id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16033v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16033v1
|
Node Classification via Semantic-Structural Attention-Enhanced Graph Convolutional Networks
| 2024-03-24T06:28:54 | 2024-03-24T06:28:54 |
Hongyin Zhu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Graph data, also known as complex network data, is omnipresent across various
domains and applications. Prior graph neural network models primarily focused
on extracting task-specific structural features through supervised learning
objectives, but they fell short in capturing the inherent semantic and
structural features of the entire graph. In this paper, we introduce the
semantic-structural attention-enhanced graph convolutional network (SSA-GCN),
which not only models the graph structure but also extracts generalized
unsupervised features to enhance vertex classification performance. The
SSA-GCN's key contributions lie in three aspects: firstly, it derives semantic
information through unsupervised feature extraction from a knowledge graph
perspective; secondly, it obtains structural information through unsupervised
feature extraction from a complex network perspective; and finally, it
integrates these features through a cross-attention mechanism. By leveraging
these features, we augment the graph convolutional network, thereby enhancing
the model's generalization capabilities. Our experiments on the Cora and
CiteSeer datasets demonstrate the performance improvements achieved by our
proposed method. Furthermore, our approach also exhibits excellent accuracy
under privacy settings, making it a robust and effective solution for graph
data analysis.
|
[
-0.08680818974971771,
-0.7576399445533752,
0.3044101595878601,
-0.2442757785320282,
-0.4194171726703644,
0.4602828621864319,
0.12865258753299713,
-0.8108742833137512,
0.36734405159950256,
0.32670462131500244,
-0.21813304722309113,
-0.8755828142166138,
-0.7597566843032837,
-0.17397518455982208,
-0.3446924388408661,
0.762062668800354,
0.1384684294462204,
0.04375873878598213,
-0.17040260136127472,
-0.023075779899954796,
-0.1989985555410385,
-0.3748247027397156,
-0.7979131937026978,
-0.23598848283290863,
0.8233401775360107,
0.13127854466438293,
0.6906465291976929,
0.6679512858390808,
0.3611619174480438,
0.43734803795814514,
-0.19412755966186523,
0.5039837956428528,
-0.4581924080848694,
-0.3264073431491852,
-0.2436111569404602,
-0.05557246878743172,
-0.48196789622306824,
-0.2043677717447281,
0.7555660605430603,
1.0679067373275757,
0.5191656351089478,
0.15712527930736542,
0.39396995306015015,
0.6172056794166565,
-0.6222164630889893,
0.876829981803894,
-0.5813610553741455,
0.11568833142518997,
-0.17230701446533203,
-0.059684593230485916,
-0.3080339729785919,
-0.3117552399635315,
0.21489106118679047,
-0.574768602848053,
0.42334091663360596,
0.2157849371433258,
0.9616610407829285,
0.07256648689508438,
-0.5741798877716064,
0.09480362385511398,
-0.46713584661483765,
0.07923506945371628,
-0.04650566354393959,
0.4747842848300934,
0.05035596713423729,
0.35524263978004456,
-0.2885061204433441,
-0.9331976771354675,
-0.20708657801151276,
0.13197167217731476,
-0.22813254594802856,
0.2910063564777374,
-0.3295593857765198,
0.3371104300022125,
0.1526227593421936,
0.3385425806045532,
-0.38550806045532227,
0.031843625009059906,
-0.5761167407035828,
-0.3795420229434967,
0.376116544008255,
0.03185926005244255,
0.3676879405975342,
-0.20752713084220886,
-0.302365243434906,
-0.022574132308363914,
-0.46421486139297485,
0.290486216545105,
0.3706710934638977,
0.7599095106124878,
0.0545739084482193,
0.6384482383728027,
-0.7339016795158386,
0.6069799065589905,
0.007382174488157034,
0.3019927442073822,
0.515632688999176,
-0.3965829908847809,
-0.3245408236980438,
0.30255016684532166,
0.7038885354995728,
0.1708686649799347,
0.23360387980937958,
-0.6273638606071472,
0.37961262464523315,
0.41967320442199707,
0.25916779041290283,
-0.8220749497413635,
-0.39015015959739685,
0.06977933645248413,
-0.39645916223526,
-0.3222532272338867,
0.07541652023792267,
-0.35862448811531067,
-0.13621404767036438,
-0.2919365465641022,
-0.04404345899820328,
-0.11183301359415054,
-0.12604030966758728,
0.17946498095989227,
-0.37278926372528076,
-0.20314596593379974,
0.33669474720954895,
-0.3230191767215729,
0.4482570290565491,
0.6340399384498596,
1.0263378620147705,
-0.20467700064182281,
0.09660620987415314,
-0.7863144278526306,
0.40921351313591003,
-0.19894714653491974,
0.7173749208450317,
-0.5860200524330139,
0.009131453931331635,
-0.1831924468278885,
0.5936416983604431,
-0.31189095973968506,
-0.09486299008131027,
0.2625715732574463,
-0.6874464750289917,
-0.10701651126146317,
0.1491091549396515,
-0.37958773970603943,
-0.4724685251712799,
0.30252087116241455,
-0.6390659809112549,
0.7892802953720093,
0.33942028880119324,
-1.0781155824661255,
0.22906094789505005,
-0.4373566508293152,
-0.49631404876708984,
0.3137267529964447,
-0.2878212332725525,
-0.5945788025856018,
-0.11094316095113754,
0.11472797393798828,
0.6976064443588257,
-0.22014987468719482,
0.09984055161476135,
-0.8296585083007812,
-0.1545511931180954,
0.027075625956058502,
0.10878396034240723,
0.572842538356781,
-0.07759913802146912,
-0.052636757493019104,
0.3499119281768799,
-0.880506694316864,
0.21865741908550262,
0.23420113325119019,
-0.06170771270990372,
-0.366678923368454,
-0.23974253237247467,
-0.17030523717403412,
0.26795902848243713,
0.12512317299842834,
-0.9843350052833557,
-0.3304775357246399,
-0.6331972479820251,
0.6032567620277405,
0.6765897274017334,
0.07135316729545593,
0.47882241010665894,
0.1290002167224884,
0.15185008943080902,
-0.022014113143086433,
0.15781301259994507,
0.5710680484771729,
-0.4527069926261902,
-0.2710872292518616,
-0.36997997760772705,
0.44058674573898315,
0.4519406259059906,
-0.4877471327781677,
0.5537406206130981,
-0.4181683361530304,
-0.48517000675201416,
-0.0704599991440773,
0.11376456171274185,
0.4796920418739319,
0.905427873134613,
0.31789764761924744,
-0.510469377040863,
-0.18722903728485107,
-0.7385252118110657,
0.09865447878837585,
0.058299604803323746,
0.029069634154438972,
0.684798538684845,
0.20040957629680634,
-0.16749964654445648,
0.9027629494667053,
-0.6672057509422302,
-0.44705691933631897,
-0.27388933300971985,
-0.21748653054237366,
0.06146036833524704,
0.3199593722820282,
0.2937687933444977,
-0.8312891125679016,
-0.487998902797699,
0.5434039235115051,
-0.7000065445899963,
0.2463296800851822,
0.40618184208869934,
-0.32854050397872925,
-0.4275578260421753,
0.33367466926574707,
-0.46758514642715454,
0.6031542420387268,
0.1917542815208435,
-0.24514104425907135,
0.22325636446475983,
0.03508862107992172,
-0.3236311078071594,
-0.9419899582862854,
0.01187133975327015,
-0.0006213266751728952,
-0.590224027633667,
-0.2217320054769516,
-0.278102844953537,
0.0425293929874897,
-0.4601002037525177,
-0.3557470142841339,
0.3616006374359131,
-0.5961604118347168,
-0.4822199046611786,
-0.09913934022188187,
0.43085968494415283,
0.17029154300689697,
0.862695038318634,
-0.01282940711826086,
0.025874070823192596,
0.7483713030815125,
-0.6256502866744995,
0.753757119178772,
0.3607969582080841,
0.0610005185008049,
0.30685704946517944,
-0.7681323885917664,
0.3645073473453522,
-0.17964544892311096,
0.26541057229042053,
-1.296372890472412,
-0.31878572702407837,
0.6946595907211304,
-0.5976666808128357,
0.577759325504303,
-0.5770758986473083,
-0.44901227951049805,
-0.5247196555137634,
-0.27224287390708923,
0.21475495398044586,
-0.1752183735370636,
-0.520983874797821,
0.7233337163925171,
0.45185986161231995,
0.15130653977394104,
-0.43740013241767883,
-0.39100414514541626,
-0.20657899975776672,
0.13887479901313782,
-0.6777858138084412,
0.502001166343689,
0.3219216763973236,
0.5513632297515869,
0.5629152655601501,
-0.32947978377342224,
0.14335420727729797,
0.2601923942565918,
0.6525672674179077,
0.20351481437683105,
0.031788721680641174,
0.2783645987510681,
0.31865817308425903,
-0.47368383407592773,
-0.12225355952978134,
-0.5509464740753174,
0.5602177381515503,
-0.11492402106523514,
-0.2862741947174072,
-0.5865048766136169,
0.1983608603477478,
0.3254486620426178,
-0.5978268980979919,
0.3097441494464874,
0.5372814536094666,
-0.371097594499588,
-0.03491264581680298,
0.055357884615659714,
0.005389511119574308,
-0.4497374892234802,
0.7713203430175781,
-0.26159071922302246,
-1.1124922037124634,
0.6148520708084106,
-0.6076051592826843,
-0.49607181549072266,
0.49834704399108887,
-0.1025913655757904,
-0.1472996324300766,
1.1592848300933838,
0.46727266907691956,
-0.25316599011421204,
0.672339916229248,
-0.5255676507949829,
0.148324653506279,
-1.1581007242202759,
-0.48420900106430054,
-0.6515811085700989,
-0.5579628944396973,
-0.6816511750221252,
-0.09923430532217026,
0.21674422919750214,
0.16554969549179077,
-0.3248518407344818,
0.29075461626052856,
-0.8925142884254456,
0.3769107460975647,
-0.10181582719087601,
0.6556217670440674,
-0.018951604142785072,
0.26488280296325684,
-0.06501691788434982,
0.4665217697620392,
-0.7747527360916138,
-0.07296344637870789,
0.9132540225982666,
0.46456438302993774,
0.4749465584754944,
-0.21599309146404266,
0.32503125071525574,
0.226250559091568,
0.1464226096868515,
-0.7143980860710144,
0.553718090057373,
-0.4374143183231354,
-0.06844911724328995,
-0.5019596815109253,
-0.6608251333236694,
-1.0430963039398193,
0.20286835730075836,
-0.10525663197040558,
-0.8193507790565491,
0.5251452922821045,
0.02385997585952282,
-0.19122298061847687,
0.14230243861675262,
-0.6790223121643066,
1.1303337812423706,
-0.1024450957775116,
-0.17036424577236176,
-0.12540745735168457,
-0.7130737900733948,
-0.11498933285474777,
0.38315486907958984,
-0.023024560883641243,
-0.21000686287879944,
0.068505197763443,
0.43655502796173096,
-0.370925635099411,
1.1342113018035889,
-0.2710774838924408,
0.5837635397911072,
0.3014088273048401,
-0.2989296317100525,
0.8997660875320435,
0.073723204433918,
0.3792436718940735,
0.3361069858074188,
-0.6925069689750671,
-0.37190955877304077,
-0.7097111940383911,
0.4759112596511841,
-0.7841191291809082,
-0.34882673621177673,
-0.026750970631837845,
-0.3633797764778137,
-0.34946098923683167,
0.3974299430847168,
0.1409759223461151,
0.7574892044067383,
-0.07386300712823868,
0.36151519417762756,
0.4458845555782318,
0.3863184452056885,
0.17185692489147186,
-0.07509058713912964,
0.0320904515683651,
-0.5217442512512207,
0.9638601541519165,
0.5172476172447205,
0.3270666301250458,
0.2846141457557678,
0.30677470564842224,
-0.48564308881759644,
-0.7615521550178528,
-0.4197424054145813,
0.22784388065338135,
-0.7322756052017212,
-0.38104692101478577,
-1.136892557144165,
-0.5166600346565247,
-0.5572016835212708,
0.09603913873434067,
-0.1457783281803131,
-0.4237504005432129,
-0.3406861424446106,
-0.5260699391365051,
0.4333231449127197,
0.25535571575164795,
0.3544464707374573,
0.4998810589313507,
-0.6173428893089294,
0.24527935683727264,
0.3912551701068878,
0.2689892053604126,
0.138383686542511,
-0.16304978728294373,
-0.16837966442108154,
-0.24209553003311157,
-0.0983554944396019,
-0.837375283241272,
-0.07777358591556549,
0.314939022064209,
0.6764205098152161,
0.33903369307518005,
0.05981579050421715,
0.42774713039398193,
-0.1123889833688736,
-0.03968103229999542,
0.27276918292045593,
-0.6583206057548523,
0.529615581035614,
-0.19568905234336853,
0.02664169669151306,
0.3310143053531647,
0.4614703953266144,
-0.27489185333251953,
-0.430194228887558,
-0.6182489395141602,
-0.8530551195144653,
0.7688947319984436,
0.055223848670721054,
0.017917854711413383,
-0.14012591540813446,
0.5652090907096863,
-0.4303358495235443,
0.1530587375164032,
-0.4568341374397278,
0.04399274289608002,
-0.403841108083725,
-0.3013943135738373,
0.3679816424846649,
0.08650008589029312,
-0.005125397350639105,
-0.23597405850887299,
0.3785066306591034,
-0.7106093168258667,
-0.03156718239188194,
0.34713253378868103,
-0.17654594779014587,
0.050521370023489,
-0.06960318982601166,
-0.08252403140068054,
0.5809782147407532,
-0.07794874161481857,
0.30713537335395813,
0.30463093519210815,
-0.4943320155143738,
-0.09225677698850632,
0.3295271694660187,
-0.3039547801017761,
-0.14653298258781433,
0.2935139238834381,
0.7263948321342468,
0.22643668949604034,
0.1408509910106659,
0.4428342282772064,
-0.1033509224653244,
0.11933542788028717,
0.03655453398823738,
0.31847965717315674,
0.22514136135578156,
0.4434717893600464,
0.04858631640672684,
0.1648511290550232,
0.4473867118358612,
-0.5177163481712341,
0.12634442746639252,
0.5326117873191833,
-0.8538064956665039,
-0.3105520009994507,
0.3501170873641968,
0.12288808822631836,
-0.10463473200798035,
0.5198786854743958,
-0.23928482830524445,
-0.6172579526901245,
0.9166492819786072,
0.5478500723838806,
0.9005361795425415,
-0.19123131036758423,
0.4085390269756317,
0.4374782145023346,
-0.019697951152920723,
0.461431086063385,
0.09768226742744446,
-0.36669930815696716,
-0.9096784591674805,
-0.1945929080247879,
-0.5169885158538818,
-0.06642889231443405,
-0.27298474311828613,
-0.41302067041397095,
-0.0740533396601677,
-0.8211345672607422,
-0.20501336455345154,
0.2641425132751465,
0.07992035895586014,
-0.6321043372154236,
0.41810569167137146,
-0.2672778367996216,
0.45952242612838745,
-0.7791547179222107,
0.731037974357605,
0.6327493190765381,
-0.2570679485797882,
-0.761459469795227,
-0.6200643181800842,
-0.3685148060321808,
-0.5594333410263062,
0.696837842464447,
0.42063602805137634,
-0.5124565362930298,
0.1522981822490692,
-0.5691825151443481,
-0.8096309304237366,
1.1043450832366943,
0.2694002091884613,
-0.41836121678352356,
0.019591040909290314,
0.25817546248435974,
0.39598938822746277,
-0.7501495480537415,
-0.02778317779302597,
-0.00798004399985075,
0.23694825172424316,
0.4430292844772339,
-0.3530966341495514,
0.24992194771766663,
-0.35638612508773804,
0.173463374376297,
0.12505145370960236,
-0.8312055468559265,
0.5912322998046875,
-0.0435502752661705,
-0.5524612665176392,
-0.7392388582229614,
0.8973861932754517,
-0.11532793939113617,
0.32009461522102356,
0.7227191925048828,
0.47461381554603577,
1.0055192708969116,
-0.09491060674190521,
0.9631220698356628,
-0.031911902129650116,
0.2856317162513733,
1.0903427600860596,
-0.24547015130519867,
0.3891770839691162,
-0.20074120163917542,
-0.05039307847619057,
0.31224456429481506,
0.9260172843933105,
0.06666531413793564,
0.5076934695243835,
0.2794817388057709,
0.1522403061389923,
-0.4432808756828308,
-0.4682791531085968,
-0.3851410150527954,
0.35442110896110535,
0.27106261253356934,
-0.3187878727912903,
-0.495567262172699,
-0.011952427215874195,
0.007924611680209637,
-0.15423810482025146,
-0.5639011263847351,
0.7228533625602722,
0.04910117760300636,
0.20641592144966125,
-0.03292180597782135,
-0.15436512231826782,
0.08393774926662445,
-0.5928043127059937,
0.007061963435262442,
0.12186542898416519,
0.2450648993253708,
-0.4593327045440674,
-0.6068609952926636,
0.5001137256622314,
-0.3423074185848236,
-0.4404637813568115,
0.23693709075450897,
1.1433112621307373,
-0.30255401134490967,
-0.47631263732910156,
0.8330472111701965,
-0.03283786028623581,
0.06894321739673615,
-0.422153502702713,
-0.5335410833358765,
-0.1577574908733368,
-0.40072712302207947,
0.21680870652198792,
0.43114012479782104,
0.6871176362037659,
-0.34711864590644836,
0.42227065563201904,
0.8651427030563354,
-0.05209047719836235,
-0.06299684941768646,
0.20303846895694733,
1.406849980354309,
-0.3472740650177002,
-0.8470422029495239,
-0.5545718669891357,
0.37007832527160645,
-0.49869030714035034,
-0.13258640468120575,
0.7214601635932922,
0.7285599708557129,
0.9631306529045105,
0.3158267140388489,
0.4679460823535919,
0.2735932469367981,
0.2705792188644409,
-0.4100179076194763,
0.6261071562767029,
-0.3486361801624298,
-0.38436359167099,
-0.4335731863975525,
-0.9082496166229248,
-0.299206018447876,
0.2906976044178009,
-0.4045567214488983,
0.06847919523715973,
0.6228160858154297,
0.6074562668800354,
-0.17540466785430908,
-0.0031939197797328234,
0.0969092845916748,
0.09540201723575592,
0.3047143220901489,
0.54362952709198,
0.6086893081665039,
-0.41547203063964844,
0.5440112948417664,
-0.09577173739671707,
-0.3696744740009308,
-0.021228887140750885,
-0.6205520033836365,
-0.9422026872634888,
-0.30505573749542236,
-0.5759073495864868,
-0.4418156147003174,
0.07526905089616776,
0.5014132261276245,
0.7700850963592529,
-0.6417698264122009,
0.3176618218421936,
-0.22537867724895477,
0.5113381743431091,
-0.11934656649827957,
-0.13632845878601074,
1.1227725744247437,
-0.35109415650367737,
-0.3806874752044678,
0.31932052969932556,
0.5706110596656799,
-0.045426804572343826,
0.1280042976140976,
0.11698617041110992,
-0.05129064619541168,
-0.3333236873149872,
0.521560788154602,
0.22922149300575256,
-0.11817087233066559,
-0.5975655913352966,
-0.05985354632139206,
-0.04201109707355499,
0.07517514377832413,
0.5276888012886047,
-0.47856763005256653,
0.512851893901825,
0.7983707785606384,
0.8178557753562927,
0.7593958973884583,
0.24492378532886505,
-0.016791388392448425,
-0.8818302154541016,
0.10435006022453308,
0.010161287151277065,
0.36868688464164734,
0.27173760533332825,
-0.8641596436500549,
0.42711082100868225,
0.6239299178123474,
-0.20220787823200226,
-0.4540969431400299,
0.1861710399389267,
-1.2177444696426392,
-0.10753926634788513,
0.746829628944397,
-0.3722997009754181,
-0.9453540444374084,
-0.6229299306869507,
-0.04866328835487366,
0.6074622869491577,
-0.37849876284599304,
0.3559240698814392,
0.2551565170288086,
-0.15637671947479248,
0.03909861296415329,
-0.07639510184526443,
0.29060614109039307,
-0.185773104429245,
-0.9369162917137146,
0.16909486055374146,
0.3419118821620941,
0.22498734295368195,
0.41573840379714966,
0.5360333323478699,
-0.37631988525390625,
0.2978418469429016,
-0.15019257366657257,
-0.0924006998538971,
-0.5989429950714111,
-0.818244993686676,
0.013660799711942673,
0.654645562171936,
-0.45211127400398254,
-0.6102742552757263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16008v1
|
CBT-LLM: A Chinese Large Language Model for Cognitive Behavioral Therapy-based Mental Health Question Answering
| 2024-03-24T04:34:34 | 2024-03-24T04:34:34 |
Hongbin Na
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent advancements in artificial intelligence highlight the potential of
language models in psychological health support. While models trained on data
from mental health service platform have achieved preliminary success,
challenges persist in areas such as data scarcity, quality, and ensuring a
solid foundation in psychological techniques. To address these challenges, this
study introduces a novel approach to enhance the precision and efficacy of
psychological support through large language models. Specifically, we design a
specific prompt derived from principles of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)
and have generated the CBT QA dataset, specifically for Chinese psychological
health Q&A based on CBT structured intervention strategies. Unlike previous
methods, our dataset emphasizes professional and structured response. Utilizing
this dataset, we fine-tuned the large language model, giving birth to CBT-LLM,
the large-scale language model specifically designed for Cognitive Behavioral
Therapy techniques. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that CBT-LLM excels in
generating structured, professional, and highly relevant responses in
psychological health support tasks, showcasing its practicality and quality.
The model is available on Hugging Face:
https://huggingface.co/Hongbin37/CBT-LLM.
|
[
-0.13233508169651031,
-1.1933494806289673,
0.8439366221427917,
0.6778354048728943,
-0.2686731815338135,
-0.04663991183042526,
-0.4740729331970215,
-0.43971705436706543,
0.14612771570682526,
0.4744950234889984,
-0.8840042352676392,
-0.4265471398830414,
-0.4782983958721161,
0.042367465794086456,
0.03233284130692482,
1.0257800817489624,
0.10068001598119736,
0.50986647605896,
0.07954218983650208,
0.2560468018054962,
-0.8507562875747681,
-0.629770815372467,
-1.0201798677444458,
-0.30674731731414795,
0.7334917783737183,
0.08203427493572235,
0.6124899983406067,
0.15836752951145172,
0.4907791018486023,
0.1169983297586441,
-0.053978338837623596,
0.018561391159892082,
-0.23534542322158813,
-0.07425753027200699,
-0.049273014068603516,
-0.43301665782928467,
-0.709533154964447,
-0.2069590985774994,
0.36164790391921997,
0.59767085313797,
-0.49599069356918335,
0.043971866369247437,
0.12286119163036346,
0.4627096354961395,
-0.03221379965543747,
0.23544520139694214,
-0.5167948007583618,
-0.0036624004133045673,
-0.00257733347825706,
0.16806785762310028,
-0.3786649703979492,
-0.5681045055389404,
0.007855282165110111,
-0.46195560693740845,
-0.13919909298419952,
-0.1682601273059845,
0.4657968580722809,
0.2018464058637619,
-0.7315160632133484,
-0.09230335801839828,
-0.5892524123191833,
0.452899694442749,
-0.8835389614105225,
0.09487433731555939,
0.443898469209671,
0.4088190793991089,
-0.23042547702789307,
-0.4880473017692566,
-0.36719512939453125,
-0.43065816164016724,
-0.026456385850906372,
0.23924940824508667,
0.08842652291059494,
0.2181014120578766,
0.19747424125671387,
0.18552207946777344,
-0.8126873970031738,
-0.10413875430822372,
-0.12083341181278229,
-0.28261882066726685,
0.7516289949417114,
0.5312116146087646,
0.46308043599128723,
0.06365704536437988,
-0.07743139564990997,
0.32016295194625854,
-0.3690488934516907,
0.3008507192134857,
-0.3448977470397949,
0.337947279214859,
-0.16923855245113373,
0.6453539133071899,
-0.23146840929985046,
0.5800904631614685,
0.19807539880275726,
-0.37829744815826416,
-0.29818063974380493,
-0.17938350141048431,
-0.18411150574684143,
0.03564891964197159,
0.7427550554275513,
0.32008546590805054,
0.19992049038410187,
-0.1735062450170517,
-0.00819062627851963,
0.03995272144675255,
0.2941221296787262,
-0.871098518371582,
-0.1505412608385086,
0.4566640853881836,
-0.48137426376342773,
-0.08432970941066742,
-0.13524247705936432,
-0.2608257234096527,
-0.4650912582874298,
-0.3305564820766449,
-0.0010899639455601573,
-0.6566433310508728,
-0.4773625433444977,
0.3274087905883789,
0.22475923597812653,
0.44669944047927856,
0.4105002284049988,
-0.6978420615196228,
0.18460756540298462,
0.6404794454574585,
0.629966676235199,
-0.11154914647340775,
0.2861412465572357,
-0.2684706449508667,
0.28791603446006775,
-0.41911324858665466,
0.7510247230529785,
-0.5083926320075989,
-0.2858755886554718,
0.18742303550243378,
0.1292218714952469,
0.17985263466835022,
-0.517076849937439,
0.5341498851776123,
-0.3501196503639221,
0.27024003863334656,
-0.6581225395202637,
-0.3509824573993683,
-0.03361610695719719,
0.6648954153060913,
-0.36748582124710083,
1.012907862663269,
0.2376742660999298,
-0.6946590542793274,
-0.03954314813017845,
-0.6684225797653198,
-0.5464804172515869,
0.30638638138771057,
-0.12994123995304108,
-0.024387618526816368,
0.05657379701733589,
0.45132800936698914,
0.43695545196533203,
-0.5601184368133545,
0.46903935074806213,
-0.6192848086357117,
-0.2173355519771576,
0.6809546947479248,
-0.3376009166240692,
0.9962445497512817,
0.18144604563713074,
-0.032895274460315704,
0.21100248396396637,
-0.5960674285888672,
0.17244258522987366,
0.4243735671043396,
-0.4695788621902466,
-0.16214720904827118,
-0.21818147599697113,
0.24997209012508392,
0.47244352102279663,
0.5801968574523926,
-0.67839115858078,
0.28945595026016235,
-0.18898668885231018,
0.5287640690803528,
0.5599817037582397,
0.2524109184741974,
-0.157953679561615,
-0.5887076258659363,
0.7517465949058533,
-0.15821340680122375,
0.31088459491729736,
-0.03936469554901123,
-0.5262542963027954,
0.08589518815279007,
-0.7012283802032471,
-0.2787742614746094,
0.7569007873535156,
-0.6301866173744202,
0.4447382986545563,
-0.05314227193593979,
-0.5775901079177856,
-0.356614351272583,
-0.011922514997422695,
0.2767064869403839,
0.5178537368774414,
0.3154034912586212,
-0.18048594892024994,
-0.4275848865509033,
-0.6807833313941956,
-0.12876830995082855,
-0.22626036405563354,
-0.15937212109565735,
0.2827748656272888,
-0.01927313022315502,
-0.18711644411087036,
0.8014780879020691,
-0.6578643918037415,
-0.07314295321702957,
-0.3304038643836975,
-0.1861211657524109,
0.19176140427589417,
0.19020098447799683,
0.3115217387676239,
-0.5687994360923767,
-0.4988519549369812,
-0.17111869156360626,
-0.8735079765319824,
-0.310916543006897,
-0.020844459533691406,
-0.45897483825683594,
-0.06488081067800522,
0.3082534074783325,
-0.6600571274757385,
0.06667767465114594,
0.36849939823150635,
-0.2902272045612335,
0.865103006362915,
0.07534082978963852,
-0.022007791325449944,
-1.1945369243621826,
0.09340018033981323,
-0.09762881696224213,
-0.1791391223669052,
-0.5677213668823242,
0.10597459226846695,
0.1204676404595375,
-0.2332332879304886,
-0.5261242985725403,
0.4308304786682129,
-0.05853249132633209,
0.4974731504917145,
-0.5006675720214844,
0.2566528618335724,
-0.2018631547689438,
0.6267760992050171,
0.26470518112182617,
0.3779170513153076,
0.4562869071960449,
-0.44498342275619507,
0.7398924827575684,
0.42379799485206604,
0.011054597795009613,
1.0672794580459595,
-0.7467367649078369,
0.16106149554252625,
0.07689827680587769,
0.6118264198303223,
-1.0155872106552124,
-0.20486858487129211,
0.29216259717941284,
-0.32112276554107666,
0.15544672310352325,
0.22840893268585205,
-0.6061685681343079,
-0.6236947774887085,
-0.07941487431526184,
0.5897159576416016,
0.2929486632347107,
-0.23177523910999298,
0.30609527230262756,
0.08656808733940125,
-0.38441261649131775,
-0.3699767291545868,
-0.623258113861084,
0.11330240964889526,
-0.33650436997413635,
-0.8237838745117188,
0.27460813522338867,
-0.5693038105964661,
-0.07002349197864532,
-0.1271849274635315,
-0.0456695593893528,
-0.03503667563199997,
0.1733943670988083,
0.02124304510653019,
0.31743931770324707,
-0.4199230372905731,
0.3441431522369385,
-0.026350270956754684,
0.04194255545735359,
0.41263359785079956,
-0.3533639907836914,
0.6583427786827087,
-0.08818459510803223,
-0.3052520751953125,
-0.4824484586715698,
0.4744809865951538,
0.24789857864379883,
-0.35444995760917664,
0.8158149719238281,
0.6123355627059937,
-0.6753497123718262,
0.1589837521314621,
-0.4933265149593353,
-0.2685721814632416,
-0.419135183095932,
0.5872748494148254,
-0.2214875966310501,
-0.8713200092315674,
0.34747618436813354,
0.18889835476875305,
-0.08712261915206909,
-0.12666058540344238,
0.8966252207756042,
-0.06985609233379364,
1.407566785812378,
0.5079835653305054,
-0.24032458662986755,
0.6097772121429443,
0.29169324040412903,
0.30356377363204956,
-0.7803794741630554,
-0.04058687388896942,
-0.18275055289268494,
-0.03059888444840908,
-0.3927820324897766,
-0.1554894745349884,
0.47105470299720764,
-0.0822458565235138,
-0.5879756808280945,
0.11031506955623627,
-0.6542555093765259,
-0.3717656135559082,
0.21318316459655762,
0.8274065256118774,
0.2738482356071472,
-0.42655444145202637,
-0.12715497612953186,
-0.13218626379966736,
-0.47681933641433716,
-0.4091810882091522,
0.7837048768997192,
0.3371376693248749,
0.6780733466148376,
0.2816694378852844,
0.2715853452682495,
0.011596329510211945,
0.5770564675331116,
-0.9103075861930847,
0.5961039662361145,
0.12052366137504578,
-0.8732612729072571,
-0.41139402985572815,
-0.13424897193908691,
-0.9701324105262756,
0.0690188854932785,
-0.16792964935302734,
-0.7464689612388611,
-0.41439417004585266,
-0.0021070512011647224,
-0.38395652174949646,
-0.05485095456242561,
-0.21264034509658813,
0.7073627710342407,
-0.4787546396255493,
-0.12462349236011505,
-0.24913641810417175,
-0.5034422278404236,
0.7310041785240173,
-0.28687846660614014,
0.19629241526126862,
-0.27838125824928284,
0.09349187463521957,
0.5634076595306396,
-0.4128199815750122,
0.7907411456108093,
-0.1610596626996994,
-0.5126634240150452,
0.2464434951543808,
0.04953067749738693,
0.4472339451313019,
0.322037935256958,
-0.13205669820308685,
-0.3519423305988312,
0.4855231046676636,
-0.8433599472045898,
-0.8283668160438538,
0.38290441036224365,
-0.643500804901123,
-0.8804029226303101,
-0.14194950461387634,
-0.7237480282783508,
-0.5247681140899658,
0.19875521957874298,
-0.020238250494003296,
0.3679952621459961,
-0.35717031359672546,
0.11006079614162445,
0.6439075469970703,
-0.6660360097885132,
0.09145661443471909,
0.8222062587738037,
-0.35646992921829224,
-0.4715050756931305,
0.47723570466041565,
-0.18392598628997803,
0.0367342047393322,
0.5375062227249146,
0.3483887016773224,
-0.1949099749326706,
-0.3426286280155182,
0.04936562106013298,
0.7124677300453186,
-0.506641685962677,
-0.14656637609004974,
-0.5186262726783752,
-0.35903578996658325,
-0.7061209678649902,
-0.1313411444425583,
-0.15939611196517944,
0.039438311010599136,
0.2798846364021301,
-0.2832828164100647,
0.5434278845787048,
0.4821995794773102,
0.16931943595409393,
0.35083064436912537,
-0.896126925945282,
0.40840741991996765,
0.1353922039270401,
0.3229247033596039,
0.13051457703113556,
-0.19478511810302734,
-0.5690971612930298,
0.2363513857126236,
-0.4558967351913452,
-1.1442588567733765,
0.3377828598022461,
-0.2970251142978668,
0.46700572967529297,
0.37346208095550537,
0.41026875376701355,
0.6438668966293335,
-0.2584143280982971,
1.0128796100616455,
0.22171640396118164,
-0.7598360180854797,
0.6713657975196838,
-0.6536933183670044,
0.36417901515960693,
0.0719563439488411,
0.18115946650505066,
-1.040185809135437,
-0.673504114151001,
-0.35418567061424255,
-0.756892740726471,
0.5960251092910767,
-0.0988275408744812,
0.27174654603004456,
-0.3078756332397461,
0.5996182560920715,
-0.18266697227954865,
0.14459429681301117,
-0.8597169518470764,
-0.14444981515407562,
-0.11551495641469955,
-0.7293821573257446,
0.10355544090270996,
-0.13153700530529022,
-0.36278223991394043,
0.056014977395534515,
0.7243994474411011,
-0.3590589463710785,
0.49010345339775085,
0.43811091780662537,
-0.10974764823913574,
-0.19771377742290497,
0.26341718435287476,
0.21572166681289673,
0.40047383308410645,
-0.08769471198320389,
-0.13877631723880768,
0.2602580487728119,
-0.45361363887786865,
0.1063382625579834,
0.05989198014140129,
0.11259446293115616,
-0.4836254119873047,
0.3439330458641052,
0.38408470153808594,
0.03128247708082199,
-1.040808916091919,
0.3804076611995697,
-0.16691277921199799,
-0.01672552153468132,
-0.5041991472244263,
0.00010028343967860565,
0.3997171223163605,
0.38650041818618774,
0.3457507789134979,
-0.8337931036949158,
0.056435465812683105,
-0.5858319401741028,
0.18730053305625916,
0.6872521042823792,
-0.4653874933719635,
-0.2879573702812195,
0.7648338675498962,
-0.1637469232082367,
-0.38462692499160767,
0.7743659615516663,
0.2310013771057129,
-0.4317053556442261,
0.6617671847343445,
0.7854037284851074,
0.4650755226612091,
-0.15770865976810455,
0.3418806493282318,
0.37064144015312195,
0.15298214554786682,
0.008596749044954777,
0.4901263415813446,
0.0778987780213356,
-0.6782596111297607,
-0.35035884380340576,
-0.1508818119764328,
-0.331108421087265,
0.2560989558696747,
-0.9096996188163757,
0.31348177790641785,
-0.7448252439498901,
-0.2404797375202179,
-0.30497828125953674,
0.41780221462249756,
-0.6563065052032471,
0.5039447546005249,
0.5113425254821777,
0.9551033973693848,
-0.5541878938674927,
1.0807454586029053,
0.8773135542869568,
-0.6400378942489624,
-1.0948811769485474,
0.24194291234016418,
-0.028879540041089058,
-1.1123058795928955,
0.21748989820480347,
0.11335761845111847,
0.26353463530540466,
-0.12519584596157074,
-0.7198705077171326,
-0.8176258206367493,
1.179140329360962,
0.5197970271110535,
-0.1461164355278015,
-0.09726924449205399,
0.272724449634552,
0.8087084293365479,
-0.35450881719589233,
0.4424060881137848,
0.48186489939689636,
0.6535452604293823,
-0.11608552932739258,
-0.7667913436889648,
0.6888098120689392,
-0.18009300529956818,
0.19125041365623474,
-0.30905768275260925,
-1.0577324628829956,
0.31040918827056885,
-0.14576764404773712,
-0.024852808564901352,
0.44184091687202454,
0.7074446082115173,
0.7563313841819763,
0.21010415256023407,
0.3682037591934204,
-0.02301000989973545,
0.9584300518035889,
0.09869939088821411,
0.8858084678649902,
-0.4702429175376892,
0.13915078341960907,
0.894358217716217,
-0.3323442339897156,
0.6699702739715576,
0.2061130553483963,
-0.3606577217578888,
0.544715940952301,
1.0151604413986206,
-0.010546114295721054,
0.33726248145103455,
0.2133464515209198,
-0.28925827145576477,
-0.32409554719924927,
-0.3743846118450165,
-0.20270615816116333,
0.041629042476415634,
0.4449778199195862,
0.09627754241228104,
0.13857333362102509,
0.17949311435222626,
0.14995330572128296,
0.18113410472869873,
-0.19395332038402557,
0.6872307062149048,
0.41306042671203613,
-0.7010369300842285,
0.5176661014556885,
0.11933856457471848,
0.5640701651573181,
-0.785039484500885,
0.26597797870635986,
-0.38020557165145874,
-0.06609579920768738,
-0.07393937557935715,
-0.6402426362037659,
0.2841487228870392,
-0.10864408314228058,
-0.2797117233276367,
0.059374820441007614,
0.3599773645401001,
-0.6147252321243286,
-0.6009997725486755,
0.46996915340423584,
0.44674283266067505,
0.0912795290350914,
-0.3514993190765381,
-0.927158772945404,
-0.25910452008247375,
-0.2271900773048401,
-0.31821465492248535,
0.4661860764026642,
0.7635833621025085,
-0.4380894601345062,
0.7477625012397766,
0.6126938462257385,
0.014611249789595604,
-0.14097429811954498,
0.057552270591259,
0.6512773036956787,
-0.9986966848373413,
-0.5871236324310303,
-0.6251887083053589,
0.3235807418823242,
0.29592999815940857,
0.08855175226926804,
0.44700267910957336,
0.1267634630203247,
0.22000691294670105,
0.14389148354530334,
0.9575533270835876,
-0.008617427200078964,
0.563953161239624,
-0.3653382956981659,
0.42273852229118347,
-0.6387516856193542,
0.09354224801063538,
-0.20023317635059357,
-0.5910325646400452,
-0.3894816040992737,
0.3055601119995117,
-0.4761103689670563,
0.2414940744638443,
0.820215106010437,
0.8589110374450684,
0.3940540552139282,
0.035175442695617676,
0.35010915994644165,
0.5844839811325073,
0.6854307651519775,
0.947576105594635,
0.8130308985710144,
-0.08270532637834549,
0.5977803468704224,
-0.22183609008789062,
-0.19870208203792572,
-0.09795401990413666,
-0.7139011025428772,
-0.748665988445282,
-0.3534962832927704,
-0.31754425168037415,
-0.46289756894111633,
-0.03490445762872696,
1.2327721118927002,
0.6514047980308533,
-0.6956927180290222,
-0.04656066745519638,
0.2113141119480133,
-0.17680320143699646,
-0.7250808477401733,
-0.3259330689907074,
0.39306890964508057,
-0.2420348972082138,
-0.4645217955112457,
0.12831062078475952,
-0.009569335728883743,
-0.19749362766742706,
-0.1444064825773239,
-0.017281869426369667,
0.051089104264974594,
0.3430350124835968,
0.625350296497345,
0.06014899164438248,
-0.842444658279419,
-0.17499569058418274,
0.33833152055740356,
-0.42936694622039795,
0.10940350592136383,
0.8735584020614624,
-0.4509690999984741,
-0.030572550371289253,
0.10233953595161438,
0.7056185007095337,
0.28543514013290405,
0.1414751559495926,
0.9261622428894043,
-0.3630117177963257,
-0.005240229424089193,
0.08296380192041397,
0.37683194875717163,
0.3810521066188812,
-0.9283404350280762,
0.35485026240348816,
0.09354378283023834,
-0.35286805033683777,
-0.654892086982727,
0.2773592472076416,
-1.3906153440475464,
-0.5815962553024292,
1.241988182067871,
-0.381387859582901,
-0.12913303077220917,
-0.22907805442810059,
-0.9222015738487244,
0.6328990459442139,
-0.45416122674942017,
1.0555245876312256,
0.9162322878837585,
-0.3352646827697754,
-0.47788262367248535,
-0.33318719267845154,
0.14885777235031128,
0.5115206837654114,
-0.7362599968910217,
0.22780556976795197,
0.289118230342865,
0.42159217596054077,
-0.4547865390777588,
0.9121138453483582,
-0.2417028695344925,
0.33421406149864197,
-0.5023083090782166,
0.1148226410150528,
0.07075177878141403,
0.39019396901130676,
-0.26406779885292053,
-0.00479403929784894,
0.31407442688941956,
0.24105405807495117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15992v1
|
BIMCV-R: A Landmark Dataset for 3D CT Text-Image Retrieval
| 2024-03-24T03:10:07 | 2024-03-24T03:10:07 |
Yinda Chen, Che Liu, Xiaoyu Liu, Rossella Arcucci, Zhiwei Xiong
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The burgeoning integration of 3D medical imaging into healthcare has led to a
substantial increase in the workload of medical professionals. To assist
clinicians in their diagnostic processes and alleviate their workload, the
development of a robust system for retrieving similar case studies presents a
viable solution. While the concept holds great promise, the field of 3D medical
text-image retrieval is currently limited by the absence of robust evaluation
benchmarks and curated datasets. To remedy this, our study presents a
groundbreaking dataset, BIMCV-R (This dataset will be released upon
acceptance.), which includes an extensive collection of 8,069 3D CT volumes,
encompassing over 2 million slices, paired with their respective radiological
reports. Expanding upon the foundational work of our dataset, we craft a
retrieval strategy, MedFinder. This approach employs a dual-stream network
architecture, harnessing the potential of large language models to advance the
field of medical image retrieval beyond existing text-image retrieval
solutions. It marks our preliminary step towards developing a system capable of
facilitating text-to-image, image-to-text, and keyword-based retrieval tasks.
|
[
-0.28361842036247253,
-0.4624553918838501,
0.7127208113670349,
0.013767130672931671,
-0.5886052846908569,
0.004610084462910891,
0.28865155577659607,
-0.3908137083053589,
0.013814852572977543,
0.829440176486969,
-0.12837259471416473,
-0.36539843678474426,
-0.7779253125190735,
0.23511499166488647,
-0.28019002079963684,
0.6783393025398254,
0.1041705310344696,
0.393216997385025,
-0.22968660295009613,
-0.30965280532836914,
-0.530778169631958,
-0.3295261263847351,
-0.556077778339386,
-0.11228100210428238,
0.9759589433670044,
0.29261448979377747,
0.8842574954032898,
1.0567268133163452,
1.2220335006713867,
0.16612091660499573,
0.07875838875770569,
0.3110472559928894,
-0.43197715282440186,
0.09131870418787003,
-0.18974658846855164,
-0.24102188646793365,
-0.2709431052207947,
-0.15229396522045135,
0.5774325728416443,
0.7891537547111511,
0.0019724962767213583,
-0.06458140909671783,
-0.18272118270397186,
0.9464597702026367,
-0.7517495155334473,
0.09594269841909409,
-0.20783141255378723,
0.08272425085306168,
-0.3763112425804138,
-0.586455225944519,
-0.30805912613868713,
-0.2987518608570099,
0.43538203835487366,
-0.4208086431026459,
0.3930020034313202,
-0.04178757965564728,
0.7748611569404602,
0.030053045600652695,
-0.6135600209236145,
-0.2120542824268341,
-0.5219268202781677,
0.320313036441803,
-0.10303681343793869,
0.31326282024383545,
0.373157799243927,
0.6865156292915344,
-0.07292342931032181,
-1.0222594738006592,
-0.10138043016195297,
0.19969947636127472,
0.1018417477607727,
0.5406755805015564,
-0.10266710072755814,
-0.17570564150810242,
-0.22486360371112823,
0.6467002034187317,
-0.858897864818573,
-0.05256005376577377,
-0.840810239315033,
-0.19227334856987,
0.46452441811561584,
0.387208491563797,
0.34270989894866943,
-0.08996602147817612,
-0.4765585958957672,
-0.2958039939403534,
-0.726822018623352,
-0.47039711475372314,
-0.14365944266319275,
0.42602428793907166,
-0.036369118839502335,
0.9956669211387634,
0.09107531607151031,
0.8486787676811218,
-0.4415567219257355,
0.13256211578845978,
0.45493990182876587,
-0.5036194920539856,
-0.3070090413093567,
0.009612633846700191,
0.7113361954689026,
0.5727141499519348,
-0.19479969143867493,
-0.030304081737995148,
-0.14968310296535492,
-0.05342242866754532,
0.5848165154457092,
-0.730961799621582,
-0.4729916751384735,
-0.0358797088265419,
-0.8871757984161377,
-0.3845577836036682,
0.3333974778652191,
-1.0115078687667847,
-0.7620775699615479,
-0.10414931178092957,
0.40271931886672974,
-0.2686261534690857,
-0.3015952408313751,
0.29586124420166016,
-0.3228898346424103,
0.02520514652132988,
0.18285098671913147,
-0.33603936433792114,
0.09443364292383194,
0.39962583780288696,
1.0923893451690674,
-0.2841166853904724,
0.18095357716083527,
-0.744805634021759,
0.08461242914199829,
-0.5130453705787659,
1.00412917137146,
-0.6235471963882446,
-0.9424263834953308,
0.1318722516298294,
0.139652818441391,
0.21916566789150238,
-0.8204872012138367,
0.40025240182876587,
-0.46745166182518005,
0.3274984061717987,
-0.2302389293909073,
-0.0034760807175189257,
-0.32713717222213745,
0.4361492991447449,
-1.0868542194366455,
0.7258657217025757,
0.12046606093645096,
-0.9152634739875793,
0.17068974673748016,
-0.23238661885261536,
-0.29695066809654236,
0.25610625743865967,
-0.6950750350952148,
-0.550412654876709,
0.19216671586036682,
0.2891845703125,
0.5723572969436646,
-0.7596763372421265,
-0.09706377238035202,
-0.3406229019165039,
-0.4474499523639679,
-0.2804321348667145,
-0.33803272247314453,
0.5288012623786926,
0.24581363797187805,
0.238695427775383,
-0.4340352714061737,
-0.6418697834014893,
-0.21563178300857544,
0.41754475235939026,
-0.44758686423301697,
-0.5142579674720764,
-0.10355301201343536,
0.07192008942365646,
0.16307586431503296,
0.11659828573465347,
-0.6560159921646118,
0.30059367418289185,
-0.3621349334716797,
-0.06321018189191818,
0.22149457037448883,
0.17796090245246887,
0.04513183981180191,
-0.5174116492271423,
0.5361013412475586,
0.40436118841171265,
0.13569892942905426,
-0.17791004478931427,
-0.7037560343742371,
-0.09905513375997543,
-0.7024244070053101,
0.0953841283917427,
0.7124000787734985,
-1.0171849727630615,
-0.005927444901317358,
-0.4453471004962921,
-0.7103583216667175,
-0.5578780770301819,
-0.24522964656352997,
0.5602521300315857,
0.7222903966903687,
0.5065741539001465,
-0.4217495024204254,
-0.49612805247306824,
-1.4955252408981323,
-0.10125931352376938,
0.08063054829835892,
-0.33025434613227844,
0.4290389120578766,
0.07997357100248337,
-0.3870640993118286,
0.5760979056358337,
-0.6195961236953735,
-0.4572281539440155,
-0.3493540585041046,
0.163619726896286,
0.536105751991272,
0.2209176868200302,
0.4621080756187439,
-1.1645818948745728,
-0.2244952768087387,
0.2869170904159546,
-0.6269988417625427,
0.012634840793907642,
0.022833598777651787,
-0.1924123615026474,
-0.08432720601558685,
0.39778852462768555,
-0.01997481845319271,
0.8112084269523621,
0.5089195370674133,
-0.21842451393604279,
0.19796620309352875,
-0.5845339894294739,
0.2799399197101593,
-1.30600106716156,
0.4531906247138977,
0.12747317552566528,
-0.32380345463752747,
-0.27907902002334595,
-0.577972948551178,
0.2594710886478424,
0.08499115705490112,
-0.2145267128944397,
0.3127674162387848,
-0.6294307708740234,
-0.13393673300743103,
-0.15479512512683868,
0.2941422164440155,
0.406358927488327,
0.13170424103736877,
0.20055478811264038,
0.4984246492385864,
0.5676324367523193,
-0.4996366798877716,
0.2467002272605896,
0.4228699803352356,
-0.39782026410102844,
0.7290935516357422,
-0.6643361449241638,
0.05535762012004852,
-0.4601026475429535,
0.14380083978176117,
-0.7637442350387573,
0.09638956189155579,
0.10995728522539139,
-0.3741444945335388,
0.3936537504196167,
-0.5705304145812988,
-0.6772774457931519,
-0.4532754123210907,
-0.10482697933912277,
0.5133922696113586,
0.11023493856191635,
-0.5427312850952148,
0.43815428018569946,
0.752658486366272,
-0.3287091851234436,
-0.47296997904777527,
-0.7973885536193848,
0.2278538942337036,
0.27707916498184204,
-0.19265685975551605,
0.23595766723155975,
0.11520236730575562,
0.12554162740707397,
-0.12301567196846008,
-0.1451464146375656,
-0.2638082206249237,
-0.2669526934623718,
0.172902449965477,
0.9596891403198242,
-0.09173255413770676,
-0.06653773784637451,
-0.13816803693771362,
-0.21063975989818573,
0.048926450312137604,
-0.2198697030544281,
0.14751207828521729,
-0.02785482071340084,
-0.3097120523452759,
-0.11527184396982193,
0.5023441910743713,
0.787922739982605,
-0.21031102538108826,
0.3100949823856354,
0.4271949529647827,
-0.5601405501365662,
0.33615541458129883,
-0.40314000844955444,
0.19878824055194855,
-0.34693893790245056,
0.615319013595581,
-0.29463931918144226,
-0.5610699653625488,
0.2140059471130371,
-0.10580841451883316,
0.1298176348209381,
0.4072050154209137,
0.8023412227630615,
-0.16206671297550201,
1.4180001020431519,
0.45083561539649963,
0.22475840151309967,
0.03873421251773834,
-0.40389060974121094,
0.2219437062740326,
-1.0407238006591797,
-0.8530774712562561,
-0.6015089154243469,
-0.24244333803653717,
-0.5200967788696289,
-0.5649816393852234,
0.7082459330558777,
-0.3383355438709259,
0.022763291373848915,
0.140827476978302,
-0.8808369040489197,
0.15114451944828033,
0.1750413030385971,
0.26104313135147095,
0.39216822385787964,
0.10363929718732834,
-0.594012439250946,
0.02550509199500084,
-0.6291797757148743,
-0.5730690360069275,
1.1046861410140991,
-0.019177895039319992,
0.44742560386657715,
0.3874480128288269,
0.17751748859882355,
0.3479791581630707,
0.38651612401008606,
-0.5775501132011414,
0.27556532621383667,
-0.5383626222610474,
-0.7109788060188293,
0.27671635150909424,
-0.4489746689796448,
-1.3256452083587646,
0.4785952866077423,
-0.31084346771240234,
-0.36721906065940857,
0.4537171423435211,
0.0672905445098877,
-0.38473477959632874,
0.5156222581863403,
-0.356553852558136,
0.8714385032653809,
-0.18182054162025452,
-0.42538365721702576,
-0.05623604729771614,
-0.9224314093589783,
0.22864240407943726,
-0.1768134981393814,
0.3029366135597229,
0.012149672023952007,
-0.2488880604505539,
0.418035626411438,
-0.42816218733787537,
0.27924391627311707,
-0.09630938619375229,
0.3716811537742615,
-0.11003603041172028,
0.2983132302761078,
0.05243770405650139,
0.20445220172405243,
0.048804402351379395,
0.15400509536266327,
0.6958588361740112,
-0.4872666299343109,
-0.4032984673976898,
0.4985097646713257,
-0.5908257961273193,
-0.057440098375082016,
-0.5455981492996216,
-0.37705665826797485,
-0.321154922246933,
0.5688806772232056,
0.33233457803726196,
1.0386812686920166,
-0.18270200490951538,
0.5681759119033813,
0.6502975225448608,
-0.3934759199619293,
0.1147865504026413,
0.3620128929615021,
-0.5062510967254639,
-0.594123899936676,
0.8344864249229431,
-0.11921514570713043,
-0.11358527839183807,
0.724808931350708,
0.2551884055137634,
-0.3159947395324707,
-0.681681215763092,
-0.4445880353450775,
0.41173437237739563,
-0.353718638420105,
-0.5897951722145081,
-0.6575943827629089,
-0.23423346877098083,
-0.03190147131681442,
-0.2436499297618866,
-0.6422056555747986,
-0.077881820499897,
-0.26415807008743286,
0.12873448431491852,
0.14346851408481598,
0.8541439771652222,
0.018667064607143402,
-0.09077560156583786,
-1.0907412767410278,
0.414092481136322,
-0.10031360387802124,
0.6589995622634888,
-0.3321978747844696,
-0.319181352853775,
-0.4261597692966461,
-0.07545723021030426,
-0.1732037216424942,
-0.6413927674293518,
0.5445083379745483,
-0.2377633899450302,
0.4233504831790924,
0.4093891680240631,
-0.0317411944270134,
0.682058572769165,
-0.2562144696712494,
0.5152284502983093,
0.37294691801071167,
-0.09763619303703308,
0.5857519507408142,
-0.35202664136886597,
0.4299044907093048,
0.8307816982269287,
0.21824832260608673,
-0.45348820090293884,
0.015961511060595512,
-0.3399965167045593,
-0.8490715622901917,
0.4316420555114746,
0.256985604763031,
-0.19883470237255096,
-0.19259455800056458,
0.46481746435165405,
0.2024354487657547,
0.021879788488149643,
0.023132842034101486,
-0.14460328221321106,
-0.3746848702430725,
-0.4088541865348816,
-0.13180533051490784,
-0.09153231978416443,
-0.11996535956859589,
-0.14014293253421783,
0.3631027638912201,
-0.06172962859272957,
0.5059459209442139,
0.6354126334190369,
0.030636224895715714,
0.29705774784088135,
-0.2342628836631775,
0.29291972517967224,
0.5314284563064575,
-0.38463541865348816,
0.27589619159698486,
-0.42137253284454346,
-1.2590469121932983,
-0.3927728235721588,
0.1974637806415558,
0.4078447222709656,
0.06810997426509857,
0.12637180089950562,
0.4050927758216858,
-0.17175410687923431,
-0.8604772090911865,
0.8270276784896851,
-0.45698970556259155,
-0.4901670813560486,
-0.2912658751010895,
-0.41110941767692566,
-0.15976260602474213,
0.1970365345478058,
0.37562131881713867,
0.21277017891407013,
0.5129097104072571,
-0.28267228603363037,
0.31874194741249084,
0.2131614238023758,
-0.756500244140625,
-0.08475466817617416,
0.5838428139686584,
0.1268903613090515,
-0.08721541613340378,
1.0484031438827515,
0.40001511573791504,
-0.11542192846536636,
0.5324282050132751,
0.2448790967464447,
0.6061599850654602,
0.2616387605667114,
-0.003663458861410618,
0.3924719989299774,
0.287672758102417,
-0.24395722150802612,
0.541977047920227,
0.23205411434173584,
-0.5274797081947327,
0.06027236208319664,
-0.1368742436170578,
-0.1698797345161438,
0.09030888229608536,
-1.0264225006103516,
0.39206647872924805,
-0.3871347904205322,
-0.20884203910827637,
-0.15443424880504608,
0.10638858377933502,
-0.7690157294273376,
0.41547703742980957,
0.3469332754611969,
1.1778661012649536,
-0.14086368680000305,
0.8396099805831909,
0.7612263560295105,
-0.4247702360153198,
-0.4155717194080353,
-0.3374340534210205,
0.3446987569332123,
-0.8398124575614929,
0.16501037776470184,
0.2369515299797058,
-0.225611612200737,
-0.09270349889993668,
-0.2415475696325302,
-0.6371976137161255,
1.3554892539978027,
-0.14575424790382385,
-0.5065957903862,
0.09725944697856903,
0.0003279904485680163,
0.6247105598449707,
-0.527397632598877,
0.17122717201709747,
0.4173811078071594,
0.35050636529922485,
0.5933699011802673,
-0.6631982326507568,
-0.08375385403633118,
-0.5813913345336914,
0.2727762758731842,
0.22101366519927979,
-0.24439392983913422,
0.281004399061203,
-0.188858762383461,
-0.2006332129240036,
0.05382458120584488,
0.27754873037338257,
0.3963972330093384,
0.4075581431388855,
0.48354631662368774,
0.4123232066631317,
0.44013357162475586,
-0.07590585201978683,
1.1976063251495361,
-0.16747838258743286,
0.08398472517728806,
0.9024820923805237,
-0.14813287556171417,
0.7391305565834045,
0.47490760684013367,
0.21005837619304657,
0.27201002836227417,
0.7482837438583374,
-0.2402958869934082,
0.7134388089179993,
0.023578258231282234,
-0.07375699281692505,
-0.22440356016159058,
0.027851276099681854,
-0.19003461301326752,
0.49322739243507385,
0.6584805250167847,
-0.5327365398406982,
-0.227987602353096,
0.09020329266786575,
-0.04520905390381813,
-0.08609050512313843,
-0.3120556175708771,
0.7235558032989502,
-0.038180869072675705,
-0.5342197418212891,
0.1789187341928482,
-0.33908116817474365,
0.212589293718338,
-0.47625648975372314,
-0.14720627665519714,
-0.22618155181407928,
0.3050650358200073,
-0.016915863379836082,
-1.0113966464996338,
0.5321123003959656,
-0.34183019399642944,
-0.06612733751535416,
-0.08711643517017365,
0.3358478248119354,
-0.28633078932762146,
-0.6063752174377441,
0.22479188442230225,
0.5489335060119629,
0.2874924838542938,
0.1091236099600792,
-0.6054455041885376,
0.15655076503753662,
-0.07271187752485275,
-0.05099647864699364,
0.21014773845672607,
0.38130125403404236,
0.11930081248283386,
0.4463212788105011,
0.39207080006599426,
0.20250356197357178,
-0.2885340452194214,
-0.06573563814163208,
0.9197514057159424,
-0.4494902789592743,
-0.12692266702651978,
-0.3496740758419037,
0.529549241065979,
-0.14727270603179932,
-0.27986863255500793,
0.2769622802734375,
1.2166954278945923,
0.6471924781799316,
0.25781336426734924,
0.926383376121521,
-0.008209324441850185,
0.7759690880775452,
-0.21366176009178162,
0.6592147350311279,
-1.0098857879638672,
0.2330787181854248,
-0.028268912807106972,
-0.48088565468788147,
-0.851486325263977,
0.3511636257171631,
-0.04682300239801407,
-0.10056569427251816,
0.7287567853927612,
1.0340267419815063,
-0.19775713980197906,
0.05720040574669838,
0.3931880593299866,
0.11855926364660263,
0.19158011674880981,
0.2545884847640991,
0.3632335960865021,
-0.414363294839859,
0.9521356821060181,
-0.03280017524957657,
-0.4679914116859436,
-0.5111939311027527,
-0.5660078525543213,
-0.7681067585945129,
-0.8656134605407715,
-0.1452954262495041,
-0.5065493583679199,
-0.0017204940086230636,
0.5538129806518555,
0.5332666635513306,
-0.3094308078289032,
0.1370803266763687,
0.2972497344017029,
-0.21765902638435364,
-0.3186722993850708,
-0.09903150051832199,
0.670368492603302,
0.09883683919906616,
-0.4331815540790558,
0.18173056840896606,
0.9549748301506042,
-0.032941870391368866,
-0.16410253942012787,
0.22099760174751282,
-0.41467761993408203,
0.007327245082706213,
0.5594491362571716,
0.37634730339050293,
-0.1822536587715149,
0.022068284451961517,
0.012650033459067345,
-0.5950084924697876,
0.35079503059387207,
1.0946638584136963,
-0.9212649464607239,
1.1254867315292358,
0.6022075414657593,
0.6840353012084961,
0.5729392766952515,
-0.1920711249113083,
0.714326798915863,
-0.09257888793945312,
-0.10325811803340912,
0.4093027412891388,
0.35230255126953125,
0.3786809742450714,
-0.3370293080806732,
0.4070455729961395,
0.3797919750213623,
-0.5346550345420837,
-0.7071866393089294,
-0.043777018785476685,
-1.3435977697372437,
-0.2775214910507202,
0.8050081729888916,
0.09141834080219269,
-0.22295458614826202,
-0.6021459698677063,
-0.2591232359409332,
0.3217560648918152,
0.09032610803842545,
0.7733317017555237,
0.16643126308918,
-0.17264367640018463,
-0.3242143988609314,
-0.7819789052009583,
0.05432215332984924,
-0.07881061732769012,
-0.5305275917053223,
-0.2078726589679718,
0.6219666600227356,
0.17521841824054718,
-0.058429960161447525,
0.5459803938865662,
-0.8946397304534912,
0.33098074793815613,
-0.17634563148021698,
0.05735185369849205,
-0.1904953420162201,
-0.42530715465545654,
-0.16861122846603394,
0.17572522163391113,
-0.42909470200538635,
-0.46435368061065674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15952v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15952v2
|
IllusionVQA: A Challenging Optical Illusion Dataset for Vision Language Models
| 2024-03-23T23:06:32 | 2024-03-30T13:21:42 |
Haz Sameen Shahgir, Khondker Salman Sayeed, Abhik Bhattacharjee, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Yue Dong, Rifat Shahriyar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The advent of Vision Language Models (VLM) has allowed researchers to
investigate the visual understanding of a neural network using natural
language. Beyond object classification and detection, VLMs are capable of
visual comprehension and common-sense reasoning. This naturally led to the
question: How do VLMs respond when the image itself is inherently unreasonable?
To this end, we present IllusionVQA: a diverse dataset of challenging optical
illusions and hard-to-interpret scenes to test the capability of VLMs in two
distinct multiple-choice VQA tasks - comprehension and soft localization.
GPT4V, the best-performing VLM, achieves 62.99% accuracy (4-shot) on the
comprehension task and 49.7% on the localization task (4-shot and
Chain-of-Thought). Human evaluation reveals that humans achieve 91.03% and 100%
accuracy in comprehension and localization. We discover that In-Context
Learning (ICL) and Chain-of-Thought reasoning substantially degrade the
performance of GeminiPro on the localization task. Tangentially, we discover a
potential weakness in the ICL capabilities of VLMs: they fail to locate optical
illusions even when the correct answer is in the context window as a few-shot
example.
|
[
-0.39943110942840576,
-0.6918855309486389,
0.5868431925773621,
-0.05011788755655289,
-0.3233855068683624,
-0.16360831260681152,
0.2034876048564911,
-0.5641452074050903,
-0.3209208548069,
0.6734024882316589,
-0.47070440649986267,
-0.3160797357559204,
-0.2959464192390442,
0.09731685370206833,
-0.5975567698478699,
0.6108307838439941,
-0.14978213608264923,
0.28032737970352173,
-0.41273361444473267,
-0.31573590636253357,
-0.4132020175457001,
-0.46343156695365906,
-0.39333924651145935,
-0.06502383947372437,
0.09446441382169724,
0.057397518306970596,
0.7063677310943604,
0.28944849967956543,
0.4758385121822357,
0.3209240734577179,
0.09782872349023819,
0.29682496190071106,
-0.5190503597259521,
-0.19960612058639526,
-0.16119414567947388,
-0.6675286889076233,
-0.12258002161979675,
-0.29300400614738464,
0.49867337942123413,
0.505750834941864,
-0.2721918821334839,
0.028837058693170547,
-0.007755808066576719,
0.7764501571655273,
-0.7925795912742615,
-0.1346723884344101,
-0.9478840231895447,
0.1950197070837021,
-0.022232096642255783,
0.13319502770900726,
-0.11398874223232269,
0.10187794268131256,
0.31068310141563416,
-0.7656592726707458,
0.3863895833492279,
0.3691301643848419,
0.9800111055374146,
0.7141778469085693,
-0.4551316499710083,
-0.2083456963300705,
-0.7375422120094299,
0.5354177355766296,
-0.44473469257354736,
0.5709637999534607,
0.26166823506355286,
0.34441694617271423,
-0.05487184599041939,
-0.7458518743515015,
-0.8872676491737366,
-0.3054979145526886,
0.022194085642695427,
0.3772861659526825,
-0.32577991485595703,
0.08860692381858826,
0.38418132066726685,
0.2705727815628052,
-0.6728155016899109,
-0.21922236680984497,
-0.5533359050750732,
-0.27370336651802063,
0.3107120990753174,
0.29573506116867065,
0.2223018854856491,
-0.17499932646751404,
-0.618378758430481,
-0.05541500076651573,
-0.5506669878959656,
0.054415203630924225,
0.18175749480724335,
-0.09506107121706009,
0.24192339181900024,
0.5954616665840149,
-0.33816593885421753,
1.1711101531982422,
-0.13898339867591858,
0.07440788298845291,
0.15034636855125427,
-0.3128754198551178,
-0.5763662457466125,
-0.007796447724103928,
0.6341664791107178,
0.3213992416858673,
0.1147100180387497,
0.1752181351184845,
-0.26904773712158203,
0.20415669679641724,
0.4923206865787506,
-0.19749696552753448,
-0.08937598764896393,
0.28201910853385925,
-0.17624779045581818,
-0.1603499799966812,
-0.128818541765213,
-0.37269434332847595,
-0.3788021206855774,
-0.47128263115882874,
1.0125542879104614,
-0.5503237247467041,
0.056339286267757416,
0.428072065114975,
-0.24108490347862244,
0.439117968082428,
0.4256271719932556,
-0.47514474391937256,
0.31245073676109314,
0.4958171546459198,
0.5330209732055664,
-0.13022322952747345,
-0.5373827219009399,
-0.17308281362056732,
-0.10222131013870239,
-0.6719341278076172,
0.7207607626914978,
-0.26851126551628113,
0.012551569379866123,
-0.2114686816930771,
-0.16416512429714203,
-0.05008118972182274,
-0.6398723721504211,
0.5929723978042603,
-0.34878283739089966,
0.3697319030761719,
-0.34120994806289673,
-0.294337660074234,
-0.3109892010688782,
0.31856009364128113,
-0.5554980039596558,
0.8989043831825256,
0.18261903524398804,
-0.5734461545944214,
0.4787738621234894,
-0.5033533573150635,
-0.18994063138961792,
0.1341199427843094,
-0.2260325849056244,
-0.16481657326221466,
0.33290308713912964,
0.3814181685447693,
0.36186808347702026,
-0.036415714770555496,
-0.03668372705578804,
-0.088250070810318,
-0.5458573698997498,
0.23547080159187317,
-0.7595198750495911,
0.6862505078315735,
0.15617156028747559,
-0.4327196776866913,
-0.1360989212989807,
-0.669996976852417,
-0.013238043524324894,
0.1364559382200241,
-0.0524466410279274,
-0.6389135122299194,
-0.023782387375831604,
-0.1623517870903015,
0.33992114663124084,
0.11514215916395187,
-0.33450567722320557,
0.15868793427944183,
-0.7215027809143066,
0.3331126868724823,
0.776127815246582,
-0.22176143527030945,
0.29904642701148987,
0.07739800214767456,
0.4184246361255646,
0.2942503094673157,
0.5074341297149658,
0.08125555515289307,
-0.5452218055725098,
-0.8753578662872314,
0.005863755941390991,
-0.1774500012397766,
0.7278112769126892,
-1.6108245849609375,
-0.3017292022705078,
-0.2190239429473877,
-0.31386610865592957,
-0.6276074647903442,
0.16515158116817474,
0.7716547846794128,
1.0064048767089844,
0.3754514157772064,
-0.27825063467025757,
-0.22238382697105408,
-1.137708067893982,
-0.37393903732299805,
-0.2374589592218399,
-0.06371308118104935,
0.4054616689682007,
0.6685961484909058,
0.08208458870649338,
0.7521711587905884,
-0.36487045884132385,
-0.39987170696258545,
0.0025798690039664507,
-0.13248437643051147,
0.1355447620153427,
0.09135362505912781,
0.5317756533622742,
-1.1428452730178833,
-0.25080636143684387,
-0.10198419541120529,
-0.8312894105911255,
0.03516503795981407,
-0.13075821101665497,
-0.05154344439506531,
0.3610413372516632,
0.23516200482845306,
-0.46270349621772766,
0.7804505228996277,
0.44582441449165344,
-0.5429288744926453,
0.6388165950775146,
-0.3594845235347748,
0.2570141851902008,
-0.6833380460739136,
-0.1620933562517166,
0.1892295479774475,
-0.1914437711238861,
-0.6981092095375061,
0.12060629576444626,
0.0854850485920906,
0.16191351413726807,
-0.8201590180397034,
0.5218116641044617,
-0.46483322978019714,
-0.37527093291282654,
0.05299606919288635,
0.13456624746322632,
0.09847699850797653,
0.5699095129966736,
0.10176389664411545,
0.7794033885002136,
0.8579779863357544,
-0.5602666139602661,
0.6021989583969116,
0.3786550462245941,
-0.7291275262832642,
0.94301837682724,
-0.6751450300216675,
0.09829939901828766,
-0.4968840181827545,
0.12234805524349213,
-0.8825263381004333,
-0.3199828267097473,
0.5244395136833191,
-0.40655413269996643,
-0.05162212625145912,
0.016825709491968155,
-0.19852524995803833,
-0.5575078129768372,
0.015943778678774834,
0.4714418351650238,
0.4397408962249756,
-0.7579349875450134,
0.7558150291442871,
0.013392469845712185,
0.5839900970458984,
-1.0203524827957153,
-0.8035394549369812,
0.34409382939338684,
-0.36413246393203735,
-0.5384111404418945,
0.1164141595363617,
-0.11625754088163376,
-0.549145519733429,
0.0856211856007576,
-0.10877181589603424,
-0.24465061724185944,
-0.026918424293398857,
0.18971598148345947,
0.28592395782470703,
-0.2173721343278885,
-0.06862712651491165,
-0.37787938117980957,
0.20110097527503967,
-0.01389492116868496,
-0.487857848405838,
0.16526100039482117,
-0.5756123065948486,
-0.6358427405357361,
-0.29761871695518494,
0.02033386006951332,
0.6300931572914124,
-0.2826622426509857,
0.5098649263381958,
0.4265952408313751,
-0.466933935880661,
-0.3584965467453003,
-0.4607000946998596,
0.08298090845346451,
-0.4996068477630615,
0.5097905993461609,
-0.634154736995697,
-0.5258772969245911,
0.3759017288684845,
0.4457602798938751,
-0.17781759798526764,
0.23989777266979218,
0.3995388448238373,
-0.24379774928092957,
1.2132548093795776,
0.32614609599113464,
0.10920854657888412,
0.11839162558317184,
-0.28341084718704224,
0.03167091682553291,
-0.8818517923355103,
-0.30198749899864197,
-0.0635344460606575,
-0.27236509323120117,
0.04280421510338783,
-0.40644973516464233,
0.6201685667037964,
0.08384630084037781,
-0.027201397344470024,
0.22830550372600555,
-0.5399973392486572,
0.7293594479560852,
0.6578683257102966,
0.4037345349788666,
0.287932425737381,
0.0866217240691185,
-0.002833501435816288,
-0.0840708464384079,
-0.8311547040939331,
-0.2376558929681778,
0.9063622355461121,
0.08459831774234772,
0.5310076475143433,
0.07948648929595947,
0.09596045315265656,
0.09871520847082138,
0.046683501452207565,
-0.8169944286346436,
0.505639910697937,
-0.04301942512392998,
-0.7446439266204834,
-0.37088024616241455,
-0.2868919372558594,
-0.7359189987182617,
0.4876154363155365,
-0.22378575801849365,
-0.7125368714332581,
0.2605848014354706,
0.48162752389907837,
-0.28571537137031555,
0.33943021297454834,
-0.633860170841217,
0.9613556861877441,
-0.5612073540687561,
-0.4839024841785431,
0.048420000821352005,
-0.689512312412262,
0.6848911643028259,
-0.08088187128305435,
0.22668778896331787,
0.21436311304569244,
-0.14851787686347961,
0.21071669459342957,
-0.32853659987449646,
0.6993856430053711,
-0.10232029110193253,
0.039656080305576324,
0.32555845379829407,
0.19509099423885345,
0.2886613607406616,
-0.16699855029582977,
0.11898662149906158,
0.2764667272567749,
-0.10080467909574509,
-0.4999341070652008,
-0.8286185264587402,
0.3071519732475281,
-0.4097570478916168,
-0.6388979554176331,
-0.4846900403499603,
-0.2943613529205322,
-0.2796403765678406,
0.13390372693538666,
0.6882066130638123,
0.8272073864936829,
-0.18170230090618134,
-0.06499935686588287,
0.7846620082855225,
-0.26958850026130676,
0.2272414267063141,
0.4428606927394867,
-0.26778557896614075,
-0.20526272058486938,
1.0866092443466187,
0.08715678006410599,
0.43759411573410034,
0.22582781314849854,
0.0069915736094117165,
-0.32589638233184814,
-0.8055596351623535,
-0.520831823348999,
-0.018225781619548798,
-0.9498134851455688,
0.09313657879829407,
-0.26090767979621887,
-0.09090925753116608,
-0.03799118474125862,
-0.06013194099068642,
-0.39020049571990967,
-0.19792471826076508,
-0.19758208096027374,
-0.05419379845261574,
-0.11465901136398315,
0.8812593817710876,
-0.08263727277517319,
0.0524296872317791,
-0.3290810286998749,
0.5464009046554565,
0.48312467336654663,
0.29417791962623596,
-0.2099459171295166,
-0.6152981519699097,
-0.08638787269592285,
0.07624958455562592,
0.023107724264264107,
-0.8158106803894043,
0.45634397864341736,
0.237045556306839,
0.50432950258255,
0.46555253863334656,
-0.00355042633600533,
0.8023834228515625,
-0.5732457041740417,
1.046934723854065,
0.06282038986682892,
-0.90097576379776,
0.39081043004989624,
-0.12668246030807495,
0.30223914980888367,
0.31195196509361267,
0.306166410446167,
-0.41126301884651184,
-0.4687249958515167,
-0.5384396314620972,
-0.681986927986145,
0.6158118844032288,
0.44597142934799194,
0.11934668570756912,
0.1937943696975708,
0.4616527855396271,
-0.0316261351108551,
0.10701426863670349,
-0.7443644404411316,
-0.32309025526046753,
-0.4899895191192627,
-0.15377028286457062,
-0.14485737681388855,
-0.09183408319950104,
-0.11938682943582535,
-0.42051514983177185,
0.4145527482032776,
-0.2049107700586319,
0.1392805427312851,
0.6006669402122498,
-0.18296244740486145,
0.01812124066054821,
-0.16211357712745667,
0.884049117565155,
0.9315472841262817,
0.05096939578652382,
0.257233202457428,
0.5372998714447021,
-0.4591186046600342,
-0.17152929306030273,
-0.247758686542511,
-0.24450820684432983,
-0.07193591445684433,
0.62181156873703,
1.0816149711608887,
-0.029797261580824852,
-0.74184650182724,
0.6400842070579529,
-0.349048376083374,
-0.39618849754333496,
-0.4406208395957947,
0.2009720355272293,
-0.2540363669395447,
0.1895204335451126,
0.44500797986984253,
0.4184897541999817,
0.3448917865753174,
-0.48252779245376587,
0.06967351585626602,
0.5587313175201416,
-0.7108167409896851,
-0.22025690972805023,
0.8487643003463745,
-0.18952131271362305,
-0.34571728110313416,
0.5931721329689026,
-0.11618240177631378,
-0.9806951284408569,
0.7082931399345398,
0.2986081540584564,
0.5254409313201904,
-0.13284912705421448,
0.2185152918100357,
0.25905224680900574,
0.5682779550552368,
-0.12618973851203918,
0.3241521418094635,
0.08675168454647064,
-1.052565574645996,
-0.2438540905714035,
-0.37758323550224304,
-0.31328755617141724,
0.17938627302646637,
-0.45936334133148193,
0.1600978672504425,
-0.29791519045829773,
0.23173043131828308,
-0.18817663192749023,
-0.4703283905982971,
-0.8305376768112183,
0.464679479598999,
0.32294806838035583,
0.9204435348510742,
-0.7448980808258057,
0.7576111555099487,
0.5793878436088562,
-0.23392674326896667,
-0.6816730499267578,
-0.00608798349276185,
0.14495845139026642,
-1.0076655149459839,
0.5922499299049377,
-0.029736125841736794,
-0.2805420756340027,
-0.06411202996969223,
-1.0574041604995728,
-0.7292687296867371,
0.9245955944061279,
0.31398245692253113,
-0.345547080039978,
0.11147670447826385,
0.18129321932792664,
0.7404290437698364,
-0.1647544652223587,
0.17378763854503632,
0.5758873224258423,
0.3920256495475769,
0.1983306109905243,
-0.9507737159729004,
-0.21156489849090576,
-0.07389964908361435,
0.007266273722052574,
0.038939811289310455,
-0.6726147532463074,
0.6366929411888123,
-0.22321531176567078,
-0.052217915654182434,
-0.11337094008922577,
0.4542994201183319,
0.059172917157411575,
0.521758496761322,
0.7472824454307556,
0.6278806328773499,
0.6087048649787903,
-0.11866161227226257,
1.2917455434799194,
0.1233774870634079,
-0.002272423356771469,
1.0519508123397827,
-0.07186337560415268,
0.8448918461799622,
0.5193632245063782,
-0.00890057347714901,
0.19118089973926544,
0.44597354531288147,
0.1250317543745041,
0.5010815262794495,
0.04840540140867233,
-0.21574564278125763,
-0.4659041464328766,
0.13796353340148926,
-0.1145700067281723,
0.6812700629234314,
0.5126523375511169,
0.03893527761101723,
0.11495539546012878,
0.35257449746131897,
-0.443878173828125,
0.02844219096004963,
-0.4342990815639496,
0.5545670986175537,
0.1435677409172058,
-0.7323588132858276,
0.7358929514884949,
-0.3937712609767914,
0.4437377452850342,
-0.354257196187973,
-0.20773331820964813,
-0.22885999083518982,
0.1255214363336563,
-0.11539407074451447,
-0.9125710129737854,
0.3509117364883423,
-0.22954823076725006,
0.07556191831827164,
-0.0022508741822093725,
0.7074626684188843,
-0.31385162472724915,
-0.5005824565887451,
0.004558551125228405,
0.30624234676361084,
0.3638552129268646,
-0.2641967833042145,
-0.9374281764030457,
-0.07801185548305511,
0.14701561629772186,
-0.3711555600166321,
-0.002844587666913867,
0.5179011821746826,
-0.0021897738333791494,
1.0251412391662598,
0.5080565810203552,
0.046723295003175735,
0.2082282304763794,
-0.19670704007148743,
0.6010454893112183,
-0.41248270869255066,
-0.23348423838615417,
-0.7846733927726746,
0.6457560658454895,
-0.13665562868118286,
-0.5981153249740601,
0.7042215466499329,
0.3815584182739258,
0.9406405687332153,
-0.12262745201587677,
0.6358468532562256,
0.09115108847618103,
0.19997215270996094,
-0.8040645122528076,
0.6048016548156738,
-1.145453929901123,
0.32100042700767517,
-0.364886611700058,
-0.7882022857666016,
-0.3499486446380615,
0.6523549556732178,
-0.31134507060050964,
-0.24467749893665314,
0.6703684329986572,
0.7674018740653992,
-0.21624258160591125,
-0.34571072459220886,
0.7488530278205872,
0.39803168177604675,
0.04081728309392929,
0.961175262928009,
1.2512331008911133,
-0.4998405873775482,
0.8156013488769531,
-0.296380877494812,
-0.0637974888086319,
-0.05118146166205406,
-0.7496799230575562,
-0.7793852090835571,
-0.8023764491081238,
-0.18446741998195648,
-0.37909045815467834,
0.03428087383508682,
0.4984605014324188,
0.5833010077476501,
-0.500507652759552,
0.1414705216884613,
-0.24103809893131256,
0.31164711713790894,
-0.29525038599967957,
-0.20510035753250122,
0.22956806421279907,
0.054421015083789825,
-0.75906902551651,
0.5103198289871216,
0.35354703664779663,
0.2105552852153778,
-0.3882434666156769,
-0.16420258581638336,
0.2652466297149658,
0.05537566542625427,
0.529691219329834,
0.40014398097991943,
-1.063788652420044,
-0.3738821744918823,
-0.02171887643635273,
-0.15400181710720062,
0.08492535352706909,
0.2571507394313812,
-1.0692888498306274,
0.8189301490783691,
0.34987375140190125,
0.28007185459136963,
0.41352975368499756,
0.05035218596458435,
0.5827578902244568,
-0.4623883068561554,
0.07564961165189743,
0.24390876293182373,
0.4221916198730469,
0.3033737540245056,
-0.34240326285362244,
0.5134607553482056,
0.31842541694641113,
-0.3661560118198395,
-0.8289116024971008,
0.3813503086566925,
-0.8883046507835388,
-0.6273123025894165,
0.9459050297737122,
0.20940303802490234,
-0.5507010817527771,
-0.2241140753030777,
-0.5773006677627563,
-0.19917534291744232,
0.0786031112074852,
0.7175559401512146,
0.6456499695777893,
-0.22159069776535034,
-0.2619878351688385,
-0.880732536315918,
0.7800706028938293,
0.5270991325378418,
-0.46434545516967773,
-0.2984474003314972,
0.7731379270553589,
0.2338988333940506,
0.15202049911022186,
0.49227574467658997,
0.28144901990890503,
0.40919190645217896,
0.08497614413499832,
-0.16781024634838104,
-0.11483608186244965,
-0.4450325667858124,
-0.5181403160095215,
0.23187807202339172,
-0.18087440729141235,
-0.0719565898180008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15940v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15940v1
|
Geotokens and Geotransformers
| 2024-03-23T22:02:56 | 2024-03-23T22:02:56 |
Eren Unlu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In transformer architectures, position encoding primarily provides a sense of
sequence for input tokens. While the original transformer paper's method has
shown satisfactory results in general language processing tasks, there have
been new proposals, such as Rotary Position Embedding (RoPE), for further
improvement. This paper presents geotokens, input components for transformers,
each linked to a specific geological location. Unlike typical language
sequences, for these tokens, the order is not as vital as the geographical
coordinates themselves. To represent the relative position in this context and
to keep a balance between the real world distance and the distance in the
embedding space, we design a position encoding approach drawing from the RoPE
structure but tailored for spherical coordinates.
|
[
-0.44404080510139465,
-0.3090319335460663,
0.4817758798599243,
-0.006932602729648352,
-0.49799737334251404,
-0.1502353549003601,
0.011017553508281708,
-0.38135871291160583,
0.5021156072616577,
0.15069234371185303,
-0.22590364515781403,
-0.868759036064148,
-0.9044069647789001,
0.06303916126489639,
-0.4203225076198578,
0.9503625631332397,
-0.33774200081825256,
-0.27255114912986755,
0.004707775544375181,
-0.4814777672290802,
-0.20587535202503204,
-0.8906678557395935,
-0.24325934052467346,
-0.3072531521320343,
0.6076231598854065,
0.3022269904613495,
1.0804115533828735,
0.7381346225738525,
0.4019721448421478,
0.35242119431495667,
-0.13472694158554077,
-0.05986529961228371,
-0.12306588888168335,
0.3073318302631378,
-0.4163741171360016,
-0.5288458466529846,
-0.06900286674499512,
-0.05607859045267105,
0.5974686741828918,
0.6468446254730225,
0.04397385194897652,
0.3630448281764984,
-0.2588995099067688,
0.14335589110851288,
-0.4220373332500458,
0.22570590674877167,
-0.13683007657527924,
0.35635629296302795,
-0.35095882415771484,
-0.38242343068122864,
-0.2285790741443634,
-0.49928683042526245,
0.17024479806423187,
-0.48303666710853577,
0.7165449261665344,
0.438726007938385,
0.9029068946838379,
0.13964203000068665,
-0.22849102318286896,
-0.35434675216674805,
-0.8293788433074951,
0.4640383720397949,
-0.1712392270565033,
0.4892808496952057,
0.6210573315620422,
0.430690199136734,
-0.12347712367773056,
-0.5402950644493103,
-0.274137407541275,
0.3756099045276642,
-0.6868005394935608,
0.008443416096270084,
0.30048584938049316,
-0.22826561331748962,
0.41787588596343994,
0.21130119264125824,
-0.5392001271247864,
0.1416119635105133,
-0.522182822227478,
-0.126508429646492,
0.6185309290885925,
0.0936262309551239,
0.345392644405365,
-0.5943214893341064,
-0.15333515405654907,
-0.3356388211250305,
-0.9332877993583679,
0.45073527097702026,
0.41041144728660583,
0.3165448307991028,
-0.35772719979286194,
0.8857046961784363,
-0.10724984854459763,
0.6321381330490112,
0.3185552656650543,
-0.0036171311512589455,
0.15184110403060913,
0.1898299604654312,
-0.28691697120666504,
0.5914374589920044,
0.58989018201828,
0.21655340492725372,
-0.11562294512987137,
-0.20087935030460358,
-0.24766163527965546,
-0.4069399833679199,
0.42934471368789673,
-0.6456499695777893,
-0.25965389609336853,
-0.022558700293302536,
-0.4510841369628906,
-0.25787314772605896,
0.9119170904159546,
-0.6873111724853516,
-0.15430738031864166,
-0.2883172631263733,
0.0020051575265824795,
-0.12783047556877136,
0.0822705402970314,
0.06924951076507568,
-0.17523010075092316,
0.5717079639434814,
-0.2379705160856247,
-1.4068260192871094,
0.22818060219287872,
0.7296192646026611,
0.982732355594635,
0.05916311591863632,
-0.17760612070560455,
-0.4757167100906372,
0.44681596755981445,
0.03982318937778473,
0.8303666114807129,
-0.7877224087715149,
-0.8968250155448914,
0.41116490960121155,
0.4637005925178528,
0.280646950006485,
-0.40982988476753235,
0.7357398271560669,
-0.879165768623352,
0.5521913170814514,
-0.40240278840065,
-0.1767774522304535,
-0.4920831024646759,
-0.10653141140937805,
-0.8349965810775757,
1.2696937322616577,
0.42616745829582214,
-0.6287473440170288,
0.5000407695770264,
-0.7611245512962341,
-0.6231622099876404,
0.12245878577232361,
-0.06213587895035744,
-0.2310657948255539,
0.4381239712238312,
0.7667672038078308,
0.14547006785869598,
-0.024095339700579643,
-0.10634010285139084,
0.16309285163879395,
-0.8414943814277649,
0.21760964393615723,
-0.24693083763122559,
0.5358642339706421,
0.012504281476140022,
-0.5050494074821472,
-0.0006350339390337467,
-0.37692686915397644,
-0.10828804224729538,
0.09478836506605148,
-0.4492284953594208,
-0.4954727292060852,
0.2587871849536896,
0.17811959981918335,
0.13483600318431854,
-0.06361979991197586,
-0.4444136917591095,
0.4535340964794159,
-0.494038850069046,
0.580342710018158,
0.6343803405761719,
-0.17110905051231384,
1.0736500024795532,
0.1534801423549652,
0.7140056490898132,
0.06020075082778931,
0.10363059490919113,
-0.11383765190839767,
-0.44012558460235596,
-0.534102201461792,
0.07495906203985214,
0.3675001263618469,
0.5316699147224426,
-0.7245621681213379,
0.37826666235923767,
-0.7331907153129578,
-0.3400344252586365,
-0.3254486620426178,
-0.3149045705795288,
-0.1289331167936325,
0.18280020356178284,
0.4751065969467163,
-0.01859697513282299,
-0.528002142906189,
-0.4602038562297821,
0.012241496704518795,
-0.1975330114364624,
-0.45590585470199585,
-0.00036641917540691793,
0.25393566489219666,
0.10389615595340729,
0.9819963574409485,
-0.694057047367096,
0.03238712623715401,
0.15501803159713745,
0.08197290450334549,
0.5523629784584045,
0.5268259048461914,
0.678635835647583,
-1.0280377864837646,
-0.12013021111488342,
-0.063066266477108,
-0.9931265115737915,
0.14881397783756256,
0.1366654932498932,
-0.23300497233867645,
-0.09717810899019241,
0.3945799469947815,
-1.0180909633636475,
0.6607201099395752,
0.7997429966926575,
-0.3319961726665497,
0.26041850447654724,
-0.13915522396564484,
0.1022346243262291,
-0.7588334679603577,
0.04457492381334305,
-0.4109494090080261,
-0.40630871057510376,
-0.31251955032348633,
-0.14276111125946045,
-0.060271166265010834,
-0.5086111426353455,
-0.48851168155670166,
0.38776642084121704,
-0.5164043307304382,
-0.31630632281303406,
0.0015328624285757542,
0.4535309970378876,
-0.09800595790147781,
0.35007038712501526,
-0.0905379131436348,
0.7493246793746948,
0.44850507378578186,
-0.5801474452018738,
0.5543339848518372,
0.5775465965270996,
-0.2192249298095703,
0.7745586633682251,
-0.8580755591392517,
0.3100559413433075,
-0.45682293176651,
0.3567502796649933,
-0.8076299428939819,
-0.28370970487594604,
0.5005980730056763,
-0.306416779756546,
0.28341513872146606,
-0.4505736529827118,
-0.10801389068365097,
-0.7752131223678589,
-0.29314640164375305,
0.8488187193870544,
0.45886045694351196,
-0.7074439525604248,
0.5820896625518799,
0.13163603842258453,
-0.25497910380363464,
-0.767355740070343,
-0.7761345505714417,
0.00920412689447403,
-0.5263550281524658,
-0.28761690855026245,
0.7763333916664124,
0.576400637626648,
0.16617247462272644,
0.3345056176185608,
-0.20646969974040985,
0.17454852163791656,
-0.29898354411125183,
0.7091999650001526,
0.10939128696918488,
-0.42616286873817444,
0.2355627715587616,
0.003279313212260604,
-0.6614930629730225,
0.17839129269123077,
-0.9276577830314636,
0.48224204778671265,
0.2850567698478699,
-0.5874200463294983,
-0.4564546048641205,
0.30745214223861694,
0.7043529748916626,
-0.17552590370178223,
0.9033757448196411,
0.5237221717834473,
-0.3898105323314667,
0.004642607178539038,
-0.25098636746406555,
-0.017505770549178123,
-0.5386376976966858,
0.04047328233718872,
-0.4895569980144501,
-0.9547483921051025,
0.5162109136581421,
-0.19742974638938904,
-0.12402355670928955,
0.4107038676738739,
0.1315506249666214,
-0.16923129558563232,
0.8204641342163086,
0.6507425308227539,
-0.5054845809936523,
0.4912993013858795,
-0.2127474844455719,
0.904455840587616,
-0.6980449557304382,
-0.3977244794368744,
-0.7730252146720886,
-0.8824891448020935,
-0.7338889837265015,
-0.5226024389266968,
0.14932160079479218,
0.4012315571308136,
-0.4315996766090393,
0.6603581309318542,
-0.6562249660491943,
0.6547669768333435,
0.5144067406654358,
-0.25596892833709717,
-0.17917777597904205,
0.19678233563899994,
-0.5248174667358398,
-0.2289663702249527,
-0.8120549917221069,
-0.6580616235733032,
0.508044421672821,
0.08220256865024567,
0.8137694597244263,
0.12102798372507095,
0.5239844918251038,
0.07049331814050674,
0.3179433345794678,
-0.7890598177909851,
0.01574685610830784,
-0.05598476156592369,
-0.54140305519104,
-0.49722057580947876,
0.14126864075660706,
-0.7990332245826721,
-0.02375037409365177,
0.10616076737642288,
-0.756289005279541,
0.23725104331970215,
-0.04700031876564026,
-0.3269694745540619,
0.5771982669830322,
-0.35472553968429565,
0.5553442239761353,
-0.1449776440858841,
0.24059540033340454,
0.3386887311935425,
-0.5996021032333374,
-0.30603718757629395,
0.577538251876831,
0.04315285384654999,
0.09269317984580994,
0.29391178488731384,
0.3710769712924957,
-0.4612402021884918,
0.7083935737609863,
-0.5832931995391846,
-0.09977377206087112,
0.45482978224754333,
0.2158864438533783,
0.527987003326416,
0.334641695022583,
-0.23686529695987701,
0.3538190722465515,
-0.3243606984615326,
-0.4194982051849365,
-0.8902484774589539,
0.5994496941566467,
-0.7618666887283325,
-0.6639409065246582,
-0.22483046352863312,
-0.4237509071826935,
0.45147860050201416,
0.11247767508029938,
0.5489292144775391,
0.9141197800636292,
0.004527277313172817,
0.07219750434160233,
0.29632991552352905,
-0.3641919195652008,
0.7237621545791626,
-0.26068568229675293,
-0.20800624787807465,
-0.6865390539169312,
0.4393153488636017,
0.009111536666750908,
-0.3648233711719513,
0.7245016694068909,
-0.13051028549671173,
-0.8531233668327332,
-0.20344239473342896,
-0.7007399797439575,
0.3082616925239563,
-1.0764707326889038,
-0.4596758484840393,
-0.12418083101511002,
-0.21003030240535736,
-0.23384755849838257,
-0.9232475161552429,
-0.0173342227935791,
-0.47045719623565674,
0.010931217111647129,
-0.5925874710083008,
0.4558785855770111,
1.2174476385116577,
-0.07078573107719421,
0.6557919383049011,
-0.8778833150863647,
0.19877125322818756,
0.17178812623023987,
0.626196563243866,
-0.18484267592430115,
-0.18270324170589447,
-0.25815269351005554,
-0.05069750174880028,
-0.009990797378122807,
-0.39356529712677,
0.18137480318546295,
-0.05229249224066734,
0.5851045250892639,
0.26310643553733826,
-0.23550738394260406,
0.8945228457450867,
-0.9919119477272034,
1.0663342475891113,
0.10357140749692917,
-1.0885334014892578,
0.4872066080570221,
0.0545426681637764,
0.431389719247818,
0.15455780923366547,
0.6082450151443481,
-0.9518194198608398,
-0.08316882699728012,
-0.2907634675502777,
-0.696028470993042,
0.8033101558685303,
0.21626487374305725,
0.3868153691291809,
-0.26387283205986023,
0.681328535079956,
-0.014175076968967915,
-0.28535187244415283,
-0.4336646795272827,
-0.46456971764564514,
-0.6030251383781433,
-0.40863901376724243,
-0.26770731806755066,
-0.40367063879966736,
-0.3176465332508087,
-0.1003410741686821,
0.11572760343551636,
-0.006017202511429787,
0.8265438675880432,
0.5119523406028748,
-0.5109416246414185,
-0.06159702688455582,
-0.18404646217823029,
0.8409892916679382,
0.7254902720451355,
0.26232656836509705,
0.7781693339347839,
0.43073466420173645,
-0.6527808308601379,
0.6381632685661316,
-0.1243639588356018,
-0.36382025480270386,
0.5574657917022705,
0.3178086280822754,
0.5454975366592407,
0.4662814438343048,
0.3061816394329071,
0.29214563965797424,
0.1398710310459137,
0.2954866290092468,
-0.20062905550003052,
-0.21992550790309906,
0.1958528608083725,
0.04962451756000519,
0.4865886867046356,
-0.008900826796889305,
-0.17330995202064514,
0.1585075855255127,
0.17009833455085754,
-0.02533545158803463,
-0.7834410071372986,
-0.9134024977684021,
0.9407180547714233,
0.11099295318126678,
-0.9667248129844666,
0.8050569891929626,
-0.17639097571372986,
-0.7320969104766846,
0.2950761914253235,
0.7993468046188354,
0.7509549260139465,
-0.5951698422431946,
0.3452775776386261,
0.7335605025291443,
0.21565203368663788,
0.10610535740852356,
0.017724018543958664,
-0.07670721411705017,
-0.5564388632774353,
-0.35758113861083984,
-0.6623690128326416,
0.12878721952438354,
-0.5773013830184937,
-0.5524058938026428,
0.7187009453773499,
-0.5678331851959229,
-0.1885911524295807,
-0.35629716515541077,
-0.7486472129821777,
-0.8466653227806091,
0.16955731809139252,
0.34153029322624207,
0.7625235915184021,
-0.564569354057312,
0.6533164381980896,
1.0684188604354858,
-0.008604156784713268,
-0.6060687303543091,
-0.22280429303646088,
0.01966121233999729,
-0.5945612192153931,
0.9786900281906128,
0.4000507891178131,
-0.45719534158706665,
-0.308733731508255,
-0.521030068397522,
-1.215933084487915,
1.3566148281097412,
0.03552122414112091,
-0.01747383363544941,
-0.16967080533504486,
0.8156643509864807,
0.2611709535121918,
-0.14307714998722076,
0.3063230812549591,
0.238843634724617,
0.3143285810947418,
-0.17139965295791626,
-0.5403932332992554,
0.21346621215343475,
-0.06016097962856293,
0.6146103739738464,
0.627139151096344,
-0.27210408449172974,
0.4411832094192505,
0.4469485282897949,
-0.4023669958114624,
0.06696813553571701,
0.5777217149734497,
0.0012173607246950269,
-0.28946760296821594,
0.336961954832077,
0.5423771142959595,
0.7498754858970642,
-0.5741475820541382,
1.1161741018295288,
-0.36112818121910095,
0.7143848538398743,
0.694313645362854,
0.07704421877861023,
0.5564302802085876,
0.34165337681770325,
-0.2542196214199066,
1.0114668607711792,
0.5105707049369812,
0.19602961838245392,
0.6271879076957703,
0.025018688291311264,
-0.3134942948818207,
0.18822361528873444,
0.0037633543834090233,
-0.4299919903278351,
0.6398835778236389,
0.490770548582077,
-0.36621493101119995,
-0.39504164457321167,
0.003243247978389263,
0.1690540462732315,
-0.1785060614347458,
-0.05445263162255287,
0.22789055109024048,
0.1830124855041504,
-0.3672996163368225,
0.3772739768028259,
0.29097455739974976,
0.4746612310409546,
-0.6510298848152161,
-0.011947222985327244,
-0.13521413505077362,
-0.17733925580978394,
-0.36066532135009766,
-0.7586612105369568,
0.5609297156333923,
-0.2186388373374939,
-0.2028196007013321,
-0.5584408640861511,
0.4952008128166199,
-0.16563692688941956,
-0.5024412870407104,
0.19578030705451965,
-0.13007408380508423,
0.09508796036243439,
0.35100454092025757,
-0.227542906999588,
-0.06126394867897034,
-0.5712531805038452,
-0.27774062752723694,
-0.35428982973098755,
0.8910961747169495,
-0.24741460382938385,
0.16200563311576843,
0.6233778595924377,
-0.3138481378555298,
0.1151358112692833,
0.1275472790002823,
0.6282064914703369,
-1.2511372566223145,
-0.7133134603500366,
-0.7864513397216797,
0.4766805171966553,
0.05271018296480179,
-0.39374256134033203,
0.6003830432891846,
0.2475997358560562,
0.8783564567565918,
-0.2046341747045517,
0.251169353723526,
-0.4040564298629761,
-0.20393364131450653,
-0.5632104277610779,
0.5623544454574585,
0.22874243557453156,
-0.20126120746135712,
-0.03208440542221069,
-1.514415979385376,
-0.8819310665130615,
0.8565178513526917,
-0.5028661489486694,
-0.14219450950622559,
0.8189993500709534,
0.5145092606544495,
-0.2381846308708191,
0.1578393280506134,
0.11332236975431442,
-0.24732606112957,
0.5714654326438904,
0.3735184967517853,
1.0572344064712524,
-0.8299960494041443,
0.17861992120742798,
-0.4008827805519104,
0.28073206543922424,
-0.07894855737686157,
-0.8373401761054993,
-0.5581110715866089,
-0.39271971583366394,
0.07967470586299896,
0.050448983907699585,
-0.31590595841407776,
0.8089247345924377,
0.8395292162895203,
-1.1329998970031738,
-0.09319593012332916,
0.11837330460548401,
0.2564333379268646,
-0.12222018092870712,
-0.1807718127965927,
0.6116292476654053,
-0.1426505595445633,
-0.8539964556694031,
0.1982855498790741,
0.6265097260475159,
0.2149478644132614,
-0.22782722115516663,
-0.05829881131649017,
0.03844960406422615,
-0.6681237816810608,
0.8156397342681885,
0.1323053240776062,
-0.8513806462287903,
-1.17649507522583,
0.26020383834838867,
-0.09195435047149658,
0.38541918992996216,
1.2294695377349854,
-0.9180583953857422,
0.16276617348194122,
0.5376753211021423,
0.538906991481781,
0.4929291307926178,
0.5937331318855286,
0.5987759828567505,
-0.9447460770606995,
0.8126955628395081,
-0.031796932220458984,
0.4539109766483307,
0.6102152466773987,
-0.6799558997154236,
0.4392222762107849,
0.13631339371204376,
-0.41565409302711487,
-0.12812210619449615,
0.11160677671432495,
-0.5632312297821045,
0.27311766147613525,
0.8036503791809082,
-0.3765425682067871,
-0.31765422224998474,
-0.2567521035671234,
-0.2788880169391632,
0.19656866788864136,
0.23754462599754333,
0.754024863243103,
0.8551193475723267,
0.2096635401248932,
0.13141730427742004,
-0.4638088643550873,
0.40922054648399353,
0.2960224747657776,
-0.18538568913936615,
-0.42544522881507874,
0.16965323686599731,
0.24024176597595215,
0.633853554725647,
-0.02059963159263134,
-0.4822119176387787,
-0.10802383720874786,
-0.11557609587907791,
-0.013948529958724976,
0.23928333818912506,
-0.45555824041366577,
-0.5942544341087341,
0.3779042065143585,
0.04693824425339699,
-0.3559468388557434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15938v1
|
LlamBERT: Large-scale low-cost data annotation in NLP
| 2024-03-23T21:54:34 | 2024-03-23T21:54:34 |
Bálint Csanády, Lajos Muzsai, Péter Vedres, Zoltán Nádasdy, András Lukács
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; F.1.1
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as GPT-4 and Llama 2, show remarkable
proficiency in a wide range of natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Despite
their effectiveness, the high costs associated with their use pose a challenge.
We present LlamBERT, a hybrid approach that leverages LLMs to annotate a small
subset of large, unlabeled databases and uses the results for fine-tuning
transformer encoders like BERT and RoBERTa. This strategy is evaluated on two
diverse datasets: the IMDb review dataset and the UMLS Meta-Thesaurus. Our
results indicate that the LlamBERT approach slightly compromises on accuracy
while offering much greater cost-effectiveness.
|
[
-0.455920934677124,
-0.35823512077331543,
0.38052746653556824,
0.10173185169696808,
-0.2754051089286804,
0.22884692251682281,
-0.5076400637626648,
-0.5180072784423828,
0.4440793991088867,
0.8178774118423462,
-0.38983288407325745,
-0.6034613251686096,
-0.6071149110794067,
0.36073389649391174,
-0.4782233238220215,
1.0545865297317505,
-0.04901231452822685,
-0.19759085774421692,
0.13792337477207184,
-0.3223157823085785,
-0.05516741797327995,
-0.7102106213569641,
-0.4410747289657593,
-0.583524227142334,
0.7812665700912476,
0.39125856757164,
0.9489089846611023,
0.5584678053855896,
0.5641674399375916,
0.08577913045883179,
-0.03217250853776932,
0.6130750179290771,
-0.41107794642448425,
0.08053959161043167,
-0.11447219550609589,
-0.45518365502357483,
-0.3346383571624756,
-0.08291249722242355,
0.5163640975952148,
0.7238702774047852,
-0.041435953229665756,
0.3254883587360382,
0.016000201925635338,
0.674307107925415,
-0.537976086139679,
-0.029189009219408035,
-0.7401496767997742,
0.14802971482276917,
-0.49076467752456665,
-0.11323278397321701,
-0.3669022023677826,
-0.23678825795650482,
-0.09823135286569595,
-0.41062700748443604,
0.04228285700082779,
0.18821774423122406,
0.7677243947982788,
0.5036801695823669,
-0.18700236082077026,
-0.15774647891521454,
-0.9882732629776001,
0.9074405431747437,
-0.5721286535263062,
0.12748555839061737,
0.42134007811546326,
0.20325587689876556,
-0.09666132926940918,
-0.6061614155769348,
-0.5170056223869324,
-0.33841434121131897,
-0.2921634316444397,
-0.30561715364456177,
-0.22714026272296906,
0.13579200208187103,
0.4988236427307129,
0.5194835066795349,
-0.3558521866798401,
0.5077903866767883,
-0.47881343960762024,
-0.23370680212974548,
0.7036373019218445,
0.10729771107435226,
-0.14473843574523926,
-0.20094342529773712,
-0.2550519108772278,
0.005949691869318485,
-0.9818234443664551,
-0.36002054810523987,
0.3398359715938568,
0.22636164724826813,
0.11401625722646713,
1.1775656938552856,
-0.12687835097312927,
0.47824332118034363,
-0.209703728556633,
-0.2004624307155609,
0.20906661450862885,
-0.0950712189078331,
-0.2517505884170532,
0.07769046723842621,
0.8322556018829346,
0.45595017075538635,
0.6364932060241699,
-0.3834744691848755,
-0.4149882197380066,
0.18325850367546082,
0.012385829351842403,
-0.4978805482387543,
-0.4227598309516907,
0.5011140704154968,
-0.10730282962322235,
-0.18832816183567047,
-0.2608943283557892,
-0.8182905912399292,
-0.6650040149688721,
-0.47728273272514343,
0.5258699655532837,
-0.2627471089363098,
0.16522294282913208,
-0.03928809612989426,
0.1090606078505516,
0.18286822736263275,
0.43624481558799744,
-1.063352346420288,
0.18922366201877594,
0.45707643032073975,
0.9933016896247864,
-0.10730455070734024,
-0.05129672959446907,
-0.6378575563430786,
0.33960285782814026,
-0.20517107844352722,
0.9063200354576111,
-0.49468332529067993,
-0.36335447430610657,
0.07139775156974792,
-0.19979853928089142,
0.1746806800365448,
-0.730700671672821,
0.7520098686218262,
-0.360884428024292,
-0.19443371891975403,
-0.03871295601129532,
-0.4528239071369171,
0.02630430832505226,
0.15001150965690613,
-0.9930108189582825,
1.3820757865905762,
0.3900883197784424,
-0.8402336835861206,
0.28853291273117065,
-0.8018243908882141,
-0.44753220677375793,
0.16337502002716064,
-0.2216617465019226,
-0.3260245621204376,
0.04786679148674011,
0.7406982779502869,
0.4751405417919159,
-0.5927697420120239,
0.38880038261413574,
-0.07211213558912277,
-0.4599362015724182,
0.3068721890449524,
-0.238774836063385,
0.5068364143371582,
0.10640063136816025,
-0.2772616744041443,
-0.015651198104023933,
-0.9292033314704895,
-0.4649333357810974,
0.06575536727905273,
-0.6946799755096436,
-0.2049892395734787,
-0.006716805975884199,
0.2906445264816284,
0.012939604930579662,
0.24340176582336426,
-0.5086461901664734,
0.44884514808654785,
-0.20221011340618134,
0.39874768257141113,
0.5530485510826111,
-0.2023952156305313,
0.421243816614151,
-0.28503626585006714,
0.4787909686565399,
-0.2632978856563568,
0.005783447530120611,
-0.0501878447830677,
-0.4593707025051117,
-1.0725593566894531,
-0.686201274394989,
0.6177594065666199,
0.6058666110038757,
-0.7804660797119141,
0.5165980458259583,
-0.3673705756664276,
-0.5165699124336243,
-0.9887654185295105,
0.442274808883667,
-0.059969644993543625,
0.303989052772522,
0.7781593799591064,
0.018723826855421066,
-0.6913489103317261,
-1.217167854309082,
-0.20250122249126434,
0.15398719906806946,
-0.48999547958374023,
0.1836031675338745,
0.41593074798583984,
-0.6153560876846313,
0.9409437775611877,
-0.19321167469024658,
-0.6510013341903687,
-0.26086777448654175,
0.37479493021965027,
0.3451088070869446,
0.35497626662254333,
0.32557764649391174,
-0.3842058777809143,
-0.15793856978416443,
0.0223965086042881,
-0.595669150352478,
-0.36681315302848816,
-0.20574702322483063,
0.012906426563858986,
0.1790662258863449,
0.49529317021369934,
-0.6642410159111023,
0.09635115414857864,
0.7627947330474854,
0.2907946705818176,
0.15187115967273712,
-0.2882485091686249,
-0.147942453622818,
-0.7226284742355347,
-0.021086877211928368,
0.20893380045890808,
-0.24335534870624542,
-0.4317927062511444,
-0.31025826930999756,
0.060693275183439255,
0.0023635372053831816,
-0.25103864073753357,
0.15442605316638947,
-0.34668245911598206,
-0.04412207007408142,
0.04157916456460953,
0.35522782802581787,
-0.18207433819770813,
0.3169304430484772,
0.08493587374687195,
0.797421395778656,
0.16846910119056702,
-0.287695974111557,
0.6068009734153748,
0.2702377736568451,
-0.2568413019180298,
0.3679949641227722,
-0.5924285650253296,
0.32524409890174866,
-0.23662729561328888,
0.4820405840873718,
-0.8895002603530884,
-0.18285046517848969,
0.09682915359735489,
0.04517349973320961,
0.22366684675216675,
-0.3622967004776001,
-0.9673290848731995,
-0.18986287713050842,
-0.5996214747428894,
0.01726320944726467,
0.5073530673980713,
-1.0026556253433228,
0.8550037145614624,
0.4627174139022827,
-0.03539456054568291,
-0.4415668845176697,
-0.8943566679954529,
0.5057690143585205,
-0.37863025069236755,
-0.44074514508247375,
0.371753454208374,
0.38267433643341064,
-0.2644517719745636,
-0.2172955870628357,
0.2419137805700302,
0.21353131532669067,
-0.12122698873281479,
0.2427532970905304,
0.32735732197761536,
-0.21204157173633575,
0.23692288994789124,
0.02015339955687523,
-0.33608755469322205,
-0.15442243218421936,
-0.3080441951751709,
0.4632374346256256,
0.07620524615049362,
-0.1389477699995041,
-0.03278963267803192,
0.3088236451148987,
0.37193891406059265,
-0.45516467094421387,
0.7573413252830505,
0.6600921154022217,
-0.42721089720726013,
-0.5045862197875977,
-0.6792123913764954,
0.10950782150030136,
-0.45229998230934143,
0.15482498705387115,
-0.10708749294281006,
-1.005082368850708,
0.16984394192695618,
-0.3211328089237213,
0.31916382908821106,
0.6507940292358398,
0.6547443270683289,
-0.22798454761505127,
0.5509927868843079,
0.43800413608551025,
-0.22583426535129547,
0.16562670469284058,
-0.309893399477005,
0.4376562535762787,
-0.9708937406539917,
-0.15840861201286316,
-0.5934637784957886,
-0.6780912280082703,
-0.7242181897163391,
-0.8042348623275757,
0.30570104718208313,
-0.00557877728715539,
-0.11736761778593063,
0.5588549971580505,
-0.5131632089614868,
0.502348780632019,
0.7738483548164368,
-0.1472471058368683,
0.685112714767456,
0.13470415771007538,
0.23173384368419647,
-0.2595215439796448,
-0.45520907640457153,
-0.964906632900238,
1.5038365125656128,
0.3806000351905823,
1.145317554473877,
0.20137764513492584,
0.7143058776855469,
0.3342713713645935,
0.595266580581665,
-0.6391255259513855,
0.4559900760650635,
-0.2850222587585449,
-0.5623701214790344,
-0.32797151803970337,
-0.25097110867500305,
-0.7878292202949524,
0.4311186671257019,
-0.5864704847335815,
-1.0422595739364624,
0.047799237072467804,
0.2703930139541626,
-0.358893483877182,
0.36691853404045105,
-0.5306112170219421,
0.4469556212425232,
-0.38460421562194824,
-0.07658994197845459,
-0.08133777976036072,
-0.43326476216316223,
0.47105661034584045,
-0.5440919995307922,
0.1692023128271103,
-0.27640411257743835,
-0.3566615879535675,
0.7627512812614441,
-0.18864856660366058,
0.7223171591758728,
0.05100048705935478,
-0.2385798990726471,
0.17092862725257874,
0.13093796372413635,
0.7880221605300903,
0.19105000793933868,
-0.10571678727865219,
0.39870232343673706,
-0.08301418274641037,
-0.09630801528692245,
-0.31798255443573,
0.7090875506401062,
-0.621481716632843,
-0.27768000960350037,
-0.3715018928050995,
-0.6551777124404907,
-0.3708701431751251,
-0.32439297437667847,
0.21018949151039124,
0.16115689277648926,
0.1937011182308197,
0.18845196068286896,
0.6142652630805969,
-0.26863595843315125,
0.2832831144332886,
0.13920994102954865,
-0.21853874623775482,
-0.5136353373527527,
0.6044962406158447,
0.2645626664161682,
0.06225376948714256,
0.4882422387599945,
0.029969342052936554,
-0.35052233934402466,
-0.5002946257591248,
-0.4363252520561218,
0.46012064814567566,
-0.8971425294876099,
-0.25593844056129456,
-0.7936925292015076,
-0.040569428354501724,
0.02801615372300148,
-0.2558431625366211,
-0.4709983766078949,
-0.7839672565460205,
-0.3001643717288971,
-0.2307993620634079,
0.6846840381622314,
0.5884429812431335,
-0.06393729895353317,
0.4961637556552887,
-0.5878891348838806,
0.3055803179740906,
0.17500926554203033,
0.17437241971492767,
-0.2574261426925659,
-0.5259251594543457,
-0.2644544839859009,
-0.22896215319633484,
-0.13771933317184448,
-0.5504054427146912,
0.2735658884048462,
0.33188095688819885,
0.3157418966293335,
0.15073035657405853,
0.1661696881055832,
0.38559460639953613,
-0.4886415898799896,
0.8086053133010864,
0.008247235789895058,
-0.9178347587585449,
0.5493811368942261,
-0.15011116862297058,
-0.07137610018253326,
0.6042699813842773,
0.3878968358039856,
-0.45916610956192017,
-0.2565421164035797,
-0.4656161963939667,
-1.0821980237960815,
0.4184604287147522,
0.27003878355026245,
0.08624197542667389,
0.21789371967315674,
0.23310135304927826,
0.03836383670568466,
0.18638217449188232,
-0.8935003876686096,
-0.2728472352027893,
0.36049196124076843,
-0.4745071530342102,
-0.40728041529655457,
-0.3416503965854645,
-0.3781673014163971,
-0.2938399314880371,
0.6203017234802246,
-0.1821451485157013,
0.15215203166007996,
0.09140542894601822,
-0.41464582085609436,
-0.06083089858293533,
0.26768454909324646,
0.398560494184494,
0.4931720495223999,
-0.3737034499645233,
0.3173774480819702,
0.4822987914085388,
-0.2621247470378876,
0.07098545879125595,
0.1061217188835144,
-0.11863523721694946,
0.2761557102203369,
0.49407151341438293,
0.5043914914131165,
0.2562151849269867,
-0.9550210237503052,
0.31297197937965393,
0.2723226547241211,
-0.29866480827331543,
-0.3972606360912323,
-0.061838746070861816,
0.2963348925113678,
0.36724671721458435,
0.26952388882637024,
-0.2784324288368225,
-0.050579048693180084,
-0.13639165461063385,
0.06579840183258057,
0.31634923815727234,
-0.10077515244483948,
-0.026788441464304924,
0.7736514210700989,
0.14252053201198578,
-0.2440868765115738,
0.5993450284004211,
0.13303741812705994,
-0.3716273605823517,
0.0927354022860527,
0.19054624438285828,
0.7917377352714539,
0.04465366154909134,
0.0044195703230798244,
0.21424491703510284,
0.8267259001731873,
-0.1700325757265091,
0.03886785730719566,
-0.036319535225629807,
-0.5480302572250366,
-0.6710754036903381,
-0.7600880861282349,
-0.7126039266586304,
0.19452591240406036,
-0.31718796491622925,
0.45707330107688904,
-0.5447497963905334,
-0.1378023326396942,
0.1888207644224167,
-0.19441020488739014,
-0.6548810601234436,
-0.032982293516397476,
0.43217435479164124,
0.8329474329948425,
-0.8533158898353577,
1.0686792135238647,
0.4022773802280426,
-0.4682903587818146,
-0.5721847414970398,
-0.27022066712379456,
-0.15664371848106384,
-0.8462489247322083,
0.7308716177940369,
0.09929510951042175,
-0.07067426294088364,
-0.07449433207511902,
-0.4350227415561676,
-0.7928612232208252,
1.1283210515975952,
0.521428644657135,
-1.0364621877670288,
0.08112461864948273,
0.45423567295074463,
0.5528994798660278,
-0.289238840341568,
0.07770080864429474,
1.1357861757278442,
0.5903310775756836,
-0.14753051102161407,
-0.8692837357521057,
-0.1968393623828888,
0.2187231183052063,
0.06103242188692093,
0.41489577293395996,
-0.344566285610199,
0.8144065141677856,
-0.1971653699874878,
-0.05128214880824089,
-0.21544155478477478,
0.464622437953949,
0.035018112510442734,
-0.03756360709667206,
0.41586607694625854,
0.5966957807540894,
0.9660307168960571,
-0.21351072192192078,
0.9096867442131042,
-0.031785231083631516,
0.6218308806419373,
1.0629184246063232,
-0.36949965357780457,
0.9792911410331726,
0.8623447418212891,
-0.6053495407104492,
0.16234317421913147,
0.6658214926719666,
-0.42923346161842346,
0.307505339384079,
0.5899712443351746,
-0.3342244625091553,
-0.1939990520477295,
-0.08245585113763809,
0.01299105491489172,
0.04403332993388176,
0.45523157715797424,
-0.5362308025360107,
-0.30422553420066833,
-0.10598212480545044,
0.14974413812160492,
-0.07002093642950058,
-0.1741437017917633,
0.4774699807167053,
0.22055451571941376,
-0.13378219306468964,
0.6054002046585083,
0.10454298555850983,
0.9117651581764221,
-0.3637929856777191,
0.04055579751729965,
-0.2532641291618347,
0.20753681659698486,
-0.4223085343837738,
-0.6504623293876648,
0.20150358974933624,
0.32951468229293823,
0.18024766445159912,
0.04777432605624199,
0.404375284910202,
-0.5866024494171143,
-0.6702020764350891,
0.4291868209838867,
0.20884205400943756,
0.1310487985610962,
-0.12982676923274994,
-0.35725387930870056,
0.20289675891399384,
-0.09349518269300461,
-0.27234047651290894,
0.16415512561798096,
0.20880380272865295,
-0.029866192489862442,
0.5676061511039734,
0.6619060635566711,
0.3232041895389557,
0.0675901398062706,
0.16289913654327393,
0.8407793045043945,
-0.6298395395278931,
-0.03826230391860008,
-0.952043354511261,
0.5147216320037842,
-0.0824366956949234,
-0.2720319330692291,
0.5204340815544128,
0.5007809996604919,
0.7118330001831055,
0.01349909882992506,
0.906365156173706,
0.0952141061425209,
0.6296338438987732,
-0.6938210129737854,
0.27685263752937317,
-0.27010297775268555,
0.6204534769058228,
-0.1341620236635208,
-1.3586770296096802,
-0.7649738788604736,
0.7148360013961792,
-0.35062915086746216,
-0.30585232377052307,
0.598425567150116,
0.932523250579834,
-0.018287083134055138,
0.043153829872608185,
0.34136807918548584,
-0.09430672973394394,
0.4772973954677582,
0.6027626395225525,
0.9643788933753967,
-0.28187358379364014,
0.5538652539253235,
-0.4092370867729187,
-0.1636122465133667,
-0.34966161847114563,
-0.9231672286987305,
-1.1820160150527954,
-0.2523512840270996,
-0.3671247661113739,
-0.37754175066947937,
-0.15451626479625702,
1.3891748189926147,
0.4198674261569977,
-0.7617277503013611,
-0.16819216310977936,
0.44502386450767517,
-0.2678217589855194,
0.08121617138385773,
-0.0696263387799263,
0.4811290204524994,
-0.07623378187417984,
-0.6891019344329834,
0.38183775544166565,
0.49785569310188293,
-0.015613723546266556,
-0.5457778573036194,
0.15748944878578186,
-0.061987705528736115,
0.08819030225276947,
0.6559321284294128,
0.061268072575330734,
-0.8879405856132507,
-0.2581343352794647,
-0.5172564387321472,
-0.04288734495639801,
0.25333869457244873,
0.7252750992774963,
-0.6292823553085327,
0.20997411012649536,
-0.06061842292547226,
0.9056407809257507,
0.777621328830719,
0.007881413213908672,
0.4711686670780182,
-0.6219812631607056,
0.2037283480167389,
0.37347280979156494,
0.5603885650634766,
0.7539742588996887,
-0.2976554036140442,
0.7607882618904114,
-0.039757803082466125,
-0.500806987285614,
-0.8443644642829895,
0.00826014019548893,
-0.9465622305870056,
0.19009386003017426,
1.362842082977295,
0.16819411516189575,
-0.006649540271610022,
-0.09364674240350723,
-0.45829281210899353,
-0.23022086918354034,
-0.25757724046707153,
0.4879196882247925,
0.5968354940414429,
-0.18553340435028076,
-0.26697033643722534,
-0.8181977868080139,
0.411038875579834,
0.13528159260749817,
-0.6564656496047974,
0.12469050288200378,
0.40076690912246704,
0.028527960181236267,
0.2801327407360077,
0.27062371373176575,
-0.05067792162299156,
-0.3106096088886261,
-0.11024307459592819,
0.30161386728286743,
0.15139906108379364,
-0.11630219966173172,
-0.47278398275375366,
0.06343425810337067,
0.3610728681087494,
-0.05189109221100807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07963v1
|
EduAgent: Generative Student Agents in Learning
| 2024-03-23T18:19:17 | 2024-03-23T18:19:17 |
Songlin Xu, Xinyu Zhang, Lianhui Qin
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Student simulation in online education is important to address dynamic
learning behaviors of students with diverse backgrounds. Existing simulation
models based on deep learning usually need massive training data, lacking prior
knowledge in educational contexts. Large language models (LLMs) may contain
such prior knowledge since they are pre-trained from a large corpus. However,
because student behaviors are dynamic and multifaceted with individual
differences, directly prompting LLMs is not robust nor accurate enough to
capture fine-grained interactions among diverse student personas, learning
behaviors, and learning outcomes. This work tackles this problem by presenting
a newly annotated fine-grained large-scale dataset and proposing EduAgent, a
novel generative agent framework incorporating cognitive prior knowledge (i.e.,
theoretical findings revealed in cognitive science) to guide LLMs to first
reason correlations among various behaviors and then make simulations. Our two
experiments show that EduAgent could not only mimic and predict learning
behaviors of real students but also generate realistic learning behaviors of
virtual students without real data.
|
[
-0.4071944057941437,
-1.3958096504211426,
0.6488177180290222,
-0.055104680359363556,
0.16629241406917572,
0.4210835099220276,
-0.3078288435935974,
-0.18938446044921875,
0.40649768710136414,
0.17197047173976898,
-0.6638327240943909,
-0.3524889051914215,
-0.005418500397354364,
-0.06680899113416672,
-0.28017598390579224,
0.8121680617332458,
0.18686240911483765,
0.1419263333082199,
-0.7199863195419312,
0.3661605715751648,
-0.16770344972610474,
-0.3932517170906067,
-0.9454939365386963,
-0.6449382901191711,
0.5153359770774841,
0.30585533380508423,
0.3007516860961914,
0.21831363439559937,
0.07473383843898773,
0.3483998477458954,
0.31036093831062317,
0.1215519979596138,
-0.6314899325370789,
0.24262793362140656,
-0.1408699005842209,
-0.548984169960022,
-0.5923635959625244,
0.06502702832221985,
0.7015343904495239,
0.8243036270141602,
-0.49728718400001526,
-0.11446323990821838,
0.32459115982055664,
0.2383228838443756,
-0.34598538279533386,
0.1847563236951828,
-0.2139257788658142,
0.15308654308319092,
-0.02064969763159752,
-0.09138078987598419,
-0.4586277902126312,
-0.28257569670677185,
0.07579492777585983,
-1.244175672531128,
0.29559043049812317,
-0.35038313269615173,
0.6947000026702881,
0.4364790916442871,
-0.3256867229938507,
-0.028096185997128487,
-0.9566033482551575,
0.7520004510879517,
-0.4803023636341095,
0.22634047269821167,
0.4988449811935425,
0.49747443199157715,
-0.3905360698699951,
-1.0769695043563843,
-0.8728092312812805,
-0.10656821727752686,
0.23533588647842407,
0.5425953269004822,
-0.0006938737933523953,
0.279111385345459,
0.28782209753990173,
0.12639883160591125,
-0.49853697419166565,
0.49856626987457275,
-0.17735201120376587,
0.03499076887965202,
0.4216923415660858,
0.4863712787628174,
0.1765608787536621,
0.22151599824428558,
-0.5050112009048462,
-0.5871375203132629,
-0.508890688419342,
0.2787861227989197,
0.6311964392662048,
0.2791244685649872,
-0.2964509129524231,
0.1795433759689331,
-0.10754771530628204,
0.44338181614875793,
-0.05490170791745186,
-0.12910088896751404,
0.285510390996933,
0.36048078536987305,
-0.21990284323692322,
0.1336044818162918,
0.6824385523796082,
0.1786135584115982,
0.3753368854522705,
0.14686143398284912,
-0.028555484488606453,
0.2716788649559021,
0.19260594248771667,
-1.0143373012542725,
-0.4082489311695099,
0.4270738363265991,
-0.14279785752296448,
-0.24854104220867157,
0.014526723884046078,
-1.2438068389892578,
-0.2568610608577728,
-0.6500697731971741,
0.32128480076789856,
-0.436444491147995,
-0.7215749025344849,
0.05164799094200134,
0.055926598608493805,
0.10561377555131912,
0.7849663496017456,
-0.5432694554328918,
0.3084562122821808,
0.7786452174186707,
0.40237098932266235,
-0.17240585386753082,
-0.7477484941482544,
-0.350056529045105,
0.10642371326684952,
-0.23256157338619232,
0.609740674495697,
-0.7130861878395081,
-0.46435388922691345,
0.3849787712097168,
-0.3468480110168457,
-0.18148872256278992,
-0.11456774175167084,
0.18137668073177338,
-0.5547114610671997,
0.03836367279291153,
-0.22935006022453308,
-0.8402102589607239,
-0.22251079976558685,
0.4162942171096802,
-0.8556163907051086,
0.7356054782867432,
0.10447227954864502,
-0.19369083642959595,
0.3225238025188446,
-0.714836597442627,
-0.4379061162471771,
0.4519055485725403,
-0.515359103679657,
-0.24199262261390686,
-0.15971677005290985,
-0.08888274431228638,
0.544176459312439,
-0.03975256159901619,
0.5218707323074341,
-0.28107407689094543,
-0.3382875919342041,
0.4307788908481598,
-0.5244892239570618,
0.818057656288147,
0.2899612784385681,
-0.16866567730903625,
0.11703415960073471,
-0.5533629059791565,
-0.022255705669522285,
0.4507251977920532,
-0.35286182165145874,
-0.38150471448898315,
0.0014798148768022656,
0.14086124300956726,
-0.04337586462497711,
-0.01297597587108612,
-0.47885286808013916,
0.5196132063865662,
-0.1406889706850052,
0.19974829256534576,
0.7577317953109741,
-0.1898776888847351,
0.27339351177215576,
-0.33472394943237305,
0.6835049390792847,
-0.18760058283805847,
-0.0624590702354908,
-0.047402020543813705,
-0.39829912781715393,
-0.6475304961204529,
-0.3523271977901459,
0.0906517431139946,
0.18787869811058044,
-1.142102837562561,
-0.13037870824337006,
-0.4333663284778595,
-0.2566092908382416,
-0.24127382040023804,
-0.046634238213300705,
0.14756032824516296,
0.052437085658311844,
0.2743503749370575,
0.0891772210597992,
-0.4371177852153778,
-0.25143590569496155,
0.06905502825975418,
-0.3025055229663849,
-0.001351460930891335,
0.20442207157611847,
0.5422871708869934,
-0.5832875967025757,
0.8643349409103394,
-0.5490928292274475,
-0.3511258661746979,
-0.3921554982662201,
0.29583847522735596,
-0.4467887580394745,
0.44775885343551636,
0.7494770884513855,
-0.6845397353172302,
-0.2357242852449417,
-0.2187046855688095,
-0.9158202409744263,
0.22223655879497528,
-0.4833484888076782,
-0.06355862319469452,
-0.15486136078834534,
0.7849816083908081,
-0.44564369320869446,
0.24420206248760223,
0.4000464975833893,
-0.2418060600757599,
0.31013691425323486,
-0.36044344305992126,
0.02274443209171295,
-1.1471707820892334,
-0.3912923038005829,
-0.027148179709911346,
-0.04119369387626648,
-0.5610653758049011,
0.2909019887447357,
-0.165965735912323,
-0.0912126749753952,
-0.34698280692100525,
0.5693968534469604,
-0.327078640460968,
0.13780805468559265,
-0.2933017611503601,
0.09777913242578506,
0.06863069534301758,
0.6170119047164917,
0.07424349337816238,
0.6762176752090454,
0.5229593515396118,
-0.7860540151596069,
0.6009461283683777,
0.1919366866350174,
-0.12846294045448303,
0.6268584728240967,
-0.6053391098976135,
-0.04559693485498428,
-0.201199010014534,
0.34197530150413513,
-0.4950278401374817,
-0.527996838092804,
-0.06505334377288818,
-0.31609421968460083,
0.3434765338897705,
0.1451382339000702,
-0.41143685579299927,
-0.2461884319782257,
-0.12176916748285294,
0.6454713940620422,
0.5498927235603333,
-0.6451394557952881,
1.1459555625915527,
0.24089761078357697,
0.019031696021556854,
-0.22462615370750427,
-0.45392701029777527,
-0.08745257556438446,
-0.07781609892845154,
-0.1081320196390152,
0.274721622467041,
-0.197421133518219,
-0.49753084778785706,
-0.043142370879650116,
0.5851879715919495,
-0.17674820125102997,
0.32511505484580994,
0.5099918246269226,
0.2965210974216461,
-0.1677250862121582,
0.4324047565460205,
0.22180578112602234,
0.19404961168766022,
0.2768085300922394,
-0.08378250896930695,
0.7021424174308777,
-0.21417123079299927,
-0.528426468372345,
-0.19436940550804138,
0.140464648604393,
0.514779269695282,
-0.16200613975524902,
0.6367002725601196,
0.5244923233985901,
-0.4766833186149597,
-0.7960200905799866,
-0.2988106310367584,
-0.44002047181129456,
-0.4722355008125305,
0.3803994059562683,
-0.4352347254753113,
-0.7300898432731628,
0.45611247420310974,
-0.40733176469802856,
0.1925458163022995,
0.09644794464111328,
0.3617399036884308,
-0.1039193868637085,
0.6476820707321167,
0.6339463591575623,
0.3453625738620758,
0.5823317170143127,
-0.4680810570716858,
-0.1377069503068924,
-0.5038324594497681,
-0.5481419563293457,
-0.1223418116569519,
-0.1675102412700653,
-0.43758106231689453,
-0.4293126165866852,
0.07152304798364639,
-0.09793338179588318,
-0.3281431496143341,
-0.051345095038414,
-0.19540315866470337,
0.35210904479026794,
0.44655776023864746,
0.11723431199789047,
0.06950671225786209,
0.4313109815120697,
-0.3625123202800751,
0.1909060925245285,
-0.5202330350875854,
-0.4499931335449219,
1.068153738975525,
0.11558754742145538,
0.873296320438385,
0.27794501185417175,
0.6029170155525208,
0.2395235002040863,
0.44334810972213745,
-0.916837215423584,
0.7385540008544922,
0.2514868974685669,
-0.4565596878528595,
-0.2476438283920288,
-0.6119639277458191,
-1.3463753461837769,
0.13300269842147827,
-0.4362621009349823,
-0.4368112087249756,
-0.033061206340789795,
0.038909632712602615,
-0.582036018371582,
0.42202726006507874,
-0.24943982064723969,
0.5546757578849792,
-0.26128867268562317,
-0.622042179107666,
-0.37498125433921814,
-0.3213183283805847,
0.05818876251578331,
-0.2078745812177658,
0.25861698389053345,
0.04759392887353897,
0.23126551508903503,
0.7686375379562378,
-0.4104118347167969,
1.186417579650879,
0.024691378697752953,
-0.03668946772813797,
0.6594753265380859,
0.2322702705860138,
0.33666643500328064,
-0.09503193199634552,
-0.015573864802718163,
0.2089848667383194,
-0.1376139372587204,
-0.4055672883987427,
-0.3416644334793091,
0.9751771092414856,
-1.0255753993988037,
-0.6115513443946838,
-0.5566366314888,
-0.4109095335006714,
-0.11876007169485092,
-0.04762865602970123,
0.19430150091648102,
0.22419770061969757,
-0.7263588905334473,
-0.019119031727313995,
0.8454504609107971,
-0.08114052563905716,
0.5359360575675964,
0.6964905261993408,
-0.4192204177379608,
-0.15455786883831024,
1.2042477130889893,
0.021231278777122498,
0.15772534906864166,
0.20981544256210327,
0.1481158286333084,
-0.03242453560233116,
-0.1067051813006401,
-0.42483848333358765,
0.16191920638084412,
-0.6688070297241211,
0.04341268911957741,
-0.6283528208732605,
-0.1385457068681717,
-0.3140331506729126,
-0.3629266023635864,
-0.3171634376049042,
-0.10514610260725021,
-0.506889283657074,
-0.48663705587387085,
0.38639605045318604,
0.8925231099128723,
0.0011396987829357386,
0.5414674878120422,
-0.48506608605384827,
0.03152473643422127,
0.7294142246246338,
0.23691175878047943,
0.2680594027042389,
-0.2108573168516159,
-0.14418981969356537,
0.28933414816856384,
-0.317159503698349,
-0.5544562935829163,
0.3017944097518921,
0.5293114185333252,
0.7254862189292908,
0.9366897940635681,
0.20301756262779236,
0.46739035844802856,
-0.31598547101020813,
0.7311944365501404,
0.22987248003482819,
-0.5603638291358948,
0.5419871807098389,
-0.35165122151374817,
-0.23561595380306244,
0.36857491731643677,
0.4019809067249298,
0.05350815877318382,
-0.14300748705863953,
-0.6789001226425171,
-0.6922134160995483,
0.3607919216156006,
0.14028973877429962,
0.4347829818725586,
-0.005584699101746082,
0.273845911026001,
0.22415581345558167,
0.21229328215122223,
-0.45797863602638245,
-0.3840913772583008,
-0.47983089089393616,
-0.4228385388851166,
-0.11086650937795639,
0.02847721427679062,
-0.0785391554236412,
-0.2797253429889679,
0.4608607888221741,
-0.12149304896593094,
-0.0289924293756485,
-0.029664386063814163,
0.06215544417500496,
-0.2139992117881775,
-0.02155821956694126,
0.3918987512588501,
0.3914777338504791,
-0.029553506523370743,
-0.04879520833492279,
0.030070658773183823,
-0.8465933203697205,
0.11615611612796783,
0.20815803110599518,
-0.18611527979373932,
-0.13626942038536072,
0.36687931418418884,
0.5472356677055359,
0.12889520823955536,
-0.96468585729599,
0.5710449814796448,
-0.3479435443878174,
-0.17905931174755096,
-0.9656509160995483,
0.27970775961875916,
-0.13158462941646576,
0.3174540400505066,
0.30918145179748535,
-0.14300726354122162,
0.07647287100553513,
-0.5775986313819885,
0.19327905774116516,
0.2360052764415741,
-0.35428744554519653,
-0.5761373043060303,
0.8513633608818054,
0.51253342628479,
-0.13669416308403015,
0.7836991548538208,
-0.1421440690755844,
-0.2718304991722107,
1.005739450454712,
0.4283430576324463,
0.7087374329566956,
-0.6465767621994019,
0.5259450078010559,
0.4387902021408081,
0.04436120018362999,
-0.2813924252986908,
0.2106710821390152,
-0.031798508018255234,
-0.8757913708686829,
-0.23379972577095032,
-0.6385856866836548,
-0.4885494112968445,
0.21710453927516937,
-0.8444267511367798,
-0.0058662062510848045,
-0.6569623351097107,
-0.2890052795410156,
0.07422564178705215,
-0.15277937054634094,
-0.957442581653595,
0.2681662440299988,
0.21565768122673035,
0.31435641646385193,
-1.0000897645950317,
0.8743409514427185,
1.2492023706436157,
-0.6116163730621338,
-0.9790078401565552,
-0.006136680021882057,
-0.09356660395860672,
-0.5570001602172852,
0.5142743587493896,
0.18161483108997345,
-0.010745953768491745,
0.367443323135376,
-0.4821258783340454,
-0.3993552029132843,
1.009096622467041,
0.34577271342277527,
-0.5758424401283264,
0.012904169037938118,
0.25206220149993896,
0.5810539722442627,
-0.40377774834632874,
0.22526445984840393,
0.17535260319709778,
0.16888177394866943,
0.25374555587768555,
-0.25006338953971863,
-0.15689368546009064,
-0.3634849190711975,
-0.21806322038173676,
-0.07946476340293884,
-0.6318234801292419,
1.2577019929885864,
-0.38206157088279724,
-0.2625885307788849,
-0.26685482263565063,
0.7921029329299927,
0.10234972834587097,
0.7387822270393372,
0.2731904089450836,
0.7043921947479248,
0.8855571746826172,
-0.08776687830686569,
0.9733745455741882,
-0.1391228288412094,
0.33092451095581055,
1.103986382484436,
-0.42280545830726624,
0.7540270686149597,
0.32583168148994446,
-0.2603326737880707,
0.8383984565734863,
0.6100369095802307,
-0.04485943540930748,
0.20615693926811218,
0.05936072766780853,
-0.5089077353477478,
-0.7698882222175598,
-0.14859679341316223,
-0.36788880825042725,
0.46684759855270386,
0.7087361812591553,
-0.04843360185623169,
-0.03939924016594887,
0.4430692195892334,
-0.1677471548318863,
0.40309351682662964,
-0.43633201718330383,
0.7675738334655762,
0.21396633982658386,
-0.592979907989502,
0.22043459117412567,
-0.2682192623615265,
0.4730852246284485,
-0.4782545864582062,
-0.45200315117836,
-0.06380585581064224,
0.2724400758743286,
-0.15914610028266907,
-0.6725488901138306,
-0.45280516147613525,
-0.22229135036468506,
0.156076118350029,
-0.030988629907369614,
0.4230077266693115,
-0.4472081959247589,
-0.5138965249061584,
0.46795597672462463,
0.7805527448654175,
0.24998979270458221,
0.05955217778682709,
-0.4068513810634613,
-0.1907760053873062,
-0.16210991144180298,
-0.38268086314201355,
0.3941931426525116,
0.46461302042007446,
0.024655068293213844,
0.8081244826316833,
0.8612791299819946,
-0.029756521806120872,
-0.10818755626678467,
0.34863680601119995,
0.8929277062416077,
-0.28535374999046326,
-0.5221349596977234,
-0.6073171496391296,
0.36377087235450745,
-0.015426949597895145,
-0.21702797710895538,
0.7590782642364502,
0.3170352280139923,
1.0472227334976196,
-0.11909573525190353,
0.8559890389442444,
0.2637595236301422,
0.08366051316261292,
-0.26965537667274475,
0.6283276081085205,
-0.5865352153778076,
0.24578675627708435,
-0.0428931899368763,
-0.8527703285217285,
0.2416059821844101,
0.7398674488067627,
-0.08340122550725937,
0.24296794831752777,
0.3563510775566101,
0.4232743978500366,
-0.045584652572870255,
0.09649976342916489,
0.6376568078994751,
0.12938903272151947,
0.3468570113182068,
0.41789451241493225,
0.9343474507331848,
-0.13918648660182953,
0.2950303554534912,
-0.14506392180919647,
-0.2930827736854553,
-0.5199640393257141,
-0.400703489780426,
-1.277803897857666,
-0.4937860667705536,
-0.42893338203430176,
-0.2384493350982666,
-0.07511167228221893,
1.2210620641708374,
0.23496806621551514,
-0.5408288240432739,
-0.08592639863491058,
-0.39980563521385193,
-0.05167284235358238,
-0.3559795618057251,
-0.26831427216529846,
0.1470436006784439,
-0.11293588578701019,
-0.9805223941802979,
0.36840173602104187,
-0.35285019874572754,
0.5545765161514282,
-0.4829883277416229,
-0.25183409452438354,
0.10137732326984406,
0.3418673872947693,
0.5971168875694275,
0.34393510222435,
-0.6308087110519409,
0.12329977005720139,
-0.2077513486146927,
-0.3622395098209381,
-0.2763884961605072,
0.7019949555397034,
-1.0482287406921387,
0.5612130761146545,
0.22014445066452026,
0.556849479675293,
0.43672776222229004,
-0.07491450011730194,
0.3478192985057831,
-0.5920278429985046,
0.32665979862213135,
0.36250558495521545,
0.4381275475025177,
0.2035292536020279,
-0.3780708312988281,
0.31513237953186035,
0.18469420075416565,
-0.3475339114665985,
-0.6469292044639587,
0.2571898102760315,
-0.9578995108604431,
-0.5936342477798462,
1.0208938121795654,
-0.45546409487724304,
-0.09224210679531097,
-0.058382149785757065,
0.02420041710138321,
0.41149455308914185,
-0.47751301527023315,
0.6885397434234619,
0.2897907495498657,
0.16929519176483154,
-0.0062646809965372086,
-0.8272664546966553,
0.4990139305591583,
0.2379578948020935,
-0.967250645160675,
-0.19306053221225739,
0.606350302696228,
0.12978921830654144,
0.17553678154945374,
0.17070241272449493,
0.4428443908691406,
0.1766415536403656,
0.4572994112968445,
0.4079945385456085,
-0.5256558656692505,
-0.5207844376564026,
-0.04012387990951538,
0.21067145466804504,
-0.16212110221385956,
-0.011018176563084126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15886v1
|
Leveraging Zero-Shot Prompting for Efficient Language Model Distillation
| 2024-03-23T16:51:52 | 2024-03-23T16:51:52 |
Lukas Vöge, Vincent Gurgul, Stefan Lessmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a novel approach for efficiently distilling LLMs into
smaller, application-specific models, significantly reducing operational costs
and manual labor. Addressing the challenge of deploying computationally
intensive LLMs in specific applications or edge devices, this technique
utilizes LLMs' reasoning capabilities to generate labels and natural language
rationales for unlabeled data. Our approach enhances both finetuning and
distillation by employing a multi-task training framework where student models
mimic these rationales alongside teacher predictions. Key contributions include
the employment of zero-shot prompting to elicit teacher model rationales,
reducing the necessity for handcrafted few-shot examples and lowering the
overall token count required, which directly translates to cost savings given
the pay-per-token billing model of major tech companies' LLM APIs.
Additionally, the paper investigates the impact of explanation properties on
distillation efficiency, demonstrating that minimal performance loss occurs
even when rationale augmentation is not applied across the entire dataset,
facilitating further reductions of tokens. This research marks a step toward
the efficient training of task-specific models with minimal human intervention,
offering substantial cost-savings while maintaining, or even enhancing,
performance.
|
[
-0.13757306337356567,
-0.8250575065612793,
0.888952374458313,
-0.02082282491028309,
-0.3781271278858185,
-0.10455253720283508,
-0.3370397686958313,
0.014695079065859318,
-0.3890526294708252,
0.4695385992527008,
-0.6078667044639587,
-0.5457562804222107,
-0.4298047125339508,
0.19939222931861877,
-0.37979093194007874,
0.8857438564300537,
-0.04549804702401161,
-0.00302238785661757,
-0.2682449519634247,
0.09077178686857224,
-0.6312537789344788,
-0.4246669411659241,
-0.6832719445228577,
-0.8011810779571533,
0.5192094445228577,
0.6965164542198181,
0.11876946687698364,
0.8144561648368835,
0.07713432610034943,
0.22355344891548157,
-0.03920625522732735,
0.09967634081840515,
-0.5214176177978516,
0.29643264412879944,
-0.06759929656982422,
-0.7344825267791748,
-0.1724955290555954,
0.21912823617458344,
0.1274821013212204,
0.6935781836509705,
-0.1469530314207077,
0.4767323136329651,
0.3030458986759186,
0.5533304810523987,
-0.7731810212135315,
0.15403223037719727,
-1.0530551671981812,
-0.052628640085458755,
-0.02934953197836876,
-0.24220353364944458,
-0.6405388712882996,
-0.060282062739133835,
0.0958387479186058,
-0.5277166962623596,
0.2690555453300476,
-0.18792624771595,
0.6206666231155396,
0.4796178340911865,
-0.1794673055410385,
-0.14073200523853302,
-0.8242316842079163,
0.8959826231002808,
-0.777346670627594,
-0.028648491948843002,
0.28730952739715576,
0.401999831199646,
-0.11266128718852997,
-0.7208511233329773,
-0.684546172618866,
-0.029767293483018875,
0.0870603621006012,
-0.03060060739517212,
-0.3860589265823364,
0.1990034580230713,
0.42458897829055786,
0.1882285624742508,
-0.2003905326128006,
0.12667837738990784,
-0.3276863694190979,
0.030444607138633728,
0.3273642957210541,
0.19126343727111816,
-0.19018252193927765,
0.03950536996126175,
-0.3842974007129669,
0.12933550775051117,
-0.6334667205810547,
0.04304086044430733,
0.18550631403923035,
0.6027795672416687,
0.005040828138589859,
0.7042659521102905,
-0.4231031537055969,
0.7350361943244934,
0.21138767898082733,
-0.5164920091629028,
-0.03270242363214493,
-0.22358408570289612,
-0.4395672678947449,
0.310805082321167,
0.6936337351799011,
0.2825050950050354,
0.33208367228507996,
-0.07641769200563431,
-0.2398410141468048,
0.21838675439357758,
0.10383189469575882,
-1.1357029676437378,
-0.15688925981521606,
0.3399257957935333,
-0.11156649887561798,
-0.4145914614200592,
-0.5766424536705017,
-0.35243043303489685,
-0.4578183889389038,
-0.7628520727157593,
0.36812764406204224,
-0.37815845012664795,
0.007519224192947149,
0.15279850363731384,
-0.47617730498313904,
0.061237115412950516,
0.4270372688770294,
-1.0005178451538086,
0.04828153923153877,
0.7396700978279114,
0.977769136428833,
-0.020877772942185402,
-0.08869785815477371,
-0.5197848081588745,
0.27932995557785034,
-0.2502206861972809,
0.6881545782089233,
-0.41815006732940674,
-0.47887247800827026,
-0.2989218235015869,
-0.33734264969825745,
0.11180593073368073,
-0.6524560451507568,
0.4918217360973358,
-0.1346169263124466,
-0.0621362179517746,
-0.1932401806116104,
-0.682211697101593,
-0.26610440015792847,
0.4265501797199249,
-0.36799129843711853,
1.0507882833480835,
-0.16289614140987396,
-0.5136135220527649,
0.4379141330718994,
-0.714637815952301,
-0.20906955003738403,
0.20782136917114258,
-0.1316215544939041,
-0.1946902871131897,
0.40895235538482666,
0.4270620048046112,
0.6744174361228943,
-0.5436002016067505,
0.49786990880966187,
-0.2753802537918091,
-0.309285044670105,
0.09519024193286896,
-0.9738718867301941,
0.7638136148452759,
0.4249170422554016,
-0.326290488243103,
-0.04520313814282417,
-0.7744967341423035,
-0.1931077390909195,
0.11451605707406998,
-0.443051278591156,
-0.4135661721229553,
-0.19362789392471313,
-0.3477309048175812,
0.042090121656656265,
0.20874641835689545,
-0.591911256313324,
0.3287108242511749,
-0.18043556809425354,
0.5153712630271912,
0.665252685546875,
-0.04453999921679497,
0.6650885343551636,
-0.19591264426708221,
0.5687631964683533,
-0.006812875159084797,
0.17113728821277618,
-0.5918186902999878,
-0.3390618860721588,
-0.7709793448448181,
-0.6196333765983582,
0.08349675685167313,
0.5918208956718445,
-0.8733697533607483,
0.05411943420767784,
-0.25464221835136414,
-0.5611940026283264,
-0.6342631578445435,
0.38525494933128357,
0.2501353323459625,
1.2117633819580078,
0.3177504539489746,
0.34617453813552856,
-0.3390846252441406,
-0.7424812912940979,
-0.18639305233955383,
-0.10474052280187607,
-0.16057263314723969,
0.1010599210858345,
0.2232373058795929,
0.1351795643568039,
1.3293975591659546,
-0.5722273588180542,
-0.06975499540567398,
-0.5038928985595703,
0.40341252088546753,
0.5755025148391724,
0.21794171631336212,
0.5667954683303833,
-0.3994178771972656,
-0.8256964683532715,
-0.16721376776695251,
-0.7285454869270325,
-0.5320584774017334,
-0.35260674357414246,
-0.11579440534114838,
0.2703053057193756,
0.4748530685901642,
-0.6104072332382202,
0.4558020532131195,
0.31017810106277466,
-0.00018385853036306798,
0.42660966515541077,
-0.16442325711250305,
0.07837546616792679,
-0.9861134886741638,
0.11214638501405716,
0.2042936533689499,
-0.17486725747585297,
-0.8935367465019226,
-0.2681261897087097,
-0.009910366497933865,
-0.24982042610645294,
-0.7216048240661621,
0.5551073551177979,
-0.5345199108123779,
0.3447887897491455,
-0.5424633026123047,
0.18434341251850128,
0.3077729046344757,
0.5096547603607178,
-0.04003438353538513,
0.8301731944084167,
0.6797104477882385,
-0.7052449584007263,
0.3385864794254303,
-0.16205884516239166,
-0.23547782003879547,
0.7719025015830994,
-0.7630944848060608,
-0.03852219134569168,
-0.2455340176820755,
0.0538778118789196,
-1.0454304218292236,
0.048028457909822464,
0.22122547030448914,
-0.21534740924835205,
0.2573210299015045,
-0.5137900114059448,
-0.49532550573349,
-0.347527414560318,
-0.3689570724964142,
0.08125025033950806,
0.6713769435882568,
-0.6769419312477112,
0.5960675477981567,
0.14123201370239258,
-0.0755571722984314,
-0.5582560300827026,
-0.9691340923309326,
0.11335569620132446,
-0.6074519157409668,
-0.3838411569595337,
0.22102992236614227,
-0.06454096734523773,
-0.261841356754303,
-0.07766491919755936,
-0.2992854714393616,
-0.15923559665679932,
0.39860886335372925,
0.1578480452299118,
0.5564053654670715,
-0.03853810206055641,
0.07228469848632812,
0.24985355138778687,
-0.25632983446121216,
-0.05430897697806358,
-0.47459620237350464,
0.37440550327301025,
0.2946939170360565,
-0.25690770149230957,
-0.8358149528503418,
0.08071795850992203,
0.5039820671081543,
0.1670146882534027,
0.6961658000946045,
0.3196694552898407,
-0.26027712225914,
-0.31320318579673767,
-0.6564847826957703,
-0.335920512676239,
-0.5501211285591125,
0.03332723677158356,
-0.4562127888202667,
-0.8602795004844666,
0.42309969663619995,
-0.36929425597190857,
0.35250091552734375,
0.1372552067041397,
0.7252810001373291,
0.04440532252192497,
0.8839049935340881,
0.4431479275226593,
0.025206761434674263,
0.496980220079422,
-0.20093479752540588,
0.4070865511894226,
-0.4733996093273163,
-0.22146527469158173,
-0.5555221438407898,
-0.344668984413147,
-0.15295761823654175,
-0.5908536314964294,
0.39843934774398804,
0.368681937456131,
-0.13983532786369324,
0.260738343000412,
-0.8554424047470093,
0.9528525471687317,
0.6439236998558044,
-0.2827420234680176,
0.417489230632782,
0.22985245287418365,
-0.18163324892520905,
0.11933793872594833,
-0.7732787132263184,
-0.7745404839515686,
1.214173436164856,
0.30032917857170105,
0.8557974696159363,
-0.23104137182235718,
1.0643724203109741,
0.048792701214551926,
0.34858623147010803,
-1.0508966445922852,
0.5509647130966187,
-0.05695817992091179,
-0.6530023217201233,
-0.3694519102573395,
-0.3530748188495636,
-0.7424814701080322,
0.3310924768447876,
-0.1291278898715973,
-0.7702153921127319,
-0.04657449945807457,
0.49499788880348206,
-0.6613575220108032,
0.3242966830730438,
-1.016208529472351,
0.7793466448783875,
-0.1966252624988556,
-0.3875323534011841,
-0.05682841315865517,
-0.2616540491580963,
0.5163357257843018,
-0.1081511527299881,
0.18804295361042023,
-0.5986965894699097,
-0.04397144541144371,
0.35159578919410706,
-0.7115491032600403,
0.9888646006584167,
-0.4780922830104828,
-0.16990895569324493,
0.6486179232597351,
0.06591760367155075,
0.45555931329727173,
-0.06480950862169266,
-0.35032281279563904,
0.23517386615276337,
-0.06271498650312424,
-0.187201127409935,
-0.6344669461250305,
0.7485247850418091,
-0.4485420882701874,
-0.7330132126808167,
-0.17731794714927673,
-0.6173065900802612,
-0.12270537763834,
0.1573023945093155,
0.12009444087743759,
0.2038753479719162,
0.13132373988628387,
0.07201384752988815,
0.5434594750404358,
-0.014325958676636219,
0.7677211761474609,
0.5837417840957642,
-0.03310588747262955,
-0.19934292137622833,
0.8042605519294739,
0.18321047723293304,
0.36922523379325867,
0.25424066185951233,
0.3735513687133789,
-0.5503277778625488,
-0.6424105763435364,
-0.5721055269241333,
0.03655315935611725,
-0.7251371741294861,
-0.349087655544281,
-0.5353884100914001,
0.14254195988178253,
-0.4143140912055969,
-0.27576902508735657,
-0.3769523799419403,
-0.5912559628486633,
-0.7497696876525879,
-0.20598728954792023,
0.7591744661331177,
0.3608274459838867,
-0.04158814623951912,
0.6498063802719116,
-0.8168941140174866,
0.3113425076007843,
0.3445553779602051,
0.16036736965179443,
0.12540236115455627,
-0.704804003238678,
-0.21098178625106812,
0.2445034384727478,
-0.4082185924053192,
-0.7887290120124817,
0.4518970549106598,
0.3828817903995514,
0.5683059692382812,
0.34553027153015137,
0.3735639154911041,
0.9969843626022339,
-0.6083150506019592,
0.8851713538169861,
0.46202608942985535,
-1.1736960411071777,
0.628511905670166,
-0.2468285858631134,
0.4930735230445862,
0.8169525861740112,
0.4680253267288208,
-0.3783564269542694,
-0.29787853360176086,
-0.18128077685832977,
-1.1008731126785278,
0.919741690158844,
0.02469276450574398,
0.38932186365127563,
-0.060899946838617325,
0.5681661367416382,
0.24753595888614655,
0.17828448116779327,
-0.6032388210296631,
-0.46157532930374146,
-0.10957944393157959,
-0.35600554943084717,
0.15938220918178558,
-0.28571760654449463,
-0.12423808872699738,
-0.43913525342941284,
0.7762826681137085,
-0.29009249806404114,
-0.24062880873680115,
-0.06590960919857025,
-0.12696003913879395,
0.3290241062641144,
0.41571834683418274,
0.4202754497528076,
0.40387168526649475,
0.01657547615468502,
0.3509068191051483,
0.3870670795440674,
-0.2199440896511078,
0.3613411486148834,
-0.08392395079135895,
-0.24741065502166748,
0.11454563587903976,
-0.12360404431819916,
1.066464900970459,
0.01601637527346611,
-0.6320318579673767,
0.3298300504684448,
-0.12100470066070557,
-0.44161635637283325,
-0.028751026839017868,
0.1945001482963562,
0.3275681734085083,
0.37867993116378784,
0.5052546262741089,
-0.31133031845092773,
0.22364461421966553,
-0.3466477394104004,
-0.03265973553061485,
0.3188275992870331,
-0.07055345177650452,
-0.011913493275642395,
0.739197850227356,
0.26648885011672974,
-0.08920995146036148,
0.5190597176551819,
-0.25042933225631714,
-0.013936722651124,
0.3928176760673523,
0.484315425157547,
0.9893291592597961,
0.06058312579989433,
0.2843274772167206,
0.40132009983062744,
0.07386787980794907,
-0.2036290317773819,
0.028635114431381226,
-0.38727715611457825,
-0.523022472858429,
-0.6176083087921143,
-0.6765471696853638,
-0.49127325415611267,
0.09427036345005035,
-0.5075342655181885,
0.5750858187675476,
-0.5205526947975159,
-0.3843719959259033,
0.2478247880935669,
-0.36520281434059143,
-0.43755993247032166,
-0.11634092777967453,
0.4605264663696289,
0.7959593534469604,
-0.7526830434799194,
0.9090086817741394,
0.37660107016563416,
-0.29787489771842957,
-0.9980371594429016,
-0.36414289474487305,
0.2087506651878357,
-0.7081326842308044,
0.7212563157081604,
0.24572455883026123,
-0.18592268228530884,
-0.004622179549187422,
-0.5996302366256714,
-0.4689252972602844,
1.3293567895889282,
0.9399620294570923,
-0.8964247703552246,
0.09466423839330673,
0.37447497248649597,
0.3433464467525482,
-0.30673205852508545,
0.29248544573783875,
0.7949387431144714,
0.27179664373397827,
0.5949246883392334,
-0.8537426590919495,
-0.03588634729385376,
-0.022753974422812462,
0.12994283437728882,
0.009831474162638187,
-0.08595682680606842,
0.8596237897872925,
-0.21083632111549377,
-0.42407751083374023,
-0.34300100803375244,
0.33809414505958557,
0.4275190532207489,
0.4725145697593689,
0.31131836771965027,
0.513353705406189,
0.7935582399368286,
-0.10684062540531158,
0.7735922336578369,
-0.49730560183525085,
0.28593990206718445,
1.3576887845993042,
-0.4910230040550232,
0.6712036728858948,
0.8817044496536255,
-0.08249283581972122,
0.24599871039390564,
0.4412858188152313,
0.07957037538290024,
0.5260874032974243,
0.32878562808036804,
-0.6435732245445251,
-0.3454594314098358,
-0.42594200372695923,
0.09791907668113708,
0.4163437783718109,
0.16081459820270538,
-0.12838102877140045,
-0.5856702327728271,
0.1421959549188614,
0.2295391708612442,
0.07622458040714264,
-0.34115326404571533,
0.8896988034248352,
0.1998363584280014,
-0.699115514755249,
0.9688482284545898,
-0.010443273931741714,
0.9813272953033447,
-0.4534762501716614,
0.05936846882104874,
-0.10855697095394135,
0.17354293167591095,
-0.14277972280979156,
-0.562670886516571,
0.4021793007850647,
0.5538013577461243,
-0.3072797656059265,
-0.6754917502403259,
0.5760329365730286,
-0.6200617551803589,
-0.4686312675476074,
0.007651558145880699,
0.44700485467910767,
0.3702477216720581,
-0.19461199641227722,
-0.6471030712127686,
0.031037811189889908,
0.08497054129838943,
-0.21396207809448242,
0.19506843388080597,
0.6829647421836853,
0.08460519462823868,
0.6330992579460144,
0.8155015707015991,
0.10467999428510666,
0.1372983753681183,
0.26253437995910645,
0.8977882266044617,
-0.34928998351097107,
-0.24295756220817566,
-1.403640866279602,
0.7044638395309448,
-0.05329743027687073,
0.04358532652258873,
0.7237752079963684,
0.48038434982299805,
0.748466968536377,
-0.09877443313598633,
0.9035313129425049,
0.2505813241004944,
0.35513854026794434,
-0.3635210692882538,
0.693435549736023,
-0.4860096275806427,
0.5622701644897461,
0.043892472982406616,
-0.719873309135437,
-0.17549774050712585,
0.480546772480011,
-0.33402684330940247,
-0.2544213831424713,
0.36703184247016907,
0.78229159116745,
0.08136828243732452,
-0.16452981531620026,
0.4793018400669098,
-0.14964474737644196,
0.4327148497104645,
0.39190587401390076,
0.5896961688995361,
-0.14847254753112793,
0.5283051133155823,
-0.5147048234939575,
-0.17717209458351135,
-0.10881389677524567,
-1.2448481321334839,
-0.983911395072937,
-0.13386797904968262,
-0.6024734377861023,
0.02668110281229019,
-0.24987481534481049,
1.0555323362350464,
0.6583834886550903,
-0.6412106156349182,
-0.31337571144104004,
-0.3438689112663269,
0.13621698319911957,
0.053702037781476974,
-0.2357134073972702,
-0.15506820380687714,
-0.6966926455497742,
-0.9755598306655884,
0.42894405126571655,
0.39352571964263916,
0.27819064259529114,
-0.19081059098243713,
0.0517648421227932,
-0.04228384792804718,
0.32099732756614685,
0.7002643346786499,
0.2014077752828598,
-0.7182421088218689,
0.11307085305452347,
0.05534014850854874,
-0.02553776279091835,
-0.08332376927137375,
0.7969689965248108,
-0.8941454291343689,
0.5105196237564087,
0.5101981163024902,
0.5445519089698792,
0.5882176756858826,
-0.0991939827799797,
0.4766445755958557,
-0.9706380367279053,
0.3601926267147064,
0.16591821610927582,
0.17003130912780762,
0.30428817868232727,
-0.3330317735671997,
0.40884432196617126,
0.18237249553203583,
-0.28452757000923157,
-1.1089969873428345,
0.0493483729660511,
-0.8527407050132751,
-0.38947832584381104,
1.1713855266571045,
-0.400508314371109,
-0.2632095515727997,
-0.15291620790958405,
-0.22205649316310883,
0.3637903332710266,
-0.5671550035476685,
0.7044139504432678,
0.6057159900665283,
-0.2766292989253998,
-0.21034552156925201,
-0.5589625239372253,
0.2944272756576538,
0.2513270080089569,
-0.7068387866020203,
0.3852408826351166,
0.6359351277351379,
0.38190311193466187,
-0.06617885828018188,
0.6698169112205505,
0.08020293712615967,
-0.08760391920804977,
0.0266275517642498,
0.26661497354507446,
-0.5431590676307678,
-0.2266397476196289,
-0.5483635067939758,
0.06558915227651596,
0.222225159406662,
-0.36305373907089233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15885v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15885v2
|
STEntConv: Predicting Disagreement with Stance Detection and a Signed Graph Convolutional Network
| 2024-03-23T16:45:22 | 2024-03-26T10:26:04 |
Isabelle Lorge, Li Zhang, Xiaowen Dong, Janet B. Pierrehumbert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rise of social media platforms has led to an increase in polarised online
discussions, especially on political and socio-cultural topics such as
elections and climate change. We propose a simple and novel unsupervised method
to predict whether the authors of two posts agree or disagree, leveraging user
stances about named entities obtained from their posts. We present STEntConv, a
model which builds a graph of users and named entities weighted by stance and
trains a Signed Graph Convolutional Network (SGCN) to detect disagreement
between comment and reply posts. We run experiments and ablation studies and
show that including this information improves disagreement detection
performance on a dataset of Reddit posts for a range of controversial subreddit
topics, without the need for platform-specific features or user history.
|
[
-0.8579110503196716,
-0.7346014976501465,
0.3288300931453705,
0.13021282851696014,
-0.6697546243667603,
0.37391823530197144,
-0.20110279321670532,
-0.377346932888031,
0.7113989591598511,
0.37045663595199585,
-0.281210333108902,
-0.6483510136604309,
-0.9598902463912964,
-0.18268106877803802,
-0.3500731587409973,
0.8942846059799194,
0.00957255344837904,
0.36448240280151367,
-0.41319599747657776,
-0.31482043862342834,
-0.20186105370521545,
-0.2509649693965912,
-0.8444945216178894,
-0.609765350818634,
0.778343141078949,
0.40749916434288025,
0.7714822292327881,
0.19442419707775116,
0.5490933656692505,
0.2797561585903168,
-0.25222161412239075,
0.23583748936653137,
-0.4115559756755829,
0.46878719329833984,
-0.20516113936901093,
-0.11543598026037216,
0.04656978324055672,
-0.36126846075057983,
0.2647237777709961,
0.4144047200679779,
0.2577133774757385,
-0.12791626155376434,
0.016537867486476898,
0.5603028535842896,
-0.35151124000549316,
0.04886410012841225,
-0.8234831690788269,
-0.10597311705350876,
-0.22493234276771545,
0.006047705188393593,
-0.20608839392662048,
-0.453197717666626,
-0.15539419651031494,
-0.1923677623271942,
0.31296220421791077,
-0.303833931684494,
0.7381901741027832,
0.3897327184677124,
-0.6344723105430603,
-0.271270215511322,
-0.6346594095230103,
0.37057051062583923,
-0.6673734784126282,
0.5203719735145569,
0.12925264239311218,
0.030415717512369156,
-0.3253853917121887,
-0.8061723113059998,
-0.6544939875602722,
0.08891361206769943,
-0.044523101300001144,
0.11630532890558243,
-0.3689202666282654,
-0.08991314470767975,
-0.007563212886452675,
-0.028250204399228096,
-0.5157972574234009,
0.17390908300876617,
-0.28830185532569885,
-0.359669029712677,
0.5334773659706116,
-0.14936614036560059,
0.28491416573524475,
-0.5388609766960144,
-0.42437827587127686,
0.16019630432128906,
-0.6256071925163269,
0.4554333984851837,
0.8320686221122742,
0.37112298607826233,
-0.0826529860496521,
0.7037583589553833,
0.017089644446969032,
0.47606131434440613,
0.3908003568649292,
0.4142031967639923,
-0.14005188643932343,
-0.03769074007868767,
0.00890266988426447,
0.2143111526966095,
1.0114712715148926,
0.542975664138794,
0.1343657672405243,
0.16155952215194702,
-0.045509494841098785,
0.5350341200828552,
-0.020534170791506767,
-0.7644676566123962,
-0.788946807384491,
0.19357921183109283,
-0.4434456527233124,
-0.4204411208629608,
0.21656838059425354,
-0.5246869325637817,
-1.2121708393096924,
-0.44125378131866455,
-0.15643569827079773,
0.026758497580885887,
-0.6231362819671631,
-0.077922523021698,
-0.26729366183280945,
-0.1892486810684204,
0.6428115963935852,
-0.4575096666812897,
0.14282453060150146,
1.014351725578308,
0.9462072253227234,
-0.1318659782409668,
0.04107961058616638,
-0.41267502307891846,
-0.5352045893669128,
-0.36484163999557495,
1.1037148237228394,
-0.6127176880836487,
-0.3020959794521332,
-0.09631013870239258,
0.23052622377872467,
0.341656893491745,
-0.044046979397535324,
0.3365594446659088,
-0.7295297980308533,
-0.08838462829589844,
-0.43724489212036133,
-0.6857105493545532,
0.012392621487379074,
0.39682039618492126,
-0.7718406319618225,
0.6466660499572754,
-0.3850835859775543,
-1.2605412006378174,
0.5754574537277222,
-0.22401078045368195,
-0.5432785749435425,
0.21885079145431519,
-0.5117170810699463,
-0.7593198418617249,
-0.2667095363140106,
-0.02217590995132923,
0.5548495650291443,
0.025552507489919662,
0.35765185952186584,
-0.8260089159011841,
-0.1603490710258484,
0.5172483325004578,
0.0707084983587265,
0.982031524181366,
0.16118107736110687,
-0.29591506719589233,
0.3691404163837433,
-0.3454973101615906,
-0.41842952370643616,
-0.22870297729969025,
-0.2236475795507431,
-0.4934321641921997,
0.2224169373512268,
-0.07655559480190277,
0.1218622699379921,
0.2989644408226013,
-0.8776640892028809,
0.2135193943977356,
-0.10636262595653534,
0.7249351739883423,
0.7265717387199402,
0.4134295582771301,
0.21313826739788055,
-0.03773472458124161,
0.27375057339668274,
0.3154861330986023,
0.11929053068161011,
0.44616594910621643,
-0.8434520959854126,
-0.468447208404541,
0.2410147786140442,
0.392962247133255,
0.21544551849365234,
-0.7731797695159912,
0.1080455482006073,
-0.11233524978160858,
-0.6166718602180481,
-0.1557333618402481,
0.3188535273075104,
0.2298453003168106,
0.4857904314994812,
0.05474657565355301,
-0.38626882433891296,
-0.8225800395011902,
-0.5281429886817932,
-0.2949734628200531,
-0.599656879901886,
0.43369895219802856,
0.3273523151874542,
0.32265275716781616,
-0.20530879497528076,
0.6509369015693665,
-0.2721584141254425,
-0.08203976601362228,
-0.03625810518860817,
0.6789295673370361,
-0.19351205229759216,
0.2852585017681122,
0.35956239700317383,
-1.1051692962646484,
-0.6882821917533875,
0.2804641127586365,
-0.6024118661880493,
0.35866662859916687,
0.04748968034982681,
-0.024369755759835243,
0.24201035499572754,
0.8398944735527039,
-0.43980827927589417,
0.2939077615737915,
0.6805144548416138,
-0.32090285420417786,
0.21494223177433014,
0.11513720452785492,
0.3360699713230133,
-1.1400951147079468,
-0.06545697897672653,
0.41853633522987366,
-0.5916340947151184,
-0.45637086033821106,
-0.5889435410499573,
-0.19996494054794312,
-0.050959475338459015,
-0.690808117389679,
0.4101117253303528,
-0.17939378321170807,
-0.009265553206205368,
-0.22705277800559998,
0.11159344017505646,
-0.2868903577327728,
0.17650489509105682,
0.28320395946502686,
0.34853923320770264,
0.5275145769119263,
-0.31644657254219055,
0.5691414475440979,
0.44981178641319275,
-0.13136808574199677,
0.43361327052116394,
-0.7405348420143127,
0.4208751320838928,
-0.3325701355934143,
0.32634201645851135,
-1.6475191116333008,
-0.2611905336380005,
0.27863645553588867,
-0.832849383354187,
0.10822436213493347,
-0.8484184741973877,
-0.0900997444987297,
-0.4004468619823456,
-0.16826695203781128,
0.39873501658439636,
0.05358121544122696,
-0.28990083932876587,
0.4234095811843872,
0.6828327775001526,
-0.07040417939424515,
-0.8472105264663696,
-0.6454011797904968,
0.16947852075099945,
-0.018045641481876373,
-0.6347712874412537,
0.03869542479515076,
0.0186486653983593,
-0.3399587869644165,
0.2584279477596283,
0.08254201710224152,
0.0011074504582211375,
0.02988174557685852,
0.5588277578353882,
-0.04408900812268257,
-0.18293198943138123,
0.3830985426902771,
-0.17300166189670563,
-0.0958547443151474,
0.012638448737561703,
-0.2462717890739441,
0.5771540999412537,
-0.3958485722541809,
-0.3655337393283844,
-0.37807172536849976,
0.13342151045799255,
0.7781051993370056,
0.03964577987790108,
0.5221043825149536,
0.43660861253738403,
-0.5223973989486694,
-0.0988667756319046,
-0.1874353587627411,
-0.1873364895582199,
-0.3937424421310425,
0.10786864906549454,
0.16434001922607422,
-0.8806557059288025,
0.7615038156509399,
-0.2751600444316864,
0.01072754804044962,
0.34209054708480835,
0.7444548010826111,
-0.3071136772632599,
1.1914575099945068,
0.3875012695789337,
0.13040241599082947,
0.5723524689674377,
-0.10181506723165512,
0.29781851172447205,
-0.3613806664943695,
-0.2558863162994385,
-0.4109551012516022,
-0.7557942867279053,
-0.8269992470741272,
0.007864575833082199,
0.04425879195332527,
0.01336091011762619,
-0.37346163392066956,
0.6111737489700317,
-0.8242629766464233,
0.35734835267066956,
0.03125400096178055,
0.31204909086227417,
0.09971237927675247,
-0.07770795375108719,
-0.01711907424032688,
-0.2686420679092407,
-0.3616812527179718,
-0.33725184202194214,
0.8704099059104919,
0.16099943220615387,
0.7292208075523376,
0.22684060037136078,
0.4750136435031891,
0.9329547882080078,
0.5929891467094421,
-0.9730504751205444,
0.345369815826416,
-0.4199049770832062,
-0.3524492084980011,
-0.2542027235031128,
-0.24637871980667114,
-1.1436659097671509,
-0.022260062396526337,
-0.4866315722465515,
-0.38749924302101135,
0.47936323285102844,
0.2789115607738495,
-0.20623064041137695,
0.7402130961418152,
-0.35436466336250305,
1.0535398721694946,
-0.236174076795578,
-0.2887761890888214,
0.06524410843849182,
-0.6580374240875244,
0.22858676314353943,
0.30416759848594666,
-0.2178676277399063,
0.0010627273004502058,
0.23367716372013092,
0.9061393737792969,
-0.3678603768348694,
0.9491940140724182,
-0.33432939648628235,
0.18104644119739532,
0.44762787222862244,
0.1607353389263153,
0.5112568736076355,
0.3742455542087555,
-0.0725565254688263,
0.18438725173473358,
-0.15056924521923065,
-0.2257944643497467,
-0.4572814106941223,
1.0276144742965698,
-0.9431036114692688,
-0.31185004115104675,
-0.26115673780441284,
0.09364891052246094,
-0.10293290764093399,
0.28572461009025574,
0.4989456236362457,
0.4275154769420624,
-0.5586180090904236,
0.41711363196372986,
0.7559576630592346,
0.45137378573417664,
0.2669154107570648,
0.0745013952255249,
-0.23747238516807556,
-0.5367844700813293,
0.666509211063385,
0.2299838364124298,
-0.18232886493206024,
0.06467695534229279,
0.3952963650226593,
-0.5116257667541504,
-0.6113239526748657,
-0.35439440608024597,
0.17259718477725983,
-1.0930365324020386,
-0.41906535625457764,
-0.5640491247177124,
-0.16528993844985962,
-0.4612380862236023,
-0.24147062003612518,
-0.5542246103286743,
-0.49954429268836975,
-0.28260502219200134,
-0.019282758235931396,
0.5721718668937683,
1.0819658041000366,
0.0992213785648346,
0.24664084613323212,
-0.20040258765220642,
0.021832384169101715,
0.3016074001789093,
0.29202574491500854,
-0.344098836183548,
-0.25509586930274963,
0.0924714133143425,
0.20687974989414215,
-0.372485488653183,
-0.9426611661911011,
-0.042912837117910385,
-0.15608495473861694,
0.1361050009727478,
0.665831983089447,
0.28725188970565796,
0.3797317445278168,
0.2900019884109497,
0.7050656676292419,
0.5540947318077087,
-0.8331259489059448,
0.512459933757782,
-0.25522494316101074,
-0.28861433267593384,
0.49263814091682434,
0.4935499131679535,
-0.7885211706161499,
-0.3662329614162445,
-0.7438687086105347,
-0.5666809678077698,
0.12549830973148346,
-0.05934183672070503,
0.009499525651335716,
-0.07025739550590515,
0.30623430013656616,
-0.04146261885762215,
0.3815143406391144,
-0.7167617678642273,
-0.13689233362674713,
-0.5645351409912109,
-0.19376985728740692,
-0.0029342358466237783,
0.1361093819141388,
-0.43015098571777344,
-0.3766995370388031,
0.5623789429664612,
-0.38861173391342163,
0.01614963263273239,
0.18319112062454224,
0.0525546669960022,
-0.4015127718448639,
-0.019047843292355537,
0.6953984498977661,
0.6259161233901978,
0.08903869241476059,
0.7179746627807617,
0.019582459703087807,
-0.13526247441768646,
0.16705568134784698,
-0.017935561016201973,
-0.31531834602355957,
0.14952145516872406,
0.0028734721709042788,
0.7981036901473999,
0.011368867941200733,
0.094771608710289,
0.7871149182319641,
-0.44550958275794983,
-0.42705705761909485,
-0.31857410073280334,
-0.3160840570926666,
0.5515997409820557,
0.2177520990371704,
-0.3698027431964874,
0.7565945982933044,
-0.20435138046741486,
-0.49498608708381653,
0.5453454256057739,
0.5824577808380127,
-1.0848194360733032,
-0.43941882252693176,
0.6483862996101379,
0.17648561298847198,
-0.4464680552482605,
0.23067054152488708,
-0.19621142745018005,
-0.7104020118713379,
0.7672688364982605,
-0.022936196997761726,
0.6680487990379333,
-0.07881568372249603,
0.7031999826431274,
0.255452036857605,
0.013692549429833889,
0.007077621761709452,
0.22699883580207825,
-0.010677951388061047,
-0.9902424812316895,
0.08300326764583588,
-0.16288095712661743,
-0.539548397064209,
0.07445958256721497,
-0.29948118329048157,
0.6319088935852051,
-0.924648642539978,
-0.6324551701545715,
0.505106508731842,
0.2099144011735916,
-0.5843775272369385,
-0.11175177991390228,
0.09623859822750092,
0.3261067271232605,
-1.2008670568466187,
0.5412538647651672,
1.1187314987182617,
-0.42023980617523193,
-0.38463494181632996,
0.04303518310189247,
0.13496769964694977,
-0.45535343885421753,
0.2802569568157196,
-0.05890295282006264,
-0.397114634513855,
-0.24918514490127563,
-0.8189442157745361,
-0.3667427599430084,
0.7259801626205444,
0.5418674349784851,
-0.3422386050224304,
0.6455459594726562,
-0.008978811092674732,
0.7064307332038879,
-0.2733716368675232,
-0.05038456618785858,
0.059266723692417145,
0.5180658102035522,
0.32995325326919556,
-0.14642277359962463,
0.14804506301879883,
-0.2824091613292694,
-0.3547736406326294,
0.30373185873031616,
-0.9185288548469543,
1.0324218273162842,
-0.012866548262536526,
-0.3112852871417999,
-0.3992187976837158,
0.8413211107254028,
-0.05352654308080673,
0.443933367729187,
0.7461414337158203,
0.3784158229827881,
1.0295264720916748,
-0.21267539262771606,
0.6618345379829407,
-0.37841424345970154,
0.6208917498588562,
0.6679595708847046,
-0.20832346379756927,
0.7306221723556519,
0.4831981062889099,
0.1350497156381607,
0.7301470637321472,
0.9667689800262451,
0.0328533798456192,
0.2613036334514618,
0.2732779085636139,
-0.3750581443309784,
-0.7471953630447388,
-0.18205487728118896,
-0.259268581867218,
0.2311762273311615,
0.3389158546924591,
-0.1421779841184616,
-0.24564673006534576,
-0.04880920797586441,
0.2419501692056656,
0.32817548513412476,
-0.2761513590812683,
0.9010570049285889,
0.10537279397249222,
-0.9871490597724915,
0.45930197834968567,
-0.12955984473228455,
0.4404606223106384,
-0.2518257200717926,
0.12401936203241348,
-0.05609406158328056,
0.3521159887313843,
-0.5450319647789001,
-1.4156609773635864,
0.373867928981781,
-0.19878573715686798,
-0.04225347936153412,
-0.1576869934797287,
1.1201553344726562,
-0.5454025864601135,
-0.5200890302658081,
0.4420410692691803,
0.3158843517303467,
0.11468968540430069,
0.16762544214725494,
-1.0519795417785645,
0.07691066712141037,
-0.06865154206752777,
-0.18005606532096863,
0.21199415624141693,
0.40916070342063904,
-0.2783101499080658,
0.49248841404914856,
0.7585479617118835,
-0.007404097821563482,
-0.2514374256134033,
0.24907903373241425,
0.9928262829780579,
0.03632499650120735,
-0.48441261053085327,
-0.739228367805481,
0.42164522409439087,
-0.2985924780368805,
-0.3031385540962219,
0.6117402911186218,
0.42219457030296326,
0.6562222242355347,
0.35156962275505066,
0.9995330572128296,
0.0018569778185337782,
0.20563435554504395,
-0.17123723030090332,
0.7903392314910889,
-0.554738461971283,
0.10317547619342804,
-0.10460595786571503,
-0.3077393174171448,
-0.5075911283493042,
0.42937612533569336,
-0.35602834820747375,
-0.19976015388965607,
0.3501955568790436,
0.8432439565658569,
-0.28482717275619507,
0.18193992972373962,
0.05180474370718002,
0.06334076821804047,
0.5263386964797974,
0.23348790407180786,
0.7663988471031189,
-0.2817685306072235,
0.5052900314331055,
-0.19662708044052124,
0.20627816021442413,
-0.23480618000030518,
-0.9276636838912964,
-1.0873312950134277,
-0.778529703617096,
-0.7162789106369019,
-0.9813060760498047,
-0.03398927301168442,
0.8413745760917664,
0.49535220861434937,
-1.0859079360961914,
-0.09774409234523773,
-0.5453212261199951,
0.7642108201980591,
0.004098120145499706,
-0.17480924725532532,
0.4470265507698059,
0.1485949456691742,
-0.36529961228370667,
-0.12284872680902481,
0.11688170582056046,
0.14001750946044922,
-0.4744913876056671,
-0.29578959941864014,
-0.2516805827617645,
0.19299493730068207,
0.1647375375032425,
0.7773538827896118,
-0.7708141207695007,
-0.5627854466438293,
-0.02539682388305664,
-0.17524272203445435,
0.31260162591934204,
1.0950685739517212,
-0.3494631350040436,
0.5874934792518616,
0.9584500789642334,
0.49728018045425415,
0.6858242154121399,
0.428846150636673,
0.18807202577590942,
-0.7767671942710876,
0.020726047456264496,
0.11321999132633209,
0.6626638174057007,
0.7773102521896362,
-0.576016902923584,
-0.12082964181900024,
0.741905927658081,
-0.6851834654808044,
-0.5485946536064148,
0.38009968400001526,
-1.0670664310455322,
-0.36752447485923767,
1.0498712062835693,
-0.10991328209638596,
-0.14306500554084778,
-0.4975188076496124,
-0.211903378367424,
0.41502389311790466,
-0.5701847672462463,
0.6697389483451843,
0.6267308592796326,
-0.2007645219564438,
-0.19764961302280426,
0.0681048184633255,
0.7433710694313049,
0.13080424070358276,
-0.3547472655773163,
0.12595240771770477,
0.220907524228096,
0.34874090552330017,
0.13131840527057648,
0.7656423449516296,
0.21559208631515503,
0.261037141084671,
-0.23549088835716248,
-0.11529947072267532,
-0.012885835953056812,
-0.43398529291152954,
-0.12651270627975464,
0.3377549350261688,
-0.03730571269989014,
-0.07584090530872345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15882v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15882v1
|
VLUE: A New Benchmark and Multi-task Knowledge Transfer Learning for Vietnamese Natural Language Understanding
| 2024-03-23T16:26:49 | 2024-03-23T16:26:49 |
Phong Nguyen-Thuan Do, Son Quoc Tran, Phu Gia Hoang, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The success of Natural Language Understanding (NLU) benchmarks in various
languages, such as GLUE for English, CLUE for Chinese, KLUE for Korean, and
IndoNLU for Indonesian, has facilitated the evaluation of new NLU models across
a wide range of tasks. To establish a standardized set of benchmarks for
Vietnamese NLU, we introduce the first Vietnamese Language Understanding
Evaluation (VLUE) benchmark. The VLUE benchmark encompasses five datasets
covering different NLU tasks, including text classification, span extraction,
and natural language understanding. To provide an insightful overview of the
current state of Vietnamese NLU, we then evaluate seven state-of-the-art
pre-trained models, including both multilingual and Vietnamese monolingual
models, on our proposed VLUE benchmark. Furthermore, we present CafeBERT, a new
state-of-the-art pre-trained model that achieves superior results across all
tasks in the VLUE benchmark. Our model combines the proficiency of a
multilingual pre-trained model with Vietnamese linguistic knowledge. CafeBERT
is developed based on the XLM-RoBERTa model, with an additional pretraining
step utilizing a significant amount of Vietnamese textual data to enhance its
adaptation to the Vietnamese language. For the purpose of future research,
CafeBERT is made publicly available for research purposes.
|
[
-0.115624338388443,
-0.7841936349868774,
0.49469029903411865,
0.36361926794052124,
-0.168214350938797,
-0.00960105936974287,
-0.3563469350337982,
-0.5246632099151611,
-0.29313790798187256,
0.6458202004432678,
-0.33189141750335693,
-0.6578227877616882,
-0.8068951368331909,
0.28981727361679077,
-0.161733016371727,
0.8613014221191406,
-0.2145652174949646,
-0.03619270399212837,
-0.14244702458381653,
-0.5196714997291565,
-0.5797100067138672,
-0.5385469198226929,
-0.7287659049034119,
-0.22763289511203766,
0.5008850693702698,
0.20554253458976746,
0.22437214851379395,
0.45934000611305237,
0.24264958500862122,
0.25070831179618835,
0.11875215172767639,
0.18445806205272675,
-0.7934278249740601,
-0.4391132593154907,
-0.06019872426986694,
-0.6870610117912292,
-0.3088427782058716,
0.10664518922567368,
0.4268674850463867,
0.5494387745857239,
0.20451225340366364,
0.27687111496925354,
-0.009911826811730862,
0.8441573977470398,
-0.8690868020057678,
0.5742820501327515,
-0.579179048538208,
-0.026747163385152817,
0.21646000444889069,
0.0565703883767128,
-0.6243371367454529,
-0.41577035188674927,
0.4891676902770996,
-0.9840817451477051,
-0.04761236906051636,
-0.4457991421222687,
1.035628318786621,
0.3650977909564972,
-0.7659273743629456,
-0.015631752088665962,
-0.5379008054733276,
0.7106307148933411,
-0.4707624614238739,
0.6468145847320557,
0.34028008580207825,
0.5660613179206848,
0.2398691177368164,
-0.7728833556175232,
-0.48040035367012024,
-0.5072392821311951,
-0.1766112893819809,
0.3508526086807251,
-0.22559888660907745,
-0.1423446536064148,
-0.1466478705406189,
0.24063575267791748,
-0.8678498268127441,
0.11909795552492142,
-0.4903188943862915,
0.012305979616940022,
0.46251463890075684,
-0.21337464451789856,
0.013224111869931221,
-0.22027598321437836,
-0.8964467644691467,
0.05387827754020691,
-0.29002612829208374,
0.08528690040111542,
-0.22478275001049042,
0.19993506371974945,
-0.1943972408771515,
0.2443889081478119,
-0.12140076607465744,
0.9903114438056946,
-0.5707632303237915,
-0.15167196094989777,
0.43204429745674133,
-0.6675079464912415,
-0.5304716229438782,
-0.020510079339146614,
0.7894891500473022,
0.3179311156272888,
0.49072831869125366,
-0.17466898262500763,
0.12834767997264862,
0.1432609260082245,
0.2631358206272125,
-0.33480286598205566,
-0.3673131763935089,
0.06935668736696243,
-0.3090111315250397,
-0.11691354960203171,
0.23465685546398163,
-0.3729534149169922,
-0.20630812644958496,
-0.704314649105072,
0.6364465355873108,
-0.5214155912399292,
-0.5810571312904358,
0.4690416157245636,
-0.16226430237293243,
0.5002400279045105,
0.5007734894752502,
-0.2571103870868683,
0.4842977225780487,
0.8305246233940125,
0.8200458288192749,
-0.5345245599746704,
-0.5345821976661682,
-0.9065393805503845,
0.06893102824687958,
-0.005689672194421291,
0.7405252456665039,
-0.10641900449991226,
-0.2526743412017822,
0.18266817927360535,
0.27692943811416626,
-0.5723733305931091,
-0.650574803352356,
0.9239234924316406,
-0.22708803415298462,
0.20973952114582062,
-0.06780429929494858,
-0.6688719391822815,
-0.5039254426956177,
0.2650958001613617,
-0.7800630331039429,
1.2868998050689697,
0.512579619884491,
-0.6067143082618713,
0.2856386601924896,
-0.5899283289909363,
-0.3398609757423401,
0.1386478990316391,
0.0035999054089188576,
-0.26611843705177307,
-0.009731101803481579,
0.2124994397163391,
0.2336345911026001,
-0.24779319763183594,
0.019911857321858406,
-0.06168348714709282,
-0.2035146951675415,
-0.05127914994955063,
-0.2217395156621933,
1.1261519193649292,
0.16896368563175201,
-0.142499640583992,
0.4135569930076599,
-0.8283056616783142,
-0.04022075608372688,
0.15477946400642395,
-0.23885245621204376,
-0.3873009979724884,
-0.5950068235397339,
0.4219394326210022,
0.179033562541008,
0.3563508689403534,
-0.11489832401275635,
0.16154280304908752,
-0.07879143208265305,
0.2775772213935852,
0.535866379737854,
-0.2734121084213257,
0.4320980906486511,
-0.1414249986410141,
0.4263595938682556,
-0.012630668468773365,
0.13648274540901184,
-0.2347603291273117,
-0.44637444615364075,
-0.7060295343399048,
-0.454117089509964,
0.31702831387519836,
0.9071484804153442,
-0.6608568429946899,
0.4213690757751465,
-0.16062094271183014,
-0.6239886283874512,
-1.2345720529556274,
0.3766602873802185,
0.39040085673332214,
0.638630747795105,
0.48337459564208984,
-0.1819065511226654,
-0.6301144361495972,
-0.6588292717933655,
-0.42919695377349854,
-0.15950331091880798,
-0.1980087012052536,
0.17972102761268616,
0.33222317695617676,
-0.4000381529331207,
0.6048564314842224,
-0.3827177584171295,
-0.49503856897354126,
-0.37616410851478577,
0.47702574729919434,
0.3193066418170929,
0.16155731678009033,
0.7080801129341125,
-0.8851644992828369,
-0.6655178666114807,
0.419420063495636,
-0.7920998334884644,
-0.07975059747695923,
0.07456821203231812,
-0.2184399962425232,
0.2997758090496063,
0.6649502515792847,
-0.5690008401870728,
0.33441269397735596,
0.6389352679252625,
-0.16612552106380463,
0.8803609013557434,
-0.4342794716358185,
0.08814944326877594,
-0.9293015599250793,
0.028422489762306213,
0.1753293126821518,
-0.4110826551914215,
-0.7769601941108704,
0.07339788228273392,
0.24419590830802917,
0.1322861611843109,
-0.6590505242347717,
0.6819154024124146,
-0.33153048157691956,
0.15119050443172455,
-0.3826810121536255,
0.6230576038360596,
0.1933017522096634,
0.2815985679626465,
0.2697749137878418,
0.4560277760028839,
0.6082098484039307,
-0.6954701542854309,
0.20642513036727905,
-0.07133904844522476,
-0.34469833970069885,
0.720794141292572,
-0.657063364982605,
0.2260071486234665,
-0.18253855407238007,
0.03862950578331947,
-0.957127034664154,
0.40564489364624023,
0.04392359033226967,
-0.2647000849246979,
0.12051445245742798,
-0.40048015117645264,
-0.18795272707939148,
-0.21728576719760895,
-0.02748083882033825,
0.3439401090145111,
0.2381235808134079,
-0.5130796432495117,
0.41801199316978455,
0.21061226725578308,
0.26010024547576904,
-0.66115403175354,
-0.23933084309101105,
0.014461188577115536,
-0.39372360706329346,
-0.46750324964523315,
0.19313208758831024,
-0.13376714289188385,
-0.21191737055778503,
0.023651598021388054,
-0.056857723742723465,
-0.43770632147789,
0.22395995259284973,
-0.23908023536205292,
0.38291996717453003,
-0.7189038991928101,
0.131283700466156,
-0.42707914113998413,
-0.4279821515083313,
0.12446869164705276,
-0.6809746623039246,
0.2866990268230438,
-0.4057905673980713,
0.15757104754447937,
-0.4206239581108093,
-0.015382291749119759,
0.44979551434516907,
-0.6506680846214294,
0.8329224586486816,
1.2375507354736328,
-0.43890586495399475,
0.08563783764839172,
-0.39914074540138245,
0.1885312795639038,
-0.3522934913635254,
0.49546557664871216,
-0.5788132548332214,
-0.8850616812705994,
0.03489965200424194,
-0.3307308554649353,
0.20294222235679626,
0.36339500546455383,
0.46563032269477844,
0.11436641216278076,
0.313446968793869,
1.0165289640426636,
-0.5119959712028503,
0.3221254050731659,
-0.2693525552749634,
0.08531007915735245,
-0.503914475440979,
0.07878364622592926,
-0.6270674467086792,
0.26233789324760437,
-0.7009538412094116,
-0.8655710816383362,
-0.009128451347351074,
0.333041250705719,
0.08110740035772324,
0.78609299659729,
-0.17251381278038025,
0.3004089295864105,
0.3567403554916382,
-0.2817343473434448,
0.45587050914764404,
-0.3415645360946655,
0.10556797683238983,
0.05497703701257706,
-0.5885661840438843,
-0.5903064012527466,
1.05537748336792,
0.11675695329904556,
0.3267695903778076,
0.020265333354473114,
0.5546810030937195,
0.3411783277988434,
0.3195898234844208,
-0.7838687300682068,
0.13285277783870697,
-0.20454411208629608,
-0.09561596810817719,
-0.24906456470489502,
-0.5223807692527771,
-1.1993215084075928,
0.5806032419204712,
-0.2054869383573532,
-0.9840245842933655,
-0.2554749846458435,
-0.17632336914539337,
0.08914505690336227,
0.011103774420917034,
-1.021457552909851,
1.4039342403411865,
-0.28525102138519287,
-0.265175998210907,
-0.12299469113349915,
-0.5232892632484436,
0.5828546285629272,
-0.04585866630077362,
0.32534265518188477,
-0.3452753722667694,
-0.034321874380111694,
0.5236341953277588,
0.05735792964696884,
0.32033783197402954,
-0.1462159901857376,
-0.14882008731365204,
0.1895454227924347,
-0.20178382098674774,
0.22983571887016296,
0.47665995359420776,
-0.31442728638648987,
0.27079689502716064,
0.05574014410376549,
-0.7567877173423767,
-0.6241334676742554,
0.5705170035362244,
-0.9519804120063782,
-0.359889954328537,
-0.2712038457393646,
-0.3733050525188446,
0.12604963779449463,
0.35427290201187134,
0.20219336450099945,
-0.13283003866672516,
-0.5111967921257019,
-0.11422865837812424,
0.6269680261611938,
-0.19303365051746368,
-0.057784996926784515,
0.7571419477462769,
-0.3565270006656647,
-0.19853687286376953,
0.9802176356315613,
-0.05566830188035965,
0.3418671190738678,
0.7423525452613831,
0.20353060960769653,
-0.32840606570243835,
-0.2112390547990799,
-0.16761766374111176,
0.3850156366825104,
-0.5922068953514099,
0.17445950210094452,
-0.7684910893440247,
-0.510408341884613,
-0.44532519578933716,
-0.1226857528090477,
-0.5303341746330261,
-0.09463492035865784,
-0.13244546949863434,
-0.2945765256881714,
0.2978307604789734,
0.8751999735832214,
0.118999183177948,
0.3124333620071411,
-0.7189189791679382,
0.6576929092407227,
0.21735776960849762,
0.025506269186735153,
-0.3720151484012604,
-0.44050848484039307,
-0.33206993341445923,
-0.23630431294441223,
-0.03770282492041588,
-0.7412815093994141,
0.2895178496837616,
0.17800173163414001,
0.7542480826377869,
0.2351815551519394,
0.17151367664337158,
0.47002848982810974,
-0.31959933042526245,
0.5064013600349426,
0.06784884631633759,
-0.904158890247345,
0.5558968782424927,
-0.07986828684806824,
0.6567754149436951,
0.6622635126113892,
0.6269575953483582,
-0.7322310209274292,
-0.3171798884868622,
-0.46665218472480774,
-0.8159556984901428,
0.4069172143936157,
0.3128041625022888,
-0.41435837745666504,
0.2537505328655243,
0.22460320591926575,
0.5591965317726135,
0.15178202092647552,
-0.8302789330482483,
-0.4292633533477783,
-0.20701701939105988,
0.06037159264087677,
-0.46701106429100037,
0.08381608873605728,
0.13035479187965393,
-0.47872745990753174,
0.367928683757782,
-0.33084845542907715,
0.1552342176437378,
0.2173355370759964,
-0.5483765006065369,
0.21491235494613647,
0.20704251527786255,
0.5826837420463562,
0.9070888757705688,
-0.3041730225086212,
0.14554324746131897,
0.29628315567970276,
-0.31728774309158325,
-0.0898417979478836,
0.2917132079601288,
0.25381651520729065,
0.34214210510253906,
0.43898436427116394,
0.913592517375946,
0.2886766791343689,
-0.543349027633667,
0.3944019079208374,
-0.5432400107383728,
-0.26174068450927734,
-0.39781761169433594,
-0.07711225003004074,
0.27577999234199524,
-0.04763888940215111,
0.12230411171913147,
-0.17396464943885803,
0.012040083296597004,
-0.36107712984085083,
0.35794010758399963,
0.04216574877500534,
-0.657829225063324,
-0.306640625,
0.6090871095657349,
0.02407175675034523,
-0.4043677747249603,
0.6444264650344849,
-0.12020203471183777,
-0.4002424478530884,
0.535886287689209,
0.3636062443256378,
0.8037245869636536,
-0.27379024028778076,
0.5046114325523376,
0.6757433414459229,
0.6159439086914062,
0.16358326375484467,
0.31925979256629944,
-0.15502935647964478,
-0.4582647979259491,
-0.5042370557785034,
-0.5468316674232483,
-0.2556169927120209,
0.4845181405544281,
-0.9102543592453003,
0.46429863572120667,
-0.11279050260782242,
0.03636901080608368,
-0.09733406454324722,
0.14310748875141144,
-1.1718209981918335,
0.05578390508890152,
0.03982385993003845,
1.0383141040802002,
-0.8894051313400269,
1.2762751579284668,
0.674737274646759,
-0.2259378880262375,
-0.27435100078582764,
-0.15194378793239594,
0.13024722039699554,
-0.8428055047988892,
0.4559441804885864,
0.5757980346679688,
-0.02460653893649578,
-0.1493755429983139,
-0.10305538028478622,
-0.5874115228652954,
0.7808575630187988,
0.6400749683380127,
-0.3278788924217224,
0.21020090579986572,
0.3030868172645569,
0.5916050672531128,
-0.4386700391769409,
0.364669531583786,
1.0261672735214233,
0.5692645907402039,
-0.46083864569664,
-1.105160117149353,
-0.2218332290649414,
-0.3075579106807709,
-0.2052815854549408,
-0.07441562414169312,
-0.6181284189224243,
0.6812248826026917,
-0.12671782076358795,
-0.06522651761770248,
-0.025513071566820145,
0.9308786392211914,
0.24931320548057556,
0.45392754673957825,
0.5090620517730713,
0.46683406829833984,
0.9871386289596558,
-0.10757985711097717,
0.8199368715286255,
-0.10488896816968918,
0.30289170145988464,
1.4210227727890015,
-0.2119017392396927,
0.9182941913604736,
0.37978386878967285,
-0.08799630403518677,
0.3486619293689728,
0.4312933087348938,
0.21417678892612457,
0.28203892707824707,
0.26210108399391174,
-0.21415214240550995,
-0.09286482632160187,
-0.3005094528198242,
-0.3067486584186554,
0.5544654130935669,
0.3240598738193512,
0.008963228203356266,
-0.1881747841835022,
0.0648827850818634,
0.052171237766742706,
0.34182628989219666,
-0.01041336264461279,
0.825750470161438,
0.29480454325675964,
-0.5962569713592529,
1.0083562135696411,
-0.27343326807022095,
0.4754570722579956,
-0.716690719127655,
-0.09772450476884842,
-0.04900403693318367,
0.2377684861421585,
-0.00955977477133274,
-0.6924377679824829,
0.038959115743637085,
-0.14177103340625763,
0.07079668343067169,
-0.18770231306552887,
0.5151979327201843,
-0.518930971622467,
-0.43167418241500854,
0.8782333135604858,
0.6711249947547913,
0.08048064261674881,
-0.11066105216741562,
-0.8299081325531006,
0.045876406133174896,
-0.20684374868869781,
0.021395567804574966,
0.23996858298778534,
0.6935871243476868,
0.16496488451957703,
0.4300951659679413,
0.3149484097957611,
-0.18553811311721802,
0.28685471415519714,
0.3383135199546814,
0.4926861524581909,
-0.4963233470916748,
-0.382846474647522,
-0.5859103798866272,
0.5696314573287964,
-0.1389876902103424,
-0.5848191976547241,
0.8931057453155518,
0.6244989633560181,
1.3229318857192993,
-0.26834186911582947,
1.012166976928711,
0.3609364330768585,
0.11060663312673569,
-0.5149480700492859,
0.6282153129577637,
-0.6472098231315613,
-0.12781453132629395,
-0.3925250470638275,
-0.8649341464042664,
-0.01419772207736969,
0.5071802735328674,
-0.14047710597515106,
-0.32953760027885437,
0.8119641542434692,
0.3455858826637268,
0.024815719574689865,
0.016881786286830902,
0.5213449597358704,
0.2278292328119278,
0.40508201718330383,
0.91680908203125,
0.4914090037345886,
-0.6830986142158508,
0.5585890412330627,
-0.24994273483753204,
-0.2998889684677124,
-0.1449805349111557,
-0.723581075668335,
-0.9308209419250488,
-0.7761220932006836,
-0.4068543314933777,
-0.021729659289121628,
0.2672787010669708,
0.6432666778564453,
0.6872314810752869,
-0.6580386757850647,
-0.6764147877693176,
-0.01789730414748192,
0.3154227137565613,
-0.6892521977424622,
-0.28310608863830566,
0.5691486597061157,
-0.5744648575782776,
-0.6811038255691528,
0.5634686946868896,
0.3597065806388855,
-0.290759414434433,
-0.03808172419667244,
-0.292085736989975,
-0.6199216246604919,
-0.24523396790027618,
1.0108474493026733,
0.43401452898979187,
-0.7111350893974304,
-0.12137259542942047,
0.09555874019861221,
-0.1552380919456482,
0.3672000765800476,
0.7113779783248901,
-0.9891050457954407,
0.7099801301956177,
0.3514866530895233,
0.9088496565818787,
0.6678659319877625,
-0.3680487871170044,
0.8442187905311584,
-0.4520958662033081,
0.3156953752040863,
-0.1828855574131012,
0.4494263231754303,
0.12171044945716858,
-0.19692353904247284,
0.7304350733757019,
0.2369605451822281,
-0.3343912363052368,
-0.6503695249557495,
0.17920832335948944,
-1.1803104877471924,
-0.24284696578979492,
0.8122501373291016,
-0.42645156383514404,
-0.4534810483455658,
-0.44722050428390503,
-0.48975226283073425,
0.6532561779022217,
-0.023875635117292404,
0.6778230667114258,
0.5020366907119751,
0.08073187619447708,
-0.37832826375961304,
-1.0434291362762451,
0.46861791610717773,
0.5075835585594177,
-1.154992699623108,
0.29572632908821106,
-0.07881710678339005,
0.05575011298060417,
-0.09373249113559723,
0.6075752377510071,
0.09601762890815735,
0.5408978462219238,
-0.2737027406692505,
-0.25552260875701904,
0.2821842432022095,
-0.3668961822986603,
-0.225108340382576,
-0.025563128292560577,
0.1623702198266983,
-0.15182171761989594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15875v1
|
LAMPER: LanguAge Model and Prompt EngineeRing for zero-shot time series classification
| 2024-03-23T15:52:37 | 2024-03-23T15:52:37 |
Zhicheng Du, Zhaotian Xie, Yan Tong, Peiwu Qin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This study constructs the LanguAge Model with Prompt EngineeRing (LAMPER)
framework, designed to systematically evaluate the adaptability of pre-trained
language models (PLMs) in accommodating diverse prompts and their integration
in zero-shot time series (TS) classification. We deploy LAMPER in experimental
assessments using 128 univariate TS datasets sourced from the UCR archive. Our
findings indicate that the feature representation capacity of LAMPER is
influenced by the maximum input token threshold imposed by PLMs.
|
[
-0.36961835622787476,
-0.6591893434524536,
0.45233461260795593,
0.38461753726005554,
0.04540782794356346,
0.2268587052822113,
0.015960510820150375,
-0.3917200267314911,
-0.268502801656723,
0.17399024963378906,
-0.4426480531692505,
-0.18713507056236267,
-0.48162218928337097,
0.16513614356517792,
-0.5504856109619141,
0.9955270290374756,
-0.3073907196521759,
0.06344006210565567,
0.39258715510368347,
0.015043423511087894,
-0.7397727966308594,
-0.5727469325065613,
-0.2905314862728119,
-0.27538344264030457,
0.4991489052772522,
0.5116549134254456,
0.40180158615112305,
0.34417349100112915,
0.49002376198768616,
0.2706029713153839,
0.26162683963775635,
-0.746151328086853,
-0.3704511821269989,
0.020115921273827553,
-0.05410352721810341,
-0.4039671719074249,
-0.24695517122745514,
0.054013464599847794,
0.46378833055496216,
0.835789144039154,
-0.00462110061198473,
0.544776976108551,
-0.16084009408950806,
-0.034540288150310516,
-0.5651757717132568,
0.1840144246816635,
-0.3361903429031372,
0.18651045858860016,
-0.2021607905626297,
-0.4837566912174225,
-0.775847852230072,
-0.30152007937431335,
0.34372979402542114,
-0.26010414958000183,
0.6193691492080688,
0.17478646337985992,
0.9017384052276611,
0.07620425522327423,
-0.2855963706970215,
0.11139225214719772,
-0.9718557000160217,
1.148479700088501,
-0.5458022952079773,
0.10206372290849686,
-0.3043237030506134,
0.7124978303909302,
0.10781047493219376,
-0.5069035291671753,
-0.6626489162445068,
-0.10794714838266373,
-0.05535799264907837,
-0.07803058624267578,
-0.3554326891899109,
0.19147583842277527,
0.3176374137401581,
0.38113927841186523,
-0.8541542887687683,
0.4337784945964813,
-0.3547319173812866,
-0.15097013115882874,
0.3772345781326294,
0.3780868947505951,
0.4002385139465332,
-0.38529032468795776,
-0.4410015642642975,
-0.20194485783576965,
-0.0716429054737091,
0.08757030218839645,
0.022633569315075874,
0.4118921160697937,
-0.09420706331729889,
0.5126153826713562,
-0.1880955994129181,
0.9590223431587219,
-0.23259225487709045,
0.13669802248477936,
0.14433902502059937,
-0.0018407334573566914,
-0.43183645606040955,
0.20330525934696198,
0.7507181167602539,
0.3032098412513733,
0.2699524164199829,
-0.09969746321439743,
-0.17028120160102844,
0.6408129334449768,
-0.10788512229919434,
-0.9127700328826904,
-0.07125686854124069,
0.32275885343551636,
-0.24894720315933228,
-0.5348414778709412,
0.31603920459747314,
-0.93235182762146,
-0.25649648904800415,
-0.2010822296142578,
0.3852981626987457,
-0.294498085975647,
-0.3416336476802826,
0.35505616664886475,
-0.3772164285182953,
0.5883567333221436,
0.26468369364738464,
-0.5031471252441406,
0.1302940994501114,
0.4202609360218048,
1.1040838956832886,
-0.16290506720542908,
-0.36275777220726013,
-0.5533279180526733,
-0.024635406211018562,
-0.2990221679210663,
0.9934852123260498,
-0.5691264867782593,
-0.8313863277435303,
-0.060323070734739304,
0.031156161800026894,
-0.2989576756954193,
-0.06982019543647766,
0.29026365280151367,
-0.5999279618263245,
0.7207627892494202,
0.15215042233467102,
-0.5995975732803345,
-0.1831543892621994,
0.08898191899061203,
-0.3633241355419159,
0.849789023399353,
0.4236457645893097,
-0.38926079869270325,
0.38919195532798767,
-1.1527079343795776,
-0.11783520877361298,
0.23446117341518402,
-0.06937756389379501,
-0.08532381802797318,
0.2050458937883377,
0.1021411120891571,
0.426520437002182,
-0.22863884270191193,
0.5347263216972351,
-0.26184433698654175,
-0.3614692986011505,
0.5493096113204956,
-0.6089675426483154,
0.7780210971832275,
0.5276057124137878,
-0.13521860539913177,
0.4589172899723053,
-1.0829273462295532,
-0.00973058957606554,
-0.0026711225509643555,
0.07328225672245026,
0.00614109355956316,
-0.3302004039287567,
0.7105912566184998,
0.28648748993873596,
0.1340460479259491,
-0.8151329755783081,
0.1436115950345993,
-0.4041596055030823,
0.47713688015937805,
0.6129960417747498,
0.10245657712221146,
0.50078946352005,
-0.3988049328327179,
0.9359509348869324,
-0.012348893098533154,
0.35061562061309814,
-0.6339325308799744,
-0.22869013249874115,
-0.8988317847251892,
-0.07357078045606613,
0.25826361775398254,
1.0423253774642944,
-0.6084887385368347,
0.3368109464645386,
-0.2724127173423767,
-0.5059333443641663,
-0.132963627576828,
-0.24955518543720245,
0.1834506243467331,
0.5870324969291687,
0.2487775832414627,
-0.22829526662826538,
-0.5404520630836487,
-0.45779886841773987,
0.08668625354766846,
-0.2584567666053772,
-0.22186914086341858,
-0.09712215512990952,
0.22500231862068176,
0.035374317318201065,
1.327889084815979,
-0.541235625743866,
-0.02610039710998535,
-0.5877314209938049,
0.6676235795021057,
0.765464723110199,
0.24158881604671478,
1.043877124786377,
-0.25145336985588074,
-0.62932288646698,
-0.12157753854990005,
-0.8679748773574829,
-0.5623267292976379,
-0.07532811909914017,
0.25563785433769226,
0.10415233671665192,
0.34468895196914673,
-0.5279330611228943,
0.6426669359207153,
0.3993448317050934,
-0.5445963740348816,
0.5368219614028931,
0.009738568216562271,
0.30142974853515625,
-0.9831821322441101,
0.14354394376277924,
0.16304071247577667,
-0.15331515669822693,
-1.027908444404602,
-0.14624595642089844,
-0.01864653266966343,
-0.762980043888092,
-0.6660825610160828,
0.8220247626304626,
-0.47133392095565796,
0.025184063240885735,
-0.48158371448516846,
-0.16980911791324615,
-0.10077079385519028,
0.32367342710494995,
-0.023947039619088173,
0.8760649561882019,
0.9877809882164001,
-0.6760300397872925,
0.41521087288856506,
0.03450486436486244,
-0.3167484998703003,
0.658067524433136,
-0.9844144582748413,
-0.10802863538265228,
-0.2332504689693451,
-0.23914660513401031,
-1.0295077562332153,
-0.2804737091064453,
0.17238089442253113,
-0.33556434512138367,
0.3948856592178345,
-0.02759372442960739,
-0.2792409658432007,
-0.5287426710128784,
-0.38180264830589294,
0.4073924720287323,
0.6660169959068298,
-0.47686222195625305,
0.6166860461235046,
-0.12843824923038483,
-0.328223317861557,
-0.35685110092163086,
-0.5485871434211731,
0.05522944778203964,
-0.16498249769210815,
-0.4190903604030609,
0.042414769530296326,
-0.22534996271133423,
-0.22257596254348755,
-0.09811078757047653,
-0.10516857355833054,
-0.030680572614073753,
-0.10950423777103424,
0.22859996557235718,
0.7009019255638123,
-0.44217449426651,
-0.1425156146287918,
-0.47115620970726013,
-0.49538108706474304,
-0.11683506518602371,
-0.10114306956529617,
0.8038376569747925,
-0.014783765189349651,
-0.504225492477417,
-0.5795042514801025,
0.0449063815176487,
0.5446882247924805,
-0.03829158842563629,
0.5924270153045654,
0.41436767578125,
0.05018260329961777,
-0.30732303857803345,
-0.5743491649627686,
-0.06684460490942001,
-0.49582844972610474,
0.2673541009426117,
-0.367593377828598,
-0.953227698802948,
0.4489154517650604,
0.034259628504514694,
0.07154640555381775,
0.21689794957637787,
0.026006663218140602,
0.05104880779981613,
0.8897658586502075,
0.9820396304130554,
-0.38007450103759766,
0.8650715351104736,
-0.11441413313150406,
0.1740763783454895,
-0.19004446268081665,
0.11438293755054474,
-0.6110790967941284,
-0.3385719656944275,
-0.1839212030172348,
-0.3307444751262665,
0.3303936719894409,
0.1397915780544281,
-0.5420871376991272,
0.22014816105365753,
-0.5047203302383423,
0.5077255964279175,
0.33723291754722595,
-0.20962995290756226,
0.13080008327960968,
-0.014159983024001122,
0.39896926283836365,
0.10712935030460358,
-0.6073429584503174,
-0.41062813997268677,
0.8316390514373779,
0.31762611865997314,
0.9732993841171265,
0.0028412938117980957,
0.33073940873146057,
0.48143085837364197,
0.2698994576931,
-0.9292580485343933,
0.6043509244918823,
-0.047094251960515976,
-0.4613358676433563,
-0.27824410796165466,
-0.2571081221103668,
-0.7210883498191833,
-0.1871866136789322,
0.2435915172100067,
-0.7249086499214172,
0.6021033525466919,
-0.07606498152017593,
-0.5263202786445618,
0.3136979639530182,
-0.8536638021469116,
1.0944163799285889,
-0.4192965626716614,
0.24513675272464752,
0.05723646655678749,
-0.46197956800460815,
0.206039160490036,
-0.01323249377310276,
0.11417185515165329,
-0.2796832025051117,
-0.022385716438293457,
0.6716382503509521,
-0.5858758687973022,
0.9934654831886292,
-0.37698185443878174,
0.29785916209220886,
0.296092689037323,
0.3532296419143677,
0.07539013773202896,
-0.1868792027235031,
-0.25143083930015564,
0.24110032618045807,
0.06030536815524101,
-0.6881664991378784,
-0.5479004979133606,
0.43780237436294556,
-0.9691664576530457,
-0.5988007187843323,
-1.0340925455093384,
-0.5593538284301758,
-0.14962920546531677,
0.2377917766571045,
0.2008499950170517,
0.5687293410301208,
-0.41317641735076904,
-0.07098683714866638,
0.6330662965774536,
-0.31855547428131104,
1.1373974084854126,
0.9243150949478149,
-0.8183361887931824,
-0.1833922415971756,
0.838857889175415,
0.08176899701356888,
0.1731547862291336,
0.5579398274421692,
-0.023109590634703636,
-0.09444793313741684,
-0.5363724827766418,
-0.5717660188674927,
0.14813648164272308,
-0.5980711579322815,
-0.32536789774894714,
-0.27563875913619995,
-0.5111883282661438,
-0.18368172645568848,
-0.4051302671432495,
0.1511416882276535,
-0.4312743842601776,
-0.5479332804679871,
-0.3199630081653595,
0.9535471200942993,
0.9576566815376282,
0.24869388341903687,
0.9039795994758606,
-0.8037369251251221,
0.12889890372753143,
0.14550194144248962,
0.7171432971954346,
-0.3037446141242981,
-0.7212704420089722,
0.1684996634721756,
-0.4942091107368469,
-0.1791594922542572,
-1.0706939697265625,
0.36699867248535156,
0.38805145025253296,
0.5426685810089111,
0.4617021679878235,
0.03214716911315918,
0.5725029706954956,
-0.4372378885746002,
1.0997405052185059,
0.5685517191886902,
-1.241279125213623,
0.766871452331543,
-0.4746536314487457,
0.5324753522872925,
0.09607874602079391,
0.2324049025774002,
-0.6194607615470886,
-0.08258220553398132,
-0.2420700192451477,
-0.5051059126853943,
1.087573766708374,
-0.29380691051483154,
0.23127253353595734,
0.0011615939438343048,
0.1948082447052002,
0.1862230896949768,
0.08088251203298569,
-0.7382591962814331,
-0.29413890838623047,
-0.5722028017044067,
-0.3765403926372528,
-0.3034362196922302,
-0.3707594573497772,
0.34852591156959534,
-0.0444185696542263,
0.36098435521125793,
-0.07590614259243011,
0.03071064129471779,
0.10503735393285751,
-0.3694586753845215,
-0.3856563866138458,
0.8014742136001587,
0.3588230013847351,
0.7997059226036072,
-0.26833832263946533,
-0.13042373955249786,
0.2079496532678604,
-0.19109006226062775,
0.3372425138950348,
0.31350529193878174,
-0.42528313398361206,
0.41367489099502563,
0.22870396077632904,
1.013551950454712,
0.42198947072029114,
-0.4763018786907196,
0.51851487159729,
0.06415523588657379,
0.10407723486423492,
-0.1611792892217636,
0.20150116086006165,
-0.5825514197349548,
-0.09781035035848618,
0.5913282632827759,
0.27958235144615173,
-0.033962465822696686,
-0.3741672933101654,
0.13184091448783875,
0.16774800419807434,
-0.4368849992752075,
-0.5769217014312744,
0.9020020365715027,
0.0996026024222374,
-0.28958579897880554,
0.3680453300476074,
-0.1783134937286377,
-0.22814607620239258,
0.38968122005462646,
0.3854881227016449,
0.8744193315505981,
-0.7809095978736877,
0.5700339674949646,
0.18138375878334045,
0.046273741871118546,
-0.0824022963643074,
0.5331786870956421,
0.2799612581729889,
-0.6026357412338257,
-0.6181889176368713,
-0.8841931819915771,
-0.39312902092933655,
0.055902402848005295,
-0.5116305947303772,
0.7594735622406006,
-0.6541122794151306,
-0.30300790071487427,
0.10711997002363205,
-0.45690518617630005,
-0.7130482196807861,
-0.13139185309410095,
0.07632806152105331,
1.1765788793563843,
-0.9971771836280823,
0.8156461119651794,
0.6135717034339905,
-0.8364341259002686,
-0.6249915361404419,
-0.36397096514701843,
-0.06863514333963394,
-0.8215451836585999,
0.6810001730918884,
0.14937099814414978,
0.014555682428181171,
0.2339809685945511,
-0.43064385652542114,
-0.7092269659042358,
1.1016610860824585,
0.39115890860557556,
-0.5176525115966797,
-0.08846230804920197,
0.44300439953804016,
0.5510846376419067,
-0.2340657114982605,
0.4714216887950897,
0.3562466502189636,
0.18726879358291626,
0.10304898768663406,
-1.2544747591018677,
-0.29766687750816345,
-0.39059630036354065,
0.4267948269844055,
0.34575155377388,
-0.4572911858558655,
0.9273361563682556,
-0.04154254123568535,
-0.40472501516342163,
0.3276972472667694,
0.6438522338867188,
0.1161920502781868,
0.5078086256980896,
0.26174113154411316,
0.26431649923324585,
0.32205715775489807,
-0.3252866566181183,
0.8999269604682922,
-0.498839795589447,
0.41860252618789673,
0.7696056962013245,
-0.6175976991653442,
0.8148102164268494,
0.38588041067123413,
-0.4432707726955414,
0.8554352521896362,
0.5079383254051208,
-0.33773279190063477,
0.31687867641448975,
0.05498867854475975,
-0.3544624447822571,
0.06978961080312729,
-0.4155733287334442,
-0.4160729944705963,
0.2267119139432907,
0.14542466402053833,
-0.0440460667014122,
-0.37516021728515625,
0.4931107759475708,
-0.2735084891319275,
-0.0759914293885231,
-0.42269131541252136,
0.6313855051994324,
-0.034279923886060715,
-0.22838331758975983,
0.1926594376564026,
-0.1528419554233551,
0.8952312469482422,
-0.7344516515731812,
0.1118553951382637,
-0.2168900966644287,
0.0402522012591362,
-0.11937692761421204,
-0.8160942196846008,
0.0472983792424202,
0.362071692943573,
-0.4461480975151062,
-0.3904958665370941,
0.7597218155860901,
-0.007958154194056988,
-0.9031152725219727,
0.2472105622291565,
0.7720345854759216,
0.1363087296485901,
0.2850632667541504,
-0.5069116353988647,
0.09741733968257904,
-0.3489977717399597,
-0.24944329261779785,
0.09587395936250687,
0.48201853036880493,
-0.003889113664627075,
0.6499856114387512,
0.4585866332054138,
0.2162679135799408,
0.3823698163032532,
0.6140965819358826,
0.6048529148101807,
-0.9755962491035461,
-0.564024031162262,
-0.8218466639518738,
0.5486165881156921,
-0.021260889247059822,
-0.0331670381128788,
0.9102956056594849,
0.4972478151321411,
0.6908166408538818,
-0.4899514615535736,
1.0086407661437988,
-0.25652822852134705,
0.7172470092773438,
-0.11674121767282486,
0.5093140006065369,
0.05218521133065224,
0.4143824577331543,
-0.25461921095848083,
-0.8392829895019531,
-0.6192606687545776,
0.2323170304298401,
-0.6738547086715698,
0.10825242847204208,
0.5099712610244751,
0.7047123312950134,
-0.2425217628479004,
0.21878142654895782,
0.4509982764720917,
0.18984299898147583,
0.28126347064971924,
0.4948306679725647,
1.0825647115707397,
-0.4662678837776184,
0.7424879670143127,
-0.1932293027639389,
-0.42669877409935,
-0.18458379805088043,
-0.9721296429634094,
-0.9765644073486328,
-0.23484711349010468,
-0.39824050664901733,
0.03124237433075905,
-0.1625840663909912,
0.9604797959327698,
0.5140534043312073,
-1.417149305343628,
-0.6250619292259216,
-0.1447337120771408,
-0.23796144127845764,
0.008007150143384933,
-0.41908708214759827,
0.11185344308614731,
-0.6555721163749695,
-0.5401644110679626,
0.3932105600833893,
0.3602128326892853,
0.2645241320133209,
-0.3608228266239166,
-0.05021866410970688,
0.2310304194688797,
-0.1492241472005844,
0.563370943069458,
0.4286144971847534,
-0.658825695514679,
-0.3550873100757599,
0.5476420521736145,
0.25138890743255615,
0.07229506224393845,
1.012623906135559,
-0.9469480514526367,
0.5607659220695496,
0.5586474537849426,
0.3019758462905884,
0.11288861930370331,
-0.1544438898563385,
0.7254431247711182,
-0.8857808709144592,
0.38493719696998596,
-0.05782280117273331,
0.5854784250259399,
0.2769155502319336,
-0.12083737552165985,
0.3336420953273773,
0.38392770290374756,
-0.6358806490898132,
-1.0429179668426514,
0.21035631000995636,
-1.1552960872650146,
-0.39900892972946167,
0.7775871753692627,
0.12735606729984283,
-0.15526074171066284,
-0.4235580265522003,
-0.3097926676273346,
0.23999649286270142,
-0.36572524905204773,
0.752774178981781,
0.6992245316505432,
-0.46927201747894287,
-0.7189473509788513,
-0.4969383180141449,
0.06867349147796631,
0.05563775822520256,
-0.5314510464668274,
-0.20702552795410156,
0.458736777305603,
0.5280715227127075,
0.3737803101539612,
0.43065693974494934,
0.03677007183432579,
0.3059437870979309,
-0.188650980591774,
0.11726191639900208,
-0.14388667047023773,
-0.2162659913301468,
-0.7332194447517395,
0.368829607963562,
0.36974063515663147,
-0.146671861410141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15872v1
|
RAAMove: A Corpus for Analyzing Moves in Research Article Abstracts
| 2024-03-23T15:43:30 | 2024-03-23T15:43:30 |
Hongzheng Li, Ruojin Wang, Ge Shi, Xing Lv, Lei Lei, Chong Feng, Fang Liu, Jinkun Lin, Yangguang Mei, Lingnan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Move structures have been studied in English for Specific Purposes (ESP) and
English for Academic Purposes (EAP) for decades. However, there are few move
annotation corpora for Research Article (RA) abstracts. In this paper, we
introduce RAAMove, a comprehensive multi-domain corpus dedicated to the
annotation of move structures in RA abstracts. The primary objective of RAAMove
is to facilitate move analysis and automatic move identification. This paper
provides a thorough discussion of the corpus construction process, including
the scheme, data collection, annotation guidelines, and annotation procedures.
The corpus is constructed through two stages: initially, expert annotators
manually annotate high-quality data; subsequently, based on the human-annotated
data, a BERT-based model is employed for automatic annotation with the help of
experts' modification. The result is a large-scale and high-quality corpus
comprising 33,988 annotated instances. We also conduct preliminary move
identification experiments using the BERT-based model to verify the
effectiveness of the proposed corpus and model. The annotated corpus is
available for academic research purposes and can serve as essential resources
for move analysis, English language teaching and writing, as well as
move/discourse-related tasks in Natural Language Processing (NLP).
|
[
-0.26073771715164185,
-1.0259652137756348,
0.37436172366142273,
0.20577076077461243,
-0.21660153567790985,
-0.058102693408727646,
0.05376392602920532,
-0.6336856484413147,
0.47423988580703735,
0.4149216115474701,
-0.4757714569568634,
-0.8037235736846924,
-0.796260416507721,
-0.016961149871349335,
-0.8631896376609802,
1.0727429389953613,
-0.08855879306793213,
-0.161337748169899,
-0.38477855920791626,
-0.36288681626319885,
-0.6655274629592896,
-0.22778533399105072,
-0.3424643278121948,
-0.12551797926425934,
0.5596754550933838,
0.16900214552879333,
0.6654103994369507,
0.6583875417709351,
0.6163185834884644,
0.2500312030315399,
-0.07000243663787842,
0.3806329369544983,
0.06515806913375854,
0.4285815358161926,
-0.19480055570602417,
-0.321902871131897,
-0.5946311354637146,
-0.2360670566558838,
0.5455073118209839,
0.4707505702972412,
0.0367378368973732,
0.02883799932897091,
-0.3320208787918091,
0.46466270089149475,
-0.4319211542606354,
0.13372331857681274,
-0.16674204170703888,
-0.05345531925559044,
-0.6460613012313843,
-0.30517613887786865,
-0.40830516815185547,
-0.5410435795783997,
-0.02431762032210827,
-0.5757259726524353,
0.16097301244735718,
0.19277791678905487,
0.8415470123291016,
0.18029087781906128,
-0.272597998380661,
-0.46303868293762207,
-0.4370654821395874,
0.6160441040992737,
-0.4145389199256897,
0.26553207635879517,
0.4690096080303192,
0.02766270376741886,
-0.03161158785223961,
-0.5945457816123962,
-0.026563379913568497,
-0.10868464410305023,
-0.01070965826511383,
-0.3497845530509949,
-0.14011497795581818,
-0.07631809264421463,
-0.0348132960498333,
-0.10252930968999863,
-0.6403260231018066,
-0.051414210349321365,
-0.7131649851799011,
-0.24162809550762177,
0.727668285369873,
0.15896712243556976,
0.6367586255073547,
0.19365869462490082,
-0.407438725233078,
-0.17957957088947296,
-0.5431949496269226,
-0.39775344729423523,
0.17347441613674164,
0.13822482526302338,
-0.13451683521270752,
0.6527165770530701,
0.23074404895305634,
0.802940309047699,
-0.06120036914944649,
-0.138970747590065,
0.393345445394516,
-0.10035127401351929,
0.06784218549728394,
0.2552422881126404,
0.8917538523674011,
-0.019152792170643806,
0.07687743008136749,
-0.14018727838993073,
0.060173727571964264,
0.0008254954591393471,
0.44006475806236267,
-0.5796869397163391,
-0.37267181277275085,
0.20870475471019745,
-0.5354126691818237,
-0.2953716218471527,
-0.05658493563532829,
-1.0963793992996216,
-0.16879738867282867,
-0.3519328236579895,
0.23535023629665375,
-0.8825179934501648,
-0.3115134537220001,
0.21716400980949402,
0.15891757607460022,
0.33958208560943604,
0.49428102374076843,
-0.5847033858299255,
0.17748330533504486,
0.917504072189331,
1.0156573057174683,
-0.6033177375793457,
-0.29442769289016724,
-0.3538375198841095,
0.06476477533578873,
-0.30140420794487,
1.3873661756515503,
-0.8363397121429443,
-0.515114426612854,
0.37654000520706177,
-0.0024561225436627865,
-0.3868214190006256,
-0.13198909163475037,
1.0008643865585327,
-0.4568558633327484,
-0.004922492895275354,
0.19271321594715118,
-0.6996846199035645,
-0.6468250155448914,
0.30963820219039917,
-0.7243289947509766,
1.0826455354690552,
-0.35058778524398804,
-0.8810261487960815,
-0.09818603843450546,
-1.1229050159454346,
-0.9910167455673218,
-0.11645244807004929,
-0.10868288576602936,
-0.2814030945301056,
0.1894235461950302,
0.17880287766456604,
0.4845874309539795,
-0.049335360527038574,
-0.006959585007280111,
0.054982468485832214,
0.034971412271261215,
0.6229968667030334,
0.04702841117978096,
0.6953871250152588,
0.42380937933921814,
0.05347460135817528,
0.22857666015625,
-0.8512837290763855,
-0.2823934853076935,
-0.3455091416835785,
-0.09674268960952759,
-0.8934348821640015,
0.09407537430524826,
0.060045983642339706,
-0.03053305298089981,
0.23350322246551514,
-0.49679839611053467,
0.5876280069351196,
-0.04881962016224861,
0.04901474714279175,
0.29858633875846863,
0.18687349557876587,
0.4400905966758728,
-0.32721367478370667,
0.9855508208274841,
-0.22935622930526733,
0.08160806447267532,
-0.267807275056839,
-0.8077892065048218,
-0.3591163456439972,
-0.614848792552948,
0.45690298080444336,
0.38155287504196167,
-0.4581952393054962,
0.06654847413301468,
-0.22120162844657898,
-0.3814135491847992,
-0.9762349128723145,
-0.1869633048772812,
0.26815086603164673,
0.26340237259864807,
0.664323627948761,
0.061378709971904755,
-0.7676869034767151,
-0.6497316360473633,
0.012362034991383553,
0.09335768967866898,
0.5274965763092041,
-0.27620041370391846,
0.7526937127113342,
-0.2999938726425171,
0.9493874311447144,
-0.5971698760986328,
-0.491882860660553,
-0.1544707864522934,
0.9176258444786072,
-0.32308775186538696,
0.4422989785671234,
0.546757161617279,
-0.9400389790534973,
-0.2919555902481079,
-0.06579975038766861,
-0.5872944593429565,
-0.33005714416503906,
-0.14996515214443207,
-0.6861147284507751,
0.024352462962269783,
0.6998056769371033,
-0.635516345500946,
0.47764334082603455,
0.5232490301132202,
-0.3604804277420044,
0.567709743976593,
-0.268358051776886,
0.278390109539032,
-1.056474208831787,
0.21825063228607178,
-0.008399656973779202,
-0.19760540127754211,
-0.5110284686088562,
0.17402242124080658,
-0.004829253535717726,
0.26889747381210327,
-0.45703503489494324,
0.5325961112976074,
-0.4811493158340454,
0.05457378178834915,
-0.5654459595680237,
0.21695862710475922,
-0.3014877438545227,
0.0687272846698761,
0.4925249218940735,
0.6486457586288452,
0.5234196782112122,
-0.8529782891273499,
-0.08314692229032516,
0.6610464453697205,
-0.3551405966281891,
0.7094070911407471,
-0.44341400265693665,
0.23460690677165985,
-0.09017077833414078,
-0.04301401972770691,
-0.8471193909645081,
0.10129475593566895,
0.09493483603000641,
-0.7437530755996704,
0.25023794174194336,
-0.3209627568721771,
-0.14513689279556274,
0.12910887598991394,
-0.14058613777160645,
0.3547017574310303,
0.32104694843292236,
-0.18701718747615814,
0.882582426071167,
0.8307977318763733,
-0.22098830342292786,
-0.6448001861572266,
-0.7177830338478088,
0.03207608312368393,
-0.263906866312027,
-0.5119178891181946,
0.21685117483139038,
-0.0879025012254715,
-0.4913176894187927,
0.17827433347702026,
0.19180338084697723,
-0.5237946510314941,
-0.029044508934020996,
0.5596377849578857,
0.4180890917778015,
0.03884518891572952,
0.11409283429384232,
0.14897680282592773,
-0.11505565047264099,
0.21462999284267426,
0.019586075097322464,
0.2329866886138916,
0.30726149678230286,
-0.12581466138362885,
-0.2473871409893036,
0.36546197533607483,
0.6701641082763672,
-0.6256983280181885,
0.31690284609794617,
0.8173390626907349,
-0.1356387585401535,
-0.22458989918231964,
-0.23835916817188263,
0.15207068622112274,
-0.2737470865249634,
0.3795080780982971,
-0.3850766718387604,
-0.6041549444198608,
0.3111055791378021,
-0.2068788856267929,
0.596854567527771,
0.6597434282302856,
0.5861381888389587,
-0.22492921352386475,
0.6130057573318481,
0.6299757361412048,
0.0498630627989769,
0.27582186460494995,
-0.1871967613697052,
-0.14386513829231262,
-1.0229467153549194,
-0.4831274449825287,
-1.103446125984192,
-0.49051761627197266,
-0.18363796174526215,
-0.9011700749397278,
0.022064587101340294,
-0.5397712588310242,
0.5077190399169922,
0.6084776520729065,
-0.4427007734775543,
-0.09217245131731033,
0.22039180994033813,
-0.279817670583725,
0.2749664783477783,
0.011410846374928951,
-0.19919581711292267,
-0.19509676098823547,
-0.43615424633026123,
-0.38335317373275757,
1.0297987461090088,
0.18633818626403809,
1.042933464050293,
0.1510957032442093,
0.7027048468589783,
0.7354852557182312,
0.5035950541496277,
-0.8504919409751892,
0.7365193367004395,
0.10857732594013214,
-0.7615063786506653,
-0.16603174805641174,
0.05977176874876022,
-1.436326265335083,
0.48739564418792725,
-0.48042798042297363,
-0.337130069732666,
0.2531222701072693,
-0.1338483691215515,
-0.27147433161735535,
0.25530341267585754,
0.04634178429841995,
0.4679674804210663,
-0.3678872883319855,
-0.3810748755931854,
-0.6478743553161621,
-0.48071110248565674,
0.28602543473243713,
-0.0671960860490799,
0.7945852279663086,
-0.23246484994888306,
-0.24310219287872314,
1.1152644157409668,
-0.4086211025714874,
0.6959947943687439,
-0.06400850415229797,
-0.054036714136600494,
0.6525989174842834,
0.5120223760604858,
0.2692394256591797,
-0.25237879157066345,
0.11967922747135162,
0.1708688884973526,
-0.07325524836778641,
0.09548618644475937,
-0.1336662620306015,
0.7246495485305786,
-0.4077208936214447,
0.09549377858638763,
-0.8545618653297424,
-0.4949871301651001,
0.11025084555149078,
-0.017749344930052757,
-0.1085943803191185,
0.4051104784011841,
-0.37052854895591736,
0.3364467918872833,
0.9077653288841248,
0.02740302123129368,
0.37649253010749817,
0.6188971996307373,
-0.2394578754901886,
-0.33281445503234863,
0.6284480094909668,
-0.054159872233867645,
-0.496319979429245,
0.8530994653701782,
0.14387153089046478,
-0.5102621912956238,
-0.7842970490455627,
-0.11380912363529205,
0.27225273847579956,
-0.26204219460487366,
-0.0976966992020607,
-0.8105052709579468,
0.18260395526885986,
-0.3563871383666992,
-0.25634628534317017,
-0.4653733968734741,
-0.5719240307807922,
-0.16172011196613312,
-0.3424566984176636,
0.5498058795928955,
0.7159151434898376,
-0.21425917744636536,
-0.1639401763677597,
-0.8657010197639465,
0.23570677638053894,
-0.07081834971904755,
-0.1994633823633194,
-0.30629628896713257,
-0.6024501919746399,
-0.5589585304260254,
-0.25212424993515015,
-0.13043811917304993,
-0.8873404860496521,
0.6004531979560852,
0.24237912893295288,
0.5727227926254272,
0.3395788073539734,
0.21181753277778625,
0.6240648627281189,
-0.539242148399353,
0.6764301657676697,
0.07204651832580566,
-0.4049575626850128,
0.6804314851760864,
-0.2233477234840393,
0.2636961340904236,
0.6731447577476501,
0.6707298159599304,
-0.1401280015707016,
-0.18296311795711517,
-0.4934579133987427,
-1.0124026536941528,
0.23450540006160736,
0.05458534508943558,
-0.2719275653362274,
-0.22274558246135712,
0.37998470664024353,
0.3714936673641205,
0.0130523182451725,
-0.32920944690704346,
-0.31664925813674927,
0.2938164472579956,
-0.35199519991874695,
0.3448081314563751,
-0.2785928547382355,
-0.26055648922920227,
0.04590296000242233,
0.7620389461517334,
0.15407995879650116,
0.294035941362381,
0.2868889272212982,
-0.5791054368019104,
0.0015553223202005029,
0.15162762999534607,
0.7599292993545532,
0.5511966347694397,
-0.19886817038059235,
0.01060681976377964,
-0.20079809427261353,
-0.8156097531318665,
0.10093452036380768,
0.13032032549381256,
-0.38792893290519714,
0.5905449986457825,
0.5623390674591064,
0.5183055400848389,
0.6266113519668579,
-0.6013379096984863,
0.4636988043785095,
0.00613432889804244,
-0.3942297399044037,
-0.6158633828163147,
-0.13717055320739746,
-0.2034730762243271,
0.0903014987707138,
0.22542445361614227,
0.16289958357810974,
0.3071364164352417,
-0.2758067846298218,
0.3026275038719177,
0.20666147768497467,
-0.37803858518600464,
-0.6822597980499268,
0.8827153444290161,
0.3690776526927948,
-0.4465937912464142,
0.40361639857292175,
0.007903835736215115,
-0.08278834074735641,
0.309272438287735,
0.18739882111549377,
1.1797142028808594,
-0.44107890129089355,
0.27946045994758606,
0.5666625499725342,
0.16711591184139252,
-0.3110910654067993,
0.22197875380516052,
-0.07524233311414719,
-0.5407333374023438,
-0.7723340392112732,
-0.5479840636253357,
-0.39903688430786133,
-0.26076316833496094,
-0.9197055697441101,
0.25133854150772095,
-0.10294678807258606,
-0.33525004982948303,
0.02596215531229973,
-0.26052385568618774,
-0.5407022833824158,
0.04584335535764694,
0.1460268795490265,
0.921911895275116,
-0.9146009087562561,
1.1464567184448242,
1.4535144567489624,
-0.45458072423934937,
-0.010546443052589893,
-0.28624287247657776,
0.10758114606142044,
-0.5937317609786987,
0.7810197472572327,
-0.21311180293560028,
-0.3644803762435913,
-0.4240390956401825,
-0.556753933429718,
-0.743952214717865,
0.9837031960487366,
-0.18399448692798615,
-0.439198762178421,
-0.07868389785289764,
-0.23533736169338226,
0.43760600686073303,
-0.38020554184913635,
0.2817642390727997,
0.29250338673591614,
0.620514452457428,
0.14983712136745453,
-0.5998201966285706,
-0.19082725048065186,
0.07259912043809891,
-0.20267736911773682,
0.38014087080955505,
-0.3958645164966583,
0.6178238391876221,
-0.13961313664913177,
0.07539292424917221,
0.28901201486587524,
0.9281038045883179,
0.051837388426065445,
0.09208492934703827,
0.2697824239730835,
0.5886059403419495,
0.7343113422393799,
-0.03017871081829071,
0.8709395527839661,
-0.48884648084640503,
0.16559618711471558,
1.186750888824463,
-0.09567546844482422,
1.1686424016952515,
0.28660377860069275,
-0.033704809844493866,
0.8276508450508118,
0.2511027157306671,
0.3168444335460663,
0.6157799959182739,
-0.06824012100696564,
-0.13496017456054688,
-0.25742608308792114,
0.22249239683151245,
-0.26678362488746643,
0.5333709120750427,
0.752525806427002,
-0.10257851332426071,
-0.23171724379062653,
0.29743680357933044,
0.4987935721874237,
0.1961091309785843,
-0.3648889362812042,
0.5438962578773499,
-0.023838955909013748,
-0.7108219265937805,
-0.056709907948970795,
0.06821443885564804,
0.6042180061340332,
-0.9871955513954163,
-0.21819694340229034,
-0.13177655637264252,
0.04046507924795151,
-0.24605074524879456,
-0.8257369995117188,
0.5986712574958801,
-0.029606502503156662,
0.17380009591579437,
-0.27065959572792053,
0.8115151524543762,
-0.44127610325813293,
-0.3170086443424225,
0.07569006085395813,
0.3118312656879425,
0.5615085363388062,
0.29088661074638367,
-0.7449684739112854,
0.3168576657772064,
0.11967514455318451,
-0.23651961982250214,
0.5635538697242737,
0.6443179249763489,
-0.2066064178943634,
0.6417903304100037,
0.5719485878944397,
0.14374545216560364,
0.13361017405986786,
-0.008305968716740608,
0.32892686128616333,
-0.7033511400222778,
-0.3733954131603241,
-0.4911957383155823,
0.6748639345169067,
0.03150475397706032,
-0.46857309341430664,
0.7845311164855957,
0.622158944606781,
0.2542717754840851,
-0.1298079937696457,
0.7905668616294861,
-0.3775826394557953,
0.7381810545921326,
-0.4964098632335663,
0.3845302164554596,
-0.23306064307689667,
-0.034422434866428375,
-0.1984798163175583,
-0.790510356426239,
-0.5256335139274597,
1.1716721057891846,
-0.11984701454639435,
-0.454741507768631,
0.868452787399292,
0.47231483459472656,
0.12326259911060333,
-0.09294047206640244,
0.178276926279068,
0.3811875879764557,
0.24052852392196655,
0.21044674515724182,
0.4823075830936432,
-0.3357873558998108,
0.5893557667732239,
0.030423808842897415,
-0.09436273574829102,
-0.5759832262992859,
-0.9057180285453796,
-0.8206995725631714,
-0.8144588470458984,
-1.0568902492523193,
-0.14895927906036377,
0.23832187056541443,
0.9774230122566223,
0.8402230739593506,
-0.7680017948150635,
-0.3893817365169525,
0.23677095770835876,
-0.1000991016626358,
-0.6314606666564941,
-0.21285682916641235,
0.8615403175354004,
-0.5276080369949341,
-0.7506824731826782,
0.7541393637657166,
0.1938244104385376,
-0.18601684272289276,
-0.19076041877269745,
0.05722394958138466,
-0.9482390880584717,
0.004370539449155331,
0.6278797388076782,
0.7349196076393127,
-0.1985781490802765,
-0.04205511137843132,
-0.15157745778560638,
0.09049730002880096,
-0.011401928029954433,
0.9974666237831116,
-0.5804764032363892,
0.5880169868469238,
0.5351905822753906,
0.5929767489433289,
0.6875078082084656,
0.250688761472702,
0.43705397844314575,
-0.66895592212677,
0.216884583234787,
0.27397897839546204,
0.35712236166000366,
0.12022814899682999,
0.041716307401657104,
0.7345392107963562,
0.07212832570075989,
-0.6533240079879761,
-0.39577242732048035,
-0.24792923033237457,
-1.1638399362564087,
-0.3800124526023865,
1.377604365348816,
-0.1357051283121109,
-0.550113320350647,
-0.46296125650405884,
-0.5572124719619751,
-0.06618855893611908,
-0.5218400955200195,
0.5201017260551453,
0.6068353652954102,
-0.5463352203369141,
-0.12309826165437698,
-0.7446275353431702,
0.44941550493240356,
0.03861170634627342,
-0.6469365358352661,
-0.1153770387172699,
0.7997083067893982,
0.19237077236175537,
0.33557751774787903,
0.4926462471485138,
-0.5960386395454407,
0.0683613121509552,
-0.16223616898059845,
0.5344473123550415,
-0.294556587934494,
-0.5019063353538513,
-0.32612931728363037,
0.5695992708206177,
0.06709757447242737,
-0.6563410758972168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15837v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15837v2
|
Centered Masking for Language-Image Pre-Training
| 2024-03-23T13:24:31 | 2024-03-27T08:54:06 |
Mingliang Liang, Martha Larson
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce Gaussian masking for Language-Image Pre-Training (GLIP) a novel,
straightforward, and effective technique for masking image patches during
pre-training of a vision-language model. GLIP builds on Fast Language-Image
Pre-Training (FLIP), which randomly masks image patches while training a CLIP
model. GLIP replaces random masking with centered masking, that uses a Gaussian
distribution and is inspired by the importance of image patches at the center
of the image. GLIP retains the same computational savings as FLIP, while
improving performance across a range of downstream datasets and tasks, as
demonstrated by our experimental results. We show the benefits of GLIP to be
easy to obtain, requiring no delicate tuning of the Gaussian, and also
applicable to data sets containing images without an obvious center focus.
|
[
-0.6787688136100769,
-0.6976497769355774,
0.1947486698627472,
0.553331732749939,
-0.6250768899917603,
0.23093049228191376,
-0.3775434195995331,
-0.534804105758667,
0.6584182977676392,
0.7835935354232788,
-0.40301838517189026,
-0.39490246772766113,
-0.5692213177680969,
-0.5517602562904358,
-0.2826206684112549,
0.7106723189353943,
0.22456154227256775,
0.1224697083234787,
0.04656219854950905,
0.1892884224653244,
-0.06359376758337021,
-0.5844078660011292,
-0.5842221975326538,
-0.05226404219865799,
0.018707487732172012,
0.6023732423782349,
0.7266433238983154,
0.6617361307144165,
0.5321534872055054,
0.19130854308605194,
0.4927964210510254,
-0.20041681826114655,
-0.19451378285884857,
-0.26287251710891724,
0.07251492887735367,
-0.5800297260284424,
-0.1918090283870697,
0.29101070761680603,
0.5130895376205444,
0.8005391359329224,
-0.16882166266441345,
0.05358622595667839,
-0.20160318911075592,
0.8260336518287659,
-1.1651800870895386,
-0.20450523495674133,
-0.7658167481422424,
0.3363267481327057,
-0.6690841913223267,
-0.2937459945678711,
-0.27729228138923645,
-0.31937578320503235,
0.15271256864070892,
-0.8919167518615723,
0.7088887095451355,
0.0563938170671463,
1.036746621131897,
0.062318384647369385,
0.12140078842639923,
-0.30412864685058594,
-0.6746850609779358,
0.8209228515625,
-0.2569912075996399,
0.32121285796165466,
0.3140731751918793,
0.8238157629966736,
0.026280658319592476,
-0.652277410030365,
-0.7479841113090515,
0.12608958780765533,
0.09202221035957336,
0.0490221343934536,
-0.0111604705452919,
0.22434160113334656,
0.08698954433202744,
0.5769909024238586,
-0.4251495897769928,
-0.16035966575145721,
-0.3125036358833313,
-0.32041364908218384,
0.5004863739013672,
-0.42467552423477173,
0.682438850402832,
0.36846381425857544,
-0.5053982734680176,
-0.2792033553123474,
-0.8776057362556458,
0.27545851469039917,
0.5312252640724182,
0.09823685884475708,
0.14420001208782196,
0.3564639389514923,
-0.20952056348323822,
0.6568953990936279,
0.14871181547641754,
-0.2956542372703552,
0.30946895480155945,
-0.07087793946266174,
-0.3880402743816376,
-0.012665138579905033,
0.5874058604240417,
0.38927462697029114,
0.5529003143310547,
-0.2107604444026947,
-0.23351223766803741,
0.07871344685554504,
0.17324529588222504,
-0.9189462065696716,
-0.6427026391029358,
-0.04496379941701889,
-0.01271336805075407,
-0.42414772510528564,
0.17136891186237335,
-0.8806203007698059,
-0.14717097580432892,
-0.3425266742706299,
0.5815298557281494,
-0.1730719804763794,
-0.10892409086227417,
0.3458747863769531,
0.007935687899589539,
0.22864271700382233,
0.35378506779670715,
-1.2148624658584595,
0.4467027485370636,
0.461087703704834,
0.7870355844497681,
-0.14722280204296112,
-0.15084591507911682,
-0.8666576147079468,
0.20298293232917786,
-0.5896410942077637,
0.9724579453468323,
-0.5981829166412354,
-0.13461968302726746,
0.3498191237449646,
0.029659558087587357,
0.0393545962870121,
-0.5163264870643616,
-0.06624068319797516,
-0.4679764211177826,
0.355180948972702,
-0.2580071687698364,
-0.10420895367860794,
-0.10144411772489548,
0.026143735274672508,
-0.6947770118713379,
0.7220873236656189,
0.02767610363662243,
-0.6613960266113281,
0.7602073550224304,
-0.4738420248031616,
-0.44382497668266296,
0.11326542496681213,
-0.2839137613773346,
-0.6766073703765869,
-0.06284651905298233,
0.7524288296699524,
0.3006111979484558,
0.05560721829533577,
-0.09938214719295502,
-0.49154821038246155,
-0.5429603457450867,
0.10444486141204834,
0.042379382997751236,
0.8997944593429565,
-0.0006054281257092953,
-0.6522073745727539,
-0.12262272089719772,
-0.7754594683647156,
-0.020253175869584084,
-0.04102593660354614,
0.2915334105491638,
-0.4559386968612671,
-0.20687222480773926,
0.11179926246404648,
0.13698771595954895,
0.031039435416460037,
-0.5274578332901001,
0.3294835090637207,
-0.34276285767555237,
0.13155311346054077,
0.5661183595657349,
0.025952719151973724,
1.0448521375656128,
0.05712150037288666,
0.832230269908905,
0.17626602947711945,
0.646213710308075,
-0.22960983216762543,
-0.6574815511703491,
-0.6861298084259033,
-0.9992596507072449,
-0.06385981291532516,
0.7390634417533875,
-0.9528741836547852,
0.016403650864958763,
0.017153751105070114,
-0.39200735092163086,
-0.627241313457489,
0.2571697235107422,
0.38589781522750854,
0.6846210956573486,
0.42453014850616455,
-0.6553081274032593,
-0.6356896758079529,
-0.9962283372879028,
-0.08910427242517471,
0.26832860708236694,
-0.1451774388551712,
0.13999629020690918,
0.14951416850090027,
-0.11107641458511353,
0.9928461909294128,
-0.5332632660865784,
-0.7938308119773865,
-0.09152361005544662,
0.013399103656411171,
0.2472238838672638,
0.3665223717689514,
0.9820023775100708,
-0.8142739534378052,
-0.985899806022644,
-0.08237534016370773,
-0.2502663731575012,
-0.282802015542984,
0.04771052300930023,
-0.21333527565002441,
0.33001455664634705,
0.8539188504219055,
-0.3715400993824005,
0.677998423576355,
0.5948100686073303,
-0.08655131608247757,
0.6224319934844971,
-0.24944283068180084,
0.15952830016613007,
-0.6193744540214539,
0.18993930518627167,
-0.2535902261734009,
-0.24913477897644043,
-0.995405375957489,
-0.18120789527893066,
0.0516686774790287,
-0.08833004534244537,
-0.6003328561782837,
0.5739878416061401,
-0.7109230160713196,
-0.2776910364627838,
-0.25979387760162354,
0.049027055501937866,
0.11967238783836365,
0.4277586340904236,
0.2838432192802429,
1.0557150840759277,
0.907776951789856,
-0.43827593326568604,
-0.12719690799713135,
-0.13329602777957916,
-0.6907406449317932,
0.5132026076316833,
-0.5201782584190369,
0.43761247396469116,
-0.120229072868824,
0.1059424951672554,
-0.9835735559463501,
-0.125385120511055,
0.593920111656189,
-0.21046404540538788,
0.3486853837966919,
-0.34803080558776855,
0.001402901136316359,
-0.3196384608745575,
-0.6321239471435547,
0.7180384993553162,
0.4365909695625305,
-0.6264621615409851,
0.24044181406497955,
0.7745388746261597,
-0.1629755049943924,
-0.9899169206619263,
-0.9202534556388855,
-0.03302446007728577,
-0.18806029856204987,
-0.46977418661117554,
0.564866304397583,
0.05694090202450752,
0.14888127148151398,
-0.039055559784173965,
0.3470614552497864,
-0.39601343870162964,
-0.07243932783603668,
0.0757472887635231,
0.24673157930374146,
-0.10830992460250854,
-0.1322556436061859,
-0.3689958453178406,
-0.10183457285165787,
-0.20868022739887238,
-0.3236374258995056,
0.5848416090011597,
-0.25440800189971924,
-0.2958446443080902,
0.0915512889623642,
0.5618704557418823,
0.338028222322464,
-0.3946077823638916,
0.4302482306957245,
0.8157544732093811,
-0.41827645897865295,
-0.24034422636032104,
-0.8661044836044312,
-0.11754781007766724,
-0.47173213958740234,
0.3429011106491089,
-0.2998521625995636,
-0.7987043261528015,
0.7231708765029907,
0.4727979004383087,
-0.24279780685901642,
-0.1344723105430603,
0.39233076572418213,
-0.12057822197675705,
0.9652093648910522,
1.2087478637695312,
-0.1798662543296814,
1.0032988786697388,
-0.20298883318901062,
0.5802311897277832,
-0.8746336102485657,
-0.008765877224504948,
-0.32294732332229614,
-0.09215438365936279,
-0.1612052470445633,
-0.779378354549408,
0.31392374634742737,
0.6653463244438171,
-0.05223044380545616,
-0.13743820786476135,
-0.7109805345535278,
1.0112121105194092,
0.8590123653411865,
0.05713113024830818,
0.13816983997821808,
0.4125118553638458,
0.12655921280384064,
-0.18961076438426971,
-0.4602074921131134,
-0.30009862780570984,
1.113975167274475,
0.1549990028142929,
0.5028738379478455,
-0.37205424904823303,
0.8032651543617249,
-0.17745642364025116,
0.6116815805435181,
-0.5493646264076233,
0.38395175337791443,
-0.340582937002182,
-0.5069063305854797,
-0.481880784034729,
0.11535743623971939,
-0.6833177208900452,
0.31000810861587524,
-0.1505136787891388,
-0.7785016894340515,
0.3317228853702545,
0.5261176824569702,
-0.26369717717170715,
0.516559898853302,
-0.8562337160110474,
0.7688931226730347,
0.027707800269126892,
0.05075744912028313,
-0.011106329970061779,
-0.6316905617713928,
0.5757204294204712,
0.03685282543301582,
0.3631288707256317,
-0.05727764964103699,
0.05475633591413498,
0.6320337057113647,
-0.5168524384498596,
0.7405572533607483,
-0.7877500057220459,
0.4738207161426544,
0.5232082009315491,
-0.16313767433166504,
0.19779269397258759,
0.14613491296768188,
0.7002356052398682,
0.1922341287136078,
-0.12109751999378204,
-0.6836790442466736,
-0.6743780374526978,
0.011871523223817348,
-0.7930030822753906,
-0.5964822173118591,
-0.33153441548347473,
-0.3859138786792755,
-0.29764124751091003,
0.3076561987400055,
0.4443122148513794,
0.12856262922286987,
-0.04685676470398903,
0.02222808636724949,
0.6572518348693848,
-0.2798941433429718,
0.4773811399936676,
0.1872890293598175,
-0.8197420239448547,
-0.9045426845550537,
0.7758826613426208,
0.2471342235803604,
0.30976414680480957,
0.23199567198753357,
0.23699936270713806,
-0.07640700787305832,
-0.46736690402030945,
-0.2664751410484314,
0.23386862874031067,
-0.7878856658935547,
-0.033333566039800644,
-0.38198134303092957,
-0.19391977787017822,
-0.464455246925354,
-0.533152163028717,
-0.4162385165691376,
-0.4629147946834564,
0.061760950833559036,
0.2940847873687744,
0.026225725188851357,
0.28804174065589905,
-0.3143617510795593,
0.5165106058120728,
-0.22024545073509216,
0.43590912222862244,
0.8370286822319031,
0.29322347044944763,
-0.2971772849559784,
-0.1456107646226883,
-0.33815962076187134,
0.10608717799186707,
-0.0669173151254654,
-0.5544010996818542,
0.3299376964569092,
0.5770744681358337,
0.6460745930671692,
0.6342974305152893,
-0.2847743630409241,
0.7940911650657654,
-0.7167184352874756,
0.787947952747345,
0.5431032180786133,
-0.9724264740943909,
0.6226111054420471,
-0.017376121133565903,
0.34131962060928345,
0.548967182636261,
0.15749457478523254,
-0.5911604166030884,
-0.4272262454032898,
-0.38103577494621277,
-0.9197176098823547,
0.3566988706588745,
-0.151572585105896,
-0.08465369045734406,
-0.04835669696331024,
0.1507454216480255,
0.06524521857500076,
0.40909481048583984,
-0.554288387298584,
0.05549269914627075,
-0.7293553352355957,
0.14893388748168945,
-0.31324502825737,
-0.23297923803329468,
-0.22697611153125763,
-0.3481895625591278,
0.6703196167945862,
-0.4646153151988983,
0.5035136938095093,
0.41319799423217773,
-0.6185051202774048,
-0.053420014679431915,
-0.08438475430011749,
1.0321766138076782,
0.39952391386032104,
-0.27698466181755066,
0.2723177671432495,
-0.25855377316474915,
-1.2134664058685303,
0.13392527401447296,
-0.28292518854141235,
-0.3702181577682495,
0.0975140929222107,
0.13453912734985352,
0.8485736846923828,
0.016071422025561333,
-0.09466861933469772,
1.1815770864486694,
0.10948047786951065,
-0.2797958254814148,
-0.17637164890766144,
-0.17260633409023285,
-0.19396096467971802,
0.0020853006280958652,
0.6479480862617493,
0.20776823163032532,
0.14352211356163025,
-0.4107617735862732,
0.2838164269924164,
0.5185412764549255,
-0.34319573640823364,
-0.43057918548583984,
0.26961007714271545,
-0.24550606310367584,
-0.11456246674060822,
0.5079743266105652,
-0.12743420898914337,
-0.9330914616584778,
0.5715909600257874,
0.5412454605102539,
1.1090649366378784,
-0.3802146315574646,
0.5470243096351624,
0.1822892278432846,
0.483799010515213,
0.11828868836164474,
0.23993128538131714,
-0.1732335090637207,
-0.9317663908004761,
-0.6062164306640625,
-0.4964423179626465,
-0.7299953699111938,
0.10447224974632263,
-0.5246005654335022,
0.35706159472465515,
-0.6314297318458557,
0.10843081772327423,
-0.28961339592933655,
-0.06552528589963913,
-0.9166146516799927,
0.3919849097728729,
0.39022547006607056,
0.8809911012649536,
-1.1017193794250488,
1.207419991493225,
0.8225273489952087,
-0.2909543514251709,
-0.6111873984336853,
-0.16246211528778076,
-0.43972283601760864,
-0.9876354336738586,
0.5306862592697144,
0.5217126607894897,
-0.23219440877437592,
-0.36334019899368286,
-0.8036987781524658,
-0.8141449689865112,
0.7471837997436523,
0.6074838042259216,
-0.4389492869377136,
0.07046102732419968,
0.6931586265563965,
0.4105924963951111,
-0.719846785068512,
0.17820966243743896,
0.32955726981163025,
0.1915649175643921,
0.03449813276529312,
-0.6426627039909363,
-0.21864385902881622,
-0.2589087188243866,
0.288274884223938,
-0.04529670625925064,
-0.46060889959335327,
0.8212687969207764,
-0.029918234795331955,
-0.19338949024677277,
-0.43777456879615784,
0.5800899267196655,
0.24868151545524597,
0.269337922334671,
0.889812171459198,
0.6467472910881042,
0.8526762127876282,
-0.10907134413719177,
0.7278087139129639,
-0.35854509472846985,
0.2699423134326935,
0.9052238464355469,
-0.02459459938108921,
0.6235578656196594,
1.0574501752853394,
-0.03931994363665581,
0.35414478182792664,
0.3561016917228699,
0.22034475207328796,
1.1853411197662354,
0.06550420075654984,
-0.21269649267196655,
-0.17381419241428375,
0.284432053565979,
-0.41847890615463257,
0.05921829864382744,
0.2350964993238449,
0.2816622257232666,
-0.08921520411968231,
0.6625961661338806,
0.04546535015106201,
-0.08508045971393585,
-0.4308825731277466,
0.34731799364089966,
0.1372688263654709,
-0.5458438992500305,
0.4049846827983856,
-0.5423104166984558,
0.8091743588447571,
-0.42984437942504883,
0.09397339820861816,
-0.3381952941417694,
0.3478377163410187,
-0.11783421784639359,
-0.8121993541717529,
0.5633531808853149,
-0.4568818211555481,
-0.2407735139131546,
-0.26539096236228943,
0.7817121148109436,
-0.753275454044342,
-0.38044223189353943,
0.036625899374485016,
-0.14463447034358978,
0.025917844846844673,
-0.30787989497184753,
-0.5205152630805969,
-0.037221457809209824,
-0.24701930582523346,
-0.5628495216369629,
0.3083920180797577,
0.5144904851913452,
-0.30506306886672974,
0.4787639379501343,
0.8475408554077148,
0.4660364091396332,
0.5532808899879456,
0.1667994260787964,
0.7562420964241028,
-0.3192903697490692,
-0.9069257378578186,
-0.4089389741420746,
0.5555479526519775,
-0.36429354548454285,
-0.17512966692447662,
0.4526534378528595,
0.3842564523220062,
0.9332137703895569,
-0.4775703251361847,
0.6995686292648315,
0.10224685072898865,
0.4024374783039093,
-0.6456397175788879,
0.7908754348754883,
-0.25961437821388245,
-0.2268138974905014,
-0.5475603938102722,
-1.1319215297698975,
-0.9284424781799316,
0.9558320045471191,
-0.526789665222168,
-0.37960511445999146,
0.4987787902355194,
0.9721927046775818,
-0.24794995784759521,
-0.27988341450691223,
0.4305482506752014,
-0.23787088692188263,
0.7462534308433533,
0.48772552609443665,
0.5797401666641235,
-0.43874141573905945,
0.4026479125022888,
-0.8910118937492371,
-0.5858080387115479,
-0.41672569513320923,
-1.059762954711914,
-0.9839306473731995,
-0.6701682806015015,
-0.3994062542915344,
0.008102628402411938,
0.04012063145637512,
0.4521540701389313,
1.2334601879119873,
-1.0484795570373535,
-0.012764140963554382,
-0.2393495738506317,
-0.1257326751947403,
-0.1827441155910492,
-0.2018413096666336,
0.4149932563304901,
-0.7477540373802185,
-0.5512646436691284,
0.06691590696573257,
0.5979426503181458,
0.0743458941578865,
-0.4058825373649597,
-0.04215891659259796,
-0.01636608876287937,
0.032399073243141174,
0.509699285030365,
0.5503466129302979,
-0.39037930965423584,
-0.6248793601989746,
0.023495132103562355,
-0.20919042825698853,
0.23531895875930786,
0.9818073511123657,
-0.6990493535995483,
0.731170654296875,
0.35817769169807434,
0.515958309173584,
0.8010954260826111,
-0.40776899456977844,
0.45397448539733887,
-0.7291542291641235,
0.9289178252220154,
0.10639198869466782,
0.2412460446357727,
0.5148053169250488,
-0.2437906712293625,
0.3292045295238495,
0.33097389340400696,
-0.5562909245491028,
-0.9769922494888306,
0.14648963510990143,
-0.9922116994857788,
0.13280777633190155,
0.6724299192428589,
-0.2390989512205124,
-0.5793344378471375,
0.026919735595583916,
-0.3209746181964874,
-0.1015496477484703,
0.07651067525148392,
0.8729161620140076,
0.7058470845222473,
0.31561169028282166,
-0.33283910155296326,
-0.462922066450119,
0.8634655475616455,
0.5194993019104004,
-0.4989948868751526,
-0.36604446172714233,
-0.009310672990977764,
0.4058862030506134,
0.31881746649742126,
1.051730990409851,
-0.36348867416381836,
0.564055323600769,
-0.302058607339859,
0.5366448163986206,
0.10454915463924408,
-0.7078830599784851,
-0.2513349950313568,
0.2337796837091446,
-0.12667851150035858,
-0.6014220714569092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15822v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15822v2
|
Computational Sentence-level Metrics Predicting Human Sentence Comprehension
| 2024-03-23T12:19:49 | 2024-04-15T19:24:12 |
Kun Sun, Rong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ML
|
The majority of research in computational psycholinguistics has concentrated
on the processing of words. This study introduces innovative methods for
computing sentence-level metrics using multilingual large language models. The
metrics developed sentence surprisal and sentence relevance and then are tested
and compared to validate whether they can predict how humans comprehend
sentences as a whole across languages. These metrics offer significant
interpretability and achieve high accuracy in predicting human sentence reading
speeds. Our results indicate that these computational sentence-level metrics
are exceptionally effective at predicting and elucidating the processing
difficulties encountered by readers in comprehending sentences as a whole
across a variety of languages. Their impressive performance and generalization
capabilities provide a promising avenue for future research in integrating LLMs
and cognitive science.
|
[
-0.4386277198791504,
-0.9176121950149536,
0.876589298248291,
0.5290448069572449,
-0.018796779215335846,
0.42785197496414185,
-0.23627141118049622,
-0.8219884037971497,
0.02161916345357895,
0.33834782242774963,
-0.6359207034111023,
-0.46260446310043335,
-0.38074150681495667,
0.40747350454330444,
-0.40338897705078125,
0.5698150992393494,
0.09383516758680344,
0.22983363270759583,
-0.6288142204284668,
0.1816636025905609,
-0.43506646156311035,
-0.7999915480613708,
-0.36251959204673767,
-0.3191121220588684,
0.5209967494010925,
0.2825411856174469,
0.6739886403083801,
0.2886703312397003,
0.7766736745834351,
0.23954857885837555,
-0.25489336252212524,
0.016953324899077415,
-0.2613300681114197,
0.21751877665519714,
-0.03738943487405777,
-0.6207097172737122,
-0.301311731338501,
-0.28206127882003784,
0.7251650094985962,
0.9476329684257507,
-0.10844762623310089,
-0.02640327252447605,
-0.044080913066864014,
0.609394371509552,
-0.5683759450912476,
0.21534611284732819,
-0.34818896651268005,
0.2724822461605072,
-0.18925458192825317,
-0.4028020203113556,
-0.5209245681762695,
-0.1876945197582245,
-0.018043583258986473,
-0.7816596031188965,
0.28884339332580566,
0.18424181640148163,
0.20875109732151031,
0.22591914236545563,
-0.36146751046180725,
-0.3178861737251282,
-0.5238604545593262,
0.579977810382843,
-0.5806733965873718,
0.548790693283081,
0.5394244194030762,
0.2335367500782013,
-0.059745945036411285,
-0.5209464430809021,
-0.4021870195865631,
-0.5706685781478882,
-0.28163421154022217,
0.04671449586749077,
-0.2785543203353882,
0.13662534952163696,
0.3928307592868805,
0.27210259437561035,
-0.8429799675941467,
0.23146700859069824,
-0.5729740262031555,
-0.344504177570343,
0.6194057464599609,
0.5963953733444214,
0.5435365438461304,
-0.17978791892528534,
-0.06469295173883438,
0.15607760846614838,
-0.4336390197277069,
0.2501222789287567,
0.21216003596782684,
0.2671430706977844,
-0.17164191603660583,
0.7056407928466797,
-0.39397481083869934,
0.7093921303749084,
-0.5139920115470886,
-0.20003925263881683,
0.569369912147522,
-0.6831344962120056,
0.09315551072359085,
-0.17302609980106354,
0.7137929797172546,
0.27654340863227844,
0.7478516697883606,
-0.40805044770240784,
0.10047433525323868,
0.28801199793815613,
0.17107434570789337,
-0.5592179298400879,
-0.024326976388692856,
0.1340702921152115,
-0.20052972435951233,
-0.01260643731802702,
-0.17017094790935516,
-0.6721064448356628,
-0.5496675372123718,
-0.2889620065689087,
-0.053858160972595215,
-0.7385101318359375,
-0.0755574181675911,
0.4366084039211273,
-0.11350665241479874,
-0.0815737172961235,
0.023263681679964066,
-0.7518517971038818,
0.3367650508880615,
0.6974811553955078,
1.1410049200057983,
-0.25714242458343506,
-0.6082218885421753,
-0.29751071333885193,
-0.02429441176354885,
-0.3677630126476288,
0.9469396471977234,
-0.6049142479896545,
-0.33962365984916687,
-0.052959028631448746,
-0.2570917308330536,
-0.29694312810897827,
-0.32349643111228943,
0.8625195026397705,
-0.49589723348617554,
-0.03744620457291603,
-0.03996307775378227,
-0.6786479949951172,
-0.15780562162399292,
0.29896295070648193,
-0.5073556900024414,
0.7359012961387634,
-0.012161605060100555,
-0.93112713098526,
0.10986440628767014,
-0.8260814547538757,
-0.8355173468589783,
0.2256239503622055,
0.2634390592575073,
0.02992013283073902,
0.41560500860214233,
0.4761312007904053,
0.5884426236152649,
-0.3033621311187744,
0.2765123248100281,
-0.19148525595664978,
-0.5802158117294312,
0.5187198519706726,
-0.4003159999847412,
0.5746084451675415,
0.3647707998752594,
0.27289968729019165,
0.06636425107717514,
-0.5163900256156921,
0.18225350975990295,
-0.24612948298454285,
-0.22195036709308624,
-0.12226327508687973,
0.09565683454275131,
0.18761798739433289,
0.1088535264134407,
0.2372225970029831,
-0.6424660682678223,
-0.05058923363685608,
-0.5345321297645569,
0.8536276817321777,
0.22302763164043427,
0.12853746116161346,
0.2911321818828583,
-0.18573276698589325,
0.9180933237075806,
-0.04907352477312088,
-0.10929573327302933,
-0.3807404339313507,
-0.37663736939430237,
-0.3568563461303711,
-0.40159285068511963,
0.12324947863817215,
0.8772653937339783,
-0.5891076922416687,
0.4012506902217865,
-0.31451988220214844,
-0.551560640335083,
-0.54770427942276,
-0.0509212389588356,
0.4518779516220093,
0.4252529442310333,
0.4558181166648865,
0.05609933286905289,
-0.40335771441459656,
-0.8034634590148926,
-0.6475850343704224,
-0.33894869685173035,
-0.26992273330688477,
0.15212030708789825,
0.45439383387565613,
-0.19450192153453827,
0.6666310429573059,
-0.720353901386261,
-0.15617628395557404,
-0.5383265614509583,
0.16569733619689941,
0.11843253672122955,
0.22537052631378174,
0.3633537292480469,
-0.6828691363334656,
-0.5124241709709167,
0.04974231868982315,
-0.7260679006576538,
-0.22452588379383087,
0.01026337593793869,
0.13043275475502014,
0.1692081242799759,
0.8359227776527405,
-0.5093797445297241,
0.3341387212276459,
0.3993114233016968,
-0.47320622205734253,
0.6555360555648804,
-0.32180872559547424,
0.2504594027996063,
-0.8119001388549805,
0.01483017299324274,
0.3124368190765381,
-0.23281340301036835,
-0.5844268798828125,
0.18468524515628815,
0.07156577706336975,
-0.03909628465771675,
-0.45117905735969543,
0.351245641708374,
-0.41566696763038635,
-0.48714888095855713,
0.10765209048986435,
0.3253321945667267,
-0.057626672089099884,
0.3707636594772339,
0.04077691212296486,
1.0283653736114502,
0.62398761510849,
-0.48390433192253113,
0.3532079756259918,
0.1216059997677803,
-0.6810568571090698,
0.6017085313796997,
-0.7900359630584717,
-0.044193048030138016,
-0.1242334172129631,
0.3109305202960968,
-1.270879864692688,
-0.2829875946044922,
-0.18325845897197723,
-0.7917317748069763,
-0.27029547095298767,
0.5044600963592529,
-0.6848882436752319,
-0.5101986527442932,
0.015723630785942078,
0.49501362442970276,
0.35279133915901184,
-0.05277197062969208,
0.37937086820602417,
0.3828345537185669,
-0.3071489930152893,
-0.4341026246547699,
-1.066023826599121,
0.17657458782196045,
-0.2595488131046295,
-0.7394822239875793,
0.3148994743824005,
-0.2722312808036804,
-0.3979180157184601,
-0.2507363557815552,
0.37258180975914,
-0.12293008714914322,
0.21511904895305634,
0.12235472351312637,
0.17774415016174316,
-0.1453237384557724,
0.26900792121887207,
-0.05947084352374077,
-0.13088421523571014,
0.13585582375526428,
-0.1172419860959053,
0.6261922717094421,
-0.30797842144966125,
-0.09010729938745499,
-0.6552760601043701,
0.3638964593410492,
0.5821438431739807,
-0.319749653339386,
0.7029070854187012,
0.5672870874404907,
-0.3710726201534271,
0.15678805112838745,
-0.477103590965271,
0.05546004697680473,
-0.3827398121356964,
0.7123273611068726,
-0.7382904887199402,
-1.1554981470108032,
0.6366078853607178,
0.23877690732479095,
-0.2393731027841568,
0.22029949724674225,
0.43595370650291443,
-0.1514303833246231,
1.2805707454681396,
0.6118658781051636,
-0.22957585752010345,
0.3461110591888428,
-0.029097791761159897,
0.21582861244678497,
-0.8030948638916016,
-0.1128067821264267,
-0.6807898283004761,
-0.2732577621936798,
-0.5124949216842651,
-0.31714731454849243,
0.508733332157135,
0.327485591173172,
-0.18041382730007172,
0.13922925293445587,
-0.24635975062847137,
0.8227710127830505,
0.283232718706131,
-0.1178581714630127,
0.5037175416946411,
0.14946319162845612,
-0.30992066860198975,
-0.14256535470485687,
-0.31197020411491394,
-0.2840779423713684,
0.9174290895462036,
0.24138297140598297,
0.4872276484966278,
0.08262255042791367,
0.23289036750793457,
0.5239868760108948,
-0.00976000726222992,
-0.8927854299545288,
0.6356805562973022,
-0.32265710830688477,
-0.6353594064712524,
-0.3922942876815796,
-0.6365972757339478,
-0.9440473914146423,
0.49999135732650757,
-0.028004297986626625,
-1.0818383693695068,
-0.3240324854850769,
-0.20321542024612427,
-0.4006190598011017,
0.05330841615796089,
-0.6135884523391724,
0.83213210105896,
-0.11476320028305054,
0.157220721244812,
-0.646009087562561,
-0.6496925354003906,
0.2538713216781616,
-0.10831107944250107,
0.3823911249637604,
-0.1952957659959793,
-0.321772962808609,
0.548007607460022,
0.089139923453331,
0.5970970392227173,
0.10613430291414261,
0.04023918882012367,
0.031821414828300476,
0.17879131436347961,
-0.22587628662586212,
0.19186007976531982,
-0.37582361698150635,
0.18678796291351318,
0.3402860164642334,
-0.55804443359375,
-0.623359739780426,
0.5620449781417847,
-0.7492753267288208,
-0.4134000837802887,
-0.41535499691963196,
-0.9972776174545288,
-0.6085661053657532,
0.11714602261781693,
0.298258513212204,
0.14477284252643585,
-0.38680216670036316,
0.11105860024690628,
0.2339266985654831,
-0.20567257702350616,
0.34269407391548157,
0.7225373983383179,
-0.22896511852741241,
-0.4418030381202698,
0.6970345377922058,
0.012359973974525928,
0.33647966384887695,
0.673861563205719,
0.09361531585454941,
-0.470949649810791,
-0.7603484392166138,
-0.23536092042922974,
0.2503769099712372,
-0.47127050161361694,
0.032256923615932465,
-0.7200427651405334,
-0.19977951049804688,
-0.49239587783813477,
-0.29319778084754944,
0.2799549698829651,
-0.4975830316543579,
-0.2668269872665405,
-0.35708948969841003,
0.27458256483078003,
0.7160579562187195,
-0.03857037052512169,
0.33937814831733704,
-0.7399210929870605,
0.39025208353996277,
-0.4675354063510895,
0.1432681381702423,
-0.03027324564754963,
-0.6157848238945007,
-0.1897691786289215,
0.049505263566970825,
-0.16840745508670807,
-0.6327769160270691,
0.5632461905479431,
0.2603808641433716,
0.40239620208740234,
0.10628630965948105,
-0.11025490611791611,
0.6758409738540649,
-0.45244231820106506,
0.8562032580375671,
0.29741236567497253,
-1.130537509918213,
0.43740808963775635,
-0.33847329020500183,
0.5283684730529785,
0.5860616564750671,
0.4210602641105652,
-0.9513039588928223,
-0.5031833648681641,
-0.06420442461967468,
-0.6283108592033386,
0.628115177154541,
-0.008465349674224854,
0.054347261786460876,
-0.014101367443799973,
0.6476736068725586,
-0.03528624400496483,
0.0033086908515542746,
-0.42644211649894714,
0.21653322875499725,
0.40509194135665894,
-0.3604080379009247,
-0.7981870770454407,
-0.07178742438554764,
0.4482378661632538,
-0.49564436078071594,
0.3554745018482208,
-0.16279469430446625,
0.0073001026175916195,
0.19697384536266327,
-0.3400554060935974,
-0.10187208652496338,
0.30977359414100647,
0.609577476978302,
0.8818130493164062,
-0.08145303279161453,
-0.014423246495425701,
0.37783071398735046,
-0.7146808505058289,
0.1982940286397934,
0.0909510925412178,
-0.07489573955535889,
-0.2400347739458084,
0.8178261518478394,
0.5605403780937195,
-0.008665252476930618,
-0.9228320121765137,
0.2153218686580658,
-0.14696992933750153,
-0.18775156140327454,
-0.4455111026763916,
0.04712001234292984,
0.36887848377227783,
0.23073585331439972,
0.16016224026679993,
0.007148676551878452,
0.3416960835456848,
-0.5546889901161194,
0.13773910701274872,
0.17342758178710938,
-0.3418843746185303,
-0.27817314863204956,
0.39577773213386536,
0.1435462087392807,
-0.471888929605484,
0.8458921909332275,
-0.029003847390413284,
-0.5302138924598694,
0.7626398205757141,
0.5892451405525208,
0.6928762793540955,
-0.12079411000013351,
0.30414000153541565,
0.34444934129714966,
0.24405688047409058,
-0.13200479745864868,
0.35839948058128357,
0.06653141230344772,
-0.8192955851554871,
-0.6796416640281677,
-0.7864570021629333,
-0.3187498152256012,
-0.18651948869228363,
-0.6032630801200867,
-0.05240150913596153,
-0.0747409537434578,
-0.17540456354618073,
0.4233609735965729,
0.25430718064308167,
-0.4631933569908142,
0.010511375032365322,
0.2928602695465088,
0.9510347247123718,
-0.7788736820220947,
0.7589081525802612,
0.6423159837722778,
-0.4631236791610718,
-0.3152044713497162,
0.10855405032634735,
-0.11910953372716904,
-0.6074360609054565,
0.5337638258934021,
0.3011298179626465,
-0.31651753187179565,
0.043171510100364685,
-0.12048288434743881,
-0.7040991187095642,
0.9007644653320312,
0.4662407636642456,
-0.5983367562294006,
-0.3199687898159027,
0.4611566364765167,
0.983413577079773,
-0.50858473777771,
0.3629609942436218,
0.8449741005897522,
0.4693635106086731,
-0.02685532718896866,
-0.9565170407295227,
-0.20070689916610718,
-0.22364112734794617,
0.10634900629520416,
0.2623552978038788,
-0.3404236435890198,
0.795293390750885,
-0.3294106125831604,
-0.14311088621616364,
0.34573429822921753,
0.628319263458252,
0.21687071025371552,
0.527593195438385,
0.5184204578399658,
0.6656005382537842,
0.874502420425415,
0.1032450944185257,
1.1749085187911987,
-0.4042101502418518,
0.17045962810516357,
0.827427864074707,
-0.3295084238052368,
1.072088360786438,
0.15642018616199493,
-0.4574143886566162,
0.6527830362319946,
0.658994734287262,
0.1792491376399994,
0.16411462426185608,
0.555862307548523,
-0.22527025640010834,
-0.257504403591156,
-0.2642545998096466,
-0.13588988780975342,
0.29373785853385925,
0.6388272047042847,
-0.15377496182918549,
0.2299780547618866,
0.3309656083583832,
-0.1519411951303482,
0.34542858600616455,
-0.44834059476852417,
0.583059549331665,
0.13305799663066864,
-0.9288860559463501,
0.5627158880233765,
0.08110419660806656,
0.7537207007408142,
-0.43497875332832336,
0.3396095931529999,
-0.18317341804504395,
0.45974621176719666,
-0.17313401401042938,
-1.1208173036575317,
0.45985910296440125,
0.131565123796463,
-0.15946151316165924,
-0.03246796503663063,
0.5772766470909119,
-0.31936711072921753,
-0.7662904262542725,
0.5146872997283936,
0.7550908327102661,
0.3526403605937958,
-0.20379948616027832,
-0.6329089999198914,
-0.018778827041387558,
-0.11242589354515076,
-0.12800924479961395,
0.20596984028816223,
0.3303029537200928,
-0.0641753152012825,
1.011523962020874,
0.4970039129257202,
0.07412169128656387,
-0.06830590963363647,
0.3314806818962097,
0.457301527261734,
-0.9475930333137512,
-0.8404054045677185,
-0.9389201998710632,
0.22269126772880554,
0.1026826873421669,
-0.36880168318748474,
0.66961270570755,
0.6354408264160156,
0.7709273099899292,
0.09383087605237961,
0.804717481136322,
0.3141171634197235,
0.671003520488739,
-0.47049635648727417,
0.5334051251411438,
-0.5449264049530029,
0.055680643767118454,
-0.24326400458812714,
-0.8184682130813599,
-0.5434117317199707,
0.4503844380378723,
-0.4708113968372345,
-0.0320015624165535,
0.9453231692314148,
0.6868153810501099,
-0.05466088280081749,
0.35705894231796265,
0.42891615629196167,
0.1933315247297287,
0.11857578903436661,
0.8987806439399719,
1.0064133405685425,
0.11234982311725616,
0.47121599316596985,
-0.09885361790657043,
-0.03961627185344696,
-0.08698838949203491,
-0.48379090428352356,
-0.9518517255783081,
-0.5855379104614258,
-0.019207442179322243,
-0.07822563499212265,
0.15785013139247894,
0.43606704473495483,
0.5817193388938904,
-0.5978124141693115,
-0.4310212731361389,
-0.4546290338039398,
-0.0349576398730278,
-0.2112419605255127,
-0.2837803065776825,
0.12264575809240341,
-0.5890341997146606,
-0.5879311561584473,
0.377399742603302,
0.23496398329734802,
-0.23945499956607819,
-0.547980785369873,
-0.1314169466495514,
-0.20772720873355865,
0.32329851388931274,
0.659888744354248,
-0.035727012902498245,
-0.867434561252594,
0.07139373570680618,
0.2144380658864975,
-0.2260085642337799,
-0.0842936709523201,
1.085728645324707,
-0.8733288645744324,
0.18161632120609283,
0.8158859610557556,
0.5367308259010315,
0.48100346326828003,
0.12773892283439636,
0.5694618821144104,
-0.49389752745628357,
0.12269988656044006,
0.3939891457557678,
0.327056348323822,
0.4042525589466095,
-0.4908114969730377,
0.800055742263794,
0.033667754381895065,
-0.5131605863571167,
-0.883335530757904,
0.3428078889846802,
-0.6999862194061279,
-0.5563499331474304,
0.8428121209144592,
-0.27201586961746216,
-0.1699874848127365,
-0.16025641560554504,
-0.20719094574451447,
0.034813426434993744,
-0.1919621229171753,
0.539676308631897,
1.0219937562942505,
-0.47711214423179626,
-0.31392714381217957,
-0.672048032283783,
0.1994115114212036,
0.5576401948928833,
-0.9690642952919006,
0.19741211831569672,
0.6473721265792847,
0.060662079602479935,
0.31238341331481934,
0.6087876558303833,
-0.0012972148833796382,
0.2879422903060913,
-0.058599792420864105,
-0.13703499734401703,
0.003948797471821308,
-0.43619272112846375,
-0.37326863408088684,
0.19372661411762238,
-0.18982405960559845,
0.3726857304573059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15800v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15800v1
|
MRC-based Nested Medical NER with Co-prediction and Adaptive Pre-training
| 2024-03-23T11:14:02 | 2024-03-23T11:14:02 |
Xiaojing Du, Hanjie Zhao, Danyan Xing, Yuxiang Jia, Hongying Zan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In medical information extraction, medical Named Entity Recognition (NER) is
indispensable, playing a crucial role in developing medical knowledge graphs,
enhancing medical question-answering systems, and analyzing electronic medical
records. The challenge in medical NER arises from the complex nested structures
and sophisticated medical terminologies, distinguishing it from its
counterparts in traditional domains. In response to these complexities, we
propose a medical NER model based on Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC), which
uses a task-adaptive pre-training strategy to improve the model's capability in
the medical field. Meanwhile, our model introduces multiple word-pair
embeddings and multi-granularity dilated convolution to enhance the model's
representation ability and uses a combined predictor of Biaffine and MLP to
improve the model's recognition performance. Experimental evaluations conducted
on the CMeEE, a benchmark for Chinese nested medical NER, demonstrate that our
proposed model outperforms the compared state-of-the-art (SOTA) models.
|
[
-0.24326324462890625,
-0.5379906296730042,
0.44396451115608215,
-0.2906230688095093,
-0.5793370008468628,
0.04758395999670029,
-0.20164354145526886,
-0.6958621740341187,
0.19615723192691803,
0.4419094920158386,
-0.5258971452713013,
-0.35546475648880005,
-0.9489692449569702,
0.4244334399700165,
0.10906800627708435,
1.0966196060180664,
0.0601082518696785,
0.37366291880607605,
-0.39446935057640076,
-0.02100546844303608,
-0.5926636457443237,
-0.6213454008102417,
-0.8826385140419006,
-0.44379985332489014,
0.7072975635528564,
0.3748159408569336,
0.3596792221069336,
0.4574745297431946,
0.9647039175033569,
0.2034679353237152,
0.08306404203176498,
0.33978548645973206,
-0.0621056966483593,
0.1003178209066391,
0.0872814953327179,
-0.5413286685943604,
-0.6241596937179565,
-0.20729632675647736,
0.5151721835136414,
0.47167083621025085,
-0.22076186537742615,
-0.2793795168399811,
-0.08898580074310303,
0.49023282527923584,
-0.3151603043079376,
0.11095978319644928,
-0.658717691898346,
0.14813978970050812,
0.11967798322439194,
-0.40554916858673096,
-0.4526137411594391,
0.1585647463798523,
0.5056807994842529,
-0.5356202125549316,
0.31311294436454773,
0.11806905269622803,
1.1532564163208008,
0.3493935763835907,
-0.21353855729103088,
-0.3781055510044098,
-0.6043182611465454,
0.5538025498390198,
-0.8316687345504761,
0.6214015483856201,
0.45500168204307556,
0.46607816219329834,
-0.03706181049346924,
-0.9376647472381592,
-0.5155503153800964,
-0.27265018224716187,
-0.2628619968891144,
0.5111660361289978,
0.048537351191043854,
-0.10873845964670181,
-0.034455519169569016,
0.2697300314903259,
-0.6467339992523193,
0.1650310456752777,
-0.39499279856681824,
0.1648992896080017,
0.3070266842842102,
0.1459636241197586,
0.5210461020469666,
-0.14342841506004333,
-0.4465567469596863,
0.16133740544319153,
-0.49104589223861694,
-0.17159666121006012,
-0.4754968583583832,
0.33019375801086426,
-0.17102305591106415,
0.46765702962875366,
0.13895615935325623,
0.5455702543258667,
0.3117935061454773,
-0.20815277099609375,
0.3868436813354492,
-0.27517709136009216,
-0.46245139837265015,
-0.011507720686495304,
0.7923071384429932,
0.09931451827287674,
0.2273191511631012,
-0.35429805517196655,
-0.2256583273410797,
-0.16793474555015564,
0.4490736722946167,
-0.8690240383148193,
-0.6109707951545715,
0.141874760389328,
-0.6551451086997986,
-0.2095085084438324,
0.09370630234479904,
-0.7691582441329956,
-0.45735880732536316,
-0.2690070569515228,
0.3366463780403137,
-0.4708928167819977,
-0.14983148872852325,
0.14573949575424194,
0.07309281826019287,
-0.023677058517932892,
0.19026705622673035,
-0.692308783531189,
0.5775354504585266,
0.3644641637802124,
0.8211076855659485,
-0.3011939823627472,
0.02508699893951416,
-0.3831879794597626,
-0.02241354063153267,
0.005264209117740393,
0.8446597456932068,
-0.5094183087348938,
-0.21100856363773346,
-0.47314023971557617,
0.10490162670612335,
-0.6566532850265503,
-0.834418773651123,
0.12921565771102905,
-0.8639897108078003,
0.387835294008255,
0.2460659146308899,
-0.3911694586277008,
-0.22419539093971252,
0.562439501285553,
-0.8271628022193909,
0.47449740767478943,
0.03438086062669754,
-1.060966968536377,
0.40686729550361633,
-0.7380502223968506,
-0.5545679330825806,
0.0878465324640274,
-0.23257069289684296,
-0.8958159685134888,
-0.11382532119750977,
0.5966951251029968,
0.47867271304130554,
-0.32171952724456787,
0.33530184626579285,
-0.04901048168540001,
-0.1455550342798233,
0.23475277423858643,
-0.1932552009820938,
0.4455343186855316,
-0.012236707843840122,
-0.16384699940681458,
0.2635626792907715,
-0.9178971648216248,
-0.009619994089007378,
0.31094175577163696,
-0.322530597448349,
-0.4361821115016937,
0.0926751047372818,
-0.2947145998477936,
0.27513378858566284,
0.10318063944578171,
-0.22251226007938385,
-0.04492644593119621,
-0.7968370914459229,
0.34544751048088074,
0.23094087839126587,
0.35224199295043945,
0.3785235285758972,
-0.2775336503982544,
0.5723549723625183,
0.40337005257606506,
-0.026720717549324036,
0.025839800015091896,
-0.25600680708885193,
-0.5561038851737976,
-0.6480794548988342,
0.7578378319740295,
0.8213132619857788,
-0.6274118423461914,
0.45673251152038574,
-0.3102399408817291,
-0.41362470388412476,
-0.45316168665885925,
-0.3010157346725464,
0.3258698880672455,
0.7093894481658936,
0.732384443283081,
-0.384658545255661,
-0.7795480489730835,
-0.6211931705474854,
-0.08572130650281906,
0.06150812283158302,
-0.0642535462975502,
0.6077393889427185,
0.6166263222694397,
-0.5934311151504517,
0.43363380432128906,
-0.6040711998939514,
-0.4827271103858948,
-0.2865592837333679,
0.12408535927534103,
0.35493358969688416,
0.4797866642475128,
0.08184584230184555,
-1.0353665351867676,
-0.4519728720188141,
0.2842923402786255,
-0.7265335321426392,
0.13620907068252563,
-0.06268838047981262,
0.09730664640665054,
-0.17539310455322266,
0.5686846971511841,
-0.3251747786998749,
0.3888598084449768,
0.5218051075935364,
-0.14262863993644714,
0.6349751353263855,
-0.4423535466194153,
0.0942925214767456,
-1.4736263751983643,
0.15062931180000305,
-0.21626096963882446,
-0.16472871601581573,
-0.5100501775741577,
0.09640141576528549,
0.09062539041042328,
0.022423146292567253,
-0.02973611280322075,
0.4501889646053314,
-0.8291006684303284,
0.19185224175453186,
-0.19215592741966248,
0.00422576442360878,
0.10729648172855377,
0.1274998039007187,
0.2860635817050934,
0.5864399671554565,
0.5894766449928284,
-0.7187575101852417,
-0.015027731657028198,
0.34359341859817505,
-0.13467609882354736,
0.45256349444389343,
-0.811218798160553,
0.36619189381599426,
-0.13174350559711456,
0.08115685731172562,
-0.43132123351097107,
-0.24703478813171387,
0.29428473114967346,
-0.5851669907569885,
0.7377603650093079,
-0.21476134657859802,
-0.32048654556274414,
-0.3693239688873291,
0.32725417613983154,
0.5085914134979248,
0.21928484737873077,
-0.41274985671043396,
0.9404535889625549,
0.4715466797351837,
-0.44421154260635376,
-0.6694011092185974,
-0.6871182322502136,
0.09960988163948059,
0.06388535350561142,
-0.4446886479854584,
0.6383876800537109,
-0.018826620653271675,
0.20584656298160553,
0.08643584698438644,
-0.1561794877052307,
-0.5584293007850647,
-0.10344944894313812,
0.3413994014263153,
0.7214494943618774,
-0.5546112656593323,
0.2449347972869873,
0.08937496691942215,
-0.16244623064994812,
-0.12422836571931839,
-0.09961982816457748,
0.47980251908302307,
-0.0023663295432925224,
-0.05375423654913902,
-0.2292136400938034,
0.23610033094882965,
0.49080169200897217,
-0.6374998688697815,
0.7960085868835449,
0.42741596698760986,
-0.9669094681739807,
0.1415288746356964,
-0.35071229934692383,
-0.4363773763179779,
-0.360743910074234,
0.5899475812911987,
-0.5823533535003662,
-0.8821194767951965,
0.4653557240962982,
-0.09026065468788147,
-0.2022143453359604,
0.488949179649353,
0.6112052202224731,
-0.1591501235961914,
0.9688163995742798,
0.5021845102310181,
0.2852640450000763,
0.18360881507396698,
-0.024780647829174995,
0.13820290565490723,
-0.9669101238250732,
-0.5789785385131836,
-0.4258931577205658,
-0.06982245296239853,
-0.29611432552337646,
-0.47773128747940063,
0.43325498700141907,
-0.006615431513637304,
0.006949726492166519,
0.22588475048542023,
-0.547796905040741,
0.3318111300468445,
0.3457335829734802,
0.44561967253685,
0.2657467722892761,
-0.11031866073608398,
-0.5479665994644165,
-0.05838300287723541,
-0.7055730819702148,
-0.2965850830078125,
0.7728472948074341,
0.2512369453907013,
0.6704076528549194,
-0.20867229998111725,
0.7429335713386536,
-0.0067146215587854385,
0.28981950879096985,
-0.8420184850692749,
0.2009703814983368,
-0.5568069219589233,
-0.5983821153640747,
-0.014515692368149757,
-0.4685061573982239,
-1.1352792978286743,
0.18047377467155457,
-0.6775346398353577,
-0.4073612093925476,
0.18164198100566864,
0.01426142081618309,
-0.5155205130577087,
0.29684263467788696,
-0.5780625343322754,
0.8782168626785278,
-0.2047889679670334,
0.20718929171562195,
-0.03874746337532997,
-0.8787912726402283,
0.1131783276796341,
-0.21622714400291443,
0.22801601886749268,
0.30809664726257324,
0.05108123645186424,
0.6720381379127502,
-0.24651503562927246,
0.6512348651885986,
-0.1263665109872818,
0.5656182169914246,
0.11367097496986389,
-0.189758762717247,
0.39676904678344727,
-0.03627684712409973,
-0.02458781562745571,
0.16250383853912354,
0.193834587931633,
-0.2265050858259201,
-0.4905276298522949,
0.38020843267440796,
-0.6630327701568604,
-0.236289381980896,
-0.5469618439674377,
-0.5401412844657898,
-0.1994006186723709,
0.6495901346206665,
0.5085285305976868,
0.484960675239563,
-0.32515749335289,
0.17985010147094727,
0.5707139372825623,
-0.1896618902683258,
0.02271016500890255,
0.32755371928215027,
0.09193985164165497,
-0.6760086417198181,
0.5897877812385559,
0.1464616358280182,
-0.015243363566696644,
0.6891967058181763,
0.29569175839424133,
-0.32322683930397034,
-0.9767352938652039,
-0.5195131301879883,
0.30408400297164917,
-0.4222206175327301,
-0.23862183094024658,
-0.9591122269630432,
-0.6406269669532776,
-0.31684166193008423,
0.08196943253278732,
-0.03978718817234039,
0.11951375752687454,
-0.6867114901542664,
0.05573820322751999,
-0.003110595280304551,
0.6227855086326599,
0.16909509897232056,
0.36643293499946594,
-1.0279157161712646,
0.5054208636283875,
0.06586674600839615,
0.4398784637451172,
-0.246907040476799,
-0.6965875029563904,
-0.2625272572040558,
-0.31361883878707886,
0.24438390135765076,
-0.7807696461677551,
0.4340137243270874,
0.07710468769073486,
0.4217776656150818,
0.3865949511528015,
0.07359711080789566,
0.8047051429748535,
-0.8672311305999756,
0.2819443643093109,
0.31407180428504944,
-0.3059066832065582,
0.3130974769592285,
-0.018948763608932495,
0.1416885107755661,
0.7082781791687012,
0.36856213212013245,
-0.1917598396539688,
-0.028066182509064674,
-0.5084203481674194,
-0.6023104190826416,
0.321997731924057,
-0.250151664018631,
-0.12308520078659058,
0.0038851588033139706,
0.446300208568573,
0.1807943880558014,
0.025656742975115776,
-0.657483696937561,
0.058404721319675446,
0.06935692578554153,
-0.5467686653137207,
0.08461602032184601,
-0.2805652320384979,
0.09269563108682632,
-0.22261951863765717,
0.6703211665153503,
0.010020582936704159,
0.4282276928424835,
0.541338324546814,
-0.22487394511699677,
-0.07307519018650055,
0.3312913179397583,
0.5353357195854187,
0.40698695182800293,
-0.3537004888057709,
0.318338006734848,
0.23557856678962708,
-0.8772761821746826,
-0.24581460654735565,
0.4339395761489868,
-0.05987580493092537,
-0.13086915016174316,
0.209777370095253,
0.670188844203949,
0.11157838255167007,
-0.6143263578414917,
0.47754591703414917,
-0.3487521708011627,
-0.13808846473693848,
-0.44577720761299133,
-0.10587017238140106,
0.18514089286327362,
0.2819875478744507,
0.08457212895154953,
0.5024797916412354,
0.25294074416160583,
-0.13891875743865967,
0.5710320472717285,
0.34970423579216003,
-0.7171453833580017,
-0.25994256138801575,
0.6514689326286316,
-0.16069403290748596,
-0.23949216306209564,
0.7012558579444885,
0.030163923278450966,
-0.5837709307670593,
0.5600913166999817,
0.8016796708106995,
0.631301760673523,
-0.2687981426715851,
-0.18536268174648285,
0.697565495967865,
0.3409968316555023,
0.12154486030340195,
0.22768503427505493,
0.35895293951034546,
-0.7783559560775757,
-0.3712979853153229,
-0.46979820728302,
-0.20349866151809692,
0.2113879919052124,
-0.7151440978050232,
0.3801414668560028,
-0.5809640884399414,
-0.1994573324918747,
0.28482067584991455,
0.08770056068897247,
-0.5953324437141418,
0.8997887969017029,
0.1012503057718277,
0.6860409379005432,
-0.405215859413147,
0.7936024069786072,
0.7684237360954285,
-0.487681120634079,
-0.8448559641838074,
0.11549238115549088,
-0.26506367325782776,
-0.7418708205223083,
0.24206523597240448,
0.30137673020362854,
-0.05411724001169205,
0.026402346789836884,
-0.26011529564857483,
-0.622271716594696,
1.0437886714935303,
-0.1077144667506218,
-0.7774714231491089,
-0.4072728753089905,
-0.3549577295780182,
0.5446396470069885,
-0.7232138514518738,
0.23822952806949615,
0.2244444638490677,
0.29057860374450684,
0.06755299121141434,
-0.811808168888092,
0.15217457711696625,
-0.3583308160305023,
-0.47404471039772034,
0.060474805533885956,
-0.07693629711866379,
0.7690662741661072,
-0.7362815737724304,
-0.3961572051048279,
0.15284045040607452,
0.4645427465438843,
0.4061048626899719,
0.6845082640647888,
0.6261841058731079,
0.5042338967323303,
0.9125034809112549,
0.1430288553237915,
0.9543130397796631,
-0.06126184016466141,
0.14820678532123566,
1.4894435405731201,
-0.1476481854915619,
1.099766492843628,
0.35112494230270386,
-0.03156647831201553,
1.0266664028167725,
0.6075477004051208,
-0.21064357459545135,
0.5944733023643494,
0.024030141532421112,
-0.17182657122612,
-0.12855713069438934,
0.12778633832931519,
-0.4390292763710022,
0.4419482350349426,
0.45520147681236267,
-0.7747066020965576,
0.11804471164941788,
0.008353373035788536,
-0.07994617521762848,
-0.11738456040620804,
-0.3323238492012024,
1.1324354410171509,
0.30359241366386414,
-0.5613188743591309,
0.4520452320575714,
-0.07968822121620178,
0.5172222256660461,
-0.47419193387031555,
-0.11269812285900116,
0.39398932456970215,
0.2918466031551361,
-0.27374282479286194,
-0.24773016571998596,
0.30757689476013184,
-0.22017140686511993,
-0.5770008563995361,
0.563085675239563,
1.216355800628662,
-0.4639081656932831,
-0.5051231384277344,
0.4576321244239807,
0.6800451874732971,
0.11865316331386566,
-0.22393298149108887,
-0.8216527104377747,
-0.45229706168174744,
-0.2748078405857086,
0.06854481995105743,
0.24232117831707,
0.3779306709766388,
0.10768497735261917,
0.40394458174705505,
0.8336212635040283,
0.3078559339046478,
0.10081220418214798,
0.2683684825897217,
0.7811977863311768,
-0.6189069151878357,
-0.583473265171051,
-0.7575353384017944,
0.3996485471725464,
-0.07088681310415268,
0.01463974267244339,
0.05537258833646774,
0.4692732095718384,
0.5508583784103394,
-0.33087149262428284,
0.5983144640922546,
0.04861822351813316,
0.7790660262107849,
-0.37857291102409363,
0.9295476675033569,
-0.7221255302429199,
-0.11888527870178223,
-0.034668851643800735,
-0.4716741740703583,
-0.7637922763824463,
0.6270400881767273,
-0.2922939956188202,
0.1396285742521286,
0.9520173668861389,
0.6590408086776733,
-0.20806638896465302,
-0.03292651101946831,
0.44128262996673584,
0.46684420108795166,
-0.05288294702768326,
0.5713297724723816,
0.5754328966140747,
-0.46588751673698425,
0.4146747589111328,
-0.09812662750482559,
-0.24019238352775574,
-0.25724005699157715,
-0.6577444672584534,
-1.0948493480682373,
-0.46113115549087524,
-0.32256847620010376,
-0.44017618894577026,
0.13718681037425995,
0.8712300062179565,
0.9153871536254883,
-1.08173668384552,
0.4222458600997925,
-0.046278975903987885,
-0.15616855025291443,
-0.4007733166217804,
-0.19583982229232788,
0.6130864024162292,
-0.10813948512077332,
-0.4970870018005371,
0.41848209500312805,
0.48466956615448,
0.0558650940656662,
0.2894153594970703,
-0.042633652687072754,
-0.38592734932899475,
0.08695598691701889,
0.5000827312469482,
0.23005419969558716,
-0.5646970272064209,
-0.14152003824710846,
0.3607303500175476,
-0.3924109637737274,
0.448738157749176,
0.6592209339141846,
-0.724489688873291,
0.6972832679748535,
0.29710352420806885,
0.9033756852149963,
0.3328765034675598,
0.016365783289074898,
0.24307109415531158,
-0.455658882856369,
-0.3363249599933624,
0.528937816619873,
0.4398466944694519,
0.32931649684906006,
-0.5073264241218567,
0.33117321133613586,
0.23389969766139984,
-0.5798119306564331,
-0.6264148354530334,
0.08167186379432678,
-1.176028847694397,
-0.2745351493358612,
0.697546124458313,
-0.21916617453098297,
-0.1608559936285019,
-0.4436678886413574,
-0.2106255739927292,
0.662982702255249,
-0.0573556013405323,
0.6543328762054443,
0.30157873034477234,
-0.12191454321146011,
-0.5286498069763184,
-0.41086453199386597,
-0.014298097230494022,
0.3938973546028137,
-0.9334274530410767,
-0.3260905146598816,
0.23833802342414856,
0.5582499504089355,
0.260683536529541,
0.7683348059654236,
-0.5384117364883423,
0.30519965291023254,
-0.010143443942070007,
0.07721611112356186,
-0.20729953050613403,
-0.5806727409362793,
-0.22554732859134674,
0.12739282846450806,
0.05658690258860588,
-0.2707105576992035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15796v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15796v2
|
Understanding Emergent Abilities of Language Models from the Loss Perspective
| 2024-03-23T11:03:31 | 2024-03-30T09:55:12 |
Zhengxiao Du, Aohan Zeng, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent studies have put into question the belief that emergent abilities in
language models are exclusive to large models. This skepticism arises from two
observations: 1) smaller models can also exhibit high performance on emergent
abilities and 2) there is doubt on the discontinuous metrics used to measure
these abilities. In this paper, we propose to study emergent abilities in the
lens of pre-training loss, instead of model size or training compute. We
demonstrate that the models with the same pre-training loss, but different
model and data sizes, generate the same performance on various downstream
tasks. We also discover that a model exhibits emergent abilities on certain
tasks -- regardless of the continuity of metrics -- when its pre-training loss
falls below a specific threshold. Before reaching this threshold, its
performance remains at the level of random guessing. This inspires us to
redefine emergent abilities as those that manifest in models with lower
pre-training losses, highlighting that these abilities cannot be predicted by
merely extrapolating the performance trends of models with higher pre-training
losses.
|
[
-0.38235756754875183,
-0.6425329446792603,
0.8131448030471802,
0.03584226965904236,
0.0023662790190428495,
0.2587859630584717,
-0.2568751573562622,
-0.4245752990245819,
0.03929422050714493,
0.3330385684967041,
-0.6808111667633057,
0.09506774693727493,
-0.8811655640602112,
-0.2226015329360962,
-0.5908371806144714,
1.0603896379470825,
0.31375250220298767,
0.0062939878553152084,
-0.11494211852550507,
0.11302302032709122,
-0.4026360511779785,
-0.2909848988056183,
-0.8789299130439758,
-0.3310000002384186,
0.5773305892944336,
0.14728426933288574,
0.6669555902481079,
0.5591660737991333,
0.38140857219696045,
0.27026769518852234,
-0.06663674116134644,
-0.37268975377082825,
-0.6347821950912476,
-0.13483643531799316,
-0.046017151325941086,
-1.0215119123458862,
-0.08272510021924973,
0.2560882866382599,
1.1092345714569092,
0.8466914296150208,
-0.2526302933692932,
0.20891357958316803,
0.35875439643859863,
0.4132264256477356,
-0.3838338851928711,
-0.21147839725017548,
-0.8659077882766724,
0.20756307244300842,
-0.36588555574417114,
-0.29257795214653015,
-0.7065297365188599,
-0.096279077231884,
0.3982163369655609,
-0.33884695172309875,
0.6187148690223694,
-0.047589290887117386,
0.9836871027946472,
0.356937974691391,
-0.21192537248134613,
0.12559404969215393,
-1.1462584733963013,
0.5685845017433167,
-0.8533416986465454,
0.4328063428401947,
0.023650409653782845,
0.36710038781166077,
0.1536339372396469,
-0.43212634325027466,
-0.47430935502052307,
-0.30731502175331116,
0.06454425305128098,
0.03313513845205307,
-0.3251055181026459,
0.004022389184683561,
0.2834027111530304,
0.47993889451026917,
-0.34612417221069336,
0.46944335103034973,
-0.18918226659297943,
-0.004951524548232555,
0.4228091239929199,
0.045630279928445816,
0.3596597909927368,
0.15667232871055603,
-0.21434496343135834,
-0.15228299796581268,
-0.7974545955657959,
0.05626756325364113,
0.4158436059951782,
0.39270779490470886,
-0.015614760108292103,
0.4375632405281067,
0.15415607392787933,
0.48470786213874817,
-0.11180367320775986,
-0.13280488550662994,
0.025859037414193153,
-0.20005539059638977,
-0.03912634402513504,
-0.16470281779766083,
0.5700540542602539,
-0.18187926709651947,
0.2943252921104431,
-0.14339038729667664,
-0.07969056814908981,
-0.39513424038887024,
0.2601814568042755,
-0.4410620629787445,
-0.4155576229095459,
-0.22585122287273407,
-0.6725066900253296,
-0.36659494042396545,
-0.17432452738285065,
-0.23202407360076904,
-0.48930418491363525,
0.10156825184822083,
0.7011376619338989,
-0.38364672660827637,
-0.7003326416015625,
-0.07576943933963776,
-0.1549447774887085,
0.087700754404068,
0.3625424802303314,
-0.8806467056274414,
0.4988955557346344,
0.3600054979324341,
0.8450074791908264,
0.10914147645235062,
-0.476860374212265,
-0.2977198362350464,
-0.2578737735748291,
-0.576401948928833,
0.599760115146637,
-0.28183168172836304,
0.03108561970293522,
-0.22975417971611023,
-0.14200332760810852,
-0.4819640517234802,
-0.37074947357177734,
0.017833711579442024,
-0.6244791746139526,
-0.11437453329563141,
-0.07395067065954208,
-0.44681352376937866,
-0.22007235884666443,
-0.18136730790138245,
-0.5751740336418152,
0.7259464859962463,
0.111736960709095,
-0.9971210956573486,
0.8011858463287354,
-0.4462869465351105,
-0.4103054106235504,
0.2287347912788391,
-0.09365677088499069,
-0.289851576089859,
0.5902683734893799,
-0.3453470468521118,
0.5541486740112305,
-0.2916763424873352,
-0.20284467935562134,
-0.2881371080875397,
-0.054114941507577896,
0.33735132217407227,
-0.6037236452102661,
0.8346463441848755,
-0.10738196223974228,
-0.47146767377853394,
-0.17914599180221558,
-0.9184514880180359,
0.3579210937023163,
0.3531864285469055,
-0.41530051827430725,
-0.5322797894477844,
0.34995463490486145,
-0.19397714734077454,
0.3286031484603882,
0.13713601231575012,
-0.36937689781188965,
-0.10378234088420868,
-0.5412291884422302,
0.30327746272087097,
0.7267409563064575,
-0.057782385498285294,
0.4694449007511139,
-0.20798997581005096,
0.6897305846214294,
0.07973189651966095,
0.030748533084988594,
-0.11278486996889114,
-0.5424796342849731,
-0.8366023898124695,
-0.0032596876844763756,
0.3424559235572815,
0.41105470061302185,
-0.4271332621574402,
0.2495456337928772,
-0.2516757845878601,
-0.8314776420593262,
-0.8487525582313538,
0.20386184751987457,
0.3529652953147888,
0.3078952133655548,
-0.03279720991849899,
-0.43841177225112915,
-0.6016974449157715,
-0.9630253911018372,
-0.3515722453594208,
-0.3664582371711731,
-0.07493087649345398,
0.16728806495666504,
0.4802398979663849,
0.1606454998254776,
0.9028791189193726,
-0.4771610498428345,
0.07162531465291977,
-0.5594215989112854,
0.3089189827442169,
0.08093851059675217,
0.5495012402534485,
0.4397730529308319,
-0.6906805634498596,
-0.10843980312347412,
0.10604335367679596,
-0.5123099684715271,
-0.05270858481526375,
-0.3233899772167206,
0.4702044725418091,
0.014099729247391224,
0.4280327260494232,
-0.50394207239151,
0.5013917684555054,
0.6152042746543884,
-0.33445197343826294,
0.8273000717163086,
-0.4149981439113617,
-0.07176406681537628,
-0.9223815202713013,
-0.002501200884580612,
-0.3171439468860626,
0.08523773401975632,
-0.7966193556785583,
-0.18241426348686218,
-0.17982220649719238,
0.05478744953870773,
-0.44691500067710876,
0.3528619110584259,
-0.5331670045852661,
-0.48717278242111206,
-0.11076829582452774,
-0.05797755345702171,
0.021202776581048965,
0.184157133102417,
0.20325958728790283,
0.6158186197280884,
0.6967869400978088,
-0.8024546504020691,
-0.278484582901001,
-0.1457114964723587,
-0.6766987442970276,
0.14553113281726837,
-0.6966071128845215,
-0.08311448991298676,
-0.36984947323799133,
0.0022605403792113066,
-0.9429188966751099,
-0.0718032494187355,
-0.21440455317497253,
-0.5373165607452393,
0.3965355157852173,
-0.3271813690662384,
-0.3718425929546356,
-0.5203623175621033,
0.13195614516735077,
0.22351588308811188,
0.6457971930503845,
-0.0979265570640564,
0.3559556305408478,
0.25498494505882263,
-0.21816258132457733,
-0.5271043181419373,
-0.8824754953384399,
-0.05210571363568306,
-0.42604154348373413,
-0.5070104002952576,
0.17609234154224396,
-0.1803794950246811,
-0.10681512206792831,
0.06728798896074295,
0.3129274845123291,
-0.12281007319688797,
0.4975668787956238,
0.15490393340587616,
-0.12924082577228546,
-0.4974045753479004,
0.23264047503471375,
-0.060894936323165894,
0.09210416674613953,
0.11688070744276047,
-0.3219743072986603,
0.5531282424926758,
-0.1487129181623459,
-0.4672120213508606,
-0.1423315852880478,
0.1533048003911972,
0.522304892539978,
-0.4759361445903778,
1.3159708976745605,
0.5113587379455566,
-0.2910979986190796,
-0.2455352395772934,
-0.6169782876968384,
-0.10930127650499344,
-0.3976399600505829,
0.7031242847442627,
-0.4839404821395874,
-0.6242664456367493,
1.0884119272232056,
0.1344607025384903,
-0.022043516859412193,
0.7872379422187805,
0.36496952176094055,
0.04108908027410507,
1.2073001861572266,
1.0023664236068726,
0.5152727961540222,
0.5890399813652039,
-0.5374821424484253,
0.269826740026474,
-1.0418304204940796,
-0.335053950548172,
-0.44324031472206116,
-0.040886372327804565,
-0.444125771522522,
-0.1883106380701065,
0.19059617817401886,
0.3312585651874542,
-0.3252633512020111,
0.23840585350990295,
-0.19051390886306763,
0.466740220785141,
0.6322669982910156,
0.005270556081086397,
0.18814454972743988,
-0.3802657723426819,
0.058162473142147064,
-0.05176352709531784,
-1.191001057624817,
-0.47781902551651,
1.0592317581176758,
0.732769787311554,
0.8965036869049072,
-0.008571917191147804,
0.7779901027679443,
0.06151626259088516,
0.3422400653362274,
-0.727319598197937,
0.35982662439346313,
0.19515158236026764,
-0.7804767489433289,
-0.674504816532135,
-0.6715913414955139,
-0.9804142713546753,
0.1850433349609375,
-0.38352420926094055,
-0.768906831741333,
0.17248600721359253,
0.3247903883457184,
-0.6120395660400391,
0.6759377717971802,
-0.8833266496658325,
1.1459800004959106,
-0.30435818433761597,
0.00338913407176733,
-0.18565945327281952,
-0.5968815088272095,
0.2986670136451721,
-0.1433373987674713,
0.14674857258796692,
-0.0623130165040493,
-0.03084990195930004,
1.0883381366729736,
-0.4280000627040863,
0.7889404296875,
-0.23332186043262482,
-0.18257522583007812,
0.42727407813072205,
0.25394773483276367,
0.21044260263442993,
-0.18133573234081268,
0.3556458652019501,
0.11299257725477219,
-0.015385271050035954,
-0.3251361846923828,
-0.7326549291610718,
0.3532894253730774,
-0.7894772887229919,
-0.5805137753486633,
-0.20422855019569397,
-0.18381008505821228,
-0.1010683923959732,
0.6767794489860535,
0.7176201939582825,
0.4884304404258728,
-0.48522302508354187,
0.08633523434400558,
0.7634319067001343,
-0.09615738689899445,
0.4995705783367157,
0.6134620308876038,
-0.05846519023180008,
0.19120314717292786,
0.8554412722587585,
0.6656715273857117,
0.7658638954162598,
0.38055986166000366,
0.23543386161327362,
-0.21195507049560547,
-1.0268968343734741,
-0.23060210049152374,
0.14379987120628357,
-0.7059888243675232,
0.13994275033473969,
-0.5288248658180237,
-0.5833247303962708,
-0.2663477957248688,
0.02452523447573185,
-0.6281538605690002,
-0.2625204622745514,
-0.16723354160785675,
-0.19634830951690674,
-0.008554929867386818,
1.0402566194534302,
-0.20628722012043,
0.3981574773788452,
-0.7704427242279053,
-0.33983367681503296,
0.3785931468009949,
0.4392145574092865,
0.5876274108886719,
-0.6902580857276917,
-0.6424945592880249,
0.08362120389938354,
-0.10238099098205566,
-0.8992601037025452,
0.2630537450313568,
0.38647738099098206,
0.5602924227714539,
0.8840221166610718,
-0.31027951836586,
0.3015974164009094,
-0.749261736869812,
0.6681665778160095,
0.1877427101135254,
-0.7184324264526367,
0.5280033349990845,
-0.44531944394111633,
0.4798736870288849,
0.5182744860649109,
0.28082314133644104,
-0.29692894220352173,
-0.6221922636032104,
-1.1357542276382446,
-0.5689813494682312,
0.7596285343170166,
0.21811966598033905,
0.19036614894866943,
0.024337632581591606,
-0.028776472434401512,
0.11495763808488846,
0.30267542600631714,
-0.8973317742347717,
-0.15974906086921692,
-0.09697074443101883,
0.15743388235569,
-0.4561295807361603,
-0.17495891451835632,
0.0005998456617817283,
-0.2370845079421997,
0.3501199185848236,
0.17110492289066315,
0.2511677145957947,
0.006944708526134491,
-0.11424484848976135,
-0.16660094261169434,
0.23458276689052582,
0.4746023714542389,
0.7324005365371704,
-0.1458466798067093,
0.31926706433296204,
0.17939569056034088,
-0.5124239325523376,
0.35688820481300354,
0.01392785832285881,
-0.06010379269719124,
-0.17416656017303467,
0.7753561735153198,
0.8318036198616028,
0.5575062036514282,
-0.6615681648254395,
0.5833771228790283,
0.10959339886903763,
0.12094096094369888,
-0.4154854416847229,
0.0899341031908989,
0.1437540203332901,
0.03447147458791733,
0.6004617810249329,
0.4790622293949127,
0.03130541369318962,
-0.6132189035415649,
0.05472004413604736,
0.29631176590919495,
-0.3796871602535248,
-0.5806902647018433,
0.6774318814277649,
0.03514225408434868,
-0.4282210171222687,
0.46558085083961487,
-0.25520288944244385,
-0.46664226055145264,
0.7487788200378418,
0.6714514493942261,
1.0013655424118042,
-0.49887415766716003,
0.4248631000518799,
-0.01111750677227974,
0.6353999972343445,
-0.0765964686870575,
-0.25270912051200867,
0.12456412613391876,
-1.005859613418579,
-0.5244495272636414,
-0.567273736000061,
0.05185730382800102,
0.3011036515235901,
-0.6236582398414612,
-0.1624128520488739,
-0.4442981779575348,
-0.2777039408683777,
0.30490103363990784,
-0.19026342034339905,
-1.0394182205200195,
0.3806678354740143,
-0.0612482987344265,
0.7519391775131226,
-1.0221266746520996,
0.2689134180545807,
0.4000360071659088,
-0.5061091184616089,
-0.9799603223800659,
-0.0681992694735527,
-0.06544823944568634,
-0.7778252959251404,
0.792486310005188,
0.10347335040569305,
-0.08806610852479935,
0.24927377700805664,
-0.10027176141738892,
-1.092780590057373,
0.8303648233413696,
0.47758519649505615,
-0.23879994451999664,
-0.46681860089302063,
-0.11301752924919128,
0.6794343590736389,
-0.6615058779716492,
0.40963873267173767,
0.4679868221282959,
0.1546431928873062,
-0.16918598115444183,
-1.1112041473388672,
-0.1610894501209259,
-0.040025871247053146,
0.09875401854515076,
0.24251094460487366,
-0.528298556804657,
1.00382399559021,
-0.6446332931518555,
-0.5604740977287292,
-0.0840507224202156,
0.3945583999156952,
-0.48478761315345764,
0.1456431895494461,
0.588505744934082,
0.5985597968101501,
0.6090205907821655,
0.10243693739175797,
1.262778639793396,
-0.06623536348342896,
0.12653425335884094,
1.0022975206375122,
0.12619943916797638,
1.0549806356430054,
0.027938812971115112,
-0.2844206392765045,
0.5052540302276611,
0.5476612448692322,
0.3988134264945984,
0.4625713527202606,
0.22103500366210938,
-0.14037983119487762,
-0.3688976764678955,
0.13588613271713257,
-0.22076688706874847,
0.7537726163864136,
0.13894017040729523,
-0.40401318669319153,
-0.03152667358517647,
0.09917628020048141,
-0.1130186915397644,
-0.013949127867817879,
-0.35929980874061584,
0.6444249153137207,
0.013366899453103542,
-0.4790458381175995,
0.6466943025588989,
-0.3175186216831207,
0.2536661624908447,
-0.7143548727035522,
0.10131281614303589,
0.23140639066696167,
0.03897447884082794,
-0.00048308668192476034,
-0.8009235858917236,
0.32892534136772156,
-0.5181406736373901,
-0.431974858045578,
0.02955058217048645,
0.5719941854476929,
-0.29106029868125916,
-0.4763815104961395,
0.22145618498325348,
0.7429227232933044,
0.21635359525680542,
0.0534583143889904,
-0.5940271615982056,
-0.12225957214832306,
-0.1506844460964203,
-0.2868453860282898,
0.2827637493610382,
0.42958348989486694,
0.13636372983455658,
1.040626049041748,
0.20934024453163147,
0.5406807065010071,
0.22581633925437927,
0.13999079167842865,
0.5591598153114319,
-0.3664151132106781,
-0.6575490832328796,
-0.7633506059646606,
0.5452027916908264,
-0.1130886971950531,
-0.48906409740448,
0.9327561259269714,
0.4017748534679413,
0.887555718421936,
-0.15600134432315826,
0.7608574628829956,
-0.1266421675682068,
0.6372379064559937,
-0.515341579914093,
1.1529208421707153,
-0.5105587244033813,
0.1459522545337677,
-0.4675937294960022,
-0.9160449504852295,
0.1391991525888443,
0.36544376611709595,
-0.4965362846851349,
0.48718732595443726,
0.6941123604774475,
0.6199936866760254,
0.04249376803636551,
-0.5384316444396973,
0.49434593319892883,
0.5698589086532593,
0.09127631038427353,
0.5749761462211609,
0.8591894507408142,
-0.1722228080034256,
0.40672051906585693,
0.20339512825012207,
-0.5230644941329956,
-0.12802816927433014,
-0.6224289536476135,
-0.8544221520423889,
-0.9849207401275635,
-0.1237666979432106,
-0.12053292244672775,
-0.16872158646583557,
0.21204684674739838,
0.9875370264053345,
-0.41894766688346863,
0.021503757685422897,
-0.19235508143901825,
0.1724332720041275,
-0.3925635516643524,
-0.2606280744075775,
0.305248498916626,
-0.15959422290325165,
-0.3213481307029724,
0.3280370831489563,
0.0331447571516037,
0.4261401295661926,
-0.6056563854217529,
-0.022759519517421722,
-0.2908143997192383,
0.2602788507938385,
0.3853653073310852,
0.5515745282173157,
-0.5375198125839233,
-0.5188105702400208,
-0.21790966391563416,
0.3609589636325836,
-0.36816829442977905,
0.8177801370620728,
-0.7525385022163391,
0.3983681797981262,
0.29064643383026123,
0.574448823928833,
0.25301483273506165,
-0.27145159244537354,
0.74755859375,
-0.7365645170211792,
0.0724460706114769,
0.3686477243900299,
0.2149118036031723,
0.4594491720199585,
-0.17024506628513336,
0.10692968219518661,
0.20015078783035278,
-0.37245264649391174,
-1.0245211124420166,
0.4912640154361725,
-0.3138221204280853,
-0.04160333052277565,
0.5017269849777222,
-0.2231275588274002,
0.018533501774072647,
0.06993237882852554,
0.06173700839281082,
0.11693229526281357,
0.1532226949930191,
0.746993362903595,
0.7626834511756897,
-0.13426107168197632,
-0.42484357953071594,
-0.5821590423583984,
0.864355742931366,
0.363267719745636,
-0.48376935720443726,
0.19832785427570343,
0.11146967113018036,
0.37271830439567566,
0.44887322187423706,
0.860165536403656,
0.11683189868927002,
0.23167765140533447,
0.39452943205833435,
-0.04022712633013725,
0.16092629730701447,
-0.6304248571395874,
-0.3001945912837982,
0.06511978805065155,
0.5243892073631287,
0.03087444230914116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19708v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19708v3
|
Cost-Efficient Large Language Model Serving for Multi-turn Conversations with CachedAttention
| 2024-03-23T10:42:49 | 2024-06-30T23:50:38 |
Bin Gao, Zhuomin He, Puru Sharma, Qingxuan Kang, Djordje Jevdjic, Junbo Deng, Xingkun Yang, Zhou Yu, Pengfei Zuo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Interacting with humans through multi-turn conversations is a fundamental
feature of large language models (LLMs). However, existing LLM serving engines
executing multi-turn conversations are inefficient due to the need to
repeatedly compute the key-value (KV) caches of historical tokens, incurring
high serving costs. To address the problem, this paper proposes
CachedAttention, a new attention mechanism that enables reuse of KV caches
across multi-turn conversations, significantly reducing the repetitive
computation overheads. CachedAttention maintains a hierarchical KV caching
system that leverages cost-effective memory/storage mediums to save KV caches
for all requests. To reduce KV cache access overheads from slow mediums,
CachedAttention employs layer-wise pre-loading and asynchronous saving schemes
to overlap the KV cache access with the GPU computation. To ensure that the KV
caches to be accessed are placed in the fastest hierarchy, CachedAttention
employs scheduler-aware fetching and eviction schemes to consciously place the
KV caches in different layers based on the hints from the inference job
scheduler. To avoid the invalidation of the saved KV caches incurred by context
window overflow, CachedAttention enables the saved KV caches to remain valid
via decoupling the positional encoding and effectively truncating the KV
caches. Extensive experimental results demonstrate that CachedAttention
significantly decreases the time to the first token (TTFT) by up to 87%,
improves the prompt prefilling throughput by up to 7.8$\times$ for multi-turn
conversations, and reduces the end-to-end inference cost by up to 70%.
|
[
-0.40917763113975525,
-0.521067202091217,
0.4931694269180298,
0.5817168951034546,
-0.33123376965522766,
-0.08812243491411209,
-0.479388028383255,
-0.4358617961406708,
0.3368411362171173,
0.6173789501190186,
-0.672514796257019,
-0.2452908307313919,
-0.13682915270328522,
-0.31209826469421387,
-0.222580686211586,
0.786531388759613,
0.11705686151981354,
-0.17512132227420807,
-0.27674388885498047,
-0.08142877370119095,
-0.5096845626831055,
-0.5725556015968323,
-1.0538792610168457,
-0.19914337992668152,
0.5941224694252014,
0.5229188799858093,
0.5472936034202576,
0.5260438919067383,
0.23863977193832397,
0.2756664752960205,
0.07723194360733032,
0.19609057903289795,
-0.7107475996017456,
0.5756230354309082,
-0.06665907800197601,
-0.3499404489994049,
-0.48635461926460266,
-0.3312540054321289,
0.5126481056213379,
0.22688432037830353,
-0.5617774128913879,
-0.006544506177306175,
-0.1552664339542389,
0.5906145572662354,
-1.0366556644439697,
0.42861929535865784,
-0.8237748146057129,
-0.1563549041748047,
-0.33882710337638855,
-0.3157047927379608,
-0.7849648594856262,
-0.22966288030147552,
0.09857863932847977,
-0.4755510091781616,
0.16854362189769745,
-0.3108632266521454,
0.6412755250930786,
0.5117098093032837,
-0.03190825507044792,
0.07446152716875076,
-0.6855321526527405,
0.6809260845184326,
-0.8580279350280762,
0.4202665090560913,
0.3730447590351105,
0.31653228402137756,
-0.053785935044288635,
-0.6842676997184753,
-0.7333752512931824,
0.04404377192258835,
0.17933261394500732,
0.2950184643268585,
-0.010044815950095654,
-0.028825893998146057,
0.1039784848690033,
0.21245938539505005,
-0.13075849413871765,
0.322873055934906,
0.19150075316429138,
-0.20392395555973053,
0.23336176574230194,
0.4034339487552643,
-0.057794440537691116,
0.14430873095989227,
-0.28297021985054016,
-0.3354348838329315,
-0.8002080917358398,
-0.04401132091879845,
0.0838981419801712,
0.37067461013793945,
0.11880143731832504,
0.15209142863750458,
-0.3640463352203369,
0.3765163719654083,
0.29151150584220886,
0.03503160551190376,
0.15812084078788757,
-0.4325765073299408,
-0.20544040203094482,
0.20114979147911072,
0.5290156602859497,
0.5598400235176086,
0.19714023172855377,
-0.21929329633712769,
0.040045492351055145,
-0.047296322882175446,
0.5697811841964722,
-1.0875898599624634,
-0.19756776094436646,
0.25408104062080383,
-0.09560312330722809,
-0.10010305047035217,
-0.300317645072937,
-0.879662811756134,
-0.338647723197937,
-0.04089140519499779,
-0.0897984504699707,
-0.07913040369749069,
-0.10736893117427826,
0.1773199439048767,
0.44015777111053467,
0.4221409857273102,
0.6367127895355225,
-1.115989089012146,
0.45345908403396606,
0.6300353407859802,
0.8155985474586487,
-0.35167092084884644,
-0.3258349299430847,
-0.8144648671150208,
0.4664125442504883,
-0.1788410246372223,
0.7701298594474792,
-0.35197776556015015,
-0.42012929916381836,
0.015208006836473942,
0.10841614753007889,
-0.0708644837141037,
-0.36833512783050537,
0.4824449419975281,
-0.9224433302879333,
-0.09310611337423325,
-0.47473421692848206,
-0.19236531853675842,
-0.01877564750611782,
0.3981255292892456,
-0.8505303859710693,
1.0163875818252563,
-0.3682812452316284,
-0.7105358839035034,
0.4307019114494324,
-0.48751938343048096,
-0.6817099452018738,
0.10530776530504227,
-0.0036024916917085648,
-0.5222946405410767,
-0.1309094876050949,
0.6129302382469177,
0.544758141040802,
-0.44813281297683716,
0.2142050713300705,
-0.03093988075852394,
-0.12422735244035721,
-0.03912944719195366,
-0.5521551370620728,
0.4116698205471039,
-0.08219155669212341,
-0.49407199025154114,
0.29102078080177307,
-0.3933604657649994,
0.19810545444488525,
0.05969388037919998,
-0.5845850110054016,
-0.09029915928840637,
0.12599967420101166,
0.22727662324905396,
0.292950302362442,
0.2207014560699463,
-0.49473804235458374,
0.3357410728931427,
-0.2896273732185364,
0.41409704089164734,
0.809687614440918,
-0.08962951600551605,
0.3688698410987854,
-0.1598614603281021,
0.2970512807369232,
0.1893647313117981,
0.3065303862094879,
-0.531521737575531,
-0.29387468099594116,
-1.055305004119873,
-0.20134888589382172,
-0.136753648519516,
0.3128095865249634,
-0.5127749443054199,
0.05238726735115051,
-0.5297983288764954,
-0.3165515065193176,
-0.6896874308586121,
-0.1538524478673935,
0.583340585231781,
0.4106157422065735,
0.33069249987602234,
-0.3133181929588318,
-0.1806015521287918,
-0.8018018007278442,
0.003912582062184811,
-0.0013658838579431176,
0.2760452330112457,
0.6868457198143005,
0.09797362238168716,
-0.19149354100227356,
0.9447815418243408,
-0.5645841956138611,
-0.1292954683303833,
0.15606380999088287,
0.22540229558944702,
-0.12197191268205643,
0.316610187292099,
0.320955365896225,
-0.6465222239494324,
-0.5922726988792419,
-0.07169081270694733,
-0.10810377448797226,
-0.026337094604969025,
-0.2555491626262665,
-0.3103885054588318,
0.7325389981269836,
0.49113932251930237,
-0.9236780405044556,
0.4041808843612671,
0.4601587653160095,
0.13132421672344208,
0.6096559166908264,
-0.317425400018692,
0.20299744606018066,
-1.0578166246414185,
0.09571556001901627,
-0.6070719361305237,
-0.24771523475646973,
-0.49897968769073486,
-0.126020610332489,
0.25228381156921387,
0.051541026681661606,
-0.4949789345264435,
0.5842052698135376,
-0.6278336644172668,
-0.19789208471775055,
-0.2644285261631012,
0.15339045226573944,
0.04722350835800171,
0.6616746187210083,
-0.006283320486545563,
1.0589799880981445,
0.23811835050582886,
-0.6971256732940674,
0.3271026611328125,
0.3380509912967682,
-0.17199964821338654,
0.34768909215927124,
-0.5241082310676575,
0.6116068959236145,
0.03745517507195473,
0.5912641286849976,
-1.0511244535446167,
0.07316432148218155,
0.0313972644507885,
-0.1116914227604866,
0.31755802035331726,
-0.2150525003671646,
-0.691218376159668,
-0.3172135055065155,
-0.3846519887447357,
0.3935915231704712,
0.02723194845020771,
-0.8079245090484619,
0.6442446112632751,
0.4549405872821808,
-0.2404828518629074,
-0.7078750729560852,
-0.613998293876648,
0.35659417510032654,
0.01796402782201767,
-0.6203138828277588,
0.43477046489715576,
-0.14234408736228943,
0.17686979472637177,
-0.21141888201236725,
-0.20394496619701385,
0.0028861002065241337,
-0.1927674263715744,
0.23576529324054718,
0.20332564413547516,
-0.10588797181844711,
0.28122878074645996,
0.01143152080476284,
-0.4169822931289673,
0.08542171865701675,
-0.48791980743408203,
1.0629559755325317,
-0.009626824408769608,
-0.640565037727356,
-0.44297289848327637,
0.48863404989242554,
1.189386010169983,
-0.3709957003593445,
0.8688637614250183,
0.5219084620475769,
-0.2767532765865326,
0.018632540479302406,
-1.1455268859863281,
-0.5098198056221008,
-0.46073412895202637,
0.4533134698867798,
-0.3198300898075104,
-0.7407498359680176,
0.7142793536186218,
0.10407427698373795,
0.320395827293396,
0.04671818017959595,
0.9998745322227478,
0.23772020637989044,
0.7851189374923706,
0.31822291016578674,
-0.5304349660873413,
0.5545065999031067,
0.016174744814634323,
0.25616371631622314,
-0.9706131219863892,
-0.18043485283851624,
-0.5034050941467285,
-0.15992432832717896,
-0.3101523518562317,
-0.6463179588317871,
0.09654337167739868,
-0.37876880168914795,
-0.3911086618900299,
0.02585858479142189,
-0.33995336294174194,
0.5073650479316711,
0.43825963139533997,
0.010541869327425957,
0.3132820427417755,
-0.3386359214782715,
-0.02523098699748516,
-0.1591063290834427,
-0.5757465958595276,
-0.20790044963359833,
0.8487916588783264,
-0.024723833426833153,
1.0696853399276733,
0.02168910764157772,
0.38809847831726074,
-0.13284951448440552,
0.2591591477394104,
-0.7191311120986938,
0.47994449734687805,
0.16066409647464752,
-0.5828632712364197,
-0.4182240664958954,
-0.2724895477294922,
-0.7334776520729065,
0.3540244698524475,
0.10767662525177002,
-0.9184514284133911,
0.11442165076732635,
0.2173556238412857,
-0.27975910902023315,
0.4597548544406891,
-0.7264227271080017,
0.7587500810623169,
-0.24378131330013275,
-0.5622703433036804,
-0.4686166048049927,
-0.6590930819511414,
0.09330938011407852,
0.074360191822052,
-0.11447755247354507,
0.15524862706661224,
0.18364454805850983,
0.6057095527648926,
-0.2692428231239319,
1.0402737855911255,
-0.22137045860290527,
-0.14996762573719025,
0.04709150642156601,
0.05463704094290733,
1.0832067728042603,
0.28613731265068054,
0.12926658987998962,
-0.15006238222122192,
-0.24183489382266998,
-0.2689715027809143,
-0.484201043844223,
1.0792629718780518,
-0.6348652243614197,
-0.7012866735458374,
-0.1322067826986313,
-0.6310473680496216,
-0.2975226938724518,
0.3586650788784027,
0.1361277550458908,
0.2862226963043213,
-0.11476245522499084,
0.20936371386051178,
0.8625349998474121,
-0.0981687605381012,
0.5647305250167847,
0.5665568709373474,
-0.14887447655200958,
-0.1127835065126419,
0.5939897894859314,
-0.12717629969120026,
0.5625755786895752,
0.5066255331039429,
0.08076140284538269,
-0.42992958426475525,
-0.2476840764284134,
-0.42705512046813965,
0.13721439242362976,
-0.7264812588691711,
-0.3068678379058838,
-1.1369374990463257,
-0.06630636006593704,
-0.2641732096672058,
-0.2229757308959961,
-0.8378981351852417,
-0.1902986466884613,
-0.31322774291038513,
-0.029385531321167946,
0.5533183217048645,
0.12962481379508972,
0.2897152304649353,
0.40493112802505493,
-0.5025445222854614,
0.14426319301128387,
0.48739272356033325,
0.40192267298698425,
0.6609219908714294,
-0.2617853581905365,
-0.3264997899532318,
-0.07740775495767593,
-0.3280222713947296,
-0.32132717967033386,
0.40628838539123535,
0.0705721452832222,
0.4119293689727783,
0.6800658106803894,
0.09420767426490784,
0.9178435206413269,
-0.6758507490158081,
0.5102395415306091,
0.2148866355419159,
-0.9279943704605103,
0.2157212346792221,
-0.31608933210372925,
0.5868744254112244,
0.754304051399231,
0.009393712505698204,
-0.8910090923309326,
-0.25049012899398804,
-0.35844963788986206,
-1.2837605476379395,
0.837367832660675,
-0.03567421808838844,
0.16229955852031708,
-0.2748674750328064,
0.2919526696205139,
-0.05019001290202141,
0.23595669865608215,
-0.2974300682544708,
-0.15576256811618805,
-0.22258605062961578,
0.26393330097198486,
-0.014403176493942738,
-0.3328888416290283,
0.04543024301528931,
-0.12978482246398926,
0.44237810373306274,
-0.2454710751771927,
0.3128887116909027,
-0.0897819995880127,
-0.05325041338801384,
-0.17638558149337769,
0.4120554029941559,
0.6984240412712097,
0.6384097933769226,
-0.017187656834721565,
0.16292637586593628,
0.42043235898017883,
-0.66751629114151,
-0.03714496269822121,
-0.1649598777294159,
0.08211977779865265,
-0.253266304731369,
-0.16642716526985168,
0.8029642105102539,
0.8063095808029175,
-0.5852599740028381,
0.27939170598983765,
-0.287115216255188,
0.24286197125911713,
-0.10343428701162338,
-0.16309697926044464,
0.707030177116394,
0.18161015212535858,
0.2667878270149231,
-0.30183345079421997,
-0.1635558307170868,
-0.31648731231689453,
0.03805852308869362,
0.4153320789337158,
-0.17114347219467163,
-0.051803816109895706,
0.5992277264595032,
0.2270853966474533,
-0.1484292596578598,
1.052430510520935,
0.10463862121105194,
-0.7308344841003418,
0.36452800035476685,
0.6970624923706055,
0.9121692776679993,
-0.512458324432373,
-0.06551951915025711,
0.2117651104927063,
0.07994293421506882,
-0.1153944805264473,
0.1992514729499817,
-0.17634887993335724,
-0.7901668548583984,
-0.7050701975822449,
-0.35086846351623535,
-0.5951493978500366,
0.11232570558786392,
-0.8852914571762085,
-0.0867600291967392,
-0.34379130601882935,
-0.22987692058086395,
-0.08857255429029465,
-0.076267771422863,
-0.6577895283699036,
-0.09551727771759033,
-0.035594504326581955,
0.827975869178772,
-0.4785694181919098,
0.862413763999939,
0.3240925371646881,
-0.14816288650035858,
-0.4915723204612732,
0.034486837685108185,
-0.08810891956090927,
-0.7230892777442932,
0.6303167343139648,
0.2297670990228653,
-0.5225271582603455,
0.15768437087535858,
-0.29623228311538696,
-0.8341551423072815,
1.1107174158096313,
0.37410590052604675,
-0.7086507678031921,
-0.07938013225793839,
-0.21960397064685822,
0.3007984459400177,
-0.2368428111076355,
0.20811015367507935,
0.46167364716529846,
0.6203662753105164,
0.22197900712490082,
-0.8755420446395874,
0.2898816764354706,
-0.15004678070545197,
0.021250369027256966,
0.48202037811279297,
-0.9069939851760864,
0.8750095963478088,
-0.26297858357429504,
-0.3438071608543396,
-0.16650129854679108,
0.5105121731758118,
0.15721803903579712,
-0.10302291065454483,
0.4258965849876404,
0.6582874655723572,
0.7001466751098633,
-0.08078409731388092,
1.010396122932434,
-0.2908667325973511,
0.27526769042015076,
1.2659226655960083,
-0.5993595123291016,
0.8513943552970886,
0.7074241638183594,
-0.02523326314985752,
0.125751793384552,
0.3308869004249573,
0.48662424087524414,
0.713966429233551,
0.253599613904953,
-0.47879475355148315,
-0.3363557755947113,
-0.005845894105732441,
-0.3110770881175995,
0.16528895497322083,
0.3366084396839142,
0.2526373863220215,
-0.3309166729450226,
-0.012601878494024277,
0.2525705099105835,
-0.38903266191482544,
-0.09198755025863647,
0.9265430569648743,
-0.06236833706498146,
-0.8075119256973267,
0.5508030652999878,
-0.13162869215011597,
0.5412930846214294,
-0.5243744254112244,
0.156545028090477,
-0.17881423234939575,
0.45961993932724,
0.03153642639517784,
-0.427083820104599,
0.13231241703033447,
-0.18069040775299072,
-0.5849109888076782,
-0.29526790976524353,
0.32090702652931213,
-0.4532682001590729,
-0.013501780107617378,
0.4014950394630432,
0.17916513979434967,
-0.1410643458366394,
-0.34361183643341064,
-0.35266008973121643,
0.27228739857673645,
-0.29298457503318787,
-0.35913190245628357,
0.473368376493454,
0.37273740768432617,
-0.3358083665370941,
0.9036102890968323,
0.8246110677719116,
0.008972554467618465,
0.2440854161977768,
0.3996625542640686,
1.2884047031402588,
-0.5306687951087952,
-0.9425093531608582,
-0.7412188649177551,
0.26254189014434814,
0.03947536647319794,
-0.2940487861633301,
0.5305107831954956,
0.5164434909820557,
0.5785030126571655,
0.04316116124391556,
0.4571759104728699,
0.38853561878204346,
0.09125631302595139,
-0.5666258335113525,
0.9429534077644348,
-0.1361665576696396,
0.06435444205999374,
-0.3173571825027466,
-0.7243184447288513,
-0.1326410323381424,
0.5163375735282898,
-0.35107067227363586,
0.0296226367354393,
0.7121285796165466,
0.6733329892158508,
-0.10629419982433319,
0.024050017818808556,
0.18707168102264404,
0.177350252866745,
0.7033140063285828,
0.6628469824790955,
0.6042316555976868,
-0.10731101036071777,
0.4788082242012024,
0.031192706897854805,
-0.09141004830598831,
-0.6227096319198608,
-0.9454491138458252,
-0.7168213725090027,
-0.6445755958557129,
0.03188830986618996,
-0.14425833523273468,
0.1589917093515396,
0.5536050200462341,
1.048632264137268,
-0.8478541374206543,
-0.10241688042879105,
-0.018466195091605186,
-0.20813393592834473,
-0.2682497501373291,
-0.281000554561615,
0.5557181239128113,
-0.5215913653373718,
-0.6134593486785889,
0.30710986256599426,
0.6071475744247437,
-0.22547367215156555,
-0.44146549701690674,
-0.06443707644939423,
-0.34450045228004456,
0.06611043214797974,
0.648345947265625,
0.33825334906578064,
-0.7620245814323425,
-0.2026922106742859,
0.08448126912117004,
-0.2930305004119873,
0.30097371339797974,
1.0278685092926025,
-0.7087774276733398,
0.5812172293663025,
0.1355755478143692,
1.1587837934494019,
1.2770246267318726,
-0.051898930221796036,
0.44032710790634155,
-0.7320085167884827,
0.2895438075065613,
0.3496643602848053,
0.26890963315963745,
0.3575601875782013,
-0.6695814728736877,
-0.05696459114551544,
-0.2478988766670227,
-0.6684259176254272,
-0.5309181809425354,
0.23899805545806885,
-1.1658051013946533,
0.09715970605611801,
0.8422781229019165,
-0.2118157297372818,
-0.24323810636997223,
-0.21774862706661224,
-0.2884884178638458,
0.11925871670246124,
-0.7837697863578796,
1.0253939628601074,
0.8172165751457214,
0.07911127060651779,
-0.3536514937877655,
-0.6229425072669983,
0.4865371882915497,
0.4493778645992279,
-1.05931556224823,
0.7778418064117432,
0.4051957428455353,
-0.010637469589710236,
0.18584325909614563,
0.9301969408988953,
-0.1346663534641266,
0.24956054985523224,
-0.27004480361938477,
0.15163911879062653,
-0.037967417389154434,
-0.5054790377616882,
-0.014409965835511684,
-0.21275532245635986,
-0.18768732249736786,
-0.3163502514362335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15776v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15776v1
|
Modeling Unified Semantic Discourse Structure for High-quality Headline Generation
| 2024-03-23T09:18:53 | 2024-03-23T09:18:53 |
Minghui Xu, Hao Fei, Fei Li, Shengqiong Wu, Rui Sun, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Headline generation aims to summarize a long document with a short, catchy
title that reflects the main idea. This requires accurately capturing the core
document semantics, which is challenging due to the lengthy and background
information-rich na ture of the texts. In this work, We propose using a unified
semantic discourse structure (S3) to represent document semantics, achieved by
combining document-level rhetorical structure theory (RST) trees with
sentence-level abstract meaning representation (AMR) graphs to construct S3
graphs. The hierarchical composition of sentence, clause, and word
intrinsically characterizes the semantic meaning of the overall document. We
then develop a headline generation framework, in which the S3 graphs are
encoded as contextual features. To consolidate the efficacy of S3 graphs, we
further devise a hierarchical structure pruning mechanism to dynamically screen
the redundant and nonessential nodes within the graph. Experimental results on
two headline generation datasets demonstrate that our method outperforms
existing state-of-art methods consistently. Our work can be instructive for a
broad range of document modeling tasks, more than headline or summarization
generation.
|
[
-0.1574099212884903,
-0.7462406158447266,
0.7159072160720825,
0.2322206348180771,
-0.45636919140815735,
0.13152574002742767,
0.13499115407466888,
-0.19903844594955444,
0.2561172544956207,
0.7413193583488464,
-0.4203316271305084,
-0.683211624622345,
-0.5895761847496033,
0.08232627809047699,
-0.5355614423751831,
1.2759125232696533,
0.23987223207950592,
-0.5191426873207092,
-0.1694691777229309,
0.1400352418422699,
-0.3932611048221588,
-0.2088296264410019,
-0.2509947121143341,
-0.3221396803855896,
0.7156977653503418,
0.48992371559143066,
0.8118178844451904,
0.9707249999046326,
0.3074060380458832,
0.256613165140152,
-0.4104575216770172,
0.02324347011744976,
-0.36854520440101624,
0.2307310700416565,
-0.3161344528198242,
0.07550723105669022,
-0.5243076086044312,
-0.12316469848155975,
0.9820994138717651,
0.9905211329460144,
-0.0018286569975316525,
-0.03760649263858795,
0.327707976102829,
0.4181336462497711,
-0.30084899067878723,
0.21820421516895294,
-0.8106013536453247,
-0.12398253381252289,
-0.41231608390808105,
-0.6062057018280029,
-0.41944611072540283,
-0.14251019060611725,
-0.005728361662477255,
-0.612975537776947,
0.09128229320049286,
0.12186684459447861,
1.3756781816482544,
-0.10071880370378494,
-0.9394233226776123,
-0.21048080921173096,
-0.6024357676506042,
0.477855920791626,
-0.5117788314819336,
-0.06652761995792389,
-0.052509065717458725,
0.09024974703788757,
-0.1878434419631958,
-0.7966794967651367,
-0.10962279140949249,
-0.30012956261634827,
-0.28836458921432495,
0.41605186462402344,
-0.37196990847587585,
0.16495543718338013,
-0.06857891380786896,
0.42104753851890564,
-0.5121994614601135,
0.028712686151266098,
-0.3363201320171356,
-0.23853741586208344,
0.32066652178764343,
0.18478083610534668,
0.14213605225086212,
-0.8491963148117065,
-0.6439169049263,
0.2171492874622345,
-0.7161480784416199,
-0.21067574620246887,
0.44825130701065063,
0.5866854786872864,
0.18912960588932037,
0.6448920369148254,
-0.31236255168914795,
0.7456271052360535,
-0.02181222289800644,
-0.27698713541030884,
-0.07353634387254715,
-0.5594081282615662,
-0.10932853817939758,
0.10439252853393555,
0.7725129127502441,
0.5413122773170471,
-0.17160549759864807,
-0.17523568868637085,
-0.05794766545295715,
0.14800293743610382,
0.5261842608451843,
-0.7382402420043945,
0.16104769706726074,
0.12173613160848618,
-0.302508145570755,
-0.5322404503822327,
-0.0329994335770607,
-0.6053368449211121,
-0.14306923747062683,
-0.42291247844696045,
-0.003187506692484021,
-0.6824852228164673,
-0.22054027020931244,
-0.007706001400947571,
-0.1937965303659439,
0.3474866449832916,
0.32243114709854126,
-0.5898637175559998,
0.25121814012527466,
0.6952518820762634,
0.6639354825019836,
-0.08111907541751862,
-0.2516273558139801,
-0.3080860376358032,
0.7397476434707642,
-0.2742948830127716,
1.0613183975219727,
-0.30357393622398376,
-0.3629312813282013,
0.0031873665284365416,
-0.24632441997528076,
-0.06308157742023468,
-0.08189510554075241,
0.8728940486907959,
-0.4529115557670593,
0.19502903521060944,
0.10901455581188202,
-0.6235963702201843,
0.04536418989300728,
0.4025880694389343,
-0.5742072463035583,
0.8390752673149109,
0.3326885402202606,
-1.212911605834961,
0.2391611486673355,
-0.5624945759773254,
-0.7218016982078552,
0.10676448047161102,
-0.22393245995044708,
-0.4538975954055786,
0.054388321936130524,
0.1868729293346405,
0.3212154507637024,
-0.43341609835624695,
0.6539148688316345,
0.21632450819015503,
-0.07082885503768921,
-0.03979073092341423,
-0.1854020208120346,
0.6716628670692444,
0.3096664547920227,
0.032325971871614456,
0.26252833008766174,
-0.8275346159934998,
-0.12720024585723877,
0.008139791898429394,
-0.2942894995212555,
-0.2649102210998535,
-0.040171120315790176,
0.03257085382938385,
0.004601571708917618,
0.12316678464412689,
-0.6365313529968262,
-0.06050845980644226,
-0.5079262256622314,
0.403092622756958,
0.41321074962615967,
0.4656965732574463,
0.49162557721138,
-0.30096372961997986,
0.2871200442314148,
0.1742137223482132,
-0.22991083562374115,
-0.7115986943244934,
-0.3344072103500366,
-0.4630967080593109,
-0.09740905463695526,
0.45412859320640564,
0.3638581335544586,
-0.4468538165092468,
0.6837155818939209,
-0.5887580513954163,
-0.2872159481048584,
-0.046317797154188156,
-0.31299182772636414,
0.4841051399707794,
0.852053165435791,
0.11383362859487534,
-0.05502411723136902,
-0.6636142730712891,
-1.026958703994751,
-0.43946999311447144,
-0.2231070101261139,
-0.1879410296678543,
-0.03548809885978699,
0.4108012318611145,
0.19632908701896667,
1.358086109161377,
-0.6432071924209595,
-0.4375462234020233,
-0.5374071598052979,
0.614043116569519,
0.004428474698215723,
0.3897930681705475,
0.2094915360212326,
-0.8235774040222168,
-0.14266470074653625,
-0.06372489035129547,
-0.7065976858139038,
-0.14266909658908844,
-0.2819257378578186,
-0.25751519203186035,
0.07635486125946045,
0.497178852558136,
-0.7830930352210999,
0.4796305298805237,
0.12163489311933517,
-0.5280906558036804,
0.657782256603241,
-0.14338311553001404,
0.07458590716123581,
-1.4301505088806152,
0.0708051472902298,
0.026920152828097343,
-0.12669207155704498,
-0.47861525416374207,
0.2078261524438858,
-0.018077697604894638,
-0.4595187306404114,
-0.4880663752555847,
0.2399558424949646,
-0.4817330241203308,
-0.25351837277412415,
-0.36076125502586365,
0.4048795700073242,
0.5448941588401794,
0.43651965260505676,
0.02325325272977352,
0.33652108907699585,
0.2447207123041153,
-0.5192626118659973,
-0.06627915799617767,
0.19296929240226746,
-0.31118613481521606,
0.8621942400932312,
-0.6579791307449341,
-0.3959943354129791,
-0.36955490708351135,
0.6698217391967773,
-1.1243057250976562,
-0.455242395401001,
-0.04167491942644119,
-0.5401995182037354,
0.08503448218107224,
-0.0991782695055008,
-0.6803318858146667,
-0.35737404227256775,
-0.1517982929944992,
-0.03490741178393364,
0.07406146079301834,
-0.12528620660305023,
0.6471375226974487,
0.5649288892745972,
-0.2718735337257385,
-0.14999175071716309,
-0.4833613932132721,
0.4945243299007416,
-0.2909723222255707,
-0.9502671957015991,
0.9029911756515503,
0.5280107259750366,
-0.019392354413866997,
0.26923927664756775,
-0.119874507188797,
0.0013758479617536068,
0.10290323197841644,
0.1678781360387802,
0.24262098968029022,
-0.2916514575481415,
0.028399283066391945,
0.26008352637290955,
-0.43736234307289124,
-0.04322930797934532,
-0.37853822112083435,
0.24782145023345947,
-0.15906837582588196,
-0.07410445809364319,
-0.4577333331108093,
0.7306215763092041,
0.6338360905647278,
-0.31175675988197327,
0.4342699646949768,
0.2792920172214508,
-0.2601512670516968,
-0.09183166921138763,
-0.09018338471651077,
0.06279199570417404,
-0.3281964957714081,
0.25689706206321716,
-0.5535869598388672,
-0.9016821980476379,
0.31765395402908325,
-0.2975328266620636,
0.3192322850227356,
0.7059696912765503,
0.2685597836971283,
-0.1397649347782135,
1.011589765548706,
0.5081731081008911,
0.26939287781715393,
0.186761274933815,
-0.13064077496528625,
0.15259970724582672,
-0.8989911675453186,
-0.08739800751209259,
-0.6491122245788574,
0.07800307124853134,
-0.2134203314781189,
-0.30176421999931335,
0.25523942708969116,
0.11777336150407791,
-0.2045244574546814,
0.5275222659111023,
-0.6590829491615295,
0.3697584867477417,
0.4097635746002197,
-0.27924221754074097,
0.6117924451828003,
0.16285209357738495,
-0.2442629337310791,
-0.10710880160331726,
-0.5361981987953186,
-0.7641350030899048,
0.4959900975227356,
0.2540200352668762,
0.5821895003318787,
-0.12037752568721771,
0.6505506634712219,
0.0909230038523674,
0.25959330797195435,
-0.5768489241600037,
0.739885687828064,
-0.07886004447937012,
-0.33482497930526733,
-0.2735578417778015,
-0.5317695736885071,
-1.3364009857177734,
0.7315669059753418,
0.028869928792119026,
-0.7866078615188599,
-0.19985947012901306,
-0.06342464685440063,
-0.44797661900520325,
0.20097555220127106,
-0.3351215422153473,
0.8457189202308655,
0.13746975362300873,
-0.054421138018369675,
0.014176573604345322,
-0.6512443423271179,
0.5339450836181641,
0.1853819340467453,
0.3477962911128998,
-0.2634752690792084,
0.03118961676955223,
0.6917364001274109,
-0.5509438514709473,
0.9005489349365234,
0.13624748587608337,
-0.25806787610054016,
0.5966159701347351,
0.053542621433734894,
0.3616953492164612,
-0.04506268724799156,
0.014137793332338333,
-0.14120438694953918,
-0.15573032200336456,
-0.27656906843185425,
-0.3924243152141571,
0.4418778419494629,
-0.4895976483821869,
-0.5391745567321777,
-0.4221135377883911,
-0.6507248282432556,
-0.19075815379619598,
0.46203216910362244,
0.2981434762477875,
0.6101475954055786,
-0.49929508566856384,
0.35916343331336975,
0.19236303865909576,
0.18129800260066986,
0.15047144889831543,
0.41975945234298706,
-0.1579681634902954,
-0.37986132502555847,
0.8331878185272217,
0.24126942455768585,
0.017253121361136436,
0.42911261320114136,
0.38047608733177185,
-0.31646665930747986,
-0.5361124277114868,
-0.3445224165916443,
0.08484391868114471,
-0.5242642760276794,
-0.4693034589290619,
-0.8950459957122803,
-0.5331944227218628,
-0.46968701481819153,
-0.31446877121925354,
-0.19669725000858307,
-0.5796360969543457,
-0.07304755598306656,
-0.2658891975879669,
0.10924822837114334,
0.636014461517334,
0.08869317173957825,
0.6691141724586487,
-0.7278337478637695,
0.4536616802215576,
0.061035800725221634,
0.07106946408748627,
-0.08947715163230896,
-0.4121754765510559,
-0.13126367330551147,
-0.10917019844055176,
-0.7445548176765442,
-0.8512307405471802,
0.29331520199775696,
-0.021302418783307076,
0.37371301651000977,
0.24872319400310516,
0.15309152007102966,
0.47915104031562805,
-0.5702858567237854,
0.7057585120201111,
0.3453056216239929,
-0.8166355490684509,
0.9422112107276917,
-1.0265225172042847,
0.4746544361114502,
0.5507873892784119,
0.10051455348730087,
-0.3300689458847046,
-0.9910972118377686,
-0.9221391081809998,
-1.211074948310852,
0.6044890284538269,
0.5326835513114929,
-0.04912698268890381,
-0.19913841784000397,
0.1358121931552887,
-0.09310297667980194,
0.14396236836910248,
-0.689570426940918,
0.1616312712430954,
-0.19966141879558563,
-0.20346282422542572,
0.4229603409767151,
-0.21065397560596466,
-0.3258732259273529,
0.025035986676812172,
0.40889519453048706,
-0.1710735261440277,
-0.0588516928255558,
0.03603124991059303,
0.020420804619789124,
0.09252539277076721,
0.5886969566345215,
0.21667146682739258,
0.5705256462097168,
-0.2673380672931671,
0.3068639039993286,
-0.3252168297767639,
-0.1855175793170929,
0.10788687318563461,
0.032035257667303085,
-0.6439405083656311,
0.1937943696975708,
0.3005698323249817,
0.8145952820777893,
0.9740405082702637,
-0.24734394252300262,
0.6218346953392029,
0.1210164949297905,
-0.4810352921485901,
-0.05386555567383766,
-0.27739647030830383,
0.35695210099220276,
-0.22326445579528809,
0.45155858993530273,
-0.027325060218572617,
0.196325421333313,
-0.6526063680648804,
0.6065592169761658,
0.1641532927751541,
-0.27139753103256226,
-0.08940736204385757,
0.6658176183700562,
0.38850903511047363,
-0.06262581795454025,
0.3009869456291199,
-0.19550946354866028,
-0.32080551981925964,
0.6022791862487793,
0.8112372159957886,
0.6686224341392517,
0.11882909387350082,
0.6916295886039734,
0.3027784824371338,
0.15687398612499237,
0.06064824014902115,
-0.21156436204910278,
-0.11447717994451523,
-0.5116414427757263,
-0.5553144812583923,
-0.8448729515075684,
-0.48320508003234863,
-0.03602639585733414,
-0.6341251134872437,
0.047711025923490524,
-0.10718003660440445,
-0.13423144817352295,
0.2776690721511841,
0.019062263891100883,
0.001225536223500967,
0.2312537133693695,
0.13575483858585358,
0.7836723923683167,
-0.6526055932044983,
0.6226465702056885,
0.5199853777885437,
-0.4666990339756012,
-0.7301316857337952,
0.20954298973083496,
0.05673209950327873,
-0.303371399641037,
0.5238884687423706,
0.36756348609924316,
-0.27258220314979553,
0.16220501065254211,
-0.20477387309074402,
-1.0478850603103638,
1.1797524690628052,
0.36755871772766113,
-0.07458671182394028,
-0.47166985273361206,
0.24671189486980438,
0.35038843750953674,
-0.7598697543144226,
-0.06131772696971893,
0.489408016204834,
0.5084366202354431,
0.7425075769424438,
-0.401180237531662,
0.09545673429965973,
-0.03776611387729645,
0.42642784118652344,
0.12214603275060654,
-0.3712732493877411,
0.8343353271484375,
-0.04649997875094414,
-0.6750449538230896,
0.07914572954177856,
1.1152987480163574,
0.4390667676925659,
0.1655053198337555,
0.5339200496673584,
0.6067901253700256,
0.7278043031692505,
-0.11405715346336365,
1.0224424600601196,
-0.5441641807556152,
0.12365399301052094,
1.2604395151138306,
-0.27136051654815674,
0.5860921740531921,
0.22969436645507812,
0.19103752076625824,
0.6050741672515869,
0.5000722408294678,
0.2584076225757599,
0.33883431553840637,
0.319699227809906,
0.007867688313126564,
-0.11154215782880783,
-0.3373541235923767,
-0.22950635850429535,
0.6072818636894226,
0.4869808852672577,
-0.11600910127162933,
-1.0523570775985718,
-0.06705940514802933,
0.2854662835597992,
0.29760026931762695,
-0.3983115255832672,
0.7885703444480896,
0.0732254832983017,
-0.9302442669868469,
0.24738852679729462,
0.19466061890125275,
0.26401540637016296,
-0.5891284942626953,
0.17309562861919403,
-0.022783348336815834,
-0.030866103246808052,
-0.11791344732046127,
-1.0569908618927002,
0.7111614942550659,
-0.05924072116613388,
-0.05568481609225273,
-0.6326591372489929,
0.976836085319519,
-0.3855222463607788,
-0.5736725330352783,
0.29112479090690613,
0.5571168065071106,
-0.007028616964817047,
-0.11680799722671509,
-0.4581879675388336,
0.13892203569412231,
-0.2366495132446289,
-0.3792303800582886,
0.41935914754867554,
0.7851013541221619,
-0.04798682779073715,
0.09496668726205826,
0.580765426158905,
0.037613946944475174,
-0.31940561532974243,
0.2215305119752884,
0.9861288070678711,
-0.7761886715888977,
-1.035132884979248,
-0.6032074093818665,
0.6846127510070801,
-0.5262597799301147,
-0.43145254254341125,
0.7876432538032532,
0.6718920469284058,
0.3100855350494385,
0.36790019273757935,
0.6676070690155029,
-0.06480962783098221,
0.6731863021850586,
-0.41153684258461,
0.6807481050491333,
-0.4294930696487427,
0.09745986759662628,
-0.2906542122364044,
-0.8386861085891724,
-0.512043297290802,
0.3277559280395508,
-0.0617576539516449,
-0.40773943066596985,
0.7991830706596375,
0.5963522791862488,
-0.02258104644715786,
0.2722904086112976,
0.2742699384689331,
0.2927917540073395,
0.19031555950641632,
0.22679845988750458,
0.780377984046936,
-0.21389338374137878,
0.9285624623298645,
0.11553309112787247,
-0.30884304642677307,
-0.220878466963768,
-1.0220720767974854,
-0.544716477394104,
-0.7309837937355042,
-0.36501485109329224,
-0.4411918520927429,
0.05973300710320473,
0.09548789262771606,
0.5779781341552734,
-0.268591970205307,
-0.27762657403945923,
-0.39048418402671814,
0.2823928892612457,
0.018448513001203537,
-0.3263169527053833,
0.4485682249069214,
-0.6252813935279846,
-0.3667346239089966,
0.43949273228645325,
0.6012915372848511,
-0.12092842906713486,
-0.13107816874980927,
0.2647590935230255,
-0.25174379348754883,
0.3532411754131317,
0.7595396637916565,
0.21582268178462982,
-0.5677569508552551,
-0.36642155051231384,
-0.36095768213272095,
-0.46243560314178467,
0.17331892251968384,
1.0917017459869385,
-0.6834197044372559,
-0.1446298509836197,
0.33807286620140076,
0.40377163887023926,
0.5267961621284485,
0.39417028427124023,
0.5948878526687622,
-0.9478980302810669,
-0.044095419347286224,
0.25559404492378235,
0.3426252603530884,
0.37821894884109497,
-0.20418570935726166,
0.5336058735847473,
0.1470802277326584,
-0.29022979736328125,
-0.819582998752594,
0.376309871673584,
-1.0974528789520264,
-0.46917128562927246,
1.04175865650177,
-0.029222635552287102,
-0.6357636451721191,
-0.3161788284778595,
-0.32630613446235657,
0.27808475494384766,
-0.4452716112136841,
0.44102129340171814,
0.46171537041664124,
-0.14393281936645508,
-0.02306428551673889,
-0.24141722917556763,
0.38291236758232117,
0.07768184691667557,
-0.8788689374923706,
0.4191606342792511,
0.6043090224266052,
0.019672783091664314,
0.5083476901054382,
1.0944560766220093,
-0.46567830443382263,
0.09349799156188965,
0.3130321800708771,
-0.2963978350162506,
-0.05802732706069946,
-0.5384134650230408,
0.10343613475561142,
0.724017322063446,
-0.36882007122039795,
0.03428852558135986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15757v1
|
User-Side Realization
| 2024-03-23T08:03:50 | 2024-03-23T08:03:50 |
Ryoma Sato
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Users are dissatisfied with services. Since the service is not tailor-made
for a user, it is natural for dissatisfaction to arise. The problem is, that
even if users are dissatisfied, they often do not have the means to resolve
their dissatisfaction. The user cannot alter the source code of the service,
nor can they force the service provider to change. The user has no choice but
to remain dissatisfied or quit the service. User-side realization offers
proactive solutions to this problem by providing general algorithms to deal
with common problems on the user's side. These algorithms run on the user's
side and solve the problems without having the service provider change the
service itself.
|
[
-0.9531136155128479,
-0.4666365087032318,
0.7497981190681458,
0.3820234537124634,
-0.16626402735710144,
0.060377221554517746,
0.14367640018463135,
-0.4384637475013733,
0.6730043292045593,
1.0413225889205933,
-1.218961477279663,
0.13658089935779572,
-0.06705737113952637,
0.23329100012779236,
-0.44725269079208374,
1.218642234802246,
-0.14485043287277222,
0.1646990031003952,
-0.6057325601577759,
0.17703191936016083,
-0.7255228161811829,
-0.6339308023452759,
-0.9671943783760071,
-0.30849066376686096,
0.16443072259426117,
0.6903386116027832,
0.6344484090805054,
-0.006001039408147335,
0.388295978307724,
0.41557031869888306,
0.37979698181152344,
-0.350781112909317,
-0.4637950658798218,
0.28839507699012756,
-0.32195204496383667,
-0.48350849747657776,
0.24565379321575165,
0.21111084520816803,
0.29718735814094543,
0.5057308673858643,
-0.24288542568683624,
0.06503506004810333,
0.037923265248537064,
1.06772780418396,
-0.5273113250732422,
-0.4246966540813446,
0.00024154169659595937,
0.4453234374523163,
-0.18428634107112885,
-0.2572234272956848,
-0.19932231307029724,
-0.3843575417995453,
0.14452332258224487,
-0.5465871095657349,
0.4528687000274658,
0.13708889484405518,
0.6283729076385498,
0.33472535014152527,
-0.5533922910690308,
-0.3953578770160675,
-1.095157265663147,
0.9645175933837891,
-0.5006628632545471,
0.5054643750190735,
0.641895592212677,
0.7525501847267151,
-0.6623097658157349,
-0.6488270163536072,
-0.49039021134376526,
-0.06893198937177658,
-0.12583491206169128,
0.17476706206798553,
-0.2697327733039856,
0.0205847155302763,
0.6028076410293579,
0.5056442618370056,
-0.06955049186944962,
0.05109249800443649,
-0.3515007197856903,
-0.3253914415836334,
0.8300348520278931,
0.44257059693336487,
0.7388827204704285,
-0.3999933898448944,
-0.47537627816200256,
0.6706966757774353,
-0.7839545011520386,
0.45119068026542664,
0.9945816993713379,
-0.13949242234230042,
0.17184408009052277,
0.4262693524360657,
-0.31760287284851074,
0.8856498003005981,
0.40603798627853394,
0.2033301442861557,
0.08058874309062958,
-0.05858026444911957,
-0.4007849097251892,
-0.1993502527475357,
0.425418883562088,
0.4570361077785492,
-0.061085429042577744,
-0.1161220595240593,
-0.794634997844696,
-0.15640303492546082,
0.44851699471473694,
-0.40415632724761963,
-0.052359748631715775,
0.6889854073524475,
-0.6928191781044006,
0.017970241606235504,
-0.030136074870824814,
-0.603938639163971,
-0.5602320432662964,
-0.7591186165809631,
0.4952618181705475,
-0.26385101675987244,
-0.323116272687912,
-0.17382988333702087,
-0.2605946660041809,
-0.11312136054039001,
0.3474145829677582,
-0.8482958078384399,
0.7803322672843933,
0.5472806096076965,
0.6664466857910156,
0.16278482973575592,
-0.06051727756857872,
-0.5155837535858154,
-0.08180782198905945,
-0.0723634660243988,
0.8701662421226501,
-0.1722659319639206,
-0.6973749399185181,
0.0026190264616161585,
-0.1850796788930893,
0.10653319209814072,
-0.7514129281044006,
0.24851146340370178,
-0.6785252690315247,
0.613677978515625,
-0.8666044473648071,
-0.637736976146698,
0.02026486210525036,
-0.09948659688234329,
-0.5245025753974915,
0.5312649607658386,
-0.05910370126366615,
-0.9300493597984314,
0.13646194338798523,
-0.5408419370651245,
-0.49299371242523193,
0.1643814593553543,
-0.48708435893058777,
-0.17290057241916656,
0.8119460344314575,
-0.21569032967090607,
0.1652037352323532,
-0.16096708178520203,
-0.39955204725265503,
-0.01977241411805153,
-0.5053573846817017,
0.3697377145290375,
0.26260295510292053,
1.080186128616333,
0.6766575574874878,
0.2014034241437912,
0.20180878043174744,
-0.5429408550262451,
-0.13355928659439087,
0.07442554831504822,
-0.028849445283412933,
-0.4494403600692749,
0.5185484290122986,
0.10657848417758942,
0.42990919947624207,
0.6197525858879089,
-0.7594594955444336,
0.4030478000640869,
-0.47990694642066956,
0.7693248391151428,
1.1969221830368042,
0.3241020143032074,
0.4226842224597931,
-0.5182478427886963,
0.5965901017189026,
0.290705144405365,
0.6226056814193726,
0.26632440090179443,
-0.6232266426086426,
-0.643397331237793,
-0.2219969630241394,
-0.11371816694736481,
0.1822386384010315,
-0.9702085852622986,
-0.027445409446954727,
0.2836642861366272,
-0.2338154911994934,
-0.3530809283256531,
0.18030737340450287,
0.3410113453865051,
0.6725484132766724,
0.22705790400505066,
-0.45173487067222595,
-1.0547913312911987,
-1.1691272258758545,
-0.311775267124176,
-0.08938662707805634,
-0.07930046319961548,
0.26359009742736816,
0.17057527601718903,
-0.5234479904174805,
1.2700881958007812,
-0.36945271492004395,
-0.5689224600791931,
-0.14565663039684296,
0.19973546266555786,
0.45255208015441895,
0.5042343735694885,
0.21136969327926636,
-1.2698915004730225,
-0.5235152244567871,
-0.24957869946956635,
-0.7237092852592468,
-0.3280543088912964,
-0.24431265890598297,
0.43388301134109497,
0.4126613438129425,
0.24336275458335876,
-0.2927818298339844,
0.5688683390617371,
0.48129022121429443,
-0.307529091835022,
0.8123494386672974,
-0.5307725667953491,
0.31166061758995056,
-0.9852732419967651,
-0.24587439000606537,
-0.24996858835220337,
-0.1383393555879593,
-0.755424439907074,
0.08233358711004257,
-0.42137444019317627,
-0.3161342144012451,
-0.40746545791625977,
0.16551464796066284,
-0.6169446706771851,
-0.7913471460342407,
-0.569449782371521,
-0.30644530057907104,
-0.2783108353614807,
0.2105739712715149,
-0.11914805322885513,
0.9451408386230469,
0.48949378728866577,
-0.8909552693367004,
0.663464367389679,
0.07903020828962326,
-0.2446097582578659,
0.7873504161834717,
-0.6136500835418701,
0.24153342843055725,
-0.3712069094181061,
0.09303177148103714,
-1.0272583961486816,
-0.39302635192871094,
0.49164077639579773,
-0.21140024065971375,
-0.17761045694351196,
-0.18258830904960632,
-0.2740597128868103,
-0.5463640093803406,
-0.12499864399433136,
0.24483565986156464,
0.6315585970878601,
-0.3637951612472534,
0.8462309837341309,
0.2614322304725647,
0.19932310283184052,
-0.3442608714103699,
-0.8566989302635193,
0.1402519941329956,
0.0738014280796051,
-0.5366353988647461,
0.18568964302539825,
-0.10349255800247192,
-0.14996524155139923,
0.13467417657375336,
-0.14417865872383118,
0.05855771154165268,
-0.08411330729722977,
0.6739615201950073,
-0.2683127522468567,
0.3857051134109497,
0.11459415405988693,
-0.08608025312423706,
-0.5812119245529175,
-0.03992603346705437,
0.06341072916984558,
0.5350735783576965,
0.09283171594142914,
-0.7742877006530762,
-0.7288612127304077,
0.870933473110199,
0.24569161236286163,
-0.08312328159809113,
0.2796424925327301,
0.21381931006908417,
-0.41208866238594055,
0.13681496679782867,
-0.8929731249809265,
-0.11076101660728455,
-0.5846872329711914,
-0.09022151678800583,
-0.5844283103942871,
-0.5514898896217346,
1.0661667585372925,
0.01888269931077957,
-0.08112774789333344,
0.2961168587207794,
0.41399553418159485,
-0.575354278087616,
1.3840842247009277,
0.6366970539093018,
0.27892816066741943,
0.755989134311676,
-0.04600360989570618,
0.15182992815971375,
-0.784665048122406,
-0.3155510127544403,
-0.550079882144928,
-0.5389862060546875,
-1.0129369497299194,
0.43029776215553284,
0.3892521858215332,
0.16308917105197906,
-0.34796950221061707,
0.6812045574188232,
-0.5035554766654968,
0.08274103701114655,
0.7145096063613892,
0.3327920436859131,
0.35090208053588867,
0.02179841883480549,
-0.02388780750334263,
-0.40103158354759216,
-0.2686670124530792,
-0.03602404519915581,
0.5272642374038696,
0.02629547379910946,
0.7588882446289062,
0.48518458008766174,
1.5310925245285034,
0.6421346664428711,
0.15490402281284332,
-0.6439195871353149,
0.7829607725143433,
0.02123141475021839,
-0.6245278120040894,
-0.16547951102256775,
-0.8548312187194824,
-0.9631902575492859,
-0.40088772773742676,
-0.030444135889410973,
-1.0611273050308228,
0.49566927552223206,
0.35726413130760193,
-0.2001132071018219,
-0.1329505890607834,
-1.1295278072357178,
0.6369282007217407,
-0.1733427196741104,
-0.22849631309509277,
-0.4819932281970978,
-0.32802534103393555,
0.08029787987470627,
0.14646653831005096,
0.30280065536499023,
0.14382889866828918,
0.03347884491086006,
1.0037249326705933,
-0.821718692779541,
0.7417933940887451,
-0.7754784226417542,
0.09492658078670502,
0.5256063938140869,
0.051435403525829315,
0.645686686038971,
-0.04265829920768738,
0.31239980459213257,
-0.2822730839252472,
0.2711810767650604,
-0.6445966958999634,
-0.8618745803833008,
0.8883242607116699,
-1.0560977458953857,
-1.1208596229553223,
-0.6276993751525879,
-0.016669616103172302,
-0.2557065188884735,
0.39770710468292236,
0.6370383501052856,
0.08540211617946625,
-0.09837586432695389,
-0.6261253356933594,
0.3818114697933197,
-0.26220157742500305,
0.5849698185920715,
0.5342828035354614,
-1.0706286430358887,
-0.2799752950668335,
0.8148747682571411,
0.5221858620643616,
0.1279243528842926,
-0.06373627483844757,
-0.04080146923661232,
-0.18457722663879395,
-0.32443124055862427,
-0.2614290416240692,
0.028600838035345078,
-0.4746406078338623,
-0.006360989063978195,
-0.3761991262435913,
-0.2457396537065506,
-0.1416473686695099,
-0.08381940424442291,
-0.5132757425308228,
-0.1981932520866394,
-0.28719785809516907,
0.18763503432273865,
-0.11091044545173645,
0.9692671895027161,
-0.40835362672805786,
0.5147569179534912,
-0.5270951986312866,
0.5206654071807861,
0.5868533253669739,
0.3730872869491577,
-0.1973683089017868,
-0.283706933259964,
-0.4804125428199768,
0.12372343242168427,
-0.3375103771686554,
-1.0549862384796143,
0.23032744228839874,
-0.4546123445034027,
0.5619853138923645,
0.643444836139679,
-0.010797540657222271,
0.6816908121109009,
-0.331546425819397,
0.6219837069511414,
0.7053898572921753,
-1.3109935522079468,
0.5657988786697388,
-0.024640899151563644,
0.0669943168759346,
0.47712573409080505,
0.35630765557289124,
-0.9228816628456116,
0.11061825603246689,
-0.49587482213974,
-0.4530673027038574,
0.4181925058364868,
-0.0633489117026329,
0.23201188445091248,
0.21511627733707428,
0.3521479368209839,
-0.0818105936050415,
0.39605122804641724,
-0.3186841309070587,
-0.09027035534381866,
-0.6156787276268005,
0.3829227089881897,
0.030476786196231842,
-0.31488221883773804,
-0.06817632168531418,
0.061116401106119156,
0.4976527988910675,
0.3264620006084442,
0.8088991641998291,
0.25546157360076904,
0.3600912392139435,
-0.7086888551712036,
0.318763792514801,
0.600249171257019,
0.839594304561615,
-0.2967529594898224,
0.02262861840426922,
-0.3458605408668518,
-0.09017091989517212,
0.3679666519165039,
-0.10246431082487106,
-0.4415324330329895,
-0.29518067836761475,
0.04941905662417412,
0.44964730739593506,
-0.02779967337846756,
-0.40153706073760986,
0.614613950252533,
-0.08289466053247452,
-0.019502848386764526,
-0.5788859128952026,
0.1944093406200409,
-0.19264595210552216,
0.11031088978052139,
0.6258354783058167,
0.7243085503578186,
0.7794356942176819,
-0.6894916296005249,
0.006270942743867636,
0.4879772663116455,
-0.5166832208633423,
-0.5726591348648071,
0.36344248056411743,
0.06143850460648537,
-1.0303735733032227,
0.7854957580566406,
-0.05735686793923378,
-0.3763006329536438,
0.3818885385990143,
0.6919819712638855,
1.0697544813156128,
-0.5157687067985535,
0.5570653676986694,
-0.09830395132303238,
-0.097382090985775,
-0.073170967400074,
0.7076287269592285,
0.009868929162621498,
-0.7951929569244385,
-0.6235997080802917,
-0.309967577457428,
-0.4404042959213257,
-0.0669434443116188,
-1.1581264734268188,
0.21093614399433136,
-0.8797831535339355,
-0.6210540533065796,
-0.27137866616249084,
0.08165915310382843,
-0.7872124314308167,
0.314365416765213,
-0.3795696198940277,
1.0683656930923462,
-0.9597897529602051,
0.36688336730003357,
0.808381974697113,
-0.691565752029419,
-0.2785208523273468,
0.0294038075953722,
-0.18498928844928741,
-0.7007654309272766,
0.5451222658157349,
0.1372184306383133,
0.10993397235870361,
-0.009073386900126934,
-0.6784245371818542,
-0.49273496866226196,
0.6172037124633789,
0.27000555396080017,
-0.5975180268287659,
0.14054469764232635,
0.020288623869419098,
0.7730687856674194,
-0.23720745742321014,
0.013925965875387192,
-0.004944018553942442,
0.47883540391921997,
0.037398483604192734,
-0.6524314880371094,
0.04822355881333351,
0.16555722057819366,
0.4364900290966034,
0.4101063907146454,
-0.7663739323616028,
0.6648020148277283,
-0.2879769802093506,
-0.4236185550689697,
-0.13927607238292694,
0.6936244368553162,
-0.2694457769393921,
0.5812095999717712,
0.668414294719696,
0.6999781727790833,
0.29318252205848694,
0.11779390275478363,
0.85639888048172,
0.17567533254623413,
0.3679755628108978,
0.792330801486969,
-0.14762777090072632,
0.5933910012245178,
1.3065640926361084,
-0.33807066082954407,
0.5592063665390015,
0.616341769695282,
0.347514271736145,
0.9754054546356201,
0.14071357250213623,
-0.3921929597854614,
-0.5306399464607239,
-0.1599244922399521,
-0.5466204881668091,
0.5714115500450134,
0.11318494379520416,
-0.20084623992443085,
-0.19327448308467865,
0.42600491642951965,
-0.34252676367759705,
0.19331185519695282,
-0.44804808497428894,
1.0386123657226562,
0.0164194256067276,
-0.8405365347862244,
0.2441515028476715,
0.246328666806221,
0.16794244945049286,
-0.4726932644844055,
0.12374752014875412,
-0.3494565486907959,
0.037731654942035675,
-0.89923095703125,
-0.5023311376571655,
0.7287691831588745,
-0.3868787884712219,
-0.43849244713783264,
-0.362030953168869,
0.6959027051925659,
0.31069982051849365,
-0.12384098023176193,
0.14201748371124268,
0.5626171827316284,
0.14711274206638336,
0.03892357274889946,
-0.5907419919967651,
0.1237819492816925,
0.3144964277744293,
-0.32555022835731506,
0.7622378468513489,
0.15324172377586365,
0.15664812922477722,
0.8256797194480896,
0.607513427734375,
-0.04057365283370018,
-0.3639791011810303,
0.014673693105578423,
1.0994951725006104,
-0.5327831506729126,
-0.6747496724128723,
-0.5387536883354187,
0.3189123570919037,
-0.04704062268137932,
-0.127752423286438,
0.8757248520851135,
0.4222680628299713,
0.803806483745575,
-0.23994873464107513,
0.9910410642623901,
-0.3574686646461487,
0.5378279685974121,
-0.4512839913368225,
0.1351420283317566,
-0.5512312650680542,
0.5173047184944153,
-0.01380301546305418,
-0.7092298269271851,
0.15736185014247894,
0.5665528178215027,
-0.8932836651802063,
0.2280539870262146,
0.08858434110879898,
0.3611900210380554,
-0.19393092393875122,
0.3774457573890686,
0.24997591972351074,
0.008933472447097301,
0.4332089126110077,
0.680288553237915,
1.120905876159668,
-0.31985047459602356,
0.05752222612500191,
-0.15170827507972717,
-0.4776284098625183,
-0.36817991733551025,
-0.7015969157218933,
-0.6628866195678711,
-0.7995319366455078,
-0.0780472680926323,
-0.45826882123947144,
0.13195225596427917,
0.7507054805755615,
0.4160163700580597,
-1.0345029830932617,
-0.17407405376434326,
-0.4676726758480072,
0.2615955173969269,
-0.6152991652488708,
-0.2490127980709076,
-0.06941410154104233,
-0.5781474113464355,
-0.457672119140625,
-0.05229148268699646,
0.24022358655929565,
-0.000007200748314062366,
-0.8010801672935486,
-0.3124021887779236,
-0.07773423194885254,
0.10395301133394241,
0.018885618075728416,
0.8442280888557434,
-0.5175350308418274,
-0.5594085454940796,
-0.24443651735782623,
-0.31173691153526306,
-0.0003457819693721831,
1.0233983993530273,
-0.7185537219047546,
0.7884873747825623,
0.6605505347251892,
0.6568467617034912,
0.6444041132926941,
-0.0659828931093216,
0.5577695369720459,
-0.7139904499053955,
-0.16223256289958954,
-0.06619442999362946,
0.35562393069267273,
0.2965776026248932,
-0.5914056897163391,
0.14986301958560944,
0.3847678303718567,
-0.8344976305961609,
-0.6040788888931274,
0.9530686140060425,
-0.7097254991531372,
-0.08712633699178696,
0.624345600605011,
-0.33056339621543884,
0.01924198307096958,
-0.4031115174293518,
-0.3082248270511627,
0.19396410882472992,
-0.323148250579834,
1.0331512689590454,
0.5966489315032959,
-0.7179178595542908,
-0.06801117956638336,
-0.30270376801490784,
0.7207805514335632,
0.3421725034713745,
-0.5036724209785461,
-0.4658656418323517,
0.5200717449188232,
0.5008267164230347,
0.3961706757545471,
1.1696079969406128,
0.3534499406814575,
0.2820740342140198,
-0.20467086136341095,
-0.050396040081977844,
-0.4366854727268219,
-0.10009537637233734,
-0.1305309385061264,
0.23940899968147278,
-0.11983823776245117,
-0.25544703006744385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15756v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Preliminary Security Risk Analysis: A Mission-Critical Case Study
| 2024-03-23T07:59:30 | 2024-03-23T07:59:30 |
Matteo Esposito, Francesco Palagiano
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY
|
Preliminary security risk analysis (PSRA) provides a quick approach to
identify, evaluate and propose remeditation to potential risks in specific
scenarios. The extensive expertise required for an effective PSRA and the
substantial ammount of textual-related tasks hinder quick assessments in
mission-critical contexts, where timely and prompt actions are essential. The
speed and accuracy of human experts in PSRA significantly impact response time.
A large language model can quickly summarise information in less time than a
human. To our knowledge, no prior study has explored the capabilities of
fine-tuned models (FTM) in PSRA. Our case study investigates the proficiency of
FTM to assist practitioners in PSRA. We manually curated 141 representative
samples from over 50 mission-critical analyses archived by the industrial
context team in the last five years.We compared the proficiency of the FTM
versus seven human experts. Within the industrial context, our approach has
proven successful in reducing errors in PSRA, hastening security risk
detection, and minimizing false positives and negatives. This translates to
cost savings for the company by averting unnecessary expenses associated with
implementing unwarranted countermeasures. Therefore, experts can focus on more
comprehensive risk analysis, leveraging LLMs for an effective preliminary
assessment within a condensed timeframe.
|
[
-0.08858532458543777,
-0.7002942562103271,
0.804439127445221,
0.08278544992208481,
-0.2820473611354828,
0.3791328966617584,
0.10850350558757782,
-0.5365473628044128,
-0.07359599322080612,
0.7560098171234131,
-0.4949723482131958,
-0.25804927945137024,
-0.5386127829551697,
-0.10639623552560806,
-0.3845299184322357,
0.8077826499938965,
-0.06931689381599426,
-0.1998787671327591,
0.3219897747039795,
0.2946404814720154,
-0.32526060938835144,
-0.8228980302810669,
-0.5804703235626221,
-0.05949949473142624,
0.23851673305034637,
0.7296951413154602,
0.7340313792228699,
0.05052268132567406,
1.018140435218811,
0.351433128118515,
-0.08463604003190994,
0.02305133081972599,
-0.36680614948272705,
-0.20134228467941284,
-0.3311963379383087,
-0.5962981581687927,
-0.5692269206047058,
-0.07730922102928162,
0.47811219096183777,
0.79767906665802,
-0.30081379413604736,
0.6290060877799988,
-0.020040063187479973,
0.544344961643219,
-0.45219436287879944,
0.2720784544944763,
-0.964263916015625,
0.005425313487648964,
-0.3161460757255554,
-0.451513409614563,
-0.44583773612976074,
-0.2826450765132904,
0.5297492742538452,
-0.41434937715530396,
0.23285329341888428,
0.12516851723194122,
0.7196663618087769,
0.1062568798661232,
-0.3415416181087494,
0.04191897436976433,
-1.1390769481658936,
0.7307971119880676,
-0.5267775654792786,
0.16608722507953644,
0.3791773319244385,
0.5920732021331787,
-0.24057677388191223,
-0.8532698154449463,
-0.28691449761390686,
-0.21662576496601105,
0.2091822326183319,
-0.3163259029388428,
-0.24024812877178192,
0.1800689846277237,
0.4231019914150238,
0.024817995727062225,
-0.3700779974460602,
0.13419540226459503,
-0.7691443562507629,
-0.574700117111206,
0.6587371826171875,
0.47899359464645386,
0.044531505554914474,
0.004264327231794596,
-0.18094204366207123,
-0.264296293258667,
-0.6931968927383423,
0.226024329662323,
0.3084237575531006,
0.5866749882698059,
-0.04808180779218674,
0.5817127823829651,
-0.4839805066585541,
0.478942334651947,
-0.15273256599903107,
-0.34053754806518555,
0.0988462045788765,
-0.43706172704696655,
-0.4626268148422241,
-0.18819786608219147,
0.6417245864868164,
0.3992405831813812,
0.30715706944465637,
-0.29951369762420654,
-0.24123935401439667,
0.21204915642738342,
0.5364468693733215,
-0.8650882244110107,
-0.28259870409965515,
0.2785643935203552,
-0.497519314289093,
-0.23322848975658417,
0.18594495952129364,
-0.7797559499740601,
-0.5933809280395508,
-0.3388712406158447,
0.3703305125236511,
-0.24467416107654572,
-0.1148717999458313,
0.32108795642852783,
0.028681302443146706,
0.36434903740882874,
0.1299908459186554,
-0.152701735496521,
0.1776614785194397,
0.6657717823982239,
0.945938766002655,
0.3831287920475006,
-0.08242993801832199,
-0.526750922203064,
0.18258745968341827,
-0.30493608117103577,
0.8251311182975769,
-0.3221319615840912,
-0.5880972743034363,
-0.10012450814247131,
0.013439597561955452,
0.03383731096982956,
-0.25949421525001526,
0.800619900226593,
-0.6119657754898071,
-0.3807775378227234,
-0.4302785396575928,
-0.11455555260181427,
-0.1321866363286972,
0.07535747438669205,
-0.2761101722717285,
0.6392410397529602,
-0.03199473395943642,
-0.772908091545105,
0.47215375304222107,
-0.25008800625801086,
-0.4115280210971832,
0.13005207479000092,
-0.31074514985084534,
-0.4214889407157898,
0.31065699458122253,
-0.046869728714227676,
0.7657338380813599,
-0.36539092659950256,
0.28320378065109253,
-0.3627657890319824,
-0.2689359486103058,
0.4501458406448364,
-0.11564246565103531,
0.29741060733795166,
0.3682734966278076,
-0.11931177973747253,
0.25982239842414856,
-0.6131923198699951,
0.12744489312171936,
0.11878427863121033,
0.006537159904837608,
-0.32191747426986694,
0.21620695292949677,
-0.003291698871180415,
0.3951030969619751,
0.33078524470329285,
-0.33002519607543945,
-0.26434236764907837,
-0.5452160239219666,
0.4219822585582733,
0.6873884201049805,
0.3207911252975464,
0.41439691185951233,
-0.24771679937839508,
0.7344427108764648,
-0.3100319802761078,
0.5932539701461792,
0.07803063094615936,
-0.16824093461036682,
-0.5925238728523254,
-0.2558659315109253,
-0.04896165058016777,
0.7780640721321106,
-0.5732789635658264,
0.2728348970413208,
-0.1950695961713791,
-0.9304033517837524,
-0.07067733258008957,
-0.03760046139359474,
0.43173906207084656,
0.5347663760185242,
0.10369859635829926,
-0.44090351462364197,
-0.7814805507659912,
-1.039451003074646,
-0.29444852471351624,
-0.4467429518699646,
-0.21185708045959473,
-0.000975947710685432,
0.3655520975589752,
-0.21904689073562622,
0.9376422166824341,
-0.9182654023170471,
-0.3452604115009308,
-0.2649118900299072,
0.20114654302597046,
0.26852619647979736,
0.23077340424060822,
0.635262668132782,
-0.47347936034202576,
-0.2849167287349701,
-0.05626409500837326,
-0.5888720750808716,
0.13015291094779968,
-0.23599272966384888,
-0.2197008579969406,
-0.18523958325386047,
0.7066429853439331,
-0.4799431264400482,
0.24921618402004242,
0.2660387456417084,
-0.24038897454738617,
0.5348502397537231,
-0.354773610830307,
-0.008597640320658684,
-1.1880459785461426,
0.5562346577644348,
0.22891390323638916,
-0.030711013823747635,
-1.0769034624099731,
0.33691322803497314,
0.17375202476978302,
-0.4540875554084778,
-0.5334157347679138,
0.10997913032770157,
-0.37917229533195496,
-0.18639153242111206,
-0.4006616175174713,
-0.20363211631774902,
-0.20996837317943573,
0.2901902198791504,
-0.02167806215584278,
0.9163478016853333,
0.4355268180370331,
-0.8550693392753601,
-0.4406222105026245,
0.1407822072505951,
-0.6193561553955078,
0.3073612153530121,
-0.8909951448440552,
0.247756689786911,
0.16115394234657288,
0.1475140005350113,
-0.9586614370346069,
-0.2385357767343521,
0.22844460606575012,
-0.010614177212119102,
0.1605035960674286,
-0.20685835182666779,
-0.6116551756858826,
-0.4651424288749695,
-0.23262622952461243,
0.053900010883808136,
0.37129735946655273,
0.17935660481452942,
0.6592329740524292,
0.657242476940155,
-0.6103756427764893,
-0.26804983615875244,
-0.6083210110664368,
0.16075904667377472,
-0.42463845014572144,
-0.4834771156311035,
0.11005129665136337,
0.04865727201104164,
-0.42368578910827637,
-0.4928187131881714,
-0.40803062915802,
-0.3996001183986664,
0.5847203135490417,
0.5377993583679199,
0.3136814534664154,
0.11994811147451401,
-0.3715449869632721,
-0.005494371987879276,
-0.29687008261680603,
0.2803398072719574,
0.028411872684955597,
0.5088148713111877,
-0.33679360151290894,
-0.24354654550552368,
-0.69597327709198,
0.25021326541900635,
0.8305823802947998,
-0.4362765848636627,
0.8225977420806885,
0.20369777083396912,
-0.49477440118789673,
0.30137747526168823,
-0.6430519223213196,
-0.30457326769828796,
-0.5397016406059265,
0.44341325759887695,
-0.3201371133327484,
-0.7197412848472595,
0.7917499542236328,
-0.21845348179340363,
0.08626735210418701,
0.32801634073257446,
0.27220845222473145,
-0.027524461969733238,
0.7327292561531067,
1.0847563743591309,
-0.26343318819999695,
0.5332709550857544,
-0.2503749132156372,
0.504295825958252,
-0.4347495436668396,
-0.4692506492137909,
-0.7709928154945374,
0.07443150132894516,
-0.219706729054451,
-0.5464855432510376,
0.6419113278388977,
-0.21426156163215637,
-0.290626585483551,
0.4465382695198059,
-0.1242765262722969,
0.31613078713417053,
0.02210754156112671,
0.29238608479499817,
0.19392746686935425,
0.07701435685157776,
0.14339186251163483,
0.12807773053646088,
-0.3327350914478302,
-0.8600839376449585,
1.1868674755096436,
0.7304913401603699,
0.6647640466690063,
0.11769436299800873,
0.36380699276924133,
0.17858706414699554,
0.12324145436286926,
-0.6978968977928162,
0.7905186414718628,
-0.0437878854572773,
-0.4901813566684723,
-0.19993822276592255,
-0.40498632192611694,
-0.5714889168739319,
-0.006095192860811949,
-0.16730274260044098,
-0.6472223401069641,
0.2710719406604767,
0.24851855635643005,
-1.0862147808074951,
-0.024863552302122116,
-0.8311121463775635,
0.4283742904663086,
-0.28258630633354187,
-0.06624796241521835,
-0.3986830711364746,
-0.8686174750328064,
0.4295256733894348,
-0.4994873106479645,
0.1791827380657196,
-0.2616890072822571,
-0.12434790283441544,
0.9304187297821045,
-0.42825260758399963,
1.2038198709487915,
-0.27314114570617676,
-0.21909528970718384,
0.15847229957580566,
0.19161993265151978,
0.6533157825469971,
0.12461616098880768,
-0.2653632164001465,
0.14774882793426514,
0.07467222958803177,
-0.30957603454589844,
-0.2157621681690216,
0.3788895606994629,
-0.6378622055053711,
-0.6192880868911743,
-0.6723188161849976,
-0.4000795781612396,
-0.5820561051368713,
0.2697329521179199,
0.08697342127561569,
0.26927757263183594,
-0.25360506772994995,
0.07783447951078415,
0.6702450513839722,
-0.14922352135181427,
0.2301354855298996,
1.0191923379898071,
0.17923204600811005,
-0.22898142039775848,
0.5038319230079651,
0.32344093918800354,
0.15032052993774414,
0.1834339201450348,
0.11719345301389694,
-0.09213656187057495,
-0.9232059121131897,
0.2091628462076187,
0.13012568652629852,
-0.4656250476837158,
-0.4266889989376068,
-0.6552525758743286,
-0.21037030220031738,
-0.12721027433872223,
-0.17160320281982422,
-0.3837035000324249,
-0.20628340542316437,
-0.1128920391201973,
-0.3023344576358795,
0.39332979917526245,
0.2464357614517212,
0.38652318716049194,
0.7051106691360474,
-0.8224121928215027,
0.443649560213089,
0.051085155457258224,
0.23758433759212494,
-0.15448187291622162,
-0.583676815032959,
-0.2774994969367981,
-0.11942669749259949,
-0.10011231899261475,
-0.9970013499259949,
0.3453182876110077,
0.15551157295703888,
0.6767669320106506,
0.601688802242279,
0.17125648260116577,
0.8146470189094543,
-0.5452091097831726,
0.6065356135368347,
-0.047546129673719406,
-0.9566238522529602,
0.6440947651863098,
-0.415303498506546,
0.0827765092253685,
1.0470530986785889,
0.4481116235256195,
-0.3553379476070404,
-0.2291964888572693,
-0.4171830713748932,
-1.0546306371688843,
0.733422577381134,
0.10193533450365067,
0.12573057413101196,
0.15837988257408142,
0.48829197883605957,
-0.1627502143383026,
0.19802844524383545,
-0.11345037817955017,
0.05320163443684578,
0.18007810413837433,
0.2911767065525055,
-0.2809966802597046,
-0.548314094543457,
-0.36459463834762573,
-0.12276874482631683,
0.5984132885932922,
-0.22180034220218658,
0.12992388010025024,
0.13271057605743408,
-0.13336612284183502,
-0.10069295018911362,
0.3588869273662567,
0.7479643821716309,
0.9412339329719543,
-0.3470926582813263,
-0.06374647468328476,
0.47205913066864014,
-0.5524569749832153,
-0.030179748311638832,
0.20922969281673431,
0.05658912658691406,
-0.5058647394180298,
0.3101038932800293,
0.49664726853370667,
0.354562908411026,
-0.8752796053886414,
0.3211412727832794,
-0.23159953951835632,
-0.022281309589743614,
-0.40060800313949585,
-0.22818979620933533,
-0.2606259882450104,
0.3515291213989258,
0.5942900776863098,
0.22806890308856964,
0.27845555543899536,
-0.5369645953178406,
0.32667917013168335,
0.3809000849723816,
-0.13333211839199066,
-0.4002673625946045,
0.33328109979629517,
0.29487958550453186,
-0.04028775170445442,
0.3608810305595398,
-0.07438870519399643,
-0.5676781535148621,
0.6231990456581116,
0.2773180305957794,
0.8642340302467346,
-0.41570863127708435,
0.4020521938800812,
0.026537301018834114,
0.8352913856506348,
-0.41369807720184326,
0.6349827647209167,
0.3410005569458008,
-0.4557456076145172,
-0.5242274403572083,
-0.6202535033226013,
-0.6337026357650757,
0.2623089551925659,
-0.5845431685447693,
0.11597804725170135,
-1.0594176054000854,
-0.3719768226146698,
-0.36859145760536194,
0.22400689125061035,
-0.7363269329071045,
0.21208056807518005,
-0.07527419179677963,
0.9838355183601379,
-1.2812663316726685,
0.5012624859809875,
0.5209453105926514,
-0.265624076128006,
-1.1162281036376953,
0.2516278326511383,
-0.08534969389438629,
-0.5876242518424988,
0.48036324977874756,
0.14891907572746277,
-0.2149381935596466,
-0.4623367190361023,
0.02095457725226879,
-0.8947266340255737,
1.1651763916015625,
0.634235680103302,
-0.8251949548721313,
-0.028369542211294174,
0.4131965637207031,
0.7731663584709167,
0.09606985002756119,
-0.008730176836252213,
0.7983804941177368,
0.2529405951499939,
-0.1426982283592224,
-0.9039304256439209,
0.24789297580718994,
0.02070012129843235,
0.047053154557943344,
0.27398681640625,
-0.6788889169692993,
0.698245108127594,
-0.15696538984775543,
-0.2231939733028412,
0.09099318087100983,
0.9024342894554138,
0.28031525015830994,
0.5786842107772827,
0.5154029726982117,
0.12970073521137238,
0.9487378597259521,
0.23689036071300507,
1.0101412534713745,
-0.49821150302886963,
-0.049725450575351715,
1.0701546669006348,
-0.6191506385803223,
1.037864089012146,
0.624737024307251,
-0.2137104868888855,
0.1214679703116417,
0.7602618336677551,
0.14173947274684906,
0.4554678201675415,
0.04667536914348602,
-0.08053896576166153,
-0.391810804605484,
-0.1651211678981781,
-0.39401644468307495,
0.5153165459632874,
0.43295449018478394,
-0.38838285207748413,
-0.06990712136030197,
-0.1028234213590622,
-0.03769153356552124,
-0.012387377209961414,
-0.3179137706756592,
0.3957444429397583,
0.2956611216068268,
-0.28028079867362976,
0.04576978087425232,
0.2805653214454651,
0.32576966285705566,
-0.8798327445983887,
0.4704824686050415,
-0.09111519157886505,
0.2664937674999237,
-0.13598179817199707,
-0.6696276664733887,
0.7195855975151062,
0.2804536521434784,
-0.0378776378929615,
-0.2177688628435135,
0.760496973991394,
0.16758477687835693,
-0.7460737228393555,
0.12083429843187332,
0.29460805654525757,
-0.14568418264389038,
-0.5241339802742004,
-0.40220773220062256,
0.1413210928440094,
-0.4408310055732727,
-0.0144197978079319,
0.3058183193206787,
0.14528284966945648,
-0.2911384403705597,
0.7917653918266296,
0.6559001207351685,
0.022615252062678337,
-0.23488742113113403,
-0.0166740994900465,
0.953737199306488,
-0.4137382209300995,
-0.5865841507911682,
-0.7283496856689453,
0.28399935364723206,
-0.026325395330786705,
-0.1988065540790558,
0.8382229208946228,
0.48395538330078125,
0.4286315143108368,
-0.3419263958930969,
0.7131162285804749,
0.14007604122161865,
0.29610490798950195,
-0.6173961758613586,
0.7899958491325378,
-0.19916656613349915,
0.5041234493255615,
-0.6270856857299805,
-0.6127976775169373,
-0.3309677541255951,
0.31787100434303284,
-0.5358609557151794,
-0.39130011200904846,
0.5263127684593201,
0.9481850862503052,
-0.04373043030500412,
-0.19625520706176758,
0.19650931656360626,
0.14601857960224152,
0.4879639148712158,
0.4356544017791748,
0.7628421187400818,
-0.40689894556999207,
0.614258885383606,
-0.29804882407188416,
-0.2966146767139435,
-0.300121545791626,
-1.056363582611084,
-0.8747638463973999,
-0.34610515832901,
-0.39114677906036377,
-0.1533811092376709,
0.006002780050039291,
0.7596045136451721,
0.6499872803688049,
-0.7402632832527161,
-0.12075034528970718,
0.04526766017079353,
-0.3188656270503998,
-0.16575269401073456,
-0.11645299196243286,
0.12120610475540161,
0.08135669678449631,
-0.050307489931583405,
0.6716457009315491,
0.14811041951179504,
-0.042784374207258224,
-0.1646682620048523,
0.16042129695415497,
0.1308428943157196,
0.4927370250225067,
0.5806187391281128,
0.4875466525554657,
-0.4580327570438385,
-0.5403797030448914,
0.14469633996486664,
0.09323063492774963,
-0.5970340371131897,
0.8995848298072815,
-0.3481540381908417,
-0.03003777749836445,
0.7204548716545105,
0.7129242420196533,
0.08222172409296036,
-0.20598360896110535,
0.746193528175354,
-0.7788873910903931,
0.2950625717639923,
0.02549072727560997,
0.5067397952079773,
0.18544070422649384,
-0.6681397557258606,
0.4395061731338501,
-0.04082803055644035,
-0.4494875967502594,
-1.0306622982025146,
0.37545710802078247,
-1.1805248260498047,
-0.06576216220855713,
0.9798300862312317,
-0.12999676167964935,
0.147328719496727,
-0.2155849039554596,
-0.382357120513916,
0.2599537968635559,
-0.25879016518592834,
1.057974934577942,
0.5441260933876038,
0.16862261295318604,
0.27370405197143555,
-0.4097461700439453,
0.36770838499069214,
0.3651113212108612,
-0.9291021227836609,
0.18554075062274933,
0.1201920136809349,
0.3705502152442932,
0.2115226835012436,
0.638685941696167,
-0.024312643334269524,
0.3831649422645569,
-0.3737371265888214,
-0.2549836337566376,
-0.10256125032901764,
-0.8175255060195923,
-0.515885591506958,
0.5186442732810974,
0.5353378057479858,
-0.05948679894208908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15744v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15744v3
|
On the Fragility of Active Learners
| 2024-03-23T07:16:23 | 2024-04-15T17:10:46 |
Abhishek Ghose, Emma Thuong Nguyen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Active learning (AL) techniques aim to maximally utilize a labeling budget by
iteratively selecting instances that are most likely to improve prediction
accuracy. However, their benefit compared to random sampling has not been
consistent across various setups, e.g., different datasets, classifiers. In
this empirical study, we examine how a combination of different factors might
obscure any gains from an AL technique. Focusing on text classification, we
rigorously evaluate AL techniques over around 1000 experiments that vary wrt
the dataset, batch size, text representation and the classifier. We show that
AL is only effective in a narrow set of circumstances. We also address the
problem of using metrics that are better aligned with real world expectations.
The impact of this study is in its insights for a practitioner: (a) the choice
of text representation and classifier is as important as that of an AL
technique, (b) choice of the right metric is critical in assessment of the
latter, and, finally, (c) reported AL results must be holistically interpreted,
accounting for variables other than just the query strategy.
|
[
-0.07001624256372452,
-0.9967182874679565,
0.26963722705841064,
-0.0479615144431591,
-0.0185751523822546,
0.05701674520969391,
-0.32711267471313477,
-0.6788763999938965,
0.010793855413794518,
-0.20675577223300934,
-0.018259771168231964,
-0.3799782991409302,
-0.4440983831882477,
-0.044191181659698486,
-0.3800942003726959,
1.0082933902740479,
-0.37065163254737854,
0.03089592605829239,
0.03378264978528023,
-0.6490810513496399,
-0.3346918821334839,
-0.3802114725112915,
-0.8345409035682678,
-0.08569786697626114,
0.8182805776596069,
0.4234234094619751,
0.8046376705169678,
0.9058042168617249,
0.6476816534996033,
0.19607406854629517,
-0.2302083522081375,
0.11131221055984497,
-0.26074352860450745,
0.31539076566696167,
0.2331874668598175,
-0.9604483246803284,
-0.18472398817539215,
0.4145348072052002,
0.8844442367553711,
0.8563805222511292,
-0.33973804116249084,
0.01692253164947033,
0.1207885667681694,
0.5677587985992432,
-1.154849886894226,
-0.0021764400880783796,
-0.4205550253391266,
0.3037088215351105,
-0.33420050144195557,
0.1719694435596466,
-0.393702894449234,
-0.25898319482803345,
0.3166046142578125,
-0.43385863304138184,
0.3268279731273651,
0.05725343897938728,
0.9250308871269226,
0.4616911709308624,
-0.3794003129005432,
-0.6640958189964294,
-0.9541633129119873,
0.8497606515884399,
-0.25665971636772156,
0.31621554493904114,
0.6439810395240784,
0.33500927686691284,
0.367809534072876,
-0.7845237255096436,
-0.32008153200149536,
0.016468683257699013,
0.13461902737617493,
0.3014100193977356,
-0.020335178822278976,
0.16806863248348236,
0.1511845737695694,
0.6477131247520447,
0.10702972859144211,
0.2555358111858368,
-0.505903959274292,
-0.29421335458755493,
0.5960215926170349,
-0.15513911843299866,
0.22270241379737854,
0.11440613120794296,
-0.4876370429992676,
-0.3808457851409912,
-0.355617880821228,
0.3429946303367615,
0.5492522120475769,
0.4138844907283783,
0.18416161835193634,
0.5983808040618896,
0.3555251359939575,
0.7131686210632324,
-0.14964795112609863,
-0.2675275504589081,
0.27255287766456604,
-0.09404861927032471,
-0.17723602056503296,
0.28701192140579224,
0.5524671673774719,
-0.07953473180532455,
0.004052908159792423,
-0.19477713108062744,
-0.609464168548584,
0.06710590422153473,
0.40869763493537903,
-0.326802134513855,
-0.3794635832309723,
0.29320868849754333,
-0.4041174650192261,
-0.40682682394981384,
0.30968981981277466,
-0.5153668522834778,
-0.11224489659070969,
-0.06086990237236023,
0.6281139850616455,
-0.18016064167022705,
-0.12346139550209045,
-0.016584619879722595,
0.003106144955381751,
-0.20557792484760284,
0.4527854025363922,
-0.6795297861099243,
0.26556825637817383,
0.12048948556184769,
0.9573302268981934,
-0.532088577747345,
-0.20754247903823853,
-0.4031851291656494,
-0.08639096468687057,
-0.43545156717300415,
0.6722307801246643,
-0.5257620215415955,
-0.26317304372787476,
0.28920283913612366,
-0.10702572762966156,
-0.33044978976249695,
-0.5587409138679504,
0.5334598422050476,
-0.549959659576416,
0.1226402148604393,
-0.2276557832956314,
-0.28775981068611145,
-0.29073095321655273,
0.0636366605758667,
-1.1407440900802612,
1.141459584236145,
-0.1857215166091919,
-0.5740943551063538,
0.8151078820228577,
-0.39272767305374146,
-0.484218567609787,
-0.2360629439353943,
-0.21641863882541656,
-0.9372195601463318,
0.0316268652677536,
-0.3013811707496643,
0.42670175433158875,
0.40389999747276306,
-0.15055520832538605,
-0.27582862973213196,
-0.5249952673912048,
0.6622404456138611,
-0.8937799334526062,
0.7441490292549133,
0.4338316321372986,
-0.5604118704795837,
-0.15124379098415375,
-0.7156404852867126,
-0.028135089203715324,
-0.15559472143650055,
-0.8309828042984009,
-0.5826900601387024,
0.2427203208208084,
0.013935009017586708,
-0.1963118314743042,
0.009645872749388218,
-0.40039491653442383,
0.1861143261194229,
-0.09287070482969284,
0.003227733075618744,
0.8169484734535217,
0.12437330186367035,
0.6277708411216736,
-0.4067174196243286,
0.628538191318512,
-0.24571681022644043,
0.08679745346307755,
-0.018712064251303673,
-0.22819453477859497,
-0.6414246559143066,
-0.7038440108299255,
0.7233688235282898,
0.4616972506046295,
-0.5206422209739685,
0.011900079436600208,
0.2298145741224289,
-0.4476805031299591,
-0.586861789226532,
0.4557587802410126,
0.4235486090183258,
-0.07361814379692078,
0.2692347764968872,
-0.3080146014690399,
-0.09154938161373138,
-0.5099950432777405,
-0.5250141024589539,
-0.3569431006908417,
0.3010503351688385,
0.2698492109775543,
0.20750033855438232,
0.12182792276144028,
0.5761668682098389,
-0.49550503492355347,
-0.4434444308280945,
-0.13932567834854126,
0.2866092920303345,
-0.21320544183254242,
0.17112761735916138,
0.6622354984283447,
-1.0550954341888428,
-0.5697031021118164,
-0.2585532069206238,
-0.6645492315292358,
0.12869299948215485,
-0.475427508354187,
0.08302082121372223,
0.16928061842918396,
0.47238969802856445,
-0.30937498807907104,
0.5900434255599976,
0.29318544268608093,
-0.2593391239643097,
0.014185010455548763,
0.011621103622019291,
-0.10964211076498032,
-0.3560267686843872,
0.03562990576028824,
0.2890194058418274,
0.015438619069755077,
-0.481663316488266,
0.0438687726855278,
0.2388370782136917,
-0.0386558473110199,
-0.494554728269577,
0.465794175863266,
-0.6909671425819397,
0.2375916987657547,
-0.19751021265983582,
-0.03930282965302467,
-0.28483039140701294,
0.31427180767059326,
-0.24458739161491394,
0.730202853679657,
0.6076244115829468,
-0.8879586458206177,
0.04427219182252884,
-0.14801210165023804,
-0.45368069410324097,
0.07994581013917923,
-0.5449617505073547,
-0.20478671789169312,
-0.12959282100200653,
0.08521320670843124,
-1.1963649988174438,
-0.2486761510372162,
0.2315760850906372,
-0.3540883958339691,
0.6133971810340881,
0.19784171879291534,
-0.4376324713230133,
-0.1870296746492386,
-0.42982205748558044,
0.3577752113342285,
0.3690037727355957,
-0.47608327865600586,
0.6124151945114136,
0.255092591047287,
0.21054233610630035,
-0.9119952321052551,
-0.6079357266426086,
-0.4655117392539978,
-0.28252437710762024,
0.07960968464612961,
-0.08125466108322144,
0.04307950288057327,
-0.5751157999038696,
0.08738096058368683,
-0.6291831731796265,
-0.07990655303001404,
0.5518458485603333,
0.296205073595047,
0.150068461894989,
0.016492534428834915,
0.4338803291320801,
0.09931574761867523,
0.15261387825012207,
-0.014101646840572357,
0.2146049439907074,
-0.13010044395923615,
-0.04834604263305664,
-0.7484885454177856,
-0.4645553529262543,
-0.03889746591448784,
0.5221031308174133,
-0.2631572484970093,
0.9767516851425171,
0.5540786981582642,
-0.14892946183681488,
-0.6417864561080933,
-0.3218185007572174,
-0.14697487652301788,
-0.4460489749908447,
0.21583181619644165,
0.008774355053901672,
-0.4347582459449768,
0.36730334162712097,
0.03086158260703087,
0.8025466799736023,
0.2852220833301544,
0.1790258139371872,
-0.41409265995025635,
1.0215156078338623,
0.651246964931488,
0.3022671937942505,
1.0399830341339111,
-0.4326876401901245,
0.2819102108478546,
-0.3045913279056549,
-0.3792952299118042,
-0.5773028135299683,
-0.7305224537849426,
-0.19156257808208466,
-0.3050214350223541,
0.3466057777404785,
0.1995600014925003,
0.17143063247203827,
-0.31065863370895386,
-0.5192390084266663,
0.22369138896465302,
0.5150203704833984,
0.35121428966522217,
0.22567780315876007,
0.46979081630706787,
0.08564702421426773,
-0.018667755648493767,
-0.8453693985939026,
-0.5272054672241211,
1.108220100402832,
0.534656286239624,
0.9754000306129456,
0.4167717695236206,
0.42096590995788574,
0.4598161280155182,
0.4904104471206665,
-1.2966541051864624,
0.4072361886501312,
0.15832559764385223,
-0.9277156591415405,
-0.3573591411113739,
-0.4182419776916504,
-1.3399347066879272,
0.22189810872077942,
-0.453570157289505,
-0.028577595949172974,
0.3719753324985504,
0.2596253752708435,
-0.3285914957523346,
0.43073391914367676,
-0.8988369107246399,
0.4918334484100342,
-0.38595300912857056,
-0.6288968324661255,
0.13228119909763336,
-0.5081539750099182,
-0.01068547461181879,
-0.34657469391822815,
0.31168222427368164,
0.09125997871160507,
-0.35967493057250977,
1.2406713962554932,
-0.09716740995645523,
1.1570401191711426,
-0.25714534521102905,
0.009413499385118484,
0.9020650386810303,
-0.12845981121063232,
0.18397293984889984,
-0.23228058218955994,
-0.1970236748456955,
-0.26472145318984985,
-0.3173176348209381,
-0.7789369225502014,
-0.4952404499053955,
0.37494388222694397,
-1.053592562675476,
-0.4833020567893982,
-0.8059000968933105,
-0.2769530117511749,
-0.15574240684509277,
0.03559041768312454,
-0.009526879526674747,
0.6011220812797546,
-0.08470337092876434,
0.3818146884441376,
1.0337162017822266,
0.15209455788135529,
0.7358511090278625,
0.3968617022037506,
0.1670811027288437,
-0.3104727566242218,
0.794512927532196,
0.6755176782608032,
0.5899366140365601,
0.05264109745621681,
0.04579201713204384,
-0.13538388907909393,
-0.6952173113822937,
-0.38223811984062195,
0.2780827581882477,
-0.9081303477287292,
-0.3958262503147125,
-0.4877728521823883,
0.09321907162666321,
-0.05244005471467972,
-0.3077361583709717,
-0.27971315383911133,
-0.5616163611412048,
-0.3668285012245178,
-0.5375485420227051,
0.31431034207344055,
0.7302813529968262,
-0.04650610312819481,
0.4047113060951233,
-0.5054146647453308,
-0.05720234662294388,
0.5125449299812317,
0.21561473608016968,
0.33943259716033936,
-0.25225895643234253,
-0.571749746799469,
-0.01393328607082367,
-0.515252411365509,
-0.8592497706413269,
-0.05267081409692764,
0.47423091530799866,
1.0659836530685425,
0.8288567066192627,
0.39243218302726746,
0.42274796962738037,
-0.17323699593544006,
0.7110845446586609,
0.09966196119785309,
-0.41307082772254944,
0.6364116072654724,
0.028389722108840942,
0.06025330349802971,
1.0605814456939697,
0.8945038914680481,
0.10061854869127274,
-0.47242188453674316,
-0.7121384739875793,
-1.1651467084884644,
0.6803441047668457,
0.26009830832481384,
0.15580593049526215,
0.008277389220893383,
0.6155372262001038,
0.0867646113038063,
0.09283041208982468,
-0.9112647771835327,
-0.6230729818344116,
-0.07300068438053131,
-0.33649998903274536,
0.12147904932498932,
0.03913213312625885,
-0.38254082202911377,
-0.020546292886137962,
0.6414198875427246,
0.034562963992357254,
0.1607997566461563,
0.3159383237361908,
0.019067304208874702,
-0.26529863476753235,
0.05998662859201431,
-0.0002073181967716664,
0.739555835723877,
-0.21849925816059113,
0.3653804063796997,
0.09720395505428314,
-0.9679988622665405,
0.1491537243127823,
-0.2232038527727127,
-0.2491474449634552,
0.13078774511814117,
0.8226454257965088,
0.6829520463943481,
0.2092069685459137,
-0.7685416340827942,
0.48587310314178467,
-0.018674632534384727,
-0.11091112345457077,
-0.22403837740421295,
0.5394383072853088,
-0.6063734292984009,
-0.05500484257936478,
0.7440367341041565,
0.5149891376495361,
-0.032246798276901245,
-1.0279717445373535,
0.05556555464863777,
0.2187035232782364,
-0.7994467616081238,
-0.32036611437797546,
0.5940521955490112,
0.2789570689201355,
-0.4062668979167938,
0.5868794322013855,
0.02202724851667881,
-0.40503132343292236,
0.6209856271743774,
0.36499083042144775,
0.48128122091293335,
-0.37156054377555847,
0.09326599538326263,
0.34718164801597595,
0.3267933428287506,
-0.5581223964691162,
0.048754218965768814,
-0.14556120336055756,
-0.5901685357093811,
-0.20403844118118286,
-0.4968183934688568,
-0.3460482358932495,
-0.3901037871837616,
-1.132941484451294,
0.27636268734931946,
-0.5057728290557861,
-0.404072105884552,
-0.1312614381313324,
0.27496689558029175,
-0.23543818295001984,
0.32729625701904297,
-0.17421099543571472,
0.867765486240387,
-1.3352357149124146,
0.5232559442520142,
1.3768938779830933,
-0.5210188627243042,
-0.8204374313354492,
0.09492988139390945,
0.08947868645191193,
-0.5422582626342773,
0.22179552912712097,
0.030808163806796074,
0.022098373621702194,
-0.2662491798400879,
-0.6214282512664795,
-0.5905966758728027,
1.12431001663208,
-0.19880084693431854,
-0.38277560472488403,
-0.04189511761069298,
-0.5706772804260254,
0.4951784312725067,
0.07831283658742905,
-0.12513072788715363,
-0.021809721365571022,
0.32115817070007324,
0.2510470747947693,
-0.6782208681106567,
-0.15222951769828796,
-0.11657091230154037,
-0.5369409322738647,
0.42639485001564026,
-0.8246053457260132,
0.6101139187812805,
-0.3071592152118683,
-0.4672185778617859,
-0.3585425615310669,
0.8216089010238647,
0.21350549161434174,
0.8623210191726685,
0.7219549417495728,
0.3224283456802368,
1.0679184198379517,
0.05193371698260307,
1.0864298343658447,
0.15468794107437134,
0.328662246465683,
0.3989759683609009,
0.08569025248289108,
0.9932780861854553,
0.36434775590896606,
-0.3013899028301239,
0.25482839345932007,
0.797356367111206,
-0.08922813087701797,
0.8192399740219116,
-0.2611972987651825,
-0.49491947889328003,
-0.18671375513076782,
0.13989906013011932,
-0.20850031077861786,
0.299127459526062,
0.49590712785720825,
-0.36261186003685,
0.1241622045636177,
0.2928154170513153,
0.38428497314453125,
0.3114553689956665,
-0.43706247210502625,
0.5717522501945496,
0.1152138039469719,
-0.693081796169281,
0.37676745653152466,
-0.05789780244231224,
0.5820384621620178,
-0.6139076352119446,
0.03068704716861248,
-0.008907275274395943,
0.40790221095085144,
-0.36982637643814087,
-0.6203937530517578,
0.16593502461910248,
-0.14547301828861237,
0.024863284081220627,
-0.3937026262283325,
0.617051362991333,
-0.1522592455148697,
-0.36331677436828613,
-0.08017447590827942,
0.7460692524909973,
0.13474439084529877,
0.36175262928009033,
-0.6238813400268555,
0.24822339415550232,
0.18362142145633698,
-0.3897097706794739,
0.3875063955783844,
0.8060365319252014,
-0.05221285670995712,
0.5388734936714172,
0.4503098726272583,
0.17656970024108887,
0.057107940316200256,
-0.3071575462818146,
0.7812502384185791,
-0.4258779287338257,
-0.17215596139431,
-0.49910449981689453,
0.31246045231819153,
0.06909770518541336,
-0.5218019485473633,
1.191064715385437,
0.5754632353782654,
0.6687323451042175,
0.4532039761543274,
0.6466127038002014,
0.03845933452248573,
0.23430749773979187,
-0.5347295999526978,
0.6334251761436462,
-0.6750227212905884,
0.6565790176391602,
-0.04009607806801796,
-0.9608956575393677,
-0.34368595480918884,
0.9682340025901794,
-0.1970333307981491,
0.11403261125087738,
0.8442526459693909,
0.09783152490854263,
-0.056409671902656555,
0.017181415110826492,
0.07305528223514557,
0.04811170697212219,
0.12202556431293488,
-0.14132416248321533,
0.6420488357543945,
-0.46990448236465454,
0.8236197829246521,
-0.2657529413700104,
-0.5143362283706665,
-0.11875484883785248,
-0.31364089250564575,
-1.0606328248977661,
-0.5154679417610168,
-0.5870530009269714,
-0.43050864338874817,
0.19885940849781036,
0.4985557496547699,
0.42509689927101135,
-0.42360785603523254,
-0.006326623260974884,
0.1456269472837448,
0.17884255945682526,
-0.6606618762016296,
-0.20556199550628662,
0.6175110936164856,
-0.44625356793403625,
-0.7836340665817261,
0.07393358647823334,
-0.3558955490589142,
0.22463715076446533,
-0.2302447110414505,
0.24092552065849304,
-0.33488884568214417,
0.07804735749959946,
0.4086189568042755,
0.4503801167011261,
-0.3175099492073059,
-0.10978527367115021,
0.10852579027414322,
-0.1586184799671173,
-0.08956863731145859,
0.7326459288597107,
-0.7134096622467041,
0.46621423959732056,
0.2589755356311798,
0.7238823175430298,
0.29328984022140503,
0.06345664709806442,
0.2743973731994629,
-0.6199655532836914,
0.06036243587732315,
0.5290094017982483,
-0.004490494728088379,
0.17276735603809357,
-0.32449084520339966,
0.7312915921211243,
0.29950085282325745,
-0.5772090554237366,
-1.2042421102523804,
-0.076065294444561,
-0.9966704249382019,
-0.5733936429023743,
1.3177204132080078,
-0.3048481345176697,
-0.3912627696990967,
-0.5293473601341248,
-0.044890835881233215,
0.21743808686733246,
-0.4741790294647217,
0.85152667760849,
0.8617594242095947,
-0.29448217153549194,
0.08600974828004837,
-0.859613299369812,
0.3689829707145691,
0.5513989329338074,
-0.2326994091272354,
-0.12646906077861786,
0.4825669527053833,
0.10240533947944641,
0.44276538491249084,
0.5063108205795288,
-0.05213974043726921,
0.22131787240505219,
0.12113873660564423,
-0.06346780061721802,
-0.005044376943260431,
-0.6231544017791748,
-0.2828793227672577,
0.4799443185329437,
0.3849051296710968,
-0.3633876144886017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15740v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15740v1
|
Ghost Sentence: A Tool for Everyday Users to Copyright Data from Large Language Models
| 2024-03-23T06:36:32 | 2024-03-23T06:36:32 |
Shuai Zhao, Linchao Zhu, Ruijie Quan, Yi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Web user data plays a central role in the ecosystem of pre-trained large
language models (LLMs) and their fine-tuned variants. Billions of data are
crawled from the web and fed to LLMs. How can \textit{\textbf{everyday web
users}} confirm if LLMs misuse their data without permission? In this work, we
suggest that users repeatedly insert personal passphrases into their documents,
enabling LLMs to memorize them. These concealed passphrases in user documents,
referred to as \textit{ghost sentences}, once they are identified in the
generated content of LLMs, users can be sure that their data is used for
training. To explore the effectiveness and usage of this copyrighting tool, we
define the \textit{user training data identification} task with ghost
sentences. Multiple datasets from various sources at different scales are
created and tested with LLMs of different sizes. For evaluation, we introduce a
last $k$ words verification manner along with two metrics: document and user
identification accuracy. In the specific case of instruction tuning of a 3B
LLaMA model, 11 out of 16 users with ghost sentences identify their data within
the generation content. These 16 users contribute 383 examples to $\sim$1.8M
training documents. For continuing pre-training of a 1.1B TinyLlama model, 61
out of 64 users with ghost sentences identify their data within the LLM output.
These 64 users contribute 1156 examples to $\sim$10M training documents.
|
[
-0.1393546313047409,
-0.6340762972831726,
0.7292874455451965,
0.17978321015834808,
-0.37670382857322693,
0.05020853877067566,
-0.20523719489574432,
-0.4435652792453766,
0.11209508776664734,
1.0000423192977905,
-0.37143266201019287,
-0.5662072896957397,
-0.47713810205459595,
0.3047429323196411,
-0.8525070548057556,
0.9875909090042114,
-0.04108397290110588,
0.23579084873199463,
-0.28316009044647217,
0.10773046314716339,
-0.33422014117240906,
-0.7462624907493591,
-0.4811883866786957,
0.1271393597126007,
0.5904503464698792,
0.6019360423088074,
0.5495882034301758,
0.886155903339386,
0.04861028119921684,
0.21297849714756012,
0.274095356464386,
-0.0712536945939064,
-0.632371723651886,
0.09204161167144775,
-0.19565945863723755,
-0.5593342781066895,
-0.2408667355775833,
0.12271641939878464,
0.5261048674583435,
0.48785045742988586,
0.0329662449657917,
0.22664645314216614,
0.162586510181427,
0.43899089097976685,
-0.6112106442451477,
-0.14535780251026154,
-0.7621107697486877,
-0.12563587725162506,
-0.4640549421310425,
-0.44725340604782104,
-0.33101147413253784,
-0.7816470265388489,
-0.15923874080181122,
-0.4215780198574066,
0.36718934774398804,
0.22853830456733704,
0.8618514537811279,
0.1977064460515976,
-0.27821317315101624,
-0.42175522446632385,
-0.25744614005088806,
0.6212515234947205,
-0.8083804249763489,
0.2641388177871704,
0.7785252928733826,
0.12008976191282272,
-0.26359784603118896,
-0.7856910228729248,
-0.9902130365371704,
-0.27741286158561707,
-0.07582613080739975,
-0.03531070426106453,
0.017304638400673866,
-0.048281267285346985,
0.3480013906955719,
0.38747093081474304,
-0.6151218414306641,
0.2414148449897766,
-0.3734155595302582,
-0.4100241959095001,
0.5424696803092957,
0.24822968244552612,
0.347417950630188,
-0.2967240512371063,
-0.3414132297039032,
-0.0426071397960186,
-0.8108083605766296,
-0.3702397644519806,
0.9238656163215637,
-0.0313129760324955,
0.06370703876018524,
0.8207570910453796,
-0.2127685546875,
0.6517848372459412,
-0.15090017020702362,
-0.16534239053726196,
0.1305164247751236,
-0.08957245200872421,
-0.056433018296957016,
0.051172807812690735,
0.6690290570259094,
0.568496823310852,
0.7810999751091003,
-0.3846534788608551,
-0.2954667806625366,
-0.08054956793785095,
0.17315012216567993,
-0.6784923672676086,
-0.24997881054878235,
0.007524271961301565,
-0.5141631960868835,
-0.2762729823589325,
0.17817430198192596,
-0.8157166838645935,
-0.6659459471702576,
-0.43212026357650757,
0.4588916599750519,
-0.4623880982398987,
0.15189582109451294,
0.06645209342241287,
-0.2756885886192322,
-0.07296956330537796,
0.07177595049142838,
-0.8768054842948914,
0.5094788074493408,
0.727194607257843,
0.7464229464530945,
-0.3317878842353821,
-0.7271724343299866,
-0.6337746381759644,
0.29460811614990234,
-0.16116070747375488,
0.6357437372207642,
-0.36187776923179626,
-0.294170081615448,
0.07362611591815948,
0.17764177918434143,
-0.11967422068119049,
-0.4670960307121277,
0.47648629546165466,
-0.5750880241394043,
0.4387311041355133,
-0.11605148762464523,
-0.7858996987342834,
0.006957039702683687,
0.0232671070843935,
-0.5426587462425232,
0.9190302491188049,
0.11071531474590302,
-0.6044198274612427,
0.3851282596588135,
-0.3048458397388458,
-0.4652494788169861,
0.2875058352947235,
-0.08810589462518692,
-0.31572744250297546,
0.30735692381858826,
0.03901910036802292,
0.8314577341079712,
0.1340230256319046,
-0.11429259181022644,
-0.26475292444229126,
-0.5470826625823975,
0.5634467005729675,
-0.413938045501709,
0.7015676498413086,
0.2940322458744049,
-0.16204805672168732,
-0.24137921631336212,
-0.8425559401512146,
-0.01857716403901577,
0.3052011728286743,
-0.44335225224494934,
-0.5671995282173157,
-0.13910190761089325,
0.45310837030410767,
0.007369967643171549,
0.40206384658813477,
-0.43853092193603516,
0.29558050632476807,
-0.11875301599502563,
0.4066790044307709,
0.8232597708702087,
0.3666977882385254,
0.13201503455638885,
-0.4516400396823883,
0.6440830230712891,
-0.43228939175605774,
0.016219759359955788,
-0.4691517949104309,
-0.3374843895435333,
-0.7074671387672424,
-0.32132649421691895,
0.424344539642334,
0.5451367497444153,
-0.4391985833644867,
0.7619474530220032,
-0.4143389165401459,
-0.17552395164966583,
-0.512999951839447,
0.5301737189292908,
0.3405013382434845,
0.3435402512550354,
0.35682010650634766,
-0.1025950163602829,
-0.5376036167144775,
-0.9396893382072449,
-0.375395804643631,
0.13276095688343048,
-0.4011159837245941,
0.26390573382377625,
0.6364477872848511,
-0.11262321472167969,
0.9952521324157715,
-0.44630616903305054,
-0.5556918382644653,
-0.27284589409828186,
0.14892740547657013,
-0.28453949093818665,
0.40781939029693604,
0.4138686954975128,
-0.6496313810348511,
-0.4908798038959503,
-0.49297818541526794,
-0.7527301907539368,
-0.3997490704059601,
-0.5295222401618958,
0.09564202278852463,
0.3621671795845032,
0.5490694046020508,
-0.4671333134174347,
0.33804336190223694,
0.6003938913345337,
-0.3657774329185486,
0.3962225019931793,
-0.28002193570137024,
-0.011998805217444897,
-1.2201931476593018,
0.020674606785178185,
-0.21484319865703583,
-0.5338826179504395,
-0.13873066008090973,
0.2673662304878235,
0.19016815721988678,
-0.04327891394495964,
-0.36424756050109863,
0.544313371181488,
-0.7894791960716248,
-0.0965268462896347,
-0.32722657918930054,
0.26283183693885803,
-0.36687615513801575,
0.4065704345703125,
-0.11204596608877182,
0.9337337613105774,
0.3486768901348114,
-0.5493384599685669,
0.20764262974262238,
0.1927480548620224,
-0.4439984858036041,
0.6273384690284729,
-0.49036622047424316,
0.6196021437644958,
0.2050875425338745,
0.2807025909423828,
-0.8240108489990234,
-0.5669722557067871,
0.21880221366882324,
-0.30297020077705383,
-0.0652213841676712,
-0.1661733090877533,
-1.1774927377700806,
-0.11393167823553085,
-0.30828744173049927,
-0.2202616035938263,
0.6745312213897705,
-0.580181360244751,
0.4671685993671417,
0.43841949105262756,
0.08307189494371414,
-0.3426894545555115,
-0.7727437019348145,
0.639431357383728,
-0.43439432978630066,
-0.520573616027832,
0.16675043106079102,
-0.1797662228345871,
-0.06281539052724838,
0.06477992236614227,
-0.0209308210760355,
-0.10553185641765594,
0.29524245858192444,
0.5075823068618774,
0.07205405831336975,
0.04775771498680115,
-0.10729434341192245,
0.14204275608062744,
-0.05887632444500923,
-0.13872234523296356,
-0.32246798276901245,
0.6347634196281433,
0.17411097884178162,
-0.2750099003314972,
-0.4696446657180786,
0.18237410485744476,
0.3675120770931244,
0.2759891152381897,
0.685989499092102,
0.3846382796764374,
-0.37437930703163147,
-0.45827218890190125,
-0.9653413891792297,
-0.2049303650856018,
-0.4578883945941925,
0.01787334680557251,
-0.1896919161081314,
-0.8016679286956787,
0.3726927638053894,
0.13913896679878235,
-0.12414033710956573,
0.10332854092121124,
0.5234279036521912,
-0.049022454768419266,
0.6663298010826111,
0.7238360047340393,
-0.23580990731716156,
0.42052915692329407,
0.15780426561832428,
-0.20928263664245605,
-0.6863230466842651,
-0.15552231669425964,
-0.4110866189002991,
-0.36266884207725525,
-0.14886431396007538,
-0.2129053771495819,
0.027993865311145782,
0.3505330979824066,
0.3892329931259155,
0.6807689070701599,
-0.4216383099555969,
0.8919477462768555,
0.6080862283706665,
0.10668690502643585,
0.5304505825042725,
0.0598636232316494,
-0.05204077810049057,
-0.12385384738445282,
-0.1535646617412567,
-1.0412274599075317,
1.3169010877609253,
0.17808566987514496,
0.8824282884597778,
-0.1903255581855774,
0.9760133028030396,
0.6667723059654236,
0.00039570016087964177,
-0.7497579455375671,
0.8778403401374817,
0.06103476509451866,
-0.5409908294677734,
-0.12833675742149353,
-0.36472228169441223,
-0.9574236869812012,
-0.19057348370552063,
-0.06994497776031494,
-0.9207451343536377,
-0.2568039298057556,
0.207779660820961,
-0.16501957178115845,
-0.010388641618192196,
-0.9416550993919373,
0.8242948651313782,
-0.40368059277534485,
-0.38891586661338806,
-0.1311073750257492,
-0.6317228078842163,
0.22948166728019714,
-0.4681517481803894,
0.06275106221437454,
0.04231260344386101,
-0.29389336705207825,
0.8974931240081787,
-0.42070695757865906,
0.8551129102706909,
-0.046166419982910156,
0.03750018775463104,
0.0028414495754987,
0.1789950579404831,
0.5358572006225586,
0.08041543513536453,
0.0662485733628273,
0.16522039473056793,
0.034895945340394974,
-0.1989932656288147,
-0.4694439172744751,
0.8566945195198059,
-0.45078524947166443,
-0.5246781706809998,
-0.3361312747001648,
-0.25918349623680115,
-0.06380017846822739,
0.5366515517234802,
0.4561586081981659,
0.04323145002126694,
-0.15892748534679413,
0.4290829300880432,
0.6333904266357422,
0.012467958964407444,
0.43379831314086914,
0.676749050617218,
-0.14866851270198822,
-0.2469479888677597,
0.9500840902328491,
0.11186696588993073,
0.08326245099306107,
0.31829315423965454,
0.21860918402671814,
-0.1849403828382492,
-0.8306754231452942,
-0.4940824508666992,
0.24518068134784698,
-0.7585839629173279,
-0.04514547064900398,
-0.9359586834907532,
-0.07157626003026962,
-0.2506122589111328,
-0.26426440477371216,
0.09597589075565338,
-0.6444344520568848,
-0.38854724168777466,
-0.07807314395904541,
0.47665202617645264,
0.7036774158477783,
0.0056897057220339775,
0.4841326177120209,
-0.8326357007026672,
0.4999176859855652,
0.2462175190448761,
0.16447122395038605,
-0.11412622034549713,
-0.5856300592422485,
-0.28723642230033875,
-0.07765042781829834,
-0.14740891754627228,
-1.0775985717773438,
0.38590916991233826,
0.15118442475795746,
0.6705197095870972,
0.22218309342861176,
-0.07136592268943787,
0.5456113815307617,
-0.5391390919685364,
1.0485364198684692,
-0.19073788821697235,
-1.1174219846725464,
0.3250194787979126,
-0.20785407721996307,
-0.028401190415024757,
0.8021348714828491,
0.3528103530406952,
-0.6264777779579163,
-0.669240415096283,
-0.5407609343528748,
-0.6921895742416382,
0.6421958208084106,
0.23157262802124023,
0.5177533030509949,
0.15013030171394348,
0.5800765752792358,
0.2652476727962494,
0.313642680644989,
-0.666973352432251,
-0.14734987914562225,
-0.20758399367332458,
-0.6012688279151917,
-0.006668972782790661,
-0.29930469393730164,
-0.06477487832307816,
0.12178825587034225,
0.4402483403682709,
-0.17541296780109406,
-0.021430570632219315,
-0.024065764620900154,
-0.4384649693965912,
0.045453958213329315,
0.16500301659107208,
0.48390424251556396,
0.6704015135765076,
-0.09574192762374878,
0.1659279316663742,
0.24625208973884583,
-0.8141377568244934,
-0.10280916094779968,
0.091459721326828,
-0.10031935572624207,
-0.09246591478586197,
0.37643471360206604,
0.2892315089702606,
0.2865174412727356,
-0.8440280556678772,
0.7190060019493103,
-0.1090676560997963,
-0.18322470784187317,
-0.647451639175415,
0.2749406397342682,
0.06533073633909225,
0.019683651626110077,
0.6330323815345764,
-0.01728326454758644,
0.07809600234031677,
-0.4203500747680664,
0.36661455035209656,
0.25831130146980286,
-0.04547518864274025,
-0.41866108775138855,
0.836237907409668,
-0.18531876802444458,
-0.46239379048347473,
0.5611387491226196,
-0.009158414788544178,
-0.6564339995384216,
0.22645103931427002,
0.3747951090335846,
1.0641865730285645,
0.030829356983304024,
-0.10222233086824417,
-0.05388679355382919,
0.29889586567878723,
-0.40363427996635437,
0.14493173360824585,
-0.11520212143659592,
-0.5614305734634399,
-0.07906852662563324,
-0.5493069291114807,
-0.396914005279541,
0.4904569685459137,
-0.4444672465324402,
0.5639552474021912,
-0.6222444176673889,
0.19724588096141815,
0.028674950823187828,
-0.13901478052139282,
-0.6903891563415527,
0.041950523853302,
0.19945241510868073,
0.5914172530174255,
-0.7366131544113159,
0.9741291999816895,
0.42333507537841797,
-0.7074015140533447,
-0.6092186570167542,
0.41428622603416443,
0.12117720395326614,
-0.9041071534156799,
0.5859545469284058,
0.07699207216501236,
-0.08537209033966064,
0.13978226482868195,
-1.02714204788208,
-0.4326896667480469,
0.8820885419845581,
0.5256545543670654,
-0.42288699746131897,
-0.1345413327217102,
0.14745943248271942,
0.6903008818626404,
-0.4039091169834137,
-0.12120459228754044,
0.40539127588272095,
0.3300664722919464,
-0.032823871821165085,
-0.673475980758667,
0.29359859228134155,
-0.018007181584835052,
-0.22157792747020721,
-0.26520323753356934,
-0.485177606344223,
0.7612598538398743,
0.055767253041267395,
-0.3564166724681854,
0.2799322009086609,
0.4274875819683075,
0.23610016703605652,
0.17109759151935577,
0.5417714715003967,
0.3836994469165802,
0.7208076119422913,
0.14915740489959717,
1.0383386611938477,
-0.34365659952163696,
0.1239733174443245,
1.2271318435668945,
-0.31342291831970215,
0.8768628835678101,
0.4539700150489807,
0.1853848248720169,
0.5117179751396179,
0.4463376998901367,
-0.5424134731292725,
0.4054025709629059,
0.38588860630989075,
-0.0005271492409519851,
-0.2557486295700073,
0.06563454121351242,
-0.3018161952495575,
0.23566359281539917,
0.07337631285190582,
-0.5302074551582336,
0.09097637981176376,
0.10090448707342148,
0.49517014622688293,
0.3296873867511749,
0.14299823343753815,
0.7942214608192444,
0.17673836648464203,
-0.505284309387207,
0.5099276900291443,
0.03745168820023537,
0.6971568465232849,
-0.6677098274230957,
-0.08607956022024155,
-0.36295193433761597,
0.319817453622818,
-0.47000595927238464,
-0.7695464491844177,
0.08628307282924652,
0.3956601321697235,
0.009380711242556572,
-0.43422478437423706,
0.5367388129234314,
-0.3275907635688782,
-0.290810763835907,
-0.015782039612531662,
0.31364941596984863,
0.5688849687576294,
-0.18904224038124084,
-0.515336811542511,
0.15443666279315948,
0.014715704135596752,
-0.294473797082901,
0.47473078966140747,
0.3914850056171417,
0.02395160309970379,
0.6777069568634033,
0.7375232577323914,
0.3302854597568512,
0.17989183962345123,
-0.00372875458560884,
0.7745986580848694,
-0.6745243072509766,
-0.6894084215164185,
-0.9575556516647339,
0.2786031663417816,
-0.3791826665401459,
-0.4623525142669678,
1.4983106851577759,
1.027032494544983,
0.9902981519699097,
-0.2262226641178131,
1.0132488012313843,
0.1496305912733078,
0.6601528525352478,
-0.9501281976699829,
0.8957506418228149,
-0.6316616535186768,
0.3479577600955963,
-0.2996708154678345,
-1.0806972980499268,
-0.09964355826377869,
0.44060441851615906,
-0.01584654487669468,
-0.05707757547497749,
0.8521834015846252,
0.7937823534011841,
-0.29846006631851196,
0.027296755462884903,
0.22914768755435944,
-0.09754770249128342,
0.28748708963394165,
0.311969518661499,
0.9730512499809265,
-0.3450160026550293,
0.7064303755760193,
-0.20827139914035797,
0.08155784755945206,
-0.2484034299850464,
-0.8657484650611877,
-1.326892375946045,
-0.6065197587013245,
-0.3276711106300354,
-0.3949055075645447,
-0.006109283771365881,
1.0866918563842773,
0.7321549654006958,
-0.7897173166275024,
-0.26635727286338806,
-0.14482925832271576,
0.06455375254154205,
-0.11739588528871536,
-0.2650108337402344,
0.28582727909088135,
-0.1384432464838028,
-0.8803486824035645,
0.5892776250839233,
-0.15361787378787994,
0.3392152786254883,
-0.4686529338359833,
0.07485363632440567,
0.06307954341173172,
0.09702959656715393,
0.11068125814199448,
0.25496670603752136,
-0.7395539879798889,
-0.2078109234571457,
-0.10892022401094437,
-0.39590132236480713,
-0.3472083508968353,
1.0352863073349,
-0.660163402557373,
0.43864133954048157,
0.370471715927124,
0.6505552530288696,
0.6487272381782532,
0.2365260124206543,
0.5701992511749268,
-0.8357193470001221,
-0.008435901254415512,
0.1256314516067505,
0.29936954379081726,
0.5784170031547546,
-0.6166995167732239,
0.6010093092918396,
0.5101349353790283,
-0.5805869698524475,
-0.963093101978302,
-0.19235490262508392,
-0.9355788826942444,
-0.3280344307422638,
1.39930260181427,
-0.2487751543521881,
-0.04449132829904556,
-0.34448838233947754,
-0.333924800157547,
0.0947260931134224,
-0.5796120166778564,
0.9353185296058655,
0.8016384840011597,
0.4093700647354126,
-0.15562760829925537,
-0.8014355301856995,
0.5968488454818726,
0.06454756110906601,
-0.8754352331161499,
0.2313571572303772,
0.7459791302680969,
0.6623026728630066,
-0.028760051354765892,
0.5498689413070679,
0.09191140532493591,
0.02047141268849373,
0.00235988711938262,
-0.039364293217659,
-0.5954862236976624,
-0.22912292182445526,
-0.48817214369773865,
0.3009002208709717,
-0.26343002915382385,
-0.28173574805259705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15737v1
|
Few-shot Dialogue Strategy Learning for Motivational Interviewing via Inductive Reasoning
| 2024-03-23T06:03:37 | 2024-03-23T06:03:37 |
Zhouhang Xie, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Mengjie Zhao, Yoshinori Maeda, Keiichi Yamada, Hiromi Wakaki, Julian McAuley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We consider the task of building a dialogue system that can motivate users to
adopt positive lifestyle changes: Motivational Interviewing. Addressing such a
task requires a system that can infer \textit{how} to motivate a user
effectively. We propose DIIT, a framework that is capable of learning and
applying conversation strategies in the form of natural language inductive
rules from expert demonstrations. Automatic and human evaluation on
instruction-following large language models show natural language strategy
descriptions discovered by DIIR can improve active listening skills, reduce
unsolicited advice, and promote more collaborative and less authoritative
responses, outperforming various demonstration utilization methods.
|
[
-0.2654225528240204,
-0.8165569305419922,
0.5621696710586548,
0.06541509926319122,
-0.0697636604309082,
0.15200082957744598,
-0.11030708998441696,
-0.0043946122750639915,
0.22553616762161255,
0.120196633040905,
-0.976398766040802,
-0.4650873839855194,
-0.3494935631752014,
0.20696082711219788,
-0.1936260610818863,
0.7399469614028931,
0.22500832378864288,
0.4022589921951294,
-0.17800675332546234,
-0.04396592080593109,
-0.7318868637084961,
-0.17312254011631012,
-0.6783179640769958,
-0.5182173252105713,
0.3725748658180237,
1.0390290021896362,
0.2786252498626709,
0.07611776888370514,
0.6001418232917786,
0.2889547348022461,
0.09346741437911987,
-0.0047645410522818565,
-0.7556441426277161,
0.2810255289077759,
-0.16765497624874115,
-0.61480712890625,
0.3792802095413208,
0.19834116101264954,
0.22959600389003754,
0.6067890524864197,
-0.46061357855796814,
-0.0009779141983017325,
0.11141074448823929,
0.4247106909751892,
-0.5448523163795471,
0.10311196744441986,
-0.5928637385368347,
-0.05450109764933586,
0.013222326524555683,
-0.6186350584030151,
-0.43083155155181885,
-0.3295014500617981,
0.2525259554386139,
-0.5372257828712463,
0.06870027631521225,
-0.1790468990802765,
0.5281950831413269,
0.3899463713169098,
-0.4179755449295044,
-0.47693535685539246,
-1.1429381370544434,
0.7419346570968628,
-0.6822711229324341,
0.09119586646556854,
0.6003319621086121,
0.4535072445869446,
-0.3668871521949768,
-0.27456429600715637,
-0.5170084238052368,
-0.2581857144832611,
-0.14394593238830566,
0.205306276679039,
-0.19429229199886322,
0.3049004375934601,
0.33502334356307983,
0.20234587788581848,
-0.29146498441696167,
-0.04184780642390251,
-0.34728214144706726,
0.13114985823631287,
0.6499102115631104,
0.20637403428554535,
0.11480928212404251,
-0.13796234130859375,
-0.29007643461227417,
-0.06059141084551811,
-0.6353335380554199,
0.11158568412065506,
0.28001901507377625,
0.19320392608642578,
-0.08706749230623245,
0.5831091403961182,
-0.5957022905349731,
0.5787889361381531,
0.5376562476158142,
-0.7672660946846008,
-0.08792667090892792,
-0.4625980854034424,
-0.10133431106805801,
0.516656756401062,
0.48293694853782654,
0.5236579775810242,
-0.1894019991159439,
-0.10091543942689896,
-0.14148686826229095,
0.1070592924952507,
0.13285045325756073,
-0.9594088792800903,
-0.12284339219331741,
0.13557866215705872,
-0.4637563228607178,
-0.2981274425983429,
-0.0959569588303566,
-0.8598496317863464,
-0.4640938639640808,
-0.43040236830711365,
0.7405402660369873,
-0.6486596465110779,
-0.19832418859004974,
0.2718808054924011,
-0.5023526549339294,
0.47385263442993164,
0.4509543180465698,
-1.1467037200927734,
0.457134872674942,
0.4796799421310425,
0.8088632822036743,
0.09769270569086075,
0.03516482189297676,
-0.6345425248146057,
0.010409328155219555,
-0.34946587681770325,
0.7684571146965027,
-0.5541071891784668,
-0.655349850654602,
0.1534644365310669,
-0.2509153485298157,
0.02796989120543003,
-0.5499047636985779,
0.5293921232223511,
-0.1023264154791832,
0.45970040559768677,
-0.41340669989585876,
-0.6115792393684387,
-0.1990838199853897,
0.4920293390750885,
-0.33419519662857056,
0.7486142516136169,
0.2976665198802948,
-0.5658952593803406,
0.566564679145813,
-1.1756532192230225,
-0.6826898455619812,
0.3499535918235779,
-0.3005335032939911,
0.018103452399373055,
-0.06295514851808548,
0.06056399643421173,
0.344134658575058,
-0.3418017029762268,
-0.04223953187465668,
0.1029461994767189,
-0.39546850323677063,
0.2380376160144806,
-0.4081420302391052,
0.9182336926460266,
0.3852871060371399,
-0.664948046207428,
-0.0044547938741743565,
-0.5358524918556213,
-0.10428740084171295,
0.1448269784450531,
-0.42151063680648804,
-0.40178394317626953,
0.019241513684391975,
-0.44610217213630676,
0.028122389689087868,
-0.3593967854976654,
-0.5558233857154846,
0.22261232137680054,
-0.5279276371002197,
0.4430581033229828,
0.4137777090072632,
0.5472835302352905,
0.475475937128067,
-0.5516841411590576,
0.7180586457252502,
-0.22457657754421234,
0.1550801396369934,
-0.3732723891735077,
-0.25939586758613586,
-0.8299173712730408,
-0.27672120928764343,
-0.13101539015769958,
0.7459601163864136,
-0.8685164451599121,
0.20974455773830414,
-0.10911098122596741,
-0.404863178730011,
-0.4007856547832489,
0.46215108036994934,
0.2573312819004059,
0.6418437957763672,
0.24196967482566833,
-0.1500910222530365,
-0.515271782875061,
-0.6667293310165405,
0.11804068833589554,
-0.30888086557388306,
0.0989864245057106,
-0.017487289384007454,
0.5142773985862732,
-0.01638822816312313,
0.8824120759963989,
-0.3006063997745514,
-0.2744506597518921,
-0.8346438407897949,
0.6506980657577515,
0.1937408149242401,
0.31642746925354004,
0.5067534446716309,
-0.7204402685165405,
-0.8192716240882874,
-0.2153678685426712,
-0.6540456414222717,
0.10696729272603989,
-0.597895622253418,
-0.17775766551494598,
-0.3021182417869568,
0.5863451361656189,
-0.7273383140563965,
0.653264582157135,
0.038362111896276474,
0.03695826232433319,
0.388184130191803,
0.2828964591026306,
0.4269486963748932,
-0.863872766494751,
-0.5134889483451843,
0.3915881812572479,
-0.17587655782699585,
-0.6518853902816772,
-0.3234424889087677,
-0.5827271938323975,
-0.07001761347055435,
-0.6625052094459534,
0.3074676990509033,
-0.23962333798408508,
0.42632725834846497,
-0.28159478306770325,
-0.18317453563213348,
0.07313689589500427,
0.5479497313499451,
0.16950468719005585,
0.7584556341171265,
0.6250767111778259,
-1.0295895338058472,
0.537882924079895,
0.7320172786712646,
-0.6693333983421326,
1.0878385305404663,
-0.732001781463623,
0.14730750024318695,
-0.32097411155700684,
0.27429062128067017,
-1.3013006448745728,
-0.37451890110969543,
0.2103787660598755,
-0.36883947253227234,
0.24204732477664948,
-0.3419121205806732,
-0.27128297090530396,
-0.21109053492546082,
-0.21786954998970032,
-0.029098404571413994,
0.49145185947418213,
-0.575573742389679,
0.364406943321228,
0.06298153102397919,
-0.17244116961956024,
-0.33544695377349854,
-0.4537760615348816,
0.022862879559397697,
-0.6072958111763,
-0.35233598947525024,
0.4670619070529938,
-0.263988733291626,
-0.6513711214065552,
-0.4086392819881439,
-0.08748044818639755,
0.01886429823935032,
0.3235129415988922,
0.20652569830417633,
0.2143927365541458,
-0.12895353138446808,
0.2983757257461548,
-0.11684469133615494,
-0.10665600746870041,
0.1164214238524437,
0.07496146857738495,
0.6421636343002319,
0.052577536553144455,
-0.43755969405174255,
-1.0072616338729858,
0.6365732550621033,
0.3318878412246704,
0.11477622389793396,
0.7005776166915894,
0.6182144284248352,
-0.21817705035209656,
0.15786203742027283,
-0.6100612878799438,
-0.7905973196029663,
-0.45229268074035645,
0.14424897730350494,
-0.2714315950870514,
-0.5228400230407715,
-0.016974210739135742,
-0.5905740857124329,
0.03099428117275238,
0.21480000019073486,
0.6841549873352051,
-0.30963531136512756,
1.1444181203842163,
0.5674864649772644,
-0.03264996409416199,
0.7134647965431213,
-0.2858993113040924,
0.16232158243656158,
-0.19168412685394287,
-0.17455226182937622,
-0.4269631803035736,
-0.4851084053516388,
-0.1776784062385559,
-0.057612452656030655,
0.30611786246299744,
0.1302565187215805,
-0.2877148389816284,
0.3054659962654114,
-0.5962353944778442,
0.643671452999115,
0.9653534293174744,
0.10484693199396133,
0.19299690425395966,
-0.13508567214012146,
-0.05272124335169792,
-0.12641340494155884,
-0.6533128023147583,
-0.5657341480255127,
0.6217662692070007,
0.2800729274749756,
1.2397726774215698,
0.4547434151172638,
1.1834502220153809,
0.29023870825767517,
0.23311002552509308,
-1.3622807264328003,
0.5508396625518799,
0.5562204718589783,
-0.7151563167572021,
-0.4427875876426697,
-0.1591305285692215,
-0.765699028968811,
-0.34812596440315247,
-0.3223157227039337,
-0.8193773031234741,
0.2477591335773468,
0.025589508935809135,
-0.6641968488693237,
-0.1395978033542633,
-1.0865569114685059,
0.7691624760627747,
-0.5004739165306091,
-0.3685317635536194,
-0.3163841664791107,
-0.6833871603012085,
0.08492694050073624,
0.43494728207588196,
-0.2172294408082962,
-0.10856473445892334,
0.5395979285240173,
0.7580699920654297,
-0.4424385726451874,
1.2052826881408691,
-0.42980456352233887,
0.26328256726264954,
0.6973453760147095,
0.2676929831504822,
0.4289127588272095,
0.16094551980495453,
-0.004671736154705286,
-0.3334994912147522,
0.14072422683238983,
-0.10887414962053299,
-0.8264163136482239,
0.2176700085401535,
-0.39109718799591064,
-0.7629575133323669,
-0.1940561980009079,
0.0022823887411504984,
-0.23450659215450287,
0.015881288796663284,
0.5313324332237244,
0.31749826669692993,
-0.7459296584129333,
0.41126665472984314,
0.844785213470459,
-0.018167909234762192,
0.37865376472473145,
0.46667787432670593,
0.21415996551513672,
0.04208928719162941,
0.6724027991294861,
-0.2293546497821808,
0.5518072247505188,
0.7615957856178284,
0.5077130198478699,
-0.4543807804584503,
-0.41903167963027954,
-0.30252593755722046,
-0.016608145087957382,
-0.8437581658363342,
-0.3711276352405548,
-0.2786470949649811,
0.017442375421524048,
-0.4637288451194763,
-0.14355863630771637,
-0.11528337746858597,
-0.3520073890686035,
-0.19534029066562653,
-0.43565618991851807,
0.5815452933311462,
0.7348687052726746,
-0.16012756526470184,
0.632159411907196,
-0.5411998629570007,
0.18990305066108704,
0.7435764074325562,
-0.13675159215927124,
-0.30067047476768494,
-0.32434535026550293,
-0.19056850671768188,
0.23827539384365082,
-0.6755809783935547,
-1.065602421760559,
0.30069947242736816,
0.2161233127117157,
0.9513038992881775,
0.6413476467132568,
0.37033888697624207,
0.5161643028259277,
-0.13740305602550507,
0.6991472840309143,
0.5267375707626343,
-0.8098801374435425,
0.9657900929450989,
-0.18839086592197418,
0.2675057351589203,
1.1842857599258423,
0.8325154781341553,
-0.5741252899169922,
0.1260141134262085,
-0.27810245752334595,
-0.31780269742012024,
0.5919440984725952,
-0.044403690844774246,
0.347566694021225,
-0.29384005069732666,
0.10028868913650513,
0.21469815075397491,
0.20576733350753784,
-0.666841983795166,
-0.13733279705047607,
-0.5193560719490051,
-0.30413100123405457,
0.3737999200820923,
-0.22164691984653473,
-0.8223953247070312,
-0.5987774729728699,
0.6723446249961853,
-0.4267162084579468,
0.455310195684433,
0.3334432542324066,
-0.05081713944673538,
0.079319067299366,
0.7398964166641235,
0.5356873273849487,
0.5491207838058472,
-0.3620166778564453,
-0.08956023305654526,
0.18841740489006042,
-0.0502849780023098,
0.42878496646881104,
-0.20033439993858337,
-0.049862153828144073,
0.10231665521860123,
0.031414326280355453,
0.9698953032493591,
0.21098658442497253,
-0.6496019959449768,
0.7555733919143677,
-0.11736015975475311,
-0.6238114237785339,
-0.3861216604709625,
0.2952575087547302,
-0.008439644239842892,
0.17215578258037567,
0.4326196312904358,
-0.3009282946586609,
0.3916313946247101,
-0.8400392532348633,
0.17989008128643036,
0.5934263467788696,
-0.6556941270828247,
-0.049114830791950226,
0.41168317198753357,
0.6404749155044556,
-0.6674667596817017,
0.5469412207603455,
-0.5745909810066223,
-0.48481231927871704,
0.06930608302354813,
0.5844659209251404,
0.7827247381210327,
-0.17455586791038513,
0.7243371605873108,
0.5263697504997253,
0.05146113410592079,
-0.27939966320991516,
-0.059535302221775055,
-0.4277555048465729,
-0.853791356086731,
-0.33122262358665466,
-0.17927198112010956,
-0.681574285030365,
0.12292644381523132,
-0.6084409356117249,
0.48027193546295166,
-0.5404203534126282,
0.00964111927896738,
0.2799643874168396,
-0.14372244477272034,
-0.7362381815910339,
-0.1395808607339859,
0.1489243358373642,
0.7868443131446838,
-0.7069001197814941,
0.40196099877357483,
0.4320642948150635,
-0.9450588226318359,
-0.7724415063858032,
-0.032042983919382095,
0.4737429916858673,
-0.6571661233901978,
0.9036038517951965,
0.2578791379928589,
-0.453545480966568,
-0.054667018353939056,
-0.8980244994163513,
-0.3912494480609894,
1.0703060626983643,
0.31811845302581787,
-0.5268905758857727,
-0.08976075053215027,
-0.12343068420886993,
0.2783329486846924,
-0.6032072901725769,
0.5054259300231934,
0.5740755796432495,
0.3210192322731018,
0.6392090916633606,
-0.8119806051254272,
-0.2914191782474518,
-0.23088355362415314,
-0.4430363178253174,
0.004750467836856842,
-0.493205189704895,
0.3673156499862671,
-0.5191798806190491,
-0.5555978417396545,
0.2134278118610382,
0.31237098574638367,
-0.16475844383239746,
0.3894847631454468,
0.7315202355384827,
0.23438148200511932,
0.714633047580719,
0.0030858037061989307,
1.0169012546539307,
-0.07495954632759094,
0.05512435361742973,
1.133000373840332,
-0.6628789901733398,
0.7067787051200867,
0.5748469829559326,
-0.08564469963312149,
0.9009891748428345,
0.4954080879688263,
0.28782007098197937,
0.8093966841697693,
0.0497668981552124,
-0.6813639998435974,
-0.4734666645526886,
-0.1907656043767929,
0.12864571809768677,
0.9830861687660217,
0.46953409910202026,
-0.22178836166858673,
-0.3177430331707001,
0.2417745143175125,
0.006169335916638374,
0.2541353106498718,
0.14676803350448608,
1.2405580282211304,
-0.1692083477973938,
-0.8329892158508301,
0.701512336730957,
-0.18726351857185364,
0.7278709411621094,
-0.6876001954078674,
-0.5596089363098145,
-0.0037123800721019506,
0.04111592099070549,
-0.1979406625032425,
-0.29739561676979065,
0.04030017554759979,
-0.24345093965530396,
-0.10550636053085327,
-0.4390503168106079,
0.5628324151039124,
-0.46839532256126404,
-0.35496786236763,
-0.06629450619220734,
0.5676589608192444,
0.14622381329536438,
0.02887515164911747,
-0.7787205576896667,
-0.480665922164917,
0.0882335752248764,
-0.006317957304418087,
0.3052375912666321,
0.3576546609401703,
0.3153018355369568,
0.588362455368042,
0.5560021996498108,
-0.36924585700035095,
-0.3368769586086273,
0.26995059847831726,
0.7558379769325256,
-0.703015923500061,
-0.3731701970100403,
-0.8442821502685547,
0.4466308355331421,
-0.34847909212112427,
-0.19415046274662018,
0.7655690908432007,
0.43314218521118164,
0.7572031617164612,
0.012146951630711555,
0.8382182121276855,
-0.14910714328289032,
0.926366925239563,
-0.5798120498657227,
0.2648612856864929,
-0.23984496295452118,
0.19057364761829376,
-0.18038184940814972,
-0.707629382610321,
0.03164992853999138,
1.1076463460922241,
-0.2530269920825958,
-0.17798076570034027,
0.8030677437782288,
1.053702712059021,
0.09562893211841583,
0.18381252884864807,
0.311937153339386,
-0.17535924911499023,
0.38601604104042053,
0.3647460341453552,
1.0942949056625366,
-0.08017174899578094,
0.6610299348831177,
-0.3516460657119751,
-0.4707416296005249,
-0.358882874250412,
-0.7801846265792847,
-0.9620533585548401,
-0.6350535154342651,
-0.6429787278175354,
-0.30295300483703613,
0.011958850547671318,
1.4187259674072266,
0.9029484987258911,
-0.44497573375701904,
-0.37528008222579956,
-0.2757638394832611,
0.1787976622581482,
-0.43942809104919434,
-0.30958735942840576,
-0.32346898317337036,
-0.4671790599822998,
-0.7164931893348694,
0.8072319030761719,
0.3382743299007416,
0.20005594193935394,
-0.49919143319129944,
-0.34931480884552,
-0.5704181790351868,
0.14138440787792206,
0.6231658458709717,
0.6050793528556824,
-0.5478644371032715,
-0.3404081165790558,
0.09113658964633942,
-0.05336218699812889,
0.2867574095726013,
1.0763672590255737,
-0.8083164691925049,
0.4848891794681549,
0.4134635627269745,
0.7385110259056091,
0.4902817904949188,
0.09240186214447021,
0.5352646708488464,
-0.6917614936828613,
0.13989026844501495,
0.4622156620025635,
0.20627780258655548,
0.4628720283508301,
-0.4657021462917328,
0.6505781412124634,
0.1706041395664215,
-0.49764686822891235,
-0.48330503702163696,
0.3514617085456848,
-1.046728491783142,
-0.019942456856369972,
1.439917802810669,
-0.005631889216601849,
-0.017435790970921516,
-0.5207647681236267,
-0.6068170666694641,
-0.11920617520809174,
-0.668601393699646,
0.7880783081054688,
0.796907901763916,
-0.5165331363677979,
-0.28983274102211,
-0.4000302255153656,
0.6370232105255127,
0.4194348156452179,
-0.7849412560462952,
-0.18936167657375336,
0.48914963006973267,
0.19958962500095367,
0.28038039803504944,
0.9993928074836731,
0.23434053361415863,
0.2826673090457916,
0.13165052235126495,
-0.18131859600543976,
0.34313055872917175,
-0.2992349863052368,
0.12832774221897125,
-0.2561091482639313,
0.48570793867111206,
-0.4641263782978058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15736v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15736v1
|
LLMs Instruct LLMs:An Extraction and Editing Method
| 2024-03-23T06:03:36 | 2024-03-23T06:03:36 |
Xin Zhang, Tianjie Ju, Huijia Liang, Ying Fu, Qin Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The interest in updating Large Language Models (LLMs) without retraining from
scratch is substantial, yet it comes with some challenges.This is especially
true for situations demanding complex reasoning with limited samples, a
scenario we refer to as the Paucity-Constrained Complex Reasoning Adaptation
for LLMs (PCRA-LLM).Traditional methods like Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) and
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) are inadequate for this critical issue,
particularly evident in our exploration of a specific medical context that
epitomize the PCRA-LLM's distinct needs.To address the issue, we propose a
Sequential Fusion method to incorporate knowledge from complex context into
LLMs. This method employs a two-stage framework: initially, it leverages
general LLMs to construct knowledge graphs (KGs) for extracting knowledge from
complex texts; subsequently, it updates the domain LLMs through knowledge edit.
According to our method, the domain LLM achieved a 71.69\% accuracy in question
answering tasks. Subsequently, we broadened our assessment to a novel dataset
we developed in the economics and management field, where our method realized a
75\% accuracy. These outcomes underline the efficacy and adaptability of our
approach for PCRA-LLM across various domains.
|
[
-0.03902130573987961,
-0.9005768895149231,
0.8616505861282349,
0.028486793860793114,
-0.2648521959781647,
0.4856385290622711,
-0.23135629296302795,
-0.3342495262622833,
-0.0822405144572258,
0.5599942207336426,
-0.49234816431999207,
-0.5073275566101074,
-0.4487079679965973,
0.0609690323472023,
-0.12037206441164017,
0.6877023577690125,
-0.20578931272029877,
0.330514132976532,
-0.3849732577800751,
0.04024491831660271,
-0.6636219024658203,
-0.4271988570690155,
-0.6121333241462708,
-0.45739197731018066,
0.2803868055343628,
0.6760952472686768,
0.3908887803554535,
0.45440447330474854,
0.3899822235107422,
0.3086280822753906,
-0.12077759206295013,
0.7266278266906738,
-0.4530276656150818,
0.16913911700248718,
-0.6461563110351562,
-0.5887519121170044,
-0.5569855570793152,
-0.15404987335205078,
0.7178696393966675,
0.9807561039924622,
-0.09133085608482361,
0.03907233849167824,
0.18561960756778717,
0.6334543824195862,
-0.5212841629981995,
-0.14146116375923157,
-0.7872520685195923,
-0.08353538811206818,
-0.00990927405655384,
-0.4550327658653259,
-0.5583378076553345,
-0.3271959125995636,
0.27718108892440796,
-0.6152432560920715,
-0.12720182538032532,
0.014918633736670017,
0.5484344959259033,
0.383655309677124,
-0.4589027464389801,
-0.2876627445220947,
-0.8161324858665466,
0.6264552474021912,
-0.5119743347167969,
0.06477900594472885,
0.15741653740406036,
0.5163156390190125,
-0.4742865562438965,
-0.9196866750717163,
-0.7382623553276062,
0.0993620976805687,
0.10725787281990051,
0.1900918185710907,
-0.000026683737814892083,
0.08072853088378906,
0.11735960841178894,
0.19274574518203735,
-0.2231757491827011,
0.34031012654304504,
-0.3731987178325653,
0.09193143248558044,
0.6274269223213196,
0.31033769249916077,
0.42558470368385315,
-0.19499270617961884,
-0.5179052948951721,
0.09474263340234756,
-0.9045448899269104,
-0.28314661979675293,
-0.11729975789785385,
0.2513304054737091,
0.0742393508553505,
0.8211538791656494,
-0.19304540753364563,
0.8758097887039185,
0.17303252220153809,
-0.5866824984550476,
0.17928943037986755,
-0.26802802085876465,
-0.4808483123779297,
0.12382107973098755,
0.5437370538711548,
0.081285260617733,
0.06953012198209763,
-0.11599321663379669,
-0.059904810041189194,
-0.07144186645746231,
0.15953432023525238,
-0.3829585313796997,
-0.058936841785907745,
0.3786246180534363,
-0.2635050415992737,
-0.1402953863143921,
-0.11217007786035538,
-0.7675127387046814,
-0.5960714221000671,
-0.484390527009964,
0.5919702649116516,
-0.4432790279388428,
0.18643967807292938,
0.2715507447719574,
-0.036685455590486526,
0.46515175700187683,
0.6956573128700256,
-0.5961458086967468,
0.22255414724349976,
0.7346179485321045,
0.6085739135742188,
-0.37154966592788696,
-0.21309228241443634,
-0.48749426007270813,
0.4803769886493683,
-0.02428368665277958,
1.0011926889419556,
-0.3400067090988159,
-0.31525787711143494,
-0.08198975771665573,
0.02407640404999256,
-0.2850400507450104,
-0.7546237707138062,
0.6274686455726624,
-0.49380427598953247,
0.4508192241191864,
-0.1790073961019516,
-0.8222975730895996,
-0.053587641566991806,
0.26749977469444275,
-0.20211531221866608,
0.8546417355537415,
0.22065384685993195,
-0.5961799621582031,
0.08014983683824539,
-0.6186009645462036,
-0.4438381791114807,
0.06582912057638168,
-0.2082422822713852,
-0.14227451384067535,
-0.13852249085903168,
0.3365336060523987,
0.4481579661369324,
-0.431639164686203,
0.3806179165840149,
-0.20340850949287415,
-0.26152342557907104,
0.2962322235107422,
-0.16973976790905,
0.7978879809379578,
0.0764862447977066,
-0.11305347830057144,
0.2760778069496155,
-0.8623537421226501,
-0.08425819873809814,
0.027555886656045914,
-0.6101611256599426,
-0.33598828315734863,
0.037293948233127594,
-0.37377339601516724,
0.27594369649887085,
0.2544277310371399,
-0.38935035467147827,
0.5773743391036987,
-0.4641932249069214,
0.34185126423835754,
0.9307248592376709,
0.35381442308425903,
0.5183640718460083,
-0.4695236384868622,
0.41457056999206543,
-0.033432487398386,
0.03359590470790863,
0.1266038715839386,
-0.33312010765075684,
-0.983714759349823,
-0.33990058302879333,
0.3834761083126068,
1.031018614768982,
-1.0715372562408447,
0.5999030470848083,
-0.33720842003822327,
-0.5529789328575134,
-0.6824094653129578,
0.25013166666030884,
0.2590155303478241,
0.7023167014122009,
0.45764440298080444,
-0.2096262276172638,
-0.6447996497154236,
-0.7732569575309753,
-0.3548469841480255,
0.08477757126092911,
-0.10012028366327286,
0.1457747370004654,
0.27583497762680054,
-0.3258953094482422,
0.9033190608024597,
-0.7161753177642822,
-0.2578129768371582,
-0.3234335780143738,
-0.07933801412582397,
0.27090132236480713,
0.591558039188385,
0.15860162675380707,
-0.5569325089454651,
-0.3671639859676361,
0.025768274441361427,
-0.9555792212486267,
-0.11713207513093948,
-0.3715932369232178,
-0.3947618901729584,
-0.02938864380121231,
0.5021049976348877,
-0.6195328831672668,
0.1132216602563858,
0.2622750699520111,
-0.2749110162258148,
0.4671632647514343,
-0.3193628489971161,
0.08224793523550034,
-1.3941127061843872,
0.015992477536201477,
-0.11583305150270462,
-0.464713990688324,
-0.7888334393501282,
0.019946439191699028,
-0.1407242864370346,
0.02146557904779911,
-0.47994422912597656,
0.5806730389595032,
-0.5361337661743164,
-0.16133509576320648,
-0.2754359543323517,
0.42751920223236084,
-0.09575172513723373,
0.37555643916130066,
-0.12320585548877716,
0.6813276410102844,
0.36528119444847107,
-0.6028808355331421,
0.2536085844039917,
0.4805580675601959,
-0.6502366662025452,
0.6061607003211975,
-0.4248243272304535,
0.23436614871025085,
-0.2267293483018875,
0.28053954243659973,
-0.8285800218582153,
-0.3601756691932678,
0.4586943984031677,
0.008425891399383545,
0.4187597334384918,
0.15997645258903503,
-0.45212018489837646,
-0.1233566626906395,
0.04858753830194473,
0.10878609865903854,
0.5475373268127441,
-0.6056523323059082,
0.8488038182258606,
0.47640708088874817,
-0.4823808968067169,
-0.6289722919464111,
-0.5342137813568115,
0.11772651225328445,
-0.07526134699583054,
-0.5029271245002747,
0.5341412425041199,
-0.1382785439491272,
-0.4615896940231323,
0.023597143590450287,
-0.02561623603105545,
-0.04961699992418289,
0.21776510775089264,
0.02212468348443508,
0.4102504253387451,
-0.10005241632461548,
0.014862146228551865,
0.5633092522621155,
-0.11549028009176254,
-0.13025322556495667,
0.009860241785645485,
0.37349337339401245,
0.30778318643569946,
-0.4898639917373657,
-0.5568279027938843,
0.2868695557117462,
0.6484078168869019,
-0.02432585507631302,
0.47481146454811096,
0.32050076127052307,
-0.38968056440353394,
-0.2594093382358551,
-0.6863275766372681,
-0.04663028195500374,
-0.44634416699409485,
0.4466888904571533,
-0.33648982644081116,
-1.0219769477844238,
0.3759934902191162,
-0.7420524954795837,
-0.06700120121240616,
0.509719729423523,
0.7131071090698242,
-0.13925953209400177,
0.6695337295532227,
0.5017955899238586,
0.11839281767606735,
0.30083534121513367,
-0.031457770615816116,
0.10585547238588333,
-1.0530807971954346,
-0.4509466886520386,
-0.39675670862197876,
-0.28841185569763184,
-0.19817739725112915,
-0.7421128749847412,
0.5056890845298767,
0.3272322714328766,
-0.14466862380504608,
-0.19411267340183258,
-0.34031614661216736,
0.40437331795692444,
0.3258269727230072,
0.5036022067070007,
0.48995932936668396,
-0.05352335050702095,
0.041717298328876495,
0.08759842067956924,
-0.8728172183036804,
-0.4146274924278259,
0.9191699624061584,
0.21259805560112,
0.5471380949020386,
0.2865208685398102,
0.6307364702224731,
0.18638335168361664,
0.5169798731803894,
-0.8060494065284729,
0.58958500623703,
-0.2024022936820984,
-0.24721886217594147,
-0.19093358516693115,
-0.38255202770233154,
-0.754658579826355,
0.3558928966522217,
-0.5518128275871277,
-0.5652703642845154,
0.34108424186706543,
0.008042256347835064,
-0.5243170857429504,
0.28065553307533264,
-0.5656976103782654,
0.5565722584724426,
-0.3584718704223633,
-0.25114020705223083,
-0.22388923168182373,
-0.8005331754684448,
0.6526039838790894,
-0.4104510545730591,
0.3456224501132965,
-0.041876956820487976,
-0.21620839834213257,
0.6394362449645996,
-0.4784501791000366,
1.00080144405365,
-0.14874036610126495,
0.02161949872970581,
0.2883324921131134,
-0.05334760621190071,
0.6207552552223206,
-0.24169360101222992,
-0.10013724863529205,
-0.339184045791626,
-0.12791042029857635,
-0.3872644901275635,
-0.7940750122070312,
0.5135440826416016,
-0.8312088847160339,
-0.8860253095626831,
-0.39333081245422363,
-0.8238048553466797,
-0.6472879648208618,
0.21006928384304047,
-0.0709872767329216,
0.15679499506950378,
-0.20224787294864655,
-0.07103369385004044,
0.7479783296585083,
-0.49888888001441956,
0.14630946516990662,
0.3043085038661957,
-0.12175426632165909,
-0.5690898299217224,
0.6233342885971069,
0.07046842575073242,
0.45303550362586975,
0.4961344599723816,
0.369648277759552,
-0.07657160609960556,
-0.6516928672790527,
-0.3657482862472534,
0.3112049698829651,
-0.931556761264801,
-0.3045322299003601,
-0.6811473965644836,
-0.23370954394340515,
-0.4178570806980133,
-0.22855432331562042,
-0.04735709726810455,
-0.5800223350524902,
-0.5267606377601624,
-0.02693270705640316,
0.2838834524154663,
0.7654296159744263,
0.05832473561167717,
0.3367738723754883,
-0.9099871516227722,
0.4369991421699524,
0.4954785406589508,
-0.09353948384523392,
-0.08635430037975311,
-0.6539518237113953,
0.0023294826969504356,
-0.11384691298007965,
-0.05412829667329788,
-0.9356720447540283,
0.28501418232917786,
0.3013145625591278,
0.7562613487243652,
0.006249943282455206,
0.04790148511528969,
1.0492684841156006,
-0.37159574031829834,
0.6743938326835632,
0.1159842312335968,
-1.0269949436187744,
0.6421114206314087,
-0.20298565924167633,
0.33031004667282104,
0.7773510217666626,
0.4269474446773529,
-0.3031597137451172,
-0.20568814873695374,
-0.40342116355895996,
-0.7950074672698975,
0.452936589717865,
-0.317134827375412,
-0.04962002485990524,
0.24991914629936218,
0.7770525813102722,
0.16000652313232422,
0.10739028453826904,
-0.3808664381504059,
-0.20820701122283936,
0.2847341299057007,
-0.3456001281738281,
0.05031491816043854,
-0.5880928039550781,
-0.2215932309627533,
-0.5190199017524719,
0.8157816529273987,
-0.14340132474899292,
0.05039965733885765,
0.47862744331359863,
-0.3295682668685913,
0.05335494875907898,
0.39276430010795593,
0.6501575112342834,
1.0552343130111694,
-0.11923880130052567,
0.1797613799571991,
0.4689198434352875,
-0.34704118967056274,
0.1333799511194229,
-0.05628136172890663,
-0.08056475222110748,
-0.17471329867839813,
0.37332016229629517,
0.549830973148346,
0.4696950316429138,
-0.851116418838501,
0.40690550208091736,
0.23066042363643646,
-0.24550458788871765,
-0.21590614318847656,
-0.04001879319548607,
0.1519870012998581,
0.4473217725753784,
0.40145522356033325,
0.13187317550182343,
-0.16283321380615234,
-0.5887547731399536,
0.3494150936603546,
0.07659436017274857,
-0.16170088946819305,
0.002355959266424179,
0.3479588031768799,
0.18527008593082428,
-0.1489916443824768,
0.4982464015483856,
-0.13881932199001312,
-0.5333787798881531,
0.12631520628929138,
0.8328566551208496,
0.6520874500274658,
-0.3813263773918152,
-0.021979425102472305,
0.31234726309776306,
0.03320394456386566,
-0.2508172392845154,
0.5292467474937439,
0.242669939994812,
-0.9118761420249939,
-0.840524435043335,
-0.5464323163032532,
-0.49964553117752075,
-0.19682759046554565,
-0.5301234722137451,
0.2863449454307556,
-0.5868232250213623,
0.2505148947238922,
0.010553454048931599,
-0.03756679967045784,
-0.39341747760772705,
0.10584989190101624,
-0.07524934411048889,
1.0234359502792358,
-0.7743805646896362,
1.0874271392822266,
0.6303220987319946,
-0.12932188808918,
-0.7336956858634949,
-0.23151810467243195,
0.10754740238189697,
-1.0452183485031128,
0.5889577865600586,
-0.38920772075653076,
0.049948278814554214,
0.19550935924053192,
-0.5861999988555908,
-0.7206229567527771,
1.3857430219650269,
0.45476892590522766,
-0.7433270812034607,
0.030204445123672485,
0.0031614634208381176,
0.2865314483642578,
-0.5363160967826843,
-0.4040782153606415,
0.7277709245681763,
0.5074331164360046,
0.35115769505500793,
-0.7489509582519531,
0.16502539813518524,
0.05986715480685234,
-0.3305305242538452,
0.038566507399082184,
-0.36743244528770447,
0.8086146712303162,
-0.35014137625694275,
-0.17710496485233307,
0.22126935422420502,
0.5747142434120178,
0.5154191255569458,
0.11575476080179214,
0.5039582252502441,
0.5974908471107483,
1.2041888236999512,
0.06159346550703049,
0.9469419717788696,
-0.1420072615146637,
0.161990225315094,
1.515835165977478,
-0.44080162048339844,
1.0046284198760986,
0.5351829528808594,
-0.12505091726779938,
0.6555745005607605,
0.6012966632843018,
-0.004785106983035803,
0.4562159478664398,
0.2008550614118576,
-0.4625881612300873,
-0.4775732457637787,
-0.2743454575538635,
-0.28971225023269653,
0.5983160734176636,
0.5026575922966003,
-0.36640074849128723,
-0.015506301075220108,
-0.01634889654815197,
0.354898601770401,
0.12607453763484955,
-0.39647284150123596,
1.0375558137893677,
0.3087567985057831,
-0.6604570746421814,
0.38889414072036743,
-0.034422699362039566,
0.438470721244812,
-0.4457930326461792,
-0.14239107072353363,
0.06278294324874878,
0.19670867919921875,
-0.3259209990501404,
-0.7174402475357056,
0.19394941627979279,
-0.09514488279819489,
-0.19479672610759735,
-0.04856003075838089,
1.0018115043640137,
-0.5968937277793884,
-0.6897486448287964,
0.03216617554426193,
1.0009058713912964,
0.015694256871938705,
0.29585567116737366,
-0.6053113341331482,
0.08938423544168472,
0.07846903800964355,
0.09069648385047913,
0.4556865096092224,
0.4141376316547394,
0.11759358644485474,
0.6030097603797913,
0.7241542339324951,
0.21357397735118866,
-0.16604264080524445,
0.07751450687646866,
1.0090277194976807,
-0.7107992768287659,
-0.23014439642429352,
-0.7978798151016235,
0.5526363849639893,
-0.1822362244129181,
-0.08200196921825409,
0.6019710302352905,
0.43195945024490356,
0.6360757350921631,
0.03930231183767319,
1.022823452949524,
0.052283454686403275,
0.4822233319282532,
-0.7466809749603271,
0.4246186912059784,
-0.4474150836467743,
0.41993677616119385,
-0.23475554585456848,
-0.8742415904998779,
-0.6037167310714722,
0.37869641184806824,
-0.40087637305259705,
-0.3599952459335327,
0.7990860342979431,
0.5407481789588928,
0.06751853227615356,
-0.091433584690094,
0.10408148914575577,
0.48289206624031067,
0.12896385788917542,
0.6404785513877869,
0.8484545350074768,
-0.3156856596469879,
0.23825015127658844,
-0.2540595233440399,
-0.37979423999786377,
-0.06089191138744354,
-0.8956749439239502,
-0.6862784624099731,
-0.25148043036460876,
-0.4093855917453766,
-0.5176821351051331,
0.14398282766342163,
1.1511002779006958,
0.38831543922424316,
-0.6374048590660095,
-0.2772292494773865,
0.2845066785812378,
0.3685745298862457,
-0.24654029309749603,
-0.1737106293439865,
0.6727650761604309,
-0.3131342828273773,
-0.5746176242828369,
0.6682040691375732,
0.3805742561817169,
0.001153730321675539,
-0.15701432526111603,
0.06418627500534058,
-0.5380244255065918,
-0.06061122938990593,
0.8806540966033936,
0.25010472536087036,
-0.6632450222969055,
-0.5259885191917419,
-0.16873352229595184,
0.0823444202542305,
0.08464721590280533,
0.8091995716094971,
-0.6919127702713013,
0.532941460609436,
0.4986369013786316,
0.9745047092437744,
0.335446298122406,
0.19766195118427277,
0.583564281463623,
-0.5502322912216187,
0.06916718184947968,
0.15089787542819977,
0.39545056223869324,
0.3536074757575989,
-0.3183137774467468,
0.4792143404483795,
0.3721414804458618,
-0.5994471907615662,
-0.8990635275840759,
0.20776192843914032,
-1.4249221086502075,
-0.5899500846862793,
1.22067129611969,
-0.05310225486755371,
-0.39563900232315063,
-0.3981906771659851,
-0.3644585609436035,
0.3479573428630829,
0.062911756336689,
0.6009277105331421,
0.1907350867986679,
-0.3117366433143616,
-0.006581796333193779,
-0.24763110280036926,
0.3311781585216522,
0.1536840796470642,
-1.1103651523590088,
-0.06497061997652054,
0.39637354016304016,
0.42760494351387024,
-0.028787247836589813,
0.6923527717590332,
-0.1530250757932663,
0.15404771268367767,
-0.1627051681280136,
0.08966022729873657,
0.08294877409934998,
-0.09646904468536377,
-0.3254137635231018,
0.4371775984764099,
0.32141217589378357,
0.033248282968997955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15729v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15729v3
|
Towards a RAG-based Summarization Agent for the Electron-Ion Collider
| 2024-03-23T05:32:46 | 2024-06-08T01:15:05 |
Karthik Suresh, Neeltje Kackar, Luke Schleck, Cristiano Fanelli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, hep-ex, physics.ins-det
|
The complexity and sheer volume of information encompassing documents,
papers, data, and other resources from large-scale experiments demand
significant time and effort to navigate, making the task of accessing and
utilizing these varied forms of information daunting, particularly for new
collaborators and early-career scientists. To tackle this issue, a Retrieval
Augmented Generation (RAG)--based Summarization AI for EIC (RAGS4EIC) is under
development. This AI-Agent not only condenses information but also effectively
references relevant responses, offering substantial advantages for
collaborators. Our project involves a two-step approach: first, querying a
comprehensive vector database containing all pertinent experiment information;
second, utilizing a Large Language Model (LLM) to generate concise summaries
enriched with citations based on user queries and retrieved data. We describe
the evaluation methods that use RAG assessments (RAGAs) scoring mechanisms to
assess the effectiveness of responses. Furthermore, we describe the concept of
prompt template-based instruction-tuning which provides flexibility and
accuracy in summarization. Importantly, the implementation relies on LangChain,
which serves as the foundation of our entire workflow. This integration ensures
efficiency and scalability, facilitating smooth deployment and accessibility
for various user groups within the Electron Ion Collider (EIC) community. This
innovative AI-driven framework not only simplifies the understanding of vast
datasets but also encourages collaborative participation, thereby empowering
researchers. As a demonstration, a web application has been developed to
explain each stage of the RAG Agent development in detail.
|
[
-0.5583846569061279,
-0.4739028811454773,
0.5979750156402588,
-0.19905543327331543,
-0.15332697331905365,
0.6906928420066833,
-0.04775388538837433,
-0.330034464597702,
0.8385977149009705,
0.1469932645559311,
-0.20793242752552032,
-0.28259167075157166,
-0.47371944785118103,
0.3604126572608948,
-0.595253586769104,
1.4265096187591553,
-0.07473816722631454,
-0.30596044659614563,
-0.422758549451828,
-0.0719454362988472,
-0.23863917589187622,
-0.21766620874404907,
-0.7430382370948792,
-0.27366527915000916,
0.858634352684021,
0.4055643677711487,
0.40153658390045166,
0.43933671712875366,
0.6392688751220703,
0.45563381910324097,
-0.29955220222473145,
0.36966192722320557,
-0.4827582538127899,
0.15432602167129517,
-0.4022214412689209,
-0.4454987943172455,
-0.8610326051712036,
-0.3441556990146637,
0.4742570221424103,
0.6567714810371399,
-0.2455870509147644,
0.2937467694282532,
-0.07113316655158997,
0.6354466676712036,
-0.8952224850654602,
-0.0012922208989039063,
-0.14322219789028168,
0.00597939221188426,
-0.20455946028232574,
-0.2814759612083435,
-0.5282716751098633,
0.14228828251361847,
-0.14463768899440765,
-0.9332621693611145,
0.20731844007968903,
0.30313095450401306,
0.8414178490638733,
0.07560749351978302,
-0.39550918340682983,
-0.4266091287136078,
-0.8138529658317566,
0.764864444732666,
-0.137168288230896,
0.2600787580013275,
0.08557827025651932,
0.28585436940193176,
-0.10190290957689285,
-1.1410597562789917,
-0.3114205300807953,
-0.22655417025089264,
-0.1837482452392578,
0.6831663846969604,
-0.0708562359213829,
-0.007675106171518564,
0.18900533020496368,
0.22578267753124237,
-0.7809723615646362,
-0.06333687901496887,
-0.36511582136154175,
-0.18023908138275146,
0.45977893471717834,
0.44537585973739624,
0.18918108940124512,
-0.062183499336242676,
-0.09125062823295593,
-0.24494753777980804,
-0.21507979929447174,
-0.2932782471179962,
0.16115997731685638,
-0.018700167536735535,
-0.19159503281116486,
0.6414108276367188,
-0.19368761777877808,
0.4384094774723053,
0.11587624251842499,
0.1669774353504181,
0.3679256737232208,
-0.31589609384536743,
0.18889182806015015,
0.06599894165992737,
0.5551559329032898,
0.32748281955718994,
-0.19193854928016663,
-0.25817614793777466,
-0.3939077854156494,
-0.21524706482887268,
0.38640737533569336,
-0.867620050907135,
-0.015423567034304142,
0.46196526288986206,
-0.16933782398700714,
-0.37421461939811707,
0.22463884949684143,
-0.9448773264884949,
-0.360039085149765,
-0.24520115554332733,
0.30387410521507263,
-0.17657428979873657,
-0.10419796407222748,
-0.38777369260787964,
-0.5695668458938599,
0.2190639227628708,
0.4768919050693512,
-0.44074776768684387,
0.5506355166435242,
0.6697530746459961,
1.0106310844421387,
-0.12581197917461395,
-0.334623783826828,
-0.8717288970947266,
0.4068736135959625,
-0.41855788230895996,
0.8315783143043518,
-0.3203459680080414,
-0.3938676118850708,
-0.3740977644920349,
-0.23049785196781158,
0.2536727786064148,
-0.24789121747016907,
0.27604252099990845,
-0.7581098079681396,
0.07437731325626373,
0.048481643199920654,
-0.6623804569244385,
0.1246425211429596,
0.1634770929813385,
-0.8560135960578918,
0.47157400846481323,
0.021154558286070824,
-1.0275957584381104,
0.05116322636604309,
-0.637087345123291,
-0.3423720896244049,
0.3155195415019989,
-0.3892356753349304,
-0.3159315586090088,
0.1534976065158844,
0.1196201741695404,
0.22105756402015686,
-0.2695445418357849,
0.1086445227265358,
0.006305122282356024,
-0.35082006454467773,
0.3669797480106354,
0.10747357457876205,
0.3800221085548401,
0.4458552598953247,
-0.03387528657913208,
0.07083763927221298,
-0.5201371312141418,
-0.2447509765625,
0.0809553936123848,
-0.0526154488325119,
-0.1853300929069519,
-0.1633361428976059,
0.04997030645608902,
-0.16308408975601196,
0.4667425751686096,
-0.34590837359428406,
-0.03786439076066017,
-0.40281787514686584,
-0.11956549435853958,
0.6694122552871704,
0.15571154654026031,
0.5082332491874695,
-0.718113124370575,
0.6868458390235901,
-0.1245141550898552,
-0.12978345155715942,
-0.5552141070365906,
-0.2019052803516388,
-0.5688517689704895,
-0.18292997777462006,
0.40946710109710693,
0.5328115820884705,
-1.146478533744812,
0.21355344355106354,
-0.2719274163246155,
-0.6184617877006531,
-0.08824759721755981,
-0.05787401273846626,
0.4578162729740143,
0.470860093832016,
0.32152488827705383,
-0.23667731881141663,
-0.5466394424438477,
-0.9004733562469482,
-0.2580166161060333,
-0.1698574274778366,
-0.29785406589508057,
0.3049257695674896,
0.646783709526062,
-0.05163342505693436,
0.6629231572151184,
-0.4864083230495453,
-0.1548173874616623,
-0.5402169227600098,
0.47039535641670227,
0.4507102966308594,
0.2403300255537033,
0.1082627922296524,
-1.0115941762924194,
-0.47209545969963074,
0.23956850171089172,
-0.7397454380989075,
-0.1599835753440857,
-0.10488878935575485,
-0.14178109169006348,
0.12189625948667526,
0.6939430832862854,
-0.45830580592155457,
0.346893310546875,
0.2513410449028015,
-0.22567792236804962,
0.4169544279575348,
-0.4966156482696533,
0.38691943883895874,
-1.389038324356079,
0.5850871205329895,
-0.20794449746608734,
-0.5355138182640076,
-0.7202529907226562,
0.22214345633983612,
0.0285370871424675,
-0.01957749016582966,
-0.5748459696769714,
0.4777830243110657,
-0.4616216719150543,
-0.4140590727329254,
-0.48274436593055725,
0.4698646068572998,
0.15091083943843842,
0.25626328587532043,
-0.3374873101711273,
0.8683583736419678,
0.16589920222759247,
-0.7078654170036316,
0.12348567694425583,
0.22725598514080048,
0.23236989974975586,
0.5423416495323181,
-0.8517345786094666,
0.29965388774871826,
-0.44999608397483826,
0.4491230547428131,
-0.33566924929618835,
-0.5583555102348328,
0.0795859694480896,
-0.7712545394897461,
0.6216777563095093,
-0.056071557104587555,
-0.4839963912963867,
-0.0812150314450264,
-0.3917282223701477,
0.3945648968219757,
0.5203009247779846,
-0.3517972230911255,
1.173647165298462,
0.6034597158432007,
-0.3452765941619873,
-0.6111708283424377,
-0.22419755160808563,
0.17322252690792084,
0.02732197195291519,
-0.4095870852470398,
0.6507973670959473,
-0.36746129393577576,
-0.5017526745796204,
0.2228410243988037,
0.22891299426555634,
0.03754175081849098,
0.11718229949474335,
0.06533503532409668,
0.35775741934776306,
0.2519577741622925,
0.1304146647453308,
0.11312008649110794,
-0.4027445912361145,
-0.1302529126405716,
-0.13348525762557983,
0.42538556456565857,
-0.2782183289527893,
-0.14360512793064117,
-0.17205876111984253,
0.3184668719768524,
0.6191457509994507,
-0.4007109999656677,
0.5145323872566223,
0.585951566696167,
-0.3952902853488922,
-0.15271936357021332,
-0.09928327798843384,
-0.08120619505643845,
-0.43101245164871216,
0.5504907369613647,
-0.3082107603549957,
-0.6155259013175964,
0.5906891822814941,
-0.24829524755477905,
0.23206652700901031,
0.5759792923927307,
0.7231206893920898,
-0.3076677918434143,
1.0339159965515137,
0.5783342719078064,
0.00310350744985044,
0.27566012740135193,
-0.3447010815143585,
-0.12875501811504364,
-1.0650296211242676,
-0.0032333594281226397,
-0.5541821122169495,
-0.30106619000434875,
-0.5187000036239624,
-0.4093439280986786,
0.7922130227088928,
-0.11564744263887405,
-0.06674834340810776,
-0.03650679066777229,
-0.48939403891563416,
0.7032822370529175,
0.09218224138021469,
-0.2735261917114258,
0.2088657021522522,
-0.2966747283935547,
0.12207041680812836,
0.33425718545913696,
-0.62106853723526,
-0.42626407742500305,
0.9524073600769043,
0.15064235031604767,
0.6806941032409668,
0.24404574930667877,
1.0729426145553589,
0.4307881295681,
0.32750579714775085,
-0.5646096467971802,
0.43906715512275696,
-0.0956873744726181,
-0.46111294627189636,
-0.17184363305568695,
-0.4381658732891083,
-1.060266137123108,
0.27497047185897827,
-0.005940117407590151,
-0.634675920009613,
-0.04479604586958885,
0.17715826630592346,
-0.24964982271194458,
0.21394847333431244,
-0.4128232002258301,
0.3437107503414154,
-0.046880658715963364,
-0.4999680817127228,
-0.4399987459182739,
-0.703172504901886,
0.09122750908136368,
-0.21731817722320557,
0.6849959492683411,
0.1950014978647232,
-0.3721988797187805,
0.9000963568687439,
-0.3914491534233093,
0.3542307913303375,
-0.11440466344356537,
0.2740241289138794,
0.30869850516319275,
0.11311738938093185,
0.6538898348808289,
0.15009358525276184,
-0.015109640546143055,
-0.22724327445030212,
-0.3133958876132965,
-0.23014745116233826,
-0.5598843693733215,
0.6312145590782166,
-0.6517009735107422,
-0.41895970702171326,
-0.46250519156455994,
-0.6238099336624146,
0.16294528543949127,
0.3472777307033539,
0.21713708341121674,
0.5381900668144226,
-0.2130739837884903,
0.11643749475479126,
0.6171608567237854,
-0.3959954082965851,
0.3387967050075531,
0.47589752078056335,
-0.5168321132659912,
-0.5184262990951538,
1.231915831565857,
0.157649964094162,
0.07421889901161194,
0.6254082918167114,
0.11617214977741241,
0.1126379519701004,
-0.3253479599952698,
-0.6060699224472046,
0.28877681493759155,
-0.5803152322769165,
-0.37598809599876404,
-0.7421954870223999,
-0.17437854409217834,
-0.12514574825763702,
-0.5991227626800537,
-0.5404080152511597,
-0.48849669098854065,
-0.1714010387659073,
-0.06622141599655151,
0.15513043105602264,
0.9225271940231323,
-0.2437838912010193,
-0.11861266940832138,
-0.8175334930419922,
0.3969193994998932,
-0.037052325904369354,
0.12961500883102417,
-0.060219619423151016,
-0.5548006296157837,
-0.7261478304862976,
-0.27280622720718384,
-0.24670802056789398,
-0.7836934328079224,
0.4123692214488983,
0.09469946473836899,
0.3731594383716583,
-0.03056223876774311,
0.006250361446291208,
0.24975138902664185,
-0.4203018844127655,
0.6434552073478699,
-0.05154770240187645,
-0.7847528457641602,
0.5557020902633667,
-0.40240609645843506,
0.3069247305393219,
0.4362652599811554,
0.13993874192237854,
-0.2826341688632965,
-0.7613097429275513,
-0.7453755140304565,
-1.2651780843734741,
0.7707674503326416,
0.44598856568336487,
-0.16567131876945496,
0.13129569590091705,
0.31183061003685,
-0.14423121511936188,
0.13645297288894653,
0.010929805226624012,
-0.47310400009155273,
-0.03288181126117706,
-0.29653558135032654,
-0.021791409701108932,
0.016130125150084496,
-0.12372054159641266,
0.34779760241508484,
0.8585603833198547,
-0.31162863969802856,
0.11416170746088028,
0.35558998584747314,
-0.3578757643699646,
-0.11791618913412094,
0.2751043140888214,
0.5052623748779297,
0.7382428050041199,
-0.2301674485206604,
-0.028676114976406097,
0.48567768931388855,
-0.5166410207748413,
0.06119932606816292,
0.38713833689689636,
-0.3060589134693146,
0.023928463459014893,
0.4524652659893036,
0.29838329553604126,
-0.024229299277067184,
-0.7886232137680054,
0.6177716851234436,
-0.4978159964084625,
-0.051658995449543,
-0.6335168480873108,
-0.0944528803229332,
-0.0049792323261499405,
0.19469542801380157,
0.48852065205574036,
-0.19108633697032928,
0.6029605269432068,
-0.05143793672323227,
0.45064592361450195,
-0.0030441454146057367,
-0.14575859904289246,
-0.35492151975631714,
0.6264591217041016,
0.18588052690029144,
-0.2835012972354889,
0.35446885228157043,
-0.5410435795783997,
-0.28606343269348145,
0.9967871904373169,
0.3549134135246277,
0.8282212615013123,
-0.11835930496454239,
0.23685429990291595,
0.46670404076576233,
0.26106294989585876,
0.4311618506908417,
0.20485076308250427,
0.18902136385440826,
-0.44339948892593384,
-0.4870965778827667,
-0.44204795360565186,
-0.6572960615158081,
-0.30464228987693787,
-0.8294597864151001,
0.3454766869544983,
-0.34251466393470764,
0.1256270706653595,
0.2044035941362381,
-0.0260375514626503,
-0.7326516509056091,
-0.06644156575202942,
0.12755493819713593,
0.6299929618835449,
-0.48158323764801025,
0.2818583548069,
1.0755281448364258,
-0.6038255095481873,
-0.779089093208313,
-0.24515016376972198,
0.10350482910871506,
-0.2762839198112488,
0.4718000590801239,
0.07159487158060074,
-0.13571131229400635,
0.13165327906608582,
-0.402142733335495,
-0.9070671200752258,
1.5103108882904053,
0.03800253942608833,
-0.5938079953193665,
0.20498891174793243,
-0.3267892003059387,
0.7011528611183167,
-0.2064371556043625,
0.7742177248001099,
0.26158154010772705,
0.3204374611377716,
0.09484419971704483,
-0.8118496537208557,
-0.20142114162445068,
-0.5265851616859436,
-0.1066020131111145,
0.5747200846672058,
-0.7890475392341614,
0.9176605939865112,
-0.21668405830860138,
-0.2491752952337265,
-0.04098501428961754,
0.923464298248291,
0.32419031858444214,
0.6067332029342651,
0.5541684031486511,
0.5737542510032654,
0.7471951246261597,
0.25975728034973145,
1.358307123184204,
-0.5928331017494202,
0.28901395201683044,
1.2190221548080444,
-0.2766590416431427,
0.46202412247657776,
0.3832748234272003,
-0.0112568698823452,
0.4399312436580658,
0.032668277621269226,
0.10550940036773682,
0.17515625059604645,
0.07257718592882156,
-0.25153934955596924,
0.15443794429302216,
-0.6720551252365112,
0.07978995144367218,
0.2704137861728668,
0.5273866057395935,
-0.21723277866840363,
-0.2712555527687073,
-0.021503863856196404,
-0.05248986557126045,
0.0023926421999931335,
-0.37519511580467224,
1.027833342552185,
0.13972273468971252,
-0.5732333660125732,
-0.12793897092342377,
0.1407332420349121,
0.11989722400903702,
-0.37985509634017944,
-0.382806658744812,
-0.24549360573291779,
0.061258405447006226,
-0.2073417752981186,
-0.7109031081199646,
0.33753862977027893,
0.27109965682029724,
-0.137933149933815,
0.08045769482851028,
0.8993387222290039,
-0.04216070473194122,
-0.3609361946582794,
0.20391452312469482,
0.6779478192329407,
0.391029417514801,
0.5432944893836975,
-0.40020105242729187,
0.14752508699893951,
-0.2172059416770935,
-0.4591425657272339,
0.33045411109924316,
0.3409847021102905,
0.021173035725951195,
0.5064879655838013,
0.4919484555721283,
0.08412925153970718,
-0.4974214434623718,
0.3080977201461792,
1.1098066568374634,
-0.5912001132965088,
-0.5621182918548584,
-0.5531134605407715,
0.8259413242340088,
-0.17374470829963684,
-0.05015724524855614,
0.5418580770492554,
0.7692419290542603,
0.7751330733299255,
0.3084799647331238,
0.7797026038169861,
-0.2949025630950928,
0.7305387854576111,
-0.21886326372623444,
0.6347836852073669,
-0.5599919557571411,
0.2833196222782135,
-0.16823886334896088,
-0.6469235420227051,
-0.14285151660442352,
0.3260985016822815,
0.29234200716018677,
0.3084794878959656,
0.5185624957084656,
0.7423486709594727,
0.08439113199710846,
-0.21759486198425293,
0.29447293281555176,
0.35899612307548523,
0.7758251428604126,
0.21589922904968262,
0.7651694416999817,
-0.2745496928691864,
0.5655182003974915,
-0.3489789366722107,
-0.4703686535358429,
-0.25812745094299316,
-0.701676607131958,
-0.7536934614181519,
-0.5038195252418518,
-0.18419280648231506,
-0.2004656046628952,
0.2649206519126892,
1.1512417793273926,
0.2089487612247467,
-0.48343023657798767,
-0.16689829528331757,
-0.19877713918685913,
-0.013099032454192638,
0.14561904966831207,
-0.20613275468349457,
0.33704516291618347,
-0.4803958833217621,
-0.7557205557823181,
0.3472602963447571,
0.37745851278305054,
-0.19034767150878906,
-0.186874121427536,
-0.22196871042251587,
-0.021186253055930138,
0.06169075891375542,
0.40265920758247375,
0.2625836133956909,
-0.14848008751869202,
0.010751797817647457,
0.058861833065748215,
0.020751306787133217,
-0.36583825945854187,
0.6449921131134033,
-0.7439989447593689,
0.8053423166275024,
0.4803127944469452,
0.713076114654541,
0.5511546730995178,
-0.09924941509962082,
0.6161731481552124,
-0.7250990867614746,
-0.12301312386989594,
0.500199556350708,
0.37023410201072693,
0.2171379029750824,
-0.5315119624137878,
0.48057782649993896,
-0.23754623532295227,
-0.8428606986999512,
-0.7838062644004822,
0.07307608425617218,
-0.7565183043479919,
-0.14366446435451508,
0.7467030882835388,
-0.08241497725248337,
-0.4335134029388428,
-0.004761857911944389,
-0.1857277750968933,
0.572677731513977,
-0.5815101861953735,
0.5824387073516846,
0.2895685136318207,
-0.2738475203514099,
0.09947650879621506,
-0.5299467444419861,
0.13735273480415344,
0.3385721743106842,
-0.9839209914207458,
-0.0791001245379448,
0.4633748531341553,
-0.14077089726924896,
0.49810072779655457,
0.7456527352333069,
-0.03793375566601753,
0.5344297289848328,
0.025558412075042725,
0.33654311299324036,
-0.32396048307418823,
-0.6374967098236084,
-0.4061304032802582,
0.02719581313431263,
0.1105126142501831,
0.011486907489597797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15724v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15724v1
|
PEaCE: A Chemistry-Oriented Dataset for Optical Character Recognition on Scientific Documents
| 2024-03-23T05:20:36 | 2024-03-23T05:20:36 |
Nan Zhang, Connor Heaton, Sean Timothy Okonsky, Prasenjit Mitra, Hilal Ezgi Toraman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Optical Character Recognition (OCR) is an established task with the objective
of identifying the text present in an image. While many off-the-shelf OCR
models exist, they are often trained for either scientific (e.g., formulae) or
generic printed English text. Extracting text from chemistry publications
requires an OCR model that is capable in both realms. Nougat, a recent tool,
exhibits strong ability to parse academic documents, but is unable to parse
tables in PubMed articles, which comprises a significant part of the academic
community and is the focus of this work. To mitigate this gap, we present the
Printed English and Chemical Equations (PEaCE) dataset, containing both
synthetic and real-world records, and evaluate the efficacy of
transformer-based OCR models when trained on this resource. Given that
real-world records contain artifacts not present in synthetic records, we
propose transformations that mimic such qualities. We perform a suite of
experiments to explore the impact of patch size, multi-domain training, and our
proposed transformations, ultimately finding that models with a small patch
size trained on multiple domains using the proposed transformations yield the
best performance. Our dataset and code is available at
https://github.com/ZN1010/PEaCE.
|
[
-0.09543121606111526,
-0.27578243613243103,
0.8906108736991882,
-0.20661288499832153,
-0.2731423079967499,
0.02084103785455227,
-0.010743249207735062,
-0.7195422053337097,
-0.07347581535577774,
0.6865572333335876,
-0.3747839331626892,
-0.4220453202724457,
-0.5325334072113037,
0.6314710378646851,
-0.2071646749973297,
0.7748317122459412,
-0.37072664499282837,
0.38804611563682556,
0.08956755697727203,
-0.14123515784740448,
-0.07091546058654785,
-0.2979382574558258,
-0.3671630024909973,
-0.20210003852844238,
0.3838064670562744,
0.1186894103884697,
0.44155582785606384,
0.7301084399223328,
0.9996423125267029,
0.3204188048839569,
-0.00354043859988451,
0.38022249937057495,
-0.49869030714035034,
0.05003093183040619,
-0.22688794136047363,
-0.5120621919631958,
-0.2147970050573349,
0.46325892210006714,
0.42373204231262207,
0.48884904384613037,
0.16873426735401154,
-0.39979884028434753,
-0.055517878383398056,
0.5534040927886963,
-0.3462352454662323,
0.4301394522190094,
-0.5464504361152649,
0.26031628251075745,
0.03337102010846138,
0.255261093378067,
-0.37798091769218445,
-0.3808344304561615,
0.1114383414387703,
-1.2481523752212524,
0.4607607424259186,
0.1506885588169098,
1.0650404691696167,
0.05564228072762489,
-0.43355298042297363,
-0.5556179881095886,
-0.8901234865188599,
0.9602574706077576,
-0.4009228050708771,
0.7309877872467041,
0.1695532202720642,
0.3318411707878113,
-0.35861194133758545,
-0.7532235980033875,
-0.7751659154891968,
-0.1627243012189865,
-0.09395264834165573,
0.5232363343238831,
0.1469089686870575,
-0.06836601346731186,
0.11339826136827469,
0.8972983360290527,
-0.5639130473136902,
-0.2861272394657135,
-0.5321735739707947,
-0.32010960578918457,
0.6422522664070129,
0.15561063587665558,
0.35212060809135437,
-0.04162035137414932,
-0.44908514618873596,
-0.36422625184059143,
-0.41256439685821533,
-0.23878279328346252,
-0.10774891823530197,
0.4714824855327606,
-0.01151247788220644,
0.6522451043128967,
0.16812998056411743,
0.5894196629524231,
0.015841195359826088,
-0.49642595648765564,
0.047693222761154175,
-0.46849706768989563,
0.02875896915793419,
0.3994221091270447,
0.8137786388397217,
0.041671544313430786,
-0.21431982517242432,
-0.26721659302711487,
-0.26259711384773254,
0.5124069452285767,
0.34040287137031555,
-0.9414852261543274,
-0.3211727440357208,
0.0020661696325987577,
-0.39554935693740845,
-0.052403081208467484,
0.1602938324213028,
-0.9407196640968323,
-0.8802724480628967,
-0.47396472096443176,
0.5510361194610596,
-0.5697044134140015,
0.15699103474617004,
0.4264710545539856,
-0.3362133800983429,
-0.08131156116724014,
0.6475965976715088,
-0.5697118639945984,
0.1434626281261444,
0.5066840648651123,
1.0619748830795288,
-0.14549671113491058,
0.09010676294565201,
-0.20962174236774445,
-0.0383807048201561,
-0.4560345411300659,
0.7503641843795776,
-0.4621424078941345,
-0.6240101456642151,
-0.12288917601108551,
0.07794225960969925,
-0.14347711205482483,
-0.5489600896835327,
0.6974915862083435,
-0.47581323981285095,
0.1575416475534439,
-0.1881522238254547,
-0.4617503583431244,
0.13596642017364502,
0.13389234244823456,
-1.2242404222488403,
0.8134351372718811,
0.40435829758644104,
-0.2957386076450348,
0.14066438376903534,
-0.7466301321983337,
-0.31607383489608765,
-0.0619976632297039,
-0.07492957264184952,
-0.6295819878578186,
0.195093035697937,
0.09786906838417053,
0.006916981656104326,
-0.4987547993659973,
-0.37215545773506165,
-0.25562766194343567,
-0.13909347355365753,
0.42259693145751953,
-0.13265539705753326,
0.46694356203079224,
0.40396082401275635,
-0.007140550762414932,
-0.6221849322319031,
-1.2333391904830933,
-0.3608078062534332,
0.11011228710412979,
-0.6047739386558533,
-0.4559550881385803,
-0.1618838906288147,
0.1375381201505661,
0.23323343694210052,
0.3072701692581177,
-1.3352577686309814,
0.5878074765205383,
-0.3778369724750519,
0.7352867126464844,
0.2910912334918976,
0.056834086775779724,
0.5461322665214539,
-0.18054205179214478,
0.15074799954891205,
-0.09450775384902954,
0.18162260949611664,
0.006514935288578272,
-0.48234236240386963,
-0.5296258330345154,
-0.6162744760513306,
0.38651806116104126,
0.44243383407592773,
-1.1211363077163696,
0.03763720393180847,
-0.3878849446773529,
-0.7541645169258118,
-0.6917991638183594,
-0.02785182185471058,
0.44067639112472534,
0.5813528895378113,
0.6187066435813904,
-0.5327888131141663,
-0.4051673114299774,
-0.41754841804504395,
-0.41241392493247986,
-0.13330073654651642,
0.016071196645498276,
0.330453097820282,
0.4629910886287689,
-0.1755601167678833,
1.0091495513916016,
-0.7304908633232117,
-0.8828976154327393,
0.08961412310600281,
0.422282338142395,
0.33575987815856934,
0.273783415555954,
0.22599467635154724,
-0.9937309622764587,
-0.641603410243988,
0.25891467928886414,
-0.7217443585395813,
-0.3109268546104431,
-0.1232573539018631,
-0.22218212485313416,
0.1803528219461441,
0.5043787956237793,
-0.3112003207206726,
0.4228808879852295,
0.5415717363357544,
-0.1619407832622528,
0.5541828870773315,
-0.05260784551501274,
0.492970734834671,
-0.9103725552558899,
-0.015583517029881477,
0.25486990809440613,
-0.03847238048911095,
-0.8966572880744934,
0.0357791930437088,
0.16026759147644043,
-0.5500312447547913,
-0.4614550471305847,
0.550258219242096,
-0.5097540020942688,
0.12657567858695984,
0.010911076329648495,
0.05616522952914238,
0.6077533960342407,
0.17319335043430328,
0.5958108901977539,
0.9972166419029236,
-0.11521542817354202,
-0.2867526710033417,
0.03289119154214859,
0.6172499656677246,
-0.3861751854419708,
0.7899007797241211,
-0.4178016781806946,
0.22814109921455383,
0.1764453649520874,
-0.08422941714525223,
-0.960539698600769,
-0.16590069234371185,
0.1312495470046997,
-0.21637606620788574,
0.3108856678009033,
-0.13127286732196808,
-0.5182280540466309,
-0.1296595335006714,
-0.10182204097509384,
0.36260995268821716,
0.3908509910106659,
-0.7354010343551636,
0.9751515984535217,
0.15642844140529633,
-0.03224034607410431,
-0.08562205731868744,
-0.6602137684822083,
-0.1860545575618744,
0.1065000370144844,
-0.40001145005226135,
0.5723076462745667,
-0.1154039055109024,
0.05367648974061012,
0.05372709408402443,
-0.3729810416698456,
-0.4396020472049713,
-0.3090364336967468,
0.21442674100399017,
0.4168223440647125,
-0.28198885917663574,
-0.04156212881207466,
-0.2992298901081085,
-0.14346322417259216,
-0.2328484058380127,
-0.2656872272491455,
0.36787694692611694,
0.06264731287956238,
-0.07171057164669037,
-0.31063711643218994,
0.20621010661125183,
0.8438563346862793,
-0.32731908559799194,
0.6130122542381287,
0.1433536410331726,
-0.04548341780900955,
-0.0734105184674263,
-0.25801628828048706,
-0.10441979020833969,
-0.5120783448219299,
0.15916147828102112,
-0.28666672110557556,
-0.6533851623535156,
0.5843057632446289,
-0.3208942413330078,
-0.010382627137005329,
0.4605259597301483,
0.04275704175233841,
-0.18655332922935486,
0.6730284094810486,
0.39565858244895935,
0.028162458911538124,
0.4272248148918152,
-0.11121461540460587,
0.7673786878585815,
-0.8634264469146729,
-0.30336758494377136,
-0.7806214094161987,
-0.07950136065483093,
-0.13077059388160706,
-0.37422847747802734,
0.8506429195404053,
0.01869365945458412,
-0.1137409433722496,
0.5596572160720825,
-0.8277186751365662,
0.5002590417861938,
0.28901660442352295,
0.39810118079185486,
0.38229864835739136,
0.3359091579914093,
0.10569212585687637,
-0.23144324123859406,
-0.42307618260383606,
-0.40071767568588257,
0.8755636215209961,
-0.06708795577287674,
0.9083226323127747,
0.00296575715765357,
0.7975224852561951,
0.26190945506095886,
0.02721281722187996,
-0.825623095035553,
0.43388688564300537,
-0.5104266405105591,
-0.43852925300598145,
-0.18394458293914795,
-0.6433166265487671,
-1.1337919235229492,
0.10319023579359055,
-0.44321712851524353,
-0.25110024213790894,
0.7270331978797913,
-0.09446118772029877,
-0.10446638613939285,
0.38900792598724365,
-0.47200849652290344,
0.7179338932037354,
-0.30356907844543457,
-0.2217189073562622,
0.21992865204811096,
-0.3804472088813782,
-0.09876593202352524,
-0.4321136474609375,
0.45602819323539734,
0.1487673968076706,
0.037384290248155594,
0.5204408764839172,
-0.4796436131000519,
0.6760491132736206,
0.12026184797286987,
-0.26497259736061096,
0.20121139287948608,
0.3051181137561798,
0.22468805313110352,
-0.4807168245315552,
-0.30607178807258606,
0.5887105464935303,
0.13000395894050598,
-0.2265433520078659,
-0.6051127910614014,
0.36875680088996887,
-0.9319487810134888,
-0.13391636312007904,
-0.6863373517990112,
-0.5647911429405212,
0.14476214349269867,
0.5074518918991089,
0.26409777998924255,
0.4584958255290985,
-0.2313031405210495,
-0.03936929628252983,
0.7891905307769775,
-0.09196443110704422,
0.07227110862731934,
0.8861987590789795,
-0.09938029199838638,
-0.7122939229011536,
1.248006820678711,
0.40594205260276794,
0.3623167872428894,
0.49554404616355896,
0.1765364408493042,
-0.26179927587509155,
-0.2798205614089966,
-0.5378322601318359,
0.20954355597496033,
-0.632652759552002,
-0.30970847606658936,
-0.2294224500656128,
-0.14010095596313477,
-0.4464222490787506,
-0.2545396089553833,
-0.39601942896842957,
-0.46180790662765503,
-0.4462946355342865,
0.3074582815170288,
0.5131136178970337,
0.9005191326141357,
0.006125926971435547,
0.30595874786376953,
-0.9519208073616028,
0.5934562683105469,
0.026263300329446793,
0.38487792015075684,
-0.4919762909412384,
-0.2908326983451843,
-0.3437975347042084,
-0.1365543007850647,
-0.44229111075401306,
-1.0867379903793335,
0.5005334615707397,
0.45070910453796387,
0.29874128103256226,
0.2414524257183075,
0.3502638339996338,
0.4814242422580719,
-0.7133146524429321,
0.8908583521842957,
0.16111554205417633,
-0.891703188419342,
0.3103463649749756,
-0.16802650690078735,
-0.10800588876008987,
0.6202561259269714,
0.6814263463020325,
-0.4627838730812073,
-0.09823604673147202,
-0.32455530762672424,
-0.62534099817276,
0.7534253001213074,
0.28715020418167114,
-0.4086869955062866,
0.24284133315086365,
0.5331971645355225,
0.2010936588048935,
0.16040392220020294,
-0.5710773468017578,
-0.07175198942422867,
-0.4982732832431793,
-0.46471840143203735,
-0.16325490176677704,
0.20208284258842468,
-0.010855255648493767,
-0.032817110419273376,
0.8582348227500916,
0.14862599968910217,
0.3549777865409851,
0.7552121877670288,
-0.16033712029457092,
0.11348620802164078,
0.21791863441467285,
0.23569825291633606,
-0.20001071691513062,
-0.21837644279003143,
0.2805665135383606,
-0.4722402095794678,
-1.0359041690826416,
0.38146457076072693,
0.21915094554424286,
-0.25818657875061035,
0.09237521141767502,
0.25269845128059387,
0.44517412781715393,
-0.03545857593417168,
-0.5086818933486938,
0.24916626513004303,
-0.15206743776798248,
-0.26967719197273254,
0.17042845487594604,
0.00729212025180459,
-0.44726458191871643,
0.12738120555877686,
0.20879001915454865,
0.17532426118850708,
0.4237256944179535,
-0.7687617540359497,
-0.06981486082077026,
0.17110732197761536,
-0.4556010067462921,
-0.11454254388809204,
0.5605984330177307,
-0.040385931730270386,
-0.3818762004375458,
0.5785747170448303,
-0.26850831508636475,
-0.7749849557876587,
0.4534575343132019,
0.5601007342338562,
0.4906623959541321,
-0.5030587315559387,
0.13488560914993286,
0.3429677188396454,
0.20609883964061737,
-0.06156313046813011,
0.3742755651473999,
0.11059384047985077,
-0.6753692030906677,
0.13218830525875092,
-0.8092987537384033,
-0.4869583249092102,
0.05790155380964279,
-0.5849573016166687,
0.2450246810913086,
-0.4824911057949066,
-0.10326215624809265,
0.3111926317214966,
0.17747282981872559,
-0.3160236179828644,
0.24534018337726593,
-0.05696341395378113,
0.6071998476982117,
-1.1322617530822754,
0.6003475785255432,
0.5763981938362122,
-0.5535066723823547,
-0.6316762566566467,
-0.3582327663898468,
0.022240327671170235,
-0.6294236779212952,
0.4737839102745056,
0.029999244958162308,
-0.02877083607017994,
-0.1161326915025711,
-0.4703651964664459,
-0.8596488833427429,
0.8654894232749939,
0.2746143639087677,
-0.6456690430641174,
0.3335212469100952,
0.8111678957939148,
0.6977037787437439,
-0.15076087415218353,
-0.09865178167819977,
0.4693051278591156,
0.47516727447509766,
0.006229147780686617,
-0.9162371158599854,
-0.07861136645078659,
-0.4714663326740265,
-0.005887491162866354,
0.33328959345817566,
-0.4152284562587738,
1.1053755283355713,
0.43226858973503113,
-0.3052663803100586,
0.4508623778820038,
0.21196986734867096,
0.18593628704547882,
0.48079684376716614,
0.2163645476102829,
0.68597012758255,
0.6819884181022644,
-0.42180335521698,
1.1225916147232056,
-0.28599482774734497,
0.3720240294933319,
0.7272899746894836,
-0.6771994829177856,
0.7356798052787781,
0.4819874167442322,
-0.23125720024108887,
0.5958023071289062,
0.39931419491767883,
-0.48457086086273193,
0.821217954158783,
-0.044879063963890076,
-0.4311924874782562,
-0.07416505366563797,
-0.2500084936618805,
-0.30241572856903076,
0.05025239661335945,
0.4736523926258087,
-0.401439368724823,
-0.15351317822933197,
0.19410741329193115,
-0.11800993978977203,
0.2711625099182129,
-0.5660969614982605,
1.0035890340805054,
0.16501598060131073,
-0.3620465099811554,
0.5827641487121582,
-0.06755256652832031,
0.1488691121339798,
-0.6771219968795776,
-0.42803820967674255,
0.056677162647247314,
0.40494754910469055,
-0.225002259016037,
-0.6917051076889038,
0.12074731290340424,
-0.19625210762023926,
-0.46281713247299194,
0.0614287331700325,
0.7034302949905396,
-0.5022086501121521,
-0.5122277140617371,
0.1623487025499344,
-0.09690456837415695,
0.36866044998168945,
0.01614336110651493,
-0.5580014586448669,
0.24018454551696777,
-0.04171739146113396,
0.0835399180650711,
0.38436228036880493,
0.4899307191371918,
-0.003056518966332078,
0.06256089359521866,
0.8366597294807434,
0.1331346333026886,
0.10660778731107712,
-0.4325747489929199,
0.8409513831138611,
-0.14528454840183258,
-0.38125675916671753,
-0.45584338903427124,
0.26972857117652893,
-0.05143071338534355,
-0.07811103761196136,
0.8171963691711426,
0.8482415080070496,
0.687351405620575,
-0.4966651201248169,
0.8355818390846252,
0.20323164761066437,
0.38532009720802307,
-0.6402290463447571,
0.8164992928504944,
-0.6844328045845032,
0.020184768363833427,
-0.3416736423969269,
-0.8533232808113098,
-0.5932780504226685,
0.9578321576118469,
-0.3670752942562103,
-0.37430045008659363,
0.7318196296691895,
0.9249750971794128,
-0.29824280738830566,
0.3528303802013397,
0.12837742269039154,
0.27396252751350403,
0.4057005047798157,
0.4249422252178192,
0.5311824083328247,
-0.786946713924408,
0.4355774223804474,
-0.27261582016944885,
-0.05607884004712105,
-0.15447211265563965,
-0.7474657297134399,
-0.7559769153594971,
-0.7128304839134216,
-0.31654736399650574,
-0.683054506778717,
0.10251442342996597,
0.6988128423690796,
0.575363039970398,
-0.821646511554718,
0.03490441292524338,
-0.1933242678642273,
-0.33648139238357544,
-0.120135098695755,
-0.16111154854297638,
0.5702723860740662,
-0.09426572918891907,
-0.6762644648551941,
0.5138399004936218,
0.23448960483074188,
0.25751423835754395,
0.09466156363487244,
0.016141384840011597,
0.16628186404705048,
0.3291160762310028,
0.49855461716651917,
0.6448625326156616,
-0.3842179775238037,
0.0427754782140255,
0.10567959398031235,
-0.19499829411506653,
0.4645738899707794,
0.7754487991333008,
-0.4699363708496094,
0.7319374084472656,
0.5104575157165527,
0.5694060325622559,
0.4709952175617218,
-0.22793257236480713,
0.31139886379241943,
-0.4976668357849121,
-0.07811123132705688,
0.25102394819259644,
0.42409747838974,
0.32868096232414246,
-0.5131974816322327,
0.7502006888389587,
0.4492599368095398,
-0.7164549827575684,
-0.8326844573020935,
0.16955497860908508,
-1.209757924079895,
-0.3817507028579712,
0.8409525752067566,
-0.3069871962070465,
-0.5963158011436462,
-0.26864635944366455,
-0.6098105311393738,
0.31079617142677307,
-0.6435707807540894,
0.911581814289093,
0.528223991394043,
-0.19371899962425232,
0.02347329445183277,
-0.1419176161289215,
0.37703028321266174,
0.038124360144138336,
-0.6791895627975464,
0.02866475097835064,
0.5004835724830627,
-0.05303008854389191,
0.9264907240867615,
0.2672252953052521,
-0.5316802263259888,
0.17808623611927032,
0.11301495879888535,
0.3715801239013672,
-0.09999945759773254,
-0.3885032832622528,
-0.5958493947982788,
0.15871047973632812,
-0.2062787562608719,
0.1625402867794037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15715v1
|
EDDA: A Encoder-Decoder Data Augmentation Framework for Zero-Shot Stance Detection
| 2024-03-23T04:29:29 | 2024-03-23T04:29:29 |
Daijun Ding, Li Dong, Zhichao Huang, Guangning Xu, Xu Huang, Bo Liu, Liwen Jing, Bowen Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stance detection aims to determine the attitude expressed in text towards a
given target. Zero-shot stance detection (ZSSD) has emerged to classify stances
towards unseen targets during inference. Recent data augmentation techniques
for ZSSD increase transferable knowledge between targets through text or target
augmentation. However, these methods exhibit limitations. Target augmentation
lacks logical connections between generated targets and source text, while text
augmentation relies solely on training data, resulting in insufficient
generalization. To address these issues, we propose an encoder-decoder data
augmentation (EDDA) framework. The encoder leverages large language models and
chain-of-thought prompting to summarize texts into target-specific if-then
rationales, establishing logical relationships. The decoder generates new
samples based on these expressions using a semantic correlation word
replacement strategy to increase syntactic diversity. We also analyze the
generated expressions to develop a rationale-enhanced network that fully
utilizes the augmented data. Experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate our
approach substantially improves over state-of-the-art ZSSD techniques. The
proposed EDDA framework increases semantic relevance and syntactic variety in
augmented texts while enabling interpretable rationale-based learning.
|
[
-0.25052085518836975,
-0.7101725935935974,
0.5425201654434204,
-0.09113574773073196,
-0.5848267078399658,
-0.12898017466068268,
0.013295548036694527,
-0.11256439983844757,
0.6633737683296204,
0.23640301823616028,
-0.6119619607925415,
-0.887648344039917,
-0.5541353821754456,
0.1858297884464264,
-0.25269609689712524,
1.0689971446990967,
-0.23362833261489868,
0.04460398480296135,
-0.26758065819740295,
-0.40423792600631714,
-0.37789860367774963,
-0.3081880807876587,
-0.2531161904335022,
-0.1410059630870819,
0.2866564095020294,
0.24938130378723145,
0.39345335960388184,
0.8280463814735413,
0.2602853775024414,
0.1283283680677414,
-0.05712532997131348,
0.19356665015220642,
-0.21031202375888824,
0.5124248266220093,
-0.11820478737354279,
-0.3639342784881592,
-0.7671350240707397,
-0.1755017340183258,
0.6286755800247192,
0.5977977514266968,
-0.09840532392263412,
-0.03338625654578209,
-0.18499815464019775,
0.42366763949394226,
-0.9229713082313538,
0.008247893303632736,
-0.2367265820503235,
0.16317327320575714,
-0.12197722494602203,
-0.26424044370651245,
-0.26101595163345337,
-0.04034153372049332,
-0.24717193841934204,
-0.632865846157074,
-0.007967636920511723,
-0.4554045796394348,
0.821651041507721,
0.3334124982357025,
-0.3356993496417999,
-0.2470724731683731,
-0.5006279349327087,
0.4095439016819,
-0.6681326627731323,
0.5453028678894043,
0.24068379402160645,
-0.051304738968610764,
-0.05824754387140274,
-0.3051769435405731,
-0.9713279604911804,
0.2570835053920746,
0.2793791592121124,
0.387256920337677,
-0.10051131248474121,
0.36179566383361816,
0.3714428246021271,
0.3229287266731262,
-0.44833412766456604,
-0.02574194222688675,
0.050016049295663834,
0.16342976689338684,
0.507617175579071,
0.09030731767416,
0.43014881014823914,
-0.3855609893798828,
-0.45905113220214844,
-0.3427046239376068,
-0.5132872462272644,
0.20647621154785156,
0.5385395884513855,
0.2270793616771698,
-0.04965057224035263,
0.8435387015342712,
-0.585742712020874,
0.8356778621673584,
0.5321385264396667,
0.03118334524333477,
0.511283278465271,
-0.2893703281879425,
-0.41689544916152954,
0.35782402753829956,
0.5908594131469727,
0.6192051768302917,
-0.2649238705635071,
-0.11310027539730072,
-0.3004234731197357,
0.47813957929611206,
-0.04194317013025284,
-0.8972374200820923,
0.13477416336536407,
0.4142410159111023,
-0.19442738592624664,
-0.4293476641178131,
0.12041419744491577,
-0.8493725657463074,
-0.48916471004486084,
-0.3288572132587433,
0.19479164481163025,
-0.6443970799446106,
-0.37045958638191223,
0.6808538436889648,
-0.38548165559768677,
0.7245088815689087,
0.16951167583465576,
-0.7968208193778992,
0.004214040469378233,
0.7996168732643127,
0.8307976126670837,
-0.04422718286514282,
-0.06861699372529984,
-0.5012486577033997,
0.28900790214538574,
-0.5355296730995178,
0.9356626868247986,
-0.7636752128601074,
-0.2145317643880844,
-0.012669762596487999,
-0.23168684542179108,
0.04625367000699043,
-0.1042885109782219,
0.8439816832542419,
-0.43157926201820374,
0.1418202817440033,
-0.33645811676979065,
-0.8676292896270752,
-0.1442064642906189,
0.8198862671852112,
-0.7130466103553772,
0.8287646174430847,
0.08360263705253601,
-0.6963439583778381,
0.8486891984939575,
-0.8567267656326294,
-0.3918231725692749,
0.20113004744052887,
-0.4929226040840149,
-0.24993166327476501,
-0.18997427821159363,
0.49030089378356934,
0.31656044721603394,
-0.05148132145404816,
0.2506397068500519,
-0.37657228112220764,
-0.2577369511127472,
-0.005056117195636034,
-0.4243661165237427,
0.8648484945297241,
0.07330913096666336,
-0.1266031116247177,
0.18756103515625,
-0.8761771321296692,
-0.13510943949222565,
0.006605080328881741,
-0.38140779733657837,
-0.5658650994300842,
0.06463916599750519,
-0.268500417470932,
0.22182683646678925,
0.12841425836086273,
-0.9753448963165283,
0.10593976825475693,
-0.5999528765678406,
-0.06362508982419968,
0.5702371001243591,
0.0724085196852684,
0.6949089169502258,
-0.0739927887916565,
0.6779726147651672,
0.2723543345928192,
-0.07264280319213867,
-0.4995695650577545,
-0.23068661987781525,
-0.6277018189430237,
-0.35254859924316406,
0.07433092594146729,
0.42100203037261963,
-1.210262656211853,
0.8103089928627014,
-0.5121337175369263,
-0.084455206990242,
-0.8073207139968872,
0.14764413237571716,
0.16594840586185455,
0.5982488989830017,
0.4015910029411316,
-0.14538076519966125,
-0.6037055850028992,
-0.704335629940033,
-0.28926676511764526,
-0.1768987625837326,
-0.02551390789449215,
-0.2835705280303955,
0.15002548694610596,
-0.244845911860466,
1.2436285018920898,
-0.36317679286003113,
-0.4078654944896698,
-0.424042671918869,
-0.09544683247804642,
-0.04141140356659889,
0.23491643369197845,
0.727258563041687,
-0.7787609696388245,
-0.4451267123222351,
0.0372081883251667,
-0.8997396230697632,
-0.06840214878320694,
-0.31385818123817444,
-0.22550424933433533,
-0.008094923570752144,
0.32639068365097046,
-0.7252970933914185,
0.4641736149787903,
0.1716814935207367,
-0.6356314420700073,
0.225624218583107,
0.0705399438738823,
0.24509498476982117,
-1.2666510343551636,
-0.30123502016067505,
0.23893079161643982,
-0.07166306674480438,
-0.8792499303817749,
0.1538916528224945,
0.14948464930057526,
-0.0682414248585701,
-0.18546073138713837,
0.023237217217683792,
-0.2068556249141693,
-0.10955148935317993,
-0.2743366062641144,
0.2139074206352234,
0.338229238986969,
0.3969992399215698,
0.15633635222911835,
0.55335932970047,
0.6941328644752502,
-0.4800211489200592,
0.4188988208770752,
0.4340116083621979,
-0.09623043984174728,
1.1584242582321167,
-0.6394981145858765,
0.12433438748121262,
-0.5795039534568787,
0.2777225971221924,
-0.7175429463386536,
-0.209636852145195,
0.5552387237548828,
-0.5519477128982544,
0.3864707350730896,
-0.1673775613307953,
-0.2933823764324188,
-0.1396637260913849,
-0.7519673109054565,
0.25282713770866394,
0.19184625148773193,
-0.7240236401557922,
0.6668068766593933,
0.34637677669525146,
0.10273895412683487,
-0.8064537048339844,
-0.6536466479301453,
0.10026002675294876,
-0.13711994886398315,
-0.5697347521781921,
0.3084940016269684,
-0.040358129888772964,
-0.2245829999446869,
0.06085764989256859,
-0.08936367183923721,
-0.010671204887330532,
-0.23358102142810822,
0.14451387524604797,
0.3235439360141754,
-0.24508005380630493,
0.16346228122711182,
0.43051883578300476,
-0.09230028837919235,
0.13881424069404602,
-0.23681525886058807,
0.5365357995033264,
0.03517025709152222,
-0.522828996181488,
-0.4051455855369568,
0.37338709831237793,
0.6613301038742065,
-0.22044308483600616,
0.8224926590919495,
0.5150030255317688,
-0.42611008882522583,
-0.3134130537509918,
-0.033813636749982834,
0.005910209845751524,
-0.4494444727897644,
0.33761656284332275,
-0.4256971776485443,
-0.4876987934112549,
0.3171142637729645,
0.061727456748485565,
0.0796419084072113,
0.31133636832237244,
0.29469114542007446,
-0.12067478895187378,
0.9597366452217102,
0.397051066160202,
0.08991850167512894,
0.49471035599708557,
-0.3474789559841156,
0.2647986114025116,
-0.9789106845855713,
-0.3163118064403534,
-0.09047392755746841,
-0.3979029059410095,
-0.14278219640254974,
-0.3858628571033478,
0.008816140703856945,
0.0424627885222435,
-0.19401949644088745,
0.5130899548530579,
-0.6337423920631409,
0.5287313461303711,
-0.22267748415470123,
0.2991042137145996,
0.16145198047161102,
-0.009247366338968277,
0.1785866767168045,
-0.18686658143997192,
-0.5144521594047546,
-0.32932227849960327,
1.1763756275177002,
0.3822239935398102,
0.5497020483016968,
0.20136675238609314,
0.8164361119270325,
0.340410053730011,
-0.004723929800093174,
-1.2806953191757202,
0.620347797870636,
0.07139435410499573,
-0.2770322561264038,
-0.06490065157413483,
-0.1304425746202469,
-0.5582261085510254,
0.22973960638046265,
-0.32185986638069153,
-0.19240814447402954,
0.732412576675415,
-0.06008840352296829,
-0.4955401122570038,
0.3746770918369293,
-0.4613923132419586,
0.674491822719574,
-0.03841415420174599,
-0.3560206890106201,
-0.0008749704575166106,
-0.244108185172081,
0.1978151649236679,
0.14426212012767792,
-0.15105696022510529,
0.09735529869794846,
-0.23479175567626953,
0.7903496026992798,
-0.2926980257034302,
0.7478252649307251,
-0.400485634803772,
-0.30130887031555176,
0.32014742493629456,
-0.031170234084129333,
0.4868289828300476,
-0.09879521280527115,
-0.37381067872047424,
-0.14742115139961243,
-0.3292006254196167,
-0.37637993693351746,
-0.688894510269165,
0.6943967938423157,
-0.39004039764404297,
-0.41056331992149353,
-0.4515867829322815,
-0.5724801421165466,
-0.1775248944759369,
0.07627829909324646,
0.13571053743362427,
0.45259857177734375,
-0.3733322322368622,
0.31063005328178406,
0.6888803243637085,
-0.07064960896968842,
0.45814260840415955,
0.5154512524604797,
0.12419161200523376,
-0.36701446771621704,
0.7165095806121826,
0.08260054886341095,
0.1584816724061966,
0.19227918982505798,
-0.28109410405158997,
-0.4735829830169678,
-0.571282684803009,
-0.8195076584815979,
-0.10033410042524338,
-0.9008418917655945,
-0.36254769563674927,
-0.5883753895759583,
-0.016460493206977844,
-0.3219574987888336,
-0.41868865489959717,
-0.25786611437797546,
-0.35332393646240234,
-0.2765028774738312,
-0.7477506995201111,
0.6997981071472168,
0.43866026401519775,
0.06716711074113846,
0.19647490978240967,
-0.36242902278900146,
0.49676546454429626,
0.004955466836690903,
0.46024617552757263,
-0.4447520077228546,
-0.4316226541996002,
0.077314592897892,
0.3489549160003662,
-0.02337820455431938,
-1.152675747871399,
0.4947241246700287,
0.2222159057855606,
0.36044034361839294,
0.6449395418167114,
0.494465172290802,
0.5151341557502747,
-0.2023182511329651,
0.5849941968917847,
0.49733543395996094,
-0.8387985825538635,
0.7609846591949463,
-0.4322737157344818,
-0.003728288458660245,
0.5035924315452576,
0.26673105359077454,
-0.190437451004982,
0.057590119540691376,
-0.4974196255207062,
-0.630738377571106,
0.702729344367981,
0.012623216025531292,
0.2572355568408966,
-0.359018474817276,
0.45205533504486084,
-0.04291118308901787,
0.10752397775650024,
-0.5414959192276001,
-0.0939033254981041,
-0.4489375054836273,
-0.612697184085846,
0.41074857115745544,
-0.05492890998721123,
-0.11997340619564056,
-0.4092382788658142,
0.3333502411842346,
-0.3573136031627655,
0.040033478289842606,
0.4433642625808716,
-0.30305761098861694,
-0.18488381803035736,
0.41320672631263733,
0.29178810119628906,
0.2060077041387558,
-0.28540968894958496,
-0.07753979414701462,
0.23172301054000854,
-0.5215854644775391,
0.26331761479377747,
0.09072491526603699,
-0.6661807894706726,
0.25691524147987366,
-0.055494584143161774,
1.0567834377288818,
0.002254822291433811,
-0.5784065127372742,
0.725193202495575,
0.20899808406829834,
-0.20152583718299866,
-0.12038421630859375,
0.045613907277584076,
-0.22969482839107513,
0.1527228057384491,
0.25000905990600586,
0.15497903525829315,
0.25582364201545715,
-0.6054068207740784,
0.4368588626384735,
0.4439217746257782,
-0.5929694175720215,
-0.4347996711730957,
0.4519970715045929,
0.2879495322704315,
-0.15585856139659882,
0.004777713678777218,
-0.519053041934967,
-0.48454219102859497,
0.7593623995780945,
0.6352951526641846,
0.8654659986495972,
-0.10819040983915329,
0.579294741153717,
0.466362327337265,
0.0755612850189209,
0.021674763411283493,
0.47115573287010193,
-0.09376083314418793,
-1.0870906114578247,
-0.3504752218723297,
-0.5153129696846008,
-0.29756641387939453,
-0.09707566350698471,
-0.9668970108032227,
0.5703238248825073,
-0.6868848204612732,
-0.1373148411512375,
0.0009344430291093886,
-0.2533900737762451,
-0.37313008308410645,
0.02203941158950329,
0.09464225172996521,
0.6262110471725464,
-0.7337336540222168,
0.8211737871170044,
0.8726921081542969,
-0.6480993032455444,
-0.4427553713321686,
0.13347487151622772,
-0.04984072595834732,
-0.4877569079399109,
0.36096641421318054,
0.0331781767308712,
-0.3412628471851349,
0.14489606022834778,
-0.38496366143226624,
-0.1368177831172943,
1.328878402709961,
0.4668479263782501,
-0.36000150442123413,
0.2532210946083069,
0.009748606011271477,
0.5137905478477478,
-0.6518498659133911,
0.1877089887857437,
0.673649251461029,
0.34307411313056946,
0.21919669210910797,
-0.2853330969810486,
0.1274489015340805,
-0.23679706454277039,
-0.2192869484424591,
0.31877031922340393,
-0.24512915313243866,
0.9578979015350342,
-0.07194003462791443,
-0.3916618227958679,
-0.3756800591945648,
0.5530406832695007,
0.0881972536444664,
0.4698975384235382,
0.2657962143421173,
0.8973343372344971,
0.5582672953605652,
0.07454933971166611,
1.0590906143188477,
-0.2687520384788513,
0.22476401925086975,
0.8048700094223022,
-0.6878606677055359,
0.9998750686645508,
0.3433258831501007,
0.06668638437986374,
0.8577682971954346,
0.25545865297317505,
0.12233635038137436,
0.521813154220581,
-0.5321555733680725,
-0.6918440461158752,
-0.20500056445598602,
-0.3662102222442627,
-0.17975623905658722,
0.5058135390281677,
0.6814444661140442,
-0.38340774178504944,
-0.5637911558151245,
0.15377852320671082,
-0.05039042979478836,
0.46622955799102783,
-0.4339075982570648,
0.8815956115722656,
-0.27072376012802124,
-0.2960696816444397,
0.4788157045841217,
0.13760297000408173,
0.9336207509040833,
-0.5515201091766357,
-0.10552108287811279,
-0.1312176138162613,
0.27068260312080383,
-0.3096775710582733,
-1.149660348892212,
0.38638877868652344,
0.24698971211910248,
-0.21811731159687042,
-0.16568858921527863,
0.9904542565345764,
-0.7133133411407471,
-0.23908381164073944,
0.3325268030166626,
0.4255342483520508,
-0.20963630080223083,
0.02213376574218273,
-0.5182077884674072,
-0.00650362903252244,
0.033445071429014206,
-0.01972559653222561,
0.455867737531662,
0.5744584798812866,
0.24725961685180664,
0.2909031808376312,
0.7629268169403076,
0.0056752790696918964,
-0.25533774495124817,
0.11335711926221848,
1.180657148361206,
-0.3927282691001892,
-0.6486716866493225,
-0.8165338039398193,
0.32766929268836975,
-0.41494691371917725,
-0.15328672528266907,
0.8712953329086304,
0.40445366501808167,
0.6356390118598938,
-0.01375534851104021,
0.7215683460235596,
-0.1856241077184677,
0.24324801564216614,
-0.4518355429172516,
0.7215029001235962,
-0.13582587242126465,
0.27914193272590637,
-0.09968648105859756,
-0.803816556930542,
-0.2264770120382309,
0.8787068724632263,
-0.34356847405433655,
-0.39223167300224304,
0.362760066986084,
0.7852684855461121,
-0.10150700807571411,
0.015419232659041882,
0.2704428434371948,
-0.18970343470573425,
0.24651698768138885,
0.5085803270339966,
0.3705095946788788,
-0.6822239756584167,
0.4749397337436676,
-0.014651075936853886,
-0.23057973384857178,
0.03624466806650162,
-0.7454125285148621,
-0.8171887397766113,
-0.3667217791080475,
-0.5198280215263367,
-0.2803342640399933,
0.11481234431266785,
1.3056342601776123,
0.363719642162323,
-0.801384687423706,
0.216146782040596,
-0.3654920160770416,
0.016749244183301926,
-0.11034758388996124,
-0.2549709975719452,
0.20112831890583038,
-0.2215024083852768,
-0.7511017918586731,
0.6204833984375,
0.4441703259944916,
-0.05634155869483948,
-0.00572547223418951,
-0.5362316966056824,
-0.38985350728034973,
0.2725300192832947,
0.7781177163124084,
0.41065940260887146,
-0.36738094687461853,
-0.23146674036979675,
0.21438071131706238,
0.028339805081486702,
0.25346094369888306,
0.6006759405136108,
-0.9101168513298035,
0.7438796162605286,
0.6241767406463623,
0.8802416920661926,
0.01178625039756298,
0.3324679732322693,
0.6433886289596558,
-0.9886264801025391,
0.44854772090911865,
0.40150946378707886,
0.3639971911907196,
0.44137534499168396,
-0.4311598539352417,
0.27216652035713196,
0.29291051626205444,
0.18424242734909058,
-0.7540649771690369,
0.27853527665138245,
-1.0362675189971924,
-0.19431504607200623,
1.1565839052200317,
-0.1782454550266266,
-0.25035548210144043,
-0.36782288551330566,
-0.2442474365234375,
0.2814624011516571,
-0.5889567136764526,
0.3825240135192871,
0.5381722450256348,
0.029350053519010544,
-0.3511306941509247,
-0.2848486602306366,
0.4722260534763336,
0.31597116589546204,
-0.74774169921875,
0.19407881796360016,
0.7885516881942749,
0.047806546092033386,
0.1657554805278778,
0.594314694404602,
-0.04583964869379997,
0.3521811366081238,
0.25405484437942505,
0.1254633665084839,
-0.3507167398929596,
-0.1909414827823639,
-0.5646151304244995,
0.04053575173020363,
-0.28876879811286926,
-0.5276380777359009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15699v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15699v2
|
FEEL: A Framework for Evaluating Emotional Support Capability with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-23T03:32:26 | 2024-05-16T02:15:38 |
Huaiwen Zhang, Yu Chen, Ming Wang, Shi Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotional Support Conversation (ESC) is a typical dialogue that can
effectively assist the user in mitigating emotional pressures. However, owing
to the inherent subjectivity involved in analyzing emotions, current
non-artificial methodologies face challenges in effectively appraising the
emotional support capability. These metrics exhibit a low correlation with
human judgments. Concurrently, manual evaluation methods extremely will cause
high costs. To solve these problems, we propose a novel model FEEL (Framework
for Evaluating Emotional Support Capability with Large Lan-guage Models),
employing Large Language Models (LLMs) as evaluators to assess emotional
support capabilities. The model meticulously considers various evaluative
aspects of ESC to apply a more comprehensive and accurate evaluation method for
ESC. Additionally, it employs a probability distribution approach for a more
stable result and integrates an ensemble learning strategy, leveraging multiple
LLMs with assigned weights to enhance evaluation accuracy. To appraise the
performance of FEEL, we conduct extensive experiments on existing ESC model
dialogues. Experimental results demonstrate our model exhibits a substantial
enhancement in alignment with human evaluations compared to the baselines. Our
source code is available at https://github.com/Ansisy/FEEL.
|
[
-0.4691753387451172,
-0.5692235231399536,
0.6167684197425842,
0.48774904012680054,
-0.05351393297314644,
0.020820293575525284,
-0.5112133026123047,
-0.4856681525707245,
0.40493065118789673,
0.08514975011348724,
-0.7609019875526428,
-0.43636536598205566,
-0.3902629315853119,
0.23631982505321503,
-0.20718514919281006,
0.9838207960128784,
-0.018215764313936234,
0.11998654156923294,
-0.23608943819999695,
-0.3629053831100464,
-0.09554203599691391,
-0.3756973147392273,
-0.7083380818367004,
-0.34044650197029114,
0.46192625164985657,
0.32229453325271606,
0.3052549660205841,
-0.296459823846817,
0.34567922353744507,
0.31823238730430603,
-0.27940359711647034,
0.11630377173423767,
-0.3790285587310791,
0.17869584262371063,
0.180794820189476,
-0.28526169061660767,
-0.8911412954330444,
-0.3638572692871094,
0.4244682788848877,
0.3306112587451935,
-0.6859531998634338,
-0.012431434355676174,
0.17782674729824066,
0.8053833246231079,
-0.41224217414855957,
0.1148018017411232,
-0.43821385502815247,
0.15640702843666077,
0.31451550126075745,
0.2302728146314621,
-0.5968262553215027,
-0.1881152093410492,
0.11754269897937775,
-0.3337891399860382,
-0.4822198748588562,
0.0017305145738646388,
0.6296460032463074,
0.10083317756652832,
-0.4182685315608978,
-0.24320167303085327,
-0.29743871092796326,
0.7767740488052368,
-0.8094229102134705,
0.5035458207130432,
0.21182425320148468,
0.09555312246084213,
0.2396649867296219,
-0.17782844603061676,
-0.7577095031738281,
-0.5735621452331543,
0.37828779220581055,
0.32967478036880493,
-0.3199153542518616,
0.3371392488479614,
0.20853736996650696,
0.33347412943840027,
-0.48923712968826294,
0.2438027262687683,
0.014710078947246075,
0.0067670634016394615,
0.716884195804596,
0.21239487826824188,
0.48086801171302795,
0.004824790172278881,
-0.42032390832901,
-0.004772793967276812,
-0.2241731882095337,
0.18920958042144775,
0.46131929755210876,
0.34467795491218567,
-0.4219101071357727,
0.49257299304008484,
-0.233113095164299,
0.5680955052375793,
0.05182304233312607,
0.3517169952392578,
0.3485240936279297,
0.3121086061000824,
-0.3812672197818756,
-0.04620339721441269,
0.7429929971694946,
0.48025092482566833,
0.4595230221748352,
0.1785127818584442,
-0.3372611999511719,
0.17922623455524445,
0.44800931215286255,
-0.8382567167282104,
0.1559258997440338,
0.29487326741218567,
-0.7347635626792908,
-0.31981906294822693,
-0.11562582105398178,
-0.8030970096588135,
-0.7911399006843567,
-0.5061728358268738,
0.10975046455860138,
-0.3985857665538788,
-0.5103833079338074,
0.12967541813850403,
0.27138787508010864,
0.29093292355537415,
0.49359825253486633,
-0.7154890298843384,
0.5372682809829712,
0.6137908697128296,
0.9521719217300415,
-0.1682112216949463,
-0.13421663641929626,
-0.32572174072265625,
-0.5125097036361694,
0.0007611064938828349,
0.742254912853241,
-0.55692058801651,
-0.33211755752563477,
0.13385866582393646,
0.06366317719221115,
0.14773093163967133,
-0.2073868215084076,
0.825691282749176,
-0.20370419323444366,
-0.051399704068899155,
-0.25160735845565796,
-0.5292443633079529,
0.030454369261860847,
0.4632114768028259,
-0.6177817583084106,
0.8623507022857666,
0.05121967941522598,
-0.5117278695106506,
0.12484022229909897,
-0.8402774333953857,
-0.3864400088787079,
-0.06176552549004555,
0.11209483444690704,
-0.16758495569229126,
0.4400726556777954,
-0.04649927094578743,
0.5811182856559753,
-0.26303741335868835,
0.08817506581544876,
-0.8090211153030396,
-0.256452351808548,
0.2861148715019226,
-0.22123335301876068,
0.27752381563186646,
0.3273240327835083,
-0.1843351274728775,
0.12354543805122375,
-0.5911242961883545,
0.0828571617603302,
-0.198031485080719,
-0.13438139855861664,
-0.40917783975601196,
0.05296182259917259,
0.2454148828983307,
0.2867882549762726,
0.30790501832962036,
-0.7351111769676208,
0.3496710956096649,
-0.5282150506973267,
0.2203785926103592,
0.8446352481842041,
-0.27125605940818787,
0.4584105610847473,
0.13344259560108185,
0.8561145067214966,
-0.16209633648395538,
0.13578234612941742,
-0.053951915353536606,
-0.28411638736724854,
-0.4814581274986267,
-0.18310227990150452,
-0.17560186982154846,
0.358685702085495,
-0.34399107098579407,
0.4337165951728821,
-0.08322132378816605,
-0.6320452094078064,
-0.44125670194625854,
0.01316579058766365,
0.3294355273246765,
0.38365381956100464,
0.2211257666349411,
-0.20143721997737885,
-0.614199697971344,
-0.8949713110923767,
-0.2024330049753189,
-0.4362189471721649,
-0.06816548109054565,
0.560248851776123,
0.25659415125846863,
-0.14138329029083252,
0.7735977172851562,
-0.37052538990974426,
-0.18234434723854065,
-0.20780523121356964,
0.14429573714733124,
-0.0403759628534317,
0.11196406185626984,
0.3577546775341034,
-0.5467499494552612,
-0.3534773290157318,
0.2567172646522522,
-0.6511322259902954,
-0.5146329402923584,
0.19908373057842255,
-0.15140525996685028,
0.49910810589790344,
0.1193566620349884,
-0.6365430951118469,
0.2957708537578583,
1.055922269821167,
-0.6283247470855713,
0.5714037418365479,
-0.09824573248624802,
0.4812581539154053,
-1.0417841672897339,
0.13490712642669678,
0.37601280212402344,
-0.1339445561170578,
-0.3685462772846222,
-0.13117565214633942,
0.16628369688987732,
-0.28025737404823303,
-0.33813661336898804,
0.7526647448539734,
-0.3172816038131714,
-0.011994760483503342,
-0.18157976865768433,
0.263393759727478,
0.028511613607406616,
0.41111525893211365,
0.08730315417051315,
0.41889825463294983,
0.3907132148742676,
-0.32900863885879517,
0.5950992703437805,
0.22137337923049927,
-0.294773668050766,
1.310797095298767,
-0.8032830953598022,
0.13526928424835205,
-0.04502410069108009,
0.4874492287635803,
-1.012087106704712,
-0.014787549152970314,
-0.30093619227409363,
-0.3808377981185913,
0.22273673117160797,
-0.0315517894923687,
-0.10616903007030487,
-0.4904937744140625,
-0.18442124128341675,
-0.00398144731298089,
0.38574662804603577,
-0.40888097882270813,
1.0468826293945312,
0.38668787479400635,
-0.2197807878255844,
-0.4169790744781494,
-0.6655794382095337,
0.22697782516479492,
-0.41271910071372986,
-0.8634039759635925,
0.024411942809820175,
-0.31966957449913025,
-0.34867623448371887,
-0.13369961082935333,
-0.029047200456261635,
-0.0025462741032242775,
0.22817060351371765,
0.6275901794433594,
0.0635581761598587,
0.06911126524209976,
0.6368535757064819,
0.038607120513916016,
0.0819653645157814,
0.07712921500205994,
-0.1686066836118698,
0.5490754246711731,
-0.628139853477478,
-0.5784529447555542,
-0.3515082597732544,
0.4245193600654602,
0.8519494533538818,
-0.34857335686683655,
0.7003681063652039,
0.6086534857749939,
-0.5679233074188232,
-0.3275744318962097,
-0.621225893497467,
-0.3483644723892212,
-0.4206477403640747,
0.6748548746109009,
-0.393574982881546,
-0.7676281332969666,
0.7622726559638977,
-0.08237963914871216,
-0.12435039132833481,
0.06963670998811722,
0.6759824752807617,
-0.07838484644889832,
1.4120533466339111,
0.4994320571422577,
-0.24967175722122192,
0.44839340448379517,
0.16099227964878082,
0.32216477394104004,
-0.8286644220352173,
-0.26447486877441406,
-0.4800143241882324,
-0.5057064890861511,
0.0031139503698796034,
-0.08081047981977463,
0.19836007058620453,
-0.19954679906368256,
-0.3676217794418335,
0.10560660809278488,
-0.20364594459533691,
-0.008493445813655853,
-0.2474784255027771,
0.24271824955940247,
-0.043991006910800934,
-0.04477382078766823,
-0.17366839945316315,
-0.19652429223060608,
-0.20001423358917236,
-0.666438102722168,
0.610568642616272,
0.6701469421386719,
0.8591388463973999,
0.3285689949989319,
0.39271965622901917,
0.5785916447639465,
0.4841592311859131,
-1.1495836973190308,
0.5903365015983582,
-0.10749003291130066,
-0.16386926174163818,
-0.22956280410289764,
-0.3708879351615906,
-0.6065184473991394,
-0.0873132050037384,
-0.4266788959503174,
-1.1783726215362549,
-0.21493175625801086,
0.09681779891252518,
-0.3806285560131073,
0.1849057376384735,
-1.0083978176116943,
0.7753240466117859,
-0.22191530466079712,
-0.44971150159835815,
-0.41164228320121765,
-0.23320625722408295,
0.12212897092103958,
-0.008868660777807236,
0.13146069645881653,
-0.09559263288974762,
0.049513161182403564,
0.6881169676780701,
-0.4085932672023773,
0.8214433789253235,
-0.40403127670288086,
-0.29934874176979065,
0.24643585085868835,
0.3165420591831207,
0.7132190465927124,
-0.19269663095474243,
-0.6589199304580688,
-0.13468360900878906,
-0.12085293233394623,
-0.20980548858642578,
-0.9677327871322632,
0.9174684882164001,
-0.667969286441803,
-0.1624051332473755,
0.03468878194689751,
-0.13534203171730042,
-0.5719970464706421,
-0.2404240220785141,
-0.3524188995361328,
0.29253941774368286,
-0.5191402435302734,
0.37798476219177246,
0.5696427822113037,
-0.3866174519062042,
0.3748129606246948,
0.6241309642791748,
-0.33727380633354187,
-0.0988185778260231,
0.5473989844322205,
-0.15920881927013397,
0.2204790860414505,
0.22688643634319305,
0.32351404428482056,
-0.4715786576271057,
-0.0027945421170443296,
-0.3102357089519501,
0.1666053980588913,
-0.4527709186077118,
-0.31488746404647827,
-0.8247218132019043,
0.2748425602912903,
-0.2727542817592621,
-0.15755672752857208,
-0.5497440695762634,
-0.00530448742210865,
-0.03075912781059742,
-0.6343982815742493,
0.6394791007041931,
0.6816263794898987,
0.17072808742523193,
0.33473777770996094,
-0.7549733519554138,
-0.15639495849609375,
0.31894466280937195,
0.7058189511299133,
0.19580502808094025,
-0.4701592028141022,
-0.3783590495586395,
-0.009879360906779766,
-0.17151802778244019,
-1.152265191078186,
0.5597158074378967,
0.26502087712287903,
0.303282231092453,
0.5238358378410339,
0.20223654806613922,
0.5525009632110596,
-0.19933561980724335,
0.9135929346084595,
0.313027560710907,
-1.3774805068969727,
0.48467573523521423,
-0.42787599563598633,
0.08522602170705795,
0.4377240836620331,
0.15719029307365417,
-0.7160930633544922,
-0.06653640419244766,
-0.7313469648361206,
-0.8056048154830933,
0.5811464786529541,
-0.1225784569978714,
0.3906596302986145,
0.008206595666706562,
0.05647144094109535,
-0.4152739942073822,
0.2567845284938812,
-0.5748036503791809,
0.16586996614933014,
0.2964172065258026,
-0.7343065142631531,
0.09332688897848129,
-0.44060006737709045,
-0.02683469094336033,
0.2693406641483307,
0.5959655046463013,
-0.43493062257766724,
0.37669992446899414,
0.20298965275287628,
0.028628086671233177,
-0.35500720143318176,
0.3759669363498688,
0.36066576838493347,
0.19156238436698914,
-0.06059472635388374,
-0.08610117435455322,
0.6632134318351746,
-0.13367965817451477,
-0.0668845921754837,
-0.08014407008886337,
0.5244766473770142,
-0.45090019702911377,
0.06428202986717224,
1.0156657695770264,
0.29920119047164917,
-0.9893808364868164,
0.7280033826828003,
-0.2434481680393219,
0.029762813821434975,
-0.33742213249206543,
-0.2078634351491928,
0.24945729970932007,
0.3418935537338257,
0.2588416039943695,
-0.10642664134502411,
0.1824532002210617,
-0.40601587295532227,
0.30151045322418213,
0.3633742332458496,
-0.904480516910553,
-0.5645416378974915,
0.1343936026096344,
0.4129170775413513,
-0.3492770493030548,
0.48753681778907776,
-0.14839811623096466,
-0.8227331042289734,
0.6450141668319702,
0.32586008310317993,
0.8496708869934082,
-0.6126255989074707,
0.37265998125076294,
0.3451444208621979,
0.07262077927589417,
-0.21382613480091095,
0.531512439250946,
-0.019689815118908882,
-0.7788965702056885,
-0.4737623929977417,
-0.6113496422767639,
-0.47881296277046204,
-0.15190373361110687,
-0.7596916556358337,
0.5387897491455078,
-0.2782191336154938,
-0.2843031585216522,
-0.5328342318534851,
0.21863152086734772,
-0.7796667814254761,
0.40360939502716064,
0.6357825398445129,
0.8928142786026001,
-1.165928602218628,
0.41948819160461426,
0.9344401359558105,
-0.065017469227314,
-1.293975830078125,
-0.3853771984577179,
0.22525379061698914,
-0.8553347587585449,
0.4823518991470337,
0.25751686096191406,
-0.2988985478878021,
-0.18480831384658813,
-0.4773857891559601,
-0.28890517354011536,
0.9413481950759888,
0.2565615475177765,
-0.6991276144981384,
0.304701030254364,
-0.49774256348609924,
1.03537118434906,
-0.6656548976898193,
1.0196279287338257,
0.21029676496982574,
0.5993199348449707,
-0.15053541958332062,
-0.9444032907485962,
0.042367350310087204,
-0.53351891040802,
-0.22384580969810486,
-0.06517070531845093,
-0.8725972771644592,
0.47296053171157837,
-0.15163786709308624,
-0.07210076600313187,
0.09050093591213226,
0.5574960112571716,
0.5178514122962952,
0.4638731777667999,
0.8855398893356323,
0.7027980089187622,
0.9794968366622925,
-0.0037551408167928457,
1.0534741878509521,
-0.3812774419784546,
0.5958724617958069,
0.8508058786392212,
-0.7667691111564636,
0.9965001344680786,
0.45318594574928284,
-0.2699175179004669,
0.7189236283302307,
0.4339166283607483,
0.30522480607032776,
-0.09386659413576126,
0.5871323347091675,
-0.3962433636188507,
-0.3888859152793884,
-0.45378583669662476,
-0.10199665278196335,
0.6496026515960693,
0.39306116104125977,
-0.34622639417648315,
0.14296218752861023,
0.041805192828178406,
0.06839296221733093,
0.24175573885440826,
-0.2982475459575653,
0.6270475387573242,
0.26563596725463867,
-0.530737578868866,
0.1097283586859703,
-0.1537717878818512,
0.6136746406555176,
-0.7811638712882996,
0.009311812929809093,
-0.28162550926208496,
0.024239102378487587,
-0.5340706706047058,
-0.8110024333000183,
0.14775249361991882,
0.4779650866985321,
-0.003200487233698368,
-0.2897287607192993,
0.7310740947723389,
-0.27926987409591675,
-0.3959183990955353,
0.6997397541999817,
0.5147874355316162,
0.14235356450080872,
-0.3205723762512207,
-0.5968164801597595,
0.2954597473144531,
-0.05059428513050079,
-0.7645057439804077,
0.3210892975330353,
0.6876479387283325,
0.12423202395439148,
0.7912561297416687,
0.47546106576919556,
0.13500234484672546,
-0.4425913095474243,
0.5300717353820801,
0.6391240954399109,
-0.48214495182037354,
-0.5789914727210999,
-0.7973899245262146,
0.8358591794967651,
-0.18812720477581024,
-0.2585255205631256,
0.5150606036186218,
0.11614906042814255,
0.16004790365695953,
0.10223342478275299,
0.6857430934906006,
-0.15443289279937744,
0.2381918728351593,
-0.37154579162597656,
0.6659345626831055,
-0.6972894072532654,
0.28449568152427673,
-0.6763901114463806,
-0.9735801815986633,
-0.12420034408569336,
0.7277970314025879,
-0.3842742145061493,
0.3058580756187439,
0.35670384764671326,
0.7727310657501221,
0.07429643720388412,
0.38315340876579285,
0.576137363910675,
0.45913922786712646,
0.31406083703041077,
0.6846171021461487,
1.2375980615615845,
-0.017256539314985275,
0.18627989292144775,
0.19266203045845032,
-0.34989190101623535,
-0.03683573007583618,
-1.1815540790557861,
-0.5554379820823669,
-0.6015393137931824,
-0.27263781428337097,
-0.47717949748039246,
-0.05113091319799423,
1.3362274169921875,
0.8980894684791565,
-0.5378527045249939,
-0.23422804474830627,
0.007588420528918505,
-0.21999958157539368,
-0.0912371575832367,
-0.27087700366973877,
0.0533955879509449,
-0.1873256415128708,
-0.7721733450889587,
0.3327745497226715,
0.23719049990177155,
-0.18835528194904327,
-0.3596717119216919,
-0.4264030456542969,
0.12558436393737793,
0.025878306478261948,
0.7434121370315552,
0.15326350927352905,
-0.41687774658203125,
-0.4653690755367279,
0.3010171055793762,
-0.05875509977340698,
-0.23554028570652008,
0.7705127000808716,
-0.6658904552459717,
0.4495088458061218,
0.39926621317863464,
0.6733750104904175,
0.12768512964248657,
0.11891771852970123,
0.734473466873169,
-0.6480481028556824,
-0.05785273760557175,
0.10400918126106262,
0.6163907051086426,
0.41892459988594055,
-0.4850798547267914,
0.40219712257385254,
-0.12413770705461502,
-0.607100248336792,
-0.8418545722961426,
0.24900174140930176,
-1.31231689453125,
0.15628927946090698,
1.3757728338241577,
-0.5071669816970825,
-0.08089221268892288,
0.3519337773323059,
-0.5340542197227478,
0.25209134817123413,
-0.8679189682006836,
0.587544858455658,
0.8255730271339417,
-0.14925816655158997,
-0.26354238390922546,
-0.21559619903564453,
0.13719971477985382,
0.689558207988739,
-0.7402431964874268,
0.24625684320926666,
0.5219148993492126,
-0.04296259209513664,
-0.06703834980726242,
0.4504215121269226,
0.054141949862241745,
-0.2602246403694153,
-0.421429306268692,
0.5617722272872925,
0.06587204337120056,
-0.11793479323387146,
-0.8635851740837097,
0.1685141772031784,
0.1313471794128418,
0.3740209639072418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15696v1
|
MixRED: A Mix-lingual Relation Extraction Dataset
| 2024-03-23T03:18:14 | 2024-03-23T03:18:14 |
Lingxing Kong, Yougang Chu, Zheng Ma, Jianbing Zhang, Liang He, Jiajun Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Relation extraction is a critical task in the field of natural language
processing with numerous real-world applications. Existing research primarily
focuses on monolingual relation extraction or cross-lingual enhancement for
relation extraction. Yet, there remains a significant gap in understanding
relation extraction in the mix-lingual (or code-switching) scenario, where
individuals intermix contents from different languages within sentences,
generating mix-lingual content. Due to the lack of a dedicated dataset, the
effectiveness of existing relation extraction models in such a scenario is
largely unexplored. To address this issue, we introduce a novel task of
considering relation extraction in the mix-lingual scenario called MixRE and
constructing the human-annotated dataset MixRED to support this task. In
addition to constructing the MixRED dataset, we evaluate both state-of-the-art
supervised models and large language models (LLMs) on MixRED, revealing their
respective advantages and limitations in the mix-lingual scenario. Furthermore,
we delve into factors influencing model performance within the MixRE task and
uncover promising directions for enhancing the performance of both supervised
models and LLMs in this novel task.
|
[
-0.6214345097541809,
-0.7024267911911011,
-0.008865796960890293,
0.42087239027023315,
-0.15622757375240326,
0.05047256499528885,
-0.3293088674545288,
-0.9372009634971619,
0.14595429599285126,
0.6694607138633728,
-0.6047605276107788,
-0.21602042019367218,
-0.5519505739212036,
0.28364595770835876,
-0.4422151744365692,
1.1416337490081787,
-0.17019164562225342,
0.056588027626276016,
-0.19074636697769165,
-0.048742733895778656,
-0.5476593971252441,
-0.5830220580101013,
-0.26591363549232483,
-0.6441459655761719,
0.554639995098114,
0.6488583087921143,
0.6826382875442505,
0.3902309536933899,
0.42946070432662964,
0.1454351246356964,
-0.1490737348794937,
0.31309881806373596,
-0.66730797290802,
0.2880415618419647,
-0.04505732282996178,
-0.21963787078857422,
-0.34229251742362976,
-0.03210771456360817,
0.3928726017475128,
0.9282591342926025,
-0.09501469135284424,
0.1714673638343811,
-0.21076110005378723,
0.49553415179252625,
-0.7088714838027954,
0.25892457365989685,
-0.5495980978012085,
0.03975008428096771,
-0.3212231993675232,
-0.16888956725597382,
-0.3704129755496979,
-0.00855118315666914,
0.15947981178760529,
-0.5744286775588989,
0.14743295311927795,
0.06249329447746277,
0.9570881128311157,
-0.17782548069953918,
-0.4446791708469391,
-0.29283198714256287,
-0.8859525918960571,
0.5711560249328613,
-0.4764178395271301,
0.7944338917732239,
0.41628047823905945,
0.3251824975013733,
-0.030283374711871147,
-0.6071885228157043,
-0.44303473830223083,
0.23038814961910248,
-0.2466307133436203,
0.09763675928115845,
0.07972897589206696,
-0.29282015562057495,
0.2177787870168686,
0.7228509187698364,
-0.23081262409687042,
-0.07176107168197632,
-0.3615935444831848,
-0.07468759268522263,
0.6715927720069885,
0.12277916818857193,
0.7227946519851685,
-0.29288551211357117,
-0.4689885377883911,
-0.03560461476445198,
-0.6657038927078247,
-0.20730210840702057,
0.28329402208328247,
0.5243414044380188,
-0.09891358017921448,
0.7978593111038208,
-0.2002311795949936,
0.685810387134552,
0.07732778787612915,
-0.011514139361679554,
0.030133863911032677,
-0.6235836744308472,
-0.23762065172195435,
0.027677156031131744,
0.7496362328529358,
0.31414106488227844,
0.5090851187705994,
-0.47264397144317627,
-0.38962748646736145,
0.22215516865253448,
-0.14008361101150513,
-0.8099497556686401,
-0.6260939836502075,
0.0445379801094532,
-0.3947363495826721,
-0.27531513571739197,
0.0479007214307785,
-0.8875558376312256,
-0.20608004927635193,
-0.37539565563201904,
0.1582677960395813,
-0.42823803424835205,
-0.866596519947052,
0.18011489510536194,
-0.07436324656009674,
0.3250100910663605,
0.21351854503154755,
-1.1168020963668823,
0.6889813542366028,
0.8072940111160278,
0.5729761719703674,
-0.5389557480812073,
-0.3747890293598175,
-0.6071833968162537,
0.0817570611834526,
-0.17042192816734314,
0.4736781716346741,
-0.5982644557952881,
-0.38985028862953186,
-0.09932830929756165,
-0.05932992324233055,
-0.23154789209365845,
-0.8574605584144592,
0.29804959893226624,
-0.8419914245605469,
0.5923407673835754,
-0.22956497967243195,
-0.5800126791000366,
-0.19493530690670013,
0.18119856715202332,
-1.0653340816497803,
1.1058026552200317,
0.28476446866989136,
-1.2824256420135498,
0.5652673840522766,
-0.5379417538642883,
-0.7597118616104126,
0.28127288818359375,
-0.23782646656036377,
-0.1627291440963745,
-0.2538395822048187,
0.4794713854789734,
0.4955560863018036,
-0.3954126834869385,
0.29868459701538086,
-0.1731143593788147,
-0.226058229804039,
0.4739367663860321,
-0.0019217286026105285,
1.0576037168502808,
0.17214684188365936,
0.01914503611624241,
0.07466480880975723,
-0.6567574143409729,
-0.29238390922546387,
0.12968415021896362,
-0.41944634914398193,
-0.6429612636566162,
-0.1543523371219635,
0.6196413636207581,
0.6643922924995422,
0.21822533011436462,
-0.5419642329216003,
-0.022093210369348526,
-0.15592435002326965,
0.06029351428151131,
0.331916481256485,
0.24619223177433014,
0.6734039187431335,
-0.38127458095550537,
0.8734181523323059,
0.20811136066913605,
-0.17020411789417267,
-0.13407345116138458,
-0.40047726035118103,
-0.8015453219413757,
-0.5286871194839478,
0.7082584500312805,
0.6871834993362427,
-1.0109959840774536,
0.22158557176589966,
-0.4505038857460022,
0.007717658765614033,
-0.7693266272544861,
0.47518226504325867,
0.3874713182449341,
0.3919543921947479,
0.28399771451950073,
-0.11750862002372742,
-0.8066315650939941,
-0.8312941193580627,
-0.23223689198493958,
0.16890506446361542,
0.10851143300533295,
0.17186324298381805,
0.335303395986557,
-0.46240219473838806,
1.2765988111495972,
-0.4892503321170807,
-0.08314599096775055,
-0.6901364326477051,
-0.039262570440769196,
0.143037348985672,
0.4476628303527832,
0.23975327610969543,
-1.2583924531936646,
-0.4774550497531891,
0.3094351887702942,
-0.8281759023666382,
-0.07372074574232101,
-0.07982343435287476,
-0.38066089153289795,
-0.11561185866594315,
0.4591430425643921,
-0.4920310080051422,
0.11645890027284622,
0.6943736672401428,
-0.2369404137134552,
0.5775867700576782,
0.1086617186665535,
0.07951483875513077,
-1.0776394605636597,
0.07320516556501389,
0.12026708573102951,
-0.5744475722312927,
-0.7418556809425354,
0.24293217062950134,
0.18551333248615265,
-0.017739279195666313,
-0.4697796404361725,
0.6266722083091736,
-0.6408703327178955,
-0.39170098304748535,
0.13420307636260986,
-0.04139319062232971,
-0.057867590337991714,
0.47578686475753784,
0.3010616600513458,
0.6918038725852966,
0.3115273416042328,
-0.5663310885429382,
0.21756611764431,
0.39159828424453735,
-0.35135141015052795,
0.35717684030532837,
-0.4029027819633484,
-0.04285712167620659,
0.05183001980185509,
-0.1379033774137497,
-0.8726031184196472,
-0.47090545296669006,
0.258676141500473,
-0.1674177199602127,
0.38051867485046387,
-0.39484164118766785,
-0.7055487632751465,
0.13293233513832092,
0.052895985543727875,
0.637774646282196,
0.31239399313926697,
-0.8045096397399902,
0.48695677518844604,
0.6401876211166382,
-0.2920758128166199,
-0.3394993245601654,
-0.794756293296814,
0.15762118995189667,
-0.41096460819244385,
-0.7713644504547119,
0.2896812856197357,
-0.02199666202068329,
-0.5562759041786194,
0.04646486043930054,
-0.1367756575345993,
-0.4991636276245117,
-0.07679948955774307,
0.22640804946422577,
0.5301163196563721,
-0.1539442390203476,
-0.18387702107429504,
-0.03661343455314636,
-0.05118214711546898,
0.07863342016935349,
0.2769535481929779,
0.39696061611175537,
0.15987306833267212,
-0.040822312235832214,
0.023928862065076828,
0.4243014454841614,
0.3856296241283417,
-0.3054157495498657,
0.4965844452381134,
0.3082579970359802,
-0.5221906304359436,
-0.2979468107223511,
-0.45429718494415283,
-0.04784382879734039,
-0.4173906445503235,
0.3979574143886566,
-0.5825175046920776,
-0.9241573810577393,
0.7160613536834717,
-0.034698937088251114,
0.11066082864999771,
0.17356736958026886,
0.39937105774879456,
0.12329760193824768,
0.5580987334251404,
0.6471371650695801,
-0.14692071080207825,
0.5089486837387085,
-0.08236262947320938,
0.09819265455007553,
-0.8466451168060303,
-0.2479432225227356,
-0.1174253597855568,
-0.07771682739257812,
-0.5639777183532715,
-0.3949216306209564,
-0.11739242076873779,
0.12487801909446716,
0.205583393573761,
0.5707346200942993,
-0.006694561801850796,
0.49456787109375,
0.08118131011724472,
0.15652188658714294,
0.6373310089111328,
0.08380160480737686,
-0.08016497641801834,
-0.272816926240921,
-0.9777438044548035,
-0.0935775637626648,
0.9294577836990356,
0.2096903771162033,
0.7668139338493347,
-0.034011468291282654,
0.9600556492805481,
0.2031974345445633,
0.38183629512786865,
-0.7795209288597107,
0.5274165272712708,
-0.04552975296974182,
-0.7180310487747192,
-0.2074999213218689,
-0.8191602826118469,
-1.0818514823913574,
0.6765288710594177,
-0.23492231965065002,
-0.47707948088645935,
0.21997062861919403,
-0.17319262027740479,
0.26318061351776123,
0.0652860701084137,
-0.6469419002532959,
0.9237633943557739,
-0.30404677987098694,
-0.3661018908023834,
0.2686925232410431,
-0.6637873649597168,
0.8205180764198303,
-0.15140704810619354,
0.617526650428772,
0.05348590016365051,
0.2806917130947113,
0.8188267946243286,
-0.2793133854866028,
0.5762831568717957,
0.23528218269348145,
-0.3858622610569,
-0.14661449193954468,
0.45223268866539,
0.14611342549324036,
0.06195107847452164,
-0.06012324243783951,
0.09081307053565979,
-0.07736892998218536,
-0.18750904500484467,
-0.49249351024627686,
0.5337227582931519,
-0.4232233762741089,
0.052350837737321854,
-0.27045875787734985,
-0.7600423693656921,
-0.3156929314136505,
0.33643168210983276,
0.3048285245895386,
0.4644898772239685,
-0.42333555221557617,
-0.18556024134159088,
0.5469475388526917,
-0.029271820560097694,
0.4026300311088562,
0.2183891385793686,
-0.7595167756080627,
-0.5509440302848816,
0.9294348955154419,
-0.13046377897262573,
0.33541157841682434,
0.37613630294799805,
-0.14623869955539703,
-0.16727009415626526,
0.005302782636135817,
-0.38253751397132874,
0.36702173948287964,
-0.7415691018104553,
0.038313157856464386,
-0.5792115330696106,
-0.2169249802827835,
0.0011255028657615185,
0.06671792268753052,
-0.41359642148017883,
-0.4382794201374054,
-0.16943281888961792,
-0.027436718344688416,
0.22701920568943024,
0.6859325170516968,
0.17446143925189972,
-0.06008777767419815,
-0.7633056044578552,
0.6946315765380859,
0.3061850965023041,
0.29479825496673584,
-0.097652867436409,
-0.18000121414661407,
-0.1661873310804367,
0.07492043823003769,
0.4575998783111572,
-0.8681830167770386,
0.4518456757068634,
0.05801297724246979,
0.4931032359600067,
0.232540100812912,
-0.028017863631248474,
0.7507140636444092,
-0.2451624721288681,
0.24827370047569275,
0.2661565840244293,
-0.713813066482544,
0.24313701689243317,
-0.4744603633880615,
0.23467859625816345,
0.6501993536949158,
0.19562925398349762,
-0.6868030428886414,
-0.14605356752872467,
-0.6207047700881958,
-0.996809184551239,
0.8010507225990295,
0.4945157766342163,
-0.21907030045986176,
0.0063712215051054955,
0.0330091156065464,
0.3295152187347412,
0.20356839895248413,
-1.0022796392440796,
-0.1320267915725708,
0.3134494721889496,
-0.19892002642154694,
-0.09874948859214783,
-0.23861519992351532,
-0.07583990693092346,
-0.29778656363487244,
0.38588258624076843,
0.31621116399765015,
-0.07999537140130997,
-0.09682571142911911,
-0.6026076674461365,
-0.20078116655349731,
0.27657803893089294,
0.11278655380010605,
0.7819207310676575,
-0.3037175238132477,
0.17415300011634827,
-0.1085793673992157,
-0.2829859256744385,
-0.10670957714319229,
0.27047479152679443,
-0.2766835689544678,
0.05461111292243004,
0.5129141211509705,
0.5918591618537903,
0.7112372517585754,
-0.7957279682159424,
0.5595607161521912,
-0.18613217771053314,
-0.19106462597846985,
-0.08637918531894684,
-0.03648835048079491,
0.30858927965164185,
0.03165772557258606,
0.19474634528160095,
0.016597827896475792,
0.1177583560347557,
-0.5019184350967407,
0.46655556559562683,
0.10613463073968887,
-0.19148313999176025,
-0.1432308554649353,
0.43063095211982727,
0.23569652438163757,
-0.2403474748134613,
0.7354387044906616,
-0.16954605281352997,
-0.6715143918991089,
0.44003838300704956,
0.6747638583183289,
0.7475084662437439,
0.040384430438280106,
0.08471492677927017,
0.12799271941184998,
0.18483583629131317,
-0.2485177367925644,
0.1788649559020996,
-0.309827595949173,
-0.9932178258895874,
-0.5475480556488037,
-0.5204765200614929,
-0.4196231961250305,
-0.01125248335301876,
-1.040948748588562,
0.3693584203720093,
-0.01713011972606182,
0.16436612606048584,
-0.11358583718538284,
-0.15851682424545288,
-0.731489360332489,
0.2062102109193802,
0.1010083481669426,
0.6429046988487244,
-0.968568742275238,
0.7417535781860352,
0.800394594669342,
-0.31854382157325745,
-0.6027169823646545,
-0.003110946388915181,
-0.33269017934799194,
-0.40554752945899963,
0.8671436905860901,
0.11778663098812103,
-0.09740535914897919,
-0.15507780015468597,
-0.16451479494571686,
-0.4639451801776886,
0.7749176621437073,
0.3265531659126282,
-0.38989052176475525,
0.12346433848142624,
0.12830698490142822,
0.35705500841140747,
-0.6298103928565979,
0.010966925881803036,
0.7221044898033142,
0.20374727249145508,
0.2670474350452423,
-0.8306024670600891,
0.1092832088470459,
-0.44513580203056335,
-0.09253374487161636,
0.39790967106819153,
-0.20696668326854706,
0.895222544670105,
0.0745469331741333,
-0.36068829894065857,
-0.42644181847572327,
0.5880451202392578,
0.36487120389938354,
0.13473860919475555,
0.5744602680206299,
0.35193830728530884,
0.575953483581543,
0.17075137794017792,
0.9851486682891846,
-0.11845697462558746,
0.2098112553358078,
1.495711088180542,
-0.6220041513442993,
0.903031587600708,
0.5695953965187073,
-0.18383203446865082,
0.4212185740470886,
0.7286995649337769,
0.19851909577846527,
0.5213879942893982,
-0.1415465772151947,
-0.1631617397069931,
-0.5288011431694031,
0.15099450945854187,
-0.3150651156902313,
0.47666892409324646,
0.3709123730659485,
-0.30551233887672424,
-0.2913370132446289,
-0.21814264357089996,
0.0668894499540329,
-0.0404728464782238,
-0.050378087908029556,
0.8319490551948547,
-0.02087966352701187,
-0.6242631673812866,
0.47254320979118347,
-0.1262914538383484,
0.8270506858825684,
-0.3419322073459625,
-0.2057967185974121,
-0.25713399052619934,
0.006167196203023195,
-0.3399098515510559,
-0.6046293377876282,
0.027296921238303185,
-0.003372051753103733,
-0.26249831914901733,
-0.20245295763015747,
0.8522492051124573,
-1.006454586982727,
-0.6785962581634521,
0.6785195469856262,
0.7302839159965515,
-0.03494745120406151,
0.2059323787689209,
-0.5121976733207703,
0.15258300304412842,
0.09807760268449783,
-0.06245298683643341,
0.5170326232910156,
0.5475562214851379,
-0.10243313759565353,
0.5889455676078796,
0.7457982897758484,
0.31932899355888367,
0.20845066010951996,
0.19976459443569183,
0.9911774396896362,
-0.5537505745887756,
-0.6413827538490295,
-0.7027251124382019,
0.45725515484809875,
-0.20942102372646332,
-0.2713130712509155,
0.820287823677063,
0.7790536880493164,
0.8763446807861328,
0.021153228357434273,
0.9615510106086731,
-0.09403204172849655,
0.5210073590278625,
-0.5110234618186951,
0.47015124559402466,
-0.41756466031074524,
0.3613540530204773,
-0.5462666749954224,
-0.9379947185516357,
-0.365735799074173,
0.5225984454154968,
-0.18978796899318695,
0.09862688183784485,
0.4342134892940521,
0.5791155695915222,
-0.630889892578125,
0.11357332020998001,
0.05781875550746918,
-0.07603894174098969,
0.14861468970775604,
0.4882069528102875,
0.9729044437408447,
-0.37873879075050354,
0.49429234862327576,
-0.41797778010368347,
-0.11102386564016342,
-0.23111487925052643,
-0.8681590557098389,
-1.0480451583862305,
-0.4636075794696808,
-0.43555498123168945,
-0.1277162730693817,
-0.0246756449341774,
0.8336426019668579,
0.6802887320518494,
-0.693910539150238,
-0.6706432700157166,
-0.12544474005699158,
0.05899208039045334,
-0.20179332792758942,
-0.28713274002075195,
-0.08198569715023041,
0.0164607223123312,
-0.5460265278816223,
0.4475959539413452,
0.09727752953767776,
0.05759045481681824,
-0.06465163081884384,
-0.29470422863960266,
-0.5820645689964294,
-0.24838639795780182,
0.5348138213157654,
0.3071810007095337,
-0.3488430976867676,
0.2166730761528015,
-0.10432248562574387,
-0.2717526853084564,
0.13470399379730225,
0.9235339164733887,
-0.48836401104927063,
0.5685128569602966,
0.5667405128479004,
0.7851383090019226,
0.9459567666053772,
0.22976480424404144,
0.9341960549354553,
-0.850185215473175,
0.24531704187393188,
0.19262279570102692,
0.44320154190063477,
0.7022004723548889,
-0.36700087785720825,
0.7088984251022339,
0.06303524971008301,
-0.3331001102924347,
-0.6927938461303711,
0.26074451208114624,
-1.0776854753494263,
-0.22653885185718536,
1.4025284051895142,
-0.01789352111518383,
0.04203183948993683,
-0.3566899597644806,
-0.21194304525852203,
0.24526210129261017,
-0.2500947117805481,
0.43192166090011597,
0.8094379305839539,
-0.2247978001832962,
-0.36136531829833984,
-0.5485237240791321,
0.3534822165966034,
0.2550002634525299,
-0.919093132019043,
0.2631419003009796,
0.6519253253936768,
0.4934166967868805,
-0.16775856912136078,
0.6720860004425049,
-0.1798286885023117,
0.2817365527153015,
-0.10873033106327057,
0.16606959700584412,
-0.08344340324401855,
-0.25262486934661865,
-0.19825607538223267,
0.20149031281471252,
-0.0237260852009058,
-0.12366009503602982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15690v1
|
EAGLE: A Domain Generalization Framework for AI-generated Text Detection
| 2024-03-23T02:44:20 | 2024-03-23T02:44:20 |
Amrita Bhattacharjee, Raha Moraffah, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the advancement in capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), one
major step in the responsible and safe use of such LLMs is to be able to detect
text generated by these models. While supervised AI-generated text detectors
perform well on text generated by older LLMs, with the frequent release of new
LLMs, building supervised detectors for identifying text from such new models
would require new labeled training data, which is infeasible in practice. In
this work, we tackle this problem and propose a domain generalization framework
for the detection of AI-generated text from unseen target generators. Our
proposed framework, EAGLE, leverages the labeled data that is available so far
from older language models and learns features invariant across these
generators, in order to detect text generated by an unknown target generator.
EAGLE learns such domain-invariant features by combining the representational
power of self-supervised contrastive learning with domain adversarial training.
Through our experiments we demonstrate how EAGLE effectively achieves
impressive performance in detecting text generated by unseen target generators,
including recent state-of-the-art ones such as GPT-4 and Claude, reaching
detection scores of within 4.7% of a fully supervised detector.
|
[
-0.35022449493408203,
-0.8482065200805664,
0.4511542022228241,
-0.04307757318019867,
-0.15503916144371033,
-0.026492295786738396,
-0.11691409349441528,
-0.738137423992157,
0.1795308142900467,
0.7095449566841125,
-0.5210362672805786,
-0.8226698637008667,
-0.9397338628768921,
0.3256922662258148,
-0.5942152738571167,
1.018236517906189,
0.05156036838889122,
-0.6990594267845154,
0.2810143232345581,
0.060927461832761765,
-0.1720721572637558,
-0.613889753818512,
-0.5999080538749695,
-0.23508450388908386,
0.1476418673992157,
0.22914355993270874,
0.4959685504436493,
1.0126852989196777,
0.5454659461975098,
0.32683712244033813,
0.3269957900047302,
0.5478278994560242,
-0.1609421968460083,
0.15720853209495544,
-0.041617345064878464,
-0.22075262665748596,
-0.3627151846885681,
-0.12219582498073578,
0.8119135499000549,
0.32154470682144165,
0.3291511535644531,
0.017878152430057526,
0.08975681662559509,
0.5723390579223633,
-0.7977792620658875,
0.22032921016216278,
-1.0048221349716187,
0.20480024814605713,
-0.3870398998260498,
-0.319489449262619,
-0.5531120896339417,
0.27995938062667847,
-0.13107527792453766,
-0.8065787553787231,
0.5929377675056458,
0.15577863156795502,
0.8669012188911438,
0.2545817792415619,
-0.5165461301803589,
-0.6574451923370361,
-0.6064164638519287,
1.0138866901397705,
-0.3717510998249054,
0.3365958631038666,
0.5038123726844788,
0.2135133594274521,
-0.1075715720653534,
-1.006476640701294,
-0.7747620940208435,
0.09821736067533493,
0.031723104417324066,
-0.002938308520242572,
-0.5714064836502075,
-0.13284528255462646,
-0.32486692070961,
0.5140706896781921,
-0.7583581805229187,
0.22685249149799347,
0.07844535261392593,
-0.26781803369522095,
0.6413887739181519,
-0.06624046713113785,
0.40126633644104004,
0.18238551914691925,
-0.34742170572280884,
-0.17066910862922668,
-0.698418378829956,
-0.08583737164735794,
0.4649193584918976,
0.7359161972999573,
0.13312093913555145,
0.3246707618236542,
-0.06664874404668808,
0.694556474685669,
0.5679435729980469,
0.31899192929267883,
0.24209347367286682,
0.05731711536645889,
-0.2624611556529999,
0.14415483176708221,
1.0087884664535522,
0.09047441929578781,
0.21057802438735962,
-0.2795434296131134,
-0.3267084062099457,
0.15317589044570923,
0.1988450437784195,
-0.8146613836288452,
-0.24912571907043457,
-0.046569857746362686,
-0.6373324990272522,
-0.5642775297164917,
0.06750696897506714,
-0.3039185702800751,
-0.3984914720058441,
0.08420543372631073,
0.11930178850889206,
-0.23603999614715576,
-0.4015633165836334,
0.13216912746429443,
0.15466465055942535,
0.20482514798641205,
-0.02039879932999611,
-1.1451469659805298,
0.12799330055713654,
0.7226598858833313,
0.49794065952301025,
-0.2820359468460083,
-0.4408170282840729,
-1.190021276473999,
0.39500629901885986,
-0.6267790198326111,
1.0270001888275146,
-0.8097378015518188,
-0.1984543353319168,
0.4463570713996887,
-0.02837992273271084,
0.07273656874895096,
-0.6877630352973938,
0.5529101490974426,
-0.7604196667671204,
-0.008853835985064507,
-0.0377238467335701,
-0.6744535565376282,
-0.1577814370393753,
0.3756490647792816,
-0.7571359872817993,
0.7671319246292114,
-0.11373717337846756,
-0.6658479571342468,
0.6575307846069336,
-0.5574308633804321,
-0.6864502429962158,
0.25904884934425354,
-0.4426196813583374,
-0.7319414019584656,
-0.1625550538301468,
0.5302059650421143,
0.604661762714386,
0.017675088718533516,
0.12481749802827835,
-0.1992436796426773,
-0.5566256046295166,
0.034868478775024414,
-0.36274847388267517,
0.5522301197052002,
0.3137683868408203,
-0.5729770064353943,
-0.06813828647136688,
-0.5623623132705688,
-0.026005180552601814,
0.033111803233623505,
-0.5761398077011108,
-0.345932275056839,
-0.1246456652879715,
0.14389018714427948,
-0.29192131757736206,
0.33567869663238525,
-0.5135063529014587,
0.06433109939098358,
-0.34762856364250183,
-0.11260443925857544,
0.7036587595939636,
0.07497164607048035,
0.3521210253238678,
-0.06976243108510971,
0.5396628975868225,
0.04308591037988663,
-0.27334392070770264,
-0.2500799596309662,
-0.376276433467865,
-0.8600611090660095,
-0.47620511054992676,
0.07379075884819031,
0.36467593908309937,
-0.9047605395317078,
0.7617811560630798,
0.18539349734783173,
-0.0667344257235527,
-0.19699054956436157,
0.46875935792922974,
0.6858606338500977,
0.37636134028434753,
0.3908557593822479,
0.11424709111452103,
-0.48544415831565857,
-0.981548011302948,
-0.7538931965827942,
-0.3475140631198883,
-0.1108415499329567,
0.2432446926832199,
0.464882493019104,
-0.5494858622550964,
0.690792977809906,
-0.43542835116386414,
-0.9460895657539368,
-0.33114561438560486,
0.47578513622283936,
-0.1714564561843872,
0.3884710669517517,
0.5871519446372986,
-1.0939959287643433,
-0.7577582001686096,
0.1703813672065735,
-1.1299052238464355,
-0.1957453340291977,
-0.12571211159229279,
0.008646859787404537,
0.22803287208080292,
0.6462441086769104,
-0.3497590720653534,
0.33672088384628296,
0.4879901707172394,
-0.15736714005470276,
0.20232044160366058,
0.02288644202053547,
0.09448603540658951,
-0.9853019714355469,
-0.044423140585422516,
0.24632757902145386,
-0.2490159273147583,
-0.7611141204833984,
0.23792368173599243,
-0.026335101574659348,
-0.1855817437171936,
-0.33379030227661133,
0.664713978767395,
-0.5937701463699341,
0.11533530801534653,
-0.8035861849784851,
-0.04305491968989372,
0.08774903416633606,
0.4021470844745636,
0.3492090404033661,
0.9572622776031494,
0.604936957359314,
-0.7602022886276245,
0.13155242800712585,
0.40036025643348694,
-0.13019433617591858,
0.45826736092567444,
-0.4371364712715149,
0.2900297939777374,
-0.06541537493467331,
0.16233915090560913,
-0.5577431917190552,
-0.11783267557621002,
0.4225616753101349,
-0.6689072847366333,
0.40440258383750916,
-0.037621866911649704,
-0.5287222266197205,
-0.0030408804304897785,
-0.103207066655159,
0.3719114661216736,
0.35265225172042847,
-0.8152463436126709,
0.812131941318512,
0.40858450531959534,
0.12968827784061432,
-0.8210988640785217,
-0.847698450088501,
0.26080405712127686,
-0.1321859210729599,
-0.38396674394607544,
0.2958166003227234,
0.031230498105287552,
-0.10784251987934113,
0.23318393528461456,
0.0004929541028104722,
-0.35676881670951843,
0.05977833643555641,
0.22763700783252716,
-0.22388015687465668,
-0.3928380310535431,
0.25099632143974304,
0.147964209318161,
-0.16362440586090088,
0.027228331193327904,
-0.4303613603115082,
0.3674364686012268,
-0.3586077094078064,
-0.3937876522541046,
-0.5211867094039917,
0.5127222537994385,
0.18718241155147552,
-0.6087924838066101,
0.5676074624061584,
0.6696938276290894,
-0.6161023378372192,
-0.6926208138465881,
-0.22893226146697998,
-0.015739355236291885,
-0.5845799446105957,
0.3707045614719391,
-0.38368844985961914,
-0.9459429979324341,
0.28645116090774536,
-0.07323143631219864,
0.029913410544395447,
0.7796871066093445,
0.43749532103538513,
0.15025340020656586,
1.1441434621810913,
1.094621181488037,
-0.19852004945278168,
0.28143781423568726,
-0.34248536825180054,
0.33500510454177856,
-0.7129276990890503,
0.04983631521463394,
-0.2917333245277405,
-0.10522090643644333,
-0.3933217525482178,
-0.018156304955482483,
-0.08826737850904465,
-0.010643835179507732,
-0.1634114682674408,
0.3323628306388855,
-0.7838327288627625,
0.5920008420944214,
0.5067450404167175,
0.05011027678847313,
0.4045707881450653,
0.12759700417518616,
0.2544911205768585,
0.16410942375659943,
-0.20786909759044647,
-0.6409731507301331,
1.4888556003570557,
0.1025509312748909,
0.37690573930740356,
0.0042485748417675495,
1.0717967748641968,
1.0107192993164062,
0.5590452551841736,
-0.5197626352310181,
0.5137162804603577,
-0.612061083316803,
-0.6568596959114075,
-0.09203125536441803,
-0.17734067142009735,
-1.1477357149124146,
0.1303035020828247,
-0.1904578059911728,
-0.41519907116889954,
0.1657973676919937,
0.3244262635707855,
-0.009797129780054092,
0.3789677619934082,
-0.42425304651260376,
0.7756909728050232,
-0.13458120822906494,
-0.050230760127305984,
0.11176157742738724,
-0.17681604623794556,
0.48281410336494446,
-0.4790794551372528,
-0.05075147747993469,
0.03754002973437309,
-0.015269017778337002,
0.668650209903717,
-0.2343333661556244,
0.9950382709503174,
-0.09644803404808044,
-0.24637560546398163,
0.5661628842353821,
0.01658809930086136,
0.6786299347877502,
-0.07346711307764053,
-0.010952401906251907,
0.05656832084059715,
-0.7953965663909912,
-0.3020520806312561,
-0.4069839417934418,
0.7424213886260986,
-0.6442093849182129,
-0.4448632001876831,
-0.6749765276908875,
-0.5769297480583191,
-0.002887803828343749,
0.5081144571304321,
0.49338430166244507,
0.261013388633728,
-0.31431958079338074,
0.05331553891301155,
0.6562826037406921,
-0.17338256537914276,
0.2896210551261902,
0.7423793077468872,
-0.23894384503364563,
-0.13651800155639648,
1.11504328250885,
-0.46452024579048157,
-0.214967280626297,
0.5758785009384155,
-0.25857073068618774,
-0.33309078216552734,
-0.7918338179588318,
-0.3429822325706482,
0.01807912439107895,
-0.866235077381134,
-0.33461669087409973,
-0.6917730569839478,
-0.315534770488739,
-0.2774275541305542,
-0.4230467975139618,
-0.25711387395858765,
0.07238543778657913,
-0.734940767288208,
-0.07228942215442657,
0.1642078161239624,
0.8371834754943848,
-0.08701995015144348,
0.50803542137146,
-0.5358521938323975,
0.5732656121253967,
0.3623397648334503,
0.05375678464770317,
-0.16487199068069458,
-0.40511855483055115,
-0.15813107788562775,
0.015134022571146488,
-0.4764622747898102,
-0.3130549192428589,
0.54401695728302,
0.5426194071769714,
0.5166175365447998,
0.6557820439338684,
0.36795949935913086,
0.1535816788673401,
-0.4579676687717438,
0.6243975162506104,
0.043694671243429184,
-0.987228274345398,
0.5275964736938477,
-0.33703920245170593,
0.17901118099689484,
0.40285223722457886,
0.06126035749912262,
-0.0501895435154438,
-0.7574102282524109,
-0.38548970222473145,
-0.46594786643981934,
0.5269994735717773,
0.36773890256881714,
0.1914326250553131,
-0.21674950420856476,
0.3188035190105438,
0.10517580062150955,
0.32423165440559387,
-0.8235814571380615,
-0.3065929114818573,
-0.25633904337882996,
-0.415463387966156,
-0.05560345575213432,
0.05341864004731178,
0.0687309131026268,
0.5356003046035767,
0.6116551160812378,
-0.3144129812717438,
0.23106281459331512,
0.024047400802373886,
-0.2712276875972748,
-0.23573657870292664,
0.0009575183503329754,
0.3523118793964386,
0.3002155125141144,
-0.15026068687438965,
0.29158130288124084,
-0.3137586712837219,
-0.5124241709709167,
0.14711514115333557,
0.4392428398132324,
-0.3406384587287903,
-0.04284156486392021,
0.7742950320243835,
0.5566147565841675,
-0.2991205155849457,
-0.5663731098175049,
0.647483766078949,
-0.04820634797215462,
-0.3267589807510376,
-0.36830562353134155,
0.22925639152526855,
-0.3298455476760864,
0.4204259216785431,
0.7531237006187439,
0.09752447158098221,
0.44516319036483765,
-0.3798169791698456,
0.6182826161384583,
0.752827525138855,
-0.37116315960884094,
-0.24382954835891724,
0.9565390944480896,
0.25773465633392334,
-0.43480509519577026,
0.4185670018196106,
-0.3344617784023285,
-0.7916378378868103,
0.8326713442802429,
0.7030541896820068,
1.2170592546463013,
-0.15548744797706604,
0.31943950057029724,
-0.12325392663478851,
0.38735494017601013,
0.20809927582740784,
-0.00003275067138019949,
-0.13379988074302673,
-0.9318864941596985,
0.00580415315926075,
-0.5022366046905518,
-0.3331945240497589,
0.6010949611663818,
-0.4738633930683136,
0.04965900629758835,
-0.5464327931404114,
-0.1413460522890091,
0.15744929015636444,
0.017441807314753532,
-0.5931159257888794,
0.36428266763687134,
0.16411694884300232,
0.5365749597549438,
-0.9671968817710876,
0.616614580154419,
0.7864357829093933,
-0.3710249960422516,
-0.5578651428222656,
0.4186215400695801,
0.09476069360971451,
-1.134257197380066,
0.9705031514167786,
0.5038496851921082,
-0.5447801351547241,
0.12025263160467148,
-0.6262467503547668,
-0.4956059753894806,
0.8256905674934387,
0.2863559126853943,
-0.1920672357082367,
0.28493860363960266,
0.32196301221847534,
0.610634982585907,
-0.7280400395393372,
-0.2658390402793884,
0.20482765138149261,
0.34592464566230774,
-0.151521697640419,
-0.4492977559566498,
0.036372896283864975,
-0.5423362851142883,
-0.20405524969100952,
0.1804134100675583,
-0.6400284171104431,
1.056938886642456,
0.10382524132728577,
-0.3460425138473511,
0.1478012353181839,
0.946360170841217,
0.422579824924469,
0.5091099739074707,
0.30081161856651306,
0.48316100239753723,
0.5922291874885559,
0.2197338491678238,
0.8936948776245117,
-0.27192142605781555,
0.24916112422943115,
0.7304685711860657,
-0.4187665283679962,
0.6309964060783386,
0.07981417328119278,
0.24647130072116852,
0.5026389360427856,
0.43844544887542725,
-0.22770631313323975,
0.6836243271827698,
-0.04043357074260712,
-0.5680840015411377,
-0.5151286125183105,
-0.10328205674886703,
-0.5091143250465393,
0.5633317828178406,
0.21398209035396576,
-0.7824556827545166,
-0.2439798265695572,
-0.01707320101559162,
-0.06094999611377716,
0.41433411836624146,
-0.3369455337524414,
0.5442578792572021,
0.005823326297104359,
-0.4216468632221222,
0.8263689279556274,
0.21295438706874847,
0.7635614275932312,
-0.642734169960022,
-0.308760404586792,
-0.2887361943721771,
0.7068187594413757,
-0.11034293472766876,
-0.628392219543457,
0.004173498135060072,
0.29746633768081665,
-0.433181494474411,
-0.1138409748673439,
0.9702098965644836,
-0.517814040184021,
-0.7301243543624878,
0.18887870013713837,
0.1994270235300064,
0.2365187257528305,
-0.33507221937179565,
-0.38512614369392395,
0.3113548457622528,
-0.033783361315727234,
-0.20565806329250336,
0.42824697494506836,
0.590197741985321,
0.0629824548959732,
0.6961305737495422,
0.6470032334327698,
-0.09442171454429626,
0.0018152501434087753,
-0.34180426597595215,
0.8290181159973145,
-0.30709993839263916,
-0.6154975891113281,
-0.6538469791412354,
0.1147245466709137,
-0.0021131259854882956,
-0.3294627368450165,
0.7897522449493408,
0.7490236759185791,
0.7218047380447388,
-0.21132276952266693,
1.2003071308135986,
0.31138402223587036,
0.5441797375679016,
-0.48130491375923157,
0.947488009929657,
-0.7645262479782104,
0.41442984342575073,
-0.16386164724826813,
-0.9865949749946594,
-0.48497021198272705,
0.586101770401001,
-0.010218881070613861,
0.11779558658599854,
0.5248562693595886,
0.5437488555908203,
-0.2267511785030365,
-0.14599542319774628,
0.28132539987564087,
-0.28674960136413574,
0.71561199426651,
0.7199463844299316,
0.6278046369552612,
-0.6642889976501465,
0.8511859774589539,
0.047039296478033066,
-0.23352138698101044,
-0.03165191039443016,
-0.966894268989563,
-1.3240565061569214,
-0.5737543702125549,
-0.4468218684196472,
0.05499177798628807,
0.2391422837972641,
0.30500566959381104,
0.6526102423667908,
-0.9892497658729553,
0.0019442110788077116,
-0.360125869512558,
-0.16761161386966705,
-0.14837495982646942,
-0.23785941302776337,
0.7916826009750366,
-0.40275001525878906,
-0.907049834728241,
0.6920927166938782,
0.15982773900032043,
0.1307961791753769,
-0.07855188101530075,
-0.2649432420730591,
-0.12755119800567627,
0.10131289809942245,
0.3102938234806061,
0.6935122013092041,
-0.70677649974823,
-0.3591323494911194,
-0.039634671062231064,
-0.04971606284379959,
-0.23126421868801117,
0.6441131234169006,
-0.7896199226379395,
0.2926652431488037,
-0.010494528338313103,
1.080589771270752,
0.3583211600780487,
0.20059017837047577,
0.4571649432182312,
-0.9143072366714478,
0.08176840841770172,
0.12076512724161148,
0.10659044981002808,
0.45714181661605835,
-0.6399266719818115,
0.22522728145122528,
0.15722526609897614,
-0.5210332274436951,
-0.8672577738761902,
0.5218269228935242,
-0.43463465571403503,
-0.35985398292541504,
0.9072487950325012,
-0.21252375841140747,
0.13010190427303314,
-0.02153630182147026,
0.01283738762140274,
0.22430838644504547,
-0.4859098196029663,
0.69402015209198,
0.41200199723243713,
-0.22909165918827057,
-0.13723647594451904,
0.023443199694156647,
0.6363916397094727,
0.18493475019931793,
-0.8381156921386719,
0.1586712896823883,
0.4706229269504547,
0.054658472537994385,
0.27142757177352905,
0.7908245325088501,
0.33558332920074463,
0.23305708169937134,
0.008979043923318386,
-0.02585080824792385,
-0.49570682644844055,
-0.5627709031105042,
-0.09848003834486008,
0.13707493245601654,
-0.07567618042230606,
-0.6160861253738403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15676v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15676v3
|
AC4: Algebraic Computation Checker for Circuit Constraints in ZKPs
| 2024-03-23T01:44:57 | 2024-05-07T04:29:29 |
Hao Chen, Minyu Chen, Ruibang Liu, Guoqiang Li, Sinka Gao
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
ZKP systems have surged attention and held a fundamental role in contemporary
cryptography. Zk-SNARK protocols dominate the ZKP usage, often implemented
through arithmetic circuit programming paradigm. However, underconstrained or
overconstrained circuits may lead to bugs. Underconstrained circuits refer to
circuits that lack the necessary constraints, resulting in unexpected solutions
in the circuit and causing the verifier to accept a bogus witness.
Overconstrained circuits refer to circuits that are constrained excessively,
resulting in the circuit lacking necessary solutions and causing the verifier
to accept no witness, rendering the circuit meaningless. This paper introduces
a novel approach for pinpointing two distinct types of bugs in ZKP circuits.
The method involves encoding the arithmetic circuit constraints to polynomial
equation systems and solving polynomial equation systems over a finite field by
algebraic computation. The classification of verification results is refined,
greatly enhancing the expressive power of the system. We proposed a tool, AC4,
to represent the implementation of this method. Experiments demonstrate that
AC4 represents a substantial 29% increase in the checked ratio compared to
prior work. Within a solvable range, the checking time of AC4 has also
exhibited noticeable improvement, demonstrating a magnitude increase compared
to previous efforts.
|
[
-0.4066827893257141,
-0.17810404300689697,
0.8105427622795105,
0.15152841806411743,
-0.16064734756946564,
0.6330060362815857,
0.2634374499320984,
-0.7278203964233398,
0.13442941009998322,
0.2901720702648163,
-0.6000545620918274,
-0.4979415833950043,
-0.6193860769271851,
0.41859570145606995,
-0.23623883724212646,
0.6280694603919983,
-0.5183233618736267,
-0.12506061792373657,
-0.19361893832683563,
0.14133332669734955,
-0.26114222407341003,
-0.7942593097686768,
-0.0711478665471077,
-0.5477757453918457,
-0.1586577147245407,
0.48244133591651917,
0.6401985287666321,
0.31955215334892273,
0.821499764919281,
0.4503936171531677,
0.0758008062839508,
0.19912129640579224,
0.0002840450615622103,
-0.02750232443213463,
0.2261071354150772,
-0.687395453453064,
-0.20594099164009094,
-0.184715136885643,
0.44281473755836487,
0.3109792470932007,
-0.021045295521616936,
0.02241005189716816,
-0.5552942156791687,
0.6109517216682434,
-1.1790233850479126,
0.45580628514289856,
-0.6059495210647583,
0.4142434597015381,
-0.5164618492126465,
-0.4854419231414795,
-0.40543675422668457,
-0.35221609473228455,
-0.6481071710586548,
-0.6955838203430176,
0.25484347343444824,
0.01601277105510235,
0.6675305366516113,
0.15852153301239014,
-0.5941051840782166,
-0.4700636863708496,
-0.6891082525253296,
0.5916234254837036,
-0.6539276242256165,
0.544252872467041,
0.40461722016334534,
0.41716110706329346,
-0.2515690326690674,
-0.6586110591888428,
-0.8188785910606384,
-0.1105106994509697,
-0.11373043805360794,
-0.05187470093369484,
-0.3316953182220459,
0.569087028503418,
0.5764355063438416,
0.6693403124809265,
-0.20144255459308624,
-0.37830397486686707,
-0.3925808370113373,
-0.660742461681366,
0.5733124017715454,
0.37119683623313904,
0.44986626505851746,
-0.12019376456737518,
-0.02904297038912773,
0.22400857508182526,
-0.8550717234611511,
0.30767980217933655,
0.6817530393600464,
-0.14653490483760834,
0.17699457705020905,
0.4555794894695282,
-0.3736611604690552,
0.5582624077796936,
0.318799763917923,
-0.0487140491604805,
0.28681427240371704,
-0.2651151716709137,
-0.010985753498971462,
0.10757274180650711,
0.5397250056266785,
0.2375594526529312,
-0.04098331555724144,
-0.21405811607837677,
-0.3900131285190582,
0.6512385010719299,
0.19157448410987854,
-0.849835216999054,
-0.7464470863342285,
0.013951596803963184,
-0.15124616026878357,
-0.31934958696365356,
-0.006300806533545256,
-0.5634757280349731,
-0.08814049512147903,
0.01468699797987938,
0.21732120215892792,
-0.2868610918521881,
0.1225145012140274,
0.21531713008880615,
-0.09860510379076004,
0.050018634647130966,
0.15898437798023224,
-1.1742124557495117,
0.679365873336792,
0.9537128210067749,
0.9825674891471863,
0.428291916847229,
0.10724982619285583,
-0.6073309779167175,
-0.013414273969829082,
-0.5015329122543335,
0.755855143070221,
-0.47161319851875305,
-0.12812155485153198,
-0.022884394973516464,
-0.15010106563568115,
0.10555592179298401,
-0.3967241942882538,
0.6135273575782776,
-0.748757004737854,
-0.7279780507087708,
-0.3733578324317932,
-0.46232205629348755,
0.051572877913713455,
0.3684579133987427,
-0.693594217300415,
0.7211889028549194,
0.38036099076271057,
-0.5905562043190002,
0.05402809754014015,
-0.5283468961715698,
-0.2400287687778473,
0.2831822335720062,
-0.596566379070282,
-0.49272605776786804,
0.036178022623062134,
0.21809875965118408,
-0.1686408668756485,
-0.0004141453537158668,
-0.4639900326728821,
-0.29522648453712463,
-0.4658953547477722,
0.20540538430213928,
0.034356676042079926,
0.8871442675590515,
0.12811289727687836,
-0.38096529245376587,
-0.062351975589990616,
-0.7902735471725464,
0.3962462544441223,
-0.23343880474567413,
-0.006591677665710449,
-0.07885171473026276,
0.030111059546470642,
-0.625092625617981,
0.21525807678699493,
0.3690868616104126,
-1.1703436374664307,
0.24251635372638702,
-0.7996630072593689,
0.6109693050384521,
0.6885249018669128,
0.2725943922996521,
0.11598990857601166,
0.028846606612205505,
0.7567355036735535,
-0.21706928312778473,
0.28607437014579773,
0.07069329172372818,
-0.5261958837509155,
-0.7168431282043457,
0.17896708846092224,
0.2942553758621216,
0.5577033758163452,
-0.9579871892929077,
0.3343825936317444,
0.21829155087471008,
-0.3172352612018585,
-0.1442864090204239,
0.1823933869600296,
0.5834978222846985,
0.29760876297950745,
0.39901965856552124,
-0.3488940894603729,
-0.4705345928668976,
-0.8189240097999573,
-0.0028947084210813046,
-0.40206971764564514,
-0.08788730204105377,
0.048899173736572266,
0.3996238112449646,
-0.07768704742193222,
0.30031973123550415,
-0.6181278824806213,
-0.23513156175613403,
-0.0015134495915845037,
0.16466592252254486,
0.15774859488010406,
0.5217803716659546,
0.5571362376213074,
-0.3728414475917816,
-0.356612890958786,
0.15179644525051117,
-0.3475930392742157,
-0.19651100039482117,
0.02313186228275299,
-0.13989587128162384,
0.2477479875087738,
0.5117135047912598,
-0.9072870016098022,
0.8927093744277954,
0.5927472710609436,
-0.5495734214782715,
0.8445967435836792,
-0.11313030868768692,
0.46990373730659485,
-0.049444880336523056,
0.07304316014051437,
-0.5382900834083557,
-0.2753053903579712,
-0.5553073287010193,
0.6635157465934753,
0.49100661277770996,
-0.013908380642533302,
0.14400674402713776,
-0.3428601622581482,
-0.5820568799972534,
-0.15593063831329346,
-0.1922038048505783,
-0.2836233973503113,
-0.10797606408596039,
0.4349392056465149,
-0.26088714599609375,
0.5537970066070557,
0.4292580783367157,
-0.3505171239376068,
0.6928906440734863,
0.4180462658405304,
-0.20386940240859985,
0.25629764795303345,
-0.4305301606655121,
0.37251901626586914,
0.2879299521446228,
0.2642417252063751,
-0.7476258873939514,
0.02803574688732624,
0.5460585355758667,
-0.6839776635169983,
0.03060286119580269,
-0.41046738624572754,
-0.7136639356613159,
-0.4977800250053406,
-0.4249110221862793,
0.8702865839004517,
0.2258378267288208,
-0.5782650709152222,
0.7808194160461426,
0.06996455043554306,
0.246084526181221,
-0.5789090394973755,
-0.3901351988315582,
0.09828440845012665,
0.45800328254699707,
-0.8034884333610535,
0.436408668756485,
-0.1865563988685608,
-0.237016960978508,
-0.17692376673221588,
-0.7601681351661682,
-0.14003747701644897,
0.04862230643630028,
0.3718988001346588,
0.370069295167923,
-0.14194470643997192,
-0.222680926322937,
0.11543605476617813,
-0.35065168142318726,
0.5915704965591431,
-0.036984022706747055,
0.45732757449150085,
-0.27429288625717163,
-0.6987736225128174,
-0.5329443216323853,
0.477798730134964,
0.28998157382011414,
-0.45875948667526245,
0.18956312537193298,
-0.1082143560051918,
-0.4260108470916748,
-0.20225746929645538,
-0.2614610195159912,
-0.17384004592895508,
-0.6346673965454102,
-0.0279493797570467,
-0.682802677154541,
-0.7458157539367676,
0.7691730856895447,
-0.06582977622747421,
0.1549481749534607,
0.45158541202545166,
0.15374809503555298,
0.48727771639823914,
1.3172675371170044,
0.43358176946640015,
0.017092321068048477,
0.01597876101732254,
-0.32200106978416443,
0.9039744734764099,
-0.5369989275932312,
-0.40962958335876465,
-0.6499400734901428,
-0.3703393340110779,
-0.44508105516433716,
-0.09279856830835342,
0.2686772048473358,
0.12178678810596466,
-0.134592667222023,
0.24316422641277313,
-0.524601399898529,
0.7035390734672546,
0.26689133048057556,
-0.010862179100513458,
0.31372418999671936,
-0.41706499457359314,
-0.18743039667606354,
-0.13329075276851654,
-0.5322120189666748,
0.14087195694446564,
0.9335461854934692,
0.15043146908283234,
0.58169025182724,
0.21867635846138,
0.8627191781997681,
0.04792923107743263,
0.2522880733013153,
-0.7859317064285278,
0.4821273684501648,
0.017788834869861603,
-0.6703286170959473,
0.04785282909870148,
-0.6129307150840759,
-0.5257951021194458,
-0.10195000469684601,
-0.17821787297725677,
-0.9821519255638123,
0.5073280930519104,
0.7449573278427124,
-0.6299340724945068,
0.4546906352043152,
-0.4720291197299957,
0.6922398805618286,
-0.04016433283686638,
0.06533841788768768,
-0.2489543855190277,
-0.5447745323181152,
0.6763356328010559,
0.2798667848110199,
0.0578303337097168,
0.09459361433982849,
0.1797652691602707,
0.2493230104446411,
-1.0651166439056396,
0.32023677229881287,
-0.16473114490509033,
-0.004004805348813534,
0.2345898300409317,
0.5079542994499207,
0.8146886229515076,
0.21133460104465485,
0.250019371509552,
0.19184303283691406,
0.2746634781360626,
-0.30361872911453247,
-0.8406391739845276,
0.8869696855545044,
-0.6534889340400696,
-0.5360637307167053,
-0.8062893152236938,
-0.31146907806396484,
-0.3859177231788635,
0.23674802482128143,
0.2535451650619507,
0.48993968963623047,
0.5496085286140442,
-0.17461225390434265,
0.5497887134552002,
0.2754967212677002,
0.1578679084777832,
0.36958974599838257,
-0.10266369581222534,
-0.2796143591403961,
0.753940224647522,
-0.11780964583158493,
0.345146507024765,
0.256664514541626,
-0.17502933740615845,
0.03897152468562126,
-0.8004953861236572,
-0.46028202772140503,
0.06186389923095703,
-0.8858180046081543,
-0.8884156346321106,
-0.30975469946861267,
-0.6746659278869629,
-0.5464812517166138,
-0.2755536437034607,
-0.36929914355278015,
-0.7564162611961365,
0.02682284452021122,
-0.13113686442375183,
0.2469196617603302,
0.4082198441028595,
-0.2961345314979553,
0.3504176735877991,
-0.6921706199645996,
0.8024779558181763,
0.3276224434375763,
0.7944363951683044,
-0.06767547875642776,
-0.05090370029211044,
-0.15021896362304688,
-0.1287456750869751,
-0.5872740149497986,
-1.0404857397079468,
0.171471506357193,
0.13771624863147736,
0.47698459029197693,
0.5189313292503357,
0.1837993711233139,
0.6779678463935852,
-0.4850655794143677,
0.4020306169986725,
0.19867931306362152,
-1.5018706321716309,
0.3182626962661743,
0.2339899092912674,
0.3401592969894409,
0.5718865394592285,
0.20698972046375275,
-0.5030384063720703,
-0.6831796765327454,
-0.6762676239013672,
-0.960513174533844,
0.6420912742614746,
0.6488584280014038,
-0.2968258261680603,
0.11591005325317383,
0.5369715690612793,
-0.40418681502342224,
0.047363489866256714,
-0.5178791880607605,
-0.6195897459983826,
-0.4845007061958313,
-0.020503472536802292,
0.270504355430603,
-0.20794019103050232,
-0.0900237187743187,
-0.16273070871829987,
0.6549050211906433,
0.11173567920923233,
0.3005947172641754,
0.35625410079956055,
0.01408014539629221,
-0.6183199882507324,
0.097714863717556,
0.5235547423362732,
0.8104766011238098,
-0.4618905782699585,
0.469012588262558,
-0.09243115037679672,
-0.7889792323112488,
0.19515107572078705,
0.3618917465209961,
-0.38451239466667175,
0.16181589663028717,
0.38461044430732727,
0.29481178522109985,
0.027519866824150085,
-0.41779717803001404,
0.47673118114471436,
-0.15899589657783508,
-0.4994746446609497,
-0.41039541363716125,
0.3363266885280609,
-0.26756036281585693,
0.13995510339736938,
0.3351632356643677,
0.3820517957210541,
0.6515795588493347,
-0.3848821818828583,
0.1841326355934143,
0.6293862462043762,
-0.08533056080341339,
-0.37476402521133423,
0.4658048152923584,
0.14178404211997986,
-0.5349146723747253,
0.6467147469520569,
-0.5632303357124329,
-0.9966921210289001,
0.8093423247337341,
0.5598711371421814,
0.5362045764923096,
-0.4389238655567169,
-0.036783959716558456,
0.4855736494064331,
0.7396516799926758,
0.2576294541358948,
0.4239952564239502,
-0.4523857831954956,
-0.7172685265541077,
-0.4162113666534424,
-0.38665080070495605,
-0.4423621594905853,
0.13892862200737,
-0.5137786865234375,
0.13045910000801086,
-1.0238151550292969,
0.040875282138586044,
0.5276033878326416,
0.2892463505268097,
-0.330116331577301,
-0.07520211488008499,
0.11703063547611237,
0.9473574161529541,
-0.885373592376709,
0.4605187177658081,
0.26958924531936646,
0.06931985169649124,
-0.8586907982826233,
-0.3258788287639618,
0.22844040393829346,
-0.727225661277771,
0.450492262840271,
0.23466609418392181,
-0.533288836479187,
-0.21059732139110565,
-0.6018258333206177,
-0.8617362976074219,
0.8544890880584717,
0.31919386982917786,
-0.718539834022522,
0.19512242078781128,
0.10100309550762177,
0.41563165187835693,
-0.030222376808524132,
0.051461100578308105,
0.6457040309906006,
0.4150986671447754,
0.2799950838088989,
-0.9343794584274292,
0.23611891269683838,
-0.5661698579788208,
-0.4285662770271301,
1.0953115224838257,
-0.3942926526069641,
0.7725024223327637,
-0.16120244562625885,
-0.2826683223247528,
0.33455899357795715,
0.5830826759338379,
0.5800110101699829,
0.5762741565704346,
0.5971649289131165,
0.4420984089374542,
0.48241856694221497,
-0.03567034378647804,
0.6440873742103577,
-0.5749332904815674,
0.23921766877174377,
0.7489861845970154,
-0.148069828748703,
0.4472474157810211,
0.5665040016174316,
-0.34305572509765625,
0.655051052570343,
0.18328212201595306,
-0.0835144892334938,
0.3055858612060547,
0.5291485786437988,
-0.7033059000968933,
-0.5661585330963135,
0.5025556087493896,
-0.4103265404701233,
0.20350521802902222,
0.4893183410167694,
-0.051373790949583054,
-0.3930458128452301,
-0.520603597164154,
-0.1730411946773529,
0.108396515250206,
-0.6099650263786316,
0.2309887707233429,
0.006836408283561468,
-0.5183732509613037,
0.44457292556762695,
0.2961905300617218,
0.3195442259311676,
-0.6760573387145996,
-0.4985921382904053,
-0.019374478608369827,
0.3324851095676422,
-0.5954298377037048,
-0.44388023018836975,
0.46479541063308716,
-0.14287053048610687,
0.05540105327963829,
0.016611294820904732,
0.7779227495193481,
-0.10078678280115128,
-0.822815477848053,
-0.06748022139072418,
-0.3556610941886902,
-0.06291250884532928,
0.0013005479704588652,
-0.26862072944641113,
0.15132184326648712,
0.12656284868717194,
0.24663031101226807,
-0.1063568964600563,
0.5006150007247925,
-0.06510936468839645,
0.8377151489257812,
0.5839427709579468,
0.35696011781692505,
0.08435546606779099,
-0.2931583523750305,
1.1342843770980835,
-0.48924699425697327,
-0.819085419178009,
-0.7943470478057861,
0.07810896635055542,
-0.01061821449548006,
-0.258323609828949,
0.9461560845375061,
0.6341230273246765,
0.7477173209190369,
0.18742939829826355,
0.5902533531188965,
-0.0984007865190506,
0.20158889889717102,
-0.4659492075443268,
0.3762560188770294,
0.0894896388053894,
0.45771512389183044,
-0.34410741925239563,
-0.3798060417175293,
-0.548602283000946,
0.6123842000961304,
-0.2042769491672516,
-0.2132549285888672,
0.8111854195594788,
0.7068092226982117,
-0.20242446660995483,
0.18379902839660645,
0.10376124083995819,
-0.011646829545497894,
0.4595463275909424,
0.926750123500824,
0.7694137096405029,
-0.46865391731262207,
0.5871447920799255,
-0.7718020677566528,
-0.38842135667800903,
-0.051636092364788055,
-0.6195412278175354,
-0.8177071809768677,
-0.23905928432941437,
-0.23696893453598022,
-0.3258601725101471,
0.1728125810623169,
0.5557964444160461,
0.4551801085472107,
-0.9844962954521179,
-0.06411085277795792,
-0.4766274094581604,
0.37966054677963257,
-0.14078715443611145,
-0.14783012866973877,
0.2654145658016205,
-0.28633275628089905,
0.05333450436592102,
0.1493941992521286,
0.4513263702392578,
-0.07864227890968323,
-0.2077445238828659,
-0.1225677952170372,
0.06893337517976761,
0.14950987696647644,
0.2624439299106598,
0.6272110342979431,
-0.36874908208847046,
-0.4466789960861206,
0.042774248868227005,
0.4365982115268707,
0.2056371420621872,
1.264114499092102,
-0.5753013491630554,
0.49334582686424255,
0.5074915885925293,
0.30139097571372986,
0.517177939414978,
-0.09125537425279617,
0.5901627540588379,
-0.6306794881820679,
-0.08451971411705017,
0.4571463465690613,
0.33555254340171814,
-0.03453400358557701,
-0.7506672739982605,
-0.05304635688662529,
0.3159259855747223,
-0.8492732644081116,
-0.9434117674827576,
0.5088587403297424,
-0.851277232170105,
0.03390565514564514,
0.5946154594421387,
-0.32881617546081543,
-0.16243968904018402,
-0.4173749089241028,
0.07801469415426254,
-0.07412004470825195,
-0.2816885709762573,
1.226656198501587,
0.571811318397522,
-0.6624903678894043,
-0.3010842204093933,
-0.29840096831321716,
0.8096623420715332,
0.10621665418148041,
-0.7788177132606506,
-0.014435604214668274,
0.6229248046875,
0.07555103302001953,
0.6536004543304443,
0.568567156791687,
-0.12788069248199463,
0.8791957497596741,
0.20465144515037537,
0.18422476947307587,
-0.26498815417289734,
-0.24603955447673798,
-0.13496653735637665,
0.15442319214344025,
0.154936283826828,
-0.1235002800822258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15673v1
|
AI for Biomedicine in the Era of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-23T01:40:22 | 2024-03-23T01:40:22 |
Zhenyu Bi, Sajib Acharjee Dip, Daniel Hajialigol, Sindhura Kommu, Hanwen Liu, Meng Lu, Xuan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The capabilities of AI for biomedicine span a wide spectrum, from the atomic
level, where it solves partial differential equations for quantum systems, to
the molecular level, predicting chemical or protein structures, and further
extending to societal predictions like infectious disease outbreaks. Recent
advancements in large language models, exemplified by models like ChatGPT, have
showcased significant prowess in natural language tasks, such as translating
languages, constructing chatbots, and answering questions. When we consider
biomedical data, we observe a resemblance to natural language in terms of
sequences: biomedical literature and health records presented as text,
biological sequences or sequencing data arranged in sequences, or sensor data
like brain signals as time series. The question arises: Can we harness the
potential of recent large language models to drive biomedical knowledge
discoveries? In this survey, we will explore the application of large language
models to three crucial categories of biomedical data: 1) textual data, 2)
biological sequences, and 3) brain signals. Furthermore, we will delve into
large language model challenges in biomedical research, including ensuring
trustworthiness, achieving personalization, and adapting to multi-modal data
representation
|
[
0.08560443669557571,
-0.9278548955917358,
1.0435348749160767,
-0.1694180816411972,
0.19654633104801178,
0.1847800761461258,
-0.16825947165489197,
-0.8195247054100037,
0.022368527948856354,
0.31943899393081665,
-0.32741719484329224,
-0.40904030203819275,
-0.7321953177452087,
0.0869150385260582,
-0.4453034996986389,
1.0436608791351318,
0.27697643637657166,
0.5115176439285278,
-0.3023662865161896,
-0.10863538086414337,
-0.13988400995731354,
-0.6967286467552185,
-0.7026666402816772,
-0.5489645600318909,
0.7160941362380981,
-0.025477537885308266,
0.72197425365448,
0.5743156671524048,
0.7317248582839966,
0.2660043239593506,
-0.08796879649162292,
-0.052970267832279205,
-0.07952158153057098,
0.17257635295391083,
-0.1812736988067627,
-0.49039721488952637,
-0.3632121980190277,
-0.19902518391609192,
0.5836828351020813,
1.1025696992874146,
0.03258446604013443,
0.03725344315171242,
-0.32387658953666687,
0.6942903399467468,
-0.06468696892261505,
0.6379485726356506,
-0.3399128317832947,
0.037530288100242615,
-0.1286487579345703,
-0.06883351504802704,
-0.16929766535758972,
-0.42344099283218384,
0.4986644983291626,
-0.352618932723999,
-0.05309203267097473,
0.0510723777115345,
0.432412326335907,
0.278634250164032,
-0.5115033388137817,
-0.22388672828674316,
-0.7429318428039551,
0.5214688777923584,
-0.7108271718025208,
0.4442862868309021,
0.440751850605011,
0.2149992287158966,
-0.3040819764137268,
-0.7709060907363892,
-0.2785176932811737,
-0.4230876863002777,
0.27067437767982483,
-0.0789719894528389,
-0.40620818734169006,
0.17567305266857147,
0.22452311217784882,
0.1775224357843399,
-0.8408278226852417,
0.29942575097084045,
-0.5591928362846375,
-0.17111456394195557,
0.6630228161811829,
0.21081112325191498,
0.6336962580680847,
-0.05125529691576958,
0.12190074473619461,
-0.017907114699482918,
-0.49402689933776855,
-0.0871269628405571,
-0.13503171503543854,
0.135243758559227,
-0.07011400163173676,
0.6081230044364929,
-0.027292994782328606,
0.5892395377159119,
-0.26231512427330017,
0.08158458769321442,
0.18501177430152893,
-0.543102502822876,
-0.015144958160817623,
0.12253660708665848,
0.8447792530059814,
0.15248003602027893,
0.15812024474143982,
-0.15787899494171143,
0.2600366473197937,
0.10751268267631531,
0.25071245431900024,
-0.7325379848480225,
-0.3811328411102295,
0.5596806406974792,
-0.5016136765480042,
-0.14819830656051636,
-0.3857370615005493,
-0.7699379920959473,
-0.722926914691925,
-0.21253468096256256,
0.31819215416908264,
-0.6876556277275085,
-0.1275762915611267,
0.3490631878376007,
-0.049002740532159805,
0.13789814710617065,
0.27546781301498413,
-0.6461268663406372,
0.10714767128229141,
0.6505633592605591,
0.7493608593940735,
0.14529918134212494,
-0.27011916041374207,
-0.21706190705299377,
0.2570647895336151,
-0.21549002826213837,
0.6000532507896423,
-0.5266459584236145,
-0.46833720803260803,
-0.13697756826877594,
-0.006614061072468758,
-0.12408780306577682,
-0.3477296233177185,
0.043520573526620865,
-0.3757112920284271,
0.03285480663180351,
-0.05577831342816353,
-0.6065058708190918,
-0.08319832384586334,
0.07005351036787033,
-0.6367112398147583,
0.2872627079486847,
0.020438451319932938,
-0.6631585359573364,
0.023017320781946182,
-1.0712584257125854,
-0.7198112607002258,
0.2002733051776886,
-0.24723070859909058,
-0.40836453437805176,
0.004305641166865826,
0.08387093245983124,
0.6180053353309631,
-0.7625938057899475,
0.6141005754470825,
-0.3955962359905243,
-0.026891503483057022,
0.698948323726654,
-0.31897133588790894,
0.7633432149887085,
0.19868972897529602,
-0.11074811965227127,
0.08649168163537979,
-0.5791996717453003,
-0.2853265702724457,
0.09540604799985886,
-0.17339450120925903,
-0.2627026438713074,
0.28502166271209717,
0.1287912279367447,
-0.11755368858575821,
0.20237776637077332,
-0.6443889737129211,
0.439318984746933,
-0.6556626558303833,
1.0832188129425049,
0.4240642786026001,
0.09404505789279938,
0.3027949333190918,
-0.40518930554389954,
0.3745391070842743,
0.027738019824028015,
0.12174144387245178,
-0.1685422658920288,
-0.8430749177932739,
0.002848768839612603,
-0.23023587465286255,
0.49215927720069885,
0.722728431224823,
-0.4883323013782501,
0.348283976316452,
-0.37830784916877747,
-0.5439679026603699,
-0.6182287335395813,
-0.23591628670692444,
-0.009133787825703621,
0.29507043957710266,
0.3610095679759979,
-0.013040485791862011,
-0.3587295711040497,
-0.8721072673797607,
-0.09108539670705795,
-0.46354663372039795,
-0.14668220281600952,
0.42482131719589233,
0.6536887884140015,
-0.7140767574310303,
0.6850252747535706,
-0.509126603603363,
0.027417022734880447,
-0.19911320507526398,
0.28361186385154724,
0.197991281747818,
0.48287829756736755,
0.25566646456718445,
-0.9894270896911621,
-0.013629644177854061,
0.42637407779693604,
-0.7946731448173523,
-0.05405072122812271,
0.11525767296552658,
0.1993851214647293,
0.013344704173505306,
0.7154893279075623,
-0.7472091317176819,
0.24103280901908875,
0.5284784436225891,
-0.36664509773254395,
0.18687498569488525,
-0.17782485485076904,
0.30371078848838806,
-1.353924036026001,
0.48252031207084656,
-0.0476226881146431,
-0.16894474625587463,
-0.6877696514129639,
-0.1397269368171692,
-0.1253248006105423,
-0.3585204780101776,
-0.025655996054410934,
0.6704238653182983,
-0.24338208138942719,
0.12275282293558121,
-0.1075720265507698,
-0.46766722202301025,
-0.1967368870973587,
-0.04710010066628456,
-0.024969054386019707,
0.3917516767978668,
0.5459516644477844,
-0.402513325214386,
0.4409501552581787,
0.3430306613445282,
-0.41021808981895447,
0.11641642451286316,
-0.8248504400253296,
-0.07824245095252991,
-0.41612255573272705,
0.47778958082199097,
-0.8020042777061462,
-0.5529291033744812,
-0.01167655922472477,
-0.622168779373169,
0.2255278080701828,
0.04992382973432541,
-0.6032055616378784,
-0.5928491353988647,
0.03540448099374771,
0.6340152621269226,
0.5256987810134888,
0.023936249315738678,
0.38134604692459106,
0.6778993606567383,
-0.5138405561447144,
-0.2912132740020752,
-0.785689115524292,
0.062153205275535583,
0.04305789992213249,
-0.44357162714004517,
0.2129422128200531,
-0.17726491391658783,
-0.31910669803619385,
-0.016573313623666763,
0.16577857732772827,
-0.16503722965717316,
0.10385669767856598,
0.4078856110572815,
0.3158016800880432,
-0.13715843856334686,
0.4404314160346985,
-0.00567597895860672,
0.132900670170784,
0.12865100800991058,
-0.5818356871604919,
0.5484411120414734,
0.06950918585062027,
-0.506580114364624,
-0.23439480364322662,
0.5969281792640686,
0.9819873571395874,
-0.38616958260536194,
0.7381566166877747,
0.545193612575531,
-0.6070713400840759,
0.31259241700172424,
-0.3717135190963745,
-0.31727734208106995,
-0.2916974425315857,
0.6590876579284668,
0.12190571427345276,
-1.1112757921218872,
0.4177650809288025,
-0.10189345479011536,
-0.08244197070598602,
0.2324363887310028,
0.7554749250411987,
-0.08957655727863312,
1.0801140069961548,
0.418954461812973,
-0.4396647810935974,
0.2152780145406723,
-0.07514318823814392,
0.41914141178131104,
-0.46903589367866516,
-0.13885392248630524,
-0.6047820448875427,
-0.12474039196968079,
-0.6467491984367371,
-0.5894367694854736,
0.9725303053855896,
-0.33702465891838074,
-0.2945912778377533,
0.01883973367512226,
-0.21598920226097107,
0.11106210947036743,
0.4987756311893463,
0.30556726455688477,
0.1560845822095871,
-0.22827120125293732,
0.21443578600883484,
0.430685818195343,
-0.8411990404129028,
-0.19862748682498932,
1.2027486562728882,
0.5262112021446228,
0.5194275975227356,
-0.03641316667199135,
0.43477022647857666,
0.30067548155784607,
0.14545375108718872,
-0.8135133981704712,
0.3094728887081146,
-0.08048386871814728,
-0.8104148507118225,
-0.3900659680366516,
-0.5284175276756287,
-1.3974339962005615,
-0.43240177631378174,
-0.35165897011756897,
-0.7292006015777588,
0.06955365091562271,
-0.02761217951774597,
-0.6092526912689209,
0.26221710443496704,
-0.475203275680542,
0.7574706077575684,
-0.186336487531662,
-0.14768138527870178,
-0.2081601321697235,
-1.0294240713119507,
0.18466949462890625,
-0.22465281188488007,
0.48083558678627014,
-0.0001992465986404568,
0.14400428533554077,
0.5596086382865906,
-0.1026419922709465,
0.9418432712554932,
0.19741162657737732,
0.005912513472139835,
0.14579841494560242,
-0.09633412957191467,
0.1085054948925972,
0.2523018717765808,
0.04553370550274849,
0.4979076385498047,
0.49325042963027954,
-0.46451258659362793,
-0.18710115551948547,
0.5481594204902649,
-0.7950218915939331,
-0.31420600414276123,
-0.4173903465270996,
-0.780410885810852,
-0.38273170590400696,
0.10432523488998413,
0.3405162990093231,
0.5024842619895935,
-0.33540287613868713,
0.1746351420879364,
0.7380697727203369,
-0.5958518981933594,
0.29098403453826904,
0.3466583490371704,
-0.16141203045845032,
-0.21147756278514862,
0.8808992505073547,
-0.04414400830864906,
0.089339479804039,
0.554833173751831,
0.22257186472415924,
-0.26942309737205505,
-0.65984708070755,
-0.3343783915042877,
0.2938701808452606,
-0.23646408319473267,
-0.228262260556221,
-0.828197717666626,
-0.4596620798110962,
-0.5718419551849365,
0.07314079254865646,
-0.20991407334804535,
-0.11660635471343994,
-0.14176180958747864,
0.11808113008737564,
0.7270592451095581,
0.8183560967445374,
-0.006887346971780062,
-0.0015893812524154782,
-1.235949158668518,
0.42808833718299866,
0.26643043756484985,
0.34672605991363525,
-0.21706287562847137,
-0.007782662287354469,
-0.2717834711074829,
0.19098655879497528,
0.1074570044875145,
-1.0501666069030762,
0.39937981963157654,
0.048488374799489975,
0.32639244198799133,
0.21837937831878662,
-0.4832609295845032,
0.06463747471570969,
-0.8406323790550232,
0.8501655459403992,
0.039978694170713425,
-0.5583931803703308,
0.648179292678833,
-0.6948139071464539,
0.3783254325389862,
0.282881498336792,
0.7005484104156494,
-0.6877415776252747,
-0.2878320813179016,
-0.6064663529396057,
-0.7783616781234741,
0.13929791748523712,
0.01746542938053608,
-0.10543709993362427,
-0.07325772941112518,
0.3659899830818176,
0.06329198181629181,
0.19193848967552185,
-0.4052930474281311,
0.05680900812149048,
0.20111849904060364,
-0.5199884176254272,
-0.20827408134937286,
0.2198300063610077,
-0.19081664085388184,
-0.1613134890794754,
0.3262802064418793,
-0.2741546928882599,
0.5306795835494995,
0.3022325932979584,
0.1068214699625969,
-0.005560637451708317,
0.4810433089733124,
0.3610784113407135,
0.4025917649269104,
-0.012079299427568913,
-0.16506244242191315,
-0.17860530316829681,
-0.5947147011756897,
0.12062510848045349,
0.5600761771202087,
0.03600446507334709,
-0.3204372227191925,
0.5594982504844666,
0.49236351251602173,
-0.006537343841046095,
-1.0579206943511963,
0.28858041763305664,
0.15199267864227295,
-0.12029993534088135,
-0.23719514906406403,
-0.09859271347522736,
0.17214016616344452,
0.5964881777763367,
0.07263917475938797,
0.027008216828107834,
0.43132105469703674,
-0.7021812200546265,
-0.011057269759476185,
0.563876211643219,
-0.18495985865592957,
-0.32140058279037476,
0.8354059457778931,
-0.07629478722810745,
-0.18478013575077057,
0.6150937676429749,
0.5008414387702942,
-0.29727301001548767,
0.7710949778556824,
0.40884506702423096,
0.49575087428092957,
-0.3834874927997589,
0.06739768385887146,
0.1370517760515213,
-0.03731987997889519,
-0.2369156777858734,
0.192718043923378,
0.3282507658004761,
-0.7115181088447571,
-0.5373386740684509,
-0.7053194642066956,
-0.45951133966445923,
0.299765944480896,
-0.29703640937805176,
0.12351639568805695,
-0.2803616523742676,
-0.29350534081459045,
0.6489579677581787,
-0.3664877414703369,
-0.4722468852996826,
0.11995791643857956,
0.4588812291622162,
0.7088475227355957,
-0.836210310459137,
0.9680233597755432,
0.8018260598182678,
-0.3915941119194031,
-0.5547672510147095,
-0.1424957513809204,
0.09261880815029144,
-0.7352902293205261,
0.5352011919021606,
-0.014457391574978828,
0.24842168390750885,
0.11683275550603867,
-0.7985714077949524,
-0.8106018304824829,
0.7949836254119873,
0.14058327674865723,
-0.5448687672615051,
-0.36470940709114075,
0.16363365948200226,
0.80928635597229,
-0.1369212418794632,
0.04768192023038864,
0.6040199995040894,
0.5272601246833801,
-0.2574109733104706,
-1.168617606163025,
-0.2655003070831299,
-0.41130751371383667,
-0.1505005806684494,
0.29197174310684204,
-0.4322190582752228,
0.8247029781341553,
-0.20742027461528778,
0.22305095195770264,
0.3104868233203888,
0.32156217098236084,
0.09363961964845657,
0.4159545302391052,
0.07616626471281052,
0.3639797270298004,
0.791720449924469,
-0.031148124486207962,
1.2493870258331299,
-0.311804860830307,
-0.059078410267829895,
0.6159635186195374,
-0.45375004410743713,
0.5442813038825989,
0.281450480222702,
-0.3272254467010498,
0.25331032276153564,
0.49799543619155884,
-0.1107478067278862,
0.002823713468387723,
0.3052832782268524,
-0.33496415615081787,
0.010675907135009766,
-0.1784011721611023,
-0.505405068397522,
0.522418737411499,
0.7177985906600952,
-0.46573591232299805,
0.20353466272354126,
0.49368324875831604,
-0.10537833720445633,
0.010859754867851734,
-0.40738245844841003,
0.9089433550834656,
0.07379621267318726,
-0.47060510516166687,
0.19899168610572815,
-0.08411827683448792,
0.266740083694458,
-0.6984608173370361,
-0.30640095472335815,
0.045269887894392014,
0.08635758608579636,
0.18731854856014252,
-0.7429757118225098,
0.10265687108039856,
-0.23146003484725952,
-0.4083697199821472,
0.037116341292858124,
0.5480795502662659,
-0.47447478771209717,
-0.5563480257987976,
0.15852735936641693,
0.5135493278503418,
0.23758284747600555,
0.01669427752494812,
-0.41328349709510803,
-0.03456709161400795,
-0.18860280513763428,
-0.012436028569936752,
0.2761937975883484,
0.2997570335865021,
-0.2651721239089966,
0.8213709592819214,
0.5344988107681274,
0.3549404442310333,
-0.1686968356370926,
-0.14353547990322113,
0.6723994016647339,
-0.9189338684082031,
-0.2628938555717468,
-0.9743236303329468,
0.10145414620637894,
0.1396602839231491,
-0.027140144258737564,
0.15340381860733032,
0.3949702978134155,
0.3004162609577179,
-0.15563958883285522,
1.074968695640564,
-0.015294461511075497,
0.730087161064148,
-0.47279277443885803,
1.0239946842193604,
-0.46088653802871704,
-0.052792783826589584,
-0.20639218389987946,
-0.3807462155818939,
-0.48398616909980774,
0.2735874354839325,
-0.2746012806892395,
0.008616448380053043,
0.6674920320510864,
0.6256436109542847,
0.18834878504276276,
0.3352038562297821,
0.16739536821842194,
0.626344621181488,
0.3240419328212738,
0.8672723770141602,
0.7936245799064636,
-0.16656503081321716,
-0.060245364904403687,
0.30521339178085327,
-0.2936248779296875,
-0.16982468962669373,
-0.5607083439826965,
-0.7740530967712402,
-0.814670205116272,
-0.19807419180870056,
-0.37590500712394714,
0.27307581901550293,
1.1392499208450317,
0.6816431879997253,
-0.8332661986351013,
-0.09832074493169785,
-0.10895887762308121,
-0.10953987389802933,
0.05517871305346489,
-0.12612439692020416,
0.32848986983299255,
-0.03945714235305786,
-0.6891425848007202,
0.6675979495048523,
0.355787992477417,
0.28627675771713257,
-0.24072158336639404,
0.3604307770729065,
-0.34879451990127563,
0.14591795206069946,
0.7126319408416748,
0.5658420324325562,
-0.4830397665500641,
-0.1127038300037384,
0.17980246245861053,
-0.28067073225975037,
-0.14913909137248993,
0.788329005241394,
-0.8489661812782288,
0.15536019206047058,
0.36725732684135437,
1.083922266960144,
0.23861177265644073,
-0.34348252415657043,
0.9545968770980835,
-0.09921135008335114,
0.05740506947040558,
0.5820294618606567,
0.3094845712184906,
0.3656281530857086,
-0.49971747398376465,
0.5766250491142273,
0.21544437110424042,
-0.8749142289161682,
-0.7138782143592834,
0.18299536406993866,
-0.9956105947494507,
-0.5851837396621704,
1.0888010263442993,
0.30130547285079956,
-0.2784276008605957,
-0.26411697268486023,
-0.2529353201389313,
0.4174014627933502,
-0.18511012196540833,
0.8481470346450806,
0.5453101396560669,
-0.3859925866127014,
-0.01177281979471445,
-0.9698225259780884,
0.6584398746490479,
0.417417049407959,
-1.074203372001648,
0.05417869612574577,
0.661765992641449,
0.12473839521408081,
0.1275757998228073,
0.6707948446273804,
-0.438320517539978,
0.3263745605945587,
-0.3682807981967926,
0.01405930146574974,
0.21747907996177673,
-0.3458062410354614,
-0.45958590507507324,
0.048101361840963364,
0.07280571758747101,
0.23118731379508972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07221v1
|
Improving Retrieval for RAG based Question Answering Models on Financial Documents
| 2024-03-23T00:49:40 | 2024-03-23T00:49:40 |
Spurthi Setty, Katherine Jijo, Eden Chung, Natan Vidra
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.GN
|
The effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) in generating accurate
responses relies heavily on the quality of input provided, particularly when
employing Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) techniques. RAG enhances LLMs by
sourcing the most relevant text chunk(s) to base queries upon. Despite the
significant advancements in LLMs' response quality in recent years, users may
still encounter inaccuracies or irrelevant answers; these issues often stem
from suboptimal text chunk retrieval by RAG rather than the inherent
capabilities of LLMs. To augment the efficacy of LLMs, it is crucial to refine
the RAG process. This paper explores the existing constraints of RAG pipelines
and introduces methodologies for enhancing text retrieval. It delves into
strategies such as sophisticated chunking techniques, query expansion, the
incorporation of metadata annotations, the application of re-ranking
algorithms, and the fine-tuning of embedding algorithms. Implementing these
approaches can substantially improve the retrieval quality, thereby elevating
the overall performance and reliability of LLMs in processing and responding to
queries.
|
[
-0.15057870745658875,
-0.8537663817405701,
0.6427853107452393,
-0.09643115103244781,
-0.2850640118122101,
0.7503328919410706,
0.011458097957074642,
-0.6980598568916321,
0.4088818430900574,
0.9435063004493713,
-0.11970962584018707,
-0.21487177908420563,
-0.692171573638916,
-0.006343904882669449,
-0.5711770057678223,
1.1733386516571045,
0.0817103460431099,
-0.05148054286837578,
-0.35836008191108704,
-0.11482273042201996,
-0.24378107488155365,
-0.42226025462150574,
-0.988524317741394,
-0.35839027166366577,
0.46018925309181213,
0.2868044376373291,
0.6782978773117065,
0.5692603588104248,
0.9159005880355835,
0.34677034616470337,
-0.5379331707954407,
0.42839306592941284,
-0.4404742419719696,
0.47963860630989075,
-0.1484687626361847,
-0.5582557320594788,
-0.5199657678604126,
-0.11949755996465683,
0.5499684810638428,
0.5400279760360718,
-0.32789257168769836,
0.3039243817329407,
0.04550780728459358,
0.7844936847686768,
-0.6764858961105347,
0.030077505856752396,
-0.7402759194374084,
-0.36287742853164673,
-0.2761782109737396,
-0.6275606155395508,
-0.5066213607788086,
-0.41922426223754883,
0.23669995367527008,
-0.6561301350593567,
0.3309052288532257,
0.25286802649497986,
0.9733964800834656,
0.26650118827819824,
-0.3701813519001007,
-0.6883682012557983,
-0.6443526148796082,
0.6667453646659851,
-0.8828205466270447,
0.28359493613243103,
0.569440484046936,
0.2821383476257324,
-0.1682072877883911,
-0.8998619318008423,
-0.03538138046860695,
-0.16871146857738495,
-0.2712209224700928,
0.08300700783729553,
0.16261625289916992,
0.10855479538440704,
0.23281358182430267,
0.5973680019378662,
-0.2607637941837311,
-0.09158489108085632,
-0.3844371736049652,
-0.14509937167167664,
0.6409167051315308,
0.18961161375045776,
-0.1171732172369957,
-0.37129563093185425,
-0.2956952750682831,
-0.29040783643722534,
-0.4345773458480835,
0.08764669299125671,
0.6272799372673035,
0.39561691880226135,
0.41220876574516296,
0.7540633082389832,
0.007692328188568354,
0.8107301592826843,
0.1746436208486557,
-0.4327228367328644,
0.05309175327420235,
-0.2927837073802948,
-0.0897885411977768,
-0.1947932243347168,
-0.013628262095153332,
0.1021614819765091,
-0.0682751014828682,
-0.07664034515619278,
-0.7080170512199402,
-0.6835777759552002,
0.5073307752609253,
-0.5573623180389404,
0.12342372536659241,
0.40928417444229126,
-0.4916204810142517,
-0.31387409567832947,
0.17121067643165588,
-0.8366516828536987,
-0.5721793174743652,
-0.3966819643974304,
0.46808546781539917,
-0.3274895250797272,
-0.11894488334655762,
0.000884281937032938,
-0.5390061140060425,
0.5248660445213318,
0.37080806493759155,
-0.8917852640151978,
0.37982702255249023,
1.1168932914733887,
0.49532678723335266,
0.2591073215007782,
0.3807971477508545,
-0.9015811681747437,
0.27774009108543396,
-0.42315593361854553,
1.020530343055725,
-0.6803888082504272,
-0.43948373198509216,
-0.040745072066783905,
-0.41219985485076904,
0.06267040222883224,
-0.8134908676147461,
0.6708455681800842,
-1.0613884925842285,
0.22722283005714417,
-0.3119160830974579,
-0.7660358548164368,
-0.13325388729572296,
0.41468924283981323,
-0.5673337578773499,
1.1123743057250977,
0.3236084580421448,
-0.9521582126617432,
0.08287400007247925,
-0.6187835931777954,
-0.34856969118118286,
0.05101698637008667,
0.09006673842668533,
-0.28640663623809814,
0.2986164689064026,
0.3172578513622284,
0.3364441990852356,
-0.613955557346344,
0.1871483325958252,
-0.0681539922952652,
-0.31520378589630127,
0.3176237642765045,
-0.2641126811504364,
0.3612525165081024,
0.26671725511550903,
0.2415267378091812,
-0.007291839458048344,
-0.6309892535209656,
0.05088292807340622,
0.09690440446138382,
-0.4159000515937805,
-0.7496944069862366,
-0.03723695129156113,
0.0546807199716568,
-0.27407824993133545,
0.4365401864051819,
-0.4644398093223572,
0.029888203367590904,
-0.8511922955513,
0.24470330774784088,
0.6666507124900818,
0.25921714305877686,
0.44410252571105957,
-0.6174048781394958,
0.7696675658226013,
-0.12859542667865753,
0.002866598544642329,
-0.43934494256973267,
-0.20052826404571533,
-0.6893892288208008,
-0.12362189590930939,
0.5933907628059387,
0.6420263648033142,
-0.8454013466835022,
-0.2429487109184265,
-0.08915869891643524,
-0.48357143998146057,
-0.7442108988761902,
0.1493072211742401,
0.24789726734161377,
0.6032963395118713,
0.31059616804122925,
-0.19388450682163239,
-0.514299213886261,
-0.8508443236351013,
-0.47242262959480286,
-0.18354976177215576,
-0.18847858905792236,
0.5797276496887207,
0.29893651604652405,
0.10252606868743896,
0.8560122847557068,
-0.8008877038955688,
-0.039849214255809784,
-0.17050312459468842,
0.3582138121128082,
0.4931557774543762,
0.1878625750541687,
0.4245131015777588,
-1.2054252624511719,
-0.3351665139198303,
-0.005394420120865107,
-0.29470911622047424,
-0.019990675151348114,
-0.1508401781320572,
0.11424653232097626,
0.5033320188522339,
0.6361252665519714,
-0.24870868027210236,
0.3650781512260437,
0.394999623298645,
-0.2754345238208771,
0.4319573640823364,
-0.32579249143600464,
0.2652111053466797,
-1.2133631706237793,
0.2517814636230469,
-0.05467213690280914,
-0.5137130618095398,
-0.4109794497489929,
0.3762963116168976,
0.07660271972417831,
0.052900657057762146,
-0.10023277252912521,
0.798852264881134,
-0.5920877456665039,
-0.4077111482620239,
-0.5866513252258301,
0.42601311206817627,
0.27449965476989746,
0.057850927114486694,
-0.3738575279712677,
0.933366596698761,
0.15987098217010498,
-0.38333606719970703,
0.2000741809606552,
0.19920854270458221,
-0.1565055251121521,
0.5980442762374878,
-0.8056067228317261,
-0.02355225943028927,
-0.5579821467399597,
0.20561838150024414,
-1.202545404434204,
-0.1970582902431488,
-0.04119204729795456,
-0.41000664234161377,
0.8431611061096191,
-0.2538979649543762,
-0.4205569922924042,
-0.2632896602153778,
-0.35859760642051697,
0.2385440319776535,
0.41183772683143616,
-0.45510268211364746,
0.9006567001342773,
0.4501418173313141,
-0.5108087062835693,
-0.9891080260276794,
-0.2794282138347626,
0.21584506332874298,
-0.25472941994667053,
-0.6188050508499146,
0.3904557228088379,
0.10387880355119705,
-0.34765294194221497,
0.009951997548341751,
-0.34488269686698914,
-0.10976698994636536,
0.16023367643356323,
-0.2665892541408539,
0.5348679423332214,
-0.09532935172319412,
0.17993034422397614,
0.02894570492208004,
-0.1912773847579956,
-0.14639514684677124,
-0.21766740083694458,
0.4040546715259552,
0.15555033087730408,
-0.15891985595226288,
0.2977021336555481,
0.33255133032798767,
0.41768380999565125,
-0.5943791270256042,
0.6747281551361084,
0.43384963274002075,
-0.2008022516965866,
-0.10228025168180466,
-0.9531779289245605,
-0.17094682157039642,
-0.5315064191818237,
0.2125997394323349,
-0.2903115451335907,
-1.1528465747833252,
0.7120729088783264,
-0.21679390966892242,
0.16821244359016418,
0.5616483092308044,
0.3120352029800415,
-0.2098972201347351,
0.6509836316108704,
0.6842605471611023,
0.09891907125711441,
0.4200257658958435,
-0.2538759708404541,
0.12290412187576294,
-1.169969916343689,
-0.19481459259986877,
-0.8471295833587646,
-0.11133322864770889,
-0.6197683811187744,
-0.7889517545700073,
0.4647029638290405,
0.13651181757450104,
0.06254501640796661,
0.2121475785970688,
-0.40267816185951233,
0.5344356894493103,
0.21573515236377716,
-0.016844233497977257,
0.37540167570114136,
-0.07308270037174225,
-0.2811025083065033,
0.05548872426152229,
-0.6604015231132507,
-0.4635380506515503,
1.0664407014846802,
0.5816675424575806,
0.9079508185386658,
0.059230588376522064,
0.7150865793228149,
0.17282484471797943,
0.5114704966545105,
-0.5455294847488403,
0.300468385219574,
-0.30975255370140076,
-0.8117178678512573,
-0.4259156286716461,
-0.635796844959259,
-0.835322380065918,
0.15782931447029114,
-0.19677326083183289,
-0.5304713249206543,
0.0847395583987236,
-0.08161189407110214,
-0.35542988777160645,
0.1661478728055954,
-0.3822718858718872,
0.37870556116104126,
-0.1409030705690384,
-0.3153928220272064,
-0.12469877302646637,
-0.4809245467185974,
0.3380502462387085,
-0.4578077495098114,
0.2813287377357483,
-0.002165796933695674,
-0.40784475207328796,
0.5836353898048401,
-0.25857800245285034,
0.564635157585144,
-0.08604639768600464,
-0.4561789333820343,
0.38087576627731323,
-0.1489393413066864,
0.7532922029495239,
0.062404386699199677,
-0.4095989465713501,
-0.3513362407684326,
0.255856990814209,
-0.45227980613708496,
-0.7674960494041443,
0.5794686079025269,
-0.3149671256542206,
-0.8993901610374451,
-0.3709862232208252,
-0.7617024183273315,
-0.4412233531475067,
-0.035118814557790756,
-0.13142527639865875,
0.5260958671569824,
0.0027686527464538813,
0.3368819057941437,
0.7102292776107788,
-0.4081340432167053,
0.3064979314804077,
0.5294974446296692,
-0.47665783762931824,
-0.5763391256332397,
0.688496470451355,
0.2767430245876312,
0.225296750664711,
0.5663291811943054,
0.16846191883087158,
-0.6592826247215271,
-0.6254061460494995,
-0.18720471858978271,
0.4609817564487457,
-0.6744363903999329,
-0.5499930381774902,
-0.625248372554779,
-0.3856967091560364,
-0.6215988993644714,
-0.02796093560755253,
-0.22416862845420837,
-0.6010065674781799,
-0.28356650471687317,
-0.16666120290756226,
0.6620206236839294,
0.7212522625923157,
-0.016053305938839912,
0.1436689794063568,
-1.1798344850540161,
0.4230791926383972,
0.1737545132637024,
0.6592408418655396,
0.19270996749401093,
-0.8779349327087402,
-0.4200717508792877,
-0.06471636891365051,
-0.25239187479019165,
-0.6459124088287354,
0.4294183552265167,
-0.053969334810972214,
0.5807192325592041,
0.09295622259378433,
0.11261289566755295,
0.8507216572761536,
-0.29505863785743713,
0.3891863226890564,
-0.2974749505519867,
-0.6781502962112427,
0.44726619124412537,
-0.5563820004463196,
0.08133608102798462,
0.602347731590271,
0.4293583333492279,
-0.5105282068252563,
-0.6177321076393127,
-0.6580687761306763,
-1.2740463018417358,
0.4800836741924286,
0.030638769268989563,
0.28634631633758545,
0.05986354500055313,
0.9474068880081177,
-0.031122654676437378,
0.19690680503845215,
-0.14960308372974396,
-0.12033683061599731,
0.21137742698192596,
-0.05076118931174278,
-0.017606569454073906,
-0.47941842675209045,
0.15220867097377777,
-0.0456441231071949,
0.9059313535690308,
-0.14573971927165985,
-0.2284131646156311,
0.3860379457473755,
0.37757736444473267,
-0.23677195608615875,
0.21425728499889374,
0.3687756359577179,
0.8104676604270935,
-0.3883711099624634,
-0.3911662697792053,
0.19620662927627563,
-0.367827445268631,
0.03661174699664116,
0.35597121715545654,
-0.2555413544178009,
0.05144515261054039,
0.23491093516349792,
0.4145813286304474,
0.2332611083984375,
-0.8279706835746765,
0.20453906059265137,
-0.14665979146957397,
-0.015710391104221344,
-0.47607743740081787,
0.02324567548930645,
0.2945459485054016,
0.45423707365989685,
0.9199395775794983,
-0.22568245232105255,
0.2581998109817505,
-0.5156698226928711,
0.33843788504600525,
0.6025542616844177,
-0.10688206553459167,
0.36176633834838867,
0.6791364550590515,
0.07643331587314606,
-0.4182721972465515,
0.5299240350723267,
0.16863517463207245,
-0.39968347549438477,
0.5852556228637695,
0.46077510714530945,
0.7580203413963318,
-0.12245246022939682,
0.20515628159046173,
0.38512203097343445,
0.26713037490844727,
-0.17243126034736633,
0.4108636975288391,
0.09451499581336975,
-0.45490461587905884,
-0.9478368759155273,
-1.0336090326309204,
-0.7293952703475952,
-0.11694717407226562,
-0.7603343725204468,
0.11014283448457718,
-0.35351428389549255,
-0.3272607922554016,
-0.08589691668748856,
0.2632775902748108,
-0.23367351293563843,
0.23559902608394623,
-0.0667475238442421,
1.1654740571975708,
-0.3136676549911499,
0.4833270013332367,
0.7161003351211548,
-0.38644590973854065,
-0.8483431339263916,
-0.014409269206225872,
-0.25258979201316833,
-0.5498274564743042,
0.5348045229911804,
-0.2396949976682663,
0.11285439878702164,
0.05665241554379463,
-0.41906893253326416,
-1.145167589187622,
1.042906403541565,
0.18887075781822205,
-0.4094075858592987,
-0.12504678964614868,
0.13422809541225433,
0.6754738092422485,
-0.10691224783658981,
0.26917630434036255,
0.5230534672737122,
0.5624598860740662,
0.5513608455657959,
-0.7727328538894653,
-0.23508353531360626,
-0.1035662367939949,
0.09234457463026047,
0.5278882384300232,
-0.5439996123313904,
0.630771279335022,
-0.10201557725667953,
-0.010988623835146427,
0.33120429515838623,
0.7639983892440796,
0.3778255879878998,
0.5257207155227661,
0.4041457772254944,
0.6470379829406738,
0.8921520709991455,
-0.14147157967090607,
1.3726497888565063,
-0.21757882833480835,
0.3389751613140106,
1.1937553882598877,
-0.3311454653739929,
1.1723359823226929,
0.5887182950973511,
-0.09141810238361359,
0.3199519217014313,
0.5719740390777588,
0.035347118973731995,
0.08732792735099792,
0.4232544004917145,
-0.15956276655197144,
-0.12884080410003662,
-0.3905615210533142,
-0.10203250497579575,
0.5174075961112976,
0.48580023646354675,
-0.47234150767326355,
-0.2242993414402008,
-0.09137793630361557,
-0.0926092118024826,
0.3574303388595581,
-0.20601551234722137,
0.9332402348518372,
0.13636763393878937,
-0.6562135219573975,
0.19328097999095917,
0.35116103291511536,
0.5958524346351624,
-0.6600449085235596,
-0.1651698499917984,
-0.5615848302841187,
-0.06009642034769058,
-0.09428376704454422,
-0.6438684463500977,
0.6676641702651978,
0.18860755860805511,
-0.29439496994018555,
-0.34830793738365173,
1.0559484958648682,
-0.29152023792266846,
-0.6735278367996216,
0.20848225057125092,
0.6180922389030457,
-0.004710364155471325,
-0.02300397865474224,
-0.5641815066337585,
-0.2071422040462494,
-0.16765949130058289,
-0.42432335019111633,
0.3801669478416443,
0.5446187257766724,
0.10688115656375885,
0.7093676924705505,
0.9110300540924072,
0.13009744882583618,
-0.22672544419765472,
-0.08874552696943283,
0.889725923538208,
-0.6792566180229187,
-0.2713746726512909,
-0.4707088768482208,
0.39031466841697693,
-0.1445292830467224,
-0.0075072795152664185,
0.7247042059898376,
0.7080804705619812,
0.6891945600509644,
0.2648612856864929,
0.41333064436912537,
0.21291999518871307,
1.0849199295043945,
-0.5500335097312927,
0.71929931640625,
-0.785713255405426,
0.5906988978385925,
-0.4833444654941559,
-1.039399266242981,
-0.24963587522506714,
0.414718896150589,
-0.31380823254585266,
0.13796469569206238,
0.3502001464366913,
0.812526524066925,
0.0941629558801651,
0.01271230261772871,
0.3070499897003174,
0.32335227727890015,
0.2583690583705902,
-0.07173706591129303,
0.7431511878967285,
-0.6030887365341187,
0.7145357131958008,
-0.024858519434928894,
0.036135971546173096,
-0.15245486795902252,
-0.9538865089416504,
-0.39412111043930054,
-0.5099362134933472,
-0.2104370892047882,
-0.33172813057899475,
0.11681579798460007,
0.6466475129127502,
0.2920812964439392,
-0.5381883978843689,
-0.31517964601516724,
0.3766031265258789,
0.19580014050006866,
0.20304548740386963,
-0.27411991357803345,
0.3643855154514313,
-0.6543081402778625,
-0.6990631222724915,
0.30555301904678345,
0.46933713555336,
0.13217468559741974,
-0.2786252796649933,
0.19153758883476257,
-0.3990863859653473,
0.5269819498062134,
0.5732985138893127,
0.08448588848114014,
-0.39072880148887634,
-0.2279372364282608,
0.2847518026828766,
-0.08551069349050522,
-0.08353466540575027,
0.7835697531700134,
-0.6302993893623352,
0.15023912489414215,
0.6634460687637329,
1.0880708694458008,
0.6338616609573364,
0.5870472192764282,
0.4592304825782776,
-0.6993590593338013,
-0.14252664148807526,
0.5337839126586914,
0.1679455041885376,
0.45593124628067017,
-0.41318267583847046,
0.7136930227279663,
-0.09805434197187424,
-0.7194136381149292,
-0.721839189529419,
-0.1604919284582138,
-0.7256662249565125,
-0.5503394603729248,
0.9748430252075195,
-0.010605151765048504,
-0.402601420879364,
-0.16185884177684784,
-0.34580788016319275,
0.07442257553339005,
-0.2688663601875305,
0.6990280151367188,
0.8521168828010559,
-0.010062097571790218,
-0.12605148553848267,
-0.7081810235977173,
0.36497023701667786,
0.45589515566825867,
-0.698591947555542,
0.2019505649805069,
0.5110373497009277,
0.1605330854654312,
0.24377533793449402,
0.6637623906135559,
-0.3715048134326935,
0.1274183839559555,
-0.17618973553180695,
-0.4058959186077118,
0.04310115799307823,
-0.23981572687625885,
-0.1515790969133377,
0.36575308442115784,
0.27107805013656616,
0.3210901916027069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02554v1
|
Hear Me, See Me, Understand Me: Audio-Visual Autism Behavior Recognition
| 2024-03-22T22:52:35 | 2024-03-22T22:52:35 |
Shijian Deng, Erin E. Kosloski, Siddhi Patel, Zeke A. Barnett, Yiyang Nan, Alexander Kaplan, Sisira Aarukapalli, William T. Doan, Matthew Wang, Harsh Singh, Pamela R. Rollins, Yapeng Tian
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
In this article, we introduce a novel problem of audio-visual autism behavior
recognition, which includes social behavior recognition, an essential aspect
previously omitted in AI-assisted autism screening research. We define the task
at hand as one that is audio-visual autism behavior recognition, which uses
audio and visual cues, including any speech present in the audio, to recognize
autism-related behaviors. To facilitate this new research direction, we
collected an audio-visual autism spectrum dataset (AV-ASD), currently the
largest video dataset for autism screening using a behavioral approach. It
covers an extensive range of autism-associated behaviors, including those
related to social communication and interaction. To pave the way for further
research on this new problem, we intensively explored leveraging foundation
models and multimodal large language models across different modalities. Our
experiments on the AV-ASD dataset demonstrate that integrating audio, visual,
and speech modalities significantly enhances the performance in autism behavior
recognition. Additionally, we explored the use of a post-hoc to ad-hoc pipeline
in a multimodal large language model to investigate its potential to augment
the model's explanatory capability during autism behavior recognition. We will
release our dataset, code, and pre-trained models.
|
[
-0.6577790379524231,
-0.7432356476783752,
0.2057196944952011,
0.28686705231666565,
0.0628104880452156,
0.15800189971923828,
0.03705219551920891,
-0.7711195945739746,
0.4730378985404968,
0.2896097004413605,
-0.6085042953491211,
-0.15482866764068604,
-0.8554787635803223,
-0.04849584773182869,
-0.594139814376831,
0.663359522819519,
0.11846029758453369,
0.17125487327575684,
-0.05139969661831856,
-0.21536508202552795,
-0.26309043169021606,
-0.36229968070983887,
-1.1207973957061768,
-0.1254434585571289,
0.28929129242897034,
0.5542406439781189,
0.3400420546531677,
0.30172964930534363,
0.32084527611732483,
0.37469273805618286,
-0.25310203433036804,
0.1663089096546173,
-0.004131583962589502,
0.01152744609862566,
0.10068811476230621,
0.12664908170700073,
-0.7811494469642639,
0.42932257056236267,
0.41180139780044556,
0.8138090372085571,
-0.03220703452825546,
0.3385825753211975,
-0.04729708284139633,
0.16273565590381622,
-0.2636306881904602,
0.4368901252746582,
-0.16669169068336487,
0.056729771196842194,
-0.13148842751979828,
-0.06784693896770477,
-0.08514723926782608,
0.445421427488327,
0.09909845888614655,
-0.5536037683486938,
-0.08013308048248291,
-0.057258374989032745,
0.32254841923713684,
-0.05922236293554306,
-0.9133353233337402,
-0.22587959468364716,
-1.0683786869049072,
0.4356430470943451,
-0.4601527452468872,
0.6195574402809143,
0.8913657069206238,
0.5983278751373291,
0.18104733526706696,
-0.5998561978340149,
-0.9288626313209534,
-0.1260855495929718,
0.31039881706237793,
-0.019447384402155876,
-0.3800325393676758,
-0.08570187538862228,
0.5040748715400696,
0.16186179220676422,
-0.7203400731086731,
-0.1292945295572281,
-0.5845431089401245,
-0.45820125937461853,
0.6655637621879578,
0.06214384734630585,
0.46996986865997314,
-0.018291059881448746,
0.17266945540905,
-0.3002931475639343,
-0.2366238236427307,
0.7236245274543762,
0.14305181801319122,
0.1630735844373703,
-0.38931190967559814,
0.5229278802871704,
-0.1923922449350357,
0.38068631291389465,
0.015899211168289185,
0.20818626880645752,
0.46566811203956604,
-0.5653545260429382,
-0.1019306480884552,
-0.03888999670743942,
0.52186518907547,
0.3527349531650543,
0.19008243083953857,
0.30815187096595764,
-0.03217925876379013,
0.3489656448364258,
0.1803050935268402,
-0.5015155076980591,
-0.14242562651634216,
-0.06104819104075432,
-0.47848963737487793,
-0.26713696122169495,
-0.18056093156337738,
-0.6061966419219971,
-0.45683184266090393,
-0.3319889008998871,
0.3672756552696228,
-0.38761115074157715,
-0.7275862097740173,
0.16338229179382324,
-0.1406196653842926,
0.3753747045993805,
0.44582560658454895,
-0.9427569508552551,
0.5771979689598083,
0.6835535764694214,
0.807983934879303,
0.5315195918083191,
-0.4480631351470947,
-1.119992733001709,
0.2643847167491913,
-0.2275177240371704,
0.7052090764045715,
-0.826111912727356,
-0.24754324555397034,
-0.22524519264698029,
0.18485531210899353,
-0.11974294483661652,
-0.48413196206092834,
0.4230540990829468,
-0.13408537209033966,
-0.15237261354923248,
-0.3502369821071625,
-0.03873602673411369,
-0.341319739818573,
0.2843102216720581,
-0.7448989748954773,
0.28919854760169983,
0.028497718274593353,
-0.3745916783809662,
0.3815446197986603,
-0.8755587935447693,
-0.4526573717594147,
0.05827648192644119,
-0.4531492590904236,
-0.39522606134414673,
-0.11850900948047638,
0.39163580536842346,
0.34275853633880615,
0.32644373178482056,
-0.021123521029949188,
-0.6042640209197998,
-0.3638017475605011,
0.1814778745174408,
-0.4200279116630554,
0.7549498677253723,
0.29897308349609375,
-0.3066073954105377,
0.21615663170814514,
-0.6311473250389099,
-0.4792281687259674,
0.11731679737567902,
-0.19780617952346802,
-0.30985164642333984,
0.14055390655994415,
0.37522876262664795,
-0.01840134523808956,
-0.08525773882865906,
-0.6747081875801086,
-0.26208874583244324,
-0.3771045207977295,
0.6964583992958069,
0.5889835357666016,
-0.24740812182426453,
0.35493847727775574,
-0.211042582988739,
0.7004570960998535,
0.2684231698513031,
0.32332512736320496,
-0.3276700973510742,
-0.5422390103340149,
-0.09413887560367584,
-0.2506791651248932,
0.042299553751945496,
0.22513897716999054,
-0.4495832920074463,
0.14194127917289734,
0.06663006544113159,
-0.050534531474113464,
-0.46832406520843506,
0.057879507541656494,
0.4917411506175995,
0.6468570232391357,
0.21768687665462494,
-0.5586180686950684,
-0.5023899078369141,
-0.6225538849830627,
-0.13913872838020325,
-0.3014640510082245,
0.24300874769687653,
0.6777376532554626,
0.39122462272644043,
-0.4134185314178467,
0.39366188645362854,
-0.010797479189932346,
-0.35649919509887695,
-0.23437318205833435,
0.41485947370529175,
0.13086029887199402,
0.46977877616882324,
0.8008542060852051,
-0.8531419038772583,
-0.25159257650375366,
0.11084849387407303,
-0.6260856986045837,
-0.03367333114147186,
0.28903743624687195,
0.27477768063545227,
-0.2004949301481247,
0.9056044220924377,
-0.31311553716659546,
0.5655874609947205,
0.5768689513206482,
-0.9625970125198364,
0.299214243888855,
0.17282631993293762,
0.4972529113292694,
-0.759803295135498,
-0.29744571447372437,
0.04388563334941864,
-0.3741205334663391,
-0.4497315585613251,
-0.3153599500656128,
-0.2599141597747803,
-0.4860030710697174,
-0.3405236601829529,
0.512182891368866,
-0.4313241243362427,
-0.6763722896575928,
-0.06896724551916122,
-0.19139890372753143,
0.0455697625875473,
0.27498942613601685,
-0.17344635725021362,
0.8880590200424194,
0.9778835773468018,
-0.6389502286911011,
0.5140464305877686,
0.5965495109558105,
-0.20894025266170502,
0.9021193385124207,
-0.6593407392501831,
-0.07801266759634018,
-0.0656927078962326,
0.13618606328964233,
-0.9958846569061279,
-0.27527672052383423,
0.549734354019165,
-0.6212990283966064,
0.40215128660202026,
-0.048935286700725555,
-0.09006187319755554,
-0.39677494764328003,
-0.3546506464481354,
0.9443642497062683,
0.06729421019554138,
-0.7490445375442505,
0.8061887621879578,
0.8244276642799377,
-0.5424294471740723,
-0.47078388929367065,
-0.4355821907520294,
0.06091400980949402,
-0.20486876368522644,
-0.6366973519325256,
-0.002362944185733795,
-0.29660564661026,
-0.24874015152454376,
-0.11545944213867188,
-0.21486309170722961,
-0.0472138449549675,
0.18805855512619019,
0.27557939291000366,
-0.2533104121685028,
-0.44573935866355896,
0.05595936253666878,
0.15098032355308533,
-0.16914796829223633,
0.17033341526985168,
0.22656743228435516,
0.4031674563884735,
-0.2960874140262604,
-0.5069942474365234,
-0.37624478340148926,
0.6923232674598694,
0.7026436924934387,
-0.5553021430969238,
0.21449920535087585,
0.6975287199020386,
-0.43733498454093933,
-0.10005242377519608,
-0.0848589763045311,
-0.3812580108642578,
-0.48239362239837646,
0.498452752828598,
-0.1813976764678955,
-0.774245023727417,
0.505477249622345,
-0.029466576874256134,
-0.23939965665340424,
-0.2872473895549774,
0.22161002457141876,
-0.7596034407615662,
1.4172025918960571,
0.6830810308456421,
-0.10256382077932358,
0.9825261235237122,
-0.35541823506355286,
0.1519344449043274,
-1.0383248329162598,
-0.21158508956432343,
-0.300447940826416,
-0.6078150272369385,
-0.05926496535539627,
-0.2507990896701813,
0.5083231329917908,
-0.43013298511505127,
-0.47360163927078247,
0.09294424206018448,
-0.10344333946704865,
0.3252009153366089,
0.5293943881988525,
0.3002769351005554,
0.3990360200405121,
0.0156011413782835,
0.21549548208713531,
-0.06653182953596115,
-0.11854030191898346,
-0.21102894842624664,
1.2182570695877075,
0.28785133361816406,
0.5223214626312256,
0.3475004732608795,
0.25994744896888733,
0.5063948631286621,
0.154091939330101,
-0.729619562625885,
0.6149868965148926,
-0.13467925786972046,
-0.3708089292049408,
-0.23171545565128326,
-0.1379583775997162,
-1.1578795909881592,
0.0947333499789238,
-0.3559545576572418,
-0.6360341906547546,
0.5155578255653381,
0.29309558868408203,
-0.10232919454574585,
0.021393755450844765,
-0.6741787791252136,
1.1330355405807495,
-0.3417127728462219,
0.28819799423217773,
-0.49648556113243103,
-0.3062770664691925,
0.3454601466655731,
0.06770603358745575,
0.8162436485290527,
-0.25952446460723877,
0.27801215648651123,
0.8955641388893127,
-0.45335400104522705,
0.7954055070877075,
-0.25056204199790955,
0.2543365955352783,
0.1860639601945877,
-0.12338068336248398,
0.037503354251384735,
0.17771121859550476,
0.38755759596824646,
0.23317553102970123,
0.1875426024198532,
-0.23169104754924774,
-0.29689720273017883,
0.5388814806938171,
-0.7931627631187439,
-0.16436612606048584,
-0.6443187594413757,
-0.45120590925216675,
-0.36643534898757935,
0.054782457649707794,
-0.1361318677663803,
0.7204381227493286,
-0.3679107129573822,
0.16965951025485992,
0.22719955444335938,
-0.16106507182121277,
0.5314801931381226,
0.7505263090133667,
-0.39238277077674866,
-0.20886407792568207,
0.9213536381721497,
-0.07075650990009308,
-0.25240832567214966,
-0.13923554122447968,
-0.04413588345050812,
-0.10849303007125854,
-0.5611192584037781,
-0.20332908630371094,
0.3644176721572876,
-0.5561632513999939,
0.10084217041730881,
-0.6356295943260193,
0.07912157475948334,
-0.7735441327095032,
0.08751790225505829,
-0.17561455070972443,
-0.2857244610786438,
-0.17921875417232513,
-0.45608609914779663,
0.5714054107666016,
0.6431738138198853,
-0.4318118989467621,
0.5722406506538391,
-0.5063225626945496,
0.8011003136634827,
0.5658079981803894,
0.4672110676765442,
-0.09347349405288696,
-0.35846465826034546,
-0.270906925201416,
0.2219802290201187,
-0.30488643050193787,
-1.0024878978729248,
0.3948383033275604,
0.5818063616752625,
0.5855287909507751,
0.566985547542572,
-0.15979379415512085,
0.48526811599731445,
-0.3346925973892212,
0.4267239570617676,
0.04068133607506752,
-1.0147300958633423,
0.688193678855896,
-0.3003895878791809,
-0.21899329125881195,
0.26995009183883667,
0.017436347901821136,
-0.43328410387039185,
-0.30533331632614136,
-0.5648283958435059,
-0.7914060950279236,
0.8198448419570923,
0.12263579666614532,
0.14862695336341858,
-0.019396794959902763,
0.0336945615708828,
-0.35693639516830444,
0.1969701647758484,
-0.6778905391693115,
-0.028435034677386284,
-0.4266960620880127,
-0.3539403975009918,
-0.3731500506401062,
-0.13585607707500458,
-0.28524768352508545,
-0.5390670895576477,
0.2808268964290619,
-0.32679876685142517,
0.19864551723003387,
-0.0064789121970534325,
-0.07628272473812103,
-0.3793892562389374,
-0.039756715297698975,
0.2156548649072647,
0.18856292963027954,
-0.04685228690505028,
0.03461231663823128,
-0.25802505016326904,
-0.7891941666603088,
-0.0054471250623464584,
0.29215675592422485,
0.16409018635749817,
-0.0680789202451706,
0.5596314668655396,
0.705949604511261,
0.27160754799842834,
-1.025368094444275,
0.8397293090820312,
-0.44608980417251587,
-0.2728894054889679,
-0.5170429348945618,
0.09587527066469193,
0.13395054638385773,
1.0134129524230957,
0.08919120579957962,
0.2384299337863922,
0.6231167316436768,
-0.7214080095291138,
0.40094757080078125,
0.8492304682731628,
-0.31138065457344055,
-0.550173282623291,
0.7976369857788086,
0.15320225059986115,
-0.44656771421432495,
0.4704383313655853,
0.1189156249165535,
-0.20806826651096344,
1.1735496520996094,
0.28382495045661926,
0.655819833278656,
-0.4914577305316925,
0.4298914968967438,
0.14086665213108063,
0.14008095860481262,
0.1480913609266281,
0.6507989168167114,
-0.4478933811187744,
-0.8496692180633545,
-0.09930137544870377,
-0.49028053879737854,
-0.6011369824409485,
0.1719071865081787,
-0.7731857895851135,
0.1666431874036789,
-0.6404078602790833,
-0.18308180570602417,
0.4986160099506378,
-0.2709927260875702,
-0.5768270492553711,
0.37471723556518555,
0.4248765707015991,
0.44306445121765137,
-1.198219656944275,
0.5194284319877625,
0.8971574902534485,
-0.5692983269691467,
-0.9338304996490479,
-0.1999180167913437,
0.3365091383457184,
-0.7893474698066711,
0.11705931276082993,
0.18737182021141052,
-0.2933539152145386,
-0.01559746079146862,
-0.8496197462081909,
-0.6982914209365845,
0.9516376852989197,
0.3168882429599762,
-0.31513625383377075,
0.35229381918907166,
-0.4336961805820465,
0.5171262621879578,
-0.709067702293396,
0.26278042793273926,
0.5944697856903076,
0.4457787871360779,
0.31981194019317627,
-0.9295310378074646,
-0.30641570687294006,
-0.7494188547134399,
-0.5347653031349182,
-0.21219289302825928,
-0.23420467972755432,
0.8488132357597351,
-0.3876758813858032,
-0.0030735291074961424,
-0.37403756380081177,
0.5799444317817688,
0.17416349053382874,
1.167702078819275,
0.7922675013542175,
0.13535867631435394,
0.6911348700523376,
0.2579505741596222,
0.7307205200195312,
-0.009778264909982681,
-0.07115032523870468,
0.8433204889297485,
-0.1415794938802719,
0.9132751226425171,
0.24120016396045685,
-0.12624911963939667,
0.2054305225610733,
0.7457144260406494,
0.20552176237106323,
0.4647245407104492,
-0.4577188193798065,
-0.2786571681499481,
-0.10427891463041306,
-0.2840545177459717,
-0.5246803760528564,
0.6617984175682068,
0.6534013748168945,
-0.11850953102111816,
0.014436015859246254,
0.42812076210975647,
-0.4228748083114624,
0.16246868669986725,
-0.6440647840499878,
1.033200979232788,
0.2523551285266876,
-0.03483525663614273,
0.2810269594192505,
-0.40010929107666016,
0.4674895107746124,
-0.35018453001976013,
-0.14695124328136444,
-0.052858635783195496,
-0.06726505607366562,
-0.35478100180625916,
-0.5463375449180603,
0.6614655256271362,
-0.07177010178565979,
-0.26674872636795044,
-0.22539593279361725,
0.4306107461452484,
-0.597847580909729,
-0.449001669883728,
0.6781195998191833,
0.5105956196784973,
0.2400854527950287,
-0.2597530782222748,
-0.5832799077033997,
0.1447339504957199,
-0.3684348165988922,
-0.08574756979942322,
0.4320153594017029,
0.4727579951286316,
-0.23050568997859955,
0.5827099680900574,
0.8358495831489563,
0.20204977691173553,
-0.05788196623325348,
0.29840800166130066,
0.6801509857177734,
-0.7145491242408752,
-0.8002311587333679,
-0.5258468389511108,
0.21871405839920044,
0.06465741246938705,
0.03389918431639671,
0.26634395122528076,
0.21345864236354828,
0.8216949701309204,
0.057828959077596664,
0.5604577660560608,
0.2729950547218323,
0.790454626083374,
-0.13095110654830933,
0.6399077773094177,
-0.9256726503372192,
0.37991800904273987,
-0.6389465928077698,
-0.5655587911605835,
-0.01819472946226597,
1.0044974088668823,
-0.25507375597953796,
0.16632844507694244,
0.3924682140350342,
0.5471335649490356,
-0.4619467258453369,
0.25109538435935974,
0.13514089584350586,
0.610358476638794,
0.5185766220092773,
0.3803061544895172,
0.7828612923622131,
-0.18978171050548553,
0.6352760195732117,
-0.02669982984662056,
-0.5173341631889343,
-0.16840794682502747,
-0.4407675862312317,
-0.5880708694458008,
-0.6774954199790955,
-0.40895959734916687,
-0.3095531165599823,
-0.27539920806884766,
0.7361956834793091,
0.8266924619674683,
-0.6628799438476562,
-0.23955276608467102,
0.0992313027381897,
0.19160999357700348,
-0.6608007550239563,
-0.13724088668823242,
-0.1264612078666687,
0.2832792401313782,
-0.7705725431442261,
0.8127492070198059,
0.4392447769641876,
0.00848245806992054,
0.0708717405796051,
-0.22472691535949707,
-0.06386152654886246,
0.0910332202911377,
0.47420504689216614,
0.7355996966362,
-0.3889422118663788,
-0.407347708940506,
-0.2727659046649933,
0.1251213699579239,
0.08085169643163681,
0.561107873916626,
-0.6393347382545471,
0.5327238440513611,
0.1513262838125229,
0.4519003927707672,
0.7944777011871338,
-0.012844054959714413,
0.6929904222488403,
-0.6021889448165894,
0.13277797400951385,
0.279120534658432,
0.6194630861282349,
0.33249813318252563,
-0.2772626578807831,
0.3992662727832794,
0.35600408911705017,
-0.2693054676055908,
-0.9159519672393799,
0.5911062359809875,
-1.517409086227417,
0.03428618237376213,
0.706253707408905,
0.08750498294830322,
-0.2405170500278473,
-0.5355218052864075,
-0.5087699294090271,
0.06432141363620758,
-0.5203328132629395,
0.4948115646839142,
0.4734174907207489,
-0.3506986200809479,
-0.7400323152542114,
-0.49110615253448486,
0.492005318403244,
0.17015142738819122,
-0.5251182317733765,
-0.025130081921815872,
0.7228277921676636,
0.27934035658836365,
0.010705806314945221,
1.1439779996871948,
-0.011153358966112137,
0.6178836822509766,
-0.0734386220574379,
-0.24263620376586914,
-0.32468950748443604,
-0.49108198285102844,
-0.6966963410377502,
-0.10350266098976135,
-0.011709798127412796,
-0.3301999270915985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15638v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15638v3
|
Differentially Private Next-Token Prediction of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-22T22:27:44 | 2024-04-26T20:24:11 |
James Flemings, Meisam Razaviyayn, Murali Annavaram
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Ensuring the privacy of Large Language Models (LLMs) is becoming increasingly
important. The most widely adopted technique to accomplish this is DP-SGD,
which trains a model to guarantee Differential Privacy (DP). However, DP-SGD
overestimates an adversary's capabilities in having white box access to the
model and, as a result, causes longer training times and larger memory usage
than SGD. On the other hand, commercial LLM deployments are predominantly
cloud-based; hence, adversarial access to LLMs is black-box. Motivated by these
observations, we present Private Mixing of Ensemble Distributions (PMixED): a
private prediction protocol for next-token prediction that utilizes the
inherent stochasticity of next-token sampling and a public model to achieve
Differential Privacy. We formalize this by introducing RD-mollifers which
project each of the model's output distribution from an ensemble of fine-tuned
LLMs onto a set around a public LLM's output distribution, then average the
projected distributions and sample from it. Unlike DP-SGD which needs to
consider the model architecture during training, PMixED is model agnostic,
which makes PMixED a very appealing solution for current deployments. Our
results show that PMixED achieves a stronger privacy guarantee than
sample-level privacy and outperforms DP-SGD for privacy $\epsilon = 8$ on
large-scale datasets. Thus, PMixED offers a practical alternative to DP
training methods for achieving strong generative utility without compromising
privacy.
|
[
-0.16135536134243011,
-0.16153484582901,
0.43548256158828735,
0.375559538602829,
-0.45323288440704346,
0.6157146096229553,
-0.07489097863435745,
-0.3872920572757721,
0.24017120897769928,
0.7203579545021057,
-0.47703906893730164,
-0.9587293267250061,
-0.6556667685508728,
-0.18811851739883423,
-0.5335241556167603,
0.8447188138961792,
0.15251785516738892,
0.006353113800287247,
-0.0617571696639061,
0.02451523393392563,
0.1443946361541748,
-1.027146339416504,
-0.46802639961242676,
-0.03210439532995224,
0.4773119390010834,
0.03135908767580986,
0.7864376306533813,
0.8486746549606323,
0.266495943069458,
0.3485284149646759,
-0.1687733381986618,
-0.011603008955717087,
-0.41171857714653015,
0.10358651727437973,
-0.07879585772752762,
-0.7599146962165833,
-0.5690057277679443,
0.11986974626779556,
0.6800557971000671,
0.5209560990333557,
-0.23332425951957703,
-0.07453715056180954,
0.009900136850774288,
0.308360755443573,
-0.9666354656219482,
0.11405900120735168,
-0.7803985476493835,
0.4988860487937927,
-0.4191838800907135,
-0.03686290979385376,
-0.44322627782821655,
-0.15943777561187744,
0.017589399591088295,
-0.2725612223148346,
0.24307386577129364,
0.15345458686351776,
0.18789178133010864,
0.04453551024198532,
-0.18408361077308655,
0.4624596834182739,
-0.6825090646743774,
0.7990346550941467,
-0.6420180797576904,
0.43804264068603516,
0.6073468923568726,
0.392954021692276,
-0.07528828084468842,
-0.6180984973907471,
-0.5051838755607605,
-0.18072907626628876,
-0.017308128997683525,
-0.02658528834581375,
-0.164925679564476,
0.1844557523727417,
-0.1447628289461136,
0.49563273787498474,
-0.28077971935272217,
0.5106194615364075,
-0.1112641990184784,
-0.380548357963562,
0.842009961605072,
0.23639537394046783,
-0.15938711166381836,
0.2361016571521759,
-0.5752809643745422,
-0.14153531193733215,
-0.9296372532844543,
-0.3392198085784912,
0.9527575969696045,
0.0656268373131752,
-0.4126698970794678,
0.46904653310775757,
-0.09208382666110992,
0.14358407258987427,
0.21218302845954895,
0.10873101651668549,
0.25446969270706177,
-0.08272819966077805,
-0.31140995025634766,
0.10751697421073914,
0.9245766401290894,
0.11171510815620422,
-0.08323723077774048,
-0.4773017168045044,
-0.3482058048248291,
0.0609428733587265,
-0.16946589946746826,
-0.709894597530365,
-0.45775818824768066,
0.534096360206604,
-0.23865358531475067,
-0.7104342579841614,
-0.15440678596496582,
-1.011106014251709,
-0.6638103723526001,
-0.11929091811180115,
0.16568893194198608,
-0.10394931584596634,
-0.4600556492805481,
-0.13918833434581757,
-0.14787258207798004,
-0.3828570246696472,
0.14134801924228668,
-1.2133983373641968,
0.6812413930892944,
1.0131263732910156,
0.9687770009040833,
-0.4565853774547577,
-0.38162869215011597,
-0.717027485370636,
0.3824938237667084,
-0.4673643708229065,
0.3847981095314026,
-0.7308012247085571,
-0.598580539226532,
0.07939267158508301,
0.06109042838215828,
0.13643646240234375,
-0.5159878134727478,
0.11233976483345032,
-0.5552821159362793,
0.021094223484396935,
0.14741651713848114,
-0.38636383414268494,
0.19059957563877106,
0.02762414701282978,
-0.3048696517944336,
0.4057706892490387,
0.015347626991569996,
-0.9016651511192322,
0.31788888573646545,
-0.5258327722549438,
-0.23972201347351074,
0.09323723614215851,
-0.3686445653438568,
-0.6122431755065918,
0.154179647564888,
0.1289798617362976,
0.7696584463119507,
0.256423681974411,
0.12335815280675888,
-0.8978289365768433,
-0.35964134335517883,
0.3060281276702881,
-0.7161595821380615,
0.748086154460907,
0.23866339027881622,
-0.63150954246521,
0.08137329667806625,
-0.8340461254119873,
-0.06004374474287033,
-0.1467795968055725,
0.004140972159802914,
-0.34054920077323914,
0.059896789491176605,
-0.09332072734832764,
-0.08987443894147873,
0.3105541467666626,
-0.4750238358974457,
-0.12025509029626846,
-0.6029225587844849,
0.7277021408081055,
1.5575758218765259,
-0.24232487380504608,
0.8832281231880188,
-0.12691394984722137,
0.7057577967643738,
0.23729176819324493,
0.2861407399177551,
-0.021829627454280853,
-0.4499492943286896,
-0.14551235735416412,
-0.5573363900184631,
0.4860694110393524,
0.40574249625205994,
-0.24621565639972687,
0.4242410659790039,
-0.07404733449220657,
-0.5961286425590515,
-0.20305712521076202,
0.08866103738546371,
0.5679248571395874,
-0.12484348565340042,
-0.03320152685046196,
-0.19035819172859192,
-0.3122631013393402,
-0.82917320728302,
0.08537334203720093,
-0.09128358215093613,
0.06362070143222809,
0.3390788435935974,
0.43476471304893494,
-0.4061869978904724,
0.4544258713722229,
-0.37891024351119995,
-0.2066843956708908,
0.1134648248553276,
0.023755129426717758,
-0.03954975679516792,
0.7553585171699524,
0.43867483735084534,
-0.8371863961219788,
-0.5557311773300171,
0.12278538197278976,
-0.2622373104095459,
0.047088053077459335,
0.34478867053985596,
-0.4213697910308838,
0.08648835867643356,
0.16074338555335999,
-0.41998451948165894,
0.26337558031082153,
1.2977997064590454,
-0.22135430574417114,
0.39733949303627014,
-0.35321059823036194,
-0.2739139795303345,
-1.1310622692108154,
-0.29321789741516113,
-0.23824253678321838,
-0.3976565897464752,
-0.21923229098320007,
0.08506326377391815,
0.1473584920167923,
-0.2967836260795593,
-0.5984006524085999,
0.6210206151008606,
-0.4164041578769684,
-0.3704100251197815,
-0.14988568425178528,
-0.17184220254421234,
-0.2870649993419647,
0.33003172278404236,
0.1984841674566269,
0.9978344440460205,
0.9635931849479675,
-0.6387869715690613,
0.24592338502407074,
0.15001945197582245,
-0.1259775012731552,
0.20818796753883362,
-0.4019559323787689,
0.2441902458667755,
0.0927971675992012,
0.3216232657432556,
-0.8593438267707825,
-0.22621621191501617,
0.13714565336704254,
-0.355706125497818,
0.4134422838687897,
-0.23719623684883118,
-0.4908134341239929,
0.033018048852682114,
-0.40094929933547974,
0.4420659840106964,
0.7723199725151062,
-0.9007695317268372,
0.47756481170654297,
0.7027469277381897,
-0.1755664050579071,
-0.9611087441444397,
-1.0809040069580078,
0.1306416094303131,
-0.20033933222293854,
-0.6821287870407104,
0.669262707233429,
-0.23073352873325348,
-0.4418068528175354,
-0.03437761217355728,
-0.07005047798156738,
-0.21554124355316162,
0.23158353567123413,
0.5116413235664368,
0.12140622735023499,
-0.08855749666690826,
-0.34764277935028076,
0.20902419090270996,
-0.27765005826950073,
-0.04298394173383713,
-0.5832783579826355,
0.6069403886795044,
0.1854202151298523,
-0.5492514371871948,
-0.49386802315711975,
0.42677274346351624,
0.5077540874481201,
-0.23821453750133514,
1.0289247035980225,
0.4344809055328369,
-0.3645588755607605,
-0.4509756565093994,
-0.37479737401008606,
-0.27436691522598267,
-0.5279816389083862,
0.16847658157348633,
-0.013122472912073135,
-0.8122636079788208,
0.6482806205749512,
0.11048614233732224,
0.328582227230072,
0.009861353784799576,
0.6270460486412048,
0.1812710016965866,
1.3070635795593262,
0.7843684554100037,
-0.2973116934299469,
0.5450802445411682,
-0.36168888211250305,
-0.07447714358568192,
-0.692704975605011,
-0.06990519911050797,
-0.26998868584632874,
-0.3177976608276367,
-0.9723811149597168,
-0.35799163579940796,
0.21198850870132446,
-0.17212679982185364,
-0.18228840827941895,
0.23091557621955872,
-0.3141911029815674,
0.573974072933197,
0.6896330714225769,
0.10508516430854797,
0.2544267475605011,
0.16182173788547516,
-0.16598451137542725,
0.05490140989422798,
-0.2893141806125641,
-0.256840318441391,
1.3829870223999023,
0.3676462769508362,
0.7948760390281677,
0.11231826990842819,
1.3444480895996094,
0.1939718872308731,
0.3760981261730194,
-0.1714155226945877,
0.6122066974639893,
-0.4239256978034973,
-0.4959985613822937,
-0.11756165325641632,
-0.5339152216911316,
-0.7518587112426758,
0.5151139497756958,
-0.03921998664736748,
-1.0359704494476318,
0.5183280110359192,
0.2678651511669159,
-0.346433162689209,
0.4581385552883148,
-0.7425962090492249,
0.5786741375923157,
-0.08230207860469818,
-0.7038720846176147,
-0.1700005829334259,
-0.4717405438423157,
0.5525155067443848,
-0.28105244040489197,
0.21012923121452332,
-0.056090690195560455,
-0.152363583445549,
0.5201141238212585,
-0.6364116668701172,
0.9825100302696228,
-0.28749215602874756,
-0.10677632689476013,
-0.2618982195854187,
0.14639681577682495,
0.9970968961715698,
0.5716360211372375,
-0.15094509720802307,
0.4652593731880188,
-0.06932742148637772,
-0.4565861225128174,
-0.35007864236831665,
1.0773969888687134,
-1.0495140552520752,
-0.9123681783676147,
-0.5455282926559448,
-0.2443227618932724,
-0.2537715435028076,
0.04700765758752823,
0.22032120823860168,
0.38783204555511475,
0.233381450176239,
0.3519479036331177,
0.6102607250213623,
-0.287609726190567,
0.3765561580657959,
0.5319103598594666,
-0.01074619498103857,
-0.46126067638397217,
0.6299839019775391,
-0.07676944881677628,
0.3639932870864868,
0.643925130367279,
0.30441591143608093,
-0.7590726613998413,
-0.9629382491111755,
-0.3218945860862732,
0.03866703808307648,
-0.5127657651901245,
-0.16631875932216644,
-0.7330717444419861,
-0.27397671341896057,
-0.6124967932701111,
-0.1440061330795288,
-0.5489420294761658,
-0.39329713582992554,
-0.16024994850158691,
-0.4740517735481262,
0.13263344764709473,
0.22916920483112335,
-0.47876834869384766,
0.28487876057624817,
-0.5816105008125305,
0.0013590730959549546,
0.17667672038078308,
0.45989617705345154,
-0.2834516763687134,
-0.31868574023246765,
0.13208329677581787,
0.1346091628074646,
-0.2586193382740021,
-0.5913509130477905,
0.4959295094013214,
-0.0527639240026474,
0.5532411336898804,
0.42714300751686096,
0.25699713826179504,
0.5608356595039368,
-0.6384245157241821,
0.8622992634773254,
0.20234666764736176,
-0.7531448602676392,
0.11447194963693619,
-0.3509467840194702,
-0.32912677526474,
0.2667314112186432,
0.024439524859189987,
-0.191006138920784,
-0.8468146324157715,
-0.8317620158195496,
-0.7534913420677185,
0.6747506260871887,
0.3173160254955292,
0.5775353312492371,
0.08225294947624207,
0.007292862981557846,
0.3173443078994751,
0.605992317199707,
-0.7234552502632141,
-0.4091949462890625,
-0.15176023542881012,
-0.1267153024673462,
-0.5436794757843018,
-0.16397783160209656,
-0.30218613147735596,
0.0639016330242157,
0.587436318397522,
0.19111740589141846,
0.5089033842086792,
-0.2172287553548813,
0.5720344185829163,
-0.04579264298081398,
0.19769321382045746,
0.41388753056526184,
0.6108522415161133,
-0.11711998283863068,
0.412274032831192,
0.0548081174492836,
-0.4314105212688446,
0.2693023085594177,
0.3208790421485901,
-0.09078516811132431,
0.025966694578528404,
-0.10950586199760437,
0.5780600309371948,
0.014185100793838501,
-0.5991595983505249,
0.8509514927864075,
-0.027504533529281616,
-0.39366909861564636,
-0.6715658903121948,
0.24912111461162567,
0.08260226249694824,
0.47463202476501465,
0.060367416590452194,
0.32953715324401855,
0.012832878157496452,
-0.3956992030143738,
0.16374529898166656,
0.49805721640586853,
-0.23166285455226898,
-0.5394883751869202,
1.0516560077667236,
0.08234614878892899,
-0.3209632635116577,
0.13059842586517334,
-0.19264493882656097,
-0.3510812819004059,
0.48895105719566345,
0.5472820997238159,
1.0738461017608643,
-0.30818575620651245,
0.344140887260437,
-0.31656575202941895,
0.03529307246208191,
-0.26012924313545227,
-0.012355407699942589,
-0.2731567621231079,
-0.635916531085968,
-0.3226073980331421,
-0.6178278923034668,
-0.6514095664024353,
0.3760598301887512,
-0.3179614245891571,
0.17866380512714386,
-0.8653102517127991,
0.018018484115600586,
-0.19836363196372986,
-0.13237419724464417,
-0.4586472809314728,
0.009958738461136818,
0.1487961709499359,
0.6940189599990845,
-0.530866265296936,
0.8280629515647888,
0.41334959864616394,
0.129669651389122,
-0.5343341827392578,
0.05768783763051033,
-0.0326048843562603,
-1.0512399673461914,
0.5385335087776184,
-0.06270676106214523,
0.052469488233327866,
-0.09646222740411758,
-0.51883465051651,
-0.6469084620475769,
1.1431758403778076,
0.6729502081871033,
-0.994124710559845,
0.20000436902046204,
0.22130827605724335,
0.4571065604686737,
0.003937155939638615,
-0.031406257301568985,
0.06160186231136322,
0.2635020315647125,
-0.01814623363316059,
-0.521361231803894,
-0.12045980244874954,
-0.06966960430145264,
-0.04848448559641838,
0.25786635279655457,
-0.7838377952575684,
1.0598583221435547,
-0.12395636737346649,
-0.26642727851867676,
0.10684797912836075,
0.6135179400444031,
0.48724278807640076,
0.5268884897232056,
0.5415903329849243,
0.3224114179611206,
0.9239439964294434,
0.16932211816310883,
1.1424012184143066,
-0.5968102216720581,
0.08064769953489304,
0.9503304362297058,
-0.37603187561035156,
0.8656594753265381,
0.4089541733264923,
-0.36511558294296265,
0.21199966967105865,
0.6553713083267212,
0.14503763616085052,
1.0113496780395508,
0.36580464243888855,
-0.602814793586731,
-0.12669415771961212,
0.20263293385505676,
-0.6307450532913208,
-0.04020942375063896,
0.019013328477740288,
-0.6762128472328186,
0.10354945063591003,
-0.1457482874393463,
-0.0753011405467987,
0.23984593152999878,
-0.26500242948532104,
0.5360289216041565,
0.15176236629486084,
-0.27355271577835083,
0.37400245666503906,
0.3144805431365967,
0.9024056792259216,
-0.5336347818374634,
0.2964431345462799,
-0.30618077516555786,
0.5076056122779846,
-0.16848260164260864,
-0.5303676128387451,
0.15435031056404114,
-0.054720453917980194,
0.10197903215885162,
-0.2320653796195984,
0.3523787558078766,
-0.3799794912338257,
-0.4559359550476074,
0.3293737471103668,
0.21047011017799377,
0.009391183033585548,
-0.05983252450823784,
-0.5340232849121094,
-0.20042212307453156,
-0.20917944610118866,
-0.15567445755004883,
0.9641753435134888,
0.46372008323669434,
0.11008025705814362,
0.6539265513420105,
0.7665027379989624,
0.31560763716697693,
0.1944650113582611,
-0.06635315716266632,
0.883234441280365,
-0.24932321906089783,
-1.139153242111206,
-1.056914210319519,
0.12038102000951767,
-0.006361030042171478,
-0.15133723616600037,
0.7039890885353088,
0.45482686161994934,
1.032944679260254,
0.05209509655833244,
1.0607036352157593,
0.5393971800804138,
0.25702762603759766,
-0.5205231308937073,
0.6204243302345276,
-0.47224682569503784,
0.5268797278404236,
-0.16370998322963715,
-0.8005203604698181,
-0.1610606461763382,
0.453204482793808,
-0.4291602373123169,
-0.1949007660150528,
0.4237549304962158,
0.9527701139450073,
-0.2518841624259949,
0.31811437010765076,
0.45764708518981934,
0.1722179502248764,
0.41639867424964905,
0.3282190263271332,
1.0076862573623657,
0.039104193449020386,
0.502324104309082,
-0.7784751653671265,
-0.15721569955348969,
0.028193453326821327,
-0.9067894816398621,
-1.0552465915679932,
-0.3508339822292328,
-0.2831028401851654,
-0.19338975846767426,
0.3992915451526642,
0.8043346405029297,
1.0008280277252197,
-0.7989923357963562,
-0.012789911590516567,
-0.5857495069503784,
0.002933195559307933,
-0.19074054062366486,
-0.16636687517166138,
0.2549983263015747,
0.07934911549091339,
-1.0150567293167114,
0.23910152912139893,
0.2979920208454132,
0.37496593594551086,
-0.6761401891708374,
-0.07496380805969238,
0.6840088963508606,
-0.1188725009560585,
0.20219328999519348,
-0.12321548908948898,
-0.4334283769130707,
-0.14054858684539795,
-0.2220146805047989,
0.03496141359210014,
-0.10025189071893692,
0.6566259264945984,
-0.345512330532074,
0.06540405005216599,
0.3522261381149292,
0.7910574078559875,
0.5004999041557312,
-0.04164415970444679,
0.7348935008049011,
-0.8740726113319397,
0.5539053678512573,
0.41075417399406433,
0.38185447454452515,
0.09374596923589706,
-0.7037417888641357,
0.18142443895339966,
0.31354570388793945,
-0.5723440051078796,
-1.0695323944091797,
0.15199406445026398,
-0.6249955892562866,
-0.049993060529232025,
1.2224688529968262,
-0.5560789108276367,
-0.4008136987686157,
-0.01618203893303871,
-0.006186237558722496,
-0.2547287940979004,
-0.7976551055908203,
0.7923527359962463,
0.42659497261047363,
0.362495481967926,
-0.10919027775526047,
-0.21304836869239807,
0.45285165309906006,
0.29115429520606995,
-0.4484792649745941,
0.39466115832328796,
0.20859937369823456,
0.2543348968029022,
-0.041396114975214005,
0.8960985541343689,
-0.2905806005001068,
-0.040219612419605255,
0.06894361227750778,
-0.5772548913955688,
-0.3328993022441864,
-0.331400990486145,
-0.1106792762875557,
0.3475029766559601,
-0.15507209300994873,
-0.48671242594718933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15615v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15615v2
|
NaturalTurn: A Method to Segment Transcripts into Naturalistic Conversational Turns
| 2024-03-22T21:05:54 | 2024-04-01T15:18:59 |
Gus Cooney, Andrew Reece
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversation is the subject of increasing interest in the social, cognitive,
and computational sciences. And yet, as conversational datasets continue to
increase in size and complexity, researchers lack scalable methods to segment
speech-to-text transcripts into conversational turns--the basic building blocks
of social interaction. We introduce "NaturalTurn," a turn segmentation
algorithm designed to accurately capture the dynamics of naturalistic exchange.
NaturalTurn operates by distinguishing speakers' primary conversational turns
from listeners' secondary utterances, such as backchannels, brief
interjections, and other forms of parallel speech that characterize
conversation. Using data from a large conversation corpus, we show how
NaturalTurn-derived transcripts demonstrate favorable statistical and
inferential characteristics compared to transcripts derived from existing
methods. The NaturalTurn algorithm represents an improvement in
machine-generated transcript processing methods, or "turn models" that will
enable researchers to associate turn-taking dynamics with the broader outcomes
that result from social interaction, a central goal of conversation science.
|
[
-0.4360346496105194,
-1.3275072574615479,
0.5058656334877014,
0.37440380454063416,
-0.49237149953842163,
0.687896192073822,
-0.3073832392692566,
-0.6147154569625854,
0.8389331102371216,
0.644882082939148,
-1.0135358572006226,
-0.35851311683654785,
-0.1055082231760025,
0.1433172971010208,
-0.6641387343406677,
0.9856518507003784,
0.6205459237098694,
0.2035776525735855,
-0.23726877570152283,
-0.10138902813196182,
-0.2816188931465149,
-0.27968546748161316,
-0.7220830321311951,
-0.3077082633972168,
0.2732577621936798,
0.5106034874916077,
0.8184884786605835,
0.240050807595253,
0.2940226197242737,
0.3817747235298157,
-0.1675766408443451,
0.4857214093208313,
-0.7115651965141296,
0.14970001578330994,
0.029345257207751274,
-0.607483446598053,
0.20153848826885223,
0.2814424932003021,
0.6232122778892517,
0.8496431112289429,
-0.1751345694065094,
0.17714431881904602,
-0.1669125258922577,
0.7870709300041199,
0.09800610691308975,
0.005246525164693594,
-0.672407329082489,
0.08631763607263565,
-0.6327243447303772,
-0.5328767895698547,
-0.5243127942085266,
-0.978678822517395,
0.5398435592651367,
-0.32388511300086975,
0.4436648488044739,
0.2781842052936554,
0.48605412244796753,
-0.2811698615550995,
-0.2479071170091629,
-0.15165379643440247,
-0.9987947344779968,
0.7892578840255737,
-0.6297371983528137,
0.17668060958385468,
0.09536587446928024,
0.5716761350631714,
-0.5667265057563782,
-0.6374010443687439,
-0.721916675567627,
-0.14020955562591553,
0.08562930673360825,
-0.17520637810230255,
0.03521537780761719,
-0.04835832491517067,
0.061512283980846405,
0.5220189094543457,
-0.14376594126224518,
-0.18738916516304016,
-0.7650350332260132,
-0.1292700469493866,
0.9031466841697693,
0.44504886865615845,
0.6273846626281738,
-0.29099348187446594,
0.06151878833770752,
0.09766881912946701,
-0.47116515040397644,
0.2255854308605194,
0.48151665925979614,
0.6326193809509277,
-0.21929268538951874,
0.6557086706161499,
-0.38639014959335327,
0.7076767086982727,
0.41477206349372864,
-0.12521100044250488,
0.14768055081367493,
-0.4315950870513916,
-0.11496301740407944,
0.19449417293071747,
0.8092189431190491,
0.5999940633773804,
0.08521078526973724,
-0.349888414144516,
0.4339202046394348,
-0.03108956292271614,
0.3860750198364258,
-0.5569342374801636,
-0.25396305322647095,
0.13553932309150696,
-0.5379751324653625,
-0.6462001204490662,
0.05895579978823662,
-1.1741043329238892,
-0.31845131516456604,
-0.8827619552612305,
0.038746219128370285,
-0.3419773280620575,
-0.25238803029060364,
-0.12012328207492828,
-0.2772008776664734,
0.6907340288162231,
0.2701682150363922,
-0.622333824634552,
0.8164692521095276,
1.0186030864715576,
1.358428955078125,
-0.5992074012756348,
0.21808698773384094,
-0.9145869016647339,
-0.3226606249809265,
-0.34313783049583435,
0.7566003203392029,
-0.8981960415840149,
-0.7559611201286316,
0.2970152199268341,
0.18547208607196808,
0.3666760325431824,
-0.4066414535045624,
0.2613831162452698,
-0.4573822617530823,
0.4821773171424866,
-0.2607196867465973,
-0.22252316772937775,
-0.13732671737670898,
0.24323537945747375,
-0.5180838704109192,
0.9018329977989197,
-0.5138756632804871,
-0.6328036189079285,
0.26313742995262146,
-0.7533150315284729,
-0.931411623954773,
0.0014279586030170321,
-0.18042300641536713,
-0.2611587643623352,
0.3484301269054413,
-0.10436683148145676,
0.01065965835005045,
-0.49179601669311523,
0.2513667941093445,
-0.5152894854545593,
-0.012195000424981117,
0.7618139982223511,
-0.6415442228317261,
0.7335590720176697,
-0.07079138606786728,
-0.21665067970752716,
0.3196464478969574,
-0.8898857235908508,
0.009423533454537392,
-0.07613947242498398,
0.08482028543949127,
-0.2972002923488617,
0.3044157326221466,
0.17716500163078308,
-0.028247086331248283,
-0.1821446418762207,
-0.8847441077232361,
0.24929679930210114,
-0.6881985664367676,
0.7267550826072693,
0.5117117762565613,
0.28083595633506775,
0.7031732797622681,
-0.3171132504940033,
0.0033252814318984747,
-0.28145310282707214,
0.35166308283805847,
0.215379998087883,
-0.8058081865310669,
-0.6864199042320251,
-0.2807568609714508,
-0.055569808930158615,
0.25682559609413147,
-0.730190634727478,
0.02239754982292652,
-0.09229622781276703,
-0.6342854499816895,
-0.6625934839248657,
-0.2833539545536041,
0.0798848494887352,
0.3159666657447815,
0.605549156665802,
-0.39806225895881653,
-0.5725345611572266,
-0.8493089079856873,
-0.4725530743598938,
0.12147524207830429,
-0.2371491938829422,
0.13899901509284973,
-0.06499293446540833,
-0.254711776971817,
1.4053994417190552,
-0.633473813533783,
0.026088403537869453,
-0.09389456361532211,
0.9053402543067932,
0.2973785698413849,
0.3929758667945862,
0.003968629986047745,
-0.6680154800415039,
-0.4494296908378601,
-0.11776946485042572,
-0.20556510984897614,
0.013161265291273594,
-0.32164672017097473,
-0.6148349642753601,
0.2998310923576355,
0.41528084874153137,
-0.626728355884552,
0.7340801358222961,
0.03556535765528679,
-0.14654822647571564,
0.5037631988525391,
-0.06164471432566643,
-0.06339451670646667,
-0.49040845036506653,
-0.08794078975915909,
-0.250216007232666,
-0.1759931743144989,
-0.9527025818824768,
-0.7290189862251282,
-0.565477728843689,
0.00019681559933815151,
-0.22539231181144714,
0.2143210470676422,
-0.3184998035430908,
-0.26441386342048645,
-0.3601507246494293,
0.056847963482141495,
-0.20555350184440613,
0.2691778242588043,
0.5468706488609314,
0.3223600387573242,
0.17994412779808044,
-0.8250160217285156,
0.4286789000034332,
0.488076776266098,
-0.2557791471481323,
0.8903566002845764,
-0.6366295218467712,
0.6697167754173279,
0.02376338467001915,
0.18818886578083038,
-1.0051014423370361,
-0.33511096239089966,
0.12640085816383362,
-0.3656066358089447,
0.14181998372077942,
-0.20368798077106476,
0.11223707348108292,
-0.4122999608516693,
-0.3801071047782898,
0.1454422026872635,
0.4249616265296936,
-0.5333558917045593,
0.7551102042198181,
0.5805655121803284,
-0.44459325075149536,
0.2698825001716614,
-0.6444937586784363,
0.29646947979927063,
-0.045881155878305435,
-0.7853458523750305,
0.6689497828483582,
-0.0679246187210083,
-0.2664296329021454,
-0.39653846621513367,
-0.1302586793899536,
-0.17887654900550842,
-0.4190719425678253,
0.28044751286506653,
0.5731173157691956,
0.09550154954195023,
-0.2596202492713928,
0.05564003437757492,
-0.11694071441888809,
0.32453790307044983,
-0.08137702941894531,
0.7280200123786926,
-0.0776909589767456,
-0.14747324585914612,
-0.46953025460243225,
0.3453725278377533,
0.8527202010154724,
-0.09569195657968521,
0.578281819820404,
0.39216598868370056,
-0.2328881025314331,
0.06566762924194336,
-0.7296830415725708,
-0.407837450504303,
-0.48663654923439026,
-0.08780895918607712,
0.027668198570609093,
-0.4708917438983917,
0.29043319821357727,
0.0932798907160759,
0.5268596410751343,
-0.019803961738944054,
0.33023005723953247,
-0.029534896835684776,
1.1083688735961914,
0.22467197477817535,
0.007200360298156738,
0.5569544434547424,
0.02108842134475708,
0.4639724791049957,
-0.6550406217575073,
-0.4980924427509308,
-0.5926188230514526,
-0.4653950333595276,
-0.7565662264823914,
-0.6802768111228943,
0.09635842591524124,
-0.7259572744369507,
-0.07822031527757645,
0.06762129068374634,
-0.5926089882850647,
0.37863922119140625,
0.887056291103363,
0.1702784150838852,
0.37822240591049194,
-0.007438704837113619,
0.08772514760494232,
-0.28197184205055237,
-0.30629199743270874,
-0.5173825025558472,
0.6882219314575195,
0.21187424659729004,
0.5086673498153687,
-0.09461405128240585,
0.834266722202301,
0.10775835067033768,
0.6316665410995483,
-0.8732894062995911,
0.6824668049812317,
0.17783962190151215,
-0.6416267156600952,
-0.7115928530693054,
-0.3851046860218048,
-0.6996108293533325,
-0.05374368652701378,
-0.44062402844429016,
-0.673057496547699,
0.09790374338626862,
-0.07854641228914261,
-0.4153829514980316,
0.13652163743972778,
-0.1850980967283249,
0.6659611463546753,
-0.4361335337162018,
-0.6510664820671082,
-0.36779695749282837,
-0.7300890684127808,
0.222605362534523,
0.3770439624786377,
0.49807265400886536,
-0.13777311146259308,
0.6808959245681763,
0.9112533926963806,
-0.6819189190864563,
1.0389620065689087,
-0.298665314912796,
0.31522417068481445,
0.7380084991455078,
0.4032020568847656,
0.481823593378067,
0.2679145336151123,
0.26595941185951233,
0.08273344486951828,
0.3359561860561371,
-0.09885052591562271,
-0.44196459650993347,
0.3686307966709137,
-0.6034857630729675,
-0.4264853000640869,
-0.321851909160614,
0.10109040886163712,
-0.3465592861175537,
-0.09996948391199112,
0.3518817722797394,
0.570121169090271,
-0.8660860657691956,
0.2831745743751526,
0.3644823431968689,
-0.18881377577781677,
0.39965882897377014,
0.5615763664245605,
-0.45740172266960144,
-0.48599275946617126,
1.063352108001709,
0.0587771050632,
0.2594952881336212,
0.10777700692415237,
0.472596138715744,
-0.23735353350639343,
-0.3754148781299591,
0.01872115023434162,
0.20784950256347656,
-0.1563413441181183,
-0.08091381937265396,
-0.44394850730895996,
-0.05590582266449928,
-0.17840443551540375,
-0.3821885585784912,
-0.6431480050086975,
-0.39571329951286316,
-0.26535770297050476,
-0.31278014183044434,
0.4871804416179657,
0.6768969893455505,
-0.24165381491184235,
0.13957522809505463,
-0.722749650478363,
0.5220038890838623,
0.6490791440010071,
0.22308136522769928,
-0.1286669373512268,
-0.48801231384277344,
0.4051298201084137,
0.4286886751651764,
-0.27743735909461975,
-0.9542405009269714,
0.7441951036453247,
0.370535671710968,
0.20215275883674622,
0.48010197281837463,
0.1286150962114334,
0.8391197323799133,
-0.7653137445449829,
0.7055779695510864,
0.6409547924995422,
-1.0755518674850464,
0.49153342843055725,
-0.11509194225072861,
0.21159018576145172,
0.8119444251060486,
0.17450813949108124,
-1.1170068979263306,
-0.24104799330234528,
-0.5641178488731384,
-0.8136990666389465,
0.7107798457145691,
0.18232621252536774,
0.2155391275882721,
-0.2760796844959259,
0.07136166840791702,
0.34927791357040405,
0.19650009274482727,
-0.5212403535842896,
0.1503734588623047,
-0.33628222346305847,
-0.1916351318359375,
0.3114840090274811,
-0.23394504189491272,
-0.3176268935203552,
-0.27630287408828735,
0.4751681685447693,
-0.2072768360376358,
0.4400208294391632,
0.2681020200252533,
0.00030537587008439004,
-0.214957132935524,
0.09909175336360931,
0.42992445826530457,
0.10079886019229889,
-0.2307724803686142,
0.18117617070674896,
0.20476731657981873,
-0.5930870175361633,
-0.05770069360733032,
-0.16971878707408905,
-0.2678260803222656,
0.17221710085868835,
0.1334887146949768,
0.5580875277519226,
0.5381313562393188,
-0.235111266374588,
0.19158437848091125,
-0.06770792603492737,
-0.10364329814910889,
-0.29093196988105774,
-0.11844822019338608,
-0.07773416489362717,
0.18993403017520905,
0.39678651094436646,
0.08887700736522675,
0.5298044085502625,
-0.8234925270080566,
0.11024363338947296,
0.45927658677101135,
-0.6205464601516724,
-0.6842108964920044,
0.13452453911304474,
0.8875113725662231,
-0.928970217704773,
0.9635589718818665,
-0.05766380950808525,
-0.5634337663650513,
0.4231850206851959,
0.32248446345329285,
1.1808339357376099,
0.06233236566185951,
0.6160759329795837,
0.33244389295578003,
0.007948328740894794,
-0.01786559447646141,
0.22345972061157227,
-0.11258815973997116,
-0.503251850605011,
-0.4274175465106964,
-0.5243076682090759,
-0.7683547735214233,
-0.18081162869930267,
-0.7396002411842346,
0.17014753818511963,
-0.5259095430374146,
-0.32066529989242554,
0.23845961689949036,
-0.20504240691661835,
-0.8210886120796204,
-0.28824740648269653,
0.37186306715011597,
0.7367124557495117,
-0.6789093613624573,
0.321480929851532,
0.25025516748428345,
-0.1777285486459732,
-0.1615547090768814,
-0.16027696430683136,
0.23936356604099274,
-0.3191567361354828,
0.5207496285438538,
0.5487370491027832,
-0.4185031056404114,
-0.47314924001693726,
-1.057204246520996,
-0.777624249458313,
0.5283118486404419,
-0.28183886408805847,
-0.6012511849403381,
-0.0018352416809648275,
0.5164904594421387,
0.5478896498680115,
-0.3707135021686554,
0.2389289289712906,
0.953725278377533,
0.4919900596141815,
0.48512718081474304,
-0.7907119989395142,
-0.09611734002828598,
0.039394620805978775,
-0.08788517862558365,
0.17029833793640137,
-0.575709342956543,
0.16092820465564728,
-0.012606116011738777,
-0.3792022168636322,
-0.13153494894504547,
1.024994134902954,
0.058153536170721054,
0.7488518357276917,
0.3949689269065857,
-0.19087442755699158,
1.0002323389053345,
-0.3507938086986542,
0.532845139503479,
0.01749955490231514,
-0.1456523835659027,
0.9429228901863098,
-0.45617344975471497,
0.786657452583313,
0.7894692420959473,
-0.4379521310329437,
0.6517645120620728,
0.3416672348976135,
0.4013071060180664,
0.7213543057441711,
0.46522849798202515,
-0.3689279556274414,
-0.2852035462856293,
0.3073555827140808,
0.11672346293926239,
0.5618361234664917,
0.5621911287307739,
0.31283313035964966,
0.34075817465782166,
0.0797087624669075,
-0.04250264912843704,
0.14129307866096497,
-0.14952503144741058,
0.9343742728233337,
0.13153229653835297,
-0.8960660099983215,
-0.030536973848938942,
-0.13909010589122772,
0.6640015244483948,
-0.28917962312698364,
-0.12001506239175797,
-0.25669336318969727,
-0.20105423033237457,
-0.2802230417728424,
-0.5794768929481506,
0.7221140265464783,
-0.09203227609395981,
-0.07534677535295486,
0.13120809197425842,
0.5175161361694336,
-0.46290525794029236,
-0.36542636156082153,
-0.10713013261556625,
-0.10541725158691406,
-0.047447919845581055,
0.08222802728414536,
-0.34246307611465454,
0.2136681228876114,
0.16138498485088348,
-0.12370894104242325,
-0.15417340397834778,
0.4589231014251709,
-0.02810748480260372,
0.5149825811386108,
1.017825961112976,
-0.28514906764030457,
0.15711013972759247,
-0.11586836725473404,
0.6474708318710327,
-0.8293725252151489,
-0.5108925700187683,
-0.703208863735199,
0.5441928505897522,
-0.8609254956245422,
-0.36560994386672974,
0.42677098512649536,
0.37167853116989136,
0.07992087304592133,
0.026946911588311195,
0.6383460760116577,
0.011434844695031643,
0.7833057641983032,
-0.5112938284873962,
0.06994929164648056,
0.21960905194282532,
-0.03302135691046715,
-0.27607035636901855,
-0.8700088262557983,
-0.12215482443571091,
0.997545599937439,
-0.8700397610664368,
-0.4039081931114197,
0.3795647919178009,
0.4766426384449005,
0.055052049458026886,
0.7599835991859436,
-0.22700975835323334,
0.16648173332214355,
0.6900272369384766,
-0.025787953287363052,
0.8608998656272888,
0.14860372245311737,
0.3857099413871765,
-0.21068190038204193,
-0.44416001439094543,
-0.6416563391685486,
-0.9780750274658203,
-1.0592267513275146,
-0.35080692172050476,
-0.6373667120933533,
-0.2697121202945709,
-0.15775950253009796,
1.3197654485702515,
0.7640122771263123,
-0.8513832092285156,
-0.3919399082660675,
-0.49088576436042786,
-0.04942548647522926,
-0.1402807980775833,
-0.2978178560733795,
-0.064180888235569,
-0.5121828317642212,
-0.6551463007926941,
0.7088517546653748,
0.5379551649093628,
-0.023132655769586563,
-0.269431471824646,
0.058687470853328705,
-0.18196073174476624,
0.5846768617630005,
0.673012375831604,
0.8037827610969543,
-0.3374994695186615,
-0.27747711539268494,
0.2669771611690521,
0.22769694030284882,
0.10601554065942764,
0.8444379568099976,
-0.5035662055015564,
0.6474080681800842,
0.5111137628555298,
0.48101094365119934,
1.0937455892562866,
-0.21157844364643097,
1.0417855978012085,
-0.5476446151733398,
0.16214729845523834,
0.31420522928237915,
-0.18164877593517303,
0.4345872104167938,
-0.08693884313106537,
0.43393760919570923,
0.2012152224779129,
-0.4589785635471344,
-0.9187163710594177,
0.15778625011444092,
-0.988078236579895,
0.05282243713736534,
0.9586026072502136,
0.6421705484390259,
-0.5237091779708862,
-0.2911977767944336,
-0.7751267552375793,
0.24485519528388977,
-0.37742966413497925,
0.9531534910202026,
0.5762577056884766,
-0.21913300454616547,
0.030217038467526436,
-0.32790735363960266,
0.7802537679672241,
0.18841663002967834,
-0.8020458221435547,
0.0952625647187233,
0.6075672507286072,
0.09192178398370743,
0.5113285183906555,
0.3721497654914856,
-0.2702524960041046,
-0.005734610836952925,
-0.38754770159721375,
-0.16974222660064697,
0.36199045181274414,
-0.21644198894500732,
0.09077424556016922,
-0.04109792038798332,
-0.09878494590520859,
-0.17299684882164001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15388v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15388v5
|
LLaVA-PruMerge: Adaptive Token Reduction for Efficient Large Multimodal Models
| 2024-03-22T17:59:52 | 2024-05-22T20:50:37 |
Yuzhang Shang, Mu Cai, Bingxin Xu, Yong Jae Lee, Yan Yan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have shown significant visual reasoning
capabilities by connecting a visual encoder and a large language model. LMMs
typically take in a fixed and large amount of visual tokens, such as the
penultimate layer features in the CLIP visual encoder, as the prefix content.
Recent LMMs incorporate more complex visual inputs, such as high-resolution
images and videos, which further increases the number of visual tokens
significantly. However, due to the inherent design of the Transformer
architecture, the computational costs of these models tend to increase
quadratically with the number of input tokens. To tackle this problem, we
explore a token reduction mechanism that identifies significant spatial
redundancy among visual tokens. In response, we propose PruMerge, a novel
adaptive visual token reduction strategy that significantly reduces the number
of visual tokens without compromising the performance of LMMs. Specifically, to
metric the importance of each token, we exploit the sparsity observed in the
visual encoder, characterized by the sparse distribution of attention scores
between the class token and visual tokens. This sparsity enables us to
dynamically select the most crucial visual tokens to retain. Subsequently, we
cluster the selected (unpruned) tokens based on their key similarity and merge
them with the unpruned tokens, effectively supplementing and enhancing their
informational content. Empirically, when applied to LLaVA-1.5, our approach can
compress the visual tokens by 14 times on average, and achieve comparable
performance across diverse visual question-answering and reasoning tasks. Code
and checkpoints are at https://llava-prumerge.github.io/.
|
[
-0.5515393614768982,
-0.6157634854316711,
0.2845078110694885,
0.37014761567115784,
-0.4873700737953186,
0.03204504773020744,
-0.1976834237575531,
-0.10879652202129364,
0.34844064712524414,
0.37609174847602844,
-0.5018956661224365,
-0.2527700364589691,
-0.47591665387153625,
0.15080352127552032,
-0.28378936648368835,
0.3893795609474182,
-0.15374577045440674,
-0.0402282178401947,
-0.45326700806617737,
-0.4606820344924927,
-0.8906254768371582,
-0.3509560823440552,
-0.35425814986228943,
0.25646525621414185,
0.7830975651741028,
0.43791380524635315,
0.3129558265209198,
0.3423859775066376,
0.8178438544273376,
0.4334954023361206,
-0.09843357652425766,
0.6925240755081177,
-0.6276862025260925,
0.20348024368286133,
-0.17326180636882782,
-0.42132022976875305,
-0.3327361047267914,
-0.5185341238975525,
0.8595975041389465,
0.3585202097892761,
-0.05357937142252922,
0.32193639874458313,
-0.0945490226149559,
0.5604572892189026,
-0.7853696942329407,
0.26379355788230896,
-0.6731365323066711,
-0.06760020554065704,
-0.25412505865097046,
-0.4312804043292999,
-0.4653181731700897,
-0.04387367516756058,
-0.26874908804893494,
-0.7225021719932556,
0.2527114748954773,
0.2088662087917328,
0.689877986907959,
0.5116803646087646,
-0.24315986037254333,
0.45262494683265686,
-0.44769319891929626,
0.7486798763275146,
-0.39578723907470703,
0.3656362295150757,
0.11128296703100204,
0.2658235430717468,
-0.2806563377380371,
-0.9290690422058105,
-0.6831693053245544,
-0.026156404986977577,
-0.2407768815755844,
0.11291169375181198,
-0.5918906331062317,
0.15137426555156708,
0.26700636744499207,
0.026968473568558693,
-0.6617862582206726,
-0.0858767032623291,
-0.6093591451644897,
-0.40738406777381897,
0.1819264441728592,
0.23754601180553436,
0.1764037013053894,
-0.17108428478240967,
-0.4886607229709625,
-0.0037413642276078463,
-0.35572922229766846,
0.0021503407042473555,
-0.15975338220596313,
-0.006592385936528444,
-0.04839133843779564,
0.6267390847206116,
-0.030749771744012833,
0.696652889251709,
0.020905816927552223,
-0.27289295196533203,
0.3688974678516388,
-0.5171347260475159,
-0.259958952665329,
-0.24737253785133362,
0.4939734637737274,
0.6196202039718628,
0.2790607213973999,
0.1265970915555954,
-0.07736209779977798,
0.2845728397369385,
0.4390885829925537,
-0.7493451833724976,
-0.1562255471944809,
0.09723827242851257,
-0.468555212020874,
-0.14872132241725922,
-0.26872751116752625,
-0.8080898523330688,
-0.5334459543228149,
-0.2458920180797577,
0.34637153148651123,
-0.29132112860679626,
-0.15718737244606018,
-0.07528387755155563,
-0.28444668650627136,
0.13036255538463593,
0.7104886770248413,
-0.5673906207084656,
0.1519908457994461,
0.5562480092048645,
1.1845334768295288,
-0.3412514925003052,
-0.5674648284912109,
-0.8443788290023804,
0.02780759520828724,
-0.20309928059577942,
0.9079057574272156,
-0.5077640414237976,
-0.21259504556655884,
-0.23746539652347565,
0.09195965528488159,
-0.2124137282371521,
-0.6449442505836487,
0.28589922189712524,
-0.5007380843162537,
-0.38888680934906006,
-0.20535388588905334,
-0.23421195149421692,
-0.3173847496509552,
0.45152661204338074,
-0.8360645174980164,
0.8891046047210693,
-0.018155474215745926,
-0.8651935458183289,
0.448382705450058,
-0.6459198594093323,
-0.2236231118440628,
0.13911405205726624,
0.005644793156534433,
-0.42833197116851807,
0.4790085554122925,
0.6230059266090393,
0.24346841871738434,
-0.246740460395813,
0.3158980906009674,
-0.37491926550865173,
-0.6369583606719971,
0.31453147530555725,
-0.49048149585723877,
0.2652643620967865,
0.17768594622612,
-0.0982787236571312,
0.6920023560523987,
-0.7150384187698364,
-0.2462081015110016,
0.12305019795894623,
-0.25333401560783386,
-0.1513928323984146,
-0.09751315414905548,
0.17886021733283997,
-0.07192398607730865,
0.09450265765190125,
-0.2892756760120392,
0.3148902654647827,
-0.23232965171337128,
0.6869251132011414,
1.0201070308685303,
0.00013493209553416818,
0.583300769329071,
-0.3019900619983673,
0.4465130567550659,
0.22215226292610168,
0.3222467005252838,
-0.44669798016548157,
-0.47805893421173096,
-0.9028356671333313,
-0.9501156806945801,
0.13908058404922485,
0.34028393030166626,
-0.8781353235244751,
-0.03325045481324196,
-0.5928358435630798,
-0.21083569526672363,
-0.3759698271751404,
0.14325283467769623,
0.04761738330125809,
0.3607354462146759,
0.37591487169265747,
-0.48412075638771057,
-0.6402270793914795,
-0.9641745090484619,
-0.1409604400396347,
-0.24294023215770721,
0.14205998182296753,
0.1841307431459427,
0.6698026061058044,
-0.19517074525356293,
1.0761544704437256,
-0.3922865688800812,
-0.2773043215274811,
-0.16262057423591614,
-0.06022952124476433,
0.07243192195892334,
0.42154911160469055,
0.594232976436615,
-0.931846022605896,
-0.048574648797512054,
-0.011326288804411888,
-0.5172097086906433,
-0.2447534203529358,
-0.3237161934375763,
-0.1752861589193344,
-0.09679338335990906,
0.550625205039978,
-0.8775414824485779,
0.8075838685035706,
0.45169952511787415,
-0.3672601878643036,
0.6107664108276367,
-0.26412394642829895,
0.14174440503120422,
-0.7066868543624878,
0.11377566307783127,
-0.1475716531276703,
-0.3982059061527252,
-0.5964295864105225,
0.15327410399913788,
0.2458692342042923,
-0.29806292057037354,
-0.5923430323600769,
0.8916009664535522,
-0.3706927001476288,
-0.25312986969947815,
-0.09980437904596329,
0.04108690097928047,
0.2983228266239166,
0.8475462198257446,
-0.2530766427516937,
0.9116973280906677,
0.38234496116638184,
-0.5284157395362854,
0.5563469529151917,
0.31821689009666443,
-0.3395436704158783,
0.5191928744316101,
-0.5523719191551208,
-0.14958463609218597,
-0.39388036727905273,
0.31141579151153564,
-1.3023104667663574,
-0.1610794961452484,
0.3411419093608856,
-0.34839555621147156,
0.11424250900745392,
-0.3424648344516754,
-0.4248345196247101,
-0.2104509472846985,
-0.34451842308044434,
0.9141217470169067,
0.25226351618766785,
-0.6441425085067749,
1.0576356649398804,
0.1835232377052307,
-0.3021395802497864,
-0.43969520926475525,
-0.6974131464958191,
0.39758649468421936,
-0.2737136781215668,
-0.7891721129417419,
0.4681316018104553,
-0.10489480942487717,
-0.16429731249809265,
0.008100167848169804,
-0.03484790027141571,
0.059359110891819,
0.09071565419435501,
0.33787283301353455,
0.27280882000923157,
-0.08139774203300476,
0.3934049606323242,
-0.2470897138118744,
-0.21968333423137665,
-0.31313586235046387,
-0.336604505777359,
0.5717969536781311,
-0.09581516683101654,
-0.592100203037262,
-0.47827059030532837,
0.3001900315284729,
1.183397650718689,
-0.591192364692688,
0.7247495055198669,
0.8958563804626465,
-0.20712563395500183,
0.04180440679192543,
-0.8185994029045105,
0.04248287156224251,
-0.487521767616272,
0.7332711815834045,
-0.31994518637657166,
-0.8478670716285706,
0.5917777419090271,
-0.08167213201522827,
0.22307699918746948,
0.0767204612493515,
0.7473726868629456,
0.19150887429714203,
0.7749764919281006,
0.4806271493434906,
-0.00531366840004921,
0.8757423758506775,
-0.1457986831665039,
0.2925282120704651,
-0.6872297525405884,
-0.26717862486839294,
-0.041951242834329605,
-0.6146359443664551,
-0.3470974564552307,
-1.1237430572509766,
0.37647587060928345,
-0.07434331625699997,
-0.3036710023880005,
-0.1256863921880722,
-0.40533241629600525,
0.4545997679233551,
0.5195202231407166,
0.08495321869850159,
0.07557661086320877,
0.3723151385784149,
-0.15012480318546295,
-0.10946208983659744,
-0.8819660544395447,
0.11014921963214874,
0.6460240483283997,
0.3259626030921936,
0.6813968420028687,
0.2263665348291397,
0.4618930518627167,
0.4043729901313782,
0.20833490788936615,
-0.8609911203384399,
0.7610312700271606,
-0.00034128210972994566,
0.0035219090059399605,
-0.17716844379901886,
-0.6831912994384766,
-0.7979432940483093,
0.6940792202949524,
-0.27658602595329285,
-0.5251109004020691,
0.4290004074573517,
0.14969469606876373,
-0.15203043818473816,
0.4391130805015564,
-0.8334302306175232,
0.7827427387237549,
-0.31788671016693115,
-0.7260304093360901,
-0.37106969952583313,
-0.21732255816459656,
0.25977063179016113,
-0.043676406145095825,
0.36694273352622986,
-0.039911556988954544,
-0.24327707290649414,
0.7014487385749817,
-0.37240058183670044,
0.9685947895050049,
-0.39173170924186707,
0.24227823317050934,
0.25070899724960327,
0.26716864109039307,
0.6637493968009949,
-0.06547541916370392,
0.29443129897117615,
0.1573832929134369,
-0.33455559611320496,
-0.6289311647415161,
-0.7028573751449585,
0.5405427813529968,
-0.5972064733505249,
-0.5690149068832397,
-0.12420529872179031,
-0.6265331506729126,
0.02621200494468212,
0.24092380702495575,
-0.13122530281543732,
0.5863530039787292,
0.07446232438087463,
0.18203675746917725,
0.3151599168777466,
-0.45032423734664917,
0.409344345331192,
0.04148140177130699,
-0.26278427243232727,
-0.8638646006584167,
0.8917558789253235,
0.015866952016949654,
0.061430711299180984,
0.3336740732192993,
0.08096347004175186,
-0.26419898867607117,
-0.7208656668663025,
-0.2934175431728363,
0.4041917026042938,
-0.9260086417198181,
-0.4066917300224304,
-0.49406424164772034,
0.20547965168952942,
-0.24313022196292877,
-0.26658347249031067,
-0.24165508151054382,
-0.47122302651405334,
-0.2523515224456787,
-0.1120200827717781,
0.49577629566192627,
0.23735935986042023,
0.15876488387584686,
0.3248172998428345,
-0.8521037697792053,
0.5094494819641113,
0.4002128541469574,
0.4028131663799286,
0.128224715590477,
-0.7775769829750061,
-0.07587984204292297,
-0.24112069606781006,
0.12323493510484695,
-0.5141317844390869,
0.5697746872901917,
0.19693514704704285,
0.5573751926422119,
0.2113678902387619,
-0.0052758133970201015,
1.4076876640319824,
-0.4357021749019623,
0.6483383178710938,
0.6030709147453308,
-0.8232547640800476,
0.29499661922454834,
0.005801162216812372,
0.466459184885025,
0.27289319038391113,
-0.33855971693992615,
-0.4257277250289917,
-0.06725610047578812,
-0.22497139871120453,
-1.1336508989334106,
0.5193942785263062,
0.3118680417537689,
-0.0539340041577816,
-0.07980164140462875,
0.14827461540699005,
-0.25398245453834534,
0.04425237327814102,
-0.6010502576828003,
0.06952674686908722,
-0.30725041031837463,
-0.28082889318466187,
0.13365887105464935,
-0.5161857008934021,
-0.21465513110160828,
-0.31954115629196167,
0.204065203666687,
-0.28558969497680664,
0.35841649770736694,
0.26856786012649536,
-0.5489028096199036,
0.19176717102527618,
0.1318625509738922,
0.9088482856750488,
0.6641363501548767,
0.13022588193416595,
0.23360584676265717,
0.4253890812397003,
-0.5581659078598022,
0.10893633961677551,
-0.2768537998199463,
0.11852668225765228,
0.00035743816988542676,
0.5146681070327759,
1.048299789428711,
0.5743358731269836,
-0.9862132668495178,
0.677226185798645,
-0.37256720662117004,
-0.3345096707344055,
-0.17135564982891083,
-0.28389015793800354,
-0.1575409471988678,
0.4549425542354584,
0.33899152278900146,
0.5344469547271729,
-0.24551522731781006,
-0.15509682893753052,
0.29322659969329834,
0.21557940542697906,
-0.24639974534511566,
-0.20031172037124634,
0.43249428272247314,
0.47590237855911255,
-0.1545179933309555,
0.6323440074920654,
0.12490509450435638,
-0.5790651440620422,
0.5408491492271423,
0.4607643485069275,
0.746130108833313,
0.19726812839508057,
0.07375986874103546,
0.4515824615955353,
0.2929151654243469,
-0.03489210829138756,
-0.08438054472208023,
-0.2098425030708313,
-0.6758686900138855,
-0.7045122981071472,
-0.8002709746360779,
0.014161752536892891,
-0.17988581955432892,
-0.31071415543556213,
0.17447347939014435,
-0.5873767733573914,
-0.3265363574028015,
-0.16621671617031097,
-0.40178269147872925,
-0.609492301940918,
-0.22164089977741241,
0.2495538294315338,
0.8859341740608215,
-0.515329897403717,
0.443438857793808,
0.6686949729919434,
-0.15427133440971375,
-0.38099464774131775,
-0.29537472128868103,
-0.02476957067847252,
-0.9130816459655762,
0.7863196730613708,
0.13039259612560272,
-0.15878638625144958,
-0.08615512400865555,
-0.18945632874965668,
-0.8984755873680115,
1.0740238428115845,
0.3866320252418518,
-0.7905358076095581,
0.05304930359125137,
-0.062004756182432175,
0.1435621678829193,
-0.14611276984214783,
0.15100017189979553,
0.30934086441993713,
0.6745999455451965,
0.2967623770236969,
-0.9109161496162415,
0.024898841977119446,
-0.47382405400276184,
0.18714407086372375,
0.39944177865982056,
-0.68846595287323,
0.8085318803787231,
-0.36812108755111694,
-0.3312067985534668,
0.10057228058576584,
0.5269449949264526,
0.3257102966308594,
0.1865663081407547,
0.6257954239845276,
0.48815006017684937,
0.8492280840873718,
-0.043572548776865005,
0.7008366584777832,
-0.12338106334209442,
0.23508045077323914,
0.632697343826294,
-0.17121073603630066,
0.675163984298706,
0.9088260531425476,
-0.1253816783428192,
0.13356465101242065,
0.3619746267795563,
-0.17776425182819366,
0.4506283700466156,
0.15074196457862854,
-0.10946214199066162,
-0.4057343304157257,
-0.08386505395174026,
-0.0947805866599083,
0.5809326767921448,
0.2977811396121979,
-0.12616288661956787,
-0.14323274791240692,
0.2523290812969208,
-0.42293527722358704,
-0.2526845335960388,
-0.6301887631416321,
0.7536154389381409,
-0.11933154612779617,
-0.5336520075798035,
0.8510596752166748,
-0.03581855446100235,
0.6485855579376221,
-0.5179572701454163,
-0.12622439861297607,
-0.4169479012489319,
0.3564031422138214,
-0.2028205692768097,
-0.39422738552093506,
0.1463301032781601,
0.11046042293310165,
-0.12974710762500763,
-0.21939997375011444,
0.9465678334236145,
-0.2723633646965027,
-0.6527760028839111,
0.19554242491722107,
0.3551409840583801,
-0.30883917212486267,
-0.12343927472829819,
-0.5694213509559631,
0.42540454864501953,
0.06137966737151146,
-0.11083739995956421,
0.4528083801269531,
0.47166386246681213,
-0.24799762666225433,
0.8825383186340332,
0.9644604921340942,
0.1739753782749176,
0.18389064073562622,
0.3307033181190491,
1.0426980257034302,
-0.774312436580658,
-0.7267740964889526,
-0.845977783203125,
0.6314245462417603,
-0.09550563246011734,
-0.07443509250879288,
0.5280213952064514,
0.3442957103252411,
0.5582661032676697,
-0.08496565371751785,
0.5184796452522278,
0.23467759788036346,
-0.09033667296171188,
-0.5215473771095276,
0.3327803611755371,
-0.7723467350006104,
0.45813095569610596,
-0.11214549839496613,
-0.7926609516143799,
-0.7060758471488953,
0.6421975493431091,
-0.18165594339370728,
-0.3188594579696655,
0.507012665271759,
1.1139599084854126,
-0.10360962897539139,
-0.44740015268325806,
0.519003689289093,
0.16348902881145477,
0.44716939330101013,
0.32577934861183167,
1.0146528482437134,
-0.20230281352996826,
0.9002992510795593,
0.13527730107307434,
-0.15756000578403473,
-0.5647431015968323,
-0.6419073343276978,
-0.7533113956451416,
-0.3930242359638214,
-0.13918671011924744,
0.0033785514533519745,
-0.04042249172925949,
0.6979703903198242,
0.6337864398956299,
-0.5731103420257568,
-0.010158810764551163,
-0.061886049807071686,
0.25594857335090637,
-0.3545474112033844,
-0.2145349681377411,
0.35346895456314087,
-0.22907713055610657,
-0.35552531480789185,
0.14592024683952332,
0.6933333873748779,
-0.1699220836162567,
-0.033223509788513184,
-0.04083983227610588,
-0.06717352569103241,
0.02931707724928856,
0.7772600650787354,
0.05108553543686867,
-0.8483150005340576,
-0.3156529366970062,
0.0007884579245001078,
0.25263747572898865,
0.24743832647800446,
1.1510199308395386,
-0.9112552404403687,
0.5698277354240417,
0.6821703314781189,
0.6694043874740601,
0.5849835872650146,
0.06855469197034836,
0.26425236463546753,
-0.7783259749412537,
0.6379945278167725,
0.18237239122390747,
0.7384446859359741,
0.2889240086078644,
0.025666629895567894,
0.26140156388282776,
0.4865751266479492,
-0.2707653343677521,
-1.0146021842956543,
0.2722046375274658,
-1.1782646179199219,
-0.4324052035808563,
0.882135272026062,
-0.0404171422123909,
-0.6130053400993347,
-0.13559560477733612,
-0.5573086738586426,
-0.17416681349277496,
-0.4086751341819763,
0.58481764793396,
0.3460800051689148,
0.12639422714710236,
-0.6807154417037964,
-0.2689386308193207,
0.07129532098770142,
0.4781271815299988,
-0.4329752027988434,
0.4813522696495056,
0.6255394816398621,
0.18221653997898102,
0.21271999180316925,
0.6248959898948669,
-0.084096759557724,
0.5557404160499573,
0.32434889674186707,
-0.08618839830160141,
-0.4468528628349304,
-0.43621957302093506,
-0.20551960170269012,
0.3956718146800995,
0.08156510442495346,
-0.27675867080688477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15371v1
|
Can large language models explore in-context?
| 2024-03-22T17:50:43 | 2024-03-22T17:50:43 |
Akshay Krishnamurthy, Keegan Harris, Dylan J. Foster, Cyril Zhang, Aleksandrs Slivkins
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We investigate the extent to which contemporary Large Language Models (LLMs)
can engage in exploration, a core capability in reinforcement learning and
decision making. We focus on native performance of existing LLMs, without
training interventions. We deploy LLMs as agents in simple multi-armed bandit
environments, specifying the environment description and interaction history
entirely in-context, i.e., within the LLM prompt. We experiment with GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Llama2, using a variety of prompt designs, and find that the models
do not robustly engage in exploration without substantial interventions: i)
Across all of our experiments, only one configuration resulted in satisfactory
exploratory behavior: GPT-4 with chain-of-thought reasoning and an externally
summarized interaction history, presented as sufficient statistics; ii) All
other configurations did not result in robust exploratory behavior, including
those with chain-of-thought reasoning but unsummarized history. Although these
findings can be interpreted positively, they suggest that external
summarization -- which may not be possible in more complex settings -- is
important for obtaining desirable behavior from LLM agents. We conclude that
non-trivial algorithmic interventions, such as fine-tuning or dataset curation,
may be required to empower LLM-based decision making agents in complex
settings.
|
[
-0.43288883566856384,
-1.068175196647644,
1.0943119525909424,
0.04497759789228439,
-0.03533646836876869,
0.091095931828022,
-0.6476632952690125,
-0.4027916193008423,
0.1797885149717331,
0.38906484842300415,
-0.5936328768730164,
-0.3721581995487213,
-0.5212671160697937,
-0.06339827179908752,
-0.18518751859664917,
1.031895637512207,
-0.24642637372016907,
-0.3643617331981659,
-0.10490763932466507,
-0.09980438649654388,
-0.7581325173377991,
-0.6082773208618164,
-0.6918960213661194,
-0.32696712017059326,
0.4853562116622925,
0.21765203773975372,
0.6094494462013245,
0.20983296632766724,
0.16012068092823029,
0.3364346921443939,
-0.3663322627544403,
0.366543173789978,
-0.5976442694664001,
0.3075683116912842,
-0.4096067249774933,
-0.4257613718509674,
-0.2229508012533188,
0.046651192009449005,
0.7939822673797607,
0.6420289278030396,
-0.04873816296458244,
-0.28365808725357056,
0.15042178332805634,
0.3203592896461487,
-0.412876695394516,
0.34341710805892944,
-0.45853132009506226,
-0.10455313324928284,
0.14255717396736145,
-0.20445185899734497,
-0.2983206510543823,
-0.23769500851631165,
0.540093183517456,
-0.5336801409721375,
-0.23559202253818512,
0.03333094343543053,
0.5227919220924377,
0.1477617472410202,
-0.7796270847320557,
-0.5533198118209839,
-0.8586386442184448,
0.7453353404998779,
-0.610297679901123,
-0.09059496223926544,
0.33304986357688904,
0.3108765184879303,
-0.3959697186946869,
-0.6539850234985352,
-0.34169846773147583,
-0.27196604013442993,
-0.13597244024276733,
-0.029167499393224716,
-0.20029877126216888,
0.219704732298851,
0.5314383506774902,
0.19870120286941528,
-0.3516499698162079,
0.28899234533309937,
-0.36073192954063416,
-0.1828458607196808,
0.5625019669532776,
0.367303729057312,
0.18401049077510834,
0.15343327820301056,
-0.3028126060962677,
-0.14234517514705658,
-0.9963328242301941,
0.6909193396568298,
0.1543382853269577,
0.38305026292800903,
-0.2013464868068695,
0.6258198618888855,
-0.143238365650177,
0.589011013507843,
-0.15723314881324768,
-0.0003714263439178467,
-0.07691505551338196,
-0.4002765417098999,
-0.21642965078353882,
-0.012210177257657051,
0.6515184044837952,
0.1407691091299057,
0.14412085711956024,
-0.08155127614736557,
-0.5661522150039673,
-0.10129821300506592,
0.2108127772808075,
-0.557854950428009,
-0.10146985948085785,
0.23756329715251923,
-0.053591612726449966,
-0.16989445686340332,
-0.17274914681911469,
-0.4767017364501953,
-0.4060850143432617,
-0.2728629410266876,
0.733826220035553,
-0.2513314187526703,
-0.26140207052230835,
-0.018303178250789642,
-0.35644960403442383,
0.37611764669418335,
0.41370031237602234,
-0.917847752571106,
0.21818023920059204,
0.6914972066879272,
0.849006175994873,
-0.23632165789604187,
-0.40941131114959717,
-0.5216519236564636,
0.1650323122739792,
-0.5316311717033386,
0.7534843683242798,
-0.8229097723960876,
-0.7631121277809143,
0.2682928740978241,
0.12151738256216049,
-0.10780880600214005,
-0.2865794599056244,
0.5095174908638,
-0.5000563859939575,
0.11054602265357971,
-0.6140120625495911,
-0.4587751626968384,
-0.40048515796661377,
0.5298430323600769,
-0.5922886729240417,
0.7959363460540771,
0.11976366490125656,
-0.5244207382202148,
0.4203879237174988,
-0.873785674571991,
-0.49195438623428345,
-0.17046251893043518,
-0.4142747223377228,
0.06651755422353745,
0.2142154574394226,
0.32762792706489563,
0.3679123818874359,
-0.07590187340974808,
0.44691407680511475,
-0.24099498987197876,
-0.7208433747291565,
0.3229781687259674,
-0.43916571140289307,
0.5288171768188477,
-0.08477899432182312,
-0.498212069272995,
0.2833368480205536,
-0.22249719500541687,
-0.13978517055511475,
0.08483731746673584,
-0.5100976228713989,
-0.41330209374427795,
0.2367454618215561,
-0.263626366853714,
0.3076588809490204,
0.2536568343639374,
-0.3274443447589874,
0.6946591734886169,
-0.4119090735912323,
0.5532505512237549,
0.8873484134674072,
0.10883090645074844,
0.6022405028343201,
-0.36741358041763306,
0.779769778251648,
-0.2604641020298004,
-0.24579374492168427,
-0.5306550860404968,
-0.39932847023010254,
-0.6705310344696045,
-0.3124085068702698,
-0.06223544850945473,
0.2506422996520996,
-0.8665819764137268,
0.009215621277689934,
-0.28294500708580017,
-0.12169548124074936,
0.037406232208013535,
-0.17258818447589874,
0.24527686834335327,
0.26776713132858276,
0.19583114981651306,
0.04564222693443298,
-0.4427770674228668,
-0.8285583853721619,
-0.16402189433574677,
0.012732310220599174,
0.037883155047893524,
0.5434929728507996,
0.5628818869590759,
-0.2399379462003708,
0.9031417369842529,
-0.2913692593574524,
0.06014810502529144,
-0.6699127554893494,
0.16398277878761292,
0.4506679177284241,
0.3217102587223053,
0.35798680782318115,
-0.6575973033905029,
-0.2417248636484146,
0.015704648569226265,
-0.9133915305137634,
0.12944187223911285,
-0.17764365673065186,
0.032900579273700714,
-0.013188671320676804,
0.5826388597488403,
-0.6781755685806274,
0.27899086475372314,
0.46259939670562744,
-0.2559119164943695,
0.3197445273399353,
-0.4404461681842804,
-0.12013861536979675,
-0.6075820326805115,
0.009300638921558857,
-0.07188088446855545,
-0.08610830456018448,
-0.7774536609649658,
0.20790375769138336,
0.07992229610681534,
-0.013492792844772339,
-0.27750885486602783,
0.7919798493385315,
-0.40804779529571533,
-0.15059472620487213,
-0.4030589461326599,
0.2628277540206909,
-0.10782567411661148,
0.6240139603614807,
0.3672349154949188,
0.7592418193817139,
0.7172368168830872,
-0.8361817598342896,
-0.004301192704588175,
0.0673108845949173,
-0.4687814712524414,
0.24480536580085754,
-0.6273614764213562,
0.09270112216472626,
-0.16370898485183716,
0.6377017498016357,
-0.911449134349823,
-0.3049478232860565,
-0.03317863866686821,
-0.05319135636091232,
0.3330649435520172,
-0.023920930922031403,
-0.3507862389087677,
-0.04947308823466301,
-0.4940608739852905,
0.3624805212020874,
0.4032801687717438,
-0.5806825160980225,
0.6704334616661072,
0.366165429353714,
-0.3442792296409607,
-0.48260101675987244,
-0.5591837167739868,
0.1147613674402237,
-0.5090247988700867,
-0.49353206157684326,
0.0374629944562912,
-0.06017884984612465,
-0.3982710540294647,
-0.314144492149353,
-0.01990308053791523,
0.2575107216835022,
0.16219764947891235,
0.19484461843967438,
0.31997328996658325,
-0.1613270491361618,
0.11449173092842102,
0.08659496903419495,
0.18940646946430206,
0.22986333072185516,
-0.1327427327632904,
0.4404263198375702,
-0.18103712797164917,
-0.2963261902332306,
0.031338825821876526,
0.3759313225746155,
0.44846269488334656,
-0.2632684111595154,
0.45095810294151306,
0.2708088159561157,
-0.29328009486198425,
-0.2740022838115692,
-0.36027416586875916,
-0.1822638064622879,
-0.4986027479171753,
0.283931702375412,
-0.2872411012649536,
-1.3958356380462646,
0.5546671748161316,
-0.19956901669502258,
0.3415716886520386,
0.29436278343200684,
0.5152122974395752,
-0.16379302740097046,
1.1052260398864746,
0.6435632705688477,
-0.03371928632259369,
0.45622360706329346,
-0.3476005494594574,
0.2080167531967163,
-1.211114764213562,
-0.11601853370666504,
-0.17421555519104004,
-0.44970518350601196,
-0.8445887565612793,
-0.1915120780467987,
0.7834808230400085,
-0.2284490317106247,
-0.330477774143219,
-0.004023068584501743,
-0.07719039916992188,
0.5213090181350708,
0.5081101059913635,
-0.09376712888479233,
0.1374533772468567,
-0.319501131772995,
-0.16635996103286743,
0.1517060101032257,
-0.6775457859039307,
-0.5003818273544312,
1.1937065124511719,
0.20866039395332336,
0.7158778309822083,
0.32525306940078735,
0.5884078145027161,
-0.013995309360325336,
0.41356968879699707,
-0.7794572710990906,
0.4009322226047516,
0.44886335730552673,
-0.6300442218780518,
-0.6050431728363037,
-0.26621901988983154,
-1.1836283206939697,
0.5075681209564209,
-0.13710805773735046,
-1.1237201690673828,
0.2049657702445984,
0.028889494016766548,
-0.5357205271720886,
0.18856112658977509,
-0.6356451511383057,
0.7841741442680359,
-0.2604803442955017,
-0.3649995028972626,
-0.1375827193260193,
-0.510826587677002,
0.7269023656845093,
-0.1335199922323227,
0.4201708137989044,
0.19298456609249115,
-0.165856271982193,
0.4438610076904297,
0.030318737030029297,
0.8852903246879578,
-0.260358601808548,
-0.3731609582901001,
0.45162540674209595,
0.31440141797065735,
1.0133442878723145,
0.05723267048597336,
0.2089865505695343,
-0.27155801653862,
-0.10359082370996475,
-0.24286215007305145,
-0.6978861689567566,
0.8622161746025085,
-0.48493677377700806,
-0.881576418876648,
-0.47544729709625244,
-0.5685113668441772,
-0.4472486674785614,
-0.011238288134336472,
0.02869010716676712,
0.5433413982391357,
-0.3114585280418396,
0.29912513494491577,
0.8580124378204346,
-0.2583111524581909,
0.7140216827392578,
0.5448280572891235,
-0.2390124499797821,
0.08509952574968338,
0.7906390428543091,
0.11059880256652832,
0.20717328786849976,
0.34601765871047974,
0.3950574994087219,
-0.4774326682090759,
-0.6513316035270691,
-0.275503933429718,
0.01573745347559452,
-0.7205213904380798,
0.22847503423690796,
-0.49942445755004883,
0.1266622096300125,
-0.019966863095760345,
-0.24885767698287964,
-0.0430467389523983,
-0.0749237909913063,
0.077975794672966,
-0.2568718194961548,
0.07377795875072479,
0.9840666651725769,
-0.11931603401899338,
0.31869128346443176,
-0.5856072306632996,
-0.07836997509002686,
0.4094259738922119,
0.017099549993872643,
0.17769311368465424,
-0.4935625493526459,
-0.3263053297996521,
0.06845109909772873,
-0.22021245956420898,
-0.6764745712280273,
0.2883533239364624,
0.009532847441732883,
0.7205333113670349,
0.4020582139492035,
-0.05946028232574463,
0.4797867238521576,
-0.3935295045375824,
0.9713284969329834,
-0.4704034626483917,
-0.7232888340950012,
0.5212209224700928,
-0.8524060845375061,
0.47630274295806885,
0.3388194441795349,
0.43781349062919617,
-0.5283031463623047,
-0.3290542662143707,
-0.4907657206058502,
-0.934759795665741,
0.8090288639068604,
-0.06444554775953293,
0.23190726339817047,
0.06853266805410385,
0.14225488901138306,
-0.04897589981555939,
0.28993213176727295,
-0.7602860927581787,
0.18403209745883942,
0.14673775434494019,
0.360031396150589,
-0.3928641080856323,
-0.12508465349674225,
-0.33211156725883484,
-0.033714793622493744,
0.45186784863471985,
-0.19427312910556793,
0.14388595521450043,
0.14315110445022583,
-0.10307178646326065,
0.13977767527103424,
0.36746013164520264,
0.6499654650688171,
0.7422745227813721,
-0.14312012493610382,
0.148372620344162,
0.26051628589630127,
0.01838020607829094,
0.038150765001773834,
-0.043893832713365555,
0.01677744649350643,
-0.4372592568397522,
0.5475800037384033,
0.7026030421257019,
0.6615421772003174,
-1.0220457315444946,
0.5044777393341064,
-0.13498039543628693,
-0.09781862795352936,
-0.42439350485801697,
0.2186664640903473,
0.0251057967543602,
0.6137923002243042,
0.23119968175888062,
-0.333614706993103,
0.24975310266017914,
-0.9981114864349365,
-0.15499454736709595,
0.6795972585678101,
-0.24344515800476074,
-0.21354231238365173,
0.3997577130794525,
0.0157672930508852,
-0.09549740701913834,
0.6477607488632202,
-0.36866438388824463,
-0.46755579113960266,
0.5753903985023499,
0.4038551151752472,
0.6964645981788635,
0.046378713101148605,
-0.015590909868478775,
0.29346027970314026,
0.3825279474258423,
-0.2501041889190674,
0.19256192445755005,
-0.2415120005607605,
-0.7095218300819397,
-0.7035375237464905,
-0.17551012337207794,
-0.5697759389877319,
0.3389584720134735,
-0.4464667737483978,
0.04484064131975174,
-0.25723522901535034,
0.125859797000885,
-0.35340169072151184,
-0.10302016884088516,
-0.6896152496337891,
-0.10712369531393051,
0.10627290606498718,
0.736982524394989,
-0.7498190402984619,
0.6817945241928101,
0.6505306959152222,
-0.2351536750793457,
-0.7153139114379883,
-0.014107833616435528,
0.16083648800849915,
-0.6046963930130005,
0.38377395272254944,
0.20949965715408325,
-0.0268257986754179,
-0.28758296370506287,
-0.6653897762298584,
-1.0805846452713013,
1.1992515325546265,
0.022956646978855133,
-0.26486653089523315,
-0.16998887062072754,
-0.2986232042312622,
0.5227549076080322,
-0.3816385865211487,
0.32672086358070374,
0.772083044052124,
0.6404128670692444,
-0.04570410028100014,
-0.9359903335571289,
0.15785162150859833,
-0.07404033839702606,
-0.09064804017543793,
0.18243081867694855,
-0.7310410141944885,
1.0273065567016602,
-0.29891911149024963,
-0.2384980022907257,
0.03752174600958824,
0.49029767513275146,
0.4191095530986786,
0.2039986252784729,
0.3319830298423767,
0.16606637835502625,
0.7107102274894714,
-0.16479206085205078,
1.3689470291137695,
0.010228728875517845,
0.0930827260017395,
1.126011610031128,
-0.3183692693710327,
0.8043795228004456,
0.44249701499938965,
-0.02269623801112175,
0.31875598430633545,
0.8440083265304565,
0.41576725244522095,
0.6447716951370239,
0.1679569035768509,
-0.32265350222587585,
-0.24578465521335602,
-0.02390313893556595,
-0.12615250051021576,
0.5058937668800354,
0.6857936978340149,
-0.15086477994918823,
-0.25613075494766235,
-0.022860389202833176,
0.11767133325338364,
-0.09747789055109024,
-0.3722832500934601,
0.6744267344474792,
-0.023932840675115585,
-1.0512681007385254,
0.3182588815689087,
0.020029518753290176,
0.7659621834754944,
-0.8032060861587524,
-0.15692666172981262,
-0.29075488448143005,
-0.12870365381240845,
0.020703932270407677,
-0.8184184432029724,
0.04978937655687332,
-0.05179057642817497,
0.25676506757736206,
-0.19891232252120972,
0.40767696499824524,
-0.3279990553855896,
-0.03455464541912079,
0.05936592072248459,
0.772028386592865,
0.15850701928138733,
-0.09322069585323334,
-0.08780181407928467,
0.028345784172415733,
-0.027894901111721992,
-0.6274558901786804,
0.6589298844337463,
0.6356385350227356,
-0.2942647933959961,
0.7059295177459717,
0.6293554306030273,
-0.06678685545921326,
-0.195418581366539,
-0.19770343601703644,
0.9916101098060608,
-0.7395429611206055,
-0.5426619648933411,
-0.9366585612297058,
0.3693590760231018,
0.05948781222105026,
-0.2387792021036148,
0.6896010637283325,
0.4426318407058716,
0.8074374794960022,
0.1758463978767395,
1.0389050245285034,
0.02853420004248619,
0.13491979241371155,
-0.7844504714012146,
0.1269223690032959,
-0.35979384183883667,
0.29782119393348694,
-0.09990131855010986,
-0.8374898433685303,
0.1300675868988037,
0.5926225185394287,
-0.5139461755752563,
0.14407499134540558,
0.6423439979553223,
0.6396295428276062,
0.015989232808351517,
0.11896961182355881,
0.3132508397102356,
0.20514236390590668,
0.6573020219802856,
0.7202854752540588,
1.1909247636795044,
0.1999933421611786,
0.3078199625015259,
0.1693384349346161,
-0.269611120223999,
-0.10623064637184143,
-0.8769741654396057,
-1.0324996709823608,
-0.5279811024665833,
0.30348050594329834,
0.025810323655605316,
-0.034469299018383026,
1.1623501777648926,
0.3351868987083435,
-0.28472936153411865,
-0.3505318760871887,
0.09725555777549744,
0.22260655462741852,
-0.16008901596069336,
-0.1708325445652008,
0.39527225494384766,
-0.4271174669265747,
-0.8569777607917786,
0.9893828630447388,
0.23756255209445953,
0.037220850586891174,
-0.6036410927772522,
-0.11217235028743744,
-0.11880362033843994,
0.03739325702190399,
0.7609415650367737,
0.44631513953208923,
-0.6573200225830078,
-0.3965558111667633,
-0.04878217354416847,
0.16393320262432098,
0.02794152870774269,
1.0580086708068848,
-0.8336406946182251,
0.5148634910583496,
0.270338773727417,
0.7089484333992004,
0.6295968294143677,
-0.23801368474960327,
0.7405195236206055,
-0.624408483505249,
0.05903587117791176,
0.293205589056015,
0.5713819265365601,
0.09592129290103912,
-0.2316954880952835,
0.4211631715297699,
-0.2970656156539917,
-0.6341499090194702,
-0.691555917263031,
0.2213941067457199,
-0.7458927631378174,
-0.25417283177375793,
1.4715046882629395,
-0.17025837302207947,
-0.06728971004486084,
-0.0381130650639534,
-0.40452492237091064,
-0.15881353616714478,
-0.5371764302253723,
0.5769446492195129,
1.0440322160720825,
-0.5635449290275574,
-0.028827475383877754,
-0.9505199790000916,
0.490460604429245,
0.1268736720085144,
-0.7363606095314026,
0.018489543348550797,
0.5798473954200745,
-0.02225237525999546,
0.024032574146986008,
0.7271437048912048,
0.13654404878616333,
0.08143807202577591,
-0.16436508297920227,
-0.5333380103111267,
0.027602652087807655,
-0.29506227374076843,
-0.6106715798377991,
-0.053139444440603256,
0.22123409807682037,
0.2228163331747055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15365v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15365v2
|
A Transfer Attack to Image Watermarks
| 2024-03-22T17:33:11 | 2024-03-25T03:06:08 |
Yuepeng Hu, Zhengyuan Jiang, Moyang Guo, Neil Gong
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Watermark has been widely deployed by industry to detect AI-generated images.
The robustness of such watermark-based detector against evasion attacks in the
white-box and black-box settings is well understood in the literature. However,
the robustness in the no-box setting is much less understood. In particular,
multiple studies claimed that image watermark is robust in such setting. In
this work, we propose a new transfer evasion attack to image watermark in the
no-box setting. Our transfer attack adds a perturbation to a watermarked image
to evade multiple surrogate watermarking models trained by the attacker itself,
and the perturbed watermarked image also evades the target watermarking model.
Our major contribution is to show that, both theoretically and empirically,
watermark-based AI-generated image detector is not robust to evasion attacks
even if the attacker does not have access to the watermarking model nor the
detection API.
|
[
-0.6659731268882751,
-0.84083491563797,
0.31008535623550415,
-0.36949416995048523,
-0.3822748064994812,
0.2065366953611374,
0.6086269021034241,
-0.5572653412818909,
-0.021530624479055405,
0.9521374106407166,
-0.487210750579834,
-0.026264479383826256,
-0.9469281435012817,
0.051225002855062485,
-0.8390157222747803,
0.7972015738487244,
0.08460260927677155,
-0.4386332333087921,
0.12227599322795868,
-0.1664329320192337,
-0.5141947865486145,
-0.5440577864646912,
-0.5889272689819336,
-0.21729739010334015,
-0.029477357864379883,
-0.09615413099527359,
0.6267502903938293,
0.546223521232605,
0.5457920432090759,
0.19436123967170715,
0.21439188718795776,
-0.15844103693962097,
-0.1673363894224167,
0.1310427039861679,
-0.04419919103384018,
-0.4729747176170349,
-0.1021551787853241,
-0.25205713510513306,
0.26929524540901184,
-0.23845311999320984,
0.6305660605430603,
-0.1014191210269928,
-0.24735157191753387,
0.7218897938728333,
-1.101255178451538,
-0.2652163803577423,
-1.0276116132736206,
0.06543406844139099,
-0.35448452830314636,
-0.2421754151582718,
-0.6456778049468994,
0.0916205570101738,
-0.3901093900203705,
-0.5316371321678162,
0.32914823293685913,
0.16191774606704712,
1.2730551958084106,
0.5795663595199585,
-0.28735390305519104,
0.11042316257953644,
-0.8771472573280334,
0.5791975259780884,
-0.31150293350219727,
-0.1045830175280571,
0.3452604413032532,
0.6511857509613037,
-0.15201038122177124,
-0.7441160678863525,
-0.569040060043335,
-0.08005237579345703,
0.13980229198932648,
0.06562303751707077,
-0.9666783809661865,
-0.4430963099002838,
0.28790003061294556,
0.10957050323486328,
-0.2496234029531479,
-0.4305974841117859,
-0.07856779545545578,
-0.2674204707145691,
0.5684035420417786,
0.043441303074359894,
0.32238516211509705,
0.3123247027397156,
-1.0855480432510376,
-0.30773353576660156,
-0.87405925989151,
0.2316655069589615,
0.39917612075805664,
-0.12922345101833344,
-0.35511302947998047,
0.1959969699382782,
0.14459021389484406,
0.30403468012809753,
0.1765546053647995,
0.1609586924314499,
-0.2969062328338623,
-0.11586097627878189,
-0.004117798991501331,
0.008000697009265423,
0.9932965040206909,
0.059329304844141006,
0.294330894947052,
-0.2073049247264862,
-0.4772098660469055,
0.15675224363803864,
0.40683963894844055,
-0.893541693687439,
-0.35427019000053406,
-0.04206713289022446,
-0.24292220175266266,
-0.6164181232452393,
0.37862780690193176,
-1.0754354000091553,
-0.5046417713165283,
0.5124449133872986,
0.7150004506111145,
-0.40827637910842896,
-0.27490848302841187,
0.08900555968284607,
-0.30460676550865173,
0.45066526532173157,
0.2609570622444153,
-0.3138883411884308,
0.26440104842185974,
0.42300546169281006,
0.6538282632827759,
0.019524196162819862,
-0.035599078983068466,
-0.7705366611480713,
0.5549602508544922,
-0.5729378461837769,
1.417358636856079,
-0.6924473643302917,
-0.6439704298973083,
-0.14560529589653015,
0.07984752953052521,
0.23698130249977112,
-0.426285058259964,
0.11501029133796692,
-0.660952627658844,
-0.349641352891922,
-0.06997068971395493,
-0.3292110860347748,
-0.2746809124946594,
0.3533155620098114,
-0.9482120871543884,
0.37190839648246765,
0.08343510329723358,
-0.714823842048645,
-0.006925502792000771,
-0.9786800742149353,
-0.4756515920162201,
0.21948884427547455,
-0.08965814858675003,
-0.7307959794998169,
0.08237557858228683,
0.4200092852115631,
0.06640572100877762,
0.17072820663452148,
-0.1840759962797165,
-0.6077015399932861,
-0.6640431880950928,
0.5226535797119141,
-0.8679113984107971,
0.7918945550918579,
0.05030506104230881,
-0.6565552353858948,
-0.458079069852829,
-0.6328057646751404,
-0.029340602457523346,
0.3979094624519348,
0.07176509499549866,
-0.2880798876285553,
-0.47767022252082825,
-0.23132506012916565,
-0.1133720800280571,
0.21208874881267548,
-0.620014488697052,
0.2750902771949768,
0.3416730761528015,
0.19962474703788757,
0.7843677997589111,
0.46371740102767944,
0.2604933977127075,
-0.2545379102230072,
0.8961538076400757,
-0.16787870228290558,
0.13697722554206848,
-0.25636446475982666,
-0.327055424451828,
-0.3413558602333069,
-0.5336503386497498,
0.41319161653518677,
0.43697407841682434,
-1.2682721614837646,
0.08628837019205093,
-0.07086462527513504,
-0.3496721684932709,
-0.3991343080997467,
0.028186960145831108,
0.4372215270996094,
0.34709692001342773,
0.5390616655349731,
-0.31034019589424133,
-0.041544683277606964,
-0.9415756464004517,
-0.5241068005561829,
0.17558380961418152,
0.2190445214509964,
0.18187855184078217,
0.7234495878219604,
-0.12233452498912811,
0.586164116859436,
-0.3460403084754944,
-0.2574663758277893,
0.02437160350382328,
0.13640443980693817,
-0.11490506678819656,
0.6217199563980103,
0.9090532064437866,
-0.7200291156768799,
-0.5306308269500732,
-0.05833619087934494,
-0.528908371925354,
-0.23302914202213287,
-0.25322669744491577,
-0.3097272515296936,
0.09189695864915848,
0.427924782037735,
-0.7816361784934998,
1.2248642444610596,
0.49589040875434875,
-0.4353032410144806,
0.6161770224571228,
-0.0644669234752655,
0.1411597728729248,
-0.720088005065918,
0.20678235590457916,
-0.16868485510349274,
-0.090866819024086,
-0.583551287651062,
0.20823028683662415,
0.33358046412467957,
-0.2703857421875,
-0.5701929330825806,
0.5829669237136841,
-0.16757053136825562,
0.1249772310256958,
-0.7702074646949768,
-0.6248963475227356,
0.422636479139328,
0.17616352438926697,
0.02195081301033497,
0.9379781484603882,
0.7754446268081665,
-0.31620046496391296,
0.14755424857139587,
0.21520885825157166,
0.1513996422290802,
1.2020485401153564,
-0.6670690774917603,
0.5869042277336121,
-0.13845938444137573,
0.36126405000686646,
-1.0572165250778198,
0.42447802424430847,
0.5803653597831726,
-0.40911659598350525,
0.7835499048233032,
-0.5984974503517151,
-0.08610879629850388,
0.11136765033006668,
-0.4143567383289337,
0.3489457964897156,
0.458591103553772,
-0.6431050896644592,
0.4532507658004761,
-0.3789764642715454,
0.5874999761581421,
-0.688603937625885,
-0.8979176878929138,
0.4194159507751465,
-0.5012531876564026,
-0.4190003573894501,
0.588369607925415,
-0.11968602240085602,
-0.1297750025987625,
0.3771325647830963,
-0.3455371558666229,
-0.4385433793067932,
0.436830997467041,
0.16006916761398315,
0.4458351135253906,
-0.2788315713405609,
-0.7500666975975037,
-0.29030144214630127,
-0.5016584992408752,
0.11996543407440186,
0.3461275100708008,
0.3731846511363983,
0.10815997421741486,
-0.7036705613136292,
-1.0187327861785889,
0.5138280391693115,
0.7901690006256104,
-0.31343457102775574,
0.6180214285850525,
0.5311474204063416,
-0.5159348249435425,
-0.14823704957962036,
-0.3368423283100128,
-0.19784484803676605,
-0.49571532011032104,
0.06657019257545471,
-0.4888917803764343,
-0.29024577140808105,
0.4312637746334076,
0.10060660541057587,
0.015409181825816631,
0.43752697110176086,
-0.3056469261646271,
-0.19227109849452972,
0.8093032836914062,
0.4236670732498169,
-0.2825559675693512,
0.546003520488739,
-0.5016298890113831,
0.2646847367286682,
-1.0467019081115723,
0.1707911342382431,
-0.6365987062454224,
-0.39527076482772827,
-0.1717282384634018,
0.23932893574237823,
0.09266460686922073,
0.15302467346191406,
-0.33874794840812683,
0.6576176285743713,
-0.3390957713127136,
0.3724740743637085,
0.4515273869037628,
0.10987501591444016,
0.11857211589813232,
0.5044068694114685,
0.2896837592124939,
0.10900063812732697,
-0.31113865971565247,
-0.299038290977478,
1.0755929946899414,
-0.0929512307047844,
0.9338964223861694,
-0.016932794824242592,
0.6793118119239807,
0.87114018201828,
0.334608256816864,
-0.1552468091249466,
0.4405282139778137,
-0.009923272766172886,
-0.6819230318069458,
-0.04165097698569298,
-0.2109251618385315,
-1.327710509300232,
0.26404350996017456,
-0.27951285243034363,
-0.7428759932518005,
0.08889606595039368,
-0.18946409225463867,
-0.2223588079214096,
0.8048008680343628,
-0.646137535572052,
0.5052570104598999,
-0.4952339828014374,
-0.6763349771499634,
-0.054632920771837234,
-0.12391649931669235,
0.20623540878295898,
-0.2767220139503479,
0.32331985235214233,
-0.20755387842655182,
-0.027115974575281143,
0.1948632299900055,
-0.337525874376297,
0.5394725799560547,
-0.492296427488327,
0.33277300000190735,
0.3955792784690857,
0.7871201038360596,
0.6491042375564575,
-0.2221871167421341,
0.05309014022350311,
0.4293821454048157,
-0.10076932609081268,
-0.729910135269165,
-0.6307140588760376,
0.14090421795845032,
-0.45744258165359497,
-0.8504579067230225,
-0.3346347510814667,
-0.4230303168296814,
0.10251554846763611,
0.20506057143211365,
0.43688255548477173,
0.15670108795166016,
0.4280078113079071,
0.3228859305381775,
0.23136194050312042,
-0.2630014717578888,
0.6181250810623169,
0.4434881806373596,
0.38804277777671814,
-0.32371947169303894,
0.798627495765686,
0.13706471025943756,
0.42888468503952026,
0.15414786338806152,
0.19621747732162476,
-0.23354309797286987,
-0.6155637502670288,
-0.7470157146453857,
-0.010223801247775555,
-0.5677829384803772,
-0.5281258225440979,
-0.05209627375006676,
-0.5998491048812866,
-0.06640562415122986,
-0.32660436630249023,
-0.3776155710220337,
0.03700149059295654,
-0.15489020943641663,
0.2531859874725342,
0.6114575862884521,
0.6530436277389526,
0.31569796800613403,
0.33644625544548035,
-0.7958311438560486,
0.4185967743396759,
0.3669710159301758,
0.3948461413383484,
-0.07554922252893448,
-0.8561039566993713,
0.40336257219314575,
0.15489032864570618,
-0.7421159148216248,
-0.9143134355545044,
0.29861778020858765,
0.08303126692771912,
0.7004603743553162,
0.7330998182296753,
0.5484054088592529,
0.8248888850212097,
-0.18016304075717926,
0.6605418920516968,
0.1697179675102234,
-1.219064712524414,
0.5735674500465393,
0.007274510804563761,
0.08303534239530563,
0.3663301169872284,
0.022039290517568588,
0.20185698568820953,
-0.3278992474079132,
-1.0962506532669067,
-0.5210525989532471,
0.5515932440757751,
0.42582300305366516,
0.35410457849502563,
0.5462596416473389,
0.2878289520740509,
0.17693933844566345,
0.27035072445869446,
-0.8715870976448059,
-0.2888016104698181,
-0.31122535467147827,
0.4793241322040558,
0.6201090216636658,
-0.018695803359150887,
-0.06921315938234329,
-0.017165271565318108,
0.756786048412323,
0.10842128843069077,
0.5233643054962158,
0.3641413152217865,
-0.011228256858885288,
-0.12265004217624664,
0.0005898326635360718,
0.3806292414665222,
0.08108444511890411,
0.1505558341741562,
0.4660241901874542,
-0.10235130786895752,
-0.21026009321212769,
0.4272853136062622,
-0.04777487739920616,
-0.49457237124443054,
-0.0913306400179863,
0.697090208530426,
0.8398080468177795,
-0.18581226468086243,
-0.30533933639526367,
0.736858069896698,
-0.19505122303962708,
-0.4597187638282776,
-0.06555315852165222,
0.35203757882118225,
-0.3089350163936615,
0.23753714561462402,
0.42630037665367126,
0.4941350221633911,
-0.11814940720796585,
-0.04724768549203873,
0.3088587522506714,
0.905190110206604,
-0.410944402217865,
-0.2878827750682831,
0.9240675568580627,
-0.17740200459957123,
-0.6081960201263428,
0.4718267619609833,
-0.08200503140687943,
-0.5356975197792053,
1.0512502193450928,
0.7925993800163269,
0.8154590129852295,
-0.3782758116722107,
-0.06171008571982384,
-0.01933947205543518,
0.6123178005218506,
-0.0019015348516404629,
-0.039108116179704666,
-0.20405736565589905,
-0.7970322966575623,
0.18121467530727386,
-0.02596183307468891,
-0.4376942813396454,
0.7282062768936157,
-0.5722166299819946,
0.22664442658424377,
-0.6214020848274231,
-0.20650170743465424,
-0.0906199961900711,
-0.4350317418575287,
-0.5452641248703003,
-0.14234353601932526,
0.3849916160106659,
0.5763653516769409,
-0.6074467301368713,
0.8074933290481567,
0.5685993432998657,
-0.035026706755161285,
-0.4553617835044861,
0.20606276392936707,
-0.2777995467185974,
-0.9209047555923462,
-0.16143552958965302,
0.4299300014972687,
-0.19632282853126526,
-0.03488751873373985,
-0.8846092820167542,
-0.9846336841583252,
0.7284460663795471,
0.861411452293396,
-0.09476228803396225,
0.8060159683227539,
0.11448658257722855,
0.2216796576976776,
-0.23420779407024384,
-0.15005996823310852,
0.43023934960365295,
0.6331702470779419,
0.06103930622339249,
-0.15369732677936554,
0.31095629930496216,
-0.47202932834625244,
-0.17285145819187164,
-0.05232144892215729,
-0.6563736200332642,
0.6087350249290466,
0.13100077211856842,
-0.1824272722005844,
0.2576424181461334,
0.1001296117901802,
0.17643950879573822,
0.39240652322769165,
0.5852643251419067,
0.6119972467422485,
0.07506067305803299,
-0.08912158012390137,
1.2998712062835693,
-0.32781827449798584,
0.044999465346336365,
0.4605723023414612,
-0.5378021597862244,
0.6506662964820862,
0.5984029173851013,
-0.35037073493003845,
0.4222296476364136,
0.15412423014640808,
-0.6880009770393372,
0.6989507079124451,
-0.05006127804517746,
-0.16050639748573303,
-0.19108104705810547,
-0.10077035427093506,
-0.5409929752349854,
0.5380306839942932,
0.2071709930896759,
-0.2348484992980957,
-0.25000450015068054,
-0.050224822014570236,
0.06059421971440315,
0.1184639036655426,
-0.24897408485412598,
0.41708803176879883,
-0.17060059309005737,
-0.3997131884098053,
0.909521758556366,
-0.1450234353542328,
0.606155276298523,
-0.5828021764755249,
-0.21293585002422333,
-0.2899407744407654,
0.02406744286417961,
-0.3070542812347412,
-0.7596380710601807,
0.33465778827667236,
0.12700989842414856,
0.3414910137653351,
-0.032894011586904526,
1.1397844552993774,
0.1293826401233673,
-0.46225887537002563,
0.408302903175354,
0.265604704618454,
0.21845117211341858,
-0.2973054349422455,
-0.6813836693763733,
0.17452186346054077,
0.21758916974067688,
-0.48321840167045593,
0.42564982175827026,
0.09889210015535355,
-0.17496149241924286,
0.7332354187965393,
0.9676119089126587,
0.11459583789110184,
0.16389743983745575,
-0.38636237382888794,
0.4056559205055237,
-0.4815523326396942,
-0.43708336353302,
-1.166764497756958,
0.2105073183774948,
-0.015052749775350094,
0.16377247869968414,
0.541286826133728,
0.18885180354118347,
0.49316269159317017,
-0.03645336627960205,
1.0688437223434448,
0.08156078308820724,
-0.5018196702003479,
-0.16332203149795532,
0.7115368247032166,
-0.49174052476882935,
0.32057586312294006,
-0.576900839805603,
-0.5303246974945068,
-0.18603841960430145,
0.5211997628211975,
-0.20403143763542175,
0.011628270149230957,
0.5473141670227051,
0.7867864370346069,
-0.1549084484577179,
0.157065287232399,
0.3878442645072937,
-0.3134095072746277,
0.5666375756263733,
0.6315339207649231,
1.0295014381408691,
-0.7789632081985474,
0.8729077577590942,
-0.4696666896343231,
0.08385017514228821,
0.14042234420776367,
-1.1383675336837769,
-0.818842887878418,
-0.14574918150901794,
-0.5371197462081909,
-0.44853684306144714,
0.09427423775196075,
0.13540755212306976,
0.886924684047699,
-0.7043291330337524,
0.23658213019371033,
-0.23931914567947388,
0.23438435792922974,
-0.42663872241973877,
-0.2737670838832855,
0.44457241892814636,
0.43526166677474976,
-0.4521813988685608,
0.2594464123249054,
0.22871261835098267,
0.5637122392654419,
-0.13526949286460876,
0.11411035805940628,
0.08032786846160889,
0.1370505839586258,
-0.20810319483280182,
0.3801932632923126,
-0.2882479131221771,
-0.4375839829444885,
-0.44862571358680725,
0.12818464636802673,
0.28598353266716003,
0.44402918219566345,
-0.6884359121322632,
0.11745302379131317,
0.0238589346408844,
0.9850965738296509,
0.5448407530784607,
0.10705562680959702,
-0.06136156991124153,
-0.6317278742790222,
0.4807526171207428,
-0.15706315636634827,
0.30141961574554443,
0.3315604031085968,
-0.7213303446769714,
0.3518732190132141,
0.7287284135818481,
0.09014488011598587,
-0.8442075252532959,
0.03744121640920639,
-0.45945799350738525,
-0.6390319466590881,
0.7940008640289307,
-0.3420720398426056,
-0.5418617725372314,
-0.11548776924610138,
-0.10852941125631332,
-0.1388767808675766,
-0.5318840742111206,
1.0493675470352173,
0.6459550857543945,
-0.1795526146888733,
-0.20342294871807098,
-0.5564361810684204,
-0.03819296136498451,
0.3509135842323303,
-0.7336596846580505,
-0.3172597587108612,
-0.13564349710941315,
0.5168159008026123,
0.3613831698894501,
0.228849858045578,
-0.24148382246494293,
0.5826293230056763,
0.25757572054862976,
0.21338006854057312,
-0.6125112175941467,
-0.07564330846071243,
-0.37054407596588135,
0.37917259335517883,
-0.2015935629606247,
-0.8958273530006409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15364v1
|
Towards Knowledge-Grounded Natural Language Understanding and Generation
| 2024-03-22T17:32:43 | 2024-03-22T17:32:43 |
Chenxi Whitehouse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This thesis investigates how natural language understanding and generation
with transformer models can benefit from grounding the models with knowledge
representations and addresses the following key research questions: (i) Can
knowledge of entities extend its benefits beyond entity-centric tasks, such as
entity linking? (ii) How can we faithfully and effectively extract such
structured knowledge from raw text, especially noisy web text? (iii) How do
other types of knowledge, beyond structured knowledge, contribute to improving
NLP tasks?
Studies in this thesis find that incorporating relevant and up-to-date
knowledge of entities benefits fake news detection, and entity-focused
code-switching significantly enhances zero-shot cross-lingual transfer on
entity-centric tasks. In terms of effective and faithful approaches to
extracting structured knowledge, it is observed that integrating negative
examples and training with entity planning significantly improves performance.
Additionally, it is established that other general forms of knowledge, such as
parametric and distilled knowledge, enhance multimodal and multilingual
knowledge-intensive tasks. This research shows the tangible benefits of diverse
knowledge integration and motivates further exploration in this direction.
|
[
-0.472212016582489,
-0.7539596557617188,
0.5697189569473267,
0.22309446334838867,
0.003488187910988927,
0.10008961707353592,
-0.2776460349559784,
-0.6197993755340576,
-0.10356564819812775,
0.7183473706245422,
-0.174580380320549,
-0.4269806444644928,
-0.42129209637641907,
0.041576825082302094,
-0.5222654342651367,
0.9370524883270264,
0.09630879014730453,
-0.022738546133041382,
-0.29141777753829956,
0.03251033276319504,
-0.5105661749839783,
-0.4616701006889343,
-0.5972599387168884,
-0.4868895411491394,
0.20201446115970612,
0.38923224806785583,
0.6237500309944153,
0.41001537442207336,
0.24871692061424255,
0.22279474139213562,
-0.003631360363215208,
0.09981605410575867,
-0.3318119943141937,
0.20769505202770233,
-0.5551964044570923,
-0.6785303950309753,
-0.10886693745851517,
-0.0014013578183948994,
0.44550976157188416,
1.0060428380966187,
-0.1490340530872345,
0.09240541607141495,
0.20479348301887512,
0.6798012852668762,
-0.571725070476532,
0.3922613561153412,
-0.7670841217041016,
0.036364536732435226,
0.04132942482829094,
-0.12520751357078552,
-0.4216460883617401,
-0.24311275780200958,
0.281537801027298,
-0.8746527433395386,
0.4165743589401245,
0.032102201133966446,
0.9847903847694397,
0.4118049740791321,
-0.796742856502533,
-0.4840046465396881,
-0.8774105310440063,
0.8259699940681458,
-0.7005643844604492,
0.6747199892997742,
0.2837553918361664,
0.3498953580856323,
-0.023649727925658226,
-0.8327789902687073,
-0.7036125063896179,
0.01822490803897381,
-0.2641339600086212,
0.20530633628368378,
-0.2159506231546402,
0.13580100238323212,
0.1652563512325287,
0.5517589449882507,
-0.19106951355934143,
-0.0815948024392128,
-0.2520920932292938,
-0.04216436296701431,
0.4494397044181824,
-0.26961106061935425,
0.593350350856781,
-0.5096049904823303,
-0.17287687957286835,
0.11028708517551422,
-0.6434144377708435,
0.0823836624622345,
0.3995545208454132,
0.24890969693660736,
-0.026039183139801025,
0.5934857726097107,
-0.2884133458137512,
0.825230598449707,
0.10290476679801941,
-0.24803444743156433,
0.033742453902959824,
-0.40979868173599243,
-0.27368059754371643,
0.046118538826704025,
0.3935098648071289,
0.15622112154960632,
0.3939613103866577,
-0.6595808267593384,
-0.031500931829214096,
0.23984050750732422,
0.461700975894928,
-0.5213934779167175,
-0.16371361911296844,
-0.005898720119148493,
-0.42705222964286804,
-0.4222855865955353,
0.12236849963665009,
-0.7530805468559265,
-0.17875909805297852,
-0.8431406617164612,
0.1689438670873642,
-0.7477381825447083,
-0.6495625376701355,
0.29833003878593445,
-0.4835776388645172,
0.41750404238700867,
0.18626190721988678,
-0.9544795751571655,
0.4844091534614563,
0.7257350087165833,
0.34925490617752075,
0.010612593032419682,
0.02254864200949669,
-0.25703996419906616,
0.42002391815185547,
-0.046660542488098145,
0.5789519548416138,
-0.34723514318466187,
-0.014354702085256577,
0.0774221271276474,
-0.2869866192340851,
-0.23696647584438324,
-0.5221301317214966,
0.763449490070343,
-0.6785844564437866,
0.6037788391113281,
-0.1641886830329895,
-0.6350858807563782,
-0.5988118052482605,
0.4097846448421478,
-0.7188321352005005,
1.1597307920455933,
0.05260505527257919,
-0.8786987662315369,
0.5160605907440186,
-0.7350558638572693,
-0.7234131693840027,
-0.0942402184009552,
-0.16802118718624115,
0.015340384095907211,
0.23464927077293396,
0.32829487323760986,
0.48945948481559753,
-0.25001564621925354,
0.6388201117515564,
0.19241465628147125,
0.1744823306798935,
-0.0893927738070488,
-0.204401433467865,
0.5926827192306519,
0.042579833418130875,
-0.5127058625221252,
-0.08862777799367905,
-1.0292675495147705,
-0.06854143738746643,
0.14019054174423218,
-0.3436073064804077,
-0.62674880027771,
0.029447857290506363,
0.0043095978908240795,
0.3297460377216339,
-0.11480382084846497,
-0.35891193151474,
0.08535163104534149,
-0.5309741497039795,
0.2657085657119751,
0.17094093561172485,
0.35056033730506897,
0.9291576147079468,
-0.17380493879318237,
0.4010430872440338,
0.28554704785346985,
-0.20404917001724243,
-0.24586179852485657,
-0.6278355121612549,
-0.9836606383323669,
0.20166683197021484,
0.21231848001480103,
0.3870948851108551,
-1.2635935544967651,
0.42080360651016235,
-0.3203619718551636,
-0.2828211784362793,
-0.5947639346122742,
0.2544134259223938,
0.1250099092721939,
0.9449910521507263,
0.6612377762794495,
0.051689282059669495,
-0.727458119392395,
-0.8370487689971924,
-0.6699555516242981,
-0.07991532981395721,
-0.180485337972641,
0.01382402703166008,
0.39936453104019165,
-0.19505372643470764,
1.3399460315704346,
-0.41817206144332886,
-0.14692983031272888,
-0.4920893609523773,
0.2856946587562561,
0.266194611787796,
0.4775448739528656,
0.5331722497940063,
-1.1239831447601318,
-0.2293531596660614,
-0.034788377583026886,
-0.8246952295303345,
-0.059871818870306015,
-0.25314071774482727,
-0.1551644206047058,
-0.054558463394641876,
0.2372387945652008,
-0.819839596748352,
0.16849809885025024,
0.4863969087600708,
-0.33690300583839417,
0.31666257977485657,
0.1275179535150528,
0.02305137924849987,
-1.3517183065414429,
-0.03241625428199768,
0.153239905834198,
-0.38475528359413147,
-1.074344515800476,
-0.037737131118774414,
0.02738109603524208,
-0.09128017723560333,
-0.2883867025375366,
0.37895187735557556,
-0.5817863941192627,
0.09532348811626434,
-0.12090161442756653,
0.35815903544425964,
0.4183952212333679,
0.3628424406051636,
0.23377364873886108,
0.5360440611839294,
0.4198765456676483,
-0.8263389468193054,
-0.010805061087012291,
0.13857777416706085,
-0.14557744562625885,
0.5109446048736572,
-0.44359272718429565,
0.05236004665493965,
-0.37867990136146545,
-0.19409044086933136,
-0.4838540852069855,
-0.18046322464942932,
0.15824106335639954,
-0.5067575573921204,
0.5480186343193054,
-0.3142472505569458,
-0.4594326615333557,
-0.0023385242093354464,
0.13083162903785706,
0.11991643905639648,
0.408587247133255,
-0.581401526927948,
0.7713919281959534,
0.5389469861984253,
0.1201815977692604,
-0.4012168049812317,
-0.7608405947685242,
0.10690973699092865,
-0.2554120123386383,
-0.7734136581420898,
0.5499856472015381,
0.4268340468406677,
-0.5737305879592896,
0.34237948060035706,
-0.18380938470363617,
-0.17340625822544098,
0.24528604745864868,
0.12787450850009918,
-0.03889308497309685,
-0.5207523107528687,
0.3111816346645355,
0.2333080768585205,
-0.18624472618103027,
0.24710701406002045,
-0.7432683706283569,
0.35649579763412476,
-0.20772777497768402,
-0.3065500855445862,
-0.08437273651361465,
0.32883939146995544,
0.3446904420852661,
-0.22202132642269135,
1.0783560276031494,
0.5983148813247681,
-0.6327863931655884,
-0.2782065272331238,
-0.6229652166366577,
-0.16765336692333221,
-0.3662838041782379,
-0.0709623321890831,
-0.28103020787239075,
-0.8869892358779907,
0.20611339807510376,
-0.27985092997550964,
0.09960273653268814,
0.6258549094200134,
0.3364306688308716,
-0.00893351249396801,
0.6845998764038086,
0.929668128490448,
0.00669742189347744,
0.32310783863067627,
-0.24569623172283173,
0.4586416184902191,
-0.6470881700515747,
-0.23501086235046387,
-0.4670042097568512,
-0.024648403748869896,
-0.3242110013961792,
-0.42642122507095337,
0.029193215072155,
0.5505363345146179,
-0.014636942185461521,
0.5248076915740967,
-0.36072567105293274,
0.1901702582836151,
0.43412065505981445,
-0.15304085612297058,
0.697631299495697,
-0.15434695780277252,
-0.1718950867652893,
-0.22309471666812897,
-0.7203512191772461,
-0.8598290681838989,
0.8475887775421143,
0.4056798815727234,
0.46725982427597046,
0.1052551120519638,
0.5532847046852112,
0.07388245314359665,
0.3160623610019684,
-0.7375271916389465,
0.12900687754154205,
0.3638148307800293,
-0.6844915747642517,
-0.14735731482505798,
-0.4382978677749634,
-0.660321056842804,
0.3177640736103058,
-0.26246970891952515,
-0.4412311315536499,
0.07677288353443146,
0.08299075067043304,
-0.02181229554116726,
0.3695763945579529,
-0.8611976504325867,
0.6210739016532898,
-0.06792931258678436,
-0.16171854734420776,
-0.0783572643995285,
-0.6091355681419373,
0.5040889978408813,
0.16740728914737701,
0.41342219710350037,
0.031055089086294174,
0.22124001383781433,
0.6840229630470276,
0.13826051354408264,
0.7203205823898315,
-0.24122975766658783,
-0.2622082829475403,
0.3056863248348236,
-0.02848605252802372,
0.268915057182312,
0.3101962208747864,
-0.17938174307346344,
0.07313672453165054,
-0.23625977337360382,
-0.2311403602361679,
-0.827157199382782,
0.3034723699092865,
-0.5696420669555664,
-0.6342037916183472,
0.030376367270946503,
-0.638382077217102,
-0.28421667218208313,
0.3171057403087616,
0.24577531218528748,
0.3332851827144623,
-0.08308453857898712,
0.39284035563468933,
0.9684829711914062,
-0.13096486032009125,
0.30172663927078247,
0.36934515833854675,
-0.28970181941986084,
-0.21264567971229553,
0.666473388671875,
0.00846730824559927,
0.29730936884880066,
0.8200578689575195,
0.004939356353133917,
-0.2745978534221649,
-0.3363972306251526,
-0.38049307465553284,
0.12099670618772507,
-0.8808488249778748,
-0.34447914361953735,
-0.9769951105117798,
-0.2063673585653305,
-0.6490781307220459,
-0.06610442698001862,
-0.3129878342151642,
-0.6369805932044983,
-0.42547592520713806,
-0.45043203234672546,
0.15305566787719727,
0.8672874569892883,
0.07639609277248383,
0.21535225212574005,
-0.8096387982368469,
0.6989080309867859,
0.2507738769054413,
0.16092538833618164,
0.011879360303282738,
-0.28481215238571167,
-0.28857579827308655,
0.05208796635270119,
-0.35702964663505554,
-1.2383722066879272,
0.342769980430603,
0.09668641537427902,
0.8782702088356018,
0.3371368646621704,
0.02247239090502262,
0.49285003542900085,
-0.31595513224601746,
0.838287889957428,
0.10519848018884659,
-1.0909396409988403,
0.6784774661064148,
-0.42749133706092834,
0.08903197944164276,
0.612733006477356,
0.4360331892967224,
-0.7119203209877014,
-0.47781866788864136,
-0.8342915177345276,
-0.8048408627510071,
0.47015106678009033,
0.576187252998352,
0.12688209116458893,
0.04092121124267578,
0.38531818985939026,
0.07039418071508408,
0.4367591440677643,
-0.9833402633666992,
-0.3327277898788452,
-0.5185297131538391,
-0.28512677550315857,
0.24134740233421326,
-0.217367485165596,
-0.05062956362962723,
-0.30979403853416443,
0.8471991419792175,
-0.3752274215221405,
0.14587950706481934,
0.19790759682655334,
-0.6388570666313171,
0.11892398446798325,
0.5726783871650696,
0.45457106828689575,
0.6484493017196655,
0.2537916898727417,
0.48160046339035034,
0.25404736399650574,
-0.30856257677078247,
-0.13931313157081604,
-0.012237653136253357,
-0.3613606095314026,
0.12284056842327118,
0.44389405846595764,
0.7983487844467163,
0.5846889615058899,
-0.2846487760543823,
0.3431585431098938,
0.013421901501715183,
-0.1637973189353943,
-0.11712478846311569,
0.035153280943632126,
0.36613306403160095,
0.0038201313000172377,
0.5324959754943848,
0.21783657371997833,
0.16144225001335144,
-0.5168619751930237,
0.3383539915084839,
0.13909564912319183,
-0.31690138578414917,
-0.4606221914291382,
0.6454480290412903,
0.22885534167289734,
-0.036600470542907715,
0.44194573163986206,
-0.1530081331729889,
-0.6508949398994446,
0.3858036696910858,
0.7326672077178955,
0.6597320437431335,
0.03763945773243904,
0.25627201795578003,
0.2694205343723297,
0.3722527325153351,
0.005800934508442879,
0.07790347188711166,
-0.2850262522697449,
-1.1208548545837402,
-0.47698742151260376,
-0.6460608243942261,
-0.22861285507678986,
-0.04408377781510353,
-0.7969105839729309,
0.24773024022579193,
-0.1749844253063202,
-0.024172600358724594,
-0.11599479615688324,
-0.08814097195863724,
-0.9409656524658203,
0.1724977046251297,
0.18051056563854218,
1.0716478824615479,
-0.9259015321731567,
0.7226344347000122,
0.8169499039649963,
-0.6225668787956238,
-0.9824095368385315,
0.09157323092222214,
-0.2484389841556549,
-0.4821428954601288,
0.6508623361587524,
0.2167869359254837,
0.10439903289079666,
0.3535597622394562,
-0.3607906401157379,
-0.8219300508499146,
1.1199514865875244,
0.4915037751197815,
-0.17112164199352264,
-0.3372285068035126,
0.43199777603149414,
0.5583227276802063,
-0.2605372369289398,
0.08980651199817657,
0.7722323536872864,
0.5632225871086121,
-0.06391796469688416,
-0.6074798107147217,
0.048595380038022995,
-0.27725544571876526,
-0.008531064726412296,
0.30343034863471985,
-0.10474222153425217,
0.4557356834411621,
0.12094590067863464,
-0.47516271471977234,
-0.5834129452705383,
0.9256511926651001,
0.04330720007419586,
0.18145665526390076,
0.3639315664768219,
0.8672062158584595,
0.7848497629165649,
-0.13074302673339844,
0.9286965727806091,
-0.4640190899372101,
0.2737749218940735,
1.0002723932266235,
-0.0720520094037056,
0.3689831495285034,
0.7279423475265503,
0.10132597386837006,
0.834656834602356,
0.1571623980998993,
0.27024218440055847,
0.34209954738616943,
-0.01069608423858881,
-0.29453399777412415,
-0.2320287525653839,
-0.3246006965637207,
-0.3008219301700592,
0.37184566259384155,
0.3871941566467285,
-0.24863716959953308,
-0.5379360318183899,
0.15889151394367218,
0.008038572035729885,
0.414507657289505,
-0.028169071301817894,
1.0114147663116455,
0.3222087323665619,
-0.7151649594306946,
0.13221170008182526,
0.12846320867538452,
0.6367184519767761,
-0.3323262333869934,
-0.25958049297332764,
0.05520665645599365,
-0.1197204515337944,
-0.3212299048900604,
-0.848946750164032,
0.6776030659675598,
-0.007513003423810005,
-0.45818954706192017,
-0.7352104783058167,
1.3448128700256348,
-0.47021719813346863,
-0.24540503323078156,
0.3368520438671112,
0.7689180374145508,
-0.30143633484840393,
-0.3427775502204895,
-0.41674959659576416,
-0.4664711058139801,
-0.021160487085580826,
-0.3411666452884674,
0.03189844638109207,
0.6906450390815735,
0.0848228856921196,
0.59516441822052,
0.797877311706543,
0.017794523388147354,
0.22636175155639648,
0.21519559621810913,
0.9597765803337097,
-0.7457663416862488,
-0.38675519824028015,
-0.710662305355072,
0.7821663022041321,
-0.2738243341445923,
-0.10282636433839798,
0.8955525159835815,
0.5473160147666931,
0.7828947901725769,
-0.04019465297460556,
0.8407164812088013,
-0.19480322301387787,
0.45425429940223694,
-0.687947154045105,
0.6821191310882568,
-0.07663189619779587,
0.10832604020833969,
-0.2345973402261734,
-0.8270003199577332,
-0.33113718032836914,
0.35772645473480225,
-0.3599163591861725,
-0.3820019066333771,
0.49567490816116333,
0.3184135854244232,
-0.09916958212852478,
0.28246039152145386,
0.3227771818637848,
-0.09180726855993271,
0.5437934994697571,
0.24391040205955505,
0.9466030597686768,
-0.5806702375411987,
0.38665810227394104,
-0.38765543699264526,
0.11753538250923157,
0.3209340274333954,
-0.8197597861289978,
-0.8721501231193542,
-0.5346830487251282,
-0.1714525669813156,
-0.0874565988779068,
-0.4031011164188385,
0.7021741271018982,
0.6968078017234802,
-0.8288992047309875,
0.11119499057531357,
-0.5245460867881775,
0.536508321762085,
-0.09162673354148865,
-0.3579367995262146,
-0.0779777243733406,
-0.7251567840576172,
-0.5936864614486694,
0.5688072443008423,
0.28961318731307983,
0.005573849659413099,
-0.17871631681919098,
0.009441230446100235,
-0.33171650767326355,
-0.17469064891338348,
0.7346264123916626,
0.10309454798698425,
-0.549274742603302,
-0.20764867961406708,
0.18616802990436554,
-0.02892419509589672,
0.06095341593027115,
1.017112135887146,
-1.0369960069656372,
0.10461679846048355,
0.5472914576530457,
0.9731076955795288,
0.4604073464870453,
0.05332346633076668,
0.8410061597824097,
-1.0370553731918335,
0.2237166464328766,
0.34837043285369873,
0.3751911222934723,
0.5537198185920715,
-0.5458669066429138,
0.5113135576248169,
0.4250679612159729,
-0.2467138171195984,
-0.44841429591178894,
0.2711072266101837,
-0.7124826312065125,
-0.09291137009859085,
1.2143940925598145,
0.010024464689195156,
-0.020203521475195885,
-0.5913364887237549,
-0.014644359238445759,
0.6682859063148499,
-0.1532745212316513,
0.48339956998825073,
0.620733380317688,
0.01399090327322483,
-0.30570322275161743,
-0.7124772667884827,
0.6824337244033813,
0.3007911741733551,
-1.2046101093292236,
-0.24373756349086761,
0.2534538805484772,
0.309585839509964,
0.5264536738395691,
0.2910045087337494,
-0.08736150711774826,
-0.16939625144004822,
-0.21084193885326385,
0.22172720730304718,
0.021184304729104042,
-0.2757934331893921,
-0.1167207807302475,
0.2960672676563263,
-0.121744804084301,
0.13861005008220673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15529v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15529v2
|
LimGen: Probing the LLMs for Generating Suggestive Limitations of Research Papers
| 2024-03-22T17:31:43 | 2024-06-14T11:19:26 |
Abdur Rahman Bin Md Faizullah, Ashok Urlana, Rahul Mishra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Examining limitations is a crucial step in the scholarly research reviewing
process, revealing aspects where a study might lack decisiveness or require
enhancement. This aids readers in considering broader implications for further
research. In this article, we present a novel and challenging task of
Suggestive Limitation Generation (SLG) for research papers. We compile a
dataset called \textbf{\textit{LimGen}}, encompassing 4068 research papers and
their associated limitations from the ACL anthology. We investigate several
approaches to harness large language models (LLMs) for producing suggestive
limitations, by thoroughly examining the related challenges, practical
insights, and potential opportunities. Our LimGen dataset and code can be
accessed at \url{https://github.com/arbmf/LimGen}.
|
[
-0.7354029417037964,
-0.6099005341529846,
0.6070361733436584,
-0.13242235779762268,
-0.2932870388031006,
-0.31290775537490845,
-0.19627851247787476,
-0.5875620245933533,
-0.06460678577423096,
0.7561120986938477,
-0.8347290754318237,
-0.34501734375953674,
-0.556303083896637,
0.3531346619129181,
-0.5590844750404358,
1.2640732526779175,
-0.2312133014202118,
-0.0016514145536348224,
-0.23088714480400085,
-0.21297842264175415,
-0.5565239191055298,
-0.13678644597530365,
-0.30404379963874817,
-0.2311360239982605,
0.48607733845710754,
0.47055965662002563,
0.5180627703666687,
0.4619448781013489,
0.6756818294525146,
0.2012757807970047,
-0.07006479054689407,
0.38083916902542114,
-0.766939640045166,
0.6950192451477051,
0.03532550111413002,
-0.5601676106452942,
-0.17707115411758423,
0.20424170792102814,
0.7961429357528687,
0.5717786550521851,
0.26921346783638,
0.3007766604423523,
0.10202478617429733,
0.6309096813201904,
-0.4587809145450592,
-0.4733453094959259,
-0.810556173324585,
0.24973911046981812,
-0.3418956696987152,
-0.27875426411628723,
-0.5069314241409302,
-0.24875149130821228,
0.2171112298965454,
-0.4789782762527466,
0.5845921635627747,
0.4348658323287964,
0.661818265914917,
0.27638670802116394,
-0.3147395849227905,
-0.6285743713378906,
-0.8069546222686768,
0.7144655585289001,
-0.8332713842391968,
0.14776234328746796,
0.2881584167480469,
0.047241274267435074,
-0.04981919005513191,
-0.8745988011360168,
-0.5185174942016602,
-0.6428003907203674,
-0.24085044860839844,
-0.2577488422393799,
-0.317123681306839,
0.057621605694293976,
0.7640605568885803,
0.5248085260391235,
-0.8298397660255432,
-0.17896762490272522,
-0.6487178206443787,
-0.1940804123878479,
1.0527172088623047,
0.307524710893631,
0.1916191130876541,
-0.20391809940338135,
-0.32658851146698,
0.13902388513088226,
-0.9066076278686523,
-0.23709793388843536,
0.375480979681015,
0.34557437896728516,
0.3509139120578766,
0.8777024745941162,
0.09442008286714554,
0.6526950597763062,
0.059112999588251114,
0.20295079052448273,
0.06922701746225357,
-0.18512289226055145,
0.004317951388657093,
-0.16828373074531555,
0.790506899356842,
0.23943771421909332,
-0.15311652421951294,
0.12247031182050705,
-0.30974799394607544,
-0.20667573809623718,
0.14271250367164612,
-0.5881672501564026,
0.30787575244903564,
0.28859230875968933,
-0.6207829117774963,
-0.0638640969991684,
0.04214232414960861,
-0.8839316368103027,
-0.8237374424934387,
-0.07945823669433594,
0.16889244318008423,
-0.2899375259876251,
-0.14706754684448242,
0.08801155537366867,
-0.17528404295444489,
0.2401769459247589,
-0.12640053033828735,
-0.5230252146720886,
0.11754359304904938,
0.443310409784317,
0.8553380370140076,
-0.2722012400627136,
-0.2557019293308258,
-0.31116998195648193,
-0.03608354553580284,
-0.20357738435268402,
0.505619466304779,
-0.6649799346923828,
-0.8696380853652954,
0.13878187537193298,
-0.11917911469936371,
0.18477585911750793,
-0.5776987671852112,
1.0591859817504883,
-0.2904616594314575,
0.08927997201681137,
-0.31283923983573914,
-0.8351752161979675,
-0.0022162345703691244,
-0.05980749800801277,
-0.902644157409668,
0.9192728400230408,
0.18473641574382782,
-0.9619010090827942,
0.40436139702796936,
-0.7095997929573059,
-0.3108033537864685,
0.4933079183101654,
-0.3415020704269409,
-0.37678399682044983,
0.34535375237464905,
-0.19915500283241272,
0.4004114270210266,
-0.5735236406326294,
0.628375768661499,
-0.3600693941116333,
-0.060154084116220474,
0.39614665508270264,
-0.19045889377593994,
0.7381213903427124,
0.7598007917404175,
-0.3333751857280731,
0.26569420099258423,
-0.8376912474632263,
-0.18987591564655304,
0.17982392013072968,
-0.14318159222602844,
-0.26093801856040955,
-0.05920608714222908,
-0.08253001421689987,
-0.08857155591249466,
0.3628588020801544,
-0.5077959895133972,
0.12850484251976013,
-0.04262983426451683,
0.3745291829109192,
0.5112261176109314,
0.03993859142065048,
0.25016987323760986,
-0.7658265829086304,
1.0868691205978394,
-0.6031712293624878,
-0.170064315199852,
-0.18439990282058716,
-0.33742931485176086,
-0.8810374140739441,
0.3275051712989807,
0.3427498936653137,
0.4266414940357208,
-0.6282210946083069,
0.2705625891685486,
0.04247705265879631,
-0.40911564230918884,
-0.6741713881492615,
0.44852277636528015,
0.25456753373146057,
0.358320951461792,
0.0341627262532711,
-0.1254594326019287,
-0.8633096218109131,
-0.9697625041007996,
-0.23226386308670044,
-0.08273917436599731,
-0.12463459372520447,
0.5168476700782776,
0.5360743403434753,
-0.1495264321565628,
0.7928591966629028,
-0.6094493865966797,
-0.38724789023399353,
-0.4995395243167877,
0.2522887885570526,
0.08171548694372177,
0.31916385889053345,
0.34007835388183594,
-0.799356997013092,
-0.4535168409347534,
-0.15763793885707855,
-0.8502158522605896,
-0.5249626636505127,
-0.25764790177345276,
0.05209985375404358,
-0.05823376029729843,
0.8890380263328552,
-0.8092519044876099,
0.36961227655410767,
0.4000456631183624,
-0.4063308835029602,
0.6940783858299255,
-0.17961688339710236,
-0.3055628538131714,
-0.5010299682617188,
0.3308374285697937,
0.2690606713294983,
-0.05074466019868851,
-0.8586875796318054,
0.3862149119377136,
-0.077595554292202,
-0.347380667924881,
-0.08458888530731201,
0.6912288665771484,
-0.5771909952163696,
0.3774067461490631,
-0.5383768081665039,
0.13252070546150208,
-0.12926100194454193,
-0.15189935266971588,
-0.2457139939069748,
0.7203105688095093,
0.4621385931968689,
-0.526033341884613,
0.24959547817707062,
0.19439201056957245,
-0.203607976436615,
0.22428739070892334,
-0.5002251267433167,
0.08845218271017075,
-0.37379318475723267,
0.4093794822692871,
-1.064155101776123,
-0.28331324458122253,
0.0500958114862442,
-0.4432379901409149,
0.2444199174642563,
0.16728515923023224,
-0.5086838006973267,
-0.5812191367149353,
-0.4407482147216797,
0.5030409097671509,
0.5286667943000793,
-0.0930541381239891,
0.6921126246452332,
0.5621039867401123,
-0.27091020345687866,
-0.4943888783454895,
-0.8092831373214722,
0.07217978686094284,
-0.6407723426818848,
-0.730096161365509,
0.12049290537834167,
-0.4220525622367859,
-0.623638391494751,
-0.03907688334584236,
0.09682714939117432,
0.375664085149765,
-0.22759303450584412,
0.2930564880371094,
0.19204114377498627,
-0.020660636946558952,
0.3219625949859619,
-0.13620077073574066,
0.23108501732349396,
0.18547092378139496,
-0.15144525468349457,
0.5739891529083252,
-0.15139128267765045,
-0.18647056818008423,
0.04978635534644127,
0.4390644431114197,
0.3818778991699219,
-0.11522182077169418,
0.176137313246727,
0.7191585302352905,
-0.17168846726417542,
-0.6206607222557068,
-0.8034048080444336,
-0.15051260590553284,
-0.5431540012359619,
0.09546990692615509,
-0.2506871223449707,
-1.3085294961929321,
0.6329094171524048,
0.05046563223004341,
0.0005023395060561597,
0.7487839460372925,
0.4116727113723755,
0.3494621813297272,
0.8471975326538086,
0.6562747359275818,
0.0650942400097847,
0.1556556671857834,
-0.2762511372566223,
0.23026402294635773,
-0.9428958296775818,
-0.1266735941171646,
-0.4650762379169464,
-0.20910269021987915,
-0.9407157301902771,
-0.40531662106513977,
0.3100256621837616,
-0.19499649107456207,
0.161861389875412,
0.1781802475452423,
-0.635407030582428,
0.3916541635990143,
0.4086384177207947,
-0.11180800199508667,
0.24780148267745972,
-0.2426268458366394,
-0.2785627245903015,
-0.17989380657672882,
-0.6496608853340149,
-0.4538813829421997,
1.2461161613464355,
0.5644469261169434,
0.9353808760643005,
-0.14136919379234314,
0.7058448195457458,
0.607455849647522,
0.43712934851646423,
-0.706322431564331,
0.9241496324539185,
-0.16829979419708252,
-1.0548399686813354,
-0.5963825583457947,
-0.5431081056594849,
-1.177836298942566,
0.18724146485328674,
-0.17536473274230957,
-0.5723620653152466,
0.24571648240089417,
-0.06908488273620605,
-0.2381310760974884,
0.2972716987133026,
-0.3250570595264435,
0.20303073525428772,
-0.41435593366622925,
-0.5940992832183838,
0.0771411880850792,
-0.5837512612342834,
0.7223814129829407,
-0.17496539652347565,
0.2880476117134094,
-0.1693233698606491,
-0.06885138154029846,
0.8108451962471008,
-0.1905616968870163,
0.7130799293518066,
-0.18014487624168396,
-0.35803571343421936,
0.7474325299263,
0.21234336495399475,
0.5227721929550171,
0.017077503725886345,
-0.17744594812393188,
-0.40450647473335266,
-0.3276447653770447,
-0.06303262710571289,
0.054104555398225784,
0.7699258327484131,
-0.2928544282913208,
-0.9794092774391174,
-0.4418919086456299,
-1.201500415802002,
-0.32420486211776733,
0.5489987134933472,
0.5293528437614441,
-0.0747588649392128,
-0.21470917761325836,
0.17659629881381989,
0.8386810421943665,
-0.4872633218765259,
0.24291689693927765,
0.34046655893325806,
-0.5967367887496948,
-0.10153399407863617,
0.8687426447868347,
0.2320277988910675,
-0.018201032653450966,
0.03465238958597183,
0.3324287533760071,
-0.34404706954956055,
-1.0817601680755615,
-0.004051636904478073,
0.517406165599823,
-0.7396318912506104,
-0.16930273175239563,
-0.4282061755657196,
-0.5094860792160034,
-0.6943555474281311,
0.018713686615228653,
0.3217286467552185,
-0.4191652536392212,
-0.5285719633102417,
-0.13877400755882263,
0.14828188717365265,
1.1055995225906372,
-0.2060316950082779,
0.23948730528354645,
-0.522449791431427,
0.1975693553686142,
0.32297074794769287,
0.44270947575569153,
0.053262609988451004,
-0.7314807176589966,
-0.03631993755698204,
-0.44009166955947876,
-0.43119698762893677,
-0.8025408983230591,
0.5496705174446106,
0.0635676309466362,
0.6914176344871521,
0.6527611017227173,
0.2751223146915436,
0.36322152614593506,
-0.5271888375282288,
0.6939191818237305,
0.1767212450504303,
-0.7268104553222656,
0.5938310623168945,
-0.7778537273406982,
0.3800660967826843,
0.7595164775848389,
0.6790387034416199,
-0.3948867917060852,
-0.7080554366111755,
-0.7347153425216675,
-1.1443982124328613,
0.4713854491710663,
0.20402109622955322,
0.13753476738929749,
0.1264132857322693,
0.6332380771636963,
0.3332177400588989,
0.09176487475633621,
-1.0902456045150757,
-0.2064334899187088,
0.2828247547149658,
0.10906054079532623,
-0.03769391030073166,
-0.6944968104362488,
-0.488900750875473,
0.08306759595870972,
0.6310798525810242,
-0.04686992987990379,
0.010043305344879627,
0.4074266254901886,
-0.17625164985656738,
-0.3933030068874359,
0.31134772300720215,
0.9538305401802063,
0.9423090815544128,
-0.35261422395706177,
0.1778983473777771,
0.33390429615974426,
-0.2411380410194397,
0.06401173025369644,
0.43667885661125183,
-0.4703734219074249,
0.14507612586021423,
0.45635923743247986,
0.7893476486206055,
-0.673684298992157,
-1.0959362983703613,
0.3137039840221405,
-0.1560826599597931,
-0.6435887217521667,
-0.4828745424747467,
0.10932128876447678,
-0.09376229345798492,
0.14324356615543365,
0.6952826380729675,
-0.44841936230659485,
0.3950202167034149,
-0.36850208044052124,
0.4176201820373535,
0.6950162053108215,
-0.37333059310913086,
0.0861816555261612,
0.7262701988220215,
0.04134484380483627,
-0.22251395881175995,
-0.008761521428823471,
-0.42523497343063354,
-0.30168068408966064,
0.40520477294921875,
0.5191217660903931,
0.8184238076210022,
-0.1479044109582901,
0.20046742260456085,
0.47337087988853455,
0.5334451198577881,
-0.07509563118219376,
0.1692080795764923,
0.1876084804534912,
-0.46291011571884155,
-0.325016051530838,
-0.6091876029968262,
-0.27926522493362427,
0.7316197156906128,
-0.47980156540870667,
0.2682766616344452,
-0.6947805285453796,
-0.43576759099960327,
0.07780148833990097,
0.03544227406382561,
-0.35296833515167236,
-0.011119895614683628,
0.3224964439868927,
0.9080776572227478,
-0.7644253969192505,
0.47483596205711365,
0.24855035543441772,
-0.20873449742794037,
-0.3853154480457306,
-0.01243872381746769,
0.2914464473724365,
-0.7762635946273804,
0.5708204507827759,
0.11237294971942902,
-0.14641766250133514,
-0.51875901222229,
-0.8555018305778503,
-0.7642380595207214,
1.0678503513336182,
0.03423330560326576,
-0.8951592445373535,
-0.22784194350242615,
0.24494177103042603,
0.7175053954124451,
-0.6465576887130737,
-0.2289809286594391,
0.6395938992500305,
0.7408608198165894,
0.028071992099285126,
-0.6332007646560669,
0.5598500370979309,
-0.41600358486175537,
-0.10453841090202332,
0.14652393758296967,
-0.7537336349487305,
0.9351733922958374,
-0.2569137215614319,
-0.3732392489910126,
0.4101960062980652,
0.5545430779457092,
0.4253444969654083,
0.5357843041419983,
0.5888877511024475,
0.6131470799446106,
0.8147913813591003,
0.1744302362203598,
1.0604684352874756,
-0.2684909403324127,
0.2298090010881424,
1.166762113571167,
-0.4649348258972168,
0.40190237760543823,
0.5341290831565857,
-0.040635332465171814,
0.08949185162782669,
0.4771921932697296,
-0.5588359236717224,
0.06571288406848907,
0.8232316970825195,
-0.4417964816093445,
0.03461999446153641,
-0.5008256435394287,
-0.5243440270423889,
0.2658255398273468,
0.7523384690284729,
-0.772817850112915,
-0.045608580112457275,
0.03536634147167206,
0.08957546204328537,
0.08525532484054565,
-0.20288561284542084,
0.5325567722320557,
0.26838910579681396,
-0.9547556638717651,
0.5859897136688232,
-0.10305244475603104,
0.7393600344657898,
-0.7525610327720642,
0.1503993272781372,
-0.23870275914669037,
-0.032413095235824585,
-0.2749314308166504,
-0.7759668231010437,
0.19443939626216888,
0.11408406496047974,
0.08206776529550552,
-0.14775919914245605,
1.192771315574646,
-0.4116116762161255,
-0.7006226181983948,
0.39250844717025757,
0.5759798884391785,
0.05618341267108917,
0.5910667181015015,
-0.6064399480819702,
0.23004667460918427,
0.21451587975025177,
-0.15075014531612396,
0.21588507294654846,
0.724059522151947,
0.09708826243877411,
0.9432777166366577,
0.4570343494415283,
0.564594030380249,
0.016665739938616753,
-0.03167738392949104,
0.75984787940979,
-0.657843291759491,
-0.08699322491884232,
-0.6859915256500244,
0.2892446219921112,
0.017009126022458076,
-0.4602077603340149,
0.9927938580513,
0.6280909180641174,
0.6929149031639099,
0.18628737330436707,
1.34584379196167,
-0.3999654948711395,
0.6267486214637756,
-0.49759143590927124,
0.547366738319397,
-0.5846818685531616,
0.6044760346412659,
-0.057999029755592346,
-0.6509509682655334,
-0.5687296986579895,
0.374317467212677,
-0.3562796711921692,
0.1436881572008133,
0.8089338541030884,
0.8092535138130188,
0.28299400210380554,
0.005389672704041004,
0.3752099871635437,
0.3168918788433075,
0.2460418939590454,
0.4474438428878784,
1.068399429321289,
0.17577585577964783,
0.8348374962806702,
0.006078868638724089,
-0.14773327112197876,
-0.23587247729301453,
-0.8363836407661438,
-1.1042593717575073,
-0.726926326751709,
0.09444965422153473,
-0.641889750957489,
-0.23571954667568207,
0.5761063694953918,
0.47285541892051697,
-0.7273764610290527,
-0.5734940767288208,
-0.21815532445907593,
-0.08006399124860764,
0.3959101736545563,
-0.25044122338294983,
0.28444719314575195,
-0.40842205286026,
-0.3122238218784332,
0.1983509063720703,
-0.14205053448677063,
0.2557818591594696,
-0.6181629300117493,
-0.054109521210193634,
-0.27729108929634094,
0.15791667997837067,
0.29664933681488037,
0.42431098222732544,
-0.6683749556541443,
-0.08215907216072083,
-0.035979680716991425,
0.148405522108078,
-0.17783546447753906,
1.5611572265625,
-0.19552426040172577,
0.5648757219314575,
0.670867383480072,
0.5404061675071716,
0.7702797651290894,
-0.1897522360086441,
0.7008618116378784,
-0.643938422203064,
0.0030739677604287863,
0.5659459829330444,
0.4645446240901947,
0.3068965971469879,
-0.5090004205703735,
0.7296932935714722,
-0.08098844438791275,
-0.8072972893714905,
-1.0543153285980225,
0.4850179851055145,
-0.9169482588768005,
-0.49223536252975464,
1.4698097705841064,
-0.019672220572829247,
0.23387150466442108,
-0.0955539271235466,
-0.3146195411682129,
0.12492343783378601,
-0.330841600894928,
0.9147736430168152,
0.9211759567260742,
-0.5420042872428894,
-0.37853050231933594,
-0.9709077477455139,
0.7596768140792847,
0.41670435667037964,
-0.6581075191497803,
0.2875808775424957,
0.5669555068016052,
0.035323694348335266,
0.40304136276245117,
0.6112344264984131,
-0.09937398880720139,
0.10282719880342484,
-0.059069082140922546,
-0.3078494369983673,
0.076400987803936,
-0.07166047394275665,
-0.5307298302650452,
0.4118603467941284,
0.4548081159591675,
0.4636431038379669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15362v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15362v1
|
CoLLEGe: Concept Embedding Generation for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-22T17:26:05 | 2024-03-22T17:26:05 |
Ryan Teehan, Brenden Lake, Mengye Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current language models are unable to quickly learn new concepts on the fly,
often requiring a more involved finetuning process to learn robustly. Prompting
in-context is not robust to context distractions, and often fails to confer
much information about the new concepts. Classic methods for few-shot word
learning in NLP, relying on global word vectors, are less applicable to large
language models. In this paper, we introduce a novel approach named CoLLEGe
(Concept Learning with Language Embedding Generation) to modernize few-shot
concept learning. CoLLEGe is a meta-learning framework capable of generating
flexible embeddings for new concepts using a small number of example sentences
or definitions. Our primary meta-learning objective is simply to facilitate a
language model to make next word predictions in forthcoming sentences, making
it compatible with language model pretraining. We design a series of tasks to
test new concept learning in challenging real-world scenarios, including new
word acquisition, definition inference, and verbal reasoning, and demonstrate
that our method succeeds in each setting without task-specific training.
|
[
-0.30329591035842896,
-1.2634085416793823,
0.32706087827682495,
-0.22276932001113892,
-0.24219496548175812,
0.13003912568092346,
-0.0954994335770607,
-0.2094065397977829,
0.35457566380500793,
0.08450067043304443,
-0.6444616913795471,
-0.5804859399795532,
-0.45902949571609497,
0.18401919305324554,
-0.15957844257354736,
0.7213451266288757,
0.14976057410240173,
-0.2010122388601303,
-0.42808008193969727,
0.18283753097057343,
-0.6981271505355835,
-0.10505343228578568,
-0.6395813822746277,
-0.3532162010669708,
0.23887942731380463,
0.6102494597434998,
0.24264752864837646,
0.35930392146110535,
0.4294300079345703,
0.18444158136844635,
0.15968790650367737,
0.21202892065048218,
-0.5372303128242493,
0.0929972380399704,
0.08570442348718643,
-0.3813723623752594,
-0.21389712393283844,
0.015357929281890392,
0.6614627242088318,
0.8712975978851318,
-0.07641731947660446,
0.12072678655385971,
0.031975504010915756,
0.38655146956443787,
-1.1727840900421143,
0.2157498002052307,
-0.9511719942092896,
0.3596481382846832,
0.0579419769346714,
-0.17544497549533844,
-0.5757927894592285,
-0.12057694047689438,
0.470516175031662,
-0.645378053188324,
0.18429651856422424,
0.016859527677297592,
0.7315530776977539,
0.22749581933021545,
-0.21582810580730438,
-0.3053724467754364,
-0.528536856174469,
0.7048068642616272,
-0.44330790638923645,
0.3887552320957184,
0.4329424500465393,
0.30149105191230774,
-0.07125591486692429,
-0.8938618302345276,
-0.7310681343078613,
-0.1650770604610443,
0.00017792156722862273,
0.09871940314769745,
-0.1814369261264801,
-0.0811929926276207,
0.019677186384797096,
-0.15377812087535858,
-0.40264299511909485,
-0.059329625219106674,
-0.3018392026424408,
0.1970585435628891,
0.5309014916419983,
0.20080260932445526,
-0.0015723929973319173,
-0.25882768630981445,
-0.14087149500846863,
-0.062007803469896317,
-0.9611369967460632,
-0.092806875705719,
0.03017115592956543,
0.6191239356994629,
-0.02116440422832966,
0.6830923557281494,
-0.057525280863046646,
0.6433995366096497,
-0.008902125060558319,
-0.1513468623161316,
0.08775658160448074,
-0.12078126519918442,
-0.3963649868965149,
0.2101866453886032,
0.5689164996147156,
-0.0013281787978485227,
0.16527540981769562,
-0.17840281128883362,
0.08151181787252426,
0.15973350405693054,
0.27363550662994385,
-0.8339934945106506,
-0.2750181257724762,
0.14497438073158264,
-0.05895829200744629,
-0.3914085924625397,
0.10593393445014954,
-0.5396748185157776,
0.07465850561857224,
-0.06122072413563728,
0.5407503247261047,
-0.5937860012054443,
-0.18794479966163635,
0.12595060467720032,
-0.03682105988264084,
0.34662875533103943,
0.19522038102149963,
-1.0081011056900024,
-0.06816621124744415,
0.718049168586731,
0.98455411195755,
-0.29446306824684143,
-0.3124275803565979,
-0.506820023059845,
0.21490462124347687,
-0.4614493250846863,
0.7050530910491943,
-0.8643698692321777,
-0.5394502878189087,
0.2522200345993042,
-0.3189600706100464,
-0.019945645704865456,
-0.35000845789909363,
0.029365766793489456,
-0.3381279706954956,
0.0474667064845562,
0.07306379824876785,
-0.8938956260681152,
0.0641518160700798,
0.47191259264945984,
-0.37038174271583557,
0.7492617964744568,
0.044754501432180405,
-0.7688469290733337,
0.5858466625213623,
-0.8117958903312683,
-0.22726470232009888,
0.378558874130249,
-0.4861389696598053,
-0.2782793343067169,
0.19203045964241028,
-0.17564287781715393,
0.8729108572006226,
0.2888370454311371,
0.03356606885790825,
-0.3057393729686737,
-0.2509844899177551,
-0.03412102535367012,
0.052680954337120056,
0.3450169265270233,
0.17259329557418823,
-0.04569369554519653,
-0.25553181767463684,
-0.6575354933738708,
-0.04137587174773216,
0.199870765209198,
-0.24726028740406036,
-0.5904712080955505,
0.00040257448563352227,
-0.12484768033027649,
0.13240878283977509,
-0.053896449506282806,
-0.5439838171005249,
0.32356080412864685,
-0.5117914080619812,
0.2634614109992981,
0.3978734612464905,
0.009983103722333908,
0.6737973690032959,
-0.08420929312705994,
0.6179282665252686,
-0.03215068578720093,
-0.362932026386261,
-0.3483458459377289,
-0.5035916566848755,
-0.711998462677002,
-0.21095362305641174,
0.18552014231681824,
0.39661842584609985,
-0.709165632724762,
0.5242810249328613,
-0.1033489853143692,
-0.2572840452194214,
-0.4320920407772064,
0.20310288667678833,
0.06121979281306267,
0.3432406187057495,
0.4257306456565857,
-0.10441736876964569,
-0.6914538145065308,
-0.430700421333313,
-0.022221814841032028,
-0.0683215856552124,
0.12325870990753174,
0.11498303711414337,
0.7883018255233765,
-0.47184041142463684,
1.2965915203094482,
-1.0007996559143066,
-0.5352911353111267,
-0.7804751992225647,
0.24778172373771667,
-0.2878272831439972,
0.26436150074005127,
0.28899890184402466,
-0.4062369465827942,
-0.22032052278518677,
-0.26630228757858276,
-0.6583912968635559,
0.38296234607696533,
-0.1309574395418167,
0.013256022706627846,
0.07526807487010956,
0.8649508357048035,
-0.484481543302536,
0.32499733567237854,
0.45489948987960815,
-0.27391108870506287,
0.5192652940750122,
-0.012576453387737274,
-0.6530941128730774,
-1.4520039558410645,
-0.11974301189184189,
0.06810308992862701,
-0.1817590743303299,
-0.4392017424106598,
0.45789721608161926,
-0.23597292602062225,
-0.223972886800766,
-0.7124640345573425,
0.7121512293815613,
-0.2343960404396057,
0.24491700530052185,
-0.5858071446418762,
0.4836234152317047,
-0.09257259219884872,
0.04543960839509964,
0.46035489439964294,
0.33866646885871887,
0.48038721084594727,
-0.7681163549423218,
0.2008538842201233,
0.6577885746955872,
-0.4217071533203125,
0.414223313331604,
-0.44010740518569946,
-0.1099359393119812,
-0.33123698830604553,
0.5457456707954407,
-0.6443490982055664,
-0.07017359137535095,
-0.17731425166130066,
-0.40699949860572815,
0.20876070857048035,
0.17109590768814087,
-0.07348667085170746,
-0.33482998609542847,
-0.20266936719417572,
0.22164572775363922,
0.2039586305618286,
-0.3626035451889038,
0.37693655490875244,
0.31927239894866943,
0.05721143260598183,
-0.6463786363601685,
-0.7857351303100586,
-0.06097998470067978,
-0.03139932081103325,
-0.357637494802475,
0.3379620909690857,
0.11864172667264938,
-0.20924679934978485,
0.04412603750824928,
0.1406465321779251,
-0.11586001515388489,
0.18134622275829315,
0.119510717689991,
0.26425597071647644,
-0.23792511224746704,
0.560482382774353,
-0.0739409551024437,
-0.18582317233085632,
-0.015416998416185379,
-0.25554946064949036,
0.5688638091087341,
-0.04799018055200577,
-0.057071007788181305,
-0.35306280851364136,
0.38941895961761475,
0.027399199083447456,
-0.2808007299900055,
0.8382275700569153,
0.8072572946548462,
-0.6233267784118652,
-0.68476802110672,
-0.10809148848056793,
-0.5853092670440674,
-0.42663994431495667,
0.6073770523071289,
-0.5195438861846924,
-1.213662028312683,
-0.1478458195924759,
-0.437798410654068,
0.42052504420280457,
0.2707224190235138,
0.4352746605873108,
-0.24355876445770264,
0.4806731045246124,
1.172356128692627,
0.31910020112991333,
0.45101311802864075,
-0.8046277165412903,
0.5238251686096191,
-0.658661961555481,
-0.21192459762096405,
-0.35292065143585205,
-0.41440892219543457,
-0.4804753363132477,
-0.5124405026435852,
0.13703303039073944,
0.2517842948436737,
-0.10044164955615997,
0.41248247027397156,
-0.10059205442667007,
0.7009940147399902,
0.3931002914905548,
-0.10462945699691772,
0.26878395676612854,
-0.015246568247675896,
-0.4721541404724121,
0.009268708527088165,
-0.7322340607643127,
-0.4989027678966522,
1.1560842990875244,
0.11260692030191422,
0.7307907938957214,
-0.02713438868522644,
1.12490975856781,
-0.12943989038467407,
0.18885187804698944,
-1.2293009757995605,
0.39607325196266174,
-0.3769785165786743,
-0.5264223217964172,
-0.36760714650154114,
-0.26597028970718384,
-0.8915078639984131,
0.0808870866894722,
-0.8308263421058655,
-0.7152970433235168,
0.07523726671934128,
0.1605977565050125,
-0.7712541818618774,
0.29477548599243164,
-0.41305673122406006,
0.8107752203941345,
0.3652518689632416,
-0.26279085874557495,
-0.31605085730552673,
-0.4155873954296112,
0.5595956444740295,
-0.3027785122394562,
0.017214583232998848,
0.010172229260206223,
0.07683690637350082,
0.4410868287086487,
-0.1665249764919281,
0.9540725350379944,
0.09742209315299988,
-0.03884011134505272,
0.4273008108139038,
0.34716030955314636,
0.36171889305114746,
0.05963015928864479,
0.04283874109387398,
-0.2527323365211487,
-0.024089209735393524,
-0.0560661144554615,
-0.4029175937175751,
0.46784013509750366,
-0.6172560453414917,
-0.35523250699043274,
-0.3176695704460144,
-0.4735041856765747,
-0.22373951971530914,
-0.14881397783756256,
0.4496939778327942,
0.08721694350242615,
-0.7513951659202576,
0.4938898980617523,
0.5413480401039124,
-0.19041293859481812,
0.7144526243209839,
0.31860634684562683,
-0.1980610340833664,
-0.024366838857531548,
0.8370814919471741,
0.03014076128602028,
0.26409852504730225,
0.6669567823410034,
0.4071292579174042,
-0.35935288667678833,
-0.21026763319969177,
-0.06846827268600464,
0.08997569978237152,
-0.4958890676498413,
-0.18616479635238647,
-0.8785276412963867,
-0.20959512889385223,
-0.5189224481582642,
-0.4867859482765198,
-0.5311787724494934,
-0.4291367828845978,
-0.2720184028148651,
-0.32273510098457336,
-0.00956008117645979,
0.7872998714447021,
-0.01351243257522583,
0.7503116726875305,
-0.6542052626609802,
0.26646775007247925,
0.6644287109375,
-0.14771342277526855,
-0.026196954771876335,
-0.37584641575813293,
-0.29467591643333435,
-0.10344275832176208,
-0.8962618112564087,
-0.5569682121276855,
0.23351901769638062,
0.8246741890907288,
0.31564491987228394,
0.8408117890357971,
-0.001623185584321618,
0.6489109396934509,
-0.8205904364585876,
0.7130749225616455,
0.3781616687774658,
-1.1120542287826538,
0.8928748965263367,
0.059037573635578156,
0.34673815965652466,
0.6231026649475098,
0.6654477715492249,
-0.5794476866722107,
-0.3497427999973297,
-0.8360201120376587,
-0.7337393760681152,
0.2879238724708557,
-0.14635902643203735,
0.6304115056991577,
-0.36393266916275024,
0.45837923884391785,
0.12378617376089096,
0.15555977821350098,
-0.7172225713729858,
-0.18521717190742493,
-0.1245175153017044,
-0.0850200355052948,
-0.26554572582244873,
-0.05141349881887436,
0.09601989388465881,
-0.43341782689094543,
0.6059463024139404,
-0.48573368787765503,
0.24587728083133698,
-0.09733109176158905,
-0.2744959592819214,
-0.04314868524670601,
0.22979629039764404,
0.6209624409675598,
0.6122650504112244,
-0.17791865766048431,
0.1327105611562729,
0.42032742500305176,
-0.4763873815536499,
0.18189182877540588,
-0.4383372664451599,
-0.20299458503723145,
0.33403733372688293,
0.48408013582229614,
0.7682545185089111,
0.26489001512527466,
-0.47989004850387573,
0.8336315751075745,
0.09660280495882034,
-0.373374342918396,
-0.3374333381652832,
0.22234073281288147,
0.29026147723197937,
0.0542767308652401,
0.3160269856452942,
-0.1886097639799118,
-0.19439169764518738,
-0.8022163510322571,
0.7033129930496216,
0.6891512274742126,
-0.32703542709350586,
-0.22504915297031403,
0.5195969343185425,
0.3006240427494049,
-0.17439289391040802,
0.4998951852321625,
-0.4901100695133209,
-0.188188374042511,
0.34313735365867615,
1.0171009302139282,
0.9957169890403748,
-0.3400060534477234,
0.6665816903114319,
0.692213237285614,
0.10795091837644577,
-0.16335919499397278,
0.0644327700138092,
0.08491358160972595,
-1.1207826137542725,
-0.561251163482666,
-0.9441110491752625,
-0.4628198742866516,
0.19552727043628693,
-0.30070242285728455,
0.6524572372436523,
-0.632709264755249,
-0.19912053644657135,
-0.14539380371570587,
0.04522709548473358,
-0.6648585796356201,
0.18820378184318542,
0.2472706139087677,
1.0242304801940918,
-1.0759222507476807,
0.9631590843200684,
0.7751877307891846,
-0.29113271832466125,
-0.7748845815658569,
0.12326759099960327,
0.03408334404230118,
-0.6302208304405212,
0.890485405921936,
0.40737971663475037,
-0.13476118445396423,
0.4211996793746948,
-0.5095622539520264,
-0.5448906421661377,
1.176759958267212,
0.20751212537288666,
-0.730394184589386,
-0.4918091893196106,
0.02486182376742363,
0.2282640039920807,
-0.9304786324501038,
0.13767462968826294,
0.535840630531311,
0.13368748128414154,
0.4803362190723419,
-0.3047390878200531,
-0.2700584828853607,
0.3414989411830902,
-0.11969238519668579,
-0.018991170451045036,
-0.22801631689071655,
0.7595824599266052,
-0.6158919930458069,
-0.197001650929451,
-0.10184375941753387,
0.8766798973083496,
0.38088297843933105,
0.17795561254024506,
0.4179895222187042,
0.8386258482933044,
0.8052747845649719,
-0.09467646479606628,
0.6432276964187622,
0.01777368225157261,
0.463518351316452,
1.3027827739715576,
-0.17420487105846405,
1.4437015056610107,
0.43654707074165344,
-0.017484020441770554,
0.6835438013076782,
0.5604178309440613,
0.056882016360759735,
0.6182295083999634,
0.4199729263782501,
-0.4789731502532959,
-0.48412537574768066,
-0.12359116226434708,
-0.33279091119766235,
1.0601729154586792,
0.516862690448761,
-0.1504596471786499,
-0.44186845421791077,
0.21545641124248505,
-0.09363863617181778,
-0.021756688132882118,
-0.05945051088929176,
0.9122792482376099,
0.4632152020931244,
-0.199410542845726,
0.36142680048942566,
0.01160269882529974,
0.9843854308128357,
-0.6639785170555115,
-0.12336365878582001,
-0.1321837157011032,
0.11581338942050934,
-0.13880056142807007,
-0.14115211367607117,
0.4191058278083801,
-0.013145583681762218,
0.18263162672519684,
-0.04911312833428383,
0.304638147354126,
-0.6464879512786865,
-0.7117118835449219,
0.12064933776855469,
0.7935088276863098,
0.1009909138083458,
0.17192107439041138,
-0.6193082332611084,
-0.2638412415981293,
-0.40773212909698486,
0.04773266986012459,
0.05196768045425415,
0.4531674385070801,
0.1754201203584671,
0.7038031220436096,
0.35875433683395386,
0.3086676597595215,
0.04762200638651848,
-0.06037023290991783,
0.4366585612297058,
-0.5006611347198486,
-0.6177346110343933,
-0.9028329253196716,
0.28999432921409607,
0.2972151041030884,
-0.3959083557128906,
0.3847741484642029,
0.47574496269226074,
1.1835612058639526,
-0.1682344377040863,
0.7560998797416687,
-0.1558021456003189,
0.007611848879605532,
-0.4974680542945862,
0.6570761799812317,
-0.6299493908882141,
-0.08363274484872818,
-0.5101298689842224,
-1.0765962600708008,
-0.4895978569984436,
0.983451247215271,
-0.07464640587568283,
-0.19152063131332397,
1.13944673538208,
0.6549727320671082,
-0.055661920458078384,
0.0947212502360344,
0.5904498100280762,
0.022442491725087166,
0.18744738399982452,
0.5433501601219177,
0.6933896541595459,
-0.30550357699394226,
0.27431127429008484,
-0.11219468712806702,
0.012280819937586784,
-0.3517424464225769,
-1.007603645324707,
-0.9547065496444702,
-0.6212610602378845,
-0.48704931139945984,
-0.10692937672138214,
-0.08669785410165787,
1.4511468410491943,
0.7765743732452393,
-0.795785665512085,
-0.15377986431121826,
-0.29633447527885437,
0.006697363685816526,
-0.15919670462608337,
-0.21440647542476654,
0.38412296772003174,
-0.8157321810722351,
-0.8135172724723816,
0.480258047580719,
-0.006281906273216009,
0.14552530646324158,
-0.3576276898384094,
-0.0647970512509346,
-0.5272300243377686,
-0.019206475466489792,
0.9429358839988708,
0.11884411424398422,
-0.5270686745643616,
-0.3859689235687256,
-0.14808109402656555,
0.0376078262925148,
-0.14123700559139252,
0.9908794164657593,
-1.0043340921401978,
0.26988813281059265,
0.42017120122909546,
0.9836130738258362,
0.21695958077907562,
-0.23991736769676208,
0.497280091047287,
-1.2204761505126953,
0.2586653232574463,
0.18218886852264404,
0.25210830569267273,
0.12842421233654022,
-0.15374332666397095,
0.28775012493133545,
0.4680822491645813,
-0.01233695074915886,
-0.584433376789093,
0.3977791666984558,
-0.605781078338623,
-0.5611831545829773,
0.8970407247543335,
-0.11197936534881592,
-0.05374722182750702,
0.04232921451330185,
0.23097585141658783,
0.2946999669075012,
-0.16105444729328156,
0.8262476921081543,
0.7400152087211609,
0.003175431163981557,
-0.16307644546031952,
-0.6597071290016174,
0.6477993130683899,
0.24068042635917664,
-0.8813269734382629,
-0.08088473975658417,
0.288330614566803,
0.15803416073322296,
0.36800527572631836,
0.3914276361465454,
0.27914151549339294,
0.15597385168075562,
-0.10470258444547653,
0.04308503121137619,
-0.030861511826515198,
-0.7557476162910461,
-0.09664111584424973,
0.24596041440963745,
-0.05936361849308014,
-0.364260196685791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07220v1
|
Blended RAG: Improving RAG (Retriever-Augmented Generation) Accuracy with Semantic Search and Hybrid Query-Based Retrievers
| 2024-03-22T17:13:46 | 2024-03-22T17:13:46 |
Kunal Sawarkar, Abhilasha Mangal, Shivam Raj Solanki
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is a prevalent approach to infuse a
private knowledge base of documents with Large Language Models (LLM) to build
Generative Q\&A (Question-Answering) systems. However, RAG accuracy becomes
increasingly challenging as the corpus of documents scales up, with Retrievers
playing an outsized role in the overall RAG accuracy by extracting the most
relevant document from the corpus to provide context to the LLM. In this paper,
we propose the 'Blended RAG' method of leveraging semantic search techniques,
such as Dense Vector indexes and Sparse Encoder indexes, blended with hybrid
query strategies. Our study achieves better retrieval results and sets new
benchmarks for IR (Information Retrieval) datasets like NQ and TREC-COVID
datasets. We further extend such a 'Blended Retriever' to the RAG system to
demonstrate far superior results on Generative Q\&A datasets like SQUAD, even
surpassing fine-tuning performance.
|
[
-0.43046650290489197,
-0.6574041843414307,
0.13204465806484222,
-0.04049065709114075,
-0.15119528770446777,
0.8541257381439209,
-0.008993896655738354,
-0.3853432536125183,
0.5258923768997192,
0.5974811315536499,
-0.47536975145339966,
-0.234643816947937,
-0.49463218450546265,
0.09875181317329407,
-0.617276668548584,
1.0460388660430908,
0.2729485332965851,
0.08856993913650513,
-0.3739114999771118,
-0.41949838399887085,
-0.4855826199054718,
-0.2424289584159851,
-0.612682580947876,
-0.34284499287605286,
0.4185653626918793,
0.2730991244316101,
0.8885330557823181,
0.31276270747184753,
0.48795226216316223,
0.26933497190475464,
-0.1655500829219818,
0.8896439075469971,
-0.8163995742797852,
0.6345151662826538,
-0.3022461235523224,
-0.4706490635871887,
-0.32904261350631714,
-0.1137445718050003,
0.4521852433681488,
0.21861004829406738,
-0.2019924372434616,
0.1314808428287506,
0.0009590047411620617,
0.7876242399215698,
-0.9056761860847473,
-0.32637840509414673,
-0.8345707058906555,
-0.04379243031144142,
-0.29096946120262146,
-0.5494949221611023,
-0.34039199352264404,
-0.19438724219799042,
-0.05704263597726822,
-0.8655612468719482,
0.6297996044158936,
0.25637826323509216,
0.9828507900238037,
0.1572713851928711,
-0.37289828062057495,
-0.23467083275318146,
-0.8762805461883545,
0.8001267910003662,
-0.2648322582244873,
0.37600207328796387,
0.372244268655777,
0.5160033106803894,
-0.4989445209503174,
-0.6318429708480835,
-0.6660298705101013,
-0.1048257052898407,
-0.11941778659820557,
0.43365880846977234,
0.14978095889091492,
-0.23765964806079865,
-0.02444896101951599,
0.6960565447807312,
-0.5877329707145691,
-0.19714535772800446,
-0.1163015067577362,
-0.047903869301080704,
0.7320493459701538,
0.2783345580101013,
0.3637584447860718,
-0.12229402363300323,
-0.4497678875923157,
-0.4270959198474884,
-0.37043508887290955,
-0.25025221705436707,
0.04737764224410057,
0.007046824786812067,
0.12779681384563446,
0.9012460112571716,
-0.4328380823135376,
0.8169841170310974,
0.3685496747493744,
-0.33989086747169495,
-0.0164240300655365,
-0.5237081050872803,
0.10497837513685226,
-0.3435681462287903,
0.44667941331863403,
0.28215017914772034,
-0.13591866195201874,
-0.3975619375705719,
-0.47301149368286133,
0.07231324166059494,
0.37613245844841003,
-0.4500243663787842,
-0.007816090248525143,
0.09981568157672882,
-0.23211263120174408,
-0.2103900909423828,
0.11792746931314468,
-0.9785512685775757,
-0.5769832730293274,
-0.30274689197540283,
0.6633813381195068,
-0.5028056502342224,
-0.38618624210357666,
0.02936391532421112,
-0.6164724230766296,
0.8642645478248596,
0.2885977327823639,
-0.39270448684692383,
0.49802786111831665,
0.904897928237915,
0.5340079665184021,
-0.30660849809646606,
0.18761798739433289,
-0.8239223957061768,
0.25312721729278564,
-0.34468939900398254,
0.9045857787132263,
-0.6192322373390198,
-0.702587366104126,
-0.08034815639257431,
-0.5863831639289856,
-0.16050899028778076,
-0.8923562169075012,
0.5800140500068665,
-0.9781624674797058,
0.3607032895088196,
0.02332712523639202,
-0.665584921836853,
0.0014469648012891412,
0.44618335366249084,
-0.5797919034957886,
1.5261030197143555,
0.3939780294895172,
-0.7463019490242004,
0.34508416056632996,
-0.38998159766197205,
-0.36515864729881287,
0.366410493850708,
-0.2580200433731079,
-0.3249587416648865,
0.0960758626461029,
0.3722444772720337,
0.2214864194393158,
-0.64717698097229,
0.2374507188796997,
-0.00013307227345649153,
-0.2847607135772705,
0.3423357307910919,
0.07962121814489365,
0.5700835585594177,
0.2816813290119171,
-0.10359799116849899,
-0.05121314898133278,
-0.6612630486488342,
0.18697477877140045,
0.17797426879405975,
-0.20300865173339844,
-0.667219340801239,
-0.1326638162136078,
0.1716422587633133,
-0.054279886186122894,
0.3217216730117798,
-0.6138231754302979,
-0.24792957305908203,
-0.4260440766811371,
-0.19771093130111694,
0.21310484409332275,
0.009012161754071712,
0.6408647894859314,
-0.7527021169662476,
0.6312733292579651,
-0.10589969903230667,
0.018164923414587975,
0.20538069307804108,
-0.5284496545791626,
-0.9108485579490662,
-0.4317992925643921,
0.47358614206314087,
0.6666446328163147,
-1.2101428508758545,
0.4745948612689972,
-0.35313132405281067,
-0.5605774521827698,
-0.6834157109260559,
-0.010083699598908424,
0.42352813482284546,
0.6282495260238647,
0.44299206137657166,
-0.3099762797355652,
-0.47249653935432434,
-0.5661464333534241,
-0.4330582618713379,
0.11394459009170532,
-0.15642449259757996,
0.646331250667572,
0.20878872275352478,
-0.34201306104660034,
1.2087578773498535,
-0.506626307964325,
-0.24290578067302704,
-0.33448007702827454,
0.22872719168663025,
-0.02631843462586403,
0.4403923749923706,
-0.008264156058430672,
-1.3752199411392212,
-0.5584712624549866,
0.2208808809518814,
-0.49213048815727234,
0.12395963072776794,
0.28632181882858276,
-0.4154621660709381,
0.11032387614250183,
0.39135754108428955,
-0.36960646510124207,
0.35915520787239075,
0.34800630807876587,
-0.24872048199176788,
0.2713947594165802,
-0.3461630344390869,
0.2737818658351898,
-1.3601261377334595,
0.11894360184669495,
-0.2839090824127197,
-0.3382796347141266,
-0.4350617825984955,
0.46532976627349854,
0.08039315044879913,
-0.2781359553337097,
-0.11433425545692444,
0.7585357427597046,
-0.4066624641418457,
-0.06733597815036774,
-0.23187895119190216,
0.013783356174826622,
0.32413366436958313,
0.11876331269741058,
-0.31013575196266174,
1.1148929595947266,
0.1944325715303421,
-0.5613548755645752,
0.32039621472358704,
0.3423919379711151,
-0.05054992437362671,
0.7443038821220398,
-0.5326932072639465,
0.26303279399871826,
-0.5024006962776184,
0.3233037292957306,
-0.8307613134384155,
-0.38426870107650757,
-0.06738511472940445,
-0.48442164063453674,
0.6746106147766113,
0.030787082388997078,
-0.4563766419887543,
-0.05460980534553528,
-0.4131211042404175,
0.52288419008255,
0.6518844962120056,
-0.5382215976715088,
0.9607243537902832,
0.5628536939620972,
0.08184421062469482,
-0.7387882471084595,
-0.20859767496585846,
0.06528227031230927,
-0.21153394877910614,
-0.8672615885734558,
0.7953928112983704,
0.05288063734769821,
-0.19774705171585083,
0.1935695856809616,
-0.28523221611976624,
-0.33668965101242065,
-0.07885542511940002,
-0.1869015097618103,
0.42041075229644775,
-0.32490020990371704,
-0.09213574975728989,
-0.05446474626660347,
-0.17448025941848755,
-0.5330038666725159,
0.047315679490566254,
0.5895983576774597,
0.07631891965866089,
-0.10798966139554977,
0.3271772265434265,
0.5962474942207336,
0.4380027651786804,
-0.7147606015205383,
0.7915263772010803,
0.5955015420913696,
-0.11195176094770432,
-0.3238990902900696,
-0.9758036136627197,
-0.16537873446941376,
-0.46482738852500916,
0.02020716853439808,
-0.30545446276664734,
-1.2163846492767334,
0.5089114904403687,
-0.15620942413806915,
-0.1600608378648758,
0.600765585899353,
0.3207046091556549,
-0.2059219777584076,
0.8576927781105042,
0.5577356815338135,
0.041392743587493896,
0.36710667610168457,
-0.39565688371658325,
0.10476326197385788,
-1.1293370723724365,
-0.41730761528015137,
-0.681556761264801,
-0.2645418047904968,
-1.0351362228393555,
-0.8981792330741882,
0.8270841836929321,
-0.031859997659921646,
0.039962995797395706,
0.10996201634407043,
-0.5175018906593323,
0.47211405634880066,
0.5065587759017944,
0.31424784660339355,
0.28275129199028015,
-0.03252258151769638,
-0.08380544930696487,
0.14001905918121338,
-0.8992184400558472,
0.05998227745294571,
0.9719319939613342,
-0.14491143822669983,
0.8878428339958191,
-0.02245834469795227,
0.9346817135810852,
0.22214899957180023,
0.0020788568072021008,
-0.6250118613243103,
0.45307594537734985,
-0.4097338616847992,
-0.7396601438522339,
-0.18253129720687866,
-0.4896872341632843,
-1.0714287757873535,
0.38030481338500977,
-0.5314027070999146,
-0.04411599040031433,
0.37542733550071716,
-0.10223124176263809,
-0.2720053791999817,
-0.11970119923353195,
-0.39816296100616455,
0.43298038840293884,
0.021266838535666466,
-0.3225894868373871,
-0.3021668493747711,
-0.6327153444290161,
0.3361152708530426,
0.010902165435254574,
0.019751161336898804,
-0.13411790132522583,
-0.3783455789089203,
0.5030520558357239,
-0.37293919920921326,
0.16282157599925995,
0.1923377513885498,
0.2745782136917114,
0.30906903743743896,
0.08042676001787186,
0.6372092962265015,
-0.08445592224597931,
-0.13096478581428528,
-0.2628288269042969,
-0.13666221499443054,
-0.45908430218696594,
-0.7333664894104004,
0.5798022150993347,
-0.5625169277191162,
-0.47821223735809326,
-0.5019217729568481,
-0.6950927376747131,
-0.3755413591861725,
0.03566759452223778,
0.4079151153564453,
0.7044329643249512,
-0.15940764546394348,
0.3630090653896332,
1.1219396591186523,
-0.3024497926235199,
-0.032422155141830444,
0.5026881098747253,
-0.017933638766407967,
-0.475318968296051,
1.1106370687484741,
0.04575046896934509,
0.12474651634693146,
0.725234866142273,
0.23119300603866577,
-0.3491882085800171,
-0.3441035747528076,
-0.3891323506832123,
0.24421988427639008,
-0.2030039280653,
-0.5755007266998291,
-0.6064811944961548,
-0.4957221448421478,
-0.29089415073394775,
-0.14669401943683624,
-0.2697126865386963,
-0.37068864703178406,
-0.02070564776659012,
0.49447524547576904,
0.5376254320144653,
0.48445481061935425,
0.19057802855968475,
0.02708267793059349,
-0.7543668746948242,
0.8046424984931946,
0.296034038066864,
0.33350399136543274,
-0.3569552004337311,
-0.4746742844581604,
-0.1743088662624359,
-0.03817010298371315,
-0.12787224352359772,
-0.6751675605773926,
0.4607098698616028,
0.3626055121421814,
0.46585214138031006,
-0.2795768082141876,
0.2569897174835205,
0.8796500563621521,
-0.3521101474761963,
0.5043926239013672,
-0.18661156296730042,
-0.42520707845687866,
0.5058500170707703,
-0.49959081411361694,
0.16368897259235382,
0.7270477414131165,
0.15802882611751556,
-0.3538646399974823,
-0.5917603969573975,
-0.6887559294700623,
-1.0028774738311768,
0.4972876310348511,
0.2675706744194031,
-0.033191435039043427,
0.06980051845312119,
0.2741478681564331,
0.002997784176841378,
0.05319927632808685,
0.03910306841135025,
-0.24300597608089447,
0.13356995582580566,
-0.27944543957710266,
0.03337572515010834,
-0.33330291509628296,
-0.12684983015060425,
-0.14895211160182953,
0.709888219833374,
-0.05277639627456665,
0.21138940751552582,
0.38120895624160767,
-0.009396194480359554,
-0.10245013982057571,
0.1806766390800476,
0.2382775843143463,
0.43745124340057373,
-0.17625412344932556,
-0.17950224876403809,
0.034947436302900314,
-0.4896892011165619,
0.12137585133314133,
0.24563364684581757,
-0.33373719453811646,
0.11506014317274094,
-0.05877886712551117,
0.3736160695552826,
0.24554617702960968,
-0.7659000754356384,
0.3615680932998657,
-0.2098488062620163,
0.16057506203651428,
-0.27080732583999634,
0.31731733679771423,
-0.12899188697338104,
0.19251306354999542,
0.44789865612983704,
0.058042239397764206,
0.4863308072090149,
-0.3359296917915344,
0.24298317730426788,
0.7960677742958069,
0.06632078438997269,
0.2905760109424591,
0.5521934628486633,
0.172664612531662,
-0.1932881772518158,
0.46949800848960876,
-0.14855042099952698,
-0.37488090991973877,
0.48669862747192383,
0.4605746269226074,
0.9401292204856873,
-0.1557569056749344,
0.21594396233558655,
0.11491218209266663,
0.03341033682227135,
-0.15186837315559387,
0.30611851811408997,
-0.20068027079105377,
-0.7500271797180176,
-0.6504409313201904,
-0.8465231657028198,
-0.5827944278717041,
-0.03164640814065933,
-0.8124451637268066,
0.1421826332807541,
-0.05050830543041229,
-0.012135249562561512,
-0.11451774835586548,
0.1878451108932495,
-0.5956128835678101,
0.2337033450603485,
-0.16077345609664917,
0.9368369579315186,
-0.28860482573509216,
0.560723066329956,
0.7227481603622437,
-0.18703190982341766,
-0.7778856158256531,
0.09424923360347748,
-0.3239070773124695,
-0.7819355726242065,
0.44655680656433105,
-0.18268610537052155,
-0.2811315655708313,
0.03861026465892792,
-0.2756322920322418,
-0.9367883205413818,
1.0656042098999023,
0.25904586911201477,
-0.12818369269371033,
0.06966645270586014,
0.10927165299654007,
0.5022671818733215,
-0.2608482539653778,
0.18409080803394318,
0.5386672019958496,
0.12320121377706528,
0.5511108636856079,
-0.9252453446388245,
-0.3521042764186859,
-0.2704918682575226,
0.2886669337749481,
0.572070837020874,
-0.5767561197280884,
0.5886690020561218,
0.21820959448814392,
-0.19233684241771698,
0.16384825110435486,
0.8017887473106384,
0.3096790015697479,
0.6406044363975525,
0.31734755635261536,
0.755267322063446,
0.7680178284645081,
-0.03910933807492256,
1.3641588687896729,
-0.14206533133983612,
0.032708413898944855,
1.0723925828933716,
-0.3143058717250824,
0.9712702631950378,
0.25382062792778015,
0.07428384572267532,
0.5082672238349915,
0.17731572687625885,
0.3531237840652466,
0.38537466526031494,
0.0004318278224673122,
-0.7462174892425537,
-0.12579765915870667,
-0.4235524833202362,
-0.28172218799591064,
0.5806836485862732,
0.5078047513961792,
0.09584970772266388,
-0.3545321524143219,
-0.17603640258312225,
-0.10185196995735168,
0.3952276408672333,
-0.2941829264163971,
1.1794315576553345,
-0.13797543942928314,
-0.7640993595123291,
0.5698862671852112,
0.057932473719120026,
0.8753688931465149,
-0.5598394870758057,
-0.07952051609754562,
-0.4722050726413727,
-0.05531181022524834,
-0.10904495418071747,
-0.6437861919403076,
0.4514150321483612,
0.06404165923595428,
-0.28401434421539307,
-0.13920274376869202,
1.2570022344589233,
-0.5998019576072693,
-0.5293418765068054,
0.10664106905460358,
0.8151431679725647,
-0.19663405418395996,
0.05645521730184555,
-0.6510633230209351,
-0.16013723611831665,
-0.3476940393447876,
0.06338305026292801,
0.4905160069465637,
0.5449704527854919,
0.01748921535909176,
0.4535607397556305,
0.6062391996383667,
0.006362669635564089,
0.36901816725730896,
-0.25909367203712463,
1.061431646347046,
-0.5836114287376404,
-0.40282300114631653,
-0.32550862431526184,
0.43559637665748596,
-0.3448784053325653,
-0.13074976205825806,
0.7027782201766968,
0.7787395119667053,
0.871208906173706,
0.0873752310872078,
0.4837592542171478,
-0.2407987266778946,
1.0603402853012085,
-0.34904518723487854,
0.6781343817710876,
-0.6203114986419678,
-0.07603252679109573,
0.07390210777521133,
-0.8949165344238281,
-0.051077183336019516,
0.4595615565776825,
0.1040324866771698,
-0.011418919079005718,
0.24367469549179077,
1.2091381549835205,
-0.1576135903596878,
-0.10096465796232224,
0.306893527507782,
-0.11036277562379837,
0.03336462378501892,
0.021118681877851486,
0.8426439762115479,
-0.5522180795669556,
0.32896897196769714,
-0.24613724648952484,
-0.1583547592163086,
-0.3339756727218628,
-0.6385292410850525,
-0.5394487977027893,
-0.5697261691093445,
-0.1753963679075241,
-0.5634511709213257,
0.22875744104385376,
0.740881621837616,
0.45064055919647217,
-0.6823886632919312,
-0.25713977217674255,
0.027110707014799118,
0.10216681659221649,
-0.1029345691204071,
-0.2576411962509155,
0.10992123931646347,
-0.6506072878837585,
-0.6185373067855835,
0.61134934425354,
0.30173707008361816,
-0.18919773399829865,
-0.1078939363360405,
-0.11707363277673721,
-0.308453768491745,
0.16638393700122833,
0.6293380856513977,
0.21680240333080292,
-0.4623052775859833,
-0.0065557449124753475,
0.2699795365333557,
-0.2479676753282547,
0.011415157467126846,
0.8376246690750122,
-1.0607445240020752,
0.7432770729064941,
0.6651118993759155,
1.1785942316055298,
0.7209374904632568,
0.09406446665525436,
0.6586142182350159,
-0.8027610778808594,
-0.016147911548614502,
0.6926203966140747,
-0.0936271995306015,
0.48792120814323425,
-0.4216339588165283,
0.7629747986793518,
0.13675622642040253,
-0.5923193693161011,
-0.6881871819496155,
-0.07456320524215698,
-1.0001639127731323,
0.07548984885215759,
1.0825974941253662,
0.39638134837150574,
-0.24044036865234375,
-0.3251252770423889,
-0.31315377354621887,
0.334746390581131,
-0.31251466274261475,
0.5075888633728027,
0.2666044235229492,
-0.21219326555728912,
0.22736792266368866,
-0.5306092500686646,
0.5319815874099731,
0.5831443667411804,
-0.5941731929779053,
-0.3831544518470764,
0.48204153776168823,
0.07134273648262024,
0.12396254390478134,
0.5525067448616028,
-0.28835543990135193,
0.32643961906433105,
-0.05525214970111847,
-0.3135855793952942,
0.15738625824451447,
-0.19246624410152435,
-0.034493338316679,
0.19325965642929077,
-0.0025323289446532726,
-0.12996259331703186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15351v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15351v2
|
Multi-Review Fusion-in-Context
| 2024-03-22T17:06:05 | 2024-03-31T23:23:46 |
Aviv Slobodkin, Ori Shapira, Ran Levy, Ido Dagan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Grounded text generation, encompassing tasks such as long-form
question-answering and summarization, necessitates both content selection and
content consolidation. Current end-to-end methods are difficult to control and
interpret due to their opaqueness. Accordingly, recent works have proposed a
modular approach, with separate components for each step. Specifically, we
focus on the second subtask, of generating coherent text given pre-selected
content in a multi-document setting. Concretely, we formalize Fusion-in-Context
(FiC) as a standalone task, whose input consists of source texts with
highlighted spans of targeted content. A model then needs to generate a
coherent passage that includes all and only the target information. Our work
includes the development of a curated dataset of 1000 instances in the reviews
domain, alongside a novel evaluation framework for assessing the faithfulness
and coverage of highlights, which strongly correlate to human judgment. Several
baseline models exhibit promising outcomes and provide insightful analyses.
This study lays the groundwork for further exploration of modular text
generation in the multi-document setting, offering potential improvements in
the quality and reliability of generated content. Our benchmark, FuseReviews,
including the dataset, evaluation framework, and designated leaderboard, can be
found at https://fusereviews.github.io/.
|
[
-0.7488558888435364,
-0.6895633339881897,
0.478411465883255,
0.10694118589162827,
-0.4685714840888977,
0.0794370248913765,
-0.1690569669008255,
-0.19812119007110596,
0.3459685146808624,
0.4632815420627594,
-0.8638420701026917,
-0.3901320695877075,
-0.29373589158058167,
0.34486111998558044,
-0.7168774008750916,
1.4191993474960327,
-0.09646377712488174,
-0.2072780430316925,
-0.5757127404212952,
-0.12982463836669922,
-0.6026301383972168,
-0.10190907120704651,
0.11044719070196152,
-0.4600848853588104,
0.49254804849624634,
0.5217145085334778,
0.4672946035861969,
0.08512047678232193,
0.35845819115638733,
0.21456976234912872,
-0.04964683949947357,
0.6111673712730408,
-0.781572163105011,
0.5360899567604065,
-0.3092131018638611,
0.24920101463794708,
-0.30753371119499207,
0.049158621579408646,
0.7469905018806458,
0.44810646772384644,
0.1338331401348114,
0.08335980027914047,
0.2731599509716034,
0.720150887966156,
-0.7583043575286865,
-0.07358517497777939,
-0.4570872187614441,
-0.22955669462680817,
-0.10755189508199692,
0.0641520619392395,
-0.570431649684906,
-0.18596820533275604,
0.21316677331924438,
-0.5156018137931824,
0.15369708836078644,
0.018826790153980255,
0.7916938662528992,
-0.13924919068813324,
-0.8170182108879089,
-0.20396815240383148,
-0.6853653192520142,
0.7156417369842529,
-0.324827641248703,
0.20467883348464966,
0.2004920244216919,
0.17819646000862122,
-0.03810794651508331,
-0.6569157242774963,
-0.6263408064842224,
0.29505932331085205,
-0.31894972920417786,
0.7023237347602844,
0.1458357870578766,
-0.07820221781730652,
-0.1703113615512848,
0.833573579788208,
-0.48190733790397644,
-0.3375629186630249,
-0.5193171501159668,
-0.26051706075668335,
0.7975906729698181,
0.1988418698310852,
0.08121991902589798,
-0.5135042667388916,
-0.4466892182826996,
-0.1749076098203659,
-0.5692712068557739,
-0.11789288371801376,
0.345520943403244,
-0.11725333333015442,
0.024057473987340927,
0.8226823806762695,
-0.6229652762413025,
0.47810378670692444,
0.23128433525562286,
-0.16239795088768005,
0.15913967788219452,
-1.245102047920227,
-0.1348242610692978,
-0.1479768455028534,
0.811428427696228,
0.35763615369796753,
-0.31534111499786377,
-0.012913855724036694,
-0.3215376138687134,
-0.14268474280834198,
0.6476993560791016,
-0.5914134383201599,
-0.02397645264863968,
0.5599039196968079,
-0.551697850227356,
-0.3352145254611969,
0.49562832713127136,
-0.5805013179779053,
-0.15950636565685272,
-0.3574523627758026,
0.403927743434906,
-0.39663031697273254,
-0.21292008459568024,
0.015221450477838516,
-0.38134491443634033,
0.047747496515512466,
0.3057410717010498,
-0.6274729371070862,
0.02921219728887081,
0.6433842778205872,
0.6076949834823608,
-0.5122455358505249,
-0.5130802392959595,
-0.2916054427623749,
0.22240793704986572,
-0.2075783759355545,
1.2428030967712402,
-0.13441361486911774,
-0.6780605912208557,
0.16025705635547638,
-0.2914414703845978,
0.06494249403476715,
-0.11915388703346252,
0.600334882736206,
-0.28538575768470764,
0.6086284518241882,
-0.25721606612205505,
-0.4999540150165558,
-0.10429073125123978,
0.500067412853241,
-0.7909457087516785,
1.0319042205810547,
0.4613510072231293,
-0.9084330201148987,
0.46623602509498596,
-0.2690849006175995,
-0.6903112530708313,
-0.06387760490179062,
-0.1354745328426361,
-0.43855321407318115,
0.23276802897453308,
0.2799191474914551,
0.4095759987831116,
-0.3444432318210602,
0.512420117855072,
-0.02266872115433216,
-0.313437283039093,
0.18984684348106384,
-0.234930619597435,
0.15997807681560516,
0.2539699077606201,
-0.19602012634277344,
0.5500450730323792,
-0.399979829788208,
-0.013239015825092793,
-0.39219367504119873,
-0.4451950490474701,
-0.06965108215808868,
0.1290244311094284,
0.25535568594932556,
0.25548702478408813,
0.027699798345565796,
-0.4598230719566345,
-0.004945841152220964,
-0.14354583621025085,
0.055896610021591187,
0.42578965425491333,
0.3646230399608612,
0.6236081719398499,
-0.7444648742675781,
0.2590407431125641,
0.036838266998529434,
0.34737464785575867,
-1.0431863069534302,
-0.4777296185493469,
-0.6003826260566711,
-0.2620845437049866,
0.26274028420448303,
0.1418876200914383,
-0.8825568556785583,
0.7142513394355774,
-0.3136146068572998,
-0.7626217007637024,
-0.19956524670124054,
0.0411236509680748,
0.6319261789321899,
0.47803807258605957,
0.4129490256309509,
-0.4502393305301666,
-0.2618204653263092,
-1.026075005531311,
-0.010966649278998375,
-0.1630784571170807,
0.12987662851810455,
0.27477142214775085,
0.4528104364871979,
-0.379564106464386,
1.071524977684021,
-0.5605440735816956,
-0.36795732378959656,
-0.4537193775177002,
0.32604900002479553,
-0.032889436930418015,
0.5897105932235718,
0.1405183970928192,
-1.0309697389602661,
-0.35287347435951233,
-0.07184771448373795,
-0.6682160496711731,
0.03615962341427803,
-0.38418474793434143,
-0.45315971970558167,
-0.017307253554463387,
0.26000604033470154,
-0.4818575084209442,
0.19995354115962982,
0.5089027881622314,
-0.2796564996242523,
0.7450668215751648,
-0.010711162351071835,
0.6004319190979004,
-1.420506477355957,
0.18469807505607605,
-0.2295362651348114,
-0.0412386953830719,
-0.5487926006317139,
0.17611445486545563,
0.13137952983379364,
-0.08483275771141052,
-0.46488305926322937,
0.41795462369918823,
-0.26381614804267883,
0.0855664536356926,
-0.24074088037014008,
0.14874215424060822,
0.4782091975212097,
0.39233553409576416,
0.03988806903362274,
0.46084582805633545,
0.121921606361866,
-0.2855222821235657,
0.0948130339384079,
0.4297243356704712,
-0.4681313931941986,
0.7018985748291016,
-0.35864102840423584,
-0.09719657152891159,
-0.20795874297618866,
0.8073793649673462,
-1.1652847528457642,
-0.6711755394935608,
-0.07268146425485611,
-0.2655411660671234,
0.13414686918258667,
0.24140697717666626,
-0.7081374526023865,
-0.16362735629081726,
-0.5695282220840454,
0.5695095658302307,
0.460752934217453,
-0.31333255767822266,
0.6127451062202454,
0.43196311593055725,
-0.3022821247577667,
-0.253724068403244,
-0.49289798736572266,
-0.1037687137722969,
0.12288909405469894,
-0.900888204574585,
0.6273196935653687,
-0.22991566359996796,
-0.13144776225090027,
-0.21570464968681335,
-0.1537947952747345,
-0.21282634139060974,
-0.09808073192834854,
0.27178269624710083,
0.07270777970552444,
-0.14132224023342133,
0.11638911068439484,
0.6936089396476746,
-0.08958574384450912,
-0.28496813774108887,
-0.27108025550842285,
0.3266809284687042,
0.02457440085709095,
-0.4942256510257721,
-0.11808501929044724,
1.0721120834350586,
0.601426899433136,
-0.3986603319644928,
0.330668568611145,
0.5019261240959167,
-0.1470295637845993,
-0.27091580629348755,
-0.6939781904220581,
-0.25629597902297974,
-0.3598065674304962,
0.08244697749614716,
-0.16312816739082336,
-0.8568410873413086,
0.3693913519382477,
0.029753997921943665,
0.5193728804588318,
0.872194230556488,
0.7344517707824707,
-0.1798274666070938,
0.6637438535690308,
0.4900229573249817,
0.36780184507369995,
0.3204665184020996,
0.04637524485588074,
-0.018652070313692093,
-0.717308759689331,
-0.5271642804145813,
-0.40200722217559814,
-0.2848949730396271,
-0.04015986993908882,
-0.34169700741767883,
0.5835722088813782,
0.20934870839118958,
0.30427876114845276,
0.3195579946041107,
-0.42836543917655945,
0.48076820373535156,
0.42982932925224304,
0.08670606464147568,
0.4422340393066406,
-0.15323679149150848,
-0.22903083264827728,
0.13048069179058075,
-0.6518057584762573,
-0.3392045497894287,
0.9491698741912842,
0.005436164326965809,
0.547678530216217,
0.03131472319364548,
0.8306336402893066,
0.2453281134366989,
0.3776952922344208,
-0.4856330156326294,
0.2221774309873581,
0.012652724981307983,
-0.6521278619766235,
-0.16449697315692902,
-0.08921816945075989,
-0.6966933012008667,
0.608278214931488,
-0.6585084199905396,
-0.1307401806116104,
0.007844689302146435,
-0.09840554744005203,
-0.4394872486591339,
-0.05821870267391205,
-0.6903108358383179,
0.6371641159057617,
0.14989051222801208,
-0.341788113117218,
-0.3573366701602936,
-0.6107583045959473,
0.8772828578948975,
-0.5133821368217468,
0.15540611743927002,
0.09559283405542374,
0.2958512306213379,
0.3724530339241028,
-0.22530211508274078,
0.4580405354499817,
0.4809225797653198,
-0.14359210431575775,
0.6138381958007812,
0.09281662851572037,
0.19353830814361572,
0.4488106369972229,
-0.07760930061340332,
0.06850261986255646,
-0.005227212328463793,
-0.2050962597131729,
-0.37934359908103943,
0.5446638464927673,
-0.2578199803829193,
-0.2825765311717987,
-0.21308109164237976,
-0.5808746814727783,
-0.16727933287620544,
0.46803924441337585,
0.4877736270427704,
0.7143561840057373,
-0.4167383015155792,
0.4172031283378601,
0.689091145992279,
-0.1364758312702179,
0.4575067460536957,
0.22894267737865448,
-0.1905241757631302,
-0.6943313479423523,
0.725421667098999,
-0.057672034949064255,
0.3379126191139221,
0.3093574643135071,
0.09414684027433395,
-0.18418340384960175,
-0.5590657591819763,
-0.7869733572006226,
0.01163044199347496,
-0.6586617231369019,
-0.2984078824520111,
-0.7687928080558777,
-0.29578328132629395,
-0.3456743359565735,
-0.45933085680007935,
-0.27444273233413696,
-0.13913145661354065,
-0.23691216111183167,
-0.0217876099050045,
-0.21254660189151764,
0.9102982878684998,
0.3336370885372162,
0.17743849754333496,
-1.1873230934143066,
0.4083336591720581,
0.14994719624519348,
0.1058608740568161,
-0.15405379235744476,
-0.07007407397031784,
-0.4474389851093292,
-0.06810898333787918,
-0.45352819561958313,
-0.7246232628822327,
-0.039062708616256714,
0.0653490349650383,
0.5478256344795227,
0.28119319677352905,
0.2521705627441406,
0.48525309562683105,
-0.3699951469898224,
1.20627760887146,
0.29781413078308105,
-0.7522474527359009,
0.5490640997886658,
-0.625732421875,
0.8029350638389587,
1.0421271324157715,
0.031548794358968735,
-0.30397704243659973,
-0.8166908621788025,
-0.7806951403617859,
-0.9831981658935547,
0.44547396898269653,
0.5526264309883118,
0.21971729397773743,
-0.1934049427509308,
0.06082914397120476,
0.5583025813102722,
0.3837296664714813,
-0.4142269492149353,
0.10742004960775375,
-0.3162309229373932,
-0.14311781525611877,
-0.0032357757445424795,
-0.41028547286987305,
-0.3436759412288666,
0.15516795217990875,
0.5279223322868347,
-0.424655556678772,
-0.00919825118035078,
0.43178582191467285,
-0.32202014327049255,
0.01324064563959837,
0.3663080036640167,
0.9116613268852234,
0.6438255310058594,
0.07657676190137863,
0.04074325039982796,
-0.1273811012506485,
-0.4430294632911682,
-0.21655014157295227,
-0.114479199051857,
-0.36836177110671997,
0.12211920320987701,
0.6250225305557251,
0.25641128420829773,
0.5083717107772827,
-0.7074306607246399,
0.6495048403739929,
-0.13522347807884216,
-0.46496301889419556,
0.03641853109002113,
0.007118541747331619,
-0.1916985958814621,
-0.00791073590517044,
0.42923858761787415,
0.21298862993717194,
0.11718705296516418,
-0.5534215569496155,
0.653941810131073,
0.18672680854797363,
-0.4062626361846924,
-0.26430124044418335,
0.2631746232509613,
0.6810232400894165,
0.34207794070243835,
0.6006896495819092,
-0.05709485709667206,
-0.3813013732433319,
0.33343377709388733,
0.2562359571456909,
0.956274151802063,
0.305096834897995,
0.2830755114555359,
0.46471816301345825,
0.0762258917093277,
-0.22159814834594727,
0.13414742052555084,
-0.4473327398300171,
-0.5225945115089417,
-0.47770464420318604,
-0.629381000995636,
-0.34474506974220276,
-0.4404854476451874,
-0.6305732131004333,
0.3153262138366699,
-0.15001501142978668,
0.03460179641842842,
-0.2011510282754898,
-0.074322909116745,
-0.04873751103878021,
0.14292164146900177,
0.05583738908171654,
0.8815470933914185,
-0.7734127640724182,
0.6963004469871521,
0.2857026755809784,
-0.5209052562713623,
-0.6405952572822571,
0.1836538165807724,
0.28405141830444336,
-0.04471701383590698,
-0.0955086275935173,
0.306670218706131,
-0.015033130533993244,
-0.21840067207813263,
-0.012645109556615353,
-0.6215629577636719,
1.3796021938323975,
-0.11806812882423401,
-0.1227152943611145,
0.11344707757234573,
-0.3297712504863739,
0.4650360643863678,
-0.6011993288993835,
0.2915964424610138,
0.3384951949119568,
0.43713000416755676,
0.26670315861701965,
-0.9512740969657898,
-0.13738611340522766,
-0.18506404757499695,
-0.38215598464012146,
0.26946911215782166,
-0.7768110036849976,
0.9978721737861633,
0.04709163308143616,
-0.3715800344944,
0.12360718846321106,
0.7499232292175293,
0.36013805866241455,
0.1324654519557953,
0.36202552914619446,
0.3013502061367035,
0.4526554346084595,
-0.1102399080991745,
1.352009654045105,
-0.27984145283699036,
0.32645535469055176,
1.0406090021133423,
-0.3049800395965576,
0.8415994644165039,
0.5485133528709412,
0.3745664954185486,
0.5605284571647644,
0.5753346085548401,
-0.016265129670500755,
0.5553478598594666,
-0.12085474282503128,
-0.2930470108985901,
-0.21056002378463745,
-0.3710700273513794,
-0.29601791501045227,
0.3119756877422333,
-0.00018998843734152615,
-0.3533572256565094,
-0.4291665554046631,
-0.20585158467292786,
-0.13227272033691406,
0.2386331409215927,
-0.22520871460437775,
1.1565176248550415,
-0.03969645872712135,
-1.363797903060913,
0.018755529075860977,
0.13079234957695007,
0.5839956998825073,
-0.8607943654060364,
0.02472749538719654,
-0.3084145486354828,
-0.14246684312820435,
-0.40990740060806274,
-1.1310994625091553,
0.5604987740516663,
-0.1319381147623062,
-0.5860174298286438,
-0.7393087148666382,
0.8948644995689392,
-0.5744708776473999,
-0.3048781156539917,
-0.07024140655994415,
0.6722562909126282,
-0.20180743932724,
-0.12016339600086212,
-0.2664552628993988,
0.06120464578270912,
0.011466004885733128,
-0.2605876922607422,
0.40557169914245605,
0.12225116789340973,
-0.20586422085762024,
0.11962459236383438,
0.8864327669143677,
-0.4030170440673828,
-0.20462718605995178,
0.026671119034290314,
0.9163666367530823,
-0.3939361572265625,
-0.7414465546607971,
-0.5085309743881226,
1.015912652015686,
-0.11989391595125198,
-0.7309046387672424,
0.7110546231269836,
0.8761486411094666,
0.8541128039360046,
-0.13601359724998474,
0.6468228697776794,
-0.17854651808738708,
0.1470932811498642,
-0.672505259513855,
1.0284088850021362,
-0.565820574760437,
-0.07026556134223938,
-0.3582496643066406,
-0.990014374256134,
-0.2243204265832901,
0.05589504539966583,
0.34145134687423706,
-0.24451100826263428,
1.1556849479675293,
0.4470888376235962,
-0.024591736495494843,
0.3194155991077423,
0.1681864708662033,
-0.3754734396934509,
0.2068154364824295,
0.3298634886741638,
0.8950250148773193,
-0.5427689552307129,
0.5237434506416321,
-0.08887141197919846,
0.034520186483860016,
0.007676675450056791,
-0.784930944442749,
-0.816718578338623,
-0.9399181008338928,
-0.08166205883026123,
-0.4503183662891388,
-0.4265061914920807,
0.543618381023407,
0.772581934928894,
-0.5797048211097717,
-0.10958105325698853,
0.11904338747262955,
0.3871665596961975,
-0.22007326781749725,
-0.13883258402347565,
0.21708327531814575,
-0.3424564599990845,
-0.5981740951538086,
0.490019291639328,
0.5180837512016296,
-0.12880080938339233,
-0.5342485904693604,
-0.07389593124389648,
-0.24438989162445068,
0.11855244636535645,
0.7539293766021729,
-0.1948140263557434,
-0.6210814118385315,
-0.1822277158498764,
-0.060704268515110016,
-0.3221483528614044,
-0.07670151442289352,
1.1490951776504517,
-0.6452957987785339,
0.627210795879364,
0.8717309236526489,
0.6278865933418274,
0.36252662539482117,
0.4316273331642151,
0.819412350654602,
-0.8559972047805786,
-0.16922606527805328,
0.16649341583251953,
0.22435137629508972,
0.08283376693725586,
-0.2217114418745041,
0.3649231195449829,
0.2183217853307724,
-0.3265317380428314,
-0.6910949349403381,
0.4122474491596222,
-1.1999878883361816,
-0.33420661091804504,
1.3420815467834473,
0.017608581110835075,
-0.025221602991223335,
-0.15876631438732147,
-0.3257952928543091,
-0.08009204268455505,
-0.35377880930900574,
0.5142554044723511,
0.8863293528556824,
-0.14814777672290802,
0.12959332764148712,
-0.08362054079771042,
0.3257593512535095,
0.3269675374031067,
-1.0475690364837646,
-0.07203605026006699,
0.9197810292243958,
0.022189578041434288,
0.3417837619781494,
0.6545899510383606,
-0.2681935429573059,
0.4863607883453369,
0.12122003734111786,
-0.11755256354808807,
-0.14282816648483276,
-0.5382779240608215,
-0.3281356990337372,
0.5255033373832703,
-0.4423506259918213,
0.33585867285728455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15322v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15322v1
|
CO-Fun: A German Dataset on Company Outsourcing in Fund Prospectuses for Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction
| 2024-03-22T16:17:55 | 2024-03-22T16:17:55 |
Neda Foroutan, Markus Schröder, Andreas Dengel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The process of cyber mapping gives insights in relationships among financial
entities and service providers. Centered around the outsourcing practices of
companies within fund prospectuses in Germany, we introduce a dataset
specifically designed for named entity recognition and relation extraction
tasks. The labeling process on 948 sentences was carried out by three experts
which yields to 5,969 annotations for four entity types (Outsourcing, Company,
Location and Software) and 4,102 relation annotations (Outsourcing-Company,
Company-Location). State-of-the-art deep learning models were trained to
recognize entities and extract relations showing first promising results. An
anonymized version of the dataset, along with guidelines and the code used for
model training, are publicly available at
https://www.dfki.uni-kl.de/cybermapping/data/CO-Fun-1.0-anonymized.zip.
|
[
-0.4673559367656708,
-0.6541697382926941,
0.32632502913475037,
0.1624518632888794,
-0.45763176679611206,
0.14319279789924622,
-0.18140803277492523,
-0.9036701321601868,
0.34957173466682434,
0.8509843349456787,
-0.7575555443763733,
-0.5657671689987183,
-0.29639965295791626,
-0.013103793375194073,
-0.6384956240653992,
1.2128913402557373,
0.129140242934227,
0.08888324350118637,
-0.6404396891593933,
0.005229854490607977,
0.14241084456443787,
-0.7685930132865906,
-1.0287433862686157,
-0.3436811566352844,
0.31826192140579224,
0.5007545948028564,
0.579120397567749,
0.2729472815990448,
1.149260401725769,
0.34114232659339905,
0.3513311743736267,
-0.1984887421131134,
-0.6314610838890076,
0.006116997450590134,
-0.24064451456069946,
-0.21401016414165497,
-0.45900535583496094,
0.009167930111289024,
0.07030992954969406,
0.7855459451675415,
-0.2527446746826172,
0.5549798607826233,
-0.32236477732658386,
0.5355349779129028,
-0.48482245206832886,
0.5727984309196472,
-0.4745369851589203,
-0.14330321550369263,
-0.4761231243610382,
-0.04663917049765587,
-0.34742408990859985,
-0.19032786786556244,
0.7246690392494202,
-0.9177562594413757,
0.5264840722084045,
0.4480634927749634,
1.276581883430481,
0.22958360612392426,
-0.0379260815680027,
-0.7874301075935364,
-0.6579921841621399,
0.4745294153690338,
-0.14311766624450684,
0.43404778838157654,
0.52044278383255,
0.5069014430046082,
-0.16027265787124634,
-0.9932498931884766,
-0.03245767205953598,
-0.013121003285050392,
-0.3185267448425293,
0.034473396837711334,
-0.2542247474193573,
0.02625012770295143,
0.17657336592674255,
0.474757581949234,
-0.08309485763311386,
0.07224152237176895,
-0.6605612635612488,
-0.29725196957588196,
0.9218140840530396,
-0.43446701765060425,
0.211633563041687,
0.41245222091674805,
-0.5035381317138672,
-0.18026971817016602,
-0.8102124929428101,
0.254536509513855,
0.8029034733772278,
0.2701558768749237,
-0.29852965474128723,
0.5896591544151306,
0.001267617684789002,
0.43372586369514465,
0.06887482851743698,
-0.03635884076356888,
0.15765343606472015,
-0.1338624209165573,
-0.5567153096199036,
0.377954363822937,
0.5593112707138062,
-0.29190582036972046,
0.5165014863014221,
-0.7621066570281982,
-0.22663326561450958,
-0.2307410091161728,
0.3493880331516266,
-0.5042825937271118,
-0.668655514717102,
0.12275906652212143,
-0.280621737241745,
-0.1949271708726883,
0.3854709267616272,
-0.6879294514656067,
-0.20951853692531586,
-0.3116823434829712,
0.3378963768482208,
-0.2792758047580719,
-0.13401424884796143,
0.1590612381696701,
-0.5310911536216736,
-0.07815910875797272,
0.12059932202100754,
-0.4727814495563507,
0.6405347585678101,
0.7473689913749695,
0.4680943787097931,
-0.1035865843296051,
0.075949527323246,
-0.7103604078292847,
0.2863309979438782,
-0.07458595931529999,
0.7083100080490112,
-0.4858192205429077,
-0.19247733056545258,
-0.11189964413642883,
0.037856727838516235,
0.20860959589481354,
-0.7940928339958191,
0.4426971673965454,
-1.1156131029129028,
0.3779314160346985,
-0.19752849638462067,
-0.6167393922805786,
-0.4106009006500244,
-0.09432810544967651,
-1.1191120147705078,
0.7245867252349854,
0.3314710557460785,
-0.7389423251152039,
0.5670293569564819,
-0.9131038188934326,
-0.27545157074928284,
0.46563324332237244,
-0.17193497717380524,
-0.521054208278656,
0.0360247865319252,
0.14463582634925842,
0.38532498478889465,
-0.5757391452789307,
0.7350665926933289,
-0.5926993489265442,
-0.29037991166114807,
0.24360229074954987,
0.18949082493782043,
1.14316987991333,
0.0011891465401276946,
-0.17381109297275543,
-0.028880305588245392,
-1.024030327796936,
-0.5029889345169067,
0.20116567611694336,
0.11408618837594986,
-0.7580957412719727,
-0.3096240758895874,
-0.21041950583457947,
0.5303023457527161,
0.17884626984596252,
-0.4547431766986847,
-0.2535989582538605,
-0.5092517733573914,
0.23508550226688385,
0.2914736568927765,
0.20359951257705688,
0.491939902305603,
-0.0063720871694386005,
0.644493579864502,
0.37004438042640686,
-0.1449541449546814,
0.03407684341073036,
-0.34839171171188354,
-0.9226012825965881,
-0.5535596013069153,
0.5029075145721436,
0.415791392326355,
-0.7120029330253601,
0.33969026803970337,
-0.4119666814804077,
-0.7156328558921814,
-0.6528400182723999,
-0.19319571554660797,
0.18142491579055786,
0.771504282951355,
0.4258553981781006,
-0.26353201270103455,
-0.6780610680580139,
-1.1583384275436401,
-0.25952306389808655,
0.10841957479715347,
0.10435457527637482,
0.6068063378334045,
0.7192366123199463,
0.006106280721724033,
1.1737480163574219,
-0.3529077470302582,
-0.4975174367427826,
0.31017810106277466,
0.14706453680992126,
0.3485111892223358,
0.19425177574157715,
0.6574073433876038,
-1.085459589958191,
-0.20898251235485077,
-0.18980200588703156,
-0.7597106099128723,
0.42087170481681824,
-0.13737866282463074,
-0.130124032497406,
-0.027905888855457306,
0.20700356364250183,
-0.42598092555999756,
0.19271503388881683,
0.4183509647846222,
-0.3611936569213867,
0.17876924574375153,
-0.23828084766864777,
-0.18069438636302948,
-0.9946529269218445,
0.46850937604904175,
0.2111126035451889,
-0.42347320914268494,
-0.24505048990249634,
0.12204819172620773,
-0.24492941796779633,
-0.2930700182914734,
-0.502149224281311,
0.47078797221183777,
-0.6535179018974304,
-0.5446680784225464,
0.21545632183551788,
0.21542027592658997,
-0.11636167019605637,
0.20954173803329468,
0.20014972984790802,
0.8548101782798767,
0.7782393097877502,
-0.6912910342216492,
0.9139723181724548,
0.25052398443222046,
-0.4470755457878113,
0.4217757284641266,
-0.3704017996788025,
0.3435713052749634,
0.1180262342095375,
0.14020384848117828,
-0.7021177411079407,
-0.26761794090270996,
0.5260375142097473,
-0.08778490126132965,
0.10884295403957367,
-0.18892470002174377,
-0.5854402184486389,
-0.35289281606674194,
0.17827275395393372,
0.15453219413757324,
0.15727843344211578,
-0.5905184745788574,
0.26482224464416504,
0.8429059386253357,
-0.30715471506118774,
-0.5113076567649841,
-0.8978244662284851,
0.20800957083702087,
-0.5288185477256775,
-0.6699610352516174,
0.7496424317359924,
0.447027325630188,
-0.3271796405315399,
0.4692681133747101,
0.13105688989162445,
-0.723785936832428,
0.19080109894275665,
0.4267110824584961,
0.3369571566581726,
-0.17537105083465576,
0.14077970385551453,
-0.21378538012504578,
-0.264808714389801,
0.29493609070777893,
-0.13677601516246796,
0.44048818945884705,
0.04184447228908539,
-0.06480755656957626,
-0.21016249060630798,
0.2768934369087219,
-0.04949263855814934,
-0.18137606978416443,
0.6776895523071289,
0.5111082196235657,
-0.692412793636322,
0.011060544289648533,
-0.23255230486392975,
-0.17362575232982635,
-0.5486304759979248,
-0.038540318608284,
-0.49325740337371826,
-1.0991675853729248,
0.6504740715026855,
-0.4129326045513153,
-0.07367704808712006,
0.8347067832946777,
0.18742021918296814,
-0.09615009278059006,
0.04280322045087814,
1.1408520936965942,
0.02287396974861622,
-0.08954720199108124,
-0.5198816657066345,
0.5225451588630676,
0.03154061734676361,
-0.5211867094039917,
-0.5089667439460754,
-0.33846306800842285,
-0.7787208557128906,
-0.15684664249420166,
-0.002882698317989707,
0.12110883742570877,
0.029920335859060287,
0.8437247276306152,
-0.17111141979694366,
0.059130311012268066,
0.6491881012916565,
-0.19008931517601013,
0.2632403075695038,
0.2759048640727997,
-0.13473545014858246,
-0.16090404987335205,
-0.4753272831439972,
-0.2256937175989151,
0.748040497303009,
0.28053638339042664,
0.5447357892990112,
-0.0761437863111496,
1.2632440328598022,
0.23876447975635529,
0.33898138999938965,
-0.7568190097808838,
0.3626895844936371,
-0.23858217895030975,
-0.8149574398994446,
-0.4798683524131775,
-0.4711260497570038,
-0.6895739436149597,
-0.7697648406028748,
-0.002987439511343837,
-0.803644597530365,
0.6069533228874207,
0.147568479180336,
-0.5851905941963196,
0.07387640327215195,
-0.6112855076789856,
0.6063911318778992,
-0.22089309990406036,
-0.22099480032920837,
-0.23736324906349182,
-0.45642349123954773,
0.5034030079841614,
-0.4600195586681366,
0.41174939274787903,
0.03669139742851257,
-0.14026552438735962,
0.8509836792945862,
-0.013312263414263725,
0.5206040143966675,
-0.11144699901342392,
-0.23169952630996704,
0.4225301742553711,
-0.09084312617778778,
0.48973092436790466,
0.39575639367103577,
-0.24575257301330566,
0.4518468976020813,
0.0023229699581861496,
0.0008722257916815579,
-0.18874017894268036,
0.5658972859382629,
-0.49403777718544006,
-0.1913723200559616,
-0.47807013988494873,
-0.4325895309448242,
-0.0332934595644474,
0.40214499831199646,
0.30394813418388367,
0.08430370688438416,
-0.43835845589637756,
0.4572444558143616,
0.35366520285606384,
-0.16964928805828094,
0.7802228331565857,
0.3033180832862854,
-0.08256654441356659,
-0.4402002990245819,
0.9474765658378601,
0.45731794834136963,
-0.3967509865760803,
0.25497350096702576,
-0.32777947187423706,
-0.6106701493263245,
0.030907772481441498,
-0.1821630895137787,
0.2216097116470337,
-0.5751473903656006,
-0.21517203748226166,
-0.7784697413444519,
-0.397695928812027,
-0.4144952595233917,
-0.044861193746328354,
-0.46859049797058105,
-0.4284016191959381,
-0.28005823493003845,
-0.05794398859143257,
0.3728156089782715,
0.7136909365653992,
-0.024052487686276436,
0.3408282399177551,
-0.6297836899757385,
0.5225128531455994,
0.1313919574022293,
0.6003752946853638,
-0.5222505331039429,
-0.00653962092474103,
-0.5432170629501343,
0.013838953338563442,
0.07822779566049576,
-0.8518145084381104,
0.352886438369751,
0.37828534841537476,
0.36653849482536316,
0.5091446042060852,
0.17547957599163055,
0.7125297784805298,
0.015157178975641727,
0.4997894763946533,
0.10979346930980682,
-0.8340774178504944,
0.2881366014480591,
-0.21026849746704102,
-0.37588047981262207,
0.5736762881278992,
0.8178070783615112,
-0.3619334101676941,
-0.007497802376747131,
-1.3674874305725098,
-0.9651317596435547,
1.0299147367477417,
0.2767236530780792,
-0.05556343495845795,
0.34113800525665283,
0.6079341173171997,
0.35229259729385376,
0.5998201966285706,
-0.5352081656455994,
-0.4408873915672302,
0.42904576659202576,
0.045393288135528564,
-0.15491929650306702,
-0.5035427212715149,
-0.36268195509910583,
0.0027928007766604424,
0.9516085982322693,
0.2886931598186493,
0.45969441533088684,
-0.003598906798288226,
-0.17169657349586487,
-0.21995335817337036,
-0.104951873421669,
0.43560242652893066,
0.9059209227561951,
-0.27671802043914795,
0.16057252883911133,
-0.07589369267225266,
-0.23946888744831085,
0.007096597924828529,
0.5794730186462402,
-0.18068747222423553,
0.310780793428421,
0.22612150013446808,
0.6731290221214294,
0.3413863778114319,
-0.539596676826477,
0.3420882523059845,
-0.13774247467517853,
-0.1630086898803711,
-0.795555055141449,
0.12467311322689056,
0.42050793766975403,
0.3084847331047058,
0.26237472891807556,
-0.030858561396598816,
0.5269138216972351,
-0.30488157272338867,
0.6719987392425537,
0.31882041692733765,
-0.5243303179740906,
-0.389128178358078,
0.4005744159221649,
0.2138853222131729,
-0.6165406703948975,
0.9039833545684814,
-0.4322883188724518,
-0.017464622855186462,
0.6992110013961792,
0.6080757975578308,
0.987945020198822,
0.17658409476280212,
0.3380977213382721,
0.3669390380382538,
0.1044105738401413,
0.04847189784049988,
0.30070099234580994,
0.016428127884864807,
-0.5857939720153809,
-0.26699066162109375,
-0.43506988883018494,
-0.508396565914154,
0.43102529644966125,
-0.8498866558074951,
0.9411035180091858,
-0.2641233801841736,
-0.2991471588611603,
0.2323695719242096,
0.1924598067998886,
-1.21761155128479,
0.5333191752433777,
0.21546967327594757,
0.777667224407196,
-0.572219967842102,
0.9416843056678772,
0.814416229724884,
-0.3375186622142792,
-0.4453853964805603,
-0.1895848959684372,
-0.26915016770362854,
-0.6755034923553467,
0.8212183117866516,
0.2606673836708069,
-0.019230008125305176,
0.3785048723220825,
-0.38317036628723145,
-1.1970863342285156,
1.0845414400100708,
0.8000858426094055,
-0.9054821729660034,
-0.36189037561416626,
0.4243311583995819,
0.41286295652389526,
-0.7581319212913513,
-0.010737569071352482,
0.49468594789505005,
0.21638791263103485,
-0.03132878988981247,
-0.6602428555488586,
-0.17538398504257202,
-0.06412060558795929,
-0.5672522187232971,
0.08074700832366943,
-0.5339868068695068,
0.5120351910591125,
-0.194659024477005,
-0.46722275018692017,
-0.5039558410644531,
0.6117641925811768,
0.24717137217521667,
0.5601298213005066,
0.5694608092308044,
0.7042645215988159,
0.8111531734466553,
-0.1754263937473297,
0.6145188808441162,
-0.44494420289993286,
0.545647382736206,
1.534926176071167,
-0.08580949902534485,
0.49898719787597656,
0.663852870464325,
0.015781283378601074,
0.5032683610916138,
0.9105994701385498,
-0.39021968841552734,
0.6182765364646912,
0.3064677119255066,
0.16139689087867737,
-0.21465149521827698,
-0.30407825112342834,
-0.34937530755996704,
0.6572495102882385,
0.3492339253425598,
-0.6078435182571411,
-0.4907419979572296,
-0.3235015571117401,
0.0515173114836216,
-0.35312187671661377,
0.20007936656475067,
0.8791077136993408,
0.4218606650829315,
-0.6393250823020935,
-0.24524438381195068,
0.09080275893211365,
0.33275794982910156,
-0.38811996579170227,
-0.0708898976445198,
0.12042280286550522,
0.13042736053466797,
-0.03249175474047661,
-0.5489245057106018,
0.5004978775978088,
-0.045010827481746674,
0.027822725474834442,
-0.20995835959911346,
0.8691695332527161,
-0.49153074622154236,
-0.5987756848335266,
0.6820991635322571,
0.4830271303653717,
0.2913495898246765,
-0.18637017905712128,
-0.7281824946403503,
-0.590059220790863,
-0.45078161358833313,
-0.2796633243560791,
0.05685305595397949,
0.5784884691238403,
-0.1697855442762375,
0.49866724014282227,
0.5948277711868286,
-0.007240919396281242,
-0.13745245337486267,
-0.0798991248011589,
0.8400346636772156,
-0.5489147305488586,
-0.6997697353363037,
-0.8877506852149963,
0.39799508452415466,
-0.4494306147098541,
-0.47074151039123535,
0.39922937750816345,
0.9510746598243713,
1.1048303842544556,
-0.18716147541999817,
0.562908411026001,
-0.024845540523529053,
0.17341361939907074,
-0.06282000243663788,
0.7015572190284729,
-0.3859427571296692,
0.025549354031682014,
-0.11000614613294601,
-0.8154228329658508,
-0.1415448635816574,
0.1849822998046875,
-0.46813011169433594,
-0.1624045968055725,
0.35580840706825256,
0.5416087508201599,
-0.4629981815814972,
0.03998144343495369,
0.17015038430690765,
-0.3335377871990204,
0.3072850704193115,
0.2586205303668976,
0.3652500808238983,
-0.6623555421829224,
0.40766534209251404,
-1.1490622758865356,
0.1570541113615036,
-0.3164686858654022,
-1.0276222229003906,
-0.7660236358642578,
-0.6834646463394165,
-0.5975064039230347,
-0.23518958687782288,
-0.14736032485961914,
0.7365965843200684,
0.7408347129821777,
-1.0917047262191772,
-0.34790897369384766,
-0.18218426406383514,
-0.214199498295784,
-0.2643354535102844,
-0.20262399315834045,
0.4105164408683777,
-0.31232255697250366,
-0.46556946635246277,
0.22784343361854553,
0.5920937657356262,
0.04059458151459694,
-0.26357200741767883,
0.06543619185686111,
-0.385942280292511,
-0.16800113022327423,
0.15680639445781708,
-0.01271818857640028,
-0.3255407214164734,
-0.025844834744930267,
0.12846370041370392,
-0.06739955395460129,
-0.14285758137702942,
0.9117990732192993,
-0.5546889305114746,
0.49672237038612366,
0.32477664947509766,
0.7045515179634094,
0.48456037044525146,
-0.08769162744283676,
0.6920942068099976,
-0.886699914932251,
0.541796863079071,
0.3139681816101074,
0.09782806783914566,
0.299435555934906,
-0.9042967557907104,
0.7966045141220093,
0.4265827536582947,
-0.2641761600971222,
-0.661288857460022,
-0.22750703990459442,
-0.8119722008705139,
0.2009461224079132,
0.839805543422699,
-0.5653975009918213,
-0.2866460978984833,
-0.22214747965335846,
0.10190548747777939,
0.6676749587059021,
-0.36669665575027466,
0.9036803841590881,
0.9743779301643372,
-0.04703771322965622,
-0.1811295747756958,
-0.4225246012210846,
0.936492919921875,
-0.192693293094635,
-0.9258899688720703,
-0.3007078170776367,
0.0982714518904686,
0.06675644218921661,
0.38921621441841125,
0.6792793869972229,
0.03489605709910393,
0.2710877060890198,
-0.08569275587797165,
0.1453743875026703,
-0.24446836113929749,
-0.5256268382072449,
0.052515413612127304,
0.49333345890045166,
-0.2337188720703125,
-0.16619744896888733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15309v1
|
Controlled Training Data Generation with Diffusion Models
| 2024-03-22T15:59:24 | 2024-03-22T15:59:24 |
Teresa Yeo, Andrei Atanov, Harold Benoit, Aleksandr Alekseev, Ruchira Ray, Pooya Esmaeil Akhoondi, Amir Zamir
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this work, we present a method to control a text-to-image generative model
to produce training data specifically "useful" for supervised learning. Unlike
previous works that employ an open-loop approach and pre-define prompts to
generate new data using either a language model or human expertise, we develop
an automated closed-loop system which involves two feedback mechanisms. The
first mechanism uses feedback from a given supervised model and finds
adversarial prompts that result in image generations that maximize the model
loss. While these adversarial prompts result in diverse data informed by the
model, they are not informed of the target distribution, which can be
inefficient. Therefore, we introduce the second feedback mechanism that guides
the generation process towards a certain target distribution. We call the
method combining these two mechanisms Guided Adversarial Prompts. We perform
our evaluations on different tasks, datasets and architectures, with different
types of distribution shifts (spuriously correlated data, unseen domains) and
demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed feedback mechanisms compared to
open-loop approaches.
|
[
-0.34761396050453186,
-1.1153929233551025,
0.370330810546875,
0.07094594091176987,
-0.23591507971286774,
-0.34342700242996216,
-0.39957037568092346,
0.28827252984046936,
-0.1107202097773552,
0.5867128372192383,
-0.7337676882743835,
-0.6433981657028198,
-0.6185809969902039,
-0.044074855744838715,
-0.6533404588699341,
1.215178370475769,
-0.18938986957073212,
0.2883683443069458,
-0.2805388867855072,
0.18173646926879883,
-0.31664374470710754,
-0.3829004168510437,
-0.9419500827789307,
-0.49391233921051025,
0.649277925491333,
0.03628093749284744,
0.7051876187324524,
0.495463103055954,
0.33498716354370117,
0.1910191774368286,
-0.02172907069325447,
0.31464993953704834,
-0.6424278020858765,
0.20576134324073792,
-0.18416503071784973,
-0.6136425137519836,
0.03440935164690018,
0.08772590011358261,
0.4967116713523865,
0.6219924688339233,
-0.1369209587574005,
-0.20213623344898224,
0.19769731163978577,
0.7714812755584717,
-0.7771450281143188,
-0.1182442158460617,
-0.3513912558555603,
0.46066761016845703,
-0.1793907880783081,
-0.336993545293808,
-0.9037136435508728,
-0.5693143010139465,
0.04787275195121765,
-0.7018526196479797,
0.5495719313621521,
-0.29701605439186096,
0.6022180914878845,
0.4054822623729706,
-0.2319086194038391,
-0.6599655747413635,
-0.8637621402740479,
0.5652299523353577,
-0.22712476551532745,
0.024894898757338524,
0.3249111473560333,
0.31237295269966125,
-0.14080002903938293,
-0.6105198860168457,
-0.24709981679916382,
-0.3244847357273102,
0.03108260966837406,
0.47409242391586304,
-0.14434577524662018,
-0.20228859782218933,
0.17485731840133667,
0.06145697832107544,
-0.3045606315135956,
0.12604640424251556,
-0.36842113733291626,
0.08326668292284012,
0.6460452079772949,
0.17382332682609558,
0.047350529581308365,
0.2093559205532074,
-0.3337750732898712,
-0.43840155005455017,
-0.7653175592422485,
-0.11544124782085419,
0.7352557182312012,
0.15890006721019745,
-0.1995195895433426,
0.6360939145088196,
-0.015954896807670593,
0.7759103775024414,
0.39721202850341797,
0.0801183357834816,
0.05638604611158371,
0.04920429736375809,
-0.09613904356956482,
-0.32870399951934814,
0.9921153783798218,
0.3751431703567505,
0.2915135622024536,
-0.15883691608905792,
-0.3956787586212158,
0.25084370374679565,
0.4754228889942169,
-0.6617026329040527,
-0.5179365277290344,
-0.166139155626297,
-0.43858712911605835,
-0.8669978976249695,
0.08862317353487015,
-0.9240396022796631,
-0.2499445676803589,
-0.2253599762916565,
0.312643438577652,
-0.2619791328907013,
-0.14524993300437927,
-0.1667439192533493,
-0.40905192494392395,
-0.28575995564460754,
0.4454937279224396,
-0.8562753200531006,
0.19901567697525024,
-0.006758613046258688,
0.9670702219009399,
-0.5855271816253662,
0.07740745693445206,
-0.5070351362228394,
0.2439970225095749,
-0.7279310822486877,
0.5173391699790955,
-0.5119401216506958,
-0.5589849948883057,
0.32638752460479736,
-0.09500432014465332,
-0.09966569393873215,
-0.6346533298492432,
0.039877332746982574,
-0.9054612517356873,
0.4467443823814392,
0.01130661554634571,
-0.4716721773147583,
-0.06609923392534256,
0.030542349442839622,
-0.6936783790588379,
0.8819950819015503,
0.16268156468868256,
-0.9371326565742493,
0.44133633375167847,
-0.9060859084129333,
-0.4088641405105591,
0.029283268377184868,
-0.2671554386615753,
-0.7267186045646667,
-0.31488826870918274,
0.29368770122528076,
0.5938262939453125,
0.0002144686586689204,
0.431759238243103,
-0.3547767400741577,
0.017651159316301346,
0.222922682762146,
-0.6287277340888977,
0.7988905906677246,
0.2699468433856964,
-0.47958382964134216,
0.07811222970485687,
-0.7282346487045288,
-0.21747401356697083,
0.31879180669784546,
-0.5199544429779053,
-0.28334665298461914,
0.007515537552535534,
0.01828908920288086,
-0.11783447861671448,
-0.04450147971510887,
-0.22579988837242126,
0.459819495677948,
0.08447340875864029,
0.21028368175029755,
0.8322948813438416,
0.37676578760147095,
0.6649168729782104,
-0.2615053057670593,
0.7184469103813171,
0.2519396245479584,
0.14061976969242096,
-0.21542176604270935,
-0.4197806417942047,
-0.6164116859436035,
-0.19830633699893951,
0.25617557764053345,
0.579336404800415,
-1.2021433115005493,
0.29006192088127136,
0.2847287058830261,
-0.31615716218948364,
-0.2869400978088379,
0.17722077667713165,
0.2886897325515747,
0.5883971452713013,
0.2138555645942688,
-0.30738040804862976,
-0.09642702341079712,
-0.5740001797676086,
0.447336882352829,
0.13512921333312988,
-0.22383944690227509,
0.30895891785621643,
0.48287251591682434,
-0.2650567889213562,
0.8766232132911682,
-0.6974025964736938,
-0.022229719907045364,
0.03364012390375137,
0.3814014792442322,
-0.1939879208803177,
0.47352415323257446,
0.7469282150268555,
-0.794641375541687,
-0.24030695855617523,
-0.1285088211297989,
-1.0228512287139893,
-0.19353938102722168,
-0.36311039328575134,
-0.3942478895187378,
0.12267111986875534,
0.5573617815971375,
-0.3982740342617035,
0.6154698729515076,
0.490037202835083,
-0.0022469665855169296,
0.4989791810512543,
-0.3191482424736023,
0.06633181869983673,
-0.9947805404663086,
-0.010171583853662014,
0.23179581761360168,
-0.05370216816663742,
-0.506547749042511,
-0.015375475399196148,
0.10462644696235657,
-0.13125421106815338,
-0.3456658124923706,
0.18803688883781433,
-0.3419398367404938,
0.2863922715187073,
-0.3398285210132599,
-0.09242402017116547,
-0.12263862788677216,
0.49713945388793945,
0.23607245087623596,
0.7480419874191284,
0.9501969814300537,
-1.0279418230056763,
0.7057868242263794,
0.3539588451385498,
-0.13721810281276703,
0.7096631526947021,
-0.6960737705230713,
0.16973912715911865,
-0.36076706647872925,
0.2977418899536133,
-0.7513207197189331,
-0.3172038793563843,
0.5183853507041931,
-0.4512538015842438,
0.3983570635318756,
-0.0110381580889225,
-0.5201317071914673,
-0.4704887866973877,
-0.1290544718503952,
0.1956108957529068,
0.6367793083190918,
-0.7784461379051208,
-0.028382427990436554,
0.023204641416668892,
0.050421811640262604,
-0.21714195609092712,
-0.7807139754295349,
-0.26623886823654175,
-0.2791205048561096,
-0.5449131727218628,
0.14466030895709991,
-0.16924609243869781,
-0.10375014692544937,
0.04843995347619057,
0.670282781124115,
0.060668110847473145,
0.018826279789209366,
0.30577653646469116,
0.26742732524871826,
0.07748907804489136,
0.29215189814567566,
0.41214999556541443,
0.009354307316243649,
0.14192982017993927,
-0.531669557094574,
0.32012036442756653,
0.6705895662307739,
-0.5754681825637817,
-0.40005776286125183,
0.5189657211303711,
0.24999064207077026,
-0.05909112095832825,
0.8376017212867737,
0.5408989787101746,
-0.13062596321105957,
-0.5497800707817078,
0.08561678975820541,
-0.28444531559944153,
-0.4875859022140503,
0.02124440297484398,
-0.21380501985549927,
-0.6011896729469299,
0.4001866281032562,
-0.33753734827041626,
0.13664191961288452,
0.2546469271183014,
1.008199691772461,
-0.09624090045690536,
1.345673680305481,
0.6511899828910828,
0.09264881163835526,
0.7588178515434265,
-0.6149750351905823,
-0.19328220188617706,
-0.46655312180519104,
-0.3479328751564026,
-0.24798579514026642,
-0.16823919117450714,
-0.21541959047317505,
-0.17943021655082703,
0.5191622376441956,
0.2647976875305176,
-0.06769352406263351,
-0.024637620896100998,
-0.6579890251159668,
0.09210124611854553,
0.8695550560951233,
0.6165245771408081,
-0.07131654769182205,
0.1964225322008133,
-0.27780088782310486,
0.2750798165798187,
-0.8725311756134033,
-0.35968145728111267,
1.3457441329956055,
0.20908330380916595,
1.219520092010498,
-0.21080762147903442,
0.6268454790115356,
0.6782664656639099,
0.6187232136726379,
-0.5495858788490295,
0.3402216136455536,
-0.09701389819383621,
-0.2814364433288574,
-0.16643176972866058,
-0.41697219014167786,
-0.9888388514518738,
-0.08465537428855896,
-0.19236420094966888,
-0.17719082534313202,
0.050866566598415375,
0.4258946180343628,
-0.0065389033406972885,
0.3498626947402954,
-0.8347267508506775,
0.43045398592948914,
0.16801244020462036,
-0.53941410779953,
0.09331202507019043,
-0.5600051879882812,
0.33029383420944214,
-0.25333526730537415,
-0.04544690251350403,
0.502072811126709,
0.1647428423166275,
0.8293275833129883,
-0.6001879572868347,
1.0500891208648682,
-0.5184815526008606,
-0.14475539326667786,
0.5134634971618652,
-0.2106282114982605,
0.6702117323875427,
-0.12455397099256516,
0.02144499681890011,
-0.25699281692504883,
-0.6097506284713745,
-0.4066182076931,
-0.5931267738342285,
0.45399007201194763,
-0.8573136329650879,
-0.38587725162506104,
0.06025772914290428,
-0.598585844039917,
0.10633727163076401,
0.13813358545303345,
0.9039113521575928,
0.33510199189186096,
-0.08972262591123581,
0.06549268215894699,
0.7956470251083374,
-0.08842591196298599,
0.3058245778083801,
0.2435382604598999,
-0.04808131232857704,
-0.4876141846179962,
0.6161187887191772,
0.0076754395850002766,
0.6483956575393677,
0.17007282376289368,
0.10761229693889618,
-0.2094656527042389,
-0.6554744839668274,
-0.732961893081665,
0.01295696385204792,
-0.8292999267578125,
-0.2146771252155304,
-0.3509678244590759,
-0.1523062139749527,
-0.4282919764518738,
-0.4512883424758911,
-0.03425520658493042,
0.0014851627638563514,
-0.8214801549911499,
-0.11875943839550018,
0.5147746801376343,
0.9828858971595764,
-0.1260000616312027,
0.7137863636016846,
-0.4557788670063019,
0.31101518869400024,
0.3558172583580017,
0.09611868858337402,
-0.07622402161359787,
-0.38476523756980896,
-0.2668415307998657,
0.251630961894989,
-0.6626072525978088,
-1.1962976455688477,
0.4513770341873169,
0.024089833721518517,
0.34732434153556824,
0.6722899079322815,
0.11034516990184784,
0.18229460716247559,
-0.4427148699760437,
0.8619295358657837,
0.43708866834640503,
-0.6294521689414978,
1.0252588987350464,
-0.5301015973091125,
0.16291368007659912,
0.027088969945907593,
0.4760102331638336,
0.03226983919739723,
-0.7710963487625122,
-0.6456059217453003,
-0.41443249583244324,
0.6756331920623779,
0.2550228536128998,
0.033578939735889435,
-0.06017318367958069,
0.42559218406677246,
0.14947828650474548,
0.2646885812282562,
-0.4818420708179474,
-0.397851824760437,
-0.31775814294815063,
-0.2739400267601013,
0.12112733721733093,
0.13628076016902924,
-0.48690980672836304,
0.1034003496170044,
0.635138988494873,
-0.227148175239563,
0.03651595860719681,
0.15353861451148987,
0.05247334763407707,
-0.3862164318561554,
-0.05461253598332405,
0.3778257668018341,
0.41366663575172424,
0.1868322491645813,
-0.060222674161195755,
-0.2941487729549408,
-0.49896159768104553,
0.2895321249961853,
-0.009803668595850468,
-1.0368009805679321,
0.13976037502288818,
0.15239153802394867,
0.9989723563194275,
-0.3563389778137207,
-0.26552173495292664,
0.5156146883964539,
0.010168912820518017,
-0.7490419745445251,
-0.058167487382888794,
0.42481473088264465,
-0.24118007719516754,
0.3467310965061188,
0.1989128440618515,
0.42412588000297546,
0.018650995567440987,
-0.1546388566493988,
0.44553467631340027,
0.5323915481567383,
-0.220086470246315,
-0.1611851453781128,
1.067213535308838,
0.08123046159744263,
-0.27089425921440125,
0.6675813794136047,
-0.19580894708633423,
-0.24390718340873718,
0.7000811100006104,
0.645661473274231,
0.6935839056968689,
-0.321913480758667,
0.7001143097877502,
0.3111072778701782,
0.08713758736848831,
-0.28369227051734924,
0.02275124378502369,
-0.2263249307870865,
-0.6446842551231384,
-0.1224885806441307,
-0.18860813975334167,
-0.3985295295715332,
0.06958042085170746,
-1.144363284111023,
0.2566470205783844,
-0.387158066034317,
-0.32887718081474304,
0.15853112936019897,
-0.4371744990348816,
-0.6767789125442505,
0.35966986417770386,
-0.05825594440102577,
0.7117317318916321,
-1.2152379751205444,
0.8009912371635437,
0.6045932769775391,
-0.4823955297470093,
-0.5792152285575867,
-0.05268768221139908,
-0.15780042111873627,
-0.7468738555908203,
0.7316826581954956,
-0.15600456297397614,
0.07066115736961365,
0.05721840634942055,
-0.969199538230896,
-0.36885982751846313,
1.049229621887207,
0.24276863038539886,
-0.3837176561355591,
0.1843637228012085,
-0.17235729098320007,
0.5025671124458313,
-0.4716185927391052,
0.054890766739845276,
0.36707741022109985,
0.2934764623641968,
0.4784800410270691,
-0.28025123476982117,
-0.1854006052017212,
-0.28983554244041443,
0.1737426370382309,
0.16964131593704224,
-0.3725714087486267,
0.6882894039154053,
-0.43311771750450134,
-0.34943878650665283,
0.040302060544490814,
0.6558012366294861,
0.19144649803638458,
0.36179009079933167,
0.5389837622642517,
0.6613243818283081,
0.6746147274971008,
-0.05449407175183296,
1.1224522590637207,
0.008986534550786018,
0.46577188372612,
0.7575836777687073,
-0.01677030511200428,
0.49667537212371826,
0.37271735072135925,
-0.2069200724363327,
0.34472617506980896,
0.7725043892860413,
-0.3700210154056549,
1.070442795753479,
0.2961108982563019,
-0.38569408655166626,
0.08154952526092529,
-0.08460867404937744,
-0.18817918002605438,
-0.2142704874277115,
0.4205557107925415,
-0.7305618524551392,
-0.32669883966445923,
0.5345855951309204,
-0.10157984495162964,
0.14267244935035706,
-0.28476718068122864,
0.8593370318412781,
-0.3524666428565979,
-0.7928451299667358,
0.6483407616615295,
-0.10007958114147186,
0.6618918776512146,
-0.6401900053024292,
-0.07506545633077621,
-0.18068324029445648,
0.17706894874572754,
-0.2282668501138687,
-0.7276282906532288,
0.21445506811141968,
0.2753883898258209,
-0.3869609534740448,
-0.418823778629303,
0.4519980251789093,
-0.7520276308059692,
-0.4531939625740051,
0.07026024907827377,
0.11758462339639664,
0.07980111986398697,
0.23328791558742523,
-0.4987525939941406,
-0.06031216308474541,
0.20004869997501373,
-0.4877054691314697,
0.1253882795572281,
0.3927253186702728,
-0.0357431136071682,
0.567348062992096,
0.6847492456436157,
0.20616605877876282,
0.39629384875297546,
0.38583120703697205,
1.0219359397888184,
-0.12939493358135223,
-0.6108350157737732,
-0.6214003562927246,
0.3505455553531647,
-0.06436187028884888,
-0.18246597051620483,
0.537548303604126,
0.33511945605278015,
0.8634629249572754,
-0.33971622586250305,
1.2629057168960571,
0.07910636067390442,
0.41999292373657227,
-0.7567547559738159,
0.5405591130256653,
-0.40526512265205383,
-0.027720704674720764,
0.028411444276571274,
-0.5915241241455078,
-0.17326079308986664,
0.4280672073364258,
-0.23599649965763092,
0.04322907701134682,
0.5876654982566833,
1.0272338390350342,
0.0022206977009773254,
-0.05689428001642227,
0.08504578471183777,
-0.16978731751441956,
0.46289801597595215,
0.4482702612876892,
0.7560380101203918,
-0.2249610722064972,
0.43979817628860474,
-0.37652891874313354,
-0.5395181775093079,
-0.02319291979074478,
-0.4871639609336853,
-1.0937079191207886,
-0.5837712287902832,
-0.5559554100036621,
-0.4022220969200134,
0.10233892500400543,
0.29249173402786255,
0.9625361561775208,
-0.7104853987693787,
0.14455164968967438,
-0.6862818002700806,
-0.08854971081018448,
-0.21170000731945038,
-0.2962801456451416,
0.45222747325897217,
-0.46365535259246826,
-0.7977638840675354,
0.12236125022172928,
0.09902369976043701,
0.4467068612575531,
-0.6330374479293823,
-0.19575107097625732,
0.254638135433197,
-0.11754497140645981,
0.39322298765182495,
0.07384601980447769,
-0.42206159234046936,
0.1098988875746727,
-0.16597719490528107,
-0.14084139466285706,
-0.11999829113483429,
0.9493491649627686,
-0.6865425705909729,
0.6319947242736816,
0.39150792360305786,
0.564001739025116,
0.6174100041389465,
0.07164926826953888,
0.7036016583442688,
-0.9701480865478516,
0.25828734040260315,
0.05983627960085869,
-0.03983069583773613,
0.35022541880607605,
-0.5862373113632202,
0.3274732530117035,
0.3317762315273285,
-0.45015400648117065,
-0.46275416016578674,
0.22338274121284485,
-0.6453964114189148,
-0.22028617560863495,
1.0866191387176514,
-0.3389783501625061,
-0.14214769005775452,
0.2685815691947937,
-0.2395453006029129,
0.4300863444805145,
-0.3789915442466736,
0.789071261882782,
0.5512481331825256,
-0.08845095336437225,
-0.2033158242702484,
-0.3665325939655304,
0.41027870774269104,
0.09364178031682968,
-0.9648227095603943,
-0.2051122933626175,
0.7361070513725281,
0.08282390236854553,
0.10621853917837143,
0.5228008031845093,
-0.0259185079485178,
0.17222218215465546,
0.14772577583789825,
-0.098689965903759,
-0.060197047889232635,
-0.5585331320762634,
-0.440466046333313,
0.37846678495407104,
-0.32397139072418213,
-0.6887572407722473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15293v1
|
Human behaviour through a LENS: How Linguistic content triggers Emotions and Norms and determines Strategy choices
| 2024-03-22T15:40:11 | 2024-03-22T15:40:11 |
Valerio Capraro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.GT, econ.GN, physics.soc-ph, q-fin.EC
|
Over the last two decades, a growing body of experimental research has
provided evidence that linguistic frames influence human behaviour in economic
games, beyond the economic consequences of the available actions. This article
proposes a novel framework that transcends the traditional confines of
outcome-based preference models. According to the LENS model, the Linguistic
description of the decision problem triggers Emotional responses and suggests
potential Norms of behaviour, which then interact to shape an individual's
Strategic choice. The article reviews experimental evidence that supports each
path of the LENS model. Furthermore, it identifies and discusses several
critical research questions that arise from this model, pointing towards
avenues for future inquiry.
|
[
-0.513913094997406,
-0.6148208975791931,
0.6565961837768555,
0.08307530730962753,
0.15836350619792938,
-0.2522299289703369,
-0.4332176744937897,
-0.7008846998214722,
0.2585524320602417,
0.6028533577919006,
-0.7425553202629089,
-0.10005524009466171,
-0.4550122320652008,
0.16336509585380554,
-0.1926460564136505,
0.7551311254501343,
0.2482719123363495,
0.4109461307525635,
0.11111361533403397,
-0.21710143983364105,
-0.29782962799072266,
-0.6520701050758362,
-0.8657999038696289,
-0.617313027381897,
0.5177537202835083,
0.31804752349853516,
0.8867953419685364,
0.17375998198986053,
0.5719367265701294,
0.36678141355514526,
-0.12791772186756134,
-0.23281259834766388,
-0.5796951651573181,
0.2443787306547165,
-0.42880386114120483,
-0.9675295948982239,
-0.06455164402723312,
0.3926706910133362,
0.4146283268928528,
0.5055707097053528,
-0.3337961435317993,
0.2111789733171463,
0.15056167542934418,
0.7530010342597961,
-0.23563092947006226,
0.13066531717777252,
-0.3527159094810486,
0.26156148314476013,
-0.2418764978647232,
-0.25507357716560364,
-0.455998033285141,
0.14376333355903625,
0.41828399896621704,
-0.8206458687782288,
0.08324721455574036,
0.19675934314727783,
0.8711562752723694,
-0.07254960387945175,
-0.6916477084159851,
-0.4144853949546814,
-0.7705066800117493,
0.6619880199432373,
-0.384673148393631,
0.5406763553619385,
0.3472974896430969,
-0.26328468322753906,
-0.00048287640674971044,
-0.2568451166152954,
-0.3947501480579376,
-0.02692774310708046,
0.0230102501809597,
0.32836347818374634,
-0.2743142545223236,
0.3698219060897827,
0.43095138669013977,
-0.12146521359682083,
-0.2291150838136673,
-0.18092820048332214,
-0.618475615978241,
0.26370474696159363,
0.8049673438072205,
0.30993926525115967,
0.5457175374031067,
-0.3625029921531677,
-0.20546795427799225,
-0.15812699496746063,
-0.6865156292915344,
0.5030134916305542,
0.7530882358551025,
0.016982754692435265,
0.05093652755022049,
0.7192956805229187,
-0.24863998591899872,
0.6407217383384705,
0.5325093865394592,
0.0582837276160717,
-0.04916994646191597,
-0.03224427253007889,
0.09926537424325943,
0.3824823796749115,
0.6481021642684937,
0.9872345328330994,
0.5963435769081116,
-0.03939150646328926,
-0.16756002604961395,
0.5008407235145569,
0.5844830274581909,
-0.4786451756954193,
0.12057944387197495,
-0.06290396302938461,
-0.5444711446762085,
-0.597802460193634,
0.028797639533877373,
-1.2383902072906494,
-0.24644507467746735,
-0.3004767596721649,
0.368514746427536,
-0.07763928920030594,
-0.474870502948761,
0.49557384848594666,
-0.20172950625419617,
0.4710472822189331,
-0.06986965239048004,
-1.3230235576629639,
0.5491523742675781,
0.7528000473976135,
0.6557276248931885,
-0.29563674330711365,
-0.2683831453323364,
-0.07289692759513855,
0.12132251262664795,
-0.7478653192520142,
0.7675265669822693,
-0.7363733053207397,
-0.7444557547569275,
0.20012781023979187,
0.028042642399668694,
0.06668087840080261,
-0.5692567229270935,
0.4962156116962433,
-0.5416580438613892,
0.3784286677837372,
-0.6674554944038391,
-0.3830898702144623,
-0.3965742886066437,
0.19601328670978546,
-0.6651941537857056,
0.9358060359954834,
-0.16034673154354095,
-0.556096613407135,
0.8132796883583069,
-1.1450499296188354,
-0.6302356719970703,
-0.016223564743995667,
-0.07514249533414841,
-0.0028464486822485924,
0.4272575080394745,
-0.1535400003194809,
0.0007900506025180221,
-0.2663441598415375,
0.30954137444496155,
-0.5102290511131287,
-0.08701638877391815,
0.6230783462524414,
-0.3532433807849884,
0.8353906273841858,
0.12925711274147034,
-0.7627556324005127,
-0.025712687522172928,
-0.37399816513061523,
-0.3623861074447632,
0.2492602914571762,
-0.3548978865146637,
-0.5099921822547913,
0.6020241379737854,
-0.006048643495887518,
0.3363870084285736,
-0.17114846408367157,
-0.4754239022731781,
-0.010231291875243187,
-0.2892422378063202,
0.7464515566825867,
0.8035886287689209,
0.11609478294849396,
0.8729512095451355,
-0.2575668692588806,
0.5606358051300049,
-0.011567873880267143,
0.47459694743156433,
0.30925244092941284,
-0.7758890986442566,
-0.8495843410491943,
0.3802067041397095,
-0.22272062301635742,
0.5727010369300842,
-0.4688434302806854,
-0.3255855441093445,
0.15177848935127258,
-0.05738997831940651,
-0.5492896437644958,
0.07895791530609131,
0.06820069253444672,
0.5666090846061707,
-0.2027248591184616,
-0.6778247356414795,
-0.638171374797821,
-0.8350109457969666,
-0.33928918838500977,
-0.6754597425460815,
0.41676267981529236,
0.6760624647140503,
0.3243740499019623,
-0.0918874442577362,
1.2698521614074707,
-0.7560686469078064,
-0.22635245323181152,
-0.31168651580810547,
0.23418565094470978,
0.02331579476594925,
0.15612834692001343,
0.6558734178543091,
-1.2241511344909668,
0.07381621748209,
-0.23962800204753876,
-0.7888518571853638,
-0.15324194729328156,
-0.21698977053165436,
-0.24091185629367828,
0.16443049907684326,
0.23815332353115082,
-0.6519045233726501,
0.2788175642490387,
0.30895715951919556,
-0.6489397287368774,
0.591289222240448,
-0.058970313519239426,
0.6624212265014648,
-0.602008581161499,
-0.30967527627944946,
0.45971032977104187,
0.08062956482172012,
-0.6592303514480591,
0.15009421110153198,
-0.2293255478143692,
-0.13984167575836182,
-0.7115392088890076,
0.5778278708457947,
-0.1872730702161789,
-0.22094258666038513,
0.16209053993225098,
-0.020793071016669273,
0.291474848985672,
0.1700303554534912,
0.6325165033340454,
0.8740134239196777,
0.3897039592266083,
-0.6274803876876831,
0.40842315554618835,
0.40153682231903076,
-0.5832248330116272,
0.9448172450065613,
-0.6274517774581909,
-0.37893715500831604,
-0.2895420491695404,
-0.28171300888061523,
-1.0070579051971436,
-0.2801815867424011,
0.20567862689495087,
-0.4485536813735962,
0.028486615046858788,
0.05440351739525795,
-0.1047591120004654,
-0.4472412168979645,
-0.11063846200704575,
0.20867906510829926,
0.6464000940322876,
-0.2210700660943985,
0.5434161424636841,
0.6121959686279297,
-0.2244909405708313,
0.001499449135735631,
-0.9033458232879639,
0.3475428819656372,
-0.6767851114273071,
-0.7283026576042175,
-0.03694891184568405,
-0.28925377130508423,
-0.8971037268638611,
-0.13643336296081543,
0.28822168707847595,
-0.036717820912599564,
0.2822269797325134,
0.1566362977027893,
0.3804903030395508,
-0.4283655285835266,
-0.037778664380311966,
-0.37980979681015015,
-0.05426306650042534,
0.391992449760437,
-0.34493356943130493,
0.31848910450935364,
-0.17662128806114197,
-0.07302285730838776,
0.01125562097877264,
0.7600857019424438,
0.33479657769203186,
-0.31149134039878845,
0.3342592120170593,
0.16075341403484344,
-0.03189673647284508,
-0.032051920890808105,
-0.5742862224578857,
-0.43161827325820923,
-0.5473734140396118,
0.69278484582901,
-0.1457483023405075,
-0.7078253626823425,
0.43008750677108765,
0.06621359288692474,
-0.5588704347610474,
0.3391687572002411,
0.7519355416297913,
-0.4402821660041809,
1.3640528917312622,
0.6568880677223206,
0.09113822877407074,
0.6490595936775208,
-0.1050160676240921,
0.2686512768268585,
-0.8163235783576965,
-0.2832299470901489,
-0.11928939819335938,
-0.3975582420825958,
-0.42704957723617554,
-0.030810920521616936,
0.5578232407569885,
-0.16687768697738647,
-0.2342119812965393,
-0.08098893612623215,
-0.32435575127601624,
0.607419490814209,
0.4936130940914154,
0.24924111366271973,
0.09983362257480621,
-0.32260051369667053,
-0.05321885645389557,
-0.21393370628356934,
-0.8578163385391235,
-0.4227546751499176,
0.8882657289505005,
0.08070890605449677,
0.705246090888977,
0.35290268063545227,
0.4364452064037323,
0.4801318943500519,
0.26482656598091125,
-0.7528715133666992,
0.6794254183769226,
0.331285297870636,
-1.316184401512146,
-0.2660614848136902,
-0.040781598538160324,
-0.9818373322486877,
0.11156706511974335,
-0.44225186109542847,
-0.984595537185669,
0.6348018050193787,
0.018364224582910538,
-0.523255467414856,
0.24174781143665314,
-0.9205255508422852,
0.7851124405860901,
-0.6325625777244568,
-0.8760703802108765,
-0.1975373476743698,
-0.40598151087760925,
0.528769314289093,
0.1392700970172882,
0.46331140398979187,
-0.025088131427764893,
-0.06020881608128548,
1.081545114517212,
0.3319321870803833,
0.9055913686752319,
0.1733633279800415,
0.02078470215201378,
0.2991684079170227,
0.23657011985778809,
0.030196791514754295,
0.25869548320770264,
-0.04968686401844025,
0.03694305568933487,
-0.19371290504932404,
-0.08542903512716293,
-0.4022829234600067,
0.40816155076026917,
-0.6717438697814941,
-0.9000257849693298,
-0.5036883354187012,
-0.4966573417186737,
-0.3226717710494995,
0.11953194439411163,
0.42009034752845764,
0.6521807909011841,
-0.5235402584075928,
-0.13910594582557678,
0.7997487187385559,
-0.126790851354599,
0.48612621426582336,
0.6249295473098755,
-0.38757646083831787,
-0.015084845013916492,
0.5947223901748657,
0.25122055411338806,
0.48635774850845337,
0.02393479458987713,
0.27450838685035706,
-0.4687114357948303,
-0.15603268146514893,
-0.28210514783859253,
-0.06732800602912903,
-0.6907824277877808,
0.07845602929592133,
-0.11896596103906631,
0.30124330520629883,
-0.32395756244659424,
-0.5916153788566589,
-0.2867676615715027,
0.18016527593135834,
-0.3118804693222046,
-0.39143064618110657,
0.4364471733570099,
1.3569186925888062,
-0.36415478587150574,
0.2649615406990051,
-0.31207892298698425,
0.172440305352211,
0.40357285737991333,
0.5973284244537354,
0.06551213562488556,
0.033742986619472504,
0.005860486067831516,
0.1691620647907257,
-0.2949635088443756,
-1.29580557346344,
0.5517943501472473,
0.14134348928928375,
0.4671284258365631,
0.7086711525917053,
0.02960578352212906,
0.39148348569869995,
-0.6970718502998352,
1.0382602214813232,
0.23172245919704437,
-0.9121283888816833,
0.2680152952671051,
-0.680519163608551,
-0.0008614824619144201,
0.43850868940353394,
0.4964104890823364,
-0.7573029398918152,
0.12696073949337006,
-0.6060951352119446,
-0.5143886804580688,
0.8251376152038574,
-0.26404958963394165,
0.02106138877570629,
-0.41344067454338074,
0.30359700322151184,
-0.14391808211803436,
0.20427235960960388,
-0.7094452977180481,
-0.21227067708969116,
0.09873943030834198,
0.03998148813843727,
-0.5358385443687439,
-0.3613738715648651,
-0.13416709005832672,
-0.2141469419002533,
0.3755948543548584,
0.07422155141830444,
0.1612091362476349,
0.45129817724227905,
-0.17538850009441376,
-0.30056363344192505,
0.24717926979064941,
0.38706091046333313,
0.6391013264656067,
-0.12089657783508301,
-0.0019216908840462565,
0.09575317054986954,
-0.36234939098358154,
0.5594457387924194,
-0.4753871560096741,
-0.5683884620666504,
-0.2878050208091736,
0.03064391389489174,
0.6301981210708618,
0.8853966593742371,
-0.7819567918777466,
0.49250611662864685,
0.13669422268867493,
-0.4890335202217102,
-0.07754877954721451,
-0.060090262442827225,
-0.04877772927284241,
0.5600000619888306,
0.18669185042381287,
0.14344526827335358,
0.5660881996154785,
-0.9618455171585083,
0.29125791788101196,
0.4952865540981293,
-0.5797922611236572,
-0.42270854115486145,
0.7883037328720093,
0.4258904457092285,
-0.5303382277488708,
0.38095852732658386,
-0.304791659116745,
-0.935260534286499,
0.4151431918144226,
0.526555597782135,
0.6522672772407532,
-0.16668139398097992,
0.7662421464920044,
0.04115141183137894,
0.3629113435745239,
-0.47506409883499146,
0.28956615924835205,
0.11729098111391068,
-0.9468716979026794,
-0.2845686078071594,
-0.409387469291687,
-0.33285292983055115,
-0.500455379486084,
-0.866085410118103,
0.013348685577511787,
-0.13794419169425964,
-0.47469931840896606,
-0.08735306560993195,
-0.00890318863093853,
-0.7796592116355896,
0.32771891355514526,
0.6130269169807434,
0.6781616806983948,
-0.9908161759376526,
0.4841615855693817,
0.5891852974891663,
-0.6437562704086304,
-0.6006563901901245,
-0.39256060123443604,
0.3474574089050293,
-0.8865145444869995,
0.9329373836517334,
-0.25560376048088074,
-0.23920461535453796,
-0.11313264816999435,
-0.5020593404769897,
-1.0091240406036377,
0.5579218864440918,
0.19834432005882263,
-0.16277027130126953,
-0.33985093235969543,
0.2612771987915039,
0.22208049893379211,
-0.4900723397731781,
0.15662893652915955,
0.8124279975891113,
0.7112696170806885,
0.0033754431642591953,
-0.484866738319397,
-0.3633553087711334,
-0.24510182440280914,
0.004965151194483042,
0.2848469316959381,
-0.7927383780479431,
0.6205071210861206,
-0.43684640526771545,
-0.20519469678401947,
-0.1677248775959015,
0.42439204454421997,
-0.26722443103790283,
0.16674505174160004,
0.39207103848457336,
0.4848567545413971,
0.39379018545150757,
-0.24212990701198578,
1.2875492572784424,
-0.2922224700450897,
0.3367873728275299,
0.4640823304653168,
-0.6396399140357971,
1.0525658130645752,
0.5200504064559937,
-0.3083813786506653,
0.5276789665222168,
0.7718215584754944,
0.06798652559518814,
0.5510382056236267,
0.10342682898044586,
-0.03584039583802223,
-0.44998645782470703,
-0.2470715194940567,
-0.0032458805944770575,
0.9808067679405212,
0.36953598260879517,
-0.0006598781328648329,
-0.01853196881711483,
0.059041768312454224,
-0.014100133441388607,
0.09189523756504059,
-0.530037522315979,
0.9420363306999207,
-0.15648013353347778,
-0.96836918592453,
-0.2951229512691498,
-0.11033895611763,
0.9245285391807556,
-0.8072262406349182,
0.20237264037132263,
-0.00960624311119318,
0.17447364330291748,
-0.15770728886127472,
-0.9674497842788696,
0.27025264501571655,
-0.2637726664543152,
-0.27977263927459717,
-0.3143625259399414,
0.764444887638092,
-0.343486487865448,
-0.6002241969108582,
0.4146304428577423,
0.4193604588508606,
-0.2251942753791809,
0.03462522476911545,
-0.7584519386291504,
0.2364903837442398,
-0.12851741909980774,
-0.6220530867576599,
0.5509858131408691,
0.43688660860061646,
0.2295936942100525,
0.4268060326576233,
0.563439130783081,
0.22136792540550232,
0.09941020607948303,
-0.3690948486328125,
0.23191015422344208,
-0.7696412205696106,
-0.8518182635307312,
-0.9183307886123657,
0.3121253550052643,
-0.2024228423833847,
-0.4790695905685425,
0.6641237139701843,
0.41267502307891846,
0.8575137853622437,
-0.0062369657680392265,
0.666124165058136,
0.11549041420221329,
-0.15304502844810486,
-0.47415125370025635,
0.8856163620948792,
-0.5166229605674744,
-0.25099265575408936,
-0.3966526985168457,
-0.6581343412399292,
-0.1407504379749298,
0.8958685994148254,
-0.7214611768722534,
0.05190367251634598,
0.507934033870697,
0.6500017642974854,
0.2953547239303589,
0.2633649706840515,
0.2705085277557373,
0.19705335795879364,
0.033571578562259674,
0.46342960000038147,
0.8768969178199768,
0.14728562533855438,
0.15791510045528412,
-0.06892219930887222,
-0.3150954246520996,
-0.18252408504486084,
-0.8619737029075623,
-0.5897884964942932,
-1.018320918083191,
-0.16879700124263763,
-0.3082710802555084,
0.1864440143108368,
1.0304216146469116,
0.8210853338241577,
-0.27648770809173584,
-0.7271755933761597,
0.22810138761997223,
0.14723148941993713,
-0.13034670054912567,
-0.23601722717285156,
-0.2645021080970764,
-0.5187881588935852,
-0.5512593388557434,
-0.1749495267868042,
0.5831320285797119,
-0.11795035004615784,
-0.3338353633880615,
-0.18444448709487915,
-0.4484943747520447,
0.6456253528594971,
0.8669236302375793,
0.258894681930542,
-0.7154266238212585,
-0.32448193430900574,
0.27770909667015076,
0.11062996834516525,
0.2308025360107422,
0.9571782946586609,
-0.5580698251724243,
0.39362379908561707,
0.16531623899936676,
0.22010448575019836,
0.18591398000717163,
-0.45242998003959656,
0.9185649752616882,
0.014023538678884506,
0.2533876299858093,
0.070326067507267,
0.6835506558418274,
0.1564299762248993,
-0.2935143709182739,
0.5138466954231262,
0.3803889751434326,
-0.41468560695648193,
-0.5630918145179749,
0.5158044099807739,
-0.729329526424408,
-0.17292186617851257,
1.472395896911621,
0.2615189552307129,
-0.6406563520431519,
0.16081111133098602,
-0.4495432674884796,
-0.22437921166419983,
-0.38082176446914673,
0.8349748849868774,
1.2343753576278687,
-0.10929980874061584,
-0.12034416198730469,
-0.7291463613510132,
0.5881392359733582,
0.4755712151527405,
-0.38770151138305664,
-0.02648245543241501,
0.5541998744010925,
0.043201617896556854,
-0.06527714431285858,
0.3533993661403656,
0.040310125797986984,
0.30541935563087463,
0.12079405039548874,
-0.023984134197235107,
0.33257153630256653,
-0.20434238016605377,
-0.24986481666564941,
0.23137016594409943,
0.1948866844177246,
0.29015785455703735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15279v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15279v2
|
Fundus: A Simple-to-Use News Scraper Optimized for High Quality Extractions
| 2024-03-22T15:22:06 | 2024-06-24T09:18:48 |
Max Dallabetta, Conrad Dobberstein, Adrian Breiding, Alan Akbik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper introduces Fundus, a user-friendly news scraper that enables users
to obtain millions of high-quality news articles with just a few lines of code.
Unlike existing news scrapers, we use manually crafted, bespoke content
extractors that are specifically tailored to the formatting guidelines of each
supported online newspaper. This allows us to optimize our scraping for quality
such that retrieved news articles are textually complete and without HTML
artifacts. Further, our framework combines both crawling (retrieving HTML from
the web or large web archives) and content extraction into a single pipeline.
By providing a unified interface for a predefined collection of newspapers, we
aim to make Fundus broadly usable even for non-technical users. This paper
gives an overview of the framework, discusses our design choices, and presents
a comparative evaluation against other popular news scrapers. Our evaluation
shows that Fundus yields significantly higher quality extractions (complete and
artifact-free news articles) than prior work. The framework is available on
GitHub under https://github.com/flairNLP/fundus and can be simply installed
using pip.
|
[
-0.21202746033668518,
-0.3776097893714905,
0.4582657814025879,
0.5082578063011169,
-0.34270980954170227,
0.1885211020708084,
-0.12886680662631989,
-0.5307868123054504,
0.9160570502281189,
0.13549086451530457,
0.021445875987410545,
-0.313351035118103,
-0.3822685778141022,
0.0993383377790451,
-0.754671037197113,
0.9802628755569458,
0.25819990038871765,
0.015435155481100082,
-0.11677302420139313,
0.10283880680799484,
0.29179930686950684,
0.32290786504745483,
-0.7793854475021362,
0.16395053267478943,
0.7007655501365662,
0.6885188221931458,
0.6814903020858765,
0.8859739899635315,
0.673264741897583,
0.25687336921691895,
0.08336188644170761,
0.018543390557169914,
-0.6445786952972412,
-0.11668147146701813,
-0.401104211807251,
-0.2626466751098633,
-0.2598353624343872,
0.07959876954555511,
0.0063295066356658936,
0.6104376316070557,
-0.12073338031768799,
0.46285536885261536,
0.07875755429267883,
0.7887341976165771,
-0.6152958273887634,
-0.2473047375679016,
-0.3956432640552521,
-0.33230286836624146,
-0.5300394892692566,
-0.18251283466815948,
-0.3269137144088745,
-0.7394360899925232,
-0.19582654535770416,
-1.0829123258590698,
0.2178879827260971,
0.22766178846359253,
1.4460033178329468,
-0.11014514416456223,
-0.10458804666996002,
-0.24854612350463867,
-0.25256967544555664,
0.619932234287262,
-0.4741562306880951,
0.4957035183906555,
0.2839517891407013,
0.34747084975242615,
-0.025965971872210503,
-1.086071252822876,
-0.33434924483299255,
0.36977750062942505,
-0.05443675071001053,
0.313381165266037,
-0.5871561169624329,
-0.553922176361084,
-0.07745286077260971,
0.6643784046173096,
-0.5681886672973633,
-0.1340024769306183,
-0.7586033344268799,
-0.013303139247000217,
0.3263980448246002,
-0.26521989703178406,
0.19243693351745605,
-0.5010714530944824,
-0.8541195392608643,
0.0593271441757679,
-0.5803986191749573,
0.40686535835266113,
0.7085939645767212,
0.002920196857303381,
0.14997895061969757,
0.43295034766197205,
-0.5559056401252747,
0.43976888060569763,
-0.04505627602338791,
-0.3169058561325073,
0.2701347768306732,
0.10377983003854752,
-0.19961358606815338,
-0.18746666610240936,
0.775504469871521,
0.23934917151927948,
-0.054957736283540726,
-0.5384670495986938,
-0.7954200506210327,
-0.030695131048560143,
0.6196456551551819,
-0.5410048365592957,
-0.4383445084095001,
0.34964802861213684,
-0.7865542769432068,
-0.9067741632461548,
0.5989677309989929,
-1.2804193496704102,
-0.14212311804294586,
-0.16127218306064606,
0.35298630595207214,
-0.32221704721450806,
-0.17507027089595795,
0.30641141533851624,
-0.7398393154144287,
0.07015763223171234,
0.6357904672622681,
-0.6946448683738708,
0.5330628156661987,
0.7111172676086426,
0.835307240486145,
-0.42722365260124207,
0.10903479903936386,
-1.3718781471252441,
0.0736204981803894,
-0.15548910200595856,
1.1425079107284546,
-0.3103651702404022,
0.06812696903944016,
-0.08964274078607559,
0.02981281653046608,
0.40547797083854675,
-0.48907774686813354,
0.8041247725486755,
-0.8909427523612976,
0.2764461934566498,
-0.467115193605423,
-0.20644545555114746,
-0.45634809136390686,
-0.10042602568864822,
-1.0893886089324951,
0.7802056074142456,
0.6197099685668945,
-0.8665480613708496,
0.5246213674545288,
-0.571290135383606,
-0.8035210371017456,
0.2065921276807785,
0.14624500274658203,
-0.1585283726453781,
0.4262527525424957,
0.18754592537879944,
0.11407209187746048,
-0.05912884697318077,
-0.09641893208026886,
-0.2507978677749634,
-0.2598241865634918,
-0.17286086082458496,
0.04089983180165291,
0.8002262115478516,
0.8199761509895325,
-0.028978770598769188,
0.22911636531352997,
-0.7865934371948242,
-0.18861794471740723,
0.26254013180732727,
-0.7989737391471863,
-0.39916425943374634,
0.08249091356992722,
0.5238490700721741,
-0.0049661449156701565,
0.30534863471984863,
-0.8466812372207642,
0.24027295410633087,
-0.2864872217178345,
0.4965660870075226,
0.5771183371543884,
-0.3378601372241974,
0.5907807350158691,
-0.5646273493766785,
0.3295302093029022,
-0.28708529472351074,
-0.002003013389185071,
-0.49515214562416077,
0.07363641262054443,
-0.760865330696106,
-0.4011049270629883,
0.6146207451820374,
0.4915885627269745,
-0.4931299686431885,
-0.004265595227479935,
-0.32839781045913696,
-0.33960312604904175,
-0.31939244270324707,
0.40723344683647156,
-0.11039955914020538,
0.2087378054857254,
0.08155447244644165,
-0.5051007866859436,
-0.6789196133613586,
-0.5044564008712769,
-0.28380289673805237,
0.09932961314916611,
-0.2605513036251068,
-0.09748492389917374,
0.28907114267349243,
0.3069595396518707,
1.168050765991211,
-0.47510114312171936,
-0.056874632835388184,
-0.3234766721725464,
-0.004464193247258663,
0.3350621163845062,
0.2923869490623474,
0.4934620261192322,
-1.128969669342041,
0.2222861647605896,
-0.024826591834425926,
-0.6713625192642212,
-0.04428093507885933,
-0.1544528752565384,
-0.3026043772697449,
-0.006957686971873045,
0.27365440130233765,
-0.6327972412109375,
0.21748888492584229,
0.5197205543518066,
-0.24668993055820465,
0.5906907320022583,
0.2901078760623932,
0.14606143534183502,
-1.1066185235977173,
0.4808969497680664,
0.25178849697113037,
-0.7290909886360168,
-0.17134998738765717,
0.3353278338909149,
-0.030371135100722313,
-0.27790969610214233,
-0.7338694334030151,
0.5097017288208008,
-0.3784846067428589,
-0.41325846314430237,
-0.06072179973125458,
0.5486370325088501,
0.5133152604103088,
0.021447883918881416,
-0.15833286941051483,
0.707443118095398,
-0.030358247458934784,
-0.368163138628006,
0.36187246441841125,
-0.014665077440440655,
-0.2758025825023651,
0.23940420150756836,
-0.6847224831581116,
0.018393365666270256,
0.03787505626678467,
-0.224818155169487,
-0.8536897301673889,
-0.4075808823108673,
0.06500022113323212,
-0.4438091218471527,
0.24781981110572815,
0.11654563248157501,
-0.44207364320755005,
-0.22701512277126312,
-0.8346800804138184,
-0.07408317923545837,
0.30316343903541565,
-0.637535572052002,
0.1620379388332367,
0.5673183798789978,
-0.34352943301200867,
-0.3756552040576935,
-0.26310646533966064,
0.2699905335903168,
-0.26249027252197266,
-0.7166421413421631,
0.17817212641239166,
0.04231547564268112,
-0.5350251793861389,
0.18128138780593872,
-0.4799650013446808,
-0.1369033306837082,
0.2837975025177002,
0.10311730951070786,
0.20399723947048187,
-0.4472353458404541,
-0.11390894651412964,
0.19307303428649902,
-0.2707373797893524,
-0.21713632345199585,
-0.2666868567466736,
0.5315842032432556,
-0.26774439215660095,
-0.013097020797431469,
-0.30596688389778137,
0.30613937973976135,
0.5569387078285217,
-0.6347447633743286,
-0.03511924296617508,
0.4861864745616913,
-0.5151452422142029,
0.08713896572589874,
-0.5347684621810913,
-0.18361981213092804,
-0.45115455985069275,
-0.07969987392425537,
-0.26105445623397827,
-0.49169886112213135,
0.32494691014289856,
-0.4585351049900055,
0.4360247552394867,
0.6568339467048645,
-0.06689037382602692,
-0.343326210975647,
0.47091034054756165,
0.7145165205001831,
-0.36061543226242065,
0.2706320881843567,
-0.26583337783813477,
-0.414270281791687,
-0.2696479558944702,
-0.03848719224333763,
-0.8252723813056946,
-0.38684165477752686,
0.03199286013841629,
0.09931553900241852,
-0.2569293677806854,
0.4371584355831146,
0.0549970306456089,
0.3104840815067291,
-0.32271093130111694,
0.6272027492523193,
0.7214977741241455,
-0.16609612107276917,
0.7251344323158264,
0.2822404205799103,
0.4253242611885071,
0.13361480832099915,
-0.6625935435295105,
-0.9501848816871643,
0.7554481029510498,
0.3356933891773224,
1.0025076866149902,
0.057783592492341995,
1.0589854717254639,
0.5201699137687683,
0.3812444508075714,
-0.841667652130127,
0.13895273208618164,
-0.19606414437294006,
-0.4927951395511627,
-0.1352308690547943,
-0.30405375361442566,
-1.084995150566101,
0.11958085745573044,
-0.13189797103405,
-0.6699024438858032,
0.2012011557817459,
-0.44447749853134155,
-0.6067972779273987,
0.5319092869758606,
-0.4422726631164551,
0.6305769681930542,
0.0039425198920071125,
-0.2624450922012329,
-0.16619311273097992,
-0.4314466714859009,
0.41108590364456177,
-0.13715305924415588,
0.741997241973877,
-0.026762116700410843,
-0.41763001680374146,
0.8334847092628479,
-0.33131495118141174,
0.4067598581314087,
0.13771583139896393,
0.11107543855905533,
0.364533931016922,
0.38287627696990967,
0.25869274139404297,
0.428246408700943,
0.002648274414241314,
0.2510259449481964,
0.1859009563922882,
-0.6612901091575623,
-0.16431856155395508,
0.7040961384773254,
-0.642553448677063,
-0.38246142864227295,
-0.3991955518722534,
-0.11561964452266693,
0.4342533349990845,
0.6688944697380066,
0.1523667871952057,
0.6206390857696533,
-0.327316552400589,
0.29366785287857056,
0.3869996666908264,
0.010096943937242031,
0.9651797413825989,
0.2974259555339813,
-0.4139815866947174,
-0.6696198582649231,
1.2335554361343384,
-0.27581870555877686,
-0.27793389558792114,
0.4207957983016968,
0.15486109256744385,
0.023443005979061127,
-0.3372936248779297,
-0.8387365937232971,
0.036888595670461655,
-0.25487062335014343,
-0.7332640290260315,
-0.5105102062225342,
0.1676800549030304,
-0.18776310980319977,
-0.49740076065063477,
-0.5403143167495728,
-0.7473675012588501,
-0.5203342437744141,
-0.024846728891134262,
-0.07045968621969223,
0.794474720954895,
-0.16581322252750397,
0.3235737681388855,
-0.910734236240387,
0.6071789264678955,
0.03070242516696453,
0.20859764516353607,
-0.43957120180130005,
0.13828250765800476,
-0.2621116042137146,
-0.31761595606803894,
-0.5310163497924805,
-1.1263033151626587,
0.5919463634490967,
0.0661320835351944,
0.21572764217853546,
1.0277090072631836,
0.25225353240966797,
0.40397101640701294,
-0.1313614398241043,
0.6311815977096558,
0.17411693930625916,
-0.8501600027084351,
0.661727786064148,
-0.6140546798706055,
-0.14513565599918365,
0.8718340992927551,
0.4135703146457672,
-0.38765448331832886,
-0.3190189003944397,
-0.4878063499927521,
-0.662338376045227,
0.4787938892841339,
0.1369282454252243,
-0.08631999045610428,
-0.11700718849897385,
0.36239534616470337,
0.7398775815963745,
0.1327291876077652,
-0.4420025050640106,
0.10588040947914124,
-0.38751065731048584,
-0.13496741652488708,
0.3035721182823181,
-0.3499840199947357,
-0.27321743965148926,
0.0910210981965065,
0.49854445457458496,
0.0590827651321888,
-0.01839352399110794,
0.3620014488697052,
-0.4393896758556366,
-0.5976960062980652,
0.1760658621788025,
0.3171079456806183,
1.1578916311264038,
-0.26944926381111145,
0.2967184782028198,
-0.20290222764015198,
-0.4909203350543976,
-0.30304306745529175,
0.3046097457408905,
-0.2550813555717468,
0.21287187933921814,
0.15570436418056488,
0.002627601381391287,
0.5191924571990967,
-0.742988109588623,
0.7453177571296692,
-0.351453959941864,
-0.1356857270002365,
-0.3791167736053467,
0.042468421161174774,
0.027371488511562347,
0.5051762461662292,
0.8383835554122925,
0.36196696758270264,
0.42987361550331116,
-0.1860804259777069,
0.6220822930335999,
0.21845804154872894,
-0.1800631284713745,
-0.25305595993995667,
1.1694903373718262,
0.4575575590133667,
-0.3398130536079407,
0.5060450434684753,
-0.448426216840744,
-0.1153707280755043,
0.24574004113674164,
0.4312053322792053,
0.4901173710823059,
0.18910466134548187,
0.3279733955860138,
0.023416290059685707,
0.291253924369812,
-0.14821405708789825,
0.49359330534935,
0.04229449853301048,
-0.4372512400150299,
-0.5862102508544922,
-0.9065374732017517,
-0.2617031931877136,
-0.12119273841381073,
-0.8278449177742004,
0.5275062322616577,
-0.4244290888309479,
0.0666363462805748,
0.11076024174690247,
0.45371270179748535,
-0.3263954818248749,
0.12817168235778809,
0.014685436151921749,
1.5152398347854614,
-0.4369635283946991,
0.6153101325035095,
0.8900519013404846,
-0.49739572405815125,
-0.594957172870636,
-0.20399950444698334,
0.21209518611431122,
-0.5554814338684082,
0.17060603201389313,
0.33274874091148376,
0.03789820894598961,
0.36277127265930176,
-0.543537437915802,
-0.6323480010032654,
1.1194241046905518,
0.5533851385116577,
-0.40299269556999207,
-0.1520615965127945,
-0.37197795510292053,
-0.27887001633644104,
-0.07553447037935257,
-0.0013559444341808558,
0.11614957451820374,
0.5064356327056885,
-0.08607086539268494,
-0.5650995373725891,
0.1213848739862442,
-0.3389389216899872,
-0.640359103679657,
0.2458757758140564,
-0.8872201442718506,
0.7476112842559814,
-0.35420018434524536,
-0.39980995655059814,
0.14483387768268585,
0.9299089312553406,
-0.15250559151172638,
0.6953547596931458,
0.5844159722328186,
0.7394170165061951,
0.7988377809524536,
-0.27843302488327026,
1.1187635660171509,
-0.4540497660636902,
0.4512476921081543,
0.2650355100631714,
0.3785037100315094,
0.8372066617012024,
0.47277283668518066,
-0.15256048738956451,
0.49541208148002625,
0.49623334407806396,
0.04414718970656395,
0.4183048605918884,
-0.10809963196516037,
-0.07343641668558121,
-0.19638614356517792,
0.09844091534614563,
-0.1546957641839981,
0.7095526456832886,
-0.1285371482372284,
-0.11696654558181763,
-0.4251500368118286,
-0.30183231830596924,
0.5207952260971069,
-0.04021556302905083,
-0.36932459473609924,
0.4730837345123291,
0.2071831375360489,
-0.19860118627548218,
-0.05575807765126228,
0.32323548197746277,
0.7241251468658447,
-0.586610734462738,
0.022939126938581467,
-0.5129614472389221,
-0.11318110674619675,
-0.45531564950942993,
-0.5000469088554382,
0.3695741295814514,
-0.11819794028997421,
-0.13899962604045868,
-0.2727515995502472,
1.0465307235717773,
0.13148178160190582,
-0.22371616959571838,
-0.16150140762329102,
0.8621737360954285,
0.3002554774284363,
-0.39745089411735535,
-0.24999520182609558,
0.19704535603523254,
-0.1253218799829483,
-0.7107914686203003,
0.3976909816265106,
0.4608917236328125,
0.30065426230430603,
0.27951186895370483,
1.2329570055007935,
0.3091539144515991,
-0.3249834477901459,
-0.3143082857131958,
1.0734894275665283,
-0.8822004199028015,
-0.572982132434845,
-0.7623619437217712,
0.41062670946121216,
-0.33291974663734436,
-0.4057512879371643,
0.6758971810340881,
1.2830071449279785,
0.8268426060676575,
0.004995341412723064,
0.5368455052375793,
-0.22296679019927979,
0.3804644048213959,
-0.20726895332336426,
1.0177823305130005,
-0.7718323469161987,
-0.07289063185453415,
-0.31924283504486084,
-0.84234619140625,
-0.19656264781951904,
0.6203624606132507,
0.3298434615135193,
-0.4816135764122009,
0.5232369899749756,
0.21324476599693298,
-0.373225599527359,
0.4352855980396271,
0.06341040879487991,
-0.35889574885368347,
0.33658918738365173,
0.19083935022354126,
0.5694995522499084,
-0.22741854190826416,
0.8918350338935852,
-0.29367029666900635,
-0.3000752031803131,
-0.19981522858142853,
-0.6888085007667542,
-0.32035213708877563,
-0.2660055458545685,
0.05110786110162735,
-0.29159000515937805,
0.13243137300014496,
0.5481042265892029,
0.7945283055305481,
-0.6411569714546204,
-0.2678544521331787,
0.24508826434612274,
0.375107079744339,
-0.2680492699146271,
-0.2740580439567566,
0.3384544253349304,
-0.6978120803833008,
-0.7324770092964172,
0.4451897442340851,
0.5013893842697144,
-0.45199865102767944,
0.06200485676527023,
0.0745338723063469,
-0.06546662002801895,
-0.24698737263679504,
0.4571259617805481,
0.551368236541748,
-0.2138158529996872,
-0.3131019175052643,
0.18223892152309418,
-0.24119536578655243,
0.40700751543045044,
0.892641007900238,
-0.9298521280288696,
0.017562102526426315,
0.5305697917938232,
0.6500880718231201,
0.4412989616394043,
0.2630936801433563,
0.26457175612449646,
-0.44748708605766296,
0.04138121381402016,
-0.075053870677948,
0.3705480098724365,
0.053328994661569595,
-0.2745720446109772,
0.5516282916069031,
0.530614972114563,
-0.2740418314933777,
-0.754358172416687,
-0.13202373683452606,
-1.2653411626815796,
-0.2792631983757019,
1.0313210487365723,
-0.21200841665267944,
-0.45102158188819885,
0.020590515807271004,
-0.2830870449542999,
0.12929683923721313,
-0.7952073812484741,
0.6768226623535156,
0.16985148191452026,
0.07820168882608414,
0.07698599994182587,
-0.8229877352714539,
0.15700770914554596,
-0.07255350798368454,
-0.7688307762145996,
-0.37506675720214844,
0.4629404544830322,
0.572468638420105,
0.25131240487098694,
0.4745100438594818,
-0.24229441583156586,
0.34488445520401,
0.19028079509735107,
0.11484631150960922,
-0.21496348083019257,
-0.4255833625793457,
-0.06204525753855705,
0.7653314471244812,
-0.2158707082271576,
-0.2828817367553711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15278v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15278v2
|
Specifying Genericity through Inclusiveness and Abstractness Continuous Scales
| 2024-03-22T15:21:07 | 2024-03-29T22:43:37 |
Claudia Collacciani, Andrea Amelio Ravelli, Marianna Marcella Bolognesi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a novel annotation framework for the fine-grained
modeling of Noun Phrases' (NPs) genericity in natural language. The framework
is designed to be simple and intuitive, making it accessible to non-expert
annotators and suitable for crowd-sourced tasks. Drawing from theoretical and
cognitive literature on genericity, this framework is grounded in established
linguistic theory. Through a pilot study, we created a small but crucial
annotated dataset of 324 sentences, serving as a foundation for future
research. To validate our approach, we conducted an evaluation comparing our
continuous annotations with existing binary annotations on the same dataset,
demonstrating the framework's effectiveness in capturing nuanced aspects of
genericity. Our work offers a practical resource for linguists, providing a
first annotated dataset and an annotation scheme designed to build
real-language datasets that can be used in studies on the semantics of
genericity, and NLP practitioners, contributing to the development of
commonsense knowledge repositories valuable in enhancing various NLP
applications.
|
[
-0.5104984045028687,
-0.3443200886249542,
0.3195900321006775,
0.3494100868701935,
-0.28355929255485535,
-0.35397979617118835,
-0.4320196807384491,
-0.56107097864151,
0.37497958540916443,
0.1867368221282959,
-0.04826529324054718,
-0.5616470575332642,
-0.569378674030304,
0.4590882956981659,
-0.5067653059959412,
1.0688464641571045,
0.2351243644952774,
-0.30647560954093933,
-0.19230636954307556,
-0.7766575217247009,
-0.04120541736483574,
-0.5706347823143005,
-0.5081855654716492,
-0.18365980684757233,
0.749316930770874,
0.1274067908525467,
1.0638184547424316,
0.7542620301246643,
0.21717925369739532,
0.2261812537908554,
-0.32084622979164124,
-0.10936858505010605,
-0.12449055910110474,
0.12967140972614288,
-0.5079798102378845,
-0.13160258531570435,
-0.3052452802658081,
-0.027058536186814308,
0.8455447554588318,
1.1555200815200806,
0.01342786569148302,
0.26071134209632874,
0.1768369823694229,
0.45442894101142883,
-0.7489302158355713,
0.2831874489784241,
-0.6454945206642151,
-0.05669485405087471,
-0.30308690667152405,
0.38046643137931824,
-0.07516952604055405,
-0.48390528559684753,
0.061031267046928406,
-0.8772261738777161,
-0.05345241352915764,
-0.20832061767578125,
0.9111483693122864,
-0.09736908972263336,
-0.24489527940750122,
-0.41897648572921753,
-0.4568232297897339,
0.6538745760917664,
-0.720938503742218,
-0.01640414446592331,
0.1642702966928482,
0.46751898527145386,
0.09566274285316467,
-0.8252537250518799,
-0.6602933406829834,
-0.3844360113143921,
-0.2759985029697418,
-0.2318078726530075,
0.021973950788378716,
0.2808097004890442,
-0.012025569565594196,
0.4996574819087982,
-0.15633933246135712,
0.23050449788570404,
-0.1949700117111206,
0.011083594523370266,
0.4818633198738098,
-0.3249174952507019,
0.1390792429447174,
-0.35959407687187195,
-0.3400186598300934,
0.6496273875236511,
-0.50855553150177,
-0.05472469702363014,
0.21425992250442505,
0.7839334607124329,
-0.16945941746234894,
0.6186600923538208,
-0.4944719672203064,
0.6238681077957153,
-0.3935892879962921,
0.13780324161052704,
0.30291253328323364,
-0.13708244264125824,
0.08886301517486572,
-0.40104344487190247,
0.39488735795021057,
0.3356522023677826,
0.7915617823600769,
-0.5535053014755249,
-0.3684912919998169,
0.3842570185661316,
0.10778847336769104,
-0.3464609384536743,
-0.059675607830286026,
0.290193110704422,
-0.32642337679862976,
-0.31168481707572937,
0.12534567713737488,
-0.5440582036972046,
-0.146482914686203,
-0.5863240957260132,
0.1339009404182434,
-0.3039819598197937,
-0.4877762198448181,
-0.004328972660005093,
-0.33169636130332947,
0.02280978485941887,
-0.026038141921162605,
-1.020403265953064,
0.7444502115249634,
1.0739879608154297,
0.9255968332290649,
0.019556893035769463,
-0.1973784863948822,
-0.1671680361032486,
0.18266434967517853,
-0.25238439440727234,
0.9179685115814209,
-0.7582300305366516,
-0.13760915398597717,
0.41620516777038574,
-0.25159934163093567,
0.022766459733247757,
-0.6334385871887207,
0.2890399992465973,
-0.05961117893457413,
-0.3668942451477051,
-0.08608582615852356,
-0.6126813292503357,
-0.27225247025489807,
0.6615003347396851,
-0.652999222278595,
1.0617090463638306,
0.41629987955093384,
-0.4864845871925354,
0.7199749946594238,
-0.8675619959831238,
-0.13258345425128937,
0.6292638182640076,
-0.40184712409973145,
0.12375796586275101,
0.2021850198507309,
-0.232168510556221,
0.40382152795791626,
0.18627135455608368,
0.525276780128479,
-0.6183760762214661,
-0.04324622452259064,
0.42192715406417847,
0.005644739139825106,
0.31298449635505676,
0.007731112651526928,
-0.31059926748275757,
-0.09774237126111984,
-1.0131362676620483,
-0.07660514116287231,
-0.38957858085632324,
-0.3051236867904663,
-0.4800175726413727,
0.09213779866695404,
0.5901692509651184,
0.3057411015033722,
0.23581042885780334,
-0.5484352707862854,
0.33012324571609497,
-0.28511691093444824,
0.5426600575447083,
0.6692848801612854,
-0.2856926918029785,
0.5558298826217651,
-0.3755612075328827,
0.3296457827091217,
-0.2253841906785965,
0.24804367125034332,
0.08868014812469482,
-0.6624898910522461,
-0.3993562161922455,
-0.49222710728645325,
0.7062923312187195,
0.2935446500778198,
-0.4488659203052521,
0.6066632866859436,
-0.3349412679672241,
-0.11813074350357056,
-0.375739723443985,
0.0631939247250557,
0.42665210366249084,
0.3408310115337372,
0.3073447644710541,
-0.368956595659256,
-0.6248924136161804,
-1.0773518085479736,
-0.25662875175476074,
-0.14596451818943024,
-0.4932464063167572,
0.04818258807063103,
0.6783192157745361,
-0.3379167318344116,
1.4322376251220703,
0.07331674546003342,
-0.325363427400589,
-0.15788127481937408,
0.4181523025035858,
-0.13491061329841614,
0.6904876828193665,
0.5320796966552734,
-0.8871858716011047,
0.1664576530456543,
0.012034707702696323,
-0.8273964524269104,
-0.12520141899585724,
-0.09760668873786926,
0.020870758220553398,
0.029881222173571587,
0.3019101619720459,
-0.34480687975883484,
0.35628408193588257,
0.546754777431488,
-0.2825291156768799,
0.5093433260917664,
0.09223321080207825,
-0.2542456090450287,
-0.8845751881599426,
0.3121733069419861,
0.2864421308040619,
-0.2352578043937683,
-0.5060483813285828,
0.5105133652687073,
-0.17893856763839722,
0.06005099043250084,
-0.47336021065711975,
1.0183407068252563,
0.03828360140323639,
-0.08308102190494537,
-0.07200489193201065,
0.5373637676239014,
-0.1282525509595871,
0.23962759971618652,
0.11393555253744125,
0.2331961840391159,
0.14631251990795135,
-0.7013198733329773,
-0.11456934362649918,
0.1159633994102478,
-0.07521369308233261,
0.8142814636230469,
-0.6374812126159668,
-0.3310212194919586,
-0.2922750413417816,
0.2964625954627991,
-0.7676997780799866,
-0.37866079807281494,
0.22293619811534882,
-0.4316331148147583,
-0.24095192551612854,
-0.4938209354877472,
-0.829865038394928,
0.03655993193387985,
-0.1513524353504181,
0.6508781313896179,
0.25024843215942383,
-0.2853412330150604,
0.51924729347229,
0.5097993612289429,
-0.135857954621315,
-0.12512357532978058,
-0.6021895408630371,
0.22500833868980408,
-0.21833036839962006,
-0.4030129313468933,
0.23084774613380432,
0.10465298593044281,
-0.5473342537879944,
-0.08199555426836014,
0.23179666697978973,
-0.3892174959182739,
0.15798978507518768,
0.199165478348732,
0.16280430555343628,
-0.04783725365996361,
0.4399513304233551,
0.1393788903951645,
-0.2664300799369812,
-0.21737422049045563,
-0.4716985821723938,
0.24481606483459473,
-0.2518005669116974,
0.08199460804462433,
-0.11150313168764114,
0.629946231842041,
0.13449618220329285,
0.27601808309555054,
0.5077989101409912,
0.3934033215045929,
-0.7809683680534363,
-0.024430174380540848,
-0.48223379254341125,
0.13282500207424164,
-0.4289621412754059,
0.008343306370079517,
-0.38618361949920654,
-1.1225048303604126,
0.7694057822227478,
-0.19152989983558655,
0.6033434271812439,
0.6924036741256714,
0.0394916869699955,
0.09601530432701111,
0.5915350317955017,
0.45648595690727234,
0.269140362739563,
-0.008658170700073242,
-0.07757684588432312,
-0.12098678946495056,
-0.914245069026947,
-0.2291678786277771,
-0.6935626864433289,
-0.4726872146129608,
-0.7183709144592285,
-0.26761218905448914,
-0.09460532665252686,
0.3247656226158142,
-0.37741777300834656,
0.26347917318344116,
-0.6048073768615723,
0.2541980743408203,
0.19515562057495117,
-0.3858180344104767,
0.17608876526355743,
-0.2891201376914978,
-0.1231517493724823,
-0.24129699170589447,
-0.36509156227111816,
-1.020493745803833,
0.901240348815918,
0.49653950333595276,
0.23230725526809692,
0.11800830066204071,
0.7974899411201477,
0.23147153854370117,
0.6076106429100037,
-0.7006811499595642,
0.6633954048156738,
-0.34924229979515076,
-0.8754367232322693,
-0.33481061458587646,
-0.30460938811302185,
-0.8926725387573242,
0.190880686044693,
-0.1822308897972107,
-0.9933080077171326,
0.5827455520629883,
0.28373321890830994,
-0.42497119307518005,
0.23526631295681,
-0.46042880415916443,
0.6619679927825928,
0.3770584762096405,
0.18436117470264435,
0.3041769862174988,
-0.36607158184051514,
0.3336910605430603,
0.10403875261545181,
0.6894551515579224,
-0.5175100564956665,
-0.6644214391708374,
0.7318437099456787,
-0.16415289044380188,
1.0283113718032837,
-0.23417536914348602,
0.2051607221364975,
0.12564146518707275,
-0.03488893434405327,
0.10962317138910294,
0.5202116370201111,
-0.2217862904071808,
0.4777214229106903,
0.12937329709529877,
-0.8077197074890137,
-0.4596097469329834,
0.5057916045188904,
-0.20169596374034882,
0.11976858228445053,
-0.4562138319015503,
-0.5710439682006836,
-0.21529608964920044,
0.11278653889894485,
0.0532769151031971,
0.46292614936828613,
-0.1701151728630066,
0.030750734731554985,
0.47055190801620483,
0.2569916248321533,
0.3881674110889435,
0.10391992330551147,
-0.303957998752594,
-0.515936553478241,
0.7787163257598877,
0.40005436539649963,
0.3428664803504944,
0.22043247520923615,
0.12260375171899796,
-0.21693213284015656,
-0.5786464810371399,
-0.21054023504257202,
0.0004724053724203259,
-0.6960382461547852,
-0.0888463482260704,
-0.5735043287277222,
-0.21606013178825378,
-0.5839146375656128,
-0.6381112337112427,
-0.3739956021308899,
-1.0411708354949951,
-0.12416118383407593,
-0.2019491046667099,
0.5192297101020813,
0.7512267827987671,
-0.2764489948749542,
0.22706584632396698,
-0.47218993306159973,
0.4151041805744171,
0.3790396749973297,
0.513382613658905,
-0.03992185741662979,
-0.4980584979057312,
-0.08655931055545807,
-0.06570407748222351,
0.05619804561138153,
-0.36124610900878906,
0.12400984019041061,
0.5176931619644165,
0.4991518259048462,
0.5454419255256653,
0.10567664355039597,
0.3877224028110504,
-0.3639403283596039,
1.0210307836532593,
0.19755029678344727,
-0.9839159846305847,
0.39427754282951355,
-0.465689092874527,
0.42962726950645447,
1.1096917390823364,
0.381392240524292,
-0.7407124638557434,
-0.6086511015892029,
-0.7402820587158203,
-1.3568787574768066,
-0.22876247763633728,
0.36156606674194336,
0.3963554799556732,
-0.5800746083259583,
0.7091342806816101,
0.4800518751144409,
0.24677130579948425,
-1.0755736827850342,
-0.23288685083389282,
-0.22854746878147125,
-0.3337414264678955,
0.09887085109949112,
-0.41416066884994507,
-0.23437705636024475,
-0.1945633590221405,
0.4445585012435913,
-0.33762356638908386,
-0.04786376655101776,
0.05223437771201134,
-0.08506949245929718,
0.5132341980934143,
0.4760550260543823,
0.4027765989303589,
0.9787038564682007,
-0.3117541968822479,
0.10238763689994812,
-0.13694125413894653,
-0.354937344789505,
-0.07793869078159332,
0.41337743401527405,
-0.47732123732566833,
0.4857073128223419,
0.2980331778526306,
0.09768050909042358,
0.9769794344902039,
-0.5316996574401855,
0.18110312521457672,
0.13315299153327942,
-0.2289361208677292,
-0.7119408249855042,
-0.297905296087265,
0.05361110717058182,
-0.051286324858665466,
0.5756675004959106,
0.037647757679224014,
0.3487936556339264,
-0.49902716279029846,
0.4840613901615143,
0.1744072139263153,
-0.4177773594856262,
-0.25535979866981506,
0.43089377880096436,
0.248590886592865,
-0.2417079508304596,
0.3020959198474884,
-0.4981415867805481,
0.03764525055885315,
0.35335859656333923,
0.2070685178041458,
0.8933908939361572,
-0.02310449630022049,
0.3752307593822479,
0.4809301197528839,
0.23729893565177917,
-0.32739701867103577,
0.039135709404945374,
-0.04934188351035118,
-0.4000735580921173,
-0.19580994546413422,
-0.8720188736915588,
-0.38450223207473755,
-0.1636105179786682,
-0.9898319840431213,
-0.03632592409849167,
-0.676124095916748,
-0.18733277916908264,
0.3391941487789154,
-0.31630948185920715,
-0.4083768427371979,
0.3690267503261566,
0.24567298591136932,
1.0227670669555664,
-0.9503627419471741,
0.48893338441848755,
0.6372767686843872,
-0.7445119023323059,
-0.5083760619163513,
-0.11737151443958282,
-0.1305840164422989,
-0.7288164496421814,
0.3598998785018921,
0.3255590796470642,
0.49497848749160767,
-0.2353987693786621,
-0.47814643383026123,
-0.7417423725128174,
0.8612051606178284,
0.052876874804496765,
-0.49879446625709534,
-0.2767246961593628,
0.37389305233955383,
0.5069355964660645,
-0.8094806671142578,
0.15191757678985596,
0.6923450231552124,
0.5330225229263306,
0.03991687297821045,
-0.7656096816062927,
0.10043362528085709,
-0.44130104780197144,
0.7020609378814697,
-0.09273666888475418,
-0.07718465477228165,
0.8364027142524719,
0.3413459360599518,
-0.05234026908874512,
0.39155006408691406,
0.8325861692428589,
0.5668778419494629,
0.38368546962738037,
0.5346089005470276,
0.4901107847690582,
0.5579632520675659,
-0.14388002455234528,
0.9470106363296509,
-0.015609425492584705,
0.23829706013202667,
1.2875405550003052,
0.07724304497241974,
1.06760835647583,
0.5337833166122437,
-0.1288042515516281,
0.705811083316803,
0.5079652667045593,
0.15885895490646362,
0.18074320256710052,
0.6864989995956421,
-0.6461511254310608,
0.07575835287570953,
-0.24012617766857147,
-0.2825561761856079,
0.06045682355761528,
0.5335506796836853,
-0.32617926597595215,
-0.5352142453193665,
0.3567267656326294,
0.02818685583770275,
0.5320037603378296,
-0.5637993812561035,
0.738849401473999,
0.30457058548927307,
-0.38482922315597534,
0.5125139951705933,
-0.04116704314947128,
1.0537077188491821,
-0.562576174736023,
0.028923597186803818,
-0.3301970362663269,
-0.15632390975952148,
-0.42902469635009766,
-0.6478483080863953,
0.5189866423606873,
0.050810232758522034,
-0.24741142988204956,
0.10461074113845825,
0.1836157888174057,
-0.2838258445262909,
-0.7452213168144226,
0.1896626055240631,
-0.040736280381679535,
0.19711372256278992,
-0.11901248246431351,
-0.5739203095436096,
-0.023989787325263023,
-0.5522540807723999,
0.10596300661563873,
0.5455463528633118,
0.6053931713104248,
-0.11873489618301392,
0.5190784931182861,
0.275531530380249,
0.4019809663295746,
0.12460079789161682,
0.21848392486572266,
0.7606515288352966,
-0.5680009126663208,
-0.46637406945228577,
-0.36241447925567627,
0.9980746507644653,
-0.3281884491443634,
-0.7486874461174011,
0.4383883476257324,
0.5700685381889343,
0.9603240489959717,
0.2027224898338318,
0.9724361300468445,
-0.30400484800338745,
0.5846238732337952,
-0.21629685163497925,
0.4542302191257477,
-0.1373784840106964,
0.24019742012023926,
-0.1666182279586792,
-0.8193697929382324,
-0.7078684568405151,
0.5867301821708679,
-0.25601476430892944,
0.051636211574077606,
0.46532729268074036,
0.6105836033821106,
-0.09721653163433075,
-0.11998405307531357,
0.22328521311283112,
-0.18613934516906738,
0.23215071856975555,
0.040607552975416183,
0.46858739852905273,
-0.3798556923866272,
0.4725649058818817,
-0.29456013441085815,
-0.4822137653827667,
-0.07032754272222519,
-0.8178091645240784,
-0.5924895405769348,
-0.8010886311531067,
-0.518805742263794,
-0.3940964341163635,
0.21761402487754822,
0.9990548491477966,
0.6805026531219482,
-0.8499609231948853,
-0.257573664188385,
-0.3389042615890503,
-0.10039570927619934,
-0.4313225746154785,
-0.33286330103874207,
0.01199431624263525,
-0.7673708200454712,
-0.5835541486740112,
-0.1572674810886383,
0.315284788608551,
-0.2152889370918274,
-0.39457079768180847,
0.119306780397892,
-0.45316779613494873,
0.29894131422042847,
0.7190715670585632,
0.8353705406188965,
-0.9016996622085571,
-0.6425344347953796,
-0.6827846169471741,
0.04856344312429428,
0.0037867678329348564,
0.6174769401550293,
-0.7022265791893005,
0.39029771089553833,
-0.08574351668357849,
0.3653123378753662,
-0.20299778878688812,
-0.1201343685388565,
0.5191872715950012,
-0.9547082185745239,
0.48587051033973694,
0.6667897701263428,
0.22744309902191162,
0.4337395131587982,
-0.08021280169487,
0.5155401229858398,
0.1299171894788742,
-0.378720760345459,
-0.8131787776947021,
0.4233982264995575,
-1.1201786994934082,
-0.18231201171875,
1.3708932399749756,
-0.4933737516403198,
-0.23944959044456482,
-0.6013181805610657,
0.22709524631500244,
-0.12140801548957825,
-0.49217668175697327,
1.0949198007583618,
0.5978464484214783,
0.21128180623054504,
0.02108578197658062,
-0.5325178503990173,
0.5938448905944824,
-0.13608287274837494,
-0.7331176400184631,
0.03393039479851723,
0.41562700271606445,
0.23427166044712067,
0.3470596671104431,
0.620736837387085,
-0.3350144922733307,
0.19546394050121307,
0.10627070814371109,
0.20382605493068695,
0.13843725621700287,
-0.00015267996059264988,
-0.4519333243370056,
0.41129931807518005,
0.1573430299758911,
-0.1483134627342224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15273v1
|
Event Temporal Relation Extraction based on Retrieval-Augmented on LLMs
| 2024-03-22T15:16:10 | 2024-03-22T15:16:10 |
Xiaobin Zhang, Liangjun Zang, Qianwen Liu, Shuchong Wei, Songlin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Event temporal relation (TempRel) is a primary subject of the event relation
extraction task. However, the inherent ambiguity of TempRel increases the
difficulty of the task. With the rise of prompt engineering, it is important to
design effective prompt templates and verbalizers to extract relevant
knowledge. The traditional manually designed templates struggle to extract
precise temporal knowledge. This paper introduces a novel retrieval-augmented
TempRel extraction approach, leveraging knowledge retrieved from large language
models (LLMs) to enhance prompt templates and verbalizers. Our method
capitalizes on the diverse capabilities of various LLMs to generate a wide
array of ideas for template and verbalizer design. Our proposed method fully
exploits the potential of LLMs for generation tasks and contributes more
knowledge to our design. Empirical evaluations across three widely recognized
datasets demonstrate the efficacy of our method in improving the performance of
event temporal relation extraction tasks.
|
[
-0.13141778111457825,
-0.563815712928772,
0.9040713906288147,
0.18937723338603973,
-0.47231751680374146,
0.27677586674690247,
-0.2017430067062378,
-0.41829296946525574,
0.08776556700468063,
0.009595388546586037,
-0.528323769569397,
-0.2745486795902252,
-0.39682283997535706,
0.03609905391931534,
-0.1488519161939621,
0.7110171914100647,
-0.030538564547896385,
-0.1861903816461563,
-0.060224749147892,
0.2499750703573227,
-0.30036109685897827,
-0.5952543616294861,
-0.6903215050697327,
-0.2994639575481415,
0.7331127524375916,
0.2789224088191986,
0.036291759461164474,
0.4249247610569,
0.3227836787700653,
0.18950654566287994,
-0.40355318784713745,
0.3613155782222748,
-0.32895368337631226,
0.3856376111507416,
-0.1672743558883667,
-0.09759127348661423,
-0.4731018841266632,
-0.13511519134044647,
0.7320119142532349,
0.4402059018611908,
-0.2659458816051483,
0.3713482916355133,
-0.15249311923980713,
0.14096781611442566,
-0.7730584144592285,
0.42608457803726196,
-0.8366650938987732,
0.007192686200141907,
-0.5474005341529846,
-0.7810443043708801,
-0.5099291801452637,
-0.15941360592842102,
-0.2443540096282959,
-0.6020105481147766,
0.2761998474597931,
0.0772610604763031,
0.8791183233261108,
0.016284937039017677,
-0.4606095850467682,
-0.06988394260406494,
-0.8190586566925049,
0.7949747443199158,
-0.5148124098777771,
0.7266170382499695,
0.20899152755737305,
0.48407846689224243,
-0.23115019500255585,
-0.9710458517074585,
-0.6247447729110718,
-0.18636652827262878,
0.027611197903752327,
0.03985266759991646,
0.04734474793076515,
-0.2916559875011444,
0.419413685798645,
0.10614816099405289,
-0.3442702889442444,
0.12168577313423157,
-0.32902616262435913,
-0.046680010855197906,
0.5101377367973328,
0.49431607127189636,
0.427078515291214,
-0.6563221216201782,
-0.3080122470855713,
0.23304420709609985,
-0.7428542375564575,
-0.14389218389987946,
0.03590952605009079,
0.36046701669692993,
0.09171795845031738,
0.6623538136482239,
-0.13301856815814972,
0.6065884828567505,
0.19152311980724335,
-0.27757930755615234,
0.17649716138839722,
-0.5614699721336365,
0.07083772122859955,
0.16833074390888214,
0.7908914089202881,
0.25496524572372437,
0.14568395912647247,
-0.4218844473361969,
-0.2629373371601105,
-0.23747287690639496,
0.016542550176382065,
-0.7760024666786194,
0.1438441127538681,
0.11251650005578995,
-0.26917123794555664,
-0.23906464874744415,
0.19224826991558075,
-0.7988656759262085,
-0.33803465962409973,
-0.3296179473400116,
-0.05126247927546501,
-0.5572038292884827,
-0.30180227756500244,
-0.27496254444122314,
-0.33844077587127686,
0.42507076263427734,
0.18220913410186768,
-0.403751015663147,
-0.22673562169075012,
0.8780916929244995,
0.7551774978637695,
-0.2437598705291748,
-0.07335475832223892,
-0.9237408638000488,
0.6135173439979553,
-0.08280526101589203,
0.7779061198234558,
-0.7695824503898621,
-0.5612663626670837,
-0.13174182176589966,
-0.22238275408744812,
0.16231854259967804,
-0.35634845495224,
0.20138975977897644,
-1.067893385887146,
0.37687158584594727,
-0.11764467507600784,
-0.537868320941925,
0.4392145276069641,
0.15997086465358734,
-0.5966953039169312,
1.0995914936065674,
-0.02754247561097145,
-0.6667441725730896,
0.28205013275146484,
-0.29985958337783813,
-0.3794674873352051,
0.3543916940689087,
-0.5126479864120483,
-0.14082838594913483,
0.22063618898391724,
0.4653050899505615,
0.44731414318084717,
-0.5500301718711853,
0.535042405128479,
-0.14404423534870148,
-0.013591905124485493,
0.38883787393569946,
-0.13416361808776855,
0.5053877234458923,
0.38937413692474365,
0.13219338655471802,
-0.12418819218873978,
-1.0085524320602417,
-0.12915587425231934,
0.1926165074110031,
-0.4807012677192688,
-0.3651782274246216,
0.022672580555081367,
0.04614323005080223,
0.430012971162796,
0.3816717863082886,
-0.6317014098167419,
0.17453017830848694,
-0.46128374338150024,
0.17678478360176086,
0.7435448169708252,
0.7329659461975098,
0.6082831621170044,
-0.20493195950984955,
0.769323468208313,
0.026237716898322105,
-0.10276557505130768,
-0.2849721312522888,
-0.14042478799819946,
-0.33561164140701294,
-0.2248985916376114,
0.16502834856510162,
0.40781262516975403,
-1.180012583732605,
0.3696554899215698,
-0.46861565113067627,
-0.4971080422401428,
-0.18453557789325714,
0.00922667607665062,
0.35498008131980896,
0.9029524922370911,
0.1259320080280304,
0.17908522486686707,
-0.7961357235908508,
-0.4191989600658417,
-0.2642686069011688,
-0.41219884157180786,
-0.2501341998577118,
0.08019118010997772,
-0.09876507520675659,
0.15076254308223724,
1.0851473808288574,
-0.6778354644775391,
0.04190698266029358,
-0.3816337287425995,
0.24973663687705994,
0.5126717686653137,
0.1862034797668457,
0.572730541229248,
-0.5460968613624573,
-0.2594856023788452,
-0.06013980135321617,
-0.7860073447227478,
-0.429057776927948,
-0.14299502968788147,
-0.13840755820274353,
0.16885651648044586,
0.6087692975997925,
-0.5167924761772156,
0.3312947750091553,
-0.15350356698036194,
-0.47795870900154114,
0.6136684417724609,
0.1632619947195053,
0.05490510165691376,
-1.3932524919509888,
0.16346050798892975,
-0.05751406401395798,
-0.185958594083786,
-0.6177825331687927,
-0.07218947261571884,
0.12564364075660706,
-0.1904943585395813,
-0.7289050221443176,
1.0933818817138672,
-0.6809815168380737,
-0.00614579813554883,
-0.1631878912448883,
0.32853156328201294,
0.1249486431479454,
0.27274051308631897,
0.041066382080316544,
0.6085384488105774,
0.21662144362926483,
-0.6330404281616211,
0.3976782560348511,
0.42737627029418945,
-0.2368244081735611,
0.6103531718254089,
-0.5740195512771606,
0.2791660726070404,
-0.3158494532108307,
0.03306763246655464,
-0.6313179731369019,
-0.07132026553153992,
0.17744341492652893,
-0.4321085512638092,
0.5052750110626221,
-0.39720314741134644,
-0.8151607513427734,
-0.14908522367477417,
-0.13839130103588104,
0.36157649755477905,
0.49864184856414795,
-0.6693510413169861,
0.9017903208732605,
0.302146315574646,
-0.6302310228347778,
-0.38294103741645813,
-0.2699717581272125,
0.0498228557407856,
-0.1860889345407486,
-0.41138243675231934,
0.397151380777359,
0.09708880633115768,
-0.4803512990474701,
-0.13793784379959106,
-0.3963177502155304,
0.007411695551127195,
-0.11095274239778519,
0.22764292359352112,
0.5299155712127686,
-0.14669005572795868,
0.4437813460826874,
-0.11940338462591171,
-0.13562604784965515,
0.042548421770334244,
0.01929835043847561,
0.7311096787452698,
0.23115120828151703,
-0.29670286178588867,
-0.5003501176834106,
0.38288113474845886,
0.41861775517463684,
-0.4395826458930969,
0.7446100115776062,
0.5207259654998779,
-0.5495868921279907,
0.14073850214481354,
-0.9189229011535645,
-0.30448049306869507,
-0.47878962755203247,
0.36902838945388794,
-0.5427091121673584,
-0.44948747754096985,
0.5569700598716736,
-0.06385982781648636,
0.042147617787122726,
0.45886436104774475,
0.34977981448173523,
-0.09387142211198807,
0.7130411863327026,
0.3081812858581543,
-0.05198946222662926,
1.0711473226547241,
0.024212278425693512,
-0.2452031522989273,
-1.0782023668289185,
-0.6720424890518188,
-0.5331622362136841,
-0.005258332472294569,
-0.01801109127700329,
-0.2592928409576416,
0.4182318449020386,
-0.026396071538329124,
-0.4503268599510193,
0.047921184450387955,
-0.02082417905330658,
0.18899327516555786,
0.25187766551971436,
0.28030288219451904,
0.44045713543891907,
0.20096156001091003,
-0.015444738790392876,
-0.24898181855678558,
-0.6825091242790222,
-0.45374536514282227,
0.7711032629013062,
-0.019196799024939537,
0.46488019824028015,
0.17407944798469543,
0.7226386666297913,
0.06842776387929916,
0.14284348487854004,
-0.503276526927948,
0.6578090190887451,
0.21145755052566528,
-0.3906567394733429,
-0.08771964907646179,
-0.6867821216583252,
-1.018333911895752,
-0.2428974211215973,
-0.1877666413784027,
-0.9505323171615601,
0.38590875267982483,
-0.2415282130241394,
-0.2523137032985687,
0.19171065092086792,
-0.40476301312446594,
0.22293081879615784,
-0.21121439337730408,
-0.3447401225566864,
-0.08218683302402496,
-0.5348160266876221,
0.05796395242214203,
-0.2301461398601532,
0.21328438818454742,
-0.2806989550590515,
-0.31692972779273987,
1.0473583936691284,
-0.4496347904205322,
0.6146476864814758,
-0.14197683334350586,
-0.008494342677295208,
0.3163115978240967,
0.2563382089138031,
0.7602235674858093,
0.3448590338230133,
-0.7235479354858398,
-0.15855073928833008,
-0.17947110533714294,
-0.187810018658638,
-0.7997720837593079,
0.6106678247451782,
-0.5593639016151428,
-0.5108242630958557,
-0.3430140018463135,
-0.44593286514282227,
-0.26592910289764404,
0.14802739024162292,
0.18593978881835938,
0.8804985880851746,
-0.34411677718162537,
-0.23872137069702148,
0.2159203737974167,
-0.2738920748233795,
0.7383391857147217,
0.9271100759506226,
-0.11313789337873459,
-0.5078716278076172,
0.7808746695518494,
0.005730553064495325,
-0.03097390942275524,
0.5910472273826599,
0.03847343102097511,
-0.3156990110874176,
-0.19913680851459503,
-0.07597900927066803,
0.5243169665336609,
-0.646392285823822,
-0.47283974289894104,
-0.8456088900566101,
-0.37894266843795776,
-0.5739474296569824,
-0.12522058188915253,
-0.17469143867492676,
-0.7305481433868408,
-0.7692276239395142,
-0.3005765378475189,
0.5198221802711487,
0.5136405229568481,
-0.038538482040166855,
0.3778180181980133,
-1.0875482559204102,
0.47285616397857666,
0.0957624763250351,
-0.0005743912770412862,
-0.043216824531555176,
-0.54261314868927,
0.19050128757953644,
-0.3965173661708832,
-0.19191092252731323,
-1.2690534591674805,
0.46905890107154846,
0.2778773307800293,
0.7344638705253601,
0.34264230728149414,
0.17152436077594757,
0.6688277125358582,
-0.5842092633247375,
0.7463394403457642,
0.273637980222702,
-0.6970330476760864,
0.9355493187904358,
-0.24462372064590454,
0.37285372614860535,
0.13705261051654816,
0.2954798936843872,
-0.4761141240596771,
-0.22742125391960144,
-1.0701231956481934,
-1.1012765169143677,
0.7568001747131348,
0.21493950486183167,
-0.24425530433654785,
-0.28636634349823,
0.6564546227455139,
-0.036287181079387665,
0.2286638468503952,
-0.11055038869380951,
-0.11151421070098877,
0.27351245284080505,
-0.1334604024887085,
-0.08331243693828583,
-0.6607757806777954,
0.036429475992918015,
-0.03046778030693531,
0.5400682091712952,
0.2745005786418915,
0.4038327634334564,
0.05557574704289436,
-0.20608213543891907,
-0.11622510850429535,
0.4977821111679077,
0.3248002529144287,
1.0123039484024048,
-0.34245210886001587,
0.23644709587097168,
0.3510422706604004,
-0.2206551730632782,
0.042415205389261246,
0.4238457977771759,
-0.08083878457546234,
0.21022139489650726,
0.5809897184371948,
0.4485739767551422,
0.20854666829109192,
-0.4552553594112396,
0.2521962821483612,
-0.11234992742538452,
0.5158330798149109,
-0.39428800344467163,
-0.14709140360355377,
-0.031848013401031494,
0.5562689900398254,
0.7082023024559021,
-0.5144619941711426,
-0.09996074438095093,
-0.3991954028606415,
0.4618648588657379,
0.22729440033435822,
-0.3036542236804962,
-0.5457382798194885,
0.6982585191726685,
0.17779245972633362,
-0.5358766317367554,
0.7805399894714355,
-0.15933947265148163,
-0.3756061792373657,
0.6825413703918457,
0.690834641456604,
0.679743766784668,
-0.24272143840789795,
-0.06448408961296082,
0.44198349118232727,
0.09487021714448929,
0.2951187491416931,
0.6309430599212646,
-0.009214639663696289,
-0.5376906394958496,
-0.5446362495422363,
-0.7311538457870483,
-0.2188052386045456,
0.06612890213727951,
-0.763703465461731,
0.4427860975265503,
-0.2645663619041443,
-0.3591735064983368,
-0.1899108737707138,
0.08655896037817001,
-0.8959835171699524,
-0.11759521067142487,
0.18351654708385468,
0.955077052116394,
-0.5110427141189575,
0.720862090587616,
0.8887028694152832,
-0.4694584310054779,
-0.8167672753334045,
-0.1576870083808899,
-0.1057809516787529,
-0.5716645121574402,
0.9107568264007568,
-0.3908218741416931,
0.2352304607629776,
0.0291280634701252,
-0.19479836523532867,
-0.7487075328826904,
1.1780269145965576,
0.3844985067844391,
-0.7682239413261414,
-0.3954266309738159,
-0.09252685308456421,
0.4556986093521118,
-0.35630860924720764,
0.42363372445106506,
0.4602804481983185,
0.3990503251552582,
0.38066762685775757,
-0.8205466270446777,
0.36846572160720825,
-0.3672720491886139,
0.07654351741075516,
0.30491793155670166,
-0.31303632259368896,
0.36827319860458374,
-0.17869548499584198,
-0.5673485398292542,
-0.022548940032720566,
1.0522514581680298,
0.7828506231307983,
0.5635092258453369,
0.14786112308502197,
0.06278297305107117,
0.8659109473228455,
0.04869064688682556,
1.0701369047164917,
-0.3168098032474518,
0.05988132953643799,
1.5145297050476074,
-0.42388853430747986,
0.6781865358352661,
0.7657878398895264,
0.044604893773794174,
0.28696998953819275,
0.5244584083557129,
0.3176691234111786,
0.6056533455848694,
-0.09114330261945724,
-0.41550564765930176,
-0.45912840962409973,
-0.47594740986824036,
-0.5420134663581848,
0.19113680720329285,
0.6083590984344482,
-0.4099506437778473,
-0.41667860746383667,
0.0032332269474864006,
0.07575713098049164,
-0.2186485081911087,
-0.21762169897556305,
0.9181831479072571,
0.2932058870792389,
-0.3918091654777527,
0.25073033571243286,
-0.20027132332324982,
0.21818885207176208,
-0.4368450343608856,
-0.027765609323978424,
-0.18633493781089783,
-0.1267969012260437,
0.15781541168689728,
-0.6645821332931519,
0.16944821178913116,
0.11460091173648834,
-0.16503497958183289,
-0.22976712882518768,
0.8617516756057739,
-0.32991036772727966,
-0.5389223098754883,
0.07661151140928268,
0.8788838982582092,
-0.047930650413036346,
0.04191459342837334,
-0.13277478516101837,
0.1596246212720871,
-0.278510719537735,
-0.34053924679756165,
0.09465043991804123,
0.7815943360328674,
0.032259903848171234,
0.4669153690338135,
0.5035154223442078,
0.5147600769996643,
0.04444732889533043,
-0.0008764977683313191,
1.0983308553695679,
-0.8706101179122925,
-0.2921780049800873,
-0.9487589597702026,
0.4189991354942322,
-0.2981176972389221,
-0.17114634811878204,
0.4256238043308258,
0.5522803664207458,
0.17360273003578186,
0.006056272424757481,
0.7531406879425049,
-0.09675651788711548,
0.5012949705123901,
-0.5602744817733765,
0.42960426211357117,
-0.4511070251464844,
0.5572385787963867,
-0.24449706077575684,
-0.9131619334220886,
-0.3095169961452484,
-0.025712210685014725,
-0.42369961738586426,
-0.16017664968967438,
0.5946285128593445,
0.729704737663269,
-0.18651442229747772,
-0.13588657975196838,
0.09801911562681198,
0.17367494106292725,
0.7030481100082397,
0.5755366086959839,
1.2695363759994507,
-0.2355961799621582,
0.6165512800216675,
-0.18320736289024353,
-0.10858605802059174,
-0.14718879759311676,
-1.22917902469635,
-0.8824167847633362,
-0.7875560522079468,
-0.4364633560180664,
-0.3163895308971405,
0.40778061747550964,
1.1781013011932373,
0.2975602149963379,
-0.5116807818412781,
0.0930931568145752,
0.4496329426765442,
0.09451186656951904,
0.11670929193496704,
-0.2698266804218292,
0.5398064255714417,
-0.3849095106124878,
-0.5482183694839478,
0.7540990114212036,
0.054177675396203995,
0.037804458290338516,
0.32775405049324036,
0.10549416393041611,
-0.19357143342494965,
0.03166496381163597,
0.6349940299987793,
0.368449330329895,
-0.37362930178642273,
-0.28588083386421204,
-0.04462723433971405,
-0.14712193608283997,
-0.0812501534819603,
0.876104474067688,
-0.9444699287414551,
0.2849644124507904,
0.8666991591453552,
0.3907839059829712,
0.6332959532737732,
0.04817074537277222,
0.8342198133468628,
-1.328992247581482,
0.24110357463359833,
0.22977764904499054,
0.6307217478752136,
0.22813212871551514,
-0.591126024723053,
0.5686648488044739,
0.24049139022827148,
-0.3663479685783386,
-0.8610886931419373,
0.362764447927475,
-1.181699514389038,
-0.0861164852976799,
1.6132044792175293,
0.272786021232605,
-0.16364336013793945,
-0.13691361248493195,
-0.10084917396306992,
0.7441495060920715,
-0.5447695851325989,
0.8046236038208008,
0.269073486328125,
-0.1760963648557663,
-0.2292030155658722,
-0.22078542411327362,
0.2656181752681732,
-0.00011410375736886635,
-0.6495971083641052,
-0.13514931499958038,
0.46461066603660583,
0.3419050872325897,
0.16765297949314117,
0.6232897043228149,
-0.2476777285337448,
0.23135538399219513,
-0.4979003369808197,
0.20988936722278595,
-0.44251909852027893,
-0.2757558822631836,
-0.10924851149320602,
0.3237994313240051,
0.040157414972782135,
-0.029675304889678955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15268v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15268v3
|
Imagination Augmented Generation: Learning to Imagine Richer Context for Question Answering over Large Language Models
| 2024-03-22T15:06:45 | 2024-06-18T07:21:24 |
Huanxuan Liao, Shizhu He, Yao Xu, Yuanzhe Zhang, Kang Liu, Shengping Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented-Generation and Gener-ation-Augmented-Generation have been
proposed to enhance the knowledge required for question answering over Large
Language Models (LLMs). However, the former relies on external resources, and
both require incorporating explicit documents into the context, which increases
execution costs and susceptibility to noise data. Recent works indicate that
LLMs have modeled rich knowledge, albeit not effectively triggered or awakened.
Inspired by this, we propose a novel knowledge-augmented framework,
Imagination-Augmented-Generation (IAG), which simulates the human capacity to
compensate for knowledge deficits while answering questions solely through
imagination, thereby awakening relevant knowledge in LLMs without relying on
external resources. Guided by IAG, we propose an imagine richer context method
for question answering (IMcQA). IMcQA consists of two modules: explicit
imagination, which generates a short dummy document by learning from long
context compression, and implicit imagination, which creates flexible adapters
by distilling from a teacher model with a long context. Experimental results on
three datasets demonstrate that IMcQA exhibits significant advantages in both
open-domain and closed-book settings, as well as in out-of-distribution
generalization. Our code will be available at
https://github.com/Xnhyacinth/IAG.
|
[
-0.6712489128112793,
-0.9629309773445129,
0.5903313159942627,
-0.10186637938022614,
-0.11237583309412003,
0.3003687858581543,
-0.19200624525547028,
-0.619555652141571,
0.15750347077846527,
0.48074355721473694,
-0.6143303513526917,
0.06980136036872864,
-0.2834254503250122,
0.016826318576931953,
-0.24896691739559174,
0.42652463912963867,
-0.011572100222110748,
-0.11585990339517593,
-0.7743141055107117,
0.2668978273868561,
-0.2550905644893646,
-0.4539044201374054,
-0.6765832304954529,
-0.12456431984901428,
0.32777324318885803,
0.5183672308921814,
0.3275225758552551,
0.429819256067276,
-0.07637494802474976,
0.2400464117527008,
0.060884442180395126,
0.6194846034049988,
-0.3293721377849579,
0.12766708433628082,
-0.06984329968690872,
-0.3357447683811188,
-0.19653642177581787,
-0.2173088639974594,
0.5369614958763123,
0.5136345028877258,
0.17195522785186768,
0.15096977353096008,
0.19526073336601257,
0.41306453943252563,
-0.787455141544342,
-0.12386497855186462,
-0.8192264437675476,
-0.09487409144639969,
0.34359094500541687,
-0.44591423869132996,
-0.27304840087890625,
-0.16226452589035034,
0.10601974278688431,
-0.6284326910972595,
0.05310484766960144,
0.2937418222427368,
0.4969414174556732,
0.1972024291753769,
-0.5565650463104248,
-0.41638827323913574,
-0.6011614203453064,
0.5654665231704712,
-0.49252229928970337,
0.17258641123771667,
0.2603035867214203,
0.33104753494262695,
-0.008597276173532009,
-0.9214051961898804,
-1.0935863256454468,
0.004687117878347635,
0.08516798913478851,
0.34810671210289,
0.025573188439011574,
0.083780437707901,
0.2901085317134857,
0.5220597386360168,
-0.30206194519996643,
-0.17233708500862122,
-0.31094181537628174,
0.12205565720796585,
0.4477425515651703,
0.02458128333091736,
0.3881920576095581,
-0.18492206931114197,
-0.5145208835601807,
-0.09579624980688095,
-0.8362612128257751,
0.22877009212970734,
0.4002254605293274,
0.01465276163071394,
0.12300173193216324,
0.6382121443748474,
-0.2961884140968323,
0.7850435376167297,
-0.04642985761165619,
-0.020021649077534676,
-0.01206759363412857,
0.02110857143998146,
-0.005927159450948238,
0.02187812514603138,
0.2668864130973816,
0.30467644333839417,
0.13853037357330322,
-0.21302257478237152,
-0.16116909682750702,
-0.26649266481399536,
0.23097991943359375,
-0.8588533997535706,
-0.12676891684532166,
0.15260381996631622,
-0.13211117684841156,
-0.07405393570661545,
-0.21499542891979218,
-0.7274613380432129,
-0.35623908042907715,
-0.398924320936203,
0.7238508462905884,
-0.4687051773071289,
-0.21966826915740967,
0.0730694830417633,
-0.14731696248054504,
0.4537563621997833,
0.37094876170158386,
-0.8373345136642456,
0.21355219185352325,
0.4800187051296234,
0.42302659153938293,
0.059995949268341064,
-0.280225932598114,
-0.4365348517894745,
0.2337256371974945,
-0.17816969752311707,
0.9586652517318726,
-0.5278567671775818,
-0.21147966384887695,
-0.052325159311294556,
-0.3314538598060608,
-0.10892956703901291,
-0.42210203409194946,
0.5494635701179504,
-0.7368031144142151,
0.5162190198898315,
-0.29467907547950745,
-0.7578245401382446,
-0.15890058875083923,
0.6335904002189636,
-0.4444107115268707,
0.8427876234054565,
0.24487541615962982,
-0.7625640034675598,
0.2968558073043823,
-0.8059267401695251,
-0.08837487548589706,
0.2067444771528244,
-0.24392502009868622,
0.04992736503481865,
0.08282407373189926,
0.7504838705062866,
0.26391229033470154,
-0.5333318710327148,
-0.11172445863485336,
-0.02639671601355076,
-0.40026408433914185,
0.40248599648475647,
-0.6567029356956482,
0.6113765239715576,
0.35644325613975525,
-0.09436366707086563,
-0.1882777065038681,
-0.6784138083457947,
0.4612411856651306,
0.1412937045097351,
-0.41198962926864624,
-0.39865726232528687,
-0.07077021896839142,
0.006419957149773836,
0.3359152376651764,
0.10078903287649155,
-0.7379909157752991,
0.2536953091621399,
-0.6734848022460938,
0.3403761386871338,
0.5448753833770752,
0.43987908959388733,
0.3862067759037018,
-0.6297225952148438,
0.7683171033859253,
0.011155772022902966,
-0.12915553152561188,
-0.3500589430332184,
-0.27473318576812744,
-0.7318596839904785,
-0.3340945243835449,
0.3824883699417114,
0.39600735902786255,
-1.2442570924758911,
0.09781888127326965,
-0.3602118492126465,
-0.17893004417419434,
-0.6159758567810059,
-0.024197647348046303,
0.2500007152557373,
0.7089343070983887,
0.3995492458343506,
0.16286586225032806,
-0.5721191763877869,
-0.7179928421974182,
-0.4142926335334778,
-0.12285278737545013,
-0.2134610265493393,
0.673610508441925,
0.32226383686065674,
-0.05348154529929161,
0.934822678565979,
-0.5719782710075378,
0.07698144018650055,
-0.2115013599395752,
-0.11039146780967712,
-0.18736174702644348,
0.5027052164077759,
0.48952946066856384,
-1.0182654857635498,
-0.37191042304039,
-0.21623554825782776,
-0.4654579162597656,
-0.03974171355366707,
-0.1993781477212906,
-0.3898419141769409,
0.05175193399190903,
0.5505396723747253,
-0.5381872057914734,
0.21323750913143158,
0.45152202248573303,
-0.3783593475818634,
0.5111163258552551,
-0.18389789760112762,
0.47054916620254517,
-1.3537927865982056,
-0.015355771407485008,
-0.3897555470466614,
-0.047007303684949875,
-0.45093533396720886,
0.3692172169685364,
0.30501967668533325,
-0.18323862552642822,
-0.584276020526886,
1.0761255025863647,
-0.5183017253875732,
0.1326693892478943,
-0.39485833048820496,
0.1543843001127243,
0.26534023880958557,
0.5300517678260803,
0.020942389965057373,
1.032349705696106,
0.38489091396331787,
-0.5428997874259949,
0.14028330147266388,
0.22774584591388702,
-0.660521924495697,
0.24446575343608856,
-0.3617517352104187,
0.18468612432479858,
-0.34597596526145935,
0.09283363819122314,
-0.7990519404411316,
-0.4379754960536957,
0.04040703549981117,
-0.6231523752212524,
0.16255487501621246,
-0.004603029694408178,
-0.7489745616912842,
-0.2884271740913391,
-0.060581643134355545,
0.7035434246063232,
0.7709981799125671,
-1.0896085500717163,
0.9146614670753479,
0.29150837659835815,
-0.18600893020629883,
-0.7575166821479797,
-0.5713456273078918,
0.18889154493808746,
-0.3039727509021759,
-0.6774582266807556,
0.44019484519958496,
-0.37929821014404297,
-0.36851224303245544,
0.17352579534053802,
0.12906719744205475,
0.01421054732054472,
0.08320021629333496,
-0.029974497854709625,
0.12733536958694458,
-0.15889163315296173,
0.33765771985054016,
0.4790286123752594,
0.26527225971221924,
0.23683306574821472,
-0.4567996859550476,
0.4589242935180664,
0.021311765536665916,
-0.2896631062030792,
0.41915398836135864,
0.6135691404342651,
0.3956541419029236,
-0.37914589047431946,
0.7616927623748779,
0.162224680185318,
-0.6250830292701721,
-0.5841839909553528,
-0.6211717128753662,
-0.13172805309295654,
-0.4907693862915039,
0.21124160289764404,
-0.4938853979110718,
-0.820265531539917,
0.4398256838321686,
-0.21108409762382507,
0.19075311720371246,
0.1095077320933342,
0.5444622039794922,
-0.1909705251455307,
0.9665560126304626,
0.49799713492393494,
0.503786027431488,
0.2649461030960083,
-0.21210379898548126,
0.21126627922058105,
-1.161184310913086,
-0.1872074007987976,
-0.03574303537607193,
-0.26885131001472473,
-0.18135052919387817,
-0.6422818303108215,
0.530203104019165,
0.3877815306186676,
-0.11342314630746841,
-0.29469072818756104,
-0.37185990810394287,
0.8827785849571228,
0.6622593998908997,
0.184817373752594,
0.30879703164100647,
-0.022443685680627823,
-0.2543947398662567,
0.10391457378864288,
-0.9858781695365906,
-0.4051821529865265,
1.033949375152588,
-0.0929236188530922,
0.5703315138816833,
0.11905691027641296,
0.6338576674461365,
0.016380375251173973,
0.4264814257621765,
-0.6391823291778564,
0.4910883903503418,
0.26128438115119934,
-0.5441385507583618,
-0.14884322881698608,
-0.27146244049072266,
-0.8304490447044373,
0.4572511613368988,
-0.5341072678565979,
-0.5031386017799377,
0.11627350747585297,
0.43125295639038086,
-0.34181031584739685,
0.5046281814575195,
-0.8189455270767212,
0.4433046281337738,
-0.25916972756385803,
-0.3905358612537384,
0.004574649501591921,
-0.3512079417705536,
0.6062251329421997,
0.013046346604824066,
0.09278791397809982,
0.3423483371734619,
-0.16501548886299133,
0.4122520387172699,
-0.23269660770893097,
0.41292816400527954,
-0.17255833745002747,
0.03146912902593613,
0.7744024395942688,
-0.02972458302974701,
0.4695200026035309,
0.23201748728752136,
-0.0651606097817421,
-0.5430769920349121,
-0.12794312834739685,
-0.4909747242927551,
-0.741698682308197,
0.9098119735717773,
-0.6767451167106628,
-0.7918168306350708,
-0.2283731997013092,
-1.0236996412277222,
-0.6228271126747131,
0.014842736534774303,
0.38276952505111694,
0.45660337805747986,
-0.07616494596004486,
0.1991211175918579,
0.9329646229743958,
-0.4845360219478607,
0.3177518844604492,
0.16701361536979675,
-0.2571294903755188,
-0.4779394865036011,
0.7043530344963074,
0.19913356006145477,
0.29078391194343567,
0.4750009775161743,
0.140632763504982,
-0.5268299579620361,
-0.31236281991004944,
-0.5399587750434875,
-0.004702203441411257,
-0.9012623429298401,
-0.2718442678451538,
-1.027148723602295,
-0.40382006764411926,
-0.4380764067173004,
-0.31525880098342896,
0.138946995139122,
-0.6357571482658386,
-0.12388201802968979,
-0.2246204912662506,
0.31119781732559204,
0.12992927432060242,
0.02099916711449623,
0.11477956920862198,
-0.46129146218299866,
0.36519119143486023,
0.7665455341339111,
0.16699892282485962,
0.316148579120636,
-0.4788680970668793,
-0.2876056432723999,
0.24088728427886963,
-0.22699233889579773,
-0.5758567452430725,
0.4357627034187317,
0.2687245011329651,
0.4052606523036957,
0.059826768934726715,
0.37043994665145874,
0.7343053817749023,
-0.4854598045349121,
0.679594099521637,
-0.12695607542991638,
-0.6810933947563171,
0.25397270917892456,
-0.27620407938957214,
0.6328607797622681,
0.4220535457134247,
0.18969956040382385,
-0.40823206305503845,
-0.30518612265586853,
-0.6998926401138306,
-1.115378737449646,
0.38220104575157166,
0.044618625193834305,
0.33175647258758545,
-0.25204718112945557,
0.637827455997467,
0.14649972319602966,
0.15843565762043,
-0.7512271404266357,
-0.009413518011569977,
-0.18379783630371094,
-0.22173812985420227,
0.07398246228694916,
-0.3409304916858673,
-0.12299222499132156,
-0.19236019253730774,
0.7698392868041992,
-0.4007021188735962,
0.42053866386413574,
0.3642697334289551,
-0.2212393581867218,
-0.10398855805397034,
0.36498063802719116,
0.33993852138519287,
0.5924878716468811,
0.047536518424749374,
0.32815447449684143,
0.4205223023891449,
-0.2694011926651001,
-0.07194266468286514,
0.10903554409742355,
-0.22179901599884033,
-0.5597615838050842,
0.2362501174211502,
0.5920040011405945,
-0.025155192241072655,
-1.2075351476669312,
0.409888356924057,
-0.27628371119499207,
-0.4154541492462158,
-0.7567244172096252,
0.3690767288208008,
0.29515257477760315,
0.4280214309692383,
0.6531280279159546,
-0.08640392869710922,
0.05490174889564514,
-0.4686536490917206,
0.06059178709983826,
0.43191584944725037,
-0.13288621604442596,
0.08834780007600784,
0.8559974431991577,
0.030189068987965584,
-0.18723736703395844,
0.5316881537437439,
-0.1472151279449463,
-0.43733271956443787,
0.704782247543335,
0.9008281230926514,
0.8225748538970947,
0.25407564640045166,
-0.12742678821086884,
0.4325285255908966,
0.21497869491577148,
0.28945401310920715,
0.5694716572761536,
-0.24696384370326996,
-0.7348408699035645,
-0.5682887434959412,
-0.5811430811882019,
-0.42356038093566895,
0.3141879439353943,
-0.3201683759689331,
0.06893017888069153,
-0.17381632328033447,
0.37439125776290894,
-0.3167067766189575,
0.029252132400870323,
-0.740146279335022,
0.4184732139110565,
0.19247306883335114,
1.0705114603042603,
-0.5576401948928833,
0.7873031497001648,
0.7607749104499817,
-0.022735200822353363,
-0.7379987239837646,
0.39161670207977295,
-0.437091201543808,
-0.6996919512748718,
0.3109801113605499,
0.08614346385002136,
-0.04792941361665726,
0.5175092220306396,
-0.6963817477226257,
-0.8447470664978027,
1.2773164510726929,
0.34508150815963745,
-0.09423542767763138,
-0.12177591770887375,
0.017797032371163368,
0.5274216532707214,
-0.7227060794830322,
0.112652488052845,
0.09315966814756393,
0.2172769010066986,
0.22035488486289978,
-0.1762179136276245,
-0.04703497141599655,
-0.430938184261322,
-0.08049998432397842,
0.1208173856139183,
-0.4682035744190216,
0.7028301954269409,
-0.3778909742832184,
-0.24252332746982574,
0.23766076564788818,
0.8791324496269226,
0.4689008891582489,
0.1591743677854538,
0.5383184552192688,
0.511495053768158,
0.578991174697876,
0.015372883528470993,
1.1272929906845093,
-0.4153949022293091,
-0.16108021140098572,
1.1114459037780762,
0.10779443383216858,
0.7625902891159058,
0.5292643904685974,
0.3211115896701813,
0.2910756766796112,
0.5249768495559692,
0.42059120535850525,
0.4395294189453125,
0.14519713819026947,
-0.7159168124198914,
-0.3506655991077423,
-0.027728674933314323,
-0.28501051664352417,
0.27216365933418274,
0.41927260160446167,
-0.27314767241477966,
-0.03930491954088211,
0.40009790658950806,
-0.29585543274879456,
0.39457592368125916,
-0.3983362913131714,
0.6858446002006531,
-0.023133696988224983,
-0.9719559550285339,
0.5638213157653809,
-0.13810688257217407,
0.49257662892341614,
-0.4280741214752197,
-0.23261764645576477,
-0.1253526210784912,
-0.06410268694162369,
0.1414063721895218,
-0.8414919376373291,
0.0043344623409211636,
0.07926518470048904,
-0.25985363125801086,
-0.18754465878009796,
0.7689189910888672,
-0.7281065583229065,
-0.5092390179634094,
-0.05225479230284691,
0.8326138854026794,
-0.17794442176818848,
-0.02438737265765667,
-0.4976474642753601,
-0.43870672583580017,
-0.1411568969488144,
-0.4238135516643524,
0.46988970041275024,
0.7293875813484192,
-0.02599886618554592,
0.6967971324920654,
0.6190349459648132,
-0.05557933449745178,
0.1518595814704895,
-0.28589046001434326,
0.9689580202102661,
-0.4436187744140625,
-0.6419594883918762,
-0.35389602184295654,
0.6451029777526855,
-0.17149968445301056,
-0.30809611082077026,
0.6484983563423157,
0.5809343457221985,
0.8441427946090698,
-0.09391973912715912,
0.9245192408561707,
-0.283956378698349,
0.6452342867851257,
-0.5654802918434143,
0.6541257500648499,
-0.7725160121917725,
0.3111039698123932,
-0.1370723694562912,
-0.9984546899795532,
-0.13620750606060028,
0.15333010256290436,
-0.24645528197288513,
-0.08566751331090927,
0.46857401728630066,
0.7259109020233154,
-0.17284533381462097,
-0.0989765152335167,
0.5296058654785156,
0.027959728613495827,
0.2115199714899063,
0.5612577199935913,
1.1784530878067017,
-0.4155377149581909,
0.5575961470603943,
-0.28529098629951477,
-0.20706459879875183,
0.08616168051958084,
-0.6650868058204651,
-0.9117134809494019,
-0.8221508860588074,
-0.08151068538427353,
-0.2500830590724945,
-0.002381274476647377,
1.2340744733810425,
0.3893149793148041,
-0.23893225193023682,
0.20178020000457764,
-0.04152851924300194,
-0.07997303456068039,
-0.19706189632415771,
-0.24429547786712646,
0.4424099326133728,
-0.2012380063533783,
-0.9508116841316223,
0.40636563301086426,
-0.0919480249285698,
0.22381266951560974,
-0.08754417300224304,
-0.07835083454847336,
-0.2544028162956238,
0.5233463644981384,
0.7859920263290405,
0.44889166951179504,
-0.5451710224151611,
-0.43301287293434143,
0.12628743052482605,
0.14613474905490875,
-0.07912630587816238,
0.6071783304214478,
-1.2719238996505737,
0.690041720867157,
0.44392484426498413,
1.0625064373016357,
0.4343217611312866,
0.26560738682746887,
0.4408198595046997,
-0.8162991404533386,
0.08936601132154465,
0.4965246319770813,
0.22220207750797272,
0.14171938598155975,
-0.5467515587806702,
0.3665311932563782,
-0.19763848185539246,
-0.5851466059684753,
-0.785051703453064,
0.29278576374053955,
-0.6318569779396057,
-0.5733906030654907,
1.0937989950180054,
0.0665673017501831,
-0.22134509682655334,
0.018053220584988594,
-0.30818164348602295,
0.0191650390625,
-0.002785694319754839,
0.9735977649688721,
0.5575046539306641,
-0.25793206691741943,
-0.49370187520980835,
-0.5129831433296204,
0.4947972893714905,
0.32108578085899353,
-1.0600188970565796,
0.03982507437467575,
0.6088143587112427,
-0.0049810344353318214,
-0.1423269361257553,
0.491300106048584,
-0.07342398166656494,
0.37500739097595215,
0.1143990233540535,
0.13538700342178345,
-0.24184291064739227,
-0.23539361357688904,
-0.018877290189266205,
0.32099175453186035,
0.2269240915775299,
0.18704409897327423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15250v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15250v2
|
Comprehensive Reassessment of Large-Scale Evaluation Outcomes in LLMs: A Multifaceted Statistical Approach
| 2024-03-22T14:47:35 | 2024-06-24T07:49:25 |
Kun Sun, Rong Wang, Anders Søgaard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Amidst the rapid evolution of LLMs, the significance of evaluation in
comprehending and propelling these models forward is increasingly paramount.
Evaluations have revealed that factors such as scaling, training types,
architectures and other factors profoundly impact the performance of LLMs.
However, the extent and nature of these impacts continue to be subjects of
debate because most assessments have been restricted to a limited number of
models and data points. Clarifying the effects of these factors on performance
scores can be more effectively achieved through a statistical lens. Our study
embarks on a thorough re-examination of these LLMs, targeting the inadequacies
in current evaluation methods. With the advent of a uniform evaluation
framework, our research leverages an expansive dataset of evaluation results,
introducing a comprehensive statistical methodology. This includes the
application of ANOVA, Tukey HSD tests, GAMM, and clustering technique, offering
a robust and transparent approach to deciphering LLM performance data. Contrary
to prevailing findings, our results challenge assumptions about emergent
abilities and the influence of given training types and architectures in LLMs.
These findings furnish new perspectives on the characteristics, intrinsic
nature, and developmental trajectories of LLMs. By providing straightforward
and reliable methods to scrutinize and reassess LLM performance data, this
study contributes a nuanced perspective on LLM efficiency and potentials.
|
[
-0.1345081478357315,
-0.6855517029762268,
0.4349667429924011,
0.1530281901359558,
0.0055050915107131,
0.4208216369152069,
-0.2819348871707916,
-0.34731146693229675,
0.11505139619112015,
0.19661952555179596,
-0.3999738395214081,
-0.44456547498703003,
-0.8331822156906128,
0.07547114789485931,
-0.39683836698532104,
0.7038995623588562,
-0.002895500510931015,
0.4895045757293701,
-0.3003038763999939,
-0.21692661941051483,
-0.35177716612815857,
-0.5543149709701538,
-0.6723563075065613,
-0.5918167233467102,
0.5213407278060913,
0.3188082277774811,
0.41640785336494446,
0.6732692718505859,
0.932888388633728,
0.2657957673072815,
-0.261904776096344,
-0.0138864042237401,
-0.6798834204673767,
-0.02169926092028618,
0.0035554904025048018,
-0.6282731890678406,
-0.7176961302757263,
0.0976356640458107,
1.2085202932357788,
1.0985628366470337,
-0.15214170515537262,
0.4663351774215698,
0.45674583315849304,
0.767129123210907,
-0.6358757019042969,
-0.060861214995384216,
-0.3950235843658447,
0.3492738902568817,
-0.14064815640449524,
-0.39986252784729004,
-0.42160794138908386,
-0.4665377736091614,
0.20893341302871704,
-0.24471543729305267,
0.2498244047164917,
-0.19437076151371002,
0.19068951904773712,
0.10034026205539703,
-0.6162794232368469,
-0.1836899369955063,
-0.8622080087661743,
0.936044454574585,
-0.30572405457496643,
0.5584167242050171,
-0.27511799335479736,
0.5266608595848083,
-0.21467627584934235,
-0.6405829787254333,
0.2043679654598236,
-0.3763343095779419,
0.20652182400226593,
0.20326578617095947,
0.14987652003765106,
0.0035305102355778217,
0.33843791484832764,
0.4346935451030731,
-0.44611963629722595,
0.4359547793865204,
-0.3146761655807495,
-0.035875070840120316,
0.7465626001358032,
0.7699241638183594,
0.10265912860631943,
0.1780063360929489,
-0.3851983845233917,
-0.23319654166698456,
-0.7215927243232727,
0.2184455841779709,
0.3189440071582794,
0.24031999707221985,
-0.08971208333969116,
0.7389057278633118,
-0.2790665328502655,
0.283420592546463,
-0.08213784545660019,
-0.33068591356277466,
0.31004396080970764,
-0.3310317099094391,
-0.16492825746536255,
-0.24160225689411163,
0.5181059241294861,
0.41964754462242126,
0.1792813092470169,
-0.4060198962688446,
-0.22517187893390656,
-0.08640360087156296,
0.5115901827812195,
-0.6405613422393799,
0.27164748311042786,
0.0957174077630043,
-0.6681888699531555,
-0.5593174695968628,
0.061090052127838135,
-1.059637188911438,
-0.4984806478023529,
-0.5034642815589905,
0.43083298206329346,
-0.15894153714179993,
-0.3345365524291992,
-0.00400448078289628,
-0.20397239923477173,
0.4472438395023346,
0.5363211631774902,
-0.5566219091415405,
0.29756250977516174,
0.8504247665405273,
0.87030029296875,
-0.6413125991821289,
-0.4595664441585541,
0.03375278040766716,
-0.09255237877368927,
-0.4860073924064636,
0.6015408635139465,
-0.4937988817691803,
-0.5627958178520203,
0.1397983282804489,
-0.1444859504699707,
-0.1278122216463089,
-0.9027314782142639,
0.27523380517959595,
-0.5262442231178284,
-0.19785034656524658,
-0.205362007021904,
-0.5824288725852966,
0.030455725267529488,
0.34076395630836487,
-0.5091279745101929,
0.7884675860404968,
0.08327195048332214,
-0.5382735133171082,
0.9570042490959167,
-0.526396632194519,
-0.4649592638015747,
-0.14868365228176117,
-0.20829901099205017,
-0.4412294030189514,
0.5554664134979248,
-0.1127052828669548,
0.3870229721069336,
-0.4061840772628784,
0.2597026824951172,
-0.4290296137332916,
-0.4309036135673523,
0.353045791387558,
-0.6685636639595032,
0.4945654571056366,
-0.03717160224914551,
-0.3251879811286926,
0.08054573088884354,
-0.9849321842193604,
0.21155120432376862,
-0.0910954475402832,
-0.5623713135719299,
0.09760666638612747,
0.06543323397636414,
-0.35176923871040344,
-0.03567321226000786,
0.2550514042377472,
-0.22652599215507507,
0.11053021252155304,
-0.04888259992003441,
0.16523942351341248,
0.7959029078483582,
0.14905983209609985,
0.5344359278678894,
-0.3989202678203583,
0.8171492218971252,
-0.352970153093338,
0.5538639426231384,
0.08935466408729553,
-0.2513808608055115,
-0.4770219326019287,
-0.46809300780296326,
0.12076389044523239,
0.24078717827796936,
-0.2362861931324005,
0.17112699151039124,
-0.2738581895828247,
-0.8423296213150024,
-0.4063122570514679,
0.1403157263994217,
0.34699001908302307,
0.2577923834323883,
0.17335538566112518,
-0.6100741028785706,
-0.46383121609687805,
-0.8291542530059814,
-0.45109760761260986,
-0.07990361750125885,
-0.08763802796602249,
0.20048333704471588,
0.7271203398704529,
-0.199833482503891,
0.7031346559524536,
-0.24163755774497986,
0.028846342116594315,
-0.21900808811187744,
0.002956663491204381,
0.16325503587722778,
0.44346144795417786,
0.23093679547309875,
-0.19363337755203247,
-0.026254557073116302,
-0.13559198379516602,
-0.9119009971618652,
0.03639800474047661,
0.02055884711444378,
-0.0493677482008934,
-0.2700919508934021,
0.3472438156604767,
-0.3446410596370697,
0.41930049657821655,
0.2080516219139099,
-0.007932672277092934,
1.0936672687530518,
-0.16979220509529114,
0.3658103048801422,
-0.1817365288734436,
0.05638674646615982,
-0.0793839544057846,
0.3191451132297516,
-0.3454909920692444,
0.10420596599578857,
-0.04749602451920509,
0.2025861293077469,
-0.3417738974094391,
0.2863161861896515,
-0.4845349192619324,
-0.6574176549911499,
-0.011669047176837921,
-0.0500495471060276,
-0.011043946258723736,
0.09791817516088486,
-0.19377586245536804,
0.7412036657333374,
0.5611419081687927,
-0.43037858605384827,
0.21773940324783325,
-0.20497946441173553,
-0.554965615272522,
0.7370847463607788,
-0.8494911193847656,
-0.18023814260959625,
0.10545259714126587,
0.3606128692626953,
-1.074469804763794,
-0.060376591980457306,
-0.1320359855890274,
-0.2612045705318451,
0.4075450897216797,
-0.08961056172847748,
-0.35009294748306274,
-0.18998774886131287,
-0.6193386912345886,
0.33598482608795166,
0.2029600888490677,
-0.2692553400993347,
0.5833123922348022,
0.1602119505405426,
0.1743171513080597,
-0.46797993779182434,
-0.47624287009239197,
0.12953999638557434,
-0.6298323273658752,
-0.6264603734016418,
-0.10185807198286057,
0.084961898624897,
-0.48606130480766296,
-0.39528703689575195,
-0.3811880052089691,
-0.05427827313542366,
0.4783954322338104,
0.1583380103111267,
0.28299400210380554,
-0.24001218378543854,
-0.029187694191932678,
-0.26550349593162537,
-0.12283849716186523,
0.4840940833091736,
0.12103300541639328,
0.35160768032073975,
-0.14988575875759125,
-0.6806917190551758,
-0.3363981544971466,
-0.060192450881004333,
0.6453897953033447,
-0.19589950144290924,
0.650098443031311,
0.532498300075531,
-0.10814225673675537,
-0.14310172200202942,
-0.46800899505615234,
-0.22105735540390015,
-0.36125263571739197,
0.6818738579750061,
-0.3156757354736328,
-0.6531773805618286,
0.52886962890625,
-0.4547710418701172,
0.22979362308979034,
0.42278027534484863,
0.6131519079208374,
-0.21902941167354584,
0.8466349244117737,
0.3997092843055725,
0.20494228601455688,
0.3551281690597534,
-0.5381162762641907,
-0.05657000094652176,
-1.1940897703170776,
-0.6216964721679688,
-0.21081116795539856,
-0.43639829754829407,
-0.4788745045661926,
-0.5963404774665833,
0.4842948019504547,
-0.04315774887800217,
-0.41426995396614075,
-0.3130832016468048,
-0.2049872726202011,
0.16693201661109924,
-0.124747134745121,
0.253483384847641,
0.44752442836761475,
-0.07644683867692947,
-0.06190430000424385,
-0.043610844761133194,
-0.5786674618721008,
-0.8738670349121094,
1.735069990158081,
0.8490784764289856,
1.0028969049453735,
0.21646322309970856,
0.6165422201156616,
0.23169395327568054,
0.6831438541412354,
-0.8400758504867554,
0.40352144837379456,
0.05147450789809227,
-0.5587781071662903,
-0.35671406984329224,
-0.4949488341808319,
-1.0924781560897827,
0.5602927207946777,
-0.3090270161628723,
-0.6239137053489685,
0.024077216163277626,
-0.3201625347137451,
-0.28724977374076843,
0.21727126836776733,
-0.7831537127494812,
0.646398663520813,
-0.7218724489212036,
-0.5757772922515869,
-0.3708938658237457,
-0.3648189902305603,
0.6246252655982971,
-0.46703818440437317,
0.35226118564605713,
-0.006273062899708748,
-0.36754435300827026,
0.9229006767272949,
-0.2041187435388565,
0.8639997243881226,
-0.16751641035079956,
-0.12849131226539612,
-0.022375043481588364,
-0.08125157654285431,
0.05464205890893936,
0.11618371307849884,
-0.16076664626598358,
0.24732200801372528,
0.013115339912474155,
-0.32970505952835083,
-0.8156077265739441,
0.6664451360702515,
-0.9157741069793701,
-0.530920147895813,
-0.247014582157135,
-0.2934187948703766,
-0.6399896144866943,
-0.13497814536094666,
0.029826555401086807,
0.5277664065361023,
-0.4154377281665802,
0.34976550936698914,
0.7582866549491882,
-0.27321115136146545,
0.08302788436412811,
0.5659121870994568,
-0.2519650161266327,
-0.4593879282474518,
0.6023944020271301,
0.46784988045692444,
0.5215041637420654,
0.11035921424627304,
0.12118329107761383,
-0.4963676631450653,
-0.7060995697975159,
-0.2420915812253952,
0.18753422796726227,
-0.622307300567627,
0.10590733587741852,
-0.23410676419734955,
0.039171863347291946,
-0.1949724704027176,
-0.23511970043182373,
-0.40295329689979553,
-0.13722440600395203,
-0.22090701758861542,
-0.20924806594848633,
-0.1420273631811142,
1.1956599950790405,
-0.05455315113067627,
0.4427577555179596,
-0.28911566734313965,
0.11807456612586975,
0.2841569185256958,
0.5357682108879089,
0.5281758308410645,
-0.7611762285232544,
-0.4841631054878235,
-0.061435598880052567,
-0.41859328746795654,
-0.6074967980384827,
-0.033264487981796265,
0.09989383816719055,
0.9582406282424927,
0.4556938707828522,
-0.39741823077201843,
0.7799475193023682,
-0.49895548820495605,
0.6778210997581482,
0.31811776757240295,
-0.4306926131248474,
0.4118344187736511,
-0.09256996959447861,
-0.03568363934755325,
0.5259931683540344,
0.23519083857536316,
0.15348215401172638,
-0.08664216101169586,
-0.5859143733978271,
-0.9282475113868713,
0.5168852806091309,
-0.10046324133872986,
-0.2033829391002655,
0.2268904149532318,
0.4594382047653198,
0.028889652341604233,
0.1992405205965042,
-0.3131226897239685,
-0.2571432888507843,
0.28988125920295715,
0.17175322771072388,
-0.28169533610343933,
-0.2659636437892914,
-0.26978567242622375,
-0.3619436025619507,
0.24702203273773193,
0.16599921882152557,
0.139031782746315,
-0.049301788210868835,
-0.2569882571697235,
0.03312849998474121,
0.26102131605148315,
0.3144422471523285,
1.185792088508606,
-0.25122520327568054,
0.050231970846652985,
0.47222593426704407,
-0.41980835795402527,
0.42512941360473633,
-0.416874498128891,
0.2843794524669647,
-0.2939970791339874,
0.9929803609848022,
0.440922349691391,
0.5434485077857971,
-0.5723908543586731,
0.3924824297428131,
0.06438545882701874,
-0.1714683175086975,
-0.2693410813808441,
0.13539312779903412,
-0.10775012522935867,
0.3618786931037903,
0.47461801767349243,
-0.0593404583632946,
0.16600027680397034,
-0.6525469422340393,
0.37359654903411865,
0.4227270781993866,
-0.1859695166349411,
-0.2140294313430786,
0.2952379286289215,
-0.00046059241867624223,
-0.21498870849609375,
0.3267561197280884,
0.3079562187194824,
-0.1506614238023758,
0.9209074378013611,
0.22916068136692047,
0.9058670401573181,
-0.19197936356067657,
0.2438448667526245,
0.2756734788417816,
0.6017652153968811,
-0.1150927022099495,
-0.029891222715377808,
0.109524205327034,
-0.46467286348342896,
-0.5661629438400269,
-0.7207846641540527,
-0.44374892115592957,
-0.00783885084092617,
-1.0378538370132446,
0.07317526638507843,
-0.7196676731109619,
-0.33596038818359375,
-0.22880060970783234,
0.2224878966808319,
-0.887069821357727,
0.45701083540916443,
0.016706783324480057,
0.9450292587280273,
-0.9188606142997742,
0.285028874874115,
0.6800990104675293,
-0.3246636688709259,
-0.6233586668968201,
-0.09113094210624695,
0.07398120313882828,
-1.072761058807373,
0.7406209111213684,
-0.020109189674258232,
-0.15287312865257263,
-0.24564996361732483,
-0.19970284402370453,
-0.8405057787895203,
1.2719587087631226,
0.3687414824962616,
-0.5220602750778198,
0.06622884422540665,
0.4390546381473541,
0.7825865149497986,
-0.46158790588378906,
0.8361925482749939,
0.9654648303985596,
0.45659470558166504,
-0.017462562769651413,
-0.735338032245636,
-0.17104430496692657,
0.1214781105518341,
0.1182674765586853,
-0.12291564792394638,
-0.7982659339904785,
0.3948726952075958,
-0.4012984335422516,
-0.016183894127607346,
-0.006871333811432123,
0.3015787601470947,
0.5727604627609253,
0.4059961438179016,
0.2361825853586197,
0.6095548272132874,
0.693855881690979,
-0.07561125606298447,
0.9875027537345886,
-0.3546115756034851,
0.4078957140445709,
0.823398232460022,
-0.29425308108329773,
0.7553254961967468,
0.5540854930877686,
-0.8303173780441284,
0.1924303025007248,
0.7544652223587036,
-0.04328632354736328,
0.19877038896083832,
0.7247053384780884,
-0.1803668588399887,
-0.21886920928955078,
0.013587838038802147,
-0.36560386419296265,
0.5336539149284363,
0.3314879536628723,
-0.3548717498779297,
-0.31810522079467773,
-0.14927972853183746,
-0.2912961542606354,
-0.13695386052131653,
-0.45264601707458496,
0.6274802088737488,
0.0742672011256218,
-0.23007255792617798,
0.2864408493041992,
-0.13351580500602722,
0.5984835028648376,
-0.6463497877120972,
0.0067485119216144085,
-0.3256559371948242,
0.0562165305018425,
-0.4252474904060364,
-0.8512074947357178,
0.2663864195346832,
0.18916884064674377,
-0.059648171067237854,
-0.36182236671447754,
0.5090247392654419,
0.05553160235285759,
-0.4873836636543274,
0.4108598828315735,
0.912011444568634,
0.333875834941864,
0.2323301136493683,
-0.5072304606437683,
0.20095643401145935,
-0.2262616753578186,
-0.35010969638824463,
0.7081369161605835,
0.670468270778656,
0.08540685474872589,
0.7546073198318481,
0.5205878019332886,
0.24181878566741943,
0.15016111731529236,
0.3370431363582611,
0.6399441361427307,
-0.6189160943031311,
0.025835763663053513,
-0.8919665813446045,
0.4311091899871826,
0.07867161184549332,
-0.5263146758079529,
0.8561318516731262,
0.7095038294792175,
0.5350114703178406,
0.24626962840557098,
0.6659078001976013,
0.30981820821762085,
0.2747081220149994,
-0.34685778617858887,
0.5431506037712097,
-0.612186074256897,
0.6093814969062805,
-0.4199717044830322,
-0.9182929992675781,
-0.13994953036308289,
0.3563908040523529,
-0.6902477741241455,
0.29026466608047485,
0.42215290665626526,
0.42703065276145935,
0.31043726205825806,
-0.10754465311765671,
0.4862346053123474,
0.052370570600032806,
0.43054208159446716,
0.3388303518295288,
1.2898272275924683,
-0.28629547357559204,
0.27480724453926086,
-0.03806678578257561,
-0.5473000407218933,
-0.25849202275276184,
-0.6623806357383728,
-0.5844784379005432,
-0.0689840316772461,
-0.31811290979385376,
0.0052032978273928165,
0.02699332870543003,
0.42026644945144653,
0.33843904733657837,
-0.36713191866874695,
-0.719879150390625,
0.3712795078754425,
0.2480669915676117,
-0.17919310927391052,
-0.2868044376373291,
0.37097519636154175,
-0.5178858041763306,
-0.23432005941867828,
0.29993298649787903,
0.30008357763290405,
-0.08553515374660492,
-0.6175045967102051,
-0.09635353833436966,
0.14240078628063202,
-0.12153229117393494,
0.8262373805046082,
-0.2393370121717453,
-0.5611885786056519,
-0.1429571807384491,
-0.08614948391914368,
-0.09809492528438568,
-0.008112364448606968,
0.8939914107322693,
-0.5334420204162598,
0.22065524756908417,
0.12316238880157471,
0.8451111316680908,
0.1746794879436493,
-0.12974411249160767,
0.4804880917072296,
-0.324679970741272,
-0.37096258997917175,
0.013260900974273682,
0.44761738181114197,
0.12534844875335693,
-0.10946184396743774,
0.7153981328010559,
0.38118404150009155,
-0.6628180742263794,
-1.000436544418335,
-0.09219257533550262,
-0.7267327904701233,
0.014739742502570152,
1.1558043956756592,
-0.2292095273733139,
0.012415504083037376,
-0.08354517817497253,
0.08896216750144958,
0.03813288360834122,
-0.08114304393529892,
0.7695650458335876,
0.6921658515930176,
-0.4206691384315491,
0.002669441746547818,
-0.751785159111023,
0.055405814200639725,
0.5203782320022583,
-0.6179120540618896,
-0.040670111775398254,
0.5664750933647156,
0.5441698431968689,
-0.13663651049137115,
0.43420541286468506,
-0.2633683979511261,
0.09536145627498627,
0.047260601073503494,
-0.12641778588294983,
0.29756903648376465,
-0.42538800835609436,
-0.7662383317947388,
0.4490525722503662,
0.25835639238357544,
-0.09001268446445465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15246v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15246v3
|
FollowIR: Evaluating and Teaching Information Retrieval Models to Follow Instructions
| 2024-03-22T14:42:29 | 2024-05-07T14:25:15 |
Orion Weller, Benjamin Chang, Sean MacAvaney, Kyle Lo, Arman Cohan, Benjamin Van Durme, Dawn Lawrie, Luca Soldaini
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Modern Language Models (LMs) are capable of following long and complex
instructions that enable a large and diverse set of user requests. While
Information Retrieval (IR) models use these LMs as the backbone of their
architectures, virtually none of them allow users to provide detailed
instructions alongside queries, thus limiting their ability to satisfy complex
information needs. In this work, we study the use of instructions in IR
systems. First, we introduce our dataset FollowIR, which contains a rigorous
instruction evaluation benchmark as well as a training set for helping IR
models learn to better follow real-world instructions. FollowIR repurposes
detailed instructions -- also known as narratives -- developed for professional
assessors to evaluate retrieval systems. In particular, we build our benchmark
from three collections curated for shared tasks at the Text REtrieval
Conference (TREC). These collections contains hundreds to thousands of labeled
documents per query, making them suitable for our exploration. Through this
process, we can measure how well IR models follow instructions, through a new
pairwise evaluation framework. Our results indicate that existing retrieval
models fail to correctly use instructions, using them for basic keywords and
struggling to understand long-form information. However, we show that it is
possible for IR models to learn to follow complex instructions: our new
FollowIR-7B model has significant improvements after fine-tuning on our
training set.
|
[
-0.043835073709487915,
-0.35159042477607727,
0.5292564034461975,
0.13003693521022797,
-0.05160144716501236,
0.18109191954135895,
-0.09302966296672821,
-0.33930298686027527,
-0.15538783371448517,
0.7093230485916138,
-0.5035021901130676,
-0.402458518743515,
-0.3926986753940582,
0.017415015026926994,
-0.4306086301803589,
1.011777639389038,
-0.42167818546295166,
0.2420007437467575,
-0.15583884716033936,
-0.22058355808258057,
-0.6892518997192383,
-0.21996630728244781,
-0.25263914465904236,
-0.44290685653686523,
0.5985817909240723,
0.6639101505279541,
0.6941273808479309,
0.6138642430305481,
0.8828006386756897,
0.13373684883117676,
0.0504184365272522,
0.29419636726379395,
-0.7295315861701965,
0.34927892684936523,
-0.20793978869915009,
-0.4203006327152252,
0.01766752265393734,
-0.00728783430531621,
0.49852582812309265,
0.742167592048645,
-0.26017481088638306,
0.2969953119754791,
-0.03188660740852356,
0.8556182980537415,
-0.8376285433769226,
0.3098544776439667,
-0.15732567012310028,
-0.08103301376104355,
0.22143656015396118,
-0.48699817061424255,
-0.7647461891174316,
-0.7512843608856201,
0.5468369126319885,
-0.4647326171398163,
0.007340095937252045,
0.33072006702423096,
0.5906543731689453,
-0.20436756312847137,
-0.2816379964351654,
-0.7220979928970337,
-0.814808189868927,
0.6964759230613708,
-0.30496349930763245,
0.5553902387619019,
0.5512484908103943,
0.4097501039505005,
-0.1944897174835205,
-0.9143573641777039,
-0.11546823382377625,
-0.5576911568641663,
-0.20008733868598938,
0.07809068262577057,
-0.3018817901611328,
0.16366975009441376,
0.3020275831222534,
0.03602825477719307,
-0.49136316776275635,
-0.1737692654132843,
-0.6712325215339661,
0.23300348222255707,
0.2875732183456421,
0.22662335634231567,
0.20331396162509918,
0.05790786072611809,
-0.7221415638923645,
-0.3540644943714142,
-0.7074518203735352,
0.02200760506093502,
0.296520859003067,
0.2549494802951813,
0.04571740701794624,
0.4862128794193268,
-0.3428815007209778,
0.8786776065826416,
-0.025536566972732544,
0.2226928025484085,
-0.014908406883478165,
-0.37514230608940125,
-0.09750615060329437,
0.02328922227025032,
0.6717818975448608,
0.30336815118789673,
0.3371899127960205,
-0.4668485224246979,
-0.6181342601776123,
-0.4220920205116272,
0.5261380672454834,
-0.9348235130310059,
-0.14068660140037537,
-0.12062210589647293,
-0.7486208081245422,
-0.03187663480639458,
0.15315808355808258,
-0.5313952565193176,
-0.24839943647384644,
-0.5979243516921997,
0.9905587434768677,
-0.6497600078582764,
0.16106894612312317,
0.29867544770240784,
-0.11710815876722336,
0.5808396339416504,
0.32143929600715637,
-0.6954764127731323,
0.6765535473823547,
0.8257914781570435,
0.6649209856987,
0.05069643631577492,
-0.2712680995464325,
-0.803821861743927,
0.0758495032787323,
-0.35983386635780334,
0.732843279838562,
-1.0958490371704102,
-0.38577398657798767,
0.08543233573436737,
-0.14935161173343658,
-0.16625367105007172,
-0.5376871228218079,
0.49104928970336914,
-0.7085307836532593,
0.18986079096794128,
-0.2445668876171112,
-0.5865512490272522,
-0.32005804777145386,
0.08642116189002991,
-0.6196020245552063,
0.8466382622718811,
0.1191168874502182,
-0.6717895865440369,
-0.06891997903585434,
-0.5925713181495667,
-0.5031716227531433,
0.034400634467601776,
-0.0062500364147126675,
0.10915212333202362,
0.11974149942398071,
-0.19519257545471191,
0.480691134929657,
-0.4023585617542267,
0.057537879794836044,
-0.13383963704109192,
-0.8577513694763184,
-0.045232150703668594,
-0.19531026482582092,
0.4218328297138214,
0.13839735090732574,
-0.229439377784729,
0.13418066501617432,
-0.5974265933036804,
0.043828465044498444,
-0.18975186347961426,
-0.31860414147377014,
-0.5266928672790527,
0.044719357043504715,
-0.05311629921197891,
-0.24815382063388824,
0.07310550659894943,
-0.21703536808490753,
0.4238308072090149,
0.10036974400281906,
0.16645078361034393,
0.6690736413002014,
-0.030199050903320312,
0.2722243070602417,
-0.599607527256012,
0.6917516589164734,
-0.5242745876312256,
0.10935165733098984,
-0.6457201838493347,
-0.08146960288286209,
-0.726753294467926,
0.1983114629983902,
0.20630183815956116,
0.49924570322036743,
-0.5567193031311035,
0.0016699146945029497,
-0.42854616045951843,
-0.6877177357673645,
-0.6666046977043152,
0.05661019682884216,
0.7821651101112366,
0.4395177960395813,
0.4779762029647827,
-0.15424692630767822,
-0.5642067790031433,
-0.7616337537765503,
-0.40599921345710754,
-0.28440171480178833,
0.060142941772937775,
0.33788567781448364,
0.6413093209266663,
-0.06572113931179047,
0.3296826481819153,
-0.28777632117271423,
-0.06028731167316437,
-0.2313595712184906,
0.258451908826828,
0.06940508633852005,
0.4771290421485901,
0.1735229194164276,
-0.8444311022758484,
-0.3235815167427063,
-0.1449083685874939,
-0.8955646753311157,
0.041703030467033386,
-0.07258600741624832,
-0.26023656129837036,
-0.22306357324123383,
0.6191747784614563,
-0.2656272053718567,
0.39731720089912415,
0.16428008675575256,
-0.3577326834201813,
0.5034828186035156,
-0.33564379811286926,
0.5077416896820068,
-0.7126995325088501,
0.22381316125392914,
0.03710770606994629,
-0.3951757252216339,
-0.5725597739219666,
0.48166564106941223,
0.14071471989154816,
-0.0025541852228343487,
-0.1437903195619583,
0.579753041267395,
-0.7528446912765503,
0.027848657220602036,
-0.1487293392419815,
-0.03402232751250267,
0.2574293911457062,
0.30594298243522644,
-0.03173161670565605,
0.6894286274909973,
0.389306902885437,
-0.7005826234817505,
0.23030509054660797,
0.2491728961467743,
-0.5884768962860107,
0.5118573307991028,
-0.6216399669647217,
0.49525654315948486,
-0.3784010410308838,
0.05516296252608299,
-0.8855999112129211,
-0.16362546384334564,
0.0991305559873581,
-0.22666944563388824,
0.6063719391822815,
-0.30777543783187866,
-0.6314947009086609,
-0.0943525955080986,
-0.4163586497306824,
0.0005605619517154992,
0.5107097625732422,
-0.6323490142822266,
0.8282236456871033,
0.01021232083439827,
0.08827473968267441,
-0.7679567933082581,
-0.4629591703414917,
-0.07936964184045792,
0.0969938412308693,
-0.4885175824165344,
0.356084942817688,
-0.23482219874858856,
-0.417294979095459,
0.0045841592364013195,
-0.3113011121749878,
-0.09810160845518112,
0.051193028688430786,
0.2860158383846283,
0.15219764411449432,
-0.2642917037010193,
0.17939959466457367,
-0.13938653469085693,
0.2393757700920105,
0.06085365265607834,
-0.15599551796913147,
0.4931699335575104,
-0.06586190313100815,
-0.34126967191696167,
-0.7120422720909119,
0.32967308163642883,
0.31061211228370667,
-0.39742958545684814,
0.7102580666542053,
0.33488622307777405,
-0.239322230219841,
-0.03414802625775337,
-0.7815238833427429,
-0.35464999079704285,
-0.44806721806526184,
0.29905903339385986,
-0.5339449644088745,
-0.5771723985671997,
0.3400864601135254,
0.05921643599867821,
0.1802721917629242,
0.02049461379647255,
-0.027689768001437187,
-0.44918376207351685,
0.8347198367118835,
0.6959943175315857,
0.11138933897018433,
0.6825507283210754,
-0.29026320576667786,
-0.13708429038524628,
-0.8240351676940918,
-0.5077223181724548,
-0.7245200872421265,
-0.3338204622268677,
-0.35803675651550293,
-0.3799321949481964,
0.15703989565372467,
0.29023197293281555,
-0.22188685834407806,
0.37754109501838684,
-0.3719511926174164,
0.6683369278907776,
0.6679540872573853,
0.48542436957359314,
0.17463481426239014,
0.1278788298368454,
0.011623360216617584,
0.18656936287879944,
-0.6106832027435303,
-0.713880181312561,
0.9353434443473816,
0.1535932719707489,
1.3781708478927612,
-0.0070547438226640224,
0.7774250507354736,
0.4558391869068146,
0.2915620803833008,
-0.7536419630050659,
0.573652446269989,
-0.24636754393577576,
-0.2359243631362915,
0.34350842237472534,
-0.5246637463569641,
-0.8954799175262451,
-0.008673223666846752,
0.008153732866048813,
-0.5102967023849487,
0.11248266696929932,
0.02237432822585106,
-0.21887555718421936,
0.11518336832523346,
-0.9245034456253052,
0.5988504886627197,
-0.28417152166366577,
-0.45539626479148865,
-0.2895321547985077,
-0.8096019625663757,
-0.06770794838666916,
0.18748794496059418,
0.10890763252973557,
0.30994343757629395,
0.058677125722169876,
0.9414262771606445,
-0.041468992829322815,
0.7673114538192749,
-0.16250844299793243,
0.33763960003852844,
0.28932100534439087,
0.4550139605998993,
0.4597682058811188,
-0.5152353644371033,
-0.3705724775791168,
-0.47731122374534607,
0.1782952845096588,
-0.19670623540878296,
-0.6741539239883423,
0.7629054188728333,
-0.5736405849456787,
-0.7501428127288818,
-0.16369828581809998,
-0.24696840345859528,
-0.01244825217872858,
0.3035159707069397,
-0.053368695080280304,
0.8041814565658569,
-0.22068984806537628,
0.4355391561985016,
0.9447242021560669,
0.027270963415503502,
0.10456164926290512,
0.7532422542572021,
-0.11200247704982758,
-0.11196226626634598,
0.7489728927612305,
0.18309146165847778,
0.3213076889514923,
0.76417076587677,
0.33066147565841675,
-0.11413995921611786,
-0.43843749165534973,
-0.33514419198036194,
0.25163084268569946,
-0.9416422843933105,
-0.3726295828819275,
-0.5372321009635925,
-0.02646162360906601,
-0.2010934054851532,
0.15049773454666138,
0.009612909518182278,
-0.08319142460823059,
-0.27861419320106506,
-0.14296680688858032,
0.25375303626060486,
1.177054762840271,
0.3322252333164215,
0.30166780948638916,
-1.0224168300628662,
0.13215477764606476,
-0.03899958357214928,
0.5290566086769104,
0.174961656332016,
-0.7726706266403198,
-0.3006501793861389,
-0.02443118579685688,
-0.14938302338123322,
-1.0032823085784912,
-0.01447274163365364,
0.16324755549430847,
0.7098205089569092,
0.10768109560012817,
0.22960397601127625,
0.7132571935653687,
-0.5627776980400085,
0.18346630036830902,
-0.29611530900001526,
-0.7377834320068359,
0.7577013969421387,
-0.11605475842952728,
0.3464961647987366,
0.7511953115463257,
0.7561572194099426,
-0.554977297782898,
-0.09642951190471649,
-0.25956693291664124,
-0.5701352953910828,
1.006422519683838,
0.10372494906187057,
0.34454309940338135,
0.16446833312511444,
0.870797336101532,
0.21804966032505035,
0.10683503746986389,
-0.45121827721595764,
-0.17507414519786835,
0.15808190405368805,
-0.6480816006660461,
0.4844585359096527,
-0.5617727041244507,
-0.12589871883392334,
0.3985903859138489,
0.5345679521560669,
0.08998888731002808,
0.29958784580230713,
0.33058568835258484,
-0.1886698305606842,
-0.16964802145957947,
0.25814735889434814,
0.3414294421672821,
0.8938917517662048,
-0.4109251797199249,
0.04086553677916527,
-0.34357205033302307,
-0.3714408874511719,
-0.16197431087493896,
0.3186050355434418,
-0.2692825198173523,
-0.032604947686195374,
0.6633162498474121,
1.036573886871338,
0.4202493131160736,
-0.892915666103363,
0.44581839442253113,
-0.2600327134132385,
-0.05051029101014137,
-0.30720359086990356,
0.3202168643474579,
0.06150539964437485,
0.33216986060142517,
0.4971102178096771,
0.058320302516222,
0.3394260108470917,
-0.7295219302177429,
0.17647455632686615,
0.3253124952316284,
-0.795518159866333,
-0.45978328585624695,
0.43239253759384155,
-0.0423613041639328,
-0.6136147975921631,
0.5729626417160034,
0.07918290793895721,
-0.4484296143054962,
0.4026961028575897,
0.35881975293159485,
0.5591038465499878,
-0.2465866655111313,
0.07305539399385452,
0.17586304247379303,
0.3794071674346924,
-0.5879656076431274,
0.5077412128448486,
-0.21101419627666473,
-0.28090861439704895,
-0.05851350352168083,
-0.37663760781288147,
-0.6011446118354797,
-0.1753307729959488,
-1.0283812284469604,
0.39515429735183716,
-0.4631923735141754,
0.3153097629547119,
0.09728502482175827,
-0.03841258957982063,
-0.7478717565536499,
0.037040360271930695,
-0.10648786276578903,
1.1545720100402832,
-0.46500176191329956,
0.48599499464035034,
0.7215608954429626,
-0.6590747237205505,
-0.8674429655075073,
-0.00008148545020958409,
-0.21207784116268158,
-0.7476360201835632,
0.9070770740509033,
0.6864598393440247,
-0.4033709466457367,
-0.09173233807086945,
-0.852571427822113,
-0.48341265320777893,
1.0266584157943726,
0.2709544897079468,
-0.6360530257225037,
-0.3299444615840912,
-0.43313732743263245,
0.6219344139099121,
-0.5351361036300659,
0.676853358745575,
0.19492052495479584,
0.25421419739723206,
0.3680826723575592,
-0.7607834339141846,
-0.09171543270349503,
-0.035135600715875626,
-0.3597375750541687,
0.18364959955215454,
-0.6680983304977417,
0.47087952494621277,
-0.5596809387207031,
-0.25633350014686584,
0.3276102840900421,
0.4167226254940033,
0.11390902101993561,
0.3152465224266052,
0.39273545145988464,
0.09448800981044769,
0.6121000051498413,
0.16460087895393372,
1.2733210325241089,
-0.12984050810337067,
0.10458964854478836,
1.4052553176879883,
-0.2734322249889374,
1.2182265520095825,
0.3164852261543274,
0.13092215359210968,
0.7073791027069092,
0.4036136567592621,
-0.05698944255709648,
0.4421803951263428,
0.18095098435878754,
-0.10477475821971893,
-0.21567709743976593,
-0.24087001383304596,
-0.08776579797267914,
0.36111631989479065,
0.30117374658584595,
-0.6858484745025635,
0.007497951854020357,
-0.02851465344429016,
-0.02287466637790203,
0.3288678228855133,
-0.351246178150177,
0.8646400570869446,
-0.019673289731144905,
-0.8926341533660889,
0.506530225276947,
-0.11328598856925964,
0.31314972043037415,
-0.6843205094337463,
-0.5319644808769226,
-0.349414199590683,
0.1874181032180786,
-0.11723463237285614,
-0.8779534101486206,
-0.15304788947105408,
0.1266106218099594,
-0.14477276802062988,
-0.32239797711372375,
0.721861720085144,
-0.3669804632663727,
-0.49201110005378723,
0.6346840858459473,
0.30333957076072693,
0.2847469747066498,
0.24142372608184814,
-0.492058128118515,
0.02746415138244629,
0.2997223138809204,
-0.3071376085281372,
0.12705884873867035,
0.25832995772361755,
-0.13831686973571777,
1.0811887979507446,
0.35826122760772705,
-0.06396152824163437,
-0.05412440747022629,
0.26428505778312683,
0.886605978012085,
-0.715932309627533,
0.0007549357251264155,
-0.7104275822639465,
0.16444428265094757,
0.2620617747306824,
-0.000027319676519255154,
0.4182529151439667,
0.5550005435943604,
0.936701238155365,
0.06669076532125473,
0.5260910987854004,
0.08517595380544662,
0.6930594444274902,
-0.6689770221710205,
0.5108518600463867,
-0.44014737010002136,
0.5251642465591431,
0.1689186543226242,
-0.8470914959907532,
-0.1907331347465515,
0.49348315596580505,
-0.0694689229130745,
0.3079385459423065,
0.3636726140975952,
0.6787863969802856,
-0.24988777935504913,
0.15977419912815094,
-0.027341198176145554,
0.19056907296180725,
0.2633638083934784,
0.24407875537872314,
0.9043974876403809,
-0.5854166150093079,
0.8882624506950378,
-0.18585726618766785,
-0.1586599051952362,
-0.30337992310523987,
-0.45412302017211914,
-1.0025638341903687,
-0.36498600244522095,
-0.2405751496553421,
-0.38917484879493713,
0.6963092088699341,
1.1189637184143066,
0.5767975449562073,
-0.6031551957130432,
-0.46927645802497864,
0.14923541247844696,
0.12447039783000946,
-0.1482115089893341,
-0.20329563319683075,
0.36653950810432434,
-0.3672727048397064,
-0.5417162775993347,
0.5389254689216614,
0.07885486632585526,
-0.02220604382455349,
-0.2164786010980606,
-0.08373793959617615,
-0.5113580822944641,
-0.12273558974266052,
0.22950772941112518,
0.0658276379108429,
-0.5650809407234192,
-0.41587480902671814,
0.5223929286003113,
-0.3200727701187134,
0.10849124193191528,
0.9172512292861938,
-0.934612512588501,
0.9599232077598572,
0.6772722601890564,
0.527280867099762,
0.514007568359375,
0.016026470810174942,
0.8291788697242737,
-0.41796186566352844,
-0.5094159245491028,
0.3274838328361511,
0.2004002183675766,
0.5333765745162964,
-0.13198213279247284,
0.6884375810623169,
-0.29097631573677063,
-0.5661413073539734,
-0.8833120465278625,
-0.05455172806978226,
-0.8529258370399475,
-0.04231545329093933,
1.0537742376327515,
-0.566012442111969,
-0.20389552414417267,
0.039028361439704895,
-0.22876819968223572,
0.13596777617931366,
-0.5474753379821777,
0.43781569600105286,
0.5386709570884705,
-0.10347612202167511,
-0.3596867024898529,
-0.5764511823654175,
0.1324373334646225,
0.3083247244358063,
-0.2900928854942322,
0.16725148260593414,
0.4169718325138092,
0.43963539600372314,
0.1192525252699852,
0.3998350501060486,
0.08709731698036194,
0.22422891855239868,
-0.30541419982910156,
0.04976941645145416,
-0.10996518284082413,
-0.3663794994354248,
-0.39626452326774597,
-0.0032986560836434364,
0.10618624836206436,
-0.17607484757900238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15226v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15226v2
|
Not All Attention is Needed: Parameter and Computation Efficient Transfer Learning for Multi-modal Large Language Models
| 2024-03-22T14:20:34 | 2024-06-05T05:52:44 |
Qiong Wu, Weihao Ye, Yiyi Zhou, Xiaoshuai Sun, Rongrong Ji
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose a novel parameter and computation efficient tuning
method for Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs), termed Efficient
Attention Skipping (EAS). Concretely, we first reveal that multi-head
attentions (MHAs), the main computational overhead of MLLMs, are often
redundant to downstream tasks. Based on this observation, EAS evaluates the
attention redundancy and skips the less important MHAs to speed up inference.
Besides, we also propose a novel propagation-of-information adapter (PIA) to
serve the attention skipping of EAS and keep parameter efficiency, which can be
further re-parameterized into feed-forward networks (FFNs) for zero-extra
latency. To validate EAS, we apply it to a recently proposed MLLM called LaVIN
and a classic VL pre-trained model called METER, and conduct extensive
experiments on a set of benchmarks. The experiments show that EAS not only
retains high performance and parameter efficiency, but also greatly speeds up
inference speed. For instance, LaVIN-EAS can obtain 89.98\% accuracy on
ScineceQA while speeding up inference by 2.2 times to LaVIN
|
[
-0.5257752537727356,
-0.7732242345809937,
0.5794188380241394,
0.42385780811309814,
-0.03266504034399986,
-0.20007607340812683,
-0.41298192739486694,
-0.5182847380638123,
-0.1624520868062973,
0.2834547460079193,
-0.5606890320777893,
-0.0034337022807449102,
-0.7065983414649963,
-0.09772767871618271,
-0.17749477922916412,
0.7554327249526978,
0.1597129851579666,
-0.09336642175912857,
0.17068994045257568,
-0.10611134767532349,
-0.0495835617184639,
-0.26542285084724426,
-0.9688183665275574,
0.10473242402076721,
0.9577207565307617,
0.22075633704662323,
0.3585246503353119,
0.890670657157898,
0.2424420565366745,
0.29955101013183594,
-0.2109834998846054,
0.6540045738220215,
-0.5917028784751892,
0.06434686481952667,
-0.17145423591136932,
-0.060242488980293274,
-0.5576621890068054,
-0.3341558575630188,
0.7986388802528381,
0.7572168707847595,
0.13923504948616028,
0.1386391967535019,
0.17166519165039062,
0.6506157517433167,
-1.072220802307129,
0.2483976036310196,
-0.78824383020401,
-0.16721026599407196,
-0.19296638667583466,
-0.3227543532848358,
-0.9039453864097595,
-0.07368446886539459,
0.10579907894134521,
-0.6763707399368286,
0.043806787580251694,
0.09774379432201385,
0.562455952167511,
0.31041744351387024,
-0.5925074219703674,
0.20248673856258392,
-0.7065417170524597,
0.9916902184486389,
-0.5770241618156433,
1.0093919038772583,
0.4708055853843689,
0.11478292942047119,
0.0988588035106659,
-0.6633330583572388,
-0.3919767737388611,
-0.294788658618927,
-0.02418149821460247,
-0.1965136080980301,
0.03116142749786377,
0.14180387556552887,
0.29236868023872375,
-0.11147452145814896,
-0.3131774067878723,
0.048919402062892914,
-0.3495215177536011,
-0.26696816086769104,
0.41070640087127686,
0.04420855641365051,
-0.3390761911869049,
0.33782443404197693,
-0.24022792279720306,
0.09895946830511093,
-0.7528631091117859,
0.24136003851890564,
0.04800854250788689,
0.4027356505393982,
-0.042391929775476456,
0.1780102550983429,
-0.2655763626098633,
1.2601721286773682,
0.25799891352653503,
-0.12983089685440063,
0.2951328158378601,
-0.6682770252227783,
-0.25995999574661255,
-0.3778907358646393,
0.6282703876495361,
-0.02883806824684143,
0.4722776412963867,
-0.17837803065776825,
0.050484370440244675,
-0.5213136076927185,
0.22867947816848755,
-0.8846536874771118,
-0.2464550882577896,
0.09141433984041214,
-0.500917911529541,
0.062249209731817245,
-0.35036736726760864,
-0.5975954532623291,
-0.001270128763280809,
-0.4805096387863159,
0.39863643050193787,
-0.48742473125457764,
-0.16344811022281647,
-0.020975815132260323,
0.3859306871891022,
0.2270822376012802,
0.5420127511024475,
-0.9409438967704773,
-0.19115838408470154,
0.46747905015945435,
0.8774366974830627,
-0.19321613013744354,
-0.6533752083778381,
-1.2286454439163208,
0.33555787801742554,
-0.2371731549501419,
0.5209318995475769,
-0.6895653009414673,
-0.010582931339740753,
-0.32088854908943176,
0.14363709092140198,
-0.5203794240951538,
-0.024539995938539505,
0.4780294895172119,
-0.7163559198379517,
-0.2653566300868988,
-0.17570622265338898,
-0.43325725197792053,
-0.4373021125793457,
-0.007689442485570908,
-0.7347890734672546,
0.7811019420623779,
-0.1110837385058403,
-0.5809139609336853,
0.1286524087190628,
-0.6772997379302979,
-0.7321621775627136,
-0.35555699467658997,
0.3127235472202301,
-0.2160094827413559,
0.07963547110557556,
0.2389056235551834,
0.6022939682006836,
-0.2802273631095886,
0.044495951384305954,
-0.4588358998298645,
-0.45322516560554504,
0.17168955504894257,
-0.767998218536377,
0.6634963750839233,
0.3555751144886017,
-0.31545180082321167,
0.2452038675546646,
-0.9224904775619507,
0.2660027742385864,
-0.2629767656326294,
-0.5442320108413696,
-0.30290040373802185,
0.06678864359855652,
0.30730733275413513,
0.3654017448425293,
0.20433518290519714,
-0.18508540093898773,
0.012874528765678406,
-0.286813884973526,
0.3676147162914276,
0.8517413139343262,
-0.2867806553840637,
0.3229886293411255,
-0.1133970245718956,
0.2241663634777069,
-0.10092433542013168,
0.23903773725032806,
-0.4437042474746704,
-0.21239984035491943,
-0.920501172542572,
-0.6230030059814453,
0.5236715078353882,
0.43133780360221863,
-0.6349477171897888,
0.4924807846546173,
-0.16506396234035492,
-0.37461915612220764,
-0.6451398730278015,
0.11222568899393082,
0.387289822101593,
0.6022844910621643,
0.38426223397254944,
0.293084979057312,
-0.30301225185394287,
-0.8627011775970459,
-0.4487701952457428,
0.12294057011604309,
0.07143786549568176,
0.3749960660934448,
0.10666700452566147,
0.19429104030132294,
0.43709853291511536,
-0.22228841483592987,
-0.04900120943784714,
-0.20948056876659393,
-0.03282685950398445,
-0.01101215835660696,
0.2826652526855469,
0.4946137070655823,
-0.6939865946769714,
-0.697552502155304,
0.21144412457942963,
-0.3217857778072357,
-0.16842198371887207,
-0.10612920671701431,
-0.13616883754730225,
0.2995876967906952,
0.6470890045166016,
-0.3950110375881195,
0.21400578320026398,
0.6974672675132751,
-0.386241614818573,
0.3029848337173462,
-0.2767946422100067,
0.37574517726898193,
-0.7977648377418518,
0.4668809175491333,
0.02830817736685276,
-0.5936069488525391,
-0.7969648838043213,
0.07132507115602493,
0.4415406286716461,
0.36530059576034546,
-0.7852345108985901,
0.6438872218132019,
-0.6423430442810059,
0.24790887534618378,
-0.40153205394744873,
-0.006898733787238598,
0.0658857524394989,
0.8861303925514221,
-0.06174810975790024,
0.8323037624359131,
0.868924081325531,
-0.9997901916503906,
0.19202972948551178,
-0.0968465805053711,
0.05437536910176277,
0.3619511127471924,
-0.4217280447483063,
0.19056271016597748,
-0.21993130445480347,
0.0962284728884697,
-0.7273361086845398,
0.27387821674346924,
0.3376534879207611,
-0.2087111622095108,
0.4513886570930481,
-0.1343604475259781,
-0.1627282202243805,
0.017494695261120796,
-0.3589790165424347,
0.5925688743591309,
0.09589560329914093,
-0.4608016610145569,
0.8457890748977661,
0.09190554171800613,
-0.09810624271631241,
-0.6598545908927917,
-0.5187199115753174,
-0.12324400246143341,
-0.18196198344230652,
-0.3890864849090576,
0.17010636627674103,
-0.4178627133369446,
0.0740547776222229,
-0.042614199221134186,
0.19096262753009796,
-0.25525355339050293,
0.11201629787683487,
-0.1596623659133911,
-0.005062030162662268,
-0.24143238365650177,
0.23785774409770966,
0.06566575169563293,
-0.12283992767333984,
-0.26666972041130066,
-0.22575125098228455,
0.48235228657722473,
-0.0050714341923594475,
-0.43179017305374146,
-0.6488996744155884,
0.47874924540519714,
0.9220216274261475,
-0.584771990776062,
1.018042802810669,
0.6905633211135864,
-0.19483092427253723,
-0.08398257195949554,
-0.585709273815155,
-0.18183660507202148,
-0.4067230522632599,
0.7640226483345032,
-0.619777262210846,
-0.8201127648353577,
0.3216269612312317,
-0.06352309882640839,
0.3315655291080475,
0.31709975004196167,
0.5966882705688477,
0.3174314796924591,
1.015506625175476,
0.7335852384567261,
-0.23199234902858734,
0.7559407949447632,
0.00036912827636115253,
0.09289465099573135,
-1.0145153999328613,
-0.0936494767665863,
-0.48808667063713074,
-0.33090370893478394,
-0.34216606616973877,
-0.6313867568969727,
0.31872424483299255,
0.02431495301425457,
-0.30207401514053345,
0.0927860215306282,
-0.04828926548361778,
0.48824599385261536,
0.31382495164871216,
0.1161496639251709,
0.4038821756839752,
-0.05135413631796837,
0.31236833333969116,
-0.031453315168619156,
-0.6350148916244507,
0.19750037789344788,
1.2281652688980103,
0.22931142151355743,
0.6353881359100342,
0.13121528923511505,
0.06638987362384796,
0.22813254594802856,
0.18857255578041077,
-0.8268444538116455,
0.33914822340011597,
-0.18438506126403809,
-0.3430509865283966,
-0.6017869114875793,
-0.517501950263977,
-0.7600722908973694,
0.7090238928794861,
0.01146609801799059,
-0.8309887647628784,
0.22189009189605713,
0.30974677205085754,
-0.47007566690444946,
0.3021726608276367,
-0.6436666250228882,
0.5811743140220642,
-0.17116117477416992,
-0.8715159893035889,
-0.5192005634307861,
-0.6413906216621399,
0.29586538672447205,
-0.4002962112426758,
0.19825631380081177,
-0.029697749763727188,
-0.25631019473075867,
0.47151896357536316,
-0.1642419695854187,
0.5419474244117737,
-0.19067074358463287,
-0.12310377508401871,
0.0908520370721817,
0.044866375625133514,
0.730660080909729,
-0.08474129438400269,
-0.30502572655677795,
0.08198042213916779,
-0.2703736126422882,
-0.41145527362823486,
-0.5609082579612732,
0.8130186200141907,
-0.38162490725517273,
-0.2856470048427582,
-0.008851205930113792,
-0.8081898093223572,
-0.5093457698822021,
0.2516385316848755,
-0.040029045194387436,
0.3634735345840454,
0.14789123833179474,
0.41448116302490234,
0.8904399871826172,
0.1280747503042221,
0.6965286135673523,
0.7771289944648743,
0.06996835023164749,
-0.19905699789524078,
0.8520152568817139,
0.13774818181991577,
0.4494958817958832,
0.47635287046432495,
0.04654402285814285,
-0.2591326832771301,
-0.5102338194847107,
-0.7124471664428711,
0.3651064932346344,
-0.41739675402641296,
-0.1163598820567131,
-0.8997959494590759,
-0.4258261024951935,
-0.30169662833213806,
0.0718584731221199,
-0.7265656590461731,
-0.13740338385105133,
-0.29863864183425903,
0.23705637454986572,
0.5587220788002014,
0.3172864317893982,
-0.008186130784451962,
0.29194071888923645,
-0.9129428863525391,
0.34211647510528564,
0.15527866780757904,
0.4327969253063202,
0.50766921043396,
-0.8148260116577148,
-0.4603117108345032,
-0.11326625943183899,
-0.08638881146907806,
-0.7214207649230957,
0.1841464787721634,
0.6549708843231201,
0.6802752614021301,
0.5783692002296448,
-0.019974682480096817,
0.7014925479888916,
-0.5355692505836487,
0.40013808012008667,
0.01694645918905735,
-1.1195627450942993,
0.2003440409898758,
-0.32296109199523926,
0.38178780674934387,
0.557315468788147,
0.30691277980804443,
-0.38173171877861023,
-0.16943398118019104,
-0.10508217662572861,
-1.0169868469238281,
1.0650697946548462,
0.007045325357466936,
-0.02395464852452278,
0.3184928297996521,
0.4013024568557739,
0.10388469696044922,
0.1357543170452118,
-0.7009477615356445,
-0.44641995429992676,
0.41010773181915283,
-0.04838990792632103,
-0.14211824536323547,
-0.24384808540344238,
0.16157038509845734,
-0.4932708740234375,
0.851108193397522,
-0.4006061553955078,
-0.040531933307647705,
0.06090221181511879,
-0.2559565603733063,
-0.0997411459684372,
0.12867899239063263,
0.7589502930641174,
0.9339329600334167,
0.1134396493434906,
0.09072958678007126,
0.37220215797424316,
-0.19916877150535583,
0.08791983127593994,
0.1970486044883728,
-0.08573061972856522,
-0.12924443185329437,
0.22323326766490936,
1.1174699068069458,
0.2912994623184204,
-0.5487298369407654,
0.46730145812034607,
-0.02376970648765564,
-0.26250430941581726,
0.04712061211466789,
-0.054088130593299866,
0.3409198820590973,
0.30971360206604004,
0.21011047065258026,
0.17843656241893768,
0.1626351773738861,
-0.20005449652671814,
0.14405392110347748,
0.4562453329563141,
-0.22242431342601776,
-0.2661176919937134,
0.6424718499183655,
0.25033020973205566,
-0.23190778493881226,
0.29972225427627563,
0.16176016628742218,
-0.22938159108161926,
0.23906803131103516,
0.4713629186153412,
0.7438542246818542,
-0.5625960230827332,
-0.06817792356014252,
0.18105030059814453,
0.2758652865886688,
0.03823902830481529,
0.15766996145248413,
-0.4207778871059418,
-0.33591383695602417,
-0.9173727631568909,
-0.6329062581062317,
-0.16395597159862518,
0.4652320444583893,
-0.35889533162117004,
0.2574390172958374,
-0.30159226059913635,
0.08686643838882446,
0.05332700535655022,
-0.46950680017471313,
-0.7446839809417725,
0.1332513839006424,
0.08631665259599686,
0.914387047290802,
-0.7200073003768921,
1.0233619213104248,
0.5240175724029541,
0.18998174369335175,
-0.7972993850708008,
0.15340407192707062,
-0.23919469118118286,
-0.5888785719871521,
0.5435688495635986,
-0.01921497844159603,
-0.552679717540741,
0.20651517808437347,
-0.0016616639913991094,
-1.161766529083252,
0.6758872270584106,
0.5541608929634094,
-0.7829312086105347,
-0.021000782027840614,
-0.2959992289543152,
0.2553948163986206,
-0.09560476988554001,
0.3748837411403656,
0.47266966104507446,
0.8031333684921265,
0.104127436876297,
-1.1700975894927979,
-0.060268938541412354,
-0.1463443636894226,
-0.14492079615592957,
0.34170472621917725,
-1.0854331254959106,
0.9805590510368347,
-0.1952609270811081,
0.30309346318244934,
-0.0013386199716478586,
0.6540879011154175,
0.04868684336543083,
0.15282122790813446,
0.7148683071136475,
0.20315124094486237,
0.6359588503837585,
0.18890205025672913,
0.8681291937828064,
-0.4882543385028839,
0.33533406257629395,
0.8370848298072815,
-0.06070571392774582,
0.8475916385650635,
0.6521898508071899,
-0.16526879370212555,
-0.04898177832365036,
0.42822927236557007,
0.3121515214443207,
0.5897719860076904,
0.08891520649194717,
-0.198622465133667,
-0.5551273822784424,
0.07143322378396988,
-0.4495273530483246,
0.6554856300354004,
0.20988579094409943,
-0.6240593791007996,
-0.11881472915410995,
0.1610167920589447,
-0.06137927249073982,
-0.3204977810382843,
-0.3817530572414398,
0.6759197115898132,
-0.048978667706251144,
-0.711383581161499,
0.8340597152709961,
0.12392497062683105,
0.6795576810836792,
-0.9128483533859253,
0.08061247318983078,
-0.07812939584255219,
0.3169141709804535,
-0.01180689875036478,
-0.22027422487735748,
0.23305881023406982,
-0.2442084401845932,
-0.5112608671188354,
-0.18212634325027466,
0.5027738809585571,
-0.6340346336364746,
-0.5050156712532043,
0.3770897686481476,
0.6834263801574707,
0.0838899314403534,
-0.2624862492084503,
-0.5061832070350647,
0.18287184834480286,
0.17260533571243286,
-0.8103846311569214,
0.4440562427043915,
0.4749249219894409,
-0.11726658046245575,
0.6888635158538818,
0.6876623034477234,
0.4151429533958435,
0.24488241970539093,
0.04528626799583435,
0.781507134437561,
-0.5761786699295044,
-0.7278844118118286,
-0.9991001486778259,
0.5156474113464355,
0.07327297329902649,
-0.18442124128341675,
0.5952978730201721,
0.4423081576824188,
0.4605996310710907,
-0.10219421237707138,
0.7333969473838806,
0.19707711040973663,
0.4437570869922638,
-0.8017842173576355,
0.7838361859321594,
-0.7620499134063721,
0.12115340679883957,
-0.13253161311149597,
-1.0882792472839355,
-0.19510982930660248,
0.504605770111084,
-0.015340791083872318,
0.3266913592815399,
0.7061605453491211,
0.6114914417266846,
-0.38915762305259705,
-0.23778705298900604,
0.5432320833206177,
0.21489204466342926,
0.3285306990146637,
0.8095989227294922,
0.4930926561355591,
-0.28718894720077515,
0.5141376852989197,
-0.02940027043223381,
-0.34229257702827454,
-0.3996962904930115,
-0.8576909303665161,
-0.6551321744918823,
-0.5723696947097778,
-0.2819702625274658,
-0.1727973073720932,
0.26390549540519714,
0.7923446893692017,
1.1425974369049072,
-0.7900947332382202,
-0.025463249534368515,
0.07656539976596832,
-0.04247007519006729,
-0.26441463828086853,
-0.2556215524673462,
0.5456812381744385,
-0.3593297600746155,
-1.0521440505981445,
0.586394727230072,
0.2871512174606323,
-0.2818422317504883,
-0.24105001986026764,
-0.0818815529346466,
-0.41794392466545105,
0.177000492811203,
0.8502932190895081,
0.297091543674469,
-0.7862410545349121,
-0.3406645357608795,
0.015481822192668915,
0.0693526566028595,
-0.10813070088624954,
0.9966663718223572,
-0.7864161133766174,
0.2890900671482086,
0.4400184452533722,
0.9335935115814209,
0.4152437448501587,
-0.1016361340880394,
0.5091765522956848,
-0.583900511264801,
0.4498606026172638,
0.0013404201017692685,
0.318742960691452,
0.2661767303943634,
-0.4360426962375641,
0.11242645233869553,
0.13574664294719696,
-0.5545388460159302,
-0.6758961081504822,
0.26076436042785645,
-0.9526166915893555,
-0.3173750638961792,
1.1077837944030762,
-0.18927323818206787,
-0.2531636357307434,
-0.15641804039478302,
-0.3263278007507324,
0.20258308947086334,
-0.4098913073539734,
0.593073308467865,
0.4970169961452484,
-0.4122099280357361,
-0.5165300965309143,
-0.548785924911499,
0.452337384223938,
0.708301305770874,
-0.7689700126647949,
0.5525141954421997,
0.4985698461532593,
0.31104710698127747,
-0.04443966969847679,
0.534187376499176,
0.22612932324409485,
0.3509151339530945,
-0.2616576850414276,
-0.24138526618480682,
-0.5312663316726685,
-0.6649590134620667,
-0.3637518584728241,
0.2625238001346588,
0.08273058384656906,
-0.3188098669052124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15214v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15214v1
|
InstaSynth: Opportunities and Challenges in Generating Synthetic Instagram Data with ChatGPT for Sponsored Content Detection
| 2024-03-22T13:58:42 | 2024-03-22T13:58:42 |
Thales Bertaglia, Lily Heisig, Rishabh Kaushal, Adriana Iamnitchi
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) raise concerns about lowering the cost of
generating texts that could be used for unethical or illegal purposes,
especially on social media. This paper investigates the promise of such models
to help enforce legal requirements related to the disclosure of sponsored
content online. We investigate the use of LLMs for generating synthetic
Instagram captions with two objectives: The first objective (fidelity) is to
produce realistic synthetic datasets. For this, we implement content-level and
network-level metrics to assess whether synthetic captions are realistic. The
second objective (utility) is to create synthetic data that is useful for
sponsored content detection. For this, we evaluate the effectiveness of the
generated synthetic data for training classifiers to identify undisclosed
advertisements on Instagram. Our investigations show that the objectives of
fidelity and utility may conflict and that prompt engineering is a useful but
insufficient strategy. Additionally, we find that while individual synthetic
posts may appear realistic, collectively they lack diversity, topic
connectivity, and realistic user interaction patterns.
|
[
-0.12666229903697968,
-0.6891486048698425,
0.5928163528442383,
0.30332839488983154,
-0.4083344638347626,
0.7281254529953003,
-0.27042242884635925,
-0.681714653968811,
0.4868259131908417,
0.5806536078453064,
-0.7715562582015991,
-0.4499844014644623,
-0.36884036660194397,
0.2953847348690033,
-0.7035201787948608,
1.0295538902282715,
-0.3844471275806427,
0.19504748284816742,
-0.5927444100379944,
0.07216981798410416,
-0.286215215921402,
-0.48034432530403137,
-0.5398617386817932,
0.01617005281150341,
0.1644265502691269,
0.5339274406433105,
0.2141331434249878,
0.2954117953777313,
0.5027597546577454,
0.17407068610191345,
0.21521109342575073,
0.4893864095211029,
-0.7281201481819153,
0.2150440514087677,
0.04145783185958862,
-0.14890067279338837,
0.043050698935985565,
0.18300731480121613,
0.6005271077156067,
0.2171536087989807,
0.12102700024843216,
0.3563399910926819,
0.30259326100349426,
0.3434518277645111,
-0.3187154233455658,
0.2183183878660202,
-0.8584036231040955,
-0.17599210143089294,
-0.11545321345329285,
-0.41991230845451355,
-0.08471101522445679,
-0.49743911623954773,
0.06719070672988892,
-0.5524206757545471,
0.31468212604522705,
0.41571006178855896,
1.0553275346755981,
0.10064756125211716,
-0.1709582805633545,
-0.6922136545181274,
-0.7336492538452148,
0.48249176144599915,
-0.7515731453895569,
0.1017768606543541,
0.2915869951248169,
0.38494354486465454,
-0.2796008884906769,
-0.8491302132606506,
-0.6028562188148499,
-0.6047145128250122,
0.007645555771887302,
0.1411036252975464,
-0.4102531671524048,
0.11565105617046356,
0.19254934787750244,
0.48767179250717163,
-0.6305288672447205,
0.177444726228714,
-0.5217722654342651,
-0.1382344365119934,
0.9350540637969971,
0.23844517767429352,
0.5403301119804382,
-0.20652399957180023,
-0.33433282375335693,
0.3402397036552429,
-1.0253151655197144,
0.06662611663341522,
1.146209478378296,
0.5153107047080994,
-0.25141197443008423,
1.0250455141067505,
-0.2841695547103882,
0.16518156230449677,
0.028591830283403397,
0.11318252235651016,
-0.06348888576030731,
-0.43682679533958435,
0.013414294458925724,
0.47890207171440125,
0.937889039516449,
0.37324047088623047,
0.4227997660636902,
-0.15496882796287537,
-0.397438645362854,
0.1542864739894867,
0.3247883915901184,
-0.9868770837783813,
-0.04875172674655914,
0.3841642439365387,
-0.42398181557655334,
-0.4873712658882141,
0.1793222278356552,
-0.3006843030452728,
-0.3455021381378174,
-0.3937254250049591,
0.39479103684425354,
-0.3825245201587677,
-0.11896330118179321,
0.25859513878822327,
-0.14068830013275146,
0.08983691036701202,
-0.03609933704137802,
-0.8180369138717651,
0.4000653326511383,
0.720624566078186,
0.8273162841796875,
-0.1649354100227356,
0.23793938755989075,
-0.2936647832393646,
-0.06013523414731026,
-0.36910754442214966,
0.6962440013885498,
-0.489046186208725,
-0.1519078016281128,
0.34069615602493286,
0.21687078475952148,
-0.00497380830347538,
-0.5598909258842468,
0.4718649387359619,
-0.6519824862480164,
0.005180212669074535,
-0.06733512133359909,
-1.003231406211853,
-0.16331838071346283,
0.3037078082561493,
-0.561115562915802,
0.6680756211280823,
0.13847312331199646,
-0.40240222215652466,
0.46850576996803284,
-0.7218471169471741,
-0.38248157501220703,
0.5702627897262573,
0.051441412419080734,
-0.27503111958503723,
0.016353247687220573,
0.06323502957820892,
0.442892849445343,
-0.2268993854522705,
0.23411348462104797,
-0.29264914989471436,
-0.499667763710022,
0.6643266081809998,
-0.5220582485198975,
0.5030021667480469,
0.26111724972724915,
-0.01978844217956066,
0.14434173703193665,
-0.4379774332046509,
-0.36266252398490906,
0.3152223229408264,
-0.18546484410762787,
-0.36983734369277954,
0.10893729329109192,
0.21957848966121674,
-0.1532420665025711,
0.19089919328689575,
-1.0032800436019897,
-0.18700863420963287,
-0.34541359543800354,
0.632885217666626,
0.6699066758155823,
0.2500964105129242,
0.3308151066303253,
-0.2191532552242279,
1.0381710529327393,
-0.4329204261302948,
0.10318565368652344,
-0.15360207855701447,
-0.512984573841095,
-0.30947360396385193,
-0.3551301956176758,
0.23909133672714233,
0.21471241116523743,
-0.777332603931427,
0.15558549761772156,
-0.34936147928237915,
-0.29729780554771423,
-0.6713960766792297,
0.22841641306877136,
0.30331048369407654,
0.3183305859565735,
-0.20018143951892853,
-0.01826516166329384,
-0.6897011995315552,
-0.9313803315162659,
-0.5402137637138367,
0.19979198276996613,
0.043665703386068344,
0.11435361206531525,
0.4883310794830322,
0.07385491579771042,
0.8828536868095398,
-0.20833763480186462,
-0.24824340641498566,
-0.4877811372280121,
-0.21199993789196014,
0.41197702288627625,
0.29896557331085205,
0.7476807832717896,
-0.854295551776886,
-1.0944960117340088,
-0.06998087465763092,
-0.6638050079345703,
-0.004272394347935915,
-0.14714674651622772,
0.1769942045211792,
0.12121972441673279,
0.5275397896766663,
-0.9415864944458008,
0.21484729647636414,
0.7016164064407349,
-0.0696677565574646,
0.6286922693252563,
0.14235499501228333,
0.2975280284881592,
-1.1283434629440308,
-0.37939485907554626,
0.5938699245452881,
-0.5228124260902405,
-0.4247116446495056,
-0.14483167231082916,
-0.10999864339828491,
-0.38356366753578186,
-0.6175922751426697,
0.5629708170890808,
-0.15777626633644104,
0.18032203614711761,
-0.29830726981163025,
-0.1043289378285408,
-0.15118013322353363,
0.11045540869235992,
-0.3496466279029846,
0.9935550093650818,
0.4288380742073059,
-0.5245984196662903,
0.6686025857925415,
0.0604318343102932,
-0.8094926476478577,
0.3955550193786621,
-0.7939236760139465,
-0.009780365973711014,
-0.39107152819633484,
0.331123024225235,
-1.3984321355819702,
-0.7854089736938477,
0.697390615940094,
-0.670871376991272,
0.13553136587142944,
-0.47418519854545593,
-1.00239098072052,
-0.3284589350223541,
-0.33992040157318115,
0.39551910758018494,
0.5533457398414612,
-0.7374090552330017,
0.2156842201948166,
0.5637653470039368,
-0.037805989384651184,
-0.04537900164723396,
-0.41507768630981445,
0.2332223355770111,
-0.7399132251739502,
-0.5763119459152222,
0.6985559463500977,
0.10034572333097458,
-0.40381577610969543,
0.36551615595817566,
-0.08689877390861511,
0.21607020497322083,
-0.4414491355419159,
0.21671777963638306,
0.2529013454914093,
-0.02186700701713562,
0.03650093078613281,
0.04566122964024544,
0.07570549845695496,
0.33597782254219055,
-0.46426185965538025,
0.6725858449935913,
0.08160750567913055,
-0.24577899277210236,
-0.849332332611084,
0.1379685252904892,
0.41306889057159424,
0.11829540133476257,
0.4893331527709961,
0.44565632939338684,
-0.43690577149391174,
-0.45458075404167175,
-0.35850244760513306,
-0.24189969897270203,
-0.5414220094680786,
0.1591825932264328,
-0.042333174496889114,
-0.940600574016571,
0.4287568926811218,
0.25390392541885376,
0.10132336616516113,
0.2382449507713318,
0.49709299206733704,
-0.6087122559547424,
1.1527373790740967,
0.37340012192726135,
0.28459200263023376,
0.5797959566116333,
-0.19171956181526184,
0.35189566016197205,
-0.4730106294155121,
-0.21017175912857056,
-0.13013432919979095,
-0.296611487865448,
-0.9639713168144226,
0.06806342303752899,
0.5026839375495911,
-0.6201690435409546,
-0.04364680498838425,
0.6904029250144958,
-0.4366934299468994,
0.6650928258895874,
0.639266848564148,
0.395553857088089,
0.24534448981285095,
0.4628536105155945,
0.4856608808040619,
-0.2983885109424591,
-0.6990813612937927,
-0.5980671644210815,
1.0449856519699097,
0.3097679018974304,
0.8639988899230957,
-0.18730194866657257,
0.278757244348526,
0.6341492533683777,
0.36714887619018555,
-1.028583288192749,
0.4795019030570984,
-0.33257654309272766,
-0.721133828163147,
0.10700466483831406,
-0.21516384184360504,
-0.8121039867401123,
-0.054771214723587036,
-0.14558002352714539,
-0.5049260854721069,
-0.32221102714538574,
0.2267671674489975,
-0.42165178060531616,
0.40680915117263794,
-0.597378671169281,
0.5165045857429504,
-0.22640472650527954,
-0.4123196601867676,
-0.25231313705444336,
-0.25533875823020935,
0.6294703483581543,
-0.090854711830616,
0.03952505812048912,
-0.4237096607685089,
0.27853482961654663,
0.5435543060302734,
-0.5081847310066223,
1.0976016521453857,
0.200638547539711,
0.052637383341789246,
0.6213147044181824,
0.1913372427225113,
0.5516486167907715,
0.23209533095359802,
0.39501771330833435,
-0.07753480970859528,
-0.009357822127640247,
-0.19400136172771454,
-0.3642544150352478,
0.7303776741027832,
-0.27674558758735657,
-0.5748938918113708,
-0.22825638949871063,
-0.7560001611709595,
-0.1892389953136444,
0.04808078333735466,
0.46629443764686584,
0.3228345513343811,
-0.224843367934227,
0.5019040107727051,
0.4383549392223358,
-0.2173607051372528,
0.4621278643608093,
0.053846705704927444,
-0.08385608345270157,
-0.5534824132919312,
1.0433963537216187,
-0.016533834859728813,
0.36349374055862427,
0.05386892333626747,
0.18966446816921234,
-0.7369345426559448,
-0.46363431215286255,
-0.35893839597702026,
0.4271129071712494,
-0.5439785718917847,
-0.19182713329792023,
-0.4145785868167877,
-0.3663673996925354,
-0.3489387333393097,
-0.1821461170911789,
-0.4599420428276062,
-0.2524324357509613,
-0.2444746047258377,
-0.11720980703830719,
0.6220489144325256,
0.6945827007293701,
0.09093831479549408,
0.4184630513191223,
-0.8075137138366699,
0.26187849044799805,
-0.04877832531929016,
0.1640482395887375,
-0.4960067868232727,
-0.5927892923355103,
-0.3011939227581024,
0.37569597363471985,
-0.06092565134167671,
-0.451516717672348,
0.5131520628929138,
-0.2884197533130646,
0.5070998072624207,
0.2589477598667145,
0.008262231014668941,
0.43764376640319824,
-0.07641370594501495,
0.5903522372245789,
0.06362861394882202,
-0.6348928809165955,
0.24879229068756104,
-0.7535666823387146,
-0.34512248635292053,
0.3100932836532593,
0.6849488019943237,
-0.4114764928817749,
-0.39650848507881165,
-0.5771165490150452,
-0.6800786852836609,
0.43200650811195374,
0.6258904337882996,
0.9675791263580322,
0.024488013237714767,
0.4098520278930664,
0.17006371915340424,
0.46924418210983276,
-0.7890792489051819,
0.2067284733057022,
0.24992913007736206,
-0.26775044202804565,
0.366493821144104,
-0.3300143778324127,
-0.04749022424221039,
-0.1965600848197937,
0.7064094543457031,
0.06751658767461777,
-0.16191057860851288,
-0.03482137620449066,
0.060352012515068054,
-0.05115976557135582,
-0.3655167520046234,
0.25165197253227234,
0.5334653854370117,
-0.2044578641653061,
-0.37281930446624756,
-0.1427202969789505,
-0.388591468334198,
0.012892352417111397,
-0.06884171813726425,
-0.5019324421882629,
0.22315500676631927,
0.15070576965808868,
0.6208963990211487,
0.08917809277772903,
-0.9829227328300476,
0.46544376015663147,
0.09412641078233719,
-0.3238944411277771,
-0.8472775220870972,
-0.12648408114910126,
-0.0012036359403282404,
0.2405892312526703,
0.08520185947418213,
-0.14034277200698853,
-0.012690871022641659,
-0.6095563173294067,
0.10562129318714142,
0.6931535005569458,
-0.5911051630973816,
-0.41668614745140076,
0.986386239528656,
0.09250463545322418,
-0.2749822735786438,
0.6641004085540771,
-0.20263107120990753,
-0.2558673024177551,
0.8325905799865723,
0.6018180251121521,
0.9979029297828674,
0.028975261375308037,
0.45415350794792175,
0.3239976763725281,
0.2631199061870575,
-0.04233327880501747,
0.14048834145069122,
0.19654031097888947,
-1.0402966737747192,
-0.39868390560150146,
-0.5029745101928711,
-0.4264604449272156,
0.28945812582969666,
-0.24168698489665985,
0.6079189777374268,
-0.3988853991031647,
-0.14515459537506104,
0.07303086668252945,
-0.44332724809646606,
-0.46919989585876465,
-0.08067736029624939,
0.06491722911596298,
0.5259736776351929,
-0.704689621925354,
0.4394431710243225,
0.6019068956375122,
-0.6527943015098572,
-0.5083118677139282,
0.0468517504632473,
0.14498461782932281,
-0.6442939043045044,
0.4046453833580017,
0.23726926743984222,
-0.1896548867225647,
0.0846661627292633,
-1.0001769065856934,
-0.6374204158782959,
0.9189413189888,
0.47680744528770447,
-0.3369542062282562,
-0.09466507285833359,
0.5951722860336304,
0.4732722342014313,
-0.7678899168968201,
-0.4216751456260681,
0.29871201515197754,
0.08166708052158356,
0.3278122842311859,
-0.6080932021141052,
0.049345456063747406,
0.022746551781892776,
-0.07853492349386215,
-0.18045316636562347,
-0.5485854744911194,
0.7085537910461426,
0.07857786118984222,
-0.5632020831108093,
0.17665283381938934,
0.26764729619026184,
0.5514349341392517,
0.2667931318283081,
0.34691065549850464,
0.21744269132614136,
0.1483137011528015,
0.07204604893922806,
1.249897837638855,
-0.333636999130249,
0.31300532817840576,
0.7831997275352478,
-0.1936340630054474,
0.2491140216588974,
0.5254148840904236,
-0.023463327437639236,
0.27384111285209656,
1.0806164741516113,
-0.28768888115882874,
0.460673987865448,
0.31813353300094604,
-0.4477252662181854,
-0.21301689743995667,
-0.7025339603424072,
0.09182578325271606,
0.5147680640220642,
0.5244808793067932,
-0.5195296406745911,
-0.23700881004333496,
0.017046624794602394,
0.2580793499946594,
0.2131282538175583,
-0.05912943184375763,
0.5122661590576172,
0.26470860838890076,
-0.41552677750587463,
0.26263439655303955,
-0.13274535536766052,
0.5944007039070129,
-0.6676369309425354,
-0.10751298069953918,
-0.1675669252872467,
0.10643170028924942,
-0.23418359458446503,
-0.8574365973472595,
0.45489972829818726,
0.06654870510101318,
0.30592820048332214,
-0.3886769413948059,
0.8367051482200623,
-0.54695063829422,
-0.6016499400138855,
0.05586874485015869,
0.1868125945329666,
0.11243759095668793,
-0.5244326591491699,
-0.46622806787490845,
0.039075758308172226,
-0.20179295539855957,
-0.10348815470933914,
0.10217652469873428,
0.13446754217147827,
-0.021564731374382973,
0.7193359732627869,
1.0056772232055664,
0.13212476670742035,
-0.1101752445101738,
0.05667102709412575,
0.9256079792976379,
-0.250743567943573,
-0.5833434462547302,
-1.0341191291809082,
0.44888240098953247,
-0.2649300992488861,
-0.11017488688230515,
1.0263779163360596,
0.7764891386032104,
1.0970925092697144,
-0.29338905215263367,
1.0508133172988892,
-0.02292327955365181,
0.2516782283782959,
-0.8277034163475037,
0.7496082782745361,
-0.7791470289230347,
0.4003250300884247,
-0.0897364467382431,
-1.0674268007278442,
-0.18727804720401764,
-0.12473529577255249,
0.04027043655514717,
-0.2970174252986908,
0.4127829968929291,
1.0456920862197876,
-0.4091154932975769,
0.05821135267615318,
0.11975093185901642,
-0.19362975656986237,
0.4446719288825989,
0.1233721673488617,
1.342375636100769,
-0.31607258319854736,
0.6151760220527649,
-0.37868696451187134,
0.18990938365459442,
-0.03910035640001297,
-0.5260898470878601,
-1.0022013187408447,
-0.5670309662818909,
-0.3301984667778015,
-0.7005100250244141,
-0.04163578152656555,
1.291357398033142,
0.6731414794921875,
-0.7168681025505066,
-0.37520018219947815,
-0.2608622908592224,
-0.1262321025133133,
0.035891637206077576,
-0.30352315306663513,
0.11709311604499817,
-0.3118639588356018,
-1.1854007244110107,
0.5387032628059387,
0.2967526912689209,
0.3686971068382263,
-0.3357790410518646,
0.11981187760829926,
0.23303981125354767,
0.16321447491645813,
0.7072450518608093,
0.2632535994052887,
-0.6097643375396729,
-0.1805776059627533,
0.1442246288061142,
0.01491495966911316,
-0.055721305310726166,
1.0181621313095093,
-0.19621829688549042,
0.3759191036224365,
0.6407918334007263,
0.6326526403427124,
0.6726149320602417,
0.3654654920101166,
0.6080388426780701,
-0.7802029848098755,
0.2262684553861618,
0.39558789134025574,
0.38590627908706665,
0.3396374583244324,
-0.528491735458374,
0.43358972668647766,
0.38543495535850525,
-0.31155452132225037,
-0.8373977541923523,
0.2521880567073822,
-0.7232058048248291,
-0.2551021873950958,
1.3813594579696655,
0.14594563841819763,
-0.12229776382446289,
-0.08534304052591324,
-0.06236448511481285,
-0.09699833393096924,
-0.3527979254722595,
1.0205059051513672,
0.5998625755310059,
-0.14227896928787231,
-0.08040419220924377,
-0.9332086443901062,
0.758756160736084,
-0.10945003479719162,
-0.7019205689430237,
-0.22714708745479584,
0.4364018142223358,
0.5609944462776184,
-0.251617968082428,
0.6005343198776245,
-0.24479874968528748,
-0.099845752120018,
-0.029836466535925865,
-0.15127213299274445,
-0.04870128631591797,
-0.2403782159090042,
0.08212514221668243,
-0.1700187772512436,
-0.4081821143627167,
-0.6074932813644409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15185v1
|
Investigating the Performance of Language Models for Completing Code in Functional Programming Languages: a Haskell Case Study
| 2024-03-22T13:13:13 | 2024-03-22T13:13:13 |
Tim van Dam, Frank van der Heijden, Philippe de Bekker, Berend Nieuwschepen, Marc Otten, Maliheh Izadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language model-based code completion models have quickly grown in use,
helping thousands of developers write code in many different programming
languages. However, research on code completion models typically focuses on
imperative languages such as Python and JavaScript, which results in a lack of
representation for functional programming languages. Consequently, these models
often perform poorly on functional languages such as Haskell. To investigate
whether this can be alleviated, we evaluate the performance of two language
models for code, CodeGPT and UniXcoder, on the functional programming language
Haskell. We fine-tune and evaluate the models on Haskell functions sourced from
a publicly accessible Haskell dataset on HuggingFace. Additionally, we manually
evaluate the models using our novel translated HumanEval dataset. Our automatic
evaluation shows that knowledge of imperative programming languages in the
pre-training of LLMs may not transfer well to functional languages, but that
code completion on functional languages is feasible. Consequently, this shows
the need for more high-quality Haskell datasets. A manual evaluation on
HumanEval-Haskell indicates CodeGPT frequently generates empty predictions and
extra comments, while UniXcoder more often produces incomplete or incorrect
predictions. Finally, we release HumanEval-Haskell, along with the fine-tuned
models and all code required to reproduce our experiments on GitHub
(https://github.com/AISE-TUDelft/HaskellCCEval).
|
[
-0.11421837657690048,
-0.40868884325027466,
0.6432085633277893,
-0.0469479039311409,
-0.06142717972397804,
0.19216808676719666,
-0.4479650557041168,
-0.6315906643867493,
-0.114937923848629,
0.8787062168121338,
-0.2750255763530731,
-0.4609321355819702,
-0.6081277132034302,
0.19433167576789856,
-0.39094337821006775,
1.0615622997283936,
-0.04362101852893829,
0.2415078729391098,
-0.6064296364784241,
-0.2735762298107147,
-0.1574784517288208,
-0.6488528847694397,
-0.0756712406873703,
-0.4450516104698181,
0.1792132407426834,
0.2875584363937378,
0.6707761883735657,
0.7144371867179871,
0.9445749521255493,
0.238658607006073,
0.058293577283620834,
-0.2453060746192932,
-0.6230988502502441,
-0.05203120410442352,
0.15347270667552948,
-0.40397313237190247,
-0.3981800675392151,
-0.05787120759487152,
0.5458617806434631,
0.8384866118431091,
-0.21170561015605927,
0.3105350732803345,
0.05174419656395912,
0.5416750311851501,
-0.49309077858924866,
0.3529418110847473,
-0.38474854826927185,
0.05374570190906525,
-0.1595461666584015,
-0.10982447862625122,
-0.2850930690765381,
-0.659172773361206,
-0.16921426355838776,
-0.30445727705955505,
-0.14179378747940063,
-0.17864269018173218,
0.427517294883728,
0.41310620307922363,
-0.41957101225852966,
-0.27285367250442505,
-0.6859793663024902,
0.7077827453613281,
-1.0371812582015991,
0.35482850670814514,
0.6738764047622681,
0.12113594263792038,
-0.026330243796110153,
-0.7033687233924866,
-0.3298701047897339,
-0.6481616497039795,
-0.18945904076099396,
-0.06180771812796593,
-0.07750298082828522,
0.20670028030872345,
0.8295971155166626,
0.5535710453987122,
-0.7391347885131836,
-0.12229012697935104,
-0.5557803511619568,
-0.1495400220155716,
0.4886890947818756,
0.05968214571475983,
0.2358330935239792,
-0.2199677973985672,
-0.2406957745552063,
0.24894605576992035,
-0.827631413936615,
0.45548608899116516,
0.24964001774787903,
0.11538766324520111,
-0.24915359914302826,
0.7621232271194458,
-0.34911754727363586,
0.8864009976387024,
-0.5734643340110779,
0.017922665923833847,
0.3028692603111267,
-0.32284530997276306,
-0.19844383001327515,
-0.6080365777015686,
0.5274256467819214,
0.2388518750667572,
0.437195748090744,
-0.303480863571167,
-0.45016488432884216,
0.21589410305023193,
0.4035473167896271,
-0.7920656204223633,
-0.28978341817855835,
0.19026413559913635,
-0.43765321373939514,
-0.37049269676208496,
-0.3415621519088745,
-0.11966255307197571,
-0.3267735540866852,
-0.5201423168182373,
0.20254315435886383,
-0.5226269960403442,
-0.23758237063884735,
0.275245726108551,
0.14462246000766754,
0.2494327425956726,
0.29182514548301697,
-0.566135585308075,
0.5344824194908142,
0.755678653717041,
0.4635917842388153,
0.0006686034030281007,
-0.2251458466053009,
-0.7697322368621826,
-0.3679298460483551,
-0.10740234702825546,
0.5006636381149292,
-0.8604984283447266,
-0.23189102113246918,
-0.017075005918741226,
-0.1552363485097885,
0.161390021443367,
-0.4943763017654419,
0.4389437735080719,
-0.41896116733551025,
-0.2060038298368454,
-0.41168850660324097,
-0.7178824543952942,
-0.3505496680736542,
0.18568560481071472,
-0.4519381523132324,
0.9804031848907471,
0.4001527726650238,
-0.7604219317436218,
0.24126289784908295,
-0.517741858959198,
-0.6318671703338623,
0.23641858994960785,
-0.39955538511276245,
-0.2533506453037262,
0.18304294347763062,
-0.23536032438278198,
0.5573124885559082,
-0.519101619720459,
0.3877732455730438,
-0.49296870827674866,
-0.5990513563156128,
0.46855413913726807,
0.08347481489181519,
0.7167415618896484,
0.2865937650203705,
-0.3005202114582062,
0.09882283955812454,
-0.8174678087234497,
0.0774005725979805,
-0.23339450359344482,
-0.5199377536773682,
-0.020906100049614906,
0.17927102744579315,
0.26093101501464844,
0.1963733732700348,
0.15633270144462585,
-0.4533204734325409,
0.4182690978050232,
-0.1327907294034958,
0.6748852729797363,
0.3657437860965729,
-0.4735166132450104,
0.3825162351131439,
-0.5454606413841248,
0.6827374696731567,
-0.2791444659233093,
0.1534726619720459,
-0.11663755774497986,
-0.4851081967353821,
-0.5667189359664917,
-0.31732410192489624,
0.39124390482902527,
0.4844058156013489,
-0.4846106767654419,
0.03461303189396858,
-0.1676420122385025,
-0.25123342871665955,
-0.30183956027030945,
0.11161854863166809,
0.5153641700744629,
0.6551585793495178,
0.20562328398227692,
-0.6860728859901428,
-0.4667987823486328,
-0.9558528661727905,
-0.1209399551153183,
-0.21036396920681,
0.05967071279883385,
0.43777790665626526,
0.5493719577789307,
-0.5612295866012573,
0.7962803244590759,
-0.22143444418907166,
0.3502810001373291,
-0.21071487665176392,
0.05111228674650192,
0.2829037606716156,
0.50218266248703,
0.5258316397666931,
-0.5517086982727051,
-0.19884267449378967,
0.09714511781930923,
-0.7212002277374268,
0.1017901599407196,
0.40403884649276733,
0.17517156898975372,
0.2436412125825882,
0.12031327188014984,
-0.36889198422431946,
0.35225287079811096,
0.597835898399353,
0.06377001851797104,
0.7300698757171631,
-0.11847560107707977,
0.5063185691833496,
-0.5663673877716064,
0.5285415053367615,
-0.3080081641674042,
-0.5904615521430969,
-0.6083316206932068,
0.29171550273895264,
0.25236648321151733,
-0.5019779205322266,
-0.10427120327949524,
0.298881471157074,
-0.3335427939891815,
-0.302768737077713,
-0.11149954050779343,
-0.351921021938324,
-0.2993209958076477,
0.5879278779029846,
0.13398107886314392,
0.8917941451072693,
0.6821926832199097,
-0.2606357932090759,
-0.09169338643550873,
-0.04589497298002243,
-0.6046227812767029,
-0.18513575196266174,
-0.666347861289978,
0.2754395008087158,
0.21770870685577393,
-0.11631865054368973,
-1.1053588390350342,
-0.589820384979248,
0.1999766230583191,
-0.3108593225479126,
0.2613567113876343,
-0.5219225287437439,
-0.41655829548835754,
-0.4412805736064911,
-0.11257798224687576,
0.5411320328712463,
0.8113008737564087,
-0.0826530009508133,
0.2758638560771942,
0.33798930048942566,
-0.32527175545692444,
-0.643355131149292,
-0.674035370349884,
-0.024064281955361366,
0.04124550148844719,
-0.6680435538291931,
-0.06604710966348648,
-0.2096957117319107,
0.007737516425549984,
0.05376080051064491,
-0.07606451958417892,
-0.14714284241199493,
0.36542409658432007,
0.2621017098426819,
0.15053869783878326,
-0.25691142678260803,
-0.1962335705757141,
-0.22435002028942108,
-0.06929900497198105,
0.02501051127910614,
-0.22111976146697998,
0.39561548829078674,
-0.39607882499694824,
-0.486403226852417,
-0.23831668496131897,
0.34688079357147217,
0.6405834555625916,
-0.4780585467815399,
0.3300570547580719,
0.29621830582618713,
-0.44408953189849854,
0.09336873888969421,
-0.7807738184928894,
-0.15014664828777313,
-0.36562779545783997,
0.16942374408245087,
-0.18336890637874603,
-1.1510730981826782,
0.662414014339447,
0.10686057060956955,
-0.13034357130527496,
-0.13149550557136536,
0.4037773311138153,
-0.14570683240890503,
0.7834338545799255,
0.8414005637168884,
-0.15777139365673065,
0.38442450761795044,
-0.4008028209209442,
0.08609180152416229,
-0.4211798906326294,
0.16821874678134918,
-0.5376152992248535,
0.11619025468826294,
-0.5488816499710083,
-0.5435436367988586,
0.2369418740272522,
0.16771171987056732,
-0.16147515177726746,
0.6537923812866211,
-0.3090957999229431,
0.5343030095100403,
0.46772053837776184,
0.04273140802979469,
0.3581675887107849,
0.26422831416130066,
-0.07630738615989685,
0.0928625762462616,
-0.617993175983429,
-0.5626601576805115,
1.2793784141540527,
0.22589942812919617,
0.7171462178230286,
0.007233834825456142,
0.8194800019264221,
0.4940950572490692,
0.38959836959838867,
-0.5994950532913208,
0.34378817677497864,
-0.20518316328525543,
-0.20373210310935974,
0.0964445248246193,
-0.6197784543037415,
-0.5065966844558716,
-0.18513579666614532,
0.11788272112607956,
-0.8522343635559082,
-0.04606546089053154,
0.2597692310810089,
-0.41423192620277405,
-0.12915851175785065,
-0.4561917185783386,
1.0237363576889038,
-0.04535558074712753,
-0.5258563160896301,
-0.46984848380088806,
-0.6474363803863525,
0.5705857276916504,
0.009320239536464214,
0.2201940268278122,
-0.05097273737192154,
0.3177570104598999,
0.46338367462158203,
-0.47658514976501465,
0.6899758577346802,
0.0005829026340506971,
-0.09605412185192108,
0.14783141016960144,
0.26327237486839294,
0.5470744371414185,
0.004552890546619892,
-0.4309267997741699,
0.24969656765460968,
0.2300921082496643,
-0.482303649187088,
-0.42188188433647156,
0.4134072959423065,
-0.6232254505157471,
-0.5450733304023743,
-0.10525357723236084,
-0.42310890555381775,
-0.1471220850944519,
0.23748749494552612,
0.25316333770751953,
0.9939271807670593,
-0.053456202149391174,
0.09078647941350937,
0.4501340389251709,
0.04821274057030678,
0.158272847533226,
0.41266950964927673,
-0.427574098110199,
-0.3466559946537018,
0.8018068671226501,
0.13163432478904724,
0.32868993282318115,
0.102558434009552,
-0.20437385141849518,
-0.1315232366323471,
-0.8361837863922119,
-0.5158721804618835,
0.2845146059989929,
-0.6362690925598145,
-0.3625432252883911,
-0.5781662464141846,
-0.3333616554737091,
-0.30015361309051514,
-0.16998781263828278,
-0.22321046888828278,
-0.6388075351715088,
0.08275236189365387,
0.15994642674922943,
0.3391517996788025,
0.9549826383590698,
0.03178221732378006,
0.0995362401008606,
-0.8863591551780701,
0.0831485465168953,
-0.2152056246995926,
0.4438936710357666,
-0.30844664573669434,
-0.3204474151134491,
-0.5042891502380371,
0.10073673725128174,
-0.09116465598344803,
-0.6555838584899902,
0.10981473326683044,
-0.1398412585258484,
0.37078186869621277,
0.09055270999670029,
-0.00024368532467633486,
0.25184354186058044,
-0.29262423515319824,
0.5197219848632812,
0.090057373046875,
-0.9139105081558228,
0.40798327326774597,
-0.6760547161102295,
0.29513511061668396,
0.658530592918396,
0.3157302737236023,
-0.6009859442710876,
-0.6316957473754883,
-0.4432957172393799,
-0.4567849338054657,
0.8621688485145569,
0.5010815262794495,
-0.14182738959789276,
0.07136327773332596,
0.2906678020954132,
0.22190384566783905,
0.43226730823516846,
-0.7358573079109192,
-0.054238755255937576,
0.14809834957122803,
-0.06748990714550018,
-0.06631600856781006,
-0.36949461698532104,
-0.17100536823272705,
-0.17887137830257416,
0.3419681191444397,
-0.06005198508501053,
0.32006627321243286,
-0.01866179145872593,
-0.42334190011024475,
-0.0810650885105133,
0.19487643241882324,
0.6566541194915771,
0.8895308971405029,
-0.34070438146591187,
-0.17209771275520325,
-0.22810718417167664,
-0.2217300981283188,
0.0332401767373085,
0.3083736300468445,
-0.1669674813747406,
-0.4455651044845581,
0.6286442875862122,
0.632265031337738,
0.24835500121116638,
-0.8307660222053528,
0.5783846974372864,
-0.13801783323287964,
0.11947273463010788,
-0.20548264682292938,
0.39232149720191956,
-0.029399650171399117,
0.11486072093248367,
0.09015603363513947,
0.5915500521659851,
0.6044745445251465,
-0.46546587347984314,
0.35446521639823914,
0.2257927656173706,
-0.27420878410339355,
-0.40461671352386475,
0.57588791847229,
0.18122230470180511,
-0.29101771116256714,
0.7475125193595886,
-0.227229505777359,
-0.6866803169250488,
0.8443963527679443,
0.3767326772212982,
0.6528630256652832,
0.11407595127820969,
0.07314498722553253,
0.3964962065219879,
0.15356384217739105,
-0.05199611932039261,
0.6099638938903809,
-0.5998659729957581,
-0.442945271730423,
-0.7356008291244507,
-0.851638913154602,
-0.3800191283226013,
-0.11622988432645798,
-0.6693160533905029,
0.20219889283180237,
-0.38722530007362366,
-0.282106876373291,
-0.32676932215690613,
0.06249164417386055,
-0.7806576490402222,
-0.14210742712020874,
0.2486872524023056,
0.9197534322738647,
-0.6718105673789978,
1.044055700302124,
0.7072832584381104,
-0.5207369327545166,
-0.8221718072891235,
-0.15014101564884186,
-0.11863863468170166,
-0.5113481879234314,
0.5579644441604614,
0.2717594802379608,
-0.3301326036453247,
0.08307735621929169,
-0.341137170791626,
-0.8197279572486877,
0.7018764019012451,
0.6183550357818604,
-0.5750436186790466,
0.22153915464878082,
0.3538880944252014,
0.5086860656738281,
-0.30715906620025635,
0.39609065651893616,
0.5272650718688965,
0.32301920652389526,
-0.1639414131641388,
-1.064454436302185,
-0.041626982390880585,
-0.4054967164993286,
0.12179499119520187,
0.20547989010810852,
-0.46383026242256165,
0.6405075788497925,
-0.421147882938385,
-0.0808112695813179,
0.39690861105918884,
0.2825920581817627,
0.037651076912879944,
0.10628604143857956,
0.19341446459293365,
0.503387451171875,
0.943217396736145,
0.01853329688310623,
1.3095355033874512,
-0.46604230999946594,
0.6250584721565247,
0.9165338277816772,
-0.5459303259849548,
0.8479303121566772,
0.12909173965454102,
-0.4272933006286621,
0.047491345554590225,
0.6021026372909546,
0.20940172672271729,
0.4318211078643799,
0.3689802587032318,
-0.20163625478744507,
-0.4931038022041321,
0.12744149565696716,
-0.5171425342559814,
0.32864028215408325,
0.08138556778430939,
-0.06409866362810135,
-0.03135690465569496,
0.21619713306427002,
-0.15282806754112244,
0.07660601288080215,
0.049041997641325,
0.5777103304862976,
0.08688624948263168,
-0.7926645278930664,
0.9472543001174927,
-0.07465509325265884,
0.38554221391677856,
-0.5592837929725647,
0.0057487874291837215,
-0.6403579711914062,
0.06661427021026611,
-0.15710195899009705,
-0.674313485622406,
0.5277522206306458,
0.20210491120815277,
-0.3077854514122009,
-0.09946207702159882,
0.5783478617668152,
-0.4233972430229187,
-0.4983576536178589,
0.5522134900093079,
0.2913403809070587,
0.3426183760166168,
0.23844298720359802,
-0.635784387588501,
0.30487462878227234,
0.13094457983970642,
-0.1153823733329773,
0.19407804310321808,
0.058349721133708954,
0.22422900795936584,
0.8711130619049072,
0.49764689803123474,
-0.05022013559937477,
-0.10343440622091293,
-0.020661676302552223,
0.9843898415565491,
-0.6223960518836975,
-0.06125825271010399,
-0.6459975242614746,
0.6181488633155823,
0.1714315265417099,
-0.04541678726673126,
0.38501405715942383,
0.8181840181350708,
0.9133726954460144,
-0.3221195638179779,
0.8628545999526978,
-0.31581446528434753,
0.3680106997489929,
-0.6642388701438904,
0.7955908179283142,
-0.8141194581985474,
0.28679129481315613,
-0.31307700276374817,
-0.7486578822135925,
-0.39147433638572693,
0.5683084726333618,
-0.44784000515937805,
-0.005988997872918844,
0.5230108499526978,
1.1331099271774292,
-0.48445823788642883,
0.014963272958993912,
0.5405473709106445,
0.23740854859352112,
0.1261359453201294,
0.40835273265838623,
1.130825161933899,
-0.3361225128173828,
0.10386770963668823,
-0.21869994699954987,
-0.3170006275177002,
-0.3658809959888458,
-0.8489657640457153,
-0.5975719690322876,
-0.6425793766975403,
-0.36011943221092224,
-0.29334166646003723,
0.33767637610435486,
0.9059625267982483,
0.7673283815383911,
-0.8630174994468689,
-0.6217717528343201,
-0.007990137673914433,
0.18668697774410248,
-0.006633544806391001,
-0.11626391112804413,
-0.06800039112567902,
-0.7337230443954468,
-0.4375128448009491,
0.3807271718978882,
0.40512892603874207,
-0.3276146352291107,
0.12067874521017075,
-0.20020048320293427,
-0.045864056795835495,
-0.21626901626586914,
0.5048769116401672,
0.45248207449913025,
-0.6676543354988098,
-0.23818358778953552,
0.09879603236913681,
-0.4468240439891815,
0.26832684874534607,
1.2348917722702026,
-0.633443295955658,
0.2496947944164276,
0.5154951810836792,
0.768049418926239,
0.514471709728241,
-0.03889838233590126,
0.7616569995880127,
-0.255634605884552,
0.02276425063610077,
0.24271155893802643,
0.6323011517524719,
0.34899675846099854,
-0.3375014662742615,
0.7592275738716125,
0.0800294503569603,
-0.8331173062324524,
-0.9419183731079102,
0.24745775759220123,
-1.0615874528884888,
-0.021559622138738632,
1.0246020555496216,
-0.27033573389053345,
-0.16721764206886292,
0.004786123987287283,
-0.14001993834972382,
0.035277336835861206,
-0.23411838710308075,
0.40448543429374695,
0.822572648525238,
-0.23154594004154205,
0.028982989490032196,
-0.6518136262893677,
0.6265372037887573,
0.3919423222541809,
-0.48831963539123535,
0.39733055233955383,
0.6713160872459412,
0.5305061936378479,
-0.1826694905757904,
0.9604333639144897,
0.02962832897901535,
0.6056560277938843,
-0.2957419157028198,
0.2711074650287628,
-0.04862150177359581,
-0.34664109349250793,
-0.4213239252567291,
-0.06603571027517319,
0.5310057401657104,
0.413260817527771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15137v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15137v1
|
CACA Agent: Capability Collaboration based AI Agent
| 2024-03-22T11:42:47 | 2024-03-22T11:42:47 |
Peng Xu, Haoran Wang, Chuang Wang, Xu Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
As AI Agents based on Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown potential in
practical applications across various fields, how to quickly deploy an AI agent
and how to conveniently expand the application scenario of AI agents has become
a challenge. Previous studies mainly focused on implementing all the reasoning
capabilities of AI agents within a single LLM, which often makes the model more
complex and also reduces the extensibility of AI agent functionality. In this
paper, we propose CACA Agent (Capability Collaboration based AI Agent), using
an open architecture inspired by service computing. CACA Agent integrates a set
of collaborative capabilities to implement AI Agents, not only reducing the
dependence on a single LLM, but also enhancing the extensibility of both the
planning abilities and the tools available to AI agents. Utilizing the proposed
system, we present a demo to illustrate the operation and the application
scenario extension of CACA Agent.
|
[
-0.5851989984512329,
-0.7560976147651672,
0.712715208530426,
0.39824849367141724,
0.11191647499799728,
0.17863407731056213,
-0.18299981951713562,
-0.7558229565620422,
0.7043137550354004,
0.8041777014732361,
-0.5582359433174133,
-0.3737178146839142,
-0.2777552902698517,
-0.21385787427425385,
-0.04206639528274536,
0.6444900035858154,
0.04807170480489731,
0.056669436395168304,
-0.5168513655662537,
-0.2795773148536682,
-0.5268023610115051,
-0.5890055298805237,
-0.8294426202774048,
-0.48713409900665283,
0.34110134840011597,
0.7220699191093445,
1.1563918590545654,
0.5294947028160095,
0.5868866443634033,
0.5051798224449158,
0.36460039019584656,
0.3053956925868988,
-0.058633435517549515,
0.23491330444812775,
-0.19731883704662323,
-0.7330029010772705,
-1.058435082435608,
-0.03339191526174545,
0.4645465314388275,
0.5235323309898376,
-0.230865016579628,
-0.1571250706911087,
-0.11878257989883423,
0.1322249323129654,
-0.6661229133605957,
0.5527077913284302,
-0.4861489236354828,
-0.3101249933242798,
0.15935295820236206,
-0.034509189426898956,
-0.2182183414697647,
-0.056292444467544556,
0.13332204520702362,
-0.8369241952896118,
-0.11023928225040436,
-0.17652592062950134,
0.35726049542427063,
0.5319689512252808,
0.08662205189466476,
-0.28552085161209106,
-0.8293439745903015,
0.6298463344573975,
-0.29604092240333557,
0.054335612803697586,
0.26394516229629517,
0.7450375556945801,
-0.15457530319690704,
-0.843966007232666,
-0.7950782775878906,
-0.5899764895439148,
0.3417224586009979,
-0.005972003564238548,
-0.03998767212033272,
0.05304364860057831,
-0.1612696796655655,
0.28587090969085693,
-0.2550329566001892,
0.2917520999908447,
-0.07620028406381607,
-0.05838855355978012,
0.6262515187263489,
0.31665292382240295,
0.48092976212501526,
0.7193377614021301,
-0.38327065110206604,
0.032740890979766846,
-0.3106636106967926,
0.2214316874742508,
-0.16934005916118622,
0.5252094864845276,
-0.40234386920928955,
0.632133424282074,
-0.22686605155467987,
0.044213153421878815,
-0.34376782178878784,
-0.18159125745296478,
0.16068629920482635,
-0.0038357118610292673,
-0.49159863591194153,
0.10414469987154007,
0.6269370913505554,
-0.15873983502388,
-0.36301031708717346,
-0.32914042472839355,
0.14320336282253265,
0.14968466758728027,
0.35595929622650146,
-0.31248611211776733,
0.27652937173843384,
0.21523748338222504,
-0.3091767132282257,
-0.11858311295509338,
0.03892049193382263,
-0.2909238338470459,
-0.3594953417778015,
-0.08016256988048553,
0.14254024624824524,
-0.33330607414245605,
-0.2577835023403168,
-0.10859287530183792,
0.15458111464977264,
0.46755924820899963,
0.6115197539329529,
-0.47871726751327515,
0.5173968076705933,
0.8834228515625,
0.9740377068519592,
-0.2859232723712921,
-0.619186282157898,
-0.8560003042221069,
0.30349108576774597,
-0.17433100938796997,
0.6262960433959961,
-0.4652045667171478,
-0.6291641592979431,
-0.048204205930233,
0.06147553026676178,
0.2718527019023895,
-0.086800217628479,
0.43826764822006226,
-0.8418926000595093,
-0.4017086625099182,
-0.07933402806520462,
-0.16421446204185486,
-0.15760742127895355,
0.4498960077762604,
-0.9279143810272217,
0.5799658298492432,
-0.017718728631734848,
-0.09084564447402954,
0.1329336017370224,
-1.090563178062439,
-0.28190866112709045,
0.612261176109314,
-0.4829584062099457,
-0.09461387991905212,
-0.49671679735183716,
0.06581754237413406,
0.17999990284442902,
-0.5685937404632568,
0.04651503637433052,
-0.46124717593193054,
-0.2554827332496643,
0.16050438582897186,
-0.09654460847377777,
0.8643305897712708,
0.3659608066082001,
-0.3882458209991455,
0.3639073371887207,
-0.47702986001968384,
0.18638862669467926,
-0.05556275695562363,
-0.2659495174884796,
0.015100223012268543,
-0.3036946654319763,
-0.05048385262489319,
-0.06736543029546738,
0.8192217946052551,
-0.4424006938934326,
0.5143759250640869,
-0.35952135920524597,
-0.06600382179021835,
0.4432286322116852,
-0.1473972201347351,
0.7703339457511902,
-0.6607053875923157,
0.8904545307159424,
-0.47357377409935,
0.33280542492866516,
0.20457971096038818,
-0.9058958292007446,
-0.5911005139350891,
-0.8748559355735779,
-0.3520676791667938,
0.4861469864845276,
-0.9943031072616577,
0.6688735485076904,
-0.2694178819656372,
-0.799892246723175,
-0.45911967754364014,
0.016329962760210037,
0.21376125514507294,
0.05176357552409172,
0.27009373903274536,
-0.45202720165252686,
-0.19176611304283142,
-0.8080781698226929,
0.3827477991580963,
-0.44491785764694214,
0.316741019487381,
0.30236172676086426,
0.17276997864246368,
-0.3454332947731018,
1.1457322835922241,
-0.3736559748649597,
-0.4787774980068207,
-0.6722792983055115,
-0.28853997588157654,
-0.006163477431982756,
0.3898340165615082,
0.6131128668785095,
-0.8263832330703735,
-0.42376089096069336,
0.16651639342308044,
-0.7656252384185791,
0.04639369994401932,
0.19751156866550446,
-0.1151704266667366,
0.4478479027748108,
0.341842383146286,
-0.7291527390480042,
0.7378103733062744,
0.5002329349517822,
-0.03851017355918884,
0.5350364446640015,
-0.5390735864639282,
0.11959987878799438,
-1.2213197946548462,
0.17211391031742096,
-0.46655306220054626,
0.003006943967193365,
-0.5790362358093262,
0.4932034909725189,
-0.35684195160865784,
-0.39417946338653564,
-0.4329597055912018,
0.5453464388847351,
-0.27369868755340576,
-0.4421996772289276,
-0.6069573760032654,
0.14532172679901123,
-0.13343483209609985,
0.504234254360199,
0.15841610729694366,
0.8230202794075012,
0.7137488126754761,
-0.6121052503585815,
0.6527266502380371,
0.44223490357398987,
0.019971808418631554,
0.3386913239955902,
-0.41614359617233276,
0.1912696361541748,
0.24174676835536957,
0.3727398216724396,
-0.49424657225608826,
-0.17626799643039703,
0.205156609416008,
-0.2548193037509918,
-0.35543209314346313,
0.21483959257602692,
-0.5595021843910217,
-0.06291275471448898,
-0.24232952296733856,
0.5076705813407898,
0.029834916815161705,
-0.8102994561195374,
0.9108116030693054,
0.5047041177749634,
-0.09675613045692444,
-0.5633177161216736,
-0.6757844686508179,
0.2877974510192871,
0.28324100375175476,
-0.8053983449935913,
0.42362111806869507,
-0.17535531520843506,
-0.482038289308548,
0.1344299018383026,
0.3911934196949005,
-0.30385521054267883,
0.06234414130449295,
0.783856987953186,
0.3386053144931793,
-0.05826111137866974,
0.14875352382659912,
-0.050860531628131866,
0.024906164035201073,
-0.2780340015888214,
0.11536289751529694,
0.707136869430542,
-0.5146041512489319,
-0.7502244114875793,
-0.658018946647644,
0.6434234976768494,
1.0878804922103882,
-0.700187623500824,
1.096958041191101,
0.12304840236902237,
-0.39355361461639404,
-0.41860783100128174,
-0.49170100688934326,
0.13544967770576477,
-0.5334960222244263,
0.12627290189266205,
-0.576918363571167,
-0.8271030783653259,
0.8169378042221069,
0.062127284705638885,
0.18557217717170715,
0.10035640746355057,
0.7784351706504822,
0.4490073323249817,
0.6922739148139954,
1.025863766670227,
-0.4303644299507141,
0.49896976351737976,
-0.49123817682266235,
0.23036012053489685,
-0.4707358479499817,
-0.5070573091506958,
-0.8558903932571411,
0.1704457402229309,
-0.4819404184818268,
-0.45272812247276306,
0.4470120668411255,
-0.2652006447315216,
-0.2619991898536682,
0.20245712995529175,
-0.3545668125152588,
0.17789357900619507,
0.5944661498069763,
0.10500911623239517,
0.4350649118423462,
-0.233143150806427,
0.0674997866153717,
0.5163645148277283,
-0.7403808236122131,
-0.689545214176178,
0.6337246894836426,
0.4433058798313141,
0.5428085327148438,
0.4905090630054474,
0.592741847038269,
0.4930248260498047,
0.44475728273391724,
-0.9828986525535583,
0.7924893498420715,
0.16379736363887787,
-0.40141111612319946,
-0.6985815763473511,
-0.1406184881925583,
-0.7448586821556091,
-0.1508861631155014,
-0.23406396806240082,
-0.8993915319442749,
0.08264482021331787,
-0.4613327980041504,
-0.13582821190357208,
0.32459789514541626,
-0.5450533032417297,
0.3187081515789032,
-0.1850748360157013,
-0.36584728956222534,
-0.6573622822761536,
-0.1020367220044136,
0.15163706243038177,
0.14955247938632965,
0.13420246541500092,
0.16117975115776062,
-0.2778473198413849,
0.1571597009897232,
-1.0675442218780518,
0.620933473110199,
-0.03808673471212387,
-0.05202934890985489,
0.6866903305053711,
0.07560694217681885,
0.514144241809845,
0.15920129418373108,
-0.5304566025733948,
0.040803369134664536,
-0.21601064503192902,
-0.36515483260154724,
-0.7943939566612244,
0.9711415767669678,
-1.0925641059875488,
-0.7101342678070068,
-0.15449777245521545,
-0.9024754166603088,
-0.30441954731941223,
0.17861491441726685,
-0.46232372522354126,
0.165956512093544,
-0.5010950565338135,
0.13717515766620636,
-0.2085951566696167,
-0.15755480527877808,
0.6475686430931091,
0.5256877541542053,
-0.0692615658044815,
-0.2948686182498932,
0.4242165982723236,
0.04080861806869507,
0.22021354734897614,
0.30843445658683777,
-0.35502809286117554,
-0.2034987360239029,
-0.4466800093650818,
-0.20658597350120544,
0.0436459481716156,
-0.5977804660797119,
0.02535630203783512,
-0.4994994103908539,
-0.2832224667072296,
-0.5271958112716675,
-0.7579271197319031,
-0.3558792173862457,
-0.21091894805431366,
-0.22268733382225037,
0.3860456049442291,
0.317763090133667,
0.5314974784851074,
0.11467061936855316,
0.5635321140289307,
-0.5926350355148315,
0.12299767136573792,
0.30324220657348633,
0.510347843170166,
0.2314637452363968,
0.13565616309642792,
-0.49809473752975464,
-0.13735318183898926,
-0.45578721165657043,
-0.6576725244522095,
0.27204570174217224,
-0.19198168814182281,
1.048604965209961,
0.4958019554615021,
0.07577741146087646,
0.23509910702705383,
0.29449450969696045,
0.9449047446250916,
0.04602281376719475,
-0.8897072076797485,
0.24078740179538727,
-0.18942618370056152,
0.26437410712242126,
0.561679482460022,
0.09044869244098663,
0.013662423007190228,
-0.5911107063293457,
-0.7055671811103821,
-0.2703622281551361,
0.7519438862800598,
0.26444128155708313,
-0.3239724338054657,
0.19439423084259033,
0.38374364376068115,
-0.051826510578393936,
0.042774748057127,
-0.2555604577064514,
-0.14940355718135834,
-0.1269942671060562,
0.042750533670186996,
-0.1904984712600708,
0.3297145664691925,
0.07346218079328537,
0.264935165643692,
0.975864589214325,
-0.47191280126571655,
0.15136100351810455,
0.32891765236854553,
0.11161252111196518,
0.1424497663974762,
0.3829859793186188,
0.2692537009716034,
0.5086657404899597,
0.010852368548512459,
-0.22072665393352509,
0.3226216435432434,
-0.4396154284477234,
0.05448710173368454,
0.04020954295992851,
0.09851444512605667,
-0.49124863743782043,
0.41990360617637634,
0.21580028533935547,
-0.36622339487075806,
-0.800564169883728,
0.45965197682380676,
-0.10698149353265762,
-0.031907495111227036,
-0.4601809084415436,
0.4490271508693695,
0.23986057937145233,
0.8235692381858826,
0.28483864665031433,
-0.10585895925760269,
-0.032534126192331314,
-0.9614563584327698,
0.07424992322921753,
0.7513434886932373,
-0.4310840368270874,
0.10119175165891647,
0.3718331754207611,
0.24478071928024292,
-0.8996223211288452,
0.3695470988750458,
-0.21777257323265076,
-0.3481657803058624,
1.0756604671478271,
0.42060914635658264,
0.8495049476623535,
-0.23166851699352264,
0.3353697955608368,
-0.23569002747535706,
0.36149126291275024,
0.12470780313014984,
0.47251585125923157,
-0.2261468768119812,
-0.8692725896835327,
-0.3532640039920807,
-0.21050845086574554,
-0.805019199848175,
0.11993777751922607,
-0.33735737204551697,
0.4287707805633545,
-0.8828298449516296,
-0.1793665885925293,
-0.09105321764945984,
0.3255464732646942,
-0.6752732396125793,
0.07495906203985214,
-0.14974664151668549,
1.1251001358032227,
-0.22109326720237732,
1.2879811525344849,
1.075640082359314,
-0.7260157465934753,
-1.0901741981506348,
-0.08537325263023376,
-0.1409643441438675,
-0.7153991460800171,
0.4220890700817108,
0.014246005564928055,
-0.564167857170105,
-0.22312815487384796,
-0.5100520253181458,
-0.496834397315979,
1.6237022876739502,
0.4513500928878784,
-0.2855016589164734,
0.09985622018575668,
0.3691372275352478,
0.8405030965805054,
-1.0954560041427612,
0.27286961674690247,
0.3678930401802063,
0.3437786400318146,
0.30385053157806396,
-1.2483625411987305,
0.20415009558200836,
-0.2619498372077942,
-0.22654666006565094,
-0.21182149648666382,
-0.9806838631629944,
0.6686541438102722,
-0.29342928528785706,
0.08650213479995728,
0.5337949991226196,
0.706648051738739,
0.2670776844024658,
0.5636039972305298,
0.6055938005447388,
0.43928027153015137,
0.7505103349685669,
0.4896862506866455,
0.7977374196052551,
-0.39472824335098267,
0.055825237184762955,
1.1939325332641602,
-0.6201077103614807,
0.5356083512306213,
0.22154906392097473,
0.25287291407585144,
0.5032883882522583,
-0.04591105505824089,
0.06690185517072678,
0.3179074227809906,
-0.16353590786457062,
-0.783744215965271,
-0.16543637216091156,
-0.7668689489364624,
-0.17198900878429413,
0.8321868181228638,
0.2792334258556366,
-0.11140751093626022,
-0.24532659351825714,
0.03588747978210449,
-0.034206222742795944,
0.24404500424861908,
-0.6084179878234863,
0.8274868726730347,
-0.06291382759809494,
-0.7169749736785889,
0.035406313836574554,
0.22493667900562286,
0.19209255278110504,
-0.5170416235923767,
-0.238758847117424,
0.18932358920574188,
0.084739089012146,
-0.18285851180553436,
-0.5850760340690613,
0.3001199960708618,
-0.22465364634990692,
-0.06257512420415878,
0.06904672086238861,
0.8132985830307007,
-0.008656198158860207,
0.06670644879341125,
0.5314448475837708,
0.8815779685974121,
0.10563316941261292,
-0.02547994628548622,
-0.48159363865852356,
0.12005718797445297,
-0.3845033347606659,
0.2131432145833969,
0.12778900563716888,
0.2560855746269226,
-0.35173308849334717,
1.0723681449890137,
0.7064450979232788,
0.23335318267345428,
-0.49257898330688477,
0.036502689123153687,
1.0272225141525269,
-0.22573469579219818,
-1.0868315696716309,
-0.4380723536014557,
0.24628877639770508,
-0.025142649188637733,
0.02330736815929413,
0.33324161171913147,
0.5695738196372986,
0.33297547698020935,
0.2864222228527069,
1.0322678089141846,
-0.1719527542591095,
0.058914121240377426,
-0.023042280226945877,
0.9644213914871216,
-0.4531138837337494,
0.5734274387359619,
-0.04125681146979332,
-0.7860637903213501,
-0.17592883110046387,
0.21034885942935944,
-0.3829357326030731,
-0.0011063558049499989,
0.4990083873271942,
0.9778147339820862,
-0.007086231838911772,
0.3633432388305664,
0.5846208930015564,
-0.05871829763054848,
0.7693460583686829,
0.4149918556213379,
0.49738335609436035,
0.08452972024679184,
0.4912703037261963,
-0.07124222069978714,
-0.8109875321388245,
-0.3636443018913269,
-0.4944256544113159,
-0.9693263173103333,
-0.8363224864006042,
0.03461898863315582,
-0.20873917639255524,
-0.06858941167593002,
1.1750743389129639,
0.6858125925064087,
-0.27372074127197266,
-0.1894904524087906,
-0.1704360395669937,
0.2507486939430237,
-0.25517475605010986,
-0.1968284696340561,
0.19492030143737793,
-0.19488227367401123,
-0.6081401705741882,
0.6695650815963745,
0.263087660074234,
-0.18472018837928772,
-0.6526257395744324,
-0.5118660926818848,
-0.10355005413293839,
0.3026287257671356,
0.3620956838130951,
0.4524897336959839,
-0.41615280508995056,
-0.32753050327301025,
-0.17812754213809967,
-0.2988263964653015,
-0.17877788841724396,
0.7975113987922668,
-0.7372649908065796,
0.42571914196014404,
0.2696656286716461,
0.9947279691696167,
0.40020763874053955,
-0.33539173007011414,
0.5690896511077881,
-0.33800509572029114,
0.31421858072280884,
0.04655710235238075,
0.3428276777267456,
-0.08767247945070267,
-0.6499664187431335,
0.36266234517097473,
-0.08295688033103943,
-0.537182092666626,
-0.3886072039604187,
0.30973878502845764,
-1.32009756565094,
-0.13247306644916534,
0.5843721032142639,
-0.3573319911956787,
-0.19434885680675507,
-0.39685773849487305,
-0.4038180708885193,
0.5246239304542542,
-0.6653966903686523,
0.8662002086639404,
0.454049289226532,
-0.42677387595176697,
-0.04547480121254921,
-0.04019882157444954,
0.18803741037845612,
0.18749995529651642,
-1.3784035444259644,
-0.3078303039073944,
0.32751449942588806,
-0.20409412682056427,
0.6508222222328186,
0.958251416683197,
0.024521255865693092,
0.5893430709838867,
0.06209699064493179,
0.4008917212486267,
-0.4999154806137085,
-0.6374149918556213,
-0.11771176755428314,
0.5952164530754089,
0.5000197291374207,
-0.22302664816379547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15115v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15115v2
|
Language Models in Dialogue: Conversational Maxims for Human-AI Interactions
| 2024-03-22T11:16:43 | 2024-06-22T12:17:38 |
Erik Miehling, Manish Nagireddy, Prasanna Sattigeri, Elizabeth M. Daly, David Piorkowski, John T. Richards
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Modern language models, while sophisticated, exhibit some inherent
shortcomings, particularly in conversational settings. We claim that many of
the observed shortcomings can be attributed to violation of one or more
conversational principles. By drawing upon extensive research from both the
social science and AI communities, we propose a set of maxims -- quantity,
quality, relevance, manner, benevolence, and transparency -- for describing
effective human-AI conversation. We first justify the applicability of the
first four maxims (from Grice) in the context of human-AI interactions. We then
argue that two new maxims, benevolence (concerning the generation of, and
engagement with, harmful content) and transparency (concerning recognition of
one's knowledge boundaries, operational constraints, and intents), are
necessary for addressing behavior unique to modern human-AI interactions. We
evaluate the degree to which various language models are able to understand
these maxims and find that models possess an internal prioritization of
principles that can significantly impact their ability to interpret the maxims
accurately.
|
[
-0.3664865493774414,
-0.8146980404853821,
0.6266688704490662,
0.23923708498477936,
0.17076747119426727,
0.10480882227420807,
-0.15753431618213654,
-0.5347205400466919,
-0.10802381485700607,
0.635255753993988,
-0.1990640014410019,
-0.12067659199237823,
-0.47011539340019226,
-0.1684267520904541,
-0.3901383876800537,
0.8953865170478821,
0.2870553731918335,
0.18391241133213043,
-0.3699016869068146,
-0.2213401049375534,
-0.5440687537193298,
-0.5157032012939453,
-0.7421116232872009,
-0.35916244983673096,
0.3625888228416443,
0.47281646728515625,
1.2234324216842651,
0.5420564413070679,
0.6787706613540649,
0.4046023488044739,
-0.11499643325805664,
0.05535280331969261,
-0.5427671670913696,
0.01643628068268299,
0.025199592113494873,
-0.4637048542499542,
-0.1956763118505478,
0.16557422280311584,
0.6147767305374146,
0.8782999515533447,
-0.1375659555196762,
-0.2730403542518616,
0.26825594902038574,
0.35780102014541626,
-0.389247864484787,
0.3227800726890564,
-0.41721951961517334,
-0.24206215143203735,
0.1572352945804596,
-0.012846902944147587,
-0.17048969864845276,
-0.4312536120414734,
0.35627731680870056,
-0.5086016058921814,
-0.05598901957273483,
-0.0031954445876181126,
1.133314847946167,
0.1124693751335144,
-0.2939170002937317,
-0.5200494527816772,
-0.8025263547897339,
1.0369043350219727,
-0.9355684518814087,
0.09423352777957916,
0.832676887512207,
0.24302732944488525,
-0.1612294763326645,
-0.4003024995326996,
-0.6467432975769043,
-0.7553717494010925,
-0.3282138705253601,
-0.39646998047828674,
-0.4080645740032196,
0.6414744853973389,
0.33596518635749817,
0.28514355421066284,
-0.2279219627380371,
-0.08825436979532242,
-0.42531004548072815,
-0.19538062810897827,
0.6684926152229309,
0.36583247780799866,
0.5301841497421265,
0.08099080622196198,
-0.1071772426366806,
0.08323289453983307,
-0.5784170031547546,
0.11641624569892883,
0.5001730918884277,
0.0876302495598793,
-0.160061314702034,
0.19616787135601044,
-0.2443237602710724,
0.5545296669006348,
-0.18866540491580963,
-0.25713837146759033,
-0.1337985098361969,
-0.8637170195579529,
-0.06943102180957794,
-0.6130441427230835,
0.634133517742157,
0.4416060447692871,
0.4395444393157959,
-0.11524848639965057,
-0.19209210574626923,
0.23490317165851593,
0.24773085117340088,
-0.5625874996185303,
-0.02779843844473362,
0.09599606692790985,
-0.1867600530385971,
-0.4414370059967041,
-0.046095527708530426,
-0.49244529008865356,
-0.3621261417865753,
-0.447854608297348,
0.3765738606452942,
-0.29453086853027344,
-0.11177106946706772,
0.11674726754426956,
-0.14993304014205933,
0.23142163455486298,
0.293311208486557,
-0.9130395650863647,
0.618979811668396,
0.7053943872451782,
0.5807958245277405,
0.24376295506954193,
-0.18416674435138702,
-0.28163066506385803,
0.08854350447654724,
-0.42253947257995605,
0.4783748984336853,
-0.7877180576324463,
-0.5608224868774414,
0.1200488731265068,
-0.40273335576057434,
0.00170661392621696,
-0.49758556485176086,
0.6826144456863403,
0.23877403140068054,
0.3965352475643158,
-0.42328932881355286,
-0.6052243113517761,
-0.18695995211601257,
0.15024574100971222,
-0.31056731939315796,
0.13162454962730408,
-0.05383715033531189,
-0.5452002286911011,
0.05161884054541588,
-0.8405892848968506,
-0.5800116062164307,
0.14143121242523193,
-0.4063580632209778,
0.03278238698840141,
0.16301898658275604,
-0.2690427005290985,
0.18880514800548553,
-0.4961571991443634,
0.5135701298713684,
-0.014860859140753746,
-0.24068213999271393,
0.38135117292404175,
-0.7809360027313232,
0.6660757064819336,
0.501581609249115,
-0.26783454418182373,
0.27282699942588806,
-0.3249828815460205,
0.00894449558109045,
0.11378548294305801,
-0.24172650277614594,
-0.23655027151107788,
0.1821085810661316,
-0.12744705379009247,
-0.13707387447357178,
0.18651160597801208,
-0.25075286626815796,
-0.14376699924468994,
-0.43643689155578613,
0.8344043493270874,
0.7640417218208313,
-0.21208299696445465,
0.6116201281547546,
-0.7226896286010742,
0.425554484128952,
-0.29575756192207336,
0.5035796761512756,
-0.2287309467792511,
-0.3828056752681732,
-0.837815523147583,
-0.2514190971851349,
-0.05673157796263695,
0.43177393078804016,
-0.4535808861255646,
0.28156620264053345,
-0.1740407794713974,
-0.3698594868183136,
-0.5357562899589539,
0.09166688472032547,
0.71466064453125,
0.49848470091819763,
-0.1116146668791771,
-0.5215207934379578,
-0.0229365061968565,
-1.1509393453598022,
-0.2691909670829773,
-0.5666977167129517,
0.08073034137487411,
0.7150118350982666,
0.2561713457107544,
-0.18509279191493988,
0.8789562582969666,
-0.21481700241565704,
0.032217349857091904,
-0.43189141154289246,
0.3383380174636841,
-0.04415671527385712,
0.51359623670578,
0.5040653347969055,
-0.9712648987770081,
-0.4872893989086151,
-0.2125474065542221,
-0.7014544010162354,
-0.027314122766256332,
-0.12406755983829498,
-0.17493294179439545,
0.03335065022110939,
0.13982214033603668,
-0.694141685962677,
0.576540470123291,
0.32878583669662476,
-0.3376609683036804,
0.4819314181804657,
-0.1640545129776001,
0.3357095718383789,
-0.8655321002006531,
-0.13938535749912262,
0.2230779379606247,
-0.18736806511878967,
-1.1942570209503174,
0.1375938504934311,
-0.39857301115989685,
-0.16430805623531342,
-0.5630858540534973,
0.8269320130348206,
-0.11803769320249557,
0.26156023144721985,
-0.3146403431892395,
0.12399767339229584,
0.17023196816444397,
0.36579465866088867,
-0.08206790685653687,
0.8424399495124817,
0.41400280594825745,
-0.6874349117279053,
0.23235994577407837,
0.37298163771629333,
-0.20211446285247803,
0.6509299874305725,
-0.9617321491241455,
0.12415796518325806,
-0.18378126621246338,
0.16237621009349823,
-0.8291338086128235,
-0.4931352734565735,
0.29829540848731995,
-0.5990184545516968,
0.19246596097946167,
-0.017165984958410263,
-0.2763856053352356,
-0.0067745777778327465,
-0.30921414494514465,
0.4825838506221771,
0.5858727693557739,
-0.09813488274812698,
0.4370407462120056,
0.6657114624977112,
-0.2807961404323578,
-0.5777024030685425,
-0.4625037610530853,
0.32882270216941833,
-0.22673523426055908,
-0.817895233631134,
0.0780855193734169,
-0.4871218204498291,
-0.8571276664733887,
-0.3247290849685669,
0.17558999359607697,
-0.26430919766426086,
0.2100367546081543,
0.16147905588150024,
0.177965447306633,
0.06635568290948868,
-0.1726941019296646,
-0.3695305585861206,
-0.0652025118470192,
-0.08330115675926208,
0.04395981505513191,
0.7262483239173889,
-0.43365660309791565,
-0.32428616285324097,
-0.9074955582618713,
0.5078739523887634,
0.7846795320510864,
0.0018093078397214413,
0.7340352535247803,
0.2439119964838028,
-0.4120328426361084,
0.555915355682373,
-0.619799792766571,
-0.5033911466598511,
-0.4686926603317261,
0.40344303846359253,
-0.13551761209964752,
-0.7445824146270752,
0.4411236643791199,
0.11969604343175888,
0.03979460895061493,
0.13988906145095825,
0.15338844060897827,
-0.29232627153396606,
1.3415205478668213,
0.6932892203330994,
-0.5099902749061584,
0.6949211359024048,
-0.038095779716968536,
0.36966827511787415,
-0.573615550994873,
0.02045801468193531,
-0.8610103726387024,
0.18921498954296112,
-0.5562553405761719,
-0.01873060129582882,
0.2878188192844391,
0.0628509595990181,
-0.39140889048576355,
0.19675324857234955,
-0.17764750123023987,
0.6460623145103455,
0.7407997250556946,
-0.2709845304489136,
0.025119781494140625,
-0.14364860951900482,
0.18878304958343506,
-0.03285318240523338,
-0.7484828233718872,
-0.9780955910682678,
0.5815665125846863,
0.5904311537742615,
0.9570443034172058,
0.15575434267520905,
0.43767938017845154,
0.4375725984573364,
0.02111632563173771,
-0.45935264229774475,
0.6368238925933838,
0.14109040796756744,
-0.8819469213485718,
-0.501519501209259,
-0.5245493054389954,
-0.9462029933929443,
0.10508319735527039,
-0.10562895238399506,
-1.017382264137268,
0.0011162727605551481,
0.2637859582901001,
-0.22384826838970184,
0.08726294338703156,
-0.8693172335624695,
1.0268192291259766,
-0.3426773250102997,
-0.41733622550964355,
-0.46965059638023376,
-0.8433946967124939,
0.2573843002319336,
0.4147842526435852,
0.3886641561985016,
-0.29663029313087463,
0.34486544132232666,
0.3934583365917206,
-0.27927687764167786,
1.0626293420791626,
0.10520043969154358,
0.0824507549405098,
0.4664458930492401,
-0.002217062283307314,
0.5639297962188721,
-0.11704972386360168,
0.2918356657028198,
0.22173631191253662,
0.12978258728981018,
-0.6693029403686523,
-0.4332820773124695,
0.3412814736366272,
-0.8712754249572754,
-0.8137719631195068,
-0.3497738540172577,
-0.6699250936508179,
0.058474257588386536,
0.062267232686281204,
0.01065246295183897,
0.5993230938911438,
-0.5405132174491882,
0.21398024260997772,
0.5332762598991394,
-0.4462762773036957,
0.22405658662319183,
0.302047997713089,
-0.015643205493688583,
-0.20254258811473846,
1.1769746541976929,
-0.24276335537433624,
0.9259738922119141,
0.13558699190616608,
0.2445930391550064,
-0.26985254883766174,
-0.38382720947265625,
-0.2760962247848511,
0.4030011296272278,
-0.849008321762085,
0.13371220231056213,
-0.44033682346343994,
-0.23477211594581604,
-0.47800421714782715,
-0.17395637929439545,
-0.14068035781383514,
-0.329733669757843,
-0.3031269609928131,
0.16660204529762268,
-0.18838664889335632,
0.7869970202445984,
-0.07955430448055267,
0.22989243268966675,
-0.8921053409576416,
0.2202814519405365,
0.2784583270549774,
0.0099524836987257,
-0.16558215022087097,
-0.4402647912502289,
-0.08885085582733154,
0.4710612893104553,
-0.45363321900367737,
-0.6436418294906616,
0.24176621437072754,
0.20909464359283447,
0.8710383176803589,
0.5945373773574829,
0.09287317842245102,
0.25442901253700256,
-0.32131102681159973,
0.7616662383079529,
0.14954200387001038,
-1.023224115371704,
0.4813576638698578,
-0.48403698205947876,
-0.07799757272005081,
0.5742214322090149,
0.35383787751197815,
-0.8045216798782349,
-0.6460930109024048,
-0.7217669486999512,
-0.6661504507064819,
0.4541087746620178,
0.570040762424469,
0.7133080959320068,
-0.10639528185129166,
0.16429252922534943,
-0.0772165060043335,
0.5808112025260925,
-0.7643619179725647,
-0.13570737838745117,
0.12980172038078308,
-0.3236963748931885,
0.09639015048742294,
-0.26033931970596313,
-0.5998971462249756,
-0.07559175044298172,
0.393017441034317,
-0.05256924778223038,
0.31750157475471497,
-0.11845657229423523,
0.04363009333610535,
-0.023142043501138687,
0.49727243185043335,
0.989193320274353,
1.1491608619689941,
0.023258177563548088,
-0.15198084712028503,
-0.03943455591797829,
-0.17931845784187317,
-0.03837393596768379,
-0.061128608882427216,
-0.4179461896419525,
-0.3160439729690552,
0.2666161358356476,
0.8367823362350464,
-0.03275517374277115,
-0.8203926086425781,
0.43519675731658936,
-0.2545110285282135,
0.09735247492790222,
-0.12345689535140991,
0.4041613042354584,
-0.2556251883506775,
0.3858337998390198,
0.11970537155866623,
0.23970338702201843,
0.12646406888961792,
-1.0565836429595947,
0.001263603218831122,
0.8186618089675903,
-0.39610859751701355,
-0.19490140676498413,
0.5522935390472412,
0.5244317650794983,
-0.6620490550994873,
0.4886387884616852,
-0.17029260098934174,
-0.5319265127182007,
0.4815278649330139,
0.19690628349781036,
0.8262912034988403,
0.014813532121479511,
0.3985641598701477,
0.011647372506558895,
0.26351624727249146,
-0.0378134660422802,
0.05491681024432182,
-0.061694301664829254,
-0.950921893119812,
-0.097181037068367,
-0.3045533299446106,
-0.792758047580719,
-0.006735044531524181,
-0.423304945230484,
-0.047376733273267746,
-0.2606157064437866,
-0.2072894424200058,
0.05121348425745964,
-0.06524918973445892,
-0.5652196407318115,
-0.09032077342271805,
0.07477652281522751,
0.3593696057796478,
-0.6083200573921204,
0.5285280346870422,
0.25564318895339966,
-0.8522188067436218,
-0.5856250524520874,
0.04542746767401695,
-0.03132036328315735,
-0.7320350408554077,
0.3762645423412323,
-0.09427434951066971,
-0.15577086806297302,
-0.12246605008840561,
-0.853162407875061,
-0.5072358846664429,
0.7452560067176819,
0.521558940410614,
-0.30762484669685364,
-0.07764443010091782,
0.30488795042037964,
0.5486167669296265,
-0.4717262387275696,
0.3105686604976654,
0.656306803226471,
0.5612977147102356,
0.0743095800280571,
-1.2214981317520142,
-0.2655746340751648,
-0.21556678414344788,
-0.10556869208812714,
-0.02632747031748295,
-0.8222713470458984,
0.4798784554004669,
-0.42213642597198486,
-0.27540355920791626,
0.4962404668331146,
0.42937248945236206,
0.00429536122828722,
0.5523141622543335,
0.3631595969200134,
0.2102392166852951,
0.6169739365577698,
-0.326154500246048,
1.3566622734069824,
-0.39860162138938904,
-0.0674649327993393,
0.6601264476776123,
-0.22583676874637604,
0.4297097325325012,
0.18105031549930573,
-0.20605939626693726,
-0.06707285344600677,
0.3507336676120758,
0.4051213264465332,
0.4536610245704651,
0.2146298885345459,
-0.37152349948883057,
-0.007463356480002403,
-0.7636142373085022,
-0.14882712066173553,
0.33777716755867004,
0.46367502212524414,
-0.10462632775306702,
0.2741076946258545,
-0.0713140144944191,
0.31562140583992004,
0.2076181024312973,
-0.050106316804885864,
0.90293949842453,
-0.04262736812233925,
-0.7542144656181335,
0.5259328484535217,
-0.043572090566158295,
0.5378202795982361,
-0.4110274016857147,
-0.16030099987983704,
-0.4289321303367615,
-0.038072146475315094,
0.17418256402015686,
-0.6766723394393921,
0.02110264077782631,
-0.12667953968048096,
0.008161616511642933,
0.030754022300243378,
0.7163491249084473,
-0.4734489917755127,
-0.30430445075035095,
-0.12704087793827057,
0.44353196024894714,
0.35689738392829895,
0.08603507280349731,
-0.7867509126663208,
0.15238112211227417,
0.12621155381202698,
0.14804567396640778,
0.34637489914894104,
0.1662987768650055,
0.07124408334493637,
1.0028750896453857,
0.4577684998512268,
0.11318784952163696,
-0.17309808731079102,
0.2967941462993622,
0.8253237009048462,
-0.5657232403755188,
-0.4161824584007263,
-0.6289201378822327,
0.4728015661239624,
-0.1845761090517044,
-0.16432443261146545,
0.43175384402275085,
0.06670266389846802,
0.7482573390007019,
0.4501258134841919,
0.9062150120735168,
0.19994880259037018,
0.2536051273345947,
-0.34707075357437134,
0.5403194427490234,
-0.31246083974838257,
0.42417919635772705,
-0.31260380148887634,
-0.8380256295204163,
-0.03485669195652008,
0.9443291425704956,
-0.2704671621322632,
0.43551212549209595,
0.37738674879074097,
0.7809603810310364,
0.30854374170303345,
0.2291562408208847,
0.7045720815658569,
0.14648813009262085,
0.6035365462303162,
0.36827296018600464,
1.2911429405212402,
-0.08864908665418625,
0.4865533411502838,
0.007271263282746077,
-0.16803312301635742,
-0.2537287175655365,
-0.545572817325592,
-0.8123928904533386,
-0.6906557083129883,
-0.21441812813282013,
-0.1782357394695282,
0.4106745719909668,
1.0040804147720337,
0.9372650384902954,
-0.4082392454147339,
-0.3949466049671173,
-0.25477519631385803,
0.23113152384757996,
0.1893850415945053,
-0.25320470333099365,
-0.17744296789169312,
-0.5203793048858643,
-0.9161692261695862,
0.28362488746643066,
0.31440821290016174,
0.3783482313156128,
-0.4203837513923645,
-0.566504955291748,
0.0055992333218455315,
0.6151463389396667,
0.39088407158851624,
0.5599657893180847,
-0.8830958604812622,
-0.49002137780189514,
-0.1605725735425949,
-0.32959774136543274,
0.13624809682369232,
0.8177140355110168,
-0.24541711807250977,
0.4264534115791321,
0.5380488634109497,
0.5212968587875366,
-0.055174216628074646,
0.14164628088474274,
0.7604796886444092,
-0.5117448568344116,
0.17335133254528046,
0.5516402721405029,
0.29547423124313354,
0.45016273856163025,
-0.1079375296831131,
0.5060533881187439,
0.145981565117836,
-0.8592425584793091,
-0.8619951009750366,
0.558863639831543,
-0.40188801288604736,
-0.2265380471944809,
0.9857245683670044,
-0.2244049459695816,
0.1444101184606552,
-0.251199334859848,
-0.40978381037712097,
-0.14508472383022308,
-0.5595770478248596,
0.7452364563941956,
0.8946847319602966,
-0.34164687991142273,
-0.09040087461471558,
-0.8638798594474792,
0.6052796244621277,
0.5152718424797058,
-0.8092634081840515,
0.096531443297863,
0.6931058764457703,
-0.06847359985113144,
0.3083495795726776,
0.7563133239746094,
0.09665308147668839,
0.053102269768714905,
0.05057210475206375,
-0.28070661425590515,
0.3359028995037079,
-0.5171357989311218,
0.0814707949757576,
-0.2115929126739502,
0.47892841696739197,
-0.12071817368268967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15112v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15112v3
|
Text clustering with LLM embeddings
| 2024-03-22T11:08:48 | 2024-05-30T15:17:55 |
Alina Petukhova, João P. Matos-Carvalho, Nuno Fachada
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; I.7.m
|
Text clustering is an important approach for organising the growing amount of
digital content, helping to structure and find hidden patterns in uncategorised
data. However, the effectiveness of text clustering heavily relies on the
choice of textual embeddings and clustering algorithms. We argue that recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) can potentially improve this task. In
this research, we investigated how different textual embeddings -- particularly
those used in LLMs -- and clustering algorithms affect how text datasets are
clustered. A series of experiments were conducted to assess how embeddings
influence clustering results, the role played by dimensionality reduction
through summarisation, and model size adjustment. Findings reveal that LLM
embeddings excel at capturing subtleties in structured language, while BERT
leads the lightweight options in performance. In addition, we observe that
increasing model dimensionality and employing summarization techniques do not
consistently lead to improvements in clustering efficiency, suggesting that
these strategies require careful analysis to use in real-life models. These
results highlight a complex balance between the need for refined text
representation and computational feasibility in text clustering applications.
This study extends traditional text clustering frameworks by incorporating
embeddings from LLMs, providing a path for improved methodologies, while
informing new avenues for future research in various types of textual analysis.
|
[
-0.13130468130111694,
-0.8358979225158691,
0.9415184855461121,
0.15779508650302887,
-0.45602381229400635,
0.2640396058559418,
-0.43740880489349365,
-0.47915977239608765,
0.46394580602645874,
0.08422651886940002,
-0.06708605587482452,
-0.8236858248710632,
-0.788753092288971,
0.18662184476852417,
-0.6978590488433838,
0.5990638136863708,
0.003398822620511055,
0.022819917649030685,
-0.6257441639900208,
-0.07445204257965088,
-0.33187127113342285,
-0.7696277499198914,
-0.2989620864391327,
-0.24048812687397003,
0.7243539094924927,
0.19806243479251862,
0.5180240869522095,
0.8355057835578918,
0.5983427166938782,
0.23080864548683167,
-0.512140691280365,
0.09800387173891068,
-0.4554167091846466,
0.2547091543674469,
0.2735652029514313,
-0.7032627463340759,
-0.29957783222198486,
-0.16561883687973022,
0.9904115796089172,
0.8126599192619324,
-0.2056771069765091,
-0.24465394020080566,
0.09410334378480911,
0.39696064591407776,
-0.37100929021835327,
0.16638872027397156,
-0.5347551107406616,
0.052530691027641296,
-0.09193433076143265,
-0.04580704867839813,
-0.32101935148239136,
-0.2764386534690857,
0.11289521306753159,
-0.19549770653247833,
0.1693767011165619,
0.25837114453315735,
0.24700389802455902,
0.3362584114074707,
-0.4141882359981537,
-0.6035118699073792,
-0.7094576358795166,
1.0417214632034302,
-0.943842351436615,
0.2765267789363861,
0.06821493804454803,
0.010539856739342213,
-0.001414917758665979,
-0.5742583870887756,
-0.31374847888946533,
0.17714430391788483,
-0.3897610008716583,
-0.10326837748289108,
-0.009285526350140572,
-0.05215105041861534,
-0.02005983144044876,
0.3755231201648712,
-0.39546382427215576,
0.7063140869140625,
-0.1598874181509018,
0.11802608519792557,
0.4984284043312073,
0.2643459141254425,
0.19606532156467438,
-0.04501257836818695,
0.006050423253327608,
-0.007671057712286711,
-0.750478982925415,
-0.23043020069599152,
0.17006559669971466,
0.2835550904273987,
-0.24976332485675812,
0.6951122283935547,
0.24472294747829437,
0.5636144280433655,
-0.13857591152191162,
-0.12902981042861938,
-0.06141543760895729,
-0.225805401802063,
0.04218859225511551,
0.14813561737537384,
0.5505053997039795,
0.4582715928554535,
0.14369390904903412,
-0.20399126410484314,
-0.054225675761699677,
0.002735018264502287,
0.16664886474609375,
-0.7051795125007629,
-0.11891653388738632,
0.4610518515110016,
-0.6848164200782776,
-0.5357076525688171,
0.33244913816452026,
-0.6123497486114502,
-0.4592300057411194,
-0.0983007624745369,
0.06757399439811707,
-0.16903507709503174,
-0.01817692443728447,
-0.06885351985692978,
-0.32673582434654236,
0.303487092256546,
0.4397498667240143,
-1.0398170948028564,
0.324596107006073,
0.8525252342224121,
1.026286244392395,
-0.5800848007202148,
-0.08339763432741165,
0.019905829802155495,
0.405887246131897,
-0.4278494119644165,
0.9097105264663696,
-0.8637466430664062,
-0.4519273042678833,
0.2618706524372101,
-0.12734590470790863,
-0.053247224539518356,
-0.5692862272262573,
0.2639228105545044,
-0.26928478479385376,
0.14492066204547882,
-0.29722699522972107,
-0.7849289774894714,
-0.10491833835840225,
0.09421619772911072,
-0.7703868746757507,
1.0849578380584717,
-0.33592262864112854,
-0.7949658036231995,
0.32232731580734253,
-0.40403857827186584,
-0.5879823565483093,
-0.3167010247707367,
-0.3121578097343445,
-0.6276863217353821,
0.6817932724952698,
0.3954803943634033,
0.991013765335083,
-0.21266178786754608,
0.1021164208650589,
-0.29080939292907715,
-0.6515264511108398,
0.4371303617954254,
-0.17337505519390106,
0.14087679982185364,
-0.12776942551136017,
-0.026221556589007378,
-0.029600858688354492,
-0.6142449975013733,
-0.2458256185054779,
0.12936203181743622,
-0.33030611276626587,
-0.6704815030097961,
0.4615856111049652,
0.037366148084402084,
-0.19821509718894958,
0.38433337211608887,
-0.41905510425567627,
0.18294192850589752,
-0.4331471920013428,
0.6772926449775696,
0.5350756645202637,
-0.05937041714787483,
0.7423014640808105,
-0.4042482376098633,
0.27306559681892395,
-0.003572069574147463,
-0.28861936926841736,
-0.44323742389678955,
-0.6126089096069336,
-0.5799418091773987,
-0.2808036804199219,
0.4803949296474457,
0.36213070154190063,
-0.45214739441871643,
0.5134055614471436,
-0.3223266005516052,
-0.4900243878364563,
-0.2962956428527832,
-0.09719730168581009,
0.07506997883319855,
-0.3260062336921692,
0.10109284520149231,
-0.05544864386320114,
-0.38405564427375793,
-0.7503039240837097,
-0.2557234466075897,
0.029611660167574883,
-0.03334124758839607,
0.14439870417118073,
0.4741842448711395,
-0.2695024311542511,
0.9812040328979492,
-0.7276727557182312,
-0.2577476501464844,
-0.4778904318809509,
0.07449312508106232,
0.16556809842586517,
0.30661773681640625,
0.7034403085708618,
-0.7332618832588196,
-0.4949336051940918,
0.0871879905462265,
-0.6945717334747314,
0.0264983419328928,
0.022607926279306412,
0.4120998680591583,
0.1558791846036911,
0.8199185729026794,
-0.3847804069519043,
0.4207666218280792,
0.7868698835372925,
-0.1111224889755249,
0.19777432084083557,
-0.42671066522598267,
-0.12729282677173615,
-1.0879440307617188,
-0.2889276444911957,
-0.14334411919116974,
-0.3326146900653839,
-0.5357843637466431,
0.0687195211648941,
0.04776155203580856,
0.06571810692548752,
-0.2018251270055771,
0.35907962918281555,
-0.5465620756149292,
-0.32087957859039307,
-0.37331363558769226,
0.4127386212348938,
-0.07558748871088028,
0.1597556471824646,
-0.12649981677532196,
0.6259728074073792,
0.32803064584732056,
-0.5269320011138916,
0.006476585287600756,
0.14525270462036133,
-0.35334932804107666,
0.2371140867471695,
-0.664850652217865,
-0.04296860471367836,
-0.2121339738368988,
0.257281631231308,
-1.0685362815856934,
-0.10452233999967575,
-0.37087517976760864,
-0.2216908484697342,
0.5548334121704102,
0.2283375859260559,
-0.8018213510513306,
-0.12560085952281952,
-0.7251021862030029,
0.46258771419525146,
0.35186266899108887,
-0.4499049186706543,
0.7214750647544861,
0.5990681648254395,
-0.38383105397224426,
-0.13904468715190887,
-0.8201351165771484,
0.12688694894313812,
-0.4582687318325043,
-0.43196508288383484,
0.667894184589386,
0.0020621861331164837,
-0.33664098381996155,
0.09440036863088608,
0.16491925716400146,
-0.07185769081115723,
0.1334487348794937,
0.20004963874816895,
-0.13739512860774994,
0.027644354850053787,
0.39920473098754883,
0.43795010447502136,
-0.1363375186920166,
-0.11132820695638657,
-0.274474561214447,
0.655745804309845,
0.11245385557413101,
-0.32529810070991516,
-0.2830692231655121,
0.6023428440093994,
0.44440019130706787,
-0.04925134778022766,
1.1011450290679932,
0.5616021156311035,
-0.40666067600250244,
-0.460327684879303,
-0.583531379699707,
-0.17884542047977448,
-0.44468674063682556,
0.2741031348705292,
0.19673070311546326,
-1.6079682111740112,
0.5222694873809814,
-0.17508557438850403,
0.14942845702171326,
0.4309577941894531,
0.7070038914680481,
-0.6074422597885132,
0.9392901062965393,
1.01970374584198,
-0.15042352676391602,
0.5154039859771729,
0.005222242791205645,
0.37580543756484985,
-0.5897685885429382,
-0.0546022392809391,
-0.7265408039093018,
-0.39236536622047424,
-0.8780384063720703,
-0.6271937489509583,
0.3323926329612732,
-0.20037789642810822,
0.2698141038417816,
-0.0007064202218316495,
-0.24439609050750732,
0.5033993721008301,
0.233454167842865,
-0.1286705583333969,
0.4886363744735718,
0.4333750605583191,
-0.09288432449102402,
-0.2281123697757721,
-0.8395757675170898,
-0.47787001729011536,
0.7965860962867737,
0.46407562494277954,
0.7330039739608765,
0.12643079459667206,
0.7358483076095581,
0.3502146303653717,
0.17598938941955566,
-0.851771354675293,
0.3781431019306183,
-0.6179495453834534,
-0.16384273767471313,
-0.3130466043949127,
-0.3256085515022278,
-0.9976523518562317,
0.3263421356678009,
-0.35227489471435547,
-0.6112586259841919,
0.14907073974609375,
-0.15748977661132812,
-0.12742246687412262,
0.33602583408355713,
-0.6355767846107483,
0.3301428556442261,
0.0911465659737587,
0.14862792193889618,
-0.3805469870567322,
-0.20416049659252167,
-0.012169530615210533,
-0.3001641035079956,
0.4833551347255707,
0.19280757009983063,
-0.3065267503261566,
0.8444933891296387,
-0.28273266553878784,
1.2206194400787354,
0.1715497225522995,
-0.5810645222663879,
0.2282429188489914,
-0.22958657145500183,
0.6474930644035339,
-0.1918090432882309,
-0.07297807931900024,
0.28441938757896423,
0.15794019401073456,
-0.2906850576400757,
-0.7045433521270752,
0.9094175696372986,
-0.49810147285461426,
-0.43175002932548523,
-0.2572900354862213,
-0.4226357340812683,
-0.026184406131505966,
-0.039110518991947174,
0.030026426538825035,
0.5323795080184937,
-0.2869199216365814,
0.711408257484436,
0.7623922824859619,
-0.48975053429603577,
0.7185518741607666,
0.3196988105773926,
-0.3905418813228607,
-0.21429066359996796,
0.841566264629364,
0.27203473448753357,
0.013693006709218025,
0.7182531952857971,
0.2739786207675934,
-0.28732985258102417,
-0.8530904650688171,
0.04457751289010048,
0.48150697350502014,
-0.6588122844696045,
-0.023669496178627014,
-0.7419881224632263,
-0.034812528640031815,
-0.3592400550842285,
-0.49061015248298645,
-0.17295877635478973,
-0.6493825912475586,
-0.47015470266342163,
-0.29955631494522095,
0.3460001051425934,
1.1789295673370361,
0.1764681190252304,
0.6886902451515198,
-0.8401087522506714,
-0.07474546879529953,
0.18014931678771973,
0.34505173563957214,
0.1928451955318451,
-0.15950779616832733,
-0.5673513412475586,
-0.36396947503089905,
0.036859530955553055,
-0.7249507904052734,
0.2276245653629303,
0.10320641100406647,
0.41001126170158386,
0.32377684116363525,
-0.31671804189682007,
0.39429721236228943,
-0.60406494140625,
0.8090855479240417,
-0.0919690728187561,
-0.6673881411552429,
0.3159607946872711,
-0.6550747752189636,
0.36425480246543884,
0.20834463834762573,
0.135634183883667,
-0.4242100417613983,
-0.4437277615070343,
-0.42438286542892456,
-0.681542158126831,
0.3417346775531769,
0.3465286195278168,
0.12162182480096817,
0.015182195231318474,
0.47733166813850403,
-0.039290934801101685,
0.29996582865715027,
-0.694124698638916,
-0.17632927000522614,
0.47583603858947754,
-0.4365444779396057,
-0.28135576844215393,
-0.6395301222801208,
0.19477398693561554,
-0.11674396693706512,
0.30305176973342896,
0.060819704085588455,
0.30694013833999634,
-0.11285222321748734,
-0.15675833821296692,
0.17905400693416595,
0.2215251922607422,
0.25801098346710205,
0.5236481428146362,
-0.015584973618388176,
0.06496670097112656,
0.2805330157279968,
-0.44625362753868103,
-0.011800295673310757,
-0.2249428778886795,
-0.22276610136032104,
0.1902182549238205,
0.6290261149406433,
0.29497456550598145,
0.5737286806106567,
-0.6062572002410889,
0.4539799094200134,
-0.15700414776802063,
-0.07701113075017929,
-0.10524451732635498,
-0.10606664419174194,
0.3460834324359894,
0.23196189105510712,
0.30054187774658203,
-0.5597668290138245,
-0.07306015491485596,
-0.4760511517524719,
-0.07734686136245728,
0.47643959522247314,
-0.2895842492580414,
-0.09452284872531891,
0.20690315961837769,
0.06535417586565018,
-0.04127286747097969,
0.11088394373655319,
0.13614006340503693,
-0.3462803065776825,
0.6953549385070801,
0.523125410079956,
0.6261358261108398,
-0.17557290196418762,
0.23280104994773865,
-0.10719551891088486,
0.5191214680671692,
-0.16473300755023956,
0.04275502264499664,
0.08633197098970413,
-0.6009464263916016,
-0.6154006123542786,
-0.7450366020202637,
-0.5025269985198975,
-0.43180373311042786,
-0.40097782015800476,
0.0543719157576561,
-0.36081886291503906,
-0.00402221130207181,
-0.3302704393863678,
-0.040751863270998,
-0.39572152495384216,
0.06598261743783951,
-0.034559834748506546,
0.570917546749115,
-0.7720615863800049,
0.6002246141433716,
0.7243069410324097,
0.30053630471229553,
-0.3110671043395996,
0.0001402247726218775,
-0.05994192883372307,
-0.4087101221084595,
0.05111518129706383,
0.3355841338634491,
0.11240918934345245,
0.09266917407512665,
-0.5969304442405701,
-0.9943528771400452,
1.3078572750091553,
-0.08689352869987488,
-0.6179892420768738,
0.07798640429973602,
0.19458629190921783,
0.6992905139923096,
-0.5819873213768005,
0.0006526531069539487,
0.5451074838638306,
0.3371286690235138,
-0.0798860564827919,
-0.5078437328338623,
0.07424978166818619,
0.1560952216386795,
0.25282707810401917,
0.35607412457466125,
-0.5610121488571167,
0.843568742275238,
0.00693490682169795,
-0.2671316862106323,
0.15270797908306122,
0.7255717515945435,
0.09879202395677567,
0.24855992197990417,
0.2860792577266693,
0.6519590020179749,
0.8186349868774414,
-0.16311383247375488,
1.067250370979309,
-0.020933063700795174,
0.2638701796531677,
0.8475074768066406,
-0.2609810531139374,
1.0231781005859375,
0.372543066740036,
-0.29369086027145386,
0.8257380127906799,
0.4102914035320282,
-0.07991563528776169,
0.3398548364639282,
0.12656402587890625,
-0.1102604866027832,
-0.10759257525205612,
-0.1269441545009613,
-0.30743882060050964,
0.40561744570732117,
0.7416951656341553,
-0.4683552384376526,
-0.21827413141727448,
-0.03378625959157944,
-0.09990132600069046,
0.23221619427204132,
-0.19723334908485413,
0.9134975671768188,
0.22774003446102142,
-0.05060607194900513,
-0.05422346293926239,
0.3757985234260559,
0.9370144605636597,
-0.3712732195854187,
0.03267429769039154,
-0.10890436172485352,
0.05478387698531151,
-0.24530905485153198,
-0.512609601020813,
0.34431201219558716,
0.022777926176786423,
-0.3229040801525116,
-0.2973651587963104,
0.9136574268341064,
-0.2977845072746277,
-0.7264376282691956,
0.457384318113327,
0.7547634840011597,
0.13768889009952545,
-0.10519775003194809,
-0.19225339591503143,
0.1743215024471283,
-0.12484628707170486,
0.017499703913927078,
0.6236143112182617,
0.5597017407417297,
-0.07162132859230042,
0.42908355593681335,
0.6796919703483582,
0.10334647446870804,
-0.041743017733097076,
0.15651622414588928,
0.9420182704925537,
-0.8239772319793701,
-0.6095421314239502,
-0.9887489676475525,
0.30038926005363464,
-0.08777498453855515,
0.21865002810955048,
0.9464703798294067,
0.5216047763824463,
0.46494871377944946,
0.1394229531288147,
0.7083128690719604,
0.15054921805858612,
0.5775063037872314,
-0.7525191307067871,
0.7364717125892639,
-0.5279157161712646,
0.5146568417549133,
-0.39692312479019165,
-1.1691533327102661,
-0.555867612361908,
0.5057504773139954,
-0.2789953351020813,
0.05922415852546692,
0.7860261797904968,
0.6632119417190552,
0.15995250642299652,
0.09340907633304596,
0.37381571531295776,
0.3961087167263031,
0.44017350673675537,
0.010197503492236137,
0.8525583744049072,
-0.14353197813034058,
0.3039674460887909,
0.02585699036717415,
-0.21701228618621826,
-0.22875939309597015,
-1.1083428859710693,
-1.2839469909667969,
-0.5178773403167725,
-0.10503842681646347,
0.205074280500412,
-0.11301834136247635,
0.5637672543525696,
0.2765001058578491,
-0.7327420711517334,
-0.20121490955352783,
0.12335288524627686,
0.425635427236557,
0.05340925604104996,
-0.20680178701877594,
0.41925570368766785,
-0.2596330940723419,
-0.6743596196174622,
0.4051961898803711,
0.5458039045333862,
0.3150949776172638,
-0.38665229082107544,
0.2636614739894867,
-0.06361936032772064,
0.03295256197452545,
0.967123806476593,
-0.2656167447566986,
-0.5053844451904297,
-0.12835784256458282,
-0.14217445254325867,
0.009265448898077011,
0.0007142178947106004,
1.0354082584381104,
-0.621941089630127,
-0.04464114084839821,
0.48184847831726074,
0.6427137851715088,
0.4107346832752228,
0.07479619979858398,
0.5903571248054504,
-0.8926769495010376,
0.11516790091991425,
0.026971373707056046,
0.36645030975341797,
0.3650011122226715,
-0.2455325573682785,
0.24852554500102997,
0.019175436347723007,
-0.46807101368904114,
-0.727462112903595,
-0.2378404587507248,
-0.78551185131073,
-0.6340107321739197,
1.164645791053772,
0.0865674614906311,
-0.1768793761730194,
-0.07265760749578476,
-0.10527414083480835,
-0.11896422505378723,
-0.2794666290283203,
0.7574076056480408,
0.9516526460647583,
0.17913295328617096,
-0.16677482426166534,
-0.19636176526546478,
0.22570523619651794,
0.35828810930252075,
-0.8588216304779053,
-0.04619238153100014,
0.40320128202438354,
-0.1551574468612671,
0.13044561445713043,
0.3378141522407532,
-0.12852822244167328,
-0.2736024856567383,
-0.22954973578453064,
-0.3789980411529541,
0.16459861397743225,
-0.5241271257400513,
-0.66526198387146,
0.37859979271888733,
-0.05149545148015022,
0.40562063455581665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15516v1
|
CTSM: Combining Trait and State Emotions for Empathetic Response Model
| 2024-03-22T10:45:13 | 2024-03-22T10:45:13 |
Wang Yufeng, Chen Chao, Yang Zhou, Wang Shuhui, Liao Xiangwen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Empathetic response generation endeavors to empower dialogue systems to
perceive speakers' emotions and generate empathetic responses accordingly.
Psychological research demonstrates that emotion, as an essential factor in
empathy, encompasses trait emotions, which are static and context-independent,
and state emotions, which are dynamic and context-dependent. However, previous
studies treat them in isolation, leading to insufficient emotional perception
of the context, and subsequently, less effective empathetic expression. To
address this problem, we propose Combining Trait and State emotions for
Empathetic Response Model (CTSM). Specifically, to sufficiently perceive
emotions in dialogue, we first construct and encode trait and state emotion
embeddings, and then we further enhance emotional perception capability through
an emotion guidance module that guides emotion representation. In addition, we
propose a cross-contrastive learning decoder to enhance the model's empathetic
expression capability by aligning trait and state emotions between generated
responses and contexts. Both automatic and manual evaluation results
demonstrate that CTSM outperforms state-of-the-art baselines and can generate
more empathetic responses. Our code is available at
https://github.com/wangyufeng-empty/CTSM
|
[
-0.3853304982185364,
-0.7136497497558594,
0.6478284001350403,
0.1440635770559311,
-0.3201255798339844,
-0.13005706667900085,
-0.11096183955669403,
-0.35586971044540405,
0.483641117811203,
0.13365314900875092,
-0.7698913812637329,
-0.23441530764102936,
-0.48285266757011414,
0.296636700630188,
0.01640143059194088,
0.7592806220054626,
0.09320808947086334,
0.3570515811443329,
0.04732442647218704,
-0.27963486313819885,
-0.32271119952201843,
-0.6587815880775452,
-0.6885209679603577,
-0.4622960388660431,
0.5083997845649719,
0.18209536373615265,
0.13493125140666962,
0.20125913619995117,
0.3296179473400116,
0.3227521479129791,
-0.1075841560959816,
0.21857815980911255,
-0.46494758129119873,
0.4679880738258362,
-0.028386538848280907,
-0.17192427814006805,
-0.6926209330558777,
-0.021578658372163773,
0.10763553529977798,
0.1284206062555313,
-0.030793700367212296,
-0.2116624116897583,
0.20997659862041473,
0.24180206656455994,
-0.7510069012641907,
0.13427047431468964,
-0.2509915232658386,
0.40889233350753784,
0.5806663036346436,
-0.5951110124588013,
-0.49815332889556885,
-0.4341083765029907,
0.3972427546977997,
-0.3230278193950653,
0.0575273297727108,
0.045368093997240067,
0.4438495337963104,
0.10102125257253647,
-1.0093598365783691,
-0.10309042781591415,
-0.5059826970100403,
0.8200710415840149,
-0.616648256778717,
0.07240355014801025,
0.12397175282239914,
0.11522068083286285,
0.27125152945518494,
-0.2972349524497986,
-0.5939476490020752,
-0.24779541790485382,
-0.15697793662548065,
0.4923546016216278,
-0.22485969960689545,
0.3341884911060333,
0.34865158796310425,
0.6031416654586792,
-0.5566591024398804,
-0.2273465096950531,
0.048669733107089996,
-0.10522452741861343,
0.45912301540374756,
0.8487260341644287,
0.19843539595603943,
-0.19576527178287506,
-0.4583686590194702,
-0.30558618903160095,
-0.31076306104660034,
0.15616175532341003,
0.14728353917598724,
0.335336834192276,
-0.47351768612861633,
0.5296809673309326,
0.07217629253864288,
0.5520492196083069,
0.37950798869132996,
0.052372854202985764,
0.13880160450935364,
-0.26095694303512573,
-0.47200414538383484,
0.06205471232533455,
0.6800916194915771,
0.5955770611763,
-0.1458343118429184,
0.25735747814178467,
-0.053264301270246506,
0.3326384723186493,
0.43273666501045227,
-0.9319980144500732,
-0.0440661683678627,
0.4801219701766968,
-0.684781551361084,
-0.35531124472618103,
-0.09481468051671982,
-1.1219674348831177,
-0.38946494460105896,
-0.17614279687404633,
0.38265788555145264,
-0.4953969120979309,
-0.4634179472923279,
-0.04436059668660164,
-0.29892346262931824,
0.4220721125602722,
0.39103996753692627,
-0.8652523159980774,
0.15718257427215576,
0.39144545793533325,
0.7397071719169617,
0.06287273019552231,
-0.009836298413574696,
-0.4530550539493561,
-0.02175177074968815,
-0.032577961683273315,
0.4228835105895996,
-0.930519163608551,
-0.7504569888114929,
0.1463463455438614,
-0.022203095257282257,
-0.13631677627563477,
-0.0564967542886734,
0.4677563011646271,
0.07278154790401459,
0.12052062898874283,
-0.4272257387638092,
-0.6754871606826782,
-0.1902153491973877,
0.6002791523933411,
-0.8132941722869873,
0.6380721926689148,
0.46703293919563293,
-0.9024636149406433,
0.03624580055475235,
-0.6967328190803528,
-0.3524048328399658,
-0.31504809856414795,
-0.01875319704413414,
-0.18711628019809723,
0.5434408187866211,
0.1475307196378708,
0.4760015308856964,
-0.38535815477371216,
-0.14606377482414246,
-0.6838188171386719,
-0.261390745639801,
0.19790571928024292,
-0.10768090188503265,
0.5218401551246643,
0.49540039896965027,
-0.25823652744293213,
0.07632776349782944,
-0.5156912803649902,
0.08729705214500427,
0.234381303191185,
-0.30074235796928406,
-0.4291468560695648,
-0.12835337221622467,
0.11624956130981445,
0.2561575472354889,
0.12746798992156982,
-0.7909217476844788,
-0.14124222099781036,
-0.3163785934448242,
0.3394168019294739,
0.6486117243766785,
0.12595480680465698,
0.4607982933521271,
-0.2717094421386719,
0.6709434390068054,
0.40025344491004944,
0.22432948648929596,
-0.39215126633644104,
-0.10373303294181824,
-0.9128016233444214,
-0.09546211361885071,
-0.478959858417511,
0.3356337547302246,
-0.5318230986595154,
0.7355397343635559,
0.302703857421875,
-0.6253649592399597,
-0.5535510182380676,
-0.5508106350898743,
0.7678194046020508,
0.667222797870636,
0.4317995607852936,
-0.3150140941143036,
-0.6366426944732666,
-0.6884881854057312,
-0.26011568307876587,
-0.07323452830314636,
0.08118457347154617,
0.5333718657493591,
0.2061731070280075,
0.02118293195962906,
0.760202169418335,
-0.5759995579719543,
-0.11018446832895279,
-0.4621813893318176,
0.2623724043369293,
-0.30746275186538696,
0.49182453751564026,
0.4343640208244324,
-0.6541973948478699,
-0.18645894527435303,
0.15213137865066528,
-0.6275797486305237,
0.005707817152142525,
0.16894933581352234,
0.03372316434979439,
0.3250180184841156,
0.05937881022691727,
-0.34673354029655457,
0.5625805258750916,
0.7493864893913269,
-0.5916655659675598,
0.34946420788764954,
0.07551559805870056,
0.7076159715652466,
-1.5150634050369263,
-0.004209934268146753,
0.345753014087677,
0.08445342630147934,
-0.7437814474105835,
0.1079569086432457,
0.0006194706074893475,
-0.26309266686439514,
-0.6163607239723206,
0.616063117980957,
-0.27184605598449707,
0.012444882653653622,
-0.2499268501996994,
-0.1511993408203125,
0.13115327060222626,
0.7212634682655334,
0.22199946641921997,
0.2555718719959259,
0.4349167048931122,
-0.5266357064247131,
0.6389944553375244,
0.3803003132343292,
0.079087994992733,
0.8760802149772644,
-0.5163071155548096,
0.011043115518987179,
0.18959805369377136,
0.5209037661552429,
-0.7156942486763,
-0.13572442531585693,
0.29836997389793396,
-0.459865540266037,
0.2422226220369339,
0.19899719953536987,
-0.14080636203289032,
-0.31530848145484924,
-0.2270181030035019,
0.46060067415237427,
0.6129733920097351,
-0.4753928780555725,
1.2538827657699585,
0.09257004410028458,
-0.15932483971118927,
-0.19255593419075012,
-0.6926379799842834,
-0.29011234641075134,
-0.22840887308120728,
-0.3447636067867279,
-0.013513914309442043,
-0.21225175261497498,
-0.046369653195142746,
-0.17722564935684204,
-0.15034571290016174,
-0.13314178586006165,
-0.050247613340616226,
0.1899469494819641,
-0.03828936815261841,
-0.031018050387501717,
0.20101509988307953,
0.37605345249176025,
-0.17519806325435638,
0.25870296359062195,
0.27307751774787903,
0.623813807964325,
-0.20445416867733002,
-0.4926236569881439,
-0.6193314790725708,
0.64908766746521,
0.5157302021980286,
-0.20315244793891907,
0.46082058548927307,
0.6783126592636108,
-0.20323188602924347,
-0.08263155072927475,
-0.1475415676832199,
-0.5426726341247559,
-0.3925785422325134,
0.47771182656288147,
-0.43525102734565735,
-1.13209867477417,
0.3528340458869934,
-0.14004001021385193,
-0.011387743055820465,
0.15018503367900848,
0.7620557546615601,
0.06534810364246368,
1.43883216381073,
0.6548411250114441,
-0.039571329951286316,
0.5349315404891968,
0.12221623212099075,
0.6431633234024048,
-0.9792946577072144,
-0.26023706793785095,
-0.704548716545105,
-0.41323208808898926,
-0.6528462171554565,
-0.22418178617954254,
0.4759571850299835,
-0.6032407879829407,
-0.4715435802936554,
0.12355693429708481,
-0.37375888228416443,
-0.06536293029785156,
0.3827122151851654,
0.6099857091903687,
0.07063958048820496,
-0.2900281250476837,
-0.3216444253921509,
-0.22374199330806732,
-0.39956986904144287,
-0.30159905552864075,
0.7803612351417542,
0.3239743411540985,
1.1059626340866089,
0.09651418030261993,
0.89556485414505,
0.21285705268383026,
0.06469497829675674,
-1.1045856475830078,
0.6564125418663025,
-0.09397728741168976,
-0.26080751419067383,
-0.05637402459979057,
-0.36414265632629395,
-0.4749121069908142,
0.23168356716632843,
-0.36304450035095215,
-0.8300533294677734,
0.24712826311588287,
0.3860204219818115,
-0.3190588355064392,
0.17309407889842987,
-0.6055046916007996,
0.5767002701759338,
-0.15879231691360474,
-0.19568710029125214,
-0.4811820685863495,
-0.7238913178443909,
0.37553417682647705,
0.01374194584786892,
-0.4444103240966797,
-0.038884907960891724,
0.21704521775245667,
0.4032857120037079,
-0.6083117127418518,
1.0785516500473022,
-0.10170939564704895,
-0.0740208625793457,
-0.04358161985874176,
0.49201080203056335,
0.3104732930660248,
-0.17215922474861145,
-0.14789509773254395,
-0.10698264837265015,
-0.05998245254158974,
-0.24079717695713043,
-0.7081701755523682,
0.5327257513999939,
-0.6217381358146667,
-0.6173396110534668,
-0.3483908176422119,
-0.6361015439033508,
-0.23293976485729218,
-0.1667555272579193,
0.2186257541179657,
0.5287190675735474,
-0.5579867362976074,
0.13485707342624664,
0.7924284934997559,
-0.40409597754478455,
0.31687113642692566,
0.484713077545166,
0.06474456191062927,
-0.4586150050163269,
0.7309380173683167,
-0.7502922415733337,
0.3678022623062134,
0.5050998330116272,
0.3795228898525238,
-0.17786049842834473,
0.3252033591270447,
0.1342601627111435,
-0.03894728049635887,
-0.5907173156738281,
-0.2817118763923645,
-0.7414765954017639,
-0.10033109784126282,
-0.44409286975860596,
-0.44382795691490173,
-0.3856428265571594,
-0.18680885434150696,
-0.3087625205516815,
-0.2169559746980667,
0.41912057995796204,
0.7831753492355347,
-0.0475165992975235,
0.18159015476703644,
-1.1491621732711792,
0.0726114884018898,
0.3541758954524994,
0.08920709788799286,
0.2094019055366516,
-0.44071584939956665,
-0.2029489427804947,
0.019489837810397148,
-0.6277828216552734,
-0.9102808833122253,
0.6849238276481628,
0.14400747418403625,
0.344621479511261,
0.8088744282722473,
0.3600825071334839,
0.6233826279640198,
0.008897016756236553,
0.8619067072868347,
0.47048068046569824,
-1.3947900533676147,
0.7448698878288269,
-0.14568418264389038,
0.20529720187187195,
-0.014970608986914158,
0.40517714619636536,
-0.5443060398101807,
-0.7676573395729065,
-0.4932818114757538,
-0.520107090473175,
0.884181022644043,
0.02530387043952942,
0.4598122537136078,
-0.21469056606292725,
-0.20023919641971588,
0.09010999649763107,
-0.14092138409614563,
-0.5725034475326538,
-0.06268727034330368,
-0.2975107729434967,
-0.5056167840957642,
-0.06984222680330276,
-0.43296533823013306,
-0.5306164622306824,
-0.1552470475435257,
0.36741843819618225,
-0.34339454770088196,
0.6427425146102905,
0.2086072564125061,
-0.017364686354994774,
-0.37437522411346436,
0.28661012649536133,
0.432832807302475,
-0.10405245423316956,
-0.2541597783565521,
-0.06209275871515274,
0.09457103163003922,
-0.09171142429113388,
0.0857435017824173,
-0.06299273669719696,
0.39118456840515137,
-0.23604591190814972,
0.3328196406364441,
0.8148708939552307,
0.49242308735847473,
-0.57370924949646,
0.6146863698959351,
-0.2756974995136261,
-0.1656092405319214,
0.1220911517739296,
0.1172199547290802,
0.055874329060316086,
0.6632531881332397,
0.046626098453998566,
-0.25386959314346313,
0.2435322403907776,
-0.5740856528282166,
0.047895126044750214,
0.18447662889957428,
-0.44414469599723816,
-0.3775719702243805,
0.41440385580062866,
0.7073607444763184,
-0.10908057540655136,
0.528228759765625,
0.18393589556217194,
-0.8832208514213562,
0.7828589677810669,
0.8056842684745789,
1.1534544229507446,
-0.578131377696991,
0.03864709287881851,
0.6070582270622253,
-0.17085136473178864,
0.18421053886413574,
0.734114408493042,
-0.2995836138725281,
-0.7105149626731873,
0.23516042530536652,
-0.5392082929611206,
-0.7194274663925171,
-0.4026481807231903,
-1.2084051370620728,
0.0068300445564091206,
-0.4279765784740448,
-0.27449166774749756,
-0.5878880023956299,
0.029819225892424583,
-0.6877733469009399,
0.4771171510219574,
0.1658521592617035,
1.0334230661392212,
-1.1875678300857544,
0.6473293900489807,
0.709183394908905,
-0.4641386568546295,
-0.9518265724182129,
0.20651806890964508,
0.31533530354499817,
-0.7379984855651855,
0.5059161186218262,
0.3933454751968384,
-0.2385653853416443,
0.029407566413283348,
-0.370476096868515,
-0.3850753605365753,
1.1554902791976929,
0.017020156607031822,
-0.32934850454330444,
0.2276957780122757,
-0.1978640854358673,
0.630799412727356,
-0.8483802080154419,
0.4974706470966339,
0.6088036894798279,
0.43540719151496887,
0.2324480563402176,
-0.6707613468170166,
0.3990671634674072,
-0.31234854459762573,
0.22010104358196259,
0.13548029959201813,
-0.8713923692703247,
0.8761813640594482,
-0.28605854511260986,
-0.1453268676996231,
0.4182164669036865,
0.45449891686439514,
0.4079143702983856,
0.2942228317260742,
0.41658350825309753,
0.7110505700111389,
0.2707935571670532,
-0.37109994888305664,
0.8152437210083008,
-0.4894105792045593,
0.4180900454521179,
0.9479714035987854,
-0.5181600451469421,
0.7421408891677856,
0.545871376991272,
0.12140960991382599,
0.43503713607788086,
0.8138124346733093,
0.08817789703607559,
0.47724974155426025,
-0.1614508181810379,
-0.64951092004776,
-0.42308616638183594,
-0.40820035338401794,
-0.3817905783653259,
0.8030232787132263,
0.34920167922973633,
-0.7238675951957703,
-0.20410504937171936,
-0.035419803112745285,
-0.03747835382819176,
-0.03725685551762581,
-0.30928927659988403,
0.7627376914024353,
0.30548787117004395,
-0.4756608307361603,
0.05000884830951691,
-0.26446664333343506,
0.502475380897522,
-0.6268045902252197,
-0.31747403740882874,
-0.5974047183990479,
-0.0004338826984167099,
-0.05951113626360893,
-0.8232681155204773,
0.1914304494857788,
0.16133730113506317,
-0.18754400312900543,
-0.1756441742181778,
0.5739773511886597,
-0.5368747711181641,
-0.07020165771245956,
0.7865601778030396,
0.4305856227874756,
-0.05735122412443161,
0.28424665331840515,
-0.5942413806915283,
0.17371222376823425,
-0.10608792304992676,
-0.5314165353775024,
0.36550459265708923,
0.4297196567058563,
0.40607884526252747,
0.621360719203949,
0.319196492433548,
-0.29522818326950073,
-0.385921448469162,
0.18287020921707153,
1.0885624885559082,
-0.9638867378234863,
-0.6907145380973816,
-0.7066406607627869,
0.6642723083496094,
0.01363261230289936,
-0.21476562321186066,
0.24937033653259277,
-0.05731339752674103,
0.4810722768306732,
-0.2254888117313385,
0.8793312311172485,
-0.456369012594223,
0.3344882130622864,
-0.5216764807701111,
0.4928683340549469,
-0.9792752861976624,
-0.23624037206172943,
-0.3492322266101837,
-0.7997069358825684,
-0.020454321056604385,
0.42426353693008423,
-0.0020467834547162056,
0.40059617161750793,
1.0698373317718506,
0.9124210476875305,
0.24547860026359558,
0.3238433599472046,
0.688119649887085,
0.27215439081192017,
0.1446262001991272,
1.2317355871200562,
0.8703523874282837,
-0.08057375997304916,
0.33039578795433044,
-0.06982521712779999,
-0.20661060512065887,
-0.41248783469200134,
-1.0087724924087524,
-0.7491572499275208,
-0.5504188537597656,
0.061012864112854004,
-0.501268208026886,
-0.10217072814702988,
1.2100753784179688,
0.3913745880126953,
-0.6930115818977356,
-0.07463648915290833,
0.2942710518836975,
-0.10092714428901672,
-0.24382413923740387,
-0.2653842270374298,
-0.044635944068431854,
-0.2882719933986664,
-0.9927517175674438,
0.12813061475753784,
0.5980096459388733,
0.07151470333337784,
-0.09069588035345078,
-0.5108636021614075,
0.26474037766456604,
0.22149761021137238,
0.5932986736297607,
0.2751995325088501,
-0.7520828247070312,
-0.2781962454319,
-0.2639073431491852,
-0.35183581709861755,
-0.02070111408829689,
1.1337436437606812,
-0.33175450563430786,
0.6790372133255005,
0.42789968848228455,
0.5339054465293884,
0.02887779287993908,
0.04361677169799805,
1.0480901002883911,
-0.37522611021995544,
0.010077378712594509,
0.25348952412605286,
0.7178332805633545,
0.10070264339447021,
-0.38969358801841736,
0.2876088619232178,
0.1466260701417923,
-0.379795640707016,
-0.5204432606697083,
0.6513476371765137,
-1.4372327327728271,
0.027553897351026535,
0.9862896800041199,
-0.5960463285446167,
-0.037305451929569244,
0.2800489366054535,
-0.32422885298728943,
0.6608054637908936,
-0.5695913434028625,
0.8009446263313293,
0.4278765022754669,
-0.45400723814964294,
-0.3790246546268463,
0.382469117641449,
0.160854771733284,
0.5100528001785278,
-0.9309781193733215,
-0.08965867012739182,
0.71527498960495,
0.10143779963254929,
-0.27811798453330994,
0.30698490142822266,
0.04868055880069733,
0.4619840085506439,
0.24029171466827393,
0.3066873252391815,
0.03508975729346275,
0.020261717960238457,
-0.6134399771690369,
-0.00021097587887197733,
-0.29650554060935974,
-0.08484292775392532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15097v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15097v2
|
Argument-Aware Approach To Event Linking
| 2024-03-22T10:32:43 | 2024-06-06T05:18:25 |
I-Hung Hsu, Zihan Xue, Nilay Pochh, Sahil Bansal, Premkumar Natarajan, Jayanth Srinivasa, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event linking connects event mentions in text with relevant nodes in a
knowledge base (KB). Prior research in event linking has mainly borrowed
methods from entity linking, overlooking the distinct features of events.
Compared to the extensively explored entity linking task, events have more
complex structures and can be more effectively distinguished by examining their
associated arguments. Moreover, the information-rich nature of events leads to
the scarcity of event KBs. This emphasizes the need for event linking models to
identify and classify event mentions not in the KB as ``out-of-KB,'' an area
that has received limited attention. In this work, we tackle these challenges
by introducing an argument-aware approach. First, we improve event linking
models by augmenting input text with tagged event argument information,
facilitating the recognition of key information about event mentions.
Subsequently, to help the model handle ``out-of-KB'' scenarios, we synthesize
out-of-KB training examples from in-KB instances through controlled
manipulation of event arguments. Our experiment across two test datasets showed
significant enhancements in both in-KB and out-of-KB scenarios, with a notable
22% improvement in out-of-KB evaluations.
|
[
-0.47302815318107605,
-0.6176003217697144,
0.6683223247528076,
-0.4298620820045471,
-0.49254539608955383,
-0.0112995570525527,
-0.1760299652814865,
-0.762751042842865,
0.04673305153846741,
0.041250087320804596,
-0.5173245668411255,
-0.20369568467140198,
-0.15641623735427856,
-0.11646102368831635,
-0.20429641008377075,
1.2545433044433594,
-0.14550039172172546,
-0.101166270673275,
-0.8549374341964722,
-0.1955254077911377,
-0.28588876128196716,
-0.5211579203605652,
-0.8864980340003967,
-0.38682976365089417,
0.510591447353363,
0.5144098997116089,
0.5123757123947144,
0.7445015907287598,
0.431384414434433,
0.08149067312479019,
-0.10387406498193741,
0.20508736371994019,
-0.2719096839427948,
0.038839951157569885,
-0.44918644428253174,
-0.19736303389072418,
-0.4190545380115509,
-0.1404198855161667,
0.5554239749908447,
0.5328544974327087,
0.2335539162158966,
0.07169722020626068,
-0.10497300326824188,
0.6718411445617676,
-0.7651078104972839,
0.10460664331912994,
-0.9156249165534973,
-0.09048309922218323,
-0.6387554407119751,
-0.32926151156425476,
-0.6012023687362671,
-0.05820881947875023,
0.29838258028030396,
-0.6856631636619568,
0.25220373272895813,
0.10838834196329117,
0.7704874277114868,
-0.04603677615523338,
-0.4163700342178345,
-0.4222007989883423,
-0.4393996596336365,
0.186136856675148,
-0.6276809573173523,
0.5838318467140198,
0.2874049246311188,
0.046695515513420105,
-0.5237331390380859,
-0.6372995972633362,
-0.6287356019020081,
-0.18233729898929596,
0.030426476150751114,
0.2108418196439743,
-0.3697795271873474,
0.230251744389534,
0.43219316005706787,
-0.23264262080192566,
-0.33761653304100037,
-0.05877654626965523,
-0.09670254588127136,
0.16350308060646057,
0.7005694508552551,
0.02350076101720333,
0.11996987462043762,
-0.2640804648399353,
-0.3440452218055725,
0.2853108048439026,
-0.9512590765953064,
-0.002020241692662239,
0.5918341875076294,
0.17478340864181519,
0.09631068259477615,
0.4493531286716461,
-0.18153171241283417,
0.7343149781227112,
0.5143340229988098,
-0.021056102588772774,
-0.1977645605802536,
-0.5313788056373596,
-0.10271036624908447,
0.4803942143917084,
0.4999873638153076,
0.40287455916404724,
0.10857237130403519,
-0.46752694249153137,
0.4348856806755066,
-0.2245897501707077,
0.08421728014945984,
-0.8489620685577393,
-0.5385047197341919,
0.16195625066757202,
-0.6053701043128967,
-0.10196598619222641,
-0.2138335108757019,
-0.7939213514328003,
-0.8967957496643066,
0.05536503717303276,
0.6770445108413696,
-0.43977048993110657,
-0.2624930143356323,
-0.19705450534820557,
-0.30116257071495056,
-0.21656762063503265,
0.3380577862262726,
-0.6375169157981873,
0.10800498723983765,
0.48856300115585327,
0.45634859800338745,
-0.07625064253807068,
0.10230442881584167,
-0.5892055034637451,
0.6713405251502991,
-0.1092853844165802,
1.1953409910202026,
-0.9224536418914795,
-0.26450225710868835,
-0.060486964881420135,
-0.302808552980423,
-0.07080966979265213,
-0.7015595436096191,
0.7000970244407654,
-0.8392776250839233,
0.06833215057849884,
-0.44821697473526,
-1.2655819654464722,
-0.3461456298828125,
0.009245157241821289,
-0.5494887232780457,
0.9220628142356873,
-0.21565966308116913,
-0.8442270755767822,
0.8866318464279175,
-0.8956801295280457,
-0.5253116488456726,
0.25023919343948364,
-0.11976110935211182,
-0.4483642280101776,
0.0456465408205986,
0.001873645931482315,
0.4311560392379761,
-0.13179761171340942,
0.22895972430706024,
-0.664747416973114,
0.10620870441198349,
0.09355543553829193,
0.048514723777770996,
0.29453372955322266,
-0.0696478858590126,
-0.2904318571090698,
0.11721660196781158,
-0.9648584127426147,
-0.2946174442768097,
0.021701037883758545,
-0.43145763874053955,
-0.6678236126899719,
0.45006459951400757,
-0.45419251918792725,
0.2934303879737854,
0.026400379836559296,
-0.5352401733398438,
0.34704747796058655,
-0.6463402509689331,
0.09251661598682404,
0.3318885266780853,
0.3835097551345825,
0.6706096529960632,
-0.00865653995424509,
0.2337970733642578,
0.49462777376174927,
0.17752738296985626,
-0.2613355219364166,
-0.8116905093193054,
-0.750808596611023,
-0.02858778089284897,
0.21560804545879364,
0.22465358674526215,
-0.7850018739700317,
0.3714275360107422,
0.07428983598947525,
-0.6079931259155273,
-0.15637721121311188,
-0.08394496887922287,
0.15878993272781372,
1.0612292289733887,
0.4681476354598999,
-0.010131352581083775,
-0.9095984697341919,
-0.49884307384490967,
-0.5882192850112915,
-0.8887505531311035,
0.3740765452384949,
0.32396820187568665,
0.6119641065597534,
0.1395321637392044,
1.0140000581741333,
-0.13140608370304108,
-0.04957170784473419,
-0.32469305396080017,
0.1026524156332016,
-0.2030755877494812,
0.28434452414512634,
0.40929675102233887,
-0.5291038751602173,
-0.5395273566246033,
0.32548630237579346,
-0.6281729340553284,
0.014433667063713074,
-0.41787686944007874,
-0.20964917540550232,
0.3278847336769104,
0.5829130411148071,
-0.5755707621574402,
0.6818941235542297,
-0.127803772687912,
-0.5365496873855591,
0.4616469144821167,
0.09742030501365662,
-0.013324892148375511,
-1.1635735034942627,
-0.18050383031368256,
-0.15824809670448303,
-0.1252664029598236,
-0.7326319217681885,
-0.36018478870391846,
0.08547942340373993,
-0.0479506179690361,
-0.22886545956134796,
0.6295789480209351,
-0.30610135197639465,
0.08064868301153183,
-0.22346433997154236,
0.2018752098083496,
0.17311818897724152,
0.22738346457481384,
0.332611083984375,
0.2300131469964981,
0.4723636507987976,
-0.5503581762313843,
0.5401303172111511,
0.29137980937957764,
-0.2926195561885834,
0.6483080983161926,
-0.17684070765972137,
0.06788454204797745,
-0.0804358422756195,
0.3524896502494812,
-0.9666797518730164,
-0.1846356987953186,
0.45957961678504944,
-0.39889147877693176,
0.3744995594024658,
-0.6629568934440613,
-0.4902796149253845,
0.06185983493924141,
-0.19361771643161774,
0.43757978081703186,
0.061041105538606644,
-0.8505605459213257,
0.9480822086334229,
0.4899618625640869,
-0.038834985345602036,
-0.2217283844947815,
-0.10495354235172272,
0.2334950566291809,
-0.6563273072242737,
-0.6018099188804626,
0.32026609778404236,
-0.13826726377010345,
-0.1812618374824524,
0.24188706278800964,
-0.06251177936792374,
-0.15557515621185303,
-0.08009956777095795,
0.31436753273010254,
0.1403612494468689,
-0.30738237500190735,
0.6989660859107971,
-0.011826138012111187,
-0.04806964471936226,
0.19906608760356903,
-0.48114946484565735,
0.02858172543346882,
0.06129450350999832,
-0.5379981994628906,
-0.510874330997467,
0.678071916103363,
0.11278732120990753,
-0.04731305316090584,
0.8183239698410034,
0.5265712141990662,
-0.5976829528808594,
0.14705850183963776,
-0.7420961260795593,
-0.22130584716796875,
-0.3884081244468689,
0.5442163944244385,
-0.2714601159095764,
-0.5866904854774475,
0.4253067076206207,
-0.49017906188964844,
-0.004653689917176962,
0.45171061158180237,
0.4380542039871216,
-0.43740448355674744,
0.9483057856559753,
0.44019708037376404,
0.22897198796272278,
0.6377934813499451,
0.2233743667602539,
0.46001580357551575,
-0.857507050037384,
-0.31816574931144714,
-0.47409892082214355,
-0.2198719084262848,
-0.16131117939949036,
-0.3929955065250397,
0.2100614309310913,
0.6061895489692688,
-0.1615738719701767,
0.5121495723724365,
-0.07543211430311203,
0.5344492793083191,
0.27702921628952026,
-0.1929931938648224,
0.32845115661621094,
-0.19066762924194336,
-0.2256837636232376,
-0.10996061563491821,
-1.3404974937438965,
-0.3247345983982086,
0.9182178378105164,
0.2681501805782318,
0.3609107434749603,
-0.048381056636571884,
0.9281930327415466,
0.11431780457496643,
0.43009111285209656,
-0.7175710797309875,
0.5846384763717651,
0.3519912362098694,
-0.8972285389900208,
-0.06591200083494186,
-0.23980508744716644,
-0.7406428456306458,
-0.16478557884693146,
-0.44794976711273193,
-1.0011940002441406,
0.5154188275337219,
0.20596210658550262,
-0.47261178493499756,
0.7586634159088135,
-0.922527551651001,
1.0228748321533203,
0.13759000599384308,
-0.24182933568954468,
-0.26433897018432617,
-0.5000993609428406,
0.03492032736539841,
-0.06449081748723984,
0.143251433968544,
-0.0007012425339780748,
0.17895831167697906,
1.1773524284362793,
-0.1655697077512741,
0.6300802230834961,
-0.13046325743198395,
0.09039801359176636,
0.6734707355499268,
0.12594784796237946,
0.8816653490066528,
0.27875813841819763,
-0.09688021242618561,
-0.07669174671173096,
-0.08844427764415741,
0.05057242140173912,
-0.7154117822647095,
0.5388970375061035,
-0.4369879961013794,
-0.4498915374279022,
-0.013573383912444115,
-0.49001964926719666,
-0.5333292484283447,
-0.08284469693899155,
0.23730289936065674,
0.6887782216072083,
-0.017984896898269653,
0.1619311273097992,
0.9163886904716492,
-0.015702273696660995,
0.707463800907135,
0.554695188999176,
0.3223363161087036,
-0.3391056954860687,
0.7108368277549744,
0.12876172363758087,
0.05601588636636734,
0.5164029002189636,
0.30317533016204834,
-0.7214967012405396,
-0.6168010234832764,
-0.6431000232696533,
-0.09275384992361069,
-1.2001163959503174,
-0.41489332914352417,
-1.0151973962783813,
0.19407661259174347,
-0.2901850640773773,
-0.41550981998443604,
-0.4189757704734802,
-0.5197994112968445,
-0.33524978160858154,
-0.256477028131485,
0.6085999011993408,
0.4808955192565918,
-0.14844700694084167,
0.14098674058914185,
-0.7560486197471619,
0.048563044518232346,
0.045448482036590576,
0.6005724668502808,
0.3221275508403778,
-0.27179139852523804,
-0.5082349181175232,
-0.4636630415916443,
-0.27482062578201294,
-1.426873803138733,
-0.24237586557865143,
0.4708741307258606,
0.8023510575294495,
0.8138097524642944,
0.4293772280216217,
0.9618499875068665,
-0.47223207354545593,
0.6895087957382202,
0.3095785677433014,
-0.8696047067642212,
0.8923779726028442,
-0.21890395879745483,
-0.23108667135238647,
0.4346088469028473,
0.5160471796989441,
-0.2218482345342636,
-0.2889759838581085,
-1.054773211479187,
-0.9520453810691833,
0.6184915900230408,
0.15353183448314667,
-0.36712321639060974,
-0.3720940351486206,
0.4835141599178314,
0.07225857675075531,
0.0626218318939209,
-0.8504871129989624,
-0.10291685909032822,
0.19279412925243378,
-0.11356338858604431,
0.3481760025024414,
-0.4038521945476532,
-0.1930604726076126,
-0.30593669414520264,
0.9610192775726318,
0.011154507286846638,
0.06916903704404831,
0.20599761605262756,
-0.16094504296779633,
-0.30519768595695496,
0.2481253743171692,
0.35678860545158386,
0.6845002770423889,
-0.044598594307899475,
0.12617804110050201,
0.6051250100135803,
-0.2138802409172058,
-0.036350883543491364,
0.18417085707187653,
-0.006846418604254723,
0.18461112678050995,
0.38332411646842957,
0.7482385039329529,
0.21675176918506622,
-0.41921907663345337,
0.2232833355665207,
0.050559885799884796,
0.05642276257276535,
0.07798710465431213,
-0.15599074959754944,
0.5227066874504089,
0.6068710088729858,
0.014728367328643799,
-0.00725398538634181,
0.20577378571033478,
-0.44786855578422546,
0.30915072560310364,
0.4324665367603302,
-0.6138283014297485,
-0.1843821406364441,
0.7032777667045593,
0.5610082745552063,
-0.06920473277568817,
0.12074490636587143,
-0.3545457124710083,
-0.30580395460128784,
0.4289417564868927,
0.628063440322876,
0.750625491142273,
0.25058630108833313,
-0.05639136582612991,
0.498941570520401,
0.24364803731441498,
0.5499770641326904,
0.21301192045211792,
-0.24022717773914337,
-0.570463240146637,
-0.3328191637992859,
-0.3907371461391449,
-0.37515437602996826,
0.1026618704199791,
-0.5177637338638306,
0.2929081320762634,
-0.11856089532375336,
-0.20346415042877197,
0.23583687841892242,
0.1812492161989212,
-0.39103201031684875,
0.07260575145483017,
0.23696380853652954,
1.1604238748550415,
-0.7269036173820496,
0.7423061728477478,
1.2079880237579346,
-0.45652535557746887,
-0.5942901372909546,
-0.08801669627428055,
-0.21027515828609467,
-0.05158049613237381,
0.5040087699890137,
-0.24963964521884918,
-0.08925388753414154,
0.03859146311879158,
-0.15603910386562347,
-0.629691481590271,
0.6620990037918091,
0.2917770743370056,
-0.2588955760002136,
0.3515157997608185,
0.056735217571258545,
0.2653869092464447,
-0.5296202301979065,
0.21407562494277954,
0.27013102173805237,
0.48463889956474304,
0.1392332762479782,
-0.6190869808197021,
0.14974969625473022,
0.05496320500969887,
-0.26021862030029297,
0.4089565575122833,
-0.236387237906456,
0.24658459424972534,
-0.35758906602859497,
-0.1585349440574646,
-0.21134306490421295,
1.0035117864608765,
0.1796862930059433,
0.7009657621383667,
0.49332553148269653,
0.572379469871521,
0.7975303530693054,
-0.02027651108801365,
0.5971827507019043,
-0.07145574688911438,
0.14018845558166504,
1.337935209274292,
-0.51352858543396,
0.8741322755813599,
0.4851541817188263,
0.1507488489151001,
0.5485081076622009,
0.7709357738494873,
0.29202473163604736,
0.4907538890838623,
-0.054465893656015396,
-0.6186177730560303,
-0.7406305074691772,
-0.34016379714012146,
-0.4251389503479004,
0.2586747109889984,
0.40387940406799316,
-0.17512857913970947,
-0.6642152070999146,
-0.17649264633655548,
0.2679612338542938,
-0.12633247673511505,
-0.5321583151817322,
1.14899742603302,
-0.14615997672080994,
-0.6404274702072144,
0.04391101002693176,
-0.12770076096057892,
0.21258051693439484,
-0.6706900596618652,
-0.16974285244941711,
0.015910886228084564,
0.1540762335062027,
-0.2219007909297943,
-0.7785732746124268,
0.46825000643730164,
0.21751387417316437,
-0.44253116846084595,
0.17350918054580688,
1.3192338943481445,
-0.4205430746078491,
-0.07200665771961212,
0.24006597697734833,
0.4291274845600128,
0.08483485132455826,
-0.04723875969648361,
-0.4358541965484619,
-0.18752676248550415,
-0.31869977712631226,
-0.33269602060317993,
0.6653456091880798,
0.6083375215530396,
-0.32064288854599,
0.48055893182754517,
0.6883411407470703,
-0.1368783414363861,
0.04738703370094299,
-0.015049660578370094,
0.952233612537384,
-0.5820010900497437,
-0.6245024800300598,
-1.0866378545761108,
0.5142606496810913,
-0.2885585427284241,
-0.3398301303386688,
0.6095417141914368,
0.6512884497642517,
0.8714731335639954,
0.009473077952861786,
0.701698899269104,
-0.0696982592344284,
0.2062177062034607,
-0.24144084751605988,
0.5762407183647156,
-0.49914872646331787,
-0.13202953338623047,
-0.4319620132446289,
-0.39837759733200073,
-0.0984233170747757,
0.38585740327835083,
-0.171041339635849,
-0.11235889792442322,
0.6053188443183899,
0.4936636686325073,
0.08763781934976578,
0.320516973733902,
0.25212764739990234,
-0.11533783376216888,
0.33668214082717896,
0.6893103718757629,
1.1366453170776367,
-0.27390387654304504,
0.7048981189727783,
-0.06014615297317505,
-0.1739145964384079,
-0.32019516825675964,
-1.5990537405014038,
-1.067537546157837,
-0.8384090662002563,
-0.9548208117485046,
-0.36789676547050476,
0.281507670879364,
0.9621729254722595,
0.8245158195495605,
-0.875399112701416,
-0.06860727816820145,
0.04124803841114044,
0.35607296228408813,
-0.16526482999324799,
-0.14975138008594513,
0.3873358964920044,
-0.32520535588264465,
-0.063121497631073,
0.5731533169746399,
0.6246650218963623,
-0.13682028651237488,
0.370255708694458,
0.19930364191532135,
-0.5738477110862732,
0.3763187527656555,
0.6496995091438293,
0.3503555357456207,
-0.4418709874153137,
-0.5149169564247131,
-0.4921448528766632,
0.38104772567749023,
-0.10678108781576157,
0.6937530040740967,
-0.9561030864715576,
0.6215516328811646,
0.5915206074714661,
0.7374194264411926,
0.20202358067035675,
-0.1581401526927948,
0.33634570240974426,
-1.0075048208236694,
-0.029214179143309593,
0.12970329821109772,
0.504091739654541,
0.12912817299365997,
-0.5892490744590759,
0.2989848554134369,
0.46967270970344543,
-0.32281026244163513,
-0.7562000155448914,
0.4352385401725769,
-1.084484577178955,
-0.021071502938866615,
1.2070077657699585,
-0.2963201403617859,
-0.03388701006770134,
-0.5664128661155701,
-0.07114361971616745,
0.5227035880088806,
-0.22136005759239197,
0.839760422706604,
0.9606485366821289,
-0.6389583945274353,
0.023595478385686874,
-0.37587031722068787,
0.9282155632972717,
0.04130434989929199,
-0.9729757905006409,
0.38108575344085693,
0.3487665355205536,
0.03799327835440636,
0.2237105369567871,
0.608444333076477,
-0.06038414686918259,
0.420484721660614,
-0.05166509747505188,
0.06399735808372498,
-0.17515772581100464,
-0.4679509997367859,
0.025720400735735893,
0.2357061803340912,
0.008184019476175308,
-0.21258623898029327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15088v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15088v2
|
CHisIEC: An Information Extraction Corpus for Ancient Chinese History
| 2024-03-22T10:12:10 | 2024-04-20T08:46:12 |
Xuemei Tang, Zekun Deng, Qi Su, Hao Yang, Jun Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Processing (NLP) plays a pivotal role in the realm of
Digital Humanities (DH) and serves as the cornerstone for advancing the
structural analysis of historical and cultural heritage texts. This is
particularly true for the domains of named entity recognition (NER) and
relation extraction (RE). In our commitment to expediting ancient history and
culture, we present the ``Chinese Historical Information Extraction
Corpus''(CHisIEC). CHisIEC is a meticulously curated dataset designed to
develop and evaluate NER and RE tasks, offering a resource to facilitate
research in the field. Spanning a remarkable historical timeline encompassing
data from 13 dynasties spanning over 1830 years, CHisIEC epitomizes the
extensive temporal range and text heterogeneity inherent in Chinese historical
documents. The dataset encompasses four distinct entity types and twelve
relation types, resulting in a meticulously labeled dataset comprising 14,194
entities and 8,609 relations. To establish the robustness and versatility of
our dataset, we have undertaken comprehensive experimentation involving models
of various sizes and paradigms. Additionally, we have evaluated the
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the context of tasks related to
ancient Chinese history. The dataset and code are available at
\url{https://github.com/tangxuemei1995/CHisIEC}.
|
[
-0.2944399118423462,
-0.894893229007721,
0.2714745104312897,
0.18122142553329468,
-0.11449167877435684,
-0.08770214021205902,
-0.356480211019516,
-0.6524510383605957,
0.24563677608966827,
0.41734936833381653,
-0.3892780542373657,
-0.5054460763931274,
-0.31812483072280884,
0.29744312167167664,
-0.5167283415794373,
0.9972842335700989,
0.16075611114501953,
-0.025869058445096016,
0.1718236654996872,
-0.16036178171634674,
-0.1710813343524933,
-0.39983004331588745,
-0.7480649948120117,
-0.12744206190109253,
0.36278390884399414,
0.13046634197235107,
0.9823768734931946,
1.1508430242538452,
0.5131309032440186,
0.20610415935516357,
-0.09317646920681,
0.40554654598236084,
-0.24004438519477844,
0.09991690516471863,
-0.2661236822605133,
-0.42096081376075745,
-0.7440689206123352,
0.08717283606529236,
0.7979651093482971,
0.6471413373947144,
0.0639340728521347,
0.15843328833580017,
0.22248300909996033,
0.4183470904827118,
-0.5970550775527954,
0.4872671961784363,
-0.4697772264480591,
-0.038958124816417694,
-0.5678880214691162,
-0.7185654640197754,
-0.2836310863494873,
-0.5592633485794067,
0.07398892939090729,
-0.6903505921363831,
0.2716180682182312,
-0.02563713677227497,
1.0330954790115356,
0.008046621456742287,
-0.21957486867904663,
-0.09100601822137833,
-0.8135969638824463,
0.9076583385467529,
-0.648507297039032,
0.3957592248916626,
0.8642427325248718,
0.2582678198814392,
-0.22996045649051666,
-1.1510460376739502,
-0.36518484354019165,
-0.1606096774339676,
0.04938806965947151,
-0.001214065938256681,
0.017430443316698074,
-0.4036726951599121,
0.40598422288894653,
0.653822660446167,
-0.6548306941986084,
0.02108808234333992,
-0.371982604265213,
-0.5157071352005005,
0.6260467767715454,
0.4295662045478821,
0.9094610214233398,
-0.29358208179473877,
-0.22787059843540192,
0.11332575231790543,
-0.8454645872116089,
-0.007558219134807587,
-0.06550902128219604,
0.3302425146102905,
-0.32996028661727905,
0.4210183322429657,
-0.2089432328939438,
0.551514208316803,
-0.007889896631240845,
-0.27341386675834656,
-0.17896506190299988,
-0.6329799294471741,
-0.00751763628795743,
0.15216992795467377,
1.0767804384231567,
0.035011548548936844,
0.36957988142967224,
-0.3322228789329529,
-0.01051442138850689,
0.007026952691376209,
0.24724657833576202,
-0.7536335587501526,
-0.6995993852615356,
0.007989875040948391,
-0.7291839718818665,
-0.2397681027650833,
0.3653683662414551,
-0.9201757907867432,
-0.4072018265724182,
-0.1062922477722168,
-0.3863013982772827,
-0.6987062096595764,
-0.2426094263792038,
-0.48559245467185974,
-0.1494848132133484,
0.602805495262146,
0.4673817455768585,
-0.9758886694908142,
0.2515611946582794,
0.8361146450042725,
1.071935772895813,
-0.21740573644638062,
-0.3839204013347626,
-0.7273401618003845,
0.08085746318101883,
-0.6749838590621948,
0.6161451935768127,
-0.7419254779815674,
-0.31139668822288513,
-0.09863290190696716,
0.4234345853328705,
0.3952614367008209,
-0.39073577523231506,
0.8458709716796875,
-0.6028296947479248,
0.2653241753578186,
-0.23876254260540009,
-0.37964826822280884,
-0.16841110587120056,
0.10075053572654724,
-1.1616498231887817,
0.929416835308075,
0.2892818748950958,
-1.088407039642334,
0.19306634366512299,
-0.06748055666685104,
-0.5591344833374023,
0.6375983953475952,
-0.5910426378250122,
-0.1048230230808258,
-0.330351859331131,
0.4227486252784729,
0.291873961687088,
-0.7874032855033875,
0.18021918833255768,
-0.48632705211639404,
-0.4156593680381775,
0.1407974660396576,
-0.407703697681427,
1.2954814434051514,
0.29830658435821533,
-0.4796077311038971,
0.00955919735133648,
-0.6636104583740234,
-0.1933996081352234,
0.2292439043521881,
-0.39089667797088623,
-0.7275069952011108,
0.06747990101575851,
0.28396061062812805,
0.13845880329608917,
0.33534902334213257,
-0.4059802293777466,
0.37630602717399597,
-0.5743041634559631,
0.5694994926452637,
0.5492884516716003,
-0.0662531852722168,
0.4315685033798218,
-0.27404698729515076,
0.3181271553039551,
-0.4109567105770111,
-0.06369766592979431,
-0.1477859616279602,
-0.3769409954547882,
-0.4358903765678406,
-0.2210453450679779,
0.5846574306488037,
0.4690260887145996,
-0.9902004599571228,
0.4204244017601013,
-0.5443329215049744,
-0.5050446391105652,
-0.4212515354156494,
0.02207174338400364,
-0.16691327095031738,
0.24400706589221954,
0.40288734436035156,
-0.32817596197128296,
-0.505119800567627,
-0.60661381483078,
0.05648896098136902,
-0.5803753733634949,
-0.17898038029670715,
0.009665426798164845,
0.13593560457229614,
-0.13701680302619934,
1.0767329931259155,
-0.055698368698358536,
-0.1078525260090828,
-0.3470000624656677,
0.17027291655540466,
0.023007074370980263,
0.3097086250782013,
0.6598809361457825,
-0.9853092432022095,
-0.18739165365695953,
0.4636106789112091,
-0.8210850358009338,
-0.04060295224189758,
-0.4827249348163605,
-0.387921541929245,
0.38731294870376587,
0.3070056438446045,
-0.21253640949726105,
0.7447324395179749,
0.275978684425354,
-0.10980075597763062,
0.8232747316360474,
0.20179414749145508,
0.41672390699386597,
-1.1740087270736694,
0.3587043285369873,
-0.1298498660326004,
-0.1870245635509491,
-0.38722050189971924,
0.04490368813276291,
0.43030408024787903,
0.07439814507961273,
-0.3135383725166321,
0.6132501363754272,
-0.6616820096969604,
0.22916635870933533,
-0.38380885124206543,
0.3432604968547821,
-0.2331489771604538,
0.23971159756183624,
0.572735607624054,
0.5643813014030457,
0.3772229552268982,
-0.8117047548294067,
0.5674733519554138,
0.3265087306499481,
-0.14107276499271393,
0.37550339102745056,
-0.3902961015701294,
0.09933453798294067,
0.380576491355896,
-0.06258314847946167,
-0.2911771535873413,
-0.3169254660606384,
0.4973926544189453,
-0.6615479588508606,
0.3416086435317993,
-0.03366541117429733,
-0.4548916816711426,
0.08199518173933029,
-0.5438420176506042,
0.46217629313468933,
-0.0195538979023695,
-0.6066117286682129,
0.7165200114250183,
0.46006980538368225,
-0.4713989794254303,
-0.8093289136886597,
-0.6774922609329224,
0.22879089415073395,
-0.29439103603363037,
-0.5637481808662415,
0.33007654547691345,
0.054201390594244,
-0.3502700626850128,
0.10790522396564484,
-0.18208664655685425,
-0.4503757357597351,
0.11692134290933609,
0.19263900816440582,
0.9363350868225098,
-0.5370224714279175,
0.02495824359357357,
-0.03631974011659622,
-0.03499971702694893,
0.07117319852113724,
0.0063127814792096615,
0.7639169096946716,
-0.017118040472269058,
0.035346053540706635,
-0.5475019216537476,
0.04171479493379593,
0.3392665386199951,
-0.23110422492027283,
0.8131451606750488,
0.5166397094726562,
-0.7549391388893127,
-0.13885660469532013,
-0.43133479356765747,
-0.20048342645168304,
-0.3446614146232605,
0.32829514145851135,
-0.22272637486457825,
-0.7321409583091736,
0.400069922208786,
0.16311033070087433,
0.4785254895687103,
0.8571988344192505,
0.54899001121521,
0.34712284803390503,
0.327934592962265,
0.5732335448265076,
-0.8916556239128113,
0.35129812359809875,
0.13190914690494537,
0.06837442517280579,
-0.6348411440849304,
0.0028431336395442486,
-0.6055514812469482,
0.10936474800109863,
-0.8025001883506775,
-0.24244175851345062,
-0.15481150150299072,
0.1353747397661209,
-0.11447535455226898,
0.6635771989822388,
-0.06758225709199905,
0.021548312157392502,
0.3280644714832306,
-0.10266287624835968,
0.533095121383667,
-0.10501939803361893,
0.3162936568260193,
-0.06282171607017517,
-0.4906448721885681,
-0.7970685362815857,
0.961524248123169,
0.2877568304538727,
0.9148373603820801,
0.030209390446543694,
0.6483094692230225,
0.30473044514656067,
0.07589887827634811,
-0.6931970715522766,
0.3459452688694,
-0.07432214170694351,
-0.5356413722038269,
-0.25244957208633423,
-0.6817528009414673,
-1.1440402269363403,
-0.259382039308548,
-0.44742411375045776,
-0.8669033646583557,
0.3811350166797638,
-0.08503390848636627,
-0.6477916836738586,
0.5527895092964172,
0.05902435630559921,
0.7068303823471069,
-0.3125151991844177,
-0.6074317693710327,
-0.09907768666744232,
-0.8201030492782593,
0.46730631589889526,
-0.04572935402393341,
0.14550235867500305,
0.2439495027065277,
0.006698595825582743,
0.6531479358673096,
-0.03915134817361832,
0.5113937258720398,
0.6121322512626648,
0.07903284579515457,
0.29532769322395325,
0.5639634728431702,
0.29466113448143005,
0.09138928353786469,
-0.15387818217277527,
0.32794225215911865,
0.5726373791694641,
-0.358376681804657,
-0.40985193848609924,
0.7577933073043823,
-0.642110288143158,
-0.06785865128040314,
-0.6274412274360657,
-0.36548855900764465,
0.41333988308906555,
0.20809195935726166,
0.3348828852176666,
0.6565975546836853,
-0.8088302612304688,
0.33398371934890747,
0.13528431951999664,
-0.4808962047100067,
0.5714708566665649,
0.121578149497509,
-0.2718702256679535,
-0.20813779532909393,
0.9230496883392334,
0.08652683347463608,
-0.06285185366868973,
0.5536609888076782,
-0.014700488187372684,
-0.11303196847438812,
-0.3356878161430359,
-0.4378921091556549,
0.3007248640060425,
-0.5926969647407532,
-0.028246603906154633,
-0.5902137756347656,
-0.6301493644714355,
-0.6672423481941223,
0.18765942752361298,
-0.33754944801330566,
-0.45947572588920593,
-0.5976576805114746,
0.05924849212169647,
-0.07838743180036545,
0.683493435382843,
-0.060676027089357376,
-0.03478477522730827,
-1.1623731851577759,
0.5153088569641113,
-0.11123357713222504,
-0.12363783270120621,
-0.135853573679924,
-0.2905494272708893,
-0.2233748733997345,
-0.18820352852344513,
-0.15069223940372467,
-1.177829384803772,
0.6964182257652283,
0.1229114755988121,
0.6125597357749939,
0.808714747428894,
0.41951659321784973,
0.5188212394714355,
-0.21903236210346222,
0.901035726070404,
-0.09836433827877045,
-0.5711522698402405,
0.38678738474845886,
-0.08829765766859055,
0.040240075439214706,
0.29176953434944153,
0.5295324325561523,
-0.8895465135574341,
-0.17410127818584442,
-0.6237896084785461,
-0.9802603721618652,
0.7871939539909363,
0.25160491466522217,
-0.4178655743598938,
-0.2544306814670563,
0.40273815393447876,
0.21577556431293488,
-0.17094305157661438,
-0.7141158580780029,
-0.3194776475429535,
-0.08378024399280548,
0.057133644819259644,
0.23606903851032257,
-0.27228695154190063,
0.17977797985076904,
0.03592513129115105,
0.7589582800865173,
0.07107243686914444,
0.0469718798995018,
0.21832385659217834,
-0.38499248027801514,
0.0324588380753994,
0.4355091154575348,
-0.10212475061416626,
0.8215165734291077,
-0.08868282288312912,
0.32124656438827515,
0.1845247745513916,
-0.607064425945282,
-0.6359994411468506,
0.36356884241104126,
-0.27444732189178467,
-0.1572689712047577,
0.891782820224762,
0.5305218696594238,
-0.13797518610954285,
-0.47646981477737427,
0.1294853836297989,
-0.354259729385376,
0.33360815048217773,
-0.6351277828216553,
-0.03968081623315811,
-0.04414384812116623,
0.2726719379425049,
0.38658738136291504,
-0.3437282145023346,
0.29918327927589417,
-0.7745206356048584,
0.41366973519325256,
0.2650144398212433,
-0.4666883647441864,
-0.2597410976886749,
0.6664623022079468,
0.02590031363070011,
-0.18353334069252014,
1.1389533281326294,
0.0058584935031831264,
-0.3667086064815521,
0.4179682433605194,
0.29617494344711304,
0.8315561413764954,
-0.28917384147644043,
0.2711164653301239,
0.8912532329559326,
0.5773853063583374,
0.01282215304672718,
-0.2621085047721863,
-0.23541776835918427,
-0.5778401494026184,
-0.3756149113178253,
-0.7815521359443665,
-0.061873964965343475,
0.14907144010066986,
-0.6971939206123352,
0.48431190848350525,
-0.507713258266449,
-0.16479292511940002,
-0.08526816219091415,
0.28298380970954895,
-0.5964433550834656,
0.011530195362865925,
0.3616028428077698,
0.8208910822868347,
-0.45736196637153625,
1.1466845273971558,
0.4052732288837433,
-0.5424922108650208,
-0.9659281969070435,
0.12383023649454117,
0.46487170457839966,
-0.4118395447731018,
0.6286767721176147,
-0.06999944895505905,
-0.21268148720264435,
-0.2980059087276459,
-0.505323588848114,
-0.4403333067893982,
1.0310603380203247,
0.12382975220680237,
-0.7539028525352478,
-0.23214901983737946,
-0.10071846842765808,
0.45456522703170776,
-0.3959771394729614,
0.4410111606121063,
0.9869573712348938,
0.4622538685798645,
-0.2617618143558502,
-0.8784800171852112,
0.26906394958496094,
-0.5561015009880066,
-0.2948512136936188,
0.04901620373129845,
-0.14287999272346497,
0.8057295680046082,
-0.07100442051887512,
-1.0597281455993652,
0.6251015067100525,
1.008718490600586,
0.10813603550195694,
0.2446427196264267,
0.37724143266677856,
0.035177916288375854,
0.8606428503990173,
-0.3265162408351898,
1.220027208328247,
-0.3351656496524811,
-0.014289416372776031,
1.2103538513183594,
0.05010242015123367,
0.6664112210273743,
0.30709779262542725,
-0.23588885366916656,
0.513821005821228,
1.0859805345535278,
0.06235859915614128,
0.0695464164018631,
-0.2986806631088257,
-0.10135066509246826,
-0.3168066740036011,
-0.30961933732032776,
-0.5007662177085876,
0.29537197947502136,
0.23581258952617645,
-0.3756549656391144,
-0.17580746114253998,
-0.8004221320152283,
0.26207733154296875,
0.0006460067816078663,
-0.34277352690696716,
0.7337521910667419,
0.16409216821193695,
-0.3609553277492523,
0.21720588207244873,
-0.043756645172834396,
0.6183581352233887,
-0.895426332950592,
-0.2871294915676117,
-0.19787150621414185,
-0.07083988189697266,
-0.36134570837020874,
-0.583717942237854,
0.18458421528339386,
-0.23280580341815948,
0.1006791740655899,
0.538260817527771,
0.7157378196716309,
-0.5152422189712524,
-0.2565879821777344,
0.5431809425354004,
0.48511701822280884,
0.24893100559711456,
-0.09947170317173004,
-0.43308359384536743,
-0.06856674700975418,
0.16796228289604187,
-0.13915690779685974,
0.2904113233089447,
0.6306374073028564,
-0.5551161766052246,
0.350864976644516,
0.8193053603172302,
0.5489329695701599,
-0.1409221887588501,
-0.04602675512433052,
0.7869718670845032,
-1.1553046703338623,
-0.42702847719192505,
-1.184423804283142,
0.06640882790088654,
-0.1817752569913864,
-0.24070577323436737,
0.7206625938415527,
0.5925565958023071,
0.6650601029396057,
0.2953573167324066,
0.8621929883956909,
-0.28446725010871887,
0.3337031900882721,
-0.2966596186161041,
0.8414555788040161,
-0.5208030343055725,
0.2904807925224304,
-0.53001868724823,
-1.052030086517334,
-0.09248445183038712,
0.7731130123138428,
-0.08818369358778,
-0.26481059193611145,
0.8642714023590088,
0.6140819191932678,
0.09314723312854767,
0.5533812046051025,
0.011092283762991428,
0.06035313382744789,
0.36064472794532776,
0.4278494119644165,
1.1674772500991821,
-0.12370762974023819,
0.5260709524154663,
-0.5878258943557739,
-0.3624729514122009,
0.2386181801557541,
-0.6694828271865845,
-0.8206511735916138,
-0.8199413418769836,
-0.1460852026939392,
-0.43693897128105164,
0.043107420206069946,
1.2192126512527466,
0.24048493802547455,
-0.9717336297035217,
-0.4391587972640991,
0.520086944103241,
0.051393043249845505,
-0.4652247428894043,
-0.2780826985836029,
0.8244711756706238,
-0.1322917938232422,
-0.9199024438858032,
0.5007271766662598,
0.42574113607406616,
-0.15238334238529205,
-0.0751713290810585,
-0.2437298446893692,
-0.30992957949638367,
-0.3805513083934784,
0.4136678874492645,
0.6181191802024841,
-0.6740351915359497,
-0.2713170349597931,
0.06507764011621475,
-0.29567885398864746,
0.1353265643119812,
1.04244065284729,
-0.4322993755340576,
0.461224228143692,
0.6998839974403381,
0.7887232303619385,
0.32872602343559265,
0.10892631858587265,
0.6929309368133545,
-0.1587337851524353,
0.07993979752063751,
0.3043346703052521,
0.5556378364562988,
0.40449967980384827,
-0.38341090083122253,
0.781987726688385,
0.3008659780025482,
-0.5124698877334595,
-0.5169564485549927,
-0.11526638269424438,
-1.246504306793213,
-0.6545672416687012,
1.0130589008331299,
-0.23735962808132172,
-0.4712075889110565,
-0.5889812707901001,
-0.29564881324768066,
0.7736085057258606,
-0.3167417049407959,
0.7613937854766846,
0.6724706292152405,
0.08495749533176422,
-0.2696617543697357,
-0.6541534066200256,
0.3721417784690857,
-0.05997716262936592,
-0.7574081420898438,
0.22501853108406067,
0.803830623626709,
0.2356330305337906,
0.3173605799674988,
0.7720777988433838,
-0.5193194150924683,
0.436206191778183,
-0.06085094437003136,
0.26313453912734985,
0.23148289322853088,
-0.4577726721763611,
-0.011140123009681702,
0.23976725339889526,
-0.017934422940015793,
0.01606675796210766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15062v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15062v1
|
Construction of a Japanese Financial Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-22T09:40:27 | 2024-03-22T09:40:27 |
Masanori Hirano
|
q-fin.CP
|
q-fin.CP, cs.CL
|
With the recent development of large language models (LLMs), models that
focus on certain domains and languages have been discussed for their necessity.
There is also a growing need for benchmarks to evaluate the performance of
current LLMs in each domain. Therefore, in this study, we constructed a
benchmark comprising multiple tasks specific to the Japanese and financial
domains and performed benchmark measurements on some models. Consequently, we
confirmed that GPT-4 is currently outstanding, and that the constructed
benchmarks function effectively. According to our analysis, our benchmark can
differentiate benchmark scores among models in all performance ranges by
combining tasks with different difficulties.
|
[
-0.395255982875824,
-0.7259203195571899,
0.7024351358413696,
0.3101443648338318,
-0.23372012376785278,
0.1336921900510788,
-0.40661412477493286,
-0.6396344900131226,
-0.21063432097434998,
0.5863581299781799,
-0.22241829335689545,
-0.5716071128845215,
-0.6886166930198669,
0.24122354388237,
-0.08833090215921402,
0.8295606970787048,
-0.49722880125045776,
-0.019655779004096985,
0.060444898903369904,
-0.15348495543003082,
-0.4713404178619385,
-0.597381591796875,
-0.9032691121101379,
-0.4085058569908142,
0.20589378476142883,
-0.016103889793157578,
0.6134132146835327,
0.5091450214385986,
0.9456919431686401,
0.3961019515991211,
0.3333251476287842,
-0.11187206208705902,
-0.24293206632137299,
0.15592379868030548,
-0.08575471490621567,
-0.6103026866912842,
-0.6588343977928162,
0.17747636139392853,
1.0225160121917725,
0.5440298914909363,
-0.11759035289287567,
0.17834293842315674,
0.004965890198945999,
0.45501595735549927,
-0.48866841197013855,
0.6445189118385315,
-0.45441150665283203,
-0.03971963748335838,
-0.7402046322822571,
-0.049593329429626465,
-0.10223856568336487,
-0.3103470802307129,
0.04862776771187782,
-0.6812441945075989,
0.1283060908317566,
0.03079434670507908,
0.8614656925201416,
0.06668663024902344,
-0.5135853290557861,
-0.13779577612876892,
-0.44280871748924255,
0.8525033593177795,
-0.8097110390663147,
0.49767476320266724,
0.4044308066368103,
0.5831778049468994,
0.042354948818683624,
-0.820773720741272,
-0.20524901151657104,
-0.3077329993247986,
0.20211854577064514,
0.011562024243175983,
-0.07333951443433762,
-0.1740635484457016,
0.6384555697441101,
0.4766959249973297,
-0.3793529272079468,
0.04573902487754822,
-0.08856935799121857,
-0.28672128915786743,
0.5379659533500671,
0.35141560435295105,
0.16125212609767914,
-0.07271794229745865,
-0.2111167162656784,
-0.19035518169403076,
-0.9796645641326904,
-0.3066091239452362,
0.6667770743370056,
0.37206727266311646,
-0.17352746427059174,
0.5076669454574585,
-0.36578649282455444,
0.34196075797080994,
-0.4362871050834656,
-0.653415858745575,
0.395906001329422,
-0.3630278706550598,
-0.17569607496261597,
-0.23988956212997437,
0.7210718989372253,
0.3472779393196106,
0.46573182940483093,
-0.09484612941741943,
-0.5365591049194336,
0.08624828606843948,
0.16561192274093628,
-0.845169723033905,
-0.18782535195350647,
-0.2428484708070755,
-0.4355292022228241,
0.05778992921113968,
-0.16700685024261475,
-0.6563072800636292,
0.12842629849910736,
-0.19041708111763,
0.37305817008018494,
-0.2513540983200073,
-0.5086362957954407,
0.05253852903842926,
-0.025228509679436684,
0.28666388988494873,
0.06602942198514938,
-0.7714651226997375,
0.768724262714386,
0.9311105608940125,
0.9703484773635864,
-0.25363999605178833,
-0.27645304799079895,
-0.4378044605255127,
0.31977686285972595,
-0.3214684724807739,
0.7695598006248474,
-0.5782082080841064,
-0.635424017906189,
-0.0474332831799984,
-0.0716967061161995,
0.04639080911874771,
-0.5774338245391846,
0.5608670115470886,
-0.5046964883804321,
0.026510892435908318,
-0.4780173897743225,
-0.7632752656936646,
-0.23976334929466248,
0.6018356680870056,
-0.6901578903198242,
1.0392156839370728,
0.46585261821746826,
-0.5094108581542969,
0.3888973891735077,
-0.7452355027198792,
-0.4907976984977722,
0.49692514538764954,
-0.36691752076148987,
-0.5052012205123901,
-0.055502213537693024,
0.07107554376125336,
0.5142912864685059,
-0.7480540871620178,
0.4240187108516693,
-0.5495557188987732,
-0.32929009199142456,
0.39482519030570984,
-0.5324791669845581,
0.1508421152830124,
0.0977543443441391,
-0.6070835590362549,
-0.23927077651023865,
-0.7557745575904846,
0.03889977186918259,
0.2733132243156433,
-0.13878732919692993,
-0.5201355218887329,
-0.1407913863658905,
0.0764855220913887,
-0.14660078287124634,
0.6410828232765198,
-0.29400476813316345,
0.24038384854793549,
-0.2121790498495102,
0.48995766043663025,
0.6992119550704956,
0.04956015944480896,
-0.08052396029233932,
-0.3732609152793884,
0.840025007724762,
-0.3234946131706238,
0.012345141731202602,
-0.05266866087913513,
-0.6546130776405334,
-0.37015634775161743,
-0.31528154015541077,
0.32719916105270386,
0.22889752686023712,
-0.37646743655204773,
0.09663471579551697,
-0.04231156036257744,
-0.4403415024280548,
-0.10959859192371368,
0.302087664604187,
0.5405977964401245,
0.2599939703941345,
0.18883445858955383,
-0.45711198449134827,
-0.38589757680892944,
-1.103069543838501,
-0.2883889079093933,
0.021389774978160858,
-0.026072874665260315,
0.2825230062007904,
0.4958508014678955,
-0.0014245172496885061,
0.36527690291404724,
-0.6541669964790344,
-0.030548159033060074,
-0.06582922488451004,
0.2699463665485382,
0.5187026858329773,
0.2549099624156952,
0.8358653783798218,
-0.7706737518310547,
-0.7260686159133911,
0.2415667325258255,
-0.4996280074119568,
-0.16736680269241333,
0.21956764161586761,
0.034450095146894455,
0.05097093805670738,
0.4098624289035797,
-0.557956337928772,
-0.033476822078228,
0.5387112498283386,
-0.19414304196834564,
0.6515063643455505,
-0.25631287693977356,
0.4798656404018402,
-0.9958992004394531,
0.37353935837745667,
0.3134121596813202,
-0.3965205252170563,
-0.40685853362083435,
0.2304123193025589,
0.2521817684173584,
-0.021914541721343994,
0.004369385074824095,
0.6240120530128479,
-0.43686309456825256,
-0.7140759229660034,
-0.25552260875701904,
0.19123448431491852,
-0.2576591670513153,
0.32988443970680237,
-0.03395494446158409,
0.9637266397476196,
0.6478462815284729,
-0.4331316649913788,
0.46538880467414856,
-0.0021522408351302147,
-0.6359240412712097,
0.7261162400245667,
-0.867062509059906,
-0.029658399522304535,
0.5334152579307556,
-0.18161620199680328,
-1.0998709201812744,
-0.14826036989688873,
0.06075860932469368,
0.09534326940774918,
0.45222723484039307,
-0.1551876962184906,
-0.7064827084541321,
-0.516498327255249,
0.011807180009782314,
0.4192502796649933,
0.5471500754356384,
-0.2727659046649933,
0.4775378704071045,
0.4199644923210144,
-0.7914581894874573,
-0.2730466425418854,
-0.47867631912231445,
0.09575876593589783,
-0.5793123841285706,
-0.36328059434890747,
0.5368445515632629,
-0.08262712508440018,
-0.2705990970134735,
0.0017165080644190311,
-0.17800867557525635,
0.09116199612617493,
0.20638880133628845,
0.10374753177165985,
0.5764162540435791,
-0.5320939421653748,
-0.27480825781822205,
-0.24189560115337372,
-0.3943198025226593,
0.17127066850662231,
-0.06887806206941605,
0.5532292723655701,
-0.23918496072292328,
-0.42768800258636475,
-0.164907768368721,
0.006043907720595598,
0.5657158493995667,
-0.3325340449810028,
0.2790927290916443,
0.22576946020126343,
-0.25847265124320984,
-0.05955098941922188,
-0.8861303925514221,
0.26522591710090637,
-0.5514570474624634,
0.4629025161266327,
-0.8961953520774841,
-1.0570740699768066,
0.7726079821586609,
-0.3736898899078369,
0.020153239369392395,
0.6962522268295288,
0.728351354598999,
0.5809774398803711,
0.9967435002326965,
0.5256637930870056,
-0.34082552790641785,
0.2689981460571289,
0.008332569152116776,
0.1311732828617096,
-0.7063482403755188,
0.0046708788722753525,
-0.7039507031440735,
-0.09800472110509872,
-0.872075080871582,
-0.5118482112884521,
0.3740227520465851,
0.04567841812968254,
-0.5889944434165955,
0.42613762617111206,
-0.17093458771705627,
0.5603196620941162,
0.45381879806518555,
-0.3485133647918701,
0.36350077390670776,
-0.3321065902709961,
-0.2534977197647095,
-0.02456147037446499,
-0.11779400706291199,
-0.5848945379257202,
1.4777387380599976,
0.5792038440704346,
0.6491365432739258,
0.23519611358642578,
0.5600811243057251,
0.09014400839805603,
0.6492578387260437,
-0.3687629997730255,
0.4741295874118805,
-0.3339864909648895,
-0.5770140290260315,
-0.28263059258461,
-0.7781574726104736,
-0.6067335605621338,
0.16415974497795105,
0.2968284785747528,
-0.6774592399597168,
-0.40736207365989685,
-0.26365581154823303,
-0.24600376188755035,
-0.05020995810627937,
-0.4262017011642456,
0.9804873466491699,
-0.38250112533569336,
-0.2901683747768402,
-0.30062028765678406,
-0.06782938539981842,
0.5588918924331665,
-0.49073395133018494,
0.23509378731250763,
-0.6291501522064209,
-0.3916138708591461,
0.7706566452980042,
-0.3720480799674988,
0.5567871928215027,
-0.29157111048698425,
-0.30952370166778564,
-0.020706674084067345,
-0.057440996170043945,
0.5873867869377136,
0.23216964304447174,
-0.22030209004878998,
0.19044914841651917,
-0.03872049227356911,
-0.342987596988678,
-0.17047008872032166,
1.0946356058120728,
-0.945713460445404,
-0.5956728458404541,
-0.3611888587474823,
-0.5548896193504333,
-0.6710957884788513,
0.4394731819629669,
-0.14030392467975616,
0.5134003758430481,
-0.26975852251052856,
0.12368716299533844,
0.1301267147064209,
-0.008925274014472961,
0.5007593631744385,
0.925809919834137,
-0.16225199401378632,
-0.5069010257720947,
0.6030707955360413,
0.1306384950876236,
0.16907718777656555,
0.2982584238052368,
0.11258722096681595,
-0.6255100965499878,
-0.6899704933166504,
-0.22335951030254364,
0.39965569972991943,
-0.6580990552902222,
-0.27468225359916687,
-0.23430687189102173,
-0.18408185243606567,
-0.32547762989997864,
0.04539138823747635,
-0.6896476149559021,
-0.10908780246973038,
0.29514312744140625,
0.0503220371901989,
0.2616516053676605,
0.9669657945632935,
0.15919922292232513,
0.15837590396404266,
-0.840823769569397,
0.5238563418388367,
0.2233235388994217,
0.8996012210845947,
0.03975094109773636,
-0.42301613092422485,
-0.3015531301498413,
-0.24477790296077728,
-0.33719930052757263,
-0.3085494637489319,
0.20357239246368408,
-0.0619753859937191,
0.9460039138793945,
0.3794563114643097,
-0.2508632242679596,
0.7189530730247498,
-0.5250248908996582,
0.5966789722442627,
0.33154043555259705,
-1.1503034830093384,
0.31832998991012573,
-0.5992575287818909,
0.3751923143863678,
0.4453691244125366,
0.6327077150344849,
-0.4273095726966858,
-0.5998075008392334,
-0.5234405398368835,
-0.7079470753669739,
0.459006130695343,
0.17013661563396454,
0.030948374420404434,
-0.0645589530467987,
0.46756115555763245,
0.33363208174705505,
0.3674578070640564,
-0.7134860754013062,
-0.16546417772769928,
0.05459346994757652,
0.059717096388339996,
-0.44328054785728455,
-0.1625511348247528,
0.037693899124860764,
0.03694148361682892,
0.7076696753501892,
-0.22495613992214203,
-0.0803946852684021,
-0.3347000479698181,
0.31245964765548706,
-0.1358872354030609,
0.05108314007520676,
0.4308041036128998,
0.7626558542251587,
-0.11694783717393875,
-0.17283403873443604,
0.21830007433891296,
-0.3479214012622833,
0.1495811939239502,
0.49248579144477844,
0.21757450699806213,
-0.21694214642047882,
0.459166556596756,
0.8119592070579529,
0.5941386818885803,
-0.6745814085006714,
0.38083991408348083,
-0.11067251861095428,
-0.4313402771949768,
-0.25699013471603394,
0.18578945100307465,
0.3158057928085327,
0.4370937943458557,
0.24412722885608673,
-0.26831334829330444,
0.002719431882724166,
-0.7256332635879517,
0.14285790920257568,
0.3626132607460022,
0.209452822804451,
-0.32857373356819153,
0.711763322353363,
0.2263675183057785,
0.011991270817816257,
0.7224562168121338,
-0.20948676764965057,
-0.5898375511169434,
0.5696336627006531,
0.7200831174850464,
0.8725747466087341,
-0.3213396370410919,
-0.08278524875640869,
0.4732966721057892,
0.06905487924814224,
-0.5274034142494202,
0.47844311594963074,
-0.14747506380081177,
-0.7724971175193787,
-0.6339438557624817,
-0.7422710657119751,
-0.7991310954093933,
0.26042070984840393,
-0.7195298075675964,
0.13785803318023682,
-0.4723089635372162,
-0.4372369050979614,
0.24312564730644226,
0.47109925746917725,
-0.8579826354980469,
0.2612015902996063,
0.18893972039222717,
0.5841495990753174,
-0.7059118747711182,
0.8995669484138489,
0.4290957748889923,
-0.21204009652137756,
-0.6929455399513245,
-0.0888025239109993,
-0.13502442836761475,
-1.0236480236053467,
0.7466868758201599,
0.20780852437019348,
0.0443434901535511,
-0.14137321710586548,
0.06585612893104553,
-1.2341501712799072,
0.91213458776474,
0.36937057971954346,
-1.0960787534713745,
0.031341902911663055,
0.38032960891723633,
0.5118153095245361,
-0.3483341336250305,
0.09482014179229736,
0.7977920770645142,
0.720479428768158,
-0.07321158051490784,
-1.099348783493042,
0.12077562510967255,
-0.4517173171043396,
0.1553623229265213,
0.7701590061187744,
-0.8754322528839111,
0.9124736189842224,
0.3278934359550476,
-0.03389517962932587,
0.33213260769844055,
0.4420299530029297,
0.38404184579849243,
0.18885639309883118,
0.39955851435661316,
0.5293975472450256,
0.7790020704269409,
-0.4466392695903778,
1.1505783796310425,
-0.6747798919677734,
0.39031678438186646,
1.083181619644165,
-0.7955451607704163,
0.9089522361755371,
0.0505932942032814,
-0.6865872740745544,
0.13502055406570435,
0.4147529602050781,
-0.4664914309978485,
0.4794030785560608,
0.353228360414505,
-0.29032912850379944,
-0.21288394927978516,
0.1554737389087677,
-0.6064799427986145,
0.509225070476532,
0.33683401346206665,
-0.03721332550048828,
-0.059493206441402435,
-0.17820364236831665,
0.02254677005112171,
-0.12503907084465027,
-0.3295961022377014,
0.5715235471725464,
0.3798162639141083,
-0.9276211857795715,
0.1805477887392044,
0.3642403781414032,
0.6457079648971558,
-1.0574617385864258,
0.3190796971321106,
-0.10346782952547073,
0.3914867639541626,
0.31478947401046753,
-0.8300797939300537,
0.2813824713230133,
0.27608826756477356,
0.03708053380250931,
-0.26856687664985657,
0.5391767621040344,
-0.2710633873939514,
-0.4597640335559845,
0.31433483958244324,
0.3456045389175415,
0.13574828207492828,
-0.08542626351118088,
-0.668668806552887,
0.26185983419418335,
-0.192825585603714,
-0.510894775390625,
0.5082356929779053,
0.4305017292499542,
-0.012502682395279408,
0.41931644082069397,
0.668537437915802,
0.1390969604253769,
-0.31887537240982056,
0.5170058608055115,
0.519369900226593,
-0.983307957649231,
-0.7218107581138611,
-0.8927366733551025,
-0.03538047522306442,
-0.12402237951755524,
-0.646213948726654,
1.0093846321105957,
0.8070567846298218,
0.8874145150184631,
0.09376177936792374,
0.9461451172828674,
0.29736924171447754,
0.485636442899704,
-0.5789697170257568,
0.5052731037139893,
-0.5305015444755554,
0.16033440828323364,
-0.5081821084022522,
-1.2212536334991455,
-0.25344493985176086,
0.5370762348175049,
-0.558113157749176,
0.4209505319595337,
0.7790079116821289,
0.5772488713264465,
0.07411693036556244,
0.3256920576095581,
0.5072450041770935,
0.07996826618909836,
0.47773244976997375,
0.5857595205307007,
0.6947259306907654,
-0.3384788930416107,
0.26075515151023865,
-0.33474546670913696,
0.022047391161322594,
-0.06076476722955704,
-1.1446679830551147,
-0.8773651123046875,
-0.4320369362831116,
-0.6170535683631897,
0.10047802329063416,
-0.09209920465946198,
0.3782433867454529,
0.5071778893470764,
-0.7069131731987,
-0.4812767207622528,
0.036829136312007904,
-0.39861249923706055,
-0.2724907100200653,
-0.16832946240901947,
0.3302075266838074,
-0.33084753155708313,
-0.8763183355331421,
0.47454017400741577,
0.6006338596343994,
0.15068049728870392,
-0.2983570694923401,
-0.2046644538640976,
0.2726840376853943,
0.006121143698692322,
0.36451008915901184,
-0.036384981125593185,
-0.5143629312515259,
-0.31423434615135193,
-0.28055036067962646,
-0.14475087821483612,
-0.03739188238978386,
0.9493443965911865,
-0.12087209522724152,
0.1336553394794464,
0.17194344103336334,
0.7006933689117432,
0.9699869155883789,
-0.12309480458498001,
0.9094076752662659,
-0.5484898686408997,
-0.06688028573989868,
-0.06994573771953583,
0.6913962960243225,
0.3890169560909271,
-0.11717935651540756,
0.6773298382759094,
0.2483493983745575,
-0.6230171918869019,
-0.5296632051467896,
-0.17464368045330048,
-0.8309808373451233,
-0.09936916828155518,
0.9202988147735596,
-0.33131474256515503,
-0.1116797924041748,
-0.013452546671032906,
0.19740143418312073,
0.02002696692943573,
-0.19969426095485687,
0.4281616508960724,
1.1342657804489136,
0.13426905870437622,
0.08358585089445114,
-0.8707579970359802,
0.2135181725025177,
0.2642691731452942,
-0.8883752226829529,
0.12333699315786362,
0.2559572756290436,
0.7124873995780945,
-0.03738423436880112,
0.8552409410476685,
-0.3382728397846222,
0.41831734776496887,
0.34416067600250244,
-0.18506816029548645,
0.0013104330282658339,
-0.08553918451070786,
0.15659932792186737,
0.47539183497428894,
0.4056820273399353,
0.21514475345611572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15042v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15042v1
|
LLM2LLM: Boosting LLMs with Novel Iterative Data Enhancement
| 2024-03-22T08:57:07 | 2024-03-22T08:57:07 |
Nicholas Lee, Thanakul Wattanawong, Sehoon Kim, Karttikeya Mangalam, Sheng Shen, Gopala Anumanchipali, Michael W. Mahoney, Kurt Keutzer, Amir Gholami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained large language models (LLMs) are currently state-of-the-art for
solving the vast majority of natural language processing tasks. While many
real-world applications still require fine-tuning to reach satisfactory levels
of performance, many of them are in the low-data regime, making fine-tuning
challenging. To address this, we propose LLM2LLM, a targeted and iterative data
augmentation strategy that uses a teacher LLM to enhance a small seed dataset
by augmenting additional data that can be used for fine-tuning on a specific
task. LLM2LLM (1) fine-tunes a baseline student LLM on the initial seed data,
(2) evaluates and extracts data points that the model gets wrong, and (3) uses
a teacher LLM to generate synthetic data based on these incorrect data points,
which are then added back into the training data. This approach amplifies the
signal from incorrectly predicted data points by the LLM during training and
reintegrates them into the dataset to focus on more challenging examples for
the LLM. Our results show that LLM2LLM significantly enhances the performance
of LLMs in the low-data regime, outperforming both traditional fine-tuning and
other data augmentation baselines. LLM2LLM reduces the dependence on
labor-intensive data curation and paves the way for more scalable and
performant LLM solutions, allowing us to tackle data-constrained domains and
tasks. We achieve improvements up to 24.2% on the GSM8K dataset, 32.6% on
CaseHOLD, 32.0% on SNIPS, 52.6% on TREC and 39.8% on SST-2 over regular
fine-tuning in the low-data regime using a LLaMA2-7B student model.
|
[
-0.18607468903064728,
-0.822838306427002,
0.3414231538772583,
0.020504789426922798,
-0.36933064460754395,
0.32860705256462097,
-0.478180468082428,
-0.4074872136116028,
-0.011982391588389874,
0.6077564358711243,
-0.6236271858215332,
-0.48004499077796936,
-0.6684381365776062,
-0.05437089875340462,
-0.311456561088562,
0.6930913925170898,
0.12605202198028564,
0.22749090194702148,
-0.22960959374904633,
0.22567042708396912,
-0.7848407030105591,
-0.35560473799705505,
-0.6368924975395203,
-0.6378567218780518,
0.27553510665893555,
1.023173451423645,
0.48091962933540344,
0.844007670879364,
0.26382365822792053,
0.18281526863574982,
-0.13926133513450623,
0.6218494772911072,
-1.007612943649292,
0.011084119789302349,
-0.046787187457084656,
-0.4883686900138855,
-0.48055270314216614,
0.05553918704390526,
0.6079264879226685,
0.7223110198974609,
-0.018117567524313927,
0.2538982927799225,
0.33590590953826904,
0.8001687526702881,
-0.3909645974636078,
0.028346754610538483,
-0.9690923690795898,
-0.1987503319978714,
-0.307372123003006,
-0.5206179618835449,
-0.34426218271255493,
-0.3482336401939392,
-0.1947295367717743,
-0.39645758271217346,
0.1597096025943756,
0.06810541450977325,
0.5444474816322327,
0.3698928654193878,
-0.18081140518188477,
-0.17374613881111145,
-0.6896487474441528,
0.8330200910568237,
-0.8170258402824402,
0.17343875765800476,
0.497443288564682,
0.16683067381381989,
-0.2803317904472351,
-0.5294269919395447,
-0.4396725594997406,
-0.05739520490169525,
0.04045645520091057,
0.07061826437711716,
0.12356172502040863,
-0.032515715807676315,
0.33711645007133484,
0.5924720168113708,
-0.48156076669692993,
0.5632370710372925,
-0.48246246576309204,
-0.049288246780633926,
0.5571706295013428,
0.3350275158882141,
-0.07721351832151413,
0.09326380491256714,
-0.34166190028190613,
0.018019692972302437,
-1.0508917570114136,
-0.010545630939304829,
0.5690532326698303,
0.5830357670783997,
0.1574445515871048,
0.7838751077651978,
-0.2861146926879883,
0.7636529803276062,
-0.04257586970925331,
-0.08288327604532242,
0.17038103938102722,
-0.4737018942832947,
-0.035162098705768585,
0.24952912330627441,
0.3558577299118042,
0.3938260078430176,
0.3623885214328766,
-0.06378056108951569,
-0.39558523893356323,
0.08715613186359406,
-0.03393698111176491,
-1.0342676639556885,
-0.32893213629722595,
0.14786531031131744,
-0.014754382893443108,
-0.44095420837402344,
-0.07788456976413727,
-0.6335086822509766,
-0.4079453945159912,
-0.6013302206993103,
0.4617932438850403,
-0.15677420794963837,
-0.21106408536434174,
0.2565295398235321,
0.281556636095047,
0.06643375754356384,
0.2740010619163513,
-0.899674654006958,
0.3302648067474365,
0.9593974947929382,
0.7306959629058838,
-0.3098260164260864,
-0.11083949357271194,
-0.7644903063774109,
0.12298555672168732,
-0.44483962655067444,
0.8016002178192139,
-0.7504351139068604,
-0.3505442142486572,
-0.1077401340007782,
-0.046840716153383255,
0.07451006770133972,
-0.8046985864639282,
0.7071996331214905,
-0.39181065559387207,
0.2439005970954895,
-0.09293831139802933,
-0.7108189463615417,
0.12836109101772308,
0.221517413854599,
-0.5140420794487,
1.685389757156372,
0.24289046227931976,
-0.3899114727973938,
0.26195308566093445,
-0.3952043950557709,
-0.5335586071014404,
0.020558515563607216,
-0.05950454995036125,
-0.5387990474700928,
0.13310880959033966,
0.37748774886131287,
0.4091174006462097,
-0.5381810069084167,
0.12234455347061157,
-0.1655811220407486,
-0.7064195871353149,
-0.09271787106990814,
-0.26172739267349243,
0.4109366536140442,
-0.009955964051187038,
-0.056940436363220215,
0.08167845010757446,
-0.8534225821495056,
0.26696982979774475,
0.10033541172742844,
-0.6773320436477661,
-0.144465371966362,
-0.15130460262298584,
0.02718331478536129,
0.21972018480300903,
0.17267541587352753,
-0.4427717924118042,
0.46286922693252563,
-0.7777765393257141,
0.3584659993648529,
0.800742506980896,
-0.09605246037244797,
0.5917237401008606,
-0.436046838760376,
0.25976184010505676,
-0.02975078858435154,
-0.13907627761363983,
-0.30644240975379944,
-0.3571920096874237,
-0.8601367473602295,
-0.26782020926475525,
0.4036000967025757,
0.5703034400939941,
-0.8145255446434021,
0.4543920159339905,
-0.5593893527984619,
-0.248615100979805,
-0.9082801938056946,
0.7297648787498474,
0.18599727749824524,
0.8108201622962952,
0.671701967716217,
-0.07624774426221848,
-0.8164237141609192,
-0.642797589302063,
-0.19377554953098297,
0.19621413946151733,
-0.07715798169374466,
0.2653467655181885,
0.07150828093290329,
-0.2934024930000305,
0.8443673253059387,
-0.42661935091018677,
-0.5652657151222229,
-0.44671767950057983,
0.012618420645594597,
0.5534716844558716,
0.6297388076782227,
0.016612650826573372,
-0.3000485599040985,
-0.44720786809921265,
-0.20157000422477722,
-0.32337772846221924,
-0.22761231660842896,
-0.06204639747738838,
-0.02770957164466381,
0.02448381297290325,
0.2244264781475067,
-0.4063397943973541,
0.2683403491973877,
0.31458884477615356,
-0.13533781468868256,
0.2718167304992676,
-0.22078925371170044,
-0.11873083561658859,
-1.1445412635803223,
-0.195548877120018,
-0.2475123554468155,
-0.40560242533683777,
-0.7963816523551941,
-0.21730583906173706,
0.10387605428695679,
-0.04308038204908371,
-0.3517809510231018,
0.5212854146957397,
-0.4997158646583557,
-0.15576043725013733,
-0.7062106132507324,
0.14112037420272827,
-0.17309224605560303,
0.25322434306144714,
-0.1138344258069992,
0.9521276354789734,
0.625440776348114,
-0.47166094183921814,
0.3407675623893738,
0.16480642557144165,
-0.5045842528343201,
0.2772129774093628,
-0.5313850045204163,
0.47067880630493164,
-0.14591103792190552,
0.07283277809619904,
-0.9504792094230652,
-0.11290030181407928,
0.0024906485341489315,
-0.4089396595954895,
0.38672029972076416,
-0.14210866391658783,
-0.8613560795783997,
-0.4680972099304199,
-0.4956992268562317,
0.23087634146213531,
0.6395847201347351,
-0.8727731108665466,
0.3711172044277191,
0.09144467115402222,
-0.05627885460853577,
-0.38431793451309204,
-0.7007303833961487,
0.3673864006996155,
-0.10136318951845169,
-0.6509414315223694,
0.5061449408531189,
0.005466771777719259,
-0.0035798323806375265,
-0.10095606744289398,
-0.11977597326040268,
0.25515252351760864,
0.28422975540161133,
0.09944622218608856,
0.4022422432899475,
-0.1304650902748108,
0.07505746185779572,
0.09487481415271759,
-0.3022013008594513,
-0.177703395485878,
-0.38369613885879517,
0.7541829347610474,
0.27989712357521057,
-0.15489545464515686,
-0.4233654737472534,
0.03697730228304863,
-0.020680109038949013,
0.0600292906165123,
0.44575032591819763,
0.7380301356315613,
-0.49850812554359436,
-0.42463114857673645,
-0.5098149180412292,
-0.6503384709358215,
-0.528680145740509,
0.40287327766418457,
-0.3682640790939331,
-0.9376229643821716,
0.025463787838816643,
-0.3339693546295166,
-0.007101120427250862,
0.0834508091211319,
0.6813684105873108,
-0.14200857281684875,
0.9069104790687561,
0.4105510115623474,
-0.3824229836463928,
0.34036585688591003,
-0.338753342628479,
0.1479063779115677,
-0.9673126339912415,
-0.13390769064426422,
-0.35740596055984497,
-0.42138010263442993,
-0.4079080820083618,
-0.6578236818313599,
0.19336016476154327,
0.40946194529533386,
0.04934132844209671,
0.21742811799049377,
-0.40001896023750305,
0.7524205446243286,
0.4651654064655304,
0.302513986825943,
0.4817664325237274,
0.2712593376636505,
0.061693452298641205,
-0.0859667956829071,
-0.7587664127349854,
-0.479704886674881,
1.3915799856185913,
0.41760769486427307,
0.8494016528129578,
0.010971724055707455,
0.4708765745162964,
0.275403767824173,
0.388275682926178,
-0.8278169631958008,
0.5548408627510071,
-0.3063147962093353,
-0.28593477606773376,
-0.13730557262897491,
-0.41398006677627563,
-0.7187142372131348,
0.06080518662929535,
-0.3417913317680359,
-0.6918457746505737,
-0.12211758643388748,
0.3825668692588806,
-0.1520659476518631,
0.12076644599437714,
-0.5152454376220703,
0.3410536050796509,
-0.23357369005680084,
-0.8059006929397583,
-0.3101799190044403,
-0.39876043796539307,
0.4104573130607605,
-0.20376034080982208,
0.040252141654491425,
-0.25327712297439575,
-0.05991561710834503,
0.5657615661621094,
-0.5621611475944519,
0.6988891959190369,
-0.3151358962059021,
-0.36524584889411926,
0.183005228638649,
-0.12977883219718933,
1.092555284500122,
0.15291088819503784,
-0.4315457046031952,
-0.05106568709015846,
-0.4030238687992096,
-0.5192203521728516,
-0.5336342453956604,
0.9328942894935608,
-0.6180450320243835,
-0.6942676305770874,
0.04408858343958855,
-0.6776514649391174,
-0.6145052313804626,
0.0005492778727784753,
0.11380524933338165,
0.3516596257686615,
0.4080577492713928,
0.3982445299625397,
0.5291181802749634,
0.16276110708713531,
0.18980242311954498,
0.6239674687385559,
-0.1310858279466629,
-0.41123995184898376,
1.0961823463439941,
0.0867454931139946,
0.2977839708328247,
0.2573297619819641,
0.21153798699378967,
-0.5725420117378235,
-0.8267642855644226,
-0.5037731528282166,
-0.006109398789703846,
-0.6131240129470825,
-0.31343162059783936,
-0.45126721262931824,
-0.14337551593780518,
-0.3987964987754822,
0.08794277906417847,
-0.4141255021095276,
-0.5055625438690186,
-0.6334307193756104,
-0.30472496151924133,
0.3957637548446655,
0.4889422357082367,
-0.035946786403656006,
0.673076868057251,
-0.4047596752643585,
0.3257456123828888,
0.1323983520269394,
0.27144718170166016,
-0.19001956284046173,
-0.9433839917182922,
-0.38276585936546326,
0.1478930562734604,
-0.12462147325277328,
-0.4578644037246704,
0.31875917315483093,
0.36387741565704346,
0.310752272605896,
0.2305270880460739,
-0.21228964626789093,
0.9963310360908508,
-0.3526798486709595,
0.5811979174613953,
0.011642838828265667,
-0.6135486960411072,
0.6423090100288391,
-0.21754804253578186,
0.18058019876480103,
0.7157126665115356,
0.0336768738925457,
-0.09783028066158295,
-0.1945492923259735,
-0.14431045949459076,
-0.9619234800338745,
0.8393881916999817,
0.2012162208557129,
0.29657620191574097,
0.4594819247722626,
0.6390453577041626,
0.053716134279966354,
0.1058860719203949,
-0.5578450560569763,
-0.28126195073127747,
-0.053682610392570496,
-0.466705858707428,
-0.2625442147254944,
-0.4858054518699646,
-0.013192776590585709,
-0.49822938442230225,
0.7795501947402954,
-0.34945207834243774,
0.04769238084554672,
-0.14602038264274597,
-0.20104293525218964,
-0.28026673197746277,
0.22827576100826263,
0.4692286252975464,
0.48471295833587646,
-0.3089701533317566,
0.29222342371940613,
0.4394751489162445,
-0.44628602266311646,
0.20053070783615112,
0.295648992061615,
-0.3133309483528137,
-0.21541234850883484,
0.24797381460666656,
0.9383983612060547,
0.29892227053642273,
-0.567894458770752,
0.21544648706912994,
0.19321483373641968,
-0.14675725996494293,
-0.06691021472215652,
0.2755697965621948,
0.1043231263756752,
0.24728526175022125,
0.6357591152191162,
-0.15970709919929504,
0.0063222297467291355,
-0.4424154460430145,
0.24946296215057373,
0.4303150475025177,
-0.12592792510986328,
-0.2490333765745163,
0.6494700312614441,
0.002248011063784361,
-0.17254047095775604,
0.45215824246406555,
-0.0582946315407753,
-0.4321138262748718,
0.49037715792655945,
0.9093964695930481,
0.5016471147537231,
-0.19353295862674713,
-0.09894529730081558,
0.5745624899864197,
0.4245922267436981,
-0.29123449325561523,
0.505504846572876,
-0.0625307708978653,
-0.7511806488037109,
-0.44533056020736694,
-0.5114542841911316,
-0.30384188890457153,
0.45703116059303284,
-0.5152654647827148,
0.5275416374206543,
-0.4003116488456726,
0.019736742600798607,
-0.25414860248565674,
0.415173202753067,
-0.619960367679596,
0.23588062822818756,
0.09993261098861694,
0.9248632788658142,
-0.5758746862411499,
1.305600643157959,
0.4743739664554596,
0.09604201465845108,
-0.7652552723884583,
-0.09050226956605911,
-0.05920104682445526,
-1.062087059020996,
0.5501977801322937,
0.3544946312904358,
0.03191673383116722,
0.4490211308002472,
-0.382910817861557,
-0.8268909454345703,
1.2932915687561035,
0.3149963617324829,
-0.995225727558136,
0.09640124440193176,
0.6977461576461792,
0.4465693235397339,
-0.4484025239944458,
0.12799756228923798,
0.7914828062057495,
0.46527817845344543,
0.2775905728340149,
-0.4751022756099701,
0.07686516642570496,
-0.08840513229370117,
0.13199856877326965,
0.05089230835437775,
-0.38885730504989624,
0.6675097942352295,
-0.3865945637226105,
-0.22168758511543274,
0.10233545303344727,
0.46856415271759033,
0.27648788690567017,
0.25018060207366943,
0.4797370731830597,
0.7997882962226868,
0.8820967674255371,
-0.25095394253730774,
0.7050570249557495,
-0.4675077795982361,
0.3212222158908844,
1.4759443998336792,
-0.35210850834846497,
0.7450939416885376,
0.5763081908226013,
-0.11764560639858246,
-0.011390659026801586,
0.8356062173843384,
-0.21258720755577087,
0.5137606263160706,
0.2608809173107147,
-0.31699037551879883,
-0.3004309833049774,
-0.26717281341552734,
-0.28987637162208557,
0.27738872170448303,
0.3905850052833557,
-0.2571515738964081,
-0.2436293214559555,
0.10042238980531693,
-0.06041061878204346,
0.09227186441421509,
-0.4383997321128845,
0.8048914670944214,
0.0213333573192358,
-0.3752686679363251,
0.7761840224266052,
0.17020612955093384,
0.7154740691184998,
-0.2942084074020386,
0.04591170325875282,
-0.40800994634628296,
0.1777799427509308,
-0.4290761649608612,
-0.7601845264434814,
0.18238604068756104,
0.16237056255340576,
-0.0736343041062355,
-0.31597501039505005,
0.9859904646873474,
-0.7438679933547974,
-0.5363529920578003,
0.16462217271327972,
0.373737096786499,
-0.008475328795611858,
-0.01961887814104557,
-0.5198183059692383,
0.16304360330104828,
0.04130407050251961,
-0.1717248260974884,
0.2016647309064865,
0.028595032170414925,
0.16564582288265228,
0.6635566353797913,
0.8590188026428223,
0.3947352170944214,
-0.015617790631949902,
0.21438443660736084,
1.2720292806625366,
-0.5223805904388428,
-0.16121643781661987,
-0.9784013628959656,
0.3899906873703003,
-0.08112145215272903,
-0.10069901496171951,
0.7064955830574036,
1.0142289400100708,
0.8541951179504395,
0.16037291288375854,
0.5943347215652466,
0.39547228813171387,
0.8266290426254272,
-0.8137035369873047,
0.19893331825733185,
-0.4720900058746338,
0.8343968391418457,
0.1888870745897293,
-0.9704627990722656,
-0.050505418330430984,
0.2659095525741577,
-0.4522130489349365,
-0.16557542979717255,
0.13909895718097687,
1.1897072792053223,
-0.0013416631845757365,
0.013559768907725811,
0.27592816948890686,
0.24651643633842468,
0.25530722737312317,
0.6549146771430969,
0.9596223831176758,
-0.5303288102149963,
0.35225358605384827,
-0.36489710211753845,
-0.06304743140935898,
-0.26822546124458313,
-0.5515645742416382,
-0.9795117974281311,
-0.15204083919525146,
-0.13082446157932281,
-0.3368528485298157,
0.15372779965400696,
1.1705600023269653,
0.7770606875419617,
-0.7483959197998047,
-0.12521539628505707,
-0.2693887948989868,
0.13227276504039764,
0.1803455948829651,
-0.2461727261543274,
0.10994948446750641,
-0.448340505361557,
-0.8473821878433228,
0.857291579246521,
0.14499717950820923,
0.15334375202655792,
-0.22122977674007416,
-0.20904241502285004,
-0.00027201068587601185,
-0.021066242828965187,
0.6558742523193359,
-0.028877899050712585,
-0.44619736075401306,
-0.0037833114620298147,
-0.12204985320568085,
-0.10575409233570099,
0.29756730794906616,
0.7923043966293335,
-0.9152276515960693,
0.3915041983127594,
0.2510715425014496,
0.9098357558250427,
0.7015522122383118,
0.29569560289382935,
0.34070146083831787,
-1.057217001914978,
0.15479713678359985,
0.23223648965358734,
0.06490620970726013,
0.4587021768093109,
-0.5924599170684814,
0.623570442199707,
0.2451123595237732,
-0.30535197257995605,
-1.1252079010009766,
0.0032646951731294394,
-0.7924736142158508,
-0.11254731565713882,
1.266073226928711,
0.20533597469329834,
0.1196347326040268,
0.08368787914514542,
-0.2706133723258972,
0.04435133934020996,
-0.42476680874824524,
0.7621796131134033,
0.388843834400177,
0.05737308785319328,
-0.37737298011779785,
-0.6573331952095032,
0.6409468650817871,
0.5349656939506531,
-1.0995851755142212,
0.0923423171043396,
0.35470259189605713,
0.23626314103603363,
-0.4761865735054016,
0.46979883313179016,
0.018208952620625496,
-0.026460736989974976,
-0.4326217770576477,
-0.35201725363731384,
-0.5024822950363159,
-0.28547877073287964,
-0.367675244808197,
0.025884192436933517,
0.09932033717632294,
-0.11904636025428772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15040v1
|
ESG Classification by Implicit Rule Learning via GPT-4
| 2024-03-22T08:45:30 | 2024-03-22T08:45:30 |
Hyo Jeong Yun, Chanyoung Kim, Moonjeong Hahm, Kyuri Kim, Guijin Son
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors are widely adopted as
higher investment return indicators. Accordingly, ongoing efforts are being
made to automate ESG evaluation with language models to extract signals from
massive web text easily. However, recent approaches suffer from a lack of
training data, as rating agencies keep their evaluation metrics confidential.
This paper investigates whether state-of-the-art language models like GPT-4 can
be guided to align with unknown ESG evaluation criteria through strategies such
as prompting, chain-of-thought reasoning, and dynamic in-context learning. We
demonstrate the efficacy of these approaches by ranking 2nd in the Shared-Task
ML-ESG-3 Impact Type track for Korean without updating the model on the
provided training data. We also explore how adjusting prompts impacts the
ability of language models to address financial tasks leveraging smaller models
with openly available weights. We observe longer general pre-training to
correlate with enhanced performance in financial downstream tasks. Our findings
showcase the potential of language models to navigate complex, subjective
evaluation guidelines despite lacking explicit training examples, revealing
opportunities for training-free solutions for financial downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.24275559186935425,
-0.6020624041557312,
0.7643736004829407,
0.019084995612502098,
-0.18483898043632507,
0.2196475714445114,
-0.25957632064819336,
-0.5255056619644165,
-0.40938395261764526,
0.26447147130966187,
-0.658160924911499,
-0.5959332585334778,
-0.8953072428703308,
0.051334261894226074,
-0.06866519153118134,
1.4354275465011597,
-0.06638563424348831,
0.06418066471815109,
0.02042003534734249,
0.23168045282363892,
-0.1657889187335968,
-0.41054826974868774,
-0.8376832008361816,
-0.3782607316970825,
0.37474045157432556,
0.0977361649274826,
0.24739636480808258,
0.3528212308883667,
0.2465357482433319,
0.2967883348464966,
-0.007671804167330265,
0.09749987721443176,
-0.4340401887893677,
-0.2483750283718109,
-0.1350143849849701,
-0.12133526802062988,
-0.25372710824012756,
0.47695374488830566,
0.31526780128479004,
0.29655909538269043,
-0.39092662930488586,
0.30251285433769226,
0.48858556151390076,
0.5745424628257751,
-0.3835667371749878,
0.9419394731521606,
-0.46579140424728394,
-0.0021475546527653933,
0.22582978010177612,
-0.2912699580192566,
-0.34002506732940674,
-0.4644070863723755,
0.7803338766098022,
-0.7102299928665161,
0.028314776718616486,
0.0014379885978996754,
1.0495327711105347,
0.34837180376052856,
-0.5769866108894348,
-0.7751138210296631,
-0.46850258111953735,
0.6369919776916504,
-0.4057527184486389,
0.2581663727760315,
0.4162901043891907,
0.1963246762752533,
0.22566188871860504,
-0.7575168013572693,
-0.13855856657028198,
-0.31571877002716064,
-0.16979563236236572,
0.3135210871696472,
-0.18357446789741516,
0.3156382441520691,
0.3794870674610138,
0.02235892415046692,
-0.15946702659130096,
-0.07254097610712051,
-0.4138684570789337,
-0.17152078449726105,
0.40469491481781006,
-0.2671011984348297,
0.06480469554662704,
-0.1365845799446106,
-0.5371536016464233,
-0.06618932634592056,
-0.7704662084579468,
0.11702392995357513,
0.8608998656272888,
0.43246856331825256,
-0.17684617638587952,
0.1708245426416397,
-0.15129593014717102,
0.23115192353725433,
0.44123631715774536,
0.08545174449682236,
0.24499183893203735,
-0.41447433829307556,
-0.012015446089208126,
0.06284796446561813,
0.32739412784576416,
0.1972200572490692,
0.14398933947086334,
-0.1941342055797577,
-0.36485496163368225,
-0.0737992450594902,
0.2981525659561157,
-0.579592227935791,
-0.07791571319103241,
-0.07741036266088486,
-0.29656484723091125,
-0.38706639409065247,
0.13529331982135773,
-0.6933704018592834,
-0.2411413937807083,
-0.6347900032997131,
0.6997907161712646,
0.08138835430145264,
-0.19478070735931396,
0.18348801136016846,
-0.27369165420532227,
0.4756371080875397,
0.41209909319877625,
-0.9460766911506653,
0.5190387964248657,
0.7209787368774414,
0.6424664855003357,
0.17122314870357513,
0.02951914072036743,
-0.6360198259353638,
0.1828448474407196,
0.03202186897397041,
0.7266860008239746,
-0.6414157748222351,
-0.29160699248313904,
0.14948786795139313,
0.01596960984170437,
-0.21841350197792053,
-0.09976031631231308,
0.5168436169624329,
-0.38661468029022217,
0.49364519119262695,
-0.544543981552124,
-0.4747256338596344,
-0.45957839488983154,
0.16388171911239624,
-0.37468618154525757,
0.9955580830574036,
0.03369414061307907,
-0.5937182307243347,
0.7848119139671326,
-1.0303775072097778,
-0.08643504977226257,
0.24612818658351898,
-0.23043818771839142,
-0.36781126260757446,
-0.18116843700408936,
0.43562793731689453,
0.5478180646896362,
-0.29946136474609375,
0.4086081385612488,
-0.3270919620990753,
-0.35877349972724915,
-0.3276223838329315,
-0.430575966835022,
0.23685531318187714,
-0.004855649545788765,
-0.8014101982116699,
0.17073309421539307,
-0.595385730266571,
0.051360853016376495,
-0.1179097592830658,
-0.3112465739250183,
-0.3529161214828491,
0.12535510957241058,
-0.1454467922449112,
0.21486376225948334,
0.34380286931991577,
-0.15013501048088074,
0.22695457935333252,
-0.07413297891616821,
0.4770551025867462,
1.254271149635315,
0.1576087772846222,
0.4285532534122467,
-0.009095147252082825,
0.6981329321861267,
-0.48565152287483215,
0.14190058410167694,
0.07208295166492462,
-0.5129139423370361,
-0.5234884023666382,
-0.2042439728975296,
0.27801063656806946,
0.391802042722702,
-0.5422166585922241,
0.12954971194267273,
-0.25237905979156494,
-0.4279564321041107,
-0.34631845355033875,
0.045820701867341995,
0.3838331401348114,
0.3761248290538788,
0.2577678859233856,
0.24760712683200836,
-0.29484501481056213,
-0.7526148557662964,
-0.5635178089141846,
-0.2464214265346527,
-0.014326856471598148,
0.5506929755210876,
0.5458667874336243,
-0.10192116349935532,
0.4071139395236969,
-0.5072687268257141,
-0.17167112231254578,
-0.20455701649188995,
0.6508697867393494,
0.2585684061050415,
0.14580126106739044,
0.3888893723487854,
-0.7309478521347046,
-0.4507751166820526,
0.17202971875667572,
-0.5282026529312134,
-0.3290404677391052,
-0.09602288156747818,
0.13379548490047455,
-0.11563441902399063,
0.6543919444084167,
-0.2354692667722702,
0.0712318867444992,
0.45207399129867554,
-0.47605055570602417,
0.40880122780799866,
-0.2943490445613861,
0.10879898071289062,
-0.5361712574958801,
-0.08590909838676453,
0.2855018079280853,
-0.3009742796421051,
-0.5292196869850159,
0.005252213682979345,
0.15477672219276428,
-0.08040421456098557,
-0.16325928270816803,
0.6861327886581421,
-0.6216369867324829,
-0.13884668052196503,
-0.10128596425056458,
0.07235774397850037,
-0.20520399510860443,
0.8008020520210266,
0.15333466231822968,
0.5719504356384277,
0.666509747505188,
-0.6109542846679688,
0.045326150953769684,
0.011781137436628342,
-0.3554362654685974,
0.4519270956516266,
-0.6744052171707153,
0.3706734776496887,
-0.11271869391202927,
0.144124835729599,
-0.783201277256012,
-0.07229211926460266,
0.2212776094675064,
0.009816818870604038,
0.46025270223617554,
-0.4435698688030243,
-0.2151913344860077,
-0.33561861515045166,
-0.166171133518219,
-0.033745452761650085,
0.5221720933914185,
-0.6028399467468262,
0.6532589793205261,
0.2106863558292389,
-0.4126144349575043,
-0.7498769760131836,
-0.19956250488758087,
-0.3459056317806244,
-0.6003416776657104,
-0.1813797503709793,
0.25651535391807556,
0.16347730159759521,
0.0820910781621933,
0.1406446248292923,
-0.37581759691238403,
0.30636951327323914,
0.1902948021888733,
0.24437788128852844,
0.2530621588230133,
0.007272320333868265,
0.03984379395842552,
0.049467846751213074,
-0.14637239277362823,
0.1431232988834381,
-0.5126107931137085,
0.16437216103076935,
-0.6342786550521851,
-0.3736495077610016,
-0.08405895531177521,
-0.08020853996276855,
0.33799096941947937,
-0.22483651340007782,
0.4701448678970337,
0.5954660773277283,
-0.35325688123703003,
-0.34333568811416626,
-0.4504728615283966,
-0.0771142914891243,
-0.5705538392066956,
0.47056517004966736,
-0.3232184052467346,
-1.0196493864059448,
0.47448864579200745,
-0.39747902750968933,
-0.04030090942978859,
0.4564392566680908,
0.4836178123950958,
0.13117168843746185,
1.098929762840271,
0.8947575092315674,
0.1941828578710556,
0.5848713517189026,
-0.1252635419368744,
0.42634788155555725,
-0.526839554309845,
-0.3672381639480591,
-0.40084460377693176,
-0.10503353178501129,
-0.6855815649032593,
-0.1705193668603897,
0.48898348212242126,
0.19107331335544586,
-0.26882460713386536,
0.22191336750984192,
-0.23968401551246643,
0.648973286151886,
0.1941562294960022,
0.10178887844085693,
0.022092677652835846,
-0.08699201792478561,
-0.3209502696990967,
0.19664157927036285,
-0.5633738040924072,
-0.5659236311912537,
1.083224892616272,
0.635543942451477,
0.666649341583252,
-0.09904395043849945,
0.5784540176391602,
0.4782295227050781,
0.6668373942375183,
-0.7033132314682007,
0.29678472876548767,
0.034737564623355865,
-0.2791174352169037,
-0.42053288221359253,
-0.43347200751304626,
-0.45408162474632263,
0.10808993875980377,
0.0187983401119709,
-0.569279670715332,
0.039169568568468094,
0.004482947289943695,
-0.6388624310493469,
-0.10519623756408691,
-0.9610360860824585,
0.7555462718009949,
-0.31808212399482727,
-0.16033907234668732,
-0.04394422844052315,
-0.2503914535045624,
0.2189677208662033,
-0.30141714215278625,
0.34764301776885986,
-0.18088942766189575,
-0.049061745405197144,
0.6110315918922424,
-0.2943713366985321,
0.9296504855155945,
-0.568535327911377,
-0.23703013360500336,
0.20967258512973785,
-0.47569531202316284,
0.9056589603424072,
0.12485945969820023,
0.22844243049621582,
0.24246880412101746,
-0.24743971228599548,
-0.29427433013916016,
-0.7460697293281555,
0.6827076077461243,
-0.7822232246398926,
-0.714683473110199,
-0.5437371134757996,
-0.024384139105677605,
-0.42621496319770813,
0.005336001515388489,
0.1585700511932373,
0.1153864786028862,
-0.0781584307551384,
0.037546828389167786,
0.41540980339050293,
-0.13385778665542603,
0.39528003334999084,
0.623134434223175,
0.053156450390815735,
-0.27033326029777527,
0.6088581085205078,
0.08443450927734375,
0.23781898617744446,
-0.029342416673898697,
0.3107469379901886,
-0.8919728994369507,
-0.3332589566707611,
-0.1873888224363327,
0.19575907289981842,
-0.8306770920753479,
-0.11330287158489227,
-0.6216138601303101,
-0.11257695406675339,
-0.23419423401355743,
-0.15120702981948853,
-0.11141769587993622,
-0.062192969024181366,
-0.029189417138695717,
-0.8194292783737183,
0.4139387607574463,
1.1124061346054077,
-0.1499163955450058,
0.22212179005146027,
-0.6144562363624573,
0.06741520017385483,
0.6632136106491089,
0.6179171204566956,
-0.03338220342993736,
-0.35585519671440125,
-0.3465956151485443,
-0.17279689013957977,
-0.08121506124734879,
-0.8062271475791931,
0.12241927534341812,
0.3283536434173584,
0.7259104251861572,
0.48809710144996643,
-0.3310408592224121,
0.6890871524810791,
-0.5710375905036926,
0.5930745005607605,
0.0017420353833585978,
-1.2064770460128784,
0.4241819679737091,
-0.5803099870681763,
-0.014186077751219273,
0.4680381119251251,
0.7047726511955261,
-0.513992965221405,
-0.20446805655956268,
-0.5586922764778137,
-0.9628804326057434,
0.806790828704834,
0.0483117438852787,
0.09520699828863144,
-0.09569627791643143,
0.3603317141532898,
0.14269812405109406,
0.44610896706581116,
-1.0170105695724487,
0.07193848490715027,
-0.1351189762353897,
0.01838606409728527,
0.12411749362945557,
-0.07740358263254166,
0.004798527341336012,
-0.024614349007606506,
0.7873393893241882,
-0.3342095613479614,
0.13632413744926453,
0.024045614525675774,
0.04303955286741257,
-0.001078563742339611,
0.2475908100605011,
0.37580907344818115,
0.4561149775981903,
-0.11521397531032562,
-0.1431543529033661,
0.11884430050849915,
-0.3435761332511902,
0.2379293143749237,
0.2839771807193756,
-0.10321281105279922,
-0.3207172155380249,
0.05689607560634613,
0.8278999924659729,
0.5959429740905762,
-0.3923001289367676,
0.7015396356582642,
-0.13948023319244385,
-0.42958730459213257,
-0.28207913041114807,
-0.10066939890384674,
-0.11560668796300888,
0.33090224862098694,
0.48814037442207336,
0.10801155865192413,
0.16833357512950897,
-0.47487542033195496,
0.3241240680217743,
0.2725781798362732,
-0.6136581897735596,
-0.39836475253105164,
0.6780408620834351,
0.4042147994041443,
0.3287365436553955,
0.3697395920753479,
-0.3244888484477997,
-0.7413790225982666,
0.5445495843887329,
0.25965771079063416,
1.163642168045044,
-0.15845531225204468,
0.4443834125995636,
0.40205854177474976,
0.35472962260246277,
-0.5958724617958069,
0.3955235779285431,
-0.12113244086503983,
-0.6358546018600464,
-0.6228933930397034,
-0.7200249433517456,
-0.2758057415485382,
0.33405542373657227,
-0.6818016767501831,
0.5725662112236023,
-0.5843605995178223,
-0.06187725439667702,
-0.17117926478385925,
-0.0328405536711216,
-1.0225298404693604,
0.011626644991338253,
0.40570154786109924,
0.48941555619239807,
-1.0476038455963135,
0.479135125875473,
0.48968932032585144,
-0.41317352652549744,
-0.9440068006515503,
-0.021127890795469284,
0.16039444506168365,
-0.7561330795288086,
0.6486718058586121,
0.3644905686378479,
-0.34408900141716003,
0.14507052302360535,
-0.5516090989112854,
-0.88652503490448,
0.9131631255149841,
0.2482643723487854,
-0.45586511492729187,
-0.4060763716697693,
-0.2643987536430359,
0.5614420175552368,
-0.3260759115219116,
0.4000415503978729,
0.4086363613605499,
0.7220682501792908,
-0.18460895121097565,
-0.8155827522277832,
0.01719476841390133,
-0.38053765892982483,
-0.34810519218444824,
0.22189217805862427,
-0.6510336995124817,
0.4189094007015228,
-0.1870756447315216,
-0.3841904103755951,
-0.3066938817501068,
0.47190624475479126,
0.14885300397872925,
0.2464989870786667,
0.6666505336761475,
0.2480858564376831,
0.9226065874099731,
-0.4196043610572815,
1.14645254611969,
-0.3237120509147644,
0.604373574256897,
0.9461173415184021,
-0.39504915475845337,
0.5661415457725525,
0.13394780457019806,
-0.1270207017660141,
0.5726733803749084,
0.8703484535217285,
-0.15346884727478027,
0.8116825222969055,
0.17898328602313995,
-0.2140011340379715,
-0.09012019634246826,
-0.02730110101401806,
-0.16395074129104614,
0.37424203753471375,
0.44598785042762756,
-0.3268362283706665,
-0.15838424861431122,
-0.15022027492523193,
-0.024403521791100502,
-0.10194624960422516,
-0.4783882796764374,
0.7865016460418701,
0.11892184615135193,
-0.6552268266677856,
0.07013893127441406,
-0.057713501155376434,
0.7624135613441467,
-0.9495748281478882,
-0.2491310089826584,
0.08056259155273438,
-0.2504546046257019,
-0.08711054921150208,
-0.38027504086494446,
0.11121106147766113,
0.3692440986633301,
0.18534114956855774,
-0.7746872901916504,
0.615103542804718,
-0.527900755405426,
-0.23529364168643951,
0.46695494651794434,
0.522516131401062,
-0.0320771299302578,
-0.2047753781080246,
-0.6910895705223083,
-0.659565269947052,
-0.030627228319644928,
-0.39093977212905884,
0.24843847751617432,
0.6251993179321289,
-0.04858236014842987,
0.4913414716720581,
0.7454332113265991,
0.011667865328490734,
-0.02006460167467594,
0.24297699332237244,
0.625816822052002,
-0.5541152954101562,
-0.8544973134994507,
-0.7445749044418335,
0.28112131357192993,
0.03458777442574501,
-0.10800117254257202,
0.6885473728179932,
0.3036395013332367,
1.0081943273544312,
-0.1899978369474411,
1.0468233823776245,
0.31476566195487976,
0.17153982818126678,
-0.7348592281341553,
0.6472412347793579,
-0.31763604283332825,
0.37366315722465515,
-0.45561230182647705,
-0.9002061486244202,
0.1939254254102707,
0.4023423194885254,
-0.6559013724327087,
0.3173811733722687,
0.647365152835846,
0.41050437092781067,
0.03709129989147186,
0.16541099548339844,
0.21377117931842804,
0.06542880088090897,
0.32525065541267395,
0.31290674209594727,
0.7912478446960449,
-0.15109115839004517,
0.559751570224762,
0.18598604202270508,
-0.20819281041622162,
-0.004153815563768148,
-1.1843265295028687,
-0.6714942455291748,
-0.4432869255542755,
-0.4721992611885071,
-0.0495201013982296,
0.10780034214258194,
1.0090640783309937,
0.6033520102500916,
-0.5683281421661377,
0.06115175038576126,
-0.12892693281173706,
-0.07357655465602875,
-0.45573359727859497,
-0.23607215285301208,
0.4594241678714752,
-0.3597920536994934,
-0.8077091574668884,
0.40706169605255127,
0.4984300136566162,
0.26890456676483154,
-0.15788233280181885,
-0.1579677164554596,
0.10011588037014008,
0.04662430286407471,
0.4175369441509247,
0.028683075681328773,
-0.6629383563995361,
-0.4923742711544037,
-0.05834733694791794,
0.1583838313817978,
-0.3239571750164032,
0.7809470295906067,
-0.5144460797309875,
0.2690484821796417,
0.2707274854183197,
0.6318277716636658,
0.5314426422119141,
0.1760227084159851,
0.7773440480232239,
-0.6508468985557556,
-0.1534976065158844,
-0.0317256897687912,
0.35868552327156067,
0.020861109718680382,
-0.639579713344574,
0.695904016494751,
0.09484324604272842,
-0.5467747449874878,
-0.4239732623100281,
0.11803533881902695,
-0.5048090815544128,
-0.02772022783756256,
1.365248441696167,
-0.4131820797920227,
-0.0875093936920166,
-0.16950185596942902,
-0.11508065462112427,
0.10057714581489563,
-0.5937871932983398,
0.805681049823761,
1.1368941068649292,
-0.028107941150665283,
-0.150932177901268,
-0.6580150127410889,
1.0074785947799683,
0.15652580559253693,
-0.7455930113792419,
0.01832076720893383,
0.3332139253616333,
0.2820360064506531,
-0.1342311054468155,
0.6801310777664185,
-0.22303706407546997,
0.16815729439258575,
-0.1585559993982315,
-0.1735685020685196,
-0.029030848294496536,
-0.35309913754463196,
-0.6328104138374329,
0.13193479180335999,
-0.07631778717041016,
0.25911763310432434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04272v1
|
Selecting Query-bag as Pseudo Relevance Feedback for Information-seeking Conversations
| 2024-03-22T08:10:32 | 2024-03-22T08:10:32 |
Xiaoqing Zhang, Xiuying Chen, Shen Gao, Shuqi Li, Xin Gao, Ji-Rong Wen, Rui Yan
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Information-seeking dialogue systems are widely used in e-commerce systems,
with answers that must be tailored to fit the specific settings of the online
system. Given the user query, the information-seeking dialogue systems first
retrieve a subset of response candidates, then further select the best response
from the candidate set through re-ranking. Current methods mainly retrieve
response candidates based solely on the current query, however, incorporating
similar questions could introduce more diverse content, potentially refining
the representation and improving the matching process. Hence, in this paper, we
proposed a Query-bag based Pseudo Relevance Feedback framework (QB-PRF), which
constructs a query-bag with related queries to serve as pseudo signals to guide
information-seeking conversations. Concretely, we first propose a Query-bag
Selection module (QBS), which utilizes contrastive learning to train the
selection of synonymous queries in an unsupervised manner by leveraging the
representations learned from pre-trained VAE. Secondly, we come up with a
Query-bag Fusion module (QBF) that fuses synonymous queries to enhance the
semantic representation of the original query through multidimensional
attention computation. We verify the effectiveness of the QB-PRF framework on
two competitive pretrained backbone models, including BERT and GPT-2.
Experimental results on two benchmark datasets show that our framework achieves
superior performance over strong baselines.
|
[
-0.56107497215271,
-0.6031468510627747,
0.17694544792175293,
-0.19258731603622437,
-0.44824618101119995,
-0.055039580911397934,
0.056013885885477066,
-0.4977360665798187,
0.8153769373893738,
0.35452428460121155,
-0.7798192501068115,
-0.23812417685985565,
0.0039032003842294216,
-0.03403405845165253,
-0.5875577926635742,
1.1465309858322144,
0.5076208710670471,
0.08443893492221832,
-0.28096863627433777,
-0.1629391610622406,
-0.279323011636734,
-0.7848498821258545,
-0.49211519956588745,
0.17204438149929047,
0.651515781879425,
0.28432998061180115,
0.4061386287212372,
-0.19551406800746918,
0.47470027208328247,
0.15858356654644012,
0.049201756715774536,
0.12966510653495789,
-0.8002657294273376,
0.20911546051502228,
-0.5742858648300171,
-0.7636491656303406,
-0.1087409257888794,
-0.16397708654403687,
0.6908102631568909,
0.4501096308231354,
-0.5006361603736877,
0.15330567955970764,
0.20408481359481812,
0.5750726461410522,
-0.9107467532157898,
-0.1748422235250473,
-0.8573606610298157,
-0.09645653516054153,
-0.14820930361747742,
-0.3341822624206543,
-0.3328903913497925,
-0.21327835321426392,
0.36200979351997375,
-0.6944524049758911,
0.26837676763534546,
0.5859488248825073,
1.1038806438446045,
-0.2287721335887909,
-0.25415661931037903,
-0.17781531810760498,
-0.7601863145828247,
0.83995121717453,
-0.42676571011543274,
0.4561556577682495,
0.7516981363296509,
0.48814553022384644,
-0.14602787792682648,
-0.8086116909980774,
-0.6267648339271545,
-0.20256197452545166,
-0.41193386912345886,
0.6155611276626587,
0.10543911159038544,
0.17291264235973358,
0.09713548421859741,
0.5616212487220764,
-0.7032954096794128,
-0.3400176465511322,
-0.2357005923986435,
-0.1585308015346527,
0.36799633502960205,
0.11423800140619278,
-0.1212330088019371,
-0.03046269901096821,
-0.3336697816848755,
-0.2582055330276489,
-0.6576446294784546,
0.11853986978530884,
0.404338002204895,
0.22857871651649475,
0.28405436873435974,
0.428465873003006,
-0.6683453917503357,
1.1078393459320068,
0.18661746382713318,
0.04442083463072777,
-0.048744551837444305,
-0.74224454164505,
-0.019034475088119507,
-0.3896649181842804,
0.6653380393981934,
0.44181883335113525,
-0.23427873849868774,
-0.039061639457941055,
-0.422540545463562,
-0.4736025035381317,
0.5307036638259888,
-0.8369885087013245,
-0.36347630620002747,
0.12403124570846558,
-0.674109697341919,
-0.0014817817136645317,
0.3568069338798523,
-0.9305601119995117,
0.011965609155595303,
-0.13496169447898865,
0.5217447280883789,
-0.02778756618499756,
-0.3348511755466461,
0.01161132100969553,
-0.13101010024547577,
0.4219350814819336,
0.23107025027275085,
-0.5820633172988892,
0.14182603359222412,
0.18308110535144806,
0.5877076983451843,
0.1642036736011505,
0.2711503505706787,
-0.7519575953483582,
0.20516735315322876,
-0.2749771475791931,
1.114194393157959,
-0.8504180908203125,
-0.7129578590393066,
0.2115049958229065,
-0.11441482603549957,
-0.029852479696273804,
-0.6140792369842529,
0.5260645747184753,
-0.9312236309051514,
0.38262006640434265,
-0.6360327005386353,
-0.38545286655426025,
-0.013526130467653275,
0.6837090253829956,
-0.4399555027484894,
1.1261613368988037,
0.08385855704545975,
-1.02878999710083,
0.24043777585029602,
-0.37246039509773254,
-0.31325215101242065,
0.12487082183361053,
-0.2008771002292633,
-0.4146077334880829,
-0.015366784296929836,
0.02325252816081047,
-0.10820594429969788,
-0.5635244250297546,
-0.04087144136428833,
-0.735787034034729,
-0.5782991647720337,
0.14909394085407257,
0.10927408188581467,
0.2826065719127655,
0.22476811707019806,
-0.0688929557800293,
0.11608254164457321,
-0.4516215920448303,
0.37170884013175964,
0.09102895110845566,
-0.14638349413871765,
-0.22300046682357788,
0.08379855751991272,
-0.09692008793354034,
0.13270030915737152,
0.1528853178024292,
-0.3639795482158661,
0.1218077540397644,
-0.5394197702407837,
-0.0050446996465325356,
0.41003909707069397,
0.06699012219905853,
0.28042712807655334,
-0.6433053016662598,
0.6129101514816284,
0.03396745026111603,
0.2718099057674408,
-0.15971827507019043,
-0.3558025658130646,
-0.7363107800483704,
-0.008618541993200779,
0.5470787286758423,
0.4545521140098572,
-1.0764057636260986,
0.40251103043556213,
-0.14779919385910034,
-0.29352259635925293,
-0.46893036365509033,
0.021815668791532516,
0.3010106086730957,
0.5008700489997864,
0.39626544713974,
-0.48417842388153076,
-0.2458026111125946,
-1.053770899772644,
-0.245560422539711,
-0.838234543800354,
-0.3090021014213562,
0.667130172252655,
0.06059595197439194,
0.17714336514472961,
1.122341275215149,
-0.7051047682762146,
-0.5391454100608826,
-0.2723039388656616,
0.14395755529403687,
0.09240728616714478,
0.185224249958992,
0.5388985276222229,
-1.119140386581421,
-0.24307876825332642,
-0.3588087260723114,
-0.06099001318216324,
-0.06813684850931168,
0.04780281335115433,
-0.5737938284873962,
-0.31904739141464233,
0.05804380774497986,
-0.5568361878395081,
0.6418872475624084,
-0.025145556777715683,
0.2204049974679947,
0.6537677645683289,
0.024130042642354965,
0.41827303171157837,
-0.9296744465827942,
0.5046296715736389,
-0.005483684130012989,
-0.16613729298114777,
-0.29487887024879456,
-0.13575227558612823,
0.039687372744083405,
0.06738758087158203,
-0.37195295095443726,
0.576354444026947,
-0.2602093815803528,
-0.2737237215042114,
-0.34713345766067505,
0.3161882758140564,
0.22397276759147644,
0.5129032731056213,
0.38816002011299133,
0.6197737455368042,
0.26290324330329895,
-0.9167665243148804,
0.35130199790000916,
0.26384663581848145,
-0.36495494842529297,
0.8585887551307678,
-0.3861188292503357,
0.2369275987148285,
-0.12400150299072266,
0.614614725112915,
-1.1339892148971558,
-0.13588817417621613,
0.38202208280563354,
-0.4326275885105133,
0.24795293807983398,
-0.21680454909801483,
-0.711683988571167,
-0.7516117095947266,
-0.5080733895301819,
0.5092097520828247,
0.31862881779670715,
-0.4676205813884735,
0.5533806085586548,
0.38730838894844055,
-0.0936380922794342,
-0.6083400845527649,
-0.4098459482192993,
-0.23158994317054749,
0.041803739964962006,
-0.2813248038291931,
0.4428935945034027,
-0.3814783990383148,
0.12075807899236679,
-0.10982757061719894,
-0.2622544765472412,
-0.2515273988246918,
-0.09774284064769745,
-0.26768943667411804,
0.3208151161670685,
-0.0302401315420866,
0.38734862208366394,
-0.07372258603572845,
0.1558537781238556,
-0.2768040895462036,
-0.6106069684028625,
0.38135603070259094,
0.016285020858049393,
-0.4578925371170044,
-0.2045879364013672,
0.43439018726348877,
-0.013828255236148834,
-0.5149550437927246,
0.7426473498344421,
0.5833756327629089,
-0.1407908946275711,
-0.05238104611635208,
-0.6935005784034729,
-0.8697859644889832,
-0.4233667552471161,
0.34845826029777527,
-0.4913192093372345,
-0.9331419467926025,
0.45751193165779114,
-0.07204415649175644,
-0.036416683346033096,
0.09135939180850983,
0.3115569055080414,
-0.35455968976020813,
1.000089406967163,
0.5709502696990967,
0.06065916270017624,
0.7465629577636719,
-0.12020418792963028,
0.6042516231536865,
-0.7310091257095337,
-0.4372422695159912,
-0.7512392997741699,
-0.4949236512184143,
-0.3359929621219635,
-0.13206827640533447,
0.2929737865924835,
0.4374626874923706,
0.3181871771812439,
0.1959865242242813,
-0.49437326192855835,
0.3919195830821991,
0.7396441102027893,
0.14327865839004517,
0.02540944144129753,
-0.03549263998866081,
-0.2714327573776245,
0.026560671627521515,
-0.8385306000709534,
0.05374244228005409,
0.9577411413192749,
-0.35357192158699036,
0.7510960698127747,
0.16083277761936188,
0.44650349020957947,
0.11532719433307648,
0.24343053996562958,
-0.8014517426490784,
0.5923236012458801,
0.24482369422912598,
-0.8466105461120605,
0.052744172513484955,
-0.5210491418838501,
-0.8631613254547119,
0.4464651644229889,
-0.2915846109390259,
-0.963629424571991,
0.2722707688808441,
0.35672318935394287,
-0.6258495450019836,
0.16341492533683777,
-0.4888457655906677,
0.6265305876731873,
-0.28995463252067566,
-0.725455641746521,
-0.2891409993171692,
-0.9773213863372803,
0.1313932090997696,
0.005832073278725147,
0.027253255248069763,
0.24674145877361298,
0.12805001437664032,
0.6814802885055542,
-0.1264508068561554,
0.5875649452209473,
-0.05268504470586777,
0.25590211153030396,
0.6540233492851257,
0.1261192113161087,
0.4960457980632782,
0.19763919711112976,
-0.01666346937417984,
-0.0930953323841095,
0.3770577013492584,
-0.42019593715667725,
-0.7565628290176392,
0.5462311506271362,
-0.2876080870628357,
-1.0907765626907349,
-0.3501019775867462,
0.029645057395100594,
-0.3971269428730011,
0.26891404390335083,
0.354269415140152,
0.37574318051338196,
-0.10273120552301407,
0.41501808166503906,
0.5452367067337036,
0.009209616109728813,
0.1900845468044281,
0.8011035323143005,
-0.4468090832233429,
-0.16725923120975494,
0.9115447402000427,
0.16501444578170776,
0.10589194297790527,
0.9036548733711243,
-0.05281761288642883,
-0.673689067363739,
-0.3912607431411743,
-0.24279995262622833,
0.20180778205394745,
-0.48376429080963135,
-0.47846028208732605,
-0.7030729651451111,
-0.06030022352933884,
-0.4569545388221741,
0.36075741052627563,
-0.22837164998054504,
-0.1919095814228058,
-0.2320730984210968,
-0.04147699847817421,
-0.21751487255096436,
0.38992446660995483,
0.13725221157073975,
0.2612595856189728,
-0.8741035461425781,
0.2552931606769562,
0.3170338273048401,
0.3553828001022339,
-0.18942353129386902,
-0.5487496256828308,
-0.40935802459716797,
0.18903784453868866,
-0.5954854488372803,
-1.0463781356811523,
0.0911666676402092,
0.2837519943714142,
0.6394659280776978,
0.4850926697254181,
0.66752028465271,
0.733851432800293,
0.1423126459121704,
0.8602893948554993,
0.16885629296302795,
-0.41318756341934204,
0.8580348491668701,
-0.18737804889678955,
0.2670367360115051,
0.735645055770874,
0.4483333230018616,
-0.2658478319644928,
-0.29525071382522583,
-0.5137239098548889,
-0.7390580177307129,
0.9825008511543274,
0.37142154574394226,
-0.04450873285531998,
-0.1725970357656479,
0.3704807758331299,
-0.0908624604344368,
0.5652714371681213,
-0.5791135430335999,
-0.1539931446313858,
-0.22565330564975739,
0.03557303547859192,
0.41425415873527527,
-0.5058345198631287,
-0.07104454189538956,
0.0030893059447407722,
0.7790076732635498,
-0.29961660504341125,
0.40189531445503235,
0.3115360140800476,
0.1323108673095703,
0.09705986827611923,
0.2414724975824356,
0.17457176744937897,
0.5883452892303467,
-0.4763593077659607,
-0.29175394773483276,
-0.014202061109244823,
-0.17158497869968414,
-0.23158064484596252,
0.08799911290407181,
-0.14000773429870605,
-0.006624285131692886,
-0.23214681446552277,
0.5179511308670044,
0.1874125897884369,
-0.7856262922286987,
0.7218136787414551,
-0.38351887464523315,
0.06850641220808029,
-0.1668434590101242,
0.04743433743715286,
-0.11487068235874176,
-0.10784377157688141,
0.39677098393440247,
-0.18925845623016357,
0.7079421877861023,
-0.572227954864502,
0.3649807572364807,
0.7241698503494263,
-0.4417728781700134,
-0.29199251532554626,
0.4087144434452057,
0.34334060549736023,
-0.1599387228488922,
0.6537119746208191,
-0.2363724559545517,
-0.6024751663208008,
0.22662906348705292,
0.44691988825798035,
0.6147934198379517,
-0.3525155782699585,
0.20759744942188263,
0.7328997254371643,
0.030892634764313698,
-0.14681608974933624,
0.06551079452037811,
-0.692126452922821,
-0.4814871847629547,
-0.08051247149705887,
-0.8868486285209656,
-0.3355098366737366,
0.26069310307502747,
-0.9634236097335815,
0.6248961687088013,
-0.41685935854911804,
-0.5433191657066345,
-0.5332201719284058,
0.02937856689095497,
-0.5923233032226562,
0.4120008647441864,
-0.21663957834243774,
0.4839876592159271,
-0.174819216132164,
0.7962363362312317,
0.9367953538894653,
-0.5123953223228455,
-0.6274257302284241,
0.4591706693172455,
-0.034693483263254166,
-0.3738263249397278,
0.4140544533729553,
0.3216884136199951,
-0.3587503135204315,
-0.05749043449759483,
-0.23380401730537415,
-0.8173085451126099,
0.8369995951652527,
0.2515746057033539,
-0.9172314405441284,
-0.14271634817123413,
-0.23070377111434937,
0.42697015404701233,
-0.24269121885299683,
1.1238394975662231,
0.26158300042152405,
0.11209139227867126,
0.5698155760765076,
-0.9898421168327332,
-0.42964231967926025,
-0.4023045301437378,
-0.006799775641411543,
0.2332904040813446,
-0.9512991905212402,
0.20678646862506866,
-0.03247867524623871,
-0.383806049823761,
0.3482973277568817,
0.5959498286247253,
0.1644725203514099,
0.2226121425628662,
0.4987919330596924,
0.5116665363311768,
0.6011581420898438,
-0.0062581817619502544,
1.1742266416549683,
-0.33265358209609985,
0.47661644220352173,
1.1516616344451904,
-0.3941337764263153,
1.0866221189498901,
0.3219560384750366,
-0.24131490290164948,
0.4382476806640625,
0.897208571434021,
0.39501267671585083,
0.8290418386459351,
0.323771595954895,
-0.288187175989151,
-0.5816789269447327,
-0.299765944480896,
-0.49971187114715576,
0.18570445477962494,
0.3979341685771942,
-0.09618618339300156,
-0.1616862416267395,
-0.19849875569343567,
-0.4860614240169525,
-0.2442447990179062,
-0.034819383174180984,
1.0426815748214722,
0.10906937718391418,
-0.7901830077171326,
0.3795355558395386,
-0.1337704062461853,
0.5238988399505615,
-0.8052316904067993,
-0.13681261241436005,
-0.3999459445476532,
0.033107612282037735,
-0.049602244049310684,
-0.5907760262489319,
0.1561625599861145,
-0.39502468705177307,
-0.21513153612613678,
0.24249228835105896,
0.8976156711578369,
-0.5352957844734192,
-0.20461344718933105,
0.48680028319358826,
0.26464223861694336,
0.04333970695734024,
-0.21052969992160797,
-0.9426099061965942,
-0.11965543031692505,
0.0909249559044838,
-0.282193124294281,
0.5163256525993347,
0.007924211211502552,
0.055920038372278214,
0.6689841151237488,
0.7667588591575623,
-0.0697585940361023,
-0.21485480666160583,
0.016963526606559753,
0.9531122446060181,
-0.5981490015983582,
-0.987987756729126,
-0.26261717081069946,
0.32852208614349365,
-0.3217002749443054,
-0.026134034618735313,
0.29407843947410583,
0.6044501066207886,
1.1057473421096802,
0.19201786816120148,
0.6589268445968628,
0.08466684073209763,
0.6914576292037964,
-0.4125249683856964,
0.3379650413990021,
-0.8747986555099487,
0.5791394114494324,
0.07032109051942825,
-1.3878766298294067,
0.03217953070998192,
0.7431409358978271,
-0.29633110761642456,
0.5140458941459656,
0.7401355504989624,
1.098064661026001,
-0.05224568024277687,
0.1965198814868927,
0.4332245886325836,
0.00813517440110445,
0.24004842340946198,
0.494092732667923,
0.9418360590934753,
-0.2900318503379822,
0.9077417254447937,
0.07987671345472336,
-0.2044941782951355,
-0.6814508438110352,
-0.39614832401275635,
-0.7460916638374329,
-0.6560609340667725,
-0.33280375599861145,
-0.472312331199646,
0.22479739785194397,
0.6454837322235107,
1.0095387697219849,
-0.7246363162994385,
-0.10684829205274582,
0.22711850702762604,
-0.01617109775543213,
0.10983549803495407,
-0.2786332964897156,
0.11426521092653275,
-0.33294838666915894,
-0.6173583269119263,
0.10884915292263031,
0.4753299355506897,
-0.11094909906387329,
0.0818539634346962,
0.11983200907707214,
-0.2867830991744995,
0.21474193036556244,
0.2252185344696045,
0.39149540662765503,
-0.6705613732337952,
-0.156255304813385,
0.0067035905085504055,
0.056576624512672424,
0.01951189711689949,
1.0196694135665894,
-1.0496187210083008,
0.8321409225463867,
0.48793405294418335,
0.6766144037246704,
0.8467092514038086,
0.22846508026123047,
0.563866376876831,
-0.683582603931427,
0.1428977996110916,
0.4935566484928131,
0.20585884153842926,
0.30680975317955017,
-0.33253541588783264,
0.2634441554546356,
0.42530590295791626,
-0.35559767484664917,
-0.6563805937767029,
0.4861085116863251,
-0.7514178156852722,
-0.14158830046653748,
1.0560065507888794,
-0.2641981542110443,
-0.2856244444847107,
-0.11887630820274353,
-0.3836822807788849,
-0.002644396387040615,
-0.5117327570915222,
0.8267804384231567,
0.6520626544952393,
-0.11366771161556244,
-0.22855883836746216,
-0.1554853916168213,
0.39124998450279236,
0.8722800016403198,
-0.5291494727134705,
-0.22865895926952362,
0.4678103029727936,
0.03659246489405632,
0.20430268347263336,
0.8780938386917114,
-0.1452401578426361,
0.32829904556274414,
-0.20137421786785126,
-0.2811121344566345,
0.3909960091114044,
-0.29510658979415894,
0.3141317665576935,
0.24699655175209045,
0.024524562060832977,
-0.2109386920928955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14990v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14990v3
|
MasonTigers at SemEval-2024 Task 1: An Ensemble Approach for Semantic Textual Relatedness
| 2024-03-22T06:47:42 | 2024-04-06T00:42:36 |
Dhiman Goswami, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Md Nishat Raihan, Al Nahian Bin Emran, Amrita Ganguly, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents the MasonTigers entry to the SemEval-2024 Task 1 -
Semantic Textual Relatedness. The task encompasses supervised (Track A),
unsupervised (Track B), and cross-lingual (Track C) approaches across 14
different languages. MasonTigers stands out as one of the two teams who
participated in all languages across the three tracks. Our approaches achieved
rankings ranging from 11th to 21st in Track A, from 1st to 8th in Track B, and
from 5th to 12th in Track C. Adhering to the task-specific constraints, our
best performing approaches utilize ensemble of statistical machine learning
approaches combined with language-specific BERT based models and sentence
transformers.
|
[
-0.4911130368709564,
-0.5358901619911194,
0.7184885740280151,
0.34966009855270386,
-0.262000173330307,
0.0030276812613010406,
-0.2544601559638977,
-0.7318910956382751,
0.27460137009620667,
0.6114626526832581,
-0.9828008413314819,
-0.7084583044052124,
-0.7986189126968384,
0.48344850540161133,
-0.3911290466785431,
1.0486946105957031,
0.07023819535970688,
0.12259908765554428,
-0.4678192734718323,
-0.2553817927837372,
-0.49876126646995544,
-0.46965187788009644,
-0.4432649612426758,
-0.22533249855041504,
0.44694244861602783,
0.3571942150592804,
0.3637656271457672,
0.3030270040035248,
0.6878830790519714,
0.3055087924003601,
0.21222414076328278,
-0.19251298904418945,
-0.2898254096508026,
0.4670007824897766,
-0.5186524987220764,
-0.47108256816864014,
-0.29924556612968445,
0.07577101141214371,
0.472001314163208,
0.6310206651687622,
0.3028492033481598,
0.33113032579421997,
0.19057942926883698,
0.37115973234176636,
-0.5270727276802063,
0.2111709862947464,
-0.7678354382514954,
-0.12988540530204773,
-0.2987443804740906,
-0.5846821069717407,
-0.5712046027183533,
-0.13987909257411957,
0.34191209077835083,
-0.7896547317504883,
0.41232922673225403,
0.26559412479400635,
0.6464509963989258,
0.5450040698051453,
-0.6793103218078613,
-0.5490744113922119,
-0.2217613011598587,
1.0762566328048706,
-0.5104376673698425,
0.22469179332256317,
0.8319581747055054,
0.11898409575223923,
-0.04598715156316757,
-0.8737321496009827,
-0.15768888592720032,
0.2831481993198395,
-0.31307128071784973,
0.24635621905326843,
-0.0500030517578125,
-0.1710439920425415,
-0.23521822690963745,
-0.03242800012230873,
-0.7384178638458252,
0.017706867307424545,
-0.316311776638031,
-0.21779181063175201,
0.8260819911956787,
0.24681229889392853,
0.15292873978614807,
-0.037996556609869,
-0.6390608549118042,
0.013563339598476887,
-0.5855394601821899,
-0.04909627512097359,
0.2526584565639496,
0.2136223316192627,
0.050152067095041275,
0.42905494570732117,
-0.4163070619106293,
0.608707845211029,
0.1230383813381195,
0.07591385394334793,
0.3075993061065674,
-0.6042512059211731,
-0.21024934947490692,
0.524220883846283,
0.766793429851532,
0.02252228371798992,
-0.028163118287920952,
-0.30537113547325134,
-0.0998484417796135,
0.10205777734518051,
0.221797913312912,
-0.5086132884025574,
-0.3897075653076172,
0.28828829526901245,
-0.6218516230583191,
-0.4569168984889984,
-0.017490392550826073,
-0.6096782088279724,
-0.17479826509952545,
-0.38908204436302185,
0.7572593688964844,
-0.5045700669288635,
-0.18389669060707092,
-0.17526327073574066,
-0.09050711244344711,
0.3280443847179413,
0.4101340174674988,
-1.102813720703125,
0.32569751143455505,
1.0774167776107788,
0.480621337890625,
-0.3807627260684967,
-0.5933539867401123,
-0.32738861441612244,
0.2087104320526123,
-0.18188446760177612,
1.0570467710494995,
-0.7696644067764282,
-0.31737223267555237,
-0.16736313700675964,
0.30410638451576233,
-0.4462014436721802,
-0.38919797539711,
0.7976900339126587,
-0.3590410053730011,
0.2713572680950165,
-0.09570629894733429,
-0.7163938283920288,
-0.4859188199043274,
0.5106474161148071,
-0.7135310173034668,
1.1758379936218262,
-0.2457786351442337,
-0.8522257208824158,
0.6196257472038269,
-0.31270647048950195,
-0.461853951215744,
0.17709600925445557,
-0.21081338822841644,
-0.23431216180324554,
0.08968482911586761,
0.12971045076847076,
0.8436906337738037,
-0.2514328360557556,
0.47409552335739136,
-0.055100031197071075,
-0.300251305103302,
0.048425450921058655,
-0.32009273767471313,
0.8412073254585266,
0.37600502371788025,
-0.33281585574150085,
0.26763734221458435,
-0.8312050700187683,
0.10583984106779099,
-0.09719465672969818,
-0.09237871319055557,
-0.6164157390594482,
-0.00247694063000381,
0.12106059491634369,
0.1880912482738495,
0.40165767073631287,
-0.2972245216369629,
0.04132125899195671,
-0.3335319459438324,
0.11629089713096619,
0.6068959832191467,
0.2894817590713501,
0.5918611288070679,
-0.3910025954246521,
0.5344477891921997,
-0.070427805185318,
0.03657998517155647,
-0.3767346441745758,
-0.6448516249656677,
-0.7176486253738403,
-0.25641319155693054,
0.47725358605384827,
0.6846786737442017,
-0.7130535244941711,
0.3083997368812561,
-0.43978866934776306,
-0.6946649551391602,
-0.14266113936901093,
-0.1777995526790619,
0.3936768174171448,
0.03615985065698624,
0.3042464852333069,
-0.12834805250167847,
-0.6447227001190186,
-0.7986416816711426,
-0.400875985622406,
-0.43986546993255615,
0.12144535034894943,
-0.28492802381515503,
0.753862738609314,
-0.2025829404592514,
0.5639959573745728,
-0.18460573256015778,
-0.2962266504764557,
0.2049131840467453,
0.2979508340358734,
0.2730618715286255,
0.6319480538368225,
0.4396243989467621,
-0.9557380676269531,
-0.27376416325569153,
0.18134815990924835,
-0.8883727788925171,
0.015107298269867897,
0.1296679824590683,
-0.1400037407875061,
0.5112076997756958,
0.6963783502578735,
0.013270048424601555,
0.2886579930782318,
0.8114127516746521,
-0.7535169124603271,
0.2053951770067215,
0.11666090041399002,
0.45979994535446167,
-1.373185634613037,
-0.23555336892604828,
-0.09067000448703766,
-0.29309433698654175,
-0.6607877016067505,
-0.10073227435350418,
-0.22642658650875092,
0.23507146537303925,
-0.3199988305568695,
0.5479934811592102,
-0.34494906663894653,
0.054078467190265656,
0.12562207877635956,
-0.06115231290459633,
-0.4100407361984253,
0.5702873468399048,
0.16961327195167542,
0.45136111974716187,
0.5776894688606262,
-0.5160230398178101,
0.3171888291835785,
0.3088635802268982,
-0.21457429230213165,
0.6631996631622314,
-0.38207507133483887,
-0.20250704884529114,
0.01731306128203869,
0.08360535651445389,
-1.2470989227294922,
-0.2859359681606293,
0.1947997361421585,
-0.8793408870697021,
0.3475022614002228,
-0.07040052115917206,
-0.4654136300086975,
0.1350524127483368,
-0.29124942421913147,
0.6903669834136963,
0.3547903001308441,
-0.39204978942871094,
0.6997535228729248,
0.5703503489494324,
-0.46058908104896545,
-0.41728225350379944,
-0.7360732555389404,
0.21020415425300598,
-0.4935074746608734,
-1.0137990713119507,
0.2699337601661682,
0.23870740830898285,
-0.3693346083164215,
0.28773561120033264,
-0.06583350151777267,
-0.22875645756721497,
0.22743932902812958,
0.23668615520000458,
0.254520058631897,
-0.14068764448165894,
0.30199313163757324,
-0.1971471607685089,
-0.21144863963127136,
0.26333561539649963,
-0.5527893304824829,
0.29377123713493347,
-0.07875099778175354,
-0.14022505283355713,
-0.011084554716944695,
0.34180209040641785,
0.10446415841579437,
-0.24025529623031616,
0.7400544881820679,
0.6815664172172546,
-0.40103691816329956,
-0.11811786890029907,
-0.6344195008277893,
-0.09094357490539551,
-0.3935156762599945,
0.22278720140457153,
-0.6227999925613403,
-1.3952025175094604,
0.5069224834442139,
-0.15360864996910095,
0.04371379688382149,
0.8079361319541931,
0.7076349258422852,
-0.10253369808197021,
0.9941993355751038,
0.5714309215545654,
0.19553248584270477,
0.0919269248843193,
-0.057937655597925186,
0.10926087200641632,
-0.4560980498790741,
-0.5857886672019958,
-0.9435526728630066,
0.04267732799053192,
-1.2670618295669556,
-0.43631428480148315,
0.2742144763469696,
-0.02964262291789055,
-0.03639402613043785,
0.745739221572876,
-0.441588431596756,
0.16208972036838531,
0.6449645757675171,
-0.29417720437049866,
0.3962099552154541,
-0.08674014359712601,
-0.24367786943912506,
0.097329281270504,
-0.8726023435592651,
-0.6410741806030273,
0.9643457531929016,
0.18123798072338104,
0.6970288157463074,
0.3241119384765625,
0.9730878472328186,
0.20901796221733093,
0.00956006720662117,
-0.6459887623786926,
0.6342644095420837,
0.04630943387746811,
-0.835626482963562,
-0.6992301344871521,
-0.13657598197460175,
-1.0461338758468628,
0.2413172572851181,
-0.48426979780197144,
-0.9579535126686096,
0.12064963579177856,
-0.07860342413187027,
0.3372534215450287,
-0.18616442382335663,
-0.42697519063949585,
0.9606131911277771,
0.11306203156709671,
-0.44810906052589417,
-0.1265181601047516,
-1.0262073278427124,
0.3288131356239319,
-0.31538519263267517,
0.46573150157928467,
-0.3071770668029785,
-0.20143207907676697,
0.9074693918228149,
-0.34198376536369324,
0.7592947483062744,
0.2693515419960022,
-0.23562046885490417,
0.3860856890678406,
0.06081761419773102,
0.5504428148269653,
0.09370191395282745,
-0.15069912374019623,
0.18382738530635834,
0.5842626690864563,
-0.5975215435028076,
-0.47182899713516235,
0.8814600110054016,
-0.4566192030906677,
-0.40458497405052185,
-0.7560795545578003,
-0.17215077579021454,
-0.43017828464508057,
0.09202729910612106,
0.5428688526153564,
0.5990961194038391,
-0.5231590270996094,
0.18871846795082092,
0.6891742944717407,
0.04830910637974739,
0.6343361139297485,
0.18272311985492706,
-0.12607212364673615,
-0.41287925839424133,
0.908591628074646,
-0.12374094128608704,
0.050975944846868515,
0.6595566272735596,
-0.07292541861534119,
-0.5235415101051331,
-0.5323528051376343,
-0.3185045123100281,
-0.01598505675792694,
-0.8512572050094604,
-0.07923870533704758,
-0.8523480892181396,
-0.009044477716088295,
-0.7799186110496521,
-0.3164348602294922,
-0.03241590037941933,
-0.7125795483589172,
-0.17185711860656738,
0.041283927857875824,
0.1711168885231018,
0.778963029384613,
0.26299548149108887,
-0.11007413268089294,
-1.0370640754699707,
-0.1665300726890564,
0.22811077535152435,
0.15217292308807373,
-0.4651559889316559,
-0.4346599280834198,
-0.24159598350524902,
-0.43010520935058594,
-0.004463017452508211,
-0.6267713904380798,
0.0680050253868103,
0.107786163687706,
0.911268413066864,
0.1807280331850052,
0.08070950955152512,
0.3645485043525696,
-0.505602240562439,
0.9520937204360962,
0.2952035963535309,
-0.9102514386177063,
0.8048540353775024,
-0.6626719832420349,
0.46285438537597656,
0.973152220249176,
0.5718753933906555,
-0.342362642288208,
-0.5691848397254944,
-0.701614499092102,
-0.7441629767417908,
0.597494900226593,
0.6366670727729797,
-0.025258781388401985,
-0.3538723886013031,
-0.27854418754577637,
0.13839292526245117,
0.04583093523979187,
-0.4829326272010803,
-0.15416085720062256,
-0.04080840200185776,
-0.5199810862541199,
-0.27737802267074585,
-0.22956562042236328,
0.16351202130317688,
0.04436982423067093,
1.1932330131530762,
-0.26053646206855774,
0.11871159076690674,
0.27597108483314514,
-0.1414947360754013,
0.19534221291542053,
0.49080023169517517,
0.6344661712646484,
0.9327340126037598,
0.030068259686231613,
0.2586531341075897,
0.5443049073219299,
-0.48675838112831116,
0.13172033429145813,
0.08313648402690887,
0.07360987365245819,
0.13082388043403625,
0.939345121383667,
0.7032356262207031,
0.4482055604457855,
-0.647495448589325,
0.5591306686401367,
-0.045282769948244095,
-0.5483799576759338,
-0.6842883825302124,
-0.20459742844104767,
0.02969028800725937,
0.2454865425825119,
0.4387463331222534,
0.13509255647659302,
0.4989026188850403,
-0.7205899357795715,
0.2990654408931732,
0.23657645285129547,
-0.9717933535575867,
-0.3099260628223419,
0.655829131603241,
0.38026392459869385,
0.06335368007421494,
0.010066674090921879,
-0.2497735172510147,
-0.6425095200538635,
0.7068204283714294,
0.41160473227500916,
0.9424924850463867,
-0.41964152455329895,
-0.09140662103891373,
0.7315592169761658,
0.43531814217567444,
-0.21610495448112488,
0.034740325063467026,
-0.14235945045948029,
-0.5588623285293579,
-0.6466239094734192,
-0.6629247069358826,
-0.13028433918952942,
-0.47023504972457886,
-0.6784332990646362,
0.7646997570991516,
-0.01631920039653778,
0.07009229809045792,
0.03833047300577164,
-0.0676644891500473,
-0.6046881079673767,
0.5069440007209778,
-0.023548481985926628,
0.8659441471099854,
-0.7220288515090942,
0.7838632464408875,
1.158248782157898,
-0.08335467427968979,
-0.7945248484611511,
-0.14355716109275818,
0.40008869767189026,
-0.48654910922050476,
0.5890675187110901,
0.051704708486795425,
-0.11200390756130219,
0.17142446339130402,
-0.3529575765132904,
-0.7322841286659241,
1.3759679794311523,
-0.2532109320163727,
-0.4847414791584015,
0.0868586078286171,
-0.12336661666631699,
0.32942354679107666,
-0.2828212380409241,
0.003833751194179058,
0.6792702078819275,
0.5264765024185181,
0.38003262877464294,
-1.0466876029968262,
-0.02126685343682766,
-0.4190357029438019,
-0.17566746473312378,
0.6521003246307373,
-0.49728208780288696,
0.44525474309921265,
0.2248823642730713,
-0.29054245352745056,
0.2738451659679413,
0.6817779541015625,
0.17607161402702332,
0.6460322737693787,
0.5290858149528503,
0.6495853066444397,
0.6290226578712463,
-0.1599760204553604,
0.9031223058700562,
-0.2625713646411896,
0.5557105541229248,
1.2889410257339478,
-0.11742343008518219,
0.6730373501777649,
0.5666612982749939,
-0.16963687539100647,
0.20874249935150146,
0.8051925301551819,
0.04981983080506325,
0.6864269375801086,
0.09548693150281906,
-0.5877030491828918,
-0.41950127482414246,
-0.29093432426452637,
-0.2595790922641754,
0.8239215016365051,
0.28214383125305176,
-0.4218638241291046,
-0.05961688235402107,
0.030147092416882515,
0.016129719093441963,
0.2670365273952484,
-0.5171979665756226,
1.1707843542099,
0.030676715075969696,
-1.0980933904647827,
0.17743095755577087,
-0.08854792267084122,
0.6749147176742554,
-0.5288910269737244,
-0.2813780605792999,
0.19907118380069733,
-0.06911374628543854,
-0.33339592814445496,
-0.8260974287986755,
0.486739844083786,
-0.1475025713443756,
-0.012314465828239918,
-0.13948211073875427,
1.160203456878662,
-0.48527583479881287,
-0.8374511003494263,
0.24752916395664215,
0.5087606906890869,
0.2211429923772812,
0.1040298119187355,
-0.2014431357383728,
-0.02932821959257126,
-0.07636836916208267,
-0.08415697515010834,
0.1917325109243393,
0.7937390804290771,
-0.41824743151664734,
0.3108825087547302,
0.2947531044483185,
-0.32471585273742676,
0.22277894616127014,
-0.04640894755721092,
0.5129818320274353,
-0.7183866500854492,
-0.5470921993255615,
-0.8629248142242432,
0.19787006080150604,
0.1400686651468277,
-0.4560105800628662,
0.9879589676856995,
0.7275002002716064,
1.2068593502044678,
0.049519360065460205,
0.8248409628868103,
-0.1846565157175064,
0.45875290036201477,
-0.8458329439163208,
0.42728346586227417,
-0.4174231290817261,
0.20607376098632812,
-0.5371111631393433,
-1.1954103708267212,
-0.32185977697372437,
0.4210338294506073,
-0.2490420937538147,
-0.25385016202926636,
1.11331045627594,
0.654906690120697,
0.05680930241942406,
0.5284313559532166,
0.5934200286865234,
-0.22806891798973083,
-0.1899956613779068,
0.6400364637374878,
0.9860898852348328,
-0.5270463228225708,
0.5877825617790222,
-0.12877851724624634,
-0.02845008671283722,
-0.05295613780617714,
-0.9098848104476929,
-1.0927060842514038,
-1.190029501914978,
-0.31768545508384705,
-0.19377544522285461,
0.09198865294456482,
0.9586436748504639,
0.5706455707550049,
-0.9333468079566956,
-0.0008596275583840907,
0.014788295142352581,
-0.21046578884124756,
0.15356065332889557,
-0.20172111690044403,
0.1751948446035385,
-0.4699128270149231,
-0.7440722584724426,
0.196768119931221,
0.3956989645957947,
-0.21295106410980225,
-0.023890839889645576,
-0.05344057455658913,
-0.5603139996528625,
-0.013802898116409779,
0.672957181930542,
-0.2796562612056732,
-0.7367148399353027,
-0.6261875033378601,
0.015174603089690208,
-0.15274205803871155,
-0.3173570930957794,
0.7737516164779663,
-0.8452454805374146,
0.2906389832496643,
0.811424970626831,
0.7973594069480896,
0.7523666024208069,
0.08312660455703735,
0.3349100649356842,
-0.5465139746665955,
0.30290114879608154,
0.37076717615127563,
0.3264717161655426,
0.1771073192358017,
-0.22189246118068695,
1.274399995803833,
0.13765265047550201,
-0.7603393197059631,
-0.3391474783420563,
0.061724334955215454,
-1.1173301935195923,
-0.4045058786869049,
1.0984458923339844,
-0.18162623047828674,
-0.36361753940582275,
-0.45509931445121765,
0.03915712237358093,
0.07980933040380478,
0.07021094858646393,
0.3708549439907074,
1.0812541246414185,
-0.11762908101081848,
-0.024206047877669334,
-0.7175848484039307,
0.3599580228328705,
0.5492858290672302,
-0.9917349219322205,
-0.5369816422462463,
0.48466819524765015,
0.32442644238471985,
0.22212809324264526,
0.7921063303947449,
-0.1533680558204651,
0.3422640264034271,
0.009570530615746975,
-0.057825569063425064,
0.39304277300834656,
-0.301933228969574,
-0.31611329317092896,
-0.022856466472148895,
-0.016710840165615082,
-0.13026227056980133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14989v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14989v2
|
MasonTigers at SemEval-2024 Task 8: Performance Analysis of Transformer-based Models on Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-03-22T06:47:28 | 2024-04-05T07:49:09 |
Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Md Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Al Nahian Bin Emran, Amrita Ganguly, Ozlem Uzuner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents the MasonTigers entry to the SemEval-2024 Task 8 -
Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Black-Box Machine-Generated Text
Detection. The task encompasses Binary Human-Written vs. Machine-Generated Text
Classification (Track A), Multi-Way Machine-Generated Text Classification
(Track B), and Human-Machine Mixed Text Detection (Track C). Our best
performing approaches utilize mainly the ensemble of discriminator transformer
models along with sentence transformer and statistical machine learning
approaches in specific cases. Moreover, zero-shot prompting and fine-tuning of
FLAN-T5 are used for Track A and B.
|
[
-0.5728937387466431,
-0.6675199866294861,
0.5024406313896179,
0.10171417891979218,
-0.039363961666822433,
0.2007092535495758,
0.05824701488018036,
-0.7938502430915833,
-0.14071527123451233,
0.7034996747970581,
-0.5962729454040527,
-0.2814904451370239,
-0.9079843163490295,
0.6982550621032715,
-0.3534102141857147,
0.9402453303337097,
0.004838652443140745,
-0.21624383330345154,
0.14042232930660248,
-0.01618257537484169,
-0.6424983143806458,
-0.5367270708084106,
-0.5161586403846741,
-0.2204044610261917,
0.39793214201927185,
0.5445338487625122,
0.21267040073871613,
0.29356274008750916,
0.4782131612300873,
0.33031222224235535,
0.06848682463169098,
0.1841229647397995,
-0.347633421421051,
0.3441288471221924,
-0.14397624135017395,
-0.3129598796367645,
-0.26380234956741333,
-0.02077898010611534,
0.5055527687072754,
0.04355510324239731,
0.3256436586380005,
0.3541308045387268,
-0.07052283734083176,
0.019429704174399376,
-0.7199464440345764,
0.055671948939561844,
-0.6602092981338501,
0.0033435840159654617,
-0.2608255445957184,
-0.5188146829605103,
-0.8126340508460999,
-0.019991541281342506,
-0.122299924492836,
-0.21150724589824677,
0.6841951012611389,
0.34293168783187866,
0.5822617411613464,
0.2836759388446808,
-0.9113774299621582,
-0.5519958734512329,
-0.7657444477081299,
0.8959600329399109,
-0.40402597188949585,
0.3540648818016052,
0.21497760713100433,
0.35716110467910767,
-0.06148819625377655,
-0.7164429426193237,
-0.4607037603855133,
0.20421062409877777,
-0.21695536375045776,
0.1280830055475235,
-0.3161833584308624,
-0.06922604888677597,
0.3736361861228943,
0.2926088571548462,
-0.6452826261520386,
-0.00959212426096201,
-0.6605923175811768,
-0.34551388025283813,
0.7427096962928772,
0.22674238681793213,
0.12966029345989227,
-0.1106211245059967,
-0.21858184039592743,
-0.00963938795030117,
-0.35155877470970154,
0.06665810197591782,
0.3734501302242279,
0.12335768342018127,
0.13108417391777039,
0.3614208698272705,
-0.15520544350147247,
0.6421524286270142,
0.14107976853847504,
-0.2350919097661972,
0.31246113777160645,
-0.38143593072891235,
-0.07644672691822052,
0.21795567870140076,
0.9204149842262268,
0.0348694734275341,
0.07894796133041382,
-0.008252794854342937,
-0.5538741946220398,
0.34208226203918457,
0.46373072266578674,
-0.9427250623703003,
-0.40080857276916504,
0.07641898095607758,
-0.7166436314582825,
-0.7344419956207275,
-0.03481171652674675,
-0.8766025304794312,
-0.38484111428260803,
-0.10301260650157928,
0.6963589191436768,
-0.1538829803466797,
-0.35508105158805847,
0.05424472689628601,
-0.24910090863704681,
0.16351322829723358,
0.1640365868806839,
-0.825780987739563,
0.11814767867326736,
0.5290961265563965,
0.5317805409431458,
-0.3192378580570221,
-0.36696314811706543,
-0.7432101964950562,
-0.0017786876996979117,
0.09432893246412277,
1.0817067623138428,
-0.5951884388923645,
-0.3605338931083679,
-0.05123615264892578,
0.4789286255836487,
-0.40887001156806946,
-0.45138785243034363,
0.9325602650642395,
-0.3026345372200012,
0.4521896243095398,
0.0917280912399292,
-0.3967427611351013,
-0.3777121901512146,
0.31049057841300964,
-0.8911696076393127,
1.1947511434555054,
-0.0690799355506897,
-0.7578291893005371,
0.3880476653575897,
-0.8392636179924011,
-0.70326828956604,
0.27151352167129517,
-0.0036975564435124397,
-0.8759808540344238,
0.21195881068706512,
0.22279639542102814,
0.7368589639663696,
-0.267007976770401,
0.4329189956188202,
0.1714743971824646,
-0.573288083076477,
0.15194037556648254,
-0.6907052993774414,
0.6848084330558777,
0.2318185567855835,
-0.8400802612304688,
0.3124176263809204,
-0.9953904151916504,
-0.245565727353096,
0.18307679891586304,
-0.2847365736961365,
0.04816884547472,
-0.029939066618680954,
0.3398812711238861,
0.4637106955051422,
0.2503107190132141,
-0.6263143420219421,
-0.06045277789235115,
0.008908651769161224,
0.259096622467041,
0.5261740684509277,
0.15613044798374176,
0.3134904205799103,
-0.2406080812215805,
0.8532254099845886,
0.16641929745674133,
0.15497758984565735,
-0.695633590221405,
-0.7539110779762268,
-0.9269870519638062,
-0.16604463756084442,
0.22568896412849426,
0.6249443888664246,
-0.8088573217391968,
0.3015385866165161,
0.06772255152463913,
-0.5115730166435242,
-0.35872572660446167,
-0.20340792834758759,
0.2802139222621918,
0.02294316329061985,
0.48986661434173584,
-0.06372290849685669,
-0.6729602813720703,
-0.7511131763458252,
-0.39948153495788574,
-0.01332024484872818,
0.17880956828594208,
-0.17664869129657745,
0.8957680463790894,
-0.3780675232410431,
0.3017570972442627,
-0.5468748211860657,
-0.06982367485761642,
-0.24552109837532043,
0.41356587409973145,
0.045398611575365067,
0.3447217047214508,
0.4042664170265198,
-0.9931318163871765,
-0.3461838364601135,
-0.1270088404417038,
-0.755522608757019,
-0.3105407953262329,
-0.03965548053383827,
0.06338602304458618,
0.21268460154533386,
0.5354083180427551,
-0.22074270248413086,
0.5893390774726868,
0.7030651569366455,
-0.6340817213058472,
0.6647560596466064,
0.055684760212898254,
0.5367171168327332,
-1.0952281951904297,
-0.09519194811582565,
0.12962855398654938,
-0.3992752730846405,
-1.0478801727294922,
0.0040899598971009254,
0.09703417122364044,
-0.21102015674114227,
-0.3454756438732147,
0.3453875780105591,
-0.4655265212059021,
0.029061416164040565,
-0.4732204079627991,
-0.266831636428833,
-0.006287537049502134,
0.4487782120704651,
-0.0938054546713829,
0.8786392211914062,
0.23304012417793274,
-0.6364310383796692,
0.06606245040893555,
0.06423896551132202,
0.031023340299725533,
0.770962655544281,
-0.5519086122512817,
0.0902591347694397,
-0.11588586866855621,
0.04109855368733406,
-1.100447654724121,
-0.06502708047628403,
0.3186239004135132,
-0.6709573268890381,
0.19889481365680695,
0.03979161009192467,
-0.3797283470630646,
-0.5021447539329529,
-0.24011285603046417,
0.4458143711090088,
0.273547887802124,
-0.4325083792209625,
0.9364220499992371,
0.39513498544692993,
0.13496261835098267,
-0.37865495681762695,
-0.48281329870224,
0.18888001143932343,
-0.4546457529067993,
-0.6734650135040283,
0.2846759259700775,
0.05961347371339798,
0.017214391380548477,
-0.1919347494840622,
0.08775178343057632,
-0.059889309108257294,
0.40584006905555725,
0.23388473689556122,
0.2614641785621643,
-0.24664349853992462,
-0.20665597915649414,
-0.0950607880949974,
-0.3704844117164612,
0.10812414437532425,
-0.32136374711990356,
0.3354555368423462,
0.04832891747355461,
-0.08822702616453171,
-0.3066328763961792,
0.348522424697876,
0.5369207262992859,
-0.508323073387146,
0.7874780297279358,
1.180083155632019,
-0.42245960235595703,
-0.17360390722751617,
-0.5746955275535583,
-0.1770428866147995,
-0.44725528359413147,
0.016110925003886223,
-0.7091735005378723,
-1.406527042388916,
0.28962358832359314,
-0.043945878744125366,
0.011286941356956959,
0.8622964024543762,
0.6975897550582886,
0.19779279828071594,
1.2991361618041992,
0.6486954689025879,
0.1855068951845169,
0.24380309879779816,
-0.10888870805501938,
0.49416056275367737,
-0.5297238230705261,
-0.2382262796163559,
-0.8895148038864136,
-0.06269139051437378,
-0.9371888041496277,
-0.2525297701358795,
0.38502535223960876,
-0.14868178963661194,
-0.0862475261092186,
0.7930526733398438,
-0.8260300159454346,
0.256329745054245,
0.6715052723884583,
-0.37637314200401306,
0.44789958000183105,
-0.3264894187450409,
-0.0749221220612526,
0.16485559940338135,
-0.49150824546813965,
-0.560675323009491,
1.0337058305740356,
0.26851141452789307,
0.5225489735603333,
0.1141405776143074,
0.7720903754234314,
0.4538596570491791,
0.13193494081497192,
-0.5402428507804871,
0.3233398497104645,
-0.07623958587646484,
-0.6875807642936707,
-0.15498395264148712,
-0.24225357174873352,
-1.093008279800415,
0.5838837027549744,
-0.36464372277259827,
-0.7178511619567871,
0.06304185092449188,
0.1267634630203247,
0.029247663915157318,
0.17102356255054474,
-0.613327145576477,
1.1965574026107788,
-0.12277858704328537,
0.01755499839782715,
0.0036212820559740067,
-0.46336275339126587,
0.5009722709655762,
-0.23462121188640594,
0.29377758502960205,
-0.14656247198581696,
0.3065577745437622,
0.7026503682136536,
0.13341566920280457,
0.6692123413085938,
-0.21143896877765656,
-0.10520726442337036,
0.3580162525177002,
0.1075427308678627,
0.5333871245384216,
-0.21013475954532623,
0.06902744621038437,
0.14779044687747955,
0.14516976475715637,
-0.0918162539601326,
-0.1613364964723587,
0.34029650688171387,
-0.45511046051979065,
-0.3360421657562256,
-0.6022315621376038,
-0.1436641812324524,
0.12109836935997009,
0.28262102603912354,
0.6642706990242004,
0.5011004209518433,
-0.2274019867181778,
0.3102237284183502,
0.6292243003845215,
-0.154925137758255,
0.6147454380989075,
0.46758174896240234,
-0.1887393742799759,
-0.4568370282649994,
0.938879668712616,
-0.2756853699684143,
-0.08347351104021072,
0.6080154180526733,
0.11981700360774994,
-0.27614712715148926,
-0.5491236448287964,
-0.5391159057617188,
-0.012976202182471752,
-0.540460467338562,
-0.36899039149284363,
-0.9410668611526489,
-0.22365683317184448,
-0.5307640433311462,
-0.152032732963562,
0.011768138036131859,
-0.35732826590538025,
-0.3996409773826599,
0.10886551439762115,
0.013110593892633915,
0.9291704297065735,
0.26461049914360046,
0.5730583667755127,
-0.9714829325675964,
0.38560739159584045,
-0.11007945984601974,
-0.05977020785212517,
-0.2754482626914978,
-0.5713729858398438,
-0.316107839345932,
-0.3343585431575775,
-0.7116091847419739,
-0.760076105594635,
0.3332435190677643,
-0.08368729054927826,
0.6297624111175537,
0.22080543637275696,
-0.10301743447780609,
0.15488408505916595,
-0.5990555286407471,
0.7125776410102844,
0.23923972249031067,
-0.9231418371200562,
0.6399295926094055,
-0.30160704255104065,
0.612200140953064,
0.4048302173614502,
0.27620312571525574,
-0.5999467372894287,
-0.5640872716903687,
-0.5452802181243896,
-0.35807594656944275,
0.7828301191329956,
0.53349769115448,
-0.13708564639091492,
0.007817386649549007,
-0.14088185131549835,
0.09514880925416946,
0.26885756850242615,
-0.821828305721283,
-0.16919556260108948,
-0.20720872282981873,
-0.46855396032333374,
-0.1943364441394806,
-0.43677669763565063,
0.3429788053035736,
0.13927525281906128,
0.8062861561775208,
-0.3513118326663971,
0.4585040807723999,
-0.111915722489357,
-0.31943824887275696,
-0.05837872624397278,
0.5152590870857239,
0.8856673240661621,
0.43699946999549866,
0.1936030089855194,
0.2569916248321533,
0.21854275465011597,
-0.49558091163635254,
0.30689537525177,
0.2910028398036957,
-0.3704020082950592,
0.10608621686697006,
0.5518185496330261,
0.9464588165283203,
0.2131866216659546,
-0.40583673119544983,
0.6493155360221863,
-0.28798481822013855,
-0.44965049624443054,
-0.5596483945846558,
0.15900950133800507,
-0.23471927642822266,
0.35061895847320557,
0.474353551864624,
0.2371441274881363,
0.6402819156646729,
-0.21788589656352997,
0.3931194841861725,
0.16815054416656494,
-0.5619078874588013,
-0.5761860609054565,
0.9672290086746216,
0.24463263154029846,
-0.4481876790523529,
0.08737331628799438,
-0.47942784428596497,
-1.0920511484146118,
0.552837073802948,
0.7052505612373352,
1.0788426399230957,
-0.6217436790466309,
0.1449974626302719,
0.4978638291358948,
0.4601513147354126,
-0.16574589908123016,
0.262370228767395,
-0.002289760624989867,
-0.8008732795715332,
-0.44574084877967834,
-0.6504029631614685,
-0.11282497644424438,
0.2101680487394333,
-0.44703760743141174,
0.6867665648460388,
-0.023354310542345047,
-0.218809574842453,
0.3595598042011261,
-0.07726912200450897,
-0.6784685254096985,
0.313922256231308,
0.07377489656209946,
0.6704574227333069,
-0.8392581939697266,
0.4210059344768524,
0.6543604135513306,
-0.18912887573242188,
-0.6327682137489319,
-0.18530824780464172,
0.34425023198127747,
-0.345517098903656,
0.3632377088069916,
0.6017119288444519,
-0.3064770996570587,
0.04914211481809616,
-0.33130598068237305,
-0.4883967339992523,
1.1056796312332153,
-0.16198714077472687,
-0.44016993045806885,
-0.004282837267965078,
0.16349175572395325,
0.34536629915237427,
-0.3121936023235321,
0.441250205039978,
0.697588324546814,
0.5057492256164551,
0.146198108792305,
-1.052817702293396,
-0.129860058426857,
-0.2654692828655243,
-0.13417977094650269,
0.6915633082389832,
-0.5150721669197083,
0.8187845349311829,
0.4083755612373352,
-0.0509110689163208,
-0.027336500585079193,
0.5255343914031982,
0.19363930821418762,
0.47348958253860474,
0.5548539161682129,
0.4935814142227173,
0.5972847938537598,
-0.14232313632965088,
0.7341108918190002,
-0.4029422104358673,
0.5126394629478455,
0.8117006421089172,
-0.1929226666688919,
0.46882325410842896,
0.06132727116346359,
0.026492910459637642,
0.4016638696193695,
0.4838918447494507,
-0.3280957341194153,
0.22107818722724915,
-0.062319863587617874,
-0.6366599798202515,
-0.1881590634584427,
-0.03274546191096306,
0.03458520397543907,
0.9670798182487488,
0.24173098802566528,
-0.5300785899162292,
0.014065146446228027,
0.20494899153709412,
-0.02254628948867321,
-0.05373266711831093,
-0.3182835578918457,
0.8298319578170776,
-0.03280097618699074,
-0.8917374610900879,
0.3034449517726898,
0.45064908266067505,
1.0094109773635864,
-0.18411195278167725,
-0.1414843499660492,
0.3004437983036041,
0.47108200192451477,
-0.23309192061424255,
-0.6790159344673157,
0.3048519492149353,
-0.04211334511637688,
-0.12187705934047699,
-0.14468783140182495,
1.4181714057922363,
-0.5471634864807129,
-0.7047846913337708,
0.2888421416282654,
0.3187659978866577,
0.050974175333976746,
-0.19513607025146484,
-0.5583660006523132,
0.24730455875396729,
0.03554770350456238,
-0.04094954952597618,
-0.07278740406036377,
0.613465428352356,
-0.25284770131111145,
0.3312839865684509,
0.4243125915527344,
-0.41370949149131775,
0.2069711685180664,
0.24519062042236328,
0.4344872534275055,
-0.729830801486969,
-0.5513631105422974,
-0.8437502980232239,
0.44068318605422974,
-0.10603798180818558,
-0.26964929699897766,
0.7941780090332031,
0.851606547832489,
0.7974079847335815,
-0.22657330334186554,
0.8471413850784302,
-0.03508342429995537,
0.51796555519104,
-0.42395010590553284,
0.3862420916557312,
-0.3143409192562103,
-0.17262518405914307,
-0.3312634527683258,
-1.1026185750961304,
-0.21741022169589996,
0.5155001878738403,
-0.0893617793917656,
-0.01496934611350298,
0.9561855792999268,
0.7574152946472168,
-0.18007659912109375,
0.47704023122787476,
0.6076319813728333,
-0.3477039933204651,
0.4811575710773468,
0.6272333860397339,
1.0696208477020264,
-0.7775994539260864,
0.7548618912696838,
-0.08227409422397614,
0.028162620961666107,
-0.2987465560436249,
-0.7142302393913269,
-1.148382544517517,
-0.7341418266296387,
-0.17674987018108368,
-0.27142810821533203,
-0.21008579432964325,
0.45001062750816345,
0.5924954414367676,
-1.167022466659546,
-0.23012354969978333,
0.16111981868743896,
-0.156716451048851,
0.058734603226184845,
-0.29548895359039307,
-0.14425861835479736,
-0.3064119517803192,
-0.7328857779502869,
0.295708030462265,
0.36149731278419495,
-0.07761137932538986,
-0.28455349802970886,
0.03393328934907913,
-0.3702279031276703,
-0.16945867240428925,
0.778122067451477,
-0.21585562825202942,
-0.4447283148765564,
-0.5100120306015015,
0.08743046969175339,
0.07125984132289886,
0.05908220261335373,
1.1650245189666748,
-0.517031192779541,
0.21637539565563202,
0.5348266959190369,
0.642211377620697,
0.7963889241218567,
0.13576257228851318,
0.492421954870224,
-0.6075181365013123,
0.001494535361416638,
0.17499467730522156,
0.3858618438243866,
0.35344070196151733,
-0.5299147367477417,
0.6262166500091553,
0.45482343435287476,
-0.9073978662490845,
-0.5841327905654907,
0.10871993750333786,
-0.48137110471725464,
-0.2930237054824829,
0.9580327868461609,
0.14393994212150574,
-0.18176676332950592,
-0.47001567482948303,
-0.21744737029075623,
0.260709285736084,
-0.24833908677101135,
0.30079686641693115,
0.7352573871612549,
-0.19241945445537567,
-0.48811790347099304,
-0.7088112831115723,
0.41338878870010376,
-0.04423551261425018,
-1.0290284156799316,
-0.3897477984428406,
0.7179406881332397,
0.2391255646944046,
0.35976845026016235,
0.7003739476203918,
0.03216584399342537,
0.36423739790916443,
0.01501934602856636,
0.15461465716362,
0.0660405308008194,
-0.6938185095787048,
-0.49168190360069275,
0.308940052986145,
-0.09644820541143417,
-0.20337963104248047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14988v1
|
Risk and Response in Large Language Models: Evaluating Key Threat Categories
| 2024-03-22T06:46:40 | 2024-03-22T06:46:40 |
Bahareh Harandizadeh, Abel Salinas, Fred Morstatter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores the pressing issue of risk assessment in Large Language
Models (LLMs) as they become increasingly prevalent in various applications.
Focusing on how reward models, which are designed to fine-tune pretrained LLMs
to align with human values, perceive and categorize different types of risks,
we delve into the challenges posed by the subjective nature of preference-based
training data. By utilizing the Anthropic Red-team dataset, we analyze major
risk categories, including Information Hazards, Malicious Uses, and
Discrimination/Hateful content. Our findings indicate that LLMs tend to
consider Information Hazards less harmful, a finding confirmed by a specially
developed regression model. Additionally, our analysis shows that LLMs respond
less stringently to Information Hazards compared to other risks. The study
further reveals a significant vulnerability of LLMs to jailbreaking attacks in
Information Hazard scenarios, highlighting a critical security concern in LLM
risk assessment and emphasizing the need for improved AI safety measures.
|
[
-0.1624218225479126,
-0.5355343222618103,
0.3116481900215149,
-0.18625982105731964,
0.0945565477013588,
0.024397779256105423,
-0.44921138882637024,
-0.7529615163803101,
-0.014490378089249134,
0.6122443675994873,
-0.3101445734500885,
-0.11794736236333847,
-0.9376704692840576,
-0.009910108521580696,
-0.33880069851875305,
1.1281869411468506,
-0.014258853159844875,
-0.23826517164707184,
-0.26110443472862244,
0.045849572867155075,
-0.5880754590034485,
-1.1232460737228394,
-0.7555901408195496,
-0.16295182704925537,
0.9035170078277588,
0.3426193296909332,
0.5884305238723755,
0.21400143206119537,
0.9403854608535767,
0.28958675265312195,
-0.04256157949566841,
-0.5771878361701965,
-0.6069372892379761,
0.20898525416851044,
-0.18316134810447693,
-0.5772007703781128,
-0.4917941093444824,
0.2707437574863434,
0.29221054911613464,
0.598406195640564,
-0.06182913854718208,
0.44457516074180603,
-0.14927026629447937,
0.7375969886779785,
-0.6627992987632751,
-0.048091866075992584,
-0.8370086550712585,
-0.04153987765312195,
-0.3194032907485962,
-0.3039855659008026,
-0.5962984561920166,
-0.3918948173522949,
0.35269200801849365,
-0.06494614481925964,
-0.27737686038017273,
0.2366342842578888,
0.43028348684310913,
0.25845450162887573,
-0.5329129099845886,
-0.305806964635849,
-0.7974681258201599,
0.7902642488479614,
-0.48018407821655273,
0.03965070843696594,
0.47271281480789185,
0.2972174286842346,
-0.027499709278345108,
-0.16247965395450592,
-0.1449533998966217,
-0.5395368933677673,
0.24453987181186676,
-0.1868806630373001,
-0.1376793384552002,
0.06021204590797424,
0.23957349359989166,
0.35139867663383484,
-0.5509493947029114,
0.6549122929573059,
-0.3545938730239868,
-0.15744970738887787,
1.0136271715164185,
0.4458329379558563,
0.3318313658237457,
0.11449830234050751,
-0.37259191274642944,
-0.4215717017650604,
-1.1492151021957397,
0.11120467633008957,
0.7436453700065613,
0.5101618766784668,
-0.08662699162960052,
0.6825788021087646,
0.16021572053432465,
0.6529481410980225,
-0.35866087675094604,
-0.12842485308647156,
0.20633308589458466,
-0.06876304000616074,
-0.23036551475524902,
0.1769910305738449,
0.8433138728141785,
0.5772587656974792,
0.5364773869514465,
-0.07592449337244034,
-0.12852318584918976,
-0.15875574946403503,
0.5347808599472046,
-0.6740018129348755,
0.09286734461784363,
0.35660338401794434,
-0.35295751690864563,
-0.6332075595855713,
-0.047669943422079086,
-0.7121294140815735,
-0.9656946659088135,
-0.017085367813706398,
0.31575697660446167,
-0.04887827858328819,
-0.3648392856121063,
0.25313928723335266,
0.16362273693084717,
0.32965487241744995,
0.35247427225112915,
-0.8543715476989746,
0.227907195687294,
0.4412005841732025,
0.5168640613555908,
-0.35024839639663696,
-0.06192201375961304,
-0.4745347797870636,
0.020568888634443283,
-0.2842475473880768,
0.6286613941192627,
-0.2920914888381958,
-0.40323755145072937,
0.146291121840477,
-0.2040805220603943,
0.037461280822753906,
-0.60284823179245,
0.44210106134414673,
-0.5562940835952759,
-0.054553285241127014,
-0.13436900079250336,
-0.346688449382782,
-0.13374684751033783,
0.5237135291099548,
-0.6778203845024109,
0.654548704624176,
0.03555793687701225,
-1.0147500038146973,
0.2894894480705261,
-0.5441746115684509,
-0.5083414912223816,
-0.009460359811782837,
-0.024074655026197433,
-0.27224841713905334,
-0.02894923835992813,
-0.40713927149772644,
0.49588099122047424,
-0.4468606412410736,
0.3096734881401062,
-0.5046525001525879,
-0.08553986996412277,
0.6735041737556458,
-0.4459981322288513,
0.441552072763443,
0.14138668775558472,
-0.24110759794712067,
0.5892335772514343,
-0.4369979798793793,
-0.09740129113197327,
0.38474783301353455,
-0.6118336915969849,
-0.5999336242675781,
0.22632259130477905,
0.15965476632118225,
0.47203314304351807,
0.32755306363105774,
-0.4497871696949005,
0.2001471221446991,
-0.32240113615989685,
0.4283585548400879,
1.0103795528411865,
-0.17500030994415283,
0.34606438875198364,
-0.19061435759067535,
0.5773642659187317,
-0.17152613401412964,
0.37254780530929565,
0.348519504070282,
-0.07896949350833893,
-0.525797963142395,
-0.1059405654668808,
0.2635805010795593,
0.7564396262168884,
-0.377692848443985,
0.398258239030838,
-0.2243063598871231,
-0.5475072860717773,
-0.21216362714767456,
-0.10643718391656876,
0.3186504542827606,
0.0024694176390767097,
0.0936296209692955,
-0.21158069372177124,
-0.5983719229698181,
-0.8253063559532166,
-0.19246581196784973,
-0.6050035357475281,
0.0541086345911026,
0.3883817791938782,
0.40425604581832886,
-0.34100502729415894,
0.5090802311897278,
-0.5173442959785461,
-0.12753388285636902,
-0.5245557427406311,
-0.14420214295387268,
0.11306298524141312,
0.4029350280761719,
0.5738604664802551,
-0.8323245048522949,
-0.33561471104621887,
-0.1308055818080902,
-0.47707659006118774,
0.10169241577386856,
0.07129518687725067,
0.2081206738948822,
0.23451703786849976,
0.607297956943512,
-0.52359539270401,
0.22329029440879822,
0.4831065535545349,
-0.23375990986824036,
0.6096649169921875,
0.1806282103061676,
0.03563012555241585,
-0.932362973690033,
0.20898570120334625,
0.044203802943229675,
-0.08673042058944702,
-0.7716479897499084,
0.06556657701730728,
-0.23305335640907288,
-0.010895430110394955,
-0.7395157814025879,
0.5892431735992432,
-0.1288924217224121,
-0.19087567925453186,
-0.4713869094848633,
-0.0655154436826706,
-0.47061511874198914,
0.07648836821317673,
0.11085055023431778,
0.6011149883270264,
0.4818269908428192,
-0.5771451592445374,
0.4486849009990692,
0.033437345176935196,
-0.41891613602638245,
0.10476651042699814,
-0.6730495095252991,
0.2352762520313263,
-0.03702684864401817,
0.03286059573292732,
-0.8319957852363586,
-0.31221893429756165,
0.191461980342865,
-0.38480910658836365,
0.4480934143066406,
0.17191921174526215,
-0.5253656506538391,
-0.49836641550064087,
-0.6104387640953064,
0.5794983506202698,
0.3434719145298004,
-0.1970975548028946,
0.14130936563014984,
0.7242797613143921,
-0.5205816626548767,
-0.6378061771392822,
-0.5423498749732971,
0.23693352937698364,
-0.7509421706199646,
-0.301756352186203,
0.03534184768795967,
-0.29349952936172485,
-0.5549887418746948,
-0.28318044543266296,
-0.027530847117304802,
0.07489051669836044,
0.7694120407104492,
0.5090274214744568,
0.45804086327552795,
0.18723712861537933,
0.09656639397144318,
-0.6442247629165649,
-0.21251073479652405,
0.2629455029964447,
0.037993889302015305,
0.7136684656143188,
-0.300817608833313,
-0.2465958595275879,
-0.009631061926484108,
0.331510066986084,
0.43207472562789917,
-0.1979030966758728,
0.9615121483802795,
0.16081421077251434,
-0.3336397409439087,
0.24389153718948364,
-0.4736603796482086,
-0.08395622670650482,
-0.4485611021518707,
0.5491958856582642,
0.04672384634613991,
-1.2778538465499878,
0.31433382630348206,
0.16827639937400818,
0.010912630707025528,
0.47480061650276184,
0.8695120811462402,
-0.2036544680595398,
0.8064411878585815,
0.7342178821563721,
-0.6445777416229248,
0.510661780834198,
0.006141133606433868,
0.19460240006446838,
-0.5144395232200623,
-0.3801974356174469,
-0.6432909369468689,
-0.02126556821167469,
-0.6958182454109192,
-0.03864407166838646,
0.404059499502182,
-0.33955514430999756,
-0.5388227701187134,
0.1873747557401657,
-0.1609177142381668,
0.3047979176044464,
0.4664091169834137,
-0.19952957332134247,
0.11124441772699356,
-0.23777523636817932,
0.4283168613910675,
0.14114660024642944,
-0.4515017867088318,
-0.596390426158905,
1.3106926679611206,
0.7478152513504028,
1.3583048582077026,
0.364319384098053,
0.5491641759872437,
0.2465338259935379,
0.4435907006263733,
-0.9888517260551453,
0.4390665590763092,
0.01516424585133791,
-0.8370716571807861,
-0.48350197076797485,
-0.4669704735279083,
-0.9711945056915283,
-0.15363678336143494,
-0.4205273985862732,
-0.8593969941139221,
-0.21973973512649536,
0.07698577642440796,
-0.35364830493927,
0.2779862582683563,
-0.6025330424308777,
0.7173753976821899,
-0.5775206685066223,
-0.18672458827495575,
-0.1573929786682129,
-0.7887696027755737,
0.5970115661621094,
-0.2690230906009674,
0.3126645088195801,
-0.1571771204471588,
0.21839863061904907,
0.9070497751235962,
0.0032552469056099653,
1.0279182195663452,
0.12467273324728012,
-0.22475232183933258,
0.0857057049870491,
0.16962145268917084,
0.4086606800556183,
-0.05816631019115448,
-0.18677888810634613,
-0.015058065764605999,
-0.08435850590467453,
-0.2592639923095703,
-0.18764612078666687,
0.5389258861541748,
-0.9021902680397034,
-0.9398836493492126,
-0.716789960861206,
-0.6812295913696289,
-0.3446468114852905,
0.07245884835720062,
0.16551633179187775,
0.021699322387576103,
-0.18358473479747772,
0.22697517275810242,
0.8157669305801392,
-0.6555443406105042,
0.29737940430641174,
0.577904224395752,
-0.12156151235103607,
-0.2113906741142273,
0.7019301056861877,
-0.06738357245922089,
0.5672122240066528,
0.30503490567207336,
0.14474059641361237,
-0.36615830659866333,
-0.7272016406059265,
-0.03045031428337097,
-0.016189096495509148,
-0.6367102265357971,
-0.3218075633049011,
-0.29884275794029236,
-0.4068257212638855,
-0.3330020010471344,
-0.036962784826755524,
-0.3625538647174835,
-0.08297452330589294,
-0.21813684701919556,
-0.41750988364219666,
0.4365394711494446,
0.716699481010437,
0.22856079041957855,
0.23076197504997253,
-0.7762159109115601,
-0.0737934410572052,
0.40039342641830444,
0.35337740182876587,
-0.08961731195449829,
-0.6025481224060059,
-0.33894845843315125,
-0.3255569040775299,
-0.21401871740818024,
-0.6312729716300964,
0.35498473048210144,
-0.19082514941692352,
0.7176607251167297,
0.286814421415329,
0.3240238428115845,
0.049341075122356415,
-0.6024643778800964,
0.8316063284873962,
0.47928351163864136,
-0.5976589322090149,
0.5090066194534302,
-0.3299386203289032,
-0.1856318712234497,
0.6803386807441711,
0.6653198003768921,
-0.685695469379425,
-0.16982866823673248,
-0.5779951214790344,
-1.0507183074951172,
0.5455999970436096,
-0.07831661403179169,
0.2683652639389038,
-0.11245396733283997,
0.20873744785785675,
-0.018717769533395767,
0.2665354311466217,
-1.1425023078918457,
-0.24913156032562256,
-0.01781984232366085,
-0.1278243362903595,
-0.3324454426765442,
-0.5510144829750061,
-0.4260157644748688,
0.0912216454744339,
0.5511407256126404,
0.07624496519565582,
0.22245670855045319,
-0.23534826934337616,
-0.09596559405326843,
-0.15024523437023163,
0.6425883173942566,
0.6761848330497742,
0.2484711855649948,
-0.4193621277809143,
0.4142690896987915,
0.13294769823551178,
-0.3640758991241455,
0.5444692969322205,
-0.13797281682491302,
0.2756567895412445,
-0.7198594808578491,
0.6391783356666565,
0.9230183959007263,
0.022676076740026474,
-1.0251972675323486,
0.7118479609489441,
0.08609014004468918,
-0.13868935406208038,
-0.29552003741264343,
0.2443261593580246,
0.00282792910002172,
0.02359054610133171,
0.13604143261909485,
-0.13800840079784393,
0.04099161922931671,
-0.7188206315040588,
-0.07701493054628372,
0.5750318169593811,
-0.37634578347206116,
-0.24062450230121613,
0.4179039001464844,
0.24118973314762115,
-0.24589863419532776,
0.41470587253570557,
0.10398337244987488,
-0.5710786581039429,
0.7378600239753723,
0.4981532096862793,
0.8831966519355774,
-0.4789102077484131,
0.0650981068611145,
0.1444583386182785,
0.6730616688728333,
0.01627068594098091,
0.06970150768756866,
0.6405607461929321,
-0.7710209488868713,
-0.29952406883239746,
-0.5003621578216553,
-0.5961104035377502,
0.5325144529342651,
-0.5524832606315613,
0.005538020748645067,
-0.5182520151138306,
-0.21451114118099213,
-0.15554410219192505,
-0.10210161656141281,
-0.4572890102863312,
0.20559054613113403,
0.40779754519462585,
0.9374962449073792,
-0.9900959730148315,
0.665459394454956,
0.7212441563606262,
-0.27763792872428894,
-0.757689356803894,
0.07824516296386719,
0.034804295748472214,
-0.6591099500656128,
0.9841215014457703,
0.28577709197998047,
0.15634779632091522,
-0.37155881524086,
-0.4019911289215088,
-0.8958330154418945,
0.744879961013794,
0.5847427845001221,
-0.4657141864299774,
-0.010520904324948788,
0.4250103235244751,
0.4225658178329468,
-0.31635698676109314,
0.09786541014909744,
0.5802624821662903,
0.3727673590183258,
-0.051685843616724014,
-0.947576642036438,
-0.01681838184595108,
0.008111750707030296,
0.07858095318078995,
0.23371347784996033,
-0.6013280153274536,
0.7469624876976013,
-0.31417402625083923,
-0.025494620203971863,
-0.22803358733654022,
0.1515064537525177,
0.19800560176372528,
0.12654678523540497,
0.6081842184066772,
0.3182634115219116,
0.5054559111595154,
0.16567836701869965,
1.2635549306869507,
0.03426164388656616,
0.22550195455551147,
1.0187774896621704,
-0.5668154358863831,
0.998067319393158,
0.4841190278530121,
-0.4019041955471039,
0.11972109228372574,
1.0286139249801636,
0.22703203558921814,
0.4655931890010834,
0.6747522950172424,
-0.2250463366508484,
-0.27390938997268677,
-0.09951489418745041,
-0.30697691440582275,
0.38035646080970764,
0.3743455410003662,
-0.25348204374313354,
-0.011774699203670025,
0.26265788078308105,
-0.07646780461072922,
-0.06301489472389221,
-0.6026414632797241,
0.7321610450744629,
0.13077859580516815,
-0.39094284176826477,
0.37793779373168945,
0.07488302141427994,
0.6162706017494202,
-0.5767031908035278,
0.36365199089050293,
0.05077488720417023,
-0.05377776920795441,
-0.17641708254814148,
-0.8916337490081787,
0.3470577299594879,
0.18477225303649902,
-0.19525989890098572,
-0.019584544003009796,
0.7330166101455688,
-0.2416876256465912,
-0.24851633608341217,
0.4389270842075348,
0.18028925359249115,
0.00871589407324791,
-0.15469257533550262,
-0.5479493141174316,
0.25452327728271484,
-0.21259883046150208,
-0.4479964077472687,
0.7936563491821289,
-0.1061629131436348,
-0.18411923944950104,
0.952246904373169,
0.4872559607028961,
0.07361126691102982,
-0.002053074538707733,
-0.05797455832362175,
0.8557851314544678,
-0.8180220127105713,
-0.2090897113084793,
-1.099837064743042,
0.32129260897636414,
0.21952402591705322,
-0.12084833532571793,
0.5554001331329346,
0.39252784848213196,
0.6004644632339478,
-0.19561976194381714,
0.8201647996902466,
0.015748757869005203,
0.3479944169521332,
-0.6798422932624817,
0.733776867389679,
-0.3481527864933014,
0.4677562415599823,
-0.37321826815605164,
-0.6508768200874329,
-0.2977285385131836,
0.37755656242370605,
-0.6585875153541565,
-0.003559208009392023,
0.4518895745277405,
0.38892310857772827,
0.4452402889728546,
-0.3204197585582733,
0.38146886229515076,
0.1531355381011963,
0.3982332944869995,
0.83961421251297,
1.2295758724212646,
-0.141839399933815,
0.37254899740219116,
0.2928261160850525,
-0.24676047265529633,
-0.47959768772125244,
-1.0002927780151367,
-0.9345734119415283,
-0.4898082911968231,
-0.2956152558326721,
-0.3281669318675995,
-0.1334933340549469,
1.0232616662979126,
0.427999347448349,
-0.7818822264671326,
-0.3633146286010742,
0.1997128576040268,
0.12822680175304413,
0.24393706023693085,
-0.22012090682983398,
0.2062462419271469,
-0.22287379205226898,
-0.37129247188568115,
0.19429415464401245,
0.24725498259067535,
0.18568934500217438,
-0.2283422201871872,
-0.10050952434539795,
-0.09744514524936676,
0.044344667345285416,
0.8292909860610962,
0.35913997888565063,
-0.5270959138870239,
-0.676578938961029,
-0.07070650905370712,
-0.3386036455631256,
-0.12882106006145477,
0.6133546829223633,
-0.25592586398124695,
0.046108368784189224,
0.23132997751235962,
0.9617860317230225,
0.2208283692598343,
-0.34198302030563354,
0.47014930844306946,
-0.5126195549964905,
0.1627088338136673,
0.27342912554740906,
0.3223617672920227,
0.4111958146095276,
-0.6004630923271179,
0.49590644240379333,
0.027648013085126877,
-0.5638046860694885,
-1.0011597871780396,
0.46194887161254883,
-1.083038330078125,
-0.23240190744400024,
1.441159963607788,
-0.12476591020822525,
-0.019280068576335907,
0.07467494904994965,
-0.20185092091560364,
0.04070545360445976,
-0.07659970223903656,
0.9284206032752991,
0.8049448132514954,
-0.007304370403289795,
-0.029883630573749542,
-0.8368198275566101,
0.6413766145706177,
0.12361606955528259,
-1.1249547004699707,
0.4362327456474304,
0.32894712686538696,
0.4422420263290405,
0.16080349683761597,
0.6004292964935303,
-0.19572663307189941,
0.2377929538488388,
-0.4904327690601349,
0.2862548530101776,
0.10722436755895615,
-0.43651723861694336,
-0.5189762115478516,
0.16121257841587067,
0.7045679688453674,
-0.034370385110378265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14982v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14982v2
|
MasonTigers at SemEval-2024 Task 9: Solving Puzzles with an Ensemble of Chain-of-Thoughts
| 2024-03-22T06:31:49 | 2024-04-03T07:40:07 |
Md Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Al Nahian Bin Emran, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Amrita Ganguly, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Our paper presents team MasonTigers submission to the SemEval-2024 Task 9 -
which provides a dataset of puzzles for testing natural language understanding.
We employ large language models (LLMs) to solve this task through several
prompting techniques. Zero-shot and few-shot prompting generate reasonably good
results when tested with proprietary LLMs, compared to the open-source models.
We obtain further improved results with chain-of-thought prompting, an
iterative prompting method that breaks down the reasoning process step-by-step.
We obtain our best results by utilizing an ensemble of chain-of-thought
prompts, placing 2nd in the word puzzle subtask and 13th in the sentence puzzle
subtask. The strong performance of prompted LLMs demonstrates their capability
for complex reasoning when provided with a decomposition of the thought
process. Our work sheds light on how step-wise explanatory prompts can unlock
more of the knowledge encoded in the parameters of large models.
|
[
-0.46635696291923523,
-1.0427734851837158,
0.9156489968299866,
0.18449851870536804,
-0.39743009209632874,
0.19749657809734344,
-0.31116676330566406,
-0.47095558047294617,
0.10075797885656357,
0.5949722528457642,
-0.8721640706062317,
-0.22431135177612305,
-0.5934748649597168,
0.5032187104225159,
-0.3510376214981079,
0.7002955079078674,
-0.19805464148521423,
0.042389918118715286,
-0.11905699968338013,
0.09401719272136688,
-0.6942757964134216,
-0.33402904868125916,
-0.7530032992362976,
-0.42099422216415405,
0.5370455384254456,
0.4221455156803131,
0.3219936490058899,
0.2690563201904297,
0.302418977022171,
0.23676098883152008,
-0.23185163736343384,
0.05229000374674797,
-0.5358351469039917,
0.3833559453487396,
-0.4191887378692627,
-0.5551756620407104,
-0.10528343915939331,
0.03751371428370476,
0.2962169349193573,
0.7221069931983948,
-0.10362491756677628,
0.35211533308029175,
0.050514306873083115,
0.4562625586986542,
-0.509048581123352,
0.2456696480512619,
-0.7612330913543701,
0.014368670992553234,
0.09639982879161835,
-0.32951340079307556,
-0.5574989318847656,
-0.2739782929420471,
0.06369222700595856,
-0.46480855345726013,
-0.07803414762020111,
0.4151519238948822,
0.4963863492012024,
0.2973843216896057,
-0.470936119556427,
-0.5215268731117249,
-0.4566962420940399,
0.674035906791687,
-0.6178528070449829,
0.1400463730096817,
0.4393269419670105,
0.20334967970848083,
-0.5045549273490906,
-0.30555015802383423,
-0.42555680871009827,
-0.18840043246746063,
0.18556712567806244,
0.07193433493375778,
-0.15769658982753754,
-0.11291840672492981,
0.376934677362442,
0.4577469527721405,
-0.663867175579071,
-0.06710256636142731,
-0.4581252932548523,
0.0963997095823288,
0.5310143828392029,
0.374122679233551,
0.22093841433525085,
-0.031381815671920776,
-0.2373688817024231,
-0.01076756976544857,
-0.7035374045372009,
0.2068863809108734,
0.24776478111743927,
0.21705013513565063,
0.07026592642068863,
0.5559799075126648,
-0.39232051372528076,
0.7232738137245178,
0.24572443962097168,
0.19312390685081482,
0.1743970662355423,
-0.32543978095054626,
-0.3126389980316162,
0.2360910326242447,
0.6539140939712524,
0.019131677225232124,
0.3223654627799988,
-0.008142911829054356,
-0.2687719762325287,
0.06409068405628204,
0.22131741046905518,
-0.3674761950969696,
-0.37252894043922424,
0.3020142912864685,
-0.27180585265159607,
-0.5369136929512024,
-0.3874920904636383,
-0.6007145643234253,
-0.5261349678039551,
-0.32870349287986755,
0.9030669331550598,
-0.38323912024497986,
-0.16096815466880798,
0.44693684577941895,
-0.22322459518909454,
0.14063550531864166,
0.45670071244239807,
-0.9165794253349304,
0.16370302438735962,
0.8020862936973572,
0.45922115445137024,
-0.03393402695655823,
-0.1630920171737671,
-0.6857894659042358,
0.006908292882144451,
-0.3755745589733124,
0.9127432107925415,
-0.7490970492362976,
-0.2929604649543762,
-0.18962936103343964,
0.11408562958240509,
-0.06046176701784134,
-0.5509950518608093,
0.5517853498458862,
-0.23753400146961212,
0.3499867022037506,
-0.4786328673362732,
-0.5906786322593689,
-0.36526933312416077,
0.778659999370575,
-0.645882785320282,
1.2085182666778564,
-0.19041429460048676,
-0.5829674601554871,
-0.024309277534484863,
-0.6019759178161621,
-0.3933056592941284,
0.2549761235713959,
-0.3587404489517212,
0.037001851946115494,
0.31998562812805176,
0.44127127528190613,
0.5268451571464539,
-0.47524788975715637,
0.4275013208389282,
-0.2486107349395752,
-0.23307880759239197,
0.13635402917861938,
-0.25092047452926636,
0.9496673345565796,
0.14470858871936798,
-0.5598952174186707,
0.027720844373106956,
-0.5756097435951233,
-0.04994373023509979,
0.342209130525589,
-0.20956988632678986,
-0.3448639214038849,
-0.25820598006248474,
-0.5879772901535034,
0.17872826755046844,
0.1282917857170105,
-0.2748667001724243,
0.43501198291778564,
-0.38921961188316345,
0.329975426197052,
0.934006929397583,
0.320981502532959,
0.46535009145736694,
-0.1968681812286377,
0.8638417720794678,
0.04680332913994789,
0.11713559925556183,
-0.5867489576339722,
-0.6334812045097351,
-0.8636082410812378,
0.08876758068799973,
0.12024631351232529,
0.34342604875564575,
-0.8799670934677124,
0.28010866045951843,
0.06039572134613991,
-0.4143929183483124,
-0.2800881862640381,
-0.11517830938100815,
0.20973941683769226,
0.49603554606437683,
0.34526658058166504,
-0.043966978788375854,
-0.5365747213363647,
-0.7588950991630554,
-0.3285364508628845,
-0.20113416016101837,
0.06411860883235931,
-0.017308885231614113,
0.9297615885734558,
0.0787377879023552,
0.4429436922073364,
-0.47503915429115295,
0.347519189119339,
-0.2613624334335327,
0.48918721079826355,
0.5166956186294556,
0.34476661682128906,
-0.10050509124994278,
-0.3535911738872528,
-0.07406604290008545,
-0.2749271094799042,
-0.6290010809898376,
-0.11071475595235825,
-0.14179342985153198,
-0.1865786761045456,
-0.10952433943748474,
0.5515426993370056,
-0.4351043105125427,
0.2659900188446045,
0.5261257290840149,
-0.46526384353637695,
0.7191349864006042,
0.02866309881210327,
0.23009921610355377,
-1.1021418571472168,
-0.06901910901069641,
-0.17548270523548126,
-0.14115768671035767,
-0.5551328659057617,
0.23399336636066437,
-0.1603463590145111,
-0.11608552187681198,
-0.23245391249656677,
0.40209823846817017,
-0.7873582243919373,
0.12536628544330597,
-0.08906025439500809,
-0.04335048049688339,
-0.057453472167253494,
0.6052286028862,
0.07969377189874649,
0.5292665362358093,
0.6545020341873169,
-0.7463951110839844,
0.4411622881889343,
0.15512220561504364,
-0.5147144794464111,
0.47837206721305847,
-0.5275058150291443,
0.3935967683792114,
-0.24288053810596466,
0.3536902666091919,
-0.9982693195343018,
-0.19902269542217255,
0.32839342951774597,
-0.3088034391403198,
-0.1176721528172493,
0.08337251842021942,
-0.5557765960693359,
-0.6381127834320068,
-0.38084876537323,
0.40204131603240967,
0.45822873711586,
-0.5710253715515137,
0.5460159182548523,
0.35050347447395325,
-0.16290050745010376,
-0.3041653037071228,
-0.5952214002609253,
0.27997273206710815,
-0.347029447555542,
-0.5944967269897461,
0.00316032487899065,
-0.31861233711242676,
-0.34733912348747253,
-0.18977771699428558,
-0.19160473346710205,
0.07983729988336563,
0.2924533188343048,
0.11490810662508011,
0.2847154438495636,
-0.22186467051506042,
0.1810140758752823,
-0.15329842269420624,
-0.028500881046056747,
0.42684829235076904,
-0.4119254946708679,
0.5308051109313965,
-0.20395685732364655,
-0.23921631276607513,
-0.046193111687898636,
0.4051417410373688,
0.18500220775604248,
-0.32545289397239685,
0.5180134773254395,
0.27855899930000305,
-0.5121473073959351,
-0.379762202501297,
-0.6618229746818542,
-0.32216644287109375,
-0.4784887433052063,
-0.06949163228273392,
-0.4697815179824829,
-1.4434897899627686,
0.5373038053512573,
-0.16686512529850006,
0.04285651072859764,
0.21434608101844788,
0.7129178643226624,
-0.2083354890346527,
1.161806583404541,
0.22732557356357574,
0.07907024025917053,
0.013333919458091259,
-0.23248766362667084,
0.5616554021835327,
-0.7885105609893799,
-0.26635944843292236,
-0.5934299826622009,
-0.3721320927143097,
-0.1655544936656952,
-0.5745668411254883,
0.4152827560901642,
0.33418577909469604,
-0.11247829347848892,
0.4135249853134155,
-0.5937873125076294,
0.7672010064125061,
0.4167781472206116,
-0.09989811480045319,
0.35452932119369507,
-0.25526565313339233,
-0.37420183420181274,
0.33225128054618835,
-0.6131647825241089,
-0.43446043133735657,
0.6284381151199341,
0.10311310738325119,
0.9976092576980591,
0.10234496742486954,
0.8378734588623047,
-0.04485231637954712,
-0.2202712595462799,
-0.9801410436630249,
0.7635825276374817,
0.49926790595054626,
-0.708602786064148,
-0.31428924202919006,
-0.21202419698238373,
-1.022059679031372,
0.20257118344306946,
-0.1553017944097519,
-1.0853369235992432,
0.03593536466360092,
0.17755626142024994,
-0.5967806577682495,
0.0754278227686882,
-0.43621909618377686,
0.7219985723495483,
-0.08868234604597092,
-0.0443587489426136,
-0.16311156749725342,
-0.5364152193069458,
0.6618407368659973,
0.06324293464422226,
0.24948251247406006,
-0.18224738538265228,
0.1621939092874527,
0.7145186066627502,
-0.31598228216171265,
0.7282136678695679,
0.2747344374656677,
-0.31522366404533386,
0.6004535555839539,
0.37292391061782837,
0.92381751537323,
0.0007567587308585644,
0.06557873636484146,
-0.3391057550907135,
-0.030004039406776428,
-0.1907283216714859,
-0.7602900862693787,
0.4554611146450043,
-0.17322444915771484,
-0.886871874332428,
-0.4513881802558899,
-0.4361686110496521,
-0.29966476559638977,
0.03584460914134979,
0.3056405782699585,
0.7221396565437317,
0.03195425122976303,
0.18021290004253387,
0.8935075402259827,
-0.09083682298660278,
0.5216050148010254,
0.2310805767774582,
-0.32292670011520386,
-0.2228853404521942,
0.5474382638931274,
-0.023001037538051605,
0.2079051285982132,
0.21457672119140625,
0.4585026502609253,
-0.32498422265052795,
-0.6144402623176575,
-0.27535951137542725,
0.11881570518016815,
-0.7289758920669556,
-0.15367719531059265,
-0.7183344960212708,
-0.014421421103179455,
-0.40928757190704346,
-0.1570376753807068,
-0.08831000328063965,
-0.5034040808677673,
-0.19241759181022644,
-0.24651366472244263,
0.18684309720993042,
1.0193276405334473,
0.1015082374215126,
-0.0859035849571228,
-0.9034206867218018,
0.05620429292321205,
0.4818479120731354,
-0.06108357012271881,
0.20679418742656708,
-0.4551953971385956,
-0.30298757553100586,
-0.19730450212955475,
-0.11903161555528641,
-1.0416446924209595,
0.20856739580631256,
-0.35126379132270813,
0.5257419943809509,
0.20170997083187103,
0.0976794958114624,
0.7207049131393433,
-0.5318102240562439,
1.0542110204696655,
0.27619731426239014,
-1.0343230962753296,
0.7175630331039429,
-0.6991866827011108,
0.862906813621521,
0.7551047801971436,
0.37449973821640015,
-0.7213708162307739,
-0.7090922594070435,
-0.765362560749054,
-0.5689129829406738,
0.4956466257572174,
0.28624817728996277,
-0.07443580776453018,
-0.2648353576660156,
0.21173255145549774,
0.0375211276113987,
0.14958472549915314,
-0.5283516645431519,
0.037743404507637024,
0.3260990083217621,
-0.25209179520606995,
0.1436956822872162,
-0.3316464126110077,
-0.12250640243291855,
-0.29679474234580994,
0.8420336842536926,
-0.2590441405773163,
0.3344569802284241,
0.19730839133262634,
-0.1709415465593338,
-0.17957435548305511,
0.559920608997345,
0.7829908132553101,
0.7430495023727417,
0.07825863361358643,
0.5362136960029602,
0.4792494475841522,
-0.24991686642169952,
0.23778195679187775,
-0.3569636344909668,
0.020700493827462196,
-0.19615186750888824,
0.4473717510700226,
0.8000757694244385,
0.2813335061073303,
-0.6673134565353394,
0.41864264011383057,
-0.1486659049987793,
-0.4255653917789459,
-0.39834827184677124,
0.17204079031944275,
0.4054186940193176,
0.317715048789978,
0.393372118473053,
-0.033604081720113754,
0.3340383768081665,
-0.7572013139724731,
0.017381485551595688,
0.26954981684684753,
-0.502467930316925,
-0.5377294421195984,
0.5382633209228516,
0.29011884331703186,
-0.39841362833976746,
0.3762109875679016,
-0.5830751657485962,
-0.8573988676071167,
0.6403933167457581,
0.5729734301567078,
0.9311689734458923,
-0.206486314535141,
0.1901981234550476,
0.5549274682998657,
0.460016131401062,
-0.5264166593551636,
0.5785111784934998,
-0.05987171456217766,
-0.6997551918029785,
-0.8518295884132385,
-0.26395702362060547,
-0.3573865294456482,
0.41403457522392273,
-0.5374287366867065,
0.46188104152679443,
-0.4271770417690277,
0.15702413022518158,
-0.10121732950210571,
-0.16670526564121246,
-0.49035850167274475,
0.05072280764579773,
0.3928753733634949,
1.059471607208252,
-0.7224668264389038,
0.5956693887710571,
0.5864344835281372,
-0.2076491117477417,
-1.3529702425003052,
-0.16643597185611725,
0.3644658923149109,
-0.6852219700813293,
0.5475782155990601,
0.3529040515422821,
-0.2031891942024231,
0.18263421952724457,
-0.9110349416732788,
-0.7114855647087097,
0.9023081064224243,
0.1494472622871399,
-0.5948117971420288,
-0.11920680850744247,
-0.1920364648103714,
0.276327520608902,
-0.47996941208839417,
0.2963501214981079,
0.6538832187652588,
0.5385894179344177,
0.42007312178611755,
-0.9006876349449158,
0.23334991931915283,
-0.32129940390586853,
-0.32343387603759766,
0.5109834671020508,
-0.38442036509513855,
0.833441972732544,
-0.12019867449998856,
-0.110145203769207,
-0.038568317890167236,
0.5477137565612793,
0.404220849275589,
0.12290531396865845,
0.7284055948257446,
0.7386019825935364,
1.005547046661377,
0.07038776576519012,
0.8853381276130676,
0.006124775856733322,
0.3309773802757263,
1.4819910526275635,
-0.18029910326004028,
0.819929301738739,
0.6224306225776672,
0.03871249035000801,
0.5332942008972168,
0.6712192893028259,
0.1159592717885971,
0.3113618493080139,
0.5305804014205933,
-0.442176878452301,
-0.6471529006958008,
-0.1658605933189392,
-0.22088903188705444,
0.4315844178199768,
0.259494811296463,
-0.1997043937444687,
-0.22869478166103363,
-0.05622018873691559,
0.06319166719913483,
-0.11669077724218369,
-0.42878004908561707,
0.7259262204170227,
0.38001692295074463,
-1.0608018636703491,
0.4838518500328064,
-0.3662511706352234,
0.4937131702899933,
-0.29522037506103516,
-0.1993034929037094,
0.15606266260147095,
-0.15554200112819672,
0.052817631512880325,
-0.9261330962181091,
0.194014772772789,
0.07425691187381744,
0.1794164478778839,
-0.3630675673484802,
0.7784368991851807,
-0.5657039880752563,
-0.5624210238456726,
0.01003441121429205,
0.39640575647354126,
0.25790831446647644,
-0.2481101006269455,
-0.7023741602897644,
0.018551552668213844,
0.15008559823036194,
-0.3190460205078125,
-0.06385867297649384,
0.5751104950904846,
-0.10057497769594193,
0.5433809161186218,
0.496843546628952,
-0.22225891053676605,
0.09208334237337112,
0.1568317711353302,
0.7519188523292542,
-0.8683021664619446,
-0.6171560287475586,
-1.0385662317276,
0.5881550908088684,
-0.10589121282100677,
-0.2687247693538666,
0.7493247389793396,
0.45281144976615906,
0.7180386781692505,
-0.0545627623796463,
0.5709145665168762,
0.09663626551628113,
0.33641475439071655,
-0.7148899435997009,
0.3086678683757782,
-0.25130826234817505,
0.1242617592215538,
-0.21365024149417877,
-0.7912513017654419,
-0.14957596361637115,
0.5535363554954529,
-0.4000950753688812,
-0.4049196243286133,
1.21138596534729,
0.80052250623703,
0.1543482393026352,
0.7036970257759094,
0.26693639159202576,
0.15512920916080475,
0.16900981962680817,
0.940140962600708,
1.3564105033874512,
-0.338382750749588,
0.4988860785961151,
-0.04847665876150131,
0.05410752072930336,
-0.06969524174928665,
-0.9555687308311462,
-1.2322255373001099,
-0.7069955468177795,
-0.343746542930603,
-0.2951281666755676,
-0.08522465825080872,
1.252639889717102,
0.30276045203208923,
-0.7613103985786438,
-0.2417082041501999,
-0.23123985528945923,
0.05069654434919357,
-0.028984198346734047,
-0.17147360742092133,
-0.11719269305467606,
-0.34970998764038086,
-0.47367826104164124,
0.6457024812698364,
0.5654901266098022,
-0.01326324138790369,
-0.3254223167896271,
-0.003830093890428543,
-0.5862249135971069,
0.19771137833595276,
0.5208171010017395,
-0.1568702906370163,
-0.7142930626869202,
-0.5615678429603577,
0.16861999034881592,
0.11446849256753922,
-0.018151648342609406,
1.0073864459991455,
-0.7741050124168396,
0.5190434455871582,
0.959987223148346,
0.6642264723777771,
0.5725683569908142,
-0.04198364540934563,
0.771638810634613,
-0.3506074845790863,
-0.08217819780111313,
0.425669401884079,
0.454054594039917,
0.11031859368085861,
-0.43927252292633057,
0.8133575916290283,
0.020909400656819344,
-0.5631777048110962,
-0.7488369941711426,
0.2512359619140625,
-0.8116209506988525,
-0.352364718914032,
1.0005407333374023,
0.05395326390862465,
-0.6826545596122742,
-0.19569651782512665,
-0.19266006350517273,
-0.07117613404989243,
-0.34510338306427,
0.5470836162567139,
1.1010172367095947,
-0.19683432579040527,
-0.4347356855869293,
-0.4837200343608856,
0.38440603017807007,
0.6892144083976746,
-0.9879766702651978,
-0.12863689661026,
0.3823290169239044,
-0.004454951733350754,
0.13856561481952667,
0.8150164484977722,
0.055458568036556244,
0.21043415367603302,
-0.22918178141117096,
-0.1395312249660492,
0.14475534856319427,
-0.2114347219467163,
-0.7307824492454529,
-0.0660647377371788,
0.019327634945511818,
0.10018927603960037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14972v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14972v1
|
A Picture Is Worth a Graph: Blueprint Debate on Graph for Multimodal Reasoning
| 2024-03-22T06:03:07 | 2024-03-22T06:03:07 |
Changmeng Zheng, Dayong Liang, Wengyu Zhang, Xiao-Yong Wei, Tat-Seng Chua, Qing Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA, cs.MM
|
This paper presents a pilot study aimed at introducing multi-agent debate
into multimodal reasoning. The study addresses two key challenges: the
trivialization of opinions resulting from excessive summarization and the
diversion of focus caused by distractor concepts introduced from images. These
challenges stem from the inductive (bottom-up) nature of existing debating
schemes. To address the issue, we propose a deductive (top-down) debating
approach called Blueprint Debate on Graphs (BDoG). In BDoG, debates are
confined to a blueprint graph to prevent opinion trivialization through
world-level summarization. Moreover, by storing evidence in branches within the
graph, BDoG mitigates distractions caused by frequent but irrelevant concepts.
Extensive experiments validate BDoG, achieving state-of-the-art results in
Science QA and MMBench with significant improvements over previous methods.
|
[
-0.7800571322441101,
-0.8125848770141602,
0.6812431216239929,
0.28301969170570374,
-0.5266703963279724,
0.18625301122665405,
0.20788505673408508,
-0.44902586936950684,
0.22251880168914795,
0.36506783962249756,
-0.2646084427833557,
-0.26300421357154846,
-0.5126819610595703,
-0.03131745383143425,
0.10078980028629303,
0.6752703785896301,
0.12631747126579285,
-0.14788486063480377,
-0.5141932964324951,
-0.4211488962173462,
-0.4242097735404968,
-0.26643189787864685,
-0.7599899768829346,
-0.3958423435688019,
0.9859306216239929,
0.4243074357509613,
0.6119491457939148,
0.5999829769134521,
0.43854138255119324,
0.3852582275867462,
-0.09670531004667282,
0.5561328530311584,
-0.2169637829065323,
0.19722899794578552,
-0.42550408840179443,
-0.26682713627815247,
-0.4161413013935089,
0.13513630628585815,
0.5049179196357727,
0.620031476020813,
0.1914309561252594,
0.001076794695109129,
-0.30701857805252075,
0.747555136680603,
-0.7290303707122803,
0.6596124768257141,
-0.5067599415779114,
-0.16964662075042725,
-0.13221381604671478,
-0.20530512928962708,
-0.630217432975769,
-0.24171313643455505,
-0.33352968096733093,
-0.4804525077342987,
-0.06343702226877213,
0.021702777594327927,
1.2415742874145508,
0.25386881828308105,
-0.8281540870666504,
-0.015195592306554317,
-0.7073811292648315,
0.4121517837047577,
-0.3925122618675232,
0.0750264897942543,
0.23123328387737274,
0.4048815071582794,
0.1537480503320694,
-1.0072327852249146,
-0.7774317860603333,
0.176488995552063,
-0.06060785800218582,
0.3902883529663086,
-0.7013686299324036,
0.2849411368370056,
0.39436691999435425,
0.129302516579628,
-0.13260449469089508,
-0.23556293547153473,
-0.47641521692276,
-0.2504260540008545,
0.6325651407241821,
0.35278457403182983,
0.22879397869110107,
-0.24076996743679047,
-0.2885759174823761,
-0.18666405975818634,
-0.3750731647014618,
0.36342108249664307,
0.08220398426055908,
0.10023672878742218,
0.092750184237957,
0.5358691215515137,
-0.4239993691444397,
0.4683670997619629,
0.28089720010757446,
-0.10486342757940292,
0.22956621646881104,
-0.6825363039970398,
-0.1550757884979248,
-0.11640762537717819,
0.5738731026649475,
0.8647190928459167,
-0.019517462700605392,
-0.09684533625841141,
0.04108431935310364,
0.3891942799091339,
0.20943155884742737,
-1.1468236446380615,
-0.39889296889305115,
0.4247911870479584,
-0.36572960019111633,
-0.10867496579885483,
-0.428401380777359,
-0.7372442483901978,
-0.49305981397628784,
-0.10036006569862366,
0.326771080493927,
-0.3059017062187195,
-0.3064716160297394,
-0.05011531710624695,
-0.6971882581710815,
-0.07259106636047363,
0.7755529284477234,
-0.5226761102676392,
-0.18169786036014557,
0.44071099162101746,
0.8736385107040405,
0.4294036328792572,
-0.3024083375930786,
-0.08936268836259842,
0.5195168852806091,
-0.5510521531105042,
1.687969446182251,
-0.4479493498802185,
-0.444443941116333,
-0.45043104887008667,
0.22996100783348083,
-0.18541960418224335,
-0.2823059856891632,
0.164901465177536,
-0.2779044806957245,
0.1430637687444687,
-0.572939395904541,
-0.5010889172554016,
-0.39494404196739197,
0.8814810514450073,
-0.9722545146942139,
0.4593500792980194,
-0.2115190029144287,
-0.9095359444618225,
0.5501105189323425,
-0.797741711139679,
-0.35871943831443787,
0.3856889307498932,
-0.5324459671974182,
-0.26402747631073,
-0.3669888973236084,
0.3857431411743164,
0.08191521465778351,
-0.056518904864788055,
-0.21767118573188782,
-0.5738955736160278,
-0.1887769103050232,
0.28824618458747864,
-0.14813293516635895,
0.8180354237556458,
0.1757505238056183,
-0.39545440673828125,
0.33386749029159546,
-0.4878407418727875,
0.22863894701004028,
0.02523195743560791,
-0.15298479795455933,
-0.14899368584156036,
0.018344301730394363,
-0.23228046298027039,
0.579289972782135,
-0.09267216920852661,
-0.9592357277870178,
0.2206171751022339,
-0.2740681767463684,
0.5797296762466431,
0.7204244136810303,
0.21997852623462677,
0.19922907650470734,
-0.670452892780304,
0.41259095072746277,
0.10177971422672272,
0.07154897600412369,
-0.4813377261161804,
-0.5927875638008118,
-0.5949704647064209,
-0.8142999410629272,
0.0627165287733078,
0.4056187570095062,
-0.8197651505470276,
-0.5403432250022888,
-0.27601009607315063,
-0.6092670559883118,
-0.45742499828338623,
-0.2807859778404236,
0.498749703168869,
0.36262139678001404,
0.34265655279159546,
-0.2659931182861328,
-0.1436235010623932,
-1.0468873977661133,
0.2551196813583374,
-0.14363156259059906,
0.3190712034702301,
0.5955151319503784,
0.5006876587867737,
-0.10044338554143906,
0.8849339485168457,
-0.4317016303539276,
-0.2604183852672577,
-0.30206412076950073,
0.32533910870552063,
-0.19610048830509186,
0.32639339566230774,
0.6182677149772644,
-0.6762869358062744,
-0.31538963317871094,
0.11257462948560715,
-0.8727160096168518,
0.2625180780887604,
-0.06032796949148178,
-0.19923682510852814,
0.5894278287887573,
0.5640393495559692,
-1.1889487504959106,
0.635360836982727,
0.06363489478826523,
-0.6239266991615295,
0.19643262028694153,
-0.0733271911740303,
0.5411314964294434,
-0.8352798223495483,
0.2181510478258133,
-0.22407834231853485,
-0.07511099427938461,
-0.1414184719324112,
0.12366977334022522,
-0.07237709313631058,
-0.292459100484848,
-0.3375977575778961,
0.8989118337631226,
-0.27058523893356323,
0.15498320758342743,
-0.39801257848739624,
0.15426573157310486,
0.5922921895980835,
0.3913975656032562,
-0.1308472752571106,
0.5606805086135864,
0.13482901453971863,
-0.1843131184577942,
0.4905529320240021,
0.39726388454437256,
-0.22365815937519073,
1.0986850261688232,
-0.581820547580719,
0.31651949882507324,
-0.3779807984828949,
0.5102173089981079,
-1.4645169973373413,
0.009299173951148987,
0.3406209647655487,
-0.5173351168632507,
0.1851448118686676,
-0.31478220224380493,
-0.40151065587997437,
-0.39644289016723633,
-0.34311988949775696,
0.3256685733795166,
-0.006564772687852383,
-0.38771316409111023,
0.5379779934883118,
0.651129424571991,
-0.4098747670650482,
-0.7726991772651672,
-0.5354427695274353,
0.31207185983657837,
-0.03643341735005379,
-0.8350095748901367,
0.270333468914032,
-0.05647564306855202,
-0.4087410867214203,
0.3796304762363434,
0.029025988653302193,
-0.2783935070037842,
-0.1361820250749588,
0.3893822431564331,
-0.003385480958968401,
-0.1385825276374817,
0.4236598312854767,
0.0016596593195572495,
-0.17512808740139008,
0.13456504046916962,
0.008872834034264088,
0.2028154879808426,
-0.4223657250404358,
-0.21541984379291534,
-0.26551929116249084,
0.4828428328037262,
0.7583742141723633,
-0.16328637301921844,
0.2844875156879425,
0.23167434334754944,
-0.32875770330429077,
-0.2651219367980957,
-0.48050540685653687,
0.038433656096458435,
-0.4516710042953491,
0.2714638411998749,
-0.40758487582206726,
-0.537151038646698,
0.3668554127216339,
-0.2456347942352295,
0.21472038328647614,
0.1579049527645111,
0.8116955757141113,
-0.6658490300178528,
1.0065982341766357,
0.20965294539928436,
0.5228912830352783,
0.13219237327575684,
-0.4250793755054474,
0.14869876205921173,
-0.3983994424343109,
-0.5204758048057556,
-0.3834421634674072,
-0.5318855047225952,
-0.10317587107419968,
-0.5081945061683655,
0.29123181104660034,
-0.17108386754989624,
-0.23546986281871796,
-0.23011338710784912,
-0.39561498165130615,
0.6467552185058594,
0.32084187865257263,
0.24074620008468628,
0.34909114241600037,
-0.07956384867429733,
-0.24744154512882233,
0.1728917807340622,
-0.49363958835601807,
-0.5224319696426392,
0.9253882169723511,
0.004385150503367186,
0.5023708343505859,
0.12176116555929184,
0.2894672155380249,
0.3607664108276367,
0.6384382843971252,
-0.8339725136756897,
0.7164086103439331,
0.20632164180278778,
-1.194449543952942,
-0.5995827913284302,
-0.39783358573913574,
-1.2990065813064575,
0.7859164476394653,
-0.11188733577728271,
-0.6516996622085571,
0.19695162773132324,
0.468298077583313,
0.005152376368641853,
0.5075171589851379,
-0.5231350660324097,
1.2271977663040161,
-0.06271522492170334,
-0.561230480670929,
-0.6887827515602112,
-0.4525311291217804,
0.2649683654308319,
0.5735988020896912,
0.4142886698246002,
-0.2988077700138092,
0.4127957224845886,
0.4870432913303375,
-0.35303324460983276,
0.6574284434318542,
-0.36635345220565796,
0.19709651172161102,
0.6119651794433594,
0.14246436953544617,
0.10202428698539734,
-0.1685628443956375,
0.28847819566726685,
-0.04057978093624115,
0.18768101930618286,
-0.8452613949775696,
-0.6972909569740295,
0.281161367893219,
-0.4489372670650482,
-0.7378339171409607,
-0.192672461271286,
-0.9174580574035645,
-0.12009654939174652,
0.3112863600254059,
0.07858343422412872,
0.6541116833686829,
-0.08909957855939865,
0.28400474786758423,
0.1420227587223053,
0.17116892337799072,
0.6548700332641602,
0.10984119772911072,
-0.10669483244419098,
-0.7080163359642029,
1.1203961372375488,
0.35669684410095215,
0.21992424130439758,
0.15096229314804077,
0.23352017998695374,
-0.5070179104804993,
-0.5350236892700195,
-0.8787466883659363,
0.24394018948078156,
-1.283329963684082,
-0.23405978083610535,
-0.7802443504333496,
0.06667593866586685,
-0.023360980674624443,
-0.2784813642501831,
-0.5067133903503418,
-0.9546651244163513,
0.39618444442749023,
-0.21250733733177185,
0.15816739201545715,
0.45624932646751404,
0.03327489644289017,
-0.07006960362195969,
-0.5645701289176941,
0.14227190613746643,
0.6989513635635376,
0.0929521843791008,
0.11445597559213638,
-0.02752046287059784,
-0.2651759684085846,
-0.04896702244877815,
-0.9479206800460815,
-0.7639740109443665,
-0.019458726048469543,
-0.24098581075668335,
0.8040457367897034,
0.4440496861934662,
0.0557183213531971,
0.5928942561149597,
-0.01817154511809349,
0.47931280732154846,
0.13321198523044586,
-0.7874889373779297,
0.3640795350074768,
-0.44142869114875793,
0.23709064722061157,
0.4632229506969452,
0.18575187027454376,
-0.19890983402729034,
-0.598166286945343,
-0.7088998556137085,
-0.7106633186340332,
0.36192238330841064,
0.2032545655965805,
-0.001107112504541874,
-0.1814931184053421,
-0.07447782903909683,
-0.2980152368545532,
0.44236114621162415,
-0.8684460520744324,
-0.03307582810521126,
-0.6741675138473511,
0.07807905226945877,
0.11890984326601028,
-0.06267272680997849,
-0.6188542246818542,
-0.35433387756347656,
0.22040143609046936,
-0.30901944637298584,
0.29991698265075684,
0.22863468527793884,
-0.08058157563209534,
-0.07991552352905273,
0.467804491519928,
0.4794989228248596,
0.9955607056617737,
-0.34053143858909607,
0.5574174523353577,
0.03696973994374275,
-0.14321961998939514,
0.2952439486980438,
0.1710200309753418,
-0.3231143653392792,
-0.007537826895713806,
0.6891083717346191,
0.7439524531364441,
0.053027309477329254,
-0.45075270533561707,
0.5128075480461121,
0.09144090116024017,
-0.45757484436035156,
0.42951521277427673,
-0.2950200140476227,
0.5718194246292114,
0.6564843058586121,
-0.016977207735180855,
-0.041146643459796906,
0.03575035184621811,
-0.7061642408370972,
0.15760396420955658,
0.7120310664176941,
-0.29065534472465515,
-0.10731904208660126,
0.5106216669082642,
0.49542543292045593,
-0.013376779854297638,
0.5178949236869812,
-0.5014020800590515,
-0.3389226198196411,
1.1896984577178955,
0.45506709814071655,
0.4374163746833801,
0.17053258419036865,
0.5941594839096069,
0.4151020646095276,
0.5516223907470703,
0.37324365973472595,
0.4099079966545105,
-0.2641826868057251,
-0.8112548589706421,
-0.34667423367500305,
0.1625649482011795,
-0.9600389003753662,
-0.06311938166618347,
-0.3098222315311432,
-0.04604901745915413,
-0.6657878756523132,
-0.4009050130844116,
0.5423314571380615,
0.038912832736968994,
-0.35686561465263367,
0.08727502822875977,
0.3719293773174286,
0.676795482635498,
-0.48248928785324097,
0.585425853729248,
0.8152977228164673,
-0.714122474193573,
-0.6031855344772339,
-0.37464451789855957,
-0.13444370031356812,
-0.4657670557498932,
0.8487600684165955,
0.33844438195228577,
-0.4288232624530792,
-0.22004017233848572,
-0.5386515855789185,
-0.4540744423866272,
1.1301109790802002,
0.5986037254333496,
-0.035105641931295395,
0.1510593593120575,
-0.40282371640205383,
0.33311915397644043,
-0.1660395860671997,
0.4717373549938202,
-0.10844793170690536,
0.7550339698791504,
0.4507368505001068,
-0.7177899479866028,
0.2876335084438324,
-0.5264108777046204,
-0.3959243595600128,
0.23961633443832397,
-1.1250892877578735,
1.050115942955017,
-0.6693257093429565,
-0.7450446486473083,
-0.3804282248020172,
0.15351863205432892,
0.4058031141757965,
1.1903530359268188,
0.5961263179779053,
0.7051587700843811,
0.6037867665290833,
0.06013820320367813,
1.0235514640808105,
-0.0946807935833931,
0.4156455099582672,
0.9769597053527832,
-0.37266576290130615,
0.43835392594337463,
0.4265049397945404,
-0.20434008538722992,
0.6806981563568115,
0.4885714650154114,
-0.15923969447612762,
0.41142958402633667,
-0.06455761939287186,
-0.09465886652469635,
-0.6310309171676636,
-0.19329732656478882,
-0.3673246502876282,
0.4823492467403412,
0.37687402963638306,
0.0376548133790493,
-0.5876709818840027,
-0.1428726464509964,
0.319097101688385,
0.10673375427722931,
-0.2810435891151428,
0.5825463533401489,
-0.145449697971344,
-0.7659558653831482,
0.4591367840766907,
-0.07304199039936066,
-0.07835465669631958,
-0.2551637291908264,
-0.24716897308826447,
-0.3578626811504364,
0.17301778495311737,
-0.16177412867546082,
-0.8693603277206421,
0.33268818259239197,
-0.4732837677001953,
-0.19589923322200775,
-0.19939395785331726,
0.6810032725334167,
-0.1520686149597168,
-0.4058404266834259,
0.2801520824432373,
0.6349061131477356,
-0.00763229513540864,
0.0464988611638546,
-0.5384588837623596,
-0.2098192721605301,
-0.27512115240097046,
-0.27197128534317017,
0.21393021941184998,
0.6226145029067993,
-0.2240525186061859,
0.8803649544715881,
0.6038001775741577,
-0.17335397005081177,
-0.23338866233825684,
-0.17702455818653107,
1.1545093059539795,
-0.7243852615356445,
-0.6878549456596375,
-0.8413711786270142,
0.43203604221343994,
-0.35157787799835205,
-0.2679678797721863,
0.7624836564064026,
0.5608821511268616,
0.6028111577033997,
0.016390595585107803,
0.5711742043495178,
0.11102337390184402,
0.06520383805036545,
-0.3305501937866211,
0.823310375213623,
-0.5041923522949219,
-0.3462674021720886,
-0.36249732971191406,
-0.29171496629714966,
-0.22339263558387756,
0.7509235739707947,
-0.11875267326831818,
-0.2096753716468811,
1.0097588300704956,
0.6584575176239014,
0.131638765335083,
0.16327820718288422,
0.1967889964580536,
0.07685213536024094,
0.4959277808666229,
0.774445652961731,
1.319995403289795,
0.1565023809671402,
0.8266969323158264,
-0.28885483741760254,
-0.25411805510520935,
0.03491203114390373,
-0.9653199315071106,
-1.177511215209961,
-0.5166294574737549,
-0.532494068145752,
-0.548477292060852,
-0.05450315773487091,
0.5037826299667358,
0.9380748271942139,
-0.22157935798168182,
-0.14334997534751892,
0.16106362640857697,
0.6289629340171814,
-0.3642386794090271,
-0.18381749093532562,
0.42588549852371216,
-0.2994380295276642,
-0.5652936697006226,
0.05111417919397354,
0.6411874890327454,
-0.1274390071630478,
-0.019468577578663826,
0.06840799748897552,
-0.3510744571685791,
0.4555545151233673,
0.8434606790542603,
0.42612600326538086,
-0.607900083065033,
-0.4706442356109619,
-0.4904874563217163,
-0.2122143656015396,
0.33369895815849304,
0.9566993117332458,
-0.7588812112808228,
0.8827330470085144,
0.4565722942352295,
0.5743137001991272,
0.8910821676254272,
0.21779820322990417,
0.08612996339797974,
-0.41238856315612793,
0.4536651074886322,
0.15518735349178314,
0.36689168214797974,
0.17645719647407532,
-0.12829378247261047,
0.5614793300628662,
0.7903136610984802,
-0.4864950478076935,
-0.9345672726631165,
0.39811256527900696,
-1.2193560600280762,
-0.6637806296348572,
0.7821012735366821,
-0.38005828857421875,
-0.051083531230688095,
-0.32636818289756775,
-0.3596248924732208,
0.11865753680467606,
-0.28671082854270935,
1.0524017810821533,
0.9371928572654724,
-0.5665197968482971,
-0.5787529349327087,
-0.12916916608810425,
0.13324403762817383,
0.19263462722301483,
-1.3140473365783691,
0.08804099261760712,
0.7610921263694763,
0.05986573174595833,
0.43093404173851013,
1.2229721546173096,
-0.16075871884822845,
0.4988507330417633,
0.7147848606109619,
0.17206799983978271,
-0.6780005693435669,
-0.5210676193237305,
0.23378601670265198,
0.6267411708831787,
0.029904639348387718,
-0.5464493036270142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14958v1
|
Adapprox: Adaptive Approximation in Adam Optimization via Randomized Low-Rank Matrices
| 2024-03-22T05:23:31 | 2024-03-22T05:23:31 |
Pengxiang Zhao, Ping Li, Yingjie Gu, Yi Zheng, Stephan Ludger Kölker, Zhefeng Wang, Xiaoming Yuan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, math.OC
|
As deep learning models exponentially increase in size, optimizers such as
Adam encounter significant memory consumption challenges due to the storage of
first and second moment data. Current memory-efficient methods like Adafactor
and CAME often compromise accuracy with their matrix factorization techniques.
Addressing this, we introduce Adapprox, a novel approach that employs
randomized low-rank matrix approximation for a more effective and accurate
approximation of Adam's second moment. Adapprox features an adaptive rank
selection mechanism, finely balancing accuracy and memory efficiency, and
includes an optional cosine similarity guidance strategy to enhance stability
and expedite convergence. In GPT-2 training and downstream tasks, Adapprox
surpasses AdamW by achieving 34.5% to 49.9% and 33.8% to 49.9% memory savings
for the 117M and 345M models, respectively, with the first moment enabled, and
further increases these savings without the first moment. Besides, it enhances
convergence speed and improves downstream task performance relative to its
counterparts.
|
[
-0.2447379231452942,
-0.5998886823654175,
0.5346155762672424,
0.026647206395864487,
-0.353994756937027,
0.35065075755119324,
-0.01751554198563099,
-0.09174887090921402,
0.1479189544916153,
-0.17760027945041656,
-0.4444220960140228,
-0.3371128439903259,
-0.49952828884124756,
-0.3379415273666382,
-0.09551379829645157,
0.5768252015113831,
-0.006607765331864357,
0.19908633828163147,
-0.19010743498802185,
-0.3933553993701935,
-0.17380768060684204,
-0.33891719579696655,
-1.204369068145752,
-0.1918012499809265,
0.5786563158035278,
0.5263781547546387,
0.8114045858383179,
0.5943289399147034,
0.7052396535873413,
0.3115057647228241,
-0.2492230385541916,
0.16891299188137054,
-0.4377884566783905,
-0.0019614039920270443,
0.005137294996529818,
-0.47618353366851807,
-0.7794431447982788,
0.09816965460777283,
0.9518476724624634,
0.8611330389976501,
-0.4050588011741638,
0.25926336646080017,
0.19875960052013397,
0.9378566741943359,
-0.7017852067947388,
-0.2831279933452606,
-0.5197746753692627,
0.4552638828754425,
0.22594279050827026,
-0.18004392087459564,
-0.32462748885154724,
-0.5298036336898804,
-0.03263985365629196,
-0.7977474927902222,
0.3415341079235077,
0.17689287662506104,
0.5586451292037964,
0.45160621404647827,
-0.042689528316259384,
0.16187551617622375,
-0.8085604906082153,
1.032787799835205,
-0.6266131401062012,
0.05343228206038475,
0.07923753559589386,
0.3063053488731384,
-0.11163772642612457,
-0.5953783988952637,
-0.31349873542785645,
-0.19943982362747192,
0.4654347896575928,
0.2691654860973358,
-0.5442253947257996,
0.02057446353137493,
0.05774189159274101,
0.1960115283727646,
-0.2905716598033905,
0.1661238968372345,
-0.2857373058795929,
0.1388242393732071,
0.5785571336746216,
0.138301819562912,
-0.17916087806224823,
0.2832139730453491,
-0.7715349793434143,
-0.4622403085231781,
-0.6407939791679382,
0.25397196412086487,
0.4368237555027008,
0.24438120424747467,
0.31084296107292175,
0.2781226933002472,
0.19398874044418335,
0.3527924120426178,
0.20320186018943787,
0.09485556930303574,
0.16911129653453827,
-0.13783985376358032,
-0.16343437135219574,
0.13333885371685028,
0.478519082069397,
0.38562318682670593,
-0.08219795674085617,
-0.02673986926674843,
0.10346843302249908,
-0.26189085841178894,
0.46543940901756287,
-0.8629745841026306,
-0.5337506532669067,
0.151591956615448,
-0.5318444967269897,
-0.30354830622673035,
-0.13987575471401215,
-0.7663838863372803,
-0.2861422598361969,
-0.3473253846168518,
0.5671408176422119,
-0.4824618399143219,
-0.032154448330402374,
-0.3730964660644531,
-0.05783284455537796,
0.1345251202583313,
0.8219408392906189,
-0.44082191586494446,
0.7848978638648987,
0.8158367276191711,
1.0321041345596313,
-0.42994362115859985,
-0.378639817237854,
-0.7683886885643005,
-0.1371230185031891,
-0.8062986135482788,
0.6686463952064514,
-0.6509053707122803,
-0.16168175637722015,
-0.5320062637329102,
-0.4181183874607086,
-0.2615872621536255,
-0.5235471129417419,
0.24144485592842102,
-0.5220599174499512,
-0.14605176448822021,
-0.2162388116121292,
-0.5014752745628357,
-0.5389688014984131,
-0.12125223129987717,
-0.48353391885757446,
1.1578620672225952,
0.13989056646823883,
-0.3550368547439575,
0.5821118950843811,
-0.7429821491241455,
-0.28479546308517456,
-0.11049710214138031,
0.15206356346607208,
-0.6617391109466553,
0.5669277906417847,
0.09480255097150803,
0.2924934923648834,
0.043048858642578125,
-0.4148631691932678,
-0.6604176759719849,
-0.4834940433502197,
0.0851416140794754,
-0.3642972707748413,
0.428452730178833,
0.3509020507335663,
-0.2418251931667328,
0.30867642164230347,
-0.7559794187545776,
0.009490856900811195,
0.3286307454109192,
-0.07990574836730957,
-0.6963043212890625,
0.2652775049209595,
-0.26509159803390503,
-0.06670226156711578,
0.09305721521377563,
-0.35936859250068665,
0.25577905774116516,
-0.3166936933994293,
0.21694916486740112,
1.0352814197540283,
0.055593568831682205,
0.6595298647880554,
-0.22486092150211334,
0.6986769437789917,
0.009596077725291252,
0.29276835918426514,
0.18345193564891815,
-0.5085958242416382,
-0.5928545594215393,
-0.2223472148180008,
0.5572537779808044,
0.55171799659729,
-0.1953914314508438,
0.04551801458001137,
-0.23112455010414124,
-0.3732087314128876,
-0.4784437119960785,
0.40231454372406006,
0.3161470592021942,
0.28780004382133484,
0.5176030993461609,
-0.48136797547340393,
-0.3764649033546448,
-0.9142197966575623,
0.004593393299728632,
-0.1306820809841156,
-0.19250962138175964,
0.509795606136322,
0.23015256226062775,
0.1763586401939392,
0.7194937467575073,
-0.45784303545951843,
-0.2058529555797577,
0.018972638994455338,
0.17767968773841858,
0.2625744044780731,
0.6117725372314453,
0.7742950916290283,
-0.549872636795044,
-0.5070940852165222,
-0.2550753653049469,
-0.27420392632484436,
0.32882440090179443,
-0.09464958310127258,
-0.04734402149915695,
0.24403123557567596,
0.4068944454193115,
-0.1897270530462265,
0.1508442759513855,
0.459698349237442,
-0.31975579261779785,
0.10933452844619751,
-0.4762563407421112,
-0.01898234523832798,
-1.154913067817688,
0.11392789334058762,
-0.06789714097976685,
-0.42917972803115845,
-0.2171565592288971,
0.14140133559703827,
-0.19010145962238312,
-0.3302793502807617,
-0.5890775918960571,
0.20964860916137695,
-0.3381923735141754,
-0.2398880571126938,
-0.3812234699726105,
-0.009360007010400295,
-0.10598891973495483,
0.4769979417324066,
-0.1844768077135086,
1.2673089504241943,
0.41212791204452515,
-0.4973747432231903,
0.013936327770352364,
0.3876189589500427,
0.027548370882868767,
0.6535460352897644,
-0.5943297743797302,
0.42601582407951355,
-0.08983156830072403,
0.012343965470790863,
-1.0000914335250854,
0.24771450459957123,
0.12281495332717896,
-0.4746607542037964,
0.4618310332298279,
-0.5597707629203796,
-0.1405842900276184,
-0.17493365705013275,
-0.8209121823310852,
0.45702064037323,
0.7616212964057922,
-0.6557478308677673,
0.5602685213088989,
0.5118468999862671,
-0.40938320755958557,
-0.5488100051879883,
-0.23684410750865936,
0.03598754480481148,
-0.1756773442029953,
-0.24282443523406982,
0.1821463406085968,
-0.13674403727054596,
-0.19509857892990112,
0.07679271697998047,
-0.3352890908718109,
0.11941330879926682,
0.3336279094219208,
0.1557847410440445,
0.1997804343700409,
-0.2396078258752823,
-0.1463678628206253,
0.2565034329891205,
-0.26626721024513245,
-0.043352723121643066,
-0.24434326589107513,
0.429940402507782,
-0.31633687019348145,
-0.07487672567367554,
-0.2418888658285141,
0.5308465957641602,
0.33598384261131287,
0.291339248418808,
0.5874671936035156,
0.7911518216133118,
-0.4085133373737335,
-0.2936549484729767,
-0.2744952142238617,
-0.14544038474559784,
-0.48144295811653137,
0.3891849219799042,
-0.3321130871772766,
-0.6671144962310791,
0.5145994424819946,
-0.20753061771392822,
0.044573333114385605,
0.708223283290863,
0.5035620927810669,
-0.22197650372982025,
1.372532844543457,
0.4474838376045227,
-0.0363755077123642,
0.3758377730846405,
-0.4471622407436371,
0.03156450018286705,
-1.2451475858688354,
0.037868011742830276,
-0.13242679834365845,
-0.8186429738998413,
-0.3604341447353363,
-0.5499379634857178,
0.394116073846817,
0.23773375153541565,
-0.23003420233726501,
0.4080479145050049,
-0.6030122637748718,
0.45079314708709717,
1.1116163730621338,
0.12901529669761658,
0.03721614554524422,
0.30608558654785156,
-0.14327555894851685,
-0.09682605415582657,
-1.0147150754928589,
-0.11280399560928345,
1.23775053024292,
0.3818866014480591,
0.8736625909805298,
0.0016128614079207182,
0.6025848984718323,
0.5310397744178772,
0.15476517379283905,
-0.7800884246826172,
0.6503204703330994,
-0.2268088012933731,
-0.27296894788742065,
-0.2595883309841156,
-0.5158467292785645,
-0.9178505539894104,
0.26364782452583313,
-0.14827336370944977,
-0.5194769501686096,
0.6115899682044983,
0.46279069781303406,
-1.0168792009353638,
0.42913201451301575,
-0.7087215781211853,
0.6024965047836304,
0.18810446560382843,
-0.55842125415802,
-0.6584532260894775,
-0.4307307302951813,
-0.038278259336948395,
0.10876550525426865,
-0.03821548447012901,
-0.4143448770046234,
-0.39629387855529785,
1.0935416221618652,
-0.6130968332290649,
0.45334717631340027,
-0.6157531142234802,
0.2893731892108917,
0.3273991644382477,
0.19129927456378937,
0.6698293089866638,
0.2595820128917694,
0.05487792193889618,
0.18420946598052979,
-0.02659163624048233,
-0.6495068073272705,
-0.42423439025878906,
0.804742157459259,
-0.7996012568473816,
-0.35778018832206726,
-0.7512674927711487,
-0.5203399062156677,
-0.15268592536449432,
-0.019919104874134064,
-0.1889747977256775,
0.20059093832969666,
-0.15714532136917114,
0.24773867428302765,
0.5014874339103699,
-0.00414692796766758,
0.7755981683731079,
0.32105767726898193,
0.1750585436820984,
-0.7550250291824341,
0.9701127409934998,
0.03430357947945595,
0.08796323090791702,
0.17193259298801422,
0.35706233978271484,
-0.1739455908536911,
-1.094257116317749,
-0.25801730155944824,
-0.21110761165618896,
-0.5008726119995117,
-0.4681260585784912,
-0.5006413459777832,
0.08647473156452179,
-0.07537127286195755,
-0.40183788537979126,
-0.8291723132133484,
-0.8771633505821228,
0.059115517884492874,
0.0722648873925209,
0.5922790169715881,
0.315513014793396,
-0.5691876411437988,
0.32560646533966064,
-0.399104505777359,
0.18679013848304749,
0.588543176651001,
0.33592522144317627,
0.04297715798020363,
-0.46394163370132446,
-0.15802642703056335,
-0.1697479784488678,
-0.2244643121957779,
-0.3332713842391968,
0.2522612512111664,
0.6485462188720703,
0.3433351516723633,
0.42685309052467346,
0.04177603870630264,
0.691998302936554,
-0.8350817561149597,
0.4471004009246826,
0.22405245900154114,
-0.5264828205108643,
0.5516136288642883,
-0.09564302116632462,
0.12738613784313202,
1.025126338005066,
0.19000589847564697,
0.18325430154800415,
-0.17561136186122894,
-0.7114830613136292,
-1.2463113069534302,
0.8586122989654541,
0.4529809355735779,
0.10440804064273834,
0.21908564865589142,
0.36474570631980896,
-0.09430217742919922,
0.1842140555381775,
-0.1896154135465622,
-0.23714111745357513,
0.02725846692919731,
-0.19363698363304138,
-0.06491866707801819,
-0.4820176959037781,
-0.4844881296157837,
-0.532630980014801,
0.8518738746643066,
-0.28034329414367676,
0.7828014492988586,
0.26085442304611206,
-0.19063520431518555,
-0.354160875082016,
0.04864517226815224,
0.7393622994422913,
0.8337007761001587,
-0.7113643884658813,
0.2131258249282837,
0.5936775207519531,
-1.0076149702072144,
0.2504456639289856,
0.5028305649757385,
-0.2716428339481354,
-0.13551250100135803,
-0.04739701747894287,
0.6315205693244934,
0.39047497510910034,
-0.3585294783115387,
0.471327006816864,
-0.13316094875335693,
-0.21678397059440613,
-0.5596877336502075,
0.3057083785533905,
-0.3050588071346283,
0.5075385570526123,
0.8600059151649475,
0.7629004716873169,
0.33910584449768066,
-0.2148151397705078,
0.3008396625518799,
0.5467504262924194,
-0.4697408676147461,
-0.3020245432853699,
1.1890597343444824,
-0.047633323818445206,
-0.2105618119239807,
0.21036523580551147,
-0.283902108669281,
-0.21211634576320648,
0.577391505241394,
0.27679112553596497,
1.0571478605270386,
-0.5061189532279968,
-0.024887405335903168,
0.4773354232311249,
0.18600839376449585,
-0.02394702285528183,
0.3317919373512268,
-0.014444705098867416,
-0.4076586663722992,
-0.6631028652191162,
-0.7755634188652039,
-0.8362381458282471,
-0.3289397656917572,
-0.7665284276008606,
-0.16708001494407654,
-1.0332814455032349,
-0.21812862157821655,
0.1139158234000206,
0.42166393995285034,
-0.5365188121795654,
-0.0033119290601462126,
0.2097359597682953,
0.8916246891021729,
-0.5893746018409729,
0.8560144305229187,
0.7765442132949829,
0.07037695497274399,
-0.6377761960029602,
-0.31317898631095886,
0.019185028970241547,
-0.9415348172187805,
0.03735486790537834,
-0.08806230872869492,
-0.16514138877391815,
0.3086303174495697,
-0.27451178431510925,
-0.8990934491157532,
1.215409517288208,
0.4523378610610962,
-0.5696545243263245,
0.175384983420372,
-0.2806834578514099,
0.1760644018650055,
-0.2938603162765503,
0.14662852883338928,
0.34086525440216064,
0.30126574635505676,
0.5481534004211426,
-0.3765804171562195,
0.1705193966627121,
-0.39445164799690247,
0.2982702851295471,
0.28120526671409607,
-0.6382514834403992,
0.7044755220413208,
-0.4745127558708191,
0.2153356671333313,
0.03825201094150543,
0.7489182949066162,
0.43776971101760864,
0.3064872622489929,
0.7928492426872253,
0.9759923219680786,
0.5385979413986206,
0.129398912191391,
1.1083598136901855,
-0.33628562092781067,
0.4988962411880493,
0.9915332794189453,
-0.20745567977428436,
1.0123523473739624,
0.44698670506477356,
-0.826889157295227,
0.3553605377674103,
0.6361017823219299,
-0.25949162244796753,
0.5713695883750916,
-0.21180418133735657,
-0.20589910447597504,
-0.22324064373970032,
0.31847083568573,
-0.4229500889778137,
0.16628232598304749,
0.00958154909312725,
-0.14978615939617157,
-0.2375117838382721,
-0.024456346407532692,
0.24532808363437653,
-0.16944484412670135,
-0.6406517028808594,
0.7921903729438782,
0.10208200663328171,
-0.4131745398044586,
0.5231157541275024,
-0.06577741354703903,
0.321020245552063,
-0.4005502164363861,
-0.21062596142292023,
-0.23183323442935944,
0.6610067486763,
0.17964772880077362,
-0.42779478430747986,
0.26682719588279724,
-0.4920082092285156,
-0.09206302464008331,
-0.08475389331579208,
0.7005475163459778,
-0.28211238980293274,
-0.9821239113807678,
0.04619478061795235,
0.09016460925340652,
-0.20064036548137665,
-0.27174991369247437,
-0.8822335004806519,
-0.10018620640039444,
-0.4879685640335083,
-0.37903666496276855,
0.5302162766456604,
-0.17174358665943146,
0.2545662820339203,
0.508894681930542,
0.7304829359054565,
0.0453358069062233,
0.101431705057621,
-0.2236868441104889,
0.749584972858429,
-0.44456979632377625,
-0.49726223945617676,
-0.7794995307922363,
0.06259440630674362,
-0.11616300791501999,
-0.2405978888273239,
0.8856740593910217,
0.8714449405670166,
0.4719361662864685,
0.08711305260658264,
0.3833308517932892,
-0.016107378527522087,
0.5769945383071899,
-0.39139774441719055,
0.5641937255859375,
-0.7149381041526794,
0.08747872710227966,
-0.3209233582019806,
-1.131452202796936,
-0.30559930205345154,
0.7229137420654297,
-0.2305941879749298,
0.060826197266578674,
0.6348773837089539,
0.3817104995250702,
-0.42547595500946045,
-0.251472532749176,
0.11619052290916443,
0.27375489473342896,
0.025753358379006386,
0.7201600074768066,
0.3693796396255493,
-0.613627016544342,
0.5692996382713318,
-0.4418584108352661,
-0.4181448221206665,
-0.29512062668800354,
-0.72528076171875,
-0.7482277154922485,
-0.20353640615940094,
-0.6254918575286865,
-0.40027597546577454,
0.23140683770179749,
1.168180227279663,
0.8999212980270386,
-1.1762069463729858,
0.13397736847400665,
-0.22206158936023712,
0.10451945662498474,
-0.8399480581283569,
-0.11631982028484344,
0.8557301163673401,
-0.5287044644355774,
-0.8185751438140869,
0.7754693031311035,
0.3996603488922119,
-0.053583670407533646,
-0.0334131233394146,
-0.2485032081604004,
-0.2147986739873886,
0.16603408753871918,
0.6403924226760864,
0.38538241386413574,
-0.14878062903881073,
-0.4304686188697815,
-0.07270444929599762,
0.3951127231121063,
0.3789726197719574,
0.7570343613624573,
-0.8678918480873108,
0.19168992340564728,
0.27574965357780457,
0.4807210862636566,
0.5712915062904358,
0.18950197100639343,
0.5752465724945068,
-0.6714323163032532,
0.42566001415252686,
0.4103084206581116,
0.248772993683815,
0.02216922491788864,
-0.17992088198661804,
0.6935399770736694,
0.4715637266635895,
-0.4606640040874481,
-0.9214770197868347,
-0.10704316198825836,
-1.3617075681686401,
-0.21549123525619507,
0.8654174208641052,
-0.005285191815346479,
-0.4452510476112366,
0.20571480691432953,
0.00809651892632246,
-0.02223912999033928,
-0.5674160718917847,
0.7509790658950806,
-0.006131286267191172,
-0.1461663842201233,
-0.4469422399997711,
-0.65666264295578,
0.5708774328231812,
0.6901915073394775,
-0.2408841997385025,
-0.27697116136550903,
0.13187383115291595,
0.2775925397872925,
0.045009203255176544,
0.4381459057331085,
-0.031707294285297394,
0.5147753953933716,
0.12565575540065765,
-0.1091616302728653,
-0.2883284091949463,
-0.4253818392753601,
-0.3614796996116638,
0.5078736543655396,
0.2896137237548828,
-0.510400652885437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15512v1
|
Enhancing Effectiveness and Robustness in a Low-Resource Regime via Decision-Boundary-aware Data Augmentation
| 2024-03-22T05:18:08 | 2024-03-22T05:18:08 |
Kyohoon Jin, Junho Lee, Juhwan Choi, Sangmin Song, Youngbin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Efforts to leverage deep learning models in low-resource regimes have led to
numerous augmentation studies. However, the direct application of methods such
as mixup and cutout to text data, is limited due to their discrete
characteristics. While methods using pretrained language models have exhibited
efficiency, they require additional considerations for robustness. Inspired by
recent studies on decision boundaries, this paper proposes a
decision-boundary-aware data augmentation strategy to enhance robustness using
pretrained language models. The proposed technique first focuses on shifting
the latent features closer to the decision boundary, followed by reconstruction
to generate an ambiguous version with a soft label. Additionally, mid-K
sampling is suggested to enhance the diversity of the generated sentences. This
paper demonstrates the performance of the proposed augmentation strategy
compared to other methods through extensive experiments. Furthermore, the
ablation study reveals the effect of soft labels and mid-K sampling and the
extensibility of the method with curriculum data augmentation.
|
[
-0.5242825150489807,
-0.8964017033576965,
0.3528410494327545,
-0.06718205660581589,
-0.3344942033290863,
0.2849329113960266,
-0.5165339112281799,
-0.39482882618904114,
-0.03952118009328842,
0.6144163608551025,
-0.6948278546333313,
-0.43910861015319824,
-0.44258230924606323,
-0.09619459509849548,
-0.019103314727544785,
1.0203288793563843,
0.05643576383590698,
-0.33025941252708435,
-0.13664542138576508,
-0.1217503696680069,
-0.629774808883667,
-0.5137003660202026,
-0.29960814118385315,
-0.4578484296798706,
0.13483405113220215,
0.27806785702705383,
0.9698725938796997,
0.8959254622459412,
0.5449073314666748,
0.2597171366214752,
-0.19453395903110504,
0.4169062674045563,
-0.33011165261268616,
0.05257147550582886,
-0.18051345646381378,
-0.23284153640270233,
-0.669101357460022,
-0.08743516355752945,
0.9330863356590271,
1.018753170967102,
0.0009522117325104773,
-0.25694403052330017,
0.315301775932312,
0.6520711779594421,
-0.9318974018096924,
-0.2488730102777481,
-0.852680504322052,
-0.022932061925530434,
-0.2551063895225525,
0.1425059586763382,
-0.30395829677581787,
-0.38950642943382263,
0.38619372248649597,
-0.4935753643512726,
0.04047005996108055,
-0.46199074387550354,
0.8405637741088867,
0.6132498979568481,
-0.2952037751674652,
-0.028681475669145584,
-0.7833713889122009,
0.859243631362915,
-0.5747777819633484,
0.8145920634269714,
0.5076531171798706,
0.07036282867193222,
-0.06756962090730667,
-0.6767762899398804,
-0.44839850068092346,
0.15029393136501312,
-0.03567066416144371,
0.12533876299858093,
-0.07139262557029724,
0.18643765151500702,
0.30666422843933105,
0.3436329960823059,
-0.25914227962493896,
0.3925354480743408,
-0.17604312300682068,
-0.42547690868377686,
0.46255165338516235,
-0.08166240155696869,
0.19288277626037598,
-0.19026857614517212,
-0.2801702916622162,
-0.4291195869445801,
-0.577978253364563,
0.12304582446813583,
0.6912909150123596,
0.6976602673530579,
-0.03580297902226448,
0.4924333691596985,
-0.1547040492296219,
0.8966615200042725,
0.000611302035395056,
-0.08565797656774521,
0.4957593083381653,
-0.5389084815979004,
-0.32728731632232666,
-0.09678085148334503,
0.5487098097801208,
0.3181019425392151,
-0.1122588962316513,
0.04268268123269081,
-0.315218985080719,
0.17384764552116394,
0.21099916100502014,
-0.9640957117080688,
-0.40998488664627075,
0.12188195437192917,
-0.3261623978614807,
-0.2730698585510254,
-0.25326746702194214,
-0.8845980763435364,
-0.08076067268848419,
-0.32742729783058167,
0.09202232211828232,
-0.6676612496376038,
-0.3072538375854492,
0.22853514552116394,
0.3240329623222351,
0.011896981857717037,
0.24811038374900818,
-0.6808753609657288,
0.18928799033164978,
0.46043190360069275,
0.6811693906784058,
-0.23647812008857727,
0.05526827648282051,
-0.4355212450027466,
0.009258194826543331,
-0.10893434286117554,
0.569905161857605,
-0.8751959800720215,
-0.4786303639411926,
-0.08018196374177933,
-0.2613450586795807,
0.13066595792770386,
-0.7456938028335571,
0.7585113644599915,
-0.37383949756622314,
0.17262648046016693,
-0.07221747934818268,
-0.31403130292892456,
-0.0326177142560482,
0.39618736505508423,
-0.9090969562530518,
1.1765128374099731,
0.20943564176559448,
-0.6084886193275452,
0.6448742151260376,
-0.5190856456756592,
-0.6587170958518982,
0.01037505641579628,
-0.0942457765340805,
-0.7489719986915588,
-0.21547654271125793,
0.5878846049308777,
0.36449477076530457,
0.23779906332492828,
0.31454014778137207,
-0.22780853509902954,
-0.0023701319005340338,
0.31988847255706787,
-0.7073349356651306,
0.6967678070068359,
0.25114214420318604,
0.01081942766904831,
-0.23781627416610718,
-0.7556754946708679,
0.30175986886024475,
-0.19387651979923248,
-0.6434562802314758,
-0.4716176986694336,
-0.19594867527484894,
0.10028890520334244,
0.07426716387271881,
0.15611009299755096,
-0.24912221729755402,
0.1508241444826126,
-0.6415823101997375,
0.06401342153549194,
0.7227952480316162,
0.02327677421271801,
0.7944623231887817,
-0.49429723620414734,
0.4654717743396759,
0.09727781265974045,
0.06641266494989395,
-0.2634314000606537,
-0.12943394482135773,
-0.5578613877296448,
-0.5659816861152649,
0.8062877058982849,
0.6164793372154236,
-1.1387115716934204,
0.7724582552909851,
-0.10546572506427765,
-0.3307000994682312,
-0.6666653156280518,
0.2750745415687561,
0.14989641308784485,
0.6870855093002319,
0.5328962206840515,
-0.42777878046035767,
-0.7250701785087585,
-0.8034847974777222,
-0.25127601623535156,
0.02108822949230671,
0.0891110897064209,
0.42769694328308105,
0.2367486208677292,
-0.5418235063552856,
1.0764148235321045,
-0.5429015755653381,
-0.11017081141471863,
-0.14880605041980743,
-0.10727190971374512,
0.16924473643302917,
0.7783019542694092,
0.44934576749801636,
-1.0010576248168945,
-0.21360041201114655,
-0.017888857051730156,
-0.35445675253868103,
-0.229297935962677,
-0.33470848202705383,
-0.3008228540420532,
-0.059913769364356995,
0.039187271147966385,
-0.2611308991909027,
0.33081382513046265,
0.21931657195091248,
-0.05130792781710625,
0.3649691939353943,
-0.09257785975933075,
0.08181159198284149,
-0.8359613418579102,
-0.29866206645965576,
0.20302513241767883,
-0.1927783489227295,
-0.7310645580291748,
-0.06859651207923889,
0.07503753155469894,
-0.01538365613669157,
-0.48294001817703247,
0.36985525488853455,
-0.41440364718437195,
0.2900799512863159,
-0.2373579740524292,
0.007368141319602728,
0.13753364980220795,
0.123509481549263,
0.18654170632362366,
0.6185746192932129,
0.6319931149482727,
-0.7137438058853149,
-0.0940142273902893,
0.3811567723751068,
-0.22149500250816345,
0.5044885277748108,
-0.24689704179763794,
-0.024409689009189606,
-0.2635299265384674,
0.11337745934724808,
-0.6067991256713867,
-0.2331913411617279,
0.15538616478443146,
-0.16578465700149536,
0.3502810001373291,
-0.14966508746147156,
-0.1493198573589325,
-0.17349806427955627,
-0.43225812911987305,
0.5860375761985779,
0.741344153881073,
-0.5223132371902466,
0.5483753681182861,
0.4445662498474121,
-0.29455894231796265,
-0.6045442223548889,
-0.8151031136512756,
-0.10783751308917999,
-0.3269326984882355,
-0.4821110665798187,
0.529310405254364,
-0.33063963055610657,
-0.2365499585866928,
-0.09977105259895325,
-0.14082877337932587,
-0.2682589888572693,
0.19505317509174347,
0.00986473448574543,
0.4353868365287781,
0.06065283715724945,
0.05743268504738808,
0.39763689041137695,
0.1436188668012619,
-0.24717766046524048,
-0.3400264382362366,
0.41924554109573364,
0.0990581139922142,
-0.32234421372413635,
-0.13528217375278473,
0.21377290785312653,
0.09344606101512909,
-0.3200939893722534,
0.39425909519195557,
0.6287940740585327,
-0.7645013332366943,
-0.4562839865684509,
-0.47944173216819763,
-0.3904229700565338,
-0.5346975326538086,
0.16032767295837402,
-0.3390510082244873,
-0.8939698934555054,
0.3711259961128235,
-0.5104491710662842,
-0.08775380253791809,
0.12632165849208832,
0.4081244170665741,
0.08655628561973572,
0.6785552501678467,
0.7325654029846191,
0.27144962549209595,
0.6515893340110779,
-0.30494046211242676,
0.1673404425382614,
-0.9290153980255127,
-0.2523333430290222,
-0.3998664915561676,
-0.1811586320400238,
-0.6070984601974487,
-0.4493129551410675,
0.22211751341819763,
0.07894033193588257,
0.13444578647613525,
0.23943307995796204,
-0.7606440186500549,
0.49132299423217773,
0.26120811700820923,
0.5581409335136414,
0.17931410670280457,
0.2845315635204315,
-0.12102565169334412,
-0.5694520473480225,
-0.7337096333503723,
-0.5732141733169556,
1.0827544927597046,
0.41757476329803467,
0.764004111289978,
-0.0012228263076394796,
0.6889157891273499,
0.3486943244934082,
0.17100903391838074,
-0.5981902480125427,
0.5077537894248962,
-0.20821426808834076,
-0.3562452495098114,
-0.25385597348213196,
-0.6321719884872437,
-0.8137214779853821,
0.27167126536369324,
-0.7875218987464905,
-0.6361433267593384,
0.38103485107421875,
-0.011769694276154041,
-0.5510275363922119,
0.27566760778427124,
-0.7027010321617126,
0.555901825428009,
-0.365008682012558,
-0.5745924711227417,
0.3254501521587372,
-0.3508997857570648,
0.1326550394296646,
-0.5265203714370728,
0.22063420712947845,
0.06987074762582779,
-0.11881964653730392,
0.7145757675170898,
-0.4663693308830261,
0.8256862759590149,
-0.13648661971092224,
-0.2003830224275589,
0.4007294178009033,
-0.12590399384498596,
0.6038896441459656,
-0.118678517639637,
-0.2683337330818176,
-0.1646101176738739,
-0.5702852606773376,
-0.2698450982570648,
-0.6069617867469788,
0.48929300904273987,
-0.6278140544891357,
-0.3887115716934204,
-0.015002552419900894,
-0.6798577308654785,
-0.4560829997062683,
0.3688757121562958,
0.17963573336601257,
0.39865344762802124,
-0.17017383873462677,
0.16836851835250854,
0.6743061542510986,
-0.21068045496940613,
0.38056689500808716,
0.22970761358737946,
0.15978476405143738,
-0.49063947796821594,
0.9279757738113403,
0.3985481858253479,
0.22400902211666107,
0.1314842253923416,
0.021186895668506622,
-0.5591199994087219,
-0.8253609538078308,
-0.3286937475204468,
-0.041415371000766754,
-0.5263809561729431,
-0.1981056183576584,
-0.7763568758964539,
-0.25405776500701904,
-0.3913974165916443,
-0.47732701897621155,
-0.414824903011322,
-0.27157899737358093,
-0.20150519907474518,
-0.29106682538986206,
0.21857766807079315,
0.4065670967102051,
-0.33203035593032837,
0.6841338276863098,
-0.6442663073539734,
0.1283055692911148,
0.21944108605384827,
0.5024633407592773,
-0.24999912083148956,
-0.3807924687862396,
-0.1975168138742447,
0.28779733180999756,
-0.2820720970630646,
-0.7961664795875549,
0.26180216670036316,
0.21723175048828125,
0.667195200920105,
0.1660643070936203,
0.34807610511779785,
0.516740083694458,
-0.2700099050998688,
0.4661523401737213,
0.24673762917518616,
-0.8802191019058228,
0.8451786637306213,
-0.38978657126426697,
0.3518736660480499,
0.7540886402130127,
0.1736670881509781,
0.17814525961875916,
-0.4703339636325836,
-0.7785513401031494,
-1.148788571357727,
0.49652567505836487,
0.4619932472705841,
0.2327813059091568,
0.32888248562812805,
0.31724753975868225,
0.34113895893096924,
0.17255951464176178,
-0.7083715200424194,
-0.17812404036521912,
-0.22350290417671204,
-0.3774554133415222,
0.2856866419315338,
0.014547038823366165,
0.013265850953757763,
-0.19039641320705414,
0.7532222867012024,
-0.15482255816459656,
-0.29696133732795715,
0.09878941625356674,
-0.07617457956075668,
0.1492786556482315,
0.5474995374679565,
0.16755439341068268,
0.5295285582542419,
-0.23728810250759125,
0.0857812762260437,
0.5037451982498169,
-0.7247346043586731,
0.28323158621788025,
0.6076838374137878,
-0.523158609867096,
-0.034503672271966934,
0.22804614901542664,
0.8643712401390076,
-0.27375438809394836,
-0.5608929991722107,
0.2326093316078186,
0.001381122274324298,
-0.12037716805934906,
0.3376011252403259,
0.1257723867893219,
-0.5513598322868347,
0.33164963126182556,
0.2816655933856964,
0.23891973495483398,
0.374468058347702,
-0.15267565846443176,
0.5443529486656189,
0.43668460845947266,
-0.28456607460975647,
0.03500863537192345,
0.48974788188934326,
0.22344835102558136,
-0.07551013678312302,
0.40495869517326355,
-0.13463445007801056,
-0.5193417072296143,
0.45259588956832886,
0.5814608931541443,
0.4684542119503021,
-0.23543517291545868,
0.27360716462135315,
0.21292002499103546,
0.5764073133468628,
0.10746138542890549,
0.2175673246383667,
-0.11445387452840805,
-0.8740143775939941,
-0.6830891966819763,
-0.3316040635108948,
-0.5470181107521057,
0.3749961853027344,
-0.6683608889579773,
0.24516138434410095,
-0.5398609638214111,
-0.7008921504020691,
-0.05119722709059715,
0.06039929762482643,
-0.8838245272636414,
0.7169446349143982,
0.23475350439548492,
0.6544913053512573,
-0.9127013683319092,
0.5939905643463135,
0.9496023654937744,
-0.11330965161323547,
-0.8144267797470093,
0.11400195211172104,
-0.4211520850658417,
-0.3975834250450134,
0.1913404017686844,
0.14557982981204987,
-0.04046095162630081,
-0.16425471007823944,
-0.36883729696273804,
-0.47315713763237,
0.6926679611206055,
0.6166144013404846,
-0.4748084247112274,
0.2337418794631958,
0.19003404676914215,
0.28327563405036926,
-0.2501014471054077,
0.13563713431358337,
0.6950165629386902,
0.555349588394165,
0.15039141476154327,
-0.5989475250244141,
0.13238662481307983,
-0.2620154917240143,
0.00914967991411686,
0.267392098903656,
-0.3462042808532715,
0.6798754334449768,
-0.19736404716968536,
-0.4312335252761841,
-0.4602290689945221,
0.8038392066955566,
0.17898063361644745,
0.19937501847743988,
0.6915062665939331,
0.7253798842430115,
1.1999037265777588,
-0.34307095408439636,
0.7518282532691956,
-0.040138207376003265,
0.21355177462100983,
1.030062198638916,
-0.28968971967697144,
0.4236838221549988,
0.321119487285614,
-0.07375437021255493,
0.5098124146461487,
0.8267818689346313,
-0.023288525640964508,
0.7929128408432007,
0.03705555573105812,
-0.43418818712234497,
-0.4369751811027527,
-0.6446053385734558,
-0.46918973326683044,
0.5102283358573914,
0.4920341968536377,
-0.15689031779766083,
-0.2213008850812912,
0.2751370370388031,
0.1157606840133667,
0.3326599597930908,
-0.3090363144874573,
0.6901623010635376,
-0.1305553913116455,
-0.539033055305481,
0.5245858430862427,
-0.021446572616696358,
0.8943702578544617,
-0.3332274854183197,
-0.16632597148418427,
-0.056696195155382156,
0.11812951415777206,
-0.42309433221817017,
-1.0508151054382324,
0.2471674084663391,
0.02809106558561325,
-0.2746298313140869,
-0.3099724054336548,
1.2401788234710693,
-0.7221854329109192,
-0.47260165214538574,
0.17003463208675385,
0.8869988918304443,
-0.05135732889175415,
0.17589616775512695,
-0.6089186072349548,
0.3777114450931549,
0.12707053124904633,
0.11283563822507858,
0.09074044227600098,
0.42284393310546875,
0.07399041205644608,
0.38562923669815063,
0.8740876913070679,
0.2984674274921417,
-0.19782952964305878,
0.07176393270492554,
1.2107036113739014,
-0.20009538531303406,
-0.7477043271064758,
-0.9923396110534668,
0.7205491662025452,
-0.34145262837409973,
-0.028623245656490326,
0.5522158145904541,
0.5214053988456726,
0.9275047779083252,
0.24235455691814423,
1.1852407455444336,
0.07153233140707016,
0.2579377293586731,
-0.6833415627479553,
0.6480683088302612,
-0.38345465064048767,
0.3303590714931488,
-0.38488075137138367,
-1.0735375881195068,
-0.24639001488685608,
0.5532037615776062,
-0.4537726044654846,
0.30533894896507263,
0.21409380435943604,
0.6399362087249756,
-0.25780433416366577,
-0.12751002609729767,
0.1901531219482422,
-0.14627580344676971,
0.12716178596019745,
0.5545718669891357,
0.7237586379051208,
-0.31197014451026917,
0.45450282096862793,
-0.37636271119117737,
-0.4179074168205261,
0.11104768514633179,
-0.9912204146385193,
-1.0035680532455444,
-0.4226367771625519,
-0.489299476146698,
-0.36982080340385437,
0.08156666159629822,
0.7593546509742737,
0.9077028036117554,
-0.49393337965011597,
0.3300956189632416,
0.29239749908447266,
0.29957351088523865,
0.07629331946372986,
-0.21566566824913025,
0.41115790605545044,
-0.10713522136211395,
-0.71309894323349,
0.48649969696998596,
0.03555252030491829,
0.5548160076141357,
-0.0428803376853466,
-0.027836011722683907,
-0.15601587295532227,
0.12927433848381042,
0.4541498124599457,
0.09766174852848053,
-0.13480204343795776,
-0.1453404277563095,
-0.05747660622000694,
-0.030062533915042877,
0.04668792337179184,
0.6360553503036499,
-0.9825016260147095,
0.6399272680282593,
0.24192902445793152,
1.2176004648208618,
0.2663958668708801,
0.27631932497024536,
0.5227147936820984,
-1.1622364521026611,
0.2991449534893036,
0.3649348020553589,
0.23976631462574005,
0.8694088459014893,
-0.586847186088562,
0.5369805097579956,
0.18135155737400055,
-0.2683584988117218,
-0.8951975107192993,
0.25711050629615784,
-0.8684292435646057,
-0.25484395027160645,
0.9613619446754456,
0.06661874055862427,
-0.07378539443016052,
-0.06719917804002762,
-0.24947847425937653,
0.3185068368911743,
-0.46477165818214417,
0.3489384353160858,
0.6218216419219971,
0.1035841703414917,
-0.1540389508008957,
-0.3320068120956421,
0.5027754902839661,
0.46353980898857117,
-1.0018419027328491,
-0.1446242779493332,
0.5312333106994629,
-0.04280152916908264,
0.13777770102024078,
0.544879674911499,
0.055225126445293427,
0.03304195776581764,
-0.07052105665206909,
-0.06671057641506195,
-0.14778240025043488,
-0.24265380203723907,
-0.2317107915878296,
0.04910269007086754,
-0.07595885545015335,
-0.20655600726604462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14952v1
|
Evidence-Driven Retrieval Augmented Response Generation for Online Misinformation
| 2024-03-22T05:05:45 | 2024-03-22T05:05:45 |
Zhenrui Yue, Huimin Zeng, Yimeng Lu, Lanyu Shang, Yang Zhang, Dong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The proliferation of online misinformation has posed significant threats to
public interest. While numerous online users actively participate in the combat
against misinformation, many of such responses can be characterized by the lack
of politeness and supporting facts. As a solution, text generation approaches
are proposed to automatically produce counter-misinformation responses.
Nevertheless, existing methods are often trained end-to-end without leveraging
external knowledge, resulting in subpar text quality and excessively repetitive
responses. In this paper, we propose retrieval augmented response generation
for online misinformation (RARG), which collects supporting evidence from
scientific sources and generates counter-misinformation responses based on the
evidences. In particular, our RARG consists of two stages: (1) evidence
collection, where we design a retrieval pipeline to retrieve and rerank
evidence documents using a database comprising over 1M academic articles; (2)
response generation, in which we align large language models (LLMs) to generate
evidence-based responses via reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF).
We propose a reward function to maximize the utilization of the retrieved
evidence while maintaining the quality of the generated text, which yields
polite and factual responses that clearly refutes misinformation. To
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, we study the case of COVID-19 and
perform extensive experiments with both in- and cross-domain datasets, where
RARG consistently outperforms baselines by generating high-quality
counter-misinformation responses.
|
[
-0.5475934743881226,
-0.9821709990501404,
0.27855923771858215,
0.14418378472328186,
-0.18420304358005524,
0.06440801918506622,
-0.0595281757414341,
-0.558820366859436,
0.5427325367927551,
0.21140286326408386,
-0.49729788303375244,
-0.08113335072994232,
-0.4244247078895569,
0.39825111627578735,
-0.3422427177429199,
1.2762649059295654,
0.34359773993492126,
0.014217224903404713,
-0.5715525150299072,
0.07478416711091995,
-0.2731660008430481,
-0.43659859895706177,
-0.4313680827617645,
-0.4876852333545685,
0.5269693732261658,
0.7649901509284973,
0.2797543704509735,
0.18389484286308289,
0.670431911945343,
0.14503999054431915,
0.3447427451610565,
0.49662190675735474,
-0.6175022125244141,
0.3167911767959595,
-0.23090456426143646,
-0.18533992767333984,
-0.1523539125919342,
0.07386455684900284,
0.08695053309202194,
0.042582470923662186,
-0.5519478917121887,
0.3845396041870117,
-0.027321312576532364,
0.4867320656776428,
-0.7033544182777405,
-0.18360717594623566,
-0.6294739842414856,
-0.020056677982211113,
-0.06620915234088898,
-0.6815282106399536,
-0.5450670719146729,
-0.4586329460144043,
0.1774505078792572,
-0.9088707566261292,
0.44048604369163513,
0.19754236936569214,
0.8630985021591187,
0.1405271291732788,
-0.06456330418586731,
-0.5098294019699097,
-0.5768452882766724,
0.6109133958816528,
-0.682662844657898,
0.15625111758708954,
0.6196404695510864,
0.1781567931175232,
-0.16658265888690948,
-0.8474132418632507,
-0.5486094355583191,
-0.14841023087501526,
-0.09029176086187363,
0.32489728927612305,
-0.2967029809951782,
-0.3635631501674652,
0.2093096524477005,
0.32747775316238403,
-0.7535464763641357,
-0.20566214621067047,
-0.28051847219467163,
-0.46342673897743225,
0.7087540030479431,
0.009707150980830193,
0.21062645316123962,
-0.10545460134744644,
-0.3868979811668396,
-0.3566364347934723,
-0.7901864051818848,
0.018837830051779747,
0.2902587652206421,
0.2946223020553589,
0.0742914155125618,
0.5217183828353882,
-0.21450670063495636,
0.509698212146759,
0.6419494152069092,
-0.2858275771141052,
0.2537858784198761,
-0.435158908367157,
-0.08755246549844742,
0.5456185936927795,
0.8349592685699463,
0.36381304264068604,
-0.24197986721992493,
-0.014326867647469044,
-0.20040515065193176,
0.11920769512653351,
0.44786587357521057,
-1.1036646366119385,
-0.17915791273117065,
0.0458294078707695,
-0.39571413397789,
-0.39065319299697876,
-0.022069860249757767,
-1.1529492139816284,
-0.4308358430862427,
0.11598236113786697,
0.5159084796905518,
-0.2769172191619873,
-0.26332974433898926,
-0.03135109692811966,
-0.4289793372154236,
-0.16665446758270264,
0.4415901005268097,
-0.6565727591514587,
0.2674289047718048,
0.26622360944747925,
0.5545034408569336,
-0.03783907741308212,
0.191433846950531,
-1.0990071296691895,
0.01294278260320425,
-0.12374166399240494,
0.9358440041542053,
-0.6898859143257141,
-0.3963083326816559,
0.039594341069459915,
-0.27667275071144104,
0.19803738594055176,
-0.5652173161506653,
0.7026314735412598,
-0.7385305166244507,
0.6957865357398987,
-0.45920512080192566,
-0.37305811047554016,
-0.18555457890033722,
0.6584069132804871,
-0.5454031825065613,
1.0352622270584106,
-0.22015006840229034,
-1.2842485904693604,
0.38036373257637024,
-0.5237173438072205,
-0.5306910872459412,
0.21079207956790924,
-0.4208771288394928,
-0.7509937882423401,
-0.057316992431879044,
0.578355610370636,
0.08795995265245438,
-0.35436394810676575,
0.25546661019325256,
-0.17161473631858826,
-0.13043686747550964,
0.24851977825164795,
-0.28330540657043457,
0.21516704559326172,
0.44751855731010437,
-0.468626469373703,
0.07512835413217545,
-0.6737303137779236,
0.03732715919613838,
0.17911969125270844,
-0.5636770725250244,
-0.511411726474762,
0.09661098569631577,
0.05833374708890915,
0.2436608374118805,
0.12785306572914124,
-0.8644747138023376,
0.12769530713558197,
-0.30295851826667786,
-0.020948808640241623,
0.38525769114494324,
0.45504721999168396,
0.08240365982055664,
-0.6496798396110535,
0.50627201795578,
0.016071319580078125,
-0.04522089660167694,
-0.1442166417837143,
-0.5391661524772644,
-0.23628833889961243,
-0.13900990784168243,
-0.01318025030195713,
0.5262448191642761,
-1.032147765159607,
0.16890950500965118,
-0.2655709385871887,
-0.31556108593940735,
-0.5879408717155457,
-0.14582866430282593,
0.4084798991680145,
0.8069140911102295,
0.743121325969696,
-0.15313732624053955,
-0.7690552473068237,
-0.6331567764282227,
-0.4602571129798889,
-0.19473475217819214,
-0.003024197882041335,
0.3234291076660156,
0.30133071541786194,
-0.15132498741149902,
1.0024443864822388,
-0.38375720381736755,
-0.16562393307685852,
-0.21356651186943054,
0.6932812929153442,
-0.15775571763515472,
0.16976357996463776,
0.2762663662433624,
-0.8354546427726746,
-0.1504470854997635,
0.014053485356271267,
-0.6840779185295105,
-0.15225021541118622,
-0.24552664160728455,
0.3260865807533264,
0.18154022097587585,
0.27549150586128235,
-0.31791940331459045,
0.3835248649120331,
0.18155649304389954,
-0.15773268043994904,
0.45152929425239563,
-0.1968262791633606,
0.7227483987808228,
-0.8925089240074158,
0.2559807300567627,
0.10449396818876266,
-0.3902066946029663,
-0.5461272597312927,
0.07485951483249664,
-0.19571925699710846,
0.059265606105327606,
-0.2829069495201111,
0.46651771664619446,
-0.16323016583919525,
0.1634790152311325,
-0.6294570565223694,
0.171198308467865,
0.0594983845949173,
0.28128522634506226,
0.17049039900302887,
0.8437420725822449,
-0.021156325936317444,
-0.8065266013145447,
0.4214724600315094,
0.3837350010871887,
-0.27202752232551575,
0.5374243855476379,
-0.6328144073486328,
0.06297115236520767,
-0.2921708822250366,
0.2867389917373657,
-0.5714601278305054,
-0.5326695442199707,
0.5113823413848877,
-0.7707736492156982,
0.09722486883401871,
0.06074856221675873,
-0.26502397656440735,
-0.2547796964645386,
-0.4386518895626068,
0.30091241002082825,
0.2617087662220001,
-0.6306264400482178,
0.4150620102882385,
0.39424747228622437,
-0.3789604902267456,
-0.7454342842102051,
-0.7989184856414795,
0.11452073603868484,
-0.17409129440784454,
-0.5013331770896912,
0.23126833140850067,
-0.1540520042181015,
-0.3648637533187866,
0.048430219292640686,
-0.12371114641427994,
0.09816093742847443,
-0.1735144853591919,
0.21083775162696838,
-0.056550879031419754,
-0.01656217873096466,
0.2042245715856552,
-0.06866093724966049,
0.2708125114440918,
0.1692802757024765,
0.10380914807319641,
0.4393530488014221,
0.0052488273940980434,
-0.4165167808532715,
-0.280366986989975,
0.40073615312576294,
0.2774284780025482,
-0.22068281471729279,
0.5321440696716309,
0.7132954001426697,
-0.40347251296043396,
-0.04903139919042587,
-0.6391427516937256,
-0.6391956210136414,
-0.42301997542381287,
0.3638441264629364,
0.06553826481103897,
-0.8338749408721924,
0.2681841254234314,
0.0020066360011696815,
0.1609896570444107,
0.48101791739463806,
0.4385164976119995,
0.14008387923240662,
0.8685417175292969,
0.32086610794067383,
0.08082859963178635,
0.3967529833316803,
0.08097168803215027,
0.25655752420425415,
-0.30130526423454285,
-0.7167448997497559,
-0.6378011703491211,
-0.11098293215036392,
-0.28855499625205994,
-0.1918792873620987,
0.4699062407016754,
-0.03063242882490158,
-0.1976061463356018,
-0.0005234282580204308,
-0.5496086478233337,
0.030561238527297974,
0.5952042937278748,
0.2771362364292145,
0.35633304715156555,
0.4764910340309143,
-0.05229082703590393,
-0.08745533972978592,
-0.980717658996582,
-0.08506204932928085,
0.8656772375106812,
0.1761968582868576,
1.1037002801895142,
0.14346757531166077,
0.653197169303894,
0.7758767008781433,
0.4677858054637909,
-0.4948984980583191,
0.3332598805427551,
0.43318018317222595,
-0.481252521276474,
-0.07886577397584915,
-0.6773427724838257,
-0.7739332914352417,
-0.058358900249004364,
-0.561098039150238,
-0.22517046332359314,
0.19768570363521576,
0.32505378127098083,
-0.43471312522888184,
0.08892834186553955,
-0.36713138222694397,
0.23943255841732025,
-0.23130609095096588,
-0.5158079862594604,
-0.6402778029441833,
-0.6655266284942627,
0.4047212302684784,
-0.059287089854478836,
0.27896711230278015,
0.36353716254234314,
0.39608460664749146,
0.8101966977119446,
-0.3499276041984558,
0.6002300977706909,
-0.19306334853172302,
0.058671969920396805,
0.4099760055541992,
-0.006870957091450691,
0.761455774307251,
0.35092782974243164,
0.09324756264686584,
-0.4006521701812744,
-0.1819799542427063,
-0.2309679388999939,
-0.4196903705596924,
0.751326322555542,
-0.6759084463119507,
-0.578693151473999,
-0.7264030575752258,
-0.3603411018848419,
-0.05933814123272896,
0.02709764987230301,
0.5750102400779724,
0.4172861874103546,
-0.360698401927948,
0.11465427279472351,
0.9702348709106445,
-0.4273906350135803,
0.32392674684524536,
0.5702827572822571,
-0.30033719539642334,
-0.6682256460189819,
1.064827799797058,
-0.1352868527173996,
-0.0092541528865695,
0.5730221271514893,
0.28668448328971863,
-0.45181289315223694,
-0.20769073069095612,
-0.41580766439437866,
-0.14471641182899475,
-0.464072585105896,
-0.6653960347175598,
-0.593808114528656,
-0.22651733458042145,
-0.5232921242713928,
0.24832075834274292,
-0.08396007120609283,
-0.3116815388202667,
-0.23626646399497986,
-0.14175724983215332,
0.7688920497894287,
0.886651337146759,
-0.3251839578151703,
-0.01604899950325489,
-0.9369523525238037,
0.39940717816352844,
0.3939349055290222,
0.11311616748571396,
0.023210739716887474,
-0.6012306213378906,
-0.5008075833320618,
0.4081929326057434,
-0.5242264866828918,
-0.7507996559143066,
0.5877912640571594,
0.34214335680007935,
0.6226403117179871,
0.41931256651878357,
0.43623974919319153,
0.695541501045227,
-0.27098098397254944,
0.7587264180183411,
0.2839714586734772,
-0.40732941031455994,
0.5774391293525696,
-0.28698790073394775,
0.04187101125717163,
0.45984897017478943,
0.5172898173332214,
-0.5860980153083801,
-0.29675400257110596,
-0.6914069056510925,
-0.8862949013710022,
0.4569580554962158,
0.02522217482328415,
-0.20258186757564545,
-0.38334131240844727,
0.23555508255958557,
0.3327312171459198,
0.2961721420288086,
-0.5768203139305115,
-0.17335210740566254,
-0.5811962485313416,
0.0214445348829031,
0.4089783728122711,
-0.16198165714740753,
-0.47010794281959534,
0.1200549378991127,
0.9302070736885071,
-0.012064898386597633,
0.38395652174949646,
0.6407399773597717,
-0.2632109224796295,
-0.511841356754303,
0.44932687282562256,
0.8282625079154968,
0.4952169358730316,
-0.2970879375934601,
0.2227058708667755,
-0.1600698083639145,
-0.6453017592430115,
0.02228860929608345,
0.22287796437740326,
-0.27830806374549866,
0.04069407284259796,
0.15205346047878265,
0.43795520067214966,
-0.25962352752685547,
-0.8423739075660706,
0.6031402945518494,
-0.23512428998947144,
-0.25198909640312195,
-0.1677498072385788,
-0.16293470561504364,
-0.287944495677948,
0.13344499468803406,
0.8538036942481995,
0.3168123960494995,
0.20810650289058685,
-0.41617444157600403,
0.5945588946342468,
0.5646697282791138,
0.02956382744014263,
-0.17448461055755615,
0.5859997272491455,
0.34732571244239807,
-0.1810426115989685,
0.5926302671432495,
-0.3111301362514496,
-0.29857513308525085,
0.23993650078773499,
0.5968111753463745,
0.5282573699951172,
-0.14404787123203278,
0.4033699333667755,
0.6589176654815674,
0.11395096033811569,
-0.2645750343799591,
0.27364683151245117,
0.026725703850388527,
-0.41780051589012146,
-0.6178724765777588,
-0.4799870252609253,
-0.2365805208683014,
0.4369349479675293,
-0.7315319180488586,
-0.11692427098751068,
-0.41599082946777344,
-0.27334824204444885,
-0.3763377070426941,
0.017096418887376785,
-0.4669601321220398,
0.2250605672597885,
0.02292669378221035,
0.8244042992591858,
-0.8758838176727295,
0.35453900694847107,
0.6183404922485352,
-0.7050983309745789,
-0.44822609424591064,
0.24538250267505646,
-0.02738085575401783,
-0.5895478129386902,
0.6384817361831665,
-0.04638027772307396,
-0.28344231843948364,
-0.2393362820148468,
-0.8520050048828125,
-0.705808699131012,
0.8733671307563782,
0.24400408565998077,
-0.567443311214447,
0.28780597448349,
-0.05038862302899361,
0.477165549993515,
-0.31185123324394226,
0.4225444793701172,
0.0009538147132843733,
0.40554913878440857,
0.13023582100868225,
-0.7263370156288147,
0.14160524308681488,
-0.4283101260662079,
-0.3370172083377838,
-0.03155656158924103,
-0.3679560422897339,
0.3282187581062317,
-0.16119050979614258,
-0.3085896372795105,
0.005944032687693834,
0.8226697444915771,
0.46564728021621704,
0.5934923887252808,
0.23695743083953857,
0.9034824371337891,
0.7557374835014343,
0.062458522617816925,
0.9567014575004578,
-0.2214900255203247,
0.20796288549900055,
1.0045057535171509,
-0.009784186258912086,
0.8886989951133728,
0.5743730664253235,
0.17377126216888428,
0.6200418472290039,
0.7557196021080017,
0.150681272149086,
0.7739444375038147,
0.1520196497440338,
-0.535149872303009,
-0.3551880121231079,
-0.5591121315956116,
-0.6433453559875488,
-0.06317988783121109,
0.494890421628952,
-0.17438745498657227,
-0.407091349363327,
0.17319776117801666,
-0.04739392548799515,
0.40827661752700806,
-0.39107686281204224,
0.8164240121841431,
-0.17154879868030548,
-0.8863276243209839,
0.5495141744613647,
0.06819355487823486,
0.8397113084793091,
-0.4909325838088989,
-0.325190931558609,
-0.2767350971698761,
0.07210277765989304,
-0.4832150638103485,
-0.6883106231689453,
0.2738993465900421,
0.1635991483926773,
-0.4633927047252655,
-0.13606266677379608,
0.8473605513572693,
-0.5759552717208862,
-0.25317278504371643,
-0.09279270470142365,
0.5088330507278442,
-0.02785385400056839,
0.0747748389840126,
-0.5073202848434448,
-0.09625877439975739,
-0.032650917768478394,
-0.2552134394645691,
0.5554156303405762,
0.262121319770813,
-0.02923278883099556,
0.6597948670387268,
0.8427739143371582,
0.09966353327035904,
0.034257858991622925,
-0.12531974911689758,
1.017038345336914,
-0.2598182260990143,
-0.5133130550384521,
-0.4916156232357025,
0.18303672969341278,
-0.3054382801055908,
-0.04502671957015991,
0.7664896249771118,
0.6987869143486023,
0.7707423567771912,
-0.06477756798267365,
1.1160403490066528,
-0.2708081305027008,
0.8773192167282104,
-0.22059322893619537,
0.6457410454750061,
-0.509086549282074,
0.25435206294059753,
-0.02271154336631298,
-0.4077482521533966,
-0.21818943321704865,
0.6028972864151001,
-0.26777884364128113,
-0.04166429862380028,
0.3149596154689789,
0.8224703669548035,
0.08212476223707199,
-0.0376349613070488,
-0.022956036031246185,
0.06575367599725723,
0.457134872674942,
0.277208536863327,
0.6449728012084961,
-0.37531906366348267,
0.6663878560066223,
0.033438827842473984,
-0.03209386020898819,
-0.506321370601654,
-0.8950327038764954,
-0.6407503485679626,
-0.3689568042755127,
-0.2039080411195755,
-0.6924548745155334,
0.34994015097618103,
1.3144826889038086,
0.3956945240497589,
-0.7628080248832703,
0.19234542548656464,
-0.1465282291173935,
-0.18535614013671875,
-0.1905088573694229,
-0.2727442681789398,
0.24090735614299774,
-0.3106880187988281,
-0.19130301475524902,
0.579513669013977,
0.06599050760269165,
-0.18849244713783264,
-0.08215322345495224,
-0.3531540334224701,
-0.5358554124832153,
0.23701566457748413,
0.39770400524139404,
0.7534914612770081,
-0.5107384324073792,
-0.3018309473991394,
0.1886560469865799,
-0.2616581916809082,
0.11331945657730103,
0.7547546029090881,
-1.112882137298584,
0.5378902554512024,
0.6672306656837463,
0.9761576056480408,
0.574918270111084,
0.42169368267059326,
0.5957349538803101,
-0.9857677817344666,
-0.1358569860458374,
0.38845741748809814,
0.013544142246246338,
0.5714309215545654,
-0.5125207304954529,
0.11894917488098145,
0.3337647020816803,
-0.703872561454773,
-0.6884543895721436,
0.16071490943431854,
-0.6697021722793579,
-0.20577490329742432,
1.022694706916809,
-0.025430191308259964,
0.006406526546925306,
-0.11723461002111435,
-0.1488018035888672,
0.22799047827720642,
-0.9641953110694885,
1.2802678346633911,
0.37186750769615173,
-0.3489918112754822,
-0.25554201006889343,
-0.18246059119701385,
0.6998308300971985,
0.28014272451400757,
-0.9663041234016418,
-0.024166518822312355,
0.611012876033783,
0.33073222637176514,
0.3510171175003052,
0.42383962869644165,
0.025168076157569885,
0.6153002381324768,
-0.07783659547567368,
0.22075079381465912,
-0.3252910077571869,
-0.2791202664375305,
-0.08942415565252304,
0.21611963212490082,
-0.04978978633880615,
-0.08458703756332397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14950v1
|
KnowLA: Enhancing Parameter-efficient Finetuning with Knowledgeable Adaptation
| 2024-03-22T04:48:41 | 2024-03-22T04:48:41 |
Xindi Luo, Zequn Sun, Jing Zhao, Zhe Zhao, Wei Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) is a key technique for adapting large
language models (LLMs) to downstream tasks. In this paper, we study leveraging
knowledge graph embeddings to improve the effectiveness of PEFT. We propose a
knowledgeable adaptation method called KnowLA. It inserts an adaptation layer
into an LLM to integrate the embeddings of entities appearing in the input
text. The adaptation layer is trained in combination with LoRA on instruction
data. Experiments on six benchmarks with two popular LLMs and three knowledge
graphs demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of KnowLA. We show that
\modelname can help activate the relevant parameterized knowledge in an LLM to
answer a question without changing its parameters or input prompts.
|
[
-0.2219451516866684,
-1.2030662298202515,
0.6971172094345093,
0.07331755757331848,
-0.13035021722316742,
0.14068232476711273,
-0.21607472002506256,
-0.19963927567005157,
-0.019150154665112495,
0.5855269432067871,
-0.010663028806447983,
-0.4135829508304596,
-0.4326525628566742,
-0.32598239183425903,
-0.2947463095188141,
0.9076333045959473,
-0.09169375896453857,
-0.06991143524646759,
-0.013735507614910603,
-0.08384978771209717,
-0.31330546736717224,
-0.24698640406131744,
-0.9737541675567627,
-0.23351623117923737,
0.5057453513145447,
0.35094842314720154,
0.5753361582756042,
0.47586336731910706,
0.18568627536296844,
0.23210369050502777,
-0.12440034747123718,
0.5616274476051331,
-0.722501814365387,
0.2698805034160614,
-0.22482560575008392,
-0.6829614639282227,
-0.554021418094635,
-0.3198125660419464,
1.0331873893737793,
0.8315727710723877,
-0.01934007927775383,
0.09421761333942413,
0.46015623211860657,
0.7565311193466187,
-0.6963927745819092,
0.3395119905471802,
-0.6886194944381714,
-0.07097030431032181,
-0.08245595544576645,
-0.1869698315858841,
-0.5584147572517395,
-0.6573365926742554,
0.22734616696834564,
-0.7536686062812805,
-0.33506640791893005,
0.08344434201717377,
0.6374874114990234,
0.5437563061714172,
-0.24208329617977142,
-0.09899768233299255,
-0.7269589900970459,
0.533545970916748,
-0.7389706969261169,
0.8212037682533264,
0.3459213972091675,
0.5593463182449341,
-0.22080473601818085,
-0.9998572468757629,
-0.4633587896823883,
-0.09824647754430771,
0.1452140212059021,
-0.11088577657938004,
-0.21011266112327576,
0.12818409502506256,
0.10243196040391922,
0.10742050409317017,
0.04647590592503548,
0.14582502841949463,
-0.27790623903274536,
-0.23129412531852722,
0.35774898529052734,
-0.1856805384159088,
0.17576032876968384,
0.2897121012210846,
-0.32549038529396057,
-0.03893057629466057,
-0.8361396789550781,
0.2105235755443573,
0.3610861599445343,
0.4466758072376251,
-0.1383613497018814,
0.3467444181442261,
-0.0604153610765934,
1.1894804239273071,
0.48983192443847656,
-0.3715131878852844,
0.23793627321720123,
-0.024998053908348083,
-0.39056628942489624,
0.017987580969929695,
0.474905401468277,
0.1299079805612564,
0.3109503984451294,
-0.3443637192249298,
-0.09066663682460785,
-0.7457602620124817,
0.04677405580878258,
-0.7947080731391907,
-0.3557465672492981,
-0.05411134287714958,
-0.12068989127874374,
-0.024944065138697624,
-0.14037171006202698,
-0.6475686430931091,
-0.4796803891658783,
-0.18535402417182922,
0.6511155962944031,
-0.6142707467079163,
0.03853622078895569,
-0.052277252078056335,
-0.07554268091917038,
0.3631097078323364,
0.5689836740493774,
-0.768348753452301,
0.3083929717540741,
0.4094785153865814,
0.6962490081787109,
0.09148355573415756,
-0.225600928068161,
-0.9866952896118164,
0.531739354133606,
-0.32399269938468933,
0.8573356866836548,
-0.6292818188667297,
0.1181127056479454,
-0.2002125382423401,
0.06115776300430298,
-0.4206249713897705,
-0.40168601274490356,
0.48351582884788513,
-0.8825828433036804,
0.09034184366464615,
-0.2929743528366089,
-0.8630073666572571,
-0.5001365542411804,
0.215736523270607,
-0.7189042568206787,
0.8580539226531982,
0.4196614921092987,
-0.6735751032829285,
0.2679973542690277,
-0.783599853515625,
-0.3418355882167816,
0.018468432128429413,
0.002647226909175515,
-0.22505103051662445,
-0.11352606862783432,
0.44925010204315186,
0.7087953090667725,
-0.03562018647789955,
0.10405280441045761,
-0.39331942796707153,
-0.1604790985584259,
0.06320077925920486,
-0.29201680421829224,
0.510930597782135,
0.26795753836631775,
0.026290101930499077,
0.002178938128054142,
-0.6112426519393921,
0.14087994396686554,
0.005029703956097364,
-0.7550955414772034,
-0.4703270494937897,
-0.04124443233013153,
-0.1647786647081375,
-0.3465258479118347,
0.26119691133499146,
-0.2839992046356201,
0.19515886902809143,
-0.8045125007629395,
0.49633145332336426,
0.711762547492981,
0.058985285460948944,
0.6609508395195007,
-0.2730932831764221,
0.49032944440841675,
-0.14549115300178528,
-0.1570628583431244,
0.1294827163219452,
-0.2804379463195801,
-0.793275773525238,
-0.1307665854692459,
0.5668548941612244,
0.5076775550842285,
-0.9651841521263123,
0.2832096219062805,
0.10420022159814835,
-0.6014899015426636,
-0.4680723547935486,
0.5319883227348328,
0.3029744327068329,
0.8303084969520569,
0.30161237716674805,
0.16201549768447876,
-0.3519676923751831,
-0.7016063332557678,
-0.2863054871559143,
0.022373994812369347,
0.19132152199745178,
0.23743969202041626,
-0.028808262199163437,
0.12547409534454346,
0.8946159482002258,
-0.6455724239349365,
-0.33046379685401917,
-0.3152276277542114,
-0.35161054134368896,
0.26831936836242676,
0.3222067356109619,
0.8733881115913391,
-0.5572569370269775,
-0.6428006887435913,
0.11875446140766144,
-0.5226665735244751,
0.08485420048236847,
0.04465509578585625,
-0.1739032119512558,
-0.008990883827209473,
0.6445534229278564,
-0.1358826905488968,
-0.10462526977062225,
0.637607216835022,
-0.5413293838500977,
0.19743025302886963,
-0.46454620361328125,
-0.0972260907292366,
-1.2617262601852417,
-0.07337765395641327,
-0.09119603037834167,
-0.6675999164581299,
-0.7527874708175659,
0.14511092007160187,
0.09623271226882935,
-0.0506582036614418,
-0.5394614934921265,
0.6369578838348389,
-0.3372364342212677,
0.012429963797330856,
-0.07998037338256836,
0.24334527552127838,
0.10532235354185104,
0.3746797442436218,
-0.17468133568763733,
0.8665229082107544,
0.790687620639801,
-0.7983107566833496,
0.275518000125885,
0.14915087819099426,
-0.4590487480163574,
0.37817949056625366,
-0.5799266695976257,
0.42249730229377747,
-0.18195918202400208,
-0.03402514383196831,
-0.8883963227272034,
-0.18221993744373322,
0.35075831413269043,
0.08983180671930313,
0.4648956060409546,
-0.2797119617462158,
-0.12884794175624847,
-0.10700705647468567,
-0.23879893124103546,
0.08653907477855682,
0.3920622766017914,
-0.6768162846565247,
0.8323799967765808,
0.5383998155593872,
-0.2512323558330536,
-0.4409996569156647,
-0.5202664136886597,
-0.2073083221912384,
-0.3578576147556305,
-0.4802819788455963,
0.387058287858963,
-0.09057587385177612,
-0.07187259942293167,
-0.08207739889621735,
0.10297539085149765,
-0.3339897692203522,
0.28556862473487854,
-0.05474554002285004,
-0.2135961651802063,
-0.4790310263633728,
0.42948877811431885,
0.5857108235359192,
0.20501285791397095,
-0.12834559381008148,
-0.3670034110546112,
0.6864917874336243,
-0.15339654684066772,
-0.11314741522073746,
-0.470355749130249,
-0.026851091533899307,
0.5210667252540588,
-0.1876767873764038,
0.9293137192726135,
0.7152591943740845,
-0.3674386441707611,
-0.45034080743789673,
-0.4948112666606903,
-0.03220600634813309,
-0.5002201199531555,
0.5153092741966248,
-0.4672788977622986,
-1.022015929222107,
0.5115452408790588,
-0.3869662880897522,
-0.15675462782382965,
0.2658499777317047,
0.32579314708709717,
-0.16830229759216309,
0.6596028804779053,
0.7930561900138855,
-0.07968069612979889,
0.5832736492156982,
-0.30377107858657837,
0.2584865987300873,
-0.9283885359764099,
-0.2539643347263336,
-0.2907196283340454,
-0.3461126983165741,
-0.2743447422981262,
-0.6715306639671326,
0.2317102700471878,
0.5951279997825623,
-0.45805612206459045,
0.21212755143642426,
-0.28826791048049927,
0.5811546444892883,
0.4652253985404968,
0.5341800451278687,
0.24186746776103973,
0.14148958027362823,
-0.025263959541916847,
0.16343708336353302,
-0.8991589546203613,
-0.4483976364135742,
1.1396645307540894,
0.572409987449646,
0.9745323061943054,
0.10728521645069122,
0.639011561870575,
0.26051974296569824,
-0.04996972903609276,
-0.7970756888389587,
0.33033573627471924,
-0.3478274345397949,
-0.169907346367836,
-0.5149568319320679,
-0.15429311990737915,
-0.6780537962913513,
-0.2626273036003113,
-0.2136673480272293,
-0.8191086649894714,
0.352348655462265,
0.34328991174697876,
-0.7492583990097046,
0.4880189597606659,
-0.9981834888458252,
0.5971880555152893,
-0.23717650771141052,
-0.18316185474395752,
0.07168637961149216,
-0.16067823767662048,
0.03553685545921326,
-0.5328342318534851,
0.08529233187437057,
-0.02242140844464302,
-0.15395419299602509,
1.2264864444732666,
-0.412362664937973,
0.9345466494560242,
-0.44583800435066223,
-0.3460686504840851,
0.4205961227416992,
-0.05497635155916214,
0.8600706458091736,
-0.13057813048362732,
-0.38945573568344116,
-0.2195567488670349,
0.16886699199676514,
-0.30105313658714294,
-0.8617618083953857,
0.84818434715271,
-0.9511722326278687,
-0.7134634256362915,
0.28414201736450195,
-0.8521775603294373,
-0.5888434648513794,
0.37694790959358215,
-0.11872252821922302,
0.3703223764896393,
-0.051541779190301895,
0.24242563545703888,
0.587450385093689,
-0.16035591065883636,
0.30344855785369873,
0.3123733699321747,
-0.44647690653800964,
-0.2571178674697876,
0.9617187976837158,
0.395396888256073,
0.22919146716594696,
0.48567062616348267,
0.39254114031791687,
-0.3938232362270355,
-0.7119678854942322,
-0.40396997332572937,
0.21154385805130005,
-0.9314733147621155,
-0.2718721926212311,
-0.663267970085144,
-0.2556595504283905,
-0.4683084785938263,
-0.2167726308107376,
-0.4407837986946106,
-0.5389880537986755,
-0.38234442472457886,
-0.0790337473154068,
0.78310227394104,
0.8289981484413147,
0.2408231794834137,
0.6320809721946716,
-0.5747940540313721,
0.186147078871727,
0.6843261122703552,
0.4378458261489868,
-0.01032431609928608,
-0.8396188020706177,
-0.1297074258327484,
0.07022527605295181,
-0.10495304316282272,
-1.0064668655395508,
0.20917820930480957,
0.8445881009101868,
0.8697612285614014,
0.5225297808647156,
0.21272574365139008,
0.7382258176803589,
-0.34306421875953674,
0.2775845527648926,
-0.06263794004917145,
-1.0623283386230469,
0.6477054357528687,
-0.2281835526227951,
0.09237195551395416,
0.5295807719230652,
0.4954504370689392,
0.08101852983236313,
-0.23524533212184906,
-0.17641407251358032,
-0.42527616024017334,
0.5780324339866638,
-0.1411719024181366,
0.4381733536720276,
0.3861694037914276,
0.6426648497581482,
0.17307452857494354,
-0.11237884312868118,
-0.576433002948761,
-0.062439557164907455,
0.028475182130932808,
-0.3669975697994232,
0.094148188829422,
-0.42390620708465576,
-0.06965810060501099,
-0.4190092086791992,
0.5824397802352905,
-0.42679911851882935,
0.24983061850070953,
0.000641156337223947,
-0.25991132855415344,
0.02152085490524769,
0.22706468403339386,
0.18775099515914917,
0.8756329417228699,
-0.16558215022087097,
0.23555316030979156,
0.550761878490448,
-0.4113408923149109,
-0.04802269861102104,
0.2887439727783203,
-0.24862204492092133,
-0.3474512994289398,
0.33388182520866394,
0.9356926083564758,
0.359401673078537,
-0.45109423995018005,
0.23160409927368164,
0.2061283439397812,
-0.11669886112213135,
-0.03238580375909805,
0.47568339109420776,
0.31095176935195923,
0.767330527305603,
0.26591143012046814,
-0.15204554796218872,
-0.022812971845269203,
-0.4759603440761566,
0.1591721773147583,
0.24922771751880646,
-0.5498308539390564,
-0.11048384755849838,
0.47543469071388245,
0.23199215531349182,
-0.4056156575679779,
0.19748638570308685,
-0.08323594927787781,
-0.42859145998954773,
0.21073828637599945,
0.9506293535232544,
0.24971483647823334,
-0.4804975390434265,
0.2471686452627182,
0.17176160216331482,
0.0905805230140686,
0.26178282499313354,
0.409841388463974,
0.008672388270497322,
-0.8241177201271057,
-0.5959486365318298,
-0.7560017108917236,
-0.3133736848831177,
-0.027275243774056435,
-0.4993645250797272,
0.3406739830970764,
-0.7777257561683655,
-0.09269828349351883,
0.06473271548748016,
-0.15222471952438354,
-0.7661769986152649,
-0.03144481033086777,
0.010975691489875317,
1.0543462038040161,
-0.820483922958374,
1.128705620765686,
0.8741984367370605,
-0.2826038897037506,
-1.3545639514923096,
0.01929735392332077,
-0.553305447101593,
-1.1855062246322632,
0.7190472483634949,
-0.27020463347435,
-0.04020512476563454,
0.49343064427375793,
-0.4722979664802551,
-1.0930280685424805,
1.2474652528762817,
0.9824790954589844,
-0.7306163311004639,
-0.13224394619464874,
-0.034705568104982376,
0.3584045171737671,
-0.3972117602825165,
-0.08268018066883087,
0.6425146460533142,
0.5025831460952759,
0.023193806409835815,
-0.8683335185050964,
0.1162300631403923,
0.0790899246931076,
-0.34470438957214355,
0.12888307869434357,
-0.5370632410049438,
0.6725038290023804,
-0.28480541706085205,
-0.01660139486193657,
-0.18515433371067047,
0.7216595411300659,
0.09299645572900772,
0.3451176881790161,
0.5993133187294006,
0.4075360596179962,
1.305859923362732,
0.040476858615875244,
0.893364429473877,
-0.2985656261444092,
0.3378656208515167,
1.3693938255310059,
-0.08300892263650894,
1.051930546760559,
0.551506519317627,
-0.3717770576477051,
0.6090432405471802,
0.34763914346694946,
0.08328013867139816,
0.7201489210128784,
-0.030747156590223312,
-0.08154889941215515,
-0.45418843626976013,
-0.22871260344982147,
-0.4785666763782501,
0.6027905344963074,
0.46467509865760803,
-0.6356977820396423,
-0.36402836441993713,
0.298276424407959,
0.2327096313238144,
0.1243109330534935,
-0.541736364364624,
0.790091872215271,
0.04267160966992378,
-0.45855847001075745,
0.6920215487480164,
-0.10178922116756439,
0.2847953140735626,
-0.5007651448249817,
-0.1619759351015091,
-0.09271872788667679,
0.28591084480285645,
-0.1647554636001587,
-0.9546754956245422,
0.18169379234313965,
-0.08309881389141083,
-0.1568537950515747,
0.11414114385843277,
1.0614668130874634,
-0.5330144166946411,
-0.6669360399246216,
0.3624333143234253,
0.7308681011199951,
0.19013631343841553,
-0.12632006406784058,
-0.6891852617263794,
-0.03769642487168312,
0.0898335874080658,
-0.13799402117729187,
0.22368836402893066,
0.32956504821777344,
0.12221857160329819,
0.8328571915626526,
0.5308597087860107,
0.11994742602109909,
0.05723630264401436,
0.1574299931526184,
1.2209975719451904,
-0.36632826924324036,
-0.44520238041877747,
-0.7208452224731445,
0.2903720438480377,
0.053920913487672806,
0.013496850617229939,
0.8086320161819458,
0.2641026973724365,
0.6113237738609314,
0.02244199626147747,
0.6435494422912598,
0.03802262246608734,
0.3934421241283417,
-0.8911969661712646,
1.0656459331512451,
-0.3352900743484497,
0.2982511818408966,
-0.330949068069458,
-1.24390709400177,
-0.26977333426475525,
0.5144466161727905,
-0.7063540816307068,
0.10128188878297806,
0.5627679824829102,
0.6666370034217834,
-0.2160319983959198,
-0.21756726503372192,
0.5145416259765625,
0.4117148816585541,
0.10159225761890411,
0.6743499040603638,
0.6998311877250671,
-0.40837615728378296,
0.4922623634338379,
-0.32927897572517395,
-0.09455553442239761,
-0.05859227105975151,
-0.9285425543785095,
-1.1145129203796387,
-0.5304616689682007,
-0.39585256576538086,
-0.14026783406734467,
0.418802946805954,
0.6159926652908325,
0.88935387134552,
-0.8462411761283875,
0.16730965673923492,
0.09329522401094437,
0.4003043472766876,
-0.018698949366807938,
-0.15608030557632446,
0.8821382522583008,
-0.4541366398334503,
-0.7779070138931274,
0.6367462873458862,
0.09452635794878006,
0.013535045087337494,
-0.11382252722978592,
-0.23957405984401703,
-0.29606926441192627,
-0.0982079952955246,
0.6646079421043396,
0.14268074929714203,
-0.5163307189941406,
-0.607450008392334,
-0.09956330806016922,
0.45677119493484497,
-0.11870784312486649,
0.4330751299858093,
-0.8789482116699219,
0.5552740693092346,
0.4634668827056885,
0.9374358654022217,
0.3283351957798004,
-0.07679618895053864,
0.6957250833511353,
-0.7169600129127502,
0.055303022265434265,
-0.04921496659517288,
0.4897008538246155,
0.3670327961444855,
-0.4290560781955719,
0.3645298480987549,
-0.11893106251955032,
-0.45733821392059326,
-0.6549142003059387,
-0.06070636585354805,
-1.0281200408935547,
-0.19742301106452942,
1.1197491884231567,
-0.4790322482585907,
-0.2815713584423065,
-0.2847711145877838,
-0.3960200548171997,
0.37888821959495544,
-0.364042192697525,
0.4296261668205261,
0.40672436356544495,
-0.026283983141183853,
-0.36106595396995544,
-0.300464928150177,
0.3849608302116394,
0.25359275937080383,
-0.9357893466949463,
-0.10675214976072311,
0.09572671353816986,
0.42032670974731445,
0.0017136118840426207,
0.43574103713035583,
0.17485295236110687,
0.15971803665161133,
-0.2239484339952469,
-0.4788001477718353,
-0.46205416321754456,
-0.2815089225769043,
-0.19117216765880585,
0.40601861476898193,
0.7189267873764038,
-0.04922449588775635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14946v1
|
A Single Linear Layer Yields Task-Adapted Low-Rank Matrices
| 2024-03-22T04:38:42 | 2024-03-22T04:38:42 |
Hwichan Kim, Shota Sasaki, Sho Hoshino, Ukyo Honda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) is a widely used Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
(PEFT) method that updates an initial weight matrix $W_0$ with a delta matrix
$\Delta W$ consisted by two low-rank matrices $A$ and $B$. A previous study
suggested that there is correlation between $W_0$ and $\Delta W$. In this
study, we aim to delve deeper into relationships between $W_0$ and low-rank
matrices $A$ and $B$ to further comprehend the behavior of LoRA. In particular,
we analyze a conversion matrix that transform $W_0$ into low-rank matrices,
which encapsulates information about the relationships. Our analysis reveals
that the conversion matrices are similar across each layer. Inspired by these
findings, we hypothesize that a single linear layer, which takes each layer's
$W_0$ as input, can yield task-adapted low-rank matrices. To confirm this
hypothesis, we devise a method named Conditionally Parameterized LoRA
(CondLoRA) that updates initial weight matrices with low-rank matrices derived
from a single linear layer. Our empirical results show that CondLoRA maintains
a performance on par with LoRA, despite the fact that the trainable parameters
of CondLoRA are fewer than those of LoRA. Therefore, we conclude that "a single
linear layer yields task-adapted low-rank matrices."
|
[
-0.31961244344711304,
-0.8468559980392456,
0.5864090919494629,
-0.10296468436717987,
-0.09307482093572617,
-0.190863236784935,
-0.13063374161720276,
-0.47121289372444153,
0.2393939048051834,
0.5402252078056335,
-0.6952992081642151,
-0.19036971032619476,
-0.4966280162334442,
-0.26788660883903503,
-0.3974020481109619,
1.1909536123275757,
-0.18092720210552216,
-0.24319888651371002,
-0.012423955835402012,
-0.3544045090675354,
-0.4966811537742615,
-0.35332995653152466,
-0.7490822076797485,
-0.48800191283226013,
1.1785038709640503,
0.6365257501602173,
0.6530866622924805,
0.17827589809894562,
0.6762336492538452,
0.2685696482658386,
0.1396290510892868,
0.05136515200138092,
-0.9008298516273499,
-0.07811255007982254,
-0.2791418731212616,
-0.5553398728370667,
-0.7636836767196655,
0.26310697197914124,
0.4013816714286804,
1.0219508409500122,
0.11248735338449478,
0.8314116597175598,
0.5928877592086792,
0.9536585807800293,
-0.848484218120575,
-0.3340308666229248,
-0.8237845301628113,
0.10994695127010345,
-0.2268625795841217,
-0.4639531075954437,
-0.42407628893852234,
-0.25461965799331665,
-0.1338963657617569,
-0.7841755151748657,
0.062188033014535904,
-0.08321622759103775,
0.8134127855300903,
0.7207444310188293,
-0.4074833393096924,
0.0001644754083827138,
-0.865746259689331,
0.7824077010154724,
-0.5993518233299255,
-0.002987155457958579,
0.22674353420734406,
0.43739116191864014,
-0.1191139817237854,
-0.5432436466217041,
-0.3242267668247223,
-0.13524463772773743,
-0.0521869920194149,
0.09040717035531998,
-0.23636627197265625,
0.03511194512248039,
0.33551812171936035,
0.05174070596694946,
-0.06895454972982407,
0.31559062004089355,
-0.5657667517662048,
0.07132019847631454,
0.3431013226509094,
-0.05704602599143982,
-0.10169695317745209,
-0.07356167584657669,
-0.6555955410003662,
-0.10476229339838028,
-0.7134560942649841,
0.5690160393714905,
0.3095298707485199,
0.4667247235774994,
-0.2613741457462311,
0.49769484996795654,
-0.0446443185210228,
0.5961280465126038,
0.5741361975669861,
-0.4001381993293762,
0.13162842392921448,
-0.18860934674739838,
-0.6010339856147766,
0.283560574054718,
0.31655406951904297,
0.13575400412082672,
0.11233264207839966,
-0.24920788407325745,
-0.10218200087547302,
0.19153788685798645,
0.2644866108894348,
-0.8310583829879761,
-0.15957048535346985,
-0.035869844257831573,
-0.774600088596344,
-0.18189214169979095,
-0.0818951278924942,
-0.4020734429359436,
-0.34393689036369324,
-0.40044793486595154,
1.2948527336120605,
-0.163521870970726,
0.19377198815345764,
0.12424154579639435,
0.0003975261643063277,
0.41756656765937805,
0.7368320822715759,
-0.5670355558395386,
0.6510719060897827,
0.49512922763824463,
0.4986426830291748,
-0.4438195824623108,
-0.49690499901771545,
-0.9151360392570496,
0.04239576309919357,
-0.2347666472196579,
0.6522933840751648,
-0.1871234029531479,
0.02796492539346218,
-0.32371053099632263,
0.09346377849578857,
-0.4802449345588684,
-0.4267103970050812,
0.5889772772789001,
-0.5237359404563904,
0.03376423195004463,
-0.637026846408844,
0.10887841880321503,
-0.2509687840938568,
0.06267029047012329,
-0.6434250473976135,
1.088728666305542,
0.28468969464302063,
-0.750649631023407,
0.5453377962112427,
-0.7602813839912415,
-0.22503520548343658,
-0.29503926634788513,
0.19538290798664093,
-0.31418511271476746,
0.2939695715904236,
-0.11878087371587753,
0.2989684045314789,
-0.4181119203567505,
-0.5105978846549988,
-0.5001788139343262,
-0.6989989280700684,
0.2650810182094574,
0.020130382850766182,
0.4604862332344055,
0.0942748486995697,
-0.19402767717838287,
-0.10747233033180237,
-0.8450442552566528,
0.2342906892299652,
-0.17849472165107727,
-0.5862383246421814,
-0.41862574219703674,
0.26943936944007874,
-0.2216111421585083,
0.2751122713088989,
0.5966816544532776,
-0.6590564250946045,
0.25577276945114136,
-0.029438572004437447,
0.24195213615894318,
0.9172891974449158,
0.20218046009540558,
0.5072343945503235,
-0.4626503586769104,
0.2488853484392166,
0.1944260150194168,
0.18340009450912476,
0.5009002089500427,
-0.225556880235672,
-1.0739244222640991,
-0.022455206140875816,
0.30458471179008484,
0.47823411226272583,
-0.5445829033851624,
0.07412906736135483,
-0.11180496215820312,
-0.4399925172328949,
-0.5481896996498108,
0.5025719404220581,
0.3869946599006653,
0.6495757699012756,
0.49880725145339966,
-0.2333754003047943,
-0.5332852005958557,
-1.1738489866256714,
-0.08388422429561615,
-0.06774856895208359,
0.27640068531036377,
0.14293695986270905,
0.5975556373596191,
-0.0074905832298099995,
0.7386617064476013,
-0.37420332431793213,
-0.5337374210357666,
0.012784198857843876,
-0.030402755364775658,
0.7453420758247375,
0.8649617433547974,
0.9934598803520203,
-0.24672310054302216,
-0.5816149115562439,
0.20830097794532776,
-0.599033534526825,
0.12054455280303955,
-0.12770958244800568,
-0.6314770579338074,
-0.0798976942896843,
0.5453102588653564,
-0.17976908385753632,
0.48639118671417236,
0.8137093782424927,
-0.2951366901397705,
0.02417963556945324,
-0.48877060413360596,
0.02204001694917679,
-0.9196227192878723,
0.3699328303337097,
-0.09458638727664948,
-0.11655008047819138,
-0.7367515563964844,
-0.03460844233632088,
-0.16039279103279114,
-0.09608438611030579,
-0.273480087518692,
0.13213534653186798,
-0.2271648794412613,
-0.4977710545063019,
-0.25264501571655273,
-0.17366701364517212,
0.016657236963510513,
1.0743011236190796,
-0.5140372514724731,
0.6626332402229309,
0.3758627772331238,
-0.6836028099060059,
-0.16914300620555878,
0.18411777913570404,
-0.2471771240234375,
0.6589343547821045,
-0.7662718892097473,
0.4443650543689728,
-0.05983121320605278,
-0.07717686146497726,
-0.9092646241188049,
0.25205156207084656,
0.010672066360712051,
-0.037273894995450974,
-0.16698795557022095,
-0.4697834253311157,
-0.3892709016799927,
0.018726812675595284,
-0.4902985692024231,
0.34718042612075806,
0.6155388355255127,
-0.5179941654205322,
0.3368346393108368,
0.17408132553100586,
0.06433462351560593,
-0.4451676905155182,
-0.8037368655204773,
-0.4160701632499695,
-0.2526214122772217,
-0.543102502822876,
0.4491453170776367,
-0.36599040031433105,
-0.07177873700857162,
0.04591028392314911,
-0.30670684576034546,
0.028283793479204178,
0.5420714020729065,
0.47620269656181335,
0.20896941423416138,
-0.6546499133110046,
-0.4019332826137543,
0.4136959910392761,
0.0892820805311203,
0.04208726808428764,
-0.20420745015144348,
0.23314900696277618,
0.19027148187160492,
-0.373109370470047,
-0.3624192178249359,
0.19489428400993347,
0.7226932048797607,
0.013818444684147835,
0.8781895041465759,
0.5604717135429382,
-0.3227476477622986,
-0.5639698505401611,
-0.2550923824310303,
0.024255745112895966,
-0.5026667714118958,
0.11750465631484985,
-0.7107776999473572,
-0.2581993341445923,
0.7488069534301758,
-0.05466248095035553,
0.010968037880957127,
0.5512599349021912,
0.35972702503204346,
-0.34914615750312805,
0.8204907178878784,
0.8997873663902283,
0.1428118497133255,
0.49500542879104614,
-0.5097954869270325,
-0.021233024075627327,
-1.0594325065612793,
-0.07699121534824371,
-0.6004807353019714,
-1.198150396347046,
-0.7673320174217224,
-0.2175966501235962,
0.6230556964874268,
0.41206708550453186,
-0.5908894538879395,
0.431550532579422,
-0.5038769841194153,
0.21680951118469238,
0.5619434714317322,
0.5221666693687439,
0.20694081485271454,
0.13495180010795593,
-0.08527397364377975,
0.0926610603928566,
-0.5521773099899292,
0.005337481386959553,
0.8433284163475037,
0.21179881691932678,
1.0730082988739014,
0.3839476406574249,
0.7525489926338196,
0.5941441059112549,
0.02065889909863472,
-0.5285758972167969,
0.5044373869895935,
-0.6722037196159363,
-0.19257918000221252,
-0.26536330580711365,
-0.08881008625030518,
-1.0923606157302856,
0.2881644070148468,
-0.41052624583244324,
-0.8019266724586487,
1.045333981513977,
0.2697669267654419,
-0.4721806049346924,
0.17080630362033844,
-0.845971941947937,
0.7825007438659668,
-0.2137613296508789,
-0.5773745775222778,
-0.2762029767036438,
-0.3317265808582306,
0.1623530387878418,
-0.33947819471359253,
-0.009168408811092377,
-0.25338634848594666,
-0.09588207304477692,
1.0312303304672241,
-0.3303743600845337,
0.7124621272087097,
-0.5606061220169067,
-0.2150793820619583,
-0.029510436579585075,
0.22806118428707123,
0.5278505682945251,
-0.0954778790473938,
-0.4468342363834381,
-0.16568663716316223,
0.1871207356452942,
-0.6623294949531555,
-0.4356899857521057,
0.9815766215324402,
-1.3861002922058105,
-0.42161861062049866,
-0.19280840456485748,
-0.63511723279953,
-0.38175246119499207,
0.10921033471822739,
-0.02374308928847313,
0.20045211911201477,
-0.09098004549741745,
0.24567173421382904,
0.5129185914993286,
-0.06399721652269363,
0.3420719802379608,
0.5846827030181885,
-0.10569337010383606,
0.2553098499774933,
0.687751829624176,
0.243899405002594,
0.3907592296600342,
0.5615344643592834,
0.010253893211483955,
0.3928886353969574,
-0.7009184956550598,
-0.15337908267974854,
0.05019943416118622,
-0.7957960367202759,
-0.16534489393234253,
-0.025062356144189835,
-0.34544286131858826,
0.20040689408779144,
-0.4366263747215271,
-0.3667462170124054,
-0.5089356899261475,
-0.16253872215747833,
0.2948800027370453,
0.369559645652771,
0.7133737802505493,
-0.020892856642603874,
0.2619718313217163,
-0.17107650637626648,
0.41812580823898315,
0.654252290725708,
0.09472860395908356,
0.03420292213559151,
-0.8041592836380005,
-0.4074260890483856,
0.10383161157369614,
-0.13357393443584442,
-0.7668430805206299,
0.011609180830419064,
0.5492972731590271,
0.6536537408828735,
0.1831897646188736,
0.022812530398368835,
0.8844647407531738,
-0.33903172612190247,
0.3829599916934967,
0.03869229555130005,
-1.0009503364562988,
0.48932763934135437,
-0.3599918782711029,
0.07061698287725449,
0.9003796577453613,
-0.04762865602970123,
-0.07957450300455093,
0.0639338418841362,
-0.20660218596458435,
-0.4424465298652649,
1.0796709060668945,
0.26102665066719055,
0.043280936777591705,
0.7825469970703125,
0.40636733174324036,
0.345444917678833,
0.1469917595386505,
-0.7536977529525757,
-0.3730190098285675,
-0.23299208283424377,
0.21882252395153046,
-0.1221354752779007,
-0.054743267595767975,
-0.31042975187301636,
-0.31602081656455994,
0.3652679920196533,
-0.35346391797065735,
0.532710611820221,
0.09247060865163803,
-0.41774532198905945,
-0.4725857377052307,
0.2241259068250656,
0.48912039399147034,
0.8377423286437988,
-0.7663743495941162,
0.22854802012443542,
0.4457570016384125,
-0.3725510239601135,
0.11993549019098282,
0.012466338463127613,
-0.24874283373355865,
-0.17979927361011505,
0.2627415359020233,
0.9112051129341125,
0.5742303729057312,
0.027720365673303604,
0.165293350815773,
0.2832068204879761,
-0.2596987783908844,
0.000714863941539079,
0.305963397026062,
-0.1310916393995285,
0.24663332104682922,
0.7430700063705444,
0.5173409581184387,
-0.09647969901561737,
-0.8841780424118042,
-0.12203347682952881,
0.4226403832435608,
-0.1744554489850998,
-0.5336570739746094,
0.6148397326469421,
0.14336241781711578,
-0.12085820734500885,
-0.10311650484800339,
-0.10660252720117569,
-0.055302511900663376,
0.6980781555175781,
0.4377062916755676,
0.5600464344024658,
-0.04225623235106468,
0.27803993225097656,
0.2925622761249542,
0.3372436463832855,
0.22863665223121643,
0.3966510593891144,
-0.09481429308652878,
-0.593307614326477,
-0.39478781819343567,
-0.9140065908432007,
-0.27981889247894287,
0.2316001057624817,
-0.9724475145339966,
0.13501404225826263,
-0.6741947531700134,
-0.1395246386528015,
0.3329809010028839,
0.24780867993831635,
-0.9058542251586914,
0.02674396149814129,
0.39346346259117126,
0.8043642044067383,
-0.9070987701416016,
1.23444402217865,
0.8467735648155212,
-0.3066941499710083,
-0.7579711079597473,
0.010653781704604626,
-0.44603991508483887,
-1.0467480421066284,
0.9137436151504517,
-0.3347831070423126,
-0.28712743520736694,
0.00953806471079588,
-0.3896753191947937,
-1.248769998550415,
1.4880515336990356,
0.8703474402427673,
-0.2181692123413086,
-0.3046450912952423,
0.2274712473154068,
0.510345995426178,
-0.4454759657382965,
-0.23538455367088318,
0.4499400854110718,
0.4224153161048889,
-0.22223994135856628,
-1.157855749130249,
0.13976238667964935,
-0.2307426780462265,
0.14969907701015472,
0.13294276595115662,
-0.6896763443946838,
1.5851775407791138,
-0.12431056052446365,
-0.009140238165855408,
0.2783694863319397,
0.4517177939414978,
0.14987985789775848,
0.2721349596977234,
0.7216306328773499,
0.28084757924079895,
0.510546863079071,
0.22116224467754364,
0.8284924030303955,
-0.40796908736228943,
0.43392375111579895,
0.901786744594574,
-0.3850235342979431,
0.9716687798500061,
0.6165593266487122,
-0.3223535716533661,
1.0915021896362305,
0.301344633102417,
0.07668396830558777,
0.7598180174827576,
-0.038622140884399414,
0.2445763200521469,
-0.24700985848903656,
0.02400442771613598,
-0.3970823884010315,
0.6713422536849976,
0.2338770031929016,
-0.24561579525470734,
-0.370207816362381,
0.12838274240493774,
-0.06559628248214722,
-0.045640721917152405,
-0.9312812089920044,
0.5752688646316528,
0.04955633357167244,
-0.9051180481910706,
0.9997706413269043,
0.034536026418209076,
0.5835554003715515,
-0.7903580069541931,
0.05994105339050293,
-0.25027328729629517,
0.583171010017395,
-0.48668646812438965,
-0.3559437096118927,
-0.1587548702955246,
-0.12837812304496765,
-0.4367794394493103,
-0.13957421481609344,
0.851607620716095,
-0.13500189781188965,
-0.6557033061981201,
0.6085258722305298,
0.806745707988739,
-0.25602373480796814,
0.2924397885799408,
-0.8122259378433228,
0.13684356212615967,
-0.1306779533624649,
-0.22667446732521057,
0.7991598844528198,
0.04315554350614548,
-0.061930183321237564,
0.30528736114501953,
0.7478683590888977,
0.08141916990280151,
0.18380290269851685,
-0.21752864122390747,
0.9742956757545471,
-0.28312551975250244,
-0.46891868114471436,
-0.35440903902053833,
0.29962098598480225,
0.27987802028656006,
-0.3002428114414215,
0.691326916217804,
0.29820454120635986,
0.4125653803348541,
-0.09193485975265503,
0.44633084535598755,
-0.1488463282585144,
0.39182859659194946,
-0.8801201581954956,
0.563046932220459,
-0.8275941610336304,
0.261074036359787,
-0.39229339361190796,
-1.102790355682373,
0.4958862364292145,
0.5049089789390564,
-0.2724049687385559,
-0.06727513670921326,
1.025937795639038,
0.700929582118988,
-0.5708745718002319,
-0.6504663825035095,
0.24152952432632446,
0.37428513169288635,
-0.2868605852127075,
1.0420902967453003,
0.3562951982021332,
-0.6973296403884888,
0.5149403810501099,
-0.330192893743515,
0.10883254557847977,
-0.20331859588623047,
-0.7913026213645935,
-0.8077706694602966,
-0.6159366965293884,
-0.2944726049900055,
-0.43750378489494324,
0.23842929303646088,
0.5164403915405273,
0.9370629191398621,
-0.9748830795288086,
-0.3221099376678467,
0.307233065366745,
0.027411924675107002,
-0.4864000380039215,
-0.12687085568904877,
0.5920712351799011,
-0.057930272072553635,
-0.6149322390556335,
0.45946547389030457,
0.07726003974676132,
-0.3132210373878479,
-0.3735043406486511,
-0.22995442152023315,
-0.22451384365558624,
0.33620816469192505,
0.5584043860435486,
0.4054184556007385,
-0.5462774038314819,
-0.5165350437164307,
-0.14628762006759644,
-0.23988813161849976,
0.21012736856937408,
0.7191547751426697,
-1.0960737466812134,
-0.16394402086734772,
0.4145950376987457,
0.398471862077713,
0.7256002426147461,
-0.023783087730407715,
0.13923129439353943,
-0.9004958868026733,
0.42633819580078125,
-0.2826522886753082,
0.44784408807754517,
-0.020749259740114212,
-0.33983999490737915,
0.40488454699516296,
-0.08363669365644455,
-0.48551222681999207,
-0.9480234980583191,
0.08270274847745895,
-1.7584521770477295,
-0.1764240264892578,
0.871757447719574,
0.007609917316585779,
-0.2538880407810211,
0.21918825805187225,
-0.1964634507894516,
-0.0805722028017044,
-0.2445058822631836,
0.587803304195404,
0.0564894936978817,
-0.2984980344772339,
-0.06289292871952057,
-0.5450112819671631,
0.5897894501686096,
0.5461199879646301,
-0.8893309235572815,
-0.3918890058994293,
-0.13422250747680664,
0.2921479046344757,
0.3395736515522003,
0.4865506887435913,
0.46738672256469727,
0.5901616215705872,
-0.255521297454834,
-0.2702084481716156,
-0.10724477469921112,
0.11285778135061264,
-0.09672658145427704,
0.5030739307403564,
0.485739529132843,
-0.4049042761325836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14938v1
|
On Zero-Shot Counterspeech Generation by LLMs
| 2024-03-22T04:13:10 | 2024-03-22T04:13:10 |
Punyajoy Saha, Aalok Agrawal, Abhik Jana, Chris Biemann, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the emergence of numerous Large Language Models (LLM), the usage of such
models in various Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications is increasing
extensively. Counterspeech generation is one such key task where efforts are
made to develop generative models by fine-tuning LLMs with hatespeech -
counterspeech pairs, but none of these attempts explores the intrinsic
properties of large language models in zero-shot settings. In this work, we
present a comprehensive analysis of the performances of four LLMs namely GPT-2,
DialoGPT, ChatGPT and FlanT5 in zero-shot settings for counterspeech
generation, which is the first of its kind. For GPT-2 and DialoGPT, we further
investigate the deviation in performance with respect to the sizes (small,
medium, large) of the models. On the other hand, we propose three different
prompting strategies for generating different types of counterspeech and
analyse the impact of such strategies on the performance of the models. Our
analysis shows that there is an improvement in generation quality for two
datasets (17%), however the toxicity increase (25%) with increase in model
size. Considering type of model, GPT-2 and FlanT5 models are significantly
better in terms of counterspeech quality but also have high toxicity as
compared to DialoGPT. ChatGPT are much better at generating counter speech than
other models across all metrics. In terms of prompting, we find that our
proposed strategies help in improving counter speech generation across all the
models.
|
[
-0.5481319427490234,
-0.7972363233566284,
0.5188363790512085,
0.17054790258407593,
-0.4594026803970337,
-0.08005574345588684,
-0.016376962885260582,
-0.38478198647499084,
-0.030487677082419395,
0.5182021260261536,
-0.6220849752426147,
-0.3034455180168152,
-0.5057113766670227,
0.35012975335121155,
-0.39884114265441895,
0.9333672523498535,
0.268464058637619,
0.25506535172462463,
0.010474048554897308,
-0.07436062395572662,
-0.8393463492393494,
-0.6011995673179626,
-0.7309242486953735,
-0.6089535355567932,
0.3861240744590759,
0.43392178416252136,
0.3575092852115631,
0.2884390652179718,
-0.08842147141695023,
0.1853296458721161,
-0.016294293105602264,
-0.09301389753818512,
-0.6629726886749268,
0.5538455247879028,
-0.15605255961418152,
-0.4297887980937958,
-0.32974618673324585,
-0.05430629849433899,
0.5117085576057434,
0.11986785382032394,
-0.23818811774253845,
0.1769026219844818,
-0.045270517468452454,
0.23119984567165375,
-0.5072211623191833,
-0.014744357205927372,
-1.077760100364685,
0.11236532032489777,
-0.43550407886505127,
-0.3786601126194,
-0.6804050803184509,
-0.011281867511570454,
-0.22775422036647797,
-0.05152976140379906,
0.3834245800971985,
-0.11689814180135727,
0.6809946298599243,
0.1858765184879303,
-0.13386797904968262,
-0.3522989749908447,
-0.6263648271560669,
0.9275219440460205,
-1.2646727561950684,
0.08919920772314072,
-0.10392121225595474,
0.2011241465806961,
-0.32305219769477844,
-0.4638274013996124,
-0.7795882225036621,
-0.255730539560318,
0.16521510481834412,
0.28948572278022766,
-0.47545838356018066,
-0.11262733489274979,
0.4409686028957367,
0.1417091339826584,
-0.848111629486084,
0.5074847936630249,
-0.035770732909440994,
0.018258564174175262,
0.4853501319885254,
0.4754301905632019,
0.17774304747581482,
-0.3005329668521881,
-0.3306356966495514,
0.11924931406974792,
-1.1948899030685425,
-0.3130834698677063,
0.10157717764377594,
0.5392217040061951,
0.039068058133125305,
0.6867297291755676,
-0.4193632900714874,
0.9240502119064331,
0.011123557575047016,
-0.05550406500697136,
-0.19213928282260895,
-0.3363247811794281,
-0.25721558928489685,
-0.01236752700060606,
1.0161139965057373,
0.2557409107685089,
0.7727158665657043,
0.07318539172410965,
-0.07226447761058807,
0.22158026695251465,
0.2942063808441162,
-1.2302242517471313,
-0.07871589809656143,
0.23042689263820648,
0.08311478048563004,
-0.6759440302848816,
-0.5609011054039001,
-0.5871566534042358,
-0.13456326723098755,
-0.122172512114048,
0.45220649242401123,
-0.491350919008255,
-0.27899208664894104,
-0.17114846408367157,
0.052433546632528305,
0.38531163334846497,
0.1361248791217804,
-0.9328158497810364,
0.09040988236665726,
0.5734401941299438,
1.0777838230133057,
-0.1480477750301361,
-0.12995506823062897,
-0.5589557886123657,
-0.019766420125961304,
-0.71517413854599,
0.9759414792060852,
-0.24828088283538818,
-0.7471392154693604,
0.023541076108813286,
-0.4918595850467682,
-0.05593807250261307,
-0.605607807636261,
0.08940257132053375,
-0.3449590504169464,
0.25758516788482666,
-0.442283570766449,
-0.5734819769859314,
0.12747979164123535,
0.3356534540653229,
-0.364141583442688,
0.8153986930847168,
-0.01158157642930746,
-0.6606408953666687,
0.5275599360466003,
-0.5692220330238342,
-0.4067336916923523,
0.5252642035484314,
-0.45896196365356445,
-0.39451414346694946,
0.3432387113571167,
0.12865565717220306,
0.6959372162818909,
-0.37684929370880127,
0.15528370440006256,
-0.04006052389740944,
-0.34000077843666077,
0.19058802723884583,
-0.4851762354373932,
0.6406205296516418,
0.28477364778518677,
-0.5090450048446655,
-0.050111208111047745,
-0.5295098423957825,
0.24853189289569855,
0.3974485397338867,
-0.05176961421966553,
0.1891438066959381,
-0.09185129404067993,
-0.21744859218597412,
0.4022684395313263,
-0.3596307039260864,
-0.5046840310096741,
0.0936887189745903,
-0.35721853375434875,
0.5186321139335632,
0.5768393874168396,
0.4933148920536041,
-0.004269062075763941,
-0.42034268379211426,
0.6911337375640869,
0.1644437313079834,
-0.21987831592559814,
-0.5473539233207703,
-0.6047131419181824,
-0.7662277221679688,
-0.30136650800704956,
0.32627424597740173,
0.5772744417190552,
-1.0035488605499268,
0.023870693519711494,
-0.14571572840213776,
-0.6322457194328308,
-0.2934552729129791,
-0.021082960069179535,
0.6119616031646729,
0.8466548323631287,
0.14744983613491058,
-0.5052273869514465,
-0.24701222777366638,
-0.5560124516487122,
-0.25494834780693054,
-0.16889819502830505,
-0.1315201222896576,
0.4153115451335907,
0.287539005279541,
0.1869581937789917,
0.9550337791442871,
-0.37988683581352234,
0.1336241364479065,
-0.4138498902320862,
0.4032379984855652,
0.2998809218406677,
0.003844652557745576,
0.7969245314598083,
-0.003291138680651784,
-0.9463972449302673,
-0.456559419631958,
-0.5679696202278137,
-0.5629902482032776,
-0.10512450337409973,
0.1664302498102188,
0.7437212467193604,
0.28376418352127075,
-0.7900445461273193,
0.4099234640598297,
0.49419966340065,
0.0013353257672861218,
0.8933115601539612,
0.3413470685482025,
-0.06968405842781067,
-0.953610897064209,
0.19342629611492157,
-0.23204173147678375,
-0.35722294449806213,
-1.224931001663208,
0.07841155678033829,
-0.2898750603199005,
-0.4243963956832886,
-0.8162401914596558,
0.6083196997642517,
-0.2903566360473633,
0.1290518045425415,
-0.2726714611053467,
0.32623013854026794,
-0.1556384265422821,
0.4030674397945404,
0.3101019263267517,
0.9051730632781982,
0.5458343625068665,
-0.6628003120422363,
0.19258767366409302,
0.14327602088451385,
-0.2947429120540619,
0.7974333167076111,
-0.8590441346168518,
0.29971176385879517,
0.12935596704483032,
0.23192258179187775,
-0.9573884606361389,
-0.003117938060313463,
0.13882975280284882,
-0.763470470905304,
0.38085439801216125,
-0.13834819197654724,
-0.504981279373169,
-0.18252477049827576,
-0.35288164019584656,
0.06438367068767548,
0.5395593047142029,
-0.3172994554042816,
-0.04608004540205002,
-0.08908971399068832,
-0.4689866602420807,
-0.39125117659568787,
-0.5580472946166992,
0.2566474676132202,
-0.1408410668373108,
-0.4266606569290161,
-0.12361964583396912,
-0.08498282730579376,
-0.19557110965251923,
-0.23257525265216827,
0.09831694513559341,
0.5569722652435303,
-0.29407936334609985,
0.2824888229370117,
0.21548599004745483,
-0.2980152666568756,
-0.005052992608398199,
-0.3151177763938904,
-0.3718656301498413,
-0.1914689689874649,
-0.06500168889760971,
1.1114784479141235,
0.18448348343372345,
-0.26736748218536377,
-0.16851216554641724,
0.2618345618247986,
0.367196649312973,
-0.15104307234287262,
0.8195810914039612,
0.5749310255050659,
-0.013347800821065903,
-0.3751269578933716,
-0.552049994468689,
-0.21275217831134796,
-0.42071375250816345,
0.17645464837551117,
-0.46767961978912354,
-0.8021485209465027,
0.46589377522468567,
0.007872411049902439,
0.18679387867450714,
0.5459139347076416,
1.0882773399353027,
0.1624966710805893,
0.9199785590171814,
0.18959136307239532,
-0.18283206224441528,
0.3676963746547699,
-0.0925820916891098,
0.2789890468120575,
-0.5825364589691162,
0.07645630091428757,
-0.4726189970970154,
0.10538292676210403,
-0.6325787901878357,
-0.36435043811798096,
0.40538322925567627,
0.12747716903686523,
-0.37356802821159363,
0.3423881232738495,
-0.4334583282470703,
0.253807008266449,
0.5719406008720398,
-0.4476771950721741,
0.1349678784608841,
0.3386479914188385,
-0.39354753494262695,
-0.09414606541395187,
-1.0849038362503052,
-0.4451352059841156,
0.9572718739509583,
0.15054430067539215,
0.4896140992641449,
0.10105139017105103,
0.7314566969871521,
0.014344383962452412,
0.3004268705844879,
-0.8264477252960205,
0.6419466137886047,
-0.2378898710012436,
-0.653348445892334,
-0.42794638872146606,
-0.4893057644367218,
-0.8935710191726685,
0.2773137390613556,
-0.27080875635147095,
-0.6376178860664368,
-0.19829556345939636,
0.17578302323818207,
-0.48625943064689636,
0.3433311879634857,
-0.4444495737552643,
0.5280137062072754,
-0.09462109208106995,
-0.3684278726577759,
-0.10517257452011108,
-0.2728031575679779,
0.5916134715080261,
-0.14469611644744873,
-0.23538680374622345,
-0.27591294050216675,
0.20764918625354767,
0.23469185829162598,
-0.3082924783229828,
0.7344834208488464,
-0.3068145215511322,
-0.19311906397342682,
0.6649710536003113,
0.5130172967910767,
0.6037570238113403,
-0.19687765836715698,
-0.21506699919700623,
0.626274049282074,
0.020947247743606567,
-0.26838698983192444,
-0.09073686599731445,
0.8112626671791077,
-0.5376119613647461,
-0.457446426153183,
-0.3888896405696869,
-0.3139817416667938,
-0.43244367837905884,
0.3251950740814209,
0.6594955921173096,
0.4384337067604065,
-0.2547129988670349,
0.017392907291650772,
0.4735036790370941,
-0.5074918270111084,
0.6316350698471069,
0.992138147354126,
-0.1798100620508194,
-0.27286583185195923,
0.9895939826965332,
0.4734666347503662,
0.5976410508155823,
0.07811036705970764,
0.15156349539756775,
-0.21101996302604675,
-0.49367812275886536,
-0.6954203844070435,
0.2638559937477112,
-0.18969734013080597,
-0.5490812063217163,
-0.4258427023887634,
-0.5874584913253784,
-0.7607756853103638,
-0.07080289721488953,
-0.23383936285972595,
-0.42245301604270935,
-0.3734779357910156,
-0.0772571861743927,
0.3909386694431305,
0.8723118305206299,
-0.23796893656253815,
0.5738142728805542,
-0.6191295385360718,
0.5475054979324341,
0.4364008605480194,
0.37357097864151,
0.17784510552883148,
-0.5275720357894897,
0.12524189054965973,
-0.09192938357591629,
-0.39233165979385376,
-1.0197927951812744,
0.5937894582748413,
0.12329058349132538,
0.34887805581092834,
0.3235781490802765,
-0.040820419788360596,
0.6420835852622986,
-0.8109951615333557,
1.1014463901519775,
0.340697705745697,
-0.7647501230239868,
0.4489486515522003,
-0.6374272108078003,
0.8026129603385925,
0.2134929746389389,
0.20442712306976318,
-0.929330587387085,
-0.4283207952976227,
-0.6799304485321045,
-0.83963543176651,
0.7701097726821899,
0.30754554271698,
0.31676506996154785,
-0.26819148659706116,
0.29364013671875,
0.011885072104632854,
0.23934873938560486,
-0.647513747215271,
0.041924845427274704,
-0.31892961263656616,
0.13085341453552246,
-0.1377381682395935,
-0.5733659863471985,
-0.041280798614025116,
0.30385881662368774,
0.6691457629203796,
0.046206310391426086,
0.12665019929409027,
-0.02577666938304901,
-0.0510522685945034,
-0.4182991683483124,
0.3721989691257477,
0.9610137343406677,
0.43228647112846375,
-0.1089305728673935,
-0.009479114785790443,
0.40677082538604736,
-0.28620466589927673,
0.06552233546972275,
-0.45514923334121704,
-0.46720075607299805,
0.22341935336589813,
0.6659756898880005,
0.8485835790634155,
0.05093133822083473,
-0.45668554306030273,
0.3139292597770691,
0.13087202608585358,
-0.35536742210388184,
-0.2666305899620056,
0.45285725593566895,
0.06689901649951935,
-0.13259421288967133,
0.09863089770078659,
-0.3885957896709442,
-0.2880522608757019,
-0.5181417465209961,
0.2903960943222046,
0.6385492086410522,
-0.30407896637916565,
-0.2522933781147003,
0.5319812297821045,
0.15694725513458252,
-0.46973705291748047,
0.775776207447052,
-0.19826723635196686,
-0.3502664864063263,
0.3440278470516205,
0.7374504804611206,
0.7958295941352844,
-0.5678201913833618,
0.336159884929657,
0.640407919883728,
0.1482437700033188,
0.24031345546245575,
0.13600030541419983,
-0.07271759957075119,
-0.8488538265228271,
-0.5875466465950012,
-0.7517794966697693,
-0.47550246119499207,
0.6163234114646912,
-0.3797646462917328,
0.22641853988170624,
-0.42783766984939575,
-0.21804872155189514,
0.003962073475122452,
0.18100912868976593,
-0.5899038910865784,
0.1133001297712326,
0.1674719750881195,
0.7037782073020935,
-0.8759391903877258,
0.5662195086479187,
0.055894885212183,
-0.2854483127593994,
-0.6929785013198853,
-0.21920396387577057,
0.3416944444179535,
-1.0542563199996948,
0.35878047347068787,
0.005528935696929693,
-0.2348334640264511,
0.16593676805496216,
-0.5499346852302551,
-0.41947153210639954,
0.9502671360969543,
0.15476743876934052,
-0.9655073285102844,
0.3366645276546478,
0.6833646893501282,
0.7744731307029724,
-0.3568213880062103,
0.35336416959762573,
0.590853214263916,
0.20469802618026733,
0.4295800030231476,
-0.9371192455291748,
0.007194507401436567,
-0.025384068489074707,
0.11586513370275497,
0.005285996478050947,
-0.838452160358429,
0.8537809252738953,
-0.08902594447135925,
-0.43047305941581726,
0.13131393492221832,
0.0765351951122284,
0.7780988812446594,
0.043177466839551926,
0.36740630865097046,
0.6821476221084595,
0.005625101737678051,
0.01420202199369669,
0.903171718120575,
-0.3237229287624359,
0.0950251966714859,
1.2997084856033325,
-0.6339940428733826,
1.0434051752090454,
0.2315772920846939,
-0.22888542711734772,
0.18979674577713013,
0.3320225179195404,
-0.1124020516872406,
0.13412930071353912,
0.41781026124954224,
-0.33334606885910034,
-0.10515198856592178,
-0.10745276510715485,
-0.2738582193851471,
0.5608749389648438,
0.30570170283317566,
-0.05102391168475151,
-0.42011329531669617,
-0.37085676193237305,
0.34420666098594666,
-0.15339191257953644,
-0.051046133041381836,
1.0053248405456543,
0.2596215307712555,
-0.8000448346138,
0.7412126064300537,
0.03542295843362808,
0.5647899508476257,
-0.5713934898376465,
-0.10724200308322906,
-0.4564043879508972,
-0.21364685893058777,
-0.028887543827295303,
-0.5848715901374817,
0.17237670719623566,
0.4126262366771698,
-0.007949573919177055,
-0.17359162867069244,
0.7915475964546204,
-0.305867999792099,
-0.4720122814178467,
0.032236307859420776,
0.5139433145523071,
0.4133400022983551,
-0.1505596786737442,
-0.5331462621688843,
-0.09562191367149353,
-0.03565629944205284,
-0.32594558596611023,
0.37885645031929016,
0.21025285124778748,
-0.05075443536043167,
0.5223841071128845,
0.6487864851951599,
0.6165447235107422,
0.15232306718826294,
0.41179075837135315,
0.5192117094993591,
-0.6879016757011414,
0.017673522233963013,
-1.0382009744644165,
0.42471620440483093,
0.11761301010847092,
-0.06699620932340622,
0.8366768956184387,
0.31605538725852966,
0.5251118540763855,
-0.11526284366846085,
0.5631570816040039,
0.02220229245722294,
0.8176065683364868,
-0.3824520707130432,
0.7880179286003113,
-0.06631704419851303,
0.0896962359547615,
-0.17686861753463745,
-0.9613268971443176,
-0.2298312932252884,
0.24913646280765533,
-0.11578540503978729,
0.10032624006271362,
0.16000202298164368,
1.0317126512527466,
0.3077106475830078,
-0.32221266627311707,
0.7974308729171753,
0.4830632507801056,
0.5751681327819824,
0.4665597379207611,
0.7621816992759705,
-0.1735079288482666,
0.3943551480770111,
0.07394766807556152,
-0.09024054557085037,
-0.19467422366142273,
-0.9213991761207581,
-0.8227195739746094,
-0.2804049551486969,
-0.012953391298651695,
-0.013713742606341839,
-0.044668857008218765,
0.2034376710653305,
0.6909112930297852,
-0.9420177340507507,
-0.1504768431186676,
-0.10929926484823227,
-0.2531362473964691,
0.2216855138540268,
-0.2972855269908905,
-0.13376863300800323,
-0.5618188977241516,
-0.5653337240219116,
0.4228895604610443,
0.4831063449382782,
0.1036597490310669,
-0.4695919156074524,
-0.007703613024204969,
-0.16098648309707642,
0.7241563200950623,
0.8865958452224731,
0.39623674750328064,
-0.7217692136764526,
-0.20146796107292175,
-0.06753485649824142,
0.07452762126922607,
-0.17667420208454132,
0.8792938590049744,
-0.8268467783927917,
0.5339606404304504,
0.5840533971786499,
-0.06642989069223404,
0.7641037702560425,
0.02327200397849083,
0.5704765915870667,
-1.0769455432891846,
0.1790480613708496,
0.2833768129348755,
-0.035701751708984375,
0.2562074661254883,
-0.1497361958026886,
0.6567586660385132,
-0.030409902334213257,
-0.5673615336418152,
-0.9395683407783508,
0.4846169948577881,
-0.5367775559425354,
-0.3063792884349823,
1.1525248289108276,
0.03569873049855232,
0.32654204964637756,
0.12891089916229248,
0.007607828360050917,
0.36745065450668335,
-0.10234401375055313,
0.6169930100440979,
0.8256621956825256,
-0.549324631690979,
-0.39289531111717224,
-0.9253605604171753,
0.44827669858932495,
0.646404504776001,
-0.5810558795928955,
0.06624293327331543,
0.4383905231952667,
0.48258405923843384,
0.16739633679389954,
0.8437895178794861,
-0.2892354726791382,
0.011358409188687801,
0.301798939704895,
0.061239875853061676,
-0.10593559592962265,
-0.14286358654499054,
-0.44928720593452454,
-0.007711230777204037,
0.2421233057975769,
0.11299692094326019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14932v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14932v3
|
Extending Token Computation for LLM Reasoning
| 2024-03-22T03:23:58 | 2024-06-23T15:50:48 |
Bingli Liao, Danilo Vasconcellos Vargas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are pivotal in advancing natural language
processing but often struggle with complex reasoning tasks due to inefficient
attention distributions. In this paper, we explore the effect of increased
computed tokens on LLM performance and introduce a novel method for extending
computed tokens in the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) process, utilizing attention
mechanism optimization. By fine-tuning an LLM on a domain-specific, highly
structured dataset, we analyze attention patterns across layers, identifying
inefficiencies caused by non-semantic tokens with outlier high attention
scores. To address this, we propose an algorithm that emulates early layer
attention patterns across downstream layers to re-balance skewed attention
distributions and enhance knowledge abstraction. Our findings demonstrate that
our approach not only facilitates a deeper understanding of the internal
dynamics of LLMs but also significantly improves their reasoning capabilities,
particularly in non-STEM domains. Our study lays the groundwork for further
innovations in LLM design, aiming to create more powerful, versatile, and
responsible models capable of tackling a broad range of real-world
applications.
|
[
-0.22020484507083893,
-0.8720005750656128,
0.7996724247932434,
-0.0004820810863748193,
-0.48747122287750244,
0.2701468765735626,
-0.34754878282546997,
-0.5800257921218872,
0.22028404474258423,
0.725560188293457,
-0.5486063361167908,
-0.4779462516307831,
-0.5761203765869141,
-0.15909941494464874,
-0.18444137275218964,
0.7841442227363586,
-0.01860041730105877,
-0.24735575914382935,
-0.40486109256744385,
0.10965453088283539,
-0.35131722688674927,
-0.6656197905540466,
-0.7566062808036804,
-0.4314177930355072,
0.4613037407398224,
0.2552642524242401,
0.37974438071250916,
0.5894584059715271,
0.5517282485961914,
0.24873414635658264,
-0.3505967855453491,
0.6874551773071289,
-0.6332884430885315,
0.07779818773269653,
-0.4215998947620392,
-0.6355198621749878,
-0.6598148941993713,
-0.4009418785572052,
0.4518216848373413,
0.7738323211669922,
0.16821503639221191,
0.32843419909477234,
0.18138107657432556,
0.6126294136047363,
-0.8125823140144348,
0.2695003151893616,
-0.8631981611251831,
-0.05630321055650711,
-0.11472183465957642,
-0.49000391364097595,
-0.6917126774787903,
-0.013560987077653408,
0.13608188927173615,
-0.5748688578605652,
0.13144120573997498,
0.16657693684101105,
0.3597325384616852,
0.3809417188167572,
-0.20602336525917053,
-0.09149736166000366,
-0.43551912903785706,
0.784809410572052,
-0.7693556547164917,
0.35257211327552795,
0.042837779968976974,
-0.13117115199565887,
-0.4747079908847809,
-0.8613266348838806,
-0.3429332971572876,
-0.20033517479896545,
-0.04237234219908714,
-0.10681408643722534,
-0.11475228518247604,
0.28931576013565063,
0.34132006764411926,
0.23785747587680817,
-0.10656034201383591,
0.022640513256192207,
-0.15995018184185028,
-0.2761927843093872,
0.34371882677078247,
0.3812372386455536,
0.003924776334315538,
0.07048334181308746,
-0.47929027676582336,
0.23894460499286652,
-0.6804541349411011,
0.17579279839992523,
0.15479913353919983,
0.3961907625198364,
-0.14641952514648438,
0.6776931881904602,
-0.18436218798160553,
0.7311907410621643,
0.11757870018482208,
-0.016986122354865074,
0.10305148363113403,
-0.3792431950569153,
-0.3595465123653412,
0.1347638964653015,
0.2763306498527527,
0.2613755464553833,
0.26719674468040466,
-0.2469666749238968,
-0.22092655301094055,
-0.07676859945058823,
0.3629528880119324,
-0.6318467259407043,
0.04374692216515541,
0.25801703333854675,
-0.3132909834384918,
-0.2741791605949402,
-0.09402012079954147,
-0.47004783153533936,
-0.344857782125473,
-0.6926689743995667,
0.12944409251213074,
-0.2544657289981842,
-0.166503444314003,
0.37318336963653564,
-0.13455718755722046,
0.09207431972026825,
0.3020623028278351,
-0.670977771282196,
0.28110143542289734,
1.1574565172195435,
0.7175896167755127,
-0.32996833324432373,
-0.06231512501835823,
-0.8898597359657288,
0.45097461342811584,
-0.2934887111186981,
0.7260663509368896,
-0.7282598614692688,
0.015933465212583542,
-0.14938344061374664,
-0.24348494410514832,
-0.16196781396865845,
-0.40631547570228577,
0.6568553447723389,
-0.7407494187355042,
-0.3093244135379791,
-0.16996043920516968,
-0.7136861681938171,
0.04374787211418152,
0.4211519658565521,
-0.5682603716850281,
1.095069408416748,
-0.007982391864061356,
-0.8779207468032837,
0.18330514430999756,
-0.9301697611808777,
-0.6736060976982117,
0.125504270195961,
-0.037066634744405746,
-0.05609365552663803,
0.4185507297515869,
0.40519580245018005,
0.39168524742126465,
-0.5962672233581543,
0.3041541874408722,
-0.28507399559020996,
-0.5053372979164124,
0.4248257279396057,
-0.38377735018730164,
0.6640629172325134,
0.06067638844251633,
-0.42727789282798767,
0.4125487208366394,
-0.6909988522529602,
0.19875620305538177,
-0.17629767954349518,
-0.10602977126836777,
-0.3291360139846802,
-0.13428877294063568,
-0.30582988262176514,
0.21641941368579865,
0.29625949263572693,
-0.37599214911460876,
0.04502482712268829,
-0.8724823594093323,
0.7363796234130859,
1.0067707300186157,
0.20274588465690613,
0.3966720402240753,
-0.08146729320287704,
0.5020301938056946,
0.24884144961833954,
0.22246046364307404,
-0.09969383478164673,
-0.3426820933818817,
-0.9017946124076843,
-0.45330148935317993,
0.14388947188854218,
0.05550604686141014,
-0.6712892055511475,
0.4214411973953247,
-0.3150826692581177,
-0.08722810447216034,
-0.5057209134101868,
0.15535280108451843,
0.4084149897098541,
0.5391837358474731,
0.24562470614910126,
-0.22157104313373566,
-0.5589779615402222,
-0.7497631907463074,
-0.4936564862728119,
-0.17860358953475952,
0.21916557848453522,
0.3870562016963959,
0.24760699272155762,
-0.18941284716129303,
0.9492515325546265,
-0.5731527209281921,
-0.09500917047262192,
-0.39352723956108093,
-0.11931860446929932,
0.24581055343151093,
0.29304879903793335,
0.19959795475006104,
-0.36452504992485046,
-0.0783517137169838,
0.12011822313070297,
-0.35185208916664124,
-0.2041831612586975,
-0.17666801810264587,
-0.59749436378479,
0.240724116563797,
0.8198418617248535,
-0.842341423034668,
0.3823881447315216,
0.05037276819348335,
-0.3434596061706543,
0.5358507037162781,
-0.06657327711582184,
-0.25060611963272095,
-0.7139434218406677,
0.045107483863830566,
-0.24598319828510284,
-0.2207491397857666,
-0.4775756001472473,
0.43923044204711914,
0.05671422556042671,
0.12790100276470184,
-0.5771095752716064,
0.7639638781547546,
-0.5118625164031982,
-0.10254938155412674,
-0.40424561500549316,
0.4505159556865692,
0.20337240397930145,
0.7760234475135803,
-0.23279914259910583,
0.7432066202163696,
0.6265273690223694,
-0.7333739995956421,
0.23036135733127594,
-0.06608904898166656,
-0.2969233989715576,
0.3070440888404846,
-0.4930056631565094,
0.3742210268974304,
-0.1508723944425583,
0.21188566088676453,
-0.9230222702026367,
0.008051636628806591,
0.07776184380054474,
-0.2970203757286072,
0.11902777850627899,
-0.008105545304715633,
-0.7262336015701294,
-0.3449034094810486,
-0.44469282031059265,
0.6228394508361816,
0.12414616346359253,
-0.6644925475120544,
0.8287618160247803,
0.3068001866340637,
0.1809183806180954,
-0.47359126806259155,
-0.5415877103805542,
0.09391634166240692,
-0.19560103118419647,
-0.504021942615509,
0.48217588663101196,
0.14669378101825714,
-0.24121332168579102,
-0.014040535315871239,
-0.19977030158042908,
0.2501586675643921,
0.085408054292202,
0.02198117785155773,
0.25255683064460754,
-0.17476443946361542,
0.4511347711086273,
0.13901358842849731,
-0.041869018226861954,
0.3416883945465088,
-0.7669193744659424,
0.8257569074630737,
0.05930166319012642,
-0.45993778109550476,
-0.3797961473464966,
0.004060741048306227,
0.808780312538147,
-0.41081979870796204,
0.6220372319221497,
0.4859279692173004,
-0.40316465497016907,
-0.4488431513309479,
-0.5892512202262878,
-0.26683759689331055,
-0.5176504254341125,
0.39244744181632996,
-0.4639182388782501,
-1.0558675527572632,
0.6001222133636475,
-0.19992172718048096,
-0.09954773634672165,
0.32526957988739014,
0.7856245636940002,
0.2692280113697052,
0.910681426525116,
0.4886831045150757,
-0.1545781046152115,
0.4923011064529419,
-0.25081104040145874,
0.45623505115509033,
-1.3456405401229858,
-0.3095236122608185,
-0.11917415261268616,
-0.33148813247680664,
-0.44046327471733093,
-0.9271126985549927,
0.23917964100837708,
-0.01745612733066082,
-0.3176787495613098,
0.025645500048995018,
-0.4249148964881897,
0.5885835289955139,
0.2618051767349243,
0.27530795335769653,
0.32978174090385437,
-0.020105035975575447,
-0.48931583762168884,
0.3106520175933838,
-0.6949971914291382,
-0.4339645504951477,
1.003077507019043,
0.3624163568019867,
0.685027003288269,
-0.07479013502597809,
0.5183975100517273,
0.21461942791938782,
0.24117189645767212,
-0.7479298114776611,
0.6967127919197083,
-0.09445800632238388,
-0.34377431869506836,
-0.35171258449554443,
-0.3691900074481964,
-0.7025699615478516,
0.25262150168418884,
0.23246979713439941,
-0.9213575124740601,
-0.09523816406726837,
0.06136797368526459,
-0.23554767668247223,
0.42412006855010986,
-0.7050434947013855,
0.4883779287338257,
-0.20876576006412506,
-0.7255503535270691,
-0.4459276795387268,
-0.5354615449905396,
0.35686421394348145,
-0.021016256883740425,
0.19005036354064941,
-0.09956655651330948,
-0.17633703351020813,
0.5486029386520386,
-0.4652148187160492,
1.062505841255188,
-0.08802180737257004,
-0.3448847830295563,
0.6016761064529419,
-0.12645255029201508,
0.8661734461784363,
0.1627475917339325,
-0.31882819533348083,
-0.06958518177270889,
-0.4147612750530243,
-0.38191142678260803,
-0.7195559740066528,
0.8397632241249084,
-0.5221357941627502,
-0.8770195245742798,
0.09032729268074036,
-0.7224969863891602,
-0.45068544149398804,
0.19843605160713196,
-0.24923750758171082,
0.31557902693748474,
0.13668853044509888,
0.09753295034170151,
0.5215575098991394,
0.10760533809661865,
0.3216743469238281,
0.1961006075143814,
-0.06890363246202469,
-0.38517260551452637,
0.5971378684043884,
-0.13349603116512299,
0.4877864122390747,
0.6432897448539734,
0.17860190570354462,
-0.4884568750858307,
-0.4999309778213501,
-0.28692981600761414,
0.16906540095806122,
-0.9771882891654968,
-0.3791423738002777,
-0.7793003916740417,
-0.2548249363899231,
-0.39662283658981323,
0.007395684719085693,
-0.14204996824264526,
-0.6288001537322998,
-0.42396262288093567,
-0.3941282331943512,
0.4998621344566345,
0.2686763107776642,
0.36261823773384094,
0.11721038818359375,
-0.4218229651451111,
0.25333788990974426,
0.11866957694292068,
0.6141757369041443,
0.6616112589836121,
-0.590502917766571,
-0.3482089340686798,
-0.008765527978539467,
-0.2583710849285126,
-0.22061187028884888,
0.1403050571680069,
-0.07856538891792297,
0.685388445854187,
0.3097102642059326,
0.10735205560922623,
1.1209975481033325,
-0.37325969338417053,
0.5572414994239807,
0.14596036076545715,
-1.1366628408432007,
0.40981733798980713,
-0.08306474983692169,
0.35014575719833374,
0.29501038789749146,
-0.43608149886131287,
-0.11040954291820526,
-0.6820011138916016,
-0.5517833828926086,
-0.9660865068435669,
0.6204301714897156,
0.3920673131942749,
0.24353089928627014,
-0.22087039053440094,
0.7281414866447449,
-0.038273315876722336,
0.13960577547550201,
-0.3322322964668274,
-0.07397425919771194,
0.240167036652565,
-0.26457881927490234,
0.18732595443725586,
-0.2086738795042038,
-0.01911040209233761,
-0.5247478485107422,
0.53642338514328,
-0.3886362910270691,
0.29462724924087524,
0.244878888130188,
-0.14094175398349762,
-0.264197438955307,
0.14531272649765015,
0.6701585650444031,
0.7401421666145325,
0.144220232963562,
0.4259990453720093,
0.41904008388519287,
-0.43360042572021484,
-0.12592361867427826,
-0.23665395379066467,
0.040517646819353104,
-0.3566226661205292,
0.4784916937351227,
0.9818627238273621,
0.4583313763141632,
-0.8022836446762085,
0.25502514839172363,
0.05360059812664986,
-0.09841521084308624,
-0.11963889002799988,
0.2758466303348541,
0.30705803632736206,
0.45729634165763855,
0.3111516833305359,
-0.012900014407932758,
0.10694476962089539,
-0.4807121157646179,
0.1824294477701187,
0.6739205718040466,
-0.30702969431877136,
-0.15352600812911987,
0.606697678565979,
0.2233451008796692,
-0.3855777382850647,
0.2984728217124939,
0.1253066211938858,
-0.6336146593093872,
0.779956042766571,
0.8191086649894714,
0.9832941293716431,
0.39984723925590515,
-0.08797179162502289,
0.15549145638942719,
0.26581326127052307,
0.1859796941280365,
0.19996467232704163,
-0.30688905715942383,
-0.7117748856544495,
-0.7045349478721619,
-0.6340711116790771,
-0.31090208888053894,
0.06329402327537537,
-0.49514836072921753,
0.3236132860183716,
-0.5392075181007385,
-0.35895469784736633,
0.01790620945394039,
-0.06837676465511322,
-0.7270684242248535,
0.15082509815692902,
0.22753378748893738,
0.8675975203514099,
-0.22369049489498138,
0.7306419014930725,
0.6272194981575012,
0.01088669802993536,
-0.5882093906402588,
0.21583260595798492,
-0.41666772961616516,
-0.9669257402420044,
0.6202650666236877,
0.3407447040081024,
-0.658446192741394,
0.12812770903110504,
-0.477627694606781,
-1.0077166557312012,
0.9225861430168152,
0.5747040510177612,
-0.694244384765625,
0.07212118059396744,
0.29839345812797546,
0.7547165155410767,
-0.6582570672035217,
0.1354207992553711,
0.7138691544532776,
0.23653201758861542,
0.14136458933353424,
-0.6082546710968018,
0.261581689119339,
-0.12340473383665085,
0.055128395557403564,
0.38243207335472107,
-0.7273364067077637,
0.5973615646362305,
-0.507396936416626,
-0.13117516040802002,
-0.16569063067436218,
0.5782521963119507,
0.606023907661438,
0.3051406145095825,
0.5093304514884949,
0.5517626404762268,
0.9082831740379333,
0.21028952300548553,
0.962608277797699,
-0.5860624313354492,
0.27485498785972595,
1.1188067197799683,
-0.4129039943218231,
0.6607247591018677,
0.9210120439529419,
-0.033003780990839005,
0.4952507019042969,
0.3842909038066864,
0.35212627053260803,
0.3717012107372284,
0.6048126220703125,
-0.28783372044563293,
-0.4058418273925781,
-0.306662917137146,
0.06663907319307327,
0.248749241232872,
0.47911912202835083,
-0.5173769593238831,
0.07235925644636154,
-0.1084517240524292,
-0.31529682874679565,
-0.14736339449882507,
-0.5273613929748535,
0.9013705253601074,
0.1460372656583786,
-0.736652135848999,
0.5672422647476196,
0.038654226809740067,
0.353686660528183,
-0.04629827290773392,
-0.02948286011815071,
0.03533710911870003,
0.4279908835887909,
-0.06027940288186073,
-0.737490177154541,
0.20843186974525452,
0.06747778505086899,
-0.1793200671672821,
-0.11258503049612045,
0.8634718656539917,
-0.19191113114356995,
-0.7000600695610046,
0.5446602702140808,
0.4788195490837097,
-0.042467840015888214,
0.024451103061437607,
-0.4498308598995209,
0.16172321140766144,
-0.08919194340705872,
-0.27704954147338867,
0.23173099756240845,
0.8345062136650085,
-0.36353811621665955,
0.7001517415046692,
0.9180664420127869,
0.016626283526420593,
0.13312606513500214,
0.6636888384819031,
1.3348413705825806,
-0.675070583820343,
-0.6460451483726501,
-1.2610405683517456,
0.39590033888816833,
-0.21697358787059784,
-0.2520008385181427,
0.3002137839794159,
0.6194206476211548,
0.7402161359786987,
0.05501605197787285,
0.5893303155899048,
0.38518643379211426,
0.2548868954181671,
-0.6930128931999207,
0.36849233508110046,
-0.45063579082489014,
0.605090320110321,
-0.1899833232164383,
-0.7116898894309998,
-0.4310765266418457,
0.3495499789714813,
-0.40824639797210693,
-0.1464284062385559,
0.772736132144928,
0.6081186532974243,
0.016565296798944473,
0.06323366612195969,
0.19576296210289001,
0.1845586746931076,
0.5112087726593018,
0.6671328544616699,
0.7022543549537659,
-0.09870781004428864,
0.38464319705963135,
-0.12862080335617065,
-0.004148309584707022,
-0.22225113213062286,
-0.9472771286964417,
-1.218948483467102,
-0.18473276495933533,
-0.22333350777626038,
-0.03423921391367912,
0.0739043802022934,
0.9931459426879883,
0.5593301057815552,
-0.6644802093505859,
0.07181214541196823,
-0.57780522108078,
0.41769370436668396,
-0.19034093618392944,
-0.2811354696750641,
0.4998498260974884,
-0.68304044008255,
-0.48412710428237915,
0.12949222326278687,
0.6078832745552063,
-0.184112086892128,
-0.23606079816818237,
0.01232331432402134,
-0.019888337701559067,
0.4666884243488312,
1.040682077407837,
-0.38655632734298706,
-1.0877020359039307,
-0.3944646716117859,
0.14363734424114227,
0.005741768516600132,
0.07905148714780807,
1.168790340423584,
-0.8719903230667114,
0.3959735631942749,
0.4223637282848358,
0.699367344379425,
0.6430694460868835,
0.10874035209417343,
0.4840824007987976,
-0.8858346343040466,
0.23834769427776337,
0.30425769090652466,
0.36021938920021057,
0.1751335859298706,
-0.7362687587738037,
0.4035305380821228,
0.001858329982496798,
-0.20269319415092468,
-1.0888726711273193,
0.2947307229042053,
-0.9117926359176636,
-0.13925158977508545,
1.1101938486099243,
-0.0305497944355011,
-0.41514167189598083,
-0.19846674799919128,
-0.2750356197357178,
0.3353655934333801,
-0.3796141743659973,
0.8238705992698669,
0.7211600542068481,
-0.3188806474208832,
-0.2990770637989044,
-0.18263597786426544,
0.30663496255874634,
0.5142913460731506,
-0.8911899924278259,
0.6580696702003479,
0.025913283228874207,
0.08272174000740051,
0.0011848517460748553,
0.4890975058078766,
-0.35449352860450745,
0.18636542558670044,
-0.36558809876441956,
-0.2240752875804901,
-0.1459978073835373,
-0.2912638783454895,
-0.06654275953769684,
0.26253411173820496,
0.0844302847981453,
0.023752408102154732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14919v1
|
Hierarchical Skip Decoding for Efficient Autoregressive Text Generation
| 2024-03-22T02:44:05 | 2024-03-22T02:44:05 |
Yunqi Zhu, Xuebing Yang, Yuanyuan Wu, Wensheng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Autoregressive decoding strategy is a commonly used method for text
generation tasks with pre-trained language models, while early-exiting is an
effective approach to speedup the inference stage. In this work, we propose a
novel decoding strategy named Hierarchical Skip Decoding (HSD) for efficient
autoregressive text generation. Different from existing methods that require
additional trainable components, HSD is a plug-and-play method applicable to
autoregressive text generation models, it adaptively skips decoding layers in a
hierarchical manner based on the current sequence length, thereby reducing
computational workload and allocating computation resources. Comprehensive
experiments on five text generation datasets with pre-trained language models
demonstrate HSD's advantages in balancing efficiency and text quality. With
almost half of the layers skipped, HSD can sustain 90% of the text quality
compared to vanilla autoregressive decoding, outperforming the competitive
approaches.
|
[
-0.10760354995727539,
-0.8305906057357788,
0.17934593558311462,
0.5942289233207703,
-0.41808149218559265,
0.4161538779735565,
0.2351956069469452,
-0.17289316654205322,
-0.3756374418735504,
0.2225811928510666,
-0.7053187489509583,
-0.4328136444091797,
-0.5442681908607483,
-0.010870197787880898,
-0.28007981181144714,
0.9371230006217957,
0.0239443127065897,
-0.33934155106544495,
-0.06272698938846588,
0.3569692075252533,
-0.32741978764533997,
-0.501741349697113,
-0.7482424974441528,
-0.2626889646053314,
0.37433239817619324,
0.4419706165790558,
0.8289990425109863,
1.4873981475830078,
0.3940316438674927,
0.19171200692653656,
-0.23757344484329224,
0.25797316431999207,
-0.3956732749938965,
0.26805582642555237,
0.05823289230465889,
0.2613435983657837,
-0.7639711499214172,
-0.3874371647834778,
0.5789585709571838,
0.6407726407051086,
-0.37564975023269653,
-0.10001984983682632,
0.38249149918556213,
0.7614322304725647,
-0.9030428528785706,
0.24733299016952515,
-0.3027394413948059,
0.24848531186580658,
-0.3018178343772888,
-0.765907883644104,
-0.5392354726791382,
-0.3898463845252991,
-0.14770367741584778,
-0.42519909143447876,
0.1554308533668518,
-0.2335628718137741,
0.5737431645393372,
0.33087053894996643,
-0.3996821939945221,
-0.18139277398586273,
-0.8967409133911133,
0.5390556454658508,
-0.7904288172721863,
0.43962395191192627,
0.3615480363368988,
-0.11761470139026642,
-0.023553291335701942,
-0.42068302631378174,
-0.3811033070087433,
0.22434070706367493,
-0.029253041371703148,
0.17699700593948364,
-0.2544853091239929,
0.05794678255915642,
0.13832996785640717,
0.5281096696853638,
-0.7857080698013306,
0.24449481070041656,
0.2822166085243225,
-0.03905482217669487,
0.41331636905670166,
0.2823166251182556,
0.12240757048130035,
-0.4181478023529053,
-0.14374084770679474,
-0.2988310754299164,
-0.38341453671455383,
0.03103376179933548,
0.49576428532600403,
0.23471814393997192,
0.004771731793880463,
0.09023281186819077,
-0.3198917806148529,
0.630269467830658,
0.3830189108848572,
-0.2497878521680832,
0.2878032326698303,
-0.49229609966278076,
-0.28984400629997253,
-0.05308215692639351,
0.7941390872001648,
-0.10905244201421738,
0.05029619112610817,
-0.12093670666217804,
-0.25918108224868774,
-0.11834661662578583,
0.13486622273921967,
-0.7730180025100708,
-0.4270800054073334,
-0.02110951766371727,
-0.9051520824432373,
-0.5130102634429932,
-0.6083819270133972,
-0.7718582153320312,
0.2650452256202698,
0.231668159365654,
0.2636023163795471,
-0.8365795016288757,
-0.1362261027097702,
0.1651955544948578,
0.00987939815968275,
-0.03059593215584755,
0.17767177522182465,
-1.1451184749603271,
0.44999387860298157,
0.29966264963150024,
0.8270978331565857,
-0.2834901511669159,
-0.4489441514015198,
-0.7527260184288025,
0.22849178314208984,
-0.5267238020896912,
0.6588789820671082,
-0.24903661012649536,
-0.5770423412322998,
-0.038672272115945816,
-0.3109723925590515,
-0.04051562026143074,
-0.32024434208869934,
0.5505774617195129,
-0.7353660464286804,
0.15940909087657928,
0.1683850884437561,
-0.4633839726448059,
0.10156963765621185,
-0.07190919667482376,
-0.6267359256744385,
1.1073932647705078,
0.009604710154235363,
-1.0255118608474731,
0.4739639461040497,
-0.359759122133255,
-1.0455007553100586,
0.21237468719482422,
0.15725670754909515,
-0.5158410668373108,
-0.06311239302158356,
0.7021195292472839,
0.42778119444847107,
-0.05282828211784363,
0.08110597729682922,
0.10133492946624756,
-0.12624038755893707,
-0.5276909470558167,
-0.6687077879905701,
0.7966971397399902,
0.51333087682724,
-0.47301799058914185,
-0.3982624411582947,
-0.8543165922164917,
0.042204778641462326,
0.11629149317741394,
-0.6235761046409607,
-0.5613501071929932,
0.3382870554924011,
0.1728801727294922,
0.2237144559621811,
0.15683957934379578,
-0.17285653948783875,
0.10787741094827652,
-0.1813100129365921,
-0.040551915764808655,
0.7400872111320496,
0.2734684646129608,
0.5796118974685669,
-0.27309226989746094,
0.6387280821800232,
0.32390904426574707,
0.032373733818531036,
-0.8685674071311951,
-0.15533918142318726,
-0.5628409385681152,
-0.248789444565773,
0.45052266120910645,
0.7051538228988647,
-1.021167516708374,
0.9138127565383911,
-0.02169726975262165,
-0.27963244915008545,
-0.46385085582733154,
0.060900866985321045,
0.5825875997543335,
0.6347551345825195,
0.5837958455085754,
-0.21091163158416748,
-0.36521247029304504,
-0.5844296813011169,
-0.4249778687953949,
-0.3217449486255646,
0.09664174914360046,
0.005609442479908466,
0.4494684338569641,
-0.3240540325641632,
0.934729278087616,
-0.5344523787498474,
-0.06905272603034973,
-0.2540748417377472,
0.489238440990448,
-0.08321268856525421,
0.899795413017273,
0.32934799790382385,
-0.4379369020462036,
-0.429287850856781,
-0.007023122627288103,
-0.6230773329734802,
-0.13231542706489563,
-0.5770003199577332,
-0.3666413426399231,
0.3810094892978668,
0.48488500714302063,
-0.49165356159210205,
0.43644198775291443,
0.4061829447746277,
-0.3544458746910095,
0.47257286310195923,
-0.5000844597816467,
0.3072027564048767,
-0.9394373893737793,
-0.017544753849506378,
-0.18782223761081696,
-0.41657987236976624,
-0.4862871766090393,
0.005088030360639095,
0.2881106734275818,
0.19516074657440186,
-0.09733261168003082,
0.1558816283941269,
-0.8537275195121765,
-0.04803952947258949,
-0.30669742822647095,
-0.310772180557251,
0.006839662324637175,
0.3433011472225189,
0.2281358689069748,
0.6236648559570312,
0.6226574778556824,
-0.8577772974967957,
-0.18458376824855804,
0.1788461059331894,
-0.11502386629581451,
0.22520765662193298,
-0.4697185754776001,
0.007930494844913483,
-0.35109400749206543,
0.4344561994075775,
-0.7843911051750183,
0.03134436905384064,
-0.08139833062887192,
-0.4634508788585663,
0.2942869961261749,
-0.0813899114727974,
-0.6538535356521606,
-0.44388237595558167,
0.08037439733743668,
0.7263036966323853,
0.9936633110046387,
-0.8265551924705505,
0.3238683342933655,
0.26612532138824463,
-0.4042741358280182,
-0.5228903889656067,
-0.8180462121963501,
0.13800965249538422,
0.001181171741336584,
-0.45582664012908936,
0.4394887089729309,
-0.2576252818107605,
0.35960492491722107,
-0.01821434684097767,
0.05143344774842262,
-0.15814393758773804,
-0.0677417442202568,
-0.2990648150444031,
0.06605184078216553,
-0.4108123481273651,
-0.23337046802043915,
0.4820197522640228,
-0.22015205025672913,
0.0115182651206851,
-0.527215301990509,
0.6019489169120789,
0.3834875524044037,
-0.06097107380628586,
-0.6680666208267212,
0.6633464097976685,
0.453528493642807,
-0.15940585732460022,
0.6406201720237732,
0.41713470220565796,
-0.42576465010643005,
-0.405832439661026,
-0.1987706869840622,
0.0231657475233078,
-0.4691524803638458,
0.22962476313114166,
-0.25489044189453125,
-0.48781609535217285,
0.35611146688461304,
0.16103839874267578,
0.28464359045028687,
0.45880547165870667,
0.46200695633888245,
-0.13804109394550323,
1.226196527481079,
0.7356749773025513,
-0.08738590031862259,
0.3630750775337219,
-0.09173666685819626,
0.04888181388378143,
-0.42919737100601196,
-0.12373963743448257,
-0.6541152596473694,
0.09951301664113998,
-0.4024299383163452,
-0.5802690982818604,
-0.02785291150212288,
0.1795143485069275,
-0.1284286230802536,
0.2375129908323288,
-0.30772316455841064,
0.4833025634288788,
0.3398631513118744,
-0.09212286025285721,
0.5749315619468689,
0.28918513655662537,
-0.07235393673181534,
-0.1803952306509018,
-1.1084951162338257,
-0.08774368464946747,
0.48409026861190796,
0.53394615650177,
0.9460064172744751,
-0.14729788899421692,
0.8987880945205688,
0.6354001760482788,
-0.20227371156215668,
-0.6251970529556274,
0.3673780858516693,
-0.41458144783973694,
-0.018202660605311394,
-0.21746081113815308,
-0.9059885740280151,
-0.7984732985496521,
0.2867208421230316,
-0.02147902175784111,
-0.25161996483802795,
0.4909924566745758,
0.42657676339149475,
-0.3961753249168396,
0.4555533826351166,
-0.33872392773628235,
0.6964440941810608,
0.10085161030292511,
-0.21121852099895477,
-0.06366875022649765,
-0.5068119168281555,
0.40755027532577515,
-0.07842643558979034,
0.31626227498054504,
0.46070292592048645,
0.0685102567076683,
0.8040129542350769,
-0.42133864760398865,
0.3980717062950134,
-0.23474010825157166,
-0.27345800399780273,
0.11386440694332123,
0.27265045046806335,
0.6051992774009705,
-0.21229350566864014,
0.09351707994937897,
-0.25617673993110657,
-0.4671020805835724,
-0.6131405234336853,
-0.2851787209510803,
0.6009383201599121,
-0.5894510746002197,
-0.03058667853474617,
-0.5445896983146667,
-0.6014900803565979,
-0.2392912656068802,
0.4257473349571228,
0.7538583874702454,
0.6245744228363037,
-0.39081549644470215,
-0.03263578936457634,
0.8441889882087708,
-0.28096213936805725,
1.0980907678604126,
0.2409861534833908,
0.19935636222362518,
-0.3829040229320526,
0.7210562229156494,
0.03332652524113655,
0.35590019822120667,
0.46878793835639954,
-0.04915868863463402,
-0.465501606464386,
-0.6764291524887085,
-0.6158676147460938,
-0.0668097510933876,
-0.5879381895065308,
-0.3514867424964905,
-1.197845220565796,
-0.49568402767181396,
-0.5584682822227478,
-0.3353698253631592,
-0.426097571849823,
-0.2807003855705261,
-0.44024235010147095,
-0.0037229061126708984,
0.104619599878788,
0.572873592376709,
-0.19960756599903107,
0.5522103905677795,
-1.049536108970642,
0.6811537146568298,
0.17632976174354553,
0.2041982114315033,
0.4241207540035248,
-0.6124184727668762,
-0.5004841685295105,
-0.28733664751052856,
-0.2170076221227646,
-0.7754897475242615,
0.7549813985824585,
0.24561698734760284,
0.47972235083580017,
0.3530670404434204,
0.25792616605758667,
0.9726736545562744,
-0.8105760812759399,
0.46994033455848694,
0.23215442895889282,
-1.0359666347503662,
0.5197869539260864,
-0.5667084455490112,
0.8871450424194336,
0.3700827360153198,
0.48128440976142883,
-0.3375430703163147,
-0.47602248191833496,
-0.6293193697929382,
-1.0361946821212769,
0.7751351594924927,
0.3679114282131195,
-0.0452289953827858,
-0.21315105259418488,
0.2645832896232605,
0.245538130402565,
-0.0036884653382003307,
-0.4780194163322449,
-0.1812283843755722,
-0.18260277807712555,
-0.17535556852817535,
-0.0008027238654904068,
-0.28790155053138733,
0.4036071300506592,
-0.08418478816747665,
0.6217459440231323,
0.03823511675000191,
0.3141214847564697,
0.2010793387889862,
-0.36762693524360657,
-0.293650358915329,
0.1643388271331787,
0.0825500637292862,
0.2997496724128723,
-0.21818695962429047,
-0.010896599851548672,
-0.1424955129623413,
-0.7130107283592224,
0.39531365036964417,
0.023851273581385612,
-0.4190070331096649,
0.19216759502887726,
0.4305884540081024,
0.7559501528739929,
-0.012318062596023083,
-0.1379033625125885,
0.3052026033401489,
-0.12190204858779907,
-0.34466689825057983,
0.11531075835227966,
-0.044950198382139206,
-0.14680638909339905,
-0.023778896778821945,
0.7586640119552612,
0.35004720091819763,
0.3941246271133423,
-0.3943233788013458,
0.5399348735809326,
-0.0009061024757102132,
-0.12515422701835632,
-0.02116224728524685,
0.6921612620353699,
0.2753491997718811,
-0.3042418360710144,
0.5888317823410034,
-0.19141750037670135,
-0.23371875286102295,
0.5871919393539429,
0.7750750184059143,
1.0482761859893799,
-0.4557732045650482,
0.334286630153656,
0.3191671669483185,
0.4306124448776245,
-0.24865314364433289,
0.08328193426132202,
-0.23828332126140594,
-0.4752776026725769,
-0.7325509190559387,
-0.8051922917366028,
-0.19065502285957336,
0.16243720054626465,
-0.8979786038398743,
-0.18044306337833405,
-0.4079940617084503,
0.08867019414901733,
-0.37485793232917786,
-0.23640501499176025,
-0.3622491955757141,
0.538827657699585,
0.09969361871480942,
1.1060339212417603,
-0.6683112978935242,
0.897262692451477,
0.2521888315677643,
0.19668464362621307,
-0.4043726623058319,
0.658859133720398,
-0.08044810593128204,
-0.23563367128372192,
0.6044522523880005,
-0.12362627685070038,
-0.44813913106918335,
0.36369788646698,
-0.14901350438594818,
-0.8044649958610535,
0.7280575633049011,
-0.11220052093267441,
-0.3110213279724121,
-0.464019238948822,
-0.32677289843559265,
0.4427216053009033,
-0.6880132555961609,
0.24378454685211182,
0.8595120906829834,
0.2256176769733429,
0.11129500716924667,
-0.5052396059036255,
0.027865741401910782,
-0.486253559589386,
0.4336981475353241,
0.054292771965265274,
-0.2949013113975525,
0.8880007863044739,
-0.24686682224273682,
-0.40115097165107727,
0.33434972167015076,
1.0304229259490967,
0.15533965826034546,
0.11519456654787064,
0.6636962294578552,
0.4035511612892151,
0.38907280564308167,
0.18543635308742523,
1.008808970451355,
-0.267488569021225,
0.34838399291038513,
0.8958167433738708,
-0.01346530020236969,
0.8483651280403137,
-0.0018667016411200166,
0.23666122555732727,
0.6927489638328552,
0.7791063785552979,
0.3597940504550934,
0.9827429056167603,
-0.16187405586242676,
-0.14694719016551971,
-0.3549913763999939,
0.38660547137260437,
-0.4676111042499542,
0.3971760869026184,
0.26519542932510376,
-0.23349563777446747,
-0.45514044165611267,
0.13591347634792328,
0.09984325617551804,
0.19081299006938934,
-0.20457440614700317,
0.7822131514549255,
-0.46250540018081665,
-0.7316430807113647,
0.7954009175300598,
0.13992410898208618,
0.8330140113830566,
-0.49784591794013977,
0.01838081330060959,
-0.526870846748352,
0.2649058699607849,
-0.17618730664253235,
-0.5808914303779602,
0.19073796272277832,
0.0778483897447586,
-0.47360843420028687,
-0.8067024350166321,
0.550814688205719,
-0.5614567995071411,
-0.292785108089447,
0.3349739909172058,
0.5946654677391052,
-0.20279277861118317,
0.25031694769859314,
-0.6755984425544739,
-0.21263374388217926,
-0.10220448672771454,
-0.38683074712753296,
0.29409918189048767,
0.7251162528991699,
0.21220621466636658,
0.3951442241668701,
0.7772563099861145,
0.157073974609375,
0.09165825694799423,
0.019021231681108475,
0.8198782801628113,
-0.9491924047470093,
-1.2445629835128784,
-0.7463563680648804,
0.5038967728614807,
0.030375029891729355,
-0.2962658405303955,
0.8565032482147217,
0.5375365614891052,
0.6043930649757385,
-0.12616263329982758,
0.8378746509552002,
0.059323422610759735,
0.5324535965919495,
-0.839651882648468,
0.7678516507148743,
-0.4521314799785614,
0.25687259435653687,
-0.7032124400138855,
-0.8869677186012268,
-0.24629423022270203,
0.7268924117088318,
0.2546657621860504,
0.30273959040641785,
0.917208194732666,
0.3762333393096924,
-0.19416582584381104,
-0.0556291900575161,
0.18877117335796356,
0.3276720643043518,
0.22430752217769623,
0.5112147927284241,
0.7509474158287048,
-0.5673742294311523,
0.4443780779838562,
-0.3050365447998047,
-0.5949558019638062,
-0.19339622557163239,
-0.9854041934013367,
-0.7074558138847351,
-0.422044575214386,
-0.3420970141887665,
-0.3730796277523041,
0.2010478973388672,
0.41582873463630676,
0.9120382070541382,
-0.35444149374961853,
-0.42861586809158325,
-0.38470369577407837,
-0.07807744294404984,
-0.39884740114212036,
-0.30577352643013,
0.3293684422969818,
-0.6822684407234192,
-0.6468961238861084,
0.440694123506546,
0.407793253660202,
0.11259700357913971,
-0.1364835649728775,
-0.17183832824230194,
-0.31201621890068054,
0.30068737268447876,
0.7381579279899597,
0.38693967461586,
-0.08632971346378326,
0.2167717069387436,
0.05003759264945984,
-0.41517117619514465,
0.09267957508563995,
0.997434139251709,
-0.9516486525535583,
-0.02723849005997181,
0.7990784049034119,
0.6846861839294434,
0.573921799659729,
0.17877823114395142,
0.6696347594261169,
-0.695551872253418,
0.2218787521123886,
0.39000096917152405,
-0.03973574936389923,
0.2911924719810486,
-0.597548246383667,
0.04261178523302078,
0.2794244885444641,
-0.6571099162101746,
-0.6239939332008362,
0.1109418049454689,
-0.6906908750534058,
-0.38112759590148926,
0.9181487560272217,
-0.045361947268247604,
-0.29702502489089966,
-0.3486138880252838,
0.11058398336172104,
0.05927211791276932,
-0.5801613926887512,
0.5608418583869934,
0.37988558411598206,
-0.10903371125459671,
-0.4338383674621582,
-0.2532627582550049,
0.8865960836410522,
0.448951780796051,
-0.9683914184570312,
0.4213526248931885,
0.6903183460235596,
-0.2095988541841507,
-0.02939542941749096,
1.2117360830307007,
-0.24041792750358582,
0.5967052578926086,
0.30418485403060913,
-0.13713078200817108,
0.041469961404800415,
-0.7223659753799438,
-0.43289715051651,
0.14198845624923706,
-0.2966054379940033,
-0.27623051404953003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08654v1
|
Optimal path for Biomedical Text Summarization Using Pointer GPT
| 2024-03-22T02:13:23 | 2024-03-22T02:13:23 |
Hyunkyung Han, Jaesik Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Biomedical text summarization is a critical tool that enables clinicians to
effectively ascertain patient status. Traditionally, text summarization has
been accomplished with transformer models, which are capable of compressing
long documents into brief summaries. However, transformer models are known to
be among the most challenging natural language processing (NLP) tasks.
Specifically, GPT models have a tendency to generate factual errors, lack
context, and oversimplify words. To address these limitations, we replaced the
attention mechanism in the GPT model with a pointer network. This modification
was designed to preserve the core values of the original text during the
summarization process. The effectiveness of the Pointer-GPT model was evaluated
using the ROUGE score. The results demonstrated that Pointer-GPT outperformed
the original GPT model. These findings suggest that pointer networks can be a
valuable addition to EMR systems and can provide clinicians with more accurate
and informative summaries of patient medical records. This research has the
potential to usher in a new paradigm in EMR systems and to revolutionize the
way that clinicians interact with patient medical records.
|
[
0.012873069383203983,
-0.5014112591743469,
0.7769442796707153,
0.11614356935024261,
-0.5645374059677124,
-0.15376271307468414,
0.21418607234954834,
-0.3121003210544586,
0.4829293191432953,
0.31210148334503174,
-0.06829850375652313,
-0.4086332619190216,
-0.7294186353683472,
0.3524056673049927,
-0.4694995880126953,
1.5202070474624634,
0.1821439266204834,
-0.0663842111825943,
-0.07527899742126465,
-0.22968176007270813,
-0.4548361599445343,
-0.7652111053466797,
-0.7978843450546265,
-0.5421338081359863,
0.658729612827301,
0.033427052199840546,
0.7091631293296814,
0.9991810321807861,
1.100955843925476,
0.25000759959220886,
-0.22474808990955353,
-0.22773832082748413,
-0.5557265281677246,
0.2798764705657959,
-0.06336380541324615,
-0.10668198019266129,
-0.8327224850654602,
-0.3317730724811554,
0.7142858505249023,
0.8865600824356079,
0.07189628481864929,
0.11926980316638947,
-0.015579050406813622,
0.964323103427887,
-0.28566592931747437,
0.1360762119293213,
-0.1092548742890358,
0.18593256175518036,
-0.040537428110837936,
-0.6337339878082275,
-0.43712833523750305,
-0.6307902336120605,
0.33939915895462036,
-0.3163931965827942,
0.408443421125412,
-0.180440753698349,
0.5450652241706848,
0.342397540807724,
-0.6028462648391724,
0.1774750053882599,
-0.7508794665336609,
0.265902042388916,
-0.4910990595817566,
0.25592947006225586,
0.0697285532951355,
0.29438015818595886,
0.07252524793148041,
-0.8673331141471863,
-0.02960784174501896,
-0.0093667758628726,
-0.2737494111061096,
0.508876383304596,
-0.37576812505722046,
0.3073574900627136,
0.13089467585086823,
0.14420050382614136,
-0.6851800084114075,
-0.28822341561317444,
-0.5878056287765503,
0.07300261408090591,
0.38644102215766907,
0.4712679386138916,
0.17735615372657776,
-0.25058436393737793,
-0.29235661029815674,
0.03745342046022415,
-0.7736998200416565,
-0.09083200246095657,
-0.10993248224258423,
0.05515038222074509,
0.17917293310165405,
0.7779063582420349,
-0.2617883086204529,
0.5968225598335266,
0.5209401845932007,
-0.15911079943180084,
0.0885901004076004,
-0.43353837728500366,
-0.1772211790084839,
0.40065595507621765,
0.8782163262367249,
0.7615999579429626,
-0.040918029844760895,
-0.26783037185668945,
-0.05556580796837807,
-0.17435258626937866,
0.40839964151382446,
-1.1231558322906494,
-0.40053802728652954,
0.3530276417732239,
-0.7764338254928589,
-0.1327160745859146,
-0.0040231202729046345,
-0.47814562916755676,
-0.27667707204818726,
-0.27220314741134644,
0.28221625089645386,
-0.7051761746406555,
0.007611554581671953,
0.14380380511283875,
-0.3002333641052246,
-0.029940899461507797,
0.4025620222091675,
-0.9076470732688904,
0.17063648998737335,
0.7413375377655029,
1.2798683643341064,
-0.14524313807487488,
-0.07414022088050842,
-0.3679003119468689,
0.5659003257751465,
0.06780622154474258,
0.9454328417778015,
-0.3033226430416107,
-0.905219316482544,
-0.34900107979774475,
-0.04545602947473526,
-0.4410476088523865,
-0.35027143359184265,
0.6045637726783752,
-0.23831869661808014,
-0.029931092634797096,
-0.3434275686740875,
-0.585408091545105,
-0.11282184720039368,
0.18225759267807007,
-0.49058419466018677,
0.5926719307899475,
-0.01479935273528099,
-1.124176263809204,
0.17150889337062836,
-0.7092509865760803,
-0.5395423769950867,
-0.058927975594997406,
-0.10834074765443802,
-0.49113768339157104,
0.1635282039642334,
0.22061406075954437,
0.6875634789466858,
0.0053588273003697395,
0.28965848684310913,
-0.050057943910360336,
-0.4827510118484497,
0.17740176618099213,
-0.02400171011686325,
0.6197585463523865,
-0.12077753990888596,
-0.06182948499917984,
0.23411262035369873,
-0.5848369002342224,
-0.3718723654747009,
0.021828291937708855,
-0.448714017868042,
-0.36122164130210876,
0.16576337814331055,
0.04803673177957535,
0.17499014735221863,
0.008311268873512745,
-0.574467658996582,
0.19823245704174042,
-0.4432310163974762,
0.37097814679145813,
0.6180402040481567,
0.43749332427978516,
0.4209703505039215,
-0.554435133934021,
0.4403661787509918,
-0.122254878282547,
0.3322102427482605,
-0.27613842487335205,
-0.6720083355903625,
-0.48533979058265686,
-0.22891782224178314,
-0.008731097914278507,
0.6155346632003784,
-0.3527173399925232,
0.33144626021385193,
-0.5711860656738281,
-0.3729676306247711,
-0.34229394793510437,
-0.6215320825576782,
0.2313118278980255,
1.019641637802124,
0.7171072959899902,
-0.20098119974136353,
-0.20747163891792297,
-0.9443686604499817,
-0.20227286219596863,
-0.3357822597026825,
-0.3419818580150604,
0.05572858452796936,
0.4061174988746643,
-0.2672962546348572,
1.0745303630828857,
-0.6359031200408936,
-0.3792210519313812,
-0.5464188456535339,
0.004516052547842264,
0.6058670282363892,
0.43042945861816406,
0.33677253127098083,
-0.898520827293396,
-0.6006160378456116,
0.23400679230690002,
-0.6471668481826782,
-0.09137947112321854,
-0.07066241651773453,
0.10339412093162537,
-0.3754994869232178,
0.18702661991119385,
-0.7410862445831299,
0.511932909488678,
0.118853360414505,
-0.4421282708644867,
0.6432303786277771,
-0.5717608332633972,
0.25926193594932556,
-1.0287895202636719,
0.6476038098335266,
-0.008956527337431908,
-0.32858917117118835,
-0.7787044644355774,
-0.32161328196525574,
0.03416764363646507,
-0.24929678440093994,
-0.10213537514209747,
0.5068770051002502,
-0.37475165724754333,
0.17336809635162354,
-0.3716631531715393,
-0.06356281787157059,
0.05652066692709923,
0.14634189009666443,
0.05729370936751366,
0.4747139513492584,
0.18956613540649414,
-0.3534817397594452,
0.26322096586227417,
0.6512007117271423,
0.37174463272094727,
0.6345380544662476,
-1.2219421863555908,
-0.02756264992058277,
-0.5342612862586975,
0.3402130603790283,
-0.7188403606414795,
-0.1213608905673027,
0.3111865520477295,
-0.4856969118118286,
0.459255188703537,
-0.20274142920970917,
-0.05212624371051788,
-0.33767154812812805,
-0.42107197642326355,
0.4005301296710968,
0.5193284749984741,
-0.12381862848997116,
0.5490850210189819,
0.4659276604652405,
-0.48460641503334045,
-0.5696384906768799,
-0.3882032334804535,
0.12775737047195435,
-0.14150376617908478,
-0.48919886350631714,
0.6367290019989014,
0.18268994987010956,
0.08493230491876602,
-0.06458055973052979,
-0.1163308322429657,
-0.028451165184378624,
-0.28884002566337585,
0.42687341570854187,
0.29270267486572266,
-0.08434319496154785,
0.12684282660484314,
0.13731083273887634,
-0.5969653725624084,
0.22639143466949463,
-0.16117407381534576,
0.06488218158483505,
-0.06496721506118774,
-0.30830323696136475,
-0.504189670085907,
0.6335425972938538,
0.5714026689529419,
-0.14354608952999115,
0.6584005355834961,
0.4064970016479492,
-0.2821160554885864,
0.32867738604545593,
-0.32177242636680603,
-0.3550703227519989,
-0.35206103324890137,
0.5504945516586304,
-0.1275280863046646,
-0.8484496474266052,
0.6075472831726074,
0.07724985480308533,
-0.1275811493396759,
0.466374009847641,
0.499663770198822,
0.032289545983076096,
0.9921351671218872,
0.7876198291778564,
-0.19964872300624847,
0.26697584986686707,
-0.13380403816699982,
0.380426287651062,
-1.0012060403823853,
-0.29016467928886414,
-0.5721980929374695,
-0.09423937648534775,
-0.34225907921791077,
-0.3810634911060333,
1.0370689630508423,
-0.05790456756949425,
-0.07869581878185272,
0.15394558012485504,
-0.7750859260559082,
0.3741990923881531,
0.4147169291973114,
0.5155438184738159,
0.5667172074317932,
-0.21702700853347778,
-0.09085807204246521,
0.05327950417995453,
-0.6663592457771301,
-0.5983064770698547,
1.0435705184936523,
0.4465130567550659,
0.5670329332351685,
0.018969569355249405,
0.6651089191436768,
0.05243932455778122,
0.5767150521278381,
-0.8029465079307556,
0.4173086881637573,
-0.17116187512874603,
-0.30584704875946045,
-0.36344513297080994,
-0.2849147319793701,
-0.8103007078170776,
0.360250860452652,
0.027716683223843575,
-0.748530387878418,
0.2258901298046112,
0.42711973190307617,
-0.5112476348876953,
0.261258065700531,
-0.3730000853538513,
0.8929919600486755,
0.20532473921775818,
-0.1495845466852188,
0.031826697289943695,
-1.086663842201233,
0.21956752240657806,
-0.08051478117704391,
-0.32136067748069763,
0.032263778150081635,
-0.0779959112405777,
0.7335230708122253,
-0.610176682472229,
0.7221691608428955,
0.023472705855965614,
0.4296874701976776,
-0.01803753152489662,
-0.09364905208349228,
0.6430140137672424,
0.13365378975868225,
0.018766190856695175,
0.11091084033250809,
0.018915917724370956,
-0.2433142215013504,
-0.3172931671142578,
0.29665467143058777,
-0.40520381927490234,
-0.5454357862472534,
-0.433184951543808,
-0.4320855736732483,
-0.047806158661842346,
0.24331718683242798,
0.5206630229949951,
0.585797131061554,
-0.43511882424354553,
0.10892471671104431,
0.5727864503860474,
-0.11022961884737015,
0.3046501874923706,
0.2758021652698517,
0.10084797441959381,
-0.30312380194664,
0.6992672085762024,
-0.08390507102012634,
0.01297034416347742,
0.941011369228363,
0.3004727065563202,
-0.27962231636047363,
-0.8722156286239624,
-0.30842480063438416,
0.511597216129303,
-0.611777126789093,
-0.22095270454883575,
-1.1511609554290771,
-0.20551449060440063,
-0.40307900309562683,
-0.29352661967277527,
-0.16281841695308685,
-0.48467501997947693,
-0.2252851128578186,
-0.1885191947221756,
0.24670973420143127,
0.710882842540741,
0.011979390867054462,
0.47625452280044556,
-1.2022881507873535,
0.24740493297576904,
0.18025510013103485,
0.030730869621038437,
-0.1938731074333191,
-0.5211890935897827,
-0.3052396774291992,
-0.31233420968055725,
-0.47264739871025085,
-1.239687442779541,
0.5225036144256592,
0.19598913192749023,
0.37238702178001404,
0.5844902396202087,
-0.05618702247738838,
0.370834082365036,
-1.0139719247817993,
0.2803904414176941,
0.3400481939315796,
-0.778199315071106,
0.6683064699172974,
-0.8366687297821045,
0.36213669180870056,
0.4507995545864105,
0.4333241283893585,
-0.8113278150558472,
-0.5155853629112244,
-0.42581069469451904,
-0.8203588724136353,
0.3004001975059509,
0.1120092123746872,
-0.3040163815021515,
-0.19358232617378235,
0.4142973721027374,
-0.08238858729600906,
0.041601650416851044,
-0.5463392734527588,
-0.36411938071250916,
-0.3425721824169159,
-0.3452928066253662,
-0.06644036620855331,
-0.30975040793418884,
-0.01657896302640438,
-0.12002354860305786,
0.486911416053772,
-0.26431119441986084,
0.6080292463302612,
0.5971951484680176,
0.10958852618932724,
-0.03307288885116577,
0.2714417576789856,
0.4327496290206909,
0.893398106098175,
-0.5895805954933167,
-0.026263313367962837,
-0.12377209216356277,
-0.799640953540802,
0.07442755997180939,
0.35588201880455017,
-0.42482995986938477,
0.27675601840019226,
0.2740798592567444,
0.5588095188140869,
0.15566962957382202,
-0.21326524019241333,
0.7507531642913818,
-0.08595849573612213,
-0.04100982844829559,
0.07949650287628174,
-0.16438676416873932,
0.0007927866536192596,
0.1639019101858139,
0.4422948360443115,
0.2518652677536011,
0.669730544090271,
0.09952744096517563,
0.28922826051712036,
0.27327510714530945,
-0.5947012901306152,
-0.5909988284111023,
0.8913424015045166,
0.18687871098518372,
-0.017363905906677246,
0.43620559573173523,
0.4068078398704529,
-0.39405491948127747,
0.5475282073020935,
0.7486581802368164,
0.989713728427887,
-0.4452826678752899,
0.46639925241470337,
0.41150835156440735,
0.3280584514141083,
-0.14092209935188293,
-0.0848303884267807,
0.22598916292190552,
-0.3598020374774933,
-0.5571624636650085,
-0.41182419657707214,
-0.6002852916717529,
-0.43153640627861023,
-0.5751069784164429,
0.03191757574677467,
-0.24692955613136292,
-0.3885675072669983,
0.14753620326519012,
-0.5301052331924438,
-0.2069973200559616,
0.06200624629855156,
-0.42200180888175964,
0.6773560047149658,
-0.698394238948822,
0.786941647529602,
0.7652249932289124,
-0.30159708857536316,
-0.5678209662437439,
-0.2649424374103546,
0.005886537954211235,
-0.4504030644893646,
0.7319086194038391,
0.17942363023757935,
0.08433336764574051,
0.08186681568622589,
0.2035130262374878,
-0.5526654720306396,
1.0600117444992065,
0.20346175134181976,
-0.2707434892654419,
-0.354886531829834,
0.11526298522949219,
0.7227400541305542,
-0.01630932278931141,
0.41103795170783997,
0.3455994725227356,
0.3171740770339966,
0.0007559615769423544,
-0.9432843923568726,
0.26357799768447876,
-0.2654617130756378,
-0.10673678666353226,
0.5947138071060181,
-0.47976112365722656,
0.9749107360839844,
-0.4675038456916809,
-0.14636936783790588,
-0.15621566772460938,
0.34567514061927795,
0.10739877820014954,
0.25511249899864197,
-0.0528014712035656,
0.35935571789741516,
0.5005739331245422,
-0.11878280341625214,
1.2522435188293457,
-0.10086144506931305,
0.44200485944747925,
0.8213232159614563,
-0.25209474563598633,
0.5741297006607056,
0.5451817512512207,
-0.3571212887763977,
0.11954985558986664,
0.3621566891670227,
0.16770456731319427,
0.34218570590019226,
-0.02101805992424488,
-0.4206121265888214,
0.0010232049971818924,
-0.12052701413631439,
-0.626314103603363,
0.14308598637580872,
0.13963954150676727,
-0.582951009273529,
-0.26339465379714966,
-0.13444265723228455,
0.09290685504674911,
-0.21351352334022522,
-0.2518397271633148,
0.7790972590446472,
0.09876327961683273,
-0.3548506498336792,
0.1057039424777031,
-0.0697123110294342,
0.22943605482578278,
-0.5398714542388916,
-0.09956514090299606,
-0.4201306998729706,
0.4177536964416504,
-0.1133335754275322,
-0.44684094190597534,
0.3724484443664551,
-0.14016109704971313,
-0.5952335000038147,
-0.20466925203800201,
0.8439897894859314,
-0.2717569172382355,
-0.48184236884117126,
0.14560618996620178,
0.5119044184684753,
0.09698179364204407,
-0.19656576216220856,
-0.5605576038360596,
-0.450358122587204,
-0.11045017093420029,
-0.3462335765361786,
0.3607039153575897,
0.42768052220344543,
0.1560511291027069,
0.7298225164413452,
0.6175490021705627,
0.41455063223838806,
-0.2625163495540619,
-0.1551002562046051,
0.9601233601570129,
-0.80544513463974,
-0.8648224472999573,
-1.0535074472427368,
0.5002817511558533,
-0.2114720642566681,
-0.25814247131347656,
0.6536374092102051,
0.6796771883964539,
0.17463037371635437,
-0.18348857760429382,
0.678826630115509,
0.13749101758003235,
0.8883195519447327,
-0.3351529836654663,
0.8730050325393677,
-0.09771905094385147,
-0.017934707924723625,
-0.4349174201488495,
-0.8415764570236206,
-0.6570936441421509,
0.5937010049819946,
-0.28070807456970215,
-0.11786428838968277,
1.0213139057159424,
0.46559807658195496,
-0.06946161389350891,
-0.020667895674705505,
0.2734840512275696,
0.20854489505290985,
0.43065008521080017,
0.818217396736145,
0.46478527784347534,
-0.4805603623390198,
0.3691488206386566,
-0.2639240622520447,
-0.4978249669075012,
-0.4450993239879608,
-1.0242663621902466,
-1.0443956851959229,
-0.25540193915367126,
-0.29356876015663147,
-0.2410193681716919,
0.3064766526222229,
0.6419604420661926,
0.5930966734886169,
-0.7729275822639465,
-0.02349739894270897,
0.20134009420871735,
0.1310408115386963,
-0.24428756535053253,
-0.13708685338497162,
0.921193540096283,
0.046899955719709396,
-0.3903563618659973,
0.24532420933246613,
0.8204635381698608,
0.2266312539577484,
0.31650131940841675,
0.05989687144756317,
0.07331100106239319,
-0.4511721730232239,
0.6352366805076599,
0.4313695728778839,
-0.3027384877204895,
-0.12909679114818573,
0.17314326763153076,
-0.1999230831861496,
0.18322579562664032,
1.1670165061950684,
-0.6940644383430481,
0.366550475358963,
0.5055465698242188,
0.7842342853546143,
0.31481122970581055,
0.33212876319885254,
0.7436015605926514,
-0.38951995968818665,
-0.04570157825946808,
0.39399775862693787,
0.4918777346611023,
0.23850873112678528,
-0.5871022343635559,
0.4952126741409302,
0.32294145226478577,
-0.8890471458435059,
-0.5011821985244751,
-0.24186059832572937,
-1.1922117471694946,
0.06870847195386887,
0.8818991780281067,
-0.12424647063016891,
-0.1464131474494934,
-0.36646947264671326,
-0.36267247796058655,
0.42007091641426086,
-0.4490109086036682,
0.7763850092887878,
0.07904323190450668,
-0.6109734177589417,
0.03590310364961624,
-0.4519760310649872,
0.5449373722076416,
0.282021164894104,
-0.8490381240844727,
-0.10075849294662476,
0.6012779474258423,
0.10453963279724121,
0.13935185968875885,
1.1041111946105957,
-0.18461409211158752,
0.2792816460132599,
-0.2993292212486267,
-0.2029569298028946,
-0.19493064284324646,
-0.296535462141037,
-0.407916784286499,
0.37774550914764404,
-0.28984132409095764,
-0.112151600420475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14895v1
|
Stance Reasoner: Zero-Shot Stance Detection on Social Media with Explicit Reasoning
| 2024-03-22T00:58:28 | 2024-03-22T00:58:28 |
Maksym Taranukhin, Vered Shwartz, Evangelos Milios
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Social media platforms are rich sources of opinionated content. Stance
detection allows the automatic extraction of users' opinions on various topics
from such content. We focus on zero-shot stance detection, where the model's
success relies on (a) having knowledge about the target topic; and (b) learning
general reasoning strategies that can be employed for new topics. We present
Stance Reasoner, an approach to zero-shot stance detection on social media that
leverages explicit reasoning over background knowledge to guide the model's
inference about the document's stance on a target. Specifically, our method
uses a pre-trained language model as a source of world knowledge, with the
chain-of-thought in-context learning approach to generate intermediate
reasoning steps. Stance Reasoner outperforms the current state-of-the-art
models on 3 Twitter datasets, including fully supervised models. It can better
generalize across targets, while at the same time providing explicit and
interpretable explanations for its predictions.
|
[
-0.3560609817504883,
-0.8555880784988403,
0.803497850894928,
0.06393727660179138,
-0.6015028357505798,
-0.1794961541891098,
-0.04315037280321121,
-0.03631943091750145,
0.41448748111724854,
0.43929246068000793,
-0.5321471691131592,
-0.7394518852233887,
-0.7637699246406555,
-0.25115251541137695,
-0.4245717227458954,
1.0504348278045654,
-0.2134605497121811,
-0.06720491498708725,
0.03274495527148247,
-0.35926342010498047,
-0.3498428761959076,
-0.1192961186170578,
-0.6440747976303101,
-0.24182534217834473,
0.6228127479553223,
0.5435479879379272,
0.5379657745361328,
0.5654441714286804,
0.12057776749134064,
0.1612052321434021,
0.16024921834468842,
-0.2967027425765991,
-0.46486324071884155,
0.3026546537876129,
-0.489546000957489,
-0.3765934705734253,
-0.27932170033454895,
-0.02780906856060028,
0.3888343572616577,
0.21023181080818176,
0.17492996156215668,
0.17110955715179443,
-0.5209429860115051,
0.4287107288837433,
-0.7857208847999573,
-0.35537582635879517,
-0.6451647281646729,
0.01764301396906376,
0.05189966410398483,
-0.16997916996479034,
-0.2665819525718689,
-0.23568180203437805,
-0.12948991358280182,
-0.43155521154403687,
0.3766798973083496,
-0.3757382333278656,
0.9601194262504578,
0.1949712038040161,
-0.5194317698478699,
0.011476781219244003,
-0.8707048892974854,
0.7751191258430481,
-0.473017156124115,
0.5585669279098511,
0.30929046869277954,
0.4361703097820282,
0.10392676293849945,
-0.2682509124279022,
-0.980111837387085,
0.10219424962997437,
0.24770747125148773,
0.174786776304245,
-0.37789246439933777,
-0.05499033257365227,
0.23515349626541138,
0.21259401738643646,
-0.4757194519042969,
-0.23365141451358795,
-0.16480568051338196,
-0.009584029205143452,
0.5214808583259583,
-0.5180405378341675,
0.4028811752796173,
-0.3708617389202118,
-0.40175774693489075,
0.0914653092622757,
-0.420380175113678,
0.2246481031179428,
0.46744075417518616,
0.04771120473742485,
-0.09070346504449844,
0.6117117404937744,
-0.41391438245773315,
0.5735567212104797,
0.6232985854148865,
0.054836977273225784,
-0.1258978545665741,
0.16388575732707977,
-0.3086736798286438,
0.18519869446754456,
0.9289388656616211,
0.5796921849250793,
0.039999328553676605,
-0.148024320602417,
-0.19024938344955444,
0.22340387105941772,
0.14665253460407257,
-0.7851783633232117,
-0.11696427315473557,
0.5543019771575928,
-0.34727743268013,
-0.335830956697464,
0.06936643272638321,
-0.45792269706726074,
-0.6521065831184387,
-0.5013849139213562,
0.2683972418308258,
-0.5386179089546204,
-0.62192702293396,
0.1896379142999649,
-0.45452484488487244,
0.983086347579956,
0.5647544860839844,
-0.5467132925987244,
-0.15693622827529907,
0.9931737780570984,
0.9724096059799194,
0.02510627545416355,
-0.050965290516614914,
-0.5852394104003906,
0.17103004455566406,
-0.5649814605712891,
1.229244589805603,
-0.4701094925403595,
-0.14583741128444672,
-0.03943486884236336,
0.07051336020231247,
0.30055704712867737,
0.043840378522872925,
0.6426231861114502,
-0.457830548286438,
0.13486972451210022,
-0.49123281240463257,
-0.7553768157958984,
-0.08035065978765488,
0.7837520837783813,
-0.6139509677886963,
0.571536660194397,
-0.14379297196865082,
-0.7570289373397827,
1.0374467372894287,
-0.711961567401886,
-0.5339851975440979,
0.25846147537231445,
-0.37530067563056946,
-0.14211636781692505,
0.14262112975120544,
0.34391921758651733,
0.6104218363761902,
0.1792009472846985,
0.41173073649406433,
-0.7670697569847107,
-0.3040640354156494,
0.0019902298226952553,
-0.11862347275018692,
0.9142647981643677,
0.10277677327394485,
-0.43960729241371155,
0.3583652377128601,
-0.4689571261405945,
-0.2912079989910126,
0.42440614104270935,
-0.12215161323547363,
-0.3441323935985565,
0.16384539008140564,
-0.26282036304473877,
0.447127103805542,
-0.019712256267666817,
-0.6984627842903137,
0.06922534853219986,
-0.35772764682769775,
0.25219419598579407,
0.6324170827865601,
0.24214956164360046,
0.6925919651985168,
-0.10361164808273315,
0.5463523864746094,
-0.03543902933597565,
0.2227347195148468,
-0.24966196715831757,
-0.29659098386764526,
-0.6962252855300903,
-0.027382804080843925,
-0.05144714564085007,
0.4390963613986969,
-0.5655038356781006,
0.5394570231437683,
-0.19142185151576996,
-0.48684749007225037,
-0.42855677008628845,
0.3061250150203705,
0.20507603883743286,
0.4104056656360626,
0.3568437099456787,
0.08942200988531113,
-0.4599802792072296,
-0.6617085933685303,
-0.6795990467071533,
-0.312263160943985,
0.2293367236852646,
-0.16708724200725555,
0.47640007734298706,
-0.07092598080635071,
1.156766653060913,
-0.2272941768169403,
-0.04808370769023895,
-0.5879303216934204,
0.22857478260993958,
0.07139015942811966,
0.12482882291078568,
0.7951416373252869,
-1.043070673942566,
-0.5860815644264221,
-0.07247864454984665,
-0.9114590287208557,
-0.024153154343366623,
-0.27518290281295776,
-0.6406975984573364,
0.18484386801719666,
0.5032669305801392,
-0.9223027229309082,
0.43001893162727356,
0.20712417364120483,
-0.44826239347457886,
0.45827022194862366,
0.3778272271156311,
0.13352379202842712,
-1.2004104852676392,
-0.09675032645463943,
0.6837672591209412,
-0.4308669865131378,
-0.7961118221282959,
0.047489240765571594,
-0.1720934510231018,
-0.1253703534603119,
-0.6362939476966858,
0.764529824256897,
-0.08478350192308426,
0.21273855865001678,
-0.44275611639022827,
0.0845557376742363,
0.18176643550395966,
0.20942962169647217,
0.31653815507888794,
0.1667734831571579,
0.736225426197052,
-0.3738367259502411,
0.3051982820034027,
0.06720760464668274,
0.009365633130073547,
1.0133485794067383,
-0.741142213344574,
0.32962438464164734,
-0.42385947704315186,
0.45534029603004456,
-1.1750197410583496,
-0.4466277062892914,
0.5205141305923462,
-0.7154451012611389,
0.16070523858070374,
-0.8143070936203003,
-0.24973620474338531,
-0.3943448066711426,
-0.525726854801178,
-0.07441499829292297,
0.10178077965974808,
-0.4385414719581604,
0.7038996815681458,
0.48473793268203735,
0.2979184091091156,
-0.8689579963684082,
-0.3233754336833954,
-0.03934955224394798,
-0.2890959680080414,
-0.390865296125412,
0.12164369970560074,
0.18851548433303833,
-0.5281999111175537,
0.13172447681427002,
-0.5293083190917969,
-0.06314843147993088,
-0.17483669519424438,
0.23653852939605713,
0.028805339708924294,
-0.22666054964065552,
0.13451595604419708,
0.17732422053813934,
-0.19127677381038666,
0.11958062648773193,
-0.46186190843582153,
0.5104862451553345,
-0.2623084783554077,
-0.46312209963798523,
-0.5822181701660156,
0.19159618020057678,
0.7775866389274597,
0.04599887877702713,
0.6821248531341553,
0.7455467581748962,
-0.395973801612854,
-0.3321002423763275,
-0.6313068270683289,
-0.08207404613494873,
-0.40725281834602356,
-0.03425298258662224,
-0.06912605464458466,
-0.7429749369621277,
0.1905413269996643,
0.05695418268442154,
0.24106939136981964,
0.3845460116863251,
0.4990036189556122,
-0.3211040794849396,
1.0974560976028442,
0.46541696786880493,
-0.34058597683906555,
0.5239177942276001,
-0.23628507554531097,
0.42072030901908875,
-0.05436326935887337,
0.09653891623020172,
-0.16932567954063416,
-0.4622783958911896,
-0.15928958356380463,
-0.4344331920146942,
-0.25698322057724,
0.20662568509578705,
-0.42818543314933777,
0.35093051195144653,
-0.4867255985736847,
0.8070043921470642,
0.2145729660987854,
0.11940261721611023,
-0.0319417342543602,
-0.1479160487651825,
0.3354100286960602,
0.24605792760849,
-0.1471911370754242,
-0.6787575483322144,
0.6903480291366577,
0.3514801859855652,
0.39911311864852905,
0.09068472683429718,
0.8405343294143677,
0.46057990193367004,
0.4071265459060669,
-1.368186593055725,
0.6597923040390015,
-0.016053257510066032,
-0.7631732821464539,
-0.22617290914058685,
-0.17202578485012054,
-0.5172988176345825,
0.17053236067295074,
-0.22934411466121674,
-0.4631692171096802,
0.09691936522722244,
0.46813544631004333,
-0.22786355018615723,
0.5736243724822998,
-0.4258713126182556,
1.0781110525131226,
-0.42429545521736145,
-0.4041215479373932,
-0.02239060029387474,
-0.6497635245323181,
0.4164648950099945,
0.23807869851589203,
0.0164178516715765,
-0.3481055200099945,
0.1965402215719223,
0.672200083732605,
-0.33865925669670105,
0.99739009141922,
-0.879104495048523,
-0.1577310860157013,
0.4325620234012604,
0.2134581208229065,
0.23834329843521118,
0.0028298699762672186,
-0.0697944238781929,
0.07743871212005615,
-0.255007266998291,
-0.45571961998939514,
-0.5462663173675537,
0.5882800817489624,
-0.5849552154541016,
-0.6233018636703491,
-0.2541567087173462,
-0.16547748446464539,
-0.23717378079891205,
0.33766818046569824,
0.28879866003990173,
-0.0012534254929050803,
-0.5144943594932556,
0.40265795588493347,
0.5741150379180908,
0.0530964732170105,
0.31977683305740356,
0.5232559442520142,
-0.24304428696632385,
-0.19989712536334991,
0.7579490542411804,
-0.11862026900053024,
-0.16918756067752838,
0.5280812382698059,
0.4719061255455017,
-0.4999080002307892,
-0.43291324377059937,
-0.4845177233219147,
0.1901712715625763,
-0.8892648816108704,
-0.07621373236179352,
-0.6574172973632812,
0.05589056387543678,
-0.27154383063316345,
-0.6316846013069153,
-0.27251166105270386,
-0.4306986331939697,
0.12012428045272827,
-0.4803202450275421,
0.4727926254272461,
0.4112817645072937,
0.009366663172841072,
0.6103841066360474,
-0.42867857217788696,
0.6026655435562134,
0.3459107577800751,
0.2864137291908264,
-0.5075699090957642,
-0.4171391725540161,
0.1560659557580948,
-0.01088889129459858,
-0.40777748823165894,
-1.2197258472442627,
0.14240121841430664,
0.009725568816065788,
0.5290952324867249,
1.0148820877075195,
0.12285522371530533,
0.4678700268268585,
-0.11983439326286316,
0.5374981760978699,
0.47237977385520935,
-0.9652460217475891,
1.116452932357788,
-0.775070071220398,
0.17615249752998352,
0.6718791127204895,
0.8016661405563354,
-0.28050321340560913,
-0.47592025995254517,
-0.5347582697868347,
-0.5890651345252991,
0.6743614077568054,
-0.05154042690992355,
0.35097405314445496,
-0.23035575449466705,
0.4801189601421356,
-0.022412454709410667,
0.01946691982448101,
-0.9438246488571167,
0.11942483484745026,
-0.7679867744445801,
-0.09379252791404724,
0.18898332118988037,
0.06245938688516617,
-0.13089407980442047,
-0.446783185005188,
0.6186152696609497,
-0.4814009964466095,
-0.009005550295114517,
-0.06641186773777008,
-0.45053809881210327,
-0.42253437638282776,
0.44046637415885925,
0.26752251386642456,
0.6848975419998169,
-0.26810377836227417,
0.09703435748815536,
0.13863299787044525,
-0.14537465572357178,
0.17696627974510193,
-0.004317971412092447,
-0.4975600242614746,
0.1826457977294922,
0.10137874633073807,
0.8553128242492676,
0.16243292391300201,
-0.21843227744102478,
0.9660835862159729,
-0.07335661351680756,
-0.4663301408290863,
-0.37572017312049866,
-0.024875706061720848,
0.18276725709438324,
0.12086968123912811,
0.13464784622192383,
0.23092958331108093,
-0.010197184048593044,
-0.4451974332332611,
0.31626296043395996,
0.45883065462112427,
-0.909900963306427,
-0.645803689956665,
0.5811035633087158,
0.03653353452682495,
-0.08095993846654892,
-0.0818161889910698,
-0.3019556403160095,
-0.47912922501564026,
0.5230297446250916,
0.4695119857788086,
0.9713786840438843,
-0.2639741003513336,
0.7848315238952637,
0.3687736690044403,
0.007320853415876627,
-0.15323050320148468,
0.311070054769516,
-0.31629881262779236,
-1.1303763389587402,
-0.5294404029846191,
-0.5777754783630371,
-0.5124768018722534,
0.3351743817329407,
-0.593480110168457,
0.684386134147644,
-0.9621722102165222,
-0.22184772789478302,
0.3375069200992584,
-0.2699386477470398,
-0.4806213080883026,
0.14553202688694,
0.3368496894836426,
0.8165412545204163,
-0.9922841787338257,
0.6298604607582092,
1.055678367614746,
-0.5850635170936584,
-0.6140068769454956,
0.6160911321640015,
0.4265238642692566,
-0.7093117833137512,
0.45422422885894775,
0.3726192116737366,
-0.6063766479492188,
-0.14980433881282806,
-0.9180566668510437,
-0.23016677796840668,
0.8467047214508057,
0.7215422987937927,
-0.32976028323173523,
0.25717732310295105,
-0.08917603641748428,
0.45399582386016846,
-0.1990707516670227,
0.04994366317987442,
0.35948577523231506,
0.33360594511032104,
0.48707273602485657,
-0.1188325360417366,
0.09192989021539688,
-0.2637791335582733,
-0.373945951461792,
0.25519663095474243,
-0.437781423330307,
0.5060307383537292,
-0.07424622029066086,
-0.17791126668453217,
-0.6898791193962097,
0.608253002166748,
0.44914788007736206,
0.5333244800567627,
0.7622042894363403,
0.649385392665863,
0.5294583439826965,
0.08186681568622589,
0.970462441444397,
-0.45477980375289917,
0.2792344093322754,
0.79857337474823,
-0.5667079091072083,
0.9701850414276123,
0.26437824964523315,
0.22226370871067047,
0.8973414301872253,
0.3579944670200348,
0.08216507732868195,
0.2905384302139282,
-0.2942582964897156,
-0.39800676703453064,
-0.707870364189148,
-0.10414359718561172,
-0.017927493900060654,
0.6676758527755737,
0.37070879340171814,
-0.2440079003572464,
-0.40060245990753174,
-0.3214288353919983,
0.38644692301750183,
0.03322109207510948,
-0.5077069401741028,
0.8356675505638123,
0.059720564633607864,
-0.7579743266105652,
0.28366634249687195,
-0.002401411533355713,
0.4771542549133301,
-0.4290311634540558,
0.0729222446680069,
-0.05872705951333046,
0.25680679082870483,
-0.28921273350715637,
-1.1202824115753174,
0.5314329266548157,
0.28689974546432495,
-0.17910738289356232,
-0.37273794412612915,
1.528329849243164,
-0.11885863542556763,
-0.3935537338256836,
0.4952937364578247,
0.7000457048416138,
-0.03690406307578087,
-0.4334357976913452,
-0.9404774308204651,
-0.3925347924232483,
-0.28613463044166565,
-0.26467594504356384,
0.1626589298248291,
0.7428171634674072,
-0.11687484383583069,
0.3177376985549927,
0.9105210900306702,
-0.20306363701820374,
-0.44234925508499146,
0.3814634680747986,
0.977489173412323,
-0.5589495301246643,
-0.5450559854507446,
-1.161413550376892,
0.42930522561073303,
-0.49075719714164734,
-0.17360176146030426,
0.8363266587257385,
0.3924741744995117,
0.6561258435249329,
0.102474145591259,
1.0798193216323853,
-0.20516665279865265,
0.4760133922100067,
-0.10596189647912979,
0.819058358669281,
-0.693732500076294,
-0.2188517302274704,
-0.25146716833114624,
-0.7270218729972839,
-0.48630982637405396,
0.8307185173034668,
-0.6803998351097107,
-0.1424115002155304,
0.27050521969795227,
0.5929754972457886,
-0.4081394374370575,
0.07816871255636215,
0.23028051853179932,
-0.044356219470500946,
0.32456180453300476,
0.14778025448322296,
0.9977692365646362,
0.03910782188177109,
0.6113482117652893,
-0.11647866666316986,
-0.13980774581432343,
-0.19648975133895874,
-1.0917198657989502,
-1.0871942043304443,
-0.217218816280365,
-0.42449527978897095,
-0.47246429324150085,
-0.0905730202794075,
1.0096290111541748,
0.8768066763877869,
-1.041929841041565,
0.06954065710306168,
-0.4117918908596039,
0.37003710865974426,
-0.0433170460164547,
-0.26594144105911255,
0.12116312980651855,
-0.28215697407722473,
-0.25565996766090393,
0.4494066536426544,
0.2235047072172165,
-0.3242906630039215,
-0.028158249333500862,
-0.2350928783416748,
-0.35989663004875183,
0.2912631332874298,
0.6821774840354919,
0.7864960432052612,
-0.8030864596366882,
-0.3125208020210266,
0.15186211466789246,
0.18597319722175598,
0.16456034779548645,
0.8336511850357056,
-0.5139990448951721,
0.4484686255455017,
0.6377627849578857,
0.2919588088989258,
0.43571266531944275,
0.40073350071907043,
0.5206251740455627,
-0.9895108342170715,
0.09865009039640427,
0.13797776401042938,
0.6187366247177124,
0.4636704623699188,
-0.29328903555870056,
0.1757974922657013,
0.48007962107658386,
-0.2894617021083832,
-0.598092257976532,
0.29774680733680725,
-1.0934066772460938,
-0.4561142921447754,
1.3521850109100342,
-0.08078476041555405,
-0.26099151372909546,
-0.33293551206588745,
-0.14255984127521515,
0.4206359088420868,
-0.6431980133056641,
0.5306404829025269,
0.5092475414276123,
-0.009947998449206352,
-0.5746316909790039,
-0.46042734384536743,
0.2687819004058838,
0.1433839201927185,
-0.5495464205741882,
-0.12523546814918518,
0.531421422958374,
0.43655160069465637,
0.22981922328472137,
1.0681824684143066,
0.18267279863357544,
0.3666072189807892,
-0.2562464773654938,
0.021264832466840744,
0.14533351361751556,
-0.40307798981666565,
-0.34269607067108154,
0.18546004593372345,
-0.15300889313220978,
-0.11558669060468674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14888v1
|
AutoRE: Document-Level Relation Extraction with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-21T23:48:21 | 2024-03-21T23:48:21 |
Xue Lilong, Zhang Dan, Dong Yuxiao, Tang Jie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional abilities in
comprehending and generating text, motivating numerous researchers to utilize
them for Information Extraction (IE) purposes, including Relation Extraction
(RE). Nonetheless, most existing methods are predominantly designed for
Sentence-level Relation Extraction (SentRE) tasks, which typically encompass a
restricted set of relations and triplet facts within a single sentence.
Furthermore, certain approaches resort to treating relations as candidate
choices integrated into prompt templates, leading to inefficient processing and
suboptimal performance when tackling Document-Level Relation Extraction (DocRE)
tasks, which entail handling multiple relations and triplet facts distributed
across a given document, posing distinct challenges. To overcome these
limitations, we introduce AutoRE, an end-to-end DocRE model that adopts a novel
RE extraction paradigm named RHF (Relation-Head-Facts). Unlike existing
approaches, AutoRE does not rely on the assumption of known relation options,
making it more reflective of real-world scenarios. Additionally, we have
developed an easily extensible RE framework using a Parameters Efficient Fine
Tuning (PEFT) algorithm (QLoRA). Our experiments on the RE-DocRED dataset
showcase AutoRE's best performance, achieving state-of-the-art results,
surpassing TAG by 10.03% and 9.03% respectively on the dev and test set.
|
[
-0.27196240425109863,
-0.9081971645355225,
0.5777314901351929,
-0.03830493986606598,
-0.21926918625831604,
-0.061646584421396255,
-0.12609925866127014,
-0.7338820099830627,
-0.18614836037158966,
0.5652278065681458,
-0.47531452775001526,
-0.32961365580558777,
-0.5907809138298035,
0.28572726249694824,
-0.4811375141143799,
0.8481481671333313,
-0.13843108713626862,
-0.44179046154022217,
-0.14836598932743073,
-0.021747102960944176,
-0.1465686559677124,
-0.5201951861381531,
-0.6478932499885559,
-0.291124552488327,
0.7017393112182617,
0.6621696352958679,
0.4884728193283081,
0.9469454288482666,
0.668062150478363,
0.16430802643299103,
0.31922367215156555,
0.37717846035957336,
-0.4039263427257538,
0.6264641880989075,
-0.30631619691848755,
-0.06878994405269623,
-0.6346977353096008,
0.14194445312023163,
0.5091382265090942,
0.3445051312446594,
-0.12516579031944275,
0.2918313145637512,
-0.22920632362365723,
0.6859787106513977,
-0.6066394448280334,
0.5029439330101013,
-0.5787120461463928,
-0.17758552730083466,
0.0004978623474016786,
-0.3650475740432739,
-0.26626089215278625,
-0.14749358594417572,
0.20511475205421448,
-0.6517253518104553,
0.3041786253452301,
0.2592773139476776,
1.2591753005981445,
0.17056958377361298,
-0.41295886039733887,
-0.23924759030342102,
-0.9054441452026367,
0.38100188970565796,
-0.5765677690505981,
0.8416835069656372,
0.377613365650177,
0.18991704285144806,
-0.1265867054462433,
-0.9130295515060425,
-0.44820985198020935,
-0.08893231302499771,
-0.18970687687397003,
0.08703886717557907,
-0.26491579413414,
-0.14413133263587952,
0.41667965054512024,
0.6852395534515381,
-0.4052633047103882,
0.009822124615311623,
-0.10135394334793091,
0.08909330517053604,
0.6057400703430176,
0.144237220287323,
0.2271737903356552,
-0.3336143493652344,
-0.2264195680618286,
-0.19587062299251556,
-0.6757693290710449,
-0.15475957095623016,
0.20169657468795776,
0.194523885846138,
0.11002177745103836,
0.5835190415382385,
-0.1358550786972046,
0.7197858691215515,
0.3236660659313202,
-0.22612376511096954,
-0.0034239632077515125,
-0.5013828873634338,
-0.2554842531681061,
-0.4548535645008087,
1.2125561237335205,
0.08496489375829697,
0.5543568730354309,
-0.29962295293807983,
-0.35530510544776917,
-0.40412840247154236,
-0.0361737459897995,
-0.9304708242416382,
-0.35315361618995667,
0.07229172438383102,
-0.5841798186302185,
-0.2923080027103424,
0.06694958359003067,
-1.1304287910461426,
-0.07719802856445312,
-0.22895823419094086,
0.04785030707716942,
-0.5034989714622498,
-0.3383980691432953,
-0.13562820851802826,
-0.008568108081817627,
0.6365742683410645,
0.3365952670574188,
-0.9236406683921814,
0.4872937500476837,
0.6920623183250427,
0.6923623085021973,
-0.21121633052825928,
-0.23935623466968536,
-0.8692201375961304,
0.3267596960067749,
-0.08207003772258759,
0.9801966547966003,
-0.6119961142539978,
-0.4238397479057312,
-0.2924503684043884,
0.04093670845031738,
-0.2145031839609146,
-0.444070041179657,
0.41212472319602966,
-0.6430249810218811,
0.42147669196128845,
0.05181584134697914,
-0.5939911603927612,
0.07826671004295349,
0.15713845193386078,
-0.9141779541969299,
1.104485034942627,
0.4029272198677063,
-0.8187180161476135,
0.2622760534286499,
-0.315451055765152,
-0.6867147088050842,
-0.14025180041790009,
-0.44478732347488403,
-0.3915167450904846,
0.0232719574123621,
0.4416290521621704,
0.46106088161468506,
-0.9606242179870605,
0.27492716908454895,
-0.22944213449954987,
0.17807184159755707,
-0.011861968785524368,
-0.22403044998645782,
0.46530431509017944,
0.36491358280181885,
-0.1491374522447586,
0.036799971014261246,
-0.9551811218261719,
-0.26713883876800537,
0.2525419294834137,
-0.3220982849597931,
-0.5042339563369751,
-0.16896724700927734,
0.03443015739321709,
0.63649582862854,
0.299134224653244,
-0.6368105411529541,
0.2232091873884201,
-0.5017749071121216,
0.36862364411354065,
0.34429633617401123,
0.4216530919075012,
0.4746440052986145,
-0.20176732540130615,
0.7456609010696411,
-0.28211134672164917,
0.07896213978528976,
-0.32196471095085144,
-0.18869170546531677,
-0.607026994228363,
-0.3895374536514282,
0.38367894291877747,
0.526488721370697,
-0.44415897130966187,
0.4217135012149811,
-0.39715296030044556,
-0.37546372413635254,
-0.34818604588508606,
0.2724599540233612,
0.4287441372871399,
0.7998511791229248,
0.12380749732255936,
-0.084299735724926,
-0.490085631608963,
-1.0719733238220215,
-0.39765939116477966,
-0.2679249346256256,
0.2081768810749054,
0.1841755509376526,
0.3472411036491394,
-0.016447659581899643,
1.2599281072616577,
-0.8599827289581299,
-0.4379589855670929,
-0.29605114459991455,
0.3167021870613098,
0.205901637673378,
0.30006030201911926,
0.34788352251052856,
-0.8838119506835938,
-0.6264700889587402,
0.10795988887548447,
-0.8737577795982361,
-0.20283956825733185,
-0.1714317798614502,
-0.03698207065463066,
0.2066861242055893,
0.6331723928451538,
-0.8206117153167725,
0.3569391071796417,
0.05306519567966461,
-0.05935165658593178,
0.4684365689754486,
-0.3158183693885803,
-0.07043533027172089,
-1.0343096256256104,
0.3692592978477478,
0.21821388602256775,
-0.5207662582397461,
-0.33712804317474365,
0.09261281788349152,
0.35309016704559326,
-0.1567099690437317,
-0.05207594111561775,
0.6946729421615601,
-0.8454245924949646,
-0.22254173457622528,
-0.213271364569664,
0.05400571972131729,
0.2927487790584564,
0.4327333867549896,
0.28010520339012146,
0.7175073623657227,
0.18645943701267242,
-0.43751704692840576,
0.3482343256473541,
0.3699277937412262,
-0.04480430483818054,
0.4251352548599243,
-0.5864208340644836,
0.16999948024749756,
0.03677356615662575,
0.3088187873363495,
-0.7249059081077576,
-0.20068266987800598,
0.3511791527271271,
-0.45559027791023254,
0.5753210186958313,
-0.18948149681091309,
-0.7979964017868042,
-0.10812054574489594,
-0.11859548836946487,
0.13865725696086884,
0.2526555359363556,
-0.3368058204650879,
0.9825724363327026,
0.6957606077194214,
-0.4030691385269165,
-0.5818859934806824,
-0.19956481456756592,
0.2176521271467209,
-0.24539798498153687,
-0.43570148944854736,
0.3589271903038025,
0.17990641295909882,
-0.35915350914001465,
0.07451134920120239,
-0.3120880126953125,
-0.38511112332344055,
-0.16156823933124542,
0.16566084325313568,
0.2815164625644684,
0.05592937394976616,
0.06868892908096313,
-0.18031196296215057,
-0.35439378023147583,
0.16864408552646637,
-0.002616205019876361,
0.3396957516670227,
0.029854001477360725,
0.12314481288194656,
-0.2538510262966156,
0.6485788822174072,
0.9627082347869873,
-0.6409392952919006,
0.4589932858943939,
0.4882121682167053,
-0.5591269731521606,
-0.05069362744688988,
-0.7012539505958557,
-0.037580061703920364,
-0.3635639250278473,
0.3443848490715027,
-0.8034008741378784,
-0.6028625965118408,
0.5826522707939148,
-0.04257714003324509,
0.4194701313972473,
0.6855862140655518,
0.18918952345848083,
-0.005148935131728649,
0.7213346362113953,
0.9168793559074402,
-0.17249450087547302,
0.5080997347831726,
-0.22801096737384796,
0.2014310359954834,
-0.9197752475738525,
-0.2898668050765991,
-0.585633397102356,
0.33550024032592773,
-0.426296204328537,
-0.14685529470443726,
0.13685324788093567,
-0.0017233798280358315,
-0.06751497834920883,
0.701005220413208,
-0.087643101811409,
0.0772169828414917,
0.2809220552444458,
-0.1126309484243393,
0.6373255252838135,
0.06716971099376678,
0.11503266543149948,
-0.0036679375916719437,
-0.7306930422782898,
-0.18863925337791443,
0.9526388645172119,
0.4074198603630066,
0.9216896891593933,
-0.05395017936825752,
0.8731063008308411,
0.11564458906650543,
0.43400856852531433,
-0.8732504844665527,
0.4299581050872803,
-0.2549770474433899,
-0.4124811291694641,
-0.31867605447769165,
-0.6359634399414062,
-1.0576664209365845,
0.21029794216156006,
-0.17187251150608063,
-0.5539753437042236,
0.5941463708877563,
-0.09675271064043045,
-0.3220469355583191,
0.14004673063755035,
-0.38577109575271606,
0.6261663436889648,
-0.2185559719800949,
-0.5241579413414001,
-0.022227967157959938,
-0.8281627893447876,
0.28456932306289673,
-0.6054109334945679,
0.41734495759010315,
-0.040754202753305435,
-0.09359981119632721,
0.8256351351737976,
-0.3954686224460602,
0.4038628339767456,
0.14825311303138733,
-0.5308661460876465,
0.03898344933986664,
0.21353590488433838,
0.7475683689117432,
0.05766405537724495,
-0.19579461216926575,
-0.09365982562303543,
0.17560742795467377,
0.18925753235816956,
-0.780912458896637,
0.6736401319503784,
-0.44803425669670105,
-0.3829534649848938,
-0.5561671853065491,
-0.7161538004875183,
-0.30471232533454895,
0.4542315900325775,
0.2203984260559082,
0.6460884809494019,
-0.3083633482456207,
0.021599173545837402,
0.5127627849578857,
-0.2556919455528259,
0.4262756109237671,
0.7685097455978394,
-0.39310410618782043,
-0.7342958450317383,
0.6868849396705627,
0.0119325565174222,
0.2063646912574768,
0.677687406539917,
0.08943720161914825,
-0.4728066027164459,
-0.15022695064544678,
-0.2584461569786072,
0.5687673687934875,
-0.6262440085411072,
-0.3241064250469208,
-1.0415445566177368,
-0.2551528215408325,
-0.6421388983726501,
0.3350355327129364,
-0.3936404585838318,
-0.5586817860603333,
-0.29748865962028503,
-0.0138612762093544,
0.1969543993473053,
0.695911169052124,
-0.26333820819854736,
0.07108402252197266,
-1.0281939506530762,
0.7670783400535583,
0.17500367760658264,
0.10767103731632233,
-0.1329546719789505,
-0.5097703337669373,
-0.18780812621116638,
-0.5116940140724182,
0.07554908096790314,
-1.0411254167556763,
0.6718115210533142,
0.3285923898220062,
0.5068539977073669,
0.182908296585083,
0.08443112671375275,
0.6945317387580872,
-0.42457666993141174,
0.1267658919095993,
0.1270821988582611,
-0.5424719452857971,
0.4529185891151428,
-0.5904231667518616,
0.05420658364892006,
0.7247787117958069,
0.18610885739326477,
-0.4148775637149811,
-0.23546943068504333,
-0.8768489956855774,
-1.1216566562652588,
0.6121835708618164,
0.15405361354351044,
-0.34249579906463623,
-0.03406943753361702,
0.7120168209075928,
0.1574278026819229,
0.18538782000541687,
-0.5786653757095337,
-0.2145249843597412,
0.2860625386238098,
-0.22099122405052185,
0.05644598603248596,
-0.3564545512199402,
0.1944490522146225,
-0.26020458340644836,
0.5333107113838196,
0.1850799173116684,
0.13148221373558044,
0.5702486634254456,
-0.3384254276752472,
-0.43525534868240356,
0.24105827510356903,
0.05280717834830284,
0.9101121425628662,
-0.5652769207954407,
0.13942588865756989,
-0.22408781945705414,
-0.25971564650535583,
0.01443059928715229,
0.552819013595581,
-0.03970140963792801,
-0.07530103623867035,
0.5471246242523193,
0.22967906296253204,
0.2566339373588562,
-0.46078887581825256,
0.4567878246307373,
-0.32315513491630554,
-0.12150152772665024,
-0.42060303688049316,
-0.07259199023246765,
-0.05932162329554558,
0.09253644198179245,
0.5117846727371216,
-0.3933624029159546,
0.061565082520246506,
-0.6341677904129028,
0.7797861695289612,
0.3092769980430603,
-0.3408150374889374,
-0.1405385136604309,
0.5238810181617737,
0.24711944162845612,
-0.3701746463775635,
0.6449467539787292,
0.054191362112760544,
-0.3097795844078064,
0.5594640374183655,
0.5778685212135315,
0.9532542824745178,
-0.14099179208278656,
-0.05744655430316925,
0.549425482749939,
0.29651758074760437,
0.002730119973421097,
0.10495664179325104,
-0.0855855643749237,
-0.6359331011772156,
-0.6120335459709167,
-0.6429223418235779,
-0.3018632233142853,
0.37760618329048157,
-1.0031472444534302,
0.1144644245505333,
-0.27104347944259644,
0.0007862268248572946,
-0.0047151208855211735,
0.13322100043296814,
-0.5958609580993652,
0.2535090744495392,
-0.11954300850629807,
0.9848178625106812,
-0.5962986946105957,
1.0666388273239136,
0.5280974507331848,
-0.6351043581962585,
-0.8560148477554321,
0.07067546993494034,
-0.2887500822544098,
-0.4232736825942993,
0.8772485852241516,
-0.011775324121117592,
-0.37006810307502747,
0.31395670771598816,
-0.25290557742118835,
-0.8201003074645996,
0.9698081016540527,
0.3117886185646057,
-0.9173192381858826,
-0.3818818926811218,
-0.13941757380962372,
0.31702256202697754,
-0.7687295079231262,
0.15438491106033325,
0.7621400952339172,
0.48235374689102173,
-0.11695220321416855,
-0.809139609336853,
0.29050371050834656,
-0.2992319166660309,
-0.40875983238220215,
0.3649957478046417,
-0.5592420101165771,
0.7152772545814514,
-0.019224826246500015,
-0.3492349684238434,
-0.09290529042482376,
0.7742000818252563,
0.06156381592154503,
0.1309453696012497,
0.7373212575912476,
0.5171450972557068,
0.6312840580940247,
0.3402477502822876,
0.988128125667572,
-0.533873975276947,
0.34633469581604004,
1.627556324005127,
-0.552535355091095,
0.7231485247612,
0.3886330723762512,
0.020547406747937202,
0.5496852397918701,
0.7102220058441162,
0.07033663988113403,
0.402681440114975,
-0.25191354751586914,
-0.0002674010756891221,
-0.33347710967063904,
0.053016699850559235,
-0.2152261584997177,
0.6092296838760376,
0.4351862370967865,
-0.5401081442832947,
-0.45563140511512756,
-0.343092679977417,
0.13491857051849365,
-0.06181182712316513,
0.037402860820293427,
0.8722704648971558,
0.3274582624435425,
-0.8183456659317017,
0.2575831115245819,
-0.10123856365680695,
0.2756795585155487,
-0.6294378042221069,
-0.29285919666290283,
-0.24119319021701813,
0.0409502349793911,
-0.030039578676223755,
-0.5494345426559448,
0.24084042012691498,
0.11475951224565506,
-0.38519051671028137,
-0.26569288969039917,
1.1847362518310547,
-0.5079085230827332,
-0.2982354164123535,
0.5906010866165161,
1.0693655014038086,
-0.0044996351934969425,
-0.13076506555080414,
-0.7371020317077637,
-0.28413936495780945,
-0.054938092827796936,
-0.4307310879230499,
0.35988736152648926,
0.6017112135887146,
0.061337459832429886,
0.6653963327407837,
0.771712601184845,
0.258137583732605,
-0.4565940797328949,
0.05984104797244072,
0.9269834756851196,
-0.9174473285675049,
-0.32970213890075684,
-0.9167646765708923,
0.01029883325099945,
-0.29810574650764465,
-0.2561696171760559,
0.6365481615066528,
0.7421413660049438,
0.2299734503030777,
0.25818169116973877,
0.8270513415336609,
-0.21592195332050323,
0.643950343132019,
-0.3076510727405548,
0.4737439453601837,
-0.4878624677658081,
0.2922891676425934,
-0.43112578988075256,
-1.106040120124817,
-0.2746577858924866,
0.49747541546821594,
-0.2843453586101532,
-0.1360958069562912,
1.0535622835159302,
0.5831813812255859,
-0.20100833475589752,
-0.15288785099983215,
0.16522030532360077,
0.18350417912006378,
0.5592405200004578,
0.5316363573074341,
0.799160897731781,
-0.34262174367904663,
0.7735663056373596,
-0.26891279220581055,
-0.3402707874774933,
0.08231599628925323,
-0.9490087032318115,
-0.6376426815986633,
-0.6095860004425049,
-0.3298878073692322,
-0.22534869611263275,
0.059412263333797455,
0.7085535526275635,
0.6405977606773376,
-0.34111812710762024,
-0.22348199784755707,
-0.16622938215732574,
-0.008743577636778355,
-0.017638463526964188,
-0.24883057177066803,
0.5877267718315125,
-0.2275235503911972,
-0.5654976963996887,
0.5316531658172607,
0.36444661021232605,
-0.15890100598335266,
-0.05867123603820801,
0.15380758047103882,
-0.5277464389801025,
-0.11329560726881027,
0.450152724981308,
0.5469908714294434,
-0.3181629180908203,
-0.22217917442321777,
0.011201729066669941,
-0.21878477931022644,
0.17800059914588928,
0.9998184442520142,
-0.7875099778175354,
0.2655085325241089,
0.6259477734565735,
0.4422762095928192,
0.7123568058013916,
0.34571582078933716,
1.1204661130905151,
-0.31800010800361633,
-0.3074400722980499,
-0.018067587167024612,
0.42752256989479065,
0.32726991176605225,
-0.5725094676017761,
0.8696460127830505,
0.22242049872875214,
-0.5886910557746887,
-0.6933676600456238,
0.40143969655036926,
-0.9660635590553284,
-0.3111637234687805,
1.3505619764328003,
-0.3087924122810364,
-0.24224364757537842,
-0.3417438864707947,
-0.04202154278755188,
0.6056464910507202,
-0.48377540707588196,
0.49168315529823303,
0.4607364535331726,
-0.4038928747177124,
-0.4862140119075775,
-0.5765207409858704,
0.38470175862312317,
0.18662120401859283,
-0.907769501209259,
0.5316943526268005,
0.7116283774375916,
0.5099593997001648,
-0.07309744507074356,
0.8111311197280884,
-0.3841054141521454,
0.06926623731851578,
-0.347507119178772,
-0.01565253548324108,
-0.3501151204109192,
-0.4678064286708832,
-0.32214048504829407,
0.3396931290626526,
0.08820486068725586,
0.06132574379444122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15503v1
|
Evaluating the Performance of LLMs on Technical Language Processing tasks
| 2024-03-21T23:40:42 | 2024-03-21T23:40:42 |
Andrew Kernycky, David Coleman, Christopher Spence, Udayan Das
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In this paper we present the results of an evaluation study of the
perfor-mance of LLMs on Technical Language Processing tasks. Humans are often
confronted with tasks in which they have to gather information from dispar-ate
sources and require making sense of large bodies of text. These tasks can be
significantly complex for humans and often require deep study including
rereading portions of a text. Towards simplifying the task of gathering
in-formation we evaluated LLMs with chat interfaces for their ability to
provide answers to standard questions that a human can be expected to answer
based on their reading of a body of text. The body of text under study is Title
47 of the United States Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) which describes
regula-tions for commercial telecommunications as governed by the Federal
Com-munications Commission (FCC). This has been a body of text of interest
be-cause our larger research concerns the issue of making sense of information
related to Wireless Spectrum Governance and usage in an automated manner to
support Dynamic Spectrum Access. The information concerning this wireless
spectrum domain is found in many disparate sources, with Title 47 of the CFR
being just one of many. Using a range of LLMs and providing the required CFR
text as context we were able to quantify the performance of those LLMs on the
specific task of answering the questions below.
|
[
-0.3354438841342926,
-0.7814834713935852,
0.49520325660705566,
0.4638219475746155,
-0.29727762937545776,
0.420768141746521,
-0.2297685295343399,
-0.7068552374839783,
0.11956331878900528,
0.3929162621498108,
-0.6351937651634216,
-0.7033088207244873,
-0.47011274099349976,
0.4421258866786957,
-0.6169824600219727,
0.44217780232429504,
-0.06335904449224472,
-0.14158406853675842,
-0.18692252039909363,
0.35020050406455994,
-0.7077814340591431,
-0.6376476287841797,
-0.63287752866745,
-0.47131606936454773,
0.34785786271095276,
0.5877674221992493,
0.2860174775123596,
0.3372441232204437,
0.8099422454833984,
0.4415445327758789,
-0.3182298243045807,
0.09921695291996002,
-0.6444216966629028,
0.2602473199367523,
-0.08307726681232452,
-0.5291900038719177,
-0.544256865978241,
0.13558784127235413,
0.6292099952697754,
0.5414870381355286,
-0.18514399230480194,
0.23363488912582397,
0.14195555448532104,
0.6004795432090759,
-0.2830348312854767,
0.08360132575035095,
-0.7272230386734009,
0.3059180974960327,
-0.37392234802246094,
-0.6305276155471802,
-0.4254310131072998,
-0.09082086384296417,
0.33428114652633667,
-0.775287926197052,
-0.018779989331960678,
0.1510976105928421,
0.898899257183075,
0.2729513347148895,
-0.48133283853530884,
-0.5093746781349182,
-0.8178291916847229,
0.7610712051391602,
-0.5319135189056396,
0.47464653849601746,
0.5323551893234253,
0.31933319568634033,
-0.22458447515964508,
-0.7061338424682617,
-0.4570619761943817,
-0.4205886125564575,
-0.10423371195793152,
0.2975688874721527,
-0.18939965963363647,
0.4028567969799042,
0.4113472104072571,
0.49723219871520996,
-0.2719937860965729,
0.10054674744606018,
-0.5493717789649963,
-0.42083418369293213,
0.6125738620758057,
0.4420459270477295,
0.19962817430496216,
-0.14826993644237518,
-0.15059080719947815,
0.1895536333322525,
-0.2929689586162567,
0.1523958146572113,
0.28105291724205017,
-0.015766330063343048,
-0.11238809674978256,
0.685516357421875,
-0.5307929515838623,
0.8119727373123169,
0.04521975666284561,
-0.2516919672489166,
0.2654808461666107,
-0.37016183137893677,
-0.5080158114433289,
-0.18935488164424896,
0.6912936568260193,
0.26443615555763245,
0.360813707113266,
-0.25145265460014343,
-0.28391751646995544,
-0.14648067951202393,
0.47702300548553467,
-0.40113067626953125,
0.27602097392082214,
0.05064768344163895,
-0.628965437412262,
-0.12870444357395172,
0.06526152044534683,
-0.5103700757026672,
-0.23416630923748016,
-0.5176811814308167,
0.34747394919395447,
-0.37867552042007446,
-0.2423734813928604,
0.34521785378456116,
-0.16933074593544006,
0.31650909781455994,
0.1838759481906891,
-0.5676400065422058,
0.5795787572860718,
0.6165931820869446,
0.7984693646430969,
-0.1899777203798294,
-0.0908084362745285,
-0.06686770915985107,
-0.01108179334551096,
0.09664429724216461,
0.7247788310050964,
-0.5488880276679993,
-0.6920604705810547,
-0.15214969217777252,
-0.12629826366901398,
-0.21147353947162628,
-0.5625278949737549,
0.9520062208175659,
-0.9104498028755188,
0.05679371580481529,
-0.240092933177948,
-0.593003511428833,
-0.02391449548304081,
0.1855960488319397,
-0.521976113319397,
0.8198125958442688,
-0.036037880927324295,
-0.7287114858627319,
0.1928199678659439,
-0.8594334721565247,
-0.48492833971977234,
0.10887327790260315,
-0.17782701551914215,
0.11360470950603485,
0.15767405927181244,
-0.223682701587677,
0.4664594531059265,
-0.343235045671463,
-0.1857975274324417,
0.10952417552471161,
-0.739031195640564,
0.6005763411521912,
-0.41823771595954895,
0.39897021651268005,
0.5756320953369141,
-0.4170277416706085,
-0.01901410147547722,
-0.6418043375015259,
0.010023473761975765,
-0.15521089732646942,
-0.9202215671539307,
-0.27167874574661255,
0.25380170345306396,
-0.0496009960770607,
0.10913392156362534,
0.2224607914686203,
-0.7938899993896484,
-0.2281879335641861,
-0.41311055421829224,
0.23076890408992767,
0.6340070962905884,
-0.07991667836904526,
0.33619198203086853,
-0.13541923463344574,
0.6818065047264099,
-0.14702878892421722,
0.20589283108711243,
0.05497661978006363,
-0.1320909857749939,
-0.9100184440612793,
-0.10447131842374802,
0.27291396260261536,
0.7097769975662231,
-0.7596811652183533,
0.3108406066894531,
-0.13189545273780823,
-0.43032145500183105,
-0.39348235726356506,
0.08290223032236099,
0.6164984703063965,
0.5072562098503113,
0.09262463450431824,
-0.29711902141571045,
-0.536759614944458,
-0.9719375371932983,
-0.2535378932952881,
-0.06804706901311874,
-0.1531314253807068,
0.4488563537597656,
0.08903781324625015,
-0.25579318404197693,
0.9267973303794861,
-0.4517202377319336,
-0.19347526133060455,
-0.14964739978313446,
0.11164356023073196,
0.18610960245132446,
0.11649013310670853,
0.13695792853832245,
-0.5787562727928162,
-0.3863988518714905,
0.09142950177192688,
-0.9584733843803406,
-0.5653069019317627,
0.025712324306368828,
-0.00969330407679081,
0.37364786863327026,
0.6940098404884338,
-0.36127299070358276,
0.17621062695980072,
0.690747857093811,
-0.4642358124256134,
0.307089239358902,
0.0014616106636822224,
0.42846179008483887,
-0.6962698698043823,
0.21165570616722107,
0.07693339884281158,
-0.2744203507900238,
-0.6009320616722107,
-0.15480923652648926,
-0.28014063835144043,
0.18251602351665497,
-0.5033892393112183,
0.11675328761339188,
-0.5485515594482422,
-0.2860507369041443,
-0.29325658082962036,
0.4697665274143219,
-0.30025359988212585,
0.22222928702831268,
-0.1312238872051239,
0.9903315305709839,
0.2252466082572937,
-0.6677599549293518,
0.25042080879211426,
-0.014263156801462173,
-0.4056653678417206,
0.514516294002533,
-0.6767820119857788,
0.22125238180160522,
0.06904709339141846,
0.06895588338375092,
-1.209779977798462,
-0.010905790142714977,
0.21128302812576294,
-0.531780481338501,
0.07375109195709229,
0.26507189869880676,
-0.45106691122055054,
-0.25259286165237427,
-0.041063010692596436,
0.24945582449436188,
0.3136546015739441,
-0.008052164688706398,
0.5588383078575134,
0.6415310502052307,
0.12232403457164764,
-0.6191542744636536,
-0.8393546342849731,
0.2534075677394867,
-0.26538506150245667,
-0.7529246211051941,
0.23884651064872742,
-0.012540524825453758,
-0.5240091681480408,
-0.14423035085201263,
-0.4512156546115875,
-0.11070550978183746,
0.36405014991760254,
0.3585768938064575,
0.04002906382083893,
-0.13550612330436707,
0.14900395274162292,
-0.009280255064368248,
-0.1914869248867035,
0.3393190801143646,
0.06409350037574768,
0.6388072371482849,
-0.13048790395259857,
-0.2796383500099182,
-0.7343035936355591,
0.27828019857406616,
0.42437201738357544,
-0.04416335001587868,
0.38441336154937744,
0.2746790051460266,
-0.10068400949239731,
-0.02661905251443386,
-0.8035438060760498,
-0.004000366199761629,
-0.5431501269340515,
0.3048740327358246,
-0.6945664286613464,
-1.2360775470733643,
0.4954700469970703,
-0.09114973992109299,
0.12780097126960754,
0.44004136323928833,
0.37830841541290283,
-0.40946975350379944,
0.5333452820777893,
0.47144627571105957,
0.07166390120983124,
0.6795255541801453,
-0.05066535249352455,
-0.06366283446550369,
-0.6050835847854614,
-0.432266503572464,
-0.6151615381240845,
-0.41754212975502014,
-0.4445575475692749,
-0.242876335978508,
0.29246219992637634,
-0.040850602090358734,
0.05459749326109886,
0.3157077133655548,
-0.5135120153427124,
0.5140597820281982,
0.30019411444664,
0.3640686571598053,
0.687378466129303,
0.21243621408939362,
-0.1185796931385994,
0.1022873967885971,
-0.5429891347885132,
-0.9694215059280396,
0.9745526909828186,
0.6059170365333557,
0.8183708190917969,
-0.02766832523047924,
0.437635213136673,
0.5430895686149597,
0.3502417802810669,
-0.8428184986114502,
0.9538332223892212,
-0.2860514521598816,
-0.4372469484806061,
-0.42205342650413513,
-0.6006428003311157,
-1.0422099828720093,
0.24953943490982056,
-0.17526520788669586,
-0.614931583404541,
-0.129736065864563,
-0.008301489055156708,
-0.0297091007232666,
-0.06868400424718857,
-0.6735568642616272,
0.39862021803855896,
-0.17325811088085175,
0.14460112154483795,
-0.6831768751144409,
-0.6111713647842407,
0.45335620641708374,
-0.1781742125749588,
0.1130296140909195,
-0.13480322062969208,
-0.36366942524909973,
1.0449233055114746,
-0.04518750309944153,
0.8640375137329102,
-0.09377516806125641,
-0.21841900050640106,
0.38061070442199707,
-0.01942620798945427,
-0.05619990825653076,
-0.14118431508541107,
-0.3408994972705841,
0.3690386116504669,
0.25149649381637573,
-0.02774091809988022,
-0.2039608359336853,
0.4976342022418976,
-0.9542604088783264,
-0.6349387168884277,
-0.44956353306770325,
-0.569929838180542,
-0.25256645679473877,
0.03656737878918648,
0.15313118696212769,
0.38236039876937866,
-0.23187345266342163,
0.23719291388988495,
0.6613878011703491,
-0.17509135603904724,
0.414600670337677,
0.796027421951294,
-0.08589286357164383,
-0.13915960490703583,
0.44539207220077515,
0.06267232447862625,
0.40044674277305603,
0.6327285766601562,
-0.08975125849246979,
-0.31584203243255615,
-0.8051043152809143,
0.08534646034240723,
0.23286490142345428,
-0.6981972455978394,
-0.08457313477993011,
-0.6565510034561157,
-0.2990696132183075,
0.03761833533644676,
0.12899380922317505,
0.0916794016957283,
-0.3662104606628418,
-0.45005181431770325,
0.12582039833068848,
0.15615998208522797,
0.7632325887680054,
0.30159738659858704,
0.6335573196411133,
-0.733971357345581,
0.17047114670276642,
0.09824495762586594,
0.5394865870475769,
-0.17248153686523438,
-0.6207112669944763,
-0.35427767038345337,
-0.07064064592123032,
-0.3593698740005493,
-0.696476936340332,
-0.05055006965994835,
0.012710713781416416,
0.8658786416053772,
-0.06127485632896423,
-0.0892057940363884,
0.6918103098869324,
-0.3076552450656891,
0.645991325378418,
0.028360221534967422,
-1.2782477140426636,
0.3162372410297394,
-0.24213221669197083,
0.20965172350406647,
0.6992944478988647,
0.14053967595100403,
-0.6769545674324036,
-0.6639479994773865,
-0.2934798300266266,
-0.6166601181030273,
0.8446284532546997,
0.38312992453575134,
0.19054554402828217,
0.030107079073786736,
0.6018885970115662,
-0.2570660412311554,
0.14390525221824646,
-0.3349434733390808,
-0.1670670360326767,
0.08830078691244125,
-0.1304987072944641,
0.1896647810935974,
-0.5377751588821411,
0.012438247911632061,
0.014205115847289562,
0.30601489543914795,
0.17152197659015656,
0.4567757546901703,
0.4318591356277466,
-0.14566677808761597,
-0.033258017152547836,
0.39737191796302795,
0.8979194164276123,
0.9151125550270081,
-0.24582035839557648,
0.10480093955993652,
0.44981637597084045,
-0.7376822829246521,
-0.011214081197977066,
-0.1530701071023941,
0.2604416012763977,
-0.013279350474476814,
0.3861209750175476,
0.352455198764801,
0.16944520175457,
-0.8562043905258179,
0.2820998430252075,
-0.48434364795684814,
-0.36961713433265686,
-0.32723474502563477,
0.20393747091293335,
0.16268639266490936,
0.3422665596008301,
0.5005502104759216,
-0.15130655467510223,
0.29191964864730835,
-0.3874989151954651,
0.21869325637817383,
0.42841053009033203,
-0.21334801614284515,
-0.2186359316110611,
0.35605520009994507,
0.6633093357086182,
-0.43981367349624634,
0.4873606562614441,
0.06535161286592484,
-0.31635260581970215,
0.6153659224510193,
0.5640361309051514,
0.8096602559089661,
-0.21893329918384552,
-0.09666135162115097,
-0.03527849167585373,
0.4287020266056061,
0.18356077373027802,
0.5077353715896606,
-0.10186395794153214,
-0.671821117401123,
-0.6922751665115356,
-0.5469942092895508,
-0.3934307396411896,
0.0022578067146241665,
-0.4214155972003937,
0.17914626002311707,
-0.3809759020805359,
-0.5286433100700378,
-0.14921024441719055,
0.16892974078655243,
-0.5594140887260437,
0.3086805045604706,
0.06833110749721527,
1.2985565662384033,
-0.3991125226020813,
0.6524025201797485,
0.6976094841957092,
-0.03387110307812691,
-0.7010422348976135,
0.15754607319831848,
-0.04341811314225197,
-0.7674058079719543,
0.9840570688247681,
-0.1434096395969391,
-0.5966898798942566,
-0.05711580440402031,
-0.1549486219882965,
-0.8231388330459595,
1.353287935256958,
0.36119499802589417,
-0.836978554725647,
0.2670390009880066,
0.29438093304634094,
0.6714706420898438,
-0.09729571640491486,
0.3827238976955414,
0.6654969453811646,
0.48429906368255615,
0.224587544798851,
-1.4265199899673462,
0.07967356592416763,
-0.13646911084651947,
-0.13630518317222595,
0.0820457860827446,
-0.6713407039642334,
0.5249964594841003,
0.42342594265937805,
-0.5818023681640625,
-0.03199711814522743,
0.6800799369812012,
0.22994203865528107,
0.38611504435539246,
0.8631776571273804,
0.10276332497596741,
0.6536294221878052,
-0.08184858411550522,
0.9412796497344971,
-0.3217483162879944,
0.23653997480869293,
0.6657240390777588,
-0.15311194956302643,
0.7639955282211304,
0.5883137583732605,
-0.3454670011997223,
0.15661504864692688,
0.5814976096153259,
0.3582163453102112,
0.33884692192077637,
0.5597735047340393,
-0.43958914279937744,
-0.06648816168308258,
-0.2574630081653595,
-0.1072811633348465,
0.6663898825645447,
0.32051435112953186,
-0.3031924068927765,
-0.092088483273983,
-0.1998111605644226,
0.06097894534468651,
0.24129410088062286,
-0.320181667804718,
0.81573486328125,
0.233393132686615,
-0.6332135796546936,
0.4025309085845947,
0.2815971374511719,
0.9418421387672424,
-0.6399075984954834,
0.14086779952049255,
-0.1144045814871788,
0.13255096971988678,
-0.4804665744304657,
-1.0572230815887451,
0.8407248258590698,
0.4358516037464142,
-0.2023608535528183,
-0.38680458068847656,
0.8480868935585022,
0.011792718432843685,
-0.3422263264656067,
0.4013518691062927,
0.4187808930873871,
0.3783194124698639,
0.15972550213336945,
-0.4867653548717499,
0.4754204750061035,
-0.03662726283073425,
-0.3316701650619507,
0.09918978810310364,
0.46788105368614197,
0.001910485210828483,
0.6912173628807068,
0.5238924026489258,
0.0014669160591438413,
0.08928052335977554,
0.09048711508512497,
0.836127758026123,
-0.7454984188079834,
-0.28959059715270996,
-0.8566734194755554,
0.3399597704410553,
-0.13012294471263885,
-0.32342788577079773,
0.8629844188690186,
0.5808199048042297,
0.7736994624137878,
0.045860521495342255,
0.7039006352424622,
-0.19081994891166687,
0.43137478828430176,
-0.6328508853912354,
0.6006481051445007,
-0.3937857449054718,
0.5953320860862732,
-0.15385811030864716,
-0.7243297100067139,
-0.23940978944301605,
0.5181928873062134,
-0.3917359709739685,
-0.12666557729244232,
0.6734760999679565,
0.7244241237640381,
0.08466055244207382,
0.18003793060779572,
0.4266320765018463,
0.14926570653915405,
0.29994654655456543,
0.4851895868778229,
1.1689796447753906,
-0.18133750557899475,
0.7960154414176941,
-0.04116767644882202,
-0.26616209745407104,
-0.023388657718896866,
-0.7854236364364624,
-0.8794741630554199,
-0.3895920217037201,
0.050751637667417526,
-0.11976169794797897,
-0.04441114887595177,
0.844173789024353,
0.5307314395904541,
-0.4492768347263336,
-0.7807853817939758,
0.06822187453508377,
0.09616810083389282,
0.06010955572128296,
-0.24806059896945953,
-0.02412039041519165,
-0.5775285959243774,
-0.5859235525131226,
0.4457750618457794,
0.2344600111246109,
-0.22947582602500916,
-0.19997118413448334,
-0.09221426397562027,
-0.11773320287466049,
0.14070174098014832,
0.955209493637085,
0.011420822702348232,
-0.7664151787757874,
-0.261496365070343,
0.3382232189178467,
-0.35369840264320374,
-0.05372457206249237,
0.9760593175888062,
-0.7649151086807251,
0.17185476422309875,
0.6766480207443237,
0.6545302271842957,
0.43973320722579956,
0.13841411471366882,
0.5967288017272949,
-0.759972095489502,
-0.261126309633255,
0.09451655298471451,
0.19624915719032288,
0.09858589619398117,
-0.4538975954055786,
0.6211987137794495,
0.059643469750881195,
-0.8082606196403503,
-0.594502866268158,
0.04531099647283554,
-1.39100980758667,
-0.12524861097335815,
1.1687361001968384,
-0.08738122880458832,
0.026839183643460274,
-0.3595198392868042,
-0.5169224143028259,
0.28033149242401123,
-0.5005620121955872,
0.6839786767959595,
0.7061751484870911,
-0.3407173156738281,
-0.12909822165966034,
-0.758210301399231,
0.22859880328178406,
0.25359684228897095,
-1.0058653354644775,
-0.15708771347999573,
0.3462442457675934,
0.4025346338748932,
-0.01695151813328266,
1.0085057020187378,
-0.06524012982845306,
-0.038591042160987854,
-0.3732950985431671,
-0.18181321024894714,
-0.14580576121807098,
0.027302835136651993,
-0.43102753162384033,
0.19868500530719757,
0.12164857238531113,
-0.4137755036354065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14870v1
|
VidLA: Video-Language Alignment at Scale
| 2024-03-21T22:36:24 | 2024-03-21T22:36:24 |
Mamshad Nayeem Rizve, Fan Fei, Jayakrishnan Unnikrishnan, Son Tran, Benjamin Z. Yao, Belinda Zeng, Mubarak Shah, Trishul Chilimbi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we propose VidLA, an approach for video-language alignment at
scale. There are two major limitations of previous video-language alignment
approaches. First, they do not capture both short-range and long-range temporal
dependencies and typically employ complex hierarchical deep network
architectures that are hard to integrate with existing pretrained image-text
foundation models. To effectively address this limitation, we instead keep the
network architecture simple and use a set of data tokens that operate at
different temporal resolutions in a hierarchical manner, accounting for the
temporally hierarchical nature of videos. By employing a simple two-tower
architecture, we are able to initialize our video-language model with
pretrained image-text foundation models, thereby boosting the final
performance. Second, existing video-language alignment works struggle due to
the lack of semantically aligned large-scale training data. To overcome it, we
leverage recent LLMs to curate the largest video-language dataset to date with
better visual grounding. Furthermore, unlike existing video-text datasets which
only contain short clips, our dataset is enriched with video clips of varying
durations to aid our temporally hierarchical data tokens in extracting better
representations at varying temporal scales. Overall, empirical results show
that our proposed approach surpasses state-of-the-art methods on multiple
retrieval benchmarks, especially on longer videos, and performs competitively
on classification benchmarks.
|
[
-0.21607241034507751,
-0.716597318649292,
0.23729363083839417,
0.3575983941555023,
-0.3503330647945404,
0.19996744394302368,
-0.3572976887226105,
-0.23577986657619476,
0.41084524989128113,
0.14539389312267303,
-0.4150749146938324,
-0.3391035199165344,
-0.6874917149543762,
-0.37094050645828247,
-0.6135525703430176,
0.6778008937835693,
-0.10786488652229309,
0.10515863448381424,
0.0094655966386199,
-0.5293986797332764,
-0.49737247824668884,
-0.020198948681354523,
-0.3182503581047058,
-0.02003815397620201,
0.40716803073883057,
0.42119547724723816,
0.8600786328315735,
1.2129957675933838,
0.8458505868911743,
0.21242515742778778,
-0.11031579226255417,
0.26554250717163086,
-0.40452802181243896,
-0.3028489053249359,
0.0011884481646120548,
-0.010002261959016323,
-0.5853274464607239,
-0.3612193167209625,
1.062255859375,
0.4408789873123169,
-0.12806816399097443,
0.43085476756095886,
-0.24806778132915497,
0.8143162727355957,
-0.7969734072685242,
0.002941971179097891,
-0.738746166229248,
0.15727746486663818,
-0.37871089577674866,
-0.1706550121307373,
-0.1309756189584732,
-0.21203401684761047,
0.21397140622138977,
-0.47990885376930237,
0.07875280827283859,
-0.312902569770813,
1.1842052936553955,
0.5707184076309204,
-0.34731900691986084,
0.22174374759197235,
-0.7990200519561768,
0.5360943675041199,
-0.45967912673950195,
0.4153612554073334,
0.03634069487452507,
0.5715287327766418,
0.29534605145454407,
-0.5134402513504028,
-0.6052144169807434,
0.3839924931526184,
0.32137346267700195,
-0.1670430302619934,
-0.056143619120121,
-0.031475335359573364,
0.15075615048408508,
0.5263414978981018,
-0.6559510827064514,
0.40833139419555664,
-0.20074865221977234,
-0.045865949243307114,
0.3427834212779999,
0.326882928609848,
0.5036412477493286,
-0.04590983688831329,
-0.4480077624320984,
-0.16501028835773468,
-0.7510306239128113,
0.1956876814365387,
0.10299008339643478,
0.3881922662258148,
-0.2786829173564911,
0.8487764596939087,
-0.2390458732843399,
0.6401450634002686,
0.1946047693490982,
-0.25260934233665466,
0.3365315794944763,
-0.5916686058044434,
-0.5660327076911926,
0.2093278020620346,
0.9428619146347046,
0.688687801361084,
0.3878803849220276,
0.14376483857631683,
0.09585192054510117,
0.21862800419330597,
0.2433076798915863,
-1.0370055437088013,
-0.056089017540216446,
0.06228006258606911,
-0.29293540120124817,
-0.2517470419406891,
0.07765264064073563,
-0.9096492528915405,
-0.38828322291374207,
-0.3763149678707123,
0.43511801958084106,
-0.0563238151371479,
-0.2486201673746109,
-0.0985613539814949,
0.2907313406467438,
0.7626667022705078,
0.2578044831752777,
-1.302104115486145,
0.19217896461486816,
0.5035648941993713,
0.9276746511459351,
-0.19340743124485016,
-0.3496467173099518,
-0.8954582810401917,
0.2461966872215271,
-0.5220338106155396,
0.42352738976478577,
-0.5347725749015808,
0.11179152876138687,
0.4935001730918884,
0.09932902455329895,
0.30881425738334656,
-0.28271862864494324,
0.0613563098013401,
-0.5133841633796692,
0.05494324862957001,
-0.12459609657526016,
-0.24662113189697266,
0.14597967267036438,
0.18633395433425903,
-0.6624116897583008,
1.0918196439743042,
-0.2359682321548462,
-0.5500795245170593,
0.6317509412765503,
0.03283173218369484,
-0.3552154302597046,
-0.2050364464521408,
-0.6166478395462036,
-0.5942725539207458,
0.008407806977629662,
0.6130255460739136,
0.40715375542640686,
-0.2300252616405487,
0.59163498878479,
-0.1517573446035385,
-0.258280485868454,
-0.13957853615283966,
-0.6584914922714233,
0.4026108682155609,
0.006213675253093243,
-0.39186882972717285,
0.013030894100666046,
-0.8092797994613647,
0.011021306738257408,
-0.2164965271949768,
-0.11103203892707825,
0.025392062962055206,
0.19777728617191315,
0.1438671201467514,
0.18826495110988617,
0.5986928343772888,
-0.3789210915565491,
0.38075727224349976,
-0.35743817687034607,
0.2875625193119049,
0.7944874167442322,
-0.5110743045806885,
0.8244805335998535,
0.3037116825580597,
0.4584598243236542,
-0.11369962990283966,
0.25700223445892334,
-0.17305096983909607,
-0.14586104452610016,
-0.4325520694255829,
-0.22811980545520782,
0.0059568388387560844,
0.5381376147270203,
-0.6036863327026367,
0.15448075532913208,
-0.9955292344093323,
-0.35470816493034363,
-0.5604179501533508,
0.49032163619995117,
0.5406403541564941,
0.4108619689941406,
0.555155336856842,
-0.5517069697380066,
-0.6727662682533264,
-0.7655510306358337,
0.22959622740745544,
-0.33500295877456665,
0.16932529211044312,
0.19263093173503876,
0.056787338107824326,
-0.19605869054794312,
1.0954138040542603,
-0.4311193525791168,
-0.6289486289024353,
0.03362373635172844,
-0.07702850550413132,
0.2139274924993515,
0.3297666907310486,
0.49873995780944824,
-0.9709152579307556,
-0.5253998637199402,
0.574393630027771,
-0.8308410048484802,
-0.029280584305524826,
-0.1072189137339592,
0.14807139337062836,
-0.051408737897872925,
0.6535430550575256,
-0.4938723146915436,
0.33930668234825134,
0.8008307814598083,
-0.1958678662776947,
0.3142032027244568,
-0.11719142645597458,
0.007791497278958559,
-1.1886197328567505,
-0.2079225480556488,
-0.14353996515274048,
-0.2086428850889206,
-0.39288151264190674,
-0.335032194852829,
-0.015787841752171516,
-0.06096429005265236,
-0.5821884274482727,
0.5462154150009155,
-0.4447604715824127,
-0.4615119397640228,
-0.19085267186164856,
0.22966250777244568,
-0.11611597239971161,
0.47500136494636536,
0.18602629005908966,
0.9587889909744263,
0.7376161813735962,
-0.308036208152771,
0.41350120306015015,
0.23308144509792328,
-0.30534452199935913,
0.5093023777008057,
-0.5631229877471924,
-0.2267843633890152,
-0.13318242132663727,
0.013208637945353985,
-0.9644889235496521,
-0.3577997088432312,
-0.144333615899086,
-0.37176719307899475,
0.48462703824043274,
-0.2897322475910187,
-0.15383324027061462,
-0.014286607503890991,
-0.3123154938220978,
0.7991778254508972,
0.4077679216861725,
-0.7466006875038147,
0.7921008467674255,
0.5858289003372192,
-0.11220519244670868,
-1.180435299873352,
-0.6336043477058411,
0.3635757863521576,
-0.41123077273368835,
-0.6011040806770325,
0.6314380764961243,
0.11339067667722702,
-0.07537147402763367,
-0.07861466705799103,
-0.41674941778182983,
-0.3090518116950989,
-0.29457932710647583,
0.28384846448898315,
0.14756183326244354,
-0.6481265425682068,
0.0817924439907074,
-0.06421311944723129,
-0.006247001234441996,
-0.1840081512928009,
-0.33416882157325745,
0.3004411458969116,
-0.33439359068870544,
-0.09187266230583191,
-0.6104387044906616,
0.2586638033390045,
0.8052759170532227,
-0.36722332239151,
0.53781658411026,
0.7936517596244812,
-0.46134209632873535,
0.11903580278158188,
-0.5866428017616272,
0.41697800159454346,
-0.4273526072502136,
0.48717617988586426,
-0.18185555934906006,
-0.9153417944908142,
0.2951888144016266,
0.046437278389930725,
0.09677710384130478,
0.15203210711479187,
0.7562590837478638,
-0.26019468903541565,
0.8759813904762268,
0.8174405097961426,
-0.3719825744628906,
1.1291128396987915,
-0.27864497900009155,
0.13872291147708893,
-0.5515701770782471,
-0.13720755279064178,
-0.2809008061885834,
-0.18507038056850433,
-0.5214827060699463,
-0.6362234950065613,
0.0885498970746994,
0.1306622475385666,
-0.29738864302635193,
0.5510144233703613,
-0.18916139006614685,
0.8123537302017212,
-0.19707544147968292,
-0.15303832292556763,
0.01900804415345192,
0.22983981668949127,
0.24097299575805664,
-0.3195233643054962,
-0.4992775619029999,
-0.4676085114479065,
0.9386296272277832,
0.44747406244277954,
0.8029546737670898,
0.46382880210876465,
0.3865113854408264,
0.2566283047199249,
0.030277855694293976,
-0.8239864706993103,
0.4433046877384186,
-0.6522949934005737,
-0.18197187781333923,
-0.5507031083106995,
-0.1144791916012764,
-0.7554847002029419,
0.196142315864563,
-0.07258496433496475,
-0.8279356360435486,
0.13275155425071716,
0.1163933128118515,
-0.26756706833839417,
0.22741323709487915,
-0.5861013531684875,
0.961572527885437,
-0.3328627347946167,
-0.6001611351966858,
-0.021149029955267906,
-0.9359700083732605,
0.13849449157714844,
0.07627652585506439,
0.3624587059020996,
-0.015053046867251396,
0.04196374863386154,
0.5377023816108704,
-0.5598610043525696,
0.9295364022254944,
0.008073147386312485,
-0.2384951263666153,
0.2593352198600769,
-0.15864986181259155,
0.36860984563827515,
0.12042581290006638,
0.4253695011138916,
-0.19157305359840393,
-0.09885481745004654,
-0.5148088932037354,
-0.6738424897193909,
0.566588819026947,
-0.7899948358535767,
-0.38173168897628784,
-0.10405832529067993,
-0.3450991213321686,
-0.11358474940061569,
0.22522421181201935,
-0.047082845121622086,
0.7421647310256958,
-0.3999917507171631,
0.49530845880508423,
0.8404120206832886,
0.032641712576150894,
0.6430237293243408,
0.16776511073112488,
-0.4439331591129303,
-0.6426286101341248,
1.1608835458755493,
-0.0874847024679184,
0.3496745526790619,
0.8831613659858704,
-0.08842644095420837,
-0.26756805181503296,
-0.6514317393302917,
-0.6762239336967468,
0.012886141426861286,
-0.7875505685806274,
-0.21559906005859375,
-0.38023316860198975,
-0.15116794407367706,
-0.41275715827941895,
-0.27469485998153687,
-0.7510221600532532,
-0.2471546083688736,
-0.39098212122917175,
-0.39382365345954895,
0.19226711988449097,
0.37818554043769836,
0.1270117610692978,
0.5620281100273132,
-0.6864591836929321,
0.6447929739952087,
0.5394223928451538,
0.30696770548820496,
-0.34601181745529175,
-0.5796765685081482,
-0.4961698055267334,
-0.29234597086906433,
-0.03519245609641075,
-0.5189962387084961,
0.23492160439491272,
0.523080587387085,
0.20368355512619019,
0.5591221451759338,
-0.6418339014053345,
1.208941102027893,
-0.7451204657554626,
0.985669732093811,
0.4363759756088257,
-0.9097444415092468,
0.5429064035415649,
-0.3462558090686798,
0.2824767231941223,
0.5882440805435181,
0.00435835774987936,
-0.2970867156982422,
-0.07772370427846909,
-0.23011940717697144,
-0.9124257564544678,
0.23779267072677612,
0.13852404057979584,
0.1966443508863449,
0.07375425845384598,
0.20586051046848297,
-0.12101805955171585,
-0.07033654302358627,
-0.6528530716896057,
-0.09371552616357803,
-0.35310909152030945,
-0.3468745946884155,
-0.1662992238998413,
-0.14411889016628265,
-0.05304526537656784,
-0.23736146092414856,
0.40191444754600525,
-0.5918416976928711,
-0.15838690102100372,
0.07949960976839066,
-0.4275287091732025,
-0.21669597923755646,
0.034520793706178665,
0.5217565894126892,
0.7188881635665894,
-0.19696518778800964,
0.10375893115997314,
0.18878276646137238,
-0.6867244839668274,
0.3921414315700531,
-0.14070077240467072,
0.08570091426372528,
-0.05269492417573929,
0.5703909397125244,
0.845992386341095,
0.2484295517206192,
-0.7192533016204834,
0.7774307727813721,
-0.07892946898937225,
-0.013308781199157238,
-0.32479026913642883,
-0.30361267924308777,
-0.1084057167172432,
0.3739819824695587,
0.19431816041469574,
-0.1196393072605133,
-0.31606364250183105,
-0.4303855895996094,
0.41003915667533875,
0.44783517718315125,
-0.5051803588867188,
-0.3667348623275757,
0.831845223903656,
0.12429247051477432,
-0.2785842716693878,
0.5046350359916687,
0.29452964663505554,
-0.22359290719032288,
0.7739865183830261,
0.14636099338531494,
0.9726840257644653,
-0.037413690239191055,
0.3574061691761017,
0.3081711530685425,
0.33216652274131775,
-0.2920134961605072,
0.20373478531837463,
-0.14508849382400513,
-0.7022600769996643,
-0.8132782578468323,
-0.6838427186012268,
-0.1420001983642578,
-0.06051758676767349,
-0.8056050539016724,
0.4683666527271271,
-0.541549801826477,
-0.10095169395208359,
-0.0928480476140976,
-0.07677556574344635,
-0.699455976486206,
0.419918417930603,
0.4982220232486725,
0.9020653367042542,
-1.041788935661316,
1.226073980331421,
0.4798353910446167,
-0.44916582107543945,
-0.7852692008018494,
-0.16729938983917236,
0.07172620296478271,
-0.7804161906242371,
0.8340614438056946,
0.2673552930355072,
-0.40929102897644043,
-0.16095642745494843,
-0.4279264509677887,
-0.9487143754959106,
1.421191930770874,
0.28461840748786926,
-0.6480532288551331,
-0.2814251184463501,
0.1999620944261551,
0.8025259971618652,
-0.6507927775382996,
-0.12687429785728455,
0.5666263699531555,
0.13653935492038727,
0.17256233096122742,
-1.0191971063613892,
-0.2864908277988434,
-0.24147038161754608,
0.21866652369499207,
0.307765394449234,
-0.6392197012901306,
0.5751484632492065,
-0.21899092197418213,
-0.1804603934288025,
0.134599506855011,
1.1407763957977295,
-0.280911922454834,
0.2002951204776764,
0.34971266984939575,
0.7422090768814087,
0.5135710835456848,
0.0782226100564003,
0.6574082374572754,
0.06589606404304504,
0.37660452723503113,
1.2894383668899536,
-0.16064518690109253,
0.9582664370536804,
0.9527596235275269,
-0.21881088614463806,
0.39727118611335754,
0.4288598895072937,
0.10739606618881226,
0.6116241216659546,
-0.01386319100856781,
-0.0765329897403717,
-0.39302629232406616,
-0.38543060421943665,
-0.32657894492149353,
0.5998710989952087,
0.36675283312797546,
-0.20599806308746338,
-0.2338452786207199,
-0.11916239559650421,
-0.27686232328414917,
0.2651318609714508,
-0.36846858263015747,
0.7180103659629822,
-0.15918275713920593,
-0.32169777154922485,
0.40784212946891785,
-0.4870469570159912,
0.42435628175735474,
-0.5686588883399963,
0.07554750144481659,
-0.28637629747390747,
0.09244108200073242,
-0.28684887290000916,
-0.7270486950874329,
0.2346341460943222,
0.3872380554676056,
-0.3139597773551941,
-0.33095306158065796,
0.2115083485841751,
-0.5945900678634644,
-0.3065522611141205,
0.2793058454990387,
0.37364643812179565,
-0.05837107449769974,
0.40848425030708313,
-0.3736550509929657,
0.3459587097167969,
-0.21378439664840698,
-0.07213829457759857,
0.4411909282207489,
0.6000758409500122,
-0.30660539865493774,
0.5586312413215637,
0.2646842896938324,
0.06660761684179306,
0.2136414349079132,
0.2683046758174896,
0.7635548114776611,
-0.6801343560218811,
-0.22440098226070404,
-1.0070762634277344,
0.46698808670043945,
0.12501265108585358,
-0.3087705075740814,
0.39774778485298157,
0.5508973598480225,
0.8560133576393127,
0.14316698908805847,
0.3741098940372467,
-0.12066517025232315,
-0.3901091516017914,
-0.9986289143562317,
0.09214188158512115,
-0.6990401148796082,
0.2891634404659271,
-0.4494725167751312,
-1.0146034955978394,
-0.43735837936401367,
0.24711506068706512,
-0.03179916366934776,
-0.45990902185440063,
0.6241742372512817,
0.8368656039237976,
-0.06036713719367981,
-0.3195357024669647,
0.1940537393093109,
0.21409972012043,
0.6725373268127441,
0.6649603843688965,
0.6664935946464539,
-0.6349408030509949,
0.8470181226730347,
-0.10421823710203171,
-0.18640735745429993,
-0.1869862973690033,
-1.1886407136917114,
-0.8373282551765442,
-0.6292072534561157,
-0.33217206597328186,
-0.10369963943958282,
0.05811270698904991,
0.7655625939369202,
0.6378211379051208,
-0.5539082884788513,
-0.3845329284667969,
0.08571792393922806,
0.10138067603111267,
-0.40599432587623596,
-0.17508088052272797,
0.47110825777053833,
-0.018755532801151276,
-0.7474176287651062,
0.5308224558830261,
0.5196970105171204,
0.08306766301393509,
-0.3029557764530182,
-0.06787411868572235,
-0.2130567580461502,
-0.23915019631385803,
0.6120139360427856,
0.6310374736785889,
-0.8339225053787231,
-0.6178880333900452,
0.018722977489233017,
-0.34679970145225525,
0.4381101429462433,
0.9079695343971252,
-0.7384575605392456,
0.6863320469856262,
0.6054852604866028,
1.1052111387252808,
0.6012344360351562,
0.16269128024578094,
0.6404703259468079,
-0.9757247567176819,
0.25776177644729614,
-0.07862810045480728,
0.4289185106754303,
0.35662636160850525,
-0.24917493760585785,
0.44443535804748535,
0.019396493211388588,
-0.2847040891647339,
-0.7965118885040283,
0.21039021015167236,
-1.499490737915039,
0.02062084525823593,
1.0843570232391357,
0.04955495148897171,
-0.27471303939819336,
0.28785645961761475,
-0.17267395555973053,
0.22659316658973694,
-0.13677066564559937,
0.6780548095703125,
0.7649859189987183,
0.3172336220741272,
-0.21776321530342102,
-0.4291667938232422,
0.36786752939224243,
0.5611589550971985,
-0.6292421221733093,
0.2633417248725891,
0.5233237147331238,
0.10229529440402985,
0.1809106022119522,
0.7520155906677246,
-0.21495848894119263,
0.49930670857429504,
-0.1846124827861786,
-0.22560842335224152,
0.21490785479545593,
-0.9012062549591064,
-0.6237399578094482,
0.1397426277399063,
-0.1200597807765007,
-0.37756630778312683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15502v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15502v2
|
Sequential Decision-Making for Inline Text Autocomplete
| 2024-03-21T22:33:16 | 2024-06-15T18:02:51 |
Rohan Chitnis, Shentao Yang, Alborz Geramifard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Autocomplete suggestions are fundamental to modern text entry systems, with
applications in domains such as messaging and email composition. Typically,
autocomplete suggestions are generated from a language model with a confidence
threshold. However, this threshold does not directly take into account the
cognitive load imposed on the user by surfacing suggestions, such as the effort
to switch contexts from typing to reading the suggestion, and the time to
decide whether to accept the suggestion. In this paper, we study the problem of
improving inline autocomplete suggestions in text entry systems via a
sequential decision-making formulation, and use reinforcement learning to learn
suggestion policies through repeated interactions with a target user over time.
This formulation allows us to factor cognitive load into the objective of
training an autocomplete model, through a reward function based on text entry
speed. We acquired theoretical and experimental evidence that, under certain
objectives, the sequential decision-making formulation of the autocomplete
problem provides a better suggestion policy than myopic single-step reasoning.
However, aligning these objectives with real users requires further
exploration. In particular, we hypothesize that the objectives under which
sequential decision-making can improve autocomplete systems are not tailored
solely to text entry speed, but more broadly to metrics such as user
satisfaction and convenience.
|
[
-0.4140394330024719,
-0.7682058215141296,
1.1210389137268066,
0.45425382256507874,
-0.18935851752758026,
0.19293929636478424,
-0.5331864356994629,
-0.4450313448905945,
0.17480625212192535,
0.09196498245000839,
-0.70292067527771,
0.1250540167093277,
-0.5508981943130493,
0.4524267315864563,
-0.30275243520736694,
0.708106279373169,
-0.510297954082489,
-0.24550305306911469,
-0.19390718638896942,
0.08757492154836655,
-0.9644892811775208,
-0.21890510618686676,
-0.9956173300743103,
-0.33165472745895386,
0.7949104309082031,
0.489975243806839,
0.7416219115257263,
0.3661003112792969,
0.12759336829185486,
0.3569064736366272,
0.15453733503818512,
0.2864721715450287,
-0.17456254363059998,
0.39773887395858765,
-0.3072594404220581,
-0.2469816654920578,
0.0909452885389328,
-0.03720581531524658,
0.5785549879074097,
0.3817746937274933,
-0.21819573640823364,
-0.2046397179365158,
0.21380266547203064,
0.4057869017124176,
-0.7727307677268982,
0.028081582859158516,
-0.3938674032688141,
0.07323255389928818,
0.07301020622253418,
-0.5598903894424438,
-0.606964111328125,
-0.2828502058982849,
0.6299525499343872,
-0.7468100190162659,
-0.2332739233970642,
0.33077141642570496,
0.30329981446266174,
0.4574134945869446,
-0.28718703985214233,
-0.5705810189247131,
-0.7920413613319397,
0.4467175006866455,
-0.25669005513191223,
0.25650709867477417,
0.5476897954940796,
0.015094946138560772,
-0.15373224020004272,
-0.3274977207183838,
-0.5572560429573059,
-0.2542355954647064,
-0.30105361342430115,
-0.02618909440934658,
0.013202732428908348,
0.23907287418842316,
0.21776069700717926,
-0.10229148715734482,
-0.542790949344635,
-0.030691983178257942,
-0.05687733367085457,
0.13507923483848572,
0.7669114470481873,
0.05749215930700302,
0.16392403841018677,
-0.1042766124010086,
-0.3951685130596161,
-0.22101515531539917,
-0.03136468306183815,
0.518132746219635,
0.007908953353762627,
0.12698720395565033,
0.18040457367897034,
0.3119730055332184,
-0.6041616797447205,
0.6480771899223328,
0.4929140508174896,
0.192123681306839,
0.15186522901058197,
-0.5281065106391907,
-0.08648396283388138,
0.09610091894865036,
0.823752760887146,
0.14187735319137573,
0.29241302609443665,
-0.0966753214597702,
-0.10289691388607025,
-0.42979714274406433,
0.5301809310913086,
-0.5103248357772827,
-0.019921015948057175,
0.41843289136886597,
-0.43795713782310486,
-0.40367841720581055,
0.26183825731277466,
-0.08989236503839493,
-0.03218163177371025,
-0.49249887466430664,
0.6127451062202454,
-0.5450587868690491,
0.11689865589141846,
0.030849725008010864,
-0.20346340537071228,
-0.334187775850296,
0.5152903199195862,
-1.0121612548828125,
0.37288805842399597,
0.21974340081214905,
0.7623113989830017,
-0.45980527997016907,
-0.42493736743927,
-0.3909023702144623,
-0.07764644920825958,
-0.2411908507347107,
0.9088422060012817,
-0.6275256276130676,
-0.7213336229324341,
-0.12583835422992706,
-0.07497459650039673,
-0.19638659060001373,
-0.2300610989332199,
0.2714258134365082,
-0.49459367990493774,
0.13877901434898376,
-0.2005625218153,
-0.46275895833969116,
0.07032337039709091,
-0.15420617163181305,
-0.4030129313468933,
1.1257576942443848,
-0.13731341063976288,
-0.42896798253059387,
0.8414150476455688,
-0.31820058822631836,
-0.5558347105979919,
0.4651653468608856,
-0.28691697120666504,
-0.2644531726837158,
0.1586305797100067,
0.20682325959205627,
0.2753247916698456,
0.20884504914283752,
0.42496970295906067,
-0.2135770469903946,
-0.42056456208229065,
0.2739292085170746,
-0.10732195526361465,
0.4462467432022095,
0.03674604743719101,
-0.46641841530799866,
0.031091518700122833,
-0.2634618282318115,
0.27983957529067993,
-0.10057725757360458,
-0.3853285312652588,
-0.5498116612434387,
0.260437935590744,
-0.17204119265079498,
0.3005914092063904,
0.447238951921463,
-0.22754932940006256,
0.43332234025001526,
-0.02881939336657524,
0.05827217549085617,
0.8147810697555542,
0.12254234403371811,
0.5016886591911316,
-0.5063549280166626,
0.2645045816898346,
-0.2101491540670395,
0.15970654785633087,
-0.1579924076795578,
-0.4602971076965332,
-0.6355031728744507,
0.05041777715086937,
0.41924822330474854,
0.7453045845031738,
-1.0385502576828003,
0.7455154657363892,
0.20036223530769348,
-0.0642937570810318,
-0.2906820774078369,
0.1596134752035141,
0.3372037708759308,
0.10794675350189209,
0.4727325439453125,
-0.4588926434516907,
-0.4811994135379791,
-0.5539712309837341,
-0.3678681254386902,
-0.3106592297554016,
-0.005227946676313877,
0.44360625743865967,
0.5149699449539185,
-0.00954069197177887,
1.1658955812454224,
-0.617914617061615,
-0.14244727790355682,
-0.112319715321064,
0.5545955896377563,
-0.21608445048332214,
0.4035418927669525,
0.04632638022303581,
-0.7934009432792664,
-0.5524416565895081,
-0.31711071729660034,
-0.3980239927768707,
-0.009170571342110634,
-0.5542294383049011,
-0.11474960297346115,
0.12040439993143082,
0.4635866582393646,
-0.36885443329811096,
0.5713221430778503,
0.03015897609293461,
-0.2776508331298828,
0.46862050890922546,
-0.7573254704475403,
0.08437590301036835,
-0.4894742965698242,
-0.12379243969917297,
0.11323025822639465,
-0.21130751073360443,
-0.21789196133613586,
-0.33012548089027405,
0.1897306591272354,
0.2528039216995239,
-0.03328471630811691,
0.5406599044799805,
-0.1135798841714859,
0.09405270218849182,
-0.5308384299278259,
0.06448513269424438,
-0.30682963132858276,
0.6162936091423035,
0.5345704555511475,
0.7291999459266663,
0.12261296063661575,
-0.894088089466095,
0.023263653740286827,
0.19234268367290497,
-0.11993332952260971,
0.49850738048553467,
-0.5650627613067627,
-0.05273113772273064,
-0.1750832051038742,
0.7252344489097595,
-1.0239819288253784,
-0.035628244280815125,
0.1522527039051056,
-0.5136632323265076,
0.011669853702187538,
0.33549612760543823,
-0.38378337025642395,
-0.5417203307151794,
-0.22574275732040405,
0.6463309526443481,
0.4838571846485138,
-0.5097449421882629,
0.2994982600212097,
0.05969059839844704,
-0.42738446593284607,
-0.5018287301063538,
-0.34358730912208557,
-0.12789294123649597,
0.25692519545555115,
-0.14059825241565704,
0.7076073884963989,
-0.35233134031295776,
0.18501673638820648,
0.08558288216590881,
-0.04140756279230118,
0.10519543290138245,
0.12623223662376404,
0.07979875057935715,
0.31584471464157104,
0.6282697916030884,
0.3779257833957672,
0.13727015256881714,
-0.23837225139141083,
-0.0018443525768816471,
-0.6895795464515686,
0.3008274734020233,
0.1765124350786209,
0.2194676697254181,
-0.4778045415878296,
0.37769845128059387,
0.010254118591547012,
-0.03539903089404106,
0.4700043499469757,
0.32232359051704407,
-0.04615086689591408,
-0.4892483055591583,
-0.5640352964401245,
-0.19736939668655396,
-0.4872005581855774,
-0.0012083894107490778,
-0.3801417052745819,
-0.8050029873847961,
-0.01524040475487709,
0.05906928330659866,
0.0604596771299839,
0.2747512459754944,
0.41580721735954285,
-0.4270670413970947,
1.210469365119934,
0.5632778406143188,
0.04510597884654999,
0.8413514494895935,
-0.06296421587467194,
-0.05968369543552399,
-0.5870876908302307,
-0.24761809408664703,
-0.2010381519794464,
-0.5124862790107727,
-0.5886104106903076,
-0.2132437378168106,
0.35903599858283997,
-0.1986997127532959,
0.06098504364490509,
0.4542595148086548,
-0.6288104057312012,
0.23996105790138245,
0.774562418460846,
0.3893758952617645,
0.3057634234428406,
-0.19916023313999176,
-0.6370807886123657,
0.22505249083042145,
-0.8984725475311279,
0.10752752423286438,
0.7977912425994873,
0.04412376508116722,
0.5184893608093262,
-0.29795801639556885,
1.0189021825790405,
0.3969998061656952,
0.021387344226241112,
-0.8658488392829895,
0.4026404917240143,
0.01332023460417986,
-0.22715917229652405,
-0.4116974472999573,
-0.450197696685791,
-1.0145288705825806,
0.059437140822410583,
-0.22865226864814758,
-0.7040100693702698,
0.39318448305130005,
0.3133421838283539,
-0.8044008016586304,
-0.21190504729747772,
-0.2767113447189331,
0.4975782334804535,
-0.5819973349571228,
-0.4706762731075287,
-0.43427619338035583,
-0.5744198560714722,
0.07566932588815689,
0.09223327040672302,
0.16547730565071106,
0.18568308651447296,
-0.24875923991203308,
0.7077068090438843,
-0.5227818489074707,
0.5581073760986328,
0.06153678148984909,
0.006401377730071545,
0.1925957202911377,
-0.04381110891699791,
0.6291742920875549,
0.14035238325595856,
0.31969404220581055,
-0.2909422516822815,
-0.13825459778308868,
-0.04145386815071106,
-0.7161973118782043,
0.4938391149044037,
-0.5821758508682251,
-0.3704804480075836,
-0.6794781684875488,
-0.42249974608421326,
-0.1706453412771225,
0.14562948048114777,
0.395708829164505,
0.4075735807418823,
-0.05224733054637909,
0.0817929357290268,
0.6449670195579529,
-0.025004155933856964,
0.6470879316329956,
0.47674164175987244,
-0.19584619998931885,
-0.4618054926395416,
0.8769679069519043,
0.3101940155029297,
0.17854104936122894,
0.40594619512557983,
0.0804780125617981,
-0.5909935832023621,
-0.3258333206176758,
-0.3458467721939087,
-0.07523714005947113,
-0.22431908547878265,
0.026744842529296875,
-0.5750513672828674,
-0.1264004111289978,
-0.14889588952064514,
-0.46650728583335876,
0.015917697921395302,
-0.3988880515098572,
-0.11316724866628647,
0.13129159808158875,
0.3567889928817749,
0.603495717048645,
-0.05220617353916168,
0.3636305332183838,
-0.2799556851387024,
0.4108060598373413,
0.30264249444007874,
0.5285784006118774,
0.14922073483467102,
-0.299498975276947,
-0.3176615536212921,
-0.20460447669029236,
-0.39327651262283325,
-0.601614773273468,
0.34412920475006104,
-0.16606582701206207,
0.38620465993881226,
0.15361528098583221,
0.22887194156646729,
0.459121435880661,
-0.6319952011108398,
0.4121895134449005,
0.10101256519556046,
-0.6648995876312256,
0.6425657868385315,
-0.1587716042995453,
0.6830583214759827,
1.0544850826263428,
0.6357243061065674,
-0.640145480632782,
-0.3862893283367157,
-0.8695906400680542,
-0.8272368907928467,
0.8585836887359619,
0.3025272786617279,
-0.32639262080192566,
-0.060495417565107346,
0.1633491963148117,
0.046256184577941895,
0.44253042340278625,
-0.47953274846076965,
-0.3004281520843506,
0.15942925214767456,
-0.1669446974992752,
-0.1332196593284607,
0.011184018105268478,
0.36219534277915955,
-0.31907889246940613,
0.6709380745887756,
-0.0988694280385971,
0.22269584238529205,
0.48275497555732727,
-0.23920662701129913,
-0.08602102845907211,
0.16148003935813904,
0.40540242195129395,
0.17599204182624817,
-0.30077505111694336,
-0.27743497490882874,
0.12261299043893814,
-0.2445991039276123,
0.3647424578666687,
0.39643922448158264,
-0.4944898784160614,
0.031644344329833984,
-0.20881476998329163,
0.803351640701294,
0.7092259526252747,
-0.5183278918266296,
0.2967468500137329,
-0.3466784656047821,
-0.1815086305141449,
-0.5815960764884949,
0.3046473264694214,
-0.44054147601127625,
0.055616721510887146,
0.5334952473640442,
0.13036321103572845,
0.33501046895980835,
-0.5308070778846741,
0.4728621244430542,
0.5664914846420288,
-0.29155415296554565,
0.3377937972545624,
0.4360050857067108,
0.5279352068901062,
-0.37161773443222046,
0.45375651121139526,
-0.3528859615325928,
-0.4713064432144165,
0.36094367504119873,
0.2546224892139435,
1.0782999992370605,
-0.161690354347229,
0.31580594182014465,
0.4737621247768402,
0.06466192752122879,
-0.5757503509521484,
0.012416568584740162,
-0.7412104606628418,
-0.5359376668930054,
-0.32542088627815247,
-0.3431263566017151,
-0.535671591758728,
-0.3282179534435272,
-0.4786641597747803,
0.33849093317985535,
-0.5892002582550049,
-0.4876497685909271,
-0.14971721172332764,
0.24070991575717926,
-0.6339051127433777,
0.2874396741390228,
0.3685797154903412,
0.8467974066734314,
-0.19878186285495758,
0.6646080017089844,
0.3266482949256897,
-0.6156933903694153,
-0.6048394441604614,
0.11552150547504425,
0.08115358650684357,
-0.6693516373634338,
0.7702327370643616,
0.08193791657686234,
-0.24310950934886932,
-0.03893174231052399,
-0.23869650065898895,
-1.0188229084014893,
1.1555557250976562,
-0.6214720606803894,
-0.5686423778533936,
-0.6050598621368408,
-0.25415506958961487,
0.14021141827106476,
-0.5466243624687195,
0.848301351070404,
0.6474829316139221,
0.49399951100349426,
0.0471651516854763,
-1.0520548820495605,
0.21537093818187714,
-0.09104412794113159,
0.33587801456451416,
0.3167772889137268,
-0.6616136431694031,
0.6246341466903687,
-0.22780749201774597,
-0.09874968975782394,
0.2975677251815796,
0.5143563747406006,
0.2184518426656723,
0.15533801913261414,
0.6774256229400635,
0.4845201373100281,
0.6642736792564392,
0.09870591014623642,
1.2887665033340454,
-0.2658814489841461,
0.15303221344947815,
1.279780626296997,
-0.1468447744846344,
1.0093528032302856,
0.2795300781726837,
-0.0386299230158329,
0.8032479882240295,
0.7061665654182434,
0.2050197273492813,
0.602762758731842,
-0.06172686442732811,
-0.22044573724269867,
-0.11083715409040451,
0.018216518685221672,
-0.11349041759967804,
0.09016526490449905,
0.5591465830802917,
-0.37435561418533325,
-0.08884871751070023,
0.02002502791583538,
-0.17162416875362396,
-0.1712026596069336,
-0.2563207447528839,
1.024665117263794,
-0.026540683582425117,
-1.3354690074920654,
0.6012521386146545,
-0.03642193228006363,
0.9383078217506409,
-0.6630105376243591,
0.12238587439060211,
0.1667080819606781,
0.004132433794438839,
-0.233295738697052,
-0.8163209557533264,
-0.18760491907596588,
-0.2647993266582489,
-0.20715612173080444,
-0.6305528283119202,
0.6249557733535767,
-0.7372525334358215,
-0.18348124623298645,
0.219512477517128,
0.17345842719078064,
-0.24560223519802094,
0.023700272664427757,
-0.8969644904136658,
0.006599928718060255,
-0.09304389357566833,
-0.0722634345293045,
0.1855064332485199,
0.1279798001050949,
0.05132945626974106,
0.6135678291320801,
0.5797093510627747,
0.1268196403980255,
-0.33255207538604736,
-0.4401901364326477,
0.49579477310180664,
-0.6496165990829468,
-0.893713653087616,
-0.6768960952758789,
0.5020689964294434,
-0.27282118797302246,
-0.3168320655822754,
0.5848144292831421,
0.24244624376296997,
1.0868247747421265,
0.16765567660331726,
1.1292930841445923,
-0.19826774299144745,
0.16153879463672638,
-0.6500855088233948,
0.2964473068714142,
-0.4776667356491089,
0.1325567215681076,
-0.18063786625862122,
-0.6914456486701965,
0.2597948908805847,
0.738061249256134,
-0.6133257150650024,
0.2404807060956955,
1.1016868352890015,
0.17790059745311737,
0.2379646897315979,
0.14374731481075287,
0.004247030708938837,
-0.14254817366600037,
-0.1811331808567047,
0.8051693439483643,
0.6602879166603088,
-0.21347813308238983,
0.3930969536304474,
-0.3725370168685913,
-0.36268460750579834,
-0.679519772529602,
-0.702072262763977,
-0.47419849038124084,
-0.8162579536437988,
-0.24868644773960114,
-0.14330650866031647,
0.24263349175453186,
1.3327929973602295,
0.6571493744850159,
-0.45708367228507996,
-0.4225548207759857,
-0.32489535212516785,
0.14884257316589355,
-0.33991965651512146,
-0.25673970580101013,
-0.06280846893787384,
-0.9423388838768005,
-0.44216886162757874,
0.2804800271987915,
0.2679213583469391,
0.05919075757265091,
-0.04475732520222664,
-0.08589514344930649,
-0.4220191538333893,
0.24230650067329407,
0.5248785018920898,
0.5726363658905029,
-0.6887213587760925,
-0.2735803723335266,
-0.11433499306440353,
-0.1433485597372055,
-0.02819308638572693,
1.2812368869781494,
-1.3215819597244263,
0.6473817229270935,
0.4208616614341736,
0.8121710419654846,
0.4508329927921295,
0.22966378927230835,
0.8259184956550598,
-0.5629982948303223,
0.019859403371810913,
0.060717493295669556,
0.18545657396316528,
-0.19145813584327698,
-0.5607191324234009,
0.24996067583560944,
0.10180521011352539,
-0.6527161598205566,
-0.24624225497245789,
0.025898532941937447,
-0.7881684303283691,
-0.40252819657325745,
0.990036129951477,
0.3173789381980896,
-0.13574989140033722,
-0.2239532321691513,
-0.530607283115387,
-0.09216698259115219,
-0.9810385704040527,
0.7216567397117615,
0.8264213800430298,
-0.6312804222106934,
-0.06937067210674286,
-0.4325968027114868,
0.9997991919517517,
0.7985551357269287,
-0.5832092761993408,
-0.06302175670862198,
0.610256552696228,
-0.18716385960578918,
0.0519963838160038,
0.8759651184082031,
0.355630487203598,
0.6452868580818176,
-0.41584494709968567,
-0.29510498046875,
0.15137284994125366,
-0.7086934447288513,
-0.2377224713563919,
-0.08763882517814636,
0.07700300961732864,
0.02441353350877762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14859v1
|
Comparing Plausibility Estimates in Base and Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models
| 2024-03-21T22:08:44 | 2024-03-21T22:08:44 |
Carina Kauf, Emmanuele Chersoni, Alessandro Lenci, Evelina Fedorenko, Anna A. Ivanova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction-tuned LLMs can respond to explicit queries formulated as prompts,
which greatly facilitates interaction with human users. However, prompt-based
approaches might not always be able to tap into the wealth of implicit
knowledge acquired by LLMs during pre-training. This paper presents a
comprehensive study of ways to evaluate semantic plausibility in LLMs. We
compare base and instruction-tuned LLM performance on an English sentence
plausibility task via (a) explicit prompting and (b) implicit estimation via
direct readout of the probabilities models assign to strings. Experiment 1
shows that, across model architectures and plausibility datasets, (i) log
likelihood ($\textit{LL}$) scores are the most reliable indicator of sentence
plausibility, with zero-shot prompting yielding inconsistent and typically poor
results; (ii) $\textit{LL}$-based performance is still inferior to human
performance; (iii) instruction-tuned models have worse $\textit{LL}$-based
performance than base models. In Experiment 2, we show that $\textit{LL}$
scores across models are modulated by context in the expected way, showing high
performance on three metrics of context-sensitive plausibility and providing a
direct match to explicit human plausibility judgments. Overall, $\textit{LL}$
estimates remain a more reliable measure of plausibility in LLMs than direct
prompting.
|
[
0.07770662009716034,
-1.0508092641830444,
1.0484979152679443,
0.17784392833709717,
-0.1271386742591858,
-0.28597068786621094,
-0.5658901333808899,
-0.2225523591041565,
-0.3066272735595703,
0.39836785197257996,
-0.6931121945381165,
-0.6353541016578674,
-0.44302698969841003,
0.3466103971004486,
-0.360561341047287,
0.8987890481948853,
-0.07926495373249054,
-0.013455253094434738,
-0.790453314781189,
0.1985701322555542,
-0.5824528932571411,
-0.3094825744628906,
-0.24795562028884888,
-0.2491709291934967,
0.5207276344299316,
0.20998720824718475,
0.5798811912536621,
0.5177497863769531,
0.26935526728630066,
0.33966919779777527,
-0.06686268001794815,
0.20728799700737,
-0.3741394877433777,
0.3076096177101135,
-0.04933254048228264,
-0.691520631313324,
-0.46069198846817017,
0.15620121359825134,
0.5889014601707458,
0.7025241851806641,
0.1848224401473999,
0.02692043036222458,
0.22100263833999634,
0.35504892468452454,
-0.6863136291503906,
0.12064845114946365,
-0.7548930048942566,
-0.04354500398039818,
0.11904885619878769,
-0.385913610458374,
-0.7434793710708618,
-0.41561806201934814,
0.289176344871521,
-0.7200421690940857,
0.1858450472354889,
0.03396870940923691,
0.7011694312095642,
0.3909783661365509,
-0.508080780506134,
-0.6063656210899353,
-0.5178529024124146,
0.8264735341072083,
-0.7421685457229614,
0.22403736412525177,
0.3556339144706726,
0.013440459035336971,
-0.45066162943840027,
-0.683993399143219,
-0.33669495582580566,
-0.9735661149024963,
-0.17236889898777008,
0.31119847297668457,
-0.07087667286396027,
0.15644386410713196,
0.531166672706604,
0.42265358567237854,
-0.41277697682380676,
0.229479119181633,
0.022543275728821754,
-0.3488702178001404,
0.6181045770645142,
0.05135686695575714,
0.1860249936580658,
-0.11424844712018967,
-0.5825173854827881,
0.013312366791069508,
-0.8610036969184875,
0.18442022800445557,
0.5993713736534119,
0.1322597861289978,
-0.03140714392066002,
0.7282944917678833,
-0.1955694705247879,
0.8676432371139526,
0.20277583599090576,
-0.22746431827545166,
-0.07780002802610397,
-0.3128715455532074,
-0.23385334014892578,
-0.08630971610546112,
0.5438001751899719,
0.36197760701179504,
0.45542460680007935,
-0.3731408417224884,
-0.2895811200141907,
0.16768768429756165,
0.02042069472372532,
-0.6095634698867798,
-0.018540283665060997,
0.16000953316688538,
-0.12585707008838654,
0.11822429299354553,
0.10401816666126251,
-0.31335535645484924,
-0.45122668147087097,
-0.49243125319480896,
0.7002841234207153,
-0.41376200318336487,
-0.04478030279278755,
0.08142450451850891,
0.0124420877546072,
0.469727486371994,
0.28456196188926697,
-0.5398613810539246,
0.1412106454372406,
0.9133265018463135,
0.6496800780296326,
-0.4159012734889984,
-0.38299357891082764,
-0.6003410220146179,
-0.09464196860790253,
-0.1987149864435196,
0.7475024461746216,
-0.5698933005332947,
-0.4169386327266693,
-0.006498437840491533,
0.20565970242023468,
-0.42034775018692017,
-0.5895686745643616,
0.9203612804412842,
-0.3886871039867401,
0.1949865072965622,
-0.24105562269687653,
-1.130077600479126,
-0.025328563526272774,
-0.051032375544309616,
-0.4749138653278351,
0.8340169191360474,
-0.051521457731723785,
-0.536798894405365,
0.4837534725666046,
-0.29326972365379333,
-0.488930881023407,
-0.03641911596059799,
-0.08278661221265793,
-0.20395340025424957,
0.46967777609825134,
-0.06317368149757385,
0.5001561045646667,
-0.2078002393245697,
0.42422476410865784,
-0.24943387508392334,
-0.8190716505050659,
0.539219081401825,
-0.8991290330886841,
0.6424045562744141,
-0.2543860375881195,
-0.3511495292186737,
0.25561973452568054,
-0.7850474715232849,
0.05686613544821739,
-0.1518172025680542,
-0.5428077578544617,
-0.22352269291877747,
0.11694297194480896,
-0.5870733261108398,
-0.06923680752515793,
0.39222803711891174,
-0.45726388692855835,
-0.07609252631664276,
-0.7122694849967957,
0.2552904784679413,
0.7849885821342468,
-0.01598772034049034,
0.37629929184913635,
-0.3582436144351959,
0.31343743205070496,
-0.17619794607162476,
-0.10953660309314728,
-0.31105178594589233,
-0.48292696475982666,
-0.6598182916641235,
-0.4600381553173065,
0.23768384754657745,
0.6683782339096069,
-0.41074901819229126,
0.516559362411499,
-0.2233450561761856,
-0.15069438517093658,
-0.49175360798835754,
0.23220261931419373,
0.529218316078186,
0.7703632116317749,
0.18963176012039185,
0.06913493573665619,
-0.43014341592788696,
-0.9835764765739441,
-0.7368460893630981,
-0.15445806086063385,
-0.4585711658000946,
0.4639115035533905,
0.5539653301239014,
0.382730633020401,
0.933029055595398,
-0.2687859535217285,
0.2701577842235565,
-0.07236529141664505,
0.14134778082370758,
0.35051214694976807,
0.2897055149078369,
0.23716026544570923,
-0.49568283557891846,
-0.34667930006980896,
-0.3509816825389862,
-0.7674382328987122,
-0.26522985100746155,
0.0333123542368412,
-0.03449075669050217,
0.478878378868103,
0.2472640424966812,
-0.7238619327545166,
0.4612398147583008,
0.40475985407829285,
-0.5490218997001648,
0.6865227818489075,
-0.30757585167884827,
0.14024609327316284,
-0.5936719179153442,
-0.06632726639509201,
-0.09330840408802032,
-0.19243308901786804,
-0.5151255130767822,
-0.009130777791142464,
0.07497967779636383,
0.21746748685836792,
-0.5258824229240417,
0.5610977411270142,
-0.5676357746124268,
-0.4614555239677429,
-0.28611108660697937,
0.2757963538169861,
0.12240712344646454,
0.39059221744537354,
0.20503054559230804,
1.0658526420593262,
0.4135882258415222,
-0.6994466781616211,
0.21998319029808044,
0.0290392879396677,
-0.8729183673858643,
0.5499805808067322,
-0.9289675354957581,
0.178363636136055,
-0.15216569602489471,
0.29398471117019653,
-1.1529916524887085,
-0.3011294901371002,
0.04261908307671547,
-0.26073041558265686,
0.10843433439731598,
0.015000551007688046,
-0.3638339638710022,
-0.08697453141212463,
-0.263282835483551,
-0.10663142800331116,
0.6786949038505554,
-0.37783679366111755,
0.6285496950149536,
-0.3283047080039978,
-0.13426350057125092,
-0.40768423676490784,
-0.4481596350669861,
-0.1289464831352234,
-0.28089725971221924,
-0.7315611243247986,
0.1899685114622116,
-0.37099689245224,
-0.3794493079185486,
-0.11677869409322739,
-0.3865811824798584,
0.11533389985561371,
0.5961496829986572,
0.4953972399234772,
0.6329017877578735,
-0.45968133211135864,
-0.0505877323448658,
-0.05471525341272354,
0.02605244517326355,
0.2694312036037445,
-0.05179062485694885,
0.1945008635520935,
-0.09340045601129532,
-0.6141892671585083,
-0.3849664032459259,
0.1610897034406662,
0.30410057306289673,
0.06690586358308792,
0.7544227838516235,
0.23477281630039215,
-0.017359746620059013,
-0.1881026178598404,
-0.5014804005622864,
-0.4037798345088959,
-0.4444595277309418,
0.15321771800518036,
-0.4119943082332611,
-0.8281393051147461,
0.30415108799934387,
-0.05794229358434677,
0.16455614566802979,
0.3180994391441345,
0.6216278076171875,
-0.23238372802734375,
0.971295177936554,
0.24551263451576233,
0.6370809078216553,
0.301850289106369,
0.1825098842382431,
-0.03101378306746483,
-0.7021642923355103,
-0.06262321025133133,
-0.34557560086250305,
-0.1381654143333435,
-0.4841315746307373,
-0.25399619340896606,
0.4886171817779541,
0.21239636838436127,
-0.24235503375530243,
0.07627276331186295,
-0.1384235918521881,
0.5869962573051453,
0.6096665263175964,
0.17414182424545288,
0.48848244547843933,
0.04473671689629555,
-0.3090260326862335,
-0.043554775416851044,
-0.4944716989994049,
-0.7330386638641357,
1.022763729095459,
0.2893756031990051,
0.4316202700138092,
0.0991022139787674,
0.27529123425483704,
0.024555785581469536,
0.4296223819255829,
-0.8120263814926147,
0.7136690616607666,
-0.19966968894004822,
-0.4737909436225891,
-0.24580971896648407,
-0.3515959680080414,
-0.7511394619941711,
0.1335083246231079,
-0.3802664279937744,
-0.7238644957542419,
-0.12621597945690155,
0.154502734541893,
-0.29892948269844055,
-0.13535863161087036,
-0.8885459303855896,
0.6921671628952026,
-0.3634478449821472,
-0.6773611903190613,
0.1284404695034027,
-0.5005193948745728,
0.46960628032684326,
0.11118476837873459,
0.07993391901254654,
-0.37093839049339294,
-0.21337808668613434,
0.5400872826576233,
-0.2749606668949127,
1.0637292861938477,
-0.19658927619457245,
-0.37217235565185547,
0.16588141024112701,
0.004819696769118309,
0.7364690899848938,
0.014663318172097206,
-0.2887817919254303,
-0.042816247791051865,
-0.14287282526493073,
-0.3196769952774048,
-0.7785238027572632,
0.834546685218811,
-0.7359832525253296,
-1.0500978231430054,
-0.07705071568489075,
-0.8282144069671631,
-0.5835614204406738,
-0.012969132512807846,
0.3904515504837036,
0.4360271990299225,
-0.04090537503361702,
0.20582446455955505,
0.7498347163200378,
-0.338858962059021,
0.43648985028266907,
0.8479702472686768,
0.23021797835826874,
-0.062495578080415726,
0.6592856049537659,
0.08043678849935532,
0.39216315746307373,
0.361253559589386,
0.2976717948913574,
-0.5705788731575012,
-0.4908736050128937,
-0.34855759143829346,
0.204694002866745,
-0.8047248125076294,
0.08078468590974808,
-0.19746220111846924,
-0.15492235124111176,
-0.15389499068260193,
-0.1855776160955429,
0.0785481259226799,
-0.13722172379493713,
-0.2842214107513428,
-0.33983954787254333,
0.385127991437912,
0.572329580783844,
0.38245198130607605,
0.0740971565246582,
-0.43585777282714844,
-0.0015669564018025994,
0.36664608120918274,
0.2732633054256439,
-0.0896419808268547,
-0.8473297953605652,
0.2310241162776947,
0.10523483902215958,
0.1027996614575386,
-0.8610691428184509,
-0.0816095843911171,
0.2634675204753876,
0.7521820664405823,
0.09904119372367859,
0.27135011553764343,
0.6073041558265686,
-0.4423379600048065,
0.7714046835899353,
-0.07339248806238174,
-1.0161771774291992,
0.5215129256248474,
-0.17903372645378113,
0.1816113442182541,
0.541445791721344,
0.3307661712169647,
0.121986024081707,
-0.5230134725570679,
-0.33961161971092224,
-0.9029340744018555,
0.5476697087287903,
0.057009801268577576,
0.19427216053009033,
-0.05072582885622978,
0.4960688650608063,
0.4093283414840698,
0.2537008821964264,
-0.5068942308425903,
-0.2249601036310196,
-0.00622226158156991,
-0.4093930721282959,
-0.1506829559803009,
-0.38171467185020447,
-0.005545245483517647,
-0.12039511650800705,
0.5068145990371704,
-0.15816622972488403,
0.0881652683019638,
0.23971469700336456,
-0.4686589241027832,
0.10509670525789261,
0.46170419454574585,
0.8375326991081238,
0.9867726564407349,
-0.28310126066207886,
0.21018610894680023,
0.2777722477912903,
-0.24589164555072784,
0.18785275518894196,
-0.11440429836511612,
-0.5385188460350037,
-0.05005083233118057,
0.937120795249939,
1.3015657663345337,
0.7168968915939331,
-0.808222234249115,
0.6912233829498291,
0.04454909637570381,
-0.27593350410461426,
-0.293663889169693,
0.34783127903938293,
0.14600826799869537,
0.1880083680152893,
0.2207411676645279,
-0.31455910205841064,
-0.016434719786047935,
-0.5527576208114624,
0.08695194870233536,
0.4732394814491272,
-0.14828796684741974,
-0.33049967885017395,
0.6124378442764282,
0.15116538107395172,
-0.24845249950885773,
0.44990548491477966,
0.08899868279695511,
-0.14346148073673248,
0.6177183389663696,
0.6692357063293457,
0.7253054976463318,
0.020700806751847267,
0.21013106405735016,
0.3120918571949005,
0.02718120627105236,
-0.08171842247247696,
0.1481936275959015,
-0.21394960582256317,
-0.5655079483985901,
-0.7703463435173035,
-0.6566554307937622,
-0.412654310464859,
0.1258007138967514,
-0.7006256580352783,
0.09365954250097275,
-0.32032832503318787,
-0.0055403863079845905,
0.05082382634282112,
0.14575302600860596,
-0.6194143295288086,
-0.05803525447845459,
0.09974704682826996,
1.0797762870788574,
-1.0106868743896484,
0.4869285523891449,
0.7619590759277344,
-0.22578367590904236,
-0.8768245577812195,
0.1750383973121643,
-0.23137187957763672,
-0.9831251502037048,
0.7353346943855286,
0.14548155665397644,
-0.20004034042358398,
0.07668088376522064,
-0.5550174713134766,
-0.6650701761245728,
1.2230510711669922,
0.8425018787384033,
-0.6557617783546448,
0.06099654734134674,
-0.1021156832575798,
0.4534968435764313,
-0.27903416752815247,
0.5062091946601868,
0.7635186910629272,
0.6761002540588379,
0.323163777589798,
-0.7821140289306641,
0.1251346468925476,
0.16636653244495392,
-0.10664355754852295,
-0.3070041537284851,
-0.2764602601528168,
0.8098107576370239,
-0.17798765003681183,
-0.4685658812522888,
0.2724398970603943,
0.7396513223648071,
0.6273994445800781,
0.4439713656902313,
0.5900765061378479,
0.20778578519821167,
0.9171227812767029,
-0.16996215283870697,
1.2939567565917969,
-0.40112391114234924,
0.10815417766571045,
1.1219995021820068,
-0.5108575224876404,
0.9636766910552979,
0.4055418372154236,
-0.2601081132888794,
0.5988278388977051,
0.5284644961357117,
0.11225087195634842,
0.46027642488479614,
0.19612711668014526,
-0.34150952100753784,
-0.5356777906417847,
-0.15144062042236328,
-0.01637592352926731,
0.3014574348926544,
0.19014908373355865,
-0.3302021026611328,
-0.12923647463321686,
-0.1332141011953354,
0.08512610197067261,
0.238115131855011,
-0.44544273614883423,
0.8767170310020447,
0.08596551418304443,
-1.0607070922851562,
0.6423518657684326,
-0.07803314924240112,
0.6917856931686401,
-0.4938684403896332,
0.015760120004415512,
-0.35537585616111755,
-0.023256897926330566,
-0.2290380448102951,
-0.7766909003257751,
0.09165292978286743,
0.23781463503837585,
-0.3322801887989044,
-0.05518827587366104,
0.8278953433036804,
-0.40640243887901306,
-0.4856054186820984,
0.06414523720741272,
0.5905845165252686,
0.27616703510284424,
0.16791021823883057,
-0.410336971282959,
0.08538273721933365,
-0.21189911663532257,
-0.45843368768692017,
0.4078928828239441,
0.301545649766922,
-0.05324314534664154,
0.40497931838035583,
0.6191099286079407,
0.015035598538815975,
0.10516831278800964,
0.025196151807904243,
0.5268970727920532,
-0.3989855647087097,
-0.10344678908586502,
-1.0381386280059814,
0.41534653306007385,
0.031004317104816437,
-0.2980949580669403,
1.0656973123550415,
0.32753974199295044,
0.5198512673377991,
-0.1417727768421173,
0.6917473673820496,
0.2682332396507263,
0.48331165313720703,
-0.9455716013908386,
0.16617250442504883,
-0.3620273470878601,
0.6021811962127686,
0.17708764970302582,
-0.7302539348602295,
-0.00107995152939111,
0.5677902102470398,
-0.7806435227394104,
0.07110410183668137,
0.5784658193588257,
0.8383499383926392,
0.0734700933098793,
0.0019234061473980546,
0.469122976064682,
0.48225370049476624,
-0.3543351888656616,
0.6802669167518616,
1.1593480110168457,
0.017196446657180786,
0.20904390513896942,
0.12267394363880157,
-0.2121221423149109,
-0.23039889335632324,
-1.135807991027832,
-0.9722345471382141,
-0.2175503671169281,
-0.25208866596221924,
-0.19270268082618713,
0.23026417195796967,
0.7412078976631165,
0.3108077943325043,
-0.8495597839355469,
0.04473745822906494,
-0.13092978298664093,
0.4146116077899933,
-0.1740022897720337,
-0.2128509283065796,
0.4339805543422699,
-0.2351466566324234,
-0.6806073188781738,
0.7984782457351685,
0.16614872217178345,
-0.0609034039080143,
-0.25425517559051514,
-0.08124197274446487,
0.05432329326868057,
0.34670233726501465,
0.5363054275512695,
0.09933847188949585,
-1.1301823854446411,
-0.5056669116020203,
0.21320326626300812,
-0.11047837138175964,
-0.24977874755859375,
0.7198053598403931,
-0.8488031625747681,
0.017174135893583298,
0.4349757432937622,
0.5403109192848206,
0.10251963883638382,
0.3573038578033447,
0.7027080655097961,
-1.0618976354599,
-0.020804930478334427,
0.06282542645931244,
0.29425331950187683,
0.35879674553871155,
-0.3841610848903656,
0.3027889132499695,
0.1759956330060959,
-0.49506548047065735,
-0.8425441384315491,
0.2855709195137024,
-0.7921566367149353,
-0.35797324776649475,
1.326430320739746,
-0.6513878107070923,
-0.38680875301361084,
-0.008337484672665596,
0.038477104157209396,
0.023499542847275734,
-0.13387736678123474,
0.28453943133354187,
0.8138768076896667,
-0.15585942566394806,
-0.03192918002605438,
-0.8731064796447754,
0.44268885254859924,
0.6060643196105957,
-0.49223190546035767,
0.15336020290851593,
0.6136705875396729,
0.5736713409423828,
-0.18882685899734497,
0.391112744808197,
0.31444263458251953,
0.2868330776691437,
-0.09846353530883789,
-0.427529901266098,
-0.37493064999580383,
-0.24273157119750977,
-0.4169532060623169,
0.2329082190990448,
0.15743955969810486,
0.03735100105404854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15501v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15501v1
|
Enhancing Medical Support in the Arabic Language Through Personalized ChatGPT Assistance
| 2024-03-21T21:28:07 | 2024-03-21T21:28:07 |
Mohamed Issa, Ahmed Abdelwahed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This Paper discusses the growing popularity of online medical diagnosis as an
alternative to traditional doctor visits. It highlights the limitations of
existing tools and emphasizes the advantages of using ChatGPT, which provides
real-time, personalized medical diagnosis at no cost. The paragraph summarizes
a research study that evaluated the performance of ChatGPT in Arabic medical
diagnosis. The study involved compiling a dataset of disease information and
generating multiple messages for each disease using different prompting
techniques. ChatGPT's performance was assessed by measuring the similarity
between its responses and the actual diseases. The results showed promising
performance, with average scores of around 76% for similarity measures. Various
prompting techniques were used, and chain prompting demonstrated a relative
advantage. The study also recorded an average response time of 6.12 seconds for
the ChatGPT API, which is considered acceptable but has room for improvement.
While ChatGPT cannot replace human doctors entirely, the findings suggest its
potential in emergency cases and addressing general medical inquiries. Overall,
the study highlights ChatGPT's viability as a valuable tool in the medical
field.
|
[
-0.6255438327789307,
-0.7685337662696838,
0.6144967079162598,
0.28573447465896606,
-0.43990710377693176,
0.2524747848510742,
-0.13262587785720825,
-0.7786796689033508,
0.37940481305122375,
-0.01678195223212242,
-0.4205363094806671,
-0.6081652641296387,
-0.7999777793884277,
0.21403361856937408,
-0.1561397910118103,
1.1270167827606201,
-0.09081179648637772,
0.34180063009262085,
0.19454258680343628,
-0.07220939546823502,
-0.5087441205978394,
-0.5769660472869873,
-1.5402392148971558,
-0.38492608070373535,
0.5910426378250122,
0.4251019060611725,
1.2399554252624512,
0.3614310920238495,
0.6090336441993713,
0.2103307545185089,
0.06873743236064911,
0.31124958395957947,
0.14521043002605438,
0.32698893547058105,
0.2682976722717285,
0.0175018347799778,
-0.42971083521842957,
-0.21394337713718414,
0.21077260375022888,
0.7857852578163147,
-0.2937098741531372,
-0.030543148517608643,
-0.04544978588819504,
1.02268385887146,
-0.06021328642964363,
0.12834453582763672,
0.010742764919996262,
0.43347612023353577,
-0.27283260226249695,
-0.07438302040100098,
0.1487167328596115,
-0.6954473257064819,
0.4052707850933075,
-0.5148589611053467,
0.3175649642944336,
0.05092678591609001,
0.7335878014564514,
0.25625261664390564,
-0.37292158603668213,
-0.6240713596343994,
-0.8116437792778015,
0.2064797282218933,
-0.5075059533119202,
0.17966988682746887,
0.44401293992996216,
0.8038443326950073,
-0.21989935636520386,
-0.7188675403594971,
-0.251778244972229,
-0.5465238690376282,
0.004044227302074432,
0.41972020268440247,
-0.26591986417770386,
0.09463866800069809,
0.05088242143392563,
0.5730019211769104,
-0.7324779033660889,
-0.2169748693704605,
0.05622813478112221,
-0.2667796313762665,
0.20490747690200806,
0.003671857761219144,
0.8548121452331543,
0.22095517814159393,
-0.08544491231441498,
0.14424093067646027,
-0.752281129360199,
0.007005907595157623,
0.09374120086431503,
-0.16918784379959106,
-0.14379170536994934,
0.37907877564430237,
-0.4668337106704712,
0.6430854201316833,
-0.08239899575710297,
-0.11727583408355713,
0.007204463239759207,
-0.0784982368350029,
-0.09076666086912155,
0.44696852564811707,
0.5961334109306335,
0.4173344075679779,
0.33230918645858765,
-0.11956853419542313,
0.0980885848402977,
0.038823336362838745,
0.12862852215766907,
-0.8789151310920715,
-0.61446613073349,
0.3579169511795044,
-0.8699935674667358,
-0.08328491449356079,
-0.3140283226966858,
-0.6843941807746887,
-0.6315088272094727,
0.10756930708885193,
0.24180464446544647,
-0.5468788146972656,
-0.18997718393802643,
0.24712984263896942,
-0.09149042516946793,
-0.0156825240701437,
0.6132354140281677,
-0.6893777251243591,
0.4448295831680298,
0.3172317147254944,
1.1709425449371338,
-0.04313227906823158,
0.4437710642814636,
-0.3731788396835327,
-0.16842739284038544,
-0.18643192946910858,
1.0990856885910034,
-0.6369866728782654,
-0.7519311904907227,
-0.03791277855634689,
-0.432248592376709,
-0.07227543741464615,
-0.9769462943077087,
0.6239389777183533,
-0.2520948350429535,
0.21184879541397095,
-0.2915182113647461,
-0.2938176691532135,
-0.2071402668952942,
0.2862139642238617,
-0.48455020785331726,
0.7885102033615112,
0.24270394444465637,
-0.5937584042549133,
0.3184957206249237,
-1.0245239734649658,
-0.3864307403564453,
0.4391489624977112,
-0.21231988072395325,
-0.573890209197998,
-0.23080754280090332,
0.6662747859954834,
0.2931041717529297,
-0.32544994354248047,
0.101229228079319,
0.003274006536230445,
-0.3065488636493683,
0.18119993805885315,
-0.4462083876132965,
0.4717094898223877,
0.5380252003669739,
-0.42247575521469116,
-0.11376845091581345,
-0.6299915313720703,
0.05097462981939316,
0.20433589816093445,
-0.4700922966003418,
-0.003726228838786483,
0.41578784584999084,
0.021238962188363075,
-0.06126304715871811,
0.1379137933254242,
-0.5275123119354248,
0.5175336599349976,
-0.7638488411903381,
-0.0774572342634201,
0.2633567750453949,
0.38927268981933594,
-0.25883764028549194,
-0.7956990599632263,
0.8267781138420105,
0.015757866203784943,
0.17260481417179108,
-0.18742763996124268,
-1.339099645614624,
-0.6480376720428467,
-0.4188176691532135,
0.40262582898139954,
0.7103445529937744,
-0.43994271755218506,
-0.011926721781492233,
0.058467261493206024,
-0.4946424961090088,
-0.7972292900085449,
-0.17813721299171448,
0.292279988527298,
0.5557639002799988,
0.43532219529151917,
-0.5751550197601318,
-0.45166510343551636,
-0.904852569103241,
-0.526411235332489,
0.01206717174500227,
-0.2330121248960495,
0.5143523812294006,
-0.10196895897388458,
-0.31880009174346924,
0.6561302542686462,
-0.4115738272666931,
-0.44641172885894775,
-0.13351157307624817,
0.09072230011224747,
0.35437658429145813,
0.2911819815635681,
0.721557080745697,
-0.7367146015167236,
-1.1175603866577148,
0.5787672400474548,
-0.4798976182937622,
-0.4500406086444855,
0.02962241880595684,
0.27637040615081787,
-0.14878880977630615,
-0.10173382610082626,
-0.28323981165885925,
0.6221580505371094,
0.6760783791542053,
-0.6791303753852844,
0.40181776881217957,
-0.5293957591056824,
0.524438738822937,
-1.0978392362594604,
-0.047774869948625565,
-0.13219138979911804,
-0.5323543548583984,
-0.5978239178657532,
-0.15296439826488495,
-0.25544747710227966,
-0.4000466465950012,
-0.19399435818195343,
0.48709508776664734,
-0.3239026665687561,
0.23582673072814941,
-0.4472149908542633,
0.19153237342834473,
-0.512130856513977,
-0.1608656793832779,
-0.15891781449317932,
0.8071810007095337,
0.5060309171676636,
-0.746157705783844,
0.4990888833999634,
0.28538861870765686,
-0.21525396406650543,
0.5747138261795044,
-0.8389339447021484,
0.08623487502336502,
-0.11752290278673172,
0.1698928028345108,
-1.0072970390319824,
-0.303121954202652,
0.8014143705368042,
-0.6842120289802551,
-0.00601403322070837,
-0.22508101165294647,
-0.3218615651130676,
-0.10213501006364822,
-0.01236183475703001,
0.44926586747169495,
0.7692477703094482,
-0.4602486789226532,
0.4015924036502838,
0.004534323699772358,
-0.5543254613876343,
-0.1815033107995987,
-0.29424068331718445,
0.2261534184217453,
-0.2238294780254364,
-0.6030218601226807,
0.32195883989334106,
-0.09611561894416809,
-0.3140420913696289,
-0.014871605671942234,
-0.07922562956809998,
-0.18326173722743988,
0.22433069348335266,
0.537911593914032,
0.0889936238527298,
-0.3304627537727356,
0.41262033581733704,
0.08397938311100006,
-0.4377451241016388,
-0.10415593534708023,
-0.15720218420028687,
0.671996533870697,
0.016156792640686035,
-0.817410409450531,
-0.563595175743103,
0.8922774195671082,
0.1292089968919754,
-0.15787601470947266,
0.779602587223053,
0.58409184217453,
-0.28829213976860046,
0.45421838760375977,
-0.5321499705314636,
-0.020309049636125565,
-0.5059424638748169,
0.050052329897880554,
-0.1257343888282776,
-0.5650342702865601,
0.44202521443367004,
-0.36376330256462097,
-0.005006025545299053,
0.43233078718185425,
0.7476463913917542,
-0.11340141296386719,
1.5043562650680542,
0.2879040837287903,
-0.072238489985466,
0.21322014927864075,
0.3717394173145294,
0.6032555103302002,
-0.32759132981300354,
-0.20822523534297943,
-0.621238648891449,
-0.18358977138996124,
-0.8846156597137451,
-0.014739097096025944,
1.0545923709869385,
-0.1353718340396881,
-0.2617420554161072,
-0.29770147800445557,
-0.6657940149307251,
0.2837316691875458,
0.4863344132900238,
0.49220263957977295,
0.409990131855011,
0.16964814066886902,
-0.3303164839744568,
-0.16037210822105408,
-0.680185079574585,
-0.5357910394668579,
0.8061482310295105,
0.08066687732934952,
0.43236157298088074,
0.5025845170021057,
0.588209867477417,
0.6261285543441772,
0.45600268244743347,
-0.9803997874259949,
0.1533145308494568,
0.07548511773347855,
-0.387524276971817,
0.17782077193260193,
-0.13631384074687958,
-1.361754298210144,
0.19081807136535645,
-0.09453995525836945,
-0.6077982783317566,
-0.4877385199069977,
0.4224535822868347,
-0.6334641575813293,
0.01342394296079874,
-1.0706197023391724,
0.657636821269989,
-0.04168421030044556,
0.20429618656635284,
-0.30067765712738037,
-0.5351898074150085,
-0.10893531143665314,
-0.013907424174249172,
0.26160693168640137,
-0.18618719279766083,
-0.07843422144651413,
0.7779207825660706,
-0.5086017847061157,
0.7939174175262451,
-0.2428676038980484,
0.29629573225975037,
-0.08237674832344055,
-0.02316327951848507,
0.3057296574115753,
0.18551743030548096,
0.22208459675312042,
-0.18903861939907074,
0.24306108057498932,
-0.6309586763381958,
-0.5543549656867981,
0.5719990730285645,
-0.6980383396148682,
-0.7477453947067261,
-0.7520490288734436,
-0.2088293880224228,
-0.6568114757537842,
0.09975627064704895,
0.04887201264500618,
0.519845724105835,
-0.14372383058071136,
-0.25290513038635254,
0.4771893322467804,
-0.5083662867546082,
0.4142245948314667,
0.4590868055820465,
-0.319035142660141,
0.010978343896567822,
0.8072547912597656,
-0.07038474082946777,
0.027036482468247414,
0.15341757237911224,
0.5646930932998657,
-0.1167304664850235,
-0.5620958209037781,
-0.6325417160987854,
0.22095660865306854,
-0.6131734848022461,
-0.1399952471256256,
-0.7110739946365356,
-0.30662134289741516,
-0.18784022331237793,
-0.04678722470998764,
-0.13871979713439941,
-0.3813684582710266,
0.05922762304544449,
0.1613815575838089,
0.7209203839302063,
0.9741934537887573,
0.06214155629277229,
0.40942689776420593,
-1.1054879426956177,
0.34553951025009155,
0.13611619174480438,
0.3456468880176544,
0.060944098979234695,
-0.22379964590072632,
-0.16356518864631653,
0.1390417367219925,
-0.3909764587879181,
-1.1516871452331543,
0.3503884971141815,
0.367997407913208,
0.47446340322494507,
0.8102308511734009,
0.02738088369369507,
0.8801494240760803,
-0.6078596115112305,
0.7976769208908081,
0.1556205451488495,
-0.7014200687408447,
0.653924822807312,
-0.2105770856142044,
0.5062382817268372,
0.03819797933101654,
0.8463756442070007,
-1.314322590827942,
-0.29489126801490784,
-0.5030276775360107,
-0.6177636384963989,
0.1616167426109314,
0.2876684367656708,
-0.0195798147469759,
-0.04158669710159302,
0.34822699427604675,
0.11281697452068329,
-0.1283997893333435,
-0.1321374922990799,
-0.6592471599578857,
-0.005746141541749239,
-0.4120364189147949,
0.08875852823257446,
-0.2873251438140869,
-0.06321345269680023,
-0.31061166524887085,
0.4921935200691223,
0.04362627863883972,
0.7392956018447876,
0.6096735000610352,
0.31361567974090576,
0.21392883360385895,
0.42767471075057983,
0.604710042476654,
0.6336714029312134,
0.2209707349538803,
-0.018590858206152916,
0.1929544359445572,
-0.8510923385620117,
0.03739064559340477,
0.11335349082946777,
0.12519168853759766,
0.32923078536987305,
0.1892937570810318,
0.41727861762046814,
-0.05890066549181938,
-0.7932964563369751,
0.4769282042980194,
-0.15424346923828125,
-0.0008917343220673501,
-0.3755427896976471,
0.08741742372512817,
0.06853793561458588,
0.27389296889305115,
0.3580058515071869,
0.16205327212810516,
0.24143734574317932,
-0.3230270445346832,
0.11274629831314087,
0.5248203873634338,
-0.5599060654640198,
-0.16906043887138367,
0.5936015844345093,
0.09104638546705246,
-0.6471281051635742,
0.5125669836997986,
-0.22522515058517456,
-0.44318342208862305,
0.5219725966453552,
0.6326293349266052,
0.278227299451828,
-0.44697630405426025,
0.3999903202056885,
0.1699589192867279,
-0.09046655148267746,
0.076156385242939,
0.4255010485649109,
-0.06558561325073242,
-0.5450517535209656,
-0.30192187428474426,
-0.20629306137561798,
-0.6946377158164978,
0.05382535234093666,
-0.2756914496421814,
0.056108973920345306,
-0.5129563808441162,
-0.2846602201461792,
0.041289523243904114,
-0.06849077343940735,
-0.42869535088539124,
0.4868708550930023,
0.03579820320010185,
0.6020505428314209,
-0.29396727681159973,
0.6526319980621338,
0.7933096289634705,
-0.2429376095533371,
-0.8521460890769958,
0.12106990069150925,
0.23803187906742096,
-1.2218127250671387,
0.17517700791358948,
0.16118517518043518,
-0.033484917134046555,
-0.011557023972272873,
-0.22150291502475739,
-0.6131297945976257,
0.64168781042099,
0.21615751087665558,
-0.3722137212753296,
0.15153104066848755,
0.033460795879364014,
0.5258299112319946,
-0.1829417645931244,
0.692853569984436,
0.4191927909851074,
0.5038852095603943,
0.054552916437387466,
-1.2533317804336548,
0.059658490121364594,
-0.21030843257904053,
-0.19584941864013672,
0.41077205538749695,
-0.3641541302204132,
0.465212345123291,
-0.24175648391246796,
-0.4362596273422241,
0.19895978271961212,
0.045116156339645386,
-0.06583448499441147,
0.26758551597595215,
0.10018708556890488,
0.2630264461040497,
0.9125788807868958,
-0.1424245834350586,
1.4522674083709717,
-0.46747615933418274,
0.10592704266309738,
0.48412612080574036,
0.10745242238044739,
0.5889999270439148,
0.3678712546825409,
-0.4517650306224823,
0.3839932084083557,
0.9075037240982056,
0.2605416178703308,
0.43266403675079346,
0.02355445735156536,
-1.0352145433425903,
-0.1394154280424118,
-0.32866525650024414,
-0.972678005695343,
0.1520666778087616,
0.36180317401885986,
-0.41228970885276794,
-0.5570307374000549,
0.05081309750676155,
0.3150010108947754,
-0.003039540722966194,
-0.2063387781381607,
0.7932711243629456,
-0.03745638206601143,
-0.4896308481693268,
0.5589228272438049,
0.11141255497932434,
0.23635390400886536,
-0.722697913646698,
-0.2888396680355072,
-0.09884708374738693,
0.06862051784992218,
-0.3896203935146332,
-0.4124235212802887,
0.4876449704170227,
-0.0215804111212492,
0.0788675993680954,
-0.180773064494133,
0.8694823384284973,
-0.0012647664407268167,
-0.35615068674087524,
-0.10018111020326614,
0.8524490594863892,
0.5861639380455017,
-0.37628427147865295,
-0.5716121792793274,
-0.1792685091495514,
0.13226419687271118,
0.055752791464328766,
0.42673259973526,
0.13855741918087006,
-0.004374288953840733,
0.8162459135055542,
0.6554695963859558,
0.4792385399341583,
0.01994127780199051,
0.09584531933069229,
0.6630489230155945,
-0.705176830291748,
-0.41465070843696594,
-1.0077992677688599,
0.05546722188591957,
-0.09344203025102615,
-0.23293831944465637,
0.6026027202606201,
0.3325772285461426,
0.47487959265708923,
-0.21465224027633667,
0.9313688278198242,
-0.1738913655281067,
0.8539207577705383,
-0.4295370876789093,
0.9580711722373962,
-0.27284467220306396,
0.03945844992995262,
0.0870005339384079,
-0.37145617604255676,
-0.5183463096618652,
0.7052009105682373,
-0.1421823501586914,
0.18707524240016937,
0.9030953645706177,
0.6790308952331543,
0.08245176076889038,
0.16871419548988342,
0.4934404194355011,
-0.054018545895814896,
0.4545769691467285,
0.4079015254974365,
0.888150691986084,
-0.13844633102416992,
0.3991403877735138,
-0.025905990973114967,
-0.41053518652915955,
-0.38267406821250916,
-0.5382815599441528,
-0.8349297642707825,
-0.3248262107372284,
-0.3116397261619568,
-0.1554415374994278,
0.3326725959777832,
1.3160609006881714,
0.6765196323394775,
-0.9228010177612305,
0.17532891035079956,
0.08133046329021454,
-0.1716972291469574,
-0.565157949924469,
-0.142968088388443,
0.39170214533805847,
-0.1799686998128891,
-0.5875163078308105,
0.3596465289592743,
0.24565228819847107,
0.14168599247932434,
0.20230133831501007,
0.035502657294273376,
0.26787838339805603,
-0.3410293757915497,
0.5891157984733582,
0.41076672077178955,
-0.6339280009269714,
-0.3017660975456238,
-0.16280679404735565,
0.06717139482498169,
0.6979397535324097,
0.8952381014823914,
-0.9311679005622864,
0.519396185874939,
0.044216156005859375,
0.9155781269073486,
0.3647271692752838,
0.07859017699956894,
0.5837390422821045,
-0.16478513181209564,
0.09042954444885254,
0.25167316198349,
0.2860180139541626,
0.2855205833911896,
-0.5650528073310852,
0.24852719902992249,
0.28436440229415894,
-0.6572354435920715,
-0.07582426071166992,
0.34969043731689453,
-0.8599388003349304,
0.27258551120758057,
0.9506688117980957,
-0.2991126477718353,
0.18845447897911072,
-0.8466570377349854,
-1.029780387878418,
0.27986934781074524,
-0.8011114001274109,
1.0716025829315186,
0.7371730208396912,
-0.9369457960128784,
-0.06660794466733932,
-0.9636930227279663,
0.629579484462738,
0.607579231262207,
-0.8341466188430786,
-0.804719865322113,
0.09530545026063919,
0.43254488706588745,
-0.12398432940244675,
0.9055947065353394,
-0.14864541590213776,
0.5523406863212585,
-0.17448484897613525,
-0.3349944055080414,
0.075853630900383,
0.3093762695789337,
-0.13837578892707825,
0.1661859005689621,
0.5568881630897522,
-0.4404626488685608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14840v1
|
TAMS: Translation-Assisted Morphological Segmentation
| 2024-03-21T21:23:35 | 2024-03-21T21:23:35 |
Enora Rice, Ali Marashian, Luke Gessler, Alexis Palmer, Katharina von der Wense
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Canonical morphological segmentation is the process of analyzing words into
the standard (aka underlying) forms of their constituent morphemes. This is a
core task in language documentation, and NLP systems have the potential to
dramatically speed up this process. But in typical language documentation
settings, training data for canonical morpheme segmentation is scarce, making
it difficult to train high quality models. However, translation data is often
much more abundant, and, in this work, we present a method that attempts to
leverage this data in the canonical segmentation task. We propose a
character-level sequence-to-sequence model that incorporates representations of
translations obtained from pretrained high-resource monolingual language models
as an additional signal. Our model outperforms the baseline in a super-low
resource setting but yields mixed results on training splits with more data.
While further work is needed to make translations useful in higher-resource
settings, our model shows promise in severely resource-constrained settings.
|
[
-0.15010562539100647,
-0.5740929245948792,
0.47254371643066406,
0.033414777368307114,
-0.8498928546905518,
0.14730152487754822,
0.07226600497961044,
-0.14597001671791077,
0.442740797996521,
0.7711687088012695,
-0.7406114339828491,
-0.5875903367996216,
-0.5532309412956238,
0.48357105255126953,
-0.4376780092716217,
0.6877803206443787,
0.1642434298992157,
0.49721935391426086,
-0.002312027383595705,
-0.24254323542118073,
-0.560634195804596,
-0.6076595783233643,
-0.7541488409042358,
-0.11437773704528809,
0.4403867721557617,
0.31902122497558594,
0.8487647771835327,
1.2796686887741089,
0.45178186893463135,
0.3627282679080963,
-0.382916122674942,
0.4293408691883087,
-0.28893816471099854,
0.6478760242462158,
-0.16938039660453796,
-0.7209748029708862,
-0.1891029179096222,
-0.2407802790403366,
1.063008189201355,
0.9516950249671936,
0.2629804015159607,
-0.07931970059871674,
-0.1353827565908432,
0.3746931850910187,
-0.24225950241088867,
-0.08319341391324997,
-0.6058871150016785,
0.16834807395935059,
-0.45010870695114136,
-0.30495941638946533,
-0.5800224542617798,
-0.30561885237693787,
0.22291196882724762,
-0.6747786402702332,
0.15257392823696136,
-0.21089774370193481,
1.0113164186477661,
0.30691468715667725,
-0.23176486790180206,
-0.08622687309980392,
-0.42909982800483704,
0.7113164663314819,
-0.33426859974861145,
0.5159399509429932,
0.3755020499229431,
-0.04402029514312744,
0.137300044298172,
-0.6439196467399597,
-0.03573090210556984,
-0.1432991921901703,
-0.15269559621810913,
-0.20768946409225464,
-0.024957124143838882,
0.07767701148986816,
0.3281618356704712,
0.46329811215400696,
-0.5280487537384033,
0.04472479596734047,
-0.4546390175819397,
-0.09471913427114487,
0.45426803827285767,
0.2562100291252136,
0.5620595216751099,
-0.6195909976959229,
-0.3951070010662079,
-0.15074144303798676,
-0.6245434880256653,
-0.3434639275074005,
0.08724986761808395,
0.45788413286209106,
0.004313266836106777,
0.6217527389526367,
0.35251346230506897,
0.660141110420227,
0.10796649754047394,
-0.3167508840560913,
0.2666051983833313,
-0.4065437316894531,
-0.2698974013328552,
-0.0020294536370784044,
0.6529200673103333,
-0.26916760206222534,
0.06797297298908234,
-0.06191152706742287,
-0.3385578691959381,
-0.28696244955062866,
0.3289041221141815,
-0.580843448638916,
0.25217682123184204,
-0.10538530349731445,
-0.4244365990161896,
-0.012569725513458252,
-0.06806871294975281,
-0.7040414214134216,
-0.22878772020339966,
-0.7126985192298889,
0.11290082335472107,
-1.0283757448196411,
-0.17483237385749817,
0.022198369726538658,
-0.25939691066741943,
0.06264371424913406,
0.2801862359046936,
-0.9384338855743408,
0.20440015196800232,
0.6510810852050781,
1.257645845413208,
-0.19216813147068024,
-0.15935638546943665,
-0.6371850967407227,
0.13450178503990173,
-0.41590455174446106,
0.8420796990394592,
-0.7898848056793213,
-0.9228169322013855,
-0.07319147139787674,
0.21172121167182922,
-0.4117242395877838,
-0.5841443538665771,
0.41383597254753113,
-0.26305246353149414,
-0.1305919587612152,
-0.20398370921611786,
-0.36793071031570435,
-0.02411695383489132,
-0.032269928604364395,
-0.8359314799308777,
1.125916600227356,
0.4923245310783386,
-0.439045250415802,
0.10381579399108887,
-0.6761351823806763,
-0.6260339021682739,
0.4256064295768738,
-0.16690124571323395,
-0.08551850914955139,
0.4001327157020569,
0.19271619617938995,
0.3379751443862915,
-0.30572888255119324,
0.23145993053913116,
-0.05427827313542366,
0.06124171242117882,
0.06533563137054443,
-0.3499615788459778,
0.7517188191413879,
0.511718213558197,
0.011297699064016342,
0.19844946265220642,
-0.644012451171875,
-0.12118863314390182,
0.09936829656362534,
-0.049624066799879074,
-1.0189801454544067,
-0.17608937621116638,
-0.04369860514998436,
0.09983162581920624,
0.3042636215686798,
-0.44088608026504517,
0.4694746136665344,
-0.2905181646347046,
0.3450676500797272,
0.4837797284126282,
-0.05664708837866783,
0.6307271718978882,
-0.06286903470754623,
0.7177924513816833,
-0.023101987317204475,
0.11152124404907227,
-0.6833120584487915,
-0.5004856586456299,
-0.7657514810562134,
-0.49734511971473694,
0.4725397825241089,
0.45731881260871887,
-0.9728485345840454,
0.5630279183387756,
-0.5447777509689331,
-0.3217480480670929,
-0.7756184935569763,
-0.2376411259174347,
0.6021736860275269,
0.3333801031112671,
0.33184942603111267,
-0.6145899295806885,
-0.6889333724975586,
-0.7266981601715088,
0.27751633524894714,
-0.2353464514017105,
0.003539584344252944,
-0.07735665142536163,
0.4932539761066437,
-0.20885099470615387,
0.821982741355896,
-0.45510467886924744,
-0.14040511846542358,
-0.3197411298751831,
0.523213803768158,
-0.20486265420913696,
0.6349932551383972,
0.3150366246700287,
-0.6046059727668762,
-0.19022633135318756,
0.2653314769268036,
-0.6991687417030334,
-0.3522781729698181,
-0.19611485302448273,
-0.2379561960697174,
0.08147275447845459,
0.7805634140968323,
-0.2950584888458252,
0.23962140083312988,
0.23941285908222198,
-0.38901013135910034,
0.3906858563423157,
-0.3388507664203644,
0.13802799582481384,
-1.3935425281524658,
0.1258678138256073,
0.0729743018746376,
-0.34428563714027405,
-0.6864875555038452,
0.3994772136211395,
-0.014997884631156921,
-0.36885306239128113,
-0.39509713649749756,
0.4120960235595703,
-0.4133775532245636,
-0.3037891983985901,
-0.08726780116558075,
-0.4016413986682892,
-0.04826389253139496,
0.2423241138458252,
0.6610998511314392,
0.8077017664909363,
0.32711678743362427,
-0.2784602642059326,
-0.07198718190193176,
0.5187574028968811,
-0.09281893819570541,
0.7938543558120728,
-0.39905697107315063,
0.06913693249225616,
-0.03996306657791138,
0.13389462232589722,
-0.7431032657623291,
-0.18973210453987122,
0.15807510912418365,
-0.0688055083155632,
0.32381153106689453,
-0.4752851724624634,
-0.6206321716308594,
0.043475810438394547,
-0.01947430521249771,
0.7689524292945862,
0.26590994000434875,
-0.3349277377128601,
0.459676593542099,
0.5915300846099854,
-0.49775904417037964,
-0.047203417867422104,
-0.5680747032165527,
0.0805569589138031,
-0.25155991315841675,
-0.9160934090614319,
0.5934367775917053,
0.2702155113220215,
-0.0701761320233345,
-0.18608880043029785,
0.03158597648143768,
-0.5974692106246948,
-0.14238417148590088,
0.21494784951210022,
0.22656072676181793,
-0.6333189606666565,
0.05445026606321335,
0.32921069860458374,
-0.3312363028526306,
-0.30684882402420044,
-0.46420273184776306,
0.9065452218055725,
0.04922526329755783,
-0.3896973431110382,
-0.6374368071556091,
0.6568167805671692,
0.8625577688217163,
-0.5064822435379028,
0.2703821361064911,
0.3027958869934082,
-0.49025821685791016,
0.1132437139749527,
-0.3642854690551758,
0.10272582620382309,
-0.3955796957015991,
0.3977431654930115,
-0.5243468880653381,
-0.6333594918251038,
0.4240089952945709,
-0.17136560380458832,
0.014916747808456421,
0.6361169815063477,
0.14521144330501556,
0.09444567561149597,
1.0915957689285278,
0.44455865025520325,
0.033810488879680634,
0.7695227861404419,
-0.3293854296207428,
-0.1841753125190735,
-0.6732412576675415,
-0.21055343747138977,
-0.7527717351913452,
-0.12047876417636871,
-0.30220159888267517,
-0.8069323301315308,
0.3973761200904846,
-0.046172790229320526,
0.19177429378032684,
0.6092759966850281,
-0.45395395159721375,
0.4949931800365448,
0.6342227458953857,
0.08492954820394516,
0.3548637926578522,
0.2170785367488861,
-0.22078624367713928,
-0.14705677330493927,
-0.6866501569747925,
-0.5446757674217224,
0.7703250050544739,
0.4932529628276825,
0.6079633235931396,
-0.48805683851242065,
0.890289306640625,
0.19904763996601105,
-0.08716250956058502,
-0.9026148915290833,
0.6173583269119263,
-0.6794195175170898,
-0.2327582985162735,
-0.6854920983314514,
-0.2948361039161682,
-1.1333515644073486,
0.27284717559814453,
0.11857422441244125,
-0.35850730538368225,
0.4325146973133087,
-0.27717363834381104,
-0.5557605028152466,
0.16456055641174316,
-0.678341269493103,
0.7615301609039307,
-0.2618075907230377,
0.12839946150779724,
-0.28768545389175415,
-0.6383765935897827,
0.12387300282716751,
-0.2360524982213974,
0.20220409333705902,
0.03420610725879669,
-0.032183222472667694,
0.8520151376724243,
-0.8260875344276428,
0.6681996583938599,
-0.016657011583447456,
-0.24434112012386322,
0.24082988500595093,
0.08424350619316101,
0.16601978242397308,
-0.11492669582366943,
-0.14738330245018005,
0.27213484048843384,
0.31916821002960205,
-0.2538253366947174,
-0.3256894648075104,
0.25076377391815186,
-0.5833063125610352,
-0.26339927315711975,
-0.4057244062423706,
-0.514860987663269,
-0.032866064459085464,
0.08784874528646469,
0.44801414012908936,
0.41929590702056885,
-0.19868993759155273,
0.1125010997056961,
0.703029215335846,
-0.004236200824379921,
0.20041027665138245,
0.3000529408454895,
-0.05444619804620743,
-0.48177608847618103,
0.8805663585662842,
0.2341386377811432,
0.2560185194015503,
0.49608153104782104,
0.11934416741132736,
-0.3506086766719818,
-0.6465571522712708,
-0.6574651002883911,
0.37389200925827026,
-0.4952744245529175,
-0.1661035716533661,
-0.2511475384235382,
-0.4707569479942322,
-0.3083817660808563,
-0.19437934458255768,
-0.5410395860671997,
-0.4992426633834839,
-0.35322925448417664,
0.1028810665011406,
0.08577471226453781,
0.7586325407028198,
-0.048289768397808075,
0.7513392567634583,
-1.0639827251434326,
0.37592583894729614,
-0.0013425659853965044,
0.07372165471315384,
-0.4436025321483612,
-0.6637796759605408,
-0.3069843053817749,
0.027462530881166458,
-0.24835659563541412,
-0.9998799562454224,
0.6089356541633606,
0.0828697681427002,
0.2618216872215271,
0.6051349639892578,
-0.33350521326065063,
1.2179224491119385,
-0.5913174152374268,
0.8070072531700134,
0.2692142724990845,
-0.9211442470550537,
0.750764012336731,
-0.291218101978302,
0.5560643672943115,
0.6027624607086182,
0.3762224316596985,
-0.8210960030555725,
-0.46086329221725464,
-0.4626101851463318,
-0.726010262966156,
1.052801489830017,
0.1659119874238968,
0.0915689542889595,
-0.4038964807987213,
0.28529679775238037,
0.4650360345840454,
-0.3049238324165344,
-0.40302783250808716,
-0.049957454204559326,
0.07620097696781158,
-0.16372793912887573,
0.18839572370052338,
-0.3563513457775116,
0.03396473824977875,
-0.255853533744812,
0.6214733719825745,
0.0741942822933197,
0.19909493625164032,
0.10920723527669907,
-0.4349266588687897,
-0.1582583636045456,
0.052614279091358185,
0.45771121978759766,
0.3973369598388672,
0.06320831179618835,
0.023440830409526825,
-0.025847485288977623,
-0.7712435126304626,
0.1809985339641571,
0.19991475343704224,
-0.32496097683906555,
0.6222196817398071,
0.39597827196121216,
0.8329752683639526,
0.4817843735218048,
-0.45688292384147644,
0.29124006628990173,
0.036690447479486465,
-0.16826996207237244,
0.18009601533412933,
-0.2556513547897339,
-0.3584851920604706,
0.03684186562895775,
0.31898197531700134,
0.03118261508643627,
-0.07720919698476791,
-0.3709303140640259,
0.3352736830711365,
0.29891446232795715,
-0.31099480390548706,
-0.42252448201179504,
0.1367621272802353,
0.4263851046562195,
-0.49144527316093445,
0.6970190405845642,
-0.07306195795536041,
-0.3508777320384979,
0.5153810977935791,
0.5166496634483337,
1.0596091747283936,
-0.8599740266799927,
0.49811047315597534,
0.3434026539325714,
0.12775792181491852,
-0.2846694588661194,
0.28254982829093933,
-0.09283152222633362,
-0.17840757966041565,
-0.4279414713382721,
-0.9178853631019592,
-0.11696962267160416,
0.314003586769104,
-0.6677375435829163,
0.5187653303146362,
-0.26132187247276306,
-0.20837828516960144,
0.03654823079705238,
-0.5297372341156006,
-0.3672058880329132,
0.27031418681144714,
0.3800877332687378,
0.8828976154327393,
-0.7644347548484802,
0.8509145975112915,
0.5386366248130798,
-0.5709581971168518,
-0.3206019997596741,
-0.0901818722486496,
-0.16213713586330414,
-1.0991218090057373,
0.6089321374893188,
0.16840551793575287,
0.007100764196366072,
-0.04155515879392624,
-0.1388104259967804,
-1.1016829013824463,
0.7718788385391235,
0.8096539974212646,
-0.44774314761161804,
-0.7643369436264038,
0.7600394487380981,
0.5135605931282043,
-0.3561752438545227,
0.009590818546712399,
0.6643717288970947,
0.34418442845344543,
0.2881580591201782,
-0.9080050587654114,
-0.12277825176715851,
-0.20507250726222992,
0.2953067123889923,
0.3494258522987366,
-0.12707044184207916,
0.657037615776062,
0.3156299889087677,
-0.5370198488235474,
0.4297352433204651,
0.5380737781524658,
0.030216336250305176,
0.14583082497119904,
0.6825817823410034,
0.5863369703292847,
0.8217318058013916,
-0.17056742310523987,
0.7317230701446533,
-0.4846073389053345,
-0.06647520512342453,
0.8891713619232178,
0.2424781322479248,
0.7443901896476746,
0.5385687351226807,
-0.027470340952277184,
0.474941611289978,
0.9940553307533264,
0.09795523434877396,
0.4099041819572449,
0.10878188908100128,
-0.2753277122974396,
-0.3892837166786194,
-0.5060357451438904,
-0.6398018598556519,
0.49548065662384033,
0.5908731818199158,
-0.7868019342422485,
-0.371916264295578,
0.06625016778707504,
-0.13649559020996094,
-0.05899006873369217,
-0.5465404391288757,
0.7931521534919739,
0.14606745541095734,
-0.9464749097824097,
0.7172982692718506,
0.16145218908786774,
0.2884432375431061,
-0.9269832372665405,
-0.0793747827410698,
-0.36437085270881653,
-0.36689293384552,
-0.11960429698228836,
-0.6619229912757874,
0.6661619544029236,
0.10792212188243866,
0.017968159168958664,
-0.6716493368148804,
0.416799396276474,
-0.39918896555900574,
-0.5190384387969971,
0.07940956950187683,
0.6537065505981445,
0.2866283357143402,
-0.11199367046356201,
-0.4406237006187439,
0.0188087560236454,
-0.08817778527736664,
0.2728976905345917,
0.2741420865058899,
0.7180226445198059,
-0.41016581654548645,
0.2878973186016083,
0.48759523034095764,
-0.16456492245197296,
0.2220757156610489,
0.23415809869766235,
0.665113091468811,
-0.4931979477405548,
-0.7671923041343689,
-0.8774306774139404,
0.533734917640686,
-0.025082500651478767,
-0.4642138183116913,
0.25307148694992065,
0.7777996063232422,
0.6809301972389221,
-0.24276772141456604,
0.6683064103126526,
0.22986885905265808,
0.05000847205519676,
-0.5735309720039368,
0.37338635325431824,
-0.49945226311683655,
0.04608531296253204,
-0.23393185436725616,
-0.5376735329627991,
-0.23944467306137085,
0.5454401969909668,
-0.24829496443271637,
-0.5683190822601318,
0.9585241675376892,
0.5704459547996521,
-0.19246728718280792,
0.21150551736354828,
0.3959742784500122,
-0.24530071020126343,
-0.12855160236358643,
0.18625310063362122,
0.7276517152786255,
-0.03211604058742523,
0.5921169519424438,
-0.14826028048992157,
-0.20037323236465454,
-0.150638610124588,
-0.3387472331523895,
-0.629777193069458,
-1.1510103940963745,
-0.19366677105426788,
-0.2217540740966797,
0.1594008505344391,
0.8754468560218811,
0.8953207731246948,
-0.5271111130714417,
-0.5309436917304993,
-0.1749165952205658,
0.1618555635213852,
-0.12477469444274902,
-0.08004312217235565,
0.3081452548503876,
-0.8170559406280518,
-0.9857645034790039,
0.5931005477905273,
0.5602617263793945,
0.20202749967575073,
-0.20706287026405334,
0.0326075553894043,
-0.1343582272529602,
0.044628046452999115,
0.6267895102500916,
0.3398728668689728,
-0.7193558216094971,
0.042401738464832306,
0.11983679234981537,
-0.23921717703342438,
0.4141333997249603,
1.058337688446045,
-0.4560966193675995,
0.5449255704879761,
0.490792453289032,
0.8001863956451416,
0.4894237518310547,
-0.030260605737566948,
0.8594662547111511,
-0.8755117654800415,
0.002481928328052163,
0.24783673882484436,
0.5631470680236816,
0.23106111586093903,
-0.33059564232826233,
0.6652457118034363,
0.5214462280273438,
0.10135015100240707,
-0.8138781189918518,
0.3918105661869049,
-1.039402723312378,
-0.29837748408317566,
1.3088264465332031,
-0.1831243336200714,
-0.24761468172073364,
-0.12051773071289062,
-0.5561702251434326,
0.4614518880844116,
-0.2866239845752716,
0.5414897203445435,
0.6283593773841858,
0.19171278178691864,
0.12184169888496399,
-0.044170599430799484,
0.36433520913124084,
0.3624163269996643,
-0.910523533821106,
-0.032264139503240585,
0.5525420308113098,
-0.07103084772825241,
0.5307078957557678,
0.6020115613937378,
-0.3546091914176941,
0.2698921859264374,
-0.024792570620775223,
-0.21920235455036163,
0.16770485043525696,
-0.29318320751190186,
-0.6145601868629456,
0.2789650559425354,
-0.19555801153182983,
-0.4125441014766693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14814v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14814v2
|
The opportunities and risks of large language models in mental health
| 2024-03-21T19:59:52 | 2024-03-26T18:10:10 |
Hannah R. Lawrence, Renee A. Schneider, Susan B. Rubin, Maja J. Mataric, Daniel J. McDuff, Megan Jones Bell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Global rates of mental health concerns are rising and there is increasing
realization that existing models of mental healthcare will not adequately
expand to meet the demand. With the emergence of large language models (LLMs)
has come great optimism regarding their promise to create novel, large-scale
solutions to support mental health. Despite their nascence, LLMs have already
been applied to mental health-related tasks. In this review, we summarize the
extant literature on efforts to use LLMs to provide mental health education,
assessment, and intervention and highlight key opportunities for positive
impact in each area. We then highlight risks associated with LLMs application
to mental health and encourage adoption of strategies to mitigate these risks.
The urgent need for mental health support must be balanced with responsible
development, testing, and deployment of mental health LLMs. Especially critical
is ensuring that mental health LLMs are fine-tuned for mental health, enhance
mental health equity, adhere to ethical standards, and that people, including
those with lived experience with mental health concerns, are involved in all
stages from development through deployment. Prioritizing these efforts will
minimize potential harms to mental health and maximize the likelihood that LLMs
will positively impact mental health globally.
|
[
-0.23453254997730255,
-0.6255453824996948,
0.9776445627212524,
0.22034578025341034,
0.05188959464430809,
0.037361349910497665,
-0.28779423236846924,
-0.6999232172966003,
0.02606694959104061,
0.6637035608291626,
-0.5441061854362488,
-0.1416473239660263,
-0.9298686981201172,
-0.15068411827087402,
-0.3197486996650696,
0.828401505947113,
-0.25116968154907227,
0.24772389233112335,
-0.08010897785425186,
0.29624536633491516,
-0.6107813715934753,
-0.8150449395179749,
-0.8405086398124695,
-0.38656967878341675,
0.8305650949478149,
0.214187890291214,
0.8350597620010376,
0.06570950150489807,
0.7027437090873718,
0.23479807376861572,
-0.17067426443099976,
-0.16907748579978943,
-0.504627525806427,
0.1825510561466217,
-0.26365283131599426,
-0.43582460284233093,
-0.6477595567703247,
0.04544222727417946,
0.6533015966415405,
0.9305940270423889,
-0.6065568327903748,
0.22850053012371063,
-0.1100282296538353,
0.46749958395957947,
-0.478532612323761,
0.010509717278182507,
-0.3308130204677582,
0.0718979761004448,
-0.19595983624458313,
0.07254908233880997,
-0.10277574509382248,
-0.27943313121795654,
0.037631407380104065,
-0.17741453647613525,
-0.5088680982589722,
-0.07420739531517029,
0.3068319261074066,
0.11916789412498474,
-0.7775320410728455,
-0.3054850399494171,
-0.890309751033783,
0.7547964453697205,
-0.7837632894515991,
0.21309144794940948,
0.32764050364494324,
0.38063591718673706,
-0.6916415095329285,
-0.6017647385597229,
-0.3045693635940552,
-0.04299091175198555,
0.20233285427093506,
-0.11497518420219421,
-0.3290433883666992,
0.3265370726585388,
0.3841080069541931,
0.3678431808948517,
-0.34323611855506897,
0.39994463324546814,
-0.3999049961566925,
0.03861835598945618,
0.8602851033210754,
0.4907922148704529,
0.7472355365753174,
0.14033734798431396,
-0.015305242501199245,
0.1477157175540924,
-0.7757107019424438,
-0.12987978756427765,
0.1744377613067627,
0.21762387454509735,
-0.0845571830868721,
0.9396352171897888,
0.23047849535942078,
0.28148481249809265,
-0.3369603455066681,
-0.5676257610321045,
-0.11075157672166824,
0.029767172411084175,
-0.3095283508300781,
0.0676342323422432,
0.46975141763687134,
0.36870214343070984,
0.24758180975914001,
-0.12215671688318253,
-0.26835399866104126,
0.15815138816833496,
0.5505660772323608,
-0.7604904770851135,
0.42321541905403137,
0.35670778155326843,
-0.4084540903568268,
0.18748439848423004,
-0.15389056503772736,
-0.7201644778251648,
-0.8310339450836182,
-0.4100343883037567,
0.2970258593559265,
-0.20669439435005188,
-0.4715626537799835,
0.5492043495178223,
0.1281893104314804,
0.1930174082517624,
0.2389097660779953,
-0.6869149804115295,
0.3500370681285858,
0.9864965081214905,
0.7530575394630432,
-0.06298191845417023,
-0.02220173366367817,
-0.17493630945682526,
0.333378404378891,
-0.5362751483917236,
0.2757296562194824,
-0.28145119547843933,
-0.5595996379852295,
0.34978359937667847,
-0.007353839930146933,
0.2032630294561386,
-0.40099036693573,
0.6137673854827881,
-0.03975474834442139,
-0.0964059829711914,
-0.48062193393707275,
-0.4404563009738922,
-0.021338948979973793,
0.05221555382013321,
-0.3974384367465973,
0.49254611134529114,
0.2087210714817047,
-0.8100436329841614,
-0.1209191307425499,
-0.5008788108825684,
-0.7596678137779236,
0.048176560550928116,
0.042593855410814285,
-0.04949624091386795,
0.5454863905906677,
-0.0410379059612751,
0.6440685987472534,
-0.5385587215423584,
0.28582051396369934,
-0.5505576729774475,
-0.4624377191066742,
0.41192182898521423,
-0.5255172848701477,
1.0156325101852417,
0.2399008572101593,
-0.2676927149295807,
0.15412703156471252,
-0.22696368396282196,
-0.041571538895368576,
0.3137378394603729,
-0.09424294531345367,
-0.4141587018966675,
0.16154098510742188,
0.20180709660053253,
0.355875164270401,
0.23705460131168365,
-0.25822713971138,
-0.09944035112857819,
-0.3345129191875458,
0.39897868037223816,
0.5357869267463684,
0.28942403197288513,
0.09087786823511124,
-0.39765527844429016,
0.9119594097137451,
-0.288265198469162,
0.6206306219100952,
-0.053926657885313034,
-0.4359009563922882,
-0.16558317840099335,
-0.6033114790916443,
-0.17843306064605713,
0.6592877507209778,
-0.40993139147758484,
0.44961321353912354,
0.012150539085268974,
-0.8129822611808777,
-0.33545881509780884,
0.05696692690253258,
0.027728818356990814,
-0.056784577667713165,
-0.14022235572338104,
-0.12083666771650314,
-0.48229965567588806,
-0.6921305060386658,
-0.22855380177497864,
-0.2721383273601532,
0.04931221157312393,
0.05253048613667488,
0.41734498739242554,
-0.777594804763794,
0.524957001209259,
-0.5866162180900574,
-0.3306671679019928,
-0.22329697012901306,
-0.14569851756095886,
0.035734307020902634,
0.33265671133995056,
0.5586656928062439,
-0.6104204654693604,
-0.28331929445266724,
-0.020536523312330246,
-0.8021541833877563,
-0.18166479468345642,
0.16171109676361084,
-0.18281389772891998,
-0.280442476272583,
0.3906189799308777,
-0.8225521445274353,
-0.04810037091374397,
0.8064389824867249,
0.016887076199054718,
0.541262686252594,
-0.2504027783870697,
-0.21004049479961395,
-1.03138267993927,
-0.09001704305410385,
0.1598503291606903,
-0.10086055099964142,
-0.7166609764099121,
0.15493206679821014,
-0.15342286229133606,
-0.29474249482154846,
-0.3954801857471466,
0.47727149724960327,
-0.35602185130119324,
0.28716084361076355,
-0.37703853845596313,
0.02232210896909237,
-0.28306862711906433,
-0.3037000298500061,
-0.3871837258338928,
0.5834885835647583,
0.5671762228012085,
-0.25331977009773254,
0.4522174894809723,
-0.18009252846240997,
-0.4872165322303772,
0.6621092557907104,
-0.48648080229759216,
-0.15272381901741028,
-0.06250379979610443,
0.38486334681510925,
-0.4757459759712219,
-0.2710477113723755,
0.11767752468585968,
-0.045886121690273285,
0.5254713296890259,
0.46176445484161377,
-0.6961868405342102,
-0.7753078937530518,
-0.19176720082759857,
0.1951044499874115,
0.3838864862918854,
-0.1834719479084015,
0.13801372051239014,
1.0401668548583984,
-0.5157110095024109,
-0.4731924831867218,
-0.5723327398300171,
0.4801105856895447,
-0.5752893090248108,
-0.29236024618148804,
0.06352595239877701,
-0.11215279251337051,
-0.5474347472190857,
-0.18496373295783997,
0.004984637722373009,
0.15582811832427979,
0.562232255935669,
0.4783128499984741,
0.16892875730991364,
-0.02097715251147747,
0.30836737155914307,
0.0095641715452075,
-0.13838109374046326,
0.4782079756259918,
-0.23942619562149048,
0.31746962666511536,
-0.1373351812362671,
-0.42996782064437866,
-0.15524017810821533,
0.9297106266021729,
0.7692000865936279,
-0.18430623412132263,
0.8096131682395935,
0.4264594316482544,
-0.9035263061523438,
0.15142516791820526,
-0.685677707195282,
-0.18023718893527985,
-0.3934619128704071,
0.669197142124176,
0.0755075067281723,
-0.9799712300300598,
0.0585978627204895,
-0.233541801571846,
-0.024536600336432457,
0.073349229991436,
0.5836282968521118,
-0.39129769802093506,
1.2333590984344482,
0.9199835062026978,
-0.13712821900844574,
0.49922069907188416,
0.0423569530248642,
0.7495347857475281,
-0.7955345511436462,
0.03923787176609039,
-0.2555267810821533,
-0.0628390982747078,
-0.7620497345924377,
-0.5658525228500366,
0.43336349725723267,
0.026074301451444626,
-0.5315965414047241,
-0.14255988597869873,
-0.18798598647117615,
-0.039272554218769073,
0.11946137249469757,
-0.0699581727385521,
0.35517361760139465,
-0.056893490254879,
0.004915700294077396,
-0.49848002195358276,
-0.4107886850833893,
-0.6505524516105652,
0.8353917598724365,
0.8422170877456665,
1.3144572973251343,
0.17443765699863434,
0.4276569187641144,
0.22163626551628113,
0.6419793367385864,
-0.8060358166694641,
0.48229503631591797,
-0.03273996338248253,
-0.7257352471351624,
-0.3890354335308075,
-0.3755837082862854,
-0.7798836827278137,
0.07046792656183243,
-0.22905233502388,
-0.9145252108573914,
-0.06224941834807396,
-0.15816932916641235,
-0.09579947590827942,
0.3193974494934082,
-0.5008607506752014,
0.578585147857666,
-0.6991719007492065,
0.07405514270067215,
-0.45223718881607056,
-0.5436547994613647,
0.5652771592140198,
-0.5189679265022278,
0.4589751958847046,
-0.5257141590118408,
0.0403318777680397,
0.561498761177063,
0.13101588189601898,
0.9050859212875366,
-0.034545283764600754,
-0.6066577434539795,
0.11856546252965927,
-0.18460623919963837,
0.23315532505512238,
0.1261110156774521,
-0.11556583642959595,
0.21833103895187378,
0.20437711477279663,
-0.2532118260860443,
-0.5280132293701172,
0.8558046817779541,
-0.7856246829032898,
-1.1688785552978516,
-0.5359981656074524,
-0.6472894549369812,
-0.4428296685218811,
0.30623623728752136,
-0.1770634949207306,
0.046399157494306564,
-0.3891214430332184,
-0.13032101094722748,
0.6289754509925842,
-0.5161221027374268,
0.05757094919681549,
0.421798437833786,
-0.6170029640197754,
-0.5977582335472107,
0.6800172924995422,
0.1566554605960846,
0.29414427280426025,
-0.09484953433275223,
0.2196236252784729,
-0.17530478537082672,
-0.4236498177051544,
0.3067280054092407,
0.6944159269332886,
-0.6384189128875732,
-0.17321214079856873,
-0.4509945511817932,
-0.4375768005847931,
-0.5012982487678528,
-0.32040518522262573,
-0.4216974973678589,
0.17419536411762238,
-0.05277968943119049,
-0.2889074683189392,
0.2853895127773285,
0.8498702049255371,
-0.12240418046712875,
0.2836557924747467,
-0.6730633974075317,
0.13632583618164062,
0.3216779828071594,
0.5427868962287903,
0.21817012131214142,
0.01737429015338421,
-0.44786667823791504,
0.09042961895465851,
-0.25807446241378784,
-0.9093270301818848,
0.3230884373188019,
-0.2833321988582611,
0.771872878074646,
0.6254271864891052,
0.14027920365333557,
0.7449442744255066,
-0.7777726054191589,
0.47241732478141785,
0.508626401424408,
-0.8296535015106201,
0.5238862037658691,
-0.41213053464889526,
0.20380252599716187,
0.328647255897522,
0.6538404822349548,
-1.1465966701507568,
-0.5633605718612671,
-0.36453890800476074,
-1.008771538734436,
0.3365437686443329,
-0.12707611918449402,
0.6256608963012695,
-0.22844810783863068,
0.4502546787261963,
-0.21476717293262482,
0.23853617906570435,
-0.5185019373893738,
-0.15309450030326843,
0.3346109986305237,
-0.17316877841949463,
-0.37294238805770874,
-0.49575096368789673,
-0.5299908518791199,
-0.11467121541500092,
0.6766981482505798,
0.007479329593479633,
0.2940431833267212,
0.1288408637046814,
0.07929312437772751,
-0.3401525020599365,
0.4868147373199463,
0.4282708466053009,
0.5512591600418091,
-0.15557990968227386,
0.201370507478714,
0.15528881549835205,
-0.45013707876205444,
0.4151446521282196,
-0.043690066784620285,
0.19891779124736786,
-0.31940487027168274,
0.17514699697494507,
0.4855218231678009,
0.4771517217159271,
-1.0003290176391602,
0.32999178767204285,
0.09085185080766678,
0.1164058968424797,
-0.3665517270565033,
0.035685453563928604,
0.5467737317085266,
0.515380859375,
0.09933552891016006,
-0.49300435185432434,
-0.060550179332494736,
-0.779642641544342,
-0.13302965462207794,
0.6980701684951782,
-0.4878305494785309,
-0.11969926208257675,
0.3950960338115692,
-0.0729178637266159,
-0.43820858001708984,
0.3871179223060608,
0.24500764906406403,
-0.29254797101020813,
0.44029301404953003,
0.9078980684280396,
0.6737015843391418,
-0.43543532490730286,
0.03829727694392204,
0.016666479408740997,
0.6429806351661682,
-0.38566267490386963,
0.227939635515213,
0.6440852284431458,
-0.505254864692688,
-0.2864609360694885,
-0.37428751587867737,
-0.6246467232704163,
0.37713944911956787,
-0.654434084892273,
0.27999913692474365,
-0.45389553904533386,
-0.6987829208374023,
-0.37661826610565186,
0.19697314500808716,
-0.5141102075576782,
0.11026009917259216,
0.8307588696479797,
0.9426275491714478,
-0.9399503469467163,
0.6830331683158875,
0.8736765384674072,
-0.035200756043195724,
-0.512814998626709,
0.2112860530614853,
0.28024908900260925,
-0.32333773374557495,
0.0982264056801796,
0.33769723773002625,
0.014239400625228882,
-0.225771963596344,
-0.2254229635000229,
-1.0493099689483643,
1.0169429779052734,
0.8756450414657593,
-0.5188968777656555,
-0.27544766664505005,
0.18982313573360443,
0.521935224533081,
-0.5637685060501099,
0.13674364984035492,
0.44111743569374084,
0.6717747449874878,
-0.18968449532985687,
-0.7588650584220886,
0.1291709691286087,
0.1892520636320114,
0.5868533253669739,
-0.020159853622317314,
-0.5104557871818542,
0.5761284828186035,
-0.41679900884628296,
-0.29932859539985657,
-0.05873871222138405,
0.47468438744544983,
0.2831379175186157,
-0.09147042036056519,
0.27061381936073303,
0.25528836250305176,
0.8853493928909302,
0.20387892425060272,
1.1143953800201416,
-0.0816916897892952,
0.2831869423389435,
0.9452264904975891,
-0.8529872298240662,
0.9507157802581787,
0.41324132680892944,
-0.3599183261394501,
0.0018441162537783384,
0.7447121143341064,
0.056342314928770065,
0.2251419574022293,
0.5815859436988831,
-0.5119478702545166,
-0.06745946407318115,
-0.3577396273612976,
-0.4060034453868866,
0.2544197142124176,
1.0580586194992065,
-0.1809832602739334,
-0.24387654662132263,
0.46665263175964355,
0.17811450362205505,
0.12314349412918091,
-0.3206467032432556,
0.2697813808917999,
0.7973111271858215,
-0.26084864139556885,
0.03581784665584564,
0.1516859531402588,
0.5502049922943115,
-0.6619004011154175,
0.17430151998996735,
0.0646677017211914,
0.22754819691181183,
-0.13257212936878204,
-0.6506578326225281,
0.5732107162475586,
-0.03223376348614693,
-0.19106677174568176,
-0.21880139410495758,
0.9166536927223206,
-0.2916361093521118,
-0.8202529549598694,
0.8772061467170715,
0.6042309999465942,
-0.11232902854681015,
-0.2341490089893341,
-0.4671001136302948,
0.11524700373411179,
-0.6286584138870239,
-0.34129205346107483,
0.6992476582527161,
0.5308479070663452,
-0.2652306854724884,
0.8104162812232971,
0.4253145754337311,
0.5397730469703674,
-0.09779158979654312,
-0.06697399169206619,
0.5290436744689941,
-0.7470362186431885,
-0.06840265542268753,
-0.8220736384391785,
0.08292235434055328,
0.07655229419469833,
0.013938140124082565,
0.624131441116333,
0.014450629241764545,
0.26921945810317993,
0.05950695648789406,
0.7471174001693726,
0.21119938790798187,
0.14767184853553772,
-0.1232936829328537,
1.0348156690597534,
-0.7508060336112976,
0.09147725254297256,
-0.26516473293304443,
-0.7549241781234741,
-0.5723513960838318,
0.5192326903343201,
-0.5132031440734863,
0.0015193958533927798,
0.7310577034950256,
0.5403443574905396,
0.4545048773288727,
-0.09364308416843414,
0.6073822975158691,
0.33082515001296997,
0.627851665019989,
0.5592913031578064,
0.8967419266700745,
-0.12081097811460495,
-0.05206838622689247,
-0.07317208498716354,
-0.2513332664966583,
-0.15044626593589783,
-0.9987279176712036,
-0.8068550229072571,
-0.3020575940608978,
-0.3432285785675049,
-0.14863841235637665,
0.05627938359975815,
0.998212993144989,
0.4898017346858978,
-0.45327073335647583,
-0.3770351707935333,
0.4493880569934845,
0.2995451092720032,
-0.3671259582042694,
-0.22873029112815857,
-0.11399532854557037,
-0.08552434295415878,
-0.4202116131782532,
0.1922072321176529,
0.6324989199638367,
0.17400197684764862,
-0.6703900694847107,
0.2900083661079407,
-0.22265419363975525,
0.12325207144021988,
0.886314868927002,
0.25120094418525696,
-0.9123692512512207,
-0.22486762702465057,
-0.2949906587600708,
-0.5633255839347839,
-0.18475522100925446,
0.7194834351539612,
-0.1901283711194992,
0.051943596452474594,
0.07251740992069244,
0.852596640586853,
0.04146876558661461,
-0.6615810990333557,
0.9186277389526367,
-0.11704429984092712,
-0.0626128688454628,
0.2662634551525116,
0.5694719552993774,
0.43061375617980957,
-0.7282283902168274,
0.44628793001174927,
-0.15795403718948364,
-0.4413813054561615,
-0.9098444581031799,
0.16682860255241394,
-0.7526585459709167,
-0.11782275885343552,
1.1870427131652832,
-0.2537941038608551,
-0.03312668204307556,
0.08057110756635666,
-0.30780407786369324,
0.34741806983947754,
0.07707762718200684,
0.9027403593063354,
0.8680405020713806,
0.14112797379493713,
-0.21976840496063232,
-1.227604627609253,
0.13165508210659027,
0.23165661096572876,
-1.0212204456329346,
0.210701584815979,
0.13755272328853607,
0.35117605328559875,
-0.15395204722881317,
0.6906889081001282,
-0.3624536395072937,
0.02500632405281067,
-0.3334774971008301,
0.2616714835166931,
0.4451293647289276,
-0.1405484974384308,
-0.6164088249206543,
-0.027517415583133698,
0.33011946082115173,
0.503852128982544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14808v1
|
A Collection of Pragmatic-Similarity Judgments over Spoken Dialog Utterances
| 2024-03-21T19:46:42 | 2024-03-21T19:46:42 |
Nigel G. Ward, Divette Marco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic measures of similarity between utterances are invaluable for
training speech synthesizers, evaluating machine translation, and assessing
learner productions. While there exist measures for semantic similarity and
prosodic similarity, there are as yet none for pragmatic similarity. To enable
the training of such measures, we developed the first collection of human
judgments of pragmatic similarity between utterance pairs. Each pair consisting
of an utterance extracted from a recorded dialog and a re-enactment of that
utterance. Re-enactments were done under various conditions designed to create
a variety of degrees of similarity. Each pair was rated on a continuous scale
by 6 to 9 judges. The average inter-judge correlation was as high as 0.72 for
English and 0.66 for Spanish. We make this data available at
https://github.com/divettemarco/PragSim .
|
[
-0.48565012216567993,
-0.35058605670928955,
0.2820579707622528,
0.017282679677009583,
-0.5456356406211853,
-0.02716999128460884,
-0.373354971408844,
-0.27489909529685974,
0.46367147564888,
0.4243449866771698,
-0.2934436500072479,
-0.7085396647453308,
-0.3242638409137726,
0.1345830261707306,
-0.4815449118614197,
0.8988387584686279,
0.07531856745481491,
0.13580632209777832,
-0.26965275406837463,
-0.31696954369544983,
-0.2964390218257904,
-0.4046279788017273,
-0.29937979578971863,
-0.2985946238040924,
0.36832520365715027,
0.3110819458961487,
0.6726303696632385,
0.1955593377351761,
0.7938779592514038,
0.4359421730041504,
0.25695791840553284,
0.09145557880401611,
-0.36332741379737854,
0.1422160118818283,
-0.40620124340057373,
-0.453273743391037,
-0.3816787898540497,
0.2691165506839752,
0.827217698097229,
0.6403192281723022,
-0.30039915442466736,
0.2701435089111328,
0.1566917449235916,
0.43007892370224,
-0.022618118673563004,
0.0927225723862648,
-0.6753250360488892,
0.083221435546875,
-0.039280809462070465,
-0.3991308808326721,
-0.24308669567108154,
-0.6660279035568237,
0.4551071524620056,
-0.6004166007041931,
0.5279474854469299,
0.1602366864681244,
0.9576418399810791,
-0.029722658917307854,
-0.2634170949459076,
-0.47988420724868774,
-0.2534938454627991,
0.9005897045135498,
-0.6998445987701416,
0.4134518802165985,
0.5097722411155701,
0.3156498670578003,
-0.06583084911108017,
-0.7964361906051636,
-0.6658085584640503,
-0.4935038685798645,
-0.2160651534795761,
0.13768842816352844,
-0.08476487547159195,
0.20724524557590485,
-0.06438656151294708,
0.4401591122150421,
-0.910818874835968,
-0.1457948386669159,
-0.3768472373485565,
-0.4003625810146332,
0.7298123836517334,
0.2049809992313385,
0.20055481791496277,
-0.07075989991426468,
-0.5305999517440796,
-0.37000352144241333,
-0.4326246678829193,
-0.295107364654541,
0.5652289986610413,
0.09157192707061768,
-0.05129676312208176,
0.0822858214378357,
-0.1463448405265808,
1.0516856908798218,
-0.14368709921836853,
-0.524960458278656,
0.5808173418045044,
-0.6524877548217773,
-0.18948721885681152,
0.040683992207050323,
1.0221805572509766,
0.8492307662963867,
0.7744739651679993,
-0.25841882824897766,
-0.025429576635360718,
-0.01630604825913906,
0.45828893780708313,
-0.3913536071777344,
-0.3692581057548523,
-0.40557730197906494,
-0.4083470106124878,
-0.24800437688827515,
0.4349808692932129,
-0.5466166734695435,
-0.14602044224739075,
-0.7995089888572693,
0.4073018431663513,
-0.33873429894447327,
-0.22386029362678528,
-0.12083366513252258,
-0.14903925359249115,
0.6244535446166992,
0.19258610904216766,
-0.44172203540802,
0.46056216955184937,
1.0225261449813843,
1.0057820081710815,
-0.15290500223636627,
-0.5484974980354309,
-0.11813905835151672,
-0.4274033308029175,
-0.1658371388912201,
0.908041775226593,
-0.6038035154342651,
-0.6964382529258728,
-0.17453910410404205,
0.03486710414290428,
-0.2403172254562378,
-1.0329562425613403,
0.49379798769950867,
-0.25742802023887634,
0.11712341755628586,
0.014312801882624626,
-0.6824535131454468,
-0.28607723116874695,
0.16875962913036346,
-0.4696981906890869,
0.7501909732818604,
0.11071312427520752,
-0.6288802027702332,
0.5757652521133423,
-0.013139449991285801,
-0.5601851940155029,
0.1670018434524536,
-0.3439119756221771,
-0.40500158071517944,
0.0409950353205204,
-0.39073559641838074,
0.25406965613365173,
-0.4910764694213867,
0.29813724756240845,
-0.19792340695858002,
-0.5636389851570129,
0.5258998870849609,
-0.3037245273590088,
0.5770871043205261,
0.20073066651821136,
0.09088648855686188,
0.23911932110786438,
-0.669974684715271,
0.24268439412117004,
-0.25691935420036316,
-0.13803328573703766,
-0.34286054968833923,
-0.18151436746120453,
-0.22862526774406433,
0.25164708495140076,
0.18062274158000946,
-0.3745272755622864,
-0.1603102684020996,
-0.5417766571044922,
0.5012149810791016,
0.607974648475647,
0.34508568048477173,
0.19955240190029144,
-0.8622034788131714,
0.5615721940994263,
-0.11588343977928162,
-0.11723670363426208,
-0.1969698667526245,
-0.5811880230903625,
-0.5008566379547119,
-0.4018920660018921,
0.49746233224868774,
0.6740164756774902,
0.016570458188652992,
0.7087715864181519,
-0.44061583280563354,
-0.7978454828262329,
-0.9029759168624878,
0.3081994354724884,
0.7731477618217468,
0.50345778465271,
0.08377493917942047,
-0.7399986982345581,
-0.45820626616477966,
-1.1540745496749878,
-0.5489280223846436,
-0.3350154161453247,
-0.3864392042160034,
0.2530857026576996,
0.4684852063655853,
0.4060385227203369,
1.0606689453125,
-0.2891489267349243,
-0.37803566455841064,
0.29891735315322876,
0.3132036030292511,
0.19032077491283417,
0.4270172119140625,
0.7124511003494263,
-0.56241774559021,
-0.6145875453948975,
0.0827171728014946,
-0.5320570468902588,
-0.20865783095359802,
-0.007822103798389435,
0.00139975908678025,
-0.4064946472644806,
0.5510594844818115,
-0.3002417981624603,
0.10751228034496307,
0.35552912950515747,
-0.32110774517059326,
0.611994206905365,
-0.22966010868549347,
0.4995025098323822,
-1.075158715248108,
0.01292617991566658,
-0.15397372841835022,
-0.47915658354759216,
-0.4919586181640625,
-0.1504792720079422,
-0.2789352238178253,
-0.010986258275806904,
-0.7561467289924622,
0.5859491229057312,
-0.22507290542125702,
-0.34536686539649963,
-0.02374495007097721,
0.6132822632789612,
0.09740947932004929,
0.5265249609947205,
0.03696780651807785,
0.9976357221603394,
0.6516793966293335,
-0.5815426707267761,
0.6989462375640869,
0.35974791646003723,
-0.9106943011283875,
1.1701545715332031,
-0.8131032586097717,
0.41077250242233276,
-0.008285252377390862,
0.11996155232191086,
-0.9717262387275696,
-0.05591484159231186,
0.12706470489501953,
-0.7440735101699829,
0.1421147882938385,
0.06492506712675095,
-0.30539777874946594,
-0.002341215731576085,
-0.3084218502044678,
0.225259929895401,
0.7070851922035217,
-0.2899682819843292,
0.3139054477214813,
0.4704470634460449,
-0.4151012599468231,
-0.11686450988054276,
-0.6225417256355286,
0.0063420808874070644,
-0.4307185709476471,
-0.500822901725769,
0.24837347865104675,
0.1679452806711197,
-0.6892063021659851,
-0.1517077088356018,
-0.1839865893125534,
-0.07223213464021683,
-0.03215117007493973,
0.42534324526786804,
-0.06412559747695923,
-0.1394609808921814,
0.1809476613998413,
-0.2773403525352478,
-0.07770013809204102,
0.09112854301929474,
-0.24582120776176453,
0.43301624059677124,
-0.37709707021713257,
-0.5377092361450195,
-0.6243152618408203,
0.4021218419075012,
0.42583397030830383,
-0.07238801568746567,
0.47607919573783875,
0.2676459848880768,
-0.18442876636981964,
0.15839266777038574,
-0.5168729424476624,
-0.13870830833911896,
-0.4116733968257904,
0.3169381618499756,
-0.758749783039093,
-0.6506691575050354,
0.40339288115501404,
0.13913147151470184,
0.1863919198513031,
0.11867865920066833,
0.7086237668991089,
-0.41737890243530273,
0.5649146437644958,
-0.12862762808799744,
0.045660682022571564,
0.7135998010635376,
0.07841096818447113,
0.13844431936740875,
-0.44538748264312744,
-0.18972495198249817,
-0.6188309192657471,
-0.520389974117279,
-0.556434690952301,
-0.5758432745933533,
-0.019829407334327698,
0.016066471114754677,
-0.10315331816673279,
0.6062463521957397,
-0.18959222733974457,
0.4935402572154999,
0.746548593044281,
-0.008849689736962318,
0.2603156864643097,
-0.060578130185604095,
-0.041294243186712265,
-0.2311505377292633,
-0.33831024169921875,
-0.8338962197303772,
0.8203811049461365,
0.06581096351146698,
0.520083487033844,
0.11811000853776932,
0.9285105466842651,
0.593148410320282,
0.1299797147512436,
-0.8832879662513733,
0.8943710327148438,
-0.0660298764705658,
-0.13433623313903809,
-0.03279067948460579,
-0.4147195518016815,
-1.0721807479858398,
0.427747517824173,
-0.07200027257204056,
-0.4218568801879883,
-0.00015451209037564695,
0.10310741513967514,
-0.1553688794374466,
-0.23205408453941345,
-0.9152820706367493,
0.8296698927879333,
-0.11473802477121353,
-0.023241659626364708,
-0.6510278582572937,
-0.8437995314598083,
-0.11265107989311218,
-0.05745532736182213,
-0.04457784444093704,
-0.31718429923057556,
0.10207343846559525,
1.0935628414154053,
-0.4405347406864166,
0.6824248433113098,
-0.1429048627614975,
0.0775422751903534,
0.713184654712677,
0.22611673176288605,
-0.06671982258558273,
-0.20441772043704987,
-0.08595460653305054,
0.34171608090400696,
0.11377222836017609,
-0.3208864629268646,
-0.594700038433075,
0.8651990294456482,
-0.5406460762023926,
-0.4757547378540039,
-0.411996990442276,
-0.22041773796081543,
-0.10314547270536423,
0.07591792196035385,
-0.04112476855516434,
0.5306239724159241,
-0.6292868852615356,
0.26279082894325256,
0.35691165924072266,
0.009900263510644436,
0.05808001756668091,
0.7347265481948853,
0.08121198415756226,
-0.32848066091537476,
1.1018682718276978,
-0.1137007474899292,
0.471951961517334,
0.45961809158325195,
0.04300996661186218,
-0.34082862734794617,
-0.30941498279571533,
-0.1137305274605751,
0.3416701853275299,
-0.6401579976081848,
-0.30231767892837524,
-0.2999953031539917,
0.12206204980611801,
-0.4243997037410736,
-0.2379239946603775,
0.036123115569353104,
-0.41142192482948303,
-0.18532298505306244,
-0.26813405752182007,
0.4584633409976959,
0.5570904016494751,
0.05816436558961868,
0.37451326847076416,
-0.8454477190971375,
0.3097124695777893,
0.663965106010437,
0.1519070863723755,
-0.37625110149383545,
-0.9030908346176147,
0.04143975302577019,
0.03375191614031792,
-0.1917678564786911,
-0.9055253863334656,
0.3966006338596344,
0.7762548923492432,
0.6111945509910583,
0.491350919008255,
-0.0891370177268982,
0.757713258266449,
-0.49032673239707947,
0.7146397829055786,
0.32070815563201904,
-0.7854066491127014,
0.5188389420509338,
-0.14380979537963867,
0.11083859205245972,
1.0522176027297974,
0.24455122649669647,
-0.43316835165023804,
-0.5494215488433838,
-0.7571895718574524,
-0.5348812937736511,
0.5339911580085754,
0.0785912573337555,
0.03865863010287285,
-0.25185802578926086,
0.1322833150625229,
0.1575939655303955,
0.336270809173584,
0.06971912831068039,
-0.021121429279446602,
-0.1330346316099167,
-0.5203056931495667,
-0.20397600531578064,
0.20264045894145966,
-0.31856730580329895,
-0.17394597828388214,
0.3094618320465088,
-0.026523178443312645,
0.3004753291606903,
0.12782041728496552,
-0.45648670196533203,
0.23833182454109192,
0.3708980977535248,
0.5931323766708374,
0.7540941834449768,
-0.11158537864685059,
0.32874900102615356,
0.4226336181163788,
-0.6718682050704956,
0.12838546931743622,
-0.20274102687835693,
0.15906713902950287,
0.19560377299785614,
0.5631396770477295,
1.004194736480713,
0.5382483005523682,
-1.0718977451324463,
0.633428156375885,
-0.06463919579982758,
-0.2927495539188385,
-0.4222918152809143,
0.11306486278772354,
-0.01866767182946205,
0.17460791766643524,
-0.2830626666545868,
-0.17132984101772308,
0.15382236242294312,
-0.693734884262085,
0.644327700138092,
0.20855586230754852,
-0.4307613670825958,
-0.47485071420669556,
0.10328441113233566,
0.4954927861690521,
-0.8800811171531677,
0.7329957485198975,
-0.33855941891670227,
-0.5552740693092346,
0.5489935874938965,
0.36212357878685,
0.6945460438728333,
-0.25932496786117554,
0.15464900434017181,
0.6136396527290344,
-0.09239552170038223,
-0.11658437550067902,
0.20544402301311493,
-0.5802677273750305,
-0.5405097007751465,
0.04158330708742142,
-0.8368335962295532,
-0.5737609267234802,
-0.43181371688842773,
-0.9236034154891968,
0.4432625472545624,
-0.2810420095920563,
-0.35095635056495667,
-0.1520853191614151,
0.010172265581786633,
-0.7817913293838501,
0.19510295987129211,
-0.011438102461397648,
0.712241530418396,
-1.041404366493225,
0.8604352474212646,
0.8725677132606506,
-0.2908676564693451,
-0.4827554523944855,
-0.11894587427377701,
-0.06724855303764343,
-0.9496967792510986,
0.40478187799453735,
0.08297199010848999,
-0.36882877349853516,
0.010295764543116093,
0.10512703657150269,
-0.22754542529582977,
1.042305588722229,
0.23496095836162567,
-1.0845577716827393,
-0.03269783779978752,
0.019318977370858192,
0.7165140509605408,
-0.30253246426582336,
0.4982970356941223,
1.1732488870620728,
0.353024423122406,
-0.14086320996284485,
-1.4474565982818604,
-0.2845466434955597,
-0.23714889585971832,
-0.3435153067111969,
0.3688686192035675,
-0.5473599433898926,
0.5479050278663635,
0.024639632552862167,
-0.32347676157951355,
-0.001911753206513822,
0.48672404885292053,
0.24455861747264862,
0.3054969608783722,
0.6504406332969666,
0.6803423166275024,
0.786529541015625,
-0.057092923671007156,
0.6279932856559753,
-0.478159099817276,
0.3552953600883484,
1.4937595129013062,
-0.3892735540866852,
0.8199694156646729,
0.4169263243675232,
-0.5560234189033508,
0.32583460211753845,
0.36577844619750977,
-0.03060375340282917,
0.38845837116241455,
0.33315566182136536,
-0.2948107123374939,
-0.112541563808918,
-0.20747222006320953,
-0.27061575651168823,
0.48964428901672363,
0.41095152497291565,
-0.4074621796607971,
-0.07507845014333725,
-0.06330898404121399,
-0.08677075803279877,
0.47000500559806824,
-0.1189439669251442,
1.1907024383544922,
0.3013463318347931,
-0.8894228935241699,
0.5677065849304199,
-0.42486193776130676,
0.5760552287101746,
-0.6322656273841858,
-0.09607263654470444,
-0.06438585370779037,
-0.02271112985908985,
-0.0985986664891243,
-1.1677987575531006,
0.45859384536743164,
0.09346941113471985,
0.15594170987606049,
-0.2572561204433441,
0.5447414517402649,
-0.5015276670455933,
-0.01743549481034279,
0.3165992498397827,
0.36989080905914307,
0.8213000297546387,
0.1556236892938614,
-0.674039363861084,
-0.15417002141475677,
-0.026883432641625404,
-0.020903265103697777,
0.328259140253067,
0.06576953828334808,
-0.05908328667283058,
0.3201238214969635,
0.2681581676006317,
0.27062106132507324,
0.33523687720298767,
0.5960350632667542,
0.4354049563407898,
-0.857906699180603,
-0.5701351761817932,
-0.548055112361908,
-0.039519213140010834,
-0.09330101311206818,
-0.5327240824699402,
0.6176059246063232,
0.37495800852775574,
1.004612684249878,
-0.018258120864629745,
0.5653977394104004,
-0.031159332022070885,
0.7503591775894165,
-0.34758734703063965,
0.3899647891521454,
-0.24263137578964233,
-0.21819403767585754,
-0.13396279513835907,
-1.078722357749939,
-0.06723273545503616,
1.0431033372879028,
-0.28814050555229187,
-0.16080166399478912,
0.5757819414138794,
1.0572428703308105,
0.055032700300216675,
0.055849649012088776,
0.3651256859302521,
0.02750190533697605,
0.04480462521314621,
0.6533412933349609,
0.8052316308021545,
-0.20580612123012543,
0.49664539098739624,
-0.02968672476708889,
-0.23487095534801483,
-0.3025082051753998,
-0.5769172310829163,
-0.7783282399177551,
-0.7473061084747314,
-0.3744868338108063,
-0.1704849898815155,
0.07952111959457397,
1.16006600856781,
0.5185659527778625,
-0.9548103213310242,
-0.30902400612831116,
-0.0698922723531723,
-0.10912694036960602,
-0.3484172523021698,
-0.22558745741844177,
0.2246449589729309,
0.0073668197728693485,
-0.7329296469688416,
0.45252755284309387,
0.016183452680706978,
0.0311232041567564,
-0.20145253837108612,
-0.2518935203552246,
-0.1679544597864151,
0.10674344003200531,
0.3141246438026428,
0.3506716787815094,
-0.7589534521102905,
-0.4130396842956543,
-0.29120907187461853,
-0.09055235981941223,
0.15545964241027832,
1.0966734886169434,
-0.7774868607521057,
0.6203070878982544,
0.9853052496910095,
0.24805089831352234,
0.16285081207752228,
0.36704540252685547,
0.47641605138778687,
-0.9044694900512695,
0.4706296920776367,
0.4577539563179016,
0.2240130454301834,
0.424571692943573,
0.3695988953113556,
0.26059505343437195,
0.20120474696159363,
-0.6180977821350098,
-0.9927772879600525,
0.5274956822395325,
-1.229200839996338,
0.36837220191955566,
0.8447301983833313,
-0.5757083296775818,
0.08236777782440186,
-0.2641238868236542,
-0.4371717870235443,
0.28480011224746704,
-0.41497430205345154,
0.44969668984413147,
0.7216755151748657,
-0.08760093152523041,
0.18091368675231934,
-0.2529675364494324,
0.2186809480190277,
0.4471175968647003,
-0.6022235155105591,
-0.2328200340270996,
0.15810178220272064,
0.4459296762943268,
0.23789696395397186,
0.596214234828949,
-0.1940660923719406,
0.3518444895744324,
0.2740076184272766,
-0.08090723305940628,
0.1983678936958313,
-0.32270947098731995,
-0.417999804019928,
0.045059479773044586,
0.22023241221904755,
-0.5100240111351013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14783v1
|
Multi-Agent VQA: Exploring Multi-Agent Foundation Models in Zero-Shot Visual Question Answering
| 2024-03-21T18:57:25 | 2024-03-21T18:57:25 |
Bowen Jiang, Zhijun Zhuang, Shreyas S. Shivakumar, Dan Roth, Camillo J. Taylor
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
This work explores the zero-shot capabilities of foundation models in Visual
Question Answering (VQA) tasks. We propose an adaptive multi-agent system,
named Multi-Agent VQA, to overcome the limitations of foundation models in
object detection and counting by using specialized agents as tools. Unlike
existing approaches, our study focuses on the system's performance without
fine-tuning it on specific VQA datasets, making it more practical and robust in
the open world. We present preliminary experimental results under zero-shot
scenarios and highlight some failure cases, offering new directions for future
research.
|
[
-0.5648626089096069,
-0.9409346580505371,
0.6473652124404907,
-0.033045895397663116,
-0.18237514793872833,
0.14313936233520508,
0.3556029200553894,
-0.636963427066803,
0.12107889354228973,
0.6887475252151489,
-0.6801304221153259,
-0.3804284930229187,
-0.31166872382164,
0.1580394059419632,
-0.47008708119392395,
0.45700976252555847,
0.026196956634521484,
-0.07913710176944733,
-0.4614216089248657,
-0.5521882772445679,
-0.7955737113952637,
-0.3052215874195099,
-0.36338236927986145,
0.12579192221164703,
0.29504427313804626,
0.7607128024101257,
0.6228557825088501,
0.32000067830085754,
0.3404565751552582,
0.3687371611595154,
0.42358076572418213,
-0.02002767287194729,
-0.4324301481246948,
0.4170619249343872,
-0.17706337571144104,
-0.5781780481338501,
-0.5140258073806763,
-0.4230998754501343,
0.6340435147285461,
0.2772060036659241,
-0.017459772527217865,
0.2682914137840271,
-0.5659844279289246,
0.20951873064041138,
-1.132189154624939,
-0.04936334490776062,
-0.6312362551689148,
-0.057671550661325455,
0.21709959208965302,
-0.3172450661659241,
-0.4195740222930908,
0.2545301020145416,
0.29488667845726013,
-0.7099862694740295,
0.4060034155845642,
-0.3943239450454712,
0.6181875467300415,
0.4417906701564789,
-0.4304378628730774,
0.13013868033885956,
-0.7112440466880798,
0.6848055124282837,
-0.20423530042171478,
0.1987568885087967,
0.015579807572066784,
0.8588893413543701,
0.07704392075538635,
-0.745978593826294,
-0.6067426800727844,
-0.06378056108951569,
0.33191490173339844,
0.32240021228790283,
-0.3131336569786072,
-0.18242131173610687,
-0.03888890519738197,
0.019950417801737785,
-0.7207417488098145,
-0.29518285393714905,
-0.3046113848686218,
-0.0569840744137764,
0.4072222113609314,
0.3764970302581787,
0.27224287390708923,
0.15531161427497864,
-0.48132815957069397,
-0.11813892424106598,
-0.2529720962047577,
0.38499099016189575,
-0.22634050250053406,
0.29268375039100647,
0.16327059268951416,
0.7286060452461243,
-0.9873735904693604,
0.9448215365409851,
-0.13524146378040314,
0.1211557686328888,
0.02932284213602543,
-0.5635858178138733,
-0.5674940943717957,
-0.24720719456672668,
0.2308237999677658,
0.3674708902835846,
0.46429741382598877,
-0.1272057145833969,
-0.03495847433805466,
0.21966056525707245,
0.30814287066459656,
-0.8455855846405029,
0.006374587304890156,
0.3231498599052429,
0.06363862752914429,
-0.3064546585083008,
0.05866705998778343,
-0.5400195121765137,
-0.27542179822921753,
0.06855720281600952,
0.9599384069442749,
-0.16132231056690216,
-0.39650362730026245,
0.43775272369384766,
-0.5665354132652283,
0.7053112387657166,
0.733963668346405,
-0.1853296458721161,
0.3239894211292267,
0.23617470264434814,
0.6841457486152649,
0.24751630425453186,
-0.7172586917877197,
-0.8976848721504211,
0.22244825959205627,
-0.5481522083282471,
1.0469369888305664,
-0.5151873230934143,
-0.2951262891292572,
-0.19426219165325165,
0.3539702892303467,
-0.013212145306169987,
-0.19407188892364502,
-0.03272154554724693,
-0.558063805103302,
-0.023525936529040337,
-0.5614891648292542,
-0.0417521595954895,
-0.2672784626483917,
0.6632099151611328,
-0.6076108813285828,
0.7395331263542175,
0.2987227141857147,
-0.29959651827812195,
0.44093626737594604,
-0.6289619207382202,
-0.12066244333982468,
0.19706164300441742,
-0.2767435908317566,
-0.27123379707336426,
0.1550183743238449,
0.3846901059150696,
0.3954750597476959,
-0.20391789078712463,
-0.1521655023097992,
-0.4619845151901245,
-0.6792293787002563,
0.25002601742744446,
-0.36785733699798584,
0.8092772960662842,
-0.16252966225147247,
-0.36089950799942017,
0.37935176491737366,
-0.6970393657684326,
0.1356215476989746,
0.3615928888320923,
0.11312347650527954,
-0.13516977429389954,
-0.19042827188968658,
-0.24929609894752502,
0.37236300110816956,
0.016723018139600754,
-0.5050431489944458,
0.3130427896976471,
-0.0033047872129827738,
0.0501977801322937,
0.5799969434738159,
0.21751205623149872,
0.3881205916404724,
-0.5335168838500977,
0.7705017328262329,
0.25539302825927734,
0.22776460647583008,
-0.33811745047569275,
-0.7358956336975098,
-0.7577205300331116,
-0.4233374297618866,
0.004765188787132502,
0.5846548080444336,
-1.517266869544983,
-0.4700363874435425,
0.02828212082386017,
-0.35732123255729675,
-0.3163590431213379,
-0.19366195797920227,
0.4120466113090515,
0.44524964690208435,
0.5382686853408813,
-0.6531695127487183,
-0.09633909910917282,
-0.6300385594367981,
0.03389797732234001,
-0.2930237650871277,
0.09381089359521866,
0.4633391797542572,
0.8990880846977234,
0.22822721302509308,
0.9981669783592224,
-0.6255273222923279,
-0.1215587854385376,
0.09049925953149796,
0.005674947984516621,
-0.21925081312656403,
0.1412287950515747,
1.3029417991638184,
-0.9493732452392578,
-0.49877381324768066,
-0.15339913964271545,
-0.9382602572441101,
0.24588419497013092,
0.11467307060956955,
-0.23404894769191742,
-0.09848056733608246,
0.3032004237174988,
-0.8754636645317078,
0.8626887798309326,
0.1852148026227951,
-0.6929786205291748,
0.6418483853340149,
0.03623616695404053,
0.3196033239364624,
-0.8589032888412476,
-0.07406124472618103,
-0.11016099900007248,
-0.36766761541366577,
-1.1776676177978516,
0.5347397923469543,
-0.10061842948198318,
-0.18444347381591797,
-0.9295478463172913,
0.7376445531845093,
-0.6467159986495972,
-0.4669702649116516,
-0.5679447054862976,
-0.09037766605615616,
0.18354344367980957,
0.6497913002967834,
0.2856504023075104,
0.76935875415802,
1.058906078338623,
-0.6603174805641174,
0.5849610567092896,
0.319108247756958,
0.013759602792561054,
1.262097954750061,
-0.743502140045166,
0.17720156908035278,
-0.6588173508644104,
0.14803209900856018,
-1.1453148126602173,
-0.3480833172798157,
0.5846195816993713,
-0.8185743689537048,
-0.13117145001888275,
-0.19540923833847046,
0.04513572156429291,
-0.17474371194839478,
-0.47212931513786316,
0.4917355477809906,
-0.024377409368753433,
-0.21833717823028564,
0.8494486808776855,
-0.05263146758079529,
0.11548559367656708,
-1.0723836421966553,
-0.6905859112739563,
0.19423234462738037,
0.051046568900346756,
-0.5882994532585144,
-0.08378761261701584,
-0.29989954829216003,
-0.1627262383699417,
0.4157467484474182,
-0.20175372064113617,
-0.5067501068115234,
0.34785810112953186,
0.22477145493030548,
0.09265244007110596,
-0.6041039824485779,
0.13379286229610443,
-0.30813583731651306,
0.0836806371808052,
-0.2572923004627228,
-0.24420702457427979,
0.3175014853477478,
-0.4579451382160187,
-0.5081891417503357,
-0.11895596981048584,
0.6333315968513489,
0.9483392834663391,
-0.6887931823730469,
0.9703782796859741,
0.49359750747680664,
-0.7569303512573242,
-0.25974854826927185,
-0.24461287260055542,
-0.021840734407305717,
-0.4674626886844635,
0.3777320086956024,
-0.7897413372993469,
-0.8653612732887268,
0.5187790989875793,
0.42297297716140747,
0.045584678649902344,
0.30796030163764954,
0.8131133913993835,
0.049653902649879456,
0.6348710656166077,
0.9722267985343933,
0.27150145173072815,
0.4053499102592468,
-0.2919987440109253,
-0.3241673409938812,
-0.303348571062088,
-0.09242414683103561,
-0.5188888311386108,
-0.03589976578950882,
-0.09376563876867294,
-0.7240250110626221,
0.33521366119384766,
0.13839006423950195,
-0.3970068097114563,
0.40686026215553284,
-0.4321022629737854,
0.45756298303604126,
0.6154889464378357,
0.2629840075969696,
0.45683568716049194,
-0.23539529740810394,
0.21462690830230713,
0.6616731286048889,
-0.6267240047454834,
-0.020210424438118935,
1.0384570360183716,
-0.019737496972084045,
0.48645108938217163,
0.547477662563324,
0.3760921359062195,
0.21605341136455536,
0.2759671211242676,
-0.7892959713935852,
0.6110499501228333,
0.17648698389530182,
-1.0297693014144897,
-0.9561243653297424,
-0.10920529067516327,
-0.7730337977409363,
0.7522716522216797,
-0.2592853903770447,
-0.7684966921806335,
0.7472048997879028,
-0.056543994694948196,
-0.5280608534812927,
0.10304130613803864,
-0.5213088989257812,
1.0687602758407593,
-0.11155321449041367,
-0.2622075080871582,
0.13797971606254578,
-0.610705554485321,
0.43110111355781555,
0.04513154551386833,
-0.27039581537246704,
-0.22351142764091492,
-0.17963264882564545,
0.18332144618034363,
-0.20927785336971283,
0.8012088537216187,
-0.45371827483177185,
0.29163217544555664,
0.815155029296875,
0.035472750663757324,
0.31900498270988464,
0.050168607383966446,
0.028830192983150482,
-0.14380063116550446,
0.38637033104896545,
-1.0190966129302979,
-0.550155520439148,
0.3436338007450104,
-0.7475656270980835,
-0.5392488837242126,
-0.508683443069458,
-0.5207183957099915,
-0.3827211260795593,
0.3833175003528595,
-0.025807609781622887,
0.40561944246292114,
-0.30676496028900146,
0.5926318168640137,
0.4240036904811859,
-0.05486398562788963,
0.604943037033081,
1.050302505493164,
-0.01911964826285839,
-0.3467887043952942,
0.8105465769767761,
0.24592001736164093,
0.3538837730884552,
0.4354436695575714,
-0.14936409890651703,
-0.14607438445091248,
-0.5764520168304443,
-0.9810002446174622,
-0.1801196038722992,
-0.8025771379470825,
-0.30999019742012024,
-0.5654132962226868,
-0.09028003364801407,
-0.41273680329322815,
-0.1085798442363739,
-0.24623939394950867,
-0.28825193643569946,
-0.35237815976142883,
-0.11083009839057922,
0.34927937388420105,
0.3880552649497986,
0.19891394674777985,
0.5138006806373596,
-0.6090842485427856,
0.8033043146133423,
0.9480743408203125,
0.42344287037849426,
-0.08940763771533966,
-0.2234145998954773,
-0.1473408341407776,
0.11669842898845673,
-0.14709646999835968,
-1.3291138410568237,
0.008839098736643791,
0.23586325347423553,
0.7319011092185974,
0.07057439535856247,
0.2722863256931305,
0.665979266166687,
-0.25001734495162964,
0.7531972527503967,
0.07742580771446228,
-0.825904130935669,
0.17140676081180573,
-0.48547080159187317,
0.5800802111625671,
0.6160484552383423,
0.18740661442279816,
-0.25682100653648376,
-0.13765603303909302,
-0.2162933349609375,
-0.33180397748947144,
0.6742209196090698,
0.324331134557724,
-0.028143320232629776,
0.26613712310791016,
0.3607206344604492,
-0.26500168442726135,
0.4855465590953827,
-0.48878148198127747,
-0.24384573101997375,
-0.5819317102432251,
-0.0043248506262898445,
-0.15691393613815308,
-0.05801098421216011,
-0.18436311185359955,
0.1073550134897232,
0.33002904057502747,
-0.6983850002288818,
0.25780975818634033,
0.5026143193244934,
-0.4597652852535248,
-0.49118590354919434,
0.1765621453523636,
0.7306424379348755,
0.9808050990104675,
-0.1605873852968216,
-0.09980174899101257,
0.3676688075065613,
-0.3679233491420746,
0.4873178005218506,
0.09546782821416855,
-0.2944382131099701,
-0.16383466124534607,
0.3646823465824127,
0.779694676399231,
-0.08726555854082108,
-0.710821270942688,
0.8551408052444458,
-0.369188517332077,
-0.4678921401500702,
-0.13736295700073242,
0.14232143759727478,
-0.00805336982011795,
0.6960540413856506,
0.6098422408103943,
0.08307281136512756,
0.21323271095752716,
-0.9298932552337646,
0.4635738432407379,
0.618173360824585,
-0.6036646962165833,
-0.2091338336467743,
0.6217175126075745,
0.01584528759121895,
-0.25033384561538696,
0.189203143119812,
0.08403842896223068,
-0.2176213562488556,
1.2697727680206299,
0.25481346249580383,
0.879123330116272,
-0.4857725203037262,
0.7430404424667358,
-0.16683347523212433,
0.6222741007804871,
-0.021775707602500916,
0.6673228144645691,
-0.05736357346177101,
-0.9816316366195679,
-0.45997893810272217,
-0.3495088517665863,
-0.7634944319725037,
0.11819286644458771,
-0.5637332797050476,
0.09419053047895432,
-0.35292255878448486,
-0.04685251787304878,
0.16010667383670807,
-0.11793313175439835,
-0.8629246950149536,
0.47230949997901917,
0.00410523870959878,
0.807059109210968,
-0.864264190196991,
0.6695323586463928,
1.0556883811950684,
-0.5344070792198181,
-0.3283863067626953,
-0.08828748017549515,
0.008110730908811092,
-0.7723063230514526,
-0.16726841032505035,
0.08849883079528809,
-0.44064944982528687,
0.1473264992237091,
-0.7546433210372925,
-0.8492488861083984,
1.4221651554107666,
0.44153836369514465,
0.020753856748342514,
0.17504075169563293,
0.11548005044460297,
0.6617364883422852,
-0.3441922068595886,
0.39783725142478943,
0.20765352249145508,
0.4285348951816559,
0.34578025341033936,
-0.8408441543579102,
-0.06139330938458443,
-0.2890439033508301,
-0.31619036197662354,
-0.0012778735253959894,
-0.9369135499000549,
1.1945581436157227,
-0.24724924564361572,
-0.13514256477355957,
0.49278053641319275,
0.5243598222732544,
0.2675412595272064,
0.7320404052734375,
0.5337692499160767,
0.4283086657524109,
0.314477801322937,
0.08668112009763718,
0.7357720136642456,
-0.02075631357729435,
0.28358587622642517,
1.1781388521194458,
-0.39847424626350403,
0.6440318822860718,
0.16560111939907074,
0.11534292250871658,
0.27401378750801086,
0.31526562571525574,
0.10502248257398605,
0.30656442046165466,
-0.15999120473861694,
-0.38494211435317993,
-0.6525189280509949,
-0.20351190865039825,
-0.3102639615535736,
0.8519728183746338,
0.031231852248311043,
0.3166264295578003,
-0.3959300220012665,
0.01423223502933979,
-0.7906559705734253,
-0.19691282510757446,
-0.3290763199329376,
0.6471782922744751,
-0.18170443177223206,
-0.4696977734565735,
0.37167084217071533,
0.014249366708099842,
0.08025152236223221,
-0.43280676007270813,
-0.3812495172023773,
-0.2617737352848053,
-0.10553082823753357,
-0.007913151755928993,
-0.7752735018730164,
-0.08829331398010254,
-0.12586703896522522,
-0.20925305783748627,
0.2759506106376648,
1.0559121370315552,
-0.31099987030029297,
-0.5129327178001404,
0.2488054782152176,
1.3020052909851074,
0.035747457295656204,
-0.46614256501197815,
-0.6314736008644104,
-0.2903682589530945,
-0.3746074438095093,
-0.3348509967327118,
0.29109421372413635,
0.5654481649398804,
-0.4118437170982361,
0.830604076385498,
0.5717341303825378,
-0.5160388946533203,
0.25421667098999023,
-0.20373983681201935,
0.8554096817970276,
-0.9021275043487549,
-0.44112491607666016,
-0.5957677364349365,
0.7863577008247375,
0.041113995015621185,
-0.2561270594596863,
0.5952441692352295,
0.1032729223370552,
0.7668902277946472,
-0.2802596688270569,
0.6248441934585571,
0.07056178152561188,
0.18706560134887695,
-0.07527058571577072,
0.40366408228874207,
-0.8279423117637634,
-0.15156450867652893,
-0.4949808418750763,
-0.8365658521652222,
-0.2714388966560364,
0.2801784873008728,
0.16186264157295227,
-0.020691221579909325,
0.32224613428115845,
0.7299966216087341,
-0.045601412653923035,
-0.3289182484149933,
0.8294819593429565,
-0.001413708203472197,
0.26413270831108093,
0.7516788244247437,
1.0602630376815796,
-0.4902495741844177,
0.8039608001708984,
-0.29071250557899475,
-0.18524256348609924,
-0.31832072138786316,
-0.6943973898887634,
-0.9511442184448242,
-0.4293399155139923,
-0.15912531316280365,
0.00982639379799366,
0.17311272025108337,
0.06223262473940849,
0.8118752837181091,
-0.8021530508995056,
-0.03697407990694046,
0.15288348495960236,
0.3456347584724426,
-0.4199400842189789,
-0.21707798540592194,
0.07049404829740524,
0.35213711857795715,
-0.519766628742218,
0.6025722622871399,
0.4611716568470001,
0.13522176444530487,
-0.3379371166229248,
-0.08944439142942429,
-0.3933577537536621,
0.34123435616493225,
0.7280499339103699,
0.6665246486663818,
-0.49550530314445496,
-0.6217295527458191,
0.34994661808013916,
0.13378512859344482,
0.02949255146086216,
0.5155353546142578,
-1.000477910041809,
0.702545166015625,
0.6279153227806091,
0.7669564485549927,
0.49073007702827454,
0.41895920038223267,
0.33881932497024536,
-0.6350834965705872,
0.25178566575050354,
0.21887628734111786,
0.13534972071647644,
0.07474537938833237,
-0.30803900957107544,
0.4327501356601715,
0.3526540696620941,
-0.2339211404323578,
-0.8839017748832703,
0.3687898516654968,
-1.0557504892349243,
-0.602688193321228,
0.586113691329956,
-0.11573006957769394,
-0.2036990076303482,
-0.35766518115997314,
-0.1758216917514801,
-0.046000901609659195,
-0.24431852996349335,
0.1712646186351776,
0.6419965028762817,
-0.27419164776802063,
-0.7318141460418701,
-0.6552363634109497,
-0.04272690787911415,
0.1646551787853241,
-0.9608194231987,
-0.5000799298286438,
0.741107165813446,
0.49797323346138,
0.27525511384010315,
1.151830792427063,
0.3593384921550751,
1.034722924232483,
0.2438163161277771,
0.05681810528039932,
-0.3291458487510681,
-1.0115665197372437,
-0.44409555196762085,
0.5612711906433105,
0.12210699170827866,
-0.5741515159606934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15498v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15498v1
|
Emergent World Models and Latent Variable Estimation in Chess-Playing Language Models
| 2024-03-21T18:53:23 | 2024-03-21T18:53:23 |
Adam Karvonen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Language models have shown unprecedented capabilities, sparking debate over
the source of their performance. Is it merely the outcome of learning syntactic
patterns and surface level statistics, or do they extract semantics and a world
model from the text? Prior work by Li et al. investigated this by training a
GPT model on synthetic, randomly generated Othello games and found that the
model learned an internal representation of the board state. We extend this
work into the more complex domain of chess, training on real games and
investigating our model's internal representations using linear probes and
contrastive activations. The model is given no a priori knowledge of the game
and is solely trained on next character prediction, yet we find evidence of
internal representations of board state. We validate these internal
representations by using them to make interventions on the model's activations
and edit its internal board state. Unlike Li et al's prior synthetic dataset
approach, our analysis finds that the model also learns to estimate latent
variables like player skill to better predict the next character. We derive a
player skill vector and add it to the model, improving the model's win rate by
up to 2.6 times.
|
[
-0.09436428546905518,
-0.8615492582321167,
0.8891781568527222,
-0.1739136427640915,
-0.15462467074394226,
0.22983264923095703,
-0.19609087705612183,
-0.8201589584350586,
0.06094727665185928,
0.45673027634620667,
-0.4665958285331726,
-0.27039796113967896,
-0.5903617739677429,
-0.3511238098144531,
-0.08445413410663605,
0.8717213869094849,
0.23909375071525574,
0.16524825990200043,
-0.12824933230876923,
0.2505308985710144,
-0.44155973196029663,
-0.40712857246398926,
-0.6464080214500427,
-0.6016926765441895,
0.1046476811170578,
0.21874478459358215,
0.6493555307388306,
0.5466130375862122,
0.43089261651039124,
0.42424315214157104,
-0.09688429534435272,
-0.01885102689266205,
-0.5396207571029663,
0.5619475841522217,
-0.11493850499391556,
-0.8345769047737122,
-0.4231530725955963,
0.44084450602531433,
0.6199276447296143,
0.5147692561149597,
-0.1620991826057434,
-0.16120851039886475,
-0.08399210125207901,
0.3685540556907654,
-0.30656197667121887,
0.5212692022323608,
-0.682284951210022,
0.3531106114387512,
-0.13123516738414764,
-0.057318903505802155,
-0.40312114357948303,
-0.09978116303682327,
0.5262870192527771,
-0.8019682765007019,
0.23934201896190643,
-0.13173756003379822,
0.56400066614151,
-0.19296304881572723,
-0.40531274676322937,
-0.38104432821273804,
-0.9972695708274841,
0.6858283281326294,
-0.6690874695777893,
0.308464378118515,
0.29947349429130554,
0.4401499629020691,
-0.3208343982696533,
-0.7250471115112305,
-0.4892089068889618,
-0.5128636360168457,
0.10969746112823486,
0.4505574703216553,
-0.12446063756942749,
0.2561163306236267,
0.25563961267471313,
0.38088470697402954,
-0.3779887855052948,
0.06702987104654312,
-0.3268243372440338,
-0.012694896198809147,
0.7406772375106812,
0.1502797156572342,
0.30327606201171875,
0.03360294550657272,
-0.2023906111717224,
-0.1891724169254303,
-0.5534692406654358,
0.38311105966567993,
0.6211776733398438,
0.3521277606487274,
0.04842536523938179,
0.539940595626831,
0.2916296124458313,
0.6007578372955322,
0.28765934705734253,
-0.1544734686613083,
-0.19770550727844238,
-0.053428784012794495,
0.18303890526294708,
-0.09483693540096283,
0.5093939304351807,
0.24410270154476166,
0.12182874232530594,
-0.4211336076259613,
-0.37107810378074646,
0.09827711433172226,
0.2780068516731262,
-0.3731692135334015,
-0.5650902390480042,
0.06202961876988411,
-0.44619324803352356,
-0.5395303964614868,
0.33740100264549255,
-0.7206053733825684,
-0.5162426233291626,
-0.07519565522670746,
0.5495176315307617,
-0.303410142660141,
-0.1475744992494583,
-0.32318323850631714,
-0.37255263328552246,
0.39417898654937744,
0.2666919231414795,
-0.8659356832504272,
0.5079605579376221,
0.6006339192390442,
0.7408515810966492,
-0.24183785915374756,
0.0007069173734635115,
-0.6239729523658752,
-0.1620761901140213,
-0.8261699080467224,
0.9886414408683777,
-0.7781413793563843,
-0.4879183769226074,
0.011975932866334915,
-0.06110116094350815,
0.17780406773090363,
-0.4592927098274231,
0.07019996643066406,
-0.5305702090263367,
0.340364933013916,
-0.14759103953838348,
-0.6077146530151367,
-0.02255905233323574,
0.04140922427177429,
-0.9379352331161499,
0.8696571588516235,
-0.15802188217639923,
-0.3212255835533142,
0.6073721051216125,
-0.550990879535675,
-0.25587525963783264,
0.06175699457526207,
0.061150796711444855,
-0.29185572266578674,
0.6168928742408752,
0.0830649584531784,
0.4190084636211395,
-0.2927902340888977,
0.22076182067394257,
-0.4845837652683258,
-0.3313618302345276,
0.4927164316177368,
-0.2814638912677765,
0.36848872900009155,
-0.12804944813251495,
-0.10460206866264343,
-0.013929097913205624,
-0.7416562438011169,
0.1579122245311737,
0.081489197909832,
-0.287984699010849,
-0.2110716998577118,
0.5673061609268188,
-0.24559904634952545,
0.41699424386024475,
0.0884377658367157,
-0.7184215784072876,
0.1685023009777069,
-0.6162342429161072,
0.3658943176269531,
0.8304026126861572,
0.31721752882003784,
0.5140031576156616,
-0.36005809903144836,
0.6096681952476501,
-0.12821580469608307,
-0.03648720681667328,
-0.05451083555817604,
-0.7669393420219421,
-0.3033912479877472,
-0.16868214309215546,
0.3521135449409485,
0.40053901076316833,
-0.7250162363052368,
0.11056222766637802,
0.07851859927177429,
-0.5334548354148865,
-0.49564576148986816,
-0.30294105410575867,
0.3308744430541992,
-0.019614307209849358,
0.15390436351299286,
-0.11872001737356186,
-0.5211273431777954,
-0.696229875087738,
-0.3542313575744629,
-0.4346396327018738,
0.12486353516578674,
0.3394912779331207,
0.5272005796432495,
0.3995234966278076,
0.8229915499687195,
-0.6104695796966553,
-0.13929055631160736,
-0.32577183842658997,
0.2400907427072525,
0.13151657581329346,
0.5026319622993469,
0.4075748026371002,
-0.7114763855934143,
-0.5957998633384705,
0.09404806047677994,
-0.6304802894592285,
0.06951217353343964,
-0.04342963546514511,
-0.011311960406601429,
0.012072148732841015,
0.7289908528327942,
-0.1780894249677658,
0.45753782987594604,
0.6235143542289734,
-0.27011632919311523,
0.6299029588699341,
-0.46433746814727783,
0.03316732868552208,
-0.9848814606666565,
-0.016674017533659935,
-0.24768109619617462,
-0.2538087069988251,
-0.8185754418373108,
0.16922877728939056,
-0.3115329146385193,
-0.02170860767364502,
-0.08437682688236237,
0.6072232723236084,
-0.5673601627349854,
-0.2101612389087677,
-0.25889337062835693,
0.3404897153377533,
-0.267547607421875,
0.48215430974960327,
0.36972784996032715,
0.6848602890968323,
0.4059302806854248,
-0.48539894819259644,
0.34540921449661255,
-0.10722433775663376,
-0.5059421062469482,
0.43497684597969055,
-0.7408409714698792,
0.18196392059326172,
-0.10298753529787064,
0.014556549489498138,
-1.3023191690444946,
-0.08912112563848495,
-0.014571771956980228,
-0.35628485679626465,
0.4002372920513153,
-0.32031744718551636,
-0.2858564555644989,
-0.3871445655822754,
-0.24229241907596588,
-0.012227780185639858,
0.618585467338562,
-0.41229671239852905,
0.4376862943172455,
0.8781208395957947,
-0.026138536632061005,
-0.39841336011886597,
-0.5788847208023071,
-0.2789860665798187,
0.005802670493721962,
-0.22419960796833038,
0.4878016710281372,
-0.3298037350177765,
-0.302571564912796,
0.07634376734495163,
-0.2818997800350189,
-0.41211584210395813,
0.2521078288555145,
0.15900032222270966,
0.006370797753334045,
-0.30668166279792786,
0.28351500630378723,
-0.000557900290004909,
-0.030887126922607422,
0.1034230887889862,
-0.6056318283081055,
0.30846017599105835,
0.07917825132608414,
-0.2027655839920044,
0.0061222561635077,
0.3233683109283447,
0.1504257619380951,
-0.28331297636032104,
0.7212658524513245,
0.343450665473938,
-0.4248277544975281,
-0.3080034852027893,
-0.2289225459098816,
-0.07080670446157455,
-0.42315438389778137,
0.5856180787086487,
-0.5239993929862976,
-0.6557743549346924,
0.8952464461326599,
0.07416064292192459,
-0.0003305335121694952,
0.7200542688369751,
0.205500528216362,
-0.32990169525146484,
1.203444242477417,
0.8368917107582092,
0.4741761386394501,
0.6271538138389587,
-0.4044876992702484,
-0.08340245485305786,
-0.9231781363487244,
-0.45498013496398926,
-0.2957684397697449,
-0.24721507728099823,
-1.045451045036316,
-0.47196775674819946,
0.3459378778934479,
-0.03731275349855423,
0.011872599832713604,
0.12102381885051727,
-0.04037947952747345,
0.798555314540863,
0.31432250142097473,
0.3329537808895111,
0.057740189135074615,
-0.14027225971221924,
-0.4794918894767761,
-0.5630593299865723,
-0.825369119644165,
-0.26215726137161255,
1.2989147901535034,
0.10615406185388565,
0.7861924171447754,
0.3471493721008301,
0.679997444152832,
0.30340898036956787,
0.3269132673740387,
-0.6272289752960205,
0.32459259033203125,
-0.14466750621795654,
-0.7925543785095215,
-0.35027608275413513,
-0.2932589054107666,
-0.8987618088722229,
0.3312673270702362,
-0.5561459064483643,
-0.9235581159591675,
0.32903143763542175,
0.12356451153755188,
-0.3512905538082123,
0.507968008518219,
-0.23725318908691406,
0.8387161493301392,
-0.11195950955152512,
-0.45874378085136414,
-0.11315736919641495,
-0.40831997990608215,
0.488679975271225,
-0.10120777040719986,
0.05317394435405731,
0.19499224424362183,
-0.10768195986747742,
0.7722609043121338,
-0.33231058716773987,
0.7763813734054565,
-0.16316860914230347,
-0.30035078525543213,
0.488174706697464,
0.2929649353027344,
0.41996335983276367,
0.09204918891191483,
0.0261524748057127,
-0.12716372311115265,
-0.062196020036935806,
-0.27966609597206116,
-0.6298974752426147,
0.5767852663993835,
-0.8883364796638489,
-0.4880724549293518,
-0.702946126461029,
-0.3584517538547516,
-0.34852170944213867,
-0.08224845677614212,
0.3763510286808014,
0.5821949243545532,
-0.9516175389289856,
0.2059960812330246,
0.7587649822235107,
-0.10712643712759018,
0.41911065578460693,
0.5749130845069885,
-0.21215622127056122,
-0.30421268939971924,
0.9162238836288452,
0.26818013191223145,
0.400829553604126,
0.6219282150268555,
0.2604718506336212,
-0.2434542179107666,
-0.36489927768707275,
0.14852797985076904,
0.13925854861736298,
-0.6263949871063232,
0.05520634725689888,
-0.28256821632385254,
-0.31308338046073914,
-0.054242152720689774,
0.10025133937597275,
-0.4580145478248596,
-0.5217824578285217,
-0.056225281208753586,
-0.06056392565369606,
-0.1080012246966362,
1.4411871433258057,
-0.45902860164642334,
0.6170958280563354,
-0.47999146580696106,
-0.008915561251342297,
0.6339254379272461,
0.3676490783691406,
0.09462054818868637,
-0.7395747303962708,
-0.38438743352890015,
0.04700909182429314,
-0.12702463567256927,
-1.1608392000198364,
0.3223331868648529,
0.428794801235199,
0.9300163388252258,
0.3796617090702057,
-0.37513184547424316,
0.6176964044570923,
-0.6692783236503601,
0.8930374383926392,
-0.166961669921875,
-0.791986346244812,
0.31939995288848877,
-0.31482836604118347,
0.4321835935115814,
0.17158319056034088,
0.3088400065898895,
-0.5324607491493225,
-0.42105916142463684,
-0.8939017057418823,
-0.487588495016098,
0.9837862253189087,
-0.06200684979557991,
-0.09262151271104813,
-0.046934518963098526,
0.31933698058128357,
0.24693822860717773,
0.2831322252750397,
-0.8199639320373535,
-0.06638725101947784,
0.11824039369821548,
0.028994120657444,
-0.293194979429245,
-0.3747708201408386,
0.29065456986427307,
0.04457850754261017,
0.6963856220245361,
-0.06135572865605354,
0.5496116280555725,
-0.13818101584911346,
-0.48149922490119934,
-0.32213306427001953,
-0.18091318011283875,
0.4119243919849396,
0.5261709094047546,
-0.24739548563957214,
-0.08731701970100403,
-0.08494856208562851,
-0.6132192015647888,
0.1432388871908188,
0.03337445482611656,
-0.02098219096660614,
-0.12251042574644089,
0.8861499428749084,
0.7035198211669922,
0.5250881910324097,
-0.42714571952819824,
0.3469759225845337,
-0.09740443527698517,
-0.12612037360668182,
-0.212100088596344,
0.15027816593647003,
-0.04939723759889603,
0.4844774305820465,
0.23231065273284912,
-0.010784906335175037,
0.04110756143927574,
-0.9320407509803772,
0.20231634378433228,
0.4517201781272888,
-0.7080122828483582,
-0.744914710521698,
0.5558690428733826,
-0.027985548600554466,
-0.2108154594898224,
0.4632015526294708,
-0.31398633122444153,
-0.6512085795402527,
0.6333757042884827,
0.7155016660690308,
0.7970675230026245,
-0.5768809914588928,
0.512167751789093,
0.4812619090080261,
0.3451522886753082,
-0.009032183326780796,
0.4452989399433136,
0.16054169833660126,
-0.7001025676727295,
-0.38267338275909424,
-0.3529152572154999,
-0.29707062244415283,
0.40929555892944336,
-0.503261148929596,
-0.23551324009895325,
-0.5775076150894165,
-0.17659194767475128,
0.07078930735588074,
0.47808048129081726,
-0.7107621431350708,
-0.09281342476606369,
0.29301467537879944,
0.42761266231536865,
-1.216274619102478,
0.5103790163993835,
0.6765961050987244,
-0.61407470703125,
-0.4177452623844147,
0.23733016848564148,
-0.07274743169546127,
-0.5833475589752197,
0.693312406539917,
-0.22330567240715027,
0.305645614862442,
-0.13202416896820068,
-0.7721591591835022,
-1.1176185607910156,
0.7712715268135071,
0.21599800884723663,
-0.18612857162952423,
-0.14895501732826233,
-0.20637528598308563,
0.7089543342590332,
-0.5971819162368774,
0.4027439057826996,
0.26494428515434265,
0.24698734283447266,
-0.1744905412197113,
-0.5710156559944153,
-0.2566538155078888,
-0.19070565700531006,
0.2587897777557373,
0.03749639913439751,
-0.31197547912597656,
1.0792711973190308,
-0.3837209939956665,
-0.17186713218688965,
0.19169364869594574,
0.8354947566986084,
0.00119529920630157,
-0.3200596570968628,
0.28543031215667725,
0.1284388154745102,
0.7762977480888367,
-0.202678844332695,
1.0829930305480957,
-0.19843563437461853,
0.0520249679684639,
1.1377053260803223,
-0.16623422503471375,
0.8980796933174133,
0.08777085691690445,
-0.1779472380876541,
0.8031104207038879,
0.6419852375984192,
0.22599931061267853,
0.7283230423927307,
0.23622101545333862,
0.04534941911697388,
-0.48274844884872437,
0.13209810853004456,
-0.10769801586866379,
0.7964205145835876,
0.6222512722015381,
-0.11229951679706573,
-0.2333228588104248,
0.040344059467315674,
-0.17495094239711761,
0.21312019228935242,
-0.07240542769432068,
1.0764904022216797,
0.013935956172645092,
-0.6513493061065674,
-0.09734312444925308,
0.03439437225461006,
0.15163560211658478,
-0.8079855442047119,
-0.5460294485092163,
-0.30852010846138,
0.30788376927375793,
0.36764323711395264,
-0.7900674939155579,
-0.23141513764858246,
-0.10636234283447266,
-0.17598606646060944,
0.14299096167087555,
0.5221477150917053,
-0.764519453048706,
-0.40837663412094116,
0.14858508110046387,
0.667704701423645,
0.24822984635829926,
0.03619846701622009,
-0.6873190402984619,
-0.18846389651298523,
-0.19582657516002655,
-0.24576474726200104,
0.26068148016929626,
0.7485313415527344,
-0.18094463646411896,
0.3964805603027344,
0.630297064781189,
0.2948179244995117,
-0.03439735248684883,
-0.3825399875640869,
0.5233368873596191,
-0.5261179208755493,
-0.7587453126907349,
-0.6055392622947693,
0.37975332140922546,
-0.19475480914115906,
-0.4141593277454376,
0.5489905476570129,
0.4811854958534241,
0.6216109991073608,
-0.08518701046705246,
0.7341119050979614,
0.04016726091504097,
0.22376684844493866,
-0.6536626219749451,
0.7037556171417236,
-0.4412497878074646,
0.0400354340672493,
-0.15243327617645264,
-0.9311490058898926,
0.06753334403038025,
0.8735392093658447,
-0.3791360855102539,
0.17452670633792877,
0.8133939504623413,
0.36454668641090393,
-0.10487109422683716,
-0.05881514027714729,
0.5122392773628235,
0.5953618288040161,
0.37381216883659363,
0.4814003109931946,
0.8149714469909668,
-0.48865604400634766,
0.19361090660095215,
-0.02967686764895916,
-0.24802666902542114,
-0.193410262465477,
-0.8987558484077454,
-0.916317880153656,
-0.7757119536399841,
-0.08002687245607376,
-0.26373034715652466,
0.3488808870315552,
0.9033335447311401,
0.6140128374099731,
-0.7778905630111694,
-0.5098621845245361,
0.1176781877875328,
0.05663049966096878,
-0.4906657338142395,
-0.14819446206092834,
0.3801477551460266,
-0.41087082028388977,
-0.6088180541992188,
0.6197101473808289,
-0.033963270485401154,
0.054558221250772476,
-0.33781662583351135,
-0.02340168133378029,
-0.5460153818130493,
0.2906990051269531,
0.5855916142463684,
0.3461013734340668,
-0.5244501829147339,
-0.26418229937553406,
0.04749155044555664,
-0.04510411247611046,
-0.010561998002231121,
0.6546148061752319,
-0.9725347757339478,
0.8498914241790771,
0.46894019842147827,
0.17226101458072662,
0.6574585437774658,
-0.3696521520614624,
1.0642693042755127,
-0.6628455519676208,
0.2401631772518158,
0.2508258819580078,
0.16725189983844757,
0.23461417853832245,
-0.14609616994857788,
0.33878815174102783,
0.44099193811416626,
-0.1804198920726776,
-0.7317245602607727,
0.15345022082328796,
-0.24665261805057526,
-0.3215543031692505,
0.6364319920539856,
-0.2670028805732727,
-0.5335373878479004,
0.19272014498710632,
0.09596151858568192,
0.17689400911331177,
-0.2720394432544708,
0.6078200340270996,
0.9557265043258667,
0.029824065044522285,
0.19692255556583405,
-0.8723545074462891,
0.8757533431053162,
-0.043944112956523895,
-0.5560677647590637,
-0.005181226879358292,
0.45634594559669495,
0.06905646622180939,
0.02901775762438774,
0.5948851704597473,
-0.0956956297159195,
0.40483972430229187,
0.35330724716186523,
-0.0015712492167949677,
0.19067314267158508,
-0.6672620177268982,
-0.4057110548019409,
-0.03229391202330589,
-0.002541294787079096,
0.1574128121137619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14774v1
|
Few-Shot Adversarial Prompt Learning on Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-21T18:28:43 | 2024-03-21T18:28:43 |
Yiwei Zhou, Xiaobo Xia, Zhiwei Lin, Bo Han, Tongliang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
The vulnerability of deep neural networks to imperceptible adversarial
perturbations has attracted widespread attention. Inspired by the success of
vision-language foundation models, previous efforts achieved zero-shot
adversarial robustness by aligning adversarial visual features with text
supervision. However, in practice, they are still unsatisfactory due to several
issues, including heavy adaptation cost, suboptimal text supervision, and
uncontrolled natural generalization capacity. In this paper, to address these
issues, we propose a few-shot adversarial prompt framework where adapting input
sequences with limited data makes significant adversarial robustness
improvement. Specifically, we achieve this by providing adversarially
correlated text supervision that is end-to-end learned from adversarial
examples. We also propose a novel training objective that enhances the
consistency of multi-modal features while encourages differentiated uni-modal
features between natural and adversarial examples. The proposed framework gives
access to learn adversarial text supervision, which provides superior
cross-modal adversarial alignment and matches state-of-the-art zero-shot
adversarial robustness with only 1% training data.
|
[
-0.23259997367858887,
-0.8979780077934265,
0.46132421493530273,
-0.09830325096845627,
-0.18381518125534058,
-0.29375508427619934,
-0.2796745002269745,
0.0002750505809672177,
-0.14583444595336914,
0.382217139005661,
-0.7037712931632996,
-0.42478734254837036,
-0.6023572087287903,
0.16398392617702484,
-0.11010978370904922,
1.2081636190414429,
0.2973763644695282,
0.09661567956209183,
0.15213172137737274,
-0.3104567527770996,
-0.4775444567203522,
-0.22653843462467194,
-0.5756134390830994,
0.07025911659002304,
0.6966623067855835,
0.33078277111053467,
0.9117974638938904,
0.4205828607082367,
0.4369036555290222,
0.21623271703720093,
-0.10216060280799866,
0.2265910506248474,
-0.606634259223938,
0.2248033732175827,
-0.08455325663089752,
-0.6062033772468567,
-0.22488002479076385,
-0.10790590196847916,
0.545561671257019,
0.4394744038581848,
0.13302555680274963,
-0.304684579372406,
0.3043035864830017,
0.4263673722743988,
-0.7584723830223083,
-0.01102431956678629,
-0.8842760324478149,
0.004501654300838709,
-0.17352715134620667,
-0.1388760209083557,
-0.46809640526771545,
-0.003211715491488576,
0.21844179928302765,
-0.782024085521698,
0.17115329205989838,
-0.11033746600151062,
0.8586714267730713,
0.49503734707832336,
-0.44089967012405396,
-0.06756105273962021,
-0.33865097165107727,
0.7049224972724915,
-0.49249520897865295,
-0.11655591428279877,
0.40021759271621704,
0.4740981161594391,
-0.3553062677383423,
-0.2860712707042694,
-0.347465455532074,
-0.15623638033866882,
0.07252782583236694,
0.2836838662624359,
-0.377629816532135,
0.19304035604000092,
0.2464899718761444,
-0.0378027968108654,
-0.7559306621551514,
0.15316161513328552,
0.02722128853201866,
-0.08778274804353714,
0.2904534935951233,
0.27932584285736084,
0.2704662084579468,
-0.04147765785455704,
-0.6253622770309448,
-0.4758087396621704,
-0.6389845013618469,
0.33328887820243835,
0.3650011122226715,
0.7402715086936951,
-0.3888852596282959,
0.29886507987976074,
-0.023535095155239105,
0.7834499478340149,
0.1479048877954483,
-0.026297757402062416,
-0.060570523142814636,
-0.3812026083469391,
-0.15648238360881805,
-0.05222724378108978,
0.9481660723686218,
0.25543344020843506,
0.1681365966796875,
-0.09094654768705368,
-0.13503319025039673,
0.1372959166765213,
0.3349964916706085,
-0.7165828347206116,
-0.30838000774383545,
-0.14000561833381653,
-0.1232205480337143,
-0.5779826641082764,
-0.11038520187139511,
-0.8399533629417419,
-0.8676779866218567,
0.10014763474464417,
0.612305223941803,
-0.6212461590766907,
0.20302003622055054,
-0.14263713359832764,
-0.05060865730047226,
0.15200433135032654,
0.4600600004196167,
-1.0279992818832397,
-0.08931493759155273,
0.43130019307136536,
0.9211429953575134,
-0.15161459147930145,
-0.3982052505016327,
-0.6569625735282898,
-0.3036560118198395,
-0.4328386187553406,
0.6105425357818604,
-0.4290481209754944,
-0.12009540945291519,
0.013320685364305973,
-0.0019877476152032614,
-0.23724913597106934,
-0.05861475691199303,
0.3987266421318054,
-0.38064223527908325,
0.42690277099609375,
-0.2605339288711548,
-0.08107054978609085,
-0.22648151218891144,
0.606697678565979,
-0.46723487973213196,
0.47884511947631836,
0.20317710936069489,
-0.8168730139732361,
0.3822944760322571,
-0.3742468059062958,
-0.4535854160785675,
-0.13552238047122955,
-0.2583898603916168,
-0.5841982364654541,
0.0432928092777729,
0.5256624817848206,
0.3587675988674164,
-0.2544580399990082,
0.14441370964050293,
-0.689114511013031,
-0.3259921669960022,
0.2954718768596649,
-0.9834505915641785,
1.1320663690567017,
0.009623953141272068,
-0.25519347190856934,
0.18856628239154816,
-0.9027408361434937,
-0.28264713287353516,
0.11948272585868835,
-0.19412055611610413,
-0.30904293060302734,
-0.3514725863933563,
-0.004262085072696209,
0.018633553758263588,
-0.06666934490203857,
-0.28986701369285583,
0.43883535265922546,
-0.8066748976707458,
0.042322590947151184,
0.7736926078796387,
0.21218988299369812,
0.8340104818344116,
-0.280527263879776,
0.7506183981895447,
0.10329141467809677,
0.24646426737308502,
-0.6668224930763245,
-0.3803771436214447,
-0.5470716953277588,
-0.4562121033668518,
0.1168835386633873,
0.8463562726974487,
-1.3215728998184204,
0.18975484371185303,
0.005422689951956272,
-0.21993394196033478,
-0.2767837941646576,
0.4519023895263672,
0.6669010519981384,
0.763533353805542,
0.4018624424934387,
-0.051468875259160995,
-0.40521207451820374,
-0.591402530670166,
-0.24770858883857727,
-0.22216930985450745,
-0.074465312063694,
0.3758121728897095,
0.32649052143096924,
-0.07757386565208435,
0.6513423919677734,
-0.24385963380336761,
-0.6107650399208069,
-0.24819687008857727,
0.10350298136472702,
0.22065287828445435,
0.27614596486091614,
0.8898963928222656,
-0.7339133024215698,
-0.5360642671585083,
-0.1580449491739273,
-0.8625289797782898,
-0.1298636496067047,
-0.44367358088493347,
-0.005899621639400721,
0.02587207406759262,
0.20857928693294525,
-0.47779935598373413,
0.2657374143600464,
0.4475346803665161,
-0.4021311402320862,
0.21175239980220795,
-0.06548529863357544,
0.0029435527976602316,
-1.254040241241455,
-0.1479988843202591,
0.037401605397462845,
-0.30744707584381104,
-0.642718493938446,
0.16843008995056152,
-0.0459919273853302,
-0.36485710740089417,
-0.6776663661003113,
0.49341726303100586,
-0.19075645506381989,
0.32854264974594116,
-0.3728015720844269,
0.26211613416671753,
0.18977560102939606,
0.6527557969093323,
-0.1280919313430786,
0.7373762726783752,
1.040368914604187,
-0.47578656673431396,
0.6023162007331848,
0.42544126510620117,
0.13304831087589264,
0.7655607461929321,
-0.48455581068992615,
-0.0070037092082202435,
-0.31224220991134644,
0.18303795158863068,
-0.9804719090461731,
-0.24536040425300598,
0.5206589102745056,
-0.6271528601646423,
0.5859196782112122,
-0.3251178562641144,
-0.03751327469944954,
0.15397682785987854,
-0.6408454179763794,
0.21915754675865173,
0.3240092098712921,
-0.6615018248558044,
0.6262598633766174,
-0.23924550414085388,
0.05843218415975571,
-0.7127453088760376,
-0.8517176508903503,
0.3307391107082367,
-0.14294224977493286,
-0.42639395594596863,
0.07921984046697617,
0.09153168648481369,
0.013138595037162304,
0.03726600110530853,
0.06673117727041245,
-0.10403146594762802,
0.315900593996048,
0.22153045237064362,
0.46026667952537537,
-0.4655839800834656,
-0.02288661152124405,
-0.3687624931335449,
-0.20730695128440857,
-0.19086797535419464,
-0.37095585465431213,
0.02236085943877697,
-0.11801266670227051,
-0.2243194580078125,
-0.36353540420532227,
0.2582279443740845,
0.6349351406097412,
0.045468878000974655,
0.6546015739440918,
0.7058574557304382,
-0.3566587567329407,
-0.3369308412075043,
-0.020335473120212555,
-0.2790212333202362,
-0.44563403725624084,
0.3829135298728943,
-0.3245948255062103,
-0.7119675278663635,
0.3617919087409973,
0.29656505584716797,
-0.10093190521001816,
0.21716684103012085,
0.2870927155017853,
0.016675541177392006,
1.0939180850982666,
0.7523629665374756,
-0.291751891374588,
0.7061366438865662,
-0.10581197589635849,
-0.048260174691677094,
-0.5449742078781128,
-0.04674985259771347,
-0.34595823287963867,
-0.23033352196216583,
-0.4198135435581207,
-0.0534563846886158,
0.46983805298805237,
0.20260028541088104,
-0.194544717669487,
0.6492531299591064,
-0.26887986063957214,
0.32086801528930664,
0.6011209487915039,
0.4686935544013977,
-0.26315683126449585,
0.007102391682565212,
-0.24591250717639923,
-0.1721140742301941,
-0.9294579029083252,
-0.2627266049385071,
1.0050525665283203,
0.23578912019729614,
1.1223087310791016,
0.2675932049751282,
0.5113937854766846,
0.242690309882164,
-0.16201594471931458,
-0.8620395660400391,
0.34389516711235046,
-0.45471158623695374,
-0.35615673661231995,
-0.2033674269914627,
-0.4006367027759552,
-0.618175208568573,
0.16519783437252045,
-0.530656635761261,
-0.671306312084198,
0.474187970161438,
0.35518863797187805,
-0.7849085927009583,
0.262231707572937,
-0.6939824223518372,
1.1217169761657715,
-0.28605541586875916,
-0.5934112668037415,
0.25130295753479004,
-0.7741392850875854,
0.39079174399375916,
-0.01574106328189373,
-0.02286296896636486,
0.24336479604244232,
-0.023124152794480324,
0.1980956494808197,
-0.1619306355714798,
1.267100214958191,
-0.2392290085554123,
-0.0029191658832132816,
0.20898693799972534,
0.1752561628818512,
0.6401532888412476,
0.17113572359085083,
0.17620542645454407,
-0.2967028021812439,
-0.28131017088890076,
-0.4984447956085205,
-0.7996323704719543,
0.5479751825332642,
-0.5978909134864807,
-0.5168943405151367,
-0.527970552444458,
-0.5065288543701172,
-0.3451354205608368,
0.14103417098522186,
0.5717010498046875,
0.584494948387146,
-0.30043795704841614,
0.3145677149295807,
0.8746705055236816,
-0.2208959311246872,
0.7926101088523865,
0.39512431621551514,
0.3103330731391907,
-0.6068251729011536,
0.9826501607894897,
-0.2768164873123169,
0.35655832290649414,
0.4805070459842682,
0.11547739058732986,
-0.21307535469532013,
-0.28759217262268066,
-0.8413439989089966,
-0.3358638286590576,
-0.7617771029472351,
-0.5104820728302002,
-0.39381274580955505,
0.046458419412374496,
-0.5484236478805542,
-0.5636777281761169,
-0.35131657123565674,
-0.34610721468925476,
-0.7913691401481628,
0.21088126301765442,
0.3700629472732544,
0.2998996675014496,
0.015877703204751015,
0.5288656949996948,
-0.6946642994880676,
0.606951117515564,
0.49577584862709045,
-0.09334977716207504,
-0.3383311927318573,
-0.8959854245185852,
-0.01044450979679823,
0.01989472098648548,
-0.34545567631721497,
-0.9190835952758789,
0.1487758606672287,
0.4909525513648987,
0.291023313999176,
0.7968398928642273,
0.28582853078842163,
0.4789044260978699,
-0.3230037987232208,
0.8918696045875549,
0.4852569103240967,
-0.6742449402809143,
0.6356629729270935,
-0.37641334533691406,
0.625780463218689,
0.6979320049285889,
0.19375891983509064,
-0.1671501249074936,
-0.22283124923706055,
-0.27076682448387146,
-0.4863121211528778,
0.9207824468612671,
-0.032890837639570236,
0.22175852954387665,
0.13095340132713318,
0.15394172072410583,
-0.06898558139801025,
-0.04027475044131279,
-0.7477110028266907,
-0.16205339133739471,
-0.5211478471755981,
-0.3698980510234833,
0.03754505515098572,
-0.23781608045101166,
-0.26197195053100586,
0.2887095808982849,
0.6877267956733704,
-0.5574294924736023,
-0.27859237790107727,
0.19525301456451416,
-0.25508031249046326,
0.11124517023563385,
0.6300809383392334,
0.7068665623664856,
0.12628617882728577,
0.02460244484245777,
0.3291621506214142,
0.3850191533565521,
-0.3085421025753021,
0.3193482458591461,
0.2844580113887787,
-0.7142215967178345,
-0.2150086760520935,
0.5907321572303772,
1.0608652830123901,
0.28537243604660034,
-0.42952945828437805,
1.1504839658737183,
-0.18579450249671936,
-0.03478270024061203,
0.09101365506649017,
0.13331452012062073,
-0.5514519810676575,
0.4916350841522217,
0.42774343490600586,
0.6191439032554626,
0.021657099947333336,
-0.4122970402240753,
0.3308710753917694,
0.6240991950035095,
-0.8267552852630615,
-0.35499122738838196,
0.8424299955368042,
0.06861859560012817,
-0.05620095506310463,
0.02513197995722294,
-0.3922919034957886,
-0.7045412659645081,
0.41768160462379456,
0.5746760368347168,
0.9997766017913818,
-0.093906469643116,
0.22325578331947327,
0.14908862113952637,
0.5514010787010193,
-0.0815322995185852,
-0.0192237738519907,
-0.05330987647175789,
-0.6132371425628662,
-0.13291478157043457,
-0.33797815442085266,
-0.3083474338054657,
-0.013824934139847755,
-0.48161885142326355,
0.6153184771537781,
-0.8122245669364929,
-0.058723293244838715,
-0.20028962194919586,
-0.3256661891937256,
-0.4530118405818939,
0.2703354060649872,
0.17400050163269043,
0.6257415413856506,
-0.9714544415473938,
0.5614098906517029,
0.736552357673645,
-0.6764264106750488,
-0.33971065282821655,
0.06487478315830231,
0.5708136558532715,
-0.7643823623657227,
0.3084324598312378,
0.0534539632499218,
-0.291839599609375,
-0.13150441646575928,
-0.6319856643676758,
-0.41693103313446045,
0.7640150785446167,
0.7722133994102478,
-0.46838465332984924,
-0.12166444957256317,
-0.24826818704605103,
0.3449592590332031,
-0.20522625744342804,
0.1163259744644165,
0.13594789803028107,
0.19375017285346985,
0.05054318159818649,
-0.5166601538658142,
0.1177031397819519,
-0.10876529663801193,
-0.06419941782951355,
-0.18417631089687347,
-0.5765380263328552,
0.6409437656402588,
-0.39865371584892273,
-0.3660989999771118,
0.0967673659324646,
0.5619680285453796,
-0.14904728531837463,
0.18569469451904297,
0.4686199426651001,
0.5702055096626282,
0.345875084400177,
-0.031048303470015526,
1.0588366985321045,
-0.16399069130420685,
0.10237076878547668,
1.2345871925354004,
-0.0078565189614892,
0.48631495237350464,
0.32881858944892883,
0.07386556267738342,
0.14487923681735992,
0.38977354764938354,
-0.1745370328426361,
0.7971171736717224,
-0.33241215348243713,
-0.4899727702140808,
-0.4320860803127289,
-0.36097025871276855,
-0.17071755230426788,
0.5407435297966003,
0.10607770830392838,
-0.43609973788261414,
-0.49611571431159973,
0.4560893774032593,
-0.08732008188962936,
0.35966938734054565,
-0.1864747703075409,
0.8729901909828186,
0.12106511741876602,
-0.405816912651062,
0.7850751280784607,
-0.2033272534608841,
0.8322094082832336,
-0.7517440915107727,
-0.030789921060204506,
-0.13979262113571167,
0.31162214279174805,
-0.13495203852653503,
-0.4503774642944336,
-0.0846317782998085,
0.08396421372890472,
-0.23456116020679474,
-0.07921764999628067,
0.786098062992096,
-0.41399744153022766,
-0.37499484419822693,
0.2195982038974762,
0.14197421073913574,
-0.25805041193962097,
-0.1152019053697586,
-0.6498452425003052,
-0.16861297190189362,
-0.11212364584207535,
-0.16556105017662048,
0.3889055848121643,
0.49858421087265015,
0.2566649615764618,
0.551227867603302,
0.5221383571624756,
0.1692652702331543,
0.010599455796182156,
0.3004646599292755,
0.9248455762863159,
-0.4889603555202484,
-0.4495302140712738,
-1.0693840980529785,
0.49386316537857056,
0.11202920228242874,
-0.6357666254043579,
0.7356675863265991,
0.1966417282819748,
0.6209503412246704,
0.17138221859931946,
0.7596829533576965,
0.0023236062843352556,
0.021111885085701942,
-0.6487638354301453,
0.5975532531738281,
-0.4958430826663971,
0.20935508608818054,
-0.15669865906238556,
-0.5956246852874756,
-0.6258723139762878,
0.42250820994377136,
0.07889076322317123,
-0.11257419735193253,
0.6395248770713806,
1.0268784761428833,
-0.21939092874526978,
-0.2842261493206024,
0.7029188871383667,
0.07775598764419556,
0.1300305426120758,
0.9191303253173828,
0.6167551875114441,
-0.6344608068466187,
0.9733158349990845,
-0.26973432302474976,
-0.3203761577606201,
-0.16759414970874786,
-0.9010714888572693,
-1.2527896165847778,
-0.3810805678367615,
-0.2683785855770111,
-0.4614870250225067,
0.3619489371776581,
0.9344141483306885,
0.5920217037200928,
-1.105278491973877,
0.536346971988678,
-0.2617851793766022,
0.1115058958530426,
-0.07703938335180283,
-0.26241403818130493,
0.34041136503219604,
-0.6732352375984192,
-0.5608145594596863,
0.8596946597099304,
0.44458845257759094,
0.3382102847099304,
-0.25750577449798584,
0.05482998490333557,
-0.035245731472969055,
-0.17946720123291016,
0.3928450047969818,
0.5000625848770142,
-0.672288715839386,
-0.1810310184955597,
0.1941300332546234,
-0.4260353744029999,
-0.052134864032268524,
0.6769123077392578,
-0.6735895276069641,
0.6901606321334839,
0.43989646434783936,
1.1835522651672363,
0.08364409953355789,
0.05989114195108414,
0.5264358520507812,
-1.0523170232772827,
0.379825234413147,
0.209567129611969,
0.3697596788406372,
0.4423958659172058,
-0.45463916659355164,
0.07871181517839432,
0.30039212107658386,
-0.24939031898975372,
-0.6979193687438965,
0.372744619846344,
-0.9492191076278687,
-0.29743117094039917,
1.1237260103225708,
-0.417545884847641,
-0.29048919677734375,
-0.005042070988565683,
-0.4231049418449402,
0.20527729392051697,
-0.49579572677612305,
0.6062993407249451,
0.539657711982727,
0.14965775609016418,
-0.4103585183620453,
-0.22194145619869232,
0.5585803985595703,
0.5476281046867371,
-0.42851805686950684,
0.19023647904396057,
0.6021904349327087,
-0.1043751910328865,
-0.006731363944709301,
0.2075778990983963,
0.027922583743929863,
0.5295263528823853,
0.2874475121498108,
-0.3808532953262329,
-0.3271336257457733,
-0.6449790596961975,
-1.0888394117355347,
0.2990584969520569,
0.04947231337428093,
-0.39132994413375854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14773v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14773v1
|
StreamingT2V: Consistent, Dynamic, and Extendable Long Video Generation from Text
| 2024-03-21T18:27:29 | 2024-03-21T18:27:29 |
Roberto Henschel, Levon Khachatryan, Daniil Hayrapetyan, Hayk Poghosyan, Vahram Tadevosyan, Zhangyang Wang, Shant Navasardyan, Humphrey Shi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, eess.IV
|
Text-to-video diffusion models enable the generation of high-quality videos
that follow text instructions, making it easy to create diverse and individual
content. However, existing approaches mostly focus on high-quality short video
generation (typically 16 or 24 frames), ending up with hard-cuts when naively
extended to the case of long video synthesis. To overcome these limitations, we
introduce StreamingT2V, an autoregressive approach for long video generation of
80, 240, 600, 1200 or more frames with smooth transitions. The key components
are:(i) a short-term memory block called conditional attention module (CAM),
which conditions the current generation on the features extracted from the
previous chunk via an attentional mechanism, leading to consistent chunk
transitions, (ii) a long-term memory block called appearance preservation
module, which extracts high-level scene and object features from the first
video chunk to prevent the model from forgetting the initial scene, and (iii) a
randomized blending approach that enables to apply a video enhancer
autoregressively for infinitely long videos without inconsistencies between
chunks. Experiments show that StreamingT2V generates high motion amount. In
contrast, all competing image-to-video methods are prone to video stagnation
when applied naively in an autoregressive manner. Thus, we propose with
StreamingT2V a high-quality seamless text-to-long video generator that
outperforms competitors with consistency and motion. Our code will be available
at: https://github.com/Picsart-AI-Research/StreamingT2V
|
[
-0.17359063029289246,
-0.9103562831878662,
0.46087345480918884,
0.3182947039604187,
-0.597272515296936,
0.15918655693531036,
-0.20016272366046906,
-0.2291359305381775,
0.14139823615550995,
0.3952924609184265,
-0.6495445370674133,
-0.032985590398311615,
-0.8518595099449158,
-0.412193238735199,
-0.8737358450889587,
0.9709495306015015,
-0.2678481638431549,
-0.463919997215271,
0.08617067337036133,
0.05565939098596573,
-0.6107144951820374,
0.06185733899474144,
-0.7193209528923035,
-0.1651095747947693,
0.40152063965797424,
0.23250654339790344,
0.8234618902206421,
1.0226085186004639,
0.5310283899307251,
0.21501438319683075,
0.24842099845409393,
0.19862033426761627,
-0.5627006888389587,
0.3930111229419708,
-0.12119784206151962,
0.14153122901916504,
-0.18838520348072052,
-0.4079333245754242,
0.7777475118637085,
-0.25023624300956726,
0.12229058891534805,
0.23046499490737915,
0.10711027681827545,
0.9012969136238098,
-0.575437068939209,
-0.03333836793899536,
-0.3095502257347107,
0.1532403975725174,
-0.20482522249221802,
-0.3094647228717804,
-0.21071141958236694,
-0.21829058229923248,
0.1867384910583496,
-0.21250750124454498,
0.5215991139411926,
-0.23825603723526,
0.6916161179542542,
0.6811618804931641,
-0.46961256861686707,
0.08383193612098694,
-1.176105260848999,
0.4373239278793335,
-0.32174044847488403,
0.421793133020401,
0.311492919921875,
0.48222893476486206,
0.024221889674663544,
-0.9383706450462341,
-0.3835524022579193,
0.1413380354642868,
0.48206627368927,
0.43251097202301025,
-0.11550097167491913,
-0.006181890610605478,
0.23483943939208984,
0.38330957293510437,
-0.8351518511772156,
0.002494803862646222,
-0.31549373269081116,
0.058822546154260635,
0.7739056348800659,
0.11499331146478653,
0.16630032658576965,
-0.2587940990924835,
-0.510222315788269,
-0.19632644951343536,
-0.4039447605609894,
0.1289389580488205,
0.5127025842666626,
-0.42966288328170776,
-0.2656606435775757,
0.6820821166038513,
-0.18854424357414246,
0.35702818632125854,
0.1638747900724411,
-0.16690413653850555,
-0.06350670009851456,
-0.40573301911354065,
-0.3771277964115143,
0.06032007932662964,
0.89921635389328,
0.6135967969894409,
-0.16964948177337646,
0.30951473116874695,
-0.09167544543743134,
0.09148754924535751,
0.20336107909679413,
-0.9993854761123657,
-0.5436122417449951,
0.2741425633430481,
-0.418678343296051,
-0.19866222143173218,
-0.10087006539106369,
-0.9286317229270935,
0.04028281196951866,
-0.18720556795597076,
0.6285746693611145,
-0.6018117070198059,
-0.3802658021450043,
-0.21307921409606934,
-0.43036705255508423,
0.12732857465744019,
0.4330656826496124,
-0.9057250022888184,
0.1363346129655838,
0.4296468198299408,
0.9687426686286926,
-0.5508471131324768,
-0.14436671137809753,
-0.7517004013061523,
0.6317908763885498,
-0.3973957300186157,
0.8128114938735962,
-0.14922165870666504,
-0.1652514487504959,
0.3143581748008728,
-0.006493987049907446,
0.5614596009254456,
-0.20395682752132416,
-0.0018665471579879522,
-0.39447492361068726,
0.2531789541244507,
0.10560397058725357,
-0.5972764492034912,
0.026017969474196434,
0.0986204668879509,
-0.4800618588924408,
1.1829757690429688,
0.16720271110534668,
-0.5261526703834534,
0.4038545787334442,
-0.6042752861976624,
-0.5250149965286255,
0.22389353811740875,
-0.11056431382894516,
-0.5134279727935791,
-0.0016146168345585465,
-0.18373169004917145,
0.23350746929645538,
-0.09426284581422806,
0.4163838326931,
0.035860102623701096,
-0.10385309159755707,
-0.062408626079559326,
-0.9213806390762329,
-0.05061337724328041,
0.39420920610427856,
-0.3635885417461395,
0.021215498447418213,
-0.5179452896118164,
-0.07098320871591568,
-0.0521642230451107,
-0.2819724678993225,
0.11336830258369446,
0.37766745686531067,
0.10334614664316177,
0.19274812936782837,
-0.05066782608628273,
-0.36533278226852417,
-0.11247172951698303,
-0.2630195617675781,
0.7031480073928833,
0.6941787600517273,
0.1912190318107605,
0.2822173535823822,
-0.1662030965089798,
0.5453847050666809,
0.011185739189386368,
0.1929057240486145,
-0.7240973114967346,
-0.43531090021133423,
-0.662726879119873,
-0.15649665892124176,
-0.12090755999088287,
0.3016807734966278,
-0.9641029834747314,
0.136729896068573,
-0.3256979286670685,
-0.19247502088546753,
-0.022426391020417213,
0.3245363235473633,
0.2657010853290558,
0.2266717255115509,
0.43024271726608276,
-0.45065951347351074,
-0.4619036316871643,
-0.8162292242050171,
0.03382635861635208,
-0.09891294687986374,
-0.13762810826301575,
0.13050894439220428,
0.3393486738204956,
-0.18009230494499207,
0.8499962687492371,
-0.5890578627586365,
-0.0724610686302185,
-0.017902828752994537,
0.23093998432159424,
-0.23399220407009125,
0.5249922275543213,
0.4126220941543579,
-0.790075421333313,
-0.6193007826805115,
-0.08901409804821014,
-0.5771653652191162,
0.4239751398563385,
-0.28688475489616394,
-0.2169371396303177,
0.2732596695423126,
0.49211955070495605,
-0.5158922076225281,
0.7242189049720764,
0.6655711531639099,
-0.20389646291732788,
0.1909457892179489,
-0.507601261138916,
0.27640804648399353,
-1.3629664182662964,
-0.38168999552726746,
0.04413996636867523,
-0.721230685710907,
-0.41279420256614685,
-0.24815085530281067,
-0.17657490074634552,
-0.28802037239074707,
-0.7636467218399048,
0.4964612126350403,
-0.34906020760536194,
-0.18187837302684784,
-0.5793642401695251,
-0.011171163991093636,
-0.0261653121560812,
0.2757509648799896,
0.24740856885910034,
0.661724865436554,
0.5256587862968445,
-0.7282432913780212,
0.6878044605255127,
0.18793582916259766,
-0.3613973557949066,
0.386068195104599,
-0.6541533470153809,
-0.1659260243177414,
-0.3323639929294586,
0.3472807705402374,
-1.0601602792739868,
-0.7950342893600464,
-0.061863142997026443,
-0.5896146297454834,
0.4055570363998413,
-0.28789204359054565,
-0.2992039918899536,
-0.38045552372932434,
-0.29158198833465576,
0.5377633571624756,
1.1490639448165894,
-0.48187142610549927,
0.38641947507858276,
0.18399973213672638,
-0.33665165305137634,
-0.30240878462791443,
-0.8791691660881042,
0.3962137997150421,
-0.19646592438220978,
-0.729924738407135,
0.5374528765678406,
-0.040705356746912,
0.22698920965194702,
-0.03199706971645355,
0.0573306605219841,
-0.24039170145988464,
-0.5701318383216858,
0.25826701521873474,
0.06923229247331619,
-0.06532274186611176,
0.07234663516283035,
0.354064017534256,
0.120391845703125,
0.04108171537518501,
-0.5088403820991516,
0.3127347528934479,
0.5018194913864136,
-0.021848145872354507,
-0.6195346713066101,
0.8311890959739685,
0.37718769907951355,
-0.0030613529961556196,
0.11295460164546967,
1.028529167175293,
-0.23623093962669373,
-0.26103341579437256,
-0.6370710730552673,
-0.024811170995235443,
-0.5538836717605591,
0.7272137999534607,
-0.04333991929888725,
-0.7780210375785828,
0.16656236350536346,
0.07695171236991882,
0.053358301520347595,
0.4093359708786011,
0.6716189384460449,
-0.45923930406570435,
0.9802098870277405,
0.5643030405044556,
0.5842736959457397,
0.9081421494483948,
-0.40627220273017883,
0.007015712093561888,
-0.5241929888725281,
-0.2665250599384308,
0.14621934294700623,
-0.28020235896110535,
-0.6914200186729431,
-0.7753923535346985,
0.2887428104877472,
-0.2063169628381729,
-0.4284948706626892,
0.3608245849609375,
-0.4667911231517792,
0.5531682968139648,
0.25182539224624634,
0.17223681509494781,
-0.0713670402765274,
0.3030468225479126,
0.47412192821502686,
-0.19743502140045166,
-0.5398291945457458,
-0.19293004274368286,
0.7300246953964233,
0.4646513760089874,
0.6784459948539734,
0.4890928268432617,
0.5679954886436462,
0.8713241815567017,
-0.06696246564388275,
-0.6979771852493286,
0.582429051399231,
-0.39395424723625183,
-0.5241061449050903,
-0.28258171677589417,
-0.0955955758690834,
-0.6462256908416748,
-0.3848471939563751,
-0.058232150971889496,
-0.5156958103179932,
-0.27274125814437866,
0.5799727439880371,
-0.2700578272342682,
0.3051612675189972,
-0.542747974395752,
0.6297315955162048,
-0.22151502966880798,
-1.1920561790466309,
-0.21219497919082642,
-0.922545850276947,
0.49769893288612366,
-0.08506546914577484,
-0.09256741404533386,
0.022832723334431648,
-0.06477601081132889,
0.6627134680747986,
-0.5625690817832947,
0.4069712460041046,
-0.15077930688858032,
-0.02477036789059639,
0.840575098991394,
0.11614742130041122,
0.6283712983131409,
0.2773972153663635,
0.6113132238388062,
-0.3438306748867035,
-0.30293574929237366,
-0.47930264472961426,
-0.5217588543891907,
0.7203637361526489,
-0.562920093536377,
-0.5283886790275574,
-0.2892935276031494,
-0.24931691586971283,
0.18277204036712646,
0.10122014582157135,
0.5373020768165588,
0.42419716715812683,
-0.20924700796604156,
0.31241118907928467,
0.8567782044410706,
-0.14816595613956451,
1.0420604944229126,
-0.22002701461315155,
-0.19644981622695923,
-0.83558189868927,
0.9337315559387207,
-0.058765850961208344,
0.5276916027069092,
0.3944832682609558,
-0.013169575482606888,
-0.33985769748687744,
-0.43687668442726135,
-0.6411879658699036,
-0.07251343876123428,
-0.3336377739906311,
-0.28593602776527405,
-0.5382445454597473,
-0.4215213656425476,
-0.46132656931877136,
-0.15174159407615662,
-0.7332121729850769,
-0.2446574717760086,
-0.2542361617088318,
-0.12529492378234863,
0.5563496351242065,
0.5648780465126038,
-0.05942177772521973,
0.4723723828792572,
-0.9519881010055542,
0.5711246728897095,
0.7704650163650513,
0.3042152523994446,
-0.305247038602829,
-0.7999568581581116,
-0.4359334707260132,
-0.1055055484175682,
-0.646475613117218,
-0.6334863305091858,
0.6615525484085083,
0.2914513051509857,
0.03952563554048538,
0.44610103964805603,
-0.3266347348690033,
0.9058172702789307,
-0.7742676734924316,
1.2207738161087036,
0.790981113910675,
-0.6632786989212036,
0.6674484014511108,
-0.6368203163146973,
0.4637404680252075,
0.17968125641345978,
0.19551001489162445,
-0.2678805887699127,
-0.16156335175037384,
-0.5240683555603027,
-1.0251692533493042,
0.41147881746292114,
0.6751358509063721,
0.31234586238861084,
-0.013318986631929874,
0.3791170120239258,
0.17039895057678223,
0.051131054759025574,
-0.4487088620662689,
0.0695195123553276,
-0.8806788921356201,
-0.12516221404075623,
-0.16407373547554016,
-0.27535557746887207,
0.1884785145521164,
0.017112240195274353,
0.5007786154747009,
-0.07092677056789398,
0.4979637563228607,
0.43810391426086426,
0.021780138835310936,
-0.1773778796195984,
-0.015196100808680058,
0.6968209147453308,
0.3640604615211487,
-0.2765004634857178,
0.014727837406098843,
-0.24579335749149323,
-0.5866110324859619,
0.41161632537841797,
-0.13882632553577423,
-0.41687801480293274,
0.18359863758087158,
0.023104218766093254,
1.0421953201293945,
-0.20290303230285645,
-0.5363914966583252,
0.6113787293434143,
0.16221652925014496,
-0.5751566290855408,
-0.7310119867324829,
0.10569468885660172,
-0.1506136655807495,
0.28443995118141174,
0.28434067964553833,
0.03129374235868454,
0.09964212775230408,
-0.6256226897239685,
0.33991047739982605,
0.16007380187511444,
-0.5047675371170044,
-0.44628992676734924,
1.199187159538269,
0.40257635712623596,
-0.7091612219810486,
0.5143847465515137,
-0.13147474825382233,
0.028916340321302414,
0.5203261971473694,
0.37953922152519226,
1.1920456886291504,
-0.17194002866744995,
0.319401353597641,
0.5125176310539246,
-0.09541933983564377,
-0.5285446643829346,
0.2064317911863327,
-0.2511076033115387,
-0.08432371914386749,
-0.7134422063827515,
-0.38555726408958435,
-0.22312870621681213,
0.17332416772842407,
-0.6066790819168091,
0.5159408450126648,
-0.2170570194721222,
-0.37779852747917175,
-0.0815826952457428,
-0.460649698972702,
-0.47884276509284973,
0.5170420408248901,
0.4225543737411499,
0.6638858318328857,
-0.7022879123687744,
1.0805999040603638,
0.22858326137065887,
-0.2487667351961136,
-0.4017871618270874,
-0.0832941010594368,
-0.09923138469457626,
-0.3005531132221222,
0.48262932896614075,
0.16374258697032928,
-0.0055212220177054405,
-0.14369167387485504,
-0.6234680414199829,
-0.8814048767089844,
1.190435767173767,
0.12557849287986755,
-0.5871931910514832,
-0.3534321188926697,
0.18434321880340576,
0.47538062930107117,
-0.3312530219554901,
0.05856410041451454,
0.35169824957847595,
0.17618651688098907,
0.610687792301178,
-0.3297346532344818,
-0.3715426027774811,
-0.07431530952453613,
0.37094980478286743,
0.4417021572589874,
-1.0672845840454102,
0.45683571696281433,
-0.19015733897686005,
0.018001824617385864,
0.19418799877166748,
1.0598126649856567,
-0.09111502766609192,
0.46477171778678894,
0.19193318486213684,
0.4838792383670807,
-0.02702064998447895,
0.04599868506193161,
0.6208093166351318,
-0.12265101820230484,
0.2526291310787201,
1.3648802042007446,
-0.054223157465457916,
0.7891613841056824,
0.6920701861381531,
-0.058855846524238586,
0.43859177827835083,
0.5821159482002258,
-0.22549007833003998,
0.7271613478660583,
-0.07813329994678497,
-0.2861102223396301,
-0.25382357835769653,
0.04204161837697029,
-0.22976244986057281,
0.37827715277671814,
0.26306235790252686,
-0.6009010076522827,
0.053011391311883926,
0.19552642107009888,
-0.2071976214647293,
-0.03159942105412483,
-0.272005170583725,
0.7792990207672119,
-0.20481346547603607,
-1.0071717500686646,
0.29680919647216797,
-0.19495132565498352,
0.4992520213127136,
-0.6982743740081787,
-0.13754336535930634,
-0.29263728857040405,
0.09795869886875153,
-0.2403930425643921,
-1.0618926286697388,
0.3390980660915375,
0.404757022857666,
-0.25763651728630066,
-0.4025455415248871,
0.501495897769928,
-0.661533772945404,
-0.36593201756477356,
-0.08802370727062225,
0.14000101387500763,
0.3125113546848297,
0.1988508254289627,
-0.36960893869400024,
-0.029189173132181168,
0.22855953872203827,
-0.40113866329193115,
0.5166595578193665,
0.2994244694709778,
0.0052972398698329926,
0.49478936195373535,
0.375203937292099,
-0.003981692250818014,
0.20927025377750397,
-0.15688537061214447,
0.5959130525588989,
-0.7158167958259583,
-0.47088947892189026,
-0.8742250800132751,
0.5830795168876648,
-0.10758351534605026,
-0.1961403638124466,
0.5683400630950928,
0.7877357006072998,
0.6005002856254578,
-0.060422684997320175,
0.9101340770721436,
-0.11767511814832687,
0.05517956241965294,
-0.6251557469367981,
0.3365098536014557,
-0.47247427701950073,
-0.19320683181285858,
-0.15940329432487488,
-1.0317566394805908,
0.09240303188562393,
0.1653497964143753,
0.2726869583129883,
-0.2152329385280609,
0.7703225612640381,
0.32739606499671936,
-0.2090308666229248,
-0.15850095450878143,
0.4105401635169983,
0.041823938488960266,
0.6418276429176331,
0.5960310101509094,
0.6813387274742126,
-0.8778297305107117,
0.8838096857070923,
-0.15979725122451782,
0.009800794534385204,
-0.03032209724187851,
-1.0421925783157349,
-0.6484012007713318,
-0.43934017419815063,
-0.7173886299133301,
-0.46514514088630676,
0.3333711624145508,
0.7030261158943176,
0.9178727865219116,
-0.13122346997261047,
-0.14853321015834808,
-0.2839944660663605,
-0.4372696876525879,
-0.05963962525129318,
-0.2353592962026596,
0.3789895474910736,
0.15312273800373077,
-0.793569028377533,
0.24253793060779572,
0.6707170009613037,
0.5318843722343445,
-0.47066348791122437,
-0.16714845597743988,
-0.05788887292146683,
0.2570789158344269,
0.7837992310523987,
0.4360930621623993,
-0.4670674800872803,
-0.39475736021995544,
-0.2146703153848648,
0.16605788469314575,
0.3649185001850128,
0.7917004227638245,
-0.656037449836731,
0.4885873794555664,
0.7162017822265625,
0.35987672209739685,
1.2896970510482788,
0.25815194845199585,
0.5461605787277222,
-0.6999258399009705,
0.34502896666526794,
0.1564943641424179,
0.02911957912147045,
0.2824326157569885,
-0.24355700612068176,
0.3808233439922333,
0.131067156791687,
-0.8226083517074585,
-0.691802978515625,
0.4740997850894928,
-1.2412585020065308,
-0.07052280008792877,
1.3191379308700562,
-0.08088421821594238,
-0.2960198223590851,
0.19483086466789246,
-0.0317210890352726,
0.4919227063655853,
-0.5236449241638184,
0.704429566860199,
0.33516818284988403,
-0.2982814908027649,
-0.46169647574424744,
-0.7289556860923767,
0.6714708209037781,
0.1373460441827774,
-0.5938738584518433,
0.018423667177557945,
0.6083062291145325,
0.38719621300697327,
-0.19466827809810638,
0.3870602250099182,
-0.07484772056341171,
0.5752397179603577,
0.061578527092933655,
-0.1967940777540207,
-0.11008522659540176,
-0.3730655610561371,
-0.06832483410835266,
0.16702121496200562,
-0.37484607100486755,
-0.23851847648620605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14624v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14624v1
|
MathVerse: Does Your Multi-modal LLM Truly See the Diagrams in Visual Math Problems?
| 2024-03-21T17:59:50 | 2024-03-21T17:59:50 |
Renrui Zhang, Dongzhi Jiang, Yichi Zhang, Haokun Lin, Ziyu Guo, Pengshuo Qiu, Aojun Zhou, Pan Lu, Kai-Wei Chang, Peng Gao, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The remarkable progress of Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has
garnered unparalleled attention, due to their superior performance in visual
contexts. However, their capabilities in visual math problem-solving remain
insufficiently evaluated and understood. We investigate current benchmarks to
incorporate excessive visual content within textual questions, which
potentially assist MLLMs in deducing answers without truly interpreting the
input diagrams. To this end, we introduce MathVerse, an all-around visual math
benchmark designed for an equitable and in-depth evaluation of MLLMs. We
meticulously collect 2,612 high-quality, multi-subject math problems with
diagrams from publicly available sources. Each problem is then transformed by
human annotators into six distinct versions, each offering varying degrees of
information content in multi-modality, contributing to 15K test samples in
total. This approach allows MathVerse to comprehensively assess whether and how
much MLLMs can truly understand the visual diagrams for mathematical reasoning.
In addition, we propose a Chain-of-Thought (CoT) evaluation strategy for a
fine-grained assessment of the output answers. Rather than naively judging True
or False, we employ GPT-4(V) to adaptively extract crucial reasoning steps, and
then score each step with detailed error analysis, which can reveal the
intermediate CoT reasoning quality by MLLMs. We hope the MathVerse benchmark
may provide unique insights to guide the future development of MLLMs. Project
page: https://mathverse-cuhk.github.io
|
[
-0.6183605790138245,
-0.9724529981613159,
0.4945489168167114,
0.41199612617492676,
-0.1837361603975296,
0.06113322824239731,
-0.17049111425876617,
-0.1677149534225464,
-0.2661623954772949,
0.41696032881736755,
-0.7413574457168579,
-0.31724411249160767,
-0.5399960279464722,
0.1712483912706375,
-0.10907641798257828,
0.6472790837287903,
-0.1484111249446869,
0.2203674465417862,
-0.8930550813674927,
-0.35480985045433044,
-0.6415590643882751,
-0.4727848768234253,
-0.2623501718044281,
-0.0645173192024231,
0.6027633547782898,
0.0336901918053627,
0.8482640981674194,
0.3574467599391937,
0.7366024255752563,
0.36072880029678345,
0.18118473887443542,
0.42368462681770325,
-0.7102823257446289,
0.19582347571849823,
-0.14339999854564667,
-0.17709454894065857,
-0.4295765459537506,
0.10282668471336365,
0.7578831911087036,
0.8979188799858093,
0.12660422921180725,
0.37198469042778015,
-0.048652347177267075,
0.6718235015869141,
-0.8629772067070007,
0.3612537384033203,
-0.42288458347320557,
0.2491568624973297,
-0.09292147308588028,
-0.24439561367034912,
-0.38844817876815796,
-0.29988786578178406,
-0.08756767213344574,
-0.8080225586891174,
-0.09149142354726791,
0.06829865276813507,
0.6336423754692078,
0.33363184332847595,
-0.5616059303283691,
0.006538234185427427,
-0.4585176408290863,
0.7854774594306946,
-0.21576860547065735,
0.6890295743942261,
0.3518955111503601,
0.7084481120109558,
-0.1630498766899109,
-0.6628511548042297,
-0.5041693449020386,
-0.04249797388911247,
0.17889100313186646,
0.32381972670555115,
-0.4597855806350708,
-0.31921738386154175,
0.7109502553939819,
0.1420530527830124,
-0.8082709312438965,
-0.29834121465682983,
-0.28198501467704773,
-0.23098817467689514,
0.4739915132522583,
0.45464497804641724,
0.12529264390468597,
-0.15372565388679504,
-0.32224181294441223,
-0.35853126645088196,
-0.5981903076171875,
0.07369142025709152,
0.14831674098968506,
-0.15443015098571777,
-0.2533676326274872,
0.8665155172348022,
0.15584778785705566,
0.8324328660964966,
-0.45394840836524963,
-0.05865993723273277,
0.20598602294921875,
-0.4222809672355652,
-0.4311389625072479,
-0.6261852979660034,
0.7489869594573975,
0.4019629955291748,
0.5113916993141174,
-0.061062950640916824,
-0.0923275351524353,
0.23289456963539124,
0.2847481071949005,
-0.9154679179191589,
-0.36500295996665955,
-0.2536998689174652,
-0.29127371311187744,
0.005398754496127367,
-0.021443193778395653,
-0.6100378036499023,
-0.6270740032196045,
-0.7720187902450562,
0.4463057816028595,
-0.37129640579223633,
-0.21642406284809113,
-0.08048078417778015,
-0.2571425437927246,
-0.04204060882329941,
0.7062090039253235,
-0.20140819251537323,
0.16664338111877441,
0.8476681113243103,
0.583283007144928,
-0.03647130727767944,
-0.3866312503814697,
-0.8854965567588806,
-0.18112260103225708,
-0.5525972843170166,
0.9469388723373413,
-0.5368126034736633,
-0.13322848081588745,
-0.3570253252983093,
-0.18184985220432281,
-0.19427666068077087,
-0.5250449180603027,
0.39947259426116943,
-0.4063534140586853,
0.06752879917621613,
-0.7162579894065857,
-0.534822404384613,
-0.05375508964061737,
0.5705547332763672,
-0.7220556735992432,
0.6204875707626343,
0.15099477767944336,
-0.714672863483429,
0.4359953701496124,
-0.40782976150512695,
-0.1026192232966423,
0.09717896580696106,
-0.6210198998451233,
-0.4451591670513153,
0.18964551389217377,
0.30112940073013306,
0.2788175046443939,
-0.38545066118240356,
0.36907288432121277,
-0.7219275832176208,
-0.4018239676952362,
0.6395600438117981,
-0.9157836437225342,
0.9025539755821228,
0.15929058194160461,
-0.31015506386756897,
0.22527039051055908,
-0.5244753956794739,
0.18196436762809753,
0.29627352952957153,
0.16930951178073883,
-0.15815098583698273,
-0.2916707694530487,
0.10993660986423492,
0.5039161443710327,
-0.0025941573549062014,
-0.1724780797958374,
0.10142751038074493,
0.02747204340994358,
0.1436687558889389,
1.0957074165344238,
-0.32918548583984375,
0.1558849960565567,
-0.27167218923568726,
0.6107900142669678,
0.042817872017621994,
0.23251695930957794,
-0.22719833254814148,
-0.7663438320159912,
-0.6663240194320679,
-0.5978174209594727,
0.05155741423368454,
0.25625598430633545,
-0.8803321123123169,
0.26470568776130676,
-0.28400808572769165,
-0.34269779920578003,
-0.22074617445468903,
0.1877003312110901,
0.4211099147796631,
0.44845274090766907,
0.32507604360580444,
-0.13042521476745605,
-0.20019696652889252,
-0.8354865312576294,
-0.44714218378067017,
0.1699414998292923,
0.020529644563794136,
0.6043293476104736,
0.633394181728363,
-0.18585854768753052,
0.7699184417724609,
-0.4527927041053772,
-0.19377706944942474,
0.180745929479599,
0.2517898380756378,
0.16723650693893433,
-0.011988578364253044,
0.4609852731227875,
-0.916676938533783,
-0.3927084505558014,
0.010737777687609196,
-1.0640431642532349,
-0.16217641532421112,
-0.0832928791642189,
-0.40528520941734314,
-0.09872353821992874,
0.23006801307201385,
-0.6247560381889343,
0.6723873019218445,
0.3999154567718506,
-0.7198911309242249,
0.6281570196151733,
-0.19518819451332092,
0.2378644198179245,
-0.4387882649898529,
0.4268333613872528,
-0.13368158042430878,
-0.20321691036224365,
-0.031693242490291595,
0.23437875509262085,
0.264477014541626,
-0.3269574046134949,
-0.08266569674015045,
0.7129625678062439,
-0.4326729476451874,
-0.4798356890678406,
0.03542833775281906,
0.25423693656921387,
0.2593405246734619,
0.6317659020423889,
-0.47065216302871704,
0.8047758340835571,
0.6194027662277222,
-0.09691231697797775,
0.6037087440490723,
0.023659199476242065,
-0.24904753267765045,
1.033623218536377,
-0.4541669189929962,
-0.04395231232047081,
-0.3845365345478058,
0.3748573958873749,
-1.0036377906799316,
0.14621089398860931,
0.2552050054073334,
-0.29640859365463257,
0.03273899480700493,
0.07566069811582565,
-0.6283233761787415,
-0.4449808597564697,
-0.297393798828125,
0.5056653618812561,
0.2611241340637207,
-0.38800811767578125,
0.8546704053878784,
0.17537245154380798,
0.11649584770202637,
-0.687747061252594,
-0.4797614514827728,
0.23160475492477417,
0.0691867247223854,
-0.6058701872825623,
-0.11220800131559372,
-0.5079331994056702,
-0.4923620820045471,
0.112019844353199,
-0.21678851544857025,
0.018443774431943893,
0.1326264590024948,
0.44019603729248047,
0.3151623606681824,
-0.27392083406448364,
-0.007985942997038364,
-0.13962188363075256,
-0.28767111897468567,
0.31317728757858276,
-0.1841508001089096,
0.30280500650405884,
-0.38393476605415344,
-0.7558620572090149,
-0.02807733416557312,
0.2932366728782654,
0.7929986715316772,
-0.49048131704330444,
0.25071844458580017,
0.8331372141838074,
-0.4640418291091919,
-0.11642567813396454,
-0.5732573866844177,
0.1653440296649933,
-0.41228872537612915,
0.23889535665512085,
-0.5814549922943115,
-0.5985468626022339,
0.44387227296829224,
0.07669107615947723,
0.12262753397226334,
0.45726847648620605,
0.565962553024292,
0.003357678884640336,
1.0629373788833618,
0.2503422498703003,
0.4146120250225067,
0.062167029827833176,
-0.43671858310699463,
0.09042556583881378,
-0.5949857234954834,
-0.22439740598201752,
-0.15214306116104126,
-0.35698261857032776,
-0.2664090096950531,
-0.9009895324707031,
0.5911481380462646,
0.3807179033756256,
-0.3936319053173065,
0.07145711034536362,
-0.3044603168964386,
0.5538251399993896,
0.27038004994392395,
0.07067415118217468,
0.43582430481910706,
0.10350627452135086,
-0.2926795780658722,
-0.31713947653770447,
-0.419520765542984,
-0.05622011423110962,
1.163237452507019,
0.06451519578695297,
0.6246885061264038,
0.2271324247121811,
0.13297514617443085,
0.1300879567861557,
0.789518415927887,
-0.5312896966934204,
0.5162150263786316,
-0.1540582925081253,
-0.47853806614875793,
-0.1990387737751007,
-0.9807929396629333,
-0.89683997631073,
0.7001827359199524,
-0.26354050636291504,
-0.41645732522010803,
-0.11863512545824051,
-0.0667654424905777,
-0.0357687771320343,
0.17534664273262024,
-0.5926840901374817,
1.2083038091659546,
-0.3210696280002594,
-0.6354294419288635,
-0.23205499351024628,
-0.35817933082580566,
0.4602816700935364,
-0.1438121348619461,
0.4476395547389984,
-0.23472706973552704,
-0.016528747975826263,
0.38172104954719543,
-0.39143553376197815,
0.6360148787498474,
-0.09725312143564224,
-0.15272295475006104,
0.22738602757453918,
0.27515944838523865,
0.17949213087558746,
0.2689742147922516,
0.18149758875370026,
0.34471264481544495,
-0.03860810026526451,
-0.4287845194339752,
-0.9493086934089661,
0.8611288666725159,
-0.6963897347450256,
-0.31509679555892944,
-0.3723001182079315,
-0.6518770456314087,
-0.29017719626426697,
0.2643795907497406,
-0.09827771037817001,
0.9221651554107666,
0.017174186185002327,
0.19558851420879364,
0.39148882031440735,
-0.3303796052932739,
0.2651955783367157,
0.1886969953775406,
-0.4007973074913025,
-0.6949882507324219,
1.001479148864746,
0.07830403745174408,
0.0571613572537899,
0.2968681752681732,
0.3665366470813751,
-0.5357593894004822,
0.03840648755431175,
-0.9337378740310669,
0.181358203291893,
-1.151228904724121,
-0.3889583945274353,
-0.6642559170722961,
-0.05953254923224449,
-0.1702301800251007,
-0.07194603979587555,
-0.24939759075641632,
-0.23749694228172302,
-0.05068827420473099,
0.3156246840953827,
0.19098258018493652,
0.5332731604576111,
0.04193354770541191,
-0.4438464641571045,
-0.4337611198425293,
0.6754598021507263,
0.6389048099517822,
0.5833142399787903,
0.12516461312770844,
-0.21665151417255402,
0.14885473251342773,
0.22851625084877014,
-0.5311432480812073,
-0.34961697459220886,
0.03713171184062958,
-0.0075973267666995525,
0.5771022439002991,
0.363262802362442,
-0.16895845532417297,
1.1728863716125488,
-0.5895385146141052,
0.38799700140953064,
0.5230486392974854,
-0.876046895980835,
0.09776128828525543,
-0.21790842711925507,
0.47413474321365356,
0.29087331891059875,
0.12196413427591324,
-0.15429732203483582,
-0.3697313368320465,
-0.4462861120700836,
-0.3466108441352844,
0.10972175747156143,
0.46259382367134094,
0.012870872393250465,
-0.010328320786356926,
-0.13906241953372955,
0.14930367469787598,
0.17088031768798828,
-0.549850583076477,
-0.30274221301078796,
-0.36339014768600464,
-0.16223745048046112,
-0.11827602982521057,
0.18688394129276276,
-0.2619093656539917,
-0.5927181839942932,
-0.10994159430265427,
-0.3138279914855957,
0.29016435146331787,
-0.02694207802414894,
-0.2790127992630005,
-0.33372652530670166,
-0.014301326125860214,
0.7140495181083679,
1.3714724779129028,
0.05673132836818695,
0.3874422609806061,
0.0014758430188521743,
-0.4417802095413208,
-0.2238183319568634,
0.3269289433956146,
0.18175522983074188,
-0.07940810173749924,
0.6613399386405945,
0.681201696395874,
0.45008260011672974,
-1.0640065670013428,
0.9871873259544373,
-0.22590209543704987,
-0.23717480897903442,
-0.26077431440353394,
-0.17066587507724762,
0.06624723970890045,
0.2570604383945465,
0.39382487535476685,
0.41921326518058777,
0.13155952095985413,
-0.4088403284549713,
0.32448121905326843,
0.6890437006950378,
-0.2112702876329422,
-0.20447559654712677,
0.7598557472229004,
-0.04334133490920067,
-0.08239048719406128,
0.4983188509941101,
-0.03138228878378868,
-0.4608239531517029,
0.6559199094772339,
0.3331749141216278,
0.6660893559455872,
0.3464781939983368,
0.09181738644838333,
0.2910100817680359,
0.18503035604953766,
0.33003243803977966,
0.3266947269439697,
-0.2577283978462219,
-0.3858093023300171,
-0.689603865146637,
-0.40245988965034485,
-0.370928555727005,
-0.19937573373317719,
-0.44102317094802856,
0.30593937635421753,
-0.5093070268630981,
-0.0790087953209877,
0.20382551848888397,
-0.10815064609050751,
-1.0730241537094116,
0.08685752004384995,
0.4050549566745758,
0.5714940428733826,
-0.5299379229545593,
0.3445736765861511,
0.5173252820968628,
-0.311941534280777,
-0.3036821484565735,
-0.4475173056125641,
-0.07029970735311508,
-0.9893215894699097,
0.6912539601325989,
0.4119378626346588,
-0.19165953993797302,
-0.1553247720003128,
-0.646168053150177,
-0.6259431838989258,
1.0132180452346802,
0.575588583946228,
-0.4417044222354889,
0.2163994163274765,
0.1841229945421219,
0.4540029466152191,
0.000043283427658025175,
0.6334970593452454,
-0.007529258728027344,
0.6966280937194824,
0.10756123065948486,
-0.8200943470001221,
0.023194435983896255,
-0.5493677854537964,
-0.13122662901878357,
0.24959123134613037,
-0.32589656114578247,
0.9997658729553223,
-0.28540992736816406,
-0.21561039984226227,
-0.08256889134645462,
0.3776843547821045,
0.6543792486190796,
0.5944318175315857,
0.5462389588356018,
0.7526782155036926,
0.6821893453598022,
-0.14058208465576172,
1.0654064416885376,
0.0021786214783787727,
0.4342063367366791,
0.7731872200965881,
-0.21749024093151093,
0.5623706579208374,
0.4093606472015381,
-0.24282953143119812,
0.26112037897109985,
0.18376833200454712,
-0.1953028440475464,
0.18757198750972748,
0.5898401141166687,
0.17061780393123627,
-0.7277171611785889,
-0.10851486027240753,
-0.6706027984619141,
0.26550212502479553,
0.18708141148090363,
-0.051851555705070496,
-0.4600251317024231,
0.12711836397647858,
-0.3263692259788513,
0.207117959856987,
-0.20337164402008057,
0.40045633912086487,
0.18696072697639465,
-0.4554218053817749,
0.8544365763664246,
-0.3213546574115753,
0.2426884025335312,
-0.4290795922279358,
-0.44334354996681213,
-0.3267812132835388,
0.29445502161979675,
0.0660165399312973,
-0.8918827176094055,
0.09126340597867966,
-0.03510715439915657,
-0.0342109240591526,
-0.3575805723667145,
0.4665549099445343,
-0.1319006234407425,
-0.8945923447608948,
0.22530673444271088,
0.8081738352775574,
0.11796935647726059,
-0.28140315413475037,
-0.8774128556251526,
0.3570670783519745,
-0.5458528995513916,
-0.028275631368160248,
0.2888323962688446,
0.8843620419502258,
-0.21844683587551117,
0.7653844356536865,
0.9332066774368286,
-0.39679959416389465,
-0.013334807008504868,
0.3428405225276947,
1.091429591178894,
-0.6525788903236389,
-0.3878933787345886,
-0.891055703163147,
0.5022684335708618,
-0.29144546389579773,
-0.6566752195358276,
0.936058521270752,
0.6856118440628052,
0.7733026742935181,
-0.05556293949484825,
0.380265474319458,
0.2656799554824829,
-0.0660744458436966,
-0.19370786845684052,
0.6081632375717163,
-0.8345621824264526,
0.03782973065972328,
-0.7656020522117615,
-1.0226101875305176,
-0.5973900556564331,
0.6028956770896912,
-0.2723808288574219,
0.018822792917490005,
0.7060625553131104,
0.32636207342147827,
-0.20017609000205994,
0.06472932547330856,
0.5515609383583069,
-0.018246378749608994,
0.3052833378314972,
0.7458662986755371,
1.187111496925354,
-0.4259085953235626,
0.6614093780517578,
-0.25320979952812195,
-0.34342384338378906,
-0.04145045578479767,
-0.8688607811927795,
-1.0717461109161377,
-0.28822824358940125,
-0.31076812744140625,
-0.29401731491088867,
-0.19006167352199554,
0.5730330944061279,
0.4565979838371277,
-0.5077975988388062,
-0.06794422119855881,
-0.051234371960163116,
0.3531630337238312,
-0.4238530993461609,
-0.1830819845199585,
0.41546496748924255,
0.0034502933267503977,
-0.2622016668319702,
0.11992283910512924,
0.6178423166275024,
-0.18741010129451752,
-0.5206938982009888,
-0.0015374512877315283,
0.2785423994064331,
-0.2251375913619995,
0.9271361827850342,
-0.2233860343694687,
-0.8666643500328064,
-0.03706876188516617,
0.3140921890735626,
-0.28848403692245483,
-0.11105746775865555,
0.9599953889846802,
-0.6568616032600403,
0.6746430993080139,
0.5235427021980286,
0.7013465166091919,
0.3991908133029938,
-0.07830498367547989,
0.32723256945610046,
-0.23847714066505432,
0.0005534224910661578,
0.28736430406570435,
0.42439034581184387,
0.2923274338245392,
-0.006319127045571804,
0.4069080352783203,
0.6363471746444702,
-0.20920446515083313,
-0.8950665593147278,
0.03491117060184479,
-0.9724224805831909,
-0.40227553248405457,
0.9513842463493347,
-0.14418324828147888,
-0.19665496051311493,
0.017176553606987,
-0.15032513439655304,
-0.2549925148487091,
0.0938221663236618,
0.392273873090744,
0.5819512009620667,
-0.0030021164566278458,
-0.2618925869464874,
-0.7667412757873535,
-0.0072293588891625404,
0.3795455992221832,
-0.8781359195709229,
0.2309887558221817,
0.7634684443473816,
0.04684809595346451,
0.031719036400318146,
0.5014522671699524,
-0.17510631680488586,
0.42081180214881897,
0.16339224576950073,
-0.27482354640960693,
-0.29662683606147766,
-0.4453025460243225,
-0.09669020771980286,
0.20564785599708557,
-0.38176611065864563,
0.24071013927459717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14613v1
|
DreamReward: Text-to-3D Generation with Human Preference
| 2024-03-21T17:58:04 | 2024-03-21T17:58:04 |
Junliang Ye, Fangfu Liu, Qixiu Li, Zhengyi Wang, Yikai Wang, Xinzhou Wang, Yueqi Duan, Jun Zhu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
3D content creation from text prompts has shown remarkable success recently.
However, current text-to-3D methods often generate 3D results that do not align
well with human preferences. In this paper, we present a comprehensive
framework, coined DreamReward, to learn and improve text-to-3D models from
human preference feedback. To begin with, we collect 25k expert comparisons
based on a systematic annotation pipeline including rating and ranking. Then,
we build Reward3D -- the first general-purpose text-to-3D human preference
reward model to effectively encode human preferences. Building upon the 3D
reward model, we finally perform theoretical analysis and present the Reward3D
Feedback Learning (DreamFL), a direct tuning algorithm to optimize the
multi-view diffusion models with a redefined scorer. Grounded by theoretical
proof and extensive experiment comparisons, our DreamReward successfully
generates high-fidelity and 3D consistent results with significant boosts in
prompt alignment with human intention. Our results demonstrate the great
potential for learning from human feedback to improve text-to-3D models.
|
[
-0.33566683530807495,
-0.2687305212020874,
0.5890361070632935,
0.28751063346862793,
-0.13908489048480988,
0.010037447325885296,
0.03521287813782692,
-0.521634578704834,
0.17896828055381775,
0.6011722683906555,
-0.4901527166366577,
-0.5100323557853699,
-0.4743382930755615,
0.2717335522174835,
-0.01457932684570551,
0.8885432481765747,
-0.03671518713235855,
-0.25588399171829224,
-0.41635432839393616,
0.5450060963630676,
-0.46904456615448,
-0.402854323387146,
-0.5732068419456482,
-0.014727856032550335,
0.6279245615005493,
0.7852928042411804,
0.5671793818473816,
0.490751713514328,
0.23853741586208344,
0.24723957479000092,
0.04752512648701668,
0.2834847569465637,
-0.8433511853218079,
-0.12717032432556152,
-0.12185395509004593,
-0.3532036244869232,
-0.43082043528556824,
0.1005520299077034,
0.07964999973773956,
0.35824960470199585,
-0.06159251928329468,
-0.07249141484498978,
0.4349953234195709,
1.169277548789978,
-0.5786794424057007,
0.1519867479801178,
-0.18932771682739258,
0.22602492570877075,
-0.2104249894618988,
-0.2806148827075958,
-0.4825679063796997,
-0.7774465680122375,
0.2718085050582886,
-0.8990792036056519,
0.5411727428436279,
0.3163025677204132,
0.516341507434845,
0.08236264437437057,
-0.33883804082870483,
-0.26636865735054016,
-0.4957965314388275,
0.7467626929283142,
-0.4544105529785156,
0.2771283984184265,
0.40980592370033264,
0.43293294310569763,
0.06650111824274063,
-0.2818363308906555,
-0.46207767724990845,
0.03595888242125511,
0.14179401099681854,
0.3627522885799408,
0.29051917791366577,
-0.002894188743084669,
-0.3151819705963135,
0.22022956609725952,
-0.585466206073761,
-0.10616972297430038,
-0.4009133577346802,
-0.024307414889335632,
0.8152815699577332,
0.048479579389095306,
0.0841793417930603,
-0.6098275780677795,
-0.43692028522491455,
-0.7395171523094177,
-0.35152173042297363,
0.2341461181640625,
0.6535128951072693,
0.3698776960372925,
-0.3159031867980957,
0.7432493567466736,
-0.07035990804433823,
0.9216896295547485,
0.09760897606611252,
-0.03594633936882019,
0.3076755404472351,
0.1654621958732605,
-0.16637761890888214,
0.09859450906515121,
0.8441927433013916,
0.8470340371131897,
0.26198065280914307,
-0.03858286887407303,
-0.11290183663368225,
-0.21931754052639008,
0.5727437734603882,
-0.648136556148529,
-0.4474431872367859,
0.3575346767902374,
-0.686950147151947,
-0.8099485039710999,
0.3200756907463074,
-0.9257561564445496,
-0.8917746543884277,
-0.3511711657047272,
0.16299057006835938,
-0.4952806532382965,
-0.5265000462532043,
0.6950189471244812,
-0.4995924234390259,
-0.369867205619812,
0.7109512090682983,
-1.14763343334198,
-0.2348979413509369,
0.641218364238739,
0.8236120939254761,
-0.5101528167724609,
-0.2801797091960907,
-0.1017272025346756,
0.40455883741378784,
-0.47763940691947937,
1.3433849811553955,
-0.36191320419311523,
-0.6581842303276062,
0.11790315061807632,
-0.71463942527771,
0.09517040103673935,
-0.6182240843772888,
0.3936609923839569,
-0.20330177247524261,
0.6570349931716919,
-0.2276459038257599,
-0.5191777944564819,
-0.27135562896728516,
0.35779842734336853,
-0.7692450881004333,
0.5372846722602844,
0.25104501843452454,
-0.7177858948707581,
0.4988892376422882,
-0.8409056067466736,
-0.3071374297142029,
0.07724881172180176,
-0.1698608547449112,
-0.013060037046670914,
0.2454068660736084,
0.43524160981178284,
0.7110524773597717,
-0.3961735665798187,
0.20496749877929688,
-0.2712043523788452,
-0.3151535093784332,
-0.07741297036409378,
-0.3881658911705017,
0.51511150598526,
0.08192304521799088,
0.05661868304014206,
0.30223846435546875,
-0.5849633812904358,
-0.1744607537984848,
0.1508442908525467,
-0.3787996172904968,
-0.293415367603302,
0.10684169083833694,
0.3349795937538147,
0.11831416189670563,
0.04977167397737503,
-0.5006639957427979,
0.2530440390110016,
-0.5531947612762451,
0.017496678978204727,
0.8858609199523926,
-0.05223655328154564,
0.2908893823623657,
-0.6475698351860046,
0.5670457482337952,
0.07310328632593155,
0.061057016253471375,
-0.0005872016190551221,
-0.48567238450050354,
-0.3720042407512665,
-0.19117246568202972,
-0.033475205302238464,
0.28863489627838135,
-0.643693208694458,
0.2872147858142853,
-0.4009510278701782,
-0.3636471629142761,
-0.6098160743713379,
0.09775116294622421,
0.23915232717990875,
0.5117961764335632,
0.5299057960510254,
0.13352671265602112,
-0.4980802536010742,
-1.0471351146697998,
-0.34207892417907715,
-0.4380640685558319,
-0.4960448443889618,
0.1711627095937729,
-0.0455353707075119,
0.03796995431184769,
1.145357608795166,
-0.7118008732795715,
-0.7479361295700073,
-0.44188982248306274,
0.12197272479534149,
0.1295086145401001,
0.3720163404941559,
0.5594763159751892,
-0.9988110661506653,
-0.30077555775642395,
-0.10457609593868256,
-0.6563176512718201,
0.27392998337745667,
-0.05870518460869789,
-0.2737354040145874,
0.05297879874706268,
0.34982210397720337,
-0.10554620623588562,
0.1319320648908615,
0.6184264421463013,
-0.4486781358718872,
0.44908407330513,
-0.004402760416269302,
0.43157637119293213,
-1.276794195175171,
-0.0985669270157814,
0.2719458341598511,
-0.1152513399720192,
-0.289009153842926,
-0.4151858389377594,
0.10714783519506454,
0.02225787565112114,
-0.727898120880127,
0.86713707447052,
-0.14601533114910126,
0.36221590638160706,
-0.304489403963089,
0.25056543946266174,
0.13146938383579254,
0.648390531539917,
0.5261372923851013,
0.300746887922287,
0.1539241522550583,
-0.7610040307044983,
0.23833291232585907,
0.6175302267074585,
-0.44357892870903015,
0.8416554927825928,
-0.475157231092453,
0.07332146167755127,
-0.18323606252670288,
0.10703808814287186,
-1.069764256477356,
-0.37699225544929504,
0.2936854064464569,
-0.4301542639732361,
-0.030800525099039078,
-0.09324090927839279,
-0.41457754373550415,
-0.5685385465621948,
-0.48475804924964905,
0.23236970603466034,
0.28160321712493896,
-0.8597336411476135,
0.46703270077705383,
0.4483681619167328,
0.054408520460128784,
-0.33586642146110535,
-0.2844044268131256,
-0.04885302484035492,
0.03897175192832947,
-0.6066552400588989,
0.5933367013931274,
-0.2805478870868683,
0.03213058412075043,
-0.19484375417232513,
0.17313826084136963,
0.36768123507499695,
-0.21178774535655975,
0.43347692489624023,
0.31011465191841125,
0.13620980083942413,
-0.1011577844619751,
0.2443447709083557,
-0.3112151622772217,
0.09854461997747421,
-0.30366185307502747,
0.3371469974517822,
-0.15239709615707397,
-0.2209053933620453,
-0.27311259508132935,
0.3108944296836853,
0.24066554009914398,
0.15947486460208893,
0.13408033549785614,
0.3142332136631012,
-0.27644583582878113,
-0.09031666815280914,
-0.48022255301475525,
-0.06421229988336563,
-0.5612034201622009,
0.4889351427555084,
-0.47991448640823364,
-0.831451416015625,
-0.1617770493030548,
0.018145307898521423,
0.5087443590164185,
0.3114140033721924,
0.3623923063278198,
-0.3512183725833893,
1.2901712656021118,
0.7774864435195923,
0.2839454114437103,
0.1858837604522705,
-0.15109029412269592,
-0.2606348693370819,
-0.8181098103523254,
-0.6343806982040405,
-0.32681527733802795,
-0.607158899307251,
0.03316380828619003,
-0.3790949285030365,
0.19545575976371765,
0.2721893787384033,
-0.3253801763057709,
0.18979516625404358,
-0.6881812810897827,
0.5157297253608704,
0.36623409390449524,
0.3010714054107666,
0.1712820827960968,
0.04523362219333649,
-0.289152055978775,
-0.2077609747648239,
-0.6572856903076172,
-0.5008734464645386,
0.7629451751708984,
0.11896169930696487,
0.6334546804428101,
0.23493635654449463,
0.6709365248680115,
0.48483705520629883,
0.39004629850387573,
-0.6158578991889954,
0.5501149892807007,
-0.2778349220752716,
-0.20830988883972168,
-0.19720113277435303,
-0.31980884075164795,
-0.7134416699409485,
0.3119491934776306,
-0.4474112391471863,
-0.5216455459594727,
0.17970553040504456,
0.572737455368042,
-0.47752001881599426,
0.5207184553146362,
-0.5634177923202515,
1.0313893556594849,
-0.41621220111846924,
-0.5609432458877563,
-0.04664747416973114,
-0.3248230218887329,
0.45636171102523804,
0.0943116620182991,
0.09709155559539795,
-0.26287034153938293,
0.025563765317201614,
0.7591412663459778,
-0.19893841445446014,
0.9351885318756104,
-0.24807803332805634,
-0.45365676283836365,
-0.11558710038661957,
0.47772666811943054,
0.18496651947498322,
0.3868129849433899,
-0.35174664855003357,
0.11992760002613068,
-0.2776544392108917,
-0.2556622326374054,
-0.5511569380760193,
0.5599384307861328,
-0.9069646000862122,
-0.6789495348930359,
-0.3732786774635315,
-0.4833098351955414,
-0.5543238520622253,
0.2762611508369446,
0.5510956645011902,
0.28493112325668335,
-0.39559632539749146,
-0.017310146242380142,
0.4813583791255951,
-0.2792767286300659,
0.36203914880752563,
0.16294030845165253,
-0.7732353806495667,
-0.6337071061134338,
0.9465189576148987,
-0.7657151818275452,
-0.12991799414157867,
0.9380778670310974,
0.44276636838912964,
-0.5182826519012451,
-0.28981974720954895,
-0.6410033106803894,
0.15828759968280792,
-0.4226861894130707,
-0.33178818225860596,
-0.5708617568016052,
-0.022441193461418152,
-0.4511868357658386,
-0.7896221876144409,
-0.6287460923194885,
-0.22040922939777374,
-0.6795497536659241,
-0.22455772757530212,
0.3593263030052185,
1.0845699310302734,
-0.08654139935970306,
0.037524305284023285,
-0.8404994010925293,
0.49596670269966125,
0.38603705167770386,
0.49185529351234436,
0.25435560941696167,
-0.31797605752944946,
-0.20128023624420166,
0.21220315992832184,
-0.31155216693878174,
-0.6510173082351685,
0.5576310753822327,
-0.1394042670726776,
0.22327931225299835,
0.6199805736541748,
0.21448248624801636,
0.7291075587272644,
-0.3183179497718811,
0.9000811576843262,
0.7051129341125488,
-0.848749577999115,
0.6467464566230774,
-0.39220160245895386,
0.46669116616249084,
0.5421923995018005,
0.2984888255596161,
-0.8354693651199341,
-0.16766704618930817,
-0.31482258439064026,
-0.7225827574729919,
0.8404108881950378,
-0.0841023400425911,
0.05836315080523491,
-0.07325827330350876,
0.379881888628006,
0.5306681990623474,
0.156495600938797,
-0.440792977809906,
0.18051303923130035,
-0.7929809093475342,
-0.29954203963279724,
-0.14379577338695526,
-0.2403009533882141,
-0.01344863511621952,
-0.04701351374387741,
0.494071364402771,
-0.35211917757987976,
0.17867039144039154,
0.02957848086953163,
0.07959169149398804,
-0.15968160331249237,
-0.03621891140937805,
0.6084946990013123,
0.5538589954376221,
-0.3874342739582062,
-0.013166486285626888,
-0.3157632052898407,
-0.4817297160625458,
0.17726828157901764,
-0.22843140363693237,
0.044348858296871185,
-0.34858429431915283,
0.1789761781692505,
0.9960784912109375,
0.3232332170009613,
-0.6576443314552307,
0.6987515091896057,
-0.3385426104068756,
-0.6867337822914124,
-0.21435639262199402,
0.34930819272994995,
0.045590877532958984,
0.022954797372221947,
0.4371170103549957,
0.7540648579597473,
0.0451856330037117,
0.08515951037406921,
0.06201789528131485,
0.17226791381835938,
-0.8166193962097168,
-0.20837441086769104,
1.1051815748214722,
0.6980381011962891,
-0.3732788562774658,
0.8037738800048828,
0.05773944407701492,
-0.2712561786174774,
0.2586529552936554,
0.6461192965507507,
1.0168904066085815,
-0.09351617842912674,
0.8312511444091797,
0.5547209978103638,
-0.06437371671199799,
-0.37678349018096924,
0.18172809481620789,
-0.12921033799648285,
-0.7076919674873352,
-0.11891432851552963,
-0.5922982096672058,
-0.395015686750412,
-0.04491302743554115,
-0.7428466081619263,
0.5720322132110596,
-0.20524585247039795,
0.038955170661211014,
-0.20867590606212616,
-0.27964162826538086,
-0.5996692776679993,
0.16983120143413544,
0.11675413697957993,
0.8674545884132385,
-0.5245850086212158,
0.5729678869247437,
0.69169020652771,
-0.1784033179283142,
-0.49102455377578735,
0.16091476380825043,
0.3559008538722992,
-0.6176161170005798,
0.4519495666027069,
0.43452340364456177,
-0.2475544512271881,
0.12535737454891205,
-0.295607328414917,
-0.6528456807136536,
0.8320991396903992,
0.28011348843574524,
-0.6194846630096436,
-0.21657118201255798,
0.2245720475912094,
0.4033046364784241,
-0.3979322016239166,
0.34086090326309204,
0.12105237692594528,
0.4469248354434967,
0.2947980463504791,
-0.4075181186199188,
-0.19440902769565582,
-0.5546940565109253,
0.38130414485931396,
0.012395953759551048,
-0.47090548276901245,
0.4139177203178406,
-0.5583304762840271,
-0.033439721912145615,
-0.06993550807237625,
1.0066853761672974,
0.7558530569076538,
-0.14659394323825836,
0.7268163561820984,
0.11333964020013809,
0.611177384853363,
0.19924414157867432,
1.2620885372161865,
0.010384089313447475,
-0.13743087649345398,
0.896331787109375,
-0.3383196294307709,
1.0308650732040405,
0.24253536760807037,
0.1449439823627472,
0.48815178871154785,
0.8428926467895508,
0.15530645847320557,
0.6680342555046082,
0.1486094743013382,
0.32542911171913147,
-0.38214972615242004,
0.317374587059021,
-0.3046110272407532,
0.16519081592559814,
0.1598222851753235,
-0.08706674724817276,
0.08551721274852753,
0.3943592607975006,
-0.21168312430381775,
0.2539687156677246,
-0.18497265875339508,
0.6973071694374084,
-0.12095950543880463,
-0.8081430196762085,
0.41792386770248413,
-0.08434572070837021,
0.9425632357597351,
-0.5321518778800964,
-0.15472263097763062,
-0.3018091320991516,
0.31852540373802185,
-0.2133914679288864,
-1.0372711420059204,
-0.08616224676370621,
-0.09871451556682587,
-0.4421866238117218,
-0.5732824206352234,
0.17884093523025513,
-0.4519033133983612,
-0.5495041608810425,
0.2241319715976715,
0.1463012397289276,
-0.18930451571941376,
-0.2939850389957428,
-0.6580061316490173,
-0.048554811626672745,
0.3467189371585846,
-0.30716606974601746,
0.23752832412719727,
0.17307354509830475,
0.17282165586948395,
0.4773769974708557,
0.5898222327232361,
0.020671145990490913,
-0.34138020873069763,
0.17690221965312958,
0.34167835116386414,
-0.6975077986717224,
-0.8406099677085876,
-0.6498931646347046,
0.5875553488731384,
-0.2651626169681549,
-0.6692681312561035,
0.663697361946106,
0.983397901058197,
0.9341540336608887,
-0.4432038366794586,
1.0860505104064941,
0.08187176287174225,
0.7922441363334656,
-0.5706321597099304,
0.8008449673652649,
-0.857110321521759,
0.3781960606575012,
-0.5973690152168274,
-0.9973820447921753,
-0.4434540867805481,
0.5578920245170593,
0.06172236427664757,
0.10469692945480347,
0.5658293962478638,
0.6004238128662109,
-0.05818573012948036,
0.4643455743789673,
0.31670376658439636,
-0.1820351481437683,
0.4914454221725464,
0.6847888231277466,
0.8082066178321838,
-0.19317084550857544,
0.6799727082252502,
-0.41761231422424316,
-0.32182514667510986,
-0.4103725850582123,
-0.9817519187927246,
-0.916102409362793,
-0.9232147932052612,
-0.3464103043079376,
-0.34051942825317383,
0.06942491233348846,
0.9481387138366699,
0.8212195634841919,
-0.7012873291969299,
-0.5460253357887268,
-0.10529010742902756,
0.0002135940158041194,
-0.6625917553901672,
-0.2269934117794037,
0.5633811354637146,
-0.05601454898715019,
-0.8332763910293579,
0.3570060729980469,
0.3421672284603119,
0.2782978415489197,
-0.19062326848506927,
-0.3290429711341858,
0.29253581166267395,
-0.1409955769777298,
0.7745229601860046,
0.2141367346048355,
-0.5261818170547485,
-0.19453002512454987,
0.12334121018648148,
-0.20376993715763092,
0.15728023648262024,
1.0185275077819824,
-0.9222719073295593,
0.48062458634376526,
0.6385502815246582,
0.23377224802970886,
0.5039531588554382,
0.12495814263820648,
1.0479599237442017,
-0.6908808946609497,
-0.09757231920957565,
0.2666354477405548,
-0.01614631898701191,
0.5346236228942871,
-0.46560534834861755,
0.3919832408428192,
0.054782915860414505,
-0.3402588963508606,
-0.36599624156951904,
0.12873826920986176,
-0.9993388056755066,
-0.5682665705680847,
1.071543574333191,
0.5151821374893188,
-0.17070309817790985,
-0.08403631299734116,
-0.5222243070602417,
-0.13156381249427795,
-0.5545132756233215,
1.177581787109375,
0.2548285722732544,
-0.43189528584480286,
-0.1467161774635315,
-0.15894244611263275,
0.9841563105583191,
0.17323563992977142,
-0.9550022482872009,
0.39639079570770264,
0.5816460847854614,
-0.15672944486141205,
0.003115206491202116,
0.6350719928741455,
-0.12699384987354279,
0.3694104850292206,
-0.22385409474372864,
0.24289456009864807,
-0.40647515654563904,
-0.5061340928077698,
-0.027564816176891327,
0.4672015607357025,
-0.16822285950183868,
0.02580833062529564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14589v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14589v3
|
ReAct Meets ActRe: When Language Agents Enjoy Training Data Autonomy
| 2024-03-21T17:43:44 | 2024-04-01T17:37:15 |
Zonghan Yang, Peng Li, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Yang Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language agents have demonstrated autonomous decision-making abilities by
reasoning with foundation models. Recently, efforts have been made to train
language agents for performance improvement, with multi-step reasoning and
action trajectories as the training data. However, collecting such trajectories
still requires considerable human effort, by either artificial annotation or
implementations of diverse prompting frameworks. In this work, we propose
A$^3$T, a framework that enables the Autonomous Annotation of Agent
Trajectories in the style of ReAct. The central role is an ActRe prompting
agent, which explains the reason for an arbitrary action. When randomly
sampling an external action, the ReAct-style agent could query the ActRe agent
with the action to obtain its textual rationales. Novel trajectories are then
synthesized by prepending the posterior reasoning from ActRe to the sampled
action. In this way, the ReAct-style agent executes multiple trajectories for
the failed tasks, and selects the successful ones to supplement its failed
trajectory for contrastive self-training. Realized by policy gradient methods
with binarized rewards, the contrastive self-training with accumulated
trajectories facilitates a closed loop for multiple rounds of language agent
self-improvement. We conduct experiments using QLoRA fine-tuning with the
open-sourced Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2. In AlfWorld, the agent trained with
A$^3$T obtains a 1-shot success rate of 96%, and 100% success with 4 iterative
rounds. In WebShop, the 1-shot performance of the A$^3$T agent matches human
average, and 4 rounds of iterative refinement lead to the performance
approaching human experts. A$^3$T agents significantly outperform existing
techniques, including prompting with GPT-4, advanced agent frameworks, and
fully fine-tuned LLMs.
|
[
-0.1608489453792572,
-0.4440191090106964,
0.6438475251197815,
0.09675244987010956,
0.08440149575471878,
0.2905198335647583,
-0.22180627286434174,
-0.3598911166191101,
0.18656452000141144,
0.39133816957473755,
-0.6695947647094727,
-0.4799245595932007,
-0.152339905500412,
0.16033698618412018,
-0.1425895392894745,
0.7085003852844238,
-0.2637837529182434,
-0.24332253634929657,
0.3268801271915436,
-0.3384084105491638,
-0.451856791973114,
-0.3011254668235779,
-0.9864157438278198,
-0.502449631690979,
0.6467058658599854,
0.5787696838378906,
0.5933007597923279,
0.6406417489051819,
0.15110692381858826,
0.37607499957084656,
0.4798796474933624,
0.25493288040161133,
-0.236470565199852,
0.4597018361091614,
-0.3709380328655243,
-0.4382131099700928,
-0.21134983003139496,
0.03500590845942497,
0.42007875442504883,
0.02338867075741291,
-0.09719959646463394,
-0.15143735706806183,
-0.5117371678352356,
0.7883389592170715,
-0.6423760652542114,
0.27197757363319397,
-0.08794863522052765,
0.16337062418460846,
0.1335524022579193,
-0.20868465304374695,
-0.2852846384048462,
-0.3868463933467865,
-0.35524293780326843,
-0.6529580354690552,
0.19360429048538208,
0.024075351655483246,
0.43418291211128235,
0.48070281744003296,
-0.3412207365036011,
-0.0994763895869255,
-0.9024888277053833,
0.36885198950767517,
-0.3917589485645294,
0.3702299892902374,
0.2913475036621094,
0.6017611026763916,
-0.046483758836984634,
-0.7643887400627136,
-0.6402490139007568,
-0.15001584589481354,
-0.026249904185533524,
-0.012728461064398289,
-0.10555820167064667,
0.15579868853092194,
0.22968709468841553,
0.07610345631837845,
-0.5495812296867371,
0.13882626593112946,
-0.09125225991010666,
-0.3551939129829407,
0.7246254086494446,
0.2149902731180191,
0.11607864499092102,
0.12674111127853394,
-0.3921048045158386,
-0.6646109223365784,
-0.563546895980835,
0.21616967022418976,
0.3315281569957733,
0.4183514714241028,
-0.05403364077210426,
0.2634026110172272,
-0.484390527009964,
0.5794689655303955,
0.067141592502594,
0.10309945791959763,
0.2606004476547241,
-0.09243278205394745,
0.11846991628408432,
-0.14273203909397125,
1.0601718425750732,
0.06168582662940025,
0.524660587310791,
-0.07417377829551697,
-0.45758914947509766,
-0.06850817799568176,
0.37054985761642456,
-0.5071823596954346,
-0.22749581933021545,
0.3957958519458771,
0.20529092848300934,
-0.18832886219024658,
-0.10155137628316879,
-0.5234067440032959,
-0.4990071654319763,
-0.35196396708488464,
0.7153984904289246,
-0.48624926805496216,
-0.26101183891296387,
0.009939005598425865,
-0.16754934191703796,
0.23634417355060577,
0.47341233491897583,
-0.9574306607246399,
0.20924824476242065,
0.5417867302894592,
0.5841329097747803,
-0.14861856400966644,
-0.5740397572517395,
-0.5106824636459351,
-0.03860846906900406,
-0.6249780654907227,
1.028105616569519,
-0.5424031019210815,
-0.16356052458286285,
0.0945720225572586,
-0.22152157127857208,
-0.24680931866168976,
-0.28151848912239075,
0.11122462898492813,
-0.5045922994613647,
-0.11797675490379333,
-0.1721733659505844,
-0.24336954951286316,
-0.33589765429496765,
0.43753841519355774,
-0.6693812608718872,
0.9632905721664429,
0.35834044218063354,
-0.3209299147129059,
0.3819381296634674,
-0.8833586573600769,
-0.4929499924182892,
0.09202374517917633,
-0.38260242342948914,
-0.023692835122346878,
-0.17045022547245026,
0.20896309614181519,
0.3115207552909851,
0.030999887734651566,
0.018452759832143784,
-0.0067399474792182446,
-0.40713921189308167,
0.23568212985992432,
-0.16794773936271667,
0.42387261986732483,
0.05554962530732155,
-0.6712965965270996,
0.4497218728065491,
-0.7601787447929382,
0.034335050731897354,
-0.053331684321165085,
-0.3092200458049774,
-0.040428921580314636,
-0.11041860282421112,
-0.3293933570384979,
0.47623398900032043,
0.021761156618595123,
-0.32537955045700073,
0.22646251320838928,
-0.4203836917877197,
0.23924674093723297,
0.8819034099578857,
0.38832956552505493,
0.47897812724113464,
-0.2893097996711731,
0.808961033821106,
-0.24165339767932892,
0.2023785263299942,
-0.16288377344608307,
-0.07007254660129547,
-0.7527112364768982,
-0.13936908543109894,
-0.08016684651374817,
0.2579801678657532,
-0.9428659677505493,
-0.1444951742887497,
-0.19327713549137115,
-0.34561458230018616,
-0.4322241544723511,
-0.06658652424812317,
0.382503479719162,
0.38091492652893066,
0.3918721377849579,
-0.00562695087864995,
-0.4094802141189575,
-0.7724248766899109,
-0.34724581241607666,
-0.40968969464302063,
0.3683657646179199,
0.02732996828854084,
0.5286365151405334,
-0.05827464908361435,
1.0501242876052856,
-0.2535589337348938,
-0.26896995306015015,
-0.2567921578884125,
0.45013946294784546,
-0.24404160678386688,
0.5052708983421326,
0.43276655673980713,
-0.500016987323761,
-0.4231105446815491,
0.00514260632917285,
-0.6458197236061096,
-0.04872268810868263,
-0.0634959265589714,
-0.2167779952287674,
0.4682588279247284,
0.4923964738845825,
-0.5311527848243713,
0.36243730783462524,
0.13072660565376282,
-0.33666038513183594,
0.45097753405570984,
-0.20674750208854675,
0.2810865044593811,
-0.6815710663795471,
0.08569588512182236,
-0.19096818566322327,
-0.36164599657058716,
-0.5891151428222656,
0.10249984264373779,
-0.11149058490991592,
-0.0880388468503952,
-0.5835522413253784,
1.0726966857910156,
-0.2412324696779251,
-0.1318831741809845,
-0.4023517966270447,
0.2082034945487976,
-0.05508079752326012,
0.8747564554214478,
0.23484180867671967,
0.8440025448799133,
0.3483065962791443,
-0.7046091556549072,
0.2612455487251282,
0.26947399973869324,
0.17991343140602112,
0.52925044298172,
-0.3033598065376282,
0.30272939801216125,
0.015301208943128586,
0.29290449619293213,
-0.9156229496002197,
-0.33995893597602844,
0.4584229290485382,
-0.25994861125946045,
0.1076962947845459,
0.1571723371744156,
-0.5032289028167725,
-0.5323399901390076,
-0.27208468317985535,
0.3186473250389099,
0.3001670241355896,
-0.5673151016235352,
0.8612009286880493,
-0.023040400817990303,
0.2810434103012085,
-0.8326374888420105,
-0.5127329230308533,
-0.14544716477394104,
0.07665853202342987,
-0.2581208348274231,
-0.21818484365940094,
-0.14659130573272705,
-0.41989803314208984,
-0.14752595126628876,
-0.30471208691596985,
-0.02466009184718132,
-0.013810986652970314,
0.2845679521560669,
-0.2701475918292999,
0.1550493985414505,
0.24463343620300293,
-0.10978590697050095,
-0.31160399317741394,
0.09325286000967026,
-0.4043123126029968,
0.3715432584285736,
-0.15981033444404602,
-0.3600675165653229,
-0.47950443625450134,
0.08408516645431519,
0.42742088437080383,
-0.2260901778936386,
0.1917562633752823,
0.5437480211257935,
-0.021627679467201233,
-0.5815275311470032,
-0.5759212970733643,
-0.19753436744213104,
-0.46698224544525146,
-0.14631935954093933,
-0.564018189907074,
-0.8884672522544861,
0.5226284265518188,
0.18996784090995789,
0.14593087136745453,
0.4947483539581299,
0.45218488574028015,
0.01185194868594408,
0.8382937908172607,
0.5318245887756348,
0.20732471346855164,
0.6052166223526001,
-0.4639261066913605,
-0.0804915800690651,
-0.32691866159439087,
-0.32568836212158203,
-0.38653069734573364,
-0.3430354595184326,
-0.48581692576408386,
-0.4403758645057678,
0.34390297532081604,
-0.4742075800895691,
-0.6346946954727173,
0.32459375262260437,
-0.4088227152824402,
0.4080768823623657,
0.59955894947052,
-0.028752153739333153,
0.2621394097805023,
-0.18219666182994843,
-0.0796915590763092,
0.2887254059314728,
-0.6564850211143494,
-0.2596106231212616,
0.7968141436576843,
0.0910894051194191,
0.8956990242004395,
0.04309026524424553,
0.9363189339637756,
0.527928352355957,
0.3084578812122345,
-0.8634733557701111,
0.7629628777503967,
0.3543538451194763,
-0.5419976115226746,
-0.3820594847202301,
-0.29103755950927734,
-0.9870862364768982,
0.3285601735115051,
0.07893659174442291,
-0.6867231726646423,
0.42707380652427673,
0.39559581875801086,
-0.2828017771244049,
-0.09650608897209167,
-0.4955843389034271,
0.9661598205566406,
-0.25297996401786804,
-0.5369820594787598,
-0.35518428683280945,
-0.7927306294441223,
0.05287852883338928,
0.0958656519651413,
0.2409682422876358,
-0.22394870221614838,
-0.1121794730424881,
0.4770514667034149,
-0.6373078227043152,
0.945021390914917,
-0.3526763916015625,
-0.18888185918331146,
0.5070462226867676,
0.5773903131484985,
0.6536237001419067,
-0.3774102032184601,
-0.09056278318166733,
-0.24804234504699707,
-0.2941363453865051,
-0.15859678387641907,
-0.8902086615562439,
0.47991958260536194,
-0.5227094888687134,
-0.5058824419975281,
-0.4219509959220886,
-0.47157302498817444,
-0.4431546926498413,
0.2015172690153122,
0.07644599676132202,
0.5587712526321411,
-0.10680247843265533,
-0.25627827644348145,
0.19846723973751068,
0.33175894618034363,
0.9718979001045227,
0.968889594078064,
-0.18285129964351654,
-0.473768949508667,
0.9445524215698242,
-0.10021641105413437,
0.2843955159187317,
0.5563077926635742,
0.2794184982776642,
-0.7109499573707581,
-0.25774839520454407,
-0.39255595207214355,
0.27979597449302673,
-1.004115104675293,
-0.2995106875896454,
-0.48142245411872864,
0.034289952367544174,
-0.23677626252174377,
-0.25862112641334534,
-0.3620989918708801,
-0.6876534819602966,
-0.08664248883724213,
-0.2330881506204605,
0.425788551568985,
1.0551235675811768,
-0.4403512477874756,
0.40994712710380554,
-0.4747896194458008,
0.1358671635389328,
0.45039239525794983,
0.2892104685306549,
0.006212589330971241,
-0.25282156467437744,
-0.3694908618927002,
-0.2298378050327301,
-0.1829100102186203,
-0.6385707259178162,
0.23096917569637299,
0.10551317036151886,
0.5359722375869751,
0.19178526103496552,
0.12543177604675293,
0.4880189895629883,
-0.41509175300598145,
0.721303403377533,
-0.08912844955921173,
-0.7312536239624023,
0.7914400100708008,
-0.49938589334487915,
0.39187347888946533,
0.7408802509307861,
0.17171281576156616,
-0.35183921456336975,
-0.7091829776763916,
-0.8748912811279297,
-0.6136742830276489,
1.036025881767273,
0.22574929893016815,
-0.23641709983348846,
-0.20790185034275055,
0.3188649117946625,
0.025067690759897232,
0.3351351022720337,
-0.7334850430488586,
-0.11960325390100479,
-0.24748481810092926,
-0.2617603838443756,
-0.1762591153383255,
0.23617768287658691,
-0.26125362515449524,
0.07037588953971863,
0.7049957513809204,
-0.4899420440196991,
0.11133517324924469,
0.281145304441452,
-0.10938091576099396,
-0.23899641633033752,
0.19854775071144104,
0.5851634740829468,
0.6486982703208923,
0.08607924729585648,
0.31842702627182007,
-0.23086245357990265,
-0.16511809825897217,
0.5879847407341003,
0.04008552432060242,
0.06941044330596924,
-0.22265742719173431,
0.4239121675491333,
0.861829400062561,
0.20581665635108948,
-0.6789489984512329,
0.5283178091049194,
0.016241982579231262,
-0.14684173464775085,
-0.2929823696613312,
0.5241362452507019,
-0.5017154812812805,
0.539793848991394,
0.3663892447948456,
-0.008354303427040577,
0.12149691581726074,
-0.4374582767486572,
0.1707013100385666,
0.08830729871988297,
-0.4899890720844269,
-0.3845769464969635,
0.6417946815490723,
0.178413987159729,
-0.6667823195457458,
0.07511044293642044,
-0.3850163519382477,
-0.49593716859817505,
0.5017165541648865,
0.4168795943260193,
1.1109592914581299,
-0.4481829106807709,
0.5941336154937744,
0.3837680220603943,
0.2383250743150711,
-0.44425514340400696,
0.48967134952545166,
-0.36233457922935486,
-0.5984619855880737,
-0.38418564200401306,
-0.469017893075943,
-0.5294226408004761,
-0.1881190687417984,
-0.20552979409694672,
0.05889815464615822,
-0.48668384552001953,
0.045143771916627884,
-0.36095327138900757,
-0.06675848364830017,
-0.5639424920082092,
0.46718621253967285,
-0.1503886580467224,
0.7445487976074219,
-0.8504688143730164,
0.44506508111953735,
0.813938319683075,
-0.788875937461853,
-1.131801962852478,
0.11181461066007614,
-0.0028639063239097595,
-0.8218200206756592,
0.6874009966850281,
0.1146361455321312,
-0.5666576027870178,
0.200408935546875,
-0.4661009907722473,
-0.7947388291358948,
0.9856832027435303,
0.3647627830505371,
-0.25753408670425415,
0.20424945652484894,
-0.0061706132255494595,
0.8173332214355469,
-0.45788657665252686,
0.22432397305965424,
0.7424359917640686,
0.5217363834381104,
0.2876037359237671,
-0.5899119973182678,
0.29420384764671326,
-0.06793128699064255,
-0.07754947245121002,
0.2316465526819229,
-0.9047696590423584,
0.5976704955101013,
-0.2784155607223511,
-0.26564496755599976,
-0.21245263516902924,
0.4294455349445343,
0.20497800409793854,
0.194459468126297,
0.5229658484458923,
0.4491347372531891,
0.5403023958206177,
-0.00039052258944138885,
1.1952017545700073,
-0.27134114503860474,
0.20688873529434204,
1.1453896760940552,
-0.03945072367787361,
0.7706822156906128,
0.20572640001773834,
0.058342453092336655,
0.8992482423782349,
0.5147328972816467,
0.4334956109523773,
0.3856663405895233,
-0.1623629331588745,
-0.23185418546199799,
-0.46876147389411926,
0.12159132957458496,
0.1557883620262146,
0.5733689069747925,
0.2612011134624481,
-0.003809582442045212,
-0.3359294533729553,
0.2273363173007965,
-0.0907793864607811,
0.16283661127090454,
-0.19983437657356262,
0.8432118892669678,
-0.07019726932048798,
-0.9644584655761719,
0.548914909362793,
-0.43622922897338867,
-0.16479015350341797,
-0.5359417200088501,
-0.24534110724925995,
-0.41044938564300537,
0.0921395868062973,
-0.1091669425368309,
-0.7404446005821228,
-0.02513791061937809,
-0.37894150614738464,
0.17287178337574005,
-0.2943032681941986,
0.5108236074447632,
-0.32592883706092834,
0.06805071979761124,
0.23455844819545746,
0.5071485638618469,
0.18065406382083893,
0.036280564963817596,
-0.5933897495269775,
0.055367812514305115,
-0.17428971827030182,
-0.4104744791984558,
-0.05771636962890625,
0.5372433066368103,
-0.27080726623535156,
0.9818596243858337,
0.19377432763576508,
-0.0932082012295723,
-0.29744017124176025,
0.41492724418640137,
0.7361119389533997,
-0.7040553092956543,
-0.6861081719398499,
-0.7134096026420593,
0.5737289786338806,
0.052865322679281235,
-0.18710868060588837,
0.46543946862220764,
0.36016345024108887,
0.5039577484130859,
0.014114915393292904,
0.7262290716171265,
-0.11563509702682495,
0.41518479585647583,
-0.45177140831947327,
0.24300631880760193,
-0.5806070566177368,
0.1435384750366211,
0.1194443628191948,
-0.7410914301872253,
-0.18721899390220642,
0.612151563167572,
-0.3111571967601776,
0.2794491946697235,
0.8955855965614319,
0.72003173828125,
0.2334301620721817,
-0.14980721473693848,
0.19064027070999146,
0.2227306216955185,
0.4851156771183014,
0.2916174829006195,
0.8842878937721252,
-0.21037964522838593,
0.561927080154419,
-0.1455720067024231,
0.06727752834558487,
-0.2494346797466278,
-0.5662807822227478,
-0.8895248770713806,
-0.6407857537269592,
-0.2637636363506317,
-0.23083889484405518,
0.1365565061569214,
1.0595221519470215,
0.6040971279144287,
-0.6007958650588989,
-0.22158952057361603,
-0.35405007004737854,
0.2889721095561981,
-0.5109995603561401,
-0.21987460553646088,
0.16370171308517456,
-0.8591238856315613,
-0.5511194467544556,
0.8109452724456787,
0.27865418791770935,
0.2857453227043152,
-0.3512703776359558,
-0.17093253135681152,
-0.08575842529535294,
0.0034349316265434027,
0.3941843509674072,
0.8422664403915405,
-0.7141380310058594,
-0.5577621459960938,
-0.2701149582862854,
-0.12453625351190567,
0.2391432523727417,
0.9234691858291626,
-0.9764419198036194,
0.7958806753158569,
0.3183368146419525,
0.3775758147239685,
0.738727867603302,
0.2388104945421219,
0.7986689209938049,
-1.021227478981018,
0.12407652288675308,
0.39461731910705566,
-0.006162931211292744,
0.34081926941871643,
-0.2382475733757019,
0.9288356900215149,
0.18329736590385437,
-0.6435763239860535,
-0.4897492825984955,
0.22739002108573914,
-0.7826111912727356,
-0.16781149804592133,
1.261985421180725,
0.02005906030535698,
-0.42159605026245117,
-0.055457763373851776,
-0.32020753622055054,
0.14828500151634216,
-0.7387257814407349,
0.502516508102417,
0.36749139428138733,
-0.6665700674057007,
-0.22252893447875977,
-0.311478853225708,
0.8204084038734436,
0.09677724540233612,
-0.8553739190101624,
0.21301478147506714,
0.7941709160804749,
0.11788938194513321,
0.14983411133289337,
1.1726155281066895,
0.21152736246585846,
0.39958199858665466,
0.13401107490062714,
0.316398948431015,
-0.142710879445076,
-0.7156833410263062,
-0.6047682166099548,
0.11386288702487946,
0.2802945077419281,
-0.18440863490104675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14582v1
|
Large Language Models for Multi-Choice Question Classification of Medical Subjects
| 2024-03-21T17:36:08 | 2024-03-21T17:36:08 |
Víctor Ponce-López
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The aim of this paper is to evaluate whether large language models trained on
multi-choice question data can be used to discriminate between medical
subjects. This is an important and challenging task for automatic question
answering. To achieve this goal, we train deep neural networks for multi-class
classification of questions into the inferred medical subjects. Using our
Multi-Question (MQ) Sequence-BERT method, we outperform the state-of-the-art
results on the MedMCQA dataset with an accuracy of 0.68 and 0.60 on their
development and test sets, respectively. In this sense, we show the capability
of AI and LLMs in particular for multi-classification tasks in the Healthcare
domain.
|
[
-0.4148973226547241,
-0.879589855670929,
0.8098873496055603,
-0.136498361825943,
0.05264719948172569,
0.12145234644412994,
-0.16122277081012726,
-0.6056029796600342,
-0.07855335623025894,
0.5479763746261597,
-0.565528929233551,
-0.24877910315990448,
-0.5806939601898193,
0.21869491040706635,
-0.2411038875579834,
0.6558448076248169,
0.023694787174463272,
0.8183767199516296,
-0.368105947971344,
-0.2853127717971802,
-0.33112311363220215,
-1.048234224319458,
-0.9172769784927368,
-0.19584259390830994,
0.9693139791488647,
0.4521024823188782,
0.5382902026176453,
0.004899894818663597,
0.45911309123039246,
0.3017001450061798,
-0.032274648547172546,
0.49277809262275696,
0.2775658965110779,
0.41544267535209656,
0.15588849782943726,
-0.6037271022796631,
0.028952186927199364,
-0.06710294634103775,
0.6958211660385132,
0.7204229831695557,
0.007604259066283703,
0.16513130068778992,
-0.09516569972038269,
0.4315524399280548,
-0.24217942357063293,
-0.2011919468641281,
-0.38074907660484314,
0.08671731501817703,
0.08665595203638077,
-0.05983470007777214,
-0.40892013907432556,
-0.5688616633415222,
0.3422325551509857,
-0.008134187199175358,
0.14126038551330566,
0.07368440181016922,
0.6938185095787048,
0.240431010723114,
-0.7496609687805176,
-0.3031603693962097,
-0.42620599269866943,
0.6576135158538818,
-0.7689228653907776,
0.4964830279350281,
0.42279380559921265,
0.4725024700164795,
0.12217772006988525,
-0.5983842015266418,
-0.5139586925506592,
-0.3371778130531311,
0.0147171625867486,
0.012138772755861282,
0.3963412940502167,
0.09916564077138901,
0.12415442615747452,
0.29587486386299133,
-0.8052211999893188,
0.4898751676082611,
-0.5429293513298035,
-0.09370999038219452,
0.7669032216072083,
0.2594086527824402,
0.29163429141044617,
-0.20409315824508667,
-0.11991036683320999,
-0.019042184576392174,
-0.560269832611084,
0.15843705832958221,
-0.07649414241313934,
0.2779158353805542,
0.2880053222179413,
0.6345134973526001,
-0.12865512073040009,
0.7382422685623169,
-0.07849796116352081,
-0.18957994878292084,
0.4585414528846741,
0.0008230420644395053,
-0.36354222893714905,
-0.02191893756389618,
0.6559925675392151,
0.17207206785678864,
0.17759713530540466,
0.06451915204524994,
0.2506115734577179,
-0.22417671978473663,
0.3812386393547058,
-0.7097501158714294,
0.07705118507146835,
0.6588269472122192,
-0.6253120303153992,
-0.09489071369171143,
-0.2612764537334442,
-0.48619604110717773,
-0.5301028490066528,
-0.4324933588504791,
0.29492661356925964,
-0.25975218415260315,
0.03843870013952255,
0.3493542969226837,
0.08234554529190063,
0.6008137464523315,
0.6334468722343445,
-0.5897464156150818,
0.176876962184906,
0.5089762210845947,
0.4132820665836334,
-0.16939646005630493,
-0.36496126651763916,
-0.39103662967681885,
-0.22003455460071564,
-0.2578423023223877,
0.7689993977546692,
-0.4325931668281555,
-0.15301267802715302,
0.030105359852313995,
0.21763016283512115,
-0.26660364866256714,
-0.6854747533798218,
0.40858593583106995,
-0.7163211703300476,
0.4545099139213562,
-0.1933548003435135,
-0.8833139538764954,
-0.36171576380729675,
0.6809318661689758,
-0.5922532081604004,
0.5749158263206482,
0.10583779215812683,
-0.45824310183525085,
0.41095221042633057,
-0.4348302185535431,
-0.48525720834732056,
0.0016437774756923318,
-0.3555346131324768,
-0.691382646560669,
-0.12320968508720398,
0.4930811822414398,
0.8053271174430847,
-0.4049527049064636,
0.47489264607429504,
-0.5371503233909607,
-0.023935798555612564,
0.7205755710601807,
-0.6421679258346558,
0.969081699848175,
0.16307391226291656,
0.07401952147483826,
0.11695315688848495,
-0.5889672040939331,
0.3201080560684204,
-0.010313098318874836,
-0.7187848091125488,
-0.13653862476348877,
-0.030031615868210793,
-0.07617869973182678,
0.6339741945266724,
-0.06793824583292007,
-0.5874097347259521,
0.41319674253463745,
-0.3716965317726135,
0.35776108503341675,
0.4896155297756195,
0.030058538541197777,
0.042069513350725174,
-0.5698419213294983,
0.5157786011695862,
0.01746259815990925,
0.3446609675884247,
0.2358577847480774,
-0.9102621078491211,
-0.7454384565353394,
-0.18795275688171387,
0.44293078780174255,
0.6712675094604492,
-0.6738693714141846,
0.3803051710128784,
0.18812783062458038,
-0.29021140933036804,
-0.9801272749900818,
-0.057502537965774536,
0.19971895217895508,
0.5441312193870544,
0.5229525566101074,
-0.09566646814346313,
-0.31959792971611023,
-0.8823784589767456,
0.0877297967672348,
-0.20076626539230347,
0.086456298828125,
0.726981520652771,
0.5143381357192993,
-0.2553665339946747,
0.4518486261367798,
-0.6427264213562012,
0.03908092901110649,
-0.10512270033359528,
0.10971446335315704,
0.16441641747951508,
0.48484277725219727,
0.6023139953613281,
-1.0804475545883179,
-0.3919074833393097,
-0.3805742859840393,
-0.6439591646194458,
0.19307604432106018,
0.0972559005022049,
-0.06204412505030632,
0.03138241916894913,
0.46990811824798584,
-0.46363717317581177,
0.09918896108865738,
0.36420518159866333,
-0.20470741391181946,
0.5230566263198853,
-0.29537492990493774,
0.391226202249527,
-1.242916464805603,
-0.037506937980651855,
-0.1727590709924698,
-0.125172957777977,
-0.7990889549255371,
-0.10057783126831055,
0.27508747577667236,
-0.10927028208971024,
-0.7593121528625488,
0.674403965473175,
-0.03287317976355553,
0.09446687251329422,
-0.13136756420135498,
-0.4582362771034241,
0.12112302333116531,
0.3573014736175537,
0.05553444102406502,
0.5787928104400635,
0.6619178056716919,
-0.8437823057174683,
0.5848219990730286,
0.5924559831619263,
-0.4894922971725464,
0.5811412334442139,
-0.4762234389781952,
0.27027449011802673,
-0.4035116136074066,
0.1319774091243744,
-1.2224979400634766,
-0.3248152732849121,
0.15456734597682953,
-0.6420402526855469,
0.26646462082862854,
-0.08912420272827148,
-0.6271976828575134,
-0.7872079014778137,
0.050814125686883926,
0.4420628547668457,
0.3277243375778198,
-0.5387458801269531,
0.2985199987888336,
0.16705632209777832,
-0.39140069484710693,
-0.7073022127151489,
-0.9144054055213928,
-0.22683550417423248,
-0.15560060739517212,
-0.45191705226898193,
0.02395991049706936,
-0.397550493478775,
-0.03696712478995323,
-0.2674490511417389,
0.21008466184139252,
-0.6667706370353699,
0.2465549260377884,
0.11284708231687546,
0.3295857012271881,
-0.263986200094223,
0.6962836980819702,
0.26887163519859314,
0.2239408791065216,
0.15828557312488556,
-0.19011233747005463,
0.6231512427330017,
0.13209684193134308,
-0.7768881916999817,
-0.3835339844226837,
0.726440966129303,
0.6747038960456848,
-0.5036259293556213,
0.8036555051803589,
0.2076874077320099,
-0.3838344216346741,
0.042804524302482605,
-0.7624823451042175,
-0.07288569211959839,
-0.3792203962802887,
0.4533991515636444,
-0.18119479715824127,
-1.1824448108673096,
0.3417627513408661,
0.19581589102745056,
0.1498575210571289,
0.5074380040168762,
0.753965437412262,
-0.48758664727211,
1.315449595451355,
0.0886755883693695,
-0.1615448296070099,
-0.039360228925943375,
-0.12446767091751099,
-0.2276284098625183,
-0.6914879679679871,
-0.2971666157245636,
-0.6504970788955688,
-0.39119669795036316,
-0.472113698720932,
-0.23873360455036163,
0.48677417635917664,
-0.32017382979393005,
-0.4464510679244995,
-0.30693668127059937,
-0.513163149356842,
0.12932927906513214,
0.7303208708763123,
0.5708354711532593,
0.10435477644205093,
-0.26943638920783997,
-0.12990280985832214,
0.2017039656639099,
-0.4742542505264282,
-0.24161295592784882,
1.2563047409057617,
0.42681950330734253,
0.7206865549087524,
-0.05601418390870094,
0.7477076649665833,
0.00651825126260519,
0.4062989056110382,
-0.9809390902519226,
0.32112178206443787,
-0.38012436032295227,
-1.1582107543945312,
-0.5737407207489014,
-0.3103250563144684,
-1.0939736366271973,
0.4862467646598816,
-0.24209950864315033,
-0.28243952989578247,
0.1895848661661148,
-0.19291210174560547,
-0.920213520526886,
0.4349687397480011,
-0.599125325679779,
0.7401584386825562,
-0.7129522562026978,
0.2781522870063782,
0.027587182819843292,
-0.8930051922798157,
0.20766714215278625,
-0.10856403410434723,
-0.09137952327728271,
-0.19361162185668945,
0.10085052251815796,
0.7833642363548279,
0.005348504520952702,
0.7053513526916504,
-0.04739629477262497,
-0.0768752470612526,
0.19218482077121735,
-0.42946913838386536,
-0.2962418794631958,
0.22548028826713562,
-0.26708927750587463,
-0.08961965888738632,
0.041257344186306,
-0.3369416296482086,
-0.44105595350265503,
0.35228434205055237,
-0.9090767502784729,
-0.5732431411743164,
-0.4664377272129059,
-0.5456051230430603,
-0.5829840898513794,
0.21328704059123993,
0.11409815400838852,
0.514936625957489,
-0.06632398813962936,
0.2220560908317566,
0.8253196477890015,
-0.5865463614463806,
0.3012615144252777,
0.5677708983421326,
-0.2640954554080963,
-0.45873069763183594,
0.46827834844589233,
0.2604876160621643,
0.2562786936759949,
0.43358686566352844,
0.36273863911628723,
-0.536047637462616,
-0.7427727580070496,
-0.508529782295227,
0.31235525012016296,
-0.7121050357818604,
-0.2953912913799286,
-0.7362130880355835,
-0.7096487879753113,
-0.37067684531211853,
0.05324235185980797,
-0.022973764687776566,
-0.09465894848108292,
-0.46368086338043213,
-0.00017210641817655414,
0.15391838550567627,
0.6820935010910034,
0.37073269486427307,
0.11320323497056961,
-1.092777132987976,
0.5235099792480469,
0.7615612745285034,
0.34376126527786255,
-0.1416928470134735,
-0.5479524731636047,
0.06419432908296585,
0.12628118693828583,
-0.2709041237831116,
-0.8576920628547668,
0.23865582048892975,
0.08866553008556366,
0.6506684422492981,
0.28370627760887146,
0.03318195417523384,
0.4459508955478668,
-0.6512384414672852,
0.6988688111305237,
0.2145295888185501,
-0.40775421261787415,
0.5254215598106384,
0.21162419021129608,
0.21170581877231598,
0.8006280660629272,
0.7414718270301819,
-0.6360164284706116,
-0.22883380949497223,
-0.562030553817749,
-0.4256385564804077,
0.49715912342071533,
-0.31556394696235657,
0.07233355194330215,
-0.02313658967614174,
0.5316741466522217,
0.27282410860061646,
0.35258564352989197,
-0.5172151327133179,
-0.5280182957649231,
0.3236842751502991,
-0.29906579852104187,
-0.27875441312789917,
-0.29762837290763855,
-0.04931541159749031,
-0.5815829038619995,
0.3661796450614929,
-0.19014717638492584,
0.4605481028556824,
0.32906126976013184,
-0.03639895096421242,
0.17179885506629944,
0.6149976849555969,
0.5547609329223633,
0.566770613193512,
-0.07789214700460434,
0.09240144491195679,
0.4045168459415436,
-0.38997000455856323,
0.5570364594459534,
0.3274628221988678,
0.06461020559072495,
-0.062347009778022766,
0.1322792023420334,
0.44872820377349854,
-0.22313179075717926,
-0.6777696013450623,
0.5496437549591064,
-0.2943935990333557,
-0.6606126427650452,
-0.2790069878101349,
-0.02031870000064373,
0.09133557230234146,
0.38509321212768555,
0.1311897486448288,
0.006773306522518396,
0.31066104769706726,
-0.5474385023117065,
0.504501223564148,
0.5207996964454651,
-0.34257087111473083,
0.2651517987251282,
0.4112791121006012,
-0.016081692650914192,
-0.09478016197681427,
1.0016448497772217,
0.1646251380443573,
-0.6490740776062012,
0.8343329429626465,
0.29148709774017334,
0.6642850041389465,
-0.654461145401001,
0.16798986494541168,
0.24042555689811707,
-0.011336431838572025,
-0.09205543994903564,
0.8245089650154114,
0.4347161650657654,
-0.8390989899635315,
-0.5944279432296753,
-0.3709389567375183,
-0.5897851586341858,
0.5179309248924255,
-0.6779448986053467,
0.06961362808942795,
-0.4045288860797882,
-0.11001145839691162,
0.38858821988105774,
-0.004972386173903942,
-0.6679509282112122,
0.7887535095214844,
0.5412254929542542,
0.7026820778846741,
-0.6399743556976318,
0.9840510487556458,
0.8794212341308594,
-0.39651599526405334,
-0.7506868243217468,
-0.051353052258491516,
-0.2524913549423218,
-0.997599720954895,
0.7500993013381958,
0.38417670130729675,
0.33671650290489197,
-0.30388009548187256,
-0.7460441589355469,
-0.8007737398147583,
0.6497321724891663,
0.14430929720401764,
-0.38947758078575134,
-0.23217521607875824,
0.2943730354309082,
0.40715742111206055,
-0.2616235315799713,
0.2683956027030945,
0.3472553789615631,
0.3726861774921417,
0.02107471413910389,
-1.177362322807312,
-0.29526469111442566,
-0.07717106491327286,
-0.43366336822509766,
0.1377241313457489,
-0.6342143416404724,
1.0881807804107666,
-0.30016469955444336,
0.3499446511268616,
0.1723541021347046,
0.3972112238407135,
0.3160642683506012,
0.251059353351593,
0.6632485389709473,
0.42776554822921753,
1.0947706699371338,
-0.176712304353714,
0.9482204914093018,
0.008043698966503143,
0.30742835998535156,
0.9764958024024963,
-0.41940996050834656,
0.853046178817749,
0.258872926235199,
-0.3772401809692383,
0.30444854497909546,
0.8592201471328735,
-0.13892708718776703,
0.37698832154273987,
0.5980383157730103,
-0.24240529537200928,
-0.4034945070743561,
0.15775004029273987,
-0.5742825269699097,
0.5562018156051636,
0.47470206022262573,
-0.550032913684845,
0.13177278637886047,
0.5070446729660034,
-0.09931692481040955,
-0.4058224558830261,
-0.4047551155090332,
0.9495672583580017,
0.0839422419667244,
-0.7095658779144287,
0.5395911931991577,
-0.11150305718183517,
0.5653442740440369,
-0.451387494802475,
0.023893525823950768,
0.10364244878292084,
0.20527055859565735,
-0.07274138182401657,
-0.9933230876922607,
0.08174022287130356,
-0.3224141299724579,
-0.15001016855239868,
0.017421938478946686,
0.727445125579834,
-0.5153467059135437,
-0.6982289552688599,
-0.019135797396302223,
0.7755858898162842,
0.08173814415931702,
-0.06112252548336983,
-1.0345267057418823,
-0.6161853671073914,
-0.14328201115131378,
-0.10987502336502075,
0.2422446310520172,
0.2188950479030609,
0.14454618096351624,
0.86079341173172,
0.5217108130455017,
0.05259658396244049,
0.20976197719573975,
0.3245810568332672,
0.7629019021987915,
-0.6777219772338867,
-0.5551014542579651,
-0.9137242436408997,
0.31369560956954956,
-0.03814895823597908,
-0.37334856390953064,
0.44543159008026123,
0.5841058492660522,
0.6753549575805664,
-0.1908552348613739,
0.9684966802597046,
0.19553110003471375,
0.9672583341598511,
-0.5633994340896606,
0.7417134046554565,
-0.8044687509536743,
-0.2115938365459442,
-0.043557461351156235,
-0.3120291233062744,
-0.6848185062408447,
0.5585452914237976,
-0.22007586061954498,
0.18905746936798096,
0.7264698147773743,
0.4253772795200348,
0.16734769940376282,
0.04123476520180702,
0.369829922914505,
-0.14954036474227905,
0.3095925748348236,
0.8869699239730835,
1.224241018295288,
-0.2628703713417053,
0.25416338443756104,
-0.2771731913089752,
0.00811335351318121,
-0.17722046375274658,
-0.2714654803276062,
-1.1069003343582153,
-0.6149085760116577,
-0.38140869140625,
-0.40618231892585754,
-0.06097307801246643,
1.174607515335083,
0.8371572494506836,
-1.1446436643600464,
-0.0397283211350441,
0.45360854268074036,
0.09194386005401611,
-0.23560626804828644,
-0.0870274230837822,
0.6577460169792175,
-0.382781445980072,
-0.6044504642486572,
0.19282807409763336,
-0.08732438832521439,
0.3210375905036926,
-0.40237364172935486,
0.05030195042490959,
-0.5606905817985535,
-0.1387345790863037,
0.6126141548156738,
0.061337534338235855,
-0.690322995185852,
-0.2566991150379181,
0.26383087038993835,
-0.3343387246131897,
0.4249497950077057,
0.818115234375,
-0.5386655926704407,
0.25751444697380066,
0.3170579671859741,
1.118398666381836,
0.15412189066410065,
-0.07401328533887863,
0.15304745733737946,
-0.6196643710136414,
-0.09788589924573898,
0.7108169198036194,
0.5909253358840942,
0.18457238376140594,
-0.46354424953460693,
0.10368728637695312,
-0.21638894081115723,
-0.8589803576469421,
-0.5036939382553101,
0.16100244224071503,
-0.7565916776657104,
-0.6848328113555908,
1.150468111038208,
0.037198539823293686,
0.07045544683933258,
-0.5606755614280701,
-0.6412268877029419,
0.24620091915130615,
-0.06832469254732132,
0.5937530994415283,
0.686308741569519,
-0.44817110896110535,
-0.4182888865470886,
-0.7809484004974365,
0.4769209921360016,
0.5329970717430115,
-1.2445875406265259,
-0.3194872736930847,
0.3853646516799927,
0.255657821893692,
0.06548981368541718,
0.612973153591156,
-0.057774461805820465,
0.2710797190666199,
-0.8036074638366699,
0.04178464785218239,
0.2032935619354248,
-0.34220948815345764,
-0.4382965862751007,
0.3876299560070038,
0.32668060064315796,
-0.5492468476295471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15492v1
|
Visual Analytics for Fine-grained Text Classification Models and Datasets
| 2024-03-21T17:26:28 | 2024-03-21T17:26:28 |
Munkhtulga Battogtokh, Yiwen Xing, Cosmin Davidescu, Alfie Abdul-Rahman, Michael Luck, Rita Borgo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In natural language processing (NLP), text classification tasks are
increasingly fine-grained, as datasets are fragmented into a larger number of
classes that are more difficult to differentiate from one another. As a
consequence, the semantic structures of datasets have become more complex, and
model decisions more difficult to explain. Existing tools, suited for
coarse-grained classification, falter under these additional challenges. In
response to this gap, we worked closely with NLP domain experts in an iterative
design-and-evaluation process to characterize and tackle the growing
requirements in their workflow of developing fine-grained text classification
models. The result of this collaboration is the development of SemLa, a novel
visual analytics system tailored for 1) dissecting complex semantic structures
in a dataset when it is spatialized in model embedding space, and 2)
visualizing fine-grained nuances in the meaning of text samples to faithfully
explain model reasoning. This paper details the iterative design study and the
resulting innovations featured in SemLa. The final design allows contrastive
analysis at different levels by unearthing lexical and conceptual patterns
including biases and artifacts in data. Expert feedback on our final design and
case studies confirm that SemLa is a useful tool for supporting model
validation and debugging as well as data annotation.
|
[
-0.42988288402557373,
-1.1158509254455566,
0.6553491353988647,
0.2024509459733963,
-0.335089772939682,
-0.19812951982021332,
-0.0292945709079504,
-0.3920215368270874,
0.1125461608171463,
0.5069528222084045,
-0.2741229236125946,
-1.007102131843567,
-0.6037777066230774,
-0.05213853716850281,
-0.5422321557998657,
0.896017849445343,
-0.24611611664295197,
0.009170003235340118,
-0.4378717243671417,
-0.29983869194984436,
-0.8777971863746643,
-0.3015146553516388,
-0.49121931195259094,
-0.22855408489704132,
0.35412415862083435,
0.40890154242515564,
0.6798942685127258,
0.4835210144519806,
0.7501693367958069,
0.3460545539855957,
-0.18987995386123657,
0.11920840293169022,
-0.40086403489112854,
0.08920730650424957,
-0.30749818682670593,
-0.34732115268707275,
-0.3475334644317627,
-0.17034873366355896,
0.18004119396209717,
0.8428553342819214,
-0.055485714226961136,
0.40593376755714417,
0.3061988055706024,
0.5346599221229553,
-0.5840982794761658,
0.5582665801048279,
-0.2905195951461792,
0.18095147609710693,
-0.5786373615264893,
-0.4927242696285248,
-0.42487388849258423,
-0.01910700649023056,
0.36802157759666443,
-0.5389344692230225,
0.23361870646476746,
0.04512501135468483,
0.8879554867744446,
0.460668683052063,
-0.2399653196334839,
-0.4111265242099762,
-0.6018338203430176,
0.712661623954773,
-0.6614369750022888,
0.08224537968635559,
0.08693728595972061,
0.5726147294044495,
0.030080724507570267,
-0.8248489499092102,
-0.3091048002243042,
0.11867982894182205,
-0.21984270215034485,
-0.08738386631011963,
-0.27095848321914673,
-0.2187330275774002,
-0.004479583818465471,
0.2806044816970825,
-0.6398518085479736,
0.3756271004676819,
-0.31923457980155945,
0.1403670758008957,
0.5875339508056641,
0.5153157711029053,
0.5466166734695435,
-0.1925080269575119,
-0.38117271661758423,
-0.11320120841264725,
-0.2706013023853302,
-0.11740455776453018,
-0.17857705056667328,
0.511124312877655,
-0.32166552543640137,
0.49983179569244385,
-0.3675921857357025,
0.713850200176239,
-0.4462052285671234,
0.24937748908996582,
0.34220752120018005,
-0.15024633705615997,
-0.551010251045227,
0.04659852385520935,
0.7221540808677673,
0.5885350108146667,
0.276635080575943,
0.07069146633148193,
-0.260954886674881,
0.3826548457145691,
0.2834998071193695,
-1.0350269079208374,
-0.5305664539337158,
0.2049313187599182,
-0.6645551323890686,
-0.565248429775238,
-0.29144033789634705,
-1.1054667234420776,
-0.7038373947143555,
-0.59123694896698,
0.5782644748687744,
-0.19937008619308472,
-0.0228253323584795,
0.19806142151355743,
-0.281203955411911,
0.07305978983640671,
0.6810581088066101,
-0.9004126191139221,
0.3059810400009155,
0.6577978134155273,
0.8527469038963318,
-0.2948443293571472,
-0.18938156962394714,
-0.2906227111816406,
-0.078614242374897,
-0.35177499055862427,
1.133763074874878,
-0.9680913090705872,
-0.10743360966444016,
0.06683603674173355,
-0.1465548425912857,
0.19472065567970276,
-0.4428900480270386,
0.5061731934547424,
-0.3573139011859894,
-0.09329329431056976,
-0.19384977221488953,
-0.5943440198898315,
-0.32788363099098206,
0.4883340001106262,
-0.5802594423294067,
0.8394309878349304,
-0.05612219125032425,
-0.861266016960144,
0.6590850949287415,
-0.5123251080513,
-0.033810216933488846,
0.1658143550157547,
-0.5502055287361145,
-0.5161967277526855,
0.23283714056015015,
0.40209347009658813,
0.8876543641090393,
-0.40812647342681885,
0.3737921416759491,
-0.5772221684455872,
-0.24570995569229126,
-0.09866932779550552,
-0.46131423115730286,
0.5004547834396362,
0.24986110627651215,
-0.31887122988700867,
0.3133339285850525,
-0.978836715221405,
-0.010178647004067898,
0.2871829867362976,
0.06158891320228577,
-0.7947126030921936,
0.17269940674304962,
0.40538859367370605,
-0.04172568395733833,
0.035228580236434937,
-0.11335519701242447,
0.21657855808734894,
-0.24802562594413757,
0.17813831567764282,
0.6622980237007141,
-0.07567450404167175,
0.6126386523246765,
0.1326436698436737,
0.292093962430954,
0.14479570090770721,
0.07280799001455307,
-0.3608781397342682,
-0.5613871216773987,
-0.9481909275054932,
-0.022033093497157097,
0.2338600754737854,
0.3146093487739563,
-0.5229989886283875,
0.10917138308286667,
-0.19607241451740265,
-0.5731427073478699,
-0.272238552570343,
0.0007530735456384718,
0.08953959494829178,
0.36555391550064087,
0.4971923828125,
-0.26448094844818115,
-0.42558491230010986,
-0.892242431640625,
-0.2618599534034729,
0.23436802625656128,
-0.03137592226266861,
0.09670957177877426,
0.7453665733337402,
-0.5991930365562439,
0.9081892967224121,
-0.6833927035331726,
-0.5435949563980103,
-0.10414190590381622,
0.5206514000892639,
0.02819797769188881,
0.4960513114929199,
0.7413206100463867,
-0.7981069684028625,
-0.4054248631000519,
0.4213840961456299,
-0.886885941028595,
-0.469536155462265,
-0.35417112708091736,
-0.06822367012500763,
-0.1381145417690277,
0.5590420961380005,
-0.13625827431678772,
0.8730472922325134,
0.3055216073989868,
-0.7702189683914185,
0.21277888119220734,
-0.01262742280960083,
0.03352084383368492,
-0.8921335935592651,
0.11820530891418457,
0.08076055347919464,
-0.0641247034072876,
-0.7097869515419006,
0.14895480871200562,
-0.17864353954792023,
-0.11447770893573761,
0.07717134058475494,
0.7156568169593811,
-0.27958181500434875,
-0.17976760864257812,
-0.30269181728363037,
0.28856322169303894,
0.14312198758125305,
0.4694657027721405,
0.084725022315979,
0.45233824849128723,
0.38661226630210876,
-0.5773592591285706,
0.09089918434619904,
0.3215089738368988,
-0.3122526705265045,
0.5526018738746643,
-0.6375617980957031,
-0.21982920169830322,
-0.22418421506881714,
-0.2231622189283371,
-0.8604081273078918,
-0.20038682222366333,
-0.041695304214954376,
-0.19720661640167236,
0.13169163465499878,
0.07605735957622528,
-0.41727229952812195,
0.034461356699466705,
-0.23458445072174072,
0.2856806814670563,
0.06746706366539001,
-0.7201313376426697,
0.7698906660079956,
0.6152701377868652,
-0.26787999272346497,
-0.16018135845661163,
-0.5902070999145508,
0.19765684008598328,
-0.21630388498306274,
-0.6984582543373108,
0.2607768774032593,
0.179673433303833,
-0.657929003238678,
0.016102219000458717,
-0.04952647164463997,
-0.4316718578338623,
0.34405240416526794,
0.38305988907814026,
0.2890273332595825,
-0.12681494653224945,
0.22673292458057404,
0.13855257630348206,
-0.2539631724357605,
-0.003800078760832548,
0.05464768782258034,
0.518993079662323,
-0.42199191451072693,
-0.32634276151657104,
-0.5665033459663391,
0.3342081904411316,
0.4008958637714386,
-0.21906204521656036,
0.4803157448768616,
0.8268249034881592,
-0.4719011187553406,
-0.5643121004104614,
-0.2606850266456604,
0.13315631449222565,
-0.44397327303886414,
0.23057347536087036,
-0.4424320161342621,
-0.6473289728164673,
0.47218844294548035,
-0.1059994027018547,
0.16731582581996918,
0.6386232972145081,
0.513863205909729,
-0.04169359803199768,
1.1220698356628418,
0.8907713294029236,
0.23790518939495087,
0.36884504556655884,
-0.3703010380268097,
0.03692543879151344,
-0.28194189071655273,
-0.4710187613964081,
-0.6988353133201599,
-0.3921491205692291,
-0.5770631432533264,
-0.5685482025146484,
0.1561535894870758,
0.13116872310638428,
-0.16702362895011902,
-0.09615011513233185,
-0.715868353843689,
0.5720882415771484,
0.3345036804676056,
-0.21446464955806732,
0.2723654508590698,
0.06038933992385864,
0.07427800446748734,
-0.19670440256595612,
-0.5092784762382507,
-0.8081310987472534,
0.6662278175354004,
0.47354620695114136,
0.9896702766418457,
-0.07541225850582123,
0.6236273050308228,
0.4009615480899811,
0.273093044757843,
-0.951903760433197,
0.4632696509361267,
-0.43147149682044983,
-0.19538399577140808,
-0.14749930799007416,
-0.19579559564590454,
-0.8548619151115417,
0.3686300814151764,
-0.37638938426971436,
-0.6772569417953491,
0.3757380545139313,
0.10037346184253693,
-0.24023781716823578,
0.01587892323732376,
-0.9136406779289246,
1.2128833532333374,
0.07833695411682129,
-0.3154623210430145,
-0.09669851511716843,
-0.411302387714386,
0.1894666850566864,
0.03972871974110603,
0.13459374010562897,
-0.04480739310383797,
0.2164592444896698,
0.6905062794685364,
-0.5627131462097168,
1.0546971559524536,
-0.23892703652381897,
-0.23756958544254303,
0.2518913745880127,
0.2260483354330063,
0.4726331830024719,
0.008861396461725235,
0.2827757000923157,
0.21634122729301453,
0.10133922100067139,
-0.31854164600372314,
-0.6141026616096497,
0.6933039426803589,
-0.36982953548431396,
-0.2558729946613312,
-0.3209248185157776,
-0.2135448306798935,
-0.18950270116329193,
0.29544591903686523,
-0.11282062530517578,
0.6734117865562439,
-0.26893413066864014,
0.32906574010849,
0.5131602883338928,
-0.3199585974216461,
0.30282098054885864,
0.29056617617607117,
-0.38560396432876587,
-0.009574180468916893,
0.8392720222473145,
0.03670145198702812,
-0.17901472747325897,
0.3863297998905182,
0.2471003383398056,
0.02052352949976921,
-0.9183710813522339,
-0.3625200092792511,
-0.30544042587280273,
-0.8412472605705261,
-0.2188781350851059,
-0.42989444732666016,
-0.10021084547042847,
-0.127190500497818,
-0.4501704275608063,
-0.22521767020225525,
-0.2800891697406769,
-0.6814372539520264,
0.03156139701604843,
0.14431506395339966,
0.9944229125976562,
0.4306195080280304,
0.32354891300201416,
-0.7970260977745056,
0.2793455719947815,
0.3623703122138977,
0.44358372688293457,
0.02511051669716835,
-0.18291530013084412,
-0.12510164082050323,
-0.3778591454029083,
-0.1979834884405136,
-0.6934288144111633,
0.6732197403907776,
-0.04717539995908737,
0.2468203455209732,
0.47614654898643494,
-0.2713565230369568,
0.8548623323440552,
-0.7053175568580627,
0.7670381665229797,
0.06598232686519623,
-0.8902190923690796,
0.7190000414848328,
-0.3300735652446747,
0.4197361171245575,
0.6262863278388977,
-0.06013549491763115,
-0.41072505712509155,
-0.2611958086490631,
-0.3414754569530487,
-0.867291271686554,
0.44396212697029114,
0.22448420524597168,
-0.005125516094267368,
0.1703808307647705,
0.14050112664699554,
0.41205522418022156,
-0.038744546473026276,
-0.4436104893684387,
-0.05450430139899254,
-0.16252097487449646,
-0.5356009602546692,
0.0353727824985981,
-0.30104202032089233,
-0.06782735884189606,
-0.061069801449775696,
0.3886541724205017,
-0.41958287358283997,
-0.14687548577785492,
0.1230568066239357,
-0.2475201040506363,
0.4498562216758728,
0.3265358805656433,
0.28094327449798584,
0.6285362243652344,
-0.011192607693374157,
0.3650217652320862,
0.19000424444675446,
-0.30027860403060913,
-0.3542814254760742,
0.06405579298734665,
-0.1459873765707016,
0.17021174728870392,
0.5745996236801147,
1.007175087928772,
0.2350389063358307,
-0.6887996792793274,
0.672447681427002,
-0.1469222754240036,
0.07051455974578857,
-0.1232469454407692,
-0.009205450303852558,
-0.05122446268796921,
0.5507556200027466,
0.001743856118991971,
0.24475230276584625,
0.7268288135528564,
-0.3000465929508209,
0.16516634821891785,
0.33055105805397034,
-0.36753350496292114,
-0.36269891262054443,
0.5852739214897156,
0.41903823614120483,
-0.10716813057661057,
0.2101474553346634,
-0.11771444976329803,
-0.19421929121017456,
0.6159963607788086,
0.33021974563598633,
0.9393548965454102,
0.15711316466331482,
0.5083664059638977,
0.13264457881450653,
0.16413849592208862,
0.03746190294623375,
0.21103982627391815,
-0.17237144708633423,
-0.5519762635231018,
-0.17197932302951813,
-0.9162020683288574,
-0.22451333701610565,
0.042953383177518845,
-0.6553834676742554,
0.44980940222740173,
-0.4256730377674103,
-0.04288942739367485,
0.426204115152359,
-0.08099843561649323,
-0.7319169044494629,
0.39389336109161377,
0.4722616970539093,
0.9381639957427979,
-0.9495159983634949,
0.458056777715683,
0.47779881954193115,
-0.305978924036026,
-0.4193183183670044,
-0.3194500803947449,
0.15058258175849915,
-0.7038626074790955,
0.8194825053215027,
0.5100902915000916,
-0.1202545315027237,
-0.4136057496070862,
-0.6318560838699341,
-0.5016422867774963,
1.0104992389678955,
-0.005328402854502201,
-0.5914493203163147,
-0.03380521386861801,
0.09319576621055603,
0.8322458267211914,
-0.3561978340148926,
0.012500588782131672,
0.815104067325592,
0.3541955351829529,
-0.13457311689853668,
-0.686386227607727,
-0.13549302518367767,
-0.46058717370033264,
0.25453194975852966,
0.2891700267791748,
-0.31199508905410767,
0.6480484008789062,
-0.11429242789745331,
-0.395029753446579,
0.0000779002220951952,
0.571111798286438,
0.01703633740544319,
0.7808636426925659,
0.2950614392757416,
0.7670703530311584,
0.7525786757469177,
-0.2250949740409851,
0.8685097694396973,
0.29356247186660767,
0.4980746805667877,
1.3575021028518677,
0.011354428716003895,
1.0024631023406982,
0.4901288151741028,
-0.032336506992578506,
0.5833319425582886,
0.5686027407646179,
-0.24691542983055115,
0.3931542932987213,
0.04150264337658882,
0.12168863415718079,
-0.23388198018074036,
-0.3475470542907715,
-0.16540561616420746,
0.685840904712677,
0.531528651714325,
-0.4403133988380432,
-0.5224729180335999,
0.03643647953867912,
-0.11325080692768097,
0.2973358631134033,
-0.546513557434082,
0.7495771050453186,
0.022135689854621887,
-0.061094604432582855,
0.2286110818386078,
-0.16624762117862701,
0.546118438243866,
-0.26652392745018005,
-0.2585722804069519,
-0.04597194120287895,
0.25409555435180664,
-0.3049319088459015,
-0.9903597831726074,
0.3898392915725708,
0.15719564259052277,
-0.07747036218643188,
-0.34146648645401,
0.8105673789978027,
-0.28704577684402466,
-0.38080278038978577,
0.24659262597560883,
0.3540540635585785,
0.03591696172952652,
-0.02157573588192463,
-0.6081780195236206,
0.26376909017562866,
-0.08473645150661469,
-0.25394368171691895,
0.06781870126724243,
0.6433995962142944,
-0.172526553273201,
0.685395359992981,
0.32975244522094727,
-0.1107734739780426,
-0.050556305795907974,
0.5307129621505737,
0.90458744764328,
-0.7677615880966187,
-0.554295003414154,
-0.9638790488243103,
0.5291417837142944,
-0.3168906569480896,
-0.3300473988056183,
0.792951762676239,
0.46689364314079285,
0.6664438247680664,
-0.08299780637025833,
0.468156635761261,
0.12081442773342133,
0.1608949601650238,
-0.7300155758857727,
0.6711381077766418,
-0.6574002504348755,
0.358977347612381,
-0.3348524868488312,
-0.7127299904823303,
-0.6575851440429688,
0.5319028496742249,
-0.18914824724197388,
-0.24934759736061096,
0.5688835978507996,
0.4627511501312256,
0.03133527189493179,
0.26775825023651123,
0.20344945788383484,
0.26849493384361267,
0.5782181620597839,
0.24910998344421387,
0.7841139435768127,
-0.3284144997596741,
0.3186652660369873,
-0.11900355666875839,
-0.2125939577817917,
-0.32226184010505676,
-0.6455660462379456,
-1.2278754711151123,
-0.652047336101532,
-0.26964104175567627,
0.07579298317432404,
-0.39254382252693176,
0.5890524387359619,
0.41040927171707153,
-0.9162572622299194,
0.041476182639598846,
-0.36584731936454773,
-0.07483495771884918,
0.1368352323770523,
-0.32824382185935974,
0.43129900097846985,
-0.6668171882629395,
-0.8889657258987427,
0.12982940673828125,
0.593227744102478,
0.2876720428466797,
-0.314574658870697,
0.34632521867752075,
0.16233478486537933,
0.01076523493975401,
0.8121755719184875,
-0.09117450565099716,
-0.5509922504425049,
-0.14312583208084106,
-0.3173327147960663,
-0.12997183203697205,
-0.0691438540816307,
0.6285718083381653,
-0.812199592590332,
0.7586590051651001,
0.8879944682121277,
0.9046688079833984,
0.4031459391117096,
-0.1789761632680893,
0.4687357246875763,
-0.5980428457260132,
0.011065035127103329,
0.19173549115657806,
0.43200260400772095,
0.22551800310611725,
-0.11236770451068878,
0.6384042501449585,
-0.05080163851380348,
-0.5067528486251831,
-1.0346647500991821,
-0.1166008710861206,
-1.0092048645019531,
-0.5963337421417236,
0.9955211281776428,
0.14264445006847382,
-0.3216903507709503,
-0.014987490139901638,
-0.5022467374801636,
-0.10496125370264053,
-0.2388399988412857,
0.8009721636772156,
0.7217928171157837,
-0.07261332869529724,
0.2641039490699768,
-0.7445921301841736,
0.5936660766601562,
0.31534212827682495,
-1.3823390007019043,
0.23564893007278442,
0.6545792818069458,
-0.06160944327712059,
0.473002552986145,
0.3796864151954651,
0.020938970148563385,
0.014807816594839096,
0.28556591272354126,
-0.1466824859380722,
0.13924114406108856,
-0.6873225569725037,
-0.5533215999603271,
0.3661905527114868,
-0.17294193804264069,
-0.13766823709011078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14565v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14565v1
|
A Chain-of-Thought Prompting Approach with LLMs for Evaluating Students' Formative Assessment Responses in Science
| 2024-03-21T17:09:08 | 2024-03-21T17:09:08 |
Clayton Cohn, Nicole Hutchins, Tuan Le, Gautam Biswas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores the use of large language models (LLMs) to score and
explain short-answer assessments in K-12 science. While existing methods can
score more structured math and computer science assessments, they often do not
provide explanations for the scores. Our study focuses on employing GPT-4 for
automated assessment in middle school Earth Science, combining few-shot and
active learning with chain-of-thought reasoning. Using a human-in-the-loop
approach, we successfully score and provide meaningful explanations for
formative assessment responses. A systematic analysis of our method's pros and
cons sheds light on the potential for human-in-the-loop techniques to enhance
automated grading for open-ended science assessments.
|
[
-0.4595416486263275,
-1.0896191596984863,
1.0674492120742798,
0.19817747175693512,
-0.40086284279823303,
0.4111460745334625,
-0.23510491847991943,
-0.1692647933959961,
0.07717488706111908,
-0.007917269133031368,
-0.6462715268135071,
-0.41146010160446167,
-0.25956815481185913,
0.30456972122192383,
-0.31276726722717285,
0.8839558362960815,
-0.40007904171943665,
-0.018497930839657784,
-0.2370755970478058,
0.14586669206619263,
-0.48546338081359863,
-0.2863781154155731,
-0.38013431429862976,
-0.6183295845985413,
0.7299051880836487,
0.5667773485183716,
0.5832021236419678,
0.4311940670013428,
0.7255887389183044,
0.26310792565345764,
0.011450638994574547,
0.02929992787539959,
-0.1367957592010498,
0.0060663591139018536,
-0.3115776777267456,
-0.09157879650592804,
-0.5760421752929688,
0.49051761627197266,
0.7592744827270508,
1.0553629398345947,
-0.2335774302482605,
0.6057198643684387,
-0.026599407196044922,
0.6467699408531189,
-0.5419021844863892,
0.019088927656412125,
-0.41738277673721313,
0.05992913618683815,
0.1280309557914734,
-0.2090972363948822,
-0.36863628029823303,
-0.500979483127594,
0.29219356179237366,
-0.6544888019561768,
-0.11524542421102524,
0.29002827405929565,
0.42304572463035583,
0.10994946211576462,
-0.1366456001996994,
-0.6057264804840088,
-0.5691074132919312,
0.8117997050285339,
-0.2252357006072998,
0.13199852406978607,
0.2874334156513214,
0.46240684390068054,
-0.20096032321453094,
-0.8070876598358154,
-0.9910243153572083,
-0.23404549062252045,
0.1903669536113739,
0.5750362873077393,
0.07183542102575302,
-0.09782180190086365,
0.29404932260513306,
0.3964148461818695,
-0.676507830619812,
0.11224284768104553,
-0.6116875410079956,
-0.029954278841614723,
0.6329405903816223,
0.3792821168899536,
0.06422487646341324,
-0.1901390254497528,
-0.3987257778644562,
-0.20703642070293427,
-0.8315848708152771,
0.26263320446014404,
0.4189888834953308,
0.4127071797847748,
0.020033588632941246,
0.7360587120056152,
0.14940807223320007,
0.7860621213912964,
0.003954065497964621,
0.1325601488351822,
-0.2039441615343094,
-0.376076340675354,
-0.43538641929626465,
-0.021867554634809494,
0.8632333278656006,
0.3681190013885498,
0.062208354473114014,
0.014926464296877384,
-0.12922365963459015,
0.47565215826034546,
0.09948443621397018,
-0.781815230846405,
-0.24386188387870789,
0.18730296194553375,
-0.21153347194194794,
-0.2824287712574005,
0.036663614213466644,
-0.981964111328125,
0.020203720778226852,
-0.42965269088745117,
0.5993775129318237,
0.05663470923900604,
0.30936193466186523,
0.28925564885139465,
-0.12394820153713226,
0.1958501935005188,
0.6337225437164307,
-0.6198135018348694,
0.7343181371688843,
0.37298718094825745,
0.8193280696868896,
-0.2884434163570404,
-0.2983379364013672,
-0.3444729447364807,
-0.14594390988349915,
-0.5800864100456238,
0.9418056011199951,
-0.6434410214424133,
-0.41810062527656555,
-0.4874363839626312,
0.08896925300359726,
0.17313317954540253,
-0.3944505751132965,
0.14204896986484528,
-0.7325182557106018,
0.7228202819824219,
-0.34591221809387207,
-0.41483089327812195,
-0.39622315764427185,
0.50129234790802,
-0.39477241039276123,
1.2104865312576294,
-0.009887266904115677,
-0.6360095143318176,
0.2354327291250229,
-0.9032853841781616,
-0.02861764468252659,
0.21231991052627563,
-0.19777266681194305,
-0.15716657042503357,
-0.1812017560005188,
0.2397562563419342,
0.48762643337249756,
-0.29843971133232117,
0.29619359970092773,
-0.27435046434402466,
-0.533553957939148,
0.23453745245933533,
-0.3678690791130066,
0.5139409303665161,
0.16353599727153778,
-0.33700335025787354,
0.20418640971183777,
-0.5619286298751831,
0.3853707015514374,
0.2208234816789627,
-0.3173554837703705,
-0.15033265948295593,
-0.015141261741518974,
-0.25206661224365234,
0.22677937150001526,
0.026636527851223946,
-0.4867093563079834,
0.5844843983650208,
-0.08901206403970718,
0.4233068525791168,
0.9258498549461365,
0.17888425290584564,
0.5026527047157288,
-0.38493725657463074,
0.633564293384552,
-0.337213933467865,
0.05965816229581833,
-0.20457005500793457,
-0.5981733798980713,
-0.308097243309021,
-0.04516253620386124,
0.09971017390489578,
0.525595486164093,
-0.5389735102653503,
0.4408189654350281,
-0.11435990780591965,
-0.757695198059082,
-0.3699846863746643,
0.21539075672626495,
0.23373731970787048,
0.6976895332336426,
0.5380525588989258,
-0.43853941559791565,
-0.40012526512145996,
-0.27439144253730774,
-0.2394607663154602,
-0.14346639811992645,
-0.25529465079307556,
0.21537615358829498,
1.0609281063079834,
-0.057751160115003586,
1.1597204208374023,
-0.6039509773254395,
0.3872624635696411,
0.10490784049034119,
0.08616820722818375,
0.35720744729042053,
0.20252494513988495,
0.09192812442779541,
-0.5526063442230225,
-0.3645658791065216,
-0.11821950972080231,
-0.7343535423278809,
-0.10452473908662796,
0.21464508771896362,
-0.08129257708787918,
-0.39587655663490295,
0.24280020594596863,
-0.4877144694328308,
0.4022585153579712,
0.45126160979270935,
-0.5266767740249634,
0.9116036891937256,
-0.05475503206253052,
0.21029062569141388,
-0.5243069529533386,
0.03872513025999069,
-0.054896604269742966,
-0.20284780859947205,
-0.17775878310203552,
-0.042784325778484344,
-0.11441939324140549,
-0.17088134586811066,
-0.479352742433548,
0.6860606670379639,
-0.4082906246185303,
-0.4385366141796112,
-0.2542402148246765,
0.4135289788246155,
0.1789964735507965,
0.14604397118091583,
-0.11276686191558838,
0.930190920829773,
0.5051690936088562,
-0.673104465007782,
0.5885109901428223,
-0.052718061953783035,
-0.34029579162597656,
0.25485959649086,
-0.712250828742981,
0.4728851914405823,
-0.1047520712018013,
0.619464635848999,
-0.9087700247764587,
-0.3903660178184509,
0.020413435995578766,
-0.27136069536209106,
-0.08861789107322693,
0.06520731747150421,
-0.4798175096511841,
-0.8866767883300781,
-0.5488640666007996,
0.1646718978881836,
0.5928552150726318,
-0.662921667098999,
0.2617919147014618,
-0.1014716774225235,
-0.3283880949020386,
-0.05359594523906708,
-0.44488760828971863,
-0.13302205502986908,
-0.5706363916397095,
-0.48709017038345337,
0.2866039574146271,
-0.5802887082099915,
-0.5939808487892151,
-0.04731559008359909,
-0.2874944806098938,
-0.041407208889722824,
0.15932290256023407,
0.1308097541332245,
0.5342329740524292,
-0.24131014943122864,
0.1483316719532013,
-0.033757466822862625,
0.1577385812997818,
0.29376307129859924,
-0.20005479454994202,
0.35220906138420105,
-0.5712809562683105,
-0.32855406403541565,
-0.34842559695243835,
0.3301263749599457,
0.7727234959602356,
0.34068048000335693,
0.24117432534694672,
0.14141741394996643,
-0.40444689989089966,
-0.06003843620419502,
-0.21482045948505402,
-0.42829036712646484,
-0.45741429924964905,
-0.0016345942858606577,
-0.32964324951171875,
-0.8530333042144775,
0.4753897488117218,
-0.3818122446537018,
-0.1106080636382103,
0.18220627307891846,
0.7814069986343384,
-0.5337451696395874,
0.8958690762519836,
0.27550041675567627,
0.1320943832397461,
0.19827884435653687,
-0.27167370915412903,
0.34101176261901855,
-0.8331844806671143,
-0.16944609582424164,
-0.3455384075641632,
-0.17149633169174194,
-0.4371660351753235,
-0.48252299427986145,
0.39651718735694885,
0.3423687517642975,
-0.6027772426605225,
-0.14836400747299194,
-0.8200882077217102,
0.8318937420845032,
0.08263112604618073,
0.07353010773658752,
0.2899927496910095,
-0.03435570374131203,
-0.22939682006835938,
0.1814940720796585,
-0.4397324025630951,
-0.9783463478088379,
0.8494159579277039,
0.26339083909988403,
0.9383620619773865,
0.05772071331739426,
0.5466647744178772,
0.18940937519073486,
0.6691270470619202,
-1.1307733058929443,
0.5116265416145325,
0.270314484834671,
-0.486717164516449,
-0.6391000151634216,
-0.1571805328130722,
-0.8101329803466797,
0.35022273659706116,
0.0008971444331109524,
-0.7350978255271912,
-0.46548375487327576,
-0.06332901120185852,
-0.6702941060066223,
0.014663401059806347,
-0.8859964609146118,
0.4145311415195465,
-0.26137369871139526,
-0.45184290409088135,
0.09710272401571274,
-0.7103236317634583,
0.22651232779026031,
-0.21706631779670715,
0.561210572719574,
0.09758421033620834,
0.10369474440813065,
1.0881788730621338,
-0.4801449179649353,
0.8875783681869507,
-0.13247910141944885,
0.03664936125278473,
0.8883291482925415,
0.1336689442396164,
0.33958831429481506,
0.018154866993427277,
-0.001395250204950571,
-0.17772947251796722,
-0.23196464776992798,
-0.41706907749176025,
-0.8841521739959717,
0.6869524717330933,
-0.7558664083480835,
-0.7321198582649231,
-0.5257473587989807,
-0.5664975047111511,
-0.07307908684015274,
0.14509610831737518,
0.017859961837530136,
-0.027669066563248634,
0.15028797090053558,
-0.24866923689842224,
0.4354184865951538,
0.11589226126670837,
0.6554674506187439,
0.405164510011673,
-0.4080447256565094,
-0.35054877400398254,
0.5634275078773499,
0.20566922426223755,
0.3734111785888672,
-0.21855264902114868,
0.8847250938415527,
-0.3389805853366852,
-0.22103387117385864,
-0.43331754207611084,
0.1828494817018509,
-0.9069522619247437,
-0.1898588389158249,
-0.3494047224521637,
0.10196545720100403,
-0.2536922097206116,
-0.6188686490058899,
-0.011913497000932693,
-0.21897853910923004,
-0.07041123509407043,
-0.3802933096885681,
0.38713082671165466,
1.2037321329116821,
0.1760309934616089,
0.48785102367401123,
-0.46231919527053833,
0.11954120546579361,
0.6332074999809265,
0.20331743359565735,
0.13622011244297028,
-0.406563937664032,
0.14531654119491577,
-0.16228991746902466,
-0.7374163269996643,
-0.879450798034668,
0.12674976885318756,
-0.00041637406684458256,
0.22377637028694153,
0.11305489391088486,
-0.5236431956291199,
0.8744422793388367,
-0.6257216334342957,
1.1784688234329224,
0.37281304597854614,
-1.1430580615997314,
0.7596182823181152,
-0.34273889660835266,
0.3992946445941925,
0.2092660367488861,
0.6684918999671936,
-0.4081195592880249,
-0.0860724002122879,
-0.40967780351638794,
-0.5227879881858826,
0.28534984588623047,
-0.056042902171611786,
-0.17311018705368042,
-0.1998070329427719,
0.4330306649208069,
0.3371416926383972,
0.03434452787041664,
-0.8675779104232788,
0.0604642778635025,
-0.34527647495269775,
-0.1745990514755249,
0.1189768835902214,
0.17384302616119385,
-0.11650683730840683,
-0.4519505202770233,
0.504806399345398,
-0.6074791550636292,
0.1818682849407196,
0.3549107611179352,
0.03034915030002594,
-0.4034160077571869,
0.6671656966209412,
0.6500166058540344,
0.8610252141952515,
-0.1662382036447525,
0.4166499972343445,
0.3447812497615814,
-0.7681677937507629,
0.335903137922287,
-0.31209608912467957,
0.12455424666404724,
-0.33967140316963196,
0.46008285880088806,
0.254814475774765,
-0.05898391455411911,
-0.37509727478027344,
0.43165236711502075,
-0.04536024481058121,
-0.38059863448143005,
-0.11227776110172272,
-0.22012053430080414,
0.017550120130181313,
0.06616634875535965,
0.6309385299682617,
-0.1479002982378006,
0.12911465764045715,
-0.5937478542327881,
0.07277173548936844,
0.07801324129104614,
-0.3588557839393616,
-0.6854090094566345,
0.1522747129201889,
-0.08893658220767975,
-0.2066609263420105,
0.5698338150978088,
-0.27478888630867004,
-0.6396278142929077,
0.7844679951667786,
0.7331453561782837,
0.43415531516075134,
-0.34281107783317566,
0.2024286985397339,
0.3600251376628876,
0.241083562374115,
-0.14413148164749146,
0.8140363693237305,
-0.18825370073318481,
-0.5685962438583374,
-0.788766086101532,
-0.5858002305030823,
-0.7473127841949463,
0.0919584333896637,
-0.583256721496582,
0.3011813163757324,
-0.7027196288108826,
-0.05832205340266228,
0.10732956975698471,
0.20978213846683502,
-0.7333871722221375,
0.44387632608413696,
0.10976618528366089,
0.847874641418457,
-1.2451587915420532,
0.5385863780975342,
0.8929635882377625,
-0.3747514486312866,
-1.1214096546173096,
-0.2566942274570465,
-0.0005860229721292853,
-0.6331677436828613,
0.986851692199707,
0.25283193588256836,
-0.28247860074043274,
0.0065404982306063175,
-0.9866902828216553,
-0.8769153952598572,
1.2250739336013794,
-0.2206319272518158,
-0.4789794385433197,
-0.040730323642492294,
-0.37381061911582947,
0.5272372364997864,
-0.3960251808166504,
0.5318096280097961,
0.40559837222099304,
0.6902801990509033,
0.14224164187908173,
-0.7905817031860352,
0.202866792678833,
0.11268220841884613,
-0.3179924786090851,
0.15184731781482697,
-0.4488464891910553,
0.7877021431922913,
-0.48463043570518494,
-0.2256537824869156,
-0.09009304642677307,
0.5776798129081726,
0.7265915870666504,
0.7826998829841614,
0.44194620847702026,
0.48103734850883484,
0.995862603187561,
-0.13558296859264374,
0.932308554649353,
0.25149470567703247,
0.5829041600227356,
0.8432331085205078,
-0.5100756883621216,
0.7348998188972473,
0.8700231313705444,
-0.6483818888664246,
0.9474206566810608,
0.9923076629638672,
0.0014753383584320545,
0.5918388366699219,
0.738262414932251,
-0.3026580214500427,
-0.1468888521194458,
0.11321869492530823,
0.009072111919522285,
0.523642361164093,
0.7443054914474487,
0.11545375734567642,
-0.2908519208431244,
0.04380543529987335,
-0.02257840521633625,
0.1071808859705925,
-0.6388302445411682,
0.4228360652923584,
0.298979789018631,
-0.8290876746177673,
0.2538389563560486,
-0.33560657501220703,
0.5233810544013977,
-0.2807408571243286,
-0.2693721354007721,
0.14274775981903076,
-0.229557067155838,
-0.28363484144210815,
-1.1152050495147705,
0.2280283123254776,
0.2020285278558731,
-0.3138744533061981,
-0.3178427815437317,
0.4983207583427429,
-0.21966452896595,
-0.3637318015098572,
0.06250748783349991,
0.5302755236625671,
0.35460057854652405,
0.3467257022857666,
-0.6293192505836487,
-0.12101339548826218,
-0.5548455715179443,
-0.4782743752002716,
-0.02970334142446518,
0.3661312758922577,
-0.5960344076156616,
0.6131264567375183,
0.9486757516860962,
0.047230448573827744,
0.08170010894536972,
0.1701216995716095,
0.8616722226142883,
-0.7621110677719116,
-0.4683353900909424,
-0.993848979473114,
0.3357538878917694,
0.16312631964683533,
0.05811339616775513,
0.5474324822425842,
0.3800309896469116,
0.49509701132774353,
0.1067802831530571,
0.8983181118965149,
0.13813214004039764,
0.5189727544784546,
-0.5926864147186279,
0.39597344398498535,
-0.056419435888528824,
0.014525104314088821,
-0.49422597885131836,
-1.0179914236068726,
-0.43277278542518616,
0.5737009644508362,
-0.5912997126579285,
0.2244076281785965,
1.373981237411499,
0.20321673154830933,
0.091215118765831,
0.18656499683856964,
0.2489975094795227,
0.10881900042295456,
0.5363898277282715,
0.31944966316223145,
1.2305063009262085,
-0.31818604469299316,
0.20643062889575958,
0.017444780096411705,
-0.5994871258735657,
0.15308140218257904,
-1.099646806716919,
-0.9477530717849731,
-0.2360783815383911,
-0.20538105070590973,
-0.26283594965934753,
-0.07237362861633301,
0.7425984740257263,
0.3639530539512634,
-0.3475048243999481,
-0.22001752257347107,
-0.13680925965309143,
0.10089194774627686,
-0.07025196403265,
-0.3023011088371277,
0.5582398176193237,
-0.1593884974718094,
-0.29222604632377625,
0.6010770797729492,
0.4142148494720459,
0.30126968026161194,
-0.43833309412002563,
0.03822940215468407,
-0.0777200236916542,
0.19098465144634247,
0.7138918042182922,
-0.035289466381073,
-0.9701840281486511,
-0.548708438873291,
0.4006900191307068,
0.07905203104019165,
-0.12277888506650925,
0.7970229983329773,
-1.047527551651001,
0.5031546950340271,
0.43066608905792236,
0.2589995563030243,
0.42837217450141907,
0.163537859916687,
0.22487229108810425,
-0.46270281076431274,
-0.03695233538746834,
0.4001261591911316,
0.22155392169952393,
0.529277503490448,
-0.44944167137145996,
0.4238205850124359,
0.3160425126552582,
-0.8084693551063538,
-0.6627042889595032,
-0.00726449117064476,
-1.0679676532745361,
-0.1498817652463913,
0.855686604976654,
-0.17542022466659546,
-0.5175014734268188,
-0.05998220294713974,
-0.00016551186854485422,
-0.12356838583946228,
-0.2513170838356018,
0.7765627503395081,
1.1258907318115234,
-0.31388774514198303,
0.13199009001255035,
-0.5000771284103394,
0.029318349435925484,
0.18702565133571625,
-0.9678552150726318,
-0.23627567291259766,
0.31142276525497437,
0.3776465058326721,
0.35951024293899536,
0.6076483130455017,
-0.1395060420036316,
0.35111498832702637,
-0.23734353482723236,
0.04449320584535599,
0.16535179316997528,
-0.4883236289024353,
-0.28354883193969727,
-0.012071310542523861,
-0.08641523122787476,
0.006485411431640387
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.