045929,
-0.8097485899925232,
0.7396970987319946,
0.2837561070919037,
-0.5906237959861755,
0.9241024851799011,
-0.7225349545478821,
0.7753318548202515,
-0.10641667991876602,
-0.16416388750076294,
-0.4582834243774414,
-0.4659532308578491,
-0.1428494155406952,
-0.6478502154350281,
0.29709652066230774,
0.05332273244857788,
-0.296507865190506,
-0.25691893696784973,
0.08779007196426392,
-0.018636025488376617,
-0.061653733253479004,
-0.6852087378501892,
0.1346455216407776,
-0.3655499517917633,
0.2860068678855896,
0.14930593967437744,
-0.15727022290229797,
-0.25712907314300537,
-0.39349502325057983,
0.26403090357780457,
-0.17490050196647644,
0.5804713368415833,
0.5188689231872559,
0.052299998700618744,
-0.145083487033844,
0.230927512049675,
0.68564772605896,
0.7956160306930542,
0.07208262383937836,
0.2917719781398773,
0.344028502702713,
-0.3498605787754059,
-0.1601898968219757,
-0.46485164761543274,
-0.1923297643661499,
-0.3061162531375885,
0.2161707878112793,
1.0367788076400757,
0.19764816761016846,
-0.756127119064331,
0.487143874168396,
-0.12154776602983475,
-0.371726393699646,
-0.21100836992263794,
0.116990827023983,
0.46289801597595215,
0.8234673142433167,
0.3073903024196625,
0.1701250672340393,
0.07953925430774689,
-0.19252753257751465,
-0.204473614692688,
0.6891486048698425,
-0.15987831354141235,
-0.2148822546005249,
0.7370842695236206,
0.07562699168920517,
-0.1484971046447754,
0.6872707009315491,
-0.06968998163938522,
-0.6348124742507935,
0.46026745438575745,
0.5651328563690186,
0.9703723788261414,
0.2774049639701843,
0.04350326582789421,
0.26819390058517456,
0.4919796288013458,
0.014344293624162674,
0.7256952524185181,
-0.2568460702896118,
-0.8590582609176636,
-0.39826875925064087,
-0.28048446774482727,
-0.2574428915977478,
0.09065525233745575,
-0.29835477471351624,
0.014244943857192993,
-0.40659791231155396,
-0.37775951623916626,
-0.37261533737182617,
-0.47428667545318604,
-0.8262414336204529,
0.24728578329086304,
0.6689851880073547,
0.9092523455619812,
-0.6628299951553345,
0.7808719873428345,
1.025087833404541,
-0.041567932814359665,
-0.6062518358230591,
0.011254888027906418,
-0.037104278802871704,
-0.9402631521224976,
0.9575435519218445,
0.11265513300895691,
-0.6670868396759033,
-0.12110680341720581,
-0.6618480086326599,
-0.7476524114608765,
1.112053632736206,
0.33728697896003723,
-0.673034131526947,
0.042383719235658646,
0.14617833495140076,
0.5459088683128357,
-0.43803149461746216,
-0.06406550854444504,
0.375491201877594,
0.709125280380249,
-0.060271624475717545,
-0.5342079401016235,
0.07612492144107819,
-0.19927942752838135,
0.34941986203193665,
0.1393864005804062,
-0.6077561378479004,
0.6327789425849915,
-0.8023912906646729,
-0.34040775895118713,
-0.25720611214637756,
0.6303226947784424,
0.7914426326751709,
0.19838254153728485,
0.7048196196556091,
0.724378764629364,
0.8383935689926147,
-0.14332368969917297,
1.077088475227356,
-0.00022587476996704936,
-0.21351097524166107,
0.7976692914962769,
-0.31380340456962585,
0.8913320899009705,
0.8152172565460205,
-0.2292276918888092,
0.46021896600723267,
0.23380620777606964,
0.1425306797027588,
0.5176858305931091,
-0.03916219249367714,
-0.12093162536621094,
-0.3971109688282013,
0.08496855944395065,
-0.20207245647907257,
0.3886394798755646,
0.5041802525520325,
0.1505971997976303,
-0.0626954510807991,
0.075359046459198,
-0.42662596702575684,
0.06261954456567764,
-0.42097118496894836,
0.5934925079345703,
0.14743587374687195,
-0.760887861251831,
0.4258132874965668,
-0.8202266693115234,
0.4612758457660675,
-0.4381227195262909,
-0.3752487599849701,
-0.14580149948596954,
0.024273710325360298,
0.009326103143393993,
-1.1015609502792358,
0.04938826337456703,
-0.08904000371694565,
-0.20502969622612,
-0.5822324752807617,
0.7870848178863525,
-0.4589756429195404,
-0.4496387541294098,
0.4611915349960327,
0.8802450895309448,
0.40206632018089294,
-0.3168150782585144,
-0.6135541796684265,
0.014538667164742947,
0.13100799918174744,
-0.31636935472488403,
0.276366263628006,
0.9864909648895264,
-0.2688017785549164,
1.2266796827316284,
0.709000289440155,
0.4532720148563385,
0.09092292934656143,
0.43796807527542114,
0.8504964113235474,
-0.9376118183135986,
-0.6343218684196472,
-0.8889807462692261,
0.5310839414596558,
-0.050505246967077255,
-0.09953384846448898,
0.6894174218177795,
0.39916667342185974,
0.7041755318641663,
-0.47580328583717346,
0.8654505014419556,
0.314300537109375,
0.3860796391963959,
-0.6204714179039001,
0.7299478054046631,
-0.6981703042984009,
0.09463468194007874,
-0.21824806928634644,
-0.8758004307746887,
-0.1738523244857788,
0.7987751364707947,
-0.6220061182975769,
-0.009220506995916367,
1.0978496074676514,
0.6979984045028687,
0.011095425114035606,
0.04473619908094406,
0.6745440363883972,
0.13948504626750946,
0.07152703404426575,
0.6500191688537598,
1.2722092866897583,
0.04834599792957306,
0.38438376784324646,
-0.06065548583865166,
-0.29597043991088867,
-0.03745225444436073,
-0.8311550617218018,
-1.096325397491455,
-0.6573244333267212,
-0.009975820779800415,
0.12245717644691467,
-0.1592218428850174,
0.5772729516029358,
0.5733107924461365,
-0.29195085167884827,
-0.22766248881816864,
-0.2968226969242096,
-0.03923018276691437,
-0.2951297461986542,
-0.23532050848007202,
0.3238459825515747,
-0.17717675864696503,
-0.48016035556793213,
0.6021122932434082,
0.9674738049507141,
0.278455913066864,
-0.4205615222454071,
-0.02047155052423477,
-0.17369535565376282,
0.09403431415557861,
0.8674635291099548,
-0.06455142050981522,
-1.196639060974121,
-0.2709949314594269,
0.1564788818359375,
-0.08505205810070038,
0.06356938928365707,
0.9687467813491821,
-0.855452835559845,
0.6622623205184937,
0.4550884962081909,
0.4156219959259033,
0.39375773072242737,
-0.07917328178882599,
0.5044229030609131,
-0.2843067944049835,
0.3070237338542938,
0.14517742395401,
0.6894087195396423,
0.26648327708244324,
-0.4593715965747833,
0.36213651299476624,
0.08121584355831146,
-0.5516265630722046,
-0.5235124230384827,
0.34093087911605835,
-1.1400591135025024,
-0.293538898229599,
1.0689096450805664,
0.0880565196275711,
-0.61342453956604,
-0.07415837794542313,
-0.9097556471824646,
-0.09483937174081802,
-0.32820016145706177,
0.9009770750999451,
0.805599570274353,
-0.40696981549263,
-0.41240280866622925,
-0.6134764552116394,
0.4234142601490021,
0.4829627573490143,
-1.0172549486160278,
0.334248811006546,
0.5174053311347961,
-0.17049068212509155,
0.12738509476184845,
0.7138333320617676,
0.08283865451812744,
0.5184512734413147,
0.19716644287109375,
0.11446313560009003,
-0.03885798156261444,
-0.463922381401062,
0.03734869137406349,
-0.12144889682531357,
-0.02391779236495495,
-0.12157788127660751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03608v1
|
Sailor: Open Language Models for South-East Asia
| 2024-04-04T17:31:32 | 2024-04-04T17:31:32 |
Longxu Dou, Qian Liu, Guangtao Zeng, Jia Guo, Jiahui Zhou, Wei Lu, Min Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Sailor, a family of open language models ranging from 0.5B to 7B
parameters, tailored for South-East Asian (SEA) languages. These models are
continually pre-trained from Qwen1.5, a great language model for multilingual
use cases. From Qwen1.5, Sailor models accept 200B to 400B tokens, primarily
covering the languages of English, Chinese, Vietnamese, Thai, Indonesian,
Malay, and Lao. The training leverages several techniques, including BPE
dropout for improving the model robustness, aggressive data cleaning and
deduplication, and small proxy models to optimize data mixture. Experimental
results on four typical tasks indicate that Sailor models demonstrate strong
performance across different benchmarks, including commonsense reasoning,
question answering, reading comprehension and examination. Embracing the
open-source spirit, we share our insights through this report to spark a wider
interest in developing large language models for multilingual use cases.
|
[
-0.43805474042892456,
-0.33212390542030334,
0.5796550512313843,
0.4835635721683502,
-0.4641169309616089,
-0.21835914254188538,
-0.3984660506248474,
-0.5987285375595093,
0.06718026846647263,
0.9095374345779419,
-0.3043636083602905,
-0.600176215171814,
-0.28075531125068665,
0.02390434220433235,
-0.007005804218351841,
0.8903270363807678,
0.02474512718617916,
0.13109220564365387,
0.327014297246933,
-0.42255863547325134,
-0.4346553385257721,
-0.44743552803993225,
-0.8854990601539612,
0.03067057393491268,
0.4004219174385071,
0.8119728565216064,
0.5624375343322754,
0.6398373246192932,
0.45850661396980286,
0.11496365815401077,
-0.01797359623014927,
-0.02808845229446888,
-0.5565071105957031,
0.39465686678886414,
-0.46747463941574097,
-0.7593116760253906,
-0.7291648387908936,
0.24221071600914001,
0.1930004060268402,
0.4910610616207123,
-0.20452618598937988,
0.7052151560783386,
-0.32135632634162903,
0.6726017594337463,
-0.5550863742828369,
0.5406143069267273,
-0.5452817678451538,
-0.37251999974250793,
-0.6209120154380798,
0.44036009907722473,
-0.37988409399986267,
-0.2902457118034363,
0.20127250254154205,
-0.5959857106208801,
0.1297958940267563,
0.12095244973897934,
0.8863714933395386,
-0.11815584450960159,
-0.6502821445465088,
-0.12038182467222214,
-0.6474049687385559,
0.7926331758499146,
-0.7804637551307678,
0.5792818665504456,
0.7012833952903748,
0.7644219994544983,
0.1497804820537567,
-0.6356056928634644,
-0.4501611292362213,
-0.1723237782716751,
0.06081823632121086,
0.39547979831695557,
0.19450806081295013,
0.12699216604232788,
-0.1881483495235443,
0.39866557717323303,
-0.6315155029296875,
0.05850444361567497,
-0.5351842045783997,
0.4815518260002136,
0.9049542546272278,
0.13249005377292633,
0.21463003754615784,
-0.11641303449869156,
-0.1220284178853035,
0.2067820429801941,
-0.9528490304946899,
-0.14025303721427917,
0.518351674079895,
0.65240478515625,
-0.39409807324409485,
0.6667517423629761,
-0.1073765680193901,
0.6153191328048706,
-0.15719778835773468,
-0.1612817943096161,
-0.34921348094940186,
-0.2741052806377411,
0.050660036504268646,
-0.2013140618801117,
0.4985574185848236,
0.3289300799369812,
0.3936304450035095,
-0.028180785477161407,
-0.21167929470539093,
-0.1493443101644516,
0.16381242871284485,
-0.5723072290420532,
-0.2888427972793579,
0.25697076320648193,
-0.7493516206741333,
-0.18103772401809692,
0.30025631189346313,
-1.0144158601760864,
-0.474621444940567,
-0.21848440170288086,
0.1724661886692047,
0.13045261800289154,
-0.8357455730438232,
0.3307272493839264,
-0.19875694811344147,
0.12783163785934448,
0.010790103115141392,
-0.8179011940956116,
0.08851958811283112,
0.5193948149681091,
0.6909278035163879,
0.13068720698356628,
-0.3860302269458771,
-0.36437633633613586,
0.429759681224823,
-0.3473714590072632,
0.36822274327278137,
-0.5767596364021301,
-0.5116842985153198,
-0.01272035576403141,
0.1785852164030075,
-0.19198115170001984,
-0.5060355067253113,
0.47162458300590515,
-0.3957289159297943,
0.27057546377182007,
-0.042501647025346756,
-0.1656644642353058,
-0.3546246290206909,
-0.03144342079758644,
-0.8058454990386963,
1.2702361345291138,
0.49026572704315186,
-0.564298689365387,
0.2611580193042755,
-0.8574227690696716,
-0.326967716217041,
0.0012535086134448647,
0.31946006417274475,
-0.34364524483680725,
0.46142393350601196,
0.30258044600486755,
0.5598805546760559,
-0.777877926826477,
0.29059407114982605,
-0.49233755469322205,
-0.3297789394855499,
-0.0712440013885498,
-0.05159302055835724,
0.8435240387916565,
0.38784128427505493,
-0.34491032361984253,
0.311358779668808,
-0.8161096572875977,
-0.030198564752936363,
0.2269037663936615,
-0.18115168809890747,
-0.7163703441619873,
-0.11859026551246643,
0.23338356614112854,
0.2952418923377991,
0.17433372139930725,
-0.6893535256385803,
0.13580448925495148,
-0.32032012939453125,
0.49945613741874695,
0.4405204951763153,
-0.01840861514210701,
0.22691282629966736,
-0.20433467626571655,
0.87436443567276,
0.2109043449163437,
0.34436994791030884,
-0.5838566422462463,
-0.582665741443634,
-0.7699970602989197,
-0.612322211265564,
0.056396860629320145,
0.6230447292327881,
-0.6189870238304138,
0.09022010862827301,
0.013158747926354408,
-1.007572054862976,
-1.098382592201233,
-0.003759710816666484,
0.4934590756893158,
0.21635232865810394,
0.3066994547843933,
0.050111137330532074,
-0.8502457737922668,
-0.6780380010604858,
-0.39277184009552,
-0.5883026719093323,
-0.06667033582925797,
0.35083022713661194,
0.42259570956230164,
-0.1750391572713852,
0.7464961409568787,
-0.3142291307449341,
0.0561450719833374,
-0.5438361763954163,
-0.31594064831733704,
0.34430310130119324,
0.33133697509765625,
0.8082027435302734,
-0.7516885995864868,
-0.7536496520042419,
0.41207000613212585,
-0.6945359110832214,
-0.2521398067474365,
0.17424607276916504,
-0.2305890917778015,
0.40936368703842163,
0.8067395687103271,
-0.7578831315040588,
0.43882253766059875,
0.756070077419281,
-0.23561884462833405,
0.9720036387443542,
-0.13856345415115356,
-0.02478042244911194,
-1.3837132453918457,
0.42447978258132935,
-0.011654075235128403,
-0.1890755593776703,
-0.5519264936447144,
0.6329394578933716,
0.20943419635295868,
-0.45983681082725525,
-0.4266537129878998,
1.006018877029419,
-0.6275413036346436,
0.016894813627004623,
-0.22905482351779938,
0.42381948232650757,
-0.14129887521266937,
0.14386656880378723,
0.22984759509563446,
0.6705690026283264,
0.44397422671318054,
-0.5952948927879333,
0.41702449321746826,
0.08368603885173798,
-0.06182806193828583,
0.8651193976402283,
-0.9474829435348511,
0.061786849051713943,
-0.3408609926700592,
-0.0674402192234993,
-0.993165135383606,
-0.1770084649324417,
0.039188824594020844,
-0.2025945782661438,
0.04143500328063965,
-0.5467021465301514,
-0.16676336526870728,
-0.6060337424278259,
-0.2503875494003296,
0.2641550600528717,
0.07762507349252701,
-0.7610436677932739,
0.406244695186615,
0.5013622045516968,
-0.46010318398475647,
-0.5436796545982361,
-0.37931427359580994,
-0.11440689861774445,
-0.499490886926651,
-0.37382712960243225,
-0.11601659655570984,
0.1653137505054474,
-0.2414102852344513,
0.04939577728509903,
0.0010805875062942505,
-0.14385904371738434,
0.06300400197505951,
0.2850695550441742,
0.49381059408187866,
-0.7508167624473572,
-0.09056635946035385,
-0.03557227551937103,
-0.23761796951293945,
-0.21206746995449066,
-0.6048354506492615,
0.5641413927078247,
-0.369770348072052,
-0.24241572618484497,
-0.05345017462968826,
0.21089880168437958,
0.6788976192474365,
-0.7876078486442566,
0.9714999794960022,
0.5878592133522034,
-0.19314128160476685,
0.12561681866645813,
-0.30299001932144165,
0.05136416107416153,
-0.44978010654449463,
0.5303052663803101,
-0.841508150100708,
-0.7618799805641174,
0.7168202996253967,
0.18347856402397156,
0.4000392258167267,
0.22280128300189972,
0.21754249930381775,
0.07121727615594864,
1.0563113689422607,
0.8992065787315369,
-0.378417044878006,
0.2323254942893982,
0.04631570726633072,
0.2992464303970337,
-0.6226247549057007,
0.09284011274576187,
-0.8179740905761719,
0.09700659662485123,
-0.7840230464935303,
-0.3519839644432068,
0.32912036776542664,
0.45185387134552,
-0.5882578492164612,
0.39841124415397644,
0.06755869090557098,
0.5599914193153381,
0.5561293363571167,
-0.22547867894172668,
0.38091257214546204,
-0.4364384412765503,
-0.05070774257183075,
-0.08791381865739822,
-0.7446678876876831,
-0.7409244775772095,
1.4253190755844116,
0.24008339643478394,
0.7666468024253845,
0.2908788323402405,
0.5114929676055908,
-0.34436333179473877,
0.6079671382904053,
-0.4255378544330597,
0.5667440891265869,
-0.2759912610054016,
-0.9797557592391968,
-0.3348204493522644,
-0.3390457332134247,
-1.0562329292297363,
0.49347221851348877,
0.14166314899921417,
-0.4655604958534241,
-0.4462202191352844,
0.02689492516219616,
0.24763073027133942,
0.40689903497695923,
-0.5331992506980896,
1.1579194068908691,
-0.14197207987308502,
-0.02437088079750538,
-0.3198835551738739,
-0.7502501010894775,
0.6391767859458923,
0.03353364020586014,
0.12605993449687958,
-0.11443101614713669,
-0.22799693048000336,
0.17235854268074036,
-0.1822713315486908,
0.7352696061134338,
-0.36603763699531555,
-0.036533173173666,
0.2665400207042694,
-0.03684410825371742,
0.08000236004590988,
0.3615688979625702,
-0.22523917257785797,
0.2672085165977478,
0.09917370975017548,
-0.8888434767723083,
-0.3400920033454895,
0.37578916549682617,
-0.6975244879722595,
-0.3583914041519165,
-0.22552774846553802,
-0.19972896575927734,
-0.2657013237476349,
0.46975451707839966,
0.20782487094402313,
0.03915766626596451,
-0.23565171658992767,
-0.03846569359302521,
0.2891135513782501,
-0.336664617061615,
0.3564234972000122,
1.003280520439148,
-0.8950676321983337,
-0.7393683791160583,
0.8299962282180786,
-0.2456064075231552,
0.3822984993457794,
0.15171784162521362,
0.07074351608753204,
-0.3251431882381439,
-0.2410532832145691,
-0.8867626190185547,
0.818746030330658,
-0.2331867516040802,
0.14300833642482758,
-0.15905427932739258,
-0.0036169220693409443,
-0.28798872232437134,
-0.054556071758270264,
-0.6648104786872864,
-0.5789624452590942,
0.030394481495022774,
-0.14418789744377136,
0.017541272565722466,
0.9618967771530151,
0.1998654305934906,
0.7368506193161011,
-0.9563364386558533,
0.22791160643100739,
-0.06213913485407829,
0.6297106146812439,
0.06254487484693527,
-0.2904844582080841,
-0.5621062517166138,
0.01647733524441719,
-0.07230847328901291,
-0.8860165476799011,
0.220468208193779,
0.27451440691947937,
0.7589663863182068,
0.6452959775924683,
-0.0551714152097702,
0.7304322719573975,
-0.16653750836849213,
0.9630445241928101,
-0.1466379314661026,
-0.9100755453109741,
0.6592367887496948,
-0.7153037786483765,
0.3687818944454193,
0.4284287989139557,
0.7019100785255432,
-1.0584869384765625,
-0.664157509803772,
-0.4691932797431946,
-0.799679696559906,
0.5250449776649475,
-0.3529455065727234,
-0.20448841154575348,
0.031703200191259384,
0.5605397820472717,
0.40775883197784424,
0.6128554940223694,
-0.5341414213180542,
-0.20904132723808289,
-0.18589745461940765,
-0.3786996304988861,
-0.5241743922233582,
-0.006007318384945393,
0.442348450422287,
-0.043325360864400864,
0.8626288175582886,
-0.18362995982170105,
-0.10029543936252594,
-0.2711424231529236,
-0.15950480103492737,
-0.08893389254808426,
0.045270927250385284,
0.4394155740737915,
0.5353958606719971,
0.0117179024964571,
-0.06671713292598724,
-0.28844472765922546,
-0.7968236207962036,
0.13309143483638763,
0.08737809211015701,
-0.2755654454231262,
0.030614981427788734,
0.1820521503686905,
0.7374905943870544,
0.0712704285979271,
-0.8887206315994263,
0.11093885451555252,
-0.1505052149295807,
0.33537557721138,
-0.08149667829275131,
-0.09562961757183075,
0.3047012686729431,
0.12887854874134064,
0.010132668539881706,
-0.27082008123397827,
-0.43696051836013794,
-0.5494804382324219,
-0.2704419493675232,
0.07610532641410828,
-0.37544748187065125,
-0.6620900630950928,
1.0930657386779785,
0.3122655153274536,
0.10132966935634613,
0.7930284142494202,
-0.21314860880374908,
-0.5652964115142822,
0.3097013831138611,
0.7651693820953369,
0.7971951365470886,
-0.6891709566116333,
0.47397130727767944,
0.5031884908676147,
0.5413954257965088,
-0.24320180714130402,
0.9266602993011475,
0.25226619839668274,
-0.3048996329307556,
-0.26132792234420776,
-0.45093420147895813,
-0.6043136715888977,
0.27505290508270264,
-0.7301613688468933,
0.4094336926937103,
-0.37440189719200134,
-0.22513063251972198,
-0.3374125063419342,
0.14035125076770782,
-0.523622989654541,
-0.016510702669620514,
-0.33043381571769714,
1.048227310180664,
-1.0006886720657349,
0.685015082359314,
1.2596837282180786,
-0.7688839435577393,
-0.7107626795768738,
-0.23833496868610382,
0.0020376271568238735,
-0.4436336159706116,
0.31818196177482605,
0.33515745401382446,
0.16533149778842926,
-0.012859156355261803,
-0.26665762066841125,
-0.8941246867179871,
0.6051744222640991,
0.4148672819137573,
-0.2321121096611023,
-0.04103400930762291,
0.33163610100746155,
0.6122308969497681,
-0.4284469485282898,
0.283105731010437,
0.6601534485816956,
0.5949153900146484,
-0.8287642598152161,
-1.2906010150909424,
-0.18309728801250458,
-0.4305782616138458,
0.15033772587776184,
0.4802495241165161,
-1.0111008882522583,
0.9672819375991821,
-0.4033072590827942,
0.16982349753379822,
0.48791229724884033,
0.6564468741416931,
0.5632748603820801,
0.5437955260276794,
0.22725193202495575,
0.2834020256996155,
0.7237843871116638,
-0.013226398266851902,
0.6809435486793518,
-0.4538887143135071,
-0.09026563167572021,
1.1041569709777832,
-0.540317177772522,
1.0605536699295044,
0.17623764276504517,
-0.31663745641708374,
0.45611968636512756,
0.5427066087722778,
0.30567625164985657,
0.08455590158700943,
-0.061115022748708725,
-0.25599077343940735,
0.25300320982933044,
-0.003926288802176714,
-0.16392001509666443,
0.7317302227020264,
0.26636311411857605,
-0.03970690071582794,
0.0746639147400856,
0.27662917971611023,
0.41136759519577026,
0.184474378824234,
-0.47815847396850586,
0.48116350173950195,
0.11483386158943176,
-0.8910595178604126,
0.43688562512397766,
0.35433584451675415,
0.4441920816898346,
-0.571358859539032,
0.22916613519191742,
-0.5491041541099548,
0.33407437801361084,
0.04825804382562637,
-0.5400447249412537,
0.08527953922748566,
0.08914513885974884,
-0.22022344172000885,
0.0924687534570694,
0.7086948156356812,
-0.8024012446403503,
-0.15809202194213867,
0.07679024338722229,
0.7417032718658447,
0.3925005793571472,
-0.43658775091171265,
-0.3392283320426941,
-0.13301318883895874,
-0.2211960107088089,
-0.15539614856243134,
0.14255455136299133,
0.48408105969429016,
-0.4165755808353424,
0.7758211493492126,
0.5924691557884216,
0.4977232813835144,
0.29750749468803406,
-0.03901556879281998,
0.30030500888824463,
-0.9041773676872253,
-0.9728968143463135,
-0.5015703439712524,
0.4346466660499573,
-0.04201687127351761,
-0.6450961232185364,
1.1066601276397705,
0.8882538080215454,
1.04957914352417,
-0.47295433282852173,
1.0455820560455322,
0.21603280305862427,
0.9834191799163818,
-0.17995396256446838,
0.9025481939315796,
-0.5395177602767944,
0.0354599691927433,
-0.24234607815742493,
-1.0617365837097168,
-0.09012412279844284,
0.37829461693763733,
-0.1136019378900528,
0.15474899113178253,
0.4532257318496704,
0.6720390319824219,
-0.19979125261306763,
0.6386198401451111,
0.017380718141794205,
0.016910428181290627,
0.5411811470985413,
0.4844973385334015,
0.7447681427001953,
-0.3236234486103058,
0.4115813970565796,
-0.1773429661989212,
-0.10759817063808441,
-0.33851054310798645,
-0.6863631010055542,
-1.160685420036316,
-0.6322150826454163,
0.04402405023574829,
-0.1342235654592514,
0.12567439675331116,
0.7587692737579346,
0.8900572061538696,
-0.6790920495986938,
-0.777894914150238,
0.1277649998664856,
-0.12011003494262695,
-0.4245406985282898,
-0.20949767529964447,
0.20816479623317719,
-0.26349833607673645,
-0.6778525114059448,
0.559633195400238,
0.2779995799064636,
0.19292783737182617,
-0.49082380533218384,
-0.19981376826763153,
-0.12492232024669647,
0.15159347653388977,
0.7582007646560669,
0.4664090871810913,
-0.3647034764289856,
0.09765221178531647,
0.12887433171272278,
-0.18688258528709412,
-0.3415708541870117,
0.8097021579742432,
-0.4917478859424591,
0.43484053015708923,
0.2246449887752533,
0.5275911688804626,
0.6774278879165649,
0.01422937586903572,
0.8068354725837708,
-0.7050479054450989,
0.48034292459487915,
0.02017633430659771,
0.12083896994590759,
0.23760753870010376,
0.1694076806306839,
0.9020357131958008,
0.20030665397644043,
-0.5412567853927612,
-1.0885401964187622,
0.300514280796051,
-0.5097804665565491,
-0.25179705023765564,
0.7079357504844666,
-0.5177130699157715,
-0.16965875029563904,
-0.3226207494735718,
-0.4894450306892395,
0.16765443980693817,
-0.05187016725540161,
0.5404688119888306,
0.7536143064498901,
0.17632171511650085,
-0.1452363282442093,
-1.000281810760498,
0.15347379446029663,
0.31962552666664124,
-0.9128037095069885,
0.34877443313598633,
0.47784674167633057,
0.1739673912525177,
-0.2928324341773987,
0.5360738039016724,
-0.2514549195766449,
0.48805734515190125,
0.19819419085979462,
-0.023944465443491936,
0.026222236454486847,
-0.5780341625213623,
-0.21003583073616028,
0.0008205163758248091,
0.3594890236854553,
-0.05881153792142868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03605v1
|
Mitigating the Impact of Outlier Channels for Language Model Quantization with Activation Regularization
| 2024-04-04T17:25:30 | 2024-04-04T17:25:30 |
Aniruddha Nrusimha, Mayank Mishra, Naigang Wang, Dan Alistarh, Rameswar Panda, Yoon Kim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We consider the problem of accurate quantization for language models, where
both the weights and activations are uniformly quantized to 4 bits per
parameter, the lowest bitwidth format natively supported by GPU hardware. In
this context, the key challenge is activation quantization: it is known that
language models contain outlier channels whose values on average are orders of
magnitude higher than than other channels, which prevents accurate low-bitwidth
quantization with known techniques. We systematically study this phenomena and
find that these outlier channels emerge early in training, and that they occur
more frequently in layers with residual streams. We then propose a simple
strategy which regularizes a layer's inputs via quantization-aware training
(QAT) and its outputs via activation kurtosis regularization. We show that
regularizing both the inputs and outputs is crucial for preventing a model's
"migrating" the difficulty in input quantization to the weights, which makes
post-training quantization (PTQ) of weights more difficult. When combined with
weight PTQ, we show that our approach can obtain a W4A4 model that performs
competitively to the standard-precision W16A16 baseline.
|
[
-0.36536118388175964,
-0.753513514995575,
0.4885505139827728,
-0.04603126272559166,
-0.3045724928379059,
0.039727821946144104,
-0.17046710848808289,
-0.16971063613891602,
-0.12399162352085114,
0.35588011145591736,
-0.2959996163845062,
-0.24885283410549164,
-0.7304878830909729,
-0.3902624547481537,
-0.4107641577720642,
0.8862298130989075,
0.0827975645661354,
0.05581279471516609,
-0.05345214158296585,
-0.20236153900623322,
-0.3611188530921936,
-0.48301202058792114,
-0.8455988168716431,
-0.3104058504104614,
0.2906363904476166,
0.35748612880706787,
0.8518757820129395,
0.4985562860965729,
0.4777437448501587,
0.2549397051334381,
-0.06707851588726044,
-0.23083361983299255,
-0.3986976742744446,
0.010520639829337597,
0.49076762795448303,
-0.3410836160182953,
-0.4057360291481018,
-0.030070066452026367,
1.038067102432251,
0.9265729188919067,
-0.18195681273937225,
0.13229770958423615,
0.21382850408554077,
0.7414549589157104,
-0.6019081473350525,
0.02862393669784069,
-0.36165651679039,
-0.1271558552980423,
-0.3800525665283203,
-0.17912937700748444,
-0.41283270716667175,
-0.2799246609210968,
-0.13035990297794342,
-0.4390387237071991,
0.0492577962577343,
-0.27739977836608887,
1.0228036642074585,
0.3067064583301544,
-0.42057809233665466,
0.20270594954490662,
-0.9518536925315857,
0.9278771877288818,
-1.060964584350586,
0.6737319231033325,
0.4975832998752594,
0.19591835141181946,
-0.18422624468803406,
-0.7025097608566284,
-0.23981072008609772,
-0.1466558575630188,
0.22588901221752167,
-0.09927765280008316,
-0.49071165919303894,
0.16645270586013794,
0.43943673372268677,
0.13301433622837067,
-0.7297787070274353,
0.07568366825580597,
-0.28671324253082275,
-0.22430087625980377,
0.3900391161441803,
-0.2949149012565613,
0.40972739458084106,
0.35746681690216064,
-0.13444854319095612,
-0.22694708406925201,
-0.7492213845252991,
0.19513669610023499,
0.8631972670555115,
0.18891029059886932,
0.1709420382976532,
0.2424902319908142,
-0.2198857218027115,
0.720084011554718,
0.04422365128993988,
0.20966193079948425,
0.11621227860450745,
-0.4165021479129791,
-0.24126428365707397,
0.05048362910747528,
0.6118607521057129,
-0.09714843332767487,
0.21877460181713104,
-0.10516960173845291,
-0.41039231419563293,
0.08823075145483017,
0.23344385623931885,
-1.0059902667999268,
-0.456363707780838,
0.3134722411632538,
-0.42157232761383057,
-0.21476516127586365,
-0.16048645973205566,
-0.4355529248714447,
0.044162798672914505,
-0.18290139734745026,
0.8974132537841797,
-0.5037882924079895,
-0.3130398094654083,
0.03533511236310005,
-0.15005254745483398,
0.15688635408878326,
0.12266421318054199,
-0.9669309258460999,
0.5352699756622314,
0.34864500164985657,
0.6543175578117371,
0.12739060819149017,
-0.08247340470552444,
-0.7821874618530273,
-0.02686130814254284,
-0.5040271878242493,
0.52845698595047,
-0.3901395797729492,
0.02627381682395935,
-0.1866670846939087,
-0.37343335151672363,
0.012336105108261108,
-0.27710607647895813,
0.35414594411849976,
-1.0183403491973877,
0.27777573466300964,
-0.13539831340312958,
-0.5559512972831726,
-0.32985129952430725,
-0.08372965455055237,
-0.7608656883239746,
1.0802000761032104,
0.2717393934726715,
-0.6033070087432861,
0.24192149937152863,
-0.5573199987411499,
-0.14821887016296387,
0.28953030705451965,
0.10406213253736496,
-0.64264976978302,
0.3449028432369232,
0.11190339922904968,
0.1584225296974182,
-0.198179692029953,
0.3098547160625458,
-0.19134530425071716,
-0.6751231551170349,
0.1176251620054245,
-0.5951684713363647,
0.8936019539833069,
0.07820010930299759,
-0.49942222237586975,
0.21811075508594513,
-0.8605756163597107,
0.3765581250190735,
0.06735262274742126,
-0.3539724349975586,
-0.48559463024139404,
-0.0806286633014679,
-0.015218962915241718,
0.21390202641487122,
0.06161322444677353,
-0.40004077553749084,
-0.037999581545591354,
-0.38717493414878845,
0.5694569945335388,
0.6832354068756104,
0.04235127195715904,
0.7331830859184265,
-0.13521689176559448,
0.5377835631370544,
0.154887393116951,
0.23887497186660767,
-0.003199242753908038,
-0.625099778175354,
-0.5009604692459106,
-0.36598682403564453,
0.7523826360702515,
0.2426658421754837,
-0.7964041233062744,
0.5686268210411072,
-0.4572678208351135,
-0.47860273718833923,
-0.48110368847846985,
0.37507274746894836,
0.2474755495786667,
0.4534079134464264,
0.3743836581707001,
-0.5596442818641663,
-0.19561316072940826,
-0.7349839210510254,
-0.18880854547023773,
0.0851060152053833,
0.04909992963075638,
-0.31471553444862366,
0.28410905599594116,
-0.27257275581359863,
1.0654953718185425,
-0.17411480844020844,
-0.36839351058006287,
-0.28185954689979553,
0.4482789933681488,
-0.056338176131248474,
0.8025780916213989,
0.45094504952430725,
-0.7944008111953735,
-0.45473712682724,
-0.09100639075040817,
-0.25570327043533325,
-0.0716557502746582,
0.04815090820193291,
-0.04976639151573181,
0.18559466302394867,
0.6093085408210754,
-0.396438866853714,
0.4196600019931793,
0.8946359753608704,
-0.2526322603225708,
0.12648937106132507,
-0.17280106246471405,
-0.11110362410545349,
-0.93840092420578,
-0.006682838778942823,
0.0593559555709362,
-0.383344441652298,
-0.9977436065673828,
-0.17029954493045807,
0.2928389310836792,
-0.13648954033851624,
-0.24712741374969482,
0.3009704649448395,
-0.2823261618614197,
-0.06415341794490814,
-0.16967397928237915,
-0.17595155537128448,
0.1504422426223755,
0.6647370457649231,
-0.05202256515622139,
0.5369172096252441,
0.5095254182815552,
-0.28678563237190247,
0.14553780853748322,
-0.14413703978061676,
-0.2422703057527542,
0.19236411154270172,
-0.6695653796195984,
0.14052367210388184,
-0.17135410010814667,
0.15231917798519135,
-1.129791498184204,
0.04393576458096504,
0.09466603398323059,
-0.49823591113090515,
0.4349760115146637,
-0.5646719336509705,
-0.5340022444725037,
0.2208833396434784,
-0.49746716022491455,
0.8840173482894897,
0.7801597118377686,
-0.33309251070022583,
0.3990894854068756,
0.20821665227413177,
-0.06938011199235916,
-0.3424738347530365,
-0.5706082582473755,
-0.11379160732030869,
-0.4054735600948334,
-0.5881589651107788,
0.26671427488327026,
-0.1921616494655609,
0.07653053104877472,
0.09489070624113083,
-0.026883382350206375,
-0.1834498643875122,
0.30562371015548706,
-0.06004777550697327,
-0.05520729720592499,
-0.18473972380161285,
-0.0988016426563263,
0.1270243227481842,
-0.16803373396396637,
0.06503754109144211,
-0.4889392554759979,
0.6556985378265381,
-0.09553640335798264,
-0.23125769197940826,
-0.5853216648101807,
0.4008801281452179,
0.49929729104042053,
-0.43352243304252625,
0.5938727855682373,
0.868196427822113,
-0.6371195912361145,
-0.09013345837593079,
-0.3411891758441925,
-0.46258923411369324,
-0.46855244040489197,
0.4035932421684265,
-0.27149248123168945,
-0.6406818628311157,
0.5039071440696716,
-0.025195283815264702,
-0.11882805824279785,
0.23210124671459198,
0.43959587812423706,
-0.023114074021577835,
1.6320770978927612,
0.7361813187599182,
0.03496343642473221,
0.8829686045646667,
-0.5160449147224426,
0.30412134528160095,
-0.8550012707710266,
0.33825331926345825,
-0.25826820731163025,
-0.4080582857131958,
-0.43468624353408813,
-0.21360759437084198,
0.3848857283592224,
0.2316269725561142,
-0.138393372297287,
0.24129676818847656,
-0.1196601390838623,
0.2812073230743408,
0.8973003029823303,
-0.008711244910955429,
0.15295331180095673,
0.23722121119499207,
0.09770329296588898,
-0.16159985959529877,
-0.9439932703971863,
-0.25606846809387207,
1.0141422748565674,
0.5722959637641907,
0.5695515871047974,
0.3409981429576874,
0.780749499797821,
0.28654956817626953,
0.25205203890800476,
-0.8196868300437927,
0.1206984743475914,
0.061551064252853394,
-0.31792598962783813,
-0.6990616917610168,
-0.7391413450241089,
-1.0351550579071045,
0.039128776639699936,
-0.0841730535030365,
-0.5403847694396973,
0.48509079217910767,
0.14410963654518127,
-0.633988082408905,
0.13516007363796234,
-0.8866317272186279,
1.1123204231262207,
0.06429044157266617,
-0.21011982858181,
0.03813137859106064,
-0.5749726891517639,
0.36422860622406006,
-0.1552264392375946,
0.4744020402431488,
-0.07873541861772537,
0.08875725418329239,
0.7996494174003601,
-0.5487181544303894,
0.7710714340209961,
-0.21220806241035461,
-0.17768257856369019,
0.2651054263114929,
0.24842031300067902,
0.582268476486206,
-0.13671471178531647,
0.4667145311832428,
0.20665065944194794,
-0.0035732085816562176,
-0.7245549559593201,
-0.7516359686851501,
0.5780792236328125,
-0.916656494140625,
-0.2316812127828598,
-0.37496575713157654,
-0.5782824158668518,
-0.38438522815704346,
0.19782057404518127,
0.38836824893951416,
0.8165773749351501,
0.20199920237064362,
0.22110731899738312,
0.7452888488769531,
0.24878105521202087,
0.7163186073303223,
0.22896075248718262,
0.1979454606771469,
-0.5272858738899231,
1.3338422775268555,
0.4149921238422394,
0.5718117952346802,
0.06911220401525497,
0.25814127922058105,
-0.16678673028945923,
-0.8939370512962341,
-0.5062155723571777,
0.11036857217550278,
-0.7872983813285828,
-0.382797509431839,
-0.3829769194126129,
-0.3501374423503876,
-0.4411437511444092,
0.15451356768608093,
-0.6064682602882385,
-0.4597787857055664,
-0.27440324425697327,
0.15054482221603394,
0.13088378310203552,
0.3674564063549042,
-0.08060193806886673,
0.6121771931648254,
-0.9618430137634277,
0.07363741844892502,
0.5499775409698486,
0.3353493809700012,
-0.09285848587751389,
-1.0423322916030884,
-0.6403999328613281,
0.05903537943959236,
-0.2825081944465637,
-0.9003981351852417,
0.5280371904373169,
0.3715268075466156,
0.3629798889160156,
0.530018150806427,
-0.1614726185798645,
0.6159300804138184,
-0.47382503747940063,
0.5312855839729309,
-0.008380847051739693,
-1.1791843175888062,
0.3239459693431854,
-0.24665820598602295,
0.38325735926628113,
0.33057019114494324,
0.4644257128238678,
-0.39308151602745056,
-0.4116537868976593,
-0.9116652607917786,
-0.9000912308692932,
0.5739526748657227,
0.4343038499355316,
0.2605392038822174,
0.24522465467453003,
0.23718154430389404,
-0.3683486878871918,
0.12892359495162964,
-0.9463644027709961,
-0.004227366764098406,
-0.1256493777036667,
-0.31012213230133057,
-0.13257218897342682,
-0.48936501145362854,
-0.18086962401866913,
-0.078633613884449,
0.6173515319824219,
-0.2717617154121399,
0.03319203853607178,
-0.09961216896772385,
-0.3724249601364136,
-0.5092669129371643,
0.1492086499929428,
0.6671568155288696,
0.6668009757995605,
-0.3833274245262146,
0.24060702323913574,
-0.16097961366176605,
-0.5396835803985596,
0.209425687789917,
0.18439479172229767,
-0.3135010898113251,
-0.04559408500790596,
0.27723225951194763,
0.7286304831504822,
0.32134270668029785,
-0.48682084679603577,
0.7056108713150024,
-0.19847674667835236,
-0.14477215707302094,
-0.09364383667707443,
-0.16124476492404938,
-0.14008107781410217,
0.17358049750328064,
0.5078306794166565,
0.15426227450370789,
0.2666231393814087,
-0.3530387878417969,
0.05016777291893959,
0.6726440787315369,
-0.4651152491569519,
-0.5350577235221863,
0.6873175501823425,
-0.02140648290514946,
-0.05028104782104492,
0.5863577723503113,
-0.4376923441886902,
-0.4356166124343872,
0.42877790331840515,
0.5233830213546753,
0.8055870532989502,
-0.30006346106529236,
0.05465992912650108,
0.2034708559513092,
0.4720456004142761,
-0.2897912561893463,
0.24312132596969604,
-0.024371780455112457,
-0.9720510244369507,
-0.7612736821174622,
-0.43536296486854553,
-0.2057192325592041,
0.07487080246210098,
-0.7704619765281677,
0.3027946650981903,
-0.3720380663871765,
-0.3277911841869354,
-0.14771132171154022,
0.00457261735573411,
-0.3948175311088562,
0.2245936393737793,
0.26082900166511536,
0.490221232175827,
-1.1536880731582642,
1.127097487449646,
0.6005070805549622,
-0.43224889039993286,
-0.7125442028045654,
-0.1416151374578476,
-0.3658595681190491,
-0.41510435938835144,
0.6225919127464294,
-0.05157650634646416,
0.19276300072669983,
0.700631856918335,
-0.44992050528526306,
-1.193163275718689,
0.9605895280838013,
0.5271249413490295,
-0.394123911857605,
0.05194384232163429,
-0.004891704302281141,
0.4085996747016907,
0.021123381331562996,
0.1717783361673355,
0.7831690311431885,
0.26547524333000183,
-0.03460078313946724,
-0.6019871234893799,
0.08690354973077774,
-0.13376601040363312,
0.23787496984004974,
0.5245025753974915,
-0.46593987941741943,
0.8482711911201477,
0.11422334611415863,
-0.15300296247005463,
-0.17922034859657288,
0.6919916272163391,
0.18172992765903473,
-0.07254893332719803,
0.6354221105575562,
0.7279018759727478,
0.424140602350235,
-0.1179739311337471,
0.8804916143417358,
-0.2196902483701706,
0.33313000202178955,
0.7778502702713013,
0.014052139595150948,
0.7467883229255676,
0.5372970700263977,
-0.058100294321775436,
0.43613219261169434,
0.5765479803085327,
0.2649565041065216,
0.599149763584137,
0.24291476607322693,
-0.15632516145706177,
-0.27344590425491333,
0.14546802639961243,
-0.21814750134944916,
0.3680289089679718,
0.396816223859787,
0.07665342837572098,
-0.2578875720500946,
0.13604247570037842,
0.10218919068574905,
-0.13671241700649261,
-0.2786923348903656,
0.7395015954971313,
-0.11114968359470367,
-0.3738202154636383,
0.6907631158828735,
0.14191283285617828,
0.40076327323913574,
-0.685653030872345,
-0.15537022054195404,
-0.5062613487243652,
0.017782775685191154,
-0.07715625315904617,
-0.15950976312160492,
0.1959741860628128,
-0.34171441197395325,
-0.1008872240781784,
-0.3460310101509094,
0.494642972946167,
-0.7120828628540039,
-0.5102667808532715,
0.08057422935962677,
0.5489588975906372,
-0.08953187614679337,
-0.46053701639175415,
-0.42434948682785034,
0.3387105464935303,
-0.18276849389076233,
-0.3983922600746155,
0.6878640055656433,
0.42798683047294617,
-0.4147683084011078,
0.4067949652671814,
0.7595307230949402,
0.28278061747550964,
0.36423856019973755,
0.23478460311889648,
0.9437679648399353,
-0.4432174861431122,
-0.4869222939014435,
-0.8128798604011536,
0.5394458770751953,
0.13374660909175873,
-0.06274009495973587,
0.6937496662139893,
0.42085424065589905,
0.6838720440864563,
0.14691506326198578,
0.4471685588359833,
0.26635339856147766,
-0.027998335659503937,
-0.5253914594650269,
0.6313724517822266,
-0.5252260565757751,
0.26107457280158997,
-0.09896468371152878,
-1.0326496362686157,
-0.5597768425941467,
0.45782285928726196,
-0.120308518409729,
0.2616502344608307,
0.5772795081138611,
0.7239415645599365,
0.035295285284519196,
-0.42716965079307556,
0.5509161353111267,
0.05774994194507599,
0.47975191473960876,
0.5319981575012207,
0.7264142632484436,
-0.7931508421897888,
0.7313397526741028,
-0.4645687937736511,
-0.5227789282798767,
-0.21630457043647766,
-0.9634828567504883,
-0.6797815561294556,
-0.6050532460212708,
-0.6627147197723389,
-0.3874834179878235,
-0.08114791661500931,
0.7298979759216309,
0.9116563200950623,
-0.8438330292701721,
-0.29464614391326904,
-0.22893407940864563,
0.1574113517999649,
-0.49240386486053467,
-0.25740954279899597,
0.5051303505897522,
-0.7383925318717957,
-0.8594680428504944,
0.31874436140060425,
0.24375568330287933,
0.41190701723098755,
-0.3536731004714966,
0.054664891213178635,
-0.053237028419971466,
0.09215150028467178,
0.4433249831199646,
0.30277514457702637,
-0.31914475560188293,
-0.33964428305625916,
-0.20672032237052917,
-0.11537916958332062,
0.09742896258831024,
0.8650196194648743,
-0.8269602656364441,
0.4353087246417999,
0.4603540897369385,
0.7008410692214966,
0.37739062309265137,
0.08027103543281555,
0.6716882586479187,
-1.1435860395431519,
0.24021711945533752,
0.342940092086792,
0.23685091733932495,
0.36245033144950867,
-0.2677973210811615,
0.22737200558185577,
0.3351183831691742,
-0.5956119894981384,
-1.0785284042358398,
0.11690983176231384,
-0.694855272769928,
-0.1360693871974945,
1.0074299573898315,
0.016804518178105354,
-0.1029738336801529,
-0.08135963976383209,
0.022543972358107567,
0.15686216950416565,
-0.19528687000274658,
0.6721147894859314,
0.7043505311012268,
-0.0742543488740921,
-0.3860148787498474,
-0.6996356844902039,
1.0544488430023193,
0.6304519176483154,
-0.5074411034584045,
-0.10947448760271072,
0.2557891309261322,
0.23984280228614807,
0.10939960926771164,
0.5564722418785095,
-0.13047383725643158,
0.48492181301116943,
-0.09125316143035889,
0.12951956689357758,
0.07167263329029083,
-0.3123690187931061,
-0.7916237115859985,
0.04953550919890404,
0.4707068204879761,
-0.18030498921871185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03602v1
|
Evaluating LLMs at Detecting Errors in LLM Responses
| 2024-04-04T17:19:47 | 2024-04-04T17:19:47 |
Ryo Kamoi, Sarkar Snigdha Sarathi Das, Renze Lou, Jihyun Janice Ahn, Yilun Zhao, Xiaoxin Lu, Nan Zhang, Yusen Zhang, Ranran Haoran Zhang, Sujeeth Reddy Vummanthala, Salika Dave, Shaobo Qin, Arman Cohan, Wenpeng Yin, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With Large Language Models (LLMs) being widely used across various tasks,
detecting errors in their responses is increasingly crucial. However, little
research has been conducted on error detection of LLM responses. Collecting
error annotations on LLM responses is challenging due to the subjective nature
of many NLP tasks, and thus previous research focuses on tasks of little
practical value (e.g., word sorting) or limited error types (e.g., faithfulness
in summarization). This work introduces ReaLMistake, the first error detection
benchmark consisting of objective, realistic, and diverse errors made by LLMs.
ReaLMistake contains three challenging and meaningful tasks that introduce
objectively assessable errors in four categories (reasoning correctness,
instruction-following, context-faithfulness, and parameterized knowledge),
eliciting naturally observed and diverse errors in responses of GPT-4 and Llama
2 70B annotated by experts. We use ReaLMistake to evaluate error detectors
based on 12 LLMs. Our findings show: 1) Top LLMs like GPT-4 and Claude 3 detect
errors made by LLMs at very low recall, and all LLM-based error detectors
perform much worse than humans. 2) Explanations by LLM-based error detectors
lack reliability. 3) LLMs-based error detection is sensitive to small changes
in prompts but remains challenging to improve. 4) Popular approaches to
improving LLMs, including self-consistency and majority vote, do not improve
the error detection performance. Our benchmark and code are provided at
https://github.com/psunlpgroup/ReaLMistake.
|
[
-0.19987575709819794,
-0.5965520143508911,
0.5672392249107361,
0.2879113256931305,
-0.058831457048654556,
-0.06695251911878586,
-0.1577073484659195,
-0.20329664647579193,
-0.06066598743200302,
0.32861167192459106,
-0.7110099196434021,
-0.6371561884880066,
-0.6172910928726196,
0.4736582934856415,
-0.05918652191758156,
0.658090353012085,
-0.11424748599529266,
-0.07587844133377075,
-0.3285290598869324,
-0.384773313999176,
-0.6716858744621277,
-0.5500469207763672,
-0.3128449618816376,
-0.20510195195674896,
0.4464826285839081,
0.46426522731781006,
0.16535477340221405,
0.13117888569831848,
0.5868574380874634,
0.34054628014564514,
-0.06265967339277267,
0.7370302081108093,
-0.384830504655838,
0.29854199290275574,
0.03674100711941719,
-0.5876530408859253,
-0.8414577841758728,
-0.0938047468662262,
0.7176927924156189,
0.5264500975608826,
-0.19033321738243103,
0.14234526455402374,
0.2834988236427307,
0.6977588534355164,
-0.5914658904075623,
0.35527533292770386,
-0.5946680307388306,
0.11212856322526932,
-0.4137646555900574,
-0.4071093499660492,
-0.4825964868068695,
-0.35508304834365845,
-0.1507405787706375,
-0.5520516037940979,
0.0691099464893341,
0.3812031149864197,
0.45393800735473633,
0.4888297915458679,
-0.1937248259782791,
-0.348631352186203,
-0.2954593598842621,
0.948731541633606,
-1.0696274042129517,
0.4918210208415985,
0.53243488073349,
0.037531524896621704,
-0.37578192353248596,
-0.2587396204471588,
-0.7467339038848877,
-0.0914015918970108,
0.04736132547259331,
0.29718875885009766,
-0.4277818500995636,
-0.028658531606197357,
0.3970775902271271,
0.08152815699577332,
-0.7040287852287292,
0.34598854184150696,
0.15170054137706757,
-0.5299714803695679,
0.29702383279800415,
0.4622381627559662,
-0.01674789749085903,
-0.41595667600631714,
-0.10299575328826904,
-0.16687850654125214,
-0.7483522295951843,
-0.09590059518814087,
0.43344488739967346,
0.026682162657380104,
-0.05299799516797066,
0.39735573530197144,
-0.13492676615715027,
0.711161196231842,
-0.010113978758454323,
-0.404632568359375,
0.3517538011074066,
-0.11677590757608414,
-0.2762179970741272,
-0.31352025270462036,
0.7751451730728149,
0.6185018420219421,
-0.08423177897930145,
-0.12203115969896317,
-0.5173556208610535,
-0.09725522249937057,
0.13614825904369354,
-0.6042755842208862,
-0.11153475195169449,
0.2288365364074707,
-0.18516239523887634,
-0.16673485934734344,
-0.2865162789821625,
-0.6260867118835449,
-0.556137204170227,
-0.13383185863494873,
0.23586735129356384,
-0.07731233537197113,
-0.16058166325092316,
0.015835927799344063,
0.23710785806179047,
0.146787628531456,
0.7499263882637024,
-0.7020775675773621,
0.32692328095436096,
0.8382183313369751,
0.748396635055542,
-0.45849522948265076,
-0.34678637981414795,
-0.7123858332633972,
-0.3034745752811432,
-0.4524744749069214,
1.2328660488128662,
0.12632869184017181,
-0.372268944978714,
0.060776714235544205,
-0.001355186221189797,
-0.04918253794312477,
-0.8806931376457214,
0.7553609609603882,
-0.6325998306274414,
-0.08148373663425446,
-0.5964063405990601,
-0.8519657254219055,
-0.05261180177330971,
0.6350603699684143,
-0.5539025068283081,
0.9020520448684692,
0.23225435614585876,
-0.8628206849098206,
0.38742250204086304,
-0.46753621101379395,
-0.0785985141992569,
0.2152342051267624,
-0.1731518656015396,
-0.41775476932525635,
0.16446836292743683,
0.2198876291513443,
0.5259305834770203,
-0.2909492254257202,
0.243275448679924,
-0.28592273592948914,
-0.3350178599357605,
0.45891979336738586,
-0.48228883743286133,
0.6698795557022095,
-0.16923320293426514,
-0.2671748399734497,
0.16460932791233063,
-0.6510550379753113,
0.030996201559901237,
0.05971832200884819,
-0.5712407827377319,
-0.05317038670182228,
-0.057928528636693954,
-0.0920315682888031,
-0.10825345665216446,
0.08985040336847305,
-0.6012964844703674,
0.07738015800714493,
-0.17853884398937225,
0.0525541752576828,
1.0979759693145752,
-0.10462719947099686,
0.05876043438911438,
-0.35586017370224,
0.5148459672927856,
0.046739835292100906,
-0.04555786773562431,
-0.035229749977588654,
-0.5050144791603088,
-0.6291468143463135,
0.15405960381031036,
0.2065175473690033,
0.5560837388038635,
-0.8211786150932312,
0.5586753487586975,
-0.3600190281867981,
-0.14943303167819977,
-0.28609225153923035,
0.48950767517089844,
0.3044603765010834,
0.6749463677406311,
0.21773645281791687,
-0.1354089081287384,
-0.6976825594902039,
-0.8781067728996277,
-0.27735331654548645,
-0.5352340936660767,
-0.05526632443070412,
0.30144497752189636,
0.5293561816215515,
-0.46636974811553955,
0.8535901308059692,
-0.3879505693912506,
-0.3168487250804901,
-0.207267165184021,
0.029782762750983238,
0.18716883659362793,
0.20736165344715118,
0.28709354996681213,
-0.4371322691440582,
-0.13646383583545685,
-0.11578872054815292,
-0.7738346457481384,
-0.5589728951454163,
0.2764628529548645,
0.27878430485725403,
0.32505351305007935,
0.21372802555561066,
-0.32348868250846863,
0.099749855697155,
0.8521448969841003,
0.01984323561191559,
0.6045145392417908,
-0.025988010689616203,
0.3784991502761841,
-0.747689425945282,
-0.09570824354887009,
0.04494008421897888,
-0.3525938093662262,
-0.47207239270210266,
-0.0702267587184906,
0.2553781270980835,
0.6296950578689575,
-0.3979174792766571,
0.4445634186267853,
-0.14640769362449646,
-0.21530960500240326,
-0.43099668622016907,
0.25188371539115906,
-0.025840450078248978,
0.67990642786026,
-0.04613768681883812,
0.8458231091499329,
0.050184521824121475,
-0.3620860278606415,
0.5975927114486694,
0.23916591703891754,
-0.2540784478187561,
0.9684219360351562,
-0.5834974646568298,
0.33829107880592346,
-0.06906775385141373,
0.25062796473503113,
-1.0616438388824463,
-0.47813302278518677,
0.33468183875083923,
-0.5379589796066284,
0.10801012814044952,
-0.12310067564249039,
-0.67960125207901,
-0.4048541486263275,
-0.5101131200790405,
0.14403033256530762,
0.43731147050857544,
-0.7053269147872925,
0.4708062708377838,
0.4290671944618225,
0.030431881546974182,
-0.6362669467926025,
-0.6471359729766846,
0.16889497637748718,
-0.09457193315029144,
-0.4585932493209839,
-0.21355774998664856,
-0.21386250853538513,
-0.29427722096443176,
-0.29611310362815857,
-0.48159152269363403,
-0.03573895990848541,
0.2831248342990875,
0.5146269202232361,
0.26056748628616333,
-0.11903560906648636,
0.038108594715595245,
-0.20359118282794952,
-0.131978377699852,
0.24862442910671234,
-0.09282375872135162,
0.2720904052257538,
-0.48671776056289673,
-0.5493003129959106,
-0.3342277705669403,
-0.1499788761138916,
0.35219353437423706,
0.21199223399162292,
0.2267221063375473,
0.36244064569473267,
-0.48611167073249817,
-0.3717111051082611,
-0.8815881013870239,
-0.12793847918510437,
-0.45512259006500244,
0.31324636936187744,
-0.21163758635520935,
-0.988745927810669,
0.446488618850708,
-0.04068842530250549,
0.3070354759693146,
0.40881723165512085,
0.6127105951309204,
-0.33200398087501526,
0.5699301958084106,
0.29011306166648865,
0.04731929302215576,
-0.04487005993723869,
-0.18326948583126068,
0.054966039955616,
-1.190630555152893,
-0.11417601257562637,
-0.508575975894928,
-0.03976139798760414,
-0.43548619747161865,
-0.5659064054489136,
0.5739073753356934,
-0.09254694730043411,
0.021901601925492287,
0.2389306277036667,
-0.20897160470485687,
0.2792688012123108,
0.32437726855278015,
-0.009737339802086353,
0.46151721477508545,
-0.08046679943799973,
0.0852232351899147,
-0.47119858860969543,
-0.7146400809288025,
-0.6338370442390442,
1.1538307666778564,
0.4970128536224365,
0.9050787091255188,
0.23237824440002441,
0.823432445526123,
0.3810327649116516,
0.9211663603782654,
-0.8108915090560913,
0.6239150762557983,
0.09768449515104294,
-0.28265446424484253,
-0.1920490711927414,
-0.48152658343315125,
-0.6837507486343384,
0.5376397371292114,
-0.017978982999920845,
-0.566618025302887,
0.0447329618036747,
0.36202317476272583,
-0.39387643337249756,
0.3447227478027344,
-0.2679593861103058,
0.832720935344696,
-0.008088251575827599,
-0.42182332277297974,
0.19085411727428436,
-0.376400351524353,
0.5138593912124634,
-0.17915937304496765,
0.29207852482795715,
-0.24491925537586212,
-0.10341962426900864,
0.9525940418243408,
-0.15966638922691345,
0.9889833927154541,
-0.17606855928897858,
-0.39382117986679077,
0.31272318959236145,
0.30667489767074585,
0.6397790908813477,
0.01192165445536375,
-0.0342043936252594,
0.3178365230560303,
-0.19647155702114105,
-0.12108639627695084,
-0.48254260420799255,
0.7086868286132812,
-0.6874231696128845,
-0.6742576360702515,
-0.5176301598548889,
-0.4697583019733429,
-0.5308881998062134,
-0.0806017741560936,
0.22607570886611938,
0.3957277238368988,
-0.17456573247909546,
0.12488031387329102,
0.6374228596687317,
-0.021402858197689056,
0.24340282380580902,
0.8570283055305481,
-0.12167531996965408,
-0.31238898634910583,
0.7011855840682983,
0.08271300047636032,
0.0013063234509900212,
0.17978040874004364,
0.17071835696697235,
-0.33218908309936523,
-0.7924757599830627,
-0.638068675994873,
-0.031977273523807526,
-1.0082048177719116,
-0.49269628524780273,
-0.8761420845985413,
0.16275957226753235,
-0.2649345397949219,
0.27204790711402893,
-0.32877251505851746,
-0.02085920237004757,
-0.16658157110214233,
-0.16291698813438416,
0.1503288298845291,
0.629514753818512,
-0.24891898036003113,
0.34841200709342957,
-0.8556948900222778,
0.18005047738552094,
0.4039115011692047,
0.09909269958734512,
-0.025239206850528717,
-0.7247255444526672,
-0.10597743093967438,
-0.14933262765407562,
-0.2663927376270294,
-0.8756055235862732,
0.30897191166877747,
-0.07501348853111267,
0.5462151765823364,
0.036918725818395615,
-0.1180650144815445,
0.51427161693573,
-0.4396103620529175,
0.7964586615562439,
0.03426499664783478,
-0.9548328518867493,
0.514552891254425,
-0.2757234573364258,
0.22460633516311646,
0.4693850874900818,
0.04201393574476242,
-0.6782404184341431,
-0.3826793134212494,
-0.516099750995636,
-0.5780537128448486,
0.61656254529953,
0.08905424177646637,
-0.0342622846364975,
-0.18189135193824768,
0.38140738010406494,
0.1302006095647812,
0.298391193151474,
-0.7940608859062195,
-0.1304173469543457,
0.1511916071176529,
-0.065557099878788,
0.05904170870780945,
-0.37894555926322937,
-0.1861802637577057,
0.03144904598593712,
0.5801738500595093,
-0.566231906414032,
0.1287829875946045,
0.2602041959762573,
-0.473355233669281,
-0.45257261395454407,
0.3447895348072052,
0.6760866641998291,
0.6897631883621216,
-0.2178266942501068,
0.26947781443595886,
0.5344988703727722,
-0.32439953088760376,
0.27927854657173157,
-0.2196512669324875,
0.004085289314389229,
0.006007067393511534,
0.9103453159332275,
0.5979577302932739,
0.29859599471092224,
-0.8834818601608276,
0.7604289650917053,
-0.11417313665151596,
-0.0443635992705822,
-0.2432720810174942,
0.11890022456645966,
0.16618528962135315,
0.09924830496311188,
0.3128420412540436,
0.12778735160827637,
0.38483622670173645,
-0.19580532610416412,
0.02829880081117153,
0.31524914503097534,
-0.13934525847434998,
-0.46396976709365845,
0.5593916177749634,
0.2500702738761902,
-0.11140081286430359,
0.39118263125419617,
-0.5080678462982178,
-0.7279621958732605,
0.5857460498809814,
0.37566885352134705,
0.8539631366729736,
-0.1721305400133133,
0.035596005618572235,
0.2850653827190399,
0.45583993196487427,
-0.12131848186254501,
0.10854126513004303,
-0.06066511943936348,
-1.0842688083648682,
-0.5303831696510315,
-0.5426592230796814,
-0.8202816247940063,
0.13521888852119446,
-0.45938146114349365,
-0.3135406970977783,
-0.5001693964004517,
-0.288208544254303,
-0.13885073363780975,
-0.017663681879639626,
-0.7244671583175659,
-0.06774740666151047,
-0.009132944978773594,
0.6443973779678345,
-0.7949262261390686,
0.4444078207015991,
0.7610530257225037,
-0.009194856509566307,
-0.6407797932624817,
0.04742201045155525,
0.42298272252082825,
-0.9934213161468506,
1.0534322261810303,
0.14140233397483826,
-0.17690713703632355,
-0.3268809914588928,
-0.5322522521018982,
-0.4601094126701355,
0.9203953742980957,
0.06821111589670181,
-0.7967789173126221,
0.3387935757637024,
-0.10059040039777756,
0.5424085855484009,
-0.14693789184093475,
0.2671809494495392,
0.7410295009613037,
0.5702747106552124,
-0.1302892118692398,
-0.9846039414405823,
-0.05901733413338661,
0.014907336793839931,
0.03034529648721218,
0.030264755710959435,
-0.563262403011322,
0.8144088983535767,
-0.0622902512550354,
-0.12671861052513123,
-0.024765221402049065,
0.6068809628486633,
0.45397302508354187,
0.33443886041641235,
0.6251717805862427,
0.6383281350135803,
0.8332911133766174,
-0.21000348031520844,
0.9482757449150085,
0.017230864614248276,
0.5420656800270081,
1.0554314851760864,
-0.5748037099838257,
0.8373343348503113,
0.3997364342212677,
-0.5670537352561951,
0.20779432356357574,
0.6509926915168762,
0.11465208232402802,
0.20802293717861176,
0.33390000462532043,
-0.18190300464630127,
-0.22651877999305725,
0.022409098222851753,
-0.007681424263864756,
0.006898609455674887,
0.46704062819480896,
0.27728891372680664,
-0.3285112679004669,
-0.012551520951092243,
-0.08384829014539719,
0.030534405261278152,
-0.1894482970237732,
0.7220121622085571,
0.09688051044940948,
-0.5930464267730713,
0.6362653970718384,
-0.0015369978500530124,
0.9807418584823608,
-0.20899517834186554,
-0.12794075906276703,
-0.5455188751220703,
0.2688976526260376,
-0.3117903172969818,
-0.823355495929718,
0.19217237830162048,
0.1716548502445221,
-0.008762650191783905,
-0.0008173235110007226,
0.685386061668396,
-0.12034977227449417,
-0.09139945358037949,
0.25810569524765015,
0.6999810338020325,
0.10936620086431503,
-0.03938470780849457,
-0.5984712839126587,
0.527034342288971,
-0.0013962994562461972,
-0.4288691580295563,
0.09313889592885971,
0.22772015631198883,
0.0760292336344719,
0.6205431818962097,
0.5416065454483032,
-0.060309313237667084,
0.01186385378241539,
0.06497977674007416,
0.5564441680908203,
-0.3702610433101654,
-0.1835441291332245,
-0.8296750783920288,
0.30119791626930237,
-0.05578979477286339,
-0.34269657731056213,
0.8759883642196655,
0.32567304372787476,
0.7216345071792603,
-0.08683454990386963,
0.6998853087425232,
0.235320046544075,
0.5211220979690552,
-0.4965267777442932,
0.08780499547719955,
-0.43708866834640503,
0.5806283950805664,
-0.07713340222835541,
-0.9835231304168701,
-0.43383046984672546,
0.6490518450737,
-0.29003259539604187,
0.009389465674757957,
0.7283654808998108,
0.8410842418670654,
0.2048005312681198,
0.037090227007865906,
0.4889366328716278,
0.4425731301307678,
0.42295658588409424,
0.6094072461128235,
1.0234326124191284,
-0.5062158107757568,
0.1555100977420807,
-0.1613181233406067,
-0.2991896867752075,
-0.4690256714820862,
-0.8414945006370544,
-0.8325694799423218,
-0.33675268292427063,
-0.39729028940200806,
-0.5470941662788391,
0.030102109536528587,
1.0015943050384521,
0.5017192959785461,
-0.9675933718681335,
-0.20707935094833374,
0.05996008217334747,
0.2511169910430908,
-0.01813805289566517,
-0.1639857292175293,
0.3639201819896698,
-0.37952640652656555,
-0.6526445150375366,
0.48247259855270386,
0.55604088306427,
-0.1335858404636383,
-0.3246021568775177,
-0.23198910057544708,
0.3359716534614563,
-0.12549687922000885,
0.6241814494132996,
0.17577692866325378,
-0.9001547694206238,
-0.3306483030319214,
0.10319212079048157,
-0.2626127302646637,
0.1516600251197815,
0.6422097086906433,
-0.4429711699485779,
0.26054850220680237,
0.44971174001693726,
0.7947193384170532,
0.08323308080434799,
-0.2940254807472229,
0.12249250710010529,
-0.7031192183494568,
-0.15651926398277283,
0.44181522727012634,
0.61320561170578,
0.6062644720077515,
-0.22096475958824158,
0.6753660440444946,
0.46800655126571655,
-0.7495864033699036,
-0.9082027673721313,
-0.02355377748608589,
-0.9984197020530701,
0.08128033578395844,
1.0800070762634277,
-0.361103892326355,
-0.4488270878791809,
-0.029252760112285614,
-0.21886442601680756,
-0.336719274520874,
-0.2205338329076767,
0.5112375617027283,
0.919438898563385,
-0.24166607856750488,
-0.06798592954874039,
-0.9704400300979614,
0.47676968574523926,
0.44167444109916687,
-1.056661605834961,
0.2782616913318634,
0.7561327815055847,
0.4821738004684448,
0.2085455358028412,
0.77751624584198,
0.03347562626004219,
0.6590772271156311,
-0.06489646434783936,
0.06449932605028152,
0.08830086141824722,
-0.01259707286953926,
-0.48270222544670105,
-0.008460774086415768,
0.35936564207077026,
-0.029609065502882004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03598v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03598v1
|
Intent Detection and Entity Extraction from BioMedical Literature
| 2024-04-04T17:09:52 | 2024-04-04T17:09:52 |
Ankan Mullick, Mukur Gupta, Pawan Goyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Biomedical queries have become increasingly prevalent in web searches,
reflecting the growing interest in accessing biomedical literature. Despite
recent research on large-language models (LLMs) motivated by endeavours to
attain generalized intelligence, their efficacy in replacing task and
domain-specific natural language understanding approaches remains questionable.
In this paper, we address this question by conducting a comprehensive empirical
evaluation of intent detection and named entity recognition (NER) tasks from
biomedical text. We show that Supervised Fine Tuned approaches are still
relevant and more effective than general-purpose LLMs. Biomedical transformer
models such as PubMedBERT can surpass ChatGPT on NER task with only 5
supervised examples.
|
[
-0.008933588862419128,
-0.9226487278938293,
1.1660664081573486,
-0.16515189409255981,
-0.06718794256448746,
-0.35013145208358765,
-0.3500509560108185,
-0.7513917088508606,
0.1275704801082611,
0.7396126389503479,
-0.4102495610713959,
-0.6004019975662231,
-0.7532385587692261,
0.43398964405059814,
-0.45111820101737976,
1.1035549640655518,
0.11445870995521545,
0.20865806937217712,
-0.43162092566490173,
-0.059793803840875626,
-0.1863406002521515,
-0.2541152238845825,
-0.8108487725257874,
-0.4633532166481018,
0.7218499183654785,
0.10136241465806961,
0.286837637424469,
0.2815018892288208,
0.9304741621017456,
0.24742886424064636,
-0.18598896265029907,
0.24632787704467773,
-0.45538902282714844,
0.21330951154232025,
-0.5489997267723083,
-0.39901602268218994,
-0.44251692295074463,
0.027265306562185287,
0.6300144195556641,
0.880448043346405,
0.20933598279953003,
0.05356487259268761,
-0.04786970838904381,
0.6450755000114441,
-0.5108317136764526,
0.005322800949215889,
-0.5676240921020508,
-0.24496835470199585,
-0.0481986328959465,
-0.28314292430877686,
-0.9031790494918823,
-0.12558555603027344,
0.4663609266281128,
-0.6179643273353577,
0.2953396141529083,
0.18729878962039948,
0.9071176052093506,
0.28425925970077515,
-0.5564975738525391,
-0.6688268780708313,
-0.8069808483123779,
0.9013945460319519,
-0.5778992176055908,
0.6153100728988647,
0.3701896369457245,
0.013906068168580532,
-0.5765640735626221,
-1.133974552154541,
-0.3008030652999878,
-0.5005201101303101,
-0.36069729924201965,
0.030508097261190414,
-0.3955346643924713,
0.30241653323173523,
0.2672162353992462,
0.18485809862613678,
-0.5830328464508057,
0.26772090792655945,
-0.34643322229385376,
0.07096116989850998,
0.567450761795044,
0.0665874108672142,
0.7123212218284607,
-0.3709906041622162,
-0.1183730885386467,
0.28963640332221985,
-0.6643856167793274,
0.23155111074447632,
-0.026645265519618988,
0.10836898535490036,
0.3241828382015228,
0.8436062335968018,
-0.23095948994159698,
0.6906499266624451,
0.317863404750824,
-0.16357682645320892,
-0.007293174508959055,
-0.4692453145980835,
-0.25371047854423523,
0.12455015629529953,
0.8484699726104736,
0.1304253488779068,
0.23165573179721832,
-0.6338071823120117,
-0.0047411322593688965,
-0.2705796957015991,
0.6063738465309143,
-0.9350916743278503,
-0.14522354304790497,
0.5736233592033386,
-0.7277548313140869,
-0.014662520959973335,
-0.31307145953178406,
-0.4430716335773468,
-0.313588947057724,
-0.40672358870506287,
0.3785344362258911,
-0.7723714113235474,
0.05680355802178383,
0.3835825026035309,
-0.2631067633628845,
0.58280348777771,
0.3370116949081421,
-0.8250097036361694,
0.23745141923427582,
0.9065840840339661,
0.6469203233718872,
-0.5764065384864807,
0.1897333264350891,
-0.5980066657066345,
0.2649405896663666,
-0.14782971143722534,
0.9698893427848816,
-0.6698601245880127,
-0.4111855626106262,
-0.29610922932624817,
0.4207780361175537,
-0.34790918231010437,
-0.3326987028121948,
0.8753851652145386,
-0.7608569860458374,
0.2332935929298401,
-0.10786710679531097,
-0.827942967414856,
-0.3285856544971466,
0.23324468731880188,
-0.66818767786026,
0.48520830273628235,
-0.10128536820411682,
-0.7616292238235474,
0.49238812923431396,
-0.953380286693573,
-0.5505817532539368,
0.17329837381839752,
-0.14729341864585876,
-0.4053446352481842,
0.2236182987689972,
0.2543143928050995,
0.6261382699012756,
-0.3181605637073517,
0.5634181499481201,
-0.32133615016937256,
-0.2582027018070221,
0.5517670512199402,
-0.3682343661785126,
0.8261920213699341,
-0.16139861941337585,
-0.37983644008636475,
0.06827066838741302,
-0.6171844601631165,
-0.06752282381057739,
0.061029717326164246,
-0.27589768171310425,
-0.7862986326217651,
0.18275131285190582,
-0.008173838257789612,
-0.21186384558677673,
0.15167096257209778,
-0.7040252685546875,
0.3227284550666809,
-0.5579817295074463,
0.4600214958190918,
0.17053478956222534,
0.2743280231952667,
0.6332007050514221,
-0.08998118340969086,
0.3363969326019287,
-0.44633421301841736,
-0.009470412507653236,
0.117716483771801,
-0.630942165851593,
-0.403208464384079,
-0.6171097755432129,
0.46654045581817627,
0.39412903785705566,
-0.5356457233428955,
0.41415518522262573,
-0.34716227650642395,
-0.4038082957267761,
-0.3693945109844208,
-0.15905141830444336,
0.24177353084087372,
0.4027962386608124,
0.6448798775672913,
0.09174960106611252,
-0.30061566829681396,
-0.9101834893226624,
-0.4846215844154358,
0.03176353871822357,
-0.21826840937137604,
0.6315979361534119,
0.5783894658088684,
-0.7062017917633057,
1.0272841453552246,
-0.46498265862464905,
-0.18523502349853516,
-0.29638388752937317,
0.14342595636844635,
0.3913855254650116,
0.339797705411911,
0.5382662415504456,
-1.0935063362121582,
-0.23551177978515625,
0.18266087770462036,
-0.8889870047569275,
-0.17149189114570618,
-0.0018759784288704395,
-0.04765027016401291,
-0.08564934879541397,
0.7366478443145752,
-0.7893144488334656,
0.3683762550354004,
0.23938661813735962,
-0.2041160613298416,
0.5158287882804871,
-0.14321820437908173,
0.2053050547838211,
-0.8306655883789062,
0.262981653213501,
0.25353172421455383,
-0.2704209089279175,
-0.970953643321991,
-0.23009845614433289,
0.2054036408662796,
0.2805355191230774,
-0.34135234355926514,
0.7147291898727417,
-0.6714279651641846,
0.0784321129322052,
-0.3265422582626343,
-0.07127854228019714,
0.13288447260856628,
-0.059521980583667755,
0.32269227504730225,
0.48863092064857483,
0.3462029695510864,
-0.7877874374389648,
-0.11066043376922607,
0.3863137662410736,
-0.19614297151565552,
0.41429129242897034,
-0.9407145380973816,
0.051968615502119064,
-0.4869225323200226,
0.10897807031869888,
-0.9863576889038086,
-0.6717799305915833,
0.2938632667064667,
-0.3860236704349518,
0.6393343210220337,
-0.24258306622505188,
-0.1806952953338623,
-0.29287824034690857,
0.02457720972597599,
0.35798996686935425,
0.42798736691474915,
-0.5087753534317017,
0.7766689658164978,
0.5226327180862427,
-0.2795458734035492,
-0.5468389987945557,
-0.5699897408485413,
0.058899350464344025,
-0.21412809193134308,
-0.23234224319458008,
0.6213266849517822,
0.20123639702796936,
-0.20385341346263885,
0.1327633261680603,
-0.06441650539636612,
-0.272449791431427,
0.05270414426922798,
0.30543994903564453,
0.42336463928222656,
-0.20733016729354858,
0.37530964612960815,
0.19473376870155334,
0.08323806524276733,
0.13350577652454376,
-0.06221887841820717,
0.3394117057323456,
0.12268492579460144,
-0.5045402646064758,
-0.4912623167037964,
0.27876076102256775,
0.5126628875732422,
-0.2609484791755676,
0.579917311668396,
0.6479924917221069,
-0.357568621635437,
0.13879117369651794,
-0.5897119641304016,
-0.3238684833049774,
-0.4209882915019989,
0.5324422717094421,
-0.13157504796981812,
-1.0116230249404907,
0.17617438733577728,
-0.3528021574020386,
-0.0028992658481001854,
0.5339894890785217,
0.48865583539009094,
-0.14646977186203003,
1.0106779336929321,
0.5368773937225342,
0.2367958277463913,
0.3476518988609314,
-0.07325245440006256,
0.4057076871395111,
-1.054147720336914,
-0.29893553256988525,
-0.5564929246902466,
-0.19286856055259705,
-0.6603986024856567,
-0.22187399864196777,
0.35166293382644653,
-0.008169975131750107,
0.23918326199054718,
0.31732600927352905,
-0.7329991459846497,
0.3562261164188385,
0.2472066879272461,
0.30940163135528564,
0.4291042387485504,
-0.04969961941242218,
0.11316365748643875,
0.05202382057905197,
-0.4203673303127289,
-0.7452617883682251,
1.2979410886764526,
0.3545934557914734,
0.6149759292602539,
0.0640464499592781,
0.8221107721328735,
-0.018941424787044525,
0.6409511566162109,
-1.115288496017456,
0.45929527282714844,
-0.2140602171421051,
-0.8197214603424072,
-0.4269329607486725,
-0.22937220335006714,
-1.5645350217819214,
0.033283744007349014,
-0.274593710899353,
-1.0156235694885254,
0.4257115423679352,
-0.34947383403778076,
-0.3138221502304077,
0.06264061480760574,
-0.6705775856971741,
0.7542010545730591,
-0.2291957288980484,
-0.23006433248519897,
0.049708519130945206,
-0.401408851146698,
0.3556361794471741,
-0.18205636739730835,
0.17508293688297272,
-0.11683133989572525,
-0.20147942006587982,
0.7485746741294861,
0.2624177932739258,
0.603588879108429,
0.07789617776870728,
0.030357863754034042,
0.1503310352563858,
-0.32574698328971863,
0.3862486481666565,
0.21506665647029877,
-0.1324806958436966,
0.14742246270179749,
-0.08817768841981888,
-0.14297908544540405,
-0.3109205365180969,
0.5216414928436279,
-0.3166932761669159,
-0.5524365901947021,
-0.1420494168996811,
-0.6282877922058105,
-0.16259336471557617,
0.5192397236824036,
0.4391135275363922,
0.4656776785850525,
-0.4784733057022095,
0.5237503051757812,
0.9303386211395264,
-0.39451536536216736,
0.30119001865386963,
0.6893657445907593,
-0.27644985914230347,
-0.00476067652925849,
0.46466049551963806,
-0.13110266625881195,
0.0686095803976059,
0.5294461846351624,
-0.09315935522317886,
-0.4184257388114929,
-0.9583211541175842,
-0.19910724461078644,
0.4232651889324188,
-0.4256473183631897,
-0.09535583853721619,
-1.2711414098739624,
-0.1617826372385025,
-0.5113055109977722,
-0.013250531628727913,
-0.1973649263381958,
-0.05578439682722092,
-0.5080442428588867,
0.15753279626369476,
0.37790533900260925,
0.8419804573059082,
0.19307050108909607,
0.19259148836135864,
-0.956777811050415,
0.5941157937049866,
0.1544843316078186,
0.1384837031364441,
-0.5346015095710754,
-0.35673704743385315,
0.08785441517829895,
-0.056276142597198486,
0.026941103860735893,
-1.0859405994415283,
0.41140201687812805,
0.2819715440273285,
0.8514356017112732,
0.366907000541687,
-0.13281407952308655,
0.17200595140457153,
-0.6816982626914978,
0.5242797136306763,
0.004330459516495466,
-0.4967361092567444,
0.647529661655426,
-0.34983953833580017,
0.10129518806934357,
0.6039202213287354,
0.9300635457038879,
-0.1902642548084259,
-0.2475196272134781,
-0.5632954835891724,
-0.7656424045562744,
0.5543339252471924,
0.16270878911018372,
-0.09120161086320877,
-0.1608031690120697,
0.6279027462005615,
0.1438501924276352,
-0.14241856336593628,
-0.6439462304115295,
-0.09976442158222198,
0.526780903339386,
-0.3184788227081299,
-0.054341599345207214,
-0.20888501405715942,
0.12084256112575531,
-0.21861426532268524,
0.5537503361701965,
-0.1179368793964386,
0.4390909671783447,
0.699590265750885,
-0.37555497884750366,
0.21486957371234894,
0.5463027954101562,
0.2262522429227829,
0.25045955181121826,
-0.26269039511680603,
-0.1582089215517044,
-0.007509847637265921,
-0.7084144353866577,
0.04625063017010689,
0.3420215845108032,
-0.34723061323165894,
0.18748579919338226,
0.3760286271572113,
0.42534515261650085,
0.4368571937084198,
-0.8008675575256348,
0.4991720914840698,
-0.20493954420089722,
-0.2593501806259155,
-0.009161493740975857,
0.2442339062690735,
0.25914266705513,
0.31585630774497986,
0.28320661187171936,
-0.10717666894197464,
0.8863306641578674,
-0.320830374956131,
0.2806479036808014,
0.773059606552124,
-0.5749537944793701,
-0.1550980806350708,
0.4721266031265259,
-0.15228313207626343,
-0.1802617907524109,
0.36651062965393066,
-0.30429017543792725,
-0.27767661213874817,
0.5825745463371277,
0.5866638422012329,
0.8384244441986084,
-0.06974169611930847,
0.12631873786449432,
0.3319583535194397,
0.13259832561016083,
-0.2511383295059204,
0.06978583335876465,
0.12233497202396393,
-0.7115476131439209,
-0.8062242865562439,
-0.7097672820091248,
-0.5282942056655884,
0.20031438767910004,
-0.6339021921157837,
0.282147079706192,
0.13638830184936523,
-0.3648744821548462,
0.832651674747467,
-0.21366074681282043,
-0.7189425230026245,
0.09694702923297882,
-0.051943495869636536,
0.5041172504425049,
-0.5338435173034668,
0.7764045000076294,
1.0250329971313477,
-0.30696406960487366,
-0.6075716018676758,
-0.06172551214694977,
-0.27404510974884033,
-0.520588755607605,
0.8966221213340759,
0.31907016038894653,
0.08687885105609894,
0.1238364651799202,
-0.7662286758422852,
-0.8468388319015503,
0.8576002717018127,
0.10651985555887222,
-0.4624633193016052,
-0.3305166959762573,
0.08570700883865356,
0.5750356316566467,
-0.3006436824798584,
0.3850567042827606,
0.7199645638465881,
0.5513757467269897,
-0.06767039000988007,
-0.870953381061554,
-0.04638483002781868,
-0.08604976534843445,
-0.4360995292663574,
0.2591334581375122,
-0.049306754022836685,
0.6638946533203125,
-0.24792726337909698,
-0.23263055086135864,
0.04997165501117706,
0.42130646109580994,
0.2183116227388382,
0.6066277027130127,
0.3133399188518524,
0.25400376319885254,
1.0325379371643066,
-0.06691718101501465,
1.1072337627410889,
-0.043620407581329346,
0.32167521119117737,
0.7485473155975342,
-0.3220617473125458,
0.7026376128196716,
0.4733550250530243,
-0.16861015558242798,
0.5355367660522461,
0.4707840383052826,
0.09500079602003098,
0.4086206257343292,
-0.13057154417037964,
-0.14023558795452118,
-0.23362112045288086,
-0.232830211520195,
-0.20940807461738586,
0.7102639675140381,
0.8862636089324951,
-0.5600721836090088,
-0.10479261726140976,
0.3247499167919159,
-0.029616091400384903,
-0.22599762678146362,
-0.44409286975860596,
1.0070695877075195,
0.16388791799545288,
-0.7358983159065247,
0.2813795804977417,
-0.27652841806411743,
0.7188952565193176,
-0.31482458114624023,
0.018433136865496635,
0.3044482469558716,
0.09693864732980728,
-0.2262827605009079,
-0.7199349999427795,
0.1597358137369156,
0.058254435658454895,
-0.351907879114151,
0.10274287313222885,
1.4720313549041748,
-0.24534031748771667,
-0.37110501527786255,
0.27072542905807495,
0.561172604560852,
0.39817583560943604,
-0.17054186761379242,
-0.5109080076217651,
-0.41112709045410156,
0.0181890819221735,
-0.4822922348976135,
0.317504346370697,
0.5969573259353638,
0.15338322520256042,
0.5464560985565186,
0.8355814218521118,
0.14427167177200317,
-0.20581558346748352,
-0.17818515002727509,
0.5994843244552612,
-0.7661793828010559,
-0.018700063228607178,
-0.910212516784668,
0.11555540561676025,
-0.3453502655029297,
0.04219828546047211,
0.5720275640487671,
0.4091951847076416,
0.3050864636898041,
-0.14329564571380615,
0.7177467346191406,
0.08671130239963531,
0.6016613841056824,
-0.5359410643577576,
0.6620771884918213,
-0.6152612566947937,
0.11132078617811203,
-0.1354687213897705,
-0.7537639141082764,
-0.4283517897129059,
0.4212561547756195,
-0.8132696747779846,
-0.057247910648584366,
0.8424012660980225,
0.46050941944122314,
-0.1321450173854828,
0.20950576663017273,
0.17916113138198853,
0.03990548104047775,
0.3617134988307953,
0.45918920636177063,
0.6681385040283203,
-0.3815409243106842,
0.26771506667137146,
0.11197039484977722,
-0.2820321321487427,
-0.4594747722148895,
-0.868952214717865,
-0.9909343719482422,
-0.19717028737068176,
-0.29477572441101074,
-0.13852205872535706,
0.09068890661001205,
0.8222851157188416,
0.4985238313674927,
-0.9132909774780273,
0.5071366429328918,
-0.23551352322101593,
0.12822818756103516,
0.013872528448700905,
-0.22961513698101044,
0.4868629276752472,
-0.7548798322677612,
-0.94203120470047,
0.4659767150878906,
0.48251745104789734,
0.014905565418303013,
0.0695776417851448,
0.20853200554847717,
-0.4834062159061432,
0.11784764379262924,
0.6239148378372192,
0.28279203176498413,
-0.5915712118148804,
-0.24750907719135284,
0.5108653903007507,
-0.5345824956893921,
0.002313039032742381,
0.6298049688339233,
-0.7803492546081543,
0.13929972052574158,
0.5260318517684937,
0.9429858326911926,
0.4395385980606079,
-0.10924642533063889,
0.3118378520011902,
-0.25841060280799866,
-0.16873696446418762,
0.40816789865493774,
0.4079650640487671,
0.18220879137516022,
-0.5802784562110901,
0.730986475944519,
-0.029164472594857216,
-1.0033246278762817,
-0.6773617267608643,
-0.11877933889627457,
-1.3179200887680054,
-0.4999764859676361,
1.5674887895584106,
0.03701026365160942,
-0.5612360239028931,
-0.49419674277305603,
-0.31719714403152466,
0.35468271374702454,
-0.2880222499370575,
0.47889259457588196,
0.34836071729660034,
-0.48293134570121765,
0.2861366868019104,
-0.9420548677444458,
0.5280190110206604,
0.445925235748291,
-0.9627367854118347,
-0.19680377840995789,
0.3942113220691681,
0.16912244260311127,
0.3353133499622345,
0.7367851734161377,
-0.23716150224208832,
0.28004899621009827,
-0.4761236011981964,
0.13439427316188812,
0.3728633224964142,
-0.12927137315273285,
-0.1433112472295761,
0.1347697526216507,
0.022665873169898987,
0.02870325930416584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04295v1
|
Transducers with Pronunciation-aware Embeddings for Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-04-04T17:03:47 | 2024-04-04T17:03:47 |
Hainan Xu, Zhehuai Chen, Fei Jia, Boris Ginsburg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper proposes Transducers with Pronunciation-aware Embeddings (PET).
Unlike conventional Transducers where the decoder embeddings for different
tokens are trained independently, the PET model's decoder embedding
incorporates shared components for text tokens with the same or similar
pronunciations. With experiments conducted in multiple datasets in Mandarin
Chinese and Korean, we show that PET models consistently improve speech
recognition accuracy compared to conventional Transducers. Our investigation
also uncovers a phenomenon that we call error chain reactions. Instead of
recognition errors being evenly spread throughout an utterance, they tend to
group together, with subsequent errors often following earlier ones. Our
analysis shows that PET models effectively mitigate this issue by substantially
reducing the likelihood of the model generating additional errors following a
prior one. Our implementation will be open-sourced with the NeMo toolkit.
|
[
-0.04163704812526703,
-0.290620356798172,
0.3291463851928711,
0.015162241645157337,
-0.25200045108795166,
0.017910979688167572,
-0.06473980844020844,
-0.4355635643005371,
0.1711570918560028,
0.1476678103208542,
0.07852400839328766,
-0.28893741965293884,
-0.46216994524002075,
0.18356700241565704,
-0.14860041439533234,
0.2950003743171692,
0.15999700129032135,
0.6078536510467529,
0.3519546687602997,
-0.26152658462524414,
-0.2729816138744354,
-0.49263936281204224,
-0.7420651912689209,
-0.19657708704471588,
0.4654484689235687,
0.10364346206188202,
0.8741510510444641,
0.9240400791168213,
0.32012709975242615,
0.22794032096862793,
-0.11111889779567719,
0.1419072300195694,
0.29862093925476074,
0.1527894288301468,
-0.06849633902311325,
-0.010678249411284924,
-0.7143434286117554,
-0.06665676087141037,
0.8331835865974426,
0.5663037300109863,
-0.16589738428592682,
-0.547720730304718,
-0.0409478098154068,
0.18367719650268555,
-0.6773181557655334,
-0.0327034518122673,
-0.3978935480117798,
0.29010429978370667,
0.12134002894163132,
-0.2297617644071579,
-0.5056899189949036,
-0.3417314887046814,
0.47442319989204407,
-0.7726072669029236,
0.10771653056144714,
-0.2426714450120926,
0.30020710825920105,
0.2655683159828186,
-0.40331968665122986,
-0.5251806974411011,
-0.9685903787612915,
0.5818229913711548,
-0.8562994003295898,
0.7552651166915894,
0.3930085599422455,
0.2612130045890808,
-0.16317953169345856,
-0.6985363364219666,
-0.6458290815353394,
-0.17834648489952087,
-0.01596321538090706,
0.09825383126735687,
0.07076311856508255,
0.3646199703216553,
0.13421998918056488,
0.3229365348815918,
-0.5364073514938354,
0.0318819098174572,
0.05061022564768791,
-0.542108952999115,
0.47228512167930603,
0.006361190229654312,
0.4734160006046295,
-0.01633577235043049,
-0.08658400177955627,
-0.4412860572338104,
-0.3946615159511566,
-0.046779900789260864,
0.32558897137641907,
0.7690230011940002,
-0.1622946560382843,
0.2005123794078827,
0.2378774881362915,
0.7986768484115601,
0.11061816662549973,
-0.1932113915681839,
0.6810182332992554,
-0.29452067613601685,
-0.15805280208587646,
0.7079325914382935,
0.8119639158248901,
-0.03492799028754234,
0.21860180795192719,
0.10213253647089005,
-0.2825287878513336,
-0.05884313955903053,
0.08254269510507584,
-0.5696144700050354,
-0.224487766623497,
0.17263518273830414,
-0.5087874531745911,
-0.16259679198265076,
0.12222204357385635,
-0.252276748418808,
-0.4671073257923126,
0.024423452094197273,
0.7615181803703308,
-0.3889502286911011,
-0.6343124508857727,
0.21848073601722717,
-0.4674152433872223,
0.31439292430877686,
0.2088405340909958,
-0.776907742023468,
0.3464367091655731,
0.5332526564598083,
0.9189833998680115,
0.36378857493400574,
-0.22246825695037842,
-0.8711856007575989,
0.24325145781040192,
-0.4754355847835541,
0.6808077692985535,
-0.6538859605789185,
-0.8254444599151611,
-0.1707964837551117,
0.17280247807502747,
-0.10845496505498886,
-0.7383419275283813,
0.3791656792163849,
-0.02786124125123024,
0.035334568470716476,
-0.2393733710050583,
-0.6160519123077393,
-0.26681360602378845,
0.018993116915225983,
-0.8941342234611511,
0.7928130626678467,
-0.04393686354160309,
-0.5163023471832275,
0.0667436271905899,
-0.6305487155914307,
-0.560524046421051,
-0.16053105890750885,
0.11869773268699646,
-0.4579029977321625,
0.17440125346183777,
0.0744837149977684,
0.29675453901290894,
-0.0025926444213837385,
-0.14277330040931702,
-0.2165042608976364,
-0.3353668749332428,
0.2529865503311157,
-0.46813759207725525,
0.653864860534668,
-0.02597457729279995,
-0.2916955351829529,
-0.1462370902299881,
-0.9619540572166443,
0.29175105690956116,
-0.08517546951770782,
-0.4071495234966278,
-0.6878474950790405,
-0.013640784658491611,
-0.02765580452978611,
0.21277791261672974,
-0.0739363506436348,
-0.715822160243988,
0.04301382973790169,
-0.40640348196029663,
0.8132067322731018,
0.4828523099422455,
0.032893430441617966,
0.4030219614505768,
-0.26539742946624756,
0.28096845746040344,
0.10917641222476959,
0.23669083416461945,
-0.17225787043571472,
-0.464627206325531,
-0.5302450656890869,
-0.142672598361969,
0.48997947573661804,
0.565087616443634,
-0.24812772870063782,
0.2331964522600174,
0.04852025583386421,
-0.5105003714561462,
-0.7098046541213989,
-0.10653086751699448,
0.5187556147575378,
0.5914496183395386,
0.23842746019363403,
-0.5397982001304626,
-0.7671288251876831,
-0.5192262530326843,
-0.35507991909980774,
-0.4313003718852997,
0.02809354104101658,
0.37493816018104553,
0.12971895933151245,
-0.1373087614774704,
0.49204427003860474,
0.07034527510404587,
-0.07465201616287231,
0.14781302213668823,
0.07692874222993851,
-0.05373043939471245,
0.8075803518295288,
0.12048598378896713,
-0.84157395362854,
-0.5543675422668457,
0.20616209506988525,
-0.3385981619358063,
0.09640826284885406,
0.05969623103737831,
0.13532410562038422,
0.15159471333026886,
0.434828519821167,
-0.3735230267047882,
0.40119537711143494,
0.6199647188186646,
-0.06632108986377716,
0.41822895407676697,
-0.1376345455646515,
-0.10880342125892639,
-1.0665123462677002,
-0.06655049324035645,
-0.39787960052490234,
-0.45419004559516907,
-0.8100230693817139,
-0.6100515127182007,
0.23049801588058472,
0.046933867037296295,
-0.7368947267532349,
0.4505240321159363,
-0.4422053396701813,
-0.6004867553710938,
-0.3279792368412018,
0.18359118700027466,
0.05975065752863884,
0.12125536054372787,
0.5875690579414368,
0.7074569463729858,
0.46730583906173706,
-0.9108514785766602,
0.4659835696220398,
0.21265706419944763,
0.05428256094455719,
0.6133356094360352,
-0.9592409729957581,
0.5072916746139526,
0.21682386100292206,
0.331240713596344,
-0.8149169683456421,
-0.18425875902175903,
0.22236289083957672,
-0.7845662236213684,
0.34020715951919556,
-0.10597983002662659,
-0.23931846022605896,
-0.2845102846622467,
-0.2339445799589157,
0.35444772243499756,
0.4142289161682129,
-0.6938436627388,
0.7609251141548157,
0.40402522683143616,
0.0825965479016304,
-0.6445586681365967,
-0.8033593893051147,
-0.20808546245098114,
-0.01659393683075905,
-0.3015287518501282,
0.33641549944877625,
-0.0476362444460392,
0.10469113290309906,
0.20720385015010834,
-0.084654800593853,
-0.23006322979927063,
-0.017839621752500534,
0.3131676912307739,
-0.292278915643692,
-0.19197489321231842,
0.592944860458374,
-0.3811255097389221,
-0.31152239441871643,
-0.17226576805114746,
-0.513366162776947,
0.43473169207572937,
-0.2521861791610718,
-0.32462117075920105,
-0.7667031288146973,
0.22654880583286285,
0.6357141137123108,
-0.21355301141738892,
0.28524333238601685,
0.6813511848449707,
-0.6136747598648071,
-0.1550903171300888,
-0.26668885350227356,
-0.12935855984687805,
-0.5117801427841187,
0.24638894200325012,
-0.3965349793434143,
-0.47926896810531616,
0.6478956341743469,
-0.08581066876649857,
-0.20458148419857025,
0.27361276745796204,
0.4490346312522888,
-0.25163769721984863,
1.2034246921539307,
0.38079145550727844,
-0.06759216636419296,
0.7303953170776367,
-0.15138199925422668,
0.21167010068893433,
-1.230379343032837,
-0.09583309292793274,
-0.5999547243118286,
-0.11264876276254654,
-0.8937343955039978,
-0.5622909069061279,
0.383663147687912,
-0.2921072542667389,
-0.4990588426589966,
0.33484771847724915,
-0.6569571495056152,
0.31471267342567444,
0.7768841981887817,
0.010401601903140545,
0.18289469182491302,
-0.03190252184867859,
-0.3592912554740906,
0.059318412095308304,
-0.6357865929603577,
-0.3303109407424927,
0.9730109572410583,
0.2213495969772339,
0.936887800693512,
-0.11184679716825485,
0.682307779788971,
0.16097155213356018,
-0.3218933641910553,
-0.976313591003418,
0.18648816645145416,
-0.2800121605396271,
-0.5270991325378418,
-0.41945165395736694,
-0.15428617596626282,
-0.7478395700454712,
0.205831378698349,
0.16393624246120453,
-0.3410870432853699,
0.5243256092071533,
0.3751424551010132,
-0.4569019675254822,
0.42446187138557434,
-0.5401485562324524,
0.6512243747711182,
-0.218011274933815,
0.0024264093954116106,
-0.025718847289681435,
-0.6456883549690247,
-0.11229557543992996,
0.11046160012483597,
-0.034721747040748596,
0.0847693383693695,
-0.037043847143650055,
0.6865591406822205,
-0.703730046749115,
0.7019171118736267,
-0.5096948742866516,
-0.0065347421914339066,
0.6048225164413452,
0.011691094376146793,
0.7996089458465576,
-0.25818777084350586,
-0.37235984206199646,
-0.007572426926344633,
-0.22331663966178894,
-0.08746817708015442,
-0.6647059321403503,
0.3197168707847595,
-0.689210832118988,
-0.13364556431770325,
-0.38228029012680054,
-0.342884361743927,
-0.2548886239528656,
0.10277020931243896,
0.23827022314071655,
0.5665019154548645,
-0.12511610984802246,
0.10545869916677475,
0.6629633903503418,
-0.32447317242622375,
0.5841498970985413,
0.781924843788147,
0.21904532611370087,
-0.8515498638153076,
0.9726659059524536,
0.3455202579498291,
0.43619823455810547,
0.2496950924396515,
0.528516411781311,
-0.29986971616744995,
-0.26007726788520813,
-0.2659991383552551,
0.18365904688835144,
-0.6472089886665344,
-0.08777083456516266,
-0.7462092041969299,
-0.407918244600296,
-0.4397875964641571,
-0.1994369626045227,
-0.85846346616745,
-0.6318527460098267,
-0.2799779176712036,
-0.19822488725185394,
0.4720941483974457,
0.8323769569396973,
-0.791627049446106,
0.47732794284820557,
-0.932776689529419,
0.2664605677127838,
0.6314075589179993,
0.39101511240005493,
0.09419568628072739,
-0.5018879771232605,
-0.3521980941295624,
0.21249990165233612,
-0.09039313346147537,
-0.9146199822425842,
0.5753661394119263,
0.5729391574859619,
0.49213314056396484,
0.1771356463432312,
-0.022697709500789642,
0.7554665207862854,
-0.36426079273223877,
0.7008447647094727,
-0.025594767183065414,
-1.511725664138794,
0.7896823883056641,
-0.29750606417655945,
0.29168230295181274,
0.21109911799430847,
0.1980130672454834,
-1.00282883644104,
-0.2577469050884247,
-0.5405836701393127,
-0.6646860837936401,
0.5395904779434204,
-0.29314491152763367,
0.17778483033180237,
0.03613363951444626,
0.136469304561615,
0.070452481508255,
0.19789226353168488,
-0.5384057760238647,
0.04784248769283295,
-0.39830282330513,
-0.19078905880451202,
0.06862863153219223,
-0.19395481050014496,
0.24394235014915466,
-0.32482677698135376,
0.9693946242332458,
-0.08921711146831512,
0.4891369044780731,
0.6083635091781616,
-0.2862359881401062,
-0.32094886898994446,
0.07099137455224991,
0.6224581599235535,
0.07995899021625519,
-0.3003023862838745,
0.34324413537979126,
0.08498726785182953,
-0.8421738147735596,
0.44700685143470764,
-0.22165635228157043,
0.06321769952774048,
0.506108820438385,
0.2516308128833771,
0.7307431697845459,
0.1692851036787033,
-0.4289717674255371,
0.5112597942352295,
-0.16405744850635529,
-0.0018743493128567934,
-0.46685630083084106,
-0.15625706315040588,
0.23187164962291718,
0.2033989131450653,
0.20856422185897827,
-0.10788895189762115,
0.33942967653274536,
-0.27236101031303406,
0.17318299412727356,
0.35702621936798096,
-0.5761117339134216,
-0.4993995130062103,
0.46770530939102173,
0.43467584252357483,
-0.5225207209587097,
0.7027477622032166,
-0.1319139152765274,
-0.734833836555481,
0.7565551400184631,
0.6517463326454163,
1.181739091873169,
-1.116254448890686,
0.13733842968940735,
0.5225793123245239,
0.3380383849143982,
-0.06709166616201401,
0.6143953204154968,
-0.16501806676387787,
-0.7348071932792664,
-0.1845218390226364,
-0.1981610804796219,
-0.9460949897766113,
-0.03599005192518234,
-0.6636736392974854,
0.32904544472694397,
-0.7393019199371338,
-0.28008636832237244,
-0.048512112349271774,
-0.19886866211891174,
-0.5653234720230103,
0.3989928960800171,
0.26671352982521057,
0.4761880934238434,
-0.746207058429718,
0.8927093148231506,
0.7483412027359009,
-0.0179329551756382,
-1.1476211547851562,
-0.169935941696167,
-0.041245777159929276,
-0.7629980444908142,
0.6015095710754395,
0.2346048802137375,
-0.25513479113578796,
-0.03102416731417179,
-0.13715605437755585,
-1.082897424697876,
0.8695494532585144,
0.3471839129924774,
-0.845765233039856,
0.1367417722940445,
0.274385005235672,
0.477222740650177,
-0.31133800745010376,
0.3492194414138794,
0.46405255794525146,
0.5470011234283447,
-0.23889493942260742,
-1.5412061214447021,
-0.0681198388338089,
-0.13053448498249054,
0.1013321727514267,
-0.037149567157030106,
-0.664237916469574,
1.1121563911437988,
-0.14374588429927826,
-0.1229807436466217,
-0.24480774998664856,
0.1652555912733078,
-0.0021010059863328934,
0.3631497919559479,
0.6012057065963745,
0.6184803247451782,
0.9821062684059143,
0.17557911574840546,
0.6213099956512451,
-0.3165218234062195,
0.10559097677469254,
1.2747825384140015,
-0.2650001049041748,
1.0302228927612305,
0.14139802753925323,
-0.11871709674596786,
0.6770772933959961,
0.5552632212638855,
0.2351309061050415,
0.7578393816947937,
0.029363425448536873,
-0.4342285990715027,
-0.23194001615047455,
-0.3370790183544159,
-0.6220443248748779,
0.7143892049789429,
0.6218045353889465,
-0.755031406879425,
0.0194068793207407,
0.2791263163089752,
-0.3501945734024048,
-0.3232339024543762,
-0.28249791264533997,
0.8153960108757019,
0.24552524089813232,
0.004327796399593353,
0.6610918045043945,
-0.34852662682533264,
0.6023271083831787,
-0.38319748640060425,
-0.112797312438488,
0.07293781638145447,
0.13940243422985077,
-0.3147231340408325,
-0.40078139305114746,
0.23314020037651062,
-0.23347942531108856,
-0.3044883608818054,
-0.07550764083862305,
0.7785964608192444,
-0.5106191635131836,
-0.14811336994171143,
0.44458550214767456,
0.1584254950284958,
0.2993273138999939,
-0.03135940432548523,
-0.498508483171463,
0.36501994729042053,
-0.2452785223722458,
-0.1939261108636856,
-0.17400085926055908,
0.27782267332077026,
0.05004945397377014,
0.5535436272621155,
0.43574655055999756,
0.14766617119312286,
0.36665329337120056,
0.14863716065883636,
0.39466896653175354,
-0.7790643572807312,
-0.7272441387176514,
-0.5823555588722229,
0.5712071657180786,
0.19910646975040436,
-0.06723516434431076,
0.600094735622406,
0.35310640931129456,
0.8661407828330994,
-0.014475863426923752,
1.157522439956665,
0.3026207685470581,
0.7971343398094177,
-0.26427918672561646,
0.47144368290901184,
-0.4613795876502991,
0.0621366985142231,
-0.3445751667022705,
-0.7805328965187073,
-0.24837596714496613,
1.0129563808441162,
-0.0485185869038105,
0.16591092944145203,
0.5950931906700134,
0.9015991687774658,
0.08631878346204758,
0.15450182557106018,
0.46309834718704224,
0.2136668562889099,
0.27843907475471497,
0.7338153719902039,
0.7983254194259644,
-0.8308253288269043,
0.44251254200935364,
-0.45316970348358154,
0.38239380717277527,
-0.47463250160217285,
-0.7758371233940125,
-0.3418092727661133,
-0.72425377368927,
-0.5356656908988953,
-0.44262707233428955,
0.23927471041679382,
0.9154355525970459,
0.9577699303627014,
-0.7888581156730652,
-0.14599332213401794,
-0.2939208149909973,
0.22169709205627441,
-0.35861170291900635,
-0.15065543353557587,
0.3993953466415405,
-0.09089692682027817,
-0.9943473935127258,
0.5460202097892761,
0.20955564081668854,
0.5644145011901855,
-0.15149569511413574,
-0.4805838465690613,
0.1068974956870079,
0.2205429971218109,
0.16928233206272125,
0.7192466855049133,
-0.5631877779960632,
-0.44116640090942383,
-0.1726960688829422,
-0.23432108759880066,
0.25414061546325684,
0.7852423787117004,
-0.925591230392456,
1.0699067115783691,
0.7386612296104431,
0.4551960229873657,
0.18051555752754211,
-0.23998986184597015,
0.852397620677948,
-0.6031770706176758,
0.33347171545028687,
0.4555192291736603,
0.2316787838935852,
0.7669656872749329,
-0.3627912402153015,
0.46207964420318604,
0.2667630910873413,
-0.40697741508483887,
-1.0885732173919678,
-0.0810977891087532,
-0.8993051052093506,
0.09057973325252533,
0.8765913844108582,
-0.333913654088974,
-0.34585127234458923,
0.01630794070661068,
0.023972447961568832,
0.629424512386322,
-0.4239621162414551,
0.16569210588932037,
0.5410491824150085,
-0.12371347099542618,
-0.08918212354183197,
-0.335615336894989,
0.5188614130020142,
0.4198244512081146,
-0.33383268117904663,
-0.03817850351333618,
0.3230213522911072,
0.5473778247833252,
0.17809823155403137,
0.6601051688194275,
-0.22422422468662262,
0.6958320736885071,
0.3554441034793854,
0.37310171127319336,
-0.19480514526367188,
-0.2558077275753021,
-0.7003040313720703,
-0.19100522994995117,
0.19233089685440063,
-0.6721188426017761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03592v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03592v3
|
ReFT: Representation Finetuning for Language Models
| 2024-04-04T17:00:37 | 2024-05-22T17:52:31 |
Zhengxuan Wu, Aryaman Arora, Zheng Wang, Atticus Geiger, Dan Jurafsky, Christopher D. Manning, Christopher Potts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) methods seek to adapt large neural
models via updates to a small number of weights. However, much prior
interpretability work has shown that representations encode rich semantic
information, suggesting that editing representations might be a more powerful
alternative. We pursue this hypothesis by developing a family of Representation
Finetuning (ReFT) methods. ReFT methods operate on a frozen base model and
learn task-specific interventions on hidden representations. We define a strong
instance of the ReFT family, Low-rank Linear Subspace ReFT (LoReFT), and we
identify an ablation of this method that trades some performance for increased
efficiency. Both are drop-in replacements for existing PEFTs and learn
interventions that are 15x--65x more parameter-efficient than LoRA. We showcase
LoReFT on eight commonsense reasoning tasks, four arithmetic reasoning tasks,
instruction-tuning, and GLUE. In all these evaluations, our ReFTs deliver the
best balance of efficiency and performance, and almost always outperform
state-of-the-art PEFTs. We release a generic ReFT training library publicly at
https://github.com/stanfordnlp/pyreft.
|
[
-0.26529791951179504,
-0.5633460879325867,
0.45751023292541504,
-0.012266685254871845,
-0.1909838169813156,
0.02622806653380394,
-0.5814415216445923,
-0.12641768157482147,
-0.02964652143418789,
0.4697360694408417,
-0.40656930208206177,
-0.2511128783226013,
-0.4637681841850281,
-0.02745450660586357,
-0.3810965120792389,
0.9313495755195618,
-0.21628034114837646,
-0.010309810750186443,
-0.031962115317583084,
-0.192910298705101,
-0.3226826786994934,
-0.45020821690559387,
-0.5667558312416077,
-0.5556633472442627,
0.5351276397705078,
0.5229228734970093,
0.7644923329353333,
0.7503390312194824,
0.4780123233795166,
0.28885889053344727,
-0.029760517179965973,
0.15661683678627014,
-0.9478849768638611,
0.02141435816884041,
-0.35015735030174255,
-0.5753965973854065,
-0.17625585198402405,
-0.014869646169245243,
0.6538782715797424,
0.9572793841362,
-0.15015248954296112,
0.05103658512234688,
0.19509044289588928,
0.7627990245819092,
-0.6570976376533508,
0.24432888627052307,
-0.8272458910942078,
0.0036158051807433367,
-0.23231986165046692,
-0.053629036992788315,
-0.6602674126625061,
-0.3381554186344147,
0.2633172273635864,
-0.645954966545105,
0.35154005885124207,
-0.1060495674610138,
0.8136502504348755,
0.5595791935920715,
-0.1203383207321167,
0.16744448244571686,
-0.7158172130584717,
0.7952710390090942,
-0.673358142375946,
0.8561104536056519,
0.354187935590744,
0.0885678231716156,
-0.020075736567378044,
-1.0364843606948853,
-0.21220619976520538,
-0.3052142560482025,
-0.2092745304107666,
0.005453825928270817,
-0.46591368317604065,
0.38852792978286743,
0.48153114318847656,
0.4982675015926361,
-0.28994011878967285,
-0.07792303711175919,
-0.35700592398643494,
-0.29002654552459717,
0.39787599444389343,
-0.1417136788368225,
-0.14425715804100037,
0.05691914260387421,
-0.31429803371429443,
-0.0672869086265564,
-0.8532352447509766,
-0.24453572928905487,
0.09633653610944748,
0.30350446701049805,
-0.005392290186136961,
0.39216360449790955,
-0.2540925443172455,
0.7654874920845032,
0.5050874352455139,
0.10059770941734314,
0.07271518558263779,
-0.03674624487757683,
-0.2767415940761566,
-0.1683809608221054,
0.5030443668365479,
0.10179300606250763,
0.16745972633361816,
-0.2569325864315033,
-0.2834572196006775,
-0.34007468819618225,
0.14016254246234894,
-0.772811233997345,
-0.6248072385787964,
-0.3030824363231659,
-0.5573921203613281,
-0.23902450501918793,
-0.10694365948438644,
-0.4813346266746521,
-0.2891465127468109,
-0.6361033320426941,
0.4336567223072052,
-0.7147550582885742,
-0.13155150413513184,
0.10582560300827026,
-0.11744900047779083,
0.13462792336940765,
0.5209118723869324,
-1.026511311531067,
0.5731679797172546,
0.513617217540741,
0.5736218690872192,
-0.08682532608509064,
-0.165435329079628,
-0.6712263226509094,
-0.05454162880778313,
-0.409233957529068,
0.7417637705802917,
-0.5981970429420471,
0.030451543629169464,
-0.18032114207744598,
-0.09039425849914551,
-0.09545769542455673,
-0.5484463572502136,
0.4710879325866699,
-0.4518703818321228,
-0.14815343916416168,
-0.513761579990387,
-0.588031530380249,
-0.28338658809661865,
-0.15610384941101074,
-0.7685398459434509,
1.0133036375045776,
0.3454332947731018,
-0.4507692754268646,
0.2423473596572876,
-0.6287402510643005,
-0.19015726447105408,
-0.0015293218893930316,
0.06674149632453918,
-0.015653254464268684,
0.4193256199359894,
0.21278423070907593,
0.637884795665741,
-0.19442401826381683,
-0.008493833243846893,
-0.07704904675483704,
-0.5544991493225098,
0.05286087840795517,
-0.7230594158172607,
0.2502973973751068,
0.3569577932357788,
-0.30685558915138245,
0.02424258179962635,
-0.5744041204452515,
-0.013036174699664116,
0.1299334019422531,
-0.4325425922870636,
-0.5573967099189758,
-0.1614900827407837,
0.10490024834871292,
-0.22427703440189362,
0.3088904917240143,
-0.41057416796684265,
0.33099010586738586,
-0.5841845273971558,
0.6164454817771912,
0.731052041053772,
-0.09247325360774994,
0.6102692484855652,
-0.1583496481180191,
0.3293363153934479,
-0.2917901873588562,
-0.10608413815498352,
-0.14172117412090302,
-0.336657851934433,
-0.8643311262130737,
-0.20923107862472534,
0.7094859480857849,
0.2424422651529312,
-0.993543803691864,
0.021037690341472626,
-0.12272872775793076,
-0.35975170135498047,
-0.5441526770591736,
0.1927877962589264,
0.5879937410354614,
0.42854246497154236,
0.4015352129936218,
0.0009737378568388522,
-0.3594153821468353,
-1.0058043003082275,
-0.32679086923599243,
0.05907629430294037,
0.2099299281835556,
-0.011824115179479122,
0.1660967916250229,
-0.08668120950460434,
0.911390483379364,
-0.6005462408065796,
0.045931246131658554,
-0.07139814645051956,
0.4048622250556946,
0.1263628751039505,
0.5445915460586548,
0.6928504705429077,
-0.6240618824958801,
-0.5209386348724365,
0.07138865441083908,
-0.302941232919693,
-0.148775115609169,
-0.14231164753437042,
0.057344455271959305,
0.2882893979549408,
0.7020130753517151,
-0.36779341101646423,
0.17023730278015137,
0.5121332406997681,
-0.31073787808418274,
0.371579110622406,
-0.2316022664308548,
0.019299767911434174,
-0.562395453453064,
-0.014940887689590454,
-0.12355612218379974,
-0.5326735377311707,
-0.806264340877533,
0.30159834027290344,
0.16910205781459808,
-0.21035873889923096,
-0.3868069648742676,
0.3983827829360962,
-0.4250646233558655,
0.14172646403312683,
-0.0025722666177898645,
-0.11919751763343811,
-0.08041210472583771,
0.779704749584198,
0.0025436459109187126,
0.7645137310028076,
0.1431407332420349,
-0.14089015126228333,
0.12826980650424957,
-0.08631986379623413,
-0.03173955902457237,
0.351975679397583,
-0.455576628446579,
0.4650249779224396,
-0.12158621847629547,
-0.03703298047184944,
-0.934593141078949,
-0.1282944530248642,
0.19953927397727966,
-0.07346250116825104,
0.4402379095554352,
-0.3293869197368622,
-0.47923505306243896,
-0.051027365028858185,
-0.2699722349643707,
0.27989256381988525,
0.5484750270843506,
-0.7642658948898315,
0.5531419515609741,
0.019644811749458313,
-0.14796066284179688,
-0.5980014204978943,
-0.7703701853752136,
-0.25895705819129944,
-0.07170707732439041,
-0.3862077295780182,
0.5294438600540161,
0.03621269017457962,
-0.0643693283200264,
0.28006651997566223,
-0.33712974190711975,
-0.1893066167831421,
0.014394138008356094,
-0.04033840820193291,
-0.1137009859085083,
-0.44918733835220337,
0.2928062677383423,
0.30437061190605164,
-0.28463053703308105,
-0.27341219782829285,
-0.30004948377609253,
0.5327469706535339,
-0.5401134490966797,
-0.36531829833984375,
-0.2832985818386078,
0.3145415186882019,
0.30513766407966614,
-0.3042429983615875,
0.34916257858276367,
0.7790988087654114,
-0.6173437237739563,
-0.26045215129852295,
-0.6746011972427368,
-0.25742968916893005,
-0.4986013174057007,
0.34817537665367126,
-0.4337979555130005,
-1.0467687845230103,
0.4017871618270874,
-0.2904401421546936,
0.272107869386673,
0.5275605320930481,
0.26895448565483093,
-0.07309672236442566,
0.7462576031684875,
0.741550624370575,
0.1806936264038086,
0.6321248412132263,
-0.4569404125213623,
0.08646731078624725,
-0.6076090335845947,
0.14806364476680756,
-0.36690303683280945,
-0.3765200972557068,
-0.3281327486038208,
-0.7613286972045898,
-0.014715808443725109,
0.500911295413971,
-0.3369484841823578,
0.4227330982685089,
-0.6791149377822876,
0.6724674105644226,
0.7012050151824951,
0.20633022487163544,
0.43347418308258057,
0.31582319736480713,
-0.15576140582561493,
-0.4559701383113861,
-0.8976840972900391,
-0.38895097374916077,
1.066523551940918,
0.4804460406303406,
0.9312295913696289,
-0.16051122546195984,
1.0218188762664795,
0.10594665259122849,
0.5312758684158325,
-0.9920820593833923,
0.4125920236110687,
-0.6982117891311646,
-0.2086099237203598,
-0.3042512834072113,
-0.388464093208313,
-0.7530431747436523,
0.060536425560712814,
-0.23404064774513245,
-0.6772576570510864,
0.5733336806297302,
0.3974451422691345,
-0.4891948997974396,
0.38734519481658936,
-0.9932799339294434,
0.7769395709037781,
0.0325290746986866,
-0.3848014175891876,
-0.4325266480445862,
-0.25724074244499207,
0.2608335614204407,
-0.13035300374031067,
-0.1424935907125473,
0.12504850327968597,
-0.048134591430425644,
0.8399969339370728,
-0.4863128960132599,
0.8137722611427307,
-0.37502458691596985,
0.009947765618562698,
0.20947150886058807,
0.2718728482723236,
0.6178686618804932,
-0.056372832506895065,
-0.19272221624851227,
0.1595822125673294,
0.22854672372341156,
-0.12627337872982025,
-0.882889449596405,
0.7612162232398987,
-0.6148028373718262,
-0.4955138564109802,
-0.17441383004188538,
-0.6490455865859985,
-0.3774200677871704,
0.2916499972343445,
0.14086005091667175,
0.48324552178382874,
-0.1364734023809433,
0.4309573769569397,
0.8513016104698181,
0.04565656930208206,
0.16321472823619843,
0.18044304847717285,
-0.1327572613954544,
-0.37145760655403137,
1.124862551689148,
0.23301900923252106,
0.37438374757766724,
0.5504494309425354,
0.40764519572257996,
-0.0307395588606596,
-0.6744904518127441,
-0.12182077765464783,
0.2932644188404083,
-0.914819061756134,
-0.2700570523738861,
-0.20579014718532562,
-0.2481767237186432,
0.01815136708319187,
-0.34307464957237244,
-0.6467275023460388,
-0.6231562495231628,
-0.1336374133825302,
-0.006024876609444618,
0.6630462408065796,
0.7984777092933655,
-0.3660026490688324,
0.4155344069004059,
-0.47895196080207825,
0.43105849623680115,
0.6034900546073914,
0.6002562046051025,
-0.07948003709316254,
-0.27333348989486694,
-0.22995416820049286,
0.00048032039194367826,
-0.24568010866641998,
-0.6615927815437317,
0.07244725525379181,
0.23062174022197723,
0.5460566878318787,
0.3096281588077545,
0.031055111438035965,
0.8121830821037292,
-0.5833261013031006,
0.5570173859596252,
0.28382715582847595,
-1.066460371017456,
0.14671383798122406,
-0.4376998543739319,
0.22963611781597137,
0.6746425032615662,
0.14466172456741333,
-0.5115189552307129,
-0.1794123500585556,
-0.7082407474517822,
-0.6941337585449219,
0.7421190142631531,
0.07721390575170517,
0.30143508315086365,
0.2568557560443878,
0.6227269768714905,
0.20838840305805206,
0.04415976628661156,
-0.5084124803543091,
-0.30628013610839844,
-0.3454238176345825,
-0.423356831073761,
0.1689009964466095,
-0.35925573110580444,
-0.058801695704460144,
-0.48571136593818665,
0.4336806535720825,
-0.37329018115997314,
0.5969306230545044,
0.3293328583240509,
-0.058922383934259415,
-0.2208690643310547,
0.20244668424129486,
0.38305696845054626,
0.503754734992981,
-0.25180646777153015,
0.13697873055934906,
0.2740345597267151,
-0.4959121644496918,
-0.16561870276927948,
0.37254998087882996,
-0.047603197395801544,
0.09212595224380493,
0.4792676270008087,
0.8965893983840942,
0.6820827126502991,
-0.44423240423202515,
0.3079843521118164,
0.013913249596953392,
-0.5181912183761597,
-0.005111962091177702,
0.09627578407526016,
0.07917006313800812,
0.29984065890312195,
0.33606112003326416,
0.45499393343925476,
0.24672023952007294,
-0.37309184670448303,
0.34738531708717346,
0.15052184462547302,
-0.5848426818847656,
-0.05815624073147774,
0.5347411632537842,
0.16837935149669647,
-0.1431504338979721,
0.5254991054534912,
-0.16479115188121796,
-0.2965449094772339,
0.22391313314437866,
0.3571445047855377,
0.833258867263794,
-0.15179449319839478,
0.14561988413333893,
0.18546560406684875,
0.296676903963089,
-0.14114238321781158,
0.18152177333831787,
-0.05804062262177467,
-0.7102022171020508,
-0.6284514665603638,
-0.4597409665584564,
-0.3827868700027466,
0.3079245686531067,
-0.5277004241943359,
0.14609576761722565,
-0.5807956457138062,
0.012621945701539516,
-0.0032395999878644943,
-0.13395747542381287,
-0.7483416795730591,
-0.2088184952735901,
0.15762640535831451,
0.9659720063209534,
-0.5932910442352295,
0.8470415472984314,
0.7290573120117188,
-0.3349546790122986,
-1.1115747690200806,
0.15111693739891052,
-0.12339280545711517,
-0.6719850301742554,
0.7160983681678772,
-0.2769351303577423,
-0.06526867300271988,
0.21317730844020844,
-0.6866494417190552,
-1.097252368927002,
0.8828814625740051,
1.0781586170196533,
-0.730711042881012,
-0.20681072771549225,
-0.17097558081150055,
0.46059852838516235,
-0.18426233530044556,
-0.08060309290885925,
0.8211054801940918,
0.4266580641269684,
-0.013548219576478004,
-0.9170986413955688,
0.19132082164287567,
-0.13892358541488647,
0.07280141860246658,
0.12485995143651962,
-0.5022900104522705,
0.6642231941223145,
-0.03715335577726364,
-0.04999160394072533,
0.1902264654636383,
0.5598950982093811,
0.22297422587871552,
-0.04961899667978287,
0.5473827123641968,
0.4783475697040558,
0.8598442077636719,
-0.4900778830051422,
0.9327176213264465,
-0.11119803786277771,
0.4354432225227356,
1.0934858322143555,
0.23459866642951965,
0.9031527638435364,
0.5758727192878723,
-0.10731449723243713,
0.35067903995513916,
0.4259616732597351,
0.023771794512867928,
0.6816930174827576,
0.18302519619464874,
-0.005942524876445532,
-0.3567967414855957,
0.08269593119621277,
-0.16566690802574158,
0.24970349669456482,
0.4986056387424469,
-0.3260006308555603,
-0.40078994631767273,
0.1864078789949417,
0.1053876131772995,
0.31785356998443604,
-0.32276663184165955,
0.6340954899787903,
0.2838594317436218,
-0.5152001976966858,
1.043758511543274,
-0.015013712458312511,
0.6102834343910217,
-0.5857731699943542,
-0.506799578666687,
-0.11372429132461548,
0.23833204805850983,
-0.26124411821365356,
-0.715820848941803,
0.30779582262039185,
-0.16543960571289062,
-0.18948861956596375,
-0.5388180613517761,
0.8050560355186462,
-0.556315004825592,
-0.27152881026268005,
0.16961044073104858,
0.3215576410293579,
0.01534204836934805,
0.05782465636730194,
-0.8759562969207764,
0.12675753235816956,
0.07199753075838089,
-0.2947765290737152,
-0.005544066894799471,
0.35611382126808167,
-0.18769118189811707,
0.37942957878112793,
0.6131184101104736,
0.1376260668039322,
0.007090975530445576,
0.23039132356643677,
0.8518388867378235,
-0.42530006170272827,
-0.17835964262485504,
-0.5521766543388367,
0.5481469631195068,
0.010689596645534039,
-0.20456251502037048,
0.33755356073379517,
0.2995220720767975,
0.8236238956451416,
-0.17505645751953125,
0.5973328948020935,
-0.017677053809165955,
0.34967395663261414,
-0.7908167243003845,
0.7654721140861511,
-0.389530748128891,
0.06666791439056396,
-0.47957727313041687,
-0.8084003925323486,
-0.4202443063259125,
0.8049822449684143,
-0.5276074409484863,
-0.054104872047901154,
0.868902325630188,
0.5618270635604858,
-0.34881117939949036,
0.08055625110864639,
0.4581553339958191,
0.408416748046875,
0.06887257099151611,
0.5713636875152588,
0.6896795034408569,
-0.5127329230308533,
0.36835843324661255,
-0.6033913493156433,
-0.20925085246562958,
-0.10804823786020279,
-0.8076838850975037,
-0.8175643682479858,
-0.7689442038536072,
-0.33085310459136963,
0.08953558653593063,
0.1841209977865219,
1.028998851776123,
1.0593053102493286,
-0.7969640493392944,
-0.08781330287456512,
-0.12392987310886383,
0.10816322267055511,
-0.43259957432746887,
-0.21718713641166687,
0.6002379059791565,
-0.5028729438781738,
-0.6697083711624146,
0.44559746980667114,
0.05491481348872185,
-0.1714080274105072,
-0.20848816633224487,
-0.10107459127902985,
-0.01029825396835804,
-0.12674447894096375,
0.6655527353286743,
0.24000075459480286,
-0.7769348621368408,
-0.48687881231307983,
-0.07406794279813766,
0.20263130962848663,
0.032572463154792786,
0.8877803683280945,
-0.8175035715103149,
0.387541264295578,
0.6019741296768188,
0.8359631896018982,
0.747509777545929,
-0.12271615862846375,
0.7729113698005676,
-0.6682627201080322,
0.19393792748451233,
0.28706902265548706,
0.607025146484375,
0.29571056365966797,
-0.3327646851539612,
0.5889942646026611,
0.2540230453014374,
-0.27299049496650696,
-0.7837936878204346,
0.12150727212429047,
-0.9866141080856323,
-0.19657261669635773,
1.005488634109497,
-0.11421141028404236,
-0.10155731439590454,
-0.05310509353876114,
-0.46505215764045715,
0.12304995954036713,
-0.6441231369972229,
0.31987643241882324,
0.5733942985534668,
-0.11090987920761108,
-0.5120976567268372,
-0.5501382350921631,
0.7033582329750061,
0.38976866006851196,
-0.48130202293395996,
0.39879149198532104,
0.3726086914539337,
0.3973645567893982,
0.28444862365722656,
0.5578282475471497,
-0.1417892426252365,
0.36883455514907837,
-0.25508975982666016,
0.01513226144015789,
-0.2442215383052826,
-0.21187716722488403,
-0.5285877585411072,
0.1385001540184021,
0.529254138469696,
0.2864358425140381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03577v1
|
Untangle the KNOT: Interweaving Conflicting Knowledge and Reasoning Skills in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T16:40:11 | 2024-04-04T16:40:11 |
Yantao Liu, Zijun Yao, Xin Lv, Yuchen Fan, Shulin Cao, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Providing knowledge documents for large language models (LLMs) has emerged as
a promising solution to update the static knowledge inherent in their
parameters. However, knowledge in the document may conflict with the memory of
LLMs due to outdated or incorrect knowledge in the LLMs' parameters. This leads
to the necessity of examining the capability of LLMs to assimilate supplemental
external knowledge that conflicts with their memory. While previous studies
have explained to what extent LLMs extract conflicting knowledge from the
provided text, they neglect the necessity to reason with conflicting knowledge.
Furthermore, there lack a detailed analysis on strategies to enable LLMs to
resolve conflicting knowledge via prompting, decoding strategy, and supervised
fine-tuning. To address these limitations, we construct a new dataset, dubbed
KNOT, for knowledge conflict resolution examination in the form of question
answering. KNOT facilitates in-depth analysis by dividing reasoning with
conflicting knowledge into three levels: (1) Direct Extraction, which directly
extracts conflicting knowledge to answer questions. (2) Explicit Reasoning,
which reasons with conflicting knowledge when the reasoning path is explicitly
provided in the question. (3) Implicit Reasoning, where reasoning with
conflicting knowledge requires LLMs to infer the reasoning path independently
to answer questions. We also conduct extensive experiments on KNOT to establish
empirical guidelines for LLMs to utilize conflicting knowledge in complex
circumstances. Dataset and associated codes can be accessed at
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KNOT .
|
[
-0.580961287021637,
-1.010902762413025,
0.6671605110168457,
-0.05842578038573265,
-0.5803698897361755,
0.38470566272735596,
-0.2921440005302429,
-0.46659600734710693,
-0.06345053017139435,
0.5325531959533691,
-0.20310507714748383,
-0.3045123219490051,
-0.8342217803001404,
0.02205999754369259,
-0.2535282075405121,
0.797918438911438,
-0.34080758690834045,
0.11864679306745529,
-0.6681695580482483,
-0.11271200329065323,
-0.4405149817466736,
-0.27387911081314087,
-0.6891515254974365,
-0.6498152017593384,
0.5992863178253174,
0.6641642451286316,
0.5809171199798584,
0.581713080406189,
0.54025799036026,
0.2856685221195221,
-0.6126625537872314,
0.5405533909797668,
-0.5664463043212891,
0.10526908934116364,
-0.514946699142456,
-0.4852231740951538,
-0.16965146362781525,
0.02380409650504589,
0.5695562958717346,
0.8813349604606628,
-0.0845816433429718,
0.24781319499015808,
0.1950659155845642,
0.706489086151123,
-0.41276803612709045,
-0.00025753333466127515,
-0.9509495496749878,
-0.2789257764816284,
-0.4791557192802429,
-0.3428628742694855,
-0.04403676837682724,
-0.35249412059783936,
0.21812468767166138,
-0.4939039647579193,
0.11439657211303711,
0.027083145454525948,
0.8753408789634705,
0.3516090214252472,
-0.9658747911453247,
-0.534207820892334,
-0.5110943913459778,
0.49192628264427185,
-0.9383640885353088,
0.25463926792144775,
0.5143834352493286,
-0.03633812442421913,
-0.42993196845054626,
-0.42756780982017517,
-0.5527746081352234,
0.14909443259239197,
-0.05660302937030792,
-0.01979977637529373,
0.17440935969352722,
-0.0099674416705966,
0.43144792318344116,
0.4191833436489105,
-0.3504747748374939,
0.23953425884246826,
-0.6052162647247314,
0.17300574481487274,
0.9148249626159668,
0.23268471658229828,
0.26633208990097046,
-0.09981611371040344,
-0.1319364309310913,
0.15288132429122925,
-0.7937529683113098,
0.47420716285705566,
0.506548285484314,
0.0021506433840841055,
0.004990388173609972,
0.6398575901985168,
-0.04045389965176582,
0.7702174186706543,
0.30695444345474243,
-0.24571041762828827,
-0.13506537675857544,
0.17405644059181213,
-0.13913153111934662,
0.1612137109041214,
0.7498748302459717,
0.35691872239112854,
0.14859263598918915,
-0.06546518206596375,
-0.04299088194966316,
-0.4621197581291199,
0.3337259292602539,
-0.3791254758834839,
-0.10417596250772476,
0.20860867202281952,
-0.300271600484848,
-0.1673801988363266,
-0.13921360671520233,
-0.8896660208702087,
-0.69244784116745,
-0.4968923330307007,
0.30654528737068176,
-0.374135822057724,
-0.47644132375717163,
0.29589492082595825,
-0.09521917998790741,
0.337274968624115,
0.31001120805740356,
-0.7669832110404968,
0.010395982302725315,
0.7914585471153259,
0.4525218904018402,
-0.10255863517522812,
-0.13732792437076569,
-0.21539276838302612,
0.2729209065437317,
-0.48179155588150024,
0.517865002155304,
-0.7703447341918945,
-0.3500117361545563,
-0.06714428216218948,
-0.13265936076641083,
-0.1597183495759964,
-0.4066326916217804,
0.617996871471405,
-0.8092920184135437,
0.18986660242080688,
-0.4921766519546509,
-0.9532769322395325,
-0.565718412399292,
0.24809367954730988,
-0.6533433198928833,
0.8217921257019043,
-0.04838116466999054,
-0.8166550993919373,
0.12371832132339478,
-0.4012475609779358,
-0.4337792992591858,
-0.07895547896623611,
-0.28998246788978577,
-0.40854257345199585,
0.10758524388074875,
0.06417103111743927,
0.3035801947116852,
-0.8030438423156738,
0.5909184813499451,
-0.5880299806594849,
-0.35991811752319336,
0.1928713172674179,
-0.12031925469636917,
0.8773308992385864,
0.24588538706302643,
0.002172512235119939,
-0.08789507299661636,
-0.562254786491394,
-0.07712045311927795,
0.3784555494785309,
-0.558990478515625,
-0.5635632872581482,
-0.09092428535223007,
-0.8302897810935974,
0.17191298305988312,
0.33746251463890076,
-0.4570482075214386,
0.557170033454895,
-0.1364007443189621,
0.2792425751686096,
0.6877378225326538,
0.2050437033176422,
0.41834259033203125,
-0.31825363636016846,
0.45550093054771423,
0.25739553570747375,
0.05583013594150543,
0.24051089584827423,
-0.5955861210823059,
-0.9793345332145691,
0.38185012340545654,
0.3255842626094818,
0.3351534307003021,
-0.7181937098503113,
0.22531308233737946,
0.040292032063007355,
-0.54696124792099,
-0.720520555973053,
0.3669642508029938,
0.42056983709335327,
0.4634692370891571,
0.3258916139602661,
-0.10474967956542969,
-0.5762179493904114,
-0.42354944348335266,
-0.6285085678100586,
-0.19326213002204895,
0.1692342460155487,
0.1860637217760086,
0.45750394463539124,
0.04076309874653816,
0.8552537560462952,
-0.5570123195648193,
-0.25600671768188477,
0.039389364421367645,
0.3679753243923187,
0.3540673851966858,
0.47730156779289246,
-0.05863503739237785,
-0.8642100095748901,
-0.3598683178424835,
0.23573154211044312,
-1.0686992406845093,
-0.083390973508358,
-0.11692630499601364,
0.02096039429306984,
0.09000455588102341,
0.8841317892074585,
-0.5584843754768372,
0.1068144217133522,
0.5059812664985657,
-0.40660786628723145,
0.6833595633506775,
-0.41305243968963623,
0.23208315670490265,
-0.9202135801315308,
-0.015957238152623177,
-0.11701547354459763,
0.17690899968147278,
-0.47284239530563354,
0.1714482307434082,
0.16051217913627625,
0.24246372282505035,
-0.11669014394283295,
0.46112245321273804,
-0.7355486750602722,
0.2692018747329712,
-0.028273995965719223,
0.25008150935173035,
0.12412840127944946,
0.6259015202522278,
-0.09251270443201065,
0.4713343679904938,
0.4998006522655487,
-0.34645116329193115,
0.41159898042678833,
0.26233527064323425,
-0.3556371331214905,
0.4206770956516266,
-0.3286685049533844,
0.3688066303730011,
-0.0802031010389328,
-0.2035554200410843,
-0.7232807874679565,
-0.2587478756904602,
0.005766420625150204,
-0.3507842421531677,
0.49322080612182617,
-0.37089940905570984,
-0.2659558057785034,
-0.30753910541534424,
-0.05320804566144943,
0.5631727576255798,
0.5024380683898926,
-0.46479639410972595,
0.7818382978439331,
0.5512527227401733,
-0.18261919915676117,
-0.604978621006012,
-0.2704150974750519,
0.0726795494556427,
-0.6702748537063599,
-0.678217351436615,
-0.1626800149679184,
-0.0012248907005414367,
-0.32631605863571167,
0.10679330676794052,
-0.4927464425563812,
-0.26166003942489624,
0.0483800545334816,
0.12615859508514404,
0.07205968350172043,
-0.2341654896736145,
0.35898497700691223,
0.28144571185112,
0.03999102860689163,
0.3096296787261963,
-0.1983499526977539,
0.16325853765010834,
-0.09259027242660522,
-0.698258101940155,
0.24520350992679596,
0.4466889798641205,
0.6389566659927368,
-0.486803263425827,
0.6913039088249207,
0.40972900390625,
-0.24771101772785187,
-0.10328022390604019,
-0.9218986630439758,
0.16216185688972473,
-0.4543303847312927,
0.09972632676362991,
-0.553716242313385,
-1.2866690158843994,
0.6402052044868469,
-0.6952682137489319,
-0.06417504698038101,
0.32354313135147095,
0.29510992765426636,
-0.32665544748306274,
0.9755017161369324,
0.4020073711872101,
0.020595211535692215,
0.022740239277482033,
-0.04827801138162613,
0.5682069659233093,
-1.191770076751709,
-0.5182395577430725,
-0.3968884348869324,
-0.19593067467212677,
-0.3324025571346283,
-0.5858194828033447,
0.3437267243862152,
1.1640654802322388,
-0.2869947552680969,
0.07126449048519135,
-0.18387848138809204,
0.6970226168632507,
0.5137028098106384,
-0.068276047706604,
0.6096700429916382,
-0.39886462688446045,
-0.6414654850959778,
0.11764674633741379,
-0.8476452827453613,
-0.5406710505485535,
1.0391796827316284,
0.22641830146312714,
0.9138713479042053,
0.24685554206371307,
0.535740315914154,
-0.029954934492707253,
-0.14966769516468048,
-0.5090565085411072,
0.4928179979324341,
-0.07395487278699875,
-0.33821386098861694,
-0.3747124671936035,
-0.5114370584487915,
-1.1890937089920044,
0.31766390800476074,
-0.25804418325424194,
-0.8949856162071228,
0.07168224453926086,
0.05086761340498924,
-0.04968644678592682,
0.7248224020004272,
-0.6846784353256226,
0.7284871339797974,
-0.36279696226119995,
-0.2859099805355072,
-0.09946154057979584,
-0.6304897665977478,
0.8741955161094666,
-0.4514573812484741,
0.15439407527446747,
-0.06834710389375687,
0.2162906676530838,
0.8186953067779541,
-0.24739879369735718,
0.7841007113456726,
0.21878162026405334,
-0.5270112156867981,
0.30429840087890625,
0.3460666835308075,
0.7307318449020386,
0.16370762884616852,
-0.006469471380114555,
0.27184271812438965,
0.06039615347981453,
-0.13011839985847473,
-0.6200791597366333,
0.6230382919311523,
-0.6174516081809998,
-1.2189974784851074,
-0.27739179134368896,
-0.8192561268806458,
-0.5223737955093384,
0.21376308798789978,
0.13489216566085815,
0.19134113192558289,
0.13727109134197235,
0.13845008611679077,
1.0409706830978394,
-0.24997936189174652,
0.15695522725582123,
0.7794129848480225,
-0.22716517746448517,
0.022621987387537956,
0.8545548915863037,
0.24187621474266052,
0.14060871303081512,
0.11296580731868744,
0.28762781620025635,
-0.2919783592224121,
-0.7496964931488037,
-0.20092912018299103,
0.3844587504863739,
-0.722546398639679,
-0.3524794578552246,
-0.4525240361690521,
-0.44812509417533875,
-0.22850742936134338,
-0.12470187991857529,
-0.14502322673797607,
-0.01683952473104,
-0.21608765423297882,
-0.0008607277413830161,
0.5642370581626892,
0.9418914914131165,
-0.1656002551317215,
-0.04120046645402908,
-1.0260099172592163,
0.27046892046928406,
0.5163195133209229,
0.5087066888809204,
0.06309052556753159,
-0.41710007190704346,
-0.3319244384765625,
-0.014398584142327309,
-0.1186177209019661,
-0.9234077334403992,
-0.11685601621866226,
-0.18586577475070953,
0.7098924517631531,
0.5668545365333557,
0.27747228741645813,
0.8843278884887695,
-0.14563706517219543,
0.5656135678291321,
0.23558108508586884,
-1.0231822729110718,
0.44178903102874756,
-0.5326511859893799,
0.4688234031200409,
0.14168010652065277,
0.44038382172584534,
-0.8155720829963684,
-0.877204418182373,
-0.6954666376113892,
-0.8273706436157227,
0.7877236604690552,
-0.10701259970664978,
-0.47776514291763306,
0.1991146206855774,
0.3688146471977234,
-0.03846517577767372,
0.0025639457162469625,
-0.2342817336320877,
0.07451315969228745,
0.4774625301361084,
-0.02796194516122341,
0.1548224240541458,
-0.4332869052886963,
-0.4754594564437866,
-0.36470741033554077,
0.6892871260643005,
-0.11254183202981949,
-0.19210854172706604,
0.03270556032657623,
-0.21232719719409943,
-0.5287641286849976,
0.19981126487255096,
0.4053858816623688,
0.7089982032775879,
-0.03928711637854576,
0.4264136552810669,
0.5070546865463257,
-0.2600153386592865,
0.1065303236246109,
-0.003089876612648368,
-0.04479178413748741,
-0.3136488199234009,
0.6333107352256775,
0.5602735877037048,
-0.022806376218795776,
-0.6064483523368835,
0.39547476172447205,
-0.028339790180325508,
-0.41232895851135254,
-0.014386346563696861,
0.12158742547035217,
0.6581419110298157,
0.5978769063949585,
0.06439889967441559,
-0.023113390430808067,
-0.2668619155883789,
-0.09774455428123474,
0.19831281900405884,
0.44806113839149475,
-0.2903845012187958,
0.11560285836458206,
0.4122675955295563,
0.3381301760673523,
-0.2119496911764145,
0.6349143981933594,
-0.39399293065071106,
-0.5076361298561096,
0.45248666405677795,
0.2846410572528839,
0.42918190360069275,
-0.30943626165390015,
-0.02191973850131035,
0.3711537718772888,
0.3752495348453522,
-0.10677148401737213,
0.18747757375240326,
0.054040491580963135,
-0.8459585905075073,
-0.5755847692489624,
-0.4242469072341919,
-0.20886321365833282,
0.40439489483833313,
-0.7713894844055176,
-0.03433091938495636,
-0.20656658709049225,
0.1313399225473404,
-0.44447648525238037,
0.18576793372631073,
-0.4068225920200348,
0.05425956845283508,
0.054675910621881485,
0.9078255891799927,
-0.584419310092926,
0.9941525459289551,
0.5098068118095398,
-0.4797116816043854,
-1.1088788509368896,
0.0334775447845459,
0.3811883330345154,
-0.6999294757843018,
0.2876262068748474,
-0.36610153317451477,
-0.15872810781002045,
-0.2110518366098404,
-0.5202406644821167,
-0.9634889364242554,
1.0172322988510132,
0.4684780240058899,
-0.6059473752975464,
-0.016086433082818985,
0.28959593176841736,
0.3140508830547333,
-0.089948371052742,
-0.032784346491098404,
0.8849067687988281,
0.4715052843093872,
0.3373808264732361,
-1.0398436784744263,
0.1813632696866989,
-0.2330285757780075,
-0.14718075096607208,
0.5493194460868835,
-0.45306485891342163,
0.8558538556098938,
-0.37838125228881836,
-0.21919184923171997,
-0.20926517248153687,
0.4240545630455017,
0.2744676172733307,
0.1753081977367401,
0.4853913187980652,
0.8004112839698792,
1.145859956741333,
-0.12100335955619812,
0.41716375946998596,
-0.09524516761302948,
0.4881049394607544,
1.5175338983535767,
-0.2570803463459015,
0.6575348973274231,
0.6626536250114441,
0.05712655931711197,
0.3032448887825012,
0.7430854439735413,
0.09561572968959808,
0.04376251995563507,
0.4303447902202606,
-0.2833578288555145,
-0.48555120825767517,
-0.11281392723321915,
-0.4421475827693939,
0.593601644039154,
0.37879911065101624,
-0.09354960918426514,
-0.4777063727378845,
-0.14931908249855042,
0.17592093348503113,
0.06852558255195618,
-0.2978169322013855,
1.0331233739852905,
0.23884518444538116,
-0.8526265025138855,
0.6628519892692566,
-0.13183583319187164,
0.3043566644191742,
-0.7372613549232483,
-0.23288647830486298,
-0.2761547565460205,
0.0835924819111824,
-0.2891961932182312,
-1.1992853879928589,
0.27495649456977844,
0.16254165768623352,
0.15902528166770935,
-0.10554581135511398,
0.8723631501197815,
-0.9208624362945557,
-0.21567559242248535,
0.564826488494873,
0.6683170795440674,
0.19597667455673218,
0.08552543818950653,
-0.7047539949417114,
0.008768351748585701,
0.07787919789552689,
-0.2405681163072586,
0.3690723478794098,
1.0805307626724243,
-0.09812968969345093,
0.7628878355026245,
0.617904007434845,
0.11093786358833313,
0.06636209040880203,
0.0005145951872691512,
1.0193113088607788,
-0.6733097434043884,
-0.15696866810321808,
-0.6762732267379761,
0.6573442220687866,
-0.19078943133354187,
-0.3532014787197113,
0.8435375690460205,
0.44493812322616577,
0.9193652272224426,
0.11597491800785065,
0.5280072093009949,
0.010459373705089092,
0.3257919251918793,
-0.842250406742096,
0.6170136332511902,
-0.7269311547279358,
0.41048362851142883,
-0.19063574075698853,
-0.39208266139030457,
-0.08904806524515152,
0.19092683494091034,
-0.3499833941459656,
-0.15524087846279144,
0.909957766532898,
0.71872878074646,
0.03338653966784477,
0.20053744316101074,
0.37201669812202454,
0.20818884670734406,
0.2802228033542633,
0.8546468019485474,
0.9960800409317017,
-0.12994784116744995,
0.6677320599555969,
0.09183475375175476,
-0.05382431298494339,
-0.06880448013544083,
-0.8907827734947205,
-0.9802370071411133,
-0.7466306686401367,
-0.3276195824146271,
-0.17498275637626648,
-0.11401954293251038,
0.7117430567741394,
0.323615700006485,
-0.4898540675640106,
-0.4693649411201477,
-0.06590558588504791,
0.6440804600715637,
-0.20257611572742462,
-0.15332528948783875,
0.3474176228046417,
-0.4832412600517273,
-0.43659111857414246,
0.30054354667663574,
0.20022638142108917,
-0.12602289021015167,
-0.05895150452852249,
-0.2561190724372864,
-0.7035669684410095,
0.05801777169108391,
0.36967137455940247,
0.20970913767814636,
-0.8590977787971497,
-0.20235575735569,
-0.4330297112464905,
0.07747267186641693,
-0.011822049506008625,
1.0785633325576782,
-0.31593355536460876,
0.6404051184654236,
0.5706468820571899,
0.7491467595100403,
0.4962446689605713,
-0.1023317202925682,
0.7290463447570801,
-0.6079692840576172,
-0.2970137596130371,
0.007186547387391329,
0.47593992948532104,
0.060177888721227646,
-0.466525137424469,
0.5857133865356445,
-0.013779413886368275,
-0.6408876776695251,
-0.5273436307907104,
0.25722482800483704,
-0.9477787613868713,
-0.6810985207557678,
1.1723190546035767,
-0.3270270824432373,
-0.012274653650820255,
-0.5297614932060242,
-0.3065197467803955,
0.648831844329834,
-0.14468897879123688,
0.8513085842132568,
0.9188517332077026,
-0.16155028343200684,
-0.14409372210502625,
-0.30430492758750916,
0.7455903887748718,
0.2937869727611542,
-0.7972952723503113,
0.28348639607429504,
0.07822202146053314,
0.23188243806362152,
0.018759731203317642,
0.4125767648220062,
-0.10464807599782944,
-0.03701603040099144,
-0.0789976492524147,
-0.18387819826602936,
-0.15778598189353943,
-0.14038869738578796,
-0.5446603298187256,
0.15253598988056183,
0.29378920793533325,
0.20280975103378296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03565v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03565v2
|
Personalized LLM Response Generation with Parameterized Memory Injection
| 2024-04-04T16:20:34 | 2024-06-11T10:47:02 |
Kai Zhang, Lizhi Qing, Yangyang Kang, Xiaozhong Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable proficiency in
comprehending and generating natural language. On the other hand, personalized
LLM response generation holds the potential to offer substantial benefits for
individuals in critical areas such as medical. Existing research has explored
memory-augmented methods to prompt the LLM with pre-stored user-specific
knowledge for personalized response generation in terms of new queries. We
contend that such paradigm is unable to perceive fine-granularity information.
In this study, we propose a novel \textbf{M}emory-\textbf{i}njected approach
using parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) and along with a Bayesian
Optimisation searching strategy to achieve \textbf{L}LM
\textbf{P}ersonalization(\textbf{MiLP}).
|
[
-0.5834705829620361,
-1.2584728002548218,
0.8270195126533508,
-0.10194247961044312,
-0.11394111067056656,
-0.0600406713783741,
-0.3165123760700226,
-0.18735210597515106,
0.48055875301361084,
0.5889742970466614,
-0.38660362362861633,
-0.42570605874061584,
-0.2207586169242859,
0.03713521361351013,
0.040762148797512054,
0.8029480576515198,
0.0564606748521328,
0.13695430755615234,
0.12695592641830444,
0.2054222971200943,
-0.24644695222377777,
-0.6607009768486023,
-0.7560997605323792,
-0.3333844840526581,
0.8513064980506897,
0.3489827513694763,
0.13208089768886566,
0.36942631006240845,
0.5218870639801025,
0.2047741711139679,
-0.1956636905670166,
0.5161817669868469,
-0.3016112446784973,
0.10011191666126251,
-0.3331480622291565,
-0.23634493350982666,
-0.611602246761322,
-0.2545427083969116,
0.6847791075706482,
1.037819743156433,
-0.29356297850608826,
0.09280546754598618,
0.12284743040800095,
0.6822150945663452,
-0.7766842246055603,
-0.26849958300590515,
-0.8038467764854431,
0.1598961353302002,
-0.07302164286375046,
-0.6561381816864014,
-0.5324026346206665,
-0.2248816192150116,
0.30850574374198914,
-0.33764907717704773,
0.24437452852725983,
0.3818013072013855,
0.8000415563583374,
-0.09163380414247513,
-0.24036237597465515,
-0.19078180193901062,
-0.8878748416900635,
0.6490610241889954,
-0.7951377034187317,
0.2492774873971939,
0.42361265420913696,
0.25173017382621765,
-0.4881921112537384,
-0.6291922330856323,
-0.4058324992656708,
-0.357387900352478,
0.02276686765253544,
0.15396557748317719,
0.013716655783355236,
0.3900996744632721,
-0.0370708592236042,
0.1031784862279892,
-0.4682242274284363,
0.07155808061361313,
-0.016154903918504715,
0.003320039249956608,
0.31550171971321106,
0.4937463104724884,
0.05611206591129303,
-0.16474667191505432,
-0.24943269789218903,
0.35738807916641235,
-0.5912082195281982,
-0.07321301847696304,
0.4043423533439636,
0.5215882062911987,
0.15562304854393005,
0.5604855418205261,
-0.5382682085037231,
0.9360446333885193,
0.5358956456184387,
-0.15301446616649628,
-0.057336851954460144,
-0.12012716382741928,
-0.49719783663749695,
-0.09898149967193604,
0.9296112656593323,
0.0706024244427681,
0.2013646364212036,
-0.1851670742034912,
-0.12952430546283722,
-0.611840009689331,
0.2570402920246124,
-0.9322037100791931,
-0.12552809715270996,
0.35407957434654236,
-0.5339685678482056,
-0.4083752930164337,
0.03012334555387497,
-0.5983029007911682,
-0.15700222551822662,
-0.11799254268407822,
0.5025774240493774,
-0.5820207595825195,
0.07353253662586212,
0.3935459554195404,
0.2255469411611557,
-0.06246083974838257,
0.23336774110794067,
-1.1790703535079956,
0.1309019774198532,
0.1846369355916977,
0.5580116510391235,
0.02191648632287979,
-0.1381889134645462,
-0.5486290454864502,
0.621618926525116,
-0.09826464205980301,
1.0079514980316162,
-0.7150638103485107,
-0.2152620404958725,
0.08168995380401611,
-0.2904810905456543,
0.05758107081055641,
-0.8970248699188232,
0.16871240735054016,
-0.43044814467430115,
0.017382601276040077,
-0.3519921600818634,
-0.3080003261566162,
0.10307355970144272,
0.2922579050064087,
-0.13943812251091003,
0.5796672105789185,
0.18118329346179962,
-0.6440432667732239,
0.41427621245384216,
-0.4301859736442566,
-0.269667387008667,
0.1989094763994217,
-0.5454117059707642,
-0.417744517326355,
0.3710115849971771,
0.5418151021003723,
0.8336783051490784,
-0.29396969079971313,
0.3870617747306824,
-0.5353424549102783,
-0.28415361046791077,
0.4857705235481262,
-0.3223189413547516,
0.012650410644710064,
0.36344292759895325,
-0.026677055284380913,
-0.03225474804639816,
-0.8240854740142822,
0.2127968966960907,
0.20324945449829102,
-0.8553289771080017,
-0.31867358088493347,
0.04798188433051109,
-0.25885245203971863,
-0.22313420474529266,
0.4858822226524353,
-0.3655779957771301,
0.24177893996238708,
-0.6282079219818115,
0.21949666738510132,
0.7561954855918884,
0.2912861108779907,
0.3781302273273468,
-0.40912461280822754,
0.3692466616630554,
0.29955360293388367,
-0.12692220509052277,
-0.1998605579137802,
-0.08937421441078186,
-0.444039911031723,
-0.2684306502342224,
0.18911363184452057,
0.4830794036388397,
-0.3845066428184509,
0.5816988945007324,
-0.096344493329525,
-0.04215974733233452,
-0.22688862681388855,
-0.0025462708435952663,
0.36779719591140747,
0.8630917072296143,
0.44286566972732544,
-0.005400579888373613,
-0.5319186449050903,
-1.1516799926757812,
-0.47340115904808044,
-0.266340970993042,
-0.459970086812973,
1.0131011009216309,
-0.07684160023927689,
-0.32213130593299866,
0.719336748123169,
-0.8196110725402832,
-0.2225932776927948,
-0.2727423310279846,
0.07501174509525299,
0.3243779242038727,
0.38237637281417847,
0.19492797553539276,
-0.31755781173706055,
-0.33105555176734924,
0.18707624077796936,
-0.4531593918800354,
-0.48458585143089294,
-0.33264803886413574,
-0.19436685740947723,
-0.051426488906145096,
0.24322731792926788,
-0.40307915210723877,
0.19898363947868347,
0.06982854008674622,
-0.2455974519252777,
0.42981231212615967,
-0.5751246213912964,
0.48356372117996216,
-1.251646876335144,
0.20037439465522766,
-0.012687030248343945,
-0.14183568954467773,
-0.5823755264282227,
0.20610907673835754,
0.09137584269046783,
0.025494568049907684,
-0.47398146986961365,
0.503875732421875,
-0.4981088936328888,
0.13767650723457336,
-0.2643290162086487,
-0.057834528386592865,
-0.23280471563339233,
0.28190451860427856,
-0.15367016196250916,
0.6385525465011597,
0.2064042091369629,
-0.7930070757865906,
-0.09101218730211258,
0.1957271844148636,
-0.016330689191818237,
0.6226900815963745,
-0.6236313581466675,
0.23397201299667358,
-0.3616669476032257,
0.1339605301618576,
-0.7808629274368286,
-0.5501236915588379,
0.32322442531585693,
-0.30592331290245056,
0.36113661527633667,
-0.17322926223278046,
-0.3402445614337921,
-0.15404821932315826,
-0.13028939068317413,
0.4414861798286438,
0.5305914282798767,
-0.560480535030365,
0.6947286128997803,
0.24568967521190643,
-0.20520958304405212,
-0.21785134077072144,
-0.5517120957374573,
0.05121956765651703,
-0.3469264507293701,
-0.613832950592041,
0.4130518436431885,
-0.3146578073501587,
-0.18857872486114502,
-0.45145711302757263,
0.05736776441335678,
-0.02294657938182354,
-0.09557986259460449,
0.042718879878520966,
0.01797347329556942,
-0.13952137529850006,
-0.007903913967311382,
0.5594282746315002,
0.03289271146059036,
-0.19694960117340088,
0.023195983842015266,
0.8667554259300232,
0.026540761813521385,
-0.32153627276420593,
-0.4453939199447632,
0.570171594619751,
0.10543767362833023,
-0.09363210201263428,
0.6273265480995178,
0.5957828164100647,
-0.38925591111183167,
-0.06322166323661804,
-0.7999342679977417,
-0.43622544407844543,
-0.5124468207359314,
0.3385978639125824,
-0.550787627696991,
-0.9841390252113342,
0.5002970099449158,
-0.40510502457618713,
-0.2948135733604431,
-0.05788933485746384,
0.8672055602073669,
-0.2337278127670288,
1.3287111520767212,
0.13096891343593597,
0.23027658462524414,
0.47325363755226135,
0.02621389552950859,
0.19316303730010986,
-1.1052130460739136,
-0.25143197178840637,
-0.331948846578598,
-0.45278170704841614,
-0.2520066201686859,
-0.2284485548734665,
0.4861724376678467,
0.2766497731208801,
-0.3526531755924225,
-0.16728077828884125,
-0.5380959510803223,
0.444850891828537,
0.3976956605911255,
0.5147235989570618,
0.18493060767650604,
0.22295807301998138,
-0.35819220542907715,
-0.12909196317195892,
-0.4374154508113861,
-0.46243152022361755,
1.2115322351455688,
0.3155776560306549,
1.145259141921997,
0.08471809327602386,
1.03164541721344,
-0.2021351307630539,
-0.12362803518772125,
-0.6712291240692139,
0.7555238604545593,
-0.1935923546552658,
-0.26561978459358215,
-0.04723881557583809,
-0.4935534596443176,
-1.1343625783920288,
0.08078420162200928,
-0.2773526906967163,
-1.0272080898284912,
0.03396748751401901,
0.32269030809402466,
-0.9546376466751099,
0.14806370437145233,
-0.7164598107337952,
0.10922159254550934,
-0.10122943669557571,
-0.40316706895828247,
-0.040216654539108276,
-0.44703495502471924,
0.17739924788475037,
-0.23441281914710999,
-0.10572806000709534,
-0.21124960482120514,
-0.3347846567630768,
0.45069220662117004,
-0.33598053455352783,
0.5662735104560852,
-0.21428228914737701,
0.26060542464256287,
-0.22666457295417786,
0.10098092257976532,
0.6845216155052185,
0.5466620922088623,
0.03563253954052925,
-0.21051566302776337,
-0.10933411121368408,
-0.42855921387672424,
-0.41791674494743347,
1.0052411556243896,
-0.4434139132499695,
-0.7664137482643127,
-0.11344864964485168,
-0.7302699685096741,
-0.48281097412109375,
0.31627124547958374,
0.2360634207725525,
0.1764981746673584,
-0.09425973147153854,
-0.05260102450847626,
0.9184515476226807,
-0.5740930438041687,
0.24493734538555145,
0.8662338852882385,
-0.2670711874961853,
-0.4504453241825104,
0.5896497964859009,
0.1318480521440506,
0.04472276195883751,
0.6298903226852417,
0.5436719655990601,
0.07015176117420197,
-1.1138797998428345,
-0.21360115706920624,
0.3171856999397278,
-0.055764611810445786,
-0.17833887040615082,
-0.8293715715408325,
0.03500105440616608,
-0.3635479509830475,
-0.32894444465637207,
-0.13400408625602722,
0.07722394913434982,
-0.6280288100242615,
0.1292918175458908,
0.16640403866767883,
0.3634141683578491,
0.06009858846664429,
0.5339851975440979,
-0.7993834018707275,
0.5232649445533752,
0.2935730218887329,
0.37351351976394653,
-0.22515952587127686,
-0.47938933968544006,
-0.1645803451538086,
0.1321343332529068,
-0.26181966066360474,
-0.9284535646438599,
0.5681478381156921,
0.26494964957237244,
0.39458754658699036,
0.47137874364852905,
-0.03761163353919983,
1.0932928323745728,
-0.8455733060836792,
0.5324749946594238,
0.06047026067972183,
-0.503670334815979,
0.9325461983680725,
-0.4876457154750824,
0.4636740982532501,
0.5195213556289673,
0.27769744396209717,
-0.11083873361349106,
-0.4262065887451172,
-0.48345139622688293,
-1.1053104400634766,
0.37096107006073,
-0.1959560364484787,
0.42131808400154114,
-0.33977821469306946,
0.9016358256340027,
0.07342961430549622,
0.1301943063735962,
-0.11051800847053528,
-0.10493743419647217,
0.7414196729660034,
-0.08312379568815231,
0.28345105051994324,
-0.509763240814209,
-0.12895609438419342,
-0.2957127094268799,
0.5100953578948975,
-0.28959694504737854,
0.512170135974884,
0.44257572293281555,
0.19335836172103882,
-0.26944535970687866,
0.2650841176509857,
0.45201706886291504,
0.6844140887260437,
-0.5953676700592041,
0.024316946044564247,
0.24926142394542694,
-0.4285576045513153,
-0.01518138125538826,
0.05892113223671913,
-0.2364925593137741,
-0.11369951069355011,
-0.09268675744533539,
0.4463390111923218,
0.10010891407728195,
-0.7566906809806824,
0.1904602199792862,
-0.12992548942565918,
-0.18969427049160004,
-0.5133495330810547,
0.13799503445625305,
0.09207266569137573,
0.3975362479686737,
0.4447743892669678,
-0.24247078597545624,
0.29466235637664795,
-0.2677365839481354,
0.2506754696369171,
0.7666407227516174,
-0.0009216060861945152,
-0.2138390839099884,
0.8178107738494873,
-0.031123574823141098,
-0.35046929121017456,
0.3495500981807709,
0.09473392367362976,
0.12919831275939941,
-0.06321332603693008,
0.786750853061676,
0.7678129076957703,
-0.2692307233810425,
-0.011591749265789986,
0.393649697303772,
-0.25065138936042786,
0.17915934324264526,
0.6476777195930481,
0.20892228186130524,
-0.6832770109176636,
-0.31359362602233887,
-0.8116678595542908,
-0.07678960263729095,
0.4514462351799011,
-0.7228010892868042,
0.25137022137641907,
-0.9218416213989258,
-0.33090683817863464,
0.1109473779797554,
-0.15187597274780273,
-0.5539495944976807,
0.2291134148836136,
-0.03632171452045441,
0.6567019820213318,
-0.4030754268169403,
0.9053617119789124,
0.8885263800621033,
-0.3889511823654175,
-0.892953634262085,
0.2356591522693634,
-0.4320380985736847,
-0.8790318369865417,
0.615660548210144,
-0.26666027307510376,
0.13420872390270233,
0.097750723361969,
-0.3930465281009674,
-0.5523160099983215,
1.019587755203247,
0.5995944142341614,
-0.8208982348442078,
-0.227519229054451,
0.10202944278717041,
0.3126518726348877,
-0.4780757427215576,
0.2835179567337036,
0.6598016023635864,
0.23088312149047852,
0.00913667306303978,
-0.766405463218689,
0.059926584362983704,
0.05845585837960243,
0.3650534749031067,
0.5394448637962341,
-0.5831957459449768,
0.7936164736747742,
-0.31655508279800415,
0.13458134233951569,
0.2236931473016739,
0.5190105438232422,
0.5847247838973999,
0.1693505197763443,
0.18062028288841248,
0.5930734276771545,
0.6210222840309143,
0.22071656584739685,
0.8990437984466553,
-0.37157106399536133,
0.2752262353897095,
1.0896517038345337,
-0.012147820554673672,
0.9970295429229736,
0.9559962749481201,
-0.3469870984554291,
0.1900394707918167,
0.5414133071899414,
0.2841409146785736,
0.5306043028831482,
0.3097900450229645,
-0.6361201405525208,
-0.2494824081659317,
-0.07520217448472977,
-0.2883983254432678,
0.17958688735961914,
0.31574326753616333,
-0.8372077345848083,
-0.018557725474238396,
-0.11100561171770096,
0.1280433088541031,
0.1097465232014656,
-0.26670295000076294,
0.9019576907157898,
0.008927217684686184,
-0.5204733610153198,
0.7486050724983215,
0.12218043208122253,
0.7819638848304749,
-0.647681713104248,
0.042880211025476456,
-0.40511611104011536,
0.10959742218255997,
-0.18541745841503143,
-0.4514874219894409,
0.14903661608695984,
-0.19737017154693604,
-0.28984901309013367,
-0.101649709045887,
0.7957402467727661,
-0.49672478437423706,
-0.37003251910209656,
0.009034418500959873,
0.6082131862640381,
0.12385156005620956,
-0.09660349786281586,
-0.633971095085144,
-0.10371387004852295,
-0.011008314788341522,
-0.5603491067886353,
0.8341402411460876,
0.14323841035366058,
0.3387800455093384,
0.7743991017341614,
0.7203665971755981,
0.4976888597011566,
-0.05455326288938522,
0.05766310170292854,
0.7512082457542419,
-0.6833513379096985,
-0.356932133436203,
-0.9412010908126831,
0.3475223481655121,
0.20236068964004517,
-0.1723388284444809,
0.3878887891769409,
0.5149483680725098,
0.517014741897583,
-0.28594717383384705,
0.7800010442733765,
-0.03694401681423187,
0.614395022392273,
-0.6853846311569214,
0.656836986541748,
-0.6010287404060364,
0.5313425064086914,
-0.2927810251712799,
-0.6740054488182068,
-0.30306434631347656,
0.5533040165901184,
-0.3160378038883209,
0.21074411273002625,
0.5614656805992126,
0.9373353123664856,
-0.14463303983211517,
-0.47263649106025696,
0.683085560798645,
0.2466503083705902,
0.40362903475761414,
0.8367835283279419,
0.573941171169281,
-0.056186493486166,
0.3249093294143677,
-0.20060762763023376,
-0.2876139283180237,
-0.34858202934265137,
-0.796394944190979,
-0.9127982258796692,
-0.5203180313110352,
-0.11853860318660736,
-0.35159721970558167,
0.1863614320755005,
1.1206042766571045,
0.524494469165802,
-0.7764727473258972,
-0.0977262407541275,
-0.11011326313018799,
-0.41994258761405945,
0.19622914493083954,
-0.20886699855327606,
0.19769838452339172,
-0.35884204506874084,
-0.7946612238883972,
0.439065545797348,
0.5791385173797607,
0.2637310028076172,
-0.3524608910083771,
-0.11599376797676086,
-0.17376820743083954,
0.35902130603790283,
0.5168983936309814,
0.1260891854763031,
-0.8028208017349243,
-0.41249892115592957,
-0.03930153697729111,
0.06401091814041138,
0.1986723244190216,
0.860234797000885,
-0.9259225130081177,
0.37159886956214905,
0.5901381373405457,
0.7347142696380615,
0.3856789469718933,
-0.008734695613384247,
0.6673944592475891,
-0.6832520365715027,
0.04829210415482521,
0.4803784489631653,
0.48285919427871704,
-0.03171961009502411,
-0.7318317890167236,
0.14971740543842316,
-0.061036594212055206,
-0.7781796455383301,
-0.7945947647094727,
0.4605906009674072,
-1.0957061052322388,
-0.23445533215999603,
1.2399518489837646,
-0.12244697660207748,
-0.16888682544231415,
-0.013374735601246357,
-0.43556877970695496,
-0.00562639394775033,
-0.5257271528244019,
0.8296679854393005,
0.26369234919548035,
-0.7097843885421753,
-0.07653521001338959,
-0.5088621377944946,
0.10022663325071335,
0.6679103374481201,
-0.7948346734046936,
-0.139491468667984,
0.4739150106906891,
0.4665934145450592,
-0.23484325408935547,
0.8236061930656433,
0.08068308234214783,
0.10555800050497055,
-0.42430922389030457,
-0.2561187148094177,
-0.166072815656662,
-0.06920554488897324,
-0.1897728592157364,
0.3232958912849426,
0.430597722530365,
0.014888627454638481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03563v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03563v2
|
EASSE-DE: Easier Automatic Sentence Simplification Evaluation for German
| 2024-04-04T16:18:37 | 2024-04-05T08:55:20 |
Regina Stodden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we propose EASSE-multi, a framework for easier automatic
sentence evaluation for languages other than English. Compared to the original
EASSE framework, EASSE-multi does not focus only on English. It contains
tokenizers and versions of text simplification evaluation metrics which are
suitable for multiple languages. In this paper, we exemplify the usage of
EASSE-multi for German TS, resulting in EASSE-DE. Further, we compare text
simplification results when evaluating with different language or tokenization
settings of the metrics. Based on this, we formulate recommendations on how to
make the evaluation of (German) TS models more transparent and better
comparable. The code of EASSE-multi and its German specialisation (EASSE-DE)
can be found at https://github.com/rstodden/easse-de.
|
[
-0.3161414563655853,
-0.9234431982040405,
0.7578561902046204,
0.5655547380447388,
-0.2894049882888794,
-0.02816532552242279,
-0.19881971180438995,
-0.38435328006744385,
0.22358807921409607,
-0.17328967154026031,
-0.6466498970985413,
-0.5820187926292419,
-0.8202009797096252,
0.755490243434906,
-0.40976765751838684,
0.7949693202972412,
-0.4914136230945587,
0.3206685185432434,
0.0232600849121809,
-0.22970056533813477,
0.015639616176486015,
-0.38944584131240845,
-0.8038479685783386,
-0.038719747215509415,
0.3920910358428955,
0.38764312863349915,
0.45485636591911316,
0.4815997779369354,
0.6215496063232422,
0.47828105092048645,
-0.20637404918670654,
0.2209191918373108,
-0.10579932481050491,
0.03225752338767052,
0.1389668881893158,
0.1787232607603073,
-0.606878936290741,
-0.38227421045303345,
0.2889106273651123,
0.6506802439689636,
0.05552298203110695,
0.17242617905139923,
-0.08903322368860245,
0.6566245555877686,
-0.6580485105514526,
0.3298344612121582,
0.06859701126813889,
-0.08427329361438751,
0.1819470375776291,
0.0921497642993927,
-0.3359515964984894,
-0.4162483215332031,
0.05871213227510452,
-0.4384780526161194,
-0.005030836444348097,
-0.17119646072387695,
0.7448096871376038,
0.12388478219509125,
-1.1099494695663452,
-0.20775747299194336,
-0.6002974510192871,
0.6445615887641907,
-0.446730375289917,
0.8286352157592773,
-0.12552879750728607,
0.22126787900924683,
0.3976367712020874,
-0.9652615189552307,
-0.25432276725769043,
-0.32495731115341187,
-0.37366634607315063,
0.06134279444813728,
-0.5026112198829651,
0.22342891991138458,
0.289902925491333,
0.23253780603408813,
-0.5747232437133789,
-0.07377301156520844,
-0.5047882795333862,
-0.4561866223812103,
0.6113943457603455,
0.008120881393551826,
0.26621004939079285,
-0.2208758294582367,
-0.2057090550661087,
0.08997748792171478,
-0.36483708024024963,
-0.1128268837928772,
0.3221006691455841,
0.14107386767864227,
-0.17335444688796997,
0.47673866152763367,
-0.5329711437225342,
0.49697181582450867,
-0.03184014558792114,
0.09958566725254059,
0.6940861940383911,
-0.36558422446250916,
-0.22956112027168274,
-0.054782502353191376,
0.7159348130226135,
0.4261498749256134,
0.3269597589969635,
-0.26600179076194763,
-0.24401545524597168,
0.15977700054645538,
-0.230047345161438,
-0.9695334434509277,
-0.11146558076143265,
0.10248130559921265,
-0.617281973361969,
0.023090099915862083,
0.5249553918838501,
-0.3837377727031708,
0.30948424339294434,
-0.3172367811203003,
0.3024330139160156,
-0.38562914729118347,
0.0011972050415351987,
0.45522674918174744,
-0.2880575656890869,
-0.13027600944042206,
0.5126142501831055,
-0.20779147744178772,
0.41109350323677063,
0.5469062328338623,
0.7350090742111206,
-0.16533824801445007,
-0.6779851913452148,
-0.8180029392242432,
0.2769289016723633,
-0.025368791073560715,
0.8340401649475098,
-0.41064587235450745,
-0.35757431387901306,
-0.24394170939922333,
0.17109477519989014,
0.12675759196281433,
0.009023098275065422,
0.9716744422912598,
-0.11362490057945251,
0.5182962417602539,
-0.22124606370925903,
-0.6603643894195557,
-0.43196314573287964,
-0.11667745560407639,
-0.9166169762611389,
0.9521139860153198,
0.015588406473398209,
-0.8290402889251709,
0.4652673304080963,
-1.1326689720153809,
-0.7824223637580872,
-0.09950698167085648,
0.1059945821762085,
-0.3397258520126343,
0.3475878834724426,
0.6000064611434937,
0.3203026056289673,
-0.11947851628065109,
0.20799200236797333,
-0.19176487624645233,
-0.4379118084907532,
-0.3532372713088989,
-0.5524091124534607,
1.0188889503479004,
0.37656286358833313,
-0.4925755560398102,
0.19826962053775787,
-0.6478277444839478,
0.4038739800453186,
-0.2243598848581314,
-0.22742487490177155,
-0.4766635000705719,
-0.437807559967041,
0.45024147629737854,
0.317926824092865,
0.13981440663337708,
-0.5502285361289978,
-0.20039169490337372,
-0.41011926531791687,
0.48689767718315125,
0.48865243792533875,
0.19907674193382263,
0.49782881140708923,
-0.18266750872135162,
0.6425766348838806,
-0.023944931104779243,
0.14951150119304657,
-0.377549409866333,
-0.3809708058834076,
-0.8725253939628601,
-0.6921179890632629,
0.69697105884552,
0.6622449159622192,
-0.42838743329048157,
0.6813186407089233,
-0.30323997139930725,
-0.4959299862384796,
-0.6953681111335754,
0.07843420654535294,
0.4438064694404602,
0.09403224289417267,
0.3043212294578552,
0.0007975107291713357,
-0.688327431678772,
-1.2636327743530273,
-0.5313421487808228,
-0.14507710933685303,
0.06420731544494629,
-0.18341851234436035,
0.6855561137199402,
-0.2590748071670532,
0.6254827976226807,
-0.3817102015018463,
-0.15458936989307404,
-0.4153955578804016,
0.20847879350185394,
-0.32132285833358765,
0.24006463587284088,
0.6281962394714355,
-0.7681120038032532,
-0.8731071352958679,
-0.2095605880022049,
-0.6526502966880798,
-0.49471035599708557,
0.10727822780609131,
0.12359994649887085,
0.34380897879600525,
0.759286642074585,
-0.46885111927986145,
0.4630883038043976,
0.44012686610221863,
-0.6189966797828674,
0.21016651391983032,
-0.30704882740974426,
0.6560129523277283,
-0.8966372013092041,
0.10616020858287811,
-0.010142388753592968,
-0.6666572093963623,
-0.5981072783470154,
0.37840306758880615,
0.47425970435142517,
0.09808188676834106,
-0.767763078212738,
0.7542240619659424,
-0.6164807081222534,
0.1953970342874527,
0.2847934663295746,
0.07744302600622177,
0.4030366837978363,
0.1890474557876587,
-0.03148370981216431,
0.6546847224235535,
0.5826155543327332,
-0.5540249943733215,
0.2003929764032364,
0.25072357058525085,
-0.35230231285095215,
0.5204446911811829,
-0.7925140857696533,
0.0010766916675493121,
-0.24691711366176605,
0.30288928747177124,
-0.6774725317955017,
0.09968098998069763,
-0.16098454594612122,
-0.06226535141468048,
0.018469443544745445,
0.2862005829811096,
-0.651237964630127,
-0.25390151143074036,
-0.583739697933197,
0.3581807315349579,
0.1516682505607605,
-0.5279101133346558,
0.7399104833602905,
0.1923372894525528,
-0.30934572219848633,
-0.32919973134994507,
-0.9726312160491943,
0.24894002079963684,
-0.4514777362346649,
-0.9107568860054016,
0.4923592805862427,
-0.3535104990005493,
-0.5890312194824219,
0.11141876131296158,
-0.06563720107078552,
-0.07218483090400696,
0.2036862075328827,
-0.15549534559249878,
-0.10612835735082626,
-0.13375267386436462,
0.1112208291888237,
0.5055414438247681,
-0.3860095739364624,
-0.38490456342697144,
0.16414721310138702,
0.27147358655929565,
-0.597377598285675,
-0.6261671185493469,
-0.5301217436790466,
0.9821605682373047,
0.3667449653148651,
-0.14825549721717834,
0.43744760751724243,
0.6631773114204407,
-0.2796897292137146,
-0.1629381626844406,
-0.5925270318984985,
-0.22044306993484497,
-0.4930014908313751,
0.5007747411727905,
-0.77644944190979,
-0.8220415115356445,
0.38994234800338745,
-0.14479365944862366,
0.09508103132247925,
0.8172084093093872,
0.4594564735889435,
0.06849582493305206,
1.2854279279708862,
0.9755945801734924,
0.24494005739688873,
0.18100383877754211,
-0.06283602863550186,
0.3758099377155304,
-0.19934852421283722,
-0.08482420444488525,
-0.649103581905365,
-0.09352704137563705,
-0.3693713843822479,
0.03493643179535866,
0.433184951543808,
0.1597324013710022,
-0.3627992868423462,
0.49488532543182373,
-0.23487718403339386,
0.5796118378639221,
0.2702237665653229,
-0.05870220810174942,
0.8286401629447937,
0.07795608043670654,
-0.24262183904647827,
-0.2540315091609955,
-0.6888361573219299,
-0.786628246307373,
0.7715811133384705,
0.3586984872817993,
0.38827240467071533,
0.3043915629386902,
1.1886488199234009,
0.3476346731185913,
0.10356009006500244,
-0.7609055042266846,
0.585138738155365,
-0.39628785848617554,
-0.22756701707839966,
-0.2875634729862213,
-0.5736971497535706,
-0.7070736289024353,
0.27406632900238037,
0.09238903969526291,
-0.5317022204399109,
-0.0757359117269516,
-0.2575289309024811,
-0.238074392080307,
0.0437343567609787,
-1.391701579093933,
0.8672616481781006,
-0.2732098698616028,
0.20474684238433838,
-0.18566472828388214,
-0.3558163046836853,
0.146208718419075,
-0.27448123693466187,
0.5437431335449219,
0.05531264841556549,
-0.4755716919898987,
0.6467480063438416,
-0.5829786658287048,
0.5781883597373962,
-0.017279556021094322,
-0.15803350508213043,
0.06550019234418869,
0.22965216636657715,
0.4537575840950012,
0.17698577046394348,
-0.2681538760662079,
0.15307891368865967,
0.10939832031726837,
-0.07057226449251175,
-0.4221210777759552,
0.7753536105155945,
-0.4261063039302826,
-0.5332047939300537,
-0.21681059896945953,
-0.3254781663417816,
-0.05397665500640869,
0.35572969913482666,
0.2589690089225769,
0.3823034465312958,
-0.6830455660820007,
-0.005657315719872713,
0.06465549767017365,
-0.17632530629634857,
0.6732202172279358,
0.7826706171035767,
-0.3040001392364502,
-0.31241652369499207,
0.3726029694080353,
0.02823246829211712,
0.1583537608385086,
0.31218916177749634,
0.175462007522583,
-0.4660424590110779,
-0.012500422075390816,
-0.6490685343742371,
0.12827657163143158,
-1.1123937368392944,
-0.26562419533729553,
-1.0769212245941162,
0.0005674786516465247,
-0.45302408933639526,
-0.3838360607624054,
-0.03367050364613533,
-1.1205832958221436,
0.1592162400484085,
-0.5668888688087463,
0.5226589441299438,
0.7419680953025818,
-0.2530706822872162,
0.2069673240184784,
-0.760734498500824,
0.46913254261016846,
0.06289059668779373,
0.32164448499679565,
-0.3620760440826416,
-0.373259037733078,
0.038012031465768814,
-0.06106831505894661,
-0.17917008697986603,
-1.037273645401001,
0.08992290496826172,
0.5343730449676514,
0.5753073692321777,
0.21936626732349396,
-0.05475590005517006,
0.8642686605453491,
-0.7241125106811523,
0.48631158471107483,
0.2717778980731964,
-1.522794485092163,
0.32701385021209717,
0.09066062420606613,
0.5839549899101257,
0.782358705997467,
0.19143125414848328,
-0.724233865737915,
-0.7674424052238464,
-0.8846111297607422,
-1.1773349046707153,
0.5955324172973633,
0.3087467849254608,
0.20985549688339233,
-0.13899052143096924,
-0.026255343109369278,
0.3575286865234375,
0.23664627969264984,
-0.9143115878105164,
-0.6091521382331848,
0.0688445195555687,
-0.3429364562034607,
-0.10864871740341187,
-0.2195076197385788,
-0.01246442086994648,
-0.31055164337158203,
0.743200421333313,
0.16755716502666473,
0.15834099054336548,
0.1238018274307251,
-0.41505658626556396,
-0.04746241122484207,
0.5560252070426941,
0.2092699408531189,
0.5887247323989868,
0.24516423046588898,
0.03641462326049805,
0.5796721577644348,
-0.06392936408519745,
0.26608043909072876,
0.25933825969696045,
-0.5432863831520081,
0.6553941369056702,
0.5534207224845886,
0.714073657989502,
0.11632547527551651,
-0.6211578249931335,
0.7590290904045105,
-0.14793696999549866,
-0.4514507055282593,
-0.07553549855947495,
-0.3452472388744354,
0.07608721405267715,
0.14709536731243134,
0.15910546481609344,
0.04601190611720085,
0.6244959831237793,
-0.46222156286239624,
0.5417888760566711,
0.06261755526065826,
-0.04534275829792023,
-0.024751456454396248,
0.4376595914363861,
0.4031763970851898,
-0.45870035886764526,
0.07221110910177231,
-0.5427602529525757,
-0.7238258719444275,
0.5872408151626587,
0.35623329877853394,
1.1186436414718628,
-0.4517817199230194,
0.4578448235988617,
0.3973223865032196,
0.5435624718666077,
-0.2315744310617447,
0.7504708170890808,
0.1515062153339386,
-0.1180751770734787,
-0.6540936827659607,
-0.41116636991500854,
-0.04892124608159065,
-0.2288709431886673,
-0.4751078188419342,
0.7819892168045044,
0.02281677909195423,
-0.10335084050893784,
-0.021601252257823944,
-0.2759021818637848,
-0.964030385017395,
0.09558972716331482,
-0.028629740700125694,
1.1623982191085815,
-1.1713480949401855,
0.5897656679153442,
0.8467405438423157,
-0.3543504774570465,
-0.7136558890342712,
0.12989239394664764,
0.11603841185569763,
-0.2328406125307083,
0.7408747673034668,
0.365742564201355,
-0.4505743086338043,
-0.06586728990077972,
0.10488637536764145,
-0.8002248406410217,
0.8590570092201233,
0.5862216949462891,
-0.4704766273498535,
-0.1625581532716751,
0.11235460638999939,
0.6877889037132263,
-0.3402678370475769,
0.6292344331741333,
0.4327220320701599,
0.958690345287323,
-0.4591228663921356,
-1.3270074129104614,
0.04515714943408966,
-0.22274281084537506,
-0.2899697422981262,
0.3694117069244385,
-0.5475590825080872,
0.681873619556427,
-0.1683560609817505,
-0.4721102714538574,
-0.09516952931880951,
0.41966763138771057,
-0.15535813570022583,
0.14694324135780334,
0.6697537302970886,
0.4979745149612427,
0.6390920281410217,
-0.21573179960250854,
0.8419561386108398,
-0.3534946143627167,
0.41913971304893494,
1.0749967098236084,
-0.16414253413677216,
0.635763943195343,
0.48343828320503235,
-0.10705181211233139,
0.5671275854110718,
0.36098116636276245,
0.08295013755559921,
0.5938949584960938,
0.022750064730644226,
-0.05812700465321541,
-0.15754246711730957,
0.2678346633911133,
-0.23698288202285767,
0.5792443156242371,
-0.018090590834617615,
-0.24404235184192657,
-0.8157617449760437,
0.18879811465740204,
0.0773279145359993,
0.16891834139823914,
-0.22816841304302216,
0.8947843909263611,
0.15720173716545105,
-0.3675115704536438,
0.2891984283924103,
0.6024141311645508,
0.6244373321533203,
-0.599600613117218,
0.1662750393152237,
-0.1762378066778183,
0.05095518380403519,
-0.3976443111896515,
-0.4927547872066498,
0.6675998568534851,
0.35515740513801575,
0.0735451877117157,
-0.4834107756614685,
0.38201215863227844,
-0.5147375464439392,
-0.9322622418403625,
0.6260457038879395,
1.3036164045333862,
0.0820523053407669,
0.09451675415039062,
-0.9297756552696228,
-0.06145220994949341,
0.13817273080348969,
-0.4726017713546753,
-0.20727379620075226,
0.8466485738754272,
-0.2321900874376297,
0.6859735250473022,
0.11067601293325424,
-0.10850761830806732,
-0.12889409065246582,
0.43280598521232605,
0.6093612909317017,
-0.5150185227394104,
-0.9743044972419739,
-1.0130479335784912,
0.5701552629470825,
-0.2197055220603943,
-0.13505394756793976,
1.0621228218078613,
0.9930222034454346,
0.9348869919776917,
-0.10159045457839966,
0.8957810997962952,
-0.24483497440814972,
0.5882474184036255,
-0.4632444679737091,
0.5579079389572144,
-0.7280404567718506,
0.32581692934036255,
-0.6510578989982605,
-1.025903344154358,
-0.4481774568557739,
0.7316204309463501,
-0.17107819020748138,
0.3412741422653198,
1.3489223718643188,
0.6315299272537231,
-0.46805256605148315,
-0.0075049446895718575,
0.2863985598087311,
0.03399961441755295,
-0.004894360899925232,
0.29138630628585815,
0.5315558910369873,
-0.557536780834198,
0.7916832566261292,
-0.40012913942337036,
-0.10932929068803787,
0.20962125062942505,
-1.2388677597045898,
-0.7862098813056946,
-0.7002878189086914,
-0.6043558120727539,
-0.055661994963884354,
-0.009515224024653435,
1.1280291080474854,
0.4484138488769531,
-0.9233940243721008,
-0.11928115040063858,
0.05352908372879028,
-0.07867202162742615,
-0.3456771671772003,
-0.17379964888095856,
0.690726101398468,
-0.2821251153945923,
-1.1145222187042236,
0.3549064099788666,
0.3416141867637634,
0.06236247718334198,
0.02090580202639103,
-0.11860879510641098,
0.05837614834308624,
0.050606757402420044,
0.7089298367500305,
-0.3448942303657532,
-0.6711851358413696,
-0.22329430282115936,
-0.04818426072597504,
-0.24446436762809753,
-0.03708607330918312,
0.9762986302375793,
-0.5132572054862976,
0.24147197604179382,
0.40557199716567993,
0.241724893450737,
0.40479525923728943,
-0.12934038043022156,
0.7820414304733276,
-0.7722808122634888,
0.4384828507900238,
0.040099188685417175,
0.8142460584640503,
0.3865741789340973,
-0.29465940594673157,
0.6306074857711792,
-0.24244922399520874,
-0.10168176889419556,
-0.6870207190513611,
0.3514798879623413,
-0.5636273622512817,
-0.5466675162315369,
1.373910665512085,
-0.20902487635612488,
0.10479229688644409,
-0.3518959581851959,
-0.5162593722343445,
0.11283157765865326,
-0.5774247646331787,
0.5937974452972412,
0.8711549639701843,
0.18284782767295837,
-0.11103541404008865,
-0.4502517879009247,
0.7200114727020264,
0.5378134250640869,
-0.8767051100730896,
0.004841843154281378,
0.7015389204025269,
0.3284572958946228,
-0.19192035496234894,
0.6476806402206421,
-0.12686872482299805,
0.42666733264923096,
-0.3225942850112915,
-0.1871393322944641,
-0.34559082984924316,
-0.34717050194740295,
-0.5960495471954346,
0.10427974164485931,
-0.08163467794656754,
0.34521591663360596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03561v1
|
Select and Summarize: Scene Saliency for Movie Script Summarization
| 2024-04-04T16:16:53 | 2024-04-04T16:16:53 |
Rohit Saxena, Frank Keller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abstractive summarization for long-form narrative texts such as movie scripts
is challenging due to the computational and memory constraints of current
language models. A movie script typically comprises a large number of scenes;
however, only a fraction of these scenes are salient, i.e., important for
understanding the overall narrative. The salience of a scene can be
operationalized by considering it as salient if it is mentioned in the summary.
Automatically identifying salient scenes is difficult due to the lack of
suitable datasets. In this work, we introduce a scene saliency dataset that
consists of human-annotated salient scenes for 100 movies. We propose a
two-stage abstractive summarization approach which first identifies the salient
scenes in script and then generates a summary using only those scenes. Using
QA-based evaluation, we show that our model outperforms previous
state-of-the-art summarization methods and reflects the information content of
a movie more accurately than a model that takes the whole movie script as
input.
|
[
-0.3615729808807373,
-0.3205123841762543,
0.7074093818664551,
0.23366519808769226,
-0.6291232705116272,
-0.048540886491537094,
0.0812315121293068,
-0.6221393942832947,
0.3059917390346527,
0.5313749313354492,
-0.5978823900222778,
-0.632706880569458,
-0.4728488624095917,
0.19381126761436462,
-0.8333932757377625,
1.2917038202285767,
0.23919805884361267,
-0.30634722113609314,
-0.2726689279079437,
-0.021454839035868645,
-0.09518557041883469,
-0.24244563281536102,
-0.3339599072933197,
0.265544593334198,
0.557381808757782,
0.353668212890625,
0.584714949131012,
0.6327024102210999,
0.6683534383773804,
0.22605852782726288,
-0.04140397161245346,
0.060161080211400986,
-0.21840670704841614,
0.31667253375053406,
-0.14828717708587646,
-0.1680452525615692,
-0.15105238556861877,
-0.2854651212692261,
0.6047732830047607,
0.7587051391601562,
0.4851479232311249,
0.48771536350250244,
-0.3436354398727417,
0.8467554450035095,
-0.8708109855651855,
0.4271423816680908,
-0.21016272902488708,
0.2136651873588562,
-0.05524502694606781,
0.23453961312770844,
-0.02593524567782879,
-0.6594996452331543,
0.35845324397087097,
-0.28869006037712097,
0.3700621426105499,
-0.13412803411483765,
0.6638073325157166,
0.3500807583332062,
-0.1787872165441513,
0.05844597518444061,
-0.5254881978034973,
0.7410975694656372,
-0.4096599221229553,
-0.01612956076860428,
0.42818692326545715,
0.38926565647125244,
0.3302096426486969,
-0.5040481686592102,
-0.2886967957019806,
-0.3485073745250702,
-0.177703857421875,
0.20253776013851166,
-0.08485904335975647,
-0.04052728787064552,
0.20983397960662842,
0.6536282300949097,
-0.3232192397117615,
-0.20219466090202332,
-0.43691617250442505,
-0.10114815831184387,
0.4885154962539673,
0.16554546356201172,
0.29810628294944763,
-0.3461163640022278,
-0.605888307094574,
-0.15011650323867798,
-0.13310284912586212,
0.2061029076576233,
0.04539463296532631,
-0.11841399222612381,
-0.005258013494312763,
0.6317518353462219,
-0.47205933928489685,
0.46655991673469543,
-0.06770019233226776,
-0.196334108710289,
0.015341714955866337,
-0.5977120399475098,
-0.10627778619527817,
0.17779967188835144,
0.48244959115982056,
1.0454623699188232,
0.20209187269210815,
0.03808135911822319,
-0.19223663210868835,
0.019827041774988174,
0.09336963295936584,
-0.7574174404144287,
-0.265220582485199,
0.5135396718978882,
-0.26252463459968567,
-0.3483203649520874,
0.08903275430202484,
-0.9707149267196655,
-0.5692380666732788,
-0.06465411931276321,
0.20054912567138672,
-0.40911003947257996,
0.12852948904037476,
-0.5301601886749268,
-0.5554352402687073,
0.30153602361679077,
0.6260407567024231,
-1.0034023523330688,
0.08517993986606598,
0.2894464135169983,
0.8786355257034302,
-0.3375215530395508,
-0.4313538074493408,
-0.42764782905578613,
0.49878448247909546,
-0.5019126534461975,
1.0526165962219238,
-0.47311148047447205,
-0.22416511178016663,
0.003178487764671445,
-0.16350342333316803,
0.06908853352069855,
-0.41824597120285034,
0.2835359573364258,
-0.31403568387031555,
0.3662540316581726,
-0.06888808310031891,
0.016532033681869507,
-0.3021288812160492,
0.0558609701693058,
-0.838005006313324,
0.7816624045372009,
0.46355754137039185,
-0.6727828979492188,
0.38458627462387085,
-0.5958849191665649,
-0.50358647108078,
-0.5125336050987244,
-0.01864042691886425,
-0.5000497102737427,
0.35643789172172546,
0.5244392156600952,
0.2923136353492737,
0.23591527342796326,
0.173482745885849,
0.09824895113706589,
-0.41735559701919556,
0.5482020378112793,
0.011267486028373241,
-0.02265803888440132,
0.2214530110359192,
-0.02178223244845867,
0.38212406635284424,
-0.7974090576171875,
-0.13722631335258484,
-0.07606443762779236,
-0.012858113273978233,
-0.08548189699649811,
-0.21574242413043976,
0.24952717125415802,
0.35401153564453125,
0.3294621407985687,
-0.03716238588094711,
-0.23643341660499573,
-0.5860289931297302,
-0.1234702318906784,
0.3928462266921997,
0.3697015047073364,
0.5343465209007263,
-0.14099469780921936,
0.5547934174537659,
0.10457180440425873,
0.07943841814994812,
-0.9096351861953735,
-0.19270771741867065,
-0.7499045729637146,
-0.5139333009719849,
0.04595969617366791,
0.3996475338935852,
-0.3381709158420563,
0.3940849006175995,
0.1213572770357132,
-0.09724568575620651,
-0.26907819509506226,
-0.22132831811904907,
0.6300367712974548,
0.2431093156337738,
0.2696479856967926,
-0.5218729376792908,
-0.609289288520813,
-1.1960409879684448,
0.015271455980837345,
-0.2244880348443985,
-0.5367266535758972,
-0.04691256210207939,
0.2827775478363037,
0.20505991578102112,
0.9678967595100403,
-0.8066216707229614,
-0.5128782391548157,
-0.6845459342002869,
-0.10093005746603012,
0.12937845289707184,
0.4017941355705261,
0.3056619465351105,
-0.5250532627105713,
-0.2415977418422699,
-0.058253899216651917,
-0.8304036855697632,
-0.03725245222449303,
-0.015920884907245636,
-0.13488337397575378,
0.05575791746377945,
0.5092878937721252,
-0.5772334337234497,
0.6003779768943787,
0.04335314780473709,
-0.2829226851463318,
0.5415574312210083,
-0.2751559019088745,
0.46857643127441406,
-1.0860087871551514,
0.2410702109336853,
0.05600936338305473,
-0.22426970303058624,
-0.4654943346977234,
-0.13637980818748474,
-0.03457357734441757,
-0.5189672112464905,
-0.4095744788646698,
0.5093877911567688,
-0.2989099323749542,
-0.6342508792877197,
-0.34350621700286865,
0.41626062989234924,
0.30932170152664185,
0.8835427761077881,
0.14883381128311157,
0.6098192930221558,
0.21296003460884094,
-0.47877177596092224,
0.2788189649581909,
0.2521122694015503,
-0.28705406188964844,
0.4120979905128479,
-0.5138773918151855,
-0.3672880232334137,
-0.5381180644035339,
0.3121751546859741,
-1.2754970788955688,
-1.0561528205871582,
0.019284235313534737,
-0.2594519257545471,
-0.12702874839305878,
-0.2401188164949417,
-0.3249642848968506,
0.21976059675216675,
-0.6002362966537476,
0.4087437391281128,
0.5921955108642578,
-0.2648622393608093,
0.47388342022895813,
0.45292210578918457,
-0.6342304944992065,
-0.4627740681171417,
-0.3208920955657959,
0.028307227417826653,
-0.22275148332118988,
-0.2871347665786743,
0.3682134747505188,
0.4091191589832306,
-0.313850075006485,
-0.3437715768814087,
-0.27373814582824707,
-0.280850350856781,
-0.1482822746038437,
0.4430948495864868,
0.30763253569602966,
0.2129097431898117,
0.05221867561340332,
0.2749674320220947,
-0.32274630665779114,
0.011648768559098244,
0.0248704981058836,
0.28654372692108154,
0.19801613688468933,
-0.07044432312250137,
-0.5543590188026428,
0.7094079852104187,
0.7385388016700745,
-0.4390374422073364,
0.035722848027944565,
0.6756186485290527,
-0.31735238432884216,
0.1015218123793602,
-0.4188785254955292,
-0.05162102356553078,
-0.27010661363601685,
0.9208295345306396,
-0.03216961771249771,
-0.4132601022720337,
0.6038703918457031,
-0.02780453860759735,
0.022373734042048454,
0.5436103343963623,
0.31845182180404663,
-0.2755485475063324,
0.9867268800735474,
0.8225617408752441,
0.10847201943397522,
0.8493858575820923,
-0.1159910261631012,
-0.07205231487751007,
-0.8794172406196594,
-0.4573330581188202,
-0.31980621814727783,
-0.20725920796394348,
-0.06943434476852417,
-0.4141220450401306,
0.5914801359176636,
0.14928875863552094,
0.26375842094421387,
0.253656804561615,
-0.13995890319347382,
1.0980112552642822,
0.5002250075340271,
0.1284494549036026,
0.4628182649612427,
0.05212661251425743,
0.16532829403877258,
0.167422816157341,
-0.06198703497648239,
-0.6040569543838501,
0.5793367028236389,
0.3446531593799591,
0.4937410056591034,
0.3096441328525543,
0.5543243885040283,
0.18150594830513,
-0.29471391439437866,
-0.4325237274169922,
0.7305866479873657,
-0.26849502325057983,
-0.3540026545524597,
-0.34866905212402344,
0.13468483090400696,
-0.6105655431747437,
0.3632529675960541,
-0.0557258203625679,
-0.9623202681541443,
0.4442982077598572,
0.015173595398664474,
-0.6805816292762756,
-0.10828042030334473,
-0.9638453722000122,
0.8934184908866882,
0.08238039910793304,
-0.3898358643054962,
-0.3429163992404938,
-1.1026946306228638,
0.486530065536499,
0.036130521446466446,
0.05481913685798645,
-0.37899523973464966,
-0.24287386238574982,
0.5265976786613464,
-0.32244306802749634,
0.8629246354103088,
0.08573074638843536,
0.10060162842273712,
0.18454715609550476,
0.07284175604581833,
0.3674648106098175,
0.18917137384414673,
0.1418261080980301,
-0.14236389100551605,
-0.038952507078647614,
-0.49417853355407715,
-0.6156957745552063,
0.4845482409000397,
-0.31143778562545776,
-0.2531173527240753,
-0.6111923456192017,
-0.5820993781089783,
0.021750401705503464,
0.19668178260326385,
0.063694529235363,
0.6202318072319031,
-0.4735274910926819,
-0.42605218291282654,
0.5072216391563416,
-0.3033949136734009,
0.967666506767273,
0.029190486297011375,
-0.6349124908447266,
-0.7721524834632874,
0.8573152422904968,
-0.164281964302063,
0.40643152594566345,
0.3419800400733948,
-0.2347068339586258,
-0.5381221175193787,
-0.6642336845397949,
-0.6526867151260376,
-0.11841433495283127,
-0.8919755220413208,
0.11646116524934769,
-0.7949041724205017,
-0.08837173879146576,
-0.012390756979584694,
-0.3707271218299866,
-0.20424319803714752,
-0.7680441737174988,
0.02936958707869053,
-0.17425870895385742,
0.33391836285591125,
0.6892053484916687,
0.2864375710487366,
0.06059844046831131,
-0.7132513523101807,
0.5416750311851501,
0.6193397045135498,
0.2965281009674072,
-0.13222506642341614,
-0.3706319034099579,
-0.6399102210998535,
-0.6130350232124329,
-0.09432833641767502,
-0.6248505711555481,
0.4680682122707367,
0.23222428560256958,
0.0850517526268959,
0.4022311568260193,
0.05779997631907463,
0.5991866588592529,
-0.1244766041636467,
1.0663073062896729,
0.39402738213539124,
-0.7250649929046631,
0.9725874662399292,
-0.4601379632949829,
0.8894028663635254,
0.8981455564498901,
0.022330082952976227,
-0.200616717338562,
-0.5378291010856628,
-0.4624505639076233,
-1.1382561922073364,
0.925855278968811,
0.4348997175693512,
0.0311876367777586,
0.09295686334371567,
-0.036290016025304794,
0.24470537900924683,
0.4408622682094574,
-0.41808199882507324,
-0.00877522211521864,
-0.29750150442123413,
-0.25257766246795654,
-0.034404151141643524,
-0.38625049591064453,
-0.04863276705145836,
-0.02517031319439411,
0.12494020164012909,
0.02617315575480461,
-0.1501416265964508,
0.42831096053123474,
-0.2215084433555603,
-0.103709876537323,
0.4395855665206909,
0.5820332765579224,
0.9250074028968811,
-0.7704649567604065,
0.26710569858551025,
0.09302374720573425,
-0.5723400115966797,
-0.12530818581581116,
0.10437490046024323,
-0.33195146918296814,
0.3510083854198456,
0.4407992660999298,
0.5889893174171448,
0.5839473605155945,
-1.0158498287200928,
0.5532326698303223,
0.12275204062461853,
0.33378294110298157,
-0.4095987379550934,
0.14891178905963898,
-0.3074096143245697,
0.370289146900177,
0.5348005890846252,
0.25049537420272827,
0.5246450901031494,
-0.7827522158622742,
0.11916171759366989,
0.005230964161455631,
-0.3318437933921814,
-0.22668716311454773,
0.4079837203025818,
0.33748137950897217,
-0.024696890264749527,
0.37141501903533936,
-0.1165354996919632,
-0.3727118968963623,
0.587141215801239,
0.216371089220047,
1.174312949180603,
-0.01143780630081892,
0.28785982728004456,
0.5619975328445435,
-0.15105710923671722,
0.15998996794223785,
-0.0986194834113121,
-0.15675275027751923,
-0.044287797063589096,
-0.4602566361427307,
-0.7194597125053406,
-0.6442832350730896,
-0.3099934756755829,
-0.4402996301651001,
0.061597660183906555,
-0.6321247816085815,
-0.044191874563694,
0.13324852287769318,
-0.27720415592193604,
0.05286398530006409,
0.4249429702758789,
0.1184803768992424,
0.2913123071193695,
-0.6713048815727234,
0.45083460211753845,
0.4823716878890991,
-0.981437087059021,
-0.12894436717033386,
0.14564557373523712,
-0.3255329132080078,
-0.4032188951969147,
0.5122038125991821,
0.3943808078765869,
-0.041793111711740494,
-0.06426402926445007,
-0.22958946228027344,
-0.7671126127243042,
1.0174518823623657,
0.16394419968128204,
-0.20238135755062103,
-0.2700919508934021,
-0.21944834291934967,
0.5101360082626343,
-0.5591219663619995,
0.2995170056819916,
0.7992090582847595,
0.21463346481323242,
0.4918310046195984,
-0.7096874713897705,
-0.25303593277931213,
-0.3504410684108734,
0.14428842067718506,
0.32024723291397095,
-0.39108923077583313,
0.533668577671051,
-0.7868307828903198,
-0.2975158989429474,
0.09128012508153915,
0.7417677640914917,
0.4608478248119354,
0.7913956046104431,
0.3782731890678406,
0.17433153092861176,
0.3379523456096649,
-0.029375141486525536,
1.1131302118301392,
-0.02665599435567856,
-0.08101629465818405,
1.1622928380966187,
-0.12431629747152328,
0.6791348457336426,
0.5990945100784302,
-0.36696648597717285,
0.4024388790130615,
0.575094997882843,
-0.1062178760766983,
0.80816251039505,
0.019924378022551537,
-0.4890039265155792,
-0.14006471633911133,
-0.3934890031814575,
-0.09942314773797989,
0.24661734700202942,
0.008932658471167088,
-0.5990312695503235,
-0.5033881664276123,
-0.11969169974327087,
-0.19079148769378662,
0.06346415728330612,
-0.5425735116004944,
1.2626607418060303,
0.0012914218241348863,
-0.7875040769577026,
0.1579674333333969,
-0.19077496230602264,
0.1995360553264618,
-0.6647652983665466,
-0.41300714015960693,
-0.43354707956314087,
-0.1044435054063797,
-0.4758702218532562,
-0.6360732913017273,
0.19715319573879242,
0.4243808388710022,
-0.7082622051239014,
0.15870633721351624,
0.3163866400718689,
-0.7950002551078796,
-0.6906433701515198,
-0.45744165778160095,
0.1179814264178276,
0.5301476120948792,
-0.22181366384029388,
-0.1803358495235443,
0.1169348731637001,
0.1435699164867401,
0.3311401903629303,
0.635031521320343,
0.3093734383583069,
-0.29992350935935974,
0.4552893042564392,
0.5268079042434692,
-0.21379785239696503,
-0.3394203782081604,
0.37192556262016296,
0.7694458365440369,
-0.9581285715103149,
-0.6972299218177795,
-0.6923385858535767,
0.9540541172027588,
-0.40040233731269836,
-0.3344208300113678,
0.5998708605766296,
0.7185086607933044,
0.3801431357860565,
-0.5863320827484131,
0.8101205229759216,
0.006290287710726261,
0.4246300458908081,
-0.7355287671089172,
0.3449164032936096,
-0.025829428806900978,
0.5301353335380554,
-0.5509403347969055,
-1.1402897834777832,
-0.4156857430934906,
0.5370485782623291,
-0.18012011051177979,
-0.02594209834933281,
0.9068552255630493,
0.5863818526268005,
0.21643811464309692,
-0.2296610325574875,
0.43376657366752625,
-0.07929188758134842,
0.039831314235925674,
0.5253026485443115,
1.052242398262024,
-0.3873330354690552,
0.4908241331577301,
-0.21308550238609314,
-0.2631681561470032,
-0.46762287616729736,
-0.9286981821060181,
-0.9167696237564087,
-0.49423345923423767,
-0.6110584139823914,
-0.08260377496480942,
0.13429409265518188,
0.9322623610496521,
0.39379996061325073,
-0.9483147859573364,
-0.12567304074764252,
0.3463292717933655,
0.4506605863571167,
-0.31575721502304077,
-0.16854673624038696,
0.8046323657035828,
-0.29954490065574646,
-1.0379871129989624,
0.3669991195201874,
0.842896580696106,
0.37836146354675293,
-0.35497406125068665,
0.43495306372642517,
0.013360988348722458,
0.12523823976516724,
0.6999974250793457,
0.08957474678754807,
-0.6595509648323059,
-0.1235700249671936,
-0.2709522545337677,
0.011874816380441189,
-0.1205645352602005,
0.6196138262748718,
-0.6619523763656616,
0.571549654006958,
0.4323793947696686,
0.03953080624341965,
0.633063793182373,
0.4225132167339325,
0.7797749638557434,
-1.026190161705017,
0.15045228600502014,
0.04134118929505348,
0.19664159417152405,
0.2143162488937378,
-0.3541663587093353,
0.43736010789871216,
-0.1391083300113678,
-0.31643903255462646,
-0.7215827703475952,
0.3303697109222412,
-1.408370852470398,
-0.08669833838939667,
0.814647912979126,
-0.07063371688127518,
-0.28204622864723206,
-0.2536641061306,
-0.6151233315467834,
-0.04699702560901642,
-0.6395509839057922,
0.8223589658737183,
0.4392980933189392,
-0.2602750062942505,
-0.2830926775932312,
-0.221814826130867,
0.7987130284309387,
0.007703031878918409,
-0.8659205436706543,
0.30389443039894104,
1.007655382156372,
0.09571924060583115,
0.29677581787109375,
0.48007214069366455,
-0.3379049003124237,
0.4917438328266144,
-0.009975778870284557,
0.14089332520961761,
-0.2407776564359665,
-0.4881970286369324,
-0.3979809880256653,
0.48937898874282837,
0.003868037834763527,
-0.2759498357772827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03558v1
|
How does Multi-Task Training Affect Transformer In-Context Capabilities? Investigations with Function Classes
| 2024-04-04T16:15:23 | 2024-04-04T16:15:23 |
Harmon Bhasin, Timothy Ossowski, Yiqiao Zhong, Junjie Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLM) have recently shown the extraordinary ability to
perform unseen tasks based on few-shot examples provided as text, also known as
in-context learning (ICL). While recent works have attempted to understand the
mechanisms driving ICL, few have explored training strategies that incentivize
these models to generalize to multiple tasks. Multi-task learning (MTL) for
generalist models is a promising direction that offers transfer learning
potential, enabling large parameterized models to be trained from simpler,
related tasks. In this work, we investigate the combination of MTL with ICL to
build models that efficiently learn tasks while being robust to
out-of-distribution examples. We propose several effective curriculum learning
strategies that allow ICL models to achieve higher data efficiency and more
stable convergence. Our experiments reveal that ICL models can effectively
learn difficult tasks by training on progressively harder tasks while mixing in
prior tasks, denoted as mixed curriculum in this work. Our code and models are
available at https://github.com/harmonbhasin/curriculum_learning_icl .
|
[
-0.37667959928512573,
-0.3509768843650818,
0.36038023233413696,
0.031940169632434845,
-0.11014424264431,
0.06605846434831619,
-0.39675527811050415,
-0.3167691230773926,
-0.7068758606910706,
0.6157583594322205,
-0.5456262826919556,
-0.18728366494178772,
-0.8208945393562317,
0.019709454849362373,
-0.38499483466148376,
1.4624309539794922,
-0.07118909806013107,
0.054442111402750015,
-0.3285754919052124,
-0.2195838838815689,
-0.7133040428161621,
-0.6809540390968323,
-0.4522940516471863,
-0.6226556897163391,
0.23695801198482513,
0.6275120377540588,
0.1757432222366333,
0.2492864578962326,
0.5637750625610352,
0.1977890133857727,
0.22252164781093597,
0.1311960071325302,
-0.4815758764743805,
0.22367174923419952,
-0.09384540468454361,
-0.510043740272522,
-0.11958622932434082,
-0.09067957103252411,
0.6604119539260864,
0.6922931671142578,
-0.037164103239774704,
0.23855020105838776,
0.7666008472442627,
0.3902241587638855,
-0.790608286857605,
0.4484950602054596,
-0.8045859932899475,
-0.10614514350891113,
-0.21023967862129211,
-0.0354846753180027,
-0.8235988020896912,
0.29310673475265503,
0.1953292042016983,
-0.39062127470970154,
0.35787680745124817,
-0.1392676681280136,
0.6093314290046692,
0.2558005452156067,
-0.7262900471687317,
-0.4626920521259308,
-0.8277391791343689,
1.1523560285568237,
-0.31857195496559143,
0.5179437398910522,
0.36240509152412415,
0.40740767121315,
0.12260392308235168,
-0.7728311419487,
-0.31128615140914917,
-0.21932251751422882,
-0.22060070931911469,
0.17038710415363312,
0.06969672441482544,
-0.07174734026193619,
0.4830927550792694,
0.11734287440776825,
-0.1365649551153183,
0.14533916115760803,
-0.25502288341522217,
0.23547783493995667,
0.14732296764850616,
0.26631247997283936,
0.09907369315624237,
0.1355481892824173,
-0.4344111979007721,
-0.4506029784679413,
-0.8039356470108032,
0.5194718241691589,
0.270190566778183,
0.416195809841156,
-0.2961108088493347,
0.44629335403442383,
0.17898549139499664,
0.6181331872940063,
0.23289334774017334,
-0.3337652385234833,
0.0636288970708847,
-0.33964109420776367,
-0.24944338202476501,
-0.37396836280822754,
0.28063929080963135,
-0.17274050414562225,
-0.0418289415538311,
-0.2214430272579193,
-0.3685874938964844,
-0.24006295204162598,
0.7322224378585815,
-0.7585307955741882,
-0.054840657860040665,
-0.12362129241228104,
-0.3659699857234955,
0.021380195394158363,
0.19444628059864044,
-0.506139874458313,
-0.0001930329599417746,
-0.6430411338806152,
0.5891079306602478,
-0.528927743434906,
0.0060327183455228806,
-0.10102976113557816,
-0.07139968872070312,
0.2117881327867508,
0.2865726947784424,
-1.0578811168670654,
0.35809388756752014,
0.5486494898796082,
0.6863208413124084,
-0.4038850665092468,
-0.4074038565158844,
-0.6050171256065369,
0.28193676471710205,
0.12620903551578522,
0.5504779815673828,
-0.4824843108654022,
-0.35047006607055664,
0.09156590700149536,
0.02891596592962742,
-0.6912880539894104,
-0.5720075368881226,
0.47680792212486267,
-0.5673816800117493,
0.04418064281344414,
-0.08999308943748474,
-0.34309107065200806,
-0.354860782623291,
0.14544416964054108,
-0.6700301766395569,
1.0787533521652222,
0.31772691011428833,
-0.8082860112190247,
0.5100187063217163,
-0.8703615665435791,
-0.6371167302131653,
-0.011815857142210007,
-0.07517595589160919,
-0.5003241896629333,
0.028467319905757904,
0.18547029793262482,
0.964259147644043,
-0.34909623861312866,
0.3822230100631714,
-0.14304064214229584,
-0.49772965908050537,
0.24871037900447845,
-0.46649467945098877,
0.7732083201408386,
0.07655442506074905,
-0.5745431780815125,
0.16772927343845367,
-0.3916700780391693,
-0.22015708684921265,
-0.07739102840423584,
-0.5084795355796814,
-0.4141012728214264,
-0.061429377645254135,
0.22915741801261902,
0.39527472853660583,
-0.18405520915985107,
-0.23800542950630188,
0.25524449348449707,
-0.305367648601532,
0.34632381796836853,
0.5787034034729004,
-0.2535760998725891,
0.6080003380775452,
-0.561766505241394,
0.41173478960990906,
0.2589010000228882,
0.021425165235996246,
-0.2907971143722534,
-0.41021034121513367,
-0.8198046684265137,
-0.4445649981498718,
-0.15176783502101898,
0.5395503044128418,
-0.9914878010749817,
0.24383506178855896,
-0.20215317606925964,
-0.527780294418335,
-0.4001305103302002,
0.2320498526096344,
0.43438777327537537,
0.5710173845291138,
0.7328473329544067,
-0.1411074846982956,
-0.18166489899158478,
-0.6280185580253601,
-0.0926806852221489,
0.34026944637298584,
-0.1023973822593689,
0.19640913605690002,
0.8910650014877319,
-0.1912762075662613,
0.8767129182815552,
-0.3784618079662323,
-0.5652213096618652,
-0.6520887613296509,
0.2034386694431305,
0.17520932853221893,
0.550311267375946,
0.5671055316925049,
-0.9674458503723145,
-0.6701247096061707,
0.032457295805215836,
-0.5430952906608582,
0.22263239324092865,
-0.2775060534477234,
0.10971818119287491,
0.06526582688093185,
0.44574424624443054,
-0.5598539113998413,
0.32235661149024963,
0.4308106005191803,
0.08039931952953339,
0.41231170296669006,
-0.36025670170783997,
0.07358207553625107,
-1.1259371042251587,
-0.08812079578638077,
0.1817859411239624,
0.038414839655160904,
-0.9290966391563416,
0.3345799148082733,
0.45575982332229614,
-0.08546211570501328,
-0.6357081532478333,
0.3513350188732147,
-0.47022363543510437,
0.14191114902496338,
-0.3345302939414978,
-0.3412642776966095,
-0.164937362074852,
0.70732182264328,
-0.0386342816054821,
0.9152777791023254,
0.7853465676307678,
-0.7314991354942322,
-0.025967400521039963,
0.1621866375207901,
-0.15639609098434448,
0.791601300239563,
-0.2890007495880127,
0.09333978593349457,
-0.25961369276046753,
0.34197160601615906,
-0.9975337982177734,
-0.11770275235176086,
0.07570985704660416,
0.2961125373840332,
0.6863071322441101,
0.0754888579249382,
-0.5311528444290161,
-0.3572610020637512,
-0.18512706458568573,
0.5454473495483398,
0.2584431767463684,
-0.7423511743545532,
0.8549864292144775,
0.24875780940055847,
0.3635469377040863,
-0.6415849924087524,
-0.78566974401474,
-0.29572466015815735,
-0.5157336592674255,
-0.2666621804237366,
0.6023163795471191,
-0.3231127858161926,
0.05802910029888153,
-0.27062278985977173,
-0.01701577939093113,
-0.3320807218551636,
0.21783111989498138,
0.4313180446624756,
0.34551066160202026,
-0.07326891273260117,
0.15265031158924103,
0.12856043875217438,
-0.0033863275311887264,
-0.1511429101228714,
-0.353964239358902,
0.46831169724464417,
-0.13503926992416382,
-0.7542177438735962,
-0.30209052562713623,
0.350196897983551,
0.7124348878860474,
-0.17962120473384857,
0.8273247480392456,
0.6705855131149292,
-0.26123011112213135,
-0.3943270742893219,
-0.5251784920692444,
-0.3583095073699951,
-0.4384574294090271,
0.44701868295669556,
-0.45183849334716797,
-0.9981873631477356,
0.38381874561309814,
-0.02991989254951477,
0.30993354320526123,
0.34056413173675537,
0.5949802994728088,
0.06093209609389305,
0.7571544051170349,
0.7897305488586426,
-0.11813961714506149,
0.49270814657211304,
-0.43763867020606995,
0.1602790206670761,
-1.0388813018798828,
-0.2158595472574234,
-0.5286837220191956,
-0.2757556736469269,
-0.25200319290161133,
-0.4980076849460602,
0.4649178683757782,
-0.12804795801639557,
-0.33025187253952026,
0.6959474682807922,
-0.4158616065979004,
0.41255757212638855,
0.6494981050491333,
0.335777223110199,
0.2076924592256546,
-0.005607991013675928,
0.023595204576849937,
-0.0006307971780188382,
-0.7903189063072205,
-0.18515603244304657,
1.3404786586761475,
0.2817816436290741,
0.7963854074478149,
-0.06017354130744934,
0.5104341506958008,
0.076791912317276,
0.6321882009506226,
-0.6650594472885132,
0.3245193362236023,
-0.4153994619846344,
-0.49654972553253174,
-0.1092652976512909,
-0.12504516541957855,
-0.7498164772987366,
0.4870328903198242,
-0.2540164589881897,
-0.5716792941093445,
0.0027583539485931396,
-0.008205885998904705,
-0.18230487406253815,
0.4212189316749573,
-0.5690871477127075,
0.8612388372421265,
-0.14277863502502441,
-0.22563213109970093,
-0.3168812394142151,
-0.813197910785675,
0.3286208212375641,
-0.4108164310455322,
0.2812172472476959,
0.27280864119529724,
0.18774423003196716,
0.4498178958892822,
0.2340635359287262,
1.190574288368225,
-0.03460114076733589,
0.006243434734642506,
0.15491436421871185,
-0.1601557582616806,
0.5128623843193054,
-0.18228359520435333,
0.035129569470882416,
0.051149580627679825,
-0.20474544167518616,
-0.2019815295934677,
-0.3160901963710785,
0.44849053025245667,
-0.7592707872390747,
-0.4534305930137634,
-0.20527268946170807,
-1.128077507019043,
-0.2715896964073181,
-0.10950763523578644,
0.5017106533050537,
0.6373118162155151,
0.19339017570018768,
0.5432089567184448,
0.7207851409912109,
0.1655835211277008,
0.6787706613540649,
0.25283852219581604,
0.4303347170352936,
-0.09900355339050293,
0.6974007487297058,
0.2695409655570984,
0.6079060435295105,
0.6132287979125977,
-0.0981883555650711,
-0.14929474890232086,
-0.46039095520973206,
-0.29717299342155457,
-0.08709706366062164,
-1.0450814962387085,
-0.2704981863498688,
-0.7111967206001282,
-0.3786378800868988,
-0.12026869505643845,
-0.45061105489730835,
-0.11793545633554459,
0.061613984405994415,
-0.5883922576904297,
0.15662482380867004,
-0.19523128867149353,
0.7116367816925049,
0.49058055877685547,
0.6942431926727295,
-0.7723129987716675,
0.06784673780202866,
0.3210417628288269,
0.06200990080833435,
0.2719987630844116,
-0.7996686697006226,
-0.5156072974205017,
-0.020321013405919075,
-0.8371444344520569,
-0.6323597431182861,
0.11223563551902771,
0.3762403726577759,
0.7505099177360535,
0.24355599284172058,
-0.008106600493192673,
0.6504654288291931,
-0.45592889189720154,
0.5899460911750793,
0.15778519213199615,
-0.9728108048439026,
0.07136692851781845,
-0.07809913903474808,
0.49225378036499023,
0.4463439881801605,
0.5175305008888245,
-0.2546221613883972,
-0.8078527450561523,
-0.511546790599823,
-0.7516686916351318,
0.8596594333648682,
0.031685784459114075,
0.43135279417037964,
0.22199884057044983,
0.22089378535747528,
0.46062779426574707,
0.18306584656238556,
-1.0229921340942383,
-0.15883663296699524,
-0.20106884837150574,
-0.3228594958782196,
0.006824177224189043,
-0.0665057972073555,
-0.1497889906167984,
-0.33278995752334595,
0.5392794609069824,
-0.5367408394813538,
0.11263120919466019,
-0.24638445675373077,
-0.4588218033313751,
0.05093025043606758,
0.44686248898506165,
0.6837519407272339,
0.5721516013145447,
0.17047134041786194,
0.226352259516716,
0.5443428754806519,
-0.5256307125091553,
0.261591374874115,
0.06760162115097046,
-0.006581553723663092,
-0.4758952260017395,
0.5247399210929871,
0.9429992437362671,
0.6810969710350037,
-0.5305429100990295,
0.6642623543739319,
0.07372745871543884,
-0.2572278678417206,
-0.08302110433578491,
0.2240992933511734,
-0.03639229014515877,
0.6003549098968506,
0.6157149076461792,
0.28052419424057007,
-0.03020951896905899,
-0.3609582483768463,
0.30869489908218384,
0.6494143605232239,
-0.39368218183517456,
-0.3587369918823242,
0.8016146421432495,
-0.2585286498069763,
0.05560910701751709,
0.5713043808937073,
0.011638641357421875,
-0.40311551094055176,
0.5828656554222107,
1.023765206336975,
0.7641804814338684,
-0.24475330114364624,
0.10340837389230728,
0.07959024608135223,
0.25306764245033264,
-0.3309863209724426,
-0.2586364150047302,
-0.2547772228717804,
-0.6084869503974915,
-0.5597108602523804,
-0.45073333382606506,
-0.39201226830482483,
-0.009461493231356144,
-0.5492432713508606,
0.4843972623348236,
-0.06569879502058029,
-0.01139228604733944,
-0.28176653385162354,
-0.4455008804798126,
-0.9580252170562744,
0.1596069633960724,
-0.04320342838764191,
0.5406200289726257,
-0.9735665321350098,
1.155888557434082,
0.700857400894165,
-0.28090664744377136,
-0.9952359199523926,
0.2066076397895813,
-0.25905081629753113,
-0.5534882545471191,
1.098252773284912,
0.5038238167762756,
0.008426208980381489,
0.1619720458984375,
-0.18866373598575592,
-0.7107853889465332,
1.2648866176605225,
0.4335102438926697,
-0.4262442886829376,
-0.30662789940834045,
0.2769072353839874,
0.3335598409175873,
-0.6682605743408203,
0.48588117957115173,
0.26808980107307434,
0.16083437204360962,
0.20930182933807373,
-0.9633563160896301,
-0.04878437519073486,
0.167019784450531,
-0.025133755058050156,
0.3165353536605835,
-0.3641999065876007,
1.0643553733825684,
-0.1702258139848709,
-0.1163657084107399,
-0.2713937759399414,
0.5684429407119751,
0.09156385064125061,
0.30049192905426025,
0.662787139415741,
0.44979384541511536,
0.5138717889785767,
-0.04745199531316757,
0.9645582437515259,
-0.20638693869113922,
0.6257383227348328,
0.9186016321182251,
-0.24570399522781372,
0.6881704926490784,
0.5482966303825378,
-0.022283708676695824,
0.4503765404224396,
0.2732318043708801,
-0.14184004068374634,
0.6508355140686035,
-0.14475837349891663,
-0.28791025280952454,
-0.19773872196674347,
-0.025486817583441734,
-0.11417725682258606,
0.4070972800254822,
0.2844769060611725,
-0.16637027263641357,
-0.463457852602005,
0.8357288837432861,
-0.0728924497961998,
-0.17322392761707306,
-0.2476068139076233,
0.5550858974456787,
0.08916568011045456,
-0.6858848333358765,
0.3639542758464813,
-0.25132161378860474,
0.7232410907745361,
-0.7181143760681152,
-0.037609998136758804,
0.22883158922195435,
0.3560149073600769,
-0.0334198884665966,
-0.8397493362426758,
0.41934001445770264,
-0.32922592759132385,
-0.23761224746704102,
-0.45457398891448975,
0.6897316575050354,
-0.6445180773735046,
-0.1912730485200882,
0.36559122800827026,
0.41636204719543457,
-0.3004329800605774,
-0.2011428326368332,
-0.5542200803756714,
-0.2511463761329651,
-0.2270044982433319,
-0.16891974210739136,
0.7785351872444153,
0.24418944120407104,
-0.2535788416862488,
0.6903572678565979,
0.5895276665687561,
-0.21837802231311798,
-0.03588012978434563,
-0.1916455328464508,
0.9578096270561218,
-0.12758953869342804,
-0.4331197142601013,
-0.9641731381416321,
0.8190004825592041,
0.24476884305477142,
-0.20275041460990906,
0.6475991010665894,
0.38951438665390015,
1.1955204010009766,
-0.4428100287914276,
0.4974250793457031,
-0.0776720643043518,
0.07254999130964279,
-0.47180822491645813,
0.4744654595851898,
-0.6625609397888184,
0.13132470846176147,
-0.08996407687664032,
-0.9239911437034607,
-0.5013467669487,
0.14048781991004944,
-0.2657921016216278,
0.021760042756795883,
0.9689688086509705,
0.433328777551651,
-0.5100627541542053,
0.023061247542500496,
0.3294951319694519,
-0.4607946276664734,
0.4425203204154968,
0.7532657980918884,
0.6637097001075745,
-0.2116648554801941,
0.47686830163002014,
-0.47301816940307617,
-0.16223856806755066,
-0.262001097202301,
-0.7900223731994629,
-1.1812998056411743,
-0.9334228038787842,
-0.010434554889798164,
-0.0708371251821518,
-0.1713690608739853,
0.9856095910072327,
0.8932104110717773,
-0.7785436511039734,
-0.5497741103172302,
-0.019110653549432755,
-0.046842388808727264,
-0.553499162197113,
-0.22268372774124146,
0.4211776852607727,
-0.6725449562072754,
-0.7226641178131104,
0.3539101183414459,
0.3262660503387451,
-0.03843013942241669,
0.0499604232609272,
0.0865805447101593,
-0.09230732917785645,
-0.2622969150543213,
0.7551308274269104,
-0.11770214885473251,
-0.6005828380584717,
-0.34180721640586853,
0.058712881058454514,
-0.29597964882850647,
0.13364052772521973,
1.200585961341858,
-0.5686750411987305,
0.24633242189884186,
0.18134121596813202,
0.9713624715805054,
0.5311199426651001,
-0.16459359228610992,
0.16005052626132965,
-0.9112288951873779,
0.2757708728313446,
0.09190963208675385,
0.370598703622818,
0.2077583372592926,
-0.4090384840965271,
0.35471388697624207,
0.26264774799346924,
-0.8008506894111633,
-0.6159719228744507,
0.28847944736480713,
-0.759823203086853,
-0.24626608192920685,
0.8700670003890991,
-0.14023543894290924,
0.17138247191905975,
-0.2814364433288574,
-0.26800820231437683,
0.33821338415145874,
-0.1288919448852539,
0.6374544501304626,
0.7946216464042664,
-0.2477026879787445,
-0.11551347374916077,
-0.9221593141555786,
0.3901728093624115,
0.45547714829444885,
-0.9379417300224304,
-0.041157182306051254,
0.07071773707866669,
0.19581708312034607,
0.13257117569446564,
0.2328069806098938,
0.305685430765152,
0.08172859996557236,
-0.533096969127655,
-0.2193077653646469,
-0.09145273268222809,
-0.6690223813056946,
-0.21684670448303223,
0.5179669857025146,
0.013521429151296616,
-0.07701963186264038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03555v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03555v2
|
From News to Summaries: Building a Hungarian Corpus for Extractive and Abstractive Summarization
| 2024-04-04T16:07:06 | 2024-04-12T08:05:13 |
Botond Barta, Dorina Lakatos, Attila Nagy, Milán Konor Nyist, Judit Ács
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training summarization models requires substantial amounts of training data.
However for less resourceful languages like Hungarian, openly available models
and datasets are notably scarce. To address this gap our paper introduces
HunSum-2 an open-source Hungarian corpus suitable for training abstractive and
extractive summarization models. The dataset is assembled from segments of the
Common Crawl corpus undergoing thorough cleaning, preprocessing and
deduplication. In addition to abstractive summarization we generate
sentence-level labels for extractive summarization using sentence similarity.
We train baseline models for both extractive and abstractive summarization
using the collected dataset. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the trained
models, we perform both quantitative and qualitative evaluation. Our dataset,
models and code are publicly available, encouraging replication, further
research, and real-world applications across various domains.
|
[
-0.06336608529090881,
-0.5013658404350281,
0.3354201018810272,
0.01649571768939495,
-0.21797113120555878,
-0.23496131598949432,
-0.46045517921447754,
-0.5229243636131287,
0.23414304852485657,
0.6190990209579468,
-0.10734647512435913,
-0.757477879524231,
-0.7828083634376526,
0.1236141175031662,
-0.5364744067192078,
1.656179666519165,
-0.17963677644729614,
-0.10870616883039474,
-0.3753204345703125,
-0.17138829827308655,
0.1824432909488678,
-0.41386985778808594,
0.05841127783060074,
-0.08339450508356094,
0.7565794587135315,
0.6328161358833313,
0.41210442781448364,
0.6540382504463196,
0.5431703329086304,
0.16150592267513275,
-0.2533680200576782,
0.049549028277397156,
-0.5144944190979004,
0.2565723955631256,
-0.24074336886405945,
-0.31006285548210144,
-0.4583258032798767,
0.008607256226241589,
0.591469407081604,
0.728309154510498,
-0.1380118876695633,
0.6728289127349854,
0.06871945410966873,
0.9302313327789307,
-0.8745689988136292,
0.32802140712738037,
-0.5378848314285278,
-0.25834447145462036,
-0.086003877222538,
-0.011458632536232471,
-0.3038119375705719,
-0.6205402612686157,
0.18494276702404022,
-0.6892416477203369,
0.1878383308649063,
-0.39556416869163513,
1.0384495258331299,
0.06123514100909233,
-0.26413533091545105,
-0.6033782362937927,
-0.7324849963188171,
0.5829759836196899,
-0.941495954990387,
-0.16598211228847504,
0.3575338125228882,
0.27529793977737427,
0.46833741664886475,
-0.9396505951881409,
0.10349312424659729,
-0.10767047852277756,
-0.44157466292381287,
0.21164315938949585,
-0.24222923815250397,
-0.20468869805335999,
0.1602897197008133,
0.39524880051612854,
-0.840802788734436,
-0.17602062225341797,
-0.8550014495849609,
0.13979443907737732,
0.4713926315307617,
0.20680196583271027,
0.040242139250040054,
-0.15747018158435822,
-0.2815217673778534,
0.21157430112361908,
-0.6922659277915955,
-0.007062652613967657,
0.637546181678772,
0.5187336206436157,
-0.34127435088157654,
0.8415712714195251,
-0.5195333957672119,
0.5444314479827881,
-0.32594776153564453,
-0.14647097885608673,
0.30024582147598267,
-0.39381393790245056,
-0.02560976892709732,
0.16320182383060455,
0.416490375995636,
0.1867990642786026,
0.35222434997558594,
-0.3194675147533417,
-0.31685730814933777,
0.21445947885513306,
0.3251025378704071,
-0.9272903203964233,
-0.30248594284057617,
0.14792269468307495,
-0.5321859121322632,
-0.510129451751709,
0.5258157849311829,
-0.8788381218910217,
0.08605194091796875,
-0.3860291540622711,
0.15815581381320953,
-0.05780999734997749,
-0.44856709241867065,
0.14210866391658783,
-0.5984060764312744,
-0.00010620176908560097,
0.14845550060272217,
-0.9938638806343079,
0.40917855501174927,
0.7718077301979065,
1.0678112506866455,
-0.2791961431503296,
-0.18193887174129486,
-0.5379092693328857,
0.2670550048351288,
-0.1892387419939041,
0.8490848541259766,
-0.1704876571893692,
-0.029512271285057068,
0.2228889912366867,
0.08597785234451294,
-0.09787485003471375,
-0.7762390375137329,
0.17834216356277466,
-0.3130732774734497,
0.25193819403648376,
0.11150462925434113,
-0.4153589606285095,
-0.18444326519966125,
0.32517382502555847,
-0.7908793687820435,
1.1504173278808594,
0.7373605966567993,
-1.2455201148986816,
-0.11907777190208435,
-0.7628196477890015,
-0.6611778140068054,
-0.14421924948692322,
0.10217618942260742,
-0.4623318016529083,
0.2169761061668396,
0.0026246285997331142,
0.25478675961494446,
0.34501633048057556,
0.16047608852386475,
-0.07610189914703369,
-0.39683815836906433,
-0.05075462907552719,
0.18906822800636292,
0.7906062602996826,
0.4914085268974304,
-0.1484510749578476,
-0.022315435111522675,
-0.7544721961021423,
-0.22938035428524017,
-0.05035531893372536,
-0.7125532627105713,
-0.5868188142776489,
0.07719973474740982,
0.2843932807445526,
0.2087361365556717,
0.4659811854362488,
-0.45208775997161865,
-0.01445011142641306,
-0.7634203433990479,
0.35917484760284424,
0.040567684918642044,
-0.11727377027273178,
0.63238126039505,
-0.36891070008277893,
0.5288524031639099,
0.049728699028491974,
-0.2392895519733429,
-0.652641773223877,
-0.2724640369415283,
-0.6742727756500244,
-0.13433939218521118,
0.32008692622184753,
0.6768904328346252,
-0.44674912095069885,
0.4283027648925781,
-0.44940298795700073,
-0.6387719511985779,
-0.4803881347179413,
0.2022530436515808,
0.3305952548980713,
0.544060468673706,
0.2585498094558716,
0.09404000639915466,
-0.9786940217018127,
-0.9158499836921692,
-0.16765178740024567,
0.04446792230010033,
-0.22743123769760132,
-0.1398455947637558,
0.7021870613098145,
-0.06979481875896454,
1.2955909967422485,
-0.34465762972831726,
-0.1649412214756012,
-0.6670791506767273,
0.4015576243400574,
0.28652316331863403,
0.35530349612236023,
0.5504185557365417,
-0.5997588634490967,
-0.2636820375919342,
0.16967247426509857,
-1.1294900178909302,
0.0028220710810273886,
0.3117911219596863,
-0.12819500267505646,
0.27489176392555237,
0.4220527410507202,
-0.4421825408935547,
0.4673391282558441,
0.5877935290336609,
-0.12524375319480896,
0.7209689617156982,
-0.16127854585647583,
-0.27098405361175537,
-1.3752001523971558,
0.6777830719947815,
-0.14401786029338837,
-0.4397539794445038,
-0.34788596630096436,
0.19289235770702362,
-0.11767806857824326,
-0.2953856885433197,
-0.6821288466453552,
0.5704622268676758,
-0.49969589710235596,
-0.45926666259765625,
-0.5456236004829407,
0.3044441044330597,
0.2040490359067917,
0.3989964723587036,
0.3056398332118988,
0.6755642890930176,
0.2623496949672699,
-0.6010292172431946,
0.060081981122493744,
0.43759432435035706,
-0.7437206506729126,
-0.011599416844546795,
-0.7467596530914307,
-0.17151646316051483,
-0.2640557289123535,
0.19030600786209106,
-0.6388835906982422,
-0.38663893938064575,
0.2068362683057785,
-0.52670818567276,
0.020835375413298607,
-0.24090303480625153,
-0.24609270691871643,
-0.2681911587715149,
-0.48518162965774536,
0.0477081835269928,
0.5363293290138245,
-0.42971187829971313,
0.32903653383255005,
0.7138824462890625,
-0.7568087577819824,
-0.5520681738853455,
-0.7305834889411926,
0.07199230045080185,
-0.16462577879428864,
-0.4137859046459198,
0.11614454537630081,
0.2688220739364624,
-0.6416038274765015,
0.1525133103132248,
0.02816476672887802,
-0.16505329310894012,
0.06597494333982468,
0.2587372064590454,
0.3672970235347748,
-0.4161561131477356,
-0.10161823034286499,
0.25131094455718994,
-0.27057912945747375,
0.07849673181772232,
-0.3368726670742035,
0.14380425214767456,
-0.1653817892074585,
0.225408673286438,
-0.2133737951517105,
0.7759407758712769,
0.38164958357810974,
-0.3524472117424011,
0.26140424609184265,
0.6181866526603699,
-0.41463780403137207,
0.066025011241436,
-0.05972984433174133,
0.015963321551680565,
-0.3487154245376587,
0.6786457896232605,
-0.047546882182359695,
-0.7801762223243713,
0.26093554496765137,
0.05680403858423233,
0.6306861639022827,
0.5143717527389526,
0.9697843790054321,
-0.2690398693084717,
0.9263633489608765,
0.6524089574813843,
-0.019826827570796013,
0.44680169224739075,
-0.45044445991516113,
-0.07941446453332901,
-0.45754489302635193,
-0.15005174279212952,
-0.7230603694915771,
-0.08936206996440887,
-0.3826868534088135,
0.12782074511051178,
0.28014644980430603,
0.04245152324438095,
0.10806312412023544,
0.6943317651748657,
-0.5346883535385132,
0.42783793807029724,
0.5207870006561279,
-0.015624318271875381,
0.37422657012939453,
0.25619742274284363,
0.3564760088920593,
0.21277576684951782,
-0.6288142204284668,
-1.0106273889541626,
0.784545361995697,
0.2820867598056793,
0.6962507367134094,
-0.07577255368232727,
0.7304815053939819,
0.3573221266269684,
0.3903566598892212,
-0.7694140076637268,
0.23006854951381683,
-0.23307648301124573,
-0.6531100273132324,
-0.2990397810935974,
-0.3214711844921112,
-1.0409890413284302,
0.21026596426963806,
-0.04817488044500351,
-0.5480573773384094,
-0.23881511390209198,
0.07389339804649353,
-0.43365970253944397,
0.1709650754928589,
-0.5563122630119324,
0.7362989187240601,
0.21189334988594055,
0.08758649975061417,
-0.22819752991199493,
-0.9609943628311157,
0.5511494874954224,
0.2594875991344452,
0.3465716242790222,
-0.3407956659793854,
0.043716467916965485,
1.1706451177597046,
-0.3746098279953003,
0.7013942003250122,
-0.011567200534045696,
-0.17675957083702087,
0.5707361698150635,
-0.02834513410925865,
0.3733975291252136,
0.14959633350372314,
-0.04701812192797661,
0.24495038390159607,
0.2595025300979614,
-0.5965844392776489,
-0.43843433260917664,
0.40015339851379395,
-0.6959846019744873,
-0.032518450170755386,
-0.3725113570690155,
-0.6741194725036621,
0.040921907871961594,
0.035146865993738174,
0.539109468460083,
0.6868588924407959,
-0.41055288910865784,
-0.04407854378223419,
0.30011361837387085,
0.08956006914377213,
0.5390487313270569,
0.4305400550365448,
-0.014286749064922333,
-0.5432801246643066,
0.9221194982528687,
-0.08167444914579391,
0.020306041464209557,
0.49286365509033203,
0.0433666817843914,
-0.017423106357455254,
-0.32398805022239685,
-0.44772446155548096,
0.20957158505916595,
-0.5226895809173584,
-0.14952048659324646,
-0.8824577927589417,
-0.48736727237701416,
-0.7663241028785706,
-0.12881681323051453,
-0.2786499559879303,
-0.8617652058601379,
-0.362331360578537,
-0.401078462600708,
0.2215254008769989,
1.0050817728042603,
-0.29445430636405945,
0.3804769515991211,
-1.0917048454284668,
0.25450384616851807,
-0.011327347718179226,
-0.1175377294421196,
-0.15087473392486572,
-0.481855571269989,
-1.0220321416854858,
0.03102419339120388,
-0.1993780881166458,
-0.7368599772453308,
0.5319526195526123,
0.07147499918937683,
0.26539352536201477,
0.6662384867668152,
0.08071346580982208,
0.123799629509449,
-0.31245851516723633,
0.7117066979408264,
0.14291495084762573,
-0.40094828605651855,
0.740366518497467,
-0.6928674578666687,
0.301118940114975,
0.9383988976478577,
0.2968501150608063,
-0.41619670391082764,
-0.5821300745010376,
-0.45290935039520264,
-0.9684287309646606,
0.7136252522468567,
0.17332205176353455,
0.023174667730927467,
0.024308349937200546,
0.09565115720033646,
0.6540105938911438,
0.22217853367328644,
-0.4751555323600769,
0.014748996123671532,
-0.21800369024276733,
-0.3983449935913086,
-0.0373050682246685,
-0.48367103934288025,
-0.036577653139829636,
-0.2398262470960617,
0.7802971005439758,
0.06235361099243164,
0.10569220781326294,
-0.19327689707279205,
-0.4982755184173584,
0.07355038821697235,
0.2240302860736847,
0.7042243480682373,
0.7679110765457153,
-0.4673241674900055,
0.34261512756347656,
-0.09576235711574554,
-0.5834159255027771,
-0.06686875969171524,
0.08704697340726852,
-0.4426436126232147,
0.59136962890625,
0.4492490291595459,
0.7271986603736877,
0.4693511724472046,
-0.9697992205619812,
0.6840916275978088,
0.1919948011636734,
-0.45070984959602356,
-0.6005579233169556,
0.026727085933089256,
0.11482789367437363,
0.05052534490823746,
0.08916307240724564,
-0.05490080267190933,
0.295157253742218,
-0.4178987443447113,
0.4017673432826996,
-0.14759288728237152,
-0.41182002425193787,
-0.6116058230400085,
0.5027024149894714,
0.2469748854637146,
-0.2048553079366684,
0.6202514171600342,
-0.010225038975477219,
-0.23027175664901733,
0.4838819205760956,
0.36744141578674316,
0.6017125844955444,
0.21946470439434052,
0.3940536379814148,
0.8806595802307129,
-0.017244672402739525,
-0.2352103441953659,
0.1467767208814621,
-0.2779684364795685,
-0.273851215839386,
-0.3776415288448334,
-0.5115939378738403,
-0.4227343499660492,
0.10189258307218552,
-1.2871752977371216,
0.29407286643981934,
0.12498040497303009,
0.10917104035615921,
-0.010114542208611965,
-0.014342247508466244,
-0.1401718109846115,
-0.09553882479667664,
0.24714204668998718,
1.0406841039657593,
-0.8501663208007812,
0.8144672513008118,
0.6552326679229736,
-0.45868855714797974,
-0.12945155799388885,
-0.5004539489746094,
-0.2499765157699585,
-0.47324034571647644,
0.2800350785255432,
0.4426026940345764,
0.1515548825263977,
-0.08383090794086456,
-0.7812250256538391,
-0.6821591854095459,
0.9681442975997925,
0.39954647421836853,
-0.43640559911727905,
-0.7387588620185852,
-0.04976462945342064,
0.2913624048233032,
-0.4504891633987427,
0.25079143047332764,
0.8129588961601257,
0.5398739576339722,
-0.16780221462249756,
-0.493599534034729,
-0.5221596360206604,
-0.514712393283844,
-0.38770508766174316,
-0.006219940725713968,
-0.12326251715421677,
0.8399568200111389,
-0.5469219088554382,
-0.26491397619247437,
0.5105962157249451,
0.864185094833374,
0.3259977698326111,
0.5956581830978394,
0.20710551738739014,
0.5470786094665527,
0.4128416180610657,
0.0931294709444046,
0.8049687147140503,
-0.4014662802219391,
0.34937140345573425,
1.6125495433807373,
-0.15435317158699036,
1.0141124725341797,
0.3869040012359619,
0.22638925909996033,
0.7285148501396179,
0.72914719581604,
-0.025017820298671722,
0.6648984551429749,
0.11728174984455109,
-0.12905558943748474,
0.009754281491041183,
0.061152562499046326,
-0.33733227849006653,
0.5021002888679504,
0.27968934178352356,
-0.38193944096565247,
-1.0390849113464355,
-0.041490472853183746,
0.3019900619983673,
0.22131547331809998,
-0.17443397641181946,
1.0060772895812988,
0.0518641360104084,
-0.7824925780296326,
0.27678945660591125,
0.215817391872406,
0.5664460062980652,
-0.686221718788147,
-0.014017723500728607,
-0.20382606983184814,
0.15536358952522278,
-0.2597854733467102,
-0.43575623631477356,
0.6898411512374878,
0.42193886637687683,
-0.47528406977653503,
-0.07312757521867752,
0.6971493363380432,
-0.7461141347885132,
-0.5191531777381897,
0.12332254648208618,
0.7825109958648682,
0.5756769776344299,
-0.14633327722549438,
-0.23927544057369232,
-0.46467846632003784,
-0.3526948094367981,
-0.38511401414871216,
0.5040858387947083,
0.20584991574287415,
0.0991179496049881,
0.03972164914011955,
0.5006860494613647,
0.33457329869270325,
-0.08978842943906784,
-0.005655531771481037,
0.7959539890289307,
-0.4927119314670563,
-0.8227031230926514,
-0.7686868906021118,
0.4259900152683258,
0.015098655596375465,
-0.34833502769470215,
0.6631863117218018,
1.1647846698760986,
0.7229055762290955,
-0.23391905426979065,
1.1999764442443848,
0.010265707969665527,
0.8696821331977844,
-0.3418866693973541,
0.8552255034446716,
-0.28557392954826355,
-0.3677273690700531,
0.1914328783750534,
-0.8160492181777954,
0.031632691621780396,
0.528429388999939,
0.022558555006980896,
-0.47306036949157715,
0.49488383531570435,
0.792114794254303,
-0.04066374897956848,
-0.008549675345420837,
0.18906830251216888,
0.04556966945528984,
-0.1453142911195755,
0.5149292349815369,
0.8971490263938904,
-0.32146021723747253,
0.6272022128105164,
-0.02819972299039364,
-0.2539592385292053,
-0.4029637277126312,
-0.6562643647193909,
-0.9974207878112793,
-0.710300087928772,
-0.12286332249641418,
-0.4942348599433899,
0.3122665286064148,
0.8400857448577881,
0.7366044521331787,
-0.9006742238998413,
-0.3992599546909332,
0.015686962753534317,
-0.026759527623653412,
-0.2742798924446106,
-0.2420097291469574,
0.41180405020713806,
-0.4535500407218933,
-0.6659429669380188,
0.32011616230010986,
0.2869240343570709,
-0.026599176228046417,
-0.21787799894809723,
-0.10152622312307358,
-0.15641415119171143,
-0.09649446606636047,
0.614509105682373,
0.4853839874267578,
-0.28080669045448303,
0.19921842217445374,
-0.09374818205833435,
-0.4480963945388794,
0.27597567439079285,
1.2083243131637573,
-0.7680539488792419,
-0.09439390897750854,
0.7027919888496399,
0.38173022866249084,
0.670662522315979,
0.20007909834384918,
0.45553919672966003,
-0.7366741895675659,
0.3057524561882019,
0.05185382068157196,
0.25846001505851746,
0.27039197087287903,
-0.1979907751083374,
0.6364049315452576,
0.06142674759030342,
-0.20950764417648315,
-0.7500977516174316,
-0.10019855201244354,
-0.9526780843734741,
-0.2750885784626007,
1.540094017982483,
-0.3792022466659546,
-0.5037244558334351,
-0.3032272756099701,
-0.1001637876033783,
0.4953606426715851,
-0.3120637834072113,
0.7610576748847961,
0.47572848200798035,
0.26608768105506897,
0.36467674374580383,
-0.533717155456543,
0.452932745218277,
-0.1387997418642044,
-1.0534565448760986,
0.38649216294288635,
0.39644503593444824,
0.3623065650463104,
-0.005316032096743584,
0.6904054284095764,
-0.346619576215744,
0.3703452944755554,
0.11943252384662628,
0.3290013074874878,
-0.5062868595123291,
-0.6418740749359131,
-0.39168375730514526,
0.28446072340011597,
-0.310781866312027,
-0.25805971026420593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03543v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03543v2
|
CodeEditorBench: Evaluating Code Editing Capability of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T15:49:49 | 2024-04-06T04:29:25 |
Jiawei Guo, Ziming Li, Xueling Liu, Kaijing Ma, Tianyu Zheng, Zhouliang Yu, Ding Pan, Yizhi LI, Ruibo Liu, Yue Wang, Shuyue Guo, Xingwei Qu, Xiang Yue, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen, Jie Fu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) for code are rapidly evolving, with code editing
emerging as a critical capability. We introduce CodeEditorBench, an evaluation
framework designed to rigorously assess the performance of LLMs in code editing
tasks, including debugging, translating, polishing, and requirement switching.
Unlike existing benchmarks focusing solely on code generation, CodeEditorBench
emphasizes real-world scenarios and practical aspects of software development.
We curate diverse coding challenges and scenarios from five sources, covering
various programming languages, complexity levels, and editing tasks. Evaluation
of 19 LLMs reveals that closed-source models (particularly Gemini-Ultra and
GPT-4), outperform open-source models in CodeEditorBench, highlighting
differences in model performance based on problem types and prompt
sensitivities. CodeEditorBench aims to catalyze advancements in LLMs by
providing a robust platform for assessing code editing capabilities. We will
release all prompts and datasets to enable the community to expand the dataset
and benchmark emerging LLMs. By introducing CodeEditorBench, we contribute to
the advancement of LLMs in code editing and provide a valuable resource for
researchers and practitioners.
|
[
-0.17095549404621124,
-0.6566814184188843,
0.5290102958679199,
0.5743445158004761,
-0.048343244940042496,
0.4136510193347931,
-0.6664641499519348,
-0.2601317763328552,
-0.2082039713859558,
0.538040280342102,
-0.3817558288574219,
-0.7768043875694275,
-0.3435162603855133,
0.2491215169429779,
-0.6343227624893188,
0.8781712055206299,
-0.4135356843471527,
0.11426986753940582,
-0.5007544755935669,
0.12105204910039902,
-0.665928304195404,
-0.47748124599456787,
-0.33963656425476074,
0.037907909601926804,
0.3084619343280792,
0.2519802153110504,
0.728000283241272,
0.4164068102836609,
0.7318295836448669,
0.3584136962890625,
-0.28407981991767883,
-0.07055079191923141,
-0.5035809874534607,
0.12604199349880219,
-0.25209617614746094,
-0.35792678594589233,
-0.8373813033103943,
-0.052504073828458786,
0.41895365715026855,
0.5399578213691711,
-0.11528622359037399,
0.3585112690925598,
-0.0009225339745171368,
0.6021864414215088,
-0.5760891437530518,
0.2683614492416382,
-0.5760245323181152,
0.04436983913183212,
-0.178502157330513,
0.05573127791285515,
-0.19782395660877228,
-0.5665256977081299,
-0.4023488163948059,
-0.3519240617752075,
0.038917917758226395,
-0.2913336753845215,
0.3040945529937744,
0.3585033118724823,
-0.06486234068870544,
-0.15958470106124878,
-0.4903423488140106,
0.3117585778236389,
-0.6419333219528198,
0.41619017720222473,
0.006967311725020409,
0.21549750864505768,
-0.12955398857593536,
-1.0403722524642944,
-0.565311074256897,
-0.41074419021606445,
0.23206083476543427,
-0.0005347592523321509,
-0.35981228947639465,
0.26333633065223694,
0.5890633463859558,
0.5963897705078125,
-0.7125816941261292,
0.08814943581819534,
-0.49515455961227417,
-0.2295653522014618,
0.5754321217536926,
0.26928892731666565,
0.3975987434387207,
-0.20401741564273834,
0.04677145555615425,
0.07944120466709137,
-0.5602924823760986,
-0.175125852227211,
0.5136004686355591,
-0.057283684611320496,
0.015240075998008251,
0.5719728469848633,
-0.2233409434556961,
0.7856406569480896,
-0.21805869042873383,
0.20290665328502655,
0.3236626088619232,
-0.20239455997943878,
-0.2001066356897354,
-0.11253278702497482,
0.5812476277351379,
0.690373957157135,
0.0906909704208374,
-0.1727934181690216,
-0.42395010590553284,
0.21355412900447845,
0.292238712310791,
-0.8979707956314087,
-0.23969867825508118,
0.2367381602525711,
-0.5851593613624573,
-0.6056116819381714,
0.0516921728849411,
-0.9923542737960815,
-0.5162962079048157,
0.02549673058092594,
-0.04107002541422844,
0.08955307304859161,
-0.26000839471817017,
0.17111018300056458,
-0.18447349965572357,
-0.19966669380664825,
0.36433249711990356,
-0.5809518694877625,
0.18327006697654724,
0.9406411051750183,
0.7867831587791443,
-0.3390830159187317,
-0.35683754086494446,
-0.5490310192108154,
-0.2729921042919159,
-0.5663411021232605,
0.5191952586174011,
-0.783679187297821,
-0.5747439861297607,
0.09827005863189697,
-0.06539500504732132,
0.17003066837787628,
-0.6492834091186523,
0.5784341096878052,
-0.7447050213813782,
-0.3057936429977417,
0.18977339565753937,
-0.5682502388954163,
0.08554045855998993,
0.30919069051742554,
-0.8840146064758301,
1.2105283737182617,
0.3993258774280548,
-0.46439284086227417,
0.06347513943910599,
-0.697483479976654,
-0.06366769969463348,
0.04435957968235016,
-0.13059073686599731,
-0.07607313245534897,
0.31119194626808167,
0.10139288008213043,
0.25089961290359497,
-0.27504488825798035,
0.5535303950309753,
-0.3560378849506378,
-0.4285411536693573,
0.419554203748703,
-0.356218546628952,
0.5357306599617004,
0.33864057064056396,
-0.06319042295217514,
0.6372532248497009,
-0.9035394191741943,
0.17560745775699615,
-0.11761201918125153,
-0.5477913022041321,
-0.009585159830749035,
-0.10318632423877716,
0.2854638993740082,
0.3278380334377289,
0.41846346855163574,
-0.5592193603515625,
0.626736581325531,
-0.18995964527130127,
0.5231056213378906,
0.759621798992157,
0.09920919686555862,
-0.01141840498894453,
0.025446634739637375,
1.0668625831604004,
-0.33867552876472473,
0.27348417043685913,
-0.10356314480304718,
-0.11512094736099243,
-0.4679951071739197,
-0.1296147108078003,
0.48715344071388245,
0.5403416752815247,
-0.6324335932731628,
0.40590617060661316,
-0.245385080575943,
-0.6294402480125427,
-0.43639978766441345,
0.48708033561706543,
0.5137133002281189,
0.04127287119626999,
0.15874114632606506,
-0.3252682387828827,
-0.5669435858726501,
-0.7125840187072754,
-0.5091836452484131,
-0.0175276231020689,
-0.0359940379858017,
0.05057177692651749,
0.5290839076042175,
-0.5580732822418213,
0.7446428537368774,
-0.5008846521377563,
0.19798468053340912,
-0.6156206130981445,
-0.06620275974273682,
0.30776527523994446,
0.4762907922267914,
0.5710662007331848,
-0.416422963142395,
-0.3028646409511566,
-0.0972955971956253,
-0.5467096567153931,
-0.5166909098625183,
-0.1570274531841278,
-0.07249996066093445,
0.25276198983192444,
0.8355045318603516,
-0.4427794814109802,
0.34904149174690247,
1.0031899213790894,
-0.3192475438117981,
0.5997428297996521,
-0.016038265079259872,
0.2780461311340332,
-0.6885524988174438,
0.24344417452812195,
-0.3553890883922577,
-0.2781025171279907,
-0.20152467489242554,
0.368033766746521,
0.4225413203239441,
-0.46283993124961853,
-0.25433534383773804,
0.36063769459724426,
-0.4475720226764679,
-0.35463541746139526,
-0.2677105963230133,
0.1949489414691925,
0.1111854687333107,
0.1694214791059494,
-0.3320368528366089,
0.9557238221168518,
0.4016086161136627,
-0.1727694422006607,
0.7836773991584778,
0.22060716152191162,
-0.8287068009376526,
0.03047705627977848,
-0.7283844947814941,
0.457810640335083,
0.24361416697502136,
0.2629185616970062,
-0.6359860897064209,
-0.13603749871253967,
-0.14637234807014465,
-0.1845836639404297,
0.25901252031326294,
-0.1666727215051651,
-0.6537312269210815,
-0.5231027603149414,
-0.4194084703922272,
0.21197576820850372,
0.2586853802204132,
-0.625459611415863,
0.408576637506485,
0.07116957008838654,
-0.4012168347835541,
-0.455645889043808,
-0.48968058824539185,
0.3954044580459595,
0.13272669911384583,
-0.6504112482070923,
0.22433225810527802,
-0.3732545077800751,
-0.4648115634918213,
0.034700844436883926,
-0.33601537346839905,
-0.2078230082988739,
0.31835103034973145,
0.34632372856140137,
0.4105066657066345,
0.011705243960022926,
0.20566082000732422,
0.0005037249648012221,
-0.12787963449954987,
0.1252901703119278,
0.066698357462883,
0.38933074474334717,
-0.1551462560892105,
-0.3642987310886383,
-0.04755924269556999,
0.0979423075914383,
0.555327296257019,
-0.6458661556243896,
0.3469017744064331,
0.20661604404449463,
-0.14499548077583313,
-0.3293258845806122,
-0.48462581634521484,
0.19381986558437347,
-0.46175602078437805,
0.8294203877449036,
-0.4800381362438202,
-1.0762070417404175,
0.672974705696106,
-0.38902807235717773,
0.05832700803875923,
0.3561648726463318,
0.6393030285835266,
0.6169601082801819,
0.8267636895179749,
0.7088193893432617,
-0.12275156378746033,
0.5216960310935974,
-0.04902028292417526,
0.18025219440460205,
-0.7360730767250061,
0.011945431120693684,
-0.6553766131401062,
-0.06594228744506836,
-0.4148519039154053,
-0.7510642409324646,
0.2549692392349243,
0.30341044068336487,
0.15275992453098297,
0.14449754357337952,
-0.33462685346603394,
0.8604357838630676,
-0.0403958335518837,
-0.034133341163396835,
0.549760103225708,
-0.5015484094619751,
-0.011016522534191608,
0.07485098391771317,
-0.5066037178039551,
-0.6025403141975403,
1.1783511638641357,
0.4379492402076721,
0.9599834084510803,
0.04118964076042175,
0.429720401763916,
0.44601863622665405,
0.48956334590911865,
-0.6516003608703613,
0.5778971910476685,
0.05286053568124771,
-0.6392041444778442,
0.040527381002902985,
-0.4020693004131317,
-0.32090282440185547,
0.1353919506072998,
0.07411253452301025,
-0.5330966114997864,
0.019729526713490486,
0.24848772585391998,
-0.2363685667514801,
0.3419431447982788,
-0.4818635582923889,
1.3197407722473145,
-0.39779454469680786,
-0.5584902763366699,
-0.49755367636680603,
-0.17141900956630707,
0.34526610374450684,
-0.26978814601898193,
0.26860272884368896,
0.1106027215719223,
-0.15237653255462646,
0.5543138384819031,
-0.3361636698246002,
0.6793137788772583,
-0.15788045525550842,
-0.25417032837867737,
0.1937018632888794,
0.49218663573265076,
0.4869470000267029,
0.17896951735019684,
-0.5233110785484314,
0.27904438972473145,
0.12606297433376312,
0.001797927194274962,
-0.7429350018501282,
0.8995366096496582,
-0.4549376666545868,
-0.5646706223487854,
-0.30124586820602417,
-0.4581567645072937,
-0.15703356266021729,
0.17523962259292603,
-0.09366987645626068,
0.4870639145374298,
-0.7354266047477722,
0.15326888859272003,
0.22960077226161957,
-0.5100911259651184,
0.36669763922691345,
0.5075555443763733,
-0.7460073232650757,
-0.3495262563228607,
0.5971071720123291,
-0.20708753168582916,
0.23026113212108612,
0.06093186140060425,
-0.008882139809429646,
0.109478659927845,
-0.8744358420372009,
-0.5709530115127563,
-0.2570827305316925,
-0.9858188629150391,
-0.29641470313072205,
-0.46369898319244385,
0.01950496807694435,
-0.11831627041101456,
-0.2567702531814575,
-0.47575730085372925,
-0.4619414210319519,
-0.025124549865722656,
-0.3307863473892212,
0.46413445472717285,
0.8825006484985352,
0.09996078908443451,
0.06872078776359558,
-1.121690034866333,
0.18778304755687714,
-0.02637949027121067,
0.9249093532562256,
-0.22497805953025818,
-0.3992304801940918,
-0.3841227889060974,
-0.5095118880271912,
-0.2065495401620865,
-0.8603357672691345,
0.16096946597099304,
-0.06175631657242775,
0.47238197922706604,
0.08417999744415283,
-0.07545667141675949,
0.5858982801437378,
-0.40607118606567383,
0.888202965259552,
-0.17539992928504944,
-1.3955479860305786,
0.3910042345523834,
-0.31917622685432434,
0.28955113887786865,
0.7449706196784973,
-0.09456614404916763,
-0.6248832941055298,
-0.38799023628234863,
-0.3431685268878937,
-0.6678042411804199,
0.5130300521850586,
-0.04537952318787575,
0.19543714821338654,
-0.024855179712176323,
0.3827248811721802,
0.0011013506446033716,
0.4259558320045471,
-0.6805710792541504,
0.15580667555332184,
-0.154179647564888,
-0.2081223875284195,
-0.042152415961027145,
-0.4430654048919678,
0.007651339750736952,
-0.2501871585845947,
0.47146111726760864,
-0.10715463012456894,
-0.057683270424604416,
0.13904236257076263,
-0.394252210855484,
-0.3274971544742584,
0.5982420444488525,
0.53385990858078,
1.1350533962249756,
-0.3068660795688629,
-0.18569442629814148,
0.20971213281154633,
-0.2557360529899597,
-0.2031184881925583,
0.11675184220075607,
0.160163015127182,
-0.028302952647209167,
0.5421796441078186,
0.8153032064437866,
0.2954348921775818,
-1.1675792932510376,
0.5275543332099915,
-0.17525410652160645,
-0.03157854080200195,
-0.23944471776485443,
0.2690495252609253,
0.09294318407773972,
0.2999819815158844,
-0.12012873589992523,
-0.05833638831973076,
0.33377525210380554,
-0.48676586151123047,
-0.025283845141530037,
0.12015954405069351,
-0.22021062672138214,
-0.1451842039823532,
0.5096182227134705,
0.4090013802051544,
-0.17495428025722504,
0.6184532046318054,
-0.02716805227100849,
-0.6308979392051697,
0.7177187204360962,
0.3168402910232544,
1.1196659803390503,
-0.06174315884709358,
-0.22870002686977386,
0.3293890357017517,
0.4669365882873535,
0.08129239082336426,
0.21703235805034637,
0.10618153214454651,
-0.3352716565132141,
-0.518732488155365,
-0.6250354051589966,
-0.49035459756851196,
-0.031957078725099564,
-0.655606746673584,
0.289626806974411,
-0.4741401970386505,
-0.001503713196143508,
-0.12810741364955902,
-0.1875331997871399,
-0.4089886248111725,
-0.2747317850589752,
-0.16023260354995728,
1.386389970779419,
-0.4709622263908386,
0.7983433604240417,
0.7417047023773193,
-0.20597757399082184,
-0.6051962971687317,
-0.0012097274884581566,
0.0975705236196518,
-0.5581098794937134,
0.6585099697113037,
0.22387762367725372,
-0.004111128393560648,
-0.0781392902135849,
-0.565972089767456,
-0.4129497706890106,
0.7876660227775574,
0.3523162305355072,
-0.9407672882080078,
0.14341984689235687,
-0.14702682197093964,
0.5638068318367004,
-0.2968427538871765,
0.3395806550979614,
0.8370041251182556,
0.5565761923789978,
-0.42592471837997437,
-1.0677165985107422,
-0.05178046599030495,
-0.5740836262702942,
0.28737872838974,
0.13401128351688385,
-0.5556681156158447,
0.7443482279777527,
-0.14582648873329163,
0.10161495208740234,
0.3927963674068451,
0.2579917013645172,
-0.08354830741882324,
0.08899375051259995,
0.3620275855064392,
0.3736073970794678,
0.46280649304389954,
-0.01152496226131916,
1.1612884998321533,
-0.6572468876838684,
0.4644981920719147,
1.0503971576690674,
-0.5458206534385681,
0.786661684513092,
0.29000547528266907,
-0.21469351649284363,
0.4937695264816284,
0.3896024823188782,
-0.2641444802284241,
0.07436608523130417,
0.5547429323196411,
-0.1684873104095459,
-0.15461529791355133,
0.20065031945705414,
-0.37309908866882324,
0.5445292592048645,
0.15456664562225342,
-0.4426427483558655,
-0.15212172269821167,
0.00728548364713788,
0.11889997124671936,
0.3153240382671356,
-0.28017759323120117,
0.6721028685569763,
-0.22304555773735046,
-0.6162859797477722,
0.5151117444038391,
0.2776217460632324,
0.4707320034503937,
-0.6837788820266724,
-0.18341390788555145,
-0.2539156675338745,
0.3605228066444397,
-0.36064600944519043,
-0.7950141429901123,
0.4149894416332245,
0.6431845426559448,
-0.2070644646883011,
-0.2811833620071411,
0.567555844783783,
-0.13857898116111755,
-0.47996777296066284,
0.5082351565361023,
0.3335447311401367,
0.07080566138029099,
-0.25594884157180786,
-0.7557156085968018,
0.9034620523452759,
0.17555895447731018,
-0.5150099992752075,
0.28253087401390076,
0.25146231055259705,
-0.021202009171247482,
0.4005049467086792,
0.6391012668609619,
0.13261687755584717,
-0.12435013800859451,
0.24143974483013153,
1.0455269813537598,
-0.7145945429801941,
-0.3491142690181732,
-0.8170440196990967,
0.4555383026599884,
-0.054534900933504105,
-0.27298223972320557,
0.7807390689849854,
0.7608352899551392,
0.8925931453704834,
-0.35012710094451904,
0.80699223279953,
-0.16442681849002838,
0.3176533579826355,
-0.6196133494377136,
0.6574623584747314,
-0.2987380623817444,
0.4353831112384796,
-0.4789520800113678,
-1.0460740327835083,
-0.2840108573436737,
0.4983064532279968,
-0.3061043918132782,
0.10673267394304276,
0.6804399490356445,
0.9575586318969727,
0.16530919075012207,
0.017554931342601776,
0.30457448959350586,
0.41556262969970703,
0.42968472838401794,
0.3380797207355499,
0.9142033457756042,
-0.01313562598079443,
0.5301765203475952,
-0.19077198207378387,
-0.44564157724380493,
-0.16667087376117706,
-0.9719554781913757,
-1.051849365234375,
-0.0909377932548523,
-0.28736627101898193,
-0.2795931398868561,
0.07909007370471954,
1.0130590200424194,
0.25422748923301697,
-0.6881886720657349,
-0.3485008776187897,
-0.16461212933063507,
0.08788276463747025,
-0.2475559264421463,
-0.2512589395046234,
0.08027498424053192,
-0.2673895061016083,
-0.6967114210128784,
0.6782041788101196,
0.3748548924922943,
-0.4087080955505371,
-0.4092157483100891,
0.03354779630899429,
0.27527499198913574,
-0.1506638377904892,
0.5937082767486572,
0.10009020566940308,
-0.44535183906555176,
-0.1011216789484024,
-0.09741444140672684,
-0.19903922080993652,
-0.1497492492198944,
1.0516958236694336,
-0.5279496312141418,
0.6654872894287109,
0.5997161269187927,
0.7386388182640076,
0.2104112058877945,
-0.11792711168527603,
0.5446019768714905,
-0.5691916346549988,
0.22215352952480316,
0.1643509417772293,
0.3957330584526062,
0.23242074251174927,
-0.29622915387153625,
0.5651569962501526,
-0.019194375723600388,
-0.6465478539466858,
-0.9952051639556885,
0.012143073603510857,
-0.9062649607658386,
-0.344529926776886,
0.9747770428657532,
-0.17093461751937866,
0.12532104551792145,
0.12956902384757996,
-0.48025164008140564,
0.08622317016124725,
-0.2919590473175049,
0.602590024471283,
0.8150351643562317,
0.029512425884604454,
-0.13391248881816864,
-1.0202662944793701,
0.3956758379936218,
0.27263304591178894,
-1.112823247909546,
0.45833754539489746,
0.987608015537262,
0.3039728105068207,
-0.06434141099452972,
0.43100786209106445,
-0.3090105652809143,
0.5583056211471558,
-0.07465299218893051,
0.5802493095397949,
-0.3592536151409149,
-0.27496519684791565,
-0.8203779458999634,
0.08086813986301422,
0.4763946235179901,
0.2841751277446747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03532v1
|
Evaluating Generative Language Models in Information Extraction as Subjective Question Correction
| 2024-04-04T15:36:53 | 2024-04-04T15:36:53 |
Yuchen Fan, Yantao Liu, Zijun Yao, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable prowess in
various tasks necessitating sophisticated cognitive behaviors. Nevertheless, a
paradoxical performance discrepancy is observed, where these models
underperform in seemingly elementary tasks like relation extraction and event
extraction due to two issues in conventional evaluation. (1) The imprecision of
existing evaluation metrics that struggle to effectively gauge semantic
consistency between model outputs and ground truth, and (2) The inherent
incompleteness of evaluation benchmarks, primarily due to restrictive human
annotation schemas, resulting in underestimated LLM performances. Inspired by
the principles in subjective question correction, we propose a new evaluation
method, SQC-Score. This method innovatively utilizes LLMs, fine-tuned through
subjective question correction data, to refine matching between model outputs
and golden labels. Additionally, by incorporating a Natural Language Inference
(NLI) model, SQC-Score enriches golden labels, addressing benchmark
incompleteness by acknowledging correct yet previously omitted answers. Results
on three information extraction tasks show that SQC-Score is more preferred by
human annotators than the baseline metrics. Utilizing SQC-Score, we conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of the state-of-the-art LLMs and provide insights for
future research for information extraction. Dataset and associated codes can be
accessed at https://github.com/THU-KEG/SQC-Score.
|
[
-0.45575445890426636,
-0.9432607889175415,
0.529336154460907,
0.09679985791444778,
-0.19325728714466095,
-0.030509237200021744,
-0.49092453718185425,
-0.5254908204078674,
-0.11233817785978317,
0.34689491987228394,
-0.4940933585166931,
-0.7034603357315063,
-0.5283827781677246,
0.23970270156860352,
-0.21451272070407867,
1.0400691032409668,
0.1301266998052597,
-0.0058922115713357925,
-0.6067209839820862,
-0.06399096548557281,
-0.3998830020427704,
-0.5164464116096497,
-0.38175904750823975,
-0.2059318721294403,
0.44754236936569214,
0.5429271459579468,
0.7932433485984802,
0.42163532972335815,
0.46348443627357483,
0.29709896445274353,
-0.031157653778791428,
0.3316245377063751,
-0.32713109254837036,
0.0032846122048795223,
-0.1329900622367859,
-0.630464494228363,
-0.3822747468948364,
0.2654116153717041,
0.575179934501648,
0.5920767188072205,
-0.15251843631267548,
0.27389517426490784,
-0.03892866522073746,
0.6028332114219666,
-0.7166544795036316,
0.20572492480278015,
-0.6288161873817444,
0.13016118109226227,
-0.04130003973841667,
-0.46186956763267517,
-0.40603652596473694,
-0.7086525559425354,
0.16351929306983948,
-0.5991259217262268,
0.32167598605155945,
0.12488339096307755,
0.9758594036102295,
0.21017436683177948,
-0.15353697538375854,
-0.48810067772865295,
-0.7577900290489197,
0.7515005469322205,
-0.7930673956871033,
0.2021150290966034,
0.47926196455955505,
0.3353891670703888,
0.10422633588314056,
-0.5707315802574158,
-0.7374867796897888,
-0.4382079541683197,
0.14835523068904877,
0.24665118753910065,
-0.44451314210891724,
-0.05104823037981987,
0.3942979574203491,
0.6562666893005371,
-0.5135201811790466,
0.03497098758816719,
-0.33767032623291016,
-0.06335479021072388,
0.6634180545806885,
0.303573340177536,
0.1812315732240677,
-0.5836189389228821,
-0.2987461984157562,
-0.008938277140259743,
-0.5245973467826843,
-0.105878084897995,
0.5042728185653687,
0.14975278079509735,
0.17146460711956024,
0.7448974251747131,
-0.2588896155357361,
0.5379955172538757,
0.1650599092245102,
0.17800284922122955,
0.32821202278137207,
-0.2253277450799942,
-0.1810097098350525,
-0.16736827790737152,
0.9789540767669678,
0.3514208495616913,
0.4211711585521698,
-0.49246883392333984,
-0.19982409477233887,
-0.16980530321598053,
0.4613645076751709,
-0.5519579648971558,
-0.13493964076042175,
0.14119507372379303,
-0.27527332305908203,
-0.38880905508995056,
0.3059762418270111,
-0.8323438763618469,
-0.20662222802639008,
-0.48857924342155457,
0.5175900459289551,
-0.31393030285835266,
-0.2881740629673004,
0.13608460128307343,
-0.10691750794649124,
0.3092329204082489,
0.45296284556388855,
-0.541013777256012,
0.23116086423397064,
0.8389768600463867,
0.6519578695297241,
-0.36184725165367126,
0.10726012289524078,
-0.42360591888427734,
-0.33417460322380066,
-0.40278369188308716,
0.7813133001327515,
-0.6774002909660339,
-0.44150081276893616,
-0.22154203057289124,
-0.15293405950069427,
0.0313226655125618,
-0.8609634041786194,
0.8673478364944458,
-0.7670761942863464,
0.5545556545257568,
-0.4991200864315033,
-0.7405839562416077,
-0.06125342845916748,
0.3184644877910614,
-0.6682682037353516,
1.4202440977096558,
0.17864705622196198,
-0.9261237978935242,
0.15162760019302368,
-0.4360993206501007,
-0.12432408332824707,
0.24074991047382355,
-0.1579531580209732,
-0.3113757371902466,
0.07724007964134216,
0.13036802411079407,
0.2896932065486908,
-0.5928800702095032,
0.4384140968322754,
-0.4026694595813751,
-0.3293885588645935,
0.46035364270210266,
-0.5364927649497986,
0.7199423909187317,
0.1860852986574173,
-0.3730209171772003,
0.0751306489109993,
-0.7602949738502502,
0.2605910003185272,
0.02433013543486595,
-0.4439680874347687,
-0.28534746170043945,
-0.11366232484579086,
-0.12275488674640656,
0.33266517519950867,
0.1918727308511734,
-0.48796552419662476,
0.14661608636379242,
-0.40025946497917175,
0.0752849206328392,
0.8735898733139038,
0.07530786842107773,
0.42381060123443604,
-0.14878536760807037,
0.6603572368621826,
-0.13821107149124146,
0.23646503686904907,
0.31084004044532776,
-0.472834050655365,
-1.0082498788833618,
-0.1700248271226883,
0.6378152966499329,
0.5364405512809753,
-0.6738112568855286,
0.8290423154830933,
-0.5058821439743042,
-0.5174109935760498,
-0.8134438395500183,
0.051890116184949875,
0.18975242972373962,
0.5380455851554871,
0.24137552082538605,
-0.5712896585464478,
-0.6162399053573608,
-0.7569207549095154,
-0.42730674147605896,
-0.4541934132575989,
-0.20386680960655212,
0.44595253467559814,
0.3154009282588959,
0.03115200065076351,
1.134252905845642,
-0.5490726828575134,
0.0300067737698555,
-0.17170849442481995,
0.5481554269790649,
0.23105508089065552,
0.2631268799304962,
-0.04917002469301224,
-0.7949924468994141,
-0.06036946550011635,
-0.19099096953868866,
-0.985477864742279,
-0.2453848421573639,
-0.05615098774433136,
-0.12473169714212418,
-0.11876111477613449,
0.23303958773612976,
-0.8513209223747253,
0.37110960483551025,
0.20198096334934235,
-0.04593447968363762,
0.9679847955703735,
-0.024844219908118248,
0.3715798556804657,
-0.6186409592628479,
0.17253652215003967,
0.12477307766675949,
-0.3189769685268402,
-0.4663183391094208,
0.09304175525903702,
0.10309872776269913,
0.20249514281749725,
-0.20357367396354675,
0.4039667546749115,
-0.35599029064178467,
-0.2910254895687103,
-0.2974144220352173,
0.5409463047981262,
0.24145156145095825,
0.3778703510761261,
-0.16484631597995758,
0.6294379234313965,
0.2065403014421463,
-0.5218172073364258,
0.418088436126709,
0.02524907886981964,
-0.5335007905960083,
0.3671664595603943,
-0.5620537996292114,
0.5395850539207458,
-0.32130223512649536,
-0.019003737717866898,
-0.8162786364555359,
0.007851625792682171,
0.4387151002883911,
-0.5568152666091919,
0.3350335955619812,
0.03144882246851921,
-0.6582537293434143,
-0.2470504492521286,
-0.2570744752883911,
0.2469046413898468,
0.33172762393951416,
-0.3678862154483795,
0.6395741701126099,
0.42683520913124084,
-0.2481730878353119,
-0.4859721064567566,
-0.42310377955436707,
0.18441730737686157,
-0.12380941957235336,
-0.49185922741889954,
0.07793256640434265,
-0.21515610814094543,
-0.28089240193367004,
-0.00800823699682951,
-0.20485219359397888,
0.04471621662378311,
0.11105149984359741,
0.3509085774421692,
0.557589590549469,
-0.3982773721218109,
0.21835292875766754,
-0.2886848449707031,
-0.06045881658792496,
0.23897020518779755,
0.039497651159763336,
0.28150561451911926,
-0.3763216733932495,
-0.4077080190181732,
-0.2937367856502533,
0.1616702377796173,
0.2849690914154053,
-0.23353494703769684,
0.44243964552879333,
0.5200948119163513,
-0.48626288771629333,
0.13337238132953644,
-0.8101876974105835,
-0.048201072961091995,
-0.3913230001926422,
0.4868609309196472,
-0.4655512571334839,
-0.9153969287872314,
0.11797139793634415,
-0.14383573830127716,
-0.13237479329109192,
0.7016798257827759,
0.5139135718345642,
-0.11443383246660233,
0.8515997529029846,
0.35023757815361023,
-0.1689341515302658,
0.1709197610616684,
-0.07094693928956985,
0.2413363754749298,
-0.8016298413276672,
-0.33895501494407654,
-0.687965989112854,
0.14763280749320984,
-0.45037415623664856,
-0.6085569858551025,
0.32696348428726196,
0.5638307332992554,
0.24342428147792816,
0.13062815368175507,
-0.30961641669273376,
0.4168829917907715,
0.33587902784347534,
0.06032455712556839,
0.4492548704147339,
-0.16560877859592438,
0.03418672829866409,
-0.21961799263954163,
-0.6658610701560974,
-0.866423487663269,
1.0074174404144287,
0.3820628225803375,
0.4481024742126465,
-0.06704773753881454,
0.4764496088027954,
0.5006665587425232,
0.6233228445053101,
-0.747109591960907,
0.45555832982063293,
-0.017988933250308037,
-0.6918969750404358,
-0.28871193528175354,
-0.6851216554641724,
-0.5762759447097778,
0.4518314599990845,
-0.2769298851490021,
-0.7305042147636414,
0.1896044909954071,
-0.18590959906578064,
-0.3775017559528351,
0.05709780007600784,
-0.6527696847915649,
0.8853960037231445,
-0.3343849182128906,
-0.3850787281990051,
-0.1140693947672844,
-0.5809447169303894,
0.47357475757598877,
-0.07217880338430405,
0.27646636962890625,
-0.3618898391723633,
0.12738436460494995,
0.7463662028312683,
-0.0893004834651947,
0.6731283664703369,
-0.13001693785190582,
-0.056339237838983536,
0.39398103952407837,
0.01300072856247425,
0.5454807281494141,
0.04605196788907051,
-0.4079520106315613,
0.32941678166389465,
-0.11601303517818451,
-0.08410627394914627,
-0.8352096080780029,
0.47264817357063293,
-0.6676442623138428,
-0.6925268173217773,
-0.4146859347820282,
-0.22813130915164948,
-0.30492040514945984,
-0.003563620848581195,
0.15674695372581482,
0.08417116105556488,
-0.49130165576934814,
-0.11478827893733978,
0.5963090062141418,
-0.2831263244152069,
0.1530960202217102,
0.5792640447616577,
-0.08614145219326019,
-0.40029752254486084,
0.8073223829269409,
-0.1722133755683899,
0.09622025489807129,
0.44903653860092163,
0.13726377487182617,
-0.4676193594932556,
-0.2002568244934082,
-0.44681474566459656,
0.10939199477434158,
-0.8285809755325317,
-0.369510293006897,
-0.8744114637374878,
-0.36221304535865784,
-0.3583892583847046,
0.4838389754295349,
-0.2799130976200104,
-0.4645894169807434,
-0.6037049889564514,
-0.25711169838905334,
-0.028248123824596405,
0.5110577940940857,
-0.06006084755063057,
-0.09730251133441925,
-0.7478023171424866,
0.4604126513004303,
0.2666017711162567,
-0.015408651903271675,
0.0797031819820404,
-0.7026240825653076,
-0.013938188552856445,
0.013983667828142643,
-0.39115944504737854,
-0.8598830699920654,
0.08137272298336029,
0.21203459799289703,
0.46617889404296875,
0.3702746033668518,
-0.03166770935058594,
0.9021035432815552,
-0.2682107090950012,
0.6631320118904114,
0.15943032503128052,
-0.9569566249847412,
0.3886352777481079,
0.13434863090515137,
0.30438515543937683,
0.6215636730194092,
0.4567563831806183,
-0.6103475093841553,
-0.3333680033683777,
-0.662439227104187,
-0.741944432258606,
0.6326841711997986,
0.2443566769361496,
-0.02224581502377987,
-0.1134403645992279,
0.5632636547088623,
0.2743484079837799,
0.1788390576839447,
-0.6995478272438049,
-0.1885158121585846,
-0.056469254195690155,
-0.33785948157310486,
0.07185222208499908,
-0.4858197867870331,
0.3076445460319519,
-0.21638092398643494,
0.6437155604362488,
0.04641210660338402,
0.08199790865182877,
0.327032208442688,
-0.2168918401002884,
-0.323523610830307,
0.5089297890663147,
0.1660168319940567,
0.623879611492157,
-0.24827253818511963,
0.18155169486999512,
0.18698237836360931,
-0.11308851838111877,
-0.17912033200263977,
0.07307010143995285,
-0.1845361292362213,
0.10125436633825302,
0.4571118950843811,
0.7376634478569031,
0.2726546823978424,
-0.7526821494102478,
0.8143367171287537,
-0.29181724786758423,
0.027809979394078255,
-0.32245776057243347,
0.09417130053043365,
0.014779016375541687,
0.23387911915779114,
0.4080089032649994,
0.18064427375793457,
0.32991841435432434,
-0.4474080204963684,
0.26031023263931274,
0.4660557210445404,
-0.5680552124977112,
-0.4464530944824219,
0.44828203320503235,
-0.19620384275913239,
-0.2435270994901657,
0.675827145576477,
-0.1419878453016281,
-0.5838218927383423,
0.36160504817962646,
0.1846701204776764,
0.8979907631874084,
-0.20392492413520813,
0.3971680998802185,
0.5297041535377502,
0.43905338644981384,
-0.0631435289978981,
0.14776109158992767,
-0.32506176829338074,
-0.700700581073761,
-0.4720465838909149,
-0.8208231329917908,
-0.16154958307743073,
0.19614990055561066,
-0.8651667237281799,
0.19094303250312805,
-0.19790807366371155,
-0.2035287618637085,
0.14491920173168182,
0.08773340284824371,
-0.7705397009849548,
0.5030199289321899,
0.19656136631965637,
0.7411932945251465,
-0.6361612677574158,
0.7169502377510071,
0.3240687847137451,
-0.4799869954586029,
-0.66531902551651,
-0.09699929505586624,
-0.17127838730812073,
-0.4924750328063965,
0.5713023543357849,
0.12271004170179367,
-0.046278517693281174,
-0.21135303378105164,
-0.46135756373405457,
-0.6243633031845093,
0.7279474139213562,
0.3316839337348938,
-0.7892435193061829,
-0.1391199678182602,
0.42748910188674927,
0.7833876609802246,
-0.4112285375595093,
0.6291521787643433,
0.7190766930580139,
0.45460817217826843,
0.01338126789778471,
-0.5547007918357849,
0.1576642096042633,
-0.26679500937461853,
-0.13360179960727692,
-0.1432097852230072,
-0.26168447732925415,
0.4852474629878998,
-0.23646530508995056,
-0.4575410783290863,
0.2012508511543274,
0.6502866148948669,
0.2033185511827469,
0.25345560908317566,
0.6127002835273743,
0.6007850170135498,
0.8193084001541138,
-0.04418836906552315,
0.9798678159713745,
0.11914987862110138,
0.44900572299957275,
1.2217439413070679,
-0.23974773287773132,
0.8938591480255127,
0.39948371052742004,
-0.3073544204235077,
0.37777411937713623,
0.5946069359779358,
-0.08654685318470001,
0.38367965817451477,
0.3251137137413025,
-0.22630314528942108,
-0.4604693353176117,
0.04181603714823723,
-0.18428559601306915,
0.6138938069343567,
0.08434443920850754,
-0.2967716157436371,
-0.12386243790388107,
-0.4105110168457031,
-0.18213336169719696,
-0.15819555521011353,
0.04790657386183739,
0.9290262460708618,
0.11388684809207916,
-0.7205448746681213,
0.6241048574447632,
0.2653454840183258,
0.35752037167549133,
-0.41385433077812195,
-0.1188347339630127,
-0.2894803285598755,
-0.1367853879928589,
-0.17335644364356995,
-0.4928899109363556,
0.14704810082912445,
0.3533700108528137,
-0.30113476514816284,
0.2097824662923813,
0.6611988544464111,
-0.4269600510597229,
-0.4028077721595764,
0.12827451527118683,
0.4655590355396271,
0.36190974712371826,
-0.3766118288040161,
-0.8632634282112122,
0.01759960688650608,
0.15491962432861328,
-0.14184726774692535,
0.028653977438807487,
0.5924547910690308,
0.014377197250723839,
0.4813528060913086,
0.6733382344245911,
0.17950044572353363,
0.17623142898082733,
0.2873094081878662,
0.7766299843788147,
-0.7636035680770874,
-0.04922335594892502,
-0.8869537711143494,
0.4793420135974884,
-0.2747250497341156,
-0.4815460443496704,
0.7690781354904175,
0.8855486512184143,
0.7676128149032593,
-0.026211971417069435,
0.8821179270744324,
-0.026599973440170288,
0.3858090043067932,
-0.41482600569725037,
0.33643069863319397,
-0.4783804714679718,
0.479655385017395,
-0.4963909089565277,
-1.0574736595153809,
-0.10736461728811264,
0.3704112768173218,
-0.4616866707801819,
0.013788415119051933,
0.608178436756134,
0.8364350199699402,
0.14785683155059814,
0.5247405767440796,
0.32705914974212646,
0.2463637739419937,
0.16791796684265137,
0.4418063461780548,
1.3101035356521606,
-0.6771848797798157,
0.3897933065891266,
-0.1459607481956482,
-0.3707198202610016,
-0.13177500665187836,
-0.7051025032997131,
-0.5440436005592346,
-0.48887011408805847,
-0.5471770167350769,
-0.26043519377708435,
0.13245850801467896,
0.5427390336990356,
0.4927193820476532,
-0.8710627555847168,
-0.0019754779059439898,
-0.021796608343720436,
0.13074631989002228,
0.019276393577456474,
-0.3488330543041229,
0.3680882751941681,
-0.28549423813819885,
-0.5423374176025391,
0.3084242343902588,
0.4100132882595062,
-0.2853677272796631,
-0.147200345993042,
-0.10515076667070389,
-0.16109362244606018,
-0.12473287433385849,
0.4383416175842285,
0.13935619592666626,
-0.8198243975639343,
-0.23506762087345123,
-0.07582607865333557,
-0.24643710255622864,
0.3335363566875458,
0.8277735710144043,
-0.6402746438980103,
0.5537804961204529,
0.27063044905662537,
0.6402022242546082,
0.6020172834396362,
0.3443085849285126,
0.3520461916923523,
-0.7244550585746765,
-0.27838757634162903,
0.4855273365974426,
0.030910734087228775,
0.6974600553512573,
-0.3504975438117981,
0.39018166065216064,
0.24909742176532745,
-0.38488924503326416,
-0.6560325622558594,
-0.12721915543079376,
-0.9026613831520081,
-0.2548806667327881,
1.2149100303649902,
-0.21552684903144836,
-0.25124889612197876,
-0.09201788157224655,
-0.230342298746109,
0.41224417090415955,
-0.03151698037981987,
1.1267069578170776,
0.7348698377609253,
0.14928683638572693,
-0.1340729296207428,
-0.5378413200378418,
0.28857555985450745,
0.4984014928340912,
-0.8798585534095764,
0.17747078835964203,
0.5811333656311035,
0.4180016815662384,
0.15378141403198242,
0.5774662494659424,
-0.5610306262969971,
0.22577588260173798,
-0.2618796229362488,
0.3441576659679413,
0.17707820236682892,
-0.11630994826555252,
-0.26871591806411743,
0.36548325419425964,
0.28813430666923523,
-0.06643711775541306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03528v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03528v3
|
BanglaAutoKG: Automatic Bangla Knowledge Graph Construction with Semantic Neural Graph Filtering
| 2024-04-04T15:31:21 | 2024-06-05T13:39:56 |
Azmine Toushik Wasi, Taki Hasan Rafi, Raima Islam, Dong-Kyu Chae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.NE, cs.SI
|
Knowledge Graphs (KGs) have proven essential in information processing and
reasoning applications because they link related entities and give context-rich
information, supporting efficient information retrieval and knowledge
discovery; presenting information flow in a very effective manner. Despite
being widely used globally, Bangla is relatively underrepresented in KGs due to
a lack of comprehensive datasets, encoders, NER (named entity recognition)
models, POS (part-of-speech) taggers, and lemmatizers, hindering efficient
information processing and reasoning applications in the language. Addressing
the KG scarcity in Bengali, we propose BanglaAutoKG, a pioneering framework
that is able to automatically construct Bengali KGs from any Bangla text. We
utilize multilingual LLMs to understand various languages and correlate
entities and relations universally. By employing a translation dictionary to
identify English equivalents and extracting word features from pre-trained BERT
models, we construct the foundational KG. To reduce noise and align word
embeddings with our goal, we employ graph-based polynomial filters. Lastly, we
implement a GNN-based semantic filter, which elevates contextual understanding
and trims unnecessary edges, culminating in the formation of the definitive KG.
Empirical findings and case studies demonstrate the universal effectiveness of
our model, capable of autonomously constructing semantically enriched KGs from
any text.
|
[
-0.3833218514919281,
-0.7523695826530457,
0.14497266709804535,
0.21182505786418915,
-0.40306738018989563,
0.11257560551166534,
0.20078133046627045,
-0.5646195411682129,
0.4470229148864746,
0.4474106729030609,
-0.31189534068107605,
-0.7221186757087708,
-0.7201008200645447,
0.25417304039001465,
-0.19092096388339996,
0.8271995186805725,
0.0575023889541626,
-0.12111873924732208,
-0.23218579590320587,
0.025225365534424782,
-0.5392795205116272,
-0.005160277709364891,
-0.5355618596076965,
-0.8915552496910095,
0.6248375177383423,
-0.006969266105443239,
0.726105272769928,
0.7360555529594421,
-0.009579561650753021,
0.2697761058807373,
-0.13046078383922577,
0.7026227712631226,
-0.34534716606140137,
0.2376033216714859,
-0.13145041465759277,
-0.20810826122760773,
-0.273040771484375,
-0.44718509912490845,
0.5383256673812866,
0.9926963448524475,
0.34847766160964966,
0.05903416499495506,
-0.05147451534867287,
0.782027006149292,
-0.6147504448890686,
0.5771286487579346,
-0.6920782923698425,
0.05124621093273163,
-0.056984495371580124,
-0.08926861733198166,
-0.19251935184001923,
-0.7415822148323059,
-0.22530941665172577,
-0.5184067487716675,
-0.2838780879974365,
0.24371470510959625,
0.9657731056213379,
0.36723655462265015,
-0.8097217082977295,
-0.5042852163314819,
-0.15914319455623627,
0.2867896854877472,
-0.5973641276359558,
0.583310067653656,
0.8036981225013733,
0.28502291440963745,
-0.4392598867416382,
-0.8068137168884277,
-0.48058584332466125,
0.07219314575195312,
-0.43280142545700073,
0.09784694761037827,
0.05075601860880852,
0.13558687269687653,
-0.20846518874168396,
0.033183060586452484,
-0.6555570960044861,
-0.16739052534103394,
-0.589036226272583,
-0.37467220425605774,
0.6297866106033325,
0.0003730678581632674,
0.2248605638742447,
-0.870039701461792,
-0.0837147906422615,
0.42333611845970154,
-0.8195938467979431,
-0.2561858594417572,
0.5179651975631714,
0.5018807649612427,
0.2289649397134781,
0.5849493145942688,
-0.38902175426483154,
1.3313813209533691,
-0.12994500994682312,
-0.36663106083869934,
0.030957140028476715,
-0.2697085440158844,
-0.28751274943351746,
0.3963463306427002,
0.6228551864624023,
0.26352354884147644,
0.4225016236305237,
-0.4207463562488556,
0.14378680288791656,
-0.10229655355215073,
0.10253916680812836,
-0.8369706273078918,
-0.5360134840011597,
-0.00491734966635704,
-0.5030345916748047,
-0.15068912506103516,
-0.3935800790786743,
-0.5146389007568359,
-0.6548555493354797,
-0.3199509084224701,
0.276492714881897,
-0.6018490791320801,
-0.24541157484054565,
-0.2439497858285904,
0.01901116780936718,
-0.032485123723745346,
0.06123826280236244,
-0.7409815192222595,
-0.26281312108039856,
0.27247050404548645,
0.8334659934043884,
0.17658740282058716,
-0.07419443875551224,
-0.16547943651676178,
0.5449764132499695,
-0.4981353282928467,
0.923317551612854,
-0.43404561281204224,
-0.4159967303276062,
0.05286543071269989,
-0.22684280574321747,
-0.09679479151964188,
-0.46912944316864014,
0.28923299908638,
-0.878237783908844,
-0.3039293885231018,
-0.1524638682603836,
-0.915306806564331,
-0.5439976453781128,
0.4905986487865448,
-0.3633989691734314,
0.8979597091674805,
0.2962197959423065,
-0.7547978758811951,
0.4997010827064514,
-0.5371857285499573,
-0.7344747185707092,
0.4107944965362549,
-0.1188478097319603,
-0.08396463096141815,
-0.32976001501083374,
0.4119981825351715,
0.6072918772697449,
-0.2494213879108429,
0.4157625436782837,
-0.2856668531894684,
-0.25812938809394836,
-0.10025566071271896,
0.033709850162267685,
0.8932863473892212,
0.471664160490036,
0.05806143581867218,
0.0804671049118042,
-0.976959228515625,
0.3258267343044281,
0.003566447179764509,
-0.358122855424881,
-0.4094005227088928,
0.035589657723903656,
-0.20752355456352234,
-0.00576973520219326,
0.24277636408805847,
-0.37942594289779663,
0.20080900192260742,
-0.5886595845222473,
0.387066513299942,
0.618299126625061,
0.1164226159453392,
0.2718532085418701,
-0.10888977348804474,
0.30391713976860046,
-0.19044724106788635,
-0.12967659533023834,
-0.20560963451862335,
-0.8888086080551147,
-0.48772352933883667,
-0.36935800313949585,
0.49294957518577576,
0.46644189953804016,
-0.7689865231513977,
0.717786431312561,
-0.3812924325466156,
-0.5495145916938782,
-0.4972796142101288,
0.5687595009803772,
0.12048593908548355,
0.7542253732681274,
0.12060631066560745,
0.02741490676999092,
-0.6468095779418945,
-0.8998907208442688,
-0.1073809564113617,
-0.33848893642425537,
0.1808657944202423,
0.13243812322616577,
0.41433051228523254,
-0.4289707839488983,
1.4924520254135132,
-0.5961759686470032,
-0.34091195464134216,
-0.23740440607070923,
0.04111618176102638,
0.10740809142589569,
0.2110968977212906,
0.4801393747329712,
-1.2084300518035889,
-0.6563034057617188,
0.17047299444675446,
-0.987211287021637,
-0.41279125213623047,
0.2922641634941101,
-0.23305481672286987,
0.199483722448349,
0.5388972759246826,
-0.4632423520088196,
0.7066716551780701,
0.30295562744140625,
-0.49978509545326233,
0.6062983274459839,
-0.05075228214263916,
0.0004324920882936567,
-1.136810541152954,
0.032519370317459106,
-0.3943188488483429,
-0.46865835785865784,
-0.5175020694732666,
-0.06099261716008186,
-0.07356878370046616,
-0.13597215712070465,
-0.06236453354358673,
0.9497516751289368,
-0.2597343325614929,
0.008924293331801891,
-0.5020142197608948,
0.4469752907752991,
0.09649910032749176,
0.4483528137207031,
-0.21495875716209412,
0.30853062868118286,
0.2802693545818329,
-0.722326397895813,
0.6367018818855286,
0.5660010576248169,
-0.3771238923072815,
0.5880947709083557,
-0.3387693166732788,
-0.1412823647260666,
-0.08715535700321198,
0.2671992778778076,
-1.2050114870071411,
-0.49364349246025085,
0.5302079319953918,
-0.5676724314689636,
0.3367941975593567,
-0.5496711134910583,
-0.6880574822425842,
-0.5857646465301514,
0.23673373460769653,
0.2053685039281845,
0.355745404958725,
-0.6044200658798218,
0.7895874381065369,
0.4085639417171478,
-0.2093029022216797,
-0.5404646992683411,
-0.8240534067153931,
0.24723190069198608,
0.09396663308143616,
-0.8284668922424316,
0.06941251456737518,
0.026788895949721336,
0.004727889783680439,
0.39211392402648926,
-0.05132056400179863,
-0.39857837557792664,
-0.13555026054382324,
0.4398222267627716,
0.01551289763301611,
0.1954137086868286,
0.4144716262817383,
0.27464568614959717,
-0.05060066655278206,
-0.032908543944358826,
-0.7366399765014648,
0.5202230215072632,
0.009134047664701939,
-0.4550597071647644,
0.0011175982654094696,
0.19967058300971985,
0.35190877318382263,
0.023120224475860596,
0.834550142288208,
1.0084893703460693,
-0.505841076374054,
-0.11783617734909058,
-0.5694869160652161,
0.09170199930667877,
-0.46803274750709534,
0.45188894867897034,
-0.30594146251678467,
-0.9765921235084534,
0.6239967942237854,
-0.28064921498298645,
-0.35666778683662415,
0.29056504368782043,
0.5326989889144897,
0.2570570409297943,
0.8603523969650269,
0.4431181252002716,
-0.02887578308582306,
0.08014432340860367,
-0.13218720257282257,
0.7810593247413635,
-0.6210917234420776,
-0.4710557162761688,
-0.1781545877456665,
-0.20151732861995697,
-0.6213387250900269,
-0.08415090292692184,
0.291853129863739,
0.4687233567237854,
-0.2945529818534851,
0.11503592133522034,
-0.730721652507782,
0.48325011134147644,
0.45961588621139526,
-0.02629115805029869,
0.19811396300792694,
-0.07710478454828262,
-0.38932380080223083,
0.04922305420041084,
-1.0408885478973389,
-0.3707995116710663,
1.0578773021697998,
-0.31005775928497314,
0.42295828461647034,
-0.20404431223869324,
0.7956767082214355,
0.3595438599586487,
0.4449688196182251,
-0.7128832340240479,
0.5836142897605896,
0.026228636503219604,
-0.7626248002052307,
-0.1399291455745697,
-0.6324281096458435,
-0.9610503315925598,
0.1993354856967926,
-0.11860278993844986,
-0.9457632303237915,
-0.015222380869090557,
0.13919927179813385,
-0.15194490551948547,
0.6010639071464539,
-0.8904630541801453,
0.7512689232826233,
-0.02510986663401127,
-0.2945084273815155,
0.0028147634584456682,
-0.6186210513114929,
0.56432044506073,
-0.18975776433944702,
0.3945801854133606,
-0.19180147349834442,
0.26959875226020813,
0.7210463285446167,
-0.509659469127655,
0.927513837814331,
-0.3102036416530609,
0.05381394550204277,
0.7085407972335815,
0.1299501657485962,
0.42899760603904724,
0.006145949475467205,
-0.09543360024690628,
0.12771888077259064,
-0.056930139660835266,
-0.5091683864593506,
-0.6007342338562012,
0.7038136720657349,
-0.5972386598587036,
-0.2613067030906677,
-0.1512705534696579,
-0.9561335444450378,
-0.21590253710746765,
0.5847405195236206,
0.056257374584674835,
0.36016201972961426,
0.23930196464061737,
0.013954803347587585,
0.15907441079616547,
-0.23677988350391388,
0.23800568282604218,
0.1793147325515747,
-0.6837939023971558,
-0.6723175048828125,
1.11540949344635,
0.5191426873207092,
-0.19670207798480988,
0.28257760405540466,
0.20530618727207184,
-0.550338625907898,
-0.6693182587623596,
-0.39650022983551025,
0.10490299016237259,
-1.0366877317428589,
-0.5235417485237122,
-0.6296581625938416,
-0.4929121434688568,
-0.7177784442901611,
-0.3842070400714874,
-0.069168321788311,
-0.44466400146484375,
0.06972936540842056,
-0.05808677524328232,
0.6808192133903503,
1.0075105428695679,
-0.431197851896286,
0.40245717763900757,
-0.7671435475349426,
0.37889501452445984,
0.4803915321826935,
0.3764418363571167,
0.19033165276050568,
-0.20931744575500488,
-0.5218259692192078,
-0.0978996753692627,
-0.2011861354112625,
-0.7821900248527527,
0.5834218263626099,
0.21978098154067993,
0.3848336935043335,
0.49171188473701477,
0.27008673548698425,
0.7110190987586975,
-0.31776484847068787,
0.657056450843811,
0.2001200169324875,
-0.7274715304374695,
0.5480168461799622,
-0.44539356231689453,
0.33120158314704895,
0.3163284361362457,
0.5271441340446472,
-0.35634854435920715,
-0.2541196346282959,
-0.2232619971036911,
-1.1727615594863892,
0.45048221945762634,
0.2548179030418396,
-0.2535792887210846,
-0.21847529709339142,
0.7140324115753174,
0.04567845165729523,
0.42971011996269226,
-0.7642332911491394,
-0.3197002410888672,
-0.5206665396690369,
-0.3949982225894928,
0.420210599899292,
-0.27636009454727173,
-0.013730939477682114,
-0.4746323227882385,
0.8574778437614441,
-0.2512512803077698,
0.09832547605037689,
0.14315155148506165,
-0.27126508951187134,
0.0753798633813858,
0.03379493206739426,
0.15002082288265228,
0.834859311580658,
-0.34546372294425964,
0.1443551927804947,
-0.006571711506694555,
-0.34741875529289246,
0.16990604996681213,
0.2607930898666382,
-0.5591688752174377,
-0.05872463062405586,
0.2725489139556885,
0.7240567207336426,
0.17970332503318787,
-0.5866150259971619,
0.04256793111562729,
0.37227532267570496,
-0.024240389466285706,
-0.1836344450712204,
0.002598215825855732,
0.5087447166442871,
0.246530681848526,
0.4397994875907898,
-0.1293347030878067,
-0.15264539420604706,
-0.1948413997888565,
0.23667235672473907,
0.25408416986465454,
-0.2541695535182953,
0.09118322283029556,
0.5781014561653137,
0.01674131117761135,
-0.333401083946228,
0.5174321532249451,
-0.8584230542182922,
-0.7645459771156311,
0.2955363094806671,
0.6761930584907532,
0.5383457541465759,
-0.0446951761841774,
0.31500932574272156,
0.5086894631385803,
0.35166361927986145,
0.4081417918205261,
0.06632774323225021,
-0.3311893343925476,
-0.8309482932090759,
-0.652127206325531,
-1.096368432044983,
-0.1628659963607788,
-0.08708874136209488,
-0.18125022947788239,
-0.12758754193782806,
-0.34529659152030945,
-0.14226952195167542,
-0.17090050876140594,
0.27356424927711487,
-0.3995979428291321,
0.3330206871032715,
0.02009286731481552,
0.7498252987861633,
-0.6791971325874329,
0.765699028968811,
0.8084338307380676,
-0.3435177206993103,
-0.8086394667625427,
-0.5664700269699097,
-0.0925188958644867,
-0.9730083346366882,
1.1820082664489746,
0.1449209600687027,
-0.04257763922214508,
0.15892457962036133,
-0.34621939063072205,
-0.8631269335746765,
1.0456711053848267,
0.4323531687259674,
-0.09868382662534714,
-0.11179465055465698,
0.33718863129615784,
0.24365799129009247,
-0.329164057970047,
0.1788235455751419,
0.4762507677078247,
0.9799522757530212,
0.4315964877605438,
-0.4898202419281006,
-0.02640637755393982,
-0.4257456958293915,
-0.18065382540225983,
0.2350153625011444,
-0.5575016736984253,
0.4716407358646393,
0.17263473570346832,
0.11561711877584457,
-0.0036922073923051357,
0.62628573179245,
0.08834876865148544,
0.3349251449108124,
0.3026856780052185,
0.798613429069519,
0.9975689649581909,
-0.17676328122615814,
0.9048620462417603,
-0.584633469581604,
0.016008256003260612,
0.9169022440910339,
-0.13951504230499268,
0.29301780462265015,
0.20192568004131317,
-0.12010069191455841,
0.5022481679916382,
0.8342297077178955,
0.0077164871618151665,
0.5131816864013672,
0.24542343616485596,
-0.18738418817520142,
-0.3749192953109741,
-0.4135955572128296,
-0.24369552731513977,
0.4686044454574585,
0.4477379322052002,
-0.08745221793651581,
-0.5533392429351807,
0.060784321278333664,
0.0531795434653759,
-0.04573532193899155,
-0.5351578593254089,
0.49279865622520447,
0.13533097505569458,
-0.3415166735649109,
0.7338876724243164,
-0.15000437200069427,
0.5294924378395081,
-1.2141633033752441,
0.15754958987236023,
-0.06153256818652153,
0.02741551771759987,
-0.4047658443450928,
-0.4721345901489258,
0.6371991634368896,
-0.13798192143440247,
-0.23606990277767181,
-0.037329405546188354,
1.2335118055343628,
-0.5526453256607056,
-0.5635315179824829,
0.5630518198013306,
0.5041363835334778,
0.16559052467346191,
-0.014617487788200378,
-0.4387693703174591,
-0.14837153255939484,
0.0001975520426640287,
-0.15409672260284424,
0.4213887155056,
0.4673410654067993,
0.09657597541809082,
0.8596127033233643,
0.6045823097229004,
0.4229832589626312,
0.31975242495536804,
-0.04338347166776657,
0.7416068315505981,
-0.31677278876304626,
-0.6874291896820068,
-0.648311972618103,
0.23406735062599182,
-0.1845005303621292,
0.008857760578393936,
0.8880667090415955,
0.46949467062950134,
0.7188431024551392,
0.20195069909095764,
0.9670283198356628,
-0.3024338483810425,
0.10472327470779419,
-0.38865843415260315,
1.3653380870819092,
-0.640964686870575,
-0.1840754747390747,
-0.16353991627693176,
-0.9918551445007324,
-0.5939880609512329,
0.7618368268013,
-0.2863291800022125,
0.009477200917899609,
0.41066086292266846,
0.8093265891075134,
0.11081928014755249,
0.13251066207885742,
0.4505707919597626,
0.3673946261405945,
0.27481964230537415,
0.2924118936061859,
0.4401627480983734,
-0.40837162733078003,
0.8215965032577515,
-0.01714453287422657,
-0.03647662326693535,
-0.16761422157287598,
-1.0294573307037354,
-1.0996605157852173,
-0.614531934261322,
-0.2211550921201706,
-0.24640525877475739,
0.14680592715740204,
0.9875251054763794,
0.9960132837295532,
-0.7931907176971436,
-0.08558020740747452,
-0.14335906505584717,
0.7438371181488037,
0.2174922227859497,
-0.24078373610973358,
0.7350741028785706,
-0.4781980514526367,
-0.34244009852409363,
0.5567517876625061,
0.40937483310699463,
-0.1264485865831375,
-0.060943201184272766,
-0.13658201694488525,
-0.5196714997291565,
0.02284378558397293,
0.6789485812187195,
0.33755260705947876,
-0.39027008414268494,
-0.28631827235221863,
-0.4855509400367737,
0.36778637766838074,
-0.02571595460176468,
0.4738197922706604,
-0.896614670753479,
0.8066818118095398,
0.4093436598777771,
0.9411594867706299,
0.5208289623260498,
-0.30356231331825256,
0.267218679189682,
-0.8569024801254272,
0.2642591893672943,
0.0515754297375679,
0.4615926146507263,
0.6063090562820435,
-0.1628444492816925,
0.5869866013526917,
0.5602801442146301,
-0.5673406720161438,
-0.8668161034584045,
0.44031208753585815,
-0.6043289303779602,
-0.42454031109809875,
0.9205629229545593,
-0.13618113100528717,
-0.4569220542907715,
-0.5175901055335999,
-0.07482437789440155,
0.6406994462013245,
-0.07185055315494537,
0.8630422949790955,
0.7913921475410461,
-0.16409187018871307,
0.2595460116863251,
-0.31872907280921936,
0.20888957381248474,
-0.05579960346221924,
-0.5166574120521545,
-0.13413850963115692,
0.39979299902915955,
0.09567031264305115,
0.3756726384162903,
0.6943897008895874,
0.1890651434659958,
-0.12242614477872849,
0.19342021644115448,
-0.05632933974266052,
-0.6709573864936829,
-0.22884850203990936,
0.31105974316596985,
0.5547675490379333,
-0.1906387209892273,
0.23786486685276031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03514v1
|
Learn When (not) to Trust Language Models: A Privacy-Centric Adaptive Model-Aware Approach
| 2024-04-04T15:21:22 | 2024-04-04T15:21:22 |
Chengkai Huang, Rui Wang, Kaige Xie, Tong Yu, Lina Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs) have been remarkably
competent in various NLP tasks. Despite their great success, the knowledge
provided by the retrieval process is not always useful for improving the model
prediction, since in some samples LLMs may already be quite knowledgeable and
thus be able to answer the question correctly without retrieval. Aiming to save
the cost of retrieval, previous work has proposed to determine when to do/skip
the retrieval in a data-aware manner by analyzing the LLMs' pretraining data.
However, these data-aware methods pose privacy risks and memory limitations,
especially when requiring access to sensitive or extensive pretraining data.
Moreover, these methods offer limited adaptability under fine-tuning or
continual learning settings. We hypothesize that token embeddings are able to
capture the model's intrinsic knowledge, which offers a safer and more
straightforward way to judge the need for retrieval without the privacy risks
associated with accessing pre-training data. Moreover, it alleviates the need
to retain all the data utilized during model pre-training, necessitating only
the upkeep of the token embeddings. Extensive experiments and in-depth analyses
demonstrate the superiority of our model-aware approach.
|
[
-0.1078704446554184,
-0.4013257622718811,
0.5620082020759583,
0.03959795460104942,
-0.15546321868896484,
0.20874592661857605,
-0.11904837191104889,
-0.5160090923309326,
-0.11671549081802368,
0.44725438952445984,
-0.21297389268875122,
-0.5633522272109985,
-0.7895207405090332,
-0.2638085186481476,
-0.6159229874610901,
0.7586228847503662,
0.13890989124774933,
-0.05200766772031784,
-0.2728685438632965,
-0.12838999927043915,
-0.165547177195549,
-0.8245893120765686,
-0.5787384510040283,
-0.13208135962486267,
0.44864392280578613,
0.11728989332914352,
0.6437488198280334,
0.8059752583503723,
0.18091337382793427,
0.19398513436317444,
-0.24284155666828156,
0.08273899555206299,
-0.36578255891799927,
0.05927610024809837,
-0.4714922308921814,
-0.6357259154319763,
-0.4383811354637146,
0.0390256904065609,
0.4940766394138336,
0.6285764575004578,
-0.33143866062164307,
0.1286454051733017,
0.14094485342502594,
0.6802618503570557,
-0.9579402804374695,
0.1632034182548523,
-1.0960724353790283,
0.2686648368835449,
-0.05370117723941803,
-0.2715195417404175,
-0.6136320233345032,
-0.4316032826900482,
0.3542831242084503,
-0.5851244926452637,
-0.0010591374011710286,
0.27720701694488525,
0.5041198134422302,
0.11786964535713196,
-0.22732792794704437,
-0.16223011910915375,
-0.5322058796882629,
0.7639244198799133,
-0.6506742835044861,
0.7219756245613098,
0.9190296530723572,
0.021839994937181473,
0.019121749326586723,
-0.6870288252830505,
-0.4350248873233795,
-0.3596329391002655,
-0.06921751797199249,
-0.192079558968544,
-0.06405612826347351,
-0.0636080801486969,
0.1858719438314438,
0.2983587086200714,
-0.4501190781593323,
0.23427098989486694,
-0.14462095499038696,
-0.5129388570785522,
0.3340398967266083,
-0.16361112892627716,
0.019063901156187057,
-0.0465950183570385,
-0.4942823648452759,
0.040731851011514664,
-0.8752084970474243,
-0.01851613260805607,
0.34541717171669006,
0.3189878463745117,
-0.19156673550605774,
0.565901517868042,
0.01794576644897461,
0.5103745460510254,
0.15385091304779053,
0.08509412407875061,
0.29197829961776733,
-0.25208720564842224,
-0.2571770250797272,
0.061706095933914185,
0.6946247220039368,
-0.06415683776140213,
0.4950951039791107,
-0.4836301803588867,
-0.14311711490154266,
-0.16149674355983734,
0.2997254729270935,
-0.6400504112243652,
-0.12743337452411652,
0.2903701961040497,
-0.3506382405757904,
-0.2522122859954834,
-0.12946555018424988,
-0.4381965398788452,
-0.42925912141799927,
-0.21183881163597107,
0.5385390520095825,
-0.4383113384246826,
-0.25105321407318115,
0.12802140414714813,
0.28559204936027527,
0.0973152443766594,
0.11458447575569153,
-0.9168771505355835,
0.3354857861995697,
0.7916640043258667,
0.799863874912262,
-0.17421980202198029,
-0.318033903837204,
-0.6213271021842957,
0.30256563425064087,
-0.42166122794151306,
0.13478484749794006,
-0.49362143874168396,
-0.6025969386100769,
0.03037143498659134,
0.0845353826880455,
-0.1127510666847229,
-0.3805564045906067,
0.20561574399471283,
-0.8351027369499207,
0.21606171131134033,
-0.2741062045097351,
-0.7941252589225769,
-0.16019155085086823,
0.3678669333457947,
-0.5022804737091064,
0.7194161415100098,
-0.04786542430520058,
-0.9453681707382202,
0.2733534872531891,
-0.5037950277328491,
-0.2627415657043457,
-0.2566750645637512,
-0.06633511185646057,
-0.4083750247955322,
0.1851430982351303,
0.3182636797428131,
0.6305243968963623,
0.2676909863948822,
0.28872808814048767,
-0.5373396277427673,
-0.14317579567432404,
0.3458121120929718,
-0.2912197709083557,
0.7978975176811218,
0.17229218780994415,
-0.24546025693416595,
0.027604887261986732,
-0.6813554763793945,
-0.055676039308309555,
0.03589813411235809,
-0.05559432879090309,
-0.5064037442207336,
0.0015250324504449964,
-0.412524938583374,
0.03480527549982071,
0.5961467027664185,
-0.5489034652709961,
-0.25948837399482727,
-0.4558798372745514,
0.250751256942749,
1.2409261465072632,
-0.1874501258134842,
0.8309778571128845,
-0.3368748724460602,
0.4249889850616455,
0.1619979590177536,
0.5571158528327942,
-0.22618168592453003,
-0.2610008716583252,
-0.6205118298530579,
-0.13363312184810638,
0.47003263235092163,
0.49946555495262146,
-0.5195746421813965,
0.44427210092544556,
-0.22555896639823914,
-0.4547922909259796,
-0.39626193046569824,
0.26782485842704773,
0.5177897214889526,
0.5580083131790161,
0.28638163208961487,
-0.47604408860206604,
-0.43944039940834045,
-0.7035430073738098,
-0.45852911472320557,
-0.35543349385261536,
0.21012289822101593,
0.6443560123443604,
0.34131863713264465,
-0.02215060032904148,
0.8640009760856628,
-0.3338329792022705,
-0.09007508307695389,
0.097760871052742,
-0.26722127199172974,
-0.10074658691883087,
0.6798799633979797,
0.3823305666446686,
-0.828561007976532,
-0.4709712862968445,
0.030937187373638153,
-0.7003651261329651,
0.2799103856086731,
0.14357680082321167,
-0.14665059745311737,
0.1533108800649643,
0.5253501534461975,
-0.5998363494873047,
0.4380475878715515,
0.8018343448638916,
-0.3415006697177887,
0.24135863780975342,
-0.4968651831150055,
-0.31190967559814453,
-1.0678640604019165,
0.20491908490657806,
-0.3668486177921295,
-0.7194284200668335,
-0.4006763696670532,
0.12567296624183655,
0.272927463054657,
-0.019700657576322556,
-0.5184833407402039,
0.8105292320251465,
-0.49502360820770264,
-0.20051690936088562,
-0.2874740660190582,
0.0481804795563221,
0.0639498382806778,
0.3107454478740692,
0.0839916542172432,
0.7612188458442688,
0.8353514671325684,
-0.795676052570343,
-0.23871615529060364,
0.17266857624053955,
-0.2886919379234314,
0.16341707110404968,
-0.45569196343421936,
0.6865373253822327,
-0.07984739542007446,
-0.08234048634767532,
-0.5583097338676453,
0.10025986284017563,
0.3800351023674011,
-0.6340883374214172,
0.5206224322319031,
-0.2096991240978241,
-0.5542972087860107,
0.1111237183213234,
-0.30947810411453247,
0.22727859020233154,
0.4665362536907196,
-0.7494240999221802,
0.9532363414764404,
0.6316954493522644,
-0.1433643400669098,
-1.0469242334365845,
-0.6392753720283508,
-0.13551904261112213,
-0.21437612175941467,
-0.06709238141775131,
0.27988702058792114,
-0.12644852697849274,
0.02832958661019802,
0.14530925452709198,
-0.24952314794063568,
-0.13570663332939148,
0.5713483691215515,
0.36427637934684753,
0.2395915985107422,
0.10321921855211258,
0.12528912723064423,
-0.06732755899429321,
-0.18571223318576813,
0.1682659536600113,
-0.5110718607902527,
0.48130491375923157,
-0.014418933540582657,
-0.5559765100479126,
-0.3974844813346863,
0.11364007741212845,
0.3167247772216797,
-0.4531002640724182,
1.1189621686935425,
0.36969131231307983,
-0.5254974365234375,
-0.17603100836277008,
-0.7164775729179382,
-0.2741200923919678,
-0.5229153037071228,
0.2310027778148651,
0.0053847962990403175,
-1.2261422872543335,
0.6405320167541504,
0.09931621700525284,
0.21064315736293793,
0.04947453737258911,
0.47704121470451355,
-0.008585266768932343,
0.6894816160202026,
0.8909081816673279,
-0.3549244701862335,
0.7055892944335938,
0.17521992325782776,
0.27253079414367676,
-0.8434457778930664,
-0.46685779094696045,
-0.5556957721710205,
-0.033818550407886505,
-0.7235363125801086,
-0.3862224519252777,
0.0506218783557415,
-0.041472580283880234,
-0.4453911781311035,
0.21294328570365906,
-0.20910058915615082,
0.4729732871055603,
0.44329342246055603,
0.3209719657897949,
0.4345068037509918,
-0.07445308566093445,
0.1676076352596283,
0.03742988780140877,
-0.4715820848941803,
-0.1990176886320114,
1.6345795392990112,
0.426216721534729,
0.7533717751502991,
0.1239987313747406,
0.777622640132904,
0.17729811370372772,
0.3119488060474396,
-0.6017329692840576,
0.5037546753883362,
-0.09756701439619064,
-0.7823969125747681,
-0.18784275650978088,
-0.5869631171226501,
-0.9245492815971375,
0.08654607087373734,
-0.1313958317041397,
-0.9402072429656982,
0.3427707254886627,
0.2925146520137787,
-0.3971076011657715,
0.33088135719299316,
-0.716572642326355,
0.5184919238090515,
-0.23207877576351166,
-0.4698408544063568,
-0.2033400982618332,
-0.6631150245666504,
0.255521297454834,
-0.4935060143470764,
0.40112143754959106,
-0.0382799468934536,
-0.20089112222194672,
0.7369214296340942,
-0.019028181210160255,
0.9437112808227539,
-0.40933969616889954,
0.189296156167984,
0.14734631776809692,
0.33003678917884827,
0.6478137373924255,
0.030110901221632957,
-0.15398451685905457,
0.15906769037246704,
-0.010105128400027752,
-0.28711313009262085,
-0.5920534729957581,
0.7758884429931641,
-0.6461448669433594,
-0.823727548122406,
-0.37763747572898865,
-0.3878656327724457,
-0.5413118004798889,
0.349077969789505,
-0.15996500849723816,
-0.06671945750713348,
0.025723380967974663,
0.4690569043159485,
0.9495258331298828,
-0.2801002562046051,
0.3568180203437805,
0.590552806854248,
-0.5680842399597168,
-0.14840276539325714,
0.7026275396347046,
0.12980598211288452,
0.2829546630382538,
0.3242577612400055,
0.4217740297317505,
-0.5265070796012878,
-0.8660657405853271,
0.05610480532050133,
0.1754295974969864,
-0.7220866680145264,
-0.1690508872270584,
-0.7452507019042969,
-0.1988954395055771,
-0.3721590042114258,
0.12888392806053162,
-0.5684636831283569,
-0.40765175223350525,
-0.5299805998802185,
-0.5288204550743103,
0.5286471843719482,
0.32213446497917175,
-0.146546870470047,
0.34197327494621277,
-0.919209361076355,
-0.022216802462935448,
0.2587592303752899,
0.6619760990142822,
0.13722428679466248,
-0.7518088221549988,
-0.24528199434280396,
-0.10764473676681519,
-0.0953550636768341,
-0.5032820701599121,
0.34318792819976807,
0.2130894809961319,
0.6982719302177429,
0.27901992201805115,
0.012314909137785435,
0.49725455045700073,
-0.4773598611354828,
0.7375707626342773,
-0.09377840161323547,
-1.114620327949524,
0.3985673189163208,
-0.16530251502990723,
-0.22011049091815948,
0.7153404951095581,
0.5419071316719055,
-0.06695972383022308,
-0.10414880514144897,
-0.756456732749939,
-0.8179759383201599,
0.4767891466617584,
-0.04865338280797005,
0.5992996692657471,
0.029275113716721535,
0.6880521774291992,
0.19991779327392578,
0.49829867482185364,
-0.8756561279296875,
-0.15425372123718262,
-0.24933716654777527,
-0.09671416878700256,
-0.0632081925868988,
-0.3228878378868103,
-0.07572755217552185,
-0.12304966896772385,
0.6189495325088501,
-0.11103242635726929,
0.119334377348423,
-0.05337727814912796,
-0.23546268045902252,
0.24424341320991516,
0.20429687201976776,
0.17871099710464478,
0.8446943163871765,
-0.3203440010547638,
0.10154348611831665,
0.10632739216089249,
-0.5131219625473022,
-0.06480315327644348,
0.03647604212164879,
-0.21174392104148865,
-0.09865544736385345,
0.01996590942144394,
0.7113122344017029,
0.3367443084716797,
-0.6539098620414734,
0.7398839592933655,
-0.039353348314762115,
-0.06384695321321487,
-0.4528644382953644,
0.03508992865681648,
0.27185896039009094,
0.22767093777656555,
0.12549228966236115,
-0.03185483068227768,
0.0005241715698502958,
-0.43272751569747925,
0.39745137095451355,
0.48962339758872986,
-0.4742259979248047,
-0.3551860749721527,
0.6087002754211426,
-0.20269672572612762,
-0.22195488214492798,
0.5193241238594055,
0.05552956834435463,
-0.30439892411231995,
0.11417116224765778,
0.462594211101532,
0.8315790891647339,
-0.5228973031044006,
0.09589909762144089,
0.13524596393108368,
0.2750323414802551,
-0.29913806915283203,
0.3184589147567749,
-0.06340494006872177,
-0.8666353821754456,
-0.32098400592803955,
-0.4787989556789398,
-0.46672260761260986,
0.06626524031162262,
-1.0011329650878906,
-0.08767256140708923,
-0.9587343335151672,
-0.2313126027584076,
-0.5373269319534302,
-0.24229830503463745,
-0.7831695079803467,
0.17178314924240112,
0.055013157427310944,
1.080561637878418,
-0.5863739252090454,
1.0323076248168945,
0.16505879163742065,
0.014261615462601185,
-0.8637240529060364,
-0.039026036858558655,
-0.18376277387142181,
-1.1329723596572876,
0.38194966316223145,
-0.037205666303634644,
-0.012322237715125084,
0.019659996032714844,
-0.5698249936103821,
-0.8317736387252808,
1.0954663753509521,
0.6300277709960938,
-0.6161600947380066,
-0.14879284799098969,
-0.14978379011154175,
0.37334054708480835,
-0.26268574595451355,
-0.09855065494775772,
0.27956297993659973,
0.2930922210216522,
-0.09353890269994736,
-0.9465952515602112,
0.03821174427866936,
0.13675737380981445,
-0.07285299897193909,
-0.2713772654533386,
-0.48747050762176514,
0.967974066734314,
-0.14444959163665771,
-0.11778699606657028,
-0.11754844337701797,
0.6881738901138306,
0.3020648658275604,
0.3141794800758362,
0.6224111914634705,
0.42886531352996826,
1.0604867935180664,
0.30771705508232117,
1.2526158094406128,
-0.5177649855613708,
0.31212595105171204,
1.4013625383377075,
-0.274393767118454,
1.1530771255493164,
0.600550651550293,
-0.0386962816119194,
0.23600263893604279,
0.40963903069496155,
0.362056165933609,
0.8107935190200806,
0.0051595186814665794,
-0.14539240300655365,
-0.31857025623321533,
-0.2204897254705429,
-0.4240839183330536,
0.5464153289794922,
0.37113991379737854,
-0.7462930679321289,
-0.047148242592811584,
-0.12842784821987152,
0.1140340119600296,
0.15291474759578705,
-0.42026636004447937,
0.9112396836280823,
0.46335798501968384,
-0.23354150354862213,
0.1908159852027893,
-0.13721419870853424,
0.6011549234390259,
-0.760784924030304,
0.4117867052555084,
-0.16285908222198486,
0.1311599463224411,
-0.09366390109062195,
-0.551377534866333,
0.37965908646583557,
0.01689063012599945,
-0.052979666739702225,
-0.19470541179180145,
0.5488686561584473,
-0.21615298092365265,
-0.3394007384777069,
0.4899721145629883,
0.7524219751358032,
-0.08299736678600311,
-0.15223798155784607,
-0.8053244948387146,
-0.01483815535902977,
-0.08789248019456863,
-0.43864351511001587,
0.7636396288871765,
0.26689356565475464,
0.10352768748998642,
0.9445140957832336,
0.8555161952972412,
0.2278803288936615,
0.13795335590839386,
-0.009585517458617687,
0.8742275834083557,
-0.43719005584716797,
-0.6386631727218628,
-1.0560078620910645,
0.31242606043815613,
0.12069143354892731,
0.0957288146018982,
0.7904582619667053,
0.5066901445388794,
0.9743197560310364,
0.20324431359767914,
0.8465781807899475,
0.46896177530288696,
0.7145666480064392,
-0.7611721754074097,
0.9754148125648499,
-0.46280595660209656,
0.4056614637374878,
-0.025195136666297913,
-0.7772361040115356,
-0.3763723373413086,
0.7639341354370117,
-0.38934409618377686,
0.11019986867904663,
0.43220090866088867,
0.9486111998558044,
-0.0917644277215004,
0.0790274441242218,
0.2556559145450592,
0.19259795546531677,
0.4181220829486847,
0.33722561597824097,
0.7316384315490723,
-0.27154508233070374,
0.1902506947517395,
-0.30497878789901733,
-0.017064416781067848,
0.10786106437444687,
-1.2054294347763062,
-0.9108615517616272,
-0.45383143424987793,
-0.13647407293319702,
-0.4105086624622345,
0.1598578691482544,
0.972429096698761,
0.7394976019859314,
-0.8066818714141846,
0.08941326290369034,
0.09590829163789749,
0.2790234088897705,
0.10963781923055649,
-0.07967974245548248,
0.5276458859443665,
-0.059473246335983276,
-0.5657176375389099,
0.45647674798965454,
0.11901616305112839,
0.2819202244281769,
-0.3491233289241791,
-0.011599430814385414,
-0.0863661989569664,
0.05160469189286232,
0.304526150226593,
0.3575751781463623,
-0.5144635438919067,
-0.47695061564445496,
0.19942568242549896,
0.12176590412855148,
0.027712274342775345,
0.7438009977340698,
-0.7517589926719666,
0.605632483959198,
0.3005755841732025,
1.0632461309432983,
0.39879828691482544,
-0.0629831850528717,
0.4815369248390198,
-0.7034774422645569,
0.319803923368454,
0.362251341342926,
0.4259917438030243,
0.5867655873298645,
-0.5328077077865601,
0.11583186686038971,
-0.017856743186712265,
-0.45886313915252686,
-1.028102159500122,
0.09034653007984161,
-0.9034332633018494,
-0.06433364748954773,
0.9619592428207397,
-0.7181127667427063,
-0.3471035361289978,
-0.22432242333889008,
0.26195982098579407,
0.11599957942962646,
-0.30466359853744507,
0.9763767123222351,
0.5217180252075195,
0.26116764545440674,
-0.2624374032020569,
-0.40320083498954773,
0.511401891708374,
0.4305395185947418,
-0.5245323777198792,
0.34092146158218384,
0.05789513513445854,
0.5791236758232117,
0.05131319537758827,
0.7661947011947632,
-0.49132758378982544,
-0.04486488178372383,
-0.22784242033958435,
-0.3842301070690155,
-0.4390260875225067,
-0.4254506528377533,
-0.38310518860816956,
0.13429227471351624,
0.4665088653564453,
-0.2927003502845764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03491v1
|
A Cause-Effect Look at Alleviating Hallucination of Knowledge-grounded Dialogue Generation
| 2024-04-04T14:45:26 | 2024-04-04T14:45:26 |
Jifan Yu, Xiaohan Zhang, Yifan Xu, Xuanyu Lei, Zijun Yao, Jing Zhang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Empowered by the large-scale pretrained language models, existing dialogue
systems have demonstrated impressive performance conducting fluent and
natural-sounding conversations. However, they are still plagued by the
hallucination problem, causing unpredictable factual errors in the generated
responses. Recently, knowledge-grounded dialogue generation models, that
intentionally invoke external knowledge resources to more informative
responses, are also proven to be effective in reducing hallucination. Following
the idea of getting high-quality knowledge, a few efforts have achieved pretty
good performance on this issue. As some inevitable knowledge noises may also
lead to hallucinations, it is emergent to investigate the reason and future
directions for building noise-tolerant methods in KGD tasks. In this paper, we
analyze the causal story behind this problem with counterfactual reasoning
methods. Based on the causal effect analysis, we propose a possible solution
for alleviating the hallucination in KGD by exploiting the dialogue-knowledge
interaction. Experimental results of our example implementation show that this
method can reduce hallucination without disrupting other dialogue performance,
while keeping adaptive to different generation models. We hope our efforts can
support and call for more attention to developing lightweight techniques
towards robust and trusty dialogue systems.
|
[
-0.6501252055168152,
-1.0469679832458496,
0.8671396374702454,
0.05097644031047821,
-0.21575146913528442,
-0.4421219229698181,
0.09628991782665253,
-0.28974953293800354,
0.25948095321655273,
0.8009436130523682,
-0.6277552843093872,
-0.25961726903915405,
-0.6505162715911865,
-0.16855674982070923,
-0.24485887587070465,
0.8156249523162842,
0.18194924294948578,
0.018787670880556107,
-0.2577041983604431,
-0.14479482173919678,
-0.9791680574417114,
-0.512731671333313,
-0.4866136312484741,
-0.43890559673309326,
0.4011342525482178,
0.2239137440919876,
0.8404366374015808,
0.17180883884429932,
0.03855035826563835,
0.23163607716560364,
0.0815342366695404,
0.11229290813207626,
-0.7559929490089417,
0.3051575720310211,
-0.12489278614521027,
-0.33571746945381165,
-0.08588764071464539,
-0.16408875584602356,
0.29094943404197693,
0.769260048866272,
-0.2875286340713501,
-0.3707956373691559,
0.06282424926757812,
0.6133127212524414,
-0.5742358565330505,
0.05324710160493851,
-0.6443537473678589,
0.23230506479740143,
0.3171239495277405,
-0.5231337547302246,
-0.3304687738418579,
-0.35418930649757385,
0.013403252698481083,
-0.7140007615089417,
0.1623043417930603,
-0.03637002408504486,
0.5407378673553467,
0.6955188512802124,
-0.2503315508365631,
-0.5338414907455444,
-0.8763490319252014,
0.5036448240280151,
-0.7215680480003357,
0.739776074886322,
0.5633966326713562,
0.09889697283506393,
-0.511326789855957,
-0.3006686270236969,
-0.8365117311477661,
-0.14800110459327698,
-0.1714305579662323,
0.1604098081588745,
-0.00958313699811697,
0.17705251276493073,
0.5241861343383789,
-0.010749788023531437,
-0.4111412465572357,
-0.1961628496646881,
-0.29961222410202026,
-0.2803538143634796,
0.16593298316001892,
-0.04591159522533417,
0.2318599373102188,
-0.28328239917755127,
0.1137329712510109,
-0.025727979838848114,
-0.8764470815658569,
-0.19710293412208557,
0.3061768710613251,
0.017571164295077324,
0.2423740029335022,
0.42084595561027527,
-0.4056825041770935,
0.5663721561431885,
0.16070789098739624,
-0.17639128863811493,
-0.15940384566783905,
-0.23961983621120453,
-0.3835366666316986,
0.5207512378692627,
0.4422527551651001,
0.5584414601325989,
0.3437122404575348,
-0.44209983944892883,
0.08667141944169998,
0.1247093677520752,
0.6256966590881348,
-1.1145411729812622,
-0.4235436022281647,
0.1070268303155899,
-0.45342376828193665,
-0.48663946986198425,
-0.3065934479236603,
-0.8001700639724731,
-0.6136801838874817,
-0.5744938254356384,
0.8540695309638977,
-0.32910460233688354,
-0.6000363230705261,
0.0712427869439125,
-0.14181335270404816,
-0.14379507303237915,
0.19269856810569763,
-0.6901981234550476,
0.11751938611268997,
0.3620651364326477,
0.5712965726852417,
0.250268816947937,
-0.06398094445466995,
-0.7106762528419495,
0.18755370378494263,
-0.5194876790046692,
0.6182961463928223,
-0.24775290489196777,
-0.6119719743728638,
-0.23470842838287354,
-0.0813017264008522,
-0.12459378689527512,
-0.7753282189369202,
0.45676860213279724,
-0.1771060675382614,
0.2380504459142685,
-0.7683453559875488,
-0.13900770246982574,
-0.29955172538757324,
0.266491174697876,
-0.20516331493854523,
0.6819740533828735,
0.14481547474861145,
-0.7511483430862427,
0.5989770889282227,
-0.36998251080513,
-0.4958517849445343,
-0.258357435464859,
-0.24357067048549652,
-0.4156157970428467,
0.34258514642715454,
0.29010507464408875,
0.2975574731826782,
-0.3407856523990631,
0.8071576356887817,
-0.21290048956871033,
-0.25898998975753784,
0.1373620629310608,
-0.3977315127849579,
0.5902788043022156,
0.3315093517303467,
-0.726033091545105,
0.11759014427661896,
-0.8862630724906921,
-0.19589374959468842,
-0.04841979220509529,
0.35970374941825867,
-0.43759065866470337,
0.05481788143515587,
-0.5374998450279236,
0.4005901515483856,
-0.4833223223686218,
-0.12619435787200928,
-0.18282973766326904,
-0.33722028136253357,
-0.11202557384967804,
0.8432351350784302,
0.26420721411705017,
0.22484855353832245,
-0.41224178671836853,
0.27935776114463806,
0.4788621664047241,
0.23726056516170502,
0.011718977242708206,
-0.3495864272117615,
-0.9725467562675476,
-0.20790189504623413,
-0.33888235688209534,
0.25167903304100037,
-1.0399610996246338,
0.29368656873703003,
0.025611134245991707,
-0.34660232067108154,
-0.34079983830451965,
0.139259472489357,
0.3472966253757477,
0.9880563020706177,
0.34955713152885437,
-0.2832954227924347,
-0.5340790152549744,
-0.6450178027153015,
-0.04913165792822838,
-0.3637399971485138,
0.039119042456150055,
0.5530767440795898,
0.20433512330055237,
-0.37480512261390686,
0.9977142810821533,
-0.5298916101455688,
-0.13514398038387299,
0.03762895613908768,
0.4455026686191559,
-0.008813867345452309,
0.5632154941558838,
0.4706210196018219,
-0.6272749304771423,
-0.10559377819299698,
-0.12783825397491455,
-1.0222997665405273,
-0.5607134103775024,
-0.3541654348373413,
-0.3753712475299835,
0.2844477891921997,
0.6598068475723267,
-1.0021262168884277,
0.48859328031539917,
0.2792535126209259,
-0.2087181955575943,
0.9177840948104858,
0.17226442694664001,
0.4439746141433716,
-1.1140238046646118,
0.11854169517755508,
-0.4490540325641632,
0.27453336119651794,
-0.6661826968193054,
-0.4173094928264618,
-0.6141694188117981,
-0.21718691289424896,
-0.12069445103406906,
0.23984839022159576,
0.08437170088291168,
-0.10139717161655426,
-0.36102941632270813,
0.3098756670951843,
-0.07943479716777802,
0.5163505673408508,
0.15731164813041687,
0.6317079067230225,
0.6233668327331543,
-0.9047101736068726,
0.2734523117542267,
0.3288800120353699,
-0.3518139719963074,
0.7799420952796936,
-0.4610631465911865,
-0.05867480859160423,
-0.3762598931789398,
0.12091322988271713,
-0.9809618592262268,
-0.18766170740127563,
0.6489325165748596,
-0.39875689148902893,
0.059927694499492645,
0.250545471906662,
-0.4474751651287079,
-0.07469642162322998,
0.04122813045978546,
0.3660179674625397,
0.5171952247619629,
-0.8725199103355408,
0.6812965273857117,
-0.0029052365571260452,
-0.2697474956512451,
-0.3061794340610504,
-0.11122369766235352,
0.09069664776325226,
-0.4412981867790222,
-0.7632328271865845,
-0.13675712049007416,
-0.29029908776283264,
-0.42365512251853943,
-0.14221331477165222,
-0.47105440497398376,
0.19304563105106354,
0.28728798031806946,
0.3365427255630493,
-0.007147247903048992,
-0.11151833087205887,
0.30856290459632874,
0.09482691437005997,
-0.20051035284996033,
0.5101134777069092,
-0.3636578619480133,
0.5364595055580139,
0.4466659724712372,
-0.42912185192108154,
-0.3060239553451538,
0.12708458304405212,
0.7772773504257202,
0.37677863240242004,
0.789717972278595,
0.46692007780075073,
-0.18951347470283508,
-0.08709847182035446,
-0.9911448955535889,
-0.7458412051200867,
-0.4414708912372589,
0.2045426219701767,
-0.47228696942329407,
-0.6594077944755554,
0.5690129995346069,
-0.472088485956192,
-0.4098539352416992,
0.21275058388710022,
0.47413328289985657,
0.06302861124277115,
0.912743866443634,
0.1337127387523651,
0.015333511866629124,
0.18204154074192047,
0.32615190744400024,
0.8146279454231262,
-0.5148686170578003,
-0.28348037600517273,
-0.5812211036682129,
0.08072246611118317,
-0.3781859278678894,
-0.20232786238193512,
0.30460935831069946,
0.4535609483718872,
-0.17817449569702148,
0.10112841427326202,
-0.4576534926891327,
0.22327399253845215,
0.424470454454422,
-0.02462918497622013,
0.32934242486953735,
-0.05904523655772209,
-0.2694796919822693,
-0.12708023190498352,
-0.7609643936157227,
-0.06855961680412292,
0.815947413444519,
-0.07616588473320007,
0.7389793395996094,
0.037523332983255386,
0.4625117778778076,
0.0909959226846695,
0.07473468780517578,
-0.5304061770439148,
0.5789464712142944,
0.5754859447479248,
-0.39041078090667725,
-0.41176775097846985,
-0.6522456407546997,
-0.4784799814224243,
0.3528837561607361,
-0.26988810300827026,
-0.8503774404525757,
0.24698850512504578,
0.04172597452998161,
-0.18916842341423035,
0.09056365489959717,
-0.6379207372665405,
0.7242521643638611,
0.08256985247135162,
-0.5390126705169678,
-0.3892330527305603,
-0.6170677542686462,
0.7462949752807617,
-0.3882713317871094,
0.33814358711242676,
0.31322813034057617,
1.2143830060958862,
0.6119954586029053,
-0.46756890416145325,
0.9070982336997986,
-0.47497084736824036,
-0.45968350768089294,
0.2859915494918823,
0.2643156945705414,
0.7928677201271057,
0.06823486089706421,
0.35950157046318054,
-0.01663452386856079,
-0.27557775378227234,
-0.038895342499017715,
-0.9730144739151001,
0.6904117465019226,
-0.8259347677230835,
-0.9557902216911316,
-0.10941198468208313,
-0.8272013664245605,
-0.3022603690624237,
-0.004528386518359184,
0.3508572280406952,
0.3708626329898834,
-0.2669721841812134,
0.22618627548217773,
1.0468721389770508,
-0.45736318826675415,
0.23642948269844055,
0.4710089862346649,
-0.4313203692436218,
-0.3607281446456909,
0.9559011459350586,
0.34483227133750916,
0.3862459659576416,
-0.08227553218603134,
0.29612472653388977,
-0.19259992241859436,
-0.14784440398216248,
-0.28279250860214233,
0.009886080399155617,
-0.7658422589302063,
-0.041833650320768356,
-1.0442328453063965,
-0.21016082167625427,
-0.5937553644180298,
-0.4015244245529175,
-0.2772998809814453,
-0.4458584785461426,
-0.1218334436416626,
-0.335858017206192,
0.18100310862064362,
0.5476366281509399,
-0.2661769688129425,
0.3438282907009125,
-0.4558686912059784,
0.7246026396751404,
0.6071722507476807,
0.18224501609802246,
0.3423953652381897,
-0.27805987000465393,
-0.18132148683071136,
0.01623433269560337,
-0.45667967200279236,
-0.6095077991485596,
0.227204367518425,
-0.35496774315834045,
0.62894606590271,
0.7585657238960266,
0.5159083008766174,
0.8567784428596497,
-0.15574145317077637,
0.7449986934661865,
0.4126623272895813,
-0.9263171553611755,
0.5145888924598694,
-0.3164074718952179,
0.2038351148366928,
0.20717619359493256,
0.272665798664093,
-0.5760826468467712,
-0.6988929510116577,
-0.7403661012649536,
-0.5294272303581238,
0.6683809161186218,
0.44178879261016846,
-0.2687934339046478,
-0.11001279205083847,
0.06154564768075943,
0.29227688908576965,
0.2983910143375397,
-0.7092245221138,
0.03455580398440361,
-0.7259237170219421,
0.15958410501480103,
-0.07239698618650436,
-0.4688751995563507,
-0.45247024297714233,
-0.2337343543767929,
1.0436022281646729,
-0.05274828150868416,
0.21314872801303864,
0.2620477080345154,
-0.2388886660337448,
-0.35414013266563416,
0.37196341156959534,
0.9094699025154114,
0.6799061298370361,
-0.13568460941314697,
0.21468575298786163,
0.1860765814781189,
-0.1799011081457138,
0.10030891001224518,
-0.08532621711492538,
-0.3086157739162445,
-0.01646931655704975,
0.08567477762699127,
0.9937974810600281,
0.1731502264738083,
-0.452422171831131,
0.2689261734485626,
0.24531984329223633,
-0.41039177775382996,
-0.09681762754917145,
0.12169817090034485,
0.03804674372076988,
0.2429751306772232,
0.27087876200675964,
0.20920728147029877,
0.14011555910110474,
-0.4095691442489624,
0.2898420989513397,
0.44562003016471863,
-0.5012044310569763,
-0.1878294050693512,
0.6393561959266663,
0.21974678337574005,
-0.119439996778965,
0.6974785923957825,
-0.18791615962982178,
-0.6311925649642944,
0.3960281014442444,
0.7142488360404968,
0.9584660530090332,
-0.24830976128578186,
0.4404609799385071,
0.3502102494239807,
0.32934632897377014,
-0.0581173337996006,
0.028310634195804596,
-0.47950097918510437,
-1.0087581872940063,
-0.5082143545150757,
-0.4529085159301758,
-0.22287434339523315,
0.1518808901309967,
-0.4768018126487732,
0.08973930776119232,
-0.2225455343723297,
0.07600237429141998,
-0.5150852203369141,
-0.49371588230133057,
-0.28136906027793884,
0.21737094223499298,
-0.2244233340024948,
0.10527324676513672,
-1.160410761833191,
0.5205404162406921,
0.004572402685880661,
-0.27420133352279663,
-0.5354857444763184,
0.24042096734046936,
0.05870271846652031,
-0.6123071312904358,
0.9252520203590393,
0.19643868505954742,
-0.35130274295806885,
0.10250594466924667,
-0.44078055024147034,
-0.5138678550720215,
0.7869914770126343,
0.26504403352737427,
-0.3893720507621765,
0.3282540440559387,
0.41714009642601013,
0.25518298149108887,
-0.11438073962926865,
0.019891778007149696,
0.6324056386947632,
0.6977185606956482,
0.4687434434890747,
-0.8401947617530823,
0.42579153180122375,
-0.07979369908571243,
-0.2140360027551651,
0.1483411341905594,
-0.4007822871208191,
0.2890065014362335,
-0.15219953656196594,
-0.020343894138932228,
-0.0778411328792572,
0.3039298355579376,
0.5703743100166321,
0.5783252120018005,
0.5992539525032043,
0.8306390643119812,
0.6993359327316284,
-0.07246742397546768,
0.5861243605613708,
-0.2618122696876526,
-0.16501489281654358,
0.8514752984046936,
-0.4496783912181854,
-0.012194865383207798,
0.8126411437988281,
0.1791919767856598,
0.2023509442806244,
-0.0009233237360604107,
0.27576538920402527,
0.8003339171409607,
0.34645411372184753,
-0.5880457162857056,
-0.4081152677536011,
-0.5641689896583557,
-0.5787498950958252,
0.2043793499469757,
0.305901437997818,
-0.07883019745349884,
-0.20915856957435608,
0.3931702971458435,
0.028136281296610832,
-0.040882594883441925,
-0.11245965957641602,
0.947474479675293,
0.06756819039583206,
-0.8460133671760559,
0.691623330116272,
-0.5895219445228577,
0.3049011826515198,
-0.4107489287853241,
-0.24076762795448303,
-0.21812228858470917,
0.018179135397076607,
-0.12910132110118866,
0.05708761140704155,
0.41117963194847107,
-0.500576376914978,
-0.2118365615606308,
-0.22173114120960236,
0.8296622633934021,
-0.30285707116127014,
-0.24148127436637878,
0.3765028119087219,
0.5168713331222534,
0.19303807616233826,
-0.3214496970176697,
0.08894078433513641,
0.08050333708524704,
0.07606256753206253,
-0.0682487040758133,
0.46324893832206726,
0.8922449350357056,
0.02312912791967392,
0.5417516231536865,
0.7181440591812134,
-0.09616261720657349,
-0.06074559688568115,
0.28137317299842834,
1.122084379196167,
-0.6801628470420837,
-0.43924859166145325,
-0.5501165390014648,
0.43024784326553345,
0.05318648740649223,
0.042232997715473175,
0.6356246471405029,
0.26270875334739685,
0.6313104629516602,
-0.18056409060955048,
0.859073281288147,
-0.05708390474319458,
0.2514623701572418,
-0.6662675738334656,
0.9915750622749329,
-0.41528356075286865,
0.23366229236125946,
-0.7667520642280579,
-1.0371596813201904,
-0.19547131657600403,
0.6849907636642456,
-0.1221872940659523,
0.007776231039315462,
0.9105113744735718,
1.2292530536651611,
0.2510160207748413,
0.2877759039402008,
0.7808542251586914,
0.6443018317222595,
0.4182179868221283,
0.18920855224132538,
0.9570747017860413,
-0.22963283956050873,
0.6050094962120056,
-0.14214792847633362,
-0.11494302749633789,
-0.28574684262275696,
-0.7492672204971313,
-1.044734239578247,
-0.6030727624893188,
-0.312551349401474,
-0.5451248288154602,
0.4465809464454651,
0.6204774975776672,
0.38956892490386963,
-0.7255659699440002,
0.17234188318252563,
-0.6924238801002502,
0.28864893317222595,
-0.2667015790939331,
-0.3034062683582306,
0.23922370374202728,
-0.6011864542961121,
-0.2673845887184143,
0.4012279510498047,
0.19311155378818512,
0.03748493269085884,
-0.006287406664341688,
-0.3626324534416199,
0.1904015988111496,
0.06886468082666397,
0.7314363121986389,
0.24729567766189575,
-0.8006417751312256,
-0.5170562267303467,
-0.11706871539354324,
0.25639963150024414,
-0.17426839470863342,
0.981988251209259,
-1.0225553512573242,
0.6850976943969727,
0.35324540734291077,
0.5030682682991028,
0.5376058220863342,
-0.005288241896778345,
0.7410684823989868,
-0.5118863582611084,
0.25925377011299133,
-0.16053301095962524,
-0.0026770401746034622,
0.07928796857595444,
-0.4723881483078003,
0.3504646122455597,
0.5560998320579529,
-0.5995219945907593,
-0.8126299381256104,
0.3604647219181061,
-0.6757003664970398,
-0.35189586877822876,
0.9892159700393677,
0.18901300430297852,
0.49445071816444397,
-0.4900074899196625,
-0.5870187878608704,
0.4517176151275635,
-0.15210948884487152,
1.4726929664611816,
1.1149529218673706,
-0.056267447769641876,
-0.4055943787097931,
-0.5548316836357117,
0.6375881433486938,
0.785858154296875,
-0.7646099925041199,
0.2622341811656952,
0.7483875155448914,
-0.1964622288942337,
0.31936192512512207,
0.7216886281967163,
-0.053228601813316345,
0.2302078902721405,
0.29509830474853516,
0.2057371288537979,
0.005789084360003471,
-0.582672655582428,
0.20959751307964325,
0.12442915141582489,
0.021458670496940613,
0.22919750213623047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03486v1
|
Generative AI and Teachers -- For Us or Against Us? A Case Study
| 2024-04-04T14:40:07 | 2024-04-04T14:40:07 |
Jenny Pettersson, Elias Hult, Tim Eriksson, Tosin Adewumi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present insightful results of a survey on the adoption of generative
artificial intelligence (GenAI) by university teachers in their teaching
activities. The transformation of education by GenAI, particularly large
language models (LLMs), has been presenting both opportunities and challenges,
including cheating by students. We prepared the online survey according to best
practices and the questions were created by the authors, who have pedagogy
experience. The survey contained 12 questions and a pilot study was first
conducted. The survey was then sent to all teachers in multiple departments
across different campuses of the university of interest in Sweden: Lule{\aa}
University of Technology. The survey was available in both Swedish and English.
The results show that 35 teachers (more than half) use GenAI out of 67
respondents. Preparation is the teaching activity with the most frequency that
GenAI is used for and ChatGPT is the most commonly used GenAI. 59% say it has
impacted their teaching, however, 55% say there should be legislation around
the use of GenAI, especially as inaccuracies and cheating are the biggest
concerns.
|
[
-0.24657970666885376,
-0.5901774168014526,
0.5190455317497253,
0.1366414874792099,
-0.3598100543022156,
0.19139403104782104,
0.0018398601096123457,
-0.1727377325296402,
-0.09103171527385712,
0.302285760641098,
0.016798391938209534,
-0.3939264416694641,
-0.518862247467041,
0.16937439143657684,
-0.8732105493545532,
0.776330292224884,
-0.20457813143730164,
0.7511590123176575,
-0.7844172716140747,
-0.0804860070347786,
-0.5429891347885132,
-0.49808740615844727,
-0.7639811635017395,
-0.7640994191169739,
0.4370507001876831,
0.5434184670448303,
0.45708686113357544,
0.022564178332686424,
0.39069920778274536,
0.32645076513290405,
0.08702562004327774,
-0.1252015382051468,
-0.28539708256721497,
0.14110016822814941,
-0.2645173966884613,
-0.894067108631134,
-0.1116395965218544,
0.21471725404262543,
0.5704828500747681,
0.6100549101829529,
-0.26620957255363464,
0.07699884474277496,
0.17744697630405426,
0.6251115798950195,
-0.35308152437210083,
-0.01649121381342411,
-0.22379067540168762,
0.4048350751399994,
-0.24665343761444092,
0.09303133934736252,
-0.372976690530777,
-0.46848708391189575,
-0.07001892477273941,
-0.6095932722091675,
0.2681790292263031,
-0.47451356053352356,
0.5053033232688904,
0.36428093910217285,
-0.3987825810909271,
-0.566144585609436,
-1.0351500511169434,
0.689437985420227,
-0.31024324893951416,
0.27469685673713684,
0.541522204875946,
0.24205158650875092,
-0.312338262796402,
-0.7532303333282471,
-0.6845661997795105,
0.03137299790978432,
0.15464824438095093,
0.504650890827179,
0.12433367222547531,
0.1690388172864914,
0.4056342840194702,
0.6252979040145874,
-0.3678750693798065,
0.4607740640640259,
-0.5167476534843445,
0.06478004157543182,
0.7022682428359985,
0.17559929192066193,
0.7507426738739014,
0.0682719424366951,
-0.3296472430229187,
-0.1625676155090332,
-0.7775477170944214,
-0.09891229122877121,
0.7135768532752991,
-0.03777594864368439,
-0.07269737124443054,
0.5422517657279968,
0.21323493123054504,
0.7116590738296509,
-0.4239048957824707,
0.17659851908683777,
-0.12852495908737183,
-0.38678210973739624,
-0.1684914380311966,
-0.11070973426103592,
0.9130852818489075,
-0.0019180818926542997,
0.5033069849014282,
-0.15434052050113678,
-0.058677684515714645,
0.4335198700428009,
0.20483538508415222,
-0.669908344745636,
-0.3632495403289795,
0.14038823544979095,
-0.058399446308612823,
-0.4080601930618286,
0.02546965703368187,
-1.075943946838379,
-0.5180133581161499,
-0.20061622560024261,
0.25316035747528076,
-0.29674872756004333,
-0.25471246242523193,
-0.34488439559936523,
-0.26201751828193665,
0.6264869570732117,
0.37731313705444336,
-1.1001548767089844,
-0.049723755568265915,
0.8397305607795715,
0.5393220782279968,
0.08682800084352493,
-0.46620598435401917,
0.025190643966197968,
-0.09837354719638824,
-0.37344783544540405,
0.703755795955658,
-0.5722324848175049,
-1.1560603380203247,
0.1397797167301178,
-0.5311827659606934,
-0.17444156110286713,
-0.48646223545074463,
0.28547218441963196,
-0.39813652634620667,
0.7081645727157593,
-0.29076334834098816,
-0.8293530344963074,
0.0871184691786766,
0.2876453101634979,
-0.5098826289176941,
1.0009937286376953,
0.1716347336769104,
-0.3392992615699768,
0.4855802357196808,
-0.7631875872612,
-0.4132362902164459,
0.5609259009361267,
-0.7557833790779114,
-0.5012657046318054,
-0.18681012094020844,
0.11561120301485062,
0.2501249313354492,
-0.1920279860496521,
0.4651779532432556,
0.17861095070838928,
-0.6919569373130798,
0.5445461273193359,
-0.8183180689811707,
1.1856781244277954,
0.3249373137950897,
-0.388523131608963,
-0.009207098744809628,
-0.35762864351272583,
-0.13773442804813385,
0.0951216071844101,
-0.5060670971870422,
-0.3852773904800415,
-0.10728627443313599,
-0.13983899354934692,
-0.03439728170633316,
-0.04755742847919464,
-0.5447476506233215,
0.4476473927497864,
-0.1368565857410431,
0.3514891266822815,
0.8880130648612976,
-0.053690724074840546,
0.458726167678833,
-0.4028877019882202,
0.9309788942337036,
-0.2441072165966034,
0.4347173869609833,
0.14775708317756653,
-0.894733190536499,
-0.6189342141151428,
-0.15366894006729126,
0.7314444780349731,
0.507178544998169,
-1.0853888988494873,
0.1286204606294632,
-0.15295837819576263,
-0.45453256368637085,
-0.759787917137146,
0.34044668078422546,
0.25911062955856323,
0.2539166510105133,
-0.16140593588352203,
-0.010849732905626297,
-0.40816277265548706,
-0.3024626672267914,
-0.21804498136043549,
-0.36162033677101135,
-0.19750350713729858,
0.3257853388786316,
0.5446955561637878,
-0.17247141897678375,
0.9700684547424316,
0.004560380708426237,
-0.333353728055954,
-0.2630913555622101,
0.18835964798927307,
-0.008837412111461163,
0.5852141976356506,
0.5627450942993164,
-1.128129005432129,
-0.692047119140625,
-0.35260140895843506,
-1.101635217666626,
0.22845850884914398,
-0.3775421977043152,
-0.16299600899219513,
0.3480774760246277,
0.22511862218379974,
-0.5772987008094788,
0.4463426470756531,
0.45245781540870667,
-0.4976828098297119,
0.23980654776096344,
-0.1916370391845703,
0.23273856937885284,
-1.2745383977890015,
0.04360317066311836,
-0.32153764367103577,
0.07017377763986588,
-0.561123788356781,
0.3430670201778412,
-0.2142268419265747,
-0.1672908365726471,
-0.4264524281024933,
0.2034754604101181,
-0.25015226006507874,
-0.06512840837240219,
-0.09139768034219742,
0.06272520869970322,
-0.2589860260486603,
-0.024607401341199875,
-0.4158399999141693,
1.3081722259521484,
0.4863332509994507,
-0.5880451798439026,
0.6856799125671387,
0.5782736539840698,
-0.39330124855041504,
0.7917503714561462,
-0.4937342405319214,
0.49265414476394653,
0.013831619173288345,
0.2649703621864319,
-0.682015061378479,
-0.14900706708431244,
0.5855227112770081,
-0.6536720991134644,
0.06992071866989136,
-0.053290143609046936,
-0.5180862545967102,
-0.41267719864845276,
-0.30126577615737915,
0.386482298374176,
0.7301986813545227,
-0.7304307222366333,
0.9319553375244141,
0.1091582402586937,
0.34564951062202454,
-0.48032474517822266,
-0.9295538663864136,
0.4574311673641205,
-0.09488274157047272,
-0.2281106561422348,
0.08741412311792374,
-0.2782540023326874,
-0.38007262349128723,
0.19075171649456024,
0.226088747382164,
-0.1264297068119049,
0.3253571093082428,
0.3702959716320038,
0.23614943027496338,
-0.028900450095534325,
-0.11187493056058884,
-0.19182753562927246,
-0.031250372529029846,
0.2253791093826294,
0.1396789848804474,
0.756171703338623,
0.2580353319644928,
-0.582707405090332,
-0.552608072757721,
0.38450586795806885,
0.7384355664253235,
0.05080913007259369,
0.7181997895240784,
0.5791095495223999,
-0.09848877042531967,
-0.20026445388793945,
-0.32145416736602783,
-0.23360984027385712,
-0.5103655457496643,
0.036318808794021606,
-0.1575300246477127,
-0.5687081813812256,
0.49579155445098877,
-0.05641859769821167,
-0.06418215483427048,
0.29448020458221436,
0.2881353795528412,
-0.33257928490638733,
0.8083455562591553,
0.5799087285995483,
-0.3613463342189789,
0.693590521812439,
-0.8147962689399719,
0.24645952880382538,
-0.6401853561401367,
-0.6207274794578552,
-0.4904130697250366,
-0.2056477963924408,
-0.7630519270896912,
0.03641805052757263,
0.3506498634815216,
-0.15324527025222778,
0.10377231240272522,
-0.052898626774549484,
-0.46881523728370667,
0.3942207992076874,
0.7635452151298523,
0.05834532156586647,
0.14913447201251984,
-0.05533354729413986,
0.2502715289592743,
0.06521715223789215,
-0.8637226223945618,
-0.31439000368118286,
1.3282357454299927,
0.12212492525577545,
0.6154137253761292,
0.19775356352329254,
1.0226035118103027,
0.39349159598350525,
0.6080774068832397,
-0.7665998339653015,
0.763605535030365,
-0.37676143646240234,
-0.6952711343765259,
-0.6052118539810181,
-0.5632245540618896,
-1.1445016860961914,
0.2622414827346802,
0.16463212668895721,
-0.09248962253332138,
-0.00865756906569004,
-0.06805434077978134,
-0.16681770980358124,
0.6439346671104431,
-0.7990244626998901,
0.6920484900474548,
-0.422489732503891,
-0.02753289043903351,
-0.2390596568584442,
-0.2525527775287628,
0.1623428463935852,
0.13975408673286438,
0.10864435136318207,
0.15083862841129303,
0.2543814182281494,
1.014563798904419,
-0.28268882632255554,
1.1029974222183228,
-0.31255120038986206,
-0.2244756519794464,
0.5363930463790894,
-0.393131285905838,
0.17554260790348053,
-0.1033305674791336,
-0.04344364255666733,
0.16578391194343567,
-0.0804886519908905,
-0.5117238759994507,
-0.6100345849990845,
0.6297407150268555,
-1.0758905410766602,
-0.7929636836051941,
-0.8965594172477722,
-0.39504849910736084,
0.0537518635392189,
0.0020321018528193235,
0.515942394733429,
0.23592406511306763,
-0.24866114556789398,
-0.05919985845685005,
0.7669587731361389,
0.1424710750579834,
0.49836090207099915,
0.5287477374076843,
-0.3567047119140625,
-0.21865202486515045,
1.176733136177063,
0.43024110794067383,
0.16526854038238525,
0.007944803684949875,
0.2470952570438385,
-0.08637604117393494,
-0.35062462091445923,
-0.7955228686332703,
0.12367047369480133,
-0.6934317350387573,
-0.034721266478300095,
-0.3819085657596588,
-0.4497454762458801,
-0.6961714029312134,
-0.2698882818222046,
-0.1016642153263092,
0.04777994751930237,
-0.7068316340446472,
-0.16439031064510345,
0.20204979181289673,
1.1396631002426147,
0.14374159276485443,
0.15370728075504303,
-0.35818010568618774,
0.0372002050280571,
0.8294355869293213,
0.3097667098045349,
-0.170027956366539,
-0.299368292093277,
0.27747368812561035,
0.13271558284759521,
-0.23503297567367554,
-0.8006588220596313,
-0.0501936711370945,
0.14573994278907776,
0.65220046043396,
0.3277168571949005,
0.012937933206558228,
0.3079206347465515,
-0.009800619445741177,
1.0978244543075562,
-0.0737123191356659,
-0.720400869846344,
0.38523241877555847,
-0.19510579109191895,
0.3659471571445465,
0.49516335129737854,
0.5312089920043945,
-0.7743472456932068,
-0.4932059943675995,
-0.695486307144165,
-0.8058037757873535,
0.2738341987133026,
0.028411246836185455,
0.8074554204940796,
0.5184308290481567,
0.3889523446559906,
0.27845507860183716,
0.19587531685829163,
-0.714946985244751,
-0.381388783454895,
-0.2269553691148758,
-0.29848551750183105,
-0.010015745647251606,
-0.5203096866607666,
-0.3201266825199127,
-0.46554723381996155,
0.49340808391571045,
0.27949970960617065,
0.42115074396133423,
-0.016405044123530388,
0.052228230983018875,
-0.015540746971964836,
0.4373580813407898,
0.5488373041152954,
0.9377834796905518,
0.33389002084732056,
0.10410407930612564,
0.26887765526771545,
-0.882523775100708,
0.24925754964351654,
0.01373651809990406,
-0.720361053943634,
0.041233327239751816,
0.2566283941268921,
0.4315961003303528,
-0.09172511845827103,
-0.35089054703712463,
0.5516592264175415,
-0.061861880123615265,
-0.2805374264717102,
-0.9614381790161133,
0.2345353066921234,
-0.2350345104932785,
0.010805875062942505,
0.28276684880256653,
-0.09575208276510239,
-0.030450670048594475,
-0.618960976600647,
-0.03626342862844467,
0.3830028176307678,
-0.15909409523010254,
-0.302819162607193,
0.45564860105514526,
0.4720706343650818,
-0.6041377186775208,
1.0300923585891724,
-0.17455585300922394,
-0.7687353491783142,
0.682094395160675,
0.678301990032196,
0.8252462148666382,
-0.5738927125930786,
0.8362990617752075,
-0.126834437251091,
0.19874870777130127,
-0.048768650740385056,
0.5875892043113708,
-0.2639971971511841,
-0.9382807612419128,
-0.07869397848844528,
-0.1627918928861618,
-0.8914746642112732,
0.07579644024372101,
-0.5013766288757324,
0.0731971263885498,
-0.46072739362716675,
0.05016634240746498,
-0.3084445595741272,
-0.23339128494262695,
-0.6124749183654785,
0.00391742866486311,
0.08104793727397919,
0.6101146340370178,
-1.0683990716934204,
0.9621891379356384,
0.9675267934799194,
-0.6088406443595886,
-0.658850908279419,
-0.009132657200098038,
-0.31560447812080383,
-0.7573479413986206,
0.26788944005966187,
-0.1427958607673645,
0.08895235508680344,
0.1993349939584732,
-0.7273579835891724,
-0.3633086681365967,
1.1102745532989502,
0.1682337075471878,
-0.38393136858940125,
0.13180242478847504,
0.6572616696357727,
0.7823514938354492,
0.013176213018596172,
0.18895967304706573,
0.5558367371559143,
0.4963717460632324,
-0.13652020692825317,
-0.4700010418891907,
-0.2954696714878082,
-0.10451009124517441,
-0.038512714207172394,
0.3665328621864319,
-0.6337888836860657,
0.6388983130455017,
0.014334463514387608,
-0.30216744542121887,
0.11941447854042053,
0.5557745695114136,
-0.08055047690868378,
0.7869880795478821,
0.2834867238998413,
0.67566978931427,
0.5754894614219666,
-0.12778715789318085,
0.9715331792831421,
0.012157818302512169,
0.14807596802711487,
0.4889943599700928,
-0.06725361943244934,
0.5719311237335205,
0.615798830986023,
-0.5320053696632385,
0.5380571484565735,
0.3758602440357208,
-0.4073348045349121,
0.27605316042900085,
0.2088967263698578,
-0.6805910468101501,
-0.0794510617852211,
-0.19473670423030853,
-0.45551732182502747,
0.597281813621521,
0.3929862976074219,
-0.12691263854503632,
-0.07636284828186035,
0.5639004111289978,
0.2790195643901825,
0.3558832108974457,
-0.3379681706428528,
0.7717700004577637,
0.1330711543560028,
-0.7273218631744385,
0.01825706847012043,
-0.24011263251304626,
0.7747388482093811,
-0.31839099526405334,
-0.19737017154693604,
-0.4451560080051422,
-0.00536534795537591,
-0.17396941781044006,
-0.897697389125824,
0.034770406782627106,
0.04133990406990051,
0.20963169634342194,
-0.5242791175842285,
0.429538369178772,
-0.6408295631408691,
-0.3729330897331238,
-0.04879085719585419,
0.3922765254974365,
0.3169213533401489,
0.1830475926399231,
-0.4459728002548218,
-0.03441727161407471,
0.0071869175881147385,
0.3246992230415344,
0.37939199805259705,
-0.06331025063991547,
0.06627915799617767,
0.5514852404594421,
0.5270827412605286,
-0.02604052796959877,
-0.039930857717990875,
0.285321980714798,
0.6818821430206299,
-0.3223969340324402,
-0.4210429787635803,
-0.7579990029335022,
0.3749593198299408,
-0.1692374050617218,
-0.641958475112915,
0.935645580291748,
0.46577852964401245,
1.1502352952957153,
0.13793538510799408,
0.779374361038208,
0.006276970263570547,
0.11995689570903778,
-0.468773752450943,
0.8658385872840881,
-0.015187660232186317,
0.22596357762813568,
0.012620463036000729,
-0.8229181170463562,
0.02278255857527256,
0.2025766670703888,
-0.47557324171066284,
0.25889521837234497,
0.391659677028656,
0.16484063863754272,
0.37896528840065,
0.2828105390071869,
0.5465195178985596,
-0.17131252586841583,
0.5988790392875671,
0.2680814564228058,
1.1510791778564453,
-0.4985451400279999,
0.416906476020813,
-0.4208904206752777,
-0.18665139377117157,
0.04740229621529579,
-0.19686353206634521,
-0.8725705742835999,
-0.5603026151657104,
-0.5716637969017029,
-0.12175384908914566,
0.282695472240448,
0.592181921005249,
-0.0055500599555671215,
-1.004052996635437,
-0.29186737537384033,
-0.3086772859096527,
0.3504899740219116,
-0.0498465858399868,
-0.2566499710083008,
0.19996565580368042,
-0.20592375099658966,
-0.8200222253799438,
0.27367618680000305,
-0.450904905796051,
0.35751840472221375,
-0.6318876147270203,
-0.0488385371863842,
-0.14860321581363678,
-0.09943346679210663,
0.42318639159202576,
0.5254631638526917,
-0.5523561239242554,
-0.36277100443840027,
-0.1607511043548584,
-0.30495551228523254,
-0.1957826316356659,
0.9315330982208252,
-0.5974037051200867,
0.7136602401733398,
0.5398350954055786,
0.7103068828582764,
0.20959961414337158,
-0.09366428107023239,
0.5881518125534058,
-0.5163245797157288,
0.0651264637708664,
0.43547722697257996,
0.10773184895515442,
0.4246768653392792,
-0.53510981798172,
0.634893536567688,
0.5410168170928955,
-0.8519353270530701,
-0.962274968624115,
0.020623870193958282,
-0.39482221007347107,
-0.12825021147727966,
1.0025324821472168,
-0.23465678095817566,
-0.013429131358861923,
-0.04214383289217949,
0.10525422543287277,
0.23025095462799072,
-0.13582801818847656,
1.0688527822494507,
0.7522671222686768,
-0.1498323678970337,
-0.1586572229862213,
-0.6156299710273743,
0.45176196098327637,
0.5956942439079285,
-0.7280327677726746,
-0.7219094038009644,
0.15565311908721924,
0.26773616671562195,
0.0031492409761995077,
0.4766130745410919,
-0.0879930630326271,
0.4795811176300049,
0.1480078548192978,
0.22235403954982758,
-0.11547283083200455,
-0.3002815544605255,
-0.6710320115089417,
-0.043819859623909,
0.1351407915353775,
-0.7139051556587219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03471v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03471v2
|
The Impact of Unstated Norms in Bias Analysis of Language Models
| 2024-04-04T14:24:06 | 2024-04-07T21:55:38 |
Farnaz Kohankhaki, Jacob-Junqi Tian, David Emerson, Laleh Seyyed-Kalantari, Faiza Khan Khattak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs), trained on vast datasets, can carry biases that
manifest in various forms, from overt discrimination to implicit stereotypes.
One facet of bias is performance disparities in LLMs, often harming
underprivileged groups, such as racial minorities. A common approach to
quantifying bias is to use template-based bias probes, which explicitly state
group membership (e.g. White) and evaluate if the outcome of a task, sentiment
analysis for instance, is invariant to the change of group membership (e.g.
change White race to Black). This approach is widely used in bias
quantification. However, in this work, we find evidence of an unexpectedly
overlooked consequence of using template-based probes for LLM bias
quantification. We find that in doing so, text examples associated with White
ethnicities appear to be classified as exhibiting negative sentiment at
elevated rates. We hypothesize that the scenario arises artificially through a
mismatch between the pre-training text of LLMs and the templates used to
measure bias through reporting bias, unstated norms that imply group membership
without explicit statement. Our finding highlights the potential misleading
impact of varying group membership through explicit mention in bias
quantification
|
[
-0.4723772406578064,
-0.406893789768219,
0.3607040047645569,
0.16336075961589813,
-0.2645091414451599,
-0.1905735582113266,
-0.2431558519601822,
-0.20485462248325348,
0.3778556287288666,
0.30897003412246704,
-0.16401147842407227,
-0.5383499264717102,
-0.8395998477935791,
-0.04770965874195099,
-0.37288400530815125,
1.2351479530334473,
0.18870924413204193,
0.2782050669193268,
-0.18783564865589142,
-0.4864819347858429,
-0.3001706302165985,
-0.7269817590713501,
0.010905069299042225,
-0.19888758659362793,
0.34537288546562195,
0.07206576317548752,
0.46599075198173523,
0.3948584794998169,
0.11039360612630844,
0.08035870641469955,
-0.3709423542022705,
-0.23942428827285767,
-0.4517701268196106,
-0.03839089721441269,
0.017213547602295876,
-0.5433489680290222,
-0.582342803478241,
0.6189496517181396,
0.6560227870941162,
0.9554027915000916,
0.042476776987314224,
0.32000720500946045,
0.26794183254241943,
0.5618244409561157,
-1.0312031507492065,
0.1354803591966629,
-0.7235918045043945,
0.11224273592233658,
-0.4209001362323761,
-0.09133080393075943,
-0.2410939335823059,
-0.17555378377437592,
-0.0044248285703361034,
-0.2280377298593521,
0.22119861841201782,
-0.10387656092643738,
0.5649679899215698,
0.18754415214061737,
-0.7086693644523621,
-0.39059126377105713,
-0.4942323863506317,
0.8974267244338989,
-1.078773021697998,
0.35809776186943054,
0.1565016210079193,
-0.17560599744319916,
-0.10673907399177551,
-0.2128949761390686,
-0.6912899613380432,
-0.0011302678612992167,
-0.14720506966114044,
0.14459501206874847,
-0.069771908223629,
0.13977541029453278,
0.5780962109565735,
0.5926803350448608,
-0.0545135922729969,
0.29482656717300415,
-0.6024681329727173,
-0.10175669193267822,
0.4856685400009155,
0.1531599462032318,
0.11693792045116425,
-0.2935712933540344,
-0.1134190782904625,
0.2273137867450714,
-0.6616771221160889,
0.13913574814796448,
0.5631806254386902,
0.638763427734375,
-0.2787192761898041,
0.7442546486854553,
0.08416152745485306,
0.6317912340164185,
0.062159162014722824,
-0.025481050834059715,
0.4585968255996704,
-0.07743468880653381,
-0.20065534114837646,
0.0542738102376461,
0.755774736404419,
0.5483537316322327,
0.6108810305595398,
0.1580142080783844,
-0.19353027641773224,
0.46084338426589966,
0.006621384061872959,
-0.7228331565856934,
0.08297178149223328,
-0.12744098901748657,
-0.55091392993927,
-0.3877708315849304,
0.08045828342437744,
-1.0398153066635132,
-0.6911590695381165,
0.01618388667702675,
0.0684901624917984,
0.21861699223518372,
-0.29200664162635803,
0.11280083656311035,
-0.2448910027742386,
0.17185541987419128,
0.331379771232605,
-0.7626658082008362,
0.3522517681121826,
0.5567741394042969,
0.7469651699066162,
-0.3367387652397156,
0.05566567927598953,
-0.4693434536457062,
-0.21610867977142334,
-0.23158462345600128,
0.3958513140678406,
-0.6892356276512146,
-0.728071928024292,
0.13167905807495117,
-0.25100716948509216,
0.08944486081600189,
-0.5225176811218262,
0.5636692047119141,
-0.43639039993286133,
0.3708679676055908,
-0.5626665949821472,
-0.7830299735069275,
0.025860276073217392,
0.10864634811878204,
-0.5155961513519287,
0.9515166282653809,
0.09742079675197601,
-1.1902371644973755,
0.7597776055335999,
-0.43692147731781006,
-0.3629027009010315,
-0.17426331341266632,
-0.472042977809906,
-0.3165667653083801,
0.6456019282341003,
0.22871118783950806,
0.3358308970928192,
-0.24936893582344055,
0.043766722083091736,
-0.5684531927108765,
-0.6240655183792114,
0.24006792902946472,
-0.3782457709312439,
1.040561556816101,
-0.02188682183623314,
-0.5715779066085815,
-0.28298211097717285,
-0.6338911056518555,
-0.14489500224590302,
-0.004182364325970411,
-0.5443724393844604,
-0.8580152988433838,
0.01425961684435606,
-0.1483895629644394,
0.3217233419418335,
-0.13173866271972656,
-0.7716614603996277,
0.2345750480890274,
-0.16501696407794952,
-0.1253436654806137,
1.0606199502944946,
-0.0600174255669117,
0.39938825368881226,
0.03012222610414028,
0.6425917744636536,
0.243368461728096,
-0.027716806158423424,
0.2412431836128235,
-0.3846208155155182,
-0.7959263920783997,
-0.23594960570335388,
0.21681004762649536,
0.20740732550621033,
-0.12075570225715637,
0.2569832503795624,
-0.12701739370822906,
-0.24896539747714996,
-0.5578424334526062,
0.09622706472873688,
0.2858426868915558,
0.42379555106163025,
0.21874214708805084,
-0.4719438850879669,
-0.583254873752594,
-0.8675640225410461,
-0.6741255521774292,
-0.303891122341156,
-0.032786641269922256,
0.1335749328136444,
0.511384904384613,
-0.31990498304367065,
1.0239039659500122,
-0.5234566926956177,
-0.4820389747619629,
-0.25021687150001526,
0.1797143965959549,
0.26690474152565,
0.23466670513153076,
0.3995017111301422,
-0.30172574520111084,
-0.43724325299263,
-0.3710488975048065,
-0.42511680722236633,
-0.5762625336647034,
0.20168697834014893,
0.28072601556777954,
0.267012357711792,
0.8001512885093689,
-0.3547365367412567,
0.5032311677932739,
0.8656226396560669,
-0.40899422764778137,
0.6739216446876526,
0.3120306730270386,
-0.024195611476898193,
-0.9680753350257874,
0.02873343601822853,
0.45934927463531494,
0.020781192928552628,
-0.4803958237171173,
-0.3972471058368683,
0.07641566544771194,
0.214191272854805,
-0.4101130962371826,
0.5729040503501892,
-0.4897083044052124,
-0.20852620899677277,
-0.23210133612155914,
-0.02628229930996895,
0.1079590916633606,
0.34341558814048767,
-0.2898367643356323,
0.9193549156188965,
0.360663503408432,
-0.560627818107605,
-0.25000491738319397,
0.08007344603538513,
-0.4302370250225067,
0.6011974811553955,
-0.5423265099525452,
0.005740687251091003,
-0.33975091576576233,
0.24472545087337494,
-0.6703977584838867,
0.23343944549560547,
0.13902701437473297,
-0.5112398862838745,
0.25701799988746643,
-0.4541119635105133,
-0.29544952511787415,
-0.09511503577232361,
-0.4816465377807617,
0.692748486995697,
0.5199658870697021,
-0.3241681456565857,
0.2819370925426483,
0.6375852227210999,
0.2062777727842331,
-0.6874672770500183,
-0.6384482979774475,
-0.3057555556297302,
-0.5636520385742188,
-0.12411047518253326,
-0.17597004771232605,
0.22176210582256317,
-0.8334531188011169,
-0.17846642434597015,
-0.2551732659339905,
0.1858825832605362,
0.18557965755462646,
0.2917982339859009,
0.1631302535533905,
-0.11822152882814407,
0.2515164017677307,
-0.05690985172986984,
0.3178436756134033,
0.3390998840332031,
-0.1737889051437378,
0.5141120553016663,
-0.1487800031900406,
-0.3941623866558075,
-0.19336286187171936,
0.16588610410690308,
0.7110112309455872,
-0.3580811321735382,
0.9508202075958252,
0.32993456721305847,
-0.2345145344734192,
-0.25637108087539673,
-0.5718536972999573,
-0.03798995539546013,
-0.46748098731040955,
0.43838363885879517,
0.10472960770130157,
-1.1190704107284546,
0.7113993763923645,
0.19220955669879913,
-0.10654545575380325,
0.5908653140068054,
0.5759730339050293,
-0.2185695767402649,
1.013455867767334,
0.5169334411621094,
-0.27518361806869507,
0.47875314950942993,
0.04157184809446335,
0.23257219791412354,
-1.1024912595748901,
-0.06926232576370239,
-0.6870607733726501,
-0.1335725486278534,
-0.962146520614624,
-0.5116595029830933,
0.5538864731788635,
-0.11089516431093216,
-0.10292647778987885,
-0.4087667763233185,
-0.1018059104681015,
0.4434055685997009,
0.18688680231571198,
-0.4809741675853729,
0.20723505318164825,
0.009716576896607876,
-0.23875226080417633,
-0.4301835894584656,
-0.4672127664089203,
-0.39850589632987976,
1.371267318725586,
0.351984441280365,
0.8781778216362,
-0.09429604560136795,
0.4553409516811371,
0.6851233839988708,
0.5551080703735352,
-0.9140708446502686,
0.363844633102417,
-0.20906798541545868,
-0.8067929148674011,
-0.1330913007259369,
-0.5301858186721802,
-0.7569651007652283,
0.43854832649230957,
-0.01865406520664692,
-0.8615238666534424,
0.43262624740600586,
0.2502847909927368,
0.053439706563949585,
0.3831356167793274,
-0.32104068994522095,
0.7072446346282959,
-0.035997867584228516,
-0.006127354688942432,
0.03904120996594429,
-0.1537778228521347,
0.560590386390686,
-0.2092626988887787,
0.35142117738723755,
-0.28071704506874084,
0.2807842791080475,
1.0958255529403687,
-0.4002479612827301,
0.9638669490814209,
-0.5155526995658875,
-0.2968846261501312,
0.04162395000457764,
0.1948259025812149,
0.36279115080833435,
0.04125090315937996,
-0.24303852021694183,
0.41504189372062683,
-0.26202914118766785,
-0.5415531992912292,
-0.5461155772209167,
0.5233825445175171,
-0.7324719429016113,
-0.7490742206573486,
-0.6815237402915955,
-0.5196094512939453,
-0.4461408257484436,
0.03703466057777405,
0.27250999212265015,
0.3581185042858124,
-0.21765150129795074,
-0.02928842604160309,
0.5635080933570862,
-0.3507705628871918,
0.07408291846513748,
0.60882169008255,
-0.12486609816551208,
0.046810515224933624,
0.5723086595535278,
0.22088852524757385,
0.4295611083507538,
-0.1800035834312439,
0.07118283957242966,
-0.1369885355234146,
-0.5931235551834106,
-0.07869884371757507,
0.45361238718032837,
-0.7503575682640076,
-0.006945185828953981,
-0.5929797291755676,
0.08914853632450104,
-0.49821874499320984,
-0.04154600575566292,
-0.4955998361110687,
-0.3126372992992401,
-0.3380506634712219,
-0.16403844952583313,
-0.07303503900766373,
0.8012824058532715,
-0.07753577828407288,
0.3274708390235901,
-0.5577647686004639,
-0.20858487486839294,
0.17065121233463287,
0.3060661554336548,
0.009858040139079094,
-0.7429658770561218,
-0.5409075021743774,
-0.06072850525379181,
-0.027505090460181236,
-0.9441701173782349,
0.22213895618915558,
0.04420038312673569,
0.5225470066070557,
0.4991662800312042,
0.19737911224365234,
0.4427590072154999,
-0.34064337611198425,
0.7278501987457275,
0.11475516855716705,
-1.296724796295166,
0.28333956003189087,
-0.5195621252059937,
0.3121422529220581,
0.5838306546211243,
0.2763424217700958,
-0.8618447184562683,
-0.7581498622894287,
-0.3891931474208832,
-0.7416582107543945,
0.5078011751174927,
-0.17899742722511292,
0.32617005705833435,
-0.326366662979126,
0.31477126479148865,
0.05415107309818268,
0.275221586227417,
-0.880547821521759,
-0.4348840117454529,
-0.09240952134132385,
0.0850299745798111,
-0.13421911001205444,
-0.6327506899833679,
-0.0472397543489933,
-0.3232009708881378,
0.5160886645317078,
-0.17937126755714417,
0.18915458023548126,
0.018218599259853363,
-0.32837051153182983,
-0.07634387165307999,
0.5234971046447754,
0.5551368594169617,
0.6029699444770813,
-0.30793657898902893,
0.1698221117258072,
0.2573419511318207,
-0.38392364978790283,
0.16743654012680054,
-0.1401911973953247,
-0.2731775939464569,
0.07280054688453674,
0.4453250467777252,
0.6917445063591003,
-0.1421961486339569,
-0.3602105975151062,
0.7885699272155762,
0.026915818452835083,
0.19499310851097107,
-0.18173624575138092,
-0.10016972571611404,
-0.10275468230247498,
-0.013881014660000801,
0.3816823959350586,
-0.0823935717344284,
0.13971595466136932,
-0.5288249850273132,
0.036591991782188416,
0.6727152466773987,
-0.9441640973091125,
-0.516621470451355,
0.4033092260360718,
0.20755049586296082,
0.29023507237434387,
0.6890348792076111,
-0.1564217209815979,
-0.7820422649383545,
0.42680755257606506,
0.34555596113204956,
0.6766406297683716,
-0.21607078611850739,
0.19012853503227234,
0.11225202679634094,
0.528717577457428,
0.19498080015182495,
0.1051936149597168,
0.30602264404296875,
-0.9785712361335754,
-0.3446093797683716,
-0.6826602816581726,
0.10141430795192719,
0.257323682308197,
-1.0045994520187378,
0.15968899428844452,
-0.389352947473526,
-0.27496573328971863,
-0.2179877758026123,
-0.14935153722763062,
-0.5209118723869324,
0.25198864936828613,
0.3235531151294708,
0.915808916091919,
-1.2914096117019653,
0.5264685750007629,
0.7066649794578552,
-0.11439627408981323,
-0.5962135791778564,
0.5813289284706116,
0.3372271955013275,
-0.7325551509857178,
0.7188892960548401,
0.14627861976623535,
-0.02817394584417343,
-0.3491334617137909,
-0.24749119579792023,
-0.5321784019470215,
0.46661680936813354,
0.3066636323928833,
-0.32468757033348083,
0.1634722501039505,
0.37319377064704895,
0.7077208161354065,
-0.36912140250205994,
0.16191226243972778,
0.5675133466720581,
0.20006488263607025,
-0.24285109341144562,
-1.0563421249389648,
0.1307140588760376,
-0.13544000685214996,
0.016192134469747543,
0.2749735713005066,
-0.6507731080055237,
1.1865460872650146,
-0.06564608216285706,
-0.24840714037418365,
-0.6408344507217407,
0.6151046752929688,
0.07649178057909012,
0.04505448043346405,
0.5328748226165771,
0.5838760733604431,
0.676470160484314,
0.10389372706413269,
1.0181384086608887,
0.024116644635796547,
0.4938074052333832,
0.9008705615997314,
-0.39756426215171814,
0.2054426223039627,
0.6433622241020203,
-0.22447659075260162,
0.2619687020778656,
0.35196682810783386,
0.1684086173772812,
0.4068077504634857,
0.575259268283844,
-0.41279107332229614,
-0.07535157352685928,
-0.4439238905906677,
-0.4702504277229309,
0.6160519123077393,
0.49709993600845337,
-0.39838120341300964,
-0.247066929936409,
-0.3153683543205261,
0.48729708790779114,
0.08848273009061813,
-0.5436443090438843,
0.4416038393974304,
0.2419348806142807,
-0.24662290513515472,
0.3492130935192108,
0.11810524761676788,
1.0120939016342163,
-0.30903032422065735,
0.23821966350078583,
-0.5578691363334656,
0.14097239077091217,
-0.32724183797836304,
-0.5926902294158936,
0.19722802937030792,
0.1277446299791336,
-0.29784083366394043,
0.023061739280819893,
0.37847092747688293,
-0.2079382985830307,
-0.5484169721603394,
0.42607927322387695,
0.8563085794448853,
-0.13681893050670624,
-0.0058213830925524235,
-0.32663509249687195,
0.3685976266860962,
0.2443348616361618,
-0.3459986746311188,
0.5913258790969849,
0.40924856066703796,
-0.2531176209449768,
0.3596092164516449,
0.3017708659172058,
0.41420260071754456,
0.12295269221067429,
0.10941094160079956,
1.0659863948822021,
-0.4384024739265442,
-0.3952745199203491,
-1.0503220558166504,
0.5123480558395386,
0.0017295107245445251,
-0.3486703932285309,
0.9892418384552002,
0.6633142232894897,
1.1004855632781982,
0.19595865905284882,
1.0390015840530396,
0.20587806403636932,
0.4988940358161926,
-0.41345012187957764,
0.7772448062896729,
-0.7303770184516907,
0.5420434474945068,
-0.5580366253852844,
-1.0035496950149536,
-0.26026421785354614,
0.440382719039917,
-0.44503697752952576,
0.31963858008384705,
0.6003204584121704,
0.6809223890304565,
-0.15200018882751465,
-0.19401395320892334,
0.22850562632083893,
0.37225592136383057,
0.45793458819389343,
-0.1471458226442337,
0.8340134620666504,
-0.07216570526361465,
0.03342745080590248,
0.1526372730731964,
-0.09023155272006989,
0.017590973526239395,
-0.8010205030441284,
-1.1635494232177734,
-0.4123268127441406,
-0.3029743432998657,
-0.6010370850563049,
-0.0076478044502437115,
0.8850583434104919,
0.30383819341659546,
-0.9354510307312012,
-0.4181300103664398,
0.4388658106327057,
0.057859063148498535,
0.4350318908691406,
-0.33408084511756897,
0.2335074245929718,
-0.14772248268127441,
-0.6868178248405457,
0.1811055988073349,
0.09907559305429459,
0.02096189558506012,
-0.34460511803627014,
-0.0950390174984932,
0.009156562387943268,
0.22305312752723694,
0.3471217453479767,
0.22007954120635986,
-0.494559109210968,
-0.2693203091621399,
-0.32201087474823,
-0.16814082860946655,
0.07262877374887466,
1.1352242231369019,
-0.6578889489173889,
0.3039918839931488,
0.24369850754737854,
0.3862556219100952,
0.31461790204048157,
-0.05807976424694061,
0.783972442150116,
-1.0708868503570557,
0.2876247763633728,
0.33206361532211304,
0.4566449820995331,
0.3930366039276123,
-0.1780414581298828,
0.1171681359410286,
0.40977898240089417,
-0.26037371158599854,
-1.1180486679077148,
0.41233041882514954,
-0.6216623783111572,
-0.1191386729478836,
1.3521745204925537,
-0.1795971393585205,
0.08966889977455139,
-0.1173543706536293,
0.20554572343826294,
0.33251088857650757,
-0.5257869362831116,
0.9958400130271912,
0.7676721811294556,
0.024741364642977715,
-0.0876137986779213,
-0.4486246705055237,
0.6392965316772461,
0.5109041333198547,
-0.6128032207489014,
0.14283455908298492,
0.6930134296417236,
0.2454380840063095,
-0.17314669489860535,
0.7431314587593079,
-0.20697443187236786,
-0.09372173249721527,
-0.34176531434059143,
0.1998174786567688,
0.034541741013526917,
0.20325134694576263,
-0.5792176127433777,
-0.10976218432188034,
0.17195437848567963,
0.02908642590045929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03441v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03441v2
|
Benchmarking ChatGPT on Algorithmic Reasoning
| 2024-04-04T13:39:06 | 2024-04-16T21:32:47 |
Sean McLeish, Avi Schwarzschild, Tom Goldstein
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We evaluate ChatGPT's ability to solve algorithm problems from the CLRS
benchmark suite that is designed for GNNs. The benchmark requires the use of a
specified classical algorithm to solve a given problem. We find that ChatGPT
outperforms specialist GNN models, using Python to successfully solve these
problems. This raises new points in the discussion about learning algorithms
with neural networks and how we think about what out of distribution testing
looks like with web scale training data.
|
[
-0.4731000065803528,
-0.6604211926460266,
0.40395766496658325,
0.03818521648645401,
-0.15518347918987274,
-0.07628807425498962,
-0.38803988695144653,
-0.4153624176979065,
-0.24489188194274902,
0.290012925863266,
-0.6314454674720764,
-0.0452573336660862,
-0.46027857065200806,
0.020675642415881157,
-0.5446009635925293,
0.8818987011909485,
0.022432541474699974,
0.359047532081604,
-0.11297532171010971,
-0.2618356943130493,
-0.34417781233787537,
-0.5117819905281067,
-1.1304908990859985,
-0.5647454261779785,
0.29911619424819946,
0.4202895164489746,
0.7982725501060486,
0.536231517791748,
0.9283507466316223,
0.32009363174438477,
-0.18709895014762878,
-0.09647180140018463,
-0.4580654203891754,
0.10151366144418716,
-0.058528270572423935,
-0.5702281594276428,
0.15966130793094635,
-0.1448136568069458,
0.43656429648399353,
0.6344268918037415,
-0.40131327509880066,
0.27025607228279114,
-0.20446139574050903,
0.8895573019981384,
-0.45202890038490295,
0.20106036961078644,
-0.8181737661361694,
0.14776688814163208,
-0.05863553658127785,
-0.02423487789928913,
-0.26957976818084717,
-0.6551180481910706,
0.4945999085903168,
-0.6098173260688782,
0.6639958024024963,
0.11247824132442474,
0.6759024858474731,
0.3381347358226776,
-0.25382351875305176,
-0.566391110420227,
-0.6650974750518799,
0.6221784949302673,
-0.5772553086280823,
0.36520013213157654,
0.1443486511707306,
0.931717038154602,
-0.28254419565200806,
-0.9579089879989624,
-0.17919710278511047,
-0.3818705081939697,
0.16689106822013855,
0.07551039010286331,
-0.10656721144914627,
-0.07511521130800247,
0.6455621123313904,
0.6462392807006836,
-0.9364110827445984,
-0.09849975258111954,
-0.6558307409286499,
-0.01984204351902008,
0.7235984206199646,
0.10544205456972122,
0.08392513543367386,
0.3678607642650604,
-0.2892362177371979,
-0.43007439374923706,
-0.6951370239257812,
0.022639252245426178,
0.45881035923957825,
0.03562675043940544,
0.2163485735654831,
0.2453196942806244,
-0.33137139678001404,
0.710723340511322,
-0.2770494818687439,
0.4043274521827698,
0.24196448922157288,
-0.04071968421339989,
-0.13865666091442108,
0.2590194344520569,
0.6675214767456055,
0.38742247223854065,
0.6624231338500977,
-0.12343669682741165,
-0.24875807762145996,
0.12290143221616745,
0.18636026978492737,
-0.8376263976097107,
-0.6896795630455017,
0.05538466200232506,
-0.3956548273563385,
-0.05065842717885971,
-0.23260007798671722,
-0.7750236988067627,
-0.5240846872329712,
-0.34486883878707886,
0.5081273317337036,
-0.31423863768577576,
-0.27842411398887634,
0.22846083343029022,
-0.6256920099258423,
0.2183147817850113,
0.19532103836536407,
-0.8298420310020447,
0.6455731391906738,
0.8086258172988892,
0.8240435719490051,
0.020817462354898453,
-0.024414297193288803,
-0.3416701555252075,
-0.4899290204048157,
-0.34802329540252686,
0.8762337565422058,
-0.37071871757507324,
-0.2785798907279968,
0.005331277847290039,
-0.408732146024704,
-0.29339516162872314,
-0.8375230431556702,
0.4188380539417267,
-0.4133665859699249,
-0.10954327881336212,
-0.4876043498516083,
-0.8939725756645203,
-0.17906981706619263,
0.4574533700942993,
-0.563406765460968,
0.8324568271636963,
-0.117681123316288,
-0.8012474179267883,
0.2682681381702423,
-0.926666259765625,
-0.07026402652263641,
0.11390213668346405,
-0.048705875873565674,
-0.386329710483551,
-0.001325407880358398,
0.2799747884273529,
0.08177819848060608,
-0.34702467918395996,
-0.041935764253139496,
-0.3760998547077179,
-0.6214705109596252,
0.4499276876449585,
-0.5299219489097595,
0.6001901030540466,
0.4707648754119873,
-0.4944581687450409,
0.08396408706903458,
-0.5476018190383911,
0.548450767993927,
0.20877093076705933,
-0.019242379814386368,
0.06466212868690491,
0.4107844829559326,
-0.1606951206922531,
-0.053843867033720016,
-0.055551111698150635,
-0.4235896170139313,
0.15210694074630737,
-0.261430025100708,
1.0496752262115479,
0.5143724083900452,
-0.039479754865169525,
-0.07137633860111237,
-0.42148837447166443,
0.1345842331647873,
-0.3745969831943512,
0.2604064643383026,
0.19322706758975983,
-0.7921491861343384,
-0.7774053812026978,
0.0906919538974762,
0.4170067608356476,
0.6527557373046875,
-0.5389500260353088,
-0.06325414776802063,
-0.061011556535959244,
-0.6842082738876343,
-0.26144567131996155,
0.029911845922470093,
0.32421088218688965,
0.3213164210319519,
0.29144415259361267,
-0.6278820633888245,
-0.4510955810546875,
-0.9779024720191956,
-0.4347010552883148,
-0.12291646748781204,
-0.12162505090236664,
0.40293818712234497,
0.6488375663757324,
0.04108034819364548,
0.7590295672416687,
-0.4308830201625824,
-0.08191944658756256,
-0.2222992181777954,
0.4421330392360687,
0.29605209827423096,
0.43311670422554016,
0.28202590346336365,
-0.9568356871604919,
-0.5442675352096558,
0.08723311871290207,
-0.7385363578796387,
-0.04540488123893738,
0.14123930037021637,
0.31873619556427,
-0.17876960337162018,
0.5899502038955688,
-0.5111470818519592,
0.575955331325531,
0.4586166441440582,
-0.1058596670627594,
0.865319013595581,
-0.36692124605178833,
0.05965345725417137,
-0.4870968163013458,
0.05780979245901108,
0.31637337803840637,
-0.21503999829292297,
-0.6858877539634705,
0.08066117763519287,
-0.091806560754776,
-0.436262845993042,
-0.4309726357460022,
0.31905606389045715,
-0.35724198818206787,
-0.5484781861305237,
-0.30731093883514404,
0.09204291552305222,
-0.2876306474208832,
0.3315383195877075,
0.25926509499549866,
0.9654684066772461,
0.5064912438392639,
-0.5273226499557495,
0.6078625321388245,
0.08758989721536636,
-0.526920735836029,
0.44456762075424194,
-1.1295617818832397,
0.263990581035614,
0.06232745572924614,
0.2012261301279068,
-1.0025347471237183,
0.07636883109807968,
0.21198545396327972,
-0.4127914011478424,
-0.25094839930534363,
-0.3802127540111542,
-0.5291703939437866,
-0.46446266770362854,
0.08258741348981857,
0.4733770489692688,
0.7011387944221497,
-0.6451517343521118,
0.1643119603395462,
0.009227163158357143,
0.26331469416618347,
-0.3245221674442291,
-0.5573224425315857,
-0.10679136961698532,
-0.30737942457199097,
-0.6248590350151062,
0.08858109265565872,
-0.3020491898059845,
-0.4677678048610687,
-0.01921539008617401,
0.09329391270875931,
-0.4335848093032837,
-0.019982533529400826,
-0.0913812667131424,
-0.3069271743297577,
-0.47136566042900085,
-0.01956159807741642,
-0.5723042488098145,
-0.25707218050956726,
0.3447398543357849,
-0.2983993589878082,
0.6555678844451904,
-0.5863083600997925,
-0.6699119806289673,
-0.2694248855113983,
0.19850973784923553,
0.2558300495147705,
-0.27447500824928284,
0.2622202932834625,
0.5907143950462341,
-0.0870077833533287,
-0.23187845945358276,
-0.6242022514343262,
-0.24870681762695312,
-0.5245381593704224,
0.2749423384666443,
-0.2718032896518707,
-0.654522716999054,
0.6909154057502747,
-0.26025936007499695,
-0.09109295904636383,
0.23273687064647675,
0.5252370834350586,
0.11295345425605774,
1.0831427574157715,
0.05956774950027466,
-0.10269320756196976,
0.36045390367507935,
-0.35368162393569946,
0.08019065856933594,
-0.6581611633300781,
0.3010174632072449,
-0.6488623023033142,
-0.5099166035652161,
-0.8428072929382324,
-0.04574073478579521,
0.5243076086044312,
0.18404138088226318,
-0.598660945892334,
0.31464412808418274,
-0.8906245827674866,
0.772580087184906,
1.0207316875457764,
0.3060283958911896,
0.11592525243759155,
-0.26934748888015747,
-0.027576494961977005,
0.2275407314300537,
-0.5801743865013123,
-0.06650141626596451,
1.0822131633758545,
0.15230508148670197,
0.47963500022888184,
-0.06702488660812378,
0.5341899394989014,
0.1457899808883667,
0.20198555290699005,
-0.4324999451637268,
0.5275246500968933,
0.04959611967206001,
-0.6936089396476746,
-0.20518940687179565,
-0.5502715110778809,
-0.9475550055503845,
0.4134521186351776,
0.11737213283777237,
-1.176863670349121,
-0.024154480546712875,
0.15374524891376495,
0.15800996124744415,
0.42215433716773987,
-0.9136306047439575,
1.2129051685333252,
-0.1339414119720459,
0.023749975487589836,
-0.4007638692855835,
-0.7001276612281799,
0.2443380355834961,
0.4404139816761017,
-0.041404131799936295,
-0.16641765832901,
0.3712688088417053,
0.666904628276825,
-0.620275616645813,
0.6103533506393433,
-0.22162309288978577,
0.6007031798362732,
0.547487199306488,
0.03368787467479706,
0.39454689621925354,
0.02128635160624981,
-0.10943914204835892,
0.1530742347240448,
0.09019576013088226,
-0.5251159071922302,
-0.6042765974998474,
0.38793429732322693,
-0.8605489134788513,
-0.45598381757736206,
-0.5250976085662842,
-0.5043491125106812,
-0.3035423755645752,
0.08705001324415207,
0.37104174494743347,
0.7015623450279236,
-0.2086106687784195,
0.23540520668029785,
0.8317694664001465,
0.20673686265945435,
0.7057130336761475,
0.2938661277294159,
-0.10067558288574219,
-0.5110649466514587,
0.8624657392501831,
0.038367487490177155,
0.45361992716789246,
0.04252166673541069,
0.48583289980888367,
-0.4121607840061188,
-0.6984644532203674,
-0.6269611716270447,
-0.14122654497623444,
-1.0062459707260132,
0.1263967901468277,
0.07165379077196121,
-0.6633836030960083,
0.11195213347673416,
0.0011471336474642158,
-0.4692530333995819,
-0.29752376675605774,
0.2503471076488495,
0.369692325592041,
0.32041800022125244,
0.7801245450973511,
-0.0805511549115181,
0.5004485845565796,
-0.5358811020851135,
0.03895444795489311,
0.4617261588573456,
0.3431374430656433,
-0.023935724049806595,
-0.23552964627742767,
0.005123394075781107,
0.019281551241874695,
-0.46841514110565186,
-0.6340272426605225,
0.0804295614361763,
0.14551082253456116,
0.765627384185791,
0.4030802547931671,
-0.140191912651062,
0.44685572385787964,
-0.4556758999824524,
0.8264712691307068,
0.029748814180493355,
-0.7547169327735901,
0.4446558952331543,
-0.4191076159477234,
0.24664771556854248,
0.5575456619262695,
0.43462073802948,
-0.7022704482078552,
0.008748902007937431,
-0.7908790111541748,
-0.412592351436615,
0.23566670715808868,
0.4721851944923401,
-0.2664240896701813,
0.12254349142313004,
0.3990972340106964,
-0.09418682008981705,
0.21530044078826904,
-0.3557835519313812,
-0.26340076327323914,
-0.23327744007110596,
-0.1245071217417717,
-0.29964083433151245,
0.0010535261826589704,
-0.11717631667852402,
-0.181195929646492,
0.6333118677139282,
-0.18222105503082275,
0.32388851046562195,
0.3296188712120056,
-0.012498201802372932,
0.18495498597621918,
0.16623646020889282,
0.727551281452179,
0.9791691899299622,
-0.16713330149650574,
-0.05973707512021065,
0.22803129255771637,
-0.40962332487106323,
-0.05115651339292526,
0.28767335414886475,
-0.17917566001415253,
-0.03185134008526802,
0.11289998888969421,
0.6868667602539062,
0.0509638711810112,
-0.7485957145690918,
0.511499285697937,
-0.4904100298881531,
-0.5018489360809326,
-0.34898123145103455,
0.2592112123966217,
0.1312529742717743,
0.38622012734413147,
0.31122565269470215,
0.21523180603981018,
0.3797662854194641,
-0.2503925859928131,
0.3359755873680115,
0.577703058719635,
-0.5608171224594116,
-0.15467454493045807,
0.6010971665382385,
-0.07864240556955338,
-0.6261439919471741,
0.962160587310791,
-0.23442447185516357,
-0.8539682030677795,
0.9691182971000671,
0.5303459763526917,
0.8018965125083923,
0.000830862729344517,
0.054262712597846985,
0.24730049073696136,
0.17480677366256714,
-0.47326594591140747,
0.1836136281490326,
-0.10463882982730865,
-0.665976345539093,
-0.3366052508354187,
-0.06958391517400742,
-1.1150637865066528,
-0.05010901391506195,
-0.5131329894065857,
0.16463135182857513,
-0.6171889305114746,
0.08328337967395782,
0.17565341293811798,
0.23292753100395203,
-0.7104946374893188,
0.34670451283454895,
0.08404920995235443,
1.0126248598098755,
-0.581403374671936,
0.6506394743919373,
0.4110904335975647,
-0.1201816275715828,
-0.7717446088790894,
-0.4260340631008148,
0.15017856657505035,
-0.9115978479385376,
0.5998402237892151,
0.4956628680229187,
0.29598069190979004,
-0.019287895411252975,
-0.5313778519630432,
-0.7956801056861877,
0.8931715488433838,
0.1953880488872528,
-0.5340139865875244,
0.3996886610984802,
0.30430281162261963,
0.5469908118247986,
-0.22385480999946594,
0.8195631504058838,
0.570340633392334,
0.30472174286842346,
0.3210533857345581,
-1.1966733932495117,
-0.3086676299571991,
-0.476030170917511,
-0.06806322932243347,
0.16042236983776093,
-0.6342087388038635,
1.1069655418395996,
0.0781363844871521,
0.0832323431968689,
0.018940934911370277,
0.4854029715061188,
0.2857310473918915,
0.4828220009803772,
0.6531020998954773,
0.8088142275810242,
0.7986758947372437,
-0.3555113971233368,
1.0993534326553345,
-0.15687960386276245,
0.5466914176940918,
0.9628880620002747,
-0.24996884167194366,
0.8029196858406067,
0.17541815340518951,
-0.21853788197040558,
0.44440263509750366,
0.7687476277351379,
-0.11936447769403458,
0.5444963574409485,
0.8214197754859924,
-0.26292943954467773,
-0.148244708776474,
0.08527728170156479,
-0.6182088255882263,
0.17272959649562836,
0.27388861775398254,
-0.03885842114686966,
-0.4385460913181305,
-0.2995569109916687,
-0.3108012080192566,
-0.13183505833148956,
-0.5797863602638245,
0.7770957350730896,
0.09387753158807755,
-0.7044593095779419,
0.5858249068260193,
-0.2795064151287079,
0.3572140634059906,
-0.6294838190078735,
-0.009033053182065487,
-0.026534071192145348,
0.8113254308700562,
0.05200864002108574,
-0.6863824129104614,
0.30254065990448,
-0.48736533522605896,
0.17305447161197662,
0.09473948925733566,
0.9101022481918335,
-0.1428259015083313,
-0.48284226655960083,
0.018502820283174515,
0.4126330614089966,
0.43640726804733276,
-0.2524489462375641,
-0.8894850015640259,
0.1405954211950302,
-0.2828274369239807,
-0.20529057085514069,
0.44991520047187805,
0.34375473856925964,
-0.0032729951199144125,
1.1332004070281982,
0.6121070384979248,
0.0463847778737545,
0.32042962312698364,
0.02590450644493103,
0.8507652282714844,
-0.49888843297958374,
-0.5828285813331604,
-0.8619924187660217,
0.16121427714824677,
-0.3926796317100525,
-0.5694733262062073,
0.5318625569343567,
0.6857122778892517,
0.9170171618461609,
0.11381381750106812,
0.7295216917991638,
0.011267151683568954,
0.4803334176540375,
-0.3498121500015259,
0.48575183749198914,
-0.2537315785884857,
-0.08291998505592346,
-0.0734151303768158,
-0.8656626343727112,
-0.2564280331134796,
0.5841751098632812,
-0.5499733090400696,
-0.02032698504626751,
0.7800908088684082,
0.7696368098258972,
-0.10638918727636337,
0.7679967880249023,
0.03391775116324425,
-0.4485456347465515,
0.5093482732772827,
0.9496324062347412,
1.041421890258789,
-0.5945435166358948,
0.7115397453308105,
-0.4750378727912903,
-0.10954898595809937,
-0.13167892396450043,
-1.0987476110458374,
-1.1255487203598022,
-0.30822649598121643,
-0.39336034655570984,
-0.33803024888038635,
0.500040590763092,
0.8784742951393127,
0.8581622838973999,
-0.845892608165741,
-0.2921575605869293,
-0.5170463919639587,
0.1504143923521042,
-0.7452910542488098,
-0.19935615360736847,
0.46000394225120544,
-0.6773913502693176,
-0.44154635071754456,
0.31962692737579346,
-0.2530762255191803,
-0.20658469200134277,
-0.197992742061615,
-0.12578877806663513,
0.13227060437202454,
-0.19671766459941864,
0.07764916867017746,
0.464164137840271,
-0.416218101978302,
-0.5988385081291199,
-0.1301182508468628,
0.14294928312301636,
0.2997613251209259,
1.165663242340088,
-0.6861398220062256,
0.2916569411754608,
0.48526009917259216,
0.8491335511207581,
0.7726134061813354,
0.13022801280021667,
0.538777768611908,
-0.47628623247146606,
0.12953323125839233,
0.24983583390712738,
0.3786172568798065,
0.2549085319042206,
-0.044413406401872635,
0.733076810836792,
0.3306953012943268,
-1.1375421285629272,
-0.662320613861084,
0.08960942924022675,
-0.8862418532371521,
-0.09064573049545288,
0.9684506058692932,
-0.18016213178634644,
-0.2126220315694809,
-0.10445001721382141,
-0.14892315864562988,
-0.11092441529035568,
-0.1716620922088623,
0.6860110759735107,
0.7060753703117371,
-0.34345629811286926,
-0.34151580929756165,
-0.9520331621170044,
0.5068143606185913,
0.39361822605133057,
-0.572884738445282,
0.05119474232196808,
0.08618904650211334,
0.46007487177848816,
0.03720173239707947,
0.6913285255432129,
0.18904346227645874,
0.41968005895614624,
0.30400747060775757,
-0.1270657777786255,
-0.06805546581745148,
-0.027393067255616188,
0.015008297748863697,
0.10301759839057922,
0.10645680874586105,
-0.3344780206680298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03437v1
|
Knowledge Graph Representation for Political Information Sources
| 2024-04-04T13:36:01 | 2024-04-04T13:36:01 |
Tinatin Osmonova, Alexey Tikhonov, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
With the rise of computational social science, many scholars utilize data
analysis and natural language processing tools to analyze social media, news
articles, and other accessible data sources for examining political and social
discourse. Particularly, the study of the emergence of echo-chambers due to the
dissemination of specific information has become a topic of interest in mixed
methods research areas. In this paper, we analyze data collected from two news
portals, Breitbart News (BN) and New York Times (NYT) to prove the hypothesis
that the formation of echo-chambers can be partially explained on the level of
an individual information consumption rather than a collective topology of
individuals' social networks. Our research findings are presented through
knowledge graphs, utilizing a dataset spanning 11.5 years gathered from BN and
NYT media portals. We demonstrate that the application of knowledge
representation techniques to the aforementioned news streams highlights,
contrary to common assumptions, shows relative "internal" neutrality of both
sources and polarizing attitude towards a small fraction of entities.
Additionally, we argue that such characteristics in information sources lead to
fundamental disparities in audience worldviews, potentially acting as a
catalyst for the formation of echo-chambers.
|
[
-0.6989197134971619,
-0.8391844034194946,
0.7077131867408752,
-0.35766956210136414,
-0.36716052889823914,
0.5684694051742554,
-0.15902511775493622,
-0.20597806572914124,
0.6755820512771606,
0.3257105052471161,
-0.3594914376735687,
-0.3915148973464966,
-0.715091347694397,
-0.13499502837657928,
-0.40263065695762634,
0.9868907332420349,
0.31947267055511475,
0.03335518762469292,
0.03506080061197281,
-0.12466837465763092,
-0.19719789922237396,
-0.6092522144317627,
-0.4823440909385681,
-0.23460102081298828,
0.7824276685714722,
0.16037940979003906,
0.8134386539459229,
0.5357591509819031,
0.08305280655622482,
0.14928022027015686,
-0.1316220462322235,
0.24930596351623535,
-0.7415826916694641,
-0.030313706025481224,
-0.11366630345582962,
-0.36410608887672424,
0.16592752933502197,
0.06258046627044678,
0.663969874382019,
0.7852452397346497,
0.08380148559808731,
0.1017460897564888,
0.43779823184013367,
1.0100634098052979,
-0.4135664403438568,
0.18953268229961395,
-0.6292032599449158,
-0.048266079276800156,
-0.36126160621643066,
-0.7512357831001282,
-0.2715706527233124,
-0.5285254120826721,
0.029085133224725723,
-0.5604456067085266,
0.17994797229766846,
0.14870844781398773,
0.8419733643531799,
-0.07878680527210236,
-0.7869202494621277,
-0.5205659866333008,
-0.8706441521644592,
0.4320355951786041,
-0.4007055461406708,
0.4241718649864197,
0.004474557936191559,
0.3645058274269104,
-0.08217444270849228,
-0.5910876393318176,
-0.580784797668457,
0.27809980511665344,
-0.2901746332645416,
0.1497860848903656,
-0.5381222367286682,
-0.2473687082529068,
-0.07930918782949448,
0.10144538432359695,
-0.35077959299087524,
-0.3339448571205139,
-0.7990575432777405,
-0.23873695731163025,
0.34208887815475464,
0.09390923380851746,
0.10272948443889618,
-0.6504440307617188,
-0.3374364376068115,
0.0171953197568655,
-0.6743060946464539,
0.0775207132101059,
0.9880083799362183,
0.6671159267425537,
-0.2041221708059311,
0.6555160880088806,
-0.1419992595911026,
0.7421994805335999,
0.039515234529972076,
0.07630712538957596,
0.061324574053287506,
-0.34656092524528503,
0.08815506845712662,
0.23432499170303345,
0.7780304551124573,
0.45006507635116577,
0.11059674620628357,
0.04646309092640877,
0.3036136329174042,
0.09165167063474655,
0.4239763021469116,
-0.39495036005973816,
0.12886172533035278,
0.03009948879480362,
-0.7247896194458008,
-0.374293714761734,
0.33081749081611633,
-0.9837086796760559,
-1.091016173362732,
-0.4752868711948395,
0.05824526771903038,
-0.024390865117311478,
-0.5325857400894165,
-0.18802718818187714,
-0.6480421423912048,
-0.14889588952064514,
0.3162345588207245,
0.0020171068608760834,
0.4537029564380646,
0.5436201095581055,
1.0097243785858154,
0.12783120572566986,
0.20772118866443634,
-0.07750004529953003,
0.043450385332107544,
-0.4281316101551056,
0.9741879105567932,
-0.4893956780433655,
0.15122511982917786,
0.24943803250789642,
-0.2641371190547943,
0.27528175711631775,
-0.3819877505302429,
0.2983506917953491,
-0.8025615215301514,
0.49919432401657104,
-0.6239506602287292,
-0.7050153017044067,
-0.44140151143074036,
0.12559707462787628,
-0.8210187554359436,
0.5679078698158264,
-0.0022819393780082464,
-1.3671551942825317,
0.187585711479187,
-0.5671193599700928,
-0.1416100263595581,
-0.24638141691684723,
-0.5065661072731018,
-0.13112543523311615,
0.05106546729803085,
0.11721249669790268,
0.3929536044597626,
-0.2010507583618164,
0.17614863812923431,
-0.3613947629928589,
-0.3226928412914276,
0.33491894602775574,
-0.36280548572540283,
0.9664689302444458,
0.1291973739862442,
-0.35031697154045105,
-0.08209430426359177,
-0.5304007530212402,
-0.4693814218044281,
0.0003745907742995769,
-0.16077929735183716,
-0.5897958874702454,
0.40299326181411743,
-0.3626650869846344,
0.08051351457834244,
0.039334479719400406,
-0.4349210560321808,
-0.015404078178107738,
-0.0256075169891119,
0.3367319703102112,
0.8738319873809814,
0.5814648866653442,
0.3742579519748688,
-0.5439223647117615,
0.22791703045368195,
0.4376848042011261,
-0.0442754328250885,
0.22112663090229034,
-0.612991213798523,
-0.6981446743011475,
0.25681808590888977,
-0.014467199333012104,
0.28487858176231384,
-0.6477296352386475,
0.2092495560646057,
-0.29281240701675415,
-0.3554639518260956,
-0.5470755100250244,
-0.1280137002468109,
-0.1456376314163208,
0.38177913427352905,
0.1151471734046936,
0.16325050592422485,
-0.529685378074646,
-1.1619658470153809,
-0.5658161640167236,
-0.29479897022247314,
0.05295640602707863,
0.3142024278640747,
0.1764238029718399,
0.1726592779159546,
0.9020806550979614,
-0.1530669927597046,
-0.11393063515424728,
-0.057894255965948105,
0.3702181279659271,
0.4121500551700592,
-0.2568008601665497,
0.41551247239112854,
-0.956231951713562,
-0.40978458523750305,
0.10352405160665512,
-0.5585262775421143,
-0.018510939553380013,
0.030530350282788277,
-0.09687726944684982,
0.08458798378705978,
0.24222765862941742,
-0.009052573703229427,
0.5280506610870361,
0.7420090436935425,
-0.5134217143058777,
0.3364768624305725,
0.5166234970092773,
0.6154446601867676,
-1.2207235097885132,
-0.2210889309644699,
-0.01014517992734909,
-0.3070865869522095,
-0.6966301202774048,
-0.4202671945095062,
-0.2661050260066986,
-0.0629047304391861,
-0.19975759088993073,
0.30071526765823364,
-0.4925243854522705,
-0.03387414664030075,
-0.28258657455444336,
0.5238457918167114,
0.023889224976301193,
0.27312353253364563,
-0.11708515882492065,
0.237505704164505,
0.5295348167419434,
-0.24589793384075165,
0.22630229592323303,
-0.2526089549064636,
-0.317249596118927,
0.40799909830093384,
-0.3342148959636688,
0.20034290850162506,
-0.3569360375404358,
0.28627094626426697,
-1.0959954261779785,
-0.34740474820137024,
0.3406868875026703,
-0.555677592754364,
-0.14698006212711334,
-0.39076468348503113,
-0.49206769466400146,
-0.2367801070213318,
-0.3477782607078552,
0.053440485149621964,
0.35777968168258667,
-0.3434005379676819,
0.31626439094543457,
0.7864975333213806,
-0.22971193492412567,
-0.5711176991462708,
-0.5626054406166077,
-0.08272935450077057,
-0.26927682757377625,
-0.6392391324043274,
-0.00797990895807743,
0.41317328810691833,
-0.6151997447013855,
0.7497207522392273,
-0.015534034930169582,
-0.05361926928162575,
-0.5643725395202637,
0.262776255607605,
-0.08739060163497925,
-0.2737823724746704,
0.4790123403072357,
-0.053289007395505905,
0.10560236126184464,
-0.04021709784865379,
-0.3061631917953491,
0.6267921328544617,
-0.13391076028347015,
-0.4797290563583374,
-0.6770115494728088,
0.5100016593933105,
0.6229311227798462,
0.012477072887122631,
1.1335983276367188,
0.28674039244651794,
-0.35814663767814636,
-0.24696822464466095,
-0.6594919562339783,
-0.4589758813381195,
-0.32788652181625366,
-0.03855568543076515,
0.3765852749347687,
-0.8498691320419312,
0.8854735493659973,
0.0238224808126688,
0.07348014414310455,
0.3621208965778351,
0.6438100934028625,
0.02255505509674549,
0.6940217614173889,
0.3327302038669586,
-0.10111412405967712,
0.44195711612701416,
-0.2672337591648102,
0.43945878744125366,
-0.5321308970451355,
-0.13840852677822113,
-0.6641134023666382,
-0.40681836009025574,
-0.7027115225791931,
-0.4411504864692688,
0.6434979438781738,
-0.21300800144672394,
-0.20331910252571106,
-0.10359735041856766,
-0.7009238600730896,
0.25471657514572144,
0.5534332990646362,
0.10054799169301987,
0.3890092968940735,
0.4629669785499573,
0.22676262259483337,
0.0027087805792689323,
-0.8722090721130371,
-0.5675981640815735,
1.0773402452468872,
0.26701822876930237,
0.6386158466339111,
-0.034910134971141815,
0.7097622752189636,
0.5775340795516968,
0.2896895110607147,
-0.59739089012146,
0.0721140205860138,
0.10834094136953354,
-0.7575462460517883,
-0.18448945879936218,
-0.7805549502372742,
-1.0372974872589111,
0.138035848736763,
-0.21443961560726166,
-0.708559513092041,
0.5501193404197693,
-0.1092132031917572,
-0.05602388083934784,
0.7955877780914307,
-0.4466305673122406,
0.4448632001876831,
0.07169509679079056,
-0.33476531505584717,
-0.4130292534828186,
-0.2997121214866638,
0.2956428825855255,
0.1820775419473648,
0.6783037185668945,
-0.10865253955125809,
0.12958773970603943,
0.9622019529342651,
-0.10298007726669312,
0.8382702469825745,
-0.3516808748245239,
0.32762590050697327,
0.7943814992904663,
-0.09333378076553345,
0.45902010798454285,
0.08290986716747284,
-0.0499841533601284,
0.36668214201927185,
-0.29049593210220337,
-0.34403592348098755,
-0.602694034576416,
0.4605708420276642,
-1.0260732173919678,
-0.47884368896484375,
-0.3944859802722931,
-0.4524148106575012,
0.10352740436792374,
0.24554505944252014,
0.2568230926990509,
0.6316602826118469,
0.06783690303564072,
0.6038624048233032,
0.3012179732322693,
0.1778818964958191,
0.12427113205194473,
0.3658038377761841,
-0.0840098112821579,
-0.4498249292373657,
0.4792061150074005,
0.8756595253944397,
0.08312682062387466,
0.1087188646197319,
0.3085860311985016,
-0.2182009071111679,
-0.4342823028564453,
-0.09416457265615463,
0.26536235213279724,
-0.5192344784736633,
-0.39941075444221497,
-0.2602282166481018,
-0.3153128921985626,
-0.15368308126926422,
-0.16300268471240997,
-0.383438378572464,
-0.2850671112537384,
0.05610903352499008,
-0.1738036721944809,
0.26419657468795776,
1.2578338384628296,
-0.09334300458431244,
0.3466769754886627,
-0.27923592925071716,
0.0923488661646843,
0.22877559065818787,
0.3543076813220978,
0.002301736967638135,
-0.18906009197235107,
-0.4280836582183838,
0.250448077917099,
-0.4602745771408081,
-1.7742599248886108,
-0.08916866779327393,
-0.41102248430252075,
0.605478823184967,
0.5866774916648865,
0.39020487666130066,
0.4654454290866852,
-0.227482408285141,
0.86727374792099,
0.006149752996861935,
-0.49998605251312256,
0.35561326146125793,
-0.7398364543914795,
-0.2979601323604584,
0.3124854564666748,
0.5871597528457642,
-0.43391096591949463,
-0.9975415468215942,
-1.0614348649978638,
-0.6225684285163879,
0.5190033316612244,
0.4945148229598999,
0.07966054230928421,
0.03848928213119507,
0.12246032804250717,
0.11948138475418091,
0.4056391716003418,
-0.7786024212837219,
-0.2805548310279846,
-0.33688145875930786,
0.019170233979821205,
0.24057084321975708,
-0.12878559529781342,
-0.4978673756122589,
-0.008509214036166668,
0.5334067940711975,
-0.07531899213790894,
0.3815839886665344,
0.38790181279182434,
0.5136625170707703,
-0.3154585361480713,
0.31024256348609924,
0.25486916303634644,
0.8670305609703064,
-0.26701951026916504,
0.44351696968078613,
-0.46621251106262207,
0.0012524188496172428,
-0.028634758666157722,
-0.07659588754177094,
-0.24456387758255005,
0.32124221324920654,
0.49587467312812805,
0.6797794103622437,
-0.1824963390827179,
-0.038747940212488174,
0.4879997968673706,
0.004721465520560741,
-0.08102704584598541,
-0.4091675281524658,
-0.27037468552589417,
0.5654821395874023,
0.39912039041519165,
0.645329475402832,
0.14870771765708923,
0.25615233182907104,
-1.0709160566329956,
0.2146405726671219,
0.4914766252040863,
-0.39650461077690125,
-0.2686091959476471,
0.34981769323349,
0.12169497460126877,
-0.2419949173927307,
0.36807650327682495,
-0.2292667031288147,
-0.37352973222732544,
0.40094655752182007,
0.1783127337694168,
0.639442503452301,
0.1424466073513031,
0.4849609434604645,
0.3299972414970398,
0.4671179950237274,
0.36125293374061584,
-0.0005587868508882821,
0.08817735314369202,
-0.8542795181274414,
-0.08409090340137482,
-0.3032084107398987,
-0.2576448619365692,
0.2909257411956787,
-0.7193944454193115,
0.19252754747867584,
-0.4298703968524933,
-0.5657675266265869,
0.23421353101730347,
0.3943752944469452,
-0.710333526134491,
-0.29470235109329224,
0.15820112824440002,
0.5465574860572815,
-1.1599514484405518,
0.17746825516223907,
0.674065887928009,
-0.16291673481464386,
-0.7511040568351746,
0.35020601749420166,
0.5523450374603271,
-0.5105594396591187,
0.12000837177038193,
-0.14340408146381378,
-0.11365638673305511,
-0.3576541244983673,
-0.4258698523044586,
-0.6495692133903503,
0.763809323310852,
0.514118492603302,
-0.4643619954586029,
0.06643101572990417,
0.10626617074012756,
0.5201181769371033,
-0.5270691514015198,
-0.03847642242908478,
0.19697624444961548,
0.7078058123588562,
-0.250126451253891,
-0.5109841823577881,
0.07963165640830994,
-0.23395825922489166,
-0.3712638020515442,
0.4188741445541382,
-0.8627263903617859,
1.0074278116226196,
0.30282193422317505,
-0.632245659828186,
-0.7669920325279236,
0.3937026560306549,
0.05579056218266487,
0.6139956116676331,
0.5968225598335266,
0.18984708189964294,
0.8335298895835876,
-0.13440579175949097,
0.9682551026344299,
-0.4364946782588959,
0.3148212134838104,
0.6781802773475647,
0.16982831060886383,
0.5650644302368164,
0.5507211685180664,
-0.2328484058380127,
0.875136137008667,
0.4979497194290161,
0.17258846759796143,
0.43165913224220276,
0.08746370673179626,
0.02172253280878067,
0.1536814570426941,
-0.3483206033706665,
-0.289713978767395,
0.16577431559562683,
0.5118557810783386,
-0.39421260356903076,
-0.443236768245697,
-0.21628710627555847,
0.2835279703140259,
0.19716133177280426,
-0.23269717395305634,
0.8030133247375488,
-0.06395361572504044,
-0.4957409203052521,
0.270374596118927,
-0.4660281240940094,
0.11617211252450943,
-0.5325483083724976,
-0.026555730029940605,
-0.19228306412696838,
-0.41459235548973083,
-0.4304691255092621,
-1.1139967441558838,
0.4250255525112152,
-0.05360335111618042,
-0.13138225674629211,
-0.028395110741257668,
0.8744508624076843,
-0.2346900999546051,
-0.38117560744285583,
0.7371163368225098,
0.9385771751403809,
0.07640638947486877,
-0.07509966939687729,
-0.3633323609828949,
0.23335301876068115,
0.11359532922506332,
-0.5088865160942078,
0.026121878996491432,
0.6899288892745972,
-0.0037251149769872427,
0.2463582456111908,
0.6396039724349976,
0.519034743309021,
0.207641139626503,
0.11834048479795456,
1.2091965675354004,
-0.36870065331459045,
-0.5013191103935242,
-0.6259651184082031,
0.6487654447555542,
-0.5971472263336182,
-0.04119034856557846,
0.7338356971740723,
0.5073243975639343,
0.7831928133964539,
0.30327630043029785,
1.1905649900436401,
-0.29948434233665466,
0.8914730548858643,
-0.4194234311580658,
0.7793677449226379,
-0.5654283761978149,
0.2249840646982193,
-0.09383094310760498,
-0.8187429904937744,
0.028978541493415833,
0.4016530215740204,
-0.29141783714294434,
0.054021988064050674,
0.5867870450019836,
0.8488323092460632,
-0.2512291967868805,
0.1243147999048233,
-0.007143336348235607,
0.5160010457038879,
0.18236804008483887,
0.16448867321014404,
1.0547690391540527,
0.07934536784887314,
0.5870912671089172,
-0.5137910842895508,
-0.3040686249732971,
-0.3995210528373718,
-0.46813419461250305,
-0.9902054071426392,
-0.9208985567092896,
-0.06025533750653267,
-0.48116248846054077,
0.17812341451644897,
0.469119668006897,
0.7213178277015686,
-0.3808285593986511,
-0.3499486446380615,
0.1428229659795761,
0.5381321907043457,
-0.10603544861078262,
-0.3632820248603821,
0.6370466351509094,
-0.1868058294057846,
-0.4546303153038025,
-0.03374483808875084,
0.19585920870304108,
-0.28049060702323914,
-0.5991595387458801,
0.14813698828220367,
0.0021934101823717356,
0.4304944574832916,
0.21516278386116028,
0.04170169308781624,
-0.6233531832695007,
-0.6310964822769165,
-0.12664765119552612,
0.09175516664981842,
0.21017096936702728,
1.039656162261963,
-0.7673378586769104,
0.5803019404411316,
0.7265133261680603,
0.2969914972782135,
0.27476632595062256,
0.32353734970092773,
0.31895995140075684,
-0.7908949255943298,
0.26248979568481445,
0.24608591198921204,
0.1803978532552719,
0.5050980448722839,
-0.33072614669799805,
0.3503752648830414,
0.32270801067352295,
-0.5523302555084229,
-0.8144213557243347,
0.13526515662670135,
-0.9329968094825745,
-0.31099531054496765,
1.0016942024230957,
0.3571455776691437,
-0.2183985859155655,
-0.4122646749019623,
-0.10935547202825546,
0.6031849384307861,
-0.7731538414955139,
1.0328904390335083,
0.940001368522644,
-0.5789708495140076,
-0.1878901720046997,
-0.9287615418434143,
0.3834688067436218,
-0.4121132493019104,
-0.7506330609321594,
0.0016455210279673338,
0.4051152467727661,
0.2378905713558197,
0.6917580366134644,
0.9017903208732605,
-0.14805752038955688,
-0.1255953460931778,
0.29229605197906494,
-0.387747198343277,
0.09129483252763748,
-0.43943509459495544,
0.2315092384815216,
0.5649736523628235,
-0.4213916063308716,
-0.021655043587088585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03429v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03429v1
|
Scaffolding Language Learning via Multi-modal Tutoring Systems with Pedagogical Instructions
| 2024-04-04T13:22:28 | 2024-04-04T13:22:28 |
Zhengyuan Liu, Stella Xin Yin, Carolyn Lee, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs) that imitate human tutors and aim to
provide immediate and customized instructions or feedback to learners have
shown their effectiveness in education. With the emergence of generative
artificial intelligence, large language models (LLMs) further entitle the
systems to complex and coherent conversational interactions. These systems
would be of great help in language education as it involves developing skills
in communication, which, however, drew relatively less attention. Additionally,
due to the complicated cognitive development at younger ages, more endeavors
are needed for practical uses. Scaffolding refers to a teaching technique where
teachers provide support and guidance to students for learning and developing
new concepts or skills. It is an effective way to support diverse learning
needs, goals, processes, and outcomes. In this work, we investigate how
pedagogical instructions facilitate the scaffolding in ITSs, by conducting a
case study on guiding children to describe images for language learning. We
construct different types of scaffolding tutoring systems grounded in four
fundamental learning theories: knowledge construction, inquiry-based learning,
dialogic teaching, and zone of proximal development. For qualitative and
quantitative analyses, we build and refine a seven-dimension rubric to evaluate
the scaffolding process. In our experiment on GPT-4V, we observe that LLMs
demonstrate strong potential to follow pedagogical instructions and achieve
self-paced learning in different student groups. Moreover, we extend our
evaluation framework from a manual to an automated approach, paving the way to
benchmark various conversational tutoring systems.
|
[
-0.1462056040763855,
-0.8890464305877686,
0.4686327278614044,
0.42822229862213135,
-0.20039944350719452,
0.4810355603694916,
-0.28232061862945557,
-0.045678120106458664,
-0.0682256892323494,
0.21961936354637146,
-0.3711155354976654,
-0.3425920009613037,
-0.3743979334831238,
0.02683831937611103,
-0.3906148374080658,
0.955329418182373,
-0.21665681898593903,
0.43542999029159546,
-0.3280045986175537,
0.04928816482424736,
-0.5036253929138184,
-0.4394366443157196,
-0.4065132141113281,
-0.3339039087295532,
0.3180106282234192,
0.6624810695648193,
0.4155581295490265,
0.9821527004241943,
0.09907078742980957,
0.4017801284790039,
0.22013208270072937,
-0.23797915875911713,
-0.05569649487733841,
0.34183961153030396,
-0.1798119992017746,
-0.45042523741722107,
0.09082817286252975,
-0.01789310947060585,
0.6658048629760742,
0.8026756048202515,
-0.4006861448287964,
0.084615059196949,
0.3288702964782715,
0.5920283794403076,
-0.23337988555431366,
0.5787497758865356,
-0.30639827251434326,
0.13833123445510864,
-0.13770239055156708,
-0.20532922446727753,
-0.30712682008743286,
-0.5977475047111511,
0.3303338885307312,
-0.380222350358963,
0.05239543318748474,
-0.14087426662445068,
0.5812526941299438,
-0.0636722519993782,
-0.3858073949813843,
-0.6631464958190918,
-0.48053112626075745,
0.7929325103759766,
-0.5200417041778564,
0.386539489030838,
0.5820263028144836,
0.5468855500221252,
-0.02459055930376053,
-0.4744037687778473,
-0.32205745577812195,
-0.3749770522117615,
0.02219446189701557,
0.07183977961540222,
0.303902268409729,
0.12106592953205109,
0.17457544803619385,
0.39373189210891724,
-0.45239222049713135,
0.14458060264587402,
-0.7780527472496033,
-0.35242101550102234,
0.350107342004776,
0.08703742176294327,
0.22097210586071014,
-0.21983954310417175,
-0.60795658826828,
-0.058043427765369415,
-0.7265939116477966,
0.12932005524635315,
0.6752273440361023,
0.33523082733154297,
-0.2966499328613281,
0.45336824655532837,
-0.18198314309120178,
0.5397500395774841,
0.03528044745326042,
-0.5693892240524292,
0.39798152446746826,
-0.3209058344364166,
0.1311318278312683,
-0.027571894228458405,
0.52299565076828,
0.21399901807308197,
0.46339523792266846,
-0.12430757284164429,
-0.08459826558828354,
0.1363891363143921,
0.1014404296875,
-0.6526012420654297,
-0.15566062927246094,
-0.1493469774723053,
-0.2789606750011444,
-0.16167764365673065,
-0.39240923523902893,
-0.7173107266426086,
-0.003788948757573962,
-0.5361400842666626,
0.42612043023109436,
-0.8683034777641296,
-0.0906112864613533,
0.08319041877985,
0.20608441531658173,
0.4227771461009979,
0.3141176104545593,
-0.9742010235786438,
0.29283228516578674,
0.2637450397014618,
0.66975337266922,
-0.2486768513917923,
-0.41180598735809326,
-0.17156311869621277,
0.42007943987846375,
-0.1498703956604004,
0.8413771390914917,
-0.6311720609664917,
-0.2960622012615204,
0.29044678807258606,
-0.03360380232334137,
-0.28703904151916504,
-0.017176112160086632,
0.24822218716144562,
-0.2500130236148834,
0.6677510738372803,
0.09761836379766464,
-0.44811367988586426,
-0.3898068964481354,
0.3342604637145996,
-0.3686528205871582,
0.9037244915962219,
0.08055995404720306,
-0.34963616728782654,
-0.09031005203723907,
-0.5319426655769348,
-0.5378410816192627,
0.23271875083446503,
-0.5998879671096802,
-0.13004159927368164,
-0.10858266055583954,
0.02920743077993393,
0.622911810874939,
-0.21030576527118683,
0.3448639512062073,
0.0959014743566513,
-0.35261234641075134,
0.02829909883439541,
-0.5387371778488159,
0.4949018955230713,
0.1518816202878952,
-0.6084693074226379,
0.1369207799434662,
-0.561224639415741,
0.09296110272407532,
0.27151429653167725,
-0.6773620843887329,
0.0019091329304501414,
-0.1398194581270218,
-0.1279778629541397,
0.13518118858337402,
0.12052395939826965,
-0.18163847923278809,
0.33102139830589294,
-0.2902461886405945,
0.5019333958625793,
0.865591287612915,
-0.01629169099032879,
0.40534743666648865,
-0.3077595829963684,
0.6648343205451965,
-0.1362999677658081,
0.20185834169387817,
-0.956716775894165,
-0.37511584162712097,
-0.8684124946594238,
-0.20741187036037445,
0.21736471354961395,
0.33285582065582275,
-1.0198484659194946,
-0.14595504105091095,
-0.06671760976314545,
-0.3142082393169403,
-0.29229387640953064,
0.3094930648803711,
0.7258209586143494,
0.36507681012153625,
0.15758301317691803,
-0.17229504883289337,
-0.28128582239151,
-1.041220784187317,
-0.03595154732465744,
-0.17592406272888184,
0.06803881376981735,
0.028500862419605255,
0.4383842349052429,
0.08387994021177292,
0.4118573069572449,
-0.025298358872532845,
-0.3039829134941101,
-0.04465159401297569,
-0.06365551054477692,
-0.046157509088516235,
0.548850953578949,
0.5585499405860901,
-0.4642038643360138,
-0.6388559937477112,
-0.1392296552658081,
-0.6990321278572083,
-0.07165984064340591,
-0.08200632780790329,
0.28674179315567017,
0.34169837832450867,
0.6181485652923584,
-0.30254286527633667,
0.366538405418396,
0.4529910683631897,
-0.13705533742904663,
0.7963945865631104,
-0.22731998562812805,
0.20517614483833313,
-0.7969167232513428,
-0.30832603573799133,
-0.09317991882562637,
-0.10198191553354263,
-0.4230317175388336,
0.14982476830482483,
-0.09233938157558441,
-0.00847902987152338,
-0.4423528015613556,
0.070758156478405,
-0.6481866240501404,
-0.028742501512169838,
-0.08340294659137726,
0.313546359539032,
-0.07856116443872452,
0.9524184465408325,
-0.17253506183624268,
0.8036031723022461,
0.729132354259491,
-0.23731283843517303,
0.3377382755279541,
-0.1512383371591568,
-0.29524239897727966,
0.7372198104858398,
-0.6230368614196777,
0.26380157470703125,
-0.034987922757864,
0.08859235048294067,
-1.0510040521621704,
-0.1036442294716835,
0.44540414214134216,
-0.03817612677812576,
0.19786709547042847,
-0.14516271650791168,
-0.6018652319908142,
-0.09256918728351593,
-0.3449588418006897,
0.31584134697914124,
0.05724283307790756,
-0.2713943123817444,
0.8509714007377625,
0.2775725722312927,
-0.35298988223075867,
-0.3073228895664215,
-0.369314968585968,
0.0643722414970398,
-0.24912160634994507,
-0.3024245500564575,
0.3485359251499176,
-0.31858283281326294,
-0.08284062892198563,
-0.04195385053753853,
-0.1279158890247345,
-0.027963213622570038,
-0.10224374383687973,
0.507465660572052,
0.14756867289543152,
-0.11025679856538773,
0.25782573223114014,
0.191463440656662,
-0.24711409211158752,
0.035886965692043304,
-0.006231554783880711,
0.7451968193054199,
-0.5445167422294617,
-0.7769674062728882,
-0.6182337999343872,
0.5199187994003296,
0.7431724071502686,
-0.1362142264842987,
0.47121676802635193,
0.23176713287830353,
-0.23998770117759705,
-0.06893671303987503,
-0.5431166291236877,
-0.17201998829841614,
-0.5351613759994507,
0.14856845140457153,
-0.5627384781837463,
-0.7977396845817566,
0.45120969414711,
-0.34187838435173035,
-0.043866753578186035,
-0.11096551269292831,
0.5150613784790039,
-0.2689801752567291,
1.149612545967102,
0.5984957814216614,
0.2416439950466156,
0.7198507189750671,
-0.4282113015651703,
0.18343138694763184,
-0.5089158415794373,
-0.6108130216598511,
-0.3865739107131958,
0.031797077506780624,
-0.2433422952890396,
-0.42468297481536865,
0.3078751564025879,
0.19765205681324005,
-0.18759825825691223,
0.24113629758358002,
-0.3528500199317932,
0.5493757724761963,
0.555181086063385,
0.12850990891456604,
0.22555872797966003,
0.3307185471057892,
-0.7945125102996826,
-0.012906786054372787,
-0.8259934186935425,
-0.8003808259963989,
0.8445035219192505,
0.3896733224391937,
0.564788818359375,
-0.06447086483240128,
0.40733107924461365,
0.24507838487625122,
0.3402726948261261,
-0.7255693078041077,
0.6210011839866638,
0.28858235478401184,
-0.505967378616333,
-0.23403505980968475,
0.1555415689945221,
-0.7535189986228943,
0.43336221575737,
-0.26843345165252686,
-0.7415049076080322,
-0.20257283747196198,
-0.16116400063037872,
-0.021771671250462532,
-0.03289269655942917,
-0.9454312324523926,
0.5094731450080872,
-0.40766605734825134,
-0.41537439823150635,
-0.6187060475349426,
-0.5588045120239258,
0.03235235437750816,
-0.056943945586681366,
0.45396003127098083,
0.20530156791210175,
0.24825888872146606,
0.7082382440567017,
-0.25210118293762207,
1.1714026927947998,
-0.16349034011363983,
-0.15202784538269043,
0.3469598591327667,
0.18965370953083038,
0.10888627171516418,
-0.26568734645843506,
-0.18143370747566223,
-0.0010400532046332955,
0.34506064653396606,
-0.6239684224128723,
-0.6248016357421875,
0.8769251108169556,
-0.6763121485710144,
-1.0562729835510254,
-0.4508470892906189,
-0.5892430543899536,
-0.15520021319389343,
0.20149391889572144,
-0.3144449293613434,
0.49447375535964966,
0.13600681722164154,
0.3363910913467407,
0.4105372726917267,
-0.03921913728117943,
0.6073878407478333,
0.6474973559379578,
-0.3538491725921631,
-0.31449973583221436,
0.9330430030822754,
0.3501623570919037,
0.31892091035842896,
-0.2162899374961853,
0.2832554578781128,
-0.27021661400794983,
-0.7085217237472534,
-0.5607291460037231,
0.3572472333908081,
-1.0533888339996338,
-0.10406605899333954,
-0.21047674119472504,
-0.19648462533950806,
-0.24263371527194977,
-0.20863604545593262,
-0.07816488295793533,
-0.4216373562812805,
0.1072608157992363,
-0.3582318127155304,
0.1394888013601303,
0.8207663893699646,
0.08858713507652283,
0.6334518790245056,
-0.5017675161361694,
-0.03672831505537033,
0.4480762183666229,
0.3835572302341461,
0.11069995164871216,
-0.22691112756729126,
-0.455172061920166,
0.1533031314611435,
-0.5209800004959106,
-0.9563590288162231,
-0.12799562513828278,
0.3148528039455414,
0.9205523729324341,
0.550880491733551,
-0.24652305245399475,
0.6330416798591614,
-0.5893882513046265,
0.7962108850479126,
0.19847628474235535,
-0.9694960117340088,
0.6329243183135986,
-0.444776326417923,
0.16991332173347473,
0.31278616189956665,
0.30834338068962097,
-0.3101693391799927,
-0.20382115244865417,
-0.4392453134059906,
-0.794695258140564,
0.5399187207221985,
-0.059678349643945694,
0.3858128488063812,
0.17510269582271576,
0.45205098390579224,
0.3628549575805664,
0.39513349533081055,
-0.7825201153755188,
-0.16836389899253845,
-0.36837467551231384,
-0.3230133652687073,
0.3493649959564209,
-0.17215357720851898,
-0.4553118348121643,
-0.0300778616219759,
0.4843454360961914,
-0.5012346506118774,
0.0804293230175972,
-0.18638451397418976,
-0.21408499777317047,
0.013698935508728027,
0.16218581795692444,
0.32494521141052246,
0.6539474725723267,
0.42779335379600525,
0.10414937883615494,
0.10646945238113403,
-0.12799575924873352,
0.0678272396326065,
-0.154852494597435,
0.011662672273814678,
-0.2960191071033478,
0.5383924245834351,
0.7683057188987732,
0.4926804304122925,
-0.6375413537025452,
0.5946289300918579,
0.08143407106399536,
-0.21577663719654083,
-0.3127976357936859,
0.22062723338603973,
0.11376277357339859,
0.42601504921913147,
0.5469931960105896,
-0.22153730690479279,
-0.15541426837444305,
-0.7361853122711182,
0.11183887720108032,
0.2706698775291443,
-0.24622100591659546,
-0.6465883851051331,
0.1593773066997528,
0.1996045559644699,
-0.7336805462837219,
0.2583467364311218,
0.18965765833854675,
-0.6124240756034851,
0.349124938249588,
0.8778665065765381,
0.5041897892951965,
-0.5869820713996887,
0.5833235383033752,
-0.08363677561283112,
0.20045827329158783,
0.1258958876132965,
0.31066352128982544,
-0.5882899761199951,
-0.4618089199066162,
-0.4917927384376526,
-0.42945846915245056,
-0.38028693199157715,
-0.12888365983963013,
-0.4972330927848816,
0.1210102066397667,
-0.5885953903198242,
0.25781381130218506,
-0.11616388708353043,
-0.19682049751281738,
-0.7947446703910828,
0.0627102255821228,
0.022222915664315224,
0.6356421113014221,
-1.0206812620162964,
0.9009536504745483,
0.8096817135810852,
-0.5967023968696594,
-0.8729103803634644,
-0.06637191027402878,
0.019193066284060478,
-0.857315719127655,
0.7679117321968079,
0.2166198343038559,
-0.347909539937973,
0.08737082779407501,
-0.5815761089324951,
-0.8469234704971313,
1.0535255670547485,
0.5521522760391235,
-0.20950818061828613,
-0.17460288107395172,
0.29453176259994507,
0.6641936302185059,
-0.6090375185012817,
0.3036101758480072,
0.1744748055934906,
0.35043302178382874,
0.13546739518642426,
-0.7857593297958374,
0.0696929320693016,
-0.21461080014705658,
-0.11429152637720108,
-0.4153073728084564,
-0.7284590601921082,
0.490840882062912,
-0.08422674238681793,
-0.4781801998615265,
0.09623607248067856,
0.39994528889656067,
0.36421579122543335,
0.1587265133857727,
0.7670907378196716,
0.13021090626716614,
0.44536837935447693,
-0.14932101964950562,
0.5877336263656616,
-0.5307790040969849,
-0.0592198483645916,
0.7336529493331909,
0.08232131600379944,
0.5468032360076904,
0.9032641053199768,
-0.20489470660686493,
0.9819401502609253,
0.5026832222938538,
0.28470751643180847,
0.4232310652732849,
0.26183193922042847,
-0.09641444683074951,
-0.20694825053215027,
-0.2957323491573334,
-0.284715861082077,
0.5383447408676147,
0.6862580180168152,
-0.1677265763282776,
-0.33106255531311035,
0.3665611743927002,
-0.10469215363264084,
0.3991962671279907,
-0.06879197061061859,
0.5275101661682129,
-0.023073071613907814,
-0.5709269046783447,
0.4869709610939026,
-0.296188622713089,
0.3878365457057953,
-0.6624647974967957,
-0.3478800654411316,
-0.004893674980849028,
-0.10540858656167984,
-0.16483667492866516,
-0.6776723265647888,
-0.04443323612213135,
-0.2051863670349121,
-0.011357047595083714,
-0.665717363357544,
0.4548751413822174,
-0.5320839285850525,
-0.2946299910545349,
0.30499908328056335,
0.7131966352462769,
0.23953358829021454,
0.5420355200767517,
-0.7309746146202087,
0.21248841285705566,
-0.029172707349061966,
-0.43950819969177246,
0.41446155309677124,
0.35687702894210815,
-0.4055027663707733,
1.139829158782959,
0.7459110021591187,
-0.048592474311590195,
0.001038660411722958,
0.14019379019737244,
1.048298716545105,
-0.3104539215564728,
-0.4626227617263794,
-0.5205385088920593,
0.6523343324661255,
0.17300041019916534,
-0.17547553777694702,
0.9623845219612122,
0.27710333466529846,
0.7988420128822327,
-0.02385915070772171,
0.6865379214286804,
0.11510302126407623,
0.25392964482307434,
-0.47125333547592163,
0.24197092652320862,
-0.09176059067249298,
0.3910429775714874,
-0.2128680795431137,
-0.9330717325210571,
-0.373410165309906,
0.8680728077888489,
-0.3523443043231964,
0.04253222048282623,
0.7365967631340027,
0.631730318069458,
0.19038164615631104,
0.25757166743278503,
0.16771546006202698,
-0.03531833738088608,
0.46059662103652954,
0.06899922341108322,
1.0401926040649414,
-0.27480876445770264,
0.5855457186698914,
-0.29726216197013855,
-0.35188746452331543,
-0.15844100713729858,
-0.7706688046455383,
-1.0095891952514648,
-0.889142632484436,
-0.2667478919029236,
-0.124612957239151,
0.41894736886024475,
0.9004697203636169,
0.6398941278457642,
-0.599690854549408,
-0.3857704699039459,
0.009175818413496017,
0.0801101103425026,
-0.27775636315345764,
-0.24804584681987762,
0.5195794701576233,
-0.43202540278434753,
-0.9049098491668701,
0.6056345105171204,
0.2940818667411804,
0.04365282133221626,
-0.8018600344657898,
-0.012575004249811172,
-0.30626535415649414,
-0.04593510180711746,
0.5180864930152893,
0.14505577087402344,
-0.7765191197395325,
-0.5767676830291748,
0.11117810755968094,
-0.05067513883113861,
-0.12932497262954712,
0.7386784553527832,
-0.9377780556678772,
0.5199891328811646,
0.26184335350990295,
0.47260692715644836,
0.6340292692184448,
-0.3315950632095337,
0.6931149363517761,
-0.49685385823249817,
0.18024225533008575,
-0.030786268413066864,
0.3817085027694702,
0.46624836325645447,
0.008841754868626595,
0.2880838215351105,
0.15003937482833862,
-0.5158092975616455,
-0.8488971590995789,
0.27758803963661194,
-0.4409830868244171,
-0.12384698539972305,
0.9417259097099304,
-0.3744187653064728,
-0.127940371632576,
-0.2931632399559021,
-0.5765382051467896,
0.27795615792274475,
-0.23822669684886932,
1.0231329202651978,
0.7580602169036865,
-0.31136226654052734,
-0.3249480128288269,
-0.3965212404727936,
0.1785130649805069,
0.4318827986717224,
-0.4430824816226959,
-0.19698435068130493,
0.40098410844802856,
0.3472786247730255,
0.30142825841903687,
0.3961505591869354,
-0.15492001175880432,
0.01951363869011402,
-0.19890430569648743,
-0.10369895398616791,
-0.15723809599876404,
-0.4168332517147064,
-0.32029083371162415,
0.4061272144317627,
-0.18093332648277283,
-0.34121885895729065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03428v1
|
Edisum: Summarizing and Explaining Wikipedia Edits at Scale
| 2024-04-04T13:15:28 | 2024-04-04T13:15:28 |
Marija Šakota, Isaac Johnson, Guosheng Feng, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An edit summary is a succinct comment written by a Wikipedia editor
explaining the nature of, and reasons for, an edit to a Wikipedia page. Edit
summaries are crucial for maintaining the encyclopedia: they are the first
thing seen by content moderators and help them decide whether to accept or
reject an edit. Additionally, edit summaries constitute a valuable data source
for researchers. Unfortunately, as we show, for many edits, summaries are
either missing or incomplete. To overcome this problem and help editors write
useful edit summaries, we propose a model for recommending edit summaries
generated by a language model trained to produce good edit summaries given the
representation of an edit diff. This is a challenging task for multiple
reasons, including mixed-quality training data, the need to understand not only
what was changed in the article but also why it was changed, and efficiency
requirements imposed by the scale of Wikipedia. We address these challenges by
curating a mix of human and synthetically generated training data and
fine-tuning a generative language model sufficiently small to be used on
Wikipedia at scale. Our model performs on par with human editors. Commercial
large language models are able to solve this task better than human editors,
but would be too expensive to run on Wikipedia at scale. More broadly, this
paper showcases how language modeling technology can be used to support humans
in maintaining one of the largest and most visible projects on the Web.
|
[
-0.7917698621749878,
-0.5485525727272034,
0.32056179642677307,
-0.03214405104517937,
-0.24045313894748688,
-0.21116892993450165,
-0.45590347051620483,
-0.3926332890987396,
0.4487246870994568,
0.4142550230026245,
-0.3605363368988037,
-0.19825923442840576,
-0.5296940803527832,
0.3425177335739136,
-0.6532496213912964,
1.1809309720993042,
-0.1441108137369156,
0.019949255511164665,
-0.34397390484809875,
-0.07283806055784225,
-0.2762541174888611,
-0.025171885266900063,
-0.7239466905593872,
-0.3087896704673767,
0.7537131905555725,
0.7050825953483582,
0.8634285926818848,
1.0133205652236938,
0.4120594263076782,
0.3482262194156647,
-0.5141628980636597,
0.30753329396247864,
-0.6566221714019775,
-0.12657447159290314,
-0.4491792321205139,
-0.2736423909664154,
-0.9226694703102112,
0.09312505275011063,
0.6163108944892883,
0.9930858612060547,
-0.18401280045509338,
0.18402843177318573,
-0.06620661914348602,
0.6828294396400452,
-0.38676732778549194,
-0.08730995655059814,
-0.4956100583076477,
-0.10266586393117905,
0.12876108288764954,
0.22735030949115753,
-0.20398655533790588,
-0.2257918119430542,
-0.046429652720689774,
-0.8171364665031433,
0.4430415630340576,
-0.15301348268985748,
0.5085880160331726,
0.1654755026102066,
-0.2735721170902252,
-0.25662854313850403,
-0.7855105400085449,
0.31425851583480835,
-0.812441349029541,
0.28659990429878235,
0.41857773065567017,
0.056421928107738495,
-0.03972563520073891,
-0.6795086860656738,
-0.8435715436935425,
-0.218393936753273,
-0.11946408450603485,
0.006104393862187862,
-0.04990147799253464,
0.14766086637973785,
0.387189656496048,
0.6787953972816467,
-0.2525860071182251,
0.3515363335609436,
-0.6426772475242615,
0.09050221741199493,
0.6175501942634583,
0.23048533499240875,
0.569598376750946,
-0.16389505565166473,
0.24661807715892792,
0.05539369583129883,
-0.6030862331390381,
-0.17233239114284515,
0.555294930934906,
0.14325134456157684,
-0.03485161066055298,
0.7557539343833923,
-0.5140259861946106,
0.812762439250946,
0.2741663455963135,
-0.051403794437646866,
-0.02883325330913067,
-0.21751031279563904,
-0.02225501462817192,
-0.1826280951499939,
0.5985414981842041,
0.8792846202850342,
0.3719108998775482,
-0.18450656533241272,
-0.29884928464889526,
-0.2822764217853546,
0.33496132493019104,
-0.8852284550666809,
-0.5150801539421082,
0.06202647089958191,
-0.49165764451026917,
-0.49567416310310364,
-0.01957714930176735,
-0.71044921875,
-0.4548754096031189,
-0.5392796993255615,
0.1297498345375061,
-0.305566668510437,
-0.42118746042251587,
-0.043687235563993454,
-0.42535319924354553,
-0.4672669768333435,
0.601417601108551,
-1.3494012355804443,
0.09355518221855164,
0.4968135356903076,
0.7659514546394348,
0.20855137705802917,
-0.5515662431716919,
-0.1827954202890396,
0.06656914949417114,
-0.50151526927948,
0.8267502188682556,
-0.37379953265190125,
-0.535396933555603,
-0.2284020483493805,
-0.14873898029327393,
0.2865847051143646,
-0.46538689732551575,
0.29252660274505615,
-0.5910995602607727,
0.09087168425321579,
-0.2980947196483612,
-0.9074094891548157,
-0.13879676163196564,
0.06604170799255371,
-0.9492629170417786,
0.7464501857757568,
0.27383992075920105,
-0.8135367631912231,
0.38713374733924866,
-0.6368682980537415,
-0.3858325183391571,
0.05705893784761429,
0.36273249983787537,
-0.16750282049179077,
0.4286469519138336,
0.28091689944267273,
0.24364836513996124,
0.045835092663764954,
0.16167312860488892,
-0.21899643540382385,
-0.17806145548820496,
0.15010122954845428,
-0.10018476098775864,
0.5554147362709045,
0.12001220136880875,
0.17726032435894012,
0.13134996592998505,
-0.831369936466217,
-0.17765803635120392,
-0.21492335200309753,
-0.545052170753479,
-0.3478700816631317,
0.2319110780954361,
0.16624778509140015,
-0.029345164075493813,
0.3058501183986664,
-0.2850995659828186,
0.3636374771595001,
-0.5223803520202637,
0.38894733786582947,
0.64422607421875,
0.060721468180418015,
0.7067112326622009,
-0.1957027018070221,
0.2908106744289398,
-0.348913311958313,
0.1397830694913864,
-0.3311918079853058,
-0.2804936170578003,
-0.748940110206604,
-0.2712889611721039,
0.4906468689441681,
0.27675938606262207,
-0.6656680107116699,
0.3242151141166687,
-0.3574196696281433,
-0.8330154418945312,
-0.6260952353477478,
0.4492873549461365,
0.03452882170677185,
0.5062147974967957,
0.33122894167900085,
-0.1395305097103119,
-0.4082508385181427,
-0.9050794839859009,
-0.51319420337677,
-0.3017526865005493,
-0.4708416759967804,
-0.03258960321545601,
0.5569162964820862,
-0.34940794110298157,
1.01172935962677,
-0.46437856554985046,
0.042106349021196365,
-0.4157218635082245,
0.18020690977573395,
-0.05192670226097107,
0.3005557954311371,
0.46066683530807495,
-0.8894477486610413,
-0.5086601972579956,
0.01827387511730194,
-0.6929645538330078,
-0.33650222420692444,
-0.20712228119373322,
-0.039834801107645035,
-0.4067838191986084,
0.4600066542625427,
-0.5742937326431274,
0.13286373019218445,
0.3333504796028137,
-0.3318046033382416,
0.4590330719947815,
-0.732684314250946,
0.2371089607477188,
-1.1816096305847168,
-0.0427967831492424,
-0.031332723796367645,
-0.3763055205345154,
-0.5968563556671143,
0.25634974241256714,
0.36985304951667786,
-0.06938531994819641,
-0.16013194620609283,
0.29389312863349915,
-0.28642430901527405,
0.18848824501037598,
-0.37032267451286316,
0.38728928565979004,
0.06036500260233879,
0.27690014243125916,
-0.16304689645767212,
0.6421892046928406,
0.25554925203323364,
-0.5948768258094788,
0.6828810572624207,
0.3396596908569336,
-0.30024799704551697,
0.762357771396637,
-0.7569048404693604,
0.017844734713435173,
-0.36300867795944214,
0.10319667309522629,
-0.717544674873352,
-0.5275914072990417,
-0.2822684347629547,
-0.37577950954437256,
0.41228169202804565,
0.05778024345636368,
-0.48813894391059875,
-0.24992862343788147,
-0.4760420620441437,
0.09674732387065887,
0.08390800654888153,
-0.5475768446922302,
0.5760738253593445,
0.7311864495277405,
-0.41355451941490173,
-0.1253150850534439,
-0.399009644985199,
0.2801132798194885,
-0.05114851891994476,
-0.529824435710907,
0.4995981454849243,
-0.31191563606262207,
-0.4370797276496887,
0.2437855750322342,
0.0938510149717331,
-0.18001127243041992,
0.24307213723659515,
0.2229766547679901,
0.26941049098968506,
0.14929762482643127,
0.2832638919353485,
0.129489928483963,
-0.07398425787687302,
-0.02162962406873703,
-0.0044517116621136665,
0.033883776515722275,
0.11763520538806915,
0.02507634460926056,
-0.3793030381202698,
0.414713978767395,
0.9009767770767212,
-0.22679488360881805,
0.7974572777748108,
0.40205833315849304,
-0.46035903692245483,
-0.0913294106721878,
-0.4098527431488037,
-0.004716458730399609,
-0.3856184780597687,
0.6487870216369629,
-0.09472563117742538,
-0.6311644315719604,
0.5580844879150391,
-0.07370670139789581,
0.391709566116333,
0.8972893953323364,
0.7032687067985535,
-0.4142249524593353,
0.9267229437828064,
0.9868882298469543,
-0.15033654868602753,
0.7359810471534729,
-0.2762266993522644,
0.022879255935549736,
-0.9377391934394836,
-0.071299709379673,
-0.416913241147995,
-0.46710482239723206,
-0.525670051574707,
-0.17900466918945312,
0.3065563440322876,
0.41992971301078796,
0.08521132171154022,
0.43072178959846497,
-0.25892773270606995,
0.8511794805526733,
0.47356629371643066,
0.11165983229875565,
0.3271835446357727,
-0.05788905546069145,
0.08425093442201614,
0.13006086647510529,
-0.6180590987205505,
-0.590130090713501,
1.052173137664795,
0.1664039045572281,
0.8119252324104309,
0.12446142733097076,
0.4556037485599518,
0.5452712178230286,
0.4878615140914917,
-0.5342527627944946,
0.40874892473220825,
-0.12605020403862,
-0.6609251499176025,
-0.6659056544303894,
-0.3353632092475891,
-0.47618478536605835,
0.21852990984916687,
-0.3335117995738983,
-0.3081092834472656,
-0.09336873143911362,
0.3780812621116638,
-0.320482462644577,
0.5326986312866211,
-0.6804305911064148,
0.8483620285987854,
0.21096466481685638,
0.040093302726745605,
-0.7247557044029236,
-0.35170838236808777,
0.1835329383611679,
-0.1710466593503952,
0.5026770234107971,
0.10386843979358673,
-0.0397273451089859,
0.8236108422279358,
-0.7038713097572327,
0.7668293714523315,
0.060968004167079926,
0.07045236229896545,
0.1858232468366623,
0.17268617451190948,
0.45148104429244995,
0.1269303411245346,
-0.08655302226543427,
0.041218847036361694,
-0.24391332268714905,
-0.271618127822876,
-0.4456247389316559,
0.8184404373168945,
-0.8736931681632996,
-0.5019544363021851,
0.21749576926231384,
-0.6147773265838623,
0.0350278802216053,
0.12743525207042694,
0.43071290850639343,
0.47409769892692566,
-0.3261551558971405,
0.10533884167671204,
0.6887913942337036,
-0.17839045822620392,
0.33252641558647156,
0.36872708797454834,
-0.26517897844314575,
-0.4671226441860199,
0.8101381063461304,
0.3808613419532776,
0.29115498065948486,
0.32334277033805847,
0.06262806802988052,
0.09196678549051285,
-0.4379550516605377,
-0.9530911445617676,
0.14417336881160736,
-0.8247659802436829,
-0.052654437720775604,
-0.6407650709152222,
0.05241703987121582,
-0.2001054883003235,
-0.44324496388435364,
-0.3221151828765869,
-0.844508707523346,
-0.39565470814704895,
-0.4136800765991211,
0.548676073551178,
1.1157423257827759,
-0.24549275636672974,
0.31834203004837036,
-0.5009375810623169,
0.5951699614524841,
0.5135812759399414,
0.45937252044677734,
0.15489718317985535,
-0.726021409034729,
-0.6997218728065491,
0.08933170139789581,
-0.2428911328315735,
-1.0004992485046387,
0.2594923973083496,
0.3289506137371063,
0.435092031955719,
0.3447975814342499,
-0.07217232882976532,
0.6290532350540161,
-0.7394062280654907,
0.7835216522216797,
0.15357588231563568,
-0.7960495948791504,
0.6328690648078918,
-0.32435375452041626,
0.39461079239845276,
0.46492326259613037,
0.17170248925685883,
-0.854659378528595,
-0.6696467995643616,
-0.422502726316452,
-0.8083473443984985,
0.44300925731658936,
0.05184120684862137,
0.32715925574302673,
-0.09737925976514816,
0.517544686794281,
0.061948955059051514,
0.18944396078586578,
-0.5299145579338074,
-0.25035494565963745,
-0.1367034614086151,
-0.19958166778087616,
-0.13562482595443726,
-0.5772957801818848,
0.06500620394945145,
-0.35083475708961487,
0.8100404143333435,
0.17426614463329315,
-0.22752714157104492,
0.06365036219358444,
-0.4008234441280365,
-0.6032702922821045,
0.19477272033691406,
0.5550529956817627,
0.9786074757575989,
-0.03102712333202362,
0.04539017006754875,
0.5814773440361023,
-0.48114991188049316,
-0.18847599625587463,
0.017497701570391655,
-0.37537944316864014,
0.1873619258403778,
0.6180752515792847,
0.7228041291236877,
0.363675057888031,
-0.5464726686477661,
0.22984205186367035,
-0.029673628509044647,
0.006135181523859501,
-0.03116237372159958,
0.11781609803438187,
0.3691347539424896,
0.23356327414512634,
0.14894291758537292,
0.13920308649539948,
0.21129938960075378,
-0.3855549991130829,
0.01909634657204151,
0.09391210973262787,
-0.06041957065463066,
-0.39988502860069275,
0.7732670307159424,
0.4545832872390747,
-0.48977020382881165,
0.7179054021835327,
-0.047587525099515915,
-0.6457352042198181,
0.50345379114151,
0.052466295659542084,
0.70125812292099,
-0.38035690784454346,
0.1952183097600937,
0.5266042947769165,
0.44972681999206543,
-0.14803922176361084,
-0.16829122602939606,
-0.010553128086030483,
-0.49560320377349854,
-0.3479190766811371,
-0.6464770436286926,
-0.43523043394088745,
-0.2037220001220703,
-0.5673936605453491,
0.3028111755847931,
-0.3788833022117615,
-0.11177992820739746,
0.4792806804180145,
-0.24111539125442505,
-0.5384957790374756,
0.33404865860939026,
0.08160321414470673,
1.1161173582077026,
-0.8735634088516235,
0.5611917972564697,
0.5731825232505798,
-0.5315017700195312,
-0.6689772009849548,
-0.2677987217903137,
-0.1364637166261673,
-0.2650383710861206,
0.253639280796051,
-0.23724117875099182,
0.1859658807516098,
0.03675561770796776,
-0.36249786615371704,
-0.5261325240135193,
0.9181921482086182,
0.31733208894729614,
-0.6175134181976318,
-0.3463253676891327,
-0.16483402252197266,
0.7504732012748718,
-0.2415418177843094,
0.24424919486045837,
0.33770450949668884,
0.19987839460372925,
-0.22033780813217163,
-1.071818470954895,
-0.31492355465888977,
-0.13281206786632538,
0.1511172503232956,
0.21754297614097595,
-0.30891579389572144,
1.0853354930877686,
-0.47124359011650085,
0.09593522548675537,
-0.0035793804563581944,
0.5998578071594238,
-0.33044031262397766,
-0.019600318744778633,
0.530890703201294,
0.7135058641433716,
0.7362250685691833,
0.11297344416379929,
1.2114253044128418,
-0.3959099352359772,
0.47300127148628235,
1.2399184703826904,
0.16979612410068512,
0.8902488946914673,
0.3401937782764435,
-0.23002076148986816,
0.5351089239120483,
0.8232151865959167,
0.11085887998342514,
0.36028656363487244,
-0.018654270097613335,
-0.377184122800827,
-0.1288948357105255,
0.05186040326952934,
-0.2482142299413681,
0.14695632457733154,
0.2552564740180969,
-0.6373011469841003,
-0.35799551010131836,
0.13380883634090424,
-0.0424831248819828,
0.17548389732837677,
-0.6726545691490173,
0.9941228628158569,
-0.19029685854911804,
-0.6055256128311157,
0.19561943411827087,
0.30188170075416565,
0.20370282232761383,
-0.3042813539505005,
-0.11489013582468033,
-0.38750091195106506,
0.05790722742676735,
-0.3259466886520386,
-0.7168868184089661,
0.3034718334674835,
0.4846137464046478,
-0.7236760258674622,
-0.3496944010257721,
0.45254048705101013,
-0.7528435587882996,
-0.65659099817276,
-0.02766190655529499,
0.2854221761226654,
0.13030648231506348,
-0.048539899289608,
-0.22686569392681122,
-0.18745216727256775,
0.019068649038672447,
-0.4252980947494507,
0.13085053861141205,
0.628959059715271,
-0.0006444925093092024,
0.5692640542984009,
0.577667236328125,
0.41501110792160034,
-0.20339025557041168,
0.11432584375143051,
0.9296945929527283,
-0.40704888105392456,
-0.7205402255058289,
-1.0126646757125854,
0.6704108715057373,
-0.288563072681427,
-0.1627407819032669,
0.6985074877738953,
0.623439610004425,
0.85347980260849,
-0.16130591928958893,
0.6358364224433899,
-0.13574694097042084,
0.44295310974121094,
-0.13585162162780762,
0.9955607056617737,
-0.5395550727844238,
0.08613966405391693,
-0.09963017702102661,
-0.9063138961791992,
-0.1080833449959755,
0.6711322069168091,
-0.11259044706821442,
-0.0357179194688797,
0.28045758605003357,
0.7256613373756409,
-0.001295464695431292,
0.021744059398770332,
0.3330895006656647,
0.3882254362106323,
0.21209461987018585,
0.09263714402914047,
0.45442265272140503,
-0.1277342140674591,
0.3224579691886902,
-0.27711206674575806,
-0.4118397533893585,
-0.45607686042785645,
-0.7233300805091858,
-0.93724125623703,
-0.7124695181846619,
-0.34264540672302246,
-0.12459482997655869,
-0.2392221838235855,
1.0001729726791382,
0.6308677196502686,
-0.63693767786026,
-0.17441271245479584,
-0.05497303977608681,
0.28395169973373413,
-0.16513194143772125,
-0.15258334577083588,
0.12812377512454987,
-0.07223618775606155,
-0.9798101782798767,
0.20470406115055084,
0.3589775562286377,
0.06777358800172806,
-0.38797369599342346,
-0.04605524614453316,
0.0036457364913076162,
0.10015654563903809,
0.5813331007957458,
0.09692776948213577,
-0.7159255146980286,
-0.2843111753463745,
-0.34716352820396423,
-0.22255106270313263,
-0.38549554347991943,
0.7110766172409058,
-0.5417643189430237,
0.9823467135429382,
0.4294171929359436,
0.43577840924263,
0.40067794919013977,
-0.30309411883354187,
0.741375744342804,
-0.6155068278312683,
-0.06887122243642807,
-0.0881090983748436,
0.5963967442512512,
0.5239731073379517,
-0.4132162034511566,
0.4957980513572693,
0.09925863146781921,
-0.4754878282546997,
-0.7502454519271851,
-0.03359716758131981,
-0.5518730878829956,
-0.2623281180858612,
0.8673946261405945,
-0.18853960931301117,
0.06154140084981918,
0.28576239943504333,
-0.3612239360809326,
0.5810556411743164,
-0.03110404498875141,
1.1369000673294067,
0.9944248795509338,
0.24801956117153168,
-0.10914721339941025,
-0.5145102739334106,
0.5263979434967041,
-0.1669769585132599,
-0.7374149560928345,
0.2465483844280243,
0.7546830773353577,
0.4061146080493927,
0.13665249943733215,
0.32581236958503723,
0.3360300362110138,
0.43168535828590393,
0.06052865460515022,
0.16633372008800507,
-0.2539365291595459,
-0.30088335275650024,
-0.27709776163101196,
0.06634248048067093,
0.2489330917596817,
0.16161677241325378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03414v1
|
Can Small Language Models Help Large Language Models Reason Better?: LM-Guided Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-04-04T12:46:37 | 2024-04-04T12:46:37 |
Jooyoung Lee, Fan Yang, Thanh Tran, Qian Hu, Emre Barut, Kai-Wei Chang, Chengwei Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce a novel framework, LM-Guided CoT, that leverages a lightweight
(i.e., <1B) language model (LM) for guiding a black-box large (i.e., >10B) LM
in reasoning tasks. Specifically, the lightweight LM first generates a
rationale for each input instance. The Frozen large LM is then prompted to
predict a task output based on the rationale generated by the lightweight LM.
Our approach is resource-efficient in the sense that it only requires training
the lightweight LM. We optimize the model through 1) knowledge distillation and
2) reinforcement learning from rationale-oriented and task-oriented reward
signals. We assess our method with multi-hop extractive question answering (QA)
benchmarks, HotpotQA, and 2WikiMultiHopQA. Experimental results show that our
approach outperforms all baselines regarding answer prediction accuracy. We
also find that reinforcement learning helps the model to produce higher-quality
rationales with improved QA performance.
|
[
-0.3197169005870819,
-1.0234811305999756,
1.1358132362365723,
-0.10926028341054916,
-0.2710612118244171,
-0.008997241035103798,
-0.5562690496444702,
-0.2845093011856079,
-0.15707840025424957,
0.6167583465576172,
-0.48159363865852356,
-0.2135031670331955,
-0.4974221885204315,
-0.059142231941223145,
-0.13005492091178894,
0.8585739135742188,
0.012471864931285381,
0.0948350802063942,
-0.07317955046892166,
-0.12109985947608948,
-0.6355747580528259,
-0.3637622892856598,
-1.0399473905563354,
-0.5117154717445374,
0.8498892188072205,
0.43269458413124084,
0.7229278087615967,
0.5939352512359619,
0.024637650698423386,
0.257271409034729,
-0.4784756600856781,
0.3904728591442108,
-0.3879242241382599,
-0.007657103706151247,
-0.597105860710144,
-0.7308241724967957,
-0.20699603855609894,
-0.24385161697864532,
0.15526182949543,
0.7629308700561523,
-0.24162593483924866,
0.14554810523986816,
0.013879992999136448,
0.7512315511703491,
-0.6041589975357056,
0.03501688316464424,
-0.7169830799102783,
-0.36480602622032166,
0.16291451454162598,
-0.06970231235027313,
-0.8055877685546875,
-0.2224349081516266,
-0.015013721771538258,
-0.31834182143211365,
-0.1776071935892105,
0.467187762260437,
0.5460962057113647,
0.30147585272789,
-0.5591253638267517,
-0.37851011753082275,
-0.7747535109519958,
1.0009472370147705,
-0.7760223150253296,
0.30213817954063416,
0.32297655940055847,
0.4101852476596832,
-0.2822461426258087,
-0.5759653449058533,
-0.590880811214447,
-0.19678854942321777,
0.0620238333940506,
-0.22657693922519684,
-0.01109178178012371,
0.07002221792936325,
0.3986915051937103,
0.18746033310890198,
-0.4375077486038208,
0.14671891927719116,
-0.344112366437912,
-0.034533265978097916,
0.5105454921722412,
0.048767685890197754,
0.14491678774356842,
0.059853777289390564,
-0.27276384830474854,
-0.06655094027519226,
-0.7112643122673035,
0.20818595588207245,
-0.10128294676542282,
0.33524104952812195,
0.10967124253511429,
0.45341452956199646,
-0.18394961953163147,
0.9444891810417175,
0.23652008175849915,
-0.38122040033340454,
-0.25457262992858887,
-0.1379532665014267,
-0.28746649622917175,
0.13502053916454315,
0.6440602540969849,
0.008355068042874336,
0.254252552986145,
-0.15065404772758484,
-0.40383243560791016,
0.11140169203281403,
0.11904118955135345,
-0.7981216907501221,
-0.38561612367630005,
0.19828324019908905,
-0.5060765147209167,
-0.28468436002731323,
-0.3277214765548706,
-0.48549705743789673,
-0.5835493206977844,
-0.600094199180603,
0.3323621153831482,
-0.4326879680156708,
-0.31234121322631836,
0.3728146255016327,
-0.09327947348356247,
0.2617082893848419,
0.535045862197876,
-0.8641551733016968,
0.27222931385040283,
0.6664770841598511,
0.6592298746109009,
-0.06220076605677605,
0.009320544078946114,
-1.0152353048324585,
0.11211415380239487,
-0.6400033831596375,
0.7343014478683472,
-0.39679384231567383,
0.08079309016466141,
-0.2723516821861267,
-0.09610696136951447,
0.061526503413915634,
-0.5221204161643982,
0.358169823884964,
-0.6378177404403687,
0.22164225578308105,
-0.49285125732421875,
-0.4511522352695465,
-0.19189666211605072,
0.4305751621723175,
-0.758616030216217,
0.762466549873352,
-0.011059116572141647,
-0.44458189606666565,
0.2779295742511749,
-0.3516632616519928,
-0.24736164510250092,
-0.03467462211847305,
-0.37903663516044617,
0.07272510230541229,
0.24143825471401215,
0.36273130774497986,
0.3152211606502533,
-0.7714626789093018,
0.434100478887558,
-0.37042859196662903,
-0.19966913759708405,
0.2772424817085266,
-0.37848228216171265,
0.6721162796020508,
0.405626505613327,
-0.4176913797855377,
0.27035707235336304,
-0.6594037413597107,
0.24838832020759583,
0.1933254599571228,
-0.3079381585121155,
-0.46557584404945374,
0.03526785224676132,
-0.2703748941421509,
0.5524461269378662,
0.08972202986478806,
-0.3347606658935547,
0.1622122973203659,
-0.4426013231277466,
0.41462376713752747,
0.8380674719810486,
-0.00127089221496135,
0.6024960875511169,
-0.22355161607265472,
0.5247943997383118,
0.06977815181016922,
-0.04123365879058838,
0.0589667484164238,
-0.3742084801197052,
-0.7643126249313354,
-0.20279748737812042,
0.30781522393226624,
0.2679072320461273,
-1.0621236562728882,
0.18103428184986115,
0.17816175520420074,
-0.4157710373401642,
-0.49496427178382874,
0.33203980326652527,
0.3696146607398987,
0.3878066837787628,
0.396187961101532,
0.11173533648252487,
-0.29410916566848755,
-0.7173455357551575,
-0.2541884779930115,
-0.19144868850708008,
0.08897597342729568,
0.11412766575813293,
0.3466717600822449,
-0.18551309406757355,
0.7812002301216125,
-0.52567458152771,
0.07452823221683502,
-0.7708349227905273,
0.13408194482326508,
0.3615676760673523,
0.32070106267929077,
0.2478972226381302,
-0.7939272522926331,
-0.27612558007240295,
0.03832828998565674,
-0.5470709204673767,
0.01758040115237236,
-0.14902378618717194,
-0.33905383944511414,
0.21116717159748077,
0.6103326678276062,
-0.7584331035614014,
0.10804224014282227,
0.31194448471069336,
-0.49862515926361084,
0.5120969414710999,
-0.22253498435020447,
-0.19471952319145203,
-1.096543550491333,
-0.1151033341884613,
-0.019921448081731796,
-0.4602266848087311,
-0.3676700294017792,
0.16099253296852112,
0.0159803107380867,
-0.07387559115886688,
-0.29729601740837097,
0.5957276821136475,
-0.4154943525791168,
0.11618809401988983,
-0.6446718573570251,
0.313070684671402,
0.14401040971279144,
0.7203032970428467,
0.15679751336574554,
0.5750022530555725,
0.3615647256374359,
-0.6413359045982361,
0.37228190898895264,
-0.11549591273069382,
-0.49943363666534424,
0.16768071055412292,
-0.7254302501678467,
0.1734258383512497,
-0.32429322600364685,
0.27466920018196106,
-0.6438339948654175,
0.05597357451915741,
0.04896565154194832,
-0.02379826456308365,
0.1303921937942505,
-0.1800806075334549,
-0.5568541884422302,
-0.2270851731300354,
-0.03189371898770332,
0.5326716303825378,
0.6461901068687439,
-0.8168039321899414,
0.629237174987793,
0.19829311966896057,
-0.1601695418357849,
-0.42261552810668945,
-0.6580762267112732,
-0.3387185037136078,
-0.149465873837471,
-0.3268986642360687,
-0.07269535213708878,
-0.1072654202580452,
-0.47328701615333557,
0.020463066175580025,
-0.2793131172657013,
-0.03727766126394272,
0.21278101205825806,
-0.057451263070106506,
0.2322443127632141,
-0.34102755784988403,
0.4736904203891754,
-0.07829168438911438,
-0.10143018513917923,
0.2082856148481369,
-0.6360206604003906,
0.6134765148162842,
-0.3522185683250427,
-0.11024592071771622,
-0.037410616874694824,
0.3360185921192169,
0.5434862375259399,
-0.1746320128440857,
0.8906755447387695,
0.40149158239364624,
-0.32275500893592834,
-0.7008045315742493,
-0.39844128489494324,
-0.3052629232406616,
-0.45169058442115784,
0.14516785740852356,
-0.40001216530799866,
-0.961094081401825,
0.22646383941173553,
-0.31083834171295166,
-0.12815652787685394,
0.32927173376083374,
0.6343470811843872,
0.030361302196979523,
1.3507400751113892,
0.7515082955360413,
-0.09760263562202454,
0.3537193238735199,
-0.23228050768375397,
0.5362920165061951,
-0.5888141989707947,
-0.20604471862316132,
-0.3615793287754059,
-0.19954568147659302,
-0.5026743412017822,
-0.6173012256622314,
0.0956118255853653,
0.5575282573699951,
-0.271564781665802,
0.14345921576023102,
-0.522838830947876,
0.7465865015983582,
0.4691195785999298,
0.06810136884450912,
0.22889018058776855,
-0.4499713182449341,
-0.47783657908439636,
0.4784103333950043,
-1.122187852859497,
-0.7583267688751221,
0.8120267391204834,
0.407344788312912,
0.9042970538139343,
0.09193088859319687,
0.6586037874221802,
0.10621073842048645,
0.24708794057369232,
-0.9139712452888489,
0.6474984884262085,
0.1514669805765152,
-0.609308660030365,
-0.36617928743362427,
-0.63619065284729,
-0.7092429399490356,
0.39984458684921265,
-0.10272198170423508,
-0.8947247862815857,
0.054997608065605164,
0.3171534538269043,
-0.3921077847480774,
0.3322094976902008,
-0.870201051235199,
1.0067195892333984,
-0.5902376174926758,
-0.5333479642868042,
-0.3915093243122101,
-0.38087207078933716,
0.5634061098098755,
0.06094684079289436,
0.36839962005615234,
-0.1563483625650406,
0.1549186408519745,
0.6648064255714417,
-0.5581912398338318,
0.6293098330497742,
-0.168110653758049,
-0.21083547174930573,
0.4710760712623596,
0.12130971997976303,
0.7481744885444641,
0.13221877813339233,
-0.09727460891008377,
-0.4129553735256195,
0.24522678554058075,
-0.5346386432647705,
-0.8145858645439148,
0.7120100855827332,
-0.576825737953186,
-0.732994019985199,
-0.4054509997367859,
-0.5673415660858154,
-0.31292104721069336,
0.1706804782152176,
0.05140407010912895,
0.5493525266647339,
0.1844673603773117,
0.26246726512908936,
0.9043928384780884,
-0.15808792412281036,
0.35368016362190247,
0.3933979272842407,
-0.40271618962287903,
-0.2313040792942047,
0.7582122087478638,
-0.2250289022922516,
0.4673622250556946,
0.47121331095695496,
0.5343044400215149,
-0.4451274275779724,
-0.4893921911716461,
-0.5115566253662109,
0.20117513835430145,
-1.0083237886428833,
-0.17651543021202087,
-0.45668044686317444,
-0.04367085546255112,
0.025843793526291847,
-0.13900114595890045,
-0.33070361614227295,
-0.40459802746772766,
-0.01797359809279442,
-0.10655341297388077,
0.28705912828445435,
0.7068483829498291,
0.29463180899620056,
0.15575093030929565,
-0.5390086770057678,
0.4222240149974823,
0.4554749131202698,
0.15804456174373627,
0.22785091400146484,
-0.3284546434879303,
-0.4209251403808594,
0.2686099708080292,
-0.22093473374843597,
-0.6632826924324036,
0.23493371903896332,
-0.3571835458278656,
0.48383989930152893,
0.24071572721004486,
0.35078439116477966,
0.59937584400177,
-0.3617505133152008,
0.7392343282699585,
0.4396916925907135,
-0.8653504848480225,
0.6810214519500732,
-0.09529833495616913,
0.5758683085441589,
0.6208812594413757,
0.21301713585853577,
-0.2953132688999176,
-0.5087469220161438,
-0.5845215320587158,
-0.766336977481842,
0.6685155630111694,
-0.07159430533647537,
-0.3744286298751831,
-0.16522327065467834,
0.2758193612098694,
0.1474909633398056,
0.16983237862586975,
-0.8471582531929016,
0.05342371016740799,
0.1798415333032608,
-0.38142380118370056,
-0.1868552565574646,
-0.2518575191497803,
-0.2042274922132492,
-0.16880740225315094,
0.8191124200820923,
-0.49469149112701416,
0.12080277502536774,
0.06134940683841705,
-0.2693563997745514,
-0.1721961796283722,
0.5267243981361389,
0.44215381145477295,
0.7930336594581604,
-0.09622069448232651,
0.46219000220298767,
0.2909514605998993,
0.15492534637451172,
0.17751039564609528,
-0.19388559460639954,
-0.057891685515642166,
-0.18982729315757751,
0.2869197130203247,
0.9402855038642883,
0.09419064223766327,
-0.8953256607055664,
0.3635336458683014,
-0.16677960753440857,
-0.1512824445962906,
-0.0413983054459095,
0.27486497163772583,
0.3205067813396454,
0.5925804972648621,
0.21948686242103577,
-0.0071358513087034225,
-0.03571654111146927,
-0.8085185289382935,
-0.03447049483656883,
0.4145515561103821,
-0.16249777376651764,
0.022842926904559135,
0.589683473110199,
0.16265758872032166,
-0.2312684953212738,
0.3166040778160095,
-0.21563205122947693,
-0.45639750361442566,
0.5742971301078796,
0.5622003674507141,
0.760553240776062,
0.24450865387916565,
0.1417408287525177,
0.25546491146087646,
0.26881498098373413,
-0.5360048413276672,
0.3211156725883484,
-0.3797098994255066,
-0.6640613675117493,
-0.6726416945457458,
-0.6292449235916138,
-0.4734133183956146,
0.32999080419540405,
-0.544671893119812,
0.19983412325382233,
-0.5159865021705627,
0.06624113768339157,
0.06612280756235123,
0.09140978008508682,
-0.6408556699752808,
0.3637661039829254,
0.2671068608760834,
0.960261881351471,
-0.5936048030853271,
1.1165565252304077,
0.6423318386077881,
-0.4641329348087311,
-1.2969088554382324,
0.026346663013100624,
-0.2527160346508026,
-0.5054715275764465,
0.6379245519638062,
0.21257902681827545,
-0.44467413425445557,
-0.1651662290096283,
-0.6278401017189026,
-0.8332812190055847,
1.026279330253601,
0.4567175507545471,
-0.8287636041641235,
-0.023807387799024582,
-0.1919456124305725,
0.47015896439552307,
-0.5442092418670654,
0.2637546956539154,
0.5795077085494995,
0.2531813979148865,
0.11978396773338318,
-0.7331705093383789,
0.21489457786083221,
-0.05013630911707878,
0.03555643931031227,
0.3725632131099701,
-0.5056853294372559,
0.6482577919960022,
-0.4415527284145355,
0.0026569971814751625,
0.05134820565581322,
0.5540666580200195,
0.7256152629852295,
0.48472005128860474,
0.6476595997810364,
0.30882230401039124,
0.9626956582069397,
0.023165659978985786,
1.0811666250228882,
-0.18127161264419556,
0.17047365009784698,
1.3014531135559082,
-0.27878299355506897,
0.89250648021698,
0.66041499376297,
0.2661328613758087,
0.7782411575317383,
0.5671041011810303,
0.5268315672874451,
0.6428393721580505,
0.2965429723262787,
-0.1288454681634903,
-0.5803045630455017,
0.02513732761144638,
-0.10647913813591003,
0.16925451159477234,
0.2134658843278885,
-0.33831050992012024,
-0.07223827391862869,
0.012649629265069962,
-0.04263225570321083,
0.3402741551399231,
-0.5805085897445679,
0.8870284557342529,
0.4009633958339691,
-0.9873467683792114,
0.842180073261261,
0.2045128047466278,
0.3099275529384613,
-0.5625025033950806,
0.13419492542743683,
-0.1069202870130539,
0.5270190834999084,
0.007371378596872091,
-0.5893406271934509,
0.06551122665405273,
0.13407017290592194,
-0.42887821793556213,
-0.44121572375297546,
0.8121301531791687,
-0.6801143288612366,
-0.42643648386001587,
0.3457675874233246,
0.7652957439422607,
-0.10656563937664032,
-0.00777351064607501,
-0.6413686871528625,
0.01745399460196495,
-0.08543405681848526,
-0.3176492154598236,
0.482444167137146,
0.8404976725578308,
-0.2513021230697632,
0.8705349564552307,
0.6052781939506531,
0.16170106828212738,
-0.12860706448554993,
0.06531789898872375,
1.0332622528076172,
-0.883024275302887,
-0.6737184524536133,
-0.8474028706550598,
0.33642467856407166,
-0.22959788143634796,
-0.006454097107052803,
0.4940418004989624,
0.3911913335323334,
0.7684616446495056,
-0.06459251791238785,
0.7157074809074402,
-0.025087591260671616,
0.3490404784679413,
-0.8375022411346436,
0.2812340557575226,
-0.5119256973266602,
0.47717249393463135,
0.0024837299715727568,
-0.8582141399383545,
0.10687211900949478,
0.6398406624794006,
-0.6163288950920105,
-0.033473577350378036,
1.1007550954818726,
0.7488768696784973,
0.07038892805576324,
0.08453024923801422,
0.3365086615085602,
0.10162260383367538,
0.34778985381126404,
0.9599737524986267,
1.0653011798858643,
-0.10665743798017502,
0.5719491243362427,
-0.2696149945259094,
-0.16843867301940918,
-0.11674235016107559,
-0.813027560710907,
-1.0984699726104736,
-0.3461349308490753,
-0.29611125588417053,
-0.38304266333580017,
-0.07301867008209229,
1.3003864288330078,
0.7320564389228821,
-0.744573175907135,
-0.22683675587177277,
-0.4988434612751007,
0.551683247089386,
-0.48096492886543274,
-0.21239490807056427,
0.11270216852426529,
-0.6178545355796814,
-0.35161373019218445,
0.514613151550293,
0.1966729760169983,
-0.28151288628578186,
-0.143086239695549,
-0.4344606399536133,
-0.21605607867240906,
0.34443339705467224,
0.8072332143783569,
0.11021517217159271,
-0.8652685284614563,
-0.3302396535873413,
-0.09732692688703537,
-0.19582709670066833,
-0.3347700238227844,
1.041771650314331,
-0.895157516002655,
0.3091724216938019,
0.33677247166633606,
0.7079996466636658,
0.5499539971351624,
-0.06680961698293686,
0.7629441618919373,
-0.42785629630088806,
0.24755944311618805,
0.4799416959285736,
0.4509718716144562,
0.09001020342111588,
-0.31804758310317993,
0.3733161389827728,
0.0015602041967213154,
-0.599982500076294,
-0.8575367331504822,
0.4254832863807678,
-1.0106009244918823,
-0.757610559463501,
1.5368521213531494,
0.03786109387874603,
-0.4749706983566284,
-0.048462413251399994,
-0.41800111532211304,
0.05569405108690262,
-0.3546769917011261,
0.7038899064064026,
0.7089101672172546,
-0.025453073903918266,
-0.6370545029640198,
-0.3614642024040222,
0.6557531952857971,
0.5074347853660583,
-0.9500647187232971,
0.26174846291542053,
0.5957217812538147,
0.206647127866745,
0.022094281390309334,
0.6186289191246033,
0.10515279322862625,
0.399233877658844,
-0.09248806536197662,
-0.15886373817920685,
-0.08870290964841843,
-0.4734536409378052,
-0.2358441948890686,
0.3044670522212982,
0.7160407900810242,
-0.04058725759387016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03411v1
|
Red Teaming GPT-4V: Are GPT-4V Safe Against Uni/Multi-Modal Jailbreak Attacks?
| 2024-04-04T12:38:14 | 2024-04-04T12:38:14 |
Shuo Chen, Zhen Han, Bailan He, Zifeng Ding, Wenqian Yu, Philip Torr, Volker Tresp, Jindong Gu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Various jailbreak attacks have been proposed to red-team Large Language
Models (LLMs) and revealed the vulnerable safeguards of LLMs. Besides, some
methods are not limited to the textual modality and extend the jailbreak attack
to Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) by perturbing the visual input.
However, the absence of a universal evaluation benchmark complicates the
performance reproduction and fair comparison. Besides, there is a lack of
comprehensive evaluation of closed-source state-of-the-art (SOTA) models,
especially MLLMs, such as GPT-4V. To address these issues, this work first
builds a comprehensive jailbreak evaluation dataset with 1445 harmful questions
covering 11 different safety policies. Based on this dataset, extensive
red-teaming experiments are conducted on 11 different LLMs and MLLMs, including
both SOTA proprietary models and open-source models. We then conduct a deep
analysis of the evaluated results and find that (1) GPT4 and GPT-4V demonstrate
better robustness against jailbreak attacks compared to open-source LLMs and
MLLMs. (2) Llama2 and Qwen-VL-Chat are more robust compared to other
open-source models. (3) The transferability of visual jailbreak methods is
relatively limited compared to textual jailbreak methods. The dataset and code
can be found here
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/red_teaming_gpt4-C1CE/README.md .
|
[
-0.2572636008262634,
-0.7633402943611145,
0.5041149258613586,
0.25473418831825256,
-0.12457140535116196,
0.2760762870311737,
-0.16512635350227356,
-0.656123161315918,
-0.16966933012008667,
0.5100888013839722,
-0.5020646452903748,
-0.4686456620693207,
-0.40596380829811096,
0.2649262249469757,
-0.2455918788909912,
1.2610968351364136,
-0.1852867305278778,
0.0036441078409552574,
0.14401909708976746,
-0.31458792090415955,
-0.820965588092804,
-0.8307643532752991,
-0.11588460952043533,
0.20680171251296997,
0.16548024117946625,
0.20940788090229034,
0.3924475312232971,
0.09232448041439056,
0.8171048164367676,
0.3288094401359558,
0.08542375266551971,
-0.32041800022125244,
-0.6177566647529602,
0.29255178570747375,
0.04970411956310272,
-0.34774574637413025,
-0.41241928935050964,
0.19099953770637512,
0.31641653180122375,
-0.27470314502716064,
-0.17428873479366302,
-0.03186526522040367,
-0.2739279270172119,
0.6175004243850708,
-0.5940039753913879,
-0.055184412747621536,
-0.8783124089241028,
-0.14703501760959625,
-0.3724006712436676,
0.13881172239780426,
-0.2821618616580963,
-0.2595464289188385,
0.015213859267532825,
-0.2881562113761902,
-0.11215944588184357,
0.025243228301405907,
0.645980179309845,
0.21462000906467438,
-0.32240936160087585,
0.06259322166442871,
-0.4480554461479187,
0.6990803480148315,
-0.7855733633041382,
0.19655650854110718,
0.3224504590034485,
0.5481641888618469,
-0.05460148677229881,
-0.6684630513191223,
-0.4016820788383484,
-0.45125481486320496,
0.22321435809135437,
0.25810250639915466,
-0.3517715036869049,
0.31170663237571716,
0.14969398081302643,
0.025775667279958725,
-0.5301700830459595,
0.19671593606472015,
-0.5226312875747681,
-0.2885318398475647,
0.49056339263916016,
0.18942610919475555,
0.5550558567047119,
-0.1575544774532318,
-0.8140013217926025,
0.22188147902488708,
-0.848064124584198,
-0.1776505559682846,
0.4123179018497467,
0.05090833455324173,
-0.3960445821285248,
0.5106924772262573,
-0.0016876091249287128,
0.6499955654144287,
-0.2553043067455292,
-0.14683936536312103,
0.2683295011520386,
-1.1295795440673828,
-0.31378135085105896,
-0.28092047572135925,
1.0238407850265503,
0.756470799446106,
0.36227312684059143,
-0.38292044401168823,
-0.2061900645494461,
0.13758040964603424,
0.4190366864204407,
-0.8457680940628052,
-0.41584697365760803,
0.24162083864212036,
-0.3194464147090912,
-0.5379054546356201,
0.07225552946329117,
-0.8300049304962158,
-0.3150251805782318,
0.23203250765800476,
0.40842559933662415,
-0.43810611963272095,
-0.3334079086780548,
-0.1555149406194687,
-0.207097128033638,
0.18705156445503235,
0.19770973920822144,
-0.952877938747406,
0.3396610915660858,
0.42012733221054077,
0.8990158438682556,
-0.46010327339172363,
-0.4264149069786072,
-0.34698376059532166,
0.15501926839351654,
0.06937823444604874,
0.5610944032669067,
-0.34596332907676697,
-0.16390801966190338,
-0.3256503641605377,
-0.18000327050685883,
-0.1611713171005249,
-0.37552398443222046,
0.17611026763916016,
-0.6906144022941589,
0.018072178587317467,
-0.23394788801670074,
-0.35961994528770447,
-0.12906670570373535,
0.6597676277160645,
-0.8488789796829224,
0.46640411019325256,
-0.13117176294326782,
-1.0676666498184204,
0.3642597794532776,
-0.9180669188499451,
-0.2043515145778656,
0.053691573441028595,
-0.265959233045578,
-0.613516092300415,
-0.3575636148452759,
0.16833440959453583,
0.43202218413352966,
-0.1877206563949585,
0.1291792392730713,
-0.41794711351394653,
-0.22047775983810425,
0.2871873378753662,
-0.44144999980926514,
0.7080662846565247,
0.2969154417514801,
-0.7249326109886169,
0.5370258688926697,
-0.29968929290771484,
0.15271058678627014,
0.18460166454315186,
-0.2991456687450409,
-0.30780935287475586,
-0.2583674490451813,
0.16681142151355743,
0.17650935053825378,
0.21145324409008026,
-0.8027521371841431,
0.1332741528749466,
-0.13320276141166687,
0.9264798164367676,
0.7083936929702759,
0.1455531120300293,
0.3261803686618805,
0.08077588677406311,
0.5951170325279236,
-0.21137285232543945,
0.5627327561378479,
0.01423356682062149,
-0.5487620830535889,
0.019164538010954857,
-0.4953586161136627,
0.31248825788497925,
0.6955521702766418,
-0.7248030304908752,
-0.0801764577627182,
0.33595147728919983,
-0.38771337270736694,
-0.15312574803829193,
0.05395723879337311,
0.6238709688186646,
0.16326549649238586,
0.4423092007637024,
-0.21614158153533936,
-0.5874817967414856,
-0.8185600638389587,
-0.252542108297348,
-0.06585023552179337,
0.3960673213005066,
0.17053602635860443,
0.801021158695221,
-0.36735841631889343,
0.7059019207954407,
-0.06015176698565483,
-0.1619378626346588,
-0.4404310882091522,
-0.10626766085624695,
-0.024118274450302124,
0.4045584201812744,
0.817943274974823,
-0.854664146900177,
-0.3816678822040558,
-0.1389586627483368,
-0.8395862579345703,
0.009670709259808064,
0.04467502608895302,
0.22929488122463226,
0.37582001090049744,
0.398385614156723,
-0.43015921115875244,
0.5342163443565369,
0.9764257669448853,
-0.5634908676147461,
0.8359300494194031,
-0.12481128424406052,
0.39206060767173767,
-0.8422061800956726,
-0.02036510407924652,
0.09105882793664932,
-0.3050483167171478,
-0.8738828897476196,
0.39883413910865784,
0.22420646250247955,
0.04652119055390358,
-0.6450187563896179,
0.16728368401527405,
-0.48479339480400085,
-0.29377707839012146,
-0.07465951889753342,
0.12386558204889297,
-0.2514924108982086,
0.21459877490997314,
-0.360337495803833,
1.131640911102295,
0.32501381635665894,
-0.11695898324251175,
0.5333950519561768,
0.04285217449069023,
-0.37234172224998474,
0.088405542075634,
-0.8344103693962097,
0.20531319081783295,
0.45718419551849365,
0.10704871267080307,
-0.7278780341148376,
-0.08441228419542313,
0.2658601999282837,
-0.22513829171657562,
0.21674109995365143,
-0.23521040380001068,
-0.5274484753608704,
-0.13675101101398468,
-0.6392910480499268,
0.5662936568260193,
0.25690606236457825,
-0.332332968711853,
-0.03138260543346405,
0.7768460512161255,
-0.0967094823718071,
-0.68571537733078,
-0.5158162117004395,
0.430650919675827,
-0.5963653922080994,
-0.8038875460624695,
0.25518545508384705,
-0.12767380475997925,
-0.5145031809806824,
-0.17226725816726685,
-0.1350862830877304,
-0.4228936433792114,
0.3608928620815277,
0.23965787887573242,
0.7062596082687378,
0.14326053857803345,
-0.4395025968551636,
-0.45472246408462524,
-0.1534590721130371,
0.10228845477104187,
0.04546813294291496,
0.3870965242385864,
-0.7881408333778381,
-0.16241241991519928,
-0.4119243323802948,
0.24669022858142853,
0.8531640768051147,
-0.3453323245048523,
0.6865156888961792,
0.4134298861026764,
-0.005843428894877434,
0.3349669277667999,
-0.6002374887466431,
-0.27188238501548767,
-0.40549713373184204,
0.40544193983078003,
-0.2997608780860901,
-1.2515101432800293,
0.40073591470718384,
0.14187875390052795,
0.08202636241912842,
0.08977223187685013,
0.7275899648666382,
-0.14737220108509064,
0.6348621249198914,
0.7271739840507507,
-0.252214252948761,
0.42554476857185364,
-0.034065090119838715,
0.045046620070934296,
-0.5961079597473145,
-0.3287985324859619,
-0.1933307945728302,
-0.08345084637403488,
-0.5284257531166077,
-0.24291113018989563,
0.49202364683151245,
0.038585249334573746,
-0.42498910427093506,
0.5740855932235718,
-0.4182393550872803,
0.6126492023468018,
0.37861892580986023,
-0.0975833535194397,
0.40633463859558105,
-0.24490314722061157,
-0.2611609697341919,
-0.16714362800121307,
-0.5300033688545227,
-0.3038311004638672,
1.269963026046753,
0.5621940493583679,
0.9165036678314209,
0.43324750661849976,
0.7158099412918091,
0.26463940739631653,
0.1652693748474121,
-0.36193734407424927,
0.4024014472961426,
0.16117289662361145,
-0.8549941778182983,
-0.39762890338897705,
-0.4898320138454437,
-0.84210205078125,
0.28062495589256287,
-0.3805900812149048,
-0.8068150281906128,
-0.3177488148212433,
0.06120996177196503,
-0.3803519308567047,
0.3781086504459381,
-0.9055708646774292,
1.149123191833496,
-0.6006667017936707,
-0.39629554748535156,
-0.1377079039812088,
-0.958082914352417,
0.8928282260894775,
-0.3520970046520233,
0.18922802805900574,
-0.015741627663373947,
0.1496920883655548,
0.7733139395713806,
-0.6361790895462036,
0.8281557559967041,
-0.20954325795173645,
0.17947536706924438,
0.20669101178646088,
0.000179828071850352,
0.48698580265045166,
0.19376645982265472,
0.3096421957015991,
0.5234894752502441,
-0.024654000997543335,
-0.09303928166627884,
-0.3376651108264923,
0.786009669303894,
-0.8695992827415466,
-0.6387348175048828,
-0.3966350853443146,
-0.5754533410072327,
-0.040883101522922516,
0.3004789352416992,
0.18174397945404053,
0.2933741509914398,
0.009196176193654537,
0.13969482481479645,
0.4036582410335541,
-0.20013727247714996,
0.6100441217422485,
0.40547487139701843,
-0.21966780722141266,
-0.585191011428833,
0.5776978731155396,
-0.0768565908074379,
0.5126464366912842,
-0.03820601478219032,
0.005931573454290628,
-0.27372634410858154,
-0.9198946952819824,
-0.5651178359985352,
0.19737690687179565,
-0.34491705894470215,
-0.37288030982017517,
-0.3223963677883148,
-0.14388412237167358,
-0.3109898269176483,
0.03462033346295357,
-0.49131840467453003,
-0.2526895999908447,
0.1648929864168167,
-0.3130011558532715,
0.6378344297409058,
0.9137641787528992,
-0.06981401890516281,
-0.05683431774377823,
-0.8574545979499817,
0.32056644558906555,
0.3631261885166168,
0.33784547448158264,
-0.48565682768821716,
-0.17381590604782104,
-0.007189391180872917,
-0.24587027728557587,
-0.20459304749965668,
-1.1556587219238281,
0.3291776180267334,
-0.4065631926059723,
0.5690934062004089,
0.030952047556638718,
0.07496994733810425,
0.5415523052215576,
-0.6384403705596924,
0.7275870442390442,
0.6325048208236694,
-0.8836649060249329,
0.541346549987793,
-0.5664685368537903,
-0.1626807600259781,
0.8165346384048462,
0.007551230955868959,
-0.012181720696389675,
-0.32752642035484314,
-0.5291644334793091,
-0.7784621119499207,
0.5144138932228088,
0.622258186340332,
-0.19036909937858582,
0.17362217605113983,
0.24073819816112518,
-0.09638439118862152,
0.27964654564857483,
-1.1383358240127563,
-0.26037779450416565,
-0.5430781841278076,
0.06517727673053741,
0.3205568194389343,
-0.3164834976196289,
-0.2827428877353668,
-0.0802675262093544,
0.14355608820915222,
0.27001723647117615,
0.14666485786437988,
-0.05468649044632912,
0.018308980390429497,
0.265544056892395,
0.4914933443069458,
0.9203332662582397,
0.5351454615592957,
-0.3698647916316986,
0.046461984515190125,
0.3682069778442383,
-0.6677079796791077,
0.3561764061450958,
-0.028094684705138206,
0.025719475001096725,
-0.39644351601600647,
0.28790104389190674,
0.629118025302887,
0.20888037979602814,
-0.7189955115318298,
0.9331731796264648,
-0.34483107924461365,
-0.2990990877151489,
-0.34114396572113037,
0.030848780646920204,
-0.11301951855421066,
0.5105212926864624,
-0.05543407425284386,
0.35257381200790405,
-0.11892746388912201,
-0.623921811580658,
0.2379266917705536,
0.6151107549667358,
-0.27194303274154663,
-0.5058164596557617,
0.8728796243667603,
0.5538544058799744,
-0.04550793766975403,
0.5573351383209229,
0.012697083875536919,
-0.7028705477714539,
0.5173736214637756,
0.7261182069778442,
0.7065122723579407,
-0.2226511538028717,
-0.02626691199839115,
0.03210535645484924,
0.7436297535896301,
-0.05087657272815704,
0.16698075830936432,
0.08666025102138519,
-0.8642247319221497,
-0.6800551414489746,
-0.1315368115901947,
-0.4244880676269531,
0.3363730013370514,
-0.5427209138870239,
-0.030876893550157547,
-0.4817134737968445,
-0.2688656449317932,
-0.4747209846973419,
-0.24523533880710602,
-0.2783545255661011,
-0.07647276669740677,
0.1752844601869583,
0.8978289365768433,
-0.8360294103622437,
1.0015531778335571,
0.6569119095802307,
-0.36824676394462585,
-0.7494723200798035,
-0.020761985331773758,
0.2668391466140747,
-0.7467633485794067,
0.7596539258956909,
0.2868208587169647,
-0.16388092935085297,
-0.17084014415740967,
-0.4586721658706665,
-0.787768542766571,
1.1947351694107056,
0.3869386613368988,
-0.7051759362220764,
-0.030639030039310455,
-0.2938103675842285,
0.1410675197839737,
-0.022561771795153618,
0.23009464144706726,
0.8186849355697632,
0.6883239150047302,
-0.239630788564682,
-1.2579734325408936,
0.11426097899675369,
-0.1999780237674713,
-0.2906528413295746,
0.3268759846687317,
-0.625079870223999,
0.791074812412262,
-0.6724374890327454,
-0.10595954954624176,
0.014999032020568848,
0.175376757979393,
0.6353607773780823,
0.2139299362897873,
0.46870893239974976,
0.669236421585083,
0.44301509857177734,
-0.08561231940984726,
1.1214662790298462,
-0.20239557325839996,
0.3112606108188629,
0.9215120673179626,
-0.3397965431213379,
0.7459896206855774,
0.4946168065071106,
-0.11043179035186768,
0.20106831192970276,
0.15583598613739014,
-0.31623125076293945,
0.8846390843391418,
0.1558595448732376,
-0.2157723307609558,
-0.06552902609109879,
0.5991103053092957,
-0.3246428370475769,
0.4551043212413788,
0.0695163756608963,
-0.0036821558605879545,
-0.17059533298015594,
0.11889670789241791,
0.3085208535194397,
-0.1320018768310547,
-0.24882853031158447,
0.7385294437408447,
-0.046710021793842316,
-0.42668354511260986,
0.5859742760658264,
0.12857255339622498,
0.9162279367446899,
-0.5720086693763733,
0.1018420159816742,
-0.01916004717350006,
0.03404757380485535,
-0.2572433054447174,
-0.8702811002731323,
0.22831976413726807,
0.5773385167121887,
-0.004048043861985207,
-0.012686280533671379,
0.8072929978370667,
-0.031162982806563377,
0.1251034289598465,
0.4441975951194763,
0.41849011182785034,
0.19622670114040375,
-0.05390123277902603,
-0.8586885929107666,
0.4080100357532501,
0.30258050560951233,
-0.22149807214736938,
0.6597168445587158,
-0.11830666661262512,
-0.10804335027933121,
0.7071884870529175,
0.6038923859596252,
0.06264439225196838,
0.2802107632160187,
0.1016598492860794,
1.0335661172866821,
-0.908820629119873,
-0.22865502536296844,
-1.2489006519317627,
0.4361222982406616,
-0.19560620188713074,
-0.11019778996706009,
1.0489592552185059,
0.2730671465396881,
0.5422298908233643,
0.12371232360601425,
1.0179063081741333,
0.008217611350119114,
0.06484648585319519,
-0.7427608370780945,
0.9409603476524353,
-0.036845091730356216,
0.46486878395080566,
-0.6123340725898743,
-0.6470205783843994,
-0.4510578513145447,
0.5960692763328552,
-0.31617188453674316,
0.043704256415367126,
0.7989227771759033,
0.5495195388793945,
0.3142080307006836,
0.17012424767017365,
0.39973679184913635,
0.36984676122665405,
0.5859779715538025,
0.5187437534332275,
1.026059865951538,
-0.18857111036777496,
0.791181206703186,
-0.0006984001374803483,
-0.43811580538749695,
-0.03644069284200668,
-0.8907231688499451,
-1.0938127040863037,
-0.23586158454418182,
-0.1396699696779251,
-0.2250763326883316,
0.3111167848110199,
0.483716756105423,
0.5960963368415833,
-0.6088321208953857,
-0.0393873006105423,
-0.22505594789981842,
-0.11249812692403793,
0.09487304091453552,
-0.20394693315029144,
-0.01367587223649025,
-0.2944178581237793,
-0.25590142607688904,
0.7984536290168762,
0.5644071102142334,
0.026548095047473907,
-0.157495379447937,
-0.09369536489248276,
-0.05839095637202263,
-0.4647740125656128,
0.5498742461204529,
0.30713728070259094,
-0.807807445526123,
-0.4171501696109772,
-0.11705528199672699,
-0.10572363436222076,
-0.025152772665023804,
0.6446934938430786,
-0.6779391765594482,
0.3991633355617523,
0.16588973999023438,
0.592433512210846,
0.4358094036579132,
0.10661780089139938,
0.6130801439285278,
-0.47772496938705444,
0.06929921358823776,
0.18345411121845245,
0.5460511445999146,
0.13265444338321686,
-0.0917702466249466,
0.5834946632385254,
0.3139618933200836,
-0.8711179494857788,
-0.8679423332214355,
0.2610014081001282,
-0.9313099384307861,
-0.3224128186702728,
1.3411469459533691,
-0.30924487113952637,
-0.04658076912164688,
-0.532788872718811,
-0.15035884082317352,
-0.15001779794692993,
-0.41378098726272583,
0.5822603702545166,
0.3011152148246765,
-0.2537335753440857,
-0.1917066127061844,
-0.897189736366272,
0.41378703713417053,
0.10025601834058762,
-0.9157095551490784,
0.11620078235864639,
0.4653046727180481,
0.7179303169250488,
-0.04212537035346031,
0.6139319539070129,
-0.409506231546402,
0.45573166012763977,
-0.18265578150749207,
0.07830708473920822,
-0.5086420178413391,
-0.43567904829978943,
-0.2710573375225067,
0.3570156991481781,
0.005588668864220381,
-0.29012343287467957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01563v1
|
Mitigating LLM Hallucinations via Conformal Abstention
| 2024-04-04T11:32:03 | 2024-04-04T11:32:03 |
Yasin Abbasi Yadkori, Ilja Kuzborskij, David Stutz, András György, Adam Fisch, Arnaud Doucet, Iuliya Beloshapka, Wei-Hung Weng, Yao-Yuan Yang, Csaba Szepesvári, Ali Taylan Cemgil, Nenad Tomasev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We develop a principled procedure for determining when a large language model
(LLM) should abstain from responding (e.g., by saying "I don't know") in a
general domain, instead of resorting to possibly "hallucinating" a non-sensical
or incorrect answer. Building on earlier approaches that use self-consistency
as a more reliable measure of model confidence, we propose using the LLM itself
to self-evaluate the similarity between each of its sampled responses for a
given query. We then further leverage conformal prediction techniques to
develop an abstention procedure that benefits from rigorous theoretical
guarantees on the hallucination rate (error rate). Experimentally, our
resulting conformal abstention method reliably bounds the hallucination rate on
various closed-book, open-domain generative question answering datasets, while
also maintaining a significantly less conservative abstention rate on a dataset
with long responses (Temporal Sequences) compared to baselines using
log-probability scores to quantify uncertainty, while achieveing comparable
performance on a dataset with short answers (TriviaQA). To evaluate the
experiments automatically, one needs to determine if two responses are
equivalent given a question. Following standard practice, we use a thresholded
similarity function to determine if two responses match, but also provide a
method for calibrating the threshold based on conformal prediction, with
theoretical guarantees on the accuracy of the match prediction, which might be
of independent interest.
|
[
-0.6014299392700195,
-0.9775878190994263,
0.7820249795913696,
0.3501996099948883,
-0.24917688965797424,
-0.2646239101886749,
-0.3027634918689728,
-0.4736033082008362,
0.306667298078537,
0.5901226997375488,
-0.676530659198761,
-0.41774535179138184,
-0.30244722962379456,
0.3776135742664337,
-0.48448076844215393,
0.5627545714378357,
0.0945410206913948,
0.1494825780391693,
-0.5201669931411743,
0.07021801918745041,
-0.500281035900116,
-0.44437476992607117,
-0.41873571276664734,
-0.30441057682037354,
0.3288222551345825,
0.1921219676733017,
0.5271472334861755,
0.5424924492835999,
0.5918774008750916,
0.1733633279800415,
-0.10805711895227432,
-0.03129471838474274,
-0.638890266418457,
0.32282474637031555,
-0.16872230172157288,
-0.5119137763977051,
-0.27607616782188416,
-0.31149986386299133,
0.4922545254230499,
0.6414799690246582,
-0.2719150483608246,
0.04857426881790161,
0.17293542623519897,
0.5941384434700012,
-0.5993021726608276,
0.03504074737429619,
-1.0040639638900757,
0.12321405112743378,
0.09043841063976288,
-0.23042768239974976,
-0.4754043221473694,
-0.42785969376564026,
-0.11354699730873108,
-0.514883279800415,
0.38485532999038696,
0.055828772485256195,
0.5864080190658569,
0.5578868389129639,
0.0111607750877738,
-0.3285601735115051,
-0.7892014384269714,
0.5702134370803833,
-0.7630571722984314,
0.49959152936935425,
0.8386693000793457,
0.24571821093559265,
-0.14008179306983948,
-0.38082510232925415,
-0.6377057433128357,
-0.5524715185165405,
-0.18922537565231323,
0.15407301485538483,
-0.04507340118288994,
0.11699653416872025,
0.23287935554981232,
0.4046393930912018,
-0.9491581916809082,
-0.027714405208826065,
-0.5212991833686829,
-0.2791723608970642,
0.507416844367981,
0.14816220104694366,
-0.053697969764471054,
-0.019427848979830742,
-0.3347749412059784,
-0.013739499263465405,
-0.8309022188186646,
-0.3393169641494751,
0.3051645755767822,
0.2678121030330658,
0.24643541872501373,
0.7078385949134827,
-0.26607397198677063,
0.5120431780815125,
0.2658480703830719,
0.1883433610200882,
0.022053053602576256,
0.03798743337392807,
-0.29575997591018677,
0.14943790435791016,
0.6675534248352051,
0.47374048829078674,
0.5863272547721863,
-0.2888035476207733,
-0.32593923807144165,
0.1946811079978943,
0.5757399201393127,
-0.7563574314117432,
-0.25541067123413086,
0.4193675220012665,
-0.3024897575378418,
0.05026262253522873,
0.14596277475357056,
-0.7903148531913757,
-0.35960114002227783,
-0.3468496799468994,
0.5812326669692993,
-0.40531596541404724,
-0.08126655966043472,
0.16655971109867096,
0.2787865400314331,
0.27573075890541077,
0.2711833715438843,
-0.9254233837127686,
0.6118034720420837,
0.7633543014526367,
0.9039872884750366,
-0.42568591237068176,
0.01744723692536354,
-0.3227715492248535,
0.09526343643665314,
-0.5035884976387024,
0.7271174192428589,
-0.31341680884361267,
-0.6791459321975708,
-0.1614898443222046,
0.027226345613598824,
0.00006519586167996749,
-0.8155640363693237,
0.30111613869667053,
-0.4667506814002991,
-0.0602107010781765,
-0.14980478584766388,
-0.8075633645057678,
-0.28472813963890076,
0.3338076174259186,
-0.7643027901649475,
0.6647117137908936,
-0.06737163662910461,
-0.5772314071655273,
-0.04907992109656334,
-0.26242688298225403,
-0.33436375856399536,
-0.034681763499975204,
-0.24606119096279144,
-0.5026878714561462,
0.25847935676574707,
0.13461045920848846,
0.26608043909072876,
-0.17408311367034912,
0.010270558297634125,
-0.49855145812034607,
-0.518683135509491,
0.25139135122299194,
-0.2955554127693176,
0.42873117327690125,
0.26519903540611267,
-0.3648390769958496,
0.1483558863401413,
-0.37163999676704407,
0.24156421422958374,
-0.029272079467773438,
0.17474450170993805,
-0.31637370586395264,
-0.19247223436832428,
-0.2551206648349762,
-0.08280158042907715,
0.1392064094543457,
-0.4650925099849701,
0.06621786952018738,
-0.5187071561813354,
0.06040162965655327,
0.9023719429969788,
0.27969157695770264,
0.08532599359750748,
-0.7461773157119751,
0.5421732068061829,
-0.16113720834255219,
0.09913889318704605,
0.0721459910273552,
-0.503654956817627,
-0.6313738822937012,
-0.05732912942767143,
0.01748594641685486,
0.571658730506897,
-0.2580384910106659,
0.7045297026634216,
-0.1559189260005951,
-0.463613361120224,
-0.6753816604614258,
0.11479629576206207,
0.4851274788379669,
0.594419002532959,
0.6544519066810608,
-0.31917813420295715,
-0.5518804788589478,
-0.9698347449302673,
-0.0946844071149826,
-0.44039931893348694,
-0.267758846282959,
0.21320079267024994,
0.48042649030685425,
-0.0028094316367059946,
0.7474521398544312,
-0.6531499028205872,
-0.4856718182563782,
0.10991042852401733,
0.07847398519515991,
-0.008540618233382702,
0.35087326169013977,
0.2349192053079605,
-0.768936038017273,
-0.4697345793247223,
-0.15775066614151,
-0.823477029800415,
-0.12199661135673523,
-0.13057231903076172,
0.1383427232503891,
0.3596639037132263,
0.6136731505393982,
-0.5253942012786865,
0.6641543507575989,
0.4247087240219116,
-0.10219384729862213,
0.5722230076789856,
-0.16264720261096954,
0.3185954689979553,
-0.8985191583633423,
0.0586216039955616,
-0.14591747522354126,
-0.11956997215747833,
-0.523581326007843,
0.01219560019671917,
0.07194335758686066,
0.4345114827156067,
-0.24795709550380707,
0.5952455401420593,
-0.32115843892097473,
0.023602087050676346,
-0.39290931820869446,
0.23327228426933289,
-0.1695963740348816,
0.38030073046684265,
0.22149249911308289,
0.8403343558311462,
0.43238627910614014,
-0.7688244581222534,
0.1828460395336151,
0.41092556715011597,
-0.2498798966407776,
0.5143948793411255,
-0.7811243534088135,
0.3823646306991577,
-0.29610881209373474,
-0.06465674191713333,
-1.0895674228668213,
0.013564812950789928,
0.38477566838264465,
-0.6768918633460999,
0.10577324032783508,
0.06093888729810715,
-0.12335207313299179,
-0.2377217411994934,
-0.3985288739204407,
0.365807443857193,
0.5995929837226868,
-0.31806665658950806,
0.3675709366798401,
0.05938003957271576,
-0.168231800198555,
-0.5664464831352234,
-0.7291341423988342,
-0.15535689890384674,
-0.25749671459198,
-0.302572637796402,
0.3652364909648895,
-0.6666633486747742,
-0.4522686302661896,
-0.11135256290435791,
-0.4187670946121216,
0.011336308903992176,
0.13285283744335175,
0.4068540632724762,
0.2510456144809723,
-0.1278318166732788,
0.25083696842193604,
-0.0590251125395298,
0.06082353740930557,
0.25037315487861633,
-0.22236935794353485,
0.699317455291748,
-0.19082042574882507,
-0.6174042820930481,
-0.4133690893650055,
0.209872767329216,
0.42413368821144104,
0.09506319463253021,
0.6890984773635864,
0.2093043029308319,
-0.5667194128036499,
-0.09183360636234283,
-0.8180589079856873,
-0.79314124584198,
-0.45215779542922974,
0.16899487376213074,
-0.7463878393173218,
-0.7803590297698975,
0.7545517683029175,
0.35726436972618103,
-0.2637209892272949,
0.2999641001224518,
0.7899138331413269,
0.006964846979826689,
0.5407548546791077,
0.5432154536247253,
0.12752412259578705,
0.00559964869171381,
0.05598597228527069,
0.19681301712989807,
-0.8542349934577942,
-0.3226499855518341,
-0.5098823308944702,
-0.03632763773202896,
-0.4312259554862976,
-0.40816184878349304,
0.27541688084602356,
0.09099113941192627,
0.04412039369344711,
0.31717801094055176,
-0.5103532075881958,
0.5164214372634888,
0.2829110622406006,
0.17323432862758636,
0.428256094455719,
-0.11646857112646103,
-0.059071991592645645,
-0.08994236588478088,
-0.0856185257434845,
-0.425007164478302,
1.1046775579452515,
0.21489503979682922,
1.079402208328247,
0.12562014162540436,
0.7552247643470764,
0.3451903760433197,
0.5575697422027588,
-0.9292609095573425,
0.5830448269844055,
0.18638233840465546,
-0.6416431069374084,
-0.6954801678657532,
-0.5239067673683167,
-0.7733522057533264,
0.2303406149148941,
-0.003037304151803255,
-0.8848769664764404,
0.0474744588136673,
0.04716798663139343,
-0.325785368680954,
0.2664984464645386,
-0.21445618569850922,
0.43175145983695984,
0.029912486672401428,
-0.23853278160095215,
-0.12925086915493011,
-0.5445815920829773,
0.4994809627532959,
-0.5212201476097107,
-0.13740363717079163,
-0.14565929770469666,
0.05228676646947861,
0.6525498032569885,
-0.055402833968400955,
0.8511040806770325,
0.13816392421722412,
-0.25732851028442383,
0.28740906715393066,
0.5505958795547485,
0.36662495136260986,
0.045361850410699844,
-0.25112834572792053,
0.2765685021877289,
0.3019424080848694,
-0.042193636298179626,
-0.8572143912315369,
0.666021466255188,
-0.5334776043891907,
-1.027904748916626,
-0.14254018664360046,
-0.6107321977615356,
-0.20586639642715454,
-0.015153774991631508,
0.3544289767742157,
-0.09421620517969131,
-0.4654141664505005,
0.21950185298919678,
0.8320826888084412,
0.15125899016857147,
0.12516216933727264,
0.5661858320236206,
-0.3895494043827057,
-0.4704663157463074,
0.40765300393104553,
-0.03998585790395737,
0.47446686029434204,
0.44797027111053467,
0.25112637877464294,
-0.6695548295974731,
-0.5450325608253479,
-0.09328226745128632,
0.41999974846839905,
-0.8027005195617676,
-0.33466973900794983,
-0.5417218208312988,
-0.4026162028312683,
-0.8449206352233887,
0.05583517253398895,
-0.19774609804153442,
-0.4605289697647095,
-0.1521085649728775,
-0.23456990718841553,
0.2640897035598755,
0.7788280844688416,
-0.15188725292682648,
0.056073129177093506,
-0.42307350039482117,
0.5176621079444885,
0.11955076456069946,
0.27334821224212646,
-0.0664496123790741,
-0.8784178495407104,
0.15418437123298645,
0.162502720952034,
-0.26174551248550415,
-0.9913773536682129,
0.5018226504325867,
0.21719571948051453,
0.771760106086731,
0.5537256002426147,
0.5630993247032166,
0.6924414038658142,
-0.4778151512145996,
0.4880291819572449,
0.13728855550289154,
-0.9782944321632385,
0.5944726467132568,
0.14007194340229034,
-0.05069177225232124,
0.5742803812026978,
0.668505847454071,
-0.641732931137085,
-0.8034506440162659,
-0.3854604959487915,
-0.5701125860214233,
0.18897534906864166,
0.36774981021881104,
0.11030859500169754,
-0.18049034476280212,
0.6367961168289185,
0.21592535078525543,
0.1856629103422165,
-0.8181310892105103,
-0.2459714412689209,
-0.06018092855811119,
-0.23634405434131622,
-0.14036999642848969,
-0.2529744505882263,
-0.4422204792499542,
-0.20384252071380615,
0.6419650912284851,
-0.2777827978134155,
0.25326257944107056,
0.5285168290138245,
-0.08762452006340027,
-0.3332206606864929,
0.17774589359760284,
0.8583992123603821,
0.8694911003112793,
-0.4768182933330536,
0.338852196931839,
0.3189658522605896,
-0.6441901326179504,
0.23731179535388947,
-0.1679859608411789,
-0.331946462392807,
-0.16159690916538239,
0.2626209259033203,
0.30626025795936584,
-0.40265852212905884,
-0.5884050726890564,
0.272752583026886,
-0.006525528617203236,
-0.35317039489746094,
-0.49621841311454773,
-0.008918048813939095,
0.08616890013217926,
0.02749735675752163,
0.30490338802337646,
-0.309332013130188,
0.12947845458984375,
-0.33899804949760437,
0.7105283141136169,
0.5966002941131592,
-0.6814306974411011,
-0.27614259719848633,
0.7707001566886902,
-0.2983005940914154,
-0.5332967638969421,
0.7088857293128967,
-0.04925031214952469,
-0.4133816957473755,
0.7486646175384521,
0.946053147315979,
1.1632394790649414,
-0.6584998965263367,
0.010178694501519203,
0.48930099606513977,
0.5400291681289673,
-0.11357744038105011,
0.24485145509243011,
0.08279421180486679,
-0.7331004738807678,
-0.11593484878540039,
-0.6614360809326172,
-0.35579416155815125,
0.3483376204967499,
-0.9124621748924255,
0.079957015812397,
-0.5338118672370911,
-0.06505319476127625,
-0.19407716393470764,
-0.19336390495300293,
-0.1871941238641739,
0.17276492714881897,
0.11650747805833817,
0.8146367073059082,
-0.8263104557991028,
0.8642842769622803,
0.22249910235404968,
-0.47163477540016174,
-0.45711901783943176,
0.5540101528167725,
0.10665047913789749,
-0.7598702311515808,
0.4343746304512024,
0.25068116188049316,
-0.4770587384700775,
-0.12719231843948364,
-0.5018303394317627,
-0.6331101059913635,
1.0495293140411377,
0.22228606045246124,
-0.7277141809463501,
0.24914567172527313,
0.16313894093036652,
0.4937315285205841,
-0.3846220076084137,
0.09269138425588608,
0.5813133120536804,
0.4975585341453552,
0.44265660643577576,
-0.9799938201904297,
0.44096872210502625,
0.04222007095813751,
-0.14814035594463348,
-0.03964206576347351,
-0.38081982731819153,
0.6413924694061279,
-0.49245986342430115,
-0.19206885993480682,
0.3344844579696655,
0.7898889183998108,
0.38691726326942444,
0.29788994789123535,
0.6477293372154236,
0.45544376969337463,
0.9061776399612427,
0.052183713763952255,
0.6420963406562805,
-0.5113927125930786,
0.43073156476020813,
1.1563184261322021,
-0.46925225853919983,
0.9358345866203308,
0.7782610654830933,
-0.04526017606258392,
0.07277963310480118,
0.5685046911239624,
-0.12822957336902618,
0.6192883849143982,
0.6993426084518433,
-0.29303768277168274,
-0.3172425627708435,
0.019676106050610542,
-0.3621399998664856,
0.16466546058654785,
0.398259699344635,
-0.0022936391178518534,
-0.12368599325418472,
-0.026536330580711365,
-0.10673388838768005,
0.4210665822029114,
-0.05114670470356941,
0.7029399871826172,
0.29798710346221924,
-0.7272809743881226,
0.9380184412002563,
-0.19502972066402435,
0.3170023262500763,
-0.591899573802948,
-0.04867897182703018,
-0.5019559264183044,
0.17097795009613037,
-0.034552622586488724,
-0.7237488627433777,
0.6796425580978394,
-0.34692487120628357,
-0.1928509622812271,
0.15698249638080597,
0.36577531695365906,
-0.5390841960906982,
-0.3669033646583557,
0.4379769563674927,
0.42300766706466675,
0.42733034491539,
-0.2538633644580841,
-0.5135404467582703,
0.09862375259399414,
-0.028321320191025734,
-0.1413266956806183,
0.08847410976886749,
0.20677396655082703,
-0.07120451331138611,
1.0599244832992554,
0.36215856671333313,
0.18463990092277527,
-0.09867829084396362,
0.07650300860404968,
0.7551052570343018,
-0.5890317559242249,
-0.3736586570739746,
-0.8655261993408203,
0.05017116665840149,
0.1028452217578888,
0.023420630022883415,
0.6757530570030212,
0.647109866142273,
0.6763912439346313,
-0.21758176386356354,
0.6609134674072266,
0.1884620040655136,
0.3608546555042267,
-0.7204962968826294,
0.6799431443214417,
-0.56467205286026,
0.5713692307472229,
-0.09481441974639893,
-1.1132512092590332,
-0.5243926048278809,
0.8563553094863892,
-0.30687540769577026,
0.1361406445503235,
0.9363003969192505,
1.2902469635009766,
0.11092956364154816,
-0.05086478963494301,
0.8245687484741211,
0.36714622378349304,
0.23303711414337158,
0.5967336297035217,
0.8164060711860657,
-0.20922504365444183,
0.598178505897522,
-0.35211363434791565,
-0.07089604437351227,
-0.24801136553287506,
-0.6581889986991882,
-1.0523096323013306,
-0.8082168698310852,
-0.3216445744037628,
-0.6458987593650818,
0.2212059646844864,
0.6582374572753906,
0.5799313187599182,
-1.1125860214233398,
-0.33363527059555054,
0.02627003937959671,
0.18247780203819275,
-0.3682299256324768,
-0.22986002266407013,
0.3971225619316101,
-0.4025646150112152,
-0.6852571368217468,
0.31020262837409973,
0.23935554921627045,
0.37897127866744995,
-0.5079363584518433,
-0.0856131985783577,
0.01565639115869999,
0.5001105666160583,
0.19455023109912872,
0.16984708607196808,
-1.0501834154129028,
-0.4939081072807312,
0.33104291558265686,
-0.23643414676189423,
0.15079139173030853,
0.6942023634910583,
-0.6207840442657471,
0.3726443946361542,
0.3022598624229431,
0.4228349030017853,
0.48336729407310486,
0.3605720102787018,
0.46910661458969116,
-0.5556434988975525,
0.003184343921020627,
0.45767009258270264,
-0.032656945288181305,
0.3317032754421234,
-0.6560316681861877,
0.5879857540130615,
0.06336329132318497,
-0.5400309562683105,
-0.7592591047286987,
0.4690455198287964,
-1.0415385961532593,
-0.45178020000457764,
1.0824190378189087,
-0.10660641640424728,
-0.3485240340232849,
-0.3293343186378479,
0.034561119973659515,
0.007586471736431122,
-0.15370717644691467,
1.3021403551101685,
0.7774049043655396,
-0.28249549865722656,
-0.159815713763237,
-0.39093339443206787,
0.6516281962394714,
0.40923774242401123,
-0.6869591474533081,
0.4204403758049011,
0.37394291162490845,
0.39530953764915466,
0.2555142343044281,
0.6514613628387451,
-0.08349008113145828,
0.09212437272071838,
-0.05096685141324997,
0.221175879240036,
0.07074333727359772,
-0.5333470702171326,
-0.47122570872306824,
0.15459254384040833,
-0.013450831174850464,
-0.11889705061912537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03381v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03381v2
|
Learning to Plan and Generate Text with Citations
| 2024-04-04T11:27:54 | 2024-05-13T15:47:57 |
Constanza Fierro, Reinald Kim Amplayo, Fantine Huot, Nicola De Cao, Joshua Maynez, Shashi Narayan, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The increasing demand for the deployment of LLMs in information-seeking
scenarios has spurred efforts in creating verifiable systems, which generate
responses to queries along with supporting evidence. In this paper, we explore
the attribution capabilities of plan-based models which have been recently
shown to improve the faithfulness, grounding, and controllability of generated
text. We conceptualize plans as a sequence of questions which serve as
blueprints of the generated content and its organization. We propose two
attribution models that utilize different variants of blueprints, an
abstractive model where questions are generated from scratch, and an extractive
model where questions are copied from the input. Experiments on long-form
question-answering show that planning consistently improves attribution
quality. Moreover, the citations generated by blueprint models are more
accurate compared to those obtained from LLM-based pipelines lacking a planning
component.
|
[
0.0916334018111229,
-0.4007576107978821,
1.1092784404754639,
0.27052170038223267,
-0.05111692473292351,
-0.1597585380077362,
0.1563657820224762,
-0.2789965271949768,
0.42848142981529236,
0.7714499831199646,
-0.6008137464523315,
-0.24954436719417572,
-0.11538591980934143,
0.010850224643945694,
-0.6128221154212952,
0.9487630128860474,
-0.4052431285381317,
-0.31781187653541565,
-0.353051096200943,
0.21985061466693878,
-0.19567686319351196,
-0.4710615575313568,
-0.6059385538101196,
-0.5914138555526733,
1.147886037826538,
0.5390087962150574,
0.3979073464870453,
0.9663845896720886,
0.38955217599868774,
0.16266024112701416,
0.17615580558776855,
0.3997388184070587,
-0.42419177293777466,
0.5052123069763184,
-0.4470432996749878,
-0.6776472926139832,
-0.20274434983730316,
0.12545213103294373,
0.5918120741844177,
0.46849074959754944,
-0.1834016591310501,
0.3839370608329773,
-0.09801892936229706,
0.5525137186050415,
-0.870966911315918,
0.18596237897872925,
-1.0304999351501465,
-0.2930631637573242,
-0.02250622771680355,
-0.8504825830459595,
-0.6608030200004578,
-0.7233230471611023,
-0.19841068983078003,
-0.5418880581855774,
0.05798645690083504,
-0.020823094993829727,
0.7714641094207764,
0.045387811958789825,
-0.3909973204135895,
-0.8845851421356201,
-0.7674558758735657,
0.7070317268371582,
-0.4344503581523895,
0.018969085067510605,
0.5189824104309082,
0.2848939299583435,
-0.12850938737392426,
-1.0417523384094238,
-0.32228437066078186,
0.3124731779098511,
-0.08258089423179626,
0.21570082008838654,
0.08324521780014038,
-0.32127195596694946,
0.09853550791740417,
0.011514240875840187,
-0.3495689034461975,
-0.12656253576278687,
-0.4567929804325104,
-0.08462225645780563,
0.7344537377357483,
0.21684306859970093,
0.012086771428585052,
-0.5461331605911255,
-0.5219194293022156,
-0.16707384586334229,
-0.9534093141555786,
0.01500536035746336,
0.3576980531215668,
0.4454117715358734,
0.2923535108566284,
1.1262922286987305,
-0.19062592089176178,
0.44234514236450195,
-0.16113772988319397,
-0.15920767188072205,
-0.4034956395626068,
-0.5852231979370117,
-0.18719470500946045,
0.10314874351024628,
0.35876867175102234,
0.36681878566741943,
0.4674023389816284,
-0.4552742838859558,
-0.3954235017299652,
-0.07144036889076233,
0.6059463024139404,
-0.6027296781539917,
-0.3113431930541992,
0.3094378411769867,
-0.3784354627132416,
-0.5285370945930481,
-0.0011363303055986762,
-0.1845034956932068,
-0.3840414583683014,
-0.4908464252948761,
0.18098875880241394,
-0.5116639137268066,
-0.07499446719884872,
-0.12416795641183853,
-0.21712709963321686,
0.4498772621154785,
0.47503694891929626,
-0.7260779142379761,
-0.15986183285713196,
0.3910163342952728,
0.7688738107681274,
-0.24398194253444672,
-0.20790621638298035,
-0.36318424344062805,
0.9610179662704468,
-0.6383011341094971,
1.3175034523010254,
-0.20519272983074188,
-0.35137513279914856,
0.40160754323005676,
-0.2687511444091797,
0.013964933343231678,
-0.5937979817390442,
0.3435138761997223,
-0.8297705054283142,
0.11124897003173828,
-0.6785233616828918,
-0.5449894070625305,
0.15501822531223297,
0.6925132274627686,
-0.5720750689506531,
0.7854510545730591,
-0.13585279881954193,
-0.6447719931602478,
0.5667251348495483,
-0.5447872281074524,
-0.20437408983707428,
0.13766731321811676,
-0.40933945775032043,
-0.17336924374103546,
0.032178573310375214,
-0.005336371250450611,
0.4239127039909363,
-0.09396292269229889,
0.4466540217399597,
0.07684990763664246,
-0.08155648410320282,
0.5684595704078674,
-0.2855795919895172,
0.8257802724838257,
0.42132434248924255,
-0.09534395486116409,
0.32225897908210754,
-0.9634483456611633,
0.5678145289421082,
0.27477937936782837,
-1.1458789110183716,
-0.19931158423423767,
0.4668472111225128,
-0.09497649222612381,
-0.10499391704797745,
0.0648776963353157,
-0.3721710741519928,
0.16929368674755096,
-0.16428323090076447,
0.20678400993347168,
0.6531909704208374,
0.31522712111473083,
0.532351016998291,
-0.6710336208343506,
0.4000307023525238,
-0.17832373082637787,
-0.3628682494163513,
-0.5835599899291992,
-0.12517593801021576,
-0.7575932741165161,
-0.039889153093099594,
-0.2527856230735779,
0.5349650382995605,
-0.7812490463256836,
-0.19011074304580688,
-0.5265205502510071,
-0.7665284872055054,
0.22122180461883545,
-0.03319380804896355,
0.3906601071357727,
0.49188685417175293,
0.35975760221481323,
0.13208292424678802,
-0.5362210869789124,
-0.6488074660301208,
-0.4677687883377075,
-0.6865238547325134,
-0.21756502985954285,
0.25729620456695557,
0.4045853614807129,
0.176823690533638,
1.1262646913528442,
-0.5349562764167786,
0.09853003174066544,
-0.3358854353427887,
0.36944469809532166,
-0.1626010239124298,
0.3908584713935852,
0.31621959805488586,
-0.7754380702972412,
-0.39199021458625793,
-0.36093461513519287,
-0.9523047208786011,
-0.11795163154602051,
-0.3915500342845917,
-0.28514495491981506,
0.03529920428991318,
0.644781231880188,
-0.6076500415802002,
0.39898866415023804,
-0.018598992377519608,
-0.40007278323173523,
0.7461589574813843,
0.10034619271755219,
0.012267809361219406,
-1.2521308660507202,
0.16382081806659698,
-0.3071766197681427,
-0.3338192105293274,
-0.43305492401123047,
0.2665235996246338,
0.2947855293750763,
-0.28624582290649414,
-0.5493583083152771,
0.5805551409721375,
-0.5881938338279724,
-0.08056581765413284,
-0.2172335833311081,
-0.049585845321416855,
0.3482793867588043,
0.259076863527298,
-0.002688954584300518,
0.8056845664978027,
-0.08877813816070557,
-0.7906306385993958,
0.3700428605079651,
0.4465946853160858,
-0.3877367675304413,
0.46686020493507385,
-0.5425516366958618,
0.09338612109422684,
-0.15298530459403992,
0.25921961665153503,
-1.0320581197738647,
-0.3336960971355438,
0.09093933552503586,
-0.45674219727516174,
0.2898923456668854,
-0.36406710743904114,
-0.6348907947540283,
-0.0995170921087265,
-0.2895931005477905,
0.20543746650218964,
0.12857195734977722,
-0.5804895162582397,
0.656041145324707,
-0.015112257562577724,
-0.6085301041603088,
-0.21652860939502716,
-0.9183251261711121,
0.06281165033578873,
-0.3260837197303772,
-0.5898032188415527,
0.6453009247779846,
0.1681208461523056,
-0.5594391822814941,
-0.08486387133598328,
0.09626632183790207,
-0.14490027725696564,
-0.12416929751634598,
0.29592928290367126,
0.11505290865898132,
-0.24046830832958221,
0.3138759732246399,
-0.06548730283975601,
-0.001801979960873723,
0.46416181325912476,
-0.19975391030311584,
0.5040323734283447,
0.3910212814807892,
-0.5141178965568542,
0.03074459172785282,
0.6829681992530823,
0.341262549161911,
-0.2745410203933716,
0.6246672868728638,
-0.1807502806186676,
-0.3113085627555847,
-0.2067038118839264,
-0.6600956320762634,
-0.2468937337398529,
-0.4720781743526459,
-0.030672095715999603,
-0.2989177107810974,
-0.23767171800136566,
0.6644601225852966,
-0.10589435696601868,
0.46046680212020874,
0.3274686932563782,
0.5089941024780273,
-0.43664878606796265,
0.4925851821899414,
0.551081120967865,
0.3693050146102905,
0.39915576577186584,
-0.1710360050201416,
-0.2653414011001587,
-0.40859201550483704,
-0.558677613735199,
-0.6842923760414124,
-0.16415825486183167,
-0.3255595862865448,
-0.5079609751701355,
0.07126674056053162,
0.12189619243144989,
-0.28415584564208984,
0.0706525668501854,
-0.31226646900177,
0.43428850173950195,
0.7168340086936951,
0.05811159312725067,
0.45186617970466614,
0.4399210810661316,
0.006769340485334396,
0.04642156884074211,
-0.5562836527824402,
-1.1714431047439575,
1.374178409576416,
0.17809703946113586,
0.757266640663147,
0.17869599163532257,
0.8596711158752441,
0.10914433002471924,
0.30991131067276,
-0.4919795095920563,
0.5614376068115234,
0.558091402053833,
-0.9192246198654175,
-0.4411311149597168,
-0.18463805317878723,
-0.773525059223175,
-0.03828420117497444,
-0.2659238576889038,
-0.6894769668579102,
0.22131606936454773,
0.23509375751018524,
-0.14419959485530853,
0.3136105239391327,
-0.5519896149635315,
0.3280174732208252,
-0.19830280542373657,
-0.601271390914917,
0.013590473681688309,
-0.2483961135149002,
0.0897536501288414,
-0.19769485294818878,
-0.1357267051935196,
0.0940597876906395,
-0.045845478773117065,
0.8787093162536621,
-0.34111928939819336,
0.6881367564201355,
-0.17797665297985077,
-0.22320489585399628,
0.8227829933166504,
0.10797947645187378,
1.0679665803909302,
0.03597000613808632,
-0.4077991545200348,
-0.4790150821208954,
-0.22964325547218323,
-0.43198397755622864,
-0.43423840403556824,
0.4418991208076477,
-0.27073755860328674,
-0.3868139684200287,
-0.05548889935016632,
-0.7468103766441345,
-0.12326864898204803,
0.41401341557502747,
0.4731580317020416,
0.4110812246799469,
-0.05400393530726433,
0.0003093373670708388,
0.6937317848205566,
-0.31623685359954834,
0.5042615532875061,
0.39925602078437805,
-0.32227808237075806,
-0.22927862405776978,
0.8090940713882446,
0.20472058653831482,
0.4175952970981598,
0.2129618227481842,
-0.2016618251800537,
-0.297971248626709,
-0.8870882391929626,
-0.24784347414970398,
0.40784886479377747,
-1.042834997177124,
-0.27605322003364563,
-0.5692691206932068,
-0.32916969060897827,
-0.33651450276374817,
-0.4791211783885956,
-0.4103638827800751,
-0.3577875792980194,
-0.3456893861293793,
-0.39682626724243164,
0.020821256563067436,
0.6463079452514648,
0.26214587688446045,
0.33393532037734985,
-0.42456358671188354,
-0.09204459190368652,
0.22823002934455872,
-0.026861773803830147,
-0.23238766193389893,
-0.25346919894218445,
-0.19622722268104553,
0.11511057615280151,
-0.6279842257499695,
-1.0440168380737305,
0.3790115416049957,
-0.17469090223312378,
0.5225381255149841,
0.14491377770900726,
0.2094351351261139,
0.729555606842041,
-0.5015945434570312,
0.6722581386566162,
0.0546548031270504,
-0.23590846359729767,
0.7911288142204285,
-0.6631465554237366,
0.15751276910305023,
0.6084078550338745,
0.6030550599098206,
0.12279617041349411,
-0.4571199417114258,
-0.5567050576210022,
-0.9338849186897278,
0.502595067024231,
0.3225571811199188,
0.28632256388664246,
-0.11001048237085342,
0.7807872891426086,
-0.14698456227779388,
0.1925298422574997,
-1.00899076461792,
-0.18626005947589874,
-0.11437511444091797,
0.0018971581012010574,
0.15199653804302216,
-0.7747970819473267,
-0.2031472623348236,
0.28569507598876953,
0.5116746425628662,
-0.1561698615550995,
0.537550151348114,
0.2709351181983948,
-0.05944015458226204,
-0.25723719596862793,
0.2949441075325012,
0.5522478818893433,
1.0518817901611328,
-0.25472551584243774,
0.4100463390350342,
-0.15929478406906128,
-0.0920376107096672,
0.19330334663391113,
0.0029072207398712635,
-0.5804567337036133,
0.042938075959682465,
0.5279086232185364,
0.3393988609313965,
-0.11109927296638489,
-0.5164999961853027,
0.17804399132728577,
0.18579433858394623,
-0.5335333347320557,
-0.5214260816574097,
0.015653695911169052,
0.43049877882003784,
0.4361386001110077,
0.5597279071807861,
-0.25969651341438293,
-0.048349685966968536,
-0.6498082876205444,
0.06468725949525833,
0.4110528230667114,
-0.3111857771873474,
-0.11603300273418427,
0.5766302347183228,
-0.05281854048371315,
-0.231612429022789,
0.5700884461402893,
0.05493021011352539,
-0.30155038833618164,
0.4712756872177124,
0.8553087115287781,
0.33482807874679565,
0.019565999507904053,
0.23525629937648773,
0.4532906413078308,
0.3192637860774994,
0.09760966897010803,
0.5780839920043945,
-0.05709126591682434,
-0.6507043838500977,
-0.354018896818161,
-0.5406626462936401,
-0.3286537826061249,
0.11614344269037247,
-0.555243968963623,
0.3013525605201721,
-0.31884855031967163,
-0.05530702322721481,
-0.12602466344833374,
-0.0903332531452179,
-0.40800201892852783,
0.3229905068874359,
-0.05670339986681938,
0.9216554760932922,
-0.6490182280540466,
0.6120022535324097,
0.9758560061454773,
-0.7180805206298828,
-1.3321744203567505,
-0.10828778892755508,
-0.272957444190979,
-0.7958762049674988,
0.7634772062301636,
0.10684198141098022,
0.03030281700193882,
0.17081943154335022,
-0.6583414077758789,
-1.2208836078643799,
1.5063718557357788,
0.46913132071495056,
-0.11538633704185486,
-0.5771785378456116,
0.2909485101699829,
0.03963955491781235,
-0.3580024242401123,
-0.054105546325445175,
-0.034551363438367844,
0.43249139189720154,
0.44574782252311707,
-0.4498578608036041,
0.08482788503170013,
-0.05646006017923355,
-0.2798563241958618,
0.025671344250440598,
0.0284364502876997,
0.8882914781570435,
-0.34007585048675537,
-0.46656090021133423,
-0.07926955819129944,
0.7989280223846436,
0.7092099785804749,
0.45637747645378113,
0.21821796894073486,
0.11703124642372131,
0.9406486749649048,
-0.03588320314884186,
1.0864074230194092,
0.10622785240411758,
-0.1248830109834671,
1.398085594177246,
-0.09343492984771729,
0.9355548024177551,
0.9371393918991089,
-0.0044928500428795815,
0.7345601320266724,
0.5563207268714905,
0.17190535366535187,
0.738795280456543,
0.1656222641468048,
-0.0775018259882927,
-0.09221455454826355,
-0.07126610726118088,
-0.2361106127500534,
0.15945985913276672,
0.20548133552074432,
-0.8475565910339355,
-0.31268346309661865,
-0.28728020191192627,
0.11351460218429565,
0.3498767614364624,
-0.3693089783191681,
0.87549889087677,
-0.04531862214207649,
-0.9928786158561707,
0.2673393785953522,
0.06945706158876419,
0.30596864223480225,
-0.6954672932624817,
0.1821361482143402,
-0.30217042565345764,
0.070182666182518,
-0.2490236908197403,
-0.6766414642333984,
0.6701294183731079,
0.16020292043685913,
-0.6413573622703552,
-0.6143902540206909,
0.9994157552719116,
-0.3246628940105438,
-0.5278785228729248,
-0.06812386959791183,
0.569973349571228,
0.28221434354782104,
-0.3574656546115875,
-0.29165229201316833,
-0.26311609148979187,
0.07515496015548706,
-0.6557134389877319,
0.1628764569759369,
0.4659528136253357,
-0.19652654230594635,
0.7738600373268127,
0.7540299892425537,
0.3508864641189575,
0.5085039734840393,
-0.4686621129512787,
0.9533500075340271,
-0.7448376417160034,
-0.3284718692302704,
-0.8331624269485474,
0.7098992466926575,
-0.1822795867919922,
-0.014946062117815018,
0.636224091053009,
0.7511374950408936,
0.7500117421150208,
0.007056429050862789,
0.7717401385307312,
0.126186802983284,
0.6059489250183105,
-0.7530385255813599,
0.6763883829116821,
-0.5640957355499268,
0.38642796874046326,
-0.22087471187114716,
-1.0779691934585571,
-0.08830174058675766,
0.497368723154068,
-0.28708022832870483,
-0.15239249169826508,
0.5266265273094177,
0.605720579624176,
0.004980779252946377,
-0.31395354866981506,
0.050827182829380035,
-0.4202226996421814,
0.9087005257606506,
0.34789907932281494,
0.8743559718132019,
-0.2903273403644562,
0.7875895500183105,
0.04120654612779617,
-0.024582969024777412,
-0.034635767340660095,
-1.109336256980896,
-0.7204373478889465,
-0.5843240022659302,
-0.1461493819952011,
-0.16421478986740112,
-0.07792031019926071,
0.409108966588974,
0.5009937286376953,
-0.39821428060531616,
-0.29147040843963623,
-0.44344979524612427,
0.041672781109809875,
0.31940576434135437,
-0.19805380702018738,
0.30083391070365906,
-0.5301083326339722,
-0.18875566124916077,
0.45115527510643005,
0.10518162697553635,
0.2921043634414673,
-0.2709435224533081,
-0.11839469522237778,
-0.4563145637512207,
0.4100157618522644,
0.4983839988708496,
0.2091667503118515,
-0.5475094318389893,
-0.22873301804065704,
0.07763329893350601,
-0.3933110237121582,
-0.15883155167102814,
0.9911364316940308,
-0.6430575847625732,
0.1510147750377655,
0.3437690734863281,
0.46852847933769226,
0.6325705051422119,
0.25317075848579407,
0.8216963410377502,
-0.7132235765457153,
-0.2123473584651947,
0.27762147784233093,
0.18479542434215546,
0.3703361451625824,
-0.2930785119533539,
0.6402334570884705,
-0.17952808737754822,
-0.6179154515266418,
-0.8401115536689758,
0.44925951957702637,
-0.6876875162124634,
-0.23159316182136536,
1.2788732051849365,
-0.2187732458114624,
0.028172649443149567,
-0.06501789391040802,
-0.04909374937415123,
0.34051957726478577,
0.06369666755199432,
0.6003740429878235,
0.7065981030464172,
-0.13768364489078522,
0.12676799297332764,
-0.2795117497444153,
0.3774878978729248,
0.3846615254878998,
-1.0243147611618042,
0.36017733812332153,
0.7200379371643066,
0.2636926770210266,
0.636396586894989,
1.030868411064148,
-0.1799640655517578,
0.012546032667160034,
0.01459230575710535,
0.06620655208826065,
-0.32587313652038574,
-0.4063245952129364,
0.5534837245941162,
0.4715430736541748,
0.4132790267467499,
0.004506635945290327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03361v1
|
nicolay-r at SemEval-2024 Task 3: Using Flan-T5 for Reasoning Emotion Cause in Conversations with Chain-of-Thought on Emotion States
| 2024-04-04T11:03:33 | 2024-04-04T11:03:33 |
Nicolay Rusnachenko, Huizhi Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotion expression is one of the essential traits of conversations. It may be
self-related or caused by another speaker. The variety of reasons may serve as
a source of the further emotion causes: conversation history, speaker's
emotional state, etc. Inspired by the most recent advances in Chain-of-Thought,
in this work, we exploit the existing three-hop reasoning approach (THOR) to
perform large language model instruction-tuning for answering: emotion states
(THOR-state), and emotion caused by one speaker to the other (THOR-cause). We
equip THOR-cause with the reasoning revision (rr) for devising a reasoning path
in fine-tuning. In particular, we rely on the annotated speaker emotion states
to revise reasoning path. Our final submission, based on Flan-T5-base (250M)
and the rule-based span correction technique, preliminary tuned with THOR-state
and fine-tuned with THOR-cause-rr on competition training data, results in 3rd
and 4th places (F1-proportional) and 5th place (F1-strict) among 15
participating teams. Our THOR implementation fork is publicly available:
https://github.com/nicolay-r/THOR-ECAC
|
[
-0.5123105645179749,
-0.9419152140617371,
0.5594667792320251,
0.02875245362520218,
-0.13226114213466644,
-0.21301911771297455,
0.043367549777030945,
-0.6579051613807678,
0.4287969172000885,
0.3699854612350464,
-0.7050936818122864,
-0.1978430300951004,
-0.3534310758113861,
0.3239300847053528,
-0.13336777687072754,
0.8313978910446167,
-0.3417041003704071,
-0.2491290271282196,
0.39038407802581787,
-0.1904975324869156,
-0.4717458486557007,
-0.5282955169677734,
-0.7444555163383484,
-0.16622690856456757,
0.9189956784248352,
0.7901173830032349,
0.3178955912590027,
0.23065629601478577,
0.39602017402648926,
0.20268073678016663,
-0.1898004412651062,
0.19879314303398132,
-0.5673545598983765,
0.4355160892009735,
-0.4483073055744171,
-0.438567578792572,
-0.8195042014122009,
-0.33828800916671753,
0.37861117720603943,
0.10646997392177582,
-0.09410468488931656,
0.046024858951568604,
-0.16554062068462372,
0.8499510288238525,
-0.7774330377578735,
-0.0930679440498352,
-0.6257116198539734,
0.12672244012355804,
-0.3734443485736847,
-0.5271866917610168,
-0.4930657148361206,
-0.17859137058258057,
-0.046272892504930496,
-0.3883218765258789,
-0.0379723459482193,
0.31866654753685,
0.8486946821212769,
0.1823064535856247,
-0.6916341781616211,
-0.22068578004837036,
-0.47163254022598267,
0.47390276193618774,
-0.6468912363052368,
0.3355327844619751,
0.2272384911775589,
-0.051402170211076736,
-0.1061883196234703,
-0.3465937674045563,
-0.6280175447463989,
0.4276893138885498,
0.2577700912952423,
0.2928672134876251,
-0.2473241537809372,
0.259516179561615,
0.442631334066391,
0.3755365312099457,
-0.3583550751209259,
-0.0825754702091217,
-0.4255077540874481,
0.02574075758457184,
0.6584343314170837,
0.11066541075706482,
0.21197599172592163,
0.010715408250689507,
-0.2029748260974884,
-0.14591029286384583,
-0.8418697714805603,
-0.18546758592128754,
0.40706077218055725,
0.25695279240608215,
0.06261551380157471,
0.3844999372959137,
-0.16816100478172302,
0.4919966161251068,
0.07078699767589569,
0.3654688596725464,
0.18489257991313934,
-0.052400488406419754,
-0.22462604939937592,
0.1568702608346939,
0.5921666026115417,
0.36870256066322327,
0.15991099178791046,
0.3238897919654846,
-0.10649777948856354,
-0.0547005832195282,
0.23073677718639374,
-0.5822242498397827,
0.017599837854504585,
0.41685646772384644,
-0.09151186048984528,
-0.38481709361076355,
-0.15980485081672668,
-0.9252431392669678,
-0.3600524067878723,
-0.1123637855052948,
0.794305682182312,
-0.4001646339893341,
-0.6460685133934021,
0.09068778157234192,
0.0005661967443302274,
0.22911196947097778,
0.4488089978694916,
-0.8961697816848755,
0.19897036254405975,
0.7174032330513,
0.585566520690918,
0.18924276530742645,
-0.4093685448169708,
-0.7279132604598999,
-0.003665362251922488,
-0.5125702619552612,
0.567812442779541,
-0.4710376560688019,
-0.028445979580283165,
-0.04287136346101761,
-0.07370249181985855,
-0.24252669513225555,
-0.10020506381988525,
0.8776546120643616,
-0.3733365535736084,
0.49010688066482544,
-0.6659877896308899,
-0.7036913633346558,
-0.3241760730743408,
0.2849767506122589,
-0.4621416926383972,
0.9166598320007324,
0.03237835690379143,
-1.087550163269043,
-0.050777606666088104,
-0.7515751123428345,
-0.628491222858429,
-0.08437065780162811,
0.09021145105361938,
-0.09471238404512405,
0.26589977741241455,
0.14837196469306946,
0.42170950770378113,
-0.28463324904441833,
0.12454014271497726,
-0.32723531126976013,
-0.32226815819740295,
-0.08927832543849945,
0.0015249509597197175,
0.26681384444236755,
0.28652334213256836,
-0.7346019148826599,
0.38847658038139343,
-0.3897665739059448,
-0.10651274770498276,
-0.048550743609666824,
0.01835715025663376,
-0.24524743854999542,
0.10008527338504791,
-0.3420269191265106,
0.5601240992546082,
-0.11852724105119705,
-0.47663256525993347,
0.014314239844679832,
-0.559994637966156,
0.2273259311914444,
0.9269578456878662,
0.4665845036506653,
0.03069758415222168,
-0.3086669445037842,
0.710254430770874,
0.2319152057170868,
0.13739082217216492,
-0.251007616519928,
-0.4836224615573883,
-1.045336365699768,
0.20746581256389618,
-0.025398127734661102,
0.3852890729904175,
-0.7390347123146057,
0.041021376848220825,
0.1093660220503807,
-0.35721907019615173,
-0.46863964200019836,
-0.40069255232810974,
0.17915134131908417,
0.7233837842941284,
0.4460984766483307,
0.18640175461769104,
-0.6732920408248901,
-0.6448275446891785,
-0.6288056969642639,
-0.16196675598621368,
0.46334534883499146,
0.2761687636375427,
0.6992800235748291,
-0.07261370867490768,
0.36340826749801636,
-0.29748275876045227,
-0.003479650476947427,
-0.32660973072052,
0.3494492173194885,
0.09872592985630035,
0.4693874716758728,
0.27132827043533325,
-0.45622217655181885,
-0.2850361168384552,
0.12683416903018951,
-0.45824548602104187,
-0.2709347605705261,
-0.11020921915769577,
-0.4995197057723999,
0.5972840189933777,
0.29734739661216736,
-0.23447425663471222,
0.5137288570404053,
0.5831503868103027,
-0.5277392268180847,
0.41732877492904663,
0.07179483771324158,
0.6055611371994019,
-1.2975302934646606,
-0.06779830157756805,
0.10403194278478622,
-0.17370271682739258,
-0.553951621055603,
0.07026155292987823,
-0.15193192660808563,
-0.09503050148487091,
-0.34747546911239624,
0.5301764607429504,
-0.08808224648237228,
0.06444364786148071,
-0.1810559779405594,
0.29656141996383667,
0.030704155564308167,
0.5646008849143982,
0.10728884488344193,
0.4796419143676758,
0.5369824171066284,
-0.5226590633392334,
0.368133544921875,
0.1606808453798294,
0.04369132220745087,
0.5433595776557922,
-0.4004625678062439,
0.3080396354198456,
0.10875830799341202,
0.2802416682243347,
-0.7125820517539978,
-0.34439313411712646,
0.31269529461860657,
-0.27524396777153015,
0.12125933915376663,
0.11847025901079178,
-0.4888838529586792,
-0.44492900371551514,
-0.1143062561750412,
0.382259339094162,
0.33411353826522827,
-0.5814094543457031,
0.7066196799278259,
0.14229528605937958,
-0.19208592176437378,
-0.3757284879684448,
-0.48060300946235657,
-0.021448571234941483,
-0.5541702508926392,
-0.7148706912994385,
0.2062172293663025,
0.021318169310688972,
-0.1728484034538269,
-0.35590633749961853,
-0.4253081679344177,
0.14718332886695862,
0.1125650554895401,
0.04341985285282135,
-0.15276002883911133,
-0.02375154383480549,
0.32463085651397705,
0.18241259455680847,
0.04358851537108421,
0.29014497995376587,
-0.20863310992717743,
0.3416402339935303,
-0.6297546029090881,
-0.24197910726070404,
-0.6433985829353333,
0.3657187223434448,
0.618340790271759,
-0.23291519284248352,
0.5673391222953796,
0.5098520517349243,
-0.2896004915237427,
-0.24555864930152893,
-0.5617021322250366,
-0.39594191312789917,
-0.3881063163280487,
0.1028585135936737,
-0.60941082239151,
-1.267094373703003,
0.4116973280906677,
-0.301238089799881,
-0.18844722211360931,
0.5917119979858398,
0.5378540754318237,
-0.4088771343231201,
1.0408804416656494,
0.20631800591945648,
-0.04544513672590256,
0.30999982357025146,
0.05528943985700607,
0.3837527334690094,
-0.9238260388374329,
-0.06345930695533752,
-0.5063099265098572,
-0.3658618628978729,
-0.7383873462677002,
-0.28659069538116455,
0.5782047510147095,
0.02376883663237095,
-0.4014538526535034,
0.21495433151721954,
-0.18009966611862183,
0.29514583945274353,
0.36081385612487793,
0.12218260020017624,
-0.23586447536945343,
-0.2540339529514313,
-0.3144473731517792,
0.1546994149684906,
-0.8222713470458984,
-0.19056624174118042,
0.5311808586120605,
0.5651357173919678,
0.6323786377906799,
0.3660754859447479,
0.9930482506752014,
0.11948402971029282,
-0.0634554848074913,
-0.6306942701339722,
0.5411561727523804,
0.25870078802108765,
-0.7824066877365112,
-0.1858186572790146,
-0.524352490901947,
-0.6546264290809631,
0.22747617959976196,
-0.06545720994472504,
-1.1956171989440918,
0.06688261032104492,
0.4900713860988617,
-0.1566716879606247,
0.32340753078460693,
-0.4882340133190155,
1.00674569606781,
-0.33324265480041504,
-0.6320984959602356,
-0.5138328671455383,
-0.8394762873649597,
0.5596258044242859,
-0.030093666166067123,
0.311832457780838,
-0.027439270168542862,
0.6380660533905029,
0.7111339569091797,
-0.7759352922439575,
0.5779705047607422,
-0.187015563249588,
-0.3372752070426941,
0.5432897806167603,
0.36428117752075195,
0.792644739151001,
-0.196597158908844,
-0.334877073764801,
-0.3702913522720337,
0.2216545194387436,
-0.1304885894060135,
-0.6605430841445923,
0.458249032497406,
-0.4357448220252991,
-0.6171373128890991,
-0.5254908800125122,
-0.2819138169288635,
-0.32619115710258484,
-0.04576510190963745,
0.27430787682533264,
0.5929597020149231,
0.1882382035255432,
0.20843252539634705,
0.6013171076774597,
-0.17676451802253723,
0.37255507707595825,
0.1713307499885559,
-0.46054866909980774,
-0.43662548065185547,
0.9104821085929871,
-0.40380942821502686,
0.3590751588344574,
0.5533321499824524,
0.6523985862731934,
-0.22494864463806152,
0.12158021330833435,
-0.040920231491327286,
0.20862595736980438,
-0.7331690788269043,
-0.2253839671611786,
-0.28635841608047485,
0.16907650232315063,
-0.3045492470264435,
-0.1282336413860321,
-0.40689727663993835,
-0.5471765995025635,
-0.3117593824863434,
-0.06766603887081146,
0.5049642324447632,
0.8044281601905823,
-0.17650289833545685,
0.11804968863725662,
-0.7604265213012695,
0.08626087009906769,
0.23245769739151,
0.18700817227363586,
-0.011719190515577793,
-0.6370587348937988,
-0.1784404218196869,
-0.041135888546705246,
-0.5279672741889954,
-1.2394756078720093,
0.23128749430179596,
0.2165655493736267,
0.1177331879734993,
0.37529319524765015,
0.1617121696472168,
0.8744348287582397,
-0.2398207187652588,
0.8034225702285767,
0.2237010896205902,
-1.3590668439865112,
1.2259384393692017,
-0.7871851325035095,
0.27898120880126953,
0.35937929153442383,
0.29101142287254333,
-0.7802058458328247,
-0.5004712343215942,
-0.9722118377685547,
-0.7134751677513123,
0.8164432048797607,
0.40384653210639954,
-0.22784559428691864,
-0.20713810622692108,
0.22578129172325134,
-0.28551948070526123,
-0.06765090674161911,
-0.4301341772079468,
0.09183445572853088,
-0.16402573883533478,
-0.11394651979207993,
0.30993643403053284,
-0.3854193389415741,
-0.10934297740459442,
-0.2425423264503479,
1.1986968517303467,
-0.31262025237083435,
0.21822018921375275,
0.29210370779037476,
0.13237617909908295,
-0.45737624168395996,
0.6978846788406372,
0.9773302674293518,
0.47458213567733765,
-0.2247716784477234,
0.2536602318286896,
0.4402438700199127,
0.13340602815151215,
-0.04171692952513695,
-0.18949654698371887,
0.36132556200027466,
-0.3374108374118805,
0.3322834372520447,
1.0889564752578735,
0.2553936541080475,
-0.32578244805336,
0.5683386921882629,
0.010624697431921959,
-0.3175787031650543,
0.0484003908932209,
0.06271397322416306,
-0.01994902826845646,
0.3691900968551636,
0.006804930046200752,
0.1081601083278656,
0.1485220491886139,
-0.5430235266685486,
0.18346364796161652,
-0.1872587352991104,
-0.44776687026023865,
-0.6164515018463135,
0.5904521346092224,
0.5355651378631592,
-0.11864718049764633,
0.46281203627586365,
-0.3511299788951874,
-0.9982223510742188,
0.3165750503540039,
0.6489854454994202,
0.9396457672119141,
-0.3890886902809143,
0.11804615706205368,
0.5424823760986328,
0.17475654184818268,
-0.06897515803575516,
1.0681191682815552,
-0.0919380933046341,
-0.7905853986740112,
-0.39720186591148376,
-0.4014890193939209,
-0.46826332807540894,
-0.020881662145256996,
-0.8065741658210754,
0.36818939447402954,
-0.2784145772457123,
-0.11119113862514496,
-0.418678343296051,
-0.20635482668876648,
-0.5029960870742798,
0.44432929158210754,
0.4086090922355652,
0.9472704529762268,
-0.9795817732810974,
0.5550000071525574,
0.7582356929779053,
-0.3112223446369171,
-1.308171033859253,
0.13269051909446716,
0.3549213111400604,
-0.3276406526565552,
0.7547560930252075,
0.1729985922574997,
-0.5651137232780457,
0.09858761727809906,
-0.4591952860355377,
-0.6327647566795349,
0.8648315668106079,
0.1099628135561943,
-0.7142243981361389,
0.22327440977096558,
-0.26489436626434326,
0.47856494784355164,
-0.3398149013519287,
0.31775525212287903,
0.5394553542137146,
0.34334051609039307,
0.3772456645965576,
-0.9865437150001526,
0.011478434316813946,
-0.2885911464691162,
-0.17239417135715485,
0.3711971044540405,
-0.8343890905380249,
0.4868324398994446,
-0.14076586067676544,
0.12086573988199234,
-0.31897667050361633,
0.6500829458236694,
0.6260755658149719,
0.15943026542663574,
0.6167258024215698,
0.7414180040359497,
0.8720870614051819,
-0.14640343189239502,
0.7570950984954834,
-0.4202163517475128,
0.47490766644477844,
1.2340452671051025,
-0.5539607405662537,
0.993439257144928,
0.5434401035308838,
-0.005108857061713934,
0.6916420459747314,
0.7166230082511902,
0.4956292510032654,
0.20317234098911285,
0.18756018579006195,
-0.41106274724006653,
-0.38526618480682373,
-0.05937064066529274,
-0.31563809514045715,
0.7754196524620056,
0.4772561490535736,
-0.2108379751443863,
0.03576715290546417,
-0.037185441702604294,
0.3272160589694977,
-0.2533051371574402,
-0.3071190416812897,
0.592534601688385,
0.07813507318496704,
-0.8402228355407715,
0.4796406924724579,
-0.2057558000087738,
0.13705651462078094,
-0.2671838402748108,
-0.04158278554677963,
-0.2952331304550171,
0.07266532629728317,
-0.2981222867965698,
-0.6795821785926819,
0.3228551149368286,
0.24492260813713074,
0.22919651865959167,
-0.395573228597641,
0.645014226436615,
-0.28576892614364624,
-0.24852655827999115,
0.16786964237689972,
0.22859986126422882,
0.3240600526332855,
-0.07832970470190048,
-0.4720991551876068,
0.34118208289146423,
-0.004743492696434259,
-0.3933559060096741,
-0.1342473030090332,
0.787635862827301,
-0.06226151064038277,
0.40853115916252136,
-0.04527400806546211,
-0.023709747940301895,
-0.10720464587211609,
0.5770437121391296,
0.7037643194198608,
-0.7827534079551697,
-0.6643778085708618,
-0.7642071843147278,
0.6363030076026917,
0.044898416846990585,
-0.37528300285339355,
0.2571611702442169,
0.47475191950798035,
0.4450182318687439,
0.12957631051540375,
0.7477174997329712,
-0.2874037027359009,
0.5700079202651978,
-0.6975096464157104,
0.3266714811325073,
-0.8266360759735107,
0.17300140857696533,
-0.7566884756088257,
-0.6216994524002075,
-0.017926137894392014,
0.6861908435821533,
-0.3587438464164734,
-0.0035968737211078405,
1.2353962659835815,
0.6069028377532959,
0.20984765887260437,
0.7066665887832642,
0.23962514102458954,
0.4220251441001892,
0.3761955201625824,
0.8841801285743713,
1.0327352285385132,
-0.5769509673118591,
0.15499630570411682,
-0.09060204774141312,
-0.15858078002929688,
-0.2670108675956726,
-1.1106935739517212,
-0.6295931339263916,
-0.8563749194145203,
-0.6386810541152954,
-0.4217303693294525,
0.10773573070764542,
1.0571871995925903,
0.4330347180366516,
-0.7540279030799866,
-0.13150721788406372,
-0.5487673282623291,
0.22743935883045197,
-0.21796488761901855,
-0.1997775286436081,
0.13111722469329834,
-0.5601713061332703,
-0.2313605546951294,
0.5196941494941711,
0.2858549952507019,
-0.16241835057735443,
0.3061560094356537,
-0.1077989786863327,
-0.4824928939342499,
0.024519164115190506,
0.6485188007354736,
0.29445376992225647,
-0.9587052464485168,
-0.8300970196723938,
-0.11667076498270035,
0.31319957971572876,
-0.06127733737230301,
0.7383034825325012,
-0.3482910692691803,
0.6111435294151306,
0.6492615342140198,
0.4684046804904938,
0.6034033894538879,
0.22020260989665985,
0.8116157650947571,
-0.8282831311225891,
-0.2289048284292221,
0.2808656394481659,
0.4592460095882416,
0.14968867599964142,
-0.27692174911499023,
0.6687259674072266,
0.2727549970149994,
-0.9011197090148926,
-0.5665202736854553,
0.4602265954017639,
-0.84566730260849,
-0.009981323964893818,
1.1611742973327637,
-0.15209944546222687,
-0.1849401444196701,
0.4903571307659149,
-0.2763187289237976,
0.46160826086997986,
-0.2956673502922058,
0.5577734112739563,
0.8608483672142029,
-0.6401335000991821,
-0.62675541639328,
-0.32804596424102783,
0.506621241569519,
0.6795745491981506,
-1.1829479932785034,
0.06137216091156006,
0.5185468196868896,
-0.010098418220877647,
-0.2023531049489975,
0.5822886824607849,
0.12466510385274887,
0.33343273401260376,
-0.20501913130283356,
0.06835712492465973,
0.3864489495754242,
-0.5925706624984741,
-0.29251518845558167,
0.004053195007145405,
0.029268693178892136,
0.0025036302395164967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03353v1
|
Towards Pareto Optimal Throughput in Small Language Model Serving
| 2024-04-04T10:45:07 | 2024-04-04T10:45:07 |
Pol G. Recasens, Yue Zhu, Chen Wang, Eun Kyung Lee, Olivier Tardieu, Alaa Youssef, Jordi Torres, Josep Ll. Berral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the state-of-the-art of many
different natural language processing tasks. Although serving LLMs is
computationally and memory demanding, the rise of Small Language Models (SLMs)
offers new opportunities for resource-constrained users, who now are able to
serve small models with cutting-edge performance. In this paper, we present a
set of experiments designed to benchmark SLM inference at performance and
energy levels. Our analysis provides a new perspective in serving, highlighting
that the small memory footprint of SLMs allows for reaching the Pareto-optimal
throughput within the resource capacity of a single accelerator. In this
regard, we present an initial set of findings demonstrating how model
replication can effectively improve resource utilization for serving SLMs.
|
[
-0.2819353938102722,
-0.6476318836212158,
1.101461410522461,
0.003056560643017292,
-0.020804787054657936,
-0.08188352733850479,
-0.35508817434310913,
-0.32291650772094727,
0.09758450090885162,
0.9143664240837097,
-0.4232301115989685,
0.017192862927913666,
-0.4555836021900177,
0.08948168903589249,
-0.22338171303272247,
0.4342198669910431,
0.26728999614715576,
0.2873196005821228,
-0.5902413129806519,
-0.1715293973684311,
-0.4742383658885956,
-0.36553022265434265,
-0.9332073926925659,
-0.5954170227050781,
0.33228352665901184,
0.6302595138549805,
1.0674006938934326,
1.0036362409591675,
0.3768281042575836,
0.24838590621948242,
-0.05362936109304428,
0.007128408178687096,
-0.6021279692649841,
-0.044853005558252335,
-0.24968010187149048,
-0.6412038803100586,
-0.37184470891952515,
-0.09593316912651062,
0.9248735904693604,
1.0893845558166504,
-0.34688839316368103,
0.387019544839859,
0.11474760621786118,
0.6236000061035156,
-0.7096359729766846,
-0.3711315393447876,
-0.8338783979415894,
-0.07892133295536041,
-0.3386494517326355,
0.25605374574661255,
-0.8123701810836792,
-0.3929915428161621,
-0.18939585983753204,
-0.4204728305339813,
0.06842860579490662,
0.41130319237709045,
0.6110873222351074,
0.15699875354766846,
-0.08851229399442673,
-0.004043017514050007,
-0.7835074067115784,
1.0871624946594238,
-0.8999297022819519,
0.5155097842216492,
0.4205559194087982,
0.428848534822464,
-0.19105787575244904,
-1.0003520250320435,
-0.302567720413208,
-0.31486237049102783,
-0.3328176736831665,
-0.5401909351348877,
-0.4929434061050415,
0.0450383685529232,
0.4183136522769928,
0.36540693044662476,
-0.3453509211540222,
0.3800390958786011,
0.07815404236316681,
0.06268732249736786,
0.24298007786273956,
0.4477998614311218,
0.2876952886581421,
0.03414219990372658,
-0.29736244678497314,
0.06552392989397049,
-0.7636224627494812,
0.09909425675868988,
0.06781420111656189,
0.475385457277298,
0.12871459126472473,
0.6974713802337646,
-0.15822158753871918,
0.752838671207428,
-0.23953887820243835,
-0.09060872346162796,
-0.11958365887403488,
-0.48746830224990845,
-0.5340193510055542,
-0.1013263612985611,
0.6888226866722107,
0.12081301957368851,
-0.048754844814538956,
-0.12321765720844269,
-0.3880625069141388,
-0.07696075737476349,
0.21519528329372406,
-0.9199362993240356,
-0.1062612384557724,
-0.19500766694545746,
-0.4150557518005371,
0.16859829425811768,
-0.32471954822540283,
-0.9431967735290527,
-0.6344607472419739,
-0.29033163189888,
0.40573850274086,
-0.3102204501628876,
0.11064965277910233,
0.27298158407211304,
0.09461656212806702,
-0.14774641394615173,
-0.004100294318050146,
-1.0551416873931885,
0.9537019729614258,
0.6995044350624084,
1.0488519668579102,
-0.03550654649734497,
-0.07515433430671692,
-0.9108665585517883,
0.2955063581466675,
-0.10564503073692322,
0.7468115091323853,
-0.6471230387687683,
-0.305392861366272,
-0.0775427371263504,
-0.26187893748283386,
-0.31399235129356384,
-0.7297360301017761,
0.5407974123954773,
-0.29535922408103943,
-0.2677536904811859,
-0.665176510810852,
-0.7685568332672119,
0.48319920897483826,
-0.19653372466564178,
-0.8159477710723877,
1.0739918947219849,
-0.16930828988552094,
-0.4213154911994934,
0.12226510047912598,
-0.5492942333221436,
-0.5131582617759705,
0.08237272500991821,
-0.2749914526939392,
-0.27865707874298096,
0.6305665969848633,
0.2691418528556824,
0.2756652534008026,
-0.7461444139480591,
-0.04861002042889595,
-0.40562984347343445,
-0.2799171209335327,
0.21489891409873962,
-0.1527012437582016,
0.4338836073875427,
0.3343507647514343,
-0.1293553113937378,
0.22199305891990662,
-0.6783249378204346,
0.03120129555463791,
0.32129746675491333,
-0.10925664007663727,
-0.3451347053050995,
0.4229756295681,
-0.3136560022830963,
-0.019170787185430527,
0.3354913294315338,
-0.6244405508041382,
0.2040073424577713,
-0.4494073688983917,
0.5301423668861389,
0.6820587515830994,
-0.17581063508987427,
0.7470909357070923,
-0.4429967403411865,
0.5719810128211975,
-0.38332340121269226,
0.2868250608444214,
-0.010107175447046757,
-0.2143501192331314,
-0.8560338616371155,
-0.41279783844947815,
0.10838596522808075,
0.12134869396686554,
-0.7610370516777039,
-0.22526897490024567,
-0.3367903232574463,
-0.3315463066101074,
-0.8686820268630981,
0.21809495985507965,
0.3218546211719513,
0.44808387756347656,
0.30045101046562195,
0.14363370835781097,
-0.47913166880607605,
-1.454866886138916,
-0.4415495693683624,
0.1875832974910736,
-0.06939014792442322,
0.631164014339447,
0.2394336313009262,
-0.07484899461269379,
0.8663551211357117,
-0.5576596856117249,
-0.0945134311914444,
-0.6566311717033386,
-0.1705930083990097,
0.5126140713691711,
0.314967542886734,
0.5085362792015076,
-0.45398053526878357,
-0.6471825242042542,
-0.05532768741250038,
-0.47434014081954956,
-0.3253900110721588,
-0.05712217837572098,
-0.12345623224973679,
0.20966653525829315,
0.33068472146987915,
-0.39784005284309387,
0.10438673198223114,
0.6298560500144958,
-0.14428110420703888,
0.31511160731315613,
-0.4990583658218384,
0.012587341479957104,
-0.5520001649856567,
-0.1154509112238884,
-0.16341117024421692,
-0.5496727824211121,
-0.7615293860435486,
-0.02910996600985527,
-0.11583461612462997,
-0.3388684391975403,
-0.4322487711906433,
0.6991509199142456,
-0.6623069047927856,
-0.604891300201416,
-0.39116597175598145,
0.12958277761936188,
0.04519422724843025,
0.18936890363693237,
-0.1876852661371231,
1.226308822631836,
0.5085740089416504,
-0.37486550211906433,
-0.18778672814369202,
-0.2445020079612732,
-0.3650151789188385,
0.23885393142700195,
-0.7875581979751587,
0.18682895600795746,
0.09146470576524734,
-0.1280469000339508,
-1.0033735036849976,
-0.0711350217461586,
-0.1427379995584488,
0.21958395838737488,
0.06821967661380768,
-0.027749182656407356,
-0.8547623157501221,
-0.18091228604316711,
-0.2653644382953644,
0.4246879518032074,
0.7750183939933777,
-0.5640334486961365,
0.679152250289917,
0.677142322063446,
0.06362998485565186,
-0.09542931616306305,
-0.5661015510559082,
-0.04582307115197182,
-0.18411242961883545,
-0.744316577911377,
0.23562665283679962,
0.0510881245136261,
-0.38793838024139404,
-0.1429983377456665,
-0.025879088789224625,
0.1651308685541153,
0.19185498356819153,
0.09613938629627228,
-0.04331933706998825,
-0.2925415635108948,
-0.10321078449487686,
-0.2426036149263382,
-0.009762405417859554,
-0.08461003005504608,
-0.2813987135887146,
0.8932762145996094,
-0.4705353379249573,
-0.3859155476093292,
-0.44643664360046387,
0.3711032271385193,
0.325198769569397,
0.011995825916528702,
1.0295263528823853,
0.11854507774114609,
-0.38100966811180115,
-0.3255292773246765,
-0.5912601351737976,
-0.0986187607049942,
-0.49139633774757385,
0.07687564939260483,
-0.5129794478416443,
-0.9019047617912292,
0.5564451217651367,
-0.05117049440741539,
-0.08151634782552719,
0.34384700655937195,
0.4808713495731354,
-0.11435907334089279,
0.9749159812927246,
0.5705232620239258,
-0.08417067676782608,
0.5627747774124146,
-0.055938515812158585,
0.039160482585430145,
-0.6954547762870789,
0.21245092153549194,
-0.7309303283691406,
-0.2497858852148056,
-0.5096774697303772,
-0.6129288673400879,
0.5006309151649475,
0.1844937652349472,
-0.4332124590873718,
0.3058355152606964,
-0.18807363510131836,
0.7458221316337585,
0.7073048949241638,
0.1567399799823761,
0.3915714919567108,
-0.0648040622472763,
-0.31498387455940247,
-0.22426389157772064,
-1.1094169616699219,
-0.8194020986557007,
0.7583810687065125,
0.4167706072330475,
0.8140538930892944,
-0.009349299594759941,
0.6672202944755554,
0.30339911580085754,
0.13605700433254242,
-0.3193240761756897,
0.7827017307281494,
-0.49699121713638306,
-0.34019559621810913,
-0.3474494516849518,
-0.5568784475326538,
-0.8515646457672119,
0.44691818952560425,
0.07733215391635895,
-1.1143022775650024,
-0.16744160652160645,
0.4339275360107422,
-0.2966100871562958,
0.5520709156990051,
-0.7809316515922546,
1.0573967695236206,
-0.21905219554901123,
-0.7194278240203857,
-0.4760489761829376,
-0.3260737657546997,
0.17590603232383728,
0.225271075963974,
0.3318062722682953,
-0.19799983501434326,
-0.18112701177597046,
0.6000080108642578,
-0.29467692971229553,
0.8441793322563171,
-0.22826750576496124,
0.2750793695449829,
0.06601008772850037,
0.0914616584777832,
0.6890403032302856,
0.09760236740112305,
-0.4136214852333069,
0.1204828992486,
-0.08768236637115479,
-0.5900995135307312,
-0.36944565176963806,
0.8945986032485962,
-0.5442696809768677,
-0.7002319097518921,
-0.34510472416877747,
-0.3198356628417969,
-0.32706984877586365,
0.3802844285964966,
-0.00012365389557089657,
0.19519245624542236,
-0.289299875497818,
0.21756936609745026,
0.8224369883537292,
-0.2765434682369232,
0.5825891494750977,
0.32534217834472656,
-0.5080257654190063,
-0.13408468663692474,
0.7772597074508667,
0.08461960405111313,
0.6542534232139587,
0.4373447000980377,
0.3870396316051483,
-0.12592792510986328,
-0.7624353766441345,
-0.3449181914329529,
0.256813645362854,
-0.42020994424819946,
-0.06894001364707947,
-0.5822113752365112,
0.05019795522093773,
-0.28140655159950256,
-0.16072866320610046,
-0.8102859258651733,
-0.16800808906555176,
-0.4626130759716034,
0.25782641768455505,
-0.0936967134475708,
0.6062611937522888,
0.016771581023931503,
0.6642802357673645,
-0.4432539641857147,
0.28173208236694336,
0.2435380220413208,
0.48072725534439087,
0.16088056564331055,
-0.3892098069190979,
-0.38511374592781067,
0.16936007142066956,
-0.17135384678840637,
-0.6217486262321472,
0.2112647294998169,
0.1487506479024887,
0.8153311014175415,
0.08075220882892609,
-0.24121426045894623,
0.5489928722381592,
-0.8188236355781555,
0.7747595906257629,
0.0672212541103363,
-0.9823527336120605,
0.4461415410041809,
-0.2605980336666107,
0.4271509647369385,
0.6841052174568176,
0.26554012298583984,
-0.39979034662246704,
-0.1289059966802597,
-0.5180999040603638,
-0.6740309000015259,
0.8530521988868713,
0.3227033019065857,
-0.08681891858577728,
-0.05297993868589401,
0.33812618255615234,
0.15205761790275574,
0.31956228613853455,
-0.7025173902511597,
-0.18151234090328217,
0.2234443575143814,
0.1126624122262001,
-0.2613154649734497,
-0.42650291323661804,
0.10528941452503204,
-0.18443043529987335,
0.856849730014801,
-0.21129503846168518,
0.33047178387641907,
-0.26414725184440613,
-0.1207592785358429,
-0.06670352071523666,
0.23500820994377136,
0.6629977822303772,
0.7630243301391602,
-0.30738675594329834,
0.41788405179977417,
0.29444965720176697,
0.0018093158723786473,
0.035344209522008896,
-0.10121467709541321,
-0.2891187071800232,
-0.07155460119247437,
0.22388365864753723,
1.161641001701355,
0.5031105875968933,
-0.8300765752792358,
0.19102995097637177,
-0.17889396846294403,
0.407803475856781,
-0.0499214306473732,
0.3054285943508148,
0.35255271196365356,
0.3295634686946869,
0.1768491119146347,
-0.20631514489650726,
0.04263833910226822,
-0.4582783579826355,
0.1364411860704422,
0.6809855103492737,
0.008920760825276375,
-0.09861060976982117,
0.7665475010871887,
-0.09215288609266281,
-0.6073682308197021,
0.41521304845809937,
-0.09153401851654053,
-0.1825120747089386,
0.30995482206344604,
0.6845986247062683,
0.6870123744010925,
0.18949325382709503,
0.010548947378993034,
0.03743898496031761,
0.3216310143470764,
-0.4083938002586365,
0.19427162408828735,
0.03272254019975662,
-0.7429894208908081,
-0.17050258815288544,
-0.9659578204154968,
-0.47704270482063293,
0.013878613710403442,
-0.838737428188324,
0.023242365568876266,
-0.39160436391830444,
-0.30569201707839966,
0.2803821861743927,
0.17221955955028534,
-0.709862232208252,
-0.2691757380962372,
0.2978484332561493,
0.977135181427002,
-0.7395241856575012,
1.1428921222686768,
0.5793249607086182,
-0.12726664543151855,
-0.3014094829559326,
-0.40466779470443726,
-0.2539762854576111,
-1.041079044342041,
0.3134557902812958,
-0.06834226101636887,
-0.2091275006532669,
-0.021047284826636314,
-0.23830866813659668,
-1.0077887773513794,
0.8942123651504517,
0.9399585723876953,
-0.7404606938362122,
-0.044435009360313416,
0.6093729138374329,
0.51493901014328,
-0.6157143712043762,
0.15332916378974915,
0.9293893575668335,
0.3289812505245209,
-0.16278338432312012,
-0.7876306772232056,
0.0009494561236351728,
0.34591585397720337,
0.615596354007721,
0.4347834885120392,
-0.5724680423736572,
0.9150100946426392,
-0.061636872589588165,
-0.08582060784101486,
0.1957114189863205,
0.8999608755111694,
0.42834198474884033,
0.3011675477027893,
0.5753397941589355,
0.6317440867424011,
0.745806872844696,
0.14516311883926392,
1.482260823249817,
-0.04794081300497055,
0.4417324662208557,
1.4101871252059937,
-0.6919364333152771,
0.9222854375839233,
0.8991307616233826,
-0.3686061203479767,
0.1882316917181015,
0.4242502748966217,
0.06448446959257126,
0.5808396935462952,
0.2660221457481384,
-0.2171960026025772,
-0.3899137079715729,
-0.488969624042511,
0.018250491470098495,
0.03710427135229111,
0.1376245617866516,
-0.35415709018707275,
-0.363341748714447,
0.32503288984298706,
0.018757689744234085,
0.4540167450904846,
-0.5244365334510803,
0.6873765587806702,
0.10987885296344757,
-0.5952601432800293,
0.30833086371421814,
0.0014942712150514126,
0.34790492057800293,
-0.45705676078796387,
0.2515999972820282,
-0.43056613206863403,
0.366176962852478,
0.34931889176368713,
-0.6318979859352112,
0.2470194548368454,
-0.09412336349487305,
-0.5834711790084839,
-0.5898057222366333,
0.8239548206329346,
-0.16257771849632263,
-0.5920442938804626,
0.45423564314842224,
0.39974334836006165,
-0.006204047705978155,
0.18198060989379883,
-0.48933640122413635,
0.45653676986694336,
-0.02920733392238617,
-0.21631009876728058,
0.8542985320091248,
0.15680795907974243,
0.19170260429382324,
0.6613141894340515,
0.35247915983200073,
0.2685536742210388,
0.36090585589408875,
0.06823816150426865,
0.7046666741371155,
-0.497938334941864,
-0.5115351676940918,
-1.1688125133514404,
0.11752454936504364,
-0.21761983633041382,
-0.09016060084104538,
0.7660216093063354,
0.7681655287742615,
0.8255513906478882,
-0.04352743923664093,
0.4448687732219696,
0.1104394719004631,
0.5610386729240417,
-0.6648535132408142,
0.42574241757392883,
-0.6204060316085815,
0.5181118845939636,
0.11584192514419556,
-0.5987345576286316,
0.13062648475170135,
0.3849605917930603,
-0.39946475625038147,
-0.19742359220981598,
0.41882607340812683,
0.6265854835510254,
-0.24067121744155884,
0.09594500064849854,
0.6038910746574402,
0.27765774726867676,
0.3339371681213379,
0.7562268376350403,
0.5597955584526062,
-0.3275042176246643,
0.07792264968156815,
-0.6126422882080078,
-0.027027778327465057,
-0.13167792558670044,
-1.0442302227020264,
-0.8619004487991333,
-0.20119161903858185,
0.04187202826142311,
-0.09278180450201035,
0.0866052508354187,
1.1473894119262695,
0.5895398259162903,
-0.759164571762085,
-0.7333557605743408,
-0.04585075378417969,
0.21937477588653564,
-0.3238498866558075,
-0.15447670221328735,
0.21793916821479797,
-0.45986783504486084,
-0.7415845394134521,
0.5926060676574707,
0.23346728086471558,
-0.18476787209510803,
-0.07883747667074203,
-0.02561248652637005,
-0.5709086060523987,
0.23156777024269104,
0.5433345437049866,
0.2711952328681946,
-0.6616222262382507,
-0.36182108521461487,
-0.03534906357526779,
-0.30739688873291016,
0.19011899828910828,
1.0497541427612305,
-0.6901785731315613,
0.21664412319660187,
0.2626248300075531,
1.1374346017837524,
0.7497878074645996,
-0.09354651719331741,
0.5353184342384338,
-0.7615107297897339,
0.16281789541244507,
0.32465603947639465,
0.6493885517120361,
0.15885639190673828,
-0.2501271665096283,
0.40156853199005127,
0.11289557069540024,
-0.7274617552757263,
-1.2833224534988403,
0.2065851390361786,
-0.7940795421600342,
-0.3554573357105255,
1.0775665044784546,
0.04373634234070778,
-0.19294023513793945,
0.5596988797187805,
0.10972060263156891,
0.03223439306020737,
-0.35902121663093567,
0.34998729825019836,
0.5221046805381775,
-0.5957508683204651,
-0.2559051811695099,
-0.8926187753677368,
0.4645717442035675,
0.6440740823745728,
-0.8227742314338684,
0.2952161729335785,
0.42656415700912476,
0.1509658247232437,
-0.1475769430398941,
0.8255236148834229,
0.4504939317703247,
-0.13389311730861664,
-0.017191318795084953,
-0.3511151969432831,
0.02136876992881298,
-0.4662916660308838,
-0.4130304455757141,
0.4228001832962036,
0.28536367416381836,
-0.08066470921039581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03344v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03344v2
|
Schroedinger's Threshold: When the AUC doesn't predict Accuracy
| 2024-04-04T10:18:03 | 2024-05-27T10:33:40 |
Juri Opitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Area Under Curve measure (AUC) seems apt to evaluate and compare diverse
models, possibly without calibration. An important example of AUC application
is the evaluation and benchmarking of models that predict faithfulness of
generated text. But we show that the AUC yields an academic and optimistic
notion of accuracy that can misalign with the actual accuracy observed in
application, yielding significant changes in benchmark rankings. To paint a
more realistic picture of downstream model performance (and prepare a model for
actual application), we explore different calibration modes, testing
calibration data and method.
|
[
-0.39152732491493225,
-0.7271766662597656,
0.892207145690918,
-0.19467172026634216,
-0.02457280270755291,
0.0026056948117911816,
0.3794662058353424,
-0.48483821749687195,
-0.1357506811618805,
0.4672265648841858,
-0.4303348660469055,
-0.2089364230632782,
-0.693450927734375,
0.031956493854522705,
-0.7800426483154297,
0.8051893711090088,
-0.44712892174720764,
-0.11548632383346558,
-0.16387827694416046,
-0.36389949917793274,
-0.40958884358406067,
-0.27352797985076904,
-0.5390466451644897,
-0.4608433246612549,
0.46055734157562256,
0.045147500932216644,
0.6463679075241089,
0.7997845411300659,
0.5028052926063538,
0.196030855178833,
0.008493497036397457,
-0.014732500538229942,
-0.23997244238853455,
0.1697639524936676,
0.1670491248369217,
-0.6962106823921204,
-0.1971411556005478,
0.25940853357315063,
0.8624938130378723,
0.8053496479988098,
-0.06654704362154007,
-0.13858479261398315,
0.23346193134784698,
0.772705078125,
-0.9997465014457703,
0.1616223156452179,
-0.6992848515510559,
-0.12224318832159042,
-0.18538260459899902,
-0.42292940616607666,
-0.5202147364616394,
-0.4629037082195282,
0.16890697181224823,
-0.3424590826034546,
0.41638603806495667,
-0.13701727986335754,
0.8920327425003052,
0.5054886341094971,
-0.8771449327468872,
-0.307828426361084,
-0.9151421785354614,
0.8900836110115051,
-0.737555205821991,
0.4768967628479004,
0.6738023161888123,
0.26754188537597656,
0.031499773263931274,
-0.7254838943481445,
-0.2565478980541229,
-0.3473435938358307,
0.3150348961353302,
0.2518823742866516,
-0.5793491005897522,
-0.01848403736948967,
0.47201380133628845,
0.4606766700744629,
-0.2999628484249115,
-0.05091124400496483,
-0.48481184244155884,
-0.12617960572242737,
0.5831825733184814,
0.5517954230308533,
-0.20664498209953308,
0.10396730899810791,
-0.2705758810043335,
-0.08092495054006577,
-0.5204992294311523,
0.45747238397598267,
0.5401089787483215,
0.41697537899017334,
0.0670071542263031,
0.554100513458252,
-0.20739978551864624,
0.6790894865989685,
0.07527706027030945,
0.33312973380088806,
0.10053636878728867,
0.08028193563222885,
0.034474194049835205,
0.24348141252994537,
0.3330129384994507,
0.24966759979724884,
0.09809282422065735,
0.015080579556524754,
-0.2923991084098816,
0.7998740077018738,
0.7506610751152039,
-0.5518389940261841,
-0.2517378330230713,
0.30324435234069824,
-0.3006145656108856,
-0.3983760178089142,
0.3672957718372345,
-0.3217902183532715,
-0.004491790663450956,
-0.3984946608543396,
0.378386914730072,
-0.10899396240711212,
0.10320571810007095,
-0.18194492161273956,
-0.16151034832000732,
-0.10300290584564209,
0.2201092392206192,
-0.686867356300354,
0.2358609288930893,
0.4656006991863251,
0.9525458216667175,
-0.17787420749664307,
-0.2958076298236847,
-0.43124935030937195,
-0.026085173711180687,
-0.878135085105896,
0.9766156673431396,
-0.5019051432609558,
-0.5041480660438538,
-0.04402417317032814,
-0.053412098437547684,
-0.08607423305511475,
-0.26582011580467224,
0.6707242727279663,
-0.4708799123764038,
-0.3706793785095215,
-0.1939316838979721,
-0.6792927980422974,
-0.26758554577827454,
-0.18008826673030853,
-0.8030243515968323,
0.9936298727989197,
0.3890070617198944,
-0.7679109573364258,
0.6487108469009399,
-0.5748215317726135,
-0.2506517469882965,
-0.013675562106072903,
-0.11422205716371536,
-0.20553947985172272,
0.3058225214481354,
-0.09014854580163956,
0.11513994634151459,
0.062424808740615845,
-0.11421962827444077,
-0.37810513377189636,
-0.5692563652992249,
0.658280611038208,
-0.7766612768173218,
0.7432811260223389,
0.42740392684936523,
-0.31680789589881897,
-0.032511282712221146,
-0.5109034180641174,
0.2689274549484253,
-0.3840712308883667,
-0.26144838333129883,
-0.448547899723053,
0.16767583787441254,
0.13132812082767487,
0.03745134919881821,
-0.1739078313112259,
-0.5169820785522461,
-0.14579008519649506,
-0.24475696682929993,
0.6649367213249207,
0.8829221725463867,
0.06265942752361298,
0.40693747997283936,
-0.6380392909049988,
0.5834616422653198,
-0.2136029452085495,
-0.0901031643152237,
0.13546617329120636,
-0.6253530979156494,
-0.7217847108840942,
0.24404966831207275,
0.6706467270851135,
0.5642293691635132,
-0.45741915702819824,
0.4936806261539459,
-0.18449077010154724,
-0.9385236501693726,
-0.3248980641365051,
-0.05118488520383835,
0.02538071572780609,
0.6279122233390808,
0.19131174683570862,
-0.8639410138130188,
-0.024172356352210045,
-0.6743060350418091,
-0.6962699294090271,
-0.17303596436977386,
-0.3341981768608093,
0.34836873412132263,
0.37534016370773315,
-0.1979922354221344,
0.7822985053062439,
-0.19241569936275482,
-0.27046680450439453,
-0.06663671880960464,
0.46473705768585205,
-0.046504877507686615,
0.45415225625038147,
0.29578354954719543,
-0.6725797653198242,
-0.2833133041858673,
-0.2867036461830139,
-0.5527350306510925,
-0.30527693033218384,
0.03467200696468353,
-0.22312848269939423,
0.22868278622627258,
0.42028307914733887,
-0.32771971821784973,
1.0002721548080444,
0.6907790303230286,
-0.3301316797733307,
0.49327561259269714,
-0.3580997884273529,
0.6764240264892578,
-0.41924789547920227,
0.07608804106712341,
0.534998893737793,
-0.0298344474285841,
-0.5796740055084229,
-0.08412997424602509,
0.38597437739372253,
0.15604160726070404,
-0.2297971248626709,
0.30754613876342773,
-0.09648850560188293,
-0.07905817776918411,
-0.4459260404109955,
0.10078465938568115,
0.03694416955113411,
-0.04097336530685425,
-0.13857579231262207,
0.6170296669006348,
0.23582452535629272,
-0.7645201683044434,
-0.02091839723289013,
0.13834214210510254,
-0.589802086353302,
0.6473423838615417,
-0.5474278330802917,
-0.07987746596336365,
0.15869605541229248,
0.45394036173820496,
-0.7471673488616943,
-0.28774726390838623,
-0.16557468473911285,
-0.5504538416862488,
0.07708435505628586,
-0.09589871019124985,
-0.17766855657100677,
-0.23140299320220947,
-0.12360221147537231,
0.6616517305374146,
0.5639562010765076,
-0.14144864678382874,
0.723106324672699,
0.38941437005996704,
0.11004350334405899,
-0.45633962750434875,
-1.2328075170516968,
-0.30020612478256226,
-0.3747505247592926,
-0.35919466614723206,
0.24203957617282867,
0.01482225302606821,
-0.29256585240364075,
-0.2019420713186264,
-0.20059174299240112,
-0.052103009074926376,
0.1727467179298401,
0.5724579691886902,
0.25929316878318787,
-0.12354496866464615,
0.013718485832214355,
0.22407397627830505,
-0.46381840109825134,
0.23067428171634674,
0.31072279810905457,
0.27205851674079895,
-0.1640273779630661,
-0.6217576265335083,
-0.7704392671585083,
0.2290646731853485,
0.369387149810791,
0.0029588104225695133,
0.21562600135803223,
-0.04366430640220642,
-0.6622994542121887,
-0.06893009692430496,
-0.31366589665412903,
-0.3462916314601898,
-0.40407633781433105,
0.10281558334827423,
-0.3601166605949402,
-0.36702409386634827,
0.7591894268989563,
-0.06073230504989624,
0.060067035257816315,
0.8887401223182678,
0.16910013556480408,
-0.024376699700951576,
1.5858248472213745,
0.8265818357467651,
0.3201321065425873,
0.4751673638820648,
-0.29911965131759644,
0.7067998051643372,
-0.8778428435325623,
0.26922857761383057,
-1.0617343187332153,
-0.1578686386346817,
-0.8195955753326416,
-0.08488919585943222,
0.274326354265213,
0.38307684659957886,
-0.5817080140113831,
0.5463517308235168,
-0.4587028920650482,
0.23635077476501465,
0.5406720638275146,
-0.027367210015654564,
0.5085126161575317,
0.04831375554203987,
0.10952221602201462,
-0.4299444854259491,
-0.7472447156906128,
-0.885628879070282,
1.1178152561187744,
0.4213886857032776,
0.7293679714202881,
-0.3314601480960846,
0.2027013748884201,
0.7307000160217285,
0.708688497543335,
-0.7000155448913574,
-0.048933323472738266,
-0.20963715016841888,
-0.9093834757804871,
-0.22062140703201294,
-0.6445749402046204,
-0.8359114527702332,
-0.01680762879550457,
-0.1089194267988205,
-1.1576849222183228,
0.5523386597633362,
0.22323229908943176,
-0.5066671967506409,
0.4875273108482361,
-0.4582395851612091,
0.9833180904388428,
-0.10525230318307877,
-0.15227971971035004,
-0.20609290897846222,
-0.13772594928741455,
0.04393894970417023,
-0.25251248478889465,
0.27971363067626953,
-0.3665652275085449,
-0.0014593681553378701,
0.7601786255836487,
-0.3489837050437927,
0.37774625420570374,
0.0838552862405777,
0.04761844128370285,
0.5964021682739258,
0.549706220626831,
0.31968605518341064,
-0.21023225784301758,
-0.41826361417770386,
0.5700415968894958,
0.24762843549251556,
-0.5266771912574768,
-0.43028274178504944,
0.6357711553573608,
-0.557588517665863,
-0.03194234147667885,
-0.7018616795539856,
-0.5204694867134094,
-0.3630291819572449,
0.04990210011601448,
0.5526429414749146,
0.599065899848938,
0.052543796598911285,
0.05265273526310921,
0.00429544597864151,
0.31695637106895447,
0.21183304488658905,
0.13571254909038544,
0.19471852481365204,
-0.04565267637372017,
0.6249684691429138,
0.3494356572628021,
0.29464173316955566,
-0.17565451562404633,
-0.02605975978076458,
-0.3951503038406372,
-0.4440103769302368,
-0.6718467473983765,
-0.17271432280540466,
-0.9603758454322815,
-0.36038413643836975,
-0.42195776104927063,
-0.5091521739959717,
-0.2447759360074997,
-0.5837365984916687,
-0.3726429343223572,
-0.09604068845510483,
-0.09582340717315674,
-0.10848569124937057,
0.33509016036987305,
0.8542681336402893,
-0.13804225623607635,
0.42091041803359985,
-0.8107734322547913,
-0.1079772338271141,
-0.02741248533129692,
0.3237799406051636,
0.11030083894729614,
-0.7282858490943909,
-0.12264055758714676,
0.43686583638191223,
-0.7563220858573914,
-0.6485550403594971,
0.34917259216308594,
0.0407099574804306,
0.6945646405220032,
0.4651494026184082,
0.33731451630592346,
0.547978937625885,
-0.18680617213249207,
0.6455667614936829,
0.12715621292591095,
-1.3697155714035034,
0.7296411991119385,
-0.025747166946530342,
0.2861974239349365,
0.7083773016929626,
0.5489151477813721,
-0.32789409160614014,
-0.7723101377487183,
-0.8427586555480957,
-1.0246702432632446,
0.3822925090789795,
0.3992314338684082,
0.20114420354366302,
0.2784774601459503,
0.4436330795288086,
0.14639629423618317,
0.08330636471509933,
-0.7208414673805237,
-0.1980460286140442,
-0.06707490980625153,
-0.24331921339035034,
-0.2025011032819748,
0.04340504854917526,
-0.08960264921188354,
0.051371920853853226,
0.7308289408683777,
-0.2999691963195801,
0.08432424813508987,
0.3219790458679199,
0.2032555788755417,
-0.802570104598999,
-0.024774771183729172,
0.13399842381477356,
1.0763930082321167,
-0.2519665062427521,
0.11674131453037262,
0.29171305894851685,
-0.4876062572002411,
-0.010252024047076702,
0.09638267010450363,
-0.49312570691108704,
-0.1725141406059265,
0.6684131026268005,
0.5886990427970886,
0.0550617054104805,
-0.6170436143875122,
0.29993754625320435,
-0.1572476178407669,
-0.25766390562057495,
-0.1803950071334839,
0.3995498716831207,
-0.5155826807022095,
0.14359380304813385,
0.7493634819984436,
0.5227517485618591,
0.41669023036956787,
-0.5076437592506409,
0.2695232927799225,
0.3217802345752716,
-1.0193729400634766,
0.22032538056373596,
0.9337905049324036,
-0.1316644847393036,
-0.31328076124191284,
0.7719898223876953,
0.3030225932598114,
-0.5916895270347595,
0.8213427066802979,
0.06278815865516663,
0.6358296275138855,
-0.17532135546207428,
-0.061965301632881165,
0.49973106384277344,
0.36736515164375305,
-0.10280703753232956,
-0.13354088366031647,
-0.007325213402509689,
-0.60457444190979,
-0.31458625197410583,
-0.33443164825439453,
-0.2924700379371643,
-0.0959751307964325,
-0.9394565224647522,
0.07365929335355759,
-0.27864718437194824,
-0.6751695871353149,
0.34170329570770264,
0.17772641777992249,
-0.5032064914703369,
0.4106214642524719,
-0.24960027635097504,
0.8583509922027588,
-1.265846848487854,
0.6185370087623596,
0.12476598471403122,
-0.27178260684013367,
-1.084736943244934,
0.07765007019042969,
-0.1895870715379715,
-0.34525471925735474,
0.02629755809903145,
0.5373411178588867,
-0.1579645723104477,
-0.09504556655883789,
-0.4746640920639038,
-0.6876407861709595,
1.0589650869369507,
0.0998740941286087,
-0.3206886649131775,
0.2817489206790924,
0.07730387896299362,
0.6119774580001831,
-0.5250336527824402,
0.4296167194843292,
0.6986986994743347,
0.35146060585975647,
-0.23367704451084137,
-0.9153186082839966,
0.00713947182521224,
-0.09429427236318588,
0.2622905373573303,
0.20583634078502655,
-0.40442144870758057,
1.0568519830703735,
-0.060140322893857956,
-0.3363717496395111,
0.2987380027770996,
0.31677135825157166,
0.4124312400817871,
0.6094362735748291,
0.7741710543632507,
0.5412721037864685,
0.3795834183692932,
-0.596219539642334,
1.2899364233016968,
-0.21710368990898132,
0.5717101693153381,
0.6206234097480774,
-0.4541895389556885,
1.06562340259552,
0.42317691445350647,
-0.34891194105148315,
0.5509443283081055,
0.9711256623268127,
-0.04046125337481499,
0.6313701272010803,
0.07255897670984268,
-0.1873071938753128,
-0.5028152465820312,
-0.13435445725917816,
-0.42851051688194275,
0.40873992443084717,
0.3116024136543274,
-0.40279585123062134,
-0.07866732031106949,
-0.3387955129146576,
-0.6080707907676697,
0.24975286424160004,
-0.4364813268184662,
0.34650862216949463,
0.36343881487846375,
-0.5938509702682495,
0.33036115765571594,
0.054740410298109055,
0.3397656977176666,
-0.47563084959983826,
-0.15347601473331451,
-0.10700591653585434,
0.41782835125923157,
-0.27223679423332214,
-0.8220243453979492,
0.3321033716201782,
-0.04974900558590889,
0.0324367918074131,
0.043728310614824295,
0.6066544651985168,
0.053492095321416855,
-0.6602567434310913,
0.3987062871456146,
0.3765734136104584,
0.3247866630554199,
-0.037749726325273514,
-0.6668508648872375,
0.08508256822824478,
-0.07971828430891037,
-0.17689181864261627,
-0.021900266408920288,
0.2801036238670349,
-0.13042181730270386,
0.7680814266204834,
0.6813042163848877,
0.18532532453536987,
-0.174247607588768,
-0.0005125284078530967,
0.23994895815849304,
-0.414133757352829,
-0.7645293474197388,
-0.3656105101108551,
0.6245142221450806,
0.05688731372356415,
-0.6479607820510864,
0.6766850352287292,
0.5099625587463379,
1.0987780094146729,
0.23342885076999664,
0.6905654072761536,
0.15847136080265045,
0.4889511168003082,
-0.4619632661342621,
0.7668136954307556,
-0.722922146320343,
0.15154579281806946,
-0.44036296010017395,
-1.1353862285614014,
-0.23225060105323792,
1.1168835163116455,
-0.5173903107643127,
0.6201155781745911,
0.6726120114326477,
0.5440399050712585,
-0.2068113535642624,
0.4762071967124939,
0.2992538511753082,
0.03453892469406128,
0.07540950924158096,
0.5396192669868469,
1.020696759223938,
-0.948115348815918,
0.2762097418308258,
-0.5944904088973999,
-0.39059320092201233,
-0.21091149747371674,
-0.7665761113166809,
-0.42843419313430786,
-0.7447826266288757,
-0.3945533335208893,
-0.8066709041595459,
-0.17250853776931763,
0.1362861543893814,
0.7819046974182129,
-0.9741436839103699,
-0.14598582684993744,
-0.49561402201652527,
-0.14621467888355255,
-0.39440128207206726,
-0.24810180068016052,
0.3043484389781952,
0.13861767947673798,
-0.6904983520507812,
0.10354595631361008,
0.03572995215654373,
0.3354390859603882,
-0.24398642778396606,
-0.0064527117647230625,
0.22899775207042694,
0.3029847741127014,
-0.06686416268348694,
0.2000686377286911,
-0.7154430150985718,
-0.3952535092830658,
-0.325953871011734,
-0.2823692858219147,
0.13161659240722656,
1.0909688472747803,
-0.7341024279594421,
0.19723264873027802,
0.1817494034767151,
0.507394015789032,
0.47308698296546936,
0.07277154922485352,
0.5393423438072205,
0.027127372100949287,
-0.03330149129033089,
0.4216421842575073,
0.3498618006706238,
0.18844351172447205,
-0.4496512711048126,
0.4603835940361023,
-0.03959232196211815,
-0.9126196503639221,
-1.1129136085510254,
0.2588401138782501,
-0.9874411225318909,
-0.2567162811756134,
0.538003146648407,
-0.15946492552757263,
-0.24215687811374664,
-0.24996168911457062,
0.10101483762264252,
0.35204261541366577,
-0.4800087511539459,
1.0514543056488037,
0.7758691310882568,
-0.38780102133750916,
0.23489458858966827,
-1.047750473022461,
0.3533424735069275,
0.47217342257499695,
-0.45435988903045654,
0.21001200377941132,
0.432061105966568,
0.21898451447486877,
0.24459148943424225,
0.4099363386631012,
0.07064195722341537,
0.36729758977890015,
0.6594491600990295,
-0.4614337384700775,
0.5181751251220703,
-0.11492098122835159,
-0.4468126893043518,
-0.040100350975990295,
0.35323554277420044,
0.2520742118358612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15320v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15320v2
|
Using Large Language Models to Enrich the Documentation of Datasets for Machine Learning
| 2024-04-04T10:09:28 | 2024-05-24T11:25:49 |
Joan Giner-Miguelez, Abel Gómez, Jordi Cabot
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.4.4
|
Recent regulatory initiatives like the European AI Act and relevant voices in
the Machine Learning (ML) community stress the need to describe datasets along
several key dimensions for trustworthy AI, such as the provenance processes and
social concerns. However, this information is typically presented as
unstructured text in accompanying documentation, hampering their automated
analysis and processing. In this work, we explore using large language models
(LLM) and a set of prompting strategies to automatically extract these
dimensions from documents and enrich the dataset description with them. Our
approach could aid data publishers and practitioners in creating
machine-readable documentation to improve the discoverability of their
datasets, assess their compliance with current AI regulations, and improve the
overall quality of ML models trained on them.
In this paper, we evaluate the approach on 12 scientific dataset papers
published in two scientific journals (Nature's Scientific Data and Elsevier's
Data in Brief) using two different LLMs (GPT3.5 and Flan-UL2). Results show
good accuracy with our prompt extraction strategies. Concrete results vary
depending on the dimensions, but overall, GPT3.5 shows slightly better accuracy
(81,21%) than FLAN-UL2 (69,13%) although it is more prone to hallucinations. We
have released an open-source tool implementing our approach and a replication
package, including the experiments' code and results, in an open-source
repository.
|
[
-0.2288249135017395,
-0.5961935520172119,
0.6136543154716492,
0.0754011869430542,
-0.1192527636885643,
-0.15720134973526,
-0.48054537177085876,
-0.4688780903816223,
-0.0491490364074707,
0.6530995965003967,
-0.2404337078332901,
-0.6751041412353516,
-0.653160035610199,
0.3816887438297272,
-0.4028615653514862,
0.9621739983558655,
-0.3163544535636902,
0.1428099125623703,
-0.5414204001426697,
-0.10008460283279419,
-0.13857011497020721,
-0.3870950937271118,
-0.2612611949443817,
-0.4651922881603241,
0.679286539554596,
0.1246766597032547,
0.4840446710586548,
0.9400036931037903,
0.5101218819618225,
0.2700148820877075,
-0.0670209676027298,
0.516533613204956,
-0.21105636656284332,
0.2912963032722473,
-0.15777750313282013,
-0.3481386601924896,
-0.3347001075744629,
0.09634310752153397,
0.6844570636749268,
0.6526187062263489,
0.13051919639110565,
0.16162319481372833,
0.27622106671333313,
0.5649945139884949,
-0.29667603969573975,
0.7947031259536743,
-0.3962891697883606,
-0.03430243581533432,
0.05835319310426712,
-0.3130146563053131,
-0.6004762053489685,
-0.09352590143680573,
0.1403505653142929,
-0.815079391002655,
0.3249782621860504,
-0.0840759426355362,
0.7088286876678467,
0.43817558884620667,
-0.20443689823150635,
-0.40898796916007996,
-0.6866487264633179,
0.685975968837738,
-0.6766278743743896,
0.17115254700183868,
0.5074109435081482,
0.22600512206554413,
-0.19157075881958008,
-0.7404435276985168,
-0.508787214756012,
-0.5009636878967285,
-0.38117867708206177,
-0.07051054388284683,
-0.13843601942062378,
-0.06249118968844414,
0.6420275568962097,
0.13148947060108185,
-0.5709942579269409,
0.5388458967208862,
-0.48457473516464233,
-0.17664991319179535,
0.7462285161018372,
0.01220988854765892,
0.03284425288438797,
-0.10335242003202438,
0.17735661566257477,
-0.34723347425460815,
-0.7648231387138367,
-0.1282605677843094,
0.4125176668167114,
0.5571717619895935,
0.01573196053504944,
0.6853936314582825,
-0.03512847423553467,
0.640661358833313,
-0.28242453932762146,
-0.031419139355421066,
0.3385348916053772,
-0.2760203182697296,
-0.16998811066150665,
-0.055487010627985,
0.7712781429290771,
0.12366814911365509,
0.21163982152938843,
-0.09606260061264038,
-0.18720266222953796,
-0.2601034641265869,
0.22724582254886627,
-0.8568770289421082,
-0.3448500633239746,
0.3516894280910492,
-0.6909249424934387,
-0.2722141444683075,
0.25090500712394714,
-0.7792243361473083,
-0.7551568746566772,
-0.8655769228935242,
0.2287372648715973,
-0.30028390884399414,
-0.012590713798999786,
-0.15709298849105835,
-0.04917479678988457,
0.14191828668117523,
0.5114036202430725,
-0.690842866897583,
-0.1734117865562439,
0.8797390460968018,
0.8065321445465088,
-0.05968355014920235,
-0.26442861557006836,
-0.5296350121498108,
0.07565292716026306,
-0.21530477702617645,
0.601268470287323,
-0.6338679790496826,
-0.4180026054382324,
0.006223213858902454,
0.28110674023628235,
0.14045652747154236,
-0.3356214761734009,
0.5011026263237,
-0.3698290288448334,
0.4139570891857147,
-0.2809262275695801,
-0.6365326046943665,
-0.4022167921066284,
0.21542614698410034,
-0.8646038770675659,
0.8199450969696045,
0.12278416007757187,
-0.7192515730857849,
0.48764145374298096,
-0.9659561514854431,
-0.4030308127403259,
0.14042288064956665,
-0.30004382133483887,
-0.48880887031555176,
-0.016911163926124573,
0.649278998374939,
0.7377612590789795,
-0.30863964557647705,
0.378292441368103,
-0.3593643307685852,
-0.1726703643798828,
0.23568852245807648,
-0.5279505848884583,
0.888577401638031,
0.1437433660030365,
-0.1561041921377182,
0.28701189160346985,
-0.735490083694458,
-0.09780320525169373,
0.011874706484377384,
-0.29220059514045715,
-0.17825797200202942,
-0.08109839260578156,
-0.06185479462146759,
0.10464052110910416,
0.11282501369714737,
-0.2730729877948761,
0.48411086201667786,
-0.1846541166305542,
0.6037387251853943,
0.6866562366485596,
-0.018963944166898727,
0.27134671807289124,
-0.3109952211380005,
0.42477136850357056,
0.02555481716990471,
0.1292436271905899,
-0.6763486862182617,
-0.3783530592918396,
-0.6272181868553162,
-0.5115558505058289,
0.4758768677711487,
0.40739887952804565,
-0.6894496083259583,
0.81952303647995,
-0.4442749619483948,
-0.5314631462097168,
-0.8029862642288208,
0.2869916260242462,
0.2373259961605072,
0.6452828049659729,
0.384572297334671,
0.22402213513851166,
-0.621204674243927,
-0.6925224661827087,
0.08571150153875351,
-0.19515927135944366,
-0.36642688512802124,
0.41337183117866516,
0.8422131538391113,
-0.41290274262428284,
0.7792445421218872,
-0.1622169315814972,
-0.128598153591156,
-0.09909511357545853,
0.35623130202293396,
0.2087750881910324,
0.36757734417915344,
0.28492990136146545,
-0.7320442795753479,
-0.3905107378959656,
0.10214591771364212,
-1.1452276706695557,
-0.05430517718195915,
-0.23482365906238556,
0.17944017052650452,
0.41337206959724426,
0.44369491934776306,
-0.6246864199638367,
0.25775468349456787,
0.10682634264230728,
-0.07038560509681702,
0.4593014717102051,
-0.42509445548057556,
0.08749513328075409,
-1.0644755363464355,
0.5094665288925171,
0.14748960733413696,
-0.07032374292612076,
-0.47232916951179504,
0.1008087545633316,
0.1367051601409912,
-0.04486406594514847,
-0.17912797629833221,
0.511708676815033,
-0.4782867431640625,
-0.06449583172798157,
-0.08973592519760132,
0.04562656208872795,
0.20185385644435883,
0.0740850418806076,
0.11931625008583069,
0.6191800832748413,
0.7344768643379211,
-0.5867816209793091,
0.4696524441242218,
0.42942214012145996,
-0.3421512544155121,
0.4362599551677704,
-0.6283561587333679,
0.1700589805841446,
-0.4260781407356262,
0.6855902075767517,
-0.37995409965515137,
-0.46527037024497986,
0.20228815078735352,
-0.3814067244529724,
0.48085829615592957,
-0.23780040442943573,
-0.9067317843437195,
-0.531178891658783,
-0.1923743188381195,
-0.2622915506362915,
0.4719434380531311,
-0.6897023320198059,
0.6437774896621704,
0.2075440138578415,
-0.08943601697683334,
-0.43042781949043274,
-0.4787978529930115,
0.2518578767776489,
-0.34504610300064087,
-0.5866245627403259,
0.07025611400604248,
-0.035795655101537704,
-0.34729790687561035,
-0.1181144192814827,
0.2773399353027344,
0.18133917450904846,
0.18012621998786926,
0.3854076862335205,
0.37391290068626404,
-0.2532525062561035,
0.37090060114860535,
-0.15932363271713257,
-0.13659106194972992,
0.20609299838542938,
-0.5421932339668274,
0.2856335937976837,
-0.012139605358242989,
-0.30249208211898804,
-0.5594664812088013,
0.32422688603401184,
0.5693593621253967,
-0.2568837106227875,
0.7632582187652588,
0.752393901348114,
-0.39556121826171875,
-0.36064913868904114,
-0.2484021931886673,
-0.3520441949367523,
-0.4438263475894928,
0.10536608099937439,
-0.1253185123205185,
-0.7185491323471069,
0.4446493089199066,
0.0015989908715710044,
0.25737059116363525,
0.5601668357849121,
0.5140317678451538,
-0.30392199754714966,
1.008586049079895,
0.6792575716972351,
-0.25589871406555176,
0.23284856975078583,
-0.3681655526161194,
0.22498150169849396,
-0.5739192962646484,
-0.5358970761299133,
-0.8456357717514038,
-0.18100804090499878,
-0.5044400095939636,
-0.4564909338951111,
0.26258015632629395,
-0.11166046559810638,
-0.17629046738147736,
0.08180486410856247,
-0.4866786003112793,
0.5108917355537415,
0.5575788021087646,
0.06047813594341278,
0.24042010307312012,
0.23060494661331177,
0.0761689841747284,
0.13587915897369385,
-0.5015311241149902,
-0.8736389875411987,
1.2368310689926147,
0.6510080695152283,
0.6622734069824219,
-0.4102499485015869,
0.5984639525413513,
0.3525160551071167,
0.3890276551246643,
-0.694922924041748,
0.31306806206703186,
-0.16658088564872742,
-0.23286744952201843,
-0.3599703013896942,
-0.5837177634239197,
-0.9220085144042969,
-0.11857239156961441,
-0.11930136382579803,
-0.6283458471298218,
0.15357501804828644,
0.08816391229629517,
-0.08413087576627731,
0.1648789495229721,
-0.36773911118507385,
0.5379594564437866,
-0.35368338227272034,
-0.11046329140663147,
-0.017714625224471092,
-0.6837141513824463,
0.11723072081804276,
-0.25139284133911133,
0.20019716024398804,
0.16303248703479767,
0.10955386608839035,
0.6803959608078003,
-0.36720460653305054,
0.8007410764694214,
-0.25905075669288635,
-0.3841492235660553,
0.188192218542099,
-0.1569925993680954,
0.8550302386283875,
-0.006620681844651699,
-0.3099669814109802,
0.2537728548049927,
-0.056909482926130295,
-0.2249370515346527,
-0.7880396842956543,
0.5400663614273071,
-0.6019900441169739,
-0.3304251730442047,
-0.0795922502875328,
-0.7422364354133606,
-0.13229697942733765,
0.12775982916355133,
0.1549910604953766,
0.31428760290145874,
0.00014457968063652515,
0.49068689346313477,
0.9634668827056885,
-0.31590765714645386,
0.15934646129608154,
0.6515786051750183,
-0.11485228687524796,
-0.11422611773014069,
0.8995264172554016,
0.1039796844124794,
-0.1488935500383377,
0.35674241185188293,
0.24964410066604614,
-0.4408701956272125,
-0.4582154154777527,
-0.2955798804759979,
0.28183937072753906,
-0.8218573927879333,
-0.21816185116767883,
-0.8179606199264526,
-0.22878727316856384,
-0.6196424961090088,
-0.03668489307165146,
0.2408457249403,
-0.4301935136318207,
-0.6666523218154907,
-0.29104554653167725,
0.5731568336486816,
0.7350507378578186,
-0.07391570508480072,
0.08864019811153412,
-0.8055077791213989,
0.12769179046154022,
-0.1489173173904419,
0.10759547352790833,
-0.08604815602302551,
-0.5492759346961975,
-0.2708580493927002,
0.14698490500450134,
0.0944192185997963,
-0.44491779804229736,
0.3960551917552948,
0.09603821486234665,
0.7108860611915588,
0.46475160121917725,
-0.0698152706027031,
0.379229873418808,
-0.286397248506546,
0.7580174803733826,
-0.10276748239994049,
-0.5519246459007263,
0.7459741234779358,
-0.4856047034263611,
-0.051386140286922455,
0.4827873706817627,
0.6163049340248108,
-0.23262721300125122,
-0.326809823513031,
-0.5470450520515442,
-0.7337942719459534,
0.487487256526947,
0.028207261115312576,
0.07192656397819519,
0.33466917276382446,
0.39870232343673706,
0.40410563349723816,
0.21069428324699402,
-0.36571741104125977,
-0.09300762414932251,
-0.18950720131397247,
-0.4620507061481476,
-0.2908003032207489,
-0.07013049721717834,
-0.477353572845459,
-0.13331012427806854,
0.7426133155822754,
-0.3076193332672119,
0.0649932473897934,
-0.09261991828680038,
-0.2045833319425583,
0.17444336414337158,
0.12694098055362701,
0.28641191124916077,
0.7415493726730347,
0.0010040889028459787,
0.13169217109680176,
-0.1567865014076233,
-0.3160690367221832,
-0.10665038228034973,
0.4309542179107666,
-0.43197962641716003,
0.017351770773530006,
0.6624278426170349,
0.6472117304801941,
-0.32522404193878174,
-0.6821742653846741,
0.20904235541820526,
0.010071614757180214,
-0.40793853998184204,
-0.053691890090703964,
0.14143703877925873,
-0.10392877459526062,
0.25388073921203613,
0.2450060099363327,
-0.31987324357032776,
0.05080169811844826,
-0.3275104761123657,
0.24218793213367462,
0.26388418674468994,
-0.1501414179801941,
-0.029442137107253075,
0.3098444938659668,
0.0668390691280365,
-0.1239432692527771,
0.7525140643119812,
-0.11797337979078293,
-0.3601827025413513,
0.651221752166748,
0.38732558488845825,
0.62635737657547,
0.11303463578224182,
0.48038408160209656,
0.3486476242542267,
0.30721497535705566,
-0.361920565366745,
0.16797709465026855,
-0.13825853168964386,
-0.28836336731910706,
-0.38469016551971436,
-0.5977419018745422,
-0.39258429408073425,
0.31998658180236816,
-0.6202000975608826,
0.24918265640735626,
-0.31342819333076477,
0.18796484172344208,
0.2017064392566681,
0.2563513517379761,
-0.765396773815155,
-0.0622640959918499,
0.19087465107440948,
0.973738968372345,
-1.0019606351852417,
0.768336296081543,
0.4082162082195282,
-0.5943552255630493,
-0.7309461236000061,
-0.1856825351715088,
0.09067032486200333,
-0.5695326328277588,
0.5877324938774109,
0.2268771529197693,
0.38892853260040283,
-0.1905943900346756,
-0.8848035931587219,
-0.6754785180091858,
1.1546648740768433,
0.27733147144317627,
-0.5815550684928894,
0.02278309315443039,
0.11429157853126526,
0.7884631156921387,
-0.4322916567325592,
0.08304445445537567,
0.5669540762901306,
0.9592238664627075,
0.04722292348742485,
-0.6124032735824585,
0.14523667097091675,
-0.4330585300922394,
-0.15397295355796814,
-0.1636240929365158,
-0.19195100665092468,
0.5325940251350403,
-0.15346422791481018,
0.002385219791904092,
-0.0565425269305706,
0.6952604055404663,
0.2330109179019928,
0.2575042247772217,
0.21655966341495514,
0.29977306723594666,
1.4322384595870972,
0.013214525766670704,
0.950328528881073,
-0.17759869992733002,
0.09529554843902588,
1.1684391498565674,
-0.3740900456905365,
0.6478592753410339,
0.33250537514686584,
-0.05816291272640228,
0.4129016697406769,
0.780322253704071,
-0.7598598003387451,
0.12230878323316574,
0.29664474725723267,
0.0219570379704237,
0.007857485674321651,
-0.2851569652557373,
-0.3232418894767761,
0.3710329532623291,
0.6081027388572693,
-0.8321029543876648,
-0.20084306597709656,
0.28709447383880615,
0.11882007122039795,
-0.02317626215517521,
-0.31718727946281433,
0.7036384344100952,
0.03946263715624809,
-0.6493484973907471,
0.3313043713569641,
-0.04799307882785797,
0.2585200369358063,
-0.3806489109992981,
-0.2046729177236557,
-0.2163412719964981,
0.006196380592882633,
-0.3091820478439331,
-0.8748199939727783,
0.16446372866630554,
0.35635092854499817,
-0.3755907714366913,
-0.45200327038764954,
0.5569508075714111,
-0.39216628670692444,
-0.7300629019737244,
0.0993478074669838,
0.289863646030426,
0.4491378664970398,
0.08007649332284927,
-0.7819701433181763,
-0.0338195264339447,
-0.07229437679052353,
-0.18880002200603485,
0.2509344518184662,
0.5349233746528625,
-0.18083445727825165,
0.7079421281814575,
0.8213380575180054,
0.16818790137767792,
-0.3246826231479645,
0.3016852140426636,
0.8623213768005371,
-0.18238838016986847,
-0.36583730578422546,
-0.7700704336166382,
0.40795907378196716,
-0.2839597463607788,
0.0761328861117363,
0.7751859426498413,
0.46510741114616394,
0.6012791991233826,
0.08492256700992584,
1.111437201499939,
0.03610467538237572,
0.4575842618942261,
-0.7478325963020325,
0.9388170838356018,
-0.2687358558177948,
0.44238677620887756,
0.13036832213401794,
-0.8891004920005798,
-0.4439333379268646,
0.488605260848999,
-0.1672787219285965,
0.11826012283563614,
0.5027201175689697,
0.8777355551719666,
0.03541821241378784,
-0.015801243484020233,
-0.02419876493513584,
0.40533867478370667,
0.6567463874816895,
0.07621608674526215,
0.5713434815406799,
0.04552822560071945,
0.38754868507385254,
-0.09794054180383682,
-0.2093348354101181,
-0.2235225886106491,
-1.13660728931427,
-1.0329515933990479,
-0.6394487023353577,
-0.36367160081863403,
-0.5190126299858093,
-0.023309659212827682,
0.8053138256072998,
0.5542402863502502,
-0.7898331880569458,
0.19804899394512177,
0.03801027312874794,
0.03147509694099426,
-0.05941147729754448,
-0.16520629823207855,
0.6707289814949036,
-0.37076717615127563,
-0.49323633313179016,
0.45522069931030273,
0.12627117335796356,
0.18834495544433594,
-0.6927812695503235,
-0.09097511321306229,
0.23304826021194458,
-0.13447289168834686,
0.4057823121547699,
0.35848280787467957,
-0.5754084587097168,
-0.03461453691124916,
-0.1172219067811966,
-0.09746413677930832,
-0.060395460575819016,
0.8036279082298279,
-0.7887985706329346,
0.46940597891807556,
0.4566485285758972,
0.6539743542671204,
0.3293646275997162,
-0.10416741669178009,
0.6411246061325073,
-0.6086724400520325,
-0.061348967254161835,
0.26727956533432007,
0.3632256090641022,
0.5694029331207275,
-0.5999221205711365,
0.5861081480979919,
-0.01518414169549942,
-0.5822970271110535,
-0.969744861125946,
-0.15681172907352448,
-0.7341788411140442,
-0.4263862371444702,
1.2053625583648682,
-0.42398932576179504,
-0.2793518006801605,
-0.050766631960868835,
-0.018205665051937103,
0.2553234100341797,
-0.1891670525074005,
0.9652795195579529,
0.6877625584602356,
0.14076322317123413,
0.0348023846745491,
-0.7177965044975281,
0.4972994327545166,
-0.21929165720939636,
-1.0964163541793823,
0.465553879737854,
0.5588688254356384,
0.007382974028587341,
0.11761278659105301,
0.08347439020872116,
-0.23009610176086426,
0.022470848634839058,
-0.09914158284664154,
-0.16043713688850403,
-0.5735710263252258,
-0.6017917394638062,
-0.622036874294281,
-0.06874708831310272,
-0.1904727816581726,
0.31879737973213196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03324v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03324v1
|
A Comparative Analysis of Word-Level Metric Differential Privacy: Benchmarking The Privacy-Utility Trade-off
| 2024-04-04T09:48:14 | 2024-04-04T09:48:14 |
Stephen Meisenbacher, Nihildev Nandakumar, Alexandra Klymenko, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The application of Differential Privacy to Natural Language Processing
techniques has emerged in relevance in recent years, with an increasing number
of studies published in established NLP outlets. In particular, the adaptation
of Differential Privacy for use in NLP tasks has first focused on the
$\textit{word-level}$, where calibrated noise is added to word embedding
vectors to achieve "noisy" representations. To this end, several
implementations have appeared in the literature, each presenting an alternative
method of achieving word-level Differential Privacy. Although each of these
includes its own evaluation, no comparative analysis has been performed to
investigate the performance of such methods relative to each other. In this
work, we conduct such an analysis, comparing seven different algorithms on two
NLP tasks with varying hyperparameters, including the $\textit{epsilon
($\varepsilon$)}$ parameter, or privacy budget. In addition, we provide an
in-depth analysis of the results with a focus on the privacy-utility trade-off,
as well as open-source our implementation code for further reproduction. As a
result of our analysis, we give insight into the benefits and challenges of
word-level Differential Privacy, and accordingly, we suggest concrete steps
forward for the research field.
|
[
-0.5206230282783508,
-0.4119868278503418,
0.3862264156341553,
0.15132930874824524,
-0.21042610704898834,
0.11932888627052307,
-0.09711660444736481,
-0.7012428641319275,
0.10520278662443161,
0.315409392118454,
-0.41071951389312744,
-0.7505703568458557,
-0.819579005241394,
0.0800047367811203,
-0.5525086522102356,
0.6901648044586182,
0.23394395411014557,
-0.016455071046948433,
0.05156145244836807,
-0.11052007973194122,
-0.08521544933319092,
-0.5689817070960999,
-0.4892977178096771,
0.20364804565906525,
0.5025103092193604,
-0.2568298578262329,
0.7782695293426514,
0.6115970015525818,
0.6713943481445312,
0.3492145240306854,
-0.4247966408729553,
-0.07326862215995789,
-0.39483991265296936,
-0.032415907829999924,
-0.2512187659740448,
-0.19619318842887878,
-0.6083518862724304,
0.24717989563941956,
0.6980464458465576,
0.6177324652671814,
0.147414430975914,
0.4032156765460968,
0.24951684474945068,
0.790373682975769,
-1.2505460977554321,
0.12030903249979019,
-0.48302918672561646,
0.46278977394104004,
-0.21014995872974396,
-0.15485896170139313,
-0.10502644628286362,
-0.7052192091941833,
0.21975161135196686,
-0.22608712315559387,
0.21342693269252777,
-0.06821057945489883,
0.6373067498207092,
0.43452557921409607,
-0.021290922537446022,
-0.17060448229312897,
-0.7321903109550476,
0.88164883852005,
-0.9082430601119995,
0.6597429513931274,
0.4969627857208252,
-0.027523458003997803,
0.1123485192656517,
-0.46539774537086487,
-0.2704509496688843,
-0.5044070482254028,
-0.07115107774734497,
0.14136911928653717,
-0.5695469975471497,
0.009657209739089012,
0.528103768825531,
0.6686935424804688,
-0.371013879776001,
0.4999953806400299,
-0.13737086951732635,
-0.21383832395076752,
0.5814944505691528,
0.12635093927383423,
-0.03150157630443573,
0.03683730959892273,
-0.11679230630397797,
-0.08869993686676025,
-0.3459029197692871,
0.12002269923686981,
0.8817678689956665,
-0.10063629597425461,
-0.1467113196849823,
0.48433730006217957,
-0.5055593848228455,
0.5514653325080872,
-0.13883793354034424,
-0.04416993632912636,
0.2603127360343933,
-0.04794754832983017,
-0.03698257356882095,
-0.12891791760921478,
0.7680764198303223,
0.615408718585968,
0.003287422237917781,
-0.6337711215019226,
-0.17749053239822388,
0.2461579591035843,
0.20537173748016357,
-0.45838242769241333,
0.002883520908653736,
0.17514847218990326,
-0.5157837867736816,
-0.4867980480194092,
-0.07323203235864639,
-1.1232397556304932,
-0.5418673753738403,
-0.2815626561641693,
0.45213741064071655,
-0.12433157116174698,
-0.20548175275325775,
0.36345529556274414,
-0.4618914723396301,
0.2051122486591339,
-0.06480607390403748,
-0.7840248942375183,
0.9675815105438232,
1.0393320322036743,
1.0713838338851929,
-0.4190351665019989,
-0.19523663818836212,
-0.5370701551437378,
-0.011495637707412243,
-0.23381294310092926,
0.25860974192619324,
-0.5713862776756287,
-0.4465027153491974,
0.03846606984734535,
-0.38067030906677246,
0.09613263607025146,
-0.46733278036117554,
0.5607069134712219,
-0.396558552980423,
0.46146032214164734,
-0.373966246843338,
-0.5619677305221558,
-0.08093336224555969,
0.10905338078737259,
-0.5912609100341797,
0.9242821931838989,
-0.036306556314229965,
-1.2703696489334106,
0.5474700331687927,
-0.7673805356025696,
-0.050155844539403915,
0.018605072051286697,
0.07311588525772095,
-0.2986374497413635,
0.2698710560798645,
0.08809326589107513,
0.5842125415802002,
-0.1940578818321228,
-0.2972094416618347,
-0.31220266222953796,
-0.5975905656814575,
0.4147956669330597,
-0.4289304316043854,
0.748461902141571,
0.1504158079624176,
-0.6831984519958496,
-0.3741804361343384,
-1.205379843711853,
-0.09140626341104507,
-0.030563371255993843,
-0.035166025161743164,
-0.7581862211227417,
0.009511031210422516,
-0.480897456407547,
-0.08932697027921677,
0.6356402635574341,
-0.8408262133598328,
-0.5087943077087402,
-0.575910747051239,
0.28924113512039185,
0.7300112843513489,
-0.24883858859539032,
0.6068442463874817,
-0.21300768852233887,
0.5236882567405701,
-0.19842341542243958,
0.4865684509277344,
0.563405454158783,
-0.47028493881225586,
-0.33053120970726013,
-0.3764154613018036,
0.6382361650466919,
0.4741499423980713,
0.05896744877099991,
0.6071125268936157,
-0.08302243053913116,
-0.42784199118614197,
-0.4762851893901825,
-0.15614962577819824,
0.506342351436615,
0.3546336591243744,
0.29835036396980286,
-0.67505943775177,
0.1282341182231903,
-0.8267267346382141,
-0.6344010233879089,
0.0180327370762825,
-0.06629832088947296,
0.386275053024292,
0.013906319625675678,
0.0050304657779634,
0.7595339417457581,
-0.5772020220756531,
-0.2798862159252167,
0.16163034737110138,
-0.033682309091091156,
-0.09210453182458878,
0.2847175598144531,
0.7194245457649231,
-0.4639584720134735,
-0.37268224358558655,
-0.2570396661758423,
-0.44583502411842346,
-0.3703552782535553,
0.35133999586105347,
-0.14992563426494598,
0.14676867425441742,
0.2134886234998703,
-0.322810560464859,
0.6586875915527344,
0.9732071757316589,
-0.239312544465065,
0.3884974718093872,
-0.49056199193000793,
0.047018151730298996,
-0.8077236413955688,
0.041542306542396545,
0.21792498230934143,
-0.24611257016658783,
-0.6639363169670105,
0.20725619792938232,
0.17579825222492218,
-0.013401508331298828,
-0.5496161580085754,
0.19565854966640472,
-0.47866153717041016,
-0.408030241727829,
-0.20925220847129822,
0.14020611345767975,
-0.09729709476232529,
0.40352243185043335,
-0.15168526768684387,
0.8480311632156372,
0.6636051535606384,
-0.7237106561660767,
0.1874556988477707,
-0.008774013258516788,
-0.10757185518741608,
0.277982622385025,
-0.5749301910400391,
0.39140549302101135,
0.09384401887655258,
-0.19176186621189117,
-0.8242549300193787,
0.3353745937347412,
0.48324334621429443,
-0.34044814109802246,
0.1660507321357727,
0.03473491221666336,
-0.7007802724838257,
-0.10298942029476166,
-0.9568115472793579,
0.13931871950626373,
0.7413080334663391,
-0.4981260895729065,
-0.042112432420253754,
0.6655676364898682,
-0.19064027070999146,
-0.8468374609947205,
-0.7639120221138,
0.3046809434890747,
-0.5012869834899902,
-0.20768702030181885,
0.4562358260154724,
0.21333390474319458,
-0.5538870096206665,
0.32091230154037476,
-0.2508348524570465,
-0.21293577551841736,
0.1354895532131195,
0.05074499920010567,
0.0005504054133780301,
0.11582639813423157,
-0.3301306366920471,
0.2600409686565399,
-0.5229348540306091,
0.35254278779029846,
-0.09434329718351364,
0.44861850142478943,
-0.05451316386461258,
-0.13412676751613617,
-0.6349585652351379,
0.3465748429298401,
0.13023337721824646,
-0.269145131111145,
0.7733020186424255,
0.459960401058197,
-0.28147390484809875,
-0.027119217440485954,
-0.6461054682731628,
0.058026786893606186,
-0.5010842680931091,
-0.03794257342815399,
-0.1271132528781891,
-0.7378484010696411,
0.45538026094436646,
-0.10044330358505249,
0.43396177887916565,
0.26860666275024414,
0.45197033882141113,
0.2722589671611786,
0.9373905062675476,
0.7307754755020142,
-0.3505038022994995,
0.3971845507621765,
-0.10478193312883377,
0.40557238459587097,
-0.8065008521080017,
0.22916914522647858,
-0.7285927534103394,
-0.5088320970535278,
-1.1332008838653564,
-0.20808234810829163,
0.1828262209892273,
-0.33862197399139404,
0.04350818321108818,
0.6074128150939941,
-0.7398318648338318,
0.40406349301338196,
0.5420944690704346,
-0.03427999094128609,
0.6554368734359741,
-0.06735371053218842,
0.10520906746387482,
-0.13536256551742554,
-0.36310890316963196,
-0.6431921720504761,
1.007484793663025,
0.413362592458725,
0.7591018676757812,
0.15513069927692413,
1.1241965293884277,
0.1833794116973877,
-0.1331271529197693,
-0.45604002475738525,
0.8012852668762207,
-0.7132768630981445,
-0.28755098581314087,
-0.4337138831615448,
-0.7174838185310364,
-1.0090991258621216,
0.47195157408714294,
-0.12860485911369324,
-1.2955108880996704,
0.2679569125175476,
-0.13798506557941437,
-0.22517378628253937,
0.3329610824584961,
-0.743598997592926,
0.4458965063095093,
0.15306025743484497,
-0.455272912979126,
-0.2565384805202484,
-0.543367326259613,
0.2432413399219513,
-0.1654481589794159,
0.19861212372779846,
-0.38920530676841736,
-0.35087916254997253,
0.8874624371528625,
-0.057830676436424255,
0.6191953420639038,
-0.43872684240341187,
-0.26314079761505127,
-0.3904702961444855,
0.11234622448682785,
0.07703009992837906,
0.2704668939113617,
-0.12109805643558502,
0.5555172562599182,
0.4121365249156952,
-0.0918826162815094,
-0.24834194779396057,
1.026262879371643,
-0.6872743368148804,
-0.53350430727005,
-0.5628051161766052,
-0.5986066460609436,
-0.40438491106033325,
0.16119757294654846,
0.2528877556324005,
0.3803096115589142,
-0.24950659275054932,
0.17636199295520782,
0.7404707670211792,
-0.5205710530281067,
0.5645920634269714,
0.4756060242652893,
0.04022025689482689,
0.019530724734067917,
0.6228650808334351,
0.3343457281589508,
0.0915134996175766,
0.6258836984634399,
0.6306560635566711,
-0.6539089679718018,
-0.5157183408737183,
-0.07518591731786728,
0.1618064045906067,
-0.3932560682296753,
0.048156775534152985,
-0.8662964105606079,
-0.30363136529922485,
-0.3651103079319,
-0.0010620972607284784,
-0.5739306211471558,
-0.4764520525932312,
-0.07725034654140472,
0.09291157126426697,
0.3335782587528229,
0.4623245894908905,
-0.4850626289844513,
-0.13612835109233856,
-0.5742533206939697,
0.712144136428833,
0.15159083902835846,
0.6696435213088989,
-0.11194164305925369,
-0.2750614285469055,
0.13257697224617004,
-0.043461307883262634,
-0.09945984184741974,
-0.8616389632225037,
0.2034289389848709,
0.01546350959688425,
0.4600687325000763,
0.17063350975513458,
0.37963762879371643,
0.4341181814670563,
-0.4582236707210541,
0.8382116556167603,
0.15561123192310333,
-1.1245771646499634,
0.15620653331279755,
0.0385185070335865,
0.15145906805992126,
0.6567124128341675,
0.258680135011673,
-0.3071835935115814,
-0.8628420233726501,
-0.7470291256904602,
-0.9387829303741455,
0.4473339319229126,
0.46233931183815,
0.40951186418533325,
0.3666558563709259,
0.325774610042572,
0.537608802318573,
0.29166990518569946,
-0.4563432037830353,
-0.36043471097946167,
0.18911150097846985,
0.16216632723808289,
-0.14856025576591492,
-0.14246229827404022,
-0.36196836829185486,
-0.25732290744781494,
0.14989130198955536,
0.311838835477829,
0.3530310392379761,
-0.00785353034734726,
0.1892346888780594,
0.34164005517959595,
0.4135036766529083,
0.2502675950527191,
0.7672937512397766,
-0.3840511441230774,
0.09493198245763779,
0.33724671602249146,
-0.7703649401664734,
0.014368033036589622,
0.3338819742202759,
-0.4127243459224701,
0.4152476191520691,
-0.03512999787926674,
0.43280288577079773,
0.12131457030773163,
-0.19485512375831604,
0.7027118802070618,
-0.38694822788238525,
-0.5668114423751831,
-0.10085484385490417,
0.27878519892692566,
-0.08029770106077194,
0.09479771554470062,
-0.2570604979991913,
-0.1711283028125763,
0.6265742182731628,
-0.1396377682685852,
-0.09940801560878754,
0.4524073898792267,
-0.2442714124917984,
-0.22530323266983032,
0.7651306390762329,
0.015415644273161888,
-0.5243649482727051,
-0.05172095447778702,
-0.3502383530139923,
-0.019104551523923874,
0.21040672063827515,
0.15774454176425934,
1.2245253324508667,
0.22354468703269958,
0.311635822057724,
-0.1618005633354187,
0.2053544521331787,
0.03357953205704689,
0.33647674322128296,
-0.33623823523521423,
-0.4760478138923645,
-0.34674790501594543,
-0.5317803025245667,
-0.7597870230674744,
0.2110424041748047,
-1.0515154600143433,
-0.23490694165229797,
-0.5962519645690918,
-0.3209611475467682,
0.08492231369018555,
0.2676468789577484,
-0.8503519892692566,
-0.04245585948228836,
-0.007598713971674442,
0.8156201839447021,
-0.39248499274253845,
0.396129846572876,
0.4732794761657715,
0.2955867052078247,
-0.31428176164627075,
0.551638126373291,
0.08046992868185043,
-0.6184682846069336,
0.28638315200805664,
0.06726287305355072,
-0.6075990200042725,
-0.14057445526123047,
-0.13219928741455078,
-0.6117868423461914,
0.8862272500991821,
0.457383930683136,
-0.8747907876968384,
0.29666033387184143,
0.45472845435142517,
0.8356207013130188,
0.3817196786403656,
-0.1698489487171173,
0.6935978531837463,
0.29702430963516235,
-0.42322227358818054,
-0.9784204959869385,
0.15577125549316406,
0.27045634388923645,
0.0848037600517273,
0.2709481418132782,
-0.6791202425956726,
0.4651481509208679,
0.40300610661506653,
-0.32736846804618835,
-0.05859517678618431,
0.255874902009964,
-0.08750130981206894,
0.5005258321762085,
0.7236044406890869,
0.6485117077827454,
0.5862467885017395,
0.1598733812570572,
0.8848276138305664,
-0.6095631718635559,
0.4025329053401947,
0.7582783699035645,
-0.5025481581687927,
0.7457541823387146,
0.42354267835617065,
-0.5497763156890869,
0.02078024111688137,
0.19322378933429718,
0.1933392584323883,
0.8402870297431946,
0.3794545829296112,
-0.333987832069397,
0.5995700359344482,
-0.039780184626579285,
-0.555969774723053,
0.33655068278312683,
0.022652050480246544,
-0.17485469579696655,
-0.43668460845947266,
-0.354475736618042,
0.0265654269605875,
0.08977467566728592,
-0.1951722502708435,
1.1200661659240723,
0.2637633681297302,
-0.12032625079154968,
0.21605271100997925,
0.2941955626010895,
0.9169555902481079,
-0.5867094397544861,
0.49483802914619446,
-0.13004224002361298,
0.18196891248226166,
-0.1725672036409378,
-0.7189351916313171,
0.6202085614204407,
0.5395218133926392,
0.37936708331108093,
-0.3144822418689728,
0.6564220786094666,
0.13613659143447876,
-0.11447792500257492,
0.5767301917076111,
0.5726683735847473,
0.218144491314888,
-0.013873623684048653,
-0.899894118309021,
-0.02990178018808365,
-0.5248187780380249,
-0.22764837741851807,
0.6777290105819702,
0.4240674078464508,
0.4399558901786804,
0.22086967527866364,
0.6308677792549133,
0.49991267919540405,
0.29034391045570374,
0.39645278453826904,
0.949733316898346,
-0.5680449604988098,
-0.9793542623519897,
-1.0049762725830078,
0.05178140848875046,
-0.3797624707221985,
-0.6053349375724792,
0.8785718679428101,
0.47289809584617615,
0.9512088298797607,
0.1502961963415146,
0.6165422201156616,
0.010645193047821522,
0.7540603876113892,
-0.5886638760566711,
0.5763575434684753,
-0.44094476103782654,
0.36156660318374634,
-0.5801821947097778,
-1.2162595987319946,
-0.4005070924758911,
0.6073592901229858,
-0.4082869291305542,
-0.42176270484924316,
0.7115825414657593,
0.9266489744186401,
-0.07775148004293442,
0.1091255396604538,
0.4774401783943176,
-0.33545583486557007,
0.1179705560207367,
0.13024988770484924,
0.8504288196563721,
-0.1716807633638382,
0.10959544777870178,
-0.8002515435218811,
-0.4724695086479187,
0.2894366681575775,
-0.9004685878753662,
-0.7053999304771423,
-0.41706883907318115,
-0.4843090772628784,
-0.1620182991027832,
0.250326007604599,
0.472306489944458,
0.602660596370697,
-0.5038086175918579,
-0.08764468878507614,
-0.14734621345996857,
-0.09378700703382492,
-0.4194525480270386,
-0.18845167756080627,
0.27580228447914124,
-0.1105838418006897,
-0.831262469291687,
0.18918147683143616,
0.6061617732048035,
-0.18051141500473022,
-0.42964401841163635,
0.24876056611537933,
0.3478509485721588,
0.22128000855445862,
0.37727078795433044,
0.06989748775959015,
-0.3929741382598877,
-0.1943199634552002,
-0.22153672575950623,
-0.16549856960773468,
-0.08540070801973343,
0.9569939970970154,
-0.19050398468971252,
0.16896271705627441,
0.7238155007362366,
0.822316586971283,
0.44989410042762756,
-0.07334839552640915,
0.35256603360176086,
-0.6637809872627258,
0.31228047609329224,
0.3588334918022156,
0.05504625290632248,
0.024719921872019768,
-0.6113614439964294,
0.38712814450263977,
-0.14295847713947296,
-0.675581157207489,
-0.8492401242256165,
0.14627878367900848,
-0.9368016719818115,
-0.2355147898197174,
1.174375295639038,
-0.27139514684677124,
0.01353973988443613,
-0.17870116233825684,
-0.05556512624025345,
0.060983944684267044,
-0.48235997557640076,
1.2476046085357666,
0.6160983443260193,
-0.12118201702833176,
0.004083625040948391,
-0.6395800113677979,
0.6570265889167786,
0.33884307742118835,
-0.5296160578727722,
0.1257224828004837,
0.04670090973377228,
0.07817012816667557,
0.03902208060026169,
0.5948845744132996,
-0.50588059425354,
-0.07385837286710739,
0.02558831311762333,
-0.5045773386955261,
0.03365573659539223,
-0.004735032096505165,
-0.6199547052383423,
0.1822773516178131,
-0.04077516123652458,
-0.7419764995574951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03312v1
|
M3TCM: Multi-modal Multi-task Context Model for Utterance Classification in Motivational Interviews
| 2024-04-04T09:17:22 | 2024-04-04T09:17:22 |
Sayed Muddashir Hossain, Jan Alexandersson, Philipp Müller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Accurate utterance classification in motivational interviews is crucial to
automatically understand the quality and dynamics of client-therapist
interaction, and it can serve as a key input for systems mediating such
interactions. Motivational interviews exhibit three important characteristics.
First, there are two distinct roles, namely client and therapist. Second, they
are often highly emotionally charged, which can be expressed both in text and
in prosody. Finally, context is of central importance to classify any given
utterance. Previous works did not adequately incorporate all of these
characteristics into utterance classification approaches for mental health
dialogues. In contrast, we present M3TCM, a Multi-modal, Multi-task Context
Model for utterance classification. Our approach for the first time employs
multi-task learning to effectively model both joint and individual components
of therapist and client behaviour. Furthermore, M3TCM integrates information
from the text and speech modality as well as the conversation context. With our
novel approach, we outperform the state of the art for utterance classification
on the recently introduced AnnoMI dataset with a relative improvement of 20%
for the client- and by 15% for therapist utterance classification. In extensive
ablation studies, we quantify the improvement resulting from each contribution.
|
[
-0.4608590006828308,
-0.638737678527832,
0.749390721321106,
0.22163301706314087,
-0.026460768654942513,
-0.1880793571472168,
-0.20443491637706757,
-0.3932221233844757,
-0.20373670756816864,
0.42971017956733704,
-0.765250027179718,
-0.5943016409873962,
-0.7776604294776917,
0.12898460030555725,
-0.066273033618927,
0.8478670716285706,
-0.070136658847332,
0.557159960269928,
-0.32973581552505493,
-0.36845648288726807,
-0.882452666759491,
-0.7137140035629272,
-0.8221864700317383,
-0.2982524037361145,
0.5103272199630737,
0.41346463561058044,
0.11451011896133423,
0.16163593530654907,
0.2184828221797943,
0.36408108472824097,
0.06771048158407211,
0.24816682934761047,
-0.23227283358573914,
0.40071749687194824,
0.07490069419145584,
-0.3669014275074005,
-0.20760425925254822,
0.2138376235961914,
0.18560422956943512,
0.6193715929985046,
-0.49840912222862244,
0.11372902244329453,
0.04308819770812988,
0.2956371307373047,
-0.6155125498771667,
0.4143584370613098,
-0.3512129485607147,
0.018774520605802536,
0.08591063320636749,
-0.6996623873710632,
-0.6645572185516357,
-0.05617145076394081,
0.17448149621486664,
-0.10017600655555725,
0.1705647110939026,
-0.045428186655044556,
0.11835354566574097,
0.2501402199268341,
-1.0946252346038818,
-0.24412110447883606,
-0.7221140265464783,
0.7618877291679382,
-0.35139283537864685,
0.48012810945510864,
0.4129228889942169,
0.306990385055542,
0.01775352843105793,
-0.29279500246047974,
-0.2623566687107086,
-0.17152833938598633,
-0.04921524226665497,
0.15094681084156036,
-0.2390652745962143,
0.4408959746360779,
0.23159503936767578,
0.10774824023246765,
-0.4529174864292145,
0.04612988978624344,
-0.1994645595550537,
-0.22561395168304443,
0.25623399019241333,
0.4500056505203247,
0.2672262191772461,
-0.013118664734065533,
-0.42813342809677124,
0.07988440990447998,
-0.3334001898765564,
0.11488089710474014,
-0.15792237222194672,
0.21815434098243713,
-0.0436120480298996,
0.36460259556770325,
-0.1497495472431183,
0.5281673669815063,
0.04507818445563316,
-0.6769089698791504,
-0.05333811789751053,
-0.22837302088737488,
-0.05131349340081215,
0.5652809143066406,
0.676460325717926,
0.5029914379119873,
-0.4289952218532562,
-0.09269078820943832,
-0.013308330439031124,
-0.09426527470350266,
0.46161338686943054,
-1.1573495864868164,
0.1339377909898758,
0.4775565564632416,
-0.4788653552532196,
-0.17979812622070312,
-0.07938242703676224,
-0.28713667392730713,
-0.3151806592941284,
-0.6160821914672852,
0.3828515410423279,
-0.5968958735466003,
-0.2577732801437378,
-0.04923711344599724,
-0.0037405891343951225,
0.20003248751163483,
0.5566515922546387,
-0.7640485763549805,
0.3815578520298004,
0.6337652206420898,
1.0281507968902588,
-0.10385379940271378,
-0.19467604160308838,
-0.5576555132865906,
0.17943039536476135,
-0.057345911860466,
0.6214060187339783,
-0.3656441569328308,
-0.3042442798614502,
-0.11184468865394592,
0.06337319314479828,
-0.3915766775608063,
-0.4588395357131958,
0.5612652897834778,
-0.28094521164894104,
0.5315577387809753,
-0.21363390982151031,
-0.48657694458961487,
-0.5474259853363037,
0.4390450716018677,
-0.32040733098983765,
0.3498244881629944,
0.5034577250480652,
-0.666283905506134,
0.28822460770606995,
-1.0020461082458496,
-0.49535703659057617,
-0.05199238657951355,
-0.19316428899765015,
-0.19974009692668915,
0.21696025133132935,
-0.04371267184615135,
0.4252576231956482,
-0.44782358407974243,
0.38261571526527405,
-0.24017812311649323,
-0.330895334482193,
0.6210577487945557,
-0.535510241985321,
0.8057349920272827,
0.327579140663147,
-0.25505563616752625,
0.3424631357192993,
-0.4852113425731659,
-0.047449350357055664,
-0.2639687955379486,
-0.28606870770454407,
-0.18365302681922913,
-0.12651920318603516,
0.3805285096168518,
0.5957244634628296,
-0.1556749790906906,
-0.6273565888404846,
-0.20128384232521057,
-0.134621724486351,
0.4874335527420044,
0.4874593913555145,
0.1316274106502533,
-0.04131979122757912,
-0.5233064889907837,
0.5454738140106201,
0.33346641063690186,
0.08796042203903198,
-0.1655907928943634,
-0.3555334210395813,
-0.24165545403957367,
-0.6756512522697449,
-0.08028557896614075,
0.6576799154281616,
-0.4075440466403961,
0.514689028263092,
0.0630391463637352,
-0.5375515222549438,
-0.47285985946655273,
-0.022731177508831024,
0.4341166615486145,
0.8104134202003479,
0.4501280188560486,
-0.2887333035469055,
-0.6967254877090454,
-0.6963005661964417,
0.0770677998661995,
-0.23802034556865692,
0.013917764648795128,
0.47266489267349243,
0.24068377912044525,
-0.44007590413093567,
0.9449620842933655,
-0.26501598954200745,
-0.5488763451576233,
-0.3887521028518677,
0.5424405336380005,
0.055793359875679016,
0.7396278381347656,
0.4909987151622772,
-0.8209937214851379,
-0.3343591094017029,
-0.05466780439019203,
-0.6126775741577148,
-0.17374959588050842,
-0.08902444690465927,
0.005485189147293568,
0.06940057873725891,
0.38957488536834717,
-0.8557577133178711,
0.059030476957559586,
0.39210519194602966,
-0.34990158677101135,
0.5824629068374634,
0.011001304723322392,
0.4571133852005005,
-1.0692452192306519,
0.08478198200464249,
-0.11469798535108566,
-0.23727789521217346,
-0.8347440958023071,
-0.32254689931869507,
-0.14197169244289398,
-0.09382952749729156,
-0.7347815036773682,
0.18865372240543365,
-0.25930342078208923,
0.22035259008407593,
-0.43638619780540466,
-0.281124085187912,
-0.0509386882185936,
0.7347331643104553,
0.029818547889590263,
0.7724609971046448,
0.6082306504249573,
-0.7636303901672363,
0.46140056848526,
0.34807121753692627,
-0.4183734655380249,
1.0844295024871826,
-0.40748879313468933,
0.2650575339794159,
-0.13022366166114807,
0.3069668710231781,
-1.0857971906661987,
-0.26412126421928406,
0.16350460052490234,
-0.36325857043266296,
0.38950949907302856,
-0.11607318371534348,
-0.31673112511634827,
0.004111213609576225,
0.001811609254218638,
0.5185523629188538,
0.1647617071866989,
-0.18271641433238983,
0.6390382647514343,
0.3539975583553314,
-0.2482483834028244,
-0.4433458745479584,
-0.41620758175849915,
-0.0010438674362376332,
-0.5453860759735107,
-0.3004312217235565,
0.4028364419937134,
-0.3015657663345337,
-0.12148725986480713,
-0.3988155126571655,
-0.3319331109523773,
-0.07512432336807251,
0.39563435316085815,
0.49210429191589355,
0.2555485665798187,
-0.16090071201324463,
0.023813704028725624,
0.10029873996973038,
-0.3702636659145355,
0.37743911147117615,
-0.21104224026203156,
0.6172797679901123,
-0.23065133392810822,
-0.41197237372398376,
-0.9447119235992432,
0.6983056664466858,
0.785783052444458,
0.09730978310108185,
0.9688120484352112,
1.1538889408111572,
-0.3505791127681732,
0.4816509187221527,
-0.754206120967865,
-0.27486327290534973,
-0.3415237069129944,
0.6175359487533569,
-0.4467109739780426,
-1.1612416505813599,
0.29068198800086975,
-0.16145028173923492,
-0.0882381945848465,
0.1706748902797699,
0.6770030856132507,
-0.16821874678134918,
1.8045345544815063,
0.5163310170173645,
-0.025211462751030922,
0.6801906824111938,
-0.032098859548568726,
0.0008254072745330632,
-0.9175257086753845,
-0.20105737447738647,
-0.5145275592803955,
-0.23709331452846527,
-0.3731539249420166,
-0.051325295120477676,
0.6016533374786377,
0.1490253061056137,
-0.20149824023246765,
0.15306797623634338,
-0.4080778658390045,
0.03729809448122978,
0.3574562072753906,
0.26393750309944153,
0.10027311742305756,
-0.3403133451938629,
-0.03370658680796623,
-0.1446543037891388,
-0.48709139227867126,
-0.4184856414794922,
0.8868316411972046,
0.3562222421169281,
0.2556155323982239,
0.5398615002632141,
0.526587963104248,
0.08598153293132782,
0.748912513256073,
-1.104396939277649,
0.49009180068969727,
0.28286829590797424,
-0.6367429494857788,
-0.08120989799499512,
-0.549078106880188,
-0.9460064768791199,
0.5815348029136658,
-0.10397882759571075,
-1.0413355827331543,
0.07790077477693558,
-0.014204531908035278,
-0.46216320991516113,
-0.05402272939682007,
-0.7077521085739136,
1.2059834003448486,
-0.26327750086784363,
-0.04580780491232872,
-0.3777141273021698,
-0.6054888963699341,
0.4984551966190338,
-0.03196120262145996,
0.35645368695259094,
-0.47097983956336975,
0.052387088537216187,
0.7715474963188171,
-0.5132068991661072,
0.6445901989936829,
-0.4903324842453003,
0.10588806867599487,
0.2040005624294281,
0.1618925780057907,
0.11380850523710251,
0.2054637372493744,
0.03316926211118698,
0.03624110668897629,
0.5735584497451782,
-0.22021234035491943,
-0.7077301740646362,
0.26447945833206177,
-0.7562195658683777,
-0.5757670402526855,
-0.20229099690914154,
-0.6508803963661194,
-0.5094370245933533,
0.23665502667427063,
0.2025223970413208,
0.7657041549682617,
-0.43203455209732056,
0.4712793827056885,
0.5601527690887451,
0.1024463027715683,
0.16107018291950226,
0.5945062637329102,
0.0459456667304039,
-0.5033056139945984,
0.625336766242981,
-0.1300475299358368,
0.17857874929904938,
0.4046202600002289,
0.22145585715770721,
-0.368547260761261,
-0.6125584244728088,
-0.18169249594211578,
0.13720789551734924,
-0.6349138021469116,
-0.27221009135246277,
-1.0007641315460205,
0.06443309038877487,
-0.6316041946411133,
0.09500371664762497,
-0.14079922437667847,
-0.11718670278787613,
-0.2884259819984436,
-0.04499189555644989,
0.15195652842521667,
0.42101994156837463,
-0.09996557235717773,
0.6051302552223206,
-0.9677425622940063,
0.14435866475105286,
0.38308483362197876,
0.03818025812506676,
-0.18809521198272705,
-0.3403922915458679,
-0.3145179748535156,
-0.005497968755662441,
-0.6453949809074402,
-1.2247341871261597,
0.6242484450340271,
0.12864050269126892,
0.5828865766525269,
0.7368842363357544,
0.21456876397132874,
0.5738990902900696,
-0.14383801817893982,
0.4999670386314392,
0.5191964507102966,
-0.9797224998474121,
0.5097978711128235,
-0.1837828904390335,
0.266955703496933,
0.8485934138298035,
0.47455480694770813,
-0.9564652442932129,
-0.2362128496170044,
-0.4173198342323303,
-0.70461106300354,
1.1717607975006104,
0.01056898757815361,
-0.0629463940858841,
-0.06844170391559601,
0.013660178519785404,
0.19864729046821594,
0.48699989914894104,
-0.5301360487937927,
-0.23714151978492737,
-0.02494429051876068,
-0.54637610912323,
-0.04947444424033165,
-0.38403546810150146,
-0.699754536151886,
-0.2815128266811371,
0.4921529293060303,
-0.3978734612464905,
0.7083765864372253,
0.3160640001296997,
-0.3025371730327606,
-0.058750249445438385,
0.5221291184425354,
0.8063409924507141,
0.51371169090271,
-0.5115367770195007,
0.4220998287200928,
0.31944704055786133,
-0.3173791468143463,
0.2938334345817566,
0.14871077239513397,
0.405939519405365,
0.11574368178844452,
0.1412377953529358,
0.989249587059021,
0.1853313148021698,
-0.7140582799911499,
0.7103708982467651,
-0.2936743199825287,
-0.4269973933696747,
-0.2738763689994812,
0.08963855355978012,
-0.08369658142328262,
0.34579750895500183,
0.15128087997436523,
0.21728472411632538,
0.5834605097770691,
-0.6642792820930481,
0.14897450804710388,
0.34228217601776123,
-0.7996768951416016,
-0.15375038981437683,
0.5303899645805359,
-0.0015905038453638554,
-0.24133503437042236,
0.48062026500701904,
-0.27244916558265686,
-0.5545443296432495,
0.33324339985847473,
0.6050101518630981,
1.1567052602767944,
-0.3429383933544159,
0.014422508887946606,
0.17006967961788177,
-0.26391279697418213,
0.043869949877262115,
0.18921694159507751,
-0.621353030204773,
-0.7730688452720642,
-0.26225563883781433,
-0.2804799973964691,
-0.7012689113616943,
0.01820186711847782,
-0.9319894313812256,
0.03557681292295456,
-0.2596190273761749,
-0.42624953389167786,
-0.0719568282365799,
-0.17835550010204315,
-0.6577850580215454,
0.05070197954773903,
0.3602674603462219,
0.4125475585460663,
-0.6785789132118225,
0.6583167910575867,
0.7529571056365967,
-0.3573439419269562,
-0.47685563564300537,
-0.3524431884288788,
0.39637789130210876,
-0.47383400797843933,
0.5916497111320496,
0.8495965600013733,
-0.25157132744789124,
0.1907276064157486,
-0.36462005972862244,
-0.8025475740432739,
1.2038077116012573,
0.35611027479171753,
-0.07289860397577286,
-0.02807224728167057,
-0.05743670463562012,
0.3484954237937927,
-0.734170138835907,
0.7144481539726257,
0.3948405981063843,
0.4226570129394531,
0.185933917760849,
-1.0761234760284424,
0.10843764245510101,
-0.17690201103687286,
0.01978999190032482,
-0.0035726502537727356,
-0.4450620114803314,
0.490106999874115,
-0.18145327270030975,
-0.3558567762374878,
-0.07547758519649506,
0.4264715015888214,
0.43388715386390686,
0.450772762298584,
0.8550828695297241,
0.17691127955913544,
0.7387382984161377,
-0.2890360653400421,
0.7947448492050171,
-0.5154201984405518,
0.2542901933193207,
0.8908689618110657,
-0.18516844511032104,
0.565955400466919,
0.40805134177207947,
-0.1187112033367157,
0.41143304109573364,
0.725801944732666,
0.28707462549209595,
0.42211443185806274,
-0.029306508600711823,
-0.47319939732551575,
-0.30851227045059204,
-0.41337060928344727,
-0.1912018358707428,
0.6349574327468872,
0.5420035719871521,
-0.13790901005268097,
0.020070970058441162,
0.5529966354370117,
0.11103212088346481,
-0.47781315445899963,
-0.17942412197589874,
0.9013267159461975,
0.27563342452049255,
-0.6488346457481384,
0.5041357278823853,
0.10058815032243729,
0.6122729182243347,
-0.37886402010917664,
0.20915231108665466,
0.22315986454486847,
0.1760927140712738,
-0.290078729391098,
-0.3164587914943695,
0.42215901613235474,
-0.3087879419326782,
-0.21719057857990265,
-0.6312647461891174,
0.43981632590293884,
-0.6330664753913879,
0.03439883142709732,
0.11185797303915024,
0.6347920298576355,
0.30178239941596985,
-0.4211685061454773,
-0.8333840370178223,
-0.20398740470409393,
-0.2476801872253418,
-0.2910250723361969,
0.3502907156944275,
0.3698301315307617,
0.32124680280685425,
0.5662128925323486,
0.6447485089302063,
-0.17787282168865204,
-0.39251983165740967,
0.33872002363204956,
0.489849328994751,
-0.8720473647117615,
-0.5340131521224976,
-0.7929067611694336,
0.33467426896095276,
0.09273678064346313,
-0.3568267226219177,
0.4130181074142456,
0.5119211077690125,
0.4545431137084961,
0.16936980187892914,
0.4847657084465027,
0.025711188092827797,
0.6558940410614014,
-0.5406708717346191,
0.44816628098487854,
-0.511086642742157,
-0.03684287518262863,
-0.2351641058921814,
-0.6907386779785156,
-0.1568230241537094,
0.46921178698539734,
-0.16750101745128632,
0.22253228724002838,
0.8866360187530518,
0.6038881540298462,
0.3349713087081909,
0.3296058475971222,
0.26922541856765747,
-0.06657145917415619,
0.45949938893318176,
0.7090460658073425,
1.0652796030044556,
-0.14797326922416687,
0.45644453167915344,
-0.3501792550086975,
-0.1882864236831665,
-0.4214867949485779,
-0.5039498209953308,
-0.5832282900810242,
-0.6701945662498474,
-0.4744994342327118,
-0.3098302185535431,
-0.3118431568145752,
1.4092164039611816,
0.9984068274497986,
-0.818696916103363,
-0.36878129839897156,
0.02178455889225006,
0.05491446703672409,
-0.7022240161895752,
-0.2793799936771393,
-0.023335084319114685,
-0.4400080740451813,
-0.7522827982902527,
0.5557395219802856,
0.44449976086616516,
0.08862863481044769,
-0.17828430235385895,
-0.11624982208013535,
-0.09664937108755112,
-0.2055129110813141,
0.7948774695396423,
0.028861070051789284,
-0.7572927474975586,
-0.1720617115497589,
-0.08028402179479599,
-0.3205810785293579,
0.34155067801475525,
1.06385338306427,
-0.5095670223236084,
0.30651822686195374,
0.1172693744301796,
0.6601899862289429,
0.5118075013160706,
0.048201292753219604,
0.6104649901390076,
-0.563278317451477,
-0.05252990871667862,
0.3069380521774292,
0.4473814070224762,
0.22102028131484985,
-0.3521861433982849,
0.2975733280181885,
0.4138191044330597,
-0.586341917514801,
-0.9630005359649658,
0.13394202291965485,
-1.3655778169631958,
-0.28416380286216736,
0.9771541357040405,
-0.03763194382190704,
-0.10433379560709,
-0.6286690831184387,
-0.6611766219139099,
0.48479822278022766,
-0.3630329966545105,
0.5698557496070862,
0.6944726705551147,
-0.6911711692810059,
-0.4020869731903076,
-0.5916566252708435,
0.45667004585266113,
0.6353809833526611,
-0.6448155641555786,
-0.09143760800361633,
0.6591230034828186,
0.1910760998725891,
0.17594066262245178,
0.7818796634674072,
-0.015336673706769943,
0.3400774896144867,
-0.30841195583343506,
0.1973866969347,
-0.19678644835948944,
-0.17837364971637726,
-0.32292866706848145,
0.5729487538337708,
0.1720203459262848,
-0.26208022236824036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03304v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03304v3
|
Concept -- An Evaluation Protocol on Conversational Recommender Systems with System-centric and User-centric Factors
| 2024-04-04T08:56:48 | 2024-05-06T12:44:34 |
Chen Huang, Peixin Qin, Yang Deng, Wenqiang Lei, Jiancheng Lv, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The conversational recommendation system (CRS) has been criticized regarding
its user experience in real-world scenarios, despite recent significant
progress achieved in academia. Existing evaluation protocols for CRS may
prioritize system-centric factors such as effectiveness and fluency in
conversation while neglecting user-centric aspects. Thus, we propose a new and
inclusive evaluation protocol, Concept, which integrates both system- and
user-centric factors. We conceptualise three key characteristics in
representing such factors and further divide them into six primary abilities.
To implement Concept, we adopt a LLM-based user simulator and evaluator with
scoring rubrics that are tailored for each primary ability. Our protocol,
Concept, serves a dual purpose. First, it provides an overview of the pros and
cons in current CRS models. Second, it pinpoints the problem of low usability
in the "omnipotent" ChatGPT and offers a comprehensive reference guide for
evaluating CRS, thereby setting the foundation for CRS improvement.
|
[
-0.4782582223415375,
-0.5723888278007507,
0.3632313311100006,
0.4062018096446991,
-0.39666372537612915,
0.18989159166812897,
-0.35950708389282227,
-0.3839263319969177,
0.4607546925544739,
0.3302425742149353,
-0.4463410973548889,
-0.23578469455242157,
-0.20464348793029785,
-0.011207681149244308,
-0.20423440635204315,
1.2419023513793945,
0.3447151780128479,
0.3526496887207031,
-0.3619263470172882,
0.1256430447101593,
-0.7836129665374756,
-0.6251073479652405,
-0.567771852016449,
-0.6896348595619202,
0.5199137330055237,
0.81851726770401,
0.6526803374290466,
0.191829115152359,
0.7852343916893005,
0.22898432612419128,
-0.086813785135746,
-0.12960468232631683,
-0.6408089995384216,
0.2964467406272888,
-0.24715742468833923,
-0.11024099588394165,
-0.6267833113670349,
-0.09073343873023987,
0.2615223526954651,
0.5228158831596375,
-0.5211189389228821,
0.024654701352119446,
0.3258501887321472,
0.6136717200279236,
-0.668584406375885,
-0.04667846858501434,
-0.38359513878822327,
0.13718055188655853,
0.22913947701454163,
-0.5654276609420776,
-0.3089677393436432,
-0.24573326110839844,
0.7216225862503052,
-0.6299272775650024,
0.08459547907114029,
0.13151459395885468,
0.2440647929906845,
-0.42735254764556885,
-0.10713302344083786,
-0.18867230415344238,
-0.8324069380760193,
0.4883827865123749,
-0.3483108580112457,
0.46362870931625366,
0.04403773695230484,
0.5944885015487671,
-0.03757089748978615,
-0.24874211847782135,
-0.4850192964076996,
-0.6124648451805115,
-0.010307026095688343,
-0.04472082853317261,
0.050527848303318024,
0.12362804263830185,
0.027546904981136322,
0.4819158911705017,
-0.332640141248703,
-0.2243226319551468,
-0.26610067486763,
-0.4073510468006134,
0.377128928899765,
0.42194849252700806,
0.09300112724304199,
-0.2739149034023285,
-0.7220157980918884,
0.1569673717021942,
-0.3958042562007904,
0.12491211295127869,
0.16668739914894104,
0.6167025566101074,
-0.29628440737724304,
0.585944652557373,
-0.5987823605537415,
0.2646644115447998,
0.06636332720518112,
-0.08020070195198059,
0.3067995011806488,
-0.6282700300216675,
-0.2723436653614044,
-0.1647602766752243,
0.7433305382728577,
0.8162857890129089,
0.214309424161911,
-0.29768893122673035,
-0.08136262744665146,
0.3133865296840668,
0.29455673694610596,
-0.6747791767120361,
-0.22854062914848328,
-0.023844892159104347,
-0.4703064262866974,
-0.44578540325164795,
0.10369517654180527,
-0.5962724685668945,
-0.5693013668060303,
-0.18715114891529083,
0.2522752285003662,
-0.4973279535770416,
-0.14773975312709808,
0.18472398817539215,
-0.37649592757225037,
-0.1310366690158844,
0.38865378499031067,
-0.817289412021637,
0.6457230448722839,
0.7065791487693787,
0.598483145236969,
-0.3491818606853485,
-0.1991564780473709,
-0.3565158247947693,
-0.1295057088136673,
0.20989976823329926,
1.0242444276809692,
-0.7791371941566467,
-0.9191206693649292,
0.029811810702085495,
-0.19584143161773682,
0.06858749687671661,
-0.26364511251449585,
0.7743218541145325,
-0.2263154536485672,
0.2181553691625595,
-0.42042815685272217,
-0.2729306221008301,
0.15551349520683289,
0.1685427874326706,
0.19178202748298645,
0.7433746457099915,
0.07748239487409592,
-0.5388579368591309,
0.6205019354820251,
-1.0055630207061768,
-0.2970755398273468,
0.39086243510246277,
-0.04518618434667587,
0.2627449631690979,
-0.14752887189388275,
-0.28528836369514465,
0.27955254912376404,
-0.407553106546402,
0.18407170474529266,
-0.48160046339035034,
-0.7363147735595703,
0.3907807469367981,
-0.27703413367271423,
0.3017446994781494,
0.35212385654449463,
0.1458657681941986,
0.2560243308544159,
-0.5784130692481995,
0.3149101436138153,
-0.1009400263428688,
-0.30759355425834656,
-0.10181108862161636,
-0.22486650943756104,
0.2572527527809143,
-0.1127171739935875,
0.2885321080684662,
-0.5687441825866699,
0.20933988690376282,
-0.16082763671875,
0.6647440195083618,
0.45600277185440063,
0.1015474945306778,
0.6625379323959351,
-0.33087077736854553,
0.5006424188613892,
-0.14811542630195618,
0.5659637451171875,
-0.32269880175590515,
-0.39439019560813904,
-1.0356199741363525,
-0.07109866291284561,
0.037407755851745605,
0.4608374238014221,
-0.4258192479610443,
0.601675271987915,
-0.2262328565120697,
-0.7640073299407959,
-0.03353344649076462,
0.07325301319360733,
0.9319212436676025,
0.2589222490787506,
0.1767064481973648,
-0.8915557861328125,
-0.5387952327728271,
-1.0199453830718994,
-0.14630016684532166,
-0.5303579568862915,
-0.000979951350018382,
0.4778136610984802,
0.1660870462656021,
-0.28307056427001953,
0.7599536180496216,
-0.3161412179470062,
-0.3377493619918823,
-0.3516799509525299,
-0.10275858640670776,
-0.20209501683712006,
0.34499096870422363,
0.02781968005001545,
-0.21952877938747406,
-0.20818932354450226,
-0.22129881381988525,
-0.41084036231040955,
-0.23215050995349884,
0.329647958278656,
-0.13950850069522858,
-0.14783883094787598,
0.03838983178138733,
-0.3204370141029358,
0.569062352180481,
0.05628843232989311,
-0.7018289566040039,
0.6588112115859985,
-0.32667112350463867,
0.46874648332595825,
-0.49448078870773315,
-0.17466463148593903,
0.39377763867378235,
0.045243363827466965,
-0.4614373445510864,
-0.03063812479376793,
-0.16578243672847748,
-0.31248241662979126,
-0.34920114278793335,
0.3280249238014221,
0.09584371745586395,
-0.21527637541294098,
-0.18443864583969116,
0.4897289574146271,
0.33142274618148804,
0.2802216112613678,
-0.04268591105937958,
0.5779940485954285,
0.32391664385795593,
-0.6834629774093628,
0.31538185477256775,
0.46393677592277527,
-0.18954940140247345,
1.269517183303833,
-0.6667974591255188,
0.24074815213680267,
0.43360635638237,
0.4281814396381378,
-0.8621138334274292,
0.32398438453674316,
0.4514835476875305,
-0.3767300844192505,
-0.26229429244995117,
-0.002299271523952484,
-0.12894059717655182,
-0.36888745427131653,
-0.2751050889492035,
0.18884828686714172,
0.1928098350763321,
-0.18173883855342865,
0.20205481350421906,
0.34390997886657715,
-0.08099827915430069,
-0.3431902527809143,
-0.16955026984214783,
0.55820631980896,
-0.0936976969242096,
-0.8125324845314026,
0.29842638969421387,
-0.39335042238235474,
-0.20203225314617157,
-0.35104814171791077,
0.045954085886478424,
0.16448993980884552,
0.1672862470149994,
0.5548563003540039,
0.2867039740085602,
-0.157420352101326,
0.045467033982276917,
-0.32775625586509705,
-0.4585230052471161,
-0.14261864125728607,
-0.16520898044109344,
0.5820540189743042,
-0.5453359484672546,
-0.5479453802108765,
-0.7863020896911621,
0.10884372144937515,
0.5016453266143799,
-0.09154180437326431,
0.011816895566880703,
0.5313354134559631,
0.06890981644392014,
-0.0035564990248531103,
-0.6890733242034912,
-0.5888206362724304,
-0.4227021038532257,
0.3455527424812317,
-0.45527029037475586,
-0.7539070844650269,
0.3247624635696411,
0.1996670365333557,
0.0022945604287087917,
0.0483662411570549,
0.4490312933921814,
-0.13054034113883972,
0.7298009991645813,
0.7597478032112122,
0.12486923485994339,
0.525119960308075,
-0.018713360652327538,
0.56218022108078,
-1.1166410446166992,
-0.45533955097198486,
-0.8058449625968933,
-0.1764734983444214,
-0.12149261683225632,
-0.2500416338443756,
0.2650984823703766,
0.16440561413764954,
-0.39487946033477783,
0.49183768033981323,
-0.5280252695083618,
0.06782069802284241,
0.5119026899337769,
0.21419981122016907,
0.6267138123512268,
0.05145282670855522,
-0.4302210807800293,
-0.07588320225477219,
-0.631706178188324,
-0.8331645727157593,
0.8880987167358398,
0.5042855143547058,
0.649672269821167,
-0.04609287157654762,
0.4149688184261322,
0.8261793851852417,
0.4252234101295471,
-0.8488868474960327,
0.8072406053543091,
0.29641425609588623,
-0.32579466700553894,
-0.46836352348327637,
-0.10216446220874786,
-0.479413777589798,
0.29330310225486755,
-0.6009411215782166,
-1.0700600147247314,
0.09737759083509445,
0.0967002660036087,
-0.41767698526382446,
-0.13495196402072906,
-0.8398598432540894,
0.6830781698226929,
-0.07469700276851654,
-0.3844839930534363,
-0.6423763632774353,
-0.2916140556335449,
0.1428987681865692,
0.389800488948822,
0.0400179959833622,
-0.10627128928899765,
0.22228902578353882,
0.7065778970718384,
-0.35886436700820923,
0.7022804617881775,
-0.279914528131485,
0.1163516566157341,
0.36514827609062195,
0.4418752193450928,
0.08853808045387268,
0.22611725330352783,
-0.2388969510793686,
0.22882455587387085,
0.3812975287437439,
-0.058594003319740295,
-0.7845826148986816,
0.7240044474601746,
-0.5656742453575134,
-0.6607412099838257,
-0.20177580416202545,
-0.040541984140872955,
-0.29679417610168457,
-0.023039046674966812,
-0.21148215234279633,
0.5467047691345215,
-0.7379377484321594,
0.3739088773727417,
-0.033116742968559265,
-0.015968870371580124,
0.1058160811662674,
1.0013079643249512,
-0.48431307077407837,
-0.5311857461929321,
0.8410828709602356,
-0.3918984830379486,
0.1759510189294815,
-0.002166044432669878,
0.3055797219276428,
-0.2507023215293884,
-0.46950674057006836,
-0.47121381759643555,
-0.04531380161643028,
-0.6039409637451172,
-0.013720412738621235,
-0.4734360873699188,
-0.08489064127206802,
-0.21594898402690887,
-0.16117331385612488,
-0.09568776935338974,
-0.34524819254875183,
0.021740444004535675,
-0.1212993711233139,
0.1459384709596634,
0.5436769723892212,
0.17136958241462708,
0.6024604439735413,
-0.5958122611045837,
0.07632452994585037,
0.05464629456400871,
0.741195559501648,
-0.028470560908317566,
-0.7948346734046936,
-0.45692873001098633,
0.07474444806575775,
-0.6662662625312805,
-0.17501789331436157,
-0.07391130924224854,
0.012053173035383224,
0.6469996571540833,
0.8533722162246704,
-0.10727348178625107,
0.5664700865745544,
-0.28574123978614807,
0.8633707165718079,
0.6081745028495789,
-0.8068687319755554,
0.28328737616539,
-0.3605334758758545,
-0.1337888240814209,
0.7776167988777161,
-0.32436230778694153,
-0.9381237626075745,
-0.10751116275787354,
-0.6754451394081116,
-0.39415115118026733,
0.5323516130447388,
0.23026061058044434,
0.2815307080745697,
-0.1248273253440857,
0.2628057897090912,
0.18746307492256165,
0.29080837965011597,
-0.400392085313797,
-0.13770273327827454,
-0.1303243190050125,
0.3261626362800598,
-0.17121373116970062,
-0.6026890277862549,
-0.25234749913215637,
0.05311860889196396,
0.6715862154960632,
0.04051358625292778,
0.27257928252220154,
0.3410421907901764,
0.05594903975725174,
-0.4119866192340851,
0.46857911348342896,
0.308973491191864,
0.8392223119735718,
-0.4419994056224823,
-0.20951518416404724,
-0.08343815803527832,
-0.2959964871406555,
0.07450404018163681,
-0.21818043291568756,
-0.10114556550979614,
-0.5470277070999146,
-0.040647491812705994,
0.5224848389625549,
0.4266832172870636,
-0.568458616733551,
0.601559042930603,
-0.42205172777175903,
0.019117824733257294,
-0.3332608938217163,
0.43909797072410583,
-0.06775294989347458,
0.11190215498209,
0.38014882802963257,
0.38955023884773254,
0.2793164849281311,
-0.5524278283119202,
0.21780593693256378,
0.4674846827983856,
-1.03700590133667,
-0.36258676648139954,
-0.05094488337635994,
0.9938589334487915,
-0.9411084651947021,
0.06717292964458466,
-0.12366259843111038,
-0.26218676567077637,
0.3144513964653015,
0.41806110739707947,
0.8074527382850647,
-0.12580506503582,
0.5134909152984619,
0.06623117625713348,
0.08282940089702606,
0.09652581810951233,
0.22742842137813568,
-0.1896006315946579,
-0.8403523564338684,
0.16467873752117157,
-0.45704346895217896,
-0.525428831577301,
-0.07566807419061661,
-0.5536156892776489,
0.6614239811897278,
-0.5675907135009766,
-0.3488919138908386,
0.04886632785201073,
0.06330648064613342,
-0.7861385345458984,
0.12635210156440735,
0.06348658353090286,
0.95390784740448,
-0.6233813762664795,
0.4348984956741333,
0.6297143697738647,
-0.2886010408401489,
-0.3162921369075775,
-0.32342708110809326,
-0.1097773090004921,
-0.6512249112129211,
0.5374602675437927,
-0.04142788052558899,
-0.4398748278617859,
-0.40133726596832275,
-0.1828938126564026,
-0.3098399043083191,
1.0586413145065308,
0.01498470176011324,
-0.5112543106079102,
0.31876859068870544,
-0.04414224624633789,
0.7612908482551575,
-0.8728956580162048,
0.8995862007141113,
0.5379762649536133,
0.4746496379375458,
-0.0011828559217974544,
-1.2796051502227783,
-0.014042853377759457,
-0.3762824237346649,
0.014888792298734188,
-0.2808258533477783,
-0.7628408670425415,
0.029864352196455002,
-0.4201975464820862,
-0.14724695682525635,
0.3950580656528473,
0.32716599106788635,
0.2613917589187622,
0.6777991652488708,
0.7608599066734314,
0.4277183413505554,
0.34916040301322937,
0.18690110743045807,
0.7761276364326477,
-0.4592193067073822,
0.018443137407302856,
0.9534410834312439,
-0.6457424759864807,
0.6845898032188416,
0.5586308240890503,
-0.3746695816516876,
0.550051212310791,
0.42232444882392883,
0.22516527771949768,
0.34023910760879517,
0.454162061214447,
-0.18555474281311035,
-0.38168296217918396,
-0.4579993486404419,
-0.38867515325546265,
0.5843014717102051,
0.46054917573928833,
-0.18232694268226624,
-0.15954886376857758,
-0.12217619270086288,
-0.23427143692970276,
0.15405015647411346,
0.1250474750995636,
0.7824859619140625,
0.10363762825727463,
-0.5666269659996033,
0.44409656524658203,
0.1730479747056961,
0.5719685554504395,
-0.47038063406944275,
-0.2220047265291214,
-0.12701687216758728,
-0.13258211314678192,
-0.28317731618881226,
-0.5863441228866577,
-0.31814298033714294,
-0.10689352452754974,
-0.28644517064094543,
-0.08398908376693726,
0.7801772356033325,
0.10973378270864487,
-0.17261727154254913,
0.4155375063419342,
0.7684713006019592,
0.26966699957847595,
0.08614816516637802,
-0.6969040036201477,
0.03621099516749382,
-0.0204333383589983,
-0.16313143074512482,
0.3158484697341919,
0.4263877868652344,
-0.019238924607634544,
1.2460004091262817,
0.7866479158401489,
0.09428548067808151,
-0.664943516254425,
0.5165995359420776,
0.8659606575965881,
-0.5761182904243469,
-0.6979284286499023,
-0.41970187425613403,
0.3216380774974823,
-0.002974905539304018,
-0.444873183965683,
0.6909222602844238,
0.5307578444480896,
0.3964625298976898,
0.2954842448234558,
0.9855283498764038,
0.025925615802407265,
0.5096738338470459,
0.06988315284252167,
0.4439575970172882,
0.06958288699388504,
0.9587007164955139,
-0.5462261438369751,
-1.165322184562683,
0.038452547043561935,
0.42404496669769287,
-0.4664829671382904,
0.17359322309494019,
0.7320688366889954,
0.7776181101799011,
-0.06471411138772964,
0.5845195055007935,
0.4720531105995178,
-0.13714028894901276,
0.34711796045303345,
0.2035885900259018,
1.0835151672363281,
-0.12180067598819733,
0.6250453591346741,
-0.21835799515247345,
-0.5975192189216614,
-0.7612075805664062,
-0.8909565806388855,
-0.7553898096084595,
-0.41548144817352295,
-0.1847108155488968,
-0.4816248416900635,
0.344241738319397,
0.9235988259315491,
0.7880110144615173,
-0.48689308762550354,
-0.431113600730896,
0.11289506405591965,
0.01728581078350544,
-0.17547832429409027,
-0.25824806094169617,
-0.13934916257858276,
-0.23873856663703918,
-0.13338103890419006,
0.4206148684024811,
0.5381423830986023,
-0.22304147481918335,
-0.7168477177619934,
-0.22280004620552063,
0.44315242767333984,
-0.0073051052168011665,
0.5177687406539917,
0.09384129196405411,
-0.5498198866844177,
-0.6464374661445618,
-0.06988029927015305,
-0.13174177706241608,
0.06020129472017288,
1.1545023918151855,
-0.8936672806739807,
0.45633211731910706,
0.277263343334198,
-0.08895426988601685,
-0.021349437534809113,
0.1496364176273346,
0.6691901683807373,
0.05112284794449806,
-0.021134117618203163,
0.10224674642086029,
0.36443161964416504,
0.3461254835128784,
-0.23173308372497559,
0.3032141327857971,
0.35036200284957886,
-0.6224686503410339,
-0.7321151494979858,
0.2478504180908203,
-1.209900975227356,
0.25469714403152466,
1.20415461063385,
-0.2907662093639374,
0.33734163641929626,
-0.47442150115966797,
-0.5315579175949097,
-0.1335502713918686,
-1.1568173170089722,
0.9661122560501099,
0.5185203552246094,
-0.0759892612695694,
0.3080146610736847,
-0.290718674659729,
0.144631028175354,
0.4119216203689575,
-0.18884655833244324,
0.26555323600769043,
0.3757307827472687,
0.27617257833480835,
0.3353212773799896,
0.743446409702301,
-0.20865781605243683,
0.12725920975208282,
-0.2829400300979614,
0.3095325529575348,
-0.13469231128692627,
-0.4319683313369751,
-0.09865213185548782,
0.10548452287912369,
0.29753464460372925,
0.105269655585289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03302v1
|
How Easily do Irrelevant Inputs Skew the Responses of Large Language Models?
| 2024-04-04T08:52:30 | 2024-04-04T08:52:30 |
Siye Wu, Jian Xie, Jiangjie Chen, Tinghui Zhu, Kai Zhang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
By leveraging the retrieval of information from external knowledge databases,
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit enhanced capabilities for accomplishing
many knowledge-intensive tasks. However, due to the inherent flaws of current
retrieval systems, there might exist irrelevant information within those
retrieving top-ranked passages. In this work, we present a comprehensive
investigation into the robustness of LLMs to different types of irrelevant
information under various conditions. We initially introduce a framework to
construct high-quality irrelevant information that ranges from semantically
unrelated, partially related, and related to questions. Furthermore, our
analysis demonstrates that the constructed irrelevant information not only
scores highly on similarity metrics, being highly retrieved by existing
systems, but also bears semantic connections to the context. Our investigation
reveals that current LLMs still face challenges in discriminating highly
semantically related information and can be easily distracted by these
irrelevant yet misleading contents. Besides, we also find that current
solutions for handling irrelevant information have limitations in improving the
robustness of LLMs to such distractions. Resources are available at
https://github.com/Di-viner/LLM-Robustness-to-Irrelevant-Information.
|
[
-0.37467026710510254,
-0.9622234106063843,
0.8301247954368591,
-0.19729405641555786,
0.006027075927704573,
-0.3112138509750366,
-0.25354260206222534,
-0.4201340973377228,
-0.10944156348705292,
0.3770049810409546,
-0.4031468331813812,
-0.2537696361541748,
-0.7413954138755798,
-0.2275351732969284,
-0.7045959830284119,
0.99619460105896,
0.3122135102748871,
-0.09703927487134933,
-0.4532184898853302,
-0.5112267136573792,
-0.39922085404396057,
-0.7959787249565125,
-0.22584405541419983,
-0.0868927538394928,
0.7360993027687073,
0.2547433376312256,
0.8000568151473999,
0.5973402261734009,
0.6013129949569702,
0.29495587944984436,
-0.29395878314971924,
-0.18053509294986725,
-0.7391982078552246,
0.5009778141975403,
-0.6084474921226501,
-0.6017431020736694,
-0.17812000215053558,
-0.3301834762096405,
0.6373229026794434,
0.7556318044662476,
0.05317161977291107,
0.5125510096549988,
0.26823103427886963,
0.5716379284858704,
-0.8947852849960327,
0.2541249394416809,
-1.2308495044708252,
-0.47550126910209656,
-0.4789876639842987,
-0.22962352633476257,
-0.5267026424407959,
-0.16910383105278015,
0.08985741436481476,
-0.4316856265068054,
0.016446469351649284,
-0.03418717533349991,
1.0340813398361206,
0.31893572211265564,
-0.36730676889419556,
-0.6713985800743103,
-0.8673014640808105,
0.6509642004966736,
-0.7941049337387085,
0.24254067242145538,
0.8558298945426941,
0.14271174371242523,
-0.05652112141251564,
-0.31453537940979004,
-0.3402840495109558,
-0.24097733199596405,
-0.11424386501312256,
-0.11362573504447937,
-0.010613318532705307,
-0.12127610296010971,
0.31624141335487366,
0.22633659839630127,
-0.35336801409721375,
0.07413630932569504,
-0.08443102985620499,
-0.1670360267162323,
0.18061727285385132,
0.19189618527889252,
0.24341975152492523,
-0.14462032914161682,
0.08070427179336548,
0.047368794679641724,
-1.0175458192825317,
0.0390993133187294,
0.4559398889541626,
0.3455250859260559,
0.23712460696697235,
0.9708038568496704,
-0.12833699584007263,
0.861506462097168,
0.2555979788303375,
-0.33870455622673035,
-0.05497266724705696,
-0.29221299290657043,
0.1621432602405548,
-0.4168720245361328,
0.5833377242088318,
0.1033325344324112,
0.034776438027620316,
-0.31520554423332214,
-0.3181684613227844,
-0.08644229918718338,
0.28017380833625793,
-0.5630137920379639,
0.04669494181871414,
0.37742218375205994,
-0.15890994668006897,
-0.14086875319480896,
-0.16565100848674774,
-0.5702094435691833,
-0.3465951979160309,
-0.11152657121419907,
0.6401675939559937,
-0.39887088537216187,
-0.16828912496566772,
-0.5011860728263855,
0.11539971828460693,
0.22761909663677216,
0.27288419008255005,
-0.7482472062110901,
0.005826103501021862,
0.6056895852088928,
0.6821559071540833,
-0.3250839114189148,
-0.0058416337706148624,
-0.704769492149353,
0.36713987588882446,
-0.254219114780426,
0.5992850065231323,
-0.6125727891921997,
0.025127172470092773,
0.11181404441595078,
0.020779499784111977,
0.07043160498142242,
-0.5747541189193726,
0.47300276160240173,
-1.0752915143966675,
-0.027552597224712372,
-0.4966762065887451,
-0.5189705491065979,
-0.05954704433679581,
0.42452943325042725,
-0.7431418299674988,
0.8800669312477112,
0.1410597413778305,
-1.1966153383255005,
0.1412741094827652,
-0.013543380424380302,
-0.49381422996520996,
-0.09748656302690506,
-0.19849158823490143,
-0.11788240820169449,
0.09859073162078857,
-0.19284726679325104,
0.5720741152763367,
-0.37919288873672485,
0.4966505765914917,
-0.7907558679580688,
-0.2575095593929291,
0.5790635347366333,
-0.5432385802268982,
0.42889678478240967,
0.16825968027114868,
-0.07182680815458298,
-0.1700785607099533,
-1.0491242408752441,
-0.18349415063858032,
0.11691970378160477,
-0.5782629251480103,
-0.6470575928688049,
0.28463107347488403,
-0.30351078510284424,
0.4976379871368408,
0.21549944579601288,
-0.3821057081222534,
-0.25597259402275085,
-0.36869943141937256,
0.4425007998943329,
0.8551812767982483,
-0.12100058794021606,
0.44410133361816406,
-0.4766152799129486,
0.36907103657722473,
0.20014908909797668,
-0.28425151109695435,
-0.03400404751300812,
-0.21337191760540009,
-0.7646217942237854,
-0.02209111861884594,
0.1342744380235672,
0.5806640386581421,
-1.0600738525390625,
0.2664288580417633,
-0.5729807615280151,
-0.2987269163131714,
-0.27670854330062866,
0.3440476655960083,
0.21561600267887115,
0.7812538146972656,
0.10903144627809525,
0.11779484152793884,
-0.22841612994670868,
-0.8374817967414856,
-0.3502429127693176,
-0.33267855644226074,
-0.06791512668132782,
0.2682744562625885,
0.355810284614563,
0.10563379526138306,
0.9196093082427979,
-0.29807451367378235,
-0.09112933278083801,
-0.12751273810863495,
-0.35051366686820984,
0.30408933758735657,
0.22592301666736603,
0.32066717743873596,
-0.6435844302177429,
-0.2935734987258911,
0.03009713627398014,
-0.6940634250640869,
-0.031474728137254715,
0.049261245876550674,
0.07148075848817825,
0.0276857390999794,
0.5838813781738281,
-0.8507937788963318,
0.34813690185546875,
0.3208393454551697,
-0.1204301118850708,
0.3330177962779999,
0.054592300206422806,
-0.13133105635643005,
-0.977072536945343,
0.5018355846405029,
-0.13803020119667053,
-0.20687873661518097,
-0.610589325428009,
0.14102597534656525,
-0.046394068747758865,
0.09278594702482224,
-0.42902472615242004,
0.5992282629013062,
-0.38599473237991333,
0.10066413134336472,
-0.2675184905529022,
0.32519733905792236,
-0.07331822067499161,
0.44297417998313904,
-0.1501716524362564,
0.551180362701416,
0.40292736887931824,
-0.9777098894119263,
0.2422533929347992,
0.07411022484302521,
-0.35337668657302856,
0.588239312171936,
-0.4330696165561676,
0.03194410726428032,
-0.4408598840236664,
0.04977389797568321,
-0.9769957661628723,
-0.6781020760536194,
0.20195803046226501,
-0.4182240962982178,
0.405928373336792,
-0.2890653908252716,
-0.508529007434845,
-0.1195363774895668,
-0.2332047075033188,
0.5097013115882874,
0.2980463206768036,
-0.41752099990844727,
0.5689135789871216,
0.6503632068634033,
-0.5872095227241516,
-0.6670083403587341,
-0.6691118478775024,
-0.1880694329738617,
-0.37634214758872986,
-0.34110212326049805,
-0.14688822627067566,
-0.042001377791166306,
-0.3998286724090576,
0.1162012442946434,
-0.31925392150878906,
-0.4001781642436981,
0.20869401097297668,
0.2883336842060089,
0.3780040144920349,
-0.34563857316970825,
0.47607436776161194,
-0.18809399008750916,
0.22833648324012756,
0.17872540652751923,
-0.12600623071193695,
0.3571923077106476,
0.2637466490268707,
-0.6742112636566162,
-0.06800335645675659,
0.30346769094467163,
0.8975756168365479,
0.23636719584465027,
0.9195482134819031,
0.4867097735404968,
-0.48766618967056274,
-0.006300080567598343,
-0.7969278693199158,
-0.010775466449558735,
-0.42380771040916443,
0.6667230725288391,
-0.3895508348941803,
-1.1167505979537964,
0.602251410484314,
0.35338330268859863,
0.15944799780845642,
0.5214213728904724,
0.6899564862251282,
0.016176428645849228,
0.9089665412902832,
0.42348459362983704,
-0.1819535791873932,
0.2834908664226532,
0.34411486983299255,
0.2588917911052704,
-0.7476810216903687,
-0.21232180297374725,
-0.7192666530609131,
0.13584302365779877,
-0.4043028950691223,
-0.23417001962661743,
0.09364611655473709,
0.12007647752761841,
-0.20282700657844543,
0.24235451221466064,
-0.27038729190826416,
0.334128737449646,
0.44042444229125977,
-0.005421787966042757,
0.3382992446422577,
-0.09841171652078629,
-0.12621304392814636,
-0.14182952046394348,
-0.840873122215271,
-0.5347097516059875,
1.1358684301376343,
0.5047435760498047,
1.1848019361495972,
0.3335803747177124,
-0.019379006698727608,
0.04308667406439781,
0.455400288105011,
-0.8329868912696838,
0.4042993187904358,
-0.03476465493440628,
-0.881758451461792,
-0.3284910321235657,
-0.5595961213111877,
-0.7231087684631348,
0.3309732675552368,
-0.16302995383739471,
-0.9807672500610352,
0.20306597650051117,
0.2696143090724945,
-0.4035833179950714,
0.3718074858188629,
-0.6768094897270203,
0.2894827723503113,
-0.21288642287254333,
-0.7217383980751038,
0.1986408829689026,
-0.5531045198440552,
0.4278757870197296,
-0.5626911520957947,
0.5233338475227356,
-0.17643027007579803,
-0.15941044688224792,
0.5022011995315552,
-0.3252488970756531,
0.7889255285263062,
-0.005671184044331312,
-0.4895811378955841,
0.26098302006721497,
0.37070101499557495,
0.5414239764213562,
0.17990505695343018,
-0.41449353098869324,
-0.03780636563897133,
0.16470614075660706,
-0.3542838394641876,
-0.5595290064811707,
0.9501528143882751,
-0.5122871398925781,
-0.8723982572555542,
-0.3563339114189148,
-0.8359679579734802,
-0.5953310132026672,
0.24840573966503143,
0.3528428077697754,
0.43013909459114075,
0.06341798603534698,
0.48673224449157715,
0.7735572457313538,
-0.2905218303203583,
0.3797900676727295,
0.5803580284118652,
0.06850691139698029,
-0.01748894900083542,
1.1532231569290161,
0.3828394412994385,
0.5382755398750305,
0.6274420022964478,
-0.0727413222193718,
-0.4113274812698364,
-0.5027094483375549,
-0.3528437614440918,
0.050091080367565155,
-0.9618691205978394,
-0.2879676818847656,
-0.6729484796524048,
-0.35083839297294617,
-0.3625767230987549,
0.30815041065216064,
-0.2735874056816101,
-0.35475316643714905,
-0.4010252356529236,
0.07313015311956406,
0.031402427703142166,
0.926422119140625,
0.30024418234825134,
0.06968988478183746,
-0.7397868633270264,
0.2580835819244385,
0.27211353182792664,
0.39324355125427246,
0.235784649848938,
-0.8582437038421631,
-0.17702820897102356,
-0.01055451575666666,
-0.08738275617361069,
-0.6713610291481018,
0.04306692257523537,
0.1711750030517578,
0.675609290599823,
0.5251413583755493,
0.20767344534397125,
0.4892283082008362,
-0.3208810091018677,
0.7515454888343811,
-0.1166418194770813,
-0.67348712682724,
0.33218953013420105,
-0.46013614535331726,
0.515925943851471,
0.6802659630775452,
0.5077576041221619,
-0.046676088124513626,
-0.715399444103241,
-0.3296560049057007,
-1.1137880086898804,
0.8436794877052307,
0.16189509630203247,
0.22799867391586304,
-0.04026740416884422,
0.5011915564537048,
0.16902735829353333,
0.16191798448562622,
-1.1916272640228271,
-0.17332957684993744,
0.04430306330323219,
-0.33365997672080994,
0.14443042874336243,
-0.3857968747615814,
-0.05370045825839043,
0.07173503190279007,
0.7628951668739319,
0.005819289013743401,
0.07495234161615372,
-0.056083180010318756,
-0.3666165769100189,
0.14144979417324066,
0.4754897952079773,
0.5084598660469055,
0.6743791103363037,
-0.11820890009403229,
0.358275830745697,
0.3443465530872345,
-0.5123212337493896,
0.2536095678806305,
-0.1539049595594406,
-0.3807847797870636,
0.009731597267091274,
0.5148792862892151,
0.5223804116249084,
0.014622245915234089,
-0.7641454339027405,
0.6192755103111267,
0.06943334639072418,
0.10536723583936691,
-0.16918621957302094,
0.0878458246588707,
0.25370028614997864,
-0.14547815918922424,
0.33366864919662476,
0.047069136053323746,
-0.10338643938302994,
-0.5627922415733337,
-0.00001857997449405957,
0.6707931756973267,
-0.5989758968353271,
-0.3818144202232361,
0.5483559370040894,
-0.10283347219228745,
0.0048633236438035965,
0.31188228726387024,
0.04183443635702133,
-0.21922218799591064,
0.27225109934806824,
0.5047215819358826,
0.26486530900001526,
-0.0660315677523613,
-0.18923000991344452,
0.30826297402381897,
0.3825252652168274,
-0.017293138429522514,
-0.1840757578611374,
-0.05869980528950691,
-0.5348871350288391,
-0.5625202059745789,
-0.5020968317985535,
-0.08455637097358704,
0.6709848046302795,
-0.7041137218475342,
0.0050194174982607365,
-0.5029191374778748,
-0.3760918974876404,
-0.13762076199054718,
-0.6308162212371826,
-0.7102759480476379,
0.09286440163850784,
-0.1357789784669876,
0.7077756524085999,
-0.615826427936554,
0.8232550024986267,
0.6420128345489502,
-0.4118848443031311,
-0.7264470458030701,
0.3531475365161896,
0.039313845336437225,
-0.777738094329834,
0.7307386994361877,
-0.1243913322687149,
-0.2172822654247284,
-0.41241687536239624,
-0.46994829177856445,
-1.389722228050232,
0.6213874220848083,
0.5927795171737671,
-0.4628523588180542,
-0.37252289056777954,
0.20415693521499634,
0.475766122341156,
0.09891241043806076,
0.2573092579841614,
0.3274722397327423,
0.3097548186779022,
0.2852770984172821,
-0.6959333419799805,
0.305175244808197,
-0.212050199508667,
-0.08465973287820816,
0.10749481618404388,
-0.5845887064933777,
0.7397031784057617,
0.0238493662327528,
-0.29780659079551697,
0.23669594526290894,
0.36664170026779175,
0.016072068363428116,
-0.0028397904243320227,
0.27813956141471863,
0.4192628562450409,
0.5071149468421936,
-0.11433887481689453,
0.9171378016471863,
-0.29847726225852966,
0.21285870671272278,
1.4639098644256592,
-0.3544200658798218,
1.0024218559265137,
0.7203340530395508,
-0.06474435329437256,
0.080115906894207,
0.36059895157814026,
0.29337000846862793,
0.42307358980178833,
0.22901353240013123,
-0.15551184117794037,
-0.2841944694519043,
-0.09615054726600647,
-0.35794490575790405,
0.28876328468322754,
0.6915819644927979,
-0.15848496556282043,
-0.2668724060058594,
-0.18122345209121704,
-0.12457942217588425,
-0.16768603026866913,
-0.10178466141223907,
0.9217221736907959,
0.14584773778915405,
-0.8709256649017334,
0.4516722857952118,
-0.07966148853302002,
0.6385438442230225,
-0.7680717706680298,
0.034900736063718796,
-0.10853670537471771,
0.18168580532073975,
-0.2625419795513153,
-0.7987681031227112,
0.3699191212654114,
-0.0001941750233527273,
-0.3483416438102722,
0.2656351327896118,
0.9032411575317383,
-0.21753686666488647,
-0.3868963420391083,
0.25517961382865906,
0.6718752384185791,
-0.02642945386469364,
0.022776708006858826,
-0.3183184564113617,
0.16906486451625824,
-0.08231677860021591,
-0.2984010577201843,
0.6288118362426758,
0.6129898428916931,
-0.11483407765626907,
1.112561821937561,
0.5167439579963684,
0.28660041093826294,
0.14170724153518677,
-0.2354166954755783,
0.8262184262275696,
-0.525675356388092,
-0.18067888915538788,
-0.9492549300193787,
0.1335967481136322,
0.08230321109294891,
-0.21523787081241608,
0.8945229649543762,
0.26282545924186707,
0.8011669516563416,
-0.015090469270944595,
0.7705283761024475,
-0.10638949275016785,
0.7846450209617615,
-0.5360323786735535,
0.7253707647323608,
-0.5032917857170105,
0.7268470525741577,
-0.34290310740470886,
-0.9215925931930542,
-0.2075708508491516,
0.3210091292858124,
-0.23206092417240143,
0.16152450442314148,
0.5608362555503845,
0.944679319858551,
-0.15216894447803497,
-0.37267380952835083,
0.476301908493042,
0.4090178310871124,
0.10822073370218277,
0.4017452597618103,
1.1040523052215576,
-0.1549886167049408,
0.932891309261322,
0.10533230751752853,
0.07874040305614471,
-0.1960524469614029,
-0.6527365446090698,
-0.8956005573272705,
-0.6788643598556519,
-0.10178867727518082,
-0.6407590508460999,
0.08916237950325012,
0.5652139186859131,
0.7247155904769897,
-1.0314311981201172,
0.026084760203957558,
0.16975189745426178,
0.2963413894176483,
0.47060126066207886,
-0.2629764676094055,
0.3735935688018799,
-0.2816351652145386,
-0.4004236161708832,
0.054516762495040894,
0.3613286316394806,
-0.009225885383784771,
-0.29544469714164734,
0.14759469032287598,
-0.2858751118183136,
0.14896084368228912,
0.7014747858047485,
0.3096453845500946,
-0.851323664188385,
-0.5556226968765259,
0.013441266492009163,
-0.41172266006469727,
-0.07753951847553253,
0.6475873589515686,
-0.5410387516021729,
0.1466081440448761,
0.6220041513442993,
0.9469826817512512,
0.16936258971691132,
0.17107854783535004,
0.4390272796154022,
-0.6415611505508423,
0.1101124957203865,
0.2255161851644516,
0.3154762387275696,
0.4378591775894165,
-0.49194374680519104,
0.12011101841926575,
0.07215723395347595,
-0.4932594895362854,
-0.7246330380439758,
0.2344285249710083,
-0.7853881120681763,
-0.37511345744132996,
1.5047613382339478,
-0.22615785896778107,
-0.2318192720413208,
-0.5142894983291626,
-0.1226106733083725,
-0.1269380748271942,
-0.16213443875312805,
0.7363068461418152,
1.3065407276153564,
0.10474807024002075,
0.06458322703838348,
-0.7559871077537537,
0.2684134840965271,
0.6005797386169434,
-0.6941837072372437,
-0.007927848957479,
0.6018754243850708,
0.6676068305969238,
0.21652957797050476,
0.5943730473518372,
-0.3568333089351654,
0.06717453896999359,
-0.08325131237506866,
-0.5730742812156677,
0.3074430823326111,
-0.15125136077404022,
-0.2235995978116989,
0.5468323230743408,
0.62833172082901,
0.08114704489707947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03301v1
|
Probing Large Language Models for Scalar Adjective Lexical Semantics and Scalar Diversity Pragmatics
| 2024-04-04T08:52:25 | 2024-04-04T08:52:25 |
Fangru Lin, Daniel Altshuler, Janet B. Pierrehumbert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scalar adjectives pertain to various domain scales and vary in intensity
within each scale (e.g. certain is more intense than likely on the likelihood
scale). Scalar implicatures arise from the consideration of alternative
statements which could have been made. They can be triggered by scalar
adjectives and require listeners to reason pragmatically about them. Some
scalar adjectives are more likely to trigger scalar implicatures than others.
This phenomenon is referred to as scalar diversity. In this study, we probe
different families of Large Language Models such as GPT-4 for their knowledge
of the lexical semantics of scalar adjectives and one specific aspect of their
pragmatics, namely scalar diversity. We find that they encode rich
lexical-semantic information about scalar adjectives. However, the rich
lexical-semantic knowledge does not entail a good understanding of scalar
diversity. We also compare current models of different sizes and complexities
and find that larger models are not always better. Finally, we explain our
probing results by leveraging linguistic intuitions and model training
objectives.
|
[
-0.760359525680542,
-0.797940731048584,
0.2082364708185196,
0.016763390973210335,
0.031097587198019028,
-0.014660368673503399,
-0.18977294862270355,
-0.461799681186676,
0.024475840851664543,
0.2898344397544861,
-0.395126074552536,
-0.06495052576065063,
-0.8643501400947571,
0.15658071637153625,
-0.3547307848930359,
1.455550193786621,
0.1437164843082428,
-0.031849827617406845,
-0.01566942408680916,
-0.28311046957969666,
-0.1912069469690323,
-0.7328316569328308,
-0.2913765013217926,
-0.04690007492899895,
0.759384274482727,
0.2594587504863739,
1.0464465618133545,
0.4900432825088501,
0.7782639265060425,
0.36882466077804565,
-0.498131662607193,
-0.04883790388703346,
-0.6429623365402222,
0.2502867579460144,
-0.3522379398345947,
-0.45112261176109314,
-0.15757198631763458,
-0.10199631750583649,
0.8082993030548096,
0.824637234210968,
0.03828715533018112,
0.1862412691116333,
-0.13696645200252533,
0.4242607057094574,
-0.75152987241745,
0.07705442607402802,
-0.630743145942688,
-0.060644473880529404,
-0.08972025662660599,
0.08551077544689178,
0.03661488741636276,
-0.11601541936397552,
0.4197433292865753,
-0.3408334255218506,
0.4063837230205536,
-0.08629371225833893,
1.1991101503372192,
0.0946732684969902,
-0.7610526084899902,
-0.2586729824542999,
-0.7740249037742615,
0.8246028423309326,
-0.7431509494781494,
0.4231441020965576,
0.3406074345111847,
0.29766175150871277,
0.03408394381403923,
-0.7404693961143494,
-0.7990257740020752,
-0.39203783869743347,
-0.16144031286239624,
-0.028689488768577576,
-0.28033387660980225,
0.08228542655706406,
0.3304118812084198,
0.7531012296676636,
-0.43434938788414,
0.039418525993824005,
-0.12859350442886353,
-0.03499367833137512,
0.28302809596061707,
0.26695606112480164,
0.29324740171432495,
-0.2144131362438202,
-0.18498817086219788,
-0.01950467936694622,
-0.5923860669136047,
-0.052565429359674454,
0.3483600616455078,
0.1059686541557312,
0.007718274835497141,
0.6255524158477783,
-0.15466822683811188,
0.7335467338562012,
0.026792749762535095,
-0.06362786144018173,
0.2825523316860199,
-0.7950557470321655,
-0.031046047806739807,
-0.42335304617881775,
0.5802496075630188,
0.15138672292232513,
0.0728302076458931,
-0.163321390748024,
-0.3585706949234009,
0.12375174462795258,
-0.021602656692266464,
-0.9397639632225037,
-0.06577218323945999,
-0.09508761018514633,
-0.19370721280574799,
-0.14842909574508667,
-0.05203934386372566,
-0.8576448559761047,
-0.30596962571144104,
-0.15873919427394867,
0.5413886308670044,
-0.47557127475738525,
-0.4451475143432617,
0.13463596999645233,
-0.27420708537101746,
0.6257189512252808,
0.07710395008325577,
-1.1377885341644287,
0.20470662415027618,
1.0395015478134155,
0.48071807622909546,
0.17494873702526093,
-0.4397546648979187,
-0.4540923237800598,
-0.20991739630699158,
-0.20296289026737213,
0.7286447286605835,
-0.8975695371627808,
-0.3177134394645691,
-0.09075699746608734,
0.0625324547290802,
-0.07616745680570602,
-0.36039629578590393,
0.7056200504302979,
-0.5764022469520569,
0.34348025918006897,
-0.4889601171016693,
-0.6714001893997192,
-0.5392408967018127,
0.2612888216972351,
-0.5950171947479248,
0.7132048010826111,
0.42254453897476196,
-0.914174497127533,
0.86797034740448,
-0.33550241589546204,
-0.21413007378578186,
0.4259180724620819,
-0.06505695730447769,
-0.4713790714740753,
0.34896790981292725,
0.16377218067646027,
0.30800044536590576,
-0.35387369990348816,
0.1351071447134018,
-0.34169328212738037,
-0.16289980709552765,
0.5223895907402039,
-0.1955316811800003,
0.42666640877723694,
0.24568097293376923,
-0.24470402300357819,
0.11673884093761444,
-0.49190211296081543,
-0.17367595434188843,
0.000582100881729275,
-0.15339265763759613,
-0.6036084294319153,
-0.05940059572458267,
-0.14907000958919525,
0.1761058121919632,
0.1909610480070114,
-0.3275472819805145,
0.01431021187454462,
-0.4735299348831177,
0.271428644657135,
0.3705693483352661,
0.16498474776744843,
0.3979506194591522,
-0.38627973198890686,
0.6637081503868103,
0.1725023090839386,
-0.15247680246829987,
-0.14844171702861786,
-0.6028754115104675,
-0.8945307731628418,
-0.6749404072761536,
0.16485051810741425,
0.19291932880878448,
-0.4665417969226837,
0.30622416734695435,
-0.4314548969268799,
-0.34758415818214417,
-0.4717814326286316,
-0.011069197207689285,
0.3625186085700989,
0.3264560103416443,
0.07334549725055695,
-0.17586037516593933,
-0.3005773723125458,
-1.01902437210083,
-0.5845701098442078,
-0.04945915564894676,
0.06817632913589478,
0.4992753565311432,
0.9925711154937744,
-0.3927798867225647,
0.9502561092376709,
-0.27806392312049866,
0.062229223549366,
-0.3272194266319275,
0.4442561864852905,
0.12364392727613449,
0.060634590685367584,
0.7476195693016052,
-1.0964959859848022,
-0.1626208871603012,
0.29029545187950134,
-0.548617959022522,
0.08435306698083878,
0.11532489955425262,
0.13919000327587128,
-0.255511999130249,
0.0002366112166782841,
-0.48864758014678955,
0.0945957824587822,
0.5344584584236145,
-0.5783434510231018,
0.5981380939483643,
-0.13512098789215088,
0.1095857098698616,
-0.9574292302131653,
-0.31267544627189636,
0.3270002603530884,
-0.017569459974765778,
-0.8475738763809204,
0.5951187610626221,
0.06112494692206383,
0.12628880143165588,
-0.1791164129972458,
0.36131569743156433,
-0.4613420069217682,
-0.10289493203163147,
-0.17803354561328888,
-0.23730117082595825,
-0.10253257304430008,
0.3459017872810364,
-0.015560487285256386,
0.8270961046218872,
0.6129088997840881,
-0.7321721315383911,
0.4742646813392639,
0.005404108669608831,
-0.37666866183280945,
0.4451475441455841,
-0.5271056890487671,
-0.2726258635520935,
-0.36033889651298523,
0.03005939908325672,
-0.9051608443260193,
-0.5022274255752563,
-0.17472495138645172,
-0.27329233288764954,
0.30717551708221436,
-0.18388701975345612,
-0.505444347858429,
-0.43782076239585876,
-0.15939383208751678,
0.7177575826644897,
0.425472617149353,
-0.5848784446716309,
0.4941677451133728,
0.5610329508781433,
-0.2989559769630432,
-0.5473706126213074,
-0.615278422832489,
0.06341762095689774,
-0.6011416912078857,
-0.6454554200172424,
-0.03306997939944267,
0.06712617725133896,
-0.6475261449813843,
-0.07726344466209412,
-0.012064375914633274,
-0.3083330988883972,
-0.043407611548900604,
0.07040811330080032,
0.27453359961509705,
-0.5281091332435608,
0.02736029215157032,
-0.20259200036525726,
0.2513062655925751,
0.05924701690673828,
-0.47693073749542236,
0.18380507826805115,
-0.8620432019233704,
-0.2546910345554352,
-0.031319256871938705,
0.2457907646894455,
0.7766015529632568,
-0.4517030715942383,
0.9700925350189209,
0.5713062286376953,
-0.1072482168674469,
-0.0487334281206131,
-0.6396002173423767,
-0.1558038592338562,
-0.4206807017326355,
0.5907480716705322,
-0.44873538613319397,
-1.3695429563522339,
0.7253189086914062,
0.14105384051799774,
-0.08765749633312225,
0.3759162425994873,
0.9650461077690125,
0.344583123922348,
1.0253287553787231,
0.6449030041694641,
0.14108383655548096,
0.43478259444236755,
-0.24721759557724,
0.34664279222488403,
-0.7473838329315186,
-0.03138305991888046,
-0.4651401937007904,
-0.12333613634109497,
-1.1758698225021362,
-0.509865403175354,
0.14990729093551636,
-0.36186257004737854,
-0.2563539147377014,
0.20662270486354828,
-0.3024744689464569,
0.5109965205192566,
0.19809339940547943,
-0.3111189901828766,
0.11569494754076004,
-0.002304342109709978,
0.0149917583912611,
-0.3380560576915741,
-0.5845917463302612,
-0.16048793494701385,
0.9138708710670471,
0.5148899555206299,
0.7107884287834167,
0.38281872868537903,
0.32401010394096375,
-0.2256327122449875,
0.14578236639499664,
-0.9782783389091492,
0.48648929595947266,
-0.1808074563741684,
-0.7917966246604919,
-0.1292121708393097,
-0.6913824677467346,
-0.8982506394386292,
0.70250004529953,
-0.15644779801368713,
-0.41922011971473694,
0.5876560211181641,
-0.14833185076713562,
-0.01921948418021202,
0.14174751937389374,
-0.6302160024642944,
0.8806540966033936,
-0.209835946559906,
-0.3202551007270813,
-0.12257777154445648,
-0.5075653195381165,
0.5961562395095825,
-0.37258338928222656,
0.5118181705474854,
0.0303081963211298,
-0.16915979981422424,
0.3940828740596771,
-0.5767822265625,
0.5447425842285156,
0.16968706250190735,
-0.25336959958076477,
0.22352364659309387,
0.049506817013025284,
0.4822361171245575,
-0.18710455298423767,
-0.007923177443444729,
0.1118040382862091,
-0.2533402144908905,
-0.3759855329990387,
-0.5021505355834961,
0.7684367299079895,
-0.7990925312042236,
-0.4057597517967224,
-0.4546974301338196,
-0.8518993258476257,
-0.21518947184085846,
0.004188476130366325,
0.4684903025627136,
0.45695120096206665,
-0.12729357182979584,
0.44997870922088623,
0.6556495428085327,
-0.1390644758939743,
0.04869822785258293,
0.599073588848114,
-0.2078760713338852,
-0.07817403972148895,
1.1018378734588623,
0.25223907828330994,
0.40744513273239136,
0.4980747401714325,
0.3597606122493744,
-0.1937907338142395,
-0.38463279604911804,
0.08605105429887772,
0.3947520852088928,
-0.6209691166877747,
0.1606328934431076,
-0.5789037346839905,
0.0027490772772580385,
-0.3919159471988678,
0.014941222965717316,
-0.07053696364164352,
-0.6416182518005371,
0.03936806321144104,
-0.17857474088668823,
0.6488589644432068,
0.7609630227088928,
0.050861284136772156,
0.24320060014724731,
-0.5057805180549622,
0.2945902943611145,
0.5933458805084229,
0.28237786889076233,
-0.19389168918132782,
-1.020742654800415,
-0.23003457486629486,
0.027833472937345505,
-0.017545480281114578,
-0.8981163501739502,
0.6014574766159058,
0.44672369956970215,
0.5502304434776306,
0.5470238924026489,
-0.29460203647613525,
0.45581379532814026,
-0.33583328127861023,
0.8552538156509399,
0.04197177663445473,
-0.7061513066291809,
0.16340886056423187,
-0.8683474659919739,
0.34261637926101685,
0.2515103816986084,
0.45060959458351135,
-0.38107264041900635,
-0.8692414164543152,
-0.5093163847923279,
-1.0324779748916626,
0.43618229031562805,
0.15347015857696533,
0.15762324631214142,
-0.19407235085964203,
0.27809640765190125,
0.1199827715754509,
0.21953724324703217,
-0.9170572757720947,
-0.05515138432383537,
-0.5694965720176697,
0.044592730700969696,
-0.10440988838672638,
-0.5120968818664551,
-0.11195793002843857,
-0.17488457262516022,
0.3653024435043335,
0.04888608306646347,
0.025197049602866173,
-0.26517125964164734,
-0.12712927162647247,
0.10258077085018158,
0.5633367896080017,
0.5434697866439819,
0.5076872706413269,
0.13036829233169556,
0.35222071409225464,
0.22074496746063232,
-0.6634834408760071,
0.03409251198172569,
0.03209768980741501,
-0.002628439338877797,
-0.07977691292762756,
0.35171133279800415,
1.1200289726257324,
0.5068029761314392,
-0.5390003323554993,
0.6109344363212585,
-0.141832634806633,
-0.18370623886585236,
-0.07014942169189453,
-0.04623622074723244,
0.08645455539226532,
0.014106596820056438,
0.17511922121047974,
-0.17923027276992798,
0.28075674176216125,
-0.5964950323104858,
0.14745019376277924,
0.6573776602745056,
-0.04891033470630646,
-0.3852563202381134,
0.4069758951663971,
-0.06802131235599518,
0.09819997102022171,
0.3892345726490021,
-0.5525277256965637,
-0.7361156344413757,
0.6138119697570801,
0.5898306965827942,
0.8641345500946045,
-0.2010868489742279,
-0.0721590667963028,
0.3391124904155731,
0.3370283246040344,
-0.006976550444960594,
0.014300903305411339,
-0.03945523872971535,
-0.7978430986404419,
-0.5275759696960449,
-0.9003347754478455,
-0.42189821600914,
0.251322478055954,
-0.6296347379684448,
0.14913120865821838,
-0.33601248264312744,
-0.2344275563955307,
0.07868161797523499,
-0.35031402111053467,
-0.5567182302474976,
0.21738091111183167,
0.0719783678650856,
0.4256635904312134,
-0.8444751501083374,
0.48603594303131104,
0.9981379508972168,
-0.6550235748291016,
-1.1678177118301392,
0.19616146385669708,
0.10288921743631363,
-0.6448637247085571,
1.13943612575531,
-0.036215223371982574,
-0.12003150582313538,
-0.07351555675268173,
-0.38370949029922485,
-0.9778673648834229,
0.5292938351631165,
0.028344376012682915,
-0.30124780535697937,
-0.13250818848609924,
0.21921862661838531,
0.7798494696617126,
-0.3596731722354889,
0.4110943675041199,
0.667310893535614,
0.46101319789886475,
0.3918987512588501,
-0.9406230449676514,
-0.1345866471529007,
-0.28419458866119385,
0.16941452026367188,
0.4639686346054077,
-0.3678995370864868,
1.2318192720413208,
-0.21456588804721832,
-0.034449707716703415,
0.006913330405950546,
0.7880387902259827,
0.0397673025727272,
-0.0889187604188919,
0.23257024586200714,
0.6800668239593506,
0.5434873104095459,
-0.09695371240377426,
1.2505288124084473,
-0.37497803568840027,
0.5278880596160889,
0.7150194644927979,
-0.13480648398399353,
0.5243326425552368,
0.171755850315094,
-0.2513381540775299,
0.5582870244979858,
0.5226388573646545,
-0.25159144401550293,
0.2215692549943924,
0.1372591108083725,
-0.763558030128479,
-0.11016704887151718,
-0.06040569394826889,
-0.3004745841026306,
0.751396894454956,
0.8122692108154297,
-0.1670452207326889,
-0.36014965176582336,
0.1329905092716217,
0.1365760862827301,
-0.32830309867858887,
-0.5217453241348267,
0.8535444140434265,
-0.008807546459138393,
-0.8232595324516296,
0.7692813873291016,
-0.10355124622583389,
0.7219176292419434,
-0.6409007906913757,
0.22704827785491943,
-0.266868531703949,
0.30903762578964233,
-0.19775386154651642,
-0.8184570670127869,
0.21500898897647858,
0.13549868762493134,
-0.09875879436731339,
0.07411850243806839,
0.6485351324081421,
-0.4398908317089081,
-0.4514918923377991,
0.089298777282238,
0.31518763303756714,
0.21560584008693695,
0.13101407885551453,
-0.5176844596862793,
-0.37617507576942444,
-0.19609694182872772,
-0.28651323914527893,
0.5474019646644592,
1.0131803750991821,
-0.12654434144496918,
0.6848055720329285,
0.4849071502685547,
0.44440969824790955,
0.31431713700294495,
0.12183765321969986,
0.766128659248352,
-0.5024035573005676,
-0.5182516574859619,
-0.7915822267532349,
0.28188690543174744,
0.22450287640094757,
-0.3078101873397827,
1.0799845457077026,
0.4251425564289093,
0.5501839518547058,
-0.03158111125230789,
0.6907227635383606,
0.13164442777633667,
0.4372785985469818,
-0.07306935638189316,
0.4893137812614441,
-0.5832705497741699,
0.16942669451236725,
-0.39785993099212646,
-0.8233126997947693,
-0.21460267901420593,
0.7875514030456543,
-0.6436634659767151,
0.26406028866767883,
0.6839982867240906,
0.8444589972496033,
-0.08866266161203384,
0.1769593060016632,
0.26962876319885254,
0.5004665851593018,
0.19971509277820587,
0.34658101201057434,
1.1071454286575317,
0.06304590404033661,
0.39195379614830017,
0.16725245118141174,
-0.47561267018318176,
-0.36436501145362854,
-0.765759289264679,
-0.513964831829071,
-0.5401828289031982,
-0.1663539707660675,
-0.3153078258037567,
-0.10715634375810623,
0.5033764243125916,
0.48753178119659424,
-0.6529535055160522,
-0.21562229096889496,
-0.3396342098712921,
0.06378193199634552,
-0.06742788106203079,
-0.26733773946762085,
-0.15234433114528656,
-0.39612334966659546,
-0.6280182600021362,
0.04234886169433594,
0.24598656594753265,
0.019969400018453598,
-0.21389561891555786,
0.07641251385211945,
0.016372747719287872,
0.3134147524833679,
0.6397652626037598,
0.400164932012558,
-0.7361009120941162,
-0.3712795674800873,
-0.1420222967863083,
-0.16689659655094147,
-0.15934887528419495,
0.7652421593666077,
-0.6511896252632141,
0.4729766249656677,
0.749120831489563,
0.6182101964950562,
0.3005150854587555,
-0.11462826281785965,
0.5388209223747253,
-0.611236035823822,
0.24270738661289215,
0.4186936616897583,
0.5373603105545044,
0.3826793432235718,
-0.21986868977546692,
0.210379958152771,
0.43932533264160156,
-0.8833450078964233,
-0.7676414251327515,
0.697803795337677,
-0.6588541865348816,
-0.2881361246109009,
1.4697684049606323,
-0.052674103528261185,
0.04266107454895973,
-0.13285495340824127,
0.04605647921562195,
-0.043776530772447586,
-0.15350086987018585,
0.4733991324901581,
0.8874732851982117,
-0.06618020683526993,
-0.18885067105293274,
-0.5827570557594299,
0.4965228736400604,
0.47038114070892334,
-0.6529120206832886,
0.14336955547332764,
0.7651563882827759,
0.3395783305168152,
0.1447795033454895,
0.16746343672275543,
-0.17345944046974182,
0.410034716129303,
0.17351026833057404,
-0.21257904171943665,
0.3307286500930786,
-0.044038183987140656,
-0.523804247379303,
0.2517312169075012,
0.24606062471866608,
0.18640364706516266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04293v1
|
Reason from Fallacy: Enhancing Large Language Models' Logical Reasoning through Logical Fallacy Understanding
| 2024-04-04T08:38:03 | 2024-04-04T08:38:03 |
Yanda Li, Dixuan Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Guochao Jiang, Qianyu He, Yanghua Xiao, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated good performance in many
reasoning tasks, but they still struggle with some complicated reasoning tasks
including logical reasoning. One non-negligible reason for LLMs' suboptimal
performance on logical reasoning is their overlooking of understanding logical
fallacies correctly. To evaluate LLMs' capability of logical fallacy
understanding (LFU), we propose five concrete tasks from three cognitive
dimensions of WHAT, WHY, and HOW in this paper. Towards these LFU tasks, we
have successfully constructed a new dataset LFUD based on GPT-4 accompanied by
a little human effort. Our extensive experiments justify that our LFUD can be
used not only to evaluate LLMs' LFU capability, but also to fine-tune LLMs to
obtain significantly enhanced performance on logical reasoning.
|
[
-0.370844304561615,
-0.8272199034690857,
0.9174636602401733,
0.07998906821012497,
-0.2855871021747589,
-0.04653097316622734,
-0.05805191397666931,
-0.26899954676628113,
-0.268440306186676,
0.749600887298584,
-0.6648939251899719,
-0.41245630383491516,
-0.6311859488487244,
0.16938996315002441,
-0.2960701882839203,
1.035651445388794,
-0.051303520798683167,
0.02738170698285103,
-0.48125210404396057,
-0.11517606675624847,
-0.4889487028121948,
-0.5696007013320923,
-0.4391401410102844,
-0.8314839005470276,
0.22307203710079193,
0.5207532644271851,
0.7019441723823547,
0.2862637937068939,
0.6572690010070801,
0.3677101135253906,
0.0642445832490921,
0.31290873885154724,
-0.7960461974143982,
-0.46088841557502747,
-0.3186505138874054,
-0.7471016049385071,
-0.37507227063179016,
0.037150558084249496,
0.3776744306087494,
0.6432467699050903,
-0.28236255049705505,
0.05354653671383858,
-0.2268785834312439,
0.7879689335823059,
-0.3916313052177429,
0.3557624816894531,
-0.6092347502708435,
0.11166410893201828,
0.015293988399207592,
0.06702214479446411,
-0.47248366475105286,
-0.44861966371536255,
0.04413305222988129,
-0.613423228263855,
0.3164839744567871,
-0.06757264584302902,
0.5685232281684875,
0.5505646467208862,
-0.4936144948005676,
-0.1146242693066597,
-0.5915675163269043,
0.9307489991188049,
-0.9421688318252563,
0.5771134495735168,
0.19809922575950623,
0.15058454871177673,
-0.2895931005477905,
-0.4677990674972534,
-0.6931363940238953,
-0.23387973010540009,
-0.12757231295108795,
-0.06386997550725937,
0.05590708926320076,
0.07776393741369247,
0.6780754327774048,
0.37603917717933655,
-0.33779123425483704,
-0.10293997824192047,
-0.15460877120494843,
-0.20471696555614471,
0.603006899356842,
0.17436246573925018,
0.24139893054962158,
-0.05681702867150307,
-0.3035750091075897,
0.2881002426147461,
-0.7819718718528748,
-0.11415428668260574,
0.20773722231388092,
0.04164811223745346,
0.004112296737730503,
0.40380585193634033,
-0.04369857907295227,
0.8198050856590271,
-0.02443184331059456,
-0.46365728974342346,
0.24210388958454132,
-0.4397740960121155,
-0.48364076018333435,
-0.17737817764282227,
0.41231366991996765,
0.3760167360305786,
0.5593633651733398,
-0.020985746756196022,
-0.2632187008857727,
0.2654156982898712,
0.10851960629224777,
-0.627459704875946,
-0.23436804115772247,
0.02412906102836132,
-0.5436683893203735,
-0.3501935601234436,
-0.239532932639122,
-0.3200858235359192,
-0.6004396080970764,
-0.6261388659477234,
0.310215562582016,
-0.7250643968582153,
-0.34049007296562195,
0.49022412300109863,
-0.1270224153995514,
0.0969170480966568,
0.7350719571113586,
-0.7480066418647766,
0.39200812578201294,
0.7868961095809937,
0.40793904662132263,
-0.34266239404678345,
-0.33123210072517395,
-0.5231308937072754,
0.1121668592095375,
-0.3813610076904297,
0.7786803841590881,
-0.4682576060295105,
-0.12688982486724854,
-0.2633097767829895,
-0.03202572464942932,
-0.15439800918102264,
-0.6731299161911011,
0.9246364235877991,
-0.3783285617828369,
0.23918887972831726,
-0.722072422504425,
-0.6151828169822693,
-0.6528729200363159,
0.37540873885154724,
-0.6989288330078125,
0.6907444596290588,
0.12497356534004211,
-0.7495526671409607,
0.4503590166568756,
-0.924328625202179,
-0.5706090331077576,
0.1027500107884407,
-0.35136350989341736,
-0.03881305083632469,
0.39303892850875854,
0.5155754685401917,
0.37366536259651184,
-0.49094346165657043,
0.2281002551317215,
-0.19443634152412415,
-0.311741441488266,
0.2787286639213562,
-0.5207738280296326,
0.8030995726585388,
0.10493729263544083,
-0.28663310408592224,
-0.027101926505565643,
-0.6146775484085083,
-0.0791468620300293,
0.16642847657203674,
-0.5415943264961243,
-0.2982165217399597,
0.4230941832065582,
-0.3032509386539459,
0.18328484892845154,
0.26275908946990967,
-0.3068711459636688,
-0.04162284731864929,
-0.6168696284294128,
0.5619238018989563,
0.717062771320343,
-0.06003165245056152,
0.05930258333683014,
-0.26627081632614136,
0.3640638291835785,
0.2795579135417938,
0.10633981972932816,
0.2872108519077301,
-0.37675684690475464,
-0.7974866628646851,
-0.21158111095428467,
-0.031556013971567154,
0.6004399061203003,
-0.907886266708374,
0.19454193115234375,
-0.2817783057689667,
-0.14965187013149261,
-0.2398572564125061,
0.5649545788764954,
0.2316783368587494,
0.8985099792480469,
0.36231595277786255,
0.08239144086837769,
-0.20364835858345032,
-1.0297622680664062,
-0.33316630125045776,
-0.30578356981277466,
0.05243370309472084,
0.1359570473432541,
0.8200207352638245,
-0.16162966191768646,
0.8481860160827637,
-0.5145219564437866,
-0.14951910078525543,
-0.7000759840011597,
-0.059192441403865814,
0.6308276653289795,
0.12429533898830414,
0.6112861633300781,
-0.7843492031097412,
0.13554811477661133,
-0.050858352333307266,
-0.9141601324081421,
-0.2552723288536072,
-0.028787819668650627,
0.038432687520980835,
0.30592992901802063,
0.33772513270378113,
-0.8459801077842712,
0.23957990109920502,
0.19007419049739838,
-0.4432086646556854,
0.6479602456092834,
-0.06386364251375198,
0.10848336666822433,
-0.7158463597297668,
-0.30298325419425964,
0.22559627890586853,
-0.38267213106155396,
-0.5172382593154907,
0.27997565269470215,
-0.05705556273460388,
0.17762936651706696,
-0.5111879706382751,
0.09602544456720352,
-0.3292844593524933,
-0.044189680367708206,
-0.032460927963256836,
0.43618839979171753,
0.07105626910924911,
0.20027726888656616,
-0.012654908001422882,
0.3834218978881836,
0.1786607801914215,
-0.439716100692749,
0.7403796911239624,
0.032590217888355255,
-0.42940661311149597,
0.7395390868186951,
-0.5404437780380249,
-0.0033402242697775364,
-0.26738283038139343,
0.3029033839702606,
-0.6916322708129883,
-0.17732663452625275,
0.11230878531932831,
-0.26365527510643005,
-0.05215684324502945,
-0.003381018992513418,
-0.5887797474861145,
-0.3845197856426239,
-0.18366706371307373,
0.2881389260292053,
0.35350480675697327,
-0.6701576113700867,
0.6778524518013,
0.28442826867103577,
0.29055047035217285,
-0.6337603330612183,
-0.8275635838508606,
-0.06363467872142792,
-0.49585214257240295,
-0.7577487230300903,
-0.09280654788017273,
-0.1405826061964035,
-0.4782930314540863,
-0.24021513760089874,
-0.20097827911376953,
0.25577312707901,
-0.01385669969022274,
-0.06173263490200043,
0.11816878616809845,
-0.2783367931842804,
0.16659444570541382,
-0.3238559663295746,
0.04588180407881737,
0.42392557859420776,
-0.18111902475357056,
0.25081878900527954,
-0.29384270310401917,
-0.5391648411750793,
-0.46861788630485535,
0.05271335318684578,
0.5458308458328247,
0.007652657106518745,
0.4347432553768158,
0.2547430098056793,
-0.5782201290130615,
-0.36255335807800293,
-0.6534017324447632,
-0.22828075289726257,
-0.4354953467845917,
0.4670206904411316,
-0.4359201490879059,
-0.7393268346786499,
0.3258249759674072,
-0.029825378209352493,
0.1376783698797226,
0.4182238280773163,
0.666098415851593,
-0.09695940464735031,
0.8887911438941956,
0.3646923899650574,
-0.25069892406463623,
-0.017888283357024193,
-0.117959164083004,
0.2740105986595154,
-0.386082261800766,
-0.2033345252275467,
-0.37966910004615784,
-0.1935851126909256,
-0.31804972887039185,
-0.7090176939964294,
0.1436951458454132,
0.0429464690387249,
-0.25230154395103455,
-0.09022948890924454,
-0.2550581991672516,
0.6479063034057617,
0.14482946693897247,
0.07655464857816696,
0.5021230578422546,
0.13290801644325256,
-0.16956587135791779,
-0.24235008656978607,
-0.5570200681686401,
-0.48059311509132385,
0.8313652276992798,
0.6521458029747009,
0.9328230023384094,
0.4094141721725464,
0.4839687645435333,
0.3411787152290344,
0.2803058922290802,
-0.9075351357460022,
0.8630245327949524,
-0.24197885394096375,
-0.6935840845108032,
-0.29043343663215637,
-0.7005293369293213,
-0.3742506504058838,
0.4055245816707611,
0.007639834191650152,
-0.695185661315918,
-0.20316095650196075,
0.3231890797615051,
-0.023381857201457024,
0.0515563078224659,
-0.8205744028091431,
0.8817291259765625,
-0.30921876430511475,
-0.032713957130908966,
-0.4948403239250183,
-0.2901420593261719,
0.8615976572036743,
-0.10124192386865616,
0.5062171220779419,
-0.07815179228782654,
-0.06381744891405106,
0.8003902435302734,
-0.7071051597595215,
0.8091006278991699,
-0.27196547389030457,
-0.5008041262626648,
0.17960326373577118,
0.012156248092651367,
0.5285916328430176,
0.21569979190826416,
-0.22552542388439178,
0.07500588893890381,
-0.0013669560430571437,
-0.3174822926521301,
-0.8350778818130493,
0.8123596906661987,
-0.6370026469230652,
-0.8816994428634644,
-0.40079182386398315,
-0.582817554473877,
-0.3327290415763855,
0.13068269193172455,
-0.004857511725276709,
0.25106650590896606,
-0.13609547913074493,
0.12847790122032166,
0.6792311072349548,
-0.015966078266501427,
0.4066520035266876,
0.34736165404319763,
-0.28617188334465027,
-0.23852254450321198,
0.7802882790565491,
0.028270330280065536,
0.2685278356075287,
0.4425927996635437,
0.28429386019706726,
-0.5661205649375916,
-0.7057368159294128,
-0.3283536434173584,
0.4126184284687042,
-1.2137749195098877,
-0.04353708401322365,
-0.2110101282596588,
-0.13751710951328278,
-0.23464351892471313,
0.055325862020254135,
-0.0674789547920227,
-0.30147311091423035,
-0.11846595257520676,
-0.32834216952323914,
0.3081737458705902,
0.7223207950592041,
0.04364383593201637,
0.25136977434158325,
-0.694675624370575,
0.6352187991142273,
0.3589020073413849,
0.03265274688601494,
-0.19543516635894775,
-0.6070870757102966,
0.07280895859003067,
-0.08841349929571152,
-0.3413730263710022,
-0.8720682263374329,
0.03110445663332939,
0.05275866761803627,
0.8434723615646362,
0.663020133972168,
0.005748235620558262,
0.5556349158287048,
-0.37022730708122253,
0.6448665261268616,
0.17366155982017517,
-1.1343141794204712,
0.6687341928482056,
-0.2556726336479187,
0.1856975108385086,
0.2821314334869385,
0.32553741335868835,
-0.10184386372566223,
-0.07709502428770065,
-0.526867151260376,
-0.38025131821632385,
0.7756146788597107,
0.3220202922821045,
-0.12835896015167236,
0.13452179729938507,
0.39332571625709534,
0.12440069764852524,
0.13063299655914307,
-0.9533571004867554,
0.023372989147901535,
-0.13544631004333496,
-0.24850961565971375,
-0.2717251181602478,
-0.10602810978889465,
-0.35442572832107544,
-0.3705827593803406,
0.5916683077812195,
-0.33985939621925354,
-0.025012029334902763,
0.0681089535355568,
-0.34053835272789,
-0.08247658610343933,
0.13917498290538788,
0.6847284436225891,
1.0425686836242676,
-0.08957523852586746,
0.22795256972312927,
0.5956968069076538,
-0.4047691524028778,
0.1550404578447342,
0.10981263965368271,
-0.14821210503578186,
-0.3122391998767853,
0.80380779504776,
0.7584846615791321,
-0.0796658918261528,
-0.5930704474449158,
0.3883018493652344,
-0.009620169177651405,
-0.3818184733390808,
-0.30510804057121277,
0.3543430268764496,
0.5010080933570862,
0.18091462552547455,
0.19467927515506744,
-0.10034193098545074,
0.011523733846843243,
-0.5907899737358093,
0.04362654313445091,
0.4484797716140747,
-0.01240046601742506,
-0.15384164452552795,
0.42734411358833313,
0.22782441973686218,
-0.1600659340620041,
0.6272892951965332,
0.04442045837640762,
-0.5907999277114868,
0.48833829164505005,
0.6151264309883118,
0.31378212571144104,
-0.17140191793441772,
0.2632351517677307,
0.05966931954026222,
0.7263100743293762,
-0.13561461865901947,
0.5713030099868774,
0.15641558170318604,
-1.1127926111221313,
-0.8159627318382263,
-0.671556830406189,
-0.2642711400985718,
0.6047130823135376,
-0.18368501961231232,
0.4177767336368561,
-0.6023082137107849,
0.12992091476917267,
-0.000011458345397841185,
-0.002357272896915674,
-0.5334409475326538,
0.5194064378738403,
0.12801562249660492,
1.050713062286377,
-0.8884528875350952,
0.5791630744934082,
0.683479905128479,
-0.30838409066200256,
-0.5488126873970032,
0.110580213367939,
0.10271335393190384,
-0.7944641709327698,
0.7578492164611816,
0.14559942483901978,
-0.41385123133659363,
-0.13297374546527863,
-0.5607258677482605,
-0.5760970711708069,
0.6639853119850159,
0.8153190612792969,
-0.6265988945960999,
-0.02956341579556465,
0.3675730228424072,
0.3685121238231659,
-0.49683886766433716,
0.1317325383424759,
1.0353962182998657,
0.6344946026802063,
0.15914669632911682,
-0.540981650352478,
0.4806663393974304,
0.11282454431056976,
-0.11404122412204742,
0.1694868952035904,
-0.5611456036567688,
0.5986835360527039,
-0.4866083860397339,
0.1651659905910492,
-0.4342449903488159,
0.5866460204124451,
0.6610916256904602,
0.2798771560192108,
0.9184728860855103,
0.8857825994491577,
0.7193040251731873,
-0.14429844915866852,
0.8066154718399048,
0.23078440129756927,
0.30306491255760193,
0.8925209641456604,
-0.3573984205722809,
0.7159401178359985,
0.4601794183254242,
-0.3167610466480255,
0.3868404030799866,
0.7132127285003662,
0.11275044828653336,
0.31091591715812683,
0.35045483708381653,
-0.29860129952430725,
-0.799827516078949,
0.2800178825855255,
-0.27171847224235535,
0.503258466720581,
0.7437229752540588,
-0.3025573790073395,
-0.3151226341724396,
-0.17307916283607483,
0.044188033789396286,
0.11452736705541611,
-0.23476578295230865,
0.3944128751754761,
0.1989029347896576,
-0.5797988176345825,
0.7567844390869141,
0.04046393930912018,
0.3386203646659851,
-0.22258515655994415,
-0.1803014576435089,
-0.24225392937660217,
0.3045792579650879,
-0.48676520586013794,
-0.6601362824440002,
0.1999543458223343,
-0.049683477729558945,
-0.1348336637020111,
0.038909558206796646,
0.7056826949119568,
0.1482548713684082,
-0.7656574845314026,
0.4172491729259491,
0.5357446074485779,
0.39391887187957764,
0.11842166632413864,
-0.8498136401176453,
0.09836138784885406,
0.22952985763549805,
-0.2562698721885681,
0.10083876550197601,
0.7189854383468628,
-0.20713049173355103,
0.6743884086608887,
0.740975558757782,
0.16740255057811737,
-0.38651537895202637,
0.4477269649505615,
0.724048376083374,
-0.8841166496276855,
-0.3938761055469513,
-1.1736980676651,
0.16934680938720703,
-0.17259392142295837,
-0.07304029166698456,
0.3823525905609131,
0.36710217595100403,
0.6794738173484802,
-0.18183189630508423,
1.0702006816864014,
-0.040836136788129807,
0.5267783999443054,
-0.8438988327980042,
0.620820939540863,
-0.6980835199356079,
0.42301133275032043,
-0.24543583393096924,
-0.9493008255958557,
-0.18363353610038757,
0.8067978024482727,
-0.5272194743156433,
0.18779878318309784,
0.9255055785179138,
0.6481724977493286,
-0.2465851753950119,
0.2806883156299591,
0.5805097222328186,
0.5568676590919495,
0.46248170733451843,
0.9003724455833435,
0.9455631375312805,
-0.13106708228588104,
0.5999575853347778,
0.015615922398865223,
-0.3279644250869751,
-0.1680542230606079,
-1.2831172943115234,
-1.0747041702270508,
-0.21495147049427032,
-0.36087822914123535,
-0.17287026345729828,
-0.17940697073936462,
0.7487758994102478,
0.5619997382164001,
-0.7507621049880981,
-0.1096884086728096,
-0.33233320713043213,
0.48553067445755005,
-0.044007305055856705,
-0.24159929156303406,
0.10357848554849625,
-0.30842527747154236,
-0.6507976651191711,
0.635358989238739,
0.11263477057218552,
-0.2496669739484787,
-0.2855251729488373,
-0.13275925815105438,
-0.15890631079673767,
0.22947047650814056,
0.704446017742157,
-0.09167014807462692,
-0.9649338126182556,
-0.5177033543586731,
-0.4593208134174347,
0.31502389907836914,
-0.035034071654081345,
0.7386253476142883,
-0.7238659262657166,
-0.08044137805700302,
0.7409693002700806,
0.5781213641166687,
0.25415533781051636,
0.1119304746389389,
0.661382257938385,
-0.34243133664131165,
-0.027340251952409744,
0.04403165727853775,
0.5331215262413025,
0.5320064425468445,
-0.3572961091995239,
0.5927619338035583,
0.597609281539917,
-0.5046083927154541,
-0.6955150365829468,
0.4390694499015808,
-0.6921215057373047,
-0.23149436712265015,
1.026021957397461,
-0.22518889605998993,
-0.10822557657957077,
-0.17142322659492493,
-0.20166119933128357,
-0.027790717780590057,
-0.2886422276496887,
0.6682690978050232,
1.0315613746643066,
-0.5647473335266113,
-0.3735341727733612,
-0.946388840675354,
0.5661908388137817,
0.5362259149551392,
-1.1529762744903564,
0.11094336956739426,
0.8278980255126953,
0.6533754467964172,
0.1251780390739441,
0.5945812463760376,
-0.08090279251337051,
0.2799595594406128,
-0.27933910489082336,
-0.32734376192092896,
0.08722005039453506,
-0.1834510862827301,
-0.1170116737484932,
0.2288205325603485,
0.1743987798690796,
-0.008099889382719994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03278v1
|
Evaluating Document Simplification: On the Importance of Separately Assessing Simplicity and Meaning Preservation
| 2024-04-04T08:04:24 | 2024-04-04T08:04:24 |
Liam Cripwell, Joël Legrand, Claire Gardent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text simplification intends to make a text easier to read while preserving
its core meaning. Intuitively and as shown in previous works, these two
dimensions (simplification and meaning preservation) are often-times inversely
correlated. An overly conservative text will fail to simplify sufficiently,
whereas extreme simplification will degrade meaning preservation. Yet, popular
evaluation metrics either aggregate meaning preservation and simplification
into a single score (SARI, LENS), or target meaning preservation alone
(BERTScore, QuestEval). Moreover, these metrics usually require a set of
references and most previous work has only focused on sentence-level
simplification. In this paper, we focus on the evaluation of document-level
text simplification and compare existing models using distinct metrics for
meaning preservation and simplification. We leverage existing metrics from
similar tasks and introduce a reference-less metric variant for simplicity,
showing that models are mostly biased towards either simplification or meaning
preservation, seldom performing well on both dimensions. Making use of the fact
that the metrics we use are all reference-less, we also investigate the
performance of existing models when applied to unseen data (where reference
simplifications are unavailable).
|
[
-0.08724379539489746,
-0.5331798195838928,
0.7345537543296814,
0.27096807956695557,
-0.7121532559394836,
-0.4970707595348358,
-0.1728014498949051,
-0.3290593922138214,
0.008678802289068699,
0.10611213743686676,
-0.6197191476821899,
-0.3844805061817169,
-0.7133606672286987,
0.22858856618404388,
-0.4182075262069702,
1.2801047563552856,
-0.11819884926080704,
0.24872583150863647,
-0.6685338616371155,
-0.4076635241508484,
-0.24061746895313263,
-0.15525126457214355,
-0.44766438007354736,
-0.49971652030944824,
0.380531370639801,
0.26899364590644836,
0.8486382961273193,
1.0461184978485107,
1.013189435005188,
0.20320507884025574,
-0.4997784495353699,
-0.0828276202082634,
-0.6412574052810669,
0.00446850573644042,
-0.05988384410738945,
-0.3413103222846985,
-0.5337799191474915,
0.22383248805999756,
0.6341661810874939,
1.176724910736084,
0.09613852202892303,
0.29567497968673706,
-0.03459617868065834,
0.7813853025436401,
-0.8541382551193237,
0.2352619767189026,
-0.4178297519683838,
-0.2879610061645508,
0.09006639569997787,
-0.14413976669311523,
-0.12675300240516663,
-0.5910865068435669,
0.06390959769487381,
-0.6896079778671265,
0.3173181712627411,
-0.04157670959830284,
0.9511703848838806,
0.41662609577178955,
-0.4291403591632843,
-0.5212861895561218,
-0.8543541431427002,
0.9634708166122437,
-0.36521756649017334,
0.13605915009975433,
0.1030571237206459,
-0.00680371792986989,
0.3312772214412689,
-0.7024657130241394,
-0.5642685294151306,
-0.10595648735761642,
-0.16452105343341827,
0.4371435046195984,
-0.38996705412864685,
0.02723814733326435,
0.4680522382259369,
0.5564279556274414,
-0.21414926648139954,
-0.18195708096027374,
-0.7124344110488892,
-0.1863655149936676,
0.6904715299606323,
0.19635622203350067,
0.12234514206647873,
-0.49956631660461426,
-0.6988584399223328,
-0.4108133316040039,
-0.49993303418159485,
0.029708947986364365,
0.23241937160491943,
0.14262978732585907,
0.15562216937541962,
0.5120888948440552,
-0.19179701805114746,
-0.05422278121113777,
-0.352873831987381,
-0.49107080698013306,
0.4076617360115051,
-0.8469812870025635,
-0.3406832218170166,
-0.38657328486442566,
0.6919493079185486,
0.5620201826095581,
0.15309351682662964,
-0.23739401996135712,
-0.15319891273975372,
0.10992781072854996,
0.2498902827501297,
-0.7375199794769287,
0.2008729875087738,
0.032700423151254654,
-0.8546372652053833,
-0.05816090106964111,
0.3651925027370453,
-0.374165803194046,
-0.280626505613327,
-0.3204944431781769,
0.47180259227752686,
-0.5901153683662415,
0.19798530638217926,
0.2546979486942291,
-0.7010226249694824,
0.12878012657165527,
0.9559242129325867,
-0.4001692235469818,
0.2869742810726166,
0.8763717412948608,
0.6177011728286743,
-0.1832083761692047,
-0.41844794154167175,
-0.02603273279964924,
0.06765073537826538,
-0.30046555399894714,
0.7197301387786865,
-0.39548978209495544,
-0.6823907494544983,
-0.3118019700050354,
-0.30341625213623047,
0.17076674103736877,
-0.44900280237197876,
1.609066367149353,
0.07797952741384506,
0.2447371929883957,
-0.47860825061798096,
-0.684391975402832,
-0.2428676337003708,
0.22584012150764465,
-0.8320339918136597,
1.0560669898986816,
-0.09780260920524597,
-0.8871585726737976,
0.5087442994117737,
-0.44428449869155884,
-0.2648145854473114,
-0.08921588957309723,
0.18835484981536865,
-0.645129382610321,
0.6504358649253845,
-0.06536341458559036,
0.05495893210172653,
-0.5737646222114563,
-0.15089690685272217,
-0.3093266189098358,
-0.49908241629600525,
-0.13710865378379822,
-0.7754465937614441,
0.5245890617370605,
0.23084230720996857,
-0.03913993760943413,
-0.259002685546875,
-0.6848694086074829,
0.08652789145708084,
-0.15090033411979675,
-0.44165927171707153,
-0.8409249186515808,
-0.007493162993341684,
0.12470336258411407,
0.25721681118011475,
0.6221119165420532,
-0.7114056944847107,
0.13095982372760773,
-0.1921720802783966,
-0.0395430289208889,
0.24104446172714233,
0.12360407412052155,
0.6021461486816406,
-0.46881529688835144,
0.5259392857551575,
0.17600345611572266,
0.4238080680370331,
-0.23733171820640564,
-0.18925081193447113,
-0.9174109101295471,
-0.3178267478942871,
0.5362475514411926,
0.3634234070777893,
-0.1321876496076584,
0.041458286345005035,
-0.8790985941886902,
-0.5967284440994263,
-0.7518459558486938,
0.33868592977523804,
0.4256722033023834,
0.1988268941640854,
0.33431991934776306,
-0.2637089490890503,
-0.21417303383350372,
-1.217072606086731,
-0.5921212434768677,
-0.15269747376441956,
-0.1688399314880371,
0.14814868569374084,
0.34361934661865234,
-0.1966876983642578,
0.7162480354309082,
-0.5364939570426941,
-0.3760293126106262,
-0.2530858814716339,
0.37671929597854614,
0.011867323890328407,
0.3483451306819916,
0.47484180331230164,
-0.8935382962226868,
-0.3328302800655365,
-0.2523807883262634,
-0.7798973321914673,
-0.26728254556655884,
-0.17684704065322876,
0.1765979379415512,
-0.21671517193317413,
0.5570105314254761,
-0.6732770800590515,
0.7406931519508362,
0.22236190736293793,
0.10279346257448196,
0.18100422620773315,
-0.3490625321865082,
0.24452702701091766,
-0.7622940540313721,
0.2593982219696045,
-0.1960056573152542,
-0.055534012615680695,
-0.8036382794380188,
0.21381904184818268,
0.36581477522850037,
-0.11603165417909622,
-0.31988993287086487,
0.6729505658149719,
-0.7254596948623657,
0.11760613322257996,
-0.2247413843870163,
0.49811843037605286,
0.48713070154190063,
0.038091614842414856,
-0.26546335220336914,
0.30245038866996765,
0.0224575474858284,
-0.2394503355026245,
-0.10865181684494019,
0.19139224290847778,
-0.126853346824646,
0.5651958584785461,
-0.539067804813385,
0.1668197512626648,
-0.4985122084617615,
0.18680095672607422,
-0.9411531686782837,
0.20065920054912567,
-0.15410111844539642,
-0.2246403843164444,
0.050691619515419006,
0.2948356568813324,
-0.5741831660270691,
-0.15312224626541138,
-0.9479816555976868,
0.4303945302963257,
0.305174320936203,
-0.16718462109565735,
0.6859323978424072,
-0.09763742238283157,
-0.18902024626731873,
-0.4555719792842865,
-0.7743663191795349,
-0.12803098559379578,
-0.33737194538116455,
-0.6193863749504089,
0.20066432654857635,
-0.3599494993686676,
-0.5047942996025085,
0.11723827570676804,
-0.6009790301322937,
0.011745976284146309,
0.18166498839855194,
0.4721664786338806,
0.054685935378074646,
0.017893677577376366,
0.5647472143173218,
0.38006895780563354,
-0.11566335707902908,
-0.1847105324268341,
0.16980230808258057,
-0.012553744949400425,
0.06936819851398468,
-0.3374514877796173,
-0.34248074889183044,
0.8360915780067444,
0.6212205290794373,
0.015771130099892616,
0.8075177073478699,
0.4127742648124695,
-0.3119986355304718,
-0.1710304319858551,
-0.6080803871154785,
0.19754797220230103,
-0.331614226102829,
0.03406815230846405,
-0.5142678618431091,
-0.3902599811553955,
0.37229958176612854,
-0.4459218382835388,
-0.02620161883533001,
0.7387250065803528,
0.16675272583961487,
-0.13254451751708984,
0.5658917427062988,
0.7658173441886902,
0.24559690058231354,
0.3041380047798157,
-0.15848006308078766,
0.38614267110824585,
-0.6375053524971008,
-0.33176523447036743,
-0.8300876617431641,
-0.07143600285053253,
-0.46406784653663635,
-0.27524739503860474,
0.4544861614704132,
0.5963553190231323,
0.3482179641723633,
0.18526455760002136,
-0.17520438134670258,
0.5704482793807983,
0.33281421661376953,
0.01143961027264595,
0.5621886253356934,
0.020941969007253647,
0.141957625746727,
-0.1458570659160614,
-0.37944480776786804,
-0.973438560962677,
1.1407893896102905,
0.3560061752796173,
0.7918663620948792,
0.02725054882466793,
0.9766750335693359,
0.04273911938071251,
0.38560324907302856,
-1.0245752334594727,
0.5224047899246216,
-0.537237286567688,
-0.2563774585723877,
-0.2264663577079773,
-0.5713428258895874,
-0.864483654499054,
0.27518391609191895,
-0.25949162244796753,
-0.3797101080417633,
0.1248970627784729,
-0.04291534423828125,
-0.178487628698349,
-0.2081327885389328,
-0.9379799962043762,
0.6353288292884827,
0.05838058888912201,
-0.09969671815633774,
-0.24589775502681732,
-0.3027127683162689,
0.23706737160682678,
-0.3645251989364624,
0.36967599391937256,
-0.0782853439450264,
-0.3652995228767395,
0.4805092215538025,
-0.4508918821811676,
0.3256719708442688,
0.19106484949588776,
0.09051530063152313,
-0.012306340038776398,
0.04299413412809372,
0.36571916937828064,
-0.1771443784236908,
-0.4699835777282715,
-0.018345866352319717,
0.19136296212673187,
-0.36551761627197266,
-1.0640043020248413,
0.589461624622345,
-0.6874211430549622,
-0.8584272861480713,
-0.12610530853271484,
-0.6926016211509705,
0.19401483237743378,
0.5488537549972534,
0.07670632004737854,
0.26727283000946045,
-0.6748936772346497,
0.5612135529518127,
0.505435049533844,
0.09634903818368912,
0.4931653141975403,
0.2596193552017212,
0.18350037932395935,
-0.22149458527565002,
0.35889992117881775,
0.17390915751457214,
0.4641108810901642,
0.5257053375244141,
0.47309163212776184,
-0.31916502118110657,
-0.5952840447425842,
0.0693506971001625,
0.21311123669147491,
-1.112099289894104,
-0.14569342136383057,
-0.7352105975151062,
0.026763707399368286,
-0.2925528883934021,
-0.05720170587301254,
0.03328089043498039,
-0.9986822605133057,
-0.18606415390968323,
-0.09998952597379684,
-0.09707344323396683,
0.8234331607818604,
-0.10829991102218628,
0.14560651779174805,
-0.4974081814289093,
0.3908471465110779,
0.19077818095684052,
0.05895929038524628,
-0.08830886334180832,
-0.26126134395599365,
0.0041574034839868546,
-0.005610666237771511,
-0.24441947042942047,
-0.8071097731590271,
0.052159953862428665,
0.37816160917282104,
0.6591490507125854,
0.46510791778564453,
0.20419436693191528,
0.6234681606292725,
-0.3126111924648285,
0.5975069403648376,
0.21327389776706696,
-1.257082223892212,
0.625098705291748,
-0.12672364711761475,
0.6780970692634583,
1.0285917520523071,
0.41147086024284363,
-0.4300552010536194,
-0.27236783504486084,
-0.958053469657898,
-0.8575790524482727,
0.7539193034172058,
0.361472487449646,
0.3689095079898834,
0.20231035351753235,
0.5075812339782715,
0.15331007540225983,
0.4473881721496582,
-0.8041224479675293,
-0.37562766671180725,
-0.2413279116153717,
-0.3750206530094147,
-0.013993444852530956,
-0.37673819065093994,
-0.408957302570343,
-0.1030154898762703,
0.42149975895881653,
0.04650425538420677,
-0.014882574789226055,
0.10767747461795807,
-0.11507801711559296,
0.11980193108320236,
0.6417887806892395,
0.5518378615379333,
0.36514851450920105,
-0.14395153522491455,
0.20113222301006317,
0.3603741526603699,
-0.5155678987503052,
0.02244884893298149,
-0.026052866131067276,
-0.48017922043800354,
0.21329055726528168,
0.6023113131523132,
0.7774869799613953,
0.17314334213733673,
-0.35061803460121155,
0.8895664215087891,
-0.21129541099071503,
-0.16273310780525208,
0.07201872766017914,
-0.07914146780967712,
0.1632491648197174,
-0.25939464569091797,
0.2633592486381531,
0.3578541874885559,
0.3824094533920288,
-0.9112575650215149,
-0.18146587908267975,
0.35227063298225403,
-0.19595453143119812,
-0.06371257454156876,
0.17901557683944702,
-0.07099644094705582,
-0.19600990414619446,
0.24349528551101685,
-0.12080489844083786,
-0.24935850501060486,
0.44337478280067444,
0.12346291542053223,
1.0036439895629883,
-0.01006238628178835,
0.02183115854859352,
0.2338668704032898,
0.5831165313720703,
-0.1712200939655304,
0.13618338108062744,
-0.3920184373855591,
-0.3599000573158264,
0.3070511817932129,
-0.7530974745750427,
-0.3248012959957123,
-0.028424113988876343,
-0.8557937145233154,
0.3948657810688019,
-0.5146222114562988,
-0.1427324414253235,
0.4298032522201538,
0.19595538079738617,
-0.8341063857078552,
0.4014292061328888,
-0.1279427409172058,
1.2487000226974487,
-1.0541257858276367,
0.5422759056091309,
0.6642511487007141,
-0.6242330074310303,
-0.8771657347679138,
0.41554227471351624,
0.07318158447742462,
-0.23904794454574585,
0.6625850796699524,
0.14049743115901947,
-0.3640236556529999,
-0.38925835490226746,
-0.24970108270645142,
-0.7619478702545166,
1.2051293849945068,
0.5392833352088928,
-0.30285435914993286,
-0.13134223222732544,
0.21491451561450958,
1.0638357400894165,
-0.19733849167823792,
0.43683263659477234,
0.4050447940826416,
0.6726020574569702,
0.10070215910673141,
-0.8902106881141663,
0.08989781141281128,
-0.32504430413246155,
0.3304550349712372,
0.1332492083311081,
-0.6094831824302673,
0.7773651480674744,
0.08422601968050003,
-0.7940171957015991,
0.21874389052391052,
0.21455515921115875,
-0.24094997346401215,
0.334865003824234,
0.46075963973999023,
0.6917937994003296,
0.6429634690284729,
-0.32786184549331665,
1.2118290662765503,
0.006431634072214365,
0.4906373620033264,
0.885385274887085,
0.10498503595590591,
0.8351148962974548,
0.5633859038352966,
0.06668034940958023,
0.2787431478500366,
0.06570360064506531,
-0.03876132518053055,
0.48973459005355835,
0.14261452853679657,
-0.24495919048786163,
-0.23902055621147156,
-0.2868025302886963,
0.12272349745035172,
0.6337840557098389,
0.13110212981700897,
-0.4945012629032135,
-0.5928869843482971,
-0.17454233765602112,
0.1979009211063385,
0.3220825791358948,
-0.2488296627998352,
0.8748589158058167,
0.2700306475162506,
-0.7865695953369141,
0.28278201818466187,
0.14794784784317017,
0.21768563985824585,
-0.6339707970619202,
0.13357168436050415,
-0.4755330979824066,
0.38559862971305847,
-0.2892891764640808,
-0.477770060300827,
0.43461939692497253,
-0.03355861082673073,
-0.7051353454589844,
-0.3707917332649231,
0.5534904599189758,
-0.4649481773376465,
-0.5786896347999573,
0.5256264805793762,
0.5893875956535339,
0.15648846328258514,
0.3998171091079712,
-0.6770928502082825,
0.32107192277908325,
-0.06782382726669312,
-0.005310027860105038,
0.05582312494516373,
0.7022562026977539,
-0.11284670233726501,
0.63360196352005,
0.37030747532844543,
0.11227072030305862,
-0.11383688449859619,
0.3347882628440857,
0.8116400837898254,
-0.47621452808380127,
-0.24387888610363007,
-0.623657763004303,
0.331098735332489,
-0.2102268636226654,
-0.5448851585388184,
1.1073932647705078,
0.6841753125190735,
0.5749964118003845,
-0.06383170932531357,
0.6054347157478333,
0.34404370188713074,
0.35101717710494995,
-0.46539992094039917,
0.570204496383667,
-0.7745685577392578,
0.2675342261791229,
-0.7460026741027832,
-1.0296556949615479,
-0.4044858515262604,
0.15032367408275604,
-0.4280855357646942,
0.09554526954889297,
0.9997548460960388,
0.564555823802948,
-0.33558040857315063,
0.046060990542173386,
0.5148205161094666,
-0.03158194199204445,
-0.16096647083759308,
0.2756384611129761,
0.710020899772644,
-0.7882717251777649,
0.7143104076385498,
-0.1768254041671753,
-0.2375277876853943,
0.016442634165287018,
-0.992820143699646,
-0.6714557409286499,
-0.5334957838058472,
-0.5144535303115845,
0.0768069475889206,
0.03600682318210602,
0.3239797055721283,
0.42857101559638977,
-0.4872678518295288,
0.10120179504156113,
0.17930468916893005,
-0.015627481043338776,
-0.2469407021999359,
-0.16510219871997833,
0.4207848310470581,
-0.14074921607971191,
-0.8294051289558411,
0.260392963886261,
0.4676402509212494,
0.16279684007167816,
-0.23162634670734406,
0.19285167753696442,
0.10649632662534714,
0.6840205788612366,
0.3556614816188812,
-0.13669490814208984,
-0.6562374830245972,
-0.19929565489292145,
-0.2083411067724228,
-0.3550844192504883,
0.017234578728675842,
0.7171061635017395,
-0.3725111782550812,
0.6070173382759094,
0.8791130185127258,
0.32733553647994995,
0.5726142525672913,
0.5139128565788269,
0.4034898579120636,
-0.775883674621582,
-0.05092291906476021,
-0.0465107187628746,
0.5029267072677612,
0.6623029708862305,
-0.18332859873771667,
0.5726057291030884,
0.14157013595104218,
-0.21669436991214752,
-0.8282194137573242,
0.21509210765361786,
-1.0612807273864746,
-0.3287636637687683,
0.9909068942070007,
-0.5316791534423828,
-0.07805812358856201,
0.14374367892742157,
-0.12181064486503601,
0.08725151419639587,
-0.14527326822280884,
0.5564084053039551,
0.841793417930603,
0.05111037567257881,
-0.21957120299339294,
-0.2031097710132599,
0.6450140476226807,
0.5052218437194824,
-0.8545632362365723,
0.10631664842367172,
0.5045083165168762,
0.325719952583313,
0.8074871897697449,
0.49265608191490173,
-0.26383131742477417,
0.2862301170825958,
0.3137054443359375,
-0.1551380306482315,
-0.0019237506203353405,
-0.14501775801181793,
-0.8509165644645691,
0.4105468690395355,
0.008334532380104065,
0.14410415291786194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03259v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03259v2
|
Enhancing the Performance of Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis Systems
| 2024-04-04T07:31:56 | 2024-04-19T07:30:23 |
Chen Li, Huidong Tang, Peng Ju, Debo Cheng, Yasuhiko Morimoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect-based sentiment analysis aims to predict sentiment polarity with fine
granularity. While Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) are widely utilized for
sentimental feature extraction, their naive application for syntactic feature
extraction can compromise information preservation. This study introduces an
innovative edge-enhanced GCN, named SentiSys, to navigate the syntactic graph
while preserving intact feature information, leading to enhanced performance.
Specifically,we first integrate a bidirectional long short-term memory
(Bi-LSTM) network and a self-attention-based transformer. This combination
facilitates effective text encoding, preventing the loss of information and
predicting long dependency text. A bidirectional GCN (Bi-GCN) with message
passing is then employed to encode relationships between entities.
Additionally, unnecessary information is filtered out using an aspect-specific
masking technique. To validate the effectiveness of our proposed model, we
conduct extensive evaluation experiments and ablation studies on four benchmark
datasets. The results consistently demonstrate improved performance in
aspect-based sentiment analysis when employing SentiSys. This approach
successfully addresses the challenges associated with syntactic feature
extraction, highlighting its potential for advancing sentiment analysis
methodologies.
|
[
-0.3648737967014313,
-0.7018318176269531,
0.5075384974479675,
0.3758392930030823,
-0.6256017088890076,
0.23382744193077087,
-0.3257256746292114,
-0.482618123292923,
0.7108535170555115,
0.7047908306121826,
-0.5202791094779968,
-0.5159671306610107,
-0.5579594969749451,
0.1306312084197998,
-0.15745508670806885,
1.2564693689346313,
0.15778471529483795,
-0.14900413155555725,
-0.27094778418540955,
-0.3695826530456543,
0.05618865042924881,
-0.6703947186470032,
-0.7132007479667664,
-0.33967673778533936,
0.7442177534103394,
0.12233606725931168,
0.9674310684204102,
0.24866925179958344,
0.7233618497848511,
0.2834863066673279,
-0.6491519808769226,
0.2932707369327545,
-0.044461850076913834,
0.4949856400489807,
-0.13999265432357788,
-0.29504188895225525,
-0.8639350533485413,
-0.19473910331726074,
0.5481293201446533,
0.7857177257537842,
0.1600838452577591,
-0.017408300191164017,
0.49867960810661316,
1.051733136177063,
-0.5040048360824585,
0.27052927017211914,
-0.3054753541946411,
0.11700545251369476,
-0.19902516901493073,
-0.0340801402926445,
-0.21266770362854004,
-0.4258398413658142,
0.26400697231292725,
-0.18006162345409393,
0.05826369673013687,
-0.24935762584209442,
0.804104745388031,
0.014843830838799477,
-0.0650939866900444,
-0.21373504400253296,
-0.6134130358695984,
0.4686390459537506,
-0.7448967099189758,
0.48136255145072937,
0.06559500843286514,
-0.04581362009048462,
-0.17722316086292267,
-0.8880414962768555,
-0.3994027078151703,
0.22563154995441437,
-0.3453071713447571,
0.3954336941242218,
-0.35528790950775146,
0.394845575094223,
0.059740979224443436,
0.6019418835639954,
-0.46702033281326294,
-0.050505198538303375,
-0.20311574637889862,
-0.3293101489543915,
0.45727765560150146,
0.08018386363983154,
0.010564719326794147,
-0.8419975638389587,
-0.11463424563407898,
0.13397002220153809,
-0.5508484244346619,
0.5243768692016602,
0.49221277236938477,
0.6727284789085388,
-0.08232433348894119,
0.3823713958263397,
-0.40140074491500854,
0.3020339012145996,
0.15556678175926208,
0.17214134335517883,
0.5797616243362427,
-0.21193942427635193,
-0.15512284636497498,
-0.15967902541160583,
1.0297095775604248,
0.2701543867588043,
-0.05794825777411461,
-0.16282236576080322,
-0.33100518584251404,
-0.11305199563503265,
0.21554411947727203,
-0.8645673394203186,
-0.4800134301185608,
0.32377389073371887,
-0.6661341190338135,
-0.33442023396492004,
-0.28965485095977783,
-0.7221857309341431,
-0.23486658930778503,
-0.3625330924987793,
0.05769319459795952,
-0.5158597230911255,
-0.4199904203414917,
-0.33555763959884644,
-0.11286888271570206,
-0.44553858041763306,
0.2731459140777588,
-0.5787186026573181,
0.20992495119571686,
0.8997820019721985,
1.1891779899597168,
-0.13674752414226532,
-0.01844269223511219,
-0.4531548023223877,
-0.2703309655189514,
-0.13593649864196777,
0.7477231025695801,
-0.6642552614212036,
-0.2201215773820877,
-0.011275598779320717,
0.2262846827507019,
0.032669518142938614,
-0.4500781297683716,
0.34597331285476685,
-0.541373610496521,
0.10528139024972916,
-0.18973742425441742,
-0.18408401310443878,
-0.5313403606414795,
0.5859863758087158,
-0.7803316116333008,
1.017388105392456,
0.07031090557575226,
-0.9216268062591553,
0.0823354497551918,
-0.5834012031555176,
-0.6414775848388672,
0.08229120075702667,
-0.059094805270433426,
-0.7303394079208374,
0.3346956968307495,
0.4464953541755676,
0.5889500975608826,
0.07618367671966553,
0.21720761060714722,
-0.46506375074386597,
-0.20874549448490143,
0.42923617362976074,
-0.5379406213760376,
0.3637752830982208,
0.146828755736351,
-0.08858533948659897,
0.32213345170021057,
-0.4349127411842346,
0.0014476161450147629,
-0.18847836554050446,
-0.29674452543258667,
-0.35089656710624695,
0.04841122403740883,
-0.14892375469207764,
0.2510085105895996,
0.3877476453781128,
-0.8102637529373169,
-0.0858273133635521,
-0.7528394460678101,
0.5113797187805176,
0.5322429537773132,
0.0472898930311203,
0.36563795804977417,
0.09156996756792068,
0.4166807234287262,
0.5533649921417236,
0.32870471477508545,
-0.11716543138027191,
-0.18821227550506592,
-0.75592041015625,
-0.18546055257320404,
0.14392565190792084,
0.32698285579681396,
-1.0658093690872192,
0.5463614463806152,
-0.5241894125938416,
-0.33191508054733276,
-0.4155629873275757,
0.0650467500090599,
0.28391027450561523,
0.26808464527130127,
0.29869142174720764,
-0.6700019240379333,
-0.24178557097911835,
-1.07084059715271,
-0.16954688727855682,
-0.14847072958946228,
0.24605286121368408,
0.49473318457603455,
-0.06451991945505142,
0.03662817180156708,
0.960951030254364,
-0.29587602615356445,
-0.12604926526546478,
-0.7139949798583984,
0.06131753697991371,
0.41793206334114075,
0.14650627970695496,
0.21613676846027374,
-0.7051488757133484,
-0.1350795477628708,
0.12956972420215607,
-0.7601741552352905,
0.27771440148353577,
0.11432177573442459,
-0.04532359167933464,
0.18528036773204803,
0.20052208006381989,
-0.6450022459030151,
0.28903454542160034,
0.6030126214027405,
-0.19050467014312744,
0.32718926668167114,
-0.1511288434267044,
0.1693628579378128,
-1.068973422050476,
-0.06557653844356537,
0.3487507700920105,
-0.5034977197647095,
-0.3865533471107483,
-0.3061984181404114,
0.1676378697156906,
-0.4991999566555023,
-0.5174184441566467,
0.01242120936512947,
-0.4330017864704132,
-0.16467279195785522,
-0.45449399948120117,
0.24708695709705353,
0.3685900866985321,
0.6767667531967163,
-0.06556867808103561,
0.5744848847389221,
0.5561010241508484,
-0.30139848589897156,
0.3371899724006653,
-0.03038622811436653,
0.34238818287849426,
0.5853738784790039,
-0.4252532422542572,
0.4075159430503845,
-0.2583317756652832,
0.2700854241847992,
-0.660861611366272,
0.3069279193878174,
0.48826655745506287,
-0.2935239374637604,
0.5362054109573364,
-0.5000491142272949,
-0.2888655662536621,
-0.5459508895874023,
-0.5031827092170715,
0.24519139528274536,
0.15977658331394196,
-0.3868638873100281,
0.8624736070632935,
0.17054735124111176,
-0.5382755398750305,
-0.42237740755081177,
-0.3973999321460724,
0.37191712856292725,
-0.27096089720726013,
-0.5752680897712708,
0.08538523316383362,
0.30494728684425354,
0.14179056882858276,
0.23806655406951904,
0.10343792289495468,
0.2458139806985855,
0.0714423656463623,
0.48305338621139526,
0.13381904363632202,
-0.24783629179000854,
0.18676146864891052,
0.3341836631298065,
-0.27320167422294617,
0.11532530933618546,
-0.31281086802482605,
0.6348352432250977,
-0.48596248030662537,
0.0187000073492527,
-0.5500324368476868,
0.41819101572036743,
0.5508469343185425,
-0.45217037200927734,
0.4492058753967285,
0.3906385898590088,
-0.2597062587738037,
-0.15771928429603577,
-0.33495059609413147,
0.0023620950523763895,
-0.4842912256717682,
0.7225338220596313,
-0.4272609055042267,
-0.8444429039955139,
0.5885583758354187,
-0.3121420741081238,
-0.346038818359375,
0.38827240467071533,
0.0677027627825737,
-0.3334422707557678,
0.8594363927841187,
0.6223220825195312,
-0.3507947027683258,
0.6228328943252563,
-0.45967698097229004,
0.43338701128959656,
-1.3220869302749634,
-0.1676788479089737,
-0.2344653606414795,
-0.44721996784210205,
-0.6207210421562195,
-0.00856450293213129,
0.318671852350235,
0.13259229063987732,
0.11101733148097992,
0.2316853255033493,
-0.7001832723617554,
0.11239505559206009,
0.17820106446743011,
0.6696962714195251,
0.04763684421777725,
0.0029366405215114355,
0.3478016257286072,
-0.08955512940883636,
-0.4699303209781647,
-0.4151947498321533,
0.9222017526626587,
0.6239897012710571,
0.5959563255310059,
-0.08368955552577972,
0.6393541097640991,
0.40750202536582947,
0.2878802716732025,
-0.7943596243858337,
0.6911982297897339,
-0.7256080508232117,
0.046009428799152374,
-0.22447985410690308,
-0.4166404902935028,
-0.7127090692520142,
0.18622231483459473,
0.01463935524225235,
-0.7629005312919617,
0.1256227344274521,
0.07104460150003433,
-0.30372676253318787,
0.3285039961338043,
-0.39716675877571106,
0.6639714241027832,
-0.12193935364484787,
-0.446763277053833,
-0.3561932444572449,
-0.4782716631889343,
-0.24814368784427643,
0.3571288287639618,
-0.05738358944654465,
-0.20073989033699036,
0.28246206045150757,
0.8673569560050964,
-0.23335348069667816,
0.8676074147224426,
-0.325465589761734,
0.3087485134601593,
0.31089138984680176,
0.1971549391746521,
0.5044870972633362,
-0.004545495845377445,
-0.1829150915145874,
0.5483713746070862,
-0.2780701816082001,
-0.07188758999109268,
-0.8517302870750427,
0.9352139830589294,
-0.60498046875,
-0.6334139704704285,
-0.07018282264471054,
-0.42091354727745056,
-0.10233254730701447,
0.0609716922044754,
0.1020650714635849,
0.8773686289787292,
0.02730368636548519,
0.10990489274263382,
0.2945736348628998,
0.2695768177509308,
0.9031148552894592,
-0.0739160031080246,
-0.09898076951503754,
-0.8658016324043274,
1.0214377641677856,
0.3351336419582367,
0.052946604788303375,
0.04578886926174164,
0.23365554213523865,
-0.22191756963729858,
-0.7516101002693176,
-0.7049500346183777,
0.18254759907722473,
-0.7333323359489441,
-0.4785599708557129,
-0.8701328635215759,
-0.48290514945983887,
-0.28666961193084717,
0.08563915640115738,
-0.6313180327415466,
-0.3692414462566376,
-0.3101699650287628,
-0.05812451243400574,
0.37055981159210205,
0.6200899481773376,
0.21048177778720856,
0.44983983039855957,
-0.8124604225158691,
-0.14950743317604065,
-0.2406262755393982,
0.4366318881511688,
0.04210962355136871,
-0.21688593924045563,
-0.45329707860946655,
0.008129378780722618,
-0.4388907253742218,
-0.8371854424476624,
0.39352846145629883,
0.07505384832620621,
0.2242518663406372,
0.35764622688293457,
-0.1487586796283722,
0.4074802100658417,
-0.0006284736446104944,
0.8522521257400513,
0.2680642604827881,
-0.8844926953315735,
0.7124244570732117,
-0.2536907196044922,
0.26265576481819153,
0.5488802790641785,
0.04525946080684662,
-0.6044479608535767,
-0.6912369728088379,
-0.6349277496337891,
-0.9200049638748169,
0.6973276734352112,
0.26596155762672424,
0.2884760797023773,
-0.08688447624444962,
0.6582629680633545,
0.20098860561847687,
0.21247299015522003,
-0.6998991370201111,
-0.0388864167034626,
-0.4144301414489746,
-0.6061892509460449,
0.057562731206417084,
-0.3107738792896271,
0.18693041801452637,
-0.04494275525212288,
0.599082350730896,
-0.3465724289417267,
0.0970461294054985,
0.5312831997871399,
-0.10083329677581787,
0.03199426084756851,
0.28638631105422974,
0.045668501406908035,
0.34744182229042053,
0.0018537268042564392,
0.3186301589012146,
0.07467719167470932,
-0.5508846044540405,
-0.13689379394054413,
0.36317217350006104,
-0.27203547954559326,
-0.050906941294670105,
0.2509802579879761,
0.9476600289344788,
-0.03408987075090408,
0.13897188007831573,
0.6326698660850525,
0.008602808229625225,
0.36685746908187866,
-0.215094193816185,
-0.10974162071943283,
0.003248372348025441,
0.5716751217842102,
0.1377565562725067,
0.10549165308475494,
0.4534972012042999,
-0.4218376576900482,
0.10486495494842529,
0.4913371801376343,
-0.9372230768203735,
-0.7376194596290588,
0.014580808579921722,
0.4189389944076538,
-0.425703763961792,
0.60197913646698,
-0.16790959239006042,
-0.8431252837181091,
0.5135158896446228,
0.34186235070228577,
1.2314780950546265,
0.08020611852407455,
0.30038413405418396,
0.1501026451587677,
0.10661051422357559,
0.3162960410118103,
0.1677028238773346,
-0.24798783659934998,
-0.48996254801750183,
-0.2543826997280121,
-0.5859166979789734,
-0.3049737513065338,
-0.11608817428350449,
-0.557455837726593,
0.0027643542271107435,
-0.5024337768554688,
-0.4456251561641693,
0.018053840845823288,
-0.018073420971632004,
-0.6826403141021729,
0.4271446764469147,
0.19725719094276428,
0.4261617064476013,
-0.7926187515258789,
0.4823186695575714,
0.7314828038215637,
-0.3603336811065674,
-0.6720271706581116,
0.12456338852643967,
-0.44737550616264343,
-0.2775573432445526,
0.39983558654785156,
0.5427316427230835,
-0.2016882300376892,
-0.3821663558483124,
-0.24003258347511292,
-0.6947147250175476,
0.939336895942688,
-0.17907723784446716,
-0.47914138436317444,
0.26387181878089905,
0.2635379135608673,
0.6720694303512573,
-0.5033013224601746,
0.5896662473678589,
0.5668253898620605,
-0.015348232351243496,
0.01405913196504116,
-0.735539436340332,
0.2493249773979187,
-0.4104369878768921,
-0.003979964647442102,
0.5079295039176941,
-0.722952127456665,
0.6377218961715698,
0.08259595930576324,
-0.15499526262283325,
-0.36153775453567505,
1.115320086479187,
-0.3227011263370514,
0.5239344835281372,
0.6083951592445374,
0.4900726079940796,
0.5922322869300842,
-0.17340411245822906,
0.7338842749595642,
-0.22389453649520874,
0.4098047912120819,
0.7898445129394531,
-0.06532970070838928,
0.8057692050933838,
0.4573272168636322,
0.03568101301789284,
0.8845024108886719,
0.60942143201828,
0.4873606860637665,
0.6188405752182007,
-0.04107455909252167,
-0.2644434869289398,
-0.24383828043937683,
-0.26310691237449646,
-0.09072162955999374,
0.33617520332336426,
0.3968324661254883,
-0.5468819737434387,
-0.2629891633987427,
0.31623899936676025,
0.3076695501804352,
-0.17435583472251892,
-0.4501064419746399,
1.0487666130065918,
0.21499675512313843,
-0.5239028930664062,
-0.04580751433968544,
-0.3447363078594208,
0.6585904955863953,
-0.37791943550109863,
0.2368074208498001,
-0.44161972403526306,
0.2844770550727844,
-0.43061792850494385,
-1.2849891185760498,
0.5244503021240234,
-0.2369052916765213,
-0.24324829876422882,
0.07046949118375778,
1.0654878616333008,
-0.42334258556365967,
-0.5970463156700134,
0.4352477192878723,
0.4197418689727783,
-0.03147834911942482,
-0.3184940814971924,
-0.5065538287162781,
-0.007175683509558439,
-0.04553878679871559,
-0.5384958386421204,
0.16129447519779205,
0.6541369557380676,
-0.03128262236714363,
0.5951175093650818,
0.4590413570404053,
0.38614559173583984,
-0.65394127368927,
0.4281100332736969,
1.2460010051727295,
-0.7943445444107056,
-0.890859067440033,
-0.9313615560531616,
0.5105650424957275,
-0.394287645816803,
-0.2838015556335449,
0.5276483297348022,
0.6989012956619263,
0.1920061558485031,
0.4628296494483948,
0.6483432650566101,
0.30816465616226196,
0.26368623971939087,
-0.47402113676071167,
0.7211445569992065,
-0.37384864687919617,
0.029753975570201874,
-0.30028221011161804,
-0.9707129597663879,
-0.2506335377693176,
-0.0866755023598671,
-0.5030355453491211,
-0.08906473219394684,
0.5696148872375488,
0.6695812940597534,
-0.1661113202571869,
0.44068142771720886,
0.10181762278079987,
0.03875800594687462,
0.615868330001831,
0.37458980083465576,
0.8239990472793579,
-0.30152633786201477,
0.41387301683425903,
-0.6145561933517456,
-0.25011059641838074,
0.059648361057043076,
-0.7228041887283325,
-0.9231476783752441,
-0.4021569490432739,
-0.4750838279724121,
-0.6226481795310974,
0.26711827516555786,
0.6121506690979004,
0.468062162399292,
-0.4884975850582123,
0.17390130460262299,
0.10432490706443787,
-0.010828415863215923,
-0.01993023231625557,
-0.22993320226669312,
0.7590591311454773,
-0.3932320177555084,
-0.34178391098976135,
0.2886112928390503,
0.764402449131012,
-0.14746007323265076,
-0.2846217751502991,
0.15130074322223663,
0.41283679008483887,
-0.030109994113445282,
0.5356003642082214,
-0.19506801664829254,
-0.5493466258049011,
-0.7283520102500916,
-0.06771140545606613,
-0.05196857452392578,
0.38555148243904114,
0.823593020439148,
-0.7654337882995605,
0.3815896213054657,
0.40375348925590515,
0.28225842118263245,
0.4528605043888092,
0.16980917751789093,
0.2246689796447754,
-0.6451177597045898,
0.21679846942424774,
0.41973942518234253,
0.44438818097114563,
0.7421316504478455,
-0.736539363861084,
0.04944528266787529,
0.3133220374584198,
-0.39271238446235657,
-0.24959884583950043,
0.0733104795217514,
-1.0516413450241089,
-0.15248015522956848,
1.0572669506072998,
-0.28457409143447876,
-0.5227677226066589,
-0.07899612933397293,
-0.033702973276376724,
0.26849839091300964,
-0.565011739730835,
0.5006530284881592,
0.3974321484565735,
-0.3646218478679657,
-0.1328958123922348,
0.12170300632715225,
0.3493899703025818,
0.44990384578704834,
-0.7954384088516235,
0.3611026704311371,
0.43564528226852417,
0.1678166687488556,
0.3475911021232605,
0.5099735260009766,
-0.18409179151058197,
0.06817013770341873,
-0.2083233743906021,
0.1951785832643509,
-0.2019154578447342,
-0.5144989490509033,
-0.46516847610473633,
0.34854280948638916,
-0.04605541378259659,
-0.48578089475631714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04292v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04292v5
|
Conversational Disease Diagnosis via External Planner-Controlled Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T06:16:35 | 2024-05-20T00:45:40 |
Zhoujian Sun, Cheng Luo, Ziyi Liu, Zhengxing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of large language models (LLMs) has brought unprecedented
possibilities for artificial intelligence (AI) based medical diagnosis.
However, the application perspective of LLMs in real diagnostic scenarios is
still unclear because they are not adept at collecting patient data
proactively. This study presents a LLM-based diagnostic system that enhances
planning capabilities by emulating doctors. Our system involves two external
planners to handle planning tasks. The first planner employs a reinforcement
learning approach to formulate disease screening questions and conduct initial
diagnoses. The second planner uses LLMs to parse medical guidelines and conduct
differential diagnoses. By utilizing real patient electronic medical record
data, we constructed simulated dialogues between virtual patients and doctors
and evaluated the diagnostic abilities of our system. We demonstrated that our
system obtained impressive performance in both disease screening and
differential diagnoses tasks. This research represents a step towards more
seamlessly integrating AI into clinical settings, potentially enhancing the
accuracy and accessibility of medical diagnostics.
|
[
-0.3739258944988251,
-0.9800171256065369,
1.1182289123535156,
0.11756502091884613,
-0.08694802969694138,
-0.009432886727154255,
-0.43442872166633606,
-0.7469944357872009,
0.6153637170791626,
0.46253150701522827,
-0.5539681315422058,
-0.6294620037078857,
-0.4172361195087433,
0.22153718769550323,
-0.2746950089931488,
0.7051504254341125,
0.02791985124349594,
0.41773292422294617,
-0.4068002998828888,
0.12025023996829987,
-0.4245448410511017,
-0.4415181279182434,
-1.3663071393966675,
-0.6027300357818604,
0.31911978125572205,
0.2649931311607361,
0.8173525929450989,
0.56891268491745,
0.4108749032020569,
0.3773699700832367,
0.18802936375141144,
0.5197277069091797,
-0.1254955530166626,
0.4582446217536926,
-0.014313815161585808,
-0.346478134393692,
-0.37514206767082214,
-0.3114292323589325,
0.36946043372154236,
0.6926389336585999,
-0.17969684302806854,
-0.32774659991264343,
-0.2880862057209015,
0.32087528705596924,
0.1059107556939125,
0.4683644771575928,
-0.05376916751265526,
0.36392688751220703,
0.15946896374225616,
-0.31460633873939514,
-0.4413951635360718,
-0.28363803029060364,
0.09555685520172119,
-0.6769022941589355,
-0.09455287456512451,
-0.10460945963859558,
0.5492621064186096,
0.2808263301849365,
-0.3309764266014099,
-0.4710630476474762,
-1.0541719198226929,
0.15051637589931488,
-0.4567500352859497,
0.3333269953727722,
0.46666374802589417,
0.5811461210250854,
-0.250282883644104,
-0.5815654993057251,
-0.5023932456970215,
-0.589867115020752,
-0.08533594012260437,
0.224347323179245,
-0.19575980305671692,
0.2237963080406189,
0.23772720992565155,
0.10518383234739304,
-0.6650965213775635,
0.5580167174339294,
-0.08133998513221741,
-0.02629256434738636,
0.6632641553878784,
0.5664410591125488,
0.49970126152038574,
0.08346115797758102,
0.008458363823592663,
0.07345312833786011,
-0.60862797498703,
-0.18992601335048676,
-0.24357376992702484,
0.22928622364997864,
-0.3565807044506073,
0.4619189500808716,
-0.22538304328918457,
0.5755470395088196,
0.06618916988372803,
-0.450662761926651,
-0.03223723918199539,
-0.08728612214326859,
-0.2892235517501831,
0.22275148332118988,
0.7137084603309631,
0.2611168324947357,
0.15925705432891846,
-0.08995550125837326,
-0.12903615832328796,
0.08303651958703995,
0.23427847027778625,
-0.5414333343505859,
-0.6105809807777405,
0.48038536310195923,
-0.5286318063735962,
-0.2372816950082779,
-0.7162877917289734,
-0.6354012489318848,
-0.6934545636177063,
-0.3567919433116913,
0.32000434398651123,
-0.5799972414970398,
-0.24700845777988434,
-0.0535646416246891,
0.11245162039995193,
-0.22595815360546112,
0.45131543278694153,
-0.797608494758606,
0.4226507544517517,
0.45467355847358704,
0.5807245969772339,
0.03462068736553192,
0.32217487692832947,
-0.6209047436714172,
0.22005067765712738,
-0.4685170352458954,
0.8476371765136719,
-0.6660933494567871,
-0.788739800453186,
0.031848594546318054,
-0.15117356181144714,
-0.1696566939353943,
-0.7663876414299011,
0.21279111504554749,
-0.25071632862091064,
0.006448605563491583,
0.05847465991973877,
-0.376161128282547,
0.04742659255862236,
0.5532495975494385,
-0.37628859281539917,
0.7442452907562256,
0.27088087797164917,
-0.22914935648441315,
0.29715025424957275,
-0.5595890879631042,
-0.32456567883491516,
0.42345497012138367,
-0.7037481069564819,
-0.42847132682800293,
-0.3403773605823517,
0.25320371985435486,
0.5667241811752319,
-0.34544041752815247,
0.5079144835472107,
-0.18504388630390167,
-0.17958225309848785,
-0.043358758091926575,
-0.241176038980484,
0.3727209270000458,
0.01719563454389572,
-0.07047132402658463,
0.37012094259262085,
-0.4639156758785248,
0.1845809519290924,
0.1936226487159729,
-0.28104889392852783,
-0.13837619125843048,
0.3841710686683655,
-0.46892794966697693,
0.08037388324737549,
0.03832738474011421,
-0.18537364900112152,
0.6235288977622986,
-0.6161971092224121,
-0.06581177562475204,
0.38944876194000244,
0.12896668910980225,
-0.03917042165994644,
-0.8603150844573975,
0.836170494556427,
0.3032393455505371,
0.0662652850151062,
-0.2280784249305725,
-0.8777099251747131,
-0.7800073027610779,
-0.3936366140842438,
-0.08115270733833313,
0.8921812772750854,
-0.736324667930603,
0.4616059362888336,
-0.2985488772392273,
-0.34341853857040405,
-0.3356211185455322,
-0.13383948802947998,
0.349122017621994,
0.5091420412063599,
0.355366975069046,
-0.02579222433269024,
-0.32053491473197937,
-0.7465224266052246,
0.18944349884986877,
-0.26742783188819885,
-0.08134307712316513,
0.6993642449378967,
0.1564997136592865,
-0.5687604546546936,
0.42652028799057007,
-0.44631296396255493,
-0.5263276100158691,
-0.6510311961174011,
-0.25148940086364746,
0.34043359756469727,
0.29979845881462097,
0.4539218842983246,
-0.31600937247276306,
-0.3886563181877136,
0.40255028009414673,
-0.6879560351371765,
-0.15406255424022675,
-0.15246376395225525,
0.2190246731042862,
0.11102096736431122,
0.5856999158859253,
-0.4715259373188019,
0.572008490562439,
0.7148693799972534,
-0.5146433115005493,
0.4577719271183014,
-0.8288373351097107,
0.05023016780614853,
-1.0043714046478271,
-0.12072973698377609,
0.2503790855407715,
-0.629006564617157,
-0.2844734489917755,
-0.11054924130439758,
-0.19384953379631042,
-0.29833847284317017,
0.03808269277215004,
0.47008728981018066,
-0.14979618787765503,
0.04418724775314331,
-0.04445773363113403,
0.09835056960582733,
-0.033268753439188004,
-0.009104225784540176,
0.15149028599262238,
0.3010386824607849,
0.5143855810165405,
-1.008304476737976,
0.5825671553611755,
0.332249253988266,
-0.12083030492067337,
0.6279683113098145,
-0.5364751815795898,
-0.2199036031961441,
-0.029236702248454094,
0.37928107380867004,
-0.7420148849487305,
-0.18969063460826874,
0.461763471364975,
-0.2161046415567398,
0.42463889718055725,
-0.023060208186507225,
-0.544058084487915,
-0.4029443562030792,
0.0836016833782196,
0.21277621388435364,
0.5966669917106628,
-0.5578514933586121,
0.6661173701286316,
0.375693678855896,
-0.3772270679473877,
0.21193841099739075,
-0.5684571862220764,
-0.03419860079884529,
-0.03755147010087967,
-0.6755650043487549,
0.4186747670173645,
0.11438941955566406,
-0.5467485785484314,
-0.10008322447538376,
0.5047710537910461,
-0.11609265208244324,
-0.054740872234106064,
0.34863561391830444,
0.3015216886997223,
-0.3007168471813202,
0.4910925030708313,
0.20073780417442322,
-0.15163929760456085,
0.10087483376264572,
0.06229101121425629,
0.7412657737731934,
0.2889195382595062,
-0.754858136177063,
-0.7535966038703918,
0.5230269432067871,
0.4128859341144562,
0.056745633482933044,
0.4437173306941986,
0.1691139191389084,
-0.5035204887390137,
-0.3925396800041199,
-0.29908090829849243,
-0.16316662728786469,
-0.4435131549835205,
0.2209576815366745,
-0.417524516582489,
-0.31202590465545654,
0.47930312156677246,
-0.3938927948474884,
-0.11147473752498627,
0.3272036612033844,
0.7205290794372559,
-0.13987576961517334,
1.5509154796600342,
0.5458467602729797,
0.044278889894485474,
0.10463422536849976,
-0.2300988733768463,
0.42775842547416687,
-0.7220130562782288,
-0.5233168601989746,
-0.41316479444503784,
-0.10289857536554337,
-0.6288720369338989,
-0.6008071303367615,
0.9564796090126038,
-0.17279589176177979,
-0.13754424452781677,
-0.2538945972919464,
-0.5735667943954468,
0.14816300570964813,
0.2975940406322479,
0.44428330659866333,
0.38167592883110046,
-0.3500122129917145,
-0.47151070833206177,
-0.2605612576007843,
-0.641120433807373,
-0.5515230298042297,
0.9560633897781372,
0.2703295350074768,
0.49758103489875793,
0.1137479692697525,
0.5808076858520508,
0.37886983156204224,
0.4792901873588562,
-1.0026073455810547,
0.4126189053058624,
-0.2872537076473236,
-0.08102035522460938,
-0.1229635700583458,
-0.3412087559700012,
-0.9587476849555969,
0.13098740577697754,
-0.17797105014324188,
-0.8999491930007935,
-0.02991735003888607,
0.3361327350139618,
-0.595763623714447,
0.26750659942626953,
-0.7274929881095886,
0.8404136300086975,
-0.4937586188316345,
-0.007587501313537359,
-0.535944402217865,
-0.16495394706726074,
0.3444172143936157,
0.0338829830288887,
0.2747096121311188,
-0.13131172955036163,
0.09280364215373993,
0.5033845901489258,
-0.1546584516763687,
0.8492401242256165,
-0.22347915172576904,
-0.09495171904563904,
-0.2882125675678253,
0.34697821736335754,
0.44501084089279175,
0.49317264556884766,
-0.18756528198719025,
-0.27389901876449585,
0.12941549718379974,
0.032522741705179214,
-0.5229591727256775,
0.8381137847900391,
-0.5853923559188843,
-0.63396155834198,
-0.520797848701477,
-0.2656838595867157,
-0.7067131996154785,
0.09067881852388382,
-0.2906138300895691,
0.6253500580787659,
-0.4042948782444,
-0.44194403290748596,
0.5155025124549866,
-0.715520977973938,
0.1652662605047226,
0.8024516701698303,
-0.505342960357666,
0.14657118916511536,
0.8151639103889465,
-0.13007794320583344,
0.11606748402118683,
0.22846832871437073,
0.46878477931022644,
-0.1905359923839569,
-0.5887550711631775,
-0.5389901995658875,
0.34088200330734253,
-0.5767826437950134,
-0.20600418746471405,
-0.8042374849319458,
-0.38122594356536865,
-0.3864409029483795,
-0.17621420323848724,
-0.21050691604614258,
0.09444176405668259,
-0.3884165287017822,
0.1715725213289261,
0.530713677406311,
1.0326467752456665,
-0.08946982026100159,
0.11050330102443695,
-0.6372203230857849,
0.6033420562744141,
-0.06726668775081635,
0.24276213347911835,
-0.18067467212677002,
-0.27591708302497864,
-0.07194638252258301,
0.26118922233581543,
-0.331868976354599,
-0.7614673972129822,
0.8477728962898254,
0.22442464530467987,
0.707342267036438,
0.8593036532402039,
0.10787525027990341,
0.7768281698226929,
-0.3462081849575043,
0.5508018732070923,
0.059739965945482254,
-0.5473020076751709,
0.7737005352973938,
-0.2803262770175934,
0.20145738124847412,
0.3349122405052185,
0.6056085228919983,
-0.7310895919799805,
-0.5246767997741699,
-0.47227489948272705,
-0.6047517657279968,
0.6314747929573059,
-0.4396940767765045,
-0.21138185262680054,
-0.2604338228702545,
0.30158519744873047,
0.004257339518517256,
-0.31754201650619507,
-0.236677885055542,
-0.23173347115516663,
0.2580857574939728,
-0.46194469928741455,
-0.3207581043243408,
-0.09130365401506424,
-0.398306667804718,
-0.7030854821205139,
0.4355067312717438,
-0.14137543737888336,
0.6451308131217957,
0.4915318489074707,
0.25135892629623413,
0.021065106615424156,
-0.052594516426324844,
0.5179435610771179,
0.5041618347167969,
0.19789369404315948,
-0.1714954525232315,
0.15943795442581177,
-0.256589412689209,
-0.1665302962064743,
0.2664867341518402,
0.08298254013061523,
0.0978715643286705,
0.14012379944324493,
0.5117013454437256,
0.26917025446891785,
-1.1155983209609985,
0.5467233657836914,
-0.05897584557533264,
-0.08274541795253754,
-0.7678667306900024,
0.20027711987495422,
0.23834875226020813,
0.5757650136947632,
-0.08117447793483734,
-0.10932232439517975,
-0.011225366964936256,
-0.5960893630981445,
0.2090550810098648,
0.5677348971366882,
-0.44341567158699036,
-0.28056013584136963,
0.47408750653266907,
0.3688089847564697,
-0.6634381413459778,
0.9717946648597717,
-0.4186023473739624,
-0.4028962552547455,
0.9372533559799194,
0.8288537263870239,
0.223593071103096,
-0.08458704501390457,
0.30354949831962585,
0.06962175667285919,
0.10939885675907135,
-0.054488588124513626,
0.46717220544815063,
0.0891144797205925,
-0.8109336495399475,
-0.3979722857475281,
-0.2789931893348694,
-0.6054800152778625,
0.5253554582595825,
-0.22552643716335297,
0.5028013586997986,
-0.5727173089981079,
0.015203028917312622,
0.06214173510670662,
0.10836360603570938,
-0.5601458549499512,
0.35338127613067627,
0.32892727851867676,
0.6260960698127747,
-0.5498359799385071,
0.9642787575721741,
0.4677911102771759,
-0.14439362287521362,
-0.792303740978241,
-0.03380855917930603,
0.11197097599506378,
-1.0364575386047363,
0.5139854550361633,
0.2693726718425751,
0.23403458297252655,
-0.07210791856050491,
0.03928253799676895,
-0.6596371531486511,
0.937118411064148,
0.2502078115940094,
-0.5836647152900696,
-0.16296355426311493,
-0.09792397916316986,
0.8299382925033569,
-0.5352105498313904,
0.4949583113193512,
0.5409932136535645,
0.5479927062988281,
0.020410971716046333,
-1.5291661024093628,
0.059597112238407135,
-0.12847329676151276,
-0.4601590037345886,
0.48026666045188904,
-0.27548351883888245,
0.611005961894989,
-0.4970732033252716,
-0.22803626954555511,
0.16101789474487305,
-0.02125680260360241,
0.15654557943344116,
0.34632596373558044,
0.17150096595287323,
0.6698166131973267,
0.8259114623069763,
0.04065925255417824,
1.3504694700241089,
-0.643589198589325,
-0.3150944709777832,
0.7498922944068909,
-0.5118063688278198,
0.851294755935669,
0.051681652665138245,
-0.09332795441150665,
0.330104261636734,
0.5621855854988098,
0.14699211716651917,
0.140387624502182,
0.29863911867141724,
-0.6295026540756226,
-0.2755063474178314,
-0.30457115173339844,
-0.5028374195098877,
0.5648393630981445,
0.9906201362609863,
-0.6466060280799866,
-0.22869977355003357,
0.030575977638363838,
-0.1916525661945343,
0.17512568831443787,
-0.2707846164703369,
0.8834174275398254,
-0.15415965020656586,
-0.6055285334587097,
0.3353312015533447,
0.08763973414897919,
0.4554321765899658,
-0.7546777129173279,
-0.3226589262485504,
0.05136008933186531,
0.4120090901851654,
-0.06879507750272751,
-0.5886898636817932,
0.4927317500114441,
-0.25718674063682556,
0.15942548215389252,
-0.4164029359817505,
0.41862452030181885,
-0.38550707697868347,
-0.5549452900886536,
0.43839794397354126,
0.6953181028366089,
0.3961554765701294,
0.03925720602273941,
-0.42502596974372864,
-0.03239436075091362,
-0.20919492840766907,
0.10941972583532333,
0.2353697121143341,
0.2795184254646301,
-0.24166560173034668,
1.0305685997009277,
0.46738770604133606,
0.5684643387794495,
-0.291259229183197,
0.1350703239440918,
0.9383836984634399,
-0.6306101083755493,
-0.5670723915100098,
-0.7081268429756165,
0.04127774015069008,
-0.1423274278640747,
-0.2611093819141388,
0.11332625150680542,
0.5555657148361206,
0.45569345355033875,
0.1550770252943039,
0.7423073649406433,
0.16810663044452667,
0.702742874622345,
-0.36720746755599976,
0.6560849547386169,
-0.37087076902389526,
0.2242155522108078,
0.10282642394304276,
-0.04320434108376503,
-0.3031463027000427,
0.5581787824630737,
-0.32465654611587524,
0.01626422256231308,
0.748240053653717,
0.6868656277656555,
0.047339051961898804,
-0.19114086031913757,
0.5400851964950562,
0.25621530413627625,
0.6109715700149536,
0.7487208247184753,
0.7297520041465759,
0.29265597462654114,
0.29356250166893005,
-0.324921578168869,
-0.27971819043159485,
-0.5265294313430786,
-0.4240482747554779,
-0.8471646308898926,
-0.3695690333843231,
-0.16493795812129974,
-0.07989141345024109,
0.28495198488235474,
1.0669604539871216,
0.8336883783340454,
-0.509009063243866,
0.022466732189059258,
-0.017916778102517128,
-0.00870254822075367,
-0.15836778283119202,
-0.2403041124343872,
0.21622301638126373,
-0.019189706072211266,
-0.5852367877960205,
0.8891401290893555,
0.35013434290885925,
0.1713293492794037,
-0.4656457006931305,
0.008472469635307789,
0.18856103718280792,
-0.20932191610336304,
0.579681932926178,
0.37606388330459595,
-0.592278778553009,
-0.1337423026561737,
-0.322902649641037,
-0.1954924315214157,
0.05348077043890953,
0.7872642278671265,
-1.2532516717910767,
0.5004844665527344,
0.13276344537734985,
0.630073606967926,
0.3449593782424927,
-0.0373489186167717,
0.7760870456695557,
-0.038096748292446136,
0.2875535190105438,
0.7947224974632263,
0.18742738664150238,
0.023145563900470734,
-0.8847931027412415,
-0.0010832902044057846,
-0.05297309160232544,
-0.47026327252388,
-0.5060326457023621,
0.31929540634155273,
-0.8905107975006104,
-0.08576621115207672,
1.0345736742019653,
-0.11009704321622849,
-0.015405574813485146,
-0.6413707137107849,
-0.2526867091655731,
0.189513698220253,
-0.41897863149642944,
0.9519760012626648,
0.08453069627285004,
-1.0820963382720947,
0.12859533727169037,
-0.6318691372871399,
0.6300575733184814,
0.2030358612537384,
-1.090422511100769,
-0.4861253798007965,
0.44965168833732605,
0.21494917571544647,
-0.18396195769309998,
1.034193754196167,
-0.05532450973987579,
0.35084080696105957,
-0.1353762447834015,
-0.21903333067893982,
-0.14035892486572266,
-0.0927654430270195,
-0.01095162145793438,
-0.07847296446561813,
0.1375221312046051,
-0.1741504967212677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03204v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03204v3
|
RALL-E: Robust Codec Language Modeling with Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Text-to-Speech Synthesis
| 2024-04-04T05:15:07 | 2024-05-19T21:34:28 |
Detai Xin, Xu Tan, Kai Shen, Zeqian Ju, Dongchao Yang, Yuancheng Wang, Shinnosuke Takamichi, Hiroshi Saruwatari, Shujie Liu, Jinyu Li, Sheng Zhao
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
We present RALL-E, a robust language modeling method for text-to-speech (TTS)
synthesis. While previous work based on large language models (LLMs) shows
impressive performance on zero-shot TTS, such methods often suffer from poor
robustness, such as unstable prosody (weird pitch and rhythm/duration) and a
high word error rate (WER), due to the autoregressive prediction style of
language models. The core idea behind RALL-E is chain-of-thought (CoT)
prompting, which decomposes the task into simpler steps to enhance the
robustness of LLM-based TTS. To accomplish this idea, RALL-E first predicts
prosody features (pitch and duration) of the input text and uses them as
intermediate conditions to predict speech tokens in a CoT style. Second, RALL-E
utilizes the predicted duration prompt to guide the computing of self-attention
weights in Transformer to enforce the model to focus on the corresponding
phonemes and prosody features when predicting speech tokens. Results of
comprehensive objective and subjective evaluations demonstrate that, compared
to a powerful baseline method VALL-E, RALL-E significantly improves the WER of
zero-shot TTS from $5.6\%$ (without reranking) and $1.7\%$ (with reranking) to
$2.5\%$ and $1.0\%$, respectively. Furthermore, we demonstrate that RALL-E
correctly synthesizes sentences that are hard for VALL-E and reduces the error
rate from $68\%$ to $4\%$.
|
[
-0.5010678768157959,
-1.2136473655700684,
0.3964715301990509,
0.21785300970077515,
-0.11538991332054138,
0.34584659337997437,
-0.29766106605529785,
-0.40351060032844543,
0.3006308078765869,
0.3307792842388153,
-0.678443193435669,
-0.7136201858520508,
-0.31094929575920105,
0.3434062898159027,
-0.38670897483825684,
1.0561296939849854,
0.17629799246788025,
-0.30128198862075806,
0.046233855187892914,
0.030613532289862633,
-0.5594432950019836,
-0.3684949278831482,
-0.3908349275588989,
-0.17934852838516235,
0.6628982424736023,
0.5275416374206543,
0.5417556166648865,
0.518639087677002,
0.153612419962883,
0.14302265644073486,
-0.03937048092484474,
0.08093966543674469,
-0.27219486236572266,
0.8436140418052673,
0.07995205372571945,
-0.27641910314559937,
-0.9536287188529968,
-0.24271050095558167,
0.403940886259079,
0.4776532053947449,
-0.3510132133960724,
0.21650730073451996,
0.12841883301734924,
0.8043169975280762,
-0.7783473134040833,
-0.025938447564840317,
-0.7704441547393799,
-0.031411830335855484,
-0.0820012241601944,
-0.2899130880832672,
-0.8043880462646484,
-0.22114764153957367,
0.0008509979234077036,
-0.38589486479759216,
0.22891558706760406,
0.45198649168014526,
0.5841392278671265,
0.4730100631713867,
-0.008233008906245232,
-0.27652183175086975,
-0.8588446378707886,
0.7971315979957581,
-0.648282527923584,
0.5053510665893555,
0.5895340442657471,
0.12457716464996338,
-0.0639948695898056,
-0.693543553352356,
-0.4343300759792328,
-0.4332265555858612,
0.17760370671749115,
0.27293819189071655,
-0.2930361032485962,
0.35027575492858887,
0.3162226974964142,
0.2716594636440277,
-0.8269070982933044,
-0.1160656213760376,
-0.1297149807214737,
-0.20404373109340668,
0.3541659414768219,
0.20656651258468628,
0.3020021617412567,
0.07726411521434784,
-0.24597299098968506,
-0.1813732236623764,
-0.8543602824211121,
-0.06113070249557495,
0.22743000090122223,
0.3650563657283783,
-0.07736014574766159,
0.6701557636260986,
-0.06647451967000961,
0.9086475968360901,
0.28009510040283203,
0.045687053352594376,
0.11466862261295319,
-0.1875707358121872,
-0.2886962592601776,
0.2168085277080536,
0.9844887256622314,
0.11740553379058838,
0.15809302031993866,
0.13700327277183533,
-0.3147016167640686,
0.14863206446170807,
0.230843186378479,
-0.7425093054771423,
-0.10403425991535187,
0.3755623996257782,
-0.24066412448883057,
-0.3954925835132599,
-0.003437330015003681,
-0.9277240633964539,
0.2754656970500946,
0.06900808215141296,
0.37747922539711,
-0.30210018157958984,
-0.21470624208450317,
0.26411372423171997,
0.48604705929756165,
0.06260353326797485,
0.129479318857193,
-0.8251355886459351,
0.3145708739757538,
0.28327345848083496,
0.855218768119812,
-0.3308992087841034,
-0.26895853877067566,
-0.9801104068756104,
0.11951454728841782,
-0.31259262561798096,
0.8411952257156372,
-0.6842975616455078,
-0.462940514087677,
-0.01375456154346466,
-0.30068710446357727,
-0.06418514251708984,
-0.3572482466697693,
0.5282482504844666,
-0.3590589165687561,
0.10639890283346176,
0.1717839241027832,
-0.569450318813324,
0.18048472702503204,
0.08195970207452774,
-0.7748894691467285,
1.3116530179977417,
-0.14152199029922485,
-0.9141510128974915,
0.05269809439778328,
-0.6683439016342163,
-0.5967837572097778,
-0.022416695952415466,
-0.13894253969192505,
-0.5209242105484009,
0.14509746432304382,
0.5093225240707397,
0.2689688801765442,
-0.4090113341808319,
0.351962685585022,
-0.21486864984035492,
-0.2522377669811249,
0.49944040179252625,
-0.5436341762542725,
0.33100783824920654,
0.5921292901039124,
-0.4674765467643738,
0.3305690586566925,
-0.5383914709091187,
0.3835248351097107,
-0.10044495761394501,
-0.09945373982191086,
-0.0598270446062088,
-0.13770435750484467,
0.384036123752594,
0.03928743675351143,
-0.11718858778476715,
-0.3195517659187317,
0.08056633919477463,
-0.7281651496887207,
0.4989316463470459,
0.4148807227611542,
0.10281255096197128,
0.3916366696357727,
-0.3465144634246826,
1.0414570569992065,
-0.47145727276802063,
0.06528199464082718,
-0.6062045097351074,
-0.6593025922775269,
-0.5866190791130066,
-0.3520052134990692,
0.3407350778579712,
0.5546489357948303,
-0.501947820186615,
0.6527091264724731,
-0.039332713931798935,
-0.22996637225151062,
-0.483692467212677,
-0.4809843599796295,
0.47586706280708313,
0.3632674813270569,
0.3246014416217804,
-0.057584136724472046,
-0.7049950361251831,
-0.5731492638587952,
-0.2636517584323883,
-0.4453098475933075,
-0.04202800616621971,
-0.11691227555274963,
0.20974361896514893,
0.08452562242746353,
1.1811070442199707,
-0.3742900490760803,
-0.29736459255218506,
-0.5650804042816162,
0.35242295265197754,
0.17377381026744843,
0.29302480816841125,
0.22815360128879547,
-0.4509426951408386,
-0.5764753222465515,
-0.08684937655925751,
-0.33194565773010254,
-0.4691622257232666,
-0.1150965616106987,
0.27873390913009644,
0.32057929039001465,
0.6639209389686584,
-0.4219362437725067,
0.5897705554962158,
0.5519232153892517,
-0.1936640590429306,
0.7022090554237366,
-0.24038298428058624,
0.24421566724777222,
-1.158674955368042,
0.12945640087127686,
-0.1916668862104416,
-0.2376391440629959,
-0.6476606726646423,
-0.10346689820289612,
-0.06858015805482864,
-0.2436189502477646,
-0.5280886292457581,
0.3777085542678833,
-0.5131144523620605,
-0.1608189344406128,
-0.380124568939209,
0.08099744468927383,
0.09712595492601395,
0.3486107885837555,
0.04676539823412895,
1.1520508527755737,
0.6586290001869202,
-0.449856698513031,
-0.09485092014074326,
0.10009130835533142,
-0.2444310188293457,
0.3598423898220062,
-0.9242684841156006,
0.5401867628097534,
0.18661056458950043,
0.26263800263404846,
-0.8451662659645081,
-0.07576869428157806,
-0.014630540274083614,
-0.6664323806762695,
0.4226897060871124,
0.005253381561487913,
-0.26668909192085266,
-0.2844533622264862,
-0.28553423285484314,
0.7709485292434692,
0.6419579982757568,
-0.15479005873203278,
0.8287033438682556,
0.37494269013404846,
-0.3169291615486145,
-0.599217414855957,
-0.706047534942627,
0.26308444142341614,
-0.12121304869651794,
-0.4946804940700531,
0.5653852224349976,
-0.23411233723163605,
-0.13376644253730774,
-0.068369559943676,
-0.06423157453536987,
-0.09002061933279037,
-0.27717646956443787,
0.20457077026367188,
0.35340628027915955,
-0.018907034769654274,
-0.11003118008375168,
0.03748611733317375,
-0.31858915090560913,
0.015173440799117088,
-0.33534523844718933,
0.5911693572998047,
-0.29997602105140686,
-0.29475513100624084,
-0.48821431398391724,
0.4938496947288513,
0.8267172574996948,
-0.39907965064048767,
0.24530717730522156,
0.5077661871910095,
-0.4357891380786896,
-0.5418084859848022,
-0.5465035438537598,
-0.3889172375202179,
-0.4566567540168762,
0.5139549970626831,
-0.4290439188480377,
-1.0424168109893799,
0.5589777827262878,
0.16590771079063416,
-0.09065418690443039,
0.16621795296669006,
0.6757485866546631,
0.03919371962547302,
1.034224033355713,
0.6099497675895691,
-0.028933735564351082,
0.42748573422431946,
-0.11576687544584274,
0.41482770442962646,
-0.7239392399787903,
-0.12356944382190704,
-0.5499637722969055,
0.07295328378677368,
-0.34212610125541687,
-0.370593398809433,
0.5349404215812683,
0.05789778381586075,
-0.040788475424051285,
0.3927086591720581,
-0.5731350183486938,
0.482116162776947,
0.18339833617210388,
-0.09659949690103531,
0.2028494030237198,
0.21618127822875977,
-0.29697319865226746,
-0.3441983759403229,
-0.8073867559432983,
-0.38579994440078735,
1.0282073020935059,
0.34264159202575684,
1.2688955068588257,
-0.34584611654281616,
0.7582065463066101,
0.4420948326587677,
0.11902811378240585,
-0.9160609245300293,
0.5265957117080688,
0.08517161011695862,
-0.3187571167945862,
-0.1375093162059784,
-0.16102805733680725,
-0.7204785346984863,
-0.24271295964717865,
-0.3420577943325043,
-0.5876197218894958,
-0.1519395112991333,
0.3432095944881439,
-0.5566122531890869,
0.24231214821338654,
-0.5106125473976135,
0.4308643937110901,
0.015477103181183338,
-0.4385765790939331,
-0.31072595715522766,
-0.4933937191963196,
-0.03804648295044899,
0.027061698958277702,
0.3602430820465088,
0.10556262731552124,
0.08586142957210541,
0.6234298348426819,
-0.3646334707736969,
0.7979331016540527,
0.1813812106847763,
-0.1302245706319809,
0.5738614201545715,
0.42415425181388855,
0.6494578123092651,
-0.029222190380096436,
0.008345584385097027,
-0.06922470778226852,
-0.24590109288692474,
0.023381102830171585,
-0.6110367774963379,
0.6046392321586609,
-0.3048880100250244,
-0.48418065905570984,
-0.3736112713813782,
-0.6930902004241943,
-0.16122443974018097,
-0.025216717272996902,
0.4604737162590027,
0.7036191821098328,
-0.3217889070510864,
0.20427356660366058,
0.7333921194076538,
-0.2712292969226837,
0.5495817065238953,
0.24583940207958221,
-0.5146381258964539,
-0.8895170092582703,
0.7000688314437866,
-0.09836221486330032,
0.512801468372345,
0.5069226622581482,
0.1859060674905777,
-0.44633355736732483,
-0.44996851682662964,
-0.3474753201007843,
0.09224636107683182,
-0.5693711638450623,
-0.46512407064437866,
-0.7763212323188782,
-0.2208670973777771,
-0.23226891458034515,
-0.3266559839248657,
-0.6720286011695862,
-0.42147958278656006,
-0.1312130093574524,
-0.20905496180057526,
0.5309459567070007,
0.9295007586479187,
0.07010042667388916,
-0.05355667695403099,
-0.6617069840431213,
0.2057524174451828,
0.15530189871788025,
0.22249342501163483,
-0.091014064848423,
-0.7648443579673767,
-0.23595194518566132,
-0.20325970649719238,
-0.13505831360816956,
-1.0889407396316528,
0.5513029098510742,
0.324757844209671,
0.2275121510028839,
0.06009518727660179,
0.33392903208732605,
0.4896574914455414,
-0.6421768069267273,
0.8052107095718384,
0.3939296305179596,
-1.0757029056549072,
0.8860052824020386,
-0.29459714889526367,
0.38575392961502075,
0.29657796025276184,
-0.15553699433803558,
-0.2961094081401825,
-0.9153972268104553,
-0.4393012225627899,
-1.106260895729065,
0.4474319815635681,
0.505294144153595,
-0.2079262137413025,
-0.40621545910835266,
0.3016614019870758,
0.02935708500444889,
-0.11023910343647003,
-0.7265669107437134,
-0.5149436593055725,
-0.179369255900383,
-0.43922191858291626,
0.4075485169887543,
-0.49583700299263,
0.37474608421325684,
-0.012058057822287083,
0.594720184803009,
-0.14968465268611908,
0.34970444440841675,
0.440502792596817,
-0.013137871399521828,
-0.31223222613334656,
0.7102692127227783,
0.7693241834640503,
0.5006186962127686,
-0.3288951516151428,
0.27588653564453125,
0.36006760597229004,
-0.6624465584754944,
0.25981593132019043,
-0.3393457233905792,
-0.3278881311416626,
0.13697268068790436,
0.27366703748703003,
0.7154990434646606,
0.1474628895521164,
-0.5508342981338501,
0.3860483169555664,
-0.011643771082162857,
-0.3764953911304474,
-0.12467939406633377,
-0.062180303037166595,
-0.07506448775529861,
-0.04645007103681564,
0.4940183460712433,
0.09724556654691696,
0.016421310603618622,
-0.18525832891464233,
0.45815417170524597,
0.24658428132534027,
-0.4423368275165558,
-0.5610042810440063,
0.9852916598320007,
0.13825058937072754,
-0.501833438873291,
0.0972750261425972,
-0.08821612596511841,
-0.46058738231658936,
0.4799838364124298,
0.9712122678756714,
1.4681317806243896,
-0.5131440162658691,
0.09550849348306656,
0.7201241850852966,
0.33981940150260925,
-0.16461880505084991,
0.3631645143032074,
0.008900012820959091,
-0.4371018409729004,
-0.6993328332901001,
-0.5248439908027649,
-0.3197259306907654,
0.05606123059988022,
-0.9917665123939514,
0.3669945001602173,
-0.4152013659477234,
-0.48927903175354004,
-0.3066682815551758,
-0.42467087507247925,
-0.42906898260116577,
0.14050588011741638,
-0.08565140515565872,
0.8117887377738953,
-0.8374549150466919,
1.196148157119751,
0.5845009684562683,
-0.3700445890426636,
-0.8531090617179871,
0.2498248964548111,
-0.12711060047149658,
-0.49210894107818604,
0.6520065069198608,
0.22139674425125122,
-0.813490092754364,
0.3120533227920532,
-0.2873823046684265,
-0.6634756326675415,
1.030234694480896,
0.3700036108493805,
-1.0642582178115845,
0.13526533544063568,
0.04132440686225891,
0.34357091784477234,
-0.7575781345367432,
0.2602810561656952,
0.29095956683158875,
0.27756261825561523,
0.09567298740148544,
-0.9845421314239502,
0.03850647807121277,
-0.08879304677248001,
0.11109209805727005,
0.027173934504389763,
-0.048441752791404724,
0.5102438926696777,
-0.5641708970069885,
-0.4398437738418579,
0.03615877404808998,
0.7441567182540894,
0.3257579505443573,
0.15718530118465424,
0.6275086998939514,
0.4521366357803345,
0.626857578754425,
0.040903378278017044,
0.7924156785011292,
-0.5591179132461548,
0.4894126057624817,
1.1335506439208984,
-0.51485675573349,
1.0856965780258179,
0.5641992092132568,
-0.278018593788147,
0.451225608587265,
0.21925415098667145,
0.4226153492927551,
0.66538405418396,
-0.00347246415913105,
-0.3698368966579437,
-0.32220134139060974,
-0.10582158714532852,
-0.4165361821651459,
0.14212699234485626,
0.43397772312164307,
-0.04645886644721031,
0.009463048540055752,
0.26064935326576233,
-0.09856780618429184,
0.32401415705680847,
-0.07029324769973755,
0.6211047172546387,
0.13889189064502716,
-0.6991655230522156,
0.7732112407684326,
-0.22873933613300323,
0.6995096802711487,
-0.49448853731155396,
-0.11287985742092133,
-0.13559895753860474,
-0.0065489159896969795,
-0.0911611020565033,
-0.7285213470458984,
0.4912489950656891,
0.24251829087734222,
-0.4576193690299988,
-0.2888670563697815,
0.6991785764694214,
-0.689677894115448,
-0.4158026874065399,
0.3238571882247925,
0.5700618624687195,
-0.0844702497124672,
0.0447443462908268,
-0.7783728837966919,
0.47200971841812134,
0.12446939945220947,
-0.28115710616111755,
0.07518233358860016,
0.2507307529449463,
0.024509567767381668,
0.7803863286972046,
0.5772132277488708,
0.020749635994434357,
-0.1648360639810562,
0.4537068009376526,
0.7053322792053223,
-0.780905544757843,
-0.5736986994743347,
-0.867438554763794,
0.4350404143333435,
0.41092318296432495,
-0.11919448524713516,
0.44974252581596375,
0.4220238924026489,
0.5155615210533142,
-0.0637926310300827,
0.7533966302871704,
-0.13982588052749634,
0.4306744933128357,
-0.818040668964386,
0.7301707863807678,
-0.2567111551761627,
0.47644034028053284,
-0.3690430521965027,
-1.1291451454162598,
-0.48160913586616516,
0.8843908905982971,
0.0106012849137187,
0.11906760185956955,
1.1824555397033691,
1.1581120491027832,
0.2716461420059204,
0.12032861262559891,
0.53072589635849,
0.24521112442016602,
0.23211975395679474,
0.4901978671550751,
0.892601490020752,
-0.3789052367210388,
0.716863751411438,
0.05502855032682419,
-0.25455424189567566,
-0.06919128447771072,
-1.12611722946167,
-0.8977175354957581,
-0.6781502962112427,
-0.5924926400184631,
-0.4574451148509979,
0.18954624235630035,
1.2675858736038208,
0.6786196231842041,
-0.9500710964202881,
-0.3041404187679291,
-0.3787238895893097,
-0.12397278100252151,
-0.2989681661128998,
-0.21230652928352356,
0.3766820430755615,
-0.5224176049232483,
-0.5279972553253174,
0.7076862454414368,
0.6575853228569031,
-0.01806737296283245,
-0.187360480427742,
-0.2437276989221573,
-0.052484143525362015,
0.0931183323264122,
0.41329625248908997,
0.16259104013442993,
-1.1039583683013916,
-0.17431329190731049,
0.44723400473594666,
-0.006131628528237343,
0.09817624092102051,
1.044736623764038,
-0.7744426131248474,
0.616511344909668,
0.33248984813690186,
0.3433130383491516,
0.49949097633361816,
-0.16134056448936462,
0.7765692472457886,
-0.7432569265365601,
0.1601163148880005,
0.2798980474472046,
0.2742934226989746,
0.28895264863967896,
-0.1823698878288269,
0.13102421164512634,
-0.08412942290306091,
-0.6918330192565918,
-0.8154085874557495,
0.49476972222328186,
-0.9990127682685852,
-0.0548383854329586,
1.1294593811035156,
-0.11363781988620758,
-0.4346073865890503,
-0.21092233061790466,
-0.4373571276664734,
0.14161375164985657,
-0.5160008668899536,
0.5964161157608032,
0.3290545642375946,
0.03209085017442703,
-0.29541975259780884,
-0.46470361948013306,
0.5367705821990967,
0.6461478471755981,
-0.6478046774864197,
0.4675643742084503,
0.5012802481651306,
0.21823206543922424,
-0.13098706305027008,
0.7207876443862915,
-0.20055051147937775,
0.2804962992668152,
-0.11694414913654327,
0.3034007251262665,
-0.19370737671852112,
-0.5159371495246887,
-0.36862170696258545,
0.0953219011425972,
0.2768735885620117,
-0.06481901556253433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03196v1
|
Okay, Let's Do This! Modeling Event Coreference with Generated Rationales and Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-04-04T04:49:46 | 2024-04-04T04:49:46 |
Abhijnan Nath, Shadi Manafi, Avyakta Chelle, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In NLP, Event Coreference Resolution (ECR) is the task of connecting event
clusters that refer to the same underlying real-life event, usually via neural
systems. In this work, we investigate using abductive free-text rationales
(FTRs) generated by modern autoregressive LLMs as distant supervision of
smaller student models for cross-document coreference (CDCR) of events. We
implement novel rationale-oriented event clustering and knowledge distillation
methods for event coreference scoring that leverage enriched information from
the FTRs for improved CDCR without additional annotation or expensive document
clustering. Our model using coreference specific knowledge distillation
achieves SOTA B3 F1 on the ECB+ and GVC corpora and we establish a new baseline
on the AIDA Phase 1 corpus. Our code can be found at
https://github.com/csu-signal/llama_cdcr
|
[
-0.4996318519115448,
-0.7433211207389832,
0.7935627102851868,
-0.21090297400951385,
-0.3528221845626831,
-0.12739281356334686,
-0.45616111159324646,
-0.49660608172416687,
0.06599005311727524,
0.3077906370162964,
-0.4865347146987915,
-0.5605431199073792,
-0.5387001633644104,
0.24071861803531647,
-0.5261827111244202,
1.1405034065246582,
-0.02089701034128666,
0.05030985176563263,
-0.3724159598350525,
-0.09474814683198929,
-0.12678763270378113,
-0.9573162794113159,
-0.6024348735809326,
-0.5534522533416748,
0.5446239709854126,
0.6052975058555603,
0.1103564128279686,
0.5537997484207153,
0.44897517561912537,
0.22833575308322906,
-0.2445864975452423,
0.10845624655485153,
-0.29480838775634766,
0.0072622536681592464,
-0.4369005560874939,
-0.5604608654975891,
-0.4137130081653595,
0.11705637723207474,
0.12492820620536804,
0.5846367478370667,
-0.08228158950805664,
0.16666577756404877,
0.12598761916160583,
0.5644162893295288,
-0.5758134126663208,
0.12395107746124268,
-0.8284894227981567,
-0.26982957124710083,
-0.0841192752122879,
-0.18361707031726837,
-0.4769538640975952,
-0.2858153283596039,
0.3258186876773834,
-0.5515655875205994,
0.7173322439193726,
0.004609001334756613,
0.6970347166061401,
0.18809279799461365,
-0.29660850763320923,
-0.7148768305778503,
-0.8228931427001953,
0.8184326887130737,
-0.44157201051712036,
0.09963911771774292,
0.31933411955833435,
0.2478199452161789,
0.02220621146261692,
-0.6011664271354675,
-0.771881103515625,
0.06563740968704224,
-0.15397150814533234,
-0.12940815091133118,
-0.2811417281627655,
0.06774085760116577,
0.2987672686576843,
0.23632396757602692,
-0.17862962186336517,
-0.05611450970172882,
-0.4827282726764679,
0.14800435304641724,
0.5069422721862793,
0.1014549508690834,
-0.05477522313594818,
-0.20393472909927368,
-0.27288615703582764,
0.2191537469625473,
-0.6598555445671082,
-0.07016707211732864,
0.06149566173553467,
0.12204978615045547,
0.011634067632257938,
0.6676589250564575,
-0.28121399879455566,
0.3264414072036743,
0.8784013986587524,
-0.3018631935119629,
-0.19693902134895325,
-0.4188758134841919,
-0.10828611254692078,
0.39957794547080994,
0.49690476059913635,
0.5283719301223755,
0.2574772834777832,
-0.46783339977264404,
0.1380605548620224,
0.18450307846069336,
0.03489893302321434,
-0.8325289487838745,
-0.2650253176689148,
0.22114740312099457,
-0.3795520067214966,
-0.13995808362960815,
-0.34752213954925537,
-0.6632107496261597,
-0.2554190158843994,
-0.8517791628837585,
0.10385231673717499,
-0.6512294411659241,
-0.03365710377693176,
-0.15341855585575104,
-0.1463865339756012,
0.24338801205158234,
0.3711525499820709,
-0.6852989196777344,
0.05480674281716347,
0.6910537481307983,
0.5746828317642212,
-0.27080053091049194,
-0.07716766744852066,
-0.24583055078983307,
0.25967341661453247,
0.01304409559816122,
0.9415349364280701,
-0.5324180126190186,
-0.5305530428886414,
-0.2653215527534485,
-0.10226378589868546,
0.03397836536169052,
-0.5453925132751465,
0.8123100399971008,
-0.4421525001525879,
0.05026400834321976,
-0.4391496777534485,
-0.7378324270248413,
-0.2401541918516159,
0.14970944821834564,
-0.40644940733909607,
0.7401679158210754,
-0.2018633931875229,
-0.7552236914634705,
0.49069997668266296,
-0.3695111572742462,
-0.1901017278432846,
-0.02926541306078434,
-0.32984107732772827,
-0.05509936809539795,
0.09390915185213089,
0.27285775542259216,
0.5216078758239746,
-0.38779035210609436,
0.6659670472145081,
-0.2596396803855896,
0.25535598397254944,
0.2343619018793106,
-0.08689869195222855,
0.3865800201892853,
0.055250734090805054,
-0.23418839275836945,
0.3349766135215759,
-1.1187940835952759,
-0.368704229593277,
-0.3257284164428711,
-0.11588725447654724,
-0.7615833282470703,
0.10291335731744766,
-0.21817106008529663,
0.25776028633117676,
0.2933482229709625,
-0.5595263838768005,
0.26382142305374146,
0.03306332230567932,
0.23182928562164307,
0.3386387825012207,
0.2399609237909317,
0.7702294588088989,
-0.2591181993484497,
0.1154501661658287,
0.24072305858135223,
-0.06584364175796509,
-0.09459531307220459,
-0.4914722442626953,
-0.8502104878425598,
-0.3815170228481293,
-0.1524268090724945,
0.4776804745197296,
-0.5425937175750732,
0.6681790351867676,
-0.10008472949266434,
-0.6719912886619568,
-0.08150803297758102,
-0.08784233033657074,
0.1670302301645279,
0.913981020450592,
0.646176815032959,
0.26833924651145935,
-0.9615539908409119,
-0.7375815510749817,
-0.0519142672419548,
-0.2922254204750061,
-0.1757362186908722,
-0.16249620914459229,
0.4555453658103943,
-0.1380460262298584,
1.2228429317474365,
-0.34921351075172424,
-0.6144858598709106,
-0.4058118760585785,
0.308698832988739,
0.27853673696517944,
0.680290699005127,
0.6379426717758179,
-0.5541486144065857,
-0.2687850296497345,
-0.048240065574645996,
-0.692547082901001,
-0.3011420667171478,
-0.126498743891716,
-0.16876302659511566,
0.2784881591796875,
0.47703132033348083,
-0.4270171821117401,
0.544852614402771,
0.2960893213748932,
-0.5047643184661865,
0.7524262070655823,
0.14769290387630463,
0.26214057207107544,
-1.1486232280731201,
0.18465937674045563,
-0.025451503694057465,
-0.040451399981975555,
-0.5646724104881287,
-0.24308930337429047,
-0.02029472216963768,
0.2435457557439804,
-0.14776012301445007,
0.33474236726760864,
-0.38487744331359863,
0.3836354613304138,
-0.543372392654419,
0.3890787661075592,
0.1475599855184555,
0.304426372051239,
0.4686906337738037,
0.42471086978912354,
0.30888667702674866,
-0.7743026614189148,
0.25880521535873413,
0.3900831341743469,
-0.2507287561893463,
0.8443723320960999,
-0.504991888999939,
-0.08714842051267624,
-0.12204684317111969,
0.2719383239746094,
-0.6853419542312622,
0.0703050047159195,
-0.1103859394788742,
-0.33645617961883545,
0.11432565003633499,
-0.29625728726387024,
-0.12229400128126144,
-0.09543982148170471,
0.06059921905398369,
0.4748742878437042,
0.4140682518482208,
-0.7348018884658813,
1.0378280878067017,
0.2881700396537781,
-0.2825120687484741,
-0.45764270424842834,
-0.6468292474746704,
-0.18978209793567657,
-0.3649817109107971,
-0.4787161946296692,
0.36435258388519287,
-0.1188613697886467,
-0.6039248108863831,
0.1754603236913681,
-0.1426895409822464,
-0.17415930330753326,
-0.21048171818256378,
0.46026521921157837,
0.5551729798316956,
-0.17951920628547668,
-0.025632724165916443,
0.28201332688331604,
-0.2164853811264038,
0.1861724555492401,
-0.31982460618019104,
0.24453900754451752,
-0.09079162031412125,
-0.3562556803226471,
-0.36035603284835815,
0.6586998105049133,
0.2929627597332001,
0.15813840925693512,
0.7642763257026672,
0.3766706883907318,
-0.6185223460197449,
-0.08032026141881943,
-1.0020849704742432,
-0.4115202724933624,
-0.35516053438186646,
0.0249953530728817,
-0.5593215823173523,
-1.046328067779541,
0.7053053379058838,
0.07734794169664383,
0.11833928525447845,
0.5383347272872925,
0.7748751640319824,
0.2076316922903061,
0.549997091293335,
0.3836685121059418,
0.12499444931745529,
0.30985671281814575,
-0.1149303987622261,
0.1494765430688858,
-0.963043212890625,
-0.38180866837501526,
-0.7784390449523926,
-0.19720758497714996,
0.020683161914348602,
-0.7428167462348938,
0.14930783212184906,
0.8806960582733154,
0.13247476518154144,
0.39430442452430725,
-0.4378598630428314,
0.7522442936897278,
0.532187283039093,
-0.2271094024181366,
0.7410856485366821,
-0.2441198229789734,
-0.3041231036186218,
-0.16706158220767975,
-0.6169875860214233,
-0.7776292562484741,
0.8815053105354309,
0.07871551811695099,
0.6057226657867432,
-0.19740229845046997,
0.8344122767448425,
-0.001137447776272893,
0.7724169492721558,
-0.6387336254119873,
0.4560014009475708,
-0.02518409863114357,
-0.695629894733429,
0.03941858559846878,
-0.3572181463241577,
-0.4847136437892914,
0.12279513478279114,
-0.06517288088798523,
-0.9973416328430176,
0.6534043550491333,
-0.023645702749490738,
-0.382395476102829,
0.3875480592250824,
-0.47278380393981934,
0.5174998641014099,
0.11612486839294434,
-0.24318958818912506,
-0.39966899156570435,
-0.29926788806915283,
0.4357198476791382,
-0.1491038054227829,
0.38935989141464233,
-0.44792604446411133,
0.11061573773622513,
0.8658384680747986,
-0.2956668436527252,
0.9167431592941284,
0.014216486364603043,
-0.11322370171546936,
0.7846538424491882,
0.1805431991815567,
0.46442386507987976,
0.31787580251693726,
-0.27521780133247375,
0.25966256856918335,
0.21391884982585907,
-0.16222263872623444,
-0.2923547327518463,
0.8830806612968445,
-0.6556270122528076,
-0.5253722071647644,
-0.24411751329898834,
-0.41154804825782776,
0.04227742925286293,
-0.03426630049943924,
0.3380783200263977,
0.4480881989002228,
-0.3981858789920807,
0.09984230995178223,
0.46807000041007996,
0.2353794127702713,
0.5826847553253174,
0.9255783557891846,
-0.08069776743650436,
-0.5833752751350403,
0.4209015369415283,
0.10968601703643799,
0.024678925052285194,
0.4220196008682251,
-0.0018618629546836019,
-0.3188588619232178,
-0.6075440049171448,
-0.38236933946609497,
0.2792556881904602,
-0.9969795942306519,
-0.38140833377838135,
-0.9440572261810303,
0.10164332389831543,
-0.5943625569343567,
-0.600527822971344,
-0.2766370475292206,
-0.7121369242668152,
-0.8323075771331787,
-0.4651961624622345,
0.4819185137748718,
0.5307777523994446,
-0.5387376546859741,
0.18256565928459167,
-1.0162416696548462,
0.22456403076648712,
-0.04144930839538574,
-0.09437552094459534,
-0.027000391855835915,
-0.5803689360618591,
-0.22282588481903076,
-0.23160937428474426,
-0.29674816131591797,
-0.8817949891090393,
0.4828108549118042,
0.23713991045951843,
0.5770886540412903,
0.5898426175117493,
0.471011757850647,
0.6958121657371521,
-0.44754794239997864,
0.7857464551925659,
0.32677581906318665,
-1.0766814947128296,
0.6381047368049622,
-0.20989066362380981,
0.08529612421989441,
0.7883003950119019,
0.6671363711357117,
-0.38608023524284363,
-0.4608290493488312,
-0.7177523970603943,
-0.9144323468208313,
0.5465505123138428,
0.04121679440140724,
-0.400961309671402,
-0.37329182028770447,
0.6647289991378784,
0.33513522148132324,
0.02719661220908165,
-0.49347835779190063,
-0.3191167116165161,
0.11970245093107224,
-0.2882877588272095,
0.005902606528252363,
-0.33844172954559326,
-0.2800593972206116,
-0.09815838187932968,
0.8504118919372559,
-0.2882958650588989,
-0.19519701600074768,
0.6263124942779541,
-0.0331403911113739,
-0.17831267416477203,
0.513952374458313,
0.34319382905960083,
0.6188272833824158,
-0.12391866743564606,
0.34137049317359924,
0.4284457266330719,
-0.26698538661003113,
0.10926176607608795,
0.25297150015830994,
-0.24278880655765533,
0.03177277371287346,
0.2688489854335785,
0.3595820367336273,
0.21264438331127167,
-0.547264039516449,
0.15865665674209595,
-0.234115332365036,
-0.22562529146671295,
-0.3887997269630432,
-0.04804017394781113,
0.22284846007823944,
0.38819512724876404,
0.8205764889717102,
-0.024903221055865288,
0.09476248919963837,
-0.2651119530200958,
0.5863091945648193,
0.08997683227062225,
-0.4486475884914398,
-0.4624144732952118,
0.6758459210395813,
0.5295999050140381,
0.22949135303497314,
0.2680841088294983,
-0.21422718465328217,
-0.50837242603302,
0.5425024032592773,
0.5364086627960205,
0.9210132360458374,
-0.12086842209100723,
-0.11794409900903702,
0.8343783617019653,
0.20549704134464264,
0.04979902505874634,
0.1266697347164154,
-0.15436223149299622,
-0.7384730577468872,
-0.5799809098243713,
-1.0204858779907227,
-0.5564370155334473,
0.003597893053665757,
-0.79426509141922,
0.3484717011451721,
-0.21306787431240082,
-0.2007284313440323,
0.0990162342786789,
-0.056008774787187576,
-0.3652813136577606,
0.13833291828632355,
0.3079478442668915,
0.9478145241737366,
-0.6818414330482483,
0.9740561842918396,
0.6032793521881104,
-0.3646582067012787,
-0.762374997138977,
-0.32650816440582275,
0.08676116168498993,
-0.05570520460605621,
0.6386198401451111,
0.09652649611234665,
0.02706882916390896,
0.06416409462690353,
-0.17866650223731995,
-0.7657691836357117,
1.1710569858551025,
0.029306726530194283,
-0.9260955452919006,
-0.29709091782569885,
0.08653657883405685,
0.44206109642982483,
-0.6707375645637512,
0.20680488646030426,
0.7579812407493591,
0.3509800434112549,
0.1199071928858757,
-0.8205394148826599,
0.11560413986444473,
0.01268455758690834,
-0.3537568151950836,
0.1318177431821823,
-0.27153289318084717,
0.598720133304596,
-0.29077011346817017,
-0.4052773416042328,
0.09366358071565628,
1.0613154172897339,
0.40366750955581665,
0.6641026139259338,
0.40421247482299805,
0.608235776424408,
0.5986039042472839,
-0.29151004552841187,
0.7179632782936096,
-0.47014787793159485,
0.18902981281280518,
1.5560835599899292,
-0.39712730050086975,
0.6742637753486633,
0.7439277768135071,
0.0008634013356640935,
0.4265204966068268,
0.2845909893512726,
0.31224697828292847,
0.2332804799079895,
-0.044759269803762436,
-0.5249561667442322,
-0.3825159966945648,
-0.2789900004863739,
-0.2966364026069641,
0.05812171474099159,
0.6243212223052979,
-0.38363614678382874,
-0.4570383131504059,
0.16517020761966705,
0.02162817493081093,
0.2649998068809509,
-0.43599218130111694,
0.9839105606079102,
0.2452400028705597,
-0.8073413372039795,
0.3529898226261139,
-0.010717383585870266,
0.7322697043418884,
-0.5125781297683716,
0.28835558891296387,
-0.051649060100317,
0.512751042842865,
-0.2120344042778015,
-0.4779966175556183,
0.8933508992195129,
0.2637084126472473,
-0.6280415058135986,
0.029459046199917793,
0.8558747172355652,
-0.648414134979248,
-0.38939446210861206,
0.5239291191101074,
0.43665584921836853,
-0.011121192015707493,
-0.095536969602108,
-0.222615584731102,
-0.1119384616613388,
-0.06096937879920006,
-0.2723315954208374,
0.3523850739002228,
0.787057101726532,
0.0015949313528835773,
0.40813058614730835,
0.7681522965431213,
-0.043438490480184555,
0.26146265864372253,
0.04684726893901825,
0.9255222678184509,
-0.7108430862426758,
-0.2660404443740845,
-0.8531800508499146,
0.17715339362621307,
-0.008548036217689514,
-0.3934553563594818,
0.5917441844940186,
0.6275318264961243,
0.7924367785453796,
-0.08420790731906891,
0.833035409450531,
-0.3582606613636017,
0.6789675951004028,
-0.25410667061805725,
0.47614502906799316,
-0.10136207938194275,
0.0914788693189621,
-0.1921810656785965,
-0.6182075142860413,
-0.20548568665981293,
0.4557192623615265,
-0.5145251750946045,
-0.5218890905380249,
0.6648566126823425,
0.5436685681343079,
0.20314183831214905,
0.3231375217437744,
0.2457803338766098,
-0.0060622780583798885,
0.3984140157699585,
0.5648982524871826,
1.041475772857666,
-0.11536203324794769,
0.6194568276405334,
-0.555891752243042,
-0.4075523912906647,
-0.24609814584255219,
-1.0996884107589722,
-1.0438746213912964,
-0.8487746715545654,
-0.6688064932823181,
-0.3678146004676819,
-0.110663503408432,
1.1333723068237305,
0.406114786863327,
-1.1067816019058228,
0.017000051215291023,
-0.18514546751976013,
0.09243471175432205,
-0.1231812834739685,
-0.2920266389846802,
0.19123627245426178,
-0.4293982684612274,
-0.8573980331420898,
0.3933688998222351,
0.021814759820699692,
0.12800152599811554,
0.06786307692527771,
0.15411563217639923,
-0.3053279221057892,
0.18909448385238647,
0.6843933463096619,
0.05782632902264595,
-0.6616455912590027,
-0.34734800457954407,
-0.14823326468467712,
-0.20218904316425323,
-0.17536871135234833,
1.158284068107605,
-0.7742549777030945,
-0.20488470792770386,
0.5859429836273193,
0.24399718642234802,
0.31081223487854004,
0.21837666630744934,
0.4897032678127289,
-0.6424923539161682,
0.12580785155296326,
0.2293853461742401,
0.4215458929538727,
0.2304317057132721,
-0.39323779940605164,
0.5319523215293884,
0.3449063003063202,
-0.7214895486831665,
-0.6292845606803894,
0.28626081347465515,
-1.3513576984405518,
-0.1618112325668335,
1.1396703720092773,
-0.2959692180156708,
-0.2776877284049988,
-0.4686545729637146,
-0.2984885573387146,
0.4198485314846039,
-0.43331024050712585,
0.8791600465774536,
0.6726024150848389,
-0.3536304533481598,
0.045071616768836975,
0.18358901143074036,
0.5978842377662659,
0.1412336826324463,
-0.7282422780990601,
0.43514904379844666,
0.7694756388664246,
0.3604525327682495,
0.6657631397247314,
0.5494266152381897,
-0.1677134931087494,
0.14978811144828796,
-0.025465091690421104,
0.35886380076408386,
-0.027545003220438957,
-0.3544372618198395,
-0.008806024678051472,
0.4603831470012665,
-0.11183197796344757,
0.24964378774166107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03192v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03192v2
|
Do Large Language Models Rank Fairly? An Empirical Study on the Fairness of LLMs as Rankers
| 2024-04-04T04:23:19 | 2024-06-25T20:54:16 |
Yuan Wang, Xuyang Wu, Hsin-Tai Wu, Zhiqiang Tao, Yi Fang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) in information retrieval has
raised a critical reevaluation of fairness in the text-ranking models. LLMs,
such as GPT models and Llama2, have shown effectiveness in natural language
understanding tasks, and prior works (e.g., RankGPT) have also demonstrated
that the LLMs exhibit better performance than the traditional ranking models in
the ranking task. However, their fairness remains largely unexplored. This
paper presents an empirical study evaluating these LLMs using the TREC Fair
Ranking dataset, focusing on the representation of binary protected attributes
such as gender and geographic location, which are historically underrepresented
in search outcomes. Our analysis delves into how these LLMs handle queries and
documents related to these attributes, aiming to uncover biases in their
ranking algorithms. We assess fairness from both user and content perspectives,
contributing an empirical benchmark for evaluating LLMs as the fair ranker.
|
[
-0.20576608180999756,
-0.4068755507469177,
1.0440845489501953,
0.020541055127978325,
0.03837006166577339,
0.2505735456943512,
-0.1626172512769699,
-0.7052750587463379,
-0.1751410961151123,
0.43662795424461365,
-0.1713515669107437,
-0.8076395392417908,
-0.9633868336677551,
0.14621824026107788,
-0.3920544683933258,
0.7504557371139526,
0.26259705424308777,
0.14990028738975525,
-0.22427566349506378,
-0.23040546476840973,
-0.5740348100662231,
-0.9513411521911621,
-0.6333047747612,
-0.3674623668193817,
0.38300642371177673,
0.004742898046970367,
0.9310338497161865,
0.656060516834259,
0.6996027231216431,
0.33960121870040894,
-0.37350934743881226,
-0.12243394553661346,
-0.6598145961761475,
0.11300991475582123,
-0.3503141701221466,
-0.77928227186203,
-0.3586517870426178,
0.3296160399913788,
0.8202522993087769,
0.9382617473602295,
-0.2712147831916809,
0.05366494134068489,
0.17296230792999268,
0.5320508480072021,
-0.5546497702598572,
-0.01658443547785282,
-0.8748113512992859,
0.06719397008419037,
-0.44670549035072327,
0.021133726462721825,
-0.620193362236023,
-0.8746556043624878,
-0.019754786044359207,
-0.1942296177148819,
0.5058610439300537,
0.4087792634963989,
0.6748689413070679,
0.1375102400779724,
-0.7625446319580078,
-0.23889093101024628,
-0.4059462249279022,
0.97303307056427,
-0.6292511820793152,
0.3381192684173584,
0.41102269291877747,
0.5386958122253418,
-0.22869639098644257,
-0.5215100049972534,
-0.2898253798484802,
-0.19021017849445343,
-0.2598804235458374,
-0.2911156117916107,
-0.19450274109840393,
0.028802447021007538,
0.3791351020336151,
0.42773932218551636,
-0.636073887348175,
0.5685307383537292,
-0.21026243269443512,
-0.2119753211736679,
0.5421825051307678,
0.04110155627131462,
0.28736060857772827,
-0.36188071966171265,
-0.22535623610019684,
0.16691040992736816,
-0.8246380090713501,
0.19822236895561218,
0.6584072709083557,
0.4541472792625427,
-0.043835852295160294,
0.8676596283912659,
-0.0718909427523613,
0.4882630705833435,
-0.1801222413778305,
0.0005029083113186061,
0.2598191797733307,
-0.1761932224035263,
-0.028398970142006874,
0.20543913543224335,
0.6609699726104736,
0.3009398579597473,
0.3794057369232178,
-0.49484983086586,
-0.5858697295188904,
-0.1730901449918747,
0.17946898937225342,
-0.6239317655563354,
0.15686537325382233,
-0.06870005279779434,
-0.7536160349845886,
-0.20899996161460876,
0.24203698337078094,
-0.47520333528518677,
-0.5172871947288513,
-0.12836238741874695,
0.284999817609787,
0.1874273121356964,
-0.2057034820318222,
-0.07033196091651917,
-0.03245972841978073,
0.2367180734872818,
0.2394295632839203,
-0.951094388961792,
0.5573203563690186,
0.9925798177719116,
0.8023781776428223,
-0.3419109582901001,
-0.09779138118028641,
-0.5632849931716919,
0.01223764568567276,
-0.22825415432453156,
0.7271517515182495,
-0.6880072951316833,
-0.3743056058883667,
0.0680861622095108,
-0.08542966097593307,
0.03471352532505989,
-0.8389899730682373,
0.5699565410614014,
-0.8320171236991882,
0.18524667620658875,
-0.5873499512672424,
-0.3349037766456604,
-0.01901591382920742,
0.11125943064689636,
-0.6712590456008911,
1.0219666957855225,
-0.007966640405356884,
-0.7952866554260254,
0.44367218017578125,
-0.6125370860099792,
-0.2642734944820404,
-0.14900600910186768,
-0.2265627682209015,
-0.10755417495965958,
0.168512225151062,
0.17888209223747253,
0.28971582651138306,
-0.40410181879997253,
0.4483957588672638,
-0.4038441479206085,
-0.6276960372924805,
0.5095452070236206,
-0.536017119884491,
0.6629747748374939,
0.25380462408065796,
-0.4462953805923462,
-0.2673693597316742,
-0.21661798655986786,
-0.0037538036704063416,
0.14036987721920013,
-0.3579173982143402,
-0.39757171273231506,
-0.005326633807271719,
-0.14523398876190186,
0.24048495292663574,
0.31874147057533264,
-0.481772780418396,
0.07385243475437164,
-0.2590276896953583,
0.27727529406547546,
1.0491960048675537,
-0.43368303775787354,
0.7087520360946655,
-0.2153582125902176,
0.39951398968696594,
-0.22331807017326355,
-0.009377988055348396,
0.4958183169364929,
-0.49000850319862366,
-0.46684572100639343,
-0.13744010031223297,
0.6915932893753052,
0.32875826954841614,
-0.44499778747558594,
0.14106173813343048,
-0.5585993528366089,
-0.12417005002498627,
-0.6921606659889221,
0.07878539711236954,
0.3757536709308624,
0.201679989695549,
0.1060391515493393,
-0.23167948424816132,
-0.05211847648024559,
-1.161407709121704,
-0.33577245473861694,
-0.1464616358280182,
-0.39718472957611084,
0.5615723133087158,
0.4044925570487976,
0.10571528971195221,
0.9273722171783447,
-0.3217102289199829,
-0.023336177691817284,
-0.18248490989208221,
0.2705012857913971,
0.292255163192749,
0.1824355274438858,
0.6940685510635376,
-1.0139309167861938,
-0.0844864621758461,
-0.2576080858707428,
-0.8049423098564148,
-0.4444558322429657,
0.5671854019165039,
-0.3157477378845215,
0.318586140871048,
0.16683058440685272,
-0.25118550658226013,
0.38119637966156006,
0.5631137490272522,
-0.5189489126205444,
0.210691899061203,
0.010732118971645832,
0.6218922734260559,
-0.5715029239654541,
0.11683580279350281,
-0.10943603515625,
-0.6903706789016724,
-0.11645034700632095,
0.12352778017520905,
-0.05532723665237427,
0.027722574770450592,
-0.4957151710987091,
0.5187276005744934,
-0.27650824189186096,
-0.7419731020927429,
-0.24884940683841705,
0.2864474058151245,
-0.2118227630853653,
0.20330527424812317,
0.04072020575404167,
0.8823642134666443,
0.1810000091791153,
-0.4502336084842682,
-0.09617947787046432,
-0.0029709977097809315,
-0.2789584696292877,
0.6473168134689331,
-0.6300716400146484,
0.3046620786190033,
-0.28949040174484253,
0.1388688087463379,
-0.8856697678565979,
0.11453243345022202,
-0.09386426210403442,
-0.39659130573272705,
0.10484080761671066,
-0.4131329655647278,
-0.7930675745010376,
-0.1627003401517868,
-0.3773229122161865,
0.7229294776916504,
0.3317831754684448,
-0.6034828424453735,
0.29450368881225586,
0.6877416968345642,
-0.2926340401172638,
-0.798110842704773,
-0.8654389381408691,
0.14885404706001282,
-0.1633240431547165,
-0.5444204807281494,
0.3394235372543335,
-0.024216949939727783,
-0.5034618377685547,
0.11022764444351196,
-0.0776902586221695,
-0.06980479508638382,
0.2725016474723816,
0.26778557896614075,
0.12082887440919876,
-0.1663116216659546,
-0.007562601938843727,
-0.21972714364528656,
-0.12939637899398804,
-0.15001684427261353,
0.10604824870824814,
0.6500776410102844,
-0.23676790297031403,
-0.6283254027366638,
-0.06407301872968674,
0.20312677323818207,
0.27225762605667114,
-0.25997626781463623,
0.8447035551071167,
0.20793364942073822,
-0.526645302772522,
0.0554378367960453,
-0.7571473717689514,
-0.06644260138273239,
-0.47105833888053894,
0.1721053570508957,
-0.1772889643907547,
-1.119758129119873,
0.593320906162262,
0.23242127895355225,
0.08948731422424316,
0.626514196395874,
0.2930111289024353,
-0.1358378380537033,
1.0873820781707764,
0.6262231469154358,
-0.20546627044677734,
0.25134044885635376,
0.09158182144165039,
0.24283353984355927,
-0.5649116635322571,
-0.476115882396698,
-0.9847865104675293,
-0.7376927733421326,
-1.0612486600875854,
-0.3173511326313019,
0.22082771360874176,
-0.027905195951461792,
-0.42128637433052063,
-0.15789735317230225,
-0.35379451513290405,
0.6269164085388184,
0.5895296335220337,
0.09126731753349304,
0.5198652148246765,
0.1643783152103424,
-0.12265636771917343,
-0.35806238651275635,
-0.403006374835968,
-0.7820845246315002,
1.1417778730392456,
0.4997827410697937,
0.7817717790603638,
0.5461560487747192,
0.5279815793037415,
0.7688429951667786,
0.35136064887046814,
-0.477554589509964,
0.5263931155204773,
-0.4672092795372009,
-0.685416042804718,
-0.176902636885643,
-0.7414964437484741,
-0.9731569886207581,
0.4020114541053772,
-0.17132486402988434,
-0.8432062268257141,
0.3171210289001465,
-0.2825464606285095,
0.11082116514444351,
0.4031035006046295,
-0.5263869762420654,
0.6872449517250061,
-0.44415608048439026,
-0.29961296916007996,
-0.2886885404586792,
-0.43569332361221313,
0.4250132441520691,
-0.06590966135263443,
0.35110387206077576,
-0.329740047454834,
-0.059614602476358414,
0.7803813815116882,
-0.12450091540813446,
0.3599740266799927,
-0.2671714425086975,
-0.029892373830080032,
-0.12875822186470032,
0.2635733187198639,
0.2935616374015808,
0.08043200522661209,
-0.6678894758224487,
0.5269261002540588,
-0.17837540805339813,
-0.5454552173614502,
-0.41802719235420227,
0.9416849613189697,
-0.5944983959197998,
-0.6503816843032837,
-0.6514934301376343,
-0.3213292062282562,
0.017420290037989616,
0.22436505556106567,
-0.046104177832603455,
0.22868947684764862,
0.0024426858872175217,
0.3407219648361206,
0.8241342306137085,
-0.4902912974357605,
0.2480456680059433,
0.6489702463150024,
-0.21438772976398468,
0.00849099736660719,
0.5907936692237854,
0.1952810287475586,
0.08077774196863174,
0.5557872653007507,
0.021544288843870163,
-0.6535423994064331,
-0.6444719433784485,
0.023915013298392296,
0.2151784896850586,
-0.7097665667533875,
-0.18205907940864563,
-0.6255977153778076,
-0.30592700839042664,
-0.33624881505966187,
0.00283217104151845,
-0.3305668532848358,
-0.2791479825973511,
0.10991346091032028,
-0.1795298308134079,
0.03801923245191574,
1.0958296060562134,
0.09576106071472168,
0.27682551741600037,
-0.2501411437988281,
0.4646502733230591,
0.2382465898990631,
0.6177696585655212,
-0.0907614454627037,
-0.5496048331260681,
0.0912403091788292,
-0.024768894538283348,
-0.22211210429668427,
-0.4839961528778076,
0.076471246778965,
-0.3424973487854004,
0.9139716029167175,
-0.047265954315662384,
-0.057124678045511246,
0.24014848470687866,
-0.4726492464542389,
0.8408681154251099,
-0.1675727665424347,
-0.7903353571891785,
0.28141170740127563,
-0.08502212166786194,
0.06481094658374786,
0.6275876760482788,
0.24004575610160828,
-0.4592592120170593,
-0.6043858528137207,
-0.18012602627277374,
-0.7486938834190369,
0.808003306388855,
0.35708317160606384,
0.08581668138504028,
0.06834425032138824,
0.4455186128616333,
0.23589883744716644,
0.4252643287181854,
-1.2509524822235107,
-0.34356188774108887,
0.09011876583099365,
-0.35335811972618103,
0.03157489001750946,
-0.5388257503509521,
0.11326714605093002,
0.08393889665603638,
0.40475529432296753,
0.19860398769378662,
0.4267674684524536,
-0.10404769331216812,
-0.4434966444969177,
0.22374992072582245,
0.5248416662216187,
0.234140083193779,
0.6925926208496094,
-0.31595221161842346,
0.36434170603752136,
0.1637737900018692,
-0.40682461857795715,
0.17706741392612457,
0.21575337648391724,
-0.22943328320980072,
-0.10573559254407883,
0.25921231508255005,
0.44205889105796814,
0.20133434236049652,
-0.48534661531448364,
0.5769583582878113,
-0.3874647915363312,
0.08113519847393036,
0.16846859455108643,
0.052486419677734375,
-0.034143947064876556,
0.4090943932533264,
0.553368330001831,
-0.21654611825942993,
0.48631712794303894,
-0.4624256491661072,
-0.055673498660326004,
0.6980928182601929,
-0.12822362780570984,
-0.01200681272894144,
0.8881229162216187,
0.23765534162521362,
-0.16741803288459778,
0.7384703755378723,
-0.0798669084906578,
-0.6269098520278931,
0.5572869777679443,
0.3225363790988922,
0.5806793570518494,
0.06816037744283676,
0.06318269670009613,
0.005454021506011486,
0.6807970404624939,
-0.23540185391902924,
0.11055959761142731,
0.007473553530871868,
-0.4342080354690552,
-0.03593382239341736,
-0.748643696308136,
-0.2783108055591583,
-0.09530068933963776,
-0.300916463136673,
0.09605755656957626,
-0.2450634092092514,
-0.3977702260017395,
-0.2256791889667511,
0.24024559557437897,
-1.1387690305709839,
0.052230097353458405,
0.334816575050354,
0.8042012453079224,
-0.5777366161346436,
0.445390522480011,
0.4495614767074585,
-0.21976202726364136,
-0.48461470007896423,
0.12588299810886383,
-0.03642069920897484,
-0.8515371084213257,
0.7835191488265991,
0.29541295766830444,
-0.2083834856748581,
-0.22989028692245483,
-0.45048457384109497,
-0.71366947889328,
1.0576953887939453,
0.9106755256652832,
-0.5190652012825012,
-0.04038780555129051,
0.7580506801605225,
0.4164663851261139,
-0.02517435885965824,
0.6550297737121582,
0.3842388093471527,
0.48233652114868164,
-0.2961738407611847,
-1.1510220766067505,
0.058302853256464005,
0.05018442124128342,
0.12790197134017944,
-0.06954209506511688,
-0.5710550546646118,
0.7032002806663513,
-0.0897008404135704,
-0.2048332691192627,
0.06939766556024551,
0.3757794201374054,
0.29203274846076965,
0.5279734134674072,
0.5570335984230042,
0.37274882197380066,
1.0135685205459595,
-0.42774567008018494,
1.2525275945663452,
0.1632477194070816,
0.43154218792915344,
0.839363157749176,
-0.3922973573207855,
0.7891359925270081,
0.19360500574111938,
-0.3723827302455902,
0.39278897643089294,
0.7232720851898193,
0.19180510938167572,
0.6994323134422302,
0.2741442620754242,
-0.18873342871665955,
-0.26784464716911316,
-0.38822802901268005,
-0.44329357147216797,
0.35999059677124023,
-0.1153501495718956,
-0.5123968124389648,
-0.22610598802566528,
-0.34408047795295715,
-0.18153706192970276,
0.23954470455646515,
-0.45054686069488525,
0.6574538350105286,
0.22309759259223938,
-0.32814085483551025,
0.060309067368507385,
0.35497042536735535,
0.9873472452163696,
-0.47520655393600464,
0.04797666519880295,
-0.5540070533752441,
-0.19696833193302155,
-0.1898767203092575,
-1.3385199308395386,
-0.05215064436197281,
0.342018723487854,
-0.4122905433177948,
-0.2794911861419678,
0.6219160556793213,
-0.2091163843870163,
-0.5460438132286072,
0.36625924706459045,
0.4886619448661804,
0.3505508601665497,
-0.07988537847995758,
-0.5122846364974976,
0.06209897622466087,
-0.2991456389427185,
-0.24598318338394165,
0.43997839093208313,
0.4634239375591278,
-0.2812809944152832,
0.8186797499656677,
0.5359663367271423,
-0.09537352621555328,
-0.023825662210583687,
0.2732654809951782,
0.4128957688808441,
-0.7249326109886169,
-0.48062101006507874,
-0.9238348603248596,
0.16624218225479126,
-0.13864301145076752,
0.14545458555221558,
0.6113336682319641,
0.7733561992645264,
0.7407324910163879,
0.3837617039680481,
0.5215539932250977,
0.20153561234474182,
0.5087425112724304,
-0.664693295955658,
1.0086209774017334,
-0.5990369915962219,
0.5892899036407471,
-0.07574567198753357,
-1.1268633604049683,
-0.05744718387722969,
0.35930177569389343,
-0.5176325440406799,
0.5481273531913757,
0.3156639337539673,
0.688043475151062,
-0.2599068880081177,
-0.22312651574611664,
0.2853596806526184,
0.1547641009092331,
0.4486158788204193,
0.44011786580085754,
0.9141374826431274,
-0.1708533763885498,
0.3865931034088135,
0.12630999088287354,
0.08126042783260345,
-0.09137681871652603,
-0.9739307165145874,
-0.7177785038948059,
-0.02996850572526455,
0.06946320086717606,
-0.14630380272865295,
0.3555119037628174,
0.8188766241073608,
0.5798027515411377,
-0.6200353503227234,
-0.17365939915180206,
0.5144324898719788,
0.7003102898597717,
0.2623414993286133,
-0.2560602128505707,
0.3027557134628296,
0.03675594553351402,
-0.957512617111206,
0.06229314208030701,
0.05939517915248871,
-0.06189938262104988,
-0.11657608300447464,
-0.18483860790729523,
0.034979138523340225,
-0.2613600194454193,
0.5412740111351013,
-0.138713538646698,
-0.6675202250480652,
-0.29029524326324463,
-0.11738409101963043,
-0.6061754822731018,
0.11414074897766113,
0.6754740476608276,
-0.9041866064071655,
0.16334418952465057,
0.34598106145858765,
0.6288396120071411,
0.2963479459285736,
0.08448274433612823,
0.5864707231521606,
-0.6922914981842041,
-0.06309576332569122,
0.13710609078407288,
0.4277810752391815,
0.6107124090194702,
-0.42478322982788086,
0.5962604284286499,
0.09112435579299927,
-0.6916331648826599,
-1.0597931146621704,
-0.16733276844024658,
-0.8513264656066895,
-0.17409364879131317,
1.1964738368988037,
0.2461402267217636,
0.06220608204603195,
0.009343888610601425,
-0.04794745892286301,
0.09622339904308319,
-0.5465421080589294,
0.7845630645751953,
0.6261828541755676,
0.21800337731838226,
0.03691580519080162,
-0.9852791428565979,
0.07966632395982742,
0.3294961154460907,
-0.7224469184875488,
-0.04317533224821091,
0.4253082871437073,
0.4810003340244293,
-0.3519211411476135,
0.5700593590736389,
-0.34803831577301025,
0.08871045708656311,
-0.7051709890365601,
-0.13107316195964813,
0.10466034710407257,
-0.013608798384666443,
-0.3279746174812317,
0.19571718573570251,
0.5183508992195129,
0.04277822747826576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03189v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03189v2
|
The Probabilities Also Matter: A More Faithful Metric for Faithfulness of Free-Text Explanations in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T04:20:04 | 2024-06-07T11:54:44 |
Noah Y. Siegel, Oana-Maria Camburu, Nicolas Heess, Maria Perez-Ortiz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In order to oversee advanced AI systems, it is important to understand their
underlying decision-making process. When prompted, large language models (LLMs)
can provide natural language explanations or reasoning traces that sound
plausible and receive high ratings from human annotators. However, it is
unclear to what extent these explanations are faithful, i.e., truly capture the
factors responsible for the model's predictions. In this work, we introduce
Correlational Explanatory Faithfulness (CEF), a metric that can be used in
faithfulness tests based on input interventions. Previous metrics used in such
tests take into account only binary changes in the predictions. Our metric
accounts for the total shift in the model's predicted label distribution, more
accurately reflecting the explanations' faithfulness. We then introduce the
Correlational Counterfactual Test (CCT) by instantiating CEF on the
Counterfactual Test (CT) from Atanasova et al. (2023). We evaluate the
faithfulness of free-text explanations generated by few-shot-prompted LLMs from
the Llama2 family on three NLP tasks. We find that our metric measures aspects
of faithfulness which the CT misses.
|
[
-0.12334992736577988,
-1.0151519775390625,
0.9572299122810364,
0.1707266867160797,
-0.4139728248119354,
-0.5241761803627014,
-0.1418929249048233,
-0.35455578565597534,
0.11700332164764404,
0.2860047519207001,
-0.5731104016304016,
-0.30308690667152405,
-0.6611924767494202,
-0.06396223604679108,
-0.4587370455265045,
1.334213376045227,
-0.3212236762046814,
0.21452097594738007,
-0.5299386978149414,
-0.06056469678878784,
-0.41050443053245544,
-0.29697245359420776,
-0.4709281921386719,
-0.5740476846694946,
0.7822293639183044,
0.18179599940776825,
1.1956325769424438,
0.6277968287467957,
0.768324613571167,
0.15304963290691376,
0.10100384801626205,
0.1333942711353302,
-0.3183947205543518,
0.037164829671382904,
-0.4103735387325287,
-0.7860792875289917,
-0.2733563780784607,
0.09233561903238297,
0.520054042339325,
0.6129306554794312,
-0.0017180134309455752,
0.04341466352343559,
0.2845163941383362,
0.5466089844703674,
-0.522181510925293,
0.18671265244483948,
-0.7666078209877014,
-0.043107178062200546,
-0.14744630455970764,
-0.264423131942749,
-0.44913774728775024,
-0.32187414169311523,
0.029094554483890533,
-0.686797559261322,
0.39852333068847656,
-0.020391268655657768,
0.8308517932891846,
0.3704114854335785,
-0.2593948543071747,
-0.24757014214992523,
-0.8298179507255554,
0.9596761465072632,
-0.6225135922431946,
0.2820299565792084,
0.7785763144493103,
0.024028928950428963,
-0.5141464471817017,
-0.35582393407821655,
-0.5842292904853821,
-0.43220239877700806,
-0.06979965418577194,
0.211575448513031,
-0.058008112013339996,
-0.021167073398828506,
-0.06121068820357323,
0.2813461422920227,
-0.6581991314888,
-0.008982459083199501,
0.18358682096004486,
-0.3639795482158661,
0.6342317461967468,
0.14198914170265198,
0.04570457711815834,
0.42756256461143494,
-0.2714597284793854,
-0.3873109221458435,
-0.8089119791984558,
-0.028737341985106468,
0.387471467256546,
-0.04967522621154785,
-0.40406137704849243,
0.6971482634544373,
0.20795691013336182,
0.6261276006698608,
-0.012703956104815006,
-0.19220134615898132,
-0.0824122205376625,
-0.7326431274414062,
-0.12308911979198456,
-0.0870712399482727,
0.9078086018562317,
0.19620463252067566,
0.4553065598011017,
-0.22732508182525635,
0.04924744367599487,
0.18434132635593414,
0.02669483982026577,
-0.6382314562797546,
-0.21721278131008148,
0.3484472930431366,
-0.5049620866775513,
-0.3518475592136383,
0.06650751084089279,
-0.45807376503944397,
-0.1679438203573227,
-0.198978990316391,
0.3490835428237915,
-0.6520140767097473,
-0.07297191023826599,
-0.03993816673755646,
-0.1303362399339676,
0.28586095571517944,
0.38108062744140625,
-0.7915812730789185,
-0.08304812759160995,
0.9251224994659424,
0.7017594575881958,
-0.1501302272081375,
-0.4313558340072632,
-0.693965494632721,
0.14604632556438446,
-0.7085005640983582,
0.7041206359863281,
-0.5955599546432495,
-0.2876347005367279,
0.06816399097442627,
-0.06150764971971512,
0.07026688009500504,
-0.1203436478972435,
0.6378395557403564,
-0.570500910282135,
-0.007394384127110243,
-0.46057358384132385,
-0.6305971741676331,
-0.27065473794937134,
0.25305044651031494,
-0.5027311444282532,
0.6508603096008301,
-0.20517922937870026,
-0.8254032135009766,
0.5541454553604126,
-0.1850665956735611,
-0.20761458575725555,
-0.15918663144111633,
-0.14287227392196655,
-0.6702088713645935,
0.2441374659538269,
0.03188885375857353,
0.3096437454223633,
-0.18769077956676483,
0.5854323506355286,
-0.7678607106208801,
-0.3564983904361725,
0.9849702715873718,
-0.8570572137832642,
0.6903190016746521,
-0.13029611110687256,
-0.27891647815704346,
-0.20562157034873962,
-0.5138833522796631,
-0.2026139199733734,
0.11358518898487091,
-0.1126006543636322,
-0.30542629957199097,
0.3665533661842346,
-0.21084672212600708,
-0.12023679167032242,
0.290485143661499,
-0.4635530114173889,
-0.1113213300704956,
-0.37310826778411865,
-0.24182619154453278,
0.6432021856307983,
0.09830991923809052,
0.338483065366745,
-0.5471009612083435,
0.2915557026863098,
0.11293962597846985,
0.25237253308296204,
-0.12585340440273285,
-0.8830984234809875,
-0.49919381737709045,
-0.22224152088165283,
0.20131874084472656,
0.47541892528533936,
-0.49479320645332336,
0.20004205405712128,
-0.14137598872184753,
-0.5062893629074097,
-0.3301221430301666,
0.21915613114833832,
0.7070648074150085,
0.23909421265125275,
0.25017234683036804,
-0.16323421895503998,
-0.3989378809928894,
-0.9488227963447571,
-0.6890116930007935,
-0.6087772846221924,
0.003292241133749485,
0.0691475197672844,
0.6328169703483582,
0.010299734771251678,
1.0622388124465942,
-0.1577480286359787,
-0.3557160496711731,
-0.06761136651039124,
0.3409298062324524,
0.3114893436431885,
0.242955282330513,
0.5584514737129211,
-0.728911817073822,
-0.23922565579414368,
-0.24613164365291595,
-0.7087435126304626,
-0.10792171955108643,
-0.319815456867218,
0.08073773980140686,
0.20614440739154816,
0.33212780952453613,
-0.5384455919265747,
0.4963085651397705,
0.8514723777770996,
-0.34244784712791443,
0.6060179471969604,
-0.4105845093727112,
0.05883407220244408,
-0.6869382858276367,
-0.0973995178937912,
0.01942981220781803,
-0.17209672927856445,
-0.3774319589138031,
0.26159992814064026,
-0.08240585029125214,
0.5890331864356995,
-0.3624858260154724,
0.4771377146244049,
-0.13695257902145386,
-0.05079328268766403,
-0.08781031519174576,
0.2505258321762085,
-0.06411490589380264,
0.2497010976076126,
0.029073212295770645,
0.749270498752594,
0.16475723683834076,
-0.5349113345146179,
-0.015051042661070824,
0.30082908272743225,
-0.10102304071187973,
0.2978383004665375,
-0.6888661980628967,
0.04835979640483856,
-0.07538032531738281,
0.3544897139072418,
-1.2528212070465088,
-0.28588181734085083,
-0.00930001586675644,
-0.7208954691886902,
-0.17067018151283264,
0.00774425407871604,
-0.6300204992294312,
0.01257238443940878,
-0.32742878794670105,
0.19081927835941315,
0.3605012595653534,
-0.3961604833602905,
0.4189544916152954,
-0.10657809674739838,
0.2396514117717743,
-0.6642610430717468,
-0.9786076545715332,
-0.10878277570009232,
0.01760042831301689,
-0.47479888796806335,
0.30555129051208496,
-0.24987781047821045,
-0.5607590079307556,
-0.10099014639854431,
0.05494574457406998,
-0.10266184061765671,
0.3277207314968109,
0.4202488660812378,
0.5385022759437561,
-0.16789239645004272,
0.11146297305822372,
-0.07544095814228058,
-0.12900801002979279,
0.33716100454330444,
-0.10312804579734802,
0.35562506318092346,
-0.0885125920176506,
-0.6090235710144043,
-0.4873448312282562,
0.14678163826465607,
0.3474389612674713,
-0.11681720614433289,
1.1574736833572388,
0.7886584997177124,
-0.13536939024925232,
0.13778166472911835,
-0.45500877499580383,
-0.29019153118133545,
-0.36814072728157043,
0.2755656838417053,
-0.3601396977901459,
-0.6559998393058777,
0.6582337617874146,
0.5629979968070984,
0.3175487518310547,
0.5575600862503052,
0.5480495691299438,
-0.1054312214255333,
1.1767163276672363,
0.3249826431274414,
0.1341293901205063,
0.28315049409866333,
0.19618822634220123,
0.40309780836105347,
-0.5489506721496582,
-0.19269558787345886,
-0.5367273688316345,
0.06468262523412704,
-0.7538254857063293,
-0.49119094014167786,
0.24230536818504333,
0.2588973641395569,
-0.11298171430826187,
0.19061101973056793,
-0.04438639432191849,
0.4178059995174408,
0.5192831158638,
0.15522034466266632,
0.4502566158771515,
0.006508600898087025,
-0.0372702032327652,
-0.17614296078681946,
-0.3132286071777344,
-0.5540446043014526,
1.2219223976135254,
0.34871622920036316,
0.658510148525238,
0.31121909618377686,
0.6705552339553833,
0.08322124928236008,
0.5450132489204407,
-0.6214947700500488,
0.4110341966152191,
-0.3135702610015869,
-0.7347874045372009,
-0.3123522400856018,
-0.25680801272392273,
-0.9004599452018738,
0.0668133944272995,
-0.3701667785644531,
-0.6941152811050415,
0.10634472966194153,
0.4193946123123169,
-0.33638814091682434,
0.20875833928585052,
-0.23251228034496307,
0.38643208146095276,
-0.16620951890945435,
-0.553741455078125,
-0.4437958598136902,
-0.4085611402988434,
0.5160797238349915,
-0.3729929029941559,
0.344768762588501,
-0.04872652888298035,
-0.14992958307266235,
0.6943035125732422,
-0.21963436901569366,
0.8275622725486755,
0.033854782581329346,
-0.2845746576786041,
0.28582680225372314,
0.5326148271560669,
0.6995394229888916,
0.3355623781681061,
-0.2804282307624817,
0.4278154969215393,
-0.026141487061977386,
-0.17838461697101593,
-0.6100261211395264,
0.5307992100715637,
-0.737932562828064,
-0.6616942286491394,
-0.20067836344242096,
-0.5656087398529053,
-0.20612043142318726,
-0.21012544631958008,
0.302076518535614,
0.28413647413253784,
-0.4513742923736572,
0.40673956274986267,
0.9795211553573608,
-0.34338077902793884,
0.37519747018814087,
0.564362108707428,
-0.29562604427337646,
-0.32179901003837585,
0.6684095859527588,
-0.09808617830276489,
0.37573981285095215,
0.5735810399055481,
0.5075593590736389,
-0.3324267566204071,
-0.5320217609405518,
-0.38017308712005615,
0.2698425054550171,
-0.5683462619781494,
-0.09292391687631607,
-0.48060980439186096,
0.07564952969551086,
-0.1964813470840454,
-0.29187726974487305,
-0.278834730386734,
-0.2729301154613495,
-0.4750302731990814,
-0.01938909851014614,
0.4142121970653534,
0.5758252143859863,
-0.21914666891098022,
0.30437755584716797,
-0.7240856885910034,
0.4909648299217224,
0.368845134973526,
0.22060224413871765,
0.04728902131319046,
-0.76393061876297,
-0.0043274289928376675,
0.46659672260284424,
-0.19026611745357513,
-1.0999786853790283,
0.25167185068130493,
0.33332088589668274,
0.4350231885910034,
0.6502783298492432,
-0.190360888838768,
0.673951268196106,
-0.2355712503194809,
1.0011929273605347,
0.33438536524772644,
-0.7538074851036072,
0.42004281282424927,
-0.5381456017494202,
0.13203029334545135,
0.5392401814460754,
0.262973427772522,
-0.27056968212127686,
-0.7550199627876282,
-0.6688337922096252,
-0.43087586760520935,
0.5687947273254395,
0.22862564027309418,
0.12918294966220856,
-0.14305229485034943,
0.3897691071033478,
0.3092496693134308,
-0.13512252271175385,
-0.7884190678596497,
-0.29037588834762573,
-0.0011986946919932961,
-0.299938827753067,
-0.0966404601931572,
-0.23463194072246552,
-0.25390517711639404,
0.17637008428573608,
0.8126553893089294,
-0.18414831161499023,
0.33794307708740234,
0.45841851830482483,
-0.08166352659463882,
-0.26358160376548767,
0.23300743103027344,
0.6287144422531128,
0.704853355884552,
-0.14406612515449524,
0.22746723890304565,
0.21634259819984436,
-0.5094043612480164,
0.010386384092271328,
-0.13837884366512299,
-0.1458752453327179,
0.26240360736846924,
0.740543007850647,
0.5670631527900696,
-0.035553768277168274,
-0.3903801441192627,
0.8361744284629822,
-0.09730396419763565,
-0.375414103269577,
-0.6052604913711548,
0.16827471554279327,
0.18240731954574585,
-0.0640246719121933,
0.2605786621570587,
-0.0944814682006836,
-0.051400307565927505,
-0.5981391072273254,
0.16390419006347656,
0.7347875833511353,
-0.7032998204231262,
-0.42898523807525635,
0.8170055747032166,
-0.27758270502090454,
-0.36094409227371216,
0.5228488445281982,
-0.29988133907318115,
-0.3676486611366272,
0.7591771483421326,
0.6157399415969849,
0.7878324389457703,
-0.18495714664459229,
0.43605124950408936,
0.2488647699356079,
0.35339075326919556,
-0.20470073819160461,
0.13915009796619415,
0.2165781706571579,
-0.8080182075500488,
-0.7382826805114746,
-0.6124889254570007,
-0.5186976194381714,
0.21414005756378174,
-0.47950097918510437,
0.15353412926197052,
-0.23636050522327423,
0.052054133266210556,
0.17789678275585175,
-0.26249194145202637,
-0.7140035033226013,
0.17600427567958832,
0.1049717590212822,
0.740110456943512,
-0.9874025583267212,
0.6170422434806824,
0.3861050307750702,
-0.5037821531295776,
-0.843863844871521,
0.11883027106523514,
0.09846055507659912,
-0.9392591118812561,
0.6138594150543213,
-0.1758434921503067,
-0.1395794004201889,
-0.5250592231750488,
-0.8078040480613708,
-0.9797768592834473,
0.7635734677314758,
0.5992287993431091,
-0.6871523261070251,
0.2364121675491333,
0.38544762134552,
0.6445117592811584,
-0.09494532644748688,
0.5944560170173645,
0.42527878284454346,
0.6223488450050354,
-0.12531057000160217,
-0.8466470241546631,
0.043177928775548935,
0.2092042863368988,
-0.1177983433008194,
0.09610103070735931,
-0.495542973279953,
0.6554222106933594,
-0.46089938282966614,
0.16105562448501587,
0.22598199546337128,
0.7013270258903503,
0.5581650733947754,
0.4142683446407318,
0.6344121098518372,
0.42530086636543274,
0.44064855575561523,
-0.20546124875545502,
1.2512363195419312,
-0.140662282705307,
0.25794586539268494,
1.0739604234695435,
-0.0012833817163482308,
0.892588198184967,
0.750562310218811,
-0.28187116980552673,
0.7234292030334473,
0.6895989775657654,
-0.0014427719870582223,
0.45656904578208923,
-0.005641284864395857,
-0.11041466146707535,
-0.5542568564414978,
-0.25487154722213745,
-0.11350121349096298,
0.504361093044281,
0.35294538736343384,
-0.6179168224334717,
-0.07147739082574844,
-0.2567026615142822,
0.26989102363586426,
-0.10684455931186676,
-0.08245406299829483,
0.774052083492279,
0.2638804018497467,
-1.076650619506836,
0.36908143758773804,
-0.058150094002485275,
0.30710411071777344,
-0.6134354472160339,
-0.26547667384147644,
-0.3114703893661499,
0.3813692629337311,
-0.25905394554138184,
-1.0790925025939941,
0.3811929523944855,
-0.17272505164146423,
-0.23353204131126404,
-0.1268903911113739,
0.40844613313674927,
-0.4687156677246094,
-0.3832022547721863,
0.3114316165447235,
0.42134302854537964,
0.33763954043388367,
-0.08238690346479416,
-0.5797887444496155,
-0.19533449411392212,
0.07695476710796356,
-0.2338772565126419,
0.26054370403289795,
0.29346033930778503,
-0.3146474361419678,
0.47063472867012024,
0.8421974778175354,
0.10642961412668228,
-0.27931976318359375,
0.06791482120752335,
0.37876656651496887,
-0.22368602454662323,
-0.37357765436172485,
-1.1873658895492554,
0.27366161346435547,
0.20510080456733704,
-0.3281877636909485,
0.6505426168441772,
0.33895209431648254,
0.46392568945884705,
-0.007120196707546711,
0.5738738775253296,
0.1879158467054367,
0.21136592328548431,
-0.5284761190414429,
0.43406081199645996,
-0.4952352046966553,
0.15053090453147888,
-0.27273494005203247,
-1.036873698234558,
-0.21621005237102509,
0.35073330998420715,
-0.2536444664001465,
-0.1853896826505661,
0.970491886138916,
0.8173099160194397,
0.013859686441719532,
0.26109999418258667,
0.3637855648994446,
0.11142851412296295,
0.23835042119026184,
0.5246617794036865,
0.6494798064231873,
-0.4508824348449707,
0.7432100772857666,
0.026385733857750893,
-0.17979256808757782,
-0.20804889500141144,
-1.1374984979629517,
-0.7546522617340088,
-0.4622149169445038,
-0.47002142667770386,
-0.4511012136936188,
0.24086745083332062,
0.5759187340736389,
0.35877108573913574,
-0.828072190284729,
0.17351678013801575,
-0.44494232535362244,
0.2122282087802887,
-0.3867575228214264,
-0.17065297067165375,
0.4366130530834198,
-0.23409341275691986,
-0.42510104179382324,
0.10296227037906647,
0.1408078819513321,
0.08044397085905075,
-0.3429817259311676,
-0.03996582701802254,
0.03445260599255562,
0.3515692949295044,
0.2536048889160156,
-0.18677577376365662,
-0.9259597659111023,
-0.451205849647522,
0.10295610874891281,
0.08570999652147293,
-0.08218216150999069,
0.6986278295516968,
-0.6259569525718689,
0.28255560994148254,
0.5595378875732422,
0.49554741382598877,
0.25179675221443176,
-0.1586790233850479,
0.6985219120979309,
-0.5744341015815735,
-0.03807944431900978,
-0.08477948606014252,
0.39850133657455444,
0.335761696100235,
-0.3764086365699768,
0.5125990509986877,
0.07828190922737122,
-0.5866369009017944,
-0.541905403137207,
0.2687610983848572,
-0.7567080855369568,
-0.16172908246517181,
1.5543529987335205,
-0.43905124068260193,
-0.26796236634254456,
-0.22488060593605042,
0.16416124999523163,
0.41425397992134094,
-0.2632734477519989,
0.7925439476966858,
0.9813917279243469,
-0.053977057337760925,
0.025062773376703262,
-0.5350727438926697,
0.4155586063861847,
0.8034444451332092,
-0.6148544549942017,
0.17700514197349548,
0.24924249947071075,
0.09611107409000397,
0.3252846300601959,
0.3952804505825043,
-0.2751629054546356,
0.45475396513938904,
0.07546553015708923,
-0.23641882836818695,
0.19210989773273468,
-0.06783922761678696,
-0.29664334654808044,
-0.09415705502033234,
0.19355091452598572,
-0.060838017612695694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03184v1
|
The Death of Feature Engineering? BERT with Linguistic Features on SQuAD 2.0
| 2024-04-04T03:50:34 | 2024-04-04T03:50:34 |
Jiawei Li, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine reading comprehension is an essential natural language processing
task, which takes into a pair of context and query and predicts the
corresponding answer to query. In this project, we developed an end-to-end
question answering model incorporating BERT and additional linguistic features.
We conclude that the BERT base model will be improved by incorporating the
features. The EM score and F1 score are improved 2.17 and 2.14 compared with
BERT(base). Our best single model reaches EM score 76.55 and F1 score 79.97 in
the hidden test set. Our error analysis also shows that the linguistic
architecture can help model understand the context better in that it can locate
answers that BERT only model predicted "No Answer" wrongly.
|
[
-0.7864550948143005,
-1.049772024154663,
0.5861031413078308,
0.24841485917568207,
-0.1585453599691391,
0.21454238891601562,
0.0006677243509329855,
-0.9848242998123169,
0.08444464951753616,
0.7249457240104675,
-0.935846745967865,
-0.09808657318353653,
-0.4006381332874298,
-0.04637095704674721,
-0.44044357538223267,
0.9656686782836914,
0.010378841310739517,
-0.018609922379255295,
-0.17135833203792572,
-0.08677969872951508,
-0.6146220564842224,
-0.6491078734397888,
-0.5929213166236877,
-0.2361615151166916,
0.49467530846595764,
0.295255184173584,
0.6551500558853149,
0.4232034683227539,
0.5752328634262085,
0.22271454334259033,
-0.4158206284046173,
-0.21208299696445465,
-0.5612384080886841,
0.5096808671951294,
-0.021175215020775795,
-0.46144503355026245,
-0.343024343252182,
0.08268091827630997,
0.14141333103179932,
0.8780410289764404,
0.4594394862651825,
0.12287977337837219,
0.11250242590904236,
0.5935235023498535,
-0.12221159785985947,
0.18200050294399261,
-0.7086316347122192,
-0.1560501754283905,
0.43689510226249695,
0.0006656285841017962,
-0.5900183916091919,
-0.013089456595480442,
0.5981578230857849,
-0.4319967031478882,
0.4743726849555969,
0.12252631038427353,
1.0490742921829224,
0.5014215707778931,
-0.1684049665927887,
-0.30296942591667175,
-0.3620281517505646,
0.8560650944709778,
-0.36741551756858826,
0.1779036521911621,
0.6328502297401428,
0.37059569358825684,
0.030682723969221115,
-0.29075703024864197,
-0.4255002439022064,
-0.19908466935157776,
0.0266756359487772,
0.17616431415081024,
0.07785570621490479,
0.12720946967601776,
-0.22599145770072937,
-0.022899523377418518,
-0.6591503620147705,
0.31486332416534424,
-0.6150522828102112,
-0.3077641427516937,
0.8090694546699524,
-0.21883724629878998,
0.29581984877586365,
-0.2938480079174042,
-0.40484312176704407,
-0.09755823761224747,
-0.4446459114551544,
0.09664752334356308,
0.27855953574180603,
0.1703672856092453,
0.1456541121006012,
0.4297860264778137,
-0.18829406797885895,
0.519999086856842,
-0.30291056632995605,
0.5541631579399109,
0.21565796434879303,
-0.11215728521347046,
-0.3103142976760864,
0.1506340205669403,
0.3290032744407654,
0.28956133127212524,
0.41852426528930664,
-0.24565763771533966,
-0.2682955265045166,
-0.1566649228334427,
0.3779903054237366,
-0.38012316823005676,
-0.17750690877437592,
0.4991516172885895,
-0.5009855031967163,
-0.44639360904693604,
-0.12033237516880035,
-0.44896945357322693,
-0.02589350752532482,
-0.016114333644509315,
0.42655760049819946,
-0.8430454134941101,
-0.271120548248291,
-0.24788163602352142,
-0.5376237034797668,
0.7014703750610352,
0.484292596578598,
-0.9356781244277954,
-0.11625692993402481,
0.7703633904457092,
0.8340687155723572,
0.12816181778907776,
-0.09632402658462524,
-0.04798833653330803,
-0.07228857278823853,
-0.3879897892475128,
1.085067868232727,
-0.6232929229736328,
-0.4978974759578705,
-0.050837233662605286,
0.18152764439582825,
-0.1526177078485489,
-0.31626570224761963,
0.27824506163597107,
-0.7450339794158936,
0.3531419336795807,
-0.4491395652294159,
-0.6616764664649963,
-0.5229341387748718,
0.2853429913520813,
-0.7265163660049438,
1.1093485355377197,
0.3168684244155884,
-0.19710761308670044,
0.2919190227985382,
-0.9765973687171936,
-0.46455681324005127,
0.08927810937166214,
0.23765182495117188,
-0.23044884204864502,
0.07648921012878418,
0.20625928044319153,
0.36986780166625977,
0.07387255877256393,
-0.050669800490140915,
-0.5471084713935852,
-0.46977007389068604,
0.2768940031528473,
-0.1414068043231964,
0.9600265026092529,
0.2563607394695282,
-0.35125038027763367,
-0.18903040885925293,
-0.4412759244441986,
0.4982606768608093,
-0.08311208337545395,
-0.19868433475494385,
-0.08888980001211166,
0.31581056118011475,
0.2690654993057251,
0.2174980640411377,
0.24540364742279053,
-0.6644133925437927,
-0.04262714833021164,
-0.4451066553592682,
0.49694857001304626,
0.7310745716094971,
0.08847106993198395,
0.5997945666313171,
-0.5821900963783264,
0.40239641070365906,
-0.309222549200058,
0.02515403740108013,
-0.22336772084236145,
-1.1394963264465332,
-0.7683801054954529,
-0.27247360348701477,
0.2533179223537445,
0.9504169821739197,
-0.45817694067955017,
0.7003125548362732,
0.2011057436466217,
-0.4105687439441681,
-0.7306800484657288,
0.03151538595557213,
0.48700860142707825,
0.4608004093170166,
0.4904070198535919,
0.0570535846054554,
-0.42804598808288574,
-1.1757681369781494,
0.015216265805065632,
-0.48966553807258606,
-0.2571316063404083,
0.12100663036108017,
0.5002079010009766,
-0.11846787482500076,
0.9970108866691589,
-0.3105512261390686,
-0.22253581881523132,
-0.8503736257553101,
0.16035005450248718,
0.06712403893470764,
0.3937470614910126,
0.7835900187492371,
-0.8667342066764832,
-0.19418197870254517,
-0.04090243950486183,
-0.9008641242980957,
-0.12762893736362457,
0.06663842499256134,
-0.15656216442584991,
0.6146957874298096,
0.2855956256389618,
-0.5382421016693115,
0.3371254801750183,
0.40736132860183716,
-0.3128056824207306,
0.24237404763698578,
-0.034573446959257126,
0.19128954410552979,
-0.9288506507873535,
-0.008518033660948277,
-0.013372671790421009,
-0.11538967490196228,
-0.7449278831481934,
0.3833397924900055,
0.06556232273578644,
-0.19968023896217346,
-0.38640227913856506,
0.4455377757549286,
-0.32070404291152954,
-0.28468653559684753,
-0.24346919357776642,
0.07544451951980591,
0.1349143534898758,
0.44809144735336304,
-0.07774433493614197,
0.8108745217323303,
0.38181623816490173,
-0.5172012448310852,
0.32639822363853455,
0.36786508560180664,
-0.27487605810165405,
0.15036910772323608,
-0.8270753622055054,
0.23098541796207428,
-0.31763580441474915,
-0.05945965647697449,
-1.5197995901107788,
-0.3410055637359619,
-0.11942458152770996,
-0.8462042212486267,
0.35704296827316284,
0.08919921517372131,
-0.5338935852050781,
-0.34267327189445496,
-0.3151642084121704,
-0.15649497509002686,
0.8127528429031372,
-0.16468970477581024,
0.22776976227760315,
0.4799681007862091,
-0.5575622916221619,
-0.17937949299812317,
-0.9621335864067078,
-0.0764334574341774,
0.21622596681118011,
-1.0442239046096802,
0.2022933065891266,
-0.0960838571190834,
-0.3393664062023163,
0.1124817281961441,
-0.004529131576418877,
-0.6674632430076599,
0.4156014919281006,
-0.017442747950553894,
0.34689635038375854,
-0.5537281632423401,
0.4866228699684143,
0.39747363328933716,
-0.07242807745933533,
0.05638031288981438,
0.182966947555542,
0.579216718673706,
-0.07615882903337479,
-0.03051750920712948,
-0.22110900282859802,
0.782311201095581,
0.6725274920463562,
-0.37915363907814026,
0.7143569588661194,
0.43021008372306824,
-0.34282076358795166,
-0.19783227145671844,
-0.5062639117240906,
-0.27064335346221924,
-0.46775463223457336,
0.8268666863441467,
-0.4403347671031952,
-1.0966061353683472,
0.8722081184387207,
0.4850718677043915,
0.3473941385746002,
0.6815907955169678,
0.3609585165977478,
-0.9010409712791443,
1.2889727354049683,
0.9583637714385986,
-0.17417898774147034,
0.4218950867652893,
-0.21685871481895447,
0.3220258057117462,
-0.5806520581245422,
-0.3255994915962219,
-0.582809329032898,
-0.6895549893379211,
-0.48856014013290405,
-0.12459871917963028,
0.41044554114341736,
0.3570937216281891,
-0.09546737372875214,
0.3543190062046051,
-0.7892006039619446,
0.34371376037597656,
0.8145332932472229,
0.5446651577949524,
-0.1497020423412323,
-0.11342579126358032,
-0.003438620362430811,
0.08256158977746964,
-0.38928988575935364,
-0.5811737179756165,
0.7699898481369019,
0.5059064030647278,
0.533640444278717,
0.12723061442375183,
0.6013056039810181,
0.4381290078163147,
0.12768816947937012,
-0.7574959993362427,
0.6812829375267029,
0.19540472328662872,
-1.0837405920028687,
-0.763817548751831,
-0.045914601534605026,
-0.5889402627944946,
0.011081831529736519,
0.07117119431495667,
-0.8127220869064331,
-0.008565094321966171,
-0.0019970342982560396,
-0.1962873637676239,
0.06461845338344574,
-1.1709086894989014,
1.0209736824035645,
-0.24094295501708984,
0.18777281045913696,
-0.12144217640161514,
-0.8815791010856628,
0.22314947843551636,
-0.17658373713493347,
0.02238261140882969,
-0.3605598211288452,
-0.16749314963817596,
0.716472864151001,
-0.38714802265167236,
0.7494591474533081,
-0.17754167318344116,
0.17043907940387726,
0.40800750255584717,
0.030468057841062546,
0.13501980900764465,
-0.07767640799283981,
-0.5649940967559814,
-0.04634930565953255,
0.21050745248794556,
-0.7555458545684814,
-0.6111375689506531,
0.44712284207344055,
-0.8716200590133667,
-0.6558859348297119,
-0.18856285512447357,
-0.7381262183189392,
-0.262794554233551,
-0.02428145706653595,
0.25721466541290283,
0.19112220406532288,
-0.054997626692056656,
0.15997670590877533,
1.0531812906265259,
-0.42296552658081055,
0.8488046526908875,
0.3607112467288971,
0.11664585024118423,
-0.11475168913602829,
0.5706418752670288,
-0.026252534240484238,
0.5567202568054199,
0.47853684425354004,
-0.21795573830604553,
-0.4705418050289154,
-0.494686096906662,
-0.776814877986908,
0.092894047498703,
-0.7664502263069153,
-0.030016006901860237,
-0.8251019716262817,
-0.6967116594314575,
-0.585689127445221,
-0.37659502029418945,
0.013157613575458527,
-0.5198356509208679,
-0.4353899359703064,
-0.29043227434158325,
0.5911704897880554,
0.8602079749107361,
0.4570067524909973,
0.38974687457084656,
-0.8284015655517578,
-0.0018356738146394491,
0.11045493930578232,
0.2178032398223877,
-0.572484016418457,
-0.695271372795105,
-0.06934264302253723,
0.037368837743997574,
-0.38230815529823303,
-1.170821189880371,
0.20603305101394653,
0.39501023292541504,
0.7253753542900085,
0.0669901892542839,
0.014787372201681137,
0.3684770464897156,
-0.39735668897628784,
0.9048418998718262,
-0.24188396334648132,
-0.826280415058136,
0.9047408699989319,
-0.2539116144180298,
0.4739096462726593,
0.6376251578330994,
0.25704845786094666,
-0.2669706642627716,
-0.7986599802970886,
-0.5310831665992737,
-0.496692031621933,
0.7091204524040222,
0.09946401417255402,
0.275684654712677,
-0.009234316647052765,
0.3931957185268402,
-0.014004519209265709,
0.05644567310810089,
-0.34118393063545227,
-0.20011384785175323,
-0.17011447250843048,
-0.3578725755214691,
0.03799431771039963,
-0.517873227596283,
0.4437187612056732,
-0.23514242470264435,
0.6100852489471436,
-0.12049936503171921,
0.6253808736801147,
0.3023264408111572,
-0.3401777744293213,
-0.14791300892829895,
0.2063220739364624,
0.723556399345398,
0.6735385656356812,
-0.5334568619728088,
-0.32976195216178894,
0.13075806200504303,
-0.35003745555877686,
-0.016210058704018593,
0.20994558930397034,
-0.20683473348617554,
0.1808190792798996,
0.6681025624275208,
0.45320355892181396,
0.2796971797943115,
-0.6743035912513733,
0.24591489136219025,
0.36470362544059753,
-0.4204312562942505,
-0.11191293597221375,
0.2590954303741455,
-0.02872922644019127,
0.21024519205093384,
0.6742637753486633,
0.1640186756849289,
0.14593151211738586,
-0.7275615930557251,
0.6741300225257874,
0.36731529235839844,
-0.7840029001235962,
-0.1824081391096115,
0.6444987654685974,
0.2018338292837143,
-0.2752845585346222,
0.5489221811294556,
-0.16037866473197937,
-0.9312597513198853,
1.1119474172592163,
0.45857104659080505,
0.8440145254135132,
-0.35716506838798523,
0.4089309573173523,
0.07619237899780273,
0.7623306512832642,
0.34346771240234375,
0.7508545517921448,
0.1492970585823059,
-0.6067249774932861,
-0.43142634630203247,
-0.6661781072616577,
-0.5049275755882263,
-0.16247113049030304,
-0.6311075687408447,
0.19439253211021423,
-0.46025148034095764,
0.23393189907073975,
0.1236506849527359,
-0.024559730663895607,
-0.5231329798698425,
0.39614298939704895,
0.060654155910015106,
1.0416337251663208,
-0.5867722034454346,
0.9377307891845703,
1.0058497190475464,
-0.6609121561050415,
-0.5439079999923706,
-0.11413063853979111,
-0.0446084663271904,
-1.0740699768066406,
0.832639217376709,
0.4731096625328064,
0.3754206895828247,
0.2341153919696808,
-0.48394158482551575,
-0.8266333341598511,
0.8814861178398132,
0.18604609370231628,
-0.3436155319213867,
-0.23187163472175598,
0.05549162998795509,
0.5651626586914062,
-0.2716296315193176,
0.535226047039032,
0.5386478304862976,
0.37072432041168213,
0.11012948304414749,
-1.0344758033752441,
-0.11672310531139374,
-0.2276105433702469,
-0.07951921969652176,
0.2835763394832611,
-0.5179944038391113,
0.6551157236099243,
-0.35660114884376526,
0.03259342908859253,
0.30959412455558777,
0.5692641735076904,
0.07693135738372803,
0.20585958659648895,
0.4578554630279541,
0.466513067483902,
0.5823420286178589,
-0.26522186398506165,
1.1754064559936523,
-0.24303339421749115,
0.47406646609306335,
0.6819331049919128,
-0.2609037458896637,
1.1605966091156006,
0.21032120287418365,
-0.05340447649359703,
0.4061262607574463,
1.1110236644744873,
0.1597975492477417,
0.8141347765922546,
-0.051268886774778366,
-0.1783534288406372,
-0.4229089021682739,
0.11160603165626526,
-0.2884787619113922,
0.4405776262283325,
0.33649665117263794,
-0.5739245414733887,
-0.27949023246765137,
0.22939424216747284,
-0.2670874297618866,
-0.12346290051937103,
-0.09341585636138916,
0.8218492865562439,
-0.07901578396558762,
-0.5716888904571533,
0.4911596179008484,
-0.17465513944625854,
0.3268924355506897,
-0.406183123588562,
-0.12541235983371735,
-0.4051149785518646,
0.044818829745054245,
0.22316919267177582,
-1.1873340606689453,
0.4611579477787018,
-0.14110103249549866,
-0.6554017663002014,
-0.3463965058326721,
0.6840782165527344,
-0.28123927116394043,
-0.6492863893508911,
0.3893120288848877,
0.5038496255874634,
0.29847252368927,
-0.3782067596912384,
-0.9264308214187622,
0.11853425204753876,
-0.014081635512411594,
-0.18881219625473022,
0.14066612720489502,
0.4316917657852173,
-0.007764492649585009,
0.8278238773345947,
0.4294516444206238,
-0.38213837146759033,
0.34655964374542236,
-0.04182203486561775,
0.8042504787445068,
-0.7682810425758362,
-0.561623752117157,
-0.7185768485069275,
0.5465980768203735,
-0.19318905472755432,
-0.364408016204834,
0.34901267290115356,
0.46292465925216675,
0.7056141495704651,
-0.023102324455976486,
1.0419048070907593,
-0.20636393129825592,
0.7730467319488525,
-0.37333327531814575,
1.0567095279693604,
-0.4955536723136902,
0.15573523938655853,
-0.21480302512645721,
-0.9789378643035889,
-0.39239275455474854,
0.5124651193618774,
-0.18541783094406128,
0.13260219991207123,
0.7241326570510864,
0.7301711440086365,
0.1500510275363922,
0.3088684678077698,
0.574271559715271,
0.1262953132390976,
0.3418997526168823,
0.6006380915641785,
0.8021069765090942,
-0.5376733541488647,
0.6643299460411072,
-0.05559356138110161,
-0.4554760754108429,
-0.3501453697681427,
-0.30726444721221924,
-1.1651756763458252,
-0.6296063661575317,
0.005144182126969099,
-0.2712857127189636,
0.30337753891944885,
0.6938431262969971,
0.7304801940917969,
-1.0242948532104492,
0.1195613294839859,
0.02587442845106125,
0.2695409655570984,
-0.1328192949295044,
-0.3085874319076538,
0.1479414403438568,
-0.9456846117973328,
-0.5737746953964233,
0.39575040340423584,
0.5944558382034302,
-0.11950454860925674,
-0.2324475347995758,
-0.016782252117991447,
-0.42488884925842285,
-0.12278637290000916,
0.6496380567550659,
0.15360742807388306,
-0.972917914390564,
-0.7384299039840698,
0.5298010110855103,
-0.1465223878622055,
-0.11954113095998764,
0.448612242937088,
-0.7692989706993103,
0.37129414081573486,
0.6201260089874268,
1.0569616556167603,
0.1012183278799057,
-0.057061318308115005,
0.791879415512085,
-0.563750147819519,
0.09397727996110916,
0.4640321433544159,
0.36136478185653687,
0.05764502286911011,
-0.5378515720367432,
0.3526301980018616,
0.2729312479496002,
-0.6171202063560486,
-0.6993062496185303,
0.17923493683338165,
-1.1171016693115234,
-0.45137467980384827,
0.8746854662895203,
-0.02768549695611,
-0.5556450486183167,
-0.561199963092804,
-0.23173916339874268,
0.08736248314380646,
-0.28814202547073364,
0.6671289205551147,
0.8517244458198547,
-0.25350141525268555,
-0.6310798525810242,
-0.8337749242782593,
0.2602584660053253,
0.6884375810623169,
-0.8397784233093262,
-0.4547456204891205,
0.241928830742836,
0.31653010845184326,
0.08444362133741379,
0.35114988684654236,
0.1789737343788147,
0.5869796276092529,
-0.1918707937002182,
0.0780024528503418,
0.09418508410453796,
-0.378764808177948,
0.02881353348493576,
0.18196024000644684,
-0.06273089349269867,
-0.5849713087081909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04287v1
|
CONFLARE: CONFormal LArge language model REtrieval
| 2024-04-04T02:58:21 | 2024-04-04T02:58:21 |
Pouria Rouzrokh, Shahriar Faghani, Cooper U. Gamble, Moein Shariatnia, Bradley J. Erickson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) frameworks enable large language models
(LLMs) to retrieve relevant information from a knowledge base and incorporate
it into the context for generating responses. This mitigates hallucinations and
allows for the updating of knowledge without retraining the LLM. However, RAG
does not guarantee valid responses if retrieval fails to identify the necessary
information as the context for response generation. Also, if there is
contradictory content, the RAG response will likely reflect only one of the two
possible responses. Therefore, quantifying uncertainty in the retrieval process
is crucial for ensuring RAG trustworthiness. In this report, we introduce a
four-step framework for applying conformal prediction to quantify retrieval
uncertainty in RAG frameworks. First, a calibration set of questions answerable
from the knowledge base is constructed. Each question's embedding is compared
against document embeddings to identify the most relevant document chunks
containing the answer and record their similarity scores. Given a
user-specified error rate ({\alpha}), these similarity scores are then analyzed
to determine a similarity score cutoff threshold. During inference, all chunks
with similarity exceeding this threshold are retrieved to provide context to
the LLM, ensuring the true answer is captured in the context with a
(1-{\alpha}) confidence level. We provide a Python package that enables users
to implement the entire workflow proposed in our work, only using LLMs and
without human intervention.
|
[
-0.3550219237804413,
-0.617830216884613,
0.7119844555854797,
-0.003519518068060279,
-0.06332945823669434,
-0.13103732466697693,
-0.2004120647907257,
-0.5373321771621704,
-0.04315873980522156,
0.4713155925273895,
-0.3513018786907196,
-0.23712725937366486,
-0.727461040019989,
0.02844161167740822,
-0.5153743028640747,
0.7492384314537048,
-0.07928705960512161,
0.034303709864616394,
-0.38780301809310913,
0.061909884214401245,
-0.26829877495765686,
-0.31364208459854126,
-0.549426257610321,
-0.34254780411720276,
0.31261178851127625,
0.40743815898895264,
0.8033238649368286,
0.23355339467525482,
0.6800590753555298,
0.23814846575260162,
-0.24262602627277374,
0.09853420406579971,
-0.5573775768280029,
0.5326071381568909,
-0.27938172221183777,
-0.5927280783653259,
-0.29921090602874756,
-0.12224560230970383,
0.5562126636505127,
0.466863751411438,
-0.3128198981285095,
0.4380034804344177,
-0.0072212559171020985,
0.6336464881896973,
-0.8668951392173767,
0.10707061737775803,
-1.023745059967041,
-0.20572049915790558,
-0.2526361346244812,
0.03149500489234924,
-0.43093758821487427,
-0.4125508666038513,
0.3005926012992859,
-0.7416852116584778,
0.2829836905002594,
0.31544631719589233,
0.8032410740852356,
0.4116075038909912,
-0.42467036843299866,
-0.5711654424667358,
-0.6665289402008057,
0.8571059107780457,
-0.8197091221809387,
0.5219974517822266,
0.7067872285842896,
0.5061442255973816,
-0.49622222781181335,
-0.9424301981925964,
-0.6361616253852844,
-0.19097064435482025,
-0.1674107164144516,
-0.032185330986976624,
0.14483466744422913,
-0.09851104766130447,
0.16748133301734924,
0.41728270053863525,
-0.6089614033699036,
-0.37214624881744385,
-0.5117820501327515,
-0.24658004939556122,
0.5433609485626221,
0.002535252133384347,
-0.2903937101364136,
-0.058434952050447464,
-0.35088542103767395,
-0.3853035271167755,
-0.4881640076637268,
-0.05101344361901283,
0.25867024064064026,
0.20681427419185638,
0.012993636541068554,
0.5687755346298218,
0.003725215559825301,
0.7581790089607239,
0.4135151207447052,
-0.32792913913726807,
0.2628505825996399,
0.046059153974056244,
-0.2402680516242981,
-0.15820994973182678,
0.727491021156311,
0.06512437760829926,
0.28340789675712585,
-0.07966316491365433,
-0.4329948425292969,
-0.24149355292320251,
0.5976987481117249,
-0.7046183943748474,
0.217542365193367,
0.40356123447418213,
-0.16924764215946198,
-0.2935149669647217,
0.27871769666671753,
-0.830727219581604,
-0.4788348376750946,
-0.3424726128578186,
0.5501765012741089,
-0.5995847582817078,
-0.15012267231941223,
0.09604007750749588,
-0.11578939855098724,
0.1235603541135788,
0.3348117172718048,
-0.6072984337806702,
0.24205303192138672,
0.7702788710594177,
0.5242156386375427,
-0.25013768672943115,
0.022119922563433647,
-0.5401779413223267,
0.25117719173431396,
-0.3294120132923126,
0.609595000743866,
-0.8317760229110718,
-0.438992440700531,
0.1552441120147705,
-0.1873268485069275,
0.07705516368150711,
-0.5261240601539612,
0.7163195610046387,
-0.997899055480957,
0.05872314050793648,
0.03890782594680786,
-0.8998100161552429,
-0.33009812235832214,
0.5504094958305359,
-0.7965117692947388,
0.9412689805030823,
0.3716416358947754,
-0.9113370776176453,
0.08067741245031357,
-0.009953792206943035,
-0.13118116557598114,
-0.0861188992857933,
-0.19174137711524963,
-0.47612330317497253,
0.09279906004667282,
-0.21645459532737732,
0.49178409576416016,
-0.45619577169418335,
0.18332213163375854,
-0.4374339282512665,
-0.26829296350479126,
0.32542353868484497,
-0.21161553263664246,
0.26253756880760193,
0.3622044324874878,
-0.058251045644283295,
-0.23135647177696228,
-0.6072769165039062,
0.29138121008872986,
-0.32112303376197815,
-0.30229803919792175,
-0.44573959708213806,
-0.211307093501091,
-0.0028891810216009617,
0.03543388471007347,
0.49358242750167847,
-0.3860088586807251,
-0.14273510873317719,
-0.37862277030944824,
-0.09329883754253387,
0.5150294899940491,
0.33126530051231384,
0.5246742963790894,
-0.60787034034729,
0.6221203804016113,
0.0999717116355896,
0.11130136996507645,
0.11926589161157608,
-0.49794286489486694,
-0.3104798197746277,
0.17883232235908508,
0.20587247610092163,
0.36776411533355713,
-0.5342428088188171,
0.06813381612300873,
-0.16330204904079437,
-0.843296468257904,
-0.39119043946266174,
0.21208521723747253,
0.580455482006073,
0.5841390490531921,
0.3781416118144989,
0.023653455078601837,
-0.6307401657104492,
-0.7185196280479431,
-0.18642888963222504,
-0.25540226697921753,
-0.14278118312358856,
0.15274213254451752,
0.42144060134887695,
-0.3018461763858795,
0.7442857623100281,
-0.5288549661636353,
-0.3735438585281372,
0.30367159843444824,
0.23221103847026825,
0.41971200704574585,
0.4473721981048584,
0.21086838841438293,
-1.3300833702087402,
-0.7097984552383423,
0.09526051580905914,
-0.42476144433021545,
0.19427073001861572,
0.10002335160970688,
0.005691590253263712,
0.3380114734172821,
0.700591504573822,
-0.46802225708961487,
0.3412347733974457,
0.7639856934547424,
0.01984693855047226,
0.689491331577301,
-0.1828683465719223,
0.1811636984348297,
-1.241032600402832,
0.3656000792980194,
-0.016511034220457077,
-0.2639144957065582,
-0.3866817057132721,
0.18607111275196075,
0.23841255903244019,
0.2217862755060196,
-0.24984805285930634,
0.7421792149543762,
-0.46867963671684265,
-0.0045829773880541325,
-0.05271558463573456,
0.27723121643066406,
0.13814164698123932,
0.1559966504573822,
-0.05466337874531746,
0.895275890827179,
0.27604517340660095,
-0.7592130303382874,
0.023434823378920555,
0.22804756462574005,
-0.1480315625667572,
0.7187818288803101,
-0.5783262848854065,
0.1368759274482727,
-0.2000201791524887,
0.18115024268627167,
-0.9148344397544861,
-0.4211253821849823,
-0.0747847855091095,
-0.6502543091773987,
0.6536097526550293,
-0.20856843888759613,
-0.2865404486656189,
-0.24783678352832794,
-0.19273027777671814,
0.34256190061569214,
0.37240296602249146,
-0.12042385339736938,
0.739474892616272,
0.6496085524559021,
0.015725402161478996,
-0.8151537179946899,
-0.3742252290248871,
-0.42683327198028564,
-0.18315526843070984,
-0.5151358842849731,
0.3989572823047638,
-0.3383598327636719,
-0.3270998001098633,
-0.16996969282627106,
-0.41668203473091125,
-0.18537917733192444,
-0.009012142196297646,
0.2708577811717987,
0.08465778827667236,
-0.0776914730668068,
0.1413404643535614,
-0.018545832484960556,
0.018237758427858353,
0.0018184686778113246,
-0.20559673011302948,
0.4455573260784149,
-0.3025822639465332,
-0.38048455119132996,
0.17530761659145355,
0.06304464489221573,
0.6188763976097107,
-0.15576937794685364,
0.5979345440864563,
0.6916963458061218,
-0.5101276636123657,
-0.09162434935569763,
-0.7935354709625244,
-0.12065235525369644,
-0.47151920199394226,
0.10954254120588303,
-0.5400258302688599,
-0.8319286108016968,
0.602618396282196,
-0.08526480942964554,
0.08020654320716858,
0.3172551393508911,
0.5694906115531921,
-0.1329098790884018,
0.6054391264915466,
0.47747939825057983,
0.24043795466423035,
0.2372787594795227,
-0.16781863570213318,
-0.12850143015384674,
-0.9858458638191223,
-0.39418825507164,
-0.6876696944236755,
-0.0810580849647522,
-0.5504353046417236,
-0.706202507019043,
0.6106418371200562,
0.2641737461090088,
-0.3578227758407593,
0.3030414879322052,
-0.3840586245059967,
0.21824519336223602,
0.43652796745300293,
-0.010977260768413544,
0.36082378029823303,
-0.11784947663545609,
-0.2312711924314499,
-0.016254255548119545,
-0.1888144165277481,
-0.5088368058204651,
1.177597999572754,
0.21791526675224304,
1.1292555332183838,
0.29648131132125854,
0.7222175598144531,
0.11507122218608856,
0.5529891848564148,
-0.6896661520004272,
0.28998449444770813,
-0.17389211058616638,
-0.7943419218063354,
-0.43899980187416077,
-0.3303961455821991,
-0.9526671171188354,
0.18001163005828857,
-0.3582797050476074,
-0.7421905398368835,
0.12410997599363327,
0.10712210834026337,
-0.19595842063426971,
0.028146784752607346,
-0.42456796765327454,
0.32202285528182983,
0.2578296959400177,
-0.23841971158981323,
-0.030808452516794205,
-0.8110727071762085,
0.38538283109664917,
-0.6968923807144165,
0.32846373319625854,
0.06738617271184921,
-0.20484517514705658,
0.4695921838283539,
-0.08129877597093582,
0.671381950378418,
0.007394181098788977,
-0.17333360016345978,
0.2808088958263397,
0.5971733927726746,
0.6537855863571167,
0.10285750031471252,
-0.7400304079055786,
-0.09262576699256897,
0.5834328532218933,
0.06988446414470673,
-0.7679833173751831,
0.6519216299057007,
-0.6166760325431824,
-0.6952475309371948,
-0.36867642402648926,
-0.7330098152160645,
-0.5078045129776001,
0.414665162563324,
0.28414449095726013,
0.12272106856107712,
-0.1428711861371994,
0.2761349678039551,
0.748431921005249,
0.1136823520064354,
0.011259971186518669,
0.6010294556617737,
-0.33869799971580505,
-0.3542950451374054,
0.3883483111858368,
0.08663829416036606,
0.3370565176010132,
0.5648771524429321,
0.2821078598499298,
-0.5303795337677002,
-0.3722440004348755,
-0.12958116829395294,
0.3434554636478424,
-0.6179606318473816,
-0.634738564491272,
-0.34019485116004944,
-0.25260716676712036,
-0.6778604388237,
-0.03926690295338631,
-0.24200594425201416,
-0.33249422907829285,
-0.2106686234474182,
0.11517336219549179,
0.37744906544685364,
0.9156454801559448,
-0.033534739166498184,
0.31273090839385986,
-0.947833240032196,
0.16358335316181183,
-0.041223347187042236,
0.39333003759384155,
-0.07843417674303055,
-0.9125169515609741,
-0.27116823196411133,
0.21052922308444977,
-0.3942508101463318,
-0.9026720523834229,
0.367281436920166,
0.23519739508628845,
0.6975652575492859,
0.2570032775402069,
0.3872999846935272,
0.7225314974784851,
-0.49921104311943054,
0.46134716272354126,
-0.09100426733493805,
-0.7947871088981628,
0.5096210241317749,
-0.15687859058380127,
0.008462551049888134,
0.7064401507377625,
0.6965985894203186,
-0.4127965569496155,
-0.598551869392395,
-0.7963429093360901,
-0.7213112115859985,
0.34895241260528564,
0.06225288286805153,
0.06235099211335182,
0.04832097887992859,
0.7889013290405273,
0.05719740316271782,
0.1799648553133011,
-0.28239238262176514,
-0.09675288200378418,
0.1606263667345047,
-0.40407612919807434,
0.0221423152834177,
-0.29776903986930847,
-0.19648265838623047,
0.13343192636966705,
0.8302267789840698,
-0.2596997618675232,
0.01516503095626831,
0.34622785449028015,
-0.03169827163219452,
-0.4572691321372986,
0.1601739525794983,
0.551554799079895,
0.8415418863296509,
-0.5096822381019592,
0.19533632695674896,
0.23956945538520813,
-0.7466262578964233,
0.11592551320791245,
0.04663405194878578,
-0.16788895428180695,
0.0842476412653923,
0.2140333354473114,
0.25916168093681335,
0.21961066126823425,
-0.5843115448951721,
0.5248413681983948,
-0.06480538845062256,
0.059361863881349564,
-0.9054036140441895,
0.009998157620429993,
0.059762485325336456,
0.3275238275527954,
0.4594259560108185,
0.03726179525256157,
0.2346307635307312,
-0.09273559600114822,
0.6958163976669312,
0.49244824051856995,
-0.48562321066856384,
-0.07059675455093384,
0.5504323840141296,
-0.34343594312667847,
-0.3421581983566284,
0.3307637572288513,
-0.08639442920684814,
-0.29189279675483704,
0.4384828209877014,
0.6607673764228821,
0.616381049156189,
-0.4366820454597473,
0.12968358397483826,
0.6541421413421631,
0.1203998327255249,
-0.270616739988327,
0.1383790522813797,
0.3268727660179138,
-0.7020187973976135,
-0.2950409948825836,
-1.0318467617034912,
-0.5716215968132019,
0.1318282037973404,
-1.0270626544952393,
0.2516208291053772,
-0.3181925117969513,
-0.39928320050239563,
-0.21689188480377197,
0.15912477672100067,
-0.632550060749054,
0.2908671796321869,
0.12093516439199448,
1.2546621561050415,
-0.4797978103160858,
0.7678490281105042,
0.7821381092071533,
-0.4445599317550659,
-1.1542545557022095,
0.24936823546886444,
0.0686516985297203,
-0.6894797682762146,
0.556672990322113,
-0.012687969021499157,
-0.10240847617387772,
-0.061602238565683365,
-0.48197516798973083,
-1.2141764163970947,
1.2907487154006958,
0.4380159378051758,
-0.5006654858589172,
-0.0748312771320343,
0.09394647926092148,
0.6334974765777588,
-0.296210914850235,
0.3091123104095459,
0.44454213976860046,
0.6349191069602966,
0.6002786159515381,
-1.0008245706558228,
0.3147682249546051,
0.15245194733142853,
0.19961489737033844,
0.05129861831665039,
-0.3538970947265625,
0.9283844232559204,
-0.22615249454975128,
-0.13079558312892914,
0.14537234604358673,
0.8080416321754456,
0.5662941336631775,
0.13524776697158813,
0.4600212275981903,
0.4880898594856262,
0.9907194972038269,
0.19748473167419434,
1.0945496559143066,
-0.4625731110572815,
0.4971902668476105,
1.2935919761657715,
-0.15328659117221832,
1.3124477863311768,
0.7927029728889465,
-0.048876140266656876,
0.515250563621521,
0.4650630056858063,
0.21761859953403473,
0.3154812753200531,
0.21458840370178223,
-0.24218589067459106,
-0.19165049493312836,
0.04840543121099472,
-0.28338342905044556,
0.2315409928560257,
0.655529797077179,
-0.18831390142440796,
-0.2781873643398285,
-0.2418418824672699,
0.12519022822380066,
0.2707308828830719,
-0.08589068800210953,
0.7049112319946289,
0.378903329372406,
-0.9385823607444763,
0.6678605675697327,
-0.10599283128976822,
0.47956106066703796,
-0.7487962245941162,
-0.20814348757266998,
-0.30646812915802,
0.3572630286216736,
-0.20515553653240204,
-1.1145128011703491,
0.5532488822937012,
-0.38198235630989075,
-0.38755878806114197,
0.15390139818191528,
0.640409529209137,
-0.5964774489402771,
-0.5091431736946106,
0.2807859778404236,
0.3517531752586365,
0.18588808178901672,
-0.07431037724018097,
-0.7371207475662231,
0.1394749879837036,
-0.08961484581232071,
-0.41328439116477966,
0.3490156829357147,
0.7263332009315491,
-0.12202678620815277,
0.8714115619659424,
0.5380203723907471,
0.08829434961080551,
0.01577497459948063,
-0.128983736038208,
0.822420060634613,
-0.11577906459569931,
-0.09410593658685684,
-0.47932878136634827,
0.4703545868396759,
0.06377403438091278,
-0.08849562704563141,
0.5035374760627747,
0.47052815556526184,
0.810745358467102,
-0.11963554471731186,
0.5414329767227173,
-0.1639847308397293,
0.6612256169319153,
-0.460445761680603,
0.7129731774330139,
-0.6335815787315369,
0.314935564994812,
-0.27622684836387634,
-0.9192411303520203,
-0.36412349343299866,
0.6405389308929443,
-0.15708477795124054,
-0.015674063935875893,
0.6334357857704163,
1.2391059398651123,
-0.11879248917102814,
-0.2169143557548523,
0.48955631256103516,
0.31231027841567993,
0.2952353060245514,
0.2796335518360138,
0.32271912693977356,
-0.6828909516334534,
0.7378131151199341,
-0.09761476516723633,
-0.13981395959854126,
-0.13037294149398804,
-0.8847817182540894,
-0.49189493060112,
-1.0530271530151367,
0.04810529947280884,
-0.8069725036621094,
-0.07433826476335526,
0.7111189961433411,
0.6987398266792297,
-0.9701734781265259,
-0.23153580725193024,
0.15714357793331146,
0.19139285385608673,
-0.0031787832267582417,
-0.23820066452026367,
0.277065634727478,
-0.6487223505973816,
-0.7861454486846924,
0.08932871371507645,
-0.17584489285945892,
0.1592918038368225,
-0.39524149894714355,
-0.219846710562706,
-0.34810757637023926,
0.11809030920267105,
0.21364334225654602,
0.1727445274591446,
-0.6896801590919495,
-0.5170289874076843,
0.08445968478918076,
-0.4464266002178192,
-0.21748735010623932,
0.5138340592384338,
-0.6319205164909363,
0.4310944676399231,
0.5556359887123108,
0.6560542583465576,
0.7836902141571045,
0.08312860131263733,
0.7954887747764587,
-0.8890929818153381,
-0.03253952041268349,
0.3361341953277588,
0.29410862922668457,
0.24307332932949066,
-0.597575843334198,
0.6786565184593201,
-0.1385139673948288,
-0.7102193236351013,
-0.5995466709136963,
0.2927975058555603,
-1.1089495420455933,
-0.09194546192884445,
1.3081969022750854,
-0.3900921642780304,
-0.40157827734947205,
-0.19026274979114532,
-0.0768793448805809,
0.10107153654098511,
-0.2968142628669739,
0.7165062427520752,
0.5884989500045776,
0.18176865577697754,
0.03610840439796448,
-0.485867977142334,
0.7312008738517761,
0.07886561006307602,
-0.443305641412735,
0.0038676061667501926,
0.42755839228630066,
0.5166846513748169,
0.6092816591262817,
0.45855119824409485,
-0.2833860218524933,
0.08732719719409943,
-0.08439947664737701,
0.007623617071658373,
0.08203049749135971,
-0.10723354667425156,
-0.043675463646650314,
0.27682605385780334,
0.19585856795310974,
0.23068484663963318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03163v1
|
Uncertainty in Language Models: Assessment through Rank-Calibration
| 2024-04-04T02:31:05 | 2024-04-04T02:31:05 |
Xinmeng Huang, Shuo Li, Mengxin Yu, Matteo Sesia, Hamed Hassani, Insup Lee, Osbert Bastani, Edgar Dobriban
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Language Models (LMs) have shown promising performance in natural language
generation. However, as LMs often generate incorrect or hallucinated responses,
it is crucial to correctly quantify their uncertainty in responding to given
inputs. In addition to verbalized confidence elicited via prompting, many
uncertainty measures ($e.g.$, semantic entropy and affinity-graph-based
measures) have been proposed. However, these measures can differ greatly, and
it is unclear how to compare them, partly because they take values over
different ranges ($e.g.$, $[0,\infty)$ or $[0,1]$). In this work, we address
this issue by developing a novel and practical framework, termed
$Rank$-$Calibration$, to assess uncertainty and confidence measures for LMs.
Our key tenet is that higher uncertainty (or lower confidence) should imply
lower generation quality, on average. Rank-calibration quantifies deviations
from this ideal relationship in a principled manner, without requiring ad hoc
binary thresholding of the correctness score ($e.g.$, ROUGE or METEOR). The
broad applicability and the granular interpretability of our methods are
demonstrated empirically.
|
[
-0.28651902079582214,
-0.828747570514679,
0.6397432088851929,
-0.046293217688798904,
-0.01158935111016035,
0.21459615230560303,
-0.28362852334976196,
-0.12630414962768555,
0.002665791427716613,
0.1851588636636734,
-0.2592959702014923,
-0.4925588071346283,
-0.762759268283844,
-0.09797941893339157,
-0.19142888486385345,
0.734234094619751,
-0.025928441435098648,
0.03903215005993843,
-0.271569162607193,
-0.007023134734481573,
-0.4211396276950836,
-0.3855460286140442,
-0.618090033531189,
-0.24778473377227783,
0.7287753224372864,
0.27278098464012146,
1.1071075201034546,
0.4004036784172058,
0.5126116871833801,
0.20594948530197144,
0.00878901220858097,
0.11233825981616974,
-0.6273981332778931,
0.3647472858428955,
0.12880946695804596,
-0.46309494972229004,
-0.5569777488708496,
0.07708917558193207,
0.8653466701507568,
1.0089828968048096,
-0.003465804038569331,
0.23117446899414062,
-0.029680216684937477,
0.6041030287742615,
-0.9236433506011963,
0.03397161513566971,
-0.8216310739517212,
-0.20590488612651825,
-0.04031234607100487,
-0.25650525093078613,
-0.5581048130989075,
-0.6575369238853455,
-0.17782177031040192,
-0.38855618238449097,
-0.04908435419201851,
0.21211852133274078,
0.9758532047271729,
0.4669525623321533,
-0.2820485532283783,
-0.17582781612873077,
-0.849144697189331,
0.8138232231140137,
-1.0425416231155396,
0.3516809642314911,
0.7026193737983704,
0.5205169320106506,
-0.10742133855819702,
-0.46244198083877563,
-0.3054812550544739,
-0.20579473674297333,
0.3025103807449341,
-0.011503156274557114,
0.18235385417938232,
0.06472232937812805,
0.013376371003687382,
0.5871917605400085,
-0.44162556529045105,
0.2221435308456421,
-0.13857759535312653,
-0.33110249042510986,
0.615874171257019,
-0.030189914628863335,
0.10146504640579224,
-0.1969802975654602,
-0.023009391501545906,
-0.4105069041252136,
-0.8266646862030029,
0.1283615231513977,
0.9068903923034668,
0.7091619372367859,
0.129652202129364,
0.5115923881530762,
-0.16042988002300262,
0.6906382441520691,
-0.00842991191893816,
-0.056608010083436966,
0.08222433179616928,
-0.16207529604434967,
-0.2191174477338791,
0.05991761013865471,
0.7346727848052979,
0.4022461771965027,
0.32516995072364807,
-0.14757660031318665,
-0.19771675765514374,
-0.007173916790634394,
0.32335102558135986,
-0.8228915929794312,
-0.16007031500339508,
0.5170040726661682,
-0.09904175996780396,
-0.7528186440467834,
0.1400926411151886,
-0.6333773732185364,
-0.4093024432659149,
-0.04712085798382759,
0.8361092805862427,
-0.3654988706111908,
-0.2997937798500061,
-0.03981339558959007,
0.1561228334903717,
0.1429801732301712,
0.24895235896110535,
-0.9548226594924927,
0.36276164650917053,
0.6661090850830078,
0.5035216212272644,
-0.19725678861141205,
-0.21783125400543213,
-0.6464489102363586,
-0.2092415988445282,
-0.7332110404968262,
0.5421123504638672,
-0.4291638731956482,
-0.3487769067287445,
-0.09460686147212982,
-0.4888591170310974,
-0.22645975649356842,
-0.2707269787788391,
0.47476139664649963,
-0.4398680031299591,
0.3019618093967438,
-0.15309378504753113,
-0.7214321494102478,
-0.09473622590303421,
0.25829455256462097,
-0.5267007350921631,
1.4228802919387817,
0.39406290650367737,
-0.64768385887146,
0.4884108304977417,
-0.033378805965185165,
-0.056174661964178085,
0.22207842767238617,
-0.1568128764629364,
-0.38286352157592773,
0.20706939697265625,
-0.018839355558156967,
0.3645738363265991,
-0.3122839629650116,
0.3947587013244629,
-0.454194575548172,
-0.371506005525589,
0.490708589553833,
-0.7069717049598694,
0.4331994354724884,
0.25212013721466064,
-0.14489386975765228,
0.028191406279802322,
-0.8555188179016113,
0.7086071968078613,
-0.26833376288414,
-0.1292475312948227,
-0.373687207698822,
0.2419424057006836,
-0.2049444168806076,
0.062469691038131714,
0.19426381587982178,
-0.23929153382778168,
-0.1987377554178238,
-0.5925632119178772,
0.25644651055336,
0.6165953278541565,
0.15447492897510529,
0.47942835092544556,
-0.4865279495716095,
0.4472084045410156,
-0.2869918644428253,
0.016178831458091736,
0.061424754559993744,
-0.547088086605072,
-0.7395727634429932,
-0.04912634193897247,
0.7204199433326721,
0.5347282886505127,
-0.3766791522502899,
0.7711939215660095,
-0.45645928382873535,
-0.661196768283844,
-0.6389546394348145,
0.015172936022281647,
0.20150823891162872,
0.33478057384490967,
0.28435075283050537,
-0.39106062054634094,
-0.05619475245475769,
-0.4838544726371765,
-0.39192789793014526,
-0.6183822154998779,
-0.06366059184074402,
0.157846599817276,
0.2846543788909912,
0.04264749959111214,
1.0531319379806519,
-0.3512961268424988,
0.23556220531463623,
-0.04276325926184654,
0.4650071859359741,
-0.10604377835988998,
0.446492999792099,
0.23647893965244293,
-0.6877660751342773,
-0.4243054687976837,
-0.21137729287147522,
-0.47519180178642273,
-0.18198716640472412,
-0.03858599066734314,
-0.128127783536911,
0.01933603733778,
0.37438008189201355,
-0.3949306011199951,
0.45405593514442444,
0.7020245790481567,
0.03882432356476784,
0.5155133008956909,
-0.24500668048858643,
0.3275308310985565,
-1.3395417928695679,
0.0014307787641882896,
-0.10550554096698761,
-0.37126609683036804,
-0.8230770230293274,
0.24979282915592194,
0.033559758216142654,
0.17170380055904388,
-0.2860213816165924,
0.4798453748226166,
-0.11311128735542297,
-0.16214273869991302,
-0.12667950987815857,
0.292167067527771,
0.04455191269516945,
0.13816344738006592,
-0.17028620839118958,
0.5952239036560059,
0.5421818494796753,
-0.5663876533508301,
0.10644886642694473,
-0.29917392134666443,
-0.29427623748779297,
0.7323724031448364,
-0.5203835964202881,
-0.013995632529258728,
-0.03121841698884964,
-0.057934802025556564,
-1.1589481830596924,
-0.3498972952365875,
0.09062326699495316,
-0.7091860771179199,
0.4352138042449951,
-0.011184027418494225,
-0.5275816917419434,
-0.07776672393083572,
-0.3116130828857422,
0.5252799987792969,
0.5530916452407837,
-0.0003074354899581522,
0.21078522503376007,
0.3384665846824646,
-0.4151502549648285,
-0.5282156467437744,
-0.3431228697299957,
0.08608892560005188,
-0.302898645401001,
-0.46234068274497986,
0.25250744819641113,
-0.3973468244075775,
-0.5846728086471558,
-0.34083202481269836,
-0.2185501754283905,
-0.1287245750427246,
0.4392342269420624,
0.39473867416381836,
0.07811137288808823,
-0.18112275004386902,
0.18308275938034058,
0.21959157288074493,
-0.15663699805736542,
-0.04610978439450264,
-0.007664657663553953,
0.4986192584037781,
-0.21095263957977295,
-0.672858476638794,
-0.12268036603927612,
0.008563718758523464,
0.6264266967773438,
-0.034989021718502045,
0.5625016093254089,
0.41937240958213806,
-0.6473085880279541,
-0.212141752243042,
-0.4873321056365967,
-0.29834553599357605,
-0.4578661024570465,
0.15916934609413147,
-0.3430560231208801,
-0.6567085385322571,
0.5246456861495972,
-0.03505156189203262,
-0.025062602013349533,
0.5238890647888184,
0.6313656568527222,
0.05027555301785469,
1.2168118953704834,
0.4760133624076843,
0.1450890749692917,
0.06291431188583374,
0.11516529321670532,
0.5452890992164612,
-0.6382241249084473,
0.02880711853504181,
-0.6839251518249512,
-0.14087975025177002,
-0.7188380360603333,
-0.5906762480735779,
0.21460705995559692,
0.2403125762939453,
-0.2587338387966156,
0.24847841262817383,
-0.39009347558021545,
0.29814574122428894,
0.39616551995277405,
-0.24419963359832764,
0.22688694298267365,
-0.10381322354078293,
-0.23670914769172668,
-0.22420693933963776,
-0.5132501125335693,
-0.8867635130882263,
0.9344658851623535,
0.5237848162651062,
0.8619605302810669,
0.08815575391054153,
0.8373032808303833,
0.24431470036506653,
0.3020980954170227,
-0.8907113075256348,
0.29071882367134094,
0.07981078326702118,
-0.5189704895019531,
-0.7628603577613831,
-0.6568366885185242,
-0.700193464756012,
0.28576070070266724,
-0.12012536078691483,
-0.9961663484573364,
0.2199448198080063,
0.06722767651081085,
-0.6329919695854187,
0.16040880978107452,
-0.579969048500061,
0.815760612487793,
-0.14059393107891083,
-0.08365735411643982,
0.2493596076965332,
-0.7076637744903564,
0.1042729988694191,
-0.29151782393455505,
0.4534633755683899,
-0.5455913543701172,
0.1820916384458542,
0.3906551003456116,
-0.3861674964427948,
0.5986611843109131,
0.06201495975255966,
-0.24982328712940216,
0.17207811772823334,
0.4612218737602234,
0.3253113627433777,
0.20776984095573425,
-0.5268693566322327,
-0.10066960752010345,
0.35811668634414673,
-0.18044091761112213,
-0.5331218242645264,
0.7096009254455566,
-0.689151406288147,
-0.2298632711172104,
-0.4032239019870758,
-0.8972674608230591,
-0.5444092750549316,
0.20504510402679443,
0.600540041923523,
0.35006022453308105,
-0.2857902944087982,
0.24754966795444489,
0.5899732112884521,
-0.16457030177116394,
0.19671151041984558,
0.16869759559631348,
-0.2698153555393219,
-0.29950758814811707,
1.05242919921875,
0.2619307339191437,
0.7535162568092346,
0.5732768177986145,
0.2920072078704834,
-0.3009902238845825,
-0.43154311180114746,
-0.40194499492645264,
-0.11353674530982971,
-0.6749734282493591,
-0.20976313948631287,
-0.23604056239128113,
-0.4356018304824829,
-0.5747285485267639,
-0.14169850945472717,
-0.4064579904079437,
-0.6695793867111206,
-0.2656484842300415,
-0.19025377929210663,
0.1811506301164627,
0.5401517748832703,
0.10242114216089249,
0.2934357523918152,
-0.39469054341316223,
0.09042301028966904,
0.28357604146003723,
0.2877887189388275,
-0.3459045886993408,
-0.7062936425209045,
-0.0362539179623127,
0.44059517979621887,
-0.0924881100654602,
-0.9856311678886414,
0.4912618100643158,
0.4177449643611908,
0.7034953236579895,
0.2095242142677307,
0.2899317741394043,
0.5158029198646545,
-0.3378352224826813,
0.9817594885826111,
-0.19382885098457336,
-1.0577633380889893,
0.4550146162509918,
-0.22110338509082794,
0.18688564002513885,
0.9670089483261108,
0.19690775871276855,
-0.5026336908340454,
-0.9872894287109375,
-0.7509400844573975,
-0.9108049869537354,
0.340537965297699,
0.5023947358131409,
0.2774975597858429,
0.10659097880125046,
0.3843894302845001,
0.038067776709795,
0.45400020480155945,
-0.6960465908050537,
-0.3484126925468445,
-0.17505130171775818,
-0.4417647123336792,
-0.4032623767852783,
-0.25173521041870117,
-0.07544326782226562,
-0.01218127179890871,
0.7474004030227661,
-0.22894778847694397,
0.1238003745675087,
-0.22499029338359833,
-0.32005220651626587,
-0.4507169723510742,
0.407042533159256,
0.7079986929893494,
0.7102119326591492,
-0.6702944040298462,
0.46439099311828613,
0.15981894731521606,
-0.41761431097984314,
0.1362147331237793,
0.02302141673862934,
-0.1960398107767105,
0.06898694485425949,
0.15061934292316437,
0.7572526931762695,
0.4075624942779541,
-0.37060579657554626,
0.5241878032684326,
-0.04400966688990593,
-0.04960951209068298,
-0.06533259153366089,
0.07973324507474899,
-0.03731266036629677,
-0.3280823826789856,
0.4523169994354248,
0.014143145643174648,
-0.0012863698648288846,
-0.2832552194595337,
0.2509748935699463,
0.3110862076282501,
-0.6754676699638367,
-0.1380862295627594,
0.6034365296363831,
-0.07937076687812805,
-0.34395888447761536,
0.29912617802619934,
-0.4778418242931366,
-0.24233591556549072,
0.696403443813324,
0.34830591082572937,
0.8672870397567749,
-0.38687217235565186,
0.43825554847717285,
0.3988995850086212,
0.5327069163322449,
-0.2561574876308441,
0.18449945747852325,
0.23250043392181396,
-0.8984503746032715,
-0.2424771636724472,
-0.837273359298706,
-0.7285958528518677,
0.04042869433760643,
-0.9496541023254395,
0.019641513004899025,
-0.24007031321525574,
-0.4562194347381592,
-0.06749490648508072,
-0.011849252507090569,
-0.2806132435798645,
0.32258424162864685,
0.1404656171798706,
0.6894170641899109,
-0.9230712652206421,
0.6656797528266907,
0.4591377377510071,
-0.300479918718338,
-1.0100661516189575,
0.14694486558437347,
0.03358162194490433,
-0.6876664161682129,
0.40570199489593506,
0.22156187891960144,
-0.23925155401229858,
0.2823978364467621,
-0.3324953615665436,
-1.018441081047058,
1.0772018432617188,
0.39709383249282837,
-0.07015274465084076,
-0.04659649357199669,
0.30486270785331726,
0.6447528004646301,
-0.40477797389030457,
0.34649911522865295,
0.5038910508155823,
0.49848443269729614,
0.15449602901935577,
-0.8902416229248047,
-0.03759317845106125,
0.017545804381370544,
0.2613985240459442,
0.20133809745311737,
-0.18182185292243958,
1.0405946969985962,
-0.09725192189216614,
-0.24064750969409943,
0.33727842569351196,
0.4469246566295624,
0.32764172554016113,
0.10955619066953659,
0.3942466378211975,
0.47346031665802,
0.9259033203125,
-0.35854455828666687,
0.9041193127632141,
-0.6738572120666504,
0.5937027931213379,
1.133884310722351,
-0.41561204195022583,
1.1593420505523682,
0.5104930996894836,
-0.19014203548431396,
0.47912490367889404,
0.9138534665107727,
0.25224727392196655,
0.3354189693927765,
0.40915659070014954,
-0.23204997181892395,
-0.47923099994659424,
0.1074010357260704,
-0.3129309415817261,
0.2059790939092636,
0.618443489074707,
-0.2514617145061493,
-0.2920863628387451,
-0.23907916247844696,
0.02857194095849991,
0.11272984743118286,
-0.15387794375419617,
0.5844786167144775,
0.18842045962810516,
-0.8139613270759583,
0.6790040731430054,
0.20181578397750854,
0.27626582980155945,
-0.5693809986114502,
0.14331503212451935,
-0.04294733703136444,
-0.11811218410730362,
-0.11820699274539948,
-0.6660403609275818,
-0.005257556680589914,
-0.09002724289894104,
0.06735701858997345,
-0.21580715477466583,
0.5927389860153198,
-0.5349140167236328,
-0.693477988243103,
-0.07981403172016144,
0.6541159152984619,
0.29926371574401855,
-0.08827770501375198,
-0.5510222911834717,
0.1416761726140976,
-0.353920578956604,
-0.22522877156734467,
0.3960856795310974,
0.13031865656375885,
-0.001364234834909439,
0.5736496448516846,
0.33343052864074707,
0.3296370208263397,
0.2050924301147461,
0.2507479786872864,
0.23293915390968323,
-0.05302289500832558,
-0.3202550709247589,
-0.6562163829803467,
0.44964635372161865,
0.0173844825476408,
-0.3927643299102783,
0.7786316871643066,
0.42957913875579834,
0.6144524216651917,
0.292603462934494,
0.6475530862808228,
-0.08146143704652786,
0.3608606159687042,
-0.45266008377075195,
0.8435003757476807,
-0.42965584993362427,
0.29622983932495117,
-0.42562079429626465,
-1.0553961992263794,
-0.5449557304382324,
0.9331681728363037,
-0.43778079748153687,
0.2657768130302429,
0.7614168524742126,
1.0961157083511353,
0.2527482509613037,
-0.3172953128814697,
0.6037664413452148,
-0.042662471532821655,
0.17296725511550903,
0.35737940669059753,
0.6501951813697815,
-0.7610888481140137,
0.34646445512771606,
-0.2479654997587204,
-0.13967391848564148,
-0.24757178127765656,
-1.113301396369934,
-0.4403126835823059,
-0.7138968110084534,
-0.375872403383255,
-0.47146663069725037,
-0.001137913204729557,
0.848246157169342,
0.8482584953308105,
-0.8949751257896423,
-0.39501678943634033,
-0.12086579203605652,
0.34466421604156494,
-0.37583231925964355,
-0.21803422272205353,
0.2335531860589981,
-0.563300609588623,
-0.8174254298210144,
0.30165085196495056,
0.2151646465063095,
0.14108121395111084,
-0.5096513628959656,
-0.29026156663894653,
0.07378231734037399,
0.52044677734375,
0.33049213886260986,
0.22631298005580902,
-0.7811769843101501,
-0.6667919754981995,
-0.14089643955230713,
-0.5333179235458374,
0.03406282141804695,
0.3291674256324768,
-0.5439587831497192,
0.6724013686180115,
0.5931710004806519,
0.41540032625198364,
0.04347508028149605,
0.18189303576946259,
0.7624822854995728,
-1.0775318145751953,
-0.17009787261486053,
0.282541960477829,
0.12361989170312881,
0.5762090086936951,
-0.27828067541122437,
0.26711195707321167,
0.008726396597921848,
-0.6861581802368164,
-1.3085980415344238,
0.447119802236557,
-0.8641055822372437,
-0.09532985836267471,
1.2832001447677612,
0.0779620110988617,
0.11561392992734909,
0.08190484344959259,
0.029055627062916756,
0.17296187579631805,
-0.19797450304031372,
0.7886316776275635,
0.9021779298782349,
0.19345128536224365,
-0.050504982471466064,
-0.6957057118415833,
0.680605411529541,
0.30853036046028137,
-0.9337526559829712,
0.040660738945007324,
0.3860621452331543,
0.22216397523880005,
0.3326568603515625,
0.39649271965026855,
-0.1366027146577835,
0.23452897369861603,
0.0784003809094429,
0.021438630297780037,
0.27085283398628235,
-0.3054601550102234,
-0.34607014060020447,
0.2630058526992798,
0.6661266088485718,
0.177312433719635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03161v1
|
BioVL-QR: Egocentric Biochemical Video-and-Language Dataset Using Micro QR Codes
| 2024-04-04T02:22:37 | 2024-04-04T02:22:37 |
Taichi Nishimura, Koki Yamamoto, Yuto Haneji, Keiya Kajimura, Chihiro Nishiwaki, Eriko Daikoku, Natsuko Okuda, Fumihito Ono, Hirotaka Kameko, Shinsuke Mori
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
This paper introduces a biochemical vision-and-language dataset, which
consists of 24 egocentric experiment videos, corresponding protocols, and
video-and-language alignments. The key challenge in the wet-lab domain is
detecting equipment, reagents, and containers is difficult because the lab
environment is scattered by filling objects on the table and some objects are
indistinguishable. Therefore, previous studies assume that objects are manually
annotated and given for downstream tasks, but this is costly and
time-consuming. To address this issue, this study focuses on Micro QR Codes to
detect objects automatically. From our preliminary study, we found that
detecting objects only using Micro QR Codes is still difficult because the
researchers manipulate objects, causing blur and occlusion frequently. To
address this, we also propose a novel object labeling method by combining a
Micro QR Code detector and an off-the-shelf hand object detector. As one of the
applications of our dataset, we conduct the task of generating protocols from
experiment videos and find that our approach can generate accurate protocols.
|
[
-0.2805628478527069,
-0.5089287757873535,
0.7272040843963623,
-0.4401465058326721,
-0.3250391185283661,
0.17594219744205475,
0.20445270836353302,
-0.3564107120037079,
0.3324480354785919,
0.2297600358724594,
-0.23937924206256866,
-0.41270697116851807,
-0.2047015130519867,
0.40368807315826416,
-0.37954074144363403,
0.6592398285865784,
0.063960961997509,
-0.000942440063226968,
-0.13800476491451263,
-0.48235103487968445,
0.03742346540093422,
-0.3490673005580902,
-0.3620806038379669,
-0.299320787191391,
0.612250030040741,
0.5433120727539062,
0.7234740257263184,
0.8424280285835266,
0.6257351040840149,
0.37526994943618774,
0.3655149042606354,
0.0805768296122551,
0.25502872467041016,
-0.16164752840995789,
-0.06155148521065712,
-0.1920168399810791,
-0.5873738527297974,
-0.45957615971565247,
0.4047069847583771,
0.16039027273654938,
0.0018555824644863605,
0.6441158652305603,
-0.12929268181324005,
0.8196109533309937,
-0.8474293947219849,
0.3392188251018524,
-0.24012112617492676,
0.44384825229644775,
-0.3833872377872467,
-0.2361188679933548,
0.03812776505947113,
-0.0796496719121933,
0.08756481111049652,
-0.49402058124542236,
0.32850193977355957,
0.06448858976364136,
0.5780714154243469,
0.3166993260383606,
-0.14119982719421387,
-0.0249330997467041,
-0.8666024804115295,
0.3687303364276886,
-0.3313318192958832,
0.6926448941230774,
0.3854827582836151,
0.6401472091674805,
0.21999706327915192,
-0.8287366628646851,
-0.7544974088668823,
0.19484594464302063,
0.24365970492362976,
-0.017278101295232773,
0.17539604008197784,
-0.06501295417547226,
-0.02649443969130516,
0.24410368502140045,
-0.5134161710739136,
-0.43830451369285583,
-0.5392720103263855,
-0.19799426198005676,
0.6562340259552002,
0.3783343434333801,
0.450922429561615,
0.08277754485607147,
-0.11803942173719406,
-0.24937784671783447,
-0.3246185779571533,
0.2479267120361328,
-0.06511122733354568,
0.05672113969922066,
0.03315555304288864,
0.7660670280456543,
-0.4268840551376343,
0.7534967064857483,
0.04975714161992073,
-0.12465734034776688,
0.6006200313568115,
-0.7560471892356873,
-0.5449603796005249,
0.2878693640232086,
1.0584205389022827,
0.3530782163143158,
0.2572014629840851,
0.03112689033150673,
-0.12440843135118484,
-0.21435630321502686,
0.3417324423789978,
-1.0483897924423218,
-0.6780692934989929,
0.576909065246582,
-0.4031373858451843,
-0.41369861364364624,
-0.07652278244495392,
-0.7153732180595398,
-0.27429574728012085,
-0.14340481162071228,
0.760714054107666,
-0.3699294328689575,
-0.027149798348546028,
0.28841397166252136,
-0.1487206369638443,
0.41094905138015747,
0.21581384539604187,
-0.9235073924064636,
0.2668764591217041,
0.1085825189948082,
0.8847584128379822,
0.37264323234558105,
0.025576738640666008,
-0.6324077844619751,
0.5107542276382446,
-0.0654255747795105,
0.8804023861885071,
-0.3951018452644348,
-0.34094566106796265,
-0.10280605405569077,
0.29255107045173645,
0.5132518410682678,
-0.6922103762626648,
0.20761746168136597,
-0.31274211406707764,
-0.4281788468360901,
-0.37739846110343933,
-0.15497133135795593,
0.0726049616932869,
-0.08244584500789642,
-0.5765647888183594,
0.8576430678367615,
-0.07292134314775467,
-0.5515481233596802,
0.3405310809612274,
-0.18725617229938507,
-0.203090101480484,
0.574894368648529,
-0.9371862411499023,
-0.5985811948776245,
-0.39561203122138977,
0.12076223641633987,
0.49462759494781494,
-0.07857027649879456,
0.12493746727705002,
-0.3281397223472595,
-0.08575276285409927,
0.460755318403244,
0.17940279841423035,
0.4151982069015503,
0.024507684633135796,
-0.33754628896713257,
0.20070680975914001,
-0.9271723031997681,
0.18930308520793915,
-0.011835130862891674,
-0.26144421100616455,
-0.26996222138404846,
0.31541213393211365,
0.17768441140651703,
0.085152767598629,
0.05947770178318024,
-0.9659610390663147,
0.1110430508852005,
-0.13628606498241425,
0.6031174063682556,
0.5001769065856934,
-0.1847638636827469,
0.38228464126586914,
0.02006600983440876,
0.23347221314907074,
-0.09005787968635559,
0.6088955402374268,
0.13913573324680328,
-0.5512357354164124,
-0.4911070168018341,
-0.38571131229400635,
-0.0419037863612175,
0.639036238193512,
-1.0170050859451294,
0.642952561378479,
-0.10735692083835602,
-0.4313632547855377,
-0.5927479863166809,
0.3095313608646393,
0.444909930229187,
0.6668030023574829,
0.6725828647613525,
-0.4084681272506714,
-0.3530733585357666,
-1.2549546957015991,
-0.05910451337695122,
-0.01761147938668728,
-0.2627948820590973,
0.3646720051765442,
0.611687421798706,
-0.40257129073143005,
0.9899470806121826,
-0.6622033715248108,
-0.6879107356071472,
0.3001880943775177,
-0.24708358943462372,
-0.1044783741235733,
0.49038800597190857,
0.5772358775138855,
-0.7339364290237427,
-0.4658811688423157,
0.3320525288581848,
-0.8095776438713074,
0.04879086837172508,
0.5487877726554871,
-0.07054509222507477,
-0.1960643231868744,
0.6481396555900574,
-0.20013171434402466,
0.7529442310333252,
0.014218750409781933,
-0.07634104043245316,
0.5833384394645691,
-0.3021949827671051,
0.33327338099479675,
-0.42415153980255127,
0.03248825669288635,
0.04626043885946274,
-0.5246824622154236,
-0.6091468930244446,
-0.1144673079252243,
0.44857585430145264,
-0.1208948865532875,
-0.7341307997703552,
0.61722332239151,
-0.4135706424713135,
0.09716329723596573,
-0.36688441038131714,
-0.22110246121883392,
0.1068464070558548,
0.42677879333496094,
0.34518343210220337,
0.6779279708862305,
0.604992151260376,
-0.7360930442810059,
0.6346255540847778,
0.41452735662460327,
-0.22991512715816498,
0.2386670559644699,
-0.8751261234283447,
0.06471794098615646,
-0.022572264075279236,
0.15739192068576813,
-1.0213892459869385,
-0.3470430076122284,
0.849844217300415,
-0.5100755095481873,
-0.023975305259227753,
0.017560278996825218,
-0.6601988077163696,
-0.29223766922950745,
-0.5966644287109375,
0.9706233143806458,
0.5562755465507507,
-0.33856070041656494,
0.7164908647537231,
0.4407038390636444,
0.14728423953056335,
-0.35107678174972534,
-0.9270197153091431,
-0.3500787615776062,
0.08833684027194977,
-0.29862362146377563,
0.21074359118938446,
0.003339504124596715,
-0.08423062413930893,
-0.07109196484088898,
-0.3420269191265106,
-0.256577730178833,
-0.47090771794319153,
0.3531760275363922,
-0.02137208916246891,
0.03228488191962242,
0.053681276738643646,
-0.05396838113665581,
-0.010769638232886791,
0.1973312944173813,
-0.2294558435678482,
0.09621945023536682,
-0.3904225528240204,
-0.3219273090362549,
-0.6176581978797913,
0.0793323889374733,
0.5050504207611084,
-0.2724418342113495,
0.571272075176239,
0.6346423029899597,
-0.5771904587745667,
0.19869926571846008,
-0.35115692019462585,
-0.186208114027977,
-0.6766402721405029,
0.15567158162593842,
-0.34335246682167053,
-0.37469613552093506,
0.6706764101982117,
0.34591975808143616,
-0.2651522755622864,
-0.034464605152606964,
0.704899251461029,
-0.21697019040584564,
0.9979152083396912,
0.4668706953525543,
0.06883664429187775,
0.3280503451824188,
-0.1110961064696312,
0.3266920745372772,
-0.9897305369377136,
-0.549525260925293,
-0.4811995327472687,
-0.12404657155275345,
0.004821855574846268,
-0.745694100856781,
0.7288718819618225,
-0.17459163069725037,
-0.4320325553417206,
0.20758064091205597,
-0.9714692831039429,
0.576384425163269,
0.32501161098480225,
0.7055942416191101,
0.34261760115623474,
0.08902731537818909,
-0.29576653242111206,
0.10490771383047104,
-0.5712215304374695,
-0.5946256518363953,
1.124190330505371,
0.1672924906015396,
0.6665787100791931,
0.0834391862154007,
0.5747633576393127,
0.3750770390033722,
0.30578145384788513,
-0.7534980773925781,
0.516757607460022,
0.10903897881507874,
-0.5553476214408875,
-0.3149649500846863,
0.17888331413269043,
-0.8426013588905334,
0.02486100234091282,
-0.10612024366855621,
-0.690592348575592,
0.6017681956291199,
0.34672436118125916,
-0.687073290348053,
0.389339417219162,
-0.557371199131012,
0.9123688340187073,
-0.43270084261894226,
-0.7207844257354736,
0.3703639805316925,
-0.9682629108428955,
0.15581491589546204,
-0.11727286875247955,
0.6085132956504822,
0.04260820895433426,
-0.17847870290279388,
0.6618546843528748,
-0.9207948446273804,
0.6781064867973328,
-0.0020567027386277914,
-0.17922905087471008,
0.5656617879867554,
0.15317711234092712,
0.14637592434883118,
0.2197331190109253,
0.5322046279907227,
0.02393953874707222,
0.25312793254852295,
-0.5134159326553345,
-0.3600783348083496,
0.1104746088385582,
-0.43526461720466614,
-0.2260587364435196,
-0.44814980030059814,
-0.20577336847782135,
0.06261466443538666,
0.39079758524894714,
0.27056649327278137,
0.5646246075630188,
0.019536243751645088,
0.11079069972038269,
0.936823308467865,
-0.536639392375946,
0.1878974735736847,
0.6772419810295105,
-0.561133086681366,
-0.4419400691986084,
1.140880823135376,
-0.07530736178159714,
0.1706041395664215,
0.41000238060951233,
0.15071575343608856,
-0.07237429171800613,
-0.25725057721138,
-0.7203782796859741,
-0.03037387505173683,
-0.5004324913024902,
-0.47955527901649475,
-0.7562108635902405,
0.03404927998781204,
-0.4155999720096588,
-0.15212242305278778,
-0.5656605958938599,
0.13514938950538635,
-0.2522971034049988,
0.025608239695429802,
0.7367603778839111,
0.22206172347068787,
-0.05184848979115486,
-0.09906841069459915,
-1.276445984840393,
0.7260464429855347,
0.5127201676368713,
0.33213189244270325,
0.0007286289473995566,
-0.06530489772558212,
-0.5055961012840271,
0.1310119479894638,
-0.11815229058265686,
-1.0886417627334595,
0.36939796805381775,
0.30741390585899353,
0.2097257524728775,
0.38822710514068604,
-0.2305746227502823,
0.42958173155784607,
-0.9759067893028259,
0.49822014570236206,
-0.006620284169912338,
-0.877545952796936,
0.788392186164856,
-0.487997829914093,
0.09153148531913757,
0.5884225368499756,
0.35293376445770264,
-0.36476531624794006,
-0.43940097093582153,
-0.522997260093689,
-1.0666965246200562,
0.29846444725990295,
0.25760218501091003,
-0.3886522948741913,
0.013085978105664253,
0.47932031750679016,
0.08093494921922684,
0.2254742980003357,
-0.5497592091560364,
-0.4683278501033783,
-0.316924512386322,
-0.4291536808013916,
0.08999645709991455,
0.27770382165908813,
-0.1858329474925995,
-0.7006402611732483,
0.34884321689605713,
-0.20672912895679474,
0.4660750925540924,
0.8067957758903503,
-0.18329012393951416,
-0.17638671398162842,
0.033542975783348083,
0.27576637268066406,
0.26754024624824524,
-0.6612369418144226,
0.10778354853391647,
-0.17380213737487793,
-0.8946537375450134,
0.51429283618927,
-0.011482102796435356,
-0.05297015607357025,
-0.176224485039711,
-0.008695272728800774,
0.02810698188841343,
-0.1240825429558754,
-1.2285754680633545,
0.42329034209251404,
-0.025981761515140533,
-0.3802335858345032,
-0.5778746604919434,
0.16455873847007751,
0.14028938114643097,
0.7068571448326111,
0.5356544256210327,
0.05311077460646629,
0.7275310754776001,
-0.5279507637023926,
0.28898555040359497,
0.36444297432899475,
-0.3659866154193878,
-0.4368898272514343,
1.0864323377609253,
0.28892001509666443,
-0.41623514890670776,
0.35851019620895386,
-0.44549331068992615,
-0.34886786341667175,
0.8924658894538879,
-0.1755041629076004,
0.9335914850234985,
-0.2504924535751343,
0.1745820790529251,
0.34899482131004333,
0.3121967911720276,
-0.00009211751603288576,
0.5284153819084167,
-0.35534802079200745,
-1.0231153964996338,
0.12697212398052216,
-0.6226704120635986,
-0.43298301100730896,
0.10074863582849503,
-0.7960042953491211,
0.26708418130874634,
-0.8006630539894104,
-0.023001408204436302,
0.4867437183856964,
-0.44900840520858765,
-0.7062628269195557,
0.22797919809818268,
0.2463119626045227,
0.5244119167327881,
-1.0561574697494507,
1.0028390884399414,
0.9209794402122498,
-0.5188228487968445,
-0.5355912446975708,
-0.554075300693512,
0.14891991019248962,
-0.5466720461845398,
0.8791911005973816,
-0.01853065937757492,
-0.39490723609924316,
-0.09520267695188522,
-0.7081182599067688,
-0.6810052394866943,
1.1164470911026,
-0.32423847913742065,
-0.6420094966888428,
0.409810870885849,
0.17905274033546448,
0.785703718662262,
-0.160129114985466,
0.04053220897912979,
0.7032347321510315,
0.3541156053543091,
-0.39164668321609497,
-0.8771553039550781,
0.21439619362354279,
-0.5610617995262146,
-0.24216854572296143,
0.255831778049469,
-0.869024932384491,
0.6187690496444702,
-0.148110032081604,
-0.07951952517032623,
-0.0659586489200592,
0.5979242920875549,
0.3866981863975525,
0.5552334189414978,
0.09266313910484314,
0.32177969813346863,
0.23743906617164612,
0.19777479767799377,
0.7424963116645813,
0.035392358899116516,
0.33434322476387024,
0.8769676089286804,
-0.6271694302558899,
0.5628194212913513,
0.3524695634841919,
-0.47036004066467285,
0.24597714841365814,
0.5745318531990051,
-0.3856029808521271,
0.5623908042907715,
0.28928759694099426,
-0.4363097548484802,
0.02772175334393978,
0.07463006675243378,
-0.49463608860969543,
0.04276401549577713,
0.5778985023498535,
-0.26794272661209106,
0.11973888427019119,
0.3337284028530121,
-0.5537614226341248,
-0.3150534927845001,
-0.31131675839424133,
0.44575992226600647,
-0.136776864528656,
0.117092065513134,
0.3093847930431366,
-0.11326552927494049,
0.6699764728546143,
-0.1690487414598465,
-0.1289246827363968,
0.1179998591542244,
0.2483304888010025,
-0.4038471579551697,
-0.7951504588127136,
0.24203082919120789,
-0.16619731485843658,
0.07934354245662689,
0.059232089668512344,
1.0396814346313477,
-0.5240036249160767,
-0.3327077329158783,
0.07881986349821091,
0.5972866415977478,
0.37123575806617737,
-0.04287358745932579,
-0.6468265652656555,
-0.17889957129955292,
-0.06648171693086624,
-0.12702219188213348,
0.3122425675392151,
0.5807400941848755,
0.14190645515918732,
0.8042324781417847,
0.17627295851707458,
-0.2296256124973297,
0.13133451342582703,
-0.14302201569080353,
0.6385155916213989,
-0.903963029384613,
0.008024693466722965,
-0.5938923954963684,
0.4610747992992401,
0.35137903690338135,
0.05332176014780998,
0.4802922010421753,
0.8486087322235107,
0.9972080588340759,
-0.6294519305229187,
0.7211862206459045,
-0.175790935754776,
0.25339049100875854,
-0.3918538987636566,
0.6080930233001709,
-0.8028426766395569,
-0.02633713372051716,
-0.29931962490081787,
-0.6381151676177979,
-0.1279730498790741,
0.7665634751319885,
0.2808797061443329,
0.01918494887650013,
0.7756667137145996,
0.6826186776161194,
-0.20364771783351898,
-0.18832701444625854,
0.00026458039064891636,
-0.004408610053360462,
0.35666897892951965,
0.45379477739334106,
0.4062809646129608,
-0.881415843963623,
0.47819238901138306,
-0.6082239747047424,
-0.1569361537694931,
-0.40690717101097107,
-0.6772484183311462,
-0.7576346397399902,
-0.6516724228858948,
-0.8100916743278503,
-0.4675705134868622,
-0.05702328681945801,
0.6003572940826416,
0.5447474718093872,
-0.6066464185714722,
-0.24178092181682587,
-0.16374602913856506,
-0.2071908712387085,
-0.1361200511455536,
-0.2502240240573883,
0.3714643120765686,
0.08671873062849045,
-0.6713922619819641,
0.041239526122808456,
0.7066583633422852,
0.3505253791809082,
-0.19316045939922333,
0.2035479098558426,
-0.40279510617256165,
-0.14177414774894714,
0.5331721305847168,
1.009521722793579,
-0.4571891129016876,
-0.40436169505119324,
0.02711334079504013,
-0.18906666338443756,
0.24081522226333618,
0.7996630668640137,
-0.9151555895805359,
0.641015350818634,
0.7227460145950317,
0.4849364459514618,
0.4661518931388855,
-0.06345850974321365,
0.3960086405277252,
-0.9143620729446411,
0.19401869177818298,
0.25086385011672974,
0.11783259361982346,
0.2058839052915573,
-0.4614024758338928,
0.5911713242530823,
0.30667829513549805,
-0.8266939520835876,
-0.666680097579956,
0.039397943764925,
-1.2366806268692017,
-0.29431837797164917,
0.9203504323959351,
0.26676154136657715,
-0.7167465090751648,
-0.45164215564727783,
-0.03579592704772949,
0.38004475831985474,
-0.21685592830181122,
0.6745496988296509,
0.5629993677139282,
-0.5522671937942505,
-0.048650480806827545,
-0.801141619682312,
0.8215453624725342,
0.24086244404315948,
-0.7927267551422119,
-0.09380624443292618,
0.5169034600257874,
0.5628382563591003,
0.36179473996162415,
0.885237455368042,
-0.21421775221824646,
0.37714093923568726,
-0.08017372339963913,
0.6611918210983276,
-0.0328645184636116,
-0.3352617025375366,
-0.1804257184267044,
-0.33510273694992065,
-0.22187213599681854,
-0.5975364446640015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04286v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04286v1
|
Language Model Evolution: An Iterated Learning Perspective
| 2024-04-04T02:01:25 | 2024-04-04T02:01:25 |
Yi Ren, Shangmin Guo, Linlu Qiu, Bailin Wang, Danica J. Sutherland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), the prevalence
of iterative interactions among these models is anticipated to increase.
Notably, recent advancements in multi-round self-improving methods allow LLMs
to generate new examples for training subsequent models. At the same time,
multi-agent LLM systems, involving automated interactions among agents, are
also increasing in prominence. Thus, in both short and long terms, LLMs may
actively engage in an evolutionary process. We draw parallels between the
behavior of LLMs and the evolution of human culture, as the latter has been
extensively studied by cognitive scientists for decades. Our approach involves
leveraging Iterated Learning (IL), a Bayesian framework that elucidates how
subtle biases are magnified during human cultural evolution, to explain some
behaviors of LLMs. This paper outlines key characteristics of agents' behavior
in the Bayesian-IL framework, including predictions that are supported by
experimental verification with various LLMs. This theoretical framework could
help to more effectively predict and guide the evolution of LLMs in desired
directions.
|
[
-0.08479771018028259,
-0.7641675472259521,
0.6958760619163513,
-0.04147949442267418,
-0.029842087998986244,
0.3527930974960327,
-0.4146944582462311,
-0.31799450516700745,
-0.022644683718681335,
0.7284600734710693,
-0.661024808883667,
-0.41954749822616577,
-0.6033756732940674,
0.06689160317182541,
-0.40583470463752747,
0.8789704442024231,
0.24796311557292938,
0.11883225291967392,
-0.13668374717235565,
-0.008618478663265705,
-0.10528084635734558,
-0.3834863603115082,
-0.8380271196365356,
-0.7822524905204773,
0.45466214418411255,
0.3006627857685089,
0.7454774975776672,
0.7055616974830627,
0.2328321784734726,
0.4042266607284546,
0.017018668353557587,
-0.04015576094388962,
-0.4362410604953766,
0.3316306471824646,
-0.2045559585094452,
-0.3841792047023773,
-0.10118434578180313,
-0.07102198898792267,
0.7746233940124512,
0.9800403118133545,
-0.372811883687973,
-0.019640987738966942,
0.057084061205387115,
0.6531333327293396,
-0.3236595094203949,
0.33578744530677795,
-0.7057584524154663,
-0.12257041037082672,
-0.04214227944612503,
-0.2648181915283203,
-0.4647989273071289,
-0.2997859716415405,
0.27607589960098267,
-0.2125091850757599,
0.010626018047332764,
-0.011189503595232964,
0.3736041486263275,
0.07668767124414444,
-0.4820137321949005,
-0.3645045757293701,
-0.9247736930847168,
0.7513648271560669,
-0.718456506729126,
0.26630717515945435,
0.26390406489372253,
0.28809019923210144,
-0.6322746872901917,
-0.5287913680076599,
-0.5104883909225464,
-0.57593834400177,
0.25602421164512634,
-0.004728052765130997,
-0.08640947937965393,
-0.04483502730727196,
-0.023537900298833847,
0.08118925243616104,
-0.3914978802204132,
0.5069750547409058,
-0.38777339458465576,
0.24582815170288086,
0.7122561931610107,
0.12818145751953125,
0.3699875473976135,
0.22997388243675232,
-0.4063042104244232,
-0.22614066302776337,
-0.7931802272796631,
0.045392297208309174,
0.2934769093990326,
0.4357452392578125,
-0.02753537707030773,
0.3307976722717285,
0.0451604500412941,
0.5517539978027344,
0.07486315816640854,
-0.4548267126083374,
0.2696376144886017,
-0.015299087390303612,
0.016770435497164726,
0.0745491236448288,
0.8703864216804504,
0.06864495575428009,
0.5763447880744934,
-0.13034199178218842,
-0.11812280118465424,
-0.030268006026744843,
0.26395946741104126,
-0.47378888726234436,
0.05879810452461243,
0.16756372153759003,
-0.3813401162624359,
-0.4470219612121582,
-0.1876835823059082,
-0.6649752259254456,
-0.5590649843215942,
-0.31014150381088257,
0.4236736297607422,
-0.33939287066459656,
-0.6978105902671814,
0.17181333899497986,
-0.10137749463319778,
0.14589941501617432,
0.23579001426696777,
-0.7839862704277039,
0.3502105474472046,
0.7415536046028137,
0.45961567759513855,
-0.2533796727657318,
-0.6750782132148743,
-0.18823829293251038,
0.24619179964065552,
-0.6270205974578857,
0.7562128305435181,
-0.7494097948074341,
-0.3414340615272522,
0.20037095248699188,
-0.09776043891906738,
-0.19110487401485443,
-0.5218636393547058,
0.22430355846881866,
-0.6426575183868408,
0.298531711101532,
-0.07896357029676437,
-0.6234325170516968,
-0.39521440863609314,
0.15109655261039734,
-0.5282209515571594,
0.8362278938293457,
0.12348274886608124,
-0.554624617099762,
0.4272565543651581,
-0.598704993724823,
-0.29680177569389343,
0.08642832934856415,
-0.3876749873161316,
-0.5480653047561646,
0.299294650554657,
-0.07390660047531128,
0.4454652667045593,
-0.582005500793457,
0.39130109548568726,
-0.7440263032913208,
-0.2240852564573288,
0.4038710296154022,
-0.34015822410583496,
1.1250925064086914,
0.28010833263397217,
-0.38443946838378906,
0.09710134565830231,
-0.7558410167694092,
-0.1996770054101944,
0.2516750991344452,
-0.4328003525733948,
-0.322089821100235,
0.3951229155063629,
-0.5740776062011719,
0.2650396227836609,
0.028013357892632484,
-0.1458331048488617,
0.5725964903831482,
-0.38335981965065,
0.48249363899230957,
0.8785369396209717,
0.22421811521053314,
0.8462370038032532,
-0.5370258092880249,
0.40528392791748047,
0.15823179483413696,
0.28478309512138367,
-0.148386150598526,
-0.330800861120224,
-0.6023745536804199,
-0.3142891228199005,
-0.15297366678714752,
0.34657397866249084,
-0.6513283252716064,
0.237228125333786,
-0.4161337912082672,
-0.4068303406238556,
-0.4212050139904022,
0.4233172535896301,
-0.021748678758740425,
0.02799440547823906,
0.09762809425592422,
-0.2999343276023865,
-0.16547563672065735,
-0.5539039969444275,
-0.12280046939849854,
-0.594314694404602,
0.07199804484844208,
0.025232607498764992,
0.37101688981056213,
-0.5757089257240295,
0.8531200885772705,
0.177769273519516,
0.11517774313688278,
-0.509727418422699,
0.2264469712972641,
0.18359272181987762,
0.3680661618709564,
0.6548110246658325,
-0.39440426230430603,
-0.26660460233688354,
0.09517553448677063,
-0.600237250328064,
-0.19651517271995544,
-0.24314168095588684,
0.10559552907943726,
0.29992517828941345,
0.5314109921455383,
-0.36968502402305603,
0.2760600745677948,
0.5978877544403076,
-0.14978906512260437,
0.37565723061561584,
-0.20138388872146606,
-0.06754139810800552,
-1.1850810050964355,
-0.4081338942050934,
0.023541783913969994,
0.11209970712661743,
-0.7891819477081299,
-0.05741599202156067,
-0.15809288620948792,
0.3562323749065399,
0.000014865450793877244,
0.7193825840950012,
-0.6869721412658691,
-0.5237546563148499,
-0.4822619557380676,
0.07358947396278381,
-0.357125461101532,
0.37442460656166077,
0.26761674880981445,
0.3209482729434967,
0.8130873441696167,
-0.7617642283439636,
0.17642603814601898,
-0.287326455116272,
-0.29788637161254883,
0.27587735652923584,
-0.2359941154718399,
0.057320285588502884,
-0.4444813132286072,
0.16542018949985504,
-0.9363988041877747,
0.09411395341157913,
0.25450730323791504,
-0.42211756110191345,
0.3420868515968323,
0.05718999728560448,
-0.728815495967865,
-0.23757092654705048,
-0.2870129942893982,
0.11907636374235153,
0.46884894371032715,
-0.7092076539993286,
0.753922164440155,
-0.05942262336611748,
-0.30011940002441406,
-0.5675398111343384,
-0.08731870353221893,
0.19995750486850739,
-0.4631427526473999,
-0.5919381976127625,
-0.014237496070563793,
-0.33063116669654846,
-0.8961650133132935,
-0.2827658951282501,
0.09938129037618637,
-0.03299526870250702,
0.46811985969543457,
0.13598038256168365,
0.12761501967906952,
-0.2752934992313385,
0.31213122606277466,
0.018446391448378563,
0.11091479659080505,
0.08486942946910858,
-0.386474072933197,
0.5962953567504883,
0.06037498265504837,
-0.34957680106163025,
-0.2849755883216858,
0.19937726855278015,
0.6058728694915771,
-0.013080774806439877,
0.8078367114067078,
0.36618006229400635,
-0.12793877720832825,
-0.3283776342868805,
-0.6041831374168396,
-0.41454577445983887,
-0.4750239849090576,
0.3335738182067871,
-0.4863080382347107,
-0.780809760093689,
0.619491457939148,
-0.42016714811325073,
0.23742012679576874,
0.3241692781448364,
0.7397382259368896,
-0.1824442446231842,
1.1180206537246704,
1.00206458568573,
-0.268090158700943,
0.698673665523529,
0.025639712810516357,
-0.05784022808074951,
-0.4685664474964142,
-0.09930575639009476,
-0.5623593330383301,
0.0017001229571178555,
-1.126912236213684,
-0.31688663363456726,
0.20865623652935028,
0.3128741383552551,
-0.5771840810775757,
0.07382972538471222,
0.07672280818223953,
0.36221790313720703,
0.3747733235359192,
-0.01695249415934086,
0.40016788244247437,
0.16154040396213531,
-0.28745368123054504,
0.44610467553138733,
-0.6368708610534668,
-0.5579600930213928,
1.0209226608276367,
0.4722520411014557,
1.0812227725982666,
0.33461394906044006,
0.7844446897506714,
0.31271910667419434,
0.5330906510353088,
-0.5131579041481018,
0.31813934445381165,
0.04304958134889603,
-0.6437132954597473,
-0.18884672224521637,
-0.1810941994190216,
-1.0335969924926758,
0.12871217727661133,
-0.16500599682331085,
-1.2070345878601074,
0.22349564731121063,
-0.03826560452580452,
0.10014200955629349,
0.15195874869823456,
-0.4197849631309509,
0.45532235503196716,
-0.4701617658138275,
-0.44512230157852173,
-0.3876233994960785,
-0.7461344599723816,
0.23058147728443146,
-0.1917576789855957,
0.4408915638923645,
-0.06325394660234451,
0.061028458178043365,
0.4230351448059082,
-0.07387630641460419,
1.0996125936508179,
0.0726892501115799,
-0.4012513756752014,
0.20133936405181885,
0.23176810145378113,
0.3789171874523163,
-0.026988331228494644,
-0.35714098811149597,
0.1563354879617691,
-0.14283186197280884,
-0.4390659034252167,
-0.4285013675689697,
0.4365249276161194,
-1.078359842300415,
-0.7543780207633972,
-0.3930414915084839,
-0.5643124580383301,
-0.1906253695487976,
-0.07924526929855347,
0.1279873102903366,
0.1806449443101883,
-0.027667324990034103,
-0.04360084608197212,
0.5649709105491638,
-0.2220233529806137,
0.7333590984344482,
0.8529177904129028,
-0.44846755266189575,
-0.03517032787203789,
0.5328304767608643,
-0.1035880297422409,
0.5024024248123169,
0.3233225345611572,
0.40517106652259827,
-0.025818457826972008,
-0.6408207416534424,
-0.15854202210903168,
0.4509367346763611,
-0.8034646511077881,
0.19223971664905548,
-0.3815136253833771,
-0.12992824614048004,
-0.5016486048698425,
-0.1372191607952118,
-0.26228007674217224,
-0.03942316398024559,
-0.2753424048423767,
-0.0998162180185318,
0.2117643505334854,
1.1558818817138672,
-0.1549200415611267,
0.6227502226829529,
-0.5671800374984741,
-0.21711689233779907,
0.19213245809078217,
0.15893393754959106,
0.012736838310956955,
-0.7017292976379395,
-0.054783765226602554,
0.01520715281367302,
-0.22923687100410461,
-1.1069908142089844,
0.37984398007392883,
0.3902333676815033,
0.9207689762115479,
0.9083641767501831,
-0.21248310804367065,
0.42992883920669556,
-0.459276020526886,
0.6401824355125427,
-0.01820012368261814,
-0.6508309841156006,
0.2994115650653839,
-0.4140323996543884,
0.13024164736270905,
0.1412004679441452,
0.5056517124176025,
-0.4038262963294983,
-0.5113692879676819,
-0.5414465069770813,
-0.537431001663208,
0.549943745136261,
-0.17796704173088074,
0.25231584906578064,
-0.06157027184963226,
0.5987011194229126,
0.4867200255393982,
0.220516636967659,
-1.0280070304870605,
-0.11006221175193787,
-0.009449496865272522,
-0.17809085547924042,
-0.38703152537345886,
-0.20339787006378174,
-0.1067715436220169,
-0.2332608699798584,
0.6461701393127441,
-0.356238454580307,
0.3390403687953949,
-0.45926353335380554,
-0.4060155153274536,
-0.1824641078710556,
0.3235129117965698,
0.6764647960662842,
0.8702846169471741,
-0.07203512638807297,
0.06398200988769531,
-0.060474321246147156,
-0.03848710656166077,
0.14664524793624878,
-0.0035271821543574333,
0.07410752028226852,
-0.20066876709461212,
0.545372724533081,
0.9311941266059875,
-0.05270940065383911,
-0.5254271626472473,
0.3225497007369995,
-0.06116877496242523,
-0.09106779843568802,
-0.5897206664085388,
0.14790531992912292,
0.18350648880004883,
0.8283582329750061,
0.5357078313827515,
-0.24703826010227203,
-0.060544613748788834,
-1.0134387016296387,
0.22927536070346832,
0.4465698301792145,
-0.08576637506484985,
-0.4836183488368988,
0.20145036280155182,
-0.07709077000617981,
-0.42448651790618896,
0.47295916080474854,
-0.2917933762073517,
-0.6112887263298035,
0.5811347961425781,
0.6751601696014404,
0.9991266131401062,
-0.4489388167858124,
0.3568294942378998,
0.27429020404815674,
0.4344725012779236,
-0.3325309157371521,
-0.013045310974121094,
-0.27099987864494324,
-1.1463584899902344,
-0.3946300148963928,
-0.7369967103004456,
-0.49608010053634644,
0.07091299444437027,
-0.45889943838119507,
0.26778867840766907,
-0.21379129588603973,
0.07537393271923065,
-0.06351438164710999,
-0.07097482681274414,
-0.6975609064102173,
0.033610712736845016,
0.412789523601532,
0.6053112149238586,
-0.9480315446853638,
1.1014387607574463,
0.793608546257019,
-0.3397864103317261,
-0.4530128836631775,
0.250784307718277,
0.07001364976167679,
-1.2055070400238037,
0.9348154664039612,
0.12333565205335617,
-0.10593297332525253,
0.12887455523014069,
-0.5947529077529907,
-0.9752082824707031,
0.9685022234916687,
0.17411887645721436,
-0.6398266553878784,
-0.03179135546088219,
0.2116512954235077,
0.7097631692886353,
-0.7702112197875977,
0.4626336991786957,
0.7066404223442078,
0.1736203283071518,
0.12428836524486542,
-0.6627786755561829,
-0.25197863578796387,
-0.02630443312227726,
0.21797963976860046,
-0.014895380474627018,
-0.4901464283466339,
0.847569465637207,
-0.6684618592262268,
-0.09073759615421295,
0.11944801360368729,
0.5377761125564575,
0.22506390511989594,
0.1783781498670578,
0.5190045237541199,
0.21931573748588562,
0.49689623713493347,
0.054683882743120193,
0.7831697463989258,
-0.41290003061294556,
0.157100111246109,
1.2513785362243652,
-0.536129355430603,
0.852931022644043,
0.42850545048713684,
-0.1384473592042923,
0.8974754810333252,
0.9182454943656921,
0.07662208378314972,
0.39710375666618347,
0.4629107713699341,
-0.33895161747932434,
-0.21699059009552002,
0.14250759780406952,
0.011131546460092068,
0.8021313548088074,
0.47832244634628296,
-0.5758923888206482,
-0.3282701373100281,
0.2249871790409088,
0.18448999524116516,
-0.047760386019945145,
-0.2919522523880005,
1.2618606090545654,
-0.10948560386896133,
-0.7623929381370544,
0.20917817950248718,
-0.1816965788602829,
0.5695338249206543,
-0.4480217695236206,
0.0013265078887343407,
-0.37688320875167847,
0.1959589123725891,
0.08718010783195496,
-0.5190172791481018,
-0.25275951623916626,
-0.2370368242263794,
-0.137750506401062,
-0.2085946649312973,
0.6162126064300537,
-0.4933602511882782,
-0.3948688209056854,
0.6623071432113647,
0.782854437828064,
0.13742457330226898,
0.3004339933395386,
-0.6371323466300964,
0.22762776911258698,
-0.1333945393562317,
-0.4615003168582916,
0.48560667037963867,
0.414101243019104,
-0.27226176857948303,
0.9745158553123474,
0.2711951434612274,
0.10796798020601273,
0.20280468463897705,
0.26849764585494995,
0.5529950857162476,
-0.6083186864852905,
-0.16356676816940308,
-1.1560025215148926,
0.3970707356929779,
-0.002415955299511552,
0.14692363142967224,
0.40440234541893005,
-0.11869168281555176,
0.7735484838485718,
0.1744828224182129,
0.860416054725647,
0.30804872512817383,
0.3882942795753479,
-0.32470208406448364,
0.409968763589859,
-0.5210054516792297,
0.5637749433517456,
-0.14140895009040833,
-1.041318655014038,
0.1726064682006836,
0.638518214225769,
-0.2355494499206543,
0.4218190312385559,
0.6906845569610596,
0.5522362589836121,
0.5087407231330872,
0.005019978154450655,
0.22535498440265656,
0.4023345708847046,
0.37742581963539124,
0.19398225843906403,
0.9244689345359802,
0.03630416467785835,
0.3026260733604431,
-0.29138675332069397,
-0.3371172249317169,
-0.15675875544548035,
-0.9460288286209106,
-0.9081383347511292,
-0.7620563507080078,
-0.5519886016845703,
-0.09947618842124939,
0.16859348118305206,
1.248504877090454,
0.41971877217292786,
-0.510718584060669,
-0.761982798576355,
-0.0837181881070137,
0.16129077970981598,
-0.3138671815395355,
-0.22041164338588715,
-0.061264511197805405,
-0.586551308631897,
-0.7876135110855103,
0.28579211235046387,
0.3593168556690216,
0.1761162430047989,
-0.4957517981529236,
-0.1280834674835205,
-0.21307332813739777,
0.27236828207969666,
0.6833497285842896,
0.3796371519565582,
-0.8283131718635559,
-0.3634984791278839,
-0.17615777254104614,
-0.0454980842769146,
0.08709745109081268,
0.47541093826293945,
-0.7558907270431519,
0.6056587100028992,
0.24546226859092712,
0.5661669969558716,
0.2889534831047058,
-0.34553664922714233,
0.7709526419639587,
-0.529150664806366,
-0.1514284610748291,
0.005188328213989735,
0.35364845395088196,
0.30504363775253296,
0.1038723886013031,
0.5148555636405945,
0.11893925070762634,
-0.7198624610900879,
-0.7554098963737488,
0.33426633477211,
-0.6754983067512512,
-0.5027093291282654,
1.347166895866394,
0.043253954499959946,
-0.16962459683418274,
-0.0031230959575623274,
0.08832431584596634,
0.2724348306655884,
-0.3769403100013733,
1.2223163843154907,
0.6886797547340393,
-0.31381139159202576,
-0.5378183126449585,
-0.5571455955505371,
0.5140020251274109,
0.20908236503601074,
-0.9735758304595947,
0.02681860327720642,
0.32575473189353943,
0.5661000609397888,
0.153359517455101,
0.5057092905044556,
0.16517630219459534,
0.23472626507282257,
-0.24486185610294342,
0.12931109964847565,
0.5276426672935486,
-0.3115293085575104,
-0.3657281994819641,
0.010360284708440304,
0.6667307615280151,
0.07805409282445908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03150v1
|
NLP at UC Santa Cruz at SemEval-2024 Task 5: Legal Answer Validation using Few-Shot Multi-Choice QA
| 2024-04-04T01:50:20 | 2024-04-04T01:50:20 |
Anish Pahilajani, Samyak Rajesh Jain, Devasha Trivedi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents our submission to the SemEval 2024 Task 5: The Legal
Argument Reasoning Task in Civil Procedure. We present two approaches to
solving the task of legal answer validation, given an introduction to the case,
a question and an answer candidate. Firstly, we fine-tuned pre-trained
BERT-based models and found that models trained on domain knowledge perform
better. Secondly, we performed few-shot prompting on GPT models and found that
reformulating the answer validation task to be a multiple-choice QA task
remarkably improves the performance of the model. Our best submission is a
BERT-based model that achieved the 7th place out of 20.
|
[
-0.35458675026893616,
-0.788379967212677,
1.0534472465515137,
0.03462297096848488,
-0.43781110644340515,
-0.3004615008831024,
0.13072042167186737,
-0.45929092168807983,
-0.07572957128286362,
0.49207547307014465,
-0.524324357509613,
-0.24646179378032684,
-0.4248593747615814,
0.23810423910617828,
-0.18312788009643555,
1.074250340461731,
0.2855744957923889,
0.6477234959602356,
-0.3682646155357361,
-0.27181342244148254,
-0.561734676361084,
-0.6900485754013062,
-0.6889766454696655,
-0.38066405057907104,
0.6458806395530701,
0.19972670078277588,
0.4402993619441986,
0.1993626058101654,
0.5484796166419983,
0.18919876217842102,
-0.22978933155536652,
-0.198406383395195,
-0.06202682480216026,
-0.024906842038035393,
-0.24381808936595917,
-0.5874882340431213,
-0.16243067383766174,
-0.11481869965791702,
0.10345600545406342,
0.3027997612953186,
-0.16484443843364716,
0.3002650737762451,
-0.24272675812244415,
0.42280375957489014,
-0.4034007489681244,
-0.15672074258327484,
-0.9648295044898987,
0.00993525329977274,
-0.08854445815086365,
-0.060668304562568665,
-0.44263216853141785,
-0.5071360468864441,
0.18272189795970917,
-0.34170064330101013,
0.2452007532119751,
-0.29168790578842163,
1.1064754724502563,
0.7161112427711487,
-0.3907146751880646,
-0.1374548226594925,
-0.4820968806743622,
0.5255480408668518,
-0.9751374125480652,
0.09478576481342316,
0.35209372639656067,
0.61063551902771,
-0.07828133553266525,
-0.6947999000549316,
-0.5864573121070862,
-0.2162119299173355,
0.24959592521190643,
0.2883688807487488,
-0.03274312987923622,
0.18430638313293457,
0.45399951934814453,
-0.3798994719982147,
-0.8317425847053528,
0.09208013862371445,
-0.5316764116287231,
-0.2649247348308563,
0.6480677723884583,
-0.1491391956806183,
0.06817129254341125,
-0.11885170638561249,
-0.3282942771911621,
0.1450696587562561,
-0.826304018497467,
0.27720698714256287,
0.4817337691783905,
0.2452460378408432,
0.23962543904781342,
0.5778278708457947,
-0.0602487213909626,
0.7737230658531189,
0.03530224785208702,
0.10035249590873718,
0.017444657161831856,
-0.2634589672088623,
-0.41327399015426636,
0.0287172794342041,
0.43988022208213806,
-0.030792348086833954,
-0.0421774722635746,
0.42674797773361206,
0.05916273593902588,
-0.2409532070159912,
0.4224174916744232,
-0.4757991433143616,
-0.0033086715266108513,
0.6118088364601135,
-0.6060031652450562,
-0.22304563224315643,
-0.15566270053386688,
-0.6350929141044617,
-0.35057637095451355,
-0.2777863144874573,
0.5542008280754089,
-0.20535610616207123,
0.3273872435092926,
0.25971102714538574,
-0.2568058967590332,
0.49563759565353394,
0.8821827173233032,
-0.5826053619384766,
0.05840776488184929,
0.677107036113739,
0.2114255428314209,
0.16337783634662628,
-0.14621038734912872,
-0.7316269278526306,
-0.03749827295541763,
-0.21114106476306915,
1.2055305242538452,
-0.4541690945625305,
-0.0003992304264102131,
-0.03638165071606636,
-0.13692954182624817,
0.24248890578746796,
-0.48722484707832336,
0.9744798541069031,
-0.7945604920387268,
0.24049592018127441,
-0.5786582827568054,
-0.5049910545349121,
-0.39827218651771545,
0.54026198387146,
-0.4983315169811249,
0.8954747319221497,
0.02199793979525566,
-0.5209282636642456,
0.7200626134872437,
-0.9837987422943115,
-0.3734718859195709,
0.23634476959705353,
-0.24193954467773438,
-0.682837724685669,
0.015047687105834484,
0.34695470333099365,
0.4025779962539673,
-0.022132759913802147,
0.3591337203979492,
-0.5681401491165161,
-0.11858174949884415,
-0.020527856424450874,
-0.3728857934474945,
1.1929740905761719,
0.3746311068534851,
-0.26933297514915466,
0.008413435891270638,
-0.7450686693191528,
0.1723737269639969,
0.21164573729038239,
-0.6360665559768677,
0.0219988115131855,
-0.04034245386719704,
-0.35479703545570374,
0.6208645105361938,
0.1715226173400879,
-0.6747311949729919,
0.2575453221797943,
-0.32006603479385376,
0.3278179168701172,
0.7182633280754089,
0.20243501663208008,
-0.04921393841505051,
-0.2627459168434143,
0.7959784269332886,
-0.014193613082170486,
0.16970431804656982,
-0.04312264919281006,
-1.023732304573059,
-0.523883044719696,
0.14966626465320587,
0.6325364708900452,
0.6171627640724182,
-0.7194768190383911,
0.12556736171245575,
0.06714369356632233,
-0.38428136706352234,
-0.5020586848258972,
-0.17160919308662415,
-0.026580672711133957,
0.4273305833339691,
0.5875579118728638,
-0.058209072798490524,
-0.7864439487457275,
-0.7821228504180908,
-0.2555783987045288,
-0.49514999985694885,
0.12480095028877258,
0.4426783323287964,
0.9254564046859741,
0.03307221457362175,
1.071840524673462,
-0.3093673884868622,
-0.1729053258895874,
-0.2005275934934616,
0.46829912066459656,
0.45138734579086304,
0.2501344382762909,
0.7496352791786194,
-0.6516650915145874,
-0.3773258924484253,
-0.07734888046979904,
-0.5146262049674988,
-0.3233683407306671,
-0.36143702268600464,
0.24857184290885925,
0.0678042322397232,
0.20661300420761108,
-0.19590653479099274,
0.38274693489074707,
0.2998449206352234,
-0.22738343477249146,
0.8030728697776794,
-0.11397690325975418,
0.1987883746623993,
-0.8059507012367249,
-0.14499403536319733,
-0.18508793413639069,
-0.5272682309150696,
-0.5685904026031494,
0.04613480344414711,
-0.20438478887081146,
-0.3402252793312073,
-0.9466571807861328,
0.2713356614112854,
-0.1241626963019371,
-0.15791229903697968,
-0.26821860671043396,
-0.1384170949459076,
-0.1529240757226944,
0.5155593752861023,
0.17167863249778748,
0.6342397928237915,
0.2770681381225586,
-0.41659337282180786,
0.6065241694450378,
0.30869075655937195,
0.005348691716790199,
0.7173255681991577,
-0.8126736879348755,
0.3451869487762451,
-0.2710483968257904,
0.4088439345359802,
-1.0375354290008545,
-0.23896539211273193,
-0.17522376775741577,
-0.3699352741241455,
-0.07870279252529144,
-0.5356472730636597,
-0.4150921404361725,
-0.7007191777229309,
-0.20859982073307037,
0.12830676138401031,
0.19506509602069855,
-0.430923193693161,
0.7687078714370728,
0.18627707660198212,
-0.38845911622047424,
-0.701126754283905,
-0.7416982650756836,
0.13267335295677185,
-0.2217874675989151,
-0.5647875666618347,
0.2166902720928192,
-0.18332669138908386,
0.012902024202048779,
-0.05590786784887314,
0.15338639914989471,
-0.44001007080078125,
0.14440299570560455,
0.012254494242370129,
0.06956594437360764,
-0.33720722794532776,
0.11973480880260468,
0.3101997673511505,
0.08065912127494812,
0.257450670003891,
-0.037723224610090256,
0.404214084148407,
-0.2265440821647644,
-0.6373318433761597,
-0.4093192219734192,
0.5855710506439209,
0.24443012475967407,
-0.07567386329174042,
0.18400545418262482,
0.30953994393348694,
-0.3954446017742157,
0.0762687623500824,
-0.7883002161979675,
-0.22544077038764954,
-0.342936247587204,
0.1000841036438942,
-0.47589534521102905,
-1.1287145614624023,
0.5642860531806946,
-0.029710471630096436,
0.5084660649299622,
0.5683907270431519,
0.8091769814491272,
-0.38527560234069824,
1.0742740631103516,
0.26222914457321167,
0.12425818294286728,
0.1366252601146698,
0.023696981370449066,
0.24594636261463165,
-0.3943663537502289,
-0.0022894551511853933,
-1.1341495513916016,
-0.04039499908685684,
-0.28976142406463623,
-0.3498074412345886,
0.6251558065414429,
-0.019697360694408417,
-0.16639403998851776,
0.5359585285186768,
-0.5327180027961731,
0.5993524789810181,
0.764863133430481,
-0.06184859946370125,
0.07535459846258163,
-0.39617836475372314,
-0.5720363855361938,
0.16514910757541656,
-0.7662478089332581,
-0.6846707463264465,
1.0139678716659546,
0.532766580581665,
0.45779702067375183,
0.2216038703918457,
1.065893530845642,
0.10067492723464966,
-0.06708604097366333,
-0.7423722147941589,
0.6771417856216431,
0.009203820489346981,
-1.0616744756698608,
-0.6019171476364136,
0.05590797960758209,
-0.9596818685531616,
0.42508119344711304,
-0.27365344762802124,
-0.5132533311843872,
0.13818992674350739,
-0.005051635671406984,
-1.0147346258163452,
-0.16115881502628326,
-0.5693228244781494,
0.8404219150543213,
-0.3108384907245636,
-0.20681345462799072,
-0.03841618075966835,
-0.959283173084259,
0.2007751762866974,
0.0892452821135521,
-0.09356161952018738,
-0.13900062441825867,
0.2674367427825928,
0.6064488291740417,
-0.4783613085746765,
0.7508977055549622,
-0.3296731412410736,
-0.09406587481498718,
0.600153923034668,
-0.33255335688591003,
0.6189457774162292,
0.18016019463539124,
-0.1258563995361328,
-0.14701451361179352,
0.5066733360290527,
-0.26106953620910645,
-0.5804053544998169,
0.22567473351955414,
-0.537074089050293,
-0.6892580389976501,
-0.5773388743400574,
-0.21958070993423462,
-0.18077924847602844,
0.21866169571876526,
0.15911272168159485,
0.03978448733687401,
-0.11751126497983932,
0.23355329036712646,
0.5334083437919617,
-0.2535012364387512,
0.5873087644577026,
0.41457894444465637,
0.13541622459888458,
-0.3386678695678711,
0.36048269271850586,
0.13879187405109406,
-0.1622040867805481,
0.2585841417312622,
0.4840882420539856,
-0.6954388618469238,
-0.7356768846511841,
-0.5530959963798523,
0.20484738051891327,
-1.0154896974563599,
-0.2659658193588257,
-0.7120445966720581,
-0.2636738419532776,
-0.723753035068512,
-0.22382424771785736,
-0.15297186374664307,
-0.5350639820098877,
-0.36866042017936707,
0.026318896561861038,
-0.21859712898731232,
0.645131528377533,
0.10225187987089157,
-0.07318820804357529,
-0.9808492660522461,
0.22991929948329926,
0.8296056389808655,
-0.021890902891755104,
-0.6096199750900269,
-0.5522604584693909,
0.10134362429380417,
-0.11679200828075409,
-0.5284168124198914,
-0.9606149792671204,
0.043605607002973557,
-0.03883860632777214,
0.7508734464645386,
0.29842260479927063,
-0.1179569736123085,
0.8743041157722473,
-0.7497319579124451,
1.2731964588165283,
0.0676460713148117,
-0.8318358063697815,
1.1950799226760864,
-0.3681076765060425,
0.3288576304912567,
0.8431591391563416,
0.34640929102897644,
-0.058590494096279144,
-0.46915727853775024,
-0.9280400276184082,
-0.37393641471862793,
0.4635554552078247,
0.05035034194588661,
0.14726552367210388,
0.1291894167661667,
0.28038299083709717,
0.03354448452591896,
0.09727209806442261,
-1.1374390125274658,
0.17653825879096985,
-0.22981761395931244,
0.08520784229040146,
0.6003697514533997,
-0.37799498438835144,
-0.4233805239200592,
-0.2132883220911026,
0.8590207695960999,
-0.5524097681045532,
0.3814694881439209,
0.13197240233421326,
0.024874646216630936,
0.16196472942829132,
0.7892546653747559,
1.1737004518508911,
0.7476740479469299,
-0.033174969255924225,
0.11479289084672928,
0.5920190811157227,
-0.1431499719619751,
0.37145495414733887,
0.10572773963212967,
-0.23745612800121307,
0.2653588652610779,
0.30668097734451294,
0.4882201552391052,
-0.2749713957309723,
-0.41492390632629395,
0.8356594443321228,
-0.054655853658914566,
-0.7405574321746826,
-0.3627743124961853,
-0.1757258027791977,
-0.1333661526441574,
0.27152034640312195,
0.3156389594078064,
0.0534648597240448,
0.37411606311798096,
-0.35643699765205383,
0.2893954813480377,
0.4798568785190582,
-0.37817758321762085,
-0.1044565737247467,
0.8317950963973999,
0.09478548169136047,
0.09221131354570389,
0.05133850872516632,
-0.255183607339859,
-0.6382665634155273,
0.7339107990264893,
0.4923332631587982,
0.6831741333007812,
-0.09446056187152863,
0.3334163725376129,
0.5140150785446167,
0.10632294416427612,
-0.21551735699176788,
0.7099372148513794,
0.009265255182981491,
-0.6640633344650269,
-0.6770226955413818,
-0.3100181221961975,
-0.4683595299720764,
0.32791855931282043,
-0.3526378870010376,
0.4978184700012207,
-0.4468444883823395,
-0.2215421497821808,
-0.006759971845895052,
0.020298898220062256,
-0.5237751603126526,
0.37913060188293457,
0.007201333995908499,
0.7593169212341309,
-1.0072243213653564,
0.8412902355194092,
0.9726351499557495,
-0.5997392535209656,
-0.8875654935836792,
-0.2665500342845917,
0.2586837112903595,
-0.52308589220047,
0.8137171268463135,
-0.07356955111026764,
-0.029687587171792984,
-0.16046598553657532,
-0.9087237119674683,
-0.4831869304180145,
0.9125717282295227,
0.483424574136734,
-0.4474862217903137,
0.0992279052734375,
0.10933930426836014,
0.6325225830078125,
-0.05980305001139641,
0.3230789601802826,
0.4110291600227356,
0.5036187767982483,
0.4686824679374695,
-0.8861121535301208,
-0.23171067237854004,
0.022426459938287735,
0.11129192262887955,
-0.2636197507381439,
-0.24550385773181915,
0.4370645582675934,
-0.39987513422966003,
0.08767139166593552,
-0.0018401656998321414,
0.8189895153045654,
0.6116969585418701,
0.19478803873062134,
0.5952349901199341,
0.7247607707977295,
0.7642033696174622,
-0.35480719804763794,
0.8819783329963684,
0.12750442326068878,
0.4875201880931854,
1.3739317655563354,
-0.6190965175628662,
0.9671252965927124,
0.6662536263465881,
-0.46232566237449646,
0.4324166476726532,
0.8125463128089905,
-0.22851531207561493,
0.42871615290641785,
0.22334866225719452,
-0.231036975979805,
-0.4642966389656067,
-0.0686904564499855,
-0.2255428433418274,
0.7899541258811951,
-0.02599858120083809,
-0.11340098828077316,
-0.46272099018096924,
0.08449699729681015,
-0.24941667914390564,
-0.06507266312837601,
-0.15194612741470337,
0.9628880023956299,
-0.06659365445375443,
-0.9708389639854431,
0.24882516264915466,
0.015266578644514084,
0.3076304495334625,
-0.3687371611595154,
-0.34653240442276,
0.1847875565290451,
-0.30617818236351013,
-0.22070255875587463,
-1.0339174270629883,
0.3422742187976837,
0.2450244128704071,
0.023838981986045837,
-0.3157060444355011,
0.8570749759674072,
-0.2327786386013031,
-0.20387960970401764,
-0.13535934686660767,
0.3696903586387634,
0.20385637879371643,
0.017342325299978256,
-1.2721408605575562,
-0.4412779211997986,
-0.1270984709262848,
-0.0520654059946537,
-0.022150147706270218,
0.39653515815734863,
-0.1499767154455185,
0.5531309247016907,
0.8319938778877258,
0.21137331426143646,
0.346469521522522,
0.5653766393661499,
0.7103263735771179,
-0.35756823420524597,
-0.62417072057724,
-0.6903740763664246,
0.7127688527107239,
-0.04738226532936096,
-0.25062915682792664,
0.2762922942638397,
0.5776848793029785,
0.5763999223709106,
-0.2798733413219452,
0.7306088805198669,
-0.09053904563188553,
0.7172121405601501,
-0.7094039916992188,
0.3020407557487488,
-0.2975523769855499,
0.18902984261512756,
-0.317359060049057,
-0.6176440715789795,
-0.6388656497001648,
0.7741631269454956,
-0.31974682211875916,
0.08822190761566162,
0.8861843347549438,
0.6435571908950806,
0.15616671741008759,
0.06854679435491562,
0.6367940902709961,
-0.2146843820810318,
0.581659197807312,
0.7589520215988159,
1.0256632566452026,
-0.47177985310554504,
0.5930466651916504,
0.011052900925278664,
0.16497193276882172,
-0.33849072456359863,
-1.2328879833221436,
-0.652099072933197,
-0.5363938808441162,
-0.3304910361766815,
-0.4297447204589844,
-0.13666744530200958,
0.9000570178031921,
0.7806861996650696,
-1.0618479251861572,
0.10160764306783676,
-0.09760799258947372,
0.1194077730178833,
-0.2968353033065796,
-0.20935553312301636,
0.06453852355480194,
-0.6264292597770691,
-0.521023154258728,
0.4529499411582947,
0.40408673882484436,
0.2190355658531189,
-0.010309590958058834,
0.20336057245731354,
-0.6382324695587158,
0.22005358338356018,
0.720211386680603,
0.2962791919708252,
-1.0248222351074219,
-0.5810440182685852,
-0.20236538350582123,
-0.13143043220043182,
0.3945139944553375,
0.7763264775276184,
-0.6871323585510254,
0.3992917537689209,
0.7542229294776917,
1.1388282775878906,
0.4407980740070343,
0.23288892209529877,
0.5270009636878967,
-0.724453866481781,
-0.09222928434610367,
0.692956268787384,
0.5727425217628479,
-0.13349905610084534,
-0.42116206884384155,
0.7633629441261292,
0.13226987421512604,
-0.815108597278595,
-0.5287190675735474,
0.161857008934021,
-1.2385705709457397,
-0.36275970935821533,
1.0654147863388062,
-0.39773163199424744,
-0.09209530055522919,
-0.5742589235305786,
-0.4026925265789032,
-0.10186205059289932,
-0.21123450994491577,
0.6333836913108826,
1.160431146621704,
-0.34518542885780334,
-0.4716934859752655,
-0.7690515518188477,
0.5074391961097717,
0.5891634821891785,
-1.316745400428772,
-0.4936615228652954,
0.5470250248908997,
0.2987821698188782,
0.33110642433166504,
0.7990306615829468,
-0.2643083930015564,
0.845507025718689,
-0.28541427850723267,
-0.09194314479827881,
0.11785618215799332,
-0.36158108711242676,
-0.778687059879303,
0.4945279359817505,
0.23380006849765778,
-0.11609144508838654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03134v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03134v2
|
Robust Pronoun Fidelity with English LLMs: Are they Reasoning, Repeating, or Just Biased?
| 2024-04-04T01:07:14 | 2024-05-01T21:35:00 |
Vagrant Gautam, Eileen Bingert, Dawei Zhu, Anne Lauscher, Dietrich Klakow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Robust, faithful and harm-free pronoun use for individuals is an important
goal for language models as their use increases, but prior work tends to study
only one or two of these characteristics at a time. To measure progress towards
the combined goal, we introduce the task of pronoun fidelity: given a context
introducing a co-referring entity and pronoun, the task is to reuse the correct
pronoun later. We present RUFF, a carefully-designed dataset of over 5 million
instances to measure robust pronoun fidelity in English, and we evaluate 37
popular large language models across architectures (encoder-only, decoder-only
and encoder-decoder) and scales (11M-70B parameters). When an individual is
introduced with a pronoun, models can mostly faithfully reuse this pronoun in
the next sentence, but they are significantly worse with she/her/her, singular
they and neopronouns. Moreover, models are easily distracted by non-adversarial
sentences discussing other people; even one additional sentence with a
distractor pronoun causes accuracy to drop on average by 34%. Our results show
that pronoun fidelity is neither robust, nor due to reasoning, in a simple,
naturalistic setting where humans achieve nearly 100% accuracy. We encourage
researchers to bridge the gaps we find and to carefully evaluate reasoning in
settings where superficial repetition might inflate perceptions of model
performance.
|
[
-0.11282322555780411,
-0.7656888365745544,
0.44883623719215393,
0.15331323444843292,
-0.36041995882987976,
-0.0824926495552063,
-0.052170105278491974,
-0.575332522392273,
-0.055364903062582016,
0.5803323984146118,
-0.1951504647731781,
-0.12251701205968857,
-0.6122123599052429,
0.3158225417137146,
-0.3580734431743622,
0.715567946434021,
0.04727291688323021,
0.22254213690757751,
-0.5048449635505676,
-0.18100674450397491,
-0.45238858461380005,
-0.5133638978004456,
-0.34158578515052795,
-0.40018805861473083,
0.534968912601471,
0.40163955092430115,
1.1085572242736816,
0.8371133804321289,
0.7040017247200012,
0.2992282807826996,
-0.2293359786272049,
0.07357113063335419,
-0.5322217345237732,
0.4084046483039856,
-0.11736810952425003,
-0.24280020594596863,
-0.3734804689884186,
0.17858968675136566,
0.5366747975349426,
0.805884063243866,
-0.23681329190731049,
0.09743201732635498,
0.3550972044467926,
0.20865270495414734,
-0.4782651662826538,
-0.26523494720458984,
-0.5996303558349609,
-0.20986825227737427,
-0.23184359073638916,
-0.10873815417289734,
-0.3449738919734955,
-0.44426923990249634,
0.12709295749664307,
-0.6485671997070312,
0.1371707171201706,
0.16582457721233368,
1.0775206089019775,
0.39889875054359436,
-0.31466543674468994,
-0.031129395589232445,
-0.5729279518127441,
0.8493345975875854,
-0.4117591679096222,
0.6977701783180237,
0.6382631659507751,
-0.22897350788116455,
-0.5450912117958069,
-0.6807041764259338,
-0.1603204756975174,
-0.6985729932785034,
-0.14259473979473114,
0.09068280458450317,
-0.2053067684173584,
-0.2029542773962021,
0.06388824433088303,
0.1721986085176468,
-0.3683752119541168,
-0.086720772087574,
-0.056583840399980545,
-0.30514681339263916,
0.5692227482795715,
0.03765691816806793,
-0.0292170662432909,
0.03879239782691002,
-0.4133095443248749,
0.0477391853928566,
-0.5743507742881775,
0.11105452477931976,
0.7701814770698547,
0.11280707269906998,
0.24278661608695984,
0.5790095329284668,
0.23589864373207092,
0.34825557470321655,
0.17978538572788239,
-0.4178021252155304,
0.1036379337310791,
-0.6510300040245056,
-0.016311796382069588,
-0.4186859726905823,
0.9174789786338806,
0.23408140242099762,
0.7919811606407166,
-0.31800785660743713,
-0.14643248915672302,
0.17676709592342377,
0.47718706727027893,
-0.388386607170105,
-0.3837209939956665,
0.13603158295154572,
-0.13937027752399445,
-0.16466251015663147,
0.07022569328546524,
-0.3503165543079376,
0.08513752371072769,
0.008386187255382538,
0.21872642636299133,
-0.6253858804702759,
-0.32161298394203186,
0.37055984139442444,
0.023055652156472206,
0.0635613203048706,
0.08893148601055145,
-0.4362897574901581,
0.23350350558757782,
0.8354255557060242,
0.506323516368866,
-0.07972981035709381,
-0.7604042291641235,
-0.6196514964103699,
0.14443087577819824,
-0.4117373824119568,
0.9115084409713745,
-0.6527180671691895,
-0.6128435134887695,
-0.0919380635023117,
0.06661561876535416,
0.12376203387975693,
-0.6590808033943176,
0.845720648765564,
-0.10070475935935974,
0.2692861258983612,
-0.48652809858322144,
-0.5377972722053528,
0.14158937335014343,
0.053752511739730835,
-0.4655127227306366,
0.9929093718528748,
-0.19869840145111084,
-0.9269942045211792,
0.5367103815078735,
0.0868978202342987,
-0.5603889226913452,
-0.03136711195111275,
0.07295340299606323,
-0.5635987520217896,
0.19386503100395203,
-0.011120975948870182,
0.4662938416004181,
0.055031340569257736,
0.3844151794910431,
-0.4964994788169861,
-0.5056557655334473,
0.6246463060379028,
-0.4109953045845032,
0.4172142446041107,
-0.1672489196062088,
0.2722724676132202,
-0.05209369584918022,
-0.41048839688301086,
-0.2141982913017273,
0.08550774306058884,
-0.1690143644809723,
-0.6006167531013489,
0.077922523021698,
-0.04539810121059418,
0.0069250562228262424,
0.09878475219011307,
-0.3184853196144104,
-0.2111477255821228,
-0.11882735788822174,
0.3464578092098236,
0.5068300366401672,
0.1270967423915863,
0.43470245599746704,
-0.7229762077331543,
0.40440577268600464,
-0.05187327787280083,
0.296578973531723,
-0.1064387634396553,
-0.494468629360199,
-0.3820253014564514,
-0.6313911080360413,
0.44686728715896606,
0.41927337646484375,
-0.0803159698843956,
0.31129559874534607,
-0.17415755987167358,
-0.08615344017744064,
-0.6173898577690125,
0.213516965508461,
0.3640941083431244,
0.6370790004730225,
0.2554057836532593,
-0.2016880363225937,
-0.4493943154811859,
-1.1038295030593872,
-0.6307854652404785,
-0.47772055864334106,
-0.0064479634165763855,
0.027121296152472496,
0.5560949444770813,
0.06337616592645645,
0.7879256010055542,
-0.05017511174082756,
-0.1763441562652588,
-0.12328829616308212,
0.2094748169183731,
-0.27800026535987854,
0.35345759987831116,
0.271101713180542,
-0.5378456115722656,
-0.12352600693702698,
-0.418465793132782,
-0.6836628913879395,
-0.19368870556354523,
-0.1511382758617401,
-0.21721309423446655,
0.1707792580127716,
0.335714727640152,
-0.46929168701171875,
0.04216606542468071,
0.43984755873680115,
-0.4727535843849182,
0.740163266658783,
-0.11121427267789841,
0.009812340140342712,
-1.0337098836898804,
-0.002178875030949712,
0.14800883829593658,
-0.7057600617408752,
-0.36488544940948486,
0.2277747094631195,
-0.1384807676076889,
0.542706310749054,
-0.5506056547164917,
0.39169684052467346,
-0.6095157861709595,
0.00014259932504501194,
-0.16671670973300934,
0.174616739153862,
0.13741397857666016,
-0.12149031460285187,
0.0026759328320622444,
0.994814395904541,
0.3017351031303406,
-0.5699877738952637,
0.09355398267507553,
0.19908146560192108,
-0.1786225140094757,
0.8707907199859619,
-0.8303758502006531,
0.2660676836967468,
0.0022190699819475412,
-0.059682197868824005,
-0.6559005975723267,
-0.2832111716270447,
0.15424934029579163,
-0.4760932922363281,
0.0877772644162178,
-0.043431613594293594,
-0.41431257128715515,
-0.15172074735164642,
-0.41272425651550293,
0.12118057161569595,
0.5578253269195557,
-0.10629259794950485,
0.2959081530570984,
0.45742425322532654,
-0.2304346263408661,
-0.7846158146858215,
-0.8471111059188843,
0.21746385097503662,
-0.2550719082355499,
-0.7197544574737549,
0.21028050780296326,
0.06111143156886101,
-0.6924983263015747,
0.42209485173225403,
-0.258073627948761,
-0.1699203997850418,
0.3124431371688843,
0.14158621430397034,
0.17574571073055267,
-0.028843900188803673,
0.013713580556213856,
-0.2992018163204193,
-0.30637192726135254,
0.11449851840734482,
0.0486425943672657,
0.1992182582616806,
-0.22338669002056122,
-0.42366158962249756,
-0.5947628021240234,
0.5760126113891602,
0.4689164459705353,
0.031521715223789215,
0.6362046599388123,
0.36626675724983215,
-0.4207015335559845,
0.10995607078075409,
-0.7011350393295288,
-0.2815355360507965,
-0.3922918438911438,
0.4090023338794708,
-0.6987795233726501,
-0.9241389632225037,
0.7588470578193665,
0.297576904296875,
0.1602758765220642,
0.1620064675807953,
0.3315035402774811,
-0.5963596105575562,
0.7003448605537415,
0.672055721282959,
0.10423184931278229,
0.20150057971477509,
0.15997937321662903,
0.07400812208652496,
-0.6795802116394043,
-0.2583424150943756,
-0.495586633682251,
-0.13658182322978973,
-0.3965398967266083,
-0.24590755999088287,
-0.052496667951345444,
0.47579842805862427,
-0.12142804265022278,
0.45113447308540344,
-0.34133750200271606,
0.41953620314598083,
0.5926516056060791,
0.12809054553508759,
0.6347039937973022,
-0.1389930099248886,
-0.07117284089326859,
-0.43348604440689087,
-0.5213693976402283,
-0.8579667806625366,
0.8321103453636169,
0.5639756917953491,
0.9217205047607422,
0.012118011713027954,
0.6704396605491638,
0.11766185611486435,
0.05955221503973007,
-0.7706107497215271,
0.6185750365257263,
-0.1115812361240387,
-0.38196101784706116,
-0.14434437453746796,
-0.39081835746765137,
-0.9499313831329346,
-0.024034660309553146,
-0.1506175398826599,
-0.404064416885376,
0.2521798014640808,
0.32121968269348145,
-0.32105350494384766,
0.06646925956010818,
-0.23562179505825043,
0.5679096579551697,
-0.3700498342514038,
-0.6634684801101685,
-0.033010635524988174,
-0.41596636176109314,
0.43341362476348877,
-0.1028992235660553,
0.024736663326621056,
-0.16219398379325867,
-0.3430936932563782,
0.472715824842453,
-0.352184921503067,
0.5028833746910095,
0.30075618624687195,
-0.15363331139087677,
0.3045003116130829,
0.36959540843963623,
0.609390914440155,
0.2081068605184555,
-0.03850191459059715,
0.4350660443305969,
0.05968708544969559,
-0.4344824254512787,
-0.28038322925567627,
0.5298056602478027,
-0.6018004417419434,
-0.6095395684242249,
-0.6750046610832214,
-0.5812649726867676,
-0.17522186040878296,
-0.0362558588385582,
0.38912689685821533,
0.06087186560034752,
-0.42838019132614136,
0.48226284980773926,
0.6135091781616211,
0.12183952331542969,
0.1010177955031395,
0.394822895526886,
-0.012823069468140602,
-0.4941368103027344,
0.4080846309661865,
0.2823752164840698,
0.361918181180954,
0.13313449919223785,
0.27108773589134216,
-0.3695247769355774,
-0.43385836482048035,
-0.0583576038479805,
0.3637826144695282,
-0.38757357001304626,
-0.2008783370256424,
-0.7237269282341003,
0.09937732666730881,
-0.2465772032737732,
-0.26199278235435486,
-0.5774610638618469,
-0.09982895851135254,
-0.3244270086288452,
-0.04335787147283554,
0.27372175455093384,
0.541886031627655,
-0.1302543431520462,
0.0728706642985344,
-0.6085823178291321,
0.31048330664634705,
0.39562779664993286,
0.17394179105758667,
-0.6569257974624634,
-0.9367435574531555,
0.060131922364234924,
0.09198400378227234,
-0.05389430746436119,
-1.0281245708465576,
0.2030150145292282,
0.1946716159582138,
0.7757302522659302,
0.2615882158279419,
0.11368392407894135,
0.642578125,
-0.23265115916728973,
0.7890310287475586,
-0.16215384006500244,
-0.7907617092132568,
0.2653758227825165,
-0.39491647481918335,
0.16937078535556793,
0.7922999262809753,
0.32329073548316956,
-0.38122740387916565,
-0.605353593826294,
-0.6371938586235046,
-0.7540149092674255,
0.15612566471099854,
0.04519112780690193,
0.1460447907447815,
-0.22648175060749054,
0.6777017712593079,
0.26752138137817383,
0.09276921302080154,
-0.6331114768981934,
-0.09082158654928207,
-0.1313914954662323,
-0.10044480860233307,
0.19092340767383575,
-0.5876700282096863,
-0.2508184313774109,
-0.06452617794275284,
0.7354035973548889,
-0.036755919456481934,
0.186487078666687,
0.19766457378864288,
-0.2397822141647339,
-0.02285330928862095,
0.2830739915370941,
0.549496591091156,
0.4672183692455292,
-0.24839627742767334,
0.1719612330198288,
0.26813918352127075,
-0.6342533826828003,
0.1889943778514862,
-0.06493836641311646,
-0.290242999792099,
0.07001473009586334,
0.6161373257637024,
0.3029092252254486,
0.45042380690574646,
-0.34033340215682983,
0.5293353199958801,
-0.19149167835712433,
-0.4226057231426239,
-0.43467769026756287,
-0.17623910307884216,
0.3424126207828522,
0.045962076634168625,
0.07280189543962479,
0.3061459958553314,
-0.16073893010616302,
-0.5915022492408752,
0.4584808349609375,
0.5763654112815857,
-0.13383664190769196,
-0.5589150190353394,
0.644833505153656,
0.18268969655036926,
-0.49769672751426697,
0.5170220732688904,
-0.39435985684394836,
-0.3918817639350891,
0.20183242857456207,
0.6020432710647583,
1.0928065776824951,
-0.14928419888019562,
0.17137838900089264,
0.2177218198776245,
0.5958006978034973,
-0.7098661065101624,
0.5339317917823792,
0.3092280924320221,
-1.043383002281189,
-0.44927987456321716,
-0.42334887385368347,
-0.6310641765594482,
0.3516075909137726,
-0.7673848271369934,
0.2303950935602188,
-0.22689729928970337,
-0.440377801656723,
-0.4972243010997772,
-0.06705774366855621,
-0.607639729976654,
-0.10990820825099945,
-0.21100036799907684,
0.872366726398468,
-0.9183658361434937,
0.6614522337913513,
0.9698244333267212,
-0.3157751262187958,
-0.7109690308570862,
0.2827262282371521,
-0.13046105206012726,
-0.4375638961791992,
0.20980730652809143,
-0.0609154999256134,
-0.47314324975013733,
-0.32300496101379395,
-0.4170868396759033,
-0.7044849395751953,
0.8270577192306519,
0.7838362455368042,
-0.7883782386779785,
0.18015946447849274,
0.14372485876083374,
0.5256631970405579,
-0.23266978561878204,
0.09281199425458908,
0.5312343239784241,
0.43443891406059265,
0.03898828849196434,
-0.9119189381599426,
-0.11505349725484848,
-0.032255738973617554,
-0.1231616958975792,
-0.1061747744679451,
-0.7935628890991211,
0.7328557372093201,
-0.44334250688552856,
-0.26932841539382935,
0.20562419295310974,
0.6663382649421692,
0.3994622826576233,
0.12020612508058548,
0.5176451206207275,
0.5648189783096313,
0.8636348247528076,
-0.18868041038513184,
0.8999618887901306,
-0.3395062983036041,
0.09022446721792221,
1.354235053062439,
-0.4602785110473633,
1.1456478834152222,
0.6114183068275452,
-0.1708187460899353,
0.2551271915435791,
0.4986315965652466,
0.1680459976196289,
0.33419638872146606,
-0.046402301639318466,
-0.07722639292478561,
-0.6362085342407227,
-0.33333060145378113,
-0.15976718068122864,
0.7181800603866577,
0.05602243170142174,
-0.2805585265159607,
0.22371149063110352,
0.03507039695978165,
0.34240594506263733,
0.42135360836982727,
0.17546547949314117,
0.6086496710777283,
0.23780196905136108,
-0.7018468379974365,
0.2966584265232086,
-0.24720561504364014,
0.7764940857887268,
-0.41026344895362854,
0.24490851163864136,
-0.448079377412796,
0.20348764955997467,
-0.04708409309387207,
-0.9218871593475342,
0.5906431078910828,
-0.03285811096429825,
-0.1534336656332016,
-0.35208359360694885,
0.8231069445610046,
-0.4227146506309509,
-0.6562735438346863,
0.4044049084186554,
0.8621270656585693,
0.33248546719551086,
0.016628315672278404,
-0.6006841063499451,
0.05422091856598854,
-0.32752400636672974,
-0.44107770919799805,
0.1847970336675644,
0.3644356429576874,
0.07395569235086441,
0.9196308255195618,
0.44403791427612305,
0.3070441484451294,
-0.011421360075473785,
0.19592440128326416,
0.44564536213874817,
-0.6220333576202393,
0.02602396532893181,
-0.8243476152420044,
0.44954243302345276,
0.08305734395980835,
-0.5271010994911194,
0.8940017223358154,
0.46800199151039124,
0.935382068157196,
0.2828384041786194,
0.5880470275878906,
0.4992542862892151,
0.5276287198066711,
-0.2174266278743744,
0.43425890803337097,
-0.42863982915878296,
0.24148555099964142,
-0.06075750291347504,
-0.870523989200592,
-0.22758260369300842,
1.0174800157546997,
-0.019887279719114304,
0.09068676084280014,
0.7083055377006531,
0.8834131360054016,
-0.0648426041007042,
-0.06934037804603577,
0.6176139712333679,
0.28090423345565796,
-0.06648433953523636,
0.29525086283683777,
1.0343899726867676,
-0.48321256041526794,
0.5506267547607422,
-0.32209402322769165,
0.027985190972685814,
-0.13300393521785736,
-1.0304783582687378,
-0.6507098078727722,
-0.3630635738372803,
-0.7843113541603088,
-0.3265056312084198,
0.4510174095630646,
0.8752242922782898,
0.5608434081077576,
-0.6243794560432434,
0.0031172558665275574,
-0.07768648862838745,
0.05694513022899628,
-0.5166188478469849,
-0.16315805912017822,
-0.022380920127034187,
-0.20767748355865479,
-0.7161850929260254,
0.3698177635669708,
0.13274139165878296,
-0.028613131493330002,
-0.4928976893424988,
-0.11751869320869446,
-0.10196436196565628,
0.28538447618484497,
0.22124697268009186,
0.14093266427516937,
-0.8528741002082825,
-0.7038148045539856,
0.42864397168159485,
-0.35520195960998535,
-0.06480623036623001,
0.4605543911457062,
-0.8437495231628418,
0.027178606018424034,
0.5575626492500305,
0.3007846772670746,
-0.17873558402061462,
0.23862071335315704,
0.5351206660270691,
-0.6232216954231262,
-0.18836034834384918,
0.3322753310203552,
0.6292162537574768,
0.5998134016990662,
-0.3692953884601593,
0.3751237094402313,
0.4944777190685272,
-0.7848353385925293,
-1.0638521909713745,
0.24350787699222565,
-0.7104852795600891,
-0.12169099599123001,
1.2307826280593872,
-0.2534133493900299,
-0.029389334842562675,
-0.48613008856773376,
0.11517321318387985,
0.14960764348506927,
-0.4592677056789398,
0.6099282503128052,
0.9171410799026489,
-0.10522686690092087,
-0.45649591088294983,
-0.4646656811237335,
0.3270118236541748,
0.7054117321968079,
-0.36564385890960693,
0.10515870153903961,
0.3531712591648102,
0.6902117133140564,
0.09507912397384644,
0.4876471757888794,
-0.1131257638335228,
0.20464207231998444,
0.38085371255874634,
0.011371235363185406,
-0.37562432885169983,
-0.515315055847168,
-0.2678624987602234,
0.24876362085342407,
0.2696987986564636,
-0.2579745948314667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04285v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04285v1
|
MIMIR: A Streamlined Platform for Personalized Agent Tuning in Domain Expertise
| 2024-04-03T23:42:38 | 2024-04-03T23:42:38 |
Chunyuan Deng, Xiangru Tang, Yilun Zhao, Hanming Wang, Haoran Wang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Arman Cohan, Mark Gerstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have evolved into interactive agents,
proficient in planning, tool use, and task execution across a wide variety of
tasks. However, without specific agent tuning, open-source models like LLaMA
currently struggle to match the efficiency of GPT- 4, particularly given the
scarcity of agent-tuning datasets for fine-tuning. In response, we introduce
\textsc{Mimir}: a streamlined platform offering a customizable pipeline that
enables users to leverage both private knowledge and publicly available,
legally compliant datasets at scale for \textbf{personalized agent tuning}.
Additionally, \textsc{Mimir} supports the generation of general
instruction-tuning datasets from the same input. This dual capability ensures
that language agents developed through the platform possess both specific agent
abilities and general competencies. \textsc{Mimir} integrates these features
into a cohesive end-to-end platform, facilitating everything from the uploading
of personalized files to one-click agent fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.45978841185569763,
-0.5971187949180603,
0.4854084551334381,
-0.0207369402050972,
0.22544129192829132,
0.4622943103313446,
-0.30504804849624634,
-0.07640830427408218,
0.3005133867263794,
0.7615593075752258,
-0.5936979055404663,
-0.6684858202934265,
-0.4073057770729065,
-0.02674226462841034,
-0.0631028488278389,
1.2636264562606812,
0.17714005708694458,
-0.22172002494335175,
-0.29198360443115234,
0.002692349487915635,
-0.3417620360851288,
-0.36080116033554077,
-0.7212768793106079,
-0.38542529940605164,
0.8846533894538879,
0.8397287726402283,
0.9382408261299133,
0.9786484837532043,
0.5754997730255127,
0.46582549810409546,
0.27570176124572754,
0.39701375365257263,
-0.6439531445503235,
0.3774425983428955,
-0.47114038467407227,
-0.4146941900253296,
-1.029570460319519,
-0.03559986129403114,
0.21178622543811798,
0.4320971667766571,
-0.33489152789115906,
0.3578990697860718,
-0.14072111248970032,
0.7594823241233826,
-0.6509765386581421,
0.21885225176811218,
-0.8742597103118896,
-0.3451306223869324,
-0.29017966985702515,
-0.5252078771591187,
-0.0803808867931366,
-0.27156248688697815,
-0.023752979934215546,
-0.9837812185287476,
0.39783868193626404,
-0.04272877797484398,
0.8675098419189453,
0.6945820450782776,
-0.34683555364608765,
-0.3858746588230133,
-0.7211973071098328,
0.6897278428077698,
-0.30937460064888,
0.013682153075933456,
0.6275246739387512,
0.6823058724403381,
-0.11797323077917099,
-0.990063488483429,
-0.3658415973186493,
-0.26329484581947327,
0.11389752477407455,
-0.15638083219528198,
-0.15935483574867249,
0.1814289540052414,
0.05784023925662041,
0.4269751310348511,
-0.37769365310668945,
0.026593614369630814,
-0.10896927118301392,
-0.2530888020992279,
0.5104547739028931,
0.4189685881137848,
0.14381876587867737,
0.5818644165992737,
0.027338912710547447,
0.06788858026266098,
-0.5941328406333923,
0.03442439064383507,
0.6550944447517395,
0.30150583386421204,
0.0575910247862339,
0.5718059539794922,
-0.735312283039093,
0.7100711464881897,
0.5125681161880493,
-0.19811251759529114,
0.22735367715358734,
0.05413227900862694,
-0.03161100298166275,
-0.27580490708351135,
0.5940196514129639,
0.1359654814004898,
0.4143954813480377,
-0.500011682510376,
-0.3465995192527771,
-0.14656086266040802,
0.25965797901153564,
-0.7790360450744629,
-0.5523154139518738,
0.15125888586044312,
-0.06680971384048462,
-0.30122196674346924,
-0.06918036937713623,
-0.48614931106567383,
-0.40982067584991455,
-0.6675195097923279,
0.483810693025589,
-0.14757752418518066,
-0.011954213492572308,
0.1886095106601715,
-0.02196582779288292,
0.16711078584194183,
0.3332594037055969,
-1.09092116355896,
0.5098402500152588,
1.005974531173706,
0.7335413098335266,
-0.12186438590288162,
-0.27658456563949585,
-0.8626931309700012,
0.3524245321750641,
-0.10105486959218979,
1.0061620473861694,
-1.030835747718811,
-0.11568012833595276,
-0.09177886694669724,
0.033459533005952835,
-0.1566317230463028,
-0.5419400930404663,
0.38371753692626953,
-0.8335183262825012,
0.2418682724237442,
-0.26351872086524963,
-0.6097984910011292,
-0.07086783647537231,
0.19992303848266602,
-0.5429828763008118,
0.8561274409294128,
0.3114587962627411,
-0.653598427772522,
0.38768333196640015,
-1.0550106763839722,
-0.1869109869003296,
0.2943706512451172,
-0.12763921916484833,
-0.4290657639503479,
-0.11053897440433502,
0.2408667355775833,
0.529975950717926,
-0.1614447981119156,
0.1404155194759369,
-0.37992390990257263,
-0.4166336953639984,
0.14697560667991638,
0.10420595854520798,
0.31597504019737244,
0.328986793756485,
-0.21585005521774292,
0.5164881348609924,
-0.8279067277908325,
0.10300283879041672,
-0.1252235770225525,
-0.4830179810523987,
-0.18211711943149567,
0.01345392968505621,
-0.018145635724067688,
0.20309744775295258,
0.784748911857605,
-0.2942028343677521,
0.3784586489200592,
-0.19723966717720032,
0.3636797070503235,
0.9646133780479431,
-0.18582116067409515,
0.532660722732544,
-0.6271182894706726,
0.8567984700202942,
-0.362087219953537,
0.04061663895845413,
-0.19075633585453033,
-0.42723900079727173,
-1.0140659809112549,
-0.7738801836967468,
0.3167719841003418,
0.5905033946037292,
-0.615698516368866,
0.5646792054176331,
-0.4577995836734772,
-0.32467779517173767,
-0.8897120952606201,
0.4228835105895996,
0.2416866421699524,
0.43757036328315735,
0.18199479579925537,
-0.10061009228229523,
-0.2554868757724762,
-1.034909725189209,
-0.18522748351097107,
0.3145889639854431,
-0.4193575084209442,
0.4890684187412262,
0.4051792025566101,
-0.46043941378593445,
1.283825159072876,
-0.5138839483261108,
-0.6075032949447632,
-0.029480500146746635,
-0.10334982722997665,
0.06372742354869843,
0.3064365088939667,
0.396467000246048,
-0.6517793536186218,
-0.8749513030052185,
0.635794460773468,
-0.468036413192749,
-0.40174412727355957,
0.2876761555671692,
-0.37670478224754333,
-0.0839061588048935,
0.44141295552253723,
-0.5465855002403259,
-0.06451167166233063,
0.600070059299469,
-0.3975948393344879,
0.29777011275291443,
-0.31855183839797974,
0.01930265873670578,
-1.1183828115463257,
0.24243012070655823,
-0.5059126615524292,
-0.5222362279891968,
-0.709516167640686,
0.11101900041103363,
-0.08815331757068634,
0.1391940712928772,
-0.08159325271844864,
0.683496356010437,
-0.23475681245326996,
-0.02852063812315464,
-0.5323175191879272,
0.17678239941596985,
-0.11104782670736313,
0.4802980422973633,
-0.11899053305387497,
1.063663125038147,
0.6158076524734497,
-0.6106451749801636,
0.2688980996608734,
0.2527793347835541,
-0.03869175910949707,
0.4777480363845825,
-0.8435502648353577,
0.7142230272293091,
0.0921640694141388,
-0.2796136736869812,
-0.4673962891101837,
-0.5477377772331238,
0.29018473625183105,
-0.2574499845504761,
0.30656006932258606,
-0.3353511691093445,
-0.43975311517715454,
0.04843350127339363,
-0.32991212606430054,
-0.1411924809217453,
0.44689735770225525,
-0.4976162612438202,
0.7812138199806213,
0.499626487493515,
-0.31930384039878845,
-0.5899332165718079,
-0.1518559604883194,
0.14038603007793427,
-0.31494563817977905,
-0.7403726577758789,
0.23187394440174103,
-0.33338555693626404,
-0.18221676349639893,
-0.08194570243358612,
0.1682114154100418,
-0.14992213249206543,
0.079993337392807,
0.2844938337802887,
-0.125825434923172,
-0.2600330412387848,
0.0715160071849823,
0.3477064073085785,
-0.4088621735572815,
-0.2220267951488495,
-0.31473299860954285,
0.32926782965660095,
-0.3282400965690613,
-0.3827848434448242,
-0.18898160755634308,
0.15586452186107635,
0.5701791048049927,
-0.4545540511608124,
0.6244388818740845,
0.7145788073539734,
0.05104098469018936,
-0.27482959628105164,
-0.7552935481071472,
-0.00139867071993649,
-0.6342900991439819,
0.18566051125526428,
-0.7712188363075256,
-1.391629934310913,
0.5292202830314636,
-0.36690136790275574,
0.10791625827550888,
0.16548608243465424,
0.9514124989509583,
-0.02715371549129486,
1.10928475856781,
1.1424020528793335,
-0.18519578874111176,
0.613681435585022,
-0.1940300613641739,
-0.14334115386009216,
-0.8085562586784363,
-0.23112307488918304,
-0.4957021474838257,
-0.3337472677230835,
-0.6153123378753662,
-0.5366585850715637,
0.26643121242523193,
-0.2128404825925827,
-0.571564793586731,
-0.036727726459503174,
-0.48607155680656433,
0.9024947285652161,
0.6458870768547058,
-0.051994625478982925,
0.6128621101379395,
0.04542948305606842,
0.05493858829140663,
0.09645380079746246,
-0.6419855356216431,
-0.9735352993011475,
1.1704624891281128,
0.3758116364479065,
0.8193624019622803,
0.11944962292909622,
0.4673718512058258,
0.4716495871543884,
0.4179818332195282,
-0.7452912330627441,
0.49210235476493835,
-0.08076416701078415,
-0.5389299988746643,
-0.3191666007041931,
-0.3129684031009674,
-1.0981065034866333,
0.2990683615207672,
0.05042033642530441,
-0.6175609827041626,
0.15470007061958313,
0.32053303718566895,
-0.09627814590930939,
0.20058169960975647,
-0.533555269241333,
0.7990539073944092,
-0.014664079993963242,
-0.41963741183280945,
-0.26076558232307434,
-0.5096893906593323,
0.23463326692581177,
-0.37903404235839844,
0.0012755468487739563,
-0.42760762572288513,
-0.7348818182945251,
0.34822332859039307,
-0.5542745590209961,
0.8981532454490662,
-0.1465299129486084,
-0.01651284471154213,
-0.011516395956277847,
0.21326348185539246,
0.7031359672546387,
-0.06256257742643356,
-0.2766728699207306,
0.009791411459445953,
-0.25823163986206055,
-0.5877372622489929,
-0.4920284152030945,
0.8248856067657471,
-0.9743810892105103,
-0.6516135931015015,
-0.014763793908059597,
-0.6462143659591675,
-0.30353742837905884,
0.13877283036708832,
0.1536855846643448,
-0.0013090749271214008,
-0.3195638358592987,
0.07855059206485748,
0.6253793835639954,
0.14000046253204346,
0.11544685065746307,
1.1132698059082031,
-0.04116420820355415,
-0.35053545236587524,
1.0833985805511475,
-0.28151634335517883,
0.0589648000895977,
0.5981269478797913,
0.10040223598480225,
-0.10280921310186386,
-0.5570534467697144,
-0.2481601983308792,
0.2123377025127411,
-0.5523036122322083,
-0.3873591423034668,
-0.6594990491867065,
0.09637749195098877,
-0.10357042402029037,
-0.32909485697746277,
-0.4289481043815613,
-0.37963801622390747,
-0.4266900420188904,
-0.01774502359330654,
0.6214443445205688,
0.792080283164978,
-0.0125120272859931,
0.6023634672164917,
-0.5250205993652344,
0.2716628313064575,
0.5216231346130371,
0.541425883769989,
-0.40837281942367554,
-0.6634096503257751,
-0.6223768591880798,
-0.07162506133317947,
-0.4675540626049042,
-0.34247416257858276,
0.3579700291156769,
0.7109159231185913,
0.5715160965919495,
0.7099278569221497,
-0.04269721359014511,
0.5202060341835022,
-0.5920668244361877,
0.43132224678993225,
-0.39527398347854614,
-0.9988149404525757,
0.6110843420028687,
-0.6667147278785706,
0.16218745708465576,
0.6926256418228149,
0.39857789874076843,
-0.28195685148239136,
-0.6014100313186646,
-0.23591366410255432,
-0.5816570520401001,
0.646191418170929,
0.12513317167758942,
0.20295146107673645,
0.22810477018356323,
0.4472227096557617,
0.4402141571044922,
0.49653783440589905,
-0.3270884156227112,
-0.1593310683965683,
-0.15334314107894897,
-0.2606362998485565,
-0.29378050565719604,
0.003122797468677163,
-0.2083430290222168,
-0.18539468944072723,
0.5667426586151123,
-0.5510289072990417,
-0.08600013703107834,
-0.11143612861633301,
-0.1346677988767624,
-0.2708832323551178,
0.27918127179145813,
0.36348581314086914,
0.7894170880317688,
-0.1974942982196808,
-0.07197994738817215,
0.06700436025857925,
-0.5369746088981628,
0.0937495306134224,
0.20452001690864563,
-0.21578717231750488,
-0.3742145895957947,
0.24609637260437012,
0.7219489812850952,
0.14920265972614288,
-0.6833630204200745,
0.3279383182525635,
-0.12106093764305115,
-0.31045809388160706,
-0.19845983386039734,
0.5024125576019287,
0.10943326354026794,
0.3899947702884674,
0.19646836817264557,
0.10581143945455551,
0.21734470129013062,
-0.09745581448078156,
0.11561179161071777,
0.35999590158462524,
-0.4220912456512451,
-0.5614092350006104,
0.7542407512664795,
0.41435912251472473,
-0.4004693925380707,
0.3727588653564453,
-0.258127897977829,
-0.2581506371498108,
0.31320902705192566,
0.18965040147304535,
1.0493876934051514,
-0.3784041702747345,
0.3176306486129761,
-0.15890051424503326,
0.22043585777282715,
0.20983198285102844,
0.17195972800254822,
-0.17352761328220367,
-0.6578567028045654,
-0.5632315874099731,
-0.5347618460655212,
-0.6755297183990479,
0.043153584003448486,
-0.4408283233642578,
0.26898160576820374,
-0.4566190242767334,
-0.24261465668678284,
-0.0960230752825737,
0.16713549196720123,
-0.7777215242385864,
-0.2719714343547821,
-0.16426710784435272,
0.8308743834495544,
-0.5316151976585388,
1.1117277145385742,
0.9677888751029968,
-0.29185888171195984,
-0.4725153148174286,
-0.16372941434383392,
-0.09649733453989029,
-0.7913552522659302,
0.3993532657623291,
-0.1369272917509079,
-0.5142992734909058,
0.1894523799419403,
-0.5339391231536865,
-0.8593372702598572,
1.3231196403503418,
0.7252407073974609,
-0.5986620783805847,
0.10958921909332275,
0.2592991292476654,
0.8030281066894531,
-0.6912312507629395,
0.1703089326620102,
0.7140815258026123,
0.5694893002510071,
0.010096692480146885,
-0.997465193271637,
-0.1256863921880722,
-0.33239278197288513,
-0.13220015168190002,
0.02300768718123436,
-0.9081833362579346,
0.8519981503486633,
-0.28601256012916565,
0.012028913013637066,
0.1163732185959816,
0.4390338957309723,
-0.009961001574993134,
0.48397311568260193,
0.406192809343338,
0.40742021799087524,
1.1697375774383545,
0.11918051540851593,
0.9566903114318848,
-0.6090793609619141,
0.22491659224033356,
1.1968735456466675,
-0.3577193319797516,
0.7099637985229492,
0.07496098428964615,
-0.06468142569065094,
0.6737629771232605,
0.5122849941253662,
-0.0021039957646280527,
0.6312083005905151,
0.02889658696949482,
-0.4091998338699341,
-0.42836329340934753,
-0.07723317295312881,
-0.2145247757434845,
0.45204228162765503,
0.38421133160591125,
-0.04104138910770416,
0.057892829179763794,
-0.10088828951120377,
0.018184909597039223,
0.19203227758407593,
-0.42232266068458557,
1.023864507675171,
-0.10399189591407776,
-0.3472634553909302,
0.30539271235466003,
0.06653653085231781,
0.776674747467041,
-0.7804614901542664,
0.0049997842870652676,
-0.32125619053840637,
0.3586025536060333,
-0.25446316599845886,
-0.5420199036598206,
0.11659660190343857,
0.06067568063735962,
-0.312737375497818,
-0.22686615586280823,
0.9452712535858154,
-0.45363548398017883,
-0.21519184112548828,
0.15311309695243835,
0.8002594113349915,
0.22754976153373718,
-0.3935580551624298,
-0.7269632816314697,
-0.13433653116226196,
-0.22520871460437775,
-0.455525279045105,
0.464446485042572,
0.7258040308952332,
0.07911984622478485,
1.307949185371399,
0.708899736404419,
0.027814831584692,
-0.013475218787789345,
0.1848696619272232,
1.194685459136963,
-0.6215739846229553,
-0.4467023015022278,
-0.46605342626571655,
0.5200636386871338,
-0.018397454172372818,
-0.34425240755081177,
0.7217361927032471,
0.7643958926200867,
0.6801947951316833,
-0.3467915952205658,
0.8516910672187805,
0.1848837286233902,
0.7717805504798889,
-0.27499720454216003,
0.776218056678772,
-0.4412584602832794,
0.4621545672416687,
0.018516136333346367,
-0.8566988706588745,
-0.010706542059779167,
0.405752569437027,
-0.33539560437202454,
0.27514803409576416,
0.2930591106414795,
1.1589550971984863,
-0.33444318175315857,
-0.4517703056335449,
0.4957123398780823,
0.09683579206466675,
0.31066474318504333,
0.35368746519088745,
0.9930152297019958,
0.10969305038452148,
0.6332542300224304,
-0.0768427848815918,
-0.32641834020614624,
-0.41616612672805786,
-0.7370375394821167,
-1.3040674924850464,
-0.5158201456069946,
-0.4070446193218231,
0.2042299509048462,
0.26610109210014343,
0.9552471041679382,
0.989271342754364,
-0.7489961981773376,
-0.25931626558303833,
0.09425217658281326,
0.22806820273399353,
-0.10440424829721451,
-0.1811957210302353,
0.19551816582679749,
-0.6067405343055725,
-0.8769087195396423,
0.46243181824684143,
0.2891109883785248,
-0.1839917153120041,
-0.22295238077640533,
-0.3514268696308136,
0.4242088496685028,
0.10588188469409943,
0.5561583638191223,
0.34084346890449524,
-0.6244695782661438,
-0.06895536184310913,
0.05205078795552254,
-0.1826479136943817,
0.07065905630588531,
0.9728513956069946,
-0.835814893245697,
0.3754632771015167,
0.16373257339000702,
0.5124967694282532,
0.542669415473938,
0.05889623239636421,
0.7049275636672974,
-0.7584953308105469,
0.001870992360636592,
0.1410011202096939,
-0.04602798819541931,
0.3560192286968231,
-0.48238158226013184,
0.599224865436554,
-0.1622854769229889,
-0.9606353640556335,
-0.46081462502479553,
-0.008075886406004429,
-1.0363845825195312,
0.044659197330474854,
0.9284828305244446,
-0.1367240995168686,
0.07478523254394531,
-0.4852234125137329,
-0.43695691227912903,
-0.13908737897872925,
-0.8445119857788086,
0.8571330308914185,
0.43803656101226807,
-0.270566463470459,
-0.03804854303598404,
-0.7128984928131104,
0.7229588031768799,
-0.018093755468726158,
-0.9162139892578125,
-0.019577808678150177,
0.41121482849121094,
0.5710054636001587,
-0.15327322483062744,
0.882982075214386,
0.30807092785835266,
0.12277001142501831,
-0.1128695085644722,
0.08840440213680267,
-0.5200148224830627,
-0.24305254220962524,
-0.2804122269153595,
0.2053600698709488,
0.4034801721572876,
-0.1653413325548172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03114v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03114v1
|
Testing the Effect of Code Documentation on Large Language Model Code Understanding
| 2024-04-03T23:33:56 | 2024-04-03T23:33:56 |
William Macke, Michael Doyle
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive abilities in recent
years with regards to code generation and understanding. However, little work
has investigated how documentation and other code properties affect an LLM's
ability to understand and generate code or documentation. We present an
empirical analysis of how underlying properties of code or documentation can
affect an LLM's capabilities. We show that providing an LLM with "incorrect"
documentation can greatly hinder code understanding, while incomplete or
missing documentation does not seem to significantly affect an LLM's ability to
understand code.
|
[
-0.3139839172363281,
-0.7783522605895996,
0.7125751376152039,
0.3468688130378723,
-0.0658646747469902,
0.05558958649635315,
-0.36724910140037537,
-0.7617342472076416,
0.055211931467056274,
0.657585859298706,
-0.24988438189029694,
-0.37226811051368713,
-0.6600648760795593,
0.018222376704216003,
-0.4752610921859741,
0.9919635653495789,
-0.09409164637327194,
0.1074906587600708,
-0.5241289138793945,
-0.07040850818157196,
-0.4844629168510437,
-0.6434900760650635,
-0.4404657483100891,
-0.5894107222557068,
0.5863281488418579,
0.4915829002857208,
0.7713415026664734,
0.5901401042938232,
0.5541393756866455,
0.2552311420440674,
-0.33357080817222595,
-0.2942604124546051,
-0.7488252520561218,
0.05027468129992485,
0.0881747305393219,
-0.9268820881843567,
-0.5608909130096436,
-0.23353081941604614,
0.850947916507721,
0.8084084391593933,
0.10450710356235504,
0.3184959888458252,
0.01039832178503275,
0.5230294466018677,
-0.3964097797870636,
0.3577772378921509,
-0.6910629868507385,
-0.08694510906934738,
-0.06384603679180145,
-0.44091731309890747,
-0.5047532320022583,
-0.057321298867464066,
-0.032929979264736176,
-0.38276129961013794,
0.31903761625289917,
0.10692929476499557,
0.7729645371437073,
0.10574503242969513,
-0.608768880367279,
-0.7244386672973633,
-0.7920289039611816,
0.5996413826942444,
-0.7430986166000366,
0.28742367029190063,
0.5441705584526062,
0.15118122100830078,
-0.19738423824310303,
-0.6690837740898132,
-0.47296521067619324,
-0.7570933103561401,
-0.13574135303497314,
0.0315852053463459,
0.0007524423999711871,
0.22316902875900269,
0.7421376705169678,
0.5883827805519104,
-0.6346178650856018,
0.39033976197242737,
-0.7368460297584534,
-0.12908998131752014,
0.5469040274620056,
0.2715948820114136,
0.5335964560508728,
-0.2372739017009735,
-0.05372341349720955,
-0.010265528224408627,
-1.019838809967041,
-0.045828111469745636,
0.500475287437439,
-0.07806184142827988,
-0.005974917206913233,
0.8945305943489075,
0.20298822224140167,
0.6955755352973938,
-0.38504359126091003,
-0.2773953080177307,
0.13990096747875214,
-0.32718437910079956,
-0.3796423077583313,
-0.013681788928806782,
0.2638298273086548,
0.19663448631763458,
0.23710179328918457,
-0.19770368933677673,
-0.46065399050712585,
-0.05858885496854782,
0.2418214976787567,
-0.8361487984657288,
-0.027157673612236977,
0.21840941905975342,
-0.7433351874351501,
-0.09752404689788818,
0.08708535879850388,
-0.3176831305027008,
-0.6658905148506165,
-0.45547789335250854,
0.26535654067993164,
-0.2965819835662842,
-0.2677675187587738,
0.023184431716799736,
-0.40041154623031616,
0.5361513495445251,
0.2667371928691864,
-0.9116048812866211,
0.19219297170639038,
0.7830643653869629,
0.6082726120948792,
0.1433829367160797,
-0.5090643167495728,
-0.4875370264053345,
-0.05355066806077957,
-0.42767032980918884,
0.5667207837104797,
-0.5057386755943298,
-0.5319006443023682,
0.0797346755862236,
0.02410011924803257,
0.06380094587802887,
-0.7372018098831177,
0.09314457327127457,
-0.6670362949371338,
-0.24889981746673584,
-0.1732283979654312,
-0.7065019011497498,
-0.2229883074760437,
0.04524264857172966,
-0.7144075632095337,
0.5108346939086914,
0.32793426513671875,
-0.5800920724868774,
0.4217415750026703,
-0.5445038676261902,
-0.5042701959609985,
-0.07395485788583755,
-0.28060126304626465,
-0.22777611017227173,
0.48296982049942017,
-0.20953966677188873,
0.375475138425827,
-0.08864656835794449,
0.21886958181858063,
-0.41403257846832275,
-0.6670544743537903,
0.709493100643158,
-0.3669164478778839,
0.757641077041626,
0.23591025173664093,
-0.2409246861934662,
0.04624951630830765,
-0.9157655835151672,
-0.32521095871925354,
0.240411639213562,
-0.5388438701629639,
-0.22098350524902344,
0.15654027462005615,
0.045331090688705444,
0.1657497137784958,
0.23360994458198547,
-0.09511230885982513,
0.40721753239631653,
-0.2870076298713684,
0.2661566734313965,
0.6624257564544678,
0.2060997188091278,
0.6091023087501526,
-0.32108303904533386,
1.0418767929077148,
-0.1920384168624878,
0.014622143469750881,
-0.5407316088676453,
-0.3889980614185333,
-0.8684819936752319,
0.10022794455289841,
0.16537097096443176,
0.33159139752388,
-0.5702069997787476,
-0.044950492680072784,
-0.08512772619724274,
-0.17068199813365936,
-0.24927589297294617,
0.5622406601905823,
0.7156122326850891,
0.06499581038951874,
-0.06319744884967804,
-0.22774837911128998,
-0.5862119793891907,
-0.8216025829315186,
-0.2391117364168167,
-0.35804590582847595,
-0.11717933416366577,
0.3858209550380707,
0.7482657432556152,
-0.43365898728370667,
0.6227931380271912,
-0.5672426223754883,
0.05572481453418732,
-0.47357022762298584,
0.2094896286725998,
0.18689049780368805,
0.29117056727409363,
0.6520588994026184,
-0.5922654271125793,
-0.06552178412675858,
-0.12572169303894043,
-0.5518303513526917,
-0.271332710981369,
-0.18531379103660583,
0.18212619423866272,
0.43946754932403564,
0.6400190591812134,
-0.4722083806991577,
0.5233283638954163,
0.7520222067832947,
-0.3884741961956024,
0.6948819756507874,
-0.6554315686225891,
-0.00203522527590394,
-0.7198349833488464,
0.09612967073917389,
-0.05381791666150093,
-0.098596952855587,
-0.4731060564517975,
0.3824707269668579,
0.40624576807022095,
-0.19833511114120483,
-0.3040868937969208,
0.47770705819129944,
-0.7310160398483276,
-0.6647897958755493,
-0.33111485838890076,
0.08587414771318436,
0.18948490917682648,
0.04040168225765228,
-0.011355123482644558,
1.0036907196044922,
0.3228340744972229,
-0.6453431844711304,
0.11398501694202423,
0.013470228761434555,
-0.5775218605995178,
0.286156564950943,
-0.5676321387290955,
0.20011764764785767,
-0.1009201928973198,
0.1648094654083252,
-0.9931687116622925,
-0.3975021541118622,
-0.21658214926719666,
-0.5187825560569763,
0.5071508884429932,
-0.2748682498931885,
-0.7997364401817322,
-0.48428475856781006,
-0.16302001476287842,
0.12630842626094818,
0.6907815933227539,
-0.41986578702926636,
0.5422542691230774,
0.17703329026699066,
0.0014856526395305991,
-0.33612486720085144,
-0.8228554725646973,
0.06856345385313034,
-0.24180985987186432,
-0.8030580282211304,
-0.06849309056997299,
-0.2395090013742447,
-0.8158652782440186,
-0.21046946942806244,
-0.0964246615767479,
-0.33361032605171204,
0.5153273940086365,
0.5152443647384644,
0.2151138037443161,
-0.44842058420181274,
0.4150465726852417,
-0.19169668853282928,
0.1088525801897049,
0.5342691540718079,
-0.0626530647277832,
0.45982789993286133,
-0.17616084218025208,
-0.5785624980926514,
-0.1234278455376625,
0.07212874293327332,
0.7502794861793518,
-0.29716628789901733,
0.9944379329681396,
0.2571248710155487,
-0.0770987868309021,
-0.3721245229244232,
-0.5624155402183533,
-0.09084097295999527,
-0.4966568946838379,
0.5560469031333923,
-0.32902976870536804,
-0.943970799446106,
1.0159615278244019,
0.18727202713489532,
-0.09632883220911026,
0.43794965744018555,
0.53024822473526,
-0.05001154541969299,
0.9809098839759827,
0.8818684220314026,
-0.07123317569494247,
0.48129552602767944,
-0.20239757001399994,
0.2895995080471039,
-0.7575924396514893,
-0.3051793575286865,
-0.8189650177955627,
-0.01117964368313551,
-0.5038643479347229,
-0.3212165832519531,
-0.02299979329109192,
0.24721366167068481,
-0.07244519144296646,
0.024849368259310722,
-0.10026901215314865,
0.5761004090309143,
0.34602120518684387,
0.09526089578866959,
0.5269792675971985,
-0.2754071354866028,
0.1695161908864975,
0.2592794895172119,
-0.6662648916244507,
-0.61394864320755,
1.2132118940353394,
0.6840924024581909,
1.1504542827606201,
0.175179585814476,
0.48481622338294983,
0.23168745636940002,
0.3306286931037903,
-0.7582810521125793,
0.3125597834587097,
0.26326796412467957,
-0.6307562589645386,
-0.05169466882944107,
-0.4764770567417145,
-0.8625093698501587,
-0.0316917710006237,
0.05179827660322189,
-0.5730344653129578,
0.04940002039074898,
0.269628643989563,
-0.0719856321811676,
0.0038905295077711344,
-1.0966792106628418,
0.7310824394226074,
-0.44277024269104004,
-0.01635136269032955,
-0.2954834997653961,
-0.16840927302837372,
0.6337951421737671,
-0.40528565645217896,
0.31496864557266235,
0.09043755382299423,
-0.08760473877191544,
0.578619122505188,
-0.2720387279987335,
0.9108141660690308,
-0.028352342545986176,
-0.44562336802482605,
0.22050468623638153,
0.27342480421066284,
0.5183486342430115,
0.2772041857242584,
-0.21746240556240082,
0.028161967173218727,
-0.1864282786846161,
-0.40554094314575195,
-0.7196952104568481,
0.7904344201087952,
-0.6040377020835876,
-0.8694050312042236,
-0.06594374030828476,
-0.8513675332069397,
0.02105056494474411,
-0.07858651131391525,
0.05519093573093414,
0.41739243268966675,
-0.12817297875881195,
0.11516040563583374,
0.8468181490898132,
-0.7254775762557983,
0.2883935272693634,
0.8109933733940125,
-0.700480043888092,
0.1876303106546402,
0.739234447479248,
0.35165083408355713,
0.5424338579177856,
-0.02090272307395935,
0.05480533465743065,
-0.21971316635608673,
-0.8681575655937195,
-0.21502700448036194,
0.22807885706424713,
-1.1686495542526245,
0.16858896613121033,
-0.36131855845451355,
-0.1980615109205246,
-0.3359008729457855,
-0.19184061884880066,
0.01472316775470972,
-0.23635751008987427,
-0.521084725856781,
-0.20834675431251526,
0.41536372900009155,
1.4137712717056274,
0.3000892400741577,
0.3117291331291199,
-0.8879009485244751,
0.2350684404373169,
0.24143409729003906,
0.5062381625175476,
0.08064386248588562,
-0.7869800329208374,
-0.4333030879497528,
-0.19996410608291626,
-0.0711810365319252,
-0.7783215045928955,
0.06974263489246368,
-0.11948913335800171,
0.6772820949554443,
0.5784142017364502,
-0.30892324447631836,
0.6311078667640686,
-0.3934134542942047,
0.8728414177894592,
0.014087902382016182,
-1.1743292808532715,
0.5253134965896606,
-0.504228413105011,
0.5508992075920105,
0.2636483311653137,
0.08404684066772461,
-0.3093239367008209,
-0.8356903791427612,
-0.6444934606552124,
-0.5529178977012634,
0.5786806344985962,
0.15903909504413605,
0.36310768127441406,
-0.025581492111086845,
0.576678454875946,
-0.011242246255278587,
0.10409777611494064,
-0.8301935791969299,
-0.22470180690288544,
0.17657721042633057,
0.24207022786140442,
-0.26678022742271423,
-0.6970072984695435,
0.10684287548065186,
-0.16440752148628235,
0.35497504472732544,
0.10359539091587067,
0.12420531362295151,
-0.026964612305164337,
-0.2813680171966553,
-0.14048762619495392,
0.34424296021461487,
1.0352667570114136,
1.4698890447616577,
-0.24706299602985382,
0.1787673681974411,
0.23432399332523346,
-0.3325296938419342,
-0.18947984278202057,
-0.05138155817985535,
0.1436299830675125,
-0.0019375028787180781,
0.8180351257324219,
0.584725022315979,
0.20912127196788788,
-0.9355708956718445,
0.5287944078445435,
-0.016090761870145798,
-0.5263078212738037,
-0.3961217403411865,
0.3802749216556549,
0.4095543622970581,
0.24481412768363953,
0.36470118165016174,
-0.30331599712371826,
-0.07431252300739288,
-0.7490907907485962,
0.07327607274055481,
0.3957868814468384,
-0.14206558465957642,
-0.10863809287548065,
0.39882490038871765,
0.035535506904125214,
-0.48962101340293884,
0.6818031072616577,
-0.15389889478683472,
-0.5673566460609436,
1.2282322645187378,
0.8661209344863892,
0.42325446009635925,
-0.05694751814007759,
-0.07659847289323807,
-0.09287457913160324,
0.6916426420211792,
0.0563751645386219,
0.2451203614473343,
0.10849138349294662,
-0.4785999655723572,
-0.8357623815536499,
-0.4007018208503723,
-0.50149005651474,
0.22142921388149261,
-0.6682751178741455,
0.10293781012296677,
-0.4281598627567291,
0.16572286188602448,
-0.1777447760105133,
0.050057824701070786,
-0.7361451387405396,
0.1818413883447647,
0.3031466007232666,
1.2132749557495117,
-0.7630516290664673,
0.9196082949638367,
0.5645560622215271,
-0.6823148131370544,
-1.0611042976379395,
0.08934561908245087,
-0.1743280291557312,
-0.8895270824432373,
0.9425904750823975,
0.15126290917396545,
-0.05277230963110924,
-0.08735349774360657,
-0.5744394063949585,
-0.7539608478546143,
1.1406265497207642,
0.4717366397380829,
-0.6660930514335632,
0.24053724110126495,
0.1982428878545761,
0.7198277115821838,
-0.16542774438858032,
0.4248962700366974,
0.58003169298172,
0.5258736610412598,
-0.09432487934827805,
-1.1070058345794678,
-0.05198344960808754,
-0.11208999156951904,
0.2600885033607483,
0.13184112310409546,
-0.4050927460193634,
0.785244882106781,
-0.3697587847709656,
-0.08778409659862518,
-0.003062757197767496,
0.44136303663253784,
0.19067968428134918,
0.4133395254611969,
0.2258264422416687,
0.41647782921791077,
0.9923458695411682,
0.1651342213153839,
1.5142782926559448,
-0.3506373465061188,
0.34530431032180786,
1.0258780717849731,
-0.37519606947898865,
0.7274016737937927,
0.37664520740509033,
-0.07041031867265701,
0.4556531012058258,
0.5262559056282043,
-0.06966947764158249,
-0.09412787854671478,
0.6285903453826904,
-0.16287042200565338,
-0.027619119733572006,
0.03985455259680748,
-0.6305415034294128,
0.5128845572471619,
0.3040880560874939,
-0.91717129945755,
0.08233018219470978,
0.07473001629114151,
-0.04385382682085037,
-0.020083945244550705,
-0.5388805270195007,
0.6065144538879395,
0.2904312014579773,
-0.5639297962188721,
0.7280538082122803,
0.0281800739467144,
0.3017989695072174,
-0.5684604048728943,
-0.14642851054668427,
-0.42123863101005554,
0.004947258625179529,
-0.37420061230659485,
-0.9644025564193726,
0.4390247166156769,
0.16079181432724,
-0.2680628299713135,
-0.2262825220823288,
0.9443885087966919,
-0.12286030501127243,
-0.36659038066864014,
0.5254799723625183,
0.6211966276168823,
0.3023795485496521,
-0.12393117696046829,
-0.4270857274532318,
0.3906480371952057,
-0.04970185458660126,
-0.40533167123794556,
0.5003161430358887,
0.5058492422103882,
0.22337499260902405,
0.7476722002029419,
0.5779194831848145,
-0.007810524664819241,
-0.010978076606988907,
0.3611554801464081,
0.9803450107574463,
-0.6783959865570068,
-0.28795984387397766,
-0.9716204404830933,
0.2844746708869934,
0.05254914239048958,
-0.11286790668964386,
0.9901561141014099,
0.6841511726379395,
0.8185636401176453,
-0.14125493168830872,
0.7399653792381287,
0.0922999158501625,
-0.09094373136758804,
-0.7966479659080505,
0.8257197141647339,
-0.5590434670448303,
0.6596484780311584,
-0.07404155284166336,
-1.0972058773040771,
-0.33877769112586975,
0.35300537943840027,
-0.525723397731781,
-0.01624254509806633,
0.8069080114364624,
0.9149921536445618,
0.03368512541055679,
-0.0759393721818924,
0.5097200870513916,
0.4552314877510071,
0.23455627262592316,
0.5480412840843201,
1.2454040050506592,
0.020511578768491745,
0.7261926531791687,
0.04626960679888725,
-0.01804298721253872,
-0.23202234506607056,
-0.8686704039573669,
-1.2244668006896973,
-0.23515412211418152,
-0.023124011233448982,
-0.5646304488182068,
-0.02536705881357193,
0.4596606492996216,
0.39483705163002014,
-0.4473944902420044,
-0.25476521253585815,
-0.25764793157577515,
0.518819272518158,
0.12501969933509827,
-0.19352693855762482,
0.18962796032428741,
-0.4591677486896515,
-0.5371537804603577,
0.24047642946243286,
0.3188965618610382,
0.05110803246498108,
-0.5721002221107483,
-0.31842052936553955,
0.2242850363254547,
-0.017007790505886078,
0.591885507106781,
0.14962047338485718,
-0.6543218493461609,
-0.13972267508506775,
-0.019117280840873718,
-0.2746249735355377,
0.15272191166877747,
1.050342321395874,
-0.42714759707450867,
0.37619853019714355,
0.5873056054115295,
0.6157668232917786,
0.37644729018211365,
-0.2880522608757019,
0.6594786643981934,
-0.43079739809036255,
0.03139817714691162,
-0.01768880896270275,
0.5583924055099487,
-0.07466335594654083,
-0.6307035684585571,
0.3479713499546051,
0.00019722514844033867,
-0.8046622276306152,
-0.6315953135490417,
0.09063581377267838,
-0.8145161271095276,
-0.5806163549423218,
1.5721256732940674,
-0.19643382728099823,
-0.25443312525749207,
-0.3598860800266266,
-0.2766299247741699,
0.0009847406763583422,
-0.0937364399433136,
0.6076304316520691,
0.8355271816253662,
0.04453853517770767,
-0.265766441822052,
-1.0424455404281616,
0.1197102889418602,
0.31335049867630005,
-0.7854982614517212,
0.0447319932281971,
0.678148627281189,
0.44836196303367615,
-0.10398631542921066,
0.7157002091407776,
0.0003292238980066031,
0.39453908801078796,
0.057313837110996246,
0.0030336512718349695,
-0.20876024663448334,
-0.14605861902236938,
-0.6912118792533875,
0.09333331882953644,
0.8352972865104675,
0.35723406076431274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03098v1
|
Exploring the Trade-off Between Model Performance and Explanation Plausibility of Text Classifiers Using Human Rationales
| 2024-04-03T22:39:33 | 2024-04-03T22:39:33 |
Lucas E. Resck, Marcos M. Raimundo, Jorge Poco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Saliency post-hoc explainability methods are important tools for
understanding increasingly complex NLP models. While these methods can reflect
the model's reasoning, they may not align with human intuition, making the
explanations not plausible. In this work, we present a methodology for
incorporating rationales, which are text annotations explaining human
decisions, into text classification models. This incorporation enhances the
plausibility of post-hoc explanations while preserving their faithfulness. Our
approach is agnostic to model architectures and explainability methods. We
introduce the rationales during model training by augmenting the standard
cross-entropy loss with a novel loss function inspired by contrastive learning.
By leveraging a multi-objective optimization algorithm, we explore the
trade-off between the two loss functions and generate a Pareto-optimal frontier
of models that balance performance and plausibility. Through extensive
experiments involving diverse models, datasets, and explainability methods, we
demonstrate that our approach significantly enhances the quality of model
explanations without causing substantial (sometimes negligible) degradation in
the original model's performance.
|
[
-0.47826892137527466,
-0.2133983075618744,
0.7957989573478699,
-0.13961608707904816,
-0.39499127864837646,
-0.4425409734249115,
-0.316811203956604,
-0.2818359434604645,
-0.23386839032173157,
0.3357577323913574,
-0.5453911423683167,
-0.27259430289268494,
-0.40899139642715454,
0.052702292799949646,
-0.2341843694448471,
1.1684143543243408,
-0.19044749438762665,
-0.14654648303985596,
-0.5017784833908081,
-0.1410464346408844,
-0.2747894823551178,
-0.6738269925117493,
-0.6134260892868042,
-0.4262237846851349,
0.6123916506767273,
0.15226982533931732,
0.7406948804855347,
0.7343810796737671,
0.4585745930671692,
0.25129860639572144,
0.029613545164465904,
-0.01519734412431717,
-0.20388275384902954,
-0.16863687336444855,
-0.4791487753391266,
-0.6192832589149475,
-0.0861043706536293,
0.134210467338562,
0.4013415277004242,
0.7928345203399658,
0.0034216151107102633,
-0.03572075814008713,
0.2508395314216614,
0.5306426286697388,
-0.7969194650650024,
0.01736801117658615,
-0.6692165732383728,
0.09681297838687897,
0.062246959656476974,
-0.5483744144439697,
-0.6133871078491211,
-0.18510666489601135,
0.7204049229621887,
-0.8298323750495911,
0.48282742500305176,
0.061335936188697815,
0.9587929844856262,
0.5137070417404175,
-0.021324560046195984,
-0.29978126287460327,
-0.55054771900177,
1.058835744857788,
-0.5803685784339905,
0.3079146444797516,
0.48253047466278076,
0.3459438681602478,
0.21385864913463593,
-0.6394020318984985,
-0.46786367893218994,
-0.028542326763272285,
-0.3782346844673157,
0.11686287820339203,
-0.07435040920972824,
0.14162099361419678,
0.23533548414707184,
0.3402566611766815,
-0.5045234560966492,
-0.16330339014530182,
-0.06407546997070312,
-0.16015656292438507,
0.6463673710823059,
-0.12506526708602905,
0.2563881576061249,
0.012768898159265518,
-0.6053860783576965,
-0.049752965569496155,
-0.12673747539520264,
0.39377954602241516,
0.20372602343559265,
-0.039211008697748184,
0.03786039724946022,
0.32195162773132324,
-0.07153628021478653,
0.5629347562789917,
-0.1631447672843933,
-0.09706901758909225,
-0.09932601451873779,
-0.2442239671945572,
-0.3189087510108948,
0.10807086527347565,
0.35328391194343567,
0.6295788884162903,
0.09076029807329178,
-0.4056231677532196,
-0.052610643208026886,
0.3989534378051758,
0.28276827931404114,
-0.7989495396614075,
-0.2838144302368164,
0.13693562150001526,
-0.8641663789749146,
-0.48131057620048523,
-0.0621597021818161,
-0.7799777984619141,
-0.28119537234306335,
-0.5202831029891968,
0.5914000272750854,
-0.49456366896629333,
-0.1297067403793335,
0.38929903507232666,
-0.485624223947525,
0.12366079539060593,
0.55592942237854,
-0.9796907901763916,
0.2806151211261749,
0.4457826316356659,
0.7719288468360901,
-0.1021261066198349,
-0.3936172425746918,
-0.19899117946624756,
0.15659058094024658,
-0.19997717440128326,
0.817782461643219,
-0.5557487607002258,
-0.05978876352310181,
-0.25748077034950256,
-0.19488485157489777,
-0.3120277523994446,
-0.3130825161933899,
0.9347408413887024,
-0.4399677515029907,
0.4772176146507263,
-0.34112420678138733,
-0.5363003611564636,
-0.7211042046546936,
0.06322721391916275,
-0.4643980860710144,
0.8219274282455444,
-0.1641467809677124,
-1.1853867769241333,
0.411041796207428,
-0.7880274653434753,
-0.363309770822525,
-0.17325466871261597,
0.20433878898620605,
-0.4701173007488251,
0.28271421790122986,
0.1232229694724083,
0.524165153503418,
-0.4266352951526642,
0.3481701612472534,
-0.2763423025608063,
-0.43095526099205017,
0.5448060035705566,
-0.5498611330986023,
0.7437660098075867,
0.16256888210773468,
-0.43255969882011414,
0.3049749433994293,
-0.677478551864624,
-0.17978531122207642,
0.09729229658842087,
-0.3073746860027313,
-0.6155292391777039,
0.21319620311260223,
-0.12823230028152466,
0.2705208659172058,
-0.10149578005075455,
-0.06544054299592972,
-0.29641011357307434,
-0.39559438824653625,
0.6942771077156067,
0.5430710315704346,
-0.3090973496437073,
0.7065779566764832,
-0.6354666352272034,
0.4257729947566986,
-0.19489337503910065,
0.18318116664886475,
-0.4006447494029999,
-0.4274921715259552,
-0.752564549446106,
-0.44728073477745056,
0.2485606074333191,
0.4855232536792755,
-0.606896698474884,
0.2868557572364807,
-0.020763011649250984,
-0.3107626438140869,
-0.49553626775741577,
-0.19207918643951416,
0.35328975319862366,
0.8896411657333374,
0.49999329447746277,
-0.13656213879585266,
-0.49409446120262146,
-1.0050429105758667,
-0.7039893269538879,
-0.12178625166416168,
-0.33567047119140625,
0.26212066411972046,
0.46288394927978516,
-0.23577293753623962,
0.9454423189163208,
-0.29609447717666626,
0.31669965386390686,
-0.23069807887077332,
0.386173814535141,
-0.12762536108493805,
0.4092605710029602,
0.5146514177322388,
-1.0083367824554443,
0.1310451179742813,
-0.11861829459667206,
-0.673716127872467,
-0.2339252084493637,
-0.5914575457572937,
-0.43010836839675903,
0.1288062185049057,
0.2691825032234192,
-0.5061984062194824,
0.6574538946151733,
0.2108265906572342,
-0.3190953731536865,
0.6342055797576904,
-0.11946215480566025,
0.10788052529096603,
-0.6162286996841431,
0.0987807884812355,
0.3100545108318329,
-0.1341375857591629,
-0.5932486653327942,
-0.12566837668418884,
-0.19739729166030884,
-0.034900519996881485,
-0.18570628762245178,
0.6323240995407104,
-0.17158973217010498,
-0.23096789419651031,
-0.29041627049446106,
0.1641099452972412,
0.4521431028842926,
0.5669332146644592,
0.34546342492103577,
0.4780022203922272,
0.5598993301391602,
-0.7460881471633911,
-0.1414507031440735,
0.15664832293987274,
-0.11418088525533676,
0.6085881590843201,
-0.7012370228767395,
-0.42048001289367676,
-0.3898533284664154,
0.19999812543392181,
-0.98880535364151,
-0.4360274374485016,
0.38001856207847595,
-0.5269998908042908,
-0.013572399504482746,
-0.05188492313027382,
-0.03435710072517395,
-0.08381079882383347,
-0.5460556745529175,
0.21414071321487427,
0.5188425183296204,
-0.8533746600151062,
0.8063237071037292,
0.048109810799360275,
-0.29840269684791565,
-0.37820929288864136,
-0.6634716987609863,
-0.04626573994755745,
-0.6607580780982971,
-0.666154146194458,
0.6823873519897461,
-0.16614161431789398,
-0.4001060426235199,
-0.04854239523410797,
-0.18482066690921783,
-0.30004391074180603,
0.5817779302597046,
0.10474740713834763,
0.4473605453968048,
-0.1583608090877533,
0.3669092357158661,
0.20590722560882568,
-0.2603454887866974,
0.2685670554637909,
-0.1368681788444519,
0.16886885464191437,
-0.14815586805343628,
-0.04999728873372078,
-1.0647614002227783,
0.21302929520606995,
0.3981457054615021,
-0.16567915678024292,
0.7515484690666199,
0.5146902799606323,
-0.3182237446308136,
-0.2819070518016815,
-0.41515785455703735,
-0.30496343970298767,
-0.38233813643455505,
0.227000892162323,
-0.391044944524765,
-0.5474119186401367,
0.4951116442680359,
-0.17193861305713654,
0.012541919015347958,
0.6829932928085327,
0.3548281490802765,
-0.11067645996809006,
1.0538671016693115,
0.34208357334136963,
0.6129867434501648,
0.5559144020080566,
0.0521186962723732,
0.0902392789721489,
-0.6768954992294312,
-0.3961451053619385,
-0.542621910572052,
-0.1684192419052124,
-0.3477400839328766,
-0.4001498520374298,
-0.09226255863904953,
0.46213552355766296,
-0.13076627254486084,
-0.02974143624305725,
-0.7357338666915894,
0.6277045607566833,
0.6996099948883057,
0.20721688866615295,
0.21098464727401733,
0.07044366002082825,
0.15381461381912231,
-0.16200317442417145,
-0.8747708797454834,
-0.8002456426620483,
0.7329748868942261,
0.514460027217865,
0.4857706129550934,
-0.16154122352600098,
0.4897138774394989,
-0.01992698386311531,
0.4747265577316284,
-0.756224513053894,
0.3025534749031067,
-0.03109297901391983,
-0.41297003626823425,
-0.37640252709388733,
-0.5407359004020691,
-0.5986769795417786,
0.6413648724555969,
-0.44398361444473267,
-0.4842827022075653,
0.2595269978046417,
0.44486749172210693,
-0.3634165823459625,
0.20746955275535583,
-0.943332850933075,
1.2518377304077148,
-0.3947712779045105,
-0.5016433596611023,
-0.13065855205059052,
-0.757727861404419,
0.6166480779647827,
0.024316485971212387,
0.3787439167499542,
0.10314995050430298,
-0.07197882980108261,
0.9182181358337402,
-0.46586719155311584,
0.7177208065986633,
-0.05660700052976608,
0.21678224205970764,
-0.034705113619565964,
-0.08849848806858063,
0.20437921583652496,
0.011338942684233189,
-0.24403662979602814,
0.20921459794044495,
-0.16504427790641785,
-0.5136046409606934,
-0.6431317329406738,
0.36140087246894836,
-0.6441431045532227,
-0.46486255526542664,
-0.2922915518283844,
-0.5463776588439941,
-0.03646021708846092,
0.07283914089202881,
0.38715994358062744,
0.33043819665908813,
0.13617567718029022,
0.14855344593524933,
0.7408214211463928,
-0.4059384763240814,
0.4739249348640442,
-0.040370844304561615,
0.21848756074905396,
-0.36673203110694885,
0.8886724710464478,
-0.11316391080617905,
0.14164623618125916,
0.3383585214614868,
0.6154674291610718,
-0.4531658887863159,
-0.7305911779403687,
-0.29975947737693787,
0.0742214247584343,
-0.8133120536804199,
0.1348879486322403,
-0.5911370515823364,
0.12013604491949081,
-0.023469772189855576,
-0.7919945120811462,
0.043598610907793045,
-0.48640570044517517,
-0.5255710482597351,
-0.03287333622574806,
0.10332579910755157,
0.2768504023551941,
0.04401782900094986,
0.4747215509414673,
-0.5089092254638672,
0.2724533975124359,
0.47975143790245056,
0.3865101933479309,
0.2751375734806061,
-0.8104367852210999,
-0.13427801430225372,
0.020648086443543434,
-0.1716829240322113,
-0.8722273111343384,
0.314458429813385,
0.19830943644046783,
0.7759189009666443,
0.5656413435935974,
0.35892847180366516,
0.43732407689094543,
-0.2186317890882492,
0.464121013879776,
0.35563117265701294,
-1.476759433746338,
0.5730698704719543,
-0.164247065782547,
-0.02771412581205368,
0.5548468232154846,
0.5844180583953857,
-0.18380403518676758,
-0.08922182768583298,
-0.5280503630638123,
-0.8520146012306213,
1.0429013967514038,
0.46205854415893555,
-0.2786702811717987,
0.33822810649871826,
0.6097094416618347,
0.3792000114917755,
0.19876568019390106,
-0.83556067943573,
-0.03339987248182297,
-0.6566541790962219,
-0.304824560880661,
0.036717016249895096,
-0.38735079765319824,
-0.1715005338191986,
-0.015859417617321014,
0.7681798338890076,
-0.08599667251110077,
-0.062341682612895966,
0.3683408796787262,
-0.28407201170921326,
0.3188839256763458,
0.3681834042072296,
0.7524402141571045,
0.8468952178955078,
-0.26134347915649414,
0.4848218858242035,
0.07624413073062897,
-0.015445759519934654,
-0.14639341831207275,
0.3693996071815491,
-0.24907873570919037,
0.13974660634994507,
0.6280421614646912,
1.0226035118103027,
0.3578474223613739,
-0.712446391582489,
0.4623619318008423,
-0.2171855866909027,
-0.27829238772392273,
0.21697258949279785,
-0.006786552257835865,
0.019991962239146233,
0.23179291188716888,
0.28984662890434265,
0.46705642342567444,
0.48862579464912415,
-0.35695740580558777,
0.10717537254095078,
0.3470480442047119,
-0.143169566988945,
-0.3333278000354767,
0.9068607091903687,
0.22549715638160706,
-0.1799977719783783,
-0.08189181983470917,
-0.08456972241401672,
-0.6542906761169434,
0.5961806178092957,
0.2149098515510559,
0.8449330925941467,
-0.234780415892601,
0.49262988567352295,
0.27458062767982483,
0.27626341581344604,
-0.36051294207572937,
-0.159419447183609,
-0.3625440001487732,
-0.6046892404556274,
-0.43092864751815796,
-0.5983365178108215,
-0.5258925557136536,
-0.179486483335495,
-0.8177481293678284,
0.19680434465408325,
-0.3343140482902527,
-0.06301756203174591,
0.6335703134536743,
-0.38796451687812805,
-0.4026098847389221,
0.3542693853378296,
0.1288791000843048,
0.6896378397941589,
-0.9817177057266235,
0.24523021280765533,
0.5334033370018005,
-0.524251401424408,
-0.44563159346580505,
0.3266526758670807,
-0.32016244530677795,
-0.582653820514679,
0.5854803919792175,
0.46595603227615356,
-0.2032601684331894,
-0.31868672370910645,
-0.4229220449924469,
-0.4998689889907837,
0.8490698337554932,
0.6118202209472656,
-0.35570022463798523,
-0.05497942864894867,
-0.29057586193084717,
0.5041289329528809,
-0.32774296402931213,
0.27745598554611206,
0.39264386892318726,
0.5225687026977539,
0.24955829977989197,
-0.5155948400497437,
0.16257020831108093,
0.005709594581276178,
0.26273053884506226,
-0.16689835488796234,
-0.2684208154678345,
0.6671097278594971,
-0.3814387619495392,
-0.25617003440856934,
-0.09854740649461746,
0.3035821318626404,
0.3361392617225647,
0.8589305281639099,
0.7058879733085632,
0.5020743608474731,
0.8466065526008606,
-0.12340351194143295,
1.3937604427337646,
-0.06177317723631859,
0.31724095344543457,
0.9392886757850647,
-0.09159521013498306,
0.6942750215530396,
0.4799758195877075,
-0.12115026265382767,
0.5496437549591064,
0.9409061074256897,
0.19043004512786865,
0.6866611242294312,
0.2099296599626541,
-0.22065550088882446,
-0.6327542066574097,
-0.24255849421024323,
-0.1774473488330841,
0.2993010878562927,
0.04560020565986633,
-0.6465069651603699,
-0.22892557084560394,
0.03968603163957596,
-0.021686067804694176,
0.1360291838645935,
-0.40780413150787354,
0.6794862747192383,
-0.21170836687088013,
-0.6998602747917175,
0.5757694244384766,
0.09018442779779434,
0.6611972451210022,
-0.25010570883750916,
0.02160048298537731,
-0.00710842851549387,
0.19933244585990906,
-0.31189438700675964,
-0.49031510949134827,
0.510566771030426,
-0.18758921325206757,
-0.622230589389801,
-0.3235270082950592,
0.6600161194801331,
-0.49949130415916443,
-0.350639671087265,
0.1258130818605423,
0.04578633978962898,
0.1854984015226364,
-0.18209348618984222,
-0.7147600054740906,
0.06178063526749611,
0.052032262086868286,
-0.1782923936843872,
0.2325143963098526,
0.6198623180389404,
0.021060360595583916,
0.5574485063552856,
0.6988375782966614,
-0.30564162135124207,
-0.3476828932762146,
-0.21307922899723053,
0.7741819620132446,
-0.5112739205360413,
-0.6821207404136658,
-1.060850739479065,
0.634033203125,
-0.16319639980793,
-0.2124449908733368,
0.59843510389328,
0.48031845688819885,
0.6897753477096558,
-0.08411645144224167,
1.0211308002471924,
0.5399298667907715,
0.5635121464729309,
-0.7217658162117004,
0.48830845952033997,
-0.6938440203666687,
0.4052071273326874,
-0.2176748514175415,
-0.5916168689727783,
-0.49297207593917847,
0.8419230580329895,
-0.5246927738189697,
-0.046195030212402344,
0.7262442111968994,
0.40012696385383606,
0.0601152628660202,
0.21180744469165802,
0.28151068091392517,
0.04843304678797722,
-0.04381711408495903,
0.4558642506599426,
0.8877511024475098,
-0.19402793049812317,
0.7044237852096558,
-0.18315784633159637,
-0.4976322054862976,
-0.4956530034542084,
-0.8879974484443665,
-1.1908553838729858,
-0.35276246070861816,
-0.522483766078949,
-0.14986063539981842,
0.12593604624271393,
0.4844086170196533,
0.8422254920005798,
-0.6686047315597534,
0.25193679332733154,
-0.23894169926643372,
0.48877254128456116,
-0.11829353123903275,
-0.2752505838871002,
0.506553053855896,
-0.4305289387702942,
-0.48957958817481995,
-0.029606562107801437,
0.324584424495697,
0.17267253994941711,
0.0863114595413208,
-0.20780672132968903,
-0.016367493197321892,
0.300110787153244,
0.7310330867767334,
0.12182176113128662,
-1.0498851537704468,
0.006391698494553566,
-0.14132407307624817,
0.24752061069011688,
-0.1369549185037613,
0.9658960700035095,
-0.6542791128158569,
0.45963799953460693,
0.513431966304779,
0.8917809128761292,
0.16626690328121185,
0.1942920833826065,
0.5474820733070374,
-0.40224409103393555,
0.1407381147146225,
0.19319970905780792,
0.41653943061828613,
0.5257430076599121,
-0.27627837657928467,
0.4568122625350952,
0.39141061902046204,
-0.48442238569259644,
-0.995302140712738,
0.05101310834288597,
-1.0159087181091309,
-0.7124284505844116,
0.7970284819602966,
-0.34946054220199585,
-0.14446347951889038,
-0.2348499596118927,
-0.378264456987381,
0.17737218737602234,
-0.2897655665874481,
0.9161693453788757,
0.7707199454307556,
-0.32247689366340637,
-0.36760252714157104,
-0.44781798124313354,
0.7611974477767944,
0.5666998028755188,
-1.1428462266921997,
0.29108065366744995,
0.44705313444137573,
0.0303169135004282,
0.2155677080154419,
0.21424710750579834,
0.15862900018692017,
0.49654269218444824,
0.014991373755037785,
0.18749728798866272,
0.07493189722299576,
-0.30408069491386414,
-0.4930521249771118,
0.20935337245464325,
-0.10956262052059174,
-0.2099844366312027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03092v1
|
Unsupervised, Bottom-up Category Discovery for Symbol Grounding with a Curious Robot
| 2024-04-03T22:13:04 | 2024-04-03T22:13:04 |
Catherine Henry, Casey Kennington
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Towards addressing the Symbol Grounding Problem and motivated by early
childhood language development, we leverage a robot which has been equipped
with an approximate model of curiosity with particular focus on bottom-up
building of unsupervised categories grounded in the physical world. That is,
rather than starting with a top-down symbol (e.g., a word referring to an
object) and providing meaning through the application of predetermined samples,
the robot autonomously and gradually breaks up its exploration space into a
series of increasingly specific unlabeled categories at which point an external
expert may optionally provide a symbol association. We extend prior work by
using a robot that can observe the visual world, introducing a higher
dimensional sensory space, and using a more generalizable method of category
building. Our experiments show that the robot learns categories based on
actions and what it visually observes, and that those categories can be
symbolically grounded into.https://info.arxiv.org/help/prep#comments
|
[
-0.36787283420562744,
-0.42180806398391724,
0.5524753928184509,
-0.09636226296424866,
-0.3474315106868744,
0.5450947880744934,
0.07030618190765381,
-0.32458996772766113,
0.4518958330154419,
0.348123699426651,
-0.5850598812103271,
-0.46439802646636963,
-0.6990631222724915,
-0.2048187553882599,
-0.24339628219604492,
0.532457709312439,
0.19701093435287476,
-0.3342915177345276,
-0.09853480756282806,
-0.046187154948711395,
-0.5629570484161377,
-0.758554220199585,
-0.4864068925380707,
-0.3756687641143799,
0.45107758045196533,
0.5964791774749756,
0.6452284455299377,
0.6639991998672485,
0.5641500353813171,
0.266977995634079,
-0.30575698614120483,
0.1659815013408661,
-0.23686234652996063,
0.005959473550319672,
-0.22826068103313446,
-0.6026812791824341,
-0.3209052085876465,
-0.13756680488586426,
0.30668237805366516,
1.1374728679656982,
0.04972655326128006,
0.14964835345745087,
-0.3119410276412964,
0.9401298761367798,
-0.6241542100906372,
0.4323617219924927,
-0.34556832909584045,
0.532967746257782,
0.07021673768758774,
-0.3221158981323242,
-0.16427767276763916,
0.017787398770451546,
-0.2160341441631317,
-0.6231720447540283,
0.25303828716278076,
0.22197391092777252,
0.8519082069396973,
0.4595106244087219,
-0.5654221773147583,
-0.22110219299793243,
-0.7337484955787659,
0.7127458453178406,
0.10920223593711853,
0.7734160423278809,
0.6187280416488647,
0.06265906244516373,
-0.21928882598876953,
-0.724292516708374,
-0.5790221095085144,
-0.5415216684341431,
-0.004193041007965803,
0.22199812531471252,
-0.48580899834632874,
-0.09103760123252869,
0.3659514784812927,
0.4270689785480499,
-0.39683207869529724,
-0.10455235838890076,
-0.413995623588562,
-0.22755976021289825,
0.311850368976593,
-0.07965119183063507,
0.7308533191680908,
-0.21625009179115295,
-0.3571853041648865,
-0.4008173942565918,
-0.8627394437789917,
0.40763258934020996,
0.1702028065919876,
0.42257386445999146,
0.047977883368730545,
1.1590238809585571,
-0.42962920665740967,
0.37222012877464294,
0.25055959820747375,
0.3649085760116577,
0.3867759108543396,
-0.08529476821422577,
-0.10627679526805878,
-0.015620285645127296,
0.4130150377750397,
0.538766086101532,
0.43048593401908875,
-0.28850480914115906,
-0.36539673805236816,
0.6197919249534607,
0.5320738554000854,
-0.4489849805831909,
-0.7950311303138733,
0.07838667929172516,
-0.511438250541687,
-0.24554109573364258,
-0.015212319791316986,
-0.3311891555786133,
-0.6967892646789551,
-0.31717973947525024,
0.42503291368484497,
-0.15147115290164948,
-0.2741951048374176,
0.41233786940574646,
-0.17729024589061737,
-0.13969455659389496,
0.2967299520969391,
-0.8295247554779053,
0.22910703718662262,
0.2663317322731018,
0.6006679534912109,
0.1854316145181656,
-0.00674832658842206,
-0.5229299664497375,
0.11049436032772064,
-0.7283806800842285,
0.8698352575302124,
-0.7323727011680603,
-0.29640865325927734,
-0.17842482030391693,
0.2868694067001343,
0.34688523411750793,
-0.4203720986843109,
0.40017494559288025,
-0.4842112958431244,
0.4287283420562744,
-0.16645410656929016,
-0.21866990625858307,
-0.4115358889102936,
0.39073601365089417,
-0.6995145082473755,
1.4156588315963745,
0.2368697226047516,
-0.7548231482505798,
0.5921119451522827,
-0.7233000993728638,
-0.3153735399246216,
0.35952866077423096,
-0.44196686148643494,
0.03566983714699745,
0.2662900686264038,
0.2807905375957489,
0.5323162078857422,
-0.00615333765745163,
0.27200689911842346,
-0.1816391795873642,
-0.16259823739528656,
-0.05132199451327324,
0.11675631254911423,
0.6098860502243042,
0.01893536001443863,
-0.35918429493904114,
0.4718853533267975,
-0.9192048907279968,
-0.06153159216046333,
0.3125476837158203,
0.15672704577445984,
-0.7295516133308411,
0.2866569757461548,
-0.14955031871795654,
0.219059556722641,
0.3657151758670807,
-0.5139772295951843,
0.4231194257736206,
-0.4551912546157837,
0.06246550753712654,
0.639616072177887,
-0.0014848073478788137,
0.5967398881912231,
-0.2160356342792511,
0.5277754068374634,
-0.007640245370566845,
0.0378536731004715,
-0.34321609139442444,
-0.5661578178405762,
-1.19038724899292,
-0.11813181638717651,
0.038595136255025864,
0.4422750174999237,
-0.8476349711418152,
0.9265923500061035,
0.05384213849902153,
-0.3591797649860382,
-0.1805473268032074,
-0.052266303449869156,
0.3272998332977295,
0.43441832065582275,
0.4613085985183716,
-0.6547098755836487,
-0.6169071197509766,
-0.863808810710907,
0.3287743031978607,
-0.36992716789245605,
-0.41791531443595886,
0.35099315643310547,
0.49398499727249146,
-0.4479618966579437,
0.8309770226478577,
-0.6477809548377991,
-0.5026030540466309,
-0.11121194809675217,
0.1474497765302658,
0.3941919207572937,
0.5197262763977051,
0.5220946073532104,
-0.8049184679985046,
0.05046191066503525,
0.31528547406196594,
-0.7445151209831238,
0.15287719666957855,
0.1492571383714676,
-0.22092083096504211,
-0.25576668977737427,
0.5228899121284485,
-0.7755246758460999,
0.3984133303165436,
0.03717409074306488,
-0.5153701901435852,
-0.11415137350559235,
-0.21901443600654602,
-0.03550390154123306,
-0.9197484850883484,
0.07894575595855713,
-0.10563443601131439,
0.0722748413681984,
-0.7415167689323425,
0.3217349350452423,
0.048046816140413284,
0.061975836753845215,
-0.5200284719467163,
0.4608440697193146,
-0.5013589859008789,
-0.22062964737415314,
-0.4643186032772064,
0.03820952773094177,
-0.26025912165641785,
0.5849254131317139,
0.44837045669555664,
0.5180561542510986,
0.851331353187561,
-0.8538273572921753,
0.22485017776489258,
0.06524121016263962,
-0.12326598912477493,
-0.03480102866888046,
-0.5438393950462341,
0.19560196995735168,
-0.10306373238563538,
-0.024807864800095558,
-1.0465528964996338,
-0.252929151058197,
0.810236394405365,
-0.7077051401138306,
0.02985239401459694,
-0.07626818120479584,
-0.8267218470573425,
-0.4791676700115204,
-0.17073796689510345,
0.37998688220977783,
0.737271785736084,
-0.7814933061599731,
0.4723469614982605,
0.8169111609458923,
0.14504669606685638,
-0.5096302032470703,
-0.29427680373191833,
0.06116821616888046,
-0.2876744866371155,
-0.29390597343444824,
-0.13773207366466522,
-0.20863191783428192,
-0.21426904201507568,
-0.05945415049791336,
-0.495978981256485,
-0.05004158988595009,
0.47593453526496887,
0.20942868292331696,
-0.041705336421728134,
-0.15606963634490967,
0.25170156359672546,
0.14369270205497742,
-0.17520232498645782,
0.4639609158039093,
-0.22721101343631744,
0.775150716304779,
-0.3766942322254181,
-0.21597450971603394,
-0.1115153506398201,
0.0799865797162056,
0.3953810930252075,
-0.10623107850551605,
0.04834167659282684,
0.29407864809036255,
-0.9430543184280396,
-0.32325422763824463,
0.1432320475578308,
-0.3560291528701782,
-0.5338013172149658,
0.183318093419075,
-0.39367422461509705,
-0.9179024696350098,
0.5133525133132935,
-0.119162917137146,
-0.39590880274772644,
0.40430858731269836,
0.6076699495315552,
-0.24232259392738342,
1.098386287689209,
1.2309701442718506,
0.19831302762031555,
0.2206152230501175,
-0.2752085030078888,
0.21012960374355316,
-0.6720241904258728,
-0.7161239385604858,
-0.42386218905448914,
-0.19406045973300934,
-0.8034375905990601,
-0.710019052028656,
0.0246109701693058,
0.31894388794898987,
-0.23347893357276917,
0.23594729602336884,
-0.8258087038993835,
0.7753561735153198,
0.8225300312042236,
0.21085187792778015,
0.26495739817619324,
0.05252617970108986,
-0.28948110342025757,
0.026165980845689774,
-0.678392767906189,
-0.7254716753959656,
0.9996200203895569,
0.227112278342247,
0.5978224277496338,
-0.0033256926108151674,
0.6544356346130371,
0.43920281529426575,
0.3590933084487915,
-1.0966771841049194,
0.7064636945724487,
-0.10874708741903305,
-0.5388447642326355,
-0.24496003985404968,
0.17331038415431976,
-1.2005889415740967,
0.3135581314563751,
-0.08496268093585968,
-0.9534572958946228,
0.25105977058410645,
0.3579704761505127,
0.06680052727460861,
0.33867883682250977,
-0.33121153712272644,
0.6115392446517944,
-0.22538597881793976,
-0.023925086483359337,
0.15729881823062897,
-0.9422332644462585,
0.408357709646225,
-0.09627573937177658,
0.14468315243721008,
0.052121683955192566,
-0.05990554392337799,
0.6445823311805725,
0.07928618043661118,
1.1047488451004028,
-0.09878060221672058,
-0.5550203919410706,
0.2588988244533539,
0.2956324517726898,
0.017241407185792923,
0.009151975624263287,
0.6205763816833496,
0.06370115280151367,
-0.5437332987785339,
-0.26051658391952515,
-0.7302091717720032,
0.13396364450454712,
-0.8618282079696655,
-0.5336563587188721,
-0.748590350151062,
-0.37806928157806396,
-0.2561866343021393,
0.6217544674873352,
-0.10167396068572998,
-0.06258805096149445,
0.015791144222021103,
0.4034566581249237,
0.9001099467277527,
-0.09587565064430237,
0.19817475974559784,
0.4775366485118866,
-0.5323428511619568,
-0.052515264600515366,
0.9844889044761658,
-0.4337726831436157,
-0.2832704782485962,
0.8772481083869934,
0.4558374285697937,
-0.31038200855255127,
-0.26353341341018677,
-0.35335472226142883,
-0.22306521236896515,
-0.8066549301147461,
-0.09348228573799133,
-0.7292100191116333,
0.04750562831759453,
0.13036730885505676,
-0.23516398668289185,
-0.5607118010520935,
-0.5640991926193237,
-0.3611365556716919,
-0.31022438406944275,
0.26254865527153015,
0.7799253463745117,
-0.17089363932609558,
0.2755688726902008,
-0.637813150882721,
0.7577404975891113,
0.2027178257703781,
0.39626529812812805,
-0.12610217928886414,
-0.44799333810806274,
-0.1359466016292572,
0.17504006624221802,
-0.04398363083600998,
-0.5017199516296387,
0.25988680124282837,
-0.22276568412780762,
0.5300067067146301,
0.4779547452926636,
0.19861796498298645,
0.4432238042354584,
-0.5293673872947693,
0.8049902319908142,
0.4337846338748932,
-0.9281840920448303,
0.9175527691841125,
-0.4525926411151886,
0.11397363245487213,
0.17198419570922852,
0.5368887186050415,
-0.40514835715293884,
-0.5679029822349548,
-0.7426067590713501,
-0.9950671792030334,
0.5442715287208557,
0.334182471036911,
0.22113454341888428,
-0.17139028012752533,
0.06499665230512619,
0.2609838843345642,
0.3213217556476593,
-0.8731670379638672,
-0.31544166803359985,
-0.5401756763458252,
0.04395611211657524,
-0.33429694175720215,
0.1268797516822815,
-0.5197490453720093,
-0.277278333902359,
0.01404823549091816,
-0.3076189160346985,
0.4061047434806824,
-0.16748930513858795,
-0.27719709277153015,
-0.40401336550712585,
0.010346082970499992,
0.5430285334587097,
0.28977131843566895,
-0.3969321548938751,
0.5115082859992981,
-0.3317412734031677,
-0.5220590829849243,
0.219829723238945,
-0.25621652603149414,
-0.08969065546989441,
-0.18315814435482025,
0.38341766595840454,
0.7106531858444214,
0.2467106282711029,
-0.7749437689781189,
0.0788472443819046,
0.05438057333230972,
-0.12413099408149719,
-0.31206339597702026,
0.357361763715744,
-0.1445702612400055,
0.33975180983543396,
0.5695908069610596,
0.05518005043268204,
0.26824069023132324,
-0.6324032545089722,
0.49606257677078247,
0.32619959115982056,
-0.386295348405838,
-0.5346890091896057,
0.6523820161819458,
0.01529393345117569,
-0.4258217513561249,
0.4270860254764557,
-0.28988564014434814,
-0.6580769419670105,
1.0628491640090942,
0.4259345829486847,
1.0406408309936523,
0.03131115064024925,
0.313127726316452,
0.2604796886444092,
0.8988584876060486,
-0.02589508146047592,
0.6938196420669556,
-0.43422645330429077,
-1.0694990158081055,
-0.09931167960166931,
-0.26988622546195984,
-0.7170190215110779,
0.1424330621957779,
-0.7662945985794067,
0.02402789145708084,
-0.48309794068336487,
0.13788825273513794,
-0.4162592887878418,
0.03770254924893379,
-0.6662420034408569,
0.7069838643074036,
0.3258655369281769,
0.3577916920185089,
-1.0535669326782227,
0.6652503609657288,
1.3137212991714478,
-0.5082661509513855,
-0.571966826915741,
0.18596050143241882,
-0.3092884123325348,
-1.1175144910812378,
1.2345095872879028,
0.39962586760520935,
-0.6129437685012817,
0.1791941374540329,
-0.7527412176132202,
-1.2111356258392334,
0.8513670563697815,
-0.18857257068157196,
-0.1949501782655716,
0.3930720090866089,
-0.044105563312768936,
0.8522438406944275,
-0.3479146361351013,
0.1294904202222824,
0.03446925804018974,
0.4132886826992035,
0.12676464021205902,
-0.3039383590221405,
0.1464764028787613,
-0.5536707639694214,
-0.25654181838035583,
0.3462211489677429,
-0.641876757144928,
0.7244874238967896,
-0.4062345027923584,
-0.5370565056800842,
-0.02060857228934765,
0.8315595984458923,
0.495174765586853,
0.6227498650550842,
0.5641114115715027,
0.550842821598053,
0.8094306588172913,
0.0017281407490372658,
0.7360432147979736,
-0.3601006269454956,
0.36615365743637085,
0.8380412459373474,
-0.30566883087158203,
0.5030591487884521,
0.4847702980041504,
-0.05985167622566223,
0.2675652503967285,
0.858985185623169,
-0.011547398753464222,
0.7550345063209534,
0.33468353748321533,
0.13211092352867126,
-0.3985612988471985,
-0.22917814552783966,
-0.4270806610584259,
0.3900308609008789,
0.48632004857063293,
-0.08950268477201462,
-0.1508713811635971,
0.0531037300825119,
-0.40727266669273376,
0.15870048105716705,
-0.451814740896225,
0.3669361472129822,
-0.06265224516391754,
-0.3600344955921173,
0.39767131209373474,
-0.10553629696369171,
0.27061405777931213,
-0.23432517051696777,
-0.2906012237071991,
-0.4343368113040924,
0.03042604960501194,
0.0658954307436943,
-0.8786417245864868,
-0.19022193551063538,
-0.09647364169359207,
-0.11501940339803696,
-0.41135773062705994,
0.911187469959259,
-0.19914360344409943,
-0.4914470314979553,
0.258975088596344,
0.8667454719543457,
0.19235442578792572,
0.25264790654182434,
-0.3131464719772339,
-0.04236980900168419,
-0.2604980766773224,
-0.4257532060146332,
0.28909990191459656,
0.7662116289138794,
-0.3836669921875,
1.0094709396362305,
0.8046591281890869,
-0.35077759623527527,
0.025420457124710083,
0.23165611922740936,
1.084398627281189,
-1.002570629119873,
-0.4652365446090698,
-0.38538235425949097,
0.6970046162605286,
0.34301307797431946,
-0.3337327837944031,
0.7160611152648926,
0.4844638705253601,
1.1956658363342285,
-0.4657033085823059,
0.4386409819126129,
-0.10640265792608261,
0.19990919530391693,
-0.5763955116271973,
0.5985448956489563,
-0.8899392485618591,
-0.04630820080637932,
-0.41821902990341187,
-0.8873369693756104,
-0.8305706977844238,
1.121443510055542,
0.3608841300010681,
0.01824921742081642,
0.9514922499656677,
0.37127962708473206,
-0.10978838056325912,
-0.15793174505233765,
0.48178645968437195,
-0.043582357466220856,
0.14450505375862122,
0.28152382373809814,
1.313330888748169,
-0.06937376409769058,
-0.05104658007621765,
-0.610481321811676,
-0.3145647943019867,
-0.04331764206290245,
-0.8304461240768433,
-1.3178507089614868,
-0.5800214409828186,
-0.37538352608680725,
0.06182868033647537,
-0.10091628134250641,
0.8006339073181152,
0.4029184579849243,
-0.6624318957328796,
-0.2238936722278595,
-0.5576860904693604,
0.20668967068195343,
-0.03573668748140335,
-0.15915220975875854,
0.48136886954307556,
-0.21255287528038025,
-0.7357625365257263,
0.6801515221595764,
0.31134462356567383,
0.01887659728527069,
-0.2503237724304199,
0.12626655399799347,
0.03136042132973671,
-0.14110127091407776,
0.8517876267433167,
0.5522603988647461,
-0.7424350380897522,
-0.6096755862236023,
0.315793514251709,
0.20047326385974884,
0.1965344250202179,
0.8629769086837769,
-0.992602527141571,
0.5028619766235352,
0.21095463633537292,
0.5209972262382507,
0.16953545808792114,
-0.02827959880232811,
0.20115073025226593,
-0.8784461617469788,
0.3189879059791565,
0.4782557785511017,
0.33786991238594055,
0.012193385511636734,
-0.3456799387931824,
0.7527523636817932,
0.41283154487609863,
-0.11227336525917053,
-1.049950122833252,
0.462008535861969,
-1.23054039478302,
-0.11063534021377563,
0.9138139486312866,
0.36240315437316895,
-0.056211017072200775,
0.05549006164073944,
-0.29119551181793213,
0.3439873456954956,
-0.33675557374954224,
1.0289474725723267,
0.5856639742851257,
-0.3202677071094513,
-0.2431945651769638,
-0.19972465932369232,
0.09748286753892899,
0.4434991180896759,
-0.7124362587928772,
-0.14134696125984192,
0.5713494420051575,
-0.11787392199039459,
0.48137739300727844,
0.5848389267921448,
0.19824853539466858,
0.3280019164085388,
0.053189054131507874,
0.568813145160675,
0.13654561340808868,
-0.891930341720581,
-0.12275663018226624,
0.29004478454589844,
-0.06695431470870972,
-0.4420064091682434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03086v1
|
Auditing the Use of Language Models to Guide Hiring Decisions
| 2024-04-03T22:01:26 | 2024-04-03T22:01:26 |
Johann D. Gaebler, Sharad Goel, Aziz Huq, Prasanna Tambe
|
stat.AP
|
stat.AP, cs.CL
|
Regulatory efforts to protect against algorithmic bias have taken on
increased urgency with rapid advances in large language models (LLMs), which
are machine learning models that can achieve performance rivaling human experts
on a wide array of tasks. A key theme of these initiatives is algorithmic
"auditing," but current regulations -- as well as the scientific literature --
provide little guidance on how to conduct these assessments. Here we propose
and investigate one approach for auditing algorithms: correspondence
experiments, a widely applied tool for detecting bias in human judgements. In
the employment context, correspondence experiments aim to measure the extent to
which race and gender impact decisions by experimentally manipulating elements
of submitted application materials that suggest an applicant's demographic
traits, such as their listed name. We apply this method to audit candidate
assessments produced by several state-of-the-art LLMs, using a novel corpus of
applications to K-12 teaching positions in a large public school district. We
find evidence of moderate race and gender disparities, a pattern largely robust
to varying the types of application material input to the models, as well as
the framing of the task to the LLMs. We conclude by discussing some important
limitations of correspondence experiments for auditing algorithms.
|
[
-0.19041059911251068,
-0.3743274509906769,
0.6910344958305359,
0.06591293960809708,
0.21419253945350647,
0.041179027408361435,
-0.17142292857170105,
-0.4314974546432495,
0.15496166050434113,
0.5541909337043762,
-0.5825235247612,
-0.3653121888637543,
-0.5910294651985168,
0.17692050337791443,
-0.8533183336257935,
0.8506823778152466,
-0.13748463988304138,
0.48532822728157043,
-0.40224578976631165,
0.08323751389980316,
-0.8540206551551819,
-0.3775475323200226,
-0.448332816362381,
-0.3926864564418793,
0.301927387714386,
0.43298783898353577,
0.5572023987770081,
0.9510815739631653,
0.5223380327224731,
0.33427372574806213,
-0.055116474628448486,
-0.008791055530309677,
-0.3425982594490051,
-0.08284329622983932,
-0.29574376344680786,
-0.9859724044799805,
-0.22615361213684082,
0.48617926239967346,
0.6034156680107117,
1.0143128633499146,
-0.17546728253364563,
0.35124215483665466,
-0.09083781391382217,
0.7598572373390198,
-0.862939715385437,
0.06736315786838531,
-0.7816684246063232,
-0.023548753932118416,
-0.33360666036605835,
-0.09331825375556946,
-0.3999958038330078,
-0.5736933946609497,
0.2630973160266876,
-0.17658455669879913,
0.5387909412384033,
0.30347922444343567,
0.5834089517593384,
0.07878793776035309,
-0.496800035238266,
-0.5501171350479126,
-0.7444227337837219,
0.8303359150886536,
-0.6463140249252319,
0.5030152797698975,
0.887287437915802,
0.3491019904613495,
-0.2553058862686157,
-0.2655678987503052,
-0.5615561008453369,
-0.18109197914600372,
-0.18885460495948792,
-0.019242258742451668,
0.21171459555625916,
0.2550314664840698,
0.4352063834667206,
0.3918628990650177,
-0.407969206571579,
0.32229775190353394,
-0.5970647931098938,
-0.14254975318908691,
0.5793527960777283,
0.3043091893196106,
0.38019582629203796,
0.15230481326580048,
0.13067826628684998,
-0.5418649911880493,
-0.6393035054206848,
-0.10479753464460373,
0.8854777812957764,
0.3768547475337982,
0.07402625679969788,
0.6292067766189575,
-0.1396985948085785,
0.6981942057609558,
-0.15194043517112732,
0.10075831413269043,
-0.12821754813194275,
-0.2778710424900055,
-0.06487260013818741,
0.22904106974601746,
0.5265933275222778,
0.447094202041626,
0.36860188841819763,
-0.038146547973155975,
-0.3255280554294586,
0.685964822769165,
0.14967133104801178,
-0.3831140100955963,
-0.25199732184410095,
0.09021226316690445,
-0.24089373648166656,
-0.2920161485671997,
0.07569224387407303,
-1.0103816986083984,
-0.6653066277503967,
-0.45044130086898804,
0.13356620073318481,
0.011047602631151676,
0.0027230281848460436,
0.0766124501824379,
-0.2597711682319641,
0.07398437708616257,
0.3858031630516052,
-1.1950862407684326,
0.392638623714447,
0.885617196559906,
0.4224177598953247,
-0.09149535745382309,
-0.5114330053329468,
-0.6112814545631409,
-0.07209397107362747,
-0.4668509066104889,
0.3645937144756317,
-0.9044376015663147,
-0.22089989483356476,
0.39788320660591125,
-0.06165226176381111,
-0.02713424526154995,
-0.6582111120223999,
0.4592815041542053,
-0.5579413175582886,
0.5878963470458984,
-0.09724730998277664,
-0.7045860886573792,
-0.1448087990283966,
-0.07819385081529617,
-0.520009458065033,
1.0966342687606812,
0.09679456055164337,
-0.5525351762771606,
0.6472651362419128,
-0.6157073378562927,
-0.042612235993146896,
-0.29301825165748596,
-0.48046979308128357,
-0.5864810943603516,
0.04242902621626854,
-0.0003976179286837578,
0.08183995634317398,
-0.23861931264400482,
0.5010935068130493,
-0.32648006081581116,
-0.6637504696846008,
0.24648632109165192,
-0.24521008133888245,
0.97133868932724,
-0.051126960664987564,
-0.3756062984466553,
0.09243091195821762,
-0.508634090423584,
-0.4954754114151001,
-0.0875101387500763,
-0.2938176095485687,
-0.6144182085990906,
0.1869693249464035,
-0.2425839751958847,
-0.08643124997615814,
-0.11998826265335083,
-0.5267874598503113,
0.06713803857564926,
-0.04281722754240036,
0.16737090051174164,
1.069968819618225,
-0.5161745548248291,
0.4387127757072449,
-0.5956786274909973,
0.5317080616950989,
-0.2582933008670807,
-0.1564461886882782,
-0.22605018317699432,
-0.4316679835319519,
-0.79918372631073,
-0.1825786679983139,
0.6206859946250916,
0.5215532183647156,
-0.21731792390346527,
0.46011579036712646,
-0.14132221043109894,
-0.6221765875816345,
-0.8303250670433044,
0.1602153778076172,
0.1975817084312439,
0.28927934169769287,
-0.2876807153224945,
-0.286909282207489,
-0.6970430016517639,
-0.895247220993042,
-0.7340184450149536,
-0.33502739667892456,
-0.28456225991249084,
0.3480975925922394,
0.7337843775749207,
-0.33181032538414,
1.055667519569397,
-0.38750261068344116,
-0.14798349142074585,
0.4801155924797058,
0.07563897967338562,
0.419668972492218,
0.5915330648422241,
0.5438450574874878,
-0.4744188189506531,
-0.25403788685798645,
-0.20521435141563416,
-0.5467031002044678,
-0.3758697807788849,
-0.08635691553354263,
-0.24913747608661652,
-0.22140152752399445,
0.47805166244506836,
-0.2260848730802536,
0.4466114640235901,
0.6494867205619812,
-0.4531334340572357,
0.6649250984191895,
-0.08161294460296631,
0.07718441635370255,
-0.46197277307510376,
0.08699557930231094,
0.19237679243087769,
-0.3464297354221344,
-0.5710148215293884,
-0.0010171366157010198,
0.14828993380069733,
-0.07112643867731094,
-0.24824993312358856,
0.5425533056259155,
-0.4389902651309967,
-0.272892028093338,
-0.03579236567020416,
0.05893596634268761,
-0.22336237132549286,
0.22681277990341187,
-0.11930903792381287,
0.8366039395332336,
0.34474506974220276,
-0.5290063619613647,
0.14254118502140045,
0.4467889070510864,
-0.630391538143158,
0.7191058993339539,
-0.23246631026268005,
0.3218405246734619,
-0.322726309299469,
0.1536613255739212,
-0.9822287559509277,
-0.20945020020008087,
-0.10789664834737778,
-0.2782128155231476,
0.06809019297361374,
0.07165878266096115,
-0.3079477548599243,
-0.24871735274791718,
-0.608853816986084,
0.4522228538990021,
0.5497774481773376,
-0.5093977451324463,
0.545608639717102,
0.2599787414073944,
-0.15141461789608002,
-0.46888065338134766,
-0.7394903302192688,
-0.029422784224152565,
-0.28193381428718567,
-0.3856593370437622,
0.06628377735614777,
0.004650176968425512,
-0.43672335147857666,
-0.1672847718000412,
-0.046484120190143585,
-0.46460264921188354,
0.38342294096946716,
0.07853241264820099,
0.6731814742088318,
-0.13703222572803497,
-0.3810918629169464,
-0.279971182346344,
0.2645294666290283,
0.2889482080936432,
0.2778271436691284,
0.16883842647075653,
0.33559665083885193,
-0.6579771637916565,
-0.4290282726287842,
0.10103555768728256,
0.6954367756843567,
0.1439180076122284,
0.5092177987098694,
0.14281125366687775,
-0.449176162481308,
-0.14271903038024902,
-0.8786041736602783,
-0.574674665927887,
-0.5247486233711243,
0.41168537735939026,
0.13776059448719025,
-0.8107234835624695,
0.5125611424446106,
-0.09920026361942291,
0.1264767199754715,
0.06249670311808586,
0.4305371344089508,
-0.2760709226131439,
0.8242266774177551,
0.5973323583602905,
-0.2264666110277176,
0.8981283903121948,
0.18501214683055878,
0.25410449504852295,
-0.7204179763793945,
-0.033803924918174744,
-0.8411381840705872,
-0.23058612644672394,
-0.6958115696907043,
-0.23482291400432587,
0.30090272426605225,
-0.2317144125699997,
-0.059822551906108856,
0.056249406188726425,
-0.3141184449195862,
0.6795713305473328,
0.8370519876480103,
-0.19531239569187164,
0.18070638179779053,
0.03174309432506561,
-0.029572060331702232,
-0.09985347837209702,
-0.5306732654571533,
-0.683322012424469,
1.274916410446167,
0.5345479249954224,
0.5740768909454346,
-0.14609962701797485,
0.5369662046432495,
0.377304345369339,
0.5907899737358093,
-0.26600828766822815,
0.4924485385417938,
-0.12286984175443649,
-0.9936235547065735,
-0.40586912631988525,
-0.37114033102989197,
-0.8319887518882751,
0.4111751914024353,
-0.43634623289108276,
-0.8153269290924072,
0.18942533433437347,
0.16220062971115112,
0.2205733209848404,
0.32871535420417786,
-0.6528460383415222,
0.7172325849533081,
-0.2246163785457611,
-0.09809532761573792,
-0.03439585864543915,
-0.3581917881965637,
0.6735837459564209,
-0.5822879672050476,
0.4217691123485565,
-0.14041998982429504,
0.3609749376773834,
1.0484164953231812,
-0.23784276843070984,
0.882754385471344,
-0.02167285606265068,
-0.016407864168286324,
-0.13920406997203827,
0.25614115595817566,
0.6384177803993225,
-0.561750590801239,
-0.35617509484291077,
0.32715827226638794,
0.1646568924188614,
-0.10381118208169937,
-0.449416846036911,
0.3830948770046234,
-0.5959553122520447,
-0.5904025435447693,
-0.5258766412734985,
-0.7405681610107422,
-0.1858663707971573,
0.3200581669807434,
-0.2938861846923828,
0.03482281416654587,
-0.17280831933021545,
0.02534964121878147,
0.2132616490125656,
-0.12649184465408325,
-0.04813043028116226,
0.6369965672492981,
-0.1527477204799652,
0.04286323860287666,
0.7841624021530151,
-0.07302068918943405,
0.16433502733707428,
-0.04203081876039505,
0.37346121668815613,
-0.3703457713127136,
-0.39582404494285583,
-0.1082652285695076,
0.4409489631652832,
-0.6011061668395996,
0.11215625703334808,
-0.1626788079738617,
0.2510746121406555,
-0.5450133681297302,
-0.10735023766756058,
-0.07389131933450699,
-0.04284864291548729,
-0.1344347894191742,
0.07580395042896271,
0.009901594370603561,
0.8822563290596008,
0.10395346581935883,
0.1783163845539093,
-0.34603792428970337,
0.1878654658794403,
0.489690363407135,
0.5037020444869995,
-0.053804099559783936,
-0.2949890196323395,
-0.03148335590958595,
0.22481752932071686,
-0.34550943970680237,
-0.8492045402526855,
0.04775773733854294,
-0.014250428415834904,
0.4528557062149048,
0.3818163573741913,
-0.016226185485720634,
0.6394103765487671,
-0.5554620623588562,
0.5535104870796204,
0.08612744510173798,
-1.0994150638580322,
0.35243403911590576,
-0.4653226435184479,
-0.23667065799236298,
0.7231376767158508,
0.1192164197564125,
-0.9153146147727966,
-0.8078089952468872,
-0.25267425179481506,
-0.4415663182735443,
1.169577717781067,
0.33800971508026123,
0.006862218491733074,
0.0936146005988121,
0.40776151418685913,
-0.03474554419517517,
0.4333917200565338,
-0.462872713804245,
-0.2572731375694275,
0.3646979033946991,
-0.439585417509079,
0.03825126960873604,
-0.281156450510025,
-0.2547849118709564,
-0.1320658177137375,
0.507278561592102,
0.11032431572675705,
-0.15584830939769745,
0.034946464002132416,
0.09716454893350601,
-0.20018455386161804,
0.1890036165714264,
0.6731474995613098,
0.9138723015785217,
-0.24734985828399658,
0.18658797442913055,
0.49890100955963135,
-0.4268738329410553,
0.1873934119939804,
-0.21452105045318604,
-0.25561100244522095,
0.09448761492967606,
0.5101585984230042,
0.48276129364967346,
0.07635107636451721,
-0.9088285565376282,
0.5781017541885376,
-0.10937809944152832,
-0.30911245942115784,
-0.31022587418556213,
0.09002462029457092,
-0.026941489428281784,
0.11371245235204697,
0.08504258841276169,
-0.19585570693016052,
0.10624781250953674,
-0.7973988056182861,
0.005132256541401148,
0.553812563419342,
-0.1326761245727539,
-0.12363256514072418,
0.7677304148674011,
0.3015701472759247,
-0.691856861114502,
0.8386707901954651,
0.2045690268278122,
-0.595899224281311,
0.7717386484146118,
0.4271215498447418,
0.8109212517738342,
-0.5856142640113831,
-0.27335938811302185,
-0.026763970032334328,
0.39777204394340515,
-0.49584540724754333,
0.04508825019001961,
0.17606741189956665,
-0.66181880235672,
-0.26035985350608826,
-0.33501067757606506,
-0.8040687441825867,
0.06461885571479797,
-0.6615467071533203,
0.5212206244468689,
-0.3130607008934021,
0.08643901348114014,
0.10288307070732117,
-0.3884757161140442,
-0.7537586092948914,
0.11984384059906006,
0.18977080285549164,
0.8890700936317444,
-1.4643698930740356,
0.3925780653953552,
0.7216197848320007,
0.08101160824298859,
-0.3786410391330719,
-0.2724114954471588,
0.1916632354259491,
-1.0069539546966553,
0.7979629635810852,
0.1337803304195404,
0.23272453248500824,
-0.551705002784729,
-0.3106383681297302,
-0.46982818841934204,
0.8121240139007568,
0.6764887571334839,
-0.7214345932006836,
-0.2471238076686859,
0.36859220266342163,
0.3650578558444977,
-0.19835521280765533,
0.5851003527641296,
0.8853440284729004,
0.5517638325691223,
-0.42825186252593994,
-1.3050249814987183,
-0.10571907460689545,
0.0249876007437706,
0.07377218455076218,
0.29521819949150085,
-0.16916371881961823,
0.8697947263717651,
0.1726526916027069,
-0.2460777312517166,
-0.1442040503025055,
0.352941632270813,
0.29994821548461914,
0.47193077206611633,
0.7230091691017151,
0.31355050206184387,
1.136802077293396,
-0.05729732662439346,
0.913911759853363,
-0.3713405430316925,
0.5332998633384705,
0.9120898246765137,
-0.53896164894104,
0.5117480158805847,
0.6059355735778809,
-0.561811625957489,
0.46983668208122253,
0.5503382682800293,
-0.21539047360420227,
0.19089600443840027,
0.5392371416091919,
-0.07218248397111893,
0.006876724306493998,
-0.36872851848602295,
0.019620992243289948,
0.4802468419075012,
0.1540096402168274,
-0.3430037200450897,
-0.1701928675174713,
-0.3163977265357971,
-0.06956789642572403,
0.34387874603271484,
-0.16237647831439972,
0.577961266040802,
-0.16664864122867584,
-0.8974692821502686,
0.05528028681874275,
-0.008885852992534637,
0.6021471619606018,
-0.42634984850883484,
-0.4942629337310791,
-0.04215385392308235,
0.20422902703285217,
-0.3363129198551178,
-0.7993952631950378,
0.15966054797172546,
0.043151892721652985,
-0.19571535289287567,
-0.06963504105806351,
0.31717005372047424,
-0.6511920094490051,
-0.385860413312912,
0.12549449503421783,
0.251468688249588,
0.29364854097366333,
0.2116287797689438,
-0.3576784133911133,
0.17232845723628998,
-0.08342359960079193,
0.2350350022315979,
0.3328841030597687,
0.08042605221271515,
-0.17200979590415955,
0.6384851336479187,
0.7772274613380432,
0.4601983428001404,
0.027703896164894104,
-0.20126159489154816,
0.41425207257270813,
-0.5915032029151917,
-0.7740355134010315,
-1.0287227630615234,
0.0526798814535141,
0.028400886803865433,
-0.09983428567647934,
0.6703185439109802,
0.6411290764808655,
1.0600162744522095,
0.11987917125225067,
0.7687601447105408,
0.6436932682991028,
0.48141199350357056,
-0.5336471199989319,
0.32085567712783813,
-0.17314158380031586,
0.2534697651863098,
-0.3938021957874298,
-1.1265568733215332,
-0.02274608053267002,
0.6572430729866028,
-0.35073840618133545,
0.2453078329563141,
0.6607555747032166,
0.8610677123069763,
-0.17791573703289032,
0.11731687188148499,
0.17068369686603546,
-0.02953757531940937,
0.48801305890083313,
0.3396599590778351,
0.7314309477806091,
-0.3509126305580139,
0.17117545008659363,
-0.11860629171133041,
-0.2043101042509079,
-0.471623957157135,
-0.9415655136108398,
-0.9912834763526917,
-0.4130927324295044,
-0.38337966799736023,
-0.3072807192802429,
0.029039129614830017,
0.7768715620040894,
0.6045659184455872,
-0.694804847240448,
-0.7825005054473877,
-0.007512193638831377,
0.18428261578083038,
0.05629507452249527,
-0.21976031363010406,
0.3087393343448639,
-0.019947726279497147,
-0.8920652270317078,
0.21467013657093048,
-0.18008501827716827,
-0.02793930470943451,
-0.42885830998420715,
0.07835343480110168,
-0.12807834148406982,
0.13452638685703278,
-0.004578753374516964,
0.1600506454706192,
-0.7366888523101807,
-0.32588914036750793,
-0.4168303310871124,
-0.1117439717054367,
-0.130380317568779,
1.0144487619400024,
-0.34037527441978455,
0.7892576456069946,
0.45680931210517883,
0.8348076343536377,
0.2743006646633148,
-0.12924374639987946,
0.7726721167564392,
-0.6678503155708313,
-0.02953372150659561,
0.14474692940711975,
0.5264509320259094,
0.24996481835842133,
-0.23921659588813782,
0.6381747126579285,
0.09957801550626755,
-0.6461006999015808,
-1.2906792163848877,
-0.007791176903992891,
-0.4375537633895874,
-0.07552288472652435,
0.9897283911705017,
0.205167755484581,
-0.2966432273387909,
0.006287005729973316,
-0.15932975709438324,
0.09093660861253738,
-0.2587657570838928,
1.1403473615646362,
1.1383905410766602,
0.12291870266199112,
0.2547786831855774,
-0.9596426486968994,
0.4582566022872925,
0.5933536291122437,
-0.6251410841941833,
0.23445115983486176,
0.4351731240749359,
0.44627049565315247,
0.16265830397605896,
0.6140229105949402,
0.12090405076742172,
0.5216487646102905,
-0.15177887678146362,
0.07974725216627121,
0.13077980279922485,
0.005138454493135214,
-0.654794454574585,
-0.35167011618614197,
0.22661827504634857,
-0.23580262064933777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03080v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03080v2
|
Construction and Application of Materials Knowledge Graph in Multidisciplinary Materials Science via Large Language Model
| 2024-04-03T21:46:14 | 2024-06-04T10:04:05 |
Yanpeng Ye, Jie Ren, Shaozhou Wang, Yuwei Wan, Haofen Wang, Imran Razzak, Tong Xie, Wenjie Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge in materials science is widely dispersed across extensive
scientific literature, posing significant challenges for efficient discovery
and integration of new materials. Traditional methods, often reliant on costly
and time-consuming experimental approaches, further complicate rapid
innovation. Addressing these challenges, the integration of artificial
intelligence with materials science has opened avenues for accelerating the
discovery process, though it also demands precise annotation, data extraction,
and traceability of information. To tackle these issues, this article
introduces the Materials Knowledge Graph (MKG), which utilizes advanced natural
language processing techniques, integrated with large language models to
extract and systematically organize a decade's worth of high-quality research
into structured triples, contains 162,605 nodes and 731,772 edges. MKG
categorizes information into comprehensive labels such as Name, Formula, and
Application, structured around a meticulously designed ontology, thus enhancing
data usability and integration. By implementing network-based algorithms, MKG
not only facilitates efficient link prediction but also significantly reduces
reliance on traditional experimental methods. This structured approach not only
streamlines materials research but also lays the groundwork for more
sophisticated science knowledge graphs.
|
[
-0.2840149700641632,
-0.9550693035125732,
0.8200482726097107,
-0.024657949805259705,
0.06749238818883896,
0.47261279821395874,
-0.008303273469209671,
-0.36670300364494324,
0.08053325861692429,
0.26781710982322693,
-0.3694072365760803,
-0.6875618696212769,
-0.4423263370990753,
0.021115800365805626,
-0.02675279788672924,
0.6925042867660522,
-0.3110998570919037,
0.05901441350579262,
-0.2147168219089508,
-0.02919117547571659,
-0.13485220074653625,
-0.3352489471435547,
-0.46746835112571716,
-0.6957662105560303,
0.564972460269928,
0.352859765291214,
0.6597083210945129,
0.9561005234718323,
0.6063955426216125,
0.4021357297897339,
-0.11192784458398819,
0.5335104465484619,
0.002674536779522896,
-0.18229541182518005,
-0.19281014800071716,
-0.36338359117507935,
-0.7567713260650635,
0.1885504573583603,
0.7716579437255859,
1.146679401397705,
0.04753457009792328,
0.10321441292762756,
0.2424863874912262,
0.6523877382278442,
-0.1932152807712555,
0.47457021474838257,
-0.2935733199119568,
0.30636098980903625,
-0.36090752482414246,
-0.5773302912712097,
-0.34565499424934387,
-0.3429749011993408,
0.21130526065826416,
-0.7736751437187195,
0.07547710835933685,
0.2955220639705658,
0.5092552900314331,
-0.13129465281963348,
-0.5208709239959717,
-0.3544139862060547,
-0.7631161212921143,
0.7457841038703918,
-0.3036474585533142,
0.5711681246757507,
0.4225449860095978,
0.49801769852638245,
-0.34274643659591675,
-0.8989196419715881,
-0.4042889475822449,
-0.18909278512001038,
-0.10979390889406204,
-0.10789132863283157,
0.4029037058353424,
0.1868097186088562,
-0.06164117902517319,
0.46369877457618713,
-0.6325420141220093,
-0.054571982473134995,
-0.4923458993434906,
-0.37567663192749023,
0.4008180797100067,
0.08867929130792618,
0.3177403509616852,
-0.1534482091665268,
-0.5559363961219788,
0.030605338513851166,
-0.4159064292907715,
-0.48423701524734497,
0.34809431433677673,
0.5736326575279236,
0.0034779170528054237,
0.8736072182655334,
-0.26973047852516174,
0.6075223684310913,
-0.5158888697624207,
-0.18345299363136292,
0.5290080308914185,
-0.7286760210990906,
0.0559040792286396,
0.10626799613237381,
0.9499363303184509,
0.10176330804824829,
0.08625062555074692,
-0.40635156631469727,
0.052841443568468094,
-0.1955062448978424,
-0.05533158406615257,
-0.7345385551452637,
-0.5116439461708069,
0.1578194946050644,
-0.4940215051174164,
-0.2596893012523651,
-0.19953115284442902,
-0.690021812915802,
-0.792269766330719,
-0.5299783945083618,
0.2866284251213074,
-0.4143688678741455,
-0.5601175427436829,
0.17024073004722595,
-0.3732537031173706,
-0.45049548149108887,
0.44289734959602356,
-0.6025527119636536,
0.264343798160553,
0.5644121170043945,
1.1814863681793213,
0.1390342116355896,
-0.5082859992980957,
-0.19200308620929718,
0.4652096629142761,
-0.12491106986999512,
0.7754599452018738,
-0.44154512882232666,
-0.15286493301391602,
-0.5187733769416809,
-0.11127719283103943,
0.13631704449653625,
-0.26184558868408203,
0.4349883794784546,
-0.3736293315887451,
0.08478080481290817,
-0.2680496573448181,
-0.373678058385849,
-0.284706175327301,
0.4545677900314331,
-0.7984753847122192,
1.0009887218475342,
0.2182348668575287,
-0.9352062940597534,
0.27659735083580017,
-0.840475857257843,
-0.3093201220035553,
0.18104225397109985,
0.08905450254678726,
-0.12075048685073853,
-0.19648732244968414,
-0.19007544219493866,
0.536689281463623,
-0.5876186490058899,
0.3464873135089874,
-0.579596757888794,
0.11243294924497604,
0.2370210736989975,
-0.1179010272026062,
0.4586975872516632,
0.2757861018180847,
-0.08947471529245377,
0.048955757170915604,
-0.8041260242462158,
-0.13634467124938965,
0.13082033395767212,
-0.3417756259441376,
-0.4707302451133728,
0.00004894053563475609,
0.13541899621486664,
0.4026767909526825,
0.3482646346092224,
-0.7446228265762329,
0.30162832140922546,
-0.14339914917945862,
0.5921787023544312,
0.8762621879577637,
-0.13776202499866486,
0.627120852470398,
-0.13694314658641815,
0.20626826584339142,
-0.3060750365257263,
0.12107286602258682,
-0.08225313574075699,
-0.362243115901947,
-0.47259193658828735,
0.11207748204469681,
0.34169188141822815,
0.2686859369277954,
-0.9065513610839844,
0.18453045189380646,
-0.2542737126350403,
-0.6619310975074768,
-0.026267215609550476,
0.31377509236335754,
0.17754881083965302,
0.6693441271781921,
0.32817959785461426,
-0.18944832682609558,
-0.5852057933807373,
-0.6710231304168701,
-0.06680004298686981,
-0.07960633933544159,
0.1463703066110611,
0.40691089630126953,
0.40363016724586487,
-0.16618895530700684,
1.143905758857727,
-1.016008734703064,
-0.3514384627342224,
-0.05432014539837837,
0.49338674545288086,
0.20881634950637817,
0.3011067509651184,
0.03588150814175606,
-0.9864591360092163,
-0.36065277457237244,
0.44649678468704224,
-1.1038609743118286,
0.15463374555110931,
0.2874821126461029,
-0.3745732009410858,
-0.00035604601725935936,
0.7247043251991272,
-0.37463170289993286,
-0.1589968204498291,
0.5338654518127441,
-0.3685622215270996,
0.6372232437133789,
-0.17247574031352997,
0.05303792655467987,
-1.2220960855484009,
0.41429489850997925,
0.2484717071056366,
0.00733844842761755,
-0.774918258190155,
-0.10126762092113495,
-0.07685995101928711,
-0.2727130353450775,
-0.2090565711259842,
0.7408530712127686,
-0.5949196219444275,
-0.13182438910007477,
-0.2082051783800125,
0.07842417061328888,
0.2844710052013397,
0.5711766481399536,
-0.07550245523452759,
0.3892430365085602,
0.33896031975746155,
-0.6744396686553955,
0.5441424250602722,
0.15355569124221802,
-0.23874910175800323,
0.6444278955459595,
-0.41567909717559814,
-0.024566631764173508,
0.0014075511135160923,
0.18624447286128998,
-0.8207072615623474,
-0.10346771776676178,
0.2775396704673767,
-0.30791082978248596,
0.48395097255706787,
-0.07307261973619461,
-1.0163594484329224,
-0.5618429183959961,
-0.33802086114883423,
0.509629487991333,
-0.17289309203624725,
-0.3821597397327423,
1.2013795375823975,
0.5966851115226746,
-0.4123975932598114,
-0.36618974804878235,
-0.37134501338005066,
0.08735857903957367,
-0.1461448073387146,
-0.7802202701568604,
0.3506621718406677,
-0.6294567584991455,
-0.0982588678598404,
0.09256678074598312,
-0.30617594718933105,
-0.37767502665519714,
0.1595243364572525,
0.16474588215351105,
0.08504322171211243,
-0.06237580627202988,
0.5779720544815063,
-0.3003809452056885,
-0.1395798921585083,
0.10646913945674896,
-0.34844037890434265,
0.9713107347488403,
-0.04377298429608345,
-0.003887197934091091,
-0.20705440640449524,
0.012705518864095211,
0.7485471367835999,
-0.2272094041109085,
0.5389434695243835,
0.5701717734336853,
-0.5239483714103699,
-0.29152214527130127,
-0.39868152141571045,
-0.12284521758556366,
-0.604262113571167,
0.46009159088134766,
-0.4489979147911072,
-0.5406161546707153,
0.5682398080825806,
-0.4566091299057007,
0.08860640227794647,
0.359219491481781,
0.034842539578676224,
-0.11029095202684402,
1.0672674179077148,
0.7309189438819885,
-0.006309850141406059,
0.3202671706676483,
-0.24054621160030365,
0.34432944655418396,
-0.8632451295852661,
-0.6660037636756897,
-0.5523645281791687,
-0.05599326640367508,
-0.28746551275253296,
-0.4140189290046692,
0.4390754699707031,
0.09375417977571487,
-0.23757387697696686,
0.3263208270072937,
-0.6163286566734314,
0.38070324063301086,
0.2376265823841095,
0.24730341136455536,
0.6262145638465881,
0.04064670205116272,
-0.06708964705467224,
0.33657947182655334,
-0.7298117280006409,
-0.3051692843437195,
1.1056091785430908,
0.4818764328956604,
0.6665053367614746,
-0.13388743996620178,
0.335297167301178,
0.41564086079597473,
0.09428339451551437,
-0.8648589849472046,
0.5867531895637512,
0.14957089722156525,
-0.6796578168869019,
-0.2697944641113281,
-0.83149254322052,
-0.7547005414962769,
-0.041569843888282776,
-0.15303631126880646,
-0.35183069109916687,
0.008164498023688793,
0.14457684755325317,
-0.04670184850692749,
0.5881269574165344,
-0.7328001856803894,
0.6595619320869446,
-0.3921799957752228,
-0.2323194295167923,
-0.060429103672504425,
-0.38639721274375916,
0.34549710154533386,
-0.31080538034439087,
0.6556437611579895,
-0.30786260962486267,
0.3301927447319031,
0.8807258009910583,
-0.40502598881721497,
0.6067947149276733,
-0.03207184001803398,
-0.2329113483428955,
0.41645878553390503,
0.16300594806671143,
0.39642736315727234,
-0.25775131583213806,
-0.2658391296863556,
0.2701447606086731,
-0.3727661371231079,
-0.21949784457683563,
-0.5061802268028259,
0.596085250377655,
-0.5740888714790344,
-0.1436670422554016,
-0.2586333155632019,
-0.9724449515342712,
-0.05793704837560654,
0.5581782460212708,
-0.053493425250053406,
0.5767419338226318,
-0.07498706132173538,
-0.0024083866737782955,
0.4763585925102234,
-0.1558959037065506,
0.26398542523384094,
0.15964661538600922,
-0.08113517612218857,
-0.33504748344421387,
1.3067315816879272,
0.5183817148208618,
0.1385798454284668,
0.29370471835136414,
0.5215991735458374,
-0.34427422285079956,
-0.5680243968963623,
-0.26322001218795776,
0.3971293270587921,
-0.7172251343727112,
-0.34275656938552856,
-0.8806664943695068,
-0.3823102116584778,
-0.3167845904827118,
-0.3671436011791229,
-0.3041773736476898,
-0.44574764370918274,
-0.02817532978951931,
-0.21392054855823517,
0.47902223467826843,
1.1007673740386963,
0.051999036222696304,
0.13989195227622986,
-0.8307075500488281,
0.44473233819007874,
0.3001922369003296,
0.9295396208763123,
0.12476687133312225,
0.1525215208530426,
-0.6120739579200745,
0.04132577031850815,
-0.05453435331583023,
-0.6410880088806152,
0.026263296604156494,
0.01385350339114666,
0.716702938079834,
0.11528434604406357,
-0.13709233701229095,
0.35014039278030396,
-0.5472609400749207,
0.16647888720035553,
0.21990638971328735,
-0.727178692817688,
0.41757699847221375,
-0.7967002391815186,
0.0798061266541481,
0.4065711200237274,
0.5375586152076721,
-0.31416070461273193,
0.055232129991054535,
-0.5221859812736511,
-0.9482813477516174,
0.9338417649269104,
0.05787166953086853,
-0.4748079478740692,
0.42729872465133667,
0.039117977023124695,
0.01810775138437748,
0.21398913860321045,
-0.7735483646392822,
-0.3359905779361725,
-0.06449190527200699,
-0.16129504144191742,
0.10743524879217148,
-0.16844750940799713,
-0.47873130440711975,
-0.025040186941623688,
0.7070370316505432,
-0.38537460565567017,
0.14747147262096405,
-0.18605035543441772,
-0.19245155155658722,
0.005927275866270065,
0.06986197084188461,
0.28415557742118835,
0.65348881483078,
-0.6141640543937683,
0.2831682860851288,
-0.08565209060907364,
-0.6093100309371948,
-0.0025107332039624453,
0.35708940029144287,
0.13865543901920319,
-0.3044908344745636,
0.009545093402266502,
0.3728114068508148,
-0.16963042318820953,
-0.378155380487442,
-0.024013441056013107,
0.08814483880996704,
-0.2464851438999176,
-0.21295027434825897,
-0.335946649312973,
0.02126178704202175,
0.323591023683548,
0.4570690989494324,
0.08897558599710464,
0.3501078188419342,
-0.7175030708312988,
0.23134315013885498,
0.2949148118495941,
-0.32176944613456726,
-0.23383492231369019,
0.30203214287757874,
0.3236639201641083,
-0.09731889516115189,
0.39611488580703735,
-0.28729572892189026,
-0.7137850522994995,
0.7230753898620605,
0.34415924549102783,
0.3904348313808441,
-0.14019575715065002,
0.3225695788860321,
0.40757158398628235,
0.33753934502601624,
-0.19758886098861694,
0.14279805123806,
-0.08207933604717255,
-0.7088611721992493,
-0.2741043269634247,
-0.6979711055755615,
-0.5001287460327148,
-0.18834273517131805,
-0.10576000809669495,
0.2229004204273224,
-0.6719744205474854,
0.12137934565544128,
0.25281670689582825,
0.384492427110672,
-0.4630400836467743,
0.2726001441478729,
0.14574632048606873,
0.7317737936973572,
-1.0109292268753052,
0.5362420082092285,
0.5686326026916504,
-0.35448896884918213,
-0.7452504634857178,
-0.6535128951072693,
0.2383849173784256,
-0.6804947257041931,
0.7797698378562927,
0.2874758839607239,
-0.2686968147754669,
0.07055399566888809,
-0.2979947030544281,
-1.3020060062408447,
1.3224998712539673,
0.025413475930690765,
0.028749916702508926,
-0.002168476115912199,
0.22338250279426575,
0.15376512706279755,
-0.06677591800689697,
0.3597191572189331,
0.46263906359672546,
0.8862165212631226,
0.3112320899963379,
-0.7932953834533691,
0.21660052239894867,
-0.5914105176925659,
-0.4394991993904114,
0.7412670850753784,
-0.6298503875732422,
0.8881978392601013,
0.2431904822587967,
-0.30859383940696716,
-0.19985854625701904,
0.44870007038116455,
0.3175041675567627,
0.3440691828727722,
0.4566907584667206,
0.5373848676681519,
0.9034718871116638,
-0.19892407953739166,
0.8037822246551514,
-0.2687220871448517,
0.1974356323480606,
0.8076459169387817,
-0.32165098190307617,
0.1271647959947586,
0.13259907066822052,
-0.09246951341629028,
0.6395774483680725,
0.45766884088516235,
-0.18697668612003326,
0.2805836498737335,
0.04759418964385986,
-0.18665426969528198,
-0.10454976558685303,
-0.7104799151420593,
-0.39520546793937683,
0.3117474615573883,
0.5518361926078796,
-0.19959664344787598,
-0.3130146563053131,
-0.17058099806308746,
0.16373351216316223,
-0.19841532409191132,
-0.38860952854156494,
0.4043918550014496,
-0.04687075689435005,
-0.20754389464855194,
0.06889486312866211,
0.08969488739967346,
0.5428898930549622,
-0.693793773651123,
-0.33991849422454834,
0.048117753118276596,
0.06337112188339233,
-0.4347308874130249,
-0.9580938220024109,
0.08976506441831589,
-0.48331260681152344,
-0.322826623916626,
-0.3597889244556427,
0.8521496653556824,
-0.31434911489486694,
-0.4173755645751953,
0.2555764615535736,
0.5080602765083313,
-0.08656542748212814,
-0.00034231913741678,
-0.4129939675331116,
-0.21218249201774597,
-0.20345735549926758,
-0.3052622675895691,
0.16544127464294434,
0.6761259436607361,
-0.1999756544828415,
0.7435724139213562,
1.1772280931472778,
-0.027525095269083977,
-0.1302533596754074,
-0.11165619641542435,
1.1635961532592773,
-0.7505791783332825,
-0.2833574414253235,
-0.7405378222465515,
0.7695232033729553,
-0.32657095789909363,
-0.055763669312000275,
0.9651451706886292,
0.8320732116699219,
0.49522989988327026,
0.4643738865852356,
0.8128621578216553,
0.03796124830842018,
0.35333317518234253,
-0.5193514227867126,
0.7550814747810364,
-0.45177793502807617,
0.18529832363128662,
-0.5680872201919556,
-0.9484227299690247,
-0.6305162906646729,
0.33525171875953674,
0.002902794163674116,
0.2797240912914276,
0.9362996220588684,
0.5676102042198181,
-0.2153056412935257,
-0.05636824294924736,
-0.1256578415632248,
0.33962202072143555,
0.4040156304836273,
0.18152973055839539,
0.6304588317871094,
-0.18379580974578857,
0.7580459117889404,
-0.337330162525177,
-0.29625454545021057,
-0.21037620306015015,
-1.0112035274505615,
-0.8307073712348938,
-0.5845497250556946,
-0.10579317063093185,
-0.4584026634693146,
-0.5246917605400085,
0.7079073786735535,
0.8052199482917786,
-0.22866709530353546,
-0.4510532021522522,
-0.32640552520751953,
0.2475949376821518,
0.16811278462409973,
-0.2020382583141327,
0.669181227684021,
-0.03766019642353058,
-0.4957958161830902,
0.564454197883606,
0.39453649520874023,
0.0117108765989542,
-0.23788847029209137,
-0.08542380481958389,
-0.4125140905380249,
-0.01176055334508419,
0.672091007232666,
0.3386794924736023,
0.11455319821834564,
-0.023095782846212387,
0.10028672963380814,
-0.050743039697408676,
0.13879120349884033,
0.7128828763961792,
-0.5915306210517883,
0.5974486470222473,
0.8274538516998291,
0.5796844363212585,
0.5553441643714905,
-0.25626957416534424,
0.7191777229309082,
-0.7639754414558411,
-0.15771295130252838,
0.13487493991851807,
0.6172577738761902,
0.5293712615966797,
-0.3236585259437561,
0.8777000904083252,
0.36125075817108154,
-0.621096670627594,
-0.8268768787384033,
0.44299110770225525,
-1.071915626525879,
-0.6359847784042358,
1.0544288158416748,
0.23658916354179382,
-0.23993848264217377,
-0.4387631416320801,
-0.13409654796123505,
0.6066324710845947,
-0.26572689414024353,
0.662659227848053,
0.652446448802948,
-0.06890948116779327,
0.04758447781205177,
-0.47092923521995544,
0.22909176349639893,
0.13187041878700256,
-1.080073356628418,
0.10259202867746353,
0.41917213797569275,
0.194379523396492,
0.6238442659378052,
0.593079149723053,
-0.09460556507110596,
-0.05015379562973976,
-0.048974309116601944,
0.37738949060440063,
-0.5930448174476624,
-0.814647376537323,
0.010344061069190502,
0.4142172038555145,
0.16267244517803192,
0.3370416760444641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03073v1
|
Mai Ho'omāuna i ka 'Ai: Language Models Improve Automatic Speech Recognition in Hawaiian
| 2024-04-03T21:29:40 | 2024-04-03T21:29:40 |
Kaavya Chaparala, Guido Zarrella, Bruce Torres Fischer, Larry Kimura, Oiwi Parker Jones
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this paper we address the challenge of improving Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR) for a low-resource language, Hawaiian, by incorporating large
amounts of independent text data into an ASR foundation model, Whisper. To do
this, we train an external language model (LM) on ~1.5M words of Hawaiian text.
We then use the LM to rescore Whisper and compute word error rates (WERs) on a
manually curated test set of labeled Hawaiian data. As a baseline, we use
Whisper without an external LM. Experimental results reveal a small but
significant improvement in WER when ASR outputs are rescored with a Hawaiian
LM. The results support leveraging all available data in the development of ASR
systems for underrepresented languages.
|
[
-0.0466889962553978,
-0.8548665642738342,
0.30598002672195435,
0.11094219982624054,
-0.2411632239818573,
0.20763343572616577,
-0.37373045086860657,
-0.688783586025238,
0.3094272315502167,
0.5506477952003479,
-0.1154196634888649,
-0.21505206823349,
-0.7202926874160767,
0.24354949593544006,
-0.2819407880306244,
0.49817487597465515,
0.014282889664173126,
0.20101246237754822,
0.09817329049110413,
-0.3577035963535309,
-0.5335039496421814,
-0.782951295375824,
-0.9188541769981384,
-0.501769483089447,
0.6365782022476196,
0.6852080225944519,
0.6843371987342834,
0.37939363718032837,
0.33748146891593933,
0.3064812123775482,
-0.11149917542934418,
0.36305612325668335,
-0.3329648971557617,
-0.04054219648241997,
0.40793460607528687,
-0.27994391322135925,
-0.3290582001209259,
-0.19563938677310944,
0.8942090272903442,
0.5754271149635315,
-0.059261880815029144,
0.16805170476436615,
0.22876933217048645,
0.8709820508956909,
-0.7741126418113708,
0.49569639563560486,
-0.7350565195083618,
-0.046147581189870834,
-0.4448365271091461,
0.09912960976362228,
-0.41037717461586,
-0.5024421811103821,
0.5747568011283875,
-0.4390968382358551,
-0.19376952946186066,
-0.285429447889328,
0.6846991777420044,
0.27179473638534546,
-0.7068870663642883,
-0.3670596182346344,
-0.9348710775375366,
0.5478315353393555,
-0.7262254357337952,
0.6645137667655945,
0.7954846620559692,
0.24824221432209015,
-0.17647279798984528,
-0.44866520166397095,
-0.7035809755325317,
-0.260121613740921,
0.1507890671491623,
0.12324099987745285,
-0.4273849427700043,
0.049097467213869095,
-0.02810877561569214,
0.3862045407295227,
-0.17963483929634094,
0.16197334229946136,
-0.5676085352897644,
-0.2597689628601074,
0.8571826815605164,
0.011035721749067307,
0.2698909640312195,
0.014511088840663433,
0.2485128492116928,
-0.08794636279344559,
-0.647398054599762,
0.3247218728065491,
0.4296628534793854,
0.8154881000518799,
-0.25294482707977295,
0.9040014147758484,
-0.26990818977355957,
0.7162256240844727,
-0.23423562943935394,
-0.43479663133621216,
0.2520405352115631,
0.25019991397857666,
-0.1734113246202469,
0.5776889324188232,
1.0577425956726074,
-0.020414303988218307,
0.3720535337924957,
0.03068637102842331,
0.029697559773921967,
0.4704180657863617,
0.17784421145915985,
-0.3694078326225281,
-0.4650454819202423,
-0.0952780544757843,
-0.44976043701171875,
-0.09252768009901047,
-0.13264945149421692,
-0.5202208161354065,
-0.35221338272094727,
-0.2932916283607483,
1.0247946977615356,
-0.3827219307422638,
-0.38186219334602356,
-0.11696230620145798,
-0.07200735062360764,
0.05669768527150154,
0.22843848168849945,
-0.5701809525489807,
0.45057353377342224,
0.21468022465705872,
0.8357120156288147,
-0.003586949547752738,
-0.21344250440597534,
-0.613818347454071,
0.11215393245220184,
-0.25415346026420593,
0.7172945141792297,
-0.4382791221141815,
-0.9954590797424316,
-0.020659444853663445,
-0.16312478482723236,
-0.4846002459526062,
-0.49621257185935974,
0.5859878063201904,
-0.3160592019557953,
0.15448097884655,
-0.26467958092689514,
-0.6923350095748901,
-0.4853326380252838,
-0.21502508223056793,
-0.7240923047065735,
0.852123498916626,
-0.03567802533507347,
-0.5089056491851807,
-0.046552594751119614,
-0.8720483779907227,
-0.6962380409240723,
-0.04405834525823593,
0.04982009530067444,
-0.6523798704147339,
0.3540220260620117,
0.13193365931510925,
0.14175699651241302,
-0.05382188409566879,
-0.0043550278060138226,
0.1792120635509491,
-0.359497994184494,
0.402480810880661,
-0.642274796962738,
0.935988187789917,
0.3579847812652588,
-0.4821174144744873,
0.018390174955129623,
-0.8152602910995483,
0.12603642046451569,
0.10019384324550629,
-0.8052251935005188,
-0.37089332938194275,
0.04430610314011574,
0.2352156788110733,
-0.42783936858177185,
0.23017868399620056,
-0.6961639523506165,
-0.15087494254112244,
-0.4827341139316559,
0.3441077768802643,
0.4207346737384796,
-0.24886773526668549,
0.35982662439346313,
-0.2064933329820633,
0.3199104368686676,
-0.00417545298114419,
0.012557202950119972,
-0.09725848585367203,
-0.9489661455154419,
-1.2070181369781494,
-0.2001582533121109,
0.45554161071777344,
0.6336610913276672,
-0.6793659329414368,
0.4815632104873657,
-0.12455093115568161,
-0.6261307001113892,
-1.0544527769088745,
0.1611270308494568,
0.6967365145683289,
0.7604408264160156,
0.36516761779785156,
-0.3041638135910034,
-0.7224227786064148,
-0.7313688397407532,
-0.26465561985969543,
-0.5592840909957886,
0.12277305126190186,
0.34239640831947327,
0.10171244293451309,
-0.5782355666160583,
0.9117647409439087,
-0.33091816306114197,
-0.6154814958572388,
-0.3178587257862091,
0.03371451422572136,
0.07830123603343964,
0.38362619280815125,
0.08081419765949249,
-0.852689266204834,
-0.8555580973625183,
0.13475678861141205,
-0.5773587226867676,
0.03219527751207352,
0.6926973462104797,
0.1631079912185669,
0.39747005701065063,
0.22970908880233765,
-0.6288313865661621,
0.6809152960777283,
0.6472975015640259,
-0.4257966876029968,
0.21859395503997803,
-0.2571333646774292,
0.10920245200395584,
-0.8352503180503845,
-0.1689337193965912,
-0.13456378877162933,
-0.19912651181221008,
-0.8872308731079102,
0.11385120451450348,
-0.028844036161899567,
-0.4884685277938843,
-0.2682398557662964,
0.6579970717430115,
-0.4878275692462921,
-0.008051896467804909,
-0.5007826089859009,
-0.21147096157073975,
-0.14372868835926056,
0.22630424797534943,
0.3837704062461853,
0.67167729139328,
0.5008385181427002,
-1.0044828653335571,
0.2720637321472168,
0.35169920325279236,
-0.18882237374782562,
0.4700721502304077,
-0.7045475840568542,
0.2257486879825592,
-0.10561878234148026,
0.1409316062927246,
-0.8518466949462891,
-0.3169221580028534,
0.17220117151737213,
-0.5147299766540527,
0.4016507863998413,
-0.11456811428070068,
-0.3447599709033966,
-0.46014437079429626,
0.1485074907541275,
0.11163865029811859,
0.8017573952674866,
-0.5479844212532043,
0.8023132085800171,
0.9496418833732605,
-0.17285875976085663,
-0.06268760561943054,
-0.5753098726272583,
0.09063240140676498,
-0.41527464985847473,
-0.1947142779827118,
-0.03328345715999603,
-0.15849097073078156,
-0.4635525941848755,
-0.21241779625415802,
0.20327839255332947,
-0.2880473732948303,
0.07536320388317108,
0.37005433440208435,
0.06479290127754211,
-0.5418604612350464,
0.3210931718349457,
-0.1290089637041092,
-0.13052676618099213,
-0.1893666386604309,
-0.29025205969810486,
0.48803356289863586,
-0.09671346843242645,
-0.17849445343017578,
-0.9373250603675842,
0.21876083314418793,
0.3576219379901886,
-0.1373981237411499,
0.7697439193725586,
0.39566487073898315,
-0.5144675970077515,
0.42585980892181396,
-0.8946200013160706,
0.13683021068572998,
-0.41934800148010254,
-0.09507206082344055,
-0.7287799715995789,
-0.6642850637435913,
0.2933814823627472,
0.2995263338088989,
0.07964861392974854,
0.6166665554046631,
0.2425260990858078,
-0.2844424247741699,
0.9440276026725769,
0.9504106640815735,
-0.6711627244949341,
0.4669191539287567,
-0.19316808879375458,
0.008058776147663593,
-0.8001179695129395,
-0.20321813225746155,
-0.7700994610786438,
-0.14819307625293732,
-0.5810964107513428,
-0.3750401437282562,
0.6123374700546265,
-0.11502750962972641,
-0.07870807498693466,
0.3508056402206421,
-0.40180256962776184,
0.3247092366218567,
0.7947072386741638,
0.38638603687286377,
0.6383084058761597,
0.12470539659261703,
0.06032554432749748,
-0.10932806134223938,
-0.8352811336517334,
-0.47162458300590515,
1.1377187967300415,
0.5325780510902405,
0.6939008831977844,
0.170004740357399,
0.6078130006790161,
0.2071063220500946,
0.2771269381046295,
-0.9539348483085632,
0.19611912965774536,
-0.5212094187736511,
-0.3290790021419525,
-0.6390453577041626,
-0.445046991109848,
-0.9692292213439941,
0.2082313448190689,
-0.01774444244801998,
-0.5230211019515991,
0.2014380246400833,
0.39091330766677856,
-0.2637164890766144,
0.24642767012119293,
-0.8207825422286987,
0.5821080207824707,
-0.015618373639881611,
0.5177222490310669,
-0.20871515572071075,
-0.3323098123073578,
0.14343424141407013,
-0.01656467095017433,
0.39349859952926636,
-0.22945016622543335,
0.09798545390367508,
0.8872159719467163,
-0.7303126454353333,
0.975951611995697,
-0.2739511728286743,
-0.21481357514858246,
0.858624279499054,
-0.05459356680512428,
0.448737233877182,
-0.27832266688346863,
-0.3013588786125183,
0.3624548017978668,
-0.34767991304397583,
-0.22776879370212555,
-0.20466530323028564,
0.618873655796051,
-1.1340422630310059,
-0.22666285932064056,
-0.19085218012332916,
-0.3608395457267761,
-0.31099292635917664,
-0.0874071940779686,
0.7459401488304138,
0.6648608446121216,
-0.13499465584754944,
0.16565556824207306,
0.6148656010627747,
-0.06185588613152504,
0.24702653288841248,
0.8289876580238342,
-0.03796442598104477,
-0.558314859867096,
1.090868353843689,
0.4457806348800659,
0.13718917965888977,
0.32932737469673157,
0.634078323841095,
-0.48432159423828125,
-0.2922605574131012,
-0.5908374190330505,
0.09232283383607864,
-0.5420640110969543,
-0.341312438249588,
-1.1163439750671387,
-0.571803092956543,
-0.4216362237930298,
0.10181871056556702,
-0.4735347032546997,
-0.6414785385131836,
-0.443445086479187,
-0.02998458594083786,
0.9122157692909241,
0.7631484866142273,
0.14551855623722076,
0.8002894520759583,
-0.8580440878868103,
0.4285048544406891,
0.48249685764312744,
-0.028384411707520485,
0.07623392343521118,
-0.8814934492111206,
-0.19879548251628876,
0.3543975353240967,
-0.22968724370002747,
-0.5631495118141174,
0.40568265318870544,
0.8406451344490051,
0.42486435174942017,
0.08164479583501816,
0.09776922315359116,
1.1025978326797485,
-0.7480827569961548,
0.6267977952957153,
0.1866464614868164,
-1.1054803133010864,
1.1014363765716553,
-0.06374917924404144,
0.6603928208351135,
0.47815167903900146,
0.34113383293151855,
-0.3221992552280426,
-0.8319393396377563,
-0.7900604009628296,
-0.4666186571121216,
0.2384866327047348,
0.3064488172531128,
0.409419983625412,
0.07557179778814316,
0.2714812755584717,
0.1451960802078247,
0.18704599142074585,
-0.8523041009902954,
-0.3110714554786682,
-0.1657162457704544,
-0.575111985206604,
-0.49544256925582886,
-0.39895662665367126,
0.2446650117635727,
-0.2425575852394104,
0.867401659488678,
-0.3001145124435425,
0.16586850583553314,
0.34367015957832336,
-0.2518835961818695,
-0.5318232178688049,
0.04643518477678299,
0.18584392964839935,
0.2833018898963928,
0.27831849455833435,
0.10467177629470825,
0.403754323720932,
-0.7892452478408813,
0.21981577575206757,
0.11174070090055466,
-0.598701536655426,
0.3911646902561188,
0.5248724818229675,
0.8875084519386292,
0.494602233171463,
-0.6570926904678345,
0.1273428052663803,
-0.18218523263931274,
0.28007975220680237,
-0.56460040807724,
0.24965797364711761,
-0.06881943345069885,
0.1726396679878235,
0.49944713711738586,
-0.056551091372966766,
0.29981210827827454,
-0.7936423420906067,
-0.12815703451633453,
0.5745692849159241,
-0.714850664138794,
-0.22642557322978973,
0.7500616908073425,
0.23994608223438263,
-0.569278359413147,
0.6734693050384521,
0.31687477231025696,
-0.6146661639213562,
0.47248977422714233,
0.5497494339942932,
0.826547384262085,
-0.7690485715866089,
0.1147783026099205,
0.42824700474739075,
0.14598333835601807,
-0.1654125154018402,
0.568854033946991,
-0.1123025119304657,
-0.8605297803878784,
0.019422926008701324,
-0.7835043668746948,
-0.5551073551177979,
-0.03337263688445091,
-0.6281875371932983,
0.38576817512512207,
-0.3628287613391876,
-0.4481793940067291,
-0.051541104912757874,
0.13493575155735016,
-0.5603719353675842,
0.41014349460601807,
0.15769614279270172,
0.7809905409812927,
-0.6568752527236938,
1.0919137001037598,
0.6139108538627625,
-0.21067839860916138,
-0.8688578605651855,
-0.09164497256278992,
0.13886108994483948,
-0.7737627029418945,
0.5373861193656921,
0.0791219174861908,
-0.3200577199459076,
0.24537867307662964,
-0.12185615301132202,
-1.0607059001922607,
0.8216689825057983,
0.15596753358840942,
-0.7030391097068787,
0.27241063117980957,
-0.04765976220369339,
0.5940998196601868,
-0.4608306586742401,
-0.17339828610420227,
0.5744828581809998,
0.2705676555633545,
0.0035266138147562742,
-1.6012728214263916,
-0.6169118881225586,
-0.1160544827580452,
0.14519692957401276,
0.10734768956899643,
-0.6929193735122681,
0.5904333591461182,
-0.4734176993370056,
-0.228776216506958,
0.43169671297073364,
0.9843096733093262,
0.24405094981193542,
0.5162641406059265,
0.5235072374343872,
0.3459853529930115,
0.8877056837081909,
-0.016135171055793762,
1.0160075426101685,
0.11818058788776398,
-0.17625802755355835,
1.1440197229385376,
-0.3042267858982086,
1.432052493095398,
0.13126857578754425,
-0.3322393000125885,
0.4912247061729431,
0.39191949367523193,
0.4346974194049835,
0.45675501227378845,
-0.1153871938586235,
-0.49185821413993835,
0.17388053238391876,
-0.41784152388572693,
-0.30469995737075806,
0.8531571626663208,
0.4528152346611023,
-0.11206376552581787,
0.40233471989631653,
0.4550047814846039,
-0.021670028567314148,
0.35701194405555725,
-0.6073462963104248,
1.1715914011001587,
0.41500192880630493,
-0.19226767122745514,
0.5657906532287598,
-0.09274408966302872,
0.727722704410553,
-0.6853174567222595,
0.2007874697446823,
0.05008948966860771,
0.2714405357837677,
-0.14012405276298523,
-0.36540934443473816,
0.36722928285598755,
0.28752753138542175,
-0.1970638781785965,
0.14759749174118042,
0.966947615146637,
-0.6452606320381165,
-0.9583837389945984,
0.2943416237831116,
0.27824217081069946,
0.33275243639945984,
-0.08111640810966492,
-0.3450927138328552,
0.48686861991882324,
-0.07952960580587387,
0.11165150254964828,
0.04308968409895897,
0.3130251169204712,
-0.034040261059999466,
0.8192146420478821,
0.7200430631637573,
0.31586751341819763,
0.21696260571479797,
0.2157585173845291,
0.6570755243301392,
-0.46419742703437805,
-0.8984430432319641,
-0.8347871899604797,
0.5895642638206482,
0.21382269263267517,
-0.19579187035560608,
0.8647971749305725,
0.5203694105148315,
0.5832558274269104,
-0.12301722913980484,
0.6949301958084106,
0.15289627015590668,
0.9576709866523743,
-0.6415418982505798,
0.8478524088859558,
-0.2733113765716553,
-0.057611629366874695,
-0.4537217915058136,
-0.971928596496582,
-0.11846420913934708,
0.9074164628982544,
-0.018158219754695892,
-0.3061272203922272,
0.15952347218990326,
0.3117866814136505,
0.07777304947376251,
0.17626655101776123,
0.5081833600997925,
0.3436177968978882,
0.074198879301548,
0.2061583697795868,
0.7918251752853394,
-0.9837692379951477,
0.4038638174533844,
-0.42139264941215515,
-0.11550430208444595,
-0.24232888221740723,
-0.4230380356311798,
-0.7744132280349731,
-0.7469552159309387,
-0.7016658186912537,
-0.17303849756717682,
0.0884183943271637,
0.8319662809371948,
0.7033068537712097,
-1.009168028831482,
-0.7080579400062561,
0.18427619338035583,
0.040895212441682816,
0.039273109287023544,
-0.23757360875606537,
0.19134871661663055,
-0.08683992922306061,
-0.6542494297027588,
0.7994122505187988,
0.12364117801189423,
0.46803969144821167,
-0.12788131833076477,
-0.475343257188797,
0.046816058456897736,
-0.0949072390794754,
0.8620432615280151,
0.5400314927101135,
-0.9238184690475464,
-0.2783580422401428,
-0.2489524483680725,
0.09395959228277206,
-0.08839768171310425,
0.6604045629501343,
-0.9850614666938782,
0.5986312031745911,
0.02789204940199852,
0.37706834077835083,
0.38498222827911377,
-0.11400458961725235,
0.8110687136650085,
-0.5601894855499268,
0.3262465000152588,
0.1943662017583847,
0.37404969334602356,
0.56856769323349,
-0.5729147791862488,
0.5639215707778931,
0.08211278915405273,
-0.38626545667648315,
-0.8778656125068665,
0.05359409749507904,
-0.5096226930618286,
0.21865177154541016,
0.8114867806434631,
-0.17879600822925568,
-0.12579773366451263,
-0.3154918849468231,
-0.403273344039917,
0.18970337510108948,
-0.3629375398159027,
0.7501270174980164,
0.3521886467933655,
-0.14043475687503815,
-0.3405561149120331,
-0.5104263424873352,
0.49233493208885193,
-0.060713838785886765,
-0.750241756439209,
-0.21438202261924744,
0.4997398257255554,
0.2304094433784485,
0.34836888313293457,
1.1213738918304443,
-0.07472866028547287,
0.3188638389110565,
-0.005762316752225161,
-0.28978821635246277,
0.3616996109485626,
-0.44739148020744324,
-0.5624624490737915,
-0.28642454743385315,
0.4136601984500885,
-0.2619532644748688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03052v1
|
GPT-DETOX: An In-Context Learning-Based Paraphraser for Text Detoxification
| 2024-04-03T20:35:36 | 2024-04-03T20:35:36 |
Ali Pesaranghader, Nikhil Verma, Manasa Bharadwaj
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Harmful and offensive communication or content is detrimental to social
bonding and the mental state of users on social media platforms. Text
detoxification is a crucial task in natural language processing (NLP), where
the goal is removing profanity and toxicity from text while preserving its
content. Supervised and unsupervised learning are common approaches for
designing text detoxification solutions. However, these methods necessitate
fine-tuning, leading to computational overhead. In this paper, we propose
GPT-DETOX as a framework for prompt-based in-context learning for text
detoxification using GPT-3.5 Turbo. We utilize zero-shot and few-shot prompting
techniques for detoxifying input sentences. To generate few-shot prompts, we
propose two methods: word-matching example selection (WMES) and
context-matching example selection (CMES). We additionally take into account
ensemble in-context learning (EICL) where the ensemble is shaped by base
prompts from zero-shot and all few-shot settings. We use ParaDetox and APPDIA
as benchmark detoxification datasets. Our experimental results show that the
zero-shot solution achieves promising performance, while our best few-shot
setting outperforms the state-of-the-art models on ParaDetox and shows
comparable results on APPDIA. Our EICL solutions obtain the greatest
performance, adding at least 10% improvement, against both datasets.
|
[
-0.10230604559183121,
-0.9035443663597107,
0.8490875959396362,
-0.07275817543268204,
-0.569341778755188,
-0.008491801097989082,
-0.1170489490032196,
-0.09918458014726639,
-0.3572254776954651,
0.23739184439182281,
-0.48269122838974,
-0.6547607779502869,
-0.2725585997104645,
0.521473228931427,
-0.31926587224006653,
1.3402488231658936,
0.135984867811203,
-0.32798314094543457,
0.06308799982070923,
0.037602078169584274,
-0.6630172729492188,
-0.17193205654621124,
-1.0198804140090942,
-0.16553980112075806,
0.6406222581863403,
0.5705459117889404,
0.16425418853759766,
0.20379728078842163,
0.11093826591968536,
0.1334020495414734,
-0.16096098721027374,
-0.13058719038963318,
-0.5472018718719482,
0.3808491826057434,
-0.4636960029602051,
-0.1428401619195938,
0.4178187847137451,
-0.14447368681430817,
0.15851035714149475,
0.07809015363454819,
-0.1301611065864563,
-0.20761439204216003,
0.30122485756874084,
0.34845373034477234,
-0.7734973430633545,
-0.1325644552707672,
-0.8237841129302979,
-0.10452763736248016,
0.01948300562798977,
-0.31701627373695374,
-0.4057786762714386,
-0.3238283693790436,
-0.020940672606229782,
-0.5460442900657654,
-0.033534180372953415,
-0.3369119465351105,
0.5850397348403931,
0.5057030320167542,
-0.39411991834640503,
-0.1773882657289505,
-0.4447229504585266,
0.6754153370857239,
-0.7576020956039429,
0.1098797619342804,
0.2652103900909424,
0.3703358769416809,
-0.020140185952186584,
-0.599894106388092,
-0.35403934121131897,
0.05006331205368042,
-0.04587167128920555,
0.33037495613098145,
-0.040735874325037,
0.04201597347855568,
0.09756691753864288,
-0.10392716526985168,
-0.908733069896698,
-0.11155468225479126,
-0.298515260219574,
-0.01870984211564064,
0.2566092014312744,
0.13920365273952484,
0.534342885017395,
-0.38204851746559143,
-0.6994704008102417,
0.1196674033999443,
-0.7237383723258972,
-0.20880098640918732,
-0.07634192705154419,
0.40894776582717896,
0.08527185022830963,
0.13800948858261108,
-0.19815108180046082,
0.1541624516248703,
0.029353100806474686,
-0.10489191859960556,
0.3043706715106964,
-0.08333876729011536,
-0.3267546594142914,
0.13221566379070282,
0.9145361185073853,
0.3995223641395569,
0.046084534376859665,
-0.38663604855537415,
0.0050413659773766994,
-0.3167727291584015,
0.259399950504303,
-1.1315089464187622,
-0.1500757783651352,
0.3970547318458557,
-0.20594240725040436,
-0.3388419449329376,
-0.1695820689201355,
-1.0232094526290894,
-0.25848454236984253,
-0.12647810578346252,
0.6173927783966064,
-0.9564229846000671,
0.01273000705987215,
0.019782207906246185,
-0.6448286771774292,
0.2251107096672058,
0.30950722098350525,
-0.744381844997406,
-0.0262357946485281,
0.5118570923805237,
1.0901442766189575,
-0.28036201000213623,
-0.06862153857946396,
-0.5438025593757629,
0.253377228975296,
0.028103549033403397,
0.7591550946235657,
-0.645825982093811,
-0.40071725845336914,
-0.03492620214819908,
-0.150346040725708,
-0.10820223391056061,
-0.5454493761062622,
0.8425849080085754,
-0.3545609414577484,
0.30178967118263245,
-0.4038064777851105,
-0.43133339285850525,
-0.22096656262874603,
0.28008684515953064,
-0.19945141673088074,
1.0202999114990234,
0.021421749144792557,
-0.8260675668716431,
0.3911261558532715,
-0.6332263946533203,
-0.34952500462532043,
0.5987905263900757,
0.004051409661769867,
-0.18021197617053986,
0.09181856364011765,
0.16278670728206635,
0.5396796464920044,
-0.1040850356221199,
0.16026514768600464,
-0.2721099257469177,
-0.6838074922561646,
-0.4063040316104889,
-0.580475926399231,
0.9884555339813232,
0.5920062065124512,
-0.4411533772945404,
0.25968462228775024,
-0.4367297291755676,
0.019643697887659073,
-0.0663299560546875,
-0.18937848508358002,
-0.6558657884597778,
-0.26253122091293335,
0.3923609256744385,
0.6322863698005676,
-0.15438176691532135,
-0.3869140148162842,
-0.20009756088256836,
-0.4011653959751129,
0.6536382436752319,
0.5086708664894104,
0.7530766129493713,
0.23268897831439972,
-0.28490132093429565,
0.5224911570549011,
-0.08885415643453598,
-0.0069283293560147285,
-0.2352934181690216,
-0.5257425904273987,
0.1793670356273651,
-0.4761925935745239,
-0.4858810305595398,
0.9347850680351257,
-1.324941635131836,
0.429646372795105,
-0.19865453243255615,
-0.4313802719116211,
0.22280091047286987,
0.32307493686676025,
0.41367700695991516,
0.8063029646873474,
0.7847935557365417,
0.28121840953826904,
-0.12029290944337845,
-0.5784977078437805,
-0.4541413187980652,
-0.10579271614551544,
-0.4957917332649231,
0.002793782390654087,
0.7480545043945312,
-0.10639350116252899,
0.8583090305328369,
-0.2516205906867981,
-0.24461066722869873,
-0.4524551033973694,
0.34801554679870605,
0.0456429049372673,
0.1625918298959732,
0.6013205647468567,
-0.6257895827293396,
-0.7535179257392883,
-0.12399456650018692,
-0.7539189457893372,
-0.3946663737297058,
-0.23525148630142212,
-0.10983845591545105,
-0.3191817104816437,
0.3197687268257141,
-0.5942254066467285,
0.3264232575893402,
-0.08574962615966797,
-0.07550343126058578,
0.5972585082054138,
-0.06273732334375381,
0.1481528878211975,
-1.1429880857467651,
0.12425078451633453,
0.35264042019844055,
-0.16645865142345428,
-0.8752469420433044,
0.1495186686515808,
0.07810969650745392,
-0.24376443028450012,
-1.0155093669891357,
0.782448410987854,
-0.0385209321975708,
0.7524315714836121,
-0.28960976004600525,
0.22317427396774292,
0.092947818338871,
0.4985405504703522,
0.24535228312015533,
0.8583651185035706,
0.3772889971733093,
-0.647628664970398,
-0.02157137356698513,
0.3460047245025635,
-0.017192160710692406,
0.9309078454971313,
-0.5393756031990051,
0.18819043040275574,
-0.283381849527359,
0.5859045386314392,
-0.9627406001091003,
-0.367294043302536,
0.6632198095321655,
0.03900019824504852,
-0.0007923815865069628,
0.005647719372063875,
-0.4387688636779785,
-0.22152073681354523,
-0.6426770687103271,
0.3497313857078552,
0.5113973021507263,
-0.6108620166778564,
0.07868539541959763,
-0.08002401888370514,
-0.15525102615356445,
-0.4213223457336426,
-0.29083865880966187,
0.2944699823856354,
-0.8849567770957947,
0.007453584112226963,
0.36768147349357605,
-0.10205399990081787,
-0.1419772058725357,
-0.3531824052333832,
-0.07780967652797699,
-0.17540618777275085,
0.11401806026697159,
-0.05860833451151848,
-0.01642276532948017,
0.3539523780345917,
0.3467780351638794,
0.49639296531677246,
-0.032078322023153305,
-0.0044003999792039394,
-0.1024245023727417,
0.315914124250412,
-0.09883174300193787,
0.14163298904895782,
-0.5875065922737122,
0.5389404296875,
0.3939233720302582,
0.04138999804854393,
0.6489878296852112,
0.7499549984931946,
-0.4408853054046631,
-0.2413908988237381,
-0.1140933483839035,
-0.27201715111732483,
-0.47494545578956604,
0.28291264176368713,
-0.32917094230651855,
-0.6438897848129272,
0.34430992603302,
-0.0783865824341774,
0.04327675700187683,
0.24999915063381195,
0.5963069796562195,
-0.03661191835999489,
0.8574336767196655,
0.12956443428993225,
-0.10544417053461075,
0.6189645528793335,
0.019564056769013405,
0.12504759430885315,
-0.6545471549034119,
0.16522106528282166,
-0.44656676054000854,
-0.19965773820877075,
-0.22898828983306885,
-0.14205631613731384,
0.4954169690608978,
0.15595859289169312,
-0.739116370677948,
0.4753386974334717,
-0.6669312715530396,
0.8128635883331299,
0.4149625897407532,
0.3207937180995941,
0.1596144735813141,
0.016287101432681084,
-0.18016472458839417,
0.04155972972512245,
-0.42180994153022766,
-0.6937305331230164,
0.7233692407608032,
0.09182096272706985,
0.410660058259964,
-0.062075357884168625,
1.0584548711776733,
0.05645354464650154,
0.48813357949256897,
-0.5565223097801208,
0.44101521372795105,
-0.04310081899166107,
-0.8226242065429688,
-0.3409334123134613,
-0.4778815507888794,
-0.5302319526672363,
0.30940449237823486,
0.25433292984962463,
-1.1299365758895874,
0.036013465374708176,
-0.20275869965553284,
-0.5579909682273865,
0.35073161125183105,
-0.7159186005592346,
0.9761523604393005,
-0.03133554011583328,
-0.6341264247894287,
0.08346796035766602,
-0.9183971285820007,
0.4930609464645386,
-0.25292256474494934,
0.23997929692268372,
-0.15156424045562744,
-0.004375113174319267,
0.4236304759979248,
-0.29759806394577026,
0.6821250319480896,
-0.43133628368377686,
-0.16701963543891907,
0.5029369592666626,
0.032950304448604584,
0.4823097586631775,
0.32944920659065247,
-0.2196987271308899,
0.012121902778744698,
0.26222026348114014,
-0.11813624203205109,
-0.46128928661346436,
0.6522388458251953,
-0.32999780774116516,
-0.3462293744087219,
-0.0442809984087944,
-0.32398343086242676,
-0.22917123138904572,
0.2966456115245819,
0.6393250226974487,
0.24753056466579437,
-0.11287670582532883,
0.25989317893981934,
0.5900229215621948,
-0.6258910894393921,
0.6777793765068054,
-0.028341324999928474,
0.09498448669910431,
-0.3015674948692322,
0.9937050342559814,
-0.4677515923976898,
0.20059892535209656,
0.581806480884552,
0.4508031904697418,
-0.4444747567176819,
-0.3491811752319336,
-0.4474136233329773,
0.02721174620091915,
-0.774655818939209,
-0.30795592069625854,
-0.5724828243255615,
-0.0006257190252654254,
-0.17465494573116302,
-0.2885979413986206,
0.15228284895420074,
0.0941106379032135,
-0.531233549118042,
-0.26107844710350037,
0.3607481122016907,
0.2626393139362335,
-0.02401556447148323,
0.557526171207428,
-0.7606339454650879,
0.35121336579322815,
0.11094620078802109,
0.0071014403365552425,
-0.2623165249824524,
-0.5953071713447571,
0.04958680272102356,
-0.03301205113530159,
-0.46945467591285706,
-1.2624335289001465,
0.5499169230461121,
0.3475819528102875,
0.3849523365497589,
0.7249976396560669,
0.300552636384964,
0.5189650058746338,
-0.6024119853973389,
0.9529763460159302,
0.07529190927743912,
-0.7414839863777161,
0.6561964154243469,
-0.6437479257583618,
0.39008811116218567,
1.1582943201065063,
0.48323678970336914,
-0.8508473634719849,
-0.753368079662323,
-0.33787772059440613,
-0.9377857446670532,
0.37631645798683167,
0.3388899862766266,
0.3745584189891815,
-0.7015061974525452,
0.5120348930358887,
0.359724223613739,
0.1719309240579605,
-0.5688848495483398,
-0.11562997847795486,
-0.28826579451560974,
-0.5433936715126038,
0.08356443047523499,
-0.07069199532270432,
-0.008925266563892365,
-0.3236459195613861,
0.8392297625541687,
-0.09005811810493469,
0.12265101820230484,
0.0626242384314537,
-0.3047068417072296,
0.20683644711971283,
0.6590504050254822,
0.36895638704299927,
0.3544488251209259,
-0.4124525189399719,
0.15298083424568176,
0.3217914402484894,
-0.47832950949668884,
0.44690820574760437,
-0.14444714784622192,
-0.30610448122024536,
-0.11464366316795349,
-0.024997182190418243,
0.593970000743866,
0.28624284267425537,
-0.7431668043136597,
0.4598735570907593,
-0.003592887194827199,
-0.3041757345199585,
0.19498875737190247,
0.14672903716564178,
-0.18334302306175232,
-0.006548130419105291,
0.6093859672546387,
-0.23659738898277283,
0.4663831889629364,
-0.391793429851532,
0.5048091411590576,
0.4376278817653656,
-0.5987265110015869,
-0.23051607608795166,
1.091550350189209,
0.1430983990430832,
-0.047058816999197006,
0.5066899061203003,
-0.47824031114578247,
-0.42040878534317017,
0.31853196024894714,
0.6178508996963501,
1.3977924585342407,
-0.09040596336126328,
0.5488224625587463,
0.5419073700904846,
0.14441876113414764,
0.001174096018075943,
-0.06894530355930328,
-0.2605058252811432,
-0.4184783399105072,
-0.22720997035503387,
-0.5503900647163391,
-0.14297106862068176,
0.47391417622566223,
-0.4077502489089966,
0.15166537463665009,
-0.5104490518569946,
0.15510092675685883,
-0.3203551471233368,
-0.11196281015872955,
-0.5177692770957947,
0.1594751924276352,
0.1670023649930954,
0.7734418511390686,
-1.2658014297485352,
0.6056301593780518,
0.5079363584518433,
-0.6612830758094788,
-0.5409759879112244,
0.3933090269565582,
0.4126373827457428,
-0.22967824339866638,
0.42306283116340637,
0.7288504838943481,
-0.18233513832092285,
0.29714202880859375,
-0.5125179290771484,
-0.27378755807876587,
0.9895680546760559,
0.4017331302165985,
-0.23579491674900055,
-0.06501152366399765,
-0.22484612464904785,
0.6000509262084961,
0.026851817965507507,
0.6325306296348572,
0.480791300535202,
0.3441232442855835,
0.32395419478416443,
-0.45070475339889526,
0.36661574244499207,
-0.15778447687625885,
0.11723655462265015,
-0.10668347775936127,
-0.3776911199092865,
0.3664628267288208,
0.09676619619131088,
-0.5019663572311401,
-0.07083874195814133,
0.28466105461120605,
0.2861078381538391,
0.220361590385437,
0.46806588768959045,
0.5669047236442566,
0.6221840381622314,
0.32700711488723755,
0.8793795108795166,
-0.20251619815826416,
0.28238704800605774,
1.1661344766616821,
-0.4754627048969269,
0.6996298432350159,
0.5253680348396301,
0.02992781437933445,
0.562698483467102,
0.6865774393081665,
0.36890092492103577,
0.9455001354217529,
-0.08531501144170761,
-0.7006806135177612,
-0.14135700464248657,
0.04793757572770119,
-0.11197252571582794,
0.04515645653009415,
0.39017507433891296,
-0.32495179772377014,
-0.9238944053649902,
0.2475183606147766,
0.08586039394140244,
-0.10596533864736557,
-0.16217873990535736,
0.8298705816268921,
0.16373573243618011,
-0.415048211812973,
0.5120965242385864,
-0.12307503074407578,
0.6542870998382568,
-0.4100462794303894,
0.008801033720374107,
-0.2502511441707611,
-0.13098357617855072,
-0.06244189292192459,
-0.6054602265357971,
0.4352308213710785,
0.06258051842451096,
0.20073524117469788,
-0.5023861527442932,
0.8853329420089722,
-0.3904714286327362,
-0.17051734030246735,
0.14834612607955933,
0.5134475231170654,
0.416225403547287,
-0.5922336578369141,
-0.8803105354309082,
-0.38455143570899963,
-0.12385518103837967,
-0.30129867792129517,
0.34906068444252014,
0.5358035564422607,
-0.12667405605316162,
0.46095168590545654,
0.45348843932151794,
-0.23468124866485596,
-0.18222792446613312,
0.16399456560611725,
0.6121892929077148,
-0.4735553562641144,
-0.46709364652633667,
-1.169019103050232,
0.4733731746673584,
-0.07309610396623611,
-0.4122849702835083,
0.7212940454483032,
0.6654291749000549,
0.47805148363113403,
-0.06390538811683655,
0.8979564309120178,
-0.008309861645102501,
0.4132753014564514,
-0.2860252857208252,
0.7952846884727478,
-0.44861873984336853,
0.08820096403360367,
-0.5692154765129089,
-0.8602967262268066,
-0.45841532945632935,
0.617350161075592,
-0.42779672145843506,
0.09623045474290848,
0.9418569803237915,
0.711410641670227,
0.007101897615939379,
0.042859140783548355,
0.33247455954551697,
-0.13931378722190857,
0.4468698799610138,
0.6456117630004883,
0.6063224673271179,
-0.34167560935020447,
0.6434293985366821,
-0.2501572370529175,
-0.24226219952106476,
-0.10744204372167587,
-0.9355797171592712,
-0.918552041053772,
-0.5623046159744263,
-0.31577613949775696,
-0.034228306263685226,
0.1157929077744484,
0.9238704442977905,
0.2925621569156647,
-0.6004374027252197,
0.3597623407840729,
-0.4456826448440552,
0.27171432971954346,
-0.6163011789321899,
-0.30929628014564514,
0.22360964119434357,
-0.665416419506073,
-0.7221073508262634,
0.5339340567588806,
0.3702266812324524,
-0.23180408775806427,
0.274159699678421,
0.21231508255004883,
-0.2583458125591278,
0.022499248385429382,
0.5928043723106384,
0.33228763937950134,
-0.5084635019302368,
-0.6749333739280701,
-0.3844422996044159,
-0.19591131806373596,
0.11513009667396545,
0.3319404423236847,
-0.7112618684768677,
0.12429626286029816,
0.5935036540031433,
0.5889852046966553,
0.35355907678604126,
0.4023546874523163,
0.19877077639102936,
-1.0817668437957764,
0.010289585217833519,
0.1150052547454834,
-0.022744128480553627,
0.2305985391139984,
-0.4755632281303406,
0.3428680896759033,
0.27620062232017517,
-0.44649621844291687,
-0.599796712398529,
0.0690360963344574,
-0.7569860219955444,
-0.5111076831817627,
1.457817554473877,
-0.04110157862305641,
-0.31204405426979065,
-0.47933048009872437,
-0.328571081161499,
0.281771183013916,
-0.6061221957206726,
0.6537735462188721,
0.5833442807197571,
0.03790837153792381,
-0.20865952968597412,
-0.9003294110298157,
0.6432744860649109,
0.037177592515945435,
-1.115011215209961,
0.07010263204574585,
0.4727274179458618,
0.7097136378288269,
-0.16169008612632751,
0.5939884185791016,
0.008005631156265736,
0.06626898795366287,
-0.3267544209957123,
-0.09873837977647781,
0.11451607197523117,
-0.3313864767551422,
-0.5109351277351379,
0.1374693363904953,
-0.6495189666748047,
-0.05267427861690521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03049v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03049v1
|
Language, Environment, and Robotic Navigation
| 2024-04-03T20:30:38 | 2024-04-03T20:30:38 |
Johnathan E. Avery
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores the integration of linguistic inputs within robotic
navigation systems, drawing upon the symbol interdependency hypothesis to
bridge the divide between symbolic and embodied cognition. It examines previous
work incorporating language and semantics into Neural Network (NN) and
Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) approaches, highlighting how these
integrations have advanced the field. By contrasting abstract symbol
manipulation with sensory-motor grounding, we propose a unified framework where
language functions both as an abstract communicative system and as a grounded
representation of perceptual experiences. Our review of cognitive models of
distributional semantics and their application to autonomous agents underscores
the transformative potential of language-integrated systems.
|
[
-0.44061601161956787,
-0.5595802068710327,
0.93409264087677,
0.07525552064180374,
-0.1083022728562355,
0.38715264201164246,
-0.20480747520923615,
-0.40799441933631897,
0.5223377346992493,
0.6180369853973389,
-0.6140223145484924,
-0.44519174098968506,
-0.7866621613502502,
-0.23511680960655212,
-0.384483277797699,
0.4323463439941406,
0.002066314220428467,
-0.13416717946529388,
0.011990578845143318,
-0.6360757946968079,
-0.6089664101600647,
-0.6737040281295776,
-0.20386196672916412,
-0.6020455956459045,
0.32833132147789,
0.04502885416150093,
1.2337754964828491,
0.3367545008659363,
0.5977311730384827,
0.3049687445163727,
0.184202641248703,
0.06856714934110641,
0.19334211945533752,
0.27082541584968567,
-0.3985643684864044,
-0.466630220413208,
-0.11517929285764694,
-0.012515171431005001,
0.5898501873016357,
1.0368467569351196,
0.13396941125392914,
-0.35498011112213135,
-0.012121548876166344,
0.4905233085155487,
-0.602180540561676,
0.6081292033195496,
-0.07040614634752274,
0.04875177890062332,
0.26628825068473816,
-0.3391586244106293,
-0.11771434545516968,
-0.11695004254579544,
0.12290523946285248,
-0.9888885021209717,
-0.4515842795372009,
-0.00807226449251175,
0.8042130470275879,
0.7439229488372803,
-0.5122635364532471,
-0.5814435482025146,
-0.8591206073760986,
0.677095890045166,
-0.4667913615703583,
0.5193710327148438,
0.3145896792411804,
0.2076694220304489,
-0.2575320601463318,
-0.46630510687828064,
-0.8180071115493774,
-0.6434785723686218,
-0.2016419768333435,
0.43174171447753906,
-0.4234723448753357,
0.4730524718761444,
-0.059735577553510666,
-0.2580878436565399,
-0.2729831635951996,
0.07928531616926193,
-0.24177725613117218,
0.17988179624080658,
0.5149967670440674,
0.05208183825016022,
1.1120576858520508,
0.018477482721209526,
-0.3273213505744934,
-0.45879384875297546,
-0.7048255801200867,
-0.20323161780834198,
0.4377165734767914,
0.7828403115272522,
-0.24517394602298737,
0.7456066608428955,
-0.19791238009929657,
0.8545629978179932,
-0.41753822565078735,
0.01662001572549343,
0.16695544123649597,
-0.39246866106987,
-0.022897550836205482,
0.2748390734195709,
0.7999144196510315,
0.39643168449401855,
0.4533472955226898,
-0.29854679107666016,
-0.13338395953178406,
0.538002610206604,
0.5296105742454529,
0.23595333099365234,
-0.2068490982055664,
0.1855400949716568,
-0.20529139041900635,
0.010999820195138454,
0.33177825808525085,
-0.12277835607528687,
-0.282241553068161,
-0.5806282758712769,
0.34771493077278137,
-0.4172668755054474,
-0.5518174171447754,
0.5854960083961487,
-0.3349572718143463,
0.16531047224998474,
0.42269763350486755,
-0.8849301338195801,
0.5750789046287537,
0.8719695210456848,
0.6822558641433716,
0.22119276225566864,
-0.4150678813457489,
-0.08223486691713333,
0.2721930146217346,
-0.30156102776527405,
0.837681770324707,
-0.6983230710029602,
-0.5088154077529907,
-0.004360475577414036,
0.1639421433210373,
-0.05824041739106178,
-0.5212264060974121,
0.1487078219652176,
-0.5142845511436462,
-0.07837498188018799,
-0.1336347460746765,
-0.007996651344001293,
-0.8785778284072876,
0.1283913105726242,
-0.7620064616203308,
0.8800492286682129,
0.2597481310367584,
-0.07203758507966995,
0.1858532726764679,
-0.9512641429901123,
-0.7136620283126831,
0.2224944829940796,
-0.4497300684452057,
0.3541823923587799,
0.02566305547952652,
-0.13977248966693878,
0.15284773707389832,
-0.34515488147735596,
0.24332042038440704,
-0.061243705451488495,
-0.3759916126728058,
-0.009684836491942406,
-0.013814987614750862,
0.8464198708534241,
0.07501886039972305,
-0.5320656895637512,
0.15972945094108582,
-0.33277827501296997,
-0.1681443452835083,
-0.019425686448812485,
-0.19422698020935059,
-0.6561079025268555,
0.3648558259010315,
0.03340606763958931,
0.2754780650138855,
0.239481583237648,
-0.20914411544799805,
0.3289523720741272,
-0.7026622295379639,
0.28961795568466187,
0.5222681760787964,
-0.3319818377494812,
1.1507244110107422,
0.04135620594024658,
0.6548721194267273,
0.09511753916740417,
-0.20572540163993835,
-0.22261254489421844,
-0.5682086944580078,
-0.8290572166442871,
0.055289581418037415,
-0.140815868973732,
0.812536895275116,
-0.9249515533447266,
0.7501517534255981,
-0.32990849018096924,
-0.033803749829530716,
-0.22568999230861664,
-0.2941616475582123,
0.18182267248630524,
0.06067569926381111,
0.25659164786338806,
-0.280234694480896,
-0.3140914738178253,
-0.5831670761108398,
0.06057291105389595,
-0.6302986741065979,
-0.1954760104417801,
0.26582419872283936,
0.473887175321579,
-0.4251360595226288,
0.7609312534332275,
-0.15343455970287323,
-0.20366084575653076,
-0.232817143201828,
0.080506332218647,
0.2622799873352051,
0.6475933194160461,
0.5511263608932495,
-0.854519248008728,
0.13075238466262817,
0.48901912569999695,
-1.2876768112182617,
-0.1506674587726593,
-0.27159667015075684,
-0.06002238765358925,
-0.18157251179218292,
0.5603430867195129,
-0.6349368095397949,
0.5553751587867737,
0.5540693402290344,
-0.4347466230392456,
-0.12496265769004822,
-0.423794686794281,
0.24962083995342255,
-0.6411722302436829,
-0.34886428713798523,
-0.16577985882759094,
0.17028306424617767,
-0.39085593819618225,
0.5196236968040466,
-0.2523915469646454,
0.2094946950674057,
-0.34946680068969727,
0.7271866798400879,
-0.7418822646141052,
-0.3512897491455078,
-0.5535100698471069,
0.6492987871170044,
-0.15579116344451904,
0.1741279810667038,
0.2010653167963028,
0.3837384283542633,
0.6254565119743347,
-0.8484025001525879,
0.7374042868614197,
0.14214348793029785,
-0.04409647360444069,
0.5891424417495728,
-0.5799483060836792,
-0.3033437728881836,
-0.21858711540699005,
0.30076533555984497,
-1.0500481128692627,
-0.08181584626436234,
0.6224164962768555,
-0.4555422067642212,
-0.19521866738796234,
-0.02106008492410183,
-0.7657718658447266,
-0.13681066036224365,
0.29946252703666687,
0.6171229481697083,
0.5375825762748718,
-0.3715636730194092,
0.9747959971427917,
0.5730677247047424,
0.20979446172714233,
-0.30928993225097656,
-0.7841977477073669,
0.3338567614555359,
-0.04094251990318298,
-0.6389493942260742,
-0.1041298359632492,
0.31838753819465637,
-0.7461016178131104,
0.046587780117988586,
-0.09062670171260834,
0.05143287405371666,
0.3656173646450043,
0.5907638072967529,
0.31784915924072266,
-0.36225056648254395,
0.3324648141860962,
0.2578505277633667,
-0.4483029246330261,
0.1792607456445694,
-0.7174269556999207,
0.5184653997421265,
-0.08210396021604538,
-0.728635311126709,
-0.291618674993515,
0.3950844407081604,
0.6278269290924072,
-0.1646377146244049,
0.7018570303916931,
-0.12858474254608154,
-0.29641786217689514,
0.08209436386823654,
-0.023431651294231415,
-0.34957608580589294,
-0.45104342699050903,
0.1568884551525116,
-0.3956977427005768,
-0.5984001159667969,
0.4019600749015808,
-0.5753968358039856,
-0.23036961257457733,
0.3321625888347626,
0.3133764863014221,
-0.31904137134552,
0.4104076027870178,
0.6999461054801941,
0.12638098001480103,
0.27004843950271606,
-0.33025261759757996,
0.6772688031196594,
-0.8399564027786255,
-0.32296401262283325,
-0.3532630205154419,
-0.6608310341835022,
-0.7243198156356812,
-0.7050526738166809,
0.44285833835601807,
-0.033851247280836105,
-0.44187772274017334,
0.5245556235313416,
-0.5734034180641174,
0.34653955698013306,
0.7670310735702515,
-0.11184549331665039,
0.2049085795879364,
-0.42390432953834534,
-0.28712502121925354,
0.2908039391040802,
-0.8415136933326721,
-0.847911536693573,
0.7908661961555481,
0.01589207723736763,
0.9140510559082031,
0.08653444796800613,
0.5033202171325684,
0.03274819627404213,
-0.1287374198436737,
-0.7119106650352478,
0.8079820275306702,
-0.08618883043527603,
-0.26807117462158203,
-0.35254523158073425,
0.14352788031101227,
-1.1193128824234009,
0.3627499043941498,
-0.23092897236347198,
-0.8532830476760864,
0.27711084485054016,
-0.2387574166059494,
-0.3075917065143585,
0.31754615902900696,
-0.574639618396759,
0.4950939416885376,
-0.37378740310668945,
0.006359280552715063,
-0.12476572394371033,
-1.040132761001587,
0.1000790074467659,
0.30285200476646423,
0.30101653933525085,
-0.29024171829223633,
-0.24364274740219116,
0.4569329023361206,
-0.25249725580215454,
0.7570222020149231,
0.002641434548422694,
-0.2627444863319397,
0.3414137363433838,
0.2466079592704773,
0.08925475925207138,
-0.13326619565486908,
0.22470800578594208,
0.5139248371124268,
-0.2962803542613983,
-0.2650549113750458,
-0.9352895617485046,
0.5867124199867249,
-0.7711280584335327,
-0.3582066595554352,
-0.6611806154251099,
-0.7216745018959045,
0.02478521689772606,
0.1484214812517166,
-0.20106342434883118,
0.13651257753372192,
-0.08991678804159164,
-0.06851008534431458,
0.6916556358337402,
-0.43607771396636963,
0.4486303925514221,
0.4372888207435608,
-0.2954259216785431,
0.07453769445419312,
0.624991238117218,
0.09445344656705856,
0.36132892966270447,
0.732617199420929,
-0.17252743244171143,
-0.2658722400665283,
-0.04560171067714691,
-0.33293741941452026,
0.2351084053516388,
-0.9556748867034912,
0.1250237226486206,
-0.6989871859550476,
-0.22297076880931854,
-0.08901959657669067,
-0.7925382256507874,
-0.44671863317489624,
-0.5235347151756287,
-0.20906250178813934,
-0.22028613090515137,
0.21350765228271484,
1.165212631225586,
-0.24293452501296997,
0.7315292954444885,
-0.5912285447120667,
0.4971536099910736,
-0.10201888531446457,
-0.09193060547113419,
-0.06983804702758789,
-0.13493895530700684,
-0.09705423563718796,
0.33261361718177795,
0.018804173916578293,
-0.7534599304199219,
0.13490772247314453,
-0.32706135511398315,
0.738082766532898,
0.06751515716314316,
0.10505864769220352,
0.3022399842739105,
-0.3537485897541046,
0.9554159045219421,
0.2821106016635895,
-0.8448124527931213,
0.6804989576339722,
-0.4731859862804413,
0.6640941500663757,
0.1957712322473526,
0.301677405834198,
-0.6437190175056458,
-0.8360341787338257,
-0.5366126894950867,
-1.040488362312317,
0.3957097828388214,
0.13908150792121887,
0.16476696729660034,
-0.11051072925329208,
0.10643073916435242,
-0.2318210005760193,
0.026512805372476578,
-0.6274600625038147,
-0.44126877188682556,
0.07563097774982452,
-0.2696114480495453,
-0.3141386806964874,
0.24703772366046906,
-0.31810709834098816,
-0.09197826683521271,
0.20330534875392914,
-0.28728362917900085,
0.4181663990020752,
-0.09236722439527512,
-0.25001516938209534,
0.26798057556152344,
-0.24116313457489014,
0.5736423134803772,
0.3497515916824341,
0.32895955443382263,
0.42813512682914734,
-0.17833152413368225,
-0.3701684772968292,
0.5537285208702087,
-0.2590252161026001,
-0.0680466741323471,
0.12291941046714783,
0.5220927596092224,
0.5641730427742004,
0.5145542621612549,
-0.5622615218162537,
0.16668649017810822,
0.3096812963485718,
0.0745103731751442,
-0.12461058795452118,
0.07939473539590836,
0.19772443175315857,
0.497709721326828,
0.16133463382720947,
0.272403359413147,
0.12403091043233871,
-0.6588174700737,
0.06642772257328033,
0.5285308361053467,
-0.4418560862541199,
-0.41726091504096985,
0.7004186511039734,
0.1213432103395462,
-0.2606768310070038,
0.6285643577575684,
0.12385569512844086,
-0.5043546557426453,
0.8119326233863831,
0.12668122351169586,
1.045965313911438,
-0.10096219927072525,
0.17624329030513763,
0.33355414867401123,
0.8555875420570374,
-0.20147950947284698,
0.3288823068141937,
-0.43616029620170593,
-0.9492932558059692,
-0.15656201541423798,
-0.34541311860084534,
-0.3790639340877533,
-0.8878912925720215,
-0.3431698679924011,
0.10028854012489319,
-0.4088513255119324,
-0.04079870507121086,
-0.28658875823020935,
-0.6457127928733826,
-0.5207415819168091,
0.4525611996650696,
0.2733380198478699,
0.34764572978019714,
-0.9953798055648804,
0.7473804950714111,
0.905157208442688,
-0.8291004300117493,
-0.6506181955337524,
0.08734796941280365,
-0.05226699635386467,
-0.8284302949905396,
1.5265789031982422,
-0.2165585309267044,
-0.8945819139480591,
-0.376192182302475,
-0.4461296796798706,
-1.095772624015808,
0.8280502557754517,
0.2887202501296997,
-0.01230616308748722,
0.018111053854227066,
0.3599952757358551,
0.42259612679481506,
-0.3952745795249939,
0.3315242826938629,
0.5306283235549927,
0.6799065470695496,
-0.08209948241710663,
-1.046607494354248,
0.01675652340054512,
-0.08840109407901764,
0.1628509908914566,
0.3012618124485016,
-0.7880811095237732,
0.80803382396698,
0.08804693818092346,
-0.4191204607486725,
-0.06249062716960907,
0.4928666055202484,
0.18712463974952698,
0.1551782190799713,
0.1933908611536026,
0.5557025074958801,
0.4709790349006653,
-0.48092034459114075,
1.0197323560714722,
-0.40064799785614014,
0.04239886626601219,
0.9451510906219482,
-0.3447777330875397,
0.4675440490245819,
0.7050411701202393,
-0.024916809052228928,
0.8304995894432068,
0.17156949639320374,
0.6556264758110046,
0.6223435401916504,
0.44956865906715393,
-0.5846245288848877,
0.01093195378780365,
-0.045327190309762955,
-0.2864597737789154,
0.6917303800582886,
0.5218914151191711,
-0.024393955245614052,
-0.32323211431503296,
0.471477746963501,
-0.13003294169902802,
0.28576555848121643,
0.01322996336966753,
0.8465169668197632,
0.21202921867370605,
-0.5937618017196655,
0.2732732892036438,
-0.3023916184902191,
0.5012598633766174,
-0.73148113489151,
-0.31881728768348694,
-0.05934561416506767,
0.054930221289396286,
0.02415880560874939,
-1.054707646369934,
0.3980129063129425,
-0.7032472491264343,
0.08975563198328018,
-0.7033063769340515,
0.5692622661590576,
-0.11466094851493835,
-0.18029539287090302,
0.8495851159095764,
0.6024465560913086,
0.2354462593793869,
0.018049074336886406,
-0.3510058522224426,
0.44981393218040466,
-0.4872078001499176,
0.030856596305966377,
0.0686725601553917,
0.7141886353492737,
0.0055799540132284164,
1.0490140914916992,
0.3989918529987335,
-0.0933007150888443,
0.19006814062595367,
-0.2152593433856964,
0.8039812445640564,
-1.034031629562378,
-0.6452438235282898,
-0.6769078373908997,
0.5007340908050537,
0.41170331835746765,
-0.1204858124256134,
0.7603633403778076,
0.26006707549095154,
0.987483024597168,
-0.08353400975465775,
0.8942956328392029,
-0.08632820099592209,
-0.22075597941875458,
-0.5651267170906067,
0.7655223608016968,
-0.5717113018035889,
0.1313970983028412,
-0.42093411087989807,
-0.7402902841567993,
-0.5396198630332947,
1.0875606536865234,
-0.34819531440734863,
0.06925783306360245,
0.7585486173629761,
0.5755022168159485,
-0.05494029447436333,
-0.11933013796806335,
0.5410563349723816,
-0.18486477434635162,
0.19146046042442322,
0.6005660891532898,
1.161582589149475,
-0.6727586984634399,
-0.3029867112636566,
0.046425651758909225,
-0.13081736862659454,
-0.13746510446071625,
-0.6098373532295227,
-0.20860452950000763,
-0.9061025977134705,
-0.2915736138820648,
-0.3914763331413269,
0.20997254550457,
0.7726531624794006,
0.7692351341247559,
-0.30699387192726135,
-0.8191311359405518,
-0.2988314926624298,
0.3886834979057312,
-0.23469480872154236,
-0.16070741415023804,
-0.20599035918712616,
-0.32304978370666504,
-0.8108385801315308,
0.6630594730377197,
1.068674921989441,
0.06473784893751144,
-0.48926272988319397,
-0.29199081659317017,
-0.4492691457271576,
0.0839078277349472,
0.6768187284469604,
0.44800177216529846,
-1.0836338996887207,
-0.41783687472343445,
0.05273272469639778,
-0.07891270518302917,
0.11660521477460861,
0.7624204754829407,
-1.063288688659668,
0.7346341609954834,
0.251264363527298,
0.7033124566078186,
0.08551444113254547,
-0.33318156003952026,
0.8559128046035767,
-0.20701085031032562,
0.7884738445281982,
0.38090816140174866,
0.2379615157842636,
0.09604993462562561,
-0.2505047023296356,
0.814311146736145,
0.1667448878288269,
-0.2649891972541809,
-0.4596169888973236,
0.4096801280975342,
-1.3124418258666992,
-0.29168620705604553,
1.1141644716262817,
0.018883394077420235,
-0.3232964873313904,
-0.09794192761182785,
-0.25379714369773865,
0.22765132784843445,
-0.05627862364053726,
0.3314956724643707,
0.812934398651123,
-0.2326122671365738,
-0.10565117746591568,
-0.686183512210846,
-0.19431260228157043,
0.24609370529651642,
-0.734283983707428,
-0.3830777108669281,
0.5664947628974915,
-0.22303803265094757,
0.46220970153808594,
0.6655852198600769,
0.19864051043987274,
0.3056115210056305,
0.3452073037624359,
0.369611918926239,
0.5339999198913574,
-0.39922595024108887,
-0.2521735429763794,
-0.0538545586168766,
-0.12095294147729874,
-0.6263002157211304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03048v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03048v2
|
Decentralised Moderation for Interoperable Social Networks: A Conversation-based Approach for Pleroma and the Fediverse
| 2024-04-03T20:29:40 | 2024-04-16T23:59:51 |
Vibhor Agarwal, Aravindh Raman, Nishanth Sastry, Ahmed M. Abdelmoniem, Gareth Tyson, Ignacio Castro
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
The recent development of decentralised and interoperable social networks
(such as the "fediverse") creates new challenges for content moderators. This
is because millions of posts generated on one server can easily "spread" to
another, even if the recipient server has very different moderation policies.
An obvious solution would be to leverage moderation tools to automatically tag
(and filter) posts that contravene moderation policies, e.g. related to toxic
speech. Recent work has exploited the conversational context of a post to
improve this automatic tagging, e.g. using the replies to a post to help
classify if it contains toxic speech. This has shown particular potential in
environments with large training sets that contain complete conversations.
This, however, creates challenges in a decentralised context, as a single
conversation may be fragmented across multiple servers. Thus, each server only
has a partial view of an entire conversation because conversations are often
federated across servers in a non-synchronized fashion. To address this, we
propose a decentralised conversation-aware content moderation approach suitable
for the fediverse. Our approach employs a graph deep learning model (GraphNLI)
trained locally on each server. The model exploits local data to train a model
that combines post and conversational information captured through random walks
to detect toxicity. We evaluate our approach with data from Pleroma, a major
decentralised and interoperable micro-blogging network containing 2 million
conversations. Our model effectively detects toxicity on larger instances,
exclusively trained using their local post information (0.8837 macro-F1). Our
approach has considerable scope to improve moderation in decentralised and
interoperable social networks such as Pleroma or Mastodon.
|
[
-0.581706166267395,
-1.0849449634552002,
0.4833970367908478,
0.231535404920578,
-0.3618681728839874,
0.12764599919319153,
-0.3163978159427643,
-0.513350784778595,
0.7031921744346619,
0.6583887338638306,
-0.5765926241874695,
-0.6695014238357544,
-0.5813987851142883,
0.002118661068379879,
-0.34033146500587463,
1.037341594696045,
0.10365204513072968,
-0.031853631138801575,
-0.4429194927215576,
-0.43930476903915405,
-0.5688626766204834,
-0.22461870312690735,
-0.8938345909118652,
-0.48607778549194336,
0.6943742632865906,
0.4469622075557709,
0.6373429298400879,
0.3964444696903229,
0.6218057870864868,
0.3771856129169464,
-0.3336222469806671,
0.5060526728630066,
-0.732739269733429,
0.3680311143398285,
-0.462041437625885,
-0.17045137286186218,
-0.4514394998550415,
0.032101936638355255,
0.35362958908081055,
0.7481712102890015,
-0.11711816489696503,
-0.02069876715540886,
0.033250726759433746,
0.33454588055610657,
-0.3737204670906067,
0.4476296007633209,
-0.43563851714134216,
0.2443171739578247,
0.11101023852825165,
-0.26047787070274353,
-0.3305235207080841,
-0.17672111093997955,
-0.0229349285364151,
-0.3792906701564789,
-0.2153334766626358,
-0.11692565679550171,
0.46083301305770874,
-0.14226336777210236,
-0.2935979664325714,
-0.3951663672924042,
-0.8078378438949585,
0.535986065864563,
-0.5848562121391296,
0.19766421616077423,
0.47910916805267334,
0.08636289089918137,
-0.28590700030326843,
-1.0548441410064697,
-0.35036513209342957,
0.028853924944996834,
-0.3157997727394104,
0.14254344999790192,
-0.2197744995355606,
0.24886038899421692,
0.0009627392282709479,
0.3754975497722626,
-0.35999757051467896,
0.21906088292598724,
-0.06818566471338272,
-0.21941399574279785,
0.6407432556152344,
0.2892628312110901,
0.22618882358074188,
-0.4051346778869629,
-0.20746420323848724,
0.15998874604701996,
-0.3624390959739685,
-0.015065408311784267,
0.6226376891136169,
0.31467893719673157,
-0.04645788297057152,
0.2000754326581955,
-0.46631449460983276,
0.6464942097663879,
0.20098701119422913,
-0.0873936340212822,
-0.013159826397895813,
-0.6965386271476746,
-0.08249153196811676,
0.07993558049201965,
1.031001329421997,
0.4427308738231659,
-0.32876598834991455,
-0.14769099652767181,
-0.056295882910490036,
0.1415766030550003,
0.1752668023109436,
-0.9924463629722595,
-0.5587981343269348,
0.3437291979789734,
-0.38390424847602844,
-0.5323545336723328,
0.13353665173053741,
-0.5920912027359009,
-0.6572886109352112,
0.00048225835780613124,
0.2669379413127899,
0.008574191480875015,
-0.4719257354736328,
-0.004036131780594587,
0.10728251934051514,
-0.2198101282119751,
0.26720181107521057,
-0.7353647947311401,
0.4217526614665985,
1.0166053771972656,
1.082274079322815,
0.21357139945030212,
0.08614065498113632,
-0.6114528179168701,
0.050119269639253616,
-0.11591789126396179,
0.7342041730880737,
-0.5816969275474548,
-0.2971861660480499,
0.016914959996938705,
0.3176862299442291,
0.018762696534395218,
-0.45548000931739807,
0.4675936996936798,
-0.6511982083320618,
0.4181532859802246,
-0.372910737991333,
-0.6961235404014587,
-0.14111047983169556,
0.4651901423931122,
-0.5341613292694092,
0.4051724970340729,
0.10348647832870483,
-1.0303993225097656,
0.11733641475439072,
-0.6628366112709045,
-0.6056851148605347,
0.25853121280670166,
-0.03284231200814247,
-0.40101075172424316,
-0.2756352722644806,
-0.036986544728279114,
0.4596569538116455,
-0.12425566464662552,
0.6099125146865845,
-0.6653366684913635,
-0.4492168724536896,
0.13242404162883759,
-0.28648510575294495,
0.8410441875457764,
0.3947846293449402,
-0.26100778579711914,
0.6174768209457397,
-0.12202533334493637,
-0.023683974519371986,
-0.11224233359098434,
-0.026026545092463493,
-0.31310945749282837,
0.1481928527355194,
-0.161553293466568,
0.058359306305646896,
0.028844013810157776,
-0.764178991317749,
-0.19272901117801666,
-0.3550277650356293,
1.1011414527893066,
0.7025385499000549,
0.357700914144516,
0.6303058862686157,
-0.7685526609420776,
0.061643537133932114,
0.14168182015419006,
0.6908189058303833,
-0.21186523139476776,
-0.4520154893398285,
-0.6039464473724365,
-0.14273235201835632,
0.13306474685668945,
0.38166314363479614,
-0.8395680785179138,
0.6691425442695618,
-0.175352543592453,
-0.6862984895706177,
-0.22755679488182068,
0.23473510146141052,
0.17775610089302063,
0.6359869837760925,
-0.03650049492716789,
-0.6497143507003784,
-0.47490954399108887,
-0.5336621403694153,
0.21042105555534363,
-0.4037359654903412,
0.22249698638916016,
0.5646871328353882,
0.3221762776374817,
-0.5234964489936829,
0.7636521458625793,
-0.11422304064035416,
-0.6163767576217651,
-0.057161156088113785,
0.08298098295927048,
0.023820141330361366,
0.5909274220466614,
0.2847708761692047,
-0.8131325840950012,
-0.563459038734436,
0.20568548142910004,
-0.8252899050712585,
-0.32372838258743286,
0.13710008561611176,
-0.20393945276737213,
-0.1263255625963211,
0.5075867772102356,
-0.4028811752796173,
-0.04865574836730957,
0.7600990533828735,
-0.17118367552757263,
0.09336721152067184,
-0.1224125549197197,
0.24657735228538513,
-1.2301411628723145,
0.037271708250045776,
-0.18908122181892395,
-0.6162073612213135,
-0.5227863192558289,
-0.050358209758996964,
-0.3804895281791687,
-0.1883636862039566,
-0.33146288990974426,
0.34293439984321594,
0.015161404386162758,
0.062417663633823395,
-0.18882901966571808,
0.23904892802238464,
0.22926601767539978,
0.23496189713478088,
-0.047241345047950745,
0.6289404630661011,
0.2411271184682846,
-0.21669591963291168,
0.6983252167701721,
0.39505133032798767,
-0.2148008942604065,
0.8574385046958923,
-0.5337685346603394,
0.1704559326171875,
-0.2049369066953659,
0.5672520995140076,
-0.9747000336647034,
-0.3708525002002716,
0.5576660633087158,
-0.12938633561134338,
-0.1118401437997818,
-0.15119720995426178,
-0.5711976885795593,
-0.22749535739421844,
-0.24436405301094055,
0.1834230273962021,
0.15870262682437897,
-0.343009352684021,
0.2893112599849701,
0.7859961986541748,
-0.31813040375709534,
-0.1423429399728775,
-0.3894370198249817,
0.1587725281715393,
-0.13173311948776245,
-0.8306211829185486,
0.09003440290689468,
-0.2904050946235657,
-0.16965137422084808,
0.20108339190483093,
0.02735147252678871,
-0.10150855779647827,
0.3196752369403839,
0.504343569278717,
-0.25489312410354614,
-0.11595891416072845,
0.1575380116701126,
0.19763067364692688,
-0.03148096799850464,
0.13685521483421326,
-0.2080887407064438,
0.9123849272727966,
-0.27476924657821655,
-0.29188165068626404,
-0.8953190445899963,
0.4631022810935974,
0.5650485157966614,
-0.22482915222644806,
0.6521934270858765,
0.6101066470146179,
-0.08835320174694061,
-0.24254120886325836,
-0.4317686855792999,
-0.49535542726516724,
-0.530479371547699,
-0.02367330715060234,
0.1541450172662735,
-1.148589849472046,
0.7248614430427551,
-0.2587282359600067,
-0.0522565059363842,
0.022016465663909912,
0.3308221995830536,
-0.3699110448360443,
1.1205251216888428,
0.5754784941673279,
0.1003917008638382,
0.9749556183815002,
-0.3673650026321411,
0.2497815042734146,
-0.49686163663864136,
-0.19616949558258057,
-0.14782236516475677,
-0.4904942214488983,
-0.6180034875869751,
-0.37248995900154114,
0.23592284321784973,
-0.15811438858509064,
-0.29790812730789185,
0.1839110106229782,
-0.4317264258861542,
0.47313007712364197,
0.4102020263671875,
0.4142937660217285,
0.4100376069545746,
-0.05617985129356384,
0.17919111251831055,
0.16213421523571014,
-0.9409195780754089,
-0.2920156419277191,
0.5801587104797363,
0.3655630052089691,
0.6340049505233765,
-0.0722012147307396,
0.726082980632782,
0.5086302161216736,
0.8314680457115173,
-0.7084165215492249,
0.46859797835350037,
-0.1896449327468872,
-0.4773457646369934,
-0.04565291479229927,
-0.7045177817344666,
-0.770078182220459,
0.05368220806121826,
-0.27686846256256104,
-0.3834739029407501,
0.2256593555212021,
-0.1642165631055832,
-0.32026565074920654,
0.554815948009491,
-0.5668838024139404,
0.987065315246582,
0.09958396106958389,
-0.40372008085250854,
-0.2357645332813263,
-0.5998049974441528,
0.16036850214004517,
0.005487583577632904,
0.23929718136787415,
-0.2310168445110321,
0.4211858808994293,
0.7045754790306091,
-0.5987090468406677,
1.0206074714660645,
-0.2200309783220291,
0.08262516558170319,
0.5224651098251343,
0.11157094687223434,
0.4780905246734619,
0.4431452453136444,
0.07952171564102173,
0.3971712589263916,
0.16427049040794373,
-0.22192901372909546,
-0.3628547191619873,
0.8512492775917053,
-0.8062998056411743,
-0.5091728568077087,
-0.0716828852891922,
-0.5020047426223755,
-0.2041189968585968,
0.42985454201698303,
0.19620785117149353,
0.35610565543174744,
-0.227803573012352,
0.562164843082428,
0.6880849599838257,
-0.10607466846704483,
0.2756403684616089,
0.5067249536514282,
-0.21823278069496155,
-0.6648711562156677,
0.687381386756897,
0.09761263430118561,
0.30882567167282104,
0.04587904363870621,
0.18800653517246246,
-0.09164246171712875,
-0.36537420749664307,
-0.013347257860004902,
0.1524152159690857,
-0.7182209491729736,
-0.5037747025489807,
-0.833202600479126,
-0.32042139768600464,
-0.2790975272655487,
-0.25691553950309753,
-0.38694483041763306,
0.2611583173274994,
-0.33553269505500793,
-0.09795307368040085,
0.3513472080230713,
0.5628469586372375,
-0.26076358556747437,
0.7259281277656555,
-0.5949756503105164,
-0.18305090069770813,
0.3918343484401703,
0.7779961824417114,
-0.19663062691688538,
-0.1981775164604187,
0.0923755094408989,
0.4619365930557251,
0.006605916656553745,
-0.745086133480072,
0.22406786680221558,
0.07150689512491226,
0.1748885065317154,
0.5597146153450012,
0.41544562578201294,
0.6875145435333252,
-0.09884108603000641,
0.3483571410179138,
0.10043692588806152,
-0.7659634351730347,
0.5443063974380493,
-0.5525036454200745,
-0.19938795268535614,
0.7738758325576782,
0.1768665760755539,
-1.1008069515228271,
-0.7979915142059326,
-0.6311833262443542,
-0.4582311511039734,
0.6453650593757629,
-0.012143516913056374,
0.6164150834083557,
-0.3226374387741089,
0.24266691505908966,
0.08821981400251389,
0.3355884552001953,
-0.46987468004226685,
0.020883833989501,
-0.12152204662561417,
-0.14883309602737427,
-0.03545413166284561,
-0.3165658712387085,
-0.5868744254112244,
-0.4060233533382416,
0.5000416040420532,
-0.0288473479449749,
0.1000850722193718,
0.24312689900398254,
-0.08271140605211258,
-0.4329454004764557,
0.07192238420248032,
0.22415320575237274,
0.46371644735336304,
-0.2014027088880539,
0.2686910033226013,
-0.20684932172298431,
-0.2277960181236267,
0.0025323648005723953,
0.007057941984385252,
-0.486181378364563,
-0.04882792383432388,
0.18315225839614868,
0.9308551549911499,
0.3374287486076355,
-0.5792388319969177,
0.8238921761512756,
-0.27350524067878723,
-0.16069839894771576,
-0.13685014843940735,
0.17664889991283417,
0.11744997650384903,
0.5317330360412598,
-0.3146228492259979,
0.07876094430685043,
-0.0139118367806077,
-0.6523436903953552,
0.5359370112419128,
0.44667908549308777,
-0.7134147882461548,
-0.32406124472618103,
0.6870291233062744,
0.46548858284950256,
-0.2733224332332611,
0.42983362078666687,
-0.3199770152568817,
-0.20352458953857422,
0.49716514348983765,
0.4388613998889923,
0.5498852729797363,
-0.07131453603506088,
0.8176549077033997,
0.13459162414073944,
0.13006162643432617,
-0.024456104263663292,
0.21927718818187714,
-0.2568042278289795,
-0.850716233253479,
-0.37416085600852966,
-0.6082015633583069,
-0.45819491147994995,
0.07317932695150375,
-0.4555104374885559,
-0.08921405673027039,
-0.8613612651824951,
-0.3972562551498413,
0.09085971862077713,
0.3501150608062744,
-0.2011624425649643,
-0.23989221453666687,
0.10780487209558487,
0.5928246974945068,
-1.2903615236282349,
0.593340277671814,
0.5661531090736389,
-0.34147125482559204,
-0.4902389943599701,
-0.40371009707450867,
-0.47360581159591675,
-0.4672170877456665,
0.12842488288879395,
0.20965950191020966,
0.14039261639118195,
0.16434703767299652,
-0.5595424175262451,
-0.41273412108421326,
1.1146128177642822,
0.23144330084323883,
-0.2739455997943878,
0.3910832405090332,
0.09249460697174072,
0.7459291219711304,
-0.30227285623550415,
0.027364255860447884,
0.14986245334148407,
0.33620500564575195,
0.3179115056991577,
-0.9602010846138,
-0.04269610345363617,
-0.12598931789398193,
-0.07787344604730606,
0.2104090005159378,
-0.9030885696411133,
0.9383326768875122,
0.15904110670089722,
-0.423673540353775,
0.032461851835250854,
0.49115070700645447,
-0.3574860990047455,
0.4690834581851959,
0.5378916263580322,
0.42042356729507446,
0.8586569428443909,
-0.03152017667889595,
0.6679275035858154,
-0.4150116741657257,
0.6327754855155945,
0.9883211851119995,
-0.36868366599082947,
0.616559624671936,
0.26571959257125854,
0.19640134274959564,
0.6179764270782471,
0.7102609872817993,
0.09066736698150635,
0.4868713617324829,
-0.32705244421958923,
-0.6461302638053894,
-0.35501402616500854,
-0.818730354309082,
-0.1517832726240158,
0.4996580481529236,
0.43468260765075684,
-0.45685452222824097,
-0.469502717256546,
0.2794918715953827,
0.3510451912879944,
0.18544673919677734,
-0.35554665327072144,
1.1807944774627686,
-0.02112692780792713,
-0.7049815654754639,
0.17776869237422943,
0.14753113687038422,
0.5416858792304993,
-0.46328455209732056,
0.19520869851112366,
-0.5388361811637878,
0.1277313083410263,
-0.3723185658454895,
-0.8747431039810181,
0.566577672958374,
-0.36356642842292786,
0.13211782276630402,
-0.628387987613678,
1.144300103187561,
-0.5969069600105286,
-0.061127740889787674,
0.33108049631118774,
0.5930542945861816,
-0.15902553498744965,
-0.047851741313934326,
-0.5605000853538513,
0.28758546710014343,
-0.3736288547515869,
0.13002561032772064,
0.3443507254123688,
0.2243007868528366,
-0.12778255343437195,
0.5629829168319702,
0.7688654661178589,
-0.07026758790016174,
-0.3002622127532959,
-0.08268289268016815,
1.056679129600525,
-0.021156173199415207,
-0.8211030960083008,
-0.6226879358291626,
0.021791597828269005,
-0.315030962228775,
0.24811725318431854,
0.624843418598175,
0.2961862087249756,
0.9337159991264343,
0.3839886784553528,
0.49841204285621643,
-0.2789866626262665,
0.036762725561857224,
0.0885675847530365,
0.9283366799354553,
-0.16934819519519806,
0.15011483430862427,
-0.13537435233592987,
-0.6509547233581543,
-0.3061002492904663,
0.8151925802230835,
-0.5074389576911926,
-0.2917105257511139,
0.39714616537094116,
0.9278501868247986,
-0.12359841912984848,
0.4062589108943939,
0.1585022211074829,
0.3091346323490143,
0.45754536986351013,
0.3817742168903351,
0.8501049876213074,
-0.16127415001392365,
0.3386652171611786,
-0.7276557087898254,
-0.09065041691064835,
-0.24877770245075226,
-0.698411226272583,
-0.6939817667007446,
-0.5711727738380432,
-0.3583531379699707,
-0.5147369503974915,
0.07040125876665115,
0.6836785078048706,
0.6759101748466492,
-0.7532595992088318,
-0.09187226742506027,
-0.2872733175754547,
0.43943890929222107,
-0.17176662385463715,
-0.22750571370124817,
-0.14862488210201263,
-0.19184018671512604,
-0.5525157451629639,
0.05154680460691452,
0.5417225360870361,
-0.279816597700119,
-0.38984325528144836,
0.12854723632335663,
-0.07759343832731247,
-0.035956308245658875,
0.7408250570297241,
0.19774997234344482,
-0.2850150167942047,
-0.6344724893569946,
-0.18447668850421906,
-0.2115766853094101,
0.15614399313926697,
0.7290396094322205,
-0.574947714805603,
0.7093346118927002,
0.6931002736091614,
0.4179067611694336,
0.27715712785720825,
0.10726386308670044,
0.13218650221824646,
-0.8829904198646545,
0.4016500413417816,
0.4153411090373993,
0.17628438770771027,
0.40744489431381226,
-0.18875081837177277,
0.29986852407455444,
0.5638507008552551,
-0.6326786279678345,
-0.8958460688591003,
0.30428966879844666,
-0.8666648864746094,
-0.27896028757095337,
1.131516695022583,
-0.30716830492019653,
-0.13372498750686646,
-0.19473682343959808,
-0.27903273701667786,
0.24564389884471893,
-0.14734339714050293,
0.7370852828025818,
0.43747326731681824,
0.08006498217582703,
-0.10432876646518707,
-0.5346377491950989,
0.3426778018474579,
0.0460331067442894,
-0.7765238285064697,
0.16294801235198975,
0.5594801306724548,
0.47767016291618347,
0.07415685057640076,
1.056386947631836,
-0.03423391655087471,
-0.03671703115105629,
-0.16800200939178467,
-0.5406181216239929,
-0.10379331558942795,
-0.32291385531425476,
-0.07612227648496628,
0.4195053279399872,
-0.2656470537185669,
0.024624112993478775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03036v1
|
MuLan: A Study of Fact Mutability in Language Models
| 2024-04-03T19:47:33 | 2024-04-03T19:47:33 |
Constanza Fierro, Nicolas Garneau, Emanuele Bugliarello, Yova Kementchedjhieva, Anders Søgaard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Facts are subject to contingencies and can be true or false in different
circumstances. One such contingency is time, wherein some facts mutate over a
given period, e.g., the president of a country or the winner of a championship.
Trustworthy language models ideally identify mutable facts as such and process
them accordingly. We create MuLan, a benchmark for evaluating the ability of
English language models to anticipate time-contingency, covering both 1:1 and
1:N relations. We hypothesize that mutable facts are encoded differently than
immutable ones, hence being easier to update. In a detailed evaluation of six
popular large language models, we consistently find differences in the LLMs'
confidence, representations, and update behavior, depending on the mutability
of a fact. Our findings should inform future work on the injection of and
induction of time-contingent knowledge to/from LLMs.
|
[
0.04661942273378372,
-0.7667955160140991,
0.8317223191261292,
0.38317930698394775,
0.005860686767846346,
0.19213958084583282,
-0.1710941046476364,
-0.6077672243118286,
0.19253142178058624,
0.10654547065496445,
-0.21979953348636627,
-0.007554422598332167,
-0.7154001593589783,
-0.1420317143201828,
-0.3689184784889221,
1.035772442817688,
-0.00671515753492713,
-0.08909893780946732,
-0.049279842525720596,
-0.6355094909667969,
-0.16414235532283783,
-0.8148539662361145,
-0.6662754416465759,
-0.518172562122345,
0.5507033467292786,
0.37758761644363403,
0.8469213247299194,
0.5409473776817322,
0.783973753452301,
0.250986248254776,
-0.09087487310171127,
0.3615206778049469,
-0.4063887298107147,
0.2821969985961914,
-0.40876686573028564,
-0.4517773389816284,
-0.669337272644043,
0.4749726355075836,
0.7429760694503784,
0.8089459538459778,
-0.4328714609146118,
0.2803945541381836,
0.29099130630493164,
0.6598814725875854,
-0.6553056240081787,
0.2113073617219925,
-0.7960445284843445,
0.0051512764766812325,
-0.49591338634490967,
-0.45496585965156555,
-0.21268180012702942,
-0.5519620180130005,
0.060248106718063354,
-0.412777841091156,
0.2215944230556488,
0.23673637211322784,
0.7865118980407715,
0.0816081240773201,
-0.3520745635032654,
-0.5456540584564209,
-0.7221518158912659,
0.8471477627754211,
-0.5698133111000061,
0.5064594745635986,
0.3559422194957733,
0.35166606307029724,
-0.2127077579498291,
-0.6743758320808411,
-0.7877649068832397,
-0.6590819358825684,
-0.3498382270336151,
-0.0028069906402379274,
0.004894387908279896,
-0.0011560525745153427,
0.46259498596191406,
0.4822273850440979,
-0.5604149699211121,
-0.3281767964363098,
-0.2325156033039093,
-0.1419903188943863,
0.36621373891830444,
0.04741220921278,
0.22530202567577362,
-0.013795070350170135,
-0.5609639286994934,
0.21691067516803741,
-0.7576598525047302,
0.13837836682796478,
0.3222753405570984,
0.10457965731620789,
-0.3106161952018738,
0.6389003992080688,
-0.21815602481365204,
0.22255870699882507,
0.0011965640587732196,
-0.6022495031356812,
0.33372944593429565,
-0.5260125398635864,
-0.1490078866481781,
-0.19256314635276794,
0.5161641240119934,
0.23310734331607819,
0.31614062190055847,
-0.17503739893436432,
-0.10992913693189621,
0.08559128642082214,
-0.3060855269432068,
-0.6425836682319641,
-0.0009334536734968424,
0.2777269780635834,
-0.5095548629760742,
-0.07344304770231247,
0.07157495617866516,
-0.44248107075691223,
-0.24224531650543213,
0.05506862327456474,
0.3681029677391052,
-0.3704693615436554,
-0.380099892616272,
0.2579617202281952,
-0.0709337592124939,
-0.07872194796800613,
0.036102574318647385,
-0.7296380400657654,
0.16605426371097565,
0.552355945110321,
0.858632504940033,
-0.24234747886657715,
-0.7861151695251465,
-0.5541039705276489,
0.21798282861709595,
-0.36396679282188416,
0.7066951990127563,
-0.35301491618156433,
-0.1395908147096634,
0.026144815608859062,
-0.031998008489608765,
-0.14229075610637665,
-0.27119752764701843,
0.6018456816673279,
-0.4901192784309387,
-0.08735699206590652,
-0.1498594582080841,
-0.6451530456542969,
0.050385117530822754,
0.5745867490768433,
-0.8407244682312012,
0.7661058306694031,
-0.10121430456638336,
-0.7700484991073608,
0.4049285352230072,
-0.6735901236534119,
-0.4275224506855011,
-0.2678089141845703,
-0.189130961894989,
-0.26340463757514954,
0.011869838461279869,
-0.3329413831233978,
0.560979425907135,
-0.2841467261314392,
0.597437858581543,
-0.47756487131118774,
-0.013513028621673584,
0.9591012597084045,
-0.6400615572929382,
0.8643380403518677,
0.4332294166088104,
0.03202735632658005,
-0.5352936387062073,
-0.6962378025054932,
-0.15123440325260162,
-0.003717048093676567,
-0.8163138628005981,
-0.13548226654529572,
0.2617504596710205,
-0.2898734509944916,
0.06323384493589401,
0.1750527173280716,
-0.8224955201148987,
0.3293083906173706,
0.02600291185081005,
0.11857418715953827,
0.4409353733062744,
0.13348662853240967,
0.2615355849266052,
-0.9570911526679993,
0.30100196599960327,
0.23632149398326874,
0.12583748996257782,
-0.2754645049571991,
-0.4228796362876892,
-0.8375817537307739,
-0.14741119742393494,
0.24436724185943604,
0.3943478763103485,
-0.5536847114562988,
-0.358610600233078,
-0.28501203656196594,
-0.38989317417144775,
-0.14994417130947113,
0.10084587335586548,
0.42218443751335144,
0.2704089283943176,
0.2558283507823944,
0.06723950803279877,
-0.5697117447853088,
-0.7237641215324402,
-0.4689459204673767,
-0.34227800369262695,
0.2930954694747925,
-0.09960100799798965,
0.5066401958465576,
0.05085098743438721,
0.7099935412406921,
-0.38226333260536194,
-0.027042314410209656,
-0.3273192048072815,
0.515708327293396,
0.3241598606109619,
0.5299530625343323,
0.8193609714508057,
-0.5433232188224792,
-0.2906787693500519,
0.06119102984666824,
-0.8228590488433838,
0.02934439666569233,
-0.08159295469522476,
0.25208088755607605,
0.24365408718585968,
0.7068212628364563,
-0.5675846338272095,
0.5104432106018066,
0.8593425750732422,
-0.20756247639656067,
0.6515905261039734,
-0.32123205065727234,
0.5146287679672241,
-0.7104396224021912,
0.040839336812496185,
-0.4337197542190552,
-0.4866490066051483,
-0.6503797173500061,
-0.07517927885055542,
0.13435658812522888,
0.06526748836040497,
-0.6387287378311157,
0.7706670165061951,
-0.47401198744773865,
0.2312154918909073,
-0.028135208413004875,
0.030449874699115753,
0.13854017853736877,
0.4281200170516968,
-0.32963138818740845,
0.6806220412254333,
0.17664137482643127,
-1.1778510808944702,
0.2785044014453888,
-0.20984679460525513,
-0.8494933247566223,
0.5230903029441833,
-0.4554905295372009,
0.06888676434755325,
-0.10205595195293427,
-0.11130842566490173,
-0.9164160490036011,
-0.09720350801944733,
0.07838645577430725,
-0.352888286113739,
0.2690400183200836,
0.02363593503832817,
-0.3231794238090515,
0.0889846682548523,
-0.23645538091659546,
0.4830605089664459,
-0.033004868775606155,
-0.42249396443367004,
0.5020078420639038,
0.5375063419342041,
-0.16961157321929932,
-0.9288799166679382,
-0.860001802444458,
-0.22412467002868652,
-0.058242373168468475,
-0.34643325209617615,
0.41935139894485474,
-0.469650000333786,
-0.679534912109375,
0.24378056824207306,
0.13283880054950714,
-0.22888781130313873,
0.33384788036346436,
0.011844886466860771,
-0.028095988556742668,
-0.23317618668079376,
0.34503239393234253,
-0.19694197177886963,
-0.1337786465883255,
-0.17194528877735138,
-0.06195656210184097,
0.1599864512681961,
0.1827637255191803,
-0.4988115429878235,
-0.048061683773994446,
0.4355085790157318,
0.75214684009552,
-0.14668771624565125,
0.7397598624229431,
0.062333278357982635,
-0.5833554863929749,
-0.30364930629730225,
-0.7048831582069397,
0.06644390523433685,
-0.37582600116729736,
0.35807064175605774,
-0.6544488668441772,
-0.6909424662590027,
0.5911175608634949,
0.2080661803483963,
0.15075922012329102,
0.25136157870292664,
0.4621575176715851,
-0.33819523453712463,
0.5537474155426025,
0.7762845754623413,
0.02434227243065834,
0.3918498754501343,
-0.12750566005706787,
0.028347153216600418,
-0.4355244040489197,
-0.06555335968732834,
-0.5370944738388062,
-0.241188183426857,
-0.6370556354522705,
-0.3557751178741455,
0.2292208969593048,
-0.23054397106170654,
-0.2043663114309311,
0.05270218849182129,
0.2017059028148651,
0.599812388420105,
0.2461336851119995,
-0.10538399964570999,
0.6499437093734741,
-0.3769560754299164,
-0.31599974632263184,
-0.07686560600996017,
-0.7236919403076172,
-0.3397279679775238,
1.0526604652404785,
0.29814720153808594,
1.081008791923523,
0.5443610548973083,
0.03527079150080681,
0.6373111009597778,
0.46792271733283997,
-0.6017981767654419,
0.34155896306037903,
-0.31376373767852783,
-1.0404162406921387,
-0.21594229340553284,
-0.23770856857299805,
-0.9277645945549011,
-0.09623754769563675,
-0.4456295669078827,
-0.6784802675247192,
0.18465423583984375,
0.213908389210701,
-0.4136601388454437,
0.5467050075531006,
-0.48203936219215393,
0.475102037191391,
-0.47154635190963745,
-0.13603661954402924,
-0.31107625365257263,
-0.33295881748199463,
0.4238125681877136,
-0.12330252677202225,
0.25694331526756287,
-0.6258594393730164,
0.07403464615345001,
0.6962291598320007,
-0.2047709822654724,
0.5530548691749573,
0.09542064368724823,
0.10642974823713303,
0.2831140160560608,
0.33780384063720703,
0.4304898679256439,
0.0016961166402325034,
-0.2965965270996094,
0.1091085821390152,
0.1999378800392151,
-0.3705940544605255,
-0.7658624053001404,
0.4745115637779236,
-0.4908691942691803,
-0.5567262172698975,
-0.7234567999839783,
-0.7278032302856445,
-0.17716561257839203,
-0.21725788712501526,
0.2162800431251526,
0.5138000845909119,
-0.5359447598457336,
0.3539620339870453,
0.5681880712509155,
-0.046988654881715775,
0.6525949835777283,
0.7338784337043762,
-0.6398302912712097,
-0.04123455658555031,
0.6483153700828552,
0.7936951518058777,
0.5478254556655884,
0.5692909955978394,
0.18951448798179626,
-0.31855839490890503,
-0.34024345874786377,
0.049458544701337814,
0.4010768532752991,
-0.6493629217147827,
-0.179462730884552,
-0.4992139935493469,
-0.4155642092227936,
0.03317902237176895,
0.12916621565818787,
-0.5004963874816895,
-0.7979627251625061,
0.2833007276058197,
-0.29393628239631653,
0.22362565994262695,
0.9199903011322021,
-0.2483467012643814,
0.16399988532066345,
-0.5819524526596069,
0.23202849924564362,
0.46365755796432495,
0.4019828140735626,
-0.17790882289409637,
-0.7027729153633118,
-0.4700154960155487,
-0.09103598445653915,
-0.2675558924674988,
-0.859738826751709,
-0.16674570739269257,
0.435764342546463,
0.7607563138008118,
0.5535833835601807,
-0.025052983313798904,
0.41241616010665894,
-0.4136958122253418,
0.5753796100616455,
-0.006208811420947313,
-1.0227391719818115,
0.26496466994285583,
-0.09892140328884125,
0.0005026842700317502,
0.24205003678798676,
0.3608580529689789,
-0.7822620868682861,
-0.5815712213516235,
-0.7298941016197205,
-0.09009289741516113,
0.26164186000823975,
-0.00389548996463418,
0.11576299369335175,
-0.006734105292707682,
0.22426755726337433,
0.23621241748332977,
0.2794226109981537,
-0.7238963842391968,
-0.5115443468093872,
0.013525880873203278,
0.08414868265390396,
-0.06678550690412521,
-0.8205748200416565,
-0.05270330607891083,
0.12109971046447754,
0.6042777299880981,
0.062232133001089096,
0.19757826626300812,
0.19107525050640106,
-0.2775728404521942,
0.1642732173204422,
0.5361024141311646,
0.7968724370002747,
1.2079094648361206,
-0.46297889947891235,
0.5254810452461243,
0.37540313601493835,
-0.5215694904327393,
0.5076761245727539,
-0.09826856106519699,
-0.1054873913526535,
0.31300780177116394,
0.5544440746307373,
0.3024135231971741,
0.2535059452056885,
-0.21943122148513794,
0.4859393537044525,
-0.03418072313070297,
0.057216495275497437,
-0.12873102724552155,
0.00532461516559124,
-0.03334840014576912,
0.22393710911273956,
0.508946418762207,
0.050784941762685776,
-0.04071368649601936,
-0.8921324610710144,
0.29460957646369934,
0.38760316371917725,
0.029408523812890053,
-0.4856228232383728,
0.5769032835960388,
0.21302039921283722,
-0.0584074966609478,
0.1239248514175415,
-0.6093606352806091,
-0.5286744236946106,
0.39991921186447144,
0.5389761328697205,
0.47989651560783386,
-0.511139452457428,
0.21930105984210968,
0.5676036477088928,
0.5643621683120728,
0.06398659199476242,
0.43959859013557434,
0.5184258222579956,
-1.1509759426116943,
-0.42922744154930115,
-0.2717253565788269,
-0.642050564289093,
0.5053706765174866,
-0.3678078353404999,
0.050619132816791534,
-0.48791149258613586,
-0.43741968274116516,
0.09433575719594955,
0.12207159399986267,
-0.8334102034568787,
0.18737028539180756,
-0.04427623748779297,
0.9549345374107361,
-0.7923290133476257,
1.1003795862197876,
0.4103511571884155,
-0.3650822341442108,
-0.7470934391021729,
-0.017767464742064476,
0.11187437176704407,
-0.6398361325263977,
0.6218571066856384,
-0.10228809714317322,
-0.42397958040237427,
-0.44193607568740845,
-0.5951471924781799,
-0.9113141298294067,
1.0677331686019897,
0.7871159911155701,
-0.31561824679374695,
0.20036932826042175,
0.16686077415943146,
0.19051679968833923,
-0.47886908054351807,
0.1603299379348755,
0.5438007116317749,
0.4438037574291229,
-0.33446311950683594,
-0.8923183679580688,
-0.04036079719662666,
-0.12480910867452621,
-0.29011982679367065,
-0.09788031876087189,
-0.8472040891647339,
1.3306246995925903,
-0.3313061594963074,
-0.5311434268951416,
-0.005748892668634653,
0.832551896572113,
0.07751461863517761,
0.3626948595046997,
0.5906872153282166,
0.37114885449409485,
1.2717838287353516,
-0.07865811884403229,
1.0156692266464233,
-0.3596805930137634,
0.5534822940826416,
1.2105978727340698,
-0.1911129206418991,
0.6402261853218079,
0.4555821716785431,
-0.40243297815322876,
0.45972582697868347,
0.21327142417430878,
0.4010868966579437,
0.3398621380329132,
-0.07987391203641891,
-0.14685821533203125,
-0.10427942126989365,
-0.3717477321624756,
-0.5406138896942139,
0.535029411315918,
0.32911935448646545,
-0.10758659988641739,
-0.09144864231348038,
-0.12283680588006973,
0.648417592048645,
-0.04243607074022293,
-0.11958666890859604,
0.1521718055009842,
0.03985268622636795,
-0.7607483267784119,
0.28140246868133545,
-0.12207157164812088,
0.4718381464481354,
-0.8617684841156006,
-0.012795386835932732,
-0.6384874582290649,
0.285008043050766,
-0.2235116958618164,
-1.0669564008712769,
0.3984418511390686,
0.022064704447984695,
-0.5396623611450195,
0.002063182182610035,
0.5418438911437988,
-0.6133422255516052,
-0.4230363965034485,
0.35772690176963806,
0.9156416654586792,
0.20395731925964355,
0.23422877490520477,
-0.46083882451057434,
0.06749489158391953,
-0.20394490659236908,
-0.18409399688243866,
-0.09542068839073181,
0.7213448286056519,
0.13383561372756958,
1.070385456085205,
0.4746103286743164,
0.35811471939086914,
0.12191496044397354,
-0.10625606030225754,
0.49706199765205383,
-0.5255870819091797,
-0.17956668138504028,
-1.042083978652954,
0.4792519807815552,
-0.008760384283959866,
-0.3947589099407196,
0.8357198238372803,
0.48452967405319214,
0.7292128801345825,
0.06465179473161697,
0.8782293796539307,
-0.13097929954528809,
0.8547360897064209,
-0.864464282989502,
0.9832296967506409,
-0.4076659083366394,
0.1882394254207611,
-0.012876208871603012,
-0.523506224155426,
-0.19416162371635437,
0.33213570713996887,
0.01335500180721283,
-0.19897741079330444,
1.2097035646438599,
0.8593518733978271,
-0.21221013367176056,
-0.20446373522281647,
0.5734953880310059,
0.3539428412914276,
0.17872731387615204,
0.4743604362010956,
1.1798341274261475,
-0.04992333799600601,
0.7131399512290955,
-0.17833437025547028,
-0.20418767631053925,
-0.2747616469860077,
-1.3285915851593018,
-0.7611644864082336,
-0.8349481225013733,
-0.4261855483055115,
-0.4162905812263489,
0.23098264634609222,
0.947752058506012,
0.6325033903121948,
-0.8417071104049683,
-0.37534502148628235,
0.6288262009620667,
0.5726491808891296,
-0.40570053458213806,
-0.1075732633471489,
0.2856994569301605,
-0.34628719091415405,
-0.504275381565094,
0.3391774892807007,
0.21608327329158783,
0.2937278151512146,
-0.24448488652706146,
-0.14118477702140808,
-0.5526419281959534,
0.4806689918041229,
0.44784611463546753,
0.38694992661476135,
-0.3648667633533478,
-0.6050198674201965,
0.01607479341328144,
-0.4163241982460022,
0.23792244493961334,
0.9906732439994812,
-0.44373464584350586,
0.5168638825416565,
0.4848340153694153,
0.45265644788742065,
0.32835251092910767,
-0.2490394562482834,
0.44153910875320435,
-0.7516416907310486,
0.2777836322784424,
-0.16782039403915405,
0.7728404998779297,
0.3942873179912567,
-0.06634245812892914,
0.714428722858429,
0.30738237500190735,
-0.7371440529823303,
-0.6126835942268372,
0.41667383909225464,
-0.8034026622772217,
0.027523277327418327,
0.8869779109954834,
-0.4924439489841461,
-0.07345066964626312,
-0.3523155152797699,
0.07508936524391174,
0.19894087314605713,
-0.1262948215007782,
0.6425053477287292,
1.0902198553085327,
-0.0011581890285015106,
0.1268029659986496,
-0.6735202670097351,
0.6556538939476013,
0.11716915667057037,
-0.6730884313583374,
0.0882597416639328,
0.017016861587762833,
0.35614293813705444,
0.4385858178138733,
0.9493065476417542,
0.12403319776058197,
0.2813495099544525,
0.057615481317043304,
-0.22694750130176544,
0.04978950321674347,
-0.5782132744789124,
0.08413716405630112,
0.1375342160463333,
0.2858448624610901,
-0.4586273431777954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04284v1
|
Assessing ML Classification Algorithms and NLP Techniques for Depression Detection: An Experimental Case Study
| 2024-04-03T19:45:40 | 2024-04-03T19:45:40 |
Giuliano Lorenzoni, Cristina Tavares, Nathalia Nascimento, Paulo Alencar, Donald Cowan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Depression has affected millions of people worldwide and has become one of
the most common mental disorders. Early mental disorder detection can reduce
costs for public health agencies and prevent other major comorbidities.
Additionally, the shortage of specialized personnel is very concerning since
Depression diagnosis is highly dependent on expert professionals and is
time-consuming. Recent research has evidenced that machine learning (ML) and
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tools and techniques have significantly bene
ted the diagnosis of depression. However, there are still several challenges in
the assessment of depression detection approaches in which other conditions
such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are present. These challenges
include assessing alternatives in terms of data cleaning and pre-processing
techniques, feature selection, and appropriate ML classification algorithms.
This paper tackels such an assessment based on a case study that compares
different ML classifiers, specifically in terms of data cleaning and
pre-processing, feature selection, parameter setting, and model choices. The
case study is based on the Distress Analysis Interview Corpus - Wizard-of-Oz
(DAIC-WOZ) dataset, which is designed to support the diagnosis of mental
disorders such as depression, anxiety, and PTSD. Besides the assessment of
alternative techniques, we were able to build models with accuracy levels
around 84% with Random Forest and XGBoost models, which is significantly higher
than the results from the comparable literature which presented the level of
accuracy of 72% from the SVM model.
|
[
-0.8519179224967957,
-0.8173039555549622,
0.4536157250404358,
0.33399698138237,
-0.04225076362490654,
-0.07721687108278275,
-0.17385517060756683,
-0.49024587869644165,
-0.12442348152399063,
0.12641486525535583,
-0.7025513052940369,
-0.6098805665969849,
-0.8000564575195312,
0.5045506358146667,
-0.3734089434146881,
1.0440932512283325,
-0.16643254458904266,
0.1437382996082306,
-0.32365095615386963,
-0.08239810168743134,
-0.3841463625431061,
-0.831659197807312,
-1.0970535278320312,
-0.07025820761919022,
0.3720816373825073,
0.00163078005425632,
0.8092066645622253,
-0.06702350080013275,
0.894757866859436,
0.3720409870147705,
-0.36554795503616333,
-0.03337560594081879,
-0.23171600699424744,
-0.05525539442896843,
0.032782312482595444,
-0.43688055872917175,
-0.37398797273635864,
0.012278945185244083,
-0.02178546041250229,
0.5936208963394165,
-0.01477130688726902,
0.24567286670207977,
0.17873172461986542,
0.4090253412723541,
-0.7022860646247864,
0.06483670324087143,
-0.20826533436775208,
0.6856462359428406,
0.08610833436250687,
-0.10492002218961716,
-0.1678430736064911,
-0.25761163234710693,
0.3534989356994629,
-0.3628433346748352,
0.5240584015846252,
-0.26269450783729553,
0.6968317031860352,
0.6717467308044434,
-0.1186174601316452,
-0.4344943165779114,
-0.7428944706916809,
0.7634080648422241,
-0.6713481545448303,
0.053857047110795975,
0.5599992275238037,
0.25516363978385925,
-0.1322961002588272,
-0.5304057002067566,
-0.35706013441085815,
-0.17705316841602325,
-0.013219388201832771,
0.08123113960027695,
-0.2307727038860321,
-0.07018334418535233,
0.6221192479133606,
0.5482310056686401,
-0.7202447652816772,
0.48644959926605225,
-0.17140650749206543,
-0.2296542078256607,
0.6522487998008728,
0.22769585251808167,
0.2839883267879486,
-0.38926154375076294,
-0.3321153223514557,
-0.2446141391992569,
0.03469764441251755,
0.26335886120796204,
0.21212460100650787,
0.20344135165214539,
0.05123678222298622,
0.3882811367511749,
-0.11737587302923203,
0.7102088928222656,
-0.1244230642914772,
-0.19627299904823303,
0.2956627309322357,
-0.02774134650826454,
-0.4968346357345581,
0.13700634241104126,
0.6453486680984497,
0.46839919686317444,
0.1245974749326706,
0.13416722416877747,
-0.26679521799087524,
0.543860912322998,
0.5054454803466797,
-0.7101540565490723,
-0.4266420602798462,
0.416960209608078,
-0.7918131947517395,
-0.30585241317749023,
-0.2872939109802246,
-0.9335578680038452,
-0.8198086619377136,
-0.4458819627761841,
0.41621270775794983,
-0.4002319872379303,
-0.4628360867500305,
0.1671934574842453,
-0.16093072295188904,
-0.03569307178258896,
0.4355810582637787,
-0.362300843000412,
0.20935581624507904,
0.6079756021499634,
0.8541786074638367,
-0.33314254879951477,
0.17741309106349945,
-0.30295035243034363,
-0.6633347868919373,
-0.4609468877315521,
0.7780819535255432,
-0.30805504322052,
-0.28201591968536377,
-0.023867448791861534,
-0.12465687096118927,
-0.10002624988555908,
-0.7157906293869019,
1.0845023393630981,
-0.1540091633796692,
0.31398630142211914,
-0.07232154160737991,
-0.635434091091156,
-0.22498378157615662,
0.31033673882484436,
-0.7753416895866394,
1.0348483324050903,
0.5409047603607178,
-1.0512546300888062,
0.6058902144432068,
-0.7472878694534302,
-0.10930141806602478,
-0.1190839558839798,
0.1688222438097,
-0.6803206205368042,
0.1780809760093689,
0.28347939252853394,
0.8021075129508972,
-0.13378968834877014,
0.022724051028490067,
-0.7140650749206543,
-0.371162474155426,
0.3760890066623688,
-0.4932987093925476,
0.888759434223175,
0.42565393447875977,
-0.17286895215511322,
-0.19554275274276733,
-0.9409756064414978,
0.03511681780219078,
-0.09032946079969406,
-0.1924358457326889,
-0.5273477435112,
0.02633039467036724,
0.12719447910785675,
0.3840392529964447,
-0.10620895773172379,
-0.1438274085521698,
-0.06360239535570145,
-0.12622037529945374,
-0.03687862679362297,
0.5114970207214355,
-0.004727874416857958,
-0.10978550463914871,
-0.19733990728855133,
0.7052902579307556,
0.24489010870456696,
0.45341745018959045,
-0.005297503899782896,
-0.6523003578186035,
-0.5622958540916443,
-0.6873139142990112,
0.5445456504821777,
0.9269314408302307,
-0.31154683232307434,
0.9961323738098145,
0.14230160415172577,
-0.47840598225593567,
-0.7129353284835815,
-0.17956028878688812,
0.11822210252285004,
0.5439802408218384,
0.5655331015586853,
-0.47306570410728455,
-0.7006439566612244,
-0.5679606199264526,
-0.19927579164505005,
0.020066799595952034,
-0.3708007037639618,
0.08480966091156006,
0.2611718475818634,
-0.49675634503364563,
0.9507197141647339,
-0.48918387293815613,
-0.4042831063270569,
0.01709851063787937,
0.552382230758667,
0.17606709897518158,
0.24121834337711334,
0.5035644173622131,
-0.8526907563209534,
-0.3495200574398041,
-0.047030773013830185,
-0.9295210242271423,
-0.1484905630350113,
0.1269742250442505,
0.32669925689697266,
0.26035645604133606,
0.1733730584383011,
-0.5897670388221741,
0.8308062553405762,
0.2914648950099945,
-0.42007994651794434,
0.6658795475959778,
-0.13672707974910736,
0.3898792266845703,
-0.6031912565231323,
-0.024508876726031303,
0.23388266563415527,
-0.169185608625412,
-0.5735698342323303,
-0.3476187288761139,
-0.2528568208217621,
-0.2775697112083435,
-0.18862149119377136,
0.016186915338039398,
-0.1596854031085968,
-0.08362571150064468,
-0.3955169916152954,
0.011245248839259148,
-0.04171660169959068,
0.2925581932067871,
0.011389615945518017,
0.26679229736328125,
0.8055312633514404,
-0.6945144534111023,
0.42717596888542175,
0.16184228658676147,
-0.5986656546592712,
0.6881909966468811,
-0.27181926369667053,
-0.12144235521554947,
-0.1533089131116867,
0.07292776554822922,
-0.9414326548576355,
0.1720733344554901,
0.4082455635070801,
-0.27284547686576843,
0.22988182306289673,
0.11938205361366272,
-0.5128828883171082,
-0.655237078666687,
-0.18635113537311554,
0.06753925234079361,
0.5477728247642517,
-0.3741305470466614,
0.34760215878486633,
0.13522207736968994,
-0.30053848028182983,
-0.5572070479393005,
-0.4274008870124817,
-0.005664402153342962,
-0.7274355292320251,
-0.2694999575614929,
0.3212606608867645,
-0.08106531202793121,
-0.37728193402290344,
0.07140212506055832,
-0.23684650659561157,
-0.3395096957683563,
0.49337753653526306,
0.1610792875289917,
0.3080219328403473,
-0.2412317544221878,
0.14356949925422668,
-0.20065833628177643,
-0.35071828961372375,
0.1473051756620407,
0.48277610540390015,
0.45182710886001587,
-0.08626522123813629,
-0.236409530043602,
-0.6002966165542603,
0.29927927255630493,
0.3154890835285187,
-0.0003632444713730365,
0.5854551792144775,
0.9795500636100769,
-0.4702354967594147,
-0.20945891737937927,
-0.28402334451675415,
0.04816386476159096,
-0.39301276206970215,
0.2740813195705414,
-0.22567489743232727,
-0.4595114290714264,
0.4377385675907135,
-0.4663775563240051,
-0.18817870318889618,
0.3289755582809448,
0.49288085103034973,
-0.2630970776081085,
1.2525266408920288,
0.721600353717804,
-0.2871244251728058,
0.3618822395801544,
-0.28714555501937866,
0.6304805278778076,
-0.3931904137134552,
0.27913767099380493,
-0.6983800530433655,
-0.2732214629650116,
-0.623574435710907,
-0.3536366820335388,
0.24934451282024384,
0.5353800058364868,
0.0412098690867424,
0.21546581387519836,
-0.6111146807670593,
0.05756636708974838,
0.24101074039936066,
0.10336693376302719,
0.21045367419719696,
-0.06849923729896545,
0.04196788743138313,
-0.11624761670827866,
-0.49496880173683167,
-0.7191479206085205,
1.035526990890503,
0.23472271859645844,
0.44959402084350586,
-0.3565208911895752,
0.6074960827827454,
0.7859715223312378,
0.5564766526222229,
-0.8635039925575256,
0.21324841678142548,
-0.16684724390506744,
-0.28086233139038086,
-0.38461241126060486,
-0.35711023211479187,
-0.923141598701477,
0.26225975155830383,
-0.43470048904418945,
-0.7177209854125977,
0.3810879588127136,
-0.08409623056650162,
-0.5972522497177124,
0.12514199316501617,
-0.901198148727417,
1.1514960527420044,
-0.20302030444145203,
0.3214355409145355,
-0.2696046233177185,
-0.543577253818512,
0.4339350759983063,
-0.4725317358970642,
0.214950293302536,
-0.17618919909000397,
0.26713111996650696,
0.7584829330444336,
-0.21683962643146515,
0.5885817408561707,
-0.29512912034988403,
-0.20464403927326202,
0.24678996205329895,
-0.23851169645786285,
0.14290650188922882,
-0.08800368756055832,
-0.2552798390388489,
0.10277227312326431,
0.34324273467063904,
-0.0999828651547432,
-0.9103269577026367,
0.18156179785728455,
-0.7599033713340759,
-0.3430209159851074,
-0.39053910970687866,
-0.19470298290252686,
-0.3239036500453949,
-0.05875491350889206,
0.3329870402812958,
0.3627806305885315,
-0.29774385690689087,
-0.02305707335472107,
0.6117396354675293,
-0.48082801699638367,
0.43687528371810913,
0.37758970260620117,
-0.23972755670547485,
-0.26137208938598633,
0.7347339987754822,
0.18179665505886078,
-0.22266098856925964,
0.1934870034456253,
0.13448992371559143,
-0.18190529942512512,
-0.5055899024009705,
0.060305289924144745,
-0.058573171496391296,
-0.6918451189994812,
-0.32337483763694763,
-0.5869451761245728,
-0.11746704578399658,
-0.3370490074157715,
0.018509170040488243,
-0.21333491802215576,
-0.3725564777851105,
-0.48532477021217346,
-0.3095909655094147,
0.4194316267967224,
0.21981564164161682,
-0.220428466796875,
0.0651078075170517,
-0.5747403502464294,
0.8059307932853699,
0.017460135743021965,
0.2264377623796463,
-0.05318004637956619,
-0.052748166024684906,
-0.19935984909534454,
-0.09598127007484436,
-0.5304155945777893,
-0.8408063054084778,
0.44096389412879944,
0.04863528907299042,
0.41176244616508484,
0.8704965114593506,
0.5438845157623291,
0.891521155834198,
-0.02569258213043213,
0.6626229882240295,
0.2749806046485901,
-0.7909337282180786,
0.5671299695968628,
0.27656954526901245,
-0.23846665024757385,
0.5486761331558228,
1.0705901384353638,
-0.6024938821792603,
-0.4130529761314392,
-0.6941313147544861,
-0.7203702926635742,
0.7124151587486267,
0.20014682412147522,
-0.426971435546875,
-0.013906188309192657,
0.21252121031284332,
0.2669185996055603,
0.06540936976671219,
-0.3480398952960968,
-0.31410279870033264,
-0.2240433394908905,
-0.41824737191200256,
-0.47004303336143494,
-0.09060975909233093,
-0.143224835395813,
-0.36400312185287476,
0.4317611753940582,
0.14470899105072021,
0.43370237946510315,
0.3977089524269104,
-0.1053861752152443,
0.01822248101234436,
0.20264390110969543,
0.13011692464351654,
0.6142670512199402,
-0.34173476696014404,
0.04871874675154686,
0.14890559017658234,
-0.2941288650035858,
0.18540161848068237,
0.3276709020137787,
0.045901887118816376,
0.20330512523651123,
0.37953585386276245,
0.7915754914283752,
-0.1231398805975914,
-0.8655152916908264,
0.5325905084609985,
-0.34938761591911316,
-0.10041279345750809,
-0.27593332529067993,
0.1418454796075821,
-0.18030084669589996,
0.312247633934021,
0.21329598128795624,
0.3425455689430237,
0.49027320742607117,
-0.2924884259700775,
0.18568019568920135,
0.30249089002609253,
-0.36365804076194763,
-0.20100870728492737,
0.08331514894962311,
-0.12122445553541183,
-0.6743353009223938,
0.7711151242256165,
-0.3080706298351288,
-0.41171693801879883,
0.6978365778923035,
0.21788054704666138,
0.8875545859336853,
-0.41965094208717346,
0.4586886465549469,
0.14191463589668274,
0.16289101541042328,
-0.21372799575328827,
0.16896899044513702,
-0.229605033993721,
-0.7739266157150269,
-0.3101358413696289,
-0.6545310616493225,
-0.3591559827327728,
0.517926037311554,
-1.0482228994369507,
0.4837828278541565,
-0.25246351957321167,
-0.6723559498786926,
-0.053743742406368256,
0.3387698531150818,
-0.80051589012146,
0.6329226493835449,
0.41475149989128113,
0.7793271541595459,
-1.0027295351028442,
0.2889396846294403,
0.5200867056846619,
-0.08289770781993866,
-0.288551926612854,
-0.0651778057217598,
-0.08139589428901672,
-0.16850686073303223,
0.30110979080200195,
0.624955415725708,
0.29434579610824585,
-0.2660661041736603,
-0.1452198475599289,
-0.5879208445549011,
0.5943155884742737,
0.11819256097078323,
-0.2832520008087158,
0.22591839730739594,
0.03973831981420517,
0.892939567565918,
-0.15099136531352997,
0.34833720326423645,
0.8380804061889648,
0.6345435976982117,
-0.3573116362094879,
-0.9331405758857727,
-0.22762759029865265,
-0.31374406814575195,
0.036150675266981125,
0.0031418914441019297,
-0.044281378388404846,
0.7189532518386841,
-0.06780192255973816,
-0.43146613240242004,
0.06751992553472519,
0.3785807192325592,
0.29374197125434875,
0.6831425428390503,
0.8132220506668091,
0.887232780456543,
1.0962761640548706,
0.09052843600511551,
1.0481066703796387,
-0.14338935911655426,
0.4773033857345581,
0.5952432751655579,
-0.4227757155895233,
0.7934343218803406,
0.05549956485629082,
-0.5811394453048706,
0.3716537356376648,
1.1907187700271606,
-0.2826206088066101,
0.4924195110797882,
0.4415978789329529,
-0.37130603194236755,
-0.17930004000663757,
0.06501928716897964,
-0.355753093957901,
0.34175410866737366,
0.39648160338401794,
-0.26006463170051575,
-0.2763097584247589,
0.48555031418800354,
-0.20108669996261597,
-0.16585257649421692,
-0.36001378297805786,
0.7207143306732178,
0.049615297466516495,
-0.4358727037906647,
0.6846923232078552,
0.06539265066385269,
0.7020875215530396,
-0.3153916001319885,
0.10912557691335678,
-0.024720193818211555,
0.33596566319465637,
-0.3035326302051544,
-0.45882150530815125,
0.5481935143470764,
0.25330767035484314,
-0.3150370121002197,
-0.1293693631887436,
0.749062716960907,
-0.034148916602134705,
-0.5757713317871094,
0.4847361743450165,
0.5750715732574463,
0.44521600008010864,
-0.3045214116573334,
-0.921608567237854,
-0.01891217567026615,
-0.44507843255996704,
-0.31680917739868164,
0.45993712544441223,
0.657609224319458,
-0.042357947677373886,
0.697881281375885,
0.3797284662723541,
0.02797059156000614,
0.07488201558589935,
0.024858947843313217,
0.34912681579589844,
-0.586838960647583,
-0.5233445763587952,
-0.7598451375961304,
0.28285303711891174,
-0.05598101392388344,
-0.2680946886539459,
0.6997682452201843,
0.3431131839752197,
0.6782089471817017,
-0.2315293401479721,
0.7614949941635132,
-0.0852665826678276,
0.733767032623291,
-0.3014948070049286,
0.42126816511154175,
-0.44906356930732727,
-0.14321580529212952,
-0.6766987442970276,
-0.6715845465660095,
-0.4304524064064026,
0.9133666753768921,
-0.2969856560230255,
0.12301699072122574,
0.7701985836029053,
0.6312506198883057,
0.11074523627758026,
0.3571247160434723,
0.2358381301164627,
0.1498342603445053,
0.14381901919841766,
0.2847917079925537,
1.1765819787979126,
-0.3065052628517151,
0.28531625866889954,
-0.4607222080230713,
-0.4201655387878418,
-0.15717585384845734,
-0.7764953374862671,
-0.7541777491569519,
-0.5034009218215942,
-0.7236684560775757,
0.001646246644668281,
-0.29177236557006836,
0.6518732905387878,
0.5547624230384827,
-0.7790092825889587,
0.07390867173671722,
0.05509761720895767,
0.3023340702056885,
-0.8714966177940369,
-0.362151175737381,
0.5623856782913208,
-0.4646490514278412,
-0.4753401279449463,
0.2848012447357178,
0.1487039476633072,
0.024699527770280838,
-0.12750637531280518,
0.18037526309490204,
0.18500961363315582,
-0.2950603663921356,
0.8259629607200623,
-0.032537128776311874,
-0.5504229664802551,
0.0908406600356102,
-0.43287086486816406,
0.07457932829856873,
0.15406014025211334,
0.8022889494895935,
-0.9499047994613647,
0.15471474826335907,
0.37539854645729065,
0.6663426160812378,
0.18919669091701508,
0.15605950355529785,
0.375234991312027,
-0.23482456803321838,
-0.10037318617105484,
0.2772122025489807,
0.33570337295532227,
0.4140399396419525,
-0.605160653591156,
0.46744489669799805,
0.18430195748806,
-0.56723952293396,
-1.0973129272460938,
-0.18155571818351746,
-0.8188207149505615,
-0.6733112931251526,
0.517484188079834,
-0.3932832181453705,
-0.10992145538330078,
-0.555150032043457,
-0.3604845106601715,
0.4021916091442108,
0.07142545282840729,
1.2242025136947632,
0.7634091973304749,
-0.594544529914856,
-0.032344140112400055,
-0.43842270970344543,
0.7387387752532959,
0.2964570224285126,
-0.7600440979003906,
-0.1131303608417511,
0.1994314193725586,
0.04890836030244827,
0.357389360666275,
0.5148987174034119,
0.03729676455259323,
0.2543751895427704,
-0.1973944753408432,
0.15448486804962158,
0.3087586462497711,
-0.25898709893226624,
-0.5825617909431458,
0.3827170431613922,
-0.36799895763397217,
-0.1057749018073082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03028v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03028v2
|
An Incomplete Loop: Deductive, Inductive, and Abductive Learning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T19:31:56 | 2024-04-10T19:03:00 |
Emmy Liu, Graham Neubig, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern language models (LMs) can learn to perform new tasks in different
ways: in instruction following, the target task is described explicitly in
natural language; in few-shot prompting, the task is specified implicitly with
a small number of examples; in instruction inference, LMs are presented with
in-context examples and are then prompted to generate a natural language task
description before making predictions. Each of these procedures may be thought
of as invoking a different form of reasoning: instruction following involves
deductive reasoning, few-shot prompting involves inductive reasoning, and
instruction inference involves abductive reasoning. How do these different
capabilities relate? Across four LMs (from the gpt and llama families) and two
learning problems (involving arithmetic functions and machine translation) we
find a strong dissociation between the different types of reasoning: LMs can
sometimes learn effectively from few-shot prompts even when they are unable to
explain their own prediction rules; conversely, they sometimes infer useful
task descriptions while completely failing to learn from human-generated
descriptions of the same task. Our results highlight the non-systematic nature
of reasoning even in some of today's largest LMs, and underscore the fact that
very different learning mechanisms may be invoked by seemingly similar
prompting procedures.
|
[
-0.2445504069328308,
-1.2311930656433105,
0.9265013337135315,
-0.2531103491783142,
-0.09676393121480942,
0.0005580433644354343,
-0.28872400522232056,
-0.336117148399353,
-0.19946908950805664,
0.43798989057540894,
-0.7067816853523254,
-0.25390323996543884,
-0.5507379770278931,
0.40620970726013184,
-0.423679381608963,
0.890279233455658,
-0.10694088041782379,
0.09393338859081268,
-0.32396164536476135,
-0.033376213163137436,
-0.6193699836730957,
-0.38425466418266296,
-0.4700566530227661,
-0.6689540147781372,
0.7395502924919128,
0.524844229221344,
0.4839116632938385,
0.48992374539375305,
0.3370475769042969,
0.29320088028907776,
0.0080290911719203,
0.10692048817873001,
-0.3068252205848694,
0.22481095790863037,
-0.2261897772550583,
-0.6705689430236816,
0.12288567423820496,
-0.09151150286197662,
0.6036157608032227,
1.0461708307266235,
0.0266096368432045,
-0.005937743466347456,
0.12954479455947876,
0.8494675159454346,
-0.6935122609138489,
0.0688614472746849,
-0.6856779456138611,
-0.2310892939567566,
0.20784857869148254,
0.07883868366479874,
-0.4373672604560852,
-0.45314618945121765,
0.18918704986572266,
-0.39114516973495483,
0.034300874918699265,
-0.22777631878852844,
0.5212919116020203,
0.32320719957351685,
-0.30048349499702454,
-0.823813259601593,
-0.8189000487327576,
0.73517245054245,
-0.5806307196617126,
0.1381106972694397,
0.4996400475502014,
0.2913720905780792,
-0.23071210086345673,
-0.440515398979187,
-0.6105305552482605,
-0.46895408630371094,
-0.05780758336186409,
-0.2657363712787628,
-0.13891416788101196,
0.11710880696773529,
0.5716398358345032,
0.13735908269882202,
-0.5040850639343262,
0.2923277020454407,
-0.520307719707489,
0.18193379044532776,
0.5062639713287354,
0.1265900433063507,
0.11361522972583771,
0.011011694557964802,
-0.28406524658203125,
0.17409518361091614,
-1.110583782196045,
-0.015325745567679405,
0.18559622764587402,
0.2590440809726715,
-0.21583373844623566,
0.5865702629089355,
-0.16423296928405762,
0.9047623872756958,
-0.0011212314711883664,
-0.3313354253768921,
0.03394307568669319,
0.1022341325879097,
-0.43990328907966614,
0.046470582485198975,
0.6433457732200623,
-0.23814037442207336,
0.4618508517742157,
-0.12322501838207245,
-0.30817684531211853,
0.04718540236353874,
0.013501265086233616,
-0.1436731070280075,
-0.1637420952320099,
0.12219870090484619,
-0.3146340847015381,
-0.030196741223335266,
-0.004393602721393108,
-0.42555463314056396,
-0.41636449098587036,
-0.5396612882614136,
0.6708654165267944,
-0.4341374933719635,
-0.029035421088337898,
0.13393881916999817,
0.060396336019039154,
0.2982521653175354,
0.4734381139278412,
-0.7842124700546265,
0.25658082962036133,
0.7273746728897095,
0.6305743455886841,
-0.09634334594011307,
-0.560377836227417,
-0.4181472063064575,
-0.04616937041282654,
-0.41571953892707825,
0.7294015884399414,
-0.7755601406097412,
-0.31825152039527893,
0.23491352796554565,
0.07791956514120102,
-0.25038009881973267,
-0.6464908123016357,
0.21159029006958008,
-0.4189773201942444,
0.24563480913639069,
-0.5361036658287048,
-0.5758414268493652,
-0.6054945588111877,
0.15031765401363373,
-0.6290957927703857,
0.9206361770629883,
0.12165788561105728,
-0.5686116218566895,
0.18117360770702362,
-0.5891593098640442,
-0.5891527533531189,
0.03805581480264664,
-0.18135100603103638,
-0.07638546824455261,
0.37649431824684143,
-0.16073845326900482,
0.5047681927680969,
-0.5103804469108582,
0.13859280943870544,
-0.41140320897102356,
-0.5079951286315918,
0.37990447878837585,
-0.3681129515171051,
0.7554709315299988,
0.2374231070280075,
-0.4135575294494629,
0.11028767377138138,
-0.8517259955406189,
-0.23520587384700775,
0.340854674577713,
-0.3339466452598572,
-0.2947133779525757,
0.03257593885064125,
-0.6933711171150208,
0.22138534486293793,
-0.03169872611761093,
-0.21484452486038208,
0.5758997201919556,
-0.2500969171524048,
0.5987905263900757,
0.6387507915496826,
0.033052291721105576,
0.6150102615356445,
-0.317297101020813,
0.4825129508972168,
-0.043773043900728226,
-0.2690200209617615,
-0.606890857219696,
-0.35520124435424805,
-0.9669898748397827,
-0.17140662670135498,
0.01614324003458023,
0.6226107478141785,
-0.7073479890823364,
0.06710763275623322,
-0.0724555253982544,
-0.2628614604473114,
-0.3081330955028534,
0.1859622299671173,
0.4541437029838562,
0.4309109151363373,
0.3447718918323517,
0.23246216773986816,
-0.3957459032535553,
-0.7031370401382446,
-0.0681573897600174,
-0.21388903260231018,
0.06835378706455231,
-0.02855728380382061,
0.8171094655990601,
-0.1484004706144333,
0.5759734511375427,
-0.24752502143383026,
0.05398635193705559,
-0.6100106835365295,
0.16047674417495728,
0.2507524788379669,
0.18409612774848938,
0.24645058810710907,
-0.3172672688961029,
-0.25160884857177734,
-0.02534578926861286,
-0.8613419532775879,
-0.007936944253742695,
-0.3827672600746155,
0.16481973230838776,
0.3764001429080963,
0.4624269902706146,
-0.7424265146255493,
0.30544155836105347,
0.15874691307544708,
0.0890643373131752,
0.62620609998703,
-0.2254176139831543,
-0.10188587754964828,
-0.6340574622154236,
-0.1322113275527954,
-0.10326115787029266,
-0.0610453262925148,
-0.5805572867393494,
0.15948249399662018,
0.03922683745622635,
0.1300467699766159,
-0.32937392592430115,
0.49385327100753784,
-0.7118546366691589,
-0.010245476849377155,
-0.5052744150161743,
0.19601990282535553,
0.048132818192243576,
0.48172035813331604,
0.06132202968001366,
0.36669015884399414,
0.820207417011261,
-0.9482150673866272,
0.5298392176628113,
-0.04245205223560333,
-0.3922407925128937,
0.19364094734191895,
-0.6434563994407654,
0.2865959405899048,
-0.4325551986694336,
0.2080741971731186,
-0.9515926837921143,
-0.31711727380752563,
0.3187970817089081,
-0.21213780343532562,
0.28944316506385803,
-0.06381675601005554,
-0.4815064072608948,
-0.4451470971107483,
-0.11536045372486115,
0.24949122965335846,
0.6699981093406677,
-0.4934581220149994,
0.23787152767181396,
-0.0861719474196434,
-0.1477201282978058,
-0.6172726154327393,
-0.7032386064529419,
-0.23683351278305054,
-0.24472394585609436,
-0.2720831036567688,
-0.10875692218542099,
0.1300276517868042,
-0.6627009510993958,
0.05703854188323021,
-0.033837515860795975,
-0.10693543404340744,
0.2561783492565155,
0.3427980840206146,
0.3645188510417938,
-0.23386916518211365,
0.5204830765724182,
-0.012532636523246765,
0.04477252811193466,
0.0087838564068079,
-0.28366613388061523,
0.4893166720867157,
0.05655801296234131,
-0.8349651098251343,
-0.32524457573890686,
0.45718345046043396,
0.48426640033721924,
-0.1605987548828125,
0.7892612218856812,
0.11464447528123856,
-0.4328013062477112,
-0.38078269362449646,
-0.5666879415512085,
-0.3947014808654785,
-0.36226770281791687,
0.0680227056145668,
-0.586277961730957,
-0.9061441421508789,
0.4605981111526489,
0.10358832031488419,
0.1338522583246231,
0.4539816081523895,
0.6654360890388489,
-0.12250512093305588,
0.8385622501373291,
0.381841242313385,
0.06910021603107452,
0.2310316562652588,
-0.3106062710285187,
0.2343689203262329,
-0.5291396379470825,
-0.2801811993122101,
-0.6097415089607239,
-0.31592050194740295,
-0.4142858386039734,
-0.3003421127796173,
0.09453702718019485,
0.47208088636398315,
-0.42356497049331665,
0.18204498291015625,
-0.28074946999549866,
0.6984970569610596,
0.665742039680481,
-0.22905080020427704,
0.36733800172805786,
-0.023136883974075317,
-0.25054946541786194,
0.3184642791748047,
-0.6770545244216919,
-0.7061680555343628,
0.9250072836875916,
0.29949429631233215,
1.09353506565094,
-0.06970712542533875,
0.8836106657981873,
0.16606305539608002,
0.15001438558101654,
-1.0447324514389038,
0.47510185837745667,
0.15439139306545258,
-0.5111725330352783,
-0.10291723161935806,
-0.29349586367607117,
-0.986373245716095,
0.2307676076889038,
-0.10773903131484985,
-0.8161553144454956,
-0.009677856229245663,
0.11979629099369049,
-0.3245895802974701,
0.28247150778770447,
-0.6289653778076172,
0.7015577554702759,
-0.19064368307590485,
-0.3252656161785126,
-0.18400150537490845,
-0.5727667212486267,
0.4987366199493408,
0.11316430568695068,
0.26567476987838745,
-0.13296882808208466,
0.19634677469730377,
0.32308799028396606,
-0.0584661066532135,
1.013435959815979,
-0.08865628391504288,
-0.2524643838405609,
0.6908877491950989,
0.3902718722820282,
0.6395350694656372,
-0.2166537642478943,
0.12948665022850037,
-0.12751159071922302,
-0.025379518046975136,
-0.2646676301956177,
-0.6116459965705872,
0.6235430240631104,
-0.5048526525497437,
-0.7862204313278198,
-0.41974344849586487,
-0.35121312737464905,
-0.022661756724119186,
-0.016085458919405937,
0.38133513927459717,
0.3975372910499573,
-0.03359466791152954,
0.02078150399029255,
0.5997849702835083,
-0.240321084856987,
0.49183419346809387,
0.4412105977535248,
-0.15044665336608887,
0.0034354235976934433,
0.6665389537811279,
0.01751464046537876,
0.4654698967933655,
0.4764201045036316,
0.14152516424655914,
-0.3529481887817383,
-0.584019124507904,
-0.2001119703054428,
0.5840908885002136,
-1.0468952655792236,
-0.1068248599767685,
-0.4965483546257019,
-0.0682491585612297,
-0.29324769973754883,
-0.13360151648521423,
-0.08449554443359375,
-0.43670111894607544,
-0.35562196373939514,
-0.27170997858047485,
0.09679564088582993,
1.241036295890808,
-0.05957919359207153,
0.13775242865085602,
-0.9181674122810364,
0.2389007806777954,
0.3985641896724701,
-0.015234533697366714,
0.290528267621994,
-0.5873491168022156,
-0.1974356472492218,
0.16336289048194885,
-0.5437313914299011,
-1.1514389514923096,
0.11954224109649658,
0.230332612991333,
0.6504486203193665,
0.5109832286834717,
0.061506230384111404,
0.5147527456283569,
-0.7663611769676208,
0.7981863021850586,
0.18449439108371735,
-0.8103869557380676,
0.5028015375137329,
-0.1000702753663063,
0.4170657694339752,
0.3031414747238159,
0.6736600399017334,
-0.6056574583053589,
-0.36683666706085205,
-0.3940892219543457,
-0.4854709506034851,
0.5790045261383057,
-0.3116421699523926,
0.12056408077478409,
-0.43313878774642944,
0.3243151009082794,
0.6392726898193359,
0.031983163207769394,
-0.8910450339317322,
-0.23841993510723114,
0.1917087882757187,
-0.14568600058555603,
0.02157885767519474,
-0.3292995095252991,
-0.1973849982023239,
-0.2501397132873535,
0.5014157891273499,
-0.13804078102111816,
0.25120222568511963,
0.16598159074783325,
-0.46635568141937256,
-0.03572617098689079,
0.5480774641036987,
0.7899854779243469,
0.8718847632408142,
0.21133406460285187,
0.3134474456310272,
0.24015407264232635,
0.12907420098781586,
0.1908167004585266,
-0.22210153937339783,
-0.06427458673715591,
-0.025493396446108818,
0.8214452266693115,
1.1646428108215332,
0.28515440225601196,
-0.7169860005378723,
0.13264793157577515,
0.2995755970478058,
-0.4655557870864868,
-0.3967568874359131,
0.22250187397003174,
0.06089632213115692,
0.4217640459537506,
0.4436955749988556,
-0.32405075430870056,
0.058429814875125885,
-0.8291360139846802,
-0.022026032209396362,
0.5056684017181396,
-0.30558401346206665,
-0.533091127872467,
0.476752370595932,
0.04174712300300598,
-0.27570971846580505,
0.5606077909469604,
-0.35072970390319824,
-0.45599234104156494,
0.3940809965133667,
0.6304550170898438,
0.9916831851005554,
-0.0785919651389122,
0.34923967719078064,
0.43022578954696655,
0.27250441908836365,
-0.3384927213191986,
0.21135716140270233,
-0.2961971163749695,
-0.5970052480697632,
-0.6717224717140198,
-0.5674883723258972,
-0.38097909092903137,
0.37724652886390686,
-0.5288468599319458,
0.15770429372787476,
-0.3666970729827881,
0.3257604241371155,
0.07771774381399155,
-0.3440662920475006,
-0.5575560927391052,
-0.08553256094455719,
0.38876256346702576,
0.6901525855064392,
-0.836394727230072,
0.8320289254188538,
0.7664704918861389,
-0.46505245566368103,
-0.7257676124572754,
-0.04205917567014694,
0.23654529452323914,
-0.8046596646308899,
0.9974937438964844,
0.3673640787601471,
-0.11058119684457779,
-0.18355999886989594,
-0.6049732565879822,
-0.6758033037185669,
0.6776525974273682,
0.3574136197566986,
-0.6424774527549744,
-0.2700605094432831,
0.08616424351930618,
0.33876049518585205,
-0.5532830953598022,
0.1938273310661316,
0.5998716354370117,
0.26793134212493896,
0.2886083126068115,
-0.9728826284408569,
0.009075937792658806,
0.26207083463668823,
-0.2870310842990875,
0.30897125601768494,
-0.06281369179487228,
1.0911800861358643,
-0.6891540288925171,
-0.4547993242740631,
0.16323687136173248,
0.18150465190410614,
0.34658244252204895,
0.3310094475746155,
0.23101498186588287,
0.5582349300384521,
0.6877886652946472,
-0.19172720611095428,
1.1997177600860596,
0.1980925351381302,
0.31571972370147705,
1.1351224184036255,
-0.43706533312797546,
0.7984703779220581,
0.3392278552055359,
-0.27147695422172546,
0.6416305303573608,
0.659596860408783,
0.2162659913301468,
0.43608739972114563,
0.19383694231510162,
-0.3392364978790283,
-0.29929476976394653,
0.27002760767936707,
-0.3523670434951782,
0.4611178934574127,
0.37685856223106384,
-0.45594295859336853,
-0.35205504298210144,
0.25489237904548645,
0.06052964925765991,
-0.020806163549423218,
-0.4094446897506714,
1.0873298645019531,
0.1542723923921585,
-0.9981622695922852,
1.0844048261642456,
-0.13999107480049133,
0.41932058334350586,
-0.4424591362476349,
-0.2502661645412445,
-0.031649596989154816,
0.15331168472766876,
-0.12840089201927185,
-0.7789881825447083,
0.19697630405426025,
0.01554626040160656,
-0.0747881606221199,
0.0036004437133669853,
0.6317096948623657,
-0.43419331312179565,
-0.3314115107059479,
0.2710314095020294,
0.6296942830085754,
0.3485160768032074,
-0.039598386734724045,
-0.613645076751709,
-0.016419151797890663,
0.025857780128717422,
-0.23972241580486298,
0.1813056468963623,
0.5964639782905579,
-0.09123758226633072,
0.8084701299667358,
0.41732579469680786,
0.09951309114694595,
0.3455440104007721,
0.1646607518196106,
0.6782594323158264,
-0.8232249617576599,
-0.05127571523189545,
-1.1578433513641357,
0.47130316495895386,
0.28282269835472107,
-0.012944315560162067,
0.5774118900299072,
0.14069676399230957,
0.9586274027824402,
-0.3924682140350342,
0.9324244856834412,
-0.004307782743126154,
0.568442165851593,
-0.7101290225982666,
0.06440865993499756,
-0.5053377151489258,
0.26991748809814453,
0.019062785431742668,
-1.0900659561157227,
-0.13016237318515778,
0.7616657614707947,
-0.4319414496421814,
-0.01830526441335678,
1.0683300495147705,
0.43910032510757446,
0.12266132980585098,
0.13396508991718292,
0.3798939287662506,
0.11835678666830063,
0.04182437062263489,
0.693828284740448,
1.154663324356079,
-0.027650458738207817,
0.30705174803733826,
-0.07328968495130539,
-0.07613950222730637,
-0.2511052191257477,
-0.7121102809906006,
-0.9465972781181335,
-0.6624903678894043,
-0.3206656873226166,
-0.18332040309906006,
-0.034861549735069275,
1.1231331825256348,
0.2379717081785202,
-0.8331100344657898,
-0.2247799187898636,
-0.306170254945755,
0.6173669695854187,
-0.19960202276706696,
-0.1915854662656784,
0.11871196329593658,
-0.6718991994857788,
-0.8007909655570984,
0.32763999700546265,
0.35597938299179077,
0.06862929463386536,
-0.2541780173778534,
-0.14088550209999084,
-0.2901897430419922,
-0.012181582860648632,
0.6897148489952087,
0.674410879611969,
-1.0682532787322998,
-0.41695675253868103,
-0.02989906258881092,
0.0007293632952496409,
-0.03312531113624573,
0.9510982036590576,
-0.8317013382911682,
0.35746434330940247,
0.6329047083854675,
0.6575112342834473,
0.18496489524841309,
-0.3064487874507904,
0.23933769762516022,
-0.4750182628631592,
0.2622920870780945,
0.21210922300815582,
0.3465980589389801,
0.26135605573654175,
0.1005832776427269,
0.3303450345993042,
0.21529589593410492,
-0.6208723187446594,
-0.9006395936012268,
0.7282456755638123,
-0.6050772666931152,
-0.5639193058013916,
1.3247778415679932,
-0.16780225932598114,
-0.1563391536474228,
-0.19223177433013916,
-0.1589435636997223,
0.11624059826135635,
-0.10818669199943542,
0.6237696409225464,
0.9142014384269714,
-0.3219594359397888,
-0.25960013270378113,
-0.6660841107368469,
0.38754743337631226,
0.19015198945999146,
-0.571609377861023,
0.16041328012943268,
0.6742597222328186,
0.23967216908931732,
0.08088048547506332,
0.3689001798629761,
0.025481324642896652,
0.27317002415657043,
-0.14742493629455566,
-0.14244022965431213,
0.0062525151297450066,
-0.5187190175056458,
-0.45494821667671204,
0.07623805105686188,
0.39549577236175537,
-0.16044051945209503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03027v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03027v2
|
JailBreakV-28K: A Benchmark for Assessing the Robustness of MultiModal Large Language Models against Jailbreak Attacks
| 2024-04-03T19:23:18 | 2024-04-18T17:11:53 |
Weidi Luo, Siyuan Ma, Xiaogeng Liu, Xiaoyu Guo, Chaowei Xiao
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid advancements in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs),
securing these models against malicious inputs while aligning them with human
values has emerged as a critical challenge. In this paper, we investigate an
important and unexplored question of whether techniques that successfully
jailbreak Large Language Models (LLMs) can be equally effective in jailbreaking
MLLMs. To explore this issue, we introduce JailBreakV-28K, a pioneering
benchmark designed to assess the transferability of LLM jailbreak techniques to
MLLMs, thereby evaluating the robustness of MLLMs against diverse jailbreak
attacks. Utilizing a dataset of 2, 000 malicious queries that is also proposed
in this paper, we generate 20, 000 text-based jailbreak prompts using advanced
jailbreak attacks on LLMs, alongside 8, 000 image-based jailbreak inputs from
recent MLLMs jailbreak attacks, our comprehensive dataset includes 28, 000 test
cases across a spectrum of adversarial scenarios. Our evaluation of 10
open-source MLLMs reveals a notably high Attack Success Rate (ASR) for attacks
transferred from LLMs, highlighting a critical vulnerability in MLLMs that
stems from their text-processing capabilities. Our findings underscore the
urgent need for future research to address alignment vulnerabilities in MLLMs
from both textual and visual inputs.
|
[
-0.3436037003993988,
-0.7396157383918762,
0.4093948006629944,
0.2660661041736603,
-0.12421504408121109,
0.2656731903553009,
-0.3229146897792816,
-0.3513733744621277,
-0.20609770715236664,
0.617824137210846,
-0.38935330510139465,
-0.49117767810821533,
-0.7262619733810425,
0.03685783967375755,
-0.45827430486679077,
0.8242607712745667,
-0.0053421068005263805,
-0.0038682292215526104,
-0.08835133910179138,
-0.39744508266448975,
-0.6183918714523315,
-0.5429784059524536,
-0.20021504163742065,
0.12266501039266586,
0.5561211109161377,
0.03998513147234917,
0.589626669883728,
0.5736239552497864,
0.7945681810379028,
0.27837228775024414,
-0.11243563145399094,
0.07824420183897018,
-0.4258401691913605,
0.28687670826911926,
-0.07730719447135925,
-0.323693186044693,
-0.189230814576149,
-0.10817848891019821,
0.308908075094223,
0.058746349066495895,
-0.17653320729732513,
0.26547011733055115,
-0.09176100790500641,
0.8517273664474487,
-1.0011651515960693,
-0.2951347529888153,
-1.004159688949585,
-0.21880389750003815,
-0.6047429442405701,
0.34295591711997986,
-0.7008980512619019,
-0.2676236629486084,
-0.30520424246788025,
-0.13408136367797852,
-0.1578010767698288,
-0.0375017449259758,
0.7381234169006348,
0.13611972332000732,
-0.3505382239818573,
-0.1528162807226181,
-0.2847278118133545,
0.5548627972602844,
-0.9410090446472168,
0.3338088393211365,
0.3270856440067291,
0.5458993315696716,
-0.27184560894966125,
-0.40653666853904724,
-0.37960195541381836,
-0.5009626746177673,
0.26165369153022766,
-0.2450028508901596,
-0.1624756157398224,
-0.11051026731729507,
0.37797975540161133,
0.02515203133225441,
-0.602645754814148,
0.3728731870651245,
-0.4174565076828003,
-0.24191980063915253,
0.5316698551177979,
0.19724813103675842,
0.5205588340759277,
-0.14782992005348206,
-0.4465256631374359,
-0.1514434814453125,
-0.9148730635643005,
0.14723533391952515,
0.6562093496322632,
0.3449397683143616,
-0.20365828275680542,
0.8102731704711914,
0.16184896230697632,
1.0109306573867798,
-0.3050084114074707,
-0.2560141086578369,
0.15996555984020233,
-0.5355256199836731,
-0.10679586976766586,
-0.1171129047870636,
1.1483840942382812,
0.716880738735199,
0.3877054452896118,
-0.31348270177841187,
-0.01985757052898407,
0.00990208238363266,
0.5331552028656006,
-0.8932931423187256,
-0.1044471338391304,
0.1700502187013626,
-0.2849537134170532,
-0.5409454107284546,
-0.017186379060149193,
-0.9541217684745789,
-1.0950701236724854,
0.3904043734073639,
0.19290079176425934,
-0.41166698932647705,
0.04156959801912308,
-0.19734032452106476,
-0.10690932720899582,
0.26327165961265564,
0.24324946105480194,
-0.9318679571151733,
0.18288986384868622,
0.5640615820884705,
0.792349636554718,
-0.25203821063041687,
-0.35128289461135864,
-0.5445854663848877,
-0.041167572140693665,
-0.257625550031662,
0.5507399439811707,
-0.24803392589092255,
-0.18228194117546082,
-0.010747874155640602,
-0.10878829658031464,
-0.18245524168014526,
-0.5611333250999451,
0.46086573600769043,
-0.5310359001159668,
-0.4623126983642578,
-0.06294321268796921,
-0.3745616674423218,
0.20910824835300446,
0.5802851319313049,
-0.8169885277748108,
0.6974984407424927,
-0.20487840473651886,
-0.7857593894004822,
0.2805973291397095,
-0.25852635502815247,
-0.3351547122001648,
-0.3036184012889862,
-0.08939595520496368,
-0.7086238861083984,
-0.08160810172557831,
0.41530048847198486,
0.41334185004234314,
-0.23766782879829407,
0.36539560556411743,
-0.8386626243591309,
-0.13248586654663086,
0.6938883662223816,
-0.6223142743110657,
0.6835092306137085,
0.4026080369949341,
-0.30781570076942444,
-0.08434254676103592,
-0.7797061204910278,
-0.14553096890449524,
0.29343438148498535,
-0.30767491459846497,
-0.33791735768318176,
0.08294901251792908,
0.10312923043966293,
0.1992599219083786,
0.30417880415916443,
-0.8120688796043396,
0.5237334966659546,
-0.25449836254119873,
0.6108081340789795,
0.607763946056366,
-0.30024340748786926,
0.15904362499713898,
-0.12318900227546692,
0.3227997422218323,
-0.18958278000354767,
0.20157591998577118,
-0.31884363293647766,
-0.37150299549102783,
-0.21397267282009125,
-0.4185638427734375,
0.2062837779521942,
0.739389955997467,
-0.3784802258014679,
0.14407658576965332,
0.01097626518458128,
-0.7743714451789856,
-0.5914976000785828,
0.4842675030231476,
0.5326902866363525,
0.44734349846839905,
0.3652123808860779,
-0.0716601088643074,
-0.5825079679489136,
-0.9630557298660278,
-0.7981546521186829,
-0.15730080008506775,
0.23026056587696075,
0.19223950803279877,
0.46578025817871094,
-0.17217658460140228,
0.5261014103889465,
-0.2309161275625229,
-0.040793996304273605,
-0.2594814598560333,
-0.0903649851679802,
0.10944297909736633,
0.3593809902667999,
0.6542148590087891,
-0.5206458568572998,
-0.4339517056941986,
-0.06440404802560806,
-0.8551000952720642,
-0.10943490266799927,
-0.019875269383192062,
0.2931022047996521,
-0.03408129885792732,
0.6731340885162354,
-0.6808993220329285,
0.4770355224609375,
0.682181715965271,
-0.5394463539123535,
0.7395029664039612,
-0.06369419395923615,
0.26392704248428345,
-1.0354552268981934,
0.005442920606583357,
0.04493403062224388,
-0.34205737709999084,
-0.5814171433448792,
0.2907847762107849,
0.4944881200790405,
-0.08746842294931412,
-0.6944454312324524,
0.38443341851234436,
-0.29900357127189636,
0.050146155059337616,
-0.10984797030687332,
0.17355366051197052,
-0.055761270225048065,
0.037553995847702026,
-0.6801636219024658,
0.8333924412727356,
0.28888100385665894,
0.1471707969903946,
0.5898694396018982,
0.14601613581180573,
-0.6148827075958252,
0.4263272285461426,
-0.5029345154762268,
0.21596376597881317,
-0.0033228485845029354,
0.058585260063409805,
-1.0148204565048218,
-0.011577103286981583,
-0.022140922024846077,
-0.4811224639415741,
0.31795093417167664,
-0.3330361247062683,
-0.5116842985153198,
-0.14674896001815796,
-0.4564962685108185,
0.17110443115234375,
0.25834569334983826,
-0.3465690314769745,
0.2871898114681244,
0.3049282729625702,
-0.11058765649795532,
-0.972243070602417,
-0.6146543622016907,
0.554800271987915,
-0.5008751153945923,
-0.8019788265228271,
0.02374555729329586,
0.027404477819800377,
-0.524256706237793,
-0.14424245059490204,
-0.0011358284391462803,
0.10782011598348618,
0.4921816885471344,
0.3591417968273163,
0.5804040431976318,
-0.10746676474809647,
-0.39785662293434143,
-0.36280232667922974,
0.23956798017024994,
0.11395350843667984,
-0.03577854111790657,
0.47548040747642517,
-0.2758457064628601,
-0.41186192631721497,
-0.25733500719070435,
0.030319124460220337,
1.1282116174697876,
-0.30439645051956177,
1.0628571510314941,
0.43479207158088684,
-0.16933421790599823,
0.040469326078891754,
-0.7136750221252441,
0.2562430202960968,
-0.4265061914920807,
0.5123565793037415,
-0.4381815791130066,
-0.9543756246566772,
0.5862050652503967,
0.08953320980072021,
0.15083658695220947,
0.2610645890235901,
0.74464350938797,
-0.16084948182106018,
0.9575560688972473,
0.3575001060962677,
-0.39329683780670166,
0.46274664998054504,
0.1975032091140747,
0.04170696437358856,
-0.8652974963188171,
-0.2596987187862396,
-0.599418580532074,
-0.16772498190402985,
-0.4677620530128479,
-0.21812601387500763,
-0.12942619621753693,
0.3070296049118042,
-0.28337541222572327,
0.6592687368392944,
-0.25120994448661804,
0.41816574335098267,
0.05370831489562988,
0.015808409079909325,
0.19134008884429932,
-0.34019923210144043,
-0.3090437650680542,
-0.01702939160168171,
-0.14659135043621063,
-0.4758325517177582,
1.4100441932678223,
0.4193614423274994,
0.996496856212616,
0.349168062210083,
0.520664632320404,
0.4237106442451477,
0.459076851606369,
-0.46669837832450867,
0.3859997093677521,
-0.4039255380630493,
-0.6603350043296814,
-0.1707998663187027,
-0.28557291626930237,
-0.8656866550445557,
0.33185842633247375,
-0.27949345111846924,
-1.3473705053329468,
-0.06047258526086807,
0.0797729343175888,
-0.2890844941139221,
0.46318289637565613,
-0.7371612787246704,
1.2101424932479858,
-0.4755404591560364,
-0.40102267265319824,
0.05597769096493721,
-0.7410213351249695,
0.6697542667388916,
-0.32091477513313293,
0.6014138460159302,
-0.475498765707016,
0.2487337738275528,
0.6712683439254761,
-0.5950462222099304,
0.6549225449562073,
-0.2563098669052124,
-0.003383276518434286,
0.01567118801176548,
0.21193604171276093,
0.7284619808197021,
0.09441875666379929,
0.09282001107931137,
-0.06893172860145569,
0.010207551531493664,
-0.2125200629234314,
-0.649023711681366,
0.7607234716415405,
-0.7786163091659546,
-0.6061543822288513,
-0.10646961629390717,
-0.5923057794570923,
-0.22491784393787384,
0.13473230600357056,
0.1770823895931244,
0.354371041059494,
-0.1580733060836792,
0.3355894088745117,
0.5687705278396606,
-0.26841989159584045,
0.3797611892223358,
0.41137272119522095,
-0.4649054706096649,
-0.6841083765029907,
0.8439933657646179,
-0.011858244426548481,
0.43661558628082275,
0.20460443198680878,
0.017987718805670738,
-0.10480646044015884,
-0.8836044073104858,
-0.7163867354393005,
-0.034722089767456055,
-0.6903570294380188,
-0.36328384280204773,
-0.4712975323200226,
-0.2698545455932617,
-0.4451363980770111,
-0.22641468048095703,
-0.7269683480262756,
-0.10639573633670807,
0.05438500642776489,
-0.031148282811045647,
0.38088059425354004,
0.41889166831970215,
0.23697593808174133,
0.11449088901281357,
-0.9732386469841003,
0.49139028787612915,
0.227476105093956,
0.09598101675510406,
-0.26121610403060913,
-0.45079895853996277,
-0.0982484295964241,
-0.061944518238306046,
-0.19981807470321655,
-1.130470871925354,
0.3128955662250519,
0.013014082796871662,
0.53066486120224,
0.356365829706192,
-0.012735671363770962,
0.7292845845222473,
-0.6608903408050537,
0.7156393527984619,
0.3578067123889923,
-0.7602554559707642,
0.5271551609039307,
-0.3893526494503021,
0.23417051136493683,
0.9322581887245178,
-0.08854836225509644,
-0.4801305830478668,
-0.6576211452484131,
-0.2970282733440399,
-0.8573995232582092,
0.2515079975128174,
0.2313428819179535,
0.08230341970920563,
0.2681015133857727,
0.18518202006816864,
0.09499393403530121,
0.16376975178718567,
-0.7647232413291931,
-0.27148211002349854,
-0.25249722599983215,
-0.3336504399776459,
-0.07531475275754929,
-0.052951786667108536,
-0.16169524192810059,
-0.1212615817785263,
0.18324244022369385,
0.13112570345401764,
-0.17531874775886536,
-0.11962733417749405,
-0.4380233883857727,
0.314627081155777,
0.5373940467834473,
0.7387110590934753,
0.5720897316932678,
-0.368712842464447,
0.2880170941352844,
0.046712201088666916,
-0.8175671100616455,
0.42498236894607544,
0.3238605856895447,
-0.05886825919151306,
-0.3900011479854584,
0.34794479608535767,
0.8499050736427307,
-0.12428130954504013,
-1.0368207693099976,
0.7299295663833618,
-0.3549213409423828,
0.02889116294682026,
0.004991831257939339,
-0.04252665862441063,
0.13920988142490387,
0.38925594091415405,
0.19337032735347748,
0.2219342589378357,
-0.2180691659450531,
-0.4497585594654083,
0.2640288174152374,
0.5958004593849182,
-0.48061656951904297,
-0.15788903832435608,
0.7646660804748535,
-0.05549994483590126,
-0.3917771875858307,
0.8005868792533875,
0.19528289139270782,
-0.3668743073940277,
0.6738174557685852,
0.6005411744117737,
0.7781955599784851,
-0.11371894180774689,
-0.04266832396388054,
0.05656299740076065,
0.8305333256721497,
0.004931147675961256,
-0.0984792560338974,
0.05178201571106911,
-0.8594963550567627,
-0.4882560968399048,
-0.6097891330718994,
-0.30360147356987,
0.25921592116355896,
-0.6382953524589539,
0.26002800464630127,
-0.44747593998908997,
-0.2260422557592392,
0.07710056006908417,
-0.48266640305519104,
-0.43069541454315186,
0.02040235511958599,
0.44792166352272034,
0.9879615306854248,
-0.7950464487075806,
0.9703286290168762,
0.5382538437843323,
0.013032389804720879,
-0.6026795506477356,
-0.33671286702156067,
0.3696611821651459,
-0.8292562961578369,
0.473836749792099,
0.46409109234809875,
0.16783808171749115,
-0.4277028739452362,
-0.6292404532432556,
-0.74945068359375,
0.8179970979690552,
0.5613114833831787,
-0.8195976614952087,
0.1509678065776825,
0.09420700371265411,
0.1833944320678711,
-0.12487352639436722,
-0.04812454804778099,
0.7891573309898376,
0.43854981660842896,
-0.13912060856819153,
-0.9734111428260803,
0.16590090095996857,
-0.4556218385696411,
-0.18791978061199188,
0.4394018352031708,
-0.40903550386428833,
0.7020899057388306,
-0.45481449365615845,
0.21599258482456207,
0.29262498021125793,
0.3445087671279907,
0.7006925344467163,
0.2458227574825287,
0.4101850688457489,
0.9340041875839233,
0.45834487676620483,
-0.06002248451113701,
0.8527669310569763,
-0.19073495268821716,
0.2583697438240051,
1.0485281944274902,
-0.28665608167648315,
0.9392136335372925,
0.6715720891952515,
-0.2440677285194397,
0.3198304772377014,
0.316283255815506,
-0.4569135010242462,
0.7802786827087402,
0.3783950209617615,
-0.07495511323213577,
0.014803917147219181,
0.3124207854270935,
-0.26417669653892517,
0.4078654944896698,
0.3906998336315155,
-0.27464672923088074,
-0.23648780584335327,
0.4669388234615326,
0.4658397436141968,
0.0042124115861952305,
-0.25287774205207825,
0.7692409157752991,
0.09278983622789383,
-0.5881473422050476,
0.5945162177085876,
0.11277639120817184,
0.6244862675666809,
-0.647017776966095,
0.2729571461677551,
-0.010976449586451054,
0.2600483000278473,
-0.1318916380405426,
-0.8541087508201599,
0.22430597245693207,
0.46600469946861267,
0.06373895704746246,
-0.025287799537181854,
0.8159505724906921,
-0.03774246573448181,
-0.2781118154525757,
0.27861493825912476,
0.2054312378168106,
-0.02328638732433319,
-0.1166796013712883,
-0.6015470027923584,
0.49808812141418457,
-0.013960548676550388,
-0.27508512139320374,
0.7636674046516418,
-0.04543759301304817,
0.09257806837558746,
0.7613393068313599,
0.6909772753715515,
0.20511816442012787,
0.3843761384487152,
-0.06563298404216766,
0.9110937118530273,
-0.6819499135017395,
0.011969948187470436,
-1.4850376844406128,
0.6901882290840149,
-0.1824531853199005,
-0.2943327724933624,
1.028734803199768,
0.44433361291885376,
0.6491401195526123,
0.17358627915382385,
0.9263057708740234,
-0.1361905038356781,
-0.04503621533513069,
-0.5877524018287659,
0.9496981501579285,
-0.24350617825984955,
0.4655643105506897,
-0.4829816222190857,
-0.60759437084198,
-0.27363651990890503,
0.23984207212924957,
-0.36748841404914856,
-0.40884119272232056,
0.5165414214134216,
0.6891674995422363,
0.35028862953186035,
-0.23453496396541595,
0.37076079845428467,
0.2504776120185852,
0.4427483379840851,
0.48776349425315857,
1.0946300029754639,
-0.29050877690315247,
0.7502989768981934,
-0.08314907550811768,
-0.1294676810503006,
-0.04031528905034065,
-0.8427557349205017,
-1.0695658922195435,
-0.22982126474380493,
-0.08529730886220932,
-0.5503659844398499,
0.3561003506183624,
0.5704541802406311,
0.3669971227645874,
-0.6978675127029419,
-0.2212507426738739,
0.007554878946393728,
0.06447260826826096,
-0.0925462618470192,
-0.15436166524887085,
0.17238235473632812,
-0.25673648715019226,
-0.21672986447811127,
0.6863482594490051,
0.4080238938331604,
-0.21721410751342773,
-0.2993057072162628,
0.18138429522514343,
-0.2032037377357483,
-0.04616973549127579,
0.3906095325946808,
0.31323346495628357,
-0.6741792559623718,
-0.11952391266822815,
0.018573077395558357,
-0.40628406405448914,
0.19464057683944702,
0.7449847459793091,
-0.5683704018592834,
0.614848792552948,
0.2797079086303711,
0.8984519839286804,
0.4391893446445465,
0.018125008791685104,
0.48383593559265137,
-0.6054501533508301,
0.09162144362926483,
0.05120294541120529,
0.5093019008636475,
0.42691442370414734,
-0.16293452680110931,
0.0008775534224696457,
0.14725540578365326,
-0.5385589003562927,
-1.050606369972229,
0.15769703686237335,
-0.8255317807197571,
-0.4495798349380493,
1.0339248180389404,
-0.3590061664581299,
-0.3478155732154846,
-0.1613682359457016,
-0.1282350867986679,
-0.004976755473762751,
-0.2419510930776596,
0.6340819597244263,
0.8431991338729858,
0.18152263760566711,
-0.36885780096054077,
-0.8125312328338623,
0.21135923266410828,
0.017421865835785866,
-0.8381657004356384,
0.25877416133880615,
0.19934380054473877,
0.39145705103874207,
0.05603203922510147,
0.16520796716213226,
-0.4208657145500183,
0.19304294884204865,
-0.030718781054019928,
0.018929891288280487,
-0.23023007810115814,
-0.1568612903356552,
-0.2691812515258789,
0.4900093674659729,
0.1893996149301529,
-0.06066237390041351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03022v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03022v2
|
BCAmirs at SemEval-2024 Task 4: Beyond Words: A Multimodal and Multilingual Exploration of Persuasion in Memes
| 2024-04-03T19:17:43 | 2024-06-11T19:34:19 |
Amirhossein Abaskohi, Amirhossein Dabiriaghdam, Lele Wang, Giuseppe Carenini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
Memes, combining text and images, frequently use metaphors to convey
persuasive messages, shaping public opinion. Motivated by this, our team
engaged in SemEval-2024 Task 4, a hierarchical multi-label classification task
designed to identify rhetorical and psychological persuasion techniques
embedded within memes. To tackle this problem, we introduced a caption
generation step to assess the modality gap and the impact of additional
semantic information from images, which improved our result. Our best model
utilizes GPT-4 generated captions alongside meme text to fine-tune RoBERTa as
the text encoder and CLIP as the image encoder. It outperforms the baseline by
a large margin in all 12 subtasks. In particular, it ranked in top-3 across all
languages in Subtask 2a, and top-4 in Subtask 2b, demonstrating quantitatively
strong performance. The improvement achieved by the introduced intermediate
step is likely attributable to the metaphorical essence of images that
challenges visual encoders. This highlights the potential for improving
abstract visual semantics encoding.
|
[
-0.652401864528656,
-0.4721068739891052,
0.46436387300491333,
0.27024567127227783,
-0.633354663848877,
0.23090124130249023,
-0.03343837708234787,
-0.2728842496871948,
0.04665594920516014,
0.25907033681869507,
-0.6527186632156372,
-0.45350539684295654,
-0.8837014436721802,
0.5014757513999939,
0.12976737320423126,
1.03059983253479,
-0.1295439600944519,
0.10142052918672562,
-0.41680896282196045,
-0.13050466775894165,
-0.7325252890586853,
-0.663138210773468,
-0.5740801692008972,
-0.23112893104553223,
0.8650689721107483,
0.43897485733032227,
0.4203609228134155,
0.16500797867774963,
0.3588644862174988,
0.3005630075931549,
0.2723456621170044,
0.169367253780365,
-0.20325471460819244,
0.012619541957974434,
-0.6477150321006775,
-0.2946094572544098,
-0.12341182678937912,
0.28639164566993713,
0.3344017565250397,
0.11300003528594971,
0.10321830213069916,
-0.09065781533718109,
0.02421557530760765,
0.2176470309495926,
-0.5775244235992432,
0.3262846767902374,
-0.6953498721122742,
0.044684939086437225,
-0.44923701882362366,
-0.800304114818573,
-0.3121985197067261,
-0.0721568837761879,
0.059880852699279785,
-0.15369820594787598,
0.10640336573123932,
0.2167140245437622,
1.2026010751724243,
0.11429153382778168,
-0.7886120080947876,
-0.36953261494636536,
-0.10913792997598648,
1.02454674243927,
-0.6706556677818298,
0.3276240825653076,
0.23482318222522736,
0.1954725980758667,
-0.1385011225938797,
-0.9312708973884583,
-0.6782504916191101,
0.23709213733673096,
0.22168226540088654,
0.33326661586761475,
-0.6711273789405823,
0.08332154899835587,
0.25330251455307007,
0.04536708444356918,
-0.3842305541038513,
-0.06018234044313431,
-0.6651322841644287,
-0.538572371006012,
0.19650447368621826,
0.0012441674480214715,
0.48594874143600464,
-0.47910767793655396,
-0.5259978771209717,
-0.2911602854728699,
-0.7250844836235046,
0.00292043574154377,
0.21520239114761353,
-0.16754426062107086,
-0.05737169459462166,
0.6273991465568542,
-0.010491474531590939,
0.46226826310157776,
-0.0318710133433342,
-0.0012722888495773077,
0.276522696018219,
-0.5690368413925171,
-0.020673196762800217,
0.029178114607930183,
0.7069944143295288,
0.5307790637016296,
-0.15310661494731903,
0.20373155176639557,
-0.06417230516672134,
0.488561749458313,
0.19280342757701874,
-0.9798403382301331,
-0.4521208107471466,
-0.07675933092832565,
-0.31393471360206604,
-0.14821738004684448,
-0.10909787565469742,
-0.897861123085022,
-0.2943040430545807,
-0.2841964364051819,
0.8166353106498718,
-0.481801301240921,
0.057128582149744034,
-0.0290510356426239,
-0.3316488265991211,
0.4009126126766205,
0.4488567113876343,
-0.7240874767303467,
-0.0771794468164444,
0.4760088622570038,
0.7829710841178894,
-0.010265653021633625,
-0.11334100365638733,
-0.48009127378463745,
0.3759137690067291,
-0.32195985317230225,
1.144262433052063,
-0.8020599484443665,
-0.0994904413819313,
-0.29501762986183167,
0.20396173000335693,
-0.16064289212226868,
-0.26620614528656006,
0.7653833031654358,
-0.4670714735984802,
0.23506012558937073,
-0.6560372710227966,
-0.36036112904548645,
-0.4955099821090698,
0.6337379217147827,
-0.6648879051208496,
0.28848332166671753,
-0.15882208943367004,
-0.7447428703308105,
0.38150453567504883,
-0.8533046841621399,
-0.3086411654949188,
0.041431743651628494,
-0.668451189994812,
-0.2547997236251831,
0.08244714140892029,
0.39303919672966003,
0.7256497740745544,
-0.4689004421234131,
-0.05486077442765236,
0.049368105828762054,
-0.07800973206758499,
0.5292582511901855,
-0.6349692940711975,
0.23123499751091003,
0.3703685402870178,
-0.5642396211624146,
0.14638687670230865,
-0.2729225754737854,
0.006511520128697157,
0.014189830981194973,
-0.35285913944244385,
-0.4239484667778015,
-0.08732723444700241,
-0.0638856589794159,
0.5311411023139954,
0.3118134140968323,
-0.6737613081932068,
-0.0461726076900959,
-0.06685444712638855,
0.7819762229919434,
0.823826789855957,
0.29006773233413696,
0.2564293444156647,
-0.19829653203487396,
0.6511849164962769,
0.2385835498571396,
-0.06972243636846542,
-0.5176102519035339,
-0.599353015422821,
-0.5585598349571228,
-0.49403950572013855,
0.3726162016391754,
0.16906017065048218,
-1.0191681385040283,
-0.09430073946714401,
-0.37302857637405396,
-0.29462072253227234,
-0.28653261065483093,
-0.01703605055809021,
0.3169747591018677,
0.3055225908756256,
0.3826287090778351,
-0.548269510269165,
-0.551144003868103,
-1.1465145349502563,
0.00043838980491273105,
0.005331411026418209,
0.18519580364227295,
0.13916729390621185,
0.713016927242279,
-0.4716123342514038,
0.30960792303085327,
-0.291248619556427,
-0.15793786942958832,
-0.2367725521326065,
0.740911602973938,
-0.020479300990700722,
0.5448482036590576,
0.4998460114002228,
-0.8440746665000916,
-0.14148637652397156,
0.006943293381482363,
-0.52705317735672,
-0.2328309565782547,
-0.28408101201057434,
-0.21230582892894745,
0.2718927562236786,
0.4820226728916168,
-0.470073938369751,
0.4141944348812103,
0.6774692535400391,
-0.4358792006969452,
0.6194514036178589,
0.0376921109855175,
0.874826967716217,
-1.1137508153915405,
-0.3590333163738251,
-0.09573550522327423,
-0.025087103247642517,
-0.3620433211326599,
-0.19558928906917572,
0.09895236045122147,
-0.18380920588970184,
-0.3079853951931,
0.29522672295570374,
-0.6775359511375427,
0.22260567545890808,
-0.25568023324012756,
-0.21929512917995453,
0.30953267216682434,
0.35224151611328125,
0.023030010983347893,
0.918017566204071,
0.5497533082962036,
-0.46463078260421753,
0.33798250555992126,
0.2422732561826706,
-0.254810094833374,
1.0012861490249634,
-0.49211403727531433,
0.20565591752529144,
-0.19623450934886932,
0.19079819321632385,
-1.2439278364181519,
-0.2755506634712219,
0.412374883890152,
-0.4668775200843811,
0.44240713119506836,
0.14810273051261902,
-0.5649186968803406,
-0.4847952723503113,
-0.33135589957237244,
0.5516679883003235,
0.242108553647995,
-0.4671785533428192,
0.5118365287780762,
0.2974892258644104,
-0.2911779284477234,
-0.3521515429019928,
-0.6499095559120178,
0.5701659917831421,
-0.4747183620929718,
-0.5601145029067993,
0.38969486951828003,
-0.2052299827337265,
0.10144688934087753,
-0.2356616109609604,
-0.15979285538196564,
0.03944610804319382,
-0.49836093187332153,
0.13152483105659485,
-0.02435348741710186,
0.011432701721787453,
-0.01658199355006218,
0.38443446159362793,
-0.13277702033519745,
0.114665687084198,
-0.11390019953250885,
0.534185528755188,
-0.3320838212966919,
-0.42650118470191956,
-0.42071980237960815,
0.45134812593460083,
0.5470026731491089,
-0.3600282669067383,
0.3814830482006073,
0.5712771415710449,
-0.3515072762966156,
0.05690458044409752,
-0.8036290407180786,
-0.2307310849428177,
-0.48458799719810486,
0.2893826365470886,
-0.6873108148574829,
-0.9588443636894226,
0.2881441116333008,
-0.39493390917778015,
0.017478909343481064,
0.15020936727523804,
0.455743670463562,
-0.19339734315872192,
1.1422691345214844,
0.3803485929965973,
0.17615802586078644,
0.19696033000946045,
-0.28963592648506165,
0.19720932841300964,
-0.707659900188446,
-0.505584716796875,
-0.40247097611427307,
-0.4163704514503479,
-0.3267463147640228,
-1.0238964557647705,
0.44771426916122437,
-0.2477400153875351,
-0.021869881078600883,
0.48679453134536743,
-0.4325464069843292,
0.21596044301986694,
0.48617124557495117,
0.08464241772890091,
-0.01914048008620739,
0.366394579410553,
-0.2726065516471863,
-0.7567649483680725,
-0.6978868246078491,
-0.6098210215568542,
0.5828213691711426,
0.31961748003959656,
0.6920645833015442,
0.22833070158958435,
0.5158525705337524,
0.38585424423217773,
0.055343493819236755,
-0.5931718945503235,
0.7455915212631226,
0.06657131016254425,
-0.4692602753639221,
0.03532744571566582,
-0.1310451328754425,
-1.2030789852142334,
0.4275189936161041,
-0.193719744682312,
-0.45401421189308167,
0.2413916140794754,
-0.0315186008810997,
0.166471466422081,
0.22654399275779724,
-0.27097949385643005,
1.197337031364441,
-0.3182065188884735,
-0.44751861691474915,
-0.568152129650116,
-0.5783975124359131,
0.1805202215909958,
-0.09293637424707413,
0.33420330286026,
-0.13441163301467896,
-0.3029005527496338,
0.8118425011634827,
-0.19570566713809967,
0.662794828414917,
0.011608651839196682,
0.012948448769748211,
0.3836435079574585,
-0.04045369103550911,
0.21253570914268494,
-0.46726366877555847,
0.03350966051220894,
0.22738967835903168,
0.24203737080097198,
-0.5586161017417908,
-0.5993908047676086,
0.6370491981506348,
-0.5320143103599548,
-0.5282236337661743,
-0.6068981289863586,
-0.38893958926200867,
-0.07424461841583252,
0.06684869527816772,
0.38278302550315857,
0.6843677759170532,
-0.09289757162332535,
0.45856642723083496,
0.5236722826957703,
-0.4498715102672577,
0.39110973477363586,
0.24559475481510162,
0.4769846498966217,
-0.7742072939872742,
1.007328987121582,
0.15659333765506744,
-0.02162899449467659,
0.41324880719184875,
0.2261497676372528,
-0.7427189946174622,
-0.5501208901405334,
-0.536643385887146,
0.217914417386055,
-1.0417108535766602,
-0.48042061924934387,
-0.5992680788040161,
-0.04841766878962517,
-0.37432968616485596,
-0.237383171916008,
-0.06515377014875412,
-0.3847823441028595,
-0.33741459250450134,
-0.11581111699342728,
0.03033236600458622,
0.499575138092041,
-0.11892440170049667,
0.279436320066452,
-0.7781751751899719,
-0.12194681912660599,
0.36854490637779236,
-0.1362973004579544,
-0.2377515435218811,
-0.5981273055076599,
-0.08018076419830322,
-0.20096246898174286,
-0.7748486399650574,
-1.2070502042770386,
0.3971068859100342,
0.12818826735019684,
0.7406771779060364,
0.7159449458122253,
-0.008993884548544884,
0.9967860579490662,
-0.5604066848754883,
0.876948893070221,
0.6167650818824768,
-0.8510822057723999,
0.6858238577842712,
-0.4999825656414032,
0.3488321602344513,
0.3215789794921875,
0.47079795598983765,
-0.27839601039886475,
-0.37206998467445374,
-0.6624454855918884,
-0.8076034188270569,
0.295186311006546,
0.5232819318771362,
0.5726568102836609,
-0.2939528524875641,
0.11275544762611389,
0.1528318226337433,
0.5100181698799133,
-0.8964698314666748,
0.10092370212078094,
-0.4393887221813202,
-0.11808815598487854,
-0.014687138609588146,
-0.5057893395423889,
-0.25040197372436523,
-0.3181019127368927,
0.6015914082527161,
-0.13269609212875366,
0.33207666873931885,
0.024638282135128975,
0.04615571349859238,
0.11804436147212982,
0.6729594469070435,
0.5829010605812073,
0.6971748471260071,
0.23021021485328674,
0.5854410529136658,
0.14948627352714539,
-0.0993608832359314,
0.16759563982486725,
0.15551425516605377,
-0.01096303854137659,
-0.006497775670140982,
0.17231202125549316,
0.8672745227813721,
0.45390841364860535,
-0.6912837624549866,
0.4915625751018524,
0.0067369346506893635,
-0.2925359904766083,
-0.12508533895015717,
-0.27907758951187134,
-0.06326772272586823,
0.3592960834503174,
0.3355313241481781,
0.0977843701839447,
0.495617538690567,
-0.6504079699516296,
0.35380852222442627,
0.5226635336875916,
-0.30916261672973633,
-0.6223154664039612,
0.7397424578666687,
0.30742165446281433,
0.3489382863044739,
0.022724542766809464,
-0.13216720521450043,
-0.7070648670196533,
0.4743822515010834,
0.6934400796890259,
0.5238372683525085,
-0.14675231277942657,
0.3200019598007202,
0.5339325666427612,
0.4139920771121979,
0.08822887390851974,
0.39091530442237854,
-0.21231958270072937,
-0.6559760570526123,
-0.3040751814842224,
-0.484824001789093,
-0.3821971118450165,
0.3176393508911133,
-0.3119035065174103,
0.45425212383270264,
-0.46987423300743103,
-0.3159232437610626,
0.08257605880498886,
-0.09501992166042328,
-0.6513617038726807,
0.43167364597320557,
0.20926998555660248,
0.6424040794372559,
-0.7972795367240906,
0.39329794049263,
1.2477104663848877,
-0.7078848481178284,
-0.7699790596961975,
-0.13952435553073883,
0.1201791763305664,
-0.18178357183933258,
0.4111991226673126,
0.5101386904716492,
-0.07389896363019943,
0.20002232491970062,
-1.0413107872009277,
-0.6193899512290955,
1.1331251859664917,
0.258620947599411,
-0.17218197882175446,
0.361615389585495,
-0.023446159437298775,
0.3127124011516571,
-0.49717429280281067,
0.1874457746744156,
0.3179847002029419,
0.6920371055603027,
0.5601382255554199,
-0.5647708177566528,
0.23673810064792633,
-0.3294008672237396,
0.03924103081226349,
-0.09983164817094803,
-0.5611807107925415,
0.7238670587539673,
-0.10175781697034836,
-0.33437082171440125,
0.09823396056890488,
0.9656827449798584,
0.5286184549331665,
0.5491976141929626,
0.4135139286518097,
0.3174789845943451,
0.5962660312652588,
-0.14795050024986267,
0.8126991987228394,
0.010204529389739037,
-0.2922931909561157,
0.7599791884422302,
0.065865658223629,
0.6741350293159485,
0.6482812762260437,
0.0747997835278511,
0.8234197497367859,
0.9400056004524231,
-0.14763318002223969,
0.709526538848877,
0.20400428771972656,
-0.45636269450187683,
-0.40322771668434143,
-0.34531375765800476,
-0.3426131010055542,
0.5213388800621033,
0.5349015593528748,
-0.24201874434947968,
-0.2566910982131958,
0.35523363947868347,
0.11365082859992981,
0.2802983522415161,
-0.3320842981338501,
0.5594408512115479,
0.17793887853622437,
-0.65950608253479,
0.43521028757095337,
0.18908962607383728,
0.6843173503875732,
-0.599172830581665,
-0.28598707914352417,
0.2436065524816513,
0.02571832574903965,
-0.12939110398292542,
-0.6947280764579773,
0.1837262511253357,
-0.24254752695560455,
0.004345328081399202,
-0.2594453692436218,
0.9245741963386536,
-0.43167954683303833,
-0.4394586682319641,
0.05316000059247017,
0.38020059466362,
0.6467580199241638,
-0.0038581346161663532,
-0.9138581156730652,
0.3260764479637146,
-0.0519520528614521,
0.0860164538025856,
0.20385369658470154,
0.7981447577476501,
-0.410313218832016,
0.49021556973457336,
0.6071211099624634,
-0.016078144311904907,
0.03339601308107376,
0.2885134816169739,
0.8941637873649597,
-0.601374626159668,
-0.5474392771720886,
-0.8000421524047852,
0.4646044969558716,
-0.14716850221157074,
0.04486221447587013,
0.8806347846984863,
0.5137437582015991,
0.6500959396362305,
-0.37002840638160706,
0.8315109014511108,
-0.3316830098628998,
-0.03199164196848869,
-0.459053099155426,
0.47452276945114136,
-0.7684242129325867,
0.07228398323059082,
-0.6006283760070801,
-0.7971733212471008,
-0.12425505369901657,
0.6589080095291138,
-0.4326281249523163,
-0.07943354547023773,
0.770779550075531,
0.807582676410675,
-0.06792514771223068,
0.0024361619725823402,
0.496519535779953,
0.05444224923849106,
0.4276506006717682,
0.5590586066246033,
1.1636520624160767,
-0.3404313027858734,
0.8709085583686829,
0.018851350992918015,
-0.15746626257896423,
0.20208774507045746,
-1.0039995908737183,
-1.0813947916030884,
-0.835303544998169,
-0.533722996711731,
-0.28479233384132385,
0.024048279970884323,
0.8774142861366272,
0.5736616849899292,
-0.868919849395752,
0.02113494835793972,
0.11944368481636047,
-0.12014681845903397,
0.06710348278284073,
-0.17795361578464508,
0.07236076146364212,
-0.24484926462173462,
-1.004716157913208,
0.20408152043819427,
0.5562214255332947,
0.14007693529129028,
-0.09924324601888657,
-0.10079212486743927,
-0.3578726351261139,
0.35976505279541016,
0.801386296749115,
0.11536919325590134,
-0.8427786231040955,
-0.461976557970047,
-0.2553039789199829,
0.02719326876103878,
0.020334184169769287,
0.7191050052642822,
-0.5025294423103333,
0.6377890706062317,
0.5838608145713806,
0.46141692996025085,
0.3475149869918823,
0.3565957546234131,
0.6489205956459045,
-0.41512706875801086,
0.11634276807308197,
0.10677234828472137,
0.4192086458206177,
0.7311722040176392,
0.009602474980056286,
0.5195589065551758,
0.4164208173751831,
-0.41990095376968384,
-0.5792537331581116,
0.1600022315979004,
-1.0709744691848755,
-0.3065555989742279,
1.1573758125305176,
-0.06747202575206757,
-0.2099844515323639,
-0.24351190030574799,
-0.581153154373169,
0.08125941455364227,
-0.44108104705810547,
0.6001598834991455,
0.9401275515556335,
-0.18288423120975494,
-0.58903968334198,
-0.5028523802757263,
0.4057541787624359,
0.5272181034088135,
-0.8365881443023682,
-0.5949980616569519,
0.9170942902565002,
0.31852614879608154,
0.2595120668411255,
0.8502243757247925,
-0.45373573899269104,
0.36768853664398193,
-0.10173120349645615,
0.14674542844295502,
0.14000681042671204,
-0.33948928117752075,
-0.08028028905391693,
0.10138072073459625,
-0.08071941882371902,
-0.40112146735191345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03021v1
|
Blessing or curse? A survey on the Impact of Generative AI on Fake News
| 2024-04-03T19:14:45 | 2024-04-03T19:14:45 |
Alexander Loth, Martin Kappes, Marc-Oliver Pahl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Fake news significantly influence our society. They impact consumers, voters,
and many other societal groups. While Fake News exist for a centuries,
Generative AI brings fake news on a new level. It is now possible to automate
the creation of masses of high-quality individually targeted Fake News. On the
other end, Generative AI can also help detecting Fake News. Both fields are
young but developing fast.
This survey provides a comprehensive examination of the research and
practical use of Generative AI for Fake News detection and creation in 2024.
Following the Structured Literature Survey approach, the paper synthesizes
current results in the following topic clusters 1) enabling technologies, 2)
creation of Fake News, 3) case study social media as most relevant distribution
channel, 4) detection of Fake News, and 5) deepfakes as upcoming technology.
The article also identifies current challenges and open issues.
|
[
-0.4341665804386139,
-0.9305573105812073,
0.46595728397369385,
0.44819340109825134,
-0.3729843497276306,
0.27877095341682434,
0.29111266136169434,
-0.8798201680183411,
0.42057138681411743,
0.34778115153312683,
-0.2500922977924347,
-0.06090318039059639,
-0.7213373184204102,
0.1251484751701355,
-0.7102459669113159,
1.0972431898117065,
0.3819383382797241,
0.37030333280563354,
-0.3224060535430908,
0.20978938043117523,
-0.40126198530197144,
-0.41555503010749817,
-0.667784571647644,
-0.01617293804883957,
0.22565439343452454,
0.0635514184832573,
0.6913976073265076,
0.037402473390102386,
0.3855624198913574,
0.442792683839798,
0.32100173830986023,
0.453360378742218,
-0.19534854590892792,
-0.03749697655439377,
-0.17903226613998413,
-0.4947790503501892,
-0.29471638798713684,
0.3551889657974243,
0.37047016620635986,
0.40398213267326355,
0.2282816469669342,
0.08816283196210861,
-0.12568755447864532,
0.4453878700733185,
-0.4112991392612457,
-0.26228514313697815,
-0.5531792640686035,
0.24581700563430786,
-0.4953548014163971,
-0.3597470223903656,
-0.13273724913597107,
-0.6246545910835266,
-0.10543200373649597,
-0.5659787058830261,
0.6290702223777771,
0.051486942917108536,
0.7731664776802063,
0.426602303981781,
-0.49716222286224365,
-0.4859166443347931,
-0.8679598569869995,
0.6235190629959106,
-0.38683560490608215,
0.33778268098831177,
0.312592476606369,
0.2216416448354721,
-0.23575924336910248,
-0.7162405252456665,
-1.000439167022705,
-0.39771169424057007,
0.26285219192504883,
0.35975250601768494,
-0.14128047227859497,
-0.1955856829881668,
-0.04622810333967209,
0.5968071222305298,
-0.41213226318359375,
0.07522974908351898,
-0.48339301347732544,
-0.37174057960510254,
0.6317048668861389,
-0.012585216201841831,
0.8046514391899109,
-0.35169076919555664,
-0.3986303508281708,
0.07784529775381088,
-0.3571856617927551,
-0.34929126501083374,
0.7164053916931152,
-0.025073956698179245,
-0.1041957214474678,
0.4261075556278229,
-0.014851577579975128,
0.6361448168754578,
0.17020918428897858,
-0.2941475510597229,
0.07845167070627213,
-0.5057504773139954,
-0.2437979280948639,
0.19386941194534302,
0.843663215637207,
0.334683895111084,
0.03993292525410652,
0.022672167047858238,
-0.11274738609790802,
0.57566899061203,
0.6562725901603699,
-0.38769569993019104,
-0.11502009630203247,
-0.08962215483188629,
-0.45681890845298767,
-0.7592712044715881,
0.4559328854084015,
-0.7626527547836304,
-0.9226257801055908,
-0.2765790820121765,
0.17742601037025452,
-0.29803991317749023,
-0.2953672707080841,
0.05035055801272392,
-0.6496710777282715,
0.20680002868175507,
0.6305570006370544,
-0.342529296875,
-0.0733884871006012,
0.623053252696991,
0.5827036499977112,
0.10631603747606277,
0.0014444036642089486,
-0.4695857763290405,
-0.3746127188205719,
-0.5587044954299927,
0.9882861375808716,
-0.0952555239200592,
-0.4427385628223419,
0.02200884185731411,
-0.19536450505256653,
0.4458731412887573,
-0.5110781788825989,
0.6979537606239319,
-0.5806857347488403,
0.21502666175365448,
-0.10181113332509995,
-0.32951024174690247,
0.08022687584161758,
0.31242993474006653,
-0.7629721760749817,
0.46858176589012146,
-0.04930698499083519,
-0.43335941433906555,
0.7781376838684082,
-0.33565637469291687,
-0.8727041482925415,
0.3680154085159302,
-0.1498892456293106,
-0.6874745488166809,
0.44752034544944763,
0.24397040903568268,
0.13067662715911865,
-0.044906165450811386,
0.18950985372066498,
-0.20652079582214355,
-0.22611045837402344,
0.42142143845558167,
-1.0609281063079834,
0.8719828724861145,
0.4337567389011383,
-0.6725409626960754,
-0.3689439594745636,
-0.4931018650531769,
-0.3492108881473541,
-0.15085643529891968,
-0.12858420610427856,
-0.38211220502853394,
-0.0732540488243103,
0.10310119390487671,
0.10206175595521927,
0.034285712987184525,
-0.6594929695129395,
0.16514918208122253,
-0.317134827375412,
0.044614486396312714,
0.7647173404693604,
0.18484008312225342,
0.29220297932624817,
-0.19131559133529663,
0.6366882920265198,
0.1284041553735733,
0.576967716217041,
0.0979170873761177,
-0.7238456010818481,
-0.7667277455329895,
0.0029245156329125166,
0.5259921550750732,
0.39259982109069824,
-1.2950894832611084,
0.43589961528778076,
-0.03590574115514755,
-0.38307052850723267,
-0.6809218525886536,
-0.12108705192804337,
0.4850582480430603,
0.17463913559913635,
0.279703289270401,
-0.3343559503555298,
-0.6750281453132629,
-0.6370046138763428,
-0.5601468682289124,
-0.20739233493804932,
0.06324075907468796,
-0.026829367503523827,
0.42429590225219727,
0.051923416554927826,
0.8000061511993408,
-0.06749794632196426,
-0.5561637878417969,
-0.13520295917987823,
0.2599956691265106,
-0.19780248403549194,
0.2853981852531433,
0.6205882430076599,
-1.4117056131362915,
-0.33637768030166626,
-0.09037001430988312,
-0.9696701765060425,
0.09145762771368027,
-0.3059890568256378,
0.20971077680587769,
0.646730899810791,
0.10593251883983612,
-0.7218289971351624,
0.614463746547699,
0.6200887560844421,
-0.5447981357574463,
0.6894888877868652,
0.12124399095773697,
0.63638836145401,
-1.0553253889083862,
-0.21385127305984497,
-0.10256893932819366,
-0.19716979563236237,
-0.6447065472602844,
-0.08672298491001129,
-0.1568923145532608,
-0.08248580992221832,
-0.3270420432090759,
0.5900315642356873,
-0.44691428542137146,
-0.039259858429431915,
-0.39840608835220337,
-0.1482306569814682,
-0.14443086087703705,
-0.4391659200191498,
-0.22694337368011475,
0.7696617245674133,
0.45156556367874146,
-0.5284044146537781,
0.5847069621086121,
0.03689592704176903,
-0.7067754864692688,
0.66607266664505,
-0.4211941957473755,
0.08541498333215714,
-0.15362073481082916,
0.727289617061615,
-0.5593457221984863,
-0.37525683641433716,
0.701371431350708,
-1.1692947149276733,
-0.0564589649438858,
0.27931374311447144,
-0.7248718738555908,
-0.7305877208709717,
-0.23994649946689606,
0.31899040937423706,
0.4913373589515686,
-0.7375677227973938,
0.5976011157035828,
0.20689657330513,
0.4031173288822174,
-0.5708813667297363,
-0.8591519594192505,
0.6480395197868347,
-0.025148572400212288,
-0.5846583843231201,
0.4220356047153473,
0.09325727820396423,
-0.5547213554382324,
0.14985226094722748,
-0.19776229560375214,
0.24091485142707825,
-0.03970017656683922,
0.33336347341537476,
-0.09783585369586945,
-0.030273819342255592,
-0.03762691468000412,
-0.06543084233999252,
0.07995240390300751,
-0.04622434079647064,
-0.2716028690338135,
0.2199171930551529,
0.06616238504648209,
-0.2765943706035614,
-0.7830106019973755,
0.28509601950645447,
0.7044695615768433,
-0.09357477724552155,
0.5396196246147156,
0.5748828053474426,
-0.2729913294315338,
-0.3940935730934143,
-0.8698292970657349,
-0.1745743304491043,
-0.5185441970825195,
-0.015201573260128498,
0.02239207923412323,
-0.5956384539604187,
0.0977826863527298,
0.1891573816537857,
-0.3355526924133301,
0.2222609668970108,
0.3670782446861267,
0.19376960396766663,
1.0242055654525757,
0.5924502611160278,
-0.37654420733451843,
0.39452630281448364,
-0.16757182776927948,
0.5941551923751831,
-0.004959824029356241,
-0.2913450002670288,
-0.27355819940567017,
-0.13119255006313324,
-0.5634687542915344,
-0.46950647234916687,
0.6053001880645752,
0.01683606207370758,
0.47536417841911316,
0.0029355157166719437,
-0.726198136806488,
0.0639534518122673,
0.9418871998786926,
0.03952595964074135,
0.5913504362106323,
0.15682120621204376,
0.4997631311416626,
0.22722601890563965,
-0.1977187693119049,
-0.3126716613769531,
0.9853073954582214,
-0.024394303560256958,
0.40966182947158813,
0.006302570924162865,
0.5942177772521973,
1.0796042680740356,
0.7301455140113831,
-0.5281018018722534,
0.41063153743743896,
-0.1965259611606598,
-0.7080141305923462,
-0.1297280490398407,
-0.13095584511756897,
-0.7969067692756653,
-0.11591106653213501,
-0.04371964558959007,
0.12689103186130524,
0.1654081791639328,
0.23252975940704346,
-0.3310418128967285,
0.37702611088752747,
-0.5251543521881104,
0.25349870324134827,
-0.4066303074359894,
-0.00165671412833035,
-0.30223333835601807,
-0.4872351586818695,
0.6255595088005066,
-0.04932624474167824,
0.29977455735206604,
0.2507520616054535,
0.14431576430797577,
0.36694326996803284,
-0.4423532783985138,
1.03108811378479,
-0.3217501938343048,
-0.19064565002918243,
0.49707934260368347,
-0.3782872259616852,
0.5056053996086121,
0.17394159734249115,
-0.05102331191301346,
0.17013299465179443,
-0.5045993328094482,
-0.34799498319625854,
-0.5579219460487366,
0.7898963093757629,
-0.5313465595245361,
-0.7179067134857178,
-0.7849946022033691,
-0.20049235224723816,
-0.003419996239244938,
0.014313490130007267,
0.4833201467990875,
0.11757797002792358,
-0.3960738182067871,
-0.15481793880462646,
0.3678361177444458,
-0.356060266494751,
0.4785522222518921,
0.40836432576179504,
0.001654610619880259,
-0.5176842212677002,
1.380204439163208,
0.2190883457660675,
-0.19996127486228943,
0.03679993748664856,
-0.0016790969530120492,
-0.09230833500623703,
-0.3810955286026001,
-0.6487445831298828,
-0.03196416050195694,
-0.2150188386440277,
-0.36827465891838074,
-0.48416638374328613,
-0.33276650309562683,
-0.9089217782020569,
-0.24930457770824432,
-0.2685806155204773,
-0.07674504816532135,
-0.45854246616363525,
-0.2117091417312622,
0.27360931038856506,
0.8533862233161926,
-0.2798037528991699,
-0.08095832914113998,
-0.4168718159198761,
0.7771074175834656,
0.4876176118850708,
0.16624583303928375,
-0.16722144186496735,
0.01810753345489502,
-0.009287516586482525,
0.12457463890314102,
-0.48237448930740356,
-0.7621713876724243,
0.37129825353622437,
-0.07136943936347961,
0.2237500101327896,
0.8111366033554077,
0.16192790865898132,
0.5495284199714661,
-0.29704949259757996,
1.2638428211212158,
0.3596303462982178,
-0.6620892286300659,
0.5492438673973083,
-0.4190712869167328,
0.025299638509750366,
0.2340528666973114,
0.426771879196167,
-0.32298147678375244,
-0.6186264157295227,
-0.8263522386550903,
-0.2897721529006958,
0.17600224912166595,
0.19038264453411102,
0.7537945508956909,
-0.21743832528591156,
0.014565523713827133,
0.33876749873161316,
0.40873807668685913,
-0.6958405375480652,
-0.4171889126300812,
-0.5159850716590881,
0.24344277381896973,
0.2183333933353424,
-0.14303985238075256,
0.2796977758407593,
-0.46693405508995056,
0.4903496205806732,
0.20259889960289001,
0.45334598422050476,
0.1343437284231186,
0.2395678162574768,
-0.1165873259305954,
-0.09179546684026718,
0.7006469368934631,
0.3832099735736847,
0.2495298981666565,
0.27482831478118896,
-0.28630170226097107,
-0.5065324902534485,
-0.026574760675430298,
0.1571953296661377,
-0.45676684379577637,
0.2872987687587738,
0.38299113512039185,
0.7123710513114929,
-0.28568926453590393,
-0.433758944272995,
0.593709409236908,
0.26405152678489685,
-0.4722914397716522,
-0.9190884828567505,
-0.04107285663485527,
-0.3326210379600525,
0.09671108424663544,
0.8031313419342041,
0.48089954257011414,
0.3209895193576813,
-0.8077275156974792,
0.08659214526414871,
0.5846671462059021,
-0.36121898889541626,
-0.5121796131134033,
0.7610079646110535,
0.28982463479042053,
-0.5580359697341919,
0.6535714864730835,
-0.4154756963253021,
-0.6465225219726562,
0.7339451909065247,
0.4667867422103882,
0.7089457511901855,
-0.46783462166786194,
0.6661895513534546,
-0.027119336649775505,
0.24756525456905365,
-0.1778976023197174,
0.15727318823337555,
-0.022171949967741966,
-0.9320040345191956,
-0.10097840428352356,
-0.8770961165428162,
0.02577493153512478,
0.48691970109939575,
-0.06577499210834503,
0.19215315580368042,
-0.21794871985912323,
-0.3465002477169037,
0.15885348618030548,
0.02724445052444935,
-0.5152620077133179,
0.4774620532989502,
0.20720621943473816,
0.4812351167201996,
-0.6929915547370911,
0.4341111481189728,
0.6241357326507568,
-0.5450380444526672,
-0.2689237594604492,
0.3645671010017395,
0.27817288041114807,
-0.6189502477645874,
0.45103389024734497,
0.026306860148906708,
0.017601817846298218,
0.15160076320171356,
-0.8953083753585815,
-0.5783523917198181,
0.5396471619606018,
0.16359801590442657,
-0.21225643157958984,
-0.08501895517110825,
0.4098372459411621,
0.7142331004142761,
0.12449038773775101,
-0.2060791701078415,
0.27817749977111816,
0.8529880046844482,
-0.2585119605064392,
-0.6428034901618958,
-0.03909553959965706,
-0.3834802210330963,
0.17773868143558502,
0.19315917789936066,
-0.6158223152160645,
0.5352228879928589,
-0.09860708564519882,
-0.4132649898529053,
0.3035900294780731,
0.8919209837913513,
0.1287137269973755,
0.7310976982116699,
0.3606557250022888,
0.798582911491394,
0.3588602542877197,
0.041318707168102264,
1.4005330801010132,
-0.0952482745051384,
-0.09410271048545837,
0.48914337158203125,
0.16745330393314362,
0.0249705258756876,
0.4484303593635559,
-0.1849445402622223,
0.5555174946784973,
0.41086429357528687,
-0.5497207045555115,
0.24941374361515045,
0.3862377107143402,
-0.7753394246101379,
-0.09942515939474106,
-0.521746039390564,
-0.4866596460342407,
0.3845759928226471,
0.3527236878871918,
-0.5165401101112366,
-0.07438705116510391,
0.6919844746589661,
0.1010470762848854,
0.30277174711227417,
-0.24748903512954712,
0.42478713393211365,
0.24568861722946167,
-0.8112828731536865,
0.16477569937705994,
0.17009352147579193,
0.9356600046157837,
-0.16835860908031464,
-0.2843552827835083,
-0.35553982853889465,
0.07118332386016846,
-0.22644579410552979,
-0.3920576274394989,
0.2092186063528061,
-0.06956374645233154,
-0.35178112983703613,
-0.30515822768211365,
0.9253498911857605,
-0.06846529990434647,
-0.5692965984344482,
0.0959823876619339,
0.4768407642841339,
0.05989474803209305,
-0.28554052114486694,
-0.3450491428375244,
0.12861289083957672,
-0.27938419580459595,
-0.06877381354570389,
0.2370087206363678,
0.27780070900917053,
-0.23227429389953613,
0.3656192421913147,
0.8277078866958618,
0.20379720628261566,
0.1866123378276825,
0.2894236147403717,
0.5839306712150574,
-0.3854248523712158,
-0.2998981177806854,
-0.5746648907661438,
0.41684040427207947,
-0.45227497816085815,
-0.621090292930603,
1.1771109104156494,
0.49765756726264954,
0.7363322377204895,
-0.40352195501327515,
1.081220030784607,
-0.5253517627716064,
0.20749714970588684,
-0.22982782125473022,
1.0371092557907104,
-0.6147608160972595,
-0.1754910796880722,
-0.32178646326065063,
-0.7104253768920898,
-0.31080272793769836,
0.08477238565683365,
-0.20368316769599915,
0.22341212630271912,
0.4046840965747833,
0.6645348072052002,
0.10217468440532684,
0.0497591532766819,
0.4414139986038208,
0.08028220385313034,
0.22436001896858215,
-0.09773247689008713,
1.0362480878829956,
-0.610511839389801,
0.4052827060222626,
-0.15340255200862885,
-0.20371787250041962,
-0.33409205079078674,
-0.4688672125339508,
-0.47775015234947205,
-0.5460036993026733,
-0.29379773139953613,
-0.32177433371543884,
0.44578272104263306,
0.17956258356571198,
0.4955163598060608,
-0.6937390565872192,
0.39752721786499023,
-0.6006560325622559,
0.33507779240608215,
-0.37294816970825195,
-0.4167085886001587,
0.27759262919425964,
-0.38284483551979065,
-0.9412187337875366,
0.5122915506362915,
0.06378428637981415,
0.13712702691555023,
-0.5742130875587463,
0.15402202308177948,
0.08432140946388245,
0.1470482051372528,
0.7788813710212708,
0.41560298204421997,
-0.9077796339988708,
-0.3606427311897278,
-0.1098008081316948,
-0.12598609924316406,
-0.4177308678627014,
0.8561083674430847,
-1.0367975234985352,
0.4362640678882599,
0.42295706272125244,
0.49945858120918274,
0.09396868199110031,
0.23993007838726044,
0.6391429305076599,
-0.6028556823730469,
-0.04341360926628113,
0.29117971658706665,
-0.21710902452468872,
0.3161618709564209,
-0.7751373052597046,
0.41400349140167236,
0.8037877678871155,
-0.45227015018463135,
-0.9102925062179565,
0.15045921504497528,
-0.7983273267745972,
-0.4827503263950348,
0.9422449469566345,
0.4524226784706116,
-0.03058294579386711,
-0.40986019372940063,
-0.03778684511780739,
0.279573917388916,
-0.2801591455936432,
1.292807936668396,
0.21456091105937958,
-0.15689046680927277,
-0.0869869813323021,
-0.41041502356529236,
0.8381571769714355,
0.3946518898010254,
-0.8871793150901794,
-0.6524458527565002,
0.7546089291572571,
0.10136842727661133,
0.4531427025794983,
0.7018824219703674,
-0.20180220901966095,
0.4670964181423187,
0.17841410636901855,
0.09842837601900101,
-0.10039103776216507,
-0.5067288279533386,
-0.029436098411679268,
0.18864013254642487,
-0.48416027426719666,
-0.01729770004749298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02983v1
|
Towards a Fully Interpretable and More Scalable RSA Model for Metaphor Understanding
| 2024-04-03T18:09:33 | 2024-04-03T18:09:33 |
Gaia Carenini, Luca Bischetti, Walter Schaeken, Valentina Bambini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Rational Speech Act (RSA) model provides a flexible framework to model
pragmatic reasoning in computational terms. However, state-of-the-art RSA
models are still fairly distant from modern machine learning techniques and
present a number of limitations related to their interpretability and
scalability. Here, we introduce a new RSA framework for metaphor understanding
that addresses these limitations by providing an explicit formula - based on
the mutually shared information between the speaker and the listener - for the
estimation of the communicative goal and by learning the rationality parameter
using gradient-based methods. The model was tested against 24 metaphors, not
limited to the conventional $\textit{John-is-a-shark}$ type. Results suggest an
overall strong positive correlation between the distributions generated by the
model and the interpretations obtained from the human behavioral data, which
increased when the intended meaning capitalized on properties that were
inherent to the vehicle concept. Overall, findings suggest that metaphor
processing is well captured by a typicality-based Bayesian model, even when
more scalable and interpretable, opening up possible applications to other
pragmatic phenomena and novel uses for increasing Large Language Models
interpretability. Yet, results highlight that the more creative nuances of
metaphorical meaning, not strictly encoded in the lexical concepts, are a
challenging aspect for machines.
|
[
-0.21711388230323792,
-0.6938394904136658,
0.6628642082214355,
0.4111637473106384,
-0.6559613943099976,
-0.22177967429161072,
-0.22837938368320465,
-0.25923141837120056,
0.4501475691795349,
0.25049126148223877,
-0.531275749206543,
-0.0893390104174614,
-0.7228383421897888,
0.03401177003979683,
-0.17498809099197388,
0.5324646234512329,
0.30705615878105164,
0.014393291436135769,
0.027555417269468307,
-0.35341334342956543,
-0.7463725805282593,
-0.541881799697876,
-0.5695198178291321,
-0.2530013918876648,
0.6594215035438538,
-0.015714023262262344,
1.0609632730484009,
0.9976028203964233,
0.6363678574562073,
0.314832478761673,
-0.1480678915977478,
-0.21049049496650696,
-0.32533907890319824,
0.20257063210010529,
-0.4320121109485626,
-0.6223479509353638,
-0.2125442773103714,
0.3968660533428192,
0.926487922668457,
0.8922176361083984,
-0.5467122197151184,
0.11294253915548325,
-0.3640824556350708,
0.5168577432632446,
-0.5618982911109924,
0.6949670314788818,
-1.0230967998504639,
-0.01849619299173355,
0.021238304674625397,
-0.42115679383277893,
-0.34484750032424927,
0.12814515829086304,
0.26749226450920105,
-1.0045479536056519,
-0.154718279838562,
0.12934456765651703,
0.9517726302146912,
0.16899199783802032,
-0.2738076448440552,
-0.30997368693351746,
-0.5706908106803894,
1.0624439716339111,
-0.3791884183883667,
0.30981919169425964,
0.12920264899730682,
0.7570339441299438,
-0.2399568259716034,
-0.9262318015098572,
-1.0145306587219238,
-0.333150178194046,
0.04476715996861458,
-0.11466008424758911,
-0.4530254304409027,
-0.04933161288499832,
0.43949130177497864,
0.03413661569356918,
-0.4314604103565216,
-0.27738919854164124,
-0.3706642985343933,
-0.0194571353495121,
0.42865344882011414,
0.41983163356781006,
0.4860766530036926,
-0.38649824261665344,
-0.6057983636856079,
-0.2759583592414856,
-0.4115477502346039,
0.11819510161876678,
-0.09705879539251328,
0.5451786518096924,
-0.4587554335594177,
0.2708444595336914,
-0.0722837895154953,
0.9202696681022644,
-0.490454763174057,
-0.04002203792333603,
0.23447030782699585,
-0.2494993507862091,
-0.38337457180023193,
-0.3262074291706085,
0.5184462666511536,
0.16046172380447388,
0.5826634764671326,
-0.157782644033432,
-0.1312362253665924,
0.4182478189468384,
0.29109808802604675,
-0.6504933834075928,
-0.150045245885849,
-0.04633546993136406,
-0.4364641308784485,
-0.08954241126775742,
0.10439978539943695,
-0.43539756536483765,
-0.4476883113384247,
-0.7851302027702332,
0.31595295667648315,
-0.47822049260139465,
-0.4260816276073456,
0.5302424430847168,
-0.43262842297554016,
0.3830636441707611,
0.35167521238327026,
-0.7545912265777588,
0.24174842238426208,
0.9395062923431396,
0.8767198324203491,
0.17231668531894684,
-0.32737600803375244,
-0.6090848445892334,
0.2846658229827881,
-0.29522043466567993,
0.7236163020133972,
-1.0672942399978638,
0.026248278096318245,
-0.3547978699207306,
-0.1830560714006424,
-0.35057833790779114,
-0.22896640002727509,
0.39257338643074036,
-0.6233252286911011,
0.14150089025497437,
-0.12779724597930908,
-0.3317813277244568,
-0.605581521987915,
0.1113409698009491,
-0.6130545735359192,
0.17490756511688232,
0.17467862367630005,
-0.5455552935600281,
0.27757444977760315,
-0.5100607872009277,
-0.2300470918416977,
0.1833658218383789,
-0.6276460886001587,
-0.14288319647312164,
0.22727952897548676,
-0.04213830828666687,
0.6024866104125977,
-0.7400766015052795,
0.600280225276947,
-0.5301936268806458,
-0.4809551239013672,
0.810507595539093,
-0.5048964619636536,
0.8931171298027039,
0.1770266443490982,
0.04649542644619942,
0.16037623584270477,
-0.7089875936508179,
-0.08361338078975677,
0.16952884197235107,
0.39816680550575256,
-0.3297945261001587,
-0.030833231285214424,
0.03104078583419323,
0.3559618294239044,
0.06215570122003555,
-0.22972089052200317,
-0.1569204181432724,
-0.4417154788970947,
0.8919217586517334,
0.7924133539199829,
0.002175327856093645,
0.49194076657295227,
-0.5945600271224976,
0.6450400948524475,
0.06858133524656296,
-0.03418400511145592,
-0.2400537133216858,
-0.5574372410774231,
-0.23315240442752838,
-1.0294767618179321,
0.24139779806137085,
0.3915427029132843,
-0.3106311559677124,
0.1442924439907074,
-0.4838915169239044,
-0.4523244798183441,
-0.30647048354148865,
-0.2606032192707062,
0.20669026672840118,
0.4856591820716858,
0.19836421310901642,
-0.4633753001689911,
-0.6102872490882874,
-1.1401344537734985,
-0.5350056886672974,
-0.3478105068206787,
-0.2793864607810974,
0.232423335313797,
0.3515445291996002,
-0.023250624537467957,
0.9901882410049438,
-0.2397695928812027,
-0.21948833763599396,
-0.3734174072742462,
0.49874815344810486,
0.3686767518520355,
0.4379238784313202,
0.3868463635444641,
-0.9980467557907104,
-0.2257048636674881,
-0.10353586822748184,
-0.6902075409889221,
0.13265149295330048,
-0.6015743017196655,
-0.0804491639137268,
-0.5549567341804504,
-0.04796972870826721,
-1.14565110206604,
0.26721474528312683,
0.1186276376247406,
-0.34755754470825195,
0.19393916428089142,
0.01050034910440445,
-0.14894163608551025,
-1.0485098361968994,
-0.032885514199733734,
0.25337880849838257,
-0.06787975132465363,
-0.5639169216156006,
0.14383424818515778,
-0.05711972713470459,
-0.06814906746149063,
-0.40399426221847534,
0.47129562497138977,
-0.16520647704601288,
-0.39982613921165466,
-0.18699537217617035,
0.416663259267807,
-0.09573027491569519,
0.4431341588497162,
0.34264642000198364,
0.7969661355018616,
0.5758049488067627,
-0.6631895303726196,
0.26140034198760986,
-0.009518159553408623,
-0.09358356148004532,
0.44808030128479004,
-0.7193045020103455,
-0.16407877206802368,
-0.5155672430992126,
0.4496835172176361,
-0.93190997838974,
-0.25786399841308594,
0.519304096698761,
-0.6992363333702087,
-0.035733673721551895,
0.02331935428082943,
-0.24033217132091522,
0.29348433017730713,
-0.09424670785665512,
0.3947972059249878,
0.7417333126068115,
-0.37544557452201843,
1.0960606336593628,
0.5620099902153015,
-0.022690366953611374,
-0.595528244972229,
-0.30498358607292175,
0.15765056014060974,
-0.452814519405365,
-0.6503910422325134,
0.2508983016014099,
0.21714049577713013,
-0.6214823722839355,
-0.32349491119384766,
-0.06502099335193634,
-0.35210445523262024,
0.3241860270500183,
0.4186340570449829,
0.45210081338882446,
-0.22847089171409607,
0.09921916574239731,
-0.10802461951971054,
-0.2530234456062317,
0.35878095030784607,
0.12258520722389221,
0.35187050700187683,
-0.21665970981121063,
0.147250697016716,
-1.1216611862182617,
0.05565398931503296,
0.8584891557693481,
-0.1263694167137146,
0.9072273969650269,
0.2939958870410919,
-0.4234607517719269,
-0.305748850107193,
-0.060011595487594604,
-0.39084744453430176,
-0.40657466650009155,
0.23605594038963318,
-0.6209243535995483,
-0.6271734833717346,
0.5313650965690613,
-0.05721841752529144,
-0.05692974478006363,
0.4079562723636627,
0.42161059379577637,
-0.14337041974067688,
0.8664675354957581,
0.3627970218658447,
0.1263163834810257,
0.43505215644836426,
0.07193850725889206,
0.28723666071891785,
-0.549796462059021,
-0.13829351961612701,
-0.5966202616691589,
-0.14025242626667023,
-0.4537143111228943,
-0.7810087203979492,
-0.014585064724087715,
-0.004343036096543074,
-0.3152334690093994,
0.3501925468444824,
-0.3482702970504761,
0.2428293526172638,
0.07439864426851273,
-0.3732728362083435,
0.3816165030002594,
0.23212172091007233,
0.10905735939741135,
-0.2893145978450775,
-0.5751349925994873,
-0.8601400256156921,
0.7679544687271118,
0.6055040955543518,
0.2869640588760376,
0.0824371725320816,
0.14844617247581482,
0.2091684192419052,
0.6928555369377136,
-0.6898133754730225,
0.791019082069397,
0.2157720923423767,
-0.6006813049316406,
-0.3349390923976898,
-0.5509563684463501,
-0.7841653227806091,
0.9248342514038086,
-0.29480889439582825,
-0.7243667840957642,
-0.058956630527973175,
0.043412793427705765,
-0.20620772242546082,
0.04552906006574631,
-0.5763164758682251,
0.8600088357925415,
0.2877870500087738,
-0.06481599062681198,
-0.6343916654586792,
-0.7088175415992737,
0.46879076957702637,
-0.08670873194932938,
0.4484601318836212,
-0.4301290512084961,
-0.32828590273857117,
0.6462822556495667,
0.003282899269834161,
0.8471440076828003,
-0.09466181695461273,
0.14910805225372314,
0.24855414032936096,
-0.11046063899993896,
0.507378101348877,
0.1722494661808014,
-0.07536368072032928,
0.2506675720214844,
0.2505420446395874,
-0.578240156173706,
-1.2571375370025635,
0.18338246643543243,
-0.5649891495704651,
-0.48968395590782166,
-0.6177460551261902,
-0.7950723171234131,
-0.2173035591840744,
-0.08611693233251572,
-0.33255884051322937,
0.2806953191757202,
-0.1307516098022461,
0.2272932231426239,
0.4018525779247284,
-0.19450561702251434,
-0.005081384442746639,
0.8253707885742188,
0.12471403181552887,
-0.22395212948322296,
1.0804955959320068,
-0.0016424872446805239,
-0.07296799123287201,
0.39245373010635376,
0.18050161004066467,
-0.31792542338371277,
-0.43387627601623535,
-0.4052538275718689,
0.48026496171951294,
-0.6242864727973938,
0.18910430371761322,
-0.5311069488525391,
0.020449044182896614,
0.015962595120072365,
0.019533472135663033,
-0.16943952441215515,
-0.7167064547538757,
-0.31069156527519226,
0.03946775197982788,
0.133607417345047,
0.4066835939884186,
-0.0014403414679691195,
0.49747225642204285,
-0.5058175325393677,
0.46652892231941223,
0.09775616228580475,
0.13441941142082214,
0.14379528164863586,
-0.819376528263092,
0.1666431576013565,
0.18161329627037048,
-0.00000441863539890619,
-0.9110074639320374,
0.42563268542289734,
-0.03116386942565441,
0.3453481197357178,
0.3367944061756134,
0.07614180445671082,
0.6811375021934509,
-0.27192240953445435,
0.6533386707305908,
0.6154170632362366,
-0.9652795195579529,
0.15278078615665436,
-0.5311752557754517,
-0.2183694839477539,
0.15111039578914642,
0.23332823812961578,
-0.6193995475769043,
-0.303443968296051,
-0.6675379872322083,
-0.5692755579948425,
0.41562893986701965,
0.3846023380756378,
0.6079805493354797,
-0.07097756117582321,
0.4737052917480469,
0.03891320526599884,
0.18420107662677765,
-0.831784188747406,
0.03138144686818123,
-0.06572482734918594,
-0.2753714323043823,
-0.09217517822980881,
-0.05350606143474579,
-0.17909272015094757,
-0.24902524054050446,
0.5743967890739441,
-0.009579891338944435,
0.1724918931722641,
-0.20893210172653198,
-0.025489183142781258,
-0.023351091891527176,
0.4228953719139099,
0.5587831735610962,
0.8776437640190125,
-0.11195926368236542,
0.08875379711389542,
-0.06175508350133896,
-0.3001105487346649,
0.012544870376586914,
0.05865519866347313,
-0.0969017893075943,
-0.0685124471783638,
0.4383528232574463,
0.8647298216819763,
0.23505771160125732,
-1.1000105142593384,
0.5736215710639954,
-0.24155986309051514,
-0.044766828417778015,
-0.480168879032135,
0.10998815298080444,
0.18963012099266052,
0.2116752564907074,
0.37584996223449707,
0.05911262705922127,
0.03620607778429985,
-0.47861483693122864,
0.27475762367248535,
0.6625916361808777,
-0.29189440608024597,
-0.3979671597480774,
0.49372240900993347,
-0.007707243785262108,
-0.28930988907814026,
0.5270885229110718,
-0.23705480992794037,
-0.1519644856452942,
0.7511687278747559,
0.5594488978385925,
0.712364137172699,
0.06797469407320023,
0.3573016822338104,
0.2853783667087555,
0.3355794847011566,
-0.11915572732686996,
0.3448270857334137,
-0.1665620505809784,
-0.894474446773529,
-0.46186792850494385,
-0.5271323323249817,
-0.5054284334182739,
0.1463417261838913,
-0.7718365788459778,
-0.055483538657426834,
-0.6059144139289856,
-0.21483758091926575,
0.3567543029785156,
-0.2948760390281677,
-0.4575558006763458,
0.23464444279670715,
-0.09610753506422043,
0.8011319637298584,
-0.8978868126869202,
0.7712832093238831,
0.845356285572052,
-0.7382926940917969,
-1.0864461660385132,
-0.07841474562883377,
-0.28341999650001526,
-0.6198543310165405,
0.8588230013847351,
0.3026074171066284,
-0.35015466809272766,
-0.1405663639307022,
-0.4518977105617523,
-0.6945431232452393,
0.9166609644889832,
0.7942498326301575,
-0.5600154995918274,
0.002070152899250388,
0.14133746922016144,
0.6175826787948608,
-0.7132529020309448,
0.1351558119058609,
0.6082317233085632,
0.36151111125946045,
0.19710157811641693,
-0.6327856183052063,
0.19254207611083984,
-0.11884897947311401,
0.18479274213314056,
-0.089967742562294,
-0.4256184697151184,
0.9751793146133423,
-0.06581466645002365,
-0.37363535165786743,
0.15288889408111572,
1.0757346153259277,
0.5361194610595703,
0.5273853540420532,
0.5709034204483032,
0.3439987897872925,
0.793849527835846,
0.16772718727588654,
0.965398907661438,
-0.257973313331604,
0.2196809947490692,
1.060383915901184,
-0.056833233684301376,
0.9078837037086487,
0.6157921552658081,
-0.23248904943466187,
0.54022616147995,
0.362151175737381,
0.31797102093696594,
0.23376712203025818,
0.46358031034469604,
-0.3837778568267822,
-0.6376940608024597,
-0.15501603484153748,
-0.16587334871292114,
0.5732744336128235,
0.5273712277412415,
-0.6650944352149963,
-0.03752635419368744,
-0.11712361872196198,
-0.22211968898773193,
0.44836676120758057,
-0.19905078411102295,
0.32775968313217163,
0.2953518331050873,
-0.5244127511978149,
0.5739768147468567,
0.25828438997268677,
0.4024851322174072,
-0.43457308411598206,
-0.22096846997737885,
0.2345801144838333,
-0.04459844529628754,
0.20596712827682495,
-0.33967074751853943,
0.40031370520591736,
-0.17767487466335297,
-0.11593356728553772,
-0.0883374959230423,
0.4493626058101654,
-0.21208488941192627,
-0.19255892932415009,
0.11549577116966248,
0.5370770692825317,
0.319131076335907,
-0.011583378538489342,
-0.92424476146698,
0.2798958420753479,
-0.35351163148880005,
-0.10766133666038513,
0.32102543115615845,
0.45023471117019653,
-0.08768317848443985,
0.9958336353302002,
0.530809760093689,
0.14879748225212097,
-0.17578217387199402,
-0.12978066504001617,
0.7070513367652893,
-0.7659152746200562,
-0.9378781318664551,
-0.788856029510498,
0.1884176880121231,
-0.07322262227535248,
-0.12463375926017761,
0.47355911135673523,
0.17973236739635468,
0.545484721660614,
-0.024473831057548523,
0.6114664673805237,
0.26415523886680603,
0.513725757598877,
-0.3692108392715454,
0.5824796557426453,
-0.3976474702358246,
0.44162020087242126,
-0.18010616302490234,
-0.7198572754859924,
-0.41849032044410706,
1.3157340288162231,
-0.4872985780239105,
-0.14185479283332825,
0.5276762247085571,
0.7742241024971008,
-0.18363246321678162,
0.6506176590919495,
0.39336737990379333,
0.04614453390240669,
0.06515099853277206,
0.4342762529850006,
1.062882661819458,
-0.10664118081331253,
0.15606309473514557,
0.01579747349023819,
-0.18797259032726288,
0.21498523652553558,
-0.7495893239974976,
-0.8159288763999939,
-0.7571118474006653,
-0.26678982377052307,
-0.3003289997577667,
0.12354331463575363,
1.0771803855895996,
0.6662344336509705,
-0.4298754930496216,
-0.3596421480178833,
-0.3547810912132263,
0.2676370441913605,
-0.45283594727516174,
-0.19867849349975586,
0.10922673344612122,
-0.4872063398361206,
-0.5910030007362366,
0.23750142753124237,
0.4044058620929718,
-0.02190987765789032,
-0.3881714642047882,
-0.15334340929985046,
0.16759267449378967,
0.7794855237007141,
0.5782546997070312,
0.3718114495277405,
-1.0024458169937134,
-0.29781582951545715,
-0.4053780734539032,
-0.06430018693208694,
0.041068606078624725,
0.9227666854858398,
-0.9638689160346985,
0.3583485782146454,
0.2644650936126709,
0.6613608002662659,
0.07781627774238586,
0.00984321627765894,
0.816446840763092,
-0.1507798284292221,
0.35275861620903015,
0.30458909273147583,
0.2855985462665558,
0.22847889363765717,
-0.021997055038809776,
0.3000522553920746,
0.5551733374595642,
0.23913133144378662,
-1.118815302848816,
0.5400471687316895,
-1.2104711532592773,
-0.3732396960258484,
1.0672107934951782,
-0.226664736866951,
-0.3792640268802643,
-0.1399601548910141,
-0.06992989778518677,
0.40098854899406433,
-0.5273234844207764,
0.8466565608978271,
0.567030131816864,
0.03903292492032051,
-0.18851469457149506,
-0.5103847980499268,
0.494629442691803,
0.6777503490447998,
-0.4874058663845062,
0.4397062659263611,
0.6344084739685059,
0.34342485666275024,
-0.03886938467621803,
0.7676811218261719,
-0.023208187893033028,
0.4969416558742523,
-0.018895411863923073,
-0.35735252499580383,
-0.05033574625849724,
-0.3266064524650574,
-0.5576573014259338,
0.6000810265541077,
-0.040557924658060074,
-0.19581280648708344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02904v1
|
ALOHa: A New Measure for Hallucination in Captioning Models
| 2024-04-03T17:59:36 | 2024-04-03T17:59:36 |
Suzanne Petryk, David M. Chan, Anish Kachinthaya, Haodi Zou, John Canny, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Trevor Darrell
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite recent advances in multimodal pre-training for visual description,
state-of-the-art models still produce captions containing errors, such as
hallucinating objects not present in a scene. The existing prominent metric for
object hallucination, CHAIR, is limited to a fixed set of MS COCO objects and
synonyms. In this work, we propose a modernized open-vocabulary metric, ALOHa,
which leverages large language models (LLMs) to measure object hallucinations.
Specifically, we use an LLM to extract groundable objects from a candidate
caption, measure their semantic similarity to reference objects from captions
and object detections, and use Hungarian matching to produce a final
hallucination score. We show that ALOHa correctly identifies 13.6% more
hallucinated objects than CHAIR on HAT, a new gold-standard subset of MS COCO
Captions annotated for hallucinations, and 30.8% more on nocaps, where objects
extend beyond MS COCO categories. Our code is available at
https://davidmchan.github.io/aloha/.
|
[
-0.6324982643127441,
-0.8464381694793701,
0.39103543758392334,
0.004063769243657589,
-0.6718084812164307,
-0.3892483413219452,
-0.17464454472064972,
-0.6694979667663574,
0.7714369297027588,
0.6691179871559143,
-0.29716479778289795,
-0.670981228351593,
-0.5168575048446655,
0.3066364526748657,
-0.5448075532913208,
0.6609430909156799,
-0.1635996699333191,
0.044675666838884354,
-0.4761083424091339,
-0.4902966320514679,
-0.7468635439872742,
-0.5871143937110901,
0.06765595078468323,
0.013047573156654835,
0.7590210437774658,
0.34637078642845154,
1.0299471616744995,
0.42216309905052185,
0.6695545315742493,
0.1408175528049469,
0.3780630826950073,
0.30397507548332214,
-0.22670826315879822,
-0.1118864193558693,
0.015231423079967499,
-0.3577956259250641,
-0.5769117474555969,
0.0552835538983345,
0.33521682024002075,
0.6813432574272156,
-0.18477746844291687,
-0.08973640948534012,
-0.17576883733272552,
0.6397080421447754,
-0.8861238360404968,
0.5247749090194702,
-0.9116445779800415,
0.44291412830352783,
0.17936985194683075,
-0.533598005771637,
-0.19291184842586517,
-0.20090869069099426,
-0.07306081056594849,
-0.7559584379196167,
0.19753079116344452,
0.4484500288963318,
1.0136053562164307,
0.48200294375419617,
0.006124407518655062,
-0.7412764430046082,
-0.3957122564315796,
0.7426905632019043,
-0.46019837260246277,
0.6569222211837769,
0.43129900097846985,
0.389126181602478,
-0.011289014481008053,
-0.3190515339374542,
-0.9849666953086853,
-0.6625655889511108,
0.0037205000407993793,
-0.05127965658903122,
0.071637362241745,
-0.10150086879730225,
-0.03537125140428543,
0.5799388885498047,
-0.37078845500946045,
0.07245071977376938,
-0.5384920239448547,
-0.3053039014339447,
0.3524770140647888,
-0.11083946377038956,
0.47934460639953613,
-0.3011622726917267,
-0.3632712662220001,
-0.16659468412399292,
-0.6471496820449829,
-0.46309834718704224,
0.21082854270935059,
0.46014782786369324,
0.018196173012256622,
0.9013454914093018,
-0.18045417964458466,
0.4700416326522827,
-0.5123326182365417,
0.023522162809967995,
0.33323153853416443,
0.08345306664705276,
-0.20584820210933685,
0.30499792098999023,
0.7332702279090881,
0.6948561072349548,
0.47553324699401855,
-0.3779143989086151,
-0.06518144905567169,
0.3509499430656433,
0.2878221273422241,
-0.6358224153518677,
-0.5632405877113342,
0.1344062089920044,
-0.4654654860496521,
-0.1547667682170868,
0.39225906133651733,
-0.736528217792511,
-0.6962320804595947,
-0.41499778628349304,
0.5945715308189392,
-0.19706569612026215,
-0.1685965359210968,
0.3937099874019623,
0.17456753551959991,
0.5583434700965881,
0.2375631183385849,
-0.6737697124481201,
0.3752744495868683,
0.5361977219581604,
1.0976532697677612,
-0.5419859290122986,
-0.3648830056190491,
-0.7293035984039307,
-0.22954867780208588,
-0.8329395651817322,
0.8075882196426392,
-0.32162725925445557,
-0.19542625546455383,
0.1237265020608902,
0.20908938348293304,
0.10459934175014496,
-0.7986508011817932,
0.2368844896554947,
-0.29831674695014954,
0.010633230209350586,
-0.12395276129245758,
-0.2626756727695465,
-0.5046700239181519,
0.30797573924064636,
-0.8629975318908691,
0.6711034774780273,
0.04904315993189812,
-0.4454435706138611,
0.42917191982269287,
-0.35015106201171875,
-0.26209190487861633,
-0.04243304952979088,
-0.43398162722587585,
-0.6012123823165894,
0.3664529323577881,
0.3484196066856384,
0.5885637998580933,
-0.13218693435192108,
0.2754087746143341,
-0.5324060916900635,
-0.6156489849090576,
0.2954206168651581,
-0.022885315120220184,
0.38544872403144836,
0.11637719720602036,
-0.14749464392662048,
0.5009477734565735,
-0.5954828858375549,
-0.27159565687179565,
0.021046672016382217,
-0.03556939586997032,
-0.1782674491405487,
-0.015376121737062931,
-0.04024174436926842,
0.044989727437496185,
0.050788138061761856,
-0.2453664094209671,
0.03847074136137962,
-0.2227964550256729,
0.09345735609531403,
0.6439105272293091,
-0.12456323951482773,
0.18342360854148865,
-0.3099733889102936,
0.46476298570632935,
-0.12292207032442093,
0.20203275978565216,
-0.16042394936084747,
-0.5137565732002258,
-0.9496526122093201,
-0.4805600941181183,
-0.33620601892471313,
0.23491673171520233,
-0.5327072739601135,
0.9461402297019958,
-0.21526981890201569,
-0.33079206943511963,
-0.3855525851249695,
0.11590729653835297,
0.07572763413190842,
0.1682775467634201,
0.4456646144390106,
-0.8874900937080383,
-0.4416283071041107,
-0.8708776235580444,
0.2200661450624466,
-0.1383041888475418,
-0.10627882182598114,
0.47351107001304626,
0.6310896873474121,
-0.27410608530044556,
0.584197998046875,
-0.4689730405807495,
-1.2599046230316162,
0.13603077828884125,
-0.04653800278902054,
0.04457326978445053,
0.21141865849494934,
0.49415579438209534,
-0.49044451117515564,
-0.14317119121551514,
0.2622238099575043,
-1.149950385093689,
0.19178129732608795,
-0.12146058678627014,
-0.17175114154815674,
0.18033143877983093,
0.6021842360496521,
-0.7907403707504272,
0.4724830389022827,
0.3250176012516022,
-0.24643580615520477,
0.6684889793395996,
-0.08109430223703384,
0.28791776299476624,
-0.6702886819839478,
0.17997156083583832,
-0.7014001607894897,
0.16182594001293182,
-0.11660094559192657,
0.35663554072380066,
-0.2013247013092041,
-0.1971483677625656,
-0.6955983638763428,
0.4150230586528778,
-0.7633565068244934,
-0.4463050961494446,
-0.29554158449172974,
0.5327537655830383,
-0.11766733229160309,
0.7888343930244446,
0.17832663655281067,
0.4111349880695343,
0.8856454491615295,
-0.6176599860191345,
0.7283686995506287,
0.38789889216423035,
-0.6648128032684326,
0.41740021109580994,
-0.3513999879360199,
0.25876671075820923,
-0.3360011577606201,
0.1536981463432312,
-1.0623680353164673,
-0.4053102731704712,
0.568549633026123,
-0.4453660249710083,
-0.11737809330224991,
0.5848438143730164,
-0.3759000599384308,
-0.32448917627334595,
-0.5231401324272156,
0.43103212118148804,
0.22407934069633484,
-0.6167741417884827,
0.8712447285652161,
0.16119447350502014,
0.1300991326570511,
-0.7345409989356995,
-0.5237891674041748,
0.22037485241889954,
-0.31826481223106384,
0.03316643089056015,
-0.07236348092556,
-0.412742018699646,
-0.12317828088998795,
-0.0715310201048851,
-0.27018237113952637,
-0.00014932490012142807,
0.046865250915288925,
0.42912614345550537,
0.3386077880859375,
-0.28224945068359375,
0.28112852573394775,
-0.26443231105804443,
0.31970441341400146,
0.22238345444202423,
0.0006704307743348181,
0.8600023984909058,
-0.22090886533260345,
-0.4972537159919739,
-0.7138159871101379,
0.18811841309070587,
0.7341218590736389,
-0.13155917823314667,
0.6648169755935669,
0.5051767826080322,
-0.7471319437026978,
0.20144473016262054,
-0.6091383695602417,
-0.47710174322128296,
-0.35436758399009705,
0.5647973418235779,
-0.6033242344856262,
-0.4391438663005829,
0.6995698809623718,
0.5340074300765991,
-0.12138233333826065,
0.2945685088634491,
0.32476896047592163,
0.2913387715816498,
0.7751196026802063,
0.3661911189556122,
-0.15365561842918396,
0.18658055365085602,
-0.18907344341278076,
0.429603636264801,
-0.6543797254562378,
-0.4268198013305664,
-0.41288504004478455,
-0.029003547504544258,
-0.3082398772239685,
-0.721577525138855,
0.013914462178945541,
0.3123956024646759,
0.07470845431089401,
0.17493432760238647,
-0.5145546197891235,
0.6613666415214539,
0.2867484390735626,
0.13826051354408264,
0.5022829174995422,
0.2761794328689575,
0.22312861680984497,
0.19018150866031647,
-0.26212286949157715,
-0.49457836151123047,
1.0409692525863647,
0.3046644628047943,
0.5946911573410034,
-0.07206007838249207,
0.6416571736335754,
0.370650053024292,
0.6531140804290771,
-1.2692886590957642,
0.6484520435333252,
-0.0027531294617801905,
-0.5290113091468811,
-0.5800632238388062,
-0.2653258144855499,
-0.777869701385498,
0.3850301206111908,
-0.2840709090232849,
-0.7675760984420776,
0.050042130053043365,
0.04004142805933952,
-0.2970382869243622,
0.2928237020969391,
0.026214029639959335,
0.990655779838562,
-0.10314931720495224,
-0.021805912256240845,
-0.25829145312309265,
-0.29037174582481384,
0.4454684853553772,
-0.028648311272263527,
0.3304014801979065,
-0.4510352313518524,
-0.08001593500375748,
0.8249067664146423,
-0.1291881501674652,
0.675008237361908,
0.056657131761312485,
-0.42031729221343994,
0.6354464888572693,
0.38322189450263977,
0.3206471800804138,
-0.21160706877708435,
0.3504526913166046,
0.4984005093574524,
-0.22951152920722961,
-0.21448250114917755,
-0.5499691963195801,
0.8663352131843567,
-0.5424804091453552,
-0.44308698177337646,
-0.3632224202156067,
-0.7261119484901428,
-0.020166266709566116,
0.10508246719837189,
0.2312767058610916,
0.1560872495174408,
-0.2042984962463379,
0.44549793004989624,
0.4650450050830841,
-0.4714024066925049,
0.11650202423334122,
0.2018461674451828,
-0.6165619492530823,
-0.49314364790916443,
0.9590755701065063,
0.037692807614803314,
-0.002032828750088811,
0.49190399050712585,
0.21052704751491547,
-0.3796349763870239,
-0.41547197103500366,
-0.36914584040641785,
0.41264811158180237,
-1.0149505138397217,
-0.23332586884498596,
-0.7205657958984375,
-0.002970373257994652,
-0.45581281185150146,
-0.23048262298107147,
-0.3262691795825958,
-0.3908120095729828,
-0.44495096802711487,
-0.40916553139686584,
0.16766412556171417,
0.6123091578483582,
0.11442245543003082,
0.05179363116621971,
-0.3728938698768616,
0.6863422393798828,
0.3914991617202759,
0.4910498261451721,
0.22702975571155548,
-0.5157670974731445,
-0.09071416407823563,
-0.3408605754375458,
-0.18309897184371948,
-0.9027266502380371,
0.5436477065086365,
0.27052971720695496,
0.3941364884376526,
0.8071972727775574,
0.12459110468626022,
0.612294614315033,
-0.2918299436569214,
0.7859909534454346,
0.6301385760307312,
-0.8551844358444214,
0.3717992603778839,
-0.07598351687192917,
0.009364656172692776,
0.22557386755943298,
0.3629399836063385,
-0.4683926999568939,
-0.5591257214546204,
-0.08820144832134247,
-0.6574912071228027,
0.2653349041938782,
0.039691805839538574,
0.4633508622646332,
-0.33583271503448486,
0.09057936817407608,
0.5168491005897522,
0.30356696248054504,
-1.1870286464691162,
0.06408113241195679,
-0.3226698935031891,
-0.17235849797725677,
-0.2329215556383133,
-0.13736826181411743,
-0.07355733215808868,
-0.30686530470848083,
0.520889937877655,
-0.32380741834640503,
0.27745553851127625,
0.06125100702047348,
-0.22468982636928558,
-0.29207444190979004,
-0.0001423031062586233,
0.5473427176475525,
0.659603476524353,
-0.37886106967926025,
0.3955971896648407,
0.18662239611148834,
-0.4416472613811493,
-0.18919779360294342,
-0.2264573872089386,
0.21525900065898895,
0.20740275084972382,
0.6074054837226868,
0.8362173438072205,
0.20380137860774994,
-1.0151201486587524,
0.5584967732429504,
0.3086085021495819,
-0.23525092005729675,
-0.48887333273887634,
-0.002561877714470029,
-0.3174286186695099,
-0.169418066740036,
0.1651994287967682,
-0.22092962265014648,
0.2690349519252777,
-0.991033673286438,
0.3399520814418793,
0.4627784788608551,
-0.828291654586792,
-0.22565917670726776,
0.9385246634483337,
-0.08190342038869858,
-0.21586313843727112,
0.711713969707489,
-0.08029332011938095,
-0.24098224937915802,
0.6703344583511353,
0.15469315648078918,
1.0586498975753784,
-0.2906608283519745,
0.1275664120912552,
0.5528844594955444,
0.34923627972602844,
-0.10875941812992096,
0.41031524538993835,
-0.2510247826576233,
-0.7653282284736633,
0.10336687415838242,
-0.9092414379119873,
-0.11767503619194031,
0.1481020301580429,
-0.7749842405319214,
0.47007545828819275,
-0.3358370065689087,
0.21775959432125092,
-0.25455862283706665,
-0.506431519985199,
-0.6318511962890625,
0.07163839042186737,
0.14108557999134064,
0.29022887349128723,
-0.9940848350524902,
0.5270387530326843,
0.31655290722846985,
-0.6470842957496643,
-0.3273600935935974,
-0.10974671691656113,
-0.31403282284736633,
-0.7358502149581909,
0.3214215338230133,
0.8083066344261169,
-0.24550043046474457,
-0.4462617039680481,
-0.3705681562423706,
-0.6461008191108704,
1.0045428276062012,
-0.022641457617282867,
-0.6354624032974243,
-0.025728343054652214,
0.22918449342250824,
0.4145304560661316,
-0.6290284991264343,
-0.00010389423550805077,
0.5632321834564209,
0.22573857009410858,
-0.03796881437301636,
-0.7828754186630249,
0.16553179919719696,
0.11500103026628494,
-0.18926309049129486,
-0.21462421119213104,
-0.3264232277870178,
0.6857704520225525,
-0.6291582584381104,
-0.35317665338516235,
0.4935591518878937,
0.983714759349823,
0.3090904653072357,
0.45615503191947937,
0.7518836259841919,
0.3535807430744171,
0.7520782947540283,
0.07303091883659363,
0.8649194240570068,
0.01628456823527813,
0.23205335438251495,
1.2913554906845093,
-0.23465120792388916,
1.0485891103744507,
0.7337542772293091,
-0.03757812827825546,
0.422061562538147,
0.5255150198936462,
0.09167753905057907,
0.5711437463760376,
0.6165693402290344,
0.019183283671736717,
-0.23342269659042358,
-0.3101029694080353,
-0.3356993496417999,
0.4496106803417206,
0.20914126932621002,
-0.2959755063056946,
0.2908842861652374,
0.6507413387298584,
-0.1468207687139511,
0.21466143429279327,
-0.3274332582950592,
0.7357298731803894,
0.2776855230331421,
-0.6735626459121704,
1.0158087015151978,
-0.5013722777366638,
0.47368815541267395,
-0.23287765681743622,
-0.26739537715911865,
-0.34837085008621216,
0.08889555186033249,
-0.10060259699821472,
-0.4082420766353607,
0.3256767988204956,
-0.23967574536800385,
0.10476545989513397,
0.4401802718639374,
0.032267842441797256,
-0.5090228915214539,
-0.4411284625530243,
0.5998616218566895,
0.24597057700157166,
0.933865487575531,
-0.4750334620475769,
-0.106637142598629,
0.3721124827861786,
-0.2451188713312149,
0.006259317509829998,
-0.09299638122320175,
0.24991242587566376,
-0.2224595844745636,
0.6222510933876038,
0.2693125903606415,
-0.05931706726551056,
0.24410803616046906,
0.5852981209754944,
0.4985446631908417,
-0.5729832053184509,
-0.4446236193180084,
-0.5810222625732422,
0.04239937663078308,
0.23578360676765442,
-0.2477923333644867,
0.5035284757614136,
0.7844101786613464,
0.8741704225540161,
-0.6110521554946899,
0.2635701298713684,
0.043220631778240204,
0.015313050709664822,
-0.7102714776992798,
0.663555920124054,
-0.8326388597488403,
0.2645527124404907,
-0.27126744389533997,
-1.671424150466919,
-0.5681102275848389,
0.8121979236602783,
0.15886999666690826,
-0.1960802972316742,
0.8663780689239502,
1.0659786462783813,
-0.06154903769493103,
-0.2886171340942383,
0.6426241993904114,
0.27641570568084717,
0.14286360144615173,
0.4323370158672333,
0.9558075070381165,
-0.4820496737957001,
0.736990213394165,
-0.25751689076423645,
-0.2618881165981293,
-0.4031699299812317,
-0.6474420428276062,
-1.0733400583267212,
-0.7261039018630981,
-0.611097514629364,
-0.1877671182155609,
0.01206291001290083,
0.715645432472229,
0.646669328212738,
-1.1578154563903809,
-0.34955158829689026,
-0.09720875322818756,
-0.035025130957365036,
-0.6201063394546509,
-0.2772715389728546,
0.7052859663963318,
-0.16647285223007202,
-0.7269464135169983,
0.19318638741970062,
0.17463330924510956,
0.07683299481868744,
-0.5918603539466858,
-0.34927037358283997,
0.1381114423274994,
0.3374936580657959,
0.8111396431922913,
-0.04453334957361221,
-1.2933591604232788,
-0.6015045046806335,
0.08435194939374924,
0.16936586797237396,
0.24359561502933502,
0.7310068011283875,
-0.5079871416091919,
0.8245056867599487,
0.3178369998931885,
0.14874127507209778,
0.30183839797973633,
-0.2569381594657898,
0.1275874227285385,
-0.5242886543273926,
0.31450819969177246,
0.11901681870222092,
0.5740002393722534,
0.5874965190887451,
-0.27882570028305054,
0.5908163785934448,
0.19840486347675323,
-0.135990709066391,
-1.027801513671875,
0.11204646527767181,
-1.2666912078857422,
-0.3688054084777832,
0.9116580486297607,
0.11120495200157166,
-0.3179367482662201,
0.12463626265525818,
-0.5334821343421936,
0.15375858545303345,
-0.055384766310453415,
1.4856082201004028,
0.8415407538414001,
0.024668388068675995,
-0.2940152585506439,
-0.5459957122802734,
0.43701836466789246,
0.1833735853433609,
-0.9718477129936218,
0.3162274956703186,
0.7649130821228027,
-0.06442811340093613,
0.5309844613075256,
0.5499175190925598,
-0.34371519088745117,
0.4213334321975708,
-0.009301218204200268,
0.590222179889679,
0.033607009798288345,
-0.9453108906745911,
-0.11700122058391571,
0.23526063561439514,
0.014536876231431961,
-0.6309642791748047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02893v1
|
ChatGLM-Math: Improving Math Problem-Solving in Large Language Models with a Self-Critique Pipeline
| 2024-04-03T17:51:18 | 2024-04-03T17:51:18 |
Yifan Xu, Xiao Liu, Xinghan Liu, Zhenyu Hou, Yueyan Li, Xiaohan Zhang, Zihan Wang, Aohan Zeng, Zhengxiao Du, Wenyi Zhao, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown excellent mastering of human
language, but still struggle in real-world applications that require
mathematical problem-solving. While many strategies and datasets to enhance
LLMs' mathematics are developed, it remains a challenge to simultaneously
maintain and improve both language and mathematical capabilities in deployed
LLM systems.In this work, we tailor the Self-Critique pipeline, which addresses
the challenge in the feedback learning stage of LLM alignment. We first train a
general Math-Critique model from the LLM itself to provide feedback signals.
Then, we sequentially employ rejective fine-tuning and direct preference
optimization over the LLM's own generations for data collection. Based on
ChatGLM3-32B, we conduct a series of experiments on both academic and our newly
created challenging dataset, MathUserEval. Results show that our pipeline
significantly enhances the LLM's mathematical problem-solving while still
improving its language ability, outperforming LLMs that could be two times
larger. Related techniques have been deployed to
ChatGLM\footnote{\url{https://chatglm.cn}}, an online serving LLM. Related
evaluation dataset and scripts are released at
\url{https://github.com/THUDM/ChatGLM-Math}.
|
[
-0.3126983344554901,
-0.5835797786712646,
0.35806238651275635,
0.2628463804721832,
0.006523612421005964,
0.38004350662231445,
-0.4819330871105194,
-0.13756288588047028,
0.10638345777988434,
0.5236462950706482,
-0.9214738607406616,
-0.4421254098415375,
-0.4100356996059418,
0.0609968863427639,
-0.20572912693023682,
1.2692980766296387,
-0.055376239120960236,
0.4290771484375,
-0.48550522327423096,
0.07889752835035324,
-0.46762701869010925,
-0.622646152973175,
-0.6566444635391235,
-0.3985959589481354,
0.4937874376773834,
0.5589061975479126,
0.6315408945083618,
0.3789219558238983,
0.82431960105896,
0.30660539865493774,
0.047227296978235245,
0.21185430884361267,
-1.0180423259735107,
0.4237528443336487,
-0.0017805589595809579,
-0.5402615070343018,
-0.4941927194595337,
-0.1752479374408722,
0.7563249468803406,
0.7505183815956116,
-0.4092159569263458,
0.32247844338417053,
0.3480818569660187,
0.8439773321151733,
-0.4595606327056885,
0.43489012122154236,
-0.6683330535888672,
0.06940720230340958,
-0.21037615835666656,
0.12281586229801178,
-0.3679099678993225,
-0.442425012588501,
0.10958506166934967,
-0.5913162231445312,
0.16488468647003174,
0.08895737677812576,
0.37613052129745483,
0.41694608330726624,
-0.00024430686607956886,
-0.3385623097419739,
-0.7440716028213501,
0.8922567963600159,
-0.7178999185562134,
0.24575039744377136,
0.21828614175319672,
0.32946422696113586,
-0.28169506788253784,
-0.3402653932571411,
-0.3512856364250183,
-0.0412391722202301,
0.07079889625310898,
0.2808983623981476,
-0.1914811134338379,
-0.22235311567783356,
0.22218894958496094,
0.38824334740638733,
-0.553088366985321,
0.1538332849740982,
-0.5900493860244751,
-0.40533626079559326,
0.7104210257530212,
0.4699578285217285,
-0.012090644799172878,
-0.09734799712896347,
-0.09055483341217041,
-0.020892174914479256,
-0.902182400226593,
-0.23235464096069336,
0.5465227961540222,
0.2012912929058075,
0.07570639252662659,
0.534687876701355,
-0.006492020096629858,
0.44467243552207947,
-0.11843291670084,
0.04496113955974579,
0.34740689396858215,
-0.12946678698062897,
0.006713707931339741,
-0.36547940969467163,
0.7439855337142944,
0.23478612303733826,
0.25706747174263,
0.0337522029876709,
-0.4208771288394928,
0.20529498159885406,
0.19282588362693787,
-0.6323636174201965,
-0.3395345211029053,
0.050470978021621704,
-0.18694622814655304,
-0.3356581926345825,
-0.3115541338920593,
-0.6592207551002502,
-0.5067000985145569,
-0.704168438911438,
0.4116261601448059,
-0.23051728308200836,
-0.05061138793826103,
0.27497363090515137,
0.3578486442565918,
0.09038212895393372,
0.6598872542381287,
-0.8746184706687927,
0.28168508410453796,
0.9750257730484009,
0.8016798496246338,
-0.3316131830215454,
-0.25087812542915344,
-0.7115851640701294,
-0.26497942209243774,
-0.21667121350765228,
0.7875085473060608,
-0.5095110535621643,
-0.40203654766082764,
0.015487496741116047,
-0.38253456354141235,
-0.053865253925323486,
-0.8975998759269714,
0.6548671126365662,
-0.41681572794914246,
0.5174874067306519,
-0.08709253370761871,
-0.7699955105781555,
0.22454634308815002,
0.41712480783462524,
-0.4635697603225708,
0.917582631111145,
-0.010884224437177181,
-0.5181891918182373,
-0.1679701805114746,
-0.6689118146896362,
-0.0200125053524971,
0.028746359050273895,
-0.06881778687238693,
-0.7109714150428772,
0.32045426964759827,
0.341164231300354,
0.20574484765529633,
-0.31529292464256287,
0.2660139203071594,
-0.5892245173454285,
-0.16238759458065033,
0.24962924420833588,
-0.35271215438842773,
0.47319719195365906,
0.43705978989601135,
0.028758779168128967,
0.22446569800376892,
-0.6016337275505066,
0.23967596888542175,
0.3028814494609833,
0.03358516842126846,
0.19018669426441193,
-0.0024326054845005274,
-0.15602757036685944,
0.22241167724132538,
0.3756297528743744,
-0.45318523049354553,
0.3571723401546478,
-0.44200414419174194,
0.44014492630958557,
0.9673972129821777,
-0.272433340549469,
0.19187785685062408,
-0.455547571182251,
0.8223577737808228,
-0.16219058632850647,
0.18750347197055817,
-0.1623222827911377,
-0.2444917857646942,
-0.9862275123596191,
-0.07578577846288681,
0.36228179931640625,
0.3722555339336395,
-0.5676476359367371,
0.15221728384494781,
-0.2887428402900696,
-0.38437747955322266,
-0.7632228136062622,
0.5817528963088989,
0.4081821143627167,
0.49458226561546326,
0.3761236071586609,
-0.40019604563713074,
-0.5634275674819946,
-0.8398655652999878,
-0.27488237619400024,
-0.11973738670349121,
-0.18927119672298431,
0.364726722240448,
0.1388288289308548,
-0.22376477718353271,
0.9254990220069885,
-0.7820848226547241,
-0.6379555463790894,
-0.08562179654836655,
0.04778038337826729,
0.30771616101264954,
0.30654457211494446,
0.09864872694015503,
-0.1644635796546936,
-0.47564297914505005,
-0.29363471269607544,
-0.6181656718254089,
-0.5552957653999329,
0.2493007481098175,
-0.2628619372844696,
0.025128623470664024,
0.3976437747478485,
-0.2066318690776825,
0.12018585205078125,
0.7693970203399658,
-0.15033169090747833,
0.7902182340621948,
-0.08612032234668732,
-0.39392906427383423,
-0.834563672542572,
-0.14672571420669556,
-0.12685540318489075,
-0.18427371978759766,
-0.23004193603992462,
0.10098038613796234,
-0.20058614015579224,
-0.41080501675605774,
-0.23560670018196106,
0.5112082362174988,
-0.4313943386077881,
0.006444940809160471,
-0.24985945224761963,
0.41016557812690735,
-0.1913638710975647,
0.5675607919692993,
-0.22235944867134094,
0.6510524153709412,
0.6308868527412415,
-0.18038353323936462,
0.5165400505065918,
0.25350889563560486,
-0.2260497510433197,
0.49785125255584717,
-0.7196841835975647,
0.45580583810806274,
-0.19735564291477203,
0.26331183314323425,
-1.0724371671676636,
-0.04896123707294464,
0.3320920765399933,
-0.34541821479797363,
0.24619604647159576,
-0.30341172218322754,
-0.48402395844459534,
-0.36535388231277466,
-0.3769688308238983,
0.4620228707790375,
0.5197567343711853,
-0.4809826910495758,
0.5066501498222351,
0.35513076186180115,
-0.35488051176071167,
-0.46904298663139343,
-0.2856736481189728,
0.05542416870594025,
-0.06880243122577667,
-0.7373462915420532,
0.10369351506233215,
-0.5040278434753418,
-0.23534584045410156,
-0.19311776757240295,
-0.13363951444625854,
0.2918238341808319,
0.040647245943546295,
0.08875177055597305,
0.5726275444030762,
-0.015512625686824322,
0.2521795928478241,
-0.26014232635498047,
-0.39569926261901855,
0.3494061231613159,
-0.5097379684448242,
0.6950955390930176,
-0.3605252802371979,
-0.5683379769325256,
-0.18676888942718506,
0.09043313562870026,
0.32090577483177185,
-0.24140006303787231,
0.34604281187057495,
0.3325292766094208,
-0.079239621758461,
-0.27329009771347046,
-0.6540138721466064,
-0.2800702750682831,
-0.4739066958427429,
0.23765645921230316,
-0.15180020034313202,
-1.159246802330017,
0.5513343811035156,
-0.05640800669789314,
0.30167147517204285,
0.4466764032840729,
0.8444908261299133,
-0.19392766058444977,
1.0252519845962524,
0.23743170499801636,
-0.26691141724586487,
0.2780376970767975,
-0.38146114349365234,
0.15692591667175293,
-0.9544278383255005,
-0.05085904151201248,
-0.4910092055797577,
-0.3979116976261139,
-0.34812068939208984,
-0.45189255475997925,
0.3941696584224701,
-0.054142676293849945,
-0.1607256531715393,
0.09154729545116425,
-0.424155592918396,
0.7545104026794434,
0.21873806416988373,
0.029416412115097046,
0.45722588896751404,
0.1361790895462036,
-0.3318072557449341,
-0.40559619665145874,
-0.6575084924697876,
-0.3936096131801605,
1.2045189142227173,
0.46713778376579285,
1.2145379781723022,
0.22421739995479584,
0.7546856999397278,
-0.056776199489831924,
0.619169294834137,
-0.9293034076690674,
0.44624531269073486,
-0.13286904990673065,
-0.462063193321228,
-0.2498873770236969,
-0.8269339203834534,
-0.9980317950248718,
0.3190471827983856,
-0.08895188570022583,
-0.625451922416687,
-0.41887331008911133,
0.33473849296569824,
-0.20924495160579681,
0.08956338465213776,
-0.7593340277671814,
0.788589358329773,
-0.3464127779006958,
-0.5384132862091064,
-0.34569984674453735,
-0.28143954277038574,
0.18092644214630127,
-0.12483639270067215,
0.4172234535217285,
-0.22423778474330902,
0.2384604960680008,
0.4585961699485779,
-0.6293624639511108,
0.9435285925865173,
0.021385349333286285,
-0.6072285771369934,
0.2274017333984375,
0.48969578742980957,
0.42000386118888855,
0.17077550292015076,
-0.001927441218867898,
0.08802438527345657,
-0.12572672963142395,
-0.2830800712108612,
-0.9817439317703247,
0.9243605136871338,
-0.9391468167304993,
-0.8808299899101257,
-0.32720714807510376,
-0.5280887484550476,
-0.47081243991851807,
0.046458952128887177,
-0.05171089246869087,
0.6090676784515381,
0.048038139939308167,
0.17129100859165192,
0.3375053405761719,
0.15099741518497467,
0.2557583153247833,
0.3903084099292755,
-0.855522096157074,
-0.5867534875869751,
0.9993159770965576,
0.11591318994760513,
0.34051212668418884,
0.12208793312311172,
0.3616832494735718,
-0.5465676784515381,
-0.4256303012371063,
-0.36701318621635437,
0.38874876499176025,
-0.7558645009994507,
-0.432258278131485,
-0.32120925188064575,
-0.417781263589859,
-0.1901882290840149,
0.18478809297084808,
-0.4755523204803467,
-0.529826283454895,
-0.24181067943572998,
0.2397141009569168,
0.1785786896944046,
0.6745161414146423,
-0.021613501012325287,
0.16295947134494781,
-0.7547157406806946,
-0.011937885545194149,
0.38379210233688354,
0.6717925071716309,
0.18733176589012146,
-0.7214298844337463,
-0.25510653853416443,
0.17441977560520172,
-0.6396626830101013,
-0.15949036180973053,
0.35062408447265625,
0.18048721551895142,
0.23241998255252838,
0.21360066533088684,
-0.06871120631694794,
0.7039260864257812,
-0.5789331197738647,
0.4682459533214569,
0.18307946622371674,
-1.019580364227295,
0.36925873160362244,
-0.3141540288925171,
0.4914390444755554,
0.36740395426750183,
0.08127181977033615,
-0.5900620818138123,
-0.4735317528247833,
-0.4791034758090973,
-0.4815466105937958,
0.5269973874092102,
0.539313554763794,
0.2844751179218292,
0.23660576343536377,
0.4379853308200836,
0.07664752751588821,
0.16166071593761444,
-0.7626011967658997,
-0.1828586906194687,
0.014476102776825428,
-0.32600146532058716,
-0.06584764271974564,
-0.21306872367858887,
-0.21881897747516632,
-0.20822511613368988,
0.6823601722717285,
-0.42596256732940674,
0.07967076450586319,
-0.04972664639353752,
-0.13210777938365936,
-0.26681625843048096,
0.2595609426498413,
0.44086503982543945,
0.8907820582389832,
0.1415899693965912,
0.10753738880157471,
0.33285993337631226,
-0.337966650724411,
0.038701798766851425,
0.04221169278025627,
-0.02294118143618107,
-0.26446500420570374,
0.2890339195728302,
0.6111518740653992,
0.2920971214771271,
-0.7045550346374512,
0.3456794023513794,
-0.16651500761508942,
-0.24601294100284576,
-0.4044262766838074,
0.19593854248523712,
0.06568174809217453,
0.11003170162439346,
0.43802323937416077,
-0.04075678437948227,
0.11386983841657639,
-0.28551405668258667,
0.002655226970091462,
0.6254507899284363,
-0.2850220203399658,
-0.31326597929000854,
0.49463599920272827,
0.12286767363548279,
-0.3447117507457733,
0.6338415145874023,
-0.03643755614757538,
-0.8618546724319458,
0.3467525243759155,
0.6625992655754089,
0.8022832870483398,
-0.03159944340586662,
0.14361406862735748,
0.31465139985084534,
-0.037116460502147675,
0.03930383548140526,
0.08236921578645706,
0.13535889983177185,
-0.8288248181343079,
-0.7670411467552185,
-0.534906268119812,
-0.699975848197937,
-0.028368644416332245,
-0.5392646193504333,
0.6190764904022217,
-0.5166432857513428,
-0.0015356708317995071,
-0.11686696112155914,
0.160453662276268,
-0.5835254788398743,
-0.06964549422264099,
0.25596266984939575,
0.35947293043136597,
-0.19928376376628876,
0.4422413110733032,
0.5120791792869568,
0.0548991896212101,
-0.7433085441589355,
-0.18483230471611023,
0.2519642114639282,
-1.126239538192749,
0.5697714686393738,
0.09596893191337585,
-0.39975112676620483,
0.1002688929438591,
-0.7346592545509338,
-0.9199258685112,
0.7610177397727966,
0.6710110902786255,
-1.0004401206970215,
0.11004418134689331,
0.09116644412279129,
0.8110786080360413,
-0.2923348844051361,
0.48605218529701233,
0.23079806566238403,
0.08004306256771088,
0.4195828139781952,
-0.9978868365287781,
-0.2916851341724396,
-0.3403075933456421,
-0.056468237191438675,
0.495853066444397,
-1.0039101839065552,
0.442436546087265,
-0.17448629438877106,
-0.039670418947935104,
-0.025839345529675484,
0.7018440365791321,
0.3576105833053589,
0.10090310871601105,
0.5827150344848633,
0.8512669801712036,
0.7212533354759216,
-0.09310870617628098,
0.7605841755867004,
-0.25486886501312256,
0.9449284076690674,
1.3143130540847778,
-0.3487987518310547,
0.7525242567062378,
0.3281932473182678,
-0.3155459463596344,
0.49776148796081543,
0.3544495701789856,
-0.14088387787342072,
0.14559465646743774,
0.7391226887702942,
-0.14909929037094116,
-0.4243535101413727,
0.025261087343096733,
-0.3895089626312256,
0.4546627700328827,
0.25627774000167847,
0.05454186350107193,
-0.4065561592578888,
-0.2770250141620636,
0.05722576007246971,
0.062019508332014084,
-0.3365441858768463,
0.7134958505630493,
0.2036067545413971,
-0.6846033930778503,
0.6399624943733215,
-0.19788675010204315,
0.41997721791267395,
-0.49319151043891907,
0.053509727120399475,
-0.3983435034751892,
0.3805699646472931,
-0.2117321491241455,
-0.7215712666511536,
0.340307354927063,
0.0072848005220294,
0.03816280886530876,
-0.2804993987083435,
0.4965378940105438,
-0.6049529314041138,
-0.7632282972335815,
0.23099257051944733,
0.5957140326499939,
-0.02860979177057743,
0.08357831835746765,
-0.6920199394226074,
0.29676011204719543,
-0.06171299144625664,
0.1183314397931099,
0.38446998596191406,
0.3749440908432007,
0.16654779016971588,
1.021282434463501,
0.7774675488471985,
0.08022310584783554,
-0.13297460973262787,
0.4443727433681488,
1.0609482526779175,
-0.4896179139614105,
-0.3699578642845154,
-1.0065633058547974,
0.16691674292087555,
0.0021690812427550554,
-0.36147087812423706,
0.7698425054550171,
0.741942286491394,
1.056262731552124,
-0.047582436352968216,
0.5380385518074036,
0.34451642632484436,
0.5898477435112,
-0.6148158311843872,
0.3589756190776825,
-0.3670541048049927,
0.5556415915489197,
-0.4295995235443115,
-1.150113582611084,
-0.5815637111663818,
0.6186452507972717,
-0.4456600844860077,
-0.04638724401593208,
0.6050558686256409,
0.6944440007209778,
0.06684957444667816,
0.09769096225500107,
0.11624981462955475,
0.17553777992725372,
0.4500081241130829,
0.6958081722259521,
1.2533373832702637,
-0.24789755046367645,
0.7304776310920715,
-0.2280917912721634,
-0.0754702165722847,
-0.10974346846342087,
-0.8819455504417419,
-0.998315691947937,
-0.2796062231063843,
-0.4852674603462219,
-0.5572909712791443,
-0.28372126817703247,
1.243107557296753,
0.5339668393135071,
-0.8790728449821472,
-0.5106222629547119,
-0.03416188806295395,
0.17211927473545074,
0.1625475287437439,
-0.2389829009771347,
0.16201284527778625,
-0.8488783836364746,
-0.7339809536933899,
0.1678139865398407,
0.35679346323013306,
-0.1668429970741272,
-0.6594786047935486,
-0.06694428622722626,
0.4084508717060089,
-0.15293502807617188,
0.5176361203193665,
0.07091867923736572,
-0.6882249116897583,
-0.2401174008846283,
0.2708989977836609,
0.01650790311396122,
0.2807135581970215,
1.0869146585464478,
-0.6099833846092224,
0.7575288414955139,
0.20599611103534698,
0.8896437287330627,
0.5573338866233826,
0.02538575790822506,
0.7003298401832581,
-0.5357017517089844,
-0.20780542492866516,
0.3565417528152466,
0.5086134076118469,
0.38111409544944763,
-0.20766058564186096,
0.5833763480186462,
0.32752352952957153,
-0.748387336730957,
-0.6520663499832153,
0.21466028690338135,
-0.6489352583885193,
0.175904780626297,
0.9540039896965027,
-0.048988278955221176,
-0.04490985721349716,
0.2094036042690277,
-0.5637528300285339,
-0.1928788274526596,
-0.4442521333694458,
1.1494910717010498,
1.1147421598434448,
-0.096583291888237,
-0.2542906105518341,
-0.15597184002399445,
0.31125780940055847,
0.9281253814697266,
-0.7198019623756409,
0.24205881357192993,
0.676432728767395,
0.23277465999126434,
0.06588041037321091,
0.3599669933319092,
-0.296256422996521,
0.014808809384703636,
-0.6182237863540649,
-0.08197595179080963,
0.021800726652145386,
-0.3171456754207611,
-0.5824636220932007,
-0.013387355022132397,
0.16055487096309662,
0.19061829149723053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02882v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02882v1
|
Linear Attention Sequence Parallelism
| 2024-04-03T17:33:21 | 2024-04-03T17:33:21 |
Weigao Sun, Zhen Qin, Dong Li, Xuyang Shen, Yu Qiao, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Sequence Parallel (SP) serves as a prevalent strategy to handle long
sequences that exceed the memory limit of a single GPU. However, existing SP
methods do not take advantage of linear attention features, resulting in
sub-optimal parallelism efficiency and usability for linear attention-based
language models. In this paper, we introduce Linear Attention Sequence Parallel
(LASP), an efficient SP method tailored to linear attention-based language
models. Specifically, we design an efficient point-to-point communication
mechanism to leverage the right-product kernel trick of linear attention, which
sharply decreases the communication overhead of SP. We also enhance the
practical efficiency of LASP by performing kernel fusion and intermediate state
caching, making the implementation of LASP hardware-friendly on GPU clusters.
Furthermore, we meticulously ensure the compatibility of sequence-level LASP
with all types of batch-level data parallel methods, which is vital for
distributed training on large clusters with long sequences and large batches.
We conduct extensive experiments on two linear attention-based models with
varying sequence lengths and GPU cluster sizes. LASP scales sequence length up
to 4096K using 128 A100 80G GPUs on 1B models, which is 8 times longer than
existing SP methods while being significantly faster. The code is available at
https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/LASP.
|
[
-0.35867491364479065,
-0.5351842641830444,
0.5222292542457581,
0.47597989439964294,
-0.1336597502231598,
-0.35228848457336426,
-0.343705415725708,
-0.4960252642631531,
0.32616114616394043,
0.11747319996356964,
-0.4453776180744171,
-0.36494722962379456,
-0.32985568046569824,
-0.21017292141914368,
-0.5713367462158203,
0.9341121315956116,
0.13976535201072693,
-0.18783065676689148,
-0.24801507592201233,
-0.28890588879585266,
-0.32276713848114014,
-0.5356399416923523,
-0.8150348663330078,
0.14828144013881683,
1.0511804819107056,
0.21249721944332123,
0.5118028521537781,
1.1616175174713135,
0.9039630889892578,
0.19485603272914886,
-0.1116795688867569,
0.007319628726691008,
-1.0116957426071167,
-0.11300509423017502,
-0.1855301409959793,
-0.13798584043979645,
-0.4993365406990051,
-0.35052573680877686,
0.8727573752403259,
0.7786038517951965,
-0.09645930677652359,
0.5120537281036377,
0.18704023957252502,
0.8467293381690979,
-0.7564072012901306,
-0.020192166790366173,
-0.5233913660049438,
0.2393491268157959,
-0.24657103419303894,
0.07533931732177734,
-0.6990256905555725,
-0.5333979725837708,
0.084723100066185,
-0.43389958143234253,
0.34799936413764954,
0.08749105036258698,
0.7431662082672119,
0.4980376064777374,
0.35616034269332886,
-0.08302561193704605,
-0.9124462604522705,
0.8842063546180725,
-0.9375935792922974,
0.33806702494621277,
-0.05892306566238403,
0.3749113976955414,
0.15992358326911926,
-0.8288571238517761,
-0.4646652340888977,
0.13780027627944946,
0.003278517397120595,
-0.1428193300962448,
0.048839058727025986,
0.14521285891532898,
0.6646673679351807,
0.39939260482788086,
-0.7814283967018127,
-0.010240345261991024,
-0.3329085111618042,
0.2982826232910156,
0.3844855725765228,
0.10897844284772873,
0.04106408730149269,
0.23681418597698212,
-0.7930067777633667,
-0.06712948530912399,
-0.7055445313453674,
0.16152752935886383,
0.021674744784832,
0.45378994941711426,
0.029888199642300606,
0.3180461823940277,
-0.06272505968809128,
1.0784963369369507,
-0.025932686403393745,
-0.03572358191013336,
-0.01759004034101963,
-0.25203198194503784,
-0.4381357729434967,
-0.022699275985360146,
0.5471463203430176,
0.23971956968307495,
-0.05127626284956932,
-0.07006821036338806,
-0.13127660751342773,
0.23193614184856415,
0.1392645388841629,
-0.5721766948699951,
0.01516047678887844,
0.3790816068649292,
-0.39711156487464905,
0.10246624797582626,
-0.08638768643140793,
-0.9726296663284302,
0.07207579165697098,
-0.3387954831123352,
0.26588350534439087,
0.02106497995555401,
0.31258073449134827,
0.26106497645378113,
0.19611713290214539,
0.036747660487890244,
0.11738124489784241,
-1.2711114883422852,
0.5237908363342285,
0.8804135322570801,
0.7549460530281067,
-0.4265751242637634,
-0.2706003189086914,
-0.955687940120697,
0.2777378559112549,
-0.07236792892217636,
0.6655260920524597,
-0.568228542804718,
0.0657530128955841,
-0.15478277206420898,
-0.32314038276672363,
-0.33092808723449707,
-0.3060721158981323,
0.4967649281024933,
-0.33224210143089294,
0.10558921098709106,
-0.6060614585876465,
-0.5978102087974548,
-0.1695614904165268,
-0.09619811177253723,
-0.352524071931839,
0.8344298005104065,
-0.5035145878791809,
-0.7996180653572083,
-0.07129896432161331,
-0.550743579864502,
-0.21491563320159912,
0.044395171105861664,
-0.35058748722076416,
-0.36537572741508484,
-0.06444131582975388,
0.2967938780784607,
0.5267249345779419,
-0.2528737187385559,
-0.0035446234978735447,
-0.608162522315979,
-0.5532665252685547,
-0.33394816517829895,
0.010836325585842133,
0.2241358757019043,
0.24096699059009552,
-0.2585504949092865,
0.4077441096305847,
-0.4750947654247284,
-0.07667501270771027,
0.20412519574165344,
-0.2408197969198227,
-0.047725923359394073,
0.14939822256565094,
0.014296750538051128,
0.32094672322273254,
0.47447869181632996,
-0.49876922369003296,
0.08970702439546585,
-0.5404596328735352,
0.23568835854530334,
0.8475422263145447,
-0.4584515392780304,
0.3723893463611603,
-0.2102091908454895,
0.24146787822246552,
-0.31676405668258667,
0.3848698139190674,
-0.40271246433258057,
-0.7684686779975891,
-0.9965200424194336,
-0.26141801476478577,
0.00352613627910614,
0.7360566854476929,
-0.32507678866386414,
0.2459360510110855,
-0.2438584715127945,
-0.23113247752189636,
-0.6082525253295898,
0.1850046068429947,
0.7294678688049316,
0.6080151200294495,
0.39652955532073975,
-0.22687503695487976,
-0.3214942216873169,
-0.8902345299720764,
-0.2597354054450989,
0.11840662360191345,
0.019588131457567215,
0.6302319169044495,
-0.10708621144294739,
0.030348466709256172,
0.85102778673172,
-0.7279528379440308,
-0.17309996485710144,
-0.2578481435775757,
-0.1402815878391266,
0.5477596521377563,
0.17837083339691162,
0.42966538667678833,
-0.4023703336715698,
-0.6381117105484009,
0.19478042423725128,
-0.6951234340667725,
-0.037505798041820526,
-0.0672086849808693,
0.011547685600817204,
0.2599896788597107,
0.4163922667503357,
-0.511995792388916,
0.43375056982040405,
0.5395304560661316,
-0.16376838088035583,
0.014096181839704514,
-0.26890644431114197,
-0.2335246354341507,
-1.00849449634552,
0.4268765151500702,
0.12934289872646332,
-0.426408052444458,
-0.8838226199150085,
0.26683494448661804,
0.06475381553173065,
-0.44905099272727966,
-0.6247360706329346,
0.2906261682510376,
-0.09207945317029953,
-0.6739098429679871,
-0.4301512539386749,
0.004025103524327278,
-0.2296215444803238,
0.9117216467857361,
0.010682028718292713,
0.4335310459136963,
0.3646279573440552,
-0.5534027218818665,
0.5630044341087341,
-0.041249774396419525,
-0.001783447922207415,
0.22537510097026825,
-0.8150801062583923,
0.33464738726615906,
-0.39789247512817383,
0.19804657995700836,
-0.8742250800132751,
0.07705729454755783,
0.18323680758476257,
-0.24949774146080017,
0.27201345562934875,
0.3121686577796936,
-0.30758634209632874,
-0.617472231388092,
-0.06276790797710419,
0.5952392816543579,
0.478469580411911,
-0.7951827645301819,
0.2742699980735779,
0.09123004972934723,
-0.4568326771259308,
-0.8496459722518921,
-0.3270619511604309,
-0.18165016174316406,
-0.34981849789619446,
-0.7629497051239014,
0.12054910510778427,
-0.15719465911388397,
0.06552925705909729,
-0.2550930976867676,
0.0022015164140611887,
0.20213539898395538,
-0.27607688307762146,
0.02461390569806099,
0.0911252498626709,
-0.3098432421684265,
0.13759781420230865,
-0.23173142969608307,
-0.26825690269470215,
-0.2990483343601227,
-0.36625248193740845,
0.7913672924041748,
-0.3838573396205902,
-0.28547075390815735,
-0.871664822101593,
0.7066556811332703,
0.505474865436554,
-0.19107063114643097,
0.4130747616291046,
0.4316200613975525,
-0.365707665681839,
-0.28133079409599304,
-0.4784587025642395,
-0.4500451385974884,
-0.4204385280609131,
0.26579350233078003,
-0.08656219393014908,
-0.8288624286651611,
0.470306932926178,
0.17114707827568054,
0.3229432702064514,
0.1306423544883728,
0.46795010566711426,
-0.15324567258358002,
0.7299878597259521,
0.679848313331604,
-0.49364227056503296,
0.2571631669998169,
0.09190201014280319,
0.5622438788414001,
-0.35454612970352173,
0.2093469649553299,
-0.397185742855072,
-0.6590943336486816,
0.16659274697303772,
-0.7123647332191467,
0.2436404824256897,
0.03568713366985321,
-0.12283015996217728,
0.5877472758293152,
-0.57125324010849,
0.5400603413581848,
0.5586063265800476,
0.08786610513925552,
0.08187391608953476,
0.2059398591518402,
0.06571877747774124,
-0.17039920389652252,
-0.8612115979194641,
0.006045209243893623,
0.7806404232978821,
0.8027290105819702,
0.7433614134788513,
-0.1329970359802246,
0.591107964515686,
0.22929826378822327,
-0.1674802303314209,
-0.48821908235549927,
0.8514978885650635,
-0.3165614604949951,
0.09074385464191437,
-0.3899335265159607,
-0.2965097427368164,
-0.6095062494277954,
0.024743705987930298,
-0.0030934149399399757,
-0.6702246069908142,
0.26911813020706177,
0.2837333381175995,
-0.7577527761459351,
0.3749382793903351,
-0.7063726186752319,
0.9242058992385864,
0.16820621490478516,
-0.4637121260166168,
-0.43786969780921936,
-0.7308236360549927,
0.28115221858024597,
-0.03314727544784546,
0.02503022365272045,
-0.074728824198246,
0.221109539270401,
0.6077011227607727,
-0.48785024881362915,
0.719999372959137,
-0.017930351197719574,
-0.059689056128263474,
-0.06324543058872223,
-0.4492662250995636,
0.813932478427887,
-0.10684006661176682,
0.39701172709465027,
0.008350188843905926,
-0.45597192645072937,
-0.6834622025489807,
-0.5041919350624084,
1.053084135055542,
-0.43657246232032776,
-0.5827518105506897,
-0.19032743573188782,
-1.0161747932434082,
-0.019455943256616592,
-0.05243776738643646,
-0.09343989938497543,
0.21263697743415833,
0.26509764790534973,
-0.06593707948923111,
0.8930861949920654,
-0.4324084520339966,
1.000012755393982,
0.2337150126695633,
-0.36930060386657715,
-0.2497890740633011,
1.2252914905548096,
-0.3116951882839203,
0.5823872685432434,
0.4995851218700409,
0.09145312756299973,
-0.15152055025100708,
-0.3110036849975586,
-0.4197362959384918,
0.43825215101242065,
-0.6380571126937866,
0.03252129629254341,
-0.6186389327049255,
-0.2945467233657837,
-0.3833360970020294,
-0.26217347383499146,
-0.668170690536499,
-0.5082602500915527,
-0.012853231281042099,
0.18929126858711243,
0.31093958020210266,
0.5993055105209351,
0.013523072935640812,
0.16700804233551025,
-0.5886582732200623,
0.5391654968261719,
0.6642194986343384,
0.21723902225494385,
0.12419410794973373,
-0.31678053736686707,
-0.30788367986679077,
-0.19330069422721863,
-0.19587919116020203,
-0.4645019471645355,
0.5420976877212524,
0.28475940227508545,
0.31038784980773926,
0.7441445589065552,
-0.14356714487075806,
0.8303858041763306,
-0.7719781398773193,
0.47691088914871216,
0.32610487937927246,
-0.8101853728294373,
0.6258396506309509,
-0.49242597818374634,
0.4355430603027344,
0.1679275631904602,
0.43270498514175415,
-0.5392321348190308,
-0.3328198492527008,
-0.22563056647777557,
-0.840994119644165,
0.8525333404541016,
0.17932477593421936,
-0.2539900541305542,
-0.028358904644846916,
0.30281662940979004,
-0.13535550236701965,
-0.19217893481254578,
-0.7224658727645874,
-0.3951813876628876,
0.2256438434123993,
-0.2687712013721466,
-0.21907788515090942,
-0.24495239555835724,
-0.08879519999027252,
-0.09793777018785477,
0.4703633189201355,
0.053143978118896484,
0.4530845880508423,
0.28223997354507446,
0.22931401431560516,
-0.07254347205162048,
0.017042728140950203,
1.0342459678649902,
0.6849713921546936,
-0.49968892335891724,
-0.07984314113855362,
0.03919871151447296,
-0.41976380348205566,
-0.21100006997585297,
0.2791396677494049,
-0.12986089289188385,
0.175428569316864,
-0.17346633970737457,
1.0115716457366943,
0.26826775074005127,
-0.4837251901626587,
0.37732774019241333,
-0.03905851021409035,
0.19593080878257751,
0.17092207074165344,
-0.25852662324905396,
0.37285104393959045,
0.36199119687080383,
0.20756392180919647,
-0.0011701633920893073,
0.10018408298492432,
-0.07057733088731766,
0.36159661412239075,
0.1351867914199829,
-0.4566396176815033,
-0.00765780545771122,
0.8370712399482727,
0.27653974294662476,
-0.2828400731086731,
0.4624921381473541,
0.14177849888801575,
0.09667636454105377,
0.644939661026001,
0.538468599319458,
0.6752347350120544,
-0.4971145987510681,
-0.0801982581615448,
0.4640401601791382,
0.05922897160053253,
-0.27834776043891907,
0.30406779050827026,
-0.12330113351345062,
-0.3408900499343872,
-0.7494611740112305,
-0.7387145757675171,
-0.29584628343582153,
-0.045675262808799744,
-0.6773291826248169,
0.20167312026023865,
-0.7080157995223999,
0.018982993438839912,
0.11308083683252335,
-0.6080172657966614,
-0.15053164958953857,
0.009054948575794697,
0.6786607503890991,
0.6571568250656128,
-0.7389959096908569,
1.2090585231781006,
0.25684401392936707,
0.1918140947818756,
-0.33861222863197327,
-0.3037085235118866,
-0.2741246521472931,
-0.7288522124290466,
0.7608192563056946,
0.5036255121231079,
0.15844430029392242,
0.10158634185791016,
-0.10594098269939423,
-0.9736919403076172,
0.8436194658279419,
0.309793084859848,
-1.13808012008667,
-0.19137051701545715,
0.5694737434387207,
0.2415561079978943,
-0.37588974833488464,
-0.15957731008529663,
0.2601294219493866,
-0.10301203280687332,
0.18295620381832123,
-1.0220270156860352,
-0.040169138461351395,
-0.12489031255245209,
0.3497663140296936,
0.36021456122398376,
-0.5630001425743103,
0.8112369179725647,
-0.40927648544311523,
-0.16989588737487793,
0.08188795298337936,
1.11652410030365,
0.6331451535224915,
0.3834700286388397,
0.40596890449523926,
1.2501753568649292,
0.4909665882587433,
-0.0016888133250176907,
0.8912104964256287,
-0.37751346826553345,
0.4935585856437683,
1.1214256286621094,
-0.3439798355102539,
1.207358956336975,
0.604611873626709,
-0.16356876492500305,
0.11382186412811279,
0.3799934387207031,
0.16685126721858978,
0.6068756580352783,
0.45875313878059387,
-0.576848566532135,
-0.09501093626022339,
-0.12016017735004425,
-0.5385165810585022,
-0.16879424452781677,
0.5354138016700745,
-0.5475446581840515,
-0.3787152171134949,
0.08492819219827652,
-0.13561825454235077,
0.20333336293697357,
-0.714995801448822,
0.5297316312789917,
0.24084089696407318,
-0.6050019264221191,
0.7430808544158936,
-0.07919702678918839,
0.6422836184501648,
-0.46740850806236267,
0.0917728990316391,
-0.35194599628448486,
0.6327441334724426,
-0.043716203421354294,
-0.4606241285800934,
0.3765958547592163,
-0.045821964740753174,
-0.5335612297058105,
-0.364675909280777,
0.4176470637321472,
-0.5303436517715454,
-0.420914888381958,
0.24026119709014893,
-0.18103653192520142,
0.2134009152650833,
-0.07332347333431244,
-0.6481226086616516,
0.24161788821220398,
0.10692501068115234,
0.03763820603489876,
0.44450443983078003,
-0.32476821541786194,
0.03153161332011223,
0.6904964447021484,
0.6298776865005493,
-0.17150647938251495,
0.4889809489250183,
0.12514330446720123,
0.8117063045501709,
-0.8144765496253967,
-0.5313308835029602,
-0.7941243648529053,
0.14672504365444183,
-0.028240090236067772,
0.06289155036211014,
0.7911192774772644,
0.6198071837425232,
0.7269471883773804,
-0.23608563840389252,
0.41040894389152527,
0.3451370894908905,
0.6880327463150024,
-0.3233170509338379,
0.47916731238365173,
-0.21375088393688202,
0.22987398505210876,
-0.31655630469322205,
-1.0599552392959595,
-0.36572784185409546,
0.4447959363460541,
-0.20827002823352814,
-0.2674735486507416,
0.6362272500991821,
0.6542616486549377,
-0.10818913578987122,
0.05456774681806564,
0.3629280626773834,
0.16048353910446167,
0.09249123185873032,
1.298639178276062,
0.30214792490005493,
-0.4490121901035309,
0.3656676113605499,
-0.3067185878753662,
-0.24412865936756134,
-0.11299170553684235,
-0.7447336316108704,
-0.9661124348640442,
-0.2547149062156677,
-0.174390509724617,
-0.1598477065563202,
0.2820323705673218,
0.6289654970169067,
0.7058073878288269,
-0.7912290096282959,
-0.4707097113132477,
-0.31983277201652527,
-0.10003788769245148,
-0.3642238676548004,
-0.1740960031747818,
0.5801423192024231,
-0.7303133010864258,
-0.8872066736221313,
0.3992702066898346,
0.7605259418487549,
-0.15459738671779633,
-0.1273231953382492,
-0.10715119540691376,
-0.29346516728401184,
-0.014675190672278404,
0.6575343012809753,
0.908770740032196,
-0.8326708078384399,
0.15179403126239777,
0.04903547838330269,
-0.13354209065437317,
0.05321042984724045,
0.7120486497879028,
-0.6097320318222046,
0.4583825469017029,
0.771622896194458,
0.8971245884895325,
0.48512449860572815,
0.09386111795902252,
0.7802305221557617,
-0.7164840698242188,
0.598921537399292,
0.20613670349121094,
0.28147998452186584,
0.21974122524261475,
-0.30778995156288147,
0.19151437282562256,
0.43519020080566406,
-0.7362677454948425,
-0.7476053833961487,
0.22166688740253448,
-1.4173609018325806,
-0.09878724813461304,
1.0613152980804443,
-0.3493022620677948,
-0.33328306674957275,
0.16966968774795532,
-0.06157812103629112,
-0.148848757147789,
-0.30369308590888977,
0.6667495965957642,
0.35164064168930054,
-0.09750619530677795,
-0.4528290927410126,
-0.613002598285675,
0.5940839052200317,
0.7648182511329651,
-0.6919742822647095,
0.254149854183197,
0.041173819452524185,
-0.2540830671787262,
0.207963228225708,
0.39307406544685364,
0.03969772905111313,
0.42683377861976624,
-0.40090212225914,
0.23706954717636108,
0.26758766174316406,
-0.5125645399093628,
-0.38960936665534973,
0.33394089341163635,
-0.3043327331542969,
-0.36047568917274475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02837v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02837v1
|
Cherry on Top: Parameter Heterogeneity and Quantization in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T16:16:31 | 2024-04-03T16:16:31 |
Wanyun Cui, Qianle Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper reveals the phenomenon of parameter heterogeneity in large
language models (LLMs). We find that a small subset of ``cherry'' parameters
exhibit a disproportionately large influence on model performance, while the
vast majority of parameters have minimal impact. This heterogeneity is found to
be prevalent across different model families, scales, and types. Motivated by
this observation, we propose CherryQ, a novel quantization method that unifies
the optimization of mixed-precision parameters. CherryQ identifies and
preserves the critical cherry parameters in high precision while aggressively
quantizing the remaining parameters to low precision. Extensive experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of CherryQ. CherryQ outperforms existing
quantization approaches in terms of perplexity and downstream task performance.
Notably, our 3-bit quantized Vicuna-1.5 exhibits competitive performance
compared to their 16-bit counterparts. These findings highlight the potential
of CherryQ for enabling efficient deployment of LLMs by taking advantage of
parameter heterogeneity.
|
[
-0.28680291771888733,
-1.2072415351867676,
0.6945756673812866,
0.4343174695968628,
-0.48849722743034363,
0.2321000099182129,
-0.375959187746048,
-0.09594191610813141,
0.10704155266284943,
0.68462735414505,
-0.1298777014017105,
-0.6180312037467957,
-0.37491753697395325,
-0.18037459254264832,
-0.09643600881099701,
0.851542055606842,
0.13572116196155548,
0.09160341322422028,
-0.21329829096794128,
-0.2906017303466797,
-0.20695064961910248,
-0.8395231366157532,
-0.4138738811016083,
-0.010550095699727535,
0.6193614602088928,
0.3470296859741211,
1.110936164855957,
0.9270815849304199,
0.5359498858451843,
0.26827648282051086,
-0.31520798802375793,
-0.03808821365237236,
-0.25186851620674133,
0.5466223955154419,
0.18532384932041168,
-0.8943231701850891,
-0.47458457946777344,
-0.15399236977100372,
1.049538493156433,
0.885516881942749,
-0.2230118364095688,
0.007990414276719093,
-0.033504340797662735,
0.5993734002113342,
-0.8646867275238037,
-0.20563055574893951,
-0.8020021915435791,
0.04196973517537117,
-0.4533097445964813,
-0.22779490053653717,
-0.1907719522714615,
-0.643301248550415,
-0.3216143250465393,
-0.7203400731086731,
0.07712481170892715,
0.10736921429634094,
0.8574340343475342,
0.46573734283447266,
-0.3545820415019989,
0.2842820882797241,
-1.1202833652496338,
1.2805933952331543,
-0.7092447876930237,
0.49016129970550537,
0.37217453122138977,
0.3632907569408417,
0.21994557976722717,
-0.6216895580291748,
-0.0423310212790966,
-0.17471137642860413,
0.23126903176307678,
-0.2663203179836273,
0.0650058463215828,
0.16837380826473236,
0.2792673707008362,
0.6538421511650085,
-0.4098116159439087,
-0.0026301112957298756,
0.14654378592967987,
-0.27010053396224976,
0.28445664048194885,
0.2647459805011749,
0.09307743608951569,
0.14790549874305725,
-0.17204797267913818,
0.10868143290281296,
-0.7108922004699707,
-0.015647156164050102,
0.2635282278060913,
0.7279512286186218,
0.025404203683137894,
0.3037179410457611,
-0.3763561248779297,
0.6291225552558899,
-0.00946019683033228,
0.010335322469472885,
0.04575752094388008,
-0.5284844040870667,
-0.31079673767089844,
-0.22015319764614105,
0.821634829044342,
-0.09611997753381729,
0.15797364711761475,
-0.24977120757102966,
-0.2511669993400574,
-0.40135708451271057,
0.15640653669834137,
-1.0359514951705933,
-0.10148007422685623,
0.4043813645839691,
-0.4212297797203064,
-0.4102729558944702,
-0.35071370005607605,
-0.688451886177063,
-0.26935309171676636,
-0.06366313248872757,
0.5843273401260376,
-0.2866763770580292,
-0.13967609405517578,
-0.1816609799861908,
0.005981292575597763,
0.07558459043502808,
0.2458144575357437,
-1.0583338737487793,
0.42386001348495483,
0.873522937297821,
0.7654896378517151,
0.054437439888715744,
-0.12762978672981262,
-0.8462694883346558,
0.03970472514629364,
-0.6754831671714783,
0.38759809732437134,
-0.5005334615707397,
-0.133017435669899,
-0.09833584725856781,
-0.28380534052848816,
0.3754057288169861,
-0.653772234916687,
0.32004112005233765,
-0.6231497526168823,
0.15128187835216522,
-0.41588857769966125,
-0.20148016512393951,
0.16276973485946655,
0.3073858916759491,
-0.8579797148704529,
1.1341642141342163,
0.24904590845108032,
-0.6186179518699646,
0.5640718936920166,
-0.23840151727199554,
-0.25510501861572266,
0.2774829864501953,
-0.39693254232406616,
-0.7141108512878418,
0.5107142925262451,
0.09431670606136322,
0.28651559352874756,
-0.7477090954780579,
0.31918707489967346,
-0.5238403081893921,
-0.5646280646324158,
0.2504333257675171,
-0.6035827398300171,
1.0454702377319336,
0.19573016464710236,
-0.3046433627605438,
0.13705910742282867,
-0.5531450510025024,
0.3670580983161926,
-0.020010629668831825,
-0.3833535611629486,
-0.7213967442512512,
-0.22395925223827362,
0.1632038652896881,
-0.1946437656879425,
0.37352269887924194,
-0.3876174986362457,
0.1932155042886734,
-0.38366037607192993,
0.4524168372154236,
0.4505155384540558,
0.05529928207397461,
0.5411825776100159,
-0.07556011527776718,
0.548816442489624,
-0.16978579759597778,
0.6605387926101685,
0.20430444180965424,
-0.5127230286598206,
-0.49271008372306824,
-0.5240669846534729,
0.878845751285553,
0.2758767008781433,
-0.5111232995986938,
0.15767179429531097,
-0.0459156408905983,
-0.41543006896972656,
-0.3852481245994568,
-0.020148400217294693,
0.463154137134552,
-0.09215372800827026,
0.1494624763727188,
-0.12244071811437607,
-0.2537669241428375,
-1.1914218664169312,
-0.5150743126869202,
-0.10435347259044647,
-0.06906469911336899,
0.26197466254234314,
0.11964359134435654,
0.18182002007961273,
0.8977386951446533,
-0.26021912693977356,
0.09365338832139969,
0.20087094604969025,
0.31750258803367615,
0.3012298345565796,
0.5694893598556519,
0.593666672706604,
-1.0040451288223267,
-0.679879903793335,
0.3074626326560974,
-0.42674946784973145,
0.04962463304400444,
0.31825563311576843,
-0.2594936788082123,
0.34980833530426025,
0.5722734928131104,
-0.3126925826072693,
0.09823115915060043,
0.628511369228363,
-0.24890197813510895,
0.4485783278942108,
-0.2415473312139511,
0.3550904393196106,
-1.0391842126846313,
-0.056654758751392365,
-0.1509653776884079,
-0.2925776243209839,
-0.5809499025344849,
0.24875932931900024,
0.37800368666648865,
0.19878539443016052,
-0.5616794228553772,
0.3742651343345642,
-0.5118948221206665,
-0.24529604613780975,
-0.08510348945856094,
-0.24999620020389557,
0.09417242556810379,
0.396712064743042,
-0.18012548983097076,
0.751541018486023,
0.5602627992630005,
-0.405646950006485,
0.4361821413040161,
-0.20438721776008606,
-0.12158222496509552,
0.633155107498169,
-0.7356511354446411,
-0.12417769432067871,
0.2512231469154358,
-0.21274174749851227,
-0.8997504711151123,
0.006875881925225258,
-0.1785038411617279,
-0.4594903588294983,
0.1475961059331894,
-0.4756469130516052,
-0.7423564791679382,
0.21551300585269928,
-0.5299552083015442,
0.6912909150123596,
0.6264863014221191,
-0.031284645199775696,
0.7885677814483643,
0.23856444656848907,
-0.24703349173069,
-0.35140177607536316,
-0.8250267505645752,
-0.08231735974550247,
-0.623782753944397,
-0.4023568332195282,
0.5277226567268372,
-0.09570243954658508,
-0.43437430262565613,
-0.13694113492965698,
0.009819425642490387,
-0.45204174518585205,
0.27793705463409424,
0.042433835566043854,
0.22915269434452057,
-0.5386825203895569,
0.24619761109352112,
0.17107877135276794,
0.011874264106154442,
-0.038309916853904724,
-0.3378506898880005,
0.5474268198013306,
-0.31265130639076233,
0.022482294589281082,
-0.0728803351521492,
0.38932865858078003,
0.6837161779403687,
-0.29290685057640076,
0.9482489228248596,
0.47172659635543823,
-0.4934394061565399,
-0.24350403249263763,
-0.4284017086029053,
-0.3510936200618744,
-0.47561612725257874,
0.4137868881225586,
-0.7165572047233582,
-0.9104839563369751,
0.6734442710876465,
0.05169285461306572,
-0.053345177322626114,
0.2602769136428833,
0.6645926833152771,
-0.008547792211174965,
1.2039817571640015,
0.8033141493797302,
0.02514621429145336,
0.49155306816101074,
0.018140733242034912,
0.07152314484119415,
-0.726958692073822,
0.17668531835079193,
-0.8250589966773987,
-0.10390277206897736,
-1.066011667251587,
-0.6186284422874451,
0.5037073493003845,
0.42263659834861755,
-0.6033585071563721,
0.0401531420648098,
-0.41378313302993774,
0.588575541973114,
0.7843093276023865,
0.03736994042992592,
0.5717689394950867,
0.12642747163772583,
-0.2009705901145935,
-0.15949827432632446,
-0.7585641145706177,
-0.3487837314605713,
1.2684059143066406,
0.4052947163581848,
0.6821513175964355,
0.10432182252407074,
0.5885670185089111,
0.16574683785438538,
0.13541921973228455,
-0.6081019639968872,
0.35939979553222656,
-0.48731425404548645,
-0.7509316205978394,
-0.7578544616699219,
-0.6514102220535278,
-0.7658710479736328,
0.34729480743408203,
-0.1180107370018959,
-0.7281836271286011,
0.1443064659833908,
0.1708516925573349,
-0.6435222029685974,
0.24301236867904663,
-0.4133962094783783,
0.9638499021530151,
-0.2950179874897003,
-0.6425739526748657,
-0.04333186149597168,
-0.552127480506897,
0.2995891869068146,
-0.26005643606185913,
0.365416944026947,
-0.13573971390724182,
-0.44878560304641724,
0.5442694425582886,
-0.43381085991859436,
0.4930853545665741,
-0.07276603579521179,
-0.18768133223056793,
-0.10089458525180817,
0.26338979601860046,
0.6073189377784729,
0.12362764030694962,
-0.22882001101970673,
0.1701129823923111,
0.06166713684797287,
-0.732175350189209,
-0.7571866512298584,
0.8448932766914368,
-0.7714105844497681,
-0.521671712398529,
-0.07938304543495178,
-0.6173170208930969,
-0.6736665368080139,
-0.02726401761174202,
0.33646360039711,
0.3567105233669281,
-0.07004166394472122,
0.6272189617156982,
0.8650335669517517,
-0.17359834909439087,
0.40014222264289856,
0.30895304679870605,
-0.3201794922351837,
-0.6292626857757568,
0.9941375851631165,
0.1305427998304367,
0.645553469657898,
0.6132716536521912,
0.40494123101234436,
-0.05937374755740166,
-0.8359336256980896,
-0.5050528049468994,
0.29579269886016846,
-0.44928717613220215,
-0.10330957174301147,
-0.42748749256134033,
-0.16964542865753174,
-0.2350742518901825,
-0.05412299558520317,
-0.9150208830833435,
-0.6159040927886963,
-0.15789742767810822,
0.32570672035217285,
0.5052380561828613,
0.3492707908153534,
0.15678724646568298,
0.3999570906162262,
-0.8136827349662781,
0.20930597186088562,
0.498427152633667,
0.6434742212295532,
-0.266330361366272,
-0.5904998779296875,
-0.582785427570343,
0.04690246284008026,
-0.0312664620578289,
-0.6796930432319641,
0.2626180350780487,
0.012626072391867638,
0.58226078748703,
0.14625486731529236,
-0.014151218347251415,
0.2708777189254761,
-0.1406102180480957,
0.7195703983306885,
-0.14897899329662323,
-1.0709797143936157,
0.3391261696815491,
-0.5732600688934326,
0.3631628751754761,
0.5800915360450745,
0.4812585711479187,
-0.43492603302001953,
-0.6037380695343018,
-0.5873981714248657,
-0.9776961207389832,
0.7063901424407959,
0.33028507232666016,
0.057065051048994064,
0.5732864141464233,
0.11976410448551178,
0.08025040477514267,
0.486423522233963,
-0.7008660435676575,
-0.32375913858413696,
0.10215320438146591,
-0.03323353826999664,
0.09652164578437805,
-0.29640400409698486,
-0.24248650670051575,
-0.030698135495185852,
0.5191303491592407,
-0.09860766679048538,
0.10102265328168869,
-0.3688983917236328,
0.18244358897209167,
-0.34599336981773376,
0.21978244185447693,
0.2812918424606323,
0.4518453776836395,
-0.3470814824104309,
0.023905348032712936,
0.08607570827007294,
-0.36376434564590454,
-0.03530009835958481,
0.024137357249855995,
-0.28877347707748413,
-0.13516131043434143,
0.3212890625,
0.8118756413459778,
0.08017800748348236,
-0.32862499356269836,
0.42530280351638794,
-0.05962197855114937,
-0.3398103415966034,
0.17291757464408875,
-0.008655094541609287,
0.017664307728409767,
0.29720330238342285,
0.4441535770893097,
-0.36158740520477295,
0.1613168716430664,
-0.7968055605888367,
0.08864355832338333,
0.733347475528717,
-0.35909226536750793,
-0.11199746280908585,
0.5877698063850403,
0.24872006475925446,
-0.40515902638435364,
0.442795068025589,
0.028939567506313324,
-0.5311605334281921,
0.8564788103103638,
0.1548679620027542,
0.9425451755523682,
-0.20517310500144958,
0.24671535193920135,
0.12599673867225647,
0.2906172275543213,
0.12988319993019104,
0.447691947221756,
-0.22353044152259827,
-0.6393980979919434,
-0.4565429091453552,
-0.7300035357475281,
-0.6199777126312256,
0.10185780376195908,
-0.5969642996788025,
0.12557898461818695,
-0.5997855067253113,
-0.15819162130355835,
0.024759726598858833,
0.07109446078538895,
-0.3240819275379181,
0.4131574332714081,
0.0981338769197464,
0.23954977095127106,
-0.8804028630256653,
0.8447839021682739,
0.6066671013832092,
-0.3334411084651947,
-0.8934338688850403,
0.2552960515022278,
-0.1930614709854126,
-0.5554432272911072,
0.3763449192047119,
-0.4238436222076416,
0.25624170899391174,
0.03201021999120712,
-0.4381387233734131,
-1.037678837776184,
0.8109429478645325,
0.4078603982925415,
-0.5163977146148682,
0.07675202190876007,
0.537229061126709,
0.4991411566734314,
-0.1660877913236618,
0.5960107445716858,
0.7132028341293335,
0.5345207452774048,
0.03912169486284256,
-1.1031520366668701,
0.16693322360515594,
0.038399308919906616,
0.5143018364906311,
0.5964599847793579,
-0.8812191486358643,
1.2542403936386108,
0.18377451598644257,
-0.034938421100378036,
0.0029908777214586735,
0.351056307554245,
0.5200064182281494,
-0.016652142629027367,
0.3365197479724884,
0.2562459111213684,
0.5453594326972961,
-0.23720933496952057,
0.8558563590049744,
-0.3121510446071625,
0.4319194257259369,
0.8513156175613403,
-0.07443390786647797,
0.8860098719596863,
0.6868717670440674,
-0.6353015303611755,
0.20522210001945496,
0.7056013941764832,
0.3517654538154602,
0.45814546942710876,
0.22913536429405212,
-0.23925085365772247,
-0.4445146322250366,
0.10507547110319138,
-0.33405277132987976,
0.17262746393680573,
0.1715874969959259,
-0.20045043528079987,
-0.05025959014892578,
0.12170325219631195,
-0.11042316257953644,
0.17487409710884094,
-0.3071567416191101,
0.5883386135101318,
-0.17593920230865479,
-0.5477994084358215,
1.0286569595336914,
0.05336080491542816,
0.7621330618858337,
-0.4789758324623108,
0.07269766181707382,
-0.5622043013572693,
0.02741694077849388,
-0.030034450814127922,
-0.569757878780365,
0.2264729142189026,
-0.23088480532169342,
-0.3198196291923523,
-0.17623558640480042,
0.2992652952671051,
-0.4100821614265442,
-0.5016635060310364,
0.12764011323451996,
0.4989868104457855,
0.0297267846763134,
-0.7535275220870972,
-0.52486252784729,
0.5242509245872498,
0.030988574028015137,
-0.4207718074321747,
0.32549893856048584,
0.9009307622909546,
-0.2985151410102844,
0.5342615842819214,
0.33216404914855957,
0.2236231565475464,
0.13927064836025238,
0.0950319766998291,
0.6967328786849976,
-0.9371401071548462,
-0.44443774223327637,
-0.8241599798202515,
0.5530959963798523,
0.1513671576976776,
-0.49497607350349426,
0.7929275035858154,
0.7956720590591431,
0.5517566800117493,
0.04962792247533798,
0.7037206292152405,
0.17914895713329315,
0.5157484412193298,
-0.5014081001281738,
0.5345302820205688,
-0.9751248359680176,
0.4515758454799652,
-0.2113284170627594,
-1.2591615915298462,
-0.4286568760871887,
0.10503466427326202,
-0.2610689699649811,
0.3837161362171173,
0.8717349767684937,
0.777053713798523,
0.061852142214775085,
-0.07214241474866867,
0.7027396559715271,
0.27891993522644043,
0.0804237350821495,
0.4711860120296478,
0.868266224861145,
-0.5030176043510437,
0.6613695621490479,
-0.42999130487442017,
-0.3827269375324249,
-0.5182673931121826,
-0.8178572058677673,
-0.5736783146858215,
-0.6309762597084045,
-0.42375656962394714,
-0.1034470647573471,
0.37189632654190063,
0.5341978669166565,
1.0047338008880615,
-0.7772923707962036,
-0.36042824387550354,
-0.38136026263237,
0.2247784435749054,
-0.126956969499588,
-0.26623252034187317,
0.09220097213983536,
-0.28777751326560974,
-0.9463899731636047,
0.038373034447431564,
0.3739570081233978,
0.014050154946744442,
-0.5812117457389832,
0.0317455492913723,
0.0031747007742524147,
0.2500225901603699,
0.3835223317146301,
0.03737356886267662,
-0.8018752932548523,
0.139610156416893,
0.06593837589025497,
-0.48299291729927063,
0.18887647986412048,
0.76972895860672,
-0.6800580024719238,
0.11006291210651398,
0.4721768796443939,
0.5778861045837402,
0.6921619772911072,
0.0687059611082077,
0.665610134601593,
-0.7638111710548401,
0.16606615483760834,
0.5880023241043091,
-0.13941960036754608,
0.26784592866897583,
-0.49017834663391113,
0.2677460014820099,
0.1723359376192093,
-0.5441097021102905,
-1.000880241394043,
0.05959875136613846,
-0.8388768434524536,
-0.5602769255638123,
1.055425763130188,
0.21037079393863678,
-0.28566592931747437,
0.17101971805095673,
0.12919293344020844,
0.1393197476863861,
-0.355540007352829,
0.4736223518848419,
0.7280887961387634,
0.0770430713891983,
-0.4007716476917267,
-0.5036653280258179,
0.6118165254592896,
0.839628279209137,
-0.9018509984016418,
0.24828556180000305,
0.3278616666793823,
0.23583421111106873,
-0.011035528965294361,
0.5031457543373108,
-0.1745728999376297,
0.29744043946266174,
0.3015877306461334,
0.11352916061878204,
0.25891080498695374,
-0.41343656182289124,
-0.33022505044937134,
0.41010579466819763,
0.4212837815284729,
-0.2778721749782562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02835v1
|
Retrieving Examples from Memory for Retrieval Augmented Neural Machine Translation: A Systematic Comparison
| 2024-04-03T16:13:29 | 2024-04-03T16:13:29 |
Maxime Bouthors, Josep Crego, Francois Yvon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Neural Machine Translation (RAMT) architectures retrieve
examples from memory to guide the generation process. While most works in this
trend explore new ways to exploit the retrieved examples, the upstream
retrieval step is mostly unexplored. In this paper, we study the effect of
varying retrieval methods for several translation architectures, to better
understand the interplay between these two processes. We conduct experiments in
two language pairs in a multi-domain setting and consider several downstream
architectures based on a standard autoregressive model, an edit-based model,
and a large language model with in-context learning. Our experiments show that
the choice of the retrieval technique impacts the translation scores, with
variance across architectures. We also discuss the effects of increasing the
number and diversity of examples, which are mostly positive across the board.
|
[
-0.36847326159477234,
-0.9428579807281494,
0.5465621948242188,
0.12749069929122925,
-0.4492616653442383,
-0.10178849846124649,
-0.07263030856847763,
-0.3815253973007202,
0.08534858375787735,
0.3621227741241455,
0.05060514807701111,
-0.13611268997192383,
-0.7241263389587402,
0.0748203843832016,
-0.549416184425354,
0.9795082807540894,
-0.21266426146030426,
0.11769118160009384,
0.03520940616726875,
-0.23541811108589172,
-0.8702067732810974,
-0.4698674976825714,
-0.7059367895126343,
-0.3441407382488251,
0.5422320365905762,
0.25623199343681335,
0.5954176187515259,
0.9215900301933289,
0.46589329838752747,
0.24441485106945038,
-0.13834092020988464,
-0.006981126498430967,
-0.20257486402988434,
0.5204815864562988,
-0.14017866551876068,
-0.28130781650543213,
-0.07041794061660767,
0.01657380536198616,
0.8001529574394226,
0.40980270504951477,
-0.09050139784812927,
0.08201057463884354,
0.1765242964029312,
0.5276161432266235,
-0.6228668093681335,
-0.11981577426195145,
-0.6364392638206482,
-0.041973941028118134,
-0.11114216595888138,
-0.2733873426914215,
-0.5064980387687683,
-0.17362429201602936,
0.4773753583431244,
0.023918941617012024,
0.18810546398162842,
0.17315705120563507,
0.5876367092132568,
-0.017871970310807228,
-0.5598089694976807,
-0.6334782242774963,
-0.6592586040496826,
0.9674464464187622,
-0.6947614550590515,
0.3554075360298157,
0.23891575634479523,
0.2733127772808075,
0.017496151849627495,
-0.6907132267951965,
-0.13753807544708252,
-0.17870108783245087,
-0.1668180525302887,
0.13241071999073029,
-0.21057607233524323,
-0.20046773552894592,
0.044703468680381775,
0.6279162764549255,
-0.4862755537033081,
-0.04133085533976555,
-0.5228261351585388,
0.1260443925857544,
0.2015126347541809,
-0.13911060988903046,
0.23201076686382294,
-0.3689476251602173,
-0.5196754932403564,
-0.25776880979537964,
-0.8848174810409546,
-0.3132493793964386,
0.38521096110343933,
0.3129291236400604,
0.20453311502933502,
0.5354157090187073,
-0.1195649653673172,
0.7023504376411438,
0.03649495169520378,
0.4611607491970062,
0.32826051115989685,
-0.3235645294189453,
-0.24912220239639282,
-0.05059521645307541,
0.5205707550048828,
0.03140438720583916,
-0.14283312857151031,
-0.36070263385772705,
-0.5701305270195007,
-0.4507557451725006,
0.48578718304634094,
-0.7165069580078125,
-0.08371151983737946,
-0.0017072763293981552,
-0.6714736223220825,
0.14047503471374512,
-0.007486344780772924,
-0.5895018577575684,
0.1956552118062973,
-0.3242475986480713,
0.8580220341682434,
-0.683252215385437,
-0.18475346267223358,
-0.08222988247871399,
-0.5598516464233398,
0.5201690196990967,
0.3545437753200531,
-0.7283710837364197,
0.4306827783584595,
0.6626381874084473,
0.9317759275436401,
-0.40292441844940186,
-0.33071964979171753,
-0.7148520350456238,
-0.197096049785614,
-0.2460108995437622,
0.8201146125793457,
-0.4248891770839691,
-0.4658448398113251,
-0.04787582531571388,
-0.40224239230155945,
-0.2154138833284378,
-1.0590673685073853,
0.42553484439849854,
-1.0029175281524658,
0.12682825326919556,
-0.38256537914276123,
-0.5497883558273315,
-0.3902670443058014,
0.11223383992910385,
-0.5563981533050537,
0.8952347040176392,
0.015219524502754211,
-0.3003101050853729,
0.29158124327659607,
-0.4297417402267456,
-0.5234282612800598,
-0.14834994077682495,
-0.35746511816978455,
-0.17460457980632782,
0.5690233707427979,
0.05127105489373207,
0.46736547350883484,
-0.13740140199661255,
0.0044858017936348915,
-0.0011390306754037738,
-0.4743868410587311,
0.013625135645270348,
-0.49406665563583374,
0.5407474637031555,
0.5338970422744751,
-0.23598457872867584,
-0.2883358299732208,
-0.2604937255382538,
-0.05541085824370384,
-0.15632762014865875,
-0.6375646591186523,
-0.6568983793258667,
0.011129801161587238,
-0.12060917913913727,
0.46547436714172363,
-0.06941338628530502,
-0.40072101354599,
0.24268566071987152,
0.04509691894054413,
0.40634462237358093,
0.5705543160438538,
0.43591153621673584,
0.3949689567089081,
-0.2855546772480011,
0.30591779947280884,
0.4168403744697571,
-0.19616785645484924,
-0.5156233906745911,
-0.6941503882408142,
-0.41603216528892517,
-0.18655918538570404,
0.33737000823020935,
0.3230630159378052,
-0.6185607314109802,
-0.1527365744113922,
-0.12508712708950043,
-0.13940700888633728,
-0.7566035389900208,
0.19498808681964874,
0.7282739281654358,
0.5545535087585449,
0.6484419107437134,
-0.48340314626693726,
-0.2616671621799469,
-1.1444214582443237,
-0.5605090856552124,
0.005068057216703892,
0.2116170972585678,
0.5123639106750488,
0.39076223969459534,
-0.0926012247800827,
0.6714050769805908,
-0.22677065432071686,
0.2786634564399719,
-0.0694795548915863,
0.46866345405578613,
0.06573600322008133,
0.6952841281890869,
0.5554526448249817,
-0.9673451781272888,
-0.3407552242279053,
-0.05585150048136711,
-0.5372873544692993,
0.140293687582016,
-0.05597183108329773,
-0.2158573567867279,
0.07288629561662674,
0.5098106861114502,
-0.7185045480728149,
0.4994155764579773,
0.24701836705207825,
0.08005562424659729,
0.34498879313468933,
-0.33292490243911743,
0.6185508370399475,
-1.1202149391174316,
-0.18789516389369965,
-0.19523537158966064,
-0.05684972181916237,
-0.5415117740631104,
0.49171578884124756,
0.3273138105869293,
0.27296531200408936,
-0.6530588865280151,
0.40718722343444824,
-0.7430188655853271,
-0.5196176171302795,
-0.2859223484992981,
0.12978608906269073,
0.0335245281457901,
0.19087976217269897,
0.003760502440854907,
1.0328773260116577,
0.17128705978393555,
-0.8776352405548096,
-0.1474330574274063,
0.12418711930513382,
-0.4506201446056366,
0.03910880908370018,
-0.5014253258705139,
0.4079693555831909,
-0.11825909465551376,
-0.062451962381601334,
-1.0994088649749756,
0.1501339226961136,
-0.05457541346549988,
-0.5746056437492371,
0.4418778717517853,
-0.23920325934886932,
-0.7094477415084839,
0.07059377431869507,
-0.15380702912807465,
0.5526394248008728,
0.7128300070762634,
-0.6686520576477051,
0.3776415288448334,
0.10390589386224747,
-0.032389186322689056,
-0.6913683414459229,
-0.8586133122444153,
0.007950371131300926,
-0.3713720440864563,
-0.18632358312606812,
0.31793397665023804,
0.03899598494172096,
-0.46294882893562317,
0.06499192863702774,
-0.16664226353168488,
-0.0461232028901577,
0.08566370606422424,
-0.06996287405490875,
0.09156081825494766,
-0.6342380046844482,
0.18009957671165466,
0.35263267159461975,
0.29105985164642334,
-0.12632809579372406,
-0.35473018884658813,
0.5441793203353882,
-0.20474673807621002,
-0.37442025542259216,
0.08181315660476685,
0.6624252200126648,
0.27958744764328003,
-0.304354727268219,
0.7552372217178345,
0.3736685514450073,
-0.1796707659959793,
-0.14101244509220123,
-0.5416803956031799,
-0.1856023073196411,
-0.42932140827178955,
0.3965678811073303,
-0.5607662200927734,
-0.7526524662971497,
0.6005925536155701,
-0.10192099958658218,
0.22802266478538513,
0.5426568388938904,
0.713153064250946,
-0.08138297498226166,
0.8330048322677612,
0.27657634019851685,
0.008360954001545906,
0.5612583160400391,
-0.30103960633277893,
0.06866151839494705,
-1.3582221269607544,
0.20697037875652313,
-0.542137861251831,
-0.5573853254318237,
-0.39429858326911926,
-0.45246273279190063,
0.02461189590394497,
0.5608968138694763,
-0.03095998801290989,
0.7401135563850403,
-0.1828557848930359,
0.3872270882129669,
0.6572023630142212,
0.04094402864575386,
0.534616231918335,
0.1307460069656372,
-0.48571473360061646,
0.05181723088026047,
-0.7671292424201965,
-0.5283834934234619,
1.0931936502456665,
-0.13009192049503326,
0.24122795462608337,
0.41178184747695923,
0.8219428658485413,
0.3543604910373688,
0.6707162857055664,
-0.7447625398635864,
0.3078421950340271,
-0.27711406350135803,
-0.6928979158401489,
0.2880096733570099,
-0.40383559465408325,
-0.9942110776901245,
0.5461071133613586,
0.2677336633205414,
-0.4943418502807617,
0.2578725814819336,
0.17056342959403992,
-0.16557645797729492,
0.19160886108875275,
-1.0488381385803223,
0.7085155248641968,
-0.22632430493831635,
-0.28642961382865906,
-0.51070237159729,
-0.5815362930297852,
0.32629460096359253,
-0.16511502861976624,
-0.17123790085315704,
0.47170737385749817,
-0.07539893686771393,
0.39262208342552185,
-0.06155815348029137,
0.3810752034187317,
0.07895050942897797,
0.03888322785496712,
0.5034306645393372,
0.11471717804670334,
0.2634883224964142,
-0.07365620881319046,
-0.48684656620025635,
0.01339374016970396,
-0.40690696239471436,
-0.4919472932815552,
-0.6765022277832031,
0.9900565147399902,
-0.8085468411445618,
-0.7750370502471924,
-0.11781610548496246,
-0.5428294539451599,
-0.12612099945545197,
0.13386784493923187,
0.3604576885700226,
0.45765748620033264,
0.04398272559046745,
0.296122282743454,
0.6493128538131714,
-0.2983286678791046,
0.5151866674423218,
0.5635143518447876,
-0.22975751757621765,
-0.12042006850242615,
0.5577954649925232,
0.2943345010280609,
0.6551976799964905,
0.5638101100921631,
0.0541389174759388,
-0.17970021069049835,
-0.7493377327919006,
-0.6134999394416809,
0.07539217919111252,
-0.729130744934082,
-0.1518903225660324,
-0.7141066789627075,
-0.03171040117740631,
-0.3169077932834625,
0.042044684290885925,
-0.2910624146461487,
-0.4721759557723999,
-0.14043861627578735,
-0.17664049565792084,
0.3654765188694,
0.797529399394989,
0.043571893125772476,
0.2834100127220154,
-0.8149347901344299,
0.15040867030620575,
0.10707969218492508,
0.1811607927083969,
0.40224793553352356,
-0.6978513598442078,
-0.39535489678382874,
0.02352721244096756,
-0.41130152344703674,
-0.9922587275505066,
0.36123257875442505,
0.06603377312421799,
0.6415144205093384,
0.24562373757362366,
-0.4610596001148224,
0.9566690325737,
-0.7813825011253357,
0.6580594182014465,
-0.33171290159225464,
-0.5832002758979797,
0.4941735565662384,
-0.2481657713651657,
0.23298530280590057,
0.48907098174095154,
0.44186681509017944,
-0.45171162486076355,
-0.2389354556798935,
-0.5360188484191895,
-0.9745451211929321,
0.4099136292934418,
0.0899801254272461,
0.2841421663761139,
-0.515739381313324,
0.8319392800331116,
0.33157971501350403,
0.3551921248435974,
-0.14188233017921448,
-0.24709051847457886,
0.11657407879829407,
0.20509403944015503,
0.06353441625833511,
0.12568482756614685,
0.34324514865875244,
-0.04808925837278366,
0.5139610767364502,
0.35639023780822754,
0.3969922363758087,
0.2834920287132263,
-0.37434205412864685,
0.12313622981309891,
0.24631765484809875,
0.5103939771652222,
0.2694641649723053,
-0.24625632166862488,
0.19978304207324982,
-0.04342636466026306,
-0.5167790651321411,
-0.11344746500253677,
-0.19999617338180542,
-0.4292512834072113,
0.2608594298362732,
0.13253900408744812,
0.822882890701294,
0.28303781151771545,
-0.5126880407333374,
0.11653508245944977,
0.046609487384557724,
-0.1591169536113739,
0.050279948860406876,
0.014012313447892666,
-0.011804761365056038,
0.4189300537109375,
0.5386670827865601,
0.4068378806114197,
0.4934786260128021,
-0.7203183174133301,
0.5951329469680786,
0.466999888420105,
-0.22513045370578766,
-0.3306788504123688,
0.3604993522167206,
-0.29103830456733704,
-0.5709729790687561,
1.0031789541244507,
-0.16269396245479584,
-0.27662423253059387,
0.4941489100456238,
0.7683061361312866,
1.0047107934951782,
-0.17275433242321014,
-0.17127548158168793,
0.16689357161521912,
0.10454670339822769,
-0.3487483561038971,
-0.06876052916049957,
-0.3274408280849457,
-0.6379923820495605,
-0.559744119644165,
-0.47122275829315186,
-0.15902648866176605,
0.05236482620239258,
-0.8467400670051575,
-0.12530124187469482,
0.042293939739465714,
-0.2292850911617279,
-0.2099158614873886,
-0.1430100053548813,
-0.600943386554718,
-0.12925127148628235,
-0.10978744924068451,
0.909206211566925,
-0.6378036737442017,
0.9595339298248291,
0.9792619943618774,
-0.6112105846405029,
-0.8137416839599609,
0.29383590817451477,
-0.11833556741476059,
-0.8069412112236023,
1.0162880420684814,
-0.15399977564811707,
-0.19972865283489227,
0.184339702129364,
-0.1834951788187027,
-0.9519248008728027,
1.0958348512649536,
0.115921750664711,
0.05201195180416107,
-0.030817419290542603,
-0.3324814438819885,
0.6452577114105225,
-0.4698094129562378,
0.3024664521217346,
0.4367249608039856,
0.08106679469347,
-0.0691380724310875,
-0.545430064201355,
-0.15663766860961914,
-0.29575368762016296,
0.1144610270857811,
0.30886027216911316,
-0.6255051493644714,
1.1167311668395996,
-0.03250278905034065,
-0.15468299388885498,
0.2626694440841675,
0.5852317810058594,
0.38035517930984497,
0.02021758258342743,
0.1720486581325531,
0.6407110691070557,
0.0760420709848404,
0.26297542452812195,
1.2997851371765137,
-0.1336994469165802,
0.1374821960926056,
1.1433515548706055,
-0.09867063164710999,
1.3429059982299805,
0.8430246114730835,
0.0769476667046547,
0.4682769775390625,
0.5950497984886169,
0.26639673113822937,
0.6769320368766785,
0.15864886343479156,
-0.20742881298065186,
0.2224358171224594,
0.2105087786912918,
-0.2745600640773773,
0.16204269230365753,
0.4474946856498718,
-0.7268105745315552,
-0.39148491621017456,
-0.05423222854733467,
-0.0930478572845459,
-0.19354034960269928,
-0.22435112297534943,
0.5932679772377014,
0.376173734664917,
-1.041639804840088,
0.41825059056282043,
0.09515929222106934,
0.5035387277603149,
-0.19837896525859833,
-0.3074581027030945,
-0.4069843888282776,
0.19835053384304047,
0.10403355211019516,
-0.6130119562149048,
0.363879531621933,
-0.05273020640015602,
-0.28905707597732544,
-0.6003362536430359,
0.695982813835144,
-0.29749059677124023,
0.011733693070709705,
0.4568001925945282,
1.0438830852508545,
0.4621553421020508,
-0.044053733348846436,
-0.5890212059020996,
-0.1407374143600464,
-0.12272565066814423,
-0.6257906556129456,
0.7231403589248657,
0.4585198163986206,
-0.2614475190639496,
0.2913471758365631,
0.4230945110321045,
0.06263479590415955,
0.5573566555976868,
-0.10178037732839584,
0.5963163375854492,
-0.46236470341682434,
0.03651011735200882,
-0.9127999544143677,
0.20920120179653168,
0.12797485291957855,
-0.574003279209137,
1.1022824048995972,
0.7862182259559631,
0.9219363927841187,
-0.28292393684387207,
0.44208472967147827,
-0.05972393602132797,
0.358673095703125,
-0.4793560206890106,
0.45801740884780884,
-0.5074610710144043,
0.5687562823295593,
-0.2224273681640625,
-0.973500669002533,
-0.06670306622982025,
0.4175078570842743,
-0.3829912841320038,
0.26341769099235535,
0.7602163553237915,
0.5600119829177856,
-0.3242878019809723,
-0.0189866591244936,
0.23058688640594482,
0.1968458890914917,
0.02157299965620041,
0.23129338026046753,
0.821732223033905,
-0.7606214284896851,
0.42199817299842834,
-0.11395463347434998,
0.054619528353214264,
-0.16311512887477875,
-0.6245869994163513,
-0.36460211873054504,
-0.6085126399993896,
-0.13385829329490662,
-0.053113825619220734,
0.26951271295547485,
0.6916258335113525,
0.524901270866394,
-0.6234363317489624,
-0.33878836035728455,
-0.07168760895729065,
0.09831062704324722,
-0.45348063111305237,
-0.2276320904493332,
0.3740176558494568,
-0.6024601459503174,
-0.6741071343421936,
0.4930255115032196,
0.3700544834136963,
-0.06105620041489601,
0.04761051759123802,
0.03943760693073273,
-0.5977698564529419,
-0.06121224910020828,
0.6589529514312744,
0.2844705581665039,
-0.5830983519554138,
-0.17881160974502563,
0.26010119915008545,
-0.20198632776737213,
0.36195558309555054,
0.9987092614173889,
-1.001442313194275,
0.1306520700454712,
0.6465795040130615,
1.0981022119522095,
0.5994246006011963,
0.1522599160671234,
0.6621372103691101,
-0.6981637477874756,
-0.20433269441127777,
0.1336362212896347,
0.39664381742477417,
0.1325427144765854,
-0.18472804129123688,
0.23582594096660614,
0.04470236226916313,
-0.7040351033210754,
-0.5614128708839417,
0.3854656517505646,
-0.5642320513725281,
-0.35573118925094604,
0.9801874756813049,
-0.20968441665172577,
-0.051563113927841187,
-0.10142810642719269,
0.05587499216198921,
0.36935755610466003,
-0.37535911798477173,
0.7031243443489075,
0.7684810757637024,
-0.3419210612773895,
-0.08047638088464737,
-1.0625429153442383,
0.22083255648612976,
0.7851802110671997,
-0.2573558986186981,
-0.26989421248435974,
0.3755115866661072,
0.11023379862308502,
0.08483868092298508,
0.48238036036491394,
-0.417572557926178,
0.20700496435165405,
-0.16459062695503235,
-0.21290315687656403,
0.3429209291934967,
-0.11672420799732208,
-0.6370202898979187,
-0.0892658457159996,
0.06034611165523529,
-0.19649532437324524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02823v1
|
Conifer: Improving Complex Constrained Instruction-Following Ability of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T15:55:39 | 2024-04-03T15:55:39 |
Haoran Sun, Lixin Liu, Junjie Li, Fengyu Wang, Baohua Dong, Ran Lin, Ruohui Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The ability of large language models (LLMs) to follow instructions is crucial
to real-world applications. Despite recent advances, several studies have
highlighted that LLMs struggle when faced with challenging instructions,
especially those that include complex constraints, hindering their
effectiveness in various tasks. To address this challenge, we introduce
Conifer, a novel instruction tuning dataset, designed to enhance LLMs to follow
multi-level instructions with complex constraints. Utilizing GPT-4, we curate
the dataset by a series of LLM-driven refinement processes to ensure high
quality. We also propose a progressive learning scheme that emphasizes an
easy-to-hard progression, and learning from process feedback. Models trained
with Conifer exhibit remarkable improvements in instruction-following
abilities, especially for instructions with complex constraints. On several
instruction-following benchmarks, our 7B model outperforms the state-of-the-art
open-source 7B models, even exceeds the performance of models 10 times larger
on certain metrics. All the code and Conifer dataset are available at
https://www.github.com/ConiferLM/Conifer.
|
[
-0.06727021187543869,
-0.7076621055603027,
0.17168807983398438,
0.18695513904094696,
-0.2700982689857483,
0.1828700751066208,
-0.22186507284641266,
-0.4773592948913574,
-0.40677404403686523,
0.6699815988540649,
-1.1022361516952515,
-0.9632487297058105,
-0.6353075504302979,
0.002580345841124654,
-0.12386146187782288,
1.0035407543182373,
0.09070879966020584,
0.24943938851356506,
0.14416995644569397,
-0.14144885540008545,
-0.7969639301300049,
-0.2831099033355713,
-0.5228651165962219,
-0.2829020023345947,
0.38213589787483215,
0.6278943419456482,
0.7601128816604614,
0.9493445754051208,
0.48098284006118774,
0.26716864109039307,
-0.035273898392915726,
0.4740001857280731,
-0.6501865386962891,
0.3631625175476074,
-0.11131846904754639,
-0.46038174629211426,
-0.3038828372955322,
-0.24499352276325226,
0.6363992691040039,
0.8088755011558533,
-0.4149008095264435,
0.01828792877495289,
0.25758111476898193,
0.5345871448516846,
-0.2607504427433014,
0.5352844595909119,
-0.7104869484901428,
-0.1442273110151291,
-0.32007306814193726,
-0.19595377147197723,
-0.4877198338508606,
-0.6832777857780457,
0.2178819179534912,
-0.8644317388534546,
0.4408663809299469,
0.20876798033714294,
0.3918508291244507,
0.5923715829849243,
-0.24624155461788177,
-0.5788933038711548,
-0.5426555275917053,
0.682992160320282,
-0.840418815612793,
0.4111892580986023,
0.13045178353786469,
0.27991971373558044,
-0.5585163235664368,
-0.6526502370834351,
-0.16976362466812134,
-0.3229249119758606,
-0.06407864391803741,
-0.16665400564670563,
0.08764929324388504,
0.43350833654403687,
0.5990142822265625,
0.2968441843986511,
-0.53336501121521,
0.146978959441185,
-0.2231709361076355,
-0.14586545526981354,
0.14685744047164917,
0.18643951416015625,
0.21803000569343567,
0.38551411032676697,
-0.09044353663921356,
-0.06408415734767914,
-0.9801095724105835,
0.2232128530740738,
0.3325519263744354,
0.2515958845615387,
0.05452846735715866,
0.4224008619785309,
-0.2952896058559418,
1.1262314319610596,
0.014097039587795734,
-0.10915713757276535,
0.06228920817375183,
-0.17409218847751617,
-0.31758132576942444,
0.3012946844100952,
0.07810047268867493,
0.2650725245475769,
0.2367464303970337,
-0.12080566585063934,
-0.2659296691417694,
0.2267633080482483,
-0.21427695453166962,
-1.2244657278060913,
-0.5633833408355713,
0.02779785357415676,
-0.14892321825027466,
0.10983602702617645,
-0.27488261461257935,
-0.4725933074951172,
-0.3563958406448364,
-0.7625964283943176,
0.03167194128036499,
-0.664709746837616,
-0.024454327300190926,
0.4035734534263611,
0.12744183838367462,
0.3026735186576843,
0.5314615368843079,
-1.1981840133666992,
0.42880335450172424,
1.1758073568344116,
0.5541263222694397,
0.026590261608362198,
-0.0999312549829483,
-1.2122249603271484,
0.22372975945472717,
-0.37537744641304016,
0.4762469232082367,
-1.3534200191497803,
-0.20367588102817535,
-0.062170397490262985,
0.18554428219795227,
0.025085628032684326,
-0.7800365090370178,
0.6326968669891357,
-0.2882627844810486,
-0.10082347691059113,
-0.060493629425764084,
-0.7275222539901733,
-0.3153221011161804,
0.24975115060806274,
-0.5440753102302551,
0.7602930068969727,
0.1927250176668167,
-0.4712170660495758,
0.11140979826450348,
-0.28422895073890686,
-0.4769632816314697,
0.14988888800144196,
-0.28918373584747314,
-0.3675936758518219,
0.022021979093551636,
0.062229689210653305,
0.3764354884624481,
-0.46134212613105774,
0.3773181736469269,
-0.5234190821647644,
-0.5024110078811646,
-0.3661186397075653,
-0.5043366551399231,
0.6514102816581726,
-0.13282138109207153,
-0.38606491684913635,
0.2679117023944855,
-0.9996417164802551,
0.13393597304821014,
-0.46036770939826965,
-0.38732126355171204,
-0.3583448827266693,
-0.029284894466400146,
-0.3801625370979309,
-0.21481716632843018,
0.15530192852020264,
-0.6512671113014221,
0.6426236033439636,
-0.15792837738990784,
0.4492747485637665,
0.672252893447876,
0.024029724299907684,
0.2090630680322647,
-0.14891907572746277,
0.5528479218482971,
-0.24542179703712463,
0.28040775656700134,
-0.31588730216026306,
-0.17124515771865845,
-0.6618849039077759,
-0.002668913220986724,
0.232872873544693,
0.5784096717834473,
-0.578265368938446,
-0.003262606682255864,
0.04561847075819969,
-0.49479442834854126,
-0.7413899302482605,
0.2192162573337555,
0.6882813572883606,
0.4803236722946167,
0.5638121962547302,
-0.17423942685127258,
-0.46789175271987915,
-0.5686173439025879,
0.012042233720421791,
0.3166719675064087,
0.07178612798452377,
0.2557012438774109,
0.22268325090408325,
-0.2341017872095108,
0.30671098828315735,
-0.5332269072532654,
-0.14799407124519348,
0.06460229307413101,
0.0740121379494667,
0.5200128555297852,
0.8393909335136414,
0.21613110601902008,
-0.5545883774757385,
-0.5363222360610962,
0.18151675164699554,
-0.48789212107658386,
-0.09775765240192413,
-0.059345543384552,
-0.239424929022789,
0.04480357468128204,
0.6066268086433411,
-0.630972146987915,
0.13356947898864746,
0.795406699180603,
-0.2763355076313019,
0.7863375544548035,
-0.3122421205043793,
-0.2707546055316925,
-0.7968388199806213,
-0.22238920629024506,
0.08285387605428696,
-0.23706836998462677,
-0.46045801043510437,
0.09252596646547318,
-0.008235400542616844,
0.009638226591050625,
-0.24558575451374054,
0.08306627720594406,
-0.7673305869102478,
0.15124072134494781,
0.02962123043835163,
-0.3229674994945526,
-0.06745171546936035,
0.6539161205291748,
0.02966206707060337,
0.6675257086753845,
0.825367271900177,
-0.4664168655872345,
0.5774515271186829,
0.1439467966556549,
-0.582219123840332,
0.472247451543808,
-0.8175395131111145,
0.16373319923877716,
-0.10914387553930283,
0.3098157048225403,
-0.6306283473968506,
-0.3147318661212921,
0.4057300388813019,
0.15089455246925354,
0.8269544243812561,
-0.6420156359672546,
-0.2805705964565277,
0.11240524798631668,
-0.10327279567718506,
0.019137665629386902,
0.22756652534008026,
-0.3973442018032074,
0.5323227643966675,
-0.07639837265014648,
-0.14119558036327362,
-0.7107304334640503,
-0.45024171471595764,
-0.15189096331596375,
0.03965712711215019,
-0.4029352366924286,
0.5005207657814026,
-0.3106438219547272,
0.016005968675017357,
-0.08314541727304459,
-0.30958104133605957,
0.2861526608467102,
-0.010179082863032818,
0.08295903354883194,
0.13856300711631775,
-0.299363911151886,
0.10161010921001434,
0.15453629195690155,
-0.03920857980847359,
-0.05938918516039848,
-0.5445678234100342,
0.4353542625904083,
-0.025048840790987015,
-0.29766756296157837,
-0.6858240365982056,
0.23842397332191467,
0.5264281034469604,
-0.4082813262939453,
0.37936511635780334,
0.41935670375823975,
-0.17230463027954102,
-0.520797848701477,
-0.14274688065052032,
-0.282808393239975,
-0.46257615089416504,
0.6310895085334778,
-0.461080402135849,
-0.8702897429466248,
0.024900639429688454,
-0.41872644424438477,
0.5367777347564697,
-0.08920881152153015,
0.12168202549219131,
-0.04681646451354027,
1.0269172191619873,
0.7276755571365356,
0.08425240963697433,
0.6199174523353577,
-0.49741673469543457,
-0.20395256578922272,
-1.0806448459625244,
-0.3289391100406647,
-0.511885404586792,
-0.4174211025238037,
-0.7744501233100891,
-0.3545922636985779,
0.12935560941696167,
0.26589435338974,
-0.46110257506370544,
0.2550898790359497,
-0.8267767429351807,
0.5402817130088806,
0.6673673987388611,
0.23250745236873627,
0.18275143206119537,
-0.1381518840789795,
-0.12761437892913818,
0.08200542628765106,
-0.7598872780799866,
-0.4134022295475006,
0.6616212725639343,
0.3516792356967926,
1.29562246799469,
0.26069051027297974,
0.33537811040878296,
0.09110041707754135,
0.6830666661262512,
-0.6105828881263733,
0.4496346712112427,
-0.6557870507240295,
-0.3508278727531433,
-0.4012089967727661,
-0.4932135045528412,
-0.8055877089500427,
0.10515494644641876,
-0.0692354142665863,
-0.6186814308166504,
0.017146479338407516,
0.506822407245636,
-0.3964282274246216,
0.05961785092949867,
-0.8230242133140564,
0.9781858325004578,
-0.439340740442276,
-0.42853811383247375,
-0.19666877388954163,
-0.7664922475814819,
0.22261179983615875,
0.2386232316493988,
-0.07693066447973251,
-0.4115067720413208,
-0.021276913583278656,
0.1967635452747345,
-0.5354673862457275,
1.0761457681655884,
-0.4006698727607727,
-0.026858000084757805,
0.14580601453781128,
0.33360254764556885,
0.9330510497093201,
-0.07898649573326111,
-0.15498961508274078,
-0.35158711671829224,
0.08319105952978134,
-0.36892199516296387,
-0.7239829897880554,
0.9091417193412781,
-0.7158076167106628,
-0.9756349325180054,
-0.225370854139328,
-0.6764094233512878,
-0.1801399290561676,
0.1435888409614563,
0.06007308512926102,
1.1357711553573608,
-0.07982826977968216,
0.5395765900611877,
0.9354590177536011,
-0.0042606499046087265,
0.2274230420589447,
0.4359632730484009,
-0.06237199157476425,
-0.26546844840049744,
0.9148293137550354,
0.33014312386512756,
0.44545111060142517,
0.5635340809822083,
0.19324350357055664,
-0.433828741312027,
-0.8476738333702087,
-0.8872811198234558,
0.0952802300453186,
-0.5630850195884705,
-0.3581582307815552,
-0.2276468575000763,
-0.0792083889245987,
-0.09179621934890747,
0.15411892533302307,
-0.03350065276026726,
-0.18954455852508545,
-0.49975714087486267,
-0.024861672893166542,
0.36566975712776184,
0.8809676170349121,
0.5898786187171936,
0.43429169058799744,
-0.8200095295906067,
-0.17766143381595612,
0.2845575511455536,
0.5786038637161255,
0.045310281217098236,
-0.5053827166557312,
-0.007846376858651638,
0.2459995597600937,
-0.5083745718002319,
-0.6405380368232727,
0.06307946145534515,
0.5969150066375732,
0.4669411778450012,
0.1534697562456131,
0.076457180082798,
0.7829933762550354,
-0.48709216713905334,
0.13298992812633514,
0.05855000019073486,
-0.8086708784103394,
0.2729716897010803,
-0.4711415469646454,
0.5788087844848633,
0.32864806056022644,
0.3770264685153961,
-0.4975157678127289,
-0.3188638389110565,
-0.23876814544200897,
-0.4906705617904663,
0.6770449280738831,
0.10601414740085602,
0.12934841215610504,
0.4126056730747223,
0.600060760974884,
0.3403533697128296,
0.19824635982513428,
-0.4118645489215851,
0.007384498603641987,
-0.16848604381084442,
-0.5250583291053772,
0.07533552497625351,
-0.0320405438542366,
0.06159903109073639,
-0.17818930745124817,
0.7490746974945068,
-0.366538405418396,
-0.46905848383903503,
0.00525513244792819,
0.011512351222336292,
-0.11207285523414612,
0.18938468396663666,
0.6169673204421997,
0.699244499206543,
-0.30991795659065247,
0.13890914618968964,
0.2459961175918579,
-0.4152402877807617,
0.0740438848733902,
0.34007102251052856,
-0.35786664485931396,
0.01021132804453373,
0.4178134799003601,
0.9634270071983337,
0.357930064201355,
-0.5311896800994873,
-0.003878798335790634,
-0.12470635026693344,
0.12062371522188187,
-0.1807127743959427,
0.5209052562713623,
0.23029197752475739,
0.3228246569633484,
0.2121737003326416,
0.33292505145072937,
0.134478360414505,
-0.725811243057251,
0.1341700702905655,
0.41796496510505676,
-0.531382143497467,
-0.38877442479133606,
0.47757914662361145,
0.3502824604511261,
-0.4850076735019684,
0.7221434116363525,
-0.07376327365636826,
-0.35649287700653076,
0.6853400468826294,
0.7621162533760071,
0.37038350105285645,
-0.3750856816768646,
0.13291150331497192,
0.340474933385849,
0.2581738829612732,
-0.21334174275398254,
0.3563326895236969,
0.0019128856947645545,
-0.41724759340286255,
-0.5488262176513672,
-0.6159597039222717,
-0.6760578155517578,
0.05108721926808357,
-0.3822198510169983,
0.5119690299034119,
-0.7950213551521301,
0.19551630318164825,
0.03759903088212013,
0.17446206510066986,
-0.6281648874282837,
0.23332662880420685,
-0.08163551986217499,
1.106313943862915,
-0.36881059408187866,
1.1795330047607422,
0.42097002267837524,
-0.06970685720443726,
-0.9521613121032715,
-0.15442503988742828,
-0.03366515040397644,
-0.5677266120910645,
0.11749834567308426,
0.6423868536949158,
-0.3888772130012512,
0.42098140716552734,
-0.8099643588066101,
-0.7082383036613464,
1.0638036727905273,
0.7147412896156311,
-1.4322866201400757,
-0.03412075340747833,
-0.09689338505268097,
0.5148544907569885,
-0.633883535861969,
0.1611909568309784,
0.758499026298523,
0.28982362151145935,
0.5274941325187683,
-0.3646145761013031,
0.04709511995315552,
-0.08238287270069122,
-0.11617995798587799,
0.5517483949661255,
-0.844109058380127,
0.5608210563659668,
-0.2786507308483124,
-0.20844899117946625,
0.16499362885951996,
0.6303901076316833,
0.28797054290771484,
0.1887577325105667,
0.4512515366077423,
0.5707682967185974,
1.1120288372039795,
-0.1482556313276291,
0.8221327066421509,
-0.3779919147491455,
0.12051355838775635,
1.586891770362854,
-0.1855795532464981,
0.6618457436561584,
0.035164352506399155,
0.2473440021276474,
0.6467128992080688,
0.9292903542518616,
-0.0960863009095192,
0.5355775356292725,
0.5993554592132568,
-0.22538965940475464,
-0.3177410066127777,
-0.3429912030696869,
-0.26615455746650696,
0.08360693603754044,
0.6010366678237915,
-0.13595695793628693,
-0.13154035806655884,
-0.28988271951675415,
0.2187136560678482,
0.043290358036756516,
-0.46829649806022644,
0.5882606506347656,
0.08061624318361282,
-1.0523229837417603,
0.9060217142105103,
-0.2637629210948944,
0.5466728806495667,
-0.7236995697021484,
-0.7333357930183411,
-0.30525267124176025,
0.44643181562423706,
-0.328937292098999,
-0.8171330094337463,
0.17509520053863525,
-0.08975719660520554,
-0.07807505875825882,
-0.05127107724547386,
0.3221045136451721,
-0.8960996866226196,
-0.4624955654144287,
0.23964214324951172,
-0.08311034739017487,
0.0690404400229454,
0.23067739605903625,
-0.6937889456748962,
0.34373217821121216,
0.32641369104385376,
0.021630849689245224,
0.02134452387690544,
0.8577588796615601,
-0.245941162109375,
0.8668639063835144,
0.7061925530433655,
0.006682849023491144,
0.12099625915288925,
0.2426043599843979,
0.93192058801651,
-0.38313058018684387,
0.13615091145038605,
-0.8526777029037476,
0.1902136653661728,
0.06933268904685974,
-0.5433713793754578,
0.37130650877952576,
0.6747884750366211,
1.069026231765747,
0.068116195499897,
0.6577357649803162,
0.1655450314283371,
0.45048975944519043,
-0.723060131072998,
0.1465778648853302,
-0.1703513115644455,
0.47366973757743835,
0.11394200474023819,
-1.0779221057891846,
-0.4025540351867676,
0.23985452950000763,
-0.21504934132099152,
-0.17917400598526,
0.4091675877571106,
1.1422823667526245,
-0.2882262170314789,
0.12945058941841125,
0.16795052587985992,
0.47350987792015076,
0.5243718028068542,
0.7884572744369507,
0.7043280601501465,
0.07604283094406128,
0.7206441164016724,
-0.08411704748868942,
-0.44573044776916504,
-0.11228886246681213,
-0.7745396494865417,
-0.7763384580612183,
-0.13299459218978882,
-0.21088610589504242,
-0.12473227828741074,
0.3203696608543396,
1.384770393371582,
0.9022441506385803,
-1.0247894525527954,
-0.25381529331207275,
-0.42195186018943787,
0.1175733432173729,
-0.34728166460990906,
-0.056856971234083176,
0.3819997310638428,
-0.42776593565940857,
-0.8303917050361633,
0.2333708554506302,
0.2241818755865097,
0.14990420639514923,
-0.3343517780303955,
-0.2734338045120239,
-0.16606679558753967,
-0.1491531878709793,
0.36937326192855835,
0.1278315782546997,
-0.5887315273284912,
-0.3941119313240051,
0.15609528124332428,
-0.09416082501411438,
0.03622305020689964,
0.7541611194610596,
-0.3904048800468445,
0.6008908152580261,
0.26070258021354675,
0.5702382326126099,
0.6299096345901489,
0.10649575293064117,
0.5929846167564392,
-0.6086449027061462,
-0.07194988429546356,
0.42777085304260254,
0.27392667531967163,
0.6698607206344604,
-0.3640352189540863,
0.5149643421173096,
0.11196592450141907,
-0.55445396900177,
-0.4787868559360504,
0.36252889037132263,
-0.6906387209892273,
-0.12206898629665375,
0.9764813780784607,
-0.3689991533756256,
-0.18065881729125977,
-0.14771173894405365,
-0.6516096591949463,
0.251183420419693,
-0.6342127919197083,
0.6634573936462402,
0.6376405954360962,
-0.1842629313468933,
-0.4687384366989136,
-0.5429297089576721,
0.7028195261955261,
0.2594797611236572,
-0.6663849949836731,
0.39017295837402344,
0.5952538847923279,
0.39091289043426514,
-0.3347417414188385,
0.08589311689138412,
0.2407548874616623,
0.22543422877788544,
-0.3322528898715973,
-0.11677243560552597,
-0.08053003996610641,
-0.5829970240592957,
-0.07352039963006973,
0.048476461321115494,
0.18781667947769165,
-0.29562681913375854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02822v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02822v2
|
Identifying Climate Targets in National Laws and Policies using Machine Learning
| 2024-04-03T15:55:27 | 2024-04-04T11:23:59 |
Matyas Juhasz, Tina Marchand, Roshan Melwani, Kalyan Dutia, Sarah Goodenough, Harrison Pim, Henry Franks
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Quantified policy targets are a fundamental element of climate policy,
typically characterised by domain-specific and technical language. Current
methods for curating comprehensive views of global climate policy targets
entail significant manual effort. At present there are few scalable methods for
extracting climate targets from national laws or policies, which limits
policymakers' and researchers' ability to (1) assess private and public sector
alignment with global goals and (2) inform policy decisions. In this paper we
present an approach for extracting mentions of climate targets from national
laws and policies. We create an expert-annotated dataset identifying three
categories of target ('Net Zero', 'Reduction' and 'Other' (e.g. renewable
energy targets)) and train a classifier to reliably identify them in text. We
investigate bias and equity impacts related to our model and identify specific
years and country names as problematic features. Finally, we investigate the
characteristics of the dataset produced by running this classifier on the
Climate Policy Radar (CPR) dataset of global national climate laws and policies
and UNFCCC submissions, highlighting the potential of automated and scalable
data collection for existing climate policy databases and supporting further
research. Our work represents a significant upgrade in the accessibility of
these key climate policy elements for policymakers and researchers. We publish
our model at https://huggingface.co/ClimatePolicyRadar/national-climate-targets
and related dataset at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ClimatePolicyRadar/national-climate-targets.
|
[
-0.45444902777671814,
-0.4038817584514618,
0.2887958586215973,
-0.022203342989087105,
0.024480493739247322,
0.09424011409282684,
-0.19334504008293152,
-0.22872763872146606,
0.07287316769361496,
0.839438796043396,
-0.4299153685569763,
-0.5155606865882874,
-0.6129646301269531,
-0.12077856063842773,
-0.4806252717971802,
1.2885684967041016,
-0.09348128736019135,
-0.3266383707523346,
-0.33150774240493774,
0.0802062600851059,
-0.4951230585575104,
-0.41290417313575745,
-0.2537294030189514,
-0.149430513381958,
0.5527222156524658,
0.2601366341114044,
0.3939584791660309,
0.6344567537307739,
0.39973852038383484,
0.24583540856838226,
-0.1855783760547638,
-0.12796230614185333,
-0.3063011169433594,
-0.2698478400707245,
-0.034310173243284225,
-0.20451056957244873,
-0.19508279860019684,
0.4992443919181824,
0.8802727460861206,
0.18851086497306824,
0.2793729603290558,
0.3367493152618408,
0.4462777078151703,
0.2941140830516815,
-1.1349347829818726,
0.5808547139167786,
-0.823911190032959,
-0.0036904390435665846,
0.14650297164916992,
-0.09002447873353958,
-0.28637638688087463,
-0.3810780644416809,
0.02175808697938919,
-0.22557763755321503,
0.6337534785270691,
0.17115992307662964,
0.8404954075813293,
0.5071265697479248,
-0.5473827719688416,
-0.32073602080345154,
-0.4355570077896118,
1.0622655153274536,
-0.3612379729747772,
0.14706775546073914,
0.24611079692840576,
0.35152292251586914,
-0.12277363985776901,
-0.2296804040670395,
-0.36397507786750793,
-0.367420494556427,
-0.1581782102584839,
-0.0425446555018425,
-0.23502029478549957,
-0.4226629137992859,
0.23574760556221008,
-0.007005201652646065,
-0.4415937662124634,
-0.08490016311407089,
-0.37856000661849976,
-0.6925247311592102,
0.7136262655258179,
0.1795133799314499,
-0.2881990671157837,
-0.2897009551525116,
-0.38840657472610474,
-0.016720468178391457,
-0.49207648634910583,
-0.030163990333676338,
0.7602125406265259,
0.8818360567092896,
-0.5451300144195557,
0.485770046710968,
-0.24430418014526367,
0.6421369314193726,
-0.2432178109884262,
-0.00825021043419838,
0.04850302264094353,
-0.2925911545753479,
0.2407156527042389,
0.36977526545524597,
0.6665791273117065,
0.25584524869918823,
0.17520207166671753,
-0.24102680385112762,
-0.10940063744783401,
-0.2200918048620224,
0.09795472770929337,
-0.6688201427459717,
-0.2651885449886322,
-0.020870758220553398,
-0.07540848851203918,
-0.5597558617591858,
0.4377392828464508,
-0.7403979897499084,
-0.45140501856803894,
-0.5262006521224976,
0.11831215769052505,
0.2122386246919632,
-0.24226024746894836,
-0.23898105323314667,
-0.360343873500824,
0.2820843756198883,
0.017795516178011894,
-0.6597176194190979,
0.19354265928268433,
0.9374444484710693,
0.8661132454872131,
0.11752720177173615,
0.014834947884082794,
-0.25547510385513306,
-0.011259419843554497,
-0.11991223692893982,
0.6569022536277771,
-0.9625169038772583,
-0.22119776904582977,
-0.07583921402692795,
0.1054830327630043,
0.25568389892578125,
-0.37279796600341797,
0.24323508143424988,
-0.4722764194011688,
0.36264240741729736,
-0.33733847737312317,
-0.5382748246192932,
-0.26712310314178467,
0.23064163327217102,
-0.7758088707923889,
0.789370596408844,
0.2323417365550995,
-0.7032566666603088,
0.5759660601615906,
-0.7493423819541931,
-0.16708336770534515,
-0.233184814453125,
0.018168741837143898,
-0.6697558164596558,
-0.29157647490501404,
0.23661598563194275,
0.6260893940925598,
-0.5861665606498718,
0.7604544162750244,
-0.359572172164917,
0.07299745827913284,
-0.0004253734659869224,
-0.7966063022613525,
0.9449014663696289,
0.15485291182994843,
-0.33131831884384155,
0.2615284025669098,
-0.7217410802841187,
-0.1787976324558258,
0.032065249979496,
-0.2532654106616974,
0.08013704419136047,
-0.12775377929210663,
0.4263158142566681,
0.03376154974102974,
0.5643319487571716,
-0.6361975073814392,
0.19937457144260406,
0.2776057720184326,
0.6759023070335388,
0.7689933776855469,
0.25055330991744995,
0.3553008735179901,
-0.28060030937194824,
0.5407274961471558,
-0.23112286627292633,
0.22287465631961823,
0.2327059507369995,
-0.4524189829826355,
-0.20534920692443848,
-0.3860222101211548,
0.5253419876098633,
0.6774038076400757,
-0.27279043197631836,
0.5699369311332703,
-0.14846715331077576,
-0.4852164685726166,
-0.23732130229473114,
-0.0195238646119833,
0.3178747296333313,
0.744815468788147,
0.2861204743385315,
0.04124551638960838,
-0.5552973747253418,
-0.5540623664855957,
-0.47603681683540344,
-0.12838239967823029,
-0.08515969663858414,
0.34093862771987915,
0.9245029091835022,
0.16754648089408875,
1.3445206880569458,
-0.6668792963027954,
-0.12845148146152496,
0.032347649335861206,
0.2797991633415222,
0.09753067791461945,
0.5856070518493652,
0.4278089702129364,
-1.1213531494140625,
-0.583073079586029,
-0.06731365621089935,
-0.47562482953071594,
0.0005611501401290298,
-0.13054896891117096,
0.03665478527545929,
-0.1081441268324852,
0.3729758858680725,
-0.1283143162727356,
0.4000304639339447,
0.07302597910165787,
-0.44199761748313904,
0.5804306864738464,
0.03114013932645321,
0.22034645080566406,
-0.8002585172653198,
0.2712079882621765,
0.4954407811164856,
-0.07678665220737457,
-0.6642413139343262,
-0.1916542798280716,
-0.03824802488088608,
-0.10033873468637466,
-0.6513303518295288,
0.9008259177207947,
-0.06786176562309265,
-0.028230758383870125,
-0.2879086136817932,
-0.5090745091438293,
0.1497018188238144,
0.22376908361911774,
0.11354201287031174,
0.6130301356315613,
0.3417527973651886,
-0.3628101646900177,
0.2507578432559967,
0.18061083555221558,
-0.18962125480175018,
0.3816928267478943,
-0.22055360674858093,
0.1823991984128952,
-0.22384041547775269,
0.1507369428873062,
-0.32541558146476746,
-0.32738664746284485,
0.47416022419929504,
-0.23703594505786896,
0.18496334552764893,
-0.5052247643470764,
-0.272787481546402,
-0.26532554626464844,
0.04205888882279396,
0.35070428252220154,
0.43233606219291687,
-0.2310674637556076,
0.39422574639320374,
0.5787374377250671,
0.12062525004148483,
-0.6030498743057251,
-0.4268746078014374,
0.13149818778038025,
-0.6697198152542114,
0.1705871969461441,
0.2801341712474823,
0.2350253313779831,
-0.15170973539352417,
0.08974701911211014,
-0.2177513986825943,
-0.36893895268440247,
0.38141632080078125,
0.3182506561279297,
0.14297442138195038,
0.14978927373886108,
-0.37405911087989807,
-0.3736031651496887,
-0.33731597661972046,
0.39959460496902466,
-0.34778058528900146,
0.3539566695690155,
-0.05713377520442009,
0.11747190356254578,
-0.5167975425720215,
0.297153502702713,
0.43256238102912903,
-0.23676970601081848,
0.7534590363502502,
0.5888872742652893,
-0.5452502369880676,
0.10333648324012756,
-0.33059754967689514,
-0.05365252494812012,
-0.3615170121192932,
0.06494104862213135,
-0.3762669861316681,
-0.7894026041030884,
0.3381265699863434,
-0.23137465119361877,
0.0849657952785492,
0.6709375977516174,
0.28513067960739136,
0.18375952541828156,
0.6495234966278076,
0.9483981728553772,
-0.7197189927101135,
0.4151337444782257,
-0.47182467579841614,
0.032858364284038544,
-0.7217859029769897,
-0.5426113605499268,
-0.8210866451263428,
0.21566002070903778,
-0.5641706585884094,
-0.40492501854896545,
0.19314171373844147,
0.04111368581652641,
-0.5444052815437317,
0.8078858852386475,
-0.7268543839454651,
0.5593809485435486,
0.5700751543045044,
0.04650794342160225,
-0.17574843764305115,
-0.044022832065820694,
0.3367984890937805,
0.08509659767150879,
-0.5091017484664917,
-0.60249263048172,
0.9957581758499146,
0.2620830237865448,
0.3823198974132538,
-0.15833386778831482,
0.6021146774291992,
0.8013794422149658,
0.28043901920318604,
-0.6231471300125122,
0.5020506381988525,
-0.00859970785677433,
-0.6376161575317383,
-0.34475070238113403,
-0.7999650835990906,
-0.9713560938835144,
-0.09460429102182388,
-0.3177647590637207,
-0.45775124430656433,
0.3106376826763153,
0.12245649844408035,
0.01578785851597786,
0.3784360885620117,
-0.05122574418783188,
0.8600595593452454,
-0.19507195055484772,
-0.15468458831310272,
-0.40775877237319946,
-0.45494991540908813,
-0.056676823645830154,
-0.26225903630256653,
0.33086201548576355,
-0.6322258114814758,
0.04588434100151062,
0.7121120691299438,
-0.31067997217178345,
0.9759673476219177,
-0.7136161923408508,
-0.05749727785587311,
0.4332287311553955,
-0.31009384989738464,
0.40201154351234436,
-0.4040639102458954,
-0.37266841530799866,
0.5741384625434875,
-0.004995675291866064,
-0.5723676681518555,
-0.1548214554786682,
0.38109081983566284,
-0.5667374730110168,
-0.2953384816646576,
-0.5591960549354553,
-0.6084577441215515,
0.029411504045128822,
0.15175263583660126,
-0.0076221805065870285,
0.4791125953197479,
-0.4163590967655182,
-0.03557345271110535,
0.2869051992893219,
-0.052625708281993866,
0.1996196061372757,
0.5152623653411865,
0.2354758381843567,
-0.49606022238731384,
1.266186237335205,
0.2723691463470459,
-0.07094403356313705,
0.5164223313331604,
0.4713713824748993,
-0.4235219955444336,
-0.45089200139045715,
0.19854792952537537,
-0.14195393025875092,
-0.5814881920814514,
-0.3185804486274719,
-0.22156482934951782,
-0.4393315017223358,
-0.7140973806381226,
-0.21609458327293396,
0.05911882594227791,
0.02996417135000229,
-0.4794349670410156,
0.07238715887069702,
0.5321318507194519,
0.6975820064544678,
-0.24242468178272247,
0.13136440515518188,
-0.3998359143733978,
0.29770025610923767,
-0.07482288032770157,
-0.013188493438065052,
-0.3476913571357727,
-0.279297798871994,
-0.15911553800106049,
0.13771232962608337,
-0.12182231992483139,
-0.5183088779449463,
0.7583996653556824,
0.33563297986984253,
0.5237516164779663,
0.37204432487487793,
0.3077220320701599,
0.6141804456710815,
-0.5170348882675171,
0.45564165711402893,
0.20670291781425476,
-0.9275774955749512,
0.6593490242958069,
-0.14113345742225647,
0.3021398186683655,
0.4902994930744171,
0.6140553951263428,
-0.14787161350250244,
-0.3468582332134247,
-0.5176156759262085,
-0.7246096730232239,
0.44965502619743347,
0.18080638349056244,
0.19187363982200623,
0.026017753407359123,
0.6292867660522461,
0.19535763561725616,
0.5194284319877625,
-0.24152055382728577,
0.17810502648353577,
-0.20187313854694366,
-0.10617713630199432,
-0.1970474123954773,
0.0891849622130394,
-0.21178005635738373,
-0.1623598337173462,
0.6681032776832581,
-0.42265722155570984,
-0.01025827694684267,
0.0217963345348835,
0.13508467376232147,
0.24463005363941193,
0.29654088616371155,
0.27494341135025024,
0.1951248049736023,
-0.324449360370636,
-0.19913935661315918,
0.021152138710021973,
-0.4856899082660675,
0.20799793303012848,
0.1492302417755127,
-0.4524623155593872,
-0.18199051916599274,
0.4164946973323822,
0.5414494276046753,
-0.03998149186372757,
-0.45951715111732483,
0.30233532190322876,
0.004460333846509457,
-0.4194144010543823,
-0.3618355393409729,
-0.03520388901233673,
-0.4452756941318512,
0.34446242451667786,
0.17636288702487946,
0.2850545644760132,
0.3246833086013794,
-0.5402765870094299,
0.3202609419822693,
0.6853428483009338,
-0.5947393178939819,
-0.022056547924876213,
0.9725528955459595,
0.14179494976997375,
-0.2391570657491684,
0.6376859545707703,
-0.04690367728471756,
-0.7027435898780823,
0.9226834774017334,
0.2881685197353363,
0.7936713099479675,
0.2919601798057556,
0.3770862817764282,
0.31735682487487793,
0.2311909943819046,
0.03820617496967316,
0.23612898588180542,
-0.43066534399986267,
-0.617262601852417,
-0.3086519241333008,
-0.5799183249473572,
-0.6224431395530701,
-0.18950344622135162,
-1.1208972930908203,
0.22773268818855286,
-0.5056602954864502,
-0.35472166538238525,
0.06615559011697769,
0.31530389189720154,
-0.9386374950408936,
-0.1066339835524559,
0.4533424377441406,
0.7086988091468811,
-1.1665968894958496,
0.7326755523681641,
0.1945381462574005,
-0.15115472674369812,
-0.5062270164489746,
0.04768917337059975,
0.36567941308021545,
-0.5898798108100891,
0.30330899357795715,
0.32371193170547485,
-0.010086899623274803,
-0.10783593356609344,
-0.7258032560348511,
-0.8211045861244202,
0.9597598910331726,
0.6830155849456787,
-0.6438506841659546,
0.08766958862543106,
0.47301945090293884,
0.050048135221004486,
-0.3585270941257477,
0.02086845599114895,
0.8372843265533447,
0.8143488168716431,
0.1069195494055748,
-0.7303693890571594,
0.20314724743366241,
0.05102778598666191,
-0.2492128610610962,
0.4306112229824066,
-0.8595696687698364,
0.5346953272819519,
-0.036286383867263794,
0.21392297744750977,
-0.22992770373821259,
0.6935060024261475,
0.11920152604579926,
0.5193738341331482,
0.5673927664756775,
0.37548571825027466,
0.9516531229019165,
-0.24206405878067017,
0.9076626300811768,
-0.5069900155067444,
0.5424760580062866,
0.8980219960212708,
-0.478996217250824,
0.8150994181632996,
0.22231172025203705,
-0.152108296751976,
0.4107426702976227,
0.6196298003196716,
-0.6830627918243408,
0.8394913077354431,
0.2897335886955261,
-0.29469725489616394,
-0.05511607602238655,
-0.42356401681900024,
0.09069565683603287,
0.3467099666595459,
0.2547379434108734,
0.08371644467115402,
-0.20236295461654663,
0.1738327145576477,
0.04352177307009697,
0.0006216553156264126,
-0.5331984758377075,
0.7765286564826965,
-0.06337863206863403,
-0.3904523551464081,
0.24047601222991943,
-0.14768005907535553,
0.52874356508255,
-0.28888750076293945,
-0.310181587934494,
0.2672377824783325,
-0.10012631863355637,
-0.28794392943382263,
-0.8716230988502502,
0.6442747116088867,
0.45043042302131653,
-0.2439868003129959,
-0.4594760835170746,
0.4534096121788025,
-0.33252909779548645,
-0.741690993309021,
0.0640779361128807,
-0.051267292350530624,
0.47511547803878784,
-0.3206949234008789,
-1.052724838256836,
-0.0706547424197197,
0.13287930190563202,
0.02865978330373764,
0.2984033524990082,
0.06526543945074081,
-0.2213471531867981,
0.4904414117336273,
0.5397175550460815,
-0.013616247102618217,
-0.08439623564481735,
-0.03181459382176399,
0.5867016911506653,
-0.7276090979576111,
-0.3180198669433594,
-0.5769072771072388,
0.3615938127040863,
-0.14035235345363617,
-0.2642501890659332,
0.6050941944122314,
0.8110378384590149,
0.7187846302986145,
0.24393057823181152,
0.9616588950157166,
-0.2599957585334778,
0.19756855070590973,
-0.519661545753479,
0.390041321516037,
-0.20350590348243713,
0.20880019664764404,
0.25698983669281006,
-1.0729840993881226,
-0.31256845593452454,
0.30095383524894714,
-0.6042113900184631,
-0.06297548115253448,
-0.001498631900176406,
0.7770123481750488,
0.20457971096038818,
-0.1850961148738861,
0.04460597410798073,
-0.051221657544374466,
0.3074500858783722,
0.14583224058151245,
0.46922361850738525,
-0.05077865347266197,
0.5918844938278198,
-0.5007252097129822,
0.09273624420166016,
-0.0540485717356205,
-0.9804383516311646,
-0.6989974975585938,
-0.4892040193080902,
-0.8003239631652832,
-0.3701210916042328,
0.09116838127374649,
0.7530785202980042,
0.8182256817817688,
-1.3194184303283691,
-0.10673727095127106,
-0.2795936167240143,
0.20940479636192322,
-0.15130658447742462,
-0.2957281768321991,
0.6038692593574524,
-0.09579203277826309,
-0.629595160484314,
0.39084452390670776,
0.08003538101911545,
-0.03632165119051933,
-0.6206154823303223,
-0.04169124737381935,
0.18216079473495483,
0.1090245321393013,
0.0909864604473114,
0.5558565855026245,
-0.6900994181632996,
-0.3990720510482788,
-0.6116476655006409,
0.18845221400260925,
0.03606022894382477,
0.7498999238014221,
-0.9435197710990906,
-0.057329654693603516,
0.2177634984254837,
0.45345795154571533,
0.3615249991416931,
-0.1310858577489853,
0.26840847730636597,
-0.8300859332084656,
0.06923586130142212,
0.4380737543106079,
0.2804734408855438,
0.3159849941730499,
-0.47813332080841064,
0.43118491768836975,
-0.10716092586517334,
-0.5172491073608398,
-0.814125120639801,
-0.13002155721187592,
-0.7861031889915466,
-0.37375906109809875,
0.8767334818840027,
-0.3227963447570801,
-0.40455347299575806,
-0.27838337421417236,
-0.043350521475076675,
0.18719589710235596,
-0.4978077709674835,
0.7488507628440857,
0.5072408318519592,
-0.01258319802582264,
-0.12545426189899445,
-0.581123411655426,
0.12192889302968979,
-0.0709565281867981,
-0.5740607380867004,
0.19032926857471466,
0.5046307444572449,
0.36758413910865784,
-0.05618147924542427,
0.07508537173271179,
0.06205886974930763,
-0.16697274148464203,
0.19672590494155884,
0.2369491457939148,
0.19903282821178436,
-0.6960412263870239,
-0.5011605024337769,
0.37269821763038635,
-0.3581993877887726,
-0.008868173696100712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02800v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02800v1
|
On Few-Shot Prompting for Controllable Question-Answer Generation in Narrative Comprehension
| 2024-04-03T15:17:21 | 2024-04-03T15:17:21 |
Bernardo Leite, Henrique Lopes Cardoso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Question Generation aims to automatically generate questions based on a given
input provided as context. A controllable question generation scheme focuses on
generating questions with specific attributes, allowing better control. In this
study, we propose a few-shot prompting strategy for controlling the generation
of question-answer pairs from children's narrative texts. We aim to control two
attributes: the question's explicitness and underlying narrative elements. With
empirical evaluation, we show the effectiveness of controlling the generation
process by employing few-shot prompting side by side with a reference model.
Our experiments highlight instances where the few-shot strategy surpasses the
reference model, particularly in scenarios such as semantic closeness
evaluation and the diversity and coherency of question-answer pairs. However,
these improvements are not always statistically significant. The code is
publicly available at github.com/bernardoleite/few-shot-prompting-qg-control.
|
[
-0.5290716290473938,
-0.9109157919883728,
0.5534243583679199,
0.028025636449456215,
-0.21590547263622284,
-0.22657127678394318,
0.1622042953968048,
-0.2934914827346802,
-0.24265089631080627,
0.4299488067626953,
-1.0645962953567505,
-0.11155708879232407,
-0.32556018233299255,
0.1806972175836563,
-0.21194708347320557,
1.0426605939865112,
-0.32727769017219543,
-0.3634643256664276,
-0.2711300551891327,
-0.12962163984775543,
-0.2863209843635559,
-0.05690861865878105,
-0.7425969243049622,
-0.40347200632095337,
0.9759417772293091,
0.6557360291481018,
0.6967968344688416,
0.5752432942390442,
0.4599992334842682,
0.12723411619663239,
0.00892165768891573,
0.2371608167886734,
-0.538486659526825,
0.4932171702384949,
-0.04356607794761658,
-0.5613826513290405,
-0.0014159104321151972,
-0.011618421413004398,
0.6856237649917603,
0.527169942855835,
0.11508988589048386,
0.2787695527076721,
0.24849307537078857,
0.42725932598114014,
-0.7542867660522461,
-0.2210090458393097,
-0.48593372106552124,
0.1362478882074356,
0.0003083433548454195,
-0.39706510305404663,
-0.37325146794319153,
-0.576790452003479,
0.01789109781384468,
-0.5214747190475464,
0.4214722514152527,
0.14791861176490784,
0.7274064421653748,
0.05642174556851387,
-0.37753984332084656,
-0.142990380525589,
-0.7017090916633606,
0.604992151260376,
-0.5338395237922668,
-0.30509278178215027,
0.795185923576355,
0.22258587181568146,
-0.12660697102546692,
-0.5693153142929077,
-0.6088879108428955,
-0.13505643606185913,
-0.3080694377422333,
0.43732261657714844,
-0.36701104044914246,
-0.0765891745686531,
0.5178623199462891,
-0.3112713396549225,
-0.9300760626792908,
-0.06265668570995331,
-0.36179864406585693,
0.012188074178993702,
0.5651973485946655,
0.48333895206451416,
0.15727481245994568,
-0.42108699679374695,
-0.4193386137485504,
-0.048643287271261215,
-0.9003044962882996,
0.45406121015548706,
0.4911538064479828,
0.1972452998161316,
-0.13284152746200562,
0.7588172554969788,
-0.36106687784194946,
0.6137605905532837,
0.5938258767127991,
-0.14496426284313202,
-0.4005817770957947,
-0.7377899885177612,
0.11667080223560333,
0.0013218008680269122,
0.668091356754303,
0.5651879906654358,
0.2672269940376282,
0.19367240369319916,
-0.04116304591298103,
-0.11610329896211624,
0.08523198962211609,
-0.7736314535140991,
-0.02209589071571827,
0.30749770998954773,
-0.2861199676990509,
-0.4528772234916687,
-0.09317153692245483,
-0.6294291615486145,
-0.19478364288806915,
0.11440429091453552,
0.4434179663658142,
-0.5183298587799072,
0.17673268914222717,
-0.39935302734375,
-0.47641855478286743,
0.544425904750824,
0.115698903799057,
-1.0431392192840576,
0.08112242817878723,
0.3246093988418579,
0.48171761631965637,
-0.29748934507369995,
-0.3305605947971344,
-0.6310998797416687,
0.5979181528091431,
-0.38048380613327026,
0.9092399477958679,
-0.5186020731925964,
-0.549801230430603,
0.1488894522190094,
-0.3154275715351105,
-0.030178867280483246,
-0.4841037690639496,
0.023525651544332504,
-0.6523585319519043,
0.4759880006313324,
-0.29104578495025635,
-0.5409082174301147,
0.16304518282413483,
0.38257986307144165,
-0.35392630100250244,
0.852077066898346,
0.034843482077121735,
-0.7721306681632996,
0.4817381501197815,
-0.1173018366098404,
-0.22366712987422943,
0.1355879008769989,
-0.21510076522827148,
-0.3591773509979248,
-0.11526136845350266,
0.40378233790397644,
0.16009238362312317,
-0.09437254071235657,
0.16292059421539307,
0.04966757819056511,
-0.18732231855392456,
0.20139393210411072,
-0.505596935749054,
0.6287667155265808,
0.042137134820222855,
-0.1423986703157425,
-0.10256507992744446,
-0.5246651768684387,
0.434777170419693,
0.19720205664634705,
-0.033554233610630035,
-0.16195468604564667,
-0.3524017035961151,
-0.4041541814804077,
-0.020204586908221245,
-0.023927003145217896,
-0.18909867107868195,
0.31551146507263184,
-0.20764368772506714,
-0.10986854881048203,
0.18195581436157227,
0.715144693851471,
0.7026490569114685,
-0.9668397307395935,
1.150947093963623,
-0.05448116362094879,
0.1399502158164978,
-0.6346042156219482,
-0.5446289777755737,
-0.47165966033935547,
0.11167614907026291,
-0.0045875669457018375,
0.5307557582855225,
-1.1872689723968506,
0.028343111276626587,
0.4265328347682953,
-0.3546704053878784,
-0.3176738917827606,
0.32330766320228577,
0.6576279401779175,
0.7313410639762878,
0.25971266627311707,
0.06698718667030334,
-0.23430266976356506,
-0.6063472032546997,
-0.13050338625907898,
-0.5491630434989929,
-0.21134306490421295,
0.4400557279586792,
0.5073778033256531,
0.4620709717273712,
1.2987992763519287,
-0.6822418570518494,
0.15046405792236328,
-0.48748779296875,
0.5365590453147888,
-0.11815297603607178,
0.7316226363182068,
0.6433380842208862,
-0.7060596346855164,
-0.4475246071815491,
-0.47017034888267517,
-0.6468087434768677,
-0.4631950557231903,
-0.3534676432609558,
-0.2577808201313019,
-0.1352773904800415,
0.4256726801395416,
-0.7177077531814575,
0.3944060206413269,
0.40551266074180603,
-0.2306268811225891,
0.6910861730575562,
0.03835039958357811,
0.17225173115730286,
-0.8856762647628784,
0.09914164990186691,
-0.18682365119457245,
-0.2313188761472702,
-0.6021369099617004,
0.4128319025039673,
0.058730173856019974,
-0.0014515281654894352,
-0.874872088432312,
0.5503071546554565,
-0.08072566241025925,
0.4190715253353119,
-0.2735348045825958,
0.27993884682655334,
0.3694859445095062,
0.40018323063850403,
-0.039284393191337585,
0.6578859686851501,
0.24631968140602112,
-0.7314411997795105,
0.5276303291320801,
0.29600808024406433,
0.13588997721672058,
0.8775603175163269,
-0.8123177886009216,
0.4841836392879486,
-0.35652244091033936,
0.3447708487510681,
-1.0500568151474,
-0.3343125581741333,
0.3814815580844879,
-0.5745227336883545,
0.3011156916618347,
-0.14947347342967987,
-0.33637717366218567,
-0.40631741285324097,
-0.524023711681366,
0.3902451694011688,
0.5132014155387878,
-0.39659950137138367,
0.13505898416042328,
-0.3850586712360382,
-0.5467432737350464,
-0.16494281589984894,
-0.7827152013778687,
-0.3413998782634735,
-0.2891157865524292,
-0.5688660144805908,
0.2280517965555191,
-0.45354586839675903,
-0.25658175349235535,
0.16126775741577148,
-0.011855165474116802,
-0.26864108443260193,
-0.32794415950775146,
-0.030928412452340126,
0.21213515102863312,
-0.4375850260257721,
0.3115007281303406,
0.698765218257904,
-0.32097160816192627,
-0.202521413564682,
-0.09607681632041931,
0.26832377910614014,
0.4216153621673584,
-0.22843006253242493,
-0.41007736325263977,
0.7050570845603943,
-0.052351534366607666,
-0.1282566785812378,
0.514497697353363,
0.295762836933136,
-0.08052689582109451,
-0.36936911940574646,
-0.30584508180618286,
-0.617142379283905,
-0.45224255323410034,
-0.1883164346218109,
-0.3333013355731964,
-0.8620047569274902,
0.47504016757011414,
0.12840010225772858,
-0.041760314255952835,
0.2667495310306549,
0.5578712821006775,
-0.533682107925415,
1.1195467710494995,
0.4201943576335907,
0.19505368173122406,
0.2681082785129547,
-0.21788924932479858,
-0.3741377890110016,
-0.43466004729270935,
-0.08415699750185013,
-0.6388458609580994,
-0.4244726896286011,
-0.3739272356033325,
-0.12689295411109924,
0.34874826669692993,
0.3447172939777374,
-0.17507308721542358,
0.2693732678890228,
-0.22818873822689056,
0.8526694178581238,
0.7726834416389465,
0.03897763416171074,
0.5849613547325134,
-0.3864980638027191,
-0.26328790187835693,
-0.006736723706126213,
-1.109413981437683,
-0.6375513076782227,
0.822726845741272,
0.017162056639790535,
0.9062687158584595,
-0.07747241109609604,
1.1093946695327759,
-0.13101355731487274,
-0.09985890984535217,
-0.6319952011108398,
0.3985893726348877,
0.3554336130619049,
-0.9716198444366455,
-0.5190708041191101,
-0.1874668002128601,
-1.1115829944610596,
0.19327963888645172,
-0.3001515567302704,
-0.6952582001686096,
0.24418778717517853,
0.37567955255508423,
-1.0483886003494263,
-0.13762347400188446,
-0.7537930011749268,
0.5315971374511719,
0.01544673927128315,
-0.7712241411209106,
0.2044639140367508,
-0.7810665369033813,
0.3974946439266205,
-0.02235729619860649,
-0.5162805914878845,
0.21433454751968384,
-0.028945239260792732,
0.628923237323761,
-0.340549111366272,
0.8680800199508667,
-0.03853626176714897,
0.12399984151124954,
0.9997509717941284,
0.3452852666378021,
0.6478387117385864,
0.14924703538417816,
0.15238626301288605,
-0.5982557535171509,
0.23041100800037384,
-0.601245641708374,
-0.6791814565658569,
0.6145814657211304,
-0.29179608821868896,
-0.8050532341003418,
-0.2090442031621933,
-0.6982729434967041,
-0.2827126383781433,
0.23941916227340698,
0.6965617537498474,
0.2145780771970749,
-0.08155450969934464,
0.10614431649446487,
0.5975936055183411,
-0.2385140359401703,
0.7443383932113647,
0.40537935495376587,
-0.2744144797325134,
-0.058094024658203125,
0.27649202942848206,
0.17964433133602142,
0.704949140548706,
0.032989099621772766,
0.4917297065258026,
-0.16089768707752228,
-0.36229586601257324,
-0.5740056037902832,
0.1369142085313797,
-0.41232600808143616,
-0.3894812762737274,
-0.2188229262828827,
-0.10870267450809479,
-0.3143441379070282,
-0.39135080575942993,
0.15301111340522766,
-0.3732864260673523,
-0.2909557521343231,
-0.37691473960876465,
0.3822346329689026,
0.6569967269897461,
0.21944573521614075,
0.6963988542556763,
-0.8385937809944153,
0.6975750923156738,
0.8313438296318054,
0.003922692500054836,
-0.18267972767353058,
-0.4107222557067871,
0.17586547136306763,
-0.10546458512544632,
-0.6460433006286621,
-1.1016136407852173,
0.17693862318992615,
-0.04416811838746071,
0.28507500886917114,
0.5346970558166504,
0.3188076913356781,
0.5828136205673218,
-0.5141595005989075,
0.9754108190536499,
0.18402308225631714,
-0.5560429096221924,
0.8970760703086853,
-0.5247476100921631,
0.9480035305023193,
0.6721513867378235,
0.34350353479385376,
-0.2616693675518036,
-0.8383238315582275,
-0.8028746247291565,
-0.2922896146774292,
0.9598394632339478,
0.46845290064811707,
0.5555049777030945,
0.15001367032527924,
0.31210553646087646,
0.2541435956954956,
0.1556769758462906,
-0.45449891686439514,
-0.26241666078567505,
-0.014355245977640152,
-0.07842468470335007,
0.3507998287677765,
-0.25350895524024963,
-0.39630892872810364,
-0.011193598620593548,
0.298230916261673,
-0.2691503167152405,
-0.10567639023065567,
0.30407971143722534,
0.11823228746652603,
-0.7262950539588928,
0.26055335998535156,
0.4871015250682831,
0.5295157432556152,
0.004808331839740276,
0.24200987815856934,
0.15030810236930847,
-0.2970508337020874,
0.19027529656887054,
-0.015972914174199104,
-0.9944944977760315,
-0.1867133229970932,
0.5824909210205078,
0.6683301329612732,
-0.16499920189380646,
-0.2553739845752716,
0.39936280250549316,
0.16717438399791718,
-0.47602251172065735,
0.14385980367660522,
0.3212314546108246,
0.03343314677476883,
0.6183434724807739,
0.4450399577617645,
-0.35413047671318054,
-0.22208920121192932,
-0.3952423334121704,
0.17972321808338165,
0.23587502539157867,
-0.12989060580730438,
-0.1372021585702896,
0.6513003706932068,
0.024202704429626465,
-0.17327781021595,
0.3640039265155792,
-0.36960139870643616,
-0.2194051295518875,
0.77704256772995,
0.9641948938369751,
0.7146173715591431,
-0.14908695220947266,
0.6288723349571228,
0.5658915638923645,
0.44701287150382996,
0.23998074233531952,
0.3699163496494293,
-0.19199752807617188,
-0.8510481119155884,
-0.14312729239463806,
0.015051404945552349,
-0.648070216178894,
0.09848941117525101,
-0.5584357380867004,
0.13985216617584229,
-0.5658663511276245,
-0.17811822891235352,
-0.16168177127838135,
-0.14774835109710693,
-0.4707951545715332,
0.18425235152244568,
0.1821814626455307,
0.5066781640052795,
-0.8294907212257385,
0.6788734197616577,
0.27253487706184387,
-0.857717752456665,
-0.9628362655639648,
0.2841331362724304,
0.014033808372914791,
-0.5142812132835388,
0.4815587103366852,
-0.2056090086698532,
-0.21750283241271973,
0.22586432099342346,
-1.0780079364776611,
-0.5069648623466492,
1.206616759300232,
0.13898977637290955,
-0.44955140352249146,
-0.15382058918476105,
0.01835285872220993,
0.5276225805282593,
-0.17996670305728912,
0.09858803451061249,
0.6355752348899841,
0.6396481394767761,
0.5139839053153992,
-0.5728567838668823,
-0.13029934465885162,
0.049096912145614624,
-0.03414783626794815,
-0.025008859112858772,
-0.49495577812194824,
0.3344975411891937,
-0.5435521006584167,
-0.15289276838302612,
0.24540378153324127,
0.7707173824310303,
0.6614751219749451,
0.8355500102043152,
0.2692355811595917,
0.10638372600078583,
0.6124825477600098,
0.0815521776676178,
1.2704157829284668,
-0.1096554845571518,
0.08562436699867249,
1.2544420957565308,
-0.16883732378482819,
0.7041282653808594,
0.875097930431366,
-0.12305187433958054,
0.18019117414951324,
0.3060607314109802,
0.14864450693130493,
0.5077664852142334,
-0.05641217529773712,
-0.37000560760498047,
-0.1031922847032547,
-0.3535829782485962,
-0.11748095601797104,
0.3395587205886841,
-0.0914224311709404,
-0.31376299262046814,
-0.23269689083099365,
0.009252865798771381,
0.17494453489780426,
0.22532935440540314,
-0.2209988236427307,
0.936954140663147,
0.16212312877178192,
-0.9849901795387268,
0.5156274437904358,
-0.34123262763023376,
0.345865398645401,
-0.9700360894203186,
-0.042670201510190964,
-0.5352823138237,
-0.4701290428638458,
-0.12398067861795425,
-0.75774747133255,
0.08000459522008896,
0.37804192304611206,
-0.24628318846225739,
-0.2864704132080078,
0.7598930597305298,
-0.8384140729904175,
-0.3734705448150635,
-0.305023729801178,
0.7876505255699158,
-0.16181257367134094,
0.2561857998371124,
-0.5379401445388794,
-0.4753953516483307,
-0.19021683931350708,
-0.4352199137210846,
0.11923251301050186,
0.3440133333206177,
-0.26752397418022156,
0.3820651173591614,
0.45678773522377014,
0.06239768862724304,
0.31270650029182434,
0.057812247425317764,
0.6449146270751953,
-0.5215758681297302,
-0.43602466583251953,
-0.6848094463348389,
0.5126389861106873,
0.22558778524398804,
-0.5008664131164551,
0.7351424694061279,
0.23852936923503876,
0.6560806035995483,
-0.07787617295980453,
0.6599005460739136,
-0.012491392903029919,
0.3789633512496948,
-0.6280027031898499,
0.6301450133323669,
-0.2811456620693207,
-0.15169858932495117,
-0.3904866576194763,
-0.8255723714828491,
-0.4747711718082428,
0.3021414279937744,
-0.19921422004699707,
0.07458610087633133,
1.0960520505905151,
1.0534976720809937,
0.24206633865833282,
-0.07626122236251831,
0.36340466141700745,
-0.20099127292633057,
0.10569410771131516,
0.6264182329177856,
1.08735990524292,
-0.10452104359865189,
0.6359527111053467,
-0.37948986887931824,
-0.0792691633105278,
0.07466492056846619,
-0.9391990900039673,
-0.7429843544960022,
-0.2243732511997223,
-0.316375195980072,
-0.3002852499485016,
0.06358785182237625,
0.7691025733947754,
0.4314221441745758,
-0.7839476466178894,
0.023364821448922157,
-0.16933870315551758,
0.24252566695213318,
-0.1737079918384552,
-0.15724529325962067,
0.33995598554611206,
-0.3413256108760834,
-0.8495056629180908,
0.29755842685699463,
0.0985565185546875,
0.36397480964660645,
-0.2091130018234253,
-0.1120891347527504,
-0.12030202150344849,
0.2677057981491089,
0.3408278524875641,
0.3715370297431946,
-0.4611106812953949,
-0.2766845226287842,
0.11362188309431076,
-0.3484407365322113,
-0.10157980769872665,
1.009390950202942,
-0.8369540572166443,
0.6031690239906311,
0.8618406057357788,
0.32969725131988525,
0.6566377282142639,
0.45110204815864563,
0.508245587348938,
-1.1305122375488281,
0.13965849578380585,
0.5199423432350159,
-0.14041151106357574,
0.040114112198352814,
-0.2163364291191101,
0.1714630126953125,
0.13815826177597046,
-0.33715546131134033,
-0.30028387904167175,
0.32780513167381287,
-0.8276345133781433,
-0.11925757676362991,
1.3168007135391235,
-0.10377095639705658,
-0.10269132256507874,
0.06920639425516129,
-0.7074035406112671,
0.27090492844581604,
-0.4548337459564209,
0.3853883147239685,
0.7740746736526489,
-0.39460289478302,
-0.5598462224006653,
-0.30654847621917725,
0.4059019088745117,
0.5627918243408203,
-0.7908039689064026,
-0.16189084947109222,
0.6133313775062561,
-0.17066079378128052,
-0.10395651310682297,
0.6349273324012756,
0.008562248200178146,
0.5170320868492126,
0.1657649278640747,
-0.2517082393169403,
-0.12171725928783417,
-0.3595035672187805,
-0.5267006158828735,
0.3977431058883667,
0.09567819535732269,
-0.11355345696210861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02772v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02772v2
|
FPT: Feature Prompt Tuning for Few-shot Readability Assessment
| 2024-04-03T14:39:47 | 2024-04-10T04:25:09 |
Ziyang Wang, Sanwoo Lee, Hsiu-Yuan Huang, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompt-based methods have achieved promising results in most few-shot text
classification tasks. However, for readability assessment tasks, traditional
prompt methods lackcrucial linguistic knowledge, which has already been proven
to be essential. Moreover, previous studies on utilizing linguistic features
have shown non-robust performance in few-shot settings and may even impair
model performance.To address these issues, we propose a novel prompt-based
tuning framework that incorporates rich linguistic knowledge, called Feature
Prompt Tuning (FPT). Specifically, we extract linguistic features from the text
and embed them into trainable soft prompts. Further, we devise a new loss
function to calibrate the similarity ranking order between categories.
Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed method FTP not only exhibits
a significant performance improvement over the prior best prompt-based tuning
approaches, but also surpasses the previous leading methods that incorporate
linguistic features. Also, our proposed model significantly outperforms the
large language model gpt-3.5-turbo-16k in most cases. Our proposed method
establishes a new architecture for prompt tuning that sheds light on how
linguistic features can be easily adapted to linguistic-related tasks.
|
[
-0.5032946467399597,
-0.5889102220535278,
0.505278468132019,
0.12433993816375732,
-0.46633365750312805,
-0.027463702484965324,
-0.443043977022171,
-0.3505984842777252,
-0.06937280297279358,
0.24046829342842102,
-0.9041809439659119,
-0.41910862922668457,
-0.41700130701065063,
0.5635858178138733,
0.10685082525014877,
0.9565697908401489,
0.24358302354812622,
-0.1658591628074646,
0.12394588440656662,
-0.3094409704208374,
-0.8037670850753784,
-0.10696926712989807,
-0.5787563920021057,
-0.145567387342453,
0.7745106220245361,
0.632006049156189,
0.7515411376953125,
0.7059048414230347,
0.44395679235458374,
0.2646375596523285,
-0.4139425456523895,
0.22828766703605652,
-0.3170417547225952,
0.014426521956920624,
-0.21629266440868378,
-0.49085795879364014,
-0.2306726723909378,
0.009238661266863346,
0.6775513887405396,
0.485608845949173,
0.24352100491523743,
0.004187659826129675,
0.47638362646102905,
0.44484108686447144,
-0.5095614194869995,
0.2908574938774109,
-0.6342061161994934,
0.031124714761972427,
-0.3473372161388397,
-0.5427177548408508,
-0.5149224996566772,
-0.3296606242656708,
0.16058720648288727,
-0.6655281186103821,
0.6599711179733276,
0.3631308078765869,
0.7211022973060608,
0.43212056159973145,
-0.08069226145744324,
0.030004233121871948,
-0.19046667218208313,
0.6245628595352173,
-0.6791502237319946,
0.377519428730011,
0.5030268430709839,
0.282397598028183,
-0.08055853843688965,
-0.17774929106235504,
-0.6563013195991516,
-0.261883407831192,
-0.15316514670848846,
-0.1717529296875,
-0.04997601732611656,
0.11814256012439728,
0.45715847611427307,
0.15403211116790771,
-0.7869195938110352,
0.44885700941085815,
0.29386651515960693,
-0.42069217562675476,
0.3313005268573761,
0.26484331488609314,
0.266508013010025,
-0.33869194984436035,
-0.20327991247177124,
-0.17008458077907562,
-0.5469505786895752,
0.2741658091545105,
0.30081355571746826,
1.0514379739761353,
-0.15894684195518494,
0.44520366191864014,
-0.40659570693969727,
0.7353410720825195,
0.008805625140666962,
-0.20562893152236938,
0.1995985060930252,
-0.38119906187057495,
-0.0757296085357666,
0.15141615271568298,
0.6068693399429321,
0.4255523681640625,
0.23097088932991028,
0.113495834171772,
-0.18073789775371552,
-0.29262205958366394,
-0.013622443191707134,
-0.8210839033126831,
-0.15029992163181305,
-0.09165026247501373,
-0.5011021494865417,
-0.3730677366256714,
-0.0997997596859932,
-0.8496664762496948,
-0.7723492980003357,
-0.10165376216173172,
0.4453922510147095,
-0.7375709414482117,
-0.1542433202266693,
-0.10775996744632721,
-0.1192174032330513,
0.3442329168319702,
0.47263097763061523,
-1.3961535692214966,
-0.10774047672748566,
0.9870014190673828,
1.0974830389022827,
-0.10891149938106537,
-0.4472346901893616,
-0.8836875557899475,
-0.46851277351379395,
-0.12966708838939667,
1.1091392040252686,
-0.6155593395233154,
-0.2783856689929962,
0.0506327785551548,
0.05958298593759537,
-0.15968337655067444,
-0.25610923767089844,
0.5481167435646057,
-0.20201584696769714,
0.13580483198165894,
-0.31103307008743286,
-0.41731858253479004,
-0.10510324686765671,
0.33920109272003174,
-0.5704547166824341,
0.9503729343414307,
0.19572068750858307,
-0.8182463645935059,
0.8342067003250122,
-0.425013929605484,
-0.33349037170410156,
0.3905929923057556,
0.07648163288831711,
-0.34702205657958984,
0.27830079197883606,
0.31610769033432007,
0.48201364278793335,
-0.16139784455299377,
-0.19282259047031403,
-0.388477623462677,
-0.6702240109443665,
0.1998460590839386,
-0.5293864011764526,
0.45312923192977905,
0.13007859885692596,
-0.17606452107429504,
0.19478218257427216,
-0.7689368724822998,
0.2120865136384964,
-0.1628493219614029,
-0.19162224233150482,
-0.33963868021965027,
-0.11479277908802032,
0.21012252569198608,
-0.09441739320755005,
0.021657848730683327,
-0.40189123153686523,
0.36479419469833374,
-0.8740792274475098,
0.22869089245796204,
0.6051349639892578,
-0.08841739594936371,
0.5143990516662598,
-0.43417486548423767,
0.7413690686225891,
-0.08724040538072586,
0.04285218194127083,
-0.5909038782119751,
-0.7013946771621704,
-0.451043963432312,
-0.36385127902030945,
0.43547558784484863,
0.8764779567718506,
-0.8987112641334534,
0.6056903004646301,
-0.06043190881609917,
-0.5191401243209839,
-0.46228569746017456,
0.17862538993358612,
0.4257720112800598,
0.721798837184906,
0.31078192591667175,
-0.1355806589126587,
0.06677898019552231,
-0.5652304887771606,
-0.6041358113288879,
-0.3234061598777771,
-0.15943849086761475,
0.26071083545684814,
0.10256356745958328,
0.19790183007717133,
0.8497251272201538,
-0.617179274559021,
-0.42883822321891785,
-0.5007928609848022,
0.2397671639919281,
0.5540638566017151,
0.37637758255004883,
0.5855218172073364,
-0.3775322735309601,
-0.291658490896225,
0.025149524211883545,
-0.2517954111099243,
-0.3464520573616028,
-0.13780854642391205,
0.1327693611383438,
0.23912015557289124,
0.09405224025249481,
-0.3955914080142975,
0.23109005391597748,
0.039239879697561264,
-0.695318341255188,
0.40571093559265137,
-0.13454069197177887,
0.48056384921073914,
-0.6410046815872192,
0.0029771546833217144,
0.16509944200515747,
-0.2737724781036377,
-0.304424911737442,
-0.05471508204936981,
0.18437454104423523,
-0.2019670158624649,
-0.6036061644554138,
0.8511442542076111,
-0.06727712601423264,
0.24702583253383636,
-0.4326252043247223,
0.006760355085134506,
0.08331490308046341,
0.380310982465744,
0.026982855051755905,
0.818622350692749,
0.4948584735393524,
-0.5642532706260681,
0.04820410907268524,
0.5096039175987244,
-0.36602234840393066,
0.8733036518096924,
-0.3992619216442108,
0.031594935804605484,
-0.13593463599681854,
-0.16372251510620117,
-1.1136384010314941,
-0.09780395776033401,
0.23617112636566162,
-0.5139994025230408,
0.5397027730941772,
-0.385283887386322,
-0.6360254287719727,
-0.0347321555018425,
-0.4480309784412384,
0.23192636668682098,
0.4060283303260803,
-0.4491763114929199,
0.26988089084625244,
-0.23322610557079315,
-0.5327653884887695,
-0.3777596652507782,
-0.5032066106796265,
-0.1589183509349823,
-0.2963402569293976,
-0.5921778082847595,
0.17608045041561127,
-0.08092322945594788,
0.32528963685035706,
-0.4717226028442383,
-0.1176796704530716,
-0.1028749942779541,
0.3402445912361145,
0.028472047299146652,
0.1159159317612648,
-0.4890468418598175,
0.3503458499908447,
0.20321141183376312,
-0.4817870259284973,
-0.43061336874961853,
-0.09596807509660721,
0.41033732891082764,
-0.11254466325044632,
0.09014219045639038,
-0.5887199640274048,
0.27458712458610535,
0.11025252193212509,
-0.24579507112503052,
0.5020068883895874,
0.8126004338264465,
-0.11245870590209961,
-0.46817314624786377,
-0.2734632194042206,
-0.3484362065792084,
-0.5400823354721069,
0.26754051446914673,
-0.523969829082489,
-1.152052402496338,
0.43193182349205017,
-0.13098114728927612,
0.05202600732445717,
0.48120981454849243,
0.43384599685668945,
-0.2644190490245819,
0.9184848070144653,
1.027266025543213,
0.12055326998233795,
0.841385543346405,
0.15521317720413208,
-0.06668860465288162,
-0.34214404225349426,
-0.11896692216396332,
-1.0473860502243042,
-0.48343703150749207,
-0.6665951013565063,
-0.1565699577331543,
0.30563822388648987,
0.17369383573532104,
-0.22989434003829956,
0.2808035910129547,
-0.5350959300994873,
0.720252275466919,
0.5425372123718262,
0.26476800441741943,
0.34408703446388245,
-0.08694624155759811,
-0.34176772832870483,
-0.4563840925693512,
-0.7658852934837341,
-0.4565134346485138,
0.5870866179466248,
0.2797032594680786,
0.6441797614097595,
-0.047369904816150665,
0.5865017175674438,
0.2609245479106903,
-0.09687130898237228,
-1.0804849863052368,
0.4625798761844635,
-0.3788313567638397,
-0.13815385103225708,
-0.3793916702270508,
-0.4126485288143158,
-0.7834940552711487,
-0.0006121181068010628,
-0.42984044551849365,
-0.6276623010635376,
0.17891550064086914,
0.4397493004798889,
-0.665764331817627,
-0.02452828362584114,
-0.8160144090652466,
1.0677043199539185,
-0.0997333750128746,
-0.19401663541793823,
0.1264805942773819,
-0.6584495902061462,
0.062479570508003235,
-0.030961008742451668,
-0.1505691260099411,
-0.3687027394771576,
-0.31657224893569946,
0.5866363644599915,
-0.45618847012519836,
0.8342540264129639,
-0.3412317931652069,
0.028384698554873466,
-0.08834078162908554,
0.11002708226442337,
0.3166147768497467,
0.2520672678947449,
-0.22521241009235382,
0.09101337939500809,
0.18010979890823364,
-0.3164183795452118,
-0.792252242565155,
0.6161995530128479,
-0.5081803202629089,
-0.23349079489707947,
-0.4970235526561737,
-0.20488707721233368,
-0.4503070116043091,
0.4810974895954132,
0.5263968110084534,
0.5991912484169006,
-0.12378416955471039,
-0.11406300961971283,
0.7617247700691223,
-0.38507989048957825,
0.7120227217674255,
0.5942857265472412,
0.08648466318845749,
-0.4110659956932068,
0.8960323929786682,
-0.08921944350004196,
-0.1503957062959671,
0.6376070380210876,
0.5449686050415039,
-0.5171967148780823,
-0.6560994386672974,
-0.6404713988304138,
0.11973309516906738,
-0.5102705955505371,
-0.5268040895462036,
-0.34663665294647217,
0.12740348279476166,
-0.25638347864151,
-0.20823507010936737,
-0.09256286919116974,
-0.4731338322162628,
-0.6678816676139832,
0.1273433268070221,
0.8191579580307007,
0.32845067977905273,
0.2780156433582306,
0.7196938395500183,
-0.9791538715362549,
0.3691377341747284,
0.056703437119722366,
0.8431932330131531,
-0.33294498920440674,
-0.8087816834449768,
-0.11824063211679459,
-0.4129549562931061,
-0.2761314809322357,
-0.8122931718826294,
0.23638619482517242,
0.6115025281906128,
0.4202553927898407,
0.2932928204536438,
0.2201252430677414,
0.4375346601009369,
-0.6662083268165588,
0.8387908935546875,
-0.006557608023285866,
-0.9663705229759216,
0.9074279069900513,
-0.39101719856262207,
0.7270064949989319,
1.1487756967544556,
0.17553970217704773,
-0.39065277576446533,
-0.22419996559619904,
-0.319998174905777,
-0.5343198776245117,
0.9181140661239624,
-0.09444986283779144,
0.1703232377767563,
-0.019608497619628906,
0.36357155442237854,
0.3766825199127197,
0.1509237140417099,
-0.2074974775314331,
-0.0527997650206089,
-0.34863078594207764,
-0.4504144489765167,
-0.2830478549003601,
-0.18758001923561096,
0.3769814074039459,
-0.16176465153694153,
0.396931529045105,
-0.6432361602783203,
0.13087166845798492,
0.05402810499072075,
-0.1274120956659317,
-0.06621742248535156,
0.5748720169067383,
0.6648748517036438,
0.3498651385307312,
-0.13914188742637634,
-0.06359589099884033,
0.08782204985618591,
-0.5708152055740356,
0.20809155702590942,
0.32829147577285767,
-0.40756651759147644,
-0.027837486937642097,
0.5074041485786438,
0.978943943977356,
0.4216778576374054,
-0.5275412797927856,
0.6530560851097107,
-0.14060339331626892,
0.0070491149090230465,
0.3906933665275574,
0.4225482642650604,
-0.5283294320106506,
0.33448177576065063,
0.24522259831428528,
0.30607733130455017,
0.15886439383029938,
-0.25505441427230835,
0.3533916771411896,
0.25934717059135437,
-0.5317845940589905,
-0.22224552929401398,
0.5269736051559448,
0.4076872169971466,
-0.36657193303108215,
0.6417728662490845,
-0.29077771306037903,
-0.39790040254592896,
0.4069320559501648,
0.292183518409729,
1.1333893537521362,
-0.11776100844144821,
0.3997773230075836,
0.3466709554195404,
0.48601916432380676,
-0.10423026978969574,
0.6082884669303894,
-0.21282987296581268,
-0.5642131567001343,
-0.4410751163959503,
-0.8246522545814514,
-0.4723266065120697,
-0.17570628225803375,
-0.3371764123439789,
0.634036660194397,
-0.6232994198799133,
-0.10408284515142441,
0.0421978160738945,
0.2716664969921112,
-0.8162665367126465,
0.10686010867357254,
0.022329533472657204,
1.091525912284851,
-0.9586662650108337,
0.5970029234886169,
0.6120342016220093,
-0.31189578771591187,
-0.7754964232444763,
0.10075327754020691,
0.23316717147827148,
-0.6440789699554443,
0.1009509339928627,
0.5483026504516602,
0.14240895211696625,
0.2708755135536194,
-0.32773491740226746,
-0.4360892176628113,
0.8696210384368896,
0.5150387287139893,
-0.698590874671936,
0.13161569833755493,
0.0517473928630352,
0.5206395387649536,
-0.15803633630275726,
0.5106823444366455,
0.6205177307128906,
0.5477350354194641,
0.12478241324424744,
-1.1546720266342163,
0.11998265236616135,
-0.14515601098537445,
-0.031320538371801376,
0.27000749111175537,
-0.6323650479316711,
0.24863791465759277,
-0.27929115295410156,
-0.11942820996046066,
0.23895421624183655,
0.6844362020492554,
0.2662191092967987,
0.5565776824951172,
0.6121657490730286,
0.23930880427360535,
0.8314668536186218,
-0.24287627637386322,
0.9285832643508911,
0.04926951602101326,
0.3533434569835663,
0.9310558438301086,
-0.1877916306257248,
0.9052830338478088,
0.20135261118412018,
-0.1138947531580925,
0.11670445650815964,
0.7861652374267578,
-0.138595312833786,
0.6804678440093994,
0.038414303213357925,
-0.09594501554965973,
-0.3423699140548706,
-0.19761215150356293,
-0.23568712174892426,
0.626304566860199,
0.060940932482481,
-0.31115734577178955,
-0.2931634187698364,
0.26062673330307007,
-0.19483539462089539,
0.10133389383554459,
-0.44926249980926514,
0.9400213956832886,
0.032743584364652634,
-0.5350190997123718,
0.6633349657058716,
-0.03593602403998375,
0.977399468421936,
-0.6647051572799683,
-0.12888103723526,
-0.3479976952075958,
-0.10786230862140656,
-0.22955232858657837,
-0.9165118336677551,
0.18362398445606232,
0.1635255366563797,
-0.4020448327064514,
-0.30703189969062805,
0.6558499932289124,
-0.28703346848487854,
-0.41821926832199097,
-0.14044910669326782,
0.4934743642807007,
0.036752793937921524,
-0.19829010963439941,
-0.7360336780548096,
0.05918331816792488,
-0.09237551689147949,
-0.09342193603515625,
0.3145653307437897,
0.5915756821632385,
0.06545274704694748,
0.4901406764984131,
0.40044957399368286,
0.11917606741189957,
-0.1417873501777649,
0.3084639608860016,
0.6298894882202148,
-0.9590529203414917,
-0.8735036849975586,
-0.7703184485435486,
0.4832955002784729,
0.275251179933548,
-0.8218434453010559,
0.403535395860672,
0.2615450322628021,
0.45599761605262756,
-0.07391874492168427,
0.5268237590789795,
0.045423608273267746,
0.655742883682251,
-0.7820734977722168,
0.918211042881012,
-0.5099931359291077,
0.23333537578582764,
-0.5132765769958496,
-0.969588577747345,
-0.5649896264076233,
0.40999969840049744,
0.016002586111426353,
0.11794336140155792,
0.7667162418365479,
0.8453981280326843,
-0.09418217092752457,
0.21696707606315613,
0.5108603239059448,
0.03102007322013378,
0.1150989830493927,
0.4365125298500061,
0.6133586764335632,
-0.18060535192489624,
0.48237401247024536,
-0.18637460470199585,
-0.5239586234092712,
-0.26077160239219666,
-1.1624181270599365,
-0.9695635437965393,
-0.549201488494873,
-0.44652822613716125,
-0.10329549759626389,
-0.12794366478919983,
0.942222535610199,
0.4697888195514679,
-0.8030754923820496,
0.47131332755088806,
0.20276106894016266,
0.23111599683761597,
-0.38029295206069946,
-0.24348805844783783,
0.2965475916862488,
-0.6230891942977905,
-0.456448495388031,
0.5546287894248962,
0.2838902473449707,
0.03862551599740982,
-0.019445883110165596,
0.21334274113178253,
0.12587496638298035,
-0.14734813570976257,
0.5608773231506348,
0.3276436924934387,
-0.6191574931144714,
-0.5055788159370422,
0.1678261011838913,
0.05537812411785126,
-0.009351017884910107,
0.9241674542427063,
-1.0961819887161255,
0.4894588589668274,
0.905831515789032,
0.7304003238677979,
0.018870078027248383,
0.08266497403383255,
0.4101361930370331,
-1.0695879459381104,
0.2259770631790161,
0.3879448175430298,
0.1645033359527588,
0.32856643199920654,
-0.5601704716682434,
0.20570681989192963,
0.27974486351013184,
-0.5059071779251099,
-0.7117229104042053,
0.11592087149620056,
-1.3303841352462769,
0.03889215737581253,
0.831187903881073,
-0.1336120069026947,
-0.08605217933654785,
-0.13027535378932953,
-0.4444655776023865,
0.11914768815040588,
-0.6299213767051697,
0.5295658111572266,
0.6366589069366455,
-0.1476324051618576,
-0.7377440929412842,
-0.22944875061511993,
0.7932866811752319,
0.46583735942840576,
-0.6521480083465576,
0.003623645519837737,
0.48684826493263245,
0.2754516005516052,
-0.13178183138370514,
0.4861263334751129,
0.2502722442150116,
0.5404385924339294,
-0.23672202229499817,
-0.3749808967113495,
-0.21196621656417847,
-0.45702239871025085,
-0.8973243236541748,
0.22022253274917603,
0.3458003103733063,
0.002099698642268777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02761v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02761v3
|
AQuA -- Combining Experts' and Non-Experts' Views To Assess Deliberation Quality in Online Discussions Using LLMs
| 2024-04-03T14:07:02 | 2024-04-17T10:56:48 |
Maike Behrendt, Stefan Sylvius Wagner, Marc Ziegele, Lena Wilms, Anke Stoll, Dominique Heinbach, Stefan Harmeling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Measuring the quality of contributions in political online discussions is
crucial in deliberation research and computer science. Research has identified
various indicators to assess online discussion quality, and with deep learning
advancements, automating these measures has become feasible. While some studies
focus on analyzing specific quality indicators, a comprehensive quality score
incorporating various deliberative aspects is often preferred. In this work, we
introduce AQuA, an additive score that calculates a unified deliberative
quality score from multiple indices for each discussion post. Unlike other
singular scores, AQuA preserves information on the deliberative aspects present
in comments, enhancing model transparency. We develop adapter models for 20
deliberative indices, and calculate correlation coefficients between experts'
annotations and the perceived deliberativeness by non-experts to weigh the
individual indices into a single deliberative score. We demonstrate that the
AQuA score can be computed easily from pre-trained adapters and aligns well
with annotations on other datasets that have not be seen during training. The
analysis of experts' vs. non-experts' annotations confirms theoretical findings
in the social science literature.
|
[
-0.9134994149208069,
-0.6936907172203064,
0.6938719749450684,
0.08414523303508759,
-0.6406259536743164,
0.4915924072265625,
0.04862073436379433,
-0.5319705009460449,
0.5970525145530701,
0.30532723665237427,
-0.19952288269996643,
-0.5085892677307129,
-0.7060387134552002,
0.04222036525607109,
-0.12646052241325378,
0.8739461898803711,
0.195539191365242,
0.11694667488336563,
-0.12246086448431015,
-0.2604435980319977,
-0.4325830936431885,
-0.1281711310148239,
-0.3612079918384552,
-0.23325110971927643,
0.5340911149978638,
0.32416704297065735,
0.6328088045120239,
0.3447783887386322,
0.5285490155220032,
0.4695384204387665,
-0.024788353592157364,
0.6349009275436401,
-0.9241260290145874,
0.27817443013191223,
-0.5012972950935364,
-0.5622650980949402,
-0.7908933162689209,
0.33323654532432556,
0.4538884460926056,
0.5786904096603394,
0.07322034984827042,
0.1434594988822937,
0.31919416785240173,
0.829509973526001,
-0.8015064597129822,
0.3963417708873749,
-0.8280861377716064,
0.2663392424583435,
0.43593040108680725,
-0.6855391263961792,
-0.08256039768457413,
-0.6880673766136169,
0.17006295919418335,
-0.7010361552238464,
-0.30525025725364685,
-0.3348388969898224,
0.3744666576385498,
0.5488995909690857,
-0.49878522753715515,
-0.1284748911857605,
-0.9083991050720215,
0.8041655421257019,
-0.8101069331169128,
0.05539767071604729,
0.22067461907863617,
0.002168838633224368,
-0.03355640172958374,
-0.5037968158721924,
-0.42479050159454346,
0.18414978682994843,
0.18796584010124207,
0.6629456281661987,
-0.12058775126934052,
0.13822084665298462,
-0.45407283306121826,
0.5315657258033752,
0.15683642029762268,
0.06002344563603401,
-0.2532797157764435,
0.004704012535512447,
1.0483328104019165,
0.25869691371917725,
-0.25863802433013916,
0.3097510039806366,
-0.23538106679916382,
0.24880388379096985,
-0.3740687072277069,
0.03470198065042496,
0.6453691720962524,
0.24739767611026764,
-0.11896426975727081,
0.47928765416145325,
-0.2894308865070343,
0.3931713104248047,
0.5275421738624573,
0.04759034141898155,
0.20277319848537445,
-0.4608639180660248,
-0.003914040047675371,
-0.16692936420440674,
0.9387909770011902,
0.7872523069381714,
0.2674039900302887,
0.40780118107795715,
0.03589622676372528,
-0.2392953336238861,
0.3418722450733185,
-0.62617027759552,
-0.48122888803482056,
0.20930171012878418,
-0.575029194355011,
-0.4403945505619049,
0.33320194482803345,
-0.6615965962409973,
-0.7042751908302307,
-0.6696741580963135,
0.3299848735332489,
0.21150217950344086,
-0.41849058866500854,
-0.27147531509399414,
-0.07348588109016418,
0.016493091359734535,
0.8778893947601318,
-0.06576408445835114,
0.20969945192337036,
0.7204518914222717,
0.6329596638679504,
-0.2950286567211151,
-0.02188318967819214,
-0.2646896243095398,
-0.0216322373598814,
-0.7175120711326599,
1.186367154121399,
-0.7325020432472229,
-0.3701934814453125,
-0.03875475749373436,
-0.3290533423423767,
0.031637050211429596,
-0.3036656081676483,
0.32535144686698914,
-0.5720320343971252,
0.5884981155395508,
-0.33836159110069275,
-1.0341212749481201,
-0.46261361241340637,
0.5276520252227783,
-0.6553139090538025,
0.48767635226249695,
-0.03766849637031555,
-0.788252592086792,
0.38010329008102417,
-0.8033830523490906,
-0.11002542823553085,
0.3253004252910614,
-0.16215366125106812,
-0.12365604937076569,
0.2075003981590271,
0.07573622465133667,
0.25525110960006714,
0.07872821390628815,
0.133612722158432,
-0.581287145614624,
-0.3338947296142578,
0.7981104850769043,
-0.4044855237007141,
0.35186827182769775,
0.08543917536735535,
-0.14840994775295258,
0.5475107431411743,
-0.435075581073761,
0.3758876919746399,
-0.5158740282058716,
-0.6330665946006775,
-0.2175251543521881,
0.2058466672897339,
-0.3789530098438263,
0.11694175004959106,
0.24462194740772247,
-0.47146037220954895,
-0.031228158622980118,
-0.33327704668045044,
0.5513430237770081,
0.8075043559074402,
0.6174267530441284,
0.34392186999320984,
-0.3649216890335083,
0.11474914848804474,
0.09454448521137238,
0.4020588994026184,
0.02557692490518093,
-0.6172183156013489,
-0.9368700981140137,
-0.3589842915534973,
0.37445953488349915,
0.551669716835022,
-0.4804414212703705,
0.5963536500930786,
-0.34632188081741333,
-0.7861177325248718,
-0.8441897630691528,
0.07580497860908508,
0.0918799638748169,
-0.0026244602631777525,
0.35960403084754944,
-0.4602604806423187,
-0.1107679232954979,
-0.6712477207183838,
-0.41962555050849915,
-0.526697039604187,
0.054585304111242294,
0.428455650806427,
0.43056434392929077,
-0.027807947248220444,
0.8280524015426636,
-0.2602746784687042,
-0.43770143389701843,
0.028821878135204315,
0.37848803400993347,
-0.010438749566674232,
0.21253851056098938,
0.1439092457294464,
-0.4442892372608185,
-0.6778011918067932,
-0.11204911023378372,
-0.5449501872062683,
0.12378892302513123,
0.024985525757074356,
-0.06482427567243576,
0.22336842119693756,
0.21823780238628387,
-0.29912620782852173,
0.393513023853302,
0.4757785499095917,
-0.16813670098781586,
0.054204218089580536,
-0.2406052201986313,
0.8121655583381653,
-0.8299410939216614,
-0.06955427676439285,
0.03965620696544647,
-0.3790661692619324,
-0.4584614932537079,
0.023383893072605133,
-0.36753273010253906,
0.36223283410072327,
-0.41111594438552856,
0.1067223772406578,
-0.13377416133880615,
0.3427702784538269,
-0.43504613637924194,
0.39256560802459717,
0.08561736345291138,
0.3309769332408905,
-0.0199322197586298,
0.43798497319221497,
0.10355181992053986,
-0.5204410552978516,
0.424776166677475,
0.15523920953273773,
-0.403285413980484,
0.6524389982223511,
-0.5438501238822937,
0.5348479747772217,
0.009434484876692295,
0.17398633062839508,
-1.2592339515686035,
-0.15997900068759918,
0.031345173716545105,
-0.4647522568702698,
0.07807736843824387,
-0.25077638030052185,
-0.13663531839847565,
0.03971599414944649,
-0.8399673700332642,
0.19005171954631805,
0.08482161909341812,
0.008340077474713326,
0.7380799651145935,
1.1155180931091309,
-0.2503993511199951,
-0.4429404139518738,
-0.5788760781288147,
0.17158791422843933,
-0.059298280626535416,
-0.33773818612098694,
0.29996636509895325,
-0.1303500384092331,
-0.381876677274704,
0.20784837007522583,
0.08446833491325378,
-0.17855647206306458,
0.13305646181106567,
0.2581799328327179,
0.1557088941335678,
-0.1746920496225357,
-0.26988351345062256,
0.0722813606262207,
-0.08100750297307968,
0.29030945897102356,
0.11903716623783112,
0.14939652383327484,
-0.07651184499263763,
-0.6286067366600037,
-0.7091420292854309,
0.46617642045021057,
0.8514307141304016,
-0.06921039521694183,
0.6081099510192871,
0.17020410299301147,
-0.225286602973938,
-0.09473494440317154,
-0.8084052205085754,
-0.07628382742404938,
-0.4548729658126831,
0.2320372611284256,
0.05678820610046387,
-1.0527201890945435,
0.6681134104728699,
-0.04398544877767563,
0.5315006375312805,
0.48326247930526733,
0.637723445892334,
-0.201515331864357,
0.9500990509986877,
0.6268123388290405,
-0.054246481508016586,
0.34544479846954346,
-0.015653131529688835,
0.39298170804977417,
-0.4623815417289734,
-0.36338189244270325,
-0.33103570342063904,
-0.44877979159355164,
-0.776094377040863,
-0.4861694872379303,
0.3287797272205353,
-0.13710206747055054,
-0.43320557475090027,
-0.35529476404190063,
-0.5495955944061279,
0.5585401058197021,
0.38146665692329407,
0.27489668130874634,
0.34380069375038147,
-0.08294404298067093,
0.27066296339035034,
-0.14112523198127747,
-0.35420963168144226,
-0.4814279079437256,
0.9158110618591309,
0.4711868464946747,
0.7726802825927734,
0.15760011970996857,
0.5551540851593018,
0.7697228789329529,
0.6354436874389648,
-0.9046900272369385,
0.5292218923568726,
0.11793650686740875,
-0.6036293506622314,
-0.26203879714012146,
-0.7189732193946838,
-0.4139499366283417,
0.31303834915161133,
-0.46572229266166687,
-0.35423147678375244,
0.2064799815416336,
0.13647863268852234,
-0.6061639189720154,
0.5027318000793457,
-0.2248987853527069,
0.3707507252693176,
-0.17804396152496338,
-0.5584532618522644,
-0.5988030433654785,
-0.46019789576530457,
0.20126000046730042,
-0.06563910841941833,
0.42422807216644287,
-0.36248549818992615,
-0.3283497393131256,
0.7855176329612732,
-0.23086300492286682,
0.9505833983421326,
-0.41532906889915466,
-0.13344226777553558,
0.6496920585632324,
0.18096789717674255,
0.0604187548160553,
-0.00256392196752131,
-0.012269018217921257,
0.384864866733551,
-0.14426235854625702,
0.18786849081516266,
-0.3594488203525543,
0.8548672795295715,
-1.119444489479065,
-0.8277618288993835,
-0.28231245279312134,
-0.3669765889644623,
-0.16078175604343414,
-0.12027058005332947,
-0.25975024700164795,
-0.18400172889232635,
-0.18293397128582,
0.1954112946987152,
0.6115163564682007,
-0.059639059007167816,
0.06763365864753723,
0.6127030253410339,
0.037272728979587555,
-0.922485888004303,
0.6881605982780457,
0.4776029884815216,
0.19760315120220184,
0.46233993768692017,
0.29719308018684387,
-0.2829102575778961,
-0.4242701232433319,
-0.005082997027784586,
-0.08352376520633698,
-0.9995586276054382,
-0.6741018891334534,
-0.4842199385166168,
-0.35588890314102173,
0.045260731130838394,
0.06110384315252304,
-0.5695720314979553,
-0.6024985909461975,
-0.5957654714584351,
-0.22399337589740753,
0.3292785584926605,
0.9989963173866272,
-0.2633344531059265,
-0.0024583644699305296,
-0.8498685359954834,
0.040402356535196304,
0.538547933101654,
0.6408898234367371,
0.07799091190099716,
-0.7083340883255005,
-0.0011235031997784972,
0.20296750962734222,
-0.5993031859397888,
-0.969708263874054,
0.1921163648366928,
0.25087684392929077,
0.6888259053230286,
0.871558427810669,
0.29540592432022095,
0.8449524641036987,
-0.07750097662210464,
0.9057552218437195,
-0.035635922104120255,
-0.8091377019882202,
0.5016093850135803,
-0.18472185730934143,
-0.05563623830676079,
0.8940386772155762,
0.4051552712917328,
0.007257440593093634,
-0.7328934669494629,
-0.23320405185222626,
-0.7820612788200378,
0.4028950333595276,
-0.009428915567696095,
0.27621743083000183,
0.07894788682460785,
0.38476455211639404,
0.2251225858926773,
0.2218306064605713,
-0.4779146611690521,
-0.3403264284133911,
-0.3412097990512848,
-0.05039183422923088,
0.20714329183101654,
-0.4955720901489258,
-0.28102636337280273,
-0.30850908160209656,
0.6895245909690857,
-0.1182098388671875,
0.13330085575580597,
0.2718910574913025,
0.266961008310318,
-0.44712212681770325,
0.27767249941825867,
0.4009166955947876,
0.7606234550476074,
-0.01947299763560295,
0.16218061745166779,
0.36922016739845276,
-0.18472601473331451,
-0.11252464354038239,
-0.17190797626972198,
-0.06279968470335007,
-0.045946236699819565,
0.4964861571788788,
0.418833464384079,
0.191494882106781,
0.0702073872089386,
0.4545432925224304,
-0.2981874644756317,
-0.3166739344596863,
-0.23993223905563354,
0.42272359132766724,
0.2490866780281067,
0.31881049275398254,
0.3155451714992523,
0.3557404577732086,
0.14581957459449768,
-0.6017048954963684,
-0.05751696601510048,
0.5464749932289124,
-0.7995030879974365,
-0.20901769399642944,
0.5272153615951538,
0.7406920194625854,
-0.2537585198879242,
0.470711886882782,
0.10828491300344467,
-0.6195277571678162,
0.3107975721359253,
-0.24949738383293152,
0.6670929789543152,
-0.4591074585914612,
-0.004588435869663954,
0.4268350303173065,
0.30703142285346985,
0.22855596244335175,
0.5086753964424133,
-0.11288383603096008,
-0.7192499041557312,
-0.7100241780281067,
-0.31125056743621826,
-0.7642235159873962,
0.12002824991941452,
-0.4945569634437561,
-0.003657330758869648,
-0.4718167185783386,
-0.6686288714408875,
0.12484659254550934,
0.40244242548942566,
-0.6818845272064209,
-0.18574823439121246,
0.27276700735092163,
0.7484485507011414,
-0.952698826789856,
0.14947821199893951,
0.628995418548584,
-0.21753095090389252,
-0.29582923650741577,
-0.2386302798986435,
-0.12154856324195862,
-0.4719856083393097,
0.28559747338294983,
0.08886159956455231,
-0.44965413212776184,
-0.3163653016090393,
-0.7611083984375,
-0.8382570743560791,
0.7633975744247437,
0.4985217750072479,
-0.5544880628585815,
0.5246181488037109,
0.4176071286201477,
0.6280640363693237,
-0.4444235861301422,
0.6727536916732788,
0.13929970562458038,
0.6448906660079956,
-0.2222440540790558,
-0.8478361368179321,
-0.14130710065364838,
-0.44338640570640564,
-0.4282442629337311,
-0.20056509971618652,
-0.6454452872276306,
0.6908389925956726,
-0.18239855766296387,
-0.22111454606056213,
-0.14922362565994263,
0.7326667904853821,
0.16560056805610657,
0.2030039131641388,
0.5016319751739502,
0.16830816864967346,
0.7315807938575745,
-0.0794595256447792,
0.6976962685585022,
-0.675351083278656,
0.33943915367126465,
1.1585642099380493,
-0.3434937000274658,
0.8527912497520447,
0.4886944591999054,
-0.22780035436153412,
0.4589541554450989,
0.5736948847770691,
0.10265418887138367,
0.3981409966945648,
0.16953127086162567,
-0.40385743975639343,
-0.7212978601455688,
-0.3565549850463867,
-0.2390950620174408,
0.35919347405433655,
0.6404666304588318,
-0.3232707679271698,
0.15853069722652435,
-0.5016334056854248,
-0.12187720090150833,
0.190556600689888,
-0.5331003069877625,
1.3274030685424805,
0.22859962284564972,
-0.8745788335800171,
-0.02780119515955448,
-0.11668454110622406,
0.40462493896484375,
-0.2809600830078125,
-0.450684517621994,
-0.2850169837474823,
0.1663278341293335,
-0.5001480579376221,
-1.5814045667648315,
0.07865151017904282,
-0.06780482083559036,
-0.10385426133871078,
0.06223636120557785,
0.4855380654335022,
-0.28873151540756226,
-0.4498900771141052,
0.30561351776123047,
0.8295512795448303,
0.2508561313152313,
-0.0387696735560894,
-0.6806709170341492,
0.03807368874549866,
-0.02494105137884617,
-0.3962152898311615,
0.06927239894866943,
0.6525408029556274,
0.21425192058086395,
0.5894777774810791,
0.6815618872642517,
-0.05678907781839371,
-0.22301587462425232,
0.21724997460842133,
1.2078264951705933,
-0.20127026736736298,
-0.3180712163448334,
-0.926317036151886,
0.5283570885658264,
-0.33353886008262634,
-0.3929436206817627,
0.49654093384742737,
0.4414685070514679,
0.7550769448280334,
0.11444389075040817,
0.8318256139755249,
0.33929672837257385,
0.49790436029434204,
-0.05533701181411743,
1.0524983406066895,
-0.25284770131111145,
0.05438216030597687,
-0.05611782521009445,
-0.901852548122406,
-0.3961077928543091,
0.8679234981536865,
-0.24705326557159424,
0.022028723731637,
0.307592511177063,
0.4492185711860657,
-0.05166340246796608,
0.22860829532146454,
0.13749226927757263,
0.2726506292819977,
0.4933221638202667,
0.280306875705719,
1.1939804553985596,
-0.12267285585403442,
0.29455068707466125,
-0.2020505964756012,
-0.23060518503189087,
-0.2326304167509079,
-1.0096712112426758,
-1.06289541721344,
-0.3293112516403198,
-0.8348407745361328,
-0.06402546167373657,
-0.1908797174692154,
1.0420775413513184,
0.5929819345474243,
-0.9156253933906555,
0.010195515118539333,
0.15217694640159607,
0.22310800850391388,
0.1389079988002777,
-0.2686249315738678,
0.2654876410961151,
0.02227012626826763,
-0.3889222741127014,
0.18036054074764252,
0.3142901360988617,
-0.3012830317020416,
-0.5741838812828064,
-0.01675879955291748,
-0.002696750219911337,
0.48430055379867554,
0.5738401412963867,
-0.06265422701835632,
-0.6055933237075806,
-0.4586317837238312,
-0.2978472113609314,
0.09787740558385849,
0.1458321511745453,
0.4907490313053131,
-0.6578640341758728,
0.5192242860794067,
0.6433795094490051,
0.25859448313713074,
0.24248775839805603,
0.17601002752780914,
0.25735074281692505,
-0.17177872359752655,
-0.39583107829093933,
0.32675328850746155,
0.2838827669620514,
0.4414635896682739,
-0.10319649428129196,
0.30647480487823486,
-0.046943794935941696,
-0.7482035756111145,
-0.47073978185653687,
-0.013127395883202553,
-0.8688847422599792,
-0.13304543495178223,
0.8462690114974976,
-0.6182297468185425,
0.07445217669010162,
-0.1678236424922943,
-0.15575337409973145,
0.3390675187110901,
-0.6466330885887146,
1.1423746347427368,
0.40865087509155273,
-0.25338128209114075,
-0.025539880618453026,
-0.2713872790336609,
0.07482024282217026,
-0.20741905272006989,
-1.0003796815872192,
-0.06907780468463898,
0.39554363489151,
0.3931945860385895,
0.3823162913322449,
0.4802507758140564,
-0.08866165578365326,
0.012185935862362385,
-0.18827320635318756,
-0.2533944547176361,
-0.30275657773017883,
-0.23519834876060486,
-0.0850406214594841,
0.48494938015937805,
0.15960216522216797,
0.057204704731702805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02717v1
|
Automatic Prompt Selection for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T13:20:24 | 2024-04-03T13:20:24 |
Viet-Tung Do, Van-Khanh Hoang, Duy-Hung Nguyen, Shahab Sabahi, Jeff Yang, Hajime Hotta, Minh-Tien Nguyen, Hung Le
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can perform various natural language processing
tasks with suitable instruction prompts. However, designing effective prompts
manually is challenging and time-consuming. Existing methods for automatic
prompt optimization either lack flexibility or efficiency. In this paper, we
propose an effective approach to automatically select the optimal prompt for a
given input from a finite set of synthetic candidate prompts. Our approach
consists of three steps: (1) clustering the training data and generating
candidate prompts for each cluster using an LLM-based prompt generator; (2)
synthesizing a dataset of input-prompt-output tuples for training a prompt
evaluator to rank the prompts based on their relevance to the input; (3) using
the prompt evaluator to select the best prompt for a new input at test time.
Our approach balances prompt generality-specificity and eliminates the need for
resource-intensive training and inference. It demonstrates competitive
performance on zero-shot question-answering datasets: GSM8K, MultiArith, and
AQuA.
|
[
-0.5947695970535278,
-0.8848100900650024,
0.9583741426467896,
0.27616432309150696,
-0.39413875341415405,
0.0451413169503212,
-0.3376549184322357,
0.037214964628219604,
0.07186631113290787,
0.19804607331752777,
-0.7804548740386963,
-0.371388703584671,
-0.217305988073349,
0.768099844455719,
0.0016291707288473845,
0.7839826941490173,
-0.012229705229401588,
-0.019891439005732536,
-0.16906972229480743,
0.05551672354340553,
-0.7574722766876221,
-0.11101403087377548,
-0.9168175458908081,
-0.14704369008541107,
0.7261912226676941,
0.46494826674461365,
0.23651248216629028,
0.740798830986023,
-0.05273837596178055,
0.35857996344566345,
-0.13581761717796326,
0.3523174524307251,
-0.14106996357440948,
0.6187337636947632,
-0.05121666565537453,
-0.19052532315254211,
-0.0024262883234769106,
0.0002920815604738891,
0.7193235158920288,
0.42552968859672546,
0.2162136435508728,
0.26772797107696533,
-0.1139436736702919,
0.21768787503242493,
-0.5191695690155029,
-0.0015769072342664003,
-0.7371143102645874,
0.058387476950883865,
0.08700038492679596,
-0.25910133123397827,
-0.5076775550842285,
-0.7758282423019409,
0.12420468777418137,
-0.5055027008056641,
0.14918601512908936,
0.20992131531238556,
0.35859039425849915,
0.2111177146434784,
-0.31336966156959534,
-0.29490721225738525,
-0.4639294445514679,
0.8407447338104248,
-0.47857460379600525,
0.12430230528116226,
0.22438645362854004,
0.5627120137214661,
-0.2259565144777298,
-0.2020650953054428,
-0.3940447270870209,
-0.47992298007011414,
0.03339065611362457,
0.07061617821455002,
-0.04578990116715431,
0.17900404334068298,
0.2995641231536865,
0.08969267457723618,
-0.9583826065063477,
0.3400752544403076,
-0.03601112589240074,
-0.15336374938488007,
0.5120862126350403,
0.2992681562900543,
0.3540017604827881,
-0.1733565330505371,
0.05819332227110863,
-0.10798128694295883,
-0.5737282633781433,
0.19740815460681915,
0.2934715151786804,
0.6171455979347229,
0.09098555892705917,
0.5318845510482788,
-0.2935733199119568,
1.0584214925765991,
0.3881261944770813,
-0.23574408888816833,
0.03299035504460335,
-0.09479665011167526,
-0.03810024634003639,
0.07366310060024261,
0.9128618240356445,
0.14757069945335388,
0.06895648688077927,
-0.126853808760643,
-0.44495564699172974,
-0.08526066690683365,
-0.055286955088377,
-0.7031210660934448,
0.18911725282669067,
0.38059940934181213,
-0.03650013729929924,
-0.3603955805301666,
-0.14783626794815063,
-0.8743327856063843,
-0.26756009459495544,
-0.4309353232383728,
0.2727505564689636,
-0.01128069031983614,
0.22279278934001923,
-0.19481416046619415,
-0.09609080106019974,
0.03160710260272026,
0.18971695005893707,
-1.0702605247497559,
-0.11124828457832336,
0.3499898612499237,
0.7350157499313354,
-0.33943411707878113,
-0.09904780238866806,
-1.1264606714248657,
-0.02995171584188938,
-0.44885483384132385,
0.9157389998435974,
-0.8232390284538269,
-0.6142006516456604,
0.017216632142663002,
-0.09555772691965103,
-0.2245064526796341,
-0.4446622133255005,
0.5346007943153381,
-0.5792702436447144,
0.46816396713256836,
-0.16372466087341309,
-0.44108662009239197,
0.1770820915699005,
0.2004973441362381,
-0.6577945947647095,
0.9515106678009033,
0.10918527841567993,
-0.3130694031715393,
0.21915298700332642,
-0.6769515872001648,
-0.42203542590141296,
0.140914186835289,
-0.11081518977880478,
-0.10250305384397507,
0.16255968809127808,
0.633687436580658,
0.4498324692249298,
-0.5420252084732056,
0.42952418327331543,
-0.10129787027835846,
-0.33570846915245056,
0.1163157969713211,
-0.32546466588974,
0.6647867560386658,
0.32826462388038635,
-0.19706395268440247,
0.37806960940361023,
-0.7501652836799622,
0.09617847204208374,
0.16814640164375305,
-0.5359023213386536,
-0.02699880115687847,
-0.2915182411670685,
-0.2688594460487366,
-0.004668053239583969,
0.21562990546226501,
-0.5420956015586853,
0.3527785539627075,
-0.5483649373054504,
0.3054873049259186,
0.8191834092140198,
0.1720837503671646,
0.5484926104545593,
-0.18318693339824677,
0.8920626640319824,
-0.41116461157798767,
0.1962430328130722,
-0.2655094861984253,
-0.22385373711585999,
-0.45324018597602844,
-0.348578542470932,
0.2777404189109802,
0.8200474977493286,
-0.7764800190925598,
0.8840445876121521,
0.10046021640300751,
-0.4194362163543701,
-0.4381113350391388,
0.013587786816060543,
0.18846982717514038,
0.5638290643692017,
0.28341227769851685,
0.3852379620075226,
-0.40545105934143066,
-0.8898707032203674,
-0.08547507226467133,
-0.14746086299419403,
-0.11234225332736969,
0.3121408224105835,
-0.0009401416755281389,
-0.0782962292432785,
1.1413085460662842,
-0.6832492351531982,
0.0757780447602272,
-0.5507152676582336,
0.03386395052075386,
0.56662517786026,
0.12098992615938187,
0.4884023666381836,
-0.4656389057636261,
-0.6990756392478943,
-0.12369082123041153,
-0.4563220739364624,
-0.6689667105674744,
-0.301294207572937,
-0.1320754587650299,
0.11169128865003586,
0.38024601340293884,
-0.7171730399131775,
-0.04799332097172737,
0.28442835807800293,
-0.10520434379577637,
0.6453502774238586,
-0.16817930340766907,
0.08696804940700531,
-1.0734025239944458,
0.24830617010593414,
0.10343316942453384,
-0.21302171051502228,
-0.4196678102016449,
-0.10629730671644211,
-0.050622712820768356,
-0.3875451683998108,
-0.24660000205039978,
1.1079245805740356,
-0.4481184482574463,
0.16514942049980164,
-0.0987364649772644,
0.21595090627670288,
-0.10221569985151291,
0.4102593958377838,
-0.015787584707140923,
0.8581874370574951,
0.460144966840744,
-0.6881433725357056,
0.6298040151596069,
0.3435244858264923,
-0.21920864284038544,
0.37028002738952637,
-0.7846720218658447,
0.18477298319339752,
-0.3079310953617096,
0.36370253562927246,
-1.0677299499511719,
-0.20174002647399902,
0.20895831286907196,
-0.379003643989563,
0.15425407886505127,
-0.07895392179489136,
-0.3797537088394165,
-0.4514268934726715,
-0.3106585443019867,
0.2596037983894348,
0.536628007888794,
-0.577343225479126,
0.5939773321151733,
0.1670677661895752,
-0.5850667953491211,
-0.3685794174671173,
-0.11566325277090073,
0.0212694201618433,
-0.23249094188213348,
-0.28713515400886536,
-0.04174543172121048,
-0.40504583716392517,
-0.12547272443771362,
-0.399127721786499,
0.1377304196357727,
0.11266860365867615,
0.13667969405651093,
0.056058723479509354,
0.4170466959476471,
-0.05244340002536774,
0.1246056854724884,
0.3655005693435669,
-0.35254526138305664,
-0.07909175008535385,
-0.24841637909412384,
0.6729461550712585,
0.0781063586473465,
-0.13966096937656403,
-0.3916008770465851,
0.5947165489196777,
0.34300607442855835,
-0.38404929637908936,
0.3791813552379608,
0.4417973458766937,
-0.04886491596698761,
-0.5906040668487549,
-0.5857334136962891,
-0.23835380375385284,
-0.5093324184417725,
0.20290912687778473,
-0.2562907636165619,
-0.913379430770874,
0.22828315198421478,
0.1739015281200409,
0.48401740193367004,
0.21908068656921387,
0.6331047415733337,
0.26005029678344727,
1.3211941719055176,
0.22885186970233917,
-0.19113847613334656,
0.5724928379058838,
0.07022571563720703,
0.30475592613220215,
-0.514272153377533,
0.05120687931776047,
-0.6161900162696838,
-0.1052691787481308,
-0.26202765107154846,
-0.04705587774515152,
0.5588297843933105,
-0.2953532636165619,
-0.32840415835380554,
0.21600276231765747,
-0.5641146898269653,
0.758464515209198,
0.6208792924880981,
-0.14894473552703857,
0.08290954679250717,
0.03398119658231735,
-0.5445138812065125,
0.19161655008792877,
-0.7192479372024536,
-0.5985414385795593,
0.6772533655166626,
0.09573596715927124,
0.5025174617767334,
-0.1713450402021408,
0.6963346600532532,
0.10853864997625351,
0.018703525885939598,
-0.7177937030792236,
0.7462712526321411,
0.04120930656790733,
-0.3526003360748291,
-0.557529866695404,
-0.5244050025939941,
-1.1102012395858765,
0.179502472281456,
-0.2673497498035431,
-0.5634868741035461,
-0.12310907989740372,
0.18956881761550903,
-0.9133701324462891,
-0.010161777958273888,
-0.5877074003219604,
0.7054070830345154,
-0.11056747287511826,
-0.0002208716032328084,
0.1265655905008316,
-0.6088619232177734,
0.08959531038999557,
-0.2938217222690582,
0.1380094736814499,
-0.130294069647789,
-0.010452638380229473,
0.3586723506450653,
-0.12750427424907684,
0.6632462739944458,
-0.23914438486099243,
-0.08408242464065552,
0.3632863163948059,
0.19138556718826294,
0.5561582446098328,
0.127638041973114,
-0.21231190860271454,
-0.40572068095207214,
-0.1460343301296234,
-0.02899325080215931,
-0.6401659250259399,
0.5832503437995911,
-0.596554160118103,
-0.6774384379386902,
-0.21933302283287048,
-0.42016837000846863,
-0.4931536614894867,
0.19836103916168213,
0.40520766377449036,
0.7317509055137634,
-0.2567618787288666,
-0.1300584375858307,
0.5257517695426941,
-0.5446614027023315,
0.7133902907371521,
0.3633134365081787,
-0.15706877410411835,
-0.6325292587280273,
0.93415766954422,
-0.13119138777256012,
0.1950276494026184,
0.36731213331222534,
0.5453213453292847,
-0.5272358059883118,
-0.46316391229629517,
-0.8709931969642639,
0.29227951169013977,
-0.6351655125617981,
-0.2325800210237503,
-0.7584501504898071,
-0.17104484140872955,
-0.37181293964385986,
-0.3291853070259094,
0.1421811878681183,
-0.21858319640159607,
-0.4913456439971924,
-0.030596258118748665,
0.17621025443077087,
0.4530112147331238,
0.10629797726869583,
0.33786189556121826,
-0.9833411574363708,
0.4111331105232239,
0.6685003042221069,
0.08283881843090057,
0.009926586411893368,
-0.5065822005271912,
0.10042624175548553,
-0.19793468713760376,
-0.05023821443319321,
-0.6114962697029114,
0.35787439346313477,
0.209203839302063,
0.7437391877174377,
0.2651238739490509,
0.2677457630634308,
0.183294877409935,
-0.7161322236061096,
0.7622073888778687,
0.21447685360908508,
-0.6702163815498352,
0.7967785596847534,
-0.5596721172332764,
0.7478997111320496,
0.7372641563415527,
0.29379069805145264,
-0.6257249712944031,
-0.4570465385913849,
-0.31035298109054565,
-0.8226156234741211,
0.5553168654441833,
-0.03794442117214203,
0.12259186804294586,
-0.3384513854980469,
0.22872492671012878,
0.35262373089790344,
0.20792008936405182,
-0.4476495683193207,
-0.1478159874677658,
0.3837600350379944,
-0.5667542815208435,
0.12129101902246475,
-0.2745632827281952,
-0.05603558197617531,
-0.13223764300346375,
0.6830651164054871,
-0.4176750183105469,
0.17886850237846375,
0.012633116915822029,
-0.07833937555551529,
-0.31039243936538696,
0.24418525397777557,
0.3705734610557556,
0.7213073372840881,
0.11160818487405777,
-0.15672318637371063,
0.32987603545188904,
-0.2501550614833832,
0.4090127944946289,
0.024605954065918922,
-0.5084799528121948,
0.23931819200515747,
0.25715333223342896,
0.9492807388305664,
-0.03643638640642166,
-0.8347833752632141,
0.42029133439064026,
-0.22843903303146362,
0.004228058736771345,
-0.19102253019809723,
0.4894711673259735,
-0.18467168509960175,
0.41210490465164185,
0.3722163438796997,
-0.2785968482494354,
-0.011764118447899818,
-0.3103879988193512,
-0.04214966297149658,
0.5137097239494324,
0.04602925106883049,
-0.12805575132369995,
0.4634106457233429,
0.3878554701805115,
-0.49659016728401184,
0.5220395922660828,
-0.3458975851535797,
-0.48471900820732117,
0.5294462442398071,
0.4162384867668152,
1.0538486242294312,
-0.4619010090827942,
0.4469868838787079,
0.621309220790863,
-0.0937502533197403,
-0.13263528048992157,
0.13770298659801483,
0.1187049150466919,
-0.4451187252998352,
-0.43245652318000793,
-0.7128055691719055,
-0.3974117934703827,
0.1617228239774704,
-0.3034331202507019,
0.5390565395355225,
-0.5654739737510681,
-0.18109679222106934,
-0.13484561443328857,
-0.03309661149978638,
-0.5522293448448181,
0.23917819559574127,
0.22476665675640106,
0.7329990863800049,
-0.7517000436782837,
0.3764721751213074,
0.49732279777526855,
-0.0917932391166687,
-0.7378924489021301,
-0.18764284253120422,
-0.013354101218283176,
-0.8808293342590332,
0.3946630656719208,
0.14606493711471558,
0.1470259726047516,
0.2025403380393982,
-0.5990715622901917,
-0.7815135717391968,
0.809428334236145,
0.5311353802680969,
-0.6860275268554688,
-0.1390920728445053,
-0.024545123800635338,
0.2588042616844177,
-0.561618983745575,
0.45170027017593384,
0.5664626359939575,
0.45231032371520996,
0.40817856788635254,
-0.9061223268508911,
0.0359870083630085,
-0.08073906600475311,
0.08185833692550659,
0.14158391952514648,
-0.5387541651725769,
0.6617675423622131,
-0.16293615102767944,
-0.153059184551239,
0.24714204668998718,
0.4109540283679962,
0.6841460466384888,
-0.03219186142086983,
0.8127865195274353,
0.1272955983877182,
0.8299289345741272,
0.21501412987709045,
0.8203255534172058,
-0.26125848293304443,
-0.008940266445279121,
0.9060260057449341,
-0.2178015261888504,
0.5592161417007446,
0.2982694208621979,
-0.011852745898067951,
0.1459667980670929,
1.063909888267517,
-0.2123999446630478,
0.5623630881309509,
0.29266291856765747,
-0.49479109048843384,
-0.4533955454826355,
-0.27131620049476624,
-0.10513480007648468,
0.13901491463184357,
-0.003695341758430004,
-0.2014947235584259,
-0.3544556498527527,
-0.05619875714182854,
-0.14026252925395966,
-0.20719020068645477,
-0.19345688819885254,
0.8659071922302246,
0.07724978029727936,
-1.027827262878418,
0.5936899185180664,
-0.006544232834130526,
0.3936671316623688,
-0.7687023878097534,
-0.004013803321868181,
-0.33315765857696533,
-0.3171549439430237,
0.09378199279308319,
-0.5684009194374084,
-0.15738718211650848,
0.31945809721946716,
-0.16243234276771545,
-0.2854950428009033,
0.5613521337509155,
-0.5573984384536743,
-0.4489351809024811,
-0.027634158730506897,
0.48383989930152893,
0.09076302498579025,
-0.21105767786502838,
-0.5329865217208862,
-0.03961092606186867,
0.030772019177675247,
-0.4078018367290497,
0.2017667591571808,
0.47869059443473816,
-0.11424896866083145,
0.6068234443664551,
0.7652459740638733,
0.3414665162563324,
-0.15509985387325287,
0.12215646356344223,
0.9321497678756714,
-0.5907306671142578,
-0.7864373326301575,
-0.9384788870811462,
0.47359347343444824,
-0.1235944852232933,
-0.42774879932403564,
0.37881579995155334,
0.41765284538269043,
0.20624755322933197,
0.007590760011225939,
1.0441688299179077,
0.12191599607467651,
0.6111741065979004,
-0.5789457559585571,
0.3311663568019867,
-0.3633360266685486,
0.18129099905490875,
-0.061139024794101715,
-1.418676495552063,
-0.20646677911281586,
0.6362184286117554,
-0.3578268885612488,
-0.059771399945020676,
0.6167054176330566,
0.8346964716911316,
0.210027813911438,
0.06951815634965897,
0.2367246299982071,
-0.11090737581253052,
0.3540857434272766,
0.583630383014679,
0.8421730995178223,
0.171268492937088,
0.40018951892852783,
0.1641315221786499,
-0.25034862756729126,
-0.27037858963012695,
-0.9233250021934509,
-1.1165071725845337,
-0.5177770256996155,
-0.09603918343782425,
0.018570132553577423,
-0.15731388330459595,
1.6333897113800049,
0.40238288044929504,
-0.7237657308578491,
-0.24005204439163208,
0.262418657541275,
0.13788285851478577,
0.2283017337322235,
-0.15168091654777527,
0.2983661890029907,
-0.7337148785591125,
-0.7595674395561218,
0.7694166302680969,
0.20269280672073364,
0.1753862500190735,
-0.2559335231781006,
0.1784883588552475,
0.027671417221426964,
0.1842477172613144,
0.6266154646873474,
0.20457576215267181,
-0.5294204354286194,
-0.21874511241912842,
0.23692873120307922,
-0.1638263314962387,
-0.10265009105205536,
0.7413331866264343,
-0.6587410569190979,
0.3412960469722748,
0.6037354469299316,
0.9159664511680603,
0.06729631125926971,
0.10274377465248108,
0.9287281036376953,
-0.7736150026321411,
-0.04436330124735832,
0.4602009057998657,
0.18801249563694,
0.2702537477016449,
-0.4402369558811188,
0.3412803113460541,
0.04090448468923569,
-0.6006388068199158,
-0.8217568397521973,
0.029595570638775826,
-0.8211826086044312,
-0.3764267861843109,
1.5681238174438477,
0.16169476509094238,
-0.37303805351257324,
-0.016583699733018875,
-0.5360847115516663,
0.14058390259742737,
-0.715446949005127,
0.6066346168518066,
0.6489781737327576,
-0.14606092870235443,
-0.1771809160709381,
-0.502334713935852,
0.49709421396255493,
0.20747782289981842,
-0.7828329801559448,
0.1415300816297531,
0.7071145176887512,
0.14504709839820862,
-0.21082547307014465,
0.3547704517841339,
0.38189488649368286,
0.08218371123075485,
-0.4210456311702728,
-0.19709035754203796,
-0.149871364235878,
-0.3847404420375824,
-0.5818873643875122,
0.19650126993656158,
0.06376086175441742,
-0.10107049345970154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02710v1
|
ART: The Alternating Reading Task Corpus for Speech Entrainment and Imitation
| 2024-04-03T13:08:26 | 2024-04-03T13:08:26 |
Zheng Yuan, Dorina de Jong, Štefan Beňuš, Noël Nguyen, Ruitao Feng, Róbert Sabo, Luciano Fadiga, Alessandro D`Ausilio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
We introduce the Alternating Reading Task (ART) Corpus, a collection of
dyadic sentence reading for studying the entrainment and imitation behaviour in
speech communication. The ART corpus features three experimental conditions -
solo reading, alternating reading, and deliberate imitation - as well as three
sub-corpora encompassing French-, Italian-, and Slovak-accented English. This
design allows systematic investigation of speech entrainment in a controlled
and less-spontaneous setting. Alongside detailed transcriptions, it includes
English proficiency scores, demographics, and in-experiment questionnaires for
probing linguistic, personal and interpersonal influences on entrainment. Our
presentation covers its design, collection, annotation processes, initial
analysis, and future research prospects.
|
[
-0.12489714473485947,
-1.2719157934188843,
0.3197338581085205,
0.16845755279064178,
-0.14551101624965668,
0.3459610641002655,
-0.05401385575532913,
-0.7929053902626038,
0.6469517946243286,
0.4005916714668274,
-0.5624736547470093,
-0.42897412180900574,
-0.5076097249984741,
0.3519093692302704,
-0.6510257124900818,
0.3737433850765228,
-0.26817992329597473,
0.16900716722011566,
-0.15560275316238403,
-0.15379254519939423,
-0.5675135850906372,
-0.3488345146179199,
-0.9158661961555481,
-0.14763693511486053,
0.45325955748558044,
0.5679996013641357,
0.5338987112045288,
0.6087691187858582,
0.25154373049736023,
0.3239763081073761,
0.3119910657405853,
0.14536498486995697,
-0.42139238119125366,
0.4729875326156616,
-0.009037510491907597,
-0.6712919473648071,
-0.0733705684542656,
0.38756054639816284,
0.9513036012649536,
0.662142813205719,
-0.03624024614691734,
-0.0459296777844429,
0.01692073605954647,
0.7062889337539673,
-0.5962951183319092,
0.17619355022907257,
-0.2571183443069458,
0.0560554675757885,
-0.5362176299095154,
-0.11204910278320312,
-0.6373318433761597,
-0.2029733657836914,
0.08874662965536118,
-0.7607636451721191,
0.0604187548160553,
0.40927425026893616,
0.5567343831062317,
0.3800199627876282,
-0.37048661708831787,
-0.5201328992843628,
-0.7109320759773254,
0.46166473627090454,
-0.24172313511371613,
0.451579749584198,
0.7539109587669373,
-0.23109497129917145,
0.2662045657634735,
-0.8960319757461548,
-0.8997353315353394,
-0.32696884870529175,
-0.2364572435617447,
0.3928140699863434,
-0.328172504901886,
0.09379249066114426,
-0.10442847013473511,
0.2698025703430176,
-0.43173882365226746,
0.018632203340530396,
-0.31886518001556396,
0.12823490798473358,
0.6515375971794128,
0.07287796586751938,
0.8799746632575989,
0.26537665724754333,
-0.007228577975183725,
-0.03180253133177757,
-0.5312369465827942,
0.11257956922054291,
0.8655953407287598,
0.0006891472730785608,
-0.08224412053823471,
0.7962837219238281,
0.10781919211149216,
0.772210419178009,
0.14693976938724518,
0.24632973968982697,
0.3477315306663513,
-0.11142548173666,
-0.0674276202917099,
0.2571568489074707,
0.5910057425498962,
0.012436771765351295,
0.09062250703573227,
-0.24453620612621307,
-0.0004747289640363306,
0.24877695739269257,
0.27566322684288025,
-0.30693358182907104,
-0.20402765274047852,
0.14342501759529114,
-0.2784576714038849,
-0.14187636971473694,
-0.06700173765420914,
-0.5586432218551636,
-0.20478123426437378,
-0.6677988171577454,
0.6636831760406494,
-0.8012398481369019,
-0.23964190483093262,
0.08531668037176132,
-0.2530519962310791,
0.023147257044911385,
-0.05613715946674347,
-1.1409162282943726,
0.5309199690818787,
0.40785518288612366,
0.8251492381095886,
-0.6680096387863159,
-0.7205464839935303,
-0.5580242276191711,
0.0822669044137001,
-0.5286920070648193,
0.8812146186828613,
-0.8297867178916931,
-0.4837944209575653,
0.17338162660598755,
0.2803857922554016,
-0.5051676630973816,
-0.25143563747406006,
0.39473390579223633,
-0.4842507839202881,
0.20754902064800262,
0.13332383334636688,
-0.792626142501831,
-0.313770592212677,
-0.2779894173145294,
-0.7712616920471191,
1.1208993196487427,
0.03349945321679115,
-0.687512993812561,
0.2517448961734772,
-0.7049258351325989,
-0.5250623226165771,
0.02974487654864788,
-0.46502766013145447,
-0.08735177665948868,
-0.11154500395059586,
-0.14424709975719452,
0.07333433628082275,
0.4678122401237488,
-0.5023929476737976,
-0.032326459884643555,
-0.5836794376373291,
0.4930516481399536,
-0.30159151554107666,
0.9258079528808594,
0.30008888244628906,
-0.28621816635131836,
0.08353990316390991,
-0.7037228345870972,
-0.11370769888162613,
0.035927534103393555,
-0.07197543978691101,
-0.5960081815719604,
0.012737641111016273,
0.06981797516345978,
-0.2021169364452362,
0.1898380070924759,
-0.9493315815925598,
0.1989036500453949,
-0.4892195165157318,
0.4617886245250702,
0.36911123991012573,
0.44267839193344116,
0.4000342786312103,
-0.6769265532493591,
0.6959425806999207,
-0.016684964299201965,
-0.13718286156654358,
0.06145460158586502,
-0.44629454612731934,
-0.7553766965866089,
-0.4442150890827179,
0.34871387481689453,
0.7482934594154358,
-1.0342252254486084,
0.03611991927027702,
0.2366494983434677,
-0.3381827175617218,
-1.1281238794326782,
0.15039092302322388,
0.47079354524612427,
0.11614757031202316,
0.30671602487564087,
-0.33581024408340454,
-0.5871235132217407,
-0.8852148652076721,
-0.2431803047657013,
-0.05959954112768173,
0.39295822381973267,
-0.10116716474294662,
0.5040661096572876,
0.07885153591632843,
0.689878523349762,
-0.2056836485862732,
-0.3194466531276703,
-0.3516868054866791,
0.44682058691978455,
-0.051504552364349365,
0.5792713165283203,
0.6536334753036499,
-0.43516287207603455,
-0.7967875003814697,
-0.48861005902290344,
-0.298499196767807,
-0.26930156350135803,
-0.22975502908229828,
-0.5209386348724365,
0.27091825008392334,
0.788689911365509,
-0.3005255460739136,
0.5380330085754395,
0.6409623622894287,
-0.4665699601173401,
0.5165120959281921,
-0.08939619362354279,
0.2960852384567261,
-0.762355387210846,
-0.05135314539074898,
-0.44913145899772644,
-0.0919252559542656,
-0.7906057238578796,
-0.16280095279216766,
-0.30563458800315857,
0.18715164065361023,
-0.5669636726379395,
0.35628315806388855,
-0.6749504804611206,
0.15705282986164093,
-0.44450926780700684,
0.1571134328842163,
0.004622071981430054,
0.338621586561203,
0.2762452960014343,
0.8886896371841431,
0.7496225833892822,
-0.2962510287761688,
0.05789870768785477,
0.5654507279396057,
-0.5287292003631592,
0.6338262557983398,
-0.5943213105201721,
0.7220178842544556,
-0.40563926100730896,
-0.18146778643131256,
-1.3425968885421753,
-0.03983128443360329,
0.35020482540130615,
-0.3076038062572479,
0.4573749601840973,
0.19324789941310883,
-0.3800925612449646,
-0.04104097932577133,
0.13707266747951508,
0.32637283205986023,
0.4292878210544586,
-0.33732500672340393,
0.5117717981338501,
0.5640457272529602,
-0.3331085741519928,
-0.5604953765869141,
-0.9190717935562134,
-0.076245978474617,
-0.09508481621742249,
-0.42098137736320496,
0.2977326214313507,
-0.13944566249847412,
-0.6695773601531982,
0.17882975935935974,
0.15768958628177643,
-0.02095983922481537,
-0.2242891490459442,
0.32683131098747253,
0.091481052339077,
0.10335103422403336,
0.1513732373714447,
0.041633497923612595,
0.22380799055099487,
-0.1502470076084137,
0.08791681379079819,
0.38762253522872925,
0.01214788481593132,
-0.6244317293167114,
-0.7759012579917908,
0.8884505033493042,
0.30788353085517883,
-0.012453286908566952,
0.4782126545906067,
0.5644336342811584,
-0.05105994641780853,
-0.24917125701904297,
-0.42777785658836365,
0.014442146755754948,
-0.474654883146286,
0.106929250061512,
-0.578514039516449,
-0.4991595447063446,
0.18755951523780823,
0.47335898876190186,
0.2754005789756775,
0.22841858863830566,
0.5531268119812012,
-0.43552786111831665,
0.8225836157798767,
0.7715545892715454,
0.054389357566833496,
0.9677992463111877,
-0.30619674921035767,
-0.1951490342617035,
-0.715069055557251,
0.27564868330955505,
-0.29294416308403015,
-0.6700998544692993,
-0.15962597727775574,
-0.43822070956230164,
0.31095319986343384,
-0.20279759168624878,
0.0312788188457489,
0.1375194787979126,
-0.42515596747398376,
0.47663986682891846,
0.8287855386734009,
0.37986084818840027,
0.5893765091896057,
-0.14559698104858398,
-0.26038914918899536,
-0.1534951776266098,
-0.4469990134239197,
-0.5499510765075684,
0.9865152835845947,
0.02709980495274067,
0.547806978225708,
0.27956968545913696,
0.776618480682373,
0.40867099165916443,
0.2658495008945465,
-0.9132178425788879,
0.3804168999195099,
-0.09381198137998581,
-0.7436860203742981,
-0.4371795058250427,
0.19333507120609283,
-1.4224416017532349,
0.18527401983737946,
-0.036218296736478806,
-0.6157765984535217,
0.4674969017505646,
0.08730750530958176,
-0.38106152415275574,
-0.07805418223142624,
-0.7556452751159668,
0.7121668457984924,
-0.09268151968717575,
-0.5707219839096069,
-0.4659128487110138,
-0.6049079895019531,
0.36455944180488586,
0.11815217137336731,
0.2986140251159668,
-0.03330584242939949,
-0.22821804881095886,
0.7678694725036621,
0.08372297883033752,
1.2678353786468506,
0.021141907200217247,
0.07910596579313278,
0.6601250767707825,
0.3833819627761841,
0.507307767868042,
-0.1885184496641159,
-0.12098787724971771,
-0.2530994415283203,
0.3394259214401245,
-0.26730746030807495,
-0.40428170561790466,
0.14719100296497345,
-0.9389007091522217,
-0.3861367404460907,
-0.5331857800483704,
-0.602545440196991,
-0.46142062544822693,
0.1419493705034256,
0.32114002108573914,
0.4933710992336273,
-0.6071193814277649,
0.1729903370141983,
0.4449408948421478,
0.020926199853420258,
0.6578430533409119,
0.9158955216407776,
-0.015774283558130264,
-0.30842703580856323,
0.680424153804779,
0.19981227815151215,
0.552686333656311,
0.45303788781166077,
-0.06553245335817337,
-0.43976476788520813,
-0.6458662748336792,
-0.3632442355155945,
0.20330490171909332,
-0.6106389760971069,
0.4423603415489197,
-0.6102546453475952,
-0.08950065821409225,
-0.465437114238739,
0.04419519379734993,
-0.18135759234428406,
-0.3809318244457245,
-0.5020025372505188,
-0.2296927571296692,
0.5156118273735046,
0.9029232859611511,
-0.33498314023017883,
0.26047202944755554,
-0.33291175961494446,
0.2923470437526703,
0.390382319688797,
0.1964307278394699,
-0.2942325472831726,
-0.5684291124343872,
-0.20896096527576447,
0.08702894300222397,
-0.4433625042438507,
-1.1378034353256226,
0.47075483202934265,
0.6008661389350891,
0.8780295848846436,
0.2573893666267395,
0.11404907703399658,
0.5481268167495728,
-0.8161288499832153,
0.8371986150741577,
0.0888713151216507,
-0.8696802258491516,
0.3554905951023102,
-0.2268117219209671,
0.08506185561418533,
0.7562572956085205,
0.5831352472305298,
-0.794472336769104,
-0.8572218418121338,
-0.7421841025352478,
-0.7827469110488892,
0.4729834794998169,
0.23193635046482086,
0.11107020825147629,
-0.29360225796699524,
0.04921001195907593,
0.37837228178977966,
0.16147927939891815,
-0.5428795218467712,
-0.26695454120635986,
-0.14297586679458618,
-0.4231542646884918,
-0.2231309860944748,
-0.0982109010219574,
-0.4720868170261383,
-0.5068223476409912,
0.8174861669540405,
0.10317394137382507,
0.4234183728694916,
0.5118173956871033,
-0.3775687515735626,
-0.23760466277599335,
0.08353526890277863,
0.5702645182609558,
0.4687044620513916,
0.08922117948532104,
0.34237560629844666,
0.08444584161043167,
-0.9740688800811768,
0.19851943850517273,
-0.14233751595020294,
-0.19394394755363464,
0.24661463499069214,
0.393189936876297,
0.9494106769561768,
0.06889571249485016,
-0.7882053852081299,
0.38305455446243286,
0.06941980868577957,
-0.393655002117157,
-0.6768202185630798,
0.08160848915576935,
0.010954400524497032,
0.2445807158946991,
-0.033635880798101425,
-0.1630580872297287,
0.23374761641025543,
-0.9239702224731445,
0.5001477003097534,
0.2618979811668396,
-0.4601856470108032,
-0.297343373298645,
0.7251811027526855,
0.18322178721427917,
-0.41393232345581055,
0.4263227581977844,
-0.3911988139152527,
0.0331382118165493,
0.3783479630947113,
0.6742269396781921,
0.9557801485061646,
-0.14055410027503967,
0.07865498214960098,
0.0007897067116573453,
0.3094605803489685,
0.07680906355381012,
0.9643709063529968,
0.05034838616847992,
-0.8941531777381897,
-0.3804113566875458,
-0.4939507842063904,
-0.879089891910553,
-0.0907493606209755,
-0.813831627368927,
0.12403359264135361,
0.27646908164024353,
-0.008608706295490265,
0.10767912119626999,
-0.20659328997135162,
-0.6715149879455566,
-0.3941889703273773,
0.19600211083889008,
0.6509835720062256,
-0.8147812485694885,
1.10911226272583,
0.8476605415344238,
-0.5737836360931396,
-0.4566538631916046,
-0.09068764001131058,
-0.00350839807651937,
-1.1949800252914429,
0.610271155834198,
-0.29307496547698975,
-0.2034061700105667,
0.5822349786758423,
-0.43390321731567383,
-0.9304726123809814,
0.8240249752998352,
0.05617693439126015,
-0.5742536187171936,
0.26401814818382263,
0.0997433140873909,
0.6017398238182068,
-0.40386322140693665,
0.25275158882141113,
0.969344973564148,
0.4669119119644165,
-0.16791260242462158,
-0.9088462591171265,
-0.2917790710926056,
-0.3765350580215454,
-0.24988478422164917,
-0.08073291927576065,
-0.8039618134498596,
0.6536096930503845,
0.05190812423825264,
-0.4436541497707367,
0.3753387928009033,
0.6938190460205078,
-0.06818141788244247,
0.04688456282019615,
0.7443814277648926,
0.5300442576408386,
0.7675015330314636,
-0.008760684169828892,
0.743364691734314,
-0.5687442421913147,
-0.3477860689163208,
1.2525253295898438,
-0.2577032446861267,
1.149940013885498,
0.5838578939437866,
-0.13765904307365417,
0.7562716007232666,
0.49346473813056946,
0.21428102254867554,
0.6228973269462585,
0.34818559885025024,
-0.5300191640853882,
0.1270042359828949,
-0.013805214315652847,
-0.14424040913581848,
0.707690417766571,
0.5978085398674011,
-0.3878509998321533,
0.417735755443573,
0.45333290100097656,
-0.19180315732955933,
0.20073184370994568,
-0.056418389081954956,
0.7302342653274536,
0.07654466480016708,
-0.8597714304924011,
0.5308647155761719,
-0.5763379335403442,
0.42067185044288635,
-0.42054733633995056,
-0.020751124247908592,
0.11364752054214478,
-0.005885628052055836,
0.062402527779340744,
-0.9909717440605164,
0.5527385473251343,
-0.3038175702095032,
0.1987205296754837,
-0.7181337475776672,
0.31545066833496094,
-0.8572048544883728,
-0.19834230840206146,
-0.06965460628271103,
0.6143284440040588,
0.6309783458709717,
0.29832935333251953,
-0.5929721593856812,
0.10810934007167816,
-0.2826550006866455,
-0.36713936924934387,
0.12354625016450882,
0.38141104578971863,
0.45919740200042725,
0.19783121347427368,
0.3041013479232788,
0.23979121446609497,
0.22518134117126465,
0.4092692732810974,
0.21684204041957855,
-0.46152612566947937,
-0.6642351150512695,
-0.601367712020874,
0.5168881416320801,
0.00637035584077239,
-0.6159510612487793,
0.788882315158844,
0.5481137037277222,
0.5838067531585693,
-0.2175247073173523,
0.8232014775276184,
-0.17226184904575348,
0.7035905718803406,
-0.6842009425163269,
0.618251383304596,
-0.3972105383872986,
-0.3297167718410492,
-0.23057354986667633,
-0.41002386808395386,
0.18692512810230255,
0.733884871006012,
-0.3138275444507599,
-0.5278962254524231,
1.2437477111816406,
0.7119377255439758,
0.13644951581954956,
0.4529028534889221,
0.393039733171463,
0.24300555884838104,
-0.1047772616147995,
0.3163694143295288,
1.1951581239700317,
-0.044080950319767,
0.38445037603378296,
-0.4220212697982788,
-0.24851398169994354,
-0.030515922233462334,
-0.6561049222946167,
-0.8804288506507874,
-0.8689835667610168,
-0.4770946502685547,
-0.29616737365722656,
0.2454398274421692,
1.0958611965179443,
0.3997079133987427,
-0.6140041351318359,
-0.45453956723213196,
-0.3517482876777649,
-0.2584923207759857,
-0.8941063284873962,
-0.25987374782562256,
0.3788108229637146,
-0.628934383392334,
-1.4057835340499878,
0.8454760313034058,
-0.04449274018406868,
0.4019167423248291,
-0.2829733192920685,
0.3480307161808014,
-0.4790876805782318,
0.13780401647090912,
0.5011379718780518,
0.46784892678260803,
-0.4675692617893219,
-0.3265816271305084,
0.06822271645069122,
-0.09594331681728363,
-0.02962091565132141,
0.762931764125824,
-0.3327394723892212,
0.6672971248626709,
0.6040568351745605,
0.44275420904159546,
0.7287657260894775,
-0.06087561324238777,
0.5450597405433655,
-0.9128699898719788,
0.46875885128974915,
0.5873956084251404,
0.41656455397605896,
-0.053043510764837265,
-0.3492571711540222,
0.5403140783309937,
0.5690255761146545,
-0.5567973256111145,
-0.7976776361465454,
0.2757874131202698,
-1.030371904373169,
-0.18186582624912262,
1.281554937362671,
0.1709018498659134,
-0.27777886390686035,
-0.6208666563034058,
-0.5985327959060669,
0.40429964661598206,
-0.35862475633621216,
0.7111891508102417,
1.2262593507766724,
-0.7989615201950073,
-0.17238719761371613,
-1.2203693389892578,
0.6485069394111633,
0.5442198514938354,
-0.4708895981311798,
-0.1741546392440796,
0.4396858513355255,
0.2721687853336334,
0.006267892196774483,
0.8838605880737305,
0.026969054713845253,
0.27338069677352905,
0.48267826437950134,
0.3611605167388916,
0.03378693386912346,
-0.2081390619277954,
-0.1257709264755249,
-0.023109475150704384,
-0.04311032593250275,
-0.7057642340660095
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.